id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14481v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14481v2 | FOCUS: Effective Embedding Initialization for Monolingual Specialization of Multilingual Models | 2023-05-23T19:21:53 | 2023-11-06T17:47:47 | Konstantin Dobler, Gerard de Melo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Using model weights pretrained on a high-resource language as a warm start
can reduce the need for data and compute to obtain high-quality language models
for other, especially low-resource, languages. However, if we want to use a new
tokenizer specialized for the target language, we cannot transfer the source
model's embedding matrix. In this paper, we propose FOCUS - Fast Overlapping
Token Combinations Using Sparsemax, a novel embedding initialization method
that initializes the embedding matrix effectively for a new tokenizer based on
information in the source model's embedding matrix. FOCUS represents newly
added tokens as combinations of tokens in the overlap of the source and target
vocabularies. The overlapping tokens are selected based on semantic similarity
in an auxiliary static token embedding space. We focus our study on using the
multilingual XLM-R as a source model and empirically show that FOCUS
outperforms random initialization and previous work in language modeling and on
a range of downstream tasks (NLI, QA, and NER). | [
-0.6301770806,
-0.5617009401,
0.2679601014,
0.4804955423,
-0.5648287535,
0.3758095801,
-0.4485692978,
-0.2881880999,
0.3870125711,
0.0453499854,
-0.2976272702,
-0.2826116383,
-0.8097816706,
0.142453298,
-0.2888673842,
0.7956438661,
-0.2259094119,
0.052712366,
-0.103015773,
-0.3789744973,
-0.4303361773,
-0.3780766428,
-0.3550850749,
0.0657648221,
0.5870231986,
0.2729527652,
0.7480509281,
1.0071737766,
0.1650421321,
0.3672098219,
-0.2303319275,
0.3099000156,
-0.5667208433,
-0.168058306,
0.1273777634,
-0.2550922632,
-0.0460971743,
-0.2276874334,
0.961597383,
1.0619828701,
-0.0074368208,
0.0981364995,
0.3060277998,
-0.0740868524,
-0.7194190621,
0.026941333,
-0.7197478414,
0.2889681756,
-0.1444552243,
0.0211269762,
-0.3300393224,
-0.0063479799,
0.0669758022,
-0.6004759073,
0.1430490017,
-0.0034648469,
0.8970143795,
0.217636928,
-0.1642335057,
0.1683659106,
-0.5502831936,
1.1329823732,
-0.4234049022,
0.6631624699,
-0.0510216095,
-0.0854764581,
0.2957174778,
-0.5229164958,
-0.4086613953,
0.1811172515,
-0.1440482438,
-0.394749254,
-0.0668504983,
0.0360453725,
0.3804982305,
0.0258858148,
-0.4511104524,
0.0143255657,
-0.3997588754,
-0.1585149616,
0.0692776665,
0.0883018598,
0.3528805375,
0.0163757224,
-0.5420711637,
0.2639180124,
-0.4063535035,
0.0236071441,
0.2006220818,
0.7425308824,
-0.0754965469,
0.5781277418,
0.0147321709,
0.9126466513,
0.1331469715,
-0.1747968048,
0.4710877538,
-0.8135516644,
-0.1353516728,
0.0073071369,
0.3916495442,
-0.0481565669,
0.0363830924,
-0.3304668963,
-0.1003851742,
-0.0409016982,
0.1177890748,
-0.6657496691,
0.5531229377,
0.2177360654,
-0.4453570247,
0.0574234761,
0.0519677401,
-0.4513467848,
0.2001887411,
-0.3807859719,
0.3387292325,
-0.3028568327,
-0.3427601159,
0.1555204988,
0.1077884659,
0.1654840112,
-0.1672395319,
-0.8632357717,
0.5219529867,
0.723230958,
0.929444313,
-0.5492429137,
-0.6982865334,
-0.676512897,
0.022965055,
-0.1273437142,
0.4448930621,
-0.5370061398,
-0.340996176,
0.1732826084,
0.0414064564,
-0.1083129272,
-0.2972725928,
0.3623399138,
-0.4677837491,
-0.1099180281,
-0.0926420987,
-0.3961093724,
-0.0387733355,
0.1985748112,
-0.675319314,
1.1823868752,
0.1820591539,
-0.6730431914,
0.8059396148,
-0.4001434743,
-0.4554581642,
0.1814353466,
-0.266613245,
-0.099780269,
0.0014965807,
0.1930372268,
0.2773835659,
0.0437586121,
0.0636323094,
-0.1392062902,
-0.4696808755,
-0.0860887095,
0.0024505104,
0.5302086473,
0.1454610825,
-0.3341324627,
0.1896978915,
-0.6865314841,
0.2732310593,
0.0899157971,
-0.2110012919,
-0.7257014513,
-0.5451976657,
0.3990562558,
0.2333316505,
0.4976498187,
-0.5256946087,
0.071340993,
-0.3990827203,
0.3044713438,
0.6105748415,
-0.3033471107,
0.5216510892,
-0.0658120289,
0.6916278005,
0.1842766404,
0.3056511581,
-0.5887384415,
-0.3981052935,
-0.7855412364,
-0.6154587269,
0.6400030255,
0.3818511665,
-0.3903338313,
0.3407700658,
-0.211199373,
-0.1815386862,
-0.4943436682,
0.442339927,
0.5595664382,
-0.0988931507,
0.1945576221,
-0.5203801394,
-0.7598639131,
-0.9559419155,
-0.2842722237,
0.4844403565,
0.5211125016,
0.3786710501,
0.1231469885,
-0.1630049497,
1.1265265942,
-0.6076232195,
-0.0386914201,
-0.5406829119,
-0.0841507241,
0.3441306055,
0.7359037399,
0.6194607615,
-0.7687397003,
-0.8410617113,
-0.0463169552,
-0.3662182093,
0.2634726763,
0.2465006411,
-0.4217778146,
-0.191627726,
0.5534314513,
-0.5752632022,
0.1150759831,
0.439404577,
-0.3458583355,
0.1326274127,
-0.1802378148,
-0.0721662045,
-1.1966636181,
0.2493335456,
-0.2547829747,
-0.1181439832,
-0.9827880859,
0.1819979846,
0.1921879649,
-0.4743267,
-0.7139093876,
0.7908800244,
-0.5894504189,
-0.0325360931,
-0.199094817,
0.1549920887,
0.052777864,
0.4623483121,
-0.0728120059,
0.7606586814,
0.5256156325,
-0.4138505757,
-0.3387693167,
0.3303575814,
-0.349304378,
0.0626670048,
-0.5947512984,
0.2257677913,
-0.1409808099,
-0.3683258593,
-0.7545557618,
0.1954797357,
0.0366252065,
-0.1345666647,
0.5405884981,
-0.3777983189,
-0.4025264084,
-0.2703362405,
-0.161826998,
1.132504344,
0.2097447217,
-0.5227461457,
0.5045890808,
0.5890139341,
-0.3999279141,
-1.0841339827,
-0.5979351997,
0.0726703256,
0.0064425231,
-0.533536911,
0.4809678495,
-0.1425915658,
-0.0313382037,
0.1928306818,
0.122948043,
-0.3723332882,
0.0631277338,
-0.0587324463,
0.3228496313,
-0.1583742201,
-0.1935910285,
0.1969974041,
-0.1948480308,
-0.5191974044,
-0.4431855083,
0.7909850478,
0.1159813702,
-0.4150914848,
-0.0804735124,
0.6607859135,
0.5257826447,
-0.4921228886,
0.8380429745,
0.5569097996,
-0.5895300508,
-0.079057008,
-0.6211269498,
-0.0996621847,
-0.4397854209,
0.7447409034,
-0.3931463063,
-1.2184346914,
0.5541085601,
0.2686202526,
0.2258660942,
0.0253733229,
0.4908603728,
0.8084132671,
1.1060060263,
1.1725481749,
-0.1196443811,
0.7082061172,
-0.3618631959,
0.3033709228,
-0.7653207183,
-0.1116325334,
-0.4075734317,
-0.0697927698,
-0.1248060539,
-1.001311779,
0.1815432161,
0.0108675491,
0.1965346485,
0.5858353972,
-0.264983356,
0.5860879421,
0.3160385191,
-0.1561963707,
0.0398685858,
0.3231305182,
-0.8132169843,
-0.2918068469,
-1.1561121941,
-0.0123750875,
1.1261972189,
0.2990152538,
0.5381747484,
-0.1982841045,
0.7566998005,
-0.0398666412,
0.3072956204,
-0.6028220057,
0.1961438507,
-0.1700615883,
-0.4615791738,
-0.3816666901,
-0.219930768,
-0.8840158582,
0.7831681967,
-0.1431279778,
-0.4654918313,
0.4452321231,
-0.0807077438,
-0.6048559546,
0.2307153046,
-0.7304428816,
0.8305152059,
-0.1177208498,
-0.5116996169,
-0.2732356787,
-0.0843962133,
0.2828928828,
-0.2692833841,
0.5758610368,
-0.140255034,
-0.3443201184,
0.6085051894,
-0.3750456274,
0.6251760125,
-0.2289983928,
-0.0666221008,
0.1599779129,
-0.2607325912,
0.3698002398,
0.0249936562,
-0.0000357537,
0.2760329247,
-0.3958592117,
-0.553907454,
-0.5317160487,
0.5115203857,
-0.6101987958,
-0.3944892287,
-0.1157317162,
-0.4869093895,
-0.2576102316,
0.6044669151,
-0.2118705958,
0.6697902083,
-0.4155474305,
-0.1227740124,
0.4001103044,
-0.1143554747,
0.2873231173,
0.7186852694,
-0.1413301677,
-0.6970447898,
1.0218371153,
0.0731696114,
0.1855160594,
0.2899062634,
-0.2155458778,
-0.054783918,
-0.4420193434,
-0.5261096358,
0.4435172379,
-0.6594731808,
-0.1306872815,
-1.0360171795,
-0.2693923116,
-0.3723463118,
-0.3065733016,
-0.6339265704,
-0.308699131,
-0.1075343192,
0.1327155679,
-0.075224258,
0.4619121253,
-0.1425240338,
0.0124530206,
-0.9344472289,
0.0451269597,
0.2567965984,
0.527436316,
0.2685531676,
-0.3985492587,
-0.959033668,
-0.3101040423,
0.1359197646,
-0.3583760262,
0.2348363698,
0.1912023872,
1.0628976822,
0.8763113022,
-0.3428310752,
0.7037436962,
-0.7380518913,
0.4026340544,
0.2815664113,
-1.0945519209,
0.0827404931,
0.0443282314,
0.5051738024,
0.59600389,
0.5060541034,
-0.5576082468,
-0.4653469622,
-0.1944299191,
-0.9887707233,
0.7917336226,
0.1901127696,
0.2691198289,
-0.2114983648,
0.3043881059,
0.3548680544,
0.2843543291,
-0.6005784869,
-0.444937259,
-0.0491892397,
0.0472805575,
-0.315112412,
-0.5759869218,
-0.1442611814,
-0.4074847102,
0.2166805118,
-0.3330058157,
0.321990639,
-0.0250155367,
-0.3835769594,
-0.3933705688,
-0.0007615295,
0.7148494124,
0.7351403236,
0.0795589015,
0.1989104599,
0.4852888882,
-0.464651525,
0.2364811897,
0.3672320545,
-0.2224949449,
0.2405878305,
0.1827355325,
0.9069872499,
0.9833086133,
-0.8091720939,
0.464759469,
-0.1851232201,
-0.0481592007,
0.1675380617,
-0.2142735273,
-0.0893651471,
0.0076321419,
0.2648885548,
0.0881617814,
-0.0944356322,
-0.29083547,
0.4281001985,
0.7137268782,
-0.34147048,
-0.2047459781,
0.5248534083,
0.1480922401,
-0.0172935855,
0.1862784475,
-0.1283604801,
-0.7994558215,
0.5536943078,
0.5379123688,
0.8383496404,
-0.170389384,
-0.062639989,
0.5165657997,
0.4160177708,
0.0777481049,
0.4480568469,
-0.2009981275,
-0.9227688909,
-0.7606372237,
-0.7405055165,
-0.2716364861,
-0.2838449478,
-0.5882330537,
0.5240364671,
-0.2950484753,
-0.2756927907,
-0.1374465227,
-0.1437710673,
-0.7339133024,
-0.2098059952,
0.1562744677,
1.0907937288,
-0.672380209,
0.7698335648,
0.6602743268,
-0.147104606,
-0.6337981224,
-0.1060977951,
-0.4442250431,
-0.8973859549,
0.6483069062,
0.2939685583,
0.1571771055,
0.1713329703,
-0.1745020896,
-1.3286941051,
0.8173335791,
0.2585930228,
-0.4860184789,
0.0301123485,
0.179291591,
0.1259155124,
-0.5586787462,
0.2530015409,
0.366381675,
0.4642464519,
-0.1796875298,
-0.8369195461,
0.2405703068,
-0.368537128,
0.1142355651,
0.281111747,
-0.7485215664,
1.01167202,
-0.4105170071,
-0.3700629473,
0.2006023377,
0.6588139534,
0.0180962179,
-0.1737297028,
0.8833758235,
0.6265545487,
0.5299565792,
0.2778134644,
0.6775624752,
-1.0505547523,
0.3287389278,
0.8326935768,
-0.289924413,
0.5878785849,
0.4576652348,
-0.131064713,
0.0824271962,
0.3348198235,
-0.1984746158,
0.4921537042,
0.066385299,
-0.3112881482,
-0.1322288066,
-0.3211450279,
-0.4762249589,
0.1996047199,
0.3375386894,
-0.2747099996,
-0.3641617894,
0.2806439102,
0.0218772013,
-0.2571810484,
-0.169922471,
0.4675987065,
-0.0169659331,
-0.7180816531,
0.759346664,
0.4407463372,
0.9068390727,
-0.7292433977,
0.184919104,
-0.2628823519,
-0.0080883531,
0.0822141096,
-0.1853157729,
0.268139571,
-0.0212453008,
-0.2420054674,
-0.4177901745,
0.5104754567,
-0.8439249992,
-0.3645325899,
0.4247914255,
0.6412585378,
-0.1093081236,
0.2567237318,
-0.6607020497,
0.3104909062,
-0.2377258688,
0.1205941215,
0.5083959103,
0.2326262146,
0.1560288072,
0.3320218027,
0.6966817975,
-0.0065409238,
0.3519842625,
0.1139282286,
1.1483352184,
-0.4509883821,
-0.8171073794,
-0.6690635085,
0.2268344462,
0.1391627938,
-0.3041946292,
0.8957656622,
0.9001504183,
0.6564772725,
0.0181218237,
0.707854569,
-0.048470296,
0.373360455,
-0.2639823258,
0.7171118259,
-0.7207762003,
-0.3704190552,
-0.4623907804,
-0.9278014302,
-0.2439887524,
0.3296617568,
0.1719035357,
0.1333584338,
0.744548738,
0.8262878656,
-0.2708754241,
-0.5015856624,
0.5788704753,
0.167480275,
-0.1207202151,
0.2874431312,
0.6540872455,
-0.0798979327,
0.5661985278,
-0.3003295064,
-0.3099817932,
-0.3278620243,
-0.6979528069,
-0.9759224057,
-0.4122770727,
-0.1091166064,
-0.3421314359,
-0.0170999449,
1.086618185,
0.9417968392,
-0.8325622082,
-0.3473106325,
0.1300989538,
0.3965100944,
-0.31231457,
-0.1870803684,
0.1806469858,
-0.7813318968,
-0.9392686486,
0.3642167449,
0.4457001686,
-0.004047282,
-0.6785904765,
-0.1590097696,
-0.3212531209,
0.1880442798,
0.4341523945,
0.425057441,
-0.519297421,
0.1962175816,
0.0844423249,
-0.0636955202,
0.1423797011,
1.248893857,
-0.5414376855,
0.4065379202,
0.3020811379,
0.6176134944,
0.2529364526,
-0.2829945982,
0.661482513,
-0.7490961552,
0.9409005046,
-0.0610138886,
0.5257054567,
0.2245583683,
-0.2302395552,
0.0652358904,
0.4069727063,
0.0873639137,
-1.1269150972,
0.0169925354,
-0.7719141245,
-0.1703679562,
0.9717059135,
-0.2890117764,
-0.1742758751,
-0.2676014006,
-0.1491400003,
0.1273548752,
-0.3320367634,
0.6027001143,
0.5871784091,
0.3621356785,
-0.0801434144,
-0.1927188337,
0.4049014449,
0.6220260859,
-0.4478863478,
-0.2128860354,
-0.2915419042,
0.2468677908,
0.2403097898,
0.6395873427,
-0.1400166899,
0.1903933287,
0.0967072099,
0.1879648715,
-0.1927517354,
-0.3266896009,
-0.2912940383,
0.3551673293,
0.2375422418,
-0.0909107849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14480v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14480v2 | BAND: Biomedical Alert News Dataset | 2023-05-23T19:21:00 | 2023-10-15T15:09:24 | Zihao Fu, Meiru Zhang, Zaiqiao Meng, Yannan Shen, David Buckeridge, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Infectious disease outbreaks continue to pose a significant threat to human
health and well-being. To improve disease surveillance and understanding of
disease spread, several surveillance systems have been developed to monitor
daily news alerts and social media. However, existing systems lack thorough
epidemiological analysis in relation to corresponding alerts or news, largely
due to the scarcity of well-annotated reports data. To address this gap, we
introduce the Biomedical Alert News Dataset (BAND), which includes 1,508
samples from existing reported news articles, open emails, and alerts, as well
as 30 epidemiology-related questions. These questions necessitate the model's
expert reasoning abilities, thereby offering valuable insights into the
outbreak of the disease. The BAND dataset brings new challenges to the NLP
world, requiring better disguise capability of the content and the ability to
infer important information. We provide several benchmark tasks, including
Named Entity Recognition (NER), Question Answering (QA), and Event Extraction
(EE), to show how existing models are capable of handling these tasks in the
epidemiology domain. To the best of our knowledge, the BAND corpus is the
largest corpus of well-annotated biomedical outbreak alert news with
elaborately designed questions, making it a valuable resource for
epidemiologists and NLP researchers alike. | [
-0.3541018963,
-0.7869153023,
0.3558462262,
0.2856106162,
0.0701195523,
-0.0271821581,
0.0659191832,
-0.7882676721,
0.5702752471,
0.5608642101,
-0.6019194126,
-0.6477022171,
-0.482755959,
0.1943489313,
-0.6754699945,
1.1669927835,
0.2890928984,
-0.3451822102,
-0.1535669267,
0.0574772358,
-0.1485714018,
-0.4756613672,
-0.6543853879,
-0.1284171194,
0.8113601804,
0.2441098988,
0.3112628758,
0.3563423753,
0.7983341813,
0.0528660081,
-0.1119878143,
0.0582300797,
-0.339651674,
0.08502689,
-0.0452993438,
-0.1835525483,
-0.4829242527,
0.050013233,
0.2672678232,
0.8436430693,
-0.244017005,
0.7800778747,
-0.4703561068,
0.2924279571,
-0.1443030685,
-0.1730235368,
-0.5108711123,
-0.1346049756,
-0.4417118132,
-0.3248702288,
-0.4103450775,
-0.1795185208,
0.4450808764,
-0.7538728714,
0.0930000395,
0.1142231897,
0.8211214542,
0.274797678,
-0.5714369416,
-0.196568653,
-0.612419486,
0.2849029899,
-0.1669857651,
0.1764882207,
0.68993783,
0.4712589383,
-0.2075556368,
-0.6219008565,
-0.0935749486,
0.5337299705,
0.2649446428,
0.1043510288,
-0.6858747005,
-0.3200587034,
0.0530712791,
0.136182338,
-0.7432906032,
-0.1191183254,
-0.4472101629,
-0.2083970159,
0.6923288107,
-0.1634217203,
0.459338963,
-0.2998058498,
-0.462313354,
0.2259783745,
-0.5705126524,
0.041414883,
0.0818366334,
-0.0697018653,
-0.3104343116,
0.2678349614,
-0.1802390516,
0.7169396281,
-0.0271884352,
0.0548853651,
0.5168084502,
-0.1995811462,
-0.1295195371,
0.1370617747,
0.3118217885,
0.562520206,
-0.445792526,
-0.3576737046,
0.0300819762,
0.1345911622,
0.2437963933,
-0.5581804514,
-0.2553481162,
0.6133835912,
-0.3898567557,
-0.0264777392,
-0.2320101559,
-0.9225100875,
-0.3624329567,
-0.1586610973,
0.4432989061,
-0.5159665346,
-0.4603161514,
0.4067680538,
-0.5608710647,
0.0560329594,
0.4262991846,
-0.3985906839,
0.0797548592,
0.8081538081,
0.3928792477,
0.0677796304,
0.4761633277,
-0.4198259115,
0.1184230223,
-0.0458711945,
1.1296931505,
-0.4588436186,
-0.1768342108,
-0.2009600848,
0.0704395324,
-0.3386511505,
-0.4897035062,
0.5905608535,
-0.4795349836,
0.1363079548,
-0.1856699586,
-0.5563408136,
-0.3104222715,
0.0331284255,
-0.2496416867,
0.7611539364,
0.1711763442,
-0.6785671115,
0.3641853631,
-0.420003891,
-0.2563047409,
0.2989029586,
-0.1608069092,
-0.4276652932,
-0.1720836312,
0.4375248849,
0.3513258994,
-0.3087897599,
0.1854566485,
-0.5583268404,
0.041786395,
0.1860804856,
0.0521015525,
0.8817138672,
0.1776314676,
0.0014827318,
-0.0810355917,
-0.9980895519,
-0.0245611835,
-0.0434077382,
-0.116422534,
-0.5365771055,
0.1264953613,
0.2339873612,
-0.1371839195,
-0.2443866134,
-0.642770648,
0.0805782676,
-0.3412198722,
0.378321588,
0.4850981534,
0.6308478713,
0.1055653542,
-0.7596219182,
0.4477294683,
-0.1718744785,
0.5179690123,
-0.3325403035,
-0.7302416563,
-0.0525571294,
-0.5200849175,
0.4929330051,
0.718729496,
-0.5208722949,
0.4755010605,
-0.1939741969,
-0.5848118663,
-0.4471340179,
-0.1856733263,
0.1846267879,
0.506449461,
0.4050344229,
0.0759398192,
-0.8290655017,
-0.6909053922,
-0.0223480966,
-0.0321919061,
-0.1940610856,
0.0630865097,
0.4453524947,
-0.3470541537,
0.9643296599,
-0.4288948476,
0.0440441743,
-0.1564288288,
0.2831039131,
0.4946228266,
0.5110430717,
0.8502162695,
-0.9579098821,
-0.0484483019,
-0.010461946,
-0.6720373631,
-0.5330320001,
-0.097162798,
-0.2793700099,
-0.2730401754,
0.2628442049,
-0.2547708154,
0.4055014253,
0.6372718811,
-0.5596987605,
0.3547254801,
0.3414462209,
0.0007872319,
-0.9726570845,
0.1548612267,
0.2989084721,
-0.3363383114,
-0.7493463755,
-0.0426512025,
-0.165994972,
-0.1254990399,
-0.0799501315,
0.3977311254,
-0.158651039,
-0.0735009834,
-0.0835626945,
-0.0164526999,
0.0495545305,
0.0522124767,
-0.2446462214,
0.2697114646,
0.5859387517,
-0.6005687714,
0.2258216441,
0.6263878345,
-0.4608795643,
0.4016670883,
-0.5315279365,
-0.1023344994,
-0.2839140296,
0.4121014774,
-0.6102828383,
-0.7595114708,
0.1264304668,
-0.842136085,
0.171477735,
-0.1541725844,
-0.2644934058,
-0.5582774878,
0.0008748895,
0.1037570536,
0.6585307121,
-0.4493580461,
0.4042354226,
0.9264125228,
-0.3085456789,
-0.4086307883,
-0.5023410916,
-0.0634515807,
-0.3297149539,
-0.592854321,
0.4178505242,
0.0741215274,
-0.5504310727,
0.1287830323,
-0.5380815864,
-0.1195474938,
0.2951847315,
0.4106907547,
0.3490840793,
-0.1864928156,
0.4974918067,
-0.1852634698,
0.0192691535,
0.183887437,
-0.0124754421,
0.4707912505,
0.0689031258,
-0.3025139272,
-0.440771848,
0.5573332906,
0.1405619234,
-0.2811224461,
0.4019989967,
0.4328210354,
-0.604521215,
-0.1257049739,
-0.4736033082,
-0.0902136266,
-0.3475772738,
0.0651948676,
-0.1288491338,
-0.6068133116,
0.6716247797,
-0.0640188828,
0.0992932245,
0.4812372327,
0.119231388,
-0.3183597624,
0.6620740891,
0.3173220456,
0.0022943052,
0.299939245,
-0.0339464583,
-0.2304252684,
-0.7368816733,
-0.1256106347,
-0.6130081415,
-0.0496245101,
-0.2338022888,
-0.2714753151,
0.7565128207,
0.2435042113,
-0.1443174928,
0.2975549996,
-0.4998475611,
0.2099839002,
0.5521432161,
0.4989295304,
0.0431837887,
-0.0328301489,
0.4151009023,
0.5795167089,
-0.6890333295,
-0.3918623626,
1.1263775826,
0.4175777137,
0.562290132,
0.3144749105,
0.7368462086,
0.45646891,
0.2315486073,
-0.2003348619,
0.277123332,
-0.0329389162,
-0.844715476,
-0.1188061982,
-0.4111166596,
-1.1413726807,
-0.1039873436,
-0.440872848,
-1.0556584597,
0.6260274053,
-0.0547416322,
-0.8963234425,
-0.0142851388,
-0.7071536183,
0.572817266,
0.1521734744,
0.1118980721,
0.1644855291,
-0.8678508997,
0.1976772398,
-0.1620190442,
0.5444761515,
-0.5630568862,
0.1330493242,
0.8498085737,
-0.1388817132,
0.9583179951,
0.2383446544,
0.211478591,
0.4663831294,
-0.3995383978,
0.2435841858,
0.4092274308,
-0.203030169,
0.2279853076,
0.2005822808,
-0.4385733902,
-0.0297277085,
0.25501737,
-0.6421521902,
-0.588486135,
-0.2608537078,
-0.5092718005,
-0.2068028152,
0.1073067263,
0.1661883742,
0.882710278,
0.0560528077,
0.1441656351,
0.8114286065,
-0.3456674218,
0.3492158055,
0.6151329875,
-0.4600897431,
-0.4986460209,
0.6727582216,
-0.0186710432,
0.136047557,
0.3380739391,
0.119823657,
0.0208554044,
-0.4691804349,
-0.6112932563,
0.0186123606,
-0.4694085717,
-0.3531624675,
-0.9649190903,
-0.0536943227,
-0.6975007653,
0.087664023,
0.2369924933,
-0.4080273807,
-0.2813242078,
-0.1865612715,
0.758684516,
0.4807003438,
-0.0801140368,
0.3756725192,
-0.9853475094,
0.3735209703,
-0.0441387668,
0.2229710519,
-0.5845778584,
-0.2368428111,
-0.1014171168,
-0.1005605832,
-0.0920996442,
-1.1993077993,
0.2517899275,
0.2178096473,
0.6943393946,
0.3852754533,
0.3316819072,
0.4652674198,
-0.2364196777,
0.5315719247,
0.1323294044,
-0.5722839832,
0.6621204019,
-0.923995018,
0.0189870428,
0.4346629977,
0.5467517376,
-0.6340665221,
-0.4688334465,
-0.8520804048,
-0.7956750989,
0.615106225,
0.2303507328,
-0.6361056566,
-0.3707643449,
0.2780737579,
0.1737606674,
0.0710458755,
-0.2365213186,
-0.2586247027,
0.089622274,
-0.2013335526,
0.1177939698,
-0.0945688635,
-0.4873088002,
-0.1261189878,
0.6986208558,
0.1620902717,
0.4693721831,
0.6299213171,
0.106347844,
-0.2174848765,
0.3121789396,
0.3449359238,
0.5990440249,
-0.5135756135,
0.1871133745,
-0.1302953809,
-0.5182420611,
-0.1488806903,
0.4264146388,
-0.346499294,
0.0709026977,
0.5593655705,
0.5306113362,
0.0766097531,
-0.7945432663,
0.4866345823,
0.3005766869,
-0.1408438981,
-0.5114243627,
-0.016092781,
-0.0284673609,
0.3196746707,
0.6993964314,
0.3277408779,
0.3712099493,
-0.5907437801,
0.6933959126,
0.2176588476,
-0.3179098666,
-0.5500500798,
0.5920712352,
0.2115998715,
-0.0417543501,
0.1454510391,
-0.1252926141,
-0.4090790153,
1.1212029457,
0.6571215987,
0.2902009189,
-0.4707988799,
0.3197418153,
0.3397084177,
0.3747876585,
0.0776604787,
0.5038856268,
0.4961510599,
-0.4772568345,
-0.446664542,
-0.6624931097,
-0.3452167213,
0.0941738486,
-0.8241811991,
0.2072349638,
-0.0463848375,
-0.4320569634,
0.8253531456,
-0.3352352083,
-0.3286576569,
0.2730495334,
0.2458524853,
1.0580474138,
-0.784507215,
0.5516439676,
0.6683093905,
-0.3193892837,
-0.5631917119,
-0.1552559733,
0.2435768545,
-0.7513375282,
0.370718658,
0.3755012453,
0.6785294414,
0.0429575108,
-0.3291301727,
-1.0311101675,
0.7670072913,
0.0615372285,
-0.4776947498,
0.0871030912,
-0.1523853689,
0.371029228,
-0.5038366914,
0.3073475361,
0.3970966339,
0.6183761358,
0.0002416331,
-0.9786428213,
-0.2343899906,
-0.388081044,
-0.6565997005,
0.4704036117,
-0.4315575361,
0.654755652,
-0.1185642034,
-0.3913871348,
-0.2522053421,
0.3692072034,
-0.1434258074,
1.0278693438,
0.4080733657,
0.6494209766,
1.0082070827,
-0.3506549597,
1.278570652,
-0.103211306,
0.054885298,
1.1385928392,
-0.3348653913,
0.7816419005,
0.1621372253,
-0.2239497304,
0.3334371448,
0.9771952629,
-0.1371891648,
0.3519364595,
0.2317557484,
-0.432074666,
-0.5489033461,
-0.249312073,
-0.6304031014,
0.2964800894,
0.6273328066,
-0.2551671863,
-0.3820438087,
0.48517102,
-0.205434531,
-0.0869817063,
-0.6361442804,
0.7538495064,
-0.2210221142,
-0.2037396729,
0.2368175238,
-0.3200254142,
0.3233523071,
-0.4986639619,
-0.0435373001,
0.1850799173,
0.1061394587,
-0.3040346205,
-0.5862281322,
0.5779752731,
-0.079735212,
-0.4842303097,
0.0498832017,
0.7262752056,
-0.3326075971,
-0.3813565075,
0.1071335748,
0.4832912982,
0.4110489488,
-0.058938995,
-0.3968979716,
-0.0923878029,
-0.0859185606,
-0.3202924132,
0.1360086948,
0.2204565853,
-0.2563074231,
0.6612774134,
0.5902778506,
0.1260690242,
0.1495761126,
-0.2161191702,
0.6549837589,
-0.5584229231,
-0.2591826916,
-0.4658379257,
0.0911265984,
-0.4803477526,
-0.3826415837,
0.7416241765,
0.8141162992,
0.4245555401,
0.122064136,
0.8320468068,
-0.2120008916,
1.1594502926,
-0.1852920949,
0.5383203626,
-0.2972310781,
0.3173845112,
0.0409952626,
-0.0707974657,
-0.3757710755,
0.1197727025,
-0.3992972076,
-0.5303515196,
0.5787410736,
0.4531766474,
0.2830916047,
0.5645631552,
-0.1701133549,
0.1041792706,
0.0962330624,
0.5380444527,
0.6976283789,
-0.4332746565,
0.4017955065,
-0.1534606814,
-0.5233225226,
-0.4371598661,
-0.6572386026,
-0.8795804381,
-0.4478597641,
-0.5740409493,
-0.3815566897,
0.4160363078,
1.2533752918,
0.5488692522,
-0.8200683594,
0.4902306497,
0.0398836359,
0.1947246641,
-0.5614182353,
-0.1951065809,
0.5150204301,
-0.0990313515,
-0.3915747404,
0.5131123066,
0.1501898915,
0.0332091786,
0.3883734643,
0.7684484124,
-0.4268582761,
0.0499898866,
0.4619788229,
0.4945042133,
-0.375172466,
-0.4556519389,
0.1126516238,
-0.0647142828,
-0.1513361633,
0.3418168724,
-0.6272576451,
0.136666894,
0.3964321613,
0.8909729719,
0.2187383771,
-0.0258579198,
0.3836308122,
-0.78068012,
-0.171368584,
0.2695250511,
0.2409541011,
-0.0266133863,
-0.5943775177,
0.8993064761,
0.4430941045,
-0.7317003012,
-1.0245579481,
0.1254042536,
-1.4390456676,
-0.3007369041,
1.290096283,
-0.0500887074,
-0.6239383817,
-0.6061458588,
-0.0393018983,
0.0050824345,
-0.5006293654,
0.551160574,
0.4883031249,
-0.295917213,
0.0704480782,
-0.7863411903,
0.4640266001,
0.0792802349,
-1.0128859282,
-0.066916734,
0.374009341,
0.3416116238,
0.2480754405,
0.6350559592,
-0.0185986161,
0.5027745366,
0.2254522294,
0.3770566285,
-0.095963046,
-0.2201699317,
-0.02852761,
0.3585930765,
-0.72983706,
-0.2128905207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14471v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14471v1 | CGCE: A Chinese Generative Chat Evaluation Benchmark for General and Financial Domains | 2023-05-23T18:54:15 | 2023-05-23T18:54:15 | Xuanyu Zhang, Bingbing Li, Qing Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative chat models, such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, have revolutionized
natural language generation (NLG) by incorporating instructions and human
feedback to achieve significant performance improvements. However, the lack of
standardized evaluation benchmarks for chat models, particularly for Chinese
and domain-specific models, hinders their assessment and progress. To address
this gap, we introduce the Chinese Generative Chat Evaluation (CGCE) benchmark,
focusing on general and financial domains. The CGCE benchmark encompasses
diverse tasks, including 200 questions in the general domain and 150 specific
professional questions in the financial domain. Manual scoring evaluates
factors such as accuracy, coherence, expression clarity, and completeness. The
CGCE benchmark provides researchers with a standardized framework to assess and
compare Chinese generative chat models, fostering advancements in NLG research. | [
-0.3152425587,
-0.9176251292,
0.0327478014,
0.6500509977,
-0.1534254849,
0.2018870562,
-0.4101316333,
-0.6025425196,
-0.199447751,
0.2217798233,
-0.5377189517,
-0.7703937292,
-0.3103337586,
-0.0935841873,
-0.3897562027,
1.0736798048,
0.2999696434,
0.0250550751,
-0.1285605431,
0.2127060592,
-0.4690792859,
-0.4468439221,
-1.3758440018,
-0.0489758067,
0.1754060239,
0.0120776491,
0.7647279501,
0.1146710664,
0.7499519587,
0.2742012441,
0.2909303904,
0.2047214657,
-0.6031092405,
-0.1871646643,
0.1274993122,
-0.1207752526,
-0.6012296677,
0.1772117466,
0.4249192476,
0.6620919704,
-0.4751613736,
0.2248102427,
0.3862347901,
0.5479396582,
-0.7836008072,
0.4377523363,
-0.6427769065,
0.0242221989,
-0.1353273988,
-0.2064238638,
-0.4537132978,
-0.7059997916,
0.5704008937,
-0.654168427,
0.5583379269,
-0.1222214997,
1.0343159437,
-0.173072651,
-0.3619141281,
-0.3107897639,
-0.5038738251,
0.6687031984,
-0.5755271316,
0.2584633529,
0.1225086674,
0.6544266343,
-0.1183250919,
-1.1218961477,
-0.2890976667,
-0.6092064977,
0.0708681345,
0.3061152101,
-0.3935960233,
0.3248178661,
0.1422449946,
0.7303544283,
-0.7862975001,
-0.1290849149,
-0.1268678308,
-0.2205360234,
0.7797170281,
-0.0178947803,
0.6233162284,
-0.058687102,
-0.4636288583,
-0.2912188172,
-0.7077067494,
-0.0938691869,
0.4576028585,
0.2284380049,
-0.0719201788,
0.079658471,
-0.2222615927,
0.6113445759,
0.1252502501,
0.1969820857,
0.0376134999,
-0.4662621021,
-0.5234715939,
-0.1454921514,
1.044908762,
0.4995694458,
0.2875293493,
-0.3208877742,
0.1033147797,
0.1719662398,
0.3186947107,
-0.8229709268,
-0.5050740838,
0.0324845202,
-0.3251436055,
-0.1305862367,
0.1365901828,
-0.8245954514,
-0.1421145052,
-0.1810984612,
0.1107900664,
-0.3238521516,
-0.2163262665,
-0.0126711791,
-0.3392999768,
0.7252933383,
0.2574371099,
-1.2370444536,
0.6327976584,
0.9243747592,
0.7281364202,
-0.3455607295,
0.0234834943,
-0.5631087422,
-0.0424687564,
-0.3692263365,
0.9871448874,
-0.4562861919,
-0.7115459442,
0.1505838633,
-0.1890094578,
-0.3440466225,
-0.5718322992,
0.8233274817,
-0.3457653821,
0.3254827261,
-0.4176166952,
-0.7534804344,
-0.0695648864,
0.400862813,
-0.4242326021,
0.9809587598,
0.210632205,
-0.6831359863,
0.6229540706,
-0.8174798489,
-0.0297226533,
0.7359198332,
-0.3952974975,
-0.2397927046,
-0.3119051158,
0.231954962,
0.1291746646,
-0.8509443402,
0.4012963772,
-0.2957488,
-0.5656305552,
0.007628026,
-0.8957973123,
0.6028721333,
0.1923764497,
-0.3912956715,
0.1211811602,
-0.6294227839,
0.4100669026,
0.0383244045,
-0.0272556618,
-0.0782351345,
0.1961091757,
0.2070349306,
-0.1214369908,
0.3746905625,
-0.4837517142,
0.2046601325,
-0.3929520547,
0.4912876785,
0.5845822096,
0.2020129114,
0.1055092067,
-0.2119014561,
0.5032446384,
-0.1475951672,
0.3239973187,
0.0598017648,
-0.5599134564,
-0.5350979567,
-0.1328033358,
0.4234072864,
0.6716547608,
-0.570864737,
0.3224306107,
-0.1662899256,
-0.8198921084,
-0.5097057223,
0.0451346971,
0.3472386897,
0.0903742239,
0.1957748532,
-0.3630032837,
-0.1790560782,
-1.0098483562,
-0.3770470619,
-0.2147141248,
-0.4907967746,
0.3915055394,
0.1254238933,
-0.0699106455,
0.661454618,
-0.5688394308,
0.0358511284,
-0.0506769791,
0.5412778258,
0.0115295174,
0.3828826547,
0.8386024833,
-0.8173608184,
-0.805218339,
0.2736675143,
-0.6130524278,
-0.1182800233,
-0.3246226311,
-0.2305437028,
-0.0696746558,
0.2777887583,
-0.4792730808,
0.3726421297,
0.9418817163,
-0.2214882076,
0.7272807956,
-0.0313974507,
0.5517943501,
-0.8253110647,
0.1137130409,
0.1249356642,
0.0023919598,
-0.6539635658,
0.0532830842,
-0.0536929406,
-0.3450659811,
-0.2456781417,
0.5044301748,
-0.3823442161,
-0.0321879089,
-0.123004362,
0.6747260094,
-0.1697972417,
0.6086788774,
-0.1248030663,
1.1439267397,
0.5964180827,
-0.5408805609,
0.3621306717,
0.1396424919,
-0.4962763488,
0.6535872817,
-1.0316513777,
0.4485527873,
0.4256460667,
-0.0352226831,
-0.9934176803,
-0.0064895586,
0.1644576639,
-0.4093350768,
0.1716552228,
-0.0185054988,
-0.26728037,
-0.3955765069,
-0.2666118741,
0.332175076,
0.3674497902,
-0.5837553144,
0.2823435068,
0.1041817516,
-0.1963865459,
-0.6430155039,
-0.4628177583,
0.3565509915,
-0.0333164334,
-1.0087248087,
0.5548501015,
-0.2747005522,
-0.0972686559,
-0.1345186383,
-0.0092221415,
-0.1197320595,
0.0348943658,
-0.0663880631,
0.4088798761,
-0.4498803318,
-0.215962857,
-0.1332509071,
0.0543716103,
0.2133656591,
-0.2763778865,
0.5890558362,
-0.3305881619,
-0.5549630523,
-0.1743962169,
0.2443036139,
-0.041453179,
-0.1000349224,
0.5104709268,
0.5140658617,
-0.2410325557,
-0.2964416146,
-0.6078551412,
0.2094514519,
-0.5937425494,
0.3339390457,
-0.3330111206,
-1.0775680542,
0.4698584378,
0.0192348287,
0.2295904756,
0.8050066829,
0.5838870406,
0.4375020266,
0.9535640478,
0.5004053712,
-0.0756364912,
0.342140764,
0.0571535639,
0.4891977906,
-0.5053364038,
0.0360195376,
-0.4960540533,
0.1410472393,
-0.9694805145,
-0.3404124677,
0.1925517917,
0.3082083762,
-0.2350778878,
0.408857882,
-0.6608421803,
0.5617654324,
0.348800391,
-0.2091639638,
0.211664781,
-0.3052422702,
-0.0541948006,
0.0403477997,
-0.4604194462,
-0.7322057486,
0.8532626033,
0.266901195,
0.4102234244,
-0.0571517162,
0.4478271902,
0.562127769,
0.7308300734,
-0.5724450946,
0.4357877076,
-0.3716757298,
-0.468714416,
-0.1663819551,
-0.6197323203,
-0.8918330669,
0.2434129417,
0.0463112518,
-0.8574998379,
-0.0210127123,
0.1206049919,
-0.3216059804,
0.0701947808,
-0.8865613937,
1.2330307961,
-0.0945532992,
0.0231671408,
-0.1705213487,
-0.0635864362,
0.7761717439,
0.0616151243,
-0.2159790993,
-0.28339082,
0.3267531693,
0.5826198459,
-0.3796988428,
0.7148521543,
-0.2232361883,
-0.1684489995,
0.7639016509,
-0.110629797,
0.3049152792,
0.2404730171,
0.095902212,
0.3328753412,
0.1387434453,
-0.5239271522,
-0.5496794581,
0.7106737494,
-0.84940207,
-0.5570821762,
-0.305762738,
-0.0981482044,
-0.4840551317,
-0.1345009506,
0.264598757,
0.1571045369,
-1.1118620634,
0.2190701365,
0.1976390034,
-0.5258312225,
0.3597761691,
0.3223478794,
-0.0032907508,
-0.4496969879,
0.6641194224,
-0.2553624213,
0.6043297052,
0.211165309,
-0.0603893623,
-0.3005129993,
-0.2705639899,
-0.3185072243,
-0.1138211563,
-0.8095026612,
-0.104958877,
-0.4017798007,
-0.7941299081,
-0.3933041394,
-0.1086051241,
-0.2869254351,
0.0258114319,
-0.0705001503,
-0.087406531,
0.1408672184,
0.5501074195,
0.0920258984,
0.3567483425,
-0.859903574,
0.327636987,
0.7438429594,
0.5452364683,
0.1058519483,
-0.1720626056,
-0.1497548372,
0.2355129123,
-0.7392633557,
-0.488884002,
0.1871125251,
0.2911731601,
0.6611014009,
0.5208268166,
-0.2531458139,
0.8376806378,
-0.4197053611,
1.1375658512,
0.4413880706,
-1.1825637817,
0.3438790739,
-0.5490374565,
0.2021818757,
0.4581620097,
0.1505075693,
-1.0387160778,
-0.5269320607,
-0.6582685709,
-0.6467276216,
0.1777699292,
0.4799771607,
0.2951286733,
-0.4767442942,
0.3830901086,
-0.0471658595,
0.1276858002,
-0.5593406558,
-0.1851751059,
-0.325012058,
0.111950703,
0.1562723368,
-0.2466327697,
0.1516283005,
0.0949062109,
0.3822230101,
-0.2760362625,
0.5135425925,
0.0906563625,
0.3913191557,
-0.0233765393,
0.3510469794,
0.4828538299,
0.6003630757,
-0.164304629,
-0.533205986,
0.3121756017,
-0.5480152369,
-0.2784385383,
0.2017208785,
-0.0025584099,
-0.1325801462,
0.3357335329,
0.8294769526,
0.3157593012,
-0.5788596272,
0.6812489629,
-0.5002444386,
-0.5588023663,
-0.4521674812,
0.3553803563,
0.1700794846,
-0.1154875681,
0.4715873301,
-0.0075587733,
0.3204535544,
-0.5350972414,
0.3617250919,
0.512701571,
-0.4096541405,
-0.2727240026,
0.920137465,
0.3552399576,
-0.0532065593,
0.9459456205,
-0.3903105855,
-0.2212091088,
0.670091331,
0.4420443475,
1.4666199684,
-0.0762839392,
0.406409353,
0.6542291641,
0.1926027536,
-0.0961100757,
0.3588651717,
-0.1536915153,
-0.7526575327,
-0.7101278901,
-0.6714453697,
-0.8097187877,
-0.0752981827,
-0.8065796494,
0.3656263649,
-0.467490077,
-0.2066683173,
0.0853978023,
0.1123427451,
-0.8299998641,
0.3299676478,
0.4140158892,
0.9801962376,
-0.4700543582,
0.6704511046,
0.0427289531,
-0.2794667184,
-0.6627289653,
-0.0124085872,
-0.3115219474,
-0.8952537775,
0.4712766409,
0.1290136576,
-0.1315751523,
-0.2348601222,
-0.7661240101,
-0.6377668381,
0.9838166833,
0.2830566764,
-0.795475781,
-0.0170931499,
0.4430873394,
0.8291529417,
-0.4205217063,
0.4530570805,
0.7585575581,
0.5490484834,
0.1829482168,
-0.9720074534,
-0.2462831438,
-0.5469403267,
0.1995522678,
0.1852846891,
-0.911267221,
0.6310468316,
0.2623529136,
-0.6460345984,
0.2284101248,
0.8243609071,
0.2488017082,
0.1413863599,
0.4459357262,
0.2114419043,
0.8255119324,
-0.6511175036,
1.2439149618,
-0.523661077,
0.4101269245,
0.9809522629,
-0.3215058148,
0.7746684551,
-0.2380788922,
-0.3940244615,
0.4578446448,
0.6868392229,
-0.431011349,
0.2061287016,
0.4764107168,
-0.4741455317,
-0.1699423939,
-0.0929899737,
-0.3710035384,
0.4811198115,
0.3075481951,
0.0013021537,
-0.1396461874,
-0.494269222,
-0.1318892092,
-0.0357057713,
-0.1926794052,
0.7895895243,
0.2035984248,
-0.8145430088,
0.5813052058,
0.0556212105,
0.6007783413,
-0.9548056126,
-0.0386781543,
-0.2036776692,
0.1089147329,
-0.0338377915,
-0.4421913922,
0.4398464561,
0.161323145,
0.2521823049,
0.0100910878,
0.5452871919,
-0.4418766499,
-0.3237292171,
0.4316034615,
0.2210909575,
-0.0484953374,
-0.2294249088,
-0.8991575837,
-0.3487668931,
-0.0298211034,
-0.2878795564,
0.3009362519,
0.5203368664,
0.0361220911,
0.4963482618,
0.827023387,
-0.1712874621,
-0.0437416397,
0.4659634829,
0.7181583047,
-0.8927210569,
-0.4435437918,
-0.8357329965,
0.2473410368,
-0.2838881612,
-0.6940922141,
0.8476105332,
0.5633612275,
0.7463873625,
-0.0504227951,
0.9323804975,
-0.0416073166,
0.170212701,
-0.2674575448,
0.6679663658,
-0.1853003949,
0.1416504085,
-0.5104783773,
-1.029753685,
-0.187618196,
0.3028306663,
-0.3573700488,
0.2021061331,
0.7035236359,
0.5611075759,
0.2994900942,
0.4868534803,
0.5293562412,
-0.1603029519,
0.6052340269,
0.7305810452,
0.824804306,
-0.7318897843,
0.7154012918,
-0.0772826821,
-0.0733493418,
0.2968057692,
-0.9937201738,
-1.0136334896,
-0.2204509228,
-0.565486908,
0.0281922687,
0.0016695885,
0.8306061625,
0.4707165658,
-1.0572086573,
-0.4026384354,
-0.1656147987,
-0.403966248,
-0.5615894794,
-0.3524886668,
0.5405861735,
-0.6310683489,
-0.7920215726,
0.241321221,
0.5633787513,
0.0130073689,
-0.2522829175,
0.0524738804,
0.11981792,
0.2207892686,
0.5796667337,
0.2496688366,
-0.493290484,
-0.4081844389,
0.0426468067,
-0.3054876328,
0.0863700733,
0.8638840318,
-0.1896072179,
0.2555969656,
0.2534754574,
0.6989201903,
0.4480359256,
0.216605112,
0.9720386863,
-0.7466871738,
-0.0070957118,
0.1129207909,
0.1921431422,
0.2857706249,
-0.322354883,
0.5774965286,
0.1200769618,
-0.8777805567,
-0.2789911032,
-0.1699720174,
-1.0442644358,
0.0096409535,
0.8923485279,
-0.3679510057,
-0.1321303844,
0.0597048365,
-0.2607522011,
0.1152944714,
-0.2588124275,
0.8310810924,
0.864941597,
0.2273484021,
-0.0050757458,
-0.7371465564,
0.7987937927,
0.294275701,
-1.0707842112,
0.2951644361,
0.3614958227,
0.1141740978,
-0.0459220633,
0.9003855586,
-0.1563694775,
0.6529477239,
0.3772506416,
0.1946156919,
0.5032963753,
0.1326520592,
0.1936451197,
0.2741902173,
0.067706652,
-0.0661858246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14468v1 | Run Like a Girl! Sports-Related Gender Bias in Language and Vision | 2023-05-23T18:52:11 | 2023-05-23T18:52:11 | Sophia Harrison, Eleonora Gualdoni, Gemma Boleda | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Gender bias in Language and Vision datasets and models has the potential to
perpetuate harmful stereotypes and discrimination. We analyze gender bias in
two Language and Vision datasets. Consistent with prior work, we find that both
datasets underrepresent women, which promotes their invisibilization. Moreover,
we hypothesize and find that a bias affects human naming choices for people
playing sports: speakers produce names indicating the sport (e.g. 'tennis
player' or 'surfer') more often when it is a man or a boy participating in the
sport than when it is a woman or a girl, with an average of 46% vs. 35% of
sports-related names for each gender. A computational model trained on these
naming data reproduces the bias. We argue that both the data and the model
result in representational harm against women. | [
0.0447530635,
-0.7266920805,
0.5840577483,
-0.1154099554,
0.0755698085,
0.1972768903,
0.1952265352,
-0.6976032853,
0.0671458542,
0.5383617878,
-0.7564225197,
-0.2807154357,
-0.7618852854,
-0.2040182799,
-0.711198926,
0.7034639716,
0.0717927888,
0.8327872753,
-0.1133070141,
0.0141389836,
-1.2706084251,
-0.5633909702,
-0.5239397287,
-0.3949080706,
0.0473528318,
0.1344216168,
0.7004848123,
0.7887141109,
0.4709277153,
0.2771575451,
-0.1103113592,
-0.0776531249,
-0.6570456624,
0.5556984544,
-0.1389859766,
-0.4844661355,
-0.0502260812,
0.3156352043,
0.5014474392,
0.7410638332,
0.1749540716,
0.2637553215,
-0.2458691299,
0.7356444001,
-0.4801420569,
0.051188048,
-0.4237597883,
0.272639066,
-0.2584035695,
0.1485367566,
0.0098181758,
-0.2996212542,
0.2948949635,
-0.5560778379,
0.4395021498,
0.368870765,
0.8614865541,
-0.0627585724,
-0.3161496818,
-0.3929237425,
-0.7267211676,
0.9631504416,
-0.2726084888,
0.577224791,
0.4234366417,
0.297660917,
0.0090350797,
0.1168262362,
-0.3304259181,
-0.0914352983,
0.0758448318,
-0.2339928299,
-0.4495799541,
-0.125777334,
0.725446701,
-0.1022645906,
-0.5036624074,
-0.0190257076,
-0.5111228824,
0.3547472954,
0.8660793304,
0.2774205804,
0.8702344298,
0.110842146,
-0.0308940392,
0.0517675951,
-0.7930626273,
0.0549742579,
1.0420310497,
0.4851522148,
-0.0104524381,
0.5504717827,
-0.2528015971,
0.5662899017,
0.2778820395,
0.0588364042,
0.5027385354,
0.2145181894,
-0.092197068,
0.5355907679,
0.5581938624,
0.6966053247,
0.8492722511,
-0.2371491641,
0.0430271439,
0.2790172696,
0.4735379815,
-0.7452628613,
-0.115135096,
-0.1015517637,
-0.7323025465,
-0.5341998935,
0.2448057681,
-0.8054867983,
-0.8621878028,
-0.2186629027,
0.5477086902,
-0.2536338568,
-0.2319217771,
0.2173069865,
-0.6076447964,
0.2306118309,
0.1102175787,
-1.1541498899,
0.331107825,
0.5501421094,
0.3673040271,
0.2461604625,
-0.1093545407,
-0.2888736725,
0.1357676834,
-0.5784671903,
0.70643574,
-0.8345662355,
-0.4172795713,
-0.084348619,
-0.1849481463,
-0.1092005,
-0.5858367085,
-0.0952081606,
0.0120836822,
-0.1185749546,
-0.4960930049,
-0.2923795283,
-0.2217698693,
-0.0631766841,
-0.4266331494,
0.8056333065,
-0.2768909633,
-0.982434392,
0.9354667664,
-0.6246230006,
-0.3852334917,
-0.1809234172,
-0.6574766636,
-0.4522973001,
0.3542888165,
0.2226618975,
0.0149040464,
-0.2537037432,
-0.0357345231,
-0.4619042873,
-0.4599940479,
0.3041312695,
-0.1915418953,
0.7454782128,
-0.1001396254,
-0.5598287582,
-0.0000917863,
-0.4931117892,
-0.3195520043,
0.2207231969,
0.3874149323,
-0.7679224014,
0.5741544366,
-0.1772711277,
0.1923515946,
-0.3551865816,
-1.0242333412,
0.1007962227,
-0.1854187846,
0.2530946434,
0.7667888999,
-0.3271524608,
0.5357968211,
-0.2882232368,
0.6333813071,
0.1587097496,
0.3753343523,
0.0519535244,
-0.6318500042,
-0.5346975327,
-0.0200120583,
0.1461120397,
0.44162184,
-0.4872328639,
-0.4427212179,
-0.253505975,
-0.3313962817,
-0.5694045424,
-0.2044992745,
0.5494353771,
0.5741485953,
0.1322809011,
-0.2655191422,
-0.7637115717,
-1.2547950745,
-0.7196412086,
-0.3848644495,
0.1752735674,
0.5529047251,
0.6176454425,
0.0289985053,
0.9013947248,
-0.7627648711,
-0.5698742867,
-0.1850910336,
0.0256571602,
0.0710653067,
0.721418798,
0.9003039002,
-0.9723287225,
-0.2740136087,
-0.4363226593,
-0.8950365782,
-0.2377099246,
0.4827157855,
-0.4162891805,
-0.0904913023,
0.3606970012,
-0.306456238,
0.9827888012,
0.323163867,
-1.0734821558,
0.3602995276,
0.2400628477,
0.4159533083,
-0.4867836833,
-0.1489816308,
0.2135632038,
-0.1403518915,
-0.712256968,
-0.0223622974,
-0.3354480565,
-0.0877367854,
-0.6145195365,
0.391149193,
-0.3498475254,
-0.2485833019,
-0.3250516653,
-0.500918746,
-0.2244025022,
-0.3899604082,
0.2539890409,
0.4480267763,
0.7759066224,
-0.3497615457,
0.3059681356,
0.4017069042,
-0.3708483577,
0.6682949066,
-0.6446177363,
0.0467229076,
-0.5153622627,
0.2485381365,
-0.8087738156,
-0.2577542961,
0.2978616655,
-0.5351334214,
0.259698838,
-0.3116209805,
-0.3343085349,
-0.6732307673,
-0.2537204623,
0.7266483903,
0.4104905427,
-0.494897455,
0.3518761992,
0.8600478172,
0.2852172554,
-0.5398690104,
-1.0667408705,
-0.0668373704,
-0.4718261063,
-0.5150435567,
0.1079543009,
-0.1127179191,
-0.5647419095,
-0.1394451857,
-0.1718571931,
-0.3719673455,
-0.0033091509,
0.6113274097,
0.0672879666,
0.0242063385,
0.1642621905,
-0.2135822028,
0.1111004204,
0.0088511398,
0.104106687,
0.5591227412,
0.2190992683,
-0.0406632833,
-0.3389397264,
0.8274049163,
0.1166256145,
0.0717193484,
0.6629762053,
0.0585551076,
-0.4168553352,
-0.3226073682,
-0.3174254298,
-0.4040598571,
-0.4397525787,
0.4914956391,
-0.4703806043,
-0.7905958891,
0.4586625397,
0.7070897818,
-0.1669818908,
0.3120160103,
0.3162763119,
-0.4779878259,
1.500629425,
0.7170751095,
-0.0631298199,
0.3938449323,
-0.1279539466,
0.2050886154,
-0.4596551359,
-0.3846564591,
-0.6058492661,
-0.5979110599,
-0.6126981974,
-0.0877291188,
-0.2739873528,
-0.3224293292,
-0.6233552098,
0.430786401,
-0.6573011875,
0.7760379314,
0.502626121,
0.2538753748,
0.0038247101,
-0.0463707447,
0.2453140318,
-0.598624289,
-0.8275291324,
-0.2172972709,
1.2070881128,
0.3969930708,
0.9061109424,
0.2105278671,
0.6777960658,
0.4997841418,
0.271779865,
-0.4838194549,
0.2995078266,
-0.470505029,
-1.2826242447,
-0.2316409051,
-0.2678789794,
-0.979896009,
0.0454060771,
-0.2083907723,
-1.0146439075,
0.5708280802,
0.2278716713,
-0.0566566363,
0.326839745,
-0.4873802066,
0.6264657974,
-0.058775872,
-0.1951115876,
0.0272990447,
-0.3252903223,
0.618255496,
-0.0103207184,
0.5919286609,
-0.4627817273,
0.2418931574,
1.0402317047,
-0.4968721867,
0.756518662,
-0.3437953889,
0.2294511795,
0.1741448492,
0.1910701245,
-0.1535079032,
-0.1414614767,
0.0563614629,
0.4253493845,
-0.2347355038,
-0.347463429,
-0.1663315594,
0.7237508297,
-0.6915720105,
-0.4932427108,
-0.7707611918,
-0.4895571172,
-0.1413107216,
-0.0351266973,
0.2975422144,
0.3705639839,
-0.1271881312,
-0.004117907,
0.7080748677,
-0.3499110341,
0.4848045409,
0.497043401,
-0.5104335546,
-0.060613919,
0.6529130936,
0.4762911201,
-0.0870603025,
-0.1417508423,
0.1176068261,
-0.192277208,
-0.3434436619,
-0.3606737852,
0.2504452765,
-0.3761192858,
-0.0826130584,
-0.2031321079,
0.0180231929,
-0.4119529426,
0.1404233724,
-0.5401893258,
-0.1801710129,
-0.1787604243,
-0.2178894281,
0.2585231364,
1.0179532766,
0.2564358711,
0.6052543521,
-0.2503768802,
0.4412311912,
0.3855285943,
0.480373323,
-0.1417464763,
-0.606372714,
0.0578539856,
-0.0001998241,
-0.3232899308,
-1.0116291046,
0.468711108,
0.0483321249,
0.4862321019,
0.3630544841,
-0.2428403795,
0.536659658,
-0.8062143326,
0.7931293249,
0.5873894095,
-0.9009711146,
0.6950411201,
-0.6246045828,
0.0318684317,
0.527694881,
0.1725482196,
-0.4396598339,
-0.2890526056,
-0.6524002552,
-0.5254735351,
0.9020661116,
0.2225039303,
0.3334578574,
-0.227058962,
0.3260855675,
0.1922353655,
0.3732194304,
-0.6487801075,
-0.5760750771,
-0.1863874048,
-0.0213999264,
-0.0215166435,
-0.3731250763,
-0.0348222293,
-0.301494658,
0.7068600655,
0.1347013414,
0.313367784,
0.0434564352,
-0.2046265751,
-0.3504679799,
-0.2390131652,
0.2673887908,
0.6346684098,
-0.0083231414,
-0.0990396738,
-0.0305266604,
-0.5280761719,
0.2945840359,
-0.145042181,
-0.7384766936,
0.2474852353,
0.4584304392,
0.9297544956,
0.4725429416,
-0.724781692,
0.4871388674,
-0.1566280425,
-0.4654309452,
0.0029170266,
0.1172122657,
-0.1058286354,
0.3609369397,
0.4999579787,
-0.0199071132,
0.2790361047,
-0.9890488982,
-0.1375460923,
0.517399013,
-0.7336261272,
-0.1264543682,
1.0904904604,
0.1643204689,
-0.3502376378,
0.3641323447,
0.3336062729,
-0.719430387,
0.7375157475,
0.2396681607,
0.747603178,
-0.2848626971,
0.2094146013,
0.4233525991,
0.273334682,
-0.1849717349,
0.5014836788,
0.4616861343,
-0.8189374804,
0.0368514583,
-0.7342332602,
-0.0304576773,
-0.0007928824,
-0.4128747284,
0.2325693518,
-0.4249817729,
-0.6269646287,
0.3604511619,
-0.1330697984,
-0.7210603952,
0.4881965816,
0.6108311415,
0.4307566583,
-1.1978524923,
0.5720914602,
0.7734355927,
-0.5962393284,
-0.5361431837,
-0.0306681953,
0.0310862586,
-0.525560379,
1.35983181,
0.3119997084,
0.1786182523,
-0.450019449,
-0.5485218167,
-0.8391051292,
0.7620864511,
0.5887801051,
-0.556376338,
-0.1261297166,
0.280529052,
0.2458771914,
-0.7144762278,
0.3474038839,
0.7350245714,
0.4793221354,
-0.1842399389,
-1.0747036934,
-0.349052459,
0.0937315822,
0.2698621154,
-0.0149717946,
-0.6900857687,
0.9630088806,
-0.2636347711,
0.0178109519,
-0.0871199742,
0.4695189297,
0.445907861,
0.3594453335,
0.5074785352,
0.3890430629,
0.5394690037,
-0.2663585246,
1.121119976,
0.2138117254,
0.1980691552,
0.9288685322,
-0.0813267529,
0.3682405949,
0.3233652115,
-0.2513108552,
0.445250988,
0.3803505599,
-0.0270242784,
0.3439645767,
0.5169375539,
0.0164522603,
-0.3962485194,
-0.0318393558,
-0.3923208416,
0.9465283751,
-0.0672227293,
-0.8784777522,
-0.0766599327,
-0.0036711704,
0.2541314065,
0.2896108329,
-0.4962809682,
0.3614929318,
0.0739868656,
-0.3097774386,
-0.0886247307,
-0.0648779124,
0.6636505723,
-0.5242589116,
-0.0846853107,
-0.1189203933,
0.2281838655,
-0.2960726619,
-0.6800835729,
0.1267590821,
0.3051512241,
-0.7932311296,
-0.2930473983,
0.9664629102,
-0.4488400221,
-0.7190721035,
0.3461385965,
0.4293194115,
0.241940856,
-0.1184770614,
-0.789404273,
0.0978864655,
0.1040549278,
-0.2041055858,
0.6103010774,
-0.0336392336,
-0.3321237862,
0.9150162935,
0.5628510118,
0.2521108389,
0.562507689,
0.3364269435,
0.3537665009,
-0.5683560371,
-0.5714851022,
-1.0578567982,
0.027246939,
-0.2858112156,
-0.2875333428,
0.9707126617,
0.9206953049,
0.4276489317,
-0.1930987835,
0.6109657288,
0.1561560184,
0.5830734968,
-0.1227327362,
1.2557028532,
-0.3404169977,
-0.0790613443,
-0.5736076832,
-1.0635370016,
-0.3355143368,
0.7931456566,
-0.4707536101,
0.2804877758,
0.3438255191,
0.4274610877,
-0.0120862983,
0.021945959,
0.3428533971,
0.2374252379,
0.2293919325,
0.2712146342,
0.7557530403,
-0.5173714757,
0.2823957801,
-0.0208044779,
-0.2251620144,
-0.1615624428,
-0.6741711497,
-1.0587421656,
-0.2178931981,
-0.6043637395,
-0.3045837283,
0.7451537848,
0.5133215785,
1.0918684006,
-0.612493813,
-0.5171704292,
0.0338759609,
0.0680061206,
-0.0574956164,
-0.1897272915,
0.2305462956,
-0.1058106571,
-0.8911619782,
0.3022496998,
-0.21714212,
-0.046521686,
-0.0708386526,
-0.1052926481,
-0.265450418,
0.2034392506,
0.4253479838,
0.2136743665,
-0.5778707266,
-0.5647490621,
-0.4349104762,
0.0479503274,
-0.1048986316,
0.616083324,
-1.0277408361,
0.5694708228,
0.4427930713,
-0.0705843866,
0.4159010649,
0.0737914443,
0.8913898468,
-0.509082675,
0.0811196938,
0.0366100781,
0.1791502386,
0.2940114737,
-0.0609181523,
0.4503458142,
0.7904910445,
-0.182286799,
-1.0589393377,
0.0543121062,
-0.4832628965,
-0.4590872824,
1.3555868864,
0.225784108,
-0.3409852982,
0.0632919222,
-0.3120145202,
0.2145472616,
-0.6270391941,
0.6073978543,
0.7974618673,
-0.2792018354,
0.2022610158,
-0.9329031706,
0.6838623285,
0.0951171294,
-0.1758294106,
0.1367069781,
0.4967634678,
0.7388263345,
-0.3657872975,
0.3468414843,
0.1275984794,
0.4401364326,
0.2065716237,
0.2201216817,
-0.2106837779,
-0.1940968037,
-0.2016633451,
0.0038983668,
-0.5004526973,
-0.3639247119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14463v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14463v3 | ReadMe++: Benchmarking Multilingual Language Models for Multi-Domain Readability Assessment | 2023-05-23T18:37:30 | 2024-06-08T15:54:54 | Tarek Naous, Michael J. Ryan, Anton Lavrouk, Mohit Chandra, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We present a comprehensive evaluation of large language models for
multilingual readability assessment. Existing evaluation resources lack domain
and language diversity, limiting the ability for cross-domain and cross-lingual
analyses. This paper introduces ReadMe++, a multilingual multi-domain dataset
with human annotations of 9757 sentences in Arabic, English, French, Hindi, and
Russian, collected from 112 different data sources. This benchmark will
encourage research on developing robust multilingual readability assessment
methods. Using ReadMe++, we benchmark multilingual and monolingual language
models in the supervised, unsupervised, and few-shot prompting settings. The
domain and language diversity in ReadMe++ enable us to test more effective
few-shot prompting, and identify shortcomings in state-of-the-art unsupervised
methods. Our experiments also reveal exciting results of superior domain
generalization and enhanced cross-lingual transfer capabilities by models
trained on ReadMe++. We will make our data publicly available and release a
python package tool for multilingual sentence readability prediction using our
trained models at: https://github.com/tareknaous/readme | [
-0.2788578868,
-0.4817886055,
0.2102295309,
0.4705553949,
-0.0654199943,
0.199130699,
-0.31848827,
-0.9787425399,
-0.1600886434,
0.1328469515,
-0.64502424,
-0.5447462201,
-0.5708044171,
0.2935974896,
-0.1409703195,
0.387147218,
-0.3955548108,
0.3377683759,
-0.278701365,
-0.4842999279,
-0.5175623894,
-0.3223740458,
-0.4388488531,
-0.3749813735,
0.5017702579,
0.5307403803,
0.565385282,
0.2108594328,
0.3823120892,
0.253665328,
-0.056267947,
-0.0132444184,
-0.1138639227,
0.1325494051,
-0.1732109785,
-0.3418291211,
-0.5924091935,
0.0560106374,
0.8323947787,
0.8690416813,
0.1032781377,
0.0911048204,
-0.1871694177,
0.3040723503,
-0.6992445588,
-0.0969159603,
-0.1390091926,
0.0740008652,
-0.4165442586,
-0.0038058355,
-0.5262755752,
-0.4253843129,
0.1908958256,
-0.4995263517,
0.0974739045,
0.0410666987,
0.3836507797,
-0.3158629537,
-0.6162572503,
-0.0808707327,
-0.334864527,
1.0183144808,
-0.7124989033,
0.6618142128,
0.4321153164,
0.2832643688,
0.3052547872,
-0.4120924473,
-0.507538259,
-0.4576617777,
-0.0277782418,
0.0187666714,
-0.100690417,
-0.4961621165,
0.1951898038,
0.202009663,
-1.0469992161,
0.0029803389,
-0.1987304837,
-0.3814397752,
0.4636110067,
-0.0088261906,
0.6627876759,
0.0742776915,
-0.4167051911,
-0.188646391,
-0.6673547029,
0.0509944074,
0.6913508177,
0.4568893909,
-0.5443325639,
0.4763464034,
-0.3453607857,
0.5132013559,
-0.7005698681,
0.1311701387,
0.5046350956,
-0.7448730469,
0.1147223637,
-0.1909212619,
0.5895201564,
0.1317816377,
0.6066432595,
-0.1950927526,
0.0737777799,
-0.1932266504,
0.2215796262,
-0.998786211,
-0.1288241744,
0.2650580108,
-0.506721139,
-0.1125089601,
-0.1308330148,
-1.0675324202,
-0.690662384,
-0.2496509254,
0.2781140804,
-0.4765252769,
-0.442579329,
0.4075243175,
-0.1143571883,
0.3051809967,
0.4280532897,
-0.5996958017,
0.3789564967,
0.5655955672,
0.7966043949,
-0.378922075,
-0.7694727778,
-0.4492391646,
-0.0420199186,
0.0565189794,
0.9329884052,
-0.5816521645,
-0.2829284072,
0.2999843359,
0.1124396101,
-0.2836859226,
-0.511988759,
0.6714565754,
-0.3346509039,
0.1258053184,
-0.0276149996,
-0.3832041919,
-0.5502237678,
0.5900883675,
-0.8244512081,
0.5284007192,
0.0785591528,
-0.7342789173,
0.5438824892,
-0.876973033,
-0.7427248359,
0.1767279655,
0.3424096406,
-0.1918827593,
-0.157918185,
0.1536643952,
0.3510626554,
-0.1498107761,
-0.0907259732,
-0.5416761041,
-0.20875521,
0.2671402097,
-0.6339012384,
0.9600519538,
0.0515944324,
-0.0966274813,
0.3973423839,
-0.8803151846,
0.2693964839,
0.0174890067,
-0.3076214492,
-0.2339121848,
-0.1151502728,
0.6915800571,
0.2602764666,
0.1606121659,
-0.6874839664,
0.0806641355,
-0.2308482677,
0.0759929791,
0.2687803209,
-0.3047432303,
0.3057203293,
-0.3762529194,
0.9080938101,
0.2199451029,
0.0354828611,
-0.4903338552,
-0.2581530511,
-0.3037143052,
-0.4116285741,
0.1761871427,
0.8115938306,
-0.4328815043,
-0.2240263373,
0.0174161829,
-0.5909265876,
-0.5326000452,
0.2369754761,
0.422196269,
0.1150772199,
0.3561526835,
-0.3637245893,
-0.2426588684,
-0.5953637362,
-0.5516437888,
-0.0491509438,
0.264785409,
0.2737259567,
0.6310101151,
-0.4214513302,
0.2064213902,
-0.205820024,
0.0654071942,
-0.5984372497,
0.0682506487,
0.2039393783,
0.4898615777,
0.4900747538,
-0.6500439644,
-0.5765331388,
0.1584614068,
-0.5782280564,
-0.0508950651,
0.0973921418,
-0.0500316285,
0.0071822139,
0.1266019791,
-0.5840435624,
0.1071995422,
0.6850593686,
-0.5923784971,
0.8903923631,
-0.0975682288,
0.4434340596,
-1.1324462891,
0.2422632873,
0.2245287299,
-0.6079742312,
-0.5246199369,
0.5947626829,
0.3643125296,
-0.309895277,
-0.9063899517,
0.8108754754,
-0.5712092519,
0.1299217343,
0.0472075418,
0.0267776642,
0.2420425713,
0.1045423225,
0.0418225564,
0.8949848413,
0.8485975862,
-0.4815641344,
0.4098876417,
0.2497642487,
-0.7203356624,
0.6247983575,
-0.854865253,
-0.0531968959,
0.1303044707,
0.1498903334,
-0.9013286233,
-0.3570311666,
0.3223613203,
-0.1665697396,
0.5785318017,
0.0707363784,
-0.5758858323,
0.1038498878,
-0.6239570379,
0.7360677719,
-0.0224856455,
-0.523419261,
0.3181794584,
0.1494626403,
-0.4431293607,
-0.5578791499,
-0.570389986,
-0.0275860745,
-0.0588303097,
-0.8184666634,
-0.0590096004,
-0.4812629819,
-0.2454330921,
-0.4081881046,
0.0395651422,
-0.4480483234,
0.187363252,
0.0721361488,
0.2107322514,
-0.3391564786,
0.0213421322,
-0.1170486361,
-0.1005276665,
-0.114849709,
-0.0586204678,
0.4364061058,
-0.4016265571,
-0.3335261047,
-0.4598892927,
0.6377875209,
0.4604590535,
-0.395244509,
0.6169427037,
0.7570713758,
-0.334538877,
-0.1014340743,
-0.093172811,
0.1147081032,
-0.4040832222,
0.3915416598,
-0.5170300007,
-0.9063847661,
0.4944216013,
-0.413190186,
0.1980115175,
0.3178084493,
0.551559031,
0.0365839824,
0.6882368326,
0.7210947275,
-0.0791199282,
0.3681241274,
-0.023745276,
-0.0852248222,
-0.2983319759,
0.0599800274,
-0.6888503432,
-0.2123945504,
-0.3950059712,
-0.38034904,
-0.0912851393,
0.1385266036,
0.0000390963,
0.5115706921,
-0.0417646281,
0.5634211898,
0.1476759911,
-0.2702845335,
0.5343017578,
-0.1321353614,
-0.4205195308,
-0.1675926149,
-0.3742211163,
-0.4752210677,
0.9732205272,
0.3531182706,
0.7827530503,
0.4356034994,
0.3559479415,
0.3782238364,
0.2202973664,
-0.8942149282,
0.3603796661,
-0.139274478,
-0.647716105,
-0.1164121628,
-0.3660727143,
-0.9410461783,
0.3378348947,
-0.0768945217,
-0.9101968408,
0.3176174462,
-0.1808719784,
0.0017538447,
0.1714407355,
-0.8783134222,
1.2912740707,
-0.1372872144,
-0.1152659282,
-0.265768826,
-0.5071915388,
0.31572631,
-0.2930375338,
0.2608007193,
-0.0974980146,
-0.197713241,
0.4101465344,
0.0727912709,
0.8332138062,
0.1367684454,
-0.2863276303,
0.0109354537,
0.2019766569,
0.303612709,
0.2947570384,
-0.4735317528,
0.5686820745,
0.4798656702,
-0.6241857409,
-0.1666521579,
0.6596791744,
-0.8184530139,
0.0173535068,
-0.5226426721,
-0.7013401985,
-0.3114809692,
0.4855757058,
0.1435190439,
0.7226678133,
-0.447788924,
0.062426053,
0.4149774611,
-0.304897815,
0.4659633934,
0.9208389521,
-0.1512587816,
-0.3589060307,
0.8664258718,
-0.2038638145,
0.1074349433,
0.4686705768,
-0.0831212997,
-0.2140054107,
-0.5182073712,
-0.5307269692,
0.3036195338,
-0.691855371,
0.0943298191,
-0.3349117041,
0.0916569829,
-0.3568808436,
0.1044772491,
-0.2787900269,
-0.38856107,
-0.0735689402,
0.0003961384,
0.0426186956,
0.5686377287,
0.1638221294,
0.4828583896,
-0.9693926573,
0.2586278915,
-0.1705543697,
0.739995718,
-0.1810639203,
-0.4679639637,
-0.4816125929,
-0.1375631094,
-0.3218209743,
-0.8002387881,
0.2349121571,
0.284236908,
0.3807956576,
0.2850021422,
-0.0058247922,
0.3179015219,
-0.6622461081,
0.7095929384,
-0.0342481695,
-0.8707154393,
0.2774376869,
-0.2323433012,
0.7695128322,
0.8057448268,
0.4980677366,
-0.7566702962,
-0.2540211976,
-0.291754514,
-0.7179931998,
0.7005342245,
0.0612721071,
0.3537027538,
0.2652516365,
0.0627879724,
0.6417628527,
0.0352309085,
-0.6792015433,
-0.0870142207,
0.0376959071,
-0.0468931757,
-0.2678598166,
-0.294151634,
-0.0414374582,
-0.1081043109,
0.6673897505,
0.0014527508,
0.0650830641,
-0.1495777667,
-0.3610359728,
-0.1851103455,
0.767279923,
0.7622359991,
1.0591043234,
-0.2815174162,
0.0283929706,
-0.0209619012,
-0.7613142729,
0.1214429289,
0.422062844,
-0.1050250158,
0.1923181713,
0.7649312615,
0.6337957978,
-0.0551392883,
-0.9237904549,
0.4528433979,
-0.5118916631,
-0.1086859405,
-0.2404989153,
-0.1309780926,
0.0229256749,
0.3457499146,
0.0117796855,
0.2843034863,
0.2318244278,
-0.4887177646,
0.2078817487,
0.1310215443,
-0.5236476064,
-0.523604691,
0.5708875656,
0.3819659948,
-0.1771830022,
0.276742667,
-0.1086989194,
-0.2082042545,
0.4432634115,
0.4147982001,
0.880110383,
-0.1370060891,
0.3631524742,
0.3739165068,
0.4413593113,
-0.0762380287,
0.526719451,
-0.018395219,
-0.8046346307,
-0.4242782295,
-0.3935337663,
-0.7148910165,
0.0613553263,
-0.5966515541,
0.1607519835,
-0.0528921783,
0.0410047024,
0.2813010812,
0.3773024976,
-0.685377419,
0.1922048479,
-0.1011734754,
1.1820287704,
-0.8393810391,
0.8348055482,
0.9571602345,
-0.3881925941,
-0.408921361,
0.1845153719,
0.1081325561,
-0.4123319387,
0.2209025174,
0.5314785838,
0.0160098635,
-0.1729550362,
-0.3617882431,
-0.5185383558,
0.8028555512,
0.4663756788,
-0.4324940741,
0.4850170016,
-0.0862919465,
0.406547457,
-0.2827419937,
0.4384972751,
0.5242156982,
0.6344770193,
-0.1211669445,
-0.8167080879,
-0.016800832,
-0.628508985,
-0.4834289551,
0.1380398124,
-0.3898104727,
0.577742815,
-0.2715267837,
-0.0693244115,
0.1113487631,
0.4722962976,
0.2269941419,
0.6037567854,
0.494227916,
0.2814186215,
0.772493422,
0.1981102824,
1.504080534,
-0.1184012294,
0.1810163409,
1.2591720819,
-0.5773199201,
1.0496678352,
0.2472024411,
-0.3610787988,
0.3932282627,
0.7075684071,
0.0688515976,
0.2919865847,
-0.0991921499,
-0.4577720463,
-0.2635691464,
-0.2255939394,
-0.4245604873,
0.1825170517,
-0.1183704734,
0.0172940306,
-0.3290602565,
-0.0377749465,
0.0807693079,
-0.0049060024,
-0.0153777609,
0.4907680452,
0.1559164375,
-0.4062909782,
0.538865447,
0.1640353352,
0.6731051803,
-0.8058898449,
0.1064800769,
-0.2110803574,
0.3693455756,
-0.1771558672,
-1.0023319721,
0.3161927462,
0.227311641,
-0.421533525,
-0.1247319058,
0.7859687805,
-0.6051037908,
-0.6417058706,
0.6352983117,
0.7630282044,
0.5268589854,
0.0090735508,
-0.80338341,
-0.2464593798,
-0.0888622552,
-0.3127917349,
0.4948465526,
0.3022540212,
-0.0871548131,
0.7400039434,
0.5815645456,
0.1624919325,
0.0180826392,
0.7436107397,
0.4901136458,
-0.5705175996,
-0.1525361836,
-0.6933383346,
0.6260003448,
0.0923251286,
-0.4535833895,
0.8133200407,
0.608379662,
0.9270266294,
-0.2023323029,
0.7884738445,
0.0322743319,
0.4709756672,
-0.1774192452,
0.9839630723,
-0.8852849603,
-0.0622849241,
-0.2093061507,
-0.8511994481,
-0.4811859131,
0.1909598708,
-0.0800018758,
0.3005485535,
0.725879848,
0.6000453234,
-0.2909409106,
0.0661777183,
0.3710374534,
-0.022679748,
0.0642884746,
0.5353875756,
0.5935284495,
-0.3454651237,
0.623771131,
-0.0709941387,
-0.050401371,
-0.0695289299,
-0.960154891,
-0.908831358,
-0.2123878151,
-0.5821304321,
-0.2555232942,
-0.1247923002,
0.6605165601,
0.6587729454,
-1.1851736307,
-0.4144298434,
0.230557397,
0.281686008,
-0.5442373753,
-0.1655981392,
0.1957279593,
-0.3223066926,
-0.6840513945,
0.5297865272,
0.25901559,
0.0147802895,
-0.2042056024,
-0.1304267347,
-0.5151817799,
0.1135620624,
0.5473570228,
0.3709905446,
-0.355145514,
0.0621203184,
-0.0706071332,
-0.2508253753,
-0.0580792129,
0.6965079904,
-0.3751973212,
0.7980236411,
0.7806539536,
0.5159762502,
0.1961994022,
-0.1146475077,
0.7739336491,
-0.8242832422,
0.3038383722,
0.0979431644,
0.5020510554,
0.352837652,
-0.2314931005,
0.5984253287,
0.0310687628,
-0.3712670207,
-0.610068202,
0.181542173,
-1.0353788137,
-0.2155041546,
1.0326733589,
-0.6194915175,
-0.0259665735,
-0.0992897674,
-0.2916248739,
0.2163981944,
-0.3040001392,
0.1994906664,
1.071698904,
0.299058795,
-0.4938798249,
-0.7859461904,
0.1309038401,
0.5177559853,
-1.1396864653,
0.0735185891,
0.3620375097,
0.3446601629,
-0.0355296768,
0.4868981242,
-0.0600241087,
0.6556476355,
0.0131258592,
0.3018555641,
-0.0012898986,
-0.403220892,
-0.7324307561,
0.1582849324,
-0.0961538628,
0.0042538792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14459v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14459v3 | Advancing Precise Outline-Conditioned Text Generation with Task Duality and Explicit Outline Control | 2023-05-23T18:33:52 | 2024-02-07T06:28:44 | Yunzhe Li, Qian Chen, Weixiang Yan, Wen Wang, Qinglin Zhang, Hari Sundaram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing works on outline-conditioned text generation typically aim to
generate text using provided outlines as rough sketches, such as keywords and
phrases. However, these approaches make it challenging to control the quality
of text generation and assess consistency between outlines and generated texts
due to lack of clarity and rationality of the rough outlines. In this paper, we
introduce a novel text generation task called Precise Outline-conditioned
Generation, which requires generating stories based on specific, sentence-level
outlines. To facilitate research on this task, we construct two new datasets,
WPOG and CDM. We provide strong baselines based on fine-tuning models such as
BART and GPT-2, and evaluating zero-shot performance of models such as ChatGPT
and Vicuna. Furthermore, we identify an issue of imbalanced utilization of the
outline information in the precise outline-conditioned generation, which is
ubiquitously observed across fine-tuned models and zero-shot inference models.
To address this issue, we propose an explicit outline utilization control
approach and a novel framework that leverages the task duality between
summarization and generation. Experimental results show that the proposed
approaches effectively alleviate the issue of imbalanced outline utilization
and enhance the quality of precise outline-conditioned text generation for both
fine-tuning and zero-shot settings. | [
-0.1214363202,
-0.8401838541,
0.5371147394,
0.1907723099,
-0.4779680967,
0.0570931323,
-0.2974453568,
-0.3326009512,
0.1923316717,
0.7708933949,
-0.6739082932,
-0.5837051868,
-0.5678014755,
0.0931690112,
-0.199325189,
1.376657486,
-0.5314775705,
-0.5427179337,
-0.0679867789,
-0.1785624921,
-0.5490728021,
-0.3438282609,
-0.4070189595,
-0.3463110924,
0.4375597537,
0.7773103714,
0.6218349934,
0.6382544637,
0.3099107444,
0.1013795733,
0.4045297503,
0.6042403579,
-0.5219530463,
0.4506065845,
0.0329613015,
-0.0085683465,
-0.4781557322,
-0.1775769442,
0.4996618032,
0.6783675551,
-0.0543077551,
0.1283036917,
0.259819895,
0.4879097044,
-0.8461672068,
-0.0217633713,
-0.630243361,
0.0795003176,
-0.0724796578,
-0.4901323617,
-0.2880708873,
0.0200190879,
-0.091882199,
-0.7294347286,
0.5903546214,
-0.1713336706,
1.1549055576,
0.1840468943,
-0.6048100591,
-0.3018556237,
-0.86518538,
0.5367358327,
-0.6560177207,
-0.2264889926,
0.2092248648,
-0.0926741809,
0.1415110677,
-0.7713811398,
-0.4835935235,
-0.008507167,
-0.1622958928,
0.4372021556,
-0.0088022603,
0.4160107076,
0.2638786435,
0.3669108152,
-0.5314013958,
0.2122355551,
-0.2892671824,
-0.1943908632,
0.716219008,
0.4581362009,
0.3154758513,
-0.0834670216,
-0.3476557732,
0.0128187966,
-0.5172148347,
0.0479546748,
0.5472767949,
0.278193891,
-0.1113536358,
0.875954926,
-0.3626891077,
0.6863984466,
0.2333311886,
-0.0333944261,
-0.1193001643,
-0.5992361903,
-0.3632861972,
0.0256862342,
0.817966938,
0.6725345254,
0.217874974,
-0.1867377907,
-0.3751532435,
0.170513019,
0.3611960411,
-1.1216777563,
-0.19118312,
0.260068357,
-0.143875733,
-0.4329805076,
-0.0578172468,
-0.389219135,
-0.2805829048,
-0.4376875162,
0.3550803065,
-0.4045884013,
-0.1002551317,
0.2223456502,
-0.4192175865,
0.0035157239,
0.2613986731,
-1.0979955196,
0.2041107565,
0.2684178948,
0.878677845,
-0.0593987107,
-0.0728484094,
-0.4235856533,
0.6744180918,
-0.3130589128,
0.7621580362,
-0.0882569924,
-0.1351291984,
0.2153975368,
-0.6110807657,
-0.1126673147,
-0.0847978368,
0.8467428684,
0.0210817363,
0.3853639066,
0.0852969438,
-0.5023354888,
0.1021980867,
0.0759554058,
-0.4056852758,
0.9097027779,
-0.0640384108,
-0.9556292892,
0.663749814,
-0.1651643366,
-0.8396931291,
-0.0463645197,
-0.3913299441,
-0.6313992143,
0.2426406294,
0.0632275715,
0.5913805962,
-0.0031781988,
0.5674542189,
-0.0203378107,
-0.3481345475,
-0.2626227736,
-0.1665674448,
0.2043502778,
0.0884694234,
-0.3538015783,
0.2975306511,
-0.8111128807,
0.2816384137,
0.0483091846,
-0.014443459,
-0.2656219602,
0.0215263925,
0.2072677314,
0.2211617976,
0.2201271802,
-0.2923578918,
0.2396484166,
-0.1883058995,
0.2494909018,
0.3637954593,
0.3872808218,
0.4585373402,
-0.5601939559,
0.4334982336,
-0.2331651896,
-0.4671187699,
-0.6267504096,
-0.1414677203,
-0.9116379023,
-0.1353356838,
-0.0003448912,
0.6530625224,
-0.6259166002,
0.6216098666,
0.0357347131,
-0.3439412415,
-0.1515500993,
-0.0224874597,
0.6463146806,
0.6292490363,
0.3285795748,
-0.0921815857,
-0.5111482739,
-1.0789442062,
-0.2408714294,
0.162584573,
-0.1398870051,
0.1259304285,
0.2544579804,
0.2634417415,
0.7554631829,
-0.842944026,
-0.2640978098,
-0.6387304068,
0.5459780693,
-0.0341032557,
0.5404620171,
0.4929796457,
-0.8137350082,
-0.6254038215,
-0.3318556547,
-0.5555719137,
-0.4028480947,
-0.6261897683,
-0.2711134851,
0.1643417031,
0.5244478583,
-0.5274822116,
0.4458084106,
0.3318645656,
-0.7282646298,
0.6982569098,
-0.4880040288,
0.0756176114,
-1.0459519625,
0.3154979646,
0.0496925004,
-0.2232500911,
-0.8086186051,
-0.0444528051,
0.1757052541,
-0.048942063,
0.1826812923,
0.492549777,
-0.5513265729,
0.5102748871,
-0.4859331548,
-0.0745292976,
0.3917767107,
0.8325138092,
0.2395229936,
0.4576971829,
0.2460560054,
-0.5161913633,
-0.2945221364,
0.1930283159,
0.0077200872,
0.5271466374,
-0.8372421265,
-0.0681934804,
-0.2737395763,
0.2367603332,
-0.9540746212,
-0.4276633263,
0.0317545608,
-0.1841746122,
0.6231030226,
0.1826149821,
-0.4977481365,
-0.0214718673,
-0.3411925733,
-0.0183792897,
0.6018828154,
0.108577624,
0.2220921963,
0.0815890431,
-0.3572785854,
-0.4613823891,
-0.4879017472,
0.0943834186,
-0.1740709245,
-0.6070955396,
0.5773089528,
0.0329828113,
-0.2025966644,
-0.1796969622,
-0.427548945,
-0.0983868837,
-0.0815885663,
0.308454901,
0.0096934214,
-0.0929062963,
-0.0473707914,
0.713401258,
0.0415994711,
-0.2728078067,
-0.3485706747,
0.2826088071,
0.5467789769,
0.0578931347,
-0.39845258,
0.6013743877,
0.3408372104,
-0.1847581565,
0.5392192006,
0.5003198981,
-0.2211004496,
-0.5057846308,
-0.345056802,
-0.2894325852,
-0.3680330813,
0.2572826147,
-0.4066163599,
-0.5833668709,
0.4270250201,
0.1896143705,
0.5922458172,
0.580626905,
0.4737353325,
-0.0979755074,
0.7962130308,
0.8919750452,
0.5784059763,
0.4393770993,
-0.2246661633,
-0.1281288117,
-0.5574987531,
-0.0799205527,
-0.3586957753,
-0.3606918454,
-0.1808216274,
-0.0926514342,
0.1594550163,
0.4776565433,
-0.2008079588,
0.2266161293,
-0.4782988429,
0.3923802972,
0.5242684484,
0.1836795062,
0.4753117263,
-0.1462491304,
-0.3575793803,
-0.0564582199,
-0.6149210334,
-0.7243790627,
1.1614807844,
-0.0481022485,
0.2687155008,
-0.2674747109,
0.7145834565,
0.3332464099,
-0.0932541713,
-0.4563290477,
0.3350758553,
-0.3762217164,
-0.4267407656,
-0.2220153511,
-0.2642160058,
-0.6746988297,
0.3966460228,
-0.4706876576,
-0.5464810133,
-0.15177463,
0.4780685008,
-0.3853642046,
0.2055264413,
-0.8118322492,
0.7444584966,
-0.0921250209,
-0.6048086882,
0.0136027914,
-0.669917047,
0.5704627037,
-0.0608979091,
-0.2289965004,
-0.3394063115,
-0.145102039,
0.4832842052,
-0.4622918367,
0.7688646913,
-0.0921978354,
-0.2706864774,
0.4482005835,
-0.1256144643,
0.5771413445,
0.1068689674,
-0.0386549458,
-0.1971920133,
-0.3630131781,
-0.6471490264,
-0.4129067063,
0.3336746693,
-0.5072451234,
-0.3307379186,
-0.2659238279,
-0.6705616713,
-0.2998668849,
0.6007636189,
0.9298637509,
0.6836709976,
-0.4372175336,
-0.2470947504,
0.5742422938,
-0.0132045206,
0.3734501302,
0.443910718,
0.2616254389,
-0.378412962,
0.5137522221,
0.0415300578,
0.6279816031,
0.5897061825,
-0.1584725976,
-0.0860837698,
-1.0246474743,
-0.7603431344,
-0.0739816651,
-0.1409201175,
-0.2855004966,
-0.8587744832,
-0.3113911748,
-0.2398351431,
-0.433193624,
-0.0969091654,
-0.7786839008,
-0.2442263514,
-0.1783829331,
-0.0206123274,
0.5874571204,
0.0904778764,
0.4269281328,
-0.3257835507,
0.8482832909,
-0.0629874468,
0.1430976093,
-0.3271578252,
-0.4119796753,
-0.263933748,
0.1881760061,
-0.6158560514,
-0.6126420498,
0.2037511617,
0.3702293336,
0.2279078513,
0.4615429044,
0.3772119284,
0.5021345019,
-0.6247230768,
0.4915899634,
0.310274452,
-0.6328197718,
0.5028774142,
-0.7656715512,
0.5158615112,
0.7461158633,
0.0117376214,
-0.3984326422,
-1.064365983,
-0.7070672512,
-1.052806139,
0.8386906385,
0.9246047139,
0.1148000732,
0.4223494828,
0.536770165,
0.369143635,
0.4015488327,
-0.3704276383,
-0.1654264927,
-0.404638201,
-0.2470822185,
-0.186266005,
-0.422085762,
-0.1245194301,
0.181568563,
0.4875240922,
-0.0651206598,
-0.0796282738,
0.2323293388,
-0.0160295069,
-0.0840445384,
0.2727384865,
0.8004590869,
0.5779159665,
-0.3649734557,
0.1144398004,
-0.1805467606,
-0.6319258809,
0.1159588918,
0.2965785265,
-0.7244849801,
0.1425257474,
0.5986650586,
1.0427480936,
0.0630737618,
-0.656516552,
0.3315421641,
-0.0147850001,
-0.4716716111,
-0.1748204678,
0.4171893001,
-0.2240492702,
-0.3165485859,
0.3894496262,
0.2358009815,
0.1241701394,
-0.1886873245,
0.1649368256,
0.4641540051,
-0.3043921888,
-0.2319866717,
0.7563429475,
0.4463253617,
0.2537299693,
0.4822054207,
-0.4806590974,
-0.0424959213,
0.8745396137,
0.6304129958,
0.9885238409,
0.2823908627,
0.2015466839,
0.5706852674,
0.3353466094,
0.0052990117,
0.221437782,
-0.3322319388,
-0.7737361193,
-0.3522183597,
-0.501707375,
-0.3782001734,
0.2066872716,
-0.7006044388,
0.5779561996,
-0.3739943802,
0.0833853707,
0.1896339208,
0.1462840289,
-0.2498188019,
0.1738888621,
0.1330522597,
0.7426313162,
-0.8784737587,
0.5674678087,
0.6750676036,
-0.3548177779,
-0.6160710454,
0.2578617334,
-0.110602662,
-0.5075483918,
-0.107730113,
0.3855788708,
-0.0945357531,
-0.0069288271,
-0.3104789257,
-0.3395399451,
1.1820669174,
0.342231214,
-0.444275707,
-0.3141563237,
-0.1192644387,
0.5427300334,
-0.1789720058,
0.1094892025,
0.3660316169,
0.4195131958,
0.3531849086,
-0.8313122392,
0.0743037313,
-0.3584789336,
-0.1623900831,
0.4692969322,
-0.7145524025,
0.518692255,
-0.5413323641,
-0.5422990918,
0.3762942851,
0.7053393722,
0.3422102928,
0.4816695154,
0.0617628098,
0.5992934108,
0.5872074962,
0.0406102352,
0.8531528711,
-0.2958740294,
-0.0175474957,
1.3340982199,
-0.3423793912,
0.3173439503,
0.1234450191,
0.3517140448,
0.3114232123,
0.3510123789,
-0.0042222748,
0.511495173,
0.1518039107,
-0.2925419807,
-0.2033820599,
-0.1046839505,
-0.1799525172,
0.370303452,
0.2865869105,
-0.3484384716,
-0.3683893979,
-0.105313018,
0.4430430233,
0.4624104202,
-0.302613169,
0.8544707894,
-0.1482721269,
-0.9240355492,
0.4923398793,
0.3345623016,
0.726267159,
-0.8982118964,
0.0090747578,
-0.3791971505,
0.0418516695,
-0.2358774692,
-0.7454940677,
0.3848035634,
0.1673933268,
-0.4867355824,
-0.6972564459,
0.7306667566,
-0.8218691945,
-0.5317431688,
-0.3421035111,
0.2691916227,
-0.1800522357,
-0.2508255541,
-0.232388854,
-0.3119015396,
0.1419988871,
-0.122157,
0.0700281709,
0.7706155777,
-0.1706519127,
0.1324780285,
0.3190227151,
0.1812240481,
-0.1603777707,
-0.072768487,
0.4942210615,
-0.5691667795,
-0.6842578053,
-0.7165479064,
0.5805032849,
-0.2774342,
-0.6587406993,
0.6270653605,
0.8915920854,
0.2742961347,
-0.0030865152,
0.9992577434,
-0.2057532966,
0.2716988623,
-0.7679287195,
0.8166360259,
-0.3864475787,
-0.2145417631,
-0.3272611797,
-0.6295893192,
-0.343426466,
0.0353970043,
0.1004027352,
-0.1856804937,
0.7337383032,
0.3249236643,
-0.212460354,
-0.2980236709,
0.1087618545,
-0.1140628755,
0.272359699,
0.743914783,
0.5569230914,
-0.3194645941,
0.5682223439,
-0.3186021745,
-0.2456068248,
-0.0617301539,
-0.9136413932,
-1.0334935188,
-0.7810474038,
-0.4519377649,
-0.1848170459,
-0.008067539,
0.3408202231,
0.6707284451,
-0.5997810364,
-0.1777136773,
-0.5555328131,
-0.0086160861,
-0.1775505543,
-0.2018196136,
0.4366365671,
-0.5598977804,
-0.758841157,
-0.008669178,
0.3503913879,
0.4014604688,
0.0398742184,
0.0470532067,
0.1599297374,
0.2795472145,
0.4568716288,
0.3184116781,
-0.2684043646,
0.2721257508,
-0.13321805,
-0.4340977073,
-0.0273603983,
1.2480899096,
-0.4706926644,
0.3165716529,
0.3555520475,
0.0843129903,
0.5217987299,
0.3544765711,
0.9517431855,
-1.1110363007,
0.4482659996,
0.3664436936,
0.1376668662,
0.1636763811,
-0.4845660627,
0.3207057416,
-0.0349000208,
-0.2420342565,
-0.5682560802,
0.3685695231,
-1.0826121569,
-0.285625577,
1.1502690315,
0.1238938347,
0.475687474,
-0.0449050181,
-0.5243074894,
0.3665656745,
-0.4793952405,
0.6823292375,
0.5721788406,
-0.4286544621,
0.0320252366,
-0.4622977674,
0.7942855358,
0.3928955495,
-0.8131028414,
0.1620931923,
0.8542852402,
-0.0597671643,
-0.0623827949,
0.7933802009,
0.1922366321,
0.1434669197,
0.1460801512,
0.1699267775,
-0.4252853096,
-0.2645874023,
0.0235852618,
0.2974643707,
-0.2007041723,
-0.198516801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14458v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14458v2 | Dancing Between Success and Failure: Edit-level Simplification Evaluation using SALSA | 2023-05-23T18:30:49 | 2023-10-22T18:25:46 | David Heineman, Yao Dou, Mounica Maddela, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (e.g., GPT-4) are uniquely capable of producing highly
rated text simplification, yet current human evaluation methods fail to provide
a clear understanding of systems' specific strengths and weaknesses. To address
this limitation, we introduce SALSA, an edit-based human annotation framework
that enables holistic and fine-grained text simplification evaluation. We
develop twenty one linguistically grounded edit types, covering the full
spectrum of success and failure across dimensions of conceptual, syntactic and
lexical simplicity. Using SALSA, we collect 19K edit annotations on 840
simplifications, revealing discrepancies in the distribution of simplification
strategies performed by fine-tuned models, prompted LLMs and humans, and find
GPT-3.5 performs more quality edits than humans, but still exhibits frequent
errors. Using our fine-grained annotations, we develop LENS-SALSA, a
reference-free automatic simplification metric, trained to predict sentence-
and word-level quality simultaneously. Additionally, we introduce word-level
quality estimation for simplification and report promising baseline results.
Our data, new metric, and annotation toolkit are available at
https://salsa-eval.com. | [
-0.1438074559,
-0.734197557,
0.5587370396,
0.6133593321,
-0.1913791299,
0.3957627416,
-0.2037795186,
-0.2942566276,
0.4152678549,
-0.028565295,
-0.515337646,
-0.5407541394,
-0.7398687005,
0.3168314993,
-0.4272274971,
1.1751914024,
-0.1974211037,
0.1022923812,
-0.2332770824,
0.1538372338,
-0.6734235883,
0.0254099574,
-0.385871917,
-0.4736998081,
0.4931692183,
0.7194319963,
1.1244258881,
0.717136085,
0.6740865111,
0.3221494555,
-0.3163787127,
0.106117703,
-0.4379703999,
0.0645028576,
-0.1407838166,
-0.3576989174,
-0.6821071506,
0.1646555364,
0.3819963932,
0.9516665936,
-0.0562381893,
0.1238198653,
0.0810510516,
0.8255224824,
-0.751660347,
0.3129640222,
-0.4927271307,
0.2021583617,
-0.2258506417,
0.0506120808,
-0.1715307683,
-0.8128805757,
-0.3967826962,
-0.7451381683,
-0.1083960757,
-0.1241622716,
0.7355217338,
0.4918977916,
-0.2478162795,
-0.5358546972,
-0.8436157107,
0.52711761,
-0.1879100204,
0.22401236,
0.3196709156,
0.3009034395,
-0.3601121306,
-0.7491344213,
-0.6961702704,
-0.118771486,
0.1954239607,
0.2618945539,
-0.0547582433,
0.1981379688,
0.2838472128,
0.5812003016,
-0.3076574802,
-0.3270703852,
-0.5342809558,
-0.2063407898,
0.6253480911,
0.0297576543,
0.4715026617,
-0.2946174443,
-0.2299781591,
-0.1465087831,
-0.4447414577,
0.0362664945,
0.4025455415,
0.0571341626,
0.2240649015,
0.750218749,
-0.3465960324,
0.4805889428,
-0.1478480995,
-0.3649075329,
0.3700732887,
-0.4286729991,
-0.4736789763,
-0.2586312294,
0.8150898814,
0.4538931549,
0.2896925807,
-0.1628933847,
-0.361681819,
0.3454574347,
0.3059676886,
-0.2585400045,
-0.157052815,
0.2234191597,
-0.227285251,
-0.3959192336,
0.2592850924,
-0.5215465426,
-0.5406104922,
-0.1545661092,
0.7161189914,
-0.616314292,
0.3001740575,
0.3298291266,
-0.4236221313,
0.0561018623,
0.6967641711,
-0.4537698627,
0.3306670785,
0.8905886412,
0.8170922399,
-0.0043844571,
-0.6027132273,
-0.5392720103,
-0.099726215,
-0.5308052301,
0.5776921511,
-0.3970607221,
-0.2937912047,
-0.1666786969,
-0.444688201,
-0.016711941,
-0.5041489601,
1.2836990356,
-0.1602901071,
-0.0607215576,
-0.2750216424,
-0.6834896207,
-0.0166560505,
0.127365306,
-0.57276088,
1.0834724903,
0.141310066,
-0.8003658652,
0.4491348565,
-0.7168004513,
-0.7077890038,
0.0824954882,
0.1911425591,
-0.3570524454,
0.3262391984,
-0.0236609522,
0.2901610732,
-0.4693223238,
0.1591466814,
-0.1506166905,
-0.6479572058,
0.071089536,
-0.1255646348,
0.5978447795,
0.2464907616,
-0.2780776024,
0.0971806869,
-0.9287045002,
0.019406464,
-0.0717736706,
-0.6678110957,
-0.2181700021,
-0.1387924254,
0.0258860998,
0.4326224625,
0.268746078,
-0.4746320844,
0.4316268563,
0.0771209821,
0.3493495584,
0.3805248439,
0.0749726519,
0.2752461731,
-0.2235595137,
0.9035799503,
-0.0650470853,
0.4398341477,
-0.3642999828,
-0.6107248068,
-0.994038105,
-0.1309576035,
0.6215843558,
0.7596126795,
-0.8074297309,
0.4499647915,
-0.4020375907,
-0.7519087791,
-0.9352226853,
0.410327673,
0.5279530287,
0.4146532118,
0.5473282337,
-0.5592240095,
-0.3169820905,
-0.9643151164,
-0.7801221609,
-0.1581290215,
0.0035358355,
-0.2200267613,
0.5454707742,
-0.3856384158,
1.0003278255,
-0.3962997198,
-0.6014432907,
-0.4014595151,
0.3639971912,
-0.0463900156,
0.4337204397,
0.2344761193,
-0.6876482964,
-0.4091922939,
-0.0322605073,
-0.6560637951,
-0.2670767307,
-0.1955687702,
0.1001596302,
-0.2642680705,
0.4047516286,
-0.4999143183,
0.5007559657,
0.4075992107,
-0.3453250229,
0.5279943943,
-0.2589446008,
0.3940323591,
-0.7709766626,
-0.2271018028,
0.0794466883,
-0.2546330392,
-0.5304139853,
-0.0089875404,
0.2458230406,
-0.0388921015,
-0.3334662914,
0.1478633583,
-0.3565540314,
-0.1420289129,
0.1693073809,
0.1608933359,
-0.0180022437,
0.2370058149,
-0.4896264076,
0.5741553307,
0.3051174581,
-0.0399904959,
0.3686429262,
0.0790039003,
-0.3513535261,
0.5471783876,
-0.7186613083,
0.0877508,
-0.2077857852,
0.2907653749,
-1.1270188093,
-0.6782812476,
0.1209026575,
-0.4051668048,
-0.1009585857,
-0.2653172314,
-0.4583861232,
-0.2944347262,
-0.7312192917,
0.1699982285,
0.4377335012,
-0.2040109485,
0.4627408683,
0.221317932,
-0.3109945655,
-0.538893342,
-0.9046517611,
0.3231604695,
-0.0528363287,
-0.781560719,
0.1590421796,
-0.212797001,
-0.3531839252,
-0.2805436254,
-0.0199894961,
-0.1408336759,
0.350872159,
0.4437546432,
-0.031479869,
0.2422101051,
-0.0939827934,
0.4662100673,
-0.1969967932,
-0.2474181205,
0.0345334113,
0.321533531,
-0.2507858276,
-0.3596071303,
-0.6584048271,
0.1378031522,
0.6916771531,
-0.1622817218,
0.5347678661,
0.4476956427,
-0.3494993448,
-0.0530866049,
-0.4810789824,
0.3141976297,
-0.3912005723,
0.0514819436,
-0.4422536194,
-0.5652397871,
0.4938470721,
-0.1647402197,
-0.197943747,
0.5749611259,
0.1368749589,
-0.2358747274,
0.3835682571,
0.401892662,
0.2574305832,
0.4173229933,
-0.1712648422,
-0.0541052595,
-0.567327261,
-0.292512238,
-0.4769254029,
-0.4465012252,
-0.4644932449,
-0.7670006156,
0.4499741197,
0.5724045038,
0.0410987735,
0.3447436392,
0.0135883745,
0.7926795483,
0.4944786429,
-0.1361671388,
0.581744194,
-0.2340016067,
-0.1914483011,
-0.3201204538,
-0.4582674205,
-0.5990236998,
0.9627589583,
0.5640712976,
0.7222633362,
0.0109389471,
1.0844677687,
0.5542541742,
0.4780726731,
-0.6666709781,
0.5294114351,
-0.0893914625,
-0.1202064753,
-0.3098151684,
-0.4517877996,
-0.4227212965,
0.1783360541,
-0.3666818142,
-0.322830081,
0.0859640613,
0.3643458188,
-0.1316377372,
-0.0912928358,
-0.9506006837,
1.1274098158,
0.013710171,
-0.2755960226,
0.0067318282,
-0.6487220526,
0.338249892,
-0.241719678,
0.6613084674,
0.1032955498,
-0.1985057592,
0.4311319292,
-0.6284748316,
0.5665968657,
-0.0669068843,
0.0978063792,
0.1670323759,
0.4560998976,
0.6051800251,
-0.1508031487,
-0.2332208902,
0.0589589663,
-0.5452292562,
-0.3278599679,
-0.6300267577,
0.5618810058,
-0.5379154086,
-0.2193926871,
-0.2256529629,
-0.2821055353,
-0.0801873878,
0.2271369696,
0.2684729397,
-0.0171349496,
-0.2504062951,
0.1920526773,
0.0751165748,
-0.095560506,
0.4712663293,
-0.1666972339,
-0.2077654004,
-0.7729569674,
0.8961849213,
0.2798954844,
0.2979484797,
0.0656089559,
0.2043176889,
-0.0274028294,
-0.7113714814,
-0.3572911322,
0.0401089638,
-0.8606886864,
-0.2046776712,
-0.5769811869,
0.1620421708,
-0.2160920203,
-0.3252511621,
-0.5680370927,
-0.8319908381,
0.0992860943,
-0.1068277657,
-0.0913256928,
1.0893844366,
-0.1229996309,
0.27602005,
-0.4498715997,
0.3931728303,
0.2402935326,
0.3501665592,
-0.2611732483,
-0.4056159556,
-0.1069133282,
-0.0721262544,
-0.5805811882,
-1.1053060293,
0.2524164319,
0.3736200035,
0.0445717648,
0.0348551311,
-0.1113770083,
0.9372760653,
-0.3123506606,
0.8022894263,
0.2438666075,
-1.6103739738,
0.9062330723,
-0.4349251986,
0.1357079297,
0.8910932541,
0.3065553606,
-0.7728331685,
-0.6745369434,
-0.606662035,
-1.0721203089,
0.5772786736,
0.446048975,
-0.1881508082,
-0.1492695659,
0.6879373193,
0.0339572579,
0.3174393177,
-1.0229170322,
-0.3270840943,
-0.1811970472,
-0.1213263348,
-0.0564370789,
-0.2761100829,
0.153385058,
-0.273596555,
0.755391717,
-0.0662346706,
-0.3053148687,
0.2689822018,
-0.3394688964,
-0.1233342662,
0.5830318332,
0.667737186,
0.7029551864,
0.0328805819,
-0.0751670524,
0.1710990965,
-0.4122709334,
0.1623702645,
-0.1609343588,
-0.4187538028,
0.0426350757,
0.7995971441,
0.6428762674,
0.2656565607,
-0.4192476273,
0.6573018432,
-0.1205881536,
-0.0400472023,
-0.1186918765,
0.3208789527,
0.1079007909,
-0.0184554588,
0.3559743762,
0.2955548465,
0.3858659267,
-0.6931077242,
0.057613574,
0.0316062868,
-0.499825865,
-0.2104320973,
0.6339633465,
0.2766952217,
-0.6422950625,
0.2849148214,
-0.5403897762,
-0.4912376404,
0.4438175261,
0.1148271039,
0.8641240001,
-0.2500270605,
0.3776258826,
0.2004298121,
0.5229413509,
-0.4261000454,
0.3797872066,
0.0657022297,
-0.4257145524,
-0.4426953793,
-0.7813510895,
-0.5089888573,
-0.2196962386,
-0.6741829515,
0.5118340254,
-0.4975728095,
-0.0059172562,
0.1818957478,
-0.0462613292,
-0.6242095232,
0.4470352829,
-0.2291620821,
0.9961448312,
-1.3477882147,
0.7195186615,
0.8799304962,
-0.7220333219,
-0.7959421873,
0.2937120795,
0.1220434681,
-0.2587035298,
0.7509105802,
0.0392523259,
-0.2576926351,
-0.3028514087,
-0.1049990878,
-0.411321342,
1.1912902594,
0.7219341993,
-0.5531696081,
0.109794952,
0.3119959235,
0.8846834302,
-0.3823361993,
0.3927147985,
0.7834166288,
0.6547641158,
0.2021144629,
-1.2458803654,
-0.2846827209,
-0.107572116,
0.2156945169,
0.0659472272,
-0.5659426451,
0.9287536144,
-0.3843995631,
-0.0560112633,
-0.0763127878,
0.5908303857,
-0.2140562534,
0.3624557555,
0.4637019634,
0.6873100996,
0.7850279212,
-0.462177068,
1.2794286013,
-0.1007751673,
0.6452545524,
1.1222609282,
0.1091210842,
0.923717916,
0.5174319744,
-0.1745297611,
0.4962383807,
0.5119264126,
0.4106526077,
0.1455815136,
0.3461313546,
-0.110920921,
-0.3103604019,
0.1120472923,
-0.0808963627,
0.5944218636,
0.134149164,
-0.3925190866,
-0.1252182126,
-0.0371758342,
0.1871791035,
0.301015377,
-0.2718226016,
0.7049567699,
-0.1768511385,
-0.7579993606,
0.2804986537,
0.2427492887,
0.5695725083,
-0.2310618758,
-0.07728865,
-0.5630999804,
0.0907937512,
-0.4799367785,
-0.9630134702,
0.4151722193,
0.0805134401,
-0.164670527,
-0.1898621023,
0.521586895,
-0.5711271763,
-0.5769805312,
0.4222210348,
0.3754997253,
0.1474101394,
-0.0824868977,
-0.7045379281,
0.633703649,
0.0162859019,
-0.2078537345,
-0.0287878793,
0.5176784396,
-0.03476559,
0.8247217536,
0.4297685325,
0.2131246328,
-0.0365928523,
0.0569452681,
0.7461983562,
-0.81594944,
-0.5942280889,
-0.8491606116,
0.608692348,
-0.0831269398,
-0.4460193813,
0.5289408565,
0.6597189307,
0.7972092628,
-0.2006736696,
0.7920889258,
-0.0462875701,
0.3746263981,
-0.3657290041,
0.5336024165,
-0.6562674642,
0.5158259273,
-0.8915139437,
-1.0971164703,
-0.5950601101,
0.6687119603,
-0.2892895341,
0.0797445849,
0.6716846824,
0.4285413921,
-0.0559651926,
-0.1379535496,
0.366268605,
0.3900283277,
0.2595396042,
0.4791407883,
0.6753973365,
-0.7461282611,
0.5597097278,
-0.3046915829,
-0.393422395,
-0.2514677048,
-1.1373690367,
-0.4328709543,
-0.5311469436,
-0.5659720302,
-0.2867357135,
0.2092043608,
1.0566000938,
0.207649976,
-0.3981873095,
-0.0782409757,
-0.0815562531,
0.4024534523,
-0.1594285667,
-0.1920632869,
-0.0137911811,
-0.4598807991,
-0.6651331782,
0.4206360579,
0.5910819173,
-0.1002692431,
-0.0859441161,
-0.1704052389,
0.090284884,
0.1669300497,
0.5485705733,
0.1993812919,
-0.7278930545,
-0.3285711408,
-0.5921762586,
-0.1573402584,
0.0814018101,
0.6992946267,
-0.4919599593,
0.5906108618,
0.3247534633,
0.5014341474,
0.0875148252,
0.1333768219,
0.4378698468,
-0.8385018706,
-0.0235482026,
0.0550431572,
0.4448714256,
0.6121055484,
0.0146828117,
0.7130061984,
0.3549665511,
-0.4224828184,
-0.6822093129,
0.0479247682,
-1.024813652,
0.1004146785,
1.1249730587,
-0.5053405166,
-0.1686063111,
-0.1587349027,
-0.3319097757,
0.0733711571,
-0.2214997262,
0.8931514621,
0.9728048444,
-0.2088889033,
0.1248662621,
-0.3855136335,
0.8569985032,
0.4111729264,
-1.104190588,
0.0835372657,
0.6941189766,
0.4292001128,
0.4438465834,
0.5451937318,
-0.070951812,
0.635381341,
-0.0510194562,
0.2812527716,
-0.159129411,
-0.5699231625,
-0.6123287082,
0.4511326849,
0.3661661148,
0.1287043989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16337v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16337v2 | Handling Realistic Label Noise in BERT Text Classification | 2023-05-23T18:30:31 | 2023-10-20T11:26:43 | Maha Tufail Agro, Hanan Aldarmaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Labels noise refers to errors in training labels caused by cheap data
annotation methods, such as web scraping or crowd-sourcing, which can be
detrimental to the performance of supervised classifiers. Several methods have
been proposed to counteract the effect of random label noise in supervised
classification, and some studies have shown that BERT is already robust against
high rates of randomly injected label noise. However, real label noise is not
random; rather, it is often correlated with input features or other
annotator-specific factors. In this paper, we evaluate BERT in the presence of
two types of realistic label noise: feature-dependent label noise, and
synthetic label noise from annotator disagreements. We show that the presence
of these types of noise significantly degrades BERT classification performance.
To improve robustness, we evaluate different types of ensembles and
noise-cleaning methods and compare their effectiveness against label noise
across different datasets. | [
-0.5997411609,
-1.0335835218,
0.2072087675,
0.1501030922,
-0.3345973194,
0.1675143689,
-0.282512188,
-1.0900440216,
-0.0322026163,
0.3927811086,
-0.5189810991,
-0.2889021933,
-0.3450650275,
0.0431321748,
-0.3476611078,
1.3108808994,
0.0699535757,
0.1071888134,
-0.4539625049,
-0.0283223838,
-0.2346821725,
-0.8302910924,
-0.8549832106,
-0.1026785597,
0.8838500977,
0.0118432362,
0.7576265931,
0.3272594213,
0.5233536363,
0.3016669154,
-0.3035033643,
0.2419706285,
-0.4135037661,
0.5000542402,
0.1891124696,
-0.2910828888,
-0.25514099,
0.1316829324,
0.5989698172,
0.2620085478,
0.1617330462,
0.0590632036,
0.1971780658,
0.2678973675,
-0.615411818,
0.2663670778,
-0.4418751895,
-0.0293556526,
-0.2776848376,
0.1112585589,
-0.4995768964,
-0.5772807598,
0.2623060644,
-0.6447452307,
0.5257372856,
-0.0492512025,
1.2770411968,
0.4269565046,
0.1695364863,
-0.4533976912,
-0.940238297,
0.7242103219,
-0.4455610216,
0.3510006964,
0.7312484384,
0.267051965,
0.008282722,
-0.7021958828,
-0.4300236702,
-0.1805633754,
-0.1264758259,
0.1950481534,
-0.0957914665,
0.1222477555,
0.3724050224,
0.1237083599,
-0.2109817713,
0.3968751431,
-0.4707219303,
-0.469198972,
0.4668557644,
-0.4826160669,
0.2339686453,
0.2261725813,
-0.2960121632,
-0.4466268718,
-0.2135992944,
0.1226216555,
0.7273705006,
0.2577237189,
0.2864287794,
-0.0310397763,
0.1843746901,
0.9572396874,
-0.0263509154,
-0.457705766,
0.2268926352,
-0.0916105434,
0.1409001797,
0.343531251,
0.4015999138,
0.168358773,
0.4141780436,
-0.1730917096,
-0.5308160782,
0.0012122191,
0.4075072408,
-0.6128778458,
-0.6023540497,
0.2142016292,
-0.5939961076,
-0.7067010403,
-0.0878654271,
-0.6822841763,
-0.4285675883,
-0.1956355572,
0.6268376112,
-0.4769352973,
0.0655639842,
-0.5158028007,
-0.3377169073,
-0.1723414361,
0.4935102463,
-0.7339621782,
-0.0207608491,
0.4572842419,
0.6111545563,
0.0775879845,
-0.0800115541,
-0.4148024321,
-0.1230528578,
-0.0704983324,
1.2494312525,
-0.3885528147,
-0.338046968,
0.0394979902,
-0.4652671218,
-0.0129539333,
-0.6863628626,
0.7671068907,
-0.5443440676,
-0.0140638202,
-0.4424155354,
-0.5565547943,
-0.204125762,
0.2290328145,
-0.8523501754,
1.0180348158,
0.0618126951,
-0.7655683756,
0.9500615001,
-0.4830916226,
-0.6112786531,
0.0255275536,
0.2819922566,
-0.9063509703,
-0.1360329688,
0.1053929627,
0.3834020495,
0.4407027364,
0.2277913392,
-0.3441371918,
-0.5229839683,
0.6968318224,
-0.6283320785,
0.6192372441,
0.2935831249,
0.047198426,
-0.1568268836,
-1.2013806105,
-0.0242293756,
-0.3710750043,
-0.4309459925,
-0.6179666519,
0.3812915087,
0.3366586566,
0.0920921713,
0.0054235766,
-0.6718617678,
0.0966454893,
0.0090931961,
0.2013326138,
0.8139730692,
0.1053974256,
-0.1328225881,
-0.8471441865,
0.0808009282,
0.0228904374,
0.0798828602,
0.1492707282,
-0.7510275245,
-0.7058745623,
-0.8104097843,
0.7008624673,
0.3995420933,
-0.4606163502,
0.2834192514,
0.0424531884,
-0.5378418565,
-0.5615944862,
0.0416909233,
0.3239004314,
0.7202503681,
0.5279121399,
-0.2510145605,
-0.5494469404,
-0.8412250876,
-0.2725574672,
-0.4052768946,
-0.105056636,
0.0505135357,
0.3056856692,
-0.3889423013,
1.1320934296,
-0.0492961407,
-0.3850559294,
0.0718483627,
0.6912158132,
-0.3642668128,
0.5738642216,
0.5648995638,
-0.7134754658,
-0.0972124711,
-0.4960054755,
-0.1522370577,
-0.3763949573,
-0.4876961708,
0.1062985137,
0.5606013536,
0.292991221,
-0.1233062968,
0.5258226991,
0.3950418234,
0.1012105718,
0.6515613198,
-0.0852954388,
-0.1487053335,
-0.4884698391,
-0.1853501946,
0.3768021762,
-0.087249577,
-0.5018371344,
-0.3316472769,
-0.2107732743,
0.1285926849,
-0.1698066741,
0.0317496136,
0.0035555793,
0.0668406263,
-0.068585746,
-0.0584919564,
0.1002443433,
0.1211724281,
0.3096255958,
0.7646275163,
0.2046702802,
-0.751940608,
0.1249937192,
0.1561188102,
-0.4531848729,
0.5376162529,
-0.4198265672,
-0.130381301,
-0.2382074594,
0.6154010296,
-1.0906428099,
-0.3470163345,
0.2629887462,
-0.4477078915,
0.5120075941,
0.1417240351,
-0.9208270907,
-0.1816203594,
-0.3654082417,
0.0558730401,
0.4773671031,
-0.797286272,
-0.0236815866,
0.0895833299,
-0.0359578393,
-0.2878865898,
-0.8680474162,
-0.2166091204,
-0.0027254485,
-0.5412156582,
0.0668453202,
0.1034652144,
-0.3605685234,
0.0646234378,
-0.2448844463,
-0.632098496,
0.2264592648,
0.2802239358,
0.1833192855,
0.0299865622,
0.5143985748,
0.124653019,
0.0202076398,
0.1108112857,
0.0346622765,
0.1400984973,
0.0201176703,
-0.1260147244,
-0.5886395574,
-0.0916871876,
0.3643575907,
0.1057823151,
0.6865462065,
0.9844262004,
-0.3213656843,
-0.2516531646,
-0.7923138142,
-0.2252378613,
-0.4516323805,
0.4794747233,
-0.2134023756,
-0.3815941513,
0.5229571462,
-0.1589675099,
0.2373564839,
0.3431185186,
0.2246674001,
-0.9801785946,
0.6520683765,
0.2730012536,
0.0757402927,
0.5609261394,
0.0510082059,
0.0782360733,
-0.4013700485,
-0.3108048439,
-0.6912184358,
-0.6128953695,
-0.7228075862,
-0.1810723394,
-0.0019275103,
0.1125770435,
-0.2286079228,
0.199390471,
-0.7757491469,
0.2706878185,
1.1133664846,
0.2339571863,
0.167830795,
0.4639649093,
0.1600029618,
-0.3545177877,
-0.8625465631,
-0.5515604615,
0.7124896646,
0.4382081628,
0.6610244513,
-0.1348247379,
0.8172702789,
0.3680663705,
0.5208976865,
-0.584844768,
0.2073289156,
-0.1819583625,
-0.9144935012,
-0.3131675422,
-0.3694295883,
-0.8574688435,
0.1230576932,
-0.5342760682,
-0.9775320292,
0.5799070597,
0.4496791363,
-0.083296977,
0.5860888958,
-0.6443479657,
0.4492128789,
-0.2183288634,
-0.2060329169,
0.1558801085,
-0.6100476384,
0.2750833035,
-0.4084547758,
0.5361745358,
0.0740282163,
0.2153481543,
0.9604130387,
-0.3054258823,
1.1679260731,
-0.1433905959,
-0.2095296681,
0.6989716887,
0.052868478,
0.5347858071,
-0.2219514102,
0.0239672791,
0.3103933036,
0.0907053202,
-0.3573619723,
-0.2392194271,
0.3494091034,
-1.0795270205,
-0.033549618,
-0.5259332657,
-0.5809037685,
-0.3279381394,
-0.1920634955,
0.8243231177,
0.3399491608,
-0.0306534152,
0.2382854521,
0.8194407821,
-0.3111673295,
0.5654560328,
0.047962945,
0.1559173018,
-0.4557270408,
1.5101499557,
0.7796218991,
0.2952414155,
0.0514706783,
-0.0602096356,
-0.2288442403,
-0.3056901395,
-0.1202608719,
-0.1988064349,
-0.5990063548,
-0.2433182895,
-0.4470807314,
-0.2368506342,
-0.0609628744,
-0.3203492463,
-0.2060054243,
-0.6852014661,
-0.4700642824,
-0.1169768497,
0.5047963262,
0.5371512175,
-0.3369860947,
0.5287650824,
-0.8161643147,
0.2244170308,
0.3523545861,
0.5178955197,
-0.1258410364,
-0.3556064665,
-0.1260321736,
0.0496439114,
-0.3652139008,
-0.7054841518,
0.1523046494,
0.3013846278,
0.4347529113,
0.5147020221,
0.40940395,
0.5679984689,
0.0035682996,
0.730740428,
-0.0226625688,
-0.6947013736,
0.4616204202,
-0.3617916405,
-0.1146520153,
0.6837621331,
0.2728742659,
-0.0626580119,
-0.7443550825,
-0.8259605765,
-0.8674871325,
0.5906292796,
0.4993548989,
-0.2644081414,
0.1342231482,
0.2401524633,
0.2385775596,
0.1790721267,
-0.8564664125,
-0.1617608517,
-0.3905027807,
0.0481139794,
0.1315366328,
-0.5661475062,
-0.0750253946,
-0.2041459084,
0.7054657936,
0.3306507468,
0.2360957265,
0.3109984994,
-0.2277247906,
-0.0914752111,
0.1575309783,
0.6262993813,
0.392133981,
-0.5911242962,
-0.0891521722,
0.089483127,
-0.5127028227,
0.0721064731,
0.1367595196,
-0.6644287109,
0.44932428,
0.6151340008,
0.6341779828,
0.1899463981,
-0.5320452452,
0.0479453951,
0.139632836,
-0.4168330133,
-0.1671045572,
0.0985305607,
-0.2992469668,
-0.1569145769,
0.2052725703,
0.5310346484,
0.1812272221,
-0.4021107256,
0.2289952934,
0.0256475322,
-0.5912441611,
-0.0554239377,
0.5529490709,
0.3911896646,
-0.2431461066,
0.6808714271,
-0.0621204972,
-0.5054185987,
0.7661881447,
0.5278636217,
0.700551331,
0.1757055372,
0.2823126316,
0.2937932014,
0.434302181,
-0.0061266189,
-0.0664017498,
-0.218037203,
-0.7565175295,
-0.403007865,
-0.4994657934,
-0.861978054,
0.0648030415,
-0.9332275987,
-0.0093866419,
-0.4747572541,
-0.4375662804,
0.0331460908,
-0.1864502579,
-0.3510786891,
0.4241897166,
0.3330606222,
0.5780825615,
-0.740172267,
0.7453890443,
0.9510302544,
-0.2936887145,
-0.2430592924,
0.1854681969,
0.0213428251,
-0.397510469,
0.7588678002,
0.2985454202,
0.0077920114,
-0.3079213798,
-0.7556570172,
-0.5471246243,
0.5326603055,
-0.0666847453,
-0.6847506166,
0.4290028512,
0.0271807592,
0.696513474,
0.4374117255,
-0.0262482855,
0.3593416512,
0.7547522187,
-0.023884587,
-0.72665447,
-0.2511924207,
0.109112829,
-0.1588644385,
-0.0295831636,
-0.924843967,
0.6125710011,
0.048984617,
0.0280166008,
0.1650273651,
0.492606163,
0.4002910256,
0.5092984438,
0.6223947406,
0.5070828795,
1.1696503162,
-0.4801609814,
0.7069517374,
-0.221635282,
0.3502749205,
1.0201445818,
-0.1080105603,
0.7073232532,
0.2425945252,
-0.2616684437,
0.4534125328,
0.9807289839,
-0.4490607381,
0.4297905564,
0.6315082908,
-0.430747509,
-0.2875285447,
-0.0260661151,
-0.4547764063,
0.2395098507,
0.5349071026,
-0.1293585896,
-0.1844077259,
0.1643933207,
-0.1461631507,
-0.0514240749,
-0.1001825556,
0.838734448,
-0.2351108044,
-0.3189406097,
0.4729492962,
-0.2087611705,
0.9009610415,
-0.3448316157,
-0.0430735163,
0.0428996682,
0.2063492239,
-0.2411436886,
-0.5797183514,
0.4504249096,
-0.0348593295,
-0.2993473113,
-0.3261199296,
0.9137422442,
-0.2188020498,
-0.5760257244,
0.0897841528,
-0.0046770205,
0.2911181152,
0.0647217855,
-0.4808513522,
0.230951637,
-0.0471307226,
-0.2531186342,
0.5874401927,
0.4597338438,
0.1069670618,
0.7489490509,
0.7909417748,
-0.0606313422,
0.0652232543,
-0.172522977,
0.742425859,
-0.3580465317,
-0.2021832168,
-0.5717286468,
0.2286907881,
-0.1381389201,
-0.4122853279,
0.497456938,
0.3995851278,
0.8664348722,
-0.0555312485,
0.8542271256,
0.1533978581,
0.6071133614,
-0.2621740401,
1.0372854471,
-0.1822933257,
0.3523932099,
-0.4434331357,
-0.9470170736,
-0.5311414599,
0.9643602967,
-0.0535704084,
0.0019224549,
0.1882907152,
0.444074899,
0.1799714714,
0.2530879378,
0.3042553961,
0.2719841897,
0.1742211431,
-0.2248215526,
0.8316292763,
-0.2379171252,
0.9004123211,
-0.7253853083,
0.0685807243,
-0.250341922,
-0.6130641103,
-0.7482669353,
-0.2496296763,
-0.8402920961,
-0.653293252,
0.3806067109,
0.5897881389,
0.6431460381,
-1.0338548422,
0.2021868974,
-0.0006989504,
0.1633142531,
-0.3520788848,
-0.3046755493,
0.3748834133,
-0.8257368207,
-0.8279775977,
0.0239372794,
-0.2390948981,
0.3263948262,
0.2161467671,
0.3467422128,
-0.0063926741,
0.0294925869,
0.5522922277,
0.499465853,
-0.567468524,
-0.465641588,
-0.5960680842,
-0.1480671018,
-0.0145666981,
0.3220077455,
-0.9895006418,
0.6824691296,
0.3906370401,
0.4144381881,
0.3169493377,
0.2758498192,
0.2446680665,
-1.0815873146,
0.2786237001,
0.3227145672,
0.0878376961,
-0.0221181866,
-0.3815101087,
0.3450368643,
0.3337278664,
-0.6561846733,
-1.0396502018,
-0.3026306033,
-0.863086462,
-0.4957413077,
1.1026985645,
-0.2151921242,
0.1009561568,
-0.4453441501,
-0.3011491895,
0.1556696445,
-0.5406275988,
0.9291669726,
1.1349881887,
-0.2143173218,
0.0389192477,
-0.4756784439,
0.5267383456,
0.1606380045,
-0.2692840993,
-0.2534977198,
0.5643800497,
0.0505603291,
0.4796343744,
0.0219850093,
0.1944933832,
0.1437444836,
0.2527423501,
0.1679567844,
-0.048923552,
-0.1088553518,
-0.072682187,
0.1165212318,
0.0656640157,
-0.3882384598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14457v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14457v4 | Pre-training Language Models for Comparative Reasoning | 2023-05-23T18:28:42 | 2023-11-28T05:54:11 | Mengxia Yu, Zhihan Zhang, Wenhao Yu, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Comparative reasoning is a process of comparing objects, concepts, or
entities to draw conclusions, which constitutes a fundamental cognitive
ability. In this paper, we propose a novel framework to pre-train language
models for enhancing their abilities of comparative reasoning over texts. While
there have been approaches for NLP tasks that require comparative reasoning,
they suffer from costly manual data labeling and limited generalizability to
different tasks. Our approach introduces a novel method of collecting scalable
data for text-based entity comparison, which leverages both structured and
unstructured data. Moreover, we present a framework of pre-training language
models via three novel objectives on comparative reasoning. Evaluation on
downstream tasks including comparative question answering, question generation,
and summarization shows that our pre-training framework significantly improves
the comparative reasoning abilities of language models, especially under
low-resource conditions. This work also releases the first integrated benchmark
for comparative reasoning. | [
-0.4900721014,
-0.570106566,
0.5598902702,
-0.1447010636,
-0.2656004727,
0.0465560146,
-0.4216755927,
-0.406801939,
0.0543834418,
0.4144025743,
-0.4412355423,
-0.5557906628,
-0.539437294,
0.1895918399,
-0.4040573537,
0.8756025434,
0.0198287275,
0.1769760102,
-0.4457098544,
-0.2246420383,
-0.179543674,
-0.6156587601,
-0.56735605,
-0.5962646008,
0.1484297365,
0.2285934538,
0.6679668427,
0.1153228059,
0.7825465202,
0.5442807078,
0.0528595038,
0.1565312296,
-0.2446231246,
-0.05965437,
-0.5240724683,
-0.7973715663,
-0.4656418264,
-0.0578457974,
0.5343225598,
0.8699828982,
-0.0296211336,
0.0843176916,
0.0463383049,
0.6639898419,
-0.5434580445,
0.0392343402,
-0.8028056622,
0.0607395582,
-0.131886065,
-0.0627625287,
-0.1516177058,
-0.4589569569,
0.2567337751,
-0.6473906636,
0.2376334518,
-0.0611459427,
0.9461533427,
0.4590323865,
-0.2917888165,
-0.179970637,
-0.4954762459,
0.9047706723,
-0.9001008868,
0.5383841991,
0.3566355407,
0.1590077132,
0.2574504912,
-0.9837937355,
-0.6423814297,
-0.4081919193,
-0.3574866354,
-0.1433831304,
-0.1464202255,
-0.005445776,
0.2822799385,
0.5291694999,
-0.7744105458,
0.1082333103,
0.0626263842,
-0.0622922592,
0.4987762868,
0.0585208721,
0.2492478937,
0.0278648585,
-0.1769437045,
-0.115874432,
-0.5399007201,
-0.0181589238,
0.3056684732,
0.2429181784,
-0.0102753881,
0.3586494923,
-0.6082863212,
0.6745383739,
-0.0010597234,
-0.0918395519,
0.41763255,
-0.314994067,
-0.3449410498,
-0.2005964965,
0.6195327044,
0.34335199,
0.5335799456,
-0.2875683308,
-0.3532160521,
0.182751894,
0.2453999072,
-0.8606395721,
-0.3980778754,
0.0045497939,
-0.6853461862,
-0.3404347897,
-0.2956167758,
-0.3390700817,
0.1582626104,
-0.6314835548,
0.4401782751,
-0.1595920175,
-0.3267273903,
0.3173920214,
0.0892288089,
0.0074070077,
0.1052584052,
-0.9540888667,
0.3976899683,
0.6005137563,
0.564391315,
-0.259640336,
-0.4086565077,
-0.1124822497,
-0.1165215671,
-0.2180038542,
1.3107591867,
-0.6896057129,
-0.2327299565,
-0.1746592969,
-0.2685803175,
0.0650323406,
-0.7987520099,
0.6289186478,
-0.4736999571,
0.4380410016,
-0.2115491182,
-0.529251039,
-0.009866246,
0.58658427,
-0.6040301919,
1.184022069,
0.0692131817,
-1.0914497375,
0.6044415832,
-0.5243981481,
-0.5034763217,
0.1467618495,
-0.3662854135,
-0.3779462874,
-0.1235741749,
0.4234559238,
0.453543812,
-0.7243811488,
0.5105170608,
-0.4631638825,
-0.2919619977,
0.0519714206,
-0.1382411569,
0.7850311399,
0.2771043479,
-0.2449808717,
0.1902742386,
-0.7696731687,
0.4706954956,
0.1714318246,
-0.3996231556,
-0.4621877968,
-0.064822562,
-0.3583010137,
0.0538612194,
0.281212002,
-0.1569849849,
0.107703656,
-0.5017642975,
0.2951003313,
0.315898329,
-0.3253794611,
0.7188467383,
-0.2032053024,
0.3117678463,
-0.2050085515,
0.0414937586,
-0.0553877018,
-0.1553250998,
-0.7300439477,
0.0066260882,
0.5346801281,
0.7034450173,
-0.9374572635,
0.5684069991,
-0.506454289,
-0.4374566972,
-0.2926105261,
0.087874569,
0.6207139492,
0.6541472077,
0.6019805074,
-0.3038686216,
-0.6254859567,
-0.7898221016,
-0.4443639517,
-0.377281785,
-0.2380419821,
0.0550936349,
0.5347552299,
-0.1264735013,
0.7198637128,
-0.5660732388,
-0.1943236589,
-0.5723674297,
0.2316099852,
0.1645265967,
0.5706657767,
0.5373675227,
-0.8165727258,
-0.4029206932,
-0.0892208591,
-0.9055134654,
-0.2624212801,
-0.0987194553,
-0.3038699925,
-0.2366754264,
0.7888345718,
-0.5535196662,
0.1797645092,
0.2868901789,
-0.2051355988,
0.5769045949,
-0.1685013771,
0.330991298,
-0.939714849,
-0.0019596778,
-0.059264984,
-0.3065192699,
-0.5333653688,
0.093938984,
-0.1779312342,
-0.0121411728,
-0.307539016,
0.5273110271,
-0.2683128119,
-0.0946485773,
-0.3385451734,
0.1131801829,
0.0879102945,
0.3855594099,
0.6691305637,
0.6510075927,
0.4886748791,
-0.5356388688,
0.2849279344,
0.1981487721,
-0.6089884639,
0.6667773724,
-0.7121704221,
-0.0619107224,
0.146960631,
0.1725026816,
-0.3784930408,
0.3005187511,
-0.248486802,
-0.4801626205,
0.291865319,
0.0532609373,
-0.3269574344,
-0.3039785922,
-0.0923562422,
0.327363044,
0.315987587,
-0.4044902623,
0.5610902905,
0.2619179785,
-0.3674378395,
-0.7965772748,
-0.7374318242,
-0.0782394409,
-0.2856845856,
-0.3563601971,
0.4970823824,
-0.006650351,
-0.4347614348,
0.2130643278,
-0.1227385029,
-0.4379741848,
0.087092109,
-0.3274044991,
0.062800914,
-0.6290317178,
0.2923919857,
0.0413979106,
-0.3829522133,
0.1282636672,
-0.5126617551,
0.3042455614,
-0.3169082105,
-0.2149166614,
-0.2078955323,
0.353708744,
-0.1476611942,
-0.3558413982,
0.5866214633,
0.3197888434,
-0.3402073085,
-0.2271572351,
-0.6226860881,
-0.2518146932,
-0.4454135895,
0.4332444668,
-0.6751288772,
-0.7656360269,
0.0775695294,
-0.5336996913,
-0.0074539296,
0.3548700511,
0.6115413308,
-0.1815376282,
0.8952767253,
0.6654072404,
0.021575002,
0.3652371466,
-0.2866621912,
0.3156858981,
-0.3283261955,
-0.144201532,
-0.8655937314,
-0.0816610083,
-0.3367803097,
-0.4704648554,
-0.2588077486,
0.4567653835,
-0.5323264599,
0.3440439701,
-0.5122810006,
0.874759376,
0.4104450643,
-0.1359997988,
0.4369075298,
-0.188463822,
-0.3612946272,
-0.1085839495,
-0.4830233753,
-0.9226157069,
1.1385439634,
-0.0291173104,
0.4348346293,
-0.1573258787,
0.6480791569,
0.2461060733,
0.4508262873,
-0.3225735128,
0.6978232265,
-0.2710708678,
-0.5459392667,
-0.408973068,
-0.5547577739,
-0.6978209615,
0.4894125462,
-0.564796567,
-0.58983922,
-0.1241877899,
0.1852659583,
-0.1714083701,
0.4612103403,
-0.8225502372,
1.1125799417,
-0.3889145851,
-0.0390729867,
-0.1723787785,
-0.5752384067,
0.2197380066,
-0.0519402735,
0.030161215,
-0.0412269123,
0.0412172228,
0.5887361169,
-0.3540407121,
0.4489376545,
-0.0927624628,
0.1703110188,
0.2184242457,
-0.0080050817,
0.2578632534,
0.0257447455,
-0.1567541957,
0.1974887848,
0.0442661643,
-0.4601297379,
-0.8189250827,
0.5067818761,
-0.5694567561,
-0.50018996,
-0.1505507976,
-0.2639405727,
-0.4473057985,
0.330945164,
0.448143214,
0.2011210769,
-0.3944067657,
0.2973637879,
0.7236077189,
-0.1120604798,
0.1338321418,
0.5290164948,
-0.1847724319,
-0.1237196252,
0.7202174067,
-0.1900721341,
0.2134771794,
0.9762695432,
0.069011502,
-0.6280924082,
-0.8046824336,
-0.1874535084,
-0.0280654635,
-0.9592593312,
-0.1930642873,
-0.8746084571,
0.1102207601,
-0.2755460441,
-0.2777464092,
-0.4847210646,
-0.4883262813,
0.1749683172,
-0.2388874739,
-0.1996798068,
0.4891996384,
-0.0979011282,
0.2555937469,
-0.6252685189,
0.4413188994,
0.5245022774,
0.1898910999,
0.0163674392,
-0.3143345416,
-0.1567800492,
-0.2716363966,
-0.2032341212,
-0.5719380975,
0.1519069076,
0.0963418186,
0.7559258938,
0.3944604397,
-0.0076801903,
0.5115724206,
-0.5050788522,
0.5748470426,
0.2111930847,
-1.1669607162,
0.7011038661,
0.1108753085,
0.2680548429,
0.8076457381,
0.5448048711,
0.0134194018,
-0.237614885,
-0.6624249816,
-0.6254790425,
0.3936815262,
0.3827401102,
-0.0361408331,
0.0792801678,
0.2137273997,
0.148425445,
0.2215421796,
-0.9609751105,
-0.1550108194,
-0.2965341508,
-0.1058104411,
-0.3376626968,
0.0526378006,
0.1813773364,
-0.461940527,
0.6256885529,
-0.1967736483,
0.035217341,
-0.0515149683,
-0.4679732025,
0.5083363652,
0.3496074378,
0.1665749699,
0.4724607468,
0.033593189,
0.2287315875,
0.7910342216,
-0.2818434536,
0.1225228682,
0.1781324595,
-0.0133771272,
-0.0346823484,
0.7670587897,
0.6828491688,
0.3540762961,
-0.6922919154,
0.4826314449,
-0.3929498196,
-0.1957244426,
0.0385533907,
-0.0774214789,
0.371339947,
0.3732861578,
-0.0176909622,
-0.1005017534,
0.4364679754,
-0.4470829964,
0.2847855687,
0.2549515963,
-0.0071199345,
-0.1350461096,
0.6055628061,
0.3794430494,
-0.2277792245,
0.6125934124,
-0.3442921638,
-0.5149169564,
0.5410462022,
0.2800274193,
0.5407318473,
-0.215764001,
0.2469582707,
0.4913289547,
0.303252697,
-0.130190596,
0.3869864941,
-0.5537326336,
-0.971871078,
-0.5626457334,
-0.606336832,
-0.4199670255,
0.1171882749,
-0.6310729384,
0.2683214843,
-0.1382692456,
-0.231027171,
0.1155208275,
0.2482188791,
-0.8515588641,
0.831694603,
0.0594056435,
0.7006967068,
-0.8591064811,
1.0303986073,
0.7725761533,
-0.4042811394,
-0.6611685753,
0.0424773097,
-0.2799823284,
-0.4069654047,
0.7930470109,
0.267056793,
-0.2150896937,
-0.2162875384,
-0.355725646,
-0.6739513278,
0.5821662545,
0.6263492107,
-0.5780594945,
-0.3106066287,
0.2288144082,
0.7577316165,
-0.5626857281,
0.5517981648,
0.8321072459,
0.2988702655,
-0.1891536117,
-0.8699195981,
-0.1241370961,
-0.4618126452,
-0.0600659437,
0.1657394767,
-0.1063744202,
0.8838217258,
-0.3503927886,
-0.1293285489,
-0.1434733123,
0.7967073321,
0.1441397518,
0.2575134337,
0.6579841971,
0.8247656822,
0.7569124103,
-0.1818218976,
0.9697532654,
-0.1396764666,
0.2592895627,
1.5827535391,
-0.4867305756,
0.8665223718,
0.1161516681,
-0.3352876008,
0.7544727325,
0.5636529922,
0.2113655359,
0.559099257,
0.2626206279,
-0.1052604914,
-0.6144561172,
0.0278960913,
-0.5056327581,
0.4792797565,
0.0950635076,
-0.1978603452,
-0.3066211045,
-0.0932466388,
-0.216261223,
0.5530942082,
-0.2303240448,
0.9053298831,
0.1501367241,
-0.6528165936,
0.477506876,
-0.0761056468,
0.6717908978,
-0.5246950984,
0.034880694,
-0.1287184805,
0.2876256704,
-0.2370059639,
-0.7299444079,
0.5846970677,
0.159479335,
-0.2560272217,
-0.2231426984,
0.7971797585,
-0.2640704215,
-0.2158757448,
0.4940263331,
0.7047094703,
0.3389757872,
-0.2493338734,
-1.0979341269,
-0.1968737841,
-0.0183840226,
-0.3467257321,
0.2489954978,
0.561770916,
-0.2290716767,
0.7137814164,
0.5683097243,
0.2280427963,
-0.1723505706,
0.4967844784,
0.795027554,
-0.7383134961,
-0.6997771263,
-0.6664772034,
0.3602330685,
-0.4002946913,
-0.2729115188,
0.2579844892,
0.6448457241,
1.3921822309,
0.1114307866,
0.6876781583,
0.0938516483,
0.8225133419,
-0.6767579913,
0.474647671,
-0.4880144596,
0.2520971894,
-0.0845773593,
-1.1575758457,
-0.2543009222,
0.8868675232,
-0.5862866044,
0.2234740853,
1.0880323648,
0.6686822772,
-0.0850709751,
0.1420654207,
0.3514630795,
0.0035891209,
0.1221669093,
0.6138047576,
0.8928152919,
-0.0724343359,
0.5820388794,
-0.3965580463,
-0.0691811144,
0.3268514872,
-0.9452390075,
-1.2330254316,
-0.6426184177,
-0.3319573104,
0.1112568378,
-0.0280739143,
0.8470621705,
0.9361534119,
-0.8814685941,
-0.0633096769,
-0.1159876511,
0.1319951266,
-0.0452414937,
-0.142018497,
0.2817384899,
-0.4565275908,
-0.7434780002,
0.3198675513,
0.1989714354,
-0.0161580089,
-0.0573308878,
-0.0582610182,
-0.1132370606,
0.2497112751,
0.562230885,
0.1141469106,
-0.549670577,
0.1046946049,
-0.4600784779,
0.0255512055,
0.0807250962,
1.0702060461,
-0.949898541,
0.2227156609,
0.5802749991,
0.7021307945,
0.4726144373,
-0.0381954461,
0.4790332019,
-0.4867818356,
0.4880144596,
0.4147897661,
0.4095493853,
0.4984821081,
-0.2050445825,
0.5634309649,
0.0437171124,
-0.3967789114,
-0.9074525833,
0.329141736,
-0.4208599031,
-0.5855112076,
0.5968784094,
-0.457688719,
0.2417011857,
-0.170653224,
0.0086232154,
0.2063602209,
-0.0007784441,
0.7001358867,
0.611923039,
-0.0204642601,
0.0564441569,
-0.27553159,
0.7142424583,
0.6015409827,
-1.3392534256,
-0.3078961372,
0.07957986,
0.1389368027,
-0.0225450788,
0.8302137852,
-0.0991048217,
0.0967838168,
0.2651908398,
0.1213054433,
0.2358094007,
-0.3414922059,
-0.0879609063,
0.1183925867,
0.0019404715,
0.0911309198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14456v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14456v4 | Having Beer after Prayer? Measuring Cultural Bias in Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T18:27:51 | 2024-03-20T17:16:37 | Tarek Naous, Michael J. Ryan, Alan Ritter, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As the reach of large language models (LMs) expands globally, their ability
to cater to diverse cultural contexts becomes crucial. Despite advancements in
multilingual capabilities, models are not designed with appropriate cultural
nuances. In this paper, we show that multilingual and Arabic monolingual LMs
exhibit bias towards entities associated with Western culture. We introduce
CAMeL, a novel resource of 628 naturally-occurring prompts and 20,368 entities
spanning eight types that contrast Arab and Western cultures. CAMeL provides a
foundation for measuring cultural biases in LMs through both extrinsic and
intrinsic evaluations. Using CAMeL, we examine the cross-cultural performance
in Arabic of 16 different LMs on tasks such as story generation, NER, and
sentiment analysis, where we find concerning cases of stereotyping and cultural
unfairness. We further test their text-infilling performance, revealing the
incapability of appropriate adaptation to Arab cultural contexts. Finally, we
analyze 6 Arabic pre-training corpora and find that commonly used sources such
as Wikipedia may not be best suited to build culturally aware LMs, if used as
they are without adjustment. We will make CAMeL publicly available at:
https://github.com/tareknaous/camel | [
-0.5212265253,
-0.4441149533,
-0.0676259175,
0.5423548222,
-0.256947875,
0.2811373174,
-0.5234484673,
-0.8728947043,
0.2186703384,
0.4277566373,
-0.5522127748,
-0.4487360418,
-0.7533453703,
0.1856418848,
-0.2538876832,
1.4895995855,
-0.2532658875,
0.4433448315,
0.0571514703,
-0.7420028448,
-0.5253301263,
-0.423222363,
-0.4219024181,
-0.431070596,
0.4618811905,
0.1715693474,
0.8767115474,
0.2111909539,
0.355137229,
0.2319942415,
-0.0126220118,
0.1739743501,
-0.447532475,
0.2262941152,
-0.2031802237,
-0.1435124129,
0.0338419862,
0.0632341057,
0.5978327394,
0.7061555982,
-0.2247479111,
0.7860311866,
0.1156063154,
0.7833871841,
-0.9010129571,
-0.0658811107,
-0.6714123487,
0.2161841989,
-0.3504956663,
-0.1148429662,
-0.258874774,
-0.4907595813,
0.4580717385,
-0.2763335407,
0.215923667,
0.1687804163,
0.7740550041,
0.2886167169,
-0.6130228639,
-0.6522923112,
-0.7946254611,
1.0824526548,
-0.2942599356,
0.5819762945,
0.6038928032,
0.2290500551,
-0.2264595479,
-0.3825877011,
-0.5282923579,
-0.3587275743,
0.0357492939,
-0.1882323623,
-0.1473122835,
-0.4419787228,
0.1456481814,
0.2286109179,
-0.4235945642,
-0.1613488495,
-0.1665620655,
-0.1005463302,
0.435605973,
-0.112968646,
0.4866215289,
0.1313709319,
-0.5190954208,
-0.2990561426,
-0.8490355015,
0.43536973,
0.430914551,
0.0562118292,
-0.1963810623,
0.3082852662,
0.0532234982,
0.607234478,
-0.3675986826,
-0.3611220121,
0.2279950082,
-0.2753327787,
-0.0850698426,
0.4878701568,
0.6775478125,
0.567004621,
0.6034731269,
0.102688618,
0.0003848047,
0.011687248,
0.1608666182,
-1.0062699318,
0.0342268944,
0.0424512774,
-0.6532868147,
0.0478089713,
-0.2764480114,
-0.3690592945,
-0.840434134,
0.1538285762,
-0.1226828769,
-0.3397322893,
-0.2381833643,
0.0426051207,
-0.5990219116,
0.2752650678,
0.0448160656,
-0.8064834476,
0.0475942604,
0.2872393131,
0.8705499172,
0.0447466075,
-0.3812526166,
-0.3735338748,
0.4306690693,
-0.6329760551,
0.5993211269,
-0.6846313477,
-0.6972745657,
0.4638463855,
-0.168644622,
0.5927639008,
-0.6433824897,
1.0355619192,
-0.5967910886,
0.0046777446,
-0.8166193962,
-0.1454019547,
-0.2539960444,
0.1375279129,
-0.6039896607,
0.7886138558,
-0.0970611125,
-0.9351973534,
0.9718592167,
-0.4882639647,
-0.7424877882,
-0.1069344655,
-0.4443856776,
-0.0871123746,
-0.0053260829,
0.290787816,
0.0693203956,
-0.5615311861,
0.0498431809,
-0.4921100736,
-0.5348100066,
0.4144054055,
-0.5163041949,
0.8842471838,
0.2467624992,
-0.3503658772,
0.1284507811,
-0.7819430232,
0.0238753352,
0.0835051611,
-0.310636878,
-0.7808969617,
0.3285289109,
0.1008263305,
0.2962869108,
0.110137932,
-0.457580179,
0.0291095972,
-0.2564218044,
0.1285111308,
0.8180971146,
-0.3434887826,
0.2435873002,
-0.2354953438,
0.5295071602,
-0.0284937937,
0.031743668,
-0.0588807091,
-0.2618943751,
-0.7661449313,
-0.2591737509,
-0.2521616518,
0.3816132843,
-0.5858299136,
0.0086508319,
-0.1201587021,
-0.6773971319,
-0.8352158666,
0.4534974694,
0.1911768317,
0.2343109101,
0.3609430194,
-0.5120313168,
-0.3994782865,
-1.0617518425,
-0.6139944196,
-0.3009183407,
-0.0179950874,
0.1219810843,
0.2915515304,
-0.1434903443,
0.5569323897,
-0.2839219272,
-0.3974798322,
-0.2342210114,
0.1387642473,
0.2410051674,
0.2288887948,
0.6917361021,
-0.5065981746,
-0.5533642769,
0.279086858,
-0.8002651334,
-0.1142346188,
0.164160341,
-0.2340603769,
0.579951942,
0.0252214558,
-0.4000392556,
0.5086157322,
0.6676059365,
-0.4301659167,
0.6294224858,
-0.0552851856,
0.2093691379,
-0.7891088128,
-0.0914695486,
0.1206420735,
-0.0038632965,
-0.2991012037,
-0.1431958228,
-0.1346494704,
0.1557480842,
-0.1830802858,
0.7147228122,
-0.6611377597,
0.0409245268,
-0.7355322838,
-0.3099250495,
0.0747952834,
0.0004587577,
0.3061458766,
0.7308152914,
0.5960285068,
-0.3810245395,
0.1939617246,
0.1031224728,
-0.8638736606,
0.4239502549,
-0.6694539189,
0.0954514518,
-0.2954206765,
0.8335903883,
-0.7366362214,
0.0689607114,
0.3567047119,
-0.1372565925,
0.0892347246,
-0.0839855373,
-0.3085888624,
-0.3138706088,
-0.2550199628,
0.7251262069,
0.5035419464,
-0.4373363554,
0.4016690552,
0.326076448,
-0.220364809,
-1.2678523064,
-0.5180510879,
-0.0001399548,
-0.2586751878,
-0.6730104089,
-0.0302314553,
-0.0507880077,
-0.471686542,
-0.2134362906,
-0.1771839857,
0.1225020736,
-0.1037862897,
0.3132825792,
0.1901582479,
-0.2389966249,
0.1680601686,
0.0086790593,
0.3322655857,
0.3249907792,
-0.4157558382,
0.6164776087,
-0.2561696768,
-0.3160132766,
-0.3742711246,
0.7300719023,
0.4622358978,
-0.5528100133,
1.1588757038,
1.1059240103,
-0.1736086607,
-0.2998048067,
-0.7746130824,
-0.0413068533,
-0.4837523699,
0.458711952,
-0.3656085432,
-0.5472055674,
0.5521629453,
0.2593053877,
0.1716596782,
0.082145296,
0.8205282688,
0.0151715316,
0.8891649842,
0.6177125573,
-0.3599371016,
0.4440268576,
0.111271888,
0.4630669951,
-0.2457346618,
-0.1263404191,
-0.7581753135,
-0.4544825256,
-0.9456629753,
-0.4826518297,
0.3596161306,
0.0202926248,
-0.4000541866,
-0.3365809917,
-0.1890131235,
0.4869403243,
0.6333025694,
-0.48365435,
0.3221026957,
0.1849382818,
-0.1295629591,
-0.0543523952,
-0.4917977154,
-0.6728817225,
0.698616147,
0.2985356152,
0.897521317,
0.1890995651,
0.2564605772,
0.4459157288,
0.8319826126,
-0.5665566325,
0.0759190917,
0.0893260092,
-0.8802486062,
-0.1627548039,
-0.1728994399,
-0.641353786,
0.4612870812,
0.0007992553,
-0.6261689067,
0.0414524116,
0.0153641962,
-0.1067438945,
0.2332938462,
-0.6721173525,
0.7450214624,
-0.2074535042,
-0.3328159451,
-0.2296990454,
-0.6049878001,
0.382828325,
-0.0505446754,
0.4965518415,
-0.2797337174,
-0.0709489733,
0.7252451777,
-0.3368575573,
0.6416501403,
-0.1269052476,
-0.3324913681,
0.3317642212,
0.198057875,
0.3103538454,
0.0572995506,
-0.2506484985,
0.4851844013,
0.3530538082,
-0.7787390351,
-0.5067215562,
0.7732570767,
-1.0387222767,
-0.7877064347,
-0.700738132,
-0.5732356906,
-0.2787924707,
-0.0209232289,
0.0284572188,
0.1682082415,
-0.3160786629,
0.137958616,
0.0488793068,
-0.6525495648,
0.3686610162,
0.7576983571,
-0.4171435833,
-0.0560182557,
0.7181627154,
0.172569409,
0.1614621729,
-0.1398574561,
0.2470407486,
-0.1822634637,
-0.3530550599,
-0.851100564,
0.0187156294,
-0.7996971011,
0.1769007444,
-0.4752679765,
0.0155337593,
-0.487472415,
-0.0868685618,
-0.3291731477,
0.1103373691,
0.2457241714,
-0.0815437287,
0.2796276212,
0.6553111076,
-0.009302604,
0.1946612746,
-0.8670227528,
-0.0532139838,
-0.3397783637,
0.1942215264,
0.3197231293,
-0.514950633,
-0.4966948926,
0.0599864498,
-0.3743679821,
-0.7119394541,
0.2466627806,
0.2102297097,
0.2486179024,
0.9923923612,
-0.0013293462,
0.8536177278,
-0.8356969953,
0.735835731,
0.2479492873,
-0.7668321133,
0.3696711361,
-0.1140022278,
0.319819212,
0.4700420499,
0.8798689246,
-0.8959958553,
-0.5696274042,
-0.0803090557,
-0.7895253897,
0.4943340421,
-0.0698989555,
0.5803111792,
-0.2958149612,
-0.0926831886,
0.5031246543,
0.3679199219,
-0.8741831779,
-0.6213653684,
-0.4066681862,
0.2544337511,
-0.1170940697,
-0.1685375869,
-0.178744927,
-0.4504419863,
0.8055170774,
0.068356961,
-0.2606494129,
0.1809917688,
-0.0688477382,
-0.3293717206,
0.2346720248,
0.5079469681,
0.8730735183,
-0.2293175161,
-0.0111665223,
0.1562480032,
-0.4465474486,
0.1886227429,
0.0837468132,
-0.0622415207,
0.2130230069,
0.5288596749,
0.8027234077,
-0.2860504091,
-0.8906697631,
0.2763596177,
-0.1601793915,
0.5661804676,
-0.6118054986,
-0.0312147811,
0.0719923377,
0.1997886598,
0.4790782332,
-0.0919396803,
0.1351368278,
-0.9805693626,
-0.2188329995,
0.7534837127,
-0.5898044705,
-0.108263202,
0.3153018951,
0.147635296,
-0.1969224513,
0.4642087221,
-0.2246202528,
-0.4780430496,
0.2082179785,
0.5995755196,
0.5032914281,
-0.3157775998,
0.3208992779,
0.2138311714,
0.4369523525,
0.3478651643,
0.2196246833,
-0.2679486573,
-1.1165786982,
-0.4147417843,
-0.9125170112,
-0.0237803534,
-0.0579225905,
-0.7315629721,
0.129044503,
-0.1072377563,
-0.3024190962,
-0.1329313666,
0.0361741707,
-1.0437932014,
0.0190503281,
0.2294798344,
0.9981507659,
-0.6603764892,
0.8488251567,
0.8079259396,
-0.5082908273,
-0.5710507631,
0.0894479901,
-0.0711600631,
-1.0297966003,
0.8015918732,
0.2766741216,
-0.4138039351,
-0.5878381133,
-0.2694105506,
-0.6470591426,
0.5617420673,
0.3240106106,
-0.2640633583,
0.0364619419,
0.188968569,
0.5740356445,
-0.2479563951,
0.5671744347,
0.5973088741,
0.4052529633,
0.0138530005,
-0.7965512872,
0.0016967404,
-0.0983654186,
-0.0922836512,
0.1746007651,
-0.7920903563,
0.408348918,
-0.2541904747,
-0.036053922,
0.0670006871,
0.8715269566,
0.3371317089,
0.3291479647,
0.5105566978,
0.101247713,
0.9454161525,
0.1958927214,
1.3079032898,
-0.4138543904,
-0.1057840884,
1.3529721498,
-0.8665254116,
0.8140562773,
0.8536713719,
-0.1209661663,
0.8712490201,
0.7166593075,
0.2361435592,
0.4724316299,
0.6535145044,
-0.581520915,
-0.0408055857,
-0.8995308876,
-0.8572790623,
0.6916779876,
0.2250037491,
-0.6760609746,
-0.1237477139,
0.0746585652,
0.13757056,
-0.1069084927,
-0.1262745708,
0.4286544323,
0.2999541163,
-0.7758363485,
0.7709645629,
0.1770603508,
0.5665538907,
-0.7811303735,
0.0644983724,
-0.1017972231,
0.0617914498,
-0.0039239726,
-0.4929421842,
0.0989214182,
0.2498224527,
-0.353274256,
-0.1775711477,
0.7281427979,
-0.3199083805,
-0.754717648,
0.5608687401,
0.7211444378,
0.2112996131,
0.0830521286,
-0.3321098983,
0.4246888459,
-0.0059910472,
-0.2564921677,
0.2648136318,
0.4764797091,
-0.2720856965,
0.7614630461,
0.6357685328,
0.3483723998,
0.0380250551,
0.4851253629,
0.4222898483,
-0.7160010338,
-0.2991793156,
-1.1822118759,
0.0104940012,
-0.0234343186,
-0.5399437547,
0.8500685096,
0.357727468,
1.1250382662,
-0.0054514366,
0.7789712548,
0.1034961343,
0.0443886928,
-0.2809872925,
1.105963707,
-0.5994265079,
0.0497182012,
-0.2249599397,
-0.9566022158,
0.2617651224,
0.6065104008,
-0.2624479234,
0.179309234,
0.6520915031,
0.554223597,
0.2504684925,
0.4864675999,
0.0101243258,
0.2532168329,
0.2623828351,
0.2134669274,
1.3111946583,
0.0746310353,
0.4319592714,
0.0254557095,
-0.2447618544,
0.1089209989,
-0.8776494265,
-0.9344760776,
-0.4085327387,
-0.0758743957,
-0.494353056,
0.0498671867,
1.3975676298,
0.7353238463,
-0.7322855592,
-0.4511054456,
0.7673094869,
0.2190707773,
-0.2795169353,
-0.1850447506,
0.2998299301,
-0.2797072828,
-0.6921573877,
0.1556802392,
0.1057054996,
-0.1950099319,
-0.4546947479,
-0.1065641344,
-0.0451727733,
0.0967019871,
0.756975472,
-0.0127596958,
-0.8241407871,
-0.3716185093,
-0.2696184516,
0.0338783972,
-0.0781250522,
0.9005508423,
-0.6173622012,
0.3998032212,
0.0927259102,
0.698231101,
0.1773809046,
-0.3377996981,
0.7527989745,
-0.6117158532,
0.3345217109,
-0.0079050716,
0.5543157458,
0.3770719767,
0.0336779431,
0.1892888397,
-0.0877762362,
-0.5236032009,
-0.8458417654,
0.2387772948,
-0.6052315235,
-0.1509868056,
1.1753059626,
-0.1851823181,
-0.0786566734,
0.0181965753,
-0.3419230282,
0.4517768621,
-0.4496328831,
1.0517053604,
1.4682877064,
0.2037038207,
0.4964483976,
-0.847769618,
0.685133338,
0.7700697184,
-0.2366606444,
-0.1321435124,
0.4767440856,
0.409049958,
0.0960787758,
0.5508525968,
0.3370244503,
0.2363760918,
-0.2787981331,
0.1695369482,
0.4365226924,
-0.218074277,
0.0481581911,
0.07646624,
0.3973422348,
-0.057089556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14453v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14453v2 | On Robustness of Finetuned Transformer-based NLP Models | 2023-05-23T18:25:18 | 2023-11-08T16:46:20 | Pavan Kalyan Reddy Neerudu, Subba Reddy Oota, Mounika Marreddy, Venkateswara Rao Kagita, Manish Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based pretrained models like BERT, GPT-2 and T5 have been
finetuned for a large number of natural language processing (NLP) tasks, and
have been shown to be very effective. However, while finetuning, what changes
across layers in these models with respect to pretrained checkpoints is
under-studied. Further, how robust are these models to perturbations in input
text? Does the robustness vary depending on the NLP task for which the models
have been finetuned? While there exists some work on studying the robustness of
BERT finetuned for a few NLP tasks, there is no rigorous study that compares
this robustness across encoder only, decoder only and encoder-decoder models.
In this paper, we characterize changes between pretrained and finetuned
language model representations across layers using two metrics: CKA and STIR.
Further, we study the robustness of three language models (BERT, GPT-2 and T5)
with eight different text perturbations on classification tasks from the
General Language Understanding Evaluation (GLUE) benchmark, and generation
tasks like summarization, free-form generation and question generation. GPT-2
representations are more robust than BERT and T5 across multiple types of input
perturbation. Although models exhibit good robustness broadly, dropping nouns,
verbs or changing characters are the most impactful. Overall, this study
provides valuable insights into perturbation-specific weaknesses of popular
Transformer-based models, which should be kept in mind when passing inputs. We
make the code and models publicly available
[https://github.com/PavanNeerudu/Robustness-of-Transformers-models]. | [
-0.3251410127,
-0.9157946706,
0.4024706483,
0.2187652141,
-0.0174051318,
-0.377068907,
-0.2559015155,
-0.3786285222,
-0.4340027869,
0.479021728,
-0.4145225585,
-0.2471958846,
-0.7750211358,
0.1377685219,
-0.6023752689,
1.1251505613,
0.0370536633,
0.1478289813,
-0.012353234,
-0.0098525565,
-0.4801093042,
-0.7220317125,
-0.3706294596,
-0.4945416749,
0.3249923587,
0.0377859101,
0.7883936763,
0.1468288302,
0.6904019117,
0.2413999587,
-0.3515910804,
-0.4314785302,
-0.4240895808,
0.3794169426,
-0.2231263965,
-0.5733757615,
-0.3242715299,
-0.192741096,
0.5274506211,
0.6856848598,
-0.0827144608,
0.0071779895,
0.6745465398,
0.2349492759,
-0.5214918852,
0.1528785229,
-1.0557650328,
-0.2056808323,
-0.1700318009,
0.2052697986,
-0.4653942883,
0.0451959185,
0.2590686381,
-0.3964579701,
0.3673950434,
-0.5371236205,
1.2517477274,
0.640012145,
-0.0754813328,
-0.227386415,
-0.9456958771,
0.7799707055,
-0.97965765,
0.5105131865,
0.5364176035,
0.2747293711,
-0.0431567468,
-0.8906164765,
-0.4278300703,
-0.4197645485,
-0.1468645781,
0.0145560093,
-0.2266145498,
0.2132278532,
0.4472289085,
0.3992744088,
-0.3068465292,
0.5268144608,
0.1571299434,
-0.3160324395,
-0.0381160565,
-0.0876779258,
0.2768889964,
-0.3333781958,
-0.2457441837,
-0.3978723586,
-0.567776382,
0.321270436,
0.3608205914,
0.3332546055,
-0.1505813748,
0.5088146925,
0.1008287519,
0.4687185884,
0.2879279256,
0.0431040153,
-0.1665680856,
-0.4848833382,
-0.2276479453,
-0.5289522409,
0.7790756226,
0.0611655898,
0.2180455327,
-0.3399844468,
-0.4706183672,
0.0623592772,
0.3858292699,
-0.7930004597,
-0.4680311978,
0.2671763897,
-0.3664206564,
-0.3888195157,
-0.0596705601,
-0.3106910586,
-0.1852083206,
-0.1503144354,
0.6992896795,
-0.5662676096,
-0.0616831928,
0.0946101397,
0.1904299557,
0.3340560794,
0.1456803977,
-1.1619429588,
0.3298844099,
0.6587942839,
0.5952300429,
-0.1612032056,
-0.3321281075,
-0.2532662749,
-0.1969987303,
0.0800084248,
0.7304347157,
-0.33850348,
0.0745703205,
0.1102784425,
0.045870617,
-0.2945231795,
-0.4593245685,
0.7477861643,
-0.5227127075,
0.1361520588,
-0.3270997107,
-0.4827699661,
0.0180072375,
0.5088772178,
-0.8216177225,
0.7446871996,
0.0487362966,
-0.9942364693,
0.3967679739,
-0.4697944522,
-0.4037675261,
-0.3198477626,
0.1300560683,
-0.5405527353,
-0.0159643274,
0.5418046713,
0.6278341413,
-0.0889052302,
0.2828749418,
-0.2432900369,
-0.2234920859,
0.2778782547,
-0.7273628712,
0.9383714199,
0.1254487187,
-0.228538692,
0.17518574,
-0.8125844598,
-0.1762145311,
-0.0169638246,
-0.452347964,
-0.0336584337,
0.1635894626,
0.2865622342,
0.2156323344,
0.0363714024,
-0.4259900451,
0.0679154694,
-0.4024226665,
0.6673021317,
0.5420200229,
-0.0269197151,
0.3128617108,
-0.2832860351,
0.3820407093,
0.1647365093,
0.06721358,
-0.2311853468,
-0.3599409759,
-0.6787981987,
-0.0554809049,
0.677760005,
0.6565188766,
-0.6956364512,
0.5254850984,
-0.0911745653,
-0.516936183,
-0.3595139086,
-0.1464285105,
0.1621958464,
0.4177906513,
0.5090605021,
-0.2685531378,
-0.2119222283,
-0.7313005328,
-0.4295518696,
0.018187765,
-0.4473055601,
-0.1884608567,
0.4797659516,
-0.4326294363,
0.683368206,
-0.0534566529,
-0.3163432181,
-0.3506616354,
0.1664087474,
0.1258427203,
0.7213389874,
0.6052346826,
-0.4692382514,
-0.3409358561,
-0.1862720102,
-0.2908694446,
-0.156329155,
-0.3957287669,
0.1728977412,
0.1407444179,
0.4465499222,
-0.7016257048,
0.3199118674,
0.6549316049,
-0.1319340467,
0.5852136612,
-0.0889182091,
-0.1777256727,
-0.9351447225,
0.0912466347,
-0.1009278744,
-0.2999510467,
-0.8574778438,
0.2740855217,
-0.0585639067,
-0.0439205728,
-0.2941555679,
0.0217081159,
-0.0471252799,
0.0421601161,
0.0093917763,
-0.1012550816,
-0.1175010875,
0.4776551425,
-0.1360583156,
0.5894951224,
0.6079884768,
-0.6177597046,
-0.1366441995,
0.2990024686,
-0.3741034269,
0.1827898324,
-0.9959235191,
0.308470875,
0.0183177404,
0.1353885382,
-0.8345945477,
-0.1766816378,
0.0390884541,
-0.4105361402,
0.5162718892,
-0.0862090588,
-0.623105824,
0.0692053139,
-0.225959152,
0.2943712771,
0.4605070353,
-0.3478214741,
0.5792890191,
0.0347359329,
-0.0479329154,
-0.5577799082,
-0.7569895983,
-0.14776887,
-0.0414189473,
-0.6820196509,
0.3094943166,
0.0987928659,
0.0327803865,
-0.2129231691,
-0.2239731401,
-0.3044712543,
0.3240879774,
0.1420982331,
0.0105652921,
-0.2049725652,
-0.2001494616,
0.029750824,
-0.1226824149,
0.0496704467,
-0.1536837667,
0.8152707219,
-0.080702126,
-0.3180633485,
-0.5952307582,
0.0778738409,
0.5705477595,
-0.3277540803,
0.8553927541,
0.9682832956,
-0.478374064,
0.0195017122,
-0.4946595728,
-0.4339972436,
-0.4485353529,
0.3935820758,
-0.3899231255,
-1.0045417547,
0.9911059141,
0.2515386343,
0.2968398631,
0.6849984527,
0.6117765307,
-0.2191230953,
0.8906364441,
0.7976842523,
0.0672717392,
0.5525069237,
-0.16987212,
0.1292673051,
-0.6881660819,
0.1438684314,
-0.7932173014,
-0.1951587796,
-0.672087431,
-0.1755174547,
0.0421600975,
0.3173902333,
-0.3312007487,
0.4785759747,
-0.4088146985,
0.3066023886,
0.4831906259,
-0.0819339007,
0.1977401823,
0.0265500546,
-0.2006076872,
-0.1331247836,
-0.7953820825,
-0.7102285028,
0.9909082055,
0.6799818873,
0.8944885731,
-0.0464378484,
0.3703909218,
-0.0874248296,
-0.02905914,
-0.6248754859,
0.1849523932,
-0.470420897,
-0.6977101564,
-0.3149303794,
-0.2229005694,
-0.8472748995,
0.0178068466,
-0.4227241874,
-0.8034904599,
0.2091912776,
0.2867892385,
-0.3740171492,
0.4184833765,
-0.5436871648,
0.8849420547,
0.0283004846,
-0.0552780516,
0.1421426386,
-0.7213996053,
0.0800035968,
-0.210337922,
-0.2139894962,
0.1781413704,
0.3566981852,
0.5353757739,
-0.3584848046,
0.8015634418,
-0.0949715823,
-0.2637325823,
0.137092039,
0.2125913203,
0.5651656389,
-0.0076163555,
-0.0064578522,
0.3591800928,
0.3637452126,
-0.3112993538,
-0.4171258509,
0.4643942416,
-0.8501731753,
-0.4866985977,
-0.1169268638,
-0.5675467253,
-0.3667027652,
0.3206566572,
0.7812510729,
0.547950089,
0.0130734369,
0.5494541526,
0.6666148901,
-0.3465582728,
0.4788271487,
0.1103440374,
0.0764332116,
0.0099318158,
0.5062276125,
0.2780862451,
0.5957783461,
0.4710009992,
0.0942043215,
-0.0609579049,
-0.7965816855,
-0.1823541671,
-0.0767127275,
-0.6996122003,
-0.1743674129,
-0.4823922515,
-0.3221017122,
-0.339630127,
-0.0793723837,
-0.5873755813,
-0.4097771645,
-0.3184542358,
0.0047916332,
-0.1453524083,
0.7911406159,
0.2150017172,
0.3817550838,
-0.6549862027,
0.3846606314,
0.3767315745,
0.5615193844,
-0.0941770151,
-0.5718646049,
-0.088314265,
0.0692999512,
-0.4258333743,
-0.7462107539,
-0.1191359758,
0.2192133218,
0.3497639894,
0.436422497,
0.103726469,
0.315613091,
-0.4928341806,
1.0298578739,
-0.1171583533,
-1.0502445698,
0.2289655358,
-0.5508748293,
0.6096730232,
0.5484842062,
0.1154174134,
-0.1117602736,
-0.7526171803,
-0.4091318548,
-0.6404922009,
0.612968564,
0.5111128092,
0.3363392949,
0.2726545036,
0.4231591821,
0.3261801302,
-0.1505721211,
-0.9950996041,
-0.0230432078,
-0.6023320556,
-0.1352341175,
0.0846817121,
-0.4728448987,
0.1311861277,
-0.1915321052,
0.3380336761,
0.0705365837,
0.362262845,
0.1817394197,
-0.2612037659,
0.1574112922,
0.4119290411,
0.5211106539,
0.4745208323,
-0.3063715994,
0.097624518,
0.3031968474,
-0.8274921179,
-0.0206607282,
0.203497991,
-0.4069249034,
-0.0136655141,
0.6439739466,
0.8120263815,
0.2437026501,
-0.2557338476,
0.3666873872,
-0.2041098326,
-0.2133220732,
0.037187364,
0.0311517883,
-0.1855221093,
0.1266975701,
0.1776490211,
0.4493987262,
0.0076085608,
-0.2989174128,
0.0312344469,
0.4440138638,
-0.4450679421,
-0.6661379933,
0.9851362705,
-0.0817348287,
-0.0757353157,
0.566449523,
0.0606558248,
-0.6116229296,
0.297555685,
0.7176075578,
0.86263448,
-0.1645851284,
-0.162125513,
0.2464379817,
0.6207243204,
-0.1695363373,
-0.1947706491,
0.0472962521,
-0.9997903109,
-0.5827351809,
-0.5598008633,
-0.321046412,
0.4519478083,
-0.7699892521,
0.2719098926,
-0.479586482,
-0.4602976739,
-0.0657388493,
-0.2625596821,
-0.8085753918,
0.2477844208,
0.0790419951,
0.6636947393,
-0.6847359538,
0.8774165511,
0.778708756,
-0.2168286741,
-1.0372765064,
0.383118391,
-0.4004584551,
-0.326492846,
0.1841511428,
0.0876826793,
-0.0297911819,
-0.0981964692,
-0.4822891653,
-0.7566407323,
0.8493344188,
0.7429580092,
-0.4800013304,
-0.3424665034,
0.2781925797,
0.5840730071,
0.1736910045,
0.1311070621,
0.6337340474,
0.2435119599,
-0.1658031642,
-1.1889750957,
-0.1593444496,
-0.0101337116,
0.1252615899,
-0.046123676,
-0.3291247189,
0.9445227385,
0.1396322846,
-0.2401989847,
0.2161061615,
0.3895988464,
-0.041578047,
-0.2386735678,
0.5571355224,
0.6051084995,
0.4639801681,
-0.415211916,
1.1099826097,
-0.4019920826,
0.6131680012,
0.8856973648,
0.2349449247,
0.9227552414,
0.2584301531,
-0.2303112447,
0.2797029912,
0.3256082237,
-0.0469235852,
0.5135059357,
-0.1450239867,
0.321272105,
-0.2589518726,
0.3130639791,
-0.3323046863,
0.5523773432,
0.1886973083,
-0.1462172717,
-0.1249955893,
0.0835089386,
0.119216077,
-0.1234133914,
-0.1546286792,
0.6147321463,
0.0462795086,
-0.5829476118,
0.757322669,
0.0407033749,
0.8999243975,
-0.6496369243,
0.3101702332,
-0.0938682929,
0.4082867205,
-0.331769526,
-0.6665024161,
0.3495716155,
0.1057890207,
-0.1548290998,
-0.3178001642,
0.9511625171,
-0.2823922038,
-0.4021832049,
0.0174526405,
0.2319294661,
-0.0954078063,
-0.1622731239,
-0.5226290226,
0.2538054287,
-0.0103440825,
-0.3557986021,
0.2841654718,
0.1789062768,
0.0685419142,
0.4817766249,
0.3312033415,
-0.1045287251,
0.263807863,
0.2862558365,
0.7160781622,
-0.2611847818,
-0.2160338014,
-0.7195622921,
0.6569745541,
0.3758682609,
-0.3419022262,
0.7674518824,
0.007401133,
0.8850845098,
-0.215338394,
0.3892504275,
0.0079001561,
0.3452711999,
-0.6791943908,
1.0780925751,
-0.1322768927,
0.3251667619,
-0.5436653495,
-1.2448772192,
-0.4889724553,
0.6479033828,
-0.1477443278,
0.1517391801,
0.587551713,
0.5101969242,
-0.1092300415,
-0.0509430766,
0.1653062254,
0.406468302,
0.5725024939,
0.3601062894,
0.6610025167,
-0.5268822908,
0.4516515434,
-0.3831517398,
0.1477593482,
0.0412725881,
-0.7781546116,
-0.8723322749,
-0.7988231182,
-0.2567402124,
-0.2077648938,
-0.1752722412,
0.4540150762,
0.5946963429,
-1.1274628639,
0.1242368892,
-0.2551968992,
-0.0976915881,
-0.2357144654,
-0.1832892746,
0.3954603076,
-0.6457887292,
-0.6002754569,
0.0874167979,
-0.1109410599,
0.1445655972,
-0.2993810773,
0.2996177077,
0.0512013808,
0.0640843585,
0.6034580469,
0.0403912105,
-0.7362138033,
-0.5196877122,
0.1147821844,
-0.1140394956,
0.0110255536,
0.5902021527,
-0.6329676509,
0.3426772058,
0.4376582205,
0.8095592856,
0.3711646795,
0.0207863692,
0.5697787404,
-0.7419343591,
0.1963000149,
0.3479921818,
0.3656792641,
0.4239846468,
-0.0722989514,
0.1933228374,
-0.2172283828,
-0.8216812611,
-0.8797395825,
0.2420293093,
-0.8411291242,
-0.0737295225,
1.0618957281,
-0.2528596818,
0.227795437,
-0.0591753572,
-0.1424142867,
0.3246087134,
0.0693582594,
0.7055754066,
1.0272339582,
-0.0070490851,
-0.1281116009,
-0.6338950396,
0.6090096235,
0.7500039339,
-0.5224704742,
-0.1215404421,
0.1306315362,
0.3539018929,
0.2420502156,
0.0561177842,
-0.1609823853,
0.0820157602,
-0.0186144039,
-0.3035773635,
0.0059996457,
-0.2149153352,
-0.4606283009,
0.2274665087,
0.3896668851,
0.0364120156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14450v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14450v1 | Is Information Extraction Solved by ChatGPT? An Analysis of Performance, Evaluation Criteria, Robustness and Errors | 2023-05-23T18:17:43 | 2023-05-23T18:17:43 | Ridong Han, Tao Peng, Chaohao Yang, Benyou Wang, Lu Liu, Xiang Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT has stimulated the research boom in the field of large language
models. In this paper, we assess the capabilities of ChatGPT from four
perspectives including Performance, Evaluation Criteria, Robustness and Error
Types. Specifically, we first evaluate ChatGPT's performance on 17 datasets
with 14 IE sub-tasks under the zero-shot, few-shot and chain-of-thought
scenarios, and find a huge performance gap between ChatGPT and SOTA results.
Next, we rethink this gap and propose a soft-matching strategy for evaluation
to more accurately reflect ChatGPT's performance. Then, we analyze the
robustness of ChatGPT on 14 IE sub-tasks, and find that: 1) ChatGPT rarely
outputs invalid responses; 2) Irrelevant context and long-tail target types
greatly affect ChatGPT's performance; 3) ChatGPT cannot understand well the
subject-object relationships in RE task. Finally, we analyze the errors of
ChatGPT, and find that "unannotated spans" is the most dominant error type.
This raises concerns about the quality of annotated data, and indicates the
possibility of annotating data with ChatGPT. The data and code are released at
Github site. | [
-0.2769677341,
-0.9436994791,
0.3173253238,
0.2485462427,
-0.0298055038,
0.2253806889,
-0.4366614223,
-0.5081964135,
-0.2235284597,
0.209336102,
-0.4426279068,
-0.2321305573,
-0.820952177,
0.031186007,
-0.5208960176,
1.228446126,
0.1346700341,
-0.1613508016,
0.1519563198,
0.1220954359,
-0.5566725135,
-0.5615720749,
-0.5684116483,
0.0491320305,
0.2066919059,
0.5397962332,
0.6866034269,
0.476008445,
0.861816287,
0.186653465,
0.0469394103,
0.0872734264,
-0.7081279159,
0.072536014,
-0.096325174,
-0.3993065059,
-0.4870265722,
-0.0999671444,
0.6881924272,
0.3019751012,
-0.1423853934,
0.3298606873,
0.3438591659,
0.5333479643,
-0.368802011,
0.6509204507,
-0.6849619746,
-0.0162387025,
-0.4611457288,
-0.1011978611,
-0.2981328368,
-0.2306436598,
0.5031286478,
-0.4300273061,
0.2037275285,
0.174552843,
1.0518044233,
0.249445349,
-0.1325268447,
-0.3655757606,
-0.6642047167,
0.5646290183,
-0.6807385683,
0.3685651422,
0.130211845,
0.3884714544,
-0.3154315948,
-0.7179706693,
-0.4804421067,
-0.0664326698,
0.055477798,
0.3145034909,
-0.2733088434,
-0.0616836399,
0.4554405212,
0.4852769971,
-0.7102331519,
-0.0125355637,
-0.4362403154,
-0.143750146,
0.5293248892,
-0.0652745515,
0.3411193192,
-0.3146838546,
-0.3683434427,
-0.0843901113,
-0.6610771418,
-0.0294528436,
0.2688176334,
0.5229303837,
0.0712843612,
0.7765875459,
-0.1591302752,
0.3880395889,
-0.2305609733,
0.1279525757,
0.1646040529,
-0.368136704,
-0.1160124093,
-0.1634373218,
0.9026084542,
0.2507242262,
0.5927070975,
-0.3083705306,
-0.0527274795,
-0.1951670647,
0.1762464345,
-0.6137507558,
-0.4306980371,
0.1469903439,
-0.2996435761,
-0.1033828557,
0.0377379358,
-0.9912344217,
-0.2474643439,
-0.0209202729,
0.5001046062,
-0.6647655964,
-0.5137686729,
0.057730522,
-0.0212008506,
0.3620953262,
0.3146311343,
-0.5895255208,
0.3190713227,
0.812751472,
0.8943250179,
-0.2919074595,
-0.1987276673,
-0.3796939254,
-0.303195715,
0.0017755289,
1.0405839682,
-0.5562898517,
0.0034141515,
-0.1590116024,
-0.1320454627,
-0.5323412418,
-0.3212307096,
0.7841992974,
-0.4670468271,
0.2492506951,
-0.2488680929,
-0.7189834714,
-0.1391991973,
0.3708835244,
-0.7342036963,
1.1373516321,
0.1118100137,
-1.0979573727,
0.2766592503,
-0.7619559765,
-0.1676155329,
0.1477130651,
-0.1154851988,
-0.4287664294,
-0.1476083994,
0.074423857,
0.4175307751,
-0.3766678572,
0.1525822431,
-0.1376446933,
-0.4281103015,
0.2587030232,
-0.4544299245,
0.5971174836,
0.206972748,
-0.4059582949,
-0.2529930472,
-0.850009799,
0.2061575949,
0.1951251924,
-0.5437039733,
0.0508027151,
0.1668315232,
0.2240582258,
0.1554336846,
0.1998574585,
-0.5461256504,
0.3746083379,
-0.183040306,
0.6334785223,
0.5769245625,
-0.08959876,
-0.0080978796,
-0.0244332086,
0.5195744038,
-0.1806468666,
0.0351395458,
-0.0716203898,
-0.5450736284,
-0.6379078627,
-0.1573332995,
0.821428597,
0.8844535947,
-0.6220377088,
0.1957810074,
-0.4076125622,
-0.5543278456,
-0.3511534333,
-0.071459204,
0.4169929922,
0.4552429914,
0.1755535007,
-0.394284904,
-0.5747501254,
-0.8061427474,
-0.3506194055,
-0.3247468174,
0.0681592748,
0.1443086714,
0.3776888549,
-0.0313760005,
1.0347901583,
-0.3125580549,
-0.1101987138,
-0.3089919388,
0.2941475511,
0.2909879684,
0.4133771062,
0.1872041523,
-0.7448900938,
-0.3999769986,
0.0688917339,
-0.5927745104,
-0.1323652267,
0.1049215421,
-0.0297614653,
-0.1126312092,
0.1837771833,
-0.6841415763,
0.3548357487,
0.4017858207,
-0.0740786791,
0.6606613398,
0.1682008356,
0.1700632423,
-0.9212270975,
0.1620917767,
0.0469649918,
-0.2695074677,
-0.591360271,
-0.0823058784,
-0.0272311717,
-0.2289024293,
-0.1468079686,
0.0518826991,
-0.3665092587,
-0.1356385499,
-0.0387153439,
0.4165078402,
-0.1535743177,
0.5262063146,
-0.0673261806,
0.7781623602,
0.5393270254,
-0.2155336291,
0.3340349197,
0.2590545714,
-0.2659474015,
0.355512321,
-0.6821123958,
0.3638835251,
-0.1317078322,
0.0715869293,
-1.2298669815,
-0.3152817488,
0.2446763813,
-0.5793768764,
0.4464165866,
-0.4373591542,
-0.6060079336,
-0.02607961,
-0.1623358279,
0.2047152966,
0.3081369698,
-0.1326121688,
0.3834583759,
0.4553831518,
-0.3698734939,
-0.6656677723,
-0.4210956693,
0.1858476102,
-0.2542419732,
-0.6997641921,
-0.1646081805,
0.2327347547,
-0.0641570836,
0.0735903308,
-0.1931766421,
-0.2009433508,
0.0189227331,
0.1785750389,
0.0666267574,
-0.3619382083,
0.1388262957,
-0.5228545666,
-0.1662628949,
-0.2022982538,
-0.119978562,
0.5706586838,
-0.5215786695,
-0.4928031266,
-0.1595927924,
0.2775699794,
0.3175926507,
-0.2433534265,
0.4511960149,
0.6800899506,
-0.2985333502,
0.1494077742,
-0.6506232023,
0.0341971181,
-0.3331001103,
0.5795001388,
-0.2685938179,
-0.8080225587,
0.5146186948,
0.0062881378,
0.347637862,
0.660381496,
0.300635457,
-0.00416969,
0.7882171869,
0.5767564774,
-0.0482558981,
0.444981575,
-0.1702579707,
0.4381278455,
-0.6311117411,
-0.2176078856,
-0.7166957855,
-0.0574725382,
-0.7788981795,
-0.0471158586,
0.2967671752,
0.1282438785,
-0.0832247362,
0.53195858,
-0.3554952145,
0.1829893291,
0.5846589804,
-0.0783798397,
0.3721833825,
-0.0318023711,
0.3093378842,
-0.095388554,
-0.8539512753,
-0.6939408779,
0.960891366,
0.469178319,
0.7660262585,
0.1376930922,
0.2843482792,
0.2511925697,
0.0632980168,
-0.7813706398,
0.3956735432,
-0.0832442418,
-0.6268494725,
-0.2466448396,
-0.479827553,
-1.0040179491,
0.2384969145,
-0.2436751574,
-1.0824337006,
-0.075718604,
0.0123247961,
-0.2215592265,
0.0314543135,
-1.1820076704,
0.9718888998,
-0.0074890419,
-0.3012758493,
0.2206947953,
-0.8043447733,
0.2529766858,
-0.0520512015,
0.10231933,
-0.2544999421,
0.2028362453,
0.9178125858,
0.0023189569,
0.575935185,
-0.0371770188,
0.0979013517,
0.3732232451,
0.1965541393,
0.49581182,
-0.172271803,
-0.0624955706,
0.2831223309,
0.3901984096,
-0.295848608,
-0.6957699656,
0.2554281354,
-0.5196185112,
-0.4568993747,
-0.4126954079,
-0.3088600934,
-0.3866545558,
0.3799122572,
0.3473594487,
0.5352848172,
-0.1184001416,
0.3468271792,
0.4251328409,
-0.0308158863,
0.3695168793,
0.322222501,
0.0801015347,
-0.00034937,
0.935539782,
0.3610578477,
0.1922890246,
0.2603809834,
0.0919391364,
-0.2881401777,
-0.5863431692,
-0.4570438564,
-0.0883447081,
-0.5793566108,
-0.2352181971,
-0.6159748435,
-0.4561354518,
-0.3110239208,
0.6346259713,
-0.6578703523,
-0.4860244989,
0.0926845446,
0.0875976458,
0.2099823803,
0.7053264976,
0.0688341856,
0.3984101117,
-0.8168854117,
-0.0635611042,
-0.0157986656,
0.2273417264,
-0.2623186111,
-0.2010960877,
-0.2627820671,
-0.0164501034,
-0.2948673666,
-0.9464380741,
0.0740080699,
0.210744366,
0.4669618607,
0.191441074,
-0.0557233468,
0.6632427573,
-0.3980538249,
0.8203167915,
-0.2519516945,
-0.7715812325,
0.4301062822,
-0.3724528551,
-0.0882155448,
0.5789061785,
0.2328879982,
-0.4676141739,
-0.4178315699,
-0.9829517603,
-0.8891109228,
0.7291398644,
0.6828312278,
-0.1928397119,
0.127110824,
0.2925026119,
0.039063219,
0.1318097711,
-0.7007430196,
0.10695941,
-0.11467053,
-0.2176723629,
0.2734341323,
-0.3587857187,
0.180960685,
0.3757196963,
0.6003015637,
-0.1051552966,
0.4251755774,
0.2003040314,
-0.1308200657,
0.2382275164,
0.4426833391,
0.1564111114,
0.7682209015,
-0.2855991721,
0.2370078415,
0.0850535408,
-0.6453202367,
-0.3442935348,
0.1842328161,
0.1999444515,
-0.1092013121,
0.6502648592,
0.3637990355,
0.0853965804,
-0.7697813511,
0.7302392721,
-0.2833192945,
0.2051281035,
-0.1478819847,
0.1364472657,
-0.2302002162,
0.3607851565,
0.3829891384,
0.0153122302,
0.3549146354,
-0.3956724107,
0.210547626,
0.529306531,
-0.3186964691,
-0.4409969151,
0.3901957572,
-0.0625870079,
-0.2573831975,
0.7233943939,
0.037537694,
-0.7576065063,
0.4678150713,
0.351885289,
0.5962992311,
-0.082847774,
-0.0284516495,
0.2286499292,
0.4764951169,
-0.1362441033,
0.1774739623,
-0.0546796918,
-0.6734518409,
-0.7551288009,
-0.3488498926,
-0.5057646036,
0.1393791735,
-0.6689296365,
0.2809692025,
-0.0922630578,
-0.1765392572,
0.0933847353,
0.1156882271,
-0.7039709687,
0.0914144814,
-0.224828735,
0.788992703,
-0.7593245506,
0.5553678274,
0.4408734739,
-0.3286928236,
-1.0262818336,
0.1408251375,
-0.0221930314,
-0.9254219532,
0.4863437712,
0.0849652216,
-0.0790418461,
-0.0932109281,
-0.4404617846,
-0.8584644794,
0.7171120644,
0.5157573223,
-0.3904100955,
-0.0435622111,
-0.0243341532,
0.4994404912,
-0.0149797229,
0.4982461035,
0.786637485,
0.3816271126,
0.014339976,
-1.3684169054,
-0.0643598959,
-0.3773237169,
-0.2684990466,
0.0591572858,
-0.7417969108,
0.7402403951,
0.1104631349,
-0.5723698139,
-0.1382014006,
0.244890973,
-0.0505315252,
0.0224877354,
0.4314098954,
0.3328171372,
0.6719505787,
-0.3553598523,
0.876495719,
-0.0848140121,
0.7524844408,
1.1155027151,
-0.1146308333,
0.897036612,
0.2457447946,
-0.351598233,
0.1638700962,
0.7539467216,
0.0023509231,
0.3467675447,
0.0683621392,
0.006068185,
-0.0270583723,
0.0100383013,
-0.3898837864,
0.7730786204,
0.3530469835,
-0.0359357856,
-0.4351196289,
-0.2535912395,
0.1651709229,
-0.4547361732,
0.0936274305,
0.8579239845,
-0.2108998746,
-0.6442661881,
0.2067627907,
-0.1111360192,
0.3510100543,
-0.4574602246,
-0.2275715172,
-0.0853318274,
0.1090520173,
-0.34599033,
-0.9352270365,
0.3049497008,
0.1178974211,
0.1917431206,
0.0698619932,
1.121196866,
-0.1872181296,
-0.172499463,
-0.0700035617,
0.6606912613,
0.5467119813,
-0.2556021214,
-0.5893847346,
0.1164883748,
0.0749426782,
-0.3967713714,
0.1454356909,
0.7030518055,
-0.006283748,
0.5595296621,
0.4110173881,
0.0659852549,
0.1525293142,
-0.1955673695,
0.7921043634,
-0.579790175,
-0.3078402579,
-1.095533967,
0.3924562633,
-0.2286957055,
-0.2583795488,
0.8256870508,
0.7411815524,
0.5190137625,
0.1676587015,
0.8878914714,
-0.4006747901,
0.6477558017,
-0.5605275631,
0.368760556,
-0.1663103104,
0.2134375721,
-0.5764149427,
-1.1076277494,
-0.2262209356,
0.6283650994,
-0.3649004698,
-0.0143105872,
0.6277809739,
0.6933585405,
-0.2062829137,
0.4479046464,
0.1609869152,
0.0988522619,
0.5000252128,
0.704577446,
1.1236748695,
-0.5079196692,
0.8739333153,
0.059470199,
-0.4722641706,
-0.1620871872,
-1.0549385548,
-0.5740140676,
-0.6530100703,
-0.36778,
-0.4050457478,
-0.0386187956,
0.6713291407,
0.8554549813,
-0.6479237676,
0.0820909068,
0.019711405,
0.0869616047,
-0.0620293766,
-0.316619277,
0.5989664793,
-0.3608311117,
-0.6950378418,
0.1548653543,
0.3486117721,
-0.0999584198,
-0.1083812341,
0.3953856528,
0.0158095807,
-0.2649613917,
0.4775473773,
0.3965339661,
-0.3397969604,
-0.5963813663,
-0.0630292892,
0.0638401732,
0.2836664915,
0.8170135617,
-0.3196183741,
0.3687170744,
0.4026567638,
0.8760495782,
0.7192329168,
0.1989771128,
0.4367425144,
-0.7302402854,
-0.1589411497,
0.1548578143,
0.3303800523,
0.3450971246,
-0.3789556921,
0.8370793462,
0.113642849,
-0.7444369793,
-0.74603194,
-0.0107341129,
-1.2353276014,
0.2498380244,
1.2666393518,
-0.4420403242,
-0.1557458192,
-0.3541685045,
-0.5338525176,
0.2100894898,
-0.3712870777,
0.7970357537,
1.055300951,
-0.5293095112,
-0.2905979753,
-0.9773005247,
0.3353362083,
0.1500577331,
-0.7228880525,
0.2315379381,
0.392583251,
0.4298433363,
0.422691226,
0.6016818881,
-0.217302531,
0.0982632041,
0.111170426,
-0.1027314216,
0.052720625,
-0.0647353083,
0.0537135787,
0.367725879,
0.2979384363,
-0.3846241832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14441v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14441v1 | Exploring Contrast Consistency of Open-Domain Question Answering Systems on Minimally Edited Questions | 2023-05-23T18:07:04 | 2023-05-23T18:07:04 | Zhihan Zhang, Wenhao Yu, Zheng Ning, Mingxuan Ju, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Contrast consistency, the ability of a model to make consistently correct
predictions in the presence of perturbations, is an essential aspect in NLP.
While studied in tasks such as sentiment analysis and reading comprehension, it
remains unexplored in open-domain question answering (OpenQA) due to the
difficulty of collecting perturbed questions that satisfy factuality
requirements. In this work, we collect minimally edited questions as
challenging contrast sets to evaluate OpenQA models. Our collection approach
combines both human annotation and large language model generation. We find
that the widely used dense passage retriever (DPR) performs poorly on our
contrast sets, despite fitting the training set well and performing
competitively on standard test sets. To address this issue, we introduce a
simple and effective query-side contrastive loss with the aid of data
augmentation to improve DPR training. Our experiments on the contrast sets
demonstrate that DPR's contrast consistency is improved without sacrificing its
accuracy on the standard test sets. | [
-0.7011727095,
-0.5410054922,
0.3110932112,
-0.107796967,
-0.3088132441,
-0.1255243868,
-0.2145859003,
-0.337300539,
0.0401427075,
0.7201169729,
-0.5315787792,
-0.4748126864,
-0.3441469669,
0.4766627848,
-0.1996325552,
0.8850762844,
-0.0822475553,
-0.025523955,
-0.2768750787,
-0.6693938971,
-0.2366776764,
-0.2219248265,
-0.6529963017,
-0.2812899351,
0.3548640907,
0.3278467059,
1.2213834524,
0.3827707469,
0.5948211551,
0.198524639,
-0.4235645831,
0.4378643036,
-0.6233569384,
0.1163337529,
-0.4057913721,
-0.3459311724,
0.0529148392,
-0.2051560581,
0.609860599,
0.9732646346,
-0.0216647089,
-0.1951795518,
0.4035404623,
0.5437628627,
-0.8602187037,
-0.217585057,
-0.7039664388,
0.1455622166,
0.0021596833,
-0.1496464163,
-0.3803211451,
-0.0610318296,
0.096860297,
-0.779319346,
0.4006300569,
0.0116575314,
1.141256094,
0.4805570245,
-0.324103117,
-0.1157118008,
-0.5946413279,
0.7145882249,
-0.5563349128,
0.3261479735,
0.4808517396,
0.2682963312,
-0.0670007765,
-0.5681308508,
-0.8987373114,
-0.0454519726,
-0.3901510835,
0.2642219663,
-0.1718258411,
0.0644171908,
0.1413422972,
0.4680788815,
-0.5981910825,
0.1388622373,
-0.1347516477,
-0.140475899,
0.4857515097,
0.3392518163,
0.091153428,
-0.09151458,
-0.3528149128,
-0.2693507671,
-0.7301111817,
-0.0013823691,
0.1149630621,
0.3245142996,
0.0738530084,
0.5995650291,
-0.4180104434,
0.7594422698,
0.145589903,
0.3790564835,
0.1398823857,
-0.4137367904,
-0.2952768207,
-0.4384349585,
0.5346320271,
0.3817583323,
0.0719256699,
0.0939645618,
-0.3516703844,
-0.2705490291,
0.073990643,
-0.6937199831,
-0.654234767,
0.2742560208,
-0.2973522246,
-0.1085095778,
0.0765251517,
-0.6851457953,
-0.6721550822,
-0.2927933335,
0.6465210319,
-0.3545017242,
0.0525456257,
0.3655866981,
-0.0977180898,
0.2136252671,
0.7117388844,
-0.7778565884,
0.4925485253,
0.5160963535,
0.5004647374,
-0.1037965789,
-0.0948534384,
-0.7124308944,
-0.2835727632,
-0.4483346343,
0.6122949123,
-0.4739083946,
-0.3649601936,
0.077948086,
-0.1367751211,
-0.0771304965,
-0.9389574528,
0.6621959805,
-0.7959361672,
0.3151105046,
-0.4872006774,
-0.5407235622,
0.1233767867,
0.4994006753,
-0.7601132989,
0.9018934965,
0.0268037859,
-0.995644033,
0.1261101216,
-0.4647163153,
0.0612368621,
-0.0869530067,
-0.341050148,
-0.3341451883,
0.2261112481,
0.5207598209,
0.0572580956,
0.0240514353,
-0.3399029672,
-0.1447815299,
-0.8106673956,
0.4413110912,
-0.2659027278,
0.8294999599,
0.0547809228,
-0.1361736208,
-0.1240291148,
-0.5420369506,
-0.1388012022,
0.1967880875,
-0.3851184547,
-0.6140878201,
-0.1169311404,
-0.2941414118,
0.0931352153,
0.1418345422,
-0.8368416429,
0.1164784953,
-0.2938694954,
-0.0941024795,
0.8317454457,
0.1918099225,
0.3719349802,
-0.3817591071,
0.3390427232,
0.4012817144,
0.0329922028,
-0.1302444488,
-0.3791459799,
-0.9258982539,
-0.0915587917,
0.581436038,
0.3696376681,
-1.1327705383,
0.1907978803,
-0.3171892166,
-0.0922197104,
-0.8853023648,
0.0704981014,
0.3743799925,
1.0073763132,
0.7374108434,
-0.1141460538,
-0.2581961453,
-1.0122747421,
-0.1789388955,
0.08945667,
-0.241635412,
0.4284796715,
0.4708168209,
-0.153695792,
0.7299179435,
-0.8182117343,
-0.133757174,
0.0092344303,
0.0447328687,
0.0509520173,
0.5501691103,
0.3311476707,
-0.8900080323,
-0.5649790168,
-0.2270617187,
-0.6145342588,
-0.0807315409,
0.1918377876,
-0.3437509239,
0.0750886351,
0.4204791188,
-0.3689993322,
0.5477141142,
0.4880928099,
-0.1495028734,
0.4699351192,
-0.0341047421,
0.4053889513,
-0.7465723753,
0.1684203148,
-0.0216605328,
-0.0994619206,
-0.593108058,
0.0379762314,
0.1251041144,
-0.1740956306,
-0.3157705367,
0.8533767462,
-0.1372450292,
0.0310137868,
-0.2040591687,
0.4846276641,
0.558170259,
0.455058068,
0.1362724602,
0.7741296887,
0.2229652256,
-0.524456203,
0.007884549,
0.8827348351,
-0.2300674021,
0.6168241501,
-0.6500988007,
0.4752894938,
-0.3775376678,
0.1641191244,
-1.2503216267,
-0.095530197,
0.2362055033,
-0.3115629554,
0.2005796582,
-0.1142906547,
-0.4033048153,
0.0427825339,
-0.555591166,
0.300858736,
0.5979443192,
-0.8696987033,
0.2974624634,
-0.1993147433,
-0.2113154978,
-1.0544304848,
-0.7981254458,
-0.1579715014,
0.1911944449,
-0.6475450397,
0.3707011938,
-0.2614468336,
-0.5241382122,
-0.0339424759,
-0.3909689784,
-0.2876935303,
0.0662081242,
-0.1155071929,
0.2387302071,
-0.3393701017,
0.2695180476,
0.0885870382,
0.3616452515,
-0.2269101292,
0.197088331,
0.397744298,
0.0124864047,
-0.3683642745,
-0.4468970895,
0.278871119,
-0.0404545851,
-0.3633389175,
0.6381035447,
0.2531631291,
-0.2747845948,
-0.3524827361,
-0.3822465539,
-0.3446153104,
-0.5107344985,
0.1007579044,
-0.6935008764,
-0.9362088442,
0.71719414,
0.3364183307,
0.196970433,
0.4945863187,
-0.1307734996,
-0.4836199284,
0.8602258563,
0.5132546425,
0.3403363526,
0.3898054361,
-0.057194192,
-0.4182115197,
-0.9639911652,
-0.0053601181,
-0.7131351829,
-0.3612721562,
-0.3914533556,
-0.3432482481,
0.3927803934,
0.2666662335,
-0.3626789451,
-0.210298717,
-0.4436005056,
0.6622668505,
0.5615369081,
0.489382267,
0.5659564137,
0.1206141636,
0.0361425914,
-0.2736964524,
-0.6065321565,
-0.4310392439,
1.027459383,
0.0182550158,
0.7993911505,
0.0674547628,
0.8547946811,
0.1496692002,
0.1247570589,
-0.2690600753,
0.5457472801,
-0.3431646824,
-0.4380748868,
-0.3634559512,
-0.5046954751,
-1.0383461714,
0.4746489823,
-0.4601881206,
-0.3346944153,
0.5520170331,
0.38893646,
-0.4288848042,
0.1773909181,
-0.1760884821,
0.9383743405,
0.240540579,
-0.5075090528,
0.1635878533,
-0.8777512312,
0.302326411,
0.1366400719,
-0.3193427324,
0.2422714978,
-0.3097699881,
0.4144380391,
-0.4501289427,
0.5248661637,
-0.1906994432,
0.0618121587,
0.3094656765,
0.2995801568,
0.4473280311,
-0.0872803926,
-0.2769019008,
-0.0504260734,
-0.2816848159,
-0.7091428638,
-0.9526699185,
0.5629874468,
-0.6636555195,
-0.5464841723,
-0.1652427465,
-0.3507670462,
-0.3280729949,
-0.0308273323,
0.1437154114,
0.4680904448,
-0.2003149539,
0.2380672842,
1.2710806131,
-0.3394958675,
0.1153140217,
0.5510101914,
-0.0596291497,
-0.4699903131,
0.5025668144,
-0.1574255973,
0.4268633127,
0.4308046699,
0.2813903987,
-0.4886293411,
-0.9548211098,
-0.566896081,
0.308906883,
-1.0257667303,
-0.1450386196,
-0.4728690386,
-0.127671659,
-0.3204507232,
-0.0804045275,
-0.0297077261,
-0.4427263141,
-0.2269077897,
0.0684298724,
0.0841557682,
0.5948037505,
0.1554675251,
0.1980568767,
-0.8326112032,
0.4540111125,
0.3373451829,
0.2285263091,
-0.3948412836,
-0.9179995656,
-0.1590948552,
0.1690826565,
-0.1977737844,
-0.726052165,
-0.0799896866,
0.3013765514,
0.2792217731,
0.115643926,
0.610081017,
0.5562645197,
-0.2067002207,
0.8781954646,
-0.2400974631,
-0.7528734207,
0.5159758925,
-0.2225916237,
0.4716469049,
1.1242246628,
0.496462822,
-0.3324328959,
-0.2324978411,
-0.692661047,
-0.4929188192,
0.5582942367,
0.2526957095,
-0.0323684402,
-0.0188757814,
0.4046376348,
0.0991902947,
0.3550499678,
-0.49514094,
-0.0944859684,
-0.2739902139,
-0.4044024646,
-0.1467627585,
-0.1440414786,
-0.4101234674,
0.1812438965,
0.5202080011,
-0.199480027,
-0.1755174398,
0.5934717655,
-0.1533499807,
-0.033999078,
0.3319380581,
0.4660373628,
0.4815156758,
-0.327147007,
0.1819534004,
0.0749809742,
-0.4020142853,
-0.0958067179,
0.2861771584,
-0.5035117269,
0.0954639539,
0.1226248741,
0.4489612281,
-0.0316499658,
-0.8514988422,
0.6576158404,
-0.0178189967,
-0.2051982731,
-0.0261958335,
-0.0354599506,
-0.1214400828,
0.1120638624,
0.1345064491,
0.1476206928,
0.2298127413,
-0.4310294092,
0.1429371536,
0.3520789742,
-0.4277743697,
0.004915975,
0.556530714,
0.3030272424,
0.0068083354,
1.0002167225,
-0.0812853947,
-0.3392629921,
0.4525004029,
0.1029165015,
0.5554649234,
-0.0997106731,
0.0362501442,
0.1788290441,
0.3393720984,
-0.069129698,
0.5295836329,
-0.093801029,
-0.8956326246,
-0.3061558008,
-0.4726890028,
-0.92075032,
0.1696569473,
-0.7565996051,
0.2038883567,
-0.4958281815,
0.2743038535,
-0.0186167825,
0.1008179262,
-0.5529094338,
0.6511430144,
-0.0321314186,
0.9585680366,
-0.7557269335,
0.5322943926,
0.6509141326,
-0.7302792072,
-0.5624564886,
0.170658946,
-0.1808055341,
-0.5385586619,
0.4822173417,
-0.0160741564,
-0.0936081707,
-0.1570427567,
-0.6643624902,
-0.3930439651,
0.9096487164,
0.2655775547,
-0.2858891785,
0.2113651186,
0.1690675765,
0.7455990911,
-0.2014831901,
0.1660540402,
0.4264498353,
0.3432853818,
0.1979550123,
-0.7029521465,
0.2148334384,
-0.2468574196,
-0.2436789572,
0.0890212134,
-0.55204916,
1.0423077345,
-0.0442089476,
-0.2210978866,
0.314147681,
0.6206522584,
0.2514836192,
0.4340328574,
0.544890523,
0.614736259,
0.7470315695,
-0.2133136392,
1.0404645205,
-0.0153831327,
0.136761412,
1.4676427841,
-0.4637543559,
1.0618139505,
0.3716263473,
0.048558034,
0.3467686176,
0.4822077453,
0.0951322392,
0.4066150486,
0.3064047694,
-0.3593186736,
-0.321275413,
-0.1271620542,
-0.0646602511,
0.2872337401,
0.0225839056,
-0.3084143996,
-0.0922622457,
-0.1104996204,
-0.0755478367,
0.6071462631,
-0.4390839338,
0.7520322204,
-0.1480074823,
-0.6807789207,
0.9330730438,
-0.3260913789,
0.5773457289,
-0.4757446051,
-0.1883265227,
-0.7118628621,
0.21965684,
-0.2399593443,
-0.9120354056,
0.2642218471,
-0.1623740196,
-0.035982389,
0.0805391371,
0.6250459552,
-0.5637325644,
-0.0023669517,
-0.0185409319,
0.5753955841,
0.1127451733,
-0.212467581,
-0.6700354218,
0.1168594211,
0.0136782639,
-0.240751341,
0.4232923687,
0.3863668442,
0.2798360884,
0.4952477515,
0.1955666244,
-0.1703052223,
-0.0294179004,
0.0858268365,
1.0252132416,
-0.5731844902,
-0.1325148195,
-0.3757996261,
0.7549615502,
-0.385602951,
-0.4062633514,
0.7166289091,
0.6063021421,
0.8460426331,
-0.0787428543,
0.6739163399,
0.3359698653,
0.7768429518,
-0.5910185575,
0.3913840353,
-0.7269065976,
0.4229341745,
-0.0915419906,
-0.7380893826,
-0.3313127458,
0.2987246215,
0.008645637,
-0.1645140648,
0.6466151476,
0.8739472628,
-0.235098362,
0.0374898426,
0.3442924321,
0.2402939945,
0.0792765692,
0.4053795338,
0.9276831746,
-0.6281577349,
0.8116001487,
-0.5023358464,
-0.0478531606,
-0.1718752533,
-0.5161959529,
-0.8737565279,
-0.2132455111,
-0.4950307012,
-0.6819731593,
0.3495547175,
0.6471971869,
0.1732200086,
-0.6959425807,
0.0761234984,
0.204933539,
0.0208229646,
-0.2169395387,
-0.2218375057,
0.4921684563,
-0.324749589,
-0.8614577055,
0.4539662302,
0.0304261819,
0.2252246141,
-0.071647577,
0.0732167363,
-0.1512412727,
0.348056823,
0.2199501246,
0.4329880774,
-0.3978265524,
-0.4077916443,
0.1681334525,
-0.2292256504,
0.3291110098,
0.4964448512,
-0.7235745788,
0.6107493639,
0.6113795042,
0.9880649447,
0.4314568937,
0.4712296426,
0.3167241812,
-0.9468715787,
-0.0892493427,
0.5992167592,
0.3311647177,
0.610457778,
-0.0375717655,
0.6633671522,
0.0432302803,
-0.635102272,
-0.8116473556,
0.3996234834,
-1.1081511974,
-0.3013174236,
0.8461390138,
-0.4345631301,
0.031158302,
-0.2169341892,
-0.2622077763,
-0.233536467,
-0.1968279034,
0.7213116288,
0.541549623,
-0.3017976284,
-0.1191465631,
-0.1948021799,
0.6423586011,
0.6888535023,
-0.6139360666,
0.1478564739,
0.7296184897,
0.26248914,
0.2497133613,
0.6853545904,
-0.0156047335,
0.3270989358,
0.199182868,
-0.125518471,
-0.0903863609,
-0.1025056541,
-0.7986573577,
0.3277433813,
0.0972146094,
-0.3487893939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14434v1 | Domain-Expanded ASTE: Rethinking Generalization in Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction | 2023-05-23T18:01:49 | 2023-05-23T18:01:49 | Yew Ken Chia, Hui Chen, Wei Han, Guizhen Chen, Sharifah Mahani Aljunied, Soujanya Poria, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction (ASTE) is a subtask of Aspect-Based
Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) that considers each opinion term, their expressed
sentiment, and the corresponding aspect targets. However, existing methods are
limited to the in-domain setting with two domains. Hence, we propose a
domain-expanded benchmark to address the in-domain, out-of-domain and
cross-domain settings. We support the new benchmark by annotating more than
4000 data samples for two new domains based on hotel and cosmetics reviews. Our
analysis of five existing methods shows that while there is a significant gap
between in-domain and out-of-domain performance, generative methods have a
strong potential for domain generalization. Our datasets, code implementation
and models are available at https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/domain-expanded-aste . | [
-0.4738213122,
-0.666365087,
0.3420893848,
0.4798119664,
-0.3436749876,
0.329161644,
-0.3808264434,
-0.684938252,
0.3716448545,
0.5951903462,
-0.6164500117,
-0.7300094962,
-0.5260432959,
0.1182205826,
-0.3084927797,
1.1368516684,
-0.2508881688,
-0.064315401,
-0.2592149973,
-0.2785350978,
-0.221716851,
-0.6012247205,
-0.4836688638,
-0.1752777994,
0.0336294211,
0.4563583732,
0.4781906605,
-0.2264880836,
0.6491656303,
0.0971189961,
0.1464369893,
0.1517543793,
0.0029558518,
0.0537717082,
-0.2083525807,
-0.1260534227,
-0.8017533422,
0.1123104617,
0.5109069943,
0.8712075353,
0.0626945347,
0.1942020655,
0.215173617,
0.9795680642,
-0.7045983672,
0.237029776,
-0.3275406361,
-0.1674238592,
-0.0755467564,
0.0909202173,
-0.1059633493,
-0.3412483037,
0.4026208222,
-0.4324716032,
0.7739297748,
0.0470390394,
1.1101280451,
-0.1640651226,
-0.4669322073,
-0.1915464997,
-0.7061994076,
0.8216586709,
-0.4713137746,
0.4731912017,
0.2566586137,
0.06686344,
0.195244655,
-0.664055407,
-0.5022831559,
0.0903976411,
0.0121388249,
0.2141544074,
-0.3382734954,
-0.121906504,
0.0741239712,
0.8483990431,
-0.1516327858,
-0.3610902131,
-0.1474366188,
0.1186257824,
0.756962955,
-0.2995425165,
0.2530369163,
-0.2740719914,
-0.4805431664,
0.0832461938,
-1.1253266335,
0.1086769477,
0.3202202022,
0.265550822,
-0.016185794,
0.4496853948,
-0.301350683,
0.1683763713,
-0.0992683321,
0.7031273246,
0.4887078404,
-0.4385034442,
-0.2493537962,
-0.1235726401,
0.8519313931,
0.6758359075,
-0.0667019561,
-0.2568486631,
-0.3693066239,
-0.0928045958,
0.5255144238,
-0.6670717597,
-0.4021031559,
0.3256327212,
-0.4379052222,
-0.2211767733,
0.3419522643,
-1.0426090956,
-0.2252522558,
-0.0154211521,
0.3268736005,
-0.2979712784,
-0.5804597139,
0.2658972442,
-0.1322838515,
0.2222897857,
0.3734781146,
-0.7402783036,
0.6593396664,
0.9159503579,
0.7757406235,
-0.583183825,
-0.1190539896,
-0.1471803933,
-0.1659709364,
-0.2572422326,
1.0247706175,
-0.6661377549,
-0.6965176463,
0.3877508938,
-0.0338583738,
0.0212994125,
-0.7603872418,
0.8130669594,
-0.8975740671,
0.0612058192,
-0.4251671433,
-0.3298597634,
-0.6226593256,
0.1533854306,
-0.8190731406,
1.0914268494,
0.2861398757,
-0.353128612,
0.6088505387,
-1.0545440912,
-0.6056241393,
-0.0185461733,
-0.1616368145,
-0.7020949125,
0.5558720827,
0.5732460618,
0.2588192225,
-0.567941606,
0.0717459992,
-0.211111322,
0.1533422768,
0.284915328,
-0.0115947053,
0.5505626202,
0.0082453266,
-0.3930311501,
0.1291678101,
-0.5075009465,
0.090889208,
-0.1015254557,
-0.2025981694,
-0.4158973992,
0.0202143192,
0.3368386626,
0.1157594547,
0.3013847768,
-0.8955361247,
0.21693483,
-0.539177835,
0.4305524826,
0.4261627197,
0.2303129435,
0.3759895861,
-0.0087802084,
0.560392797,
0.1208718345,
-0.0160299763,
0.2294102311,
-0.6113292575,
-0.8789587021,
-0.1354148239,
0.4060081542,
0.0787534863,
-0.8495349288,
0.4429241419,
-0.5004353523,
0.0307804197,
-0.4911729395,
-0.0645829067,
0.5822771788,
-0.0221356973,
0.6535851955,
-0.5965580344,
-0.4868671,
-1.0495445728,
-0.4961442649,
-0.0218832009,
-0.0643392876,
0.1435210407,
0.6133009195,
-0.2320800722,
1.1076176167,
-0.7812615037,
-0.3639680445,
-0.3384016156,
0.2176305354,
0.1325917095,
0.3772799373,
0.3758392632,
-1.0323779583,
-0.5912899375,
0.1353979856,
-0.5521636605,
-0.0534466952,
0.318649888,
-0.0133265015,
0.2994739711,
0.2477935106,
-0.4268214405,
0.5510941148,
0.4180859327,
-0.1286721528,
0.5494742393,
0.3012077808,
0.4085939229,
-1.1430270672,
-0.2871692181,
0.3205148876,
-0.1472311914,
-0.7102602124,
0.3808239698,
0.3109837472,
-0.0373027846,
-0.1018721014,
0.3652826846,
-0.625451982,
-0.1293259263,
-0.4958648682,
-0.1836929321,
0.3999116123,
0.5390161872,
0.3189381659,
0.725777626,
0.6138355136,
-0.3482390046,
0.2044444382,
0.2762315571,
-0.2237706631,
0.6298826933,
-0.4634827673,
0.3312045336,
0.2888264954,
0.3339102566,
-0.9272758961,
-0.0441170558,
0.2139483392,
-0.5518698692,
0.3080024123,
-0.3058913052,
-0.3738870025,
-0.2668756247,
-0.6989436746,
0.5544669032,
0.1484954357,
-0.7668979764,
0.8324501514,
0.4889785945,
-0.2587619424,
-0.4971854985,
-0.3542792201,
0.1856966913,
-0.2732258439,
-0.4124867618,
0.5454202294,
0.1336729974,
-0.2545804381,
0.2013944238,
-0.455730617,
-0.153187573,
-0.3388231099,
0.3058513999,
0.3258374333,
-0.4760231972,
-0.1386132687,
0.1686054319,
0.0399632268,
0.359732002,
-0.3368504643,
0.5934656858,
-0.6182767153,
-0.2952846289,
-0.2827156484,
0.7697945833,
0.04986725,
-0.2126772255,
0.3443568051,
0.2107456774,
-0.5164394379,
-0.2790736258,
-0.5553742051,
-0.0562630892,
-0.4229002297,
0.3509072661,
-0.8046640754,
-0.8905976415,
0.4555854201,
-0.1371548176,
0.1113890707,
0.8711799979,
0.380355984,
-0.0617332906,
0.7801774144,
1.0002453327,
0.0026249504,
0.2188448906,
-0.4484740794,
0.3920513988,
-1.2991346121,
-0.074725993,
-0.304797262,
-0.2295926362,
-0.5836716294,
-0.4397857785,
0.1625514328,
0.2266210169,
0.2173013985,
0.5110717416,
-0.3958107531,
0.3604496419,
0.6174853444,
0.2453553081,
0.4502408803,
0.0861215442,
0.3489494026,
-0.0004859503,
-0.1835463494,
-0.3386463821,
1.3025276661,
0.3328095973,
0.3530375659,
0.4121501744,
0.524717927,
0.3956310749,
0.5068174005,
-0.9818015695,
0.3784283996,
-0.540772438,
-0.5184280276,
-0.0052795196,
-0.2102111131,
-0.611350894,
0.2004370093,
0.0945964158,
-0.6682311296,
0.717769444,
-0.1122576147,
-0.6407555938,
0.2730269432,
-0.6496194005,
0.5872090459,
0.1201275885,
-0.2037455142,
-0.1956749707,
-0.3979305625,
0.2397939563,
-0.3211245537,
0.1707216948,
-0.3175700605,
-0.2136800289,
0.9308674932,
-0.3044957221,
0.7439734936,
-0.0862508863,
-0.0863405913,
0.2278542221,
-0.0620483346,
0.1230417192,
0.2709599137,
0.112384297,
0.7897403836,
-0.2766644359,
-0.2459503412,
-0.5424586535,
0.8865501881,
-0.8854944706,
-0.5143119097,
-0.4951450527,
-0.1938012689,
-0.7881943583,
0.0344182551,
0.2734244168,
0.5033297539,
-0.2679643631,
0.0559960715,
0.4845682979,
-0.0546496175,
0.4363423288,
0.6198791862,
-0.1380591393,
-0.6135668755,
0.8489845991,
-0.2371884733,
0.1670898199,
0.497525692,
0.1499709338,
-0.4043962061,
-0.7534034252,
-0.5326849222,
0.0329206288,
-0.6701565385,
-0.3612076044,
-0.8880016208,
-0.2678641975,
-0.6888058186,
-0.1333824694,
-0.5732013583,
-0.554150939,
0.0006127265,
-0.0271185953,
0.3884370029,
0.9161547422,
0.1207491755,
0.524715662,
-0.7037317157,
0.424374193,
0.0859269798,
0.4971426725,
-0.3499687612,
-0.454372406,
-0.2401081175,
-0.1178526357,
-0.2654560804,
-0.7575967908,
0.4934055507,
0.3592974544,
0.2708320618,
0.372445792,
-0.0648531839,
0.4835104346,
-0.4504479766,
0.8907064795,
0.2545827031,
-0.9638608694,
0.6332119107,
-0.219739303,
0.0428478122,
0.7024325728,
0.425436914,
-0.4174352884,
-0.205415979,
-0.969027102,
-1.2441693544,
0.6587457657,
0.403763324,
0.1152189001,
0.1235206202,
0.3804472089,
0.4294163287,
0.540876925,
-0.583347559,
-0.3818251193,
-0.2253400981,
0.0616347939,
0.0143671762,
-0.5329514742,
-0.2261205167,
-0.1764073223,
0.7601546645,
-0.0920773745,
0.4919172823,
0.0979883149,
-0.1186061203,
-0.0504101254,
0.2498409301,
0.2498574555,
0.5068249106,
-0.4454411566,
0.1199792102,
-0.0451567397,
-0.7324876785,
-0.2961834371,
0.285274446,
0.002451869,
-0.1570071429,
0.2380129248,
0.6225072145,
-0.0335350633,
-0.1802883893,
0.7523953319,
-0.171706453,
-0.0936286598,
-0.3974505067,
-0.2527607977,
-0.3937068284,
0.0759630352,
0.3787565529,
0.2901692986,
0.6464746594,
-0.6818410754,
0.4882024229,
0.4347295165,
-0.7084413767,
-0.6090387702,
0.5952267647,
0.4874612689,
-0.0946230814,
0.4025201201,
-0.362434417,
-0.6242300272,
0.4488165677,
0.3716001809,
1.6831223965,
0.0149173206,
0.0933874547,
0.4100211561,
0.1266467422,
0.0600890368,
0.3277341127,
-0.1142904982,
-1.1175804138,
-0.5274230242,
-0.7758098841,
-0.4790310264,
-0.0226786733,
-0.9859582782,
0.1457956135,
-0.3097236454,
-0.1494041234,
0.1990715712,
0.2238730639,
-0.4951665103,
0.3339957893,
-0.0235188082,
0.6114860773,
-0.9655051827,
0.9246835113,
1.0296558142,
-0.6009328365,
-0.4428873658,
0.5578492284,
0.0183530971,
-0.8809829354,
0.4891760051,
0.2480145395,
-0.486920923,
-0.2736830711,
-0.3480626941,
-0.6043839455,
0.5268361568,
-0.3139791489,
-0.2949252725,
0.1540625244,
0.1311107129,
0.4546385109,
-0.7811217308,
-0.0172112808,
1.0194427967,
-0.0090268319,
-0.0692044571,
-0.8714184761,
0.1329130679,
-0.5801889896,
0.0650650561,
0.1888720244,
-0.484805733,
0.7246682644,
0.0776461884,
-0.2307896614,
-0.1581824571,
0.9678855538,
-0.037962012,
0.3336584568,
0.6701904535,
0.395833075,
0.3135426939,
-0.4108754098,
1.0248228312,
-0.1543473452,
0.5007128119,
1.3307673931,
-0.2892114222,
1.0459597111,
0.2772905529,
-0.2943114936,
0.7543914318,
0.611168921,
0.2109987885,
0.5849862099,
-0.1142002419,
-0.530334115,
0.0050203856,
-0.072229512,
-0.3756353557,
0.3161413074,
0.6897842288,
-0.1743448675,
-0.0916827843,
0.0127647696,
0.1093259305,
-0.1481518745,
-0.350526154,
0.8441255689,
0.1310204417,
-0.4542437196,
0.1997413635,
0.0148282899,
0.7437031865,
-0.3535303771,
-0.0001931445,
-0.2221974134,
0.0379689187,
-0.3528512716,
-0.9921243191,
0.4082581997,
-0.0274569392,
-0.3521516621,
-0.335332036,
0.6644257307,
-0.3544194996,
-0.5821896195,
0.1786787361,
0.5082800388,
-0.0432970673,
-0.6894983053,
-0.6107616425,
-0.0832354873,
0.2063176483,
-0.3684051633,
0.073046051,
0.4695861638,
-0.3638037443,
0.2250865102,
0.433753103,
0.152915135,
-0.2346467376,
0.5047935843,
0.9604251981,
-0.7457996607,
-0.3842294216,
-0.7434085011,
0.247366339,
-0.5254494548,
-0.4687173665,
0.8460845947,
0.9166638851,
0.7568747997,
-0.0659875721,
1.0342848301,
-0.24123694,
0.5793402195,
-0.4283066392,
0.4040893316,
-0.5781908631,
0.4684769213,
-0.3195410371,
-1.0762956142,
-0.4478447139,
0.4281276166,
-0.5747138262,
0.1133530661,
1.1609592438,
0.6793977022,
0.0274250954,
0.5730677247,
-0.0010014182,
-0.011474424,
0.4663254917,
0.2276805341,
1.0046401024,
-0.5837407112,
0.0895318091,
-0.4948707521,
-0.3620423377,
-0.2267443389,
-0.681837678,
-0.5460751057,
-0.7425165772,
-0.7318078279,
-0.47954759,
-0.0041577113,
0.8323059082,
0.4819082618,
-1.2124488354,
-0.1882044971,
0.0634230077,
-0.0240018945,
-0.533801496,
-0.2571205199,
0.7641140223,
-0.2762183547,
-0.9446840286,
0.3356611431,
0.4868897498,
-0.2234067619,
-0.1686118543,
0.4921981692,
0.0530530289,
0.1047388837,
0.7528682351,
0.0640389472,
-0.5256423354,
-0.4491607547,
-0.1771814525,
0.2504533231,
0.3370858431,
1.1897153854,
-0.2998282313,
0.3817679286,
0.1714294553,
0.3460172117,
0.4598321617,
0.1673920602,
0.7863845229,
-1.0211904049,
-0.3409120142,
0.2683545351,
0.3223451376,
0.412748009,
-0.2249587029,
0.5818804502,
0.21635665,
-0.3548318744,
-0.5626622438,
0.3781690001,
-1.1869063377,
-0.1471241713,
1.3810633421,
-0.0339085534,
-0.212920934,
-0.3416127264,
0.0216993075,
-0.1868094653,
-0.6447006464,
0.7963023782,
0.550424695,
-0.5534659028,
0.166184634,
-0.7040048242,
0.8675377965,
0.1690314561,
-0.9324715734,
0.314365834,
0.500141561,
0.3311183751,
0.2332227081,
0.9439399242,
-0.2163749635,
0.2479886115,
-0.1572069675,
0.3885920346,
0.355810225,
-0.5425387621,
-0.3790567517,
0.3271458745,
0.0672319978,
-0.4587101936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14342v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14342v4 | Sophia: A Scalable Stochastic Second-order Optimizer for Language Model Pre-training | 2023-05-23T17:59:21 | 2024-03-05T17:07:16 | Hong Liu, Zhiyuan Li, David Hall, Percy Liang, Tengyu Ma | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, math.OC | Given the massive cost of language model pre-training, a non-trivial
improvement of the optimization algorithm would lead to a material reduction on
the time and cost of training. Adam and its variants have been state-of-the-art
for years, and more sophisticated second-order (Hessian-based) optimizers often
incur too much per-step overhead. In this paper, we propose Sophia,
Second-order Clipped Stochastic Optimization, a simple scalable second-order
optimizer that uses a light-weight estimate of the diagonal Hessian as the
pre-conditioner. The update is the moving average of the gradients divided by
the moving average of the estimated Hessian, followed by element-wise clipping.
The clipping controls the worst-case update size and tames the negative impact
of non-convexity and rapid change of Hessian along the trajectory. Sophia only
estimates the diagonal Hessian every handful of iterations, which has
negligible average per-step time and memory overhead. On language modeling with
GPT models of sizes ranging from 125M to 1.5B, Sophia achieves a 2x speed-up
compared to Adam in the number of steps, total compute, and wall-clock time,
achieving the same perplexity with 50% fewer steps, less total compute, and
reduced wall-clock time. Theoretically, we show that Sophia, in a much
simplified setting, adapts to the heterogeneous curvatures in different
parameter dimensions, and thus has a run-time bound that does not depend on the
condition number of the loss. | [
-0.1301284432,
-0.7786269188,
0.5199229121,
0.0773108825,
-0.4580053687,
0.0017984965,
-0.1457847804,
-0.3998337686,
0.3879379928,
0.2465047687,
-0.7308770418,
-0.0610853955,
-0.7430484891,
-0.4566894174,
-0.1309297234,
0.857870698,
0.2315478325,
0.2640695572,
0.4470304251,
0.1056089699,
0.1320290118,
-0.161495775,
-0.9627399445,
0.1384926438,
0.4783946574,
0.3854728639,
0.9132367969,
0.6524910927,
0.3756830096,
0.2768695951,
-0.3871916831,
0.0043812552,
-0.5204110742,
-0.4080800116,
-0.1942683011,
-0.169253543,
-0.5528525114,
0.0160533525,
0.7558651567,
0.6304767132,
-0.42061463,
0.3141064048,
0.0103478087,
0.6601805687,
-0.6217079759,
-0.2683974504,
-0.5033321381,
0.1921093017,
-0.0267098751,
-0.0286597107,
-0.2775544226,
-0.3497597277,
0.2068707198,
-0.5892007947,
-0.0154744247,
-0.0395214483,
1.2534741163,
0.4549447894,
0.0386264883,
0.2061280608,
-0.9523147345,
1.0490373373,
-0.7031616569,
0.3338052034,
0.2119886875,
0.3765929639,
-0.1984381825,
-0.8099928498,
-0.4270265102,
-0.3751565814,
0.377941519,
-0.0370057225,
-0.4048592448,
0.1656503826,
0.1766680628,
0.2069046348,
-0.2906123996,
0.3721102178,
-0.3461657166,
-0.0156257283,
0.2994980514,
-0.0548114739,
0.3038607538,
0.1523361355,
-0.3778399229,
-0.1504383534,
-0.6543409824,
0.1725702584,
0.6534976363,
0.1704359502,
-0.0953207538,
0.1572321057,
0.0875906572,
0.5814080238,
-0.0257648211,
-0.1663831323,
-0.1689870805,
-0.208114028,
-0.0311611816,
-0.5354875326,
0.9016470909,
0.0316196121,
0.1768363416,
0.1330073625,
-0.0043716007,
-0.1086643711,
0.3305737674,
-1.2714027166,
-0.240566954,
-0.1939965636,
-0.4636878073,
-0.3959492743,
-0.3166560829,
-0.5502633452,
0.36366418,
-0.1412168741,
0.4120263755,
-0.5434244871,
-0.1800568849,
-0.0950551108,
0.4963235557,
-0.0532179698,
0.3494417965,
-1.1296447515,
0.5318813324,
0.6543701291,
0.8426590562,
0.1689447463,
-0.2742818594,
-0.6475270987,
-0.2932116091,
-0.8432565331,
0.6779502034,
-0.6075097322,
-0.2839562893,
-0.3659275174,
-0.3413253129,
-0.0071368874,
-0.093234092,
0.4339530468,
-0.5109356046,
0.3753767312,
-0.1171375364,
-0.1807622164,
-0.2298448086,
-0.2410498261,
-0.2809539139,
1.3887250423,
0.3015957475,
-0.6854419708,
0.421127677,
-0.1431673616,
-0.3679009676,
0.0671624243,
-0.2730160654,
-0.6511535645,
0.4681469202,
0.0130121186,
0.0626134872,
-0.4794682562,
-0.0151816597,
-0.4376324117,
-0.4824397266,
-0.2156675458,
-0.1840992421,
0.5486485362,
0.1126926243,
-0.361269474,
0.3290563524,
-0.9083679318,
0.2037449777,
0.1570750326,
-0.6192662716,
-0.2478226423,
0.5467866063,
0.3364782631,
0.261133492,
0.114108555,
-0.3302040398,
0.1411642879,
-0.6299567223,
0.3773876429,
0.7071753144,
-0.3511662781,
0.3850001991,
-0.1800809503,
0.7253518105,
-0.3454961777,
0.3849950433,
0.2706552148,
-0.5417645574,
-0.8317945004,
-0.500138104,
0.2559534311,
0.5526782274,
-0.346904099,
0.2251300961,
-0.302408874,
-0.6167471409,
-0.4516806006,
-0.0137462122,
0.6943015456,
0.4607618451,
0.4872298837,
-0.2942602336,
-0.2629773021,
-1.0398306847,
-0.2759067118,
-0.1805178523,
-0.1722798049,
0.3817772567,
0.3565097749,
-0.1616661102,
0.7264019251,
-0.422147423,
0.0896270201,
-0.4476080239,
0.2398871928,
0.5011604428,
0.5848395824,
0.6871744394,
-0.3301282525,
-0.558355391,
0.0749817342,
0.0000190105,
-0.0244217571,
0.1099224314,
-0.1866925955,
0.1672227383,
0.3967746794,
-0.5409067869,
0.3813329339,
0.6464806199,
-0.2525398731,
0.6998333931,
-0.6959207654,
-0.1943083853,
-1.3657048941,
-0.102603592,
-0.3212785423,
-0.2021993846,
-0.8663082719,
-0.0406959802,
-0.0041978247,
-0.2105184942,
-0.3164412975,
0.1023687571,
-0.3871156573,
-0.3073059916,
-0.2682992518,
-0.2260424793,
-0.1001338288,
0.4964693487,
0.3805740178,
0.8969461918,
0.4124107063,
-0.6368225217,
-0.2306999713,
0.0827203616,
-0.5892495513,
0.2364013046,
-0.8935468197,
0.3330782652,
-0.1468693912,
-0.2839138508,
-0.5839674473,
0.3152291179,
0.2395896465,
-0.3619541228,
0.4083521068,
-0.5529227257,
-0.2698746026,
-0.2179927677,
-0.3446804881,
0.3410610259,
0.5244704485,
-0.3947873712,
0.7809318304,
0.2133615911,
-0.3976947367,
-0.872079432,
-0.5802595615,
-0.0108539192,
-0.0274918079,
-0.6094449162,
0.4474302828,
-0.2151706666,
0.0041698497,
-0.0207875259,
-0.0173459593,
-0.2248583883,
0.172982946,
-0.2717184722,
0.3976873755,
-0.4107734859,
-0.0965170935,
0.1839303672,
-0.4234955907,
-0.1898023933,
-0.680284977,
0.4759457409,
-0.1642341912,
-0.0692741275,
-0.5710722804,
0.4332417548,
0.5640456676,
-0.0604937226,
0.9001950622,
0.5660856366,
-0.3968250155,
-0.455570668,
-0.4217169881,
-0.199865818,
-0.4987926185,
0.9625236988,
-0.6000028849,
-0.7931764126,
0.2199968845,
0.2999175191,
0.0084950048,
0.2139817327,
0.477243185,
-0.0571172312,
0.708057344,
1.0273846388,
-0.3689363897,
0.7821926475,
-0.0932800323,
0.5006079674,
-0.4722708464,
0.252733618,
-0.4261699915,
-0.0436329767,
-0.5941268206,
-0.6975048184,
0.247464329,
0.4649458826,
-0.2433023751,
0.5551204681,
-0.4592220783,
0.4585569501,
0.773880899,
-0.1388815492,
0.0653811023,
0.0797148794,
0.0227314234,
-0.2476036847,
-0.6926177144,
-0.3640268147,
0.8561689258,
0.4870988727,
0.6492590904,
0.2600463927,
0.4877331555,
-0.0765076727,
0.0440159068,
-0.9199365377,
0.3811338544,
-0.1850413233,
-0.4777246118,
-0.3257046938,
-0.5828492641,
-0.4294067919,
0.6026234031,
-0.2777692378,
-0.8127941489,
0.0860361159,
0.4157881141,
-0.7338644266,
0.3287692666,
-0.5426710844,
0.9216781855,
-0.1263676584,
-0.4337863326,
-0.7749513388,
-0.3090759814,
0.1612059325,
-0.0843649656,
0.3159459531,
-0.327867955,
0.0472728536,
0.8312181234,
-1.1654675007,
0.3095027804,
-0.2280541807,
0.3115541041,
0.2182553411,
0.2372228652,
0.7022013068,
-0.0652370751,
0.3427876532,
-0.0557554513,
0.2029629201,
-0.4132951796,
-0.4747722745,
0.139442414,
-0.8097945452,
-0.5077312589,
-0.2399556637,
-0.4445127249,
-0.188203305,
0.1717582196,
0.3447399437,
0.4202317894,
-0.1821911037,
-0.2896662652,
0.4174275994,
-0.2664352655,
0.6241255403,
0.5683579445,
-0.1549730152,
-0.3034581244,
0.7960599661,
0.2135020047,
0.4637907147,
0.3884215951,
0.5830860138,
0.1263582706,
-0.9804406762,
-0.521489799,
0.3509843647,
-0.1854304671,
0.1276285648,
-0.5286134481,
0.0573496819,
-0.1751758456,
-0.2355827838,
-0.9682876468,
-0.7210633755,
-0.27872774,
-0.0207418222,
0.2141913027,
0.5837426186,
-0.177460134,
0.6116640568,
-0.5093877912,
0.0506326035,
0.4210243523,
0.1762143523,
-0.2137733102,
-0.8740881681,
-0.3632316291,
-0.3386509717,
-0.0181269068,
-0.6989400387,
0.316601336,
0.4566815197,
0.1569392979,
0.9374679327,
-0.4302262962,
0.6705597639,
-0.9187238216,
0.2858046293,
0.2750028074,
-0.9935370088,
0.3836252093,
-0.5384879112,
-0.0431540385,
0.647129178,
0.249756217,
-0.4142998755,
0.139790386,
-0.2399916351,
-0.8920027614,
1.186506629,
0.0864316672,
0.2630429864,
0.4137119055,
0.2803308666,
-0.3497154713,
0.1775512695,
-0.7201023698,
-0.207332477,
0.0122264614,
0.0023949633,
-0.0688148662,
-1.0126365423,
0.2701200843,
-0.2992034554,
1.0908700228,
-0.0522386506,
0.1381087154,
-0.2552368045,
-0.0100861136,
0.016514184,
0.3452136219,
0.7120953202,
0.5609843135,
-0.3842459917,
-0.2229391336,
0.4255021214,
-0.6757155657,
-0.0708665401,
0.4283386171,
-0.3721559942,
0.0032599634,
0.2065749764,
0.6903601289,
0.4646788538,
-0.4859152734,
0.700894773,
-0.0271872319,
-0.0371653996,
-0.3269369304,
-0.2803190053,
0.1727706194,
0.2605665326,
0.1628792137,
0.0738384575,
0.0818109214,
-0.2975089848,
-0.0023597137,
0.5004776716,
-0.3723512888,
-0.6074252725,
0.7125311494,
-0.196604237,
-0.5535481572,
0.2733205557,
-0.2533406317,
-0.5325507522,
0.305831939,
0.2900892198,
0.8674181104,
-0.7425884604,
0.1755603105,
0.3525854647,
0.5915659666,
0.0327040479,
0.4750207365,
-0.2684486508,
-0.886991024,
-0.4228267372,
-0.9631393552,
-0.5052472353,
-0.0622752495,
-0.6864153147,
0.249251619,
-1.0795361996,
-0.2624228001,
0.0983315483,
-0.0355093107,
-0.3187720776,
0.2297215462,
-0.0588060245,
0.742554307,
-0.4617536664,
1.2963198423,
0.3795716763,
-0.3032114208,
-0.9069743752,
-0.3281478286,
-0.0598816834,
-0.5807889104,
0.3943709433,
0.020602705,
-0.7797912955,
-0.1172831059,
0.0341484174,
-1.3080860376,
0.518860817,
0.6224585772,
-0.7411549091,
-0.3167701364,
-0.0953984633,
0.4392120242,
-0.3445134163,
0.6356024146,
0.6134166718,
0.062320184,
0.1209421232,
-0.7142282128,
-0.2779475749,
-0.3705609739,
0.6323892474,
0.1782099456,
-0.6161231399,
0.9938248992,
-0.3679160178,
-0.2307510525,
0.2135668397,
0.7921233773,
-0.2261143327,
-0.3143068552,
0.4708167017,
0.8110018373,
0.5815569162,
0.0999355614,
0.8555139899,
-0.6139119267,
0.4280708432,
1.1439982653,
0.1223498061,
1.0450667143,
0.470239222,
-0.5875715017,
0.7241325378,
0.727793932,
0.135291636,
0.5910508633,
0.2704068422,
-0.3276463151,
-0.3619678617,
0.0818262175,
-0.3957415521,
0.231414482,
0.1688082516,
-0.2048160583,
-0.0188123696,
-0.3328597248,
0.516985774,
0.0396437533,
-0.1472620964,
0.3623226583,
0.1755568236,
-0.3674361706,
0.5669204593,
0.3775817156,
0.5721058846,
-0.8572175503,
0.4355560839,
-0.060181044,
0.5673649311,
0.1078265309,
0.2826411724,
0.3593049347,
-0.1755206287,
-0.2040984929,
-0.1513191909,
0.2568099499,
-0.2993991077,
-0.8982077241,
0.6402407885,
0.1284495443,
0.1370566636,
0.1193620414,
-0.610871315,
-0.0851760507,
-0.2302327156,
-0.6711605787,
0.031904541,
-0.2505609393,
0.3083300889,
0.5655548573,
0.6823142767,
0.27805987,
-0.0542974919,
-0.0213256273,
0.7909923792,
-0.4051752985,
-0.8700593114,
-0.7273573875,
0.3248195052,
0.1964989156,
-0.4789009392,
0.5140302181,
0.4469833374,
0.6738315821,
0.0656192675,
0.4224646688,
0.0864638984,
0.7173193097,
-0.5299031138,
0.7519552112,
-0.6049621105,
0.0649676621,
-0.3632246554,
-1.1429108381,
0.0005626624,
0.8931705952,
-0.471624881,
0.2704234123,
0.7799481153,
0.93505615,
-0.1283743531,
-0.1156175882,
0.4105192125,
0.2051499933,
0.0708677843,
0.6396011114,
0.7807604671,
-0.3001321256,
0.4560854733,
-0.2365271896,
-0.4566554427,
-0.0127454596,
-0.5612800717,
-1.1159676313,
-0.2240412086,
-0.244267866,
-0.3692603409,
0.2080949843,
1.1445044279,
1.1401766539,
-0.9372653365,
-0.2442238927,
-0.1138121486,
-0.0105656143,
-0.2117149979,
-0.1040626168,
0.590040803,
-0.449457556,
-0.9360455275,
0.8200690746,
0.4185372591,
-0.034558475,
0.0333115309,
-0.1116167158,
-0.1655472666,
0.4628169537,
0.3352255523,
0.2202241421,
-0.5666044354,
-0.318867594,
-0.3295966387,
0.0677716061,
0.1492355615,
0.6353756189,
-0.3306947351,
0.3530521691,
0.157437101,
0.6670020223,
0.9832000136,
-0.1086495519,
0.3893497884,
-0.3167317808,
0.4699963033,
0.2354388684,
0.4218589664,
0.0210072156,
-0.2307850122,
0.11361745,
0.5175572634,
-0.2693784237,
-0.5100520253,
0.5925443769,
-0.6046235561,
-0.2615165412,
0.691251874,
-0.2671067119,
-0.2784078717,
0.1968052238,
0.1710990667,
-0.0524555333,
-0.2365226299,
0.616132021,
0.3862837851,
0.1434475929,
-0.1763128489,
-0.4201627374,
0.7474392653,
1.083552599,
-0.5296691656,
-0.2263552397,
0.4457766116,
0.4801940024,
-0.0257769693,
0.8012630343,
0.1117537916,
0.3013227284,
0.1784485132,
0.1049128994,
-0.2363477647,
-0.4714276195,
-0.3725702465,
0.1133963466,
0.3127424419,
-0.3630029857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14341v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14341v2 | APPLS: Evaluating Evaluation Metrics for Plain Language Summarization | 2023-05-23T17:59:19 | 2024-01-31T02:32:19 | Yue Guo, Tal August, Gondy Leroy, Trevor Cohen, Lucy Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While there has been significant development of models for Plain Language
Summarization (PLS), evaluation remains a challenge. PLS lacks a dedicated
assessment metric, and the suitability of text generation evaluation metrics is
unclear due to the unique transformations involved (e.g., adding background
explanations, removing specialized terminology). To address these concerns, our
study presents a granular meta-evaluation testbed, APPLS, designed to evaluate
metrics for PLS. We define a set of perturbations along four criteria inspired
by previous work that a PLS metric should capture: informativeness,
simplification, coherence, and faithfulness. An analysis of metrics using our
testbed reveals that current metrics fail to capture simplification
consistently. In response, we introduce POMME, a new metric designed to assess
text simplification in PLS; the metric is calculated as the normalized
perplexity difference between an in-domain and out-of-domain language model. We
demonstrate POMME's correlation with fine-grained variations in simplification
and validate its sensitivity across 4 text simplification datasets. This work
contributes the first meta-evaluation testbed for PLS and a comprehensive
evaluation of existing metrics. The APPLS testbed and POMME is available at
https://github.com/LinguisticAnomalies/APPLS. | [
-0.3152445257,
-0.8190497756,
0.4267081618,
0.349090457,
-0.5160915256,
-0.0880736187,
-0.1648102552,
0.2358164787,
0.0409402549,
0.1770821959,
-0.1389744133,
-0.67406106,
-0.481528312,
0.5576034188,
-0.3463617563,
1.4543668032,
-0.2138126493,
-0.2278895378,
-0.4814690948,
-0.1518124491,
-0.3308600485,
-0.4381071329,
-0.1914644241,
0.0125957988,
0.1121870205,
0.5813837647,
0.8460434675,
0.3205930889,
0.7790411711,
0.2776202261,
-0.2923431098,
0.1696347147,
-0.547518611,
-0.0584226176,
-0.057283245,
-0.1762772799,
-0.9156796336,
-0.0076212804,
0.7807648182,
1.0299239159,
-0.1369679719,
0.5005851984,
0.2410016507,
0.6143254638,
-0.9006605744,
0.1077127755,
-0.312908411,
-0.0513655953,
-0.1584288776,
-0.3262650371,
-0.2592516541,
-0.5789095759,
0.1462859064,
-0.491245389,
0.1963626891,
-0.0437877215,
0.9371273518,
0.1531368345,
-0.2197422683,
-0.5249226689,
-0.5872463584,
0.841781795,
-0.8013163209,
0.0093733296,
0.2211573124,
0.3867045045,
0.1911772043,
-0.8586729765,
-0.355419457,
-0.1906141043,
-0.2146699578,
0.2127768099,
-0.1602478474,
-0.1268293709,
0.174479112,
0.8705819845,
-0.419344306,
-0.584227562,
-0.4436798692,
-0.2875274122,
0.8769136667,
0.5539392829,
0.312253356,
-0.157772705,
-0.3969215155,
0.1295732707,
-0.4370442033,
0.1971864551,
0.4784426093,
0.2079517692,
-0.3576631546,
0.6428610086,
-0.2449705601,
0.552482307,
-0.1098304987,
-0.3464976251,
0.5496287346,
-0.8329997659,
-0.3237769902,
-0.1993684918,
1.0683928728,
0.4440559447,
0.1844521463,
-0.0336666219,
-0.2646920085,
-0.0821420699,
0.039477054,
-0.7122453451,
-0.0390099958,
0.1850269735,
-0.5300671458,
-0.3044101298,
0.3824683428,
-0.6252530217,
-0.3596281409,
-0.1771544069,
0.4033917189,
-0.6126387715,
-0.180138588,
0.4511782825,
-0.2514981925,
-0.0545553826,
0.4060975611,
-0.6219987273,
0.545674026,
0.656416893,
0.7881731391,
-0.1824182719,
-0.6301063299,
-0.4444485903,
0.0251212455,
-0.2911116481,
0.6309123635,
-0.4518644214,
-0.4464470446,
-0.2180764973,
-0.4434259534,
-0.2329684794,
-0.5299578309,
0.9924614429,
0.0740262941,
0.3117067814,
-0.1378783882,
-0.5193941593,
-0.1372374296,
0.079278715,
-0.4944817424,
0.9139871597,
0.2363384515,
-0.9532920718,
0.2977391183,
-0.7827412486,
-0.6746547222,
-0.0657032505,
-0.0239692833,
-0.7159646153,
0.6114509106,
-0.0293202568,
0.2826077938,
-0.2031662762,
0.3781330585,
-0.1489033401,
-0.7058560848,
0.1102521047,
-0.4000300765,
0.3474228084,
0.2799524367,
-0.1043351144,
0.1727669388,
-0.5997476578,
-0.0776344091,
0.0333836749,
-0.4582356811,
-0.5033769011,
-0.0027673361,
-0.2635685802,
-0.2019259334,
0.4785907567,
-0.2457856089,
0.1169553697,
-0.3276647031,
0.2865417898,
0.1593840718,
0.0740815252,
0.5122795701,
-0.3716792166,
0.5320796371,
-0.1753560156,
0.5028793812,
-0.5889183283,
-0.4134765267,
-0.6604450345,
-0.4780650139,
0.5785043836,
0.2777686715,
-0.4194541276,
0.5622906089,
-0.6168698072,
-0.3465257883,
-0.5652591586,
0.131991595,
0.5600773692,
0.2748192549,
0.4372481108,
-0.4350253642,
-0.4750302136,
-0.8733784556,
-0.6794747114,
0.0595023669,
-0.302303642,
0.1788396835,
0.4941579103,
-0.0602948032,
1.2113081217,
-0.2556183338,
-0.34972772,
-0.616701901,
0.5335729122,
0.1222492009,
0.0279366206,
0.3307118714,
-0.6889126897,
-0.6043970585,
-0.3277703226,
-0.6620884538,
-0.5577787161,
0.1181138679,
0.4336461127,
-0.0933517888,
0.4559555948,
-0.3495034575,
0.5985261798,
0.5033610463,
-0.3089613318,
0.7500628233,
-0.2179176211,
0.1714798361,
-0.6080593467,
0.3466085494,
-0.5117796063,
-0.2530029118,
-0.6505349874,
0.0656356215,
0.0624695271,
-0.1949534565,
-0.5140835643,
0.5821073651,
-0.4437548816,
-0.3435986042,
0.0750899836,
0.4315527976,
0.287040472,
0.0014805628,
-0.3425740302,
0.8348263502,
0.2815735042,
-0.6785171032,
-0.1983990222,
0.2364576012,
-0.2712793648,
0.4600661993,
-0.6115937829,
-0.1159582958,
-0.018157931,
0.3094950914,
-1.0967463255,
-0.2568257749,
-0.1411482543,
-0.3972876072,
-0.0341886878,
0.3512316644,
-0.3964830935,
-0.0473258533,
-0.9093084335,
0.4142122567,
0.3263323009,
-0.058743909,
0.6034075618,
0.1795367748,
-0.4185959697,
-0.2419546843,
-0.5817539096,
0.2021265775,
-0.1048106104,
-0.523603797,
0.1178434491,
-0.1917895377,
-0.5296778679,
-0.0955656916,
-0.1898288727,
0.1569408327,
0.2892930508,
-0.102189526,
-0.0069858767,
-0.2354087681,
-0.1648029685,
0.2710466981,
-0.1920215189,
-0.1997355819,
0.3710108995,
0.5759544373,
-0.557677269,
-0.4242384434,
-0.3845641911,
0.1400358528,
0.5193833113,
-0.2432760149,
0.2920795977,
0.4070185423,
0.066908665,
-0.0697734877,
-0.3015313745,
0.1517304182,
-0.4005743265,
0.2173018306,
-0.5632145405,
-0.5435362458,
0.3861066699,
-0.2110666931,
0.203448385,
0.7387192845,
0.3901818395,
-0.0968691409,
0.7412734032,
0.4998104572,
0.289169848,
0.1104929969,
-0.1275677532,
0.1529743671,
-0.8145230412,
-0.0084231738,
-0.3243293464,
-0.2023273408,
-0.0882195458,
-0.3949781954,
0.3808653057,
0.6202218533,
0.1200717166,
0.11799521,
-0.0368116274,
0.5378337502,
-0.0021636353,
-0.3549099565,
0.6642821431,
-0.0915583521,
-0.2532114387,
-0.1220467091,
-0.5988871455,
-1.0265511274,
1.0806219578,
0.4733311236,
0.6223398447,
0.1028928012,
0.7866137624,
0.3864196539,
0.6089832783,
-0.5771982074,
0.6984981298,
-0.563124299,
-0.0849572718,
-0.3809256554,
-0.6555133462,
-0.7517817616,
0.3242323995,
0.0117130093,
-0.3479632735,
-0.243297264,
0.0456561781,
-0.5280584693,
-0.0559885241,
-0.943099916,
0.7838142514,
-0.2247745842,
-0.1208023205,
0.1651969701,
-0.5645372272,
0.5719433427,
-0.0970675647,
0.5097410083,
-0.0244440325,
-0.4796639085,
0.4758536518,
-0.5384567976,
0.6258726716,
0.0821264312,
-0.1963464022,
0.2919843495,
0.2510342598,
0.0708115324,
0.0533704087,
-0.05760286,
0.3594220877,
-0.2120361328,
-0.2172213495,
-0.5570112467,
0.3735305667,
-0.3422064483,
-0.3577403426,
-0.1818421185,
-0.56566751,
-0.1965218037,
0.1737647504,
0.3184098005,
0.3308600783,
-0.4523051679,
0.2921775579,
0.4261552691,
-0.4222535491,
0.4866611063,
0.6441909671,
-0.5015577078,
-0.5547167063,
0.9828904271,
-0.0900702253,
0.4128069282,
0.2709600627,
0.6049974561,
-0.1619321406,
-0.5790279508,
-0.3291400373,
0.1156207919,
-0.526517868,
-0.1435301751,
-0.4293912351,
-0.1593890041,
-0.3476566672,
-0.0642864853,
-0.2702368796,
-0.5107952952,
-0.108854562,
0.1120424792,
-0.3263522089,
0.855650425,
0.179120332,
0.2128976434,
-0.7350732684,
0.3124909997,
0.0796380639,
0.4159221351,
-0.3861297369,
-0.6737495661,
-0.003489902,
-0.1074535251,
-0.3481689095,
-0.752718389,
0.0016801161,
0.5451591611,
0.4704500735,
0.3869800568,
0.0702302009,
0.6012286544,
-0.5709047914,
0.9836931229,
0.2558683455,
-1.439278841,
0.5165900588,
-0.372777909,
0.5082222223,
0.9118428826,
0.0718521029,
-0.3199552596,
-0.6421121955,
-0.8242917061,
-0.8690299392,
0.5180081725,
0.581967175,
0.1737525314,
0.0903685316,
0.363419801,
0.418446213,
0.5982118845,
-0.4945843816,
-0.3520407975,
-0.0751694813,
-0.3749315739,
-0.2828297019,
-0.5109046698,
-0.1435680985,
0.0304114874,
0.3583647609,
-0.0145094227,
-0.0420196615,
0.220771268,
-0.2988730669,
0.0964232683,
0.5142049789,
0.9346724153,
0.8168110251,
-0.1921680868,
0.2141512632,
0.3035166562,
-0.6303479075,
-0.1955260783,
-0.072037898,
-0.4061844945,
0.6046457887,
0.6505421996,
0.7446514964,
0.3894863427,
-0.6050379872,
1.0309137106,
-0.3258974254,
-0.397321403,
0.30051139,
-0.0314539112,
-0.2189180702,
-0.3247054219,
0.2440661192,
0.1156931818,
0.381883204,
-0.5637984872,
0.2007346004,
0.1706775874,
-0.1778213084,
-0.6073123813,
0.3189459145,
0.3672215939,
-0.3777186275,
-0.2789625525,
-0.5098111629,
-0.4890457988,
0.2470176369,
0.1909737736,
0.9416264296,
-0.4922453165,
0.2674328983,
0.219522655,
0.4957195818,
0.1017637551,
0.5587849021,
-0.079888083,
-0.0894751623,
-0.3180119395,
-0.8901568651,
-0.5904432535,
0.3082022667,
-0.4895812273,
0.7393125296,
-0.3397539258,
-0.0717456415,
-0.3269887865,
-0.0156092532,
-0.3011758626,
0.127833575,
0.0427168608,
0.9967095256,
-1.0313572884,
0.2570198476,
0.8788589239,
-0.4289389551,
-0.5077831149,
0.3713807762,
-0.2347072661,
-0.248312816,
0.2531971037,
0.165338546,
-0.1151646376,
-0.2386753112,
-0.1274932325,
-0.6656511426,
1.0144369602,
0.5267872214,
-0.3815654516,
0.1891628057,
0.4007645547,
0.7178421021,
-0.3242619634,
0.5506284833,
0.6593649983,
0.5027740002,
-0.1865909696,
-1.2378227711,
-0.0778774247,
-0.2366361469,
-0.0424171649,
0.1211240068,
-0.467620343,
1.095158577,
-0.238403976,
-0.5029292703,
0.2109677345,
0.3520852625,
0.0872016028,
0.5732245445,
0.477817148,
0.5071643591,
0.6258304119,
-0.1991255134,
1.2503744364,
-0.1949715763,
0.6895228028,
1.3220473528,
-0.2008008063,
0.8296756744,
0.4901510775,
-0.3028413951,
0.4728173912,
0.1738105714,
0.3000797033,
0.4434657693,
0.3655645251,
-0.0042570378,
0.1070508137,
-0.0380557925,
-0.4360964894,
0.2814206779,
0.3181418478,
-0.2978465259,
-0.5780518055,
-0.0986312106,
0.038841445,
0.2342212498,
-0.22512196,
0.9418268204,
0.0150498962,
-0.5205881596,
0.5648314953,
0.2282378227,
0.429302752,
-0.8716169,
0.1647499055,
-0.5967994332,
0.2232866883,
-0.4348866642,
-0.6394168735,
0.4879258275,
0.2961620688,
0.1198717877,
-0.1416580528,
0.6393049955,
-0.4722443521,
-0.2818032205,
0.0286429133,
0.5581563115,
0.2977419794,
0.0109585421,
-0.4916073084,
0.2164468765,
-0.116977632,
-0.3224888742,
0.2096644938,
0.5513483286,
-0.0722561777,
0.3266407251,
0.4894896746,
0.0730946064,
-0.0000410505,
0.4107472003,
0.693149209,
-0.3474058211,
-0.6029242277,
-1.0153558254,
0.5965881944,
-0.1297272593,
-0.5237131119,
1.0913892984,
1.0529948473,
0.4678488672,
0.0090677086,
0.9544044137,
-0.0557348058,
0.5184966922,
-0.3436511457,
0.4954937696,
-0.6005573273,
0.4209947884,
-0.5237827897,
-1.013974309,
-0.3819012642,
0.3473774493,
-0.5076904893,
-0.1267867386,
1.0976284742,
0.1767483205,
-0.2307111323,
0.1523297429,
0.4458515048,
0.2134751379,
0.0038761795,
0.2430811971,
0.9676201344,
-0.6301769018,
0.7802368999,
-0.1096327901,
-0.4519070685,
-0.299233526,
-1.0869709253,
-0.8525161147,
-0.322691977,
-0.297842741,
0.0814166293,
0.0003554339,
0.2172470838,
0.1271160841,
-0.7973700762,
-0.3689744771,
-0.0430422537,
0.019107217,
-0.1740667224,
-0.2668311894,
0.305049181,
-0.7052416205,
-0.6445112228,
0.2418053746,
0.5445896983,
-0.1201836243,
-0.2996559143,
-0.1211776212,
0.1048826426,
0.2845404744,
0.5242438316,
-0.1332970113,
-0.5905501842,
0.0893073753,
-0.146637246,
-0.3110304773,
-0.1448111981,
0.9466174245,
-0.2871235907,
0.4860015512,
0.5850698352,
0.3719405234,
0.01077866,
0.4590550661,
0.5631192923,
-1.0726873875,
-0.1583810002,
0.1158137396,
0.4016597271,
0.5119221807,
0.1072440818,
0.5330656767,
0.1700503081,
-0.1720623225,
-0.9348064065,
0.0528731383,
-0.4921641946,
-0.1523387134,
1.2960003614,
-0.3442885578,
-0.0402104296,
-0.153332755,
-0.3480399251,
-0.0441370271,
-0.2213766277,
0.5816546679,
0.7009749413,
-0.0453531891,
0.3552794158,
-0.3833858073,
0.5886372924,
0.610100925,
-0.9866347909,
0.2326737642,
0.3086439967,
0.2498509437,
0.5987804532,
0.7322759628,
-0.2730772197,
0.3343887031,
-0.1140264124,
-0.0202186387,
-0.2244494855,
-0.3119629025,
-0.6809382439,
0.367752254,
-0.2468836755,
-0.0707600638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14410v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14410v2 | Image Manipulation via Multi-Hop Instructions -- A New Dataset and Weakly-Supervised Neuro-Symbolic Approach | 2023-05-23T17:59:10 | 2023-10-24T20:44:09 | Harman Singh, Poorva Garg, Mohit Gupta, Kevin Shah, Ashish Goswami, Satyam Modi, Arnab Kumar Mondal, Dinesh Khandelwal, Dinesh Garg, Parag Singla | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | We are interested in image manipulation via natural language text -- a task
that is useful for multiple AI applications but requires complex reasoning over
multi-modal spaces. We extend recently proposed Neuro Symbolic Concept Learning
(NSCL), which has been quite effective for the task of Visual Question
Answering (VQA), for the task of image manipulation. Our system referred to as
NeuroSIM can perform complex multi-hop reasoning over multi-object scenes and
only requires weak supervision in the form of annotated data for VQA. NeuroSIM
parses an instruction into a symbolic program, based on a Domain Specific
Language (DSL) comprising of object attributes and manipulation operations,
that guides its execution. We create a new dataset for the task, and extensive
experiments demonstrate that NeuroSIM is highly competitive with or beats SOTA
baselines that make use of supervised data for manipulation. | [
-0.3134265542,
-1.0281395912,
0.5993686914,
-0.0318422765,
-0.3110176027,
-0.1296106875,
-0.0749548972,
-0.789280057,
0.2115231156,
0.6595366001,
-0.9067450166,
-0.6952418685,
-0.7814154625,
0.1464423537,
-0.4357301593,
0.9289442897,
0.06767001,
0.172574982,
-0.3383733034,
-0.1832929999,
-0.5688406229,
-0.4039522111,
-0.7558736801,
-0.2413663566,
0.4067829549,
0.4700707793,
0.7192574739,
0.6900779009,
0.9691787362,
0.3606753051,
-0.1139376536,
0.410064131,
0.0072946674,
0.0843893141,
-0.2687007785,
-0.5632846355,
-0.4380907714,
-0.1736535728,
0.4185507894,
0.7240189314,
0.3178885281,
0.1128046364,
-0.2926973403,
0.5804751515,
-0.5793861747,
0.1533408165,
-0.4509734511,
0.012918517,
0.1059291139,
-0.3911886811,
-0.4082252681,
-0.4634537697,
0.1008812562,
-0.7943364978,
-0.1309649497,
-0.0772206485,
0.8700720072,
0.7660033107,
-0.5304620266,
-0.2516297102,
-0.5973590016,
0.8653729558,
-0.3437883556,
0.0198712554,
0.5516681075,
0.4996585846,
-0.008997784,
-0.8060875535,
-0.2269365191,
-0.1738003045,
-0.1547679007,
-0.17183052,
-0.3765434623,
0.0726660043,
0.641032517,
-0.1580502391,
-0.3734011352,
-0.1088962629,
-0.6260924339,
-0.2142603844,
0.5041681528,
0.4070686698,
0.618670404,
-0.151461646,
-0.7252063155,
-0.0227374677,
-0.6160056591,
-0.0687888563,
0.0297496673,
0.1695979238,
0.0423000157,
0.7640827298,
-0.2907923758,
0.7482582927,
-0.2697972655,
0.0824087188,
0.2191482335,
-0.2752782702,
-0.1152220815,
0.2054785937,
0.6345148683,
0.4781946242,
0.2338958979,
-0.2084017098,
-0.1378381997,
0.3101079166,
0.2302582711,
-0.8000119925,
-0.1689420193,
-0.1725129336,
-0.5159386396,
-0.0910410509,
0.0352583714,
-0.6475788355,
-0.1586403251,
-0.5946061611,
0.5986064076,
-0.7505654097,
0.182658866,
0.2697766125,
-0.2709668875,
0.3958588243,
0.6500236988,
-0.4639796317,
0.6263184547,
0.4210906327,
0.8444057703,
-0.1500244141,
-0.4874013364,
-0.6989363432,
0.2477096468,
-0.4496644735,
0.6973540783,
-0.4706636965,
0.023302041,
-0.5593657494,
0.1133403108,
0.0149081573,
-0.3287661374,
0.269577533,
-0.7292109132,
0.003263955,
-0.1609904319,
-0.2137773633,
-0.5266515613,
0.3851981163,
-0.8117283583,
0.6853058338,
-0.2416722029,
-0.6577121615,
0.1438901722,
-0.8661477566,
-0.7725321651,
-0.1688511968,
-0.1612322927,
-0.0672373399,
-0.0295605697,
0.3388978541,
0.390455395,
-0.232321322,
0.0211638138,
-0.2594498992,
-0.7499950528,
0.2429638952,
-0.3759988546,
0.8464389443,
-0.0793470591,
-0.445969075,
0.1383275241,
-0.47152704,
0.0386110507,
0.2770371139,
0.0613085628,
-0.6487318277,
-0.140416041,
-0.1662784517,
0.5519430637,
0.3147161603,
-0.4279414117,
0.4537565708,
-0.3361141682,
0.4281148911,
0.7523596287,
0.1132219359,
0.5440189242,
-0.0015489848,
0.3925434053,
0.0042072884,
0.2558783293,
-0.1026860029,
-0.3631705046,
-0.7313089371,
-0.2842571735,
0.0805068761,
0.4545246661,
-1.241672039,
-0.0560311675,
0.0408237576,
-0.2786014974,
-0.2271808982,
0.0976150259,
0.4696384668,
0.5421121716,
0.6988216043,
-0.1645751446,
-0.372638613,
-1.0969548225,
-0.0196026973,
0.0590195432,
0.3061656356,
0.2270811945,
0.6061198711,
-0.2161404341,
0.5499879122,
-0.6700308919,
-0.4145750403,
0.0035861195,
0.559525311,
0.255481571,
0.4755845368,
0.4724882543,
-0.8465400934,
-0.1098987684,
-0.1518025398,
-0.8972919583,
-0.0420712829,
-0.3580909669,
-0.28330338,
0.0647682324,
0.8359106183,
-0.8027037382,
0.558350265,
0.0702798292,
-0.1308766007,
0.5615385175,
-0.1166684702,
0.3285531402,
-0.907490015,
-0.1779228002,
0.076594837,
-0.1937473714,
-0.5712876916,
0.1275242567,
0.0427220538,
0.1460087746,
-0.9432551265,
0.2193197906,
-0.6018627286,
-0.2162258178,
-0.4324423373,
-0.1440022737,
-0.1409902573,
0.7549826503,
0.5065037012,
0.454312861,
1.0197681189,
-0.5473240614,
0.261534363,
0.2514411211,
0.1165723205,
0.6885232329,
-0.8249556422,
0.3242396116,
-0.3079281747,
-0.2017528266,
-0.8150818348,
-0.0831807256,
0.3185165823,
-0.3484796584,
0.1905704141,
-0.0334214419,
-0.4943257868,
0.0314572081,
-0.1115152836,
0.4982488155,
0.2119715959,
-0.5699320436,
0.5662610531,
0.0686981902,
0.0674689636,
-0.6457861066,
-0.8788560033,
0.3159851134,
-0.2204883099,
-0.3033745885,
0.2455266863,
0.0332784764,
-0.1765491813,
0.4503309429,
-0.2202839553,
-0.3013705313,
0.187770173,
0.4026488662,
0.5447899103,
-0.0664843991,
0.122004047,
0.1818303615,
-0.4893188477,
0.2446264327,
0.0004826369,
0.3391227424,
-0.4118794203,
-0.6492984891,
-0.6326472163,
0.2346450537,
0.5873196125,
-0.1877880394,
0.2413592339,
0.538015008,
-0.6752977371,
-0.1667572856,
0.2026879936,
-0.5333580375,
-0.4414223135,
0.4363381863,
-0.3637554646,
-0.773917675,
-0.0969753712,
-0.3020940125,
-0.1264028847,
0.2335416973,
0.3058101833,
-0.3008086681,
1.2573029995,
0.5589371324,
0.0330499299,
0.1817668974,
-0.4486302435,
0.0149655994,
-0.5710216165,
-0.1653228998,
-0.3910230696,
-0.8634983897,
-0.2250885218,
-0.5161096454,
0.3775266111,
-0.0152597371,
-0.2291228026,
0.615796268,
-0.5325196981,
0.6946009398,
0.679813385,
0.3215021193,
0.3854857385,
0.0305447578,
0.104881525,
-0.1151934788,
-0.4901690185,
-0.4560671449,
0.835711658,
-0.0196443461,
1.1118949652,
-0.1237873137,
0.5390073061,
0.0895823985,
0.0280552916,
-0.9443786144,
0.904492557,
-0.2906327546,
-0.3838717341,
-0.1746352613,
-0.3787604868,
-0.6922454238,
-0.0102844443,
-0.2313114107,
-0.8807122707,
0.0456778668,
-0.0878873244,
-0.1288885325,
0.4192460775,
-0.5596061349,
0.6717706323,
-0.5605052114,
-0.2767142355,
-0.3765168488,
-0.9899270535,
0.5474553108,
0.1910503954,
-0.1420520395,
-0.0819387212,
-0.1876699477,
0.5054457784,
-0.2694070041,
0.9212003946,
-0.0587540455,
0.4254172444,
0.1208516732,
0.3519833684,
0.0699566379,
0.0566040613,
0.161921367,
0.3924515545,
0.0229241326,
-0.2116438597,
-0.8631124496,
0.4854281545,
-0.6618418097,
-0.2077905387,
-0.5345872045,
-0.8747028708,
-0.1187308654,
0.2219626606,
-0.0415545739,
0.5691875219,
0.2009408623,
0.3563918471,
0.466386795,
-0.0752881989,
0.5052108169,
0.0508171394,
0.0653449371,
-0.2687697113,
0.7452412248,
-0.0591976047,
0.3562919199,
0.442892909,
-0.0353563018,
-0.3144216537,
-0.3729509115,
-0.4759088755,
-0.0454474427,
-0.7831479907,
-0.271891892,
-0.6548099518,
-0.1785591543,
0.2013120949,
-0.2020653486,
-0.2268632203,
-0.5806884766,
-0.2617259026,
0.1370747089,
0.4158326983,
0.5288857818,
0.0110435821,
0.4776043594,
-0.6122455001,
0.8400576711,
0.3831391335,
0.0217153113,
-0.3335054815,
-0.1633474529,
-0.1295573413,
0.1395856887,
-0.1197300106,
-1.1831040382,
0.2685809731,
0.2681888044,
0.5555768013,
0.2048657387,
-0.1894172579,
0.7828665376,
-0.3437378705,
0.550285697,
0.2744001448,
-0.9504069686,
0.8513058424,
0.0590445213,
0.3432820141,
0.4859388769,
0.6594110131,
-0.449698776,
-0.3178528249,
-0.5864705443,
-0.6077031493,
1.0073047876,
0.0360953882,
0.1120283976,
0.1204593852,
0.3152750731,
-0.0692412183,
0.3748777807,
-0.507186234,
-0.3220879436,
-0.0092424368,
-0.0878337249,
0.2109028548,
0.2601550817,
-0.1005015373,
-0.4799859226,
0.5690047145,
-0.6002344489,
0.3259754181,
0.099876903,
-0.3655954301,
0.1342547387,
-0.0657251999,
0.2480720431,
0.4273113906,
0.0860650912,
0.6357326508,
0.2429964989,
-0.4389321804,
0.0920296013,
-0.0772315487,
-0.4598396719,
-0.0597940907,
0.4609098434,
0.832498014,
0.1028270423,
-0.7257282138,
0.4031512439,
-0.2408963293,
-0.5897898078,
0.2587476373,
0.2291508168,
0.1327504665,
0.3437915742,
0.0978392363,
0.6329830885,
0.3214853704,
-0.3119885027,
0.4656873941,
0.4289241135,
-0.5517293811,
-0.2793216109,
0.5800586939,
-0.5693766475,
-0.1614424437,
0.8363798857,
-0.3226485252,
-0.3615418971,
0.968959868,
0.6925032735,
0.6103395224,
0.167061463,
0.5678167939,
0.2618328929,
0.6385379434,
0.1018366888,
0.682420969,
-0.0907811299,
-0.7439060807,
-0.7622602582,
-0.1409257948,
-0.490410924,
-0.0354154631,
-0.6186825037,
0.4123096466,
-0.7775304914,
0.003420756,
0.038899865,
-0.4874053299,
-0.5916647315,
0.2814172208,
0.0624484681,
0.848788619,
-0.9750466347,
0.8069190979,
1.1090686321,
-0.6340415478,
-0.8036572933,
-0.1615524143,
0.1372887492,
-0.6201340556,
1.007811904,
0.2999608219,
-0.2904126346,
-0.1454139352,
-1.0263172388,
-0.6919234991,
0.8371375799,
0.6505031586,
0.0224455632,
0.1260410845,
0.0199500285,
0.449526906,
-0.0721325725,
0.312413305,
0.4410182238,
0.4967916012,
0.3037391901,
-0.2979007959,
0.0587425418,
-0.4761357009,
-0.2440266609,
0.3096261919,
-0.4316352308,
0.7437784076,
-0.2775718272,
-0.1038441062,
-0.0774185732,
0.521282196,
0.2385098189,
0.2894807756,
0.7142602801,
0.6203941107,
0.4407775402,
-0.1946484149,
0.6461212635,
-0.2215491831,
0.1348141283,
1.3013426065,
-0.166481331,
0.5957945585,
0.9632229209,
0.2660842836,
0.4330221415,
0.4679418802,
0.0574470907,
0.5273644328,
-0.1115371957,
0.1286221743,
-0.5331930518,
-0.2951764464,
0.0245373175,
0.8217772245,
0.42150563,
-0.0593198501,
-0.6131606698,
0.0133813741,
-0.2824012935,
0.0638376027,
-0.2832975984,
0.7452941537,
0.2530173957,
-0.2492059171,
0.3764313757,
0.0826686919,
0.497137785,
-0.4497048855,
-0.5158651471,
0.2341321111,
-0.1807876825,
-0.2111033499,
-0.8942295909,
0.7123699188,
-0.0341387428,
0.1503136456,
-0.3908210695,
1.2933530807,
-0.176618129,
-0.4097661972,
0.2518483698,
0.7677783966,
0.3615537584,
-0.0212010983,
-0.9051104784,
-0.1888653785,
-0.3472438157,
-0.1592894047,
0.073031418,
0.3876168728,
-0.3602940142,
0.6795719862,
0.7119062543,
0.1769896746,
0.0511363521,
0.0190919414,
0.8973224163,
-0.6754294038,
-0.3826119602,
-0.8302409053,
0.3069825172,
-0.1711319983,
-0.3308287859,
0.7846717834,
0.3759255409,
0.7490591407,
-0.0408480503,
0.5379015803,
-0.1948875338,
-0.1367843598,
-0.6294898391,
0.2587134242,
-0.7748665214,
-0.1307121664,
-0.4083429277,
-0.8486828804,
-0.5156167746,
0.7568346262,
-0.6123654842,
-0.1635575593,
0.9448960423,
1.0157674551,
-0.364005208,
0.4639453292,
0.1644195169,
-0.1025564373,
-0.1262215674,
0.9399763942,
1.149153471,
-0.396846652,
0.332678467,
-0.5909405947,
-0.0366907679,
0.1784102768,
-1.0123900175,
-0.729880631,
-0.2947963774,
-0.5537053943,
-0.1088102609,
0.0387099721,
0.9614858627,
0.9268259406,
-0.5327441692,
0.0095837926,
-0.1528304964,
0.3278316259,
-0.8516190648,
-0.1495597363,
0.4829210043,
-0.361035049,
-0.8719261289,
0.4391735196,
0.6666857004,
-0.2647379339,
-0.0784910396,
-0.1815993041,
-0.425796777,
-0.2330224216,
0.5663423538,
0.028840052,
-0.2091515362,
-0.1090980917,
0.458073616,
-0.3099585772,
0.1285727322,
0.6391348243,
-0.569909513,
0.3640335798,
0.613042295,
1.0087082386,
0.5550312996,
-0.0676397532,
-0.0043004137,
-0.7332469821,
0.0517048016,
0.2462650239,
0.3622558415,
0.1022594273,
-0.3771698475,
0.3044429123,
0.381947577,
-0.0941560343,
-0.4552149773,
0.2557708025,
-1.1352930069,
-0.603941977,
1.031467557,
0.2152211666,
-0.6840789318,
-0.0283198096,
-0.5185136795,
0.1784454584,
-0.091837272,
0.308303684,
0.3572461307,
-0.4793906212,
-0.343203634,
-0.6596744657,
0.131680578,
0.4658558369,
-1.1607884169,
-0.4660348296,
0.8010846376,
0.0170432255,
0.2776393294,
0.5185238123,
-0.3941639662,
0.6617544889,
-0.2904930413,
0.3842565417,
-0.3153703511,
-0.7871268988,
-0.4496507943,
0.3276415467,
-0.1173838079,
-0.6319484115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14337v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14337v2 | Anchor Prediction: Automatic Refinement of Internet Links | 2023-05-23T17:58:21 | 2023-05-24T07:12:33 | Nelson F. Liu, Kenton Lee, Kristina Toutanova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Internet links enable users to deepen their understanding of a topic by
providing convenient access to related information. However, the majority of
links are unanchored -- they link to a target webpage as a whole, and readers
may expend considerable effort localizing the specific parts of the target
webpage that enrich their understanding of the link's source context. To help
readers effectively find information in linked webpages, we introduce the task
of anchor prediction, where the goal is to identify the specific part of the
linked target webpage that is most related to the source linking context. We
release the AuthorAnchors dataset, a collection of 34K naturally-occurring
anchored links, which reflect relevance judgments by the authors of the source
article. To model reader relevance judgments, we annotate and release
ReaderAnchors, an evaluation set of anchors that readers find useful. Our
analysis shows that effective anchor prediction often requires jointly
reasoning over lengthy source and target webpages to determine their implicit
relations and identify parts of the target webpage that are related but not
redundant. We benchmark a performant T5-based ranking approach to establish
baseline performance on the task, finding ample room for improvement. | [
-0.5161753297,
-0.3551023006,
0.440261811,
0.0082304552,
-0.2999342382,
0.0264044721,
-0.1749601513,
-0.9010565281,
0.0045733456,
0.1898977011,
-0.7137829065,
-0.6027951837,
-0.4111018479,
0.3552086949,
-0.208592549,
0.7762981057,
0.011228987,
-0.0857712477,
-0.4202539921,
-0.0757420287,
-0.3507790267,
0.2708163261,
-0.5987392664,
-0.3334054947,
0.5819330812,
0.5986116529,
0.5672864318,
1.3044849634,
0.7007490396,
0.2979460359,
-0.0016378874,
0.0170147363,
-0.6144090295,
0.0869522616,
-0.7234799862,
-0.4294975698,
-0.3926739395,
-0.0127033973,
0.5229329467,
0.9234127402,
0.2299957722,
0.4449091256,
0.0582137257,
0.8192542195,
-0.6888944507,
0.0687759072,
-0.7002795935,
-0.1714128405,
-0.2890370786,
-0.3138920963,
-0.3279129267,
-0.5590405464,
0.5127569437,
-0.6480188966,
0.6517214775,
0.4789260626,
0.6499868631,
0.6054982543,
-0.6224996448,
-0.073424086,
-0.4191991985,
0.5536754131,
-0.3143196106,
0.4929281771,
0.5927088261,
0.4314934313,
-0.2728937864,
-0.4950131178,
-0.1726806313,
-0.0703912228,
-0.1327479482,
0.0915268362,
-0.0811943337,
0.229857415,
0.3902531564,
0.2030015886,
-0.3650187552,
-0.1686632633,
-0.7843283415,
-0.0241981391,
0.741838932,
-0.124482356,
0.1122635528,
-0.1444849819,
-0.3323915899,
0.0239180364,
-0.7757356763,
0.0736099109,
0.5934993029,
0.2995508313,
0.3349016607,
0.5867189765,
-0.6725707054,
0.6276653409,
0.6817653179,
-0.0375420004,
0.2415565401,
-0.0854706839,
0.3117782772,
0.4925884604,
0.2723997235,
0.6181482673,
0.4855003357,
-0.0993883014,
-0.0029435027,
-0.2097506821,
0.6270013452,
-0.4973181784,
-0.2715291381,
0.4969874918,
-0.5408989787,
-0.0855242386,
0.3493182659,
-0.5397837758,
-0.3733829856,
-0.2125138193,
0.0240848754,
-0.1961690336,
0.0112686343,
-0.2444443405,
-0.4288766086,
-0.2173133045,
0.5093868375,
-0.4911155999,
-0.0581298135,
0.4946356714,
0.4326466024,
-0.16670461,
-0.3495066464,
-0.3263753951,
0.6270642281,
-0.199152112,
1.0584247112,
-0.8394818306,
0.0002073592,
0.3450056612,
0.1472713947,
0.346577853,
-0.1796782911,
0.7691168189,
-0.8558704257,
-0.2510921061,
-0.2064742446,
-0.7363762259,
-0.5242049694,
0.2951587141,
-1.290024519,
0.6309919357,
-0.174720645,
-0.7496187091,
0.4585562944,
-0.5032710433,
-0.5169880986,
-0.1942723691,
0.5379770994,
-0.2509282827,
0.1792067736,
0.293815434,
0.2526531816,
-0.2069814354,
-0.1120654047,
-0.4611988366,
-0.3266078234,
0.0552632511,
-0.0824232101,
0.2901754379,
0.0156006273,
-0.2846862674,
0.0741105899,
-0.6154065132,
0.0520908497,
-0.1154478267,
-0.3181300163,
-0.4492699504,
0.2946643829,
-0.2698367238,
0.0035689902,
0.4647613168,
-0.570500195,
0.172812283,
-0.4107495844,
-0.0894485041,
0.6466647387,
0.2207169831,
0.4081802368,
-0.0425271243,
0.5372110009,
-0.0932885781,
0.1308691055,
-0.4092536271,
-0.5402516127,
-0.7467572093,
0.5542360544,
0.3566055596,
0.1922904849,
-0.5234051943,
0.0641204491,
-0.3473137021,
-0.6582738757,
-0.4842069149,
0.2185971439,
0.6386235952,
0.5977839231,
0.7006074786,
0.0569314063,
-0.5082978606,
-0.5698189735,
-0.5482595563,
-0.158868134,
-0.0240914542,
-0.0136626996,
0.2775275111,
0.12419191,
0.9811721444,
-0.6698259711,
-0.4584142268,
0.0366389491,
0.2900033891,
0.1265227646,
0.3785092533,
-0.0147627611,
-1.0756450891,
-0.8208513856,
-0.0457871817,
-0.7353546619,
-0.1765581369,
0.1776749641,
0.1240430549,
-0.238526389,
0.7385617495,
-0.1274409741,
0.7037299275,
0.4084064066,
-0.2270314395,
0.4456169605,
-0.1080311388,
-0.011166567,
-0.8269543052,
0.1547905952,
0.3350119889,
-0.1244245619,
-0.4084481001,
-0.2557747066,
0.1633952111,
-0.0675734431,
-0.0613085516,
0.7497457862,
-0.8301364183,
-0.2383571267,
-0.3023374081,
0.2424611151,
-0.1313699037,
0.3495603502,
0.1269938201,
0.6078605056,
0.0138031822,
-0.4672255218,
0.3886094391,
0.218949765,
-0.0525355078,
0.3946858644,
-0.7248703837,
-0.0268928315,
-0.176128611,
0.3138033748,
-1.1440593004,
-0.3273904622,
-0.0689771175,
-0.747682631,
0.2428726852,
-0.416526705,
-0.1334472597,
-0.479206264,
-0.3610919416,
0.6763938069,
0.0028926993,
-0.4036026299,
0.3104094863,
0.4473748207,
-0.0896820351,
-0.8412226439,
-0.0627000257,
-0.1639312059,
0.048207432,
-0.6373734474,
0.5073934197,
-0.0335663632,
-0.0578742623,
0.4880873263,
-0.1150936037,
-0.1934983283,
0.0761529356,
0.5158705711,
-0.0959450379,
-0.0741185024,
0.3722231984,
0.1745541692,
-0.6295775175,
0.0176501833,
-0.3624067008,
-0.1016089916,
-0.1392040253,
-0.7067786455,
-0.464119494,
0.0662032291,
0.2988675535,
-0.390447557,
0.3889955282,
0.5582080483,
-0.3769228458,
-0.1454971284,
-0.8091186881,
-0.1871298701,
-0.4790155888,
0.1405911595,
-0.2295220047,
-0.5643768907,
0.3825838864,
-0.3750515282,
-0.2419013232,
0.7159955502,
-0.1102091074,
-0.2363708913,
1.1394797564,
0.9519015551,
-0.1604459882,
0.3477270603,
-0.0585998036,
0.1895569265,
-0.9297018647,
-0.2603912354,
-0.5588808656,
-0.5945242643,
-0.8808546066,
-0.1783718616,
0.3104954064,
0.421063751,
-0.0316864587,
0.5829580426,
-0.508877933,
0.6635709405,
0.7894614935,
0.062157765,
0.5971754193,
0.0963119343,
-0.3214266896,
0.1580694169,
-0.501214385,
-0.4155718386,
1.3856006861,
0.2789905667,
0.6813215613,
0.0508797392,
0.3806302547,
0.6485644579,
0.3563575745,
-0.5149322152,
0.3388539553,
0.1112583727,
-0.7619021535,
-0.4632919729,
0.0498849154,
-1.0648319721,
-0.2748620212,
-0.2506686449,
-0.6488399506,
0.203761965,
0.4111936092,
-0.0514797717,
0.1613827497,
-0.3476428986,
0.6448316574,
0.012869563,
-0.7872571945,
-0.6023616791,
-0.8139484525,
-0.0456945375,
-0.04788078,
-0.2176329941,
-0.1759975702,
-0.054008428,
0.4906414747,
-0.2175971866,
0.6515393257,
0.1062646136,
0.3591662645,
0.4396998584,
0.0516246557,
0.402023226,
-0.046464473,
-0.314315021,
0.3521773517,
-0.2922030687,
-0.3518023789,
-0.4027240276,
0.5273922086,
-0.5294694304,
-0.6361524463,
-0.4678399861,
-0.0868344828,
-0.299880296,
0.4364331365,
0.2438938171,
0.2927406728,
-0.2222437859,
0.3230396807,
0.6284166574,
0.1854672879,
0.5761024356,
0.4613698125,
0.2711220086,
-0.5192079544,
0.533279717,
-0.2165984064,
-0.193896845,
0.5369746089,
0.07353165,
-0.7076904178,
-0.6208549738,
-0.2765564024,
0.3345121145,
-0.9116753936,
-0.4746626318,
-0.1082467735,
-0.1854694933,
-0.1602504104,
-0.4126808345,
-0.3243788481,
-0.18409504,
-0.1939595938,
-0.3146123588,
0.0994528905,
0.9375666976,
-0.264103055,
0.194891721,
-0.8721923828,
0.1166149527,
0.1349568069,
0.4724245071,
0.2244931906,
-0.0398958772,
-0.5491793752,
-0.0723568946,
-0.2250445485,
-0.886021018,
0.1569553763,
0.0327791311,
0.6623942256,
1.0528818369,
0.2959966362,
0.6636351347,
-0.7584536076,
0.3957946897,
0.170050174,
-0.639719069,
0.8173823357,
-0.4654784501,
0.3606210649,
0.8489092588,
0.8681311011,
-0.1930322796,
-0.1263870299,
-0.5726571083,
-0.6659588814,
0.3673531413,
0.1331887245,
-0.2922724485,
-0.0814768597,
0.3385121822,
-0.1119149923,
0.4384869039,
-0.5302935243,
-0.1239383593,
-0.0462889224,
-0.164496392,
-0.0029009141,
-0.577937305,
0.1753700376,
-0.1767174602,
0.6187998056,
-0.3275366127,
0.1392699778,
0.2390528917,
-0.2273278683,
-0.8395997286,
-0.1665856689,
0.3220612109,
1.3526067734,
-0.4780361056,
0.0080401981,
-0.0348401926,
-0.4711252153,
0.0162994154,
0.1111329719,
-0.1898598224,
0.0924365222,
0.7276188731,
0.5231571198,
0.4217371941,
-0.5374381542,
0.5079466701,
0.2692734301,
0.6335090399,
-0.725797534,
-0.085410282,
-0.1374040842,
0.4234009981,
0.5987230539,
-0.0598685332,
0.2966636717,
-0.3423126936,
0.4365172088,
0.1907596141,
-0.7748261094,
-0.4305420816,
0.7747276425,
0.621391654,
-0.3092970848,
0.6897560954,
-0.0048835617,
-0.8309860229,
0.7174001932,
0.4208649099,
1.1718690395,
-0.6157054305,
-0.08370886,
0.9596271515,
0.1389300227,
0.0077828686,
-0.1100200266,
0.0519351065,
-0.582752645,
-0.329964608,
-0.5743396878,
-0.4507280886,
-0.3829627931,
-0.7572660446,
0.3042330444,
-0.3932969272,
-0.2111917287,
-0.0772462115,
0.3068055511,
-0.5620383024,
0.4956280887,
-0.0556336492,
1.2252836227,
-0.7158370018,
0.6225162148,
0.8294451833,
-0.615214169,
-0.4022626579,
0.4287699461,
0.240167588,
-0.6036211848,
0.8280483484,
0.3717467189,
-0.3389518559,
0.0611637942,
-0.4073069394,
-1.0928924084,
1.1954036951,
-0.0934753343,
-0.282961607,
-0.2207119018,
0.1224713326,
0.4148626626,
-0.2628079951,
0.5214278698,
-0.0569147579,
0.5997697711,
0.2349265218,
-0.8971786499,
0.2303876579,
-0.230483979,
-0.0624049529,
0.2015382797,
-0.5564508438,
0.5604267716,
-0.3469395041,
0.0736181065,
-0.1035665572,
0.9037753344,
0.0303156655,
0.4873699546,
0.5277178884,
0.4371393621,
0.6484774947,
0.0561246835,
0.8541371226,
-0.5736450553,
0.0962091461,
1.1177107096,
0.0886684731,
1.246515274,
0.2933425605,
0.1328743696,
0.6767002344,
0.675640285,
-0.1936305016,
0.5007443428,
-0.0916121677,
-0.0769627914,
-0.147713691,
-0.3540104628,
-0.3254139423,
0.4356766045,
0.3372882307,
-0.4134254456,
-0.4310621619,
-0.4380593002,
-0.1415804923,
0.0705942959,
-0.6519939303,
0.6637714505,
0.0517446548,
-1.0309307575,
0.0677741393,
0.044987414,
0.0219122153,
-0.5285763144,
-0.2456073165,
-0.2000566721,
0.3799262345,
-0.3464015126,
-0.8735101223,
0.1128820404,
-0.1632759124,
-0.4124628305,
-0.2208511084,
1.0873605013,
-0.3405405283,
-0.3280023634,
0.315294683,
0.3038054705,
-0.0046928115,
-0.406329155,
-0.5733290911,
-0.1405563504,
0.1499370784,
-0.2123031467,
0.0998377204,
0.5116897821,
-0.1603393555,
1.0855509043,
0.7086276412,
0.0475121029,
-0.057858292,
-0.5565552711,
0.8299276233,
-0.8582146168,
-0.6209722757,
-0.3957041204,
0.6252423525,
-0.44065395,
-0.3535848558,
0.9361718893,
0.5766473413,
0.9661902189,
0.0655110851,
0.5855512023,
0.3630651236,
0.6039978266,
-0.4669746459,
0.5404492617,
-0.6941165924,
0.0723459125,
-0.2678076327,
-1.3553086519,
0.0319477096,
0.394402653,
-0.5105186105,
0.1013296843,
0.8560721874,
0.4288691878,
-0.1995942295,
-0.0666248873,
-0.0379368775,
-0.0783426315,
-0.0996425822,
0.4031823874,
0.5581108332,
-0.2284610868,
0.6746907234,
-0.4982185662,
0.034746781,
-0.7022345066,
-1.2597318888,
-0.9907123446,
-0.6805657148,
-0.4010876715,
-0.1684161872,
0.1968141496,
0.6495023966,
0.7100979686,
-0.8420854807,
-0.3748252094,
-0.0145926559,
0.3574737608,
-0.1930458695,
-0.173038289,
0.6218479276,
-0.2234591842,
-0.6923995614,
0.3532275558,
0.3402996361,
-0.2056623101,
-0.2476376295,
0.1710817665,
-0.4063746929,
-0.187939018,
0.1284507066,
0.4977689981,
-0.8219741583,
-0.2746049762,
-0.1341570616,
0.180589512,
0.0575552247,
0.5192447305,
-0.8359048367,
0.8055394888,
0.6963207722,
0.5386668444,
0.4621005654,
0.8099571466,
0.764380455,
-0.7079665661,
-0.0525058657,
0.1147742569,
0.2379305959,
0.2338891178,
-0.4536199868,
0.8558590412,
0.0620361008,
-0.3060003519,
-0.3298693597,
0.189922601,
-0.7144824862,
-0.2575305402,
0.8883675337,
-0.303419143,
-0.359726876,
-0.2029931396,
0.2301555723,
0.3767000735,
-0.4944594204,
0.791821301,
0.4519304931,
0.0160972886,
-0.1060307845,
-0.5084413886,
0.7553005815,
-0.0076618781,
-0.4639558792,
-0.3696692586,
0.6154114008,
0.2497549057,
0.4835859239,
0.161681205,
0.5151050091,
0.2231284082,
-0.0862605497,
-0.0805867314,
-0.3672265112,
-0.7094256282,
0.0336162373,
0.4307178855,
0.0263793375,
-0.0545676649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14336v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14336v3 | Schema-Driven Information Extraction from Heterogeneous Tables | 2023-05-23T17:58:10 | 2024-03-12T18:54:12 | Fan Bai, Junmo Kang, Gabriel Stanovsky, Dayne Freitag, Alan Ritter | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we explore the question of whether large language models can
support cost-efficient information extraction from tables. We introduce
schema-driven information extraction, a new task that transforms tabular data
into structured records following a human-authored schema. To assess various
LLM's capabilities on this task, we present a benchmark comprised of tables
from four diverse domains: machine learning papers, chemistry literature,
material science journals, and webpages. We use this collection of annotated
tables to evaluate the ability of open-source and API-based language models to
extract information from tables covering diverse domains and data formats. Our
experiments demonstrate that surprisingly competitive performance can be
achieved without requiring task-specific pipelines or labels, achieving F1
scores ranging from 74.2 to 96.1, while maintaining cost efficiency. Moreover,
through detailed ablation studies and analyses, we investigate the factors
contributing to model success and validate the practicality of distilling
compact models to reduce API reliance. | [
-0.012510431,
-0.910102725,
0.6822684407,
0.1405683607,
-0.1235714406,
0.0252533704,
-0.4559683204,
-0.6145108938,
-0.2170092613,
0.739079237,
-0.2216038257,
-0.7657266259,
-0.4280803502,
0.1080197543,
-0.4504962862,
0.8436262012,
-0.0173763428,
-0.229652673,
-0.3761844039,
0.2176453173,
-0.0946345106,
-0.2892808616,
0.2759551406,
-0.2898657024,
0.5321423411,
0.5590102077,
0.5230576396,
1.3740298748,
0.6795336604,
0.194965139,
0.1639430672,
0.1165425926,
-0.2536055446,
0.3761398792,
-0.2876343429,
-0.5873532295,
-0.5304534435,
0.3711575568,
0.5613853931,
0.969593823,
-0.4338319302,
0.441870153,
0.1818518639,
0.5297962427,
-0.5054336786,
0.7275901437,
-1.0926889181,
0.1497315466,
-0.5471078753,
-0.1458395869,
-0.7582533956,
-0.5849485397,
0.1820009947,
-0.6053113937,
0.1149441227,
0.1610910445,
0.9570515752,
0.2297060639,
-0.0655881241,
-0.5758588314,
-0.9923648834,
0.7330519557,
-0.5612729788,
0.7224025726,
0.283806026,
0.4416833222,
-0.0323392339,
-0.9482626319,
-0.4867995977,
-0.2299773842,
-0.1646844149,
-0.1592786014,
-0.2293263525,
-0.2284874469,
0.4897700846,
0.5149234533,
-0.4512551129,
0.1728444248,
-0.4121816158,
0.0359474421,
0.4469045997,
0.2537402511,
0.1073496416,
-0.1011491045,
-0.2585386336,
0.0587471537,
-0.7139472365,
-0.2868607044,
0.34341833,
0.8057350516,
0.0476601608,
0.9875779152,
-0.3359054625,
0.6380291581,
-0.2508308887,
-0.3976920247,
0.1114040837,
-0.233428359,
-0.1038035527,
-0.1260211468,
0.5827445984,
0.0688052922,
0.0829088539,
-0.7142207623,
-0.2579892278,
0.1965001374,
0.1180282161,
-0.6726394892,
-0.395688653,
0.236688301,
-0.3813302815,
-0.296849966,
-0.0812500641,
-1.0912891626,
-0.5370978117,
-0.4774202704,
0.1114121526,
-0.2679736614,
-0.1991912425,
-0.386305213,
-0.3320477903,
0.0956445709,
0.4891214669,
-0.9446584582,
0.4551771879,
0.717024684,
0.9325652122,
-0.7659470439,
0.0121043297,
-0.515599668,
0.304580152,
-0.0637591332,
0.8868345022,
-0.5051653981,
-0.3221771717,
0.0109701045,
-0.2048233449,
0.3400609791,
-0.8894302249,
0.2242799699,
-0.423912406,
-0.072799243,
-0.4762606919,
-0.4541093707,
0.3763588965,
0.0945531055,
-0.9995119572,
1.0148131847,
0.4465884864,
-0.520437181,
0.5556970239,
-0.6192191243,
-0.4790335298,
0.4307391047,
-0.3683398366,
-0.2018378377,
0.0541311055,
-0.22377415,
0.4304179251,
-0.8452914953,
0.2377046347,
-0.3082476854,
-0.0228739846,
0.0194308795,
-0.140089035,
0.6117545366,
0.5980402231,
-0.0595485009,
-0.2064121515,
-0.9955041409,
-0.1842484176,
0.182114169,
-0.9347835183,
-0.2556686997,
0.0161687024,
0.1452471912,
0.3763860166,
0.1902250201,
-0.7384033799,
0.4645296931,
-0.0325467214,
0.3629347086,
0.5862109065,
-0.2472292632,
0.7086215615,
-0.090747565,
0.239735797,
-0.1589947194,
-0.1313819587,
0.0942728445,
-0.08982604,
-0.5331555605,
-0.7051065564,
0.5157814026,
0.5347281098,
-0.6099274158,
0.2532227337,
-0.4150571525,
-0.8669362664,
-0.5256118178,
0.3009535968,
0.0372515284,
0.9521991014,
0.4842530787,
-0.133941263,
-0.3839737177,
-0.9093462825,
-0.5338026285,
0.0881400034,
-0.1468319446,
0.4550329149,
0.2476891577,
-0.0763233528,
1.1053168774,
-0.7037579417,
-0.2837492228,
-0.3301367462,
0.2728071809,
0.2812539041,
0.3740885556,
0.0852698535,
-0.5965417027,
-0.6760681868,
0.3911260068,
-0.9701147676,
-0.5369081497,
0.1631292254,
0.029422611,
0.3155082464,
0.5231177211,
-0.8069140315,
0.3784166873,
0.1177559942,
0.1312961429,
0.6633455753,
0.0307677295,
-0.2010701001,
-0.5663408637,
0.3636872768,
0.2417182177,
0.0881051421,
-0.6867269874,
0.0461266041,
0.1836938858,
-0.1917744428,
-0.4243526459,
0.4399229586,
-0.704102993,
-0.4725159407,
-0.0164591018,
0.2231931239,
0.1501205415,
0.4646325707,
0.1074140146,
0.5264329314,
0.0228010137,
-0.4084922671,
0.275940299,
0.2190657854,
-0.4054779708,
0.4119270742,
-0.3995918334,
-0.0056571583,
0.1074519232,
-0.0545255616,
-0.7895310521,
-0.3410282433,
0.0857990086,
0.1015014276,
0.4276995063,
-0.2056259215,
-0.721904099,
-0.1075595394,
0.0734845027,
-0.2626743615,
0.349335134,
-0.4647261798,
1.0692055225,
0.6877596974,
-0.4320884645,
-0.5235762596,
-0.6876037121,
-0.3014508486,
-0.3941252232,
-0.386431098,
0.4875849485,
0.1239485815,
-0.6095965505,
0.166905418,
-0.427105844,
-0.173439458,
0.3008816838,
0.3130699992,
0.447348386,
-0.0679898858,
0.2400475144,
-0.0253204703,
0.0560331307,
0.0392167717,
-0.0543099754,
0.8762751818,
-0.045802027,
-0.1561783552,
-0.5434167981,
0.4192644358,
0.5663000345,
-0.40183869,
0.4381793737,
0.1619738787,
-0.603595376,
-0.2020475566,
-0.6012713909,
-0.0988280103,
-0.4566192031,
0.4097197652,
-0.5073074698,
-0.4274635017,
0.7995172739,
-0.2805226743,
0.4807111621,
0.6873062253,
0.6128994226,
-0.1147100106,
0.5906762481,
0.520282805,
0.0737742782,
0.3196330965,
-0.1058310196,
0.1579659879,
-0.3127634823,
-0.4015705287,
-1.0812358856,
0.0726407021,
-0.5392659307,
-0.1721599102,
0.2001701742,
-0.2755095363,
-0.036610622,
0.3635755181,
-0.3146058917,
0.3519604206,
0.5303884149,
-0.0499170162,
0.738014102,
0.2529894114,
0.2059179842,
0.0826791972,
-0.5385125279,
-0.6872130036,
1.1868399382,
0.3769016266,
0.904097259,
-0.0027663519,
0.6741495728,
0.4625401795,
0.7140930295,
-0.5704950094,
0.3938224018,
-0.1198678091,
-0.6973654032,
-0.4266655445,
-0.6231814623,
-0.627245307,
0.3601379991,
-0.5290744305,
-0.8079295754,
0.183505863,
-0.0090242103,
-0.0746502653,
0.1215677112,
-0.7084232569,
0.7506258488,
-0.2658632398,
-0.785378933,
0.2096911371,
-0.5453817844,
0.3462599218,
-0.2940374613,
0.4182646275,
-0.3382213414,
0.1187501773,
0.6357076764,
-0.3490948975,
0.2514040172,
-0.2552525103,
-0.1348526776,
0.1378588974,
0.2469067574,
0.4826207459,
-0.309879601,
-0.4932513833,
0.386567235,
-0.0501741245,
-0.1392810345,
-0.549267292,
0.5577527285,
-0.5033168793,
-0.5680946708,
-0.3092502356,
-0.8513358235,
-0.3023641109,
0.3188258708,
0.2805291414,
0.0772670954,
0.0350018293,
0.2633469105,
0.3656384945,
-0.0699493065,
0.2525025606,
0.4761526287,
-0.0137921823,
-0.0340375938,
0.8457548022,
0.5000299215,
0.3046539426,
0.2142941803,
0.1690941155,
-0.3461163938,
-0.6573106647,
-0.3423087597,
0.169598639,
-0.7883282304,
-0.3133252561,
-0.8490709066,
0.0011529276,
-0.4460612237,
0.1428589076,
-0.5217559934,
-0.5522429347,
-0.3152757585,
-0.2273394316,
0.002341968,
0.5581743717,
0.095607914,
0.32330212,
-0.7758690119,
0.0022451882,
0.0996050835,
0.2690636516,
-0.1752184778,
-0.1274071932,
-0.204627499,
-0.315410018,
-0.088327378,
-0.9474271536,
0.4466988444,
0.0801235586,
0.8754082322,
0.1243980676,
-0.0708579421,
0.5594331622,
-0.504760921,
0.5402529836,
-0.0703049451,
-0.8248747587,
0.3077585399,
-0.2901642621,
-0.2087758929,
0.685280025,
0.5014255047,
-0.1906235069,
0.0142182279,
-0.4451887608,
-1.0105068684,
0.7937148213,
-0.0718837008,
-0.3604932427,
0.2751129568,
0.4734245837,
0.5744013786,
0.4048016667,
-0.9277924299,
-0.1544431746,
0.2191106081,
-0.3711106777,
0.2631540298,
-0.1584593356,
-0.1152695939,
0.0639950484,
0.5187049508,
0.0413192436,
-0.0113289552,
-0.096567601,
-0.5129520297,
-0.0817015469,
0.229221642,
0.0241665598,
0.6159650683,
-0.3371673524,
0.209708944,
-0.1968144923,
-0.3522624075,
-0.2168175429,
0.539630115,
-0.1007995978,
-0.0737366453,
0.1943425387,
0.2555879951,
-0.290753752,
-0.7918448448,
0.2430985272,
-0.0494967662,
-0.1023786291,
0.2136631161,
0.0784530938,
0.0124966232,
0.3537465632,
0.5226414204,
-0.5245794058,
0.4054391086,
-0.7109370232,
0.3304237127,
0.447586,
-0.0620304197,
-0.1612157375,
0.609788537,
0.0014827751,
-0.311314702,
0.6549374461,
0.1183257028,
-0.0941659436,
0.2156131119,
0.5530982018,
0.2832510173,
-0.2002172023,
-0.022337351,
0.1446974128,
0.2097946554,
0.0758119076,
0.26435256,
-0.3602519929,
-0.3854646981,
0.028284885,
-0.6461853981,
-0.6362769604,
0.1045414433,
-0.6102723479,
0.314475894,
-0.4308012426,
0.0776418298,
0.5604285598,
0.1566861868,
-0.8024068475,
-0.0471988507,
0.0185834803,
0.9034551382,
-1.0453361273,
0.7541883588,
0.0871107206,
-0.6023375988,
-0.7264143229,
-0.4226151705,
-0.0785471722,
-0.3843507171,
0.546446383,
-0.0488801636,
0.2571616471,
-0.2452100217,
-0.5771086812,
-0.857583642,
1.1005824804,
0.5707526207,
-0.5219805241,
-0.2882806659,
0.5707553029,
0.4267210066,
-0.4853960276,
0.0332508832,
1.0264018774,
0.408549875,
-0.2387577444,
-0.781848073,
0.0934749693,
-0.3583133221,
-0.3611882329,
0.0522952117,
-0.0940658376,
1.3345171213,
0.2224199921,
-0.4617506564,
-0.2048356384,
0.6492584944,
0.3588171601,
0.366917938,
0.4185431302,
0.3052566648,
1.0552903414,
-0.2127409279,
0.7958745956,
-0.1705212593,
0.1294901818,
1.2799106836,
-0.9396551251,
0.7057806849,
0.7627611756,
-0.172088936,
0.6049576998,
0.4059087038,
-0.097182557,
0.668610394,
0.2794139683,
0.0243890248,
0.0002282539,
-0.2075104862,
-0.2969715893,
0.6705705523,
0.5633054972,
-0.4886342287,
-0.4531178772,
-0.3669792116,
-0.080223456,
0.0881780386,
0.1535910368,
0.8375109434,
-0.2320132405,
-0.5231719017,
0.0975365192,
0.0102210101,
0.1683188826,
-0.4809603095,
-0.229228884,
-0.1667473763,
-0.0701278895,
-0.2549691796,
-0.5047115684,
0.1983276755,
0.170611605,
-0.0932840407,
-0.0977411121,
0.8621386886,
-0.5246779919,
-0.1008352563,
-0.0542003773,
0.9341030121,
0.1913093776,
-0.1133923382,
-0.2568132579,
0.2550794482,
-0.0497007407,
-0.291434288,
0.3489380479,
0.4379972219,
-0.0072145998,
0.4090903401,
0.9608310461,
0.1344460398,
0.0516544953,
-0.3679179251,
1.071274519,
-0.6451228857,
-0.47174263,
-0.8411604762,
0.5081682205,
-0.4172359705,
-0.0082116239,
0.6748834848,
0.866497159,
0.5778641105,
-0.1223598048,
1.0108846426,
0.032021489,
0.640267849,
-0.429617703,
0.6448199749,
-0.4105238914,
0.6216816306,
-0.425156951,
-1.1492829323,
-0.4086466134,
0.4382287264,
-0.2843528688,
-0.4295509756,
0.317928344,
0.566473186,
0.0232871883,
0.1972397715,
-0.0792994499,
0.032644406,
0.577383399,
0.0506785847,
0.7041274905,
0.0628930479,
0.4704635143,
-0.4152413607,
-0.302872777,
-0.3125090897,
-0.917034328,
-0.4520373046,
-0.5008536577,
-0.1510621905,
-0.4613013268,
-0.2689988911,
1.0220046043,
0.5405297875,
-0.4632501006,
-0.2665921152,
0.0020897184,
0.1525805146,
0.0919582993,
-0.2596205473,
0.5138007998,
-0.1983579397,
-0.6886392236,
0.2413599044,
0.3702141941,
-0.0919205844,
-0.1550681591,
0.3301731646,
-0.2160099447,
0.0128923636,
0.5082057118,
0.2926708758,
-0.461289227,
-0.0626021996,
0.1866038144,
-0.4135257602,
0.3377949893,
0.5466198325,
-0.4766995311,
0.1779901087,
0.3483917713,
0.6841124296,
0.7390494347,
0.1354564428,
0.3047831953,
-0.6013303995,
0.0352257341,
0.2987073362,
0.360960573,
0.3049218953,
-0.443897903,
0.7849425673,
0.3383843303,
-0.3667254746,
-1.2403466702,
0.1639503539,
-1.0767756701,
-0.3347065449,
1.1684961319,
-0.2199894339,
-0.4958435893,
-0.1812224835,
-0.0050663291,
0.4689812362,
-0.3806396425,
0.8459533453,
0.6283507347,
-0.3344373703,
0.1774401218,
-0.3755760789,
0.490298003,
-0.061181426,
-1.1946018934,
0.6387135983,
0.8226425052,
0.2412629128,
0.4068893194,
0.3999618292,
-0.4787464142,
0.0323776044,
0.1318048686,
0.3638991117,
-0.0985343605,
-0.4952920675,
-0.1662128866,
0.5728351474,
0.0411321223,
0.2289924771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14333v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14333v2 | Automatic Model Selection with Large Language Models for Reasoning | 2023-05-23T17:57:59 | 2023-10-23T14:46:07 | James Xu Zhao, Yuxi Xie, Kenji Kawaguchi, Junxian He, Michael Qizhe Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and Program-Aided Language Models (PAL) represent two
distinct reasoning methods, each with its own strengths. CoT employs natural
language, offering flexibility and interpretability, while PAL utilizes
programming language, yielding more structured and rigorous logic. We introduce
a model selection method to combine the best of both worlds by employing a
large language model (LLM) to dynamically select between them. Our theoretical
analysis underscores the feasibility of this method, which is further
corroborated by empirical results. Our proposed method demonstrates significant
performance improvements across eight reasoning datasets with Codex, ChatGPT,
and GPT-4. Additionally, our method is complementary to self-consistency; when
integrated, it can further enhance performance while significantly reducing
computation costs. Moreover, we achieve new state-of-the-art results on GSM8K
and SVAMP, with respective accuracies of 96.8% and 93.7%. Our code, data and
prompts are available at https://github.com/XuZhao0/Model-Selection-Reasoning | [
-0.59059304,
-0.826832056,
0.8456698656,
0.1942041814,
-0.4001166821,
0.3631543219,
-0.284307301,
-0.6888878345,
-0.0660603642,
0.6627060771,
-0.226511538,
-0.2539732754,
-0.4068353474,
0.0674484149,
-0.2474506944,
0.5615839958,
-0.3666545153,
0.0761187598,
-0.1024909094,
-0.0161421206,
-0.4981424809,
-0.4777466655,
-0.4927489758,
-0.700150311,
0.1063373908,
-0.0766223297,
0.6160213947,
0.5280947089,
0.5945494175,
0.2114828825,
-0.0642263666,
0.4824362397,
-0.0092160851,
0.2974793613,
-0.3105497658,
-0.1548301876,
-0.6218198538,
-0.021343803,
0.5699368119,
0.3891893923,
-0.0584168881,
0.1000619754,
-0.2740501165,
0.5287236571,
-0.7031123638,
0.2016873211,
-0.8776308298,
-0.1028878242,
0.1497807205,
0.1081679389,
-0.6084305644,
-0.3647355735,
0.1265023202,
-0.3251595199,
-0.1962327957,
0.187414512,
0.5946916938,
0.1718857139,
-0.5260495543,
-0.3476607502,
-0.8337255716,
0.7471781969,
-0.6757241488,
0.615195334,
0.4703533053,
0.5497049093,
-0.1288095862,
-0.6049976349,
-0.6196511984,
-0.7491729259,
0.1291098595,
0.0269120336,
0.0375428125,
0.1919365078,
0.3634331822,
0.3885695636,
-0.654812336,
-0.0490872115,
-0.2627693415,
-0.2172399312,
0.7735139728,
-0.128924191,
0.2579447031,
0.0646293461,
-0.3297862113,
-0.0893360078,
-0.8535379171,
-0.3186858296,
0.3770690262,
0.1970029324,
-0.0090996847,
0.5607104301,
-0.2386160493,
1.033334136,
-0.1497226804,
-0.194903791,
0.0457627997,
-0.192301318,
-0.5837267637,
-0.0977287292,
0.9417536855,
-0.0240341555,
0.1970007569,
0.0553119257,
-0.4824520946,
0.2152709514,
0.0417250991,
-0.3590984344,
-0.3811772764,
0.1486885995,
-0.6144412756,
-0.1358701885,
-0.1488195509,
-0.6278601289,
-0.2768834531,
-0.5689915419,
0.1990567148,
-0.1817527413,
-0.4665831029,
0.1567352563,
-0.1152492017,
0.1301995665,
0.4134968221,
-0.8786385655,
0.3803955019,
0.5509477258,
0.7010669708,
-0.2308838069,
-0.123425819,
-0.5212990046,
0.147345677,
-0.6369376779,
0.9316331744,
-0.8719556928,
-0.4512057304,
-0.3650737405,
-0.4089131355,
-0.0872688442,
-0.5031626225,
0.4779919982,
-0.637819469,
0.0005688124,
-0.4043869674,
-0.5501376987,
-0.0817942917,
0.3253253102,
-0.8708274364,
1.2271929979,
0.1501389444,
-0.5438889265,
0.2659634948,
-0.3775022626,
-0.272085309,
-0.1249447167,
-0.3668513,
-0.1513378024,
-0.1241327301,
0.2562893927,
0.2717959881,
-0.7859407067,
0.5111427903,
-0.635330677,
-0.2962092757,
0.1246183887,
-0.5381410122,
0.7617025375,
0.5330098271,
-0.3203165531,
0.0845181271,
-0.7437661886,
0.1791689843,
0.2254238576,
-0.3634071052,
-0.0819545388,
0.1426265985,
-0.1700831056,
0.4970206022,
0.2688860297,
-0.433601886,
0.4340667427,
-0.2482867688,
0.5693182349,
0.6497013569,
-0.3783596456,
0.4326545298,
-0.3085045815,
0.6004061699,
-0.3966393173,
0.1241886392,
0.136151135,
-0.3410459459,
-0.6317250729,
-0.3083190024,
0.3980143666,
0.4087692499,
-0.7354927659,
0.4085220397,
0.0375712365,
-0.3298764229,
-0.3255093098,
-0.0103325015,
0.4039965868,
0.4347698987,
0.3782542944,
-0.2268888205,
-0.58314991,
-0.7955190539,
-0.0277267359,
-0.6144439578,
0.1408720016,
0.3821719289,
0.2893357873,
-0.1112453938,
0.9234988689,
-0.5518383384,
0.267454803,
-0.5723580718,
-0.0934653431,
0.0548422374,
0.2382770926,
0.6150135398,
-0.7528543472,
-0.5175848603,
0.1817076057,
-0.5388559699,
-0.3390475512,
-0.204818666,
-0.4392156303,
0.3392979801,
0.4010508358,
-0.7054444551,
0.4973300397,
0.5146505237,
-0.2832970023,
1.0008269548,
-0.3719261885,
0.1358550787,
-0.7749207616,
0.1733935028,
-0.0208947454,
-0.4444357753,
-0.367293328,
0.1228030473,
0.3124961257,
0.2448991239,
-0.197161898,
0.9018929601,
-0.62072438,
-0.3796421587,
-0.5117667317,
0.1739593893,
0.2540229857,
0.2917299271,
0.2543631792,
0.8017861247,
0.5584414005,
-0.457565695,
0.6063967943,
0.3058587611,
-0.4597276449,
-0.0634107813,
-0.5680545568,
0.1797874421,
0.2054527104,
0.6790444255,
-0.7206827998,
-0.114739567,
0.175800696,
-0.1762687266,
0.0912196338,
-0.259654671,
-0.6502269506,
-0.6333955526,
-0.0241721552,
0.3202262521,
0.425679177,
-0.6571530104,
0.6964641809,
0.5013902783,
-0.0336717665,
-0.4608910978,
-0.5010433197,
-0.0531839393,
0.0445597917,
-0.3651602566,
0.2009490579,
-0.277592063,
-0.3136982918,
-0.3671764135,
-0.3909041882,
-0.0710852444,
-0.0707599148,
-0.1197689399,
0.7743548155,
-0.1769946814,
0.2810155153,
0.2100096494,
-0.0734827518,
0.0498074517,
-0.4150353968,
0.7954395413,
-0.3472980261,
-0.5282270312,
-0.1333248168,
0.3176226914,
0.6919387579,
-0.7356258631,
0.4708946049,
0.2506080568,
-0.1336106062,
-0.4323857427,
-0.7344160676,
-0.0223808587,
-0.4486221969,
0.0752919763,
-0.5848366618,
-0.6496942043,
0.5332468152,
0.0250520706,
-0.0663986802,
0.213705644,
0.699659586,
0.4284725785,
1.3001155853,
0.3651963174,
-0.179604575,
0.5077852607,
-0.102374725,
0.5652854443,
-0.9784097672,
-0.1452308297,
-0.4378339648,
0.1676234156,
-0.5375591516,
-0.437644273,
0.1719683409,
-0.054101713,
-0.5337406397,
0.2212183475,
-0.5818091035,
0.6193216443,
0.4476881027,
0.1161027551,
0.3821249604,
-0.2399022579,
-0.58545959,
0.6263417602,
-0.4844267964,
-0.7228862047,
1.1272753477,
0.1892879754,
0.7282301784,
0.0600944944,
0.2854701281,
0.0729998425,
0.0732005984,
-0.5930084586,
0.8210058808,
-0.1405035555,
-0.6141167879,
-0.1636749804,
-0.4942028821,
-0.6796665192,
0.5550796986,
-0.1760014743,
-0.9502128959,
-0.0036423886,
0.2828971744,
-0.3725410104,
0.441313535,
-0.6893358231,
0.5899687409,
-0.3476474583,
-0.1462382376,
-0.2986424267,
-0.6438551545,
0.459321022,
-0.1703555286,
-0.0772537068,
-0.5040950775,
0.2748095095,
0.2968710065,
-0.1832062006,
0.3247107565,
0.1841551661,
-0.1559957862,
0.4824411869,
0.3468587995,
0.5751305223,
-0.024349872,
-0.4650245607,
0.0378335789,
0.1428648531,
-0.1064354554,
-0.5892261863,
0.7139616013,
-0.7077464461,
-0.6894316077,
-0.3891906738,
-0.6994535327,
-0.3378342986,
0.3891921937,
-0.0090643587,
0.5452273488,
0.0218400396,
-0.0499000065,
0.5483084917,
-0.2373205125,
0.4591854513,
0.3251414895,
-0.6548047066,
-0.2827974558,
0.5813187957,
-0.0026000994,
0.7729613185,
0.2919996679,
0.3065932095,
-0.4286217093,
-0.5430744886,
-0.4681639969,
0.2738127112,
-0.8511509895,
-0.0894543603,
-0.683206141,
-0.4340763092,
-0.3667144477,
-0.1359899193,
-0.4635783434,
-0.438477993,
0.1372007877,
0.0274754465,
-0.0671783835,
0.4907334149,
0.2857477069,
0.0503240041,
-0.5886746645,
0.5975925326,
0.2460690588,
0.4479485452,
0.130543381,
-0.2168930322,
0.1250920892,
0.1666537523,
-0.4128279686,
-0.7991411686,
0.4102414846,
-0.0551857129,
0.747882843,
0.1282184422,
0.1678456664,
0.5291751623,
-0.323207438,
0.5507494211,
0.1553651392,
-1.0490653515,
0.7101498246,
-0.4428563714,
0.315774709,
0.345305413,
0.0441564769,
-0.3021838665,
-0.4064269066,
-0.61517483,
-0.6107879281,
0.506167531,
0.3035633266,
-0.38761428,
-0.1352352798,
0.0964305699,
0.1725351661,
0.1636299789,
-0.6605682373,
0.0242197923,
0.1075015068,
-0.225682795,
0.2909041047,
-0.02100862,
-0.0601516105,
-0.3876324892,
0.7152327299,
-0.3718720078,
0.4684545398,
0.0662047267,
-0.0643265098,
-0.2455446571,
0.0605074652,
0.3658584952,
1.1515204906,
-0.0916039199,
0.076026842,
0.1254633367,
-0.3804802895,
0.0511123464,
0.012349545,
-0.0807770863,
-0.1378649622,
0.2774203122,
1.0705224276,
-0.0271709785,
-0.9126285315,
0.3229767382,
-0.1367677897,
-0.0169745423,
-0.26970613,
0.3703606129,
-0.11257682,
0.4097366929,
0.0493563265,
0.0665006787,
0.0938193053,
-0.5780880451,
-0.0887287483,
0.6231957674,
0.2852503061,
-0.0334080756,
0.6548876762,
0.0867034346,
-0.1277196854,
0.61971277,
-0.2290237099,
-0.4816022217,
0.8905571699,
0.7001487613,
0.7860059738,
-0.1537131071,
0.4169360399,
0.1786869615,
0.138884142,
-0.6634586453,
0.2770851254,
-0.1110507324,
-0.8610581756,
-0.5908535123,
-0.6633729339,
-0.5328234434,
0.1987794042,
-0.5249404907,
0.4806622267,
-0.4905562699,
-0.1054589525,
-0.0491594486,
0.2508256733,
-0.4389687181,
0.2355333716,
0.5944869518,
1.0531414747,
-0.6746607423,
1.2254507542,
0.6152185798,
-0.1322371662,
-1.0481381416,
0.1248130351,
-0.0264645442,
-0.6249921322,
0.3808541596,
0.1420855969,
-0.2917010188,
-0.2035683692,
-0.4325548708,
-1.0787203312,
1.103738904,
0.5453750491,
-0.7293983102,
0.0300688483,
-0.1756340712,
0.4865756035,
-0.6630297899,
0.6403661966,
0.8739343286,
0.282110095,
0.5186131597,
-1.4495483637,
-0.0780856162,
-0.0898917392,
0.1249533966,
0.5370838642,
-0.7703896761,
0.7878249288,
-0.0509498194,
0.1715674698,
0.0465087034,
0.3722265363,
0.8432930708,
0.3260705471,
0.6206015944,
0.2163901627,
0.9845182896,
0.1225659102,
0.8792189956,
-0.4818637967,
0.4663999677,
1.2229627371,
-0.7007519603,
0.9385142922,
0.199526757,
-0.2899856269,
0.5105350614,
0.8101466298,
0.0226125438,
0.5190898776,
0.007494146,
-0.3590139151,
-0.6169497371,
0.3405481577,
-0.3299233913,
0.5907486677,
0.3456887603,
-0.3665571213,
-0.163943097,
-0.2051127106,
-0.1209139749,
-0.2098201662,
-0.2045738101,
0.5476016402,
0.1320288479,
-0.9882512093,
0.6514991522,
-0.0078086792,
0.1669245809,
-0.6439315081,
-0.0025456902,
-0.0118740462,
0.0615846403,
0.1259295493,
-0.7304632068,
0.2290565372,
0.0585328229,
-0.0715431049,
-0.291066438,
1.0888313055,
-0.3892535865,
-0.5236555338,
0.4689988494,
0.5011930466,
-0.0412464254,
-0.0591957495,
-0.736569643,
0.4020007253,
0.0140208611,
-0.2157438695,
0.2829283476,
0.2572216094,
-0.3614598513,
1.0728429556,
0.7908027768,
0.3487857282,
-0.151482746,
0.0583497547,
1.191409111,
-0.5070464015,
-0.7650245428,
-0.9632480145,
0.2438217998,
-0.3438209593,
-0.1526782066,
0.2336224318,
0.4877826869,
0.7538685203,
0.0897883326,
1.0484052896,
-0.2019609511,
0.3518902659,
-0.7101786137,
0.4821300209,
-0.2049820721,
0.6807621717,
-0.1852165759,
-1.164041996,
-0.2136176974,
0.9244456887,
-0.7853819728,
0.0905770212,
0.9279329181,
0.763448,
-0.2263123095,
0.2073023617,
0.2712212503,
0.1134468764,
0.5588712692,
0.6526870131,
0.8053132892,
-0.0840677917,
0.2717260122,
0.0039485288,
-0.2813591957,
-0.2044223249,
-1.0354532003,
-1.0623908043,
-0.5176766515,
-0.2112986594,
-0.2734467685,
0.0535121486,
1.4070211649,
0.8031867743,
-0.577339828,
-0.2596224248,
-0.2325115949,
0.3053579628,
-0.0080580693,
-0.0925961584,
0.2591481805,
-0.3007044494,
-0.5027886033,
0.5123171806,
0.3501494229,
-0.0819767267,
-0.2698897719,
-0.2723305523,
-0.3030200303,
0.3701314032,
0.7497062087,
0.1769362688,
-0.9631974697,
-0.1601092666,
-0.1329890788,
-0.0631179735,
0.1362061352,
0.9150740504,
-0.9002430439,
0.6414161325,
0.6623930931,
0.4004529119,
0.473326534,
-0.0526660942,
0.77902776,
-0.2087179869,
0.0751680806,
0.3441587985,
0.5425158739,
0.1690044999,
-0.2372920811,
0.4808159769,
0.0709096789,
-0.8377206922,
-0.9774516225,
0.4759734571,
-0.9818000793,
-0.4557129443,
1.5213394165,
-0.10120482,
-0.0936292782,
-0.0623786822,
-0.422190994,
0.2544359565,
-0.2323366553,
0.8425040841,
0.8937215805,
-0.3000903428,
-0.2799673378,
-0.6430116296,
0.3510927856,
0.1176214591,
-0.9087401032,
0.1399430931,
0.572483778,
0.1566179544,
-0.2081724852,
0.6550205946,
0.0119330715,
0.2173527032,
-0.058522325,
0.0061102095,
0.0024192126,
-0.447419852,
-0.0189459063,
-0.0676318556,
0.2069069445,
0.1670587212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14332v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14332v2 | Evaluating and Modeling Attribution for Cross-Lingual Question Answering | 2023-05-23T17:57:46 | 2023-11-15T17:15:31 | Benjamin Muller, John Wieting, Jonathan H. Clark, Tom Kwiatkowski, Sebastian Ruder, Livio Baldini Soares, Roee Aharoni, Jonathan Herzig, Xinyi Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Trustworthy answer content is abundant in many high-resource languages and is
instantly accessible through question answering systems, yet this content can
be hard to access for those that do not speak these languages. The leap forward
in cross-lingual modeling quality offered by generative language models offers
much promise, yet their raw generations often fall short in factuality. To
improve trustworthiness in these systems, a promising direction is to attribute
the answer to a retrieved source, possibly in a content-rich language different
from the query. Our work is the first to study attribution for cross-lingual
question answering. First, we collect data in 5 languages to assess the
attribution level of a state-of-the-art cross-lingual QA system. To our
surprise, we find that a substantial portion of the answers is not attributable
to any retrieved passages (up to 50% of answers exactly matching a gold
reference) despite the system being able to attend directly to the retrieved
text. Second, to address this poor attribution level, we experiment with a wide
range of attribution detection techniques. We find that Natural Language
Inference models and PaLM 2 fine-tuned on a very small amount of attribution
data can accurately detect attribution. Based on these models, we improve the
attribution level of a cross-lingual question-answering system. Overall, we
show that current academic generative cross-lingual QA systems have substantial
shortcomings in attribution and we build tooling to mitigate these issues. | [
-0.1462916583,
-0.8057949543,
0.5797874331,
0.2629210651,
-0.2138931155,
0.1794207692,
0.1606250256,
-0.7407459021,
0.1370191872,
0.3183042705,
-0.5933096409,
-0.1287525594,
-0.4880254865,
0.0739380196,
-0.3669878542,
0.7877421975,
-0.2312970757,
0.023245316,
-0.4767401218,
-0.2106563896,
-0.2730052471,
-0.4180049896,
-0.9314974546,
-0.4700273275,
0.6078397036,
0.5649995208,
0.7295985818,
0.3743031025,
0.090637207,
0.1858611554,
0.0193850622,
-0.0705461949,
-0.5393859148,
-0.2802722752,
-0.472076565,
-0.6875942349,
-0.2838146389,
-0.0126874177,
0.5745475292,
0.5647063851,
-0.0556139201,
0.3895313144,
-0.1471686959,
0.3075173497,
-0.7521471977,
-0.0605733655,
-0.7370155454,
0.0249982998,
-0.1789771467,
-0.4799485803,
-0.451602906,
-0.6154168248,
0.1256711781,
-0.7729286551,
0.1180455387,
0.1238259226,
0.9920734763,
-0.0654250234,
-0.5328425765,
-0.3845464587,
-0.5051980019,
0.9743262529,
-0.5644184351,
0.4827537835,
0.6682955027,
0.1936926544,
0.4697333872,
-0.4400254488,
-0.4423479736,
0.0357229672,
-0.111402601,
0.0614704825,
-0.3587501347,
-0.6161677837,
-0.1612030268,
0.2212694734,
-0.7584836483,
0.0374849886,
-0.2253445238,
-0.4489679635,
0.6431362629,
-0.0132377511,
0.5578520298,
-0.3285740018,
-0.5568527579,
-0.1950984001,
-0.9424563646,
0.1616439074,
0.5334973335,
0.0642881393,
-0.0373537056,
0.6581456661,
0.068897225,
0.4177577496,
0.1232193336,
0.1776826829,
-0.0593284667,
-0.6877401471,
0.0745868906,
0.2560560703,
0.7448558807,
0.2854444981,
0.6929979324,
-0.3087644577,
-0.1489013284,
-0.2047684044,
0.2015246749,
-0.632873714,
-0.1822067648,
0.0348186307,
-0.4165487289,
-0.329446286,
-0.1512309015,
-0.5333787799,
-0.3061635494,
0.1499514878,
0.3908180594,
-0.44575423,
-0.5611160994,
-0.0935530588,
0.0037872409,
0.5421618223,
0.2210790366,
-0.8073749542,
0.2699906826,
0.5553972125,
0.6113561988,
-0.3058852553,
-0.3141882718,
-0.5972635746,
0.2540834248,
-0.5483132601,
0.7556707263,
-0.6298846006,
-0.3603700995,
0.1050916389,
0.0933639929,
-0.1311275661,
-0.7354633212,
0.5571408868,
-1.1018009186,
0.5128862858,
-0.5592775345,
-0.5024530888,
-0.1942504644,
0.4242917001,
-0.7601853609,
0.8659117818,
0.258815676,
-0.8267203569,
0.2881181836,
-0.5099871755,
-0.488230437,
-0.0580927096,
0.0671053156,
-0.1626740694,
-0.0346253216,
0.3836022615,
0.0515639186,
-0.5295443535,
0.1688146591,
-0.1542736143,
-0.1975593269,
0.5237575173,
-0.6858723164,
1.385859251,
0.155373767,
0.0015348453,
-0.0971249267,
-0.6001134515,
0.2931160331,
0.2679719031,
-0.2705387771,
-0.758227706,
-0.3263089955,
0.2569747865,
0.2368765175,
0.3266754746,
-0.831864953,
-0.2706377804,
-0.2467618138,
0.1396895051,
0.4617764652,
0.0243108459,
0.4211550355,
-0.1035036966,
0.9453644753,
0.1598111242,
-0.0890008062,
0.316075474,
-0.4218616188,
-0.3481561542,
0.0809129924,
0.3513159454,
0.9046271443,
-1.128007412,
-0.0174571369,
-0.5170102119,
-0.4444465339,
-0.6927545667,
0.3118920326,
0.8664276004,
0.5898550153,
0.336663574,
-0.5378846526,
-0.2299862057,
-0.8875730634,
-0.5899064541,
-0.701315999,
-0.2216593176,
0.3790116608,
0.32694453,
0.2010062933,
0.9334101677,
-0.4161661863,
0.020577522,
-0.1963860095,
0.245427683,
-0.3687612414,
0.450876385,
0.6758995056,
-0.9305919409,
-0.7794058323,
0.0751765594,
-0.750967443,
-0.2688044608,
0.1208090186,
-0.2080299854,
0.2174637467,
0.3790854216,
-0.532500267,
-0.0137696825,
0.6207281947,
-0.5555521846,
0.606112361,
0.0885713845,
0.3023252785,
-0.9731474519,
0.2849734724,
0.0284336898,
-0.2318897545,
-0.4747446179,
0.1418930292,
0.2645412087,
-0.066820249,
-0.7433417439,
0.8499690294,
-0.4506864548,
-0.245964095,
0.0147010079,
0.1923588216,
0.321475476,
0.441829294,
0.1908008307,
0.9073975086,
0.3543893993,
-0.2769082487,
0.6155585647,
0.4307562709,
-0.4425120354,
0.8526596427,
-0.884041667,
-0.0078409631,
0.0546217971,
0.2061612755,
-0.9382737279,
-0.0781130344,
0.3509848416,
-0.76093328,
0.1719587147,
-0.373252064,
-0.5769476295,
0.0184554905,
-0.1143084094,
0.8857664466,
0.1431194842,
-0.4814944565,
0.5769706964,
0.1917873025,
-0.5825589895,
-0.58063519,
-0.8041049242,
0.0165731795,
-0.2974790037,
-0.8354562521,
0.2802894711,
0.1328274757,
-0.2399561405,
0.2198759168,
-0.0976455286,
-0.4134358168,
0.0500024185,
-0.3888274729,
0.2905814648,
-0.4758702815,
0.0294921454,
0.0258964729,
-0.1905725896,
0.5359179974,
0.0157269575,
0.3627937436,
-0.0279069021,
-0.6085556746,
-0.1779536903,
0.6478163004,
0.360368371,
-0.6123282909,
0.7115348577,
0.6981993318,
-0.3895006776,
0.0973035544,
-0.4053511024,
-0.3103505373,
-0.4270553291,
0.4874637425,
-0.4303043485,
-0.599512279,
0.912746489,
0.5609139204,
-0.039062798,
0.4563295841,
0.4710512757,
0.1617450118,
1.0160312653,
0.5674547553,
-0.0393052585,
0.3040896058,
0.1440782547,
0.1145124212,
-0.5292119384,
-0.2244920135,
-0.5835593939,
0.0156985633,
-0.4290521741,
-0.3887389898,
0.2906650007,
-0.0529929213,
-0.0343637653,
0.2514735162,
-0.0131219868,
0.4502597153,
0.5646109581,
0.0056927563,
0.4957202077,
-0.0414635986,
0.1242560968,
0.0229887795,
-0.9353716969,
-0.373049587,
0.8566614389,
0.4044531882,
0.9628627896,
0.3321478069,
0.3581504226,
0.0933545828,
0.4374343455,
-0.4920216501,
0.3440891802,
-0.088028878,
-1.0044851303,
-0.522180438,
-0.5958844423,
-0.7738878727,
0.2090238333,
0.1206949949,
-0.7145805955,
0.2420791239,
0.1828595251,
-0.4584448636,
0.240031451,
-0.8129966855,
1.3282176256,
-0.2149840295,
-0.5875843167,
0.0320057757,
-0.7428933978,
0.5056525469,
-0.1366879493,
-0.0010776585,
0.0705692396,
0.0418940596,
0.9944658875,
-0.0991540402,
0.8610772491,
-0.1879392564,
-0.8028311133,
0.5055670142,
0.2906317711,
0.5513299108,
0.2608237863,
-0.2472140938,
-0.1401147246,
0.3622376025,
-0.5890623331,
-0.769094944,
0.7378332019,
-0.7728366852,
-0.3577905595,
-0.2006227821,
-0.5150437951,
-0.4449420869,
0.0839888528,
0.3861889839,
0.2999048829,
-0.2693755627,
0.0063651293,
0.8566457629,
-0.4341523647,
0.0119132344,
0.6839036942,
-0.1469781697,
-0.0404746681,
1.2423530817,
-0.1996691823,
0.604776144,
0.3711377382,
0.1441959143,
-0.7374657393,
-0.1812094003,
-0.9031524062,
0.3247139156,
-0.9821042418,
-0.0358521603,
-0.5006289482,
-0.0969765782,
-0.5450860262,
-0.1771695316,
-0.5423320532,
-0.4607280195,
-0.3101657629,
-0.070863992,
0.2678384483,
0.1506052464,
0.1294356138,
0.123756893,
-1.0769283772,
0.2824216485,
0.3918799162,
0.2796722949,
0.1038442627,
-0.6600763798,
-0.2856550515,
0.2341283709,
-0.1246571392,
-0.8956059217,
0.3415379822,
0.2040283531,
0.5169222355,
0.1947931945,
0.0977348462,
0.6555170417,
-0.2417939752,
0.8235788941,
0.0523806848,
-0.9641168714,
0.4448728859,
-0.0957807228,
0.3049236238,
0.564543128,
0.6676412225,
-0.6478270292,
-0.4669657946,
-0.6219297051,
-0.6183041334,
0.5775483251,
-0.0581360906,
0.1723365039,
0.2053474784,
0.0573425628,
0.1975638419,
0.0004495833,
-0.8670065403,
-0.1499780416,
-0.3922581375,
-0.1867860705,
-0.2146881372,
-0.1536313891,
-0.2607856691,
-0.0656684935,
0.7663347125,
-0.3124181628,
0.13418369,
0.0150146279,
-0.3734787405,
-0.5740274191,
0.4090166688,
0.3645202219,
0.8528938293,
0.0200000051,
0.1922858953,
0.1459837854,
-0.3136337996,
0.1821168661,
0.2375730127,
-0.3199855089,
0.0994841456,
0.4897727072,
0.538256824,
0.1150479391,
-0.7213675976,
0.7045230865,
0.1120154709,
-0.0002425358,
-0.1874478459,
-0.2618484795,
0.2644408941,
0.0852570534,
0.3923263252,
-0.365204215,
0.1422522813,
-0.7594880462,
0.1965446323,
0.593560636,
-0.6412314773,
-0.3885858655,
0.7161635756,
0.1712531,
0.0453909561,
0.6770642996,
0.1003828049,
-0.8261209726,
0.6643183827,
0.6224916577,
0.7931135297,
-0.258762002,
0.5044955611,
0.199090451,
0.3095155358,
0.2972812057,
0.3591923416,
0.1211179495,
-0.8803581595,
-0.583894372,
-0.4108304977,
-0.4519423842,
-0.2210794091,
-0.75330621,
-0.2557465434,
0.0668308809,
0.1800323725,
-0.130088225,
0.1251997501,
-0.4542194903,
0.3422475457,
0.0996069238,
0.8995905519,
-1.1969790459,
0.6883277297,
0.8916081786,
-0.5071129203,
-0.7986894846,
-0.0648842752,
-0.0465593673,
-1.0590720177,
0.7239771485,
-0.2453726679,
-0.1803290844,
0.084338747,
-0.5015238523,
-0.7390980124,
0.9516013265,
0.453830421,
0.1482119858,
-0.1422652304,
0.402217865,
0.5280812383,
-0.2004169971,
0.1545232832,
0.4152045548,
0.4524683654,
0.0870995894,
-1.080884099,
0.3095252812,
-0.3035692573,
-0.1939513087,
-0.0243354868,
-0.4006696939,
0.6695787907,
-0.1924245059,
-0.2616492808,
-0.1062861755,
0.7055891752,
0.4289571047,
0.3571991622,
0.6313066483,
0.2993738055,
0.4464552999,
0.0701189414,
1.1180772781,
-0.034793932,
0.2017007917,
0.9513386488,
-0.3089805245,
0.8243017197,
0.8882604241,
-0.0710417479,
0.6241936088,
0.7085741758,
0.2686833441,
0.5701892972,
0.1097732261,
-0.2221750617,
-0.3763406277,
-0.4159009159,
-0.234452948,
0.428591907,
0.158104673,
-0.4572530687,
-0.2780957222,
-0.060498517,
-0.0907307416,
0.0887079909,
-0.213572666,
0.6364881992,
0.1071178988,
-0.8380047679,
0.753390193,
0.0956694186,
0.4399397075,
-0.6936327219,
0.1447241902,
-0.2526611984,
0.0038671989,
-0.1832015216,
-0.9364000559,
0.4274043441,
0.1711755097,
-0.1360847801,
-0.44626531,
0.7797082663,
-0.7979428172,
-0.5677272677,
0.2467395812,
0.948946476,
0.1532928348,
-0.140659079,
-0.5948570371,
-0.1275922656,
-0.0649669319,
-0.3653674722,
0.1698542982,
0.7533044815,
-0.3174054325,
0.901293695,
0.4811208248,
0.0080477605,
0.3206812143,
-0.0164391939,
0.6860172749,
-0.3056010306,
-0.6144192219,
-0.5085222125,
0.2814236879,
0.0554330647,
-0.3444649577,
0.8829222918,
0.5980231166,
1.0664874315,
-0.1492642462,
0.7021423578,
-0.175479576,
0.5708636642,
-0.4967699349,
0.7776392698,
-0.9953379035,
0.1613694578,
-0.3074516356,
-0.8594473004,
-0.0401508398,
0.3541351855,
-0.3311985135,
0.0112881819,
0.5322936773,
0.77367419,
-0.3726976216,
0.0017985837,
0.2467746139,
-0.1397540718,
0.2690619528,
0.7922412157,
0.8153114915,
-0.5812054276,
1.0090692043,
-0.1907037944,
-0.0758368596,
-0.1928327829,
-0.7834287286,
-0.388146013,
-0.4176835716,
-0.4270323217,
-0.2827174366,
0.1622163504,
0.4177196622,
0.3341747224,
-0.926649034,
-0.180559352,
0.2059305012,
0.1908788085,
-0.3912738562,
-0.3130340576,
0.4153201878,
0.0472897515,
-0.6121384501,
0.1535337865,
-0.2918008566,
0.0662153289,
-0.545414865,
-0.201937899,
-0.3594532907,
0.0891793966,
0.6058862209,
0.5374401808,
-0.7082221508,
-0.4844041467,
0.3472151756,
-0.3651889265,
-0.0150495367,
0.7905630469,
-0.5110659003,
0.2066799253,
0.6104316711,
0.9363593459,
0.2121901214,
0.3169392347,
0.8596712351,
-0.8377814889,
-0.4027639329,
0.4020789564,
0.0922014713,
0.583384335,
-0.254391849,
0.3593406975,
0.1207533628,
-0.3785312772,
-0.6082934141,
0.3365464211,
-0.8612883091,
-0.1357250214,
1.1967487335,
-0.4881008267,
-0.1317159534,
-0.3464009762,
-0.0355865285,
0.3712264597,
-0.1493916363,
0.7251138687,
0.9929374456,
0.1558122784,
-0.3801505566,
-0.3871642947,
0.455118686,
0.956407547,
-0.9250871539,
0.4501665831,
0.4784469903,
0.4437146187,
0.3940266073,
0.7266901731,
-0.3240143359,
0.5316448212,
0.0284769572,
-0.1715113968,
0.2280814648,
-0.1952308416,
-0.0880378783,
0.1798817366,
0.1592462063,
-0.077004388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14331v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14331v2 | What Else Do I Need to Know? The Effect of Background Information on Users' Reliance on QA Systems | 2023-05-23T17:57:12 | 2023-10-26T01:01:11 | Navita Goyal, Eleftheria Briakou, Amanda Liu, Connor Baumler, Claire Bonial, Jeffrey Micher, Clare R. Voss, Marine Carpuat, Hal Daumé III | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | NLP systems have shown impressive performance at answering questions by
retrieving relevant context. However, with the increasingly large models, it is
impossible and often undesirable to constrain models' knowledge or reasoning to
only the retrieved context. This leads to a mismatch between the information
that the models access to derive the answer and the information that is
available to the user to assess the model predicted answer. In this work, we
study how users interact with QA systems in the absence of sufficient
information to assess their predictions. Further, we ask whether adding the
requisite background helps mitigate users' over-reliance on predictions. Our
study reveals that users rely on model predictions even in the absence of
sufficient information needed to assess the model's correctness. Providing the
relevant background, however, helps users better catch model errors, reducing
over-reliance on incorrect predictions. On the flip side, background
information also increases users' confidence in their accurate as well as
inaccurate judgments. Our work highlights that supporting users' verification
of QA predictions is an important, yet challenging, problem. | [
-0.4959931374,
-0.2372163087,
0.8926097751,
0.1710377485,
0.0720977932,
-0.3116838336,
0.2675808966,
-0.8269283772,
0.2627936304,
0.7032111287,
-0.5899361968,
-0.0905990228,
-0.3674186468,
-0.1250046194,
-0.4209027588,
0.9560713768,
0.3406874537,
-0.1408085823,
-0.6101337075,
-0.0350975432,
-0.9669057727,
-0.7682899237,
-0.5154132843,
-0.5083059669,
0.3663716018,
0.1657367796,
1.0103977919,
0.2034068108,
0.2226381898,
0.218797788,
-0.0707100034,
0.0027734563,
-0.3306950927,
0.2999872863,
-0.7044879794,
-0.5761809349,
-0.1780011803,
-0.1587068886,
0.3664312959,
0.3529305458,
-0.072702989,
0.6386640668,
0.1031124145,
0.6818500757,
-1.1277127266,
0.0290683303,
-0.2722074389,
0.0419720709,
0.0990012884,
-0.378195107,
-0.3728738129,
-0.2232334018,
0.3616426885,
-0.7375321984,
0.0068834322,
0.0022836269,
1.2240378857,
0.5716183186,
-0.6694082618,
0.049059283,
-1.0849809647,
0.36977759,
-0.6716544628,
0.3425220847,
0.9186176062,
0.3850251436,
-0.0804063976,
-0.5542978048,
-0.7195644379,
-0.0856327936,
-0.5025458932,
0.282964468,
-0.1407689154,
0.1784523875,
0.8813048601,
0.0678456724,
-0.1105926484,
-0.3008135259,
-0.5989593267,
-0.2470932603,
0.6031685472,
0.1264202148,
0.3781052828,
-0.1626792401,
-0.3675152361,
-0.0694667101,
-0.5960531831,
0.4387841523,
0.0182571374,
-0.1722140461,
-0.1344087422,
0.7495934367,
-0.3516970277,
0.5884242058,
0.2310027182,
0.1680924594,
0.1319124401,
-0.5319021344,
-0.2291150391,
-0.3277320564,
0.4481582046,
0.3729674816,
-0.0027597856,
-0.0008287915,
-0.2747024596,
-0.0340189785,
0.5126293302,
-0.5601813197,
-0.2914114892,
0.6029356718,
-0.3499733806,
0.2490855008,
0.2254995853,
-0.6093756557,
-0.5156574249,
-0.4206104875,
0.6273403764,
-0.318975538,
-0.2733214796,
-0.2407898456,
-0.550152123,
0.1335217506,
0.6231660247,
-0.6444292665,
0.0780461654,
0.4182810187,
0.5660715699,
0.1113529727,
-0.279425174,
-0.6357471943,
0.120933786,
-0.4161948562,
0.502194643,
-0.3558974564,
-0.1445389688,
-0.0262599736,
0.1617218256,
0.0690798908,
-0.2145670801,
0.5244924426,
-0.998623848,
0.2874729931,
-0.9054783583,
-0.5372518897,
-0.3928816617,
0.1873344928,
-0.7327978015,
0.7593646049,
0.0864707977,
-0.9005920887,
0.3167966604,
-0.4276716113,
-0.2347995937,
0.2531000972,
-0.0598150529,
-0.0524069108,
0.3747275174,
-0.0089720646,
0.2531060576,
0.0799183771,
0.1021578163,
-0.361371249,
-0.4732087851,
0.5378926396,
-0.0309760831,
0.8017545342,
0.2954140902,
-0.1464789808,
-0.0985425785,
-0.6716897488,
0.3079952002,
-0.241397962,
-0.4128506482,
-0.5490937233,
-0.0396622978,
-0.0193406641,
0.4967600405,
0.3869699538,
-0.509843111,
-0.0967847854,
-0.3248085976,
-0.0504185632,
0.733756423,
-0.0522570014,
0.1869175434,
-0.5989456773,
0.9046218395,
-0.2708980739,
-0.0640856326,
-0.2320624739,
-0.6913233995,
-0.4796906412,
0.0970799923,
0.4763047993,
0.6942491531,
-0.696391046,
0.2684053779,
0.0975001752,
-0.3346737623,
-0.3649865687,
0.0504763722,
0.5685787797,
0.5283918381,
0.3608713746,
-0.1074441001,
-1.061953187,
-0.6373994946,
-0.074714385,
-0.3240650594,
-0.3197624981,
0.4550236464,
0.5673543811,
-0.3044004142,
1.2348228693,
-0.5786710978,
-0.1513562948,
-0.019120004,
-0.464609772,
0.0698769763,
0.5251037478,
0.409997046,
-0.9704731107,
-0.1427832246,
-0.1624383777,
-0.9935722947,
-0.0284986962,
-0.027856756,
-0.0937198475,
-0.1195727289,
0.1765886247,
-0.8400267363,
0.5031647086,
0.9560155869,
-0.6714712381,
0.719086647,
-0.2229312807,
0.2343039364,
-0.889007628,
0.4318284094,
-0.1145783737,
-0.3389256895,
-0.5195582509,
0.298443675,
0.0894053355,
-0.3247452974,
-0.0525730886,
0.9628594518,
-0.2053281963,
-0.1678792536,
-0.4169962108,
0.1462141722,
0.4052532613,
0.3105157018,
0.0620937757,
0.9140902162,
0.3392104506,
-0.8077919483,
0.0155775035,
0.4452455938,
-0.2828710973,
0.2724369168,
-0.5916282535,
0.0007424581,
-0.0894347802,
0.3677747846,
-0.7286942601,
-0.4363517463,
0.1897729635,
-0.7492585182,
-0.2552198172,
-0.2962372303,
-0.4534988701,
-0.2608724236,
0.1142414361,
0.1881244779,
0.6943645477,
-0.5052359104,
1.0259947777,
0.612064302,
0.0211204924,
-0.8639109135,
-0.5859178305,
-0.077105917,
-0.0611768514,
-0.42668733,
0.2018012851,
0.1383723766,
-0.4198860526,
0.0080722282,
-0.2309928536,
-0.5474566221,
0.4806151092,
0.6592225432,
0.2527166307,
-0.214064464,
0.8426197767,
-0.0717220455,
0.0406456031,
0.38542521,
-0.3550895452,
0.2285243124,
0.0491318554,
-0.400202781,
-0.9264603257,
0.2315099686,
0.3815880716,
-0.0936168358,
0.6852699518,
0.5368574262,
-0.5788375139,
0.1047511771,
-0.7441754341,
-0.4952747226,
-0.4366544187,
0.1735501885,
-0.2106502354,
-0.5718621016,
0.5643120408,
0.3944634199,
-0.0603806116,
0.5001428723,
0.2082835734,
-0.4419232905,
1.1310563087,
1.1413133144,
0.29146716,
0.3832270205,
0.1838857681,
-0.1046518236,
-0.7923596501,
-0.2775516212,
-0.4984696507,
-0.1212195233,
-0.4705826342,
-0.0832220763,
0.0361692719,
0.3238402307,
0.0428179204,
0.2719163001,
-0.4110092223,
0.4329467714,
0.639824748,
0.2461693883,
0.4822631776,
-0.3404895365,
0.2439971864,
0.1463226825,
-0.4112155139,
-0.4189325571,
1.1820782423,
0.2216186076,
0.6177030802,
0.1652853936,
0.2982286513,
0.4531880319,
0.2007410675,
-0.3532848954,
0.199841246,
0.2384546697,
-0.952767849,
-0.2737544775,
-0.284674257,
-0.7527854443,
0.3887972534,
-0.4615682662,
-0.7245113254,
0.5015317798,
0.7198095918,
-1.0294269323,
-0.2015011311,
-0.9015681744,
0.4561649263,
0.0697929859,
-0.1750309467,
-0.1659390479,
-0.5348541141,
0.4266276956,
-0.0693231672,
0.1325832307,
-0.0577513725,
0.0139571261,
0.891661942,
-0.5532715917,
0.9148561954,
-0.3402741551,
-0.093679741,
0.3299235106,
-0.1331849843,
0.5453840494,
0.5189366341,
-0.0729500949,
-0.0592169091,
0.591966629,
-0.4101855457,
-0.8056710958,
0.371902287,
-0.6224355698,
-0.9854345918,
-0.4546143413,
-0.2809206247,
-0.4895706177,
0.1692699194,
0.3578078151,
0.0393650606,
0.2831515968,
0.2068924308,
0.7899470329,
0.1049457639,
-0.1019748002,
0.5278254747,
-0.4899020493,
-0.0364179835,
0.3310593367,
-0.0706042051,
0.1048961133,
0.1440416723,
0.3266318142,
-0.2749629319,
-0.3650668263,
-0.4409166574,
0.1433027536,
-0.7739179134,
-0.1094914824,
-0.914300859,
-0.2074156553,
-0.2629327774,
0.2748973072,
-0.0907011405,
-0.4492890537,
-0.3191125691,
-0.1577355266,
0.2626430094,
0.7118299603,
-0.0462430604,
0.4868273735,
-0.9661023021,
0.1258397549,
0.5189127922,
0.170964703,
0.1020766646,
-0.4770204723,
-0.5539595485,
0.1313929707,
-0.3394185007,
-1.1336671114,
0.1575579941,
-0.0157633051,
0.5197457075,
0.2822338045,
0.2652273178,
0.4427194595,
-0.0644002706,
0.8935894966,
-0.0501062945,
-1.0577043295,
0.6263416409,
-0.0907905698,
0.3808550835,
0.6620733142,
0.363979131,
-0.4749668837,
-0.3519123197,
-0.673339963,
-0.5530552864,
0.6308045983,
0.2493796945,
0.3572460115,
0.3335109353,
0.5053747892,
-0.1901551485,
0.3883732855,
-0.9015496373,
-0.2032026798,
-0.1943297833,
0.2855911851,
0.0505438745,
-0.4753999114,
-0.3135630786,
0.0943138003,
0.563809216,
-0.0879140869,
-0.0431287773,
0.2986152172,
0.0921224952,
-0.0620609,
0.3144448102,
0.5890818238,
1.0651515722,
-0.2279463261,
-0.1615074724,
0.3271791935,
-0.3200498223,
0.0168734808,
-0.1474222541,
-0.4348526001,
0.1547935307,
0.251070857,
0.5566170216,
-0.126159966,
-0.9850929379,
0.6683022976,
-0.1659923643,
0.1732454151,
-0.6099377871,
0.1820297241,
0.0244322494,
0.3287475705,
0.5667117834,
0.4929652214,
0.2782472372,
-0.4495972693,
0.3845415711,
0.5281012058,
-0.7119916081,
-0.4953754544,
0.4636056721,
0.0350291505,
-0.1549930125,
0.3375893533,
0.0841671526,
-0.484544158,
0.790653646,
0.4944248796,
0.5830318332,
-0.2682524621,
0.2095653564,
0.4338759482,
0.094924137,
-0.2442985028,
0.4804367721,
-0.1533162445,
-0.8275142908,
-0.6016961932,
-0.3510254025,
-0.6475803852,
0.3431025743,
-0.7814777493,
0.2968246639,
-0.7786265016,
-0.5836622715,
-0.2044284344,
-0.2195889801,
-0.7302345634,
0.5158361197,
-0.1287731826,
0.7035962939,
-0.7716064453,
0.6318743825,
0.6310434341,
-0.5371651053,
-0.8013640642,
0.2147281766,
-0.0375470892,
-0.4954301715,
0.9597414732,
0.1627296507,
-0.0465296246,
-0.3907037675,
-0.3930521011,
-1.2349437475,
0.690541923,
0.36230582,
-0.3301669359,
-0.2815929055,
-0.7410852313,
0.7293094993,
-0.2297495753,
0.2932998538,
0.1484857649,
0.4527731538,
0.026584262,
-0.8457806706,
0.4222654998,
-0.2620441318,
-0.1062048823,
-0.1115076616,
-0.2581437528,
0.9682424664,
-0.5865542293,
-0.6420887709,
-0.0266204644,
0.618748188,
0.3056200445,
0.4049310982,
0.3578498065,
0.241505459,
0.9564709663,
0.1547220349,
1.0748336315,
-0.3036113679,
0.2793544531,
1.5987073183,
-0.1589939594,
1.0174105167,
0.3459619582,
-0.127280876,
0.5775139928,
0.4664722085,
-0.1961729676,
0.2640139163,
-0.1135522053,
0.0842155293,
-0.3276747465,
-0.2063628882,
-0.9316066504,
0.4186595976,
0.3489890397,
-0.4177040458,
0.0013631434,
0.1106898263,
-0.2476213574,
0.1028272063,
-0.0775917768,
0.8980955482,
0.051639121,
-1.0330183506,
0.5523890257,
-0.1033606604,
0.4591191113,
-0.4742586613,
-0.1035410687,
0.0393848903,
-0.0367723741,
-0.6719902158,
-0.8094106913,
0.5377045274,
-0.2836784124,
-0.5920801759,
0.0268958677,
0.6454443932,
-0.1207309738,
-0.080008246,
0.3398981988,
0.6008261442,
-0.0879347175,
-0.3626137972,
-0.3954385221,
-0.3918023109,
0.0023885975,
0.0956235155,
0.2754247487,
0.134567067,
-0.0363255069,
0.9792069197,
0.9345529079,
0.196483776,
-0.2660948932,
-0.5001020432,
0.6744509339,
-0.6137269735,
-0.7586052418,
-0.780133307,
0.42157197,
-0.1938107461,
-0.4411572516,
0.9683231115,
0.2597778141,
0.6855229139,
-0.1796334386,
0.9557565451,
0.182140395,
0.6456215382,
-0.736785233,
0.7280272245,
-0.5959880948,
0.4374957979,
-0.0731108859,
-0.4491086602,
0.2183380723,
0.0774692968,
-0.1702298522,
0.0353889987,
0.592248261,
0.3206538856,
0.2031966299,
0.2561515272,
0.3951506913,
-0.0227497462,
0.0356225334,
0.385622263,
1.0624747276,
-0.4657334089,
0.4737262428,
-0.2752305865,
-0.1869701445,
-0.351282239,
-0.6122040749,
-0.8506752849,
-0.62799716,
-0.2370684743,
-0.8328722715,
0.1376986206,
0.673561573,
0.8113062978,
-1.0753171444,
-0.0049765259,
0.2665465176,
0.5864617229,
-0.3150024414,
-0.2508839667,
0.1591666043,
-0.2359036356,
-0.2398035377,
0.1247837469,
-0.0152510004,
0.2230150849,
-0.1944233626,
0.1233845577,
-0.1345729679,
0.2677706182,
0.3753894866,
0.735601902,
-0.8973895907,
-0.289458096,
-0.0824933946,
-0.1901266575,
0.1066161841,
0.6668879986,
-1.1723060608,
0.3088029623,
0.8123012185,
0.7221538424,
0.2678993046,
0.4641478062,
1.072165966,
-0.5587682724,
-0.1712467372,
0.1705327183,
0.3482186496,
0.1633270532,
-1.0188326836,
0.3118568957,
-0.0935430899,
-0.4331509173,
-0.825429678,
0.4358641505,
-0.5186556578,
-0.1791246533,
0.9472904801,
-0.4818491638,
-0.0277201571,
-0.5025293231,
-0.0516529083,
-0.2179889381,
-0.521489501,
1.0441073179,
0.8250377774,
0.0178635307,
-0.2623866796,
-0.6289143562,
1.012162447,
0.4889499247,
-0.9416151047,
-0.0685236752,
0.4229776561,
0.3314481974,
0.7156794667,
0.7710302472,
0.3474340439,
0.7555069327,
-0.1271019429,
-0.1697798967,
-0.0021017636,
-0.0643803999,
-0.3183199167,
0.4505271912,
-0.0386730023,
-0.0319424942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14330v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14330v3 | DirecT2V: Large Language Models are Frame-Level Directors for Zero-Shot Text-to-Video Generation | 2023-05-23T17:57:09 | 2024-02-06T18:44:30 | Susung Hong, Junyoung Seo, Heeseong Shin, Sunghwan Hong, Seungryong Kim | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | In the paradigm of AI-generated content (AIGC), there has been increasing
attention to transferring knowledge from pre-trained text-to-image (T2I) models
to text-to-video (T2V) generation. Despite their effectiveness, these
frameworks face challenges in maintaining consistent narratives and handling
shifts in scene composition or object placement from a single abstract user
prompt. Exploring the ability of large language models (LLMs) to generate
time-dependent, frame-by-frame prompts, this paper introduces a new framework,
dubbed DirecT2V. DirecT2V leverages instruction-tuned LLMs as directors,
enabling the inclusion of time-varying content and facilitating consistent
video generation. To maintain temporal consistency and prevent mapping the
value to a different object, we equip a diffusion model with a novel value
mapping method and dual-softmax filtering, which do not require any additional
training. The experimental results validate the effectiveness of our framework
in producing visually coherent and storyful videos from abstract user prompts,
successfully addressing the challenges of zero-shot video generation. | [
-0.0122471415,
-0.801376462,
0.6676980257,
0.3334532082,
-0.1933387667,
0.0124236634,
-0.2472338378,
-0.0369662605,
-0.3883548081,
0.3563376069,
-0.7441456318,
-0.5839295983,
-0.7433165908,
0.0948138759,
-0.5872918367,
0.7650160193,
-0.3498167992,
0.0049861092,
-0.0569423735,
-0.0169407576,
-0.6109451056,
-0.0717547312,
-0.7117518187,
-0.2151138484,
0.3993340433,
0.4690220356,
0.7631793618,
0.9325284958,
0.1197188795,
0.0996092632,
0.0211915933,
0.0890525728,
-0.3868722618,
0.4388065934,
-0.1782948524,
-0.1525699049,
-0.2198072076,
-0.1812960804,
0.8702447414,
0.4152148962,
0.0415178128,
0.1188101694,
-0.1572041363,
0.4019388855,
-0.5535586476,
0.0105154151,
-0.4472146332,
0.3555983007,
0.1449489594,
-0.3106752634,
-0.4120411277,
-0.1232752129,
0.0397447385,
-0.5025029182,
0.2862915993,
-0.2987882197,
0.6093859076,
0.4772362113,
-0.5692282319,
-0.053643588,
-1.0109715462,
0.6151813269,
-0.566182971,
0.2483355105,
0.0705028623,
0.2866584361,
0.0707728714,
-0.5127514005,
-0.7685821056,
-0.0875618756,
0.4916059673,
-0.0428678021,
-0.0168012884,
-0.1869645715,
0.288683027,
0.0112552131,
-0.5733317733,
0.5546642542,
-0.0764779374,
0.1143779233,
0.5452240705,
0.379198879,
0.4416233003,
-0.2439681441,
-0.3988209367,
-0.2078620344,
-0.9937844872,
0.0304956194,
0.4457340837,
-0.0337704606,
-0.2591011822,
0.7443521619,
-0.1681118757,
0.5825690627,
0.2085157931,
-0.2980614603,
-0.1701978445,
-0.3744549155,
-0.1428171992,
0.1767545342,
0.7603939176,
0.5448789597,
0.4021248817,
0.0613860749,
-0.1668342203,
0.1791197509,
-0.0540881641,
-1.1378278732,
-0.070942454,
0.1228479892,
-0.1755959541,
-0.4435018301,
-0.1109945923,
-0.7002053261,
-0.5160139203,
-0.3400888145,
0.2230701745,
-0.0792785883,
-0.5808630586,
-0.0260735992,
-0.2040280253,
0.5253093839,
0.5255677104,
-0.8566159606,
0.0667513683,
0.5145428777,
0.8197488189,
-0.5087587833,
0.0174387321,
-0.7587515116,
0.5570039749,
-0.5857661963,
0.6362475157,
-0.5706643462,
-0.4774222076,
0.5212858915,
-0.0901131481,
0.4614714682,
-0.2718608081,
-0.0047805016,
-0.4049650729,
0.2514124513,
0.13043347,
-0.2690269649,
0.1541860253,
0.2936348915,
-0.333462894,
0.7620257139,
-0.0123947589,
-0.3011409044,
0.3568479419,
-0.3264361024,
-0.5746815205,
0.0971335247,
-0.5120100379,
-0.1364006251,
-0.0067088068,
0.1346577853,
0.5015278459,
-0.4374729991,
0.7784048319,
0.0223744586,
-0.2438158244,
0.1215874255,
-0.7944326997,
0.1956564486,
0.2136892974,
-0.3991830051,
0.220577985,
-0.7656915188,
-0.1400531083,
0.0925488845,
-0.2468352467,
0.0673062205,
0.2484689802,
0.0644270182,
0.4302506149,
-0.0360822678,
-0.4026100338,
0.3145138025,
-0.3087502718,
0.5382047296,
0.8539550304,
0.0928896591,
0.6960591674,
0.1177048758,
0.6833537221,
0.2811183631,
-0.0962176323,
-0.7657698393,
-0.3954439461,
-0.5687063336,
0.0426092222,
-0.1791282743,
0.6258819103,
-0.8588064313,
0.0405037701,
-0.3308499753,
-0.0539510623,
-0.2412980497,
0.2134984136,
0.1609193236,
0.6531152725,
0.0932112485,
-0.2106478363,
-0.2733279467,
-0.7516158223,
0.3367336988,
-0.1407479197,
-0.3376300037,
0.4460577667,
0.1853614151,
-0.3138708174,
0.8583691716,
-0.6673378348,
-0.1756494492,
-0.2400511801,
0.2623281777,
0.1370849907,
0.3950329721,
0.2230299711,
-0.6919065118,
-0.4862421155,
-0.1943102926,
-1.0325807333,
-0.0769369528,
-0.276180774,
0.0346672796,
0.3927106559,
0.5586870313,
-0.6350653172,
0.3649392128,
0.5007437468,
-0.5105707049,
0.3775238395,
-0.5175979137,
0.2264068127,
-1.1539106369,
-0.0536066592,
0.1817058176,
-0.3597219288,
-0.3522202373,
-0.244624272,
-0.1529655159,
-0.5508597493,
-0.7433398962,
0.8257402778,
-0.4198906124,
-0.1402040124,
-0.3751921058,
0.3199387789,
0.1680331528,
0.4319022298,
0.2562000453,
0.7191987634,
0.7866236567,
-0.7186643481,
0.5670909286,
0.4777492285,
-0.4654933512,
0.695748508,
-0.8368504643,
0.0369001552,
-0.4219008982,
0.3641173542,
-1.0948336124,
-0.4980317354,
0.2591311634,
-0.259422332,
0.4066931009,
-0.1791781187,
-0.5291627645,
-0.1488576233,
-0.2090421766,
0.4815762937,
0.8995318413,
-0.4920659959,
0.4331968725,
0.1519742757,
-0.350764364,
-0.5178126693,
-0.7928238511,
0.262188673,
-0.0295539144,
-0.9316712022,
0.3365356624,
-0.2449728101,
-0.1602008045,
0.0874506235,
-0.0146694761,
-0.2479436845,
-0.151140824,
0.532410562,
0.3022084534,
-0.3167034984,
-0.0362007059,
0.3020245731,
0.0578757748,
-0.0142682083,
-0.4258882701,
0.2395370156,
0.5385591984,
-0.1359023154,
-0.5376737118,
0.7514110804,
0.4224571288,
-0.2095908225,
0.5200756788,
0.6196326017,
-0.1061339602,
-0.4384272099,
-0.3165678978,
-0.0414204486,
-0.448197633,
0.5856739879,
-0.2087409645,
-1.0327857733,
0.1462099403,
-0.1021740362,
0.0628925711,
0.370893836,
0.687995553,
-0.0246771742,
1.2914611101,
0.5907516479,
0.4856043458,
0.6741751432,
-0.3160136938,
-0.0739324465,
-0.5387405157,
-0.3031228483,
-0.1965958625,
-0.2635483146,
-0.1391636878,
-0.5435380936,
0.3382975757,
-0.1626612395,
-0.6148295999,
0.0263607185,
-0.3576139212,
0.5698364377,
0.2290999591,
-0.1756683141,
0.2616979182,
0.2938127816,
0.2143211365,
-0.0227071717,
-0.6234586239,
-0.4076396227,
0.9133014083,
0.3823592663,
1.0893431902,
0.2250685096,
0.1479715705,
0.6838182807,
-0.1215462908,
-0.6668983698,
0.7889658809,
-0.2992415428,
-0.4208479524,
-0.1979157925,
-0.2676459849,
-0.6408706307,
-0.2205474973,
-0.2427917868,
-0.4495692551,
-0.0120473662,
0.1156141832,
-0.4544163346,
0.1827506423,
-0.605060637,
0.8825528622,
-0.2166161239,
-0.8288251758,
-0.1514486223,
-0.6163040996,
0.2186025381,
0.0558536537,
-0.078825146,
-0.2847110927,
-0.1734715104,
0.4119809866,
-0.1883348227,
0.8113042116,
-0.2318628281,
-0.3220832348,
0.5999838114,
0.4219055772,
0.5599558949,
0.2999709249,
0.198806569,
0.0076004346,
-0.4353720248,
-0.0419528633,
-0.4257700145,
0.9305220842,
-0.8761562109,
-0.7428973913,
-0.2155228257,
-0.4401459098,
0.2034163177,
0.0906545892,
0.2424425483,
0.7940863371,
-0.2569754124,
0.1425079852,
0.9550095797,
-0.5561702251,
0.7222319245,
0.4550052583,
-0.1149849743,
-0.3611819744,
0.7258681655,
-0.2130369842,
0.2979535758,
0.5395483375,
-0.0671157241,
-0.3487992883,
-0.3458769619,
-0.818906188,
0.1002252772,
-0.56105721,
-0.3023863137,
-0.4565643072,
-0.2353789806,
-0.5280898213,
-0.3503441513,
-0.470333606,
-0.2969926298,
-0.5732868314,
-0.1891893446,
0.2848464251,
0.687058866,
0.0983133316,
0.3643791974,
-0.6466026902,
0.4839750826,
0.4566403925,
0.335790664,
-0.2893030643,
-0.766941607,
-0.0451136269,
-0.1299494952,
-0.2402649224,
-0.6730862856,
0.3725887537,
0.3018347919,
0.0802400932,
0.3329148591,
-0.1657796204,
0.3513019085,
-0.9275910258,
1.2003433704,
0.5357441306,
-0.7924180627,
0.6724571586,
-0.5219475627,
0.6559448242,
-0.0247946996,
0.2472471893,
-0.5861642361,
-0.0524628088,
-0.1962592304,
-0.8903850913,
0.8881858587,
0.0614647679,
0.4213601947,
-0.0720912293,
0.3436150551,
0.1248189434,
0.2013473809,
-0.5462387204,
-0.0122239208,
-0.4046832621,
-0.4031923115,
-0.030763166,
-0.5679084063,
0.010427298,
0.1737475544,
0.3908466697,
-0.1128426269,
0.1308403313,
0.2519226372,
-0.0284663867,
-0.4620053768,
0.3827600181,
0.6443510056,
0.5713651776,
0.0239800252,
0.1355902553,
-0.3124971986,
-0.0714825317,
0.64513129,
-0.1202303469,
-0.5121204257,
0.0087041333,
0.1673019975,
1.2282652855,
0.0808534995,
-0.8449738026,
0.8158246875,
0.1696038097,
-0.3725103438,
-0.5583695173,
0.229641661,
-0.3681783974,
0.3359962106,
0.2521002591,
0.0071200756,
-0.1417462826,
-0.4590602815,
0.2533039451,
0.1784397513,
-0.2658781409,
-0.4576273561,
1.2496217489,
0.5273489356,
-0.5437268615,
0.7444911599,
-0.0828659981,
0.0387927629,
0.6243436337,
0.576541543,
0.9754031897,
-0.174779892,
0.6428253651,
0.5012303591,
-0.1193984076,
-0.529563725,
-0.056617815,
-0.0681263283,
-0.4755253494,
-0.7029196024,
-0.4328137338,
-0.2796973586,
0.0396878123,
-0.3161711693,
0.541829586,
-0.5778415203,
-0.0809831768,
-0.1840541065,
-0.4886849821,
-0.6916328669,
0.1846574247,
0.6936505437,
0.7618040442,
-0.7701480985,
0.8169856071,
0.4207417965,
-0.3831655085,
-0.8127975464,
-0.1814722866,
-0.13492769,
-0.6473120451,
0.8348512053,
0.1828344017,
-0.008667551,
0.0208319444,
-0.6988896728,
-0.6147665381,
1.1812982559,
0.5149149895,
-0.626599133,
-0.425137639,
0.1866392493,
0.4264811575,
-0.6027889848,
0.052906666,
0.204760924,
0.207211405,
0.7416867018,
-0.4128500223,
-0.128927663,
-0.0399719626,
0.2582944632,
-0.0011800464,
-0.4378789067,
0.6381348372,
-0.4169701934,
-0.2041243911,
0.0038515045,
0.7514004707,
0.0769090801,
0.3178218901,
0.2481835485,
0.3050590754,
0.146464169,
0.1223920882,
1.0504918098,
-0.1436560601,
-0.0537419692,
1.2296814919,
-0.5100772381,
0.6873137951,
0.3537585735,
0.2361465842,
0.6726480722,
0.3037573397,
-0.2999346256,
0.6803629994,
-0.0047586607,
-0.3393144906,
-0.4037870169,
-0.4225876033,
-0.1688513011,
0.3237614334,
0.0097442139,
-0.467448622,
-0.2095562965,
0.2247216254,
-0.0814017281,
0.2067870945,
-0.3913575411,
0.7013183236,
-0.0330063403,
-0.9598609805,
0.3167310655,
0.0925732777,
0.4462020695,
-0.7949607968,
-0.2235302329,
-0.3456044197,
0.211015135,
-0.0208488703,
-1.1121565104,
-0.0241348222,
0.6295226812,
-0.3714672029,
-0.6428107023,
0.5213837624,
-0.8812103271,
-0.3771199286,
0.032418102,
0.2728457153,
0.0362255462,
0.0741145313,
-0.3433979154,
0.2729898691,
0.0269113407,
-0.286082983,
0.191319257,
0.4782038331,
0.0210470725,
0.4833552241,
0.2061203122,
-0.0559001192,
-0.0896087736,
0.265224278,
0.4821466208,
-0.5472828746,
-0.4263488352,
-0.948456049,
0.6684888005,
0.1473798901,
-0.1165178865,
0.5446623564,
0.3040060103,
0.6031301618,
-0.3196484447,
0.7635298967,
-0.032807719,
-0.0637231842,
-0.544660449,
0.4739470482,
-0.602686882,
0.1652333885,
-0.0885629952,
-1.0336225033,
-0.2549672425,
0.2679505348,
0.0273407996,
-0.2715228796,
0.438775301,
0.8084520102,
0.0401702002,
-0.4537505805,
0.4022233188,
0.3294796348,
0.6290547252,
0.7770844698,
0.8000984192,
-0.2798038423,
0.8289743662,
0.3963034451,
-0.0347498693,
0.0121701229,
-1.0381512642,
-0.9606046677,
-0.3838399053,
-0.6307347417,
-0.2345835268,
0.0742048025,
0.8570506573,
0.7589671612,
-0.4003236592,
-0.1960778832,
-0.2312330902,
-0.0572588965,
0.1772957742,
-0.1303683668,
0.1547298431,
0.1793074012,
-0.7946727276,
0.5539184809,
0.5606498718,
0.3181638122,
-0.6398481727,
-0.2523819804,
0.0244368743,
0.3053349257,
0.5760160089,
0.2760882378,
-0.5639727712,
-0.2828803062,
0.0343537591,
-0.2783069909,
0.1675403416,
0.7750646472,
-0.7633292675,
0.509699285,
0.464311868,
0.575905025,
0.6337102652,
0.0218745247,
0.879285574,
-1.0521461964,
0.4365953505,
-0.0810716823,
0.0178598184,
0.6027188301,
-0.350854218,
0.3976394236,
0.2667800188,
-0.4259839356,
-0.6960715652,
0.5240530372,
-1.0726437569,
-0.2752002478,
1.6532864571,
0.036099989,
-0.1150300205,
0.4233667254,
-0.2699732482,
0.3155535161,
-0.5230097175,
0.4438252747,
0.5049133897,
0.2054826766,
-0.3237846196,
-0.4878620207,
0.3897067904,
0.1977919936,
-0.5801431537,
-0.0252744909,
0.857412219,
0.3342207372,
-0.2285458446,
0.6491664052,
-0.0016569055,
0.1431925595,
-0.0133461682,
-0.1579588354,
-0.368478179,
-0.7131456137,
-0.4715597928,
0.3201352954,
-0.1205832362,
-0.0373523608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14328v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14328v2 | Benchmarking LLM-based Machine Translation on Cultural Awareness | 2023-05-23T17:56:33 | 2024-03-23T02:20:02 | Binwei Yao, Ming Jiang, Diyi Yang, Junjie Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Translating cultural-specific content is crucial for effective cross-cultural
communication. However, many MT systems still struggle to translate sentences
containing cultural-specific entities accurately and understandably. Recent
advancements in in-context learning utilize lightweight prompts to guide large
language models (LLMs) in machine translation tasks. Nevertheless, the
effectiveness of this approach in enhancing machine translation with cultural
awareness remains uncertain. To address this gap, we introduce a new data
curation pipeline to construct a culturally relevant parallel corpus, enriched
with annotations of cultural-specific items. Furthermore, we devise a novel
evaluation metric to assess the understandability of translations in a
reference-free manner by GPT-4. We evaluate a variety of neural machine
translation (NMT) and LLM-based MT systems using our dataset. Additionally, we
propose several prompting strategies for LLMs to incorporate external and
internal cultural knowledge into the translation process. Our results
demonstrate that eliciting explanations can significantly enhance the
understandability of cultural-specific entities, especially those without
well-known translations. | [
-0.3630960584,
-0.3565157056,
0.4459380805,
0.2319437116,
-0.397383213,
0.0607628785,
-0.7137582302,
-0.3804209828,
0.009624511,
0.1595809013,
-0.4079103768,
-0.6252773404,
-0.6977841258,
0.4629580975,
-0.2676280737,
0.9421122074,
-0.4731518626,
0.2352350354,
-0.2788613439,
-0.5714987516,
-0.5595228672,
-0.573518455,
-0.457687676,
-0.4321962297,
0.512040019,
0.4893262684,
0.4806693494,
0.7504796386,
0.5511312485,
0.2128046751,
-0.071735166,
0.4794147313,
-0.5319392085,
0.2226923704,
-0.109478116,
-0.5604650378,
-0.2573705912,
0.0290955771,
0.5367521644,
0.725661397,
0.2596547902,
0.4815867543,
0.1167661697,
0.553529501,
-0.4311126471,
0.1749510467,
-0.8477476239,
0.3049534857,
-0.1953103691,
-0.2676808238,
-0.2731803656,
-0.1717435718,
0.0831886753,
-0.6090083122,
-0.0730646849,
0.0918172896,
0.4874532819,
0.5649905205,
-0.6092727184,
-0.2156431973,
-0.5342314839,
0.7623860836,
-0.3058611155,
0.5376304984,
0.4361998439,
0.3967214823,
-0.0179765206,
-0.6683261991,
-0.3780274093,
0.0547807999,
-0.0135210622,
0.3350853026,
-0.1202890575,
-0.5764161348,
0.2196970284,
0.4642955959,
-0.5420581102,
0.1827649027,
-0.2186385244,
-0.2243770212,
0.2396866083,
0.2191207707,
0.2416263968,
-0.0801094249,
-0.5614391565,
0.0827064142,
-0.7646228075,
0.0807818696,
0.0849328935,
0.107086435,
-0.3211777806,
0.1714238822,
-0.365411669,
0.4646601379,
-0.084199883,
0.0430217646,
0.3949694037,
-0.2379343808,
-0.1654625088,
-0.1021376029,
0.6780392528,
0.682949245,
0.3966342211,
-0.364585191,
-0.1312588602,
-0.0684218109,
0.0924319178,
-0.8862934709,
0.0191992484,
0.1326512098,
-0.4606174827,
-0.1613687426,
-0.3218585551,
-0.2809226513,
-0.481307447,
-0.322062403,
0.0604553036,
-0.4017553031,
-0.1904741526,
-0.1565059125,
-0.0441538244,
0.2765365839,
0.3352616429,
-0.8518927693,
-0.1546756923,
0.4706269801,
0.8163445592,
-0.3586271703,
-0.0854609385,
-0.4361324608,
0.2063660026,
-0.4980240762,
0.5344455838,
-0.2608950436,
-0.281671226,
-0.0393591933,
0.0769721791,
0.1050277129,
-0.6717677116,
0.8926890492,
-0.5099490881,
0.1218558848,
-0.6555386186,
-0.286689043,
-0.4360021353,
0.6064392328,
-0.2174880952,
0.8606702685,
0.1459062248,
-0.5734090209,
0.5135434866,
-0.3704857528,
-0.4965102077,
0.4150530398,
-0.1021404639,
-0.0142414141,
0.1898102909,
0.5377949476,
0.489356935,
-0.4993253946,
0.2285458744,
-0.1946503222,
-0.5152434707,
0.2125640512,
-0.4306212664,
0.638666153,
0.5856702924,
-0.2610942423,
0.0956178084,
-0.2832249999,
-0.0865093619,
0.0585129298,
-0.2740094364,
-0.3017502129,
-0.2235686034,
-0.2000313699,
0.3547219038,
0.3886238933,
-0.1871993095,
-0.1290592551,
-0.0837734193,
0.5206818581,
0.6608054638,
-0.2994983494,
0.484077245,
-0.3051790595,
0.5353050828,
0.2538354695,
-0.0733481348,
-0.3791573346,
-0.4816862047,
-0.6373648643,
-0.2377492189,
0.0462911054,
0.6725727916,
-0.9538430572,
0.2421357781,
-0.5566907525,
-0.3633802831,
-0.6867476702,
0.4537595809,
0.2643372416,
0.9290725589,
0.4028529525,
-0.5176230669,
-0.4586470723,
-0.7535409331,
-0.3441619277,
0.0249472838,
-0.2160152495,
0.4012077451,
0.2228982002,
-0.2217151225,
0.4237787426,
0.0852457881,
-0.1294767261,
-0.2251376361,
0.0804957151,
0.3409840167,
0.3821433485,
0.2867302597,
-0.5766592622,
-0.62874192,
0.2770485282,
-1.21352911,
-0.1869804114,
-0.0071945549,
-0.2916421592,
0.1697614044,
0.4418070316,
-0.3204168379,
0.1252924055,
0.4905351698,
0.0910857394,
0.1553583741,
-0.2476248294,
0.3707379699,
-1.1221153736,
0.1410645545,
-0.0459037125,
-0.2168721557,
-0.5740817189,
0.0703649372,
0.4182904065,
-0.0125871887,
-0.5758638382,
0.4547478259,
-0.4306499958,
-0.0776185915,
-0.2403419763,
0.3894560337,
-0.0156145664,
0.4066545665,
0.1762560755,
0.734064877,
0.2281038612,
-0.3817543089,
0.2553412914,
0.1970057935,
-0.6283149123,
0.9961783886,
-0.3728518188,
0.3407406509,
-0.0947763249,
0.4616321027,
-0.6647476554,
-0.0605719686,
0.3147938251,
-0.4220456481,
0.1001314372,
-0.4479443133,
-0.5962071419,
-0.2819062471,
0.1115424559,
0.4762848914,
0.6599600315,
-0.4725759029,
0.2683057487,
0.0639633834,
-0.1033277586,
-0.6281306148,
-0.7667013407,
0.2849673927,
-0.6294350624,
-0.7639857531,
0.0907450616,
-0.1483957469,
-0.2350577563,
-0.3828883469,
-0.2319494337,
0.221869275,
0.4713155329,
0.1192107573,
0.0732064024,
-0.2405182868,
0.0907872915,
-0.0780771822,
-0.0917290449,
0.206525147,
-0.6616638899,
0.3071419597,
-0.3176535666,
-0.2320641726,
-0.366975069,
0.2781897485,
0.5410091877,
-0.4054855704,
0.6268733144,
1.0470998287,
-0.2516211271,
-0.0320929587,
-0.4634248912,
-0.2502675056,
-0.3767978251,
0.1386177242,
-0.6437467337,
-0.8610128164,
0.7164811492,
-0.223459363,
-0.184187606,
0.3987382948,
0.746062398,
-0.154755801,
0.961645484,
0.3217554092,
-0.2057080865,
0.2788304687,
-0.0480019152,
0.1128796712,
-0.8904119134,
-0.0569021031,
-0.4261668324,
-0.6381450891,
-0.6701699495,
-0.6920105219,
0.4464099109,
0.0469728671,
-0.2477613539,
0.2458122075,
-0.2620882094,
0.4496950507,
0.4260957837,
-0.0797968954,
0.4595463872,
0.036652185,
-0.4361302853,
-0.1824834347,
-0.5701419115,
-0.5439264178,
1.0429333448,
0.3451837599,
0.3471994996,
0.0711495653,
0.3807298243,
0.0222740788,
0.7898628712,
-0.6266373992,
0.2184064388,
-0.3215524554,
-0.3888682723,
0.1250991076,
-0.5627965927,
-0.4840199351,
0.4189613461,
-0.1261266023,
-0.5708338618,
-0.121478036,
-0.015333348,
0.0012834171,
0.2507405877,
-0.7397536039,
0.9801993966,
-0.4040619731,
-0.2128943205,
-0.0153284678,
-0.6195425987,
0.3064575791,
-0.3169659674,
0.3980741799,
-0.3801906407,
-0.1017430648,
0.2620061338,
0.0632705912,
0.6833664775,
-0.0588980466,
-0.0540483706,
-0.042173028,
0.2149086148,
0.5184496641,
0.0342453197,
-0.3815208077,
0.4168899059,
-0.3173152208,
-0.3814630508,
-0.5955277085,
0.7052963972,
-0.6365897655,
-0.6699802279,
0.0206495784,
-1.1111575365,
-0.2742080986,
0.1128854603,
0.1872788519,
-0.1104800329,
0.0025687362,
0.402381897,
0.646635294,
-0.2444631457,
0.1122435182,
0.7636057734,
-0.0194109976,
-0.3197268844,
0.7594265342,
0.0718371868,
0.145487085,
0.4527953267,
0.2120699286,
-0.1309185177,
-0.7472728491,
-0.9328557849,
-0.1706583947,
-0.8529083133,
-0.088489227,
-0.6355513334,
0.2671502233,
-0.2812029421,
-0.2068139166,
0.0249243453,
-0.3902629614,
0.0030762488,
-0.1620615572,
0.3375995159,
0.4526037574,
0.0324954055,
0.1753893793,
-0.7488951683,
-0.011268395,
-0.1115199551,
0.2183217108,
-0.1957641095,
-0.859975338,
-0.5819529295,
0.0429830961,
-0.2055617422,
-0.6679193377,
0.4353389144,
-0.1321638972,
0.6779643297,
0.2841721475,
0.1329214871,
0.718349874,
-0.4220832884,
0.6500389576,
-0.1495960951,
-0.920206666,
0.4418822527,
-0.4579854906,
0.6508102417,
0.4395981133,
0.6315926313,
-1.1127816439,
-0.6378160119,
-0.2039975375,
-0.9047071934,
0.4540519416,
0.00318618,
0.1446143985,
-0.1502703875,
0.1342746317,
0.2259711921,
0.1653626561,
-0.553201735,
-0.1004585326,
-0.3084985614,
-0.3075419962,
-0.2294180095,
0.0867709592,
-0.2877357304,
-0.0344122536,
0.4804134667,
-0.3006732762,
-0.1656232327,
0.0064439899,
-0.5963395238,
-0.0613570102,
0.1668366194,
0.5533482432,
0.4533427954,
-0.1769828498,
0.2137613595,
0.7797857523,
-0.2486653328,
-0.1558681875,
0.0322055519,
-0.3037072718,
-0.246445924,
0.1167082861,
0.6502587199,
0.0751611292,
-0.4095309079,
0.1878629774,
-0.1774895936,
0.0628754273,
-0.2116579562,
-0.4037651122,
0.3024024069,
0.1034661829,
0.2156604975,
-0.0394568555,
0.0249044839,
-0.3106391132,
0.0561419427,
0.2755921483,
-0.6247669458,
-0.1513158679,
0.7429209352,
0.4068692625,
0.0625570193,
0.7238251567,
-0.0187227223,
-0.4404172301,
0.4186141193,
0.3945164084,
0.8708309531,
-0.0854100734,
-0.0826389194,
0.2724653482,
0.4693374336,
0.1166049391,
0.1447715461,
-0.2932773829,
-0.7837718129,
-0.4912670553,
-0.4174361229,
-0.6085606217,
-0.1954808533,
-0.548835218,
0.1118656546,
-0.1541308016,
-0.0586226918,
-0.2115017325,
-0.0533101261,
-0.9944970608,
0.1490961164,
0.2369051427,
1.0348153114,
-0.8936416507,
1.0270738602,
0.7449788451,
-0.4392561018,
-0.6726011634,
-0.1460525692,
0.1567600518,
-1.0331635475,
0.8119333982,
0.4103904665,
-0.0079003638,
-0.1861447394,
-0.0837772861,
-0.5910264254,
1.2251689434,
0.460365504,
-0.2064212859,
0.5179004669,
0.2890931666,
0.642329514,
-0.5746350288,
0.4201063216,
0.4943238795,
0.6239913106,
-0.1057189927,
-0.7461736798,
0.1593898982,
-0.3193551004,
0.1446711421,
0.0605888143,
-0.5265719891,
0.4244228005,
-0.0121958172,
-0.0900243595,
-0.0734977052,
0.6918665767,
0.1249937564,
0.4133291245,
0.4767820537,
0.5235230923,
0.9588693976,
-0.3018618524,
0.9806933999,
-0.5627380013,
-0.1388920546,
1.0853378773,
-0.2697023749,
0.7413660884,
0.5657742023,
0.2176477313,
0.443795532,
0.7908080816,
0.0655846074,
0.2004863918,
0.3833323717,
-0.3089861572,
-0.2975969017,
-0.5361964703,
-0.3540469408,
0.4826028943,
0.4890747666,
-0.6239500642,
-0.0364470929,
-0.0451568067,
0.2124717683,
0.1326252371,
-0.171493873,
0.6669053435,
0.2613565028,
-0.7881743908,
0.6638874412,
-0.0193273071,
0.6835880876,
-0.3409251273,
0.3204013407,
-0.6310912371,
0.1003100574,
-0.1389814019,
-0.6105914116,
0.313070178,
0.2836610973,
-0.3160907328,
-0.7210760117,
0.3774849772,
-0.5570892096,
-0.2734363079,
0.2831027508,
0.7533062696,
0.517998755,
-0.0776702166,
-0.3914974034,
0.1691941172,
0.0073610097,
-0.032412868,
0.3637197316,
0.7683473825,
-0.4643426538,
0.5950625539,
0.6232486367,
-0.1349897087,
-0.1753800511,
0.2551396489,
0.3784427345,
-0.5137275457,
-0.2310789227,
-0.7214920521,
0.4774533212,
0.0128603932,
-0.1694801748,
0.8934559822,
0.4374269545,
1.1684292555,
-0.0605039857,
0.8023824096,
0.2482420951,
0.2926781476,
-0.2391651124,
0.872941494,
-0.517285645,
0.3663884401,
0.1031075343,
-0.7189289927,
-0.2278279513,
0.3124422133,
-0.5228292346,
-0.0769153684,
0.6807739735,
0.6052606702,
0.0100664748,
0.2033584714,
0.4494111836,
0.1491649747,
0.1693042666,
0.7030072212,
0.8476658463,
-0.1968335509,
0.9393875003,
-0.3116475344,
-0.1643205136,
0.0773148015,
-1.2307299376,
-0.6427554488,
-0.4213541746,
-0.1447405666,
-0.1497174203,
0.021105092,
0.8780282736,
0.7641885281,
-0.7140036821,
-0.2865555882,
0.3680400252,
0.1860467046,
-0.4925419092,
-0.0804919377,
0.1745322645,
-0.5172514319,
-0.8703139424,
0.5718914866,
0.312690556,
-0.0138236936,
-0.0571784042,
-0.1398667544,
0.3540475965,
-0.2757462561,
0.5633325577,
0.0679736957,
-0.6767505407,
-0.2264565974,
0.0983390436,
-0.1032245234,
0.0653061047,
0.7549820542,
-0.7335127592,
0.5635491014,
0.5280796885,
0.8542712927,
0.5027182102,
-0.21042867,
0.9019123912,
-0.8332253695,
0.1674007326,
0.0427947752,
0.496273011,
0.7973524928,
-0.3222868443,
0.696087718,
0.2580990493,
-0.5476873517,
-0.504137814,
0.2345494926,
-0.7915776372,
0.0428285562,
0.9375688434,
-0.5718363523,
-0.02859734,
-0.0854925141,
0.0857767761,
0.3702257872,
-0.236020118,
0.6587889194,
0.7798121572,
0.2991654277,
-0.1866591424,
-0.9189546108,
0.2399483025,
0.7633826733,
-0.7133514881,
0.0396778211,
0.2714455426,
0.3392293155,
-0.1292598397,
0.3345469832,
-0.2182916552,
0.2573429346,
-0.4159526527,
-0.027403513,
-0.1112158597,
0.0709347874,
-0.3501865566,
-0.0843107477,
0.0228098873,
-0.047266826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14327v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14327v2 | Dynosaur: A Dynamic Growth Paradigm for Instruction-Tuning Data Curation | 2023-05-23T17:56:26 | 2023-10-26T05:10:18 | Da Yin, Xiao Liu, Fan Yin, Ming Zhong, Hritik Bansal, Jiawei Han, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction tuning has emerged to enhance the capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) to comprehend instructions and generate appropriate responses.
Existing methods either manually annotate or employ LLM (e.g., GPT-series) to
generate data for instruction tuning. However, they often overlook associating
instructions with existing annotated datasets. In this paper, we propose
Dynosaur, a dynamic growth paradigm for the automatic curation of
instruction-tuning data. Based on the metadata of existing datasets, we use
LLMs to automatically construct instruction-tuning data by identifying relevant
data fields and generating appropriate instructions.
By leveraging the existing annotated datasets, Dynosaur offers several
advantages: 1) it reduces the API cost for generating instructions (e.g., it
costs less than $12 USD by calling GPT-3.5-turbo for generating 800K
instruction tuning samples; 2) it provides high-quality data for instruction
tuning (e.g., it performs better than Alpaca and Flan on Super-NI and Longform
with comparable data sizes); and 3) it supports the continuous improvement of
models by generating instruction-tuning data when a new annotated dataset
becomes available. We further investigate a continual learning scheme for
learning with the ever-growing instruction-tuning dataset, and demonstrate that
replaying tasks with diverse instruction embeddings not only helps mitigate
forgetting issues but generalizes to unseen tasks better.
Code and data are available at https://github.com/WadeYin9712/Dynosaur. | [
0.0164836179,
-0.9053222537,
0.5005235672,
-0.1087960601,
-0.2014411688,
0.6015151739,
-0.0714693218,
-0.1314779967,
0.2503877878,
0.467179358,
-0.8054312468,
-0.3620992899,
-0.4674891829,
-0.0465459563,
-0.3016842902,
0.8107846379,
-0.2225509435,
-0.2402492464,
-0.2879371047,
0.1115335301,
-0.7763618827,
-0.0780132711,
-0.5384895802,
-0.1065683663,
0.5172973275,
0.7042047977,
0.5665920377,
1.5429484844,
0.2791255116,
0.3947969377,
0.0709278956,
0.6399531364,
-0.4965423644,
0.6697611213,
0.2084651887,
-0.2700810134,
-0.5740876794,
-0.0308520719,
0.8563379049,
0.5788190365,
-0.2849141359,
0.4360450506,
0.0308697373,
0.7822377086,
-0.3005396128,
0.1811746806,
-0.6710854769,
0.1082959771,
-0.2537178695,
-0.3718897402,
-0.10271772,
-0.5460802913,
-0.1420170963,
-0.5164574981,
0.0739388838,
0.1125845313,
0.4918779135,
0.5854610801,
-0.149821192,
-0.6101977825,
-0.9539228082,
0.7763931751,
-0.404270798,
0.0832683519,
0.0776924267,
0.3105915189,
-0.3677919209,
-0.7110637426,
-0.4733456075,
-0.2965898812,
0.2145126313,
0.0030090031,
0.0805749446,
-0.192201823,
0.3281196952,
0.8268232942,
-0.1422580779,
0.0352543183,
-0.4158307612,
0.0665437579,
0.6216651797,
0.4496749341,
0.2262370735,
0.1915080547,
-0.3139230013,
-0.0398664102,
-0.7689873576,
-0.3408195972,
0.491351068,
0.1767073125,
0.1601638347,
0.2774160504,
-0.0640252456,
0.7955949903,
0.2747408748,
-0.1143872067,
0.1334642023,
-0.075844489,
-0.1279347241,
0.3044253886,
0.4558017552,
0.0585123226,
-0.1006986573,
-0.2586788833,
-0.3078168333,
0.0550332852,
0.4772691429,
-0.7999644279,
-0.6388208866,
0.127166748,
-0.1388015598,
-0.4032622874,
-0.126641199,
-1.0829256773,
-0.330552578,
-0.5097590089,
0.197411418,
-0.345715344,
-0.1130055264,
-0.2118744552,
0.1659992784,
-0.1847278029,
0.1844619066,
-1.117092967,
0.338824451,
0.5870506167,
0.8243373036,
-0.2091749609,
-0.1561649144,
-0.8854569197,
-0.0051351748,
-0.4472252131,
0.5424314141,
-0.6600176692,
-0.2716605067,
-0.0561326705,
0.1391937435,
-0.2194932997,
-0.7131489515,
0.1150231957,
-0.6581012607,
-0.0543543138,
-0.0977085233,
-0.859395206,
-0.1078664511,
0.0208586976,
-0.6731515527,
1.0963417292,
0.4607086182,
-0.1468893141,
0.5630563498,
-0.5286704302,
-0.2186485529,
0.6344888806,
-0.3528883457,
-0.6697641015,
0.0501359738,
-0.0280803237,
0.2160345614,
-0.2378748059,
0.3527136147,
-0.0107245268,
-0.5106772184,
0.0585871004,
-0.5027750731,
0.2918509841,
0.0432317816,
-0.6074386835,
-0.0246048793,
-0.9286148548,
0.0508246832,
0.1066006869,
-0.4531452358,
-0.1309606284,
0.2524446845,
-0.4677408338,
-0.1018770039,
0.3011621833,
-0.5739557147,
0.4471085966,
-0.1801699102,
0.5527959466,
0.8106002212,
0.078404814,
0.1747235954,
-0.5088794231,
0.7446374297,
-0.1131330878,
0.1179559305,
-0.6302217245,
-0.2023029476,
-0.9240076542,
-0.3414412439,
0.3071977794,
0.5945031643,
-0.556376338,
0.3750070632,
-0.2802697718,
-0.40184021,
-0.5462604761,
0.4708771706,
0.3057806194,
0.7298399806,
0.5273715854,
0.0797888935,
-0.5990672708,
-0.5824542046,
0.2404128611,
0.2363569587,
0.0939891189,
0.4679669142,
0.3330256343,
-0.1969816089,
0.3533449471,
-0.477820009,
-0.0310621541,
0.1147754788,
0.0557891391,
0.2511416674,
0.416477561,
0.3290539682,
-0.5213619471,
-0.5864121914,
-0.1422481388,
-0.4848236144,
0.0077889962,
-0.2782568932,
-0.2763184607,
0.069536157,
0.3951599002,
-0.3001915216,
0.1053951904,
0.6845317483,
-0.115910098,
0.38620013,
-0.2750448287,
0.2107480466,
-1.0299278498,
-0.1072145924,
-0.3743519485,
-0.3770177364,
-0.3654386103,
-0.0924207121,
0.0554717518,
-0.0364782102,
-0.0977731198,
0.1937002093,
-0.3597861528,
0.222339958,
-0.2254221886,
0.192370519,
-0.0841749758,
0.3589898944,
-0.2550188005,
1.0848212242,
0.5428433418,
-0.8843445778,
0.9157306552,
0.1691452414,
-0.4431313574,
0.1007231921,
-0.64212358,
0.2527279556,
0.0792080015,
-0.0086322837,
-0.8223229051,
-0.2877568305,
0.3938944936,
0.1294901222,
0.4529953003,
-0.3852217197,
-0.2717528343,
-0.4445976913,
-0.1463423967,
0.0202775132,
0.6802530289,
-0.7326959372,
0.3704390228,
0.4200021029,
-0.2712433636,
-0.31097579,
-0.4403772056,
-0.0451676063,
-0.4486714303,
-0.2395415753,
0.7387714386,
0.0009661266,
-0.0871808454,
-0.0047863564,
-0.319532305,
0.1292295009,
-0.0032338847,
0.2362707257,
0.465781033,
-0.3260556757,
0.4354030192,
0.2736624479,
0.0349993445,
-0.0876081884,
-0.5991436243,
0.637077868,
-0.010310675,
-0.1129751354,
-0.3142403662,
0.1261613667,
0.5770823359,
-0.036556311,
0.5511158705,
0.4063279629,
0.0866829604,
-0.3932230175,
-0.2718601227,
-0.1520330906,
-0.5195935965,
0.2115546465,
-0.0716002658,
-0.7472856641,
0.1993045658,
-0.4789493978,
0.5703033209,
0.3940780759,
0.4593047202,
-0.23972027,
0.9012253881,
0.5305910707,
0.049632322,
0.6327162385,
-0.3490970433,
-0.0065106875,
-0.8996103406,
-0.2100979388,
-0.0093631195,
-0.721739769,
-0.7868688107,
-0.411708951,
0.1623012275,
-0.0526954159,
-0.2878936827,
0.1792370975,
-0.7203866839,
0.4972711205,
0.4849367738,
0.1643169671,
0.1698638946,
0.1974940002,
0.0462156571,
0.0131035242,
-0.8647918105,
-0.5781704783,
0.9485138059,
0.2401290834,
0.639611125,
0.0530221649,
0.7208656669,
0.4286686778,
0.159636572,
-0.8160895705,
0.4242070615,
-0.3803410232,
0.0905754343,
-0.294129312,
-0.7448072433,
-0.9725509286,
-0.1882490814,
-0.0041441177,
-0.3778933287,
0.0726773515,
0.900156498,
-0.6354454756,
0.4180835783,
-0.3717854619,
0.5477576256,
-0.5880174637,
-0.697018981,
-0.2671942115,
-0.1327172667,
0.1823698282,
-0.1005425081,
-0.0588872619,
-0.3517959118,
-0.1473905891,
0.6346201301,
-0.4078117013,
0.7301265597,
-0.1951581687,
-0.1733477116,
0.272615701,
0.2944475114,
0.4914565682,
0.3891743124,
0.0231776424,
-0.149910152,
-0.1587860733,
-0.2755886316,
-0.5707480907,
1.083537817,
-0.4996744096,
-0.799934268,
-0.4418065548,
-0.6508170962,
-0.0371638276,
0.0321969762,
-0.1841708422,
0.5210245252,
0.1115081534,
0.2363707125,
0.9976946115,
-0.0644665882,
0.2366258949,
0.2527185977,
-0.1816617697,
-0.4358984828,
1.0896888971,
0.1136526838,
0.1243394986,
0.2036086619,
0.3292897344,
-0.1014622748,
-0.2364817113,
-1.0156341791,
0.0105360737,
-0.2276880145,
-0.3812357783,
-0.3889331818,
-0.0948987603,
0.0105646737,
0.1959849149,
-0.3705909848,
-0.4231857657,
-0.2466928065,
0.1265205443,
0.9385569692,
0.5846508145,
0.240155071,
0.1698147953,
-0.7358742952,
0.1168705076,
0.5443723202,
0.35345608,
0.0744275674,
-0.612637043,
-0.301739186,
0.4932896197,
-0.5481984019,
-0.580221951,
0.3343122602,
0.6450299621,
0.436932385,
0.0548311658,
-0.1823439151,
0.8878773451,
-0.7386857271,
0.6049399972,
-0.2956465185,
-0.5932936072,
0.7400523424,
-0.2709859312,
0.5249764919,
0.4930131435,
0.5125738382,
-0.4841740727,
-0.0610230751,
-0.3724682033,
-1.0916547775,
0.5422621369,
-0.1347799003,
0.5355843306,
-0.2233269364,
0.7911508679,
0.2456757724,
0.3114405572,
-0.0468953699,
-0.1227484792,
-0.2190633267,
-0.3851416111,
0.2274943292,
-0.189167738,
-0.1959549636,
-0.3901031911,
0.6579527855,
-0.0115794186,
0.2126029283,
-0.2042064518,
-0.1608036757,
-0.1667497009,
-0.1113434061,
0.6151060462,
0.6720364094,
-0.0462392978,
-0.1819447726,
0.0832675621,
-0.8160076141,
0.0987684876,
0.0141952708,
-0.3717834055,
-0.1181275323,
0.1672681272,
1.1574777365,
0.3093053699,
-0.7798196077,
-0.0562555268,
-0.0708404556,
-0.2636075914,
-0.6124198437,
0.6464443803,
-0.1770384461,
0.2252706885,
0.2550190985,
-0.1015976816,
-0.170742169,
-0.5839374661,
0.4958353937,
-0.0620389394,
-0.3376013935,
-0.1371613592,
0.5703838468,
0.2108862251,
-0.358425945,
1.1174075603,
-0.1791448593,
-0.2165154666,
0.6211512685,
0.5464112163,
0.4450393319,
-0.4340803623,
0.2948821187,
0.4084566832,
-0.1136463508,
-0.0302390885,
0.3633277714,
-0.2889022231,
-0.3278976083,
-0.435659796,
-0.8785880208,
-0.3414131701,
0.2533182204,
-0.4994376898,
0.1798477024,
-0.6986461878,
-0.057925038,
-0.0563039891,
0.1105782017,
-0.4399681389,
0.0308190435,
-0.0871434808,
0.5731725097,
-0.5549080968,
0.797955513,
0.6468469501,
-0.2784045935,
-0.5416458249,
0.1159985811,
0.0532976314,
-0.7369840145,
0.520706594,
0.123478964,
-0.2020138055,
0.2068700343,
-0.0351547673,
-0.9203295708,
1.3910951614,
0.2463874221,
-1.1324720383,
0.0782548487,
-0.052964855,
0.4370042682,
-0.5483178496,
-0.2437382936,
0.7040264606,
0.0838029683,
0.4287597537,
-0.3352598846,
-0.124512963,
-0.2188165039,
-0.0228754077,
0.6748828292,
-0.6230101585,
1.0241652727,
-0.0335434414,
-0.2106279284,
0.1256997883,
0.5485121608,
0.1956649721,
-0.0889976919,
0.4296412766,
0.3866452575,
1.1144024134,
-0.1278007776,
0.7816731334,
-0.6265016198,
-0.0292600095,
1.2064483166,
-0.0865839645,
0.5583478808,
0.2396058589,
0.0313846357,
0.7772254944,
0.6633814573,
-0.4558846951,
0.4674414992,
0.375079304,
-0.3619661033,
-0.1641474217,
0.1309491396,
-0.1778235883,
0.6585924625,
0.5379203558,
-0.6025044918,
0.0864501372,
-0.1250865608,
0.1515324861,
0.2695035338,
-0.3475541174,
0.7915040851,
-0.1600667834,
-0.5357224941,
0.7435560822,
-0.2927491963,
0.4719221294,
-0.5458420515,
-0.5162997246,
-0.3136510849,
0.3541761935,
-0.0064087883,
-0.5876905322,
0.4432292879,
-0.0218813252,
-0.1006781459,
-0.3630250394,
0.355745405,
-0.6955523491,
-0.753029108,
-0.1504088193,
0.13526842,
-0.0106973583,
0.4873813689,
-0.5480739474,
0.2389688492,
-0.0751399472,
-0.1607819498,
0.3131125867,
0.3319053948,
-0.0303484555,
0.6648326516,
0.3994994164,
0.3779121041,
0.0249632038,
-0.1460361332,
0.9828109145,
-0.3128179014,
-0.090572305,
-0.9086976051,
0.3974280655,
-0.3380475342,
-0.4084296525,
0.6112092137,
0.4607495666,
0.6460704803,
0.0685058385,
0.5380218625,
-0.1890216023,
0.5288537741,
-0.6207867265,
0.4973921478,
-0.5005203485,
0.356964469,
0.1090791449,
-0.9090489745,
-0.0495400243,
0.7363575101,
-0.1916989833,
0.0789407715,
0.2716539204,
0.7612041235,
-0.287194401,
-0.0804717168,
0.0830905288,
0.0926897302,
0.0999665856,
0.3988907337,
0.5090896487,
-0.389233917,
0.33431077,
-0.3103881478,
-0.5110864639,
-0.0379513167,
-0.8333726525,
-0.6694169044,
-0.485006094,
-0.466776818,
0.0149722239,
0.2962984443,
0.9415466189,
0.5887844563,
-0.7120150924,
-0.1691056937,
-0.2410452664,
-0.0545423441,
-0.6844405532,
-0.1237995028,
0.348495692,
-0.6202049851,
-0.7623795271,
0.7079846263,
0.3110179305,
-0.0389868394,
-0.4265945852,
-0.0107211741,
0.0489065163,
0.019702049,
0.5325852036,
0.2786875665,
-0.3206001818,
-0.1499841362,
0.1495542228,
0.3334662616,
0.089583382,
0.777012825,
-0.824581027,
0.439113915,
0.0349176601,
0.7668457031,
0.4754909873,
-0.1688843369,
0.6057538986,
-0.8043776751,
0.044527065,
0.3993689418,
0.0087009342,
0.2698431909,
-0.7375863791,
0.2156252116,
0.0568139441,
-0.7637229562,
-0.6712832451,
0.386385113,
-0.1645897627,
0.0962329879,
0.6051555276,
-0.1942045838,
-0.3393976688,
0.0500416569,
0.0012880077,
0.2575235069,
-0.370473206,
1.4116222858,
0.393982023,
-0.303343147,
-0.3738922477,
-0.7563314438,
0.7254551649,
0.1385617107,
-0.6600968838,
0.4546256065,
0.6428387761,
0.1360106915,
0.0097334841,
0.09262833,
-0.0116918171,
0.3525952697,
0.1661785245,
-0.370595783,
-0.4364665747,
-0.6276077032,
0.1047466621,
-0.1398633868,
-0.0097438516,
-0.3729057908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14326v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14326v2 | TalkUp: Paving the Way for Understanding Empowering Language | 2023-05-23T17:55:34 | 2023-10-23T06:37:47 | Lucille Njoo, Chan Young Park, Octavia Stappart, Marvin Thielk, Yi Chu, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Empowering language is important in many real-world contexts, from education
to workplace dynamics to healthcare. Though language technologies are growing
more prevalent in these contexts, empowerment has seldom been studied in NLP,
and moreover, it is inherently challenging to operationalize because of its
implicit nature. This work builds from linguistic and social psychology
literature to explore what characterizes empowering language. We then
crowdsource a novel dataset of Reddit posts labeled for empowerment, reasons
why these posts are empowering to readers, and the social relationships between
posters and readers. Our preliminary analyses show that this dataset, which we
call TalkUp, can be used to train language models that capture empowering and
disempowering language. More broadly, TalkUp provides an avenue to explore
implication, presuppositions, and how social context influences the meaning of
language. | [
-0.0519130342,
-0.8626401424,
0.618956387,
0.4573135376,
-0.1167864725,
0.322119832,
-0.4784961939,
-0.6259964108,
0.118084833,
0.2325400114,
-0.3766127229,
-0.3020960391,
-1.2959755659,
0.2366371304,
-0.5555950999,
0.7471206784,
0.1057271659,
-0.1695237756,
-0.3076131642,
-0.1668743789,
-0.5407060981,
-0.5106936693,
-0.3019143939,
-0.4266598225,
0.323864609,
0.4014632404,
1.0094490051,
0.4458356798,
0.5282911062,
0.3266350031,
-0.0119979223,
-0.2314732075,
-0.5154504776,
0.091976352,
-0.0418470018,
-0.6023088098,
-0.1938751936,
-0.0488771945,
0.3664811254,
1.0629276037,
-0.2929280698,
0.3114751577,
0.1774306297,
0.7197686434,
-0.4352154136,
0.3825647235,
-0.5689042807,
0.0091266474,
-0.1524534523,
0.0088158669,
-0.1758416295,
-0.5263366103,
-0.2638466358,
-0.5023760796,
0.0253802426,
-0.0138430316,
0.5686321259,
0.2614411712,
-0.4945116639,
-0.3995387852,
-0.661773026,
0.80717206,
-0.3652643859,
0.5254051685,
0.7984861135,
0.1633411497,
0.1619813144,
-0.79008919,
-0.7497493029,
0.1644372046,
-0.3229712546,
-0.1891485602,
-0.4862017035,
0.1096273437,
0.1698511541,
0.311249584,
-0.1899546087,
-0.1566872746,
-0.4365160465,
0.4524643719,
0.4142100513,
-0.3228946924,
0.8680866361,
-0.3205780983,
-0.1042025983,
0.0479276925,
-0.5654614568,
-0.034953367,
0.1709727049,
0.4483785629,
-0.1888760775,
0.6708302498,
0.0779974833,
0.9943565726,
-0.1157949641,
0.3267758489,
0.0360097662,
-0.1412993222,
-0.0993665159,
0.0498388261,
0.4909750819,
0.4506872296,
0.4599600732,
-0.2680567205,
0.2431625426,
-0.0712005794,
0.4285635054,
-0.5895259976,
0.1180924773,
0.3328556716,
-0.5967438817,
-0.3729841113,
0.1119775027,
-0.6197161078,
-0.6634150743,
-0.499029249,
0.1629845053,
-0.126204595,
-0.6910967231,
0.071702309,
-0.3585239947,
0.3784565628,
0.0293042324,
-1.4182246923,
0.2625381649,
1.0614801645,
0.9586901665,
0.3963783383,
-0.309913367,
-0.1385141611,
0.0455606021,
-0.3163616061,
0.5491036177,
-1.0114895105,
-0.4359710515,
0.2739687264,
-0.0145888766,
-0.1033322811,
-0.3110821843,
0.430727303,
-0.1936849803,
0.0697892532,
-0.139683485,
-0.392349422,
0.1612339616,
0.0577249229,
-0.5218710303,
0.8347627521,
0.0522882305,
-0.6161577106,
0.3730740845,
-0.6069986224,
-0.4350761473,
0.1635759473,
-0.4449562132,
-0.1602844596,
0.5169433355,
0.0434428751,
0.6491594315,
-0.0116100991,
0.2664094269,
-0.2597123384,
-0.0108225755,
0.2959775627,
0.1573485434,
0.9540533423,
-0.0063542984,
-0.2464769036,
-0.1859887838,
-0.4822886884,
-0.1893084496,
0.2076910287,
-0.1319313645,
-0.8301818967,
0.0520721748,
-0.1560084224,
0.0718285218,
0.138232097,
-0.5343206525,
0.1378059834,
-0.2690441906,
0.5817194581,
0.6272653341,
-0.1655015647,
0.508415997,
-0.1159960255,
0.563621223,
-0.6905583143,
0.2426762879,
-0.005735728,
-0.6562024355,
-0.2094106972,
0.1006389111,
0.2586084902,
0.3020731509,
-0.5724049807,
0.5339836478,
-0.1452454925,
-0.4953096509,
-0.7721265554,
0.4081768394,
0.2925836742,
0.385230571,
0.1280542016,
0.2264320254,
-0.4975661337,
-0.8409789801,
-0.6262019873,
-0.3520179391,
-0.2806422412,
0.2693827152,
0.1995738894,
-0.1231782362,
0.7626777291,
-0.5467624664,
-0.2775135338,
-0.4805794954,
0.3206604123,
0.1130910069,
0.253923595,
0.3308335245,
-1.0497024059,
-0.5074885488,
0.0039685271,
-0.9631958008,
-0.5021078587,
0.101835981,
-0.1318173707,
-0.5126279593,
0.7888624072,
-0.2114926577,
0.2900507152,
0.8346362114,
-0.5693519115,
0.088558957,
-0.1395197064,
0.2610242367,
-1.1964632273,
-0.1296723932,
-0.1033800095,
-0.1612561345,
-0.908932507,
0.1725507379,
-0.0597069487,
-0.6743626595,
-0.2078410089,
0.2744759023,
-0.5808206201,
0.2562809885,
-0.3594213426,
0.3900727332,
-0.1291230768,
0.0529647134,
0.3685799837,
0.1855891198,
0.647336483,
-0.3398731053,
0.103415072,
0.5612009764,
-0.2037102133,
0.4886974692,
-0.8992367983,
0.244094938,
-0.1764685363,
-0.1429599077,
-0.9084103703,
-0.2977833152,
-0.048777923,
-0.5848013163,
0.2008053362,
-0.0860842019,
-0.3500777185,
-0.0722958371,
-0.0520037264,
0.4119697511,
0.3118693531,
-0.6698250771,
0.3586131334,
1.1480779648,
-0.4515130222,
-0.4947825074,
-0.7569821477,
0.1336768717,
-0.1353832781,
-0.4050294757,
0.2242505848,
0.2469385564,
-0.8100605011,
-0.2985877097,
0.3468705416,
-0.019786628,
0.2053532749,
0.5405603051,
-0.2338225693,
0.4681464434,
0.6665144563,
0.1336248815,
-0.1778046787,
0.1712965071,
0.2673191428,
0.5639977455,
-0.3249515891,
-0.4128471315,
-0.0070761777,
0.7504405379,
0.2364614755,
0.0716115311,
0.6831235886,
0.2705732882,
-0.5493482351,
-0.0138853984,
-0.0236088019,
-0.3236519694,
-0.4759458303,
0.2408282757,
-0.0333444141,
-0.7212611437,
0.0235067774,
-0.1990011036,
0.2555782199,
-0.1143939421,
0.4223583937,
-0.0082799969,
1.0380555391,
1.013302803,
0.1074275151,
0.6533241868,
0.1366303563,
0.4667254984,
-0.4782009423,
-0.1170606688,
-0.753734231,
-0.3344672024,
-0.633003056,
-0.4630863667,
0.1701939106,
0.2313943952,
0.369306922,
0.5278887749,
-0.6960833073,
0.2908323109,
0.3673006296,
0.0877443403,
0.5434601307,
-0.1968793571,
0.3986434937,
-0.3596124947,
-0.6002653837,
-0.6850218177,
0.8843203187,
0.1942128837,
0.6866825819,
0.436737597,
0.6868860126,
0.608371675,
0.3631677032,
-0.7152534127,
0.4580333531,
0.1484472156,
-0.6066069007,
-0.2575262189,
-0.0384526476,
-1.3195644617,
0.109713167,
-0.3908072412,
-0.7593021393,
0.4727347195,
0.2346973568,
-0.0053016241,
0.1988758147,
-1.0287065506,
0.5545229912,
-0.1602319479,
-0.2208064049,
-0.3132487833,
-0.7184625268,
0.2348587215,
0.2000136971,
0.6917238832,
-0.1100313962,
-0.1054859459,
0.6038463712,
-0.4252175689,
1.1436992884,
-0.030217804,
-0.2955836952,
0.0209281836,
-0.2462838441,
0.1758521646,
-0.2112807333,
-0.073118709,
0.4714640081,
-0.2042573094,
-0.4987086654,
-0.7088317871,
0.5492405891,
-0.5257917047,
-0.3426228464,
-0.3177643716,
-0.1070324704,
-0.2843738496,
0.100287579,
0.0079779159,
0.3712468743,
-0.386957407,
0.4079837501,
0.2324099243,
-0.044072751,
0.5427904129,
0.2948833704,
-0.5817581415,
0.0065044742,
0.9490550756,
0.2165575325,
0.4117485881,
0.4878948629,
0.3604973555,
-0.3759136796,
-0.1083317623,
-0.3332248628,
0.1282396019,
-0.6181319356,
0.1823389232,
-0.6878684759,
0.2299313247,
-0.6753336787,
-0.5260789394,
-0.1357225478,
-0.653455317,
0.0775703266,
-0.6914125085,
0.3354079127,
1.1087567806,
-0.5824273825,
0.3537513614,
-0.5238628387,
0.4836741686,
0.7214455605,
0.1748623401,
0.0385540463,
-0.0707493946,
-0.239446491,
-0.2938018441,
-0.1865934581,
-1.3848236799,
0.3331234455,
0.3206327558,
0.5006501675,
0.5349990726,
0.2008702904,
0.3232724965,
-0.3546259999,
0.758225739,
0.1969130784,
-0.9770302773,
0.9698593616,
-0.2000339925,
0.200296402,
0.523655057,
0.5294969678,
-0.9222322106,
-0.710298419,
-1.043545723,
-1.1900056601,
0.2892586291,
0.3801160455,
0.6133266687,
-0.2867159247,
0.0924025029,
0.2142975032,
0.628819108,
-0.8590958118,
-0.3144718707,
-0.3070846498,
-0.1334563494,
0.1103187278,
-0.2483209819,
-0.2897987366,
-0.1749499291,
0.4444859326,
-0.0580376051,
0.3374351561,
0.0538676977,
-0.2006331235,
0.0310819279,
0.3800299466,
-0.0621984527,
0.7443084717,
0.0580001026,
0.405170083,
-0.2273724526,
-0.5226467848,
0.0415764973,
0.2270228863,
0.001785584,
0.0607243776,
0.5913019776,
0.624251008,
0.4360694587,
-0.6049628854,
0.5019155741,
-0.3977106214,
0.1018059924,
-0.1029088944,
0.0919723734,
0.1462554634,
-0.0275244154,
0.5412348509,
-0.4226515293,
-0.0179557111,
-0.7069489956,
0.0244157109,
0.4450623989,
-0.6059746146,
-0.2891122699,
0.5156646371,
0.6227635145,
-0.9841051102,
0.2356858552,
-0.0273122899,
-0.2672360837,
0.2773583233,
0.6457195282,
0.7214957476,
-0.0005032234,
0.4512150586,
0.314309597,
0.4239763916,
0.3796348572,
0.2953786254,
-0.7416366935,
-0.8746029139,
-0.2978258431,
-0.4032852948,
-0.6994005442,
-0.0933517739,
-0.9979307055,
0.0574736558,
-0.1150152981,
-0.2564583123,
0.0861427486,
-0.1134068668,
-0.3894265294,
-0.0403784029,
0.0376368277,
0.5808823109,
-1.3515511751,
0.330822885,
0.6201636195,
-0.2090195268,
-0.5536192656,
0.064212136,
-0.0486250632,
-0.976046741,
0.2626695633,
0.1872473955,
0.0156305246,
0.3534862995,
-0.6614806056,
-0.2741675079,
0.7756482363,
0.2787338495,
-0.483689189,
0.143407017,
0.1551300287,
0.4191717207,
-0.2200087011,
0.2060071081,
0.5702990294,
0.6726742983,
-0.6195946932,
-0.6184673309,
0.1296843588,
-0.4429537058,
-0.1588463485,
0.2575152814,
-0.570096314,
0.3664062619,
-0.4482489228,
-0.3996087313,
-0.2850279212,
0.585791707,
0.142529726,
0.1680582911,
0.4818905294,
0.3021333218,
0.9397562742,
-0.2632421255,
1.2266949415,
-0.2741003931,
0.1213163361,
0.9390736818,
0.0461190268,
0.8058617115,
0.7418858409,
-0.2849185467,
0.5737791061,
0.2583276033,
0.496304214,
0.1686945111,
0.028857924,
-0.6446089149,
-0.2673634291,
-0.3488614559,
-0.3872397542,
0.6269321442,
0.4390541315,
-0.6820249557,
-0.3387095034,
0.2711161077,
0.160728097,
0.6396833658,
-0.2331624329,
1.0111515522,
0.2912172675,
-0.4934873581,
0.2891045511,
-0.4605138302,
0.2959884703,
-0.5513828993,
-0.1946928203,
0.1141394451,
-0.1284497827,
-0.092706807,
-0.9212656617,
0.5915683508,
0.0814887658,
-0.189350307,
-0.770368278,
1.1999258995,
-0.4113588631,
-0.4462512434,
0.5435864925,
0.8084952831,
0.3471339941,
-0.0755294263,
-0.6283604503,
0.0200755037,
-0.0045471364,
-0.0547193214,
0.3535374999,
0.4602099061,
0.3048272431,
0.6037899256,
0.6736382246,
0.3329460025,
-0.0869430304,
0.3178115189,
0.5314642191,
-0.6161919236,
-0.3130040169,
-0.9073597789,
0.4566075802,
-0.4653101563,
-0.494695276,
0.8599982858,
0.1861746013,
0.4798363447,
0.0630490184,
1.0157274008,
-0.7513372898,
0.5328621268,
-0.1862808168,
0.8679727316,
-0.4303506315,
-0.0449892431,
-0.2582265437,
-0.3244765401,
-0.3554054201,
0.654525578,
-0.4468905628,
-0.2746579945,
0.1635639668,
0.740154624,
0.1560169607,
0.2128574401,
0.5221562386,
0.2963090241,
0.1166992262,
0.1267226487,
0.9003794789,
-0.0989854485,
0.5156225562,
-0.3313580155,
-0.6451969743,
-0.020503195,
-1.177985549,
-0.7525133491,
-0.8243994117,
-0.2133281231,
-0.3848516047,
-0.003164765,
0.8184790611,
0.7228875756,
-0.43566221,
-0.2537300885,
-0.4087409675,
0.680088222,
-0.5392464399,
-0.2637895942,
0.1028348431,
-0.460518539,
-1.1940921545,
0.3807887435,
0.1609758288,
-0.1207168922,
-0.3425855637,
0.2909362614,
-0.2586862743,
-0.0522544086,
0.7179637551,
0.4907030761,
-0.040720433,
-0.1077479422,
-0.2823081017,
0.2632624805,
-0.157814011,
1.1994538307,
-0.4894867837,
0.6818734407,
0.5422165394,
0.4382263422,
0.0226895623,
0.2699769735,
1.1424958706,
-1.1242024899,
0.1375945061,
0.1323197335,
0.3358083665,
0.5785636306,
-0.3297557533,
0.5381376743,
0.1477238834,
-0.6995896101,
-0.9267974496,
0.3064292371,
-0.6753644943,
-0.2551046014,
1.2851346731,
0.1247791275,
-0.3237078488,
-0.5613063574,
-0.3207558393,
0.346543014,
-0.3703660965,
1.0416908264,
0.6703401804,
-0.1971739084,
-0.3179608583,
-0.5709357262,
0.7134671807,
0.1246125177,
-0.7679101825,
0.53115803,
0.1645228863,
-0.1498815864,
0.4548852146,
0.846816361,
-0.005792628,
-0.0947050601,
0.0007359789,
0.0336178727,
0.13453798,
-0.0097542629,
-0.307092905,
0.3326142728,
0.1323252022,
-0.3091646433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14325v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14325v1 | Improving Factuality and Reasoning in Language Models through Multiagent Debate | 2023-05-23T17:55:11 | 2023-05-23T17:55:11 | Yilun Du, Shuang Li, Antonio Torralba, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Igor Mordatch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
language generation, understanding, and few-shot learning in recent years. An
extensive body of work has explored how their performance may be further
improved through the tools of prompting, ranging from verification,
self-consistency, or intermediate scratchpads. In this paper, we present a
complementary approach to improve language responses where multiple language
model instances propose and debate their individual responses and reasoning
processes over multiple rounds to arrive at a common final answer. Our findings
indicate that this approach significantly enhances mathematical and strategic
reasoning across a number of tasks. We also demonstrate that our approach
improves the factual validity of generated content, reducing fallacious answers
and hallucinations that contemporary models are prone to. Our approach may be
directly applied to existing black-box models and uses identical procedure and
prompts for all tasks we investigate. Overall, our findings suggest that such
"society of minds" approach has the potential to significantly advance the
capabilities of LLMs and pave the way for further breakthroughs in language
generation and understanding. | [
-0.467471391,
-0.9111299515,
0.9624500275,
0.0466186069,
0.0313649625,
0.1965292394,
-0.4069776237,
-0.0622100756,
-0.0397591479,
0.6433755755,
-0.4384128153,
-0.2982601523,
-0.6146377325,
0.320101589,
-0.0555888675,
0.6758062243,
0.1689507514,
0.1020253971,
-0.4652258754,
-0.2436884642,
-0.3858322799,
-0.6300648451,
-0.6260741353,
-0.6305990219,
0.5886972547,
0.5088107586,
0.511944592,
0.2628965378,
0.408560276,
0.4544331133,
0.1126993597,
0.6296162009,
-0.4514494836,
0.4148186743,
-0.3780733049,
-0.5266935825,
-0.3561235964,
0.0014908826,
0.5838759542,
0.663410008,
-0.3695398271,
-0.0124429073,
0.0480994992,
0.5123717189,
-0.438986212,
0.0611068942,
-0.8933089972,
-0.1519470513,
0.0409804918,
-0.2623185813,
-0.843582809,
-0.3084749281,
0.1067971364,
-0.4439836442,
0.2027835846,
-0.057624422,
0.5292363763,
0.1592394114,
-0.3909565806,
-0.2490340769,
-0.7384349704,
0.7448988557,
-0.8075689673,
0.31042099,
0.019145377,
0.1602503061,
-0.345938772,
-0.5248961449,
-0.6932510734,
-0.3548668325,
0.0834622309,
0.2206100821,
-0.1659408659,
-0.0643196031,
0.4867033958,
-0.2053822875,
-0.3712715507,
-0.1095729023,
-0.2908029854,
-0.2913497388,
0.6953521967,
0.2124339342,
0.0830406323,
-0.0607674718,
-0.1587949842,
0.0021430128,
-0.8510365486,
-0.0135583403,
0.3463129401,
0.4093138576,
0.0111158257,
0.4718378782,
-0.3184228539,
0.5282684565,
0.1834507883,
-0.3210752606,
-0.0220901649,
-0.4194778204,
-0.0537396334,
-0.0364396833,
0.4880440533,
0.2588169277,
0.1930119097,
-0.0543137789,
-0.0114875641,
0.22874327,
0.3441262841,
-0.8370817304,
-0.2778249383,
0.3535503745,
-0.1646894366,
-0.0770644397,
-0.1158169881,
-0.613391161,
-0.4963395,
-0.5445395112,
0.2776161432,
-0.3537108898,
-0.4131242931,
0.4711928964,
-0.0992010012,
0.0914854035,
0.8602671623,
-0.6150493026,
0.2892043591,
0.7250772119,
0.6614435911,
-0.024625292,
-0.1271510571,
-0.5688413382,
0.2808119059,
-0.5653316975,
1.2011295557,
-0.5783032179,
-0.4139358699,
-0.0914179981,
-0.3771674335,
0.1151147857,
-0.5740565658,
0.3133658469,
-0.3788056374,
0.2811171114,
-0.784769237,
-0.5567772388,
0.0190114547,
0.7513173819,
-0.6224948764,
0.8164113164,
-0.5384596586,
-0.5582800508,
0.1172732636,
-0.8689738512,
-0.2935074866,
0.1588021815,
-0.4095651507,
-0.248650372,
0.190613538,
0.4400551319,
0.3890418708,
-0.214388147,
0.5268465281,
-0.4602592289,
0.0686626211,
0.6537786722,
-0.6091515422,
0.5080381632,
0.1441429406,
-0.2286771238,
0.1980828941,
-0.5432026982,
0.0369828567,
0.1850567013,
-0.2452018857,
-0.1547452062,
0.0598288849,
-0.4688486457,
0.4137023091,
0.0019447887,
-0.4964218736,
0.247970745,
-0.4467312992,
0.4747985303,
0.9781357646,
-0.0160887092,
0.2674894631,
-0.5467123389,
0.4032511115,
0.308842808,
-0.0441304184,
-0.3487446904,
-0.588329494,
-0.8298873901,
-0.1958523691,
0.0341294296,
0.2616066337,
-0.967300117,
-0.0328850932,
-0.3297866285,
-0.3060009778,
-0.4641698301,
0.0376285017,
0.3327325583,
0.5510135293,
0.2642608285,
-0.222140789,
-0.3984016478,
-0.751822412,
-0.2098583132,
-0.2883033454,
0.1981754154,
0.4233264029,
0.5634212494,
0.1417448968,
1.041031599,
-0.5085169673,
0.465718776,
-0.3091366887,
0.3117772341,
-0.0701926276,
0.1811775267,
0.2227670401,
-0.4762366712,
-0.3221241236,
-0.063989602,
-0.7656270266,
0.0832041278,
-0.0796022788,
-0.1927268952,
0.375474453,
0.3159255385,
-0.6925552487,
0.2379996032,
0.2264849842,
-0.1630658507,
0.7353271246,
-0.1147474349,
0.4126563966,
-1.0406296253,
-0.1226319671,
0.0602392517,
-0.30924505,
-0.6627853513,
0.0512965135,
-0.221770823,
-0.0535110794,
-0.4135473371,
0.7251461148,
-0.3028820455,
0.0848187357,
-0.3262285888,
0.575642705,
0.1554336995,
0.2261690348,
0.1123761907,
0.9407048225,
0.4155293107,
-0.6068739295,
0.4764496088,
0.2608453333,
-0.2907457352,
0.8547765613,
-0.7385003567,
0.4916986227,
-0.4802300036,
0.496026963,
-1.2208300829,
-0.2377725393,
0.1170916781,
-0.517546773,
-0.0561738238,
0.0515170991,
-0.4630131423,
-0.3914126158,
-0.260715723,
0.0886669084,
0.1657240242,
-0.5468766093,
0.6347571015,
0.2665065229,
-0.4063281417,
-0.6635178924,
-0.3863622248,
0.3646389544,
-0.1170559973,
-0.7793780565,
0.0307557248,
-0.3751719594,
-0.7361658812,
-0.2026847601,
-0.1229818538,
0.0344072022,
0.0452094041,
-0.198792696,
0.3133714199,
-0.3116650879,
0.5591231585,
-0.0691205934,
-0.0259550568,
0.2038715035,
-0.4377962053,
0.550688684,
-0.1927197427,
-0.384214282,
-0.0749955997,
0.3229688406,
0.3103715479,
-0.4714485705,
0.7296848297,
0.1602940112,
-0.3691218495,
-0.4338642955,
-0.9266014695,
-0.5764735937,
-0.5275982022,
0.3065772355,
-0.5532711148,
-1.0940465927,
0.5035433173,
-0.3404322267,
0.228537932,
0.1750927269,
0.8398417234,
0.0243626311,
1.0568636656,
0.4189591408,
0.1730257124,
-0.013106931,
0.0262310617,
0.2873470485,
-0.5503897071,
-0.3042882383,
-0.639785111,
0.0476216301,
-0.2407082766,
-0.632342577,
0.4274241328,
-0.4251125753,
-0.1224722341,
-0.0514391139,
-0.4261218011,
0.6712504625,
0.2231374979,
0.2917794287,
0.4398198128,
0.1157017797,
-0.412789613,
-0.0246225186,
-0.8381231427,
-0.9209816456,
1.1267117262,
0.1746758372,
0.6588881016,
0.3454365432,
0.7396866083,
0.0861124471,
0.5316187143,
-0.6673529744,
0.7184917331,
0.1589178443,
-0.8296800256,
-0.4429468215,
-0.4979172349,
-0.8776281476,
0.5700144768,
-0.1907665431,
-0.7132664323,
-0.0821092576,
0.1308824718,
-0.618952632,
0.1796550602,
-0.4582407475,
0.681363523,
-0.1043639556,
-0.6529967189,
-0.541041851,
-0.4587541521,
0.5157222152,
0.1021261439,
0.3493306637,
-0.0864732862,
0.1110510901,
0.4842219949,
-0.3537145853,
0.8860387206,
0.0729099065,
-0.5466088057,
0.5320001245,
-0.0501173399,
0.4813767076,
0.2134525478,
-0.1818838269,
-0.2773068547,
-0.2202324718,
-0.3982854486,
-0.860147059,
0.7357468009,
-0.6779256463,
-1.0448275805,
-0.2078963369,
-0.7781436443,
-0.3077502549,
-0.0469965711,
-0.1706016958,
0.7573327422,
-0.2123338282,
0.1661892384,
0.9951517582,
-0.0491567552,
0.3810894191,
0.5651184916,
-0.0788820684,
-0.4297272265,
0.587705791,
0.1099922583,
0.4689477682,
0.0778719038,
0.3057761788,
-0.5971471071,
-0.311095506,
-0.320331037,
0.2876972556,
-1.0611747503,
-0.1671747565,
-0.739440918,
0.0451683179,
-0.7228428721,
0.0069388929,
-0.2985198498,
-0.4102897942,
0.0903452784,
-0.1652086079,
0.2429014444,
0.8633572459,
0.0133714452,
0.1565322578,
-0.7614063621,
0.2179748714,
0.5478124022,
0.0441891998,
0.1829916388,
-0.5720576048,
-0.0468487181,
0.1643373668,
-0.5359870195,
-1.0302350521,
0.0503709763,
-0.1407316923,
0.7133698463,
0.0989857987,
0.0268679764,
0.7609900832,
-0.7227842808,
0.7027871609,
0.2414383292,
-1.0241833925,
0.5650960207,
-0.2777941525,
0.3402551711,
0.4049465358,
0.2214243412,
-0.4259761572,
-0.4373535812,
-0.6897094846,
-0.3787953258,
0.5328364372,
0.1851170957,
0.2199835926,
-0.1348970532,
0.3770073354,
0.0020992968,
0.3501985669,
-0.7417637706,
-0.0542199835,
-0.1214938685,
-0.1207291335,
0.1298296303,
0.0137296282,
-0.4768272042,
-0.1536355019,
0.717838943,
-0.5391498804,
0.0642694011,
0.2297609448,
0.047001712,
-0.1726816297,
0.5907678604,
0.7444751263,
1.007643342,
0.4160443246,
0.4001796246,
0.3624541461,
-0.0548620149,
0.4062022567,
-0.0611006543,
-0.1831880659,
0.0064126295,
0.2073078007,
0.6833918691,
0.0542755947,
-0.5526152253,
0.2385357171,
-0.0382420421,
-0.3830629587,
0.1196296662,
0.080946967,
0.2681256831,
0.4639194012,
0.2130703032,
0.1158128381,
0.0769876093,
-0.72567451,
0.3912141919,
0.5975041389,
0.089033775,
-0.108728461,
0.4014463127,
0.33753407,
-0.2676772773,
0.3816314936,
-0.2922978997,
-0.5821626186,
0.705245316,
0.6973034739,
0.5335322022,
-0.3498735428,
0.6796459556,
0.4095731676,
0.4845967889,
-0.4549460709,
0.2781291008,
0.1787078083,
-1.1641359329,
-0.8259216547,
-0.1810411066,
-0.7669399381,
0.1848652661,
-0.24492006,
0.216797024,
-0.492800951,
-0.2729697526,
0.116070047,
0.2301964015,
-0.4972915053,
0.0965788886,
0.2789492607,
0.5892160535,
-0.7663533688,
0.7783676386,
0.8807768822,
-0.3957273662,
-0.9355935454,
0.0379906073,
0.0269232113,
-0.4961632192,
0.4709376991,
0.2188783139,
-0.4358839989,
-0.0155024901,
-1.0160950422,
-0.8664969802,
0.6924282312,
0.6262034178,
-0.5273635387,
0.2310058326,
0.111528635,
0.3911171854,
-0.3509855568,
0.4115436971,
0.4132988155,
0.6832793951,
0.4122965932,
-0.6747381091,
0.1447229683,
-0.0956776217,
-0.1138004735,
-0.0478328615,
-0.579171896,
0.7241334319,
-0.4720365107,
-0.1149588525,
-0.0845753551,
0.8924276233,
0.9285749793,
0.2897553444,
0.3785777092,
0.3980321288,
1.1292032003,
-0.0576185808,
0.7835783958,
-0.1339682341,
0.2994363308,
1.0577582121,
-0.741022706,
0.7449274659,
0.2672210038,
-0.2438015491,
0.5459685326,
0.1989204288,
0.2248038948,
0.0931190029,
0.2589963973,
-0.4078171253,
-0.7987090349,
-0.192733556,
-0.1120336577,
0.4436566532,
0.3516019881,
0.3116292357,
-0.3523601294,
0.0126597248,
0.2019171566,
0.5846964717,
-0.0588275939,
0.6553040147,
0.1332922727,
-0.9580410123,
0.3405787349,
0.0458563417,
0.6015594602,
-0.4101425409,
-0.2020617425,
-0.2074807882,
0.0401073396,
0.0325946286,
-0.6557759047,
0.1117173135,
0.053295698,
-0.166716665,
-0.2074377686,
0.8513914347,
-0.7284983397,
-0.5955110788,
-0.0768543035,
0.7862582207,
0.0185575821,
0.0914679989,
-0.8065105081,
0.1698774099,
-0.258315742,
-0.0552279726,
0.0464614257,
0.6700178981,
0.0635840148,
0.7804012299,
0.6355563998,
-0.0142636998,
-0.0083501916,
0.2156222463,
0.9215226769,
-0.3461226821,
-0.3579470515,
-1.110716939,
0.6000407934,
-0.4353909194,
-0.0447607264,
0.8717337847,
0.399095118,
0.7442439198,
0.0180225708,
0.9643820524,
0.2187622488,
0.3990493715,
-0.5605158806,
0.4039035141,
-0.3630666733,
0.1774276197,
-0.2957843244,
-0.651991725,
-0.2439527661,
0.800227046,
-0.4387763739,
0.2040239573,
0.7113082409,
0.8614190221,
0.1386967748,
0.0512692109,
0.3795379996,
0.3109951913,
0.541428566,
0.4145933986,
1.0600618124,
-0.1677976102,
0.4207187891,
0.0374656022,
-0.1026014835,
0.1261678338,
-0.9208799601,
-1.0910922289,
-0.3342642784,
-0.5049017072,
-0.3686804175,
0.2469501942,
1.1545227766,
0.5964705348,
-0.6936181784,
-0.393728137,
0.0884064808,
0.2784650624,
-0.0553727485,
-0.1661390066,
-0.0909218416,
-0.6587948203,
-0.70758605,
0.4704189599,
0.5085657239,
-0.2477395087,
-0.4436511695,
-0.167977497,
-0.2745755315,
0.7474768758,
0.854834795,
-0.0578082725,
-1.0127137899,
-0.4976005256,
0.1957716197,
-0.0788112208,
0.1763418913,
0.8317456245,
-0.7499654293,
0.4838605225,
0.4493530691,
0.6343019009,
0.1901568025,
0.0986120179,
0.5592172146,
-0.6725336313,
0.065415442,
0.1536269039,
0.3185212016,
0.5601294041,
-0.1848920286,
0.3532502949,
0.329963237,
-0.5044283867,
-0.7287126184,
0.4243565202,
-0.6066931486,
-0.4580380619,
1.0778497458,
-0.0905658752,
-0.1166342199,
-0.1879645586,
-0.3371812999,
0.1299364418,
-0.499684751,
0.9371444583,
1.1221516132,
0.0316039957,
-0.3899049461,
-0.4600415528,
0.1999255121,
0.5326589346,
-1.2757927179,
0.2447912097,
0.7663028836,
0.1797139943,
0.3188001812,
0.866459012,
-0.0485815182,
0.1519523859,
-0.1231546849,
-0.0604141802,
0.1998220533,
-0.7284846902,
-0.1352821887,
0.2001248598,
0.1128990725,
0.3075742424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14324v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14324v2 | Ties Matter: Meta-Evaluating Modern Metrics with Pairwise Accuracy and Tie Calibration | 2023-05-23T17:54:57 | 2023-10-17T16:33:33 | Daniel Deutsch, George Foster, Markus Freitag | cs.CL | cs.CL | Kendall's tau is frequently used to meta-evaluate how well machine
translation (MT) evaluation metrics score individual translations. Its focus on
pairwise score comparisons is intuitive but raises the question of how ties
should be handled, a gray area that has motivated different variants in the
literature. We demonstrate that, in settings like modern MT meta-evaluation,
existing variants have weaknesses arising from their handling of ties, and in
some situations can even be gamed. We propose instead to meta-evaluate metrics
with a version of pairwise accuracy that gives metrics credit for correctly
predicting ties, in combination with a tie calibration procedure that
automatically introduces ties into metric scores, enabling fair comparison
between metrics that do and do not predict ties. We argue and provide
experimental evidence that these modifications lead to fairer ranking-based
assessments of metric performance. | [
-0.4165199995,
-0.5152605772,
0.7421638966,
-0.0338759385,
-0.3704330921,
0.1524439603,
0.0713722557,
-0.4892660379,
0.5448967218,
0.2188238651,
-0.2090144753,
-0.1106608436,
-0.9764063954,
0.2728382051,
0.0900234804,
1.377646327,
-0.0404633321,
0.3163661361,
-0.4240426719,
-0.9504486322,
-0.6585008502,
-0.464042902,
-0.3685323596,
-0.7135522962,
0.6109087467,
0.4857399464,
1.4101829529,
0.6475606561,
1.1901967525,
0.2344671786,
-0.1273077428,
0.3353287578,
-0.5722588897,
0.0952016935,
-0.2582012415,
-0.4291087985,
-0.9859111309,
0.3938486278,
0.6297051311,
0.8783888817,
0.0863888711,
0.6300331354,
-0.1429668069,
1.2081152201,
-0.6181689501,
0.1259954423,
-0.4726548493,
-0.0602984242,
-0.2957280874,
-0.3816887438,
-0.4309392571,
-0.5663921833,
0.2273693681,
-0.6341970563,
0.033890795,
0.1792035103,
0.9609240294,
0.2868460417,
-0.8043538928,
-0.1729970872,
-0.6618013978,
0.5550861359,
-0.7357172966,
0.2132657915,
0.7076547146,
0.5461933017,
-0.1185791418,
-0.5514914989,
-0.0459411703,
0.1579872668,
-0.2266630679,
0.394143343,
0.1060501263,
0.1185911894,
0.0027716216,
0.7408056259,
-0.3186933398,
-0.2513184249,
-0.4500784576,
-0.0822223127,
0.6829771399,
0.2806531489,
0.1048543751,
-0.1989630461,
0.057551071,
-0.2803651392,
-0.4889793098,
0.1189710498,
0.3883034885,
0.2802364826,
-0.1026267037,
0.6634112,
0.0332831033,
0.9164646268,
0.4297889173,
-0.0375468247,
0.2116784304,
-0.3373445868,
-0.1569406837,
-0.1547701806,
0.9059394598,
0.8326726556,
0.4662570357,
-0.4483560622,
-0.0394949056,
0.1429574192,
0.226582557,
-0.4107888341,
-0.3750987053,
-0.0369126163,
-0.5773836374,
-0.4511391819,
0.5048871636,
-0.3562602103,
-0.0968188643,
-0.4055353999,
0.6103144288,
-0.0066799391,
-0.0101537127,
-0.1974025667,
-0.2646434903,
0.354550451,
0.048845537,
-0.50215137,
0.2818371356,
0.8601818085,
0.7672322392,
0.0998445898,
-0.2859035432,
-0.8346142173,
0.1805408448,
-0.6471489072,
0.2760973871,
-0.7219569683,
-0.3764233291,
-0.2975575626,
-0.1873635799,
-0.002400239,
-0.2979338169,
0.5761991739,
-0.6020722389,
0.0893824697,
-0.7602068186,
-0.4295859635,
-0.2183189541,
0.2125867158,
-0.7137516737,
1.0242389441,
0.0757548809,
-0.7879662514,
0.5249902606,
-0.4248909056,
-0.701890111,
-0.0443432443,
-0.0655077398,
-0.5041427016,
0.5598794818,
0.1329955459,
0.12569727,
-0.2254831344,
0.5614786148,
-0.574339211,
-0.6022773981,
0.2766471207,
0.0110503267,
0.4192171991,
0.1168972328,
-0.2971043587,
0.059287563,
-0.1973217279,
-0.0230559446,
0.0146673927,
-0.1817255318,
-0.5613923073,
0.1132942364,
-0.5642798543,
0.160176605,
-0.1655910313,
-0.2382660508,
0.242122978,
-0.4419950247,
0.2758419812,
0.8028393984,
-0.2921698391,
0.8151494265,
-0.714197278,
0.311547488,
-0.3270141184,
0.2863894105,
0.1866443455,
-0.8772707582,
-0.8504416943,
0.2720020413,
0.6828761101,
0.4246293008,
-0.7386553884,
0.3162829876,
-0.5454661846,
-0.8413975835,
-0.9088416696,
-0.1975910962,
0.3984709978,
0.5939603448,
0.1797342747,
-0.4961432219,
-0.1155673712,
-0.7568673491,
-0.7476825118,
-0.293556869,
0.2645368278,
0.8175672293,
0.512298882,
0.1209033802,
1.0645745993,
-0.4014165699,
-0.3967368603,
0.2728376389,
0.4036714137,
0.2617962062,
0.4684429765,
0.6293491721,
-0.8552777767,
-0.424472332,
-0.0911050066,
-0.9626332521,
-0.0132199731,
0.2748194933,
-0.0103211803,
-0.0472649671,
0.3616779447,
-0.0124329515,
0.5046899319,
0.8877152205,
-0.7308141589,
0.4849664867,
-0.3584462106,
0.8224824667,
-0.851962626,
0.248824507,
-0.4157925248,
-0.7325208783,
-0.366085887,
0.5096922517,
0.1125772074,
-0.1628401279,
-0.2585876882,
0.2919089198,
-0.0715609938,
-0.3587775826,
-0.0800671205,
0.3473093212,
0.140267998,
0.2642305195,
-0.483435303,
0.7117709517,
0.0717992708,
-0.8581831455,
0.2476471364,
0.342553705,
-0.1185624003,
0.6591261029,
-0.7858803272,
0.4845944345,
-0.0996804684,
0.519338131,
-0.8507689834,
0.0045061489,
0.2226944417,
-0.8690363765,
0.2797144651,
-0.1909549385,
-0.4036875963,
-0.2034865171,
-0.4959500432,
0.9498904347,
0.1838710457,
-0.2141489089,
0.4481182694,
0.4653088152,
0.2502281666,
-0.5777472258,
-0.8000462055,
0.1556094587,
-0.2469245344,
-0.6920298338,
0.2650943696,
-0.2432902306,
-0.2252734154,
0.2315279543,
-0.435765326,
0.0585479774,
0.4078013301,
0.1983745247,
-0.0290799234,
-0.1766678393,
0.1809611619,
-0.002313395,
-0.6169592142,
-0.1435348094,
-0.0913281515,
0.2109351307,
-0.4576149881,
-0.2160793543,
-0.1012882143,
0.2830521166,
0.9595704675,
-0.3331840038,
0.7160103321,
0.5675675869,
-0.2543721497,
0.5138301849,
-0.6456222534,
-0.2365274131,
-0.4212200642,
0.0808856264,
-0.6132019162,
-0.8012276292,
0.5172299743,
-0.0930896848,
0.2694768906,
0.9535829425,
0.1173247918,
-0.6975584626,
1.0744202137,
0.7242500782,
-0.2753741145,
0.066118136,
-0.0835459977,
0.3399536908,
-1.0629643202,
-0.0153329847,
-0.759649992,
-0.9791378379,
-0.9978922009,
-0.3702948689,
0.6383497119,
0.3575933874,
-0.1370804161,
0.4296250045,
-0.234930858,
0.7403377891,
0.5452134013,
0.0258874986,
0.4009285271,
-0.5264011621,
-0.1936385781,
-0.4817475975,
-0.7239072919,
-0.4117263854,
1.1552034616,
0.0944374353,
0.5053871274,
0.4566901624,
0.6538156867,
0.5177818537,
0.4348087609,
-0.8544943333,
0.1895761043,
-0.452595681,
-0.5553489923,
-0.1722943932,
-0.802039206,
-0.7888347507,
0.1327122301,
-0.4367081523,
-0.4741761982,
-0.0753020793,
0.3695858717,
-0.0071376311,
0.4392880797,
-0.4173511565,
0.8940148354,
-0.1896797717,
0.0849580839,
-0.364277333,
-0.8636079431,
0.3801263571,
-0.0915005952,
0.5268354416,
-0.1692323387,
0.09054254,
1.1240092516,
-0.5080034137,
0.3901519477,
0.2997204363,
0.2416476011,
0.0483642071,
0.6808270812,
0.5225569606,
0.1583984345,
-0.3389462829,
0.2710025012,
0.2531224787,
-0.4099951386,
-0.655670166,
0.5816658139,
-0.7347816229,
-0.6871999502,
-0.5476434827,
-0.6642047763,
-0.1304680258,
0.1535324752,
0.3371029496,
0.3806845546,
-0.1749178022,
0.2819877267,
0.2254095823,
0.0411971547,
0.3524977863,
0.3041543663,
-0.219431743,
-0.8189190626,
0.7987776995,
0.1024199203,
0.4802098274,
0.1894524843,
0.7013519406,
0.0035833283,
-0.1108979061,
-0.5027037859,
0.4598316848,
-0.6924560666,
-0.6393448114,
-0.1844926775,
0.1370649487,
-0.4853629172,
-0.5759401917,
-0.4846297503,
-0.575632453,
0.2771026194,
0.0714710578,
0.2895051539,
0.8734564781,
-0.2146329731,
0.2046461552,
-1.0255669355,
0.3142460585,
0.2210183442,
0.6243553758,
-0.3938031793,
-0.7200452089,
-0.0918478519,
0.0733435154,
-0.3213988841,
-0.9925789833,
-0.2323989719,
0.3440819979,
0.3409388065,
0.193233192,
0.318843931,
1.0237073898,
-0.3864610493,
0.6452286839,
0.2560445964,
-1.1671376228,
0.6593523622,
-0.2799617052,
0.5169157982,
1.0484862328,
0.1478312016,
-0.7410156131,
-0.6654827595,
-0.792550087,
-0.5437921882,
0.7450603843,
0.4928201735,
-0.0105962902,
0.1585443169,
0.5900097489,
-0.1581341028,
0.2632867992,
-0.836522162,
-0.7656618357,
0.2658188641,
-0.1397186518,
-0.4318706691,
-0.1404487789,
-0.1973702461,
-0.3357621729,
0.671092093,
-0.1345805079,
0.0298657212,
0.3740424812,
-0.2515330315,
-0.4553963244,
-0.1379413307,
0.5054103136,
0.9203740358,
-0.3480455875,
0.1184096709,
0.1843194664,
-0.206200406,
0.1150714085,
-0.4551191628,
-0.4024010897,
0.2316433936,
0.3528270423,
0.5061545968,
0.5879784226,
0.0918538049,
0.6862643361,
-0.0840078145,
-0.2924520373,
0.3918747306,
-0.5241333246,
-0.004847833,
0.0366565697,
-0.1511179656,
0.5154262185,
0.1004978269,
-0.7170875669,
0.2935091853,
0.3260791004,
-0.7675657868,
-0.3463573158,
0.535099864,
0.5612930059,
-0.7780629992,
0.5179493427,
-0.2617525756,
-0.7911510468,
0.5278899074,
0.275954932,
0.6384577751,
-0.4793185592,
0.1359840035,
0.5309183002,
0.6691214442,
0.1844955087,
-0.009225104,
-0.167595908,
-0.4802846014,
-0.4461408854,
-0.3538889289,
-0.5828846693,
-0.2627115548,
-0.7773305774,
0.3226868808,
-0.1810195297,
-0.4663673937,
-0.3244170249,
-0.0052289995,
-0.7753956318,
0.0796633959,
-0.1724151224,
0.5186644793,
-0.9791047573,
0.5576384664,
0.7475798726,
-0.3359523714,
-0.5334953666,
-0.155269146,
0.0797512978,
-0.4898827374,
0.305737704,
0.0459114388,
-0.1660589725,
-0.3960716724,
0.1166525558,
-1.0220605135,
1.0669384003,
0.4982164204,
-0.2715889513,
-0.030101778,
0.2300206423,
0.1105214357,
0.0822873116,
0.2693283558,
0.5588084459,
0.7852265835,
-0.1504149139,
-1.3868881464,
-0.1466249973,
0.0883238539,
-0.5776288509,
0.7173612714,
-0.7479683161,
0.4698491096,
-0.0770285577,
-0.0554218255,
-0.1517828554,
0.31094262,
-0.0167474356,
0.6077129841,
0.6119917035,
0.7065901756,
0.678193748,
-0.5069554448,
0.8241789341,
-0.1713968962,
0.6051425338,
1.4143072367,
0.0152344815,
0.631275475,
0.5979429483,
-0.2212534994,
0.3246797025,
0.6213191748,
0.1215634793,
0.317212522,
0.0580466911,
0.4041127264,
-0.3012345433,
-0.1311469972,
-0.5140131712,
0.7455158234,
0.1074411273,
-0.1829335392,
-0.1553040892,
-0.5431835651,
0.108958438,
0.227226615,
-0.209824875,
0.957433939,
0.4773628116,
-1.0216104984,
-0.0018273812,
0.154952541,
0.3537724912,
-0.5724260211,
0.1520054191,
-0.2764895856,
0.0536975265,
-0.2767091095,
-0.722848177,
0.6837205291,
-0.1015504524,
-0.1003089026,
-0.1117081866,
0.4496250451,
-0.1252138913,
-0.5281785727,
0.338696599,
0.5433930755,
0.1179565415,
0.0828025118,
-0.6830004454,
-0.1498832703,
-0.3940587938,
0.0326422155,
0.0785844699,
0.3103311062,
0.0452529564,
0.4744921625,
0.5424588919,
-0.0082410732,
-0.2062093616,
-0.0843868479,
0.4329250455,
-0.6140350103,
-0.5421699286,
-0.9716408253,
0.4317481518,
-0.064637877,
-0.5725322366,
0.6155813932,
0.4527262151,
0.5482649207,
0.2879536152,
-0.0002625152,
0.0424554124,
-0.1312776804,
-0.2544927001,
0.864379406,
-0.6746175885,
-0.1724708825,
-0.7172953486,
-1.0466781855,
-0.3909750581,
0.350823164,
-0.1133709326,
-0.0213465709,
0.8668066859,
0.1112468392,
-0.1559350938,
-0.1483918875,
0.4235701263,
-0.2006295472,
0.4506644011,
0.5502960086,
0.372513026,
-1.0812534094,
0.665581286,
-0.1916489005,
-0.2329129279,
-0.4156097472,
-1.1051114798,
-0.6342309117,
-0.6552978754,
-0.438311398,
-0.4036430418,
-0.0859378502,
0.4396579862,
0.8536394835,
-0.5036005378,
-0.3714078069,
0.221576646,
0.4319437146,
-0.4259934127,
-0.1804307997,
0.3996774256,
-0.3247404397,
-0.3979635239,
0.3252354264,
0.4665904045,
-0.1308879256,
0.2782853246,
-0.4495147765,
-0.2462335229,
0.1446175277,
0.5028057098,
-0.0112262107,
-0.932323277,
-0.5331725478,
-0.0470061339,
-0.0042203697,
0.0907897726,
1.0926429033,
-0.8029313087,
0.8707705736,
0.6664765477,
0.7794647217,
0.4770976007,
0.0095769977,
1.1302082539,
-0.6193211079,
-0.0677504167,
0.1755491495,
0.5444375277,
0.3232225478,
-0.0169942435,
0.8713850975,
0.3657368422,
-0.6723196507,
-0.820716083,
0.2877822816,
-0.8916296959,
0.0594646744,
0.5928360224,
-0.1010655686,
0.0896399319,
0.1987092942,
0.0831873119,
0.487937808,
-0.0206637215,
0.7074984908,
0.8070579767,
0.155011043,
0.5265325308,
-0.3469127417,
0.4497328997,
0.8394911885,
-0.3840030134,
-0.0814674646,
-0.0983201265,
0.0865305886,
0.1612873673,
0.5192798972,
-0.1734360009,
0.6218109727,
-0.4771119058,
-0.6022173166,
-0.0670977607,
-0.3003180921,
-0.2972185314,
-0.2656122744,
0.3660437465,
-0.2956553102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14323v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14323v3 | ChatCoT: Tool-Augmented Chain-of-Thought Reasoning on Chat-based Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:54:33 | 2023-11-06T11:00:26 | Zhipeng Chen, Kun Zhou, Beichen Zhang, Zheng Gong, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although large language models (LLMs) have achieved excellent performance in
a variety of evaluation benchmarks, they still struggle in complex reasoning
tasks which require specific knowledge and multi-hop reasoning. To improve the
reasoning abilities, we propose ChatCoT, a tool-augmented chain-of-thought
reasoning framework for chat-based LLMs (e.g., ChatGPT). In ChatCoT, we model
the chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning as multi-turn conversations, to utilize
tools in a more natural way through chatting. At each turn, LLMs can either
interact with tools or perform the reasoning. Our approach can effectively
leverage the multi-turn conversation ability of chat-based LLMs, and integrate
the thought chain following and tools manipulation in a unified way. Specially,
we initialize the early turns of the conversation by the knowledge about tools,
tasks, and reasoning format, and propose an iterative tool-augmented reasoning
step to perform step-by-step tool-augmented reasoning. The experiment results
on two complex reasoning datasets (MATH and HotpotQA) have shown the
effectiveness of ChatCoT on complex reasoning tasks, achieving a 7.9% relative
improvement over the state-of-the-art baseline. Our code and data are available
at: \url{https://github.com/RUCAIBOX/ChatCoT}. | [
-0.4205414653,
-1.0322386026,
0.6364194155,
0.2357116342,
-0.2757840157,
0.7013183832,
-0.4353777766,
-0.4979581833,
0.3341863751,
0.8446906805,
-0.5736716986,
-0.5414763689,
-0.4629439116,
-0.2448575795,
-0.4420733154,
0.7048565745,
-0.0314795561,
-0.0192300696,
-0.1080548391,
0.1339157224,
-0.4435337186,
-0.6688081622,
-0.6604472399,
-0.3139839768,
0.533937335,
0.6281679869,
0.7958974838,
0.0376710445,
0.7409839034,
0.2868877351,
-0.1416438669,
0.8603829741,
-0.4958417416,
0.3874822855,
-0.2013856471,
-0.486961931,
-0.9077807069,
-0.2597278655,
0.1041702703,
0.5698036551,
-0.2601602674,
-0.0808704495,
-0.0709599629,
0.3108670413,
-0.522613585,
0.0798570961,
-1.05715096,
-0.0722495466,
-0.0565323085,
-0.3856102824,
-0.6220309138,
-0.1239656284,
0.10477902,
-0.4901982248,
-0.0424059518,
0.5337567925,
0.3143473566,
-0.0294992141,
-0.3842437863,
-0.3490310609,
-0.8302561045,
0.6270368099,
-0.7398834825,
0.5724751949,
0.2720313668,
0.3803130984,
-0.6978065372,
-0.8416275382,
-0.6736988425,
-0.2817847133,
0.0305925179,
0.1699439883,
0.2353425026,
0.2124506831,
0.4437376261,
0.4159642756,
-0.3014807999,
-0.1297303885,
-0.093120575,
-0.2066297382,
0.5314223766,
0.1409974247,
0.2231274396,
0.1534441411,
-0.3202940226,
-0.0018136073,
-0.749909699,
-0.1732358336,
0.0234307647,
0.3745113611,
0.047689721,
0.6206917167,
-0.086049363,
0.5052084923,
-0.1477909386,
-0.1132224575,
0.0436904728,
-0.3417051733,
-0.3027184606,
0.0583292469,
0.8348844051,
0.3078149855,
0.3365329802,
-0.1615034044,
-0.1491719931,
-0.0961768925,
0.2219015658,
-0.5909337401,
-0.3547666371,
0.5227312446,
0.012015501,
-0.2887425125,
-0.1328098625,
-0.5108946562,
-0.5675785542,
-0.216891706,
0.1736967415,
-0.4810352027,
-0.4706352353,
0.3879297376,
-0.024688853,
0.1404538602,
0.7115081549,
-0.4345114529,
0.4710966349,
0.9044610262,
0.8849974871,
-0.2331355661,
-0.4056458473,
-0.656457305,
0.1327080727,
-0.3131912351,
1.0701766014,
-0.635720849,
-0.4114450216,
-0.1557210237,
-0.1329304725,
0.0287073087,
-0.2510057688,
0.417855233,
-0.4430703223,
0.2900886834,
-0.0732234567,
-0.5204912424,
0.0647045299,
0.6699064374,
-0.520242393,
1.040121913,
-0.2723671198,
-0.9454675317,
0.1920511127,
-0.8578380346,
-0.6526228189,
0.0367333181,
-0.0398947559,
-0.276596427,
-0.2817999721,
0.4114016294,
0.2313691676,
-0.6195674539,
0.3784706295,
-0.6780977249,
-0.2697205544,
0.520078063,
-0.5098576546,
0.7814994454,
0.1262856126,
-0.1948472261,
0.3279744387,
-0.4370228052,
0.3165255785,
-0.0153362667,
-0.0182694569,
0.0332299173,
0.0501740947,
-0.0895042494,
0.3385164142,
0.0723313615,
-0.565623045,
0.6239045858,
-0.3792943358,
0.4895133972,
0.6458249688,
0.1197948158,
0.2276958823,
-0.1916683465,
0.3297054172,
0.307212472,
0.4977279007,
-0.0670185611,
-0.5647505522,
-0.9212507606,
-0.1668931097,
0.2028077394,
0.511913836,
-1.0795900822,
0.229409039,
-0.1073846817,
-0.5064762235,
-0.3822275102,
-0.0511977375,
0.2312246859,
0.2779617608,
0.4330516458,
-0.3520801961,
-0.5612457395,
-0.4935385287,
-0.2438557446,
-0.2592300177,
0.0644992888,
0.1576840729,
0.36294052,
-0.2094802856,
0.8128788471,
-0.6769194603,
-0.0101072676,
-0.4675809145,
0.0580478311,
0.2506721318,
0.3320504725,
-0.0314860381,
-0.5645444989,
-0.3078733087,
0.2402243316,
-0.2106571347,
0.0427316017,
-0.2020140588,
-0.6200610995,
0.023610495,
0.3997364044,
-0.7597963214,
0.3868973851,
0.2500976026,
-0.3391890526,
0.8890421987,
-0.1757957041,
0.257363081,
-1.0047534704,
-0.2000546157,
-0.4167991579,
-0.3996832371,
-0.5794071555,
-0.107563749,
-0.0410251319,
-0.0210294034,
-0.4949179292,
0.4672704935,
-0.3931878209,
-0.0538280345,
-0.3384660482,
0.4402641952,
0.2162958235,
0.7812722325,
0.1403606981,
0.8559993505,
0.6631522179,
-0.421402216,
0.5941300988,
0.2131975889,
-0.1713656187,
0.5003308654,
-0.4843820632,
0.5377799273,
0.3046997786,
0.3836380243,
-0.8529398441,
-0.0424410403,
0.2086026222,
-0.3120088279,
-0.024489101,
-0.1263152659,
-0.7634533048,
-0.5671507716,
-0.1873422116,
0.0638089105,
0.2294689268,
-0.646427691,
0.8178738952,
0.3723680675,
0.0403445289,
-0.4279839993,
-0.4643751979,
0.3546285927,
0.0000299113,
-0.521015048,
0.2536014915,
-0.1382613927,
-0.2414751649,
-0.3064275682,
-0.1665632725,
-0.2045907825,
-0.0899214223,
0.0812590793,
0.4066871703,
0.037128143,
0.4383675456,
0.0072197039,
0.0511386991,
0.0882317722,
-0.5793505311,
0.7710083723,
-0.3787404895,
-0.7630140781,
0.1432993114,
0.211948514,
0.8710581064,
-0.4395305812,
0.6156279445,
0.3820979297,
-0.1746504158,
-0.2769225538,
-0.7549043894,
-0.3259103596,
-0.4596551657,
0.1866866052,
-0.5732813478,
-0.8798123002,
0.5209174156,
-0.4324598014,
0.3658110201,
0.053847082,
0.6899308562,
-0.2521114051,
1.1952111721,
0.1909630746,
0.1896054298,
0.2609986067,
-0.3776877522,
0.507519424,
-0.9925344586,
-0.2445189655,
-0.2042052448,
-0.1568599194,
-0.493576616,
-0.7264004946,
0.2866560519,
-0.0106785987,
-0.3929640055,
0.3234662414,
-0.4607762098,
0.4763502777,
0.5556713939,
0.3379346728,
0.6111057401,
-0.3557049334,
-0.4566957653,
0.4855903685,
-0.9513697028,
-0.3613978624,
0.8563151956,
0.1950231344,
0.8682166338,
-0.0513631478,
0.4103898704,
0.2130001485,
0.3031626642,
-0.9686336517,
0.745441556,
0.260566175,
-0.4728858769,
-0.2925139964,
-0.4581512213,
-0.7191894054,
0.3168181777,
-0.3223841786,
-0.7909883261,
-0.1997769773,
0.2369858176,
-0.0346219316,
0.6389389634,
-0.8266675472,
0.6139172912,
-0.6615201235,
-0.4530790746,
-0.3490866125,
-0.4504620135,
0.4405343831,
0.1680563241,
0.1970240623,
-0.0634430125,
0.3383731246,
0.4335596561,
-0.8740631342,
0.8039948344,
0.1190151051,
-0.203079775,
0.6374224424,
0.3806382716,
0.8228445649,
-0.0237947572,
0.1649387032,
0.0386438966,
0.1500766426,
-0.2203634977,
-0.9587996602,
0.6086443067,
-0.4795251787,
-0.8437781334,
-0.2306097001,
-0.7155781984,
-0.6110460162,
0.2376917452,
-0.2073172927,
0.6057264805,
0.0574745201,
0.0084845899,
0.3634873629,
0.0039847745,
0.0813607424,
0.1793710887,
-0.8127568364,
-0.4731049538,
0.5768030882,
-0.089943707,
0.560184896,
0.3892883062,
0.1946462691,
-0.3029426336,
-0.3004872501,
-0.2880533934,
0.0987927914,
-0.7061217427,
-0.2267287374,
-0.6864623427,
-0.3478038013,
-0.1412225366,
-0.0024582073,
-0.5152683854,
-0.618763566,
0.3203766048,
-0.0250394996,
0.7658063769,
0.38439399,
0.4277572334,
0.3636443913,
-0.5804005861,
0.1282339096,
0.3419964314,
0.6582197547,
0.1919513345,
-0.2198958993,
-0.2184032798,
0.3134429157,
-0.4359444976,
-0.5567758083,
0.0625941977,
-0.1917222142,
0.2303427458,
0.2495159954,
0.137327686,
0.8464133739,
-0.5041848421,
0.4932246804,
0.3686257005,
-0.9239864349,
0.4988640547,
-0.1212263703,
0.408067137,
0.1340931654,
-0.1332428902,
-0.7746219635,
-0.8165528178,
-0.8671540618,
-0.6645483971,
0.453945756,
0.4650186896,
-0.3276007175,
-0.1023748815,
-0.1265936047,
-0.0592275448,
0.1950164586,
-0.3478766084,
0.137934953,
-0.0240544919,
0.025814632,
0.4328303933,
-0.0105578974,
0.0093118884,
-0.2846628129,
0.6966970563,
-0.260944277,
0.3022630811,
0.0830242634,
-0.1059254557,
0.0876475275,
0.439014107,
0.3180070519,
0.7446702719,
-0.191112116,
0.5598098636,
0.5553151965,
-0.5141907334,
-0.0756555498,
-0.2664799392,
0.3949910402,
-0.2206788063,
0.4440130889,
0.8300990462,
0.2129605711,
-0.7423469424,
0.2830069363,
-0.1162044406,
0.018416794,
-0.1396894008,
0.3868239522,
0.413990736,
0.3436379135,
-0.0500567406,
0.174265638,
0.0773092881,
-0.6197417378,
0.1239560917,
0.4949142337,
-0.3869597316,
-0.0258973688,
0.3442983925,
0.4620845318,
-0.6252667308,
0.6454676986,
-0.0913864523,
-0.7754656672,
0.4523775578,
0.5611599684,
0.9342077374,
0.1383005977,
0.1191871539,
0.1306904405,
0.2679856718,
-0.008313613,
0.3950690329,
-0.1930278242,
-0.9663110375,
-0.808888495,
-0.1344235241,
-0.8865712881,
-0.0920226499,
-0.1247444302,
0.5172204971,
-0.3995220363,
-0.318931073,
-0.1990456432,
-0.0772317722,
-0.6697174907,
-0.0410017334,
-0.0083945282,
1.056235075,
-0.2756460607,
0.8483879566,
0.4953468144,
-0.1540047675,
-0.7937926054,
0.0541178621,
-0.2158515304,
-0.7617500424,
0.2391889691,
0.0585416146,
-0.7480247021,
-0.0174911227,
-0.7116746306,
-0.6725962162,
0.9153460264,
0.0676158965,
-0.8774186373,
0.1826183498,
0.1794470102,
0.5353848934,
-0.4344516695,
0.7621740699,
0.546456039,
0.2962241471,
0.7528984547,
-1.1262156963,
-0.1520167738,
-0.1920840293,
-0.2341185659,
0.5396580696,
-0.5391799212,
0.4817897081,
-0.3936613798,
-0.0824250728,
-0.4307164252,
0.4214564264,
0.477026403,
0.1872438937,
0.6524823308,
0.3499621451,
0.9580304027,
-0.059208937,
0.8869125247,
-0.341745466,
0.3278091848,
1.411487937,
-0.5359579921,
0.7804972529,
0.4868001342,
-0.2907082438,
0.6124076247,
0.3464169502,
0.4331066906,
0.1148149595,
0.1469518542,
-0.253393501,
-0.5628623962,
-0.0758948848,
-0.057655178,
0.4434182942,
0.5258939862,
0.1002748981,
-0.0168400072,
0.0507843904,
0.2055442333,
-0.273681432,
-0.2313523442,
0.8032467365,
0.1539422572,
-0.7634725571,
0.542160213,
-0.2629403472,
0.2981939912,
-0.3767706156,
-0.1932871044,
-0.0019295251,
0.2490337044,
-0.1104600355,
-1.2945781946,
0.1020936742,
0.0874255598,
0.1825513989,
-0.207488969,
0.9198723435,
-0.6089280248,
-0.5896294117,
0.2080779672,
0.7539762855,
0.1146142036,
-0.2095893621,
-0.7272270322,
0.0144069325,
-0.0599960238,
-0.1001524478,
-0.0991649628,
0.8173670769,
-0.2748159766,
1.0234197378,
0.8931624889,
0.233631447,
-0.3038499057,
0.5153948665,
1.1279046535,
-0.6276053786,
-0.4137041867,
-0.9243402481,
0.4550971687,
-0.5320872664,
-0.1013602838,
0.4894710183,
0.5549334288,
0.5967775583,
0.081279628,
0.6397220492,
-0.0598842129,
0.6278703809,
-0.6312306523,
0.4365319014,
-0.1731541157,
0.4857628942,
-0.3095194995,
-0.8821004033,
-0.2488149554,
0.4517363012,
-0.6233765483,
-0.1127342358,
1.0300825834,
0.8574172258,
-0.2785289586,
0.357573241,
0.2065748721,
0.3225082159,
0.6781166196,
0.60644871,
1.0250946283,
0.0064227036,
0.6117122173,
-0.163786009,
-0.205746904,
-0.0828074589,
-0.9172602892,
-1.1299011707,
-0.4350972772,
-0.3116995394,
-0.3469233215,
0.0360756218,
1.3481662273,
0.5474815369,
-0.6997438073,
-0.3563359678,
-0.4061291516,
0.4791057706,
-0.3765850067,
-0.2117289901,
0.2320650369,
-0.4270382524,
-0.4049627483,
0.1015214622,
0.6770820022,
-0.2180662304,
-0.4080277681,
0.009312449,
-0.5150519013,
0.194281891,
0.934697032,
-0.1851512045,
-0.7433560491,
-0.5000133514,
0.2172929943,
0.1152132377,
0.2818623483,
1.0812808275,
-0.7081158161,
0.7024030685,
0.3625705242,
0.3041426241,
0.6961181164,
-0.1010953858,
0.6074213982,
-0.4654409587,
0.1338977367,
0.3704594374,
0.498452276,
0.2430314124,
-0.294210583,
0.5085882545,
0.0334957503,
-0.4791807532,
-0.6865539551,
0.4755199552,
-0.964216888,
-0.219147414,
1.0636367798,
0.0485840403,
-0.312910527,
-0.2274459004,
-0.8698931932,
0.2669645548,
-0.2858192623,
0.8289352059,
0.8557485342,
-0.3419528306,
-0.4493660927,
-0.124316752,
0.2353108227,
0.1398081779,
-1.154411912,
0.4810329676,
0.2849928737,
-0.0958106667,
0.1027480289,
0.6092289686,
-0.0314774923,
0.0615940653,
-0.124030754,
0.1844341755,
-0.0647197664,
-0.4778515399,
0.6503208876,
-0.1591691971,
0.2137986422,
0.0141989831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14322v1 | RET-LLM: Towards a General Read-Write Memory for Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:53:38 | 2023-05-23T17:53:38 | Ali Modarressi, Ayyoob Imani, Mohsen Fayyaz, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of natural
language processing (NLP) through their extensive parameters and comprehensive
data utilization. However, existing LLMs lack a dedicated memory unit, limiting
their ability to explicitly store and retrieve knowledge for various tasks. In
this paper, we propose RET-LLM a novel framework that equips LLMs with a
general write-read memory unit, allowing them to extract, store, and recall
knowledge from the text as needed for task performance. Inspired by Davidsonian
semantics theory, we extract and save knowledge in the form of triplets. The
memory unit is designed to be scalable, aggregatable, updatable, and
interpretable. Through qualitative evaluations, we demonstrate the superiority
of our proposed framework over baseline approaches in question answering tasks.
Moreover, our framework exhibits robust performance in handling temporal-based
question answering tasks, showcasing its ability to effectively manage
time-dependent information. | [
0.13233459,
-0.9244497418,
0.7436766028,
0.1413896233,
-0.2967714965,
0.1396948695,
-0.1524970382,
-0.3563366532,
0.2433386743,
0.6643242836,
-0.3930605948,
-0.6160079241,
-0.3066591918,
0.0405218154,
-0.5369158983,
0.7032360435,
-0.3105414808,
-0.4738923609,
-0.1733288467,
-0.1485518217,
-0.5530847907,
-0.5527399182,
-0.8414942026,
-0.1402910054,
0.9734500647,
0.3637934625,
0.4950785041,
0.6787325144,
0.4716455936,
0.1838734597,
0.2068697661,
0.3242403269,
-0.307995975,
0.4237267077,
-0.1203108951,
-0.7570970058,
-0.7947386503,
-0.2662574351,
1.0899660587,
0.4504350424,
-0.2156892121,
0.1558731198,
-0.1377983093,
0.5918474793,
-0.4524788558,
0.1454548389,
-0.6285910606,
0.0959138498,
-0.0231714118,
-0.5353755951,
-0.5783726573,
-0.3918824792,
0.2460548878,
-0.6720983386,
0.2388123721,
0.3490026891,
0.4082911015,
0.2668362558,
-0.3801404834,
-0.1105441749,
-0.8016364574,
0.7833939791,
-0.5130626559,
0.5364544988,
0.3537344635,
0.2081001699,
0.0167335812,
-0.7218852639,
-0.5575056672,
0.0451462157,
0.0549058057,
0.009255413,
-0.0903895572,
-0.0794783607,
-0.1027978137,
0.3914093673,
-0.5975928307,
-0.1318940967,
-0.0276525002,
0.121611394,
0.3004240692,
0.445408076,
0.4349292219,
-0.0501694418,
-0.5505979657,
0.4773620367,
-0.7554852366,
-0.285373956,
0.079727672,
0.26660043,
-0.0136146778,
0.5135881901,
-0.0875471234,
0.670047164,
-0.2062747627,
0.0103565613,
-0.0961676911,
-0.2593772709,
-0.2516602576,
-0.3393675387,
0.624417007,
0.2180326581,
0.3487973511,
-0.7281495333,
-0.1802137792,
-0.4194067419,
0.4109303057,
-0.8521374464,
-0.1018864438,
0.116079323,
-0.3171855509,
-0.2295290679,
-0.2288772911,
-0.632232964,
-0.0421707816,
-0.4168911576,
0.3993106782,
-0.5093910098,
-0.3090334237,
0.3606164157,
0.1403131485,
0.4183344543,
0.3214079142,
-1.0718218088,
0.5167184472,
0.6260709763,
0.9438884258,
-0.5088091493,
-0.2550668716,
-0.5063427091,
0.8441175222,
-0.0725130588,
0.7899846435,
-0.572419405,
-0.1876974404,
-0.0035152871,
0.034195561,
-0.2958871126,
-0.2786976397,
0.4396319985,
-0.9300509095,
0.2198205143,
-0.2979078591,
-0.5625455379,
-0.2032350749,
0.4948568642,
-0.5839762092,
0.7993523479,
-0.0212353189,
-0.8509694934,
0.1683794707,
-0.4237739742,
-0.5532915592,
0.0542369001,
0.0264418516,
-0.2542605102,
0.1143711284,
0.3237197697,
0.5738809109,
-0.696588099,
0.445160687,
-0.0924683809,
-0.3702017963,
0.1844196171,
-0.5550982356,
0.4032855034,
0.0565032437,
0.2689514458,
0.0482793003,
-0.7243307233,
0.1067605168,
0.1665280163,
-0.881922543,
-0.1761825681,
0.1190041676,
-0.2842871845,
-0.2476391792,
0.3688828051,
-0.8414782286,
0.32077384,
-0.1551827937,
0.6132004261,
0.550576508,
0.0054913196,
0.5160970688,
-0.515809834,
0.5167582631,
-0.0179218929,
-0.2373431772,
-0.1360852122,
-0.0600818396,
-0.894210875,
-0.2572167516,
0.1298578978,
0.6892852187,
-0.8218670487,
0.1016394421,
-0.4482081532,
-0.1323537081,
-0.354760766,
0.2723333538,
0.3386556804,
0.5897485018,
0.4114722311,
0.3145817816,
-0.5570241213,
-1.0820537806,
-0.4573864937,
-0.2979972959,
-0.153654933,
0.2508716881,
0.2637889981,
-0.3562643528,
0.9914562702,
-0.7410253882,
-0.2375271022,
-0.439063549,
0.0410884283,
0.1837777197,
0.2060766518,
0.0684369653,
-0.5469127297,
-0.1133997217,
-0.2566746771,
-0.8993433118,
-0.1268334687,
-0.0661215931,
-0.198365435,
0.3317059577,
0.6295371056,
-0.6022629142,
-0.0620069019,
0.2549849749,
-0.2520158887,
0.4464308023,
-0.3371724486,
0.0567605458,
-1.3354929686,
0.1475241333,
-0.4000889659,
-0.4002354443,
-0.558663249,
-0.0496138372,
0.2153730392,
0.25422436,
-0.3638581932,
0.6463391781,
-0.5211632252,
-0.1655517668,
-0.1636707187,
0.3049363792,
0.1667923927,
0.4869134724,
0.2238721102,
0.6873899698,
0.2056669146,
-0.6061020494,
0.3997313082,
0.2163813412,
-0.0363243595,
0.5052188039,
-0.612349987,
0.2629262507,
-0.1030638441,
0.1636249423,
-0.8282668591,
-0.1250813603,
-0.0872272104,
-0.3305829167,
0.4570635557,
-0.0561104901,
-0.749166131,
-0.2977326512,
-0.0955344364,
0.5206731558,
0.1721080393,
-0.4420430958,
1.0769313574,
0.2944664359,
-0.3392960727,
-0.5462423563,
-0.9247906208,
0.0714526847,
-0.2433622777,
-0.8534801006,
0.1493243277,
0.1536509842,
0.0652302578,
0.1852742881,
0.0848834142,
-0.1213201582,
-0.083724916,
0.0284462608,
0.3094268143,
-0.5124760866,
0.6522239447,
-0.2369639426,
-0.4062941372,
0.1390686333,
-0.5033823848,
0.5384123325,
-0.467358917,
-0.2091802806,
-0.295609504,
0.4530454874,
0.3341269195,
-0.1458273232,
0.6621041298,
0.4431288242,
-0.4236661494,
-0.2672688365,
-0.6889400482,
-0.0193542782,
-0.4185828567,
0.5238527656,
-0.3230470717,
-1.2571310997,
0.4963731766,
0.0801709071,
0.3698049486,
0.3852698207,
0.6070793271,
-0.1925726831,
0.4988442659,
0.604111433,
-0.1536886394,
0.238562271,
-0.0168100707,
0.3075176179,
-1.0429881811,
-0.0400656126,
-0.2092039287,
-0.3582758009,
-0.0589776747,
-0.5194571614,
-0.1109335795,
0.0817129314,
-0.4786420763,
0.1296198964,
-0.1727715582,
0.6308228374,
0.443787843,
-0.2657210231,
0.7615236044,
-0.1875832379,
-0.1170060933,
0.0228538513,
-0.6347301006,
-0.6893620491,
1.1485505104,
0.3190713823,
0.8476299047,
0.3273698688,
0.6860483885,
0.027156163,
0.2621311247,
-0.5259840488,
0.6808822751,
-0.2206247598,
-0.542963326,
-0.2722350955,
-0.5175039172,
-0.8650981188,
0.2536771297,
0.1575880647,
-0.6790835857,
-0.2894067764,
0.1954259872,
-0.4718928337,
0.9460387826,
-0.7436478734,
0.58316046,
-0.2650715709,
-0.3608059883,
-0.0959378481,
-0.5797471404,
0.5250102282,
-0.1098155826,
-0.0374728628,
-0.0613939799,
-0.5292057395,
0.9487535357,
-0.0012953304,
0.8583954573,
-0.0463129133,
-0.053872481,
0.4021236002,
0.4163173735,
0.308732152,
0.3344607949,
0.0539032668,
-0.1867606938,
0.4035767615,
-0.2176635414,
-0.5816841125,
0.7426162958,
-0.7637078166,
-0.5948083997,
-0.3476525247,
-1.0255891085,
-0.4670167267,
0.2789649665,
-0.1925707012,
0.5423820615,
-0.3718571961,
0.3281819522,
0.7595207691,
-0.2081429809,
0.446798116,
0.8540145755,
-0.525424242,
-0.3075741827,
0.924457252,
0.0045539825,
0.4578552246,
0.9419475198,
0.2025488168,
-0.3534802496,
-0.6031309366,
-0.2062520981,
0.3311809599,
-0.4668118358,
-0.2688013017,
-1.0245640278,
-0.2815565467,
-0.137977615,
-0.2683582902,
-0.1749848872,
-0.5377845168,
-0.2294720858,
-0.1543713063,
0.4476315081,
0.826178968,
-0.0135068931,
0.4786026776,
-0.7881219983,
0.7031405568,
0.4877398014,
0.5883437395,
-0.0197506826,
-0.4320261776,
-0.0451148786,
-0.1990251541,
-0.1433289796,
-0.3420497477,
0.3835164607,
0.0544270985,
0.3073741198,
-0.0560456663,
-0.0305263083,
0.2448624372,
-0.3559287786,
0.4982801974,
0.0293648634,
-0.5498706698,
0.2483682036,
-0.6921869516,
0.4825318456,
0.5378956199,
-0.0590398908,
-0.930559814,
-0.2701254487,
-0.4435983002,
-0.8106276989,
0.5956776142,
-0.0618892536,
-0.1165829003,
-0.1500068456,
0.5070670843,
0.0943462998,
0.2183751166,
-0.5158435106,
0.1182729304,
0.1524707824,
-0.2875500023,
-0.0396500938,
-0.7544366717,
0.1690631211,
-0.0534613878,
0.5021568537,
-0.0416773334,
0.4789690971,
0.1501331478,
-0.3690000772,
0.0409277081,
0.5849812031,
0.3674989939,
0.4951340258,
-0.5726883411,
0.4615024626,
0.3080634177,
-0.7488015294,
0.1310053915,
-0.2416264713,
-0.3851744533,
-0.4619092047,
0.4505744278,
0.3509286642,
0.4459623992,
-0.4465644062,
0.1968879104,
-0.3892753124,
-0.3047414422,
-0.3975842893,
-0.056783285,
0.7989435792,
0.2628177702,
0.1487952322,
-0.3586833477,
-0.2012123913,
-0.4777328372,
0.2704078853,
0.1600421667,
-0.3068884909,
-0.3339188397,
0.6336275339,
0.3595556021,
-0.2857461572,
0.7437070608,
-0.0060640052,
-0.328989774,
0.2920883298,
0.8020242453,
1.0236020088,
0.01262978,
0.0080489237,
0.2753669918,
0.2845952809,
0.0494292714,
0.6281863451,
0.1548124254,
-0.9404418468,
-0.3874051869,
-0.8617601991,
-0.2360563129,
-0.0678388402,
-0.5146699548,
-0.1301673055,
-0.6107094884,
0.1032849699,
-0.3577868044,
0.1199557781,
-0.6711904407,
-0.0035359384,
-0.2171443552,
0.7206130028,
-0.4900937378,
1.0327965021,
0.2693254054,
-0.3250962496,
-0.660379827,
-0.3065691292,
-0.0941906869,
-0.9529320002,
0.6480035186,
0.0009248212,
-0.2619301677,
0.2852269411,
-0.2315992415,
-0.8937885761,
1.2926775217,
0.2881480455,
-0.5966081023,
-0.3595720828,
0.2094781697,
0.3918761909,
-0.6586074233,
-0.1151684672,
0.8545127511,
0.4356095493,
0.1744613498,
-0.4032583535,
0.109363541,
-0.0848300084,
-0.1736966521,
0.3426864743,
-0.5472455025,
0.8928063512,
-0.3819652796,
-0.2810834348,
0.0711953864,
0.664509356,
0.2641995251,
-0.0540781952,
0.2431028783,
0.7691319585,
0.8077754974,
-0.0855794922,
1.2389348745,
0.0426240228,
-0.0212591756,
1.4113075733,
-0.184699893,
1.0398645401,
0.4182668924,
-0.0971301049,
0.161668092,
0.1640967429,
0.3550958633,
0.26164639,
0.165590629,
-0.341879189,
-0.4300735593,
0.0829987898,
-0.0650908798,
0.1002856344,
0.2430721521,
-0.2666448057,
-0.3097162247,
-0.2952625751,
0.1081663296,
-0.1436727643,
-0.2383234948,
0.8026198745,
0.3545598388,
-0.3305778801,
0.277726233,
-0.1127133742,
0.5757389069,
-0.5732825398,
0.0967564136,
0.012279016,
0.5002817512,
-0.1003000513,
-1.0944069624,
0.5661423802,
-0.0647413433,
-0.5317399502,
-0.3527267575,
0.660990119,
-0.5721668005,
-0.6244142652,
0.3160333037,
0.6966850162,
-0.0090355473,
-0.0152476812,
-0.3036910892,
-0.165039748,
-0.0942535326,
-0.2743675113,
0.1815325469,
0.6213703156,
0.085051097,
0.9058089852,
0.5215175748,
0.1655646265,
0.1425236166,
0.2236834317,
0.5466572642,
-0.9506579638,
-0.2985281646,
-0.7380111217,
0.1864046603,
0.212289229,
-0.2659406662,
0.5447731018,
0.6370460391,
0.27866292,
0.2223617435,
0.8398248553,
0.0855626538,
1.0019879341,
-0.5923512578,
0.6441376805,
-0.3002780378,
0.2949965,
0.0757290572,
-0.9318924546,
-0.5038920045,
0.2214484662,
-0.528380692,
-0.1604322493,
0.8022894859,
0.5778664947,
0.0101932753,
0.3546102345,
0.3349197507,
0.4539670348,
0.7409596443,
1.0646055937,
0.783973515,
-0.1798731834,
0.5417286754,
0.3232688606,
0.087675713,
-0.0751361847,
-0.8570982814,
-0.9708046913,
-0.5648061037,
0.0153089417,
0.0617543459,
0.1400450617,
0.5366578698,
0.1790781468,
-0.5046311617,
-0.1379040927,
0.0314882994,
0.1224523187,
0.3100736141,
-0.1254466176,
0.5974979401,
-0.392139703,
-0.2647181749,
0.2017686665,
0.4799993038,
-0.0076823505,
-0.189075619,
-0.0058439891,
-0.4799640775,
0.0582110696,
0.6375865936,
0.346608609,
-0.5881528258,
-0.5404767394,
0.1272574216,
-0.0256067831,
0.0125524532,
0.8586283922,
-0.7638205886,
0.2412908822,
0.6016820073,
0.9738159776,
0.6215337515,
-0.1293501109,
0.9325184822,
-0.5178929567,
-0.1866700798,
0.4268414974,
0.4811376929,
0.3566202521,
-0.1444368064,
0.4349024892,
0.0297886413,
-0.7077871561,
-0.4712486565,
0.2506661117,
-1.0943652391,
-0.0803036541,
1.2908104658,
-0.0118152546,
-0.3556722999,
-0.3538073897,
-0.0728243589,
0.0991328806,
-0.30072698,
0.4027449489,
0.5978756547,
0.1849167198,
-0.2198843509,
-0.8303769231,
0.2155179828,
0.1693132371,
-0.6487014294,
0.5269438624,
0.3869785666,
0.5964002609,
-0.2506169677,
0.8840796351,
-0.2683971524,
0.0277540926,
-0.224570483,
0.0694034845,
-0.3261058927,
-0.4728074074,
-0.0595621914,
0.3765674531,
-0.0020898608,
0.0336856917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14321v1 | ConGraT: Self-Supervised Contrastive Pretraining for Joint Graph and Text Embeddings | 2023-05-23T17:53:30 | 2023-05-23T17:53:30 | William Brannon, Suyash Fulay, Hang Jiang, Wonjune Kang, Brandon Roy, Jad Kabbara, Deb Roy | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose ConGraT(Contrastive Graph-Text pretraining), a general,
self-supervised method for jointly learning separate representations of texts
and nodes in a parent (or ``supervening'') graph, where each text is associated
with one of the nodes. Datasets fitting this paradigm are common, from social
media (users and posts), to citation networks over articles, to link graphs
over web pages. We expand on prior work by providing a general,
self-supervised, joint pretraining method, one which does not depend on
particular dataset structure or a specific task. Our method uses two separate
encoders for graph nodes and texts, which are trained to align their
representations within a common latent space. Training uses a batch-wise
contrastive learning objective inspired by prior work on joint text and image
encoding. As graphs are more structured objects than images, we also extend the
training objective to incorporate information about node similarity and
plausible next guesses in matching nodes and texts. Experiments on various
datasets reveal that ConGraT outperforms strong baselines on various downstream
tasks, including node and text category classification and link prediction.
Code and certain datasets are available at
https://github.com/wwbrannon/congrat. | [
-0.232986182,
-0.4536291361,
0.4203451872,
-0.033965975,
-0.5521168709,
0.2258369327,
-0.1994363815,
-0.3541883826,
0.7021965981,
0.3783443272,
-0.2727075815,
-0.8468847871,
-0.6345669627,
0.3159357309,
-0.2633802891,
1.272854805,
-0.18614842,
0.2016190737,
-0.6473318338,
-0.2563404739,
-0.1421693563,
-0.6605135202,
-0.3084653914,
-0.2563495636,
0.9058824182,
0.2481189519,
0.4301791787,
0.641587317,
0.6397789121,
0.3833075166,
0.2207921743,
0.3957104087,
-0.7008843422,
0.2347589433,
-0.3665198386,
-0.081429489,
-0.1800210923,
0.122227408,
0.6230232716,
0.7983304262,
0.3637449741,
0.0032853696,
0.5433392525,
0.7734768987,
-0.8802896738,
0.2356669009,
-0.1922182143,
0.0830173716,
-0.1349589974,
-0.3953800797,
-0.4894146621,
-0.4813477695,
-0.2456168532,
-0.7519868612,
0.3094438016,
0.2435152829,
0.7428799272,
0.3014286757,
-0.6238307357,
-0.2432277054,
-0.442854017,
0.5737103224,
-0.0643175691,
0.5090632439,
0.2999494374,
-0.0991047323,
-0.093798779,
-1.2753469944,
-0.390740186,
0.0300853103,
-0.4648862183,
0.5126442909,
0.0421457365,
0.2686853111,
0.0509917587,
0.485886693,
-0.5705277324,
-0.0342047624,
-0.1861862987,
-0.1410804838,
0.4731394053,
-0.2740441263,
0.2512764633,
-0.0982064977,
-0.6057595611,
-0.24438788,
-0.4838714004,
-0.2841666639,
0.5991607904,
0.4389738739,
-0.2437942624,
0.3572499156,
-0.1914737672,
0.5437430739,
0.0603594631,
0.2819667459,
0.5409964919,
-0.5942547321,
-0.0927513465,
0.0994504392,
1.2315717936,
0.3187779188,
0.3035090864,
-0.2980600595,
0.1002844945,
-0.0012169918,
0.1651663929,
-0.7778711915,
-0.8332567215,
-0.1024550945,
-0.5498584509,
-0.2499758899,
0.1532316357,
-0.4311123192,
-0.3263961077,
-0.2497625351,
0.6081447005,
-0.3454930484,
-0.0352146029,
-0.1590529531,
-0.3420808613,
-0.3150140941,
0.2580073178,
-0.9493131042,
0.4089476466,
0.527451396,
0.7236614227,
-0.1413637996,
-0.5931510925,
-0.6349807978,
0.2339586616,
-0.2567608058,
0.9554212093,
-0.6455504298,
-0.3215897083,
0.0555594489,
0.0813379362,
-0.1781357378,
-0.2314480394,
0.5678578615,
-0.4411505163,
0.3620301783,
-0.26106897,
-0.7553143501,
0.092103608,
0.3495981097,
-0.794246316,
0.9793015122,
0.2573367655,
-1.5633311272,
0.2338795364,
-0.1605171114,
-0.690948844,
-0.0855042562,
-0.3940881789,
-0.5666528344,
-0.1431563795,
0.247361213,
0.4810832143,
-0.0450221114,
-0.1120005399,
-0.4905360341,
-0.4755563736,
-0.1590301692,
0.0386492126,
0.5537144542,
0.1009109244,
-0.0309730582,
0.2095393986,
-0.4418280721,
0.0428338498,
0.2237627208,
-0.1158524901,
-0.6083152294,
-0.2334355116,
-0.1367736459,
0.1586092114,
0.641695559,
-0.5119589567,
0.1086772606,
-0.1329934448,
0.2079394758,
0.5543441772,
-0.0519093536,
0.3119452298,
-0.0528520979,
0.2820731699,
0.0501170047,
0.1267374456,
-0.5214676261,
-0.185048759,
-0.43927145,
-0.1372947842,
0.6615098715,
0.3567931056,
-0.9426028132,
0.6513643861,
-0.1687679887,
-0.4843786359,
-0.1162538826,
0.3241454065,
0.856061697,
0.6501362324,
0.6059319973,
-0.7922555208,
-0.6350100636,
-0.7620531321,
-0.0928815305,
-0.1896290779,
0.2372351736,
0.1434231251,
0.5102449656,
0.0318312235,
0.6917991042,
-0.6091070771,
-0.594473362,
-0.1268711537,
0.3705225587,
-0.1045137048,
0.6935727596,
0.4676623642,
-0.9194107652,
-0.7821279764,
-0.1473042369,
-1.0359710455,
0.134404704,
0.2399369925,
-0.1292968392,
-0.2443085313,
0.968940556,
-0.1609813571,
0.093393974,
0.8657338619,
-0.0800865442,
0.6677780747,
-0.4369536042,
0.3890038729,
-1.3448082209,
-0.1156614348,
0.087287344,
-0.4741587639,
-0.2823642194,
-0.3586978912,
0.0365322754,
0.0006456088,
-0.1391791552,
0.2735337317,
-0.6342340112,
-0.0669965148,
-0.100498043,
0.2311093509,
0.1478808224,
0.4957807958,
-0.0356572419,
0.6708451509,
0.4553276002,
-0.2833266258,
0.2284164429,
0.4082406461,
0.0224691927,
0.8462354541,
-0.7045844793,
0.3331935406,
-0.0767995492,
0.6056569815,
-1.3865536451,
-0.1604121476,
0.3280149996,
-0.5110825896,
0.479862839,
-0.2170815617,
-0.5787130594,
-0.5181706548,
-0.4973578751,
0.5464547276,
0.0599648468,
-0.7289055586,
0.3411352038,
0.4775787592,
-0.0464777201,
-0.7369198799,
-0.6230751276,
-0.0877072141,
0.0815020055,
-0.1521361023,
0.6042382717,
-0.053880278,
0.4765231311,
0.3342828155,
0.0561169647,
-0.1520102769,
-0.0208929367,
0.4093099535,
0.0586889982,
0.0680166408,
0.3713415265,
0.0060683987,
-0.5457293987,
-0.0950649604,
-0.5950204134,
0.4795162976,
-0.03496534,
-0.5728038549,
-0.4557622075,
0.2419104874,
-0.2540152371,
-0.264964819,
0.5676168203,
0.8475717306,
-0.270201087,
0.1066684648,
-0.348518014,
-0.0424275286,
-0.4890465438,
0.3464720547,
-0.2836766243,
-1.1929774284,
0.2762822211,
-0.4364891946,
-0.3002981544,
0.5065018535,
0.2555782199,
-0.4801207185,
1.0313494205,
0.8250616193,
-0.1231869087,
0.7385454774,
-0.3516370952,
0.0578591526,
-0.6677598953,
-0.1674070954,
-0.5506616235,
-0.407348156,
-0.9459980726,
-0.33044976,
-0.0039470894,
0.2758367658,
-0.3774698973,
0.4017468989,
-0.7675490975,
0.650372386,
0.5976458788,
0.3483947814,
0.2803513706,
0.0244572684,
-0.2470711172,
-0.2376082391,
-0.7428079247,
-0.2368993163,
1.0344386101,
-0.1044102684,
0.8485108614,
-0.6052551866,
1.4028679132,
0.3613387942,
0.4665903449,
-0.355273366,
0.3187633157,
-0.6229992509,
-0.1290015429,
-0.1137202606,
-0.5653206706,
-1.2033450603,
-0.0852695704,
-0.3960573375,
-0.5149407983,
0.126093775,
0.5044348836,
0.0016253578,
0.3679098785,
-0.7924798131,
1.2497398853,
-0.1607679576,
-0.3711720705,
-0.1965107918,
-0.8512362242,
-0.1156856939,
0.2002709955,
0.0044637267,
0.1630426645,
0.0608138256,
0.9219018817,
-0.2149423063,
0.9513686299,
-0.0601240434,
0.3104842901,
0.2836260498,
-0.106370911,
0.5464670658,
-0.3513815105,
0.0680647343,
0.0511672534,
-0.2446909845,
-0.4783608913,
-0.6085329652,
0.7348653078,
-0.7895280123,
-0.2023756057,
-0.261562109,
-0.128878504,
-0.1391853392,
0.4179724455,
0.3781617582,
0.5490740538,
-0.5365854502,
0.3310693204,
0.3477240503,
0.2133676112,
0.1868739426,
-0.0842117518,
-0.1193683073,
-0.9716289043,
1.1311056614,
0.0660321712,
0.0860222578,
0.6350984573,
0.1437343806,
-0.5559465885,
-0.5517416,
0.0908602476,
0.3891189992,
-0.9976960421,
-0.256916374,
-0.7676182389,
-0.2739577889,
-0.4171023667,
-0.4108004272,
-0.5697314143,
-0.3006283045,
-0.3400968313,
-0.0511152707,
0.0134584224,
1.0019366741,
-0.2330506295,
0.3342511952,
-0.5803868771,
0.1539035887,
0.4027174115,
0.4702872932,
-0.2115353942,
-0.2285850346,
-0.6935956478,
-0.3419911265,
-0.2986837924,
-0.6912401319,
0.1347892284,
0.1789448112,
0.6544395685,
0.2232837081,
0.3037827611,
0.3852472901,
-0.3931668997,
0.5582564473,
0.6522194147,
-0.5796993375,
0.5236893892,
-0.2130988389,
-0.0551666431,
1.0278029442,
0.8502580523,
-0.1344286799,
-0.3509728611,
-0.8502787352,
-0.8181095719,
0.188484773,
0.2197129279,
0.0985701159,
-0.2784076929,
0.2869423926,
0.0775757208,
0.2773552239,
-0.6535547376,
-0.4455423355,
-0.4015990496,
-0.5632103682,
-0.3516566157,
-0.3624632359,
-0.2801498175,
-0.1647739559,
0.295825392,
-0.5197567344,
0.2133051753,
0.4384990335,
-0.3236199915,
0.166565612,
-0.0326034613,
-0.1201504022,
0.4395577908,
-0.0267355274,
0.6631593704,
0.2095144987,
-0.3312045634,
0.1221504509,
0.4202359319,
0.1587956101,
-0.0548579283,
0.5472516418,
0.4578109384,
0.6393420696,
0.0403050855,
0.6465445757,
-0.172376439,
-0.2163797915,
0.0134345479,
-0.1128972694,
0.1000321805,
0.1915908605,
0.1834938973,
-0.2037331164,
0.1743014753,
-0.2664031386,
0.3749561012,
0.2503344119,
-0.774566412,
-0.4320018589,
0.7471907139,
0.4131274223,
-0.236874029,
0.2608231902,
-0.5594218969,
-0.5852811933,
0.4878400862,
0.8505838513,
0.8711801767,
-0.0373684354,
0.3576016426,
0.6513599157,
-0.1152506843,
-0.0309383813,
0.0430192463,
-0.3547643125,
-0.7720278502,
-0.3130835593,
-0.476765126,
-0.7332140803,
-0.4028408229,
-0.4733820558,
0.1954644173,
-0.3367824554,
-0.1939079911,
0.0696404204,
0.2660365701,
-0.6974956393,
0.4060475528,
-0.0057660085,
0.4486009181,
-1.0857992172,
0.7310769558,
0.947380662,
-0.5488173962,
-0.5876316428,
0.021920817,
-0.2586944699,
-0.4626134038,
0.6062383056,
0.4615077376,
-0.3488282859,
0.3993137479,
-0.745153904,
-0.634477973,
0.9913763404,
0.5738388896,
-0.3089157641,
0.1780416518,
-0.116005145,
0.6108503938,
-0.5650016069,
0.463955909,
-0.0458674729,
0.1936307549,
0.0042072469,
-0.5374090672,
0.1350694299,
-0.3981076181,
-0.0832113773,
0.0153636932,
-0.8909084201,
0.6801610589,
-0.0674551576,
-0.2601004243,
-0.1916911602,
1.0434888601,
0.1770975888,
0.4160381854,
0.6450608373,
0.7804480195,
0.8322761059,
-0.0563340299,
1.1766489744,
-0.6516646743,
0.4988985956,
1.3623597622,
-0.0692815855,
0.6730005145,
0.1531661004,
-0.1255864501,
0.9386669397,
0.7239528298,
0.2104631215,
0.5115776062,
-0.1781354398,
-0.0382217988,
-0.4340517223,
-0.4955848157,
-0.6432804465,
0.1932639033,
0.0244193915,
-0.5284481049,
-0.2659868598,
-0.3826114535,
-0.0818384662,
0.4190842211,
-0.0149897477,
0.7084296942,
0.2412588149,
-0.3968021274,
0.1759790182,
-0.4902214706,
0.674061358,
-0.6353743672,
0.0482432544,
0.0228096582,
0.1359342784,
-0.2838646472,
-0.9833292961,
0.0684571192,
-0.4808679223,
-0.1535979211,
-0.4315006137,
1.0859105587,
-0.5427206755,
-0.2487995476,
0.6654274464,
0.489821434,
0.1270906478,
0.0639603734,
-0.7669497132,
-0.1257118881,
-0.2268853933,
-0.1603663713,
0.4597817659,
0.6142699122,
0.1971930712,
0.291138798,
0.6370568871,
-0.1693999618,
-0.4858289659,
0.4524567127,
1.1979448795,
-0.7572237253,
-0.720484972,
-0.7844886184,
0.2932096422,
-0.388851732,
-0.2773118317,
0.9059845209,
0.8331535459,
0.9900388718,
0.2442142814,
0.6399877667,
0.1850074232,
0.2665800452,
-0.3346919715,
0.4482425153,
-0.5808935165,
-0.4369854927,
-0.4757582545,
-0.8932759166,
-0.3257391751,
0.3570100069,
-0.383559227,
0.3250829577,
0.8803774714,
0.5773035884,
-0.0904293954,
-0.1218511835,
0.1126228571,
-0.0501489788,
0.0358020253,
0.4103188813,
0.7463897467,
-0.342063725,
0.8010300398,
-0.4346467853,
-0.1524977237,
-0.1888494343,
-0.9531723857,
-1.0163171291,
-0.7428117394,
-0.504553318,
-0.3914174736,
0.3800368905,
0.645293951,
0.8551817536,
-0.7128133774,
0.1191288084,
-0.1389569193,
0.3481520116,
-0.0625393987,
-0.1036095768,
0.7225245833,
-0.5736759901,
-0.5445491672,
0.1459423155,
0.3996969461,
0.1237976253,
-0.1264838874,
-0.1262117624,
-0.2630755603,
-0.4506500363,
0.3266545534,
0.3536650538,
0.1606517285,
-0.4346435666,
-0.3925850391,
-0.5013765097,
0.4087310433,
0.861846149,
-0.7580792904,
0.6791948676,
0.839484036,
0.5384061337,
0.7076503634,
0.439340502,
0.3921454847,
-1.1261744499,
0.2837183177,
-0.0483930148,
0.3734681308,
0.7121577859,
-0.2266169488,
0.6750841141,
0.4919319451,
-0.6792934537,
-0.4907824099,
0.1430804431,
-0.842284441,
-0.0767957792,
0.5949081779,
-0.5258321762,
-0.2614544034,
-0.1429497451,
-0.0777354911,
0.7706779838,
-0.0578055233,
0.6729485989,
0.275550127,
-0.0127718961,
-0.0352711752,
-0.0413099714,
0.4873375595,
0.3179177642,
-0.8806349635,
-0.1970251054,
0.3019758165,
-0.0482918024,
0.3623591661,
1.0655014515,
0.0447555371,
0.0789810047,
0.3786803484,
0.2218576372,
-0.2732878327,
-0.4625762701,
-0.0177566055,
0.3246415257,
-0.0477879979,
-0.4104461968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14318v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14318v3 | CREATOR: Tool Creation for Disentangling Abstract and Concrete Reasoning of Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:51:52 | 2024-06-21T16:51:22 | Cheng Qian, Chi Han, Yi R. Fung, Yujia Qin, Zhiyuan Liu, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant progress in utilizing
tools, but their ability is limited by API availability and the instability of
implicit reasoning, particularly when both planning and execution are involved.
To overcome these limitations, we propose CREATOR, a novel framework that
enables LLMs to create their own tools using documentation and code
realization. CREATOR disentangles abstract tool creation and concrete decision
execution, resulting in improved performance. We evaluate CREATOR on MATH and
TabMWP benchmarks, respectively consisting of challenging math competition
problems and diverse tabular contents. Remarkably, CREATOR outperforms existing
chain-of-thought, program-of-thought, and tool-using baselines. Additionally,
we introduce the Creation Challenge dataset, featuring 2K diverse questions, to
emphasize the necessity and benefits of LLMs' tool creation ability. Further
research demonstrates that leveraging LLMs as tool creators facilitates
knowledge transfer, and LLMs exhibit varying levels of tool creation abilities,
enabling them to adapt to diverse situations. The tool creation ability
revolutionizes the LLM's problem-solving paradigm, driving us closer to the
next frontier of artificial intelligence. All the codes and data are released. | [
-0.4379388392,
-0.766100347,
0.857111156,
0.3137944937,
-0.1307942122,
0.4457216263,
-0.2154746503,
-0.2690764666,
-0.1104198098,
0.375433594,
-0.5116644502,
-0.4661967456,
-0.7830252647,
0.0402634367,
-0.6690420508,
0.8557621837,
-0.0607221089,
-0.258879751,
-0.4649440944,
0.1035552546,
-0.4676552713,
-0.146036908,
-0.6062041521,
-0.4375023246,
0.7143939137,
0.1725182384,
0.7863224745,
0.8776564002,
0.3645638227,
0.4815723002,
-0.0537183136,
0.1057151332,
-0.3965135813,
0.0359037071,
-0.4100666046,
-0.4921852946,
-0.418176204,
-0.1724149436,
0.4759000838,
0.8432778716,
-0.0961824134,
0.2524265945,
0.0088140545,
0.440402925,
-0.5928013325,
-0.0569286197,
-0.8784024715,
0.146615088,
-0.2616134584,
-0.1921413839,
-0.4172814786,
-0.484814018,
0.1482690871,
-0.4811912477,
0.3355996609,
-0.1998604089,
0.2736420929,
0.5116642118,
-0.4891351163,
-0.4389496744,
-0.9716486931,
0.5891990662,
-0.824572742,
0.1243261769,
-0.0796466693,
0.5162281394,
-0.5867036581,
-0.8401295543,
-0.6921586394,
0.1658599824,
0.2379196584,
-0.264757216,
-0.0620782077,
-0.2063488364,
0.5460021496,
0.4460174441,
-0.4200353324,
0.3187330663,
-0.4119094014,
-0.1744561642,
0.7028138041,
0.2367133647,
0.3838127255,
0.0128172692,
-0.0687785372,
0.1821712404,
-1.1153740883,
-0.1776171625,
0.5031471848,
-0.0371232331,
-0.0468148962,
0.6454957724,
0.1827559918,
0.6325931549,
-0.2362878472,
-0.5154246688,
0.1419302225,
0.3051635027,
-0.1810933203,
0.0918054655,
0.8259222507,
0.0342533588,
0.2039703131,
-0.1798318028,
-0.1987504214,
-0.1339162737,
0.0347192958,
-0.7125379443,
-0.3314083219,
0.2809070051,
-0.1320586503,
-0.3013215065,
-0.0657643899,
-0.2330077887,
-0.868376255,
-0.674718976,
0.1859387457,
-0.0735810101,
-0.7552995086,
0.1782078147,
-0.2610624433,
0.1011857539,
0.5080106258,
-0.7590793967,
0.0296034664,
0.6907791495,
0.7067696452,
-0.2510381639,
-0.2624995708,
-0.6545039415,
0.3535450995,
-0.6274421215,
0.5498105288,
-0.2629538476,
-0.5190892816,
-0.1370902359,
-0.2097252309,
0.3965298831,
-0.6641061902,
0.0179452002,
-0.391571939,
0.1316457689,
-0.231443584,
-0.4816754162,
0.1310624182,
0.1681593955,
-0.6316261292,
1.1304148436,
0.1708162576,
-0.489133954,
0.2629934847,
-0.4963074625,
-0.3778532743,
0.4530553818,
-0.8128038645,
-0.189874202,
0.3900918365,
0.0630748793,
0.2750372589,
-0.5130384564,
0.5852201581,
-0.3665403426,
-0.1823175699,
0.3195916414,
-0.2024779767,
0.9139642119,
0.271058023,
-0.4579469562,
0.0551937222,
-0.7467259169,
0.0793797746,
0.4178224504,
-0.4060080945,
-0.0714982897,
0.2039141506,
-0.1953204572,
0.4904907644,
0.3080328405,
-0.6075924039,
0.1734509468,
-0.3533158898,
0.5086380243,
0.9570112824,
-0.1666018367,
0.2078038752,
-0.1180822328,
0.6546370983,
-0.1207060218,
-0.0538791791,
0.0302952714,
-0.3666274846,
-0.7591832876,
-0.3267059028,
0.168838352,
0.3651511371,
-0.5163202882,
0.5641264319,
-0.1783319116,
-0.5310317278,
-0.5081110597,
0.4959160388,
0.3905372024,
0.4330757856,
0.0138434572,
0.0457447767,
-0.56707412,
-0.9922550917,
-0.1764291525,
-0.005751167,
-0.3875048459,
0.2197814882,
0.4278236032,
-0.228100881,
1.1492860317,
-0.7165865302,
-0.058811944,
-0.6062565446,
0.2028637677,
0.1281125844,
0.5289480686,
0.4619296193,
-0.5955677629,
-0.425660044,
-0.0088361884,
-0.9464237094,
-0.439650476,
-0.2150172293,
-0.2452991456,
0.0691433772,
0.8266150355,
-0.6118735075,
0.3859204352,
0.3075277805,
-0.2120972872,
0.7162768841,
-0.0759397894,
-0.4316825569,
-1.2123286724,
0.1780052632,
-0.3484221697,
-0.2207845598,
-0.1566541195,
0.0275180619,
-0.2421052307,
-0.171526894,
-0.5491243601,
0.5383062363,
-0.5205087662,
-0.1676883101,
-0.3856041431,
0.3501406908,
0.0425709225,
0.3354553282,
-0.1067157984,
0.5029771924,
0.4897215664,
-0.4931588769,
0.3283322752,
0.3573945761,
-0.5427256823,
0.3648244143,
-0.9534528852,
0.4226478636,
-0.1961233765,
-0.0299107488,
-0.795866549,
-0.0283902381,
-0.0004213698,
-0.3085066676,
0.2385488451,
-0.3702001274,
-0.8823541999,
-0.2825780511,
0.0539778695,
0.2905831337,
0.5910353065,
-0.6385519505,
0.8136649728,
0.3539647162,
-0.3954482675,
-0.5183714628,
-0.5848551989,
0.3000030518,
-0.1380007565,
-0.559812963,
0.4496407509,
-0.4647044241,
-0.4639952481,
0.153332442,
-0.2843972445,
0.1624629945,
0.3142815232,
0.2481859922,
0.2447297126,
-0.0058798329,
0.1444545388,
0.2824454904,
-0.1807402968,
0.5373580456,
0.0331484266,
0.4912660122,
0.0300807804,
-0.5993354321,
0.1648175418,
0.3467725515,
0.5936744809,
-0.4633725584,
0.5493754148,
0.5339044929,
-0.2381000966,
-0.7008777261,
-0.562956214,
0.1545221508,
-0.5937566757,
0.3297215402,
-0.4952606857,
-0.84873873,
0.4596162736,
-0.4317153692,
0.5234670639,
0.2615676522,
0.7695192695,
0.2652203739,
1.3112956285,
0.4840819836,
0.0088744685,
0.28353104,
-0.3688095212,
0.3610519171,
-0.8192290664,
-0.3104687333,
-0.3767752349,
-0.3856790662,
-0.2807300687,
-0.2462430745,
0.3124007285,
0.3245044649,
-0.2550545037,
0.0486929305,
-0.7391308546,
0.774631083,
0.5120013356,
-0.3056577444,
0.4296888411,
-0.2590924203,
-0.2274986506,
-0.0238662977,
-0.5441876054,
-0.6675422788,
1.1189005375,
0.2814150453,
0.6408616304,
0.4415155053,
0.8720686436,
0.2081984431,
0.2796466351,
-0.5824646354,
0.7606565952,
0.2476931214,
-0.6169237494,
-0.056250155,
-0.381264478,
-0.7364255786,
0.2601369321,
-0.1582404971,
-0.8340650201,
-0.2498207539,
0.1069808006,
-0.1091956496,
0.2847994268,
-0.6825797558,
0.8428872228,
-0.3886941671,
-0.4208862185,
-0.0917358398,
-0.3372962177,
0.481433779,
-0.1324511021,
0.1755685061,
-0.3569922447,
0.1307726949,
0.4552469254,
-0.5888106227,
0.6650413275,
-0.1256902516,
-0.4571781158,
0.4121013582,
0.5454667807,
0.5918585062,
0.277146697,
0.1797645241,
-0.2060159445,
-0.0599798076,
-0.0450661667,
-0.9739609957,
0.8884482384,
-0.5494444966,
-0.9650526047,
-0.1148896441,
-0.7193766832,
0.0274567772,
0.4412275255,
0.1103015542,
0.5515768528,
-0.0738075599,
0.3304279149,
0.558044374,
-0.3611225784,
0.4279636443,
0.6499285698,
-0.4598765671,
-0.1956766844,
0.8515985608,
-0.1624334306,
0.1166331246,
0.072288692,
0.3107527196,
-0.2777314782,
-0.7400919795,
-0.4507209957,
0.1446881592,
-0.8196696043,
-0.0632827878,
-0.4788503647,
-0.4162522256,
-0.0345440432,
-0.3437615037,
-0.4422761202,
-0.4343017936,
-0.0932429433,
-0.1400924772,
0.2011055201,
0.7792205215,
0.0625192001,
0.120364435,
-0.5189660788,
0.304469198,
0.3053985536,
0.2507205904,
0.069253087,
-0.1730208397,
-0.1199426502,
-0.1473887116,
-0.463958025,
-0.6272730231,
0.0270604584,
-0.1206268147,
0.5578913689,
0.5478933454,
0.134891212,
0.5349158049,
-0.5458352566,
0.5834001303,
0.1558975577,
-1.0413365364,
0.5867144465,
-0.3279008567,
0.5432244539,
0.2028214335,
0.0688300505,
-0.2152860761,
-0.7179706693,
-0.4256840944,
-0.8225255609,
0.511859715,
0.2504567206,
-0.0054877247,
-0.0534729287,
0.1825525016,
0.2376814634,
0.3535494208,
-0.8273755908,
-0.215582341,
0.0349241532,
-0.2996107638,
0.135779798,
-0.10283418,
-0.2428078949,
-0.3937594891,
0.4658245742,
-0.152412653,
0.0568928011,
-0.0520534292,
-0.209777683,
-0.0275072232,
0.294185698,
0.3145217001,
1.0283279419,
-0.0163126048,
0.3718394041,
0.057339225,
-0.1274950504,
0.1016331092,
0.2222244889,
0.052082397,
-0.0779957026,
0.4575321674,
0.4203439057,
-0.0530055687,
-0.9764205813,
0.2929761112,
0.1392469853,
-0.4784942567,
-0.6027975082,
0.2777736187,
0.5949828029,
0.3381953239,
0.3002628684,
-0.1652530134,
0.0575511716,
-0.2054793835,
-0.1059042737,
0.3387044072,
0.1014674008,
-0.2620696723,
0.8157944679,
0.169068709,
-0.4311400056,
0.6439799666,
-0.2986823022,
-0.2366380543,
0.5930665731,
0.7782557011,
0.8732486367,
0.1286877841,
0.2703083158,
0.0895878375,
0.1753059179,
0.0974709466,
0.2401631624,
-0.1534286886,
-0.701654911,
-0.5777512789,
-0.4208441675,
-0.100656487,
0.5747826695,
-0.3173378408,
0.2652056217,
-0.7758637071,
-0.0633844137,
0.3193267882,
-0.1901285201,
-0.7607324719,
-0.2121431977,
-0.027089756,
0.7681521177,
-0.4235977232,
0.4906841218,
0.6938487887,
-0.265170604,
-0.7538251877,
-0.5490349531,
0.3623296916,
-0.3883319199,
0.5742175579,
0.1619694084,
-0.3154082596,
0.0849436149,
-0.5159556866,
-0.7604727149,
1.020382762,
0.8226943016,
-0.6002979279,
-0.0537321717,
0.3378072679,
0.4534824491,
-0.2583329082,
-0.069017224,
0.5340140462,
0.2698286772,
0.2468439043,
-0.7153505087,
0.1136234775,
-0.4182751477,
-0.100063473,
0.5089690685,
-0.0149041442,
0.7503515482,
-0.2904077172,
-0.2094140947,
-0.0597325191,
0.2064540684,
0.5258925557,
0.1832291931,
0.4196145833,
0.651402235,
0.4741013348,
-0.0050006653,
0.6556367874,
-0.0770926401,
-0.0976650044,
1.4006346464,
-0.2309594005,
0.481790036,
0.4426368177,
-0.177716583,
0.7499120235,
0.183201775,
-0.101826027,
0.1162648797,
0.5027642846,
-0.4399372041,
-0.3205046952,
-0.0107340068,
-0.3941198587,
0.4717166424,
0.2525295317,
-0.4947710335,
-0.3468187451,
-0.1970828176,
0.1326710433,
0.2855739295,
-0.0334216468,
0.8263635039,
0.1491091698,
-0.569324553,
0.4004157782,
0.0992262438,
0.1923908889,
-0.6248803139,
-0.0967401564,
-0.0599088967,
0.3536569774,
-0.2725219727,
-0.8976129293,
0.3739722669,
0.0963744894,
-0.1316407621,
-0.1836318672,
0.4144934118,
-0.3982820511,
-0.47849828,
0.1151136532,
0.825001955,
0.1770657599,
-0.0001865462,
-0.7298390269,
0.1155485362,
-0.0483761467,
-0.0894065872,
0.2500541508,
0.6863726377,
-0.0440957956,
0.8840115666,
0.7488453984,
0.1184304133,
-0.0007832808,
0.1500028968,
0.9395665526,
-0.5433353186,
-0.3698841631,
-1.0840693712,
0.6620485783,
-0.1890713274,
-0.4204388261,
0.8546767831,
0.8425986767,
0.8218436241,
-0.1923101097,
0.9648061991,
-0.4017006755,
0.3410463929,
-0.3130751252,
0.5335219502,
-0.5469133258,
0.5236310959,
-0.5977480412,
-1.0010163784,
-0.1273031831,
0.4337723553,
-0.1891491562,
-0.1370468885,
0.3921625316,
0.7038606405,
-0.1563201547,
-0.482488662,
0.0254938081,
-0.1576679796,
0.9474526644,
0.7429690361,
1.0138144493,
0.0712590665,
0.6766870022,
0.0007240089,
-0.0877168402,
0.1147741228,
-1.094553709,
-1.2502961159,
-0.5789057612,
-0.3355686665,
-0.0077064126,
-0.4820312858,
0.964654088,
0.5887184739,
-0.3719468713,
-0.1670708507,
-0.5317518115,
0.4924931526,
-0.008436759,
-0.2610246837,
0.2595781982,
-0.2240452766,
-0.6923140883,
0.4497535229,
0.2710117102,
0.1502623558,
-0.6166928411,
-0.2600474656,
0.1767582893,
0.0686886832,
0.7700566053,
0.3086138666,
-0.7926737666,
-0.0221829657,
-0.2667415738,
0.1629447043,
-0.237631321,
0.9631890059,
-0.6347631216,
0.6498779058,
0.4006285965,
0.6740270257,
0.4536893964,
-0.2034124881,
0.8393049836,
-0.8653632402,
0.2796851695,
0.1367911696,
0.3296505213,
0.3407883048,
-0.1970812231,
0.4858469665,
-0.1027881727,
-0.3619315326,
-1.0845578909,
0.5490427017,
-0.6652351022,
-0.4756239653,
0.9159245491,
0.0919689685,
0.0623928234,
-0.0587245189,
-0.4566188455,
0.1342431903,
-0.1701921672,
0.9393861294,
0.585966289,
0.018577816,
-0.288256228,
-0.4683075547,
0.595874846,
0.0251125414,
-0.8388518691,
0.0831768587,
0.7003241181,
0.4816220701,
0.1094848663,
0.5837054253,
-0.3396455348,
0.1948073655,
-0.0472391844,
0.2682625353,
-0.7551177144,
-0.4320324361,
0.2639575899,
0.0496254787,
0.4681358635,
0.0439476296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14310v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14310v3 | Navigating Prompt Complexity for Zero-Shot Classification: A Study of Large Language Models in Computational Social Science | 2023-05-23T17:48:21 | 2024-03-24T18:03:10 | Yida Mu, Ben P. Wu, William Thorne, Ambrose Robinson, Nikolaos Aletras, Carolina Scarton, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive
language understanding and the capacity to generate responses that follow
specific prompts. However, due to the computational demands associated with
training these models, their applications often adopt a zero-shot setting. In
this paper, we evaluate the zero-shot performance of two publicly accessible
LLMs, ChatGPT and OpenAssistant, in the context of six Computational Social
Science classification tasks, while also investigating the effects of various
prompting strategies. Our experiments investigate the impact of prompt
complexity, including the effect of incorporating label definitions into the
prompt; use of synonyms for label names; and the influence of integrating past
memories during foundation model training. The findings indicate that in a
zero-shot setting, current LLMs are unable to match the performance of smaller,
fine-tuned baseline transformer models (such as BERT-large). Additionally, we
find that different prompting strategies can significantly affect
classification accuracy, with variations in accuracy and F1 scores exceeding
10\%. | [
-0.0239469483,
-0.8699389696,
0.6916707754,
0.2079586089,
-0.0140976701,
0.3861643076,
-0.3759294748,
-0.1867702156,
-0.1800913811,
0.1773424447,
-0.4787133038,
-0.533921957,
-0.8296194673,
0.10777542,
-0.3437227905,
1.0223588943,
-0.0500042513,
-0.0198168624,
-0.3005183935,
0.0532005988,
-0.5775664449,
-0.3889021873,
-0.6819863319,
-0.4373967052,
0.7852588892,
0.6584175825,
0.6999876499,
0.5159201026,
0.1325081885,
0.3085581064,
-0.4220555425,
-0.225199163,
-0.8613426685,
0.3646502495,
-0.2366164923,
-0.559638679,
-0.0028590059,
-0.0389116928,
0.6892098188,
0.889945507,
0.1196802184,
0.3464893699,
0.233294785,
0.397685796,
-0.771284163,
0.5250489712,
-0.4618621767,
0.0034842016,
-0.0155952163,
-0.1386100203,
-0.6436091065,
-0.20892407,
0.2152585685,
-0.4113423824,
0.4323619604,
0.1311281472,
0.4948918819,
0.0825841352,
-0.1426459402,
-0.3407756388,
-0.8818612099,
0.7432163954,
-0.2449931204,
0.0938566104,
0.2331137061,
0.4165796936,
-0.333204031,
-0.4703294337,
-0.5037354827,
-0.1765692085,
0.1628851742,
-0.0418095514,
-0.3659667373,
0.1659222543,
0.5053706169,
0.0197899751,
-0.6425250769,
0.4183291495,
-0.5592021346,
-0.2171713114,
0.3496028185,
0.3747066259,
0.0067718504,
-0.235217303,
0.0050346069,
-0.1439510733,
-0.6397662163,
0.3653843403,
0.1248970851,
0.6991977096,
-0.250025034,
0.6062089205,
-0.5581816435,
0.7192465663,
0.1699147969,
0.0488879159,
0.0888371915,
0.0409519449,
-0.148535639,
0.2143481821,
0.7133070827,
0.0172224846,
0.3155231774,
-0.2069626004,
-0.002949951,
-0.0015563754,
0.1054999307,
-0.8877463937,
-0.0507729948,
0.1741831303,
-0.0486238785,
-0.4424852431,
-0.2547194362,
-0.5610954165,
-0.6011178493,
-0.3443236947,
0.595253706,
-0.4147758782,
0.0751309246,
0.1814386696,
0.013148631,
0.5546647906,
0.7335219979,
-0.6385607719,
0.0398586653,
0.728920877,
1.3133596182,
-0.0758725554,
-0.2167682499,
-0.6301324964,
-0.0924769714,
-0.3215228319,
0.7480389476,
-0.6786824465,
-0.4271733761,
0.0968842953,
-0.0381531641,
-0.2520229816,
0.0101340879,
0.4078499675,
-0.5808587074,
0.2484128773,
-0.3331002295,
-0.5970329642,
-0.2067625672,
0.3255154192,
-0.3542541265,
0.6926369667,
0.051824294,
-0.4903493226,
0.063481912,
-0.7171010375,
-0.338670969,
0.39863047,
-0.2066787779,
0.0454697497,
0.2163911015,
-0.0435334966,
0.8198741078,
-0.2009063363,
0.30824247,
-0.2992069721,
-0.5984894037,
0.1897617429,
-0.6205127239,
0.7599888444,
0.0332192294,
-0.4172831774,
0.1999268681,
-0.5978677273,
-0.13153404,
0.2202821374,
-0.0983280241,
-0.0748109147,
-0.1862312257,
-0.362539202,
0.0664525181,
-0.0169380717,
-0.5697128773,
0.2539553344,
-0.2514998317,
0.4545868635,
0.9462568164,
-0.0898130983,
0.6246173382,
-0.3018557131,
0.6805757284,
-0.2375764698,
0.0951998383,
-0.577278614,
-0.7255099416,
-0.700498879,
-0.1859840453,
0.4176522791,
0.6241255403,
-0.8360667229,
0.035856925,
-0.3937425911,
-0.8564220667,
-0.2839241624,
-0.2433854491,
0.2535413206,
0.5310201049,
0.266556859,
0.0677898303,
0.0189901888,
-0.4691543281,
0.0220491346,
-0.2497055233,
-0.2357651889,
0.4788678885,
0.5396783948,
0.0473164506,
0.7876518965,
-0.5754612684,
0.1108520105,
-0.1329673678,
0.4468263984,
0.3570338488,
0.0235913545,
0.3742882311,
-0.3123761415,
-0.5543766618,
-0.1339889467,
-0.5829218626,
-0.3439954221,
-0.0589704849,
0.2048158497,
0.1246046573,
0.5384082794,
-0.6992467642,
0.5141386986,
0.2360450625,
-0.0766771883,
0.7544907331,
0.0109788841,
0.1523277313,
-0.6411213875,
0.038719371,
-0.1263020486,
0.0489960313,
-0.9601230025,
-0.0556320585,
-0.0175366867,
-0.3709608912,
-0.7169902325,
0.6289213896,
-0.4969793558,
0.2352997363,
-0.2424104959,
0.1392289847,
-0.353300631,
0.4917147458,
0.038216792,
0.6473385692,
0.916169703,
-0.6131227016,
0.2517365217,
0.0033181289,
-0.3323287964,
0.486541599,
-0.7385433316,
0.2277773321,
-0.5095660686,
0.2455483675,
-1.2488478422,
-0.5062003136,
0.2902591527,
-0.6111782789,
0.4540975094,
-0.0680563971,
-0.3924478889,
-0.2523773313,
-0.4166707098,
0.3061002791,
0.5063961148,
-0.4406583905,
0.42597121,
-0.2131434083,
-0.2252198309,
-0.5345622301,
-0.2939404845,
-0.0066520558,
-0.0247559641,
-0.4280596077,
0.1878959984,
-0.0997074395,
0.0184938237,
-0.268501848,
-0.0374113768,
0.2693674564,
0.0777683258,
0.6213497519,
0.1945559978,
-0.2349774539,
0.2064403743,
0.0987839773,
0.0441651568,
0.0413312577,
0.1222313195,
0.6410543919,
-0.1800287366,
-0.4472033978,
-0.2789646685,
0.1697070003,
0.7465993166,
0.0641141906,
1.0015387535,
0.349686712,
-0.1518387198,
-0.1592308879,
-0.3880006671,
-0.1790578663,
-0.499024123,
0.0015630582,
-0.1912766993,
-1.3385434151,
0.4873339236,
-0.1524154544,
0.0978087634,
0.1046956182,
0.4935073256,
-0.029139284,
0.8495310545,
0.4541503191,
-0.1275016963,
0.5971040726,
-0.0022290787,
0.1876510382,
-0.4147980213,
-0.3326547146,
-0.8294495344,
-0.2359011769,
-0.4403787553,
-0.5463670492,
0.3938069344,
0.1324040592,
-0.5420040488,
0.1889191717,
-0.4371153712,
0.7077748775,
0.3961341083,
0.0477734469,
0.1188654453,
0.1716887355,
0.047845874,
0.3743712902,
-0.9685732126,
-0.383802563,
0.9375862479,
0.2841573954,
0.8224044442,
-0.0091684293,
0.6169254184,
0.170378834,
0.2456732243,
-0.9694167972,
0.708716929,
0.0796839148,
-0.3461357057,
-0.4413942993,
-0.4642282128,
-1.0695554018,
0.0732888356,
-0.2504746914,
-0.8700546622,
0.0739836097,
0.0550960265,
-0.5462869406,
0.1023567468,
-0.6590827107,
0.6268265843,
-0.1190384552,
-0.34794873,
0.0079237726,
-0.8554229736,
0.2257437855,
-0.0836047009,
0.261063844,
-0.1613222659,
0.0643145144,
0.4643823504,
-0.0219351258,
1.2203371525,
-0.194414869,
0.0837209597,
0.2170090079,
0.2277013361,
0.4369321764,
-0.4437606931,
-0.0201589447,
0.3628278077,
-0.0912793577,
-0.4632087052,
-0.618247509,
0.5263823867,
-0.7342888713,
-0.7011859417,
-0.4988458157,
-0.4325350821,
-0.1776273251,
0.0930582732,
0.4378101528,
0.3373216689,
-0.193389982,
0.3938401043,
0.8829492927,
-0.4219937623,
0.3430065811,
0.7372307181,
-0.0230775978,
-0.0296085309,
0.7885350585,
0.4964596331,
0.4408417344,
0.3213745058,
0.2975551188,
-0.2208237797,
-0.5227587223,
-0.4987081885,
0.1763426512,
-0.6496579051,
-0.4174494445,
-0.5146117806,
-0.501930654,
-0.6138976812,
-0.294937402,
0.017038364,
-0.4218499064,
-0.5579149723,
-0.0477053002,
0.4723605216,
0.756894052,
0.0392427966,
0.6402916312,
-0.6086730361,
-0.0846614763,
0.0776710138,
0.5365382433,
0.2492073774,
-0.8049765825,
-0.0933640376,
-0.1302827448,
-0.3001699448,
-1.1310402155,
-0.1903210133,
0.2260216624,
0.5391386747,
0.4537262917,
0.3615878522,
0.5314813852,
-0.6663954854,
0.8702876568,
0.2022009343,
-0.8257639408,
0.587151885,
-0.3599670529,
0.7388842702,
0.3147836626,
0.7409601808,
-0.5502801538,
-0.3542755842,
-0.3191780746,
-0.7277167439,
0.9093648195,
0.204129532,
0.3891070187,
-0.1145626158,
0.5460392237,
-0.0323541313,
0.0147282518,
-0.4998203516,
-0.1516824216,
-0.1840933859,
0.0043918025,
-0.0809878185,
-0.2764754593,
0.2342173755,
-0.1402545869,
0.5245347023,
-0.2158544809,
0.1039431244,
0.0036825391,
-0.0807537138,
-0.193896994,
0.5196500421,
0.6336019039,
0.2208902538,
0.1003610194,
0.0020476505,
0.2523535788,
-0.2800534666,
0.2657500207,
-0.1228115633,
-0.4435375929,
-0.0951017737,
0.5286498666,
1.0069372654,
0.3245374262,
-0.5850332975,
0.4949406087,
0.036659915,
-0.2667510509,
0.0252895188,
0.4402776361,
-0.2818671465,
0.3096677959,
0.2381978631,
-0.2488077879,
0.0522947237,
-0.3612319231,
-0.3004435897,
0.4431933761,
-0.3487508893,
-0.2391604185,
0.3390932381,
-0.031503696,
-0.5303278565,
0.6243912578,
-0.3545483649,
-0.4782567918,
0.4025980532,
0.5207354426,
0.8852918744,
-0.5815568566,
0.5069984794,
0.4142296612,
0.3719935119,
-0.1513562948,
0.0195734296,
-0.3782340586,
-0.6380757689,
-0.6552476883,
-0.6586055756,
-0.8235471845,
0.2044538856,
-0.5733056664,
0.354459554,
-0.5355450511,
-0.1112665683,
0.2262572944,
-0.304870069,
-0.6144969463,
-0.2696922719,
0.1819598675,
0.9434208274,
-1.0159207582,
0.4038820863,
0.7136762738,
-0.0598455705,
-0.8113723397,
-0.2238822132,
0.2503615022,
-0.6189129353,
0.4730403721,
0.4575632215,
-0.3795362413,
-0.01168779,
-0.9835238457,
-0.7079246044,
1.0496122837,
0.3451171815,
-0.5666680336,
0.0214368552,
0.3041580021,
0.7254964113,
-0.047720883,
0.329731077,
0.4160020649,
0.3113085926,
0.5994135141,
-0.9371715188,
0.0225024484,
0.0296674445,
-0.0816185623,
0.0597414523,
-0.4229620397,
0.729755342,
-0.2831077278,
-0.5311532617,
0.0330310501,
0.5091157556,
0.2749239802,
0.4870081544,
0.4041653275,
0.0751153752,
0.6996314526,
-0.078238599,
0.7266937494,
-0.0715454072,
0.2006183416,
1.020925045,
-0.5284245014,
0.8166298866,
0.1228322312,
-0.1572711915,
0.5493921041,
0.6653966308,
-0.0014551,
0.1862804443,
0.4333534539,
-0.4244707823,
-0.1008957997,
-0.254419297,
-0.144568041,
0.4269273579,
0.5099974871,
-0.1012577116,
-0.4023045301,
0.1559212655,
0.0212346446,
-0.1517778188,
-0.6247805953,
0.8021872044,
-0.0132179419,
-0.668253243,
0.5834933519,
-0.0860231519,
0.4936955869,
-0.5714065433,
0.0044299788,
-0.1219260022,
-0.2077218443,
-0.0950628966,
-0.9699734449,
0.096253179,
0.2145082206,
-0.1877376288,
-0.0973000005,
0.8699961901,
-0.2209449708,
-0.2415636182,
0.1633028835,
0.5096751451,
0.3986744583,
-0.1503352374,
-0.5185688138,
0.0412660092,
-0.2555465102,
-0.3181257248,
0.3796217144,
0.6044875979,
-0.3015059829,
0.7501900196,
0.7494828105,
-0.1908942312,
0.0741217658,
0.0336765014,
0.8006258011,
-0.5816445947,
-0.3144285679,
-0.9861639142,
0.0882031769,
0.0925390497,
0.0260005109,
0.7260468006,
0.227827251,
0.6894721389,
-0.168091476,
0.4717612565,
-0.0501099788,
0.3603228331,
-0.3410699964,
0.5637652874,
-0.1507296115,
0.1588948518,
-0.2651788294,
-0.7138864398,
-0.5565031767,
0.4000944197,
-0.5487424731,
-0.0034625931,
0.2707516551,
0.9647962451,
0.1528186649,
0.214792341,
0.4294116199,
0.2417933941,
0.1602997631,
0.4438263178,
1.0185611248,
0.193426773,
0.6003812551,
-0.0941958651,
-0.5468171239,
-0.1894628704,
-0.9408499002,
-1.1286110878,
-0.2490424067,
-0.2161838561,
-0.3000492752,
0.0774709955,
0.9195732474,
0.5425823331,
-0.7768346071,
-0.213438794,
0.0116289426,
0.2181626558,
0.0856854618,
-0.2819155455,
0.2035690546,
-0.4644688666,
-0.4368030131,
0.3326941431,
0.3701337278,
0.18359676,
-0.3263936937,
0.008801505,
0.1855715513,
0.285315454,
0.9645562768,
0.4391929209,
-0.7518870831,
-0.4562889934,
0.3007054925,
0.0601380616,
-0.1443483233,
0.7538453937,
-0.8736367226,
0.4486482143,
0.6150035858,
0.578586936,
0.3947776854,
-0.0832509622,
0.255889833,
-0.7634992599,
-0.2598879635,
0.1411598027,
0.1096367016,
0.2602599263,
-0.3750630617,
0.40813905,
0.1600282043,
-0.7634881139,
-0.8955639005,
0.2236658335,
-0.9190480709,
-0.4283677936,
1.284781456,
-0.0547078736,
-0.3317395151,
-0.1745277792,
-0.2623059154,
0.1423494816,
-0.5180152059,
0.7422814369,
0.8852224946,
-0.2408401519,
-0.4053485394,
-0.5878062248,
0.1589832008,
0.1820694953,
-0.3905301988,
0.1530385017,
0.5919620395,
0.1977522522,
0.3513450027,
0.569760859,
0.1473858953,
0.2240843922,
-0.1917972416,
-0.1957041174,
-0.1558160633,
-0.5475798249,
-0.7954599857,
0.3194686174,
-0.0036823079,
0.0188875459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14307v1 | Debiasing should be Good and Bad: Measuring the Consistency of Debiasing Techniques in Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:45:54 | 2023-05-23T17:45:54 | Robert Morabito, Jad Kabbara, Ali Emami | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Debiasing methods that seek to mitigate the tendency of Language Models (LMs)
to occasionally output toxic or inappropriate text have recently gained
traction. In this paper, we propose a standardized protocol which distinguishes
methods that yield not only desirable results, but are also consistent with
their mechanisms and specifications. For example, we ask, given a debiasing
method that is developed to reduce toxicity in LMs, if the definition of
toxicity used by the debiasing method is reversed, would the debiasing results
also be reversed? We used such considerations to devise three criteria for our
new protocol: Specification Polarity, Specification Importance, and Domain
Transferability. As a case study, we apply our protocol to a popular debiasing
method, Self-Debiasing, and compare it to one we propose, called Instructive
Debiasing, and demonstrate that consistency is as important an aspect to
debiasing viability as is simply a desirable result. We show that our protocol
provides essential insights into the generalizability and interpretability of
debiasing methods that may otherwise go overlooked. | [
-0.0639933422,
-0.8219512701,
0.6114820242,
0.4558207989,
-0.2760771215,
-0.3738895655,
-0.1878616214,
-0.4241911769,
0.2012260556,
0.57010746,
0.1881353259,
-0.5426356196,
-0.9166436791,
-0.0125545217,
-0.6014785171,
1.0503287315,
-0.1205838695,
0.2531549335,
-0.340016216,
-0.2413778007,
-0.4247802496,
-0.4293783009,
-0.681543529,
-0.6535060406,
0.4239864945,
0.4736227691,
1.166046381,
0.4737490118,
0.7971730232,
0.1775929779,
0.0412575416,
-0.3304439485,
-0.4097716212,
0.2070042193,
-0.5876942277,
-0.3117753565,
-0.5986689925,
0.550901413,
0.3238244951,
0.6889026165,
-0.2916306257,
0.1314892322,
0.5294427276,
0.6434571743,
-0.9485965967,
0.0371096693,
-0.5040997863,
-0.2102502435,
-0.0069143702,
-0.1468580216,
-0.476977855,
-0.7401546836,
-0.017761685,
-0.25999403,
-0.2302254587,
-0.2288827896,
0.6672715545,
0.213042587,
-0.2970227003,
-0.2904797792,
-0.8502835035,
0.9587025642,
-1.1609778404,
0.3881771863,
0.7579528093,
0.2660265267,
0.1054183096,
-0.4623575807,
-0.5294088721,
-0.4601817727,
-0.1131323874,
-0.0960160941,
-0.1303250343,
0.2316995114,
0.0950855985,
0.0599021129,
-0.2711701393,
0.1238256916,
0.0266936943,
-0.2359994054,
0.6121925116,
-0.1158527955,
0.3300534487,
-0.1428066194,
-0.3528231382,
0.2139499933,
-0.868032217,
-0.291618675,
0.437887162,
0.1553797722,
-0.1689915955,
0.384518981,
-0.2428126335,
0.4336179793,
0.0529797934,
-0.1731596887,
0.2489587963,
-0.3714857697,
-0.2355988771,
-0.0451738164,
0.5671922565,
0.9555516839,
0.2975583076,
-0.4365596771,
-0.3485763669,
0.3612800539,
0.28778705,
-0.7298780084,
-0.2106253207,
0.3889816999,
-0.5685112476,
-0.3953717053,
-0.2395946831,
-0.5708768964,
-0.492700696,
-0.4399900734,
0.8381482959,
-0.2303055227,
-0.3861398697,
0.2887580693,
-0.2063556165,
-0.0501704104,
0.206175819,
-0.9198310971,
0.4253362119,
0.7660521865,
0.5875258446,
-0.2562109232,
-0.24029091,
-0.4371303618,
0.1701664776,
-0.5382633805,
0.5462012291,
-0.6078194976,
-0.3041984141,
-0.1025959253,
-0.1741826236,
0.294926405,
-0.5859658718,
0.7213922143,
-0.1359609663,
0.063475728,
-0.4210552871,
-0.4553365707,
-0.0797742382,
0.4612989724,
-0.3665390909,
0.6303197145,
-0.0868485048,
-0.7836205959,
0.5156772733,
0.0278919041,
-0.1579243243,
-0.455448091,
0.1202800721,
-0.5485824943,
-0.1287797689,
-0.2430088222,
0.3725457788,
-0.1869686842,
0.5960844159,
-0.8753409386,
-0.4850164354,
0.2579770088,
-0.5349112153,
0.958078742,
0.4063255489,
-0.6094101071,
0.0169963501,
-0.8182376623,
0.2095084339,
-0.1948889941,
-0.0504246615,
-0.6640001535,
0.251873374,
-0.3787674904,
0.1075670198,
0.0381006747,
-0.6293839216,
0.0308868587,
-0.3030163944,
0.3660147786,
0.7258760929,
0.1514393985,
0.612392664,
-0.557600677,
0.1076606438,
-0.0243994948,
0.5468543768,
0.5346158147,
-0.231796205,
-0.8777725697,
-0.1561473161,
0.023317473,
0.3130425513,
-0.2864484787,
0.4817647338,
0.0474131927,
-0.6665919423,
-0.4157075584,
-0.0183652006,
0.6395042539,
0.5225138068,
0.463696152,
-0.3892741203,
-0.6913291216,
-1.0820739269,
-0.5201865435,
-0.4496030509,
0.3779335916,
-0.1290711313,
0.4000891745,
-0.5225997567,
0.6888841987,
0.0338248909,
-0.090990521,
-0.095790267,
0.3804118335,
0.0714234859,
0.6446723938,
0.6702877283,
-0.3612797558,
-0.5540701151,
-0.4043344259,
-0.9492417574,
-0.4633043706,
-0.0977566466,
-0.2873990536,
0.0938303769,
0.5466737747,
-0.2036082,
0.4113727212,
0.6138878465,
-0.2371156067,
0.5173108578,
0.0019767683,
0.4030247629,
-0.5983303189,
0.0142290816,
-0.0676311478,
-0.2157219052,
-0.6471480727,
0.1196264103,
0.0042122155,
0.3105624914,
-0.2913489938,
0.5528647304,
-0.0899011269,
0.3961594999,
-0.2687574923,
0.2687775493,
0.3166110814,
-0.1338174194,
-0.1611163169,
0.5196831822,
0.5861629248,
-0.7893953919,
0.1950638443,
0.1409208775,
-0.0726845413,
0.8292791247,
-0.6767895818,
0.2365782112,
-0.3209065199,
-0.0378403217,
-0.8050430417,
0.3713371456,
0.6121634245,
-0.4376662076,
0.1255112886,
-0.1418997049,
-0.1523560286,
-0.0408444107,
-0.568834722,
0.3110310733,
0.4539987147,
-0.4013619125,
0.1912256032,
0.338285476,
0.0387980454,
-0.8444000483,
-0.9686030746,
0.0939067975,
-0.26938954,
-0.3083107173,
0.2746937573,
-0.2736453414,
-0.7039780021,
-0.1061932892,
-0.2368349284,
-0.0688879564,
0.3105181158,
0.0763723925,
-0.0843707398,
0.0568643734,
0.1278204769,
-0.1011788025,
-0.3251335025,
0.3137475848,
0.1237185523,
0.1452209204,
0.0255055372,
-0.534555912,
-0.4195934236,
0.3742292225,
0.4037179649,
-0.0805400312,
0.5991700888,
-0.057987161,
-0.2743221521,
-0.2953668833,
-0.5124351382,
-0.3078971505,
-0.4293245971,
0.0673863515,
-0.1537033617,
-0.2379145622,
0.5013819337,
0.2677006423,
0.0054458752,
0.219626233,
0.5110900402,
-0.099582687,
1.0819225311,
0.681168139,
-0.2294791192,
0.1421290934,
0.027594272,
0.4638132453,
-0.3725372851,
0.0504825898,
-0.8511877656,
-0.1557632238,
-0.4449697435,
-0.0420206934,
0.0898543596,
0.4761321843,
-0.3383110464,
0.2376185954,
-0.4489300251,
0.6200580597,
0.2845110297,
-0.012284779,
0.5406967998,
-0.2423816621,
-0.0012784512,
-0.2039942592,
-0.2235899568,
-0.9543779492,
0.8771578074,
0.5214391351,
1.0822240114,
0.2565010786,
1.0425928831,
0.3363139331,
0.8502660394,
-0.686203301,
0.5615509152,
-0.0122249192,
-0.8419356346,
-0.2369484603,
-0.3327817023,
-0.6803560853,
0.1339169294,
-0.0303441323,
-0.62721771,
0.2514838576,
0.4397711158,
0.0714743957,
0.2482165694,
-0.6440973282,
0.931566298,
-0.1088736728,
-0.3968794942,
-0.3827327788,
-0.4169291258,
0.1479937136,
0.125910297,
0.3368326128,
-0.2995297015,
0.2832031846,
0.6717826128,
-0.0108543793,
1.0913639069,
-0.2824684978,
-0.3387753963,
0.4973672032,
0.6308256388,
0.4033362269,
0.1555548161,
-0.2824891508,
0.257068783,
0.2902732193,
-0.2880677283,
-0.6479726434,
0.706112206,
-0.5742598176,
-0.8500632644,
-0.3527655602,
-0.1410360485,
-0.2042984813,
0.2613102496,
0.1270283163,
0.2144609094,
-0.4603088498,
0.0996948183,
0.5099654198,
-0.017844392,
0.1913666129,
0.8251199722,
-0.285366714,
-0.2023670524,
0.9692386389,
0.1495346874,
0.6704676747,
0.1836734414,
0.3335870206,
-0.0219387952,
-0.7451756001,
-0.0278072003,
0.0977319553,
-1.0161979198,
-0.3968701363,
-0.2609773576,
-0.1484507471,
-0.6032177806,
-0.0276799574,
-0.5457494259,
-0.360960573,
-0.0831774548,
-0.2608915865,
-0.1383130103,
0.523249805,
-0.4638952911,
-0.0619222485,
-0.8502576947,
0.2054571658,
0.2589113414,
0.5126356483,
-0.2067915946,
-0.570967555,
-0.0447293594,
0.4081020355,
-0.4769605994,
-1.0580329895,
0.0268274434,
0.0937851518,
0.8771772385,
0.4665153623,
0.3383121789,
0.1884475499,
-0.1936706156,
0.5421825647,
0.094510898,
-1.1479622126,
0.467846185,
-0.2336884141,
-0.2508900464,
0.7850221395,
0.6091351509,
-0.9260920882,
-0.9920598865,
-0.5360437036,
-0.5069683194,
0.201896444,
0.1880393177,
0.3530813754,
-0.4758776426,
0.2821919024,
0.4452273548,
0.1319368184,
-0.8558003902,
-0.2762131691,
-0.3383041918,
-0.206583783,
-0.1705218405,
-0.561732173,
-0.3945427239,
-0.0891317055,
0.8325431347,
0.1491343677,
-0.0676546544,
0.2971652448,
-0.2012080997,
-0.117411226,
0.6158782244,
0.2980069518,
0.9744330049,
-0.4404233396,
0.6851046681,
-0.181348294,
-0.4100009501,
0.3937748373,
-0.1999653876,
-0.5953304172,
-0.0904887915,
0.2545520365,
0.2005500346,
-0.0655782521,
-0.2776929438,
0.6088254452,
0.3406211734,
-0.102515392,
0.1011034995,
0.042941533,
-0.1311442554,
-0.0298581459,
-0.2265463322,
0.0776603445,
0.4795870781,
-0.72813344,
0.3886059523,
0.4018628299,
-0.4178425074,
-0.4839446545,
0.4433826208,
0.5155571699,
-0.0980200469,
0.3762338758,
-0.3406870067,
-0.2288181335,
0.3808754385,
0.6306969523,
0.9958422184,
-0.4656043649,
0.5823002458,
0.5388614535,
0.5385221243,
-0.2458339185,
0.3566387296,
0.3127757013,
-0.9882330894,
-0.2410452515,
-0.3550137579,
-0.5232067704,
0.0032948968,
-0.686896801,
0.188513115,
-0.318349123,
-0.2764928341,
0.0425443165,
-0.3957655132,
-0.1856414229,
0.1137636378,
0.0703625828,
0.7326990366,
-0.9914605618,
0.7255198956,
0.3755471408,
-0.64562428,
-0.3971809745,
0.0131120654,
0.1102499813,
-0.5782598853,
0.5690079331,
-0.0262727104,
-0.3299260736,
-0.3961544037,
-0.7666653395,
-0.7325821519,
0.4555248916,
0.4738990366,
-0.5788835287,
0.2594976127,
0.2508440614,
0.4915160537,
-0.0988655239,
0.2918251753,
0.6538826823,
0.7215169072,
-0.4384007752,
-1.1326121092,
0.2667995989,
0.0668471307,
-0.2077583969,
0.1344471872,
-0.4067876935,
0.5437121391,
-0.3397197127,
-0.323187381,
0.0211705845,
0.2597264349,
-0.0807099044,
0.5774821043,
0.4312680662,
0.6835933328,
0.4627601504,
0.0933731124,
0.6241005063,
-0.0598621108,
0.5327441692,
1.1653341055,
-0.4558970928,
0.7152681351,
0.6660587192,
-0.1154848412,
0.3138667941,
0.1355962455,
0.2653332949,
0.7136512995,
0.3779707551,
0.1299432516,
-0.376313746,
-0.0776600465,
-0.3735508919,
0.2978608012,
0.020316653,
-0.3646860123,
-0.5665835738,
0.0946112052,
0.3161150813,
0.4683782458,
-0.0284951497,
0.6474007368,
0.198713541,
-0.7000265121,
0.8799302578,
0.013113616,
0.5723467469,
-0.4352909327,
-0.1673256457,
-0.4231559932,
0.4554720819,
-0.283341527,
-0.9008209109,
0.7068449855,
-0.3919399381,
-0.2279559821,
-0.2800176144,
0.6500396729,
-0.3709543049,
0.0121680191,
0.6009936929,
0.6075220704,
0.1110888347,
-0.0474679545,
-0.5611686707,
0.1141637489,
0.0248123519,
-0.1029334217,
0.3292998672,
0.2649753392,
0.0136431279,
0.6679937243,
0.1337280273,
0.1467563659,
-0.2837148011,
0.4679416418,
0.6652733088,
-0.5545015335,
-0.1009691581,
-0.900610745,
0.4360415041,
-0.0648990273,
-0.2837905884,
1.0136773586,
0.3825647235,
0.7556374669,
0.2497394383,
0.7220652103,
0.1072987691,
0.4568754733,
-0.5046452284,
0.6050439477,
-0.277646482,
0.5558334589,
-0.3084887564,
-1.0861500502,
-0.3599028289,
0.7114776373,
-0.3508982658,
-0.0234945826,
0.827272892,
0.8756561875,
-0.0166947879,
-0.1089080051,
0.3087997735,
0.4275381565,
0.4904106259,
0.1251700968,
0.7621774673,
-0.2216413468,
0.4026965499,
-0.535402,
-0.5101252794,
-0.0629381388,
-1.1495565176,
-0.756208837,
-0.4621466696,
-0.6096602678,
-0.6963617206,
0.4371775389,
0.6128214002,
0.4952767491,
-0.6491698027,
-0.1513538808,
-0.1372146308,
0.3539356291,
-0.6096751094,
-0.1905227751,
-0.0977483839,
-0.6649630666,
-0.4494291246,
-0.0556745343,
0.232768178,
-0.002717928,
-0.391925633,
-0.1631555706,
0.159627378,
0.3624353409,
0.4419731498,
0.1278227419,
-0.4859995544,
-0.869882822,
-0.3512263894,
-0.5263275504,
-0.0273079108,
0.6908960938,
-0.3240563273,
0.6037775874,
0.7495929599,
0.1503837854,
-0.2258810401,
-0.1795168072,
0.5068257451,
-0.3811160326,
0.0916100666,
0.5084873438,
0.2926206291,
0.2825280726,
-0.2026613057,
0.4681215584,
-0.078706719,
-0.8106583953,
-0.8828639984,
0.4597353637,
-0.758040607,
-0.3657959402,
1.3826130629,
-0.2080134302,
-0.0172167141,
-0.3204959929,
-0.187240243,
-0.0078152306,
-0.1645098329,
1.1331871748,
0.7721720934,
0.1177918836,
0.1330322921,
-0.265973568,
0.6394034624,
0.5612673759,
-0.627404809,
0.4827150702,
0.3022732139,
0.4916358292,
0.2993781567,
0.8088460565,
-0.4446697533,
0.1413976699,
-0.0116212256,
0.1885837317,
0.2193868011,
-0.3612804711,
-0.0820246711,
-0.4773550928,
0.4533171654,
0.0096949767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14303v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14303v2 | QTSumm: Query-Focused Summarization over Tabular Data | 2023-05-23T17:43:51 | 2023-11-07T04:53:07 | Yilun Zhao, Zhenting Qi, Linyong Nan, Boyu Mi, Yixin Liu, Weijin Zou, Simeng Han, Ruizhe Chen, Xiangru Tang, Yumo Xu, Dragomir Radev, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | People primarily consult tables to conduct data analysis or answer specific
questions. Text generation systems that can provide accurate table summaries
tailored to users' information needs can facilitate more efficient access to
relevant data insights. Motivated by this, we define a new query-focused table
summarization task, where text generation models have to perform human-like
reasoning and analysis over the given table to generate a tailored summary. We
introduce a new benchmark named QTSumm for this task, which contains 7,111
human-annotated query-summary pairs over 2,934 tables covering diverse topics.
We investigate a set of strong baselines on QTSumm, including text generation,
table-to-text generation, and large language models. Experimental results and
manual analysis reveal that the new task presents significant challenges in
table-to-text generation for future research. Moreover, we propose a new
approach named ReFactor, to retrieve and reason over query-relevant information
from tabular data to generate several natural language facts. Experimental
results demonstrate that ReFactor can bring improvements to baselines by
concatenating the generated facts to the model input. Our data and code are
publicly available at https://github.com/yale-nlp/QTSumm. | [
-0.2070734352,
-0.7868424058,
0.5519924164,
-0.2375767678,
-0.3251213729,
-0.1723230034,
0.0444200821,
0.0274768565,
0.2297649831,
1.0649698973,
-0.4579110742,
-0.7552931905,
-0.0836593136,
0.0814671367,
-0.5837089419,
1.2069005966,
0.0256457888,
-0.1687896103,
-0.6546904445,
-0.1199596003,
-0.4791819751,
-0.4654567242,
-0.1665142179,
-0.0982438475,
0.5711234212,
0.8134154081,
0.7330750227,
0.5592805743,
0.4462742507,
0.2433435321,
0.1780442148,
0.399959743,
-0.6421922445,
0.5531046391,
-0.1304699183,
-0.9111565948,
-0.6043118238,
-0.1586196423,
0.775599122,
0.6252580881,
-0.3280356824,
0.2904429436,
-0.1820412874,
1.1120874882,
-0.5358352661,
0.09202528,
-0.6274526119,
0.0361148827,
-0.2477347702,
-0.2454741746,
-0.5065823793,
-0.7603670359,
0.0291604418,
-0.7774299383,
0.3630180359,
0.1968577951,
0.732499361,
0.3450816572,
-0.7127748132,
0.0484078899,
-0.4945470691,
0.5304718018,
-0.6902171969,
0.3756432831,
0.3220857382,
0.6519656777,
-0.3541041315,
-1.0998679399,
-0.581844449,
-0.3017248809,
-0.4086252749,
0.1705207676,
-0.2734920979,
-0.1400282383,
0.5293280482,
0.2280995995,
-0.8354731798,
-0.4330612123,
-0.1567426175,
0.0778099447,
0.6911576986,
0.5436640382,
0.2249489278,
-0.2262113839,
-0.2691385448,
-0.149380967,
-0.5677015781,
-0.2487499565,
-0.023901999,
0.1049413607,
0.0724284425,
0.5933040977,
-0.8583484888,
0.6021642685,
-0.2708922923,
-0.0983932167,
-0.1321825236,
-0.6809099913,
-0.2587657571,
-0.116321072,
0.7140821815,
0.7118113041,
0.1275049597,
-0.4044314027,
-0.1188543439,
-0.0410110243,
0.4803379178,
-0.9871569276,
-0.3485638201,
0.1600795835,
-0.1361608356,
-0.0578514263,
0.0611511208,
-0.6486440301,
-0.2240620255,
-0.3617656231,
0.2947434485,
-0.2253869921,
-0.1380163878,
-0.1159834936,
-0.4050603807,
0.1679116786,
0.4262798131,
-0.3595955968,
0.4813143611,
0.5241354108,
0.5496100783,
-0.3060106039,
-0.0007513085,
-0.5017629862,
0.4798269272,
-0.3722153902,
0.9197010994,
-0.1197146326,
-0.4304005802,
-0.2319355011,
-0.1258612722,
0.0875634849,
-0.6348972321,
0.5881382227,
-0.3916159272,
0.4333889782,
-0.6482456923,
-0.4919418991,
-0.1909106374,
0.4818189144,
-0.5895489454,
0.9586110115,
0.1902579069,
-0.789934516,
0.7009450793,
-0.5174805522,
-0.6304180622,
0.2331635207,
-0.2367308587,
-0.7478052974,
0.0691800639,
0.230120495,
0.3232169151,
-0.6579049826,
0.7572063208,
0.1038343459,
-0.1981651187,
0.4337572455,
0.0836151317,
0.2948474586,
0.2091957033,
-0.2205504179,
0.5606493354,
-0.6836579442,
0.3296402395,
0.2593466043,
-0.3156479597,
-0.0685069188,
0.2259175479,
-0.1294003427,
-0.0735467598,
-0.1217476875,
-0.1193697974,
0.1029302254,
-0.0673484355,
0.3571726382,
-0.1142908335,
0.3541260958,
0.2859458029,
-0.6425096393,
0.5544612408,
0.015540801,
-0.2212725282,
-0.4915161133,
-0.107154429,
-0.688723743,
0.0075151124,
0.2805269659,
0.2396188825,
-1.0750061274,
0.0354865529,
-0.2929078937,
-0.7189940214,
-0.358322978,
-0.2229865044,
0.5016762018,
0.8746013641,
0.5523860455,
-0.1526214927,
-0.5038463473,
-1.2552906275,
-0.6263411045,
-0.1661783755,
-0.2358996272,
0.0867172927,
0.2533919811,
-0.0316403359,
1.0566971302,
-0.9345709085,
-0.2314141989,
-0.5777628422,
0.3026337922,
-0.0976844653,
0.4414568841,
0.2694534957,
-0.768004477,
-0.3117177784,
-0.2103134692,
-0.7116547227,
-0.0534097329,
-0.1384555697,
-0.3162206113,
-0.0053447923,
0.6658142805,
-0.5360963941,
0.3087452054,
-0.4265315533,
-0.2285638899,
0.6344812512,
-0.0628944933,
0.2729919553,
-1.241574645,
0.4091140628,
0.0620290115,
-0.3688398898,
-0.7834125757,
0.3491431475,
0.1788452417,
-0.3750609159,
-0.2014013678,
0.20773682,
-0.4858371615,
-0.161410436,
-0.2241263539,
0.3845176697,
0.2347600162,
0.4930908382,
-0.0521832295,
0.7514079809,
-0.0705672875,
-0.6678138375,
0.1087306812,
0.3146567941,
-0.3218186796,
0.6258618832,
-0.8258756399,
-0.0974784717,
-0.192812711,
0.3894777,
-1.2162189484,
-0.5024594069,
-0.0200917572,
-0.6306809783,
0.2705198824,
0.2108356357,
-0.5099951029,
-0.1305628568,
-0.4475194216,
0.1550281346,
0.3428996503,
-0.1907560378,
0.5582787395,
0.7264354229,
-0.2303752899,
-0.0758174211,
-0.6657320261,
0.3338967562,
-0.2468277365,
-0.5438156128,
0.4968510568,
0.2423875481,
-0.3666336536,
-0.0572120063,
-0.19845061,
-0.0811372027,
0.280592382,
0.0961452797,
-0.0946955308,
-0.2166255265,
0.0625068769,
0.3260865808,
-0.1402074695,
0.3315077424,
0.0643170923,
0.3512195349,
0.1008508354,
0.1664256603,
-0.5318574309,
0.2834941149,
0.4080466926,
-0.3773107827,
0.3113657534,
0.4714638889,
-0.401792258,
-0.1552050561,
-0.5336319208,
-0.2681989968,
-0.3528882861,
0.5345218778,
-0.2859683633,
-0.7262239456,
0.2799069881,
-0.0070037907,
0.4125616252,
0.5998279452,
0.5180193186,
-0.1666593999,
0.9682348967,
0.3002639115,
0.1120458469,
0.2748161256,
-0.0574898385,
-0.2455185503,
-0.6072232127,
-0.2598602474,
-0.8397218585,
-0.379021436,
-0.6297106147,
-0.3402402997,
0.3179106712,
-0.1696822941,
0.0139846187,
0.3347771466,
-0.4182031751,
0.3343583345,
0.6516014934,
0.1000712067,
0.4795743525,
-0.2325429171,
0.0648774952,
-0.1278741211,
-0.6397971511,
-0.4879440963,
0.9314467907,
-0.0435650945,
0.4805198312,
0.101434432,
0.7053507566,
0.364217937,
0.5460708141,
-0.4995675087,
0.8395767212,
0.1000668705,
-0.4851498008,
-0.4238781035,
-0.9089936018,
-0.996925652,
0.4518963397,
-0.3664450049,
-0.289183408,
-0.1851338744,
0.2397636473,
-0.1938984692,
-0.0736020878,
-0.9419654012,
0.9103691578,
-0.0815450698,
-0.4771893322,
-0.2028688192,
-0.754429996,
0.6889843345,
0.0956518427,
0.0024696847,
-0.3062042594,
-0.0352584906,
0.8915758729,
-0.7168924212,
0.4525483549,
-0.2775165737,
0.1645553261,
0.40402174,
0.2093723416,
0.2638018727,
0.1703067273,
-0.0620735213,
-0.3963236809,
0.0446203016,
-0.3036942482,
-0.6371272206,
0.4220858514,
-0.2968778014,
-0.7525572181,
-0.2321776152,
-0.6418847442,
-0.3614748418,
0.3361687362,
0.0991113335,
0.4345674515,
-0.324067235,
0.323866725,
0.2616810799,
-0.1652766615,
0.0783012435,
0.6958749294,
-0.2091253847,
-0.5301037431,
0.927577436,
0.2891627848,
0.0053241397,
0.7627623677,
0.13357234,
-0.2931465209,
-0.5646969676,
-0.5877543688,
0.0551716797,
-0.1204477772,
-0.5157662034,
-0.6279575825,
0.2950478792,
-0.2459112555,
0.1261653453,
0.0734214932,
-0.6938667297,
-0.0227705073,
-0.1462622434,
0.128604576,
0.3881986737,
0.5398590565,
0.4075948298,
-0.8121384978,
0.6765809655,
0.3360611498,
0.1399376541,
-0.0921515003,
-0.218620941,
-0.2768854797,
0.0515934192,
-0.5008963943,
-1.0132510662,
0.4530391693,
0.0763623714,
0.4877249002,
0.1348461062,
0.4341083467,
0.5674410462,
-0.1524322182,
0.6535347104,
0.2096223086,
-0.731613338,
0.7167426944,
-0.419156462,
0.7597205639,
0.9011484981,
0.227072224,
-0.4367250502,
-0.5118177533,
-0.4255868495,
-0.830471158,
0.7201318741,
0.2134778053,
-0.3286274672,
-0.0511946306,
0.5386200547,
0.0770737082,
0.4400568902,
-0.3741711974,
0.0215653013,
-0.0898132473,
-0.1016622037,
-0.0406727009,
-0.3633236289,
0.0896588117,
-0.1188197732,
0.5550111532,
-0.314486444,
-0.1094467565,
0.1421737671,
-0.4040509164,
-0.0778129548,
0.489207238,
0.6796482801,
0.8152585626,
-0.1879675239,
0.188420698,
0.194706738,
-0.3675156534,
-0.149411425,
0.1455871314,
-0.5435679555,
0.1705842465,
0.078696616,
0.5477175117,
0.498698473,
-0.7176892161,
0.1175405458,
-0.4988425672,
-0.3803972602,
0.1143179759,
0.3381116688,
0.2474355102,
0.0124841668,
0.4541067481,
-0.5719323158,
0.5200164318,
-0.65653795,
0.4621163011,
0.3139545619,
-0.2477189004,
-0.2708760202,
0.9129038453,
0.2065110654,
-0.0766642019,
0.593492806,
-0.2144856304,
-0.3042592406,
0.6468068957,
0.3741799891,
0.8113697767,
-0.1047660038,
0.2359971851,
0.5877996683,
0.2217945307,
0.0524940006,
0.5767246485,
-0.3239079416,
-0.3003306985,
-0.2646335661,
-0.2759501636,
-0.8092424273,
-0.2138701081,
-1.0613462925,
0.1206025332,
-0.2104447484,
-0.4011949301,
0.1282039583,
0.1038634479,
-0.326076597,
0.3265647292,
-0.6358335018,
0.6135425568,
-0.4412122965,
0.6611116529,
0.5971550941,
-0.4296064675,
-0.5691340566,
0.0489904583,
-0.2371988297,
-0.472412616,
0.0509139523,
0.0894932896,
0.293746233,
0.0149195362,
-0.462482065,
-0.4949029386,
1.1670458317,
0.3310593367,
-0.5946641564,
-0.1446980387,
0.3365952969,
0.6233418584,
-0.0052037546,
0.1844355315,
1.0261713266,
0.5228467584,
-0.1259012818,
-0.3973245025,
0.3075958788,
-0.2093935162,
-0.1454339176,
0.8053356409,
-0.5550076365,
0.4716748893,
-0.3144626915,
-0.37361902,
-0.201523453,
1.0266983509,
0.2259454429,
0.6842195392,
0.2721877992,
0.7061170936,
0.658005476,
-0.336900413,
0.9934674501,
-0.1234480739,
-0.1248360351,
1.353292346,
-0.3272199631,
0.8128231764,
0.2510286868,
-0.3107276559,
0.1322720498,
0.2076664716,
0.0878812894,
0.1854790449,
0.3941086829,
0.2626233101,
0.0342656709,
-0.3098313808,
-0.4217529893,
0.3526545167,
0.3626255989,
-0.0723540038,
-0.3974996805,
-0.4707972407,
0.169469893,
0.3090884089,
-0.3082497418,
1.2732561827,
-0.0162513442,
-0.9452961683,
0.4159067869,
0.1040719151,
0.1810828745,
-0.4117580652,
0.0302344374,
-0.5694847107,
-0.1309417039,
-0.3081946075,
-0.6783599257,
0.475718528,
0.1041546315,
-0.1357506365,
-0.0855137557,
0.6582685113,
-0.693621397,
-0.181404531,
-0.4377421141,
0.6919378638,
0.1125738025,
-0.2783589363,
-0.2083604187,
-0.2707997561,
0.1764514595,
-0.1491685957,
0.4103710055,
0.590924859,
-0.2284456789,
0.5101751685,
0.4994183183,
-0.3986474574,
-0.2631153166,
0.1642902941,
0.9419162273,
-1.0024744272,
-0.7363176346,
-0.670525074,
0.5049190521,
-0.1386999786,
-0.5164160132,
0.8213780522,
1.0203166008,
0.4946430922,
0.0742841065,
0.5078526139,
0.4177391231,
0.862955451,
-0.4091240168,
0.906501174,
-0.710753262,
-0.050896056,
-0.3018950224,
-0.8578843474,
-0.2926653922,
0.1028602123,
-0.1415823698,
0.0096305739,
0.4084747732,
0.598356545,
0.4506816566,
0.1207859218,
0.2706415057,
0.1982222646,
0.3383240104,
0.2960624993,
0.7029603124,
-0.3143811524,
0.6276638508,
-0.0739080757,
0.0502193533,
-0.5076990128,
-0.6408760548,
-0.5909984708,
-0.5281655788,
-0.4612729847,
-0.1197501495,
-0.0481495857,
0.4391449392,
0.4335266352,
-0.5889971256,
-0.3716573715,
-0.1726588458,
0.3409708142,
-0.0239459909,
-0.2959239781,
0.3806975186,
-0.3107311428,
-0.3096772432,
0.2117878497,
0.2295674831,
-0.1630720198,
-0.0540283471,
0.2144030184,
-0.0290295724,
-0.0082815187,
0.6406109333,
0.1946165115,
-0.3465380967,
0.2722862363,
0.0809664577,
-0.1636547446,
0.1374504715,
1.0346615314,
-0.8489124775,
0.4570971131,
0.7002820969,
0.6094809771,
0.9849205017,
0.4405560791,
0.7217717767,
-0.8721656799,
-0.3964123428,
0.365249902,
0.2718193829,
0.2567906082,
-0.1048399806,
0.5675949454,
-0.043094229,
-0.3990094066,
-1.0226458311,
0.0650192127,
-0.9215651155,
-0.2021763325,
0.6472206116,
0.193487525,
-0.3208219707,
-0.0179997962,
-0.3647070825,
0.3795801401,
-0.4720291197,
0.7955725789,
0.1002117768,
-0.0865010545,
-0.2267192304,
-0.3720521331,
0.6129006147,
0.564930737,
-1.5066667795,
0.3169484138,
0.7315394282,
-0.0450558178,
-0.0740995184,
0.5070115924,
-0.173989296,
0.5907325149,
-0.0958383605,
0.1626145542,
-0.236342743,
-0.2830183804,
0.1709585488,
0.5256743431,
0.0094797378,
-0.0144760655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14299v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14299v1 | TaDSE: Template-aware Dialogue Sentence Embeddings | 2023-05-23T17:40:41 | 2023-05-23T17:40:41 | Minsik Oh, Jiwei Li, Guoyin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Learning high quality sentence embeddings from dialogues has drawn increasing
attentions as it is essential to solve a variety of dialogue-oriented tasks
with low annotation cost. However, directly annotating and gathering utterance
relationships in conversations are difficult, while token-level annotations,
\eg, entities, slots and templates, are much easier to obtain. General sentence
embedding methods are usually sentence-level self-supervised frameworks and
cannot utilize token-level extra knowledge. In this paper, we introduce
Template-aware Dialogue Sentence Embedding (TaDSE), a novel augmentation method
that utilizes template information to effectively learn utterance
representation via self-supervised contrastive learning framework. TaDSE
augments each sentence with its corresponding template and then conducts
pairwise contrastive learning over both sentence and template. We further
enhance the effect with a synthetically augmented dataset that enhances
utterance-template relation, in which entity detection (slot-filling) is a
preliminary step. We evaluate TaDSE performance on five downstream benchmark
datasets. The experiment results show that TaDSE achieves significant
improvements over previous SOTA methods, along with a consistent Intent
Classification task performance improvement margin. We further introduce a
novel analytic instrument of Semantic Compression method, for which we discover
a correlation with uniformity and alignment. Our code will be released soon. | [
-0.4414616525,
-0.5479909778,
0.6046025753,
0.1304617524,
-0.4381038845,
0.0116543239,
0.0090940753,
-0.1994466335,
0.5902508497,
0.4836707413,
-0.6070404649,
-0.5815526843,
-0.4107590318,
0.0360841453,
-0.221262008,
0.6218688488,
0.3330527842,
0.3466674387,
-0.1116897911,
-0.377453953,
-0.5486038327,
-0.2626567185,
-0.670802176,
0.3691724539,
0.2763108611,
0.2709315419,
0.174210906,
0.5788914561,
0.002818956,
0.3893515468,
-0.1164785698,
0.2064483315,
-0.3185718954,
0.4760867655,
-0.2735108137,
-0.4098482132,
-0.4127440155,
-0.1082486808,
0.4197642505,
0.5045843124,
-0.1756822169,
-0.3142190576,
0.1867876351,
0.0709937215,
-0.7215861678,
0.2011506557,
-0.658829689,
0.0972355902,
-0.0415772721,
-0.1307079792,
-0.375997752,
-0.2294336408,
0.2274896801,
-0.6070385575,
0.0993757397,
0.3124556839,
0.3580647409,
0.1328570396,
-0.4284768403,
-0.4041415155,
-0.0759807453,
0.6749871373,
-0.7338012457,
0.5608096123,
-0.0558147021,
0.0907600597,
0.1320648938,
-0.8485963345,
-0.760819912,
-0.1411597878,
-0.0704207048,
0.2490005791,
0.2587769032,
0.2741642594,
0.0507058688,
0.6428468227,
-0.1833296418,
0.1043797806,
-0.0490319729,
-0.2446271628,
0.271376878,
0.2661842108,
0.3449374139,
-0.5544344783,
-0.5002474189,
-0.2655899227,
-0.5737463236,
-0.295343101,
0.2354118377,
0.2626446784,
-0.2183172107,
0.4182902873,
0.1419565678,
0.4120959342,
0.1734035313,
0.2062158436,
0.1493237168,
-0.5520602465,
-0.2391203493,
0.255782336,
0.7919210792,
0.2753861248,
-0.1241865158,
0.0365155376,
-0.0936682597,
-0.174531132,
0.1768386066,
-0.6965286136,
-0.2135175914,
0.0721752271,
-0.0970145613,
-0.3486197889,
0.1556381285,
-0.7981090546,
-0.4605919421,
-0.0270152967,
0.2079962343,
-0.7669974566,
0.0674800575,
-0.0520210452,
-0.0643502846,
0.2690971494,
0.4682793319,
-0.8600351214,
0.3558108509,
0.709423542,
0.753562808,
0.130872786,
-0.0844984874,
-0.8514042497,
0.145308435,
-0.3824730515,
0.7835034132,
-0.5632004142,
-0.5205698013,
0.091593422,
-0.2909429371,
-0.1498837769,
-0.4670071006,
0.8424978256,
-0.2350668162,
0.6209153533,
0.047748182,
-1.0895441771,
0.0120031526,
0.1813185662,
-0.4258241951,
0.7387199402,
0.399361372,
-0.7874776125,
0.2365991026,
-0.6097509265,
-0.3062694371,
0.0101744737,
-0.3747291565,
-0.3538192213,
0.2456841171,
0.6033869386,
0.4412972331,
-0.2487377822,
0.2788839936,
-0.1999229044,
-0.3459859788,
0.1574234664,
-0.3652256131,
0.5669430494,
0.1529773623,
-0.1783931404,
0.1774186194,
-0.4440930486,
-0.0179398134,
-0.129543677,
0.0929362029,
-0.1616616994,
-0.4057736695,
-0.0009577862,
0.0490878522,
-0.0496790633,
-0.8160381317,
0.1295624822,
-0.778636992,
0.3264746368,
0.9457004666,
0.332069397,
0.3973257244,
-0.0960157886,
0.3213450909,
0.4233819842,
0.0346569642,
-0.6898248196,
-0.2554146349,
-1.0506272316,
-0.4674364924,
0.5758441687,
0.4987702966,
-0.8531427383,
0.9397900701,
-0.1569697261,
0.0613467731,
-0.9643962383,
0.1112781912,
0.3615671396,
0.7142642736,
0.3970758617,
-0.4024839401,
-0.756649673,
-0.9710693359,
-0.0829047337,
-0.0926041603,
-0.0672957897,
0.4386690259,
0.1522718668,
0.0189128704,
0.8774926066,
-0.4949607253,
-0.3623541296,
-0.4974474311,
0.1385251731,
-0.100619331,
0.7410182953,
0.3215314746,
-0.5664144158,
-0.6485090852,
-0.3353911042,
-0.5984508395,
-0.1400392354,
-0.0912139267,
0.2172180861,
0.078166768,
0.7859281898,
-0.3860126734,
0.1470051408,
0.4026833177,
-0.2572479844,
0.2788477242,
0.016121367,
0.2155115455,
-1.5700831413,
-0.3619756699,
0.0395288318,
-0.412719667,
-0.4716983438,
-0.212872684,
0.1017944813,
-0.2187907547,
-0.5499648452,
0.4827015102,
-0.1310281605,
0.0608287193,
0.0611884966,
0.5418940783,
0.2405933738,
0.5636244416,
-0.0822069421,
1.1884874105,
0.6409355402,
-0.282823801,
0.1957909763,
0.4828892648,
-0.4203881025,
1.0162336826,
-0.5982159972,
0.3234139085,
-0.1153027266,
0.3591002226,
-0.888209939,
-0.0579381064,
0.4424478114,
-0.3116819859,
0.5529717803,
-0.2441341728,
-0.3971437812,
0.2294068485,
-0.5105621219,
0.2118642181,
0.3633782864,
-0.6890639067,
0.5138089657,
0.3467077613,
-0.5180974007,
-0.3898825049,
-0.3511733413,
0.2139237076,
-0.3212177753,
-0.4931923449,
0.2840678692,
0.214976564,
0.1396345198,
-0.1019503772,
-0.2402787656,
-0.0057851984,
-0.1441870928,
-0.0479585975,
0.0779194087,
-0.3509756029,
0.4573411345,
0.2361422479,
-0.3360954225,
-0.1538922787,
-0.6103605628,
0.7067854404,
-0.2474544495,
-0.4109594524,
-0.7135835886,
0.4774848223,
0.2190448344,
-0.1574463844,
0.8031823039,
0.6498011947,
-0.0440943614,
0.0696000978,
-0.7380197644,
-0.1889898032,
-0.4924997687,
0.3653669953,
-0.4801254869,
-1.0513794422,
0.2851920426,
-0.2921232581,
-0.2262205333,
0.5104932189,
-0.0823088512,
-0.4031479061,
0.8934467435,
0.4333818257,
-0.0363744572,
0.6820455194,
-0.4071872234,
0.3592721224,
-1.3466979265,
-0.210554108,
-0.3863942027,
0.0024116957,
-0.6004041433,
-0.6682018042,
0.4063785374,
0.0047127237,
-0.1729904264,
0.3045567572,
-0.2514221668,
0.4166201651,
0.4061627686,
0.0182943456,
0.060989473,
-0.2978134751,
-0.4071951807,
-0.367703706,
-0.7742077708,
-0.4409821928,
0.8238288164,
0.1148629412,
0.7059830427,
-0.019115556,
0.9177598357,
0.3068318069,
-0.1758176386,
-0.5881022215,
0.6622210145,
-0.0949675143,
-0.0672690794,
-0.1424658,
-0.4737563431,
-0.7500200868,
0.1359698474,
-0.2554314733,
-1.162784338,
0.303584069,
0.1046996191,
-0.1815144271,
0.2332681417,
-0.8234428167,
0.7945308685,
-0.0179393161,
-0.4556932449,
-0.2527476251,
-0.5892539024,
0.0510067791,
0.283526659,
-0.3201830685,
0.0293455347,
-0.0102421669,
0.6002664566,
-0.412579,
0.7490487695,
-0.3070565164,
0.1183617711,
0.2825820446,
0.0327352285,
0.4713214338,
0.4804334342,
0.030954564,
-0.3100607991,
-0.118782185,
-0.5336130261,
-1.0441420078,
0.8205834031,
-0.3576843143,
-0.8338673115,
-0.3303308487,
-0.278801918,
-0.568041265,
-0.0079727611,
0.1796486825,
0.7116836905,
-0.3800329566,
0.3672329187,
0.7995501161,
-0.2589169741,
0.1519850343,
0.1144862399,
0.0459450334,
-0.7606270313,
0.8732103109,
-0.3592072129,
0.0971414372,
0.4838292301,
0.1145547032,
-0.6488283873,
-0.3747894168,
-0.4075849056,
0.055334948,
-0.723459661,
-0.2782365978,
-0.8520766497,
-0.2606615424,
-0.5356981158,
-0.4227039814,
-0.3438257575,
-0.7367325425,
-0.1363034993,
-0.1575926989,
0.1450763047,
0.5612753034,
0.0445202626,
0.4972707629,
-0.6941302419,
0.1884948462,
0.3741421103,
0.3537093103,
-0.1714076698,
-0.1747929305,
-0.1714252084,
0.0067276489,
-0.3859830499,
-0.7732799053,
0.0807246864,
0.214467302,
0.5230540633,
0.4174033999,
0.1178957,
0.6318127513,
-0.1603370756,
0.953545332,
0.4339176118,
-1.2158303261,
0.7281219363,
-0.1538977921,
0.2075439245,
0.6986536384,
-0.1176933423,
-0.5350907445,
-0.4938281775,
-1.0114488602,
-0.7838431001,
0.6504353285,
0.3534132838,
0.4508313835,
-0.2569971979,
0.2397767454,
0.0111565422,
0.2965278029,
-0.3789629936,
0.046919927,
-0.4038819671,
-0.5783469677,
-0.05459553,
-0.3158649802,
0.1007545516,
-0.1864180118,
0.5269921422,
-0.190976724,
0.4135226011,
0.4552868307,
-0.3167638779,
0.4454710484,
0.7105960846,
0.3594051898,
-0.0393166952,
-0.2474560142,
-0.0191804562,
0.4372608662,
-0.0330340788,
0.0746371523,
0.0479182526,
0.0915117115,
-0.1148954034,
0.3289251924,
0.8763469458,
0.3866881132,
-0.5034999251,
0.7210227251,
-0.2064426094,
0.2647938132,
-0.1444033831,
0.3419576287,
0.1247626022,
0.2230298817,
-0.0512867607,
-0.0372354686,
0.4626505077,
-0.6748498082,
0.2809484899,
0.1926076859,
-0.7663814425,
-0.0625879243,
0.3880702257,
0.6689979434,
-0.3005264997,
0.7277649641,
-0.2122084796,
-0.5155791044,
0.255010277,
0.6316410899,
1.0050083399,
-0.2966187894,
0.1980549544,
0.2539129853,
-0.17312181,
0.5362839103,
0.1617530733,
-0.3815358579,
-0.6139131188,
-0.2716701031,
-0.3966713548,
-0.5996627808,
0.043829307,
-0.6116937995,
0.0653528795,
-0.3637553155,
0.0316369049,
-0.1158994362,
-0.0030383333,
-0.6016962528,
0.1501805037,
-0.252078265,
1.0131675005,
-0.5499942899,
0.6183254719,
0.460293591,
-0.2987969518,
-0.4396138787,
0.311837703,
-0.1288054436,
-0.5527095795,
0.295301348,
0.3453881741,
-0.2485133857,
0.1693862379,
-0.1869971454,
-0.3310098946,
0.7846800685,
0.5271570683,
-0.3173062503,
0.0395787507,
-0.0878063068,
0.4131695032,
-0.8299347758,
0.1887547523,
0.4548359215,
0.2044897079,
0.1779321432,
-0.5228059292,
0.0477753133,
-0.3023283482,
0.205272615,
0.2051259428,
-0.4938241541,
0.3668500185,
0.0797895119,
-0.1238371208,
0.2402845919,
0.7304888964,
0.0857728198,
0.1055794954,
0.545268178,
0.6187719107,
0.6499363184,
-0.1777216941,
0.9149972796,
-0.3046406209,
0.1251114309,
1.3793811798,
-0.2964984477,
0.6451945901,
0.3871283233,
0.1353722364,
0.7299673557,
0.1729727238,
0.1769856811,
0.6207696795,
0.0411493108,
-0.6206979752,
-0.195216015,
-0.4624323845,
-0.2209465355,
0.615657866,
0.6472288966,
-0.4003248215,
-0.0705761462,
0.0550083965,
-0.1428612471,
0.1481417865,
0.0934252217,
1.1013422012,
0.135964945,
-0.4989920259,
0.1913089156,
-0.2379486859,
0.4667467177,
-0.4725811183,
-0.0630046502,
-0.1694906503,
0.1222490147,
0.1902720034,
-0.8166942596,
0.2188261598,
-0.1854936033,
0.3453742862,
-0.167010054,
0.6298233867,
-0.437097609,
-0.2416734844,
0.0367459208,
0.6870393753,
-0.2648433745,
0.2587611079,
-0.5640972853,
-0.1285528988,
-0.0805570409,
0.1075376496,
0.1945393234,
0.4301022589,
0.3659301102,
0.5100386143,
0.304212898,
-0.0026452236,
-0.3526137471,
0.1981503814,
1.0591832399,
-0.6514517665,
-0.7991037369,
-0.4172000587,
0.5473722219,
-0.7858942151,
-0.2955079377,
0.5894309282,
0.715755403,
0.7169260383,
0.0808729157,
0.6708092093,
0.1057370082,
0.477979064,
-0.9532892704,
0.212486878,
-0.3123301268,
0.4311719537,
-0.1998579502,
-0.8893335462,
-0.0784301385,
0.8731908798,
-0.1656782031,
0.0649641603,
0.8263418078,
0.7902055979,
-0.3903224468,
0.257620573,
0.3539938927,
0.2211470604,
0.3384502828,
0.3082789481,
0.9110665321,
-0.4361422062,
0.2691143155,
-0.1620878875,
0.2495258749,
-0.3084413707,
-0.6840652227,
-0.8058616519,
-0.7282999158,
-0.3498332798,
-0.1617364138,
0.3933198452,
1.0766462088,
0.9006454349,
-0.9544332623,
0.0362180471,
-0.3416247666,
0.1628115922,
0.0616138019,
-0.2440879792,
0.427691102,
-0.7077293992,
-0.93601197,
0.627335608,
0.6181653142,
0.2564037144,
-0.0539881885,
-0.0170949791,
-0.2202280909,
0.2688449621,
0.3426106572,
-0.0250062123,
-0.7797335386,
-0.4377269447,
-0.1418559402,
-0.0480970666,
0.3932672441,
1.0771563053,
-0.9155373573,
0.7230949998,
0.218816936,
0.4962610602,
0.5926134586,
-0.0089946641,
0.8736811876,
-1.1862967014,
0.3367164433,
0.4244560301,
0.7369354367,
0.5724086761,
-0.160450086,
0.4176491201,
-0.0030820929,
-0.074825339,
-0.5400623679,
0.4853750765,
-0.93893224,
0.0071813846,
0.4598186016,
-0.4790906906,
0.1313861907,
-0.2484829575,
-0.5897645354,
0.35730654,
-0.5427455902,
0.7621483207,
0.4386824965,
-0.115493238,
-0.6332653761,
0.0033825214,
0.4274677634,
0.6208404899,
-0.8831021786,
-0.2019760758,
0.383986026,
-0.0365130864,
0.1278693825,
0.4976614416,
0.0593230352,
0.2565576732,
0.3069482744,
-0.4721454382,
-0.1451777369,
-0.1619748026,
-0.1545036584,
0.193449229,
-0.0294401646,
-0.2479115874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14296v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14296v2 | USB: A Unified Summarization Benchmark Across Tasks and Domains | 2023-05-23T17:39:54 | 2023-12-04T15:53:50 | Kundan Krishna, Prakhar Gupta, Sanjana Ramprasad, Byron C. Wallace, Jeffrey P. Bigham, Zachary C. Lipton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | While the NLP community has produced numerous summarization benchmarks, none
provide the rich annotations required to simultaneously address many important
problems related to control and reliability. We introduce a Wikipedia-derived
benchmark, complemented by a rich set of crowd-sourced annotations, that
supports $8$ interrelated tasks: (i) extractive summarization; (ii) abstractive
summarization; (iii) topic-based summarization; (iv) compressing selected
sentences into a one-line summary; (v) surfacing evidence for a summary
sentence; (vi) predicting the factual accuracy of a summary sentence; (vii)
identifying unsubstantiated spans in a summary sentence; (viii) correcting
factual errors in summaries. We compare various methods on this benchmark and
discover that on multiple tasks, moderately-sized fine-tuned models
consistently outperform much larger few-shot prompted language models. For
factuality-related tasks, we also evaluate existing heuristics to create
training data and find that training on them results in worse performance than
training on $20\times$ less human-labeled data. Our articles draw from $6$
domains, facilitating cross-domain analysis. On some tasks, the amount of
training data matters more than the domain where it comes from, while for other
tasks training specifically on data from the target domain, even if limited, is
more beneficial. | [
-0.4251902699,
-0.7219638228,
0.3090611398,
0.5490225554,
-0.1474633366,
0.0653308928,
-0.2641890049,
-0.511312902,
0.2600548863,
0.2052717954,
-0.4457643032,
-0.3027013242,
-0.7934087515,
0.2998385131,
-0.4741197526,
1.3016580343,
0.1047187373,
-0.248430714,
-0.7179254293,
-0.2932193875,
-0.4125783443,
-0.4182274044,
-0.3823508918,
-0.3936960101,
0.6587507725,
0.2524276376,
0.6312227249,
0.5212771893,
0.9592769146,
0.204926312,
-0.0512351692,
0.4526266456,
-0.5173426867,
-0.0159318894,
-0.3695380688,
-0.0267128497,
-0.5974200964,
0.1526338756,
0.486516118,
1.1038694382,
0.0625767633,
0.4013238847,
0.0680315346,
0.7877541184,
-0.867033124,
0.1182168722,
-0.4857607484,
-0.1873650253,
-0.2365381867,
-0.2943075299,
-0.402487725,
-0.3524523973,
0.1360042393,
-0.573120296,
0.4339174032,
0.0765416622,
1.0977888107,
0.4716975689,
-0.5364985466,
-0.0444463268,
-0.6731035113,
0.8484638333,
-0.6078984141,
0.3648781776,
0.4360014796,
0.1513199359,
-0.0101064993,
-0.8305727243,
-0.3444522619,
-0.1584017575,
-0.2408001423,
0.3230816126,
-0.3463549614,
-0.0969223082,
0.1493089497,
0.1728606969,
-0.5369660854,
-0.0386706404,
-0.6708773971,
-0.1651724428,
0.8066700697,
0.2046469301,
0.0098444335,
0.1174409464,
-0.3017797768,
0.1296690702,
-0.8824648857,
-0.126001969,
0.0630597472,
0.2609981894,
-0.0561309867,
0.6339352727,
-0.5540349483,
0.7506387234,
-0.0383892655,
-0.3174371421,
0.1094737649,
-0.4412712455,
-0.2286945581,
-0.1665939391,
0.6912143826,
0.7351666093,
0.126321435,
-0.628673315,
-0.0234237295,
-0.1713670939,
0.5365878344,
-0.6699870229,
-0.4532959461,
0.4721723199,
-0.3948186636,
0.0546226054,
0.1546045989,
-0.4198884964,
-0.2139868885,
-0.4254841805,
0.2809129357,
-0.5009610057,
0.0203117579,
-0.1509771198,
-0.2901459336,
-0.0079128807,
0.5782763362,
-1.0078049898,
0.4419432282,
0.814822495,
1.1011003256,
-0.6997865438,
-0.6351570487,
-0.5884855986,
0.2792626917,
-0.2745892107,
1.0397335291,
0.124583818,
-0.2443079799,
-0.1870247871,
-0.0770542398,
-0.1175794601,
-0.5233075023,
0.4675849974,
-0.3910243809,
-0.042341996,
-0.5594348311,
-0.8235535026,
-0.2967359722,
0.0941931382,
-0.7472800612,
0.9470316768,
-0.0037870638,
-0.947535634,
0.4972667396,
-0.4253395498,
-0.7488401532,
-0.0514979996,
0.0337103158,
-0.4190782607,
0.1494846344,
-0.048428949,
0.7997626662,
-0.4682290256,
0.4376045763,
-0.4191266298,
-0.2634692192,
-0.0011309077,
-0.1864459068,
0.9505779147,
-0.0387085862,
-0.2916222513,
0.0969489142,
-0.8362544179,
-0.2401076406,
-0.0536364354,
-0.348400116,
-0.2233522087,
0.0647931248,
0.1859302521,
0.0777429864,
0.3104462624,
-0.4980587363,
-0.061527919,
-0.0193848573,
-0.1698472053,
0.44190678,
-0.0743740946,
0.1409029216,
-0.4751114249,
0.2812579572,
-0.1977290809,
-0.0861915722,
-0.1766961664,
-0.5403011441,
-0.5615047812,
-0.4004067779,
0.221955806,
0.5494917035,
-0.4347143471,
0.6839462519,
-0.3305404186,
-0.6736354828,
-0.3831233084,
0.2359887064,
0.4032520354,
0.8374354243,
0.6951013207,
-0.2776952088,
-0.2702578902,
-0.9442929626,
-0.1598764658,
-0.1496396065,
-0.1117498502,
-0.1704579145,
0.7018136382,
0.1720520556,
0.9578681588,
-0.4329833984,
-0.5022875071,
-0.363918066,
0.5282332301,
-0.036062751,
0.4494058192,
0.5874708891,
-0.7658940554,
-0.4288049042,
-0.0367294252,
-1.0258136988,
-0.3117423356,
-0.347315371,
0.296325773,
0.2610177398,
0.4290593266,
-0.7345294952,
0.4220234454,
0.4464514256,
-0.2505219579,
0.8053566217,
-0.3928314745,
0.0489295237,
-0.733422935,
0.515681386,
0.0308153927,
-0.3157365322,
-0.4860685766,
0.0672581941,
0.2259082198,
0.3234554529,
-0.33018291,
0.3770407736,
-0.2809320986,
-0.135606125,
-0.4284089804,
0.3430389166,
0.1016473547,
0.4575036168,
0.0209230427,
0.8807933927,
0.2766801119,
-0.7028582692,
0.4596974254,
0.2454415411,
-0.1511550248,
0.6503653526,
-1.1253483295,
-0.2481968403,
-0.2178628892,
0.1753375381,
-0.9757427573,
-0.2409601361,
-0.3314048946,
-0.376858294,
0.1457097828,
0.4122824073,
-0.484482497,
-0.0944291502,
-0.4701558948,
-0.0680885091,
0.2074968666,
-0.4430684149,
0.5402008295,
0.4536871016,
-0.2052865922,
-0.8058763742,
-0.5924905539,
0.034263093,
-0.0996607542,
-0.4449361265,
0.5118740797,
-0.020767184,
-0.3318648338,
0.0618975237,
-0.3216446638,
-0.1213713959,
0.4048926234,
0.4261121154,
0.1917665303,
-0.074368082,
0.1660822928,
0.2865857184,
-0.1004052311,
0.2568465471,
-0.026336018,
0.1377692819,
-0.1230105087,
-0.1764356047,
-0.4045630395,
0.4288173914,
0.3214836717,
-0.2232114971,
0.7616285086,
0.560654819,
-0.2347356379,
-0.0193740893,
-0.5710313916,
-0.0200129319,
-0.3820835352,
0.2902902067,
-0.3206705153,
-0.5626547337,
0.3672420681,
-0.1799018085,
0.4741428792,
0.7351683378,
0.5099751949,
-0.5035743117,
0.4132775366,
0.9757830501,
-0.2467884868,
0.0466642417,
-0.1480477899,
-0.1127415895,
-0.5450472236,
-0.2330708355,
-0.571857214,
-0.1116940007,
-0.1640826017,
-0.1646164805,
0.2686123252,
0.3676110804,
0.0370161422,
0.628575325,
-0.1521561593,
0.5265002251,
0.7342314124,
-0.1846236438,
0.4770700336,
-0.2476101965,
0.076918222,
-0.0926550925,
-0.5949489474,
-0.4863547981,
1.2625910044,
0.0768108517,
0.5091778636,
0.2844557464,
0.4573468566,
0.6098470688,
0.4196549058,
-0.3580684662,
0.4093002975,
-0.1649941802,
-0.553737402,
-0.2662009895,
-0.3532618284,
-0.8057876229,
0.2049183547,
-0.2704290748,
-0.8244114518,
0.0858300105,
0.3018427491,
-0.3969377279,
0.1537230164,
-0.617387414,
0.9570656419,
0.0818982497,
-0.3658027947,
-0.3790090978,
-0.9287427664,
0.4550491869,
-0.2549682856,
-0.161838159,
-0.3938521743,
-0.0167497359,
0.8549565673,
-0.454815805,
0.7199855447,
0.1578958929,
0.1487796903,
0.0111269746,
-0.1567362398,
0.2641326189,
0.0582310371,
0.0406478755,
0.3116623163,
-0.0145274317,
-0.5653355718,
-0.4508166313,
0.390439868,
-0.5738345385,
-0.2921720743,
-0.3954758644,
-0.6293435693,
-0.3860276043,
0.2733562291,
0.3645719886,
0.4647007287,
-0.3510807753,
0.3350554109,
0.7255728245,
-0.0576157123,
0.5819645524,
0.4599942565,
-0.0086937528,
-0.2789923549,
0.8233141899,
-0.0367992856,
0.3803416491,
0.6738481522,
-0.1893825084,
-0.1697165817,
-0.5823233128,
-0.3802811801,
0.3200959265,
-0.7966793776,
-0.3933125436,
-0.8613538146,
0.0111250635,
-0.3633849025,
-0.3576505482,
-0.5176554322,
-0.80237782,
-0.1501556188,
-0.2135509998,
0.2932873666,
0.6530225873,
-0.1889656782,
0.4857046306,
-0.5824004412,
0.6340174675,
0.1688139737,
0.0803122222,
-0.1309654415,
-0.5145248771,
-0.4897359312,
-0.3196283281,
-0.4010085464,
-0.6574371457,
0.1897678375,
0.2936890125,
0.399739027,
0.2422649115,
0.16354312,
0.6538230181,
-0.4998133481,
0.7714188695,
0.241906032,
-1.0184043646,
0.5041755438,
-0.1851724386,
0.4851348698,
0.8657074571,
0.7279992104,
-0.3520147204,
-0.7351562381,
-0.514347434,
-0.9206284285,
0.5753439069,
0.186253041,
-0.2943645716,
0.0990071297,
0.0952995643,
0.2031517774,
0.2709047496,
-0.4116728008,
-0.6774522066,
-0.1553188413,
-0.0299343374,
-0.0720994174,
-0.038540069,
-0.2093369514,
-0.2159059346,
0.8939793706,
-0.2887783051,
0.0325480662,
0.2027959973,
-0.3547279239,
0.1612725258,
-0.118142359,
0.7377964258,
1.100502491,
-0.6000679731,
0.195942387,
0.0969925448,
-0.5893202424,
-0.1398162246,
0.3993822932,
-0.2813045084,
0.3723485768,
0.7055591941,
0.4583110213,
0.0290282965,
-0.8021213412,
0.6192647815,
-0.0019229172,
-0.0302220751,
-0.0482554212,
-0.1315699667,
0.1194847152,
0.0395094417,
0.5708069801,
0.1169740483,
0.348682642,
-0.2236136496,
0.4106203914,
0.3451078236,
-0.1942816675,
-0.4649046957,
1.1035678387,
0.2742648423,
0.0935247317,
0.3160110414,
-0.3180965185,
-0.0265673231,
0.52101475,
0.4146504402,
0.8252306581,
0.0755449235,
0.3142842948,
0.2895068824,
0.5961536765,
-0.0109289875,
0.2213322371,
-0.1758964062,
-0.4807470143,
-0.6961165071,
-0.3209083676,
-0.8308714032,
-0.0372497737,
-0.715650022,
0.0336359441,
-0.3694333136,
-0.0669856742,
0.5890364051,
0.0163161848,
-0.4729114473,
0.4687044621,
-0.1604056209,
1.0372006893,
-0.7441343069,
0.8711186647,
0.5938875675,
-0.6490310431,
-0.3683536351,
-0.1165847555,
0.0992006734,
-0.2577415705,
0.6342790127,
0.0924410149,
-0.1643418223,
-0.3441010118,
-0.3127266169,
-0.8456993699,
1.2041422129,
0.3022018969,
-0.2783280015,
0.0601818375,
0.0393520109,
0.469242245,
-0.1451895237,
0.1962182522,
0.6954209805,
0.1054163724,
-0.3143813908,
-1.1774923801,
0.1088357791,
-0.1930449456,
-0.214814052,
0.0803189054,
-0.6440718174,
0.84217453,
-0.2675371468,
-0.0747119784,
-0.1383504868,
1.0813093185,
0.1456464082,
0.3439303041,
0.1526286304,
0.2970690131,
0.903991282,
-0.2453468144,
1.103117466,
-0.2919836044,
0.3878465593,
1.5209727287,
-0.2733410299,
0.7613509893,
0.4824083447,
-0.3402181566,
0.0677741468,
0.311542511,
-0.0589574315,
0.580336988,
-0.1987503022,
-0.1440057755,
0.1006934643,
-0.1180724204,
-0.2671341598,
0.2701075673,
0.2180341035,
-0.0311734155,
-0.4323891103,
-0.0564287566,
0.1321107447,
0.0463145077,
-0.1310606003,
0.7780826092,
-0.0179954264,
-0.6449554563,
0.4815212488,
0.1302911192,
0.6147444248,
-0.7216814756,
0.1915353388,
-0.4105548561,
0.1649967432,
-0.2201363295,
-0.5943117738,
0.7373943925,
0.0183042195,
-0.2741556168,
-0.2388592511,
0.717598021,
-0.3171386421,
-0.2146110386,
0.110622026,
0.5181725025,
0.2059729099,
-0.1980354786,
-0.413841635,
0.0395722501,
-0.1362458616,
-0.2531582117,
0.1556254327,
0.3655079007,
0.0752899274,
0.7276281714,
0.4221398234,
0.2628038526,
0.0046002939,
-0.1984464973,
0.694756031,
-0.6752288938,
-0.288272649,
-0.6720685363,
0.5208720565,
-0.4918932319,
-0.7016208768,
0.9682074785,
0.7786861062,
0.8786485791,
-0.0774655417,
0.8170887232,
-0.2723869979,
0.5332254767,
-0.3771073818,
0.6874011755,
-0.5174880624,
0.041987855,
-0.1751749516,
-0.8141708374,
-0.5923182368,
0.3538249135,
0.0425121188,
-0.272687614,
0.8977856636,
0.3600578904,
-0.0585139431,
0.0886027887,
0.3087786734,
-0.1673793048,
0.2545946836,
0.1762607992,
0.371461004,
-0.4405617416,
0.3547319472,
-0.6292876005,
-0.1479161829,
-0.2652132213,
-0.9767212272,
-0.9861472845,
-0.6399462223,
-0.6343684196,
-0.2487524301,
0.0658194646,
0.9291988015,
0.7391906381,
-1.0374400616,
-0.2637695074,
0.0343360454,
0.1728815138,
-0.6988928318,
-0.1629445851,
0.6240252256,
-0.5481013656,
-0.6136868596,
0.3149660528,
0.5930595994,
-0.079840064,
-0.14661102,
0.2622974217,
-0.3277432323,
-0.0202655643,
0.7060613036,
0.4367511272,
-0.6852893829,
-0.0462124608,
-0.1393762976,
-0.2119483799,
-0.1111986935,
0.8135014176,
-0.6220174432,
0.2239285111,
0.232157886,
1.0716847181,
0.4297849834,
0.1417453587,
0.6187942028,
-1.0603032112,
-0.0011634815,
0.0284928512,
0.4014042914,
0.38763237,
-0.1088534817,
0.8171895742,
0.2957004309,
-0.5704953671,
-0.7594531775,
-0.2049510479,
-1.261687398,
-0.3016903102,
0.8291897774,
-0.5061223507,
-0.1042168885,
-0.4336557686,
0.1343904287,
0.086120382,
-0.2504836023,
0.9326745868,
0.7005241513,
-0.2696925402,
0.2303266525,
-0.5171262026,
0.70042485,
0.5333304405,
-1.2684794664,
0.396967411,
0.6026221514,
0.129131794,
0.4504587054,
0.7561035156,
0.2593986094,
0.5987936258,
-0.0297389105,
0.1157372594,
-0.0436797775,
-0.619559288,
-0.2529327869,
0.377881825,
-0.2036342919,
-0.0606541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14293v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14293v2 | WebIE: Faithful and Robust Information Extraction on the Web | 2023-05-23T17:37:53 | 2023-06-15T13:51:36 | Chenxi Whitehouse, Clara Vania, Alham Fikri Aji, Christos Christodoulopoulos, Andrea Pierleoni | cs.CL | cs.CL | Extracting structured and grounded fact triples from raw text is a
fundamental task in Information Extraction (IE). Existing IE datasets are
typically collected from Wikipedia articles, using hyperlinks to link entities
to the Wikidata knowledge base. However, models trained only on Wikipedia have
limitations when applied to web domains, which often contain noisy text or text
that does not have any factual information. We present WebIE, the first
large-scale, entity-linked closed IE dataset consisting of 1.6M sentences
automatically collected from the English Common Crawl corpus. WebIE also
includes negative examples, i.e. sentences without fact triples, to better
reflect the data on the web. We annotate ~21K triples from WebIE through
crowdsourcing and introduce mWebIE, a translation of the annotated set in four
other languages: French, Spanish, Portuguese, and Hindi. We evaluate the
in-domain, out-of-domain, and zero-shot cross-lingual performance of generative
IE models and find models trained on WebIE show better generalisability. We
also propose three training strategies that use entity linking as an auxiliary
task. Our experiments show that adding Entity-Linking objectives improves the
faithfulness of our generative IE models. | [
-0.4678229392,
-0.416839838,
0.4173801839,
0.2258797437,
-0.1135705784,
-0.2530896962,
-0.1899097115,
-0.9409141541,
0.1128112674,
0.3211007118,
-0.3739032149,
-0.5867707133,
-0.4631744921,
0.4664767087,
-0.4940946698,
0.8739743829,
0.0999050364,
-0.0979889557,
-0.2815755606,
0.0061281752,
0.159579128,
-0.2301790267,
-0.2259668261,
0.1309624463,
0.5148371458,
0.6014173031,
0.4390769601,
0.4982334971,
0.6194714308,
0.1990172416,
0.5695106387,
0.4070031047,
-0.6060968637,
-0.0190627854,
-0.3666453362,
-0.4865550399,
-0.3382971287,
0.5322805643,
0.459264189,
0.7351834178,
-0.1125777066,
0.406579107,
0.0766809657,
0.4749163389,
-0.870590508,
0.3802262843,
-0.6547256112,
-0.3384373784,
-0.193333745,
0.0214416422,
-0.4851820469,
-0.3805273473,
0.1043563709,
-1.1115704775,
0.442058444,
0.2165748626,
1.4445666075,
0.1766965836,
-0.3668067455,
-0.2026488185,
-0.6301784515,
0.8639683723,
-0.3325246274,
0.861954391,
0.4308176339,
-0.0910144225,
-0.0457148477,
-0.6777133942,
-0.8133247495,
0.0576561503,
0.0595994592,
0.2162656188,
-0.461766839,
-0.2040033191,
0.2851422727,
0.1803483665,
-0.4221152365,
0.0956275314,
-0.4224403203,
-0.1740383804,
0.5436319709,
-0.4225985408,
0.5068783164,
-0.2472472638,
-0.3902819753,
-0.1358471811,
-0.6967593431,
-0.3391112089,
0.4205734432,
0.2422392815,
-0.0321950614,
0.7063271999,
-0.0205432046,
0.418384254,
0.1416193992,
-0.4625111222,
0.2940891087,
-0.1305235624,
0.0698960796,
-0.2109104991,
0.8645294309,
0.6090158224,
0.546751976,
-0.6473004222,
-0.0873207375,
0.0313568264,
-0.0067508887,
-0.7775446177,
-0.3083870113,
0.2381682396,
-0.3498650193,
-0.144572705,
0.3577335179,
-0.8242946267,
0.1862780154,
-0.1658647358,
0.2655776441,
-0.4876022637,
-0.3255490661,
0.057639651,
-0.6628392935,
0.1958544403,
0.2516260445,
-0.6337091327,
0.3580387235,
0.4214888513,
0.6095071435,
-0.2248579413,
-0.297164768,
-0.4104016721,
0.6867787242,
-0.0801716596,
0.7633466125,
-0.5222233534,
0.0609400682,
-0.0543606989,
-0.0081511419,
0.0098761488,
-0.4684141576,
0.6160508394,
-0.7425428629,
0.357925266,
-0.1005358174,
-0.6418482065,
-0.1802205294,
0.2490750253,
-1.0950329304,
0.7516023517,
-0.3485265374,
-0.9384727478,
0.5024887919,
-0.740245223,
-0.4591135979,
-0.0190946385,
0.0985319167,
-0.0680320486,
0.0112905698,
0.3609725833,
0.5315150023,
-0.3060201108,
-0.0294389054,
-0.5140382051,
-0.2050907612,
-0.1060359776,
-0.4655769169,
0.8616454005,
-0.0479253754,
-0.255181402,
-0.6877223253,
-1.174757719,
0.0719820112,
0.2648364007,
-0.5552894473,
-0.5148690939,
0.0404616259,
0.171540454,
0.0446809791,
0.1552933902,
-0.8798782229,
0.2533598542,
-0.2310071439,
0.252669394,
0.4167668223,
0.0526927561,
-0.0297902804,
0.0631958619,
-0.0197174735,
-0.1270457655,
0.0192177705,
0.2636734843,
-0.6395291686,
-0.5755233169,
-0.522433579,
0.6429224014,
0.7435318828,
-0.7792901397,
0.2906051576,
-0.867702961,
-0.1837864667,
-0.4903353751,
0.1509002149,
0.1588622779,
0.3882165849,
0.5641795993,
-0.0416871309,
-0.5307269692,
-1.0569263697,
-0.1503454298,
-0.273989439,
-0.3821208179,
-0.0777216777,
0.4377553761,
-0.1297903955,
0.8118425012,
-0.485693574,
-0.1314703375,
-0.001484422,
0.4938688874,
-0.0772179663,
0.1185594201,
0.241586253,
-1.1516158581,
-0.3664171696,
-0.1959351152,
-1.0935572386,
-0.0771362036,
0.2042510957,
-0.1296065152,
-0.0973451212,
0.1277314276,
-0.9597190619,
0.222395435,
0.5489775538,
0.2264739871,
0.2708161175,
0.3596359193,
0.0890755504,
-1.0773074627,
0.2608616948,
0.3877496123,
-0.4302597344,
-0.2672350705,
0.2800881565,
0.0806016251,
-0.0353348628,
-0.2609614432,
0.4176042676,
-0.7814183235,
0.0118912989,
-0.08594127,
0.6006606221,
0.4785714746,
0.4980233014,
-0.0155845443,
0.8193230629,
0.1479612291,
-0.7429126501,
0.3633410633,
0.4961697757,
0.0223025717,
0.5077241063,
-0.223940447,
0.2958273292,
-0.0387278125,
0.0827175751,
-0.5199965239,
-0.4503305256,
0.0031723748,
-0.4820964038,
0.4230103493,
-0.1913270801,
-0.4568419158,
-0.3401273191,
-0.4763548672,
0.0136304321,
0.2785745561,
-0.6935213804,
0.4570224285,
0.6536487937,
-0.0202441402,
-0.5766797662,
-0.4977292418,
0.4209454954,
0.028191071,
-0.6602137089,
0.3728633821,
0.0052585294,
-0.5119934082,
0.2914645076,
-0.1389479935,
-0.4997197092,
0.2173275501,
0.0709249824,
0.356351018,
-0.207184121,
0.099085629,
-0.2653838694,
0.1446487308,
0.1426676363,
-0.4776520729,
0.0624655969,
-0.1226745471,
-0.0987929851,
-0.5449793339,
0.5555462241,
0.3629369736,
-0.066481173,
0.686332047,
0.7544431686,
-0.7018711567,
0.1916796565,
-0.7576296329,
0.0721922219,
-0.3521057665,
0.0825923979,
-0.4603580832,
-0.5970563889,
0.0183182675,
-0.2179545313,
0.2517722249,
0.8711061478,
-0.1232262626,
-0.4513435364,
0.8817286491,
0.9208887815,
-0.1554847956,
0.0718974918,
-0.2438134551,
0.1409127414,
-0.5568785071,
-0.2028412074,
-0.6162769794,
0.0082283262,
-0.6255520582,
-0.0009356479,
0.234341383,
0.6057943702,
0.1900893301,
0.3277429044,
-0.1693685949,
0.4531444609,
0.7103464007,
0.2975665629,
0.3645052612,
0.3360545933,
0.0345240347,
0.2237946838,
-0.5714452267,
-0.7301529646,
1.2742391825,
0.0078676241,
0.4944920838,
0.445114702,
0.6712487936,
0.3857076168,
0.3209812045,
-0.6107330918,
0.3874710798,
-0.0430862643,
-0.6889379025,
-0.4095695019,
-0.4004098177,
-0.7956798077,
-0.1679820567,
-0.3186331689,
-0.771900773,
0.2156850547,
0.1732976437,
-0.0441884063,
0.3890203536,
-0.884924829,
0.3688042462,
0.0234291609,
-0.6997020841,
-0.0794890821,
-0.7176946402,
0.2292344719,
0.0411718898,
0.2807220221,
-0.003456024,
-0.0805757642,
0.6053767204,
-0.1178774983,
0.6998413801,
-0.0183510408,
-0.0086689638,
0.3180051446,
-0.0609983094,
0.6518903971,
-0.0923078284,
0.1366879344,
0.6583513021,
-0.1706361175,
-0.6611267924,
-0.3913227916,
0.5528698564,
-0.8305525184,
-0.6759219766,
-0.0838166252,
-0.0120950984,
-0.520968318,
0.343857199,
0.3529975712,
0.4014696479,
-0.3805054724,
0.1465542465,
0.8618580103,
0.2183010429,
0.5847673416,
0.2778719366,
0.1027462706,
-0.3936778903,
0.99540627,
-0.134257704,
-0.0046595368,
0.7296898365,
-0.0688368827,
-0.2321484983,
-0.3814083934,
-0.6782252789,
0.2167609036,
-0.6344009638,
-0.3250250518,
-0.9285982847,
-0.0294949878,
-0.3135102689,
0.1942436546,
-0.1694504619,
-0.7135606408,
-0.2864284813,
-0.3811564445,
0.134320125,
0.9051390886,
-0.4646600783,
-0.2202645093,
-1.0356948376,
0.6428355575,
0.4535852671,
0.2872996032,
-0.3026937544,
0.1590184569,
-0.3197778165,
0.0413623415,
-0.0305491406,
-1.20782125,
-0.0483468845,
0.3830374181,
0.483061403,
0.4676101804,
-0.1788176298,
0.5633612871,
-0.4783278704,
0.788428843,
0.3003263474,
-0.7199751735,
0.3865080774,
-0.4075215757,
-0.2797582746,
0.4643985033,
0.8371919394,
-0.0346118957,
-0.1203444898,
-0.5397192836,
-0.6667134762,
0.3630777001,
0.4299507439,
-0.1039452851,
-0.4170943201,
0.3708432615,
0.250546366,
0.2956320345,
-0.8724934459,
-0.1414838731,
-0.3989872634,
-0.4349995852,
0.3157021105,
-0.3543287516,
-0.1284297556,
-0.1150661334,
0.9809653163,
-0.1713277847,
0.2336155176,
0.29266873,
-0.5704134703,
-0.1914407909,
0.2374271005,
0.0447295159,
0.759493351,
-0.2525982261,
0.1561520547,
0.0080742678,
-0.7850496173,
-0.0621851124,
0.3115856051,
-0.2161530405,
0.0079945046,
0.6094921231,
0.4457185268,
0.146431461,
-0.496339947,
0.7666162252,
-0.0443908609,
-0.0598962717,
-0.1893385947,
-0.1289976984,
-0.0411876999,
0.0463359579,
0.4924572408,
-0.0187593047,
0.5757238269,
-0.434636116,
0.3822862208,
0.264531523,
-0.216800645,
-0.5617759824,
0.6450583935,
0.5491400361,
0.0516304933,
0.7925071716,
-0.2960098982,
-0.4068852663,
0.1035567448,
0.6560864449,
0.8378423452,
0.1283891797,
0.1995333135,
0.5454195738,
0.4620556831,
-0.0227162838,
0.1394536346,
0.1201302633,
-0.8620898128,
-0.4252725542,
-0.6085510254,
-0.3637106717,
0.3215566576,
-0.9037077427,
0.1735937893,
-0.1436220706,
0.0573028438,
0.168618843,
-0.0373521671,
-0.9813301563,
0.3511638641,
0.2688499093,
0.9890691042,
-0.7724419236,
0.5483847857,
0.6138111949,
-0.716511488,
-0.6979660988,
0.4089703262,
-0.0876706168,
-0.7273312807,
0.5567967892,
0.2248488814,
-0.3167233765,
0.2244625092,
-0.9612480402,
-0.9030835629,
0.8526116014,
0.4098553956,
-0.6095164418,
-0.3159530163,
-0.0213967878,
0.192750141,
-0.0534112081,
0.1281688511,
0.1759032011,
0.6061272621,
-0.2764135897,
-0.7544667721,
-0.0509583429,
-0.446626991,
-0.5298674703,
0.1768749058,
-0.7655014992,
0.5863952041,
-0.1648985744,
-0.5640750527,
-0.219328329,
0.6917744875,
-0.1827647239,
-0.138339445,
0.7099661827,
0.7207072377,
1.0004533529,
0.0710435733,
0.9525571465,
-0.3586689532,
0.1957629472,
0.9805433154,
-0.3258591294,
1.0161209106,
0.3464890122,
-0.0053907367,
0.7579770088,
0.3531271219,
-0.1164384633,
0.3037160635,
-0.2819836736,
-0.1883943528,
-0.4331786335,
-0.2303619385,
0.1640303135,
0.6032902598,
0.3292689919,
0.0897219628,
-0.1994519979,
0.0275762677,
0.2077390999,
-0.0155885825,
-0.1151715741,
0.8078337312,
-0.1147073209,
-0.5091218352,
0.2685698569,
0.0159502346,
0.3228583634,
-0.320089817,
-0.6292800903,
-0.0586967468,
-0.3575627506,
-0.2192490548,
-0.5118437409,
-0.1335312426,
0.3536064923,
-0.499067992,
0.0538745448,
0.8649866581,
-0.215934068,
-0.4350522757,
0.240230605,
0.5830678344,
0.3318009675,
-0.2517151833,
-0.4485214353,
-0.3267852962,
0.1018520519,
-0.3201500177,
-0.0936625004,
0.7150450945,
-0.0987617001,
0.5163975954,
0.7290552258,
-0.1339956224,
0.1032621115,
-0.1255487055,
0.81511271,
-0.7730268836,
-0.1623084247,
-0.6614140868,
0.3448934257,
-0.5628374815,
-0.0799153447,
0.7563247085,
0.8684574366,
0.8430582881,
0.192688629,
1.1717225313,
-0.1088853255,
0.4821192622,
-0.6836915612,
0.24687846,
-0.4664030373,
-0.1081080288,
-0.0099996962,
-1.0668021441,
-0.0164570846,
0.2233968973,
0.3404235244,
-0.2252958268,
0.8045935035,
0.3174172342,
-0.3559915721,
0.2143352181,
0.2583094537,
0.3815446496,
0.0793104544,
0.1540616155,
0.5747586489,
-0.5163879395,
0.7408430576,
-0.141760543,
-0.3447338641,
0.067675367,
-0.7652611136,
-0.8257363439,
-0.4242456257,
-0.2648026347,
-0.25924775,
0.0533859394,
0.8858536482,
0.7481483221,
-0.8248705864,
0.2529467642,
0.0626893267,
0.0767393708,
0.0508819968,
-0.2201232314,
0.2543233931,
-0.0854936093,
-0.7882829309,
0.6394036412,
0.3367435634,
0.03601804,
-0.1082630381,
0.4310610294,
-0.6028422117,
0.1426033378,
0.4217387438,
0.2782835066,
-0.5224555731,
-0.7049828768,
-0.0043331571,
-0.1297024637,
0.2209623307,
0.3142464459,
-0.4711516201,
0.1914561093,
-0.0175356623,
0.4625590742,
0.5538460612,
0.0191607662,
0.5657674074,
-0.8521744013,
-0.0580140315,
-0.0355317071,
0.3543992937,
0.5259615183,
-0.4207681119,
0.7109906077,
0.5484666228,
-0.1464827359,
-0.4514736533,
0.0473163128,
-0.7841615677,
-0.2079820484,
1.1494756937,
-0.348076582,
-0.4018895626,
-0.3451023102,
0.3385199308,
0.3544820845,
-0.276669383,
0.6803450584,
0.8494853973,
0.1653604507,
0.2129000425,
-0.5059921145,
0.298073858,
-0.3832645714,
-0.8470484614,
-0.2337548882,
0.7303822041,
0.4871996045,
0.5192388296,
0.3469958305,
0.2069348246,
0.0065140673,
0.2251144797,
0.6987512708,
-0.0069458387,
-0.7096924186,
0.2670194805,
0.4430117011,
-0.078312479,
-0.2731033862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14292v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14292v2 | WikiChat: Stopping the Hallucination of Large Language Model Chatbots by Few-Shot Grounding on Wikipedia | 2023-05-23T17:37:36 | 2023-10-27T19:11:55 | Sina J. Semnani, Violet Z. Yao, Heidi C. Zhang, Monica S. Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the first few-shot LLM-based chatbot that almost never
hallucinates and has high conversationality and low latency. WikiChat is
grounded on the English Wikipedia, the largest curated free-text corpus.
WikiChat generates a response from an LLM, retains only the grounded facts,
and combines them with additional information it retrieves from the corpus to
form factual and engaging responses. We distill WikiChat based on GPT-4 into a
7B-parameter LLaMA model with minimal loss of quality, to significantly improve
its latency, cost and privacy, and facilitate research and deployment.
Using a novel hybrid human-and-LLM evaluation methodology, we show that our
best system achieves 97.3% factual accuracy in simulated conversations. It
significantly outperforms all retrieval-based and LLM-based baselines, and by
3.9%, 38.6% and 51.0% on head, tail and recent knowledge compared to GPT-4.
Compared to previous state-of-the-art retrieval-based chatbots, WikiChat is
also significantly more informative and engaging, just like an LLM.
WikiChat achieves 97.9% factual accuracy in conversations with human users
about recent topics, 55.0% better than GPT-4, while receiving significantly
higher user ratings and more favorable comments. | [
-0.3886688352,
-1.0927786827,
0.5813964605,
0.0965394899,
-0.2355377823,
0.1761705577,
-0.3413698971,
-0.5433812141,
0.6199232936,
0.358784169,
-0.4544837177,
-0.5983406901,
-0.4631812871,
0.0948267132,
-0.6533869505,
1.0375666618,
0.6714092493,
-0.0999680534,
-0.3777609169,
0.1242088974,
-0.1939684153,
-0.3745888174,
-0.3179976046,
-0.3320688903,
0.6871929765,
0.6122424603,
0.8327472806,
0.0305410624,
0.344511807,
0.3347732425,
-0.006073562,
0.1060656086,
-1.0223733187,
0.3509578705,
-0.0498838164,
-0.7679727674,
-0.207503736,
-0.0067966101,
0.0143872099,
0.410243839,
-0.3013278544,
0.1304088086,
-0.0368708745,
0.3697622716,
-0.6394537687,
0.0294375923,
-0.9200494885,
-0.1788625568,
-0.3513661027,
-0.1993461996,
-0.4488196075,
-0.3073822856,
-0.0412513576,
-0.7126407623,
0.1256883442,
0.0720195025,
0.786429584,
0.3802408278,
-0.0725902691,
-0.1457194537,
-0.767313838,
0.5310137272,
-0.8138192892,
0.4288415611,
0.7312718034,
0.4029620886,
-0.5763292313,
-0.5490481853,
-1.1806397438,
-0.3412683606,
0.0966653526,
0.12529549,
-0.2216128707,
0.0246997643,
0.2669907212,
-0.0317911729,
-0.5366843939,
0.2280954719,
-0.6122285724,
-0.3348625898,
0.2863339186,
0.0910689086,
0.2110276222,
-0.5327866673,
-0.1802308708,
0.2661875486,
-0.5877842307,
-0.1225268319,
0.4711180329,
0.0042049875,
-0.1351419836,
0.8438662291,
-0.699018538,
0.4559026062,
0.3735900819,
-0.6629101634,
0.1797554642,
0.141211167,
-0.1853014082,
-0.2066109478,
0.9979252815,
0.4960594177,
0.3282570541,
-0.3366098106,
0.2549962103,
0.381184727,
0.3741606176,
-0.758192122,
-0.4476643801,
0.4113573134,
-0.3112207055,
-0.6406034827,
-0.1382614672,
-0.6107544303,
-0.5026597977,
0.054667186,
0.4717288613,
-0.5389826894,
-0.2811673284,
-0.1599131972,
0.0693255216,
0.2147125006,
0.6275651455,
-0.9235972166,
0.3609990478,
0.7313498259,
1.0747106075,
-0.4824557006,
-0.2524366677,
-0.2576104105,
0.0941955447,
-0.5662699342,
1.012491107,
-0.4329340756,
-0.1563644111,
-0.2003887892,
-0.2586395442,
0.6211310029,
-0.2305986434,
0.3816690743,
-0.4959897101,
0.5335288048,
0.1688269228,
-0.5788843632,
-0.2281966209,
0.630400598,
-0.5066689253,
1.1544594765,
-0.2212960422,
-0.9100257158,
0.3843876123,
-0.5885289907,
-0.3259314895,
0.3072709739,
-0.414298892,
0.0203831345,
0.0117456047,
-0.068342872,
0.6300222874,
-0.2392798811,
0.24515827,
-0.4332438707,
-0.72329849,
0.0810077786,
-0.5223489404,
0.6636772156,
-0.0650930777,
-0.4720628858,
0.0712788552,
-0.926004231,
-0.0475871339,
0.1107586846,
-0.2354026735,
-0.2443381995,
-0.0113448184,
-0.1632550508,
0.424310565,
0.2553804815,
-0.6519238949,
0.0484932475,
-0.5800931454,
0.1728187948,
0.8766257167,
-0.158721298,
0.3905727565,
-0.2038169652,
0.4708608389,
-0.1224944964,
0.3011204898,
-0.0625439212,
-0.8767220378,
-0.928162992,
-0.4251223505,
0.013970674,
0.6285078526,
-0.7560886741,
0.7047905326,
-0.5031759739,
-0.842284739,
-0.4681660533,
0.1496128738,
-0.1183440313,
0.6979093552,
0.2579874098,
-0.0628100783,
-0.3259653747,
-0.9557864666,
0.1510539651,
-0.5570499897,
-0.3007452488,
0.1385060847,
0.3561629653,
-0.2728485763,
1.1084574461,
-0.3160028458,
-0.0210358314,
-0.1882870644,
-0.1077247038,
0.471627444,
0.1065397039,
0.2820127904,
-0.6822813153,
-0.7657103539,
-0.1654940844,
-0.8300154209,
0.0062585315,
-0.0412393883,
-0.3065418005,
0.2431983352,
-0.012448011,
-1.4348398447,
0.624268651,
0.6501259804,
-0.1251884699,
0.5160158277,
0.1578345895,
0.2331194133,
-1.104613781,
0.1233709231,
-0.3081775904,
-0.4574077427,
-0.659671545,
-0.3030452728,
-0.0665389821,
-0.0633118972,
-0.5970453024,
0.4930711389,
-0.0285228733,
0.1064499766,
-0.5016307831,
0.3001888096,
-0.1942374855,
0.6534817219,
-0.1935671568,
0.7815961838,
0.4955582619,
-0.5685973763,
0.6470208764,
0.5482866168,
-0.3284142315,
0.61450243,
-0.4788197279,
0.4802859426,
-0.068162851,
0.5270134211,
-1.1414747238,
-0.3895316124,
0.5331831574,
-0.8341493011,
-0.0134731019,
-0.0231875386,
-0.6136299372,
-0.3838091493,
-0.6553825736,
-0.2722406089,
0.6902366281,
-0.4795489907,
0.4199120104,
0.3865020573,
-0.1725144833,
-0.6719282866,
-0.365475297,
0.4954937696,
-0.1067910194,
-0.7724084854,
0.2740277052,
-0.2069140822,
-0.1934849471,
-0.2459667921,
-0.4098666906,
0.0031849809,
0.1136327684,
0.4693503678,
0.391766578,
0.1345066577,
0.1030015647,
-0.2082606256,
-0.3176240921,
-0.1628159285,
-0.1534026861,
0.8544511199,
0.3685201705,
-0.157732591,
-0.7408210039,
0.161610648,
0.5768094063,
0.5144785047,
0.84332335,
0.6494013071,
-0.4813853204,
-0.0216053315,
-0.885284543,
-0.4144593775,
-0.5113642216,
0.3029950559,
-0.5088763833,
-0.89890486,
0.2357700467,
0.1261876225,
0.1112620011,
0.3737894595,
0.8764087558,
-0.5424262285,
0.6510540843,
0.7510522008,
-0.3373964131,
0.297213316,
0.2038052529,
0.2902040184,
-0.165201202,
-0.2857292593,
-0.4988590479,
-0.3302618861,
-0.6568344831,
-0.3203708231,
0.2898963988,
0.1077249795,
0.0798765048,
0.4427844286,
-0.422006309,
0.6713120341,
0.5597201586,
0.2434310615,
0.4067405164,
0.0383212641,
0.0663676336,
-0.1368563324,
-0.5949530005,
-0.7201342583,
1.2286483049,
0.1249595284,
0.9066646099,
0.2119294256,
0.6302629113,
0.5293045044,
0.3743072152,
-0.8980811834,
0.6735364795,
0.3936634362,
-0.8690602183,
-0.6022389531,
-0.3683934808,
-0.635543406,
0.3343495727,
-0.3938292563,
-0.902808845,
-0.4316403866,
-0.0084152902,
-0.2287487835,
0.266636461,
-0.5207149386,
0.3702478707,
-0.0705167279,
-0.4382340014,
-0.4067321122,
-0.6658838391,
0.5079342127,
-0.1381091923,
0.1196962744,
-0.5604994893,
-0.0652186051,
0.7181951404,
-0.3416744173,
1.1274579763,
-0.0685736611,
-0.2079930454,
0.1185349673,
0.3016746342,
0.6966663599,
-0.0227682851,
0.0915257409,
0.5739510059,
-0.0013830315,
-0.3844948113,
-0.6735936403,
0.8224110007,
-0.6851407886,
-0.7919192314,
-0.1725046933,
-0.234478876,
-0.3765833378,
0.1970636398,
0.5210456848,
-0.0968078375,
-0.2206309289,
0.3687579632,
0.4077526331,
-0.2772940695,
0.1413409114,
0.4569426477,
-0.3045597076,
-0.2248622328,
0.7037665844,
-0.0609649718,
0.1318418533,
0.3482314646,
0.272995919,
-0.2219900042,
-0.4280784726,
-0.3083479702,
0.183400318,
-0.8822912574,
-0.4066752791,
-0.9519760013,
0.01020444,
-0.5123270154,
-0.054601144,
-0.4323927462,
-0.5951113701,
-0.0543392375,
-0.2279933989,
0.5549701452,
0.6679347157,
0.0311617926,
0.3048279583,
-0.5169520378,
0.7066833377,
0.2503318787,
0.1684524566,
-0.2343295217,
-0.6369431615,
-0.0238593444,
-0.1129821613,
-0.2471212745,
-0.9663370252,
0.0567361787,
0.0604878776,
0.5581426024,
0.5846661925,
0.1895723194,
0.6577051282,
-0.6248616576,
0.9392076135,
0.6487213373,
-0.7828598022,
0.4165414274,
-0.2815795839,
0.0266112909,
0.4994463027,
0.45920223,
-0.712002337,
-0.6941845417,
-0.5421817303,
-0.4959287047,
0.5759146214,
0.4310322404,
0.6423784494,
-0.1554755569,
0.1664585918,
0.4774790108,
0.1719566584,
-0.799041748,
-0.2427664995,
-0.2498533875,
-0.2690805197,
0.1304678321,
-0.4235447645,
-0.0287412126,
-0.3275873661,
0.64459306,
-0.222553432,
0.225342989,
-0.3008001149,
-0.3624064922,
0.0845961124,
0.1292729378,
0.5985962152,
0.7076385617,
-0.0374731943,
0.1155327335,
0.3515205681,
-0.6221737862,
0.170289278,
-0.3022973835,
-0.2888269126,
0.21098046,
0.3535318077,
0.4896219075,
0.4283660948,
-0.5071392655,
0.7265481949,
0.1830044538,
-0.0531936064,
-0.3439799249,
0.3255246878,
0.2424286753,
0.2887368202,
0.5520454049,
-0.0682895109,
0.1018400714,
-0.3140186667,
0.128652066,
0.3619777262,
0.054890044,
-0.4789802134,
0.666249752,
0.6298735142,
-0.4745224714,
0.3739314079,
0.0549320616,
-0.4769476652,
0.093245618,
0.5113836527,
0.5596917272,
-0.0448476225,
0.3454463482,
0.3778349757,
0.227793619,
0.0664001927,
-0.0182633009,
-0.4494818151,
-0.8378121853,
-0.4478359222,
-0.4253052771,
-0.7538174391,
0.2472066581,
-0.2724785209,
0.5106551051,
-0.6130427122,
-0.2447522134,
-0.0436479896,
0.0534898452,
-0.6471952796,
-0.1827370971,
0.1496009678,
0.8825137615,
-0.4523304701,
0.989592433,
0.1353481561,
-0.3415227532,
-0.0887723044,
0.1606577188,
0.1499244124,
-0.6964544654,
0.4936676621,
0.4086606503,
-0.3735326827,
0.0426689461,
-1.1268081665,
-0.7374184728,
0.9898667932,
0.4586715102,
-0.8019964099,
-0.1901875138,
-0.0472014546,
0.3548390567,
0.2933470607,
0.2828175426,
0.4862547517,
0.3840925992,
0.0881690383,
-1.1540509462,
-0.2329909652,
-0.1803482324,
-0.428683579,
-0.1248347685,
-0.6206624508,
0.4167856872,
-0.1920972615,
-0.2567632496,
0.1301348656,
0.6279255152,
0.3628976643,
-0.0171078332,
0.5355288982,
0.2424933612,
1.0898849964,
0.1146779135,
0.8026492596,
-0.3386363089,
0.2748283148,
0.9708977938,
-0.4644754231,
0.9951589704,
0.748375535,
-0.4252047241,
0.521297574,
0.3820039928,
0.1471410245,
0.4923618138,
0.0922077373,
-0.3579575717,
-0.3311511874,
0.3159076869,
-0.1813696623,
0.7515444756,
0.3407742977,
0.3443436027,
-0.0706357583,
0.0500385799,
0.2508847713,
-0.1334072053,
0.3022428751,
0.8395658135,
-0.0553984158,
-0.3464540839,
0.5514032841,
-0.0630775243,
1.394996047,
-0.7451305985,
-0.0649850368,
-0.3717670441,
-0.1745438129,
-0.2644386292,
-0.4665514529,
-0.065621838,
0.3570126891,
-0.1919174939,
0.1766480654,
1.0793832541,
-0.2786642611,
-0.3146778941,
0.2071008533,
0.4504634142,
0.5488976836,
-0.1974566132,
-0.4233166277,
0.1696654409,
-0.2353605926,
-0.421828866,
0.0559621528,
0.3879857361,
0.0306208767,
0.8745097518,
1.0304961205,
0.0660765544,
-0.0623444244,
-0.077684775,
0.8326153159,
-0.7966966629,
-0.7131236196,
-0.9258415103,
0.312264055,
-0.3817612529,
-0.2429257929,
0.8745482564,
0.4720117152,
0.6086940169,
-0.0048889332,
0.7722449303,
-0.1907179207,
0.6471968889,
-0.4157671928,
1.0500338078,
-0.1316580623,
0.0336584188,
-0.3295462132,
-0.9732209444,
-0.2701639533,
1.0001553297,
0.1669610441,
-0.1770797819,
0.438552022,
0.7977210879,
-0.040122997,
-0.1331201643,
1.0093775988,
0.3737979829,
0.40170753,
0.2709259093,
1.1204292774,
-0.1616942734,
0.8598965406,
-0.245286122,
-0.2128263265,
-0.3998037875,
-0.61543262,
-1.2062913179,
-0.3958927989,
-0.1121888757,
-0.4868451059,
-0.0800519511,
0.9464678168,
0.9214689136,
-0.6802369952,
0.1163438484,
0.2700664997,
0.0135529432,
0.3923942149,
-0.2353508174,
0.0093214409,
-0.3813537359,
-0.6962587237,
0.6567826271,
0.5008538365,
-0.1960226297,
-0.6041021347,
-0.3364747167,
-0.0562226363,
0.1169804558,
0.7937171459,
0.1430106014,
-1.0639243126,
-0.499019891,
0.1072981879,
-0.3651434779,
0.1596055925,
0.4173538685,
-0.9795903563,
0.2696597278,
0.3305136263,
0.574770689,
0.7563685179,
-0.0991457999,
0.3338917196,
-0.6228555441,
0.5243980885,
0.1880427003,
0.0143713411,
0.4069103301,
-0.4741243422,
0.5167449117,
0.4107684195,
-0.2508509457,
-0.7064580917,
-0.0990862921,
-0.8759055734,
-0.143073827,
1.2260756493,
0.2070908993,
-0.1257059723,
-0.3705895245,
-0.2805452943,
0.1242332086,
-0.5356826782,
1.1140428782,
1.0030784607,
0.0306734648,
-0.0420201793,
-0.6548696756,
0.388766259,
0.074826315,
-1.0684591532,
-0.2240804583,
0.7207023501,
0.5336428285,
0.1387598664,
1.0215872526,
0.225132823,
0.3447805941,
0.0720880106,
0.2512819767,
0.0403765775,
-0.5347305536,
0.0530337356,
0.1387411058,
-0.18451868,
-0.3275064528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14291v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14291v2 | Evaluation of African American Language Bias in Natural Language Generation | 2023-05-23T17:34:37 | 2023-11-13T01:41:43 | Nicholas Deas, Jessi Grieser, Shana Kleiner, Desmond Patton, Elsbeth Turcan, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL | We evaluate how well LLMs understand African American Language (AAL) in
comparison to their performance on White Mainstream English (WME), the
encouraged "standard" form of English taught in American classrooms. We measure
LLM performance using automatic metrics and human judgments for two tasks: a
counterpart generation task, where a model generates AAL (or WME) given WME (or
AAL), and a masked span prediction (MSP) task, where models predict a phrase
that was removed from their input. Our contributions include: (1) evaluation of
six pre-trained, large language models on the two language generation tasks;
(2) a novel dataset of AAL text from multiple contexts (social media, hip-hop
lyrics, focus groups, and linguistic interviews) with human-annotated
counterparts in WME; and (3) documentation of model performance gaps that
suggest bias and identification of trends in lack of understanding of AAL
features. | [
-0.6376785636,
-0.9938216805,
0.1792406738,
0.214335978,
0.0131492028,
0.2696102858,
-0.2690548897,
-0.752425313,
0.2291725278,
0.3469597995,
-0.5580120683,
-0.4378884435,
-0.536691308,
0.2890720963,
-0.4321863949,
0.8099197149,
-0.0433212258,
0.2548104525,
-0.246389091,
-0.0861454457,
-0.5844271779,
-0.3350681663,
-0.6902530193,
-0.3731969297,
0.1040866747,
0.2160868794,
0.6160908937,
0.6159502268,
0.0085872551,
0.2559364736,
-0.1700123399,
0.0521579795,
-0.250919193,
-0.0096919304,
-0.1342796534,
-0.1478501409,
-0.278365016,
0.3832870126,
0.6010251641,
1.0685172081,
0.0605514497,
0.4264888763,
0.2245858759,
0.7988846302,
-0.8341183066,
-0.1389900595,
-0.7513307929,
0.06327378,
-0.2069336772,
0.157471478,
-0.302192241,
-0.5268048644,
0.0781548768,
-0.2399175763,
0.4149634242,
0.1375672966,
0.7564806342,
0.1380873471,
-0.8641159534,
-0.5356994867,
-0.5928778052,
0.6581465602,
-0.7477110624,
0.4285843074,
0.5811128616,
0.2678389251,
-0.0990114734,
-0.4980427027,
-0.6385682821,
-0.4592342973,
0.1335758418,
0.1586188972,
-0.1806180626,
0.0504033789,
0.2135062367,
0.4681390226,
-0.5938122272,
0.254018575,
-0.5166460276,
-0.4197635651,
1.054148674,
0.0643439814,
0.2966754138,
-0.1498968005,
-0.292824775,
0.1483753622,
-0.6286376119,
-0.0424339436,
0.7263841033,
0.277507633,
-0.0795140341,
0.4302033782,
-0.1098779514,
0.6333971024,
-0.225947246,
0.0907024071,
0.2410957962,
-0.4037133455,
-0.0783874914,
-0.0007318736,
0.7713692784,
0.5353533626,
0.5461392999,
-0.1904987991,
-0.3319838345,
0.5403721929,
0.2404641956,
-0.5411160588,
0.2691757679,
-0.2447206676,
-0.4448987544,
-0.0492807589,
-0.0694892928,
-0.7639806271,
-0.3250654638,
-0.3311457634,
0.4466066062,
-0.1755576134,
0.1172977015,
-0.2050633729,
-0.116832599,
0.0596396774,
0.0217124783,
-0.8064036965,
0.4874978662,
0.3519600332,
0.6657943726,
-0.4090997875,
-0.2617086172,
-0.1388856769,
-0.2015449405,
-0.2975228131,
0.3802740276,
-0.3444325328,
-0.5112118125,
0.4402483106,
-0.27995947,
-0.0799647644,
-0.6534086466,
0.7147541046,
-0.3912775218,
0.1197148561,
-0.2289019525,
-0.5872440338,
-0.1780986488,
0.0397539325,
-0.5942816138,
0.9319768548,
0.0671725348,
-0.5583280325,
0.5967649221,
-0.5311396718,
-0.6571270823,
-0.0373503789,
-0.0960262716,
-0.1428223699,
0.1728317589,
0.2818005383,
0.1157737523,
-0.0869791359,
0.0440848917,
-0.1187638789,
-0.4489825964,
0.0660305694,
-0.6284570098,
0.8779839873,
0.3051303029,
-0.6086766124,
-0.2151031792,
-0.9591954947,
-0.1585461199,
0.2573270798,
-0.325604409,
-0.3889480829,
0.0210946891,
0.1495339125,
0.3042797148,
0.2133174241,
-0.7299906611,
-0.0899883583,
-0.3205275834,
0.0725797489,
0.6997778416,
0.1075026691,
0.319663018,
-0.1030691043,
0.6947661042,
-0.3295833766,
-0.0896314234,
0.0267228298,
-0.3522525132,
-0.9819946289,
0.2113114446,
0.2340258509,
0.3536772728,
-0.3339507878,
0.5954737067,
0.2667255402,
-0.1524026692,
-0.8098646402,
0.3635999858,
0.2418168187,
0.6151165962,
0.4968137443,
-0.653978467,
-0.6945705414,
-1.239330411,
-0.2782296836,
0.011959359,
-0.0791504011,
0.3353171647,
0.4580513835,
-0.4762324989,
0.7795025706,
-0.2796010673,
-0.1535567343,
-0.3564531505,
0.3966574967,
-0.1237859726,
0.2428728938,
0.5307625532,
-0.0624302365,
-0.6108267903,
-0.3187152445,
-0.4970884919,
-0.5794223547,
0.1823745668,
-0.2450191975,
0.3450123668,
0.5023155212,
-0.3222001195,
0.697005868,
0.7524660826,
-0.7767083645,
0.6322131753,
0.166669935,
0.1497796923,
-0.7645574808,
-0.1570804864,
0.1883870512,
-0.0705066472,
-0.6479712129,
-0.2458141446,
-0.0453210808,
0.0013564212,
-0.1413680911,
0.6680513024,
-0.6849818826,
-0.3262137175,
-0.6488259435,
0.2889985442,
0.1691305041,
0.1278411299,
0.0292011239,
0.9079215527,
0.3048943281,
-0.6395815611,
-0.1000058278,
0.1962039322,
-0.4183267355,
0.2407300323,
-0.468539685,
0.3580306768,
-0.2082442939,
0.1126852557,
-0.8017243147,
0.2569141686,
-0.1919353157,
-0.4215940833,
0.4289954305,
0.1697467119,
-0.0796390474,
-0.5350657701,
-0.1349965632,
0.1726746559,
0.4544060826,
-0.2837091386,
0.0426685251,
0.3838936388,
-0.2704861462,
-0.6943745017,
-0.6261065602,
0.264026463,
0.1321252882,
-0.4993466139,
0.0556620881,
-0.0735163093,
-0.6236061454,
-0.1486220062,
-0.115446955,
-0.0175259076,
0.3156474233,
0.0745823309,
0.311290592,
-0.256565541,
0.0113049801,
0.0535573699,
0.3122970164,
0.3261268437,
0.0386688747,
0.6222702265,
0.0246390812,
-0.2377608418,
0.0028664218,
0.4517726898,
0.1015630513,
-0.2319978178,
0.7639921904,
0.5637293458,
-0.3784758449,
-0.2986811996,
-0.5914298296,
-0.1701869369,
-0.3695357144,
0.4848172069,
0.124918066,
-0.8510281444,
0.3450924456,
0.6141681075,
0.2922200859,
0.4282437861,
0.6263138652,
0.0098857051,
1.2294107676,
0.5745910406,
-0.144254595,
0.4257500768,
-0.2534234822,
0.0305762067,
-0.745031476,
0.0277629271,
-0.4749917388,
-0.5127478838,
-0.4179799259,
-0.2717137337,
-0.011690516,
0.1111639589,
-0.1694289297,
0.0038132651,
-0.1040357053,
0.3005636632,
0.5295110345,
-0.2850778699,
0.240825668,
-0.0837787017,
-0.2818913758,
-0.1114046052,
-0.2326824516,
-0.9733906984,
1.3705986738,
0.5056462884,
0.3315664828,
0.0347279571,
0.7246569991,
0.5311461091,
0.5136432052,
-0.6125222445,
0.4478839636,
0.0357172452,
-0.7860307693,
-0.1695875078,
-0.3646674752,
-1.005006671,
0.2927016914,
-0.4146701992,
-0.6653755903,
-0.1946358979,
0.2872838378,
0.0294419546,
-0.0228342805,
-0.7481892705,
0.7069044709,
-0.2367158085,
-0.4168986678,
-0.2046296746,
-0.4177056849,
0.6069174409,
0.0093804831,
0.4351764917,
-0.2567652166,
-0.0910838321,
0.8979231715,
-0.3389544785,
0.5401904583,
-0.2894953787,
0.0466413274,
0.4156348407,
0.0347495712,
0.2439480573,
-0.0677831247,
-0.1831319183,
0.2599799037,
-0.5819087625,
-0.3927564025,
-0.3325740993,
0.4979629815,
-0.6946524382,
-0.5564908385,
-0.3356482685,
-0.7030512094,
-0.5692229867,
0.0102427211,
0.4005888402,
0.1626107395,
-0.5101410151,
-0.1167379543,
0.0507464372,
-0.1084239781,
0.6306508183,
0.4747353196,
-0.0805607364,
-0.1492032707,
0.5748288631,
0.2267752737,
0.3629553616,
-0.1325461864,
0.2980477214,
-0.4552758932,
-0.938626349,
-0.3877931833,
0.1782609373,
-0.5691639781,
0.027323477,
-0.4923537374,
-0.3540098071,
-0.5931840539,
-0.2477440983,
-0.1926471144,
-0.4630179405,
-0.1263104528,
-0.4051254392,
-0.146628648,
1.0348823071,
0.0391602442,
0.3377400041,
-0.5615008473,
0.1095710546,
0.3796736598,
0.1090643406,
0.1009501144,
-0.7832391262,
-0.385635078,
0.1303856969,
-0.6249507666,
-1.0211498737,
0.3866572678,
0.3009170592,
0.7488650084,
0.3570472002,
-0.1073783338,
0.3271690607,
-0.6426691413,
0.969994247,
0.0626125559,
-0.9908459783,
0.5722463727,
-0.0119528556,
0.3148093522,
0.671475172,
0.3311705589,
-0.4568950832,
-0.8479457498,
-0.5957568884,
-0.9682751894,
0.3926576376,
0.1925377697,
0.266653657,
-0.364700526,
0.0482950583,
0.1592468917,
0.4572928846,
-0.9961583614,
-0.7839176655,
-0.2294572294,
-0.2307458222,
-0.3484272659,
-0.3993335366,
0.137136966,
-0.0713945925,
0.6573473215,
-0.0588023737,
-0.018642107,
0.0384979062,
-0.417145133,
-0.3096455336,
0.5146149397,
0.7256920934,
1.0212043524,
-0.2037544996,
0.113034144,
0.2440053076,
-0.7884337902,
0.0869607776,
0.2049094588,
-0.5644842386,
0.208095178,
0.6062294245,
0.9407333136,
-0.2547389269,
-0.5837800503,
0.3550046682,
0.0009604979,
-0.3491033316,
-0.2084977031,
-0.0555403493,
-0.083574608,
-0.1170399934,
0.5724950433,
-0.0651368797,
0.4205464721,
-0.7045755982,
0.3674750328,
0.7278836966,
-0.5124834776,
-0.4003261924,
0.7641657591,
0.4393354952,
-0.230704084,
0.2777151167,
-0.2731686532,
-0.5689175129,
0.6129888296,
0.8650384545,
0.9772844911,
-0.2829028666,
0.0359166339,
0.4539847076,
0.6867583394,
0.5272746682,
0.0985036641,
0.0856306925,
-0.9726961851,
-0.3383938074,
-0.8811240792,
0.0141910911,
0.4395869374,
-0.6813605428,
0.0470557883,
-0.539511621,
-0.1692201197,
-0.0943894461,
0.2539494336,
-0.8104506135,
0.3437747955,
0.5667423606,
1.1201332808,
-1.3266997337,
0.4339632392,
0.8693020344,
-0.3630218804,
-0.7331394553,
0.3175728619,
0.2573274672,
-0.7520922422,
0.6068378687,
0.2486774027,
0.0941888392,
-0.1499817073,
-0.0839193165,
-0.6304344535,
0.8020417094,
0.1771937907,
-0.4503264725,
0.239138931,
-0.0177159496,
0.5429545641,
-0.5769377351,
0.36982584,
0.8644228578,
0.3120511472,
-0.1454201788,
-0.9075503945,
-0.264256984,
-0.086183995,
0.095781453,
0.2344843,
-0.4172424078,
0.6417264342,
-0.1653770655,
-0.2692282796,
-0.3289810419,
0.8959550858,
0.2289050221,
0.5459843874,
0.6481448412,
0.4668049514,
0.7665808201,
0.0994034186,
0.8701996207,
-0.1560629457,
0.0289644636,
0.8447705507,
-0.3953389525,
0.7529501319,
0.5213842988,
-0.3949724436,
0.4453193843,
0.4927605093,
0.321562916,
0.2331981361,
0.4061330259,
-0.3416664004,
0.1269772202,
-0.2946127653,
-0.3256336451,
0.5995762944,
0.1989075989,
-0.4723757207,
-0.0950703993,
-0.1536454856,
-0.0476307012,
0.6172770858,
-0.636374712,
0.6517534852,
0.0747653991,
-0.7433405519,
0.5270138979,
-0.0412915088,
0.7694666386,
-0.4161739647,
0.0156663321,
-0.4515711963,
-0.214035362,
-0.120905444,
-0.537561357,
0.4030192196,
0.1786161959,
-0.2403223664,
0.0783369467,
0.5902058482,
-0.6569840312,
-0.5367668271,
0.3387637436,
0.4496492147,
-0.0294797011,
0.4434119761,
-0.6238362193,
0.0852676705,
0.2397812307,
-0.2905395925,
0.2794053853,
-0.1051813439,
-0.1222987846,
0.590898931,
0.4956496954,
0.5710887909,
0.4974636734,
0.4416616261,
0.3549362719,
-0.6446018815,
-0.4195308685,
-0.6578735709,
0.3625994325,
-0.2228225917,
-0.3187729716,
0.9521302581,
0.6653604507,
0.8155328035,
0.0804023221,
1.0461933613,
-0.0167250726,
0.747094512,
-0.6115952134,
0.6123944521,
-0.4314346015,
0.2389651388,
-0.2833433747,
-1.1879054308,
0.1983402371,
0.6949796081,
-0.1222978383,
0.2679117322,
0.7214679122,
0.513538599,
0.1138625145,
0.0331567898,
0.3270172477,
0.1002188623,
0.0125664165,
0.3679728508,
0.8677325845,
-0.3961960971,
0.3170409203,
-0.3537226319,
-0.2886902392,
0.003136527,
-0.8398568034,
-0.8767217398,
-0.1661967486,
-0.349794805,
-0.270933181,
-0.1279246211,
1.05245924,
0.3872725368,
-0.8673767447,
-0.4661741257,
0.0115188677,
0.1117791384,
-0.0595843568,
-0.2566537857,
0.1938953698,
-0.4362348318,
-0.9252691269,
0.5373270512,
0.0574430041,
0.0737241656,
-0.43889153,
-0.2822587788,
-0.3413336873,
0.2192699015,
0.6141306162,
0.2047247738,
-0.7125516534,
-0.4073930085,
-0.1904594153,
-0.2792862654,
-0.2876247764,
0.6688184738,
-0.4473044276,
0.5185969472,
0.28300789,
0.5081506371,
0.3250171244,
0.1684860587,
0.9169647694,
-1.0730115175,
0.2960742712,
0.3396500051,
0.5471785069,
0.3859332204,
-0.0517266467,
0.4273197949,
0.2688699961,
-0.5745238066,
-0.7956727743,
0.2816757858,
-0.5140502453,
-0.0882629827,
1.129099369,
0.109000966,
0.0341228992,
-0.3522959352,
-0.0648244098,
0.239281401,
-0.2887816727,
0.5816832185,
0.7491309643,
-0.0396300182,
-0.1638536751,
-0.9406961799,
0.5556510091,
0.3007111847,
-0.5975504518,
-0.065024212,
0.8127495646,
0.0477428362,
0.077723667,
0.5376490355,
0.1216742843,
0.3454280198,
-0.0780263692,
0.5241431594,
-0.0998726785,
-0.0180574302,
-0.3430885077,
-0.218015641,
0.4460296333,
-0.330031693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14288v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14288v2 | LLM-powered Data Augmentation for Enhanced Cross-lingual Performance | 2023-05-23T17:33:27 | 2023-10-22T22:57:00 | Chenxi Whitehouse, Monojit Choudhury, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper explores the potential of leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs)
for data augmentation in multilingual commonsense reasoning datasets where the
available training data is extremely limited. To achieve this, we utilise
several LLMs, namely Dolly-v2, StableVicuna, ChatGPT, and GPT-4, to augment
three datasets: XCOPA, XWinograd, and XStoryCloze. Subsequently, we evaluate
the effectiveness of fine-tuning smaller multilingual models, mBERT and XLMR,
using the synthesised data. We compare the performance of training with data
generated in English and target languages, as well as translated
English-generated data, revealing the overall advantages of incorporating data
generated by LLMs, e.g. a notable 13.4 accuracy score improvement for the best
case. Furthermore, we conduct a human evaluation by asking native speakers to
assess the naturalness and logical coherence of the generated examples across
different languages. The results of the evaluation indicate that LLMs such as
ChatGPT and GPT-4 excel at producing natural and coherent text in most
languages, however, they struggle to generate meaningful text in certain
languages like Tamil. We also observe that ChatGPT falls short in generating
plausible alternatives compared to the original dataset, whereas examples from
GPT-4 exhibit competitive logical consistency. | [
-0.310977906,
-0.6096233726,
0.4692168832,
0.0107664587,
-0.2090892196,
0.1705523729,
-0.5112617016,
-0.5440291762,
0.0341331176,
0.5020831823,
-0.4192669094,
-0.5008645058,
-0.2815663815,
0.4319562316,
-0.1369761527,
0.8582825661,
-0.0062183239,
0.2628940344,
-0.2504639924,
-0.1962627172,
-0.6087847352,
-0.6097593307,
-0.3919549584,
-0.4331176281,
0.4448237121,
0.5109151006,
0.8803429008,
0.476075381,
0.201739803,
0.2885734141,
0.0981323794,
0.680395484,
-0.6732209921,
0.0248510204,
-0.4591424763,
-0.5523839593,
-0.4830709696,
-0.1023777649,
0.6805204749,
0.72586447,
0.1269968301,
-0.1183152273,
0.0422114693,
0.4832574725,
-0.2996026278,
0.3521784544,
-0.9002257586,
0.0009877658,
-0.1974989474,
-0.1072866246,
-0.2501711547,
-0.2256478816,
-0.0806549191,
-0.8470942378,
0.0531638712,
0.2650040388,
0.8054583073,
0.202369988,
-0.5079135895,
-0.3033863306,
-0.5675917864,
1.0039806366,
-0.7975841761,
0.7669161558,
0.2266078144,
0.1984201223,
0.008583785,
-0.5259292126,
-0.7225022316,
-0.2782891989,
-0.2494248301,
0.22635445,
-0.0983468592,
-0.092257835,
0.3441887498,
0.3809672892,
-0.6913297772,
0.327608645,
-0.3513052762,
-0.1354245096,
0.7819532156,
0.2799359858,
0.1734533757,
-0.3124965131,
-0.2748326063,
-0.0315124355,
-0.9485741258,
-0.3653060198,
0.6150400639,
0.5696954727,
-0.0069515524,
0.8285114765,
-0.2650259435,
0.853130877,
-0.1461029649,
-0.33362481,
0.354696095,
-0.6031900048,
-0.1015339494,
-0.0131419608,
0.7219846845,
0.2523273528,
0.3974980414,
-0.1998665333,
-0.3367398679,
0.050428573,
-0.2992705703,
-0.5190713406,
-0.1493120342,
0.0944587737,
0.0044306819,
-0.0971810967,
-0.1795849651,
-0.5586773157,
-0.3299366832,
-0.7682405114,
0.3041525185,
-0.4959467351,
-0.4092987776,
0.2797857225,
0.1472663432,
0.195184499,
0.3152270615,
-0.9334070086,
0.2193193436,
0.7380483747,
0.5678129196,
-0.3012553751,
-0.3209989965,
-0.5069941282,
0.2646822631,
-0.4830404818,
0.6967702508,
-0.6335225105,
-0.2496224344,
-0.1054022014,
-0.0681809559,
-0.140872106,
-0.6640161872,
0.6964446306,
-0.404314667,
0.3477330804,
-0.3257877827,
-0.7123298049,
-0.0634367391,
0.4427575469,
-0.789832592,
1.1548594236,
0.0675475821,
-0.6878228784,
0.4391822219,
-0.4759049118,
-0.5482311845,
0.0528772287,
-0.2789690793,
-0.112480998,
-0.158268705,
0.637049675,
0.6402755976,
-0.3091412783,
0.3195976615,
-0.2539936006,
-0.1897613108,
0.2565521002,
-0.6742069125,
0.5625337362,
0.1916763335,
-0.0763756633,
-0.0914128944,
-0.8714762926,
0.0309512094,
-0.0126535958,
-0.4076837897,
-0.2749530375,
-0.3437756598,
0.1625571251,
0.3540376127,
0.2052583396,
-0.4808315039,
0.1284962445,
-0.443375051,
0.2285392731,
0.5869471431,
-0.3077099025,
0.2703178525,
-0.3431644738,
0.4555606246,
-0.0414295718,
-0.1325018555,
-0.1615303755,
-0.5609940886,
-0.6519269943,
-0.3008190691,
0.4686018229,
0.7473044991,
-1.1249203682,
0.1633449495,
-0.7554644346,
-0.3294347227,
-0.5501118898,
0.6315182447,
0.2661236525,
0.5864326358,
0.3753544688,
0.1101929322,
-0.6019082069,
-0.8676584363,
-0.2442790717,
-0.0915353075,
-0.0788014978,
0.3203759491,
0.3307138681,
-0.1315345317,
0.8050899506,
-0.2348456681,
-0.1367503256,
-0.5623501539,
-0.1876453459,
0.3452115953,
0.2698701322,
0.2356048226,
-0.8282455802,
-0.5190940499,
0.4243758619,
-0.8016812801,
-0.2007705569,
-0.217717424,
0.105463177,
0.447948277,
0.3550873697,
-0.6369959116,
0.0467113964,
0.6697291136,
0.0398081839,
0.7175220251,
-0.2358001471,
0.324790746,
-1.0961934328,
-0.1572306007,
-0.0064848494,
-0.3434761465,
-0.6581588984,
-0.0015284769,
0.1360749006,
-0.1285302341,
-0.5594885945,
0.7618134618,
-0.6119408011,
-0.090340443,
-0.06141923,
0.5602039695,
0.1943631917,
0.3644350767,
0.2625192702,
0.8022349477,
0.4388230145,
-0.3551926911,
0.5404053926,
0.2519518137,
-0.4863437414,
0.5558034778,
-0.5976204872,
-0.035413865,
0.0736130029,
0.050245408,
-0.835921824,
-0.4069648385,
-0.0422048867,
-0.3452939987,
0.3382543623,
-0.2303634882,
-0.7617504597,
-0.1651873887,
-0.0943670869,
0.3038463891,
0.3924596906,
-0.8673805594,
0.4830116332,
0.2490862906,
-0.3214454055,
-0.5068211555,
-0.9334096313,
0.3442536891,
-0.2967391908,
-0.9757295847,
0.2489619702,
0.1009005904,
-0.4162519574,
-0.0742535368,
0.2403212339,
0.2218220532,
-0.3384506702,
-0.1661562175,
0.3143498003,
-0.1804143786,
0.3936410248,
0.1343018413,
-0.0916434377,
-0.2414775342,
-0.2145092189,
0.3298651278,
-0.2585932314,
-0.5271576643,
-0.0828871727,
0.2952121198,
0.308586657,
-0.0305426866,
0.5376948714,
0.6732593179,
-0.2375441641,
-0.1338417828,
-0.5342171192,
-0.1119876727,
-0.4424958527,
0.2892653644,
-0.5364511609,
-0.9423506856,
0.4617702067,
0.0418710746,
0.0421092585,
0.2367000133,
0.653386116,
0.248480022,
1.0228875875,
0.1385549456,
0.0075404835,
0.161661014,
-0.11771442,
0.2414946705,
-0.7516419888,
-0.0542131476,
-0.1480503827,
0.0521466322,
-0.9406105876,
-0.7397387028,
0.4241057634,
-0.1454440206,
0.1286383271,
0.1594710052,
-0.0956354365,
0.5205379128,
0.3748418093,
0.0431333631,
0.5251775384,
0.0859895423,
-0.2141448855,
-0.1711070091,
-1.1059750319,
-0.5365346074,
1.1712812185,
0.1552497447,
0.938475728,
0.1819549054,
0.4916338325,
-0.0652641281,
0.2197685689,
-0.6561890244,
0.4817708731,
-0.1940267682,
-0.6067286134,
-0.2823067009,
-0.5564819574,
-1.0412400961,
0.4071610272,
-0.3771981597,
-0.4646406174,
-0.0847402513,
0.1124411896,
-0.0558023788,
0.3094855249,
-0.8903177977,
0.5897017121,
-0.5111533403,
-0.8995668292,
-0.106877327,
-0.4815449715,
0.6086949706,
-0.1993563026,
0.3454291821,
0.0248399563,
-0.0619223826,
0.4709646404,
-0.3709585667,
0.818796277,
0.0870037377,
-0.4340770543,
0.2170164287,
-0.2775071263,
0.6555129886,
0.2491601557,
-0.258228451,
0.2857282758,
-0.1466120929,
-0.4997368455,
-0.7628828883,
0.8679075241,
-0.6270201206,
-0.7508524656,
-0.172419548,
-0.8646352887,
-0.5607456565,
0.0786554441,
-0.0612741634,
0.5737601519,
0.0261135884,
0.1993314922,
0.5658636689,
-0.2882715166,
0.0873909891,
0.4146696925,
-0.3099382222,
-0.6146733165,
0.9472964406,
0.2881899476,
0.5263601542,
0.5564238429,
0.1795984209,
-0.7240314484,
-0.5245950222,
-0.7178010345,
0.3206553757,
-0.8968228102,
-0.1220103055,
-0.4948159754,
0.0493387282,
-0.5606580377,
0.0251932107,
-0.2237952054,
-0.7561884522,
-0.1186327264,
-0.2780340016,
0.5423022509,
0.5787082911,
-0.3393613398,
0.1521993279,
-0.7829170227,
0.2754826546,
0.2874565125,
0.1850674748,
-0.3248849213,
-0.4791173041,
-0.3140491545,
0.2395916879,
0.0025378319,
-0.6456284523,
0.5612804294,
0.1174961999,
0.7338119745,
0.1004610658,
-0.1741996408,
0.7829903364,
-0.3574248552,
0.7355466485,
0.0947815478,
-0.7654234171,
0.377301544,
-0.5908367634,
0.352324307,
0.3521808088,
0.3328342736,
-0.4240847826,
-0.3040976226,
-0.4747811854,
-0.7758146524,
0.4599171877,
0.3294519186,
0.1285560131,
0.1562230587,
0.1609122604,
0.4071625173,
0.0823935494,
-0.6955865026,
-0.0712230578,
-0.1485887766,
-0.2841313481,
-0.1917400211,
0.0454173647,
-0.0078223543,
-0.351154387,
0.854415834,
-0.4013368189,
-0.1895744056,
0.0424728468,
-0.1909046769,
0.2628067136,
0.3927145004,
0.4522116482,
0.7322909832,
0.1081996411,
0.0617148057,
0.4463673234,
-0.2467524409,
0.0247175395,
0.2772607505,
-0.0690140799,
0.0398738347,
0.4801883996,
1.0172011852,
0.2245052308,
-0.7897694707,
0.1339306682,
-0.050571233,
-0.13611871,
-0.0795669332,
0.078433007,
0.1380606294,
0.261967361,
0.1618340462,
-0.1861719936,
-0.0073164334,
-0.4957805574,
0.0775081441,
0.4850111008,
-0.0423845425,
-0.210710302,
0.4897894859,
0.1136267781,
0.0425315164,
0.4454034865,
-0.1619424522,
-0.4072561562,
0.2337860912,
0.5915984511,
0.4205243587,
-0.077307649,
0.0353994444,
0.3576719463,
0.5060598254,
0.0489397384,
0.2705316842,
0.0005197208,
-0.9857245684,
-0.7775699496,
-0.4549227953,
-0.6102651954,
0.215883702,
-0.4126424789,
0.5465922356,
0.045157548,
0.1088808998,
-0.200805679,
0.192454204,
-0.7276359797,
0.2881150544,
0.1372208893,
0.8997594714,
-0.9168232679,
0.9091957808,
0.6300264001,
-0.200492695,
-0.9532862306,
-0.2530092895,
-0.138539359,
-0.8175032735,
0.4076112509,
-0.0153856501,
0.0183928758,
-0.1099074706,
-0.2232177258,
-0.7806047797,
1.0333868265,
0.5784737468,
-0.708771944,
0.3164327741,
0.685423255,
0.6159020662,
-0.2984285653,
0.2860835493,
0.7356525064,
0.676667273,
0.2128175795,
-0.9901129007,
-0.0843557417,
-0.2300899178,
-0.1058328152,
-0.006332662,
-0.5123348832,
0.6493192911,
-0.2485983968,
-0.0392862074,
-0.0649585798,
0.610693872,
0.667581439,
0.21242401,
0.3577669859,
0.6392263174,
1.0526198149,
-0.1274183393,
1.1231272221,
-0.1767859459,
0.1155210733,
1.1854667664,
-0.5479697585,
0.7114801407,
0.5935557485,
-0.1092112884,
0.2809693217,
0.5725672245,
0.1603429317,
0.2423338592,
-0.038277965,
-0.3019907176,
-0.3939998746,
-0.1041002274,
-0.2686375678,
0.5044298172,
0.5692694783,
-0.1085854247,
-0.2354038805,
0.1518973112,
0.1743323505,
0.1353253722,
-0.3545027971,
0.5495628715,
0.001594694,
-0.6906228662,
0.8620936275,
-0.0875776038,
0.6273409128,
-0.5063476562,
0.011836621,
-0.3526207209,
0.1670399904,
-0.3107640147,
-0.9789996743,
0.246539101,
0.104628861,
0.0246961974,
-0.1987693012,
0.8396314979,
-0.7136394978,
-0.7784171104,
0.2246819884,
0.7443886399,
0.2729812264,
0.1737824827,
-0.7114427686,
0.0937029719,
-0.002105434,
-0.2058868706,
0.313757807,
0.6714478135,
-0.2632211447,
0.7364600301,
0.8589714766,
0.2427457869,
0.1490235925,
0.3065112233,
0.9187113047,
-0.3644688129,
-0.2830756903,
-0.7701353431,
0.3955430984,
-0.2125015706,
-0.1561927646,
1.0349546671,
0.7028539777,
1.0592623949,
-0.0312742144,
1.048058629,
0.1519789398,
0.5382615328,
-0.9332201481,
0.3761866987,
-0.5049090981,
0.5149145126,
-0.2116100341,
-0.7724347711,
-0.3528158367,
0.3256874681,
-0.5648699403,
0.1546447277,
0.4749197364,
1.2143232822,
-0.2950996757,
0.0595669784,
0.7731804252,
0.1286865622,
0.3014973998,
0.6465935707,
0.9141128063,
-0.431648016,
0.6043228507,
-0.1146200076,
-0.0868227035,
0.0964765549,
-0.8982422352,
-0.942376852,
-0.4032390118,
-0.1798826903,
-0.1399627179,
0.0530687757,
0.8146346807,
0.7066252232,
-0.7385566235,
-0.1962015331,
-0.0196798109,
0.2682343125,
0.0163493324,
-0.2626154125,
0.2300211042,
-0.3692819476,
-0.9675142765,
0.6567679644,
0.1824326068,
-0.0606458113,
-0.4092920721,
-0.3687414229,
-0.2288098037,
0.1458909512,
0.8116961122,
0.0267309621,
-0.6368917823,
-0.1544665694,
0.1082027256,
0.1096538901,
0.0833124444,
0.5483525395,
-0.9144716263,
0.4520297647,
0.5387271643,
0.6107938886,
0.4414036572,
-0.0574353747,
0.631988883,
-0.8127046824,
0.1267722249,
0.1351673901,
0.5791205168,
0.9034785032,
-0.2562009692,
0.6620329022,
0.2532302141,
-0.442024976,
-0.7867561579,
0.1906303763,
-0.8259499669,
-0.1091658399,
1.5677062273,
-0.0712287351,
-0.2381032109,
-0.2531744242,
-0.3290650249,
0.0621916316,
-0.2357110083,
0.4625460207,
0.6607076526,
-0.2930651307,
-0.3221755028,
-0.6298748255,
0.2756236196,
0.3633254468,
-1.0500167608,
0.2184951603,
0.6201078296,
0.2408427447,
0.0952881053,
0.3051080108,
-0.2171550691,
0.16102162,
0.0560791939,
-0.2514864504,
-0.1608769,
-0.0922312811,
-0.2733840346,
-0.0013905807,
-0.0911107361,
0.2471261472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14283v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14283v3 | Query Rewriting for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:27:50 | 2023-10-23T02:34:49 | Xinbei Ma, Yeyun Gong, Pengcheng He, Hai Zhao, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) play powerful, black-box readers in the
retrieve-then-read pipeline, making remarkable progress in knowledge-intensive
tasks. This work introduces a new framework, Rewrite-Retrieve-Read instead of
the previous retrieve-then-read for the retrieval-augmented LLMs from the
perspective of the query rewriting. Unlike prior studies focusing on adapting
either the retriever or the reader, our approach pays attention to the
adaptation of the search query itself, for there is inevitably a gap between
the input text and the needed knowledge in retrieval. We first prompt an LLM to
generate the query, then use a web search engine to retrieve contexts.
Furthermore, to better align the query to the frozen modules, we propose a
trainable scheme for our pipeline. A small language model is adopted as a
trainable rewriter to cater to the black-box LLM reader. The rewriter is
trained using the feedback of the LLM reader by reinforcement learning.
Evaluation is conducted on downstream tasks, open-domain QA and multiple-choice
QA. Experiments results show consistent performance improvement, indicating
that our framework is proven effective and scalable, and brings a new framework
for retrieval-augmented LLM. | [
-0.0349453092,
-0.7896800041,
0.6289087534,
-0.2109813094,
-0.3332336545,
0.1532989293,
-0.1273431927,
-0.2680686712,
0.4532189369,
0.9661377668,
-0.8026320934,
-0.3872311413,
-0.2596533298,
0.0909021124,
-0.338322401,
0.7039275169,
-0.0967054591,
-0.3194205463,
-0.1893724352,
0.0475736782,
-0.3250121474,
-0.4525015056,
-0.8254990578,
-0.2837938964,
0.8536465168,
0.2241719663,
0.5224339962,
0.5357707143,
0.0982780606,
0.242282182,
-0.157939896,
0.2822673321,
-0.7958101034,
0.5265811086,
-0.4711489677,
-0.8862428069,
-0.2578746676,
-0.3598859012,
0.8335773945,
0.5264762044,
-0.4510896206,
-0.0007341534,
-0.1342948526,
0.5748057961,
-0.7946015,
-0.0518242978,
-1.2035694122,
-0.0728617311,
0.1188937053,
-0.5099006295,
-0.7161823511,
-0.1923202574,
0.0756438747,
-0.73245579,
0.3568554521,
0.499265343,
0.4482399225,
0.3069102168,
-0.6690794826,
-0.3073037565,
-0.4194802642,
0.7238733172,
-0.589830637,
0.5687992573,
0.2847547829,
0.5236336589,
-0.4174387455,
-0.8646627069,
-0.6383152604,
-0.2907999158,
0.0913455784,
0.0083891861,
0.0721657202,
-0.2008274794,
0.0064194128,
0.3605917692,
-0.3713617027,
0.0851531327,
-0.2713622451,
-0.2027801424,
0.7113720775,
0.234656617,
0.0297105759,
-0.0733815655,
-0.2913398445,
0.1189524084,
-1.0076117516,
-0.3667267263,
0.0836849436,
0.2637499869,
0.3799140453,
0.6222080588,
-0.344127208,
0.6879219413,
0.0683967248,
-0.0653132871,
0.0800907612,
-0.2214144915,
-0.3518981338,
-0.0979332849,
0.3389735818,
0.1850768775,
0.1281277984,
-0.3075249195,
-0.3552194536,
-0.5821191669,
0.5557868481,
-0.8727144599,
-0.0484809354,
0.051739376,
-0.2430694699,
-0.0884164274,
-0.4666489065,
-0.4898098707,
-0.3576357365,
-0.2436950356,
0.52526474,
-0.3791517317,
-0.3036156595,
0.2513831556,
0.0702806413,
0.5114178061,
0.5113949776,
-0.9084378481,
0.2545585632,
0.8334882855,
0.6346387267,
-0.107896477,
-0.3902973831,
-0.7995398641,
0.378257215,
-0.2626226246,
0.749022603,
-0.6021193862,
-0.2324841321,
0.3037394583,
0.2868479192,
-0.1311454922,
-0.5055348873,
0.3151749372,
-1.3672463894,
0.0076680044,
0.0082905088,
-0.6311897039,
-0.0787968114,
0.5283085704,
-0.6318355203,
0.7986432314,
0.0635147393,
-0.4403640628,
0.2929040492,
-0.1761267632,
-0.384264797,
-0.1178382635,
0.1276501864,
-0.3746241927,
0.2872699797,
0.2134137899,
0.1529179513,
-0.29230389,
0.093651928,
-0.2537382543,
-0.5058759451,
0.2165147364,
-0.4015448689,
0.4678113163,
0.102350831,
0.0699959248,
0.1050302908,
-0.5867726803,
0.2208930403,
0.0760486275,
-0.6886764765,
-0.1072356924,
0.2363472134,
-0.0752233043,
0.0078194952,
0.1358495653,
-0.5854927897,
0.5699652433,
-0.551187396,
0.5201339126,
0.6380062699,
0.0650075823,
0.492526412,
-0.1457607597,
0.7123736143,
-0.3087410331,
-0.1208809391,
-0.1599965543,
0.0433313139,
-0.7227774858,
-0.1443265378,
0.2746787965,
0.4171885848,
-1.1386839151,
-0.143256411,
-0.2257939577,
-0.4303726256,
-0.8265867233,
0.1493880451,
0.40610376,
0.3676113784,
0.3054925501,
0.0317954496,
-0.3370803297,
-0.676928103,
-0.53270787,
-0.1892160773,
0.0384619087,
0.4742944837,
0.5261728764,
-0.2912457883,
0.4491393268,
-0.8846100569,
-0.2063214183,
-0.3274195492,
-0.2680187225,
0.2021567971,
0.3374534845,
0.03071611,
-0.7151657343,
-0.3296255469,
-0.1367488801,
-0.473154366,
-0.0313652083,
0.1279690862,
-0.5135492682,
0.2585985363,
0.8994106054,
-0.5599822402,
0.1458894312,
0.1458013505,
-0.3023308516,
0.7377251983,
-0.3074474633,
0.063528046,
-1.0787411928,
-0.0227270164,
-0.3416708112,
-0.3142994046,
-0.3017010093,
0.5395030975,
0.1324347705,
-0.1047534123,
-0.5635101199,
0.7343047261,
-0.6142018437,
-0.2141554207,
-0.5339382291,
0.326153636,
0.2141970396,
0.4853509963,
-0.0471531786,
0.7689943314,
0.2235485911,
-0.4983412027,
0.3510655463,
0.3522122204,
-0.3055117726,
0.5130577087,
-0.484685123,
0.3395515382,
-0.2342076898,
0.5543251634,
-0.6393392086,
-0.119882904,
0.068142347,
-0.3416736424,
0.2864111662,
-0.449423641,
-0.6530593038,
-0.052899152,
-0.1639841497,
0.3720277846,
0.3299795091,
-0.6208798885,
0.8098885417,
0.0459281728,
-0.094775185,
-0.7276918888,
-0.5396853685,
0.0684593618,
0.0121911597,
-0.3795071244,
0.4464517832,
-0.0749737918,
0.2205947787,
-0.0626007244,
-0.1398565769,
-0.3017669916,
0.2341901958,
-0.1698847562,
-0.0052048545,
-0.3117476106,
0.1772619933,
0.0656499565,
-0.0021519142,
0.136432454,
-0.5011242628,
0.4595908225,
0.3163377941,
-0.3521334827,
-0.2359531373,
0.4259108901,
0.4699017107,
-0.4934404492,
0.878592968,
0.418382436,
-0.3143384755,
-0.4958470762,
-0.4847500026,
-0.3264216483,
-0.4382627308,
0.5090144873,
-0.6804680228,
-1.3630990982,
0.2705634832,
-0.0092332372,
0.1321786642,
0.209495008,
0.6599706411,
-0.0186023023,
0.8410298228,
0.7854781747,
-0.0076283044,
0.5091717839,
-0.0623059347,
0.1683521569,
-1.071295619,
-0.3299306333,
-0.4249316752,
-0.1562094688,
-0.4124829173,
-0.4177003503,
0.1782237887,
0.3141004741,
-0.2757532299,
-0.007308288,
-0.2092815489,
0.5013202429,
0.4648428559,
0.1351898909,
0.4824854732,
0.0771849081,
-0.1778934449,
0.0587070622,
-0.6386756897,
-0.249135375,
1.2396739721,
-0.0248528644,
0.8190027475,
0.4199187458,
0.6113493443,
0.07988213,
0.4289203882,
-0.8148063421,
0.508590579,
0.1110835746,
-0.8242599964,
-0.3283698857,
-0.3539330363,
-1.1658951044,
0.7760404944,
-0.0653548315,
-0.5693084598,
-0.0117895706,
0.3137203455,
-0.1872039586,
0.375969857,
-0.7775579691,
0.8521520495,
-0.2525166273,
-0.6392162442,
-0.4422287941,
-0.3373464942,
0.3512480259,
-0.1912869811,
-0.0761227682,
0.1164190248,
-0.3242396712,
0.2995892465,
-0.43721053,
0.7188497186,
-0.1359267086,
-0.2359956652,
0.1646793187,
0.3493746519,
0.5975637436,
0.2295686305,
-0.4997710586,
-0.6767118573,
0.2231037915,
-0.5065921545,
-0.8616940975,
0.6247785687,
-0.4324640334,
-0.9968717694,
-0.4560830891,
-0.7048296332,
-0.1739059389,
0.4956860542,
-0.2327263206,
0.3840057552,
-0.1877184212,
0.2653007507,
0.6387264132,
-0.2922793329,
-0.023782244,
1.1164317131,
-0.5076268911,
-0.2223334312,
0.7289792299,
-0.0838777274,
0.4689688981,
0.7828716636,
-0.2548587322,
-0.5819677711,
-0.8474336863,
-0.4548040628,
0.4307959676,
-0.5743376017,
-0.140485689,
-0.5994910598,
-0.0706843585,
-0.4073154032,
-0.1478902102,
-0.1163637936,
0.0079789301,
-0.3077476025,
0.095072329,
0.453528434,
0.3241903186,
0.3340142965,
0.2986640036,
-0.4824794531,
0.3261198401,
0.242963776,
0.6011624932,
0.1457073689,
-0.6851524711,
-0.3310546875,
-0.2525992095,
-0.2126218528,
-0.5967725515,
0.597938478,
0.2556654513,
0.3217561841,
-0.0788950324,
0.2026771754,
0.6315186024,
-0.9215105772,
0.4148379862,
-0.2485960424,
-0.5874758363,
0.4215349555,
-0.178783372,
0.3320016861,
0.6483546495,
0.2112281471,
-0.5179344416,
-0.1355755776,
-0.3643036187,
-0.8205771446,
0.5869077444,
-0.0672789738,
0.123171933,
0.00886478,
0.7730519772,
0.1084212959,
0.4143437743,
-0.4237994254,
0.0036004717,
0.0376456678,
0.0350529999,
-0.2599084079,
-0.6094515324,
0.1261130124,
0.0012074023,
0.6916930676,
-0.3548441231,
0.3154044151,
0.1695829183,
-0.5907244086,
-0.0537197888,
0.5068153739,
0.1672569215,
0.6760199666,
-0.5093155503,
0.0933495313,
0.1140354425,
-0.2271455526,
0.2312461436,
0.0933317468,
-0.2263848782,
-0.2461768538,
0.189532578,
0.6825605035,
0.5104444623,
-0.869895339,
0.2042868286,
-0.0880074799,
-0.2216792554,
-0.4154527187,
0.2308768481,
0.3199079633,
0.5133817792,
0.2801350355,
-0.5114008784,
0.1219060719,
-0.6771716475,
0.3338680863,
0.4512340128,
-0.1997992098,
-0.1477248222,
0.7253711224,
0.0936230198,
-0.4622346163,
0.7685816884,
-0.2119572759,
-0.4388599396,
0.2093829662,
0.8777599931,
0.5826478601,
-0.0342777222,
0.0670928657,
0.1755585223,
0.3825334311,
0.0318127051,
0.4789459705,
-0.011490169,
-0.6430131197,
-0.7624681592,
-0.747854054,
-0.4290072024,
0.0924054608,
-0.7325581908,
0.0453529805,
-0.2383888811,
0.2748226523,
-0.0569328889,
0.2823907435,
-0.4332587123,
0.2685179412,
-0.3719311059,
1.1423960924,
-0.3556595147,
0.8333514333,
0.7205910683,
-0.4664309323,
-0.6302714944,
-0.0383173898,
-0.1664934009,
-0.934286654,
0.3883545697,
-0.1712319553,
-0.1155008748,
0.4414637387,
-0.481831044,
-1.0173733234,
1.2447792292,
0.5472425222,
-0.6024021506,
-0.1676676869,
-0.3028386533,
0.5775258541,
-0.3961978853,
0.2649729252,
0.6348485351,
0.1033900082,
0.1118784994,
-0.7462279201,
0.1108319908,
-0.1467208564,
-0.0222032778,
0.2517769039,
-0.6621488333,
0.5252440572,
-0.16392003,
-0.0443623289,
0.2486021966,
0.7432317138,
0.5051188469,
0.2562840879,
0.3975825012,
0.5109136701,
0.6682331562,
0.1990754753,
1.3087537289,
-0.0214545727,
0.2291371077,
1.215934515,
-0.480979383,
1.3970714808,
0.4917763472,
-0.0416249894,
0.4365946054,
0.4427593648,
0.2730494738,
0.4646151066,
0.5428048372,
-0.3232482672,
-0.3951051831,
-0.105249308,
-0.2042223513,
0.2566902637,
0.2168121338,
-0.3287909031,
-0.1337554753,
-0.1212261841,
0.047674384,
0.1341326833,
-0.5358657837,
0.694419086,
0.275167346,
-0.772973597,
0.906984508,
0.151252389,
0.5603283644,
-0.3757510483,
0.1003591046,
-0.2497482002,
0.3528864086,
-0.0559752919,
-0.6846417189,
0.2439961433,
-0.0252463762,
-0.4356339574,
-0.1628795564,
0.6878499985,
-0.5170965791,
-0.4649785459,
0.2114902437,
0.572579205,
0.2628432214,
-0.3564218581,
-0.7080247998,
0.0504064001,
0.2261087298,
-0.2733418941,
0.5575216413,
0.5808550119,
0.0421141684,
0.9756993055,
0.6573565006,
0.0736358613,
0.1744597256,
0.2156527787,
0.9102458954,
-0.90003407,
-0.4251514673,
-0.4514511824,
0.3077348471,
0.1696079224,
-0.0378650054,
0.5424769521,
0.6145048738,
0.8309029341,
0.0400877185,
0.5885240436,
0.31534639,
0.6952716708,
-0.7646999955,
0.7717782259,
-0.9179683924,
0.3070213795,
0.080985263,
-0.9689535499,
-0.2690402865,
0.1879342645,
-0.3878661692,
-0.0195045825,
0.5782754421,
1.1051203012,
-0.0435957573,
-0.3497105837,
0.2867709696,
0.3236997426,
0.4278553128,
0.7928634286,
0.7533977032,
-0.3916154802,
0.779506743,
0.350881815,
0.1004190296,
-0.5593767762,
-0.7501523495,
-0.7424138784,
-0.3413577676,
-0.200352326,
-0.5252711177,
0.3716200292,
0.5248660445,
0.3790712059,
-0.4727737308,
-0.0771083683,
0.1557090282,
0.3986661434,
-0.0673621967,
-0.1670962423,
0.4077522457,
-0.430329144,
-0.7115209699,
0.5439236164,
0.1317733079,
-0.3959337473,
-0.2598498464,
-0.1108640283,
-0.4432929754,
-0.0707452074,
0.809040904,
0.4159202874,
-0.7805252075,
-0.1683763713,
0.1411874145,
0.0752220303,
-0.0333282351,
0.8192619681,
-0.9455154538,
0.5354693532,
0.2656211555,
1.0846208334,
0.7996532321,
-0.1919133812,
0.6881782413,
-0.5497744083,
-0.0401090048,
0.307364136,
0.2612407207,
0.1960781813,
-0.2429549694,
0.2019216567,
0.0592953302,
-0.6017914414,
-0.9383445978,
0.4813271761,
-0.7579523325,
-0.2933904827,
1.1545726061,
0.0453819372,
-0.3452166617,
-0.1122285053,
-0.2631759346,
0.1737750918,
-0.2676986754,
0.6252493262,
0.3675670028,
0.3022949994,
-0.4725544453,
-0.6596009135,
0.2737334371,
0.5945841074,
-0.5636916161,
0.1677708477,
0.7276145816,
0.5211448073,
-0.4282763302,
0.8083988428,
-0.0697512403,
0.2400636524,
-0.2006338388,
-0.042773664,
-0.0534755737,
-0.0984635353,
-0.2936136127,
0.2645933628,
0.3862751126,
0.1027200595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14282v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14282v3 | INSTRUCTSCORE: Explainable Text Generation Evaluation with Finegrained Feedback | 2023-05-23T17:27:22 | 2023-10-26T18:21:30 | Wenda Xu, Danqing Wang, Liangming Pan, Zhenqiao Song, Markus Freitag, William Yang Wang, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatically evaluating the quality of language generation is critical.
Although recent learned metrics show high correlation with human judgement,
these metrics can not explain their verdict or associate the scores with
defects in generated text. To address this limitation, we present
InstructScore, an explainable evaluation metric for text generation. By
harnessing both explicit human instruction and the implicit knowledge of GPT-4,
we fine-tune a text evaluation metric based on LLaMA, producing both a score
for generated text and a human readable diagnostic report. We evaluate
InstructScore on a variety of generation tasks, including translation,
captioning, data-to-text and commonsense generation. Experiments show that our
7B model surpasses all other unsupervised metrics, including those based on
175B GPT-3 and GPT-4. Surprisingly, our InstructScore, even without direct
supervision from human-rated data, achieves performance levels on par with
state-of-the-art metrics like COMET22, which were fine-tuned on human ratings. | [
-0.2919207513,
-0.4644569457,
0.6741605997,
0.2736932337,
-0.3445959389,
0.326597631,
-0.3278159499,
-0.4178036153,
-0.3943502605,
0.4892015457,
-0.4744997919,
-0.5643121004,
-0.402520299,
0.1392414421,
-0.4853640497,
1.6254643202,
0.013398991,
-0.0909928754,
-0.4818145633,
0.2615171969,
-0.5090603828,
-0.2222498655,
-0.4629392326,
-0.5601966381,
0.1951075643,
0.9188650846,
0.5385382771,
0.5010086894,
0.6082770824,
0.211704731,
0.1100242585,
0.510391593,
-0.558870852,
-0.1443219632,
-0.2631446123,
-0.3166120052,
-0.3177399039,
-0.0229233,
0.518568635,
0.6102304459,
-0.0979853049,
0.383060962,
0.3519480228,
0.7096868753,
-0.3391402364,
0.1841866672,
-0.6378852129,
-0.2383366078,
-0.2052927762,
-0.4126555324,
-0.3539264202,
-0.8525308967,
0.0645614415,
-0.4769360721,
0.5618802309,
0.1059295461,
0.7039331198,
0.3278877139,
-0.3005290627,
-0.5613309145,
-0.7214878201,
0.566482842,
-0.6828520298,
0.0294688698,
0.41694507,
0.3267353475,
-0.3107391894,
-0.8135130405,
-0.6810067296,
-0.5718103647,
0.0147973914,
0.2964102328,
-0.3118739128,
-0.0173727162,
0.0810624585,
0.6521965861,
-0.4871345758,
0.2569044828,
-0.3788043261,
-0.1880253851,
0.6318795085,
0.2127147913,
0.2835015357,
-0.3063074648,
-0.2456958294,
-0.0177777149,
-0.8691422343,
0.0835681558,
0.6969659328,
-0.0357506238,
0.1232122108,
0.4358460009,
-0.4123058915,
0.3621632457,
0.3976146281,
-0.0932549238,
0.178524822,
-0.3731317818,
-0.110905014,
0.1358665228,
1.0068962574,
0.5216278434,
0.1240937263,
-0.3568865955,
-0.4027046859,
0.3629744053,
0.3674229681,
-1.0072200298,
-0.4024011493,
-0.1002559513,
-0.2507861555,
-0.4994628131,
0.0861493051,
-0.6940280795,
-0.4939165115,
-0.0950621888,
0.5091593862,
-0.5537980199,
-0.030321382,
0.0752249658,
0.0474464931,
0.0320918709,
0.2921990752,
-1.1200153828,
0.2993758619,
0.6077293158,
0.5518491864,
-0.1778824925,
-0.3381114602,
-0.5237103701,
-0.052449055,
-0.4487638772,
1.0426813364,
-0.4569369853,
-0.2467092872,
-0.1250931323,
-0.2084778845,
0.1949924529,
-0.7276748419,
0.5807785988,
-0.0901991129,
0.5330546498,
0.1355176568,
-0.664114356,
-0.3199545443,
-0.035557244,
-0.2202950716,
1.0905895233,
0.3393265605,
-0.7413310409,
0.8690969348,
-0.7220078111,
-0.5132023692,
0.3676978648,
0.0147357462,
-0.5013425946,
0.1505917311,
0.4552999139,
0.6034941077,
-0.6104091406,
0.4959399402,
0.1297459304,
-0.3572353721,
0.1625239104,
-0.6927857995,
0.294089973,
0.1405988932,
-0.7311450839,
0.218555972,
-1.043426156,
0.039072305,
0.0115251634,
-0.454537183,
-0.121918574,
0.0309617314,
-0.228635177,
-0.1214268953,
0.190981701,
-0.5677098632,
-0.0672639236,
-0.6754243374,
0.5104238391,
0.4802226126,
0.2270591557,
0.4881204069,
-0.2740465403,
0.5976376534,
-0.230352357,
0.1592446864,
-0.3532962501,
-0.5135186315,
-0.8007376194,
0.1241864339,
0.0041274545,
0.169518128,
-0.6018548012,
0.2209562212,
-0.2310043573,
-0.8006286025,
-0.71033746,
0.3482659459,
0.772834301,
0.7446348071,
0.2915917039,
-0.3920441866,
-0.1805260926,
-0.8483409286,
-0.2305967808,
-0.3042451143,
-0.1654972732,
0.0643844828,
0.3703563809,
-0.3032879531,
0.6267055273,
-0.4105305672,
-0.0741612688,
-0.3335316479,
0.4741039574,
0.0618357211,
0.5051222444,
0.3865114748,
-0.2262274772,
-0.30482319,
0.1712970585,
-0.4946058393,
-0.4112123251,
-0.2249449342,
-0.1261605024,
0.0930701718,
0.3824361265,
-0.2880302966,
0.2028366923,
0.5797973871,
-0.4395277202,
0.6795475483,
-0.4667580426,
0.283262223,
-0.9456430674,
-0.1748007238,
-0.0497363918,
-0.2169835865,
-0.2537751198,
-0.0683902875,
0.1390600204,
0.0769110918,
-0.1903208643,
0.1994049847,
-0.3560760021,
0.0109129343,
-0.1458426118,
0.1966878176,
0.1150774136,
0.3064581752,
-0.5640183091,
0.8548443913,
0.1791181266,
-0.6335936785,
0.2208471894,
0.2309719622,
-0.8308279514,
0.633462131,
-0.5503939986,
0.3639927208,
-0.0210737437,
0.1009830832,
-1.1426782608,
-0.6049209833,
0.1019671038,
-0.4674815834,
0.2585383654,
0.0030328352,
-0.7190905213,
-0.3925655186,
-0.1115980521,
0.1556320339,
0.5880334377,
-1.0123819113,
-0.1308699995,
0.2395210713,
-0.0559041798,
-0.1963199675,
-0.5032966733,
0.1794193834,
-0.3834106326,
-0.5420057178,
0.3738982975,
-0.2688136995,
-0.0835665688,
-0.1754472256,
0.0732510611,
0.0423870571,
0.0779217258,
0.4145200849,
-0.0235770531,
-0.1501249224,
0.1205852106,
0.4433755279,
-0.1148277149,
0.3737817407,
-0.1520052254,
0.2845090032,
-0.2781227827,
-0.2571130097,
-0.5706216693,
0.0858857036,
0.5441918969,
-0.1894516945,
0.1472566426,
0.4611631334,
-0.0961799398,
-0.5043249726,
-0.3097468615,
-0.092499949,
-0.4802389741,
0.4224810302,
-0.000424464,
-0.7520154119,
0.1711773574,
-0.2166018784,
0.08115796,
0.6685688496,
0.640888989,
-0.0362476967,
1.3200861216,
0.5940737724,
0.4020341635,
0.3656274974,
-0.0970365182,
-0.0339189246,
-0.5875584483,
-0.4629645944,
-0.3735950291,
0.1277022511,
-0.5797552466,
-0.0530059896,
0.1774163544,
0.1889552176,
-0.3309063613,
0.2051780522,
-0.8951389194,
0.7232834697,
0.6018876433,
0.104455404,
0.4522158504,
-0.1018412039,
-0.0949843675,
-0.0479955301,
-0.6818476319,
-0.8798778057,
1.0852757692,
0.2055168301,
0.7268867493,
-0.0302790236,
0.8129323125,
0.2994037271,
0.7194175124,
-0.6516187787,
0.3589830101,
-0.3852061927,
-0.2250787318,
-0.0259843133,
-0.4607996643,
-0.8391503692,
-0.0502419509,
-0.2429586649,
-0.5540185571,
-0.4712949097,
0.4511694312,
-0.2808565497,
-0.0789094344,
-1.0052227974,
0.7726349831,
-0.3869545162,
-0.148007676,
-0.3784109652,
-0.3958249092,
0.6182396412,
-0.228773132,
0.1688984931,
-0.041911725,
0.3502899408,
0.9303053021,
-0.5682424307,
0.9396085739,
-0.0240527298,
-0.2662440836,
0.3795279264,
0.2165478766,
0.3529679477,
0.1145871729,
0.0604382902,
-0.0720060468,
-0.2256903946,
0.0980000421,
-0.7265955806,
0.8914164901,
-0.6223439574,
-0.5301330686,
0.0155949192,
-0.3998285234,
-0.2923679352,
0.1357704848,
0.7465427518,
0.4751790166,
-0.2856253386,
0.0402235836,
0.3463541865,
-0.3198994398,
0.3674699068,
0.3527724445,
-0.1052829251,
-0.5726231933,
1.1091468334,
-0.0384194404,
0.2573996186,
0.362832576,
0.5502659678,
-0.3750090897,
-0.5822283626,
-0.8118309975,
0.0585537329,
-0.6611807346,
-0.4453048706,
-0.3135866523,
-0.0925058648,
0.0777973086,
-0.271443367,
-0.3646412194,
-0.401203841,
-0.4615569711,
-0.307712853,
0.3178481758,
1.3756119013,
0.0555676557,
0.6698223948,
-0.6746013761,
0.1477115601,
0.2450795621,
0.4428601563,
0.0721007884,
-0.7167919874,
-0.3913886249,
-0.0501010269,
-0.5868126154,
-0.7436547875,
0.2167505324,
0.2854086459,
0.4356887043,
0.4781566262,
-0.0195364524,
0.5857447386,
-0.5044877529,
0.8398817182,
0.3056448102,
-1.2120497227,
0.7009803057,
-0.258538574,
0.4178018272,
0.4145020545,
0.0020961259,
-0.0891576633,
-0.9345633984,
-0.6481232047,
-0.8665069342,
0.5565601587,
0.3714612126,
0.2778703272,
-0.1010331884,
0.372326225,
0.619879663,
0.1309034228,
-0.5153641105,
0.2119064629,
-0.4483955801,
-0.2664851844,
-0.2316914648,
-0.2471702993,
0.0623058937,
-0.2264753878,
0.4095399678,
-0.1020250469,
-0.0173805226,
0.1146046072,
-0.1877055466,
-0.14345783,
0.358070612,
0.628618896,
0.7523946762,
-0.0321763866,
0.1909435987,
0.0286498815,
-0.6105129123,
0.0005825899,
0.0029408827,
-0.1396441907,
-0.0921931937,
0.5206278563,
0.7945553064,
0.2646580935,
-0.536685884,
0.5105605125,
-0.1089840159,
-0.3570094705,
-0.0410118066,
0.2712863982,
-0.1643682867,
0.2273512781,
0.2727046311,
0.0735206157,
0.2072505057,
-0.2617605627,
0.1427683234,
0.1494307369,
-0.4639796019,
-0.6319493651,
1.031899929,
0.3956829011,
-0.0986296907,
0.4403741658,
-0.4095787704,
-0.3561210334,
0.6076518893,
0.8278287649,
0.8935393691,
-0.0055004512,
0.5471608043,
0.520570755,
0.5346214771,
-0.0948435739,
0.2303834707,
-0.1715858579,
-0.4607777894,
-0.5566650033,
-0.6630265713,
-0.5834426284,
0.2935681641,
-0.512376368,
-0.0634584054,
-0.5400013924,
-0.0306329932,
0.2572852075,
-0.1065911204,
-0.715419054,
0.4124775231,
-0.0482675843,
0.4196967185,
-0.6953064203,
0.4709004462,
0.6308939457,
-0.6240009069,
-0.9321060777,
0.2257605642,
-0.2020577639,
-0.7025846839,
0.5682739019,
0.4478416741,
-0.4038294554,
0.2327032685,
-0.7964852452,
-0.446541667,
0.8900073767,
0.6025006771,
-0.4291113913,
0.354670614,
-0.0194459911,
0.7570537925,
-0.3605603576,
0.3106989861,
0.6369304657,
0.3810042441,
-0.2645736039,
-0.885350585,
0.2405328155,
-0.1157481298,
-0.1091476083,
0.1776771098,
-0.4756425321,
0.398294121,
-0.6620091796,
-0.4823343754,
0.2135473639,
0.6040495038,
0.076178588,
0.4556930363,
0.4145127237,
0.3479651511,
0.9197266102,
-0.0959361866,
1.1717342138,
-0.076861769,
0.1717715114,
1.0760815144,
0.189151302,
0.6765320301,
0.2613419592,
-0.0535282828,
0.6637399793,
0.5658074617,
0.0104380958,
0.497228235,
0.2746314704,
-0.2025238127,
-0.1216882616,
-0.0872417688,
-0.0955111012,
0.7389760017,
0.2527046502,
-0.4249835312,
-0.169349879,
-0.1160296053,
0.1542675942,
0.335257113,
-0.2993062139,
0.9245944023,
-0.0688189864,
-0.9646853805,
0.6868242621,
-0.1553841829,
0.6195087433,
-0.4519945979,
-0.2208348066,
-0.4154346287,
0.2866908312,
-0.5062289238,
-1.2128254175,
0.1184397191,
0.4217735827,
-0.3152565062,
-0.1685980409,
0.3988426924,
-0.3364448249,
-0.3646349609,
0.108438611,
0.2519191206,
0.2967461348,
0.0073428354,
-0.1501682103,
-0.504850328,
0.2440450937,
-0.1373639703,
0.231780827,
0.7415091395,
-0.270719707,
0.6691314578,
0.8342809081,
-0.1397689879,
-0.0634652898,
0.4251689911,
0.7539955974,
-0.5834293962,
-0.4091491401,
-0.7497237325,
0.4839448929,
0.0424350239,
-0.8485348225,
0.6525632739,
0.5025833249,
0.8588384986,
-0.1117112711,
0.9526404738,
0.2131596804,
0.4458295107,
-0.5823866725,
0.9975779057,
-0.5333669782,
0.3077550828,
-0.566039741,
-1.0687944889,
-0.2713678479,
0.287386328,
-0.0887979567,
-0.2269917428,
0.7699673176,
0.7523784637,
-0.0273622386,
-0.1004373208,
0.3073963821,
0.1769910306,
0.4308051169,
0.4169040322,
1.1984724998,
-0.0951855481,
0.9781286716,
-0.3447081149,
-0.5003566146,
-0.0385732278,
-1.0166282654,
-0.8762611151,
-0.5451934338,
-0.282559514,
-0.2167179286,
-0.0823252052,
0.4219196439,
0.4525778592,
-0.599403739,
-0.0296865124,
-0.444129765,
-0.0623756349,
-0.1207000762,
-0.2841252387,
0.3293929696,
-0.4743699431,
-0.7567415237,
0.600279212,
0.2954617143,
-0.0046835095,
-0.3867098093,
-0.1909991354,
0.5778015256,
-0.0164637659,
0.6354468465,
0.1270726621,
-0.6424956918,
-0.4095575511,
-0.2961998284,
-0.1554864794,
-0.1557704061,
0.6065540314,
-0.7339605689,
0.6522564292,
0.3702993393,
0.4185520709,
0.3975716829,
0.026115654,
0.8027433157,
-0.6737501025,
-0.2262956947,
0.1159634814,
0.1872970909,
0.80557096,
-0.5071228743,
0.5221686363,
-0.0348082408,
-0.9721859694,
-0.6535563469,
0.1499937326,
-0.835762918,
0.1455005258,
1.0833251476,
0.0387415588,
0.133849442,
0.0727264285,
-0.4623122811,
0.2391210347,
-0.579303503,
1.0568841696,
0.3390386105,
-0.1730708629,
0.0269536246,
-0.533763051,
0.6797682643,
0.3425211608,
-1.0436111689,
0.0182103459,
0.6686173677,
0.3263103962,
-0.1115325913,
0.4720316827,
-0.047177013,
0.4344610572,
0.0836489722,
0.1426828802,
-0.0828280225,
-0.2190970927,
-0.0569450371,
-0.0608746149,
0.280749917,
-0.193460077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14281v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14281v2 | Weakly-Supervised Learning of Visual Relations in Multimodal Pretraining | 2023-05-23T17:27:12 | 2023-10-19T17:46:34 | Emanuele Bugliarello, Aida Nematzadeh, Lisa Anne Hendricks | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Recent work in vision-and-language pretraining has investigated supervised
signals from object detection data to learn better, fine-grained multimodal
representations. In this work, we take a step further and explore how we can
tap into supervision from small-scale visual relation data. In particular, we
propose two pretraining approaches to contextualise visual entities in a
multimodal setup. With verbalised scene graphs, we transform visual relation
triplets into structured captions, and treat them as additional image
descriptions. With masked relation prediction, we further encourage relating
entities from image regions with visually masked contexts. When applied to
strong baselines pretrained on large amounts of Web data, zero-shot evaluations
on both coarse-grained and fine-grained tasks show the efficacy of our methods
in learning multimodal representations from weakly-supervised relations data. | [
-0.5881541967,
-0.6851072311,
0.5026478767,
-0.0320011042,
-0.4216136932,
-0.591057837,
-0.2935797274,
-0.6386318207,
0.2152246088,
0.4977799356,
-0.5892067552,
-0.3675458431,
-0.5234044194,
-0.0407955758,
0.0401116647,
0.9627494812,
0.0171177592,
0.3321561515,
-0.6068581939,
-0.1573198289,
-0.3434393406,
-0.5373023748,
-0.2123703957,
-0.1183043644,
0.896355927,
0.4220092297,
0.5666953325,
0.4133924544,
0.6524454951,
0.3017481267,
0.3688394129,
0.1409996599,
-0.53283602,
0.0561133213,
-0.172058627,
-0.4681346714,
-0.4251556396,
0.1210721731,
0.1559878737,
0.8849592805,
0.4374064207,
0.3372313976,
0.0605314188,
0.2911319733,
-0.9742044806,
0.8069116473,
-0.5650428534,
0.23725532,
-0.363922596,
-0.3152661324,
-0.6026793122,
0.3416366875,
0.0237094518,
-0.7816643715,
0.333322823,
0.1416328102,
0.9647526741,
0.3925381899,
-0.6955704689,
-0.0039431602,
-0.454039216,
0.8411922455,
0.0380567908,
0.4629115164,
0.7326274514,
0.3240002096,
0.1804779619,
-1.0233254433,
-0.2167393714,
-0.1460648924,
-0.5868912935,
0.1672765464,
0.0601638891,
0.1412306726,
0.3329261243,
0.3115338981,
-0.1508208066,
-0.1426856965,
-0.4497013092,
-0.1627971381,
0.5360031724,
0.0012585508,
0.2038490772,
-0.3383984566,
-0.6067214608,
-0.1933404654,
-0.7124918103,
-0.0211575199,
-0.0773024708,
0.4611897767,
-0.3792118132,
0.5911124945,
-0.1979279518,
0.6174309254,
0.0868150815,
-0.2073218822,
0.2728352249,
-0.5726297498,
-0.0776679367,
-0.2109605223,
0.8284627795,
0.4814730883,
0.5916141272,
-0.2453072816,
-0.0627297238,
0.3938256204,
0.2083926648,
-0.7741906047,
-0.6871092319,
-0.3753266633,
-0.4704160988,
-0.2610754073,
0.0888473317,
-0.5667006373,
-0.1708170176,
-0.5918664336,
0.5886797309,
-0.2269660681,
-0.0773604214,
-0.3651742935,
-0.028742278,
0.1460020393,
0.3626308441,
-0.9923064113,
0.2927184999,
0.1103908196,
0.4745795429,
0.1615987867,
-0.4424476326,
-0.8750395775,
0.6161593795,
-0.3156192005,
0.7979207039,
-0.3930664062,
0.0335944556,
0.0341309719,
0.3016498387,
0.1426357776,
-0.359903574,
0.0416378938,
-0.3585197926,
-0.0519271009,
0.0214377996,
0.0609712489,
0.277977705,
0.2160574645,
-0.758045733,
0.6160542369,
0.132589072,
-1.0160113573,
0.7693449855,
-0.1431100816,
-0.7126297951,
-0.2046651989,
-0.4065413475,
-0.5132091641,
0.0219923258,
0.6494338512,
0.9655649066,
0.2173351049,
-0.0676321089,
-0.9102155566,
-0.1451925784,
-0.1442896128,
-0.1156041101,
0.3151661754,
-0.0606007464,
0.1102954969,
0.1849463582,
-0.7569983602,
-0.083612822,
-0.0452228487,
0.186025545,
-0.4197082818,
-0.1373846978,
0.0286916569,
0.4580178261,
0.2010691166,
-0.1331961602,
0.0980705023,
-0.0270888507,
0.1878664941,
0.5831614733,
0.0915178284,
0.8715028167,
0.1238253117,
0.2583115399,
0.5070806146,
0.2374402285,
-0.5430534482,
-0.2659717202,
-0.757543087,
-0.1733052284,
0.040063031,
0.1720951349,
-1.4279283285,
-0.0428740531,
-0.2191754133,
-0.0183083471,
0.1335277557,
0.6318541765,
0.6623565555,
0.4954513609,
0.6373405457,
-0.418243438,
-0.5779471993,
-1.0608859062,
0.1191708222,
-0.1314585358,
-0.1317881048,
0.333332926,
0.6261623502,
-0.3021435738,
0.7759129405,
-0.6806904674,
-0.9093101621,
-0.1451482177,
0.3274318874,
-0.0549826659,
0.6813964844,
0.6596112251,
-0.9003605843,
-0.3863248825,
-0.1371578574,
-1.0755292177,
0.362126857,
0.2504381835,
-0.0418982692,
-0.3642650545,
0.9313455224,
-0.4710086286,
0.4872506559,
0.2314849943,
0.0340512693,
0.2545434535,
-0.0306051467,
-0.1672022939,
-0.9270249009,
-0.3623574674,
0.186907813,
-0.5523253083,
-0.5053658485,
-0.0686752126,
0.0904763639,
-0.2623102367,
-0.8302385211,
0.4445246458,
-0.9556865096,
-0.2459795922,
0.1938171834,
0.0191624835,
-0.0889710411,
0.8072946668,
0.4151104987,
0.4634722769,
1.0082933903,
-0.5718846917,
0.4160471261,
0.3356781304,
-0.1677328497,
0.8482289314,
-0.227812469,
0.1389618665,
-0.2698635459,
0.219641611,
-0.8051662445,
-0.6554450393,
0.1301843524,
-0.3466112614,
0.3826247454,
-0.6729643941,
-0.462818861,
-0.174163267,
-0.3214512467,
0.6676843762,
0.10827481,
-0.5833969116,
0.5412641764,
0.3059890568,
0.030637918,
-0.5756924152,
-0.9530801177,
-0.2551703155,
-0.0746253654,
-0.4633121789,
-0.0146077769,
0.480240196,
-0.1095198169,
0.2494125217,
-0.1232973337,
-0.5034042001,
-0.083829619,
0.5040159822,
0.2021857947,
-0.3405992091,
0.2237203866,
-0.3165146112,
-0.2731741965,
0.0530324765,
-0.0062553906,
0.0068107508,
-0.2374219149,
-0.2822833359,
-0.4134296477,
0.2281466275,
0.097266458,
-0.1730351001,
0.6543833613,
1.0465093851,
-0.4197289944,
-0.0988574252,
-0.1922216564,
-0.4062312543,
-0.4262764454,
0.240173623,
-0.7441737652,
-0.6964938045,
0.2410516739,
-0.0930866227,
-0.6747276187,
0.1724018306,
0.218745783,
-0.4653625786,
0.8983748555,
1.0052148104,
0.1011823416,
0.5818050504,
-0.3486191928,
-0.0430199169,
-0.5861182809,
-0.2595157623,
0.0903649852,
-0.2193725556,
-0.5241778493,
-0.4305075109,
0.2854314744,
0.5548975468,
0.0090010138,
0.3786895573,
0.0185718965,
0.5055008531,
0.4374671876,
0.5603737235,
0.2241478115,
-0.0246441606,
0.2213449031,
-0.0735497847,
-0.7275209427,
-0.1495096385,
1.1436662674,
0.0925686136,
1.1302756071,
-0.1859038621,
0.7178637385,
-0.0538187884,
0.5424872637,
-0.8342707753,
0.333142072,
-0.1069812998,
-0.5275597572,
-0.0279104412,
-0.5225302577,
-0.9409887195,
0.2442734689,
-0.4648014009,
-0.8192459941,
0.3978205621,
0.5062246323,
-0.1611949056,
0.0616372526,
-1.1498888731,
1.2832833529,
-0.1855185479,
-0.7504443526,
0.1148561165,
-0.9413396716,
0.6561003923,
0.2428352684,
0.2076430768,
0.0022149945,
0.0804806426,
0.5224983692,
-0.2581246197,
1.0900439024,
-0.14500992,
0.1359520704,
0.0607081056,
-0.1115803123,
0.1819595098,
0.4104216099,
0.7202541232,
-0.0262886081,
0.0692446604,
-0.7434960008,
-0.4468319416,
0.5044872761,
-0.6458237171,
-0.2312831134,
-0.3745368421,
-0.3422028124,
-0.629835844,
0.3494637311,
0.3028981686,
0.8082335591,
-0.0988485217,
0.4878414571,
0.4788895845,
0.1708391905,
0.3323830366,
0.0159618985,
-0.4610802233,
-0.2272016555,
0.8259145617,
-0.1219953969,
0.2795699835,
0.5307894349,
-0.2792763412,
-0.2931442261,
-0.2122487277,
-0.1968726516,
0.0440267511,
-0.9099600315,
-0.2860294878,
-0.3607314527,
0.1171351895,
-0.3324549794,
-0.191409871,
-0.4336036742,
0.0656583756,
-0.4793484211,
0.0229316875,
-0.0033963565,
0.6996564865,
-0.069472976,
0.4497290552,
-0.4916591942,
0.8984355927,
0.7679150701,
0.3421824276,
-0.2899394333,
0.0523420386,
-0.4087632895,
-0.0801881626,
-0.0866151527,
-0.7077149749,
0.1447328776,
0.3224695623,
0.2490712851,
0.7673236728,
-0.0179694872,
1.0380172729,
-0.5381031036,
0.5793291926,
0.6173659563,
-0.5951331258,
0.7523800731,
-0.3112385273,
0.1232940182,
0.6712465286,
0.4121805131,
0.2296357602,
-0.0788586661,
-0.6599875093,
-0.5874714255,
0.8387330174,
0.173454836,
0.1795285791,
0.0172346085,
0.0407392718,
-0.2003116161,
0.2757338583,
-0.9576668143,
-0.2043329924,
-0.4245409071,
-0.0259808302,
-0.4767237902,
-0.2783800066,
-0.3536302149,
-0.4271315634,
0.0889636278,
-0.4395048618,
0.3264479637,
-0.0845434591,
-0.7430596352,
0.0629109442,
-0.0216885302,
0.1220016181,
0.8482844234,
-0.3253047764,
0.8182198405,
0.1742163301,
-0.2716079056,
0.0962324813,
-0.0112379687,
0.2210819572,
-0.0576825328,
0.9226101041,
0.7775678635,
0.7200214267,
-0.250832051,
0.9915831089,
-0.0452687293,
-0.0554072559,
-0.1735669225,
-0.230602935,
-0.0526643582,
0.1069327593,
0.0932783708,
0.2370538861,
0.0228691995,
-0.9824614525,
0.5033857226,
0.3110227585,
-0.7204053402,
-0.5341590047,
0.7208386064,
0.0924094915,
0.460621357,
0.3630308211,
-0.315296948,
-0.3170520663,
0.3451463282,
0.4198517799,
0.3111415207,
0.1715873331,
0.0668052658,
0.2800917625,
0.2138158679,
0.0562803894,
-0.0487721972,
-0.4586890638,
-0.7802234292,
-0.529179275,
-0.4596983492,
-0.1640523076,
0.1474689394,
-0.9432705045,
0.3527038991,
-0.4332574904,
-0.1781704873,
0.0681080446,
-0.2508128285,
-1.0919605494,
0.380066365,
0.3706983626,
0.1661679447,
-1.0952790976,
0.9652104378,
0.8317551613,
-0.9958619475,
-0.8288107514,
-0.162056312,
-0.1426664591,
-0.629193306,
1.2411276102,
0.4094882011,
-0.2484169006,
-0.1698724777,
-0.7967982292,
-0.5988830924,
0.8510023952,
0.5276379585,
-0.3032285273,
0.0823187605,
-0.2208009958,
0.359477669,
-0.2138603479,
0.2833913267,
0.1185261831,
0.2666378021,
0.0669557229,
-0.6536629796,
-0.2256625891,
-0.3018098772,
0.0103205629,
0.0332640074,
-0.4840725362,
0.8915964961,
0.0370748825,
-0.2233686,
-0.1146630123,
0.8462889194,
-0.2725768089,
0.4794462621,
0.4883582592,
0.5855130553,
0.1759269238,
-0.2211764604,
1.0115984678,
0.020211393,
0.4229967594,
1.4891744852,
-0.1530820578,
0.8302648664,
0.8383218646,
-0.0289345849,
0.3974523246,
0.5594695807,
0.0732476488,
0.6181886792,
-0.3533376157,
-0.0964369401,
-0.6358392835,
-0.3209472597,
-0.3393725455,
0.3532747328,
0.2083274275,
-0.2501476407,
-0.3418086469,
0.3431536257,
-0.158204481,
0.070969142,
-0.565730989,
0.9511010647,
0.4381013811,
-0.2358281612,
0.3801904619,
-0.5143600106,
0.4982465506,
-0.4975880682,
-0.1180101857,
-0.0726731494,
0.3256814778,
-0.4181067944,
-0.6506347656,
0.024984451,
-0.2095621377,
-0.2038015574,
-0.3982726038,
0.9514529705,
-0.541080296,
-0.3622579277,
0.4213643074,
0.5509430766,
0.0754576251,
-0.0656391159,
-0.2540062368,
-0.2848699093,
-0.4355328977,
-0.019056946,
0.5159340501,
0.5509344339,
-0.1990302056,
0.4493982792,
0.5692288876,
-0.1187303439,
0.144803524,
0.278644681,
1.0999988317,
-0.445150584,
-0.3376252651,
-0.6335346699,
0.3413662612,
-0.0840565041,
-0.1207941547,
0.747184515,
0.3947562277,
1.1851211786,
-0.5609121323,
0.2547632158,
-0.0156682283,
-0.206948325,
-0.8659579158,
0.239912346,
-0.5529990196,
-0.2561613917,
-0.428882122,
-1.1258778572,
-0.4716999531,
0.5764437318,
-0.5687195063,
-0.1165426075,
0.8748957515,
0.5753942132,
-0.6842210889,
-0.4424912035,
0.4253480136,
-0.0170732662,
-0.1619525701,
0.7321619391,
1.222088933,
-0.2845450342,
0.6770628095,
-0.6956235766,
0.1208667383,
-0.0557518601,
-0.8009278774,
-1.3209285736,
-0.4991755188,
-0.1359570771,
0.1249869168,
-0.0793552175,
0.4744393826,
1.2666540146,
-0.6019666791,
-0.0192569774,
0.1088208258,
0.0313836001,
-0.0714521781,
-0.1552799344,
0.2779785097,
-0.5209667087,
-0.5334805846,
0.2766113281,
0.2633281946,
0.10348811,
-0.2666162848,
-0.0058303936,
-0.3062125146,
-0.6221920848,
0.89824754,
0.0736588165,
-0.4861267507,
-0.3501325846,
-0.5831319094,
-0.0460871905,
0.1692044884,
0.7929431796,
-0.6739535332,
0.5256891251,
0.3390710056,
0.2883773744,
1.1626638174,
0.2398622632,
0.1943497211,
-1.4414917231,
0.8730546832,
0.0890087113,
0.5244069099,
0.2967840731,
-0.0895831659,
0.5759446621,
0.3255648911,
0.0717029199,
-0.7315959334,
0.4135644436,
-1.0588377714,
-0.164839834,
0.8102968335,
-0.4822369516,
-0.4724389613,
-0.0543689579,
-0.0544581674,
0.1515009701,
-0.0427723825,
0.0817308947,
0.3510065079,
-0.1505917758,
-0.5275750756,
-0.5329329967,
0.5976853371,
0.2397258729,
-0.8002684712,
-0.2994033992,
0.6414183974,
0.0426666737,
0.4086289406,
0.6485795975,
0.0659943894,
0.2334912419,
0.2661651969,
-0.1278366596,
-0.165942952,
-0.665862143,
0.0362651199,
0.3624200821,
-0.0493875332,
-0.434797138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14280v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14280v2 | Multilingual Pixel Representations for Translation and Effective Cross-lingual Transfer | 2023-05-23T17:26:50 | 2023-10-24T13:36:49 | Elizabeth Salesky, Neha Verma, Philipp Koehn, Matt Post | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce and demonstrate how to effectively train multilingual machine
translation models with pixel representations. We experiment with two different
data settings with a variety of language and script coverage, demonstrating
improved performance compared to subword embeddings. We explore various
properties of pixel representations such as parameter sharing within and across
scripts to better understand where they lead to positive transfer. We observe
that these properties not only enable seamless cross-lingual transfer to unseen
scripts, but make pixel representations more data-efficient than alternatives
such as vocabulary expansion. We hope this work contributes to more extensible
multilingual models for all languages and scripts. | [
-0.3991677761,
-0.2388860136,
0.4229477048,
0.3763675094,
-0.1009855941,
0.2424808592,
-0.2536530197,
-0.5155798793,
0.2788465619,
0.2320203334,
-0.249064669,
-0.4911108911,
-0.8763901591,
-0.1354616135,
-0.5624102354,
0.7102702856,
-0.4206999242,
0.5248895884,
0.0287390761,
-0.1655091792,
-0.17614007,
-0.7088299394,
-0.3242137134,
-0.4506910443,
0.8106520772,
0.3037872016,
1.0331007242,
0.6829262376,
0.4993306696,
0.2546261549,
0.4552637041,
-0.0060484568,
-0.3541323543,
-0.1452524364,
-0.1854865402,
-0.6073232889,
-0.1039060503,
-0.1041637361,
0.717790544,
0.9616293907,
0.1038187519,
-0.3130289018,
-0.1652230024,
0.045327235,
-0.4416431785,
0.1102745906,
-0.4614951015,
0.3237518072,
0.0186957382,
-0.3427725136,
-0.5274687409,
-0.2764406204,
-0.0514903143,
-0.7012518048,
0.2801803946,
-0.0341786928,
0.6126405001,
-0.1207987294,
-0.7319005132,
-0.2874387205,
-0.5931997299,
0.9027122259,
-0.2939422429,
0.5360656381,
0.4255494177,
0.5072333217,
0.2490930706,
-0.7319431305,
-0.3617227674,
-0.0645947009,
-0.2086051404,
0.0730868876,
-0.1333186924,
-0.1694492251,
-0.0160753522,
0.355389148,
-0.4136530161,
0.1293674707,
-0.2827194333,
-0.6811847687,
0.6074720621,
0.0249067862,
0.7699576616,
0.0884363651,
-0.4917265773,
-0.3504267335,
-0.7523673177,
-0.1148517132,
0.3971237838,
0.2160806209,
-0.324734211,
0.5945750475,
0.138702184,
0.6029226184,
-0.4142461419,
0.1649800837,
0.2197978348,
-0.8387060165,
0.2762870193,
0.093323268,
0.4198304713,
0.4342193604,
0.4898723662,
-0.444083035,
-0.1079786643,
-0.0109326355,
0.0982286185,
-1.029916048,
-0.2531574965,
-0.1024924144,
-0.393842876,
0.1884534657,
-0.0594072416,
-0.7281665802,
-0.462043345,
-0.2219843268,
0.4080684185,
-0.571300447,
-0.4871949852,
0.2981444895,
-0.1426924169,
0.3463153541,
0.3249902129,
-1.2560398579,
0.2548635602,
0.29864645,
0.7547658086,
-0.0512592271,
-0.7459656,
-0.4183512628,
0.0897624418,
-0.8501992822,
0.5219141841,
-0.5251440406,
-0.3134342432,
0.3840667307,
0.1996012181,
-0.2909471095,
-0.3275956213,
-0.0851344615,
-0.3967572153,
0.0218239557,
-0.1255711317,
-0.4813581109,
-0.341909796,
-0.0226367265,
-0.6222553253,
0.5858392119,
0.2417658418,
-0.3039976954,
0.3845347464,
-0.434381336,
-0.4240540564,
-0.2116187662,
0.0024520545,
-0.0077978414,
0.1569507718,
0.4872866273,
0.7430365086,
0.1184913218,
-0.3221497834,
-0.2470273077,
-0.3055661321,
0.4912306964,
-0.3216128349,
0.4531650841,
0.3105523586,
-0.0987444967,
0.1185562387,
-0.3084459007,
0.1034655795,
0.0386812314,
-0.0910115018,
-0.1842264533,
-0.4182931781,
0.6704206467,
0.2253729552,
0.3539896607,
-0.6041579843,
0.1550637335,
0.0407903418,
0.2583505213,
0.2561128438,
-0.3238318861,
0.8664482236,
-0.2095269263,
0.7877096534,
0.3834636211,
-0.276142925,
-0.5082651973,
-0.3800350428,
-0.6043015718,
-0.2689659894,
0.6174231768,
0.2962692678,
-1.1532526016,
-0.2054538131,
-0.3386490345,
-0.3689532876,
-0.8576657772,
0.210458234,
0.4650978744,
-0.0926682204,
0.3080334663,
-0.4041939378,
-0.1432202011,
-0.9448902011,
-0.0342496596,
0.4118023217,
0.1793329418,
0.1722908318,
0.3849261701,
-0.2894007862,
0.4136596322,
-0.2155481577,
0.0390158221,
-0.7370707393,
0.376413703,
0.0411482453,
0.6792162061,
0.9131445885,
-0.9908994436,
-0.9533450603,
0.5459948182,
-0.3985352814,
-0.0013002526,
-0.420039624,
-0.1289803684,
0.5453450084,
0.3910910487,
-0.2433753014,
0.5171348453,
0.9916515946,
-0.471357435,
0.417891264,
-0.6375135183,
0.5704997182,
-1.2221773863,
0.0811601728,
0.0760796368,
-0.8866033554,
-0.7175891995,
0.1937713623,
0.6225827932,
-0.2890332043,
-0.8981558084,
0.4952941239,
-0.6095747352,
-0.480820626,
-0.1606210023,
0.0751400813,
-0.0851442814,
0.5688734651,
0.2925318182,
1.077814579,
1.050309062,
-0.5127152205,
0.4686657488,
0.1291914731,
-0.5369664431,
0.5897156,
-0.4832063019,
-0.0969746336,
0.1017078906,
0.0483700447,
-0.9391039014,
-0.2430369407,
0.106873326,
-0.4792012572,
0.5058621168,
-0.3238317966,
-0.8250203729,
0.1901762486,
-0.000160543,
0.6701530218,
0.5717520118,
-0.6977112293,
0.0938722789,
0.2988694012,
-0.2335642725,
-0.2644945085,
-0.9673855305,
0.2345424742,
-0.1593958735,
-0.5248681903,
0.724214673,
0.1523184925,
0.2609179318,
0.1632171869,
0.199601993,
-0.4293764234,
-0.3018242121,
-0.2706891596,
0.1425209343,
-0.1246986017,
0.0602689721,
-0.0884315148,
-0.3051264584,
-0.2864764929,
-0.2612081468,
0.908419311,
-0.06625624,
-0.6426400542,
-0.4372434914,
0.7139511108,
0.7488541603,
-0.3687261045,
0.6452583671,
1.0526313782,
-0.4376433492,
-0.1275941879,
-0.0194898993,
0.0120045366,
-0.3499923348,
0.7570288777,
-0.597205162,
-0.4660692811,
0.871468544,
0.0299503002,
-0.2023297697,
0.2811919153,
0.5408287048,
-0.0436130092,
1.4252111912,
0.972776413,
-0.0616738908,
0.5010263324,
-0.3579566777,
0.1075065881,
-0.7779824138,
-0.1779029518,
-0.3170458078,
-0.4187101424,
-0.5522006154,
-0.7096393704,
0.1325700283,
0.1592371017,
0.1451372951,
0.8583682775,
-0.0502018109,
0.5270816684,
0.474480629,
0.0259002559,
0.0081377048,
0.2748315334,
-0.2592482865,
-0.3335824609,
-0.8027917147,
-0.2678079605,
0.9913338423,
0.4344445467,
1.0920177698,
0.2764604986,
0.4257166982,
0.1235486716,
-0.1021780893,
-0.843221724,
0.2220465392,
-0.3320767581,
-0.434676677,
-0.002319705,
-0.4300238788,
-0.9599459767,
0.4760198593,
-0.1073182449,
-0.6641280651,
0.2821184993,
-0.1439302415,
-0.0597387441,
0.4690962136,
-0.8872185946,
0.964460969,
-0.386252284,
-0.3883744478,
-0.6017873883,
-0.3787710667,
-0.2041497678,
-0.0439121909,
-0.1006902158,
0.0583954044,
-0.2772576511,
0.2805715799,
-0.159191519,
0.8639987111,
0.0400075987,
-0.2025786936,
-0.0563443415,
0.3497972488,
0.0333260633,
-0.1481527686,
-0.0495951287,
0.3846369088,
0.3268211782,
-0.7107857466,
-0.6365821958,
0.521500349,
-0.7562664151,
-0.1663692296,
-0.2631607652,
-1.0631773472,
-0.0912954733,
0.2663351297,
0.122872524,
0.5848500729,
0.0690000728,
0.3857260644,
0.4076210558,
-0.4091133475,
0.5072200894,
0.166407153,
-0.8331012726,
-0.2248761803,
0.9580565095,
0.2223295122,
0.6146110296,
0.309923321,
-0.084858492,
-0.6508268118,
-0.5982620716,
-1.0575786829,
0.1011907533,
-1.0522559881,
0.0967554003,
-0.3589464128,
-0.2277035564,
-0.5314989686,
-0.3622640371,
-0.4123340249,
-0.6492740512,
-0.1678253114,
0.1344150305,
0.3220386207,
0.7474582791,
-0.2075341791,
0.4423606694,
-0.7911039591,
0.3320667446,
0.0561678261,
0.4731601179,
-0.3572530746,
-0.3779533803,
-0.5489271879,
0.1736956835,
-0.1616392285,
-0.9898002744,
0.7111762762,
0.2591437697,
0.7882894874,
0.0375211425,
-0.3707896471,
0.7570135593,
-0.3913519979,
0.7349120378,
0.4280995131,
-1.0055638552,
0.1544831991,
-0.4201964736,
0.3610134721,
0.2159943432,
0.7021389604,
-0.9039738774,
-0.011501858,
-0.3025933504,
-0.5569663644,
0.7611281872,
0.1021814123,
0.5179914236,
0.4021973312,
-0.028956145,
0.3531772494,
0.0341282152,
-0.7371226549,
-0.0113539649,
-0.4305776656,
-0.1604529172,
-0.428625077,
-0.00808925,
-0.0160111804,
-0.270704478,
0.4343257546,
-0.3410331011,
0.4218626916,
0.1513495445,
-0.4249306023,
0.1805780232,
0.0621707328,
0.5439276099,
0.6692282557,
0.177699253,
0.3968827724,
0.0575325452,
-0.2267681211,
0.0087564383,
0.002150075,
0.2272863239,
0.1580619365,
0.418463856,
0.7045311928,
0.2099562287,
-0.287324816,
0.543620348,
0.1818261594,
-0.0090526072,
0.1062356979,
-0.1582119167,
0.2772798836,
-0.0058540702,
-0.1348628253,
0.1449993402,
0.0336444564,
-0.8326687813,
0.3800335824,
0.2334642261,
-0.5643209815,
-0.3359158039,
0.2709673345,
0.1129882187,
-0.0676332563,
0.5029904246,
-0.0241060853,
-0.8164522052,
0.8096653223,
1.0447638035,
0.5175833106,
-0.1294422746,
0.5122224092,
0.3636154532,
0.1567983925,
0.1014642343,
0.2135512382,
-0.2246862352,
-0.7460334301,
-0.3039325774,
-0.2591317296,
-0.5939795971,
-0.4416559637,
-0.5066174865,
0.2610134482,
0.0157620814,
0.1628638506,
-0.2576475441,
-0.1880485415,
-0.7769729495,
-0.0294299535,
0.3522692919,
0.8997818828,
-0.6565348506,
1.2587925196,
0.8083244562,
-0.6802034974,
-0.5574789047,
-0.2255682647,
-0.2783131897,
-1.1824994087,
0.5987052917,
0.2689152062,
-0.2015804052,
0.0027104646,
-0.1984889358,
-0.8466402292,
0.8302776814,
0.5202178955,
-0.3858274519,
0.4840010107,
0.8095526099,
0.55901438,
-0.5722513199,
0.2918142378,
0.2313891947,
0.4602977037,
0.2967330515,
-0.9924414158,
-0.1889083683,
-0.2997977138,
0.1310817599,
0.0398835801,
-0.1551639438,
0.7268362045,
-0.1982287318,
-0.3781971335,
0.266313225,
0.3607799411,
-0.2647125423,
0.1141727641,
0.1268685609,
0.30235973,
0.5089933276,
-0.3207426369,
1.5156241655,
-0.6135198474,
0.2662477493,
0.6828139424,
0.0228133071,
0.8683904409,
0.6746866107,
0.0562500097,
0.2590792477,
0.8832563162,
0.105763182,
0.7448334694,
0.1533869058,
-0.1537448466,
-0.3822904229,
-0.3273369968,
-0.5427100658,
0.3707087934,
0.3379418552,
-0.4304562509,
-0.4634627104,
0.2423770577,
0.0115134846,
0.2772165835,
-0.4727968574,
0.5141384602,
0.0447533652,
-0.7678489685,
0.6735134721,
0.0828670189,
0.7509586215,
-0.8562003374,
-0.1465130448,
-0.3396259844,
0.3044466972,
-0.268204391,
-1.112526536,
0.5695611238,
-0.1116821915,
0.179021731,
-0.8749660254,
0.6886747479,
-0.9837397337,
-0.7254500985,
0.5169440508,
0.4451580644,
0.4090693891,
0.0897126347,
-0.5166398287,
-0.1493247449,
0.0855293646,
0.1750200093,
0.2874197066,
0.4506804943,
-0.0518728159,
0.594684124,
0.6041169167,
0.5595561266,
0.5016686916,
0.2181759924,
0.4650676847,
-0.6040670872,
-0.4769096971,
-0.5418437123,
0.4823229015,
-0.014647942,
-0.2165281773,
0.7392778397,
0.4541932344,
1.0274016857,
-0.4118220806,
0.6889846921,
0.0321724303,
-0.0928270295,
-0.7307718992,
1.0804783106,
-0.6826567054,
-0.2228246927,
0.0574097447,
-0.9838843346,
-0.6287778616,
0.7548209429,
-0.1986246854,
-0.0151711246,
0.7953032255,
0.9457535148,
-0.4346019328,
-0.2969546914,
0.7564179301,
-0.3069341183,
0.3058966696,
0.8073936105,
0.9878739119,
-0.491201371,
0.5500583053,
-0.4016610682,
-0.1294182539,
-0.0302960631,
-0.851170063,
-0.6889836788,
-0.7017748356,
-0.3842047155,
0.0087595889,
-0.1488569081,
0.6676928997,
1.1504900455,
-0.8459587693,
-0.45703426,
-0.0364529043,
0.1459609419,
-0.34795174,
-0.0516151674,
0.2584638596,
-0.6341471672,
-1.2084454298,
0.2147563994,
-0.0202446021,
0.2715829611,
-0.6554803252,
-0.3036922812,
-0.0358329602,
-0.1380621642,
0.5159592628,
0.0667913109,
-0.4097257555,
-0.1443403214,
-0.00062647,
-0.3717094064,
0.1477908492,
0.9023164511,
-0.484595865,
0.6141074896,
0.6949129701,
1.0290516615,
0.5998673439,
-0.5087870359,
0.8820293546,
-0.7462680936,
0.2002383173,
-0.055303365,
0.8350665569,
0.6219929457,
-0.1685543209,
0.4581650794,
-0.0072163646,
-0.0712005347,
-0.3423963189,
0.3835848868,
-0.8528189659,
-0.3017056286,
1.30341506,
-0.3586029112,
0.0885438398,
0.063137956,
-0.3425266445,
0.1350141913,
-0.0819243342,
0.4506753087,
0.9604773521,
-0.0311597567,
-0.4157207906,
-0.5595618486,
0.1430909783,
0.5327538848,
-0.7169179916,
-0.0862481818,
0.3744949996,
0.1097718105,
0.3909063637,
0.3568595052,
-0.6737287045,
0.4106104076,
0.213999182,
0.2297295034,
0.0078552123,
-0.6190575361,
-0.4884540439,
-0.0022911632,
-0.0327949002,
-0.5002313256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14279v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14279v4 | Two Failures of Self-Consistency in the Multi-Step Reasoning of LLMs | 2023-05-23T17:25:59 | 2024-02-02T18:37:07 | Angelica Chen, Jason Phang, Alicia Parrish, Vishakh Padmakumar, Chen Zhao, Samuel R. Bowman, Kyunghyun Cho | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved widespread success on a variety of
in-context few-shot tasks, but this success is typically evaluated via
correctness rather than consistency. We argue that self-consistency is an
important criteria for valid multi-step reasoning in tasks where the solution
is composed of the answers to multiple sub-steps. We propose two types of
self-consistency that are particularly important for multi-step reasoning --
hypothetical consistency (a model's ability to predict what its output would be
in a hypothetical other context) and compositional consistency (consistency of
a model's final outputs when intermediate sub-steps are replaced with the
model's outputs for those steps). We demonstrate that multiple variants of the
GPT-3/-4 models exhibit poor consistency rates across both types of consistency
on a variety of tasks. | [
-0.0606304221,
-0.599632442,
1.2669283152,
0.5948089957,
0.2224564403,
0.0928156227,
0.0036960305,
-0.1947573125,
-0.1186473221,
0.2768913805,
-0.4988631904,
-0.1074076071,
-0.7425057292,
0.3492001593,
-0.5769620538,
0.8287482262,
-0.6098926663,
0.0537131801,
-0.3330016434,
-0.218436867,
-0.6832453609,
-0.5585584044,
-0.5316051841,
-0.7608593702,
0.7953745723,
0.3637033701,
0.5769608617,
0.6896798611,
0.4600409865,
0.3072804213,
0.3659959733,
0.1916986406,
-0.1499507725,
0.5902618766,
-0.1857193112,
-0.3249926269,
-0.3666279912,
0.2889610231,
0.6989827156,
0.3993317187,
-0.2581367791,
-0.2416423708,
0.3156463802,
0.4836378992,
-0.3818417192,
0.1937103122,
-0.3911025822,
-0.2333017588,
0.0166153722,
0.0531238727,
-0.2507352829,
-0.0417669527,
-0.2712708116,
-0.3604995906,
0.033308316,
-0.1784648746,
0.448350668,
0.3535104394,
-0.5502963662,
-0.4316192567,
-0.8098094463,
0.686316967,
-0.9333258867,
0.4660506546,
0.3578726947,
0.2515336573,
-0.3267357647,
-0.439745158,
-0.6071112156,
-0.3355607092,
-0.1736964732,
0.1239860728,
0.2691855729,
0.0428287834,
0.4062646925,
0.1024681553,
-0.3699192405,
0.0399965085,
-0.0312625058,
-0.1935236752,
0.3628775179,
0.3122056425,
0.0808555409,
-0.2679383755,
-0.2461807728,
0.1320336461,
-0.8333132863,
-0.1679964513,
0.3428396881,
0.5317487717,
-0.0751237869,
0.763776958,
-0.2786799967,
0.6703600883,
0.2070182711,
-0.8443557024,
0.0294364635,
-0.9035288692,
-0.1882634759,
-0.3218820691,
0.7539442778,
-0.1025298014,
0.1840402484,
0.0089782905,
-0.4087779522,
0.0214135945,
0.1288208961,
-0.4789934754,
-0.1354464293,
0.6597576141,
-0.2064455003,
0.2784210742,
-0.1006952599,
0.1409319341,
-0.2468417585,
-0.6366346478,
0.9095155597,
-0.4929786623,
-0.0811073929,
0.2001532912,
0.2293054163,
0.0708666742,
0.641061604,
-0.8695267439,
0.102843605,
0.9195730686,
0.8840575814,
-0.2216906846,
-1.0349478722,
-0.4114694297,
0.3329808414,
-0.6698703766,
0.6956678629,
-0.4928962588,
-0.1275002509,
-0.1832820922,
-0.0423021279,
-0.4248230159,
-0.3632955253,
0.5426718593,
0.0233567487,
-0.0029720343,
-0.7417189479,
-0.8152176738,
-0.0573331453,
0.5055215955,
-0.4538932443,
0.8680447936,
-0.1599416137,
-0.5222986341,
0.4538453817,
-0.291305244,
-0.5084886551,
-0.2239379883,
-0.4360415339,
-0.1808460206,
0.2078893334,
-0.3420726359,
0.6121688485,
0.0023860733,
0.2819003463,
-0.47862643,
-0.5094223619,
0.0411662944,
-0.4728557467,
0.4687252343,
-0.0029447924,
-0.3814904392,
-0.1539227068,
-0.6576247215,
-0.0429888628,
0.0705910549,
-0.6341386437,
-0.1132794991,
0.2855416238,
-0.5638135076,
0.6562476158,
0.4259774089,
-0.5648322105,
0.4909729064,
0.2839104235,
0.3587353528,
0.7383887768,
-0.1652621627,
0.1411936283,
-0.5715247393,
0.2672546804,
0.4314379394,
-0.068125993,
-0.5140078068,
-0.6693879962,
-0.8795539141,
-0.136721611,
0.1731708944,
0.4861491919,
-0.3789661527,
0.0613176785,
-0.014728887,
-0.5088968277,
-0.1761840135,
0.2787945569,
0.5584241152,
0.3564653993,
0.32153669,
-0.1180280298,
-0.3364565969,
-0.9295461774,
-0.50025177,
-0.0693538412,
0.2978215814,
0.0138691254,
0.7480637431,
-0.3293895125,
0.6185924411,
0.0462306216,
-0.2579255104,
-0.1602377594,
0.3453613818,
0.2486790121,
0.7546983957,
0.2352951765,
-0.2973947227,
-0.5155491233,
-0.3121372759,
-0.779039979,
0.1245778948,
-0.2270876765,
-0.0107543571,
0.1717482209,
0.4201985002,
-0.7714164853,
0.2042997032,
0.7693254352,
-0.08712589,
0.6791080236,
-0.5548456311,
0.4624321163,
-0.8801563978,
-0.5299782157,
0.2093404084,
-0.3178726137,
-0.7507437468,
-0.0954007879,
0.1947961301,
0.4465366304,
-0.2547521889,
0.3841129243,
-0.436733216,
-0.2511921227,
-0.3090890646,
-0.0006513589,
0.1633158773,
0.1747822315,
-0.1007813066,
0.8733995557,
0.6629514694,
-0.6514815092,
0.4348664284,
-0.0444818996,
0.0289869178,
0.7364199162,
-0.8395892382,
0.3416315913,
-0.0586692877,
0.4001867473,
-1.236890316,
-0.3545184731,
0.1897923201,
-0.0218813177,
0.2777126431,
-0.2504961491,
-0.8269832134,
-0.3531527519,
-0.1617864519,
0.3884214163,
0.1114829183,
-0.4633285105,
0.7971923947,
-0.300088048,
0.1245179623,
-0.6690862179,
-0.7394776344,
-0.1448674053,
-0.0387598574,
-0.489648819,
0.0429409109,
-0.431848377,
-0.1397687495,
-0.1700948775,
-0.3244582117,
0.032451231,
-0.1056497917,
0.3201708496,
-0.0375034809,
-0.0828943998,
-0.0502931923,
-0.301523,
-0.0358146466,
-0.118993409,
-0.2694402933,
0.3685509264,
-0.2501713037,
-1.1238600016,
-0.4880056083,
0.5139681697,
0.7644143105,
0.1427538842,
0.5652992725,
0.228562668,
-0.5220521092,
0.0723484755,
-0.7577217817,
-0.1140642241,
-0.3721168935,
-0.0630843565,
-0.9526197314,
-0.8209639788,
0.728422761,
0.2941573262,
0.1985573173,
0.5475879312,
0.4604604244,
-0.511334002,
1.068256855,
0.3888278902,
0.2791308165,
-0.1503418237,
0.0775508657,
0.4310930967,
-0.8145610094,
-0.32566154,
-0.5566159487,
-0.124102354,
-0.7857889533,
-0.3941991329,
0.2741259933,
0.0042932685,
-0.5523828268,
0.4745216668,
-0.0310058445,
0.5061333179,
0.6994775534,
-0.1015464887,
0.546702981,
-0.3256011307,
-0.394112885,
0.0113057047,
-0.6908944845,
-0.5974591374,
0.8674294949,
0.2887195349,
0.9961070418,
0.2047469169,
1.0746200085,
0.0643660724,
0.1316237897,
-0.6368994713,
0.369612515,
-0.1608605385,
-0.848859489,
-0.5084878206,
-0.3093211949,
-0.8403468728,
0.5054196119,
0.1267510355,
-0.5853497386,
0.0129275611,
0.4315025508,
-0.2817534506,
0.1497068554,
-0.4766498506,
1.0373648405,
-0.2515639961,
-0.2395785749,
0.0365068279,
-0.6092604995,
0.697776258,
-0.2808121443,
0.2923828065,
-0.3581945598,
0.137903899,
0.3587303758,
-0.3429590464,
0.8544787169,
0.0217551552,
-0.2607784867,
0.2459888607,
0.4238339961,
0.7378016114,
-0.2700329125,
0.2604085803,
0.0185420737,
0.2535340488,
-0.4002017379,
-0.6683930755,
0.7012607455,
-0.5735018253,
-0.9896783829,
-0.6192506552,
-0.4660140574,
-0.316795826,
0.1430204511,
0.1316088736,
0.555513978,
0.2946827412,
0.0967018902,
0.5955629349,
0.4066622853,
0.6144099236,
0.3901333213,
-0.1916313171,
-0.0337903835,
0.6436802745,
0.4230801165,
0.6349070072,
-0.0166529138,
0.0501579791,
-0.4504790008,
-0.657371223,
-0.449955076,
0.5095643401,
-1.1198447943,
-0.1409448683,
-0.6151021719,
-0.2128063738,
-0.3124082983,
0.0251897704,
-0.6385500431,
-0.2252638042,
-0.1868874431,
0.0361211635,
-0.1827320606,
1.1534743309,
-0.3786016107,
-0.1043522954,
-0.750120759,
0.5415890813,
0.5292955041,
0.4051225483,
-0.058438845,
-0.6613731384,
-0.1010106504,
-0.0125622135,
-0.2515944242,
-0.9756838679,
-0.2581808567,
0.0635045022,
0.7417228818,
0.2341806144,
-0.4765159488,
0.7075300813,
-0.7636861801,
0.7420968413,
0.3224058449,
-1.0400805473,
0.4000923932,
-0.4710198343,
0.3668627143,
0.5384988785,
0.5496065617,
-0.613391459,
-0.6350632906,
-0.602375567,
-0.4653822482,
0.3820199072,
0.1091032773,
0.0540604703,
-0.1870722026,
0.4477403462,
0.2215753496,
-0.003802378,
-0.9962341785,
-0.2099864781,
-0.3194124103,
-0.0431072228,
-0.0929327905,
-0.426497668,
-0.2887724638,
0.0383858122,
0.6771057844,
-0.3233380318,
-0.0874576047,
0.2533536553,
0.1707683206,
0.0666137114,
0.3791754544,
0.8734596968,
0.9886980653,
0.1076281145,
0.4880574942,
0.0105354441,
-0.0738878995,
0.718740344,
-0.2155723423,
-0.1171972901,
-0.1718146354,
0.4507441521,
0.3477508128,
0.207136184,
-0.2050135136,
0.5852296948,
0.1536384523,
-0.2770103514,
-0.3162470162,
0.0771665052,
0.3753573298,
0.3262704313,
0.1975656748,
0.0806653202,
0.057870172,
-0.9164406061,
0.0980170518,
0.4597894251,
0.04982071,
-0.1601713151,
0.6166704297,
-0.3345220983,
-0.0671566874,
0.483374536,
-0.4155841768,
-0.3439268172,
0.4647226632,
0.6421729326,
0.7663546205,
-0.3917454183,
0.1911921203,
0.3662863374,
0.4195155203,
-0.769099772,
0.4464806616,
0.203682214,
-0.9016885161,
-0.768548727,
-0.5704678893,
-0.6701255441,
0.0429264754,
-0.1880241781,
0.116775617,
-0.3217743337,
-0.039272476,
-0.0795588642,
-0.3880314827,
-0.5519769788,
0.4478867352,
-0.0076380093,
0.5641528368,
-0.9977416396,
0.7466911077,
0.4070037901,
-0.5642695427,
-1.2621994019,
0.0538181812,
0.1162682921,
-0.6458070874,
0.6552190185,
0.0486281849,
-0.3457858562,
-0.4357783794,
-0.2911992669,
-1.3315821886,
1.1082395315,
0.4410735071,
-0.6156394482,
-0.0906124637,
0.0411507264,
0.3719991446,
-0.7076166868,
0.1732684821,
0.6745887995,
0.8077359796,
0.3641164899,
-1.2833324671,
0.1673987359,
0.5458008647,
0.0598465912,
-0.1028017849,
-0.8070924282,
1.1746356487,
-0.4746437371,
-0.0096947011,
0.0575676486,
0.549151063,
0.8719519377,
0.0851526335,
0.342066884,
0.7979943752,
0.6419557929,
-0.3586095572,
1.2014893293,
-0.1851789504,
0.4003552198,
1.3089967966,
-0.3659147322,
0.7908979654,
0.1701334566,
-0.3517290354,
0.5227000713,
0.716594696,
0.1098360047,
0.2566945255,
-0.0240563117,
-0.0238479469,
-0.5544307828,
0.4285334945,
-0.1443210095,
0.7092636228,
0.0035453674,
-0.1367910057,
-0.1510425508,
-0.2709087729,
0.2072345167,
-0.2455404103,
-0.1748472452,
0.360586971,
0.0697201937,
-0.9586929083,
0.5779295564,
-0.0104150744,
0.3144793808,
-0.3292874694,
0.0107780434,
-0.2635346353,
-0.0573962219,
-0.4549073279,
-0.9700005054,
0.2883989811,
-0.3658173382,
-0.3223798275,
-0.2562710643,
0.6013995409,
-0.4788919687,
-0.3658896983,
0.2932609618,
0.962849021,
0.3988078833,
-0.0238959678,
-0.7007958889,
0.1504679322,
-0.2573176622,
-0.2683818936,
0.2035221308,
0.536160171,
0.2782331109,
0.7298452854,
0.2972140908,
-0.0725244433,
0.3194755018,
0.3505359888,
0.3995488882,
-0.6243069172,
0.0506422073,
-1.065222621,
0.3801733553,
0.2524689436,
-0.0486537591,
1.0346660614,
0.62684232,
0.6388584971,
0.0574697852,
0.8050550222,
0.2903994918,
0.4994291365,
-0.6727278829,
-0.0890721679,
-0.61878407,
0.16639705,
-0.1626028121,
-1.1199420691,
-0.0305964127,
0.5228550434,
-0.1208188087,
0.6416739225,
1.2515289783,
0.3513239622,
-0.2138166577,
-0.1615528762,
0.7135298848,
0.3193876147,
0.1908386201,
0.5620606542,
0.8898587227,
-0.2530709803,
0.280010134,
-0.0399589017,
-0.0295925569,
0.0511388518,
-1.1365884542,
-0.5753688216,
-0.6635944843,
-0.4613969028,
-0.4971831143,
-0.0662586465,
0.7108421922,
0.7633869648,
-0.7586767673,
-0.1838169843,
-0.2087872177,
0.1745507121,
-0.251052916,
-0.0794449747,
-0.1340705901,
-0.7796798944,
-0.6754399538,
0.5959587097,
0.7485583425,
0.3477451503,
-0.620921433,
-0.0394919701,
-0.1278411299,
0.4253939092,
0.4236746132,
0.2849389613,
-1.2997978926,
-0.6185603142,
-0.1933261305,
-0.3577964902,
0.355799228,
0.8037697077,
-0.4316783547,
0.2725484073,
0.3652876318,
0.3155113459,
0.5737423897,
0.1198888496,
0.296223104,
-0.3921783268,
-0.4972329438,
0.0711586401,
0.9624736309,
0.6314128637,
-0.1662324965,
0.4391975701,
0.3541823924,
-0.9355297685,
-0.2867210209,
0.616169095,
-0.8616390228,
-0.2153178751,
1.3436529636,
-0.4463346303,
0.1459828764,
-0.1479085386,
0.1753225923,
-0.1323000789,
-0.1250191033,
0.4683202505,
1.3240389824,
-0.8219721913,
-0.1924006343,
-0.6324918866,
0.3662356734,
0.3697511256,
-0.6699030399,
0.1644092798,
0.7567548156,
0.7606201172,
0.4392377138,
0.9852616191,
0.0483395793,
0.0333722308,
-0.0416473858,
-0.5202108026,
0.3666816056,
-0.8499950171,
-0.2306454927,
0.2389491647,
0.3500211239,
0.1152250543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14268v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14268v1 | Masked Path Modeling for Vision-and-Language Navigation | 2023-05-23T17:20:20 | 2023-05-23T17:20:20 | Zi-Yi Dou, Feng Gao, Nanyun Peng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Vision-and-language navigation (VLN) agents are trained to navigate in
real-world environments by following natural language instructions. A major
challenge in VLN is the limited availability of training data, which hinders
the models' ability to generalize effectively. Previous approaches have
attempted to address this issue by introducing additional supervision during
training, often requiring costly human-annotated data that restricts
scalability. In this paper, we introduce a masked path modeling (MPM)
objective, which pretrains an agent using self-collected data for downstream
navigation tasks. Our proposed method involves allowing the agent to actively
explore navigation environments without a specific goal and collect the paths
it traverses. Subsequently, we train the agent on this collected data to
reconstruct the original path given a randomly masked subpath. This way, the
agent can actively accumulate a diverse and substantial amount of data while
learning conditional action generation. To evaluate the effectiveness of our
technique, we conduct experiments on various VLN datasets and demonstrate the
versatility of MPM across different levels of instruction complexity. Our
results exhibit significant improvements in success rates, with enhancements of
1.32\%, 1.05\%, and 1.19\% on the val-unseen split of the Room-to-Room,
Room-for-Room, and Room-across-Room datasets, respectively. Furthermore, we
conduct an analysis that highlights the potential for additional improvements
when the agent is allowed to explore unseen environments prior to testing. | [
-0.2437768579,
-0.5474047661,
0.6102751493,
-0.0883737206,
-0.2694380581,
0.0736438334,
-0.0441523641,
-0.1911402643,
0.4135905206,
0.9960199594,
-0.9152555466,
-0.7506935,
-0.4520380199,
-0.3142094612,
-0.0295607075,
0.7562581897,
-0.0785636529,
-0.1980057061,
-0.2281452417,
0.0518191829,
-0.7218289971,
-0.4786293805,
-0.5059530139,
-0.2895087302,
0.5035758018,
0.2642668784,
0.6663723588,
0.7900593877,
0.4069162011,
0.3051102757,
0.3528924584,
0.3980837762,
-0.2961511314,
0.2860373855,
-0.302728951,
-0.2707952857,
-0.429513514,
0.0738197938,
0.6958754659,
0.6167097092,
-0.1159870699,
-0.039153222,
-0.1039814055,
0.6868524551,
-0.8525930047,
0.4580442905,
-0.1989931613,
0.4684612751,
0.0479204245,
-0.2412875742,
-0.3389350772,
0.0408266112,
0.41099298,
-0.7907265425,
0.0392592512,
0.0775477961,
0.7095700502,
0.4594430625,
-0.5675131083,
-0.1788720042,
-0.8333515525,
0.6199287176,
-0.1333403736,
0.5344772339,
0.5174239278,
0.589440763,
-0.2019248158,
-0.7346807122,
-0.2568657696,
-0.3942555189,
-0.3219083846,
0.4026963413,
-0.2266980708,
0.2596370876,
0.2240640819,
-0.2251906246,
-0.5489011407,
-0.0837333873,
-0.4861012697,
-0.4092636108,
0.6300751567,
0.3325319588,
0.3041324615,
-0.099520795,
-0.61906147,
-0.3065531552,
-0.5721056461,
0.2514844835,
0.2082501054,
0.4191227555,
-0.0267073009,
0.4485307634,
-0.6282147169,
1.0356681347,
-0.3047817945,
-0.2497734725,
0.1806402206,
-0.4146277606,
-0.2286170125,
0.1135653406,
0.2782960236,
0.3171228766,
0.2452451587,
-0.274858892,
-0.4113799334,
-0.1498720646,
0.5280536413,
-0.6475830674,
-0.5343171954,
0.0400819369,
-0.0762177482,
-0.0749688148,
-0.1120016202,
-0.5533357263,
-0.6389971375,
-0.4683178961,
0.7608575225,
-0.2149226069,
-0.3170540035,
0.2530859113,
-0.0677404702,
0.5976791978,
0.5980997086,
-0.4652425051,
0.3275010288,
0.4266403913,
0.8787534833,
-0.1021560356,
-0.225198999,
-0.9577819109,
0.1000938416,
-0.3563709557,
0.3720767796,
-0.5685739517,
-0.3225397468,
-0.0419675224,
0.0481381752,
-0.328223139,
-0.3515129387,
0.1129576117,
-0.3170546889,
0.0715033859,
-0.1456547379,
-0.1354384124,
-0.4595187306,
0.4971759617,
-0.4530318081,
0.6852566004,
0.0050283587,
-0.1778171211,
0.3892846406,
-0.7658727169,
-0.5201554894,
0.3036121428,
-0.2667136192,
-0.5131289959,
-0.134097442,
0.3755858839,
0.3876768351,
0.2061768025,
0.2592314184,
0.3563256562,
-0.4523540139,
-0.1720361114,
-0.4077741504,
0.6989319324,
-0.155873701,
-0.9364597201,
0.0484933332,
-0.6861440539,
-0.0221575275,
-0.0403685383,
-0.2844779491,
-0.4998144805,
0.38299793,
-0.4160068333,
0.3590047956,
0.0508975387,
-0.5201635957,
0.3108304143,
-0.2423950285,
-0.2816248834,
0.9550452232,
0.1463038176,
0.4924201369,
-0.2075953037,
0.8900588155,
0.0778040886,
0.4190998077,
-0.2531778216,
-0.69304353,
-1.241956234,
-0.4288588166,
-0.0124888103,
0.5269870162,
-1.166020751,
0.0979093015,
-0.2682874501,
-0.3229193091,
-0.4096911848,
-0.1235296875,
0.7815420032,
0.5838497877,
0.4664427936,
-0.5299504399,
-0.5452773571,
-0.4764434397,
-0.0253969561,
-0.0629724115,
0.0304222684,
0.7143816948,
0.3717757761,
-0.4832214117,
0.9690490365,
-0.5407904387,
-0.4693253338,
-0.2304783911,
-0.0929427668,
-0.1237239018,
0.6478253007,
0.1700058728,
-0.9578693509,
-0.4375824332,
-0.1093620807,
-0.771299839,
-0.0935937241,
-0.3421068192,
-0.4307533205,
-0.0532151274,
0.7088647485,
-0.4330349863,
1.0607407093,
0.4113961458,
-0.3255619705,
0.233105734,
-0.2181941271,
-0.0618292242,
-0.4940193295,
-0.1916434467,
-0.0478446037,
-0.4209059179,
-0.8782837391,
0.1156653166,
-0.1414047331,
-0.3232812881,
-0.6456072927,
0.6639270186,
-0.7945322394,
-0.2017938793,
-0.2824386656,
0.0171750076,
-0.0965930894,
1.0051008463,
0.5897787809,
0.3803161085,
0.9031597376,
-0.7348136902,
0.322480917,
-0.0745824054,
-0.082650274,
0.2525127828,
-0.2709181309,
0.1903595924,
-0.3156067431,
0.2438789159,
-0.7445502281,
-0.0638253763,
0.7336938977,
-0.2189530134,
0.3248962164,
-0.47172153,
-0.1075773761,
-0.0177776404,
-0.0973710492,
0.2571713924,
0.7290376425,
-0.5568698645,
1.0498641729,
0.1460376233,
0.2841929197,
-0.4902158976,
-0.316578716,
0.1311077178,
-0.0490302332,
-0.412404865,
0.0875350758,
-0.1906843334,
-0.1834893078,
-0.2410065681,
-0.3505685925,
0.1916462928,
0.1025090516,
0.8339158297,
0.3655363619,
-0.1350385845,
-0.0657565072,
-0.1808722615,
-0.272356391,
0.1812421381,
-0.6314114928,
0.5709283948,
-0.0502685793,
-0.6138014793,
-0.0893307105,
0.2455996573,
0.2036841065,
-0.5007854104,
0.7392868996,
0.4771151245,
-0.318164885,
-0.4241882861,
-0.2280631363,
-0.1595638394,
-0.5993726254,
0.1978835166,
-0.3252240419,
-0.6215993762,
0.1947326362,
-0.1530767381,
-0.0064637228,
-0.0059150313,
0.1830992401,
-0.0246883165,
0.8964626789,
0.8645710349,
0.4671764374,
0.4961239696,
-0.4397473037,
0.2493258715,
-0.7057635188,
-0.7001843452,
0.047823526,
-0.2365586311,
-0.6369131804,
-0.7240124345,
0.6617343426,
-0.2346108109,
-0.0983326137,
0.3183315098,
-0.5990903974,
0.4862047732,
0.9308369756,
0.4026407599,
0.071327202,
0.080027625,
-0.3023695648,
0.1240945458,
-0.9008567333,
-0.2193958163,
1.0335931778,
0.2340694815,
0.6532108784,
-0.0039191814,
0.9088174105,
0.3203955591,
0.2239432931,
-0.7657558918,
0.9273297787,
0.2648629248,
-0.5160947442,
-0.524289906,
-0.3180793524,
-0.9454017282,
0.5604344606,
-0.1499878317,
-0.7346948385,
0.3265258968,
0.2940386832,
-0.3460747302,
0.2547577322,
-0.8472807407,
0.7917368412,
-0.395984292,
-0.5556243062,
0.4352843165,
-0.9457153678,
0.2300162613,
-0.0999466181,
-0.0644370019,
0.1041250676,
-0.0886801258,
0.6073004603,
-0.3707578778,
0.9618602991,
-0.4994443953,
0.236837849,
0.3030590415,
0.1659265012,
0.69743222,
-0.1688164473,
0.3635014594,
0.2399102449,
-0.6673921943,
-0.3726831973,
-0.5951623321,
0.3034683764,
-0.4807596207,
-0.9399181604,
-0.7274065018,
-0.3797872365,
-0.2970059812,
0.1436841786,
0.093600288,
0.4072926939,
0.2732866406,
0.055455707,
0.6429635882,
-0.5333641171,
0.5422608256,
1.1275993586,
-0.1808551848,
0.1936707795,
1.0508977175,
0.2166647464,
0.3287747502,
0.4625846744,
0.0803950205,
-0.1689981669,
-0.6406034231,
-0.3357682228,
-0.0971072391,
-0.5403942466,
0.007406665,
-0.586440742,
-0.5888020992,
-0.17835325,
-0.2513304651,
-0.3599884212,
0.0157453325,
-0.1130231693,
-0.2255509645,
0.1056074947,
0.4904246926,
-0.46787709,
0.2637265325,
-0.3228174746,
0.2630305886,
0.6855447292,
0.1160624176,
-0.0994566455,
-0.1665574312,
-0.3016260266,
0.1698947102,
-0.0251960009,
-0.5672169328,
0.556034565,
0.0849997178,
0.6649010777,
0.1065818295,
0.2503503263,
0.6413111687,
-0.5903499126,
0.6503440738,
0.0185201839,
-0.5184000134,
0.9285688996,
-0.2871600091,
0.4440509975,
0.3660748899,
0.317884922,
-0.2570102513,
-0.4775587022,
-0.3613171577,
-0.9470389485,
0.8589895964,
0.6261857748,
-0.0872078687,
0.461296469,
0.149870649,
-0.2720419765,
0.2188335359,
-0.9286426902,
-0.2219174057,
-0.3351825774,
0.219610393,
-0.3255009353,
0.0818611085,
-0.1205738932,
-0.2493070215,
0.5216398239,
0.0079840794,
0.1431258321,
0.3467404842,
-0.2017783821,
0.0960359052,
-0.1053942218,
0.6614557505,
0.6355443001,
-0.4328481853,
0.4303539395,
-0.1010661572,
-0.8192486167,
0.2663707137,
0.0966932997,
-0.2975358665,
0.0412788987,
0.5329953432,
0.9054983854,
-0.2183282673,
-0.7755271792,
0.6184666753,
0.0320772342,
0.0059845559,
-0.3129606545,
0.5161610842,
-0.3102577627,
0.3545049131,
0.3603293598,
0.2285370082,
0.1302249581,
-0.4382301271,
0.3667929471,
0.2488979846,
-0.7931001782,
-0.0659117475,
0.472394824,
0.1345674247,
-0.6508328319,
0.7097014189,
-0.3441778123,
-0.5703636408,
0.7227997184,
0.1520843804,
0.9572972655,
-0.2607040703,
0.4547381699,
0.1095771343,
0.8249331117,
0.2712872922,
-0.0762861967,
-0.4053683877,
-0.418862313,
-0.0542888269,
-0.7453790903,
-0.308632195,
-0.0168013535,
-0.432159245,
-0.0532713607,
-0.2791479826,
0.105967015,
-0.4076562226,
-0.1027574092,
-0.8797380924,
0.640278101,
0.1995394677,
0.5416609645,
-0.7177277803,
0.8287866116,
0.5102026463,
-0.3782992959,
-0.8993700147,
0.2159718722,
-0.0111771924,
-1.0095603466,
0.5794135332,
0.2491015792,
-0.4729150832,
-0.0609447844,
-0.3981590569,
-0.7443436384,
1.1567461491,
0.1871627271,
-0.5786901712,
-0.0089119673,
0.3147357404,
0.4994212091,
-0.5047020316,
0.0244634394,
0.3416894972,
0.3763941526,
0.1639884412,
-0.559099853,
0.0642844439,
-0.2466307282,
-0.0623295605,
0.1818648875,
-0.5666367412,
0.8274259567,
-0.1208608747,
-0.214871034,
-0.2475381941,
0.2158678621,
0.2861075103,
0.5111496449,
0.6339649558,
0.1529024988,
0.3057489991,
-0.0160568263,
0.982606113,
-0.0122255199,
0.0367356539,
1.150408268,
-0.1204150319,
0.4344778955,
0.341751188,
0.3901237249,
0.4486975372,
0.5182729363,
0.216878742,
1.0358924866,
0.4048930109,
-0.3908364475,
-0.6198020577,
-0.1754971445,
-0.1469895095,
0.7182279229,
0.120536156,
-0.3227548897,
-0.1569434404,
0.3458360434,
-0.0306105707,
-0.1362407804,
-0.6240022779,
0.6508285999,
-0.0852080509,
-0.8520156741,
0.3702184558,
-0.076477088,
0.2741703391,
-0.8362198472,
-0.4297193587,
-0.5858691931,
-0.0666634515,
-0.016261721,
-0.429549396,
0.0121943355,
-0.0094290664,
0.2686010301,
-0.5052391887,
0.9796670675,
-0.3901190162,
-0.4951340854,
0.2949337363,
0.5013538599,
0.1492467225,
-0.083655715,
-0.3085743189,
-0.0941529572,
0.1723017246,
-0.2647003829,
0.2832656503,
0.1361798048,
-0.1062209383,
0.9486348629,
0.5782437921,
-0.0000920116,
0.3986513615,
-0.2619957924,
0.9310443997,
-0.688275516,
-0.6158638597,
-0.6837924719,
0.8326807618,
-0.11452014,
-0.0892652348,
0.8225829005,
0.5388226509,
0.7474361658,
0.016212374,
0.4593183398,
0.3105545938,
0.1121066958,
-0.8334666491,
0.6415069699,
-0.5425966382,
0.3945188522,
-0.2647304535,
-0.7626051307,
-0.0337123796,
0.7122141123,
-0.2841048241,
0.1732478887,
0.3796515167,
0.9236903191,
-0.4066728652,
-0.6674063206,
0.4648375213,
-0.1599014997,
0.2994575202,
0.8625203967,
0.8891252279,
-0.2708421648,
0.4991495311,
-0.2521083057,
-0.281619966,
-0.1001478806,
-0.7444742918,
-0.978208065,
-0.5856097937,
-0.52648592,
-0.1833343208,
0.4324825406,
0.35893327,
1.1386393309,
-0.2702517807,
-0.1782765836,
-0.3187106848,
0.2801591158,
-0.1410800517,
-0.1744530797,
0.1881587952,
-0.022817051,
-0.4126787484,
0.6561496854,
0.5352253318,
0.1882664859,
-0.5813153982,
-0.3626812994,
-0.1390924603,
0.244822681,
0.4853619337,
0.3880279958,
-0.6122508645,
-0.4963316619,
-0.0016742643,
-0.0252484679,
-0.0093060648,
0.5917323232,
-1.0885968208,
0.9991003871,
-0.0501991957,
0.394785732,
0.9608381987,
-0.1494071037,
0.593419373,
-1.0716422796,
0.2149513513,
0.2750607729,
0.1003086567,
0.1985516995,
-0.349119544,
0.744066,
0.1519666165,
-0.100281395,
-0.7657340169,
0.2195032984,
-0.9263860583,
-0.1215780452,
1.2504540682,
-0.3742585182,
-0.1992132962,
-0.0666959584,
-0.2907731533,
0.1636082977,
-0.0721555501,
0.4833706915,
0.1925403029,
-0.2059103101,
-0.2824674547,
-0.6124807,
0.6836255193,
0.0481454544,
-0.7136597037,
-0.3385656476,
0.5607936978,
0.0445767753,
0.2014190406,
0.8461632729,
0.3994315863,
0.3213678598,
0.1388844848,
-0.171986118,
-0.4762087166,
-0.8386356235,
-0.1357471347,
0.1481703967,
-0.5186015368,
-0.8112236261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14264v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14264v2 | Active Learning Principles for In-Context Learning with Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T17:16:04 | 2023-11-22T10:22:18 | Katerina Margatina, Timo Schick, Nikolaos Aletras, Jane Dwivedi-Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The remarkable advancements in large language models (LLMs) have
significantly enhanced the performance in few-shot learning settings. By using
only a small number of labeled examples, referred to as demonstrations, LLMs
can effectively grasp the task at hand through in-context learning. However,
the process of selecting appropriate demonstrations has received limited
attention in prior work. This paper addresses the issue of identifying the most
informative demonstrations for few-shot learning by approaching it as a
pool-based Active Learning (AL) problem over a single iteration. Our objective
is to investigate how AL algorithms can serve as effective demonstration
selection methods for in-context learning. We compare various standard AL
algorithms based on uncertainty, diversity, and similarity, and consistently
observe that the latter outperforms all other methods, including random
sampling. Notably, uncertainty sampling, despite its success in conventional
supervised learning scenarios, performs poorly in this context. Our extensive
experimentation involving a diverse range of GPT and OPT models across $24$
classification and multi-choice tasks, coupled with thorough analysis,
unambiguously demonstrates that in-context example selection through AL
prioritizes high-quality examples that exhibit low uncertainty and bear
similarity to the test examples. | [
-0.1988760084,
-1.1209700108,
0.5270011425,
-0.0406615026,
-0.2740992904,
-0.1839564741,
-0.2682027221,
-0.3618405759,
-0.297988236,
-0.054141622,
-0.2837490439,
-0.5266804099,
-0.2693589628,
-0.127456665,
-0.4683385193,
0.6174699068,
-0.3767096996,
-0.0767774507,
-0.0265739411,
-0.2710998058,
-0.0763725713,
-0.0071174651,
-0.9214681983,
-0.3029076159,
0.2831555009,
0.7174693346,
0.5336663127,
0.6097910404,
0.0929385498,
0.2723062634,
-0.0082569234,
0.3732169271,
-0.3492470086,
0.3339588642,
0.0507924818,
-0.4643542171,
0.3274922669,
0.2963806987,
0.923545301,
0.7474938631,
0.0217108373,
0.0475777425,
0.0761805177,
0.3292217255,
-1.0365700722,
0.0818927512,
-0.7167798877,
0.3179110587,
-0.0959304199,
0.1842752248,
-0.4039051235,
-0.1257184148,
0.2434774488,
-0.5412054062,
0.1599697024,
0.1230515689,
0.707727313,
0.1196360439,
-0.5182199478,
-0.3578392565,
-0.9488905668,
1.1301301718,
-0.5742826462,
0.1128088534,
0.4809059799,
0.4935944676,
0.0021121411,
-0.7926084995,
-0.499230057,
-0.2657055557,
0.1595136225,
0.2201914489,
-0.2619372308,
0.0414473303,
0.1577611268,
0.2584565282,
-0.2716401219,
0.4510298967,
-0.2519515157,
-0.1765805781,
0.5240789652,
-0.2348481268,
0.0413294286,
0.0822280571,
-0.5254049301,
-0.2502717674,
-0.9352282882,
0.2296495736,
0.2976472676,
0.4660494328,
-0.0520435423,
0.5331311226,
-0.3224597573,
0.9880590439,
-0.0895053148,
-0.1873815209,
0.0663862005,
-0.0247298051,
-0.4326393902,
-0.1264498234,
0.6429206729,
-0.2680966258,
-0.2277867049,
0.0667586178,
-0.4802086353,
-0.2580007017,
-0.1040677056,
-0.5362896919,
-0.0723761171,
0.3355672359,
-0.3974873722,
-0.0977817625,
0.2610543072,
-0.613555789,
-0.3246868551,
-0.0575679727,
0.9054825306,
-0.2828028798,
-0.0431408957,
-0.077987127,
0.0863829628,
0.0926958993,
0.5147810578,
-0.4539502859,
0.3088596165,
0.4194951952,
0.75631392,
-0.4588553905,
-0.3661656976,
-0.9237223268,
-0.0034533571,
-0.3619527817,
0.782602489,
-0.5101670623,
0.0661420003,
0.3729562461,
-0.3727120161,
-0.2790677547,
-0.601123631,
0.2592834234,
-0.5734372139,
0.3263591528,
0.0115473894,
-0.7950078845,
-0.3354350924,
0.1037476137,
-0.7444949746,
0.8372070193,
0.0701961964,
-0.484349966,
0.5340087414,
-0.6826315522,
-0.3664419949,
0.072519049,
-0.4240808189,
-0.738886714,
-0.030735584,
-0.0597943254,
0.7092897892,
0.3919782043,
-0.3946653903,
-0.3577601016,
-0.6882286072,
0.3836486936,
-0.5667611957,
0.4669085443,
0.5439178348,
-0.6543874741,
0.246721819,
-0.4457930923,
0.0795799941,
0.0618696064,
-0.3340430856,
-0.283983618,
0.0656890646,
-0.2073520124,
0.2262789458,
-0.1157168075,
-0.2137246579,
0.0843259469,
-0.2380052507,
0.1973890215,
0.5517954826,
0.3926834166,
0.6405854821,
-0.3851675987,
0.645703733,
-0.1167374775,
0.1607094854,
-0.201464951,
-0.3468025327,
-0.4970273674,
-0.6093552709,
0.3008754253,
0.3843853772,
-0.7293739319,
0.1180012971,
0.195738852,
-0.3046929538,
-0.3252088726,
0.5766169429,
0.3990947902,
0.2671304941,
0.2672756612,
-0.1241398975,
-0.0561014675,
-0.8601074219,
0.0322390348,
-0.2340212315,
0.1582461447,
0.4291690588,
0.2664964795,
0.0987224206,
0.8975675702,
-0.1702162325,
-0.1561174095,
-0.4469857812,
0.0836859494,
0.1309986264,
0.0730690882,
0.6197413206,
-0.8970051408,
-0.5806203485,
-0.169549197,
-0.5881384611,
0.0616064854,
-0.313654989,
-0.1024323776,
0.1118532345,
0.4542863965,
-0.4214304984,
0.5270803571,
0.5005245805,
-0.0176709313,
0.096238032,
-0.0419720076,
-0.0717006475,
-0.6285110712,
-0.2908251882,
0.1476604939,
-0.2313647121,
-0.454349339,
0.182080254,
0.2187976092,
0.0492163375,
-0.9558320045,
0.7787158489,
-0.6118144989,
-0.1215502843,
-0.4980261028,
0.1577768773,
-0.2511042058,
0.3075043559,
0.1477274299,
0.6095770001,
0.966227591,
-0.8295224905,
0.3008215129,
0.0150016993,
-0.6607291698,
-0.0137009928,
-0.2704929709,
0.0640432686,
-0.0818189159,
0.2597951889,
-1.1637052298,
-0.2272026539,
0.0685776249,
0.0301016532,
0.4460332394,
-0.2351691574,
-0.3295362592,
-0.156321317,
-0.3533638716,
0.2641095817,
0.6388927102,
-0.6440867782,
0.2559903562,
0.1184268743,
0.0144531643,
-0.8666856885,
-0.3852784038,
-0.465351969,
-0.3925891221,
-0.0249289814,
0.0423618034,
0.042699758,
-0.5758782029,
-0.2693579197,
-0.4098845124,
-0.0951704755,
0.376250118,
0.298027128,
-0.0315347239,
-0.0310048945,
0.3096904159,
0.2545907497,
0.23859483,
-0.4267259538,
-0.0503017418,
0.3334194422,
-0.1456386745,
-1.0193842649,
-0.3584163785,
0.3042178154,
0.224597767,
-0.0452744663,
0.5781449676,
0.5334652662,
-0.4030293226,
-0.7831875682,
-0.3106748462,
-0.2992118001,
-0.4046739936,
0.4830719531,
-0.0880556479,
-0.8403602242,
0.4070003629,
-0.1686475277,
0.4943965673,
0.145780623,
0.4465236962,
-0.2330683023,
0.6944432855,
0.3685443103,
-0.1089444533,
1.024356842,
-0.51620996,
0.0648217127,
-0.3320684433,
0.1753869951,
-0.3108186722,
-0.518586874,
-0.0454607569,
-0.5079912543,
0.3802608848,
0.3955886066,
-0.3211317062,
-0.0253056586,
-0.0267095491,
0.5769922733,
0.5950921178,
0.2982594967,
0.1931264549,
0.3320497274,
-0.1923448294,
0.2188559473,
-0.9037781954,
-0.7244105339,
0.8730288744,
0.3326803446,
0.8148498535,
0.3200519681,
0.8602250814,
0.1937689036,
0.4604358375,
-0.9488429427,
0.4903891683,
0.1477425843,
-0.7323445678,
-0.7001963854,
-0.252717644,
-1.2436407804,
0.3530055881,
-0.2914484441,
-0.6327564716,
0.1321930289,
0.2667798698,
-0.5359225273,
0.3511359394,
-0.8006308675,
0.6770880818,
-0.1642358005,
-0.7229444385,
-0.1136953235,
-0.6219420433,
0.240645498,
-0.2003111243,
0.398896575,
0.1421521902,
-0.2637223899,
0.5820137262,
-0.0624087267,
1.0204490423,
-0.3536741436,
-0.0182102043,
0.8750317693,
0.2003801763,
0.5501410961,
0.0131827677,
-0.1953101456,
-0.497097373,
-0.565074265,
-0.5329086781,
-0.5743595958,
0.5947533846,
-0.785995543,
-0.2071367055,
-0.2016622871,
-0.2803892195,
-0.3264330029,
-0.0345115364,
0.1952458918,
0.4923973382,
-0.0673830211,
0.3311503232,
0.8367729783,
-0.2366018891,
0.9283457994,
0.4048415124,
-0.045236595,
0.0669076368,
0.6620022058,
0.1627872884,
0.6159567237,
0.4713253081,
0.20227772,
-0.3088057935,
-1.0370682478,
-0.2883887887,
0.1231314689,
-1.0172729492,
-0.3815551102,
-0.4471923709,
-0.0022296819,
-0.138814643,
-0.1361108273,
-0.3862498999,
-0.4098596275,
-0.1751763225,
-0.3910730183,
0.1318709999,
0.6433490515,
0.1033931449,
0.4324289262,
-0.4371451735,
0.3057838976,
0.9097845554,
0.1902184933,
0.0858595446,
-0.5674933791,
-0.2085859776,
0.0104879076,
-0.488024652,
-0.8313185573,
0.1931528449,
0.6330875158,
1.2068493366,
0.9758017659,
0.2686845362,
0.4839214981,
-0.1866262704,
0.7954535484,
-0.1516510546,
-0.6917365789,
0.7199656367,
-0.1516734362,
0.0888671726,
0.834089756,
0.6187241673,
-0.1277525574,
-0.5581117868,
-0.8318970203,
-1.0274684429,
0.5093613267,
0.2424866557,
0.1542060822,
-0.0230488498,
0.2927380204,
0.3065887392,
0.082523115,
-0.9056118727,
-0.356069833,
0.1516537815,
-0.1949002147,
0.0343552232,
0.1665740013,
-0.2380385101,
0.0696065575,
0.7808665037,
-0.3693701029,
0.207075581,
0.0306777097,
-0.3182866275,
-0.2692196965,
0.3899955451,
0.5266214013,
0.7745004892,
-0.058170557,
0.3074985743,
0.3321283758,
-0.2713741064,
0.0959730297,
0.0481202677,
-0.3492289782,
0.0003342881,
0.7318928838,
0.9834865928,
0.3207178414,
-0.8529406786,
0.872870028,
0.139491573,
-0.0281940568,
-0.2677637041,
0.3573420048,
-0.3560782075,
0.3483560085,
0.8232025504,
-0.0753875524,
0.1207537651,
-0.8018407822,
0.3152315319,
0.6007720828,
-0.5483044386,
0.030000478,
0.2296584696,
-0.0553305596,
-0.2994147837,
0.6055856943,
-0.3199756742,
-0.3164251447,
0.5330426097,
0.4116382003,
0.4949111938,
-0.2436439991,
0.1776935756,
0.2433365434,
-0.1027546227,
-0.508780241,
0.1354041398,
-0.2709985375,
-0.8959896564,
-0.3825086057,
-0.2898129225,
-0.6750608087,
0.0308577884,
-0.7117081285,
0.3480843306,
-0.2992814481,
0.1005179659,
-0.3128811121,
0.3133417368,
-0.5476694107,
0.1226388738,
0.4362551272,
0.85403651,
-1.3633219004,
0.861195147,
0.9608854651,
-0.1470086426,
-0.8843951225,
-0.0162629075,
-0.0051545287,
-0.770403564,
0.1697328389,
0.0622886755,
0.1354912966,
-0.0475757122,
-1.0261807442,
-0.547323525,
1.1948009729,
0.2111508548,
-0.3260513842,
0.3090746105,
-0.5528401136,
0.2368301004,
-0.4557943046,
0.4195842147,
0.0277081765,
0.2476986349,
0.3735320568,
-0.7133561969,
-0.3448599875,
0.080786474,
-0.3652358651,
-0.1212862656,
-0.8158710599,
0.5882509947,
-0.3092162013,
-0.1698017865,
0.0119807776,
0.9150943756,
0.9613417983,
0.6334679723,
0.8787333369,
0.0035421175,
0.8545835614,
0.1229577586,
1.1509736776,
0.2139648348,
0.3274933994,
0.9424039721,
-0.4641425014,
1.0618060827,
0.6147848368,
-0.3066111803,
0.3719734251,
0.9220100045,
0.1799428612,
0.7228592038,
0.263877809,
-0.5204922557,
-0.4565787911,
0.1825947464,
-0.011982278,
0.5170405507,
0.3132118285,
-0.3256494999,
-0.2418562472,
0.281019628,
-0.1223962232,
0.0978222266,
-0.4478487372,
0.6863805056,
-0.0040801633,
-0.6352712512,
0.2144321948,
-0.2134063542,
0.6674103141,
-0.7709038258,
-0.3261770308,
-0.1584097743,
-0.0084593352,
-0.1048856974,
-0.5781500936,
-0.2140891999,
-0.2242428064,
0.1810501367,
-0.3757972121,
0.6142845154,
-0.4252594113,
-0.2565998137,
-0.0153785162,
0.7549755573,
0.4886160195,
-0.0217515603,
-0.595928967,
0.0074056238,
-0.0336491764,
-0.5265956521,
0.5927957892,
0.4878663123,
-0.2891732752,
0.725594461,
0.2232444733,
0.0664101467,
0.1509983689,
0.0963133052,
0.6297430396,
-0.2295454144,
-0.2560079694,
-0.6265856028,
0.3444271982,
-0.0211172365,
-0.1422469169,
0.8812990785,
0.7144871354,
0.8391343355,
-0.0378112197,
0.8150426149,
0.0864337385,
0.5010054708,
-0.6044889688,
0.4281235933,
-0.4149771929,
0.2925362885,
-0.3031132221,
-0.96154356,
-0.3714552224,
1.0880891085,
-0.2361006737,
0.2618420124,
0.7855721116,
0.4501384497,
-0.2729327083,
-0.1110807806,
0.3800079823,
-0.0152084427,
0.1765992343,
0.5844560266,
1.0203851461,
-0.447884649,
0.5543549061,
-0.4219399393,
-0.4547567666,
-0.1360031664,
-0.9403074384,
-0.7477382421,
-0.5627636313,
-0.6468215585,
-0.1486396939,
-0.1760477424,
1.2699682713,
1.029619813,
-0.7891628742,
-0.2360556275,
0.1696993709,
0.2590996027,
-0.7784913778,
-0.1444814056,
0.5727524161,
-0.3197039068,
-0.9530548453,
0.6938988566,
-0.0934472606,
0.3379271328,
-0.0953907669,
-0.066272065,
-0.3277086914,
-0.2169695199,
0.4696167111,
0.5020081997,
-0.531250596,
-0.2134578824,
-0.2542216778,
-0.1021517292,
-0.1458683312,
0.7261555195,
-0.928453207,
0.2035524845,
0.3054693341,
0.6234112978,
0.7506886125,
0.0680878758,
0.1887416691,
-0.9448032975,
0.334546417,
0.4560884237,
0.4268538654,
0.1534256935,
-0.0512929335,
0.4758839011,
0.0926114395,
-0.3811684549,
-0.7938431501,
0.2072251886,
-1.1574972868,
-0.4705305099,
1.6476057768,
-0.3405982852,
-0.189456597,
-0.3194724321,
-0.0333945304,
0.1589677334,
-0.3468996882,
0.7688344717,
0.5201186538,
-0.3440118134,
-0.3956742585,
-0.7883561254,
0.3237731457,
0.2561939955,
-0.5324451923,
-0.0620648749,
0.4807504714,
0.1524398774,
-0.116355896,
0.4421873093,
0.1279014498,
0.3040028214,
-0.294632256,
-0.2286502868,
-0.092669338,
-0.3781833351,
-0.5925326347,
0.6165744662,
0.4189223349,
-0.3049040437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14263v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14263v2 | LIMIT: Language Identification, Misidentification, and Translation using Hierarchical Models in 350+ Languages | 2023-05-23T17:15:43 | 2023-11-06T16:29:21 | Milind Agarwal, Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowing the language of an input text/audio is a necessary first step for
using almost every NLP tool such as taggers, parsers, or translation systems.
Language identification is a well-studied problem, sometimes even considered
solved; in reality, due to lack of data and computational challenges, current
systems cannot accurately identify most of the world's 7000 languages. To
tackle this bottleneck, we first compile a corpus, MCS-350, of 50K multilingual
and parallel children's stories in 350+ languages. MCS-350 can serve as a
benchmark for language identification of short texts and for 1400+ new
translation directions in low-resource Indian and African languages. Second, we
propose a novel misprediction-resolution hierarchical model, LIMIt, for
language identification that reduces error by 55% (from 0.71 to 0.32) on our
compiled children's stories dataset and by 40% (from 0.23 to 0.14) on the
FLORES-200 benchmark. Our method can expand language identification coverage
into low-resource languages by relying solely on systemic misprediction
patterns, bypassing the need to retrain large models from scratch. | [
-0.4138535559,
-0.3520336151,
0.1115626693,
0.4726162553,
-0.0311889797,
0.2648742199,
-0.1979553699,
-0.7525943518,
-0.0764564648,
0.3100934327,
-0.6211780906,
-0.1927437037,
-0.654628098,
0.247367546,
-0.5779624581,
0.9076449275,
-0.0670365319,
-0.2318427712,
0.0512205809,
-0.1895919442,
-0.2396188825,
-0.2331608385,
-0.6614182591,
0.1255160868,
0.6168561578,
0.6212638617,
0.8122413754,
1.0616310835,
0.3985596299,
0.23143287,
-0.2291738093,
0.1591234952,
-0.3170068562,
-0.3055345118,
-0.2490427643,
-0.2108132243,
-0.1599397063,
-0.1263699681,
0.6647875905,
1.1155767441,
0.0890191048,
0.3313027918,
0.1644517928,
0.5153164268,
-0.7050732374,
-0.0211519375,
-0.5191279054,
0.0532499254,
-0.4853024483,
-0.1223548353,
-0.5176845789,
-0.2253908366,
0.0789827406,
-0.5628941059,
0.352458477,
0.1053056121,
0.891700685,
0.0588756502,
-0.3601003587,
-0.514326036,
-1.0337873697,
1.0690293312,
-0.5421106219,
0.4475038648,
0.629617095,
0.362755239,
0.0891896263,
-0.2481403798,
-0.5792511702,
-0.0980418175,
-0.0250692945,
-0.3148820102,
-0.3813101053,
-0.2427832186,
0.4237687588,
0.2772552967,
-0.7729457617,
0.1269666702,
-0.6387550235,
-0.2946488857,
0.573451519,
0.1033577695,
0.5137964487,
-0.0844411552,
-0.3160696328,
-0.0127026532,
-0.6182706356,
-0.1478290111,
0.2917602658,
0.6391713023,
-0.2307162881,
0.5023376942,
-0.1776915789,
0.5787112713,
-0.1463724971,
-0.4431409538,
0.5470122099,
-0.4313693047,
-0.0697780699,
-0.1070056781,
0.8765087128,
0.0859740749,
0.3100751042,
-0.1184793413,
-0.1585041881,
0.0167970378,
-0.0974394605,
-0.3496315777,
0.3817959428,
-0.0611802004,
-0.2762515247,
-0.2579583526,
-0.3447982669,
-0.9521719813,
-0.4241443872,
-0.1729964316,
0.0972414166,
-0.5016670227,
-0.3664068878,
0.026172068,
0.0999459252,
0.2579758167,
0.0320067406,
-1.0693126917,
0.5882424712,
0.3960930705,
0.7343711853,
-0.3732883334,
-0.5959303975,
-0.1001405641,
0.0773297176,
-0.6039917469,
0.4233854115,
-0.460409373,
-0.2057463378,
0.0607051402,
-0.0274369456,
-0.0154701285,
-0.8006164432,
0.6610301137,
-0.4190131724,
-0.1373962462,
-0.2290299833,
-0.0798966289,
0.1386746615,
-0.0808649287,
-0.7947400808,
1.123611331,
0.1857744604,
-0.7608764768,
0.3400286734,
-0.1664969325,
-0.4754835367,
0.2358870208,
0.0259657577,
-0.0925274193,
0.2681837678,
0.3164369464,
0.0295771752,
-0.5058541894,
0.473747313,
0.0310661923,
-0.222279802,
-0.1970768869,
-0.8142927289,
1.0300781727,
0.6200757027,
-0.0064999657,
-0.1429026574,
-0.8156805038,
-0.1910355389,
0.1662240028,
-0.3576840162,
-0.3309066296,
-0.0305119306,
0.2064455897,
0.331749469,
0.3234078288,
-0.7240689993,
0.0369577892,
-0.2822595537,
0.2199552357,
0.1549161375,
-0.285682857,
0.2540757656,
-0.5553048253,
0.8284422755,
0.1048639864,
0.2291468978,
-0.2623176873,
-0.5878486633,
-0.6181560159,
-0.1738583893,
0.5658248067,
0.881290257,
-0.6874343753,
0.2189641148,
-0.4587229788,
-0.6239277124,
-0.6149786711,
0.1919555664,
0.5100979805,
0.3723817766,
0.5943064094,
-0.2839280665,
-0.9077198505,
-1.0467221737,
-0.3646410108,
-0.2278375775,
-0.2740319073,
0.3488203287,
0.28768152,
-0.3907384276,
0.7998306155,
-0.0324827582,
-0.1651944667,
-0.3873916268,
0.0456202626,
0.3097604811,
0.6156713963,
0.4315764904,
-0.7101133466,
-0.6189848185,
0.0161471646,
-0.4336141944,
-0.3696294129,
-0.2223820239,
0.2064887136,
0.1265330464,
0.7556233406,
-0.4556894004,
0.3674968183,
0.7253355384,
0.1277194768,
0.5502904654,
-0.1359508038,
-0.1585229188,
-0.7947606444,
0.1555042714,
0.003712971,
-0.1231807768,
-0.5781471133,
0.1201510504,
0.2356301993,
-0.1926336139,
-0.5191090703,
0.556108892,
-0.3761985004,
0.0221525822,
-0.0310883801,
0.2210069597,
-0.4609934688,
0.475338757,
0.0629229024,
0.6409566998,
0.4020097554,
-0.5670802593,
0.3470509946,
-0.0053881626,
-0.4503588378,
0.3888275325,
-0.3420844376,
-0.1915276647,
-0.0872002542,
0.2345170379,
-1.012440443,
-0.2001752108,
0.0706724375,
-0.5256721973,
0.3061988056,
-0.1159763038,
-0.6553993821,
-0.5898250341,
0.1386416852,
0.7810593247,
0.3066546321,
-0.5883851051,
0.6296126246,
0.6439982057,
-0.4194703102,
-0.8527339101,
-0.7860078812,
0.1051346362,
-0.1880967915,
-0.0905614123,
0.2680923343,
-0.1926829964,
-0.0655236244,
-0.145422399,
-0.2464021742,
-0.4123972356,
-0.0975584462,
-0.0148775736,
0.2004092187,
-0.2382941842,
0.34458974,
0.4356295466,
-0.3192070127,
-0.1582626998,
-0.1650915146,
0.500074029,
-0.1618213207,
-0.2562308609,
-0.3089855015,
0.7020458579,
0.7536576986,
-0.2054869533,
0.6624091864,
0.3094238639,
-0.7031510472,
-0.0992738381,
-0.4027105272,
0.3782631755,
-0.4531851709,
0.3907068074,
-0.7423137426,
-0.633882165,
0.5220596194,
-0.2028179616,
-0.1321566552,
0.7778298259,
0.4217137396,
0.1669389904,
0.9488127828,
0.8029852509,
-0.5999899507,
0.2684101164,
0.2536884844,
0.0858271495,
-0.5834599733,
0.0161831174,
-0.8515420556,
-0.1224175096,
-0.8538772464,
-0.4135632515,
-0.0106264288,
0.2954238057,
-0.0329970196,
0.85044384,
-0.2601103783,
0.823753655,
0.473057121,
-0.1787946671,
0.4769821465,
-0.0830251724,
-0.4173190594,
-0.2186831236,
-0.763740778,
-0.5518513918,
0.9324429035,
0.5001666546,
0.5919888616,
0.2914997041,
0.6633345485,
0.1140979975,
0.626753509,
-0.7530923486,
0.3935554326,
-0.1779735833,
-0.9609043002,
-0.4737338424,
-0.4637700915,
-0.9241827726,
0.1974168867,
0.0126219401,
-0.7547110915,
0.5244235992,
0.0163551196,
-0.3013409674,
0.224816516,
-0.6429328322,
0.7320859432,
-0.1558479667,
-0.019067429,
0.0284509696,
-0.6423210502,
0.3032402694,
-0.5656730533,
0.7457945347,
0.0236679167,
-0.2975552976,
0.6545214057,
-0.3211299479,
0.9176620841,
0.1365718991,
-0.2692412138,
0.3870982528,
0.1951624602,
0.378148824,
-0.2815112472,
0.0601179712,
0.2101350576,
0.2085394859,
-0.5584465265,
-0.1462781876,
0.6979498863,
-0.658108592,
-0.3058030009,
-0.3920977414,
-0.8286581039,
-0.3226291537,
0.4886062741,
0.3531641662,
0.1086666137,
-0.069049947,
0.1969911158,
0.5714901686,
-0.5338354111,
0.6137267947,
0.6777358651,
-0.3052607477,
-0.1751644313,
1.1499158144,
0.1487015486,
0.3696598113,
0.4206853807,
0.3378855288,
-0.0779391527,
-0.5279780626,
-0.5986790657,
0.4245395064,
-0.4520366788,
-0.0772441179,
-0.4541933537,
-0.2411679178,
-0.2544915974,
-0.0347048379,
-0.4698704779,
-0.3266971707,
-0.1392684579,
-0.0438381061,
-0.1747908443,
0.5349559188,
-0.3385120332,
0.276617974,
-0.7964421511,
0.4170687199,
0.2618715167,
0.4751544595,
0.0282541197,
-0.7746417522,
-0.3632429838,
0.0259358007,
-0.0897335559,
-1.1134670973,
0.6010453105,
0.3091641963,
0.4252336025,
0.3583169878,
-0.0024793593,
0.8077542782,
-0.7070109248,
0.3975130916,
0.1005866528,
-1.1991636753,
0.3350881636,
-0.4186132848,
0.3989107609,
0.5614768267,
0.8007215261,
-0.8382835388,
-0.4471725225,
-0.5721050501,
-0.9155765772,
0.7192105055,
0.0234996434,
0.284645468,
-0.1287541389,
0.1250191033,
0.0060610077,
0.0923064128,
-0.6691132784,
-0.2876957953,
0.1944063008,
-0.4498412013,
-0.2445150912,
-0.3663371205,
-0.0233448967,
-0.2980923653,
0.5021336079,
-0.0067362948,
-0.0274350401,
-0.0680776909,
-0.3569976985,
-0.5278580785,
0.2740671039,
0.6513956189,
0.5736215115,
-0.0625328645,
0.2074620277,
0.3305807412,
-0.5458331108,
0.0614695884,
0.1198643073,
-0.1595072746,
0.141077444,
0.5994468927,
0.4320369661,
0.0947046876,
-0.9273031354,
0.426658541,
0.1289042681,
-0.0546437167,
-0.1098242328,
-0.1654267311,
0.149928838,
0.0231816433,
0.5354606509,
0.1488805711,
0.056581229,
-0.4310123324,
0.3413847685,
0.1602500975,
-0.5500348806,
-0.0731059462,
0.5298106074,
0.0236805249,
-0.4927143157,
0.4771660864,
-0.2030544132,
-0.2791246176,
0.7676478624,
0.70615834,
0.7608503699,
-0.6492760181,
0.0843192786,
0.6996335983,
0.8167018294,
-0.0855142698,
0.0685078651,
-0.1398037374,
-0.8689431548,
-0.5669392347,
-0.69426018,
-0.3583129346,
0.3717888594,
-0.8831213713,
0.1706227511,
-0.3357765079,
0.0801930279,
0.189225167,
-0.1127083823,
-0.540545702,
0.3087688386,
0.3273049295,
1.0120601654,
-1.3248935938,
1.0238140821,
0.0465825573,
-0.3421811461,
-0.6092763543,
-0.1786705405,
0.1848552674,
-0.5491013527,
0.5478909016,
-0.0249142796,
-0.1562080681,
0.1945581734,
-0.6549242139,
-1.0996046066,
0.6166229248,
0.2439006716,
-1.0138098001,
0.1641648114,
0.2408769578,
0.7714745402,
-0.5231732726,
0.0773978755,
0.7985698581,
0.343354702,
0.2223483622,
-1.3544855118,
-0.1051770672,
-0.3107652962,
0.1004508287,
0.1439778954,
-0.1520463079,
0.7290588617,
-0.501028657,
-0.5066627264,
0.3068450987,
0.4209466577,
0.2634036839,
0.2056264877,
0.5158261061,
0.4533335865,
0.7414957285,
0.0564319342,
1.021271944,
-0.2502355874,
0.4374216497,
1.372541666,
0.0018015204,
0.9036521316,
0.4841239154,
-0.4006745219,
0.1616290361,
0.714866817,
0.1629171818,
0.3545125425,
0.4452171028,
-0.2121475935,
0.0169769768,
-0.3133569956,
-0.3201549053,
0.0390709527,
0.7239323258,
-0.4326391518,
-0.1604550332,
0.0652996302,
0.0893614218,
-0.1700056791,
-0.1116658226,
0.3987194896,
-0.0242299084,
-0.4346964657,
0.8103913069,
0.1649691463,
0.5090866089,
-0.4900883138,
0.1838738024,
-0.2886287272,
0.0590670593,
-0.1175412536,
-0.2883825004,
0.4656350613,
0.1475107521,
-0.2984952331,
-0.1480976492,
0.380654186,
-0.7628968954,
-0.5358689427,
0.3399617076,
0.5084106922,
0.2374800444,
0.1945941299,
-0.5198004246,
0.1028687283,
-0.0433083363,
0.1631450206,
0.0809831992,
0.3579410613,
-0.4123029113,
0.7899093032,
0.5440873504,
0.2149197757,
0.3078118265,
0.0652623698,
0.5713957548,
-0.6452770233,
-0.3130686879,
-0.5508539677,
0.1753219366,
0.2755743563,
-0.4994552732,
0.7053450346,
0.6330736876,
1.1487962008,
-0.1774152368,
0.7708077431,
-0.1297214478,
0.8798775077,
0.0589411519,
0.4225229323,
-0.4836028814,
0.3460524976,
-0.5460499525,
-0.7055927515,
-0.5823680162,
0.4055178165,
-0.2180287391,
-0.0025940975,
0.9092047215,
0.7345926762,
-0.0249968506,
-0.1984656453,
0.359569937,
0.1469275653,
0.04399205,
0.6493726373,
0.6740844846,
-0.5447977185,
0.879691422,
-0.3111211061,
-0.4924502373,
-0.1573667377,
-0.6938266158,
-0.4042705894,
-0.565824151,
-0.3276230991,
-0.2368979156,
-0.2408519536,
0.5343197584,
0.6236568093,
-1.095382452,
-0.4990172982,
-0.1359226853,
0.2146398276,
-0.6310788989,
-0.1568392366,
0.1504101306,
-0.1712574214,
-0.9292499423,
0.5944991708,
0.1278763413,
0.0547705479,
-0.2500860989,
-0.1427900791,
-0.3456313312,
0.3199262321,
0.3671268821,
0.8294170499,
-0.7920648456,
-0.0928874016,
-0.2321161032,
-0.4504673481,
-0.0960814431,
0.8367480636,
-0.6699699759,
0.6799187064,
0.5104349256,
0.6721873879,
0.4545807838,
-0.276427269,
0.3441376686,
-0.7830960751,
0.2621269524,
0.2326668203,
0.1311967969,
0.2233494371,
0.0071233283,
0.4574068189,
0.4624911845,
-0.101052165,
-0.9022114873,
0.4300221503,
-0.8194847107,
-0.060643632,
0.8990588188,
-0.0743491873,
-0.1949235648,
-0.4465021491,
-0.059022937,
0.1316597164,
-0.1271377206,
0.4486530423,
0.8662589192,
0.3107440472,
-0.4315062761,
-0.6782777905,
0.5432364345,
0.3131158054,
-0.5639851689,
0.0186079107,
0.3281580806,
0.0533191226,
0.675052166,
0.6236204505,
-0.3895318806,
0.1847879738,
0.2638606727,
0.0607035272,
0.3301698565,
-0.720236659,
-0.4459730685,
0.1579541415,
-0.0230816212,
-0.2375838459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14260v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14260v2 | R2H: Building Multimodal Navigation Helpers that Respond to Help Requests | 2023-05-23T17:12:09 | 2023-10-17T17:46:41 | Yue Fan, Jing Gu, Kaizhi Zheng, Xin Eric Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Intelligent navigation-helper agents are critical as they can navigate users
in unknown areas through environmental awareness and conversational ability,
serving as potential accessibility tools for individuals with disabilities. In
this work, we first introduce a novel benchmark, Respond to Help Requests
(R2H), to promote the development of multi-modal navigation helpers capable of
responding to requests for help, utilizing existing dialog-based embodied
datasets. R2H mainly includes two tasks: (1) Respond to Dialog History (RDH),
which assesses the helper agent's ability to generate informative responses
based on a given dialog history, and (2) Respond during Interaction (RdI),
which evaluates the effectiveness and efficiency of the response during
consistent cooperation with a task performer. Furthermore, we explore two
approaches to construct the navigation-helper agent, including fine-tuning a
novel task-oriented multi-modal response generation model that can see and
respond, named SeeRee, and employing a multi-modal large language model in a
zero-shot manner. Analysis of the task and method was conducted based on both
automatic benchmarking and human evaluations. Project website:
https://sites.google.com/view/response2helprequests/home. | [
-0.3732575178,
-0.4874744713,
0.4551016688,
0.120350033,
0.0350096226,
-0.0790854618,
0.0482005887,
-0.6639360189,
0.2040311992,
0.2321597636,
-0.8662243485,
0.1112055331,
-0.2646045089,
0.2009487152,
0.1914710402,
0.7596526742,
-0.0854237899,
-0.0247265436,
-0.1626446843,
-0.306027025,
-0.9702530503,
-0.2332442552,
-0.6868408322,
-0.0290705189,
0.9100441337,
0.7318505645,
0.811194241,
0.2864763737,
0.4967021644,
0.3119934499,
0.3578475714,
0.3944863677,
-0.3705934286,
0.5458364487,
-0.173375845,
-0.2479402274,
-0.7622470856,
-0.3527741134,
0.3810571134,
0.3742926419,
-0.0301362034,
0.1299901456,
0.152586922,
0.4354567826,
-0.6386734843,
0.417008251,
-0.1258354932,
-0.1259084344,
-0.0304538738,
-0.3723377883,
-0.2073292583,
-0.0157526154,
0.104609333,
-1.0963612795,
0.1984566152,
0.4011719823,
0.302819103,
0.6631848216,
-0.6115319133,
-0.2869666815,
-0.3638712466,
0.649597168,
-0.4921629429,
0.7021144629,
0.5009785891,
0.5961765647,
-0.3102736175,
-0.5550590158,
-0.5563075542,
-0.3233379424,
-0.0228275247,
0.370131135,
-0.1771638095,
-0.1379985064,
0.1102761105,
-0.2731968462,
-0.7554397583,
-0.0981202573,
-0.1610358208,
-0.395475924,
0.6697129011,
0.2317038476,
0.2707800269,
-0.411719799,
-0.573125422,
-0.2504981756,
-0.3586452305,
0.1417209208,
-0.0163820274,
0.446395278,
-0.2132310569,
0.6776652336,
-0.3950099945,
0.6449561119,
-0.1546544731,
-0.073589161,
0.1751480699,
-0.7462952733,
-0.110271126,
-0.2113826275,
0.3490081429,
0.7767782211,
0.3571638763,
-0.2917944789,
-0.2951917052,
-0.3443942368,
0.5578273535,
-0.7065398693,
-0.1636779308,
0.0329298079,
-0.5598266721,
0.3555795252,
-0.1191914082,
-0.907230258,
-0.7819250226,
-0.3211117089,
0.3770821989,
-0.2867080569,
-0.6600596905,
-0.0719496757,
-0.3565090597,
0.1654970795,
0.4782728851,
-0.5202875733,
0.2254586667,
0.3823218644,
0.7428861856,
0.0177263096,
-0.2229013443,
-0.9274809361,
0.2972484827,
0.0659179538,
0.8650202155,
-0.5178319216,
-0.66737324,
-0.1639237851,
0.3779305518,
-0.1972340196,
-0.4221682847,
0.4930784702,
-0.4007222056,
-0.0964371413,
-0.513225913,
0.1899968684,
-0.5154083371,
0.3781113923,
-0.7358312011,
0.788200438,
0.3338486254,
-0.623474896,
0.056134019,
-0.7286962271,
-0.4300350249,
0.3375935256,
-0.1823043376,
-0.1623640805,
0.2476569861,
0.1574575752,
0.1451321393,
-0.4873345494,
-0.2320050746,
-0.1355027258,
-0.1091129929,
-0.0572623722,
-0.3862424195,
0.3950001597,
-0.1157452762,
-0.538964808,
0.3406097591,
-0.710223794,
0.163782984,
0.224909246,
-0.3399768174,
-0.4374417961,
0.1167659461,
0.5976538062,
0.285104543,
0.2054121047,
-0.281142056,
0.1834727824,
-0.1207342595,
0.0388199501,
0.5358479023,
0.0218737554,
0.0513150841,
-0.4247517288,
0.7005305886,
-0.0919839665,
0.1232019216,
-0.263715148,
-0.7209954262,
-0.6965059042,
-0.0940701067,
-0.0482074991,
0.5368850827,
-1.0575336218,
0.0180837195,
-0.3988449574,
-0.3229186833,
-0.3068844378,
-0.1178771779,
0.6720781922,
0.7146612406,
0.557169795,
-0.5039221048,
-0.3664705455,
-0.9156589508,
0.0728024617,
-0.4850309789,
-0.2002694756,
0.7099648714,
0.395326674,
-0.174534902,
0.7770687938,
-0.2066968381,
-0.1917669922,
0.0220959987,
0.0692335144,
-0.4585523605,
0.420411557,
0.5277634859,
-1.0267974138,
-0.1193897203,
0.1786077172,
-0.7962862849,
0.0696359873,
0.0813282505,
-0.0335014351,
0.1709326506,
0.3311969042,
-0.2665424347,
0.4846109748,
0.3534483612,
-0.6376917362,
0.2658521831,
-0.4242939651,
0.4140267074,
-1.1334170103,
0.2919925153,
-0.0087349787,
-0.1812037677,
-0.5944641232,
0.0509771742,
0.1463721246,
-0.1112830788,
-0.2808598876,
0.7377040386,
-0.7309362292,
-0.170461759,
-0.3010630906,
0.242640987,
-0.3367156982,
0.7419649959,
0.098663263,
0.857709825,
0.2709770203,
-0.6096636653,
0.4891696274,
0.3230988383,
0.0202663857,
0.93582654,
-0.8239422441,
0.1565517783,
-0.2252491415,
0.2739730775,
-1.3431680202,
-0.4365329742,
0.4906116724,
-0.3064948022,
0.0428099334,
-0.1503574699,
-0.389572978,
-0.2539726496,
-0.3568024337,
0.6513483524,
0.0660315901,
-0.3241237998,
1.0295370817,
0.3721427917,
-0.5536273718,
-0.3101344109,
-0.5181804895,
0.0336751379,
-0.0730745792,
-0.7101005316,
0.1085341573,
-0.4743249714,
-0.0406480059,
-0.2859476507,
-0.2561835349,
-0.0571651869,
0.1777276248,
0.6999991536,
0.2295734584,
-0.0802349448,
0.1449072212,
-0.0688566267,
-0.3718540967,
0.0214633718,
0.0921541005,
0.1979805678,
-0.1173227206,
-0.6543856263,
-0.3083435595,
0.5459980369,
0.7382680774,
-0.4763599038,
0.1328410953,
0.3995966911,
-0.1806043237,
0.2298481762,
-0.3979946971,
-0.4018960595,
-0.4403353333,
0.5625903606,
-0.5773809552,
-0.5240409374,
0.3855013549,
-0.0842860639,
0.2512588203,
-0.0511547662,
0.4907687604,
0.1634263992,
1.0343794823,
0.5889015198,
0.1107599139,
0.4259639382,
0.0276731085,
0.1324324906,
-0.9412286878,
-0.6886059046,
-0.58770293,
-0.4573810101,
-0.4550836384,
-0.7586095929,
0.7585120797,
-0.0625926629,
-0.0830500871,
0.432187885,
-0.3069208562,
-0.1442411095,
0.6057675481,
0.161652565,
0.2972830832,
-0.1185324937,
0.076937668,
0.0217988268,
-0.8076769114,
-0.3474310338,
0.9499723911,
0.2894293666,
0.7326848507,
0.5736192465,
0.1412061602,
0.2780990899,
0.1289332509,
-1.0228691101,
0.7185537219,
0.6382085681,
-0.3384363055,
-0.3092623353,
-0.1478142291,
-1.0492819548,
0.3443498015,
-0.2125864625,
-0.5547357202,
0.2001744062,
0.1533690095,
-0.4183230102,
-0.1243619174,
-0.8717516065,
0.6786280274,
-0.3695825636,
-0.4365403056,
-0.3591025174,
-0.9938060045,
-0.2048834711,
0.0485921949,
0.4358869493,
0.0586569421,
-0.3782454133,
0.4550096691,
-0.1934696287,
0.7424430847,
-0.4115623236,
-0.1984755397,
-0.0498168878,
0.2164992243,
0.3519119322,
0.2679165304,
-0.0308816247,
-0.183021307,
-0.033786647,
-0.3625437319,
-0.5299832225,
0.6740188003,
-0.561668396,
-0.5581078529,
-0.2480033934,
-0.8750163317,
-0.5384821296,
0.3040875196,
-0.2817794681,
0.8526315689,
-0.1501027048,
0.1619959772,
0.4864776731,
0.0107592633,
0.7416263819,
0.904820025,
0.1857062727,
-0.1594278663,
0.8676448464,
0.044762753,
-0.0769237354,
0.3889552355,
-0.2090517581,
-0.464500159,
-0.4948889017,
-0.789742887,
0.0945463553,
-0.3094577193,
-0.25388062,
-0.3341325819,
0.0764975473,
-0.310190469,
0.1501217186,
-0.1543234438,
-0.3731360137,
0.0985679999,
0.0254040323,
0.2083603591,
0.8101550341,
-0.2482099086,
-0.164141506,
-0.6485548615,
0.4503727555,
0.6771066189,
0.2532311976,
0.2568137944,
-0.2692453265,
-0.2366367131,
0.0620558113,
-0.2730691731,
-0.7610328794,
-0.110949181,
-0.1769885868,
0.8836500049,
0.0051087751,
0.2678400278,
0.392770052,
-0.5202444196,
0.815308094,
0.2354046702,
-0.3040533364,
0.6856017709,
-0.3887001872,
0.4127639532,
0.440844059,
0.2512521446,
-0.551662147,
-0.037617173,
-0.2785529196,
-0.9997743368,
0.7793974876,
0.3034579754,
-0.0455121994,
0.0953064114,
-0.0009583497,
-0.0551038459,
0.1251274794,
-0.2497279942,
-0.2066882253,
-0.3918008506,
-0.065830484,
0.0092872325,
-0.158774972,
-0.3983205259,
0.2311432511,
0.4939290583,
-0.5394381881,
0.1340612024,
0.2893947959,
-0.2390503585,
-0.1264680177,
0.3317055404,
0.8471016288,
0.7699261308,
0.0108173257,
0.0071425117,
0.2039177865,
-0.4343367517,
-0.1324731112,
0.5319646597,
0.0953908637,
-0.2224399,
0.3671597838,
0.6757821441,
0.4195045829,
-0.9700921178,
0.3991703987,
-0.4148597419,
0.1978092492,
0.0215396415,
0.1710579991,
-0.0602788255,
0.5272305608,
0.4724138975,
0.0497302823,
0.2130333632,
-0.4318472743,
0.0039247544,
0.4013297856,
-0.5103449225,
-0.4175940454,
0.7526493073,
0.6721295118,
-0.663254261,
0.411886245,
0.161066696,
-0.0888114125,
0.4909059703,
0.3057892025,
0.6490878463,
-0.3661594093,
0.1111275628,
0.3480941951,
0.0829397961,
0.2802054882,
0.3258689642,
-0.542489171,
-0.293564111,
0.1116319969,
-0.0825757906,
-0.3095992804,
-0.265037179,
-0.9380393624,
-0.2798572183,
-0.1363856941,
-0.2639900148,
-0.0816628337,
-0.0572204031,
-0.7830040455,
0.3053740263,
0.0977726951,
0.8221536279,
-0.3774174154,
0.4033524394,
1.0628640652,
-0.7540135384,
-0.8348369002,
0.3746334314,
0.2889947593,
-0.7487096786,
0.3489894867,
0.1315418929,
-0.7754802108,
0.0304620247,
-0.1185990497,
-0.622600913,
1.387362957,
0.1760200858,
-0.6101979613,
-0.3275292814,
-0.0780803636,
0.3049625456,
-0.0164100453,
0.5753801465,
0.3372344673,
0.6520882249,
-0.0832568482,
-1.4224630594,
0.3000501096,
-0.492287606,
0.4085911512,
-0.025271697,
-0.976541698,
0.3052904904,
-0.303206563,
-0.0728950649,
0.5162636042,
0.415997982,
0.556347549,
0.47871539,
0.7613973618,
0.1589417309,
0.763549149,
0.0005771217,
1.0086014271,
-0.3477813601,
-0.0681227297,
1.1805458069,
-0.0800435916,
0.8555418253,
0.7482558489,
0.3007852435,
0.4863677323,
0.3361131847,
0.4324669242,
0.7451900244,
0.1175690666,
-0.3315550387,
-0.2604875267,
-0.4430092871,
-0.6839118004,
0.2939496934,
0.1934624314,
0.1487480253,
-0.4105712771,
0.2893784344,
-0.1075962707,
0.0978777334,
-0.324801296,
0.8057906628,
-0.2145108134,
-0.9347770214,
0.3430676162,
-0.0775969923,
0.4887942076,
-0.6425837278,
-0.1615096033,
-0.4121409357,
0.0395896174,
-0.1809992492,
-0.7393484712,
-0.0451171063,
-0.1197940484,
-0.4441203177,
-0.1442907155,
0.4415028393,
-0.1578818411,
-0.1581216007,
0.4650633335,
0.7111918926,
0.1065536663,
0.1549423486,
-0.6581283212,
0.0427750535,
-0.1404595822,
-0.3422141075,
0.3644751608,
0.3345356286,
-0.3183612823,
0.8239840269,
0.3761921525,
-0.4215117097,
-0.0084150368,
0.2248083651,
0.9680873752,
-0.5185372829,
-0.3466777802,
-0.1471749693,
0.8246068954,
0.0779418424,
-0.3899887204,
0.7661532164,
0.672580719,
0.5910770893,
-0.0530449301,
0.8276280761,
-0.3362668455,
0.472697705,
-0.2734946012,
0.4860045612,
-0.9527429938,
-0.08356902,
0.0309925154,
-0.6110391617,
0.0484965295,
0.6489332914,
0.0008862974,
0.3182378411,
0.3806533217,
1.2665257454,
-0.2438950241,
-0.0144606503,
0.1444461346,
-0.1009366587,
0.4297134578,
0.7012892365,
0.7825351954,
-0.4696905911,
0.7162157297,
0.2826395929,
-0.2650936246,
-0.4884686768,
-0.6406789422,
-0.5810556412,
-0.8040516376,
-0.0944415852,
-0.3887088895,
0.227061227,
0.7277626395,
1.1261944771,
-0.6302161217,
-0.1921453178,
-0.0606409088,
0.0861829072,
-0.3138507903,
-0.1511288285,
0.1188629344,
-0.0347875841,
-0.705370605,
0.9263823032,
0.4509740472,
0.0970919132,
-0.3499130309,
-0.3741577864,
0.0547981374,
-0.1314337999,
0.4898916483,
0.5050427914,
-0.7294077277,
-0.5004879236,
-0.0223810598,
-0.0279314741,
0.0263540577,
0.9703410268,
-0.8613558412,
0.7937099338,
0.2380559891,
0.610488832,
0.3797770739,
0.1104386598,
0.6610171199,
-0.6350926757,
0.2339723259,
0.125760287,
0.1115729511,
0.4377467334,
-0.0679414794,
0.6343191266,
0.0496679954,
-0.4744400084,
-0.5626623631,
0.3213895857,
-1.3246642351,
-0.0359372832,
1.0867798328,
-0.1070259884,
-0.0320453458,
-0.5805937052,
-0.7389805317,
0.0986045301,
-0.5848363638,
0.5096396804,
0.2172943652,
-0.3379510343,
-0.1819270849,
-0.6866824031,
0.3831610084,
0.4434940517,
-1.021625042,
0.1075326353,
0.8846725821,
0.3521613181,
0.3347498178,
0.7397592068,
0.3011170924,
0.6047384739,
-0.0023130609,
-0.3919126391,
-0.4289640188,
-0.571633637,
-0.0323755443,
0.5063425899,
0.0081654089,
-0.4151936471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14259v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14259v7 | SciMON: Scientific Inspiration Machines Optimized for Novelty | 2023-05-23T17:12:08 | 2024-06-03T21:15:28 | Qingyun Wang, Doug Downey, Heng Ji, Tom Hope | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We explore and enhance the ability of neural language models to generate
novel scientific directions grounded in literature. Work on literature-based
hypothesis generation has traditionally focused on binary link
prediction--severely limiting the expressivity of hypotheses. This line of work
also does not focus on optimizing novelty. We take a dramatic departure with a
novel setting in which models use as input background contexts (e.g., problems,
experimental settings, goals), and output natural language ideas grounded in
literature. We present SciMON, a modeling framework that uses retrieval of
"inspirations" from past scientific papers, and explicitly optimizes for
novelty by iteratively comparing to prior papers and updating idea suggestions
until sufficient novelty is achieved. Comprehensive evaluations reveal that
GPT-4 tends to generate ideas with overall low technical depth and novelty,
while our methods partially mitigate this issue. Our work represents a first
step toward evaluating and developing language models that generate new ideas
derived from the scientific literature | [
-0.2539969683,
-0.4325763285,
1.0083819628,
0.0549728572,
-0.4739125073,
-0.0017359288,
-0.0164226647,
-0.3644913137,
0.3725775182,
0.2298515439,
-0.705678761,
-0.4257779121,
-0.3985681236,
0.4439595044,
-0.3759649694,
1.2881616354,
0.1240797937,
0.012794097,
-0.4545062184,
0.1958136261,
-0.1613375098,
-0.0624656603,
-0.4318016469,
-0.3511493504,
0.9043719172,
0.0798397586,
0.2651163042,
0.72852391,
0.5545902848,
0.2895501256,
0.0639258772,
0.0613118298,
-0.3338356018,
0.3347316682,
-0.3737183213,
-0.6538259387,
-0.0548314825,
0.0722617581,
0.682788074,
0.7643023133,
0.1249845996,
0.1178068668,
-0.1361077279,
0.3105603755,
-0.2028861195,
-0.0102665359,
-0.9585667849,
0.1561446339,
-0.1594121009,
-0.5230115652,
-0.1717437506,
-0.6125997305,
0.1963294744,
-0.7570061088,
0.7857851982,
0.2382689118,
0.864200294,
0.1014985666,
0.1668711603,
-0.45681265,
-0.6606803536,
0.7081716061,
-0.7601146102,
-0.0498801097,
-0.02068373,
0.1917818487,
-0.2394664288,
-1.0161345005,
-0.537763536,
-0.5531218052,
0.1468576044,
0.0533575565,
-0.3118819594,
-0.4833427966,
0.2620959282,
-0.0773047134,
-0.8043208718,
-0.1992172003,
-0.7806470394,
0.1512823105,
0.5137370825,
0.119550094,
0.2560395598,
-0.2961433828,
-0.1870975494,
-0.0513946339,
-0.6703189015,
-0.1945094764,
0.4401813745,
0.0398975648,
0.3653498292,
0.521161139,
-0.2031921595,
0.3993236721,
0.0869376287,
0.0792048723,
0.3673408329,
-0.3709956408,
0.1578886956,
0.4252111316,
0.985309124,
0.2218538076,
-0.3250159919,
-0.3966789544,
-0.2214555591,
0.156223312,
0.2735073268,
-0.990365088,
-0.3660036922,
0.1623683274,
-0.3069211841,
-0.6247187257,
0.0751308128,
-0.5805109143,
-0.3537344337,
-0.1263827235,
0.3891662359,
-0.6394195557,
-0.2525461614,
0.0450646095,
-0.600961566,
-0.4381133616,
0.1864830256,
-0.9967417717,
0.0681405216,
0.7042235732,
1.0084689856,
-0.3230080605,
-0.3188329041,
-0.132588923,
0.1180400029,
-0.5484283566,
0.8085806966,
-0.4569859803,
-0.3381742537,
-0.5842459202,
-0.1046471521,
0.127146244,
-0.1646176875,
0.6797266006,
-0.3816089034,
0.5046929121,
-0.066995807,
-0.3017763793,
-0.3416056633,
-0.0888022184,
-0.6737678051,
0.6306052804,
-0.0625313371,
-0.9972856045,
0.4564673007,
-0.9173175693,
-0.3388827443,
0.4011579156,
-0.3809675574,
-0.2481111884,
0.6150963306,
-0.0873972401,
0.0680913553,
-0.7070049644,
0.5917909741,
-0.3440578282,
-0.3551885486,
0.3356645405,
-0.4557505846,
0.5109531283,
0.5181043148,
-0.4440072477,
0.2380442768,
-0.8831367493,
0.1587855816,
0.3456210494,
0.1834567338,
-0.7335132957,
0.0138645275,
-0.2377616167,
0.1896118969,
0.4225441813,
-0.8764587045,
0.1112496927,
-0.586755693,
0.6773118973,
0.5126563907,
0.164899826,
0.2193849683,
-0.4127019346,
0.5021420121,
-0.0853298306,
-0.128902033,
-0.3889997602,
-0.6717976928,
-0.2971941531,
-0.0982836336,
0.1991569549,
0.1331419796,
-0.6469470263,
0.2216689289,
-0.1028912216,
-0.8201262355,
-0.5055459142,
0.1395596266,
0.0121780569,
0.6331731081,
0.1421017945,
-0.255997628,
-0.6509202123,
-0.9190438986,
-0.4284493029,
0.055587545,
-0.1581074893,
0.0661617294,
0.6117786169,
-0.2034737915,
1.1249883175,
-0.4262247682,
0.339329958,
-0.1584474593,
0.5597118139,
0.8884801269,
0.5538235307,
0.5606799722,
-0.9377573729,
-0.3139108121,
0.1326331943,
-1.0938476324,
-0.1612559259,
-0.0667450503,
0.0010954032,
0.0046663946,
0.3875383437,
-0.7159849405,
0.2258439362,
0.3486000896,
-0.0756419525,
0.6483730078,
-0.1472790241,
-0.0502690896,
-1.1491731405,
0.450455606,
0.0713396817,
0.400336504,
-0.5085871816,
-0.3958623707,
-0.0428180546,
-0.4647957385,
-0.3216955066,
0.5239005089,
-0.27758497,
0.2378566861,
-0.5448477268,
0.0309685115,
0.1844099164,
0.1629001349,
0.0077338386,
0.448898077,
0.4573380053,
-0.4611206651,
0.3847239614,
-0.1402621567,
-0.2455846965,
0.2756366432,
-1.0889385939,
0.1630630642,
-0.4232088625,
0.0483795665,
-0.7363010049,
-0.3567422032,
0.2701057792,
-0.4478131533,
0.1803665012,
0.1134839132,
-0.2268223464,
-0.6484156251,
-0.3679424524,
0.2580922246,
0.4609972537,
-0.3867641091,
0.3687814176,
-0.110354431,
-0.5487571359,
-0.3518276811,
-0.4677554369,
0.1021826938,
-0.4285214841,
-0.534117341,
0.6201878786,
-0.1891696453,
-0.1765484661,
0.5475966334,
-0.1583617181,
0.3230701685,
0.0450806879,
0.2502132356,
0.3157324791,
-0.3332001269,
0.0210188832,
0.2360129505,
-0.1457280368,
0.3008490801,
-0.859901011,
0.4925214052,
-0.1957588941,
-0.3064450026,
-0.1713025421,
0.4023688734,
0.3611549139,
-0.008324896,
0.2209625989,
0.7505663037,
-0.2687952518,
-0.1593325287,
-0.2228438854,
-0.5231433511,
-0.5445811749,
0.6987342834,
-0.4663553834,
-0.6940779686,
0.1513524652,
-0.0966431573,
0.1741582751,
0.5008098483,
0.5481802225,
-0.0935132578,
1.0173922777,
0.6884215474,
0.3675690889,
0.3876041174,
0.0181739088,
0.3956684172,
-0.7372531295,
-0.2526815236,
-0.6647937894,
-0.2413478941,
-0.5809521079,
-0.2077739239,
0.5267990828,
0.0675439686,
-0.0985014662,
0.2955360711,
-0.8011994958,
0.4716799259,
0.8635423779,
-0.1494247615,
0.1349847317,
0.3373019397,
-0.6711235046,
-0.2917482257,
-1.089402914,
-0.6577704549,
1.2198637724,
0.1362194866,
0.8562315702,
-0.237791568,
0.9299729466,
0.0311741065,
0.7471088171,
-0.6098483801,
0.4153114259,
0.20480676,
-0.5824688673,
-0.1450934559,
-0.5935835838,
-1.0992035866,
0.3186472654,
-0.0992382094,
-0.6431563497,
0.0897234902,
-0.0141203962,
-0.2868120968,
0.2209303826,
-0.4325771332,
0.6687161326,
-0.554497242,
-0.8052034974,
0.0197861306,
-0.501485765,
0.621737659,
-0.5021989942,
0.1129991189,
-0.0755862221,
0.143366009,
0.7297540903,
-0.0745768994,
0.7473390102,
0.0582395084,
-0.0253327154,
0.3583068848,
0.1793669909,
0.2798156142,
0.1109950915,
-0.3622781932,
0.1134729907,
-0.0414035916,
-0.1073540375,
-0.6143323779,
0.9408916831,
-0.5930168629,
-0.8608475924,
-0.6480810642,
-0.8007532954,
-0.0069464878,
0.5767769814,
0.643317461,
0.2231253535,
-0.3159674406,
0.3762889504,
0.454515785,
-0.3412384987,
0.5081650615,
0.4810147882,
-0.1774367392,
-0.5990946293,
1.0261534452,
-0.2189873904,
0.0122492779,
0.1188062355,
0.4771441221,
-0.434240967,
-0.5718755126,
-0.2972879708,
0.4012853503,
-0.6728727221,
0.0120922616,
-0.6606456637,
-0.0034842342,
-0.4426849186,
-0.0577212647,
-0.2141124755,
-0.5846792459,
-0.232955575,
0.1430565268,
0.2499100268,
0.9135767221,
-0.2963994443,
-0.2304385602,
-0.6282039285,
0.0325591043,
0.0957196951,
0.0086363982,
-0.1142042652,
-0.3517117798,
-0.3586875498,
-0.029370917,
-0.5845292211,
-0.7990454435,
0.7878836393,
0.1415382028,
0.7296222448,
0.3772839606,
-0.2156820446,
-0.0129369423,
-0.8798494339,
0.7342306972,
0.6550732255,
-0.4978465736,
0.8237294555,
-0.5192629099,
0.1794314086,
0.3216784596,
0.8258672953,
-0.2866928279,
-0.4029217958,
-0.8891352415,
-0.6612944603,
0.2715682685,
0.0179344919,
0.0092771957,
-0.0675787702,
0.2235291302,
0.3529876173,
0.6364555359,
-0.6623101234,
0.3030748069,
-0.6028097272,
-0.3858243227,
-0.1015290245,
0.170649156,
-0.3971415758,
-0.3152959347,
0.5360251665,
-0.353931427,
0.4017923176,
0.2483904809,
0.3383125365,
-0.3921798766,
0.000800067,
0.904096365,
0.826172471,
-0.2232784778,
0.3616761863,
-0.2553926408,
-0.535689652,
0.0921047404,
0.1663090289,
-0.6267625093,
0.3939779401,
0.0399911255,
0.9573323727,
0.2559797764,
-0.3940213025,
-0.1044990271,
-0.0024383962,
-0.3613726199,
-0.1764115542,
0.4505207241,
0.3056397438,
0.1849443913,
0.6200921535,
0.5927360058,
0.1792052686,
-0.4900207222,
0.3258430064,
0.5263735056,
-0.0822832882,
-0.7288006544,
1.1099504232,
-0.172695756,
-0.3959421813,
0.0870061442,
-0.362048775,
-0.4449313581,
0.7478262186,
1.0822386742,
1.0355032682,
0.0932379514,
0.2940868139,
0.4550312757,
0.4173058867,
-0.0098450053,
0.1840225458,
0.1942655146,
-0.5960441232,
-0.2509768903,
-0.8072978854,
-0.3788000047,
0.2278543562,
-0.2553895116,
0.4458677769,
-0.6131296754,
-0.303520143,
0.1747243851,
-0.0594392717,
-0.6708077192,
-0.1932771504,
-0.0509846881,
0.5894815922,
-0.7606883645,
0.9716387987,
0.8016121387,
-0.5118668079,
-0.6308020949,
-0.1745548546,
-0.1243067086,
-0.4193803668,
0.9549133778,
0.1736647338,
-0.1619206071,
0.199192673,
-0.8251745701,
-1.1432315111,
1.2177852392,
0.2300661057,
-0.5999290347,
-0.0098029114,
-0.0922814831,
0.6212983131,
-0.6575090885,
0.0470413342,
0.1705882102,
0.5195421576,
0.2705587447,
-0.3802965581,
0.1583419293,
-0.7276782393,
0.0232109372,
-0.095404014,
-0.3749650419,
1.1876533031,
-0.3868378699,
0.0232156068,
0.3413240016,
0.602676332,
0.852801621,
0.6932473183,
0.1333263218,
0.3780940175,
0.881113708,
0.1294766515,
1.114459753,
-0.3833359778,
0.1176930368,
0.9808688164,
-0.5769297481,
0.3720191419,
0.6010626554,
0.2806766331,
0.5959852338,
0.5226274729,
-0.424990803,
0.7845989466,
0.1917131543,
-0.2566503882,
0.2000101507,
-0.1388268173,
-0.4213935137,
0.1571536213,
0.5212863088,
-0.5590891838,
-0.1613997817,
-0.0257076565,
0.0324329436,
-0.0701554343,
0.0286930464,
0.1431293637,
0.2705721259,
-0.9234085083,
0.7068279982,
0.0319052823,
0.6793698072,
-0.8180343509,
-0.0388325378,
-0.2507178187,
0.0594873279,
-0.0176820718,
-0.1944861859,
0.0665340349,
0.0737292022,
-0.2281634808,
0.0294172578,
0.910998702,
-0.3003844619,
-0.5852695107,
-0.3412312269,
0.3430631459,
0.3243433833,
0.3187225759,
-0.6844066381,
0.0708952993,
0.0051623797,
-0.2865208685,
0.2187857032,
0.9442087412,
-0.1183600426,
0.5405234694,
0.9968552589,
0.463498652,
-0.0961791649,
-0.3659234047,
0.8720973134,
-0.6891965866,
-0.620544374,
-0.7590841055,
0.044574786,
-0.293005079,
-0.5221494436,
1.0917173624,
0.4737153649,
0.2920211256,
-0.408111155,
1.0793149471,
-0.0193790887,
0.381909281,
-0.3474292457,
0.8598789573,
-0.5179206729,
0.2463270277,
-0.4131015837,
-0.9877493382,
-0.2969868779,
0.5928040743,
-0.3048513234,
0.0191100836,
1.2454054356,
0.6829668283,
-0.1462724656,
0.3897289336,
0.1994805187,
0.065461129,
0.5078170896,
0.5465451479,
0.9440600276,
-0.0131340194,
0.120653905,
-0.0972301587,
-0.2503913641,
-0.2514351308,
-1.2085087299,
-0.8492987156,
-0.4477426708,
-0.229309544,
-0.1642079055,
-0.0662972853,
0.8391564488,
0.493594557,
-0.616317153,
-0.0486873426,
-0.5274219513,
-0.1844990253,
-0.1951812208,
-0.2364068329,
0.4114761949,
-0.618406117,
-0.5264867544,
0.8746653199,
0.3327988684,
-0.0366506614,
-0.5460216403,
0.011166974,
0.0199969374,
0.1078211069,
0.3597094119,
0.4962780178,
-0.4562610388,
-0.1299280077,
0.2502164841,
-0.1677304357,
-0.2846136391,
0.9912406802,
-0.8165055513,
0.2991798222,
0.548400104,
0.6896198392,
0.5474068522,
-0.221182555,
0.7603352666,
-0.6612305641,
0.4130526185,
0.6354604959,
0.2793296278,
0.3516846299,
-0.2898747027,
0.587112546,
0.7830765843,
-0.3985141516,
-1.0838319063,
0.0967872515,
-0.59171772,
-0.4118296802,
0.9538472295,
0.0148705076,
-0.6924097538,
0.07816118,
-0.0498516485,
0.0351593606,
-0.2421940863,
0.9148461819,
0.4856895506,
-0.2559592426,
0.0546501167,
-0.7996312976,
0.5233709216,
0.6176231503,
-0.6902649999,
-0.4961008132,
0.3498444557,
0.4002867937,
0.7213180065,
0.2988322377,
-0.227866441,
0.2814830244,
0.2027531564,
0.2508392632,
-0.2476786524,
-0.4507935941,
-0.0683780462,
0.465246439,
0.0308289789,
0.0753133968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14257v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14257v3 | Hierarchical Prompting Assists Large Language Model on Web Navigation | 2023-05-23T17:10:39 | 2023-10-30T00:55:53 | Abishek Sridhar, Robert Lo, Frank F. Xu, Hao Zhu, Shuyan Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) struggle on processing complicated observations
in interactive decision making tasks. To alleviate this issue, we propose a
simple hierarchical prompting approach. Diverging from previous prompting
approaches that always put the full observation (e.g. a web page) to the
prompt, we propose to first construct an action-aware observation which is more
condensed and relevant with a dedicated SUMMARIZER prompt. The ACTOR prompt
then predicts the next action based on the summarized observation. While our
method has broad applicability, we particularly demonstrate its efficacy in the
complex domain of web navigation where a full observation often contains
redundant and irrelevant information. Our approach outperforms the previous
state-of-the-art prompting mechanics by 6.2% on task success rate,
demonstrating its potential on interactive decision making tasks with long
observation traces. | [
-0.2990347743,
-0.8698545098,
0.7725612521,
0.4415673614,
-0.0943052769,
-0.0669142455,
-0.1285423487,
-0.0486622341,
0.2796924114,
-0.0146983871,
-1.0094382763,
-0.4527470469,
-0.2705571949,
-0.0458284132,
-0.3589796126,
0.9854384661,
0.15817976,
-0.0931771845,
-0.2250492871,
0.3508529663,
-0.3196007013,
-0.0863709301,
-1.323723793,
-0.4284835458,
0.9883956313,
0.5992410779,
0.7068060637,
0.4635049701,
0.2196909487,
0.3652126789,
-0.2374964356,
0.4534717202,
-0.302780956,
0.1064219847,
-0.392249465,
-0.5039892197,
-0.7220270634,
-0.3163860738,
0.5863734484,
1.0643299818,
-0.2633933127,
-0.0466979071,
0.2237828672,
0.6856307983,
-0.6272746921,
0.3549254835,
-0.2338011414,
0.1983306557,
0.300984472,
-0.3664153814,
-0.4170721769,
-0.1709951609,
0.2519474626,
-0.8118346334,
0.0815499574,
0.2246341556,
0.3829716444,
0.2842348516,
-0.6466467381,
-0.0431046858,
-0.6713172197,
0.6774510145,
-0.4814310074,
0.2732657492,
0.6641104817,
0.3171622753,
-0.3005042672,
-0.7181087732,
-0.5903900862,
-0.1902424395,
0.0167389289,
0.3901070654,
-0.5926975012,
0.2740947306,
0.2805258632,
-0.0547928661,
-0.4704227149,
0.3000028431,
-0.0741572306,
-0.0771061853,
0.1596650481,
0.3203726113,
0.2793128788,
-0.2179486752,
-0.0824233964,
0.0537970252,
-0.7504945397,
0.3745746315,
0.0418096744,
0.4675914943,
-0.4805287123,
0.3757942617,
-0.486544311,
0.7905035019,
0.5886788368,
-0.1931512952,
-0.0929920971,
-0.1452762038,
-0.3294701874,
-0.0315407142,
0.4774257243,
0.620244801,
0.4291711748,
0.1882693022,
-0.1059222519,
-0.3122177422,
0.2087975889,
-0.6455253363,
-0.3463596404,
0.4950649738,
-0.4671039879,
-0.0788243786,
-0.0607078262,
-0.7381777167,
-0.5876179338,
-0.4994921684,
0.3248101771,
-0.2357615829,
-0.0453015678,
-0.0214337613,
0.0026686566,
0.2228438705,
0.9876195788,
-1.2287614346,
0.2679795027,
0.731189847,
0.6502858996,
-0.208413884,
-0.470987469,
-1.0662018061,
0.4316273332,
-0.3180779815,
0.9773119092,
-0.5090484023,
-0.4245987833,
0.2436622083,
-0.1193274781,
-0.0720539391,
-0.4571042061,
0.3416515291,
-0.47657305,
0.1164406016,
-0.3134444654,
-0.319070816,
-0.335391134,
0.6255538464,
-0.6089027524,
0.6307919025,
-0.2587077618,
-0.4891764522,
0.4651529193,
-0.4696974158,
-0.6125615835,
0.036238268,
-0.2022866309,
-0.0587032922,
0.0267190151,
0.7568016648,
0.4423172474,
0.0042407326,
0.2529598475,
-0.0290626567,
-0.1336359829,
0.0411660857,
-0.4383713007,
0.400887996,
-0.2156548202,
-0.2339668721,
0.4217736721,
-0.5457548499,
-0.2044619024,
-0.1889998764,
-0.6897289753,
-0.1743954122,
0.2635764182,
-0.3529475629,
-0.0054319394,
0.2540829778,
-0.06626679,
0.5971502066,
-0.1863760799,
-0.1862399131,
0.9240995049,
0.3475156724,
0.4629625976,
-0.3273304403,
0.7720322609,
-0.0637168959,
0.3192281723,
-0.3782520592,
-0.4509082735,
-0.9078023434,
-0.3030955195,
0.2550254166,
0.5252137184,
-0.8719623685,
0.2971711755,
-0.2249245346,
-0.0300044715,
-0.0808209702,
0.0539650545,
0.4647358358,
0.3906258643,
0.26375404,
0.220642522,
-0.5159593821,
-0.6395724416,
-0.132456407,
-0.4966694713,
-0.2409023046,
0.226763472,
0.4187128842,
-0.2541103959,
0.7432706952,
-0.465295732,
-0.1184337363,
-0.5444167256,
0.3918910027,
0.3951801062,
0.3752282858,
0.1568590254,
-0.9426721931,
-0.507383585,
0.0468492135,
-0.6976577044,
-0.0697064549,
-0.3675153852,
-0.0499371178,
-0.0643234178,
0.7546120882,
-0.6821655631,
0.3168738782,
0.4634081423,
-0.0692264363,
0.3715751767,
-0.1998860687,
0.2896980941,
-1.0193138123,
-0.0429479145,
0.0153340325,
-0.2475760877,
-0.8309199214,
0.018092785,
0.0267478637,
0.1871866733,
-0.2515152097,
0.4886852503,
-0.5539814234,
-0.0860036239,
-0.238773644,
0.2376440912,
-0.3043828905,
0.7747490406,
0.0944711193,
0.4511362612,
0.5784655213,
-1.0790028572,
0.0876500234,
0.2537742853,
-0.2002873868,
0.5696638227,
-0.5750359297,
-0.2663494349,
-0.313516885,
0.4520110786,
-1.2185140848,
-0.5489262938,
0.132491678,
-0.5352466702,
0.3142015636,
-0.3320996463,
-0.3951759338,
-0.3088189363,
-0.4446692169,
0.1856603473,
0.3426656127,
-0.6033226848,
0.8410058022,
0.0876475275,
-0.6461800337,
-0.5257476568,
-0.4976182282,
0.1360298544,
0.0375603139,
-0.3842293322,
0.1286953241,
-0.3421615362,
-0.3570714295,
-0.4368912876,
-0.2293971181,
0.1137457415,
0.0716875568,
0.2238649577,
0.3802148104,
-0.1564623564,
-0.0670547783,
0.3089248538,
-0.0682321787,
0.1631927639,
-0.0882760733,
0.4076498151,
0.1008966193,
-0.5270233154,
-0.9753422141,
0.4401215017,
0.6031628847,
0.0644943267,
0.2530530095,
0.0197565854,
-0.3771997094,
-0.1062029377,
-0.3018255234,
-0.1686326414,
-0.5114026666,
0.0629922003,
-0.1815971434,
-0.746955514,
0.4757481217,
-0.4752379954,
0.3508035243,
0.1345867962,
0.4721167088,
-0.3340196311,
1.6730293036,
0.5806606412,
-0.1078006998,
0.7024258375,
-0.1781241894,
0.1266479045,
-0.8283812404,
-0.4434343278,
-0.5279631615,
-0.4472257495,
-0.339109689,
-0.3526195288,
0.8392689824,
0.2311246693,
-0.2446757108,
-0.3679256141,
0.1570808142,
0.376213491,
0.5523058772,
0.247245878,
0.4674164057,
0.1268032193,
-0.2945307493,
0.1585830152,
-0.8701418638,
-0.0400241949,
0.3681314886,
-0.0876865089,
0.8959184289,
0.4469503462,
0.6825467348,
0.3219094574,
0.0790745094,
-1.1883416176,
0.796693027,
0.2387853861,
-0.2583178878,
-0.5614914894,
-0.268653959,
-1.329636693,
0.2013767064,
-0.3053907454,
-0.8796789646,
0.31737113,
0.5367299318,
-0.8084061742,
0.0285009854,
-0.4043262899,
0.4381106198,
-0.0367627107,
-0.3030328751,
-0.2926730216,
-0.6936531067,
0.0671892464,
0.1537577659,
0.4733830988,
0.3689520359,
-0.3819305003,
0.4258675873,
-0.459235549,
1.31503582,
-0.2241018116,
-0.1411972195,
0.007419745,
0.3325959444,
0.9910354614,
-0.3373292089,
0.1482503414,
-0.6122823954,
-0.7374639511,
-0.2189007849,
-0.7895855904,
0.5148661733,
-0.3346690238,
-0.8360939622,
-0.3909103274,
-0.3245722651,
-0.5627069473,
0.2031848282,
0.145570308,
0.5485988855,
-0.0786980391,
0.1652709246,
0.8561356068,
-0.1505252868,
0.805300653,
0.8190448284,
-0.459410578,
-0.2501551807,
0.487787962,
-0.2468645126,
0.1664419323,
0.7656424642,
0.5207125545,
-0.3019207716,
-0.7556011677,
-0.6276837587,
0.11362499,
-0.6035690904,
-0.2218148559,
-0.719497323,
0.0690293387,
-0.2155680954,
-0.4057932794,
0.1305471063,
-0.3941837549,
-0.1373057365,
-0.3393953145,
0.2680973709,
0.8413490653,
-0.0899597555,
0.3855706453,
-0.8773077726,
0.5438158512,
0.7505051494,
-0.0052387835,
0.6229378581,
-0.4200172424,
-0.2216923088,
-0.1033728346,
-0.0622386597,
-0.4381076097,
0.1054331139,
0.1661625057,
0.6996241212,
0.7839295268,
0.0441903584,
0.9727698565,
-0.5919106007,
1.0424870253,
0.4481720626,
-0.8697755933,
0.9091402292,
-0.7585004568,
1.0012434721,
0.5082401037,
0.6496695876,
-0.5518013835,
-0.3946275115,
-0.2330634296,
-0.9334067702,
0.6977601051,
-0.0173593909,
-0.0509060845,
-0.0233830921,
0.0110511109,
-0.0817225948,
0.2451963574,
-0.5311795473,
-0.3134945929,
0.2938995361,
0.1212444752,
0.1489548832,
-0.1267712861,
0.0579907484,
-0.3011206985,
0.5656962395,
-0.314974457,
-0.1314436644,
0.2257515937,
-0.0451919585,
-0.370087266,
0.29285869,
0.3794163167,
0.89464885,
0.1358210593,
0.0205548257,
0.2433052957,
-0.2702699304,
-0.0430702642,
-0.1208308488,
-0.2698392868,
-0.2369858027,
0.6599962115,
0.6378108859,
0.5530714989,
-0.6191852689,
0.5732612014,
-0.1372276843,
-0.0820986703,
-0.2360245734,
-0.0144391945,
0.123877719,
0.380920887,
0.5482463241,
-0.076914221,
0.5209389925,
-0.7974207401,
-0.0380702913,
0.1203330681,
-0.3662767708,
-0.0662894771,
0.5361423492,
0.3836078346,
-0.307577312,
0.6110023856,
-0.0700967312,
-0.4960802197,
0.492393136,
0.476598233,
0.8289031982,
-0.5491307378,
0.3376342356,
0.4101367891,
-0.0189304668,
-0.199424535,
0.3573361337,
-0.4843018651,
-0.3875689507,
-0.5266387463,
-0.4758877158,
-0.6680212021,
-0.1690876782,
-0.7913389802,
0.0223595817,
-0.4661559165,
-0.0168486722,
0.1375930905,
-0.3105176389,
-0.1369118243,
0.4040410817,
0.2033399493,
0.881501615,
-0.5345423222,
0.5243025422,
0.7341754436,
-0.1969163865,
-0.9334461093,
0.3835832775,
0.4102479815,
-0.7461904287,
0.5088862777,
-0.0169311874,
-0.6678840518,
-0.0876123011,
-0.5510481,
-0.6600840092,
0.9324426651,
0.0140436497,
-0.6436462998,
-0.1101447195,
-0.3712477088,
0.5304662585,
-0.2388858944,
0.0136976512,
0.4034263492,
0.6458233595,
0.450476557,
-0.8474767208,
0.1120964363,
-0.3475954831,
-0.0965610966,
0.3285920024,
-0.6333414912,
0.8184299469,
-0.5368902087,
-0.169206962,
0.2569249272,
0.6692459583,
0.3385757804,
0.3532481492,
0.8495287895,
0.0664905459,
1.0885794163,
0.2751179338,
1.2061430216,
-0.0008816599,
-0.0728050694,
1.2371208668,
-0.1504189521,
1.0062506199,
0.4351280332,
-0.0325025395,
0.8537169099,
0.7878388762,
0.3163761497,
0.5600278974,
-0.0076585263,
-0.6071204543,
-0.5373219252,
-0.3244485855,
0.0253998395,
0.3211972117,
0.5100231171,
-0.1646796167,
-0.2944087684,
-0.023770541,
0.2037213594,
-0.1146399379,
-0.999717176,
1.1478214264,
0.1268348545,
-1.3279989958,
0.438303411,
-0.2538534999,
0.3290432394,
-1.0077164173,
-0.3176307678,
-0.2667468786,
-0.0657139719,
-0.3976764977,
-0.7691105008,
-0.2338355035,
0.0985269845,
-0.4033761322,
-0.369332999,
0.3187207282,
-0.3612831533,
-0.200603053,
0.2182735503,
0.7477290034,
0.1666649431,
-0.049904041,
-0.4489835799,
-0.2034599632,
0.2554754317,
-0.2903161645,
0.3173042834,
0.5206461549,
-0.346829325,
0.924693346,
0.6857836246,
-0.0737861544,
-0.2222681344,
0.5077902675,
0.7516602874,
-0.7528369427,
-0.8841356635,
-0.8771921396,
0.591145277,
-0.1177825704,
-0.0894862711,
0.6796128154,
0.4081808329,
0.4368937612,
0.038010899,
0.8977009058,
0.1645794958,
0.3411291242,
-0.8039588332,
0.4129169285,
-0.6578965187,
0.2479011714,
-0.1088891178,
-0.6667969227,
-0.3990670443,
0.3553620577,
-0.1077669784,
0.2131452262,
0.8353601694,
0.6678946018,
-0.1455091238,
0.0529075637,
0.3167925179,
0.3787022233,
0.0015732093,
0.4233423769,
0.9710503221,
0.2234119028,
0.464145273,
0.1392612457,
-0.4689728022,
-0.5404574871,
-1.0143510103,
-1.0210067034,
-0.2804509401,
-0.1919258684,
-0.1091735587,
-0.0033999453,
1.157022953,
0.7250196338,
-0.7255372405,
-0.4213835597,
-0.0853823721,
0.229887709,
-0.5052643418,
-0.1143901497,
0.3015184999,
-0.1644618213,
-0.8507905006,
0.5816677213,
0.3605525792,
0.1999931335,
-0.0956238285,
0.0258836579,
-0.455016315,
0.0857263952,
0.8196730018,
0.341276139,
-0.6662350893,
-0.1765182614,
-0.2294930816,
0.0969261453,
0.0435061902,
1.0740811825,
-0.6710425615,
0.4245740175,
0.5258806944,
0.4254001677,
0.7020971775,
0.2036047578,
0.8517320752,
-0.7580842376,
-0.1676971763,
0.2182540298,
0.4879141748,
0.3146952391,
-0.4943889678,
0.309089452,
-0.2173571587,
-0.350481838,
-0.2627699673,
0.3988545537,
-1.2530741692,
-0.3394671977,
1.1151219606,
-0.1152820066,
-0.2543855011,
-0.165352419,
-0.42941764,
-0.0476970784,
-0.7853972912,
0.6055265069,
0.4954520166,
-0.5615311265,
-0.2095784396,
-0.3001820445,
0.4496042132,
0.3657247126,
-0.9348836541,
0.1429240555,
0.876873076,
-0.0866918489,
0.1055872664,
0.6667238474,
0.3809457719,
0.6839196086,
-0.0735434145,
-0.3607262969,
0.171693936,
-0.7482572198,
-0.6508619785,
0.1109070852,
0.0703449175,
0.0460112318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14256v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14256v2 | Linear Cross-Lingual Mapping of Sentence Embeddings | 2023-05-23T17:10:37 | 2024-06-27T03:43:18 | Oleg Vasilyev, Fumika Isono, John Bohannon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Semantics of a sentence is defined with much less ambiguity than semantics of
a single word, and we assume that it should be better preserved by translation
to another language. If multilingual sentence embeddings intend to represent
sentence semantics, then the similarity between embeddings of any two sentences
must be invariant with respect to translation. Based on this suggestion, we
consider a simple linear cross-lingual mapping as a possible improvement of the
multilingual embeddings. We also consider deviation from orthogonality
conditions as a measure of deficiency of the embeddings. | [
-0.2945831418,
-0.9469123483,
0.7173054218,
0.4522366226,
-0.1261145324,
-0.3592719138,
-0.1590267569,
-0.4785885215,
0.619302094,
0.1812970042,
-0.4661363363,
-0.4120823443,
-0.8757522106,
0.1252290606,
-0.3034855425,
0.8417158127,
-0.4494814575,
0.2550961673,
-0.3978949487,
-0.7521380782,
-0.6428283453,
-0.2523585558,
-0.140498504,
-0.1510088444,
0.5359759927,
0.2047443241,
1.2229479551,
0.6770407557,
0.4782128334,
0.3365750611,
0.1082862318,
-0.1177275628,
-0.4827617705,
0.1154870316,
-0.3093918562,
-0.5849896073,
-0.2721588612,
0.0930132717,
0.4594313204,
1.2317522764,
-0.0247528106,
-0.141519621,
0.0234783292,
0.5515778661,
-0.362931639,
0.1022468284,
-0.2760671675,
0.4434440434,
-0.1263320893,
-0.4315968752,
-0.1792421788,
-0.4378125072,
0.1882647723,
-0.947276473,
-0.1863729209,
0.3872437775,
1.0157381296,
0.014067593,
-0.636643827,
-0.5202162862,
-0.4345545471,
0.8884140849,
-0.5988115668,
0.6863706112,
0.2108095139,
-0.0770543516,
0.0050217621,
-0.5295874476,
-0.4980871677,
-0.1065047085,
-0.3616046011,
0.0822072402,
-0.1771743447,
-0.0145924985,
0.13263686,
0.0898491591,
-0.541264534,
0.0155521892,
-0.1391934454,
-0.2317555845,
0.4420692623,
0.2127733678,
0.8489207625,
-0.2656341493,
-0.9491161108,
0.0514417961,
-0.9252710938,
-0.0673148409,
0.3613693118,
0.3972125947,
-0.24537839,
0.5310729742,
0.0120874466,
0.4098829031,
-0.2497543991,
-0.2286211103,
0.5365966558,
-0.5984762907,
0.0241021756,
0.124811694,
0.4270161688,
0.6476060152,
0.5766533613,
-0.4479166865,
-0.0747212246,
0.2014576644,
-0.1013333052,
-0.4573567212,
0.1441557854,
-0.0421057194,
-0.7093273997,
0.2642524838,
0.1669036448,
-0.4527457356,
0.0597695857,
-0.5427074432,
0.2633139193,
-0.4426748157,
-0.0696050599,
0.3033137023,
-0.180628702,
0.1284424514,
0.0902505293,
-0.9208506942,
0.356408447,
0.7224877477,
0.6563848853,
-0.1555976868,
-0.7499707937,
-0.2606014311,
0.1618065834,
-0.5250843167,
0.5203719735,
-0.5144483447,
-0.1654489487,
0.392683953,
0.089993313,
-0.1161944196,
-0.1924883425,
0.5109764338,
-0.3627751768,
0.2517734766,
-0.4418838918,
-0.7664764524,
-0.4183285236,
0.2887921929,
-0.3830646276,
0.7236067057,
0.1082539186,
-0.5021405816,
0.6657995582,
-0.1540326476,
-0.4572909176,
-0.1510588527,
-0.1990170628,
-0.1491714567,
0.2623214126,
0.0432600267,
0.2194965631,
-0.1217374504,
0.1095836982,
-0.4497287273,
-0.1528886259,
0.3359185457,
-0.1297460943,
0.8622072935,
0.0907551199,
-0.1679598689,
-0.1821188778,
-0.4582584202,
0.4215030372,
-0.2509700358,
-0.4739131331,
-0.910320282,
0.1269418895,
0.26730901,
0.3720126152,
0.1331620365,
-0.7540794611,
0.3449425101,
-0.62295717,
0.2209188938,
0.5454495549,
0.0116999242,
0.6715564132,
-0.462251991,
0.4930258095,
0.2146350741,
-0.1961743534,
0.0495874025,
-0.7889806032,
-0.8136765361,
0.0326021016,
0.4533374608,
0.9544162154,
-0.4983244538,
0.2251774073,
-0.5565136075,
0.1083253473,
-0.7084400654,
0.5052044988,
0.4788013399,
-0.1682388037,
0.2581635118,
-0.1362871975,
-0.7111061811,
-0.8646495342,
-0.4659429193,
0.0563876182,
0.3984964192,
0.0145198423,
0.4758248627,
-0.4307667911,
0.7110883594,
-0.1529334337,
-0.5679864287,
-0.1623733938,
0.1846250147,
-0.155334428,
0.407666862,
0.8605148196,
-0.7458648682,
-0.6154236794,
0.2194491774,
-0.869790554,
-0.3452311456,
-0.3545882106,
-0.2559762299,
0.3289275467,
0.7949439287,
-0.4299253821,
0.5806973577,
0.632601738,
-0.6515806317,
-0.2668873668,
-0.4553108215,
0.099461332,
-0.8375805616,
-0.3345509768,
-0.2659852803,
-0.4254540503,
-0.636923492,
0.3062401116,
-0.033210516,
0.1331217587,
-0.4377779067,
0.1920632273,
-0.5884615779,
-0.1769768745,
0.0075002033,
0.8465491533,
0.0916159749,
0.3456522226,
-0.159971714,
0.2294469029,
0.5404896736,
-0.5460320115,
0.3828367889,
0.3575942516,
-0.2018475384,
0.8409793973,
-0.6561025977,
-0.1340104938,
-0.2744039297,
0.0639040172,
-0.9091937542,
0.2523536682,
0.1796201617,
-0.3062384129,
-0.0065496168,
0.3634409904,
-0.2639449537,
0.2527198792,
-0.359480828,
0.642699182,
0.1452913135,
-0.2009159327,
0.3500359058,
0.2775627971,
-0.0961785242,
-0.4988622367,
-1.1031692028,
-0.0903841034,
-0.1312010139,
-0.8054847121,
0.3769283295,
0.1154820547,
-0.4087305963,
0.4974515438,
0.2815814912,
0.0462572575,
-0.1374218762,
0.2852727175,
0.0409546383,
-0.7120284438,
0.5198616982,
0.1003500372,
-0.2901660502,
0.0436569266,
-0.3855626881,
0.3023843765,
-0.0077903471,
-0.5826787353,
-0.1328631192,
1.0232162476,
0.2174502015,
0.0696782917,
0.6024002433,
0.4966895282,
-0.3370457292,
-0.1947350204,
-0.1565988213,
0.2384827286,
-0.3804952204,
0.138108924,
-0.5069077015,
-0.7678228617,
0.5818748474,
-0.0512670688,
-0.3308586478,
0.51660496,
0.4279613495,
-0.1587014198,
0.6066741943,
0.7866481543,
0.0567296557,
-0.0821799487,
0.0681689307,
0.5533669591,
-0.4706204236,
-0.169585228,
-0.5968926549,
-0.5433644056,
-1.0175610781,
-0.2713732421,
0.1958319992,
-0.063089937,
-0.0208435934,
0.2868926227,
-0.0155595746,
0.394187808,
0.5039605498,
-0.2197223157,
0.0004378421,
-0.1347894669,
-0.4394383729,
-0.6513712406,
-0.6247310042,
-0.3784188926,
0.6838428378,
0.0868766308,
0.8970142603,
0.4616663754,
0.6377322078,
0.0259145107,
-0.4718378186,
-0.7960304022,
0.3348545432,
-0.2525083721,
-0.3408098519,
-0.2471570373,
-0.2575553656,
-1.3473768234,
0.3100856245,
-0.4101507664,
-0.6974399686,
0.605266571,
-0.0823768899,
-0.0557480864,
0.1123908833,
-0.7201128006,
1.0296570063,
-0.4304924309,
-0.0872795284,
-0.1208420172,
-0.5894330144,
-0.0340546034,
0.2359506339,
0.3686406314,
-0.1070302576,
-0.3346534371,
0.4998878837,
-0.3470579684,
0.7659495473,
-0.0417288095,
-0.0752686784,
0.0668244287,
0.3022428453,
0.2255958468,
-0.1411790997,
0.1298276484,
0.1057450771,
0.3157446384,
-0.6552442312,
-0.8775342703,
0.6178062558,
-0.7604458332,
-0.5161467195,
-0.4824664593,
-0.8656175733,
-0.151655674,
0.2981144488,
0.2226487249,
0.4136765599,
-0.3146895468,
0.3400311768,
0.6019399166,
-0.4498286247,
0.5045775175,
0.1948545277,
-0.5966161489,
0.2500861287,
0.697537601,
0.2651613951,
0.5400499105,
0.773711741,
0.1851409227,
-0.2016205937,
-0.3617168069,
-0.1112714335,
0.0163762737,
-0.9490368962,
0.0517008305,
-0.3918613195,
0.0169024505,
-0.5657693744,
-0.5962044597,
-0.0870543942,
-0.6468170285,
-0.0200627558,
-0.1649516672,
0.3043460548,
0.756749332,
-0.3259591758,
-0.0334864408,
-0.6723287106,
0.3695787787,
0.0655872971,
0.0165234432,
-0.4626080394,
-0.4737976789,
-0.1964438707,
0.1273847669,
-0.1204424277,
-0.6803518534,
0.3411189318,
0.617785275,
0.7183263898,
0.535654068,
-0.0274646264,
0.8871036172,
-0.611386776,
0.6797596216,
0.1879596859,
-1.3545786142,
0.5554576516,
-0.179149434,
0.426489383,
0.3312657475,
0.5755368471,
-0.9475114346,
-0.6332811117,
-0.3839986026,
-0.9314635992,
0.2086446583,
-0.2283572555,
0.5397371054,
-0.0540361553,
0.1192673221,
0.2078225911,
-0.1559303999,
-0.9363046288,
-0.2912168503,
-0.2089413106,
-0.0851138458,
-0.1227349713,
-0.3749954104,
-0.3717581928,
-0.2041476816,
0.301238656,
0.1547427326,
0.5105198026,
0.0994008109,
-0.5151332021,
0.0109435096,
0.3750728071,
0.7633078694,
0.7495129704,
0.0062103225,
0.4874854386,
0.3194215298,
-0.2602099478,
0.227786094,
-0.1851977557,
-0.1439502835,
0.2532114983,
0.7415722013,
0.7863630056,
0.6747078896,
-0.4077089131,
0.8071300983,
0.4511820078,
-0.0623953566,
-0.1582151502,
-0.3446965814,
0.2119451612,
-0.0146544231,
-0.1189587936,
0.0872548521,
0.0853964686,
-0.8617286682,
0.4006134272,
0.3552604616,
-0.3705645204,
-0.0284246225,
0.4563862681,
-0.0381949395,
-0.2858439386,
0.6279232502,
-0.2324074805,
-0.5880601406,
0.2937448025,
0.6970379949,
0.4651990831,
-0.247349605,
0.2310329676,
0.1076858416,
0.7208744287,
0.2315035909,
0.3777033389,
0.2188554257,
-0.9784548283,
-0.0706771538,
-0.1516507119,
-0.026548706,
-0.8561820984,
-0.8759057522,
0.3114512861,
-0.1098400578,
0.2297656238,
0.2117151767,
-0.4486589134,
-0.4793961942,
0.1659821868,
0.0729080886,
0.6645201445,
-1.0537382364,
0.9983100891,
0.620567441,
-0.5088739991,
-0.7188946605,
-0.2918609679,
0.1280394047,
-0.9398717284,
1.1146142483,
-0.1296972334,
-0.1518508941,
-0.6867189407,
-0.127287358,
-0.894099772,
0.8889020681,
0.5817539096,
-0.379961729,
0.0375514701,
0.6793166995,
0.7148295045,
-0.6758676171,
-0.0342126228,
0.1662885845,
0.5025220513,
-0.3793054819,
-0.8602815866,
0.1251373589,
-0.1476746649,
0.5589539409,
0.3238501847,
-0.2094996274,
1.2060666084,
0.0782853365,
-0.3477133811,
-0.1816736758,
0.4156856537,
-0.3509102762,
0.2278683931,
0.1886450201,
0.7997828126,
0.5463888645,
-0.4296445251,
1.3749756813,
-0.2980872691,
0.4615393579,
0.7979533076,
-0.0896684453,
1.0541123152,
0.7996315956,
-0.0022259299,
0.728330791,
0.2521596551,
0.2823368013,
0.6536191702,
0.2166656554,
0.1114572287,
-0.2428998053,
0.0848741531,
-0.4503051341,
0.5734608173,
0.5208367109,
-0.3945168853,
-0.344971031,
0.3383718431,
0.304982841,
0.5445966125,
-0.0740389377,
0.5129942894,
0.2473822087,
-0.5575702786,
0.6723784208,
0.0510078892,
0.5766581297,
-0.5132554173,
-0.0221885424,
-0.2739205062,
0.3317427039,
-0.472340256,
-0.6487757564,
0.7719498277,
-0.6306938529,
-0.2284127474,
-0.7005764246,
0.4487078786,
-0.7313904762,
-0.4925507307,
0.7523580194,
0.6246863008,
0.1746180654,
0.7972255945,
-0.5456192493,
0.2664483786,
-0.104534924,
-0.0236516092,
0.2157645673,
0.8653636575,
0.0374796018,
0.4836262465,
0.121656552,
0.2638166547,
0.6017807722,
-0.1803374588,
0.360601455,
-0.5258001685,
-0.4183443189,
-0.6047443748,
0.3623563647,
0.1799721718,
-0.7406774759,
0.995939672,
0.4817698896,
0.9935041666,
-0.0882534906,
0.3755533397,
-0.2264887691,
0.3208058476,
-0.9916174412,
0.3093349934,
-0.6267133951,
0.1627019048,
-0.2692169845,
-0.7824165821,
-0.4595906436,
1.0952208042,
-0.1900596917,
-0.0483896919,
1.4044519663,
0.9007462859,
-0.3072364926,
-0.1118552759,
0.4705804586,
0.0625368804,
-0.2579603791,
0.7800629735,
0.6944081187,
-0.675709486,
0.4089148045,
-0.0596228242,
0.0634244159,
0.0191589966,
-0.8118993044,
-0.515117228,
-0.8002129197,
-0.5114548206,
-0.280764997,
0.1587596983,
0.7522983551,
0.5302810669,
-0.9254553318,
-0.374583751,
-0.0616168901,
0.2383492142,
-0.53733778,
-0.1533805579,
0.2384995967,
-0.6166590452,
-0.8131625056,
0.0594099499,
0.470377326,
-0.0909662545,
-0.3164123595,
-0.181197688,
-0.6094517112,
0.2837358415,
0.6318368316,
0.0880461708,
-0.9175293446,
-0.8114080429,
-0.146257624,
-0.45476529,
0.1406497657,
0.8111582994,
-0.3302740157,
0.5748445988,
0.6711167693,
0.74589324,
0.2905875146,
-0.3807778656,
0.6945632696,
-0.876313448,
0.5958032012,
-0.0300699808,
0.6261634827,
0.2519600987,
-0.143789947,
0.3976525962,
0.2608668506,
-0.4138898551,
-0.3883447051,
0.5088954568,
-1.2114391327,
-0.1874269545,
1.2760722637,
-0.5964607,
0.0712532401,
-0.3833052218,
0.0005656626,
-0.0756610855,
0.1211341321,
0.4340395033,
1.0076218843,
0.1651118845,
-0.1151274219,
-0.6291500926,
0.2376416773,
0.608427465,
-0.723857522,
-0.5414094329,
0.4097522497,
0.1821682155,
0.4761682153,
0.2619817257,
-0.132908985,
0.364528507,
0.3608607054,
-0.1355222613,
0.4906326234,
-0.0482245572,
-0.2023672163,
0.2225976884,
-0.0693261251,
-0.4206217825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14251v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14251v2 | FActScore: Fine-grained Atomic Evaluation of Factual Precision in Long Form Text Generation | 2023-05-23T17:06:00 | 2023-10-11T05:27:50 | Sewon Min, Kalpesh Krishna, Xinxi Lyu, Mike Lewis, Wen-tau Yih, Pang Wei Koh, Mohit Iyyer, Luke Zettlemoyer, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Evaluating the factuality of long-form text generated by large language
models (LMs) is non-trivial because (1) generations often contain a mixture of
supported and unsupported pieces of information, making binary judgments of
quality inadequate, and (2) human evaluation is time-consuming and costly. In
this paper, we introduce FACTSCORE, a new evaluation that breaks a generation
into a series of atomic facts and computes the percentage of atomic facts
supported by a reliable knowledge source. We conduct an extensive human
evaluation to obtain FACTSCOREs of people biographies generated by several
state-of-the-art commercial LMs -- InstructGPT, ChatGPT, and the
retrieval-augmented PerplexityAI -- and report new analysis demonstrating the
need for such a fine-grained score (e.g., ChatGPT only achieves 58%). Since
human evaluation is costly, we also introduce an automated model that estimates
FACTSCORE using retrieval and a strong language model, with less than a 2%
error rate. Finally, we use this automated metric to evaluate 6,500 generations
from a new set of 13 recent LMs that would have cost $26K if evaluated by
humans, with various findings: GPT-4 and ChatGPT are more factual than public
models, and Vicuna and Alpaca are some of the best public models. FACTSCORE is
available for public use via `pip install factscore`. | [
-0.2607708275,
-0.8994884491,
1.0348900557,
-0.0386352316,
-0.158431977,
0.0847856551,
-0.3657613695,
-0.4631436765,
-0.2087036073,
0.4070704877,
-0.4196573496,
-0.6636286974,
-0.4235761464,
0.0640234724,
-0.1884578764,
1.0960671902,
0.3271685839,
-0.476991117,
-0.5460550785,
-0.0042899027,
0.0222849716,
-0.4528560638,
-0.2626778185,
-0.3680634499,
0.2552437782,
0.6035579443,
0.9591168165,
0.8315244913,
0.4074974358,
0.2919096351,
-0.2219962925,
0.4142171144,
-0.4653816223,
-0.0816904381,
-0.3174718022,
-0.2321127504,
-0.5557578206,
0.0793895274,
0.6035259962,
0.5649906993,
0.012731473,
0.4497339725,
-0.1985195279,
0.7812042832,
-0.5602732897,
0.3929679394,
-0.537024498,
-0.0711182952,
-0.3351432681,
-0.0146927079,
-0.5636851192,
-0.6584418416,
0.0026606377,
-0.2895455062,
0.4240913093,
0.09228383,
0.5953866243,
0.0309423748,
-0.4687734544,
-0.3505118191,
-0.7398956418,
0.9526723027,
-0.6918885112,
0.3868061602,
0.2317605615,
0.2845565677,
-0.251480937,
-0.5604759455,
-0.5507050753,
-0.7728584409,
0.1574056596,
0.0888752863,
-0.2314195931,
0.0970196277,
0.3734727502,
0.5118125081,
-0.470911026,
-0.0837415308,
-0.3675991893,
-0.2863591611,
0.7844658494,
0.0620436706,
0.2427655458,
-0.5872926712,
-0.6869466305,
-0.0481931306,
-0.5669659376,
-0.1917400509,
0.3538887501,
0.4262053967,
-0.0986880809,
0.7115859389,
-0.5840376616,
0.3831534386,
0.0418928899,
-0.4179769754,
0.2609777451,
-0.4646859765,
0.1354728043,
0.3631668389,
0.903465271,
0.4523606002,
0.2611339986,
-0.2169750333,
-0.1803042442,
0.2233037502,
0.1689996421,
-0.8914190531,
0.0224084649,
0.2077580541,
-0.3331600726,
-0.2914368212,
-0.0150629366,
-0.6953644753,
-0.5410926342,
-0.1738653183,
0.4171000719,
-0.5976806879,
0.0015716939,
0.1304822117,
-0.2590527833,
-0.1380811483,
0.2839409113,
-0.509955585,
0.266818285,
0.7929994464,
0.9186791778,
-0.0119707156,
-0.2647162974,
-0.3108564019,
-0.0162242018,
-0.1381897777,
1.1588726044,
-0.1895529181,
-0.4147951305,
-0.2752135694,
-0.4715558589,
0.4035398066,
-0.5259939432,
0.821821034,
-0.4727499783,
0.0037767717,
-0.1467590481,
-0.7379001975,
-0.0701965094,
0.2511829138,
-0.7873348594,
0.987238884,
0.2450396866,
-0.6477844119,
0.3311462998,
-0.5743361712,
-0.5041500926,
0.2987231016,
-0.0719433203,
-0.4608643651,
0.0745133013,
0.0366838723,
0.3523378372,
-0.6380484104,
0.5834525824,
-0.3737293184,
-0.1375308335,
0.3118377626,
-0.7993468046,
0.5496791601,
0.3692242205,
-0.5152909756,
-0.1175884157,
-0.9397947192,
0.0271108989,
-0.0873525217,
-0.4361087978,
-0.0993392542,
0.1922212839,
-0.1476893574,
0.1584445983,
0.4630953372,
-0.6945908666,
0.0349594168,
-0.1760367304,
0.3049103618,
0.5573586822,
0.2179351598,
0.1068620607,
-0.523599565,
0.2437980771,
-0.0296669491,
0.4258784354,
0.0115337828,
-0.4448711574,
-0.5647193789,
-0.1242984682,
0.132049188,
0.2188953161,
-0.3942991793,
0.5748409629,
-0.5614208579,
-0.9267027974,
-0.196080789,
0.1172525585,
0.4527434707,
0.6809197068,
0.3876008391,
-0.3505421281,
-0.3835659921,
-1.1076620817,
-0.3052460253,
-0.37579301,
0.2163805813,
0.1663738489,
0.5126409531,
-0.2010790408,
1.2987746,
-0.6456608772,
0.1464394927,
-0.0441061817,
0.5154798031,
0.1936214268,
0.2014146,
0.1016656756,
-0.5978656411,
-0.1266998053,
-0.0543676242,
-0.7470477819,
0.0447998606,
-0.096075885,
0.0133336717,
0.2293718308,
0.305329591,
-0.8292115927,
0.0833332911,
0.5514937043,
-0.2569363117,
0.8949106336,
-0.2569746077,
0.2642444074,
-0.8144004345,
0.2911223173,
0.1885950118,
-0.4051293731,
-0.2911993265,
0.1976032257,
0.1313307285,
-0.1085865572,
-0.5721046329,
0.5041903257,
-0.4218288958,
-0.0531241894,
-0.1417824626,
0.3352439702,
-0.0300775412,
0.1611580402,
-0.2329224646,
0.8914138079,
-0.1121760383,
-0.4382897615,
0.4676094055,
-0.0901755467,
-0.8030073047,
0.4217637777,
-0.4366384745,
0.2394521087,
-0.103785865,
0.3985309005,
-0.70672822,
-0.1877093017,
-0.2103061974,
-0.332726717,
-0.147561118,
-0.147456944,
-0.4041190743,
-0.2424072325,
-0.5271381736,
0.2302607447,
0.61069417,
-0.3013620377,
0.4259183407,
0.4520358741,
-0.2580397427,
-0.3619464636,
-0.30484882,
0.2608170211,
0.0722125173,
-0.7275059223,
0.1211048663,
-0.2704196274,
-0.49233073,
0.1000584736,
-0.1987864971,
-0.0772784427,
0.2273580879,
0.2128328085,
0.2027345151,
-0.3337329626,
0.1743309796,
-0.0002943221,
-0.1028297096,
0.0976566672,
0.0013529467,
0.5792995095,
-0.2760019004,
-0.2487843782,
-0.4058881104,
0.1034292579,
0.6810368896,
-0.1290712804,
0.5665350556,
0.1970089972,
-0.2285581529,
-0.3302261829,
-0.655403018,
0.1053377911,
-0.4020207822,
0.5487341285,
-0.0973072276,
-0.7338561416,
0.2145576626,
-0.085810788,
-0.0412216559,
0.9762844443,
0.5951313972,
0.1785360277,
0.9941432476,
0.1636010557,
-0.1063813716,
0.074530296,
-0.0302846022,
0.0064768852,
-0.4738228321,
-0.1170316339,
-0.4181165993,
0.0749205053,
-0.4979743063,
-0.5798788667,
0.4592913985,
-0.0568066314,
-0.3858726025,
0.1421241909,
-0.0693641976,
0.5878431797,
0.5324674845,
0.3349145651,
0.7170639634,
-0.1560605317,
0.3778311014,
0.3923637867,
-0.5451177955,
-0.7476739883,
1.1886578798,
0.3586464226,
0.5629472733,
0.1739868224,
0.7676582932,
0.8539094329,
0.559104681,
-0.9208660722,
0.610011816,
-0.4036861062,
-0.8837179542,
-0.2159653902,
-0.8521769047,
-0.5335970521,
-0.3029451668,
-0.3072184622,
-0.3803238273,
-0.1320852786,
0.1771574616,
-0.7196108103,
0.1137593463,
-0.7491415143,
0.5506016612,
-0.4024538696,
-0.3778976202,
-0.4186824858,
-0.5148186684,
0.6340467334,
-0.1867266148,
0.4146460295,
-0.350605309,
0.2435654402,
0.7810481787,
-0.4821795821,
0.7166086435,
-0.0321336947,
-0.2145942748,
0.5280835629,
0.1243770048,
0.411180079,
0.0579965636,
-0.3687771261,
0.0494553521,
-0.1751111895,
-0.249541074,
-0.5419227481,
0.7782879472,
-0.8248757124,
-0.5879307985,
-0.5408662558,
-0.4697931111,
-0.1895255744,
0.3839260936,
0.1815027595,
0.6582620144,
-0.5323402286,
0.2744274437,
0.4865150154,
-0.0291783735,
0.0174784325,
0.2671502829,
-0.1033447906,
-0.5088564754,
0.9449301362,
0.256252408,
0.4205506742,
0.2414523661,
0.5026604533,
-0.4212726951,
-0.4601764083,
-0.5114174485,
0.322991401,
-0.6714652181,
-0.3041809201,
-0.5596048236,
-0.1999136508,
-0.3394988477,
0.1634205431,
-0.6136041284,
-0.5350379348,
-0.0305740666,
-0.0895681158,
0.3151659369,
0.8034542203,
0.0851204619,
0.2662284374,
-1.010196209,
0.4655508399,
0.5392178893,
0.4025311768,
-0.0609886758,
-0.2812733948,
-0.3721151948,
0.2372709215,
-0.364957571,
-0.6467444301,
-0.0851818845,
0.2653720975,
0.2260842025,
0.4056173861,
0.3094148636,
0.6168868542,
-0.5452111363,
0.837411046,
0.1166058853,
-1.1278584003,
0.2069367468,
-0.2453724444,
0.1567594111,
0.8178497553,
0.2364995629,
-0.6107198,
-0.1680137962,
-0.8407362103,
-0.7620403767,
0.6754799485,
0.0302339885,
0.0314957686,
-0.253703922,
0.3760249019,
0.187077567,
0.0466118231,
-0.3685267866,
-0.1806344688,
0.0125901178,
-0.4491050243,
-0.2737105191,
-0.4825850129,
-0.0870143548,
0.005302093,
0.6867570877,
-0.0388802364,
-0.0647654161,
0.216789633,
-0.3343500197,
-0.136565268,
0.4751102626,
0.5944009423,
0.6658986807,
-0.5320658088,
0.4275815785,
0.1148064658,
-0.4551640451,
0.1081235632,
0.0500155874,
-0.3606497347,
-0.0758320689,
0.4721102417,
0.8298922181,
0.2950325906,
-0.7018218637,
0.6034104824,
0.1126205698,
0.0164224841,
-0.3308337629,
0.2480839342,
0.1058739647,
0.2258398086,
0.2846696675,
0.1545934528,
0.2816183567,
-0.9098605514,
0.3635881841,
0.2923745215,
-0.2171223909,
-0.4243448973,
0.3801393509,
0.3839411438,
-0.1763040721,
0.6143236756,
-0.4083508551,
-0.6548628807,
0.4970656633,
0.6037859321,
0.8209600449,
0.0033681174,
0.4331765771,
0.340069443,
0.1293022484,
-0.447159797,
0.0299165007,
-0.0430810824,
-0.6673996449,
-0.5587017536,
-0.7841733694,
-0.6530998349,
-0.0288092326,
-0.3499639332,
0.2469752282,
-0.5089321733,
-0.3908717632,
0.0332705528,
0.3476961851,
-0.3612268269,
0.4754229784,
0.4247603118,
0.9669632912,
-0.9214778543,
0.4464401901,
0.4050754011,
-0.4793330729,
-0.5818924904,
0.0259701312,
-0.0389634669,
-0.563975513,
0.580504179,
0.1251798421,
-0.5011001825,
0.1114391237,
-0.4171087742,
-0.7550154328,
0.9414315224,
0.5137902498,
-0.5381188393,
-0.0182522889,
0.1384805739,
0.381960541,
0.0638949126,
0.5556807518,
0.7425812483,
0.6458914876,
-0.2286531925,
-0.6801716685,
0.0488246903,
-0.1062714234,
-0.2247241735,
0.2796204686,
-0.9324430227,
1.035836935,
-0.124816142,
-0.622296989,
0.0574658774,
0.7734707594,
0.4060142934,
0.4483120739,
0.6672685146,
0.5262542963,
0.9302693605,
0.180360347,
1.2078288794,
-0.4489901662,
0.7343398333,
0.8619340062,
-0.2868826985,
0.7062181234,
0.129165262,
-0.5033333898,
0.5393053889,
0.1341938376,
0.1135624871,
-0.0571504571,
0.0432405397,
-0.5111460686,
-0.4071194232,
-0.1871601194,
-0.1800563931,
0.4995531738,
-0.0931247547,
-0.2124216706,
-0.4748611748,
-0.5777727365,
0.5161849856,
0.1865129322,
-0.2201120555,
0.637247622,
-0.0389314517,
-0.6805369854,
0.434578836,
0.089413859,
0.5423568487,
-0.5887497067,
0.0066675125,
-0.2359015644,
0.215163365,
-0.3850620687,
-0.8422733545,
-0.0089624394,
0.4744679332,
-0.4081045985,
0.1547175795,
0.5351763964,
-0.2701389492,
-0.7168323398,
-0.0572127141,
0.3852985203,
0.1895678788,
-0.272580415,
-0.3171401322,
0.0154509619,
0.0080327438,
-0.3351891041,
0.0827536806,
0.2933837473,
-0.2257305831,
0.4661489725,
0.8145699501,
0.3007544577,
-0.1050603315,
-0.0886163712,
0.6201934218,
-0.978100419,
-0.2860170603,
-1.1262664795,
0.2747046947,
-0.2547433972,
-0.4611080587,
0.8122239709,
0.8277395368,
0.5357359052,
0.0641014129,
1.0322341919,
-0.06185982,
0.4643055797,
-0.5893876553,
0.9497944117,
-0.2220563591,
-0.0627786815,
-0.2552647293,
-1.0899649858,
-0.1418001503,
0.1542652249,
-0.4150093198,
0.0238450542,
0.6079015136,
0.5560141802,
-0.0530513413,
0.1612750888,
0.2195074111,
0.3845657706,
0.4498774409,
0.3314423561,
0.9592751265,
-0.1947666258,
0.301571548,
-0.5431511998,
-0.4623970091,
-0.3391925693,
-1.1273832321,
-0.2117624432,
-0.3050450981,
-0.2404795289,
-0.2343066037,
0.1432834268,
1.2577941418,
0.4565875828,
-0.5536141992,
-0.329993546,
0.1790442914,
0.081383884,
0.0213364884,
-0.2169524133,
0.5925205946,
-0.3981610537,
-0.6305124164,
0.5099134445,
0.1304765195,
-0.3619219661,
-0.2789791524,
0.0890763327,
-0.0465805642,
0.1848737746,
0.8781234622,
0.1643058658,
-0.2400578111,
-0.6222422719,
-0.2863273025,
-0.2515232861,
0.2057967931,
0.5776008964,
-0.7802253962,
0.380864948,
0.4254452586,
0.4257888198,
0.295799762,
0.5738043189,
0.3119026124,
-0.4780310392,
-0.1588493735,
0.2610002458,
0.1247629523,
0.4477757514,
-0.3506955802,
0.09513212,
0.4426834285,
-0.6778273582,
-0.7074488997,
0.2457053959,
-1.037956357,
-0.1706557721,
1.1941931248,
0.108314395,
-0.6221050024,
0.0042473567,
-0.1913878471,
0.5031530857,
-0.6387353539,
0.9552618861,
0.5599966049,
-0.1385153234,
0.3424520195,
-0.4254853725,
0.3566950262,
0.2079191208,
-0.8767202497,
0.3231181204,
0.7697744966,
0.2492659092,
0.3809063733,
0.3864929974,
-0.2047796547,
0.2523369193,
0.0533627234,
0.4080844522,
-0.2551988661,
-0.3457525373,
-0.030685937,
0.2998826802,
0.4353549182,
0.3042824566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14250v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14250v2 | Language Models with Rationality | 2023-05-23T17:04:25 | 2023-10-29T14:51:48 | Nora Kassner, Oyvind Tafjord, Ashish Sabharwal, Kyle Richardson, Hinrich Schuetze, Peter Clark | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While large language models (LLMs) are proficient at question-answering (QA),
it is not always clear how (or even if) an answer follows from their latent
"beliefs". This lack of interpretability is a growing impediment to widespread
use of LLMs. To address this, our goals are to make model beliefs and their
inferential relationships explicit, and to resolve inconsistencies that may
exist, so that answers are supported by interpretable chains of reasoning drawn
from a consistent network of beliefs. Our approach, which we call REFLEX, is to
add a rational, self-reflecting layer on top of the LLM. First, given a
question, we construct a belief graph using a backward-chaining process to
materialize relevant model beliefs (including beliefs about answer candidates)
and their inferential relationships. Second, we identify and minimize
contradictions in that graph using a formal constraint reasoner. We find that
REFLEX significantly improves consistency (by 8%-11% absolute) without harming
overall answer accuracy, resulting in answers supported by faithful chains of
reasoning drawn from a more consistent belief system. This suggests a new style
of system architecture in which an LLM extended with a rational layer can
provide an interpretable window into system beliefs, add a systematic reasoning
capability, and repair latent inconsistencies present in the LLM. | [
-0.331949085,
-0.6991271973,
0.8350383043,
0.3629055023,
-0.0226885937,
0.0695775822,
-0.1478068978,
-0.4708903432,
0.2804679573,
0.581143558,
-0.3631419539,
-0.0480221435,
-0.3208629489,
0.0931790918,
-0.1832021177,
0.7505474091,
0.0193102341,
0.163565129,
0.0354114063,
-0.3220834732,
-0.4084848166,
-0.5754583478,
-0.5338839889,
-0.5929150581,
0.5136064887,
0.527970314,
0.9112266898,
0.5158164501,
0.2358449399,
0.30673033,
0.0747448429,
-0.0345100388,
-0.1829310656,
0.3706637919,
-0.4505266249,
-0.608618319,
-0.6401780248,
-0.1111062691,
0.8037348986,
0.7559996843,
-0.1498695314,
0.0764980987,
-0.0985979363,
0.764283061,
-0.4299530685,
0.0947375298,
-0.5678914785,
-0.0907784179,
0.1637573987,
-0.2944007814,
-0.6136440039,
-0.4327690601,
0.1091300845,
-0.4465251863,
-0.079839088,
0.0891634822,
0.7518694997,
0.1302939355,
-0.5114067197,
-0.0445749722,
-0.9373906255,
0.7315567136,
-0.9920837879,
0.5131052732,
0.2454668581,
0.2365053594,
-0.2258851975,
-0.3006042242,
-0.7801530361,
-0.1279789656,
-0.112017788,
-0.1168401912,
0.1500107944,
0.1415020674,
0.5884076953,
0.2825229764,
-0.5848819017,
-0.1950648129,
0.1817237586,
-0.0137896175,
0.5558626652,
0.2608682811,
0.2486766726,
0.029455442,
-0.469471097,
0.1571040601,
-0.9270180464,
0.0715343133,
0.2184807211,
0.1276682317,
0.3491183817,
0.5688574314,
-0.3243511617,
0.6130373478,
0.1651832908,
-0.1971586496,
-0.0753368214,
-0.1183955073,
-0.3117977977,
-0.1644557267,
0.4202518165,
0.3154243827,
0.3773947656,
0.0456769839,
-0.5914695859,
0.2203702182,
0.0356277525,
-0.6980721951,
-0.0547614768,
0.3115992546,
-0.3801640868,
-0.0504421704,
-0.0805888921,
-0.4319869876,
-0.2690050304,
-0.588620007,
0.3550677896,
-0.4050472379,
-0.7611200213,
0.4020398557,
0.0456737876,
0.5461540222,
0.5756864548,
-0.972376883,
0.7292547226,
0.9344571829,
0.5790479779,
0.1390766501,
-0.1301785856,
-0.207114175,
0.1677239686,
-0.528059423,
0.8985773921,
-0.5917274952,
-0.0159322135,
-0.0319738761,
0.1443351209,
-0.0730097145,
-0.5227181911,
0.3841378987,
-0.8242169619,
0.3394261599,
-0.4151609838,
-0.885763526,
-0.4346933365,
0.513874054,
-0.4399321377,
0.7609854341,
0.0097366683,
-0.6061217189,
0.1532793641,
-0.4331407547,
-0.1388934851,
0.0728936121,
-0.1248251274,
0.0044919658,
0.3118722439,
-0.2335569412,
0.1071453094,
-0.3833130598,
0.5741671324,
-0.475938797,
-0.0790514722,
0.4557453394,
-0.393982023,
0.711999774,
0.2321732491,
-0.3400151134,
0.3304753602,
-0.7155690789,
0.2690440416,
0.1006736234,
-0.3624891639,
-0.2232538611,
0.3138790429,
-0.2395870239,
0.290481776,
0.2305040658,
-0.5178471208,
0.3421079814,
-0.5800557137,
0.314173758,
0.8991783261,
-0.1373244673,
0.6445069909,
-0.5110253692,
0.4348812699,
-0.0051119826,
0.1769889891,
-0.2225690037,
-0.4864682853,
-1.0970779657,
0.1526367068,
-0.1005576551,
0.6654533148,
-0.4484420419,
0.2587397695,
-0.1712015718,
-0.2802919149,
-0.1515560448,
0.1391209364,
0.5296744108,
0.7667907476,
0.2127977759,
-0.3391331434,
-0.536442101,
-1.0687248707,
-0.4281006157,
-0.5475030541,
0.1062906981,
0.2713996768,
0.3145268559,
-0.0878235325,
0.9092040062,
-0.5314096212,
0.171128571,
-0.1067212,
-0.0526583418,
0.5231518149,
0.6126348376,
0.1129502505,
-0.6805158257,
-0.4868609011,
-0.1596805155,
-0.8380514383,
-0.0414659753,
-0.0866682529,
-0.1361928135,
0.459007591,
0.1780749708,
-0.7999933362,
0.1470389664,
0.3499495387,
-0.6943659782,
0.6823092103,
-0.0840693787,
0.0730221793,
-0.8559521437,
0.0909245461,
0.0293924231,
-0.3783719838,
-0.8121606708,
0.065280363,
0.1162325591,
0.0986059606,
-0.1975425482,
0.7372341156,
-0.421982348,
-0.1314310133,
-0.3283748031,
0.1071022376,
0.2282145619,
0.4974822402,
0.2469591051,
0.6052494645,
0.3980536461,
-0.4589644074,
0.3054557741,
0.1192090362,
-0.1823819429,
0.5565083623,
-0.685582757,
0.2312652022,
-0.0802638158,
0.1963961869,
-1.1082425117,
-0.3040010929,
0.3461510241,
-0.3988396227,
0.2884893715,
-0.2411146909,
-0.3860776722,
-0.1390090734,
-0.0807882845,
0.47099033,
0.4922814965,
-0.5124745369,
0.8476092219,
0.3022011817,
-0.1642354131,
-0.6752330065,
-0.5096766353,
0.0723603815,
-0.0752259642,
-0.90999192,
-0.0730857328,
-0.1770516038,
-0.7429483533,
-0.0033814923,
-0.1222823858,
-0.2845155895,
0.2087460309,
0.0268589668,
0.516443193,
-0.7789465189,
0.4268073142,
-0.0848446861,
-0.2254373282,
0.3108188212,
-0.4471744895,
0.4511538446,
-0.5277299285,
-0.3062776625,
-0.4109369516,
0.3769938648,
0.6433435678,
-0.022463806,
0.8048703074,
-0.1908489913,
-0.3815891147,
-0.2472413629,
-0.8385946751,
-0.4391782582,
-0.4889687598,
-0.0909545347,
-0.5762547255,
-0.8543899655,
0.683457911,
-0.1002380401,
-0.0833376125,
0.2284327149,
0.4058595002,
0.0153822629,
1.1978510618,
0.5421002507,
0.1910467148,
0.4233502448,
0.0924620628,
0.2560955584,
-0.866101861,
-0.2448531985,
-0.3069299161,
-0.0458998717,
-0.3245849013,
-0.2734734714,
0.0459002107,
0.4228118956,
-0.5653858781,
0.1514514536,
-0.475051403,
0.4978758693,
0.2357002795,
0.0288864244,
0.48528862,
-0.3037604392,
-0.066390574,
0.0609451495,
-0.6932143569,
-0.9331339598,
0.785028398,
0.5272936225,
0.8229637742,
0.4009698629,
0.333439678,
-0.1024081483,
0.8295608163,
-0.7833731771,
0.6993253231,
0.304499805,
-1.0252764225,
-0.3622941375,
-0.3049011827,
-0.4126565158,
0.5344369411,
-0.1917443722,
-0.5543647408,
0.2515007854,
0.3967794478,
-0.2004149407,
0.4143775105,
-0.763905108,
0.7974333763,
-0.1561464965,
-0.6397000551,
-0.2620635033,
-0.602329433,
0.568926096,
0.0685266331,
0.0204667766,
-0.3028099835,
-0.2132040709,
0.428200841,
-0.4582108855,
0.94068259,
-0.2792054415,
-0.4992461205,
0.2994779944,
0.4441678822,
0.6519123912,
0.1554478705,
-0.2407250106,
-0.1409987658,
0.0356270373,
-0.3982897699,
-0.989983201,
0.6882199645,
-0.4503912628,
-1.2833877802,
-0.5016569495,
-0.5545483828,
-0.3714939058,
0.3128193915,
-0.4130990207,
0.5619320869,
-0.1767721921,
-0.0996468142,
0.7556859851,
-0.0642024651,
0.3209272325,
0.9061136246,
-0.5709044933,
-0.4277439415,
0.6145273447,
-0.0052916636,
0.5569602251,
0.2717410028,
0.3323558271,
-0.4118417203,
-0.2708746195,
-0.361135751,
0.4739202857,
-0.8145109415,
-0.16466254,
-0.5682202578,
-0.2317837775,
-0.4186449945,
-0.0533884689,
-0.2964999676,
-0.6498120427,
-0.0498905033,
0.0468825176,
0.2776533067,
0.8376510739,
-0.060208939,
0.09948764,
-0.7449367642,
0.1387533247,
0.2971213162,
0.5211135149,
0.0258947555,
-0.6461696625,
-0.0665203705,
0.0529054739,
-0.1771378964,
-0.8730425239,
0.3918799162,
0.0623297654,
0.2677396536,
0.4631039202,
-0.0711397678,
0.5528902411,
-0.7084754705,
0.4488829374,
0.3785997033,
-1.1349639893,
0.5740957856,
-0.4318780005,
0.0856689215,
0.2351231128,
0.4022468328,
-0.6421490908,
-0.4520554841,
-0.5517552495,
-0.3438475132,
0.3804188371,
-0.319832474,
0.2234421372,
-0.1699142754,
0.4972908199,
0.0308199264,
0.0246621296,
-0.8006940484,
0.0261460692,
-0.2448099554,
-0.0646922737,
0.0158902463,
-0.5220489502,
-0.2693317533,
-0.2510829568,
0.6314186454,
-0.4350937605,
0.0518524945,
0.4939188361,
0.0610543303,
-0.4058197737,
0.5410212874,
0.6301119924,
0.9046353698,
-0.1368739754,
0.4397533238,
0.1614156961,
-0.0036074752,
0.4328086376,
-0.3334009051,
-0.3571102917,
-0.209815979,
0.2727919221,
0.5690683722,
0.1575354785,
-0.5775474906,
0.5046589375,
0.1256179065,
-0.0165815577,
-0.5005941391,
0.1423564404,
0.175380066,
0.4407220483,
0.2589339912,
0.4003930688,
0.0576243959,
-0.7697262168,
0.1934652328,
0.4850517809,
-0.3889857531,
-0.6805530787,
0.3906301856,
0.1307083815,
-0.5730155706,
0.3846116364,
0.1560247391,
-0.7379680872,
0.416824013,
0.8339545131,
0.917193532,
-0.4120063782,
0.2682551146,
0.4399200082,
0.2621406019,
-0.3683103025,
0.5117077827,
0.0931805819,
-1.1975769997,
-0.6926700473,
-0.3149508536,
-0.5400838852,
-0.1874767393,
-0.5136432052,
0.0747066066,
-0.747166574,
-0.1281665713,
-0.2683359981,
-0.0618866198,
-0.1740326136,
0.2218879163,
-0.0903798118,
1.1014691591,
-0.7073660493,
1.068929553,
0.3951279819,
-0.5939221978,
-0.9885531068,
-0.086053513,
-0.1751072705,
-0.750472784,
0.9728319645,
0.0176667497,
-0.3619303405,
0.01533652,
-0.7412249446,
-0.9138364792,
0.7100092769,
0.6244817972,
-0.6304590106,
0.087438494,
-0.0920325816,
0.5868957043,
-0.5272681117,
0.1916877478,
0.3146417141,
0.5337334871,
0.0663984194,
-0.7198238969,
0.4182133079,
-0.2206656933,
-0.1795502454,
0.179047212,
-0.6852074862,
0.797896564,
-0.3717729151,
-0.4344008565,
0.1563300192,
0.5039215088,
0.3171819448,
0.206550315,
0.5388018489,
0.6216310859,
0.8021553755,
-0.0661709681,
1.0542732477,
-0.5181577206,
0.2588414848,
1.2229324579,
-0.606726706,
1.11079669,
0.6291746497,
-0.0442719758,
0.7802604437,
0.3312470615,
0.326613158,
0.1723635644,
0.1727589518,
-0.5553680062,
-0.6095540524,
-0.1833728105,
-0.2271452397,
0.0662521124,
0.3362334073,
-0.3050253689,
0.062487863,
-0.2968842685,
-0.0234869979,
0.2415357232,
-0.0581413619,
0.709369123,
0.2287626714,
-1.0167760849,
0.6469621658,
-0.1814897507,
0.3157678843,
-0.47421965,
-0.2026402652,
-0.4057155252,
0.4205817282,
-0.3049992919,
-0.9989343286,
0.4043420255,
-0.1898189932,
-0.3536797464,
-0.4731479883,
0.943646431,
-0.4163629413,
-0.2523910403,
0.4677032232,
0.6450368762,
-0.0338555723,
0.1135601252,
-0.6373130679,
0.0454887487,
-0.2305346876,
-0.3973177671,
-0.0257884897,
0.6927345395,
0.1546307057,
1.0266078711,
0.6263073087,
0.1927640736,
-0.1047613546,
0.0310148802,
1.1285462379,
-0.8910423517,
-0.0834985077,
-0.8680641055,
0.3483140171,
-0.0051644822,
-0.1308782846,
0.8658017516,
0.5135151148,
0.5214902163,
0.1473238766,
0.5215356946,
0.1496635079,
0.5654252172,
-0.5097400546,
0.4671717286,
-0.4261139929,
0.4768339097,
0.0164571367,
-0.9953801036,
-0.4805461168,
0.7300007343,
-0.4850414693,
-0.1713461131,
0.7659670711,
0.9982336164,
0.0789244622,
0.1960175335,
0.4410762489,
0.5300478339,
0.3856833875,
0.6044933796,
1.3060983419,
-0.3689898551,
0.0727338791,
0.0831749439,
-0.3460866213,
-0.0372304991,
-0.8003185987,
-0.6642125249,
-0.396490097,
-0.3141603172,
-0.6929441094,
-0.1217119843,
0.8719575405,
0.676512897,
-0.983048737,
-0.5385469198,
-0.2750598788,
0.3465162218,
0.0858359858,
-0.2565855086,
-0.0961581692,
-0.6058894396,
-0.2459269464,
0.2918919921,
0.4702663422,
0.0077290926,
-0.5618985295,
-0.2963446081,
-0.3951140046,
0.5221000314,
0.6540586948,
0.6011301279,
-0.9162925482,
-0.7246482372,
0.2494154423,
-0.104154624,
0.2264917493,
0.9306108952,
-0.7389013171,
0.325614661,
0.5443499088,
0.4020399451,
0.1827417314,
-0.0859303549,
0.8765006065,
-0.0789197162,
0.0638212487,
0.4112092257,
0.5249346495,
0.2656074464,
-0.1186059564,
0.4876866937,
0.3731845319,
-0.6097412109,
-0.8464722633,
0.5841295719,
-0.8429807425,
-0.260566026,
1.1115328074,
-0.3040404022,
-0.3375353217,
-0.3153197765,
-0.1635591239,
-0.0947449133,
-0.2279846668,
0.5962584615,
0.7525101304,
-0.261454612,
-0.2140156478,
-0.3170817494,
0.5230912566,
0.6663476229,
-0.7241231799,
0.2947762907,
0.6150978208,
0.6289316416,
0.2456650883,
0.8957280517,
-0.132208392,
0.1075129807,
-0.0280110985,
-0.0208030567,
0.3863344491,
-0.3632621467,
-0.4271198213,
0.160702318,
0.4938938022,
0.3306723535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14246v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14246v2 | Modeling Empathic Similarity in Personal Narratives | 2023-05-23T17:00:45 | 2023-12-06T10:13:44 | Jocelyn Shen, Maarten Sap, Pedro Colon-Hernandez, Hae Won Park, Cynthia Breazeal | cs.CL | cs.CL | The most meaningful connections between people are often fostered through
expression of shared vulnerability and emotional experiences in personal
narratives. We introduce a new task of identifying similarity in personal
stories based on empathic resonance, i.e., the extent to which two people
empathize with each others' experiences, as opposed to raw semantic or lexical
similarity, as has predominantly been studied in NLP. Using insights from
social psychology, we craft a framework that operationalizes empathic
similarity in terms of three key features of stories: main events, emotional
trajectories, and overall morals or takeaways. We create EmpathicStories, a
dataset of 1,500 personal stories annotated with our empathic similarity
features, and 2,000 pairs of stories annotated with empathic similarity scores.
Using our dataset, we fine-tune a model to compute empathic similarity of story
pairs, and show that this outperforms semantic similarity models on automated
correlation and retrieval metrics. Through a user study with 150 participants,
we also assess the effect our model has on retrieving stories that users
empathize with, compared to naive semantic similarity-based retrieval, and find
that participants empathized significantly more with stories retrieved by our
model. Our work has strong implications for the use of empathy-aware models to
foster human connection and empathy between people. | [
-0.3515118957,
-0.5089893937,
0.8826431036,
0.2114344537,
-0.1973234415,
0.0003762346,
0.045181863,
-0.7926591039,
0.6396204829,
0.5505075455,
-0.5010452271,
-0.443949908,
-0.5446387529,
0.4364556968,
-0.2952114046,
0.5829353333,
0.0029714622,
-0.2483043969,
-0.1974370033,
-0.3680914342,
-0.0633916482,
-0.5623600483,
-0.357771337,
-0.3222368658,
0.6441922188,
0.1794744879,
0.514349699,
0.7307875156,
0.786077261,
0.3185841739,
-0.0936855525,
-0.1574363559,
-0.4229848981,
0.1430617422,
-0.1678625047,
-0.24130629,
-0.299284935,
0.2400033027,
0.0747911558,
0.3863302767,
-0.0182841308,
0.3947621286,
0.3262721598,
0.3628154993,
-0.2328850776,
-0.263320446,
-0.2059967667,
0.4257015288,
0.3326252103,
-0.4847491384,
-0.1512388438,
-0.4525881708,
0.3185336888,
-0.2078083754,
0.5125065446,
0.4359546304,
0.7453163862,
-0.2572886348,
-0.527367115,
-0.1787989587,
-0.4001277387,
0.4903413951,
-0.462521106,
0.0520377681,
0.3412421644,
0.0715534091,
0.3777386546,
-0.4929856062,
-0.4597031474,
-0.3987823427,
-0.350227356,
-0.0840217322,
-0.2494874597,
-0.1508113891,
0.4140875041,
0.4289493859,
-0.8149674535,
-0.2184470296,
-0.1722507626,
0.115942277,
0.57401371,
0.7740567327,
0.2868408859,
-0.3975248635,
-0.6572018266,
-0.0873025358,
-0.3900356293,
0.1006590351,
0.444288671,
0.2803153694,
-0.3825833499,
0.3696997464,
0.0881190673,
0.6411060095,
0.1174794212,
-0.0440239124,
0.3540468514,
0.0638402849,
0.1049695164,
0.2000513226,
0.4901673496,
1.1011726856,
0.4871568084,
-0.2673930526,
0.0811408907,
0.0441450551,
0.4934588969,
-0.6884824634,
0.0210985988,
-0.0586317144,
-1.1089317799,
-0.6712540984,
-0.0939420313,
-0.7348816395,
-0.9140920639,
-0.4948856831,
0.2138464898,
-0.2843867838,
-0.4382712841,
0.0631512254,
-0.2733180523,
0.4063994288,
-0.0784739032,
-0.9742382169,
0.8129469752,
1.2091411352,
1.1910846233,
0.1578252017,
-0.59211725,
-0.3758276701,
0.0565680712,
0.1548184305,
0.7396295071,
-0.9776784778,
-0.2659481168,
-0.1214471087,
-0.2027499229,
0.215783298,
-0.3667685091,
0.4810693562,
-0.0061135651,
-0.1988063008,
-0.41458112,
-0.6420258284,
-0.0808525011,
0.6398421526,
-0.6780686378,
0.4850262702,
0.2071496844,
-0.9233304262,
0.0980269313,
-0.1968130916,
-0.2158875465,
-0.3942970634,
0.1597930044,
-0.0783073977,
0.6008675098,
-0.2034873217,
0.6389047503,
-0.7758557796,
-0.0078543471,
-0.689961195,
-0.2996488214,
0.1854180396,
-0.0734107718,
0.5068167448,
0.1111933887,
0.1425345242,
-0.1227437481,
-0.6280112863,
-0.2457091808,
0.0365076959,
0.4508708715,
-0.7961588502,
-0.4547821581,
0.2954076529,
0.3869352341,
0.0086417152,
-1.0135177374,
0.0565185472,
-0.5366125107,
0.4469386637,
0.5754753351,
0.2759154737,
0.3061606288,
-0.9119154811,
0.5398961902,
0.1219549477,
0.4401596189,
-0.2341022193,
-0.4930075109,
-0.0196913891,
-0.1218541339,
-0.1131014749,
0.3372182548,
0.4283365905,
0.2662391067,
-0.1461500973,
-0.7559295893,
-0.6843152642,
-0.1494045705,
0.5157984495,
0.7766683102,
0.3354827762,
-0.7234412432,
-0.3242686987,
-0.8251661062,
-1.0540724993,
-0.0323611796,
-0.2005117387,
0.8210346699,
0.0965524912,
0.0794404522,
0.7401070595,
-0.5582988262,
-0.5222786069,
0.0150222322,
0.1354883015,
0.2099379748,
0.3469333351,
0.5701143146,
-0.9764616489,
-0.8571096659,
0.1218399554,
-0.7405843139,
-0.1002949998,
-0.1327336133,
0.0104569113,
-0.2753973901,
0.3814024329,
-0.4558761716,
0.5276142955,
0.5187485814,
-0.9742945433,
0.0610044189,
-0.0721100941,
0.597055316,
-1.4111330509,
0.1312454641,
0.0338784605,
0.0252717603,
-0.5065693259,
-0.0784437582,
-0.1732721925,
-0.0126784425,
-0.3432800174,
0.9592396617,
-0.2126334757,
-0.1979643106,
0.2565023601,
0.2671676278,
0.1787434369,
0.3785969913,
-0.0269320346,
-0.1842985451,
0.5387538075,
-0.0869615227,
0.7686423063,
0.5348440409,
0.0320354886,
0.9444663525,
-0.631268084,
0.1721071452,
0.1108916774,
-0.0171314497,
-0.4999333918,
-0.1245545223,
0.1603640318,
-0.7298148274,
0.140038982,
-0.0325362831,
-0.4142264426,
-0.1871574819,
-0.4726575911,
0.3848023117,
0.5117800832,
-0.6740828156,
1.1419798136,
0.0570554845,
-0.4442947805,
-0.0926453024,
-0.5370230079,
0.1132750511,
-0.6804401875,
-0.6948354244,
0.3871336877,
0.1504737437,
-0.5030225515,
0.2452681214,
0.2184880823,
-0.2747201622,
0.0351715684,
0.63415277,
-0.2022994012,
0.0113527542,
0.3786340952,
0.0004062782,
-0.3799881637,
0.1862075925,
0.4285506308,
0.4281472266,
-0.4540999532,
-0.38967219,
-0.3309291303,
0.7125625014,
0.3774954677,
-0.1085684821,
0.9082476497,
0.5682601333,
-0.3416911364,
0.3710786998,
-0.6904562116,
-0.5558199883,
-0.4027652144,
-0.0609618463,
-0.6818198562,
-0.8907247782,
0.8550710678,
-0.1156056598,
-0.1723077744,
-0.1521320492,
0.2727135122,
0.0136818765,
0.834862411,
0.5912047029,
-0.1728873551,
0.1784131825,
0.4251344502,
0.5475955009,
-1.052618742,
-0.2908197641,
-0.2972494066,
-0.5517110229,
-0.5416762829,
0.0836023986,
-0.0102673741,
-0.273452878,
-0.420561552,
0.3181297481,
-0.4156958759,
0.4193264842,
0.4521446824,
0.370043546,
0.4501642585,
-0.0599272884,
0.0836268514,
-0.2882733643,
-0.1897972226,
-0.5977749228,
0.9045692682,
0.2524228692,
0.679053247,
0.2115424275,
1.2450537682,
0.3904760778,
0.296797961,
-0.5214309096,
0.2874469757,
0.0914804265,
-0.2779143751,
-0.0516799688,
-0.3567199409,
-0.8988528848,
0.0300166011,
-0.2251089215,
-1.0280146599,
0.0171045121,
0.1550988108,
-0.4008284807,
0.3331573606,
-0.6132332683,
0.6132041216,
0.0198388416,
-0.4071660638,
-0.2949874103,
-1.0393520594,
-0.0011531587,
-0.1164524034,
-0.1288323104,
-0.2000332475,
0.1951325387,
0.4121949375,
-0.1723548025,
0.8718026876,
-0.0200559907,
0.332778424,
0.1515453607,
0.515756309,
0.2025115937,
-0.1653854996,
-0.1532262862,
0.1134499237,
0.2177328765,
-0.3124383986,
-0.7960104346,
0.9613335729,
-0.4816488624,
-0.4746760428,
-0.4315933287,
-0.3573820591,
-0.0596067347,
-0.1476005167,
-0.1477058083,
0.4894313216,
-0.5398244858,
0.1016211212,
0.172435537,
-0.205610916,
0.2049602568,
0.6511111259,
0.0084362896,
-0.117678754,
0.6687864065,
-0.4104951024,
0.0385249928,
0.4324176013,
0.5672202706,
-0.0932602733,
0.3632994592,
0.212893784,
0.5537312031,
-0.3747743964,
-0.4255723953,
-0.8308947086,
0.0973252654,
-0.3500270247,
-0.6803047061,
-0.3048177063,
-0.099352181,
-0.2138722986,
-0.4848669171,
0.9468407631,
0.7918891907,
-0.5313302875,
-0.1316195577,
-1.277977705,
0.2559033334,
0.2258847356,
0.3970141113,
0.2850074768,
-0.6289466023,
0.0457097404,
-0.1340633333,
-0.3123122156,
-0.7605509162,
0.8957777619,
0.2538735271,
0.0703903958,
0.5529242158,
0.3665556312,
0.5917919278,
-0.4016314745,
0.4619969428,
0.2942717373,
-1.0420402288,
0.4222981632,
-0.2889641821,
-0.3316735923,
0.5151563287,
0.6703466773,
-0.7579692006,
-0.2704990208,
-0.9642139077,
-0.604011178,
0.3164832294,
0.0325821526,
0.4798751175,
-0.2062663734,
0.6000053883,
0.2543514669,
-0.1276498139,
-0.4243654609,
0.0024871056,
0.1097336113,
-0.6347420812,
-0.1709038019,
-0.3165302575,
-0.2403804511,
-0.1427345276,
-0.1337967515,
0.0544962697,
0.5096629858,
0.3698227108,
0.1661324501,
-0.3597805798,
-0.1142535731,
0.0868612304,
0.0514228418,
-0.3333662152,
0.2478799671,
0.3106021881,
-0.4092029631,
0.1134063452,
-0.1021668687,
0.5324712396,
-0.253772676,
0.6978983283,
0.3308437467,
0.4319275916,
-0.6566749811,
0.9390460253,
-0.3795727789,
-0.021615671,
-0.1726266742,
-0.1884359568,
0.2159166783,
0.8676702976,
-0.2632688582,
0.0608289875,
0.435839653,
-0.6523550749,
0.2650640011,
0.0011262149,
-0.6303421855,
-0.6517074704,
0.150321573,
0.2319822907,
-0.9037597775,
0.9127743244,
0.1831377149,
-0.5467783213,
0.6231834292,
0.5280335546,
0.9536650181,
-0.4187985063,
0.1029004753,
0.4517890811,
-0.0105534568,
-0.0203822758,
0.3128255606,
-0.2401109636,
-0.5495445132,
0.310477227,
-0.8233876228,
-0.3873295784,
-0.5860610604,
-1.4142974615,
0.1405678689,
-0.1505218595,
-0.0726875588,
-0.3910191059,
0.0677736625,
-0.8082560301,
0.0535394438,
0.014364115,
0.7621085644,
-1.4596431255,
0.4192225337,
0.3176276982,
-0.1208413616,
-0.9875186086,
-0.0697940513,
0.0757507607,
-0.5695366263,
0.3966065645,
0.4711600244,
-0.0042279069,
-0.0377202146,
0.0262493342,
-0.5192084908,
1.4369512796,
0.126343593,
-0.5290111303,
0.0578678735,
0.0467751175,
0.9871370792,
-0.9161204696,
0.2841159105,
0.5359085798,
0.1790693998,
-0.0604672208,
-0.8246060014,
0.4107930362,
-0.3996528387,
-0.1083361059,
0.0558775589,
-0.7506014705,
0.6130589247,
-0.4675680697,
0.1300598979,
0.3067514002,
0.1254650652,
0.293004185,
0.7704635262,
0.1303170621,
0.7395920157,
0.5348991156,
0.2857575417,
1.1911344528,
-0.4700779915,
0.3749872148,
1.37619555,
-0.7206088901,
0.9559867978,
0.4143837988,
0.2818151414,
0.361905694,
0.5642403364,
-0.3011293709,
0.4588838816,
0.0981659368,
-0.2471721917,
-0.1090503559,
-0.4014373124,
-0.3272210956,
0.4834105372,
0.0313319638,
-1.0920311213,
0.108737953,
0.0548756756,
-0.2584171891,
0.2944974005,
-0.2538878918,
0.8895951509,
0.5073841214,
-0.282977879,
-0.1395249516,
-0.437351495,
0.1621326655,
-0.175906539,
-0.2905225754,
-0.2035721242,
0.0458375737,
-0.0742752999,
-0.874424994,
0.5725613832,
0.2083474994,
-0.280247122,
-0.3409993947,
0.7022618055,
-0.1052746028,
-0.1415109187,
0.8616176248,
0.5093129873,
0.3460639715,
-0.2578131855,
-0.4390952885,
0.0728504434,
-0.2411340326,
-0.3620400429,
0.5657790303,
0.7159258127,
0.2416563332,
0.7750874758,
0.3249797225,
0.0179839954,
-0.14088355,
0.2250211537,
0.8514990807,
-1.1188925505,
-0.3331315219,
-0.9470220208,
0.1570073217,
-0.188967973,
-0.5251230597,
0.6940000653,
0.493696183,
0.4738538265,
-0.1672665179,
0.2855767608,
0.0421231538,
0.910846293,
-0.1478998512,
0.5704414248,
-0.4256302714,
0.0686588883,
-0.5110849738,
-1.0806385279,
-0.3003409505,
0.7704269886,
-0.1291689426,
-0.0398074538,
0.5675465465,
1.116953969,
-0.1002633646,
0.2127133757,
0.5413857698,
0.3974829018,
-0.2153568268,
0.7140115499,
1.0619534254,
-0.1441386044,
0.1075727865,
-0.1262604296,
-0.147457093,
-0.228594169,
-0.8557406068,
-0.9153857827,
-0.7010945678,
-0.1235538125,
-0.3079532981,
-0.1351248771,
1.1756410599,
0.2467440963,
-0.2215561718,
0.055195149,
-0.0693582818,
-0.2381587476,
-0.1676382869,
-0.2266174108,
0.2054350227,
0.2967908382,
-0.155185625,
-0.3136961758,
0.5158588886,
-0.1322394311,
0.1577426493,
-0.2631733418,
0.2610390186,
0.255795449,
0.5619055033,
0.0884466842,
-0.677396059,
-0.5715625882,
-0.014971206,
-0.0982951224,
-0.117908515,
1.0429024696,
-0.7384821177,
0.461443603,
0.2949318588,
0.1093741134,
0.3988215923,
0.2549087405,
0.5101716518,
-0.4366051853,
-0.1854393035,
0.423858732,
0.1857617199,
0.2866939902,
-0.5825058818,
0.6062731743,
-0.1732946187,
-0.5453359485,
-0.8307182193,
0.3971154094,
-1.2375047207,
0.0335242562,
1.1204190254,
-0.6510366797,
-0.0954608545,
-0.1604109854,
-0.3772504926,
0.1089639887,
-0.2667429745,
1.0720714331,
0.4895994067,
-0.397561729,
-0.1605142355,
0.2950186133,
0.312936008,
-0.0173955355,
-0.424441129,
0.1374962479,
0.1414149702,
0.2588959038,
0.1033257768,
0.2162194252,
-0.0181714483,
0.1349719167,
0.4580806792,
-0.0986391455,
-0.1154563203,
-0.1346326917,
-0.4254797101,
0.3117126822,
-0.1918117851,
0.3526082635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14240v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14240v1 | Revisiting Machine Translation for Cross-lingual Classification | 2023-05-23T16:56:10 | 2023-05-23T16:56:10 | Mikel Artetxe, Vedanuj Goswami, Shruti Bhosale, Angela Fan, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Machine Translation (MT) has been widely used for cross-lingual
classification, either by translating the test set into English and running
inference with a monolingual model (translate-test), or translating the
training set into the target languages and finetuning a multilingual model
(translate-train). However, most research in the area focuses on the
multilingual models rather than the MT component. We show that, by using a
stronger MT system and mitigating the mismatch between training on original
text and running inference on machine translated text, translate-test can do
substantially better than previously assumed. The optimal approach, however, is
highly task dependent, as we identify various sources of cross-lingual transfer
gap that affect different tasks and approaches differently. Our work calls into
question the dominance of multilingual models for cross-lingual classification,
and prompts to pay more attention to MT-based baselines. | [
-0.3484559357,
-0.3352904022,
0.0060936301,
0.1193006262,
-0.165453285,
-0.0509662777,
-0.3140357137,
-0.6995590925,
-0.0349689759,
0.4760818183,
-0.4303414524,
0.0205945056,
-0.8457206488,
0.3967468143,
-0.3936057985,
0.9190174937,
-0.4675230682,
0.309207648,
-0.2040811926,
-0.3516038358,
-0.6530784369,
-0.6375010014,
-0.6014606357,
-0.6785338521,
0.7135812044,
0.3289572299,
0.5919572115,
0.5175293684,
0.4761195481,
0.2480872422,
0.2334860414,
0.257294327,
-0.364728421,
-0.1926624477,
-0.1087690294,
-0.7542241216,
-0.3043218255,
0.0497855954,
0.4899034202,
1.156780839,
0.3026058376,
0.1141626164,
0.2672508955,
0.2557147741,
-0.6304047704,
0.0445550829,
-0.5164541602,
0.4781704545,
-0.1659202427,
-0.3314270675,
-0.9004139304,
0.3015777469,
0.0115148071,
-0.7403600812,
0.2795377374,
0.3350212872,
0.7201060057,
0.1777314693,
-0.882704854,
0.0433540531,
-0.8071989417,
1.0644869804,
-0.4221222103,
0.7502403855,
0.5227415562,
0.4660227299,
0.299592793,
-0.4482737482,
-0.2659986615,
-0.1223968044,
-0.3188295662,
0.0114165964,
-0.188962698,
-0.2956717312,
0.1995922029,
0.2607973218,
-0.6675025821,
0.2816165686,
-0.3789971173,
-0.2734961212,
0.4410562813,
0.004518196,
0.6070575118,
-0.0194839332,
-0.6668176055,
-0.2263664454,
-0.7305188179,
-0.0191976558,
-0.0418275036,
0.6546670198,
0.1043395922,
0.6684933901,
-0.1840872318,
0.5774564743,
-0.0687589198,
-0.1019535363,
0.440741092,
-0.4376069903,
-0.3372655809,
0.2509679794,
0.6191907525,
0.6441523433,
0.4336233735,
-0.4128451049,
-0.1714293063,
0.0214752126,
0.3576274514,
-0.7447361946,
0.0011462166,
-0.1065856889,
-0.2648926973,
0.0217624586,
-0.2494560033,
-0.434943825,
0.0240506157,
-0.4018953145,
0.3321113884,
-0.2443358749,
-0.2468888164,
0.0788212493,
0.0470782705,
0.1319875121,
0.3204093874,
-0.8152307272,
0.1897244751,
0.5065674186,
0.7054300308,
-0.4339143336,
-0.6977645159,
-0.7261406779,
0.1521647573,
-0.603902936,
0.6133878231,
-0.264698416,
-0.1910263449,
0.1025687754,
0.4000647366,
-0.6205021739,
-0.4871121943,
0.2652584016,
-0.4690278471,
0.7352420688,
-0.2031032443,
-0.2503376603,
-0.2771219015,
0.44297418,
-0.518224299,
1.0080115795,
-0.0076572043,
-0.9564483166,
0.5928057432,
-0.3961232901,
-0.8789249063,
-0.2272933125,
0.2975017726,
-0.3063308597,
-0.0880763233,
0.4432454109,
0.4208885133,
-0.2767433524,
0.1789784133,
-0.2496514767,
-0.3546037972,
0.0757708624,
-0.4115353227,
0.9246959686,
0.3231993318,
-0.4602069259,
-0.1856377125,
-0.3552720845,
0.05396685,
-0.052437149,
-0.3394306302,
-0.7250927091,
-0.2044348866,
0.2002625912,
0.3018397391,
0.0724136084,
-0.4218496084,
-0.0164243039,
-0.2389963418,
0.0699029192,
0.3733892143,
-0.4716421068,
0.7485015392,
-0.3222365379,
0.6473141909,
-0.0401688181,
-0.0823131651,
0.0254548024,
-0.4180942774,
-0.6579087973,
-0.2887986004,
0.8101602793,
1.0051879883,
-1.1059160233,
0.0287005324,
-0.4403660893,
-0.3365483284,
-0.5922906399,
0.0634255558,
0.4975292385,
0.4488808811,
0.595646441,
-0.3296426833,
-0.3886599839,
-0.9021278024,
-0.4240246117,
-0.159327969,
0.0134415124,
0.0615788996,
0.3704564273,
-0.3534562886,
0.2795406282,
-0.0926029757,
-0.1040118188,
-0.5332594514,
0.1672529578,
-0.3307971656,
0.5948667526,
0.698880136,
-1.0227105618,
-0.7549906969,
0.6844767332,
-0.6948346496,
-0.3721389771,
-0.2805972397,
-0.3492893577,
0.3930802643,
0.4333664179,
-0.4744366705,
0.3334597647,
0.5954295397,
-0.1175150126,
0.2993008792,
-0.0772272199,
0.5854176283,
-1.1084260941,
0.2274758816,
-0.2587317228,
-0.4898577929,
-0.6508883238,
0.2616841793,
0.2254720628,
0.0913235992,
-0.4951207936,
0.5943566561,
-0.4571497142,
-0.1244469434,
-0.4337074161,
-0.0844902992,
-0.0180865936,
0.4269326031,
-0.0555878095,
0.5956193805,
0.4776242375,
-0.5514806509,
0.0460330136,
0.2234515995,
-0.1401948035,
0.7978224158,
-0.2076710612,
0.0019606322,
0.0935828388,
0.0999935344,
-0.9035491347,
-0.0708214566,
0.4429863989,
-0.507943809,
0.6384110451,
-0.2338019758,
-0.5293011069,
-0.1929188073,
0.1009780839,
0.5397408605,
0.4145287573,
-0.5780667663,
0.5567813516,
0.1877436191,
-0.1256641448,
-0.7001881599,
-0.9624720812,
0.2675083578,
-0.456944406,
-0.4487192631,
0.3873383403,
0.107164681,
-0.1272059828,
-0.1219430715,
-0.2321636379,
-0.2151516676,
0.2521212697,
-0.0726458654,
0.1115815863,
-0.2130600512,
0.0473358817,
0.2128548473,
-0.2070611119,
0.0368247665,
-0.3140757382,
0.2919217646,
0.345805645,
-0.4083768725,
-0.2056783736,
0.6731802821,
0.7983210683,
-0.4504387081,
0.5263456106,
0.8374211192,
-0.4686624706,
-0.2389388829,
-0.2005800009,
-0.0514099002,
-0.3343714178,
0.3922580779,
-0.6518146396,
-0.6915689111,
0.2283441871,
-0.0383229591,
0.1757971793,
0.5205138326,
0.4412801862,
-0.0865817517,
1.1919865608,
0.7382159829,
-0.1518207192,
0.3744787276,
-0.0992490947,
0.0936809629,
-0.7081972361,
0.0132944444,
-0.6332484484,
-0.4306809604,
-0.5549943447,
-0.4174599349,
0.0437283479,
-0.0888184607,
0.1016436815,
0.6350831389,
-0.254952848,
0.1798779666,
0.450430125,
-0.0240422357,
0.2731509507,
0.2019776255,
-0.2340811789,
-0.1520850807,
-0.9383000731,
-0.3215684593,
1.0547341108,
0.1092078462,
0.539914906,
-0.0406901836,
0.5258325934,
0.0681462064,
0.7507743835,
-0.6318795085,
0.3916513622,
-0.4597018361,
-0.6914179921,
-0.0792134106,
-0.6905081868,
-1.2315034866,
0.7183929682,
-0.0099227959,
-0.2165108323,
-0.041570846,
0.0516460575,
0.1191730872,
0.4974419475,
-0.9023172259,
1.3371893167,
-0.5819526315,
0.0374590382,
-0.0597083047,
-0.6547393203,
0.3113151491,
-0.2669888437,
0.5001856089,
0.2010442466,
-0.0536497459,
0.6145730019,
-0.2921804786,
0.9653669,
-0.0206083171,
-0.2354303151,
-0.067729868,
0.2541747689,
0.2106535584,
-0.4858081937,
0.1664607823,
0.1800629199,
0.0303859524,
-0.6130307913,
-0.5657766461,
0.3793106973,
-0.6543670893,
-0.4369668365,
-0.3738109469,
-0.7514818311,
-0.2030076981,
0.3717125654,
0.3709919751,
0.2746434808,
-0.1393057108,
0.1366433352,
0.5185377002,
-0.0390202217,
-0.021701958,
0.5040225387,
-0.4823854864,
-0.3023244143,
0.9090269208,
0.3020216823,
0.6685163379,
0.763561368,
0.1605421007,
-0.1783101857,
-0.60081774,
-0.8346576691,
0.031352479,
-0.6479938626,
0.007698237,
-0.6069172621,
0.2074148953,
-0.4371880293,
-0.1592015028,
-0.3291465044,
-0.3534655571,
-0.1291485131,
0.0412709452,
-0.063426584,
0.3124204576,
-0.0517524667,
0.0938027278,
-0.6780637503,
0.384316355,
0.2023305595,
-0.0001577603,
-0.3297143579,
-0.8487883806,
-0.442355454,
0.0848262087,
-0.0414025448,
-0.769687295,
0.4513805509,
0.1488771141,
0.7275650501,
-0.088195093,
0.0856512785,
0.7760075927,
-0.8099279404,
0.4470893741,
0.2334082127,
-0.67396909,
0.1484467983,
0.0322680101,
0.3325197101,
0.4261061251,
0.76242733,
-0.8974409699,
-0.4255121052,
-0.2760333121,
-0.6724940538,
0.5454406738,
0.023669403,
0.0759276748,
0.1744039804,
-0.1272904873,
0.4254975319,
0.0186864007,
-0.772492826,
-0.0402719751,
-0.074334152,
-0.1606120169,
-0.5387179852,
0.2888457775,
-0.0356027372,
-0.2791084051,
0.4394989014,
-0.3091172874,
0.1449429691,
0.0962427855,
-0.6255427003,
-0.259904772,
0.238999486,
0.4204997122,
0.442170769,
0.0972350761,
0.4213635623,
0.5236490369,
-0.1870538145,
0.1677027196,
0.2264768034,
-0.3397864699,
0.232046321,
0.5330334902,
0.7748156786,
0.3915006816,
-0.4569815695,
0.2594266832,
0.2455274016,
-0.2500879467,
0.1791640371,
-0.2566208243,
-0.0335090868,
0.1058821157,
0.0611184537,
0.3002000153,
0.1227263808,
-0.5639776587,
0.1650238633,
0.2929039001,
-0.4904390872,
-0.2364045382,
0.6026484966,
0.1584069878,
-0.3932175636,
0.4175213575,
-0.0901029408,
-0.9822002053,
0.4359528422,
0.5701823235,
0.8184264898,
-0.3905166984,
0.0307331514,
0.2334533483,
0.7445398569,
-0.2169508785,
-0.0372803137,
-0.0952278301,
-0.5833119154,
-0.7247732878,
-0.1410526782,
-0.470746547,
-0.3253966868,
-0.6849733591,
0.0990058258,
0.1891456246,
-0.0927012414,
-0.0769692883,
-0.2126421034,
-0.6428399086,
0.2577943802,
0.3697665334,
0.8616167903,
-0.9666911364,
0.8568034172,
0.8051818013,
-0.1200888529,
-0.4049185514,
-0.1124597713,
-0.2123494595,
-0.7083326578,
0.9064494967,
0.3816177249,
-0.1850130111,
-0.2463837415,
-0.2032385021,
-0.4914176464,
0.6644646525,
0.2753635943,
-0.2171243578,
0.0453679599,
0.4188946486,
0.5270333886,
-0.3820337653,
-0.0989033654,
0.2040637136,
0.4857276976,
-0.2264758348,
-1.511988163,
-0.053325098,
-0.3892688453,
-0.1088551357,
0.3172856569,
-0.2862989008,
0.7988510728,
-0.0847390667,
-0.3235659897,
-0.108471781,
0.445594877,
-0.1738030612,
0.638813138,
0.7379694581,
0.5724686384,
0.568148315,
-0.0710607171,
1.2941818237,
0.0512638949,
0.3270359039,
0.9465679526,
-0.4279819727,
0.997759521,
0.6844919324,
-0.190524891,
0.2176107764,
0.8713154197,
0.1318983138,
0.4368970394,
0.1171640232,
0.187474981,
-0.5798729658,
0.0893475115,
-0.4255110919,
0.3081542253,
0.0529705025,
-0.240353018,
-0.2591814697,
0.3863106966,
0.0533421598,
-0.0562140457,
-0.2705807984,
0.4256562591,
0.068690151,
-0.9723730087,
0.9112494588,
0.1022399291,
0.7163186669,
-0.4188167155,
0.2108492553,
-0.3442100286,
0.3022020757,
0.0908879265,
-0.4759665728,
0.3870027661,
0.0856434107,
-0.0810330659,
-0.6751226187,
0.6028575301,
-0.7319201231,
-0.5939107537,
0.5059894323,
0.6810076237,
0.3210375905,
-0.0609676503,
-0.6779601574,
-0.2821754813,
0.1295830607,
-0.0429844297,
0.5260295272,
0.6882085204,
-0.2478191704,
0.6385145783,
0.674298048,
-0.1396499127,
0.4143280983,
-0.1042347625,
0.4467008114,
-0.4767925143,
-0.4478862882,
-0.5158486366,
0.3397189975,
0.1157282367,
-0.3749291301,
0.906006515,
0.6510749459,
1.5267591476,
-0.1381694973,
0.6924077868,
0.0187071636,
0.5196397901,
-0.5350999832,
0.4731973112,
-1.1240638494,
-0.0829582438,
-0.1468813419,
-0.7131651044,
-0.5134673715,
0.3993436396,
-0.3629260957,
0.052162651,
0.9780060053,
0.5125240088,
-0.2933724821,
-0.1822331548,
0.4199555516,
-0.2154711783,
-0.0187594071,
0.8977071643,
0.9179128408,
-0.6955437064,
0.9162720442,
-0.2301004678,
-0.0712624043,
-0.3578806221,
-0.5762222409,
-1.0220154524,
-0.3597700894,
-0.4790004194,
-0.143569231,
0.0141950687,
0.6855430603,
0.7276297808,
-0.8621762395,
-0.4804957211,
0.4427936673,
0.1538815051,
-0.7459334135,
-0.1177399457,
0.0507611148,
-0.5192683339,
-0.9860082269,
0.3241944313,
-0.0493681505,
0.112307325,
-0.1312421858,
-0.2264363021,
-0.2240281552,
-0.2294433713,
0.7746270895,
0.2506843805,
-0.6266717315,
-0.2753175497,
0.4360162914,
-0.5082470179,
0.0698156431,
0.832183063,
-0.3034704924,
0.4631335735,
0.5519425869,
1.1915632486,
0.5698019862,
-0.3929512501,
0.7755054235,
-0.5499389172,
0.0130636394,
-0.0153654832,
0.541713357,
0.4715973735,
-0.0784529969,
0.5910835266,
0.512286067,
-0.2515157759,
-1.1439330578,
0.1447173506,
-0.8892413378,
-0.4810172319,
1.0468753576,
-0.1391991079,
-0.2099143714,
-0.2135823071,
-0.2488699108,
0.3415920436,
0.3077087998,
0.4807393551,
0.7533897161,
0.104673408,
-0.2335509062,
-0.823084414,
0.0947395116,
0.90149647,
-0.7934088707,
0.0819989368,
0.197819978,
0.239385426,
0.3902235329,
0.2420495152,
-0.0307908133,
0.2827527225,
-0.028109448,
0.1659224331,
0.1772196293,
-0.5199800134,
-0.1018430293,
0.0833561346,
-0.123799473,
-0.5405995846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14239v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14239v2 | On Learning to Summarize with Large Language Models as References | 2023-05-23T16:56:04 | 2023-11-16T05:55:43 | Yixin Liu, Kejian Shi, Katherine S He, Longtian Ye, Alexander R. Fabbri, Pengfei Liu, Dragomir Radev, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have found that summaries generated by large language models
(LLMs) are favored by human annotators over the original reference summaries in
commonly used summarization datasets. Therefore, we investigate a new learning
setting of text summarization models that considers the LLMs as the reference
or the gold-standard oracle on these datasets. To examine the standard
practices that are aligned with this new learning setting, we investigate two
LLM-based summary quality evaluation methods for model training and adopt a
contrastive learning training method to leverage the LLM-guided learning
signals. Our experiments on the CNN/DailyMail and XSum datasets demonstrate
that smaller summarization models can achieve similar performance as LLMs under
LLM-based evaluation. However, we found that the smaller models can not yet
reach LLM-level performance under human evaluation despite promising
improvements brought by our proposed training methods. Meanwhile, we perform a
meta-analysis on this new learning setting that reveals a discrepancy between
human and LLM-based evaluation, highlighting the benefits and risks of this
LLM-as-reference setting we investigated. | [
-0.1501348019,
-0.1855944991,
0.3732714057,
-0.3055591583,
-0.6504039764,
-0.071766153,
-0.2667957246,
-0.4717166424,
0.0999934226,
0.6299467087,
-0.3834645152,
-0.5774695277,
-0.684217453,
0.3891254365,
-0.3545483649,
1.3851563931,
0.0907460079,
0.3470574021,
-0.400587976,
-0.3372423947,
-0.2107087821,
-0.7170414329,
-0.5065737963,
-0.666497767,
0.6045086384,
0.2734683454,
0.7500500679,
0.7100051641,
0.6929299235,
0.2042228431,
-0.3542653322,
0.4100583196,
-0.6187255979,
-0.1919265687,
-0.121853523,
-0.5290647745,
-0.4620760977,
0.1775364876,
0.5899950862,
0.9820376635,
-0.1337827742,
0.307197541,
0.2476429194,
0.9548867941,
-0.7413420081,
0.1783786118,
-0.4797885716,
0.0236874167,
0.2808167934,
-0.0628480241,
-0.4294465184,
-0.431864202,
0.3157664537,
-0.4036186039,
0.3398700655,
-0.0062275105,
0.8146939278,
0.2889328301,
-0.6810119748,
-0.4540614784,
-0.4762195647,
0.8399606943,
-0.9922611713,
0.1314787269,
0.2359766066,
0.519764483,
0.4066585898,
-0.6232562065,
-0.2867740393,
-0.276539892,
-0.3974983096,
0.1251833588,
0.0531081781,
-0.0351254158,
0.0232799854,
0.515745759,
-0.4254639745,
0.2547158003,
-0.4578973949,
0.0571150072,
0.7594115138,
0.4154754281,
-0.0765297785,
-0.2355313301,
-0.1815086156,
-0.0281660985,
-0.8970966935,
-0.3003832102,
0.1322650015,
0.5945606232,
-0.4026268721,
0.3867110312,
-0.2577036023,
0.6066027284,
-0.1889235675,
-0.3603806496,
0.4058977365,
-0.4258498847,
-0.3446355462,
-0.1720313579,
0.6362758279,
0.7066970468,
0.6482181549,
-0.2163558751,
-0.3571588695,
-0.2866818309,
0.0463708006,
-0.8234212399,
-0.2501441836,
-0.1748256981,
-0.750630796,
-0.3667160869,
0.1700649112,
-0.3422162831,
-0.3885904253,
-0.6768883467,
0.2291190028,
-0.0962305516,
-0.055011183,
0.0965085626,
-0.0358537473,
0.2895302773,
0.6320698261,
-1.1613093615,
0.514202714,
0.6299237013,
0.7028262615,
-0.2633572519,
-0.2902415991,
-0.4765983522,
0.1254418343,
-0.4848592281,
0.851516366,
-0.2883253098,
-0.4998434186,
0.1711538881,
-0.2909702361,
0.0474714041,
-0.8611342311,
0.3922390342,
-0.5450512171,
0.3957036436,
-0.559956789,
-0.5564916134,
-0.3424248695,
0.20469971,
-0.7365769148,
0.6825552583,
-0.14230977,
-0.8578711152,
0.4392923415,
-0.3203726709,
-0.4346880913,
-0.3878000677,
-0.1576736271,
-0.4766485095,
0.2991881669,
0.3047325313,
0.7019744515,
-0.2125190645,
0.0411283448,
-0.1374425143,
-0.5619910955,
0.1909222007,
-0.2847556174,
0.6239854097,
0.2162419111,
0.1743506938,
0.2874842584,
-0.6578062177,
-0.3323600888,
0.0343290754,
-0.4607026875,
-0.4394339323,
-0.0191649422,
-0.1855615675,
0.1441680342,
-0.0284413025,
-0.033566162,
0.0617976747,
-0.386295706,
0.1471923292,
0.615239203,
0.0625390038,
0.4327656925,
-0.5567628145,
0.2152573764,
-0.1744650453,
-0.1980421245,
-0.4859534502,
0.0497788563,
-0.8726332188,
-0.0609890334,
0.4520142674,
0.3941262662,
-0.6558093429,
0.2542105615,
-0.5140245557,
-0.2912726998,
-0.3214647472,
0.2839873731,
0.5820809007,
0.5242697001,
0.3208329678,
-0.0923668072,
-0.5507121086,
-0.8100898862,
-0.0754431561,
-0.081022948,
-0.3297428787,
0.2901777625,
0.7444896698,
0.0120188883,
0.668674469,
-0.4565831125,
-0.2845729291,
-0.6437999606,
0.1472972929,
0.1680110097,
0.021159213,
0.4965245128,
-0.6849891543,
-0.5098586679,
-0.2715984881,
-0.9673309922,
-0.0983020142,
-0.0245977622,
0.2769620419,
0.2648943663,
0.7761487365,
-0.0580424406,
-0.022162376,
0.610481441,
-0.11599572,
0.6944764256,
-0.1688085049,
0.1104707271,
-1.3034642935,
0.0791945979,
0.0294354055,
-0.4435409904,
-0.4582493603,
0.0159104485,
0.0752334222,
-0.089153029,
-0.4534150064,
0.5688397288,
-0.6072236896,
-0.2852071524,
-0.6248759031,
0.481737107,
0.1071638986,
0.4106635451,
0.2619283497,
0.7911480665,
0.0808887556,
-0.6713406444,
0.136976704,
0.3076259196,
-0.5580595136,
0.3294984996,
-0.7164258957,
-0.1052941233,
-0.2327828407,
0.4115810692,
-0.7929407358,
-0.1680159122,
-0.0279771518,
-0.3725612164,
0.3388724029,
0.1933682561,
-0.4825947881,
0.0695636794,
-0.5453577638,
0.190081656,
0.6501479149,
-0.691881299,
0.3841331899,
0.2161888331,
-0.2952489555,
-0.7686326504,
-0.8469746113,
0.1241192669,
-0.2268705219,
-0.3565803766,
0.3368415236,
0.1144152358,
-0.5252505541,
-0.0020531258,
-0.1001195386,
0.0671955869,
0.1648630947,
0.0755247995,
0.3134589493,
-0.2300713658,
0.1817293912,
-0.1580243111,
-0.269425422,
0.043533951,
0.2681882381,
0.1895079464,
0.0559555478,
-0.2927011251,
-0.4365022182,
0.2207527757,
0.1657805592,
-0.2553185225,
0.6886582971,
0.3062325418,
-0.1400611401,
-0.0886023119,
-0.5557625294,
-0.3758687079,
-0.3651269972,
0.5428973436,
-0.0365715101,
-0.8599368334,
0.4987482429,
0.0074022501,
0.3761155009,
0.5840427876,
0.5409088135,
-0.3532807231,
0.6496285796,
0.9666578174,
-0.2196268439,
0.5782473087,
-0.2675370276,
-0.2855572402,
-0.9792408943,
-0.0687222481,
-0.4828568995,
-0.1461375207,
-0.2558256388,
-0.2909435332,
0.2897101641,
0.0054858378,
-0.0752725974,
-0.0304568037,
0.0894310847,
0.8437178731,
0.3461575806,
0.160339132,
0.7262867093,
0.0035449108,
0.0054433402,
0.0164383333,
-0.6865228415,
-0.8259148002,
1.2970273495,
0.3341232538,
0.93506217,
0.0490005389,
0.7616960406,
0.1808407605,
0.7656093836,
-0.5924047232,
0.3901531994,
-0.5300369859,
-0.3102633953,
-0.1962761581,
-0.5808489919,
-0.7540233731,
0.6132378578,
-0.3529435098,
-0.3329482079,
-0.0878559276,
0.1754085273,
-0.4346232414,
0.3091474473,
-0.5799740553,
0.568040967,
-0.0670357868,
-0.1288299859,
-0.3587169051,
-0.6975302696,
0.558131814,
0.1577493101,
0.1404538602,
-0.046116963,
-0.2215415686,
0.7092236876,
-0.2938524485,
1.1546714306,
0.1842980683,
-0.1615315527,
0.1739315093,
-0.2496101558,
0.3776482344,
-0.0567501262,
-0.182705313,
0.0845367759,
-0.3295872509,
-0.3759599626,
-0.6329872012,
0.4078866541,
-0.8437923193,
-0.5302951932,
-0.4111827314,
-0.4518711865,
-0.1134253442,
-0.0943744928,
0.2297212929,
0.3768554032,
-0.2764396369,
0.3083234131,
0.761611402,
-0.1998117119,
0.3322419226,
0.7862654924,
-0.1188048571,
-0.6653683186,
0.8032175899,
0.0505880825,
0.5768483281,
0.5550917387,
0.1731144637,
-0.1488499194,
-0.8169427514,
-0.2373127192,
0.5574952364,
-0.9758453369,
-0.1182985678,
-0.2768551111,
-0.2173756212,
-0.2561288774,
-0.1154105738,
-0.1759839952,
-0.244314447,
-0.3213955164,
-0.2052987516,
-0.1727846861,
0.6786261797,
0.2049618959,
0.3608899415,
-0.8993397951,
0.2573585808,
0.4811760783,
0.1150780022,
0.0853481814,
-0.8753508925,
-0.7496067286,
-0.163254559,
-0.2160912603,
-0.6805180311,
0.2770785093,
0.2194401175,
0.6418176293,
0.4431995153,
0.0145939924,
0.4171231389,
-0.4760718644,
0.7803645134,
0.047474321,
-0.5967125297,
0.2318505049,
-0.2634800971,
0.4612587392,
0.7661026716,
0.3949986398,
-0.7085617781,
-0.189584434,
-0.3482092023,
-0.6120860577,
0.5239059925,
0.0936282054,
0.3130581379,
0.1904348135,
0.7291258574,
0.2729367018,
0.4241216481,
-0.9473894238,
-0.4041665196,
0.0670192763,
-0.184135437,
-0.4347269237,
-0.7008610964,
-0.1085572839,
0.1233249605,
0.7129771113,
-0.2370532304,
-0.1291455328,
-0.0307573825,
-0.3474013507,
0.0718672276,
0.1492404342,
0.5250461102,
0.9024692774,
-0.2187574506,
0.106679678,
0.4738665819,
-0.1524790674,
-0.1123714447,
-0.1089931875,
-0.1890062243,
0.1101169959,
0.9312435985,
0.7584803104,
0.4837206006,
-0.7798378468,
0.5538995862,
-0.065499723,
-0.3298452199,
-0.2033474594,
0.1555077583,
0.1407588571,
0.1516095996,
0.287926048,
-0.1958101094,
0.205245316,
-0.4956157207,
0.0123966075,
0.3325499892,
-0.3390100598,
-0.3021654189,
0.384755075,
0.4816022813,
0.0190083738,
0.6346677542,
-0.0137210675,
-0.2569588125,
0.4770936072,
0.327052772,
0.9674306512,
-0.154155314,
-0.0131749045,
0.4057446122,
0.3126985431,
-0.116163604,
-0.0261406153,
-0.1716670394,
-0.7157491446,
-0.7460694313,
-0.4159413576,
-0.8855533004,
0.113761723,
-0.7716121078,
0.5010153055,
-0.1452442706,
0.2892087996,
-0.1169255376,
0.1027721092,
-0.2312021703,
0.2611203492,
0.2989906073,
0.9904245138,
-1.1537790298,
0.7551310062,
0.6286500096,
-0.45965904,
-0.4183034301,
0.1846403629,
0.0154045569,
-0.5752632618,
0.6286264062,
0.1960783601,
-0.0253304541,
-0.4202966392,
-0.246461004,
-0.7598192096,
1.2756491899,
0.5539007187,
-0.4842649698,
-0.3159557879,
-0.1236725301,
0.6733078361,
-0.4731295109,
0.3311414421,
0.4246222675,
-0.0796946287,
0.1941672713,
-0.8705673814,
-0.221954897,
-0.202643469,
-0.054258965,
-0.0066198753,
-0.8410241604,
0.7099194527,
-0.6069905758,
-0.1871107817,
0.0543755218,
0.8640525937,
0.2943152189,
0.2643967569,
0.2944620848,
0.3950251043,
0.5990108848,
0.1055254042,
1.1827590466,
-0.0104650641,
0.336198777,
1.6773234606,
-0.1369410902,
1.0017130375,
0.3361839354,
-0.2484669089,
0.5254619122,
0.7213477492,
-0.0808289126,
0.4895090461,
0.2142335176,
-0.1305307001,
-0.2223691046,
0.0773447752,
-0.3537174463,
0.1522093564,
0.1350224614,
-0.6704659462,
-0.5733339787,
-0.1196566448,
-0.0096272789,
0.3842329681,
-0.4559232891,
1.1065719128,
0.3374934494,
-0.3619362414,
0.4630797803,
0.0751509443,
0.7136865258,
-0.6231667995,
-0.0209090058,
-0.4330139756,
0.0593193136,
-0.2194028795,
-0.3688849807,
0.4580160975,
0.0882714316,
-0.3297789395,
-0.0495542772,
0.3646226525,
-0.3639042675,
-0.4611799717,
0.0514541268,
0.4966905415,
0.2028575093,
0.0262887646,
-0.4620987475,
-0.1665293276,
-0.0145287039,
-0.3592838943,
0.5388557911,
0.2932437956,
-0.0762147531,
0.7544529438,
0.3641267717,
0.0491791815,
-0.3775081933,
0.3411223888,
0.8731711507,
-0.6514785886,
-0.5342034698,
-1.0355752707,
0.4021234512,
-0.0698119253,
-0.1637945175,
0.823590219,
0.6689473987,
0.9309776425,
-0.033423081,
0.7833172679,
0.5860645771,
0.6708901525,
-0.8510690928,
0.5076459646,
-0.4747263789,
0.6074548364,
-0.2089200318,
-1.0315935612,
-0.4441851974,
0.5201522112,
-0.4815612733,
0.3461358249,
0.7057702541,
0.4642522037,
0.0495539978,
-0.0244672671,
0.50197047,
0.0610121377,
0.2763059139,
0.3778484166,
0.7673723698,
-0.364444375,
0.6463131309,
-0.1869307309,
-0.1953179091,
-0.4566444159,
-1.0536330938,
-1.2548457384,
-0.3502289355,
-0.265113622,
-0.046620138,
0.2165212333,
1.1037092209,
0.6810145378,
-0.759143889,
-0.4793775678,
0.2090577632,
0.1557506472,
-0.2201355696,
-0.1101357564,
0.6576351523,
-0.4806755185,
-0.8439249396,
0.0494048595,
0.0481868647,
0.1935372949,
-0.2961253524,
-0.2410845757,
0.1630914211,
-0.0684784725,
0.6461037993,
0.0632197112,
-0.6308503151,
-0.0539105944,
-0.26856938,
-0.2450978458,
0.0641413182,
0.8555562496,
-0.8252544403,
0.1497350484,
0.4125968814,
0.5867179036,
0.4981972873,
0.1620645225,
0.5343500376,
-0.673317194,
0.0075004487,
0.0691475943,
0.4385210872,
0.4897253513,
-0.0816920698,
0.4818790555,
-0.0282370411,
-0.4869432151,
-0.7258114815,
0.1081152409,
-0.673573494,
-0.2776771784,
1.1658272743,
-0.2240195721,
-0.1027298719,
0.1272118092,
-0.1692754179,
0.1018429473,
-0.1962286085,
1.0156149864,
0.5455648303,
-0.156170398,
-0.2224961519,
-0.4871949852,
0.5122110844,
0.2498720288,
-0.8733479977,
0.3551257551,
0.5274441242,
0.4520527422,
-0.0423566289,
0.4658022821,
-0.2053655088,
0.376711607,
-0.1490944326,
0.0904958472,
-0.3089064658,
-0.2630067766,
-0.7013568282,
0.0899368599,
0.2478818297,
0.018840421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14237v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14237v1 | HOP, UNION, GENERATE: Explainable Multi-hop Reasoning without Rationale Supervision | 2023-05-23T16:53:49 | 2023-05-23T16:53:49 | Wenting Zhao, Justin T. Chiu, Claire Cardie, Alexander M. Rush | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Explainable multi-hop question answering (QA) not only predicts answers but
also identifies rationales, i. e. subsets of input sentences used to derive the
answers. This problem has been extensively studied under the supervised
setting, where both answer and rationale annotations are given. Because
rationale annotations are expensive to collect and not always available, recent
efforts have been devoted to developing methods that do not rely on supervision
for rationales. However, such methods have limited capacities in modeling
interactions between sentences, let alone reasoning across multiple documents.
This work proposes a principled, probabilistic approach for training
explainable multi-hop QA systems without rationale supervision. Our approach
performs multi-hop reasoning by explicitly modeling rationales as sets,
enabling the model to capture interactions between documents and sentences
within a document. Experimental results show that our approach is more accurate
at selecting rationales than the previous methods, while maintaining similar
accuracy in predicting answers. | [
-0.376734376,
-0.8278418779,
0.9979470968,
0.2678798139,
0.0335229412,
-0.1173093766,
0.1453614086,
-0.2206733972,
0.422609061,
0.2365596443,
-0.9460980892,
0.079519853,
-0.3761588037,
0.2142402679,
0.0671603158,
0.744730711,
-0.0639948323,
0.1252173334,
-0.2898953259,
-0.3716996014,
-0.5336660743,
-0.5639302731,
-0.6522553563,
-0.1889221519,
0.5946843028,
0.1814053953,
0.427546978,
0.4056430757,
0.3645998538,
0.2640881538,
0.0284770764,
0.5966639519,
-0.0183392633,
0.1611094922,
-0.033021953,
-0.5784096718,
-0.1483415216,
0.3324576616,
0.3377542794,
0.8332709074,
0.0883609056,
0.0304124504,
-0.3270713985,
0.5334736705,
-0.7017390728,
0.2447369993,
-0.5814967155,
-0.1274668723,
0.2016280591,
-0.6034538746,
-0.7656972408,
-0.6236718297,
0.0103958957,
-1.0335211754,
-0.1268545836,
-0.0800778046,
0.5579072237,
0.0400006846,
-0.6164562106,
-0.2801170945,
-0.5640622973,
0.5458185673,
-0.4211556315,
0.3248759806,
0.3487183154,
0.4632565975,
-0.4010533392,
-0.5956259966,
-0.6485781074,
0.0010392318,
-0.2530481219,
0.4030434489,
0.2405021936,
0.2120604813,
0.5516910553,
-0.1588044614,
-0.3499281704,
-0.5190659165,
-0.1399570554,
0.0976579785,
0.5822395086,
-0.0543373972,
0.084810473,
0.0776389614,
-0.4985001385,
-0.1898516417,
-0.2972617149,
0.6971694231,
0.2700407207,
0.2012124062,
0.2473582923,
0.6552963853,
-0.2308354974,
0.5240048766,
0.1952190995,
-0.3206734359,
0.2298254967,
-0.2553384006,
-0.2114209384,
-0.4007788599,
0.83838135,
-0.0183820464,
0.3684866428,
-0.5682910085,
0.0301733911,
-0.0215322319,
0.2157178521,
-0.5215420723,
-0.1958771497,
0.5966190696,
-0.3158972561,
-0.3626584113,
0.0785883963,
-0.729198575,
-0.2553770244,
-0.4394366443,
0.476693958,
-0.7872154713,
-0.2957821488,
-0.081601046,
-0.5510172248,
0.4743047655,
0.2015109211,
-0.7890174985,
-0.1020812243,
0.3803299665,
0.6251149178,
0.2159388214,
-0.722953856,
-1.0374757051,
0.2472683787,
-0.6603156924,
0.8295952082,
-0.5582966805,
-0.0609331541,
0.0763096139,
0.0566462241,
-0.5592334867,
-0.0282080509,
0.4415466487,
-0.8696122169,
0.1122947261,
-0.2868950665,
-0.8488873839,
-0.2815954685,
0.3344968855,
-0.6196847558,
0.4298708439,
0.1405789703,
-1.1661226749,
0.3630062342,
-1.0462213755,
-0.2503555119,
0.0020971599,
-0.2455257773,
-0.3318170309,
-0.1791412085,
0.4772851169,
0.1551123708,
0.3087622821,
0.6310330033,
-0.647952795,
-0.0855083764,
0.6847097278,
-0.422449559,
1.2742919922,
0.0693490133,
-0.0301312618,
0.5307155252,
-0.8274093866,
0.2014138103,
0.1315621883,
-0.4412478209,
-0.2238937318,
-0.0306941941,
-0.3720724583,
0.2833848298,
-0.0522259623,
-0.3989724815,
0.3043940961,
-0.2395571917,
0.3341805041,
0.5864747167,
0.2940687239,
0.712511003,
-0.5053422451,
0.7063264847,
0.121276632,
0.1796381176,
-0.6241087317,
-0.5959250331,
-0.5375230908,
-0.3416137397,
0.0712719336,
0.5666370988,
-0.8848697543,
0.3674428463,
0.0364389122,
-0.3968040943,
-0.4862547517,
-0.0286718197,
0.2423447967,
0.7321820259,
0.6270044446,
0.5187606812,
-0.4904089272,
-0.9063887596,
-0.5772648454,
-0.2187839746,
-0.2424131483,
-0.0751059875,
0.2790528238,
-0.0152974846,
1.2850438356,
-0.3675237,
0.0439765863,
-0.2464014739,
0.3938999474,
-0.1128451824,
0.6315983534,
0.3046354949,
-0.8660308123,
-0.0737048537,
-0.3180140257,
-1.1546822786,
-0.0126801655,
-0.6362400055,
-0.390865922,
0.0261680763,
0.7167394161,
-0.8942998052,
0.430998683,
0.3127472103,
-0.2905740738,
0.7956943512,
-0.0594994761,
0.08242248,
-1.1455962658,
0.0501507558,
-0.0231255684,
-0.0234527942,
-0.5581226349,
0.2407960594,
0.2605037093,
-0.0885356143,
-0.1882502288,
0.3617550731,
-0.4160426557,
0.1259368658,
-0.0135559617,
0.0688844547,
0.3638834655,
0.7437479496,
0.3838093877,
0.6789882779,
0.429353267,
-0.4490397871,
0.1119577661,
0.5175994635,
0.1922908723,
0.4944449663,
-0.5539979935,
0.0286386888,
-0.2321470082,
0.5089013577,
-0.7516653538,
-0.257384032,
0.2027736753,
-0.7015966773,
-0.1573098302,
-0.5551594496,
-0.2250530273,
-0.3187009096,
-0.2195607275,
0.1416699886,
0.2650021017,
-0.8832925558,
0.8731034994,
0.1670284569,
0.1254399419,
-0.5233389139,
-0.3209958971,
-0.3495968282,
-0.4661298096,
-0.8148561716,
-0.2458855063,
-0.2633351386,
-0.320016712,
-0.2032461464,
-0.0435805991,
-0.4237730205,
0.392526418,
0.3695981801,
0.2346727103,
-0.2212829888,
0.5634478331,
0.2060720325,
-0.1618203521,
0.4314526618,
-0.3259627521,
0.1678916663,
-0.1891989708,
-0.4394858479,
-0.5581488013,
0.67762357,
0.6502416134,
-0.5530934334,
0.8484666944,
0.5328587294,
-0.2942635417,
-0.2050367743,
-0.3019628525,
-0.3105903268,
-0.4266913533,
-0.0045256354,
-0.7526699901,
-0.6521846056,
0.6078544855,
-0.3007498682,
0.395092696,
0.4048879445,
0.1361171901,
-0.355833143,
0.9262253046,
0.3678529263,
0.536881268,
0.3574038446,
-0.073416546,
0.3896312416,
-0.7423680425,
-0.4442127347,
-0.5202050209,
0.0070147491,
-0.510837853,
-0.1153542995,
0.3115501106,
0.8315727711,
-0.3158262074,
0.1667685509,
-0.318361789,
0.6806321144,
1.0493929386,
-0.1807039678,
0.2911677957,
-0.2166990638,
-0.0908218846,
0.3978612721,
-0.8150939941,
-0.5520328283,
1.2137123346,
0.1735935062,
0.397369802,
0.020655062,
0.79096663,
-0.2775954008,
0.246446088,
-0.7395138144,
0.1991183907,
0.6647546887,
-0.5836058855,
-0.5516859889,
-0.6120007038,
-0.9087232947,
0.484772563,
-0.4516112506,
-0.8546645045,
0.0712086335,
0.115661487,
-0.4084277749,
0.3629673719,
-0.997182548,
0.8625959754,
0.0954579711,
-0.1250305623,
0.2220399827,
-0.775503993,
0.6775931716,
-0.1462657005,
0.2742867172,
0.175759092,
0.4622814953,
0.9118254185,
-0.5197546482,
0.5176461935,
-0.3042120039,
0.2396500856,
0.6006010771,
0.1952128559,
0.3667454123,
0.5471825004,
0.0693255812,
-0.1521712691,
0.2494672686,
-0.5700895786,
-0.6661667824,
0.3938162327,
-0.757832706,
-0.3705842197,
-0.2606688738,
-0.886461854,
-0.7370702624,
0.1954219788,
0.1747804582,
0.4887262881,
0.2600186765,
-0.124857232,
0.5964062214,
-0.0022024706,
0.5843428969,
0.2463526577,
-0.1216012016,
-0.4300642014,
0.4711363912,
-0.0298022199,
0.0725617856,
0.1515300274,
0.3198910952,
-0.6263267994,
-0.2495230138,
-0.5483483076,
0.1296690851,
-0.799405992,
-0.1096978784,
-1.0039156675,
-0.1818999946,
-0.4834002256,
-0.5433515906,
-0.1004728898,
-0.47833547,
-0.1116315648,
-0.193626374,
0.5461195111,
0.3019376993,
-0.1907618195,
0.5939240456,
-0.9727045894,
0.6262440681,
0.7101039886,
0.3447710574,
-0.0508080684,
-0.2992727757,
0.0467717238,
0.1602978259,
-0.4114896059,
-1.2209061384,
0.1308898628,
-0.1489843279,
0.5993642211,
0.5257380605,
0.4215134978,
0.562425673,
-0.4201634824,
0.4248657823,
0.3579497337,
-0.893039465,
0.8626440763,
-0.4148420393,
-0.0214137137,
0.6727516055,
0.6144378781,
-0.0280402731,
-0.3993779719,
-0.9455743432,
-0.6270544529,
0.6998504996,
0.1639203727,
-0.1836654842,
-0.2515612543,
0.2425139397,
0.0456851125,
-0.0121127712,
-0.8337517977,
0.0217502136,
-0.1715155393,
0.0710832328,
0.2980172336,
-0.0643603578,
-0.4646230042,
0.0586093925,
0.8262159228,
-0.3325818479,
-0.0085144136,
0.2780096531,
-0.1206811592,
-0.0630009845,
0.352976352,
0.2614836693,
1.0010344982,
-0.5135099292,
0.1171965525,
-0.272138387,
0.0600146316,
0.2550649941,
0.1759043485,
-0.2381628901,
0.1610544175,
0.5649261475,
0.5742645264,
-0.4806051254,
-0.6525461078,
0.7202612758,
-0.1474503577,
-0.6168577075,
-0.4730112255,
-0.1576327384,
0.4730755389,
0.4341600239,
0.2744774818,
0.3005616069,
0.0175658483,
-0.2429544628,
0.2771175504,
0.3627953231,
-0.1699709445,
-0.214920789,
0.8293439746,
0.2036110312,
-0.3683645725,
0.7923715115,
-0.4324153066,
-0.2300453782,
0.7515618801,
0.6079689264,
0.7616588473,
0.0533164106,
0.3679243326,
0.5660321712,
0.3837851286,
-0.0151432361,
0.1775787324,
0.1872980744,
-0.7863966823,
-0.7002775073,
-0.5153103471,
-0.6008486748,
0.3198529184,
-0.6980797648,
0.0443636551,
-0.29948771,
0.0710599944,
0.3030173481,
-0.3606271744,
-0.4479106665,
0.1093068868,
-0.1212176904,
0.9227161407,
-1.3272269964,
0.7909216285,
0.6036865115,
-1.0163956881,
-1.2773784399,
0.0458525717,
-0.3393380642,
-0.4363199472,
0.3361466527,
0.3642299473,
0.0714849904,
-0.0905627906,
-0.5680631399,
-0.4115059078,
0.8443098664,
0.3914040625,
-0.122042641,
0.0571646728,
-0.260381639,
0.2723529637,
-0.2970370054,
0.4760823846,
0.5070820451,
0.4561534822,
0.1550594866,
-0.4146538377,
-0.2087804377,
-0.1087767556,
-0.3040833771,
-0.1001891047,
-0.3735631704,
0.7846756577,
-0.5400898457,
-0.0801786408,
-0.2771621943,
0.4621920586,
0.8160638809,
0.5742060542,
0.5414291024,
0.4551250339,
0.9373680949,
0.1015141234,
1.0419303179,
-0.1370351166,
0.1399659067,
1.4824502468,
-0.0915275663,
0.7180971503,
0.7814686894,
-0.1858160943,
0.3066938818,
0.6569866538,
0.4117463827,
0.3324016631,
0.077841863,
-0.1734852642,
-0.678373158,
0.1203342527,
-0.1944492012,
0.3557619452,
0.0249389764,
-0.1393656284,
-0.0899954438,
-0.2755821049,
-0.1191188097,
0.1757734418,
-0.1194820255,
0.9212394357,
-0.1030940264,
-0.8807193637,
0.4045705497,
-0.1340841353,
0.2210985124,
-0.692666173,
-0.1244735271,
-0.5079481602,
-0.0527722351,
-0.1849858612,
-0.6893878579,
0.4910604954,
-0.1886215508,
-0.3974102437,
-0.1607966423,
0.4241962731,
-0.3946121037,
-0.4934937656,
0.3399527967,
0.9082844257,
0.0312120039,
-0.1419101954,
-0.3189138472,
-0.6679342389,
-0.1628136337,
-0.5531528592,
0.3318845034,
1.0259057283,
-0.2080329657,
0.7610880136,
1.0191192627,
-0.2039853185,
0.3080515563,
-0.0588612333,
0.8326299191,
-0.3249484897,
-0.7210689187,
-0.5968114138,
0.5298400521,
-0.0653830171,
-0.1720175743,
0.4458414912,
0.4282126129,
0.5372565389,
-0.271322906,
1.044891119,
0.0411601663,
0.5393566489,
-0.4397871792,
0.3972641826,
-0.3198714554,
-0.0449026488,
-0.0128546609,
-0.7683198452,
-0.2664631009,
0.772205472,
-0.1826129407,
-0.2444919199,
0.972360611,
0.5466660857,
-0.1508671194,
0.1950195134,
0.1220413446,
-0.2326645851,
0.4885718822,
0.4791290164,
0.8829247355,
-0.2903090417,
0.7679312229,
-0.1752630174,
-0.3931110501,
0.1462808549,
-0.8865534067,
-0.9395894408,
-0.5187860727,
-0.3178558648,
-0.4089130759,
-0.2577335536,
0.6756783128,
0.5906124711,
-0.8084955215,
0.1529473811,
-0.3855461776,
0.3588144779,
-0.5912461877,
-0.2531546056,
0.5891626477,
-1.0025110245,
-0.3373323381,
0.6397612095,
0.1165394261,
-0.1594106704,
0.1435998082,
-0.0466186665,
-0.4817132354,
0.2937739789,
0.4888912439,
0.2872428596,
-0.5321422219,
-0.298826009,
0.0565191992,
0.2093651742,
0.120112963,
0.5462144017,
-0.8225263953,
0.4836695194,
0.4767951667,
1.0041201115,
0.0005817926,
0.2752745152,
0.4099800885,
-0.660570085,
0.0457874723,
0.101450026,
0.4357277751,
-0.0360684358,
-0.0916675776,
0.7165148854,
0.3394581378,
-0.5450901389,
-0.469999373,
0.2687143385,
-1.178586483,
-0.3251584172,
1.1879519224,
-0.7193394303,
-0.0131349806,
-0.3024984598,
-0.0572365671,
0.3664067388,
-0.1764693111,
0.7438055277,
0.425486356,
-0.2235750556,
-0.1415358335,
-0.3912602365,
0.3762367368,
0.212748006,
-1.1270706654,
0.4420240819,
0.6955400705,
0.275309056,
0.2762887776,
0.9691678286,
0.0435283594,
0.3269685507,
0.3205282688,
0.0884005949,
-0.2923216522,
-0.3871552646,
-0.2260011733,
0.5701296926,
0.1071917787,
-0.5080365539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14235v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14235v2 | Multilingual Large Language Models Are Not (Yet) Code-Switchers | 2023-05-23T16:50:48 | 2023-10-23T15:17:59 | Ruochen Zhang, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Jan Christian Blaise Cruz, Genta Indra Winata, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently shown great
capabilities in a wide range of tasks, exhibiting state-of-the-art performance
through zero-shot or few-shot prompting methods. While there have been
extensive studies on their abilities in monolingual tasks, the investigation of
their potential in the context of code-switching (CSW), the practice of
alternating languages within an utterance, remains relatively uncharted. In
this paper, we provide a comprehensive empirical analysis of various
multilingual LLMs, benchmarking their performance across four tasks: sentiment
analysis, machine translation, summarization and word-level language
identification. Our results indicate that despite multilingual LLMs exhibiting
promising outcomes in certain tasks using zero or few-shot prompting, they
still underperform in comparison to fine-tuned models of much smaller scales.
We argue that current "multilingualism" in LLMs does not inherently imply
proficiency with code-switching texts, calling for future research to bridge
this discrepancy. | [
-0.4271436334,
-0.6781462431,
0.424492538,
0.5448610783,
-0.0161056835,
0.4653665721,
-0.5647394657,
-0.4971267879,
0.0216362439,
0.1945194602,
-0.4683419466,
-0.4019960761,
-0.6931045055,
0.4774448872,
-0.4038359523,
0.8256918788,
-0.1528066397,
0.2680682838,
-0.024713289,
-0.2540919483,
-0.3346524835,
-0.6231569052,
-0.414288193,
-0.5816355944,
0.8808289766,
0.3538194299,
0.7204998136,
0.2193107009,
0.2710296512,
0.2224125117,
-0.0823640004,
0.1426097155,
-0.3963247538,
-0.1172374189,
0.1522444785,
-0.6665395498,
-0.2043428868,
-0.0429472588,
0.6897533536,
0.8333386779,
0.0420113578,
0.217262432,
0.0992951989,
0.5529530644,
-0.5511353016,
0.0673542395,
-0.6535841227,
0.1346227378,
-0.4042842388,
-0.0617950186,
-0.6391769052,
-0.1381030679,
-0.1953792274,
-0.1408695579,
-0.1266884357,
-0.2210907489,
0.5068549514,
-0.0393002927,
-0.5407420993,
-0.3728639781,
-0.5447962284,
0.980817616,
-0.9906250834,
0.5032644272,
0.1535088122,
-0.0025423975,
0.2995494306,
-0.0945444703,
-0.4741856754,
-0.31244874,
0.1508734226,
0.0943867937,
-0.2891429663,
-0.1179368347,
0.2635287642,
-0.0032871626,
-0.5634539127,
0.4627480209,
-0.2372683138,
-0.0763314813,
0.4146587551,
0.1909212172,
0.4013129771,
-0.0010434765,
-0.4098973274,
0.1003047228,
-0.7985301018,
0.2889050245,
0.4238187671,
0.6755005717,
-0.3818332851,
0.5967794657,
0.0979129076,
0.6930269599,
-0.3169667423,
-0.4597097337,
0.2896986902,
-0.3312118351,
-0.2758311927,
-0.1823187023,
0.8269584179,
0.2306406498,
0.4191608727,
-0.2427870482,
-0.1145989075,
0.2374782264,
-0.103796795,
-0.6496862173,
-0.0153218219,
0.3146797121,
-0.553098917,
-0.0873753205,
-0.2402187288,
-0.7158101201,
-0.3110041022,
-0.1156591773,
0.1656461656,
-0.3569557667,
-0.5567432642,
0.0883141384,
0.0308319982,
0.2026921511,
0.1079993993,
-0.64287287,
0.140091449,
0.4841602743,
0.951887846,
-0.6773346066,
-0.9236609936,
-0.2413612902,
-0.1605693251,
-0.6626315117,
0.648514688,
-0.7298743129,
-0.5707768202,
0.4391666353,
0.1058192477,
-0.2516247332,
-0.4057863951,
0.0648896992,
-0.6985967755,
-0.0880528614,
-0.4295404553,
-0.1171799153,
-0.1592029035,
0.4913622439,
-0.5625044107,
0.8227755427,
-0.2533047795,
-0.5262809992,
0.4009542763,
-0.260451138,
-0.6374376416,
-0.1087029427,
-0.2412218899,
-0.1655197591,
0.2550280094,
-0.0931662023,
0.303373307,
-0.2684004009,
0.2332432419,
-0.3518505096,
-0.413138032,
0.4751867056,
-0.7430289388,
0.694467485,
0.0191255454,
-0.1285443157,
-0.0802162513,
-0.5648396015,
0.1948183626,
-0.0003797208,
-0.6225411892,
-0.1877044439,
0.0433635041,
0.2028516084,
0.6934636235,
0.2147447616,
-0.3635023832,
0.3892988265,
-0.1715942472,
0.1523925662,
0.5293250084,
-0.4903784096,
0.3936003447,
-0.2844033539,
1.0022176504,
0.2092153579,
-0.2161995918,
-0.2788382769,
-0.4829834998,
-0.7877223492,
-0.2176021636,
0.1701639742,
0.7125190496,
-0.8829051256,
-0.357876122,
-0.055324439,
-0.2278151363,
-0.4812577367,
0.4252837896,
0.6930034757,
-0.1927589476,
0.2302198857,
-0.1367625743,
-0.2219587266,
-0.9491485953,
-0.5846590996,
-0.2173272818,
0.5390848517,
0.0474969968,
0.2938184142,
-0.081823431,
0.5167037845,
-0.0028798466,
0.0899491385,
-0.592046082,
0.2889761031,
0.4180842936,
0.0144793969,
0.5170469284,
-0.5726860166,
-0.7249602675,
0.2472953498,
-0.79405123,
-0.2023044676,
-0.2503503561,
0.4383912086,
0.4710067511,
0.7611276507,
-0.5012420416,
-0.0209926683,
1.0650558472,
0.0950929597,
0.7586479187,
-0.2192849219,
0.2706363201,
-0.763248384,
0.0478262417,
-0.0509741269,
-0.0599316172,
-0.9340928793,
0.1652071774,
0.414265275,
-0.0003908277,
-0.7171463966,
0.6977649331,
-0.7838554978,
-0.1897478551,
-0.5454599261,
-0.0368969329,
-0.2181718498,
0.5152821541,
0.1038864106,
0.8140256405,
0.6255776286,
-0.6268820763,
0.0204839874,
0.0134756966,
-0.2577812374,
0.3741801977,
-0.4004188776,
0.1210534722,
-0.1470403224,
-0.0305868089,
-1.1110316515,
-0.0432699695,
-0.0670036077,
-0.2309035957,
0.5218670368,
-0.4512328804,
-0.652133584,
-0.4632587135,
-0.2823960781,
0.6397358179,
0.2986305058,
-0.3997202814,
0.235598579,
0.0754773095,
-0.4242778718,
-0.7002778053,
-1.0199079514,
0.3877565563,
-0.2013335824,
-0.3368851542,
-0.0887755081,
-0.1463036984,
-0.5757667422,
-0.440806061,
0.0625881553,
-0.1430692375,
-0.0635375753,
0.0293141287,
0.4923804402,
-0.3420170546,
0.2392369658,
0.006000136,
-0.1519023478,
-0.0902913809,
-0.1714750379,
0.6070151925,
-0.2784481943,
-0.5519926548,
-0.0046552317,
0.4145142436,
0.5467156172,
-0.4679936171,
0.702765882,
0.3973974884,
-0.0930569097,
-0.1001024097,
-0.5892188549,
0.2985572815,
-0.3859031498,
0.5347986221,
-0.6090086699,
-0.9745977521,
0.6250295639,
-0.0535444133,
0.2023267299,
0.1881900579,
0.9415326118,
0.1396066695,
1.0588541031,
0.5235854983,
-0.1085627005,
0.452987045,
0.1324050277,
0.2972700894,
-0.4293781817,
0.1189347282,
-0.4882775247,
-0.1777789146,
-0.7853827477,
-0.4898460805,
0.4856273532,
0.1098273993,
0.0485813916,
0.2240408063,
0.0308188349,
0.5054466128,
0.0362748168,
-0.509575665,
0.5370040536,
-0.172159031,
-0.0001254903,
-0.0457234122,
-0.9206990004,
-0.436116904,
1.0152292252,
0.1578743011,
0.9795664549,
0.1702064425,
0.5265231133,
-0.0127821127,
0.2800086141,
-0.8234937191,
0.5124543309,
-0.3694872558,
-0.6305042505,
-0.2909063697,
-0.2806534767,
-0.9269706607,
0.8380482793,
-0.1178474873,
-0.6479880214,
0.1490920931,
0.0591466539,
-0.1684970856,
0.469817996,
-0.7039582729,
0.5863026977,
-0.3804933727,
-0.3631306589,
-0.099923104,
-0.4456951022,
0.5271411538,
-0.3006252348,
0.733289957,
-0.3383099139,
-0.0857824385,
0.1418485343,
0.0614952743,
1.0643808842,
-0.015405423,
-0.512157023,
0.0339614265,
0.3398555815,
0.3670270443,
-0.114819333,
-0.2156601548,
0.4721282125,
0.0948269963,
-0.3538910151,
-0.0838433877,
0.8081135154,
-0.5545628667,
-0.3088753819,
-0.4020315707,
-0.6423967481,
-0.5330563784,
0.4845685363,
0.3597538471,
0.5331900716,
-0.3057075739,
-0.0959828869,
0.563832283,
-0.5060797334,
0.8168782592,
0.7743697762,
-0.5333160758,
-0.0279575586,
0.9846997261,
0.2351016998,
0.5247386098,
0.4313536584,
-0.0058287694,
-0.1480588615,
-0.6034650207,
-0.6513236761,
0.2665279806,
-0.735705018,
-0.0448441021,
-0.6971921325,
0.1321512759,
-0.3564252257,
-0.28055498,
-0.5006511211,
-0.1010398567,
-0.0134904142,
0.175982967,
-0.119403787,
0.7135537863,
0.0012993915,
-0.0487915501,
-0.8530073762,
0.3764148653,
0.2188774645,
0.2834718227,
0.0963757485,
-0.4648973644,
-0.4184385836,
-0.0007042707,
-0.0672258139,
-0.8477272987,
0.2857990563,
0.1831759363,
0.5996366739,
0.3014580011,
-0.3408290148,
0.5761452913,
-0.6974526644,
0.854033947,
0.426678896,
-0.9433588982,
-0.049533572,
-0.4707425535,
0.8418992758,
0.493822068,
0.2995114923,
-0.8725333214,
-0.5943567157,
-0.0507208742,
-0.6669975519,
0.7851199508,
-0.1470393538,
0.480537504,
-0.3154826164,
-0.2485369593,
0.364060998,
0.4512533844,
-1.1529166698,
-0.332166791,
-0.0153359445,
0.2743997276,
-0.2959696352,
-0.1341035515,
0.0619058199,
0.1244407147,
0.445248127,
-0.4240719378,
0.1274263859,
-0.2215102613,
-0.4211986661,
-0.0953897163,
0.7533094287,
0.6769037247,
0.8248953819,
0.2743857205,
0.3308574855,
0.3157672584,
-0.0420926996,
0.1952066571,
-0.0934637114,
-0.0504273549,
0.1219526753,
0.6685350537,
0.6724805832,
0.5079835653,
-0.7160528898,
0.5150731802,
0.2605276704,
-0.2610678673,
-0.0091936812,
-0.1740209609,
0.2838021219,
0.2135354728,
0.2079161257,
-0.0508451946,
-0.0795418769,
-0.8037692904,
-0.3523538113,
0.672789216,
-0.3148860037,
-0.4128162861,
0.4282467365,
0.1574287266,
-0.2535603046,
0.3379176557,
-0.2819397449,
-0.2780154347,
0.6281391382,
0.6502267122,
0.7525400519,
-0.165821299,
0.2688301206,
0.1650553346,
0.5901491046,
-0.3245162368,
0.2034913152,
0.1348773241,
-0.9138966203,
-0.5598099232,
-0.3946557343,
-0.3139241934,
-0.085664399,
-0.8192568421,
0.2630041838,
-0.0279888473,
-0.1195808128,
0.0915451199,
-0.3846822977,
-0.7740936279,
0.0028129837,
0.433952719,
1.0124977827,
-0.7107735276,
0.9913419485,
0.7460750341,
-0.2147904336,
-0.4075535536,
0.0769137815,
0.1845118254,
-0.9984474778,
0.4747300446,
0.2186406255,
-0.322362721,
-0.1875563264,
-0.3519993722,
-0.4040516019,
0.5990224481,
0.4089291096,
-0.6220586896,
-0.1519097686,
0.2992960215,
0.572288692,
-0.2288714945,
0.3785631955,
0.5166753531,
0.5041846037,
-0.1293067634,
-1.0537346601,
-0.3840120137,
-0.2773414552,
0.148867473,
0.2800805867,
-0.9024659991,
1.0404871702,
-0.329877764,
-0.1443099976,
0.0516501553,
0.1588570774,
0.1278481781,
0.2518895566,
0.3866361678,
0.0309457742,
0.3641829789,
0.0438485742,
1.2422134876,
-0.4294865727,
0.2993555367,
0.9687518477,
-0.73711133,
1.0455468893,
0.5542389154,
-0.4375120997,
0.4112863839,
0.3162666559,
0.0799092501,
0.2254240811,
-0.0373614728,
-0.1311326474,
-0.6256064773,
0.17286174,
-0.441519171,
0.5551944971,
0.1209546626,
-0.2624675333,
-0.2713255286,
0.1392521411,
0.1486509889,
-0.0943276361,
-0.2527034581,
0.7483013868,
0.2096803933,
-0.8719879389,
0.6758115292,
0.1339353025,
1.0973576307,
-0.8178690672,
0.1668950468,
-0.3079966903,
-0.1539916396,
-0.172000289,
-0.7172209024,
0.0460749567,
0.218877241,
-0.2635710239,
-0.5519191027,
0.5746567845,
-0.5772104263,
-0.638384223,
0.6310870647,
0.9425237775,
0.0232154317,
0.1737104654,
-0.5834040046,
0.2956391573,
0.0170242302,
-0.1156172976,
0.4832615852,
0.2672215402,
0.0263028499,
0.5889561176,
0.5383163095,
0.1532155275,
0.1203532964,
0.2885627151,
0.4834111333,
-0.6662832499,
-0.3485169113,
-1.0271582603,
0.3395130038,
0.3202311099,
-0.4386023581,
1.0551462173,
0.6215031743,
0.8432307839,
-0.2708356977,
1.0485224724,
0.2361474335,
0.2782760561,
-0.6621667743,
0.4651592672,
-0.650079906,
0.2164300382,
-0.4077843428,
-0.7658393383,
-0.1489682496,
0.2379170507,
-0.2444110066,
0.2324085832,
0.6778201461,
0.7424829602,
0.0161826611,
-0.0934406519,
0.7325918674,
0.3006024361,
0.129998073,
0.4698701799,
1.0675679445,
-0.0218329597,
0.5746512413,
0.4004887938,
-0.1957014352,
-0.2796971202,
-0.826318264,
-1.0435082912,
-0.2373680025,
-0.1688887775,
-0.1486213356,
0.0282511394,
0.7804751396,
0.606502533,
-0.8175647259,
-0.6409579515,
0.1095794663,
0.1904070675,
-0.2976696193,
-0.1136218384,
-0.3190635443,
-0.548109889,
-0.7939655781,
0.5584093928,
0.5410477519,
-0.0713455379,
-0.5576334596,
-0.0004214386,
-0.227351442,
0.1960818022,
0.7948957682,
0.477583766,
-0.9133910537,
0.1343615651,
0.2828827202,
-0.2478675842,
0.1231933236,
1.0760402679,
-0.4511744082,
0.4942194223,
0.3198576272,
0.4662990868,
0.3387758434,
-0.414773494,
0.3634437323,
-0.6316376925,
0.2144971043,
-0.0474184304,
0.3500439227,
0.2828309536,
0.1347435117,
0.1151988357,
-0.1311935037,
-0.3996486068,
-0.7910933495,
0.3481558561,
-0.7022209764,
-0.4239991605,
1.5759322643,
-0.0827103183,
0.1896704286,
-0.1879899949,
-0.0382357277,
-0.209680438,
-0.1497732103,
0.5451017022,
1.175989747,
-0.14988859,
-0.302727133,
-0.7292084098,
0.2353232801,
0.5224468112,
-0.8857926726,
0.2090358436,
0.3527666032,
0.2082554996,
0.2424860895,
0.8970036507,
-0.087877959,
0.2611992359,
0.0368489288,
0.0251403321,
0.1816999465,
-0.3547763526,
-0.787617743,
0.1370527744,
0.4274204671,
0.1544896513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14233v1 | Enhancing Chat Language Models by Scaling High-quality Instructional Conversations | 2023-05-23T16:49:14 | 2023-05-23T16:49:14 | Ning Ding, Yulin Chen, Bokai Xu, Yujia Qin, Zhi Zheng, Shengding Hu, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun, Bowen Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Fine-tuning on instruction data has been widely validated as an effective
practice for implementing chat language models like ChatGPT. Scaling the
diversity and quality of such data, although straightforward, stands a great
chance of leading to improved performance. This paper aims to improve the upper
bound of open-source models further. We first provide a systematically
designed, diverse, informative, large-scale dataset of instructional
conversations, UltraChat, which does not involve human queries. Our objective
is to capture the breadth of interactions that a human might have with an AI
assistant and employs a comprehensive framework to generate multi-turn
conversation iteratively. UltraChat contains 1.5 million high-quality
multi-turn dialogues and covers a wide range of topics and instructions. Our
statistical analysis of UltraChat reveals its superiority in various key
metrics, including scale, average length, diversity, coherence, etc.,
solidifying its position as a leading open-source dataset. Building upon
UltraChat, we fine-tune a LLaMA model to create a powerful conversational
model, UltraLLaMA. Our evaluations indicate that UltraLLaMA consistently
outperforms other open-source models, including Vicuna, the previously
recognized state-of-the-art open-source model. The dataset and the model will
be publicly released\footnote{\url{https://github.com/thunlp/UltraChat}}. | [
-0.0843203366,
-0.966068387,
0.1761820316,
0.107987307,
-0.1353381574,
0.0828867629,
-0.4739300609,
-0.3873111308,
-0.0433497168,
0.5582944751,
-0.3209702969,
-0.6336047053,
-0.322112143,
-0.4988190234,
-0.5844616294,
1.1541211605,
0.3696865141,
0.1065319479,
-0.0158952605,
-0.2713189125,
-0.5557360649,
-0.4527867138,
-0.598724246,
-0.2328478247,
0.1286697388,
0.8898419142,
1.0692909956,
0.776106298,
0.6057761312,
0.2850964963,
-0.1177534536,
0.4210632443,
-1.0020163059,
0.1156953573,
0.0366067961,
-0.4340648055,
-0.6108666658,
-0.1797281355,
0.6900314689,
0.6523169875,
-0.6453097463,
0.1285303682,
0.1993435025,
0.5110840797,
-0.2975120246,
0.3031798005,
-0.730001092,
-0.1764693111,
-0.1050709933,
-0.0522503667,
-0.6372460723,
-0.3803087771,
0.1396716982,
-0.558421433,
0.0237908829,
-0.0573549829,
0.7540606856,
0.1775672436,
-0.1280547678,
-0.1238837093,
-1.2020250559,
0.6242172122,
-0.9184661508,
0.4783474803,
0.3180578053,
0.5095406771,
-0.240584597,
-0.5082876682,
-0.3678593338,
-0.4331427217,
0.304504782,
-0.0523966141,
-0.4311006963,
0.1661738306,
-0.1673425287,
0.5930936337,
-0.3514436185,
0.5129216313,
-0.4614371359,
0.0877702758,
0.4613761902,
0.5693766475,
0.2892180979,
0.2770667076,
-0.014088654,
-0.2996131182,
-0.7350449562,
-0.084812507,
0.3129913509,
0.5360419154,
-0.2142831534,
0.6338502169,
-0.3434970677,
0.5139127374,
-0.1137773097,
-0.0905954018,
-0.1101282835,
-0.3395021856,
-0.2508256733,
-0.2046486735,
0.8368885517,
0.620445013,
0.2451509833,
0.0304581784,
0.2256439924,
-0.2330003828,
0.2029220313,
-0.9472184777,
-0.455952853,
0.0768712908,
-0.2641381919,
-0.2272521257,
-0.1874739528,
-0.8063184023,
-0.4519221485,
-0.309518218,
0.1054737717,
-0.570974946,
-0.3283995092,
0.0723080784,
0.5299222469,
0.0485692956,
0.5250897408,
-0.9552907944,
0.2208900899,
0.6196158528,
0.929248035,
-0.0139321107,
-0.2172611207,
-0.1669598669,
0.0005903374,
-0.5398378968,
0.7281368375,
-0.7438985705,
-0.4593825638,
0.0058350014,
-0.3372594416,
0.1492933631,
-0.5112794042,
0.3523366749,
-0.260510236,
0.2142152041,
0.1282410771,
-0.7051531076,
-0.0680752993,
0.0822133869,
-0.2781789005,
0.9422668219,
0.1072629541,
-0.4501757622,
-0.0396076515,
-0.8619154692,
-0.2010799944,
0.188648358,
-0.0189815816,
-0.24104774,
0.0178295095,
0.3668773472,
0.3278616965,
-0.529132843,
0.2058367431,
-0.1635230333,
-0.2961547673,
0.3235450089,
-0.7303857803,
0.602812767,
0.2568232119,
-0.2169748396,
0.3238021731,
-0.7540623546,
0.1189204454,
-0.0259144492,
-0.3532455266,
-0.2748205066,
-0.056197729,
-0.0922468826,
-0.2164746076,
0.0917682871,
-0.4343698919,
0.3749530017,
-0.263402909,
0.3957709372,
0.9166668653,
-0.1663488001,
0.3194014132,
-0.0764949694,
0.4272087812,
-0.0878389403,
0.6089928746,
-0.5021023154,
-0.5801995397,
-1.0046728849,
-0.2722243071,
0.1887473166,
0.5049542189,
-0.4509837925,
0.3256392479,
-0.3837392926,
-0.822897017,
-0.9440916181,
0.2642409503,
0.4063020647,
0.4092916548,
0.3681851327,
-0.390461266,
-0.303858757,
-0.6100406051,
0.1425508559,
-0.3984269202,
-0.3264689147,
0.5923640132,
-0.0130443359,
-0.31274575,
0.7155292034,
-0.5715727806,
-0.274638623,
-0.1952035427,
0.1915701479,
0.0923965722,
0.4278973341,
0.3093583584,
-0.3234384358,
-0.5904619098,
0.1401366144,
-0.6163293719,
0.1226505488,
-0.1001776233,
-0.4075759351,
-0.0275791734,
0.3350498378,
-0.4180290997,
0.3445427716,
0.612899363,
-0.0829898864,
0.4014833272,
-0.3655616045,
0.2285316736,
-1.28231287,
-0.3475319147,
-0.0963271484,
0.1888325214,
-0.7373411655,
0.2007348984,
-0.0028341205,
-0.1747317165,
-0.5673010945,
0.2597147226,
-0.2474624366,
0.0399259776,
-0.2762615979,
0.0334158055,
-0.3816059232,
0.5608009696,
-0.0902252793,
0.9761247039,
0.4747135937,
-0.44943434,
0.5009258389,
0.3691832721,
-0.306232661,
0.6624506712,
-0.9410214424,
0.3671963513,
0.305595845,
0.3624464273,
-1.0013654232,
-0.3074596226,
-0.1680340469,
-0.4257807732,
0.1472578794,
-0.2949978411,
-0.5158752203,
-0.1122285128,
-0.23713395,
0.0480983295,
0.630592525,
-0.7179713845,
0.1177803278,
0.4518663883,
-0.1640184373,
-0.3905157149,
-0.2651447356,
0.3597407639,
-0.0303518809,
-0.5193001032,
-0.1394809783,
-0.2423850745,
-0.0935494751,
-0.2890305817,
0.1669480205,
-0.1777827889,
-0.0814848319,
0.2448743135,
0.5386274457,
-0.4431505799,
0.1399665177,
-0.0146245221,
0.0575734638,
-0.302011162,
-0.3961950839,
0.7558162808,
-0.3641986251,
-0.5011994839,
-0.6965492368,
0.2757592201,
0.7978836894,
-0.219149217,
0.867631495,
0.5458062291,
-0.0546883196,
0.02677246,
-0.4622844756,
-0.2534072995,
-0.5093586445,
0.4388688803,
0.0576823056,
-1.0008432865,
0.4364049733,
0.1070123091,
0.5782031417,
0.158029601,
0.6776945591,
-0.1574079543,
1.1946542263,
0.814191401,
-0.2464700788,
0.6634571552,
-0.281553477,
0.2010282874,
-0.8444276452,
-0.2632192075,
-0.6274478436,
-0.008139289,
-0.6156796813,
-0.5050261021,
0.3697357178,
-0.0707137659,
-0.220631972,
0.4390409291,
-0.6119170189,
0.6792277098,
0.7077925205,
0.1243380681,
0.3252331316,
0.1449741125,
0.2619661987,
-0.0766512007,
-0.6884889603,
-0.7028028965,
1.3677790165,
0.4515770078,
1.1976735592,
0.2131935954,
0.427549988,
0.1010558829,
0.3174533546,
-0.6586502194,
0.5664365292,
-0.2933654785,
-0.557677567,
-0.6043221951,
-0.6627258658,
-1.0447275639,
0.0914283171,
-0.1917973012,
-0.8402417302,
-0.3726895452,
0.1828142852,
-0.3817717135,
0.4568048716,
-0.824015677,
0.6599368453,
-0.0983390659,
-0.2828218937,
-0.3875501752,
-0.3937287033,
0.4219217598,
0.1861254126,
0.0885738134,
-0.1985704303,
0.3585275412,
0.7068613768,
-0.487279892,
1.0274088383,
0.177515462,
-0.3701376319,
0.5514036417,
0.213131398,
0.2488834858,
-0.0332711414,
0.1707598865,
0.2727330625,
-0.1659611017,
-0.4771425426,
-0.5478281379,
0.7560366988,
-1.1278402805,
-0.4020861983,
0.2859266698,
-0.7680258155,
-0.2447799295,
-0.0768338293,
0.0313810296,
0.5156897306,
-0.2975409925,
0.4872538149,
0.7307342887,
-0.271306932,
0.0602663606,
0.7309523225,
-0.0836045891,
-0.2184105963,
1.1150130033,
0.0609772503,
0.5447365046,
0.3397337794,
0.2170373499,
-0.1590345651,
-0.5104171634,
-0.6514905691,
0.009469158,
-0.5914334655,
-0.2356982529,
-0.5499800444,
-0.230140686,
-0.6304576397,
0.0626605973,
-0.6732860208,
-0.4886486232,
-0.3919637203,
-0.0654640421,
0.6011259556,
0.834272325,
0.146369338,
0.8113312125,
-0.9919615388,
0.0250472482,
0.4347974956,
0.4088650644,
0.1088432893,
-0.7942442298,
-0.3452503085,
0.3613083065,
-0.5171686411,
-0.5605920553,
0.3041885495,
0.4192460775,
0.4255942404,
0.6582762003,
-0.0486070067,
0.8429441452,
-0.4925018251,
0.896673739,
0.2038725913,
-0.6614442468,
0.674646914,
-0.4250678122,
0.3310323358,
0.4771011472,
0.1855653226,
-0.6559923887,
-0.7213572264,
-0.7804285884,
-0.7611246109,
0.7553657293,
0.2487857342,
0.6617393494,
0.2127556652,
0.1500037909,
0.1782042235,
-0.0471928418,
-0.2698930204,
-0.118829824,
-0.3208562732,
-0.3691983223,
-0.1322297454,
-0.1083206907,
-0.122010462,
-0.3039648533,
0.5842408538,
-0.1897408962,
0.1192616224,
-0.5160920024,
0.111054115,
-0.1405109912,
0.3749260008,
0.5228044391,
0.5174830556,
-0.1788769513,
-0.0602788515,
0.1657912433,
-0.6694779396,
-0.0310406312,
-0.0033149414,
-0.015800247,
-0.1527296156,
0.4300630987,
0.9024052024,
0.2455588579,
-0.729197979,
0.1923459321,
-0.2551928163,
0.2702071965,
0.2358624935,
0.5617169738,
0.1801883429,
0.2729299963,
0.1502007991,
-0.3616557419,
0.0581422336,
-0.6445657015,
-0.0093230186,
0.2804274559,
-0.2924638391,
-0.3248723149,
0.599843204,
0.5229604244,
-0.4869464338,
1.1156215668,
0.2527970672,
-0.1820067316,
0.4689610898,
0.4674150646,
0.6008948088,
-0.5540602207,
0.3885429204,
0.3739772141,
0.3653637767,
-0.0276655089,
-0.0828749165,
-0.2059047669,
-0.5165458918,
-0.2146332115,
-0.3283144832,
-1.0898625851,
0.2352597862,
-0.5034189224,
0.0657903254,
-0.3810444772,
-0.0561791062,
-0.0247764941,
-0.0662166849,
-0.379868716,
-0.080977574,
0.0037933497,
0.5806126595,
-0.7742224932,
0.8778930902,
0.5368522406,
-0.5296120048,
-0.8577325344,
-0.2240678072,
-0.0464035012,
-0.9974513054,
0.0554373339,
-0.0074850023,
0.0301936157,
-0.0706615597,
-0.8207702637,
-0.7335322499,
0.8609815836,
0.4584077597,
-0.7350816727,
-0.1011846587,
0.3617070317,
0.7990036011,
-0.3253544271,
0.6850429177,
0.5297501087,
-0.0179233514,
0.348518461,
-1.1749237776,
-0.3635685146,
-0.0882416666,
0.0640402436,
0.0269371178,
-0.7020082474,
0.7631165981,
-0.4056309462,
-0.0324452333,
0.0846159905,
0.8258992434,
-0.0074939909,
0.0472877845,
0.277841717,
0.3367761672,
0.7705309987,
0.0230093114,
0.7183504105,
-0.2079412788,
0.2741148174,
1.3950794935,
-0.1422273219,
0.8382572532,
0.1099042669,
-0.3303731084,
0.3123414814,
0.5593420267,
0.1153246164,
0.1633989811,
0.0524546169,
-0.0625903532,
-0.1178183183,
-0.2662957311,
-0.3340045512,
0.5894667506,
0.5061994791,
-0.0998491049,
-0.1895068586,
-0.0484325141,
0.1355260909,
0.0124169542,
-0.0671245679,
1.0221478939,
-0.1777380854,
-0.4815936089,
0.8503149748,
-0.1648248285,
0.5817986727,
-0.4891814291,
-0.2116263956,
-0.7307525277,
0.3039937317,
-0.0596766062,
-0.8527774215,
-0.1009742543,
0.3593764603,
0.2684226036,
0.080914177,
0.3358469903,
-0.6503915787,
-0.4258471727,
-0.0037558139,
0.3341750503,
0.4861791134,
0.1578832865,
-0.525949657,
0.1574102789,
0.0967637226,
-0.1930583864,
0.4269154966,
0.5261368155,
-0.1428108513,
0.7718205452,
0.747454226,
-0.0729951859,
0.0740517005,
0.2649059296,
0.8658157587,
-0.1770241261,
-0.3179706633,
-0.6309426427,
0.2695720792,
-0.0821862444,
-0.5365141034,
0.6959112883,
0.406692028,
0.7316200137,
0.2528725564,
0.4300177991,
0.3099130988,
0.4270587862,
-0.3131182492,
0.6859049797,
-0.2911227643,
0.2805744112,
-0.4000192583,
-0.7624374628,
-0.0638312027,
0.5169360638,
0.0942933485,
-0.0170039088,
0.1215187609,
0.8922922015,
-0.2388014495,
0.4583990276,
0.4724442959,
0.2379736751,
0.6974976659,
0.491851747,
0.9551181197,
-0.2074680328,
0.8893559575,
-0.2555133998,
-0.6650899053,
-0.5068756342,
-0.5368717909,
-0.9188760519,
-0.6754249334,
-0.2733391225,
-0.0915122256,
0.1043831855,
0.8981002569,
1.0737441778,
-0.6231099367,
-0.5332854986,
0.039381437,
-0.1154540107,
-0.1867224872,
-0.2168190479,
0.2308636457,
-0.389487803,
-0.8328057528,
0.5337072015,
0.0670365095,
0.1970865279,
-0.3822133839,
-0.0618056655,
0.161876291,
0.4384092689,
0.6655047536,
0.307584554,
-0.4172853231,
-0.1952205747,
0.0500504896,
-0.1758615226,
0.1991518289,
0.6452481151,
-0.1976566613,
0.4951146841,
0.0729264617,
0.6661895514,
0.4182936251,
-0.1416508108,
0.4680402577,
-0.6293483377,
0.0245132446,
0.0590975583,
-0.0019153845,
0.5208256841,
-0.3842523396,
0.5815063119,
-0.2878780961,
-0.6306573749,
-0.9149336219,
-0.0014156515,
-0.6855931282,
-0.1263437122,
1.1249777079,
-0.1835633367,
0.0793245435,
0.2049820721,
-0.6006718278,
0.3511890471,
-0.6857141256,
1.0197452307,
0.6353807449,
-0.3671773374,
-0.2098301649,
-0.5913565755,
0.1302025616,
0.4005978107,
-1.0730654001,
0.5703836679,
0.6973495483,
-0.042756591,
0.1379396915,
0.6360962987,
-0.0841628984,
0.1734677255,
-0.045357462,
0.0800106823,
-0.0447838642,
-0.5610767603,
-0.1130963564,
-0.0475324392,
0.2107045054,
-0.3596138954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14232v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14232v2 | Pre-training Multi-task Contrastive Learning Models for Scientific Literature Understanding | 2023-05-23T16:47:22 | 2023-10-19T01:18:49 | Yu Zhang, Hao Cheng, Zhihong Shen, Xiaodong Liu, Ye-Yi Wang, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Scientific literature understanding tasks have gained significant attention
due to their potential to accelerate scientific discovery. Pre-trained language
models (LMs) have shown effectiveness in these tasks, especially when tuned via
contrastive learning. However, jointly utilizing pre-training data across
multiple heterogeneous tasks (e.g., extreme multi-label paper classification,
citation prediction, and literature search) remains largely unexplored. To
bridge this gap, we propose a multi-task contrastive learning framework,
SciMult, with a focus on facilitating common knowledge sharing across different
scientific literature understanding tasks while preventing task-specific skills
from interfering with each other. To be specific, we explore two techniques --
task-aware specialization and instruction tuning. The former adopts a
Mixture-of-Experts Transformer architecture with task-aware sub-layers; the
latter prepends task-specific instructions to the input text so as to produce
task-aware outputs. Extensive experiments on a comprehensive collection of
benchmark datasets verify the effectiveness of our task-aware specialization
strategy, where we outperform state-of-the-art scientific pre-trained LMs.
Code, datasets, and pre-trained models can be found at
https://scimult.github.io/. | [
-0.316981256,
-0.2691409886,
0.3411002755,
0.3260234296,
-0.412876904,
0.1404093057,
-0.2589036226,
-0.3203650713,
0.0898210257,
0.4293352365,
-0.5266627669,
-0.4631323516,
-0.688990593,
0.2265381068,
-0.1222711951,
1.3202537298,
-0.0533896275,
0.2693791389,
-0.8053364754,
-0.2133610994,
-0.0697298944,
-0.2849024236,
-0.0663608834,
-0.5187959671,
0.8229188919,
0.3740660548,
0.3418643475,
0.4356518686,
0.5621876121,
0.2517997026,
0.0732229352,
0.3084026575,
-0.590041101,
0.1509818584,
-0.4305381775,
-0.6329010725,
-0.1576905102,
0.0723942071,
0.6265858412,
0.8513825536,
0.2597441971,
0.0535849705,
0.5169816613,
0.4297065735,
-0.7078502178,
0.2065396756,
-0.4665074646,
0.2791995406,
-0.2147024572,
-0.4222095013,
-0.4770691693,
0.1297976822,
0.2029860914,
-1.0363335609,
0.7367192507,
0.15145576,
0.7479509711,
0.3124198914,
-0.4191763103,
0.0254658703,
-0.474241972,
1.0383056402,
-0.2637213767,
0.3117055595,
0.4167776108,
-0.0079594757,
0.0068901926,
-0.9453646541,
-0.4007688761,
-0.2062830478,
-0.5134264231,
0.4713511169,
-0.0085837292,
0.0222871937,
0.1080406457,
0.204885453,
-0.7380561233,
0.113984257,
-0.5272442102,
-0.092809096,
0.1661113203,
-0.0728065744,
-0.0519298427,
0.0203474611,
-0.3366790116,
-0.065431565,
-0.5010340214,
-0.014397284,
0.0951262712,
0.178344667,
0.0384916626,
0.3597910404,
-0.0003955484,
0.5004372001,
0.1441567838,
0.1077435613,
0.4518113434,
-0.5997802019,
-0.1788628846,
-0.1380195767,
0.7055786848,
0.005144374,
-0.2168860584,
-0.2990597785,
0.0502106398,
0.0740396753,
0.4743352532,
-0.9711065292,
-0.5265282393,
0.0731878504,
-0.4667367041,
-0.2381670773,
-0.2278813124,
-0.505810678,
-0.5204021335,
-0.4332084954,
0.5316806436,
-0.4557291269,
-0.2675109506,
-0.0277432706,
0.0106258709,
-0.3587884307,
0.1974083036,
-0.7130888104,
0.3094830215,
0.4857898057,
0.8081917763,
-0.3000106215,
-0.5982369781,
-0.6337419152,
0.2574772537,
-0.0083699701,
0.8076336384,
-0.5719423294,
-0.4924195409,
-0.3386586607,
0.0251776967,
-0.3728168309,
-0.1948809028,
0.6133961082,
-0.5398614407,
0.4046643972,
-0.2410769463,
-0.4424399734,
-0.19512932,
0.2565342188,
-0.684928894,
0.7534249425,
-0.127101481,
-1.3104014397,
0.312022388,
-0.9941909313,
-0.5256491303,
0.094641529,
-0.2028788775,
-0.5121173859,
0.1182070747,
0.3401688337,
0.57336092,
-0.1391454786,
0.4115948081,
-0.2690261304,
-0.3501530886,
0.0606518947,
-0.2116686106,
0.6035922766,
0.3924369812,
-0.1108168438,
0.50661093,
-0.4312265515,
-0.270798564,
-0.0863146931,
0.0259404313,
-0.5607213378,
-0.0070407279,
0.1999607682,
0.0727491453,
0.1924392283,
-0.4893249869,
0.0789440945,
-0.113212958,
0.2841100097,
0.3378857672,
-0.2967900932,
0.4851447642,
-0.4174986482,
0.4318067431,
0.4948686659,
0.0783325285,
-0.5013588667,
-0.1388221383,
-0.5284188986,
-0.3646354079,
0.2784717083,
0.4020188749,
-0.8380678296,
0.2782355845,
-0.1470724642,
-0.723500967,
-0.6354003549,
0.2138375044,
0.6371943951,
0.7072144747,
0.7262368798,
-0.277084887,
-0.5220886469,
-0.7469234467,
-0.4083705246,
0.3665066957,
-0.0278217047,
0.3202096224,
0.6792710423,
-0.2623298466,
0.8250047565,
-0.539922595,
-0.2957007885,
-0.089055337,
0.595446527,
0.168803528,
0.8321278095,
0.3445497155,
-1.1129552126,
-0.5093839765,
0.1190279201,
-0.6742984653,
0.0035180012,
-0.0435595252,
-0.0766562298,
-0.1851369888,
0.693184495,
-0.3839604557,
0.0052454513,
0.537180841,
-0.1365292966,
0.790987432,
-0.444786191,
0.4079768062,
-1.1595226526,
0.3281376362,
0.2313827425,
0.0004083008,
-0.8998838067,
-0.0962039605,
0.3508072793,
0.0111635542,
-0.297214359,
0.2505975068,
-0.600273788,
-0.003380452,
-0.2097802311,
-0.1239907891,
0.2687887251,
0.2811876237,
0.3067443073,
0.5890447497,
0.7827737927,
-0.5797635317,
-0.2165694982,
0.0384667777,
-0.4252208173,
0.5539484024,
-0.5511891246,
0.0181817375,
-0.3198171854,
0.3878414333,
-0.7401947975,
-0.0912387371,
0.0636627749,
-0.1710018069,
0.3259160221,
-0.0316432081,
-0.3786204755,
-0.1442826688,
-0.1043650657,
0.5701674819,
0.1105120778,
-0.4410896003,
0.8375793099,
0.1178737059,
-0.3632220626,
-1.1378599405,
-0.5308566689,
-0.3477867544,
-0.2383674979,
-0.198116228,
0.8064231873,
-0.2374146134,
0.0759960264,
0.1962360293,
-0.2091186792,
-0.2414689213,
0.1354889721,
0.3487504423,
0.2898414135,
-0.1759696007,
0.3495873809,
0.4332157671,
0.067631565,
-0.1099241003,
-0.3938679695,
0.3346243799,
-0.1183636189,
-0.4069196284,
-0.0738142729,
0.2528407276,
0.478045553,
-0.540332973,
0.7155584097,
1.0128744841,
-0.1284004748,
0.0614083409,
-0.462356776,
-0.3862118423,
-0.4520544112,
0.5562086105,
-0.5030222535,
-1.0298409462,
0.3267137408,
-0.255471617,
0.38911587,
0.2857229114,
0.317859441,
-0.4398210645,
0.7835288048,
0.858677268,
0.1558464319,
0.5453959107,
-0.0764775723,
-0.001866838,
-0.7092584968,
-0.4690778255,
-0.7482010126,
-0.1950112283,
-0.2276280373,
-0.7002238631,
0.3619396687,
0.1586772203,
-0.1406602412,
0.0965507701,
-0.5001224875,
0.7609421015,
0.6001723409,
0.1785478145,
0.4046440125,
0.0570680164,
-0.3482607007,
-0.1141861603,
-0.8400911689,
-0.209894523,
1.0346423388,
0.0560118854,
0.6672712564,
-0.4902606308,
0.816486299,
0.1704668701,
0.4520438612,
-0.4487346411,
0.2100885212,
-0.3253217041,
-0.397241354,
-0.2818206549,
-0.3331648707,
-1.220923543,
0.8276104927,
-0.4255650043,
-0.2889233828,
0.1774829477,
0.3638143837,
-0.1779072434,
0.1457392871,
-0.6740637422,
1.0072114468,
-0.285402894,
-0.4557343423,
-0.5754798055,
-0.8603870273,
0.3935059011,
-0.25348562,
0.3615061641,
0.1895729452,
-0.0465242527,
0.7496205568,
0.3724990785,
0.8541220427,
-0.1170436591,
0.3297460675,
-0.226306051,
-0.0216968171,
0.1650735289,
0.0140825259,
-0.0817827061,
0.0075851171,
0.1562739164,
-0.6892097592,
-0.3011879325,
0.8044124842,
-0.9178204536,
-0.5604729056,
-0.4835082591,
-1.0818463564,
-0.3053956628,
0.2728548348,
0.4176623225,
0.1612081081,
-0.2958267033,
0.2921495736,
0.9105821848,
-0.0508648045,
0.1459041238,
0.7317845225,
0.0005425065,
-0.0158896875,
0.9727181792,
-0.0728602409,
0.0578857884,
0.50072366,
0.1003031582,
-0.1643747836,
-0.6325352192,
0.1307300329,
0.236882031,
-0.6833921671,
-0.0838323087,
-1.0249319077,
0.0083168726,
-0.5102252364,
-0.247252956,
-0.1444619894,
0.0149784535,
-0.6605536342,
0.1468487084,
0.0692985803,
0.6150146723,
-0.0692526102,
0.1875011176,
-0.8590410352,
0.3628673851,
0.0724296123,
0.2368265241,
-0.2100846618,
-0.5263046622,
-0.5819013119,
-0.1401003301,
-0.2337021083,
-0.6049016118,
0.4830486476,
0.3073678017,
0.7189484239,
0.2902169824,
0.0814056098,
0.5085068941,
-0.4607715607,
0.4524233639,
0.462831229,
-0.7733920813,
0.4554837346,
-0.0746539533,
0.4617697895,
0.7040243149,
1.0201889277,
-0.2967452109,
-0.4220714569,
-0.5023543239,
-0.5884708762,
0.6560027003,
-0.065164879,
-0.1414753348,
0.4869052768,
-0.1083854511,
0.6671750546,
0.2926962376,
-0.7523522973,
-0.0393768437,
-0.6867869496,
-0.1889816672,
-0.5552105904,
0.1809757501,
-0.4312088192,
-0.4339970946,
0.5685928464,
-0.3293412626,
-0.0453010984,
0.1255944818,
-0.6575369835,
0.081259504,
0.4171020091,
0.6081379056,
0.6401894093,
-0.0843723342,
0.4003539383,
-0.0440689251,
-0.7229698896,
-0.1609975249,
0.5609859228,
0.0980864763,
-0.0944025218,
0.2431647778,
0.902829051,
0.2551496029,
-0.4880273342,
0.1667119265,
-0.0498910844,
-0.5217694044,
0.3651685715,
0.0156542324,
0.3144779503,
0.3371945322,
0.4865474403,
0.4280344546,
0.2036008388,
-0.179313913,
0.1011486501,
0.3202039301,
-0.1806676686,
-0.2371433526,
0.4870357215,
0.2532312572,
0.1869046539,
0.1752652079,
-0.1319791973,
-0.5028464198,
0.5847391486,
0.6169716716,
0.3965907991,
-0.2569679618,
0.3084303737,
0.1569960713,
0.2430496514,
-0.049234774,
0.1265709102,
-0.4284078479,
-0.6541556716,
-0.6010599136,
-0.5170734525,
-0.5690715909,
0.2380165458,
-0.6388076544,
0.1702780575,
-0.0694189072,
0.1116169542,
0.3074709177,
0.1120985821,
-0.8080681562,
0.115656808,
-0.2540009618,
0.4952487648,
-1.1957163811,
1.1842368841,
0.9002743363,
-0.2525238991,
-0.3486853838,
-0.0966230258,
-0.2948996127,
-0.358078301,
0.7761346102,
0.3011833131,
-0.0923678055,
0.0933460146,
-0.467081815,
-0.6862905622,
1.0292365551,
0.3394138813,
-0.7760355473,
0.0716495812,
-0.2168922424,
0.6118962765,
-0.4230651557,
0.4699181318,
0.2750653625,
0.3373010457,
0.0040121283,
-0.8451450467,
-0.1624937654,
-0.424998939,
-0.3373007774,
-0.0874611661,
-0.2524874508,
0.950532198,
-0.2055547833,
0.0487660579,
-0.2786951959,
0.7737954855,
0.4055210352,
0.6185197234,
0.6980635524,
0.2415769845,
0.9704865217,
0.1353609711,
0.6199646592,
-0.3810088038,
0.2489709854,
1.1483120918,
-0.4242727458,
0.4317338467,
0.5467272401,
0.0686457604,
0.4588984549,
0.6214193702,
-0.177217707,
0.7084094882,
0.151012823,
-0.3528255224,
-0.3158018291,
-0.3103215098,
-0.5432654023,
0.0959855616,
0.538424015,
-0.3975050151,
-0.0647754595,
0.5721361637,
-0.2286970764,
0.1422458738,
-0.439804256,
0.4512870014,
0.0012602244,
-0.8576225638,
0.4411619306,
-0.3574730158,
1.0198105574,
-0.6230553389,
0.1192491427,
-0.0089636622,
0.0513448156,
-0.3984466195,
-0.7158428431,
-0.0026840745,
-0.0411925577,
-0.4455412328,
-0.3151597977,
0.8816806078,
-0.7857205272,
-0.3199131191,
0.0556651279,
0.6038774848,
0.2028876543,
0.1250064969,
-0.7225697041,
-0.0845535994,
-0.2219551802,
-0.3135868609,
0.7469670177,
0.2049091607,
-0.0080456026,
0.5561566353,
0.6139840484,
-0.0133391516,
-0.1669519395,
0.1586937308,
0.9559519887,
-0.1777884662,
-0.5983015895,
-0.4600121975,
0.4039233625,
-0.204772085,
-0.0897985026,
0.5977343321,
0.5174437165,
0.8046619892,
-0.3761903942,
0.8153267503,
0.2244497389,
0.5282588005,
-0.244321242,
0.8567453623,
-0.5571429729,
-0.0218627676,
-0.1426863521,
-0.7795863152,
-0.4685414732,
0.4838862717,
-0.2668817043,
0.0074719153,
1.0401624441,
0.6785678267,
-0.4098258615,
0.1482531577,
0.2769560218,
0.1298832148,
0.1303651482,
0.3371084929,
0.5963680744,
0.1331422329,
0.6070976257,
-0.3465250134,
-0.1695513725,
-0.1915380657,
-1.0133875608,
-1.0935870409,
-0.6987615228,
-0.3200471699,
0.0085666617,
0.105300121,
0.7091738582,
0.775734961,
-0.7082574368,
-0.137084052,
-0.1436868459,
-0.1065591276,
-0.4308291078,
-0.1200322956,
0.5051671267,
-0.6042575836,
-0.6660662889,
0.5176433325,
0.0816783831,
-0.2276303768,
-0.2403580248,
-0.0598013289,
-0.2590947747,
-0.1326110363,
0.4724209607,
0.332488507,
-0.5186060071,
0.3128448129,
0.0395545326,
-0.2351025492,
-0.055765111,
1.0778412819,
-0.8444687128,
0.5858168602,
0.4471649826,
0.7070656419,
0.9664368033,
-0.2279059291,
0.4045619369,
-0.7866671681,
0.1346293092,
0.5262254477,
0.3924948275,
0.2756004632,
-0.3544508815,
0.3645614684,
0.2040928304,
-0.6997378469,
-0.854205668,
0.0884138048,
-0.979626298,
-0.6461207271,
0.6134489179,
-0.5747745633,
0.0792010799,
-0.3451095521,
-0.1201315001,
0.5330420136,
-0.1012845784,
0.6508677006,
0.5764179826,
-0.2067318112,
-0.25954023,
-0.313939184,
0.4109763503,
1.0134170055,
-0.9955397248,
-0.1037582979,
0.3314367831,
0.1805297732,
0.3933582306,
0.3011418283,
0.1675108969,
0.3858008385,
-0.1706846505,
0.1095583439,
-0.4996483326,
-0.4879719317,
-0.264038682,
0.3747748733,
-0.1711611599,
-0.0064806058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14230v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14230v2 | Exploring Representational Disparities Between Multilingual and Bilingual Translation Models | 2023-05-23T16:46:18 | 2024-03-26T13:16:37 | Neha Verma, Kenton Murray, Kevin Duh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual machine translation has proven immensely useful for both
parameter efficiency and overall performance across many language pairs via
complete multilingual parameter sharing. However, some language pairs in
multilingual models can see worse performance than in bilingual models,
especially in the one-to-many translation setting. Motivated by their empirical
differences, we examine the geometric differences in representations from
bilingual models versus those from one-to-many multilingual models.
Specifically, we compute the isotropy of these representations using intrinsic
dimensionality and IsoScore, in order to measure how the representations
utilize the dimensions in their underlying vector space. Using the same
evaluation data in both models, we find that for a given language pair, its
multilingual model decoder representations are consistently less isotropic and
occupy fewer dimensions than comparable bilingual model decoder
representations. Additionally, we show that much of the anisotropy in
multilingual decoder representations can be attributed to modeling
language-specific information, therefore limiting remaining representational
capacity. | [
-0.5760402679,
-0.1718334854,
0.611240983,
0.4368022084,
-0.3319651186,
-0.02027102,
-0.1902701855,
-0.5337690115,
0.1873926967,
0.1165466458,
-0.3986491263,
-0.4606487751,
-0.9425805807,
0.3779214025,
-0.1554298699,
0.4865430593,
-0.2043941617,
0.610517323,
-0.4661878347,
-0.6534200311,
-0.1961320639,
-0.7828672528,
-0.0507814251,
-0.3718704283,
0.6434001327,
-0.0592124425,
0.9052661061,
0.8373954892,
0.6500027776,
0.3193589151,
0.0195205119,
0.0537358969,
-0.3745127022,
0.0953099579,
0.2103038579,
-0.4938973188,
-0.3867091835,
-0.1063633636,
1.025665164,
0.9096918106,
-0.0549835376,
-0.0117295384,
0.1362866759,
0.6429249048,
-0.4959303439,
0.4872422516,
-0.3060949743,
0.2568317354,
-0.1788374484,
0.0514610894,
-0.3337877095,
-0.2206500024,
-0.1663684696,
-0.9121711254,
0.0923526734,
-0.0175415725,
0.6595865488,
0.3323955536,
-0.7773279548,
-0.3303031921,
-0.7926313877,
0.6071801186,
-0.7403730154,
0.9039617181,
0.3428556919,
0.2546267211,
0.2767740488,
-0.137073949,
-0.4532139301,
-0.3371514082,
-0.4343304038,
0.0781930313,
-0.456135571,
-0.1053822339,
0.2537311316,
0.118146278,
-0.7255536914,
0.4164473712,
-0.5317258835,
-0.063425608,
0.6339765191,
0.1171407029,
0.3285318315,
-0.293287307,
-0.4974579513,
-0.3592858315,
-0.7497567534,
0.0219795331,
0.5565493703,
0.3232406974,
-0.4367902875,
0.6845487952,
0.2795314789,
0.5092738867,
-0.2675710022,
-0.0864285827,
0.3224752843,
-0.2101833969,
0.1111147478,
-0.0730248615,
0.9704322219,
0.2804204822,
0.0194177069,
-0.2133004218,
-0.0553475805,
-0.1055422351,
-0.0904995501,
-0.7212823629,
0.0983548239,
-0.2270839065,
-0.5117830038,
0.5063030124,
0.3504282534,
-0.3624882102,
-0.3945189416,
-0.5098580718,
0.0532580465,
-0.5505280495,
-0.3350579143,
0.0936509296,
-0.3290872872,
0.0192049351,
0.1320236623,
-0.868286252,
0.1414484382,
0.4896911979,
0.8257260919,
0.0424424484,
-0.6692979932,
0.0161756799,
0.2202251405,
-0.5086681843,
0.411985904,
-0.6888466477,
-0.5030279756,
-0.1947690398,
-0.0539638735,
-0.3556154072,
-0.6171078682,
0.0288953204,
-0.485558331,
-0.0694206208,
-0.7230318785,
-0.2340745181,
-0.4646399021,
0.0789125413,
-1.0856460333,
0.5705087781,
-0.005550582,
-0.718506813,
0.5468207598,
-0.2803443074,
-0.1591510624,
-0.2225760669,
-0.4243972301,
-0.2707329094,
0.5965047479,
0.3234594464,
0.3129657507,
-0.4893372357,
-0.1179189831,
-0.5507705212,
-0.2899949849,
0.2791450024,
-0.5800237656,
0.8373701572,
0.1736356169,
0.1100497469,
-0.300802052,
-0.569714129,
-0.4758612812,
0.1620201468,
-0.4168785214,
-0.6295861006,
-0.0112873204,
0.0616602898,
0.4506621361,
0.1625418961,
-0.4728694856,
0.2161504626,
0.0254274365,
0.2756091058,
0.4737177491,
-0.311488688,
0.7120339274,
-0.1193557009,
0.6062681079,
0.4956457317,
-0.2491146624,
0.0433628522,
-0.4017038643,
-0.4084620178,
-0.4939644635,
0.1874059439,
0.4177804291,
-0.609079659,
-0.0674930289,
-0.4826003313,
-0.2394412309,
-0.8436418176,
0.3298644722,
0.4767629504,
0.0465564393,
0.3665067554,
-0.3822199106,
-0.1572421491,
-1.2221194506,
-0.3283798099,
-0.387639612,
-0.1969663054,
0.0008990992,
0.3016923368,
-0.2739226222,
0.3868242502,
-0.1613116562,
-0.2358320653,
-0.0700101107,
0.0511381067,
-0.0084518446,
0.3461238444,
1.0286197662,
-0.6600596905,
-0.7992993593,
0.3366244435,
-0.9438251257,
0.2501926422,
0.1765938103,
0.1014777496,
0.1702895015,
0.308637321,
-0.5707296133,
0.3967457116,
0.7891896367,
-0.2559530139,
0.3450905979,
-0.713329792,
0.4610881507,
-0.8276512623,
-0.087347962,
0.1793418825,
-0.2103063166,
-0.5154280066,
0.0697813779,
0.2800822258,
-0.1791595668,
-0.3017603755,
0.3059825003,
-0.8544782996,
-0.3468745053,
0.2236447632,
0.1446160525,
0.2304492742,
0.3619683683,
0.1308938414,
0.6795219183,
0.6326463819,
-0.4723261893,
0.102699928,
0.2580967247,
-0.1250205189,
0.6038119197,
-0.7163654566,
-0.0302213617,
-0.4927986264,
0.1425934285,
-0.8006361127,
-0.1022476107,
-0.0117416186,
-0.3549099267,
0.6360113025,
-0.2662315667,
-0.6691203713,
-0.0643553287,
-0.291221559,
1.0103237629,
0.3598751426,
-0.363497287,
0.1788059771,
0.4021451771,
-0.1820847541,
-0.3639468253,
-1.1162824631,
-0.1113618836,
-0.3381994069,
-0.6362136602,
0.330176264,
0.3463597298,
-0.2804426849,
0.174074024,
0.0564847216,
-0.1417364627,
-0.2355660498,
0.056942746,
0.0080814054,
-0.4510401189,
0.191283673,
0.2255197018,
-0.2251862735,
0.1160786897,
-0.2310087085,
0.4407329857,
-0.1322623193,
-0.7665197253,
-0.4080561697,
0.790227592,
0.8755996823,
-0.5138885379,
1.0622633696,
0.6108145118,
-0.4460154176,
0.2180110365,
-0.3381497562,
-0.0668586567,
-0.3834196031,
0.6057032347,
-0.5645204782,
-0.5631305575,
0.8668282032,
0.4194963276,
-0.1111973748,
0.5207279325,
0.5264592767,
-0.0354335345,
1.4158084393,
0.7041272521,
-0.0237431917,
0.2930984795,
-0.3740976751,
0.3382563591,
-0.8350805044,
-0.4807656109,
-0.5377739668,
-0.3227839768,
-0.9340510964,
-0.7215717435,
0.6804271936,
0.3010237515,
-0.2764434516,
0.4184544981,
-0.260099858,
0.2559280396,
0.5740898252,
-0.0694560334,
0.40062657,
0.309038341,
-0.3852059543,
-0.6072443128,
-0.9748293757,
-0.6113076806,
0.8297483921,
0.4887570441,
0.6828819513,
0.3665611744,
0.6107472777,
-0.1101727709,
-0.078571707,
-0.5433858037,
0.0577641949,
-0.5166778564,
-0.5077203512,
-0.1061514691,
-0.6901364326,
-0.8754656911,
0.5757812262,
0.0186347049,
-0.6575436592,
0.6143417358,
0.0828906149,
0.137700364,
0.5167523026,
-0.6727121472,
0.9176359177,
-0.2216956615,
-0.0737624317,
-0.316454798,
-0.4202198982,
0.2619605362,
0.1385814101,
0.3291121125,
-0.0933255255,
0.0105131818,
0.3902181387,
-0.386433512,
0.5162892342,
-0.2029120773,
-0.1740219742,
0.0247166548,
0.4837152064,
0.0659707859,
0.2832084,
-0.2985621095,
0.7224840522,
0.1894523948,
-0.633918047,
-0.6594390273,
0.6080733538,
-1.0711171627,
-0.488493681,
-0.2075234503,
-0.8374366164,
-0.0066325972,
-0.1378388703,
0.5752218366,
0.4696455896,
-0.2891940475,
0.1255024076,
0.3138931394,
-0.436676234,
0.3230303824,
0.2215823829,
-0.3130209148,
-0.1649381667,
0.8672158718,
0.4189872742,
0.3816904724,
0.7019348741,
-0.0570115447,
-0.7540017962,
-0.2481723279,
-0.7629616261,
0.5297024846,
-0.845523119,
0.0045626229,
-0.3879706264,
0.0071649919,
-0.430696547,
0.0000016944,
-0.5380287766,
-0.7626318336,
-0.1093823761,
-0.0932298228,
0.0750665814,
1.0561813116,
-0.2934623957,
0.1373048723,
-0.7688578963,
0.2250764668,
0.0256284717,
0.1356066316,
0.0866476521,
-0.5216071606,
-0.3594518006,
0.3446223736,
-0.2581697702,
-1.1522142887,
0.4033853412,
0.0837198049,
0.6044454575,
0.5753473639,
-0.2021631449,
0.7819678783,
-0.6284534931,
0.6255105734,
0.4095676541,
-0.8347705007,
-0.0257327687,
-0.0832875147,
0.3898724318,
0.2758128643,
0.8310398459,
-0.621420145,
-0.4647527039,
-0.0883525535,
-0.5254814625,
0.6315205693,
0.0829434842,
0.1802325547,
0.0973221362,
0.0225146115,
0.3991121948,
-0.0425494611,
-0.9392447472,
-0.3280896842,
-0.3639187813,
0.034476459,
-0.4536631107,
-0.1764484048,
0.0268510021,
-0.2968984544,
0.243859306,
0.1857184023,
0.5383868217,
0.0805762261,
-0.4037225246,
0.0703312457,
0.2333844155,
0.5420786142,
0.7013972998,
0.0862972438,
0.4263680875,
0.1258129179,
-0.066397503,
0.4591909349,
0.2497464269,
0.1711858958,
0.3288379908,
0.7618942857,
0.9924442172,
-0.0058499537,
-0.2152940929,
0.1900019199,
-0.0204807334,
-0.1154636294,
0.1879507303,
-0.5496609807,
0.3515627384,
0.1408688426,
0.1116230041,
-0.0010866317,
0.06635198,
-0.5048103929,
-0.2454612106,
0.3198634088,
-0.5387957692,
-0.648753643,
0.6867412329,
-0.0771256536,
-0.1402254403,
0.7552702427,
-0.4011427462,
-0.565296948,
0.4713017642,
0.4786915183,
0.5803977251,
-0.2267662883,
0.3600304127,
0.5458688736,
0.4749467969,
0.2124165595,
-0.2508381903,
-0.1580462754,
-0.6817886233,
-0.0473787151,
-0.4310453832,
0.100183785,
-0.2146082222,
-0.8545302153,
0.0664842054,
-0.0746632218,
-0.1064865291,
-0.1730406433,
-0.3045667708,
-0.8656836152,
-0.3051635623,
0.0862209573,
0.3275203109,
-0.9263281822,
0.6643570662,
0.8986142874,
-0.6340110898,
-0.7655725479,
-0.1833049357,
0.2303554118,
-0.7029349804,
0.850676775,
0.1753598303,
-0.1130512208,
-0.4990843236,
0.3191719055,
-0.689979434,
0.94160676,
1.0072574615,
-0.7070165277,
-0.2127603889,
0.9904676676,
0.6748428345,
-0.1671964824,
0.1782742292,
0.2374994755,
0.5401394963,
-0.2939887345,
-0.9991250634,
-0.0163960792,
-0.1864514798,
0.382227391,
0.2209019065,
-0.5242496729,
1.0695226192,
-0.0256560929,
-0.5203852057,
-0.3231436908,
0.1642650217,
0.3946394026,
0.1628363878,
0.1674719602,
0.5978379846,
0.4768637717,
-0.0065920223,
1.4577425718,
-0.4580141902,
0.3313430548,
0.601852119,
0.0298365578,
0.6518996954,
0.7077128887,
-0.183683008,
0.234945938,
0.4957943857,
0.3789502978,
0.3495532572,
0.0549097843,
-0.1129074022,
-0.2881696224,
0.1631113887,
-0.6359587908,
0.3581454754,
0.124234505,
-0.2491124272,
-0.600171864,
0.1174188256,
-0.0274862796,
0.4638696909,
0.0160782505,
0.5815643072,
0.3915993571,
-0.4030005634,
0.9947343469,
0.3611752689,
0.3490218222,
-0.4267778695,
-0.0237548202,
-0.4304531515,
0.2506056428,
-0.0676394999,
-0.4731928706,
0.4740284681,
-0.0285428856,
-0.4100586772,
-0.4766368568,
0.1114842668,
-0.711771071,
-0.7523244023,
0.8561919928,
0.7469883561,
0.1229625866,
-0.0619049929,
-0.7567947507,
0.2393317074,
-0.1345378458,
0.023330763,
0.2089784145,
0.8116755486,
-0.1461474001,
0.4757917225,
0.1980468035,
0.2383642644,
0.5513316989,
0.1659695059,
0.6214103103,
-0.3483218551,
-0.3294811845,
-0.9956102967,
0.5553542972,
0.2091042548,
-0.2830369771,
0.8959242105,
0.8237888813,
1.1880135536,
-0.3012089133,
0.4680271447,
0.0387912318,
-0.0850603953,
-0.6730684042,
0.8323910832,
-0.7828410268,
0.4280948341,
-0.060605932,
-1.2142175436,
-0.3434911072,
0.7049044371,
-0.2759234607,
0.0868516713,
0.6351510286,
0.8630344868,
-0.6002980471,
-0.4852705896,
0.533983469,
0.0984810889,
0.3874541521,
0.5798984766,
1.073846221,
-0.5335267186,
0.2185843736,
-0.2607687414,
-0.0093914531,
0.0541430116,
-0.5310084224,
-0.8255942464,
-0.886192441,
-0.1410957575,
0.0229756348,
-0.1742141694,
0.6755960584,
0.8687707782,
-0.5222683549,
-0.6453303695,
0.1197388992,
0.2947989106,
-0.095489718,
-0.1267297268,
0.1650774181,
-0.2813594937,
-0.9071294665,
0.2317286581,
0.3971025348,
0.1392352432,
-0.4740420282,
-0.5337403417,
-0.0203468744,
-0.1319510788,
0.495433867,
0.1018533558,
-0.7856707573,
0.0887268335,
0.1042150855,
-0.2374028713,
0.3730070591,
1.0408014059,
-0.2223780006,
0.530755043,
0.5812782049,
0.4378764629,
0.903314054,
-0.1795854717,
0.7679444551,
-0.7447295189,
0.6059328318,
0.2475295365,
0.4249186218,
0.5503399968,
-0.054548163,
-0.0478780903,
0.1333753616,
-0.1505275667,
-0.8093256354,
0.399467051,
-0.6641051769,
-0.3920002282,
0.9679002762,
-0.2978692055,
-0.0263491627,
0.2658639848,
0.1782380491,
0.1049844921,
-0.166145891,
0.5268606544,
0.9265663624,
0.0795669183,
-0.1702460945,
-0.4617549479,
0.1485811919,
0.3155519664,
-0.4065589905,
0.0147248534,
0.4308871925,
0.1577854604,
0.3154864907,
0.4164687991,
-0.4988022745,
0.0811385587,
0.271214813,
-0.0795387626,
-0.0960880443,
-0.4848853648,
-0.5841594934,
-0.1553695351,
0.2806266546,
-0.0590178445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14225v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14225v2 | ManiTweet: A New Benchmark for Identifying Manipulation of News on Social Media | 2023-05-23T16:40:07 | 2024-06-12T06:25:15 | Kung-Hsiang Huang, Hou Pong Chan, Kathleen McKeown, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Considerable advancements have been made to tackle the misrepresentation of
information derived from reference articles in the domains of fact-checking and
faithful summarization. However, an unaddressed aspect remains - the
identification of social media posts that manipulate information within
associated news articles. This task presents a significant challenge, primarily
due to the prevalence of personal opinions in such posts. We present a novel
task, identifying manipulation of news on social media, which aims to detect
manipulation in social media posts and identify manipulated or inserted
information. To study this task, we have proposed a data collection schema and
curated a dataset called ManiTweet, consisting of 3.6K pairs of tweets and
corresponding articles. Our analysis demonstrates that this task is highly
challenging, with large language models (LLMs) yielding unsatisfactory
performance. Additionally, we have developed a simple yet effective basic model
that outperforms LLMs significantly on the ManiTweet dataset. Finally, we have
conducted an exploratory analysis of human-written tweets, unveiling intriguing
connections between manipulation and the domain and factuality of news
articles, as well as revealing that manipulated sentences are more likely to
encapsulate the main story or consequences of a news outlet. | [
-0.1267243326,
-1.1821374893,
0.6039768457,
0.3055187166,
-0.4942046404,
0.4818482995,
-0.0149938995,
-0.473823756,
0.4900743663,
0.3991827667,
-0.4965970218,
-0.4675316215,
-0.9786551595,
-0.0084436871,
-0.9816281796,
0.8226113915,
-0.2219744474,
-0.0921220928,
0.2038696855,
-0.0600939207,
-0.2935300767,
-0.4208842814,
-0.2240763456,
0.0362702645,
0.8194724321,
-0.1342540383,
0.6712978482,
0.5958554149,
0.6675589681,
0.1981971264,
-0.0998091102,
0.4977034926,
-0.6778008342,
-0.2582805455,
-0.3185270429,
-0.1268678457,
-0.2036545724,
0.4263171256,
0.5219687819,
0.5712051392,
0.210815385,
0.4613265097,
-0.0161894374,
0.6265442371,
-0.7376006246,
-0.0342631675,
-0.8637714386,
-0.2999629378,
-0.5574833155,
-0.4663317502,
-0.1699670404,
-0.5132964253,
-0.5915292501,
-0.3491096497,
0.1202071682,
-0.2494830787,
1.0104963779,
0.2060877532,
-0.54333812,
-0.0856074244,
-0.7420040369,
0.4105554223,
-0.0616896264,
0.4110487103,
0.357631743,
0.2623471022,
-0.0195691679,
-0.3804300129,
-0.5963439941,
0.0495849289,
-0.3040361404,
-0.1124250814,
-0.4602189958,
-0.4204134047,
0.2492972612,
0.0236675087,
-0.318054378,
-0.3692285419,
-0.5720117688,
-0.2188863307,
0.6438971162,
0.0766977072,
0.4649451375,
-0.4324422777,
-0.5597916842,
0.1905283183,
-0.6214081049,
-0.0575176962,
0.5455508828,
0.2150639594,
-0.0086094076,
0.9788849354,
-0.1617148519,
0.6030148268,
0.1410418451,
0.0063275238,
0.2460557073,
-0.2669709325,
-0.1301218271,
-0.0417051874,
0.8776625991,
1.0332387686,
0.0877142102,
-0.3213738799,
-0.2398607284,
0.2279569656,
0.4909454584,
-0.4654574096,
-0.0643511713,
-0.099137567,
-0.3262609243,
-0.8121794462,
0.6692026854,
-0.4866276085,
-0.6903346777,
-0.3097911775,
0.5539603233,
-0.3867912292,
-0.2379157096,
-0.1513882279,
-0.2810179591,
-0.11149358,
0.4562301934,
-0.279253602,
0.0913158953,
1.0109930038,
1.0254211426,
-0.404727608,
-0.4548828602,
-0.5165085196,
0.3602522016,
-0.4892969429,
0.8899404407,
-0.3845922053,
0.0592013635,
-0.1759011149,
-0.0478772558,
-0.0192845222,
-0.4587139189,
0.3798405826,
-0.8435104489,
-0.0641425848,
-0.4390193224,
-0.5341362357,
-0.0032992419,
0.435455054,
-0.9893420935,
0.8698496819,
0.4186960757,
-1.2686145306,
0.5005460978,
-0.4822101295,
-0.5999837518,
-0.0623447374,
0.1328668147,
-0.2605074048,
0.1698900312,
0.0953990445,
0.4502595067,
0.0235117525,
0.3872930408,
-0.1541639566,
-0.4848860502,
0.3564200401,
-0.2423428595,
0.8910759091,
0.0008598473,
0.2528333664,
0.0699411854,
-0.4167514145,
-0.5827777386,
0.2826899886,
-0.4042173028,
-0.5813117623,
-0.2157829106,
0.0560471788,
0.1836996973,
0.3223021924,
-0.660993576,
0.4463900328,
0.1430384815,
0.203667596,
0.535887897,
0.4897478521,
0.3874325752,
-0.6529644132,
0.2381209433,
0.0706982017,
0.2848763764,
0.1716185063,
-0.0306096692,
-0.0846747458,
-0.1169680879,
0.4962944984,
0.5506188273,
-0.9542388916,
0.2460463196,
-0.4038841128,
-0.5355070233,
-0.6765300632,
0.3664532304,
-0.1450312734,
0.289693594,
0.4427614212,
0.2744031549,
-0.6743320823,
-0.9438779354,
-1.1606786251,
0.0131679717,
0.0062724659,
-0.3502209485,
0.2361756265,
-0.1548576355,
0.9495849609,
-0.1571152508,
-0.2321391404,
-0.1703942567,
0.6016703844,
0.0741845146,
-0.0800273567,
0.548360765,
-1.0869297981,
-0.5486911535,
-0.0850075856,
-0.5388886333,
-0.3802270591,
-0.4754118323,
-0.222770676,
0.0815193057,
0.6319202185,
-0.8332172036,
0.5347164869,
0.4145543873,
-0.2578959763,
0.7010272145,
0.466034919,
0.4513813555,
-0.972481966,
-0.0680749044,
-0.1078246087,
-0.5772265196,
-0.5663197637,
-0.1765921265,
0.4301816523,
0.4165657461,
-0.7682674527,
0.3729746044,
-0.4291326404,
0.1992192715,
-0.3701695502,
0.1629275382,
-0.3693654239,
0.1679265201,
-0.239632979,
0.4203297794,
0.0914614052,
-0.1946909577,
0.5501010418,
0.0579240806,
-0.6046625376,
0.3528740406,
-0.3732379973,
0.1074096188,
-0.181447506,
-0.0030448583,
-0.669481039,
-0.362862587,
0.298257798,
-0.7007204294,
-0.1579320282,
-0.1594190747,
-1.0698722601,
-0.0281177554,
-0.5931996703,
0.1254007071,
0.0842441022,
-0.4480924308,
0.4931384623,
0.4327128232,
0.083421953,
-0.4959880412,
-0.4432523847,
0.2501959205,
-0.1113838404,
-0.4404951334,
0.4706930518,
0.1980888993,
-0.5183491707,
0.3746525943,
-0.1955879033,
0.3643743396,
0.07070674,
0.0990599543,
-0.0074116285,
0.2205855995,
0.3091101646,
0.3406589031,
-0.0144654568,
0.0677833036,
0.6845138073,
0.746737659,
0.2750450671,
-0.1796276569,
-0.6013045311,
0.3342834115,
0.765596509,
-0.1716494411,
0.7220944166,
0.7097324729,
-0.4459513724,
0.1257784665,
-0.5318810344,
-0.1336114556,
-0.3521107137,
0.3576785624,
-0.0790414885,
-0.5271013379,
0.3307602406,
-0.1200625524,
-0.0739391744,
0.3772439659,
0.5541408658,
-0.0121585522,
1.1433092356,
0.4351990819,
-0.429353714,
0.5782501698,
0.061243929,
0.1308785975,
-0.4743455648,
0.1553862691,
0.020749595,
-0.5851469636,
-0.4749748111,
-0.4863581955,
0.446698308,
0.1634254158,
-0.0189697165,
0.4272143841,
-0.0538192838,
0.7317997217,
0.4761918187,
0.1878574342,
0.7004008889,
-0.0493791327,
0.4152859747,
0.220750019,
-0.2184725255,
-0.6052980423,
0.8596752286,
0.182924211,
0.6224400401,
0.1884339601,
0.642977953,
0.6714754701,
0.6787129045,
-0.5685582161,
0.4317723215,
0.0293973498,
-0.3946694732,
0.0072998656,
-0.4535093606,
-0.8104427457,
0.0392977409,
-0.3229631186,
-0.7768390775,
-0.0321988985,
-0.1724413931,
-0.2622092068,
0.5982369781,
-0.5804367065,
0.5435276031,
-0.2289400846,
-0.3384148479,
-0.2432697117,
-0.496478647,
0.5013702512,
-0.1994479448,
0.3391828537,
-0.3312730789,
-0.1513139158,
0.5491963625,
-0.2890709341,
0.7805556059,
0.0294144601,
0.1247333437,
0.0615459718,
0.5537695289,
0.4091261327,
0.0340711921,
0.1431333721,
0.128310129,
0.0358776562,
-0.3422684669,
-0.5820480585,
0.5480196476,
-0.6177226901,
-0.3861818016,
-0.2738981545,
-0.6465111375,
-0.2992295027,
0.1595207453,
0.3636965454,
0.1295817792,
-0.3556802869,
0.2036570609,
-0.1764605492,
0.4155628979,
0.372628212,
0.4413667619,
-0.5003480911,
-0.1430105567,
0.8840051889,
0.2624061406,
-0.0616675317,
0.4044298828,
0.2035952806,
-0.0179188438,
-0.3089992404,
-0.4157749712,
0.3008497953,
-0.2491428554,
-0.5092775822,
-0.6953372955,
-0.2484910935,
-0.1763430834,
-0.1719557196,
-0.4177396595,
-0.4592344165,
-0.2479843795,
-0.4019322097,
0.2591284215,
0.8582953811,
-0.247063458,
0.5238885283,
-0.8095522523,
0.7183679938,
0.1876312792,
0.2227604389,
-0.3763088286,
-0.2146468908,
-0.2766619623,
0.2465662807,
-0.5062251687,
-1.6997474432,
0.3847095072,
-0.3406127095,
0.3182696104,
0.5004887581,
0.1706319451,
0.2667280138,
-0.0588528588,
0.6002905965,
-0.0648293942,
-0.8343301415,
0.6497570276,
-0.7535289526,
-0.0259170011,
0.467738837,
0.5880203247,
-0.7933347225,
-0.6704512835,
-0.8143482804,
-0.5720689297,
0.4597237706,
0.1842189729,
0.2147115022,
-0.1567401886,
0.214258641,
0.2762752473,
0.579457581,
-0.6765188575,
0.0217369683,
0.2119562924,
-0.015704995,
0.21306853,
-0.2616608143,
-0.1012419164,
-0.4511983097,
0.4719575644,
0.2177307308,
0.0483525991,
-0.0531680807,
-0.6100139618,
-0.3781917989,
-0.1290589422,
0.3858830035,
0.844825089,
-0.3933164775,
0.3622325659,
-0.1877335161,
-0.3256153166,
-0.3034861982,
0.0524079129,
-0.3579251766,
0.128004089,
0.630143106,
0.4262016416,
0.0405135266,
-0.492184639,
0.7569161057,
0.0590150543,
-0.2661062777,
-0.0425690487,
-0.0960854068,
-0.0299117155,
0.2048676759,
0.556455791,
0.2321573645,
0.0229400899,
-0.7531030774,
0.203059122,
0.3051170707,
-0.2930226922,
-0.7386946678,
0.4163038731,
-0.0763809979,
-0.4926984608,
0.3247790337,
-0.3680942953,
-0.6839026213,
0.1348579526,
0.141028583,
0.6125327349,
-0.3274646699,
0.5668349266,
0.1606897116,
0.6172317266,
-0.0295098275,
0.2820959687,
0.016263105,
-1.0810633898,
-0.397962153,
-0.2781370878,
-0.1221487895,
0.3862809539,
-0.6496143937,
0.6199021935,
-0.3605519831,
-0.1403998882,
0.3166318834,
-0.1483867168,
-0.434946686,
-0.2514899671,
-0.0580527261,
0.8246721029,
-1.3324331045,
0.6891615987,
0.7959169745,
-0.3977431655,
-0.4448800981,
0.2971036136,
0.2762180865,
-0.5477688313,
0.3316313028,
0.0974181816,
-0.0582352988,
-0.2710417807,
-1.0045588017,
-0.2458678484,
0.7693380713,
0.6045159698,
-0.1924335361,
0.0906063616,
0.2422641814,
0.4618333876,
-0.1242557019,
-0.2546000481,
0.9081027508,
0.713937521,
-0.188068971,
-0.7949765921,
0.0344717987,
-0.3510402143,
-0.3565454781,
0.4203919768,
-0.7601721883,
0.8439310193,
-0.119594492,
-0.2907307446,
-0.2733206153,
0.321159482,
-0.1970432252,
0.4277620018,
0.6992687583,
0.2877958417,
0.5235359669,
-0.1164102554,
1.0042812824,
-0.2321621925,
0.5594220757,
0.9346677065,
0.087804988,
0.8131539226,
0.8069179654,
0.0369748659,
0.2703115344,
0.5509771705,
-0.0920635834,
0.5365421176,
-0.0531551801,
-0.1176072806,
-0.3550917506,
-0.0762115568,
-0.0103778131,
0.6989660263,
0.4293613136,
-0.3836040795,
-0.5269223452,
0.1253261268,
0.3795321286,
0.1912642121,
-0.2672275603,
0.8151524067,
-0.3762981594,
-0.3407119513,
0.166177839,
0.1539049149,
0.4792172611,
-0.1972115487,
-0.0300448313,
0.1020410955,
-0.0903057531,
-0.1109291762,
-0.8060178757,
0.7131336331,
-0.0080707744,
-0.1372347623,
-0.4165237248,
0.9066796303,
-0.4858537614,
-0.6494418979,
0.3461057544,
0.8810752034,
-0.0758889616,
-0.8230580688,
-0.4871050417,
0.3211757839,
-0.0724637881,
-0.3718485832,
0.1280892342,
0.4548747241,
-0.1361674666,
0.2508957386,
0.7043156028,
0.1777755618,
-0.0580284409,
-0.0239525251,
0.9344465733,
-0.7263754606,
-0.3506798446,
-0.9559790492,
0.1762306839,
-0.5048877001,
-0.1939807981,
0.8676893711,
0.8337175846,
0.7017070651,
-0.008582877,
0.8261330724,
-0.0595001429,
1.2353311777,
-0.3164785802,
0.9265277982,
-0.6015544534,
0.2519188523,
-0.3395395279,
-0.6294468045,
-0.3021666408,
0.3370922208,
-0.5468853712,
-0.0955583453,
0.56442976,
0.7144930959,
-0.3357028067,
0.2261350602,
0.213948369,
0.4826402962,
0.035566289,
0.0273785852,
1.1440579891,
-0.3056183457,
0.3903357089,
-0.6317082047,
-0.1460686475,
-0.6331762671,
-0.8611311913,
-1.0211633444,
-0.654014349,
-0.4157964289,
-0.2399282008,
0.1379523724,
0.942258954,
0.4393568635,
-0.4788347185,
0.2290606797,
0.1670240313,
0.5593756437,
-0.6076284051,
-0.2451561093,
0.7126749158,
-0.0039340048,
-0.7414485812,
0.2285727561,
0.0602341108,
-0.1558686793,
-0.0354588144,
0.5798478127,
-0.360845536,
0.0805523023,
0.7836405039,
-0.1328073293,
-0.3025864065,
-0.4569722414,
0.0980665535,
-0.0712892711,
-0.0179537367,
1.1621799469,
-0.515032053,
0.1813106835,
0.5695121288,
0.3586319983,
0.3709464371,
0.7031956315,
0.1584456414,
-1.144849658,
-0.242600292,
0.0370572805,
0.1155637652,
0.4048977196,
-0.4541157186,
0.2825904489,
0.5275477767,
-0.1093074009,
-0.8202167749,
-0.1191368625,
-1.2516680956,
-0.3316812515,
1.316421032,
0.5585429072,
-0.4888499081,
-0.2174284905,
-0.4182656705,
0.1738583446,
-0.4386039078,
1.0734379292,
0.9536811709,
-0.0729374439,
-0.2423270196,
-0.5337960124,
0.2396451384,
-0.179446727,
-0.5579690337,
0.2490665913,
0.3778364062,
0.3957774937,
0.1845113188,
0.4911845028,
-0.2363270819,
0.3462288976,
-0.3050882518,
-0.1673737615,
-0.3162105978,
-0.2434729189,
0.0659342259,
0.3240138292,
-0.5498782992,
-0.3154062927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14224v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14224v1 | mmT5: Modular Multilingual Pre-Training Solves Source Language Hallucinations | 2023-05-23T16:38:01 | 2023-05-23T16:38:01 | Jonas Pfeiffer, Francesco Piccinno, Massimo Nicosia, Xinyi Wang, Machel Reid, Sebastian Ruder | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual sequence-to-sequence models perform poorly with increased
language coverage and fail to consistently generate text in the correct target
language in few-shot settings. To address these challenges, we propose mmT5, a
modular multilingual sequence-to-sequence model. mmT5 utilizes
language-specific modules during pre-training, which disentangle
language-specific information from language-agnostic information. We identify
representation drift during fine-tuning as a key limitation of modular
generative models and develop strategies that enable effective zero-shot
transfer. Our model outperforms mT5 at the same parameter sizes by a large
margin on representative natural language understanding and generation tasks in
40+ languages. Compared to mT5, mmT5 raises the rate of generating text in the
correct language under zero-shot settings from 7% to 99%, thereby greatly
alleviating the source language hallucination problem. | [
-0.4560629427,
-0.418910265,
0.5529482961,
0.0583920106,
-0.4491346776,
0.0956693739,
-0.1563700438,
-0.2106687576,
0.030642774,
0.3035801649,
-0.9977297783,
-0.4023974836,
-0.5328152776,
0.4589469433,
-0.3278501034,
1.0736433268,
0.1387825012,
0.0476789437,
0.2561016083,
-0.0917656869,
-0.5615631342,
-0.7115341425,
-0.1787309796,
-0.3083041012,
0.8324769139,
0.3865100741,
0.3843550086,
0.5180140138,
0.5517453551,
0.2236948609,
0.2387433499,
0.027997002,
-0.3842791617,
-0.0262895189,
0.0778762102,
-0.5203159451,
-0.4980443418,
-0.3447971642,
0.6253009439,
0.4742108583,
-0.2731100321,
0.216371417,
-0.3560826182,
0.4406627715,
-0.5845202804,
0.0359407775,
-0.7833666205,
0.2167337984,
-0.3324787021,
-0.1242144331,
-0.6796312332,
-0.071130082,
-0.0227227956,
-0.3039958477,
0.4074250758,
-0.3636693358,
0.5641511679,
0.2089506537,
-0.3996807039,
-0.0739438459,
-0.651000917,
0.519992888,
-0.7992143035,
0.4572406113,
0.2382083386,
0.4289469123,
0.1579256654,
-0.4814157188,
-0.8837436438,
-0.1083415896,
0.1497157812,
0.1989675462,
0.1325758398,
-0.0436134376,
0.3687888086,
0.177160114,
-0.8539825678,
-0.0698885322,
-0.6257867217,
-0.1832908392,
0.340616554,
0.0011193267,
0.3496111035,
-0.4557298422,
-0.1762299985,
-0.0077913143,
-0.6990403533,
-0.340373069,
0.398126483,
0.4762695134,
0.0990303606,
0.4123466611,
-0.0479629599,
0.6352620721,
0.1486089975,
-0.1019129455,
0.4189105928,
-0.3113932014,
-0.2525096536,
0.2939551473,
0.667175591,
-0.033867579,
0.2065258771,
-0.1364147365,
-0.0914779752,
-0.038017869,
0.4436922371,
-0.8721695542,
-0.3466190696,
0.2118669003,
-0.1295946836,
-0.2524582446,
0.0764171258,
-0.370744586,
0.0476517677,
-0.264387846,
0.5562605262,
-0.7371999025,
-0.5014877915,
0.1990609318,
-0.0824889913,
0.0887338072,
0.1257365048,
-1.271327734,
-0.2252001911,
0.3350749314,
0.9072585106,
-0.2246110588,
-0.5496993065,
-0.3714104891,
0.4077901542,
-0.3412103057,
0.9020907283,
-0.4202282429,
-0.2998261154,
-0.0418395512,
0.0230778251,
-0.1136167869,
-0.4425291121,
0.1424464285,
-0.2730669379,
0.4894606769,
-0.2449631095,
-0.2516800463,
-0.1986062825,
0.3446609676,
-0.5626778007,
0.6497524381,
-0.0163350049,
-0.5388848782,
0.4201865196,
-0.7015795112,
-0.4051294625,
0.0690695196,
-0.1670823693,
-0.3547093868,
0.3696730137,
0.1814231873,
0.5473832488,
0.1544269919,
0.1663619578,
-0.107268028,
-0.3032405972,
-0.0024745932,
-0.5069866776,
0.3582992554,
0.2546823621,
-0.3247573972,
0.2307169288,
-0.7926802039,
-0.12770468,
0.0495549291,
-0.263125211,
-0.1456979662,
-0.1455590278,
-0.0338667557,
0.507504642,
0.0577845983,
-0.3745382428,
0.3380495608,
-0.3336679041,
0.3713892102,
0.6701980829,
-0.230870083,
0.3044625819,
-0.221694082,
0.4640964568,
0.7277644873,
-0.1362369359,
-0.8993985057,
-0.3274053037,
-0.6871047616,
-0.3370921612,
0.2156575173,
0.5306496024,
-1.090509057,
0.2671474516,
-0.4065311551,
-0.2365243137,
-0.6452577114,
-0.1315948069,
0.2856846154,
0.322799772,
0.5324963331,
-0.6189697385,
-0.5264899135,
-0.8307360411,
0.0979952887,
0.1288657933,
0.080213882,
-0.2737765014,
0.4647460878,
-0.4168025255,
0.657155633,
-0.3109465837,
-0.3135561347,
-0.481444329,
0.4949825406,
0.1234452426,
0.4454933703,
0.4314464927,
-0.5022815466,
-0.400215745,
0.1384179443,
-0.7257230878,
0.1538469046,
-0.170578599,
0.1421782225,
0.463123709,
0.2810713053,
-0.8648243546,
0.0105848853,
0.5929128528,
-0.1084950492,
0.6688395739,
-0.3719819784,
0.1862157881,
-1.6452085972,
0.1035798043,
-0.3836706877,
-0.2808114588,
-0.7346272469,
0.0603992343,
0.1967212409,
-0.3125013113,
-0.6056955457,
0.1175599396,
-0.5846862793,
-0.0426742807,
-0.2115399241,
0.0550002679,
-0.2659898996,
0.4620359838,
0.1228197142,
0.774074316,
0.4630629718,
-0.5728170872,
0.1976563632,
0.2105015069,
-0.18334499,
0.5553355217,
-0.0701202899,
0.3447231352,
-0.295997113,
0.2154035717,
-0.5900854468,
-0.3884921372,
0.0489156842,
-0.5699838996,
0.4636655748,
-0.0577375516,
-0.4583162665,
-0.2795056105,
-0.2279922664,
0.5461924076,
0.5697723031,
-0.2099766135,
0.3131887615,
-0.1122203171,
-0.0129080638,
-0.7346062064,
-0.9065114856,
0.1843003631,
-0.210936904,
-0.3992820084,
0.2172478139,
-0.2052493244,
0.2251457125,
-0.2597168386,
-0.1295831203,
-0.2037352771,
-0.1878521889,
-0.2706490457,
-0.0002036342,
-0.511660099,
0.0802909657,
-0.0377119631,
-0.4007105231,
-0.1554861963,
-0.7459091544,
0.7068337798,
0.162477836,
-0.6042175293,
-0.2761137486,
0.4957294166,
0.7060602307,
-0.3292827904,
0.6179783344,
0.9559394717,
-0.2024866194,
-0.2810717523,
-0.4534006417,
-0.3571698666,
-0.4471871853,
0.7053993344,
-0.8111405969,
-0.8406858444,
0.5357382298,
0.1211444736,
0.0510832183,
0.5466670394,
0.8319764733,
0.1278617084,
1.0543638468,
0.7914005518,
0.0679103434,
0.4900819361,
-0.0150614688,
0.4026343524,
-0.5495384932,
-0.104098767,
-0.1764503866,
-0.0958002284,
-0.4247875512,
-0.5932527184,
0.2896355689,
-0.1260570586,
-0.0733717307,
0.5323534608,
-0.3685849607,
0.6263227463,
0.3952840865,
-0.142234385,
0.5076559782,
0.0505849719,
-0.3102360368,
-0.1876173466,
-0.7384629846,
-0.3503913581,
1.0447431803,
0.0060248328,
0.399284333,
0.4376792908,
0.7844563723,
0.156168595,
0.1507472396,
-0.5989591479,
0.3671615422,
-0.3056764007,
-0.7503160834,
-0.2129749954,
-0.4400451779,
-0.6927503943,
0.370000273,
0.1114045531,
-0.5868296027,
-0.0254965294,
0.0867030919,
-0.4539104104,
0.2877166867,
-0.728323698,
0.9197031856,
-0.0093510868,
-0.0676098987,
-0.2324167192,
-0.6996337771,
0.7080721259,
-0.3533389568,
0.1909736991,
-0.2891000509,
0.3019557297,
0.1046284512,
-0.2310391814,
0.6702725887,
0.0377511755,
-0.1434287429,
0.0302432515,
0.1790516227,
0.1914539337,
-0.1129869595,
0.0015401022,
0.153477937,
0.0329389051,
-0.5563052893,
-0.5378496051,
0.457523942,
-0.6453436017,
-0.3980670571,
-0.4286914766,
-0.547583282,
-0.0794683695,
0.2713383138,
0.6280045509,
0.3537257314,
-0.2878668308,
0.0167958066,
0.8388206363,
-0.1758366972,
0.8147955537,
0.6085874438,
-0.4008476138,
-0.3166984022,
1.1266791821,
0.2846205831,
0.4682874978,
0.4854809344,
-0.1651254594,
-0.1030192077,
-0.5941435695,
-0.8324312568,
0.1015050337,
-0.6591066718,
-0.2140606344,
-0.6150981188,
-0.3034908175,
-0.3932272196,
0.0449587516,
-0.5120645165,
-0.3630410731,
-0.171283111,
-0.3378939033,
-0.0238626022,
0.7881352305,
-0.2007205784,
0.3481708169,
-1.0840264559,
0.3455942571,
0.2877708077,
0.1964513808,
-0.1519239098,
-0.632001996,
-0.4521738589,
0.0159599259,
-0.3993584216,
-1.0053943396,
0.4894701242,
0.2934255898,
0.3173135519,
0.4059479237,
-0.1990781128,
0.8591579199,
-0.9073969722,
0.9150127172,
0.4472524226,
-1.0593580008,
0.398580879,
-0.6758421063,
0.7526788712,
0.2955026329,
0.2988089621,
-0.5952213407,
-0.44250983,
-0.5325010419,
-0.7136009336,
0.8420096636,
0.1449805349,
0.3951332867,
-0.1487082392,
0.140514791,
0.3213484883,
0.3594257236,
-1.1256859303,
0.0850154087,
-0.4864391685,
-0.3777216673,
-0.3325056434,
-0.2271028161,
0.1276413202,
-0.2192971855,
0.4197976291,
-0.4213526249,
0.5439949036,
0.1522762775,
-0.4826063216,
-0.1085416749,
0.303499639,
1.1953123808,
0.5939261913,
-0.1324180812,
0.4067600369,
0.3558513522,
-0.6007837057,
0.3176009357,
-0.0531278364,
-0.0553763993,
0.1949790567,
0.3976589143,
0.9741469622,
0.0725646988,
-0.4746388197,
0.3954952359,
0.0968894362,
-0.3330434859,
-0.2135103643,
-0.0168570615,
0.1037798896,
0.0794271752,
0.3892286718,
0.1598328948,
0.0312873572,
-0.6795815825,
0.5044993758,
0.1120815948,
-0.497194767,
-0.8865157366,
0.6331337094,
0.1005159095,
-0.1718408614,
0.5974144936,
-0.1683566868,
-0.3626129329,
0.4065146744,
0.7543355823,
0.9821510911,
-0.6338259578,
0.4061930776,
0.2961425483,
0.4196582139,
-0.2220817208,
0.2108306736,
0.0654653013,
-0.6922852993,
-0.6910995841,
-0.5932076573,
-0.2397448421,
0.0202626418,
-0.4519210458,
0.4969966114,
-0.2049017549,
-0.0203497838,
-0.2318785489,
-0.4385078251,
-0.3309132755,
0.0406353138,
0.5120167732,
0.5933137536,
-0.6697565913,
1.2311319113,
0.5213932991,
-0.7685063481,
-0.6841512918,
0.1598404348,
0.0251132138,
-0.6708928347,
0.4347864687,
0.4290303886,
-0.0965626463,
0.3845708966,
-0.3280558884,
-0.748049736,
1.0960803032,
0.746769011,
-0.4683181942,
-0.0469875187,
0.4405168593,
0.4197123051,
-0.4104044437,
0.2728867531,
0.50459975,
0.3502691686,
0.3820423782,
-0.9536387324,
-0.124013193,
-0.0909844488,
-0.1408747584,
0.2886432707,
-0.5420973897,
1.0207394361,
-0.2868954837,
-0.0504183061,
-0.2224937081,
0.5232925415,
0.159066841,
0.0177729316,
-0.0354244709,
0.6116449237,
0.6500791907,
-0.0531142652,
0.91367805,
-0.2030688226,
0.2443747073,
0.9426756501,
-0.2870401144,
1.0201792717,
0.3462449312,
0.150579825,
0.521330893,
0.677364707,
0.0825592205,
0.7900335789,
-0.0355205871,
-0.4541207254,
-0.0905752927,
0.3063018024,
-0.5303243399,
0.2743743956,
0.0919903517,
-0.1708607078,
-0.2921955585,
0.3340823352,
0.0694765672,
-0.3413253725,
-0.062594153,
0.9783142805,
0.1219481304,
-0.6966570616,
0.6582239866,
0.0321449563,
0.6459838152,
-0.7654942274,
0.1018574387,
-0.4679152071,
0.3049080372,
-0.2053291053,
-0.2456079125,
0.665805459,
-0.0613623187,
-0.3362730742,
-0.411221087,
0.3496359885,
-0.7038899064,
-0.4700564146,
0.0124381958,
0.7178265452,
0.138252452,
-0.3319070935,
-0.4842616022,
-0.2316930741,
0.1033696011,
-0.088942185,
0.4944015145,
0.7744461298,
0.0300974902,
0.3940568566,
0.7186724544,
-0.0876837969,
0.3102198541,
0.1939202845,
0.6216591001,
-0.8727229834,
-0.4858415723,
-1.1645960808,
0.8171156049,
0.2493139505,
-0.2680335045,
0.5482913852,
0.4983884692,
0.8864140511,
-0.4958990216,
0.84004426,
-0.0251171514,
0.1283849776,
-0.6116236448,
0.8772303462,
-0.4631358087,
0.0952657983,
-0.1974318624,
-1.0793412924,
-0.4971776605,
0.5987660289,
-0.0598621741,
-0.0515462197,
1.1325737238,
0.5171406865,
-0.3157717288,
-0.3007080555,
0.7980912924,
0.2964101434,
0.3209276795,
0.5563232303,
0.7829527855,
-0.3078147173,
0.5998875499,
0.1248880029,
0.1981881112,
-0.0776778907,
-0.8060798049,
-1.0018898249,
-0.7153041959,
-0.0861736909,
0.0516346954,
0.1208563074,
0.8937887549,
0.8631018996,
-0.8412973285,
-0.3733120263,
-0.1807453483,
-0.0352347307,
0.0015646593,
-0.132395342,
-0.0075954222,
-0.8500192165,
-0.6344158649,
0.3924819231,
0.5805225968,
0.2666254938,
-0.5555461049,
0.0034784903,
-0.2213012427,
0.0894308165,
0.8306887746,
-0.0749500245,
-0.7789599895,
-0.3179887235,
0.1404707134,
-0.0801093355,
0.3985937536,
0.8410007358,
-0.5873042345,
0.4942397773,
0.3526837826,
0.4399233758,
0.5522211194,
-0.1868431568,
1.0471529961,
-0.9458411932,
0.5190205574,
0.1324191242,
0.0764797702,
0.3487501442,
-0.0758948997,
0.2939765751,
0.5214306116,
-0.2222556919,
-0.7666803002,
0.4756793678,
-0.7366493344,
-0.3524369895,
0.7967550159,
-0.094681032,
-0.0726598948,
-0.1161346883,
-0.2152130604,
0.2512530982,
-0.1740865707,
0.9903728962,
0.9190984964,
0.0862799063,
-0.5267022252,
-0.7571565509,
0.7384538651,
0.4605006874,
-0.7635987401,
-0.1557673067,
0.4876023531,
0.1051045805,
0.2546066642,
0.6352360845,
-0.0196348596,
0.2307763249,
0.0190530885,
0.3989962041,
0.0060468656,
-0.5086116195,
-0.4475115836,
0.2936022282,
0.0989761576,
-0.1055238172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14221v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14221v3 | Question Answering as Programming for Solving Time-Sensitive Questions | 2023-05-23T16:35:16 | 2023-10-20T13:21:53 | Xinyu Zhu, Cheng Yang, Bei Chen, Siheng Li, Jian-Guang Lou, Yujiu Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question answering plays a pivotal role in human daily life because it
involves our acquisition of knowledge about the world. However, due to the
dynamic and ever-changing nature of real-world facts, the answer can be
completely different when the time constraint in the question changes.
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable intelligence in
question answering, while our experiments reveal that the aforementioned
problems still pose a significant challenge to existing LLMs. This can be
attributed to the LLMs' inability to perform rigorous reasoning based on
surface-level text semantics. To overcome this limitation, rather than
requiring LLMs to directly answer the question, we propose a novel approach
where we reframe the $\textbf{Q}$uestion $\textbf{A}$nswering task
$\textbf{a}$s $\textbf{P}$rogramming ($\textbf{QAaP}$). Concretely, by
leveraging modern LLMs' superior capability in understanding both natural
language and programming language, we endeavor to harness LLMs to represent
diversely expressed text as well-structured code and select the best matching
answer from multiple candidates through programming. We evaluate our QAaP
framework on several time-sensitive question answering datasets and achieve
decent improvement, up to $14.5$% over strong baselines. Our codes and data are
available at https://github.com/TianHongZXY/qaap | [
0.0060084905,
-0.8976539373,
0.7635971308,
0.4044014812,
-0.0140367262,
0.4474627674,
0.0514545441,
-0.5573000312,
-0.1815137416,
0.4164462686,
-0.6723009348,
-0.3098064661,
-0.387440294,
0.076331526,
-0.2530729175,
0.6133949161,
-0.2799815834,
-0.1515476555,
-0.3606315851,
-0.2182982713,
-0.2624565065,
-0.4344030023,
-0.4383114278,
-0.3499744534,
0.3509679735,
0.4815875292,
0.5735974312,
0.6667849422,
0.5461484194,
0.2007973194,
-0.065360032,
0.0805118755,
-0.2735773027,
0.3905805051,
-0.137565583,
-0.5820227265,
-0.1885085702,
-0.1578199863,
0.5018877983,
0.8713555336,
-0.2405689061,
0.5161950588,
-0.1479268223,
0.5843515396,
-0.6121653914,
0.2032428384,
-0.703979671,
0.1201400012,
0.1185615659,
-0.4981234074,
-0.2603476048,
-0.4183458984,
-0.0307053365,
-0.5841900706,
0.0400192924,
0.1032431126,
0.7680225968,
0.5163280964,
-0.3643425703,
-0.1960770935,
-0.934594512,
0.8686879873,
-0.7527389526,
0.2370212674,
0.1503956318,
0.3838308454,
-0.1496259421,
-0.6750226021,
-0.5717586279,
-0.1522039324,
0.2938252985,
-0.1314960718,
0.099576436,
-0.1760428399,
0.4706305563,
0.3064373434,
-0.6038587093,
-0.1263920665,
-0.0939818025,
-0.1719100028,
0.4460487366,
0.4168591797,
0.4696941674,
0.0717603713,
-0.3816601336,
0.290422529,
-0.5253108144,
0.2221109569,
0.052254796,
0.1128114983,
0.1874694824,
0.5072439909,
-0.493704766,
0.7260608077,
-0.220785141,
-0.07680583,
-0.0319567285,
-0.1454660743,
-0.0430770591,
-0.5338565707,
0.2425181866,
0.3473403156,
0.4583037496,
-0.0843394995,
-0.0221263431,
0.1212257743,
0.0926366821,
-0.7476081848,
0.0082502086,
0.5921947956,
-0.451759398,
-0.1551701277,
-0.3202121854,
-0.5738394856,
-0.3038588762,
-0.1768719852,
0.3364767432,
-0.2745935023,
-0.1519156694,
0.4213631749,
0.0915355012,
0.557620585,
0.1914729327,
-0.5382423997,
0.1115053222,
0.5660128593,
0.6582567692,
0.0927257687,
-0.1611223966,
-0.6461375356,
0.3297548294,
-0.1545437872,
0.7818613052,
-0.881506145,
-0.3742222488,
-0.0358155146,
-0.3037301302,
0.0175242294,
-0.4742708802,
0.3841394186,
-0.8209990263,
0.2301704586,
-0.2566685677,
-0.3593795598,
0.1905971169,
0.4747035801,
-0.3885278404,
0.9344545603,
0.2371334434,
-0.6301524639,
-0.0715472549,
-0.6122399569,
-0.3475226164,
-0.0431528315,
-0.1066638306,
-0.3430278897,
-0.0105599128,
0.6337139606,
0.254263103,
-0.2388159335,
0.242076844,
-0.2327777147,
-0.4845906496,
0.6525256038,
-0.2838805616,
0.8236748576,
0.3135693073,
-0.0793333501,
0.0329307467,
-0.6860729456,
0.4697766602,
0.2843162417,
-0.6498377323,
0.0045944629,
0.2091331631,
-0.170524478,
0.2234719694,
0.3682233691,
-0.7946769595,
0.4967059493,
-0.374052614,
0.7560201287,
0.6501041651,
0.2297933847,
0.3777828515,
-0.4614783525,
0.9082919359,
-0.3820227385,
0.1621425748,
-0.1397798806,
-0.4084787667,
-0.4561148584,
0.0008042044,
0.1047778875,
0.9794604778,
-1.0830624104,
-0.1585305631,
-0.322458744,
-0.228788957,
-0.4986004531,
0.0795127749,
0.4952452183,
0.5896478295,
0.4788594544,
0.0551771373,
-0.3349457979,
-0.7509937882,
-0.6124398112,
-0.3368913829,
-0.3268571496,
0.4188996851,
0.2458627373,
0.0184681881,
0.9782910347,
-1.0653033257,
0.0660617352,
-0.3454807699,
0.0258356966,
0.2221037894,
0.3107302189,
0.3079702854,
-0.7415339351,
-0.3943105638,
-0.5400950909,
-0.5966151357,
-0.4773373604,
-0.1975290775,
-0.1155388504,
0.1187166125,
0.8223907948,
-0.6047332287,
0.3612776995,
0.4480450451,
-0.2898640335,
0.7442394495,
-0.0538775735,
0.1468382627,
-0.8359495401,
0.1491934955,
-0.328271389,
-0.1814318299,
-0.537086308,
0.3765034974,
-0.0681476891,
-0.5700065494,
-0.5570061803,
0.6580433846,
-0.5158666372,
0.0923710763,
-0.3765766323,
0.0250502359,
0.0733684823,
0.7096391916,
-0.0691579357,
0.7110401988,
0.2512154281,
-0.4595110118,
0.4299584627,
0.3004257381,
-0.408914268,
0.2467240542,
-0.8514847755,
0.4126200974,
-0.3897182047,
0.2767223716,
-0.7900378704,
-0.0010726736,
0.2467559576,
-0.6100623012,
0.1468683332,
-0.1667266041,
-0.2861393094,
-0.3343426287,
-0.2096996754,
0.7426341772,
0.3855621219,
-0.2596684694,
0.764030993,
0.2552193701,
-0.3452583849,
-0.6384902,
-0.6346333027,
0.1162742004,
0.0149965649,
-0.6194192767,
0.4433009624,
-0.2032268941,
-0.3579231501,
0.0785939246,
-0.4852493405,
-0.1756053716,
0.1611411422,
0.0041382825,
0.1879160702,
-0.0496804304,
0.0640982091,
-0.0945759565,
-0.5285361409,
0.0192079917,
-0.4536574483,
0.5626733899,
-0.0954249799,
-0.5086787939,
-0.347057879,
0.7360057831,
0.417375505,
-0.5520186424,
0.6622518301,
0.3923036158,
-0.4651979506,
-0.3371227086,
-0.2822032571,
-0.0290669333,
-0.4755814373,
0.3711436987,
-0.4182844758,
-1.0999326706,
0.4760884941,
0.1584339142,
0.2808952332,
-0.071524173,
0.4316444099,
-0.1954922229,
1.0956469774,
0.6126562953,
-0.0290534459,
0.566614151,
0.0609041378,
0.3765646815,
-0.758943975,
-0.1785342544,
-0.6413899064,
-0.3219602406,
-0.3183282316,
-0.582280159,
0.3769966662,
-0.0167956818,
-0.2548106015,
0.0487534478,
-0.598927021,
0.6031864882,
0.5610363483,
0.0999534503,
0.2989639938,
-0.1807835698,
0.2886633575,
-0.0365217291,
-0.7040261626,
-0.5142348409,
1.0350999832,
0.3207525909,
0.885982573,
0.1426500529,
0.3881314099,
0.1828343123,
0.1047187448,
-0.5048976541,
0.90060395,
0.0156261157,
-0.5562148094,
-0.4438457191,
-0.6570522785,
-0.8815816045,
0.0489947498,
-0.1004820392,
-0.7376998663,
-0.0564889684,
0.1886145771,
-0.5460604429,
0.1771366894,
-0.6841002703,
0.7885139585,
-0.313611716,
-0.284976989,
-0.0926439166,
-0.6922630668,
0.0214550924,
0.420889318,
0.136961475,
-0.5230526328,
-0.2015140355,
0.5698029399,
-0.130446896,
0.7345226407,
-0.3371966481,
-0.1121079922,
0.4198126793,
0.3915234208,
0.33873564,
0.3670695424,
-0.0640706122,
-0.1279854625,
0.3732981384,
-0.8074308038,
-0.849424243,
0.5811844468,
-0.4282672107,
-0.8794091344,
-0.5215874314,
-0.9033669233,
-0.5367916226,
-0.0192918442,
-0.1116295233,
0.5986932516,
0.0734322891,
-0.1486938149,
0.6471481919,
-0.5077082515,
0.3312206268,
0.5956158638,
-0.4127887189,
0.0707623065,
0.8913766742,
-0.1345296502,
0.3448983729,
0.8351061344,
0.113157481,
-0.2693868876,
-0.6744022369,
-0.1539020538,
0.264890939,
-0.6552001238,
-0.1235981807,
-0.6241428852,
-0.223601982,
-0.3134718835,
-0.164334923,
0.0476752222,
-0.7532637119,
-0.0699737519,
0.1039858609,
0.0398912504,
0.1239298508,
0.3740185201,
-0.0111682108,
-0.9105095863,
0.8336731791,
0.6358246207,
0.4706562459,
-0.2664829195,
-0.4462319911,
-0.0104488954,
-0.0233956315,
-0.0740868375,
-0.9227586389,
0.1891187727,
0.2679564953,
0.5248513818,
-0.1118648201,
0.2821979225,
0.4891059101,
-0.500410378,
0.683657527,
-0.4285187125,
-0.9504896402,
0.6849837303,
-0.3062409461,
0.892848134,
0.5955485702,
0.2073861063,
-0.8872849345,
-0.5666740537,
-0.3943921328,
-1.0994843245,
0.456774503,
0.174280867,
0.0872723013,
0.099713102,
0.780251205,
-0.1766530126,
0.2901096046,
-0.6081292033,
-0.0389195383,
-0.0302962493,
-0.2516372502,
0.2007953376,
-0.338264972,
0.0520044677,
0.0134286182,
0.5760087371,
-0.2846091688,
0.4771263003,
0.2853934765,
-0.2795087993,
0.07548289,
0.5853713155,
0.4039496779,
0.8000258803,
-0.2263419032,
0.1064057946,
0.1161924079,
-0.3542919159,
0.103804186,
0.0654402375,
-0.3759430051,
-0.3809337914,
0.5873155594,
0.1847805381,
-0.0065505491,
-1.027765274,
0.2531976998,
-0.0947215855,
0.1144261584,
-0.1998375952,
0.1827934086,
0.183224678,
0.3253195286,
0.5278070569,
-0.3089159727,
-0.0225735046,
-0.6528833508,
0.0450895987,
0.382085681,
-0.1748265028,
-0.0368624814,
0.8204237223,
0.3515289128,
-0.4892787933,
0.814538002,
-0.1350807846,
-0.7704057693,
0.8029516935,
0.585778594,
0.6802366972,
-0.2351252437,
0.1910416335,
0.1662129909,
0.2783106863,
0.2513511181,
0.7250369191,
-0.0410343185,
-0.8527517915,
-0.6930539012,
-0.6572006941,
-0.5334964395,
-0.0426414683,
-0.5404602885,
-0.174862802,
-0.742914319,
-0.001727802,
-0.316681236,
0.0483381487,
-0.2808959484,
0.2015522122,
0.1159655526,
0.9981229305,
-0.6614024043,
0.5193683505,
0.8405120373,
-0.1765393168,
-0.5561055541,
0.3354383707,
-0.2346189022,
-0.8456271887,
0.4289862812,
0.1528377533,
-0.2840110958,
0.1240908653,
-0.8763949871,
-0.7886550426,
0.9271219969,
0.4034118354,
-0.3406332731,
-0.2510195971,
0.2073869258,
0.4659808874,
-0.3162742853,
-0.1082519293,
0.6052942872,
0.2624177039,
-0.04277163,
-0.725536406,
0.169415012,
-0.4186087549,
-0.013699214,
0.3208932579,
-0.5295319557,
0.5387023687,
-0.4621548057,
-0.4380342662,
0.0049170651,
0.7509025335,
0.3874287009,
0.3409048021,
0.4381489158,
0.271553874,
0.5752012134,
-0.1554975212,
0.8872061372,
-0.3607504368,
0.2166813165,
1.0582934618,
-0.3186791837,
0.7660067081,
0.6129943728,
-0.3962861001,
0.5042210221,
0.3219620585,
0.2774622142,
0.250685811,
0.3792926967,
-0.4312461317,
-0.6219726801,
-0.1163290367,
-0.2669430673,
0.304575026,
0.241599381,
0.208728537,
-0.2904960513,
0.042497769,
-0.1104734764,
0.4984101653,
-0.2527483702,
0.3432771266,
0.1408440173,
-0.5709807873,
0.4599889815,
0.2561751604,
0.4262292683,
-0.6069636345,
-0.1003485695,
-0.2085417211,
0.1286334842,
-0.1951739639,
-0.9962764382,
0.5239212513,
0.0328917317,
-0.2447393239,
-0.4696795344,
0.6237655282,
-0.3088894188,
-0.5346081853,
0.0235016793,
0.5718614459,
-0.2247404009,
-0.1315129697,
-0.7967743278,
0.096902363,
0.0362174436,
-0.2918447554,
0.1129075661,
0.2048452944,
-0.1500801146,
1.3742476702,
0.5828911662,
0.0229540542,
-0.0433460437,
0.0649863183,
0.797819376,
-0.7690232396,
-0.6435367465,
-0.570569694,
0.3657718599,
0.1696169376,
-0.278470546,
0.4279875755,
0.4308824241,
0.5660638809,
0.0656887442,
0.7143596411,
-0.1738674343,
0.8391509652,
-0.7179664373,
0.3178710043,
-0.460616678,
0.6430985332,
-0.0671649873,
-0.8448752761,
-0.5038295388,
0.4592850506,
-0.5418844819,
-0.0412898585,
0.5747190714,
0.6967577934,
0.2979865968,
-0.1755803376,
-0.0252548512,
0.1024933085,
0.508936882,
1.2313766479,
0.9781422615,
-0.0765744746,
1.1079832315,
-0.1111188829,
-0.3444332182,
-0.1314558238,
-0.8516831994,
-0.6969719529,
-0.4687417746,
-0.4382396042,
-0.4434000552,
0.0331724919,
0.8397222757,
0.2240389436,
-0.6123076677,
-0.0134168323,
0.170206219,
0.2857978344,
-0.4008958638,
-0.2407568544,
0.3348901272,
-0.23490417,
-0.5865795612,
0.3697595596,
0.2727814317,
-0.1220873669,
-0.0034431515,
0.2179502696,
-0.2407963276,
0.2447039187,
0.500459075,
0.7208099961,
-0.3444219828,
-0.6188046336,
0.36242944,
-0.0552433692,
0.0846661776,
1.0255059004,
-0.7955834866,
0.1693423837,
0.6899127364,
0.8565972447,
0.5051249266,
0.326942414,
0.4926860034,
-0.6623001099,
-0.0809037089,
0.6264253259,
0.1247593313,
0.3139502108,
-0.2556092739,
0.3291342258,
0.189071551,
-0.6913401484,
-0.7437106371,
0.9061374068,
-0.9169889092,
-0.6394474506,
1.1239877939,
-0.0063206847,
-0.3144672811,
-0.5232872367,
-0.2759943008,
0.1141722575,
-0.2256872952,
0.9937953353,
0.6797590852,
-0.4857626259,
-0.2579822242,
-0.5053818822,
0.2624555826,
0.535545826,
-0.8833503127,
0.2155196369,
0.4937707782,
0.4364240468,
0.0943266079,
1.0098592043,
-0.2214995921,
0.3107663691,
-0.1281912923,
-0.0313630514,
-0.3676181734,
-0.3049228489,
-0.2118040472,
0.5063561797,
0.260274142,
-0.2076901346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14215v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14215v2 | Exploring Chain-of-Thought Style Prompting for Text-to-SQL | 2023-05-23T16:32:36 | 2023-10-27T15:21:38 | Chang-You Tai, Ziru Chen, Tianshu Zhang, Xiang Deng, Huan Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning with large language models (LLMs) has recently caught
increasing attention due to its superior few-shot performance on various tasks.
However, its performance on text-to-SQL parsing still has much room for
improvement. In this paper, we hypothesize that a crucial aspect of LLMs to
improve for text-to-SQL parsing is their multi-step reasoning ability. Thus, we
systematically study how to enhance LLMs' reasoning ability through chain of
thought (CoT) style prompting, including the original chain-of-thought
prompting (Wei et al., 2022b) and least-to-most prompting (Zhou et al., 2023).
Our experiments demonstrate that iterative prompting as in Zhou et al. (2023)
may be unnecessary for text-to-SQL parsing, and using detailed reasoning steps
tends to have more error propagation issues. Based on these findings, we
propose a new CoT-style prompting method for text-to-SQL parsing. It brings 5.2
and 6.5 point absolute gains on the Spider development set and the Spider
Realistic set, respectively, compared to the standard prompting method without
reasoning steps; 2.4 and 1.5 point absolute gains, compared to the
least-to-most prompting method. | [
-0.3985154331,
-0.9824208021,
1.0306327343,
0.3507366478,
-0.6170363426,
0.1123347431,
-0.2349797636,
-0.1703572124,
0.0177725833,
0.5306628942,
-0.8481214046,
-0.5775784254,
-0.2800569236,
0.6695490479,
-0.4517426193,
0.8366516829,
-0.1287465245,
0.0761735812,
-0.1772829145,
0.2639539838,
-0.6785305142,
-0.5313459039,
-0.7656699419,
-0.189745754,
0.6938143969,
0.6006305814,
0.4136422873,
0.3664312363,
0.0445159487,
0.183312282,
-0.5099498034,
0.6356846094,
-0.0901666433,
0.4086160958,
-0.5608144999,
-0.4947641194,
-0.5038680434,
-0.2923033834,
0.6056489348,
0.476552844,
-0.0858646259,
0.0287784059,
0.0738639161,
1.136801362,
-0.7154852748,
-0.2528645694,
-0.9651529193,
0.0463691428,
0.0019116342,
-0.5777338743,
-1.0253348351,
-0.1155538484,
0.0185410138,
-0.2955720723,
-0.0550958626,
0.3475809991,
0.4094673693,
0.1723395586,
-0.7094489932,
-0.4860250056,
-0.2975755334,
0.5974533558,
-0.5276060104,
0.3226478994,
0.2047470361,
0.1578938216,
-0.4675729573,
-0.5607614517,
-0.830478549,
-0.112902984,
-0.0390624516,
-0.1404311955,
0.2273409069,
0.0035997711,
0.4217998385,
0.0923705697,
-0.2397797555,
-0.1741987616,
0.1056512073,
0.3058087528,
0.3926542699,
0.1379125863,
-0.1406324059,
-0.2173379958,
-0.8016147614,
-0.1680864394,
-0.9991214275,
0.1118649691,
-0.0068382216,
0.477699846,
-0.0452821814,
0.4691843688,
-0.1962684244,
1.0020904541,
0.1789680421,
-0.0067403824,
-0.2213560641,
-0.467479229,
-0.3749501109,
0.2140488327,
0.6287304759,
0.1771239936,
0.4156771004,
-0.0651509538,
-0.2283824831,
-0.1318648458,
0.2676478624,
-0.4921028912,
-0.1533736587,
0.4519821107,
-0.2561225891,
-0.217257306,
-0.1593120694,
-1.0318725109,
-0.6197911501,
-0.3508185446,
0.3788705766,
-0.5330814719,
0.004454155,
0.1305195987,
-0.1680990458,
0.460789144,
0.6331183314,
-0.7280741334,
0.2436371446,
0.5409431458,
0.7849977016,
-0.2881747782,
-0.2131729871,
-0.5932507515,
0.3159059286,
-0.6943295002,
1.1561157703,
-0.6106106639,
-0.2480614334,
-0.073866576,
-0.1699685156,
-0.196223706,
-0.241125688,
0.2820945382,
-0.4371998012,
0.1396639645,
-0.7801474929,
-0.5315395594,
-0.0469289124,
0.453376025,
-0.3566043973,
0.9716719985,
-0.2105429769,
-0.6418962479,
0.5981103778,
-0.5811181068,
-0.4892288148,
-0.2873179615,
-0.3344122767,
-0.1574592441,
-0.0430169478,
0.7131082416,
0.4476815462,
-0.4353016615,
0.1649346501,
-0.2000849545,
-0.4492277503,
0.3651299775,
-0.3946558833,
0.7300786376,
0.0240793396,
-0.5956707597,
0.2310814857,
-0.7425851226,
0.3455472291,
0.0912424549,
-0.1109231859,
-0.1581001282,
0.1417935789,
-0.5968396068,
0.4701919258,
-0.1425870359,
-0.0970252827,
0.3504644334,
-0.3184456527,
0.2944943607,
1.0488898754,
0.2648332119,
0.323728621,
-0.179140538,
0.4113662243,
0.1508147269,
0.060750071,
-0.4314486682,
-0.4743209779,
-0.8678468466,
-0.1882795244,
0.0004612033,
0.5118953586,
-1.0882525444,
0.4715867341,
0.2211472392,
-0.1925989836,
-0.0863169655,
0.0480245389,
0.5795255303,
0.536440134,
0.6898179054,
0.0243359152,
-0.4769005775,
-0.32310462,
-0.5554531217,
-0.1252508014,
0.2779998183,
0.0921179131,
0.5384489894,
0.1374908686,
0.9389899373,
-0.384778291,
0.0658077523,
-0.4409543872,
-0.181382522,
0.248817578,
0.3565799892,
0.1707202643,
-0.5354029536,
-0.3836330473,
-0.2796883285,
-0.5489552021,
0.1337085068,
-0.2436010242,
-0.4241188169,
0.3734737933,
0.6573534608,
-0.4391122758,
0.4258155823,
0.2719761729,
-0.5970309377,
0.7787549496,
-0.1099645421,
0.2816528082,
-1.3067032099,
-0.2052125335,
0.0076853591,
-0.0884798542,
-0.4719742239,
0.0652399138,
0.1631748229,
0.1289565265,
-0.527073741,
0.4252896607,
-0.6322625279,
-0.0907671377,
-0.1756038964,
0.3871597648,
0.2418722808,
0.4238738418,
0.1327472776,
1.1736476421,
0.6452317238,
-1.0567319393,
0.1223086193,
0.2310226262,
-0.212210387,
0.6284342408,
-0.4024234712,
0.6003555059,
-0.0304209068,
0.8139942884,
-1.1491245031,
0.0575426184,
0.0745951831,
-0.1683971882,
0.1043135375,
-0.1045138985,
-0.74553442,
-0.3263765872,
-0.5113725662,
0.274148345,
0.2002649605,
-1.020026207,
0.5904724002,
-0.1946422607,
0.2064893544,
-0.6147630811,
-0.6227911115,
0.2067095637,
-0.2788743079,
-0.4797022343,
0.4473937154,
0.0238897856,
-0.3728541732,
-0.6181160212,
-0.26113078,
-0.0643795282,
-0.3218494952,
-0.2508772314,
0.5087797046,
-0.0502491966,
0.289655298,
0.3238495588,
0.0307797473,
0.2505841255,
-0.3788746893,
0.6978881359,
-0.130659923,
-0.1532473266,
-0.5322713256,
0.2034973204,
0.1156265438,
-0.159376055,
0.8340677023,
0.0782244951,
-0.0906249061,
-0.4753215015,
-0.4711384177,
-0.3702545464,
-0.5066853166,
-0.2157999575,
-0.5993971229,
-0.7199105024,
0.1942940652,
-0.4688486159,
-0.0645981506,
0.17981565,
0.442068994,
-0.3026558161,
0.970433116,
0.3654700816,
0.4175171256,
0.3678791821,
-0.2118652612,
0.3879266381,
-1.0440443754,
-0.4385238886,
-0.7385496497,
-0.0021966717,
-0.3769694269,
-0.6594900489,
0.3812363446,
0.2451484352,
-0.4059399962,
0.3238326907,
-0.6737377048,
0.7740742564,
0.0249698795,
0.4037761092,
0.4623996317,
0.181956768,
-0.5648272634,
0.3060810566,
-0.7070819736,
-0.5005938411,
0.6465901732,
0.0547651052,
0.8848128915,
0.0644434467,
0.8168333769,
0.0392882973,
-0.2400054634,
-0.8499014378,
0.8384236693,
0.0180361103,
-0.3439205289,
-0.3453051448,
-0.2997980714,
-0.6761935353,
0.2960076928,
-0.1317015886,
-1.0187494755,
0.3529964089,
0.4730226099,
-0.2730024457,
0.3917643428,
-0.6630008221,
0.4118397236,
-0.1041540056,
-0.529497087,
-0.2354187369,
-0.6897107363,
0.2658326924,
0.2121248692,
0.2649161816,
0.181319505,
-0.3011285663,
0.5196208358,
-0.5910481811,
0.8198011518,
0.048279807,
-0.371673435,
0.4763007164,
0.3953991532,
1.0632361174,
-0.0326412767,
-0.2754848003,
-0.3656839132,
-0.2375715226,
-0.2750462294,
-0.6755643487,
0.5095114112,
-0.0332614481,
-0.7629169822,
-0.4491823316,
-0.443883568,
-0.6911227703,
0.0100391954,
0.3118686378,
0.4427152574,
0.4540697336,
0.0380002409,
0.9859524369,
-0.0590018407,
0.5914201736,
0.053166274,
-0.2715501487,
-0.488188833,
0.4733815491,
-0.287992388,
0.614051044,
0.4760738909,
0.3548942506,
-0.695348084,
-0.2405867875,
-0.8019121289,
0.2301470935,
-0.9733248353,
-0.1734815687,
-0.6712411642,
0.0899583846,
-0.2676362395,
-0.389187187,
-0.141789481,
-0.372289896,
-0.1729363352,
-0.0293648206,
0.7728251219,
0.8208069205,
0.8191561699,
0.2328765392,
-0.4810582995,
0.0107989088,
0.1241777241,
0.3544162512,
0.3816865087,
-0.4069197476,
0.0553249717,
-0.2133539021,
-0.3019944727,
-1.0904269218,
-0.1101794243,
-0.1434713751,
0.1201938614,
0.1837621331,
0.2125061303,
1.2025238276,
-0.5919391513,
1.0113538504,
0.3164586425,
-1.2184813023,
0.8694422245,
-0.1446658373,
0.2888858318,
0.6414582133,
0.3887216747,
-0.2799535394,
-0.2625173032,
-0.4832690358,
-0.7878219485,
0.5983203053,
0.1236181036,
-0.110837929,
-0.3111700118,
0.3458119929,
0.0125517976,
0.2321048677,
-0.7281605005,
-0.1279651821,
0.067971848,
0.2678887844,
0.3477588594,
-0.0607501194,
0.1352017075,
-0.5354533792,
0.5253421068,
-0.5203790069,
0.3010103405,
0.4510095119,
0.0765496865,
-0.0533389524,
0.6299450397,
0.4912266433,
0.9594029188,
0.2086359411,
0.3574613035,
0.7413704991,
-0.0006531019,
0.1580025405,
-0.5880331993,
0.1361149102,
-0.1328601241,
0.2420070022,
0.7639951706,
0.0368606038,
-0.5205867887,
0.3814052939,
0.0724212825,
-0.1037334725,
-0.111413911,
0.2555098534,
0.021380173,
0.1085495874,
0.2806638181,
-0.0472305268,
0.1363426447,
-0.7446838617,
-0.051932238,
0.3322556913,
-0.3378610909,
0.2280370146,
0.3205770254,
0.0271727666,
-0.3466770649,
0.3503736556,
-0.2130610347,
-0.6145223975,
0.3700023293,
0.9632349014,
0.7986394763,
-0.0845318064,
0.1157039255,
0.4001637101,
0.1097226813,
-0.2736493945,
0.6407274604,
-0.461163789,
-0.3412831426,
-0.5986588597,
-0.4800551832,
-0.6094844937,
-0.2001020759,
-0.4173954427,
0.7427674532,
-0.6512095332,
0.0041070068,
-0.2502168119,
-0.3292201459,
-0.2560693026,
0.3957505226,
-0.1863964051,
1.3458822966,
-0.3813936114,
0.9351328611,
0.6054327488,
-0.1692840755,
-1.1420471668,
0.5547665358,
0.1303751469,
-0.5778710842,
0.1876681,
0.2272813767,
-0.6074057221,
0.0204962902,
-0.6622105837,
-0.6347183585,
1.0137250423,
0.1995249838,
-0.7093974948,
-0.361985445,
-0.1818326414,
0.4122179747,
-0.6565067172,
0.24064897,
0.6236556172,
0.3261039853,
0.5016048551,
-0.6100980639,
0.4694527686,
0.0912424102,
0.2815458179,
0.3787947595,
-0.5841724873,
0.9482281804,
-0.4852742255,
-0.0236547478,
-0.0825296268,
0.4910646081,
0.8612107635,
0.341756165,
0.7965649962,
0.0761094317,
0.8972521424,
0.1137224138,
1.1458975077,
-0.0709112138,
0.0748048052,
1.221824646,
-0.4597990215,
1.1449127197,
0.8179975152,
-0.2436614186,
1.2024724483,
0.5938336253,
0.3852426112,
0.2582879066,
0.1266466677,
-0.2480035424,
-0.3352423906,
0.0767213851,
-0.2414017767,
0.1473930925,
0.4640791416,
-0.4578008652,
-0.1282561123,
-0.2217034101,
0.2577596009,
0.2850055397,
-0.2907195687,
0.913788259,
0.3130676746,
-0.9446941018,
0.87830621,
-0.3880203664,
0.572316587,
-0.4173035622,
-0.2672929466,
0.0444077402,
-0.0411401168,
-0.3218263388,
-1.1027189493,
0.1173946038,
0.3252235353,
-0.0978246406,
-0.2244968712,
0.6156161427,
-0.2816154361,
-0.2189452946,
0.4845873117,
0.2925686538,
0.1701209396,
-0.1168181822,
-0.6396438479,
0.036965359,
0.0073703541,
-0.1873439401,
0.2165967524,
0.6874668598,
-0.3242777288,
0.6772381663,
0.6757820249,
0.0105261561,
-0.1757477522,
0.4175837636,
0.9921781421,
-0.92759341,
-0.5528363585,
-1.2258827686,
0.5430447459,
-0.2941704094,
-0.304333657,
0.6163163781,
0.3639611304,
0.6250508428,
0.0495849699,
0.3401627839,
-0.0817784071,
0.2941063941,
-0.9597993493,
0.3149355352,
-0.5779668093,
0.5328623652,
-0.6426687241,
-0.8991512656,
0.0254622661,
0.4936387241,
-0.2220709175,
0.2343448102,
1.5077139139,
0.8376674652,
0.4296287,
0.4120519459,
0.1215573922,
0.1267303526,
0.2683030367,
0.5202481151,
0.8074376583,
-0.1234337986,
0.4628544152,
-0.2014393359,
-0.2395242155,
-0.0024048816,
-1.1368625164,
-1.0913574696,
-0.5938727856,
-0.0689105988,
-0.8425039649,
0.1988996863,
1.3944517374,
0.4663935304,
-0.7210291028,
-0.3581912816,
-0.6421590447,
0.2607600093,
-0.4675050676,
-0.1349456906,
0.285494864,
-0.7655685544,
-0.3535419703,
0.6522194147,
0.3754884303,
-0.0919086561,
-0.0259104557,
-0.0071578459,
-0.61023283,
0.3163355589,
0.9334204197,
-0.2919279933,
-0.9135122895,
-0.106212981,
-0.0523888581,
-0.0401913524,
0.1561964601,
1.0379961729,
-0.9975742102,
0.3871071637,
0.4772262275,
0.2654937506,
0.4114359915,
0.0272153001,
0.5938022137,
-0.8617243171,
-0.0212204959,
0.1663173288,
0.3129586875,
0.2218540013,
-0.6635336876,
0.475802809,
0.1671947837,
-0.4254225194,
-0.7230286598,
0.2280569971,
-0.9594420195,
-0.3913715482,
1.2291595936,
0.0882264972,
-0.5663477182,
-0.1080329418,
-0.6107088923,
0.1338534504,
-0.4990333319,
0.6714740992,
0.6564633846,
-0.5367717743,
-0.3020358384,
0.0309115779,
0.7014787793,
0.5384286642,
-1.1040091515,
0.3554157019,
0.1694049537,
-0.0223203301,
-0.0084938239,
0.6330192089,
-0.1637423784,
0.4822752476,
-0.0592439324,
-0.418130815,
0.2815541327,
-0.8112204075,
-0.2444538176,
-0.154611215,
0.1167811602,
0.253542304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14214v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14214v2 | CompoundPiece: Evaluating and Improving Decompounding Performance of Language Models | 2023-05-23T16:32:27 | 2023-10-23T11:17:53 | Benjamin Minixhofer, Jonas Pfeiffer, Ivan Vulić | cs.CL | cs.CL | While many languages possess processes of joining two or more words to create
compound words, previous studies have been typically limited only to languages
with excessively productive compound formation (e.g., German, Dutch) and there
is no public dataset containing compound and non-compound words across a large
number of languages. In this work, we systematically study decompounding, the
task of splitting compound words into their constituents, at a wide scale. We
first address the data gap by introducing a dataset of 255k compound and
non-compound words across 56 diverse languages obtained from Wiktionary. We
then use this dataset to evaluate an array of Large Language Models (LLMs) on
the decompounding task. We find that LLMs perform poorly, especially on words
which are tokenized unfavorably by subword tokenization. We thus introduce a
novel methodology to train dedicated models for decompounding. The proposed
two-stage procedure relies on a fully self-supervised objective in the first
stage, while the second, supervised learning stage optionally fine-tunes the
model on the annotated Wiktionary data. Our self-supervised models outperform
the prior best unsupervised decompounding models by 13.9% accuracy on average.
Our fine-tuned models outperform all prior (language-specific) decompounding
tools. Furthermore, we use our models to leverage decompounding during the
creation of a subword tokenizer, which we refer to as CompoundPiece.
CompoundPiece tokenizes compound words more favorably on average, leading to
improved performance on decompounding over an otherwise equivalent model using
SentencePiece tokenization. | [
-0.4644751549,
-0.7581933141,
0.0840691775,
0.3630144298,
-0.6133227348,
0.2412456572,
-0.4566064179,
-0.392442584,
-0.0383511223,
0.5703421831,
-0.713245213,
-0.5459253192,
-0.3558944762,
0.2355072498,
-0.5719614029,
0.9912577271,
0.1599604338,
0.2926879823,
-0.2397426963,
-0.0292252917,
-0.6342297196,
-0.2775420845,
-0.496614933,
-0.5818710327,
0.4410611391,
0.2297712266,
0.2584460974,
0.8596996069,
0.344679147,
0.382183969,
-0.2925644219,
0.2970448136,
-0.7009536028,
-0.0105627012,
-0.3449453712,
-0.4852808118,
-0.0876553059,
0.1387446076,
0.2776880562,
1.1025469303,
-0.1953407973,
-0.0471225195,
-0.0255230181,
0.327070415,
-0.4814296365,
0.2580336034,
-0.6510818601,
0.1125661656,
-0.4416892529,
-0.1179976389,
-0.4821382761,
0.021925997,
0.0640808642,
-0.7634939551,
0.2954275906,
0.0583053045,
0.3473783731,
0.0251127277,
-0.1389537752,
-0.5615817904,
-0.7329352498,
0.9498255253,
-0.7419359684,
0.4208596945,
0.2204280645,
-0.1321953386,
-0.2025896758,
-0.8882299662,
-0.5963956118,
-0.0895609036,
-0.0887237638,
0.2259966135,
-0.0873268023,
0.2551346719,
-0.1179530472,
0.920547843,
-0.582881391,
0.1078980789,
-0.5903165936,
-0.2894836068,
0.5523782372,
0.1920882314,
0.6939824224,
-0.3484682441,
-0.5724489093,
-0.1770640165,
-0.6218105555,
-0.1434088647,
0.4654573202,
0.6583403945,
0.0431106314,
0.6430737972,
-0.0942244008,
0.3923482299,
0.0399868004,
-0.4806410074,
0.216558069,
-0.5534284711,
-0.0118689826,
0.2516269088,
0.4107731283,
0.2573237121,
0.0314341597,
-0.5732529759,
-0.3787596524,
0.4059154093,
0.055420436,
-0.7529238462,
-0.8379562497,
0.3231955171,
-0.3624140322,
-0.2316482961,
-0.0790085196,
-0.3277490735,
-0.2116561532,
-0.6291848421,
0.7313529253,
-0.5550223589,
-0.3916290402,
0.3086180687,
-0.3578624427,
-0.1287723184,
0.0050515379,
-0.9384685159,
0.5669033527,
1.1151531935,
0.8498478532,
-0.588340342,
-0.3995316923,
-0.6064687967,
0.180940643,
-0.478504777,
1.0708922148,
-0.3570681214,
-0.8462900519,
-0.035431128,
0.1055322737,
-0.1038552374,
-1.0627492666,
0.7487624288,
-0.2859352529,
0.3817417622,
-0.3033472896,
-0.8953090906,
-0.1832291037,
0.0665358305,
-0.7117341161,
0.7507154942,
0.0619860217,
-0.6512612104,
0.5916987658,
-0.6991698742,
-0.63715446,
0.1295247674,
0.1024485677,
-0.2706848681,
0.3725554645,
0.3371547163,
0.0944340527,
0.0154476911,
0.0133739179,
-0.1647861749,
-0.4960252643,
0.1149881259,
-0.2837007642,
0.5043724179,
0.1252179444,
-0.1124277934,
0.1364848465,
-0.5668759942,
-0.2446294427,
-0.1866324991,
-0.6262761354,
-0.4078811109,
-0.0132117579,
0.4324721396,
0.0348196477,
0.1507512927,
-0.8122422099,
0.0462305918,
-1.0306515694,
0.439368397,
0.7492725849,
0.1446087062,
0.4353120625,
-0.27238065,
0.4022148252,
0.2619077861,
-0.1535277814,
-0.3507690132,
-0.1102085114,
-0.9310292602,
-0.6654759049,
0.6385262609,
0.34379071,
-0.4478014708,
0.2289874554,
-0.2650672793,
-0.3792154193,
-0.4527516961,
0.3223188221,
0.5205975771,
0.4336642027,
0.4115488231,
-0.5029191971,
-0.5525391698,
-0.8771224022,
-0.3970397115,
-0.0052926159,
-0.1751831323,
-0.0280127786,
0.3105808198,
-0.1971155405,
0.7450085282,
-0.5652192235,
-0.4597394764,
-0.2535891235,
0.6290161014,
0.2310712337,
0.5366091132,
0.1653164476,
-0.5536950827,
-0.2348675132,
-0.045426961,
-0.3395879269,
-0.1809554696,
0.1062875986,
-0.1639868915,
0.2249322534,
0.453271836,
-0.7091096044,
0.1938510239,
0.4941665232,
-0.0737894252,
0.4860678911,
-0.1086490974,
-0.3025554121,
-1.0559556484,
0.1153360382,
-0.3513078392,
-0.0484994985,
-0.658123076,
0.0697235093,
-0.3578782082,
-0.0532035828,
-0.4331819713,
0.333248347,
-0.6291351914,
-0.1217040569,
-0.6765018106,
0.2789391875,
-0.073059693,
0.4101443887,
0.1361554563,
0.8597861528,
0.2385303974,
-0.5310697556,
0.3600212038,
0.3841386139,
-0.5546075702,
0.4985381365,
-0.718822062,
0.0367172286,
-0.0270592533,
0.1844432354,
-1.1844354868,
-0.3450273275,
-0.0519212633,
-0.1094113886,
0.4873137176,
-0.1935091615,
-0.5671659112,
-0.1247650161,
-0.2080594003,
0.5463857651,
0.1129580215,
-0.5970904231,
0.4977016151,
0.6671187282,
-0.4166863263,
-0.1904599518,
-0.8708834052,
0.0595816895,
-0.4080601037,
-0.6979822516,
0.7407111526,
-0.1065019816,
-0.1416042894,
-0.0620427653,
-0.4391393065,
-0.020924475,
-0.1369811893,
0.153083086,
-0.0147251673,
0.0944906026,
0.3913573921,
0.1331668049,
-0.3651231527,
0.0981536433,
-0.2681613564,
0.8653088808,
0.1837485135,
-0.2239740342,
-0.2685347199,
0.3869765699,
0.4286234677,
-0.5023785233,
0.5088171363,
0.8057756424,
-0.3548789024,
-0.4398442209,
-0.4698014855,
-0.176581189,
-0.492484659,
0.2861846387,
-0.4357589781,
-0.8059321642,
0.5952126384,
-0.2210152149,
0.0557990856,
0.2589630187,
0.6852258444,
0.0621713996,
0.8648161292,
0.4177276492,
-0.0653066784,
0.2660341263,
-0.4348466694,
0.2955220044,
-0.8114728332,
-0.2984277606,
-0.2066385001,
-0.1876272559,
-0.6519950628,
-0.4787155092,
0.4419366717,
0.1313841343,
0.2952742577,
0.3014116585,
-0.384549886,
0.4796330035,
0.5317163467,
0.0754395798,
0.4801199138,
0.2486717701,
-0.2276993692,
-0.0182050746,
-0.5291420221,
-0.2100998163,
0.9656898379,
0.2417176962,
0.5728809834,
0.0270813592,
0.9211933613,
0.2112086862,
0.0311825722,
-0.9360032082,
0.3428618908,
-0.4293113649,
-0.7804096937,
-0.2883398533,
-0.4062225819,
-1.0118377209,
0.4224825501,
0.1068145931,
-0.4572737515,
0.0972595289,
-0.1508453488,
-0.2562536895,
-0.0002402099,
-0.4860590994,
0.8357315063,
0.1353426129,
-0.1696670353,
-0.4916522205,
-0.3416697979,
0.5871428847,
-0.2688494921,
0.4675935209,
-0.2105071992,
-0.0365580171,
0.8668978214,
-0.7385185957,
0.5968323946,
-0.1398625523,
-0.4356926084,
0.2454174906,
0.2962544262,
0.2783992887,
-0.0831907392,
0.1664405018,
0.0487939827,
0.281894803,
-0.3472949564,
-0.5004633665,
0.8435384035,
-0.6415100098,
-0.3403757811,
-0.0897352248,
-0.6057169437,
-0.2812486291,
0.190411672,
0.3009864688,
0.7840203047,
-0.0781843588,
0.3031326234,
0.5395675898,
-0.0454874896,
0.5893157721,
0.3336660862,
-0.2167423069,
-0.6531881094,
1.1800295115,
0.3313807547,
0.0657175928,
0.4818567932,
0.3362154067,
-0.6909862757,
-0.733715713,
-0.152331993,
0.2247285992,
-0.6211461425,
-0.0386299044,
-0.4776979089,
0.0553302728,
-0.2258093655,
0.2109699845,
-0.5712378025,
-0.5753864646,
-0.1417008936,
-0.2031952739,
0.1395347416,
0.7058067322,
-0.4274341166,
0.1647911668,
-0.761038363,
0.3637142479,
0.5460654497,
0.2520891726,
-0.1955212504,
-0.5984798074,
-0.2353405058,
-0.1199024618,
-0.0430475771,
-0.6076737642,
0.3290240467,
0.3127373457,
0.5612211227,
0.3967436552,
0.2081731558,
0.9687618017,
-0.4926553369,
0.8772146702,
0.006371628,
-1.216011405,
0.3456633091,
-0.730053544,
0.2454352081,
0.6401552558,
-0.0609168671,
-0.6494579911,
-0.1189621836,
-0.2548127472,
-1.1519210339,
0.7205674052,
0.2703305781,
0.3041521609,
-0.2338633686,
0.0157270264,
0.2350228429,
0.3034846485,
-0.6155062914,
-0.0912653357,
-0.0343375802,
-0.1599338204,
-0.2058038116,
-0.3149359524,
-0.2317682952,
-0.2618684471,
0.6673491001,
0.1023519114,
0.0753960386,
0.0095108915,
-0.2967014611,
-0.1104663312,
0.0681718513,
0.6799569726,
0.5970474482,
0.0245035756,
0.1738655567,
0.2351686656,
-0.4593613148,
0.1091300994,
0.0236207861,
0.1460416615,
0.1347525269,
0.7323025465,
0.4921752214,
0.6567788124,
-0.8129758239,
0.5216947794,
0.11656674,
-0.0349614508,
-0.3747453094,
-0.0386668853,
0.2956354916,
0.0566477552,
0.3517615795,
-0.1729287207,
0.4619594514,
-0.7205610275,
0.4242613912,
0.2277231067,
-0.1141926423,
-0.3851955831,
0.4065100849,
0.2156054974,
-0.1019520015,
0.6419372559,
-0.0985436514,
-0.4773414135,
0.0486160219,
0.48237288,
0.8018614054,
-0.2522569001,
0.0522153527,
0.206064865,
0.1564588845,
-0.0443769991,
0.1804838777,
-0.2955299914,
-0.4574159384,
-0.7794616818,
-0.8281418085,
-0.1603140235,
0.2729069889,
-0.6952273846,
-0.0843872353,
-0.3065059781,
-0.0106911212,
-0.0758029744,
0.2076040506,
-0.2801298499,
0.2751834095,
0.1389715374,
0.7550849319,
-0.9373623133,
0.411817342,
0.4765602052,
-0.3689745069,
-0.7546336055,
-0.0155357821,
-0.1030737162,
-0.4245663881,
0.6502711773,
0.3360904157,
-0.1952427775,
-0.0566391535,
-0.1979345679,
-0.818838954,
0.8289280534,
0.256600827,
-0.34686777,
0.0163244512,
0.5367728472,
0.4801906943,
-0.1610230953,
-0.1041569188,
0.7127258182,
0.4612058103,
0.1764593273,
-0.9733796716,
-0.2039255351,
-0.2372066677,
0.1929529756,
0.2104864568,
-0.5255413651,
1.0006505251,
0.5094893575,
-0.5966588259,
0.3863710761,
0.6595987082,
0.2268912792,
0.2116262019,
0.6588614583,
0.9556442499,
0.5669867396,
-0.2945109904,
0.6756691933,
-0.5126681924,
0.3544327319,
1.0797617435,
0.0178039763,
1.0295345783,
0.5474852324,
-0.2660740912,
0.4963978529,
0.5737227798,
0.1072270945,
0.7274183631,
0.4080342948,
-0.4781774879,
-0.5912542939,
-0.2145356089,
-0.1518648416,
1.059186697,
0.3268501759,
-0.233171165,
-0.3207052648,
0.2057264894,
0.0326043665,
0.1314994395,
-0.2807815075,
0.952021718,
0.0522989184,
-0.7223058939,
0.4265186787,
0.2611454427,
0.5676653385,
-0.2709030509,
0.0906050801,
-0.4605678022,
0.3477236032,
-0.1964687407,
-0.3175515831,
0.3819574118,
-0.2904604375,
-0.130999878,
0.1690416783,
0.5494424701,
-0.6666448116,
-0.6357795596,
0.1912377179,
0.29956761,
0.1671353579,
-0.0875902995,
-0.3499136865,
0.4007964134,
-0.1996219903,
-0.0832843855,
0.1154544801,
0.2513458729,
0.3321718872,
0.4848793149,
0.9340372086,
0.0115449326,
0.1626543105,
0.1224114001,
0.907805562,
-0.3686558306,
-0.5116292238,
-0.6518380642,
0.7174375057,
-0.0297661517,
-0.1891007572,
1.0563570261,
0.9434936643,
1.2273237705,
-0.2095065266,
0.5577847362,
0.4122251868,
0.8674756289,
-0.6604084373,
0.5002132058,
-0.4956535697,
0.2407350391,
-0.4514323771,
-0.8901872635,
-0.1733694524,
0.542124331,
-0.3316558301,
0.0608347133,
0.3643173277,
0.9076148272,
-0.2511814833,
0.0373128839,
0.3015716672,
0.066013746,
0.2811700106,
0.0982364118,
0.9054017663,
-0.4192169309,
0.5274071097,
-0.6082117558,
0.1249145716,
-0.2142750472,
-0.5461226106,
-0.9753184915,
-0.4889343977,
-0.3338365555,
0.1434783489,
-0.1514546573,
0.7726140618,
0.9229134321,
-0.9351096153,
-0.4286354184,
-0.4490655363,
-0.2985056937,
-0.0968819112,
-0.2729579806,
0.400698483,
-0.5483335257,
-0.9549162388,
0.8743416071,
0.3187393248,
-0.1567546874,
-0.6146802306,
0.1318764836,
0.1122375354,
0.2897056043,
0.7892452478,
0.0009913312,
-0.8232220411,
-0.0810989588,
-0.1733105779,
0.3105353117,
-0.0693198442,
0.8684981465,
-0.4804604948,
0.7032318711,
0.667609036,
0.2962746024,
0.6945174336,
0.3035904467,
0.5912469029,
-0.8840184808,
0.1260617524,
0.1029318497,
0.2772414982,
0.4985426962,
0.081869483,
0.3453454673,
0.4123426676,
-0.3856719434,
-1.1015231609,
0.354527384,
-0.7869276404,
-0.5772951841,
0.8133117557,
-0.1364264339,
-0.2731166482,
-0.0422633104,
-0.3540333509,
0.4532375038,
-0.0976694077,
0.8181446791,
0.5968618393,
-0.0049360008,
-0.1244750544,
0.0342919864,
0.4334678352,
0.4023237526,
-0.4809319079,
0.1589335799,
0.5244718194,
0.5028841496,
0.4397766888,
0.0496541485,
-0.3265518248,
0.1650669128,
0.291837275,
-0.0395465419,
-0.1380452961,
-0.3568447232,
-0.4070180357,
0.337408334,
0.0705354065,
-0.2706340849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14211v1 | Towards Graph-hop Retrieval and Reasoning in Complex Question Answering over Textual Database | 2023-05-23T16:28:42 | 2023-05-23T16:28:42 | Minjun Zhu, Yixuan Weng, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | In Textual question answering (TQA) systems, complex questions often require
retrieving multiple textual fact chains with multiple reasoning steps. While
existing benchmarks are limited to single-chain or single-hop retrieval
scenarios. In this paper, we propose to conduct Graph-Hop -- a novel
multi-chains and multi-hops retrieval and reasoning paradigm in complex
question answering. We construct a new benchmark called ReasonGraphQA, which
provides explicit and fine-grained evidence graphs for complex questions to
support interpretable reasoning, comprehensive and detailed reasoning. And
ReasonGraphQA also shows an advantage in reasoning diversity and scale.
Moreover, We propose a strong graph-hop baseline called Bidirectional Graph
Retrieval (BGR) method for generating an explanation graph of textual evidence
in knowledge reasoning and question answering. We have thoroughly evaluated
existing evidence retrieval and reasoning models on the ReasonGraphQA.
Experiments highlight Graph-Hop is a promising direction for answering complex
questions, but it still has certain limitations. We have further studied
mitigation strategies to meet these challenges and discuss future directions. | [
-0.3710250854,
-1.3368846178,
0.8089544773,
-0.0703263953,
-0.1273983121,
0.5335301161,
0.2515072227,
-0.5295708179,
-0.0336645395,
0.3342752159,
-0.4907822311,
-0.4794103801,
-0.4310459197,
0.1972118765,
-0.0828839317,
0.63359797,
-0.2582412064,
0.0067732534,
-0.2208063453,
-0.0757516026,
-0.5487444401,
-0.6828838587,
-0.527079165,
-0.3570711315,
0.7500278354,
0.5152644515,
0.573687315,
0.2656744719,
0.4511156976,
0.2056301832,
-0.246573329,
0.6445574164,
-0.4258489013,
0.4135017395,
-0.0835298672,
-0.4513307214,
-0.4701678753,
-0.2920258343,
0.4190058112,
0.9560762644,
0.2286977321,
0.2033793628,
-0.285190165,
0.7169336677,
-0.7497699261,
0.0672216639,
-0.5769367814,
-0.2297376096,
-0.2283406854,
-0.3597285748,
-0.6261889935,
-0.6471589208,
0.080041118,
-0.6031079888,
-0.1385666132,
0.3917684853,
0.7863122225,
-0.0940226912,
-0.9416969419,
-0.3256700635,
-0.5551234484,
0.3102268279,
-0.3904922307,
0.4149611294,
0.1236505657,
0.6431663036,
-0.219242394,
-1.1011712551,
-0.5106406808,
0.2104501873,
-0.2022934109,
0.1278142333,
-0.1484702677,
0.0900096372,
0.37560004,
0.0776148811,
-0.7140120268,
-0.5676543117,
0.0190491509,
-0.3694406152,
0.4462699294,
0.2110164613,
0.3578105867,
-0.2630173862,
-0.3757975399,
0.0185922757,
-0.6142926812,
0.3697006106,
0.1781263649,
0.3989949822,
0.489330411,
0.6118982434,
-0.5391258001,
0.891266346,
-0.1661913246,
0.0733054727,
0.2418010086,
-0.4699819386,
-0.060405165,
0.2133215815,
0.5844579339,
0.1317388415,
0.2162513733,
-0.360414058,
0.1806769967,
-0.2837139666,
0.0529681109,
-0.8208306432,
-0.0552961305,
0.436035037,
-0.4307036996,
0.1336088479,
0.0090054777,
-0.8470469713,
-0.0418937542,
-0.1972723603,
0.554130435,
-0.6685375571,
-0.2444735914,
0.3820606768,
-0.51208812,
0.2925157845,
0.7005308867,
-0.2746882141,
0.3693700433,
0.7742093801,
0.7485943437,
0.1189869046,
-0.3761367202,
-0.7599925399,
0.3717164397,
-0.2384293675,
0.9745128155,
-0.5539445281,
0.0196710639,
-0.0651242957,
0.0205976181,
-0.1292043775,
-0.3474662304,
0.8986267447,
-0.9564874768,
0.0584744997,
-0.6779760718,
-0.5383806825,
-0.504355371,
0.7578077912,
-0.4852227271,
0.8842507601,
-0.1282062978,
-1.1209826469,
0.06318257,
-0.2985539138,
-0.6439293623,
0.1633110195,
0.0598146655,
-0.2274752259,
-0.5704569817,
0.1843618155,
0.1335379481,
-0.4942000508,
0.4158494174,
-0.4597762525,
-0.404605478,
0.0024305969,
-0.246828407,
0.9678177834,
0.2425661981,
-0.2027765512,
-0.0493644625,
-0.6466599703,
0.4812124074,
0.1065803468,
-0.3990022838,
-0.6125186682,
0.0925523341,
-0.253526926,
0.1543302387,
0.1359030604,
-0.6725683808,
0.3983919322,
0.0298594516,
0.3759594858,
0.3211390376,
0.3327419162,
-0.1014019847,
-0.3292642236,
0.3577554524,
0.0305653438,
0.032310091,
-0.2184218019,
-0.6104985476,
-0.262948066,
-0.2216867507,
0.2433492541,
0.5444574952,
-0.9377044439,
0.0708866268,
-0.2802131772,
-0.416448921,
-0.3270252347,
-0.4021711349,
0.4424487054,
0.8287013769,
0.7622588873,
0.078165397,
-0.4614294767,
-0.6864977479,
-0.582801044,
-0.3172357678,
-0.0149504272,
0.4217825234,
0.5193923712,
-0.1278388351,
0.9845988154,
-0.7778360844,
0.2963027954,
-0.1665882468,
0.2667728662,
0.1507938355,
0.2319714129,
0.3484237492,
-0.9854858518,
-0.2464833111,
-0.0807251781,
-0.8010456562,
0.0651162043,
0.0134349531,
-0.6980245709,
-0.4578741789,
0.4309097826,
-0.9292322397,
0.0280057769,
0.0970714688,
-0.6270009279,
0.7398421168,
0.2490761131,
0.3344250321,
-0.7969361544,
0.1826615781,
-0.3289199471,
-0.4746424258,
-0.6153775454,
0.2041675895,
-0.0177622754,
0.0551217683,
0.0767130181,
0.2609148622,
-0.3579834104,
-0.0240138453,
0.2772163749,
0.4306384325,
0.4838375747,
0.4504917264,
-0.2224874496,
0.5618584752,
0.3546772003,
-0.4443659484,
0.3542850614,
0.4702186584,
0.1250794381,
0.5231616497,
-0.7744549513,
0.2235505432,
-0.4503278434,
0.4100952744,
-1.3246141672,
0.0325548984,
0.1975595206,
-0.4701568484,
0.3299585581,
-0.3774679005,
-0.4480459988,
-0.5674104095,
-0.1683789939,
0.4313048124,
-0.0260413401,
-0.474742204,
0.7850404382,
0.182914272,
-0.0232167989,
-0.7432916164,
-0.2190887332,
0.1744619906,
0.1108516157,
-0.7645308375,
0.0606402941,
-0.156232059,
-0.2205857188,
0.0641219318,
-0.3032188416,
-0.0564610921,
0.1155980527,
-0.1162564009,
0.0888871029,
-0.313418895,
0.3475757837,
0.3622401953,
-0.0575620309,
0.1631744057,
-0.4665282071,
0.4715020955,
-0.3725994229,
-0.4072347283,
-0.0309506766,
0.4112158418,
0.5697354078,
-0.4694853127,
0.3349352777,
0.3980234861,
-0.2692238986,
0.0156488828,
-0.3151604831,
-0.0931165889,
-0.3473623097,
0.1493736804,
-0.7655245066,
-0.8718298674,
0.3712430596,
-0.8169442415,
-0.1016076654,
0.376730293,
0.4392817914,
-0.3135333955,
0.8800113201,
-0.2528079152,
0.3514170945,
-0.1575981528,
-0.2774502337,
0.2580826581,
-0.6846715212,
-0.4811641574,
-0.8865012527,
-0.0982168466,
-0.3516034782,
-0.4450175762,
0.3868383765,
0.5182122588,
-0.7940421104,
-0.0367776267,
-0.3771120906,
0.2170286179,
0.5857169032,
0.2239183784,
0.7833071351,
-0.273344636,
-0.3213582635,
0.2787916362,
-0.6888961792,
-0.4906270206,
0.710985899,
0.0720182955,
0.6128125787,
0.397194922,
0.3329805136,
0.1248840019,
-0.0090503478,
-0.690479517,
0.4535634816,
0.1967789382,
-0.8252564073,
-0.5217126608,
-0.7308802009,
-0.8515853882,
0.4945768118,
-0.2193444371,
-0.5891488194,
0.1228225157,
-0.048667267,
0.0717368796,
0.3448734283,
-0.6802126169,
1.0120069981,
-0.1712117791,
-0.2618914545,
0.211314261,
-1.0389316082,
0.346834898,
0.2607749999,
0.185517475,
0.046630688,
0.4005323648,
0.4837637246,
-0.4994141757,
0.4920108914,
-0.3302537203,
0.2365582585,
0.6645875573,
0.3724671304,
0.6878278255,
0.0714489669,
-0.1399213225,
-0.0601673052,
0.3050327301,
-0.6110877991,
-0.5542173982,
0.2961999178,
-0.7623462081,
-0.5444536805,
-0.2743334174,
-0.4304972589,
-0.6852548718,
0.6392305493,
-0.0270636529,
0.6762167215,
0.0320698507,
0.2928203046,
0.6835082769,
0.1503102183,
0.1311079711,
0.2203508019,
-0.1285173893,
-0.2350181043,
0.5673192143,
0.1373626739,
0.277479142,
0.7947507501,
0.2802429199,
-0.4083087146,
-0.6179648042,
-0.713168323,
0.2156620175,
-0.640000701,
-0.4396595359,
-1.1121094227,
-0.1742642224,
-0.1069995388,
0.1727360487,
-0.0940753892,
-0.5480138659,
0.2403874099,
-0.2885912061,
0.3357136846,
0.2966909111,
0.4916642904,
-0.1287065446,
-0.8649544716,
0.5565530062,
0.7044950128,
0.453636378,
0.2277092934,
-0.0996132866,
0.0526821911,
0.0941488817,
-0.2519382238,
-1.0450060368,
-0.2553803325,
0.0062732357,
0.502835989,
0.0320476256,
0.3876079619,
0.6779289842,
-0.5762547255,
0.4123554528,
0.0047045471,
-0.9487730265,
0.5592124462,
-0.5280790925,
0.0840587839,
0.6352912784,
0.6558694243,
-0.5090802908,
-0.2612621784,
-0.3265262544,
-0.7415187359,
0.4837783575,
0.3556156158,
-0.3259256184,
0.0889895707,
0.6224092841,
0.0056954282,
0.2937010825,
-0.3992371857,
-0.3080176115,
-0.4649681747,
-0.0808720291,
0.3836731017,
-0.2101780772,
-0.383418113,
-0.1256935447,
0.4282222688,
-0.4382475615,
0.1157908142,
0.5261397362,
-0.0770100877,
-0.1154247448,
0.4586439431,
-0.0557322763,
0.8736793399,
-0.4383744895,
0.4798183143,
-0.1078548506,
-0.450992316,
0.1904450506,
0.1851316988,
-0.4305882752,
-0.0265579373,
0.6867823005,
0.4786375165,
-0.2432330698,
-0.7035319805,
0.5664480925,
-0.2037793249,
-0.2195805013,
0.2091365457,
-0.2056137621,
0.4011694789,
0.3828730881,
0.637904346,
-0.0487720668,
0.5265568495,
-0.7432981133,
0.2832809985,
0.4115171134,
-0.3940115869,
-0.064162448,
0.7508510947,
-0.0555402488,
-0.2032145858,
0.660844326,
-0.3603022099,
-0.5705770254,
0.685849309,
0.6322674155,
0.3898303509,
0.1128386483,
0.4235961735,
0.5863617659,
0.2149009854,
0.1145911142,
0.6291878819,
0.0393220708,
-0.8146967292,
-0.359957248,
-0.265399605,
-0.6033181548,
-0.5388337374,
-0.6031316519,
-0.0073506082,
-0.2778764367,
-0.0013737057,
0.1768135428,
0.0935541689,
-0.1834447533,
0.2475191951,
-0.1859704405,
0.8776215911,
-0.5766830444,
0.5439729095,
0.6203581095,
-0.531314671,
-1.0825146437,
0.0721590668,
-0.0684282854,
-0.4766029418,
0.5402696729,
0.0041825329,
-0.52366817,
0.0548662581,
-0.5823861361,
-0.620967865,
1.2206680775,
0.1872674972,
-0.3989226818,
-0.0384993963,
-0.1971712112,
0.5218414068,
-0.1362111717,
0.4709227979,
0.5024880171,
0.5812200904,
0.666554749,
-0.3620166481,
0.4439198971,
-0.2426277101,
-0.2970441878,
0.328946054,
-0.7713387012,
0.9221132398,
-0.2459231913,
-0.155558154,
-0.3288977444,
0.2775646448,
0.5238787532,
0.7611711025,
0.510271132,
0.3782314658,
1.0468121767,
-0.2443119884,
0.8312277794,
-0.198294282,
0.5204693675,
1.1803977489,
-0.301348716,
0.6720960736,
0.3033426106,
-0.3505568206,
0.9329542518,
0.8180873394,
0.4914630055,
0.1760122627,
0.1599605829,
0.0236608386,
-0.6204406619,
-0.2023416758,
-0.4193962812,
0.3263176978,
0.233564809,
0.3266485333,
-0.3193946779,
-0.4599344134,
0.2098613381,
-0.0351998284,
-0.2586140037,
0.5458548069,
-0.1542215794,
-0.5904344916,
0.5852969885,
-0.1951560378,
-0.1271015257,
-0.5465189219,
-0.2815033197,
-0.2170511484,
-0.299964577,
-0.2454571575,
-0.9718496203,
-0.0017638658,
-0.2246644646,
-0.0757276788,
0.1073987558,
0.8058283329,
-0.3380413651,
-0.1962454021,
0.4710683227,
0.9074540138,
-0.1283377707,
-0.1906532794,
-0.6470772028,
-0.4149233699,
-0.2732798457,
-0.3179604709,
-0.077327922,
1.2174699306,
-0.2384708375,
0.787623167,
0.7171615958,
-0.1728685796,
0.0388382524,
0.3768939972,
1.0987093449,
-0.7146512866,
-0.4139012992,
-0.5601834059,
0.2396267951,
-0.214691788,
0.0878743827,
0.7427558899,
0.7538466454,
0.4152984917,
0.3572924733,
0.6576915383,
-0.2118065953,
0.6429998875,
-0.4314590394,
0.1009115353,
-0.5838298202,
-0.013262135,
-0.62898314,
-0.6246733665,
-0.3186332881,
0.024870757,
-0.1310352385,
-0.0279211849,
0.9689688087,
0.3265253305,
-0.036059007,
0.2787722349,
-0.0173593014,
0.5528604984,
0.518964529,
0.5896047354,
0.8615326881,
-0.5548756123,
0.8849841952,
0.2950025499,
-0.1553459466,
-0.1761174649,
-0.5804448128,
-0.5742179155,
-0.4182713628,
-0.0255553685,
-0.650013864,
0.1027008891,
0.5849421024,
0.4820504785,
-0.6839134097,
0.0460116491,
-0.0638108477,
0.7130752802,
-0.4588070214,
-0.1928283423,
0.6694821715,
-0.3821642995,
-0.3538761139,
-0.0247013494,
0.559365809,
-0.2392697483,
0.1968543828,
0.0740419179,
-0.893640697,
-0.0642734319,
0.8656436205,
0.2314703763,
-0.2573112547,
-0.5274990797,
0.1789045632,
-0.0409977287,
0.3584612012,
1.1236203909,
-0.5282318592,
0.7395577431,
0.840252161,
0.8926675916,
0.8560560346,
0.5494769812,
0.2188239992,
-0.4361112714,
-0.1866463125,
0.4181483388,
0.2534531057,
0.032429792,
-0.3486040831,
0.6030195951,
0.4171741009,
-0.5183510184,
-0.5136361718,
0.415995568,
-1.2401431799,
-0.64817518,
0.9451033473,
-0.286434561,
-0.0963344648,
-0.8322973847,
-0.3590651453,
0.25803864,
-0.1688326895,
0.3994820118,
0.6238391399,
-0.4425850511,
-0.0893674642,
-0.3751736879,
0.1982315183,
0.0045907167,
-1.1020604372,
0.2610570192,
0.689556241,
0.1428084522,
0.1789567769,
0.8974855542,
-0.0742423087,
0.2988325059,
0.1545406282,
-0.2043305486,
-0.0498038046,
-0.5223249793,
0.3023283482,
0.6272731423,
0.1965324432,
0.0051792683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14210v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14210v2 | Skill-Based Few-Shot Selection for In-Context Learning | 2023-05-23T16:28:29 | 2023-10-10T16:23:33 | Shengnan An, Bo Zhou, Zeqi Lin, Qiang Fu, Bei Chen, Nanning Zheng, Weizhu Chen, Jian-Guang Lou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning is the paradigm that adapts large language models to
downstream tasks by providing a few examples. Few-shot selection -- selecting
appropriate examples for each test instance separately -- is important for
in-context learning. In this paper, we propose Skill-KNN, a skill-based
few-shot selection method for in-context learning. The key advantages of
Skill-KNN include: (1) it addresses the problem that existing methods based on
pre-trained embeddings can be easily biased by surface natural language
features that are not important for the target task; (2) it does not require
training or fine-tuning of any models, making it suitable for frequently
expanding or changing example banks. The key insight is to optimize the inputs
fed into the embedding model, rather than tuning the model itself. Technically,
Skill-KNN generates the skill-based descriptions for each test case and
candidate example by utilizing a pre-processing few-shot prompting, thus
eliminating unimportant surface features. Experimental results across five
cross-domain semantic parsing datasets and six backbone models show that
Skill-KNN significantly outperforms existing methods. | [
-0.5400537848,
-0.8278967738,
0.572016716,
0.0811127275,
-0.5102340579,
-0.240430519,
-0.2302694023,
-0.3189778924,
-0.0911005065,
0.3954235911,
-0.5772233605,
-0.5713806152,
-0.5618882179,
0.2023750097,
-0.0558379032,
0.897335887,
0.2223114669,
0.0598502755,
-0.4917838275,
-0.1178646013,
-0.5759356618,
-0.1917177439,
-0.6104261279,
-0.4681738019,
0.4769530594,
0.8982270956,
0.120345071,
0.6860316992,
0.4602793455,
0.2073744237,
0.0112339091,
-0.0078183208,
-0.5343478322,
0.0158472247,
0.1422231197,
-0.5268563032,
-0.1930897981,
0.1029203087,
0.52388376,
0.7491902709,
0.3527365327,
0.1163015589,
0.2614306808,
0.4273967147,
-0.8625656366,
0.1676892042,
-0.8198927641,
0.0393564776,
-0.381334126,
0.1179706231,
-0.3487319052,
-0.0497155376,
0.2979933918,
-0.769898653,
0.3142341375,
-0.3219947219,
0.5334477425,
0.189641431,
-0.363964349,
-0.0463076942,
-0.3178383112,
1.0134749413,
-0.7108179331,
0.4020269513,
0.8725435138,
0.6181607246,
-0.1444530934,
-0.4126399457,
-0.4125191271,
-0.2091068029,
-0.0621008463,
0.4232715666,
0.5087720752,
-0.0259623732,
0.2500264645,
-0.3476109803,
-0.4366763234,
0.2713627219,
-0.0828754231,
-0.0843338147,
0.482327342,
-0.0387614295,
-0.130710274,
-0.24358055,
-0.2789796591,
-0.3292417526,
-0.7826696634,
0.2500195503,
0.2748448253,
0.7727794051,
-0.1348181069,
0.4636250436,
-0.5838999748,
1.0235139132,
-0.0742585286,
-0.6441504359,
0.0320000984,
-0.1723104417,
-0.0655879453,
0.1842322797,
0.3822250962,
0.0707238764,
0.1024437398,
-0.108869575,
-0.1032115817,
-0.0508848056,
0.2943291068,
-0.7346793413,
-0.2274780869,
0.0012872521,
-0.4472013712,
-0.5374329686,
0.0383817479,
-0.6535274982,
-0.0541891716,
-0.0586008318,
0.4470146596,
-0.5137652755,
0.0645552352,
-0.4060996175,
-0.3852740824,
0.252094388,
0.1715391874,
-0.7431997061,
0.2673363686,
0.7032190561,
0.7492906451,
-0.2536008954,
-0.5077508092,
-0.9627030492,
0.0486817099,
-0.2257577479,
0.9971249104,
-0.9060208201,
-0.4144408703,
0.0058245994,
-0.2968839109,
0.1877259165,
-0.4159857333,
0.2721745372,
-0.5493773222,
-0.1107984185,
-0.4081330299,
-0.6784369946,
-0.0967941135,
0.4218842685,
-0.4173862338,
1.0959866047,
0.3830077648,
-0.4891600907,
1.0788229704,
-0.6907281876,
-0.5629961491,
0.2278544456,
-0.1902260184,
-0.5385136604,
-0.0329051763,
0.2844582498,
0.6617854238,
0.2172582299,
-0.3863394856,
-0.5534945726,
-0.406116128,
0.1090913117,
-0.1441320181,
0.3852670789,
-0.0989135578,
-0.2193878144,
-0.0545252599,
-0.8102372289,
0.1731645614,
0.001268112,
-0.2836800814,
-0.5117619038,
-0.2455050498,
0.0031473169,
0.5607602596,
-0.1878356338,
-0.7128418088,
0.0580598786,
-0.8116900325,
0.0657319948,
0.4918328822,
0.0970137045,
0.8100695014,
-0.3422154188,
0.5695841312,
0.1380612701,
0.0784486458,
-0.185843274,
-0.5192203522,
-0.4474046826,
-0.4977416396,
0.3877730072,
0.4761164188,
-0.7927274704,
0.3501124084,
-0.120390825,
-0.3099835217,
-0.5084967017,
0.6039529443,
0.6023834944,
0.74233073,
0.3904143572,
-0.2500666976,
-0.2619780302,
-0.7882214785,
-0.2599572837,
0.1805698425,
0.0802208036,
0.5412306786,
0.4986953735,
0.1940032095,
1.3104592562,
-0.3789489269,
-0.6570224166,
-0.5090530515,
0.0516918041,
-0.0667416826,
0.2815146446,
0.4800394773,
-0.6731622219,
-0.7588593364,
0.0650230199,
-0.5611847639,
-0.0961754322,
-0.1895478517,
-0.1797449142,
0.162266016,
0.4316582978,
-0.3706114292,
0.5582945347,
0.2240481228,
0.035964787,
0.2065959126,
0.0046535847,
-0.2151322067,
-0.9422991872,
-0.1060258299,
-0.0091961809,
-0.5080261827,
-0.3515030444,
-0.0759111792,
0.1791488379,
-0.0274524987,
-0.774230361,
1.0010250807,
-0.0843863189,
-0.2056339383,
-0.5567436218,
0.3413287103,
-0.0056717922,
0.4736123681,
0.1813588291,
0.3877177835,
0.5937232375,
-0.8303036094,
0.0527326576,
0.5561699867,
-0.3363801241,
0.6526811123,
-0.2168917209,
0.3765613735,
-0.0390778296,
0.1806965619,
-0.727825284,
-0.2701076269,
-0.0035162391,
-0.1913828254,
0.2466703355,
-0.7325860858,
-0.2138257772,
-0.197926566,
-0.2377579659,
0.2650492489,
0.3743346035,
-0.6287249923,
0.3997804224,
0.0953599215,
-0.092843093,
-0.5992065668,
-0.6090781689,
-0.340369612,
-0.1531683207,
-0.2878891826,
0.3726857007,
0.1714641005,
0.1548836827,
-0.028585216,
-0.2037068009,
-0.153936103,
0.2598254681,
0.2842392325,
0.1191979498,
-0.1270523816,
0.0873105973,
0.221796304,
-0.3444872499,
-0.4543213844,
-0.26474756,
0.2697898746,
0.1576325893,
-0.3587380052,
-0.2522884011,
0.4326275587,
0.1020495817,
-0.1635152251,
0.630859673,
0.5755082369,
-0.1376101375,
-0.6614345312,
-0.4799764156,
-0.5639483333,
-0.4078161716,
0.49007532,
-0.6106731296,
-1.0164103508,
0.3720201552,
-0.291588515,
-0.1647898406,
0.1212711334,
0.2827010155,
-0.5298012495,
0.8399770856,
0.6996642947,
-0.0325687043,
0.5972914696,
-0.3589256406,
0.1877322048,
-0.7021189332,
0.00791944,
-0.211733222,
-0.5063940287,
-0.3317695558,
-0.0699542761,
0.6615744233,
0.1766384393,
-0.2130502015,
0.2249940485,
-0.1864970475,
0.8304651976,
0.7501223087,
0.3504444957,
-0.0490046851,
-0.2043622136,
-0.4716155529,
0.0846796259,
-0.9429712892,
-0.292596817,
1.2405866385,
0.0689922422,
0.4810834825,
-0.158100903,
0.9672611952,
-0.1217362657,
0.2365880907,
-1.1034190655,
0.4920135438,
-0.4042823911,
-0.4681048393,
-0.5694260001,
-0.2298313528,
-0.7738292217,
0.1266129464,
-0.3807033598,
-0.4447461367,
-0.0816257,
0.2244924456,
-0.6416421533,
0.0236655474,
-0.6167445183,
1.1057173014,
-0.1023094952,
-0.1934337318,
-0.1616272032,
-0.7125200033,
0.1964814067,
-0.1770270914,
-0.1281283349,
-0.0161979496,
0.078251183,
0.4533065856,
-0.4293328226,
1.1594992876,
-0.4633838534,
0.4170137346,
0.3149248064,
0.3004927635,
0.5621507764,
0.060041029,
-0.0110160746,
0.0160001926,
0.0190315917,
-0.4384025335,
-0.7345881462,
0.5715039968,
-0.5294798613,
-0.2053005695,
-0.1565599591,
-0.3741932213,
-0.5026596189,
0.2507299185,
0.5143652558,
0.5120841265,
-0.4231438041,
0.3632245958,
0.4319462776,
-0.0117033282,
0.6150135994,
0.2088255882,
0.0522912629,
-0.223167032,
0.760864079,
0.1463086605,
0.299551338,
0.3324383795,
0.4665359259,
-0.1767717004,
-0.4564536214,
-0.3070649505,
-0.0199054871,
-0.9391095638,
-0.5568578839,
-0.5695214272,
-0.0677148104,
-0.2201020718,
-0.5292246938,
-0.5028284788,
-0.2380342931,
-0.0624761656,
-0.0380650535,
0.472843647,
0.4693330526,
0.2135656774,
0.7308108807,
-0.7625312805,
0.5459249616,
0.6384360194,
0.5315445065,
-0.1482974589,
-0.4553028047,
-0.3808856905,
-0.0499127321,
-0.2444007248,
-0.5565087795,
0.1782368422,
0.5357174277,
0.6788764596,
0.4650577903,
-0.1421988457,
0.551594913,
-0.5064834356,
0.6055016518,
-0.0661551356,
-0.7438372374,
0.8358356357,
-0.1777625978,
0.7025215626,
1.0291882753,
0.4011079967,
-0.3802144229,
-0.3152770698,
-0.485714972,
-0.468267411,
0.9521529675,
0.0112884911,
0.1633400172,
-0.1608133316,
0.3507506251,
0.5152717233,
-0.137991339,
-0.4674865901,
-0.0249778759,
-0.3815811574,
-0.1946556717,
0.1494636089,
-0.110696353,
-0.0554366373,
-0.3049951196,
0.5995414257,
-0.6182989478,
0.0058408664,
0.0993970335,
-0.557062149,
-0.0272107329,
0.1194292232,
0.4609554112,
0.4685575664,
-0.1164419279,
-0.1016809642,
0.5362039208,
-0.5082117319,
-0.0039254464,
-0.1964900792,
-0.262860328,
-0.140947327,
0.4672324955,
0.766214788,
0.6473255754,
-0.4118477106,
0.8180910945,
0.4040555656,
-0.2239976525,
-0.1525743902,
0.1869940609,
-0.3605779111,
0.2484172881,
0.2152691931,
0.1173480973,
-0.0139090633,
-0.4163195491,
0.4017834961,
0.507170558,
-0.3661306202,
-0.1492338628,
0.1155216172,
0.1521552652,
-0.1438143551,
0.5855595469,
-0.5795647502,
-0.4638712406,
0.5051051974,
0.731759429,
0.8641638756,
0.0032609233,
0.3823589385,
0.3452766836,
-0.0103031304,
-0.1776838899,
0.2867880762,
-0.1683014184,
-1.0289356709,
-0.5082751513,
-0.5343664885,
-0.3330403566,
0.1135088354,
-0.3917244673,
0.5292802453,
-0.5379807353,
-0.245748654,
-0.1647505611,
-0.0846120492,
-1.1536535025,
0.137698099,
0.2002273202,
0.8049665093,
-0.9158638716,
1.028984189,
0.6405795217,
-0.4349213839,
-0.5148138404,
-0.0059369551,
0.1878862828,
-0.4249307513,
0.9470931888,
0.0304125249,
0.0428428315,
0.0879791602,
-0.5790963173,
-0.720410049,
0.9614464641,
0.2703430653,
-0.1882402003,
0.2171232104,
0.1348345429,
0.1821897328,
-0.7268289328,
0.1936304718,
0.468575269,
0.3625363111,
0.0648877323,
-0.8832325935,
-0.2927891612,
0.178991735,
0.1883666813,
0.0641971454,
-0.4938658774,
0.2976907194,
0.0339904055,
0.258154273,
-0.1775947958,
0.5571998358,
0.389654547,
0.296551466,
0.5914691091,
0.5740162134,
0.4469071329,
0.2722500563,
1.0970528126,
0.166960597,
-0.0207935255,
1.2617800236,
-0.4950512648,
1.0762345791,
0.4471645355,
-0.0873412043,
0.3963417411,
0.3757373691,
0.0732779726,
0.9527887106,
-0.0916325226,
-0.2463276237,
-0.4900584519,
0.0905155614,
0.1732390821,
1.1158638,
0.174928695,
-0.0071771378,
-0.5522934794,
0.5062804222,
-0.2875702679,
0.0100829871,
-0.1795286983,
1.1480727196,
0.267565906,
-0.467194587,
0.1423108876,
-0.1340043843,
0.7981409431,
-0.8769510984,
-0.3914100528,
-0.1044839397,
-0.0304600988,
-0.1532540172,
-0.5498180985,
0.1483908594,
0.0109198857,
-0.1578336805,
-0.2170708776,
1.0763545036,
-0.3484928608,
-0.5341559052,
0.2495923638,
0.6147801876,
0.1123885214,
-0.2637509704,
-0.6063328385,
-0.2389046401,
-0.4614369571,
0.0307257548,
0.6835201383,
0.4189449251,
-0.2142557502,
0.5161068439,
0.6295948029,
0.1214245036,
-0.0644339845,
0.2781911194,
0.6936423182,
-0.5485334396,
-0.7265543342,
-0.6505865455,
0.5396382809,
-0.0814640597,
-0.4832606316,
0.5136852264,
0.4905797839,
1.1789543629,
-0.1452380568,
0.8621848822,
0.2144089937,
0.4696272612,
-0.6045134068,
0.8149856329,
-0.2761220932,
-0.0929043964,
-0.3462414742,
-1.0607841015,
-0.3920553327,
0.872568965,
-0.4725270569,
0.3113749921,
0.7109982967,
0.776034236,
-0.3722324073,
-0.1535742581,
0.711989522,
-0.2098925859,
-0.0325151049,
0.3522151709,
0.4790816903,
-0.3619244695,
0.3519441485,
-0.8386958241,
-0.1182367206,
-0.4633305371,
-1.1322643757,
-1.081559062,
-0.6541178823,
-0.3482432663,
-0.0201165024,
-0.1922464669,
1.1040565968,
1.0866856575,
-0.8447121978,
-0.0236604922,
0.1398359686,
0.1567801684,
-0.4874401093,
-0.1676272154,
0.2139646858,
-0.7145524621,
-0.3627406657,
0.8770056367,
0.3164674342,
-0.1531411409,
0.1979687661,
-0.0000631987,
-0.3214409053,
-0.3661208153,
0.8314564228,
0.1773201823,
-0.5720237494,
-0.5007784367,
0.0487798862,
-0.0465685092,
-0.007066966,
0.7950052619,
-1.1439836025,
0.6277552247,
0.4087365568,
0.9686796069,
0.6919634938,
-0.1429433823,
0.437502861,
-1.3478477001,
0.4608675539,
0.3478750587,
0.1160498112,
0.2474408746,
-0.4024302065,
0.2754355073,
0.1942780465,
-0.1477688402,
-0.5803166032,
0.0974284634,
-0.8941326737,
-0.2816447616,
1.0419807434,
-0.0711446404,
-0.15932253,
-0.2747069895,
-0.0068771862,
0.2669397295,
-0.2029793262,
0.617770195,
0.812689662,
-0.1569706947,
-0.3159244955,
-0.6779900193,
0.7457589507,
0.3882036507,
-0.6434534192,
-0.3128531575,
0.1953972876,
0.238216415,
-0.2323037982,
0.3634979129,
-0.0127912434,
0.5697360635,
-0.0895245448,
-0.0976716504,
-0.2457390875,
-0.5782052279,
-0.4185835421,
0.0705293268,
0.2292566597,
-0.1535633504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14208v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14208v2 | Domain Private Transformers for Multi-Domain Dialog Systems | 2023-05-23T16:27:12 | 2023-12-07T19:46:09 | Anmol Kabra, Ethan R. Elenberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large, general purpose language models have demonstrated impressive
performance across many different conversational domains. While multi-domain
language models achieve low overall perplexity, their outputs are not
guaranteed to stay within the domain of a given input prompt. This paper
proposes domain privacy as a novel way to quantify how likely a conditional
language model will leak across domains. We also develop policy functions based
on token-level domain classification, and propose an efficient fine-tuning
method to improve the trained model's domain privacy. Experiments on membership
inference attacks show that our proposed method has comparable resiliency to
methods adapted from recent literature on differentially private language
models. | [
-0.2960918844,
-0.7631578445,
0.5444976091,
-0.0304940064,
0.2976542413,
0.2650464177,
-0.1949021816,
-0.4258944392,
-0.4829492271,
0.7779074311,
-0.6622827649,
-0.5204183459,
-0.7937071323,
-0.0320088267,
-0.3053413033,
0.9203975797,
0.2339498103,
-0.1724682152,
-0.0638074204,
-0.1741839796,
-0.4881609678,
-1.0472122431,
-0.4322205186,
-0.0648827851,
0.3280153871,
0.0769719109,
0.8692682981,
0.0453375764,
0.34457919,
0.3970929086,
0.1210532635,
0.2750691175,
-0.4196034372,
0.1406501085,
-0.4484365582,
-0.5090387464,
-0.561342001,
-0.0061693089,
0.4789467752,
0.6493365169,
-0.0265624989,
-0.1054350957,
0.1844526231,
0.2834022045,
-0.6034377813,
0.5076052547,
-0.7000908256,
0.0271131229,
-0.0713427365,
-0.2444511056,
-0.8707844615,
-0.2762244344,
0.4546304345,
-0.3692091405,
0.3203223944,
0.2318486124,
0.7333421707,
0.0682814792,
-0.4619254172,
0.2904224396,
-0.695448637,
0.9391973019,
-0.6698218584,
0.4654557109,
0.7003780007,
0.4174173474,
-0.0492278561,
-0.7142909169,
-0.5473630428,
-0.3104637563,
-0.430044204,
-0.2309129834,
-0.3677633703,
0.2225845605,
-0.1075124815,
0.3774833083,
-0.4418562651,
-0.0336417109,
0.0117630465,
-0.3768494129,
0.6182943583,
0.3610450327,
0.2818387151,
0.2954427898,
-0.4104120135,
0.1074934676,
-0.6548504233,
0.0916083381,
0.7095765471,
0.441372931,
-0.231518954,
0.3336653411,
-0.1652537733,
0.5435423851,
0.1095732823,
-0.1619767994,
-0.0696317181,
-0.3465782702,
-0.1988959312,
-0.3716723323,
0.5385645628,
0.0951362327,
0.3932081163,
-0.4787679911,
-0.1408536881,
0.1277334541,
0.2936378717,
-0.8238347769,
-0.4152816832,
0.23911044,
-0.4169832468,
-0.3249351084,
0.0417947806,
-0.6257556677,
-0.4361762404,
-0.2884637713,
0.4380289316,
-0.4008523226,
-0.3942857981,
0.3032147288,
-0.0063010133,
-0.325869292,
0.1853621751,
-1.0676183701,
0.7386463284,
0.9900588393,
0.5514431,
-0.5120674372,
-0.4042734802,
-0.4613544643,
0.2173773646,
0.0813513771,
0.4903752208,
-0.8404484987,
-0.4635539055,
0.4349263906,
0.4732670486,
-0.2987025976,
-0.4570918381,
0.0438197255,
-0.7682139874,
0.3034513593,
0.2242137045,
-0.6108989716,
-0.0116447117,
0.1097917482,
-0.4125140607,
0.2950458825,
0.3866971731,
-0.6382164955,
0.0487071835,
-0.44034338,
-0.300677985,
0.1434823126,
-0.0554305762,
-0.5394212604,
-0.0742244124,
0.0772033483,
0.5251065493,
0.0322270915,
0.39201051,
-0.4353353083,
-0.1144639924,
0.6392627358,
-0.5906772017,
0.7565201521,
0.1577299684,
-0.3591436744,
0.0177829769,
-0.5282850266,
0.0565324016,
-0.0770426169,
-0.023630498,
-0.5182079077,
-0.1425929517,
-0.3182930648,
-0.0993781239,
0.4006477296,
-0.4387938678,
0.1752016395,
-0.4704276621,
0.4929530323,
0.9100563526,
0.2292260826,
0.8676201701,
-0.2006476969,
0.6601904631,
0.2697207928,
0.4771279395,
-0.136114642,
-0.8324398994,
-0.5074353218,
-0.4511240721,
0.5666642785,
0.4251039028,
-0.5477381349,
0.5127712488,
-0.0886392593,
0.0002310733,
-0.22671175,
-0.152762413,
0.5994757414,
0.2419816107,
0.1143631935,
-0.4989471436,
0.1200106442,
-0.9439364076,
-0.4251211584,
-0.0658340603,
0.0923008099,
0.5254682302,
0.2666244805,
-0.2918284535,
0.8724097013,
-0.6552718282,
-0.3218803704,
-0.0378625356,
-0.1470999122,
-0.1449567378,
0.5174328685,
0.5558577776,
-0.8651481271,
-0.6415462494,
0.0980871767,
-0.4871386886,
0.2298732996,
0.1927087456,
-0.2616940737,
0.2862790823,
0.0226839017,
-0.7012929916,
0.7094609737,
0.9339279532,
-0.5311791301,
0.3668675125,
0.000994503,
-0.0953705162,
-0.7201168537,
-0.228916496,
-0.1352926493,
-0.563357234,
-0.8684722781,
0.1960352659,
-0.0415594205,
-0.5717837214,
-0.6900426149,
0.7222494483,
-0.4176233411,
0.1623639315,
-0.1519482732,
-0.2039022744,
0.1420843303,
0.9040101767,
0.0255303215,
0.9897389412,
0.7819168568,
-0.7995377183,
-0.0968800634,
0.5670391917,
-0.0635740906,
0.3086244762,
-0.3837074637,
0.4927252233,
0.3183328211,
0.3077591956,
-0.853733182,
-0.3272697926,
0.2441262305,
-0.4824363887,
0.6209856272,
-0.4891421199,
-0.1895632744,
0.1256768852,
-0.1646567583,
0.2489560395,
0.3625001609,
-0.5865586996,
0.5771226883,
0.824036181,
-0.2346794754,
-0.7535426617,
-0.5856538415,
-0.0433240123,
-0.1243838966,
-0.8778003454,
0.4007494152,
-0.0569630228,
-0.1889662743,
0.0688175485,
-0.212790519,
-0.5348793268,
0.1955032349,
0.4070146978,
0.1968745142,
-0.2087548673,
-0.1829248816,
0.1987015456,
-0.2846662402,
0.137771219,
-0.4432958364,
0.6084215045,
-0.2218716741,
-0.239810437,
-0.7496111989,
0.8115351796,
0.3550057411,
-0.3397954404,
1.1782267094,
-0.0062030903,
-0.2770661116,
-0.7138391137,
-0.2612435222,
-0.4556560218,
-0.6302405,
0.1198018491,
-0.4995411634,
-1.1602702141,
0.4821380675,
-0.3078730106,
0.0248924773,
0.0539266653,
0.5644350052,
0.4535240233,
1.1075474024,
1.2212620974,
-0.1482986361,
0.2062736452,
-0.248440057,
0.8392192125,
-0.262052983,
-0.1840133071,
-0.5244965553,
0.1379685402,
-0.8207113743,
-0.1869163513,
0.1516715288,
-0.1952886581,
-0.0829528943,
0.6056919098,
-0.4648478031,
0.5849254131,
0.4244588614,
-0.0832749754,
0.4333689511,
0.2102441937,
-0.0554189533,
-0.0214186627,
-0.4548054039,
-0.627130568,
0.7692372203,
0.5294029117,
0.8212553859,
0.4359062016,
0.6419235468,
0.4183671772,
0.4003406167,
-0.5207999945,
0.5098010302,
-0.335564971,
-0.7533108592,
-0.5382890701,
-0.4099120498,
-0.8480363488,
0.2759622931,
0.2612662911,
-1.1017196178,
0.5034170747,
0.1137849018,
-0.3961512744,
0.2545264363,
-0.9071933031,
0.857924521,
0.3388923407,
-0.2334102839,
-0.0656776801,
-0.6891898513,
0.5862355232,
-0.2889071703,
0.0759100169,
-0.1816676855,
0.226209864,
0.211663112,
-0.5811671019,
1.1966993809,
-0.2719335556,
-0.1531249434,
0.2062461376,
0.4044468105,
0.4707742333,
0.4473673105,
0.062684834,
0.6899650097,
0.1507491767,
-0.2927487195,
-0.6581860185,
0.7595509291,
-0.878898859,
-0.7631713748,
-0.3973466158,
-0.2559302747,
-0.7548308969,
0.024704149,
0.1504981518,
0.3855876923,
-0.1011704504,
0.0778350309,
0.6959764361,
-0.3764341176,
0.2986996174,
0.8668473959,
0.0986038148,
-0.0455875471,
0.925680697,
-0.2833577096,
0.3754202724,
0.4023551345,
0.1504213214,
-0.4487074316,
-0.3639520109,
-0.1899762005,
0.1716205478,
-0.5573698878,
-0.6046332121,
-0.8370162249,
-0.638675034,
-0.5251817107,
0.0393132158,
-0.2371183932,
-0.8180984855,
-0.0980301946,
-0.1982428581,
0.3025627434,
0.5104501843,
0.0627967641,
0.4010058939,
-0.8284141421,
0.2782063782,
0.4928439558,
0.506708324,
-0.0942205712,
-0.5636003017,
0.0696984082,
-0.191357851,
-0.4850181937,
-0.5036488771,
0.5879261494,
0.4404428005,
0.4069778621,
0.305785805,
0.3070221543,
0.2974660993,
-1.0132992268,
0.9434756041,
0.1714117229,
-1.0345083475,
0.2079899907,
-0.2987415791,
-0.2417785376,
0.4686243534,
0.2962566316,
-0.3325117528,
-0.8235311508,
-0.8205416799,
-0.5970354676,
0.8136854172,
0.3711723387,
0.7035983801,
0.1227365583,
0.1731922179,
0.4734547436,
0.367192626,
-0.4607277215,
-0.6723045707,
-0.147027716,
-0.0370549075,
0.0102138938,
-0.0947230309,
-0.3313166499,
-0.1599307507,
0.4653415978,
-0.146214813,
0.5901607275,
-0.2217369378,
0.123883456,
0.0941915587,
0.3247080743,
0.6122119427,
0.7857521176,
0.0683770552,
0.2550245821,
-0.1145893633,
-0.4556884766,
0.283156991,
0.1119668335,
-0.0501296222,
0.1091462746,
-0.0036324516,
0.6536723375,
-0.0444094315,
-0.2863858342,
0.9729887843,
-0.4178560078,
-0.3418265879,
-0.386916995,
0.2590700388,
-0.0879098848,
0.1021334901,
0.0021921338,
0.3855250776,
0.1354973316,
-0.5012596846,
0.470261693,
0.276235044,
-0.2550711036,
-0.7372937799,
0.8986531496,
0.3358182907,
-0.587422967,
0.2599007487,
-0.0908213407,
-0.6609098911,
0.2089902461,
0.4355928004,
1.1072909832,
-0.4186311066,
0.3525657356,
-0.1863692701,
0.0572890341,
0.0964857712,
-0.0364609212,
-0.1014165506,
-0.8521474004,
-0.3606606424,
-0.469034493,
-0.6976351142,
0.4468268156,
-0.4273933172,
-0.1074974537,
-0.5118156075,
-0.447453171,
0.1234593466,
-0.2132561505,
-0.6961843967,
0.045427978,
0.0971206874,
0.6237060428,
-0.5831648111,
1.0012309551,
0.0000874176,
-0.0908895433,
-0.6584278941,
0.225831762,
-0.0168636907,
-0.8351914287,
0.7962706089,
0.0262172855,
-0.439707607,
-0.4216906726,
-0.6301307678,
-0.6549639106,
0.4237546921,
0.5016608834,
-0.716915071,
0.0880987942,
0.4859136343,
0.5623213053,
-0.3042294681,
-0.430601418,
0.5632796884,
0.278616786,
-0.665245235,
-0.9546847343,
0.0743116662,
0.0254410543,
-0.1014995575,
0.1245386004,
-0.8730587363,
0.7197833061,
0.1324959546,
-0.3471557498,
0.1622743607,
0.5849972367,
-0.0806777179,
0.4139997959,
0.4992384613,
0.1188004836,
0.7803936005,
-0.045363348,
1.1158622503,
-0.6788471341,
0.4177481532,
1.0286580324,
-0.6271432638,
0.5450665951,
0.0737807974,
-0.0817963928,
0.4025366902,
0.1128743291,
0.223993361,
1.0647964478,
0.2396488637,
-0.6593814492,
-0.2007739097,
-0.0683368668,
-0.2411838025,
0.2479393333,
0.3657443523,
-0.2008994967,
0.1550565064,
-0.0657665953,
0.118473798,
0.0102985725,
0.1674008965,
0.7225814462,
0.5002866983,
-0.6793512106,
0.4419123828,
0.3788307607,
0.4324315786,
-0.5520757437,
0.0214152783,
-0.3275830746,
0.5162469149,
-0.1406772435,
-0.4155848622,
0.3530096412,
0.0051605776,
0.0003051768,
-0.5064430833,
0.8077896833,
-0.3316118121,
0.0275345296,
0.3377052546,
0.500816524,
-0.0143568059,
-0.1075968072,
-0.6883998513,
-0.21372208,
-0.1452435106,
-0.2578751445,
0.6057502627,
0.5648753643,
-0.1438294798,
0.5765598416,
0.5210236907,
-0.2530641258,
0.3107447624,
0.4283152223,
0.8735140562,
-0.2726432383,
-0.6147156358,
-0.6854479909,
0.3300562501,
-0.179482162,
-0.3416405618,
0.9647738338,
0.2890102267,
0.8778607845,
-0.2354518771,
0.9408561587,
0.4506207407,
0.6040875316,
-0.3973339498,
0.8321120739,
-0.1449865252,
0.3113648891,
0.0453756154,
-0.7305373549,
-0.2695782781,
0.3809854686,
-0.150892511,
-0.1868819594,
0.9604901075,
0.8656951785,
-0.1243448183,
0.260511905,
0.6130287647,
0.009646696,
0.3941286206,
0.1855275631,
1.0724761486,
-0.2668961287,
0.3741374016,
-0.4228808284,
-0.1626609862,
0.1000169367,
-0.5201741457,
-1.2018690109,
-0.5370975137,
-0.5412852168,
-0.4454520345,
0.2089701593,
0.1468906999,
1.2114688158,
-1.1062498093,
0.1338044852,
0.0726868734,
-0.0492046028,
-0.0154551677,
-0.2744068801,
0.2853142023,
-0.4239177406,
-0.8055548668,
0.585523665,
0.3525071442,
-0.0438919626,
-0.4547570348,
0.1126314774,
0.5030972958,
0.429779917,
0.5648102164,
0.1097634658,
-0.6616285443,
-0.5354198813,
0.0203097761,
-0.0321665853,
-0.0279712509,
1.1434973478,
-0.3346385956,
-0.0193362199,
0.2430935651,
0.7502864003,
0.4749541581,
0.1304276437,
0.7084955573,
-1.2286701202,
0.3493984044,
0.3849667609,
0.2957361341,
0.2568172514,
-0.6885287762,
0.342707783,
0.0076786457,
-0.8217770457,
-0.8436555266,
0.4122503698,
-0.8146138191,
-0.4688751996,
1.0134621859,
-0.6245208979,
-0.2819907665,
-0.5536813736,
0.053917706,
-0.2163064033,
-0.7096191049,
0.8025032282,
0.6303873062,
0.0798696801,
0.1227407902,
-0.5258678794,
0.8476477861,
0.1900757551,
-0.7192786932,
0.3795620799,
0.1414520442,
0.4788014293,
0.2010402679,
0.7359517813,
-0.3351201415,
-0.1278019398,
-0.1352153271,
-0.5480974317,
0.0741901398,
-0.777410388,
-0.3748715222,
0.3412002027,
-0.1315271705,
-0.2906181514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14205v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14205v2 | $μ$PLAN: Summarizing using a Content Plan as Cross-Lingual Bridge | 2023-05-23T16:25:21 | 2024-01-31T13:28:58 | Fantine Huot, Joshua Maynez, Chris Alberti, Reinald Kim Amplayo, Priyanka Agrawal, Constanza Fierro, Shashi Narayan, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual summarization consists of generating a summary in one language
given an input document in a different language, allowing for the dissemination
of relevant content across speakers of other languages. The task is challenging
mainly due to the paucity of cross-lingual datasets and the compounded
difficulty of summarizing and translating. This work presents $\mu$PLAN, an
approach to cross-lingual summarization that uses an intermediate planning step
as a cross-lingual bridge. We formulate the plan as a sequence of entities
capturing the summary's content and the order in which it should be
communicated. Importantly, our plans abstract from surface form: using a
multilingual knowledge base, we align entities to their canonical designation
across languages and generate the summary conditioned on this cross-lingual
bridge and the input. Automatic and human evaluation on the XWikis dataset
(across four language pairs) demonstrates that our planning objective achieves
state-of-the-art performance in terms of informativeness and faithfulness.
Moreover, $\mu$PLAN models improve the zero-shot transfer to new cross-lingual
language pairs compared to baselines without a planning component. | [
-0.5008551478,
-0.2410095185,
0.3477822542,
0.3047427833,
-0.2925817966,
0.0815646201,
-0.0886607319,
-0.2107188702,
0.9412279725,
0.3983514011,
-0.607947886,
-0.369866401,
-0.5067794919,
-0.0902572796,
-0.0478072278,
0.880018115,
-0.3840366304,
0.1399302632,
0.1462448388,
-0.1137108281,
-0.2490662485,
-0.0314661041,
-0.6156600118,
-0.3944977522,
0.9959380031,
1.0708117485,
0.7895932794,
0.3345826566,
0.1503393799,
0.1478635818,
0.1979978234,
0.2617324889,
-0.6910220981,
-0.2247007936,
-0.4049286544,
-0.448562324,
-0.7387803793,
-0.3159511089,
0.7108076215,
1.2352434397,
0.1132770851,
0.1229048744,
-0.0901464298,
0.9251697063,
-0.6556303501,
0.3040615916,
-0.3038155735,
0.3028811812,
-0.1837186366,
-0.2896261513,
-0.1762750149,
0.3290168941,
-0.0388748534,
-0.840395391,
-0.2559644878,
0.0675805211,
0.5324985385,
-0.4926190078,
-0.4411052167,
-0.1948280036,
-0.5502767563,
0.5732070208,
-0.6052094698,
0.5745455623,
0.3616047204,
0.4443573654,
0.0794304013,
-0.6916410923,
-0.3771026731,
0.1276555806,
-0.3064784706,
0.3946202397,
-0.079328537,
-0.0818704516,
0.0086931745,
0.307084173,
-0.8013774753,
0.0068341303,
-0.6069382429,
-0.0615912713,
0.8201268315,
0.2521794736,
0.5399829149,
-0.2564617395,
-0.4224053919,
0.033463005,
-0.8940760493,
-0.1223111898,
0.4188595712,
0.3928073049,
-0.5088977218,
0.9530126452,
-0.6951248646,
0.183211118,
-0.1141433567,
-0.189990133,
0.0205050129,
-0.5808647871,
-0.2367127538,
0.2190472186,
0.6498702168,
0.7657617331,
0.3438075781,
-0.4108843207,
-0.2484064102,
-0.4146469831,
-0.1301828325,
-0.6190549135,
-0.2129234523,
0.1076745167,
-0.4367437065,
0.090322338,
-0.2885806859,
-0.7666712403,
0.0883544907,
-0.4193630517,
0.3820863068,
-0.4117828906,
-0.6057513356,
0.1385955215,
-0.020027617,
-0.0664933696,
0.1378290057,
-1.2202295065,
0.4748675525,
0.5408085585,
0.8249826431,
-0.111526303,
-0.6300382018,
-0.3667469621,
0.7789562941,
-0.4753685892,
0.7869006991,
0.0667312294,
-0.6843436956,
0.0326335989,
-0.1190094575,
-0.0668701753,
-0.0010737791,
0.4191196263,
-0.3763730526,
0.3101907372,
-0.4922300875,
-0.3440331817,
-0.2601849437,
0.6001542807,
-0.9351468682,
0.4190408289,
0.3059877455,
-0.9280608892,
0.2600111961,
-0.5515981913,
-0.8764939904,
-0.1808651984,
-0.3171451986,
-0.0974221975,
-0.0917645991,
0.3599169552,
0.4295318723,
-0.0559792556,
0.2134692073,
0.0649704337,
0.0178116914,
-0.1113255396,
-0.0487596132,
0.804439187,
0.2404186726,
-0.3023062646,
0.1336357892,
-0.5056205988,
0.0707312673,
0.0179726034,
-0.3347772956,
-0.4830000997,
-0.0781513676,
0.1497555077,
0.3446588516,
0.1170042753,
-0.2985129952,
0.2750400901,
-0.3998299539,
-0.1575523019,
0.231218338,
-0.0237487517,
0.9683622122,
-0.5802093744,
0.5280665755,
-0.0781870037,
-0.0006019195,
-0.5547774434,
-0.4468089938,
-0.5759264827,
0.1554353386,
0.3436920047,
0.6314755678,
-1.2026770115,
-0.2250303179,
-0.7523434162,
-0.5185279846,
0.0560655445,
0.0842620507,
0.6762707829,
0.3900058568,
0.2886261344,
-0.1039623842,
-0.4867164195,
-0.8711776733,
-0.1149106175,
-0.3256268799,
-0.0053456649,
-0.0820546374,
0.2732712924,
0.2071808726,
0.5155507326,
-0.4670527875,
-0.4586941004,
-1.0075010061,
0.3511085212,
0.0061321906,
0.4357817769,
0.6816914082,
-1.1519367695,
-0.8263355494,
0.3012804687,
-0.6229627132,
-0.1573723704,
-0.4020423889,
-0.572024107,
0.0831217766,
0.4272974133,
-0.6384884715,
0.2528350353,
0.5934372544,
-0.4054483175,
0.6647011042,
-0.143862918,
0.3009501994,
-1.3391132355,
0.2802972496,
-0.4572445154,
-0.2148983479,
-0.656340301,
0.0460243709,
0.1586086154,
-0.2487611026,
-0.4826191962,
0.5997374058,
-0.8323379755,
-0.0807235241,
-0.0306793395,
0.1682720929,
0.0750820488,
0.8458060026,
0.28098616,
0.147307381,
0.1649332345,
-0.5960629582,
0.1070651263,
0.2359164208,
-0.1090970859,
0.7878735662,
-0.3400683701,
-0.4711934924,
0.0436218567,
0.2217562199,
-0.838339746,
-0.2809551954,
0.4143820107,
-0.7107227445,
0.6825911999,
-0.086973846,
-0.2371979505,
0.2298042774,
-0.4780102074,
0.4716686308,
-0.2075580508,
-0.1722139269,
1.0436309576,
0.7150779366,
-0.6777909994,
-0.488198638,
-1.0071698427,
0.4392909408,
0.0130183259,
-0.8907341361,
0.9270832539,
-0.0967208073,
-0.2608617544,
0.267023921,
0.0505926497,
0.0220446978,
-0.2871283889,
-0.056564182,
0.137406677,
-0.2737835646,
-0.3252243102,
0.3795095384,
-0.3586674333,
0.1544705778,
-0.1613064557,
0.5615264773,
0.6407423019,
-0.3446246088,
0.0714584813,
1.1168879271,
0.5120580792,
-0.215455994,
0.2756952047,
0.318656981,
-0.401432246,
-0.1021789387,
-0.0755172148,
0.3254703879,
-0.2879908979,
0.1336157173,
-0.9349746108,
-0.2225724459,
0.6174563169,
0.1405647397,
0.6466510892,
0.3234253228,
0.526479125,
0.0225520208,
0.9520430565,
0.9331949353,
-0.1922306567,
0.3416081071,
-0.4351522326,
0.0687434897,
-0.609706223,
-0.4464661479,
-0.092269212,
-0.6581472158,
-0.2102521658,
-0.3880067468,
0.451515317,
-0.010599358,
0.3618828058,
0.4515919685,
0.4149895608,
0.2146803141,
0.538595438,
-0.0797470212,
0.6035677195,
0.0144845005,
-0.4819038808,
-0.0239956789,
-0.9004997611,
-0.276343435,
0.9095011353,
0.0578388758,
0.7232112288,
0.350194335,
0.6686769724,
0.0720889792,
0.216559127,
-0.515044868,
0.454565078,
0.0542327166,
-0.4314393997,
-0.6152600646,
-0.5381931067,
-0.9313238859,
0.5792475343,
-0.1158654615,
-0.3903573453,
0.215192765,
-0.2251307368,
-0.1114743426,
0.5555971861,
-0.6311169267,
0.8149064183,
-0.4732016623,
-0.0515460446,
-0.331490159,
-0.7419185638,
0.6194038987,
-0.0783817768,
0.3287196755,
-0.2932134867,
-0.2496661395,
0.6691371799,
-0.3141193688,
0.4086008668,
0.0178464316,
-0.0764788091,
0.0450919643,
0.3351637721,
0.2183363587,
0.1900439411,
0.1732947826,
0.0221681334,
-0.2409723103,
-0.5539079309,
-0.5568612218,
0.4640330672,
-0.3045017719,
-0.2662637234,
0.0164576136,
-0.9091201425,
-0.3522781432,
0.5444953442,
0.4628941715,
0.5336382985,
-0.4568531513,
-0.3776742518,
0.3973795474,
-0.200798586,
0.5455576181,
0.9481494427,
-0.7367776036,
-0.6517170072,
0.9365289807,
0.5536497235,
0.6289696097,
1.0543824434,
-0.0074766208,
-0.0729621649,
-0.3847621679,
-0.9566217065,
0.3519831598,
-0.6339387298,
-0.0412516557,
-0.6585104465,
-0.0392908007,
-0.6536251307,
-0.3166386187,
-0.1916666925,
-0.8410869837,
0.4432098269,
-0.1314045489,
-0.4297483563,
0.3544285297,
-0.5334314108,
0.0882381275,
-0.7709823251,
0.7678601146,
-0.025594471,
0.0427909903,
-0.1749347597,
-0.1631676257,
-0.5246952176,
0.0816948563,
0.099492766,
-0.8817181587,
0.4302862585,
0.05588568,
0.850818038,
0.4350747168,
0.3282434046,
0.6611227393,
-0.6424785852,
0.3586108685,
0.4901943207,
-0.5663670897,
0.5066505075,
-0.3220693171,
0.6316853166,
0.5716115236,
0.8496019244,
-0.9457435608,
-0.4325090051,
-0.5661168694,
-0.8804066181,
0.4620189667,
0.1310203075,
0.0589939319,
0.2130106986,
-0.367156595,
0.078447111,
-0.0090512633,
-0.6048861146,
-0.2494798303,
0.0155701451,
-0.0306261443,
-0.0945234522,
-0.2843360007,
-0.1491232961,
-0.0829077139,
0.7735750675,
-0.2411024868,
-0.0280020144,
0.2000106871,
-0.3965524137,
-0.1525873691,
0.1630760878,
0.6565182805,
0.9553086758,
0.1607911438,
0.4160628319,
0.226435855,
-0.4064573944,
-0.0998636559,
0.1461229622,
-0.5177152157,
0.4417788684,
0.6668325663,
0.3450853229,
0.8653619289,
-0.634088099,
0.4509649873,
-0.0995432138,
-0.2967581153,
-0.0673160404,
-0.5430814028,
0.3464829326,
0.1512009948,
0.1527073234,
-0.3346424103,
0.2657181919,
-0.5950689316,
0.1708582193,
0.0367721356,
-0.2377829105,
-0.4192906618,
0.5539879203,
0.2466247231,
0.0296502542,
0.2911619246,
-0.2531227767,
-0.5573062897,
0.3067937493,
0.3583860397,
0.6837724447,
-0.2060870379,
0.3593187332,
0.3745971322,
0.5496208668,
0.3882105649,
0.6228125095,
-0.1832168251,
-0.575137198,
-0.5350083113,
-0.2169907838,
-0.4496282935,
-0.3777515888,
-0.3748579621,
0.5846580863,
-0.0548248738,
0.3646551669,
-0.0793590695,
0.1029634997,
-0.2047444433,
0.1923588216,
0.4405888617,
1.4018322229,
-0.8053147793,
0.6551756859,
0.6125673056,
-0.7864304185,
-0.8967713714,
-0.2838667631,
0.0580330975,
-0.7513192296,
0.3997122347,
-0.0258301254,
-0.1463186294,
-0.3539239168,
0.3279207051,
-0.8523257971,
1.1701604128,
0.3211547732,
-0.4070949256,
-0.4957277179,
0.4072961509,
-0.062162675,
-0.2269828618,
0.0675759241,
0.285677731,
0.5988377929,
0.1949246526,
-0.9867693782,
-0.0962966383,
-0.3878276944,
-0.362028867,
0.3786744475,
-0.4862789214,
1.0069526434,
-0.5136758685,
-0.6390343308,
-0.1241864637,
0.9224926829,
-0.0098532671,
0.4714679122,
0.616220355,
0.6479309201,
0.4423784316,
0.1964836568,
0.852435708,
-0.4314768612,
-0.0611674339,
1.2862370014,
-0.0900265202,
0.8379402161,
0.4402209222,
0.0724455416,
0.2835984528,
0.576269567,
0.5004882216,
0.7611757517,
-0.1112647727,
-0.2106127143,
0.1540433317,
-0.1833326966,
-0.3411061466,
0.3160037398,
0.3756859601,
-0.1881036013,
-0.7378279567,
0.0812096596,
0.4805237651,
0.039438609,
-0.6710548401,
0.6376080513,
0.1488999575,
-0.9419279695,
0.1336683333,
0.2487736493,
0.2969883382,
-0.923833251,
0.1262016296,
-0.4708407521,
0.0922520012,
-0.4291529655,
-1.0854768753,
0.5388855934,
-0.1873341948,
-0.2226583362,
-0.4775811136,
0.6080904603,
-0.9526990056,
-0.5224009752,
0.480874449,
0.6353824139,
0.1460104287,
-0.1667260677,
-0.5197131038,
-0.3787404895,
-0.1388337612,
-0.1720330864,
0.2818372846,
0.7301793098,
-0.4133499861,
0.4219226539,
0.5387454033,
0.2390845716,
0.1955720037,
0.2541759908,
0.8964923024,
-0.3857166171,
-0.9404698014,
-0.6597654819,
0.7737926245,
-0.1180220619,
-0.3071293831,
0.6612061858,
1.1477737427,
1.3582849503,
0.2001773715,
0.5961951613,
-0.2728762031,
0.3966497183,
-0.7500432134,
0.8725263476,
-0.703271389,
-0.0279128235,
-0.136550501,
-0.7558071017,
-0.2893857956,
0.0513388142,
-0.093554318,
-0.3795275986,
0.661457181,
0.6241038442,
-0.3353971541,
-0.283308804,
0.6609778404,
-0.3224896193,
0.1622684598,
0.8506162167,
0.5655990243,
-0.1278255284,
0.8466159701,
-0.6104333997,
-0.3499290049,
-0.0816397294,
-0.726924777,
-0.8068922162,
-0.6831507683,
-0.0217549372,
0.0697350278,
-0.2522891462,
0.4522114694,
0.7311858535,
-0.5837846398,
-0.6451806426,
0.3108327687,
0.3095976412,
-0.2303842008,
-0.156229645,
0.2033627629,
-0.5006284714,
-0.7696794271,
0.3655645549,
0.4805423319,
-0.2788866758,
-0.623957634,
-0.4262952805,
-0.4699843228,
-0.0096704578,
0.7538644671,
0.4016541541,
-0.287522763,
0.3319988251,
0.0705503076,
-0.380397588,
-0.16268906,
1.104385972,
-0.3252714574,
0.4077084064,
0.7446750402,
0.5493551493,
0.7849076986,
-0.4077870548,
1.0594278574,
-0.8133244514,
-0.0566117242,
-0.0093886042,
0.7394199371,
0.1194674596,
-0.2410387099,
0.6860762239,
-0.0506015942,
-0.0375271328,
-0.2936144471,
0.2805460095,
-1.0048464537,
-0.4016567469,
0.862457931,
-0.3266125023,
-0.2199772149,
-0.0479811952,
-0.3853235543,
0.2135627419,
0.106918402,
0.3961664736,
0.5473217964,
-0.0571702719,
-0.0708074868,
-0.534735918,
0.115316011,
0.1905180514,
-1.0195522308,
-0.0276074503,
0.3366570473,
0.0643337592,
0.4105558991,
1.1303031445,
-0.2899602354,
0.4836060107,
0.2437675297,
-0.0188256372,
0.0204251595,
-0.5210009217,
0.2371985018,
0.1581884325,
-0.3688791394,
-0.2963503897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14202v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14202v2 | Fine-tuned LLMs Know More, Hallucinate Less with Few-Shot Sequence-to-Sequence Semantic Parsing over Wikidata | 2023-05-23T16:20:43 | 2023-11-05T19:26:17 | Silei Xu, Shicheng Liu, Theo Culhane, Elizaveta Pertseva, Meng-Hsi Wu, Sina J. Semnani, Monica S. Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) can answer many questions correctly, they
can also hallucinate and give wrong answers. Wikidata, with its over 12 billion
facts, can be used to ground LLMs to improve their factuality. This paper
presents WikiWebQuestions, a high-quality question answering benchmark for
Wikidata. Ported over from WebQuestions for Freebase, it consists of real-world
data with SPARQL annotation. This paper presents a few-shot
sequence-to-sequence semantic parser for Wikidata. We modify SPARQL to use the
unique domain and property names instead of their IDs. We train the parser to
use either the results from an entity linker or mentions in the query. We
fine-tune LLaMA by adding the few-shot training data to that used to fine-tune
Alpaca. Our experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of this
methodology, establishing a strong baseline of 76% and 65% answer accuracy in
the dev and test sets of WikiWebQuestions, respectively. By pairing our
semantic parser with GPT-3, we combine verifiable results with qualified GPT-3
guesses to provide useful answers to 96% of the questions in dev. We also show
that our method outperforms the state-of-the-art for the QALD-7 Wikidata
dataset by 3.6% in F1 score. | [
-0.7707928419,
-0.9776917696,
0.4748592675,
0.0700496361,
-0.2785689533,
-0.1620481908,
-0.1391783357,
-0.664875567,
0.2013808042,
0.5312451124,
-0.8332158923,
-0.6742589474,
-0.4282220304,
0.4412549734,
-0.4300872386,
0.9241936803,
0.2272445261,
-0.0635538027,
-0.2371836603,
-0.20542413,
-0.4254803061,
-0.0463530719,
-0.1419325471,
-0.161499247,
0.9260391593,
0.6667257547,
0.9102057815,
0.6941040754,
0.3616047502,
0.2420278341,
-0.104900375,
0.6839177012,
-0.5606715679,
0.1600580066,
-0.2768992782,
-0.4000558555,
-0.0912939832,
-0.1963791102,
0.0608703271,
0.7888356447,
-0.0054248641,
0.4193155169,
-0.08166264,
0.5122700334,
-0.7238086462,
-0.0685526505,
-0.9207258821,
-0.0887112394,
-0.1380563676,
-0.2988334894,
-0.2538028657,
-0.3627325296,
-0.0345033109,
-1.0758311749,
0.4487012625,
0.0063805175,
1.1085426807,
0.5134628415,
-0.3860751987,
-0.1903123856,
-0.4078650773,
0.3068404198,
-0.5736945271,
0.3893910944,
0.7397766709,
0.1537510306,
-0.5582579374,
-0.6443328261,
-0.7494232059,
-0.0870065168,
-0.0488138273,
-0.288441509,
0.1365496963,
-0.1183645576,
0.4778600037,
0.1066622585,
-0.7879591584,
0.1890347153,
-0.18270953,
-0.1754608452,
0.4318480492,
0.2613607943,
-0.0351872854,
-0.4247893691,
-0.0481329523,
-0.1744797677,
-0.6800808311,
0.0123526705,
0.178872928,
0.1682207882,
0.2663774192,
0.9291418195,
-0.9061899781,
0.9427409172,
0.1399574429,
-0.2804867625,
0.1317023486,
-0.0118349688,
0.0890571102,
-0.1168296933,
0.537678659,
0.6726608276,
0.3570200801,
-0.4900419712,
0.0585486814,
0.0641105399,
0.2053047717,
-0.8179647326,
-0.0806809068,
0.3371226788,
-0.0352938958,
-0.0904032663,
0.0707047209,
-0.7326386571,
-0.40864259,
-0.1669123471,
0.5077494383,
-0.3007233441,
0.057664603,
0.1539275795,
-0.2129283398,
0.697857976,
0.2744297385,
-0.8944590092,
0.3469954431,
0.959703207,
0.6657497287,
-0.0939694047,
-0.4306135178,
-0.610302031,
0.2526578307,
-0.5748806,
1.234185338,
-0.1146105602,
-0.1635025293,
-0.193950206,
-0.0718943849,
0.3002423942,
-0.6342308521,
0.3148631454,
-0.8374142647,
-0.1145631596,
-0.5473161936,
-0.8017434478,
0.0917573795,
0.6420431137,
-0.622426331,
1.0891536474,
0.0463081226,
-0.7502948642,
0.4698961377,
-0.1584263742,
-0.3586269915,
-0.0415084884,
0.0133893779,
-0.0525182858,
0.1181155667,
0.3543819487,
0.42335096,
-0.3201316297,
0.3215385079,
-0.4097843766,
-0.3932461441,
0.4182543457,
-0.3469611406,
0.4561893344,
0.1348450333,
-0.33172822,
-0.3428017795,
-1.1895251274,
0.37086308,
0.0315095037,
-0.1731015295,
-0.3021152914,
-0.113674745,
-0.3483648896,
0.3305715621,
0.0760603622,
-0.5453225374,
0.1653541625,
-0.6228153706,
-0.0464537591,
0.4788966775,
0.1729291379,
0.1175745577,
-0.3441086113,
0.1177587286,
-0.1457352191,
0.2277147472,
0.1492304057,
-0.6718936563,
-0.9936659336,
-0.0979174748,
0.0889304802,
0.6475112438,
-0.6706758142,
0.557153523,
-0.4810230732,
-0.6665742397,
-0.7078796625,
0.394502908,
0.0738476217,
0.7262378931,
0.582804203,
-0.1503395438,
-0.3277205825,
-0.7705250382,
-0.2418611497,
-0.0964955911,
-0.1240760013,
0.1819586754,
0.4263319671,
-0.1492335945,
1.0808407068,
-0.7258359194,
-0.1329076141,
0.1575686932,
0.0009824105,
0.2793886662,
0.0815800428,
0.0785491839,
-0.7265866399,
-0.3840576112,
-0.052492436,
-0.7119827271,
-0.1457448304,
0.2374509871,
-0.3080320954,
-0.147604242,
0.1495252997,
-1.3885005713,
0.2169072777,
0.1557291746,
-0.5188379884,
0.227002725,
0.1677801758,
0.1718600541,
-0.9422554374,
0.024196839,
-0.4500130713,
-0.2206164449,
-0.3782095015,
0.1567633152,
0.0037641532,
0.0869067609,
-0.4978894591,
0.5663098693,
-0.117346473,
-0.2500165105,
-0.2308288515,
0.2798419595,
0.3563832641,
0.376131326,
-0.2392749339,
0.6770321727,
0.0599611551,
-0.7665620446,
0.6371836066,
0.596816361,
-0.4565377831,
0.3592628241,
-0.4829982519,
0.3138419986,
-0.1578879803,
0.1172258258,
-0.7289537787,
-0.4456095994,
-0.0011559102,
-0.6021985412,
-0.0326029025,
-0.0115884086,
-0.6236424446,
-0.2916439176,
-0.4666080177,
-0.0577270724,
0.1784822792,
-0.6577953696,
0.2437416911,
0.1100329533,
-0.0704723597,
-0.8325879574,
-0.4644601345,
0.1284926683,
0.0207934827,
-0.7102667093,
0.4002249241,
-0.097991623,
-0.2335179597,
0.2469708771,
-0.1571379155,
-0.1114353836,
0.212404415,
0.192119047,
0.2046125531,
-0.2629964948,
0.0242773518,
-0.0675246939,
-0.187869966,
-0.0633821413,
-0.1120201349,
0.573513031,
0.0837224498,
-0.334802568,
-0.2210163921,
0.3557346165,
0.2173662782,
-0.0749536455,
0.7071064711,
0.5180131197,
-0.3863752186,
-0.1543985009,
-0.9087805748,
-0.1167871654,
-0.4396729469,
0.2408965379,
-0.5324854255,
-1.0495599508,
0.4606166184,
0.1083187982,
0.0434774272,
0.6898025274,
0.5541141629,
-0.3231623471,
0.7620840669,
0.307433486,
-0.0552736782,
-0.0330282301,
-0.4045300782,
-0.0583196953,
-0.3298460543,
-0.4420015216,
-0.7424434423,
-0.06954512,
-0.5769667625,
-0.4890031517,
0.1418752819,
0.3699646592,
-0.2072937191,
0.3059908152,
-0.3666786551,
0.8393711448,
0.2878644466,
0.1308321357,
0.6330506206,
-0.0294040311,
0.1634937823,
0.1335137486,
-0.4456450939,
-0.4220927358,
0.8659750819,
-0.0345184393,
0.7926777601,
0.0934204459,
0.6814771295,
0.178191483,
0.2477364838,
-0.9467574954,
0.4470567703,
0.0421879254,
-0.7293973565,
-0.4420633018,
-0.3345716298,
-0.7758273482,
0.3717694283,
-0.1556748152,
-0.4961146116,
0.1866421551,
-0.0042481325,
-0.2646295428,
-0.1046517119,
-0.4523969889,
0.7980639935,
-0.0677616224,
-0.3186438382,
-0.2801387608,
-0.7108758092,
0.2786318064,
0.0636390671,
0.1231645122,
-0.5167837143,
-0.2506285608,
0.511501193,
-0.6591142416,
0.8023383021,
-0.1177505404,
-0.138947472,
0.3709096909,
-0.0906417593,
0.5773509145,
0.1806951761,
-0.0273985844,
-0.0580347031,
0.1549468786,
-0.4364086688,
-0.7484933138,
0.8447505236,
-0.7865722775,
-0.665032506,
-0.1761517823,
-0.3435874879,
-0.8017973304,
0.0373646542,
0.5004344583,
0.1796964556,
-0.2893856764,
0.0409891382,
0.8550027013,
-0.0190284513,
0.2407139391,
0.5863547921,
0.2160636336,
-0.5311971903,
0.6404186487,
0.1900867671,
0.1061518639,
0.5563834906,
0.0472441129,
-0.3873518705,
-0.3036064804,
-0.6499504447,
0.2256308198,
-0.9493592381,
-0.8398138881,
-0.8758009076,
-0.1208849698,
-0.4420424402,
-0.0165252853,
-0.2509175837,
-0.7874552608,
-0.2309621274,
-0.3954671025,
0.7904711366,
0.6040871739,
0.1499960423,
0.0420121253,
-0.8441109061,
0.916477859,
0.4822974503,
0.3031022251,
-0.1373393089,
-0.4943767488,
-0.0986828506,
-0.101596944,
-0.2661110163,
-0.9424455166,
0.0550911576,
0.430024296,
0.4721404612,
0.0750745907,
0.2308670282,
1.1893247366,
-0.5066750646,
0.6897139549,
-0.1197359785,
-0.5742273331,
0.6661501527,
-0.0976772606,
0.0906043872,
0.9416855574,
0.5545050502,
-0.5157699585,
-0.4733198583,
-0.387231797,
-0.7717007995,
0.3116026521,
-0.2073122859,
0.3951566815,
-0.3080220819,
0.7014935613,
0.3101150095,
-0.1630530804,
-0.4268313348,
-0.1358662397,
-0.2601634562,
-0.3817034364,
0.1129677743,
-0.2442471683,
0.0127463052,
-0.3364096582,
0.7146500349,
-0.3294496536,
-0.1777100265,
0.33272174,
-0.541931808,
-0.0592620522,
0.419950217,
0.2374276221,
0.6417993307,
0.0923081562,
0.0808548108,
0.424403131,
-0.4182857573,
0.3532021642,
0.2675023079,
-0.3782828748,
0.161774531,
0.5280106068,
0.6440755725,
0.1710339189,
-0.6817597151,
0.6882103086,
0.053034313,
-0.0623899996,
0.0343488492,
0.2098195553,
0.1513778418,
0.2660498917,
0.3047040999,
-0.4699404538,
0.3807832301,
-0.1721189767,
0.1618018448,
0.2806661725,
0.0947035551,
-0.081493102,
0.366860956,
0.1028583348,
0.0747526586,
0.5389555097,
-0.0631557554,
-0.1612019092,
0.5227496624,
0.5320488811,
0.4576714337,
0.12545982,
0.2073597014,
0.3938940167,
0.1820179671,
-0.1460289955,
0.3475974798,
-0.2794318795,
-0.7238903642,
-0.6557998061,
-0.8972626925,
-0.493727684,
0.0354145505,
-0.6209978461,
0.3496550024,
-0.4205804765,
-0.1552185118,
0.102649048,
0.2311437875,
-0.7751566768,
0.1751460731,
-0.1881671995,
1.2714499235,
-0.5959517956,
0.834180057,
0.2880435884,
-0.448089689,
-0.8670002818,
-0.1553835571,
-0.1387503147,
-0.7285367846,
0.5258877873,
0.2624030113,
-0.1437812001,
0.1907681674,
-0.5460630059,
-0.7925508022,
1.1244375706,
0.4693543911,
-0.5534971952,
-0.1813193262,
0.3467735052,
0.350271374,
0.0993084908,
-0.1476493329,
0.708425045,
0.4426130056,
-0.020084504,
-0.7443193793,
-0.098928757,
-0.0324172005,
-0.0114136999,
0.0866780505,
-0.4090545774,
0.2679656148,
-0.4980507791,
0.0701494589,
0.3915283978,
0.8522637486,
0.2778634429,
0.2463593483,
0.3549214005,
0.8458348513,
0.8552299142,
0.0407477133,
0.9913300872,
-0.1481316239,
0.3170877695,
1.0990732908,
-0.1573151946,
1.1098629236,
0.7006929517,
-0.1222116947,
0.3900326788,
0.7517014146,
-0.0086395722,
0.6569488645,
0.2531278133,
-0.3064567447,
-0.2325176597,
-0.3307600319,
-0.2864549458,
0.5164703131,
0.3974476457,
0.2330985963,
-0.2351280302,
0.0815170035,
0.0093824612,
-0.0065384558,
-0.1391308457,
1.1528819799,
0.0630871505,
-0.8072625399,
0.6947130561,
0.0779755637,
0.7379606366,
-0.7025958896,
-0.0045015276,
-0.5872400999,
-0.0936339647,
-0.4553946555,
-0.7941744924,
0.2952269018,
0.3840609491,
-0.2788641155,
0.3220815361,
0.718660295,
-0.2402031273,
-0.2360224873,
0.1796894073,
0.5507830977,
0.1161403134,
-0.1044499204,
-0.3442957103,
-0.0482392795,
-0.4331810474,
-0.3738909364,
0.2400681674,
0.721324563,
-0.1159923077,
0.6136031151,
0.6427524686,
0.0213925485,
0.3926649392,
0.2403581738,
1.0365098715,
-0.8175447583,
-0.2037598789,
-0.740475893,
0.240596503,
-0.0939976797,
-0.5054598451,
0.517472446,
0.6310216188,
0.9675753713,
0.0264179707,
0.2365318388,
-0.1434670985,
0.5074396133,
-0.7032065988,
0.4231699109,
-0.2933543026,
0.0533981845,
-0.0924135894,
-1.0047700405,
-0.3129232228,
0.5920908451,
0.1848405004,
-0.2989205122,
0.4070357084,
1.179271698,
0.1322117895,
-0.0256518517,
0.4429295361,
0.0913137421,
0.0749861747,
0.324749887,
1.0430407524,
-0.515221715,
0.7922955155,
-0.6162409186,
0.036057055,
-0.0828475282,
-0.6488786936,
-0.5631198883,
-0.3890099227,
-0.1361026764,
-0.4086338282,
0.2643625736,
0.9700129628,
0.5623707175,
-0.7556664944,
0.1637627035,
0.1648495346,
0.1886453182,
0.0568960458,
-0.1929459274,
0.2366272956,
-0.5237398744,
-0.2526664734,
0.4158118069,
0.1091768444,
-0.1482290179,
-0.0205549356,
-0.1713401228,
-0.1024500057,
-0.1530448049,
0.7735587358,
0.1700358093,
-0.8919545412,
-0.3850103021,
0.2841374278,
-0.3789799809,
0.0071075042,
0.6409564018,
-0.8403006792,
0.0237576142,
0.430362612,
1.0383249521,
0.6497663856,
0.0059817145,
0.0565513335,
-0.7339788675,
0.0668154508,
0.1544488519,
0.0874044448,
0.5153909922,
-0.5441217422,
0.486895293,
0.2671196759,
-0.2954006791,
-0.4629293382,
-0.0192719586,
-0.9086624384,
-0.3123317957,
1.0458371639,
0.0651502982,
-0.2090978771,
-0.2929842472,
-0.0945914239,
0.1810577214,
-0.062508218,
0.6550959945,
0.7863366604,
-0.2148954868,
-0.136091426,
-0.5192215443,
0.5134294033,
0.2277968675,
-1.0884177685,
0.0551925302,
0.7600930929,
0.5795665383,
0.0294605233,
0.7689674497,
-0.1387698203,
0.5152870417,
0.0066978564,
-0.2607171237,
-0.0220358334,
-0.2924472988,
-0.0802375227,
0.1433803886,
0.6253661513,
-0.0942301303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14201v1 | Goat: Fine-tuned LLaMA Outperforms GPT-4 on Arithmetic Tasks | 2023-05-23T16:20:30 | 2023-05-23T16:20:30 | Tiedong Liu, Bryan Kian Hsiang Low | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce Goat, a fine-tuned LLaMA model that significantly outperforms
GPT-4 on a range of arithmetic tasks. Fine-tuned on a synthetically generated
dataset, Goat achieves state-of-the-art performance on BIG-bench arithmetic
sub-task. In particular, the zero-shot Goat-7B matches or even surpasses the
accuracy achieved by the few-shot PaLM-540B. Surprisingly, Goat can achieve
near-perfect accuracy on large-number addition and subtraction through
supervised fine-tuning only, which is almost impossible with previous
pretrained language models, such as Bloom, OPT, GPT-NeoX, etc. We attribute
Goat's exceptional performance to LLaMA's consistent tokenization of numbers.
To tackle more challenging tasks like large-number multiplication and division,
we propose an approach that classifies tasks based on their learnability, and
subsequently decomposes unlearnable tasks, such as multi-digit multiplication
and division, into a series of learnable tasks by leveraging basic arithmetic
principles. We thoroughly examine the performance of our model, offering a
comprehensive evaluation of the effectiveness of our proposed decomposition
steps. Additionally, Goat-7B can be easily trained using LoRA on a 24GB VRAM
GPU, facilitating reproducibility for other researchers. We release our model,
dataset, and the Python script for dataset generation. | [
-0.3436237872,
-1.0560686588,
0.2220704257,
0.3239703476,
-0.4418229461,
0.3096474111,
-0.2167297453,
-0.7697550058,
0.1991991252,
0.2412602305,
-0.3984690905,
-0.3291814029,
-0.8232375383,
0.0570325404,
-0.2887842655,
1.3466085196,
0.1883881837,
-0.1677684486,
-0.0331404768,
-0.1226434857,
-0.3970563114,
-0.4225136936,
-0.5514129996,
-0.5241273046,
0.4360877573,
0.4152392745,
0.8384760022,
0.8739746809,
0.7009105086,
0.3523118794,
0.0045903372,
0.489564091,
-0.6099153161,
-0.4321503043,
0.0026170411,
-0.2142624855,
-0.9423407316,
-0.0412456915,
0.4288962185,
0.6228094697,
-0.5009558797,
0.646694243,
-0.4663635492,
0.7606296539,
-0.3148379028,
0.4031178355,
-0.9367908835,
-0.1078637987,
-0.5545529127,
0.0573540367,
-0.0115180407,
-0.3539470732,
-0.4983961284,
-0.8556099534,
0.4716729522,
-0.2345838696,
0.5805565715,
0.6753139496,
-0.3284498453,
-0.212079227,
-0.4898365438,
0.6528089643,
-0.6637530327,
0.1979048848,
0.504109621,
0.1012745351,
-0.2514593005,
-0.6125535965,
-0.7047752142,
-0.2509511411,
0.3987746835,
-0.1322081536,
-0.1845239401,
-0.1174813658,
0.3929607272,
0.6476985216,
-0.2000044435,
-0.0652412102,
-0.4443047643,
-0.045428101,
0.4536780417,
0.229947865,
0.2386804521,
0.365976274,
-0.0977860764,
0.0617030449,
-0.8658466935,
0.302185297,
0.523291707,
0.1538152993,
0.2869057655,
0.7997983694,
-0.5536350608,
0.8164907694,
0.2636324465,
-0.3255986273,
0.2148978561,
-0.264965266,
-0.1804312617,
-0.0766489059,
0.4129863977,
0.073471278,
0.2683873773,
-0.1595446318,
-0.5441397429,
0.5756945014,
0.2834688723,
-1.0563219786,
-0.5535553694,
-0.1994390339,
0.0127409957,
-0.2040752321,
-0.3331512213,
-0.1600287855,
0.0048279539,
-0.3776655793,
0.702373147,
-0.2634739578,
-0.0058175442,
0.5116886497,
0.1392098516,
-0.0140347136,
0.3596393466,
-1.3044048548,
0.7011762261,
1.1933268309,
0.6216281652,
-0.2545936704,
-0.2206538767,
-0.8472830057,
0.0046531996,
-0.6446817517,
0.6905149221,
-0.6157282591,
-0.2948780358,
-0.4800510108,
-0.2404232472,
0.184332639,
-0.8069595695,
0.5527024865,
-0.843193531,
-0.5344976187,
-0.2689486146,
-0.3278548419,
-0.2949379683,
0.358273685,
-0.7080000639,
1.0943969488,
-0.0500286967,
-0.4014932811,
0.2223481834,
-0.721116364,
-0.6650945544,
-0.0357330143,
0.1860882938,
-0.512011826,
0.4038640559,
0.3167278767,
0.3347209394,
-0.4696112871,
0.0725092813,
-0.2498155534,
-0.5615196228,
0.1351583004,
-0.4537778199,
0.5135884285,
-0.0542782173,
-0.3151041567,
0.0055303345,
-0.9331148863,
0.0715543404,
0.0567781292,
-0.4897427857,
0.0476216264,
-0.0834450498,
-0.4121542275,
-0.082551904,
0.5991472602,
-0.7344833016,
0.1167736575,
-0.2964238524,
0.4734534323,
0.5014634728,
-0.2860741615,
0.1328701973,
-0.3095109165,
0.2806021273,
-0.2849478722,
0.094055891,
0.0301879253,
-0.6542053819,
-0.5015490651,
-0.4009394646,
0.2870225906,
0.6400798559,
-0.5419698954,
0.1781650931,
-0.2311956733,
-0.6164414287,
-0.2231057435,
0.4981239736,
0.5755900741,
0.7621996403,
0.4576815963,
-0.424996078,
0.1202903986,
-0.6323058605,
-0.152857855,
-0.0448614508,
0.1504763514,
-0.1216422468,
0.3860084713,
-0.3640159965,
0.3720636666,
-0.5372852087,
-0.2457491606,
-0.0012268842,
0.2547655404,
0.3914472163,
0.5652890801,
0.221273154,
-0.6799007058,
-0.187924087,
0.4008762538,
-0.4213103354,
-0.147287339,
0.2310505658,
-0.0709573701,
0.1109782904,
0.070214048,
-0.9325125813,
0.5720726848,
0.5473912954,
-0.2043945193,
0.5780791044,
-0.387129873,
0.0159055535,
-0.5994256735,
-0.2279536575,
-0.1591183841,
-0.1972000003,
-0.4920809865,
0.0240497869,
0.1836590618,
0.0626711994,
-0.0855536908,
0.1248158291,
-0.1576485783,
-0.3873541057,
-0.3480264843,
-0.3611339033,
-0.0572017245,
0.6694014072,
-0.0714165941,
0.9691442251,
0.2264160365,
-0.5276145339,
0.372361064,
0.2557360232,
-0.4930624962,
0.1182945892,
-0.9887511134,
0.2263826132,
0.3497726619,
0.18606022,
-0.7249215841,
-0.1945534348,
0.0561229028,
-0.4755523503,
0.3740088642,
0.1852123886,
-0.6036559343,
-0.1644386202,
-0.2848606408,
0.9097065926,
0.5091421604,
-0.5966355801,
0.3269873857,
0.5584496856,
-0.2489785552,
-0.8056491017,
-0.383867383,
0.0413438007,
-0.0150666516,
-0.422752738,
0.5442814231,
-0.1504434794,
-0.184843868,
-0.0149575677,
-0.3631471395,
-0.0092702778,
0.0776434913,
0.211038813,
0.4218505323,
-0.2032403499,
-0.0180001613,
-0.094154194,
-0.2739289999,
-0.0020684025,
-0.1139907092,
0.3166052103,
-0.4019922912,
-0.5773785114,
-0.2814101279,
-0.1415095329,
0.4173566103,
-0.5507351756,
0.2683276832,
0.8009555936,
-0.4828625023,
-0.1708481461,
-0.5222080946,
0.2807033658,
-0.4836096764,
0.4621061981,
-0.534083426,
-0.7565886974,
0.46257177,
-0.1219418496,
0.2803650796,
0.4151108861,
0.7033470869,
0.254440546,
1.0313699245,
0.6483262181,
-0.0562420636,
0.445563674,
-0.2515288889,
0.1405905634,
-0.6253198981,
-0.2300813347,
-0.2941429913,
-0.2693988383,
-0.5181832314,
-0.6526377201,
0.3135622144,
0.0585144721,
-0.5670005083,
0.1357145458,
-0.4064152837,
0.8096765876,
0.6060585976,
0.1979433298,
0.3652552962,
0.0279824026,
0.296839267,
0.1860335916,
-0.3109430075,
-0.406857878,
1.0584214926,
0.0912069455,
0.8080003858,
0.1927366555,
0.5442069173,
0.4000503719,
0.5503435731,
-0.8685140014,
0.5070226192,
-0.4895412028,
-0.5666934848,
-0.553660512,
-0.4423654675,
-0.673668623,
0.3051765859,
0.0405284166,
-0.4911920726,
-0.2735634446,
0.2295633554,
-0.3991129398,
0.3129136562,
-0.5605946779,
0.7503711581,
-0.2080832869,
-0.4125826061,
-0.6673097014,
-0.3618873358,
0.6530295014,
-0.4872378707,
0.1956086606,
-0.5289598107,
-0.3081796467,
0.519151032,
-0.8005515933,
0.8100862503,
0.054799322,
-0.2865130007,
0.2895361781,
0.2192507088,
0.5505474806,
0.0832029283,
-0.208346203,
0.4615396261,
-0.0190721713,
-0.7543839216,
-0.439117223,
0.7102560997,
-0.9422438741,
-0.733101368,
-0.209641546,
-0.5653967261,
-0.4172613025,
0.005364161,
-0.0568364374,
0.7680138946,
-0.1718765646,
-0.0706725195,
0.5031597614,
0.0101604396,
0.4871706367,
0.2532509267,
-0.0316444784,
-0.6405023932,
1.1948020458,
0.0582344979,
0.2250893265,
0.4158465862,
0.0582889467,
-0.4227720499,
-0.6148878932,
-0.9074465036,
0.20976834,
-0.4958698153,
-0.3594608903,
-0.140440613,
0.0761404783,
-0.049502492,
0.0098494226,
-0.3490887284,
-0.7607982755,
-0.2424264848,
-0.2243095487,
0.4227370322,
1.201974988,
-0.3442411125,
0.3444963098,
-0.7857163548,
0.8184064627,
0.7001706362,
0.2447902411,
-0.0983091593,
-0.783203721,
-0.2807949185,
0.0582338423,
-0.4561075866,
-0.2997847199,
0.3727090061,
0.4218131304,
0.2352249026,
0.2080781907,
-0.2226306349,
1.0159682035,
-0.8193743825,
0.5115770698,
0.2643922865,
-1.1187435389,
0.0085499175,
-0.5038949847,
0.0536191873,
0.3291846514,
0.0002674991,
0.0922840908,
0.1466587931,
-0.4057709575,
-0.4859658182,
0.6584321856,
0.0819409639,
0.2613247037,
0.0046282178,
0.3060189188,
0.3969765306,
0.3764159977,
-0.5613096952,
0.0520936809,
-0.2209197134,
-0.1827349216,
-0.4558157027,
-0.1498221457,
-0.1017471626,
-0.5085637569,
0.6318199039,
-0.1004704461,
-0.1386612505,
-0.2628890574,
-0.1382986307,
-0.3018422127,
-0.1570018977,
0.6899906993,
0.909203887,
-0.0032836187,
0.1082030311,
0.4741884768,
-0.8259772658,
0.0396982059,
0.2393555343,
0.1313355863,
-0.1791277826,
0.2647538781,
0.4405150115,
0.245745182,
-0.5895149708,
0.3821561635,
0.0313729756,
-0.1214100122,
-0.1724150181,
0.1426843256,
0.1149411052,
0.233711645,
0.3773895502,
0.2861845195,
0.0889362022,
-0.4939352274,
-0.0159899034,
0.5412322283,
0.1800233424,
-0.7943829894,
0.6868728399,
0.0430294462,
-0.3889618218,
0.3435915709,
-0.4037615657,
-0.4621691108,
0.8835142851,
0.7422314286,
0.4096981287,
-0.0338349976,
0.258544594,
0.1035776585,
0.2462139875,
-0.3275101781,
0.2426557392,
-0.4746293426,
-0.6300436258,
-0.763420701,
-0.9122456908,
-0.5639705658,
-0.2196417898,
-0.5425331593,
-0.1017828658,
-0.6586290598,
-0.1349417716,
0.3769903183,
0.3597211838,
-0.668522656,
0.2958749533,
0.0029794059,
0.6977843046,
-0.4990763962,
1.0288801193,
0.8113062382,
-0.1680422872,
-0.7782618403,
-0.2745766938,
-0.3985920548,
-1.2579016685,
0.760463953,
0.2106239945,
-0.4724824131,
0.1273199618,
-0.4537838101,
-0.8837445974,
0.9124347568,
0.538546443,
-0.443970561,
0.4648946226,
0.3454033434,
0.5374957919,
-0.0315735005,
0.0383711867,
0.6541649103,
0.2167679667,
0.413793385,
-1.1589076519,
-0.1158573627,
-0.3313454986,
-0.2445661426,
0.4667761624,
-0.9533746839,
1.2532615662,
-0.621394217,
0.1826965511,
0.0487133004,
0.6036996841,
0.235921517,
0.5520387888,
0.3979931176,
0.9558543563,
0.9526054263,
-0.0167503972,
0.8385384083,
-0.2061445564,
-0.0735108107,
0.8667618632,
-0.1514702141,
1.0847760439,
0.0624539405,
-0.4583639801,
0.4408996403,
0.7091019154,
0.4215524793,
0.5154774785,
0.2793329954,
-0.5088490844,
-0.4905289412,
0.0873558894,
-0.2293225527,
0.4627649486,
0.5657689571,
0.4672674835,
-0.0448239297,
-0.4494086802,
-0.2497480363,
-0.0835206285,
-0.8180058002,
0.7471215129,
0.052551344,
-0.6216962934,
0.696316421,
0.0301064793,
0.6565651298,
-0.4977281392,
-0.2638917863,
-0.284090817,
0.3963956833,
-0.2938778996,
-0.4790784121,
0.216989696,
0.1368483007,
-0.1471457183,
0.1146623716,
0.6806707382,
-0.2275191247,
-0.8013772368,
-0.2922934592,
0.407070756,
0.2361399382,
-0.1403119415,
-0.4907632172,
0.1465708017,
-0.035522487,
-0.0984386206,
0.3933967948,
0.9595295191,
-0.3173089027,
0.6521615386,
1.0418344736,
0.225110963,
0.2310909182,
-0.0457999445,
0.9610899687,
-0.8371888399,
-0.2732013464,
-0.9510197043,
-0.0438784435,
0.2323505133,
-0.4020700157,
0.4324704409,
0.5889995694,
0.9000046253,
-0.0687518045,
0.3738079667,
0.2723081112,
0.3747372925,
-0.2801593244,
0.2042417526,
-0.4722167253,
0.2392500639,
0.0163648296,
-0.8431448936,
-0.3209729791,
0.4959057868,
-0.2762127519,
-0.0659018457,
0.247114554,
0.7585599422,
-0.1407097727,
0.0875377506,
0.4127278626,
-0.1981797218,
0.1980261058,
0.5669339895,
0.8599296808,
-0.1748623103,
0.6900807023,
-0.1840895563,
-0.3193736076,
-0.0233389549,
-0.8260370493,
-0.7971683145,
-0.2044747621,
-0.1328502297,
0.3232713044,
-0.0624283552,
0.7920301557,
0.5588759184,
-0.6643448472,
-0.1184379011,
-0.0723210126,
0.0619507097,
-0.1771306098,
-0.0044443212,
0.3178861439,
-0.4170413315,
-0.7671467066,
0.3143145442,
0.3266058862,
0.039617762,
0.0441751406,
0.0102837272,
0.4090293646,
0.0384366512,
0.7700363994,
0.4548554718,
-0.7049048543,
-0.0961982906,
-0.0493456982,
0.0472289883,
0.0196527429,
0.5479558706,
-0.7441290617,
0.2174801975,
0.1757564843,
1.15922153,
0.704110384,
0.4763680398,
0.2696293294,
-0.3356672525,
0.0211867504,
-0.0344206654,
0.2095075846,
0.4354431331,
-0.2711433768,
0.7310385108,
0.1445081532,
-0.7854398489,
-0.640625596,
-0.0314622521,
-0.9967294931,
-0.0356709622,
1.0397228003,
-0.1365132481,
-0.3251059353,
0.0930410996,
-0.3133997321,
0.2002650797,
-0.3789277077,
1.030184865,
0.4204517603,
-0.3772469461,
0.5465541482,
-0.6968944073,
0.5596128106,
0.4963979721,
-0.6974064708,
0.0668187141,
0.6294562817,
0.3852162659,
0.0892542377,
0.6459497213,
-0.0036283189,
0.4548906684,
0.0783771649,
-0.0660982653,
-0.4062312841,
-0.1563115567,
0.0123580946,
0.1310174316,
0.2857671082,
-0.5386955738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14200v1 | Accessing Higher Dimensions for Unsupervised Word Translation | 2023-05-23T16:19:30 | 2023-05-23T16:19:30 | Sida I. Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | The striking ability of unsupervised word translation has been demonstrated
with the help of word vectors / pretraining; however, they require large
amounts of data and usually fails if the data come from different domains. We
propose coocmap, a method that can use either high-dimensional co-occurrence
counts or their lower-dimensional approximations. Freed from the limits of low
dimensions, we show that relying on low-dimensional vectors and their
incidental properties miss out on better denoising methods and useful world
knowledge in high dimensions, thus stunting the potential of the data. Our
results show that unsupervised translation can be achieved more easily and
robustly than previously thought -- less than 80MB and minutes of CPU time is
required to achieve over 50\% accuracy for English to Finnish, Hungarian, and
Chinese translations when trained on similar data; even under domain mismatch,
we show coocmap still works fully unsupervised on English NewsCrawl to Chinese
Wikipedia and English Europarl to Spanish Wikipedia, among others. These
results challenge prevailing assumptions on the necessity and superiority of
low-dimensional vectors, and suggest that similarly processed co-occurrences
can outperform dense vectors on other tasks too. | [
-0.5997902155,
-0.3736367524,
0.3731861413,
0.3721904159,
-0.5034854412,
0.1080763265,
-0.3872840106,
-0.5893957019,
0.3021309078,
0.3751761019,
-0.2966162264,
-0.6710426211,
-0.8372526169,
-0.0860562697,
-0.5088706613,
0.6646410823,
-0.1058872417,
0.0065643699,
-0.652502954,
-0.3646554053,
-0.2473206222,
-0.8194659352,
-0.1910421699,
-0.2579284906,
0.3113586903,
0.5949280858,
0.5754841566,
0.3374269009,
0.8266625404,
0.2185719162,
0.1630426943,
0.5257850289,
-0.626357317,
-0.4247855246,
-0.0803392902,
-0.28784284,
-0.4831276536,
0.4632160962,
0.4466414452,
1.1064816713,
0.0226707235,
0.0790987015,
0.1846825182,
0.5763327479,
-0.4866114259,
0.1818116158,
-0.5601752996,
0.347887367,
-0.1968895048,
-0.4587594867,
-0.3381818533,
-0.0823597088,
0.0565408058,
-1.0999447107,
0.4195880592,
0.1603041291,
0.6718904972,
0.3355300426,
-0.3772081435,
-0.1795096844,
-0.9490616322,
0.9441388845,
-0.3641448915,
0.5441268682,
0.5245563984,
0.0747975558,
-0.4145658612,
-0.7394375801,
-0.6525591612,
0.0962434262,
-0.1385566294,
0.2960114777,
-0.2910390198,
-0.2514272332,
0.3290124536,
0.4677308798,
-0.4199919403,
0.2402921468,
-0.2447952032,
-0.2735525966,
0.6567264199,
-0.1003175527,
0.3685098588,
-0.1170368865,
-0.631944418,
-0.3446229994,
-0.5663727522,
0.0877308771,
0.0543488599,
0.2436794043,
-0.2356397063,
0.5979835987,
-0.1555841565,
0.4055567682,
-0.0936391875,
-0.0944647267,
0.2899660766,
-0.1668677181,
0.0496725813,
-0.0515606962,
0.579257071,
0.5169490576,
0.0729656816,
-0.3990043104,
0.1498966515,
0.1158482954,
0.2061789483,
-0.7100963593,
-0.1650485694,
0.0440490209,
-0.2506409287,
0.1001922488,
0.0531755313,
-0.8031554222,
-0.1269584149,
-0.2336071432,
0.4218498468,
-0.342061311,
0.1362155527,
0.2084947228,
-0.2453384697,
0.000991557,
0.3195870519,
-0.6182226539,
0.2070290297,
0.6716359258,
0.9571034908,
-0.60867697,
-0.5485963225,
-0.7506927848,
0.1098934487,
-0.6437776685,
0.7414987683,
-0.5302655697,
-0.2982984781,
-0.0859607831,
-0.1557282507,
-0.0450474471,
-0.5355497599,
0.5718311667,
-0.5170259476,
0.0683622956,
-0.468890667,
-0.4732117951,
-0.3113170862,
0.0907009542,
-0.4920053184,
0.9467729926,
0.0940306038,
-0.6923694015,
0.4199047983,
-0.417078197,
-0.5988041759,
0.1438314915,
-0.1573483497,
-0.300290525,
0.5060433745,
0.5076451302,
0.473204881,
-0.1702542305,
-0.1845242977,
-0.1510938257,
-0.3244786561,
-0.0768853351,
-0.4369234741,
0.7997480035,
0.1023961008,
-0.0316724628,
-0.4178729951,
-0.6983963847,
-0.0518660396,
0.1865175813,
-0.5085957646,
-0.9019248486,
0.0711727664,
-0.1627821326,
0.2920754254,
0.3195045888,
-0.6599239111,
0.2254834622,
-0.3317624331,
0.2805456221,
0.2051736414,
-0.0805177167,
0.6452465057,
0.1261322647,
0.4147092998,
0.4650141597,
-0.0821149498,
0.1146961749,
-0.6143351793,
-0.6590652466,
-0.2850080132,
0.1489989758,
0.3788155019,
-1.0553617477,
0.5218008757,
-0.7031924725,
-0.5223922133,
-0.5090097189,
0.1786805391,
0.1454615146,
0.4132686555,
0.8750187159,
-0.6466957927,
-0.3508409858,
-0.5157846808,
-0.2934449911,
0.0652570575,
-0.0861729383,
0.2154711336,
0.4097907543,
-0.264547497,
0.557943821,
-0.7179490924,
-0.7720071673,
-0.0830594748,
0.3665010929,
-0.0618410446,
0.406758666,
0.5465192199,
-0.6409806013,
-0.4404238462,
0.1573640108,
-0.6963924766,
0.0141097596,
-0.0518049188,
-0.1802887619,
0.0569159091,
0.7347912788,
-0.4769248664,
0.7197434902,
0.9757204652,
-0.0915583372,
-0.1076641604,
-0.7848598957,
-0.0299030505,
-1.2538850307,
-0.0669056773,
-0.2644182444,
-0.2720113993,
-0.5819211006,
0.0880453438,
-0.0560222529,
-0.2149266303,
-0.4648690224,
0.1450450271,
-0.5960941315,
-0.3504911959,
-0.1869816631,
0.4045749605,
0.1169979051,
0.5583435297,
0.0592662208,
0.6429837942,
0.1444832385,
-0.6490406394,
0.4687262774,
0.7383391857,
-0.6608021259,
0.5742537379,
-0.1878129691,
0.2303735465,
-0.0805558413,
0.1808289587,
-0.7095557451,
-0.0176650342,
-0.1240320802,
-0.507964313,
0.1883531064,
0.1128430367,
-0.3026276827,
-0.3889575005,
-0.2625065744,
0.3758543134,
0.2472479939,
-0.9558295608,
0.1685786098,
0.7266085744,
0.1783123165,
-0.5606003404,
-0.6849364042,
0.3447697461,
0.0721011311,
-0.3560365736,
0.3902084529,
-0.0751618519,
0.2042305321,
-0.0808957592,
-0.0261081588,
-0.1021293029,
0.0900347009,
0.2229503691,
-0.0607142374,
-0.0516788922,
-0.0635354742,
0.0868887901,
-0.2265066803,
-0.1390751749,
-0.4386900067,
0.7074368596,
0.1464656591,
-0.4428245127,
-0.2415654361,
0.635258019,
0.6683828235,
-0.3387699723,
0.5902971625,
0.8060283065,
-0.5968654156,
-0.2171577364,
-0.0692000836,
0.1011617482,
-0.3811545968,
0.4633587301,
-0.2797684968,
-0.6936932206,
0.2183742672,
-0.1640039533,
0.0867722481,
0.5935139656,
0.3797823489,
-0.2185518593,
0.9851551056,
0.8379193544,
-0.2622909546,
0.1892777979,
-0.5666875243,
0.6339492798,
-0.8825377226,
-0.2408715039,
-0.5364124775,
-0.5872203708,
-0.757617712,
-0.8291938305,
0.4553504288,
0.1363366693,
0.4674400687,
0.6508290172,
-0.2824359536,
0.3193973303,
0.7403411865,
-0.1749379635,
0.4511457086,
0.6213573813,
-0.272498101,
-0.3651258349,
-0.8522193432,
-0.0459947325,
0.602558434,
0.0025178923,
0.6035051346,
-0.1180566996,
0.4617120326,
0.1333795637,
-0.0006139448,
-0.9708682895,
0.5454329252,
-0.79786551,
-0.241790548,
-0.5388544798,
-0.2907986045,
-1.1237641573,
0.3800921738,
-0.469928056,
-0.2339204103,
0.7286238074,
0.0488658957,
-0.1705383062,
0.3878480494,
-0.6879816055,
0.6310040951,
-0.1229500771,
0.0560490265,
-0.4297126532,
-0.2534073293,
-0.0331809521,
-0.2860997617,
0.2926670611,
-0.180438295,
-0.0645055324,
0.7787870169,
-0.5203739405,
0.750340879,
-0.0571805462,
-0.2671634257,
0.0983032659,
0.0250461791,
0.4045523107,
-0.0430171564,
0.2456716448,
0.8844030499,
0.0871765167,
-0.4769082367,
-0.5417253971,
0.762921989,
-0.9270471931,
-0.4245019257,
-0.4123369455,
-0.9100351334,
-0.2064234912,
0.1857943684,
0.7296444178,
0.3112562597,
-0.3461604714,
0.3125450611,
0.2720068693,
-0.356295526,
0.4738017023,
0.5355743766,
-0.0934998021,
-0.180947572,
1.2896339893,
0.4660422504,
-0.0382739827,
0.656619668,
0.1746678501,
-0.1168925241,
-0.7433519959,
-0.3579737842,
0.0700678602,
-0.4900888801,
-0.1289102584,
-0.6960446239,
-0.2588697076,
-0.382820636,
-0.2117570341,
-0.5225020647,
-0.5499759316,
-0.1713042855,
0.0781331882,
0.1451877803,
0.5586568117,
-0.5071950555,
0.1258559525,
-0.8160347342,
0.5953533649,
0.4038871527,
0.1282940358,
-0.1912236661,
-0.6543083787,
-0.6370511055,
0.0997812897,
-0.1457520574,
-0.3555796742,
0.643669188,
0.3071433306,
0.3918043971,
0.4255611002,
0.294000417,
0.9923088551,
-0.7581233382,
0.629830718,
0.1694072336,
-0.7478476763,
0.3236336112,
0.0716784447,
0.4068806469,
0.3497450054,
0.66538167,
-0.7631442547,
-0.3838951886,
-0.4517768621,
-0.8226142526,
0.46786201,
0.0739197433,
0.2344413251,
-0.113017641,
0.2730283141,
0.1082677841,
0.1362137496,
-0.1047629714,
-0.1056714207,
-0.1888922155,
-0.0000249228,
-0.7546541095,
-0.2736617625,
-0.041149877,
-0.6166152358,
0.3948777318,
-0.1131449863,
0.3971603513,
0.2366393954,
-0.5437804461,
-0.3074393272,
0.00346494,
0.6700351238,
0.5044981241,
-0.0140499026,
0.5602729321,
0.3356561065,
-1.0510191917,
0.0170608219,
0.0341888405,
-0.188819021,
0.1524489373,
0.5458772779,
0.5841813087,
0.0542676672,
-0.2275773883,
0.8636044264,
-0.0867365524,
-0.1140311137,
-0.2060193717,
-0.2003716677,
0.1112210751,
0.0389614254,
0.0968975127,
0.2760821283,
-0.1083859503,
-0.4729579985,
0.1083976552,
0.4825377762,
-0.4834091961,
-0.6435910463,
0.6457805037,
0.2393284142,
-0.2146731019,
0.5975388885,
-0.0402122512,
-0.4916611612,
0.1924281269,
0.4891991317,
0.6387589574,
-0.2846047282,
0.2220571637,
0.3234561086,
0.5245903134,
-0.1532630771,
0.2301246226,
-0.0125746671,
-0.9154843092,
-0.4452919364,
-0.6194800735,
-0.252040565,
0.3808037043,
-0.7374823689,
0.0731787309,
-0.2538715005,
0.1154044196,
0.0261389036,
0.0760450363,
-0.8974629045,
0.149655953,
0.0784853846,
0.9496418834,
-0.8147464395,
0.9402833581,
0.715903759,
-0.1340568662,
-0.3012725711,
0.0917633548,
-0.3285811543,
-1.0011624098,
0.4684031606,
-0.0503106043,
-0.2397459,
0.2192608416,
-0.5705397129,
-0.8471519947,
0.9128315449,
0.4542605579,
-0.6404528618,
0.0573241189,
0.6730307341,
0.8166827559,
-0.3229764402,
-0.525852859,
0.5279218554,
0.3183010221,
0.0226239301,
-0.4437213242,
-0.2039547414,
0.0254169535,
0.1093018875,
-0.0803803056,
-0.4993053079,
0.7121927738,
-0.3670199513,
-0.3075772524,
-0.2047820091,
0.9126311541,
-0.4604607224,
0.3136286438,
0.512579143,
0.8371596932,
0.8624310493,
0.0407383367,
1.0064512491,
-0.3003243804,
0.3071197867,
1.0532670021,
0.0120766582,
1.0874631405,
0.5574888587,
-0.051239837,
0.1024593264,
0.3601398468,
0.1563389748,
0.5499099493,
-0.1455762982,
-0.1513857096,
-0.5039100647,
-0.2630696893,
-0.2517032623,
0.8344453573,
0.3705306649,
0.1468275487,
-0.2588430047,
0.1678661406,
-0.188156873,
0.2741486132,
-0.1690939516,
0.5804005861,
0.445276767,
-0.3954255283,
0.6560204029,
0.0614632033,
0.4438110292,
-0.1246320903,
-0.062013153,
-0.46112746,
0.284122467,
-0.1461824328,
-0.5395610929,
0.3740151823,
-0.1288766414,
-0.0972555801,
-0.3257630169,
0.5261541009,
-0.5920777917,
-0.5748578906,
0.5246838331,
0.6002637744,
0.3707033694,
-0.0533690713,
-0.2076895386,
-0.1989389211,
-0.2407642007,
-0.0736488327,
0.3442389071,
0.5712733865,
-0.2582642436,
0.2628587186,
0.6531711817,
0.3539819419,
0.1606671214,
-0.2718630135,
0.6547734737,
-0.4701482058,
-0.4651349783,
-0.4664693177,
-0.1418979019,
-0.0681602582,
-0.1962432563,
0.8589642048,
0.6977490187,
1.3814418316,
-0.0472943373,
0.7325838804,
0.3021987975,
0.5376113653,
-0.332749486,
0.7497594953,
-0.6884449124,
0.0656709448,
0.002610618,
-0.9172959924,
-0.4414399862,
0.4836791456,
-0.3576007485,
-0.4849674106,
0.8373948932,
0.460675478,
-0.3185485899,
-0.2918289304,
0.8940243721,
0.3531619906,
0.2752493322,
0.5222236514,
0.6055229306,
-0.5808655024,
0.5558508635,
-0.4401886165,
-0.206614241,
-0.269361347,
-0.7949473858,
-1.0642073154,
-0.8720605969,
-0.1197217926,
-0.1198688149,
-0.3960470259,
0.7039447427,
0.5715614557,
-0.8515891433,
-0.0837750658,
0.1888601929,
0.135211423,
-0.3511632085,
-0.0429729819,
0.5277747512,
-0.15035595,
-0.9154551029,
0.5671963692,
0.5530551076,
0.1666640639,
-0.2226485461,
-0.0617245659,
-0.1569321603,
0.2356122881,
1.0366744995,
0.25306651,
-0.2414486706,
-0.5625756383,
-0.1298006326,
-0.2395206392,
0.2800618708,
0.9553211331,
-0.5832237005,
0.5121084452,
0.7729687095,
0.6489904523,
0.6266889572,
-0.2103141695,
0.4752720892,
-0.9447313547,
0.5486547947,
-0.1752945185,
0.2584633529,
0.4854924977,
-0.3119643033,
0.2745185196,
0.5986809134,
-0.1007953584,
-0.6186821461,
0.1722076684,
-0.9984325171,
-0.1310817003,
0.8715132475,
-0.2419962287,
-0.3009893894,
-0.2337759733,
0.1077744961,
0.3668655753,
0.0856338814,
1.062656641,
0.6472538114,
0.1813817918,
0.2316627353,
-0.6944824457,
0.6066204309,
0.2500644624,
-0.77469033,
-0.0172172934,
0.1515246332,
-0.0789261982,
0.5109283328,
0.5656605363,
-0.0970353708,
-0.0009554799,
-0.1301909089,
0.1320464164,
-0.0298676211,
-0.548299253,
-0.1752543896,
0.0481613651,
-0.1845253706,
-0.3580331206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14196v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14196v3 | ZeroSCROLLS: A Zero-Shot Benchmark for Long Text Understanding | 2023-05-23T16:15:31 | 2023-12-17T17:05:09 | Uri Shaham, Maor Ivgi, Avia Efrat, Jonathan Berant, Omer Levy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML | We introduce ZeroSCROLLS, a zero-shot benchmark for natural language
understanding over long texts, which contains only test and small validation
sets, without training data. We adapt six tasks from the SCROLLS benchmark, and
add four new datasets, including two novel information fusing tasks, such as
aggregating the percentage of positive reviews. Using ZeroSCROLLS, we conduct a
comprehensive evaluation of both open-source and closed large language models,
finding that Claude outperforms ChatGPT, and that GPT-4 achieves the highest
average score. However, there is still room for improvement on multiple open
challenges in ZeroSCROLLS, such as aggregation tasks, where models struggle to
pass the naive baseline. As the state of the art is a moving target, we invite
researchers to evaluate their ideas on the live ZeroSCROLLS leaderboard. | [
-0.1996826828,
-0.7638201118,
0.72795403,
0.2386792302,
-0.3175141513,
0.1176220626,
-0.4836402237,
-0.5128415823,
0.0948003083,
0.6662133336,
-0.649657011,
-0.7543175817,
-0.5445050597,
0.0343818814,
-0.8927548528,
1.5645840168,
-0.1967797875,
-0.298992604,
-0.4258493781,
-0.4145935774,
-0.4308423996,
-0.1295439005,
-0.2886738777,
-0.195086956,
0.7672402263,
0.4334322214,
0.4936619401,
0.5259897113,
0.607572794,
0.1340165436,
-0.1110922992,
-0.0402229391,
-0.7752664089,
0.3601665795,
-0.2628037632,
-0.3598440886,
-0.3261094689,
0.1128132194,
0.4855777621,
0.812562108,
0.0737525225,
0.1845247298,
-0.0350483023,
0.7488412857,
-0.7919327021,
0.1986955404,
-0.4435116053,
-0.0493111201,
-0.4256244004,
0.090563044,
-0.4210702479,
-0.5576295257,
0.0812656581,
-0.6994785666,
0.3031449914,
-0.1212549731,
0.7838928103,
0.1788459122,
-0.5664566755,
-0.5531566739,
-0.6048305631,
1.0507355928,
-0.4390948713,
0.4309851229,
0.3596846461,
0.3133761287,
0.0215042122,
-0.4740706682,
-0.6647388935,
-0.2329695523,
0.0471844263,
0.3703669906,
-0.1674439758,
-0.0271451883,
0.206456095,
0.6049345136,
-0.8920610547,
0.1841351241,
-0.3671830297,
0.0082627423,
0.5599355102,
-0.0633948073,
0.0861368179,
-0.1604525149,
-0.5047725439,
-0.133280158,
-0.3452722728,
0.0466998443,
-0.1198194325,
0.1029994413,
-0.3586071134,
0.625369966,
-0.6191210151,
0.9173668027,
-0.2798480988,
0.0983184576,
0.4528324008,
-0.3831127286,
-0.4318431914,
-0.0340536274,
0.88684237,
0.4065662324,
0.4058177471,
-0.4770612121,
-0.0601504371,
0.4443151057,
0.08521121,
-0.7992649674,
-0.0279896669,
0.2648892105,
-0.0761597008,
-0.3494077027,
-0.2277586013,
-0.6692736149,
-0.4012496769,
-0.220736295,
0.2640310824,
-0.7700505257,
0.1057424322,
0.4279435873,
-0.2616585195,
0.4223712683,
0.4062886834,
-0.80297786,
0.326526612,
1.0044265985,
0.9087492228,
-0.4373540878,
-0.4413058758,
-0.6129670143,
0.0478029698,
-0.5102319717,
1.1593526602,
-0.4718898535,
-0.3186748624,
0.0138554564,
-0.2395755798,
-0.1373180747,
-0.0696438178,
1.1644842625,
-0.1927324682,
0.5423019528,
-0.2047086507,
-0.8524083495,
-0.2149042338,
0.6108767986,
-0.3424116969,
1.0803039074,
0.0813215673,
-0.4613031745,
0.2453122139,
-0.9537828565,
-0.4309754074,
0.2900669873,
-0.1482954919,
-0.1649656147,
0.2796889246,
0.2648997307,
0.3767427802,
-0.2938090563,
0.0814951733,
-0.4820573032,
-0.4809615016,
0.1514371783,
-0.4591387212,
0.60431844,
0.1828308702,
-0.0235840362,
0.0511253364,
-0.5885105133,
0.3013336957,
-0.0314829238,
0.1369437128,
-0.2587651908,
-0.1032613292,
-0.1420105547,
0.0440878123,
0.1777140498,
-0.8074623942,
0.3026731312,
-0.301317215,
0.3975094259,
0.4760028124,
0.1310644746,
0.4618996978,
-0.2204698771,
0.2988489568,
-0.0579263046,
0.1524009258,
-0.7562391162,
-0.5208737254,
-0.8117006421,
-0.1649434119,
0.3728102148,
0.3646905124,
-0.7856332064,
0.3420391381,
-0.5776827931,
-0.8257380724,
-0.6369428635,
0.2632278502,
0.5282598138,
0.5493746996,
0.5186615586,
-0.4054428041,
0.0623778254,
-0.8237683177,
-0.546533823,
-0.038274806,
-0.3278999627,
-0.1154529303,
0.5601453781,
-0.1022663116,
0.9016437531,
-0.7206301093,
-0.6252161264,
0.0064575267,
0.6914975047,
0.3105465174,
0.1474577487,
0.4589755535,
-0.4053978026,
-0.6100873947,
0.0607735738,
-0.9915826321,
0.0766826496,
-0.193211779,
0.0562092997,
0.2026449442,
0.3589737117,
-0.6574512124,
0.3543611467,
0.643606782,
-0.3174470067,
0.2778621018,
-0.2253372371,
0.0868245512,
-0.6378298998,
-0.1597038954,
0.2558831573,
-0.0930922478,
-0.8624994159,
0.1069825664,
0.4905429184,
-0.1500106305,
-0.3879650235,
0.5484530926,
-0.4369258285,
0.0320515148,
-0.1628672779,
0.6625909209,
0.0792586356,
0.5822717547,
-0.0883306935,
0.5508290529,
0.5009096861,
-0.2088250071,
0.2152265161,
0.2160875797,
-0.5537567735,
0.8221338987,
-0.4933050573,
0.273721844,
-0.4055936038,
0.3483065069,
-0.998144567,
-0.0800678879,
-0.1625564396,
-0.6196466684,
0.1149742752,
0.0305859428,
-0.2897075713,
-0.4345958233,
-0.600217998,
0.1037152484,
0.5747224689,
-0.2481257617,
0.2458634526,
0.1817114949,
-0.0203838274,
-0.3667381406,
-0.6065063477,
0.2494358569,
0.1475381553,
-0.4350407124,
0.3539453745,
-0.153447926,
-0.0228430461,
0.0193683859,
-0.2425262928,
-0.1347125471,
-0.0487069599,
0.1956505775,
0.0877994522,
-0.2635778487,
0.1637296826,
-0.1536802948,
-0.3249265254,
-0.2793509364,
-0.2396827042,
0.2849285901,
-0.159848243,
-0.5183169246,
-0.3484456539,
0.1093624905,
0.7070472836,
-0.3415768743,
0.3873404264,
0.4531543851,
-0.1768040061,
-0.1578395218,
-0.7027416229,
0.1327354908,
-0.433016479,
0.2043205202,
-0.1857838333,
-1.0572934151,
0.1863688082,
0.3590169251,
0.3933486938,
0.4740697443,
0.3801108301,
-0.3333904147,
0.7786758542,
0.6336270571,
-0.2392163277,
0.1164261922,
0.0317353606,
0.3354526758,
-0.5340261459,
-0.0570327714,
-0.7599970102,
-0.2536745965,
-0.6929501295,
-0.7285219431,
0.0278897807,
0.1528865844,
-0.1041292995,
0.3899701834,
-0.547939539,
0.8335837126,
0.3387472332,
-0.2116449326,
0.3532815576,
-0.2732714713,
0.0823913813,
-0.0588543676,
-0.2906834781,
-0.2581041157,
0.9469061494,
0.2433485836,
0.5634565353,
-0.159176603,
0.5766348839,
0.3119744062,
0.5026408434,
-0.8450521827,
0.5469697118,
-0.2645049095,
-0.4644576311,
-0.41291219,
-0.4315633774,
-0.8608868718,
0.1408530176,
-0.0407482721,
-0.6536546946,
-0.2104422152,
-0.2195093483,
-0.250829488,
0.1734882295,
-0.7699103355,
0.9663134813,
-0.4172733724,
-0.3734207451,
-0.0633139387,
-0.3676332831,
0.3899777234,
-0.1027109623,
0.40208444,
-0.3653407991,
-0.0454519615,
0.8367563486,
-0.0079502854,
0.6340952516,
-0.1456059068,
0.0344142914,
0.2522864342,
0.2422084212,
0.2384512275,
-0.309384644,
-0.169055745,
0.3375906944,
0.0341255553,
-0.7118685842,
-0.7448759079,
0.9741973877,
-0.6032246947,
-0.1924153715,
-0.6019521356,
-0.3891657889,
-0.2252769023,
0.3925448656,
-0.0308614373,
0.1983505934,
-0.4182119071,
0.5218404531,
0.5712373257,
-0.1279110461,
0.5066425204,
0.7593895793,
-0.2321915925,
-0.194001615,
0.9944598079,
0.0939680114,
0.1900362074,
0.5189597011,
-0.0057994928,
-0.3142909706,
-0.6901052594,
-0.5281471014,
0.324950099,
-0.3841815889,
-0.1657000333,
-0.617607832,
-0.2238610685,
-0.3215788305,
-0.2723343372,
-0.4291889966,
-0.4349868596,
0.0465412028,
-0.1962906718,
0.3462076783,
0.916932404,
0.2515802383,
0.1931121796,
-0.7958107591,
0.4994552732,
0.1311775744,
0.8673811555,
-0.1907605678,
-0.4441128373,
-0.308712095,
0.0836584419,
-0.5332850814,
-0.6877717972,
0.2249457538,
-0.0170111507,
0.3152088225,
0.4858071208,
0.1575062573,
0.8655737638,
-0.4528632462,
0.9747707844,
0.4422879517,
-1.0203211308,
0.2192796171,
-0.6880452037,
0.7026413083,
0.8441846371,
0.4646773934,
-1.1295776367,
-0.4892699122,
-0.349108994,
-0.4922060668,
0.5431615114,
0.6309345961,
0.118055746,
-0.0604210384,
0.1843732893,
0.0870639756,
0.1110019907,
-0.6852428913,
0.0976124629,
-0.2148663253,
-0.2535552084,
-0.3214899898,
-0.2583557665,
0.2522680461,
-0.0624486208,
0.5265248418,
-0.24220182,
0.0390558988,
0.037449833,
-0.2474384457,
-0.087732479,
0.4073729515,
0.6707612872,
0.476587981,
-0.4312860668,
-0.1185965389,
0.2150511146,
-0.3801433146,
-0.2066886425,
-0.1250338554,
-0.2964588106,
-0.0288149472,
0.518276155,
0.8029896021,
0.5696806312,
-0.5380023122,
0.6298218369,
-0.2055593729,
-0.4978429675,
-0.142776683,
0.0478005894,
0.1385159492,
-0.3463025093,
0.3233181536,
-0.2331870347,
-0.2098006457,
-0.5917335749,
0.2977364063,
0.3605042398,
-1.0227667093,
-0.3240676522,
0.5406386256,
0.2344755828,
-0.4176134765,
0.7110326886,
-0.2544424236,
-0.2654913366,
0.2783186436,
0.1610332131,
0.8618312478,
0.0415676385,
0.3546931148,
0.2556042969,
0.31139642,
-0.178796038,
0.0080849594,
-0.3933146298,
-0.4636341035,
-0.8246634603,
-0.6600245833,
-0.8803278208,
-0.0087773101,
-0.7767755389,
0.5571393967,
-0.1350143105,
0.3422454298,
0.3521460593,
0.074112758,
-0.5031324625,
0.1598626822,
0.1315735281,
1.1047209501,
-0.7613158822,
1.0203678608,
0.1438014656,
-0.397020489,
-0.1874564439,
0.0534841791,
0.0172380395,
-0.7405587435,
0.1898490638,
0.4868775308,
0.1657722741,
-0.2221461087,
-0.3949686289,
-0.6476351023,
0.8671921492,
0.0506174788,
-0.601446569,
-0.2076235563,
0.2954214513,
0.8465024233,
-0.0663944781,
0.6886690855,
0.6610875726,
0.4799380004,
0.2063114196,
-0.851852715,
-0.4177379012,
-0.1317730099,
-0.4106707275,
0.4325978458,
-0.6272819638,
0.7783161998,
0.1296834201,
-0.2912190259,
0.1607717574,
0.6255733371,
-0.1144474074,
0.4466412067,
0.3641382456,
0.7654258609,
0.6630029678,
-0.2350859344,
1.2255684137,
-0.2269335836,
0.5716590285,
1.2627027035,
-0.6581628323,
0.969561398,
0.2570414841,
0.0080364952,
0.6686608195,
0.1774216741,
0.0250780191,
0.3038340807,
0.1974607706,
-0.0708061531,
-0.1387822032,
-0.0673315972,
-0.2709615529,
0.5335237384,
0.4006350935,
0.162362054,
-0.8452409506,
0.0062566772,
0.1231502146,
0.2433710545,
-0.118507199,
0.9179118276,
0.0069982912,
-1.0005962849,
0.7053835988,
-0.0545797944,
0.7204741836,
-0.827239275,
0.1556492001,
-0.3822064102,
0.262604028,
-0.1032705307,
-1.255382061,
0.3210975826,
0.385263294,
-0.0107179107,
-0.6505439878,
0.5597853661,
-0.2388806939,
-0.5957804918,
0.453764379,
0.408852607,
0.2352990806,
-0.2074101865,
-0.5636621714,
0.090733245,
0.1257911921,
-0.1866498888,
0.4933224618,
0.5720892549,
-0.2178064287,
0.4693626761,
0.8184111118,
-0.1095245034,
-0.2742950022,
-0.0276130028,
0.6879380345,
-1.034812808,
-0.3983900249,
-0.8817358613,
0.2714743316,
-0.4299042821,
-0.4623002112,
1.1080080271,
0.7751132846,
0.8335801959,
0.2507432103,
0.5912179351,
0.2832446992,
0.9683150649,
-0.16859743,
0.867526114,
-0.3874799609,
-0.1010487974,
-0.1543668509,
-0.8060100079,
-0.5415438414,
0.3410888612,
-0.5707584023,
-0.395093888,
0.8557533026,
0.4617941976,
-0.1039561704,
0.4467995167,
0.4877072275,
0.3461125195,
0.4489119947,
0.6661812663,
0.6080485582,
-0.4075285196,
0.6899756193,
-0.175268665,
-0.2323186547,
0.0097245164,
-1.0563300848,
-0.9226211309,
-0.4259991944,
-0.2272838652,
-0.1268066466,
0.0234743766,
0.4126045108,
0.5053764582,
-0.8301692009,
-0.3489668965,
-0.0725831017,
0.2596581876,
-0.0818408281,
-0.2226942331,
0.2342081815,
-0.5924596786,
-0.5898364186,
0.4496834874,
0.6874449253,
-0.2280385643,
-0.1220529601,
0.1268040538,
-0.045666676,
0.2054918855,
0.772996664,
0.4315540791,
-0.4208674431,
-0.3425834477,
0.2881102562,
-0.1233590841,
0.0901124701,
0.6965013742,
-0.8765437603,
0.5118342638,
0.4587441981,
0.6184088588,
1.0566651821,
-0.1032813936,
0.2057958841,
-0.5055938959,
0.0978624821,
0.2992213666,
0.0495895594,
0.2697803378,
0.1360574663,
0.6513962746,
-0.0414104573,
-0.5669385791,
-1.1096264124,
0.1526284814,
-1.1938308477,
-0.2487000078,
0.8228339553,
-0.0209242739,
-0.4928833544,
-0.1222917587,
0.1218968928,
-0.1147048473,
-0.3312806189,
0.7348878384,
0.7543491721,
-0.1756068021,
0.0557292476,
-0.7000454664,
0.257751435,
0.5671561956,
-0.8896160126,
0.2676683366,
0.4274537861,
0.1691471338,
0.2956569493,
0.7684980631,
-0.0788257271,
0.1351224631,
-0.2826373875,
-0.0593972877,
0.1498162448,
-0.1711367965,
-0.4288309216,
0.3117119968,
-0.174169004,
-0.0476994179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14195v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14195v3 | HumBEL: A Human-in-the-Loop Approach for Evaluating Demographic Factors of Language Models in Human-Machine Conversations | 2023-05-23T16:15:24 | 2024-02-05T17:28:07 | Anthony Sicilia, Jennifer C. Gates, Malihe Alikhani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While demographic factors like age and gender change the way people talk, and
in particular, the way people talk to machines, there is little investigation
into how large pre-trained language models (LMs) can adapt to these changes. To
remedy this gap, we consider how demographic factors in LM language skills can
be measured to determine compatibility with a target demographic. We suggest
clinical techniques from Speech Language Pathology, which has norms for
acquisition of language skills in humans. We conduct evaluation with a domain
expert (i.e., a clinically licensed speech language pathologist), and also
propose automated techniques to complement clinical evaluation at scale.
Empirically, we focus on age, finding LM capability varies widely depending on
task: GPT-3.5 mimics the ability of humans ranging from age 6-15 at tasks
requiring inference, and simultaneously, outperforms a typical 21 year old at
memorization. GPT-3.5 also has trouble with social language use, exhibiting
less than 50% of the tested pragmatic skills. Findings affirm the importance of
considering demographic alignment and conversational goals when using LMs as
public-facing tools. Code, data, and a package will be available. | [
-0.4964824915,
-0.8304944634,
0.3441548645,
0.0840330124,
0.0847882628,
0.3259080946,
-0.2502680719,
-0.3992153406,
-0.3626533747,
0.6412887573,
-0.6154824495,
-0.5203288794,
-0.3619463742,
-0.1481045038,
-0.0476584658,
0.5977067351,
0.1555184722,
0.2766335607,
-0.4814206064,
-0.0542894751,
-0.5585041046,
-0.6907021403,
-0.4543187916,
-0.6335787177,
0.3799625933,
0.6196838617,
0.8725433946,
0.6409335732,
0.470449239,
0.2988597155,
-0.2485756725,
-0.1775174141,
-0.467207849,
0.0117347632,
-0.1764585823,
-0.2759529054,
-0.682299614,
0.1846053302,
0.5214314461,
1.2991492748,
-0.3846660554,
0.2006368339,
-0.0395194888,
0.7826400995,
-0.2616411448,
-0.0130454097,
-0.5258746147,
-0.2401259542,
-0.2730653882,
-0.2443558574,
-0.1336423308,
-0.5565574169,
0.3227037489,
-0.2359420508,
0.3885214925,
0.0767597109,
0.5570331812,
0.1600982994,
-0.391902864,
-0.2770343721,
-0.6611639857,
0.7272218466,
-0.7558947206,
0.4844372272,
1.1805042028,
0.3975359499,
-0.3449563384,
-0.3476799428,
-0.3232098818,
-0.7817964554,
0.0541321523,
-0.3291840553,
-0.210031569,
0.0081183193,
0.3332214355,
0.0416463092,
-0.925006032,
0.1034826189,
-0.8039337397,
-0.3414225578,
0.5825267434,
0.2115460187,
0.4665758908,
0.0349716023,
-0.0123275137,
0.0792992488,
-0.5724014044,
-0.1406868398,
0.5559570193,
0.3105205595,
-0.1818039119,
0.3818489909,
-0.1114171296,
0.7712586522,
0.08340092,
-0.2742639482,
0.2161664218,
-0.1641802043,
-0.0291702449,
-0.0801525712,
0.4530321658,
0.0199309029,
0.6892386079,
-0.2337830961,
0.0957922488,
-0.0723647475,
0.6153351665,
-0.4814134538,
-0.0999040976,
0.0437144004,
-0.5463083982,
-0.0574446321,
-0.1525445133,
-0.8877732158,
-0.5805190802,
-0.3493830562,
0.150312081,
-0.3261121809,
0.0816500783,
0.0954631343,
0.0982855037,
0.1535346061,
0.0924254656,
-0.7446137071,
0.3336901069,
0.3901702166,
0.4397372901,
0.0436089858,
-0.3728834093,
-0.4241150916,
-0.0173022971,
-0.1939005405,
0.6226893067,
-0.5206541419,
-0.6213631034,
0.2052482218,
-0.0607702546,
-0.145033747,
-0.7983214855,
0.5489178896,
-0.4828001261,
0.4910002351,
-0.0029178441,
-0.3775024414,
0.0162658617,
-0.1210988462,
-0.3794667721,
0.776990056,
0.4446232021,
-0.6428974867,
0.3825652003,
-0.5511365533,
-0.4891901314,
0.3644915223,
0.0051848474,
-0.3907072246,
-0.0751476362,
0.2142342478,
0.1298826635,
-0.4103316367,
0.4768551886,
-0.5189335942,
-0.4108483493,
0.4532167614,
-0.3470226526,
0.9809117913,
0.2571291625,
-0.1204319075,
0.2746011615,
-0.6761502624,
-0.0709819272,
0.0436414555,
-0.3664112687,
0.0948891863,
0.0883692503,
-0.0289041717,
0.0813487172,
0.0158228055,
-0.3158534169,
0.044855956,
-0.2951968014,
0.4987478852,
0.3467342257,
-0.0634219944,
0.421590358,
-0.5404902697,
0.8330383301,
-0.3056521118,
0.2805992961,
-0.1700580716,
-0.6354073286,
-0.6458073854,
-0.0477443673,
0.1539790034,
0.5552344918,
-0.4641947746,
0.7578139901,
-0.1130248383,
-0.6252647042,
-0.566398263,
0.4050216675,
0.3590948582,
0.3139130771,
0.1347094029,
-0.6446698308,
-0.4665816128,
-0.9253134727,
-0.2614875734,
-0.6703596115,
-0.1087394282,
0.3739876747,
0.4476886988,
-0.5296355486,
1.0113412142,
-0.2306757867,
-0.2693261504,
-0.2891194224,
0.4576634467,
-0.0199436229,
0.4925059676,
0.2877665162,
-0.4300409257,
-0.0616044663,
0.1050589904,
-0.6288815737,
-0.4887093306,
0.2088412344,
0.0319362804,
0.1361269653,
0.3776876032,
-0.351159364,
0.5482159853,
0.5026744008,
-0.4799602032,
0.5157337785,
-0.4740202427,
0.1433315426,
-0.3796889782,
0.193535611,
0.288217634,
-0.2732191384,
-0.8850424886,
-0.2023799419,
-0.0921672657,
-0.548842907,
-0.2717717588,
0.5290305018,
-0.4973231852,
-0.169272393,
-0.2734112442,
0.1682457179,
-0.5020025373,
0.3022068739,
-0.3302870095,
0.9527623653,
0.2972339988,
-0.4398815036,
0.0967008024,
0.2920512557,
-0.5185998678,
0.7146784067,
-0.663782239,
0.7109520435,
-0.2877394259,
0.2224420458,
-0.9173087478,
-0.4448212087,
0.1600086242,
-0.7152392268,
0.1952557266,
0.0696399584,
-0.0091786375,
-0.6653338671,
0.0072745364,
0.2660528123,
0.6936872602,
0.2591926157,
0.5583484769,
0.6884988546,
-0.5897125602,
-0.2665563822,
-0.3474435806,
0.2153170705,
-0.3860218525,
-0.7947403193,
0.0183714032,
-0.1050826162,
-0.4141550064,
-0.2774980366,
0.0077319075,
-0.4390454292,
0.3170906603,
0.1367150098,
0.2465009242,
-0.1523416936,
0.158749193,
-0.2827526331,
-0.1952698231,
0.0223276652,
-0.0806502625,
0.7164267302,
-0.1460503489,
-0.5319182277,
-0.6013307571,
0.192585364,
0.6014565229,
-0.018447455,
0.5757597685,
0.6290831566,
-0.4111291468,
0.2532264292,
-0.7686705589,
-0.1849659085,
-0.3608994186,
0.3534369767,
-0.1653256118,
-0.8660196066,
0.427198559,
0.0445274748,
-0.2344312668,
0.0881485939,
0.8997117877,
-0.3759865761,
0.8894935846,
0.6672324538,
-0.0002267361,
0.3526256382,
0.1797811836,
0.0266641434,
-0.5731708407,
-0.1594624519,
-0.8502616882,
-0.1452522129,
-0.3258986175,
-0.5014976263,
0.1525584757,
0.1111634672,
-0.5773826241,
0.3237245083,
-0.0615972206,
0.1930680573,
0.4351314604,
0.0679528937,
0.1888077259,
-0.1217793822,
0.1533376575,
-0.2271741182,
-0.5590688586,
-0.7860543132,
0.8609619737,
0.729875803,
0.8337448835,
-0.0116802473,
0.4364116788,
0.8321229219,
0.6892115474,
-0.6043035388,
0.5875554681,
0.0035074751,
-1.015681982,
-0.464692831,
-0.4940925539,
-1.0530716181,
0.0926440507,
-0.0249420162,
-1.1696971655,
0.2975317538,
0.2027387619,
-0.2217177004,
-0.1684154421,
-0.6896858215,
0.886654675,
-0.2633117437,
-0.2254142314,
-0.2424061894,
-0.8489091992,
0.2611879706,
-0.3900088668,
0.3854334056,
-0.4504523575,
0.1655556858,
0.8520236611,
0.0092123533,
1.0408127308,
-0.2671251595,
-0.1543527842,
0.2096366733,
0.0826520771,
0.0633833855,
-0.3364675939,
0.0082542067,
0.175266996,
0.0948659927,
-0.5419859886,
-0.4282577336,
0.2901104093,
-0.9353381395,
-0.8090741634,
-0.2558132708,
-0.6865919828,
-0.5727548003,
-0.1858581305,
-0.1360002756,
0.3832004964,
-0.5477454662,
0.4139644802,
0.2644168437,
-0.4133743942,
-0.014660948,
0.4448614419,
-0.3532409668,
-0.5112355351,
0.6939793229,
-0.0846426636,
0.4543236792,
-0.1323847622,
0.3169020712,
-0.2824981213,
-0.286741823,
-0.4353244007,
0.5539101362,
-0.7871668339,
0.1549028605,
-0.5950086713,
-0.0275646616,
-0.4851512313,
-0.0382190235,
0.1505605578,
-0.011739214,
-0.2443199605,
0.3477217853,
-0.072029762,
0.6355112195,
0.0851669759,
0.7259876132,
-0.8503674269,
0.2333787978,
0.4682520032,
0.0312045328,
-0.0258579459,
-0.9400312304,
-0.2076950371,
0.046000801,
-0.4779878855,
-1.0993032455,
0.4052500725,
0.2745751143,
0.7984498739,
0.363042444,
-0.3464182317,
0.6122533083,
-0.1822179854,
0.6151794195,
0.0686122999,
-1.1018676758,
0.3986541927,
-0.5410741568,
0.3190972507,
0.5799786448,
0.405223161,
-0.8559037447,
-0.1400951445,
-0.6618772745,
-0.3810823262,
0.8106218576,
0.2766464353,
0.0589103848,
0.2723895311,
0.1045011431,
0.0154394889,
0.2306689173,
-0.2414049655,
-0.0519319214,
0.1348872483,
-0.221204266,
-0.125538528,
-0.287330389,
-0.2656857967,
-0.3940669596,
0.3485150635,
-0.2603965998,
0.2828289568,
-0.0675970539,
-0.2719855905,
-0.4550071359,
0.5701521039,
0.698618114,
1.410553813,
-0.4812542796,
0.0727961212,
0.3657341003,
-0.4735249281,
0.3888097405,
0.1381801069,
0.0503954031,
-0.3001556993,
0.6214303374,
0.834649682,
0.3307953477,
-0.7658826709,
0.2783920467,
0.0843650326,
-0.2324358076,
-0.0589334182,
-0.0616844073,
0.2192543149,
0.1181216538,
0.3006232977,
-0.2233600765,
-0.2039006054,
-0.7992391586,
0.4215960503,
0.1844021231,
-0.8060017824,
-0.3536214828,
0.5211750269,
0.3710149825,
-0.9754222035,
0.6404348612,
0.0956826806,
-0.4998841286,
0.5007688403,
0.6957381964,
0.9889081717,
-0.3837938011,
0.3519276381,
0.1594786048,
0.3795241416,
0.0575711429,
0.2132636458,
0.0970893651,
-0.7765740752,
-0.3826943338,
-0.4357507825,
-0.3246216178,
-0.023089299,
-0.6585838795,
0.1631341279,
-0.0716389045,
-0.6300263405,
0.0794595033,
-0.060655769,
-0.8544418812,
0.1072448045,
0.3325172365,
0.8106208444,
-0.8297508955,
0.8696110249,
0.8898012638,
-0.3066834211,
-0.2486433685,
0.2120372504,
0.2863518596,
-1.0242359638,
0.8383339643,
-0.065883331,
0.0794877335,
0.0953528583,
-0.588118732,
-0.442615062,
0.7043921947,
0.3408738077,
-0.4660805464,
-0.1010806933,
0.0391493551,
0.6431722641,
-0.3938252032,
0.3040897846,
1.0621312857,
0.5771283507,
-0.0275835097,
-1.2356487513,
-0.3943651915,
0.0162885692,
0.1558963805,
0.0804839358,
-0.0404712558,
0.6384136081,
-0.4319034517,
-0.5118855238,
0.2364071757,
0.6386336088,
0.3097248375,
0.3940428495,
0.6954236627,
0.3219472766,
0.9115660787,
0.0315448865,
1.0021119118,
-0.1250756979,
0.3643089831,
0.6696187258,
-0.4792626202,
0.4579437971,
0.2709249258,
-0.6134919524,
0.2677017748,
0.3298383951,
0.3874347806,
0.1022340432,
0.4289996028,
-0.0953889713,
-0.3507613838,
-0.2475036383,
-0.2647187114,
0.525752008,
0.2638156712,
-0.1768923104,
-0.1414411962,
0.1224913374,
0.2015901953,
0.1917025596,
0.1016275436,
0.7299941778,
0.1787682921,
-0.5179971457,
0.73271209,
-0.1596717387,
0.3003155589,
-0.5282868147,
0.1235074103,
-0.2076637894,
0.2349178344,
0.0603783093,
-0.7843253016,
0.1013899744,
0.1770244241,
0.0183035806,
-0.021380974,
0.9264060855,
-0.4499958158,
-0.398057431,
0.206433624,
1.0528627634,
0.4144698679,
0.0735680237,
-0.6624987721,
0.1119656041,
-0.0047052214,
-0.062638171,
0.330886066,
0.1232794002,
-0.3169616759,
0.9592841268,
0.631906569,
0.2627531588,
-0.1026971117,
0.4523197711,
0.604876101,
-0.8303131461,
-0.1477107108,
-0.6625894904,
0.3333678842,
-0.0044006403,
-0.5697549582,
0.451259613,
0.0135538019,
0.5644766092,
0.0212977827,
0.6145919561,
0.0123729473,
0.4452017844,
-0.1880804747,
0.6359016299,
-0.2451328337,
-0.0050848834,
-0.1143334433,
-1.0266489983,
-0.2308816314,
0.7855536342,
-0.5791909695,
0.4177038372,
0.6525232792,
0.8357287049,
0.2672985792,
0.2024366409,
0.6058741212,
-0.1751379967,
0.4127296805,
0.3073412478,
1.1748152971,
0.0824853256,
0.1969481111,
-0.1292808205,
-0.5341080427,
-0.2361304909,
-0.6647913456,
-0.9422754645,
-0.4878422916,
-0.177784428,
-0.2385837287,
0.320355922,
0.9892056584,
0.7480385303,
-0.5826931596,
-0.7353231311,
0.3525363803,
-0.2284308523,
-0.1782765985,
-0.1154255345,
0.1260282248,
-0.3559096754,
-0.4550317824,
0.3393407762,
0.2185392976,
-0.0709805712,
-0.6228244901,
-0.1078451201,
0.0094907368,
0.0062091155,
0.2988892794,
0.3712370694,
-0.7809020281,
-0.2012533247,
-0.0254076887,
-0.1994587481,
0.0693278983,
1.2820096016,
-0.6672583818,
0.4826076925,
0.4486553669,
0.6725817323,
0.1106023043,
0.4618083835,
0.6279727221,
-0.2656450272,
0.2478602827,
0.4958295524,
0.2495341897,
0.5248953104,
0.0246069115,
0.4391493499,
0.3495517373,
-0.9423141479,
-0.8354930282,
0.1241293475,
-0.887717247,
-0.1183279976,
1.0691812038,
0.0602731109,
0.0005046833,
-0.8044924736,
-0.501455307,
0.1889881045,
-0.3685387671,
0.7793709636,
0.7316223383,
0.025352262,
-0.150764659,
-0.914349854,
0.2973528802,
0.2459732592,
-0.9499588013,
0.1262048036,
0.3409154117,
0.0570147149,
0.1458957344,
0.7745580673,
-0.2187602967,
0.2732200623,
-0.2600730956,
0.3256565034,
0.25256899,
-0.190589726,
-0.3826649785,
-0.0343489386,
0.36126405,
0.2429203093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14189v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14189v3 | Beyond Shared Vocabulary: Increasing Representational Word Similarities across Languages for Multilingual Machine Translation | 2023-05-23T16:11:00 | 2024-01-20T22:29:15 | Di Wu, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Using a vocabulary that is shared across languages is common practice in
Multilingual Neural Machine Translation (MNMT). In addition to its simple
design, shared tokens play an important role in positive knowledge transfer,
assuming that shared tokens refer to similar meanings across languages.
However, when word overlap is small, especially due to different writing
systems, transfer is inhibited. In this paper, we define word-level information
transfer pathways via word equivalence classes and rely on graph networks to
fuse word embeddings across languages. Our experiments demonstrate the
advantages of our approach: 1) embeddings of words with similar meanings are
better aligned across languages, 2) our method achieves consistent BLEU
improvements of up to 2.3 points for high- and low-resource MNMT, and 3) less
than 1.0\% additional trainable parameters are required with a limited increase
in computational costs, while inference time remains identical to the baseline.
We release the codebase to the community. | [
-0.2970170379,
-0.3046281934,
0.4588057697,
0.2553144693,
-0.2517117262,
0.2251154333,
-0.2986017168,
-0.493342936,
0.3881368041,
0.3003852665,
-0.122417137,
-0.365983963,
-1.0149681568,
0.0232082084,
-0.2586417496,
0.6448668838,
-0.4195616841,
-0.0321555398,
-0.0868210196,
-0.6169518232,
-0.4119908214,
-0.5274383426,
-0.6193998456,
-0.6802117825,
1.1094431877,
0.021835031,
0.7474873662,
0.6583025455,
0.4689697623,
0.2909913659,
0.062345773,
0.4878444374,
-0.3294336796,
-0.107973583,
-0.297642976,
-0.3912713826,
-0.3434337676,
-0.3991255462,
0.6809204221,
1.0664952993,
0.1341746002,
-0.0322404541,
0.3085421622,
0.6241175532,
-0.5048251748,
0.3521047831,
-0.6065478921,
0.0886212811,
-0.0863672867,
-0.1367284209,
-0.2243537009,
-0.4009617567,
0.0055602146,
-0.7389492393,
-0.1167443618,
-0.0017612476,
0.8727180958,
-0.1255359203,
-0.5138524771,
-0.2742518783,
-0.2308336496,
0.3735834956,
-0.3539844751,
0.609782517,
0.1070089489,
0.040541973,
-0.0497820415,
-0.7964600325,
-0.6681221128,
0.045201771,
-0.2856110632,
0.0990941226,
-0.294703275,
0.1244633645,
0.076474756,
0.1119887829,
-0.4572509527,
0.1052821428,
-0.3868607879,
-0.366859287,
0.2506739497,
-0.1007927284,
0.3397724628,
-0.1449483931,
-0.5574195981,
-0.1337580234,
-0.8468876481,
-0.2465502322,
0.2467271984,
0.6127266884,
-0.1588661224,
0.5821258426,
0.1444266737,
0.7647404671,
-0.4959304035,
0.2942298353,
0.7005131841,
-0.5574315786,
0.0464796908,
0.2307226211,
0.8097963929,
0.4757988751,
0.1346924007,
-0.5694392323,
-0.1107596681,
0.0995109156,
-0.1142532006,
-0.7253983021,
0.0694741458,
-0.1780836731,
-0.375240624,
0.1193455458,
0.0934744701,
-0.3057458103,
-0.3708877265,
-0.3462082148,
0.7310037613,
-0.460624665,
-0.440625906,
0.2213059962,
-0.4694024622,
0.0922454298,
0.1123885214,
-0.786264658,
0.2628518045,
0.7916446328,
1.2307217121,
-0.3424254656,
-0.6300326586,
-0.4044130445,
0.5914398432,
-0.5453969836,
0.4608645141,
-0.3541654646,
-0.237533465,
0.0136483964,
0.1303767264,
-0.4683072269,
-0.4476477802,
0.0360690914,
-0.5225430727,
0.0551857054,
-0.4744209647,
-0.730267942,
-0.2391816974,
0.4537803233,
-0.3377924562,
0.8798804879,
0.0266949609,
-0.7795095444,
0.267963022,
-0.6726936102,
-0.6978005171,
0.0056252684,
-0.0982794836,
0.0711515024,
0.0973179489,
0.061436519,
0.4587905109,
0.0734424666,
0.0011213117,
-0.2853720486,
-0.4327774346,
0.1086555943,
-0.2748447061,
0.5956546068,
0.2749411464,
-0.0666392148,
0.1228897274,
-0.338696152,
0.0060518403,
-0.1517419964,
-0.3148480952,
-0.6651096344,
-0.5597620606,
-0.1629827172,
0.3302401602,
0.4585876763,
-0.6686782241,
0.3076885045,
-0.4264953136,
0.5533106327,
0.613057971,
-0.1701383293,
0.6558380723,
-0.3601759076,
0.2659032047,
0.2945258915,
-0.2532336414,
-0.0184862558,
-0.5216968656,
-0.6621154547,
-0.0927479416,
0.4553083479,
0.5075980425,
-1.0230467319,
0.3946635723,
-0.7195594907,
-0.2844338417,
-0.8153591156,
0.2196758091,
0.3639098406,
0.384134829,
0.3419824541,
-0.464841783,
-0.3267354965,
-0.7830950022,
-0.2344819903,
0.0310297981,
0.0786161125,
0.2135441601,
0.2067722529,
-0.2893031538,
0.181447193,
-0.4297583997,
-0.2298485041,
-0.3012667596,
0.0401356183,
0.2675856948,
0.4412493408,
0.3073277473,
-0.5126914382,
-0.671102047,
0.6921404004,
-0.7751720548,
0.0783880055,
-0.0894884542,
-0.4865782261,
0.1057740897,
0.7257479429,
-0.4894581139,
0.09690433,
0.8203679919,
-0.12522012,
-0.1630611867,
-0.4695604444,
0.2602079511,
-1.5537722111,
0.1673761457,
-0.3184325695,
-0.3326380849,
-0.4542192221,
0.2160129994,
0.0601683818,
-0.1764432192,
-0.4429012537,
0.7531804442,
-0.5029579997,
-0.248426035,
-0.2970437407,
0.6103222966,
0.119410716,
0.442933023,
-0.1654747427,
0.6609581113,
0.6104958057,
-0.4837900698,
0.3325489759,
0.1822493672,
-0.099595584,
0.5380690694,
-0.3793365359,
0.1967879832,
-0.0162600931,
0.1716443896,
-0.6984101534,
0.2347966582,
0.3579291403,
-0.501670599,
0.4832837284,
-0.1081048772,
-0.6554634571,
-0.1266580522,
0.0260892082,
0.2402237207,
0.3024237454,
-0.4814038277,
0.4104811847,
0.3010908663,
-0.0439379327,
-0.4889288843,
-1.0879576206,
0.4524280727,
-0.075950332,
-0.6912158132,
0.5115545392,
0.3740231693,
0.19078812,
0.2265364528,
-0.0160650667,
-0.1181416735,
-0.0463951081,
0.1034881249,
-0.0070106857,
-0.2962485552,
0.5434638858,
0.2211903632,
-0.2069348246,
-0.2917480469,
-0.8216958642,
0.7505608201,
-0.0455684923,
-0.3002054989,
-0.3396772146,
0.413544327,
0.26324296,
-0.2760392129,
0.994204402,
1.0064085722,
-0.3408217132,
0.220053345,
0.0263834987,
-0.1132425442,
-0.4239131808,
0.4650629759,
-0.7546328902,
-1.0843685865,
0.440548718,
-0.3481608629,
0.0478094891,
0.353435874,
0.3409709632,
0.0690624192,
0.7135205865,
0.6108570099,
-0.0395186394,
0.4258311093,
-0.3089587092,
0.2523112595,
-0.9544581175,
-0.0844553113,
-0.3245529532,
-0.5251434445,
-0.6987416744,
-0.8282738328,
0.0324282572,
0.3414191902,
-0.0875533968,
0.7472282648,
-0.2265465856,
0.3588719666,
0.4348472059,
0.0679281428,
0.3064239919,
0.3380163908,
-0.4919291437,
0.0414501019,
-1.1002472639,
-0.1573579162,
0.912723124,
0.0743899792,
0.3027507961,
0.1870728433,
0.9940063953,
0.0718471184,
0.442399025,
-0.7399258614,
0.4054876864,
-0.486818403,
-0.2944548726,
-0.2062170804,
-0.6615695357,
-1.1477622986,
0.5293706059,
-0.2305261791,
-0.7132927179,
-0.1091322824,
0.0017525363,
0.2576654553,
0.4853144288,
-0.7347060442,
0.8639782667,
-0.022150185,
-0.3149635792,
-0.5445142388,
-0.735296607,
-0.1217274293,
-0.1726283282,
0.1564127058,
-0.032069359,
-0.2186586559,
0.4598950744,
-0.4196712375,
0.5577247143,
-0.0172523782,
-0.0283791088,
0.0972167775,
0.0328962915,
0.2991210818,
-0.5534629822,
-0.2529641986,
0.5728514791,
-0.0920693949,
-0.5301578641,
-0.809150517,
0.7962348461,
-0.6087270379,
-0.2437779009,
-0.0754256323,
-0.8372352123,
-0.1839332432,
0.4886923134,
0.1799912602,
0.3322060108,
0.0884051919,
0.115301311,
0.2621891201,
-0.1611812115,
0.2706767619,
0.1389542818,
-0.4347946346,
-0.3805601299,
1.2788436413,
0.3007340133,
0.494810909,
0.6540983319,
0.3436189592,
-0.4155427516,
-0.403154701,
-0.751291275,
0.1964527369,
-0.6933070421,
-0.0608149841,
-0.7307993174,
-0.2043624818,
-0.3660590351,
-0.1638270319,
-0.2119233906,
-0.6397029757,
0.1033509895,
-0.2729010284,
0.4361045361,
0.6338261962,
-0.2815431654,
0.3525486887,
-1.0899617672,
0.1237710714,
-0.1301369518,
0.4013906419,
0.2337230295,
-0.3303174973,
-0.4466207623,
0.0932499468,
-0.2090070844,
-0.8072801232,
0.0086791748,
0.2725711763,
0.6735956669,
0.0153445462,
-0.3206462562,
0.9432801008,
-0.4956004024,
0.4577022493,
0.6987800598,
-1.077709198,
0.0317259468,
-0.2015205175,
0.3010778725,
0.4350413084,
0.5031907558,
-1.1237338781,
-0.2855837941,
-0.3546577692,
-0.8482490778,
0.3451583683,
0.2125252038,
0.4196437597,
-0.1109116673,
0.138279438,
0.1195812598,
0.291397959,
-0.4789262414,
-0.236660108,
-0.0168120265,
-0.2794555724,
-0.1285367012,
0.5304791927,
-0.119341664,
-0.3608566225,
0.4272598326,
-0.2976236343,
0.2950799167,
0.1448845863,
-0.2994407117,
0.141415,
0.100969702,
0.2903311253,
0.547858417,
0.2933416665,
0.4987693131,
0.3991465867,
-0.2392592728,
0.0535777844,
0.1861687154,
-0.0001703388,
0.0655353367,
0.3747504354,
0.8963254094,
0.0971136391,
-0.0107140495,
0.4640007317,
0.1044867858,
-0.1952174455,
0.4603134692,
-0.1933655143,
0.6168423295,
0.216020748,
-0.2475580424,
0.2823429704,
-0.0386988781,
-0.557874918,
0.2852783203,
0.2386185974,
-0.6939020753,
-0.1677239984,
0.2194337994,
0.1833265871,
-0.3100182116,
0.5029096007,
-0.2637291253,
-0.6428291798,
0.3052359819,
0.6979342103,
0.5382822752,
0.0148836887,
0.2256786674,
0.3186205328,
0.3548496366,
-0.0762142166,
0.4063094258,
-0.0455357805,
-0.8960997462,
-0.3281384706,
-0.5754404068,
-0.019760225,
-0.4159437418,
-0.4357247651,
0.1151727811,
-0.1863876283,
-0.0829332471,
-0.2369715124,
-0.1961965114,
-0.6812248826,
-0.3082406521,
0.1228179261,
0.7961171865,
-0.8259344101,
1.0534743071,
0.7453820705,
-0.4374034703,
-0.9727051258,
-0.1775225699,
-0.2947611511,
-1.0247370005,
0.5661654472,
0.2381179631,
-0.1617690772,
0.1245120466,
0.0189847834,
-0.7411726713,
0.9980472326,
0.5507289171,
-0.6016575098,
0.0288160853,
0.5113343,
0.5814632177,
-0.3451725245,
-0.2601504922,
0.2469187677,
0.4809716344,
0.2784425318,
-0.8135675192,
0.2060013562,
-0.1026318148,
-0.0347924754,
0.6147594452,
-0.4746386111,
0.5555874109,
-0.0459329076,
-0.2175480425,
0.0679136962,
0.5718016028,
0.0988842994,
0.3152266741,
0.3045223951,
0.7963371873,
0.9888064861,
-0.0396369882,
0.9270661473,
-0.5504851341,
0.2201740593,
1.0284129381,
-0.0661366582,
0.822707355,
0.655875802,
-0.0434367582,
0.3681357205,
0.449567765,
0.0389851928,
0.3343845904,
0.47308442,
-0.1612764746,
-0.1633546203,
-0.4242359698,
-0.5473329425,
0.1518285275,
0.3816334605,
-0.5830068588,
-0.1836711466,
-0.1284963787,
0.1412198097,
0.0284654461,
-0.3832502365,
0.6513585448,
0.5545214415,
-0.4907218218,
0.5233193636,
-0.1772430241,
0.6097555161,
-0.5638420582,
-0.0698401406,
-0.3066561818,
0.1943658739,
-0.2798107266,
-0.9454257488,
0.4343834221,
-0.340909183,
0.1222035512,
-0.3371935785,
0.7729462981,
-0.7642293572,
-0.4045119584,
0.7288894057,
0.8002923727,
0.384537667,
0.088655971,
-0.7280161381,
-0.1625703424,
-0.1733962744,
0.3840665519,
0.2847373188,
0.702542007,
-0.1594624221,
0.3639970124,
0.5967264771,
0.4997049868,
0.4325266778,
0.3520690799,
0.7129875422,
-0.4339939058,
-0.3923375607,
-0.7061105967,
0.1228448004,
-0.1597611755,
-0.2456198335,
0.7554004788,
0.626236856,
0.9617766142,
0.2722603083,
0.5959964395,
0.0684031248,
0.0325205997,
-0.4837209582,
0.8885064721,
-0.7284627557,
-0.0980275944,
-0.3176302016,
-1.0831657648,
-0.3636319935,
0.3978823125,
0.0294808913,
-0.3133080304,
0.7826467752,
0.7328810096,
-0.348624289,
-0.2849088013,
0.4396462142,
-0.0839011744,
0.2017432749,
0.7120178938,
0.6162204742,
-0.5716984272,
0.6496517062,
-0.0174743086,
0.0102566583,
0.1991562843,
-0.8554394841,
-0.6076729298,
-0.496741116,
-0.2549346983,
-0.5743864775,
0.3264188766,
0.8775532842,
0.576982677,
-0.4261923134,
-0.3457736671,
-0.2332379669,
0.3497873247,
-0.3243907988,
-0.0927216187,
0.5067207813,
-0.2770337462,
-0.4329927266,
0.0853036419,
0.4267040193,
-0.0272822622,
-0.0393994227,
-0.3045405149,
-0.1678957045,
-0.1366401613,
0.6337967515,
0.058829084,
-0.3940759301,
-0.5038049817,
-0.0195855554,
-0.2815597653,
0.2309852391,
0.8205457926,
-0.3246032894,
0.5884644389,
0.8286708593,
1.0460991859,
0.6369232535,
-0.4164984524,
0.7393353581,
-0.885877192,
0.2639003694,
-0.1834024638,
0.5054832101,
0.6295113564,
0.0705869719,
0.3798731565,
0.3845654428,
-0.1055734232,
-0.4905628562,
0.481272161,
-0.7778013945,
-0.3147750795,
1.0568009615,
-0.504635036,
-0.2024931014,
0.0388118513,
0.0150643289,
0.7480382323,
-0.1178801507,
0.4741788805,
0.6846584678,
0.0130109508,
0.0723365918,
-0.2539278269,
0.1624449641,
0.1587169319,
-0.6515232325,
-0.0141924499,
0.0113988118,
0.235861212,
0.3351484537,
0.5263232589,
-0.2764074802,
-0.0477898382,
0.1405062377,
0.110511139,
-0.0796100423,
-0.2861187756,
-0.2635999024,
-0.0626182631,
-0.0597249232,
-0.3900969923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14171v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14171v3 | In-Context Probing: Toward Building Robust Classifiers via Probing Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T15:43:04 | 2023-12-22T13:27:11 | Afra Amini, Massimiliano Ciaramita | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models are able to learn new tasks in context, where they are
provided with instructions and a few annotated examples. However, the
effectiveness of in-context learning is dependent on the provided context, and
the performance on a downstream task can vary considerably, depending on the
instruction. Importantly, such dependency on the context can surface in
unpredictable ways, e.g., a seemingly more informative instruction might lead
to a worse performance. In this paper, we propose an alternative approach,
which we term In-Context Probing (ICP). Similar to in-context learning, we
contextualize the representation of the input with an instruction, but instead
of decoding the output prediction, we probe the contextualized representation
to predict the label. Through a series of experiments on a diverse set of
classification tasks, we show that in-context probing is significantly more
robust to changes in instructions. We further show that ICP performs
competitive or superior to finetuning and can be particularly helpful to build
classifiers on top of smaller models, with less than a hundred training
examples. | [
-0.5640903115,
-0.7215044498,
0.4228495955,
-0.2291168869,
-0.0236036144,
-0.3234592378,
-0.4860119522,
-0.5007628798,
-0.3837323189,
0.2541135252,
-0.2872263491,
-0.274584353,
-0.6860784888,
-0.09023083,
-0.3019558787,
0.9965296388,
0.1194015294,
0.2295366079,
-0.4347719848,
-0.1591007411,
-0.575951457,
-0.6598268747,
-0.7267466187,
-0.5951164961,
0.2579167783,
0.6107634306,
0.2897547781,
0.5060478449,
0.270888865,
0.3262832165,
-0.02590896,
0.1443154514,
-0.4856595099,
0.318246901,
-0.3118746579,
-0.5419293642,
0.0123018343,
0.0751295388,
0.7178304791,
0.9282175303,
0.3438926935,
0.3061583042,
0.6849954128,
0.236683026,
-0.8707711101,
0.3129556477,
-0.6431292892,
-0.1303441226,
-0.1109554172,
-0.5451265574,
-0.7985880971,
0.1823984832,
0.4824438989,
-0.0915242061,
0.2889356315,
-0.1525159627,
0.7027899623,
0.2966929674,
-0.6560536027,
-0.2870894372,
-0.6845007539,
0.7954751849,
-0.6607087851,
0.5582312942,
0.4651645422,
0.4772379398,
-0.2429199219,
-0.875439465,
-0.2300927043,
-0.394795686,
-0.3219164908,
-0.0597845986,
0.2024901658,
-0.043866381,
0.3626283407,
0.1365395188,
-0.1143445298,
0.096456416,
0.0706134439,
-0.2354408801,
0.3697290719,
0.0742588863,
0.282833159,
0.1624790579,
-0.5268290043,
-0.4752618968,
-0.8200414181,
0.5089621544,
0.1442647129,
0.6060044765,
-0.0257988218,
0.3725583255,
-0.0930658728,
0.8500398397,
0.2857379615,
-0.1601200402,
-0.1750554293,
0.0186839923,
-0.2617912591,
0.414754957,
0.4230472744,
0.2966578901,
-0.1572721004,
-0.1034393162,
-0.3593719006,
0.0698326007,
0.1695471406,
-1.0399593115,
-0.3238784075,
0.1744306237,
-0.3043584526,
-0.2440510988,
0.144595027,
-0.605287075,
-0.0527066402,
-0.4369318187,
0.6461242437,
-0.5561898351,
0.2312076986,
-0.0466103964,
0.0398004241,
0.4606623054,
0.209480226,
-1.1409779787,
0.356642276,
0.8422253132,
0.815667212,
-0.0320899598,
-0.4213130772,
-1.1364666224,
0.257360518,
-0.2733570039,
0.7116959095,
-0.7229900956,
-0.302551657,
-0.0798764452,
-0.0061779902,
-0.0042598671,
-0.6061911583,
0.1733728647,
-0.5116879344,
0.1821867675,
-0.3143519163,
-0.9001573324,
-0.2921589315,
0.6955708861,
-0.4854466319,
1.0719510317,
0.2236056924,
-0.9093948603,
0.5696516037,
-0.7131860852,
-0.3962088227,
0.2523241341,
-0.3419627845,
-0.2266827673,
0.0007135434,
0.2287016362,
0.8386974931,
-0.002918018,
0.2548181117,
-0.5236638784,
-0.6449452043,
0.4015725851,
-0.495876044,
0.9234632254,
-0.0125033893,
-0.7348261476,
-0.0818812251,
-0.4984708428,
0.0120872008,
-0.1580015868,
-0.6204247475,
-0.6847727895,
0.2152407467,
-0.0565951467,
-0.1168188229,
-0.0543114766,
-0.5442646742,
0.2381007671,
-0.513569653,
0.361300528,
0.7174915671,
-0.0733090639,
0.6313933134,
-0.2239065468,
0.3564941287,
-0.2421607673,
0.0032906027,
-0.3229130208,
-0.3374015093,
-0.7563708425,
-0.2194922864,
0.3394877315,
0.5049586296,
-0.6494244933,
0.0801448822,
-0.2956804931,
-0.4353452921,
-0.0177291408,
-0.1390361488,
0.5091726184,
0.9704814553,
0.344288975,
-0.2918011546,
-0.2784257531,
-0.5231440067,
-0.3582321107,
-0.1589479297,
-0.2715348601,
0.5475367904,
0.4668586254,
-0.3331277072,
0.7147479057,
-0.4924308658,
-0.2994754016,
-0.2204685658,
0.1200307235,
0.0038829851,
0.5554510951,
0.5875430107,
-0.7623656988,
-0.6246542335,
0.251321435,
-0.4067080021,
-0.0186515339,
-0.1603645086,
-0.0297295116,
-0.0587977283,
0.9576276541,
-0.1290977895,
0.1264598966,
0.4785251617,
-0.2084696293,
0.3448035717,
-0.0279174354,
0.0046802959,
-1.0501192808,
-0.0140081318,
0.1432333142,
-0.2360101938,
-0.6838068366,
0.590503633,
0.4144013524,
-0.0337069817,
-0.5990334749,
0.6866871715,
-0.3873704076,
-0.0169767104,
-0.2133377194,
-0.1837484092,
-0.0392216295,
0.3094977438,
-0.0266521685,
0.7916727662,
0.7861186266,
-0.794416368,
0.1302953959,
-0.0377442241,
-0.6084656715,
0.4059852362,
-0.4006885588,
0.0888870209,
-0.0834661275,
0.4305432737,
-1.1068906784,
-0.5955063701,
0.1225078255,
-0.5431981683,
0.8075917363,
-0.610129118,
-0.5129135251,
0.2226437181,
-0.1317831576,
0.7991319299,
0.2190632224,
-1.1280920506,
0.4924639165,
0.3314783275,
0.1840393245,
-0.5412658453,
-0.6758370996,
-0.0885423422,
-0.6779294014,
-0.4207930267,
0.3779553175,
0.0712481439,
-0.3409997523,
-0.4237041175,
-0.0941253528,
-0.1518399566,
0.4263913631,
0.2959309518,
0.1812819391,
-0.379435122,
0.208599031,
-0.070680134,
0.0920087844,
0.4045278132,
-0.2990686595,
0.648109436,
-0.2934327722,
-0.4566882551,
-0.4049537182,
0.437147975,
0.373108238,
-0.3398005664,
0.3294135928,
0.4113198221,
-0.4436913133,
-0.628266871,
-0.2305858433,
-0.6468502879,
-0.5891562104,
0.2353981733,
-0.4585144222,
-0.9188016057,
0.3677653968,
-0.3200916052,
-0.1291200072,
0.0522084422,
0.2484664619,
-0.2451556027,
1.3061697483,
0.9060932994,
-0.0596913546,
0.5356743336,
-0.3018840849,
0.3157421649,
-0.7644042969,
-0.1901605129,
-0.533539176,
-0.4250460565,
-0.6951825023,
-0.1729880571,
0.6397102475,
-0.012557365,
-0.0532107502,
0.2565865517,
-0.519674778,
0.667231679,
0.808978796,
0.3786244094,
-0.0520319566,
-0.2115370333,
-0.0097394027,
-0.0144014833,
-0.7837483287,
-0.4915577471,
1.027862072,
0.2917594314,
0.59243083,
-0.0217439812,
0.6324059367,
-0.1847217083,
0.5331320763,
-1.1525429487,
0.457616955,
-0.0517869629,
-0.4842236936,
-0.2852198184,
-0.2942832708,
-0.8323541284,
0.3492745459,
0.0157192852,
-0.8905440569,
0.2001329064,
0.5164326429,
-0.2489450425,
0.3719357848,
-0.8549969792,
0.8994361758,
-0.1848473251,
-0.3299172521,
0.2705765367,
-0.6177025437,
0.2859351039,
0.1620178223,
0.0054829586,
0.465130955,
0.1029859111,
0.3108582199,
-0.2255000323,
1.1257647276,
-0.1410044283,
-0.0949690565,
0.2369804531,
0.3496169448,
0.4050519764,
0.2243124694,
0.1938564628,
-0.138250798,
0.1286902577,
-0.3768522739,
-0.6706356406,
0.7340678573,
-0.3386677802,
-0.4607301056,
-0.4182620347,
-0.6402145624,
-0.4756201804,
0.103294462,
0.578199625,
0.9219170213,
0.0956751257,
0.3534178138,
1.0080996752,
-0.0387418568,
0.472356379,
0.105662331,
0.2407111824,
0.3436542153,
0.8165623546,
-0.0200274121,
0.2992711365,
0.8723528385,
0.5751039386,
-0.2676035464,
-0.5169407725,
-0.4429103136,
-0.1487087607,
-0.934844017,
-0.2933953404,
-0.3801947534,
0.0592083447,
-0.223750338,
-0.3537254035,
-0.2555591166,
0.0813009441,
-0.3217767179,
0.0779392794,
0.0296185035,
0.4212648571,
0.1877240986,
0.2531281412,
-0.6754773855,
-0.3206185997,
0.6348062158,
0.3357036412,
0.0035587831,
-0.5494764447,
-0.2563812733,
0.1144591421,
-0.2957427502,
-0.9430785179,
0.2476507872,
0.3957543969,
0.369350493,
0.7123695612,
0.2704160213,
0.6383849382,
-0.4629881382,
0.6625016928,
-0.3445518017,
-1.2033076286,
0.6080916524,
-0.4172334969,
0.566020906,
0.5363088846,
0.6272829771,
-0.3568292856,
-0.4650281072,
-0.2224220932,
-0.8330855966,
0.6187187433,
-0.4447271824,
0.3890675604,
-0.0433331951,
0.479190737,
0.2259887159,
-0.1929406673,
-0.724373877,
0.0635700524,
-0.0193288177,
0.0174909793,
-0.1943470389,
-0.2329653651,
-0.3083873093,
-0.2736736238,
0.4601591825,
-0.5741348267,
0.124879308,
0.1485347748,
-0.1840579808,
0.3101805151,
0.06772881,
0.486536175,
0.5136178136,
-0.307775259,
0.6308760643,
0.2765356302,
-0.3950490057,
0.0096821235,
-0.0658052117,
-0.2095643282,
-0.1484956443,
0.6914858818,
0.5097084641,
0.5178360343,
-0.9111351967,
0.7126174569,
-0.0129946535,
-0.0909658223,
-0.2308804393,
0.1780954152,
-0.2009942979,
0.3596175909,
0.1204049811,
-0.0441444926,
0.677608192,
-0.8251878023,
0.3194961548,
0.4473145604,
-0.7506968379,
-0.1261394322,
0.551015377,
-0.1517930478,
-0.1390868425,
0.5915868282,
-0.2654416859,
-0.7061464787,
0.5722802281,
0.7289010882,
0.5653618574,
-0.3855589926,
-0.0050434754,
0.3925044835,
0.0819097683,
-0.1311612576,
-0.0161248706,
-0.4792420268,
-0.6054503918,
-0.5358529091,
-0.0865352079,
-0.5245702863,
0.2559003234,
-0.9586592317,
0.2438843548,
-0.3374293745,
0.1274341494,
-0.084760502,
-0.1077520698,
-0.5522313118,
0.4063280523,
0.1150644422,
0.7682775855,
-0.802414,
0.9255652428,
1.0084975958,
0.0463059917,
-0.6800407767,
0.2766804695,
-0.0698761567,
-0.3363162875,
0.6451814175,
0.8030701876,
-0.2910255194,
-0.2369184047,
-0.9033284783,
-0.9008910656,
0.8508287668,
0.3432162702,
-0.2905861735,
0.1809856892,
-0.0590057522,
0.4140842259,
-0.3073786795,
0.0841073245,
0.285228461,
0.1785628796,
-0.2150012106,
-0.6340700388,
0.1934177577,
-0.1711072475,
-0.1446246058,
0.3213024437,
-0.4175049663,
0.9336392879,
-0.0926754102,
-0.4703110456,
-0.2338926345,
0.6377829313,
0.0304624233,
0.5359550118,
0.645601809,
0.2859176993,
0.4836596549,
-0.2297968417,
1.2467886209,
-0.0624072254,
0.2119785249,
1.4265340567,
0.0555378497,
0.9926224351,
0.651943922,
0.2341459095,
0.2265651673,
0.9314119816,
0.0916534066,
0.7792941332,
0.2554589212,
-0.3863906264,
-0.2319957912,
-0.055007901,
-0.1519761235,
0.8679147363,
0.5778900385,
-0.2078055888,
-0.242449522,
0.0929748863,
0.0942156389,
0.2230640054,
-0.254218936,
0.6538236737,
-0.2214271426,
-0.8446683884,
0.6047093868,
0.0114138592,
0.7180779576,
-0.4361628592,
-0.2706282139,
-0.2093322575,
0.3531173766,
0.0358109549,
-0.5793084502,
0.1649513245,
-0.309289068,
0.0288515426,
-0.4395184815,
0.5294930339,
-0.410242945,
-0.167792663,
0.4054518342,
0.0952019915,
0.1006809175,
-0.166700229,
-0.2426967919,
0.0639407784,
-0.0890731215,
-0.136195913,
0.7755972743,
0.3952553272,
-0.0893030539,
0.6833210588,
0.3446164429,
-0.2847253084,
0.112683028,
-0.3349466622,
0.8741822839,
-0.1363765299,
-0.4206514657,
-0.8374651074,
0.4138530493,
0.0708301291,
-0.5088730454,
0.7143920064,
0.4985435009,
1.7285994291,
0.1133642346,
0.6006343365,
0.1102295518,
0.1991310269,
-0.6433253288,
0.6311909556,
-0.6547594666,
0.2403615415,
-0.2049112171,
-0.8049601316,
-0.3791823685,
0.7142321467,
-0.188389048,
-0.1078345254,
0.4832839966,
0.8179605603,
-0.6369268894,
-0.0063512125,
0.1730720997,
0.0407094546,
0.4789756238,
0.446659565,
0.7358085513,
-0.2655539215,
0.327200532,
-0.7022483945,
-0.4334839582,
-0.4072641134,
-0.959569633,
-1.1852135658,
-0.9197625518,
-0.1484462917,
-0.2377651334,
-0.2964276373,
0.7922221422,
0.9652909636,
-0.6707331538,
-0.4091208577,
0.0005123919,
-0.1908649206,
-0.5032516718,
-0.2971968055,
0.3863832951,
-0.6029488444,
-0.9968365431,
0.7756453753,
-0.0105850231,
0.1434565187,
-0.1781710982,
0.2417940944,
0.080974929,
-0.0914630368,
0.8338065743,
0.2085691094,
-0.5471066833,
-0.6319306493,
-0.0623628907,
0.0230134986,
-0.0800872445,
0.8759145737,
-0.6653675437,
0.6713950634,
0.6063964367,
1.0513179302,
0.5656388402,
-0.2405714244,
0.718947947,
-0.8758118153,
0.1094032824,
0.348395586,
0.4105942249,
0.4501706362,
-0.5289435387,
0.3313560784,
-0.2943089306,
-0.5999450684,
-1.089774251,
0.4883926809,
-0.7398101091,
-0.496306777,
0.9949765205,
-0.2839888334,
-0.1893410385,
0.1036814675,
-0.1485952288,
0.2418412715,
-0.1672156751,
1.0633615255,
0.6078313589,
-0.2807925045,
0.0448676534,
-0.7136083841,
0.5184135437,
0.5296231508,
-0.6864001751,
-0.2223890871,
0.419266969,
0.2576157451,
0.0903326124,
0.1411748827,
0.0703959465,
0.1688512117,
-0.0261579286,
-0.4477495551,
0.2300987542,
-0.5234330893,
-0.258943826,
0.310346514,
0.0373653136,
-0.4396016598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14169v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14169v1 | EASE: An Easily-Customized Annotation System Powered by Efficiency Enhancement Mechanisms | 2023-05-23T15:38:37 | 2023-05-23T15:38:37 | Naihao Deng, Yikai Liu, Mingye Chen, Winston Wu, Siyang Liu, Yulong Chen, Yue Zhang, Rada Mihalcea | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | The performance of current supervised AI systems is tightly connected to the
availability of annotated datasets. Annotations are usually collected through
annotation tools, which are often designed for specific tasks and are difficult
to customize. Moreover, existing annotation tools with an active learning
mechanism often only support limited use cases. To address these limitations,
we present EASE, an Easily-Customized Annotation System Powered by Efficiency
Enhancement Mechanisms. \sysname provides modular annotation units for building
customized annotation interfaces and also provides multiple back-end options
that suggest annotations using (1) multi-task active learning; (2) demographic
feature based active learning; (3) a prompt system that can query the API of
large language models. We conduct multiple experiments and user studies to
evaluate our system's flexibility and effectiveness. Our results show that our
system can meet the diverse needs of NLP researchers and significantly
accelerate the annotation process. | [
-0.3874245286,
-0.8268635869,
0.3307973742,
0.4261485934,
-0.212632522,
-0.2750700116,
-0.5177698731,
-0.47259745,
0.3725760877,
0.2629904449,
-0.4210691154,
-0.3951663971,
-0.5618103743,
0.3127215803,
-0.1943215132,
0.8812209368,
0.1613142192,
-0.1057302803,
-0.1962310225,
-0.4703174531,
-0.1980730295,
-0.542383194,
-0.7696480155,
-0.4077607691,
0.5506688356,
0.3450167775,
0.7710528374,
0.7413657904,
0.8422573805,
0.357850343,
-0.084754318,
0.1990681291,
-0.1163692102,
0.5319193602,
0.2615191936,
-0.3710458875,
-0.7638167143,
-0.2633907199,
0.4303368926,
0.8158245087,
-0.0042900792,
0.3908828497,
0.1173234135,
0.4253682494,
-0.9217156172,
0.3428515792,
-0.4555891752,
-0.0943651125,
-0.2604081631,
-0.0792672038,
-0.237529099,
-0.2329744399,
0.1550927013,
-0.9446070194,
-0.2290991992,
-0.1798255295,
0.5546450019,
0.6635425687,
-0.043434117,
-0.1846222728,
-0.3678745627,
0.6114560962,
-0.3332200646,
0.3316041529,
0.2518940866,
0.4122626483,
0.2896128297,
-1.1087015867,
-0.3775680363,
-0.225012213,
-0.4883406162,
-0.1502639651,
0.0048874756,
0.1370087415,
0.5528562069,
0.1794795394,
-0.2598564923,
0.0988036469,
0.0416088142,
-0.3128754795,
0.6583461761,
0.0887010992,
0.3000540137,
-0.1498740464,
-0.1218348742,
-0.0591884404,
-0.2719085813,
0.1444633752,
0.2884082794,
0.5887843966,
0.2389849126,
0.5994722843,
-0.5491586328,
0.8019010425,
-0.3133514822,
-0.0704315156,
0.6478618383,
-0.0620676912,
-0.2689171135,
-0.0738622919,
0.6114609241,
-0.0477587394,
-0.0976461023,
-0.2604633868,
-0.5202519298,
-0.1796618253,
0.2245374918,
-0.7334609032,
-0.5312850475,
0.0882864669,
-0.3654835224,
-0.3341757953,
-0.0824643001,
-0.4559779763,
-0.368532449,
-0.4391819835,
0.5987350345,
-0.4846874475,
-0.17806229,
-0.1222094297,
-0.3390059471,
-0.159663409,
0.7357958555,
-0.7883263826,
0.1637081802,
0.7349949479,
1.0398910046,
-0.4764870703,
0.0110567138,
-0.5998850465,
-0.0816078931,
0.0462394394,
0.7104402184,
-0.8793945312,
-0.3217850029,
0.0183155239,
-0.1258791387,
0.1121615097,
-0.222794503,
0.7481681108,
-0.3218580782,
-0.0593220256,
-0.0552460849,
-0.5572654009,
-0.4317772985,
0.1747707874,
-0.8512263894,
1.1083807945,
0.0134060532,
-0.704148829,
0.5110741854,
-1.2431634665,
-0.4640002251,
0.5808752179,
-0.0549879484,
-0.298009932,
0.0651828051,
0.2210013121,
0.5881877542,
0.3766275644,
0.169374764,
-0.3987902999,
-0.3888206184,
0.1191525012,
-0.3530029953,
1.0249954462,
0.3211396933,
-0.4280633926,
0.3140947819,
-0.8856070638,
-0.0684334189,
-0.118796587,
-0.605768621,
-0.6476503611,
-0.2156797647,
0.1221613437,
-0.2174496055,
0.6019826531,
-0.3100834489,
0.4597707689,
-0.0182839297,
0.0068845516,
0.6252502799,
-0.1276631802,
0.5331614614,
0.0964394137,
0.4409062862,
-0.4692138433,
0.2992743552,
-0.3643115461,
-0.531611383,
-0.855604589,
-0.7994009852,
0.4036934972,
0.6593136787,
-0.5366286039,
0.6253795624,
-0.2059220821,
-0.3617942631,
-0.5541102886,
0.3870464861,
0.0903180614,
0.4117417634,
0.3585288525,
-0.3005034328,
-0.3429605961,
-0.9681002498,
-0.1991576999,
-0.0668853745,
-0.0671403408,
0.4384540021,
0.2564924955,
-0.1020571142,
0.8576892018,
-0.4904497862,
-0.1325647533,
-0.3063831329,
0.3266378343,
0.0049941172,
0.5092176795,
0.555758059,
-1.0022988319,
-0.3093007505,
-0.1563854367,
-0.7679514885,
-0.3172237873,
-0.0424465537,
-0.2678178549,
0.1636578143,
0.4464704096,
-0.4489960372,
0.4314796627,
0.2314443439,
-0.1249135956,
0.2242167145,
-0.0998575613,
0.082956858,
-0.665060401,
0.4260189533,
0.0098666158,
-0.1201269478,
-0.6209170222,
0.1347779036,
0.2418892533,
0.0572999232,
-0.1567580104,
0.3551845253,
-0.2990654707,
0.2533813715,
-0.3164963722,
0.2608347833,
-0.1697389781,
0.4626257718,
0.2122256309,
0.4964333177,
0.7414844036,
-0.7422396541,
0.4178230464,
0.1566353887,
-0.0604629889,
0.4184703827,
-0.5143896341,
0.0043699127,
-0.0423550308,
0.1456821561,
-0.7820140719,
-0.5761705041,
0.2837330997,
-0.309101373,
0.1863995641,
0.0492434204,
-0.4106009901,
-0.0635275543,
-0.3526078463,
-0.022698421,
0.4636780322,
-0.8578172922,
0.7024478912,
0.2108627856,
-0.2480757982,
-0.8372696638,
-0.5209400654,
0.2459663004,
-0.341288656,
-0.2766287327,
-0.0888232216,
0.0619154014,
-0.3672891557,
0.0542983525,
0.2754404247,
-0.1845436245,
0.6172600985,
0.4557666183,
0.1614037156,
-0.0312759317,
0.8755578399,
0.2721348107,
-0.0883832052,
-0.2439365238,
-0.1268939525,
0.1763937473,
-0.0690853894,
-0.3560695648,
-0.6642764807,
0.256021589,
0.2212429196,
-0.5103139281,
0.4897013605,
0.8947094679,
-0.5129873157,
-0.2311979979,
-0.4479913712,
-0.2638896406,
-0.5001351237,
0.4144529104,
-0.4832690358,
-0.898866117,
0.2911036909,
-0.2863664329,
0.5357546806,
0.5574638247,
0.2184975743,
0.2096800804,
1.0043996572,
0.712333858,
0.2650067806,
0.8414222598,
-0.1683776528,
0.0164635349,
-0.7357048988,
-0.3078860343,
-0.6065401435,
-0.5212345123,
-0.3938672841,
-0.0197300948,
0.1222421899,
0.234485656,
-0.1982880831,
0.183215037,
-0.8267353177,
0.1523889154,
0.7732462287,
0.1879476607,
0.3350611627,
-0.0800126269,
0.3575382829,
0.0710021257,
-0.6008626819,
-0.7207214832,
1.1925046444,
0.2398856133,
0.7187823653,
0.2985367477,
0.8702494502,
0.2605080903,
0.6483456492,
-0.8477903605,
0.6927909851,
-0.1430857629,
-0.5723987222,
-0.464813292,
-0.4060276449,
-0.6335206628,
-0.041252505,
-0.7300168872,
-0.8349141479,
0.3291199505,
0.3931642175,
-0.5208602548,
0.2598919272,
-0.9136444926,
0.7100620866,
-0.1764012426,
-0.4607587755,
0.029679982,
-0.5126758814,
0.3203385472,
-0.1893381476,
-0.15385288,
-0.2271758914,
-0.5191640854,
0.7701146007,
-0.2795406282,
0.8546000719,
-0.5569210649,
0.4177111089,
0.15049465,
-0.098549448,
0.3257033527,
0.2716314197,
-0.4012828469,
0.0038056369,
-0.5421900749,
-0.1847274005,
-0.679890871,
0.6990534067,
-0.3551054895,
-0.5130781531,
-0.0522190966,
-0.5958376527,
0.1319876015,
0.1540084332,
-0.1150900945,
0.419988364,
0.1154558063,
0.3199698329,
0.4054442346,
-0.0055813231,
0.845864594,
0.1460772306,
-0.1873405129,
-0.2064735889,
0.6901856065,
0.2477818578,
-0.0815670267,
0.2283761799,
0.2221281081,
-0.4957362115,
-0.6250849366,
-0.4858392775,
-0.2959513366,
-0.7784677148,
-0.3505593836,
-1.0518633127,
0.2582803667,
-0.4269586504,
-0.2860016525,
-0.1159920841,
-1.124065876,
-0.2435050905,
-0.2228196263,
0.9165215492,
0.6233839989,
-0.1249285415,
0.5926831365,
-0.4871375859,
0.2215300351,
0.557136476,
0.4228842556,
-0.1133691296,
-0.3187964261,
-0.1575869024,
-0.3416673243,
-0.1755128652,
-0.6343018413,
0.0265265405,
0.7195971012,
0.7059882283,
0.6143877506,
0.2124608308,
0.5582894087,
-0.0888925493,
0.8791570663,
0.0142431306,
-1.0203727484,
0.7724155188,
0.0714921802,
-0.0037606535,
0.7953513265,
0.4328970313,
-0.0091445632,
-0.4033589363,
-0.6734405756,
-1.2768836021,
0.616276443,
0.0282287635,
0.0489417836,
0.2255910933,
0.8411166072,
0.4663875997,
0.104490988,
-0.594527781,
-0.4377007186,
-0.3561554551,
-0.4003709257,
-0.1067275256,
0.0517029464,
-0.182619378,
-0.1604432613,
0.8435869813,
-0.2767056525,
-0.1109382436,
0.1652926207,
-0.2594843507,
0.3358728588,
0.1079044715,
0.1823821813,
0.5172557831,
-0.1922397912,
0.2746421993,
0.4198971689,
-0.3993709981,
-0.0558574088,
0.4950031042,
-0.3798215687,
0.227458477,
0.4267643392,
1.0224307775,
-0.1573112309,
-0.4812407196,
0.3584879041,
-0.1540320367,
0.0711900741,
-0.3218493462,
0.5379074216,
0.0182528961,
0.2679540813,
0.4964489937,
0.1766636819,
0.5872365236,
-0.1861365587,
0.4053272307,
0.3755942285,
-0.4135995805,
-0.0428149588,
0.5651425123,
0.514680624,
-0.7246843576,
0.460696727,
-0.4415711462,
-0.3030715585,
0.2380293906,
0.2059641033,
0.8063086271,
-0.2931007743,
0.0105357347,
0.4957906902,
0.1495160162,
-0.1597387791,
0.1061551198,
-0.2584522367,
-0.2915132046,
-0.6855424047,
-0.6337793469,
-0.5654033422,
-0.2393447608,
-0.7421839237,
0.2943559885,
-0.3147671223,
-0.4276183248,
0.2061533034,
0.0071511962,
-0.7278620601,
0.2380975038,
0.0721201301,
1.0249984264,
-0.8370163441,
0.7275494337,
1.2625973225,
-0.4329225719,
-0.7025377154,
-0.3093919456,
-0.1421678811,
-0.7769252658,
0.6976514459,
0.4090134799,
-0.0500988215,
-0.11475759,
-0.6293452978,
-0.4175507724,
1.0619134903,
0.3271226585,
-0.3897907734,
0.4053039551,
-0.3392252326,
0.5313476324,
-0.5054151416,
0.3602049649,
0.6195204258,
0.7419238687,
-0.391241163,
-0.6963796616,
0.2075431943,
-0.5051501393,
-0.2924037576,
0.1024114937,
-0.4019853473,
0.4530424774,
-0.1619012207,
-0.0020280858,
-0.1720013618,
0.7407768965,
-0.0564777181,
0.5159783363,
0.9144231677,
0.5313479304,
0.8851935863,
-0.3896938562,
0.9578691721,
-0.3274299502,
0.2468158603,
0.8425247669,
0.1358176023,
0.7947202325,
0.4911759794,
0.0493594781,
0.3304485977,
0.4624857605,
0.160108,
0.2016675323,
0.1267071068,
-0.5462688208,
-0.5673143864,
-0.336858809,
-0.0323584601,
0.4973267317,
0.4796716869,
-0.1905613989,
0.1041233093,
0.0581566729,
0.0524230376,
-0.0556381047,
-0.2468010932,
0.8957556486,
-0.1816984415,
-0.5111804008,
-0.0353695787,
-0.3110164702,
0.9944181442,
-0.8218774199,
-0.1732277274,
-0.0509753115,
-0.1292544305,
-0.5361934304,
-0.6276375651,
0.2060927749,
0.0015030288,
0.2190989405,
-0.1031341031,
0.7220700383,
-0.2954841256,
-0.5941160917,
0.1957591474,
0.5726143122,
0.2813014388,
-0.0068036951,
-0.6025678515,
0.1099347025,
0.0279639252,
-0.6909477711,
-0.0824864358,
0.5026407838,
0.0686572418,
0.736486733,
0.5353217125,
0.262586087,
0.0519653372,
0.162922889,
0.7739505768,
-0.4661565125,
-0.2717404664,
-0.6686448455,
0.5994520187,
-0.5788249969,
-0.4267635047,
0.5963916779,
0.4789831638,
0.4430450201,
0.1975539625,
1.1473653316,
-0.3902081549,
0.5333873034,
-0.1956293285,
0.5812407136,
-0.7599743605,
0.3067847192,
-0.2079313099,
-0.9701662064,
-0.833206594,
0.8732498288,
-0.1634487063,
0.1085439399,
0.4344005287,
0.5361151099,
-0.1139925048,
0.1480932534,
0.0627876744,
-0.2156082243,
0.3709173501,
0.0293812212,
0.4164918959,
0.0577359088,
0.5905097127,
-0.7250434756,
-0.574148953,
-0.5133928657,
-0.9011908174,
-0.6386306882,
-0.414473027,
-0.6097415686,
0.1642100215,
0.1936685592,
1.0503070354,
0.6845796108,
-0.6276501417,
0.1415996403,
0.1167616472,
-0.1022806391,
-0.4226336479,
-0.2414437234,
0.8542946577,
-0.902987361,
-0.9453294873,
0.1923946291,
0.2710923851,
-0.0542447269,
-0.0805735216,
-0.0167034306,
0.0805477351,
-0.2159556001,
0.5157889724,
0.1542886794,
-0.3207832873,
-0.3961952031,
-0.1762911528,
-0.0560060292,
-0.1139581352,
0.7042361498,
-0.6201720834,
0.640515089,
0.4944707453,
0.8915124536,
0.1065661982,
0.0531077683,
0.297870189,
-0.7164060473,
0.325001806,
0.2048346996,
0.4643048346,
0.516528964,
-0.4075095952,
0.7090277672,
0.0779728442,
-0.445340842,
-0.7918396592,
0.0159910638,
-1.1872928143,
-0.1680277139,
0.9185115695,
-0.583224535,
-0.099004738,
-0.3599707484,
-0.2448997796,
0.3723288178,
-0.7224276662,
0.7481523156,
0.4012458622,
-0.7494072914,
0.0155100692,
-0.5842069983,
0.6732865572,
0.4729654491,
-0.8540682197,
-0.0008940305,
0.5336210728,
-0.043776799,
0.5649318695,
0.3960564733,
0.0393198207,
0.1927144974,
0.003489997,
0.4301739931,
-0.4213436544,
-0.180397287,
-0.4368571937,
0.5407184958,
0.3616394401,
-0.3576388955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14163v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14163v2 | Leveraging Open Information Extraction for More Robust Domain Transfer of Event Trigger Detection | 2023-05-23T15:27:35 | 2024-02-01T17:34:22 | David Dukić, Kiril Gashteovski, Goran Glavaš, Jan Šnajder | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Event detection is a crucial information extraction task in many domains,
such as Wikipedia or news. The task typically relies on trigger detection (TD)
-- identifying token spans in the text that evoke specific events. While the
notion of triggers should ideally be universal across domains, domain transfer
for TD from high- to low-resource domains results in significant performance
drops. We address the problem of negative transfer in TD by coupling triggers
between domains using subject-object relations obtained from a rule-based open
information extraction (OIE) system. We demonstrate that OIE relations injected
through multi-task training can act as mediators between triggers in different
domains, enhancing zero- and few-shot TD domain transfer and reducing
performance drops, in particular when transferring from a high-resource source
domain (Wikipedia) to a low(er)-resource target domain (news). Additionally, we
combine this improved transfer with masked language modeling on the target
domain, observing further TD transfer gains. Finally, we demonstrate that the
gains are robust to the choice of the OIE system. | [
-0.5413357615,
-0.6419767141,
0.3501954973,
-0.2041747272,
-0.2176487744,
-0.4760380983,
-0.6219693422,
-0.9065582156,
-0.0221120212,
0.2563572228,
-0.4869150221,
-0.3453390896,
-0.6508359313,
-0.1254925728,
-0.1820497066,
1.1609516144,
-0.1946241111,
-0.521903038,
0.0730087683,
-0.1454737931,
-0.261765033,
-0.5852569342,
-0.5954687595,
-0.1429510266,
0.3521156013,
0.3520313799,
0.2119631022,
0.4850602448,
0.574565649,
0.0425942652,
0.2829355299,
0.2015524507,
-0.6412281394,
0.1190670058,
-0.6134420633,
-0.1801074892,
-0.4288076162,
-0.001597923,
0.4342305064,
0.4624682963,
0.1469427049,
0.494217515,
-0.0097592883,
0.2256142944,
-1.2614985704,
0.4162154496,
-0.6764070392,
0.0151849296,
-0.5380693674,
-0.3555775583,
-0.7101743221,
0.0239281803,
0.0834730491,
-0.8501597643,
0.3153938353,
-0.1430505216,
1.0373660326,
-0.0352803953,
-0.3258825243,
0.0729468465,
-0.8782361746,
0.6142348647,
-0.3072944283,
0.5156649947,
0.3327351213,
0.0567137487,
0.0573005341,
-0.5249955654,
-0.7691476941,
0.1116013229,
-0.0838398188,
-0.0951417014,
-0.4549026191,
-0.4194681048,
0.3450782001,
-0.1404229552,
-0.3444303572,
0.1209750473,
-0.3506184518,
-0.1176764295,
0.4432945549,
-0.1868462712,
0.2417662889,
-0.0082644606,
-0.4720773399,
-0.0333665945,
-0.8083636165,
0.0249064509,
0.2304733992,
0.6086724401,
0.0476822928,
0.4053136408,
-0.2166301161,
0.747243166,
0.2214583009,
-0.1954068244,
-0.0031409482,
-0.3971507549,
-0.1359011084,
0.132678777,
0.708793819,
0.2865650356,
0.4580447972,
-0.3446394205,
0.0953712761,
0.013482267,
0.1611688137,
-0.9530026913,
-0.0835738629,
-0.0862304419,
-0.6853281856,
-0.0545588993,
0.4108607769,
-0.8264271021,
-0.3015736341,
-0.219804883,
0.5473520756,
-0.4156817198,
-0.6692896485,
0.2536756694,
-0.2376460582,
0.1676034778,
0.5016554594,
-0.7297568321,
0.3465120494,
0.5871894956,
0.835126698,
-0.5932453275,
-0.1965221316,
-1.1314359903,
0.6364469528,
-0.0182441566,
0.9207445383,
-0.6017494798,
0.0004261592,
0.3496953249,
0.1223021075,
-0.369620651,
-0.4956376553,
0.520152092,
-0.9025456309,
0.147969678,
-0.1246055216,
-0.4060200453,
0.0820918828,
-0.1000432521,
-0.7931416035,
0.9275875688,
0.0352353118,
-0.6740404367,
0.5922795534,
-1.0043152571,
-0.7705888152,
-0.1172153428,
0.0485094227,
-0.2555428147,
-0.0326173492,
0.2033886462,
0.4575075507,
-0.0212269146,
-0.0758918375,
-0.4294844568,
-0.1329022944,
-0.0247626025,
-0.0713588744,
0.7092484832,
0.1539815366,
-0.41777426,
-0.1863592416,
-0.9239735603,
-0.320156306,
0.1254518479,
-0.344050318,
-0.6133253574,
-0.126850009,
0.0607284904,
0.2713516653,
0.0699347705,
-0.7076086402,
0.4614235163,
0.1562760174,
-0.0175072104,
0.4914232492,
0.2881782949,
0.7016895413,
-0.0492689759,
0.29102391,
0.4140881002,
0.068635039,
-0.1244023889,
-0.5463709235,
-0.4512041807,
-0.3381453454,
0.0993456617,
0.4736053944,
-0.8676502705,
0.4004868567,
-0.1798666418,
0.0727655515,
-0.2791731656,
-0.0653678849,
0.0436226577,
0.7216794491,
0.5367261171,
-0.3894020319,
-0.4561493993,
-0.3895342946,
-0.4614959061,
-0.2644450366,
-0.0279397648,
0.0527123846,
0.2448654175,
0.3075170815,
1.0206606388,
-0.8467276096,
-0.7402547598,
-0.0248534884,
0.4139352739,
0.0808601379,
0.3562721014,
0.7785750628,
-0.8720597029,
-0.4398049414,
0.3076810837,
-0.8180376291,
-0.1581050754,
0.0959603786,
-0.4287397861,
0.3303431571,
0.407923609,
-0.7068072557,
0.6881245375,
0.1520320326,
-0.4119706452,
0.5526590347,
0.4053073525,
0.4197480381,
-0.8690601587,
0.2636313736,
0.1754503399,
-0.2646348774,
-0.8341498971,
-0.1253906339,
0.1951438487,
-0.0898228139,
-0.7752389908,
0.7238093615,
-0.5143566728,
-0.1497117281,
-0.3516837656,
0.1803399324,
-0.0413873456,
0.5839147568,
0.1939562112,
0.8505762219,
0.4417456686,
-0.880805254,
0.170567438,
0.5871859193,
-0.2714142799,
0.9696054459,
0.0527570136,
0.0721246675,
0.0207784735,
-0.0781865567,
-0.3386280537,
-0.2465276569,
0.5329210162,
-0.3377114534,
0.5058535337,
-0.5106229782,
-0.3896850944,
0.0012214923,
-0.2822116315,
0.2663915455,
0.3790251911,
-0.7430110574,
0.4417331517,
0.464458406,
-0.0528798737,
-0.6017706394,
-0.3646106422,
0.1058671251,
-0.012547899,
-0.5763427615,
0.3869433403,
0.2057679296,
-0.1322192699,
0.6345881224,
-0.3054302037,
-0.4626951218,
0.0746292025,
0.1359547228,
0.2910619974,
-0.5456393361,
0.3180069625,
-0.1015631184,
0.0755261183,
-0.0523390211,
-0.6934598684,
0.1997029781,
0.3113792539,
-0.5471200347,
-0.6442696452,
0.4469066858,
0.4804958701,
-0.6202712655,
1.1685897112,
0.8346252441,
-0.7120577097,
-0.2117600739,
-0.4057305157,
-0.4616272151,
-0.34394449,
0.2442532629,
-0.5448259115,
-0.7942483425,
0.3728392422,
-0.3388290703,
-0.2154207826,
0.6363610625,
0.3323119581,
0.1893040538,
0.670653522,
0.9285454154,
-0.2842179239,
1.005661726,
-0.1607854515,
0.2458585054,
-0.7959331274,
0.0003347959,
-0.5990124345,
-0.0211719908,
0.0543578081,
-0.2350757569,
0.308482945,
0.3771083653,
-0.0031117871,
0.6400027871,
-0.0764414445,
0.3830619454,
0.6829110384,
0.0798559785,
0.611356914,
0.2244600803,
0.4479731321,
0.1881180853,
-0.6757124662,
-0.4153755605,
0.9079695344,
-0.0355185531,
0.7942624092,
0.3066866994,
0.6113111973,
0.43300879,
0.4252262115,
-0.5175486803,
0.3591770232,
-0.1535113752,
-0.6194046736,
-0.3872756064,
-0.3009788692,
-0.8553071022,
0.0287034828,
-0.4011827409,
-1.1167801619,
0.578186512,
-0.1940700114,
-0.2034544349,
0.7028746009,
-0.6780682206,
0.8503225446,
0.5431339145,
-0.4581453502,
0.0060643274,
-0.4017118216,
0.2841179967,
-0.2564755082,
0.0534992442,
-0.2812432647,
0.0247789677,
0.6713331342,
0.0578454547,
0.8422862887,
-0.1565953344,
-0.1449462622,
0.3953078091,
0.2488612831,
0.6446389556,
-0.1467375308,
-0.2644474506,
0.2855042517,
-0.440412432,
-0.1998597383,
-0.4972010851,
0.5382057428,
-0.6848301291,
-0.4033884704,
-0.0254054293,
-0.2633044124,
-0.0577489138,
0.3024720848,
0.2854106128,
0.3400265872,
-0.1724673212,
-0.0856103525,
0.5598670244,
0.242527023,
0.5871420503,
0.931679666,
0.2342637926,
0.0868575573,
0.8295046687,
0.0342350565,
0.4343501329,
0.4300929606,
-0.1266431212,
-0.0276343338,
-0.4759191573,
-0.7044766545,
0.0662861019,
-0.7410663366,
-0.5942698717,
-0.8156229258,
-0.2395813167,
-0.6484180689,
0.0688643083,
-0.0471652076,
-0.4071274698,
-0.7378154993,
-0.0663050935,
0.3475994766,
0.5024267435,
-0.3020381629,
0.1445209831,
-1.0699335337,
0.6072359681,
0.1835045666,
0.3976492286,
-0.1765630245,
-0.4500102997,
-0.4108231664,
-0.4120022058,
-0.4043618441,
-1.1584528685,
0.1498212814,
0.5718801618,
0.5708376765,
0.4509522021,
0.5920223594,
0.4736232162,
-0.5928979516,
0.740778923,
0.2457616925,
-1.1280858517,
0.7663033009,
-0.2389131635,
-0.1328595132,
0.2581065297,
0.6584844589,
-0.455676049,
-0.5633081198,
-0.4845341742,
-0.4647419155,
1.3315576315,
0.1784104556,
-0.209290579,
-0.1539574265,
0.3352446556,
0.2743564546,
0.2228090763,
-0.6768330932,
-0.139534533,
0.296258688,
-0.0177031849,
0.3490675986,
0.0030584107,
-0.1407559812,
0.301081568,
0.703089416,
-0.3604302108,
0.4161861837,
0.3689317107,
-0.4927281439,
-0.8053154349,
0.1721313745,
0.4432032108,
0.724658072,
-0.1987280697,
0.2591837347,
0.0073673255,
-0.5496382117,
0.0719908178,
0.3213847578,
-0.0197161175,
-0.0815734044,
0.7507925034,
0.7670187354,
0.0318176225,
-0.2063919455,
0.8855128288,
0.1080281809,
-0.0806908682,
0.4951394498,
0.0823184177,
-0.4450411201,
0.4823197424,
0.5861031413,
0.2446924448,
0.2714793086,
-0.5886918306,
0.434659034,
0.1746823192,
-0.3202014267,
-0.5130983591,
0.656517148,
0.2914298177,
-0.121996887,
0.3648037612,
-0.1169350296,
-0.578199923,
0.5125273466,
0.5675593615,
0.8238852024,
-0.243157804,
0.0635383949,
0.312489748,
0.2790699005,
0.1171963289,
0.1768149287,
-0.1829434484,
-0.7311879992,
-0.8325551152,
-0.4655001462,
-0.2996521294,
0.2164480537,
-0.9371774197,
0.4348852038,
0.2343058884,
-0.2046410441,
0.2921217084,
-0.2862139642,
-0.8545015454,
-0.2383314222,
0.3477959037,
0.9951330423,
-0.9479886889,
0.9618319869,
0.6186509728,
-0.5885575414,
-0.2874598503,
0.2936174273,
-0.1866837889,
-0.5783125162,
1.1709413528,
0.0497729667,
-0.0021493924,
-0.0694744661,
-0.231182918,
-0.6580148339,
0.6411489248,
0.5465522408,
-0.3093526363,
0.0886009559,
-0.0495000109,
0.3441518843,
-0.372490257,
-0.1928520352,
0.291122824,
0.3996309936,
-0.0599482954,
-1.2355909348,
0.3047621548,
0.1665413529,
-0.5917539001,
0.7463730574,
-0.2588599324,
0.8278411627,
-0.2784130573,
-0.6143718958,
-0.2498241067,
0.6052914858,
-0.374984771,
0.6513715982,
0.4257007241,
0.3607032597,
0.4966154099,
0.1363802403,
0.8151528239,
-0.3038740456,
0.5166655183,
1.0671875477,
-0.6800848246,
1.1653351784,
0.2734542489,
-0.1045790464,
0.4771612883,
0.1365983337,
0.3727783561,
0.7564209104,
-0.2369472682,
-0.595056951,
-0.2242111117,
-0.4518078566,
-0.3293893039,
0.3355287015,
0.2463272959,
-0.2357608378,
-0.5124298334,
0.4887187481,
-0.0362279341,
-0.1834027469,
-0.3817424476,
1.0901092291,
-0.107051827,
-0.7179250717,
0.3353175223,
-0.0852038488,
0.3906069696,
-0.5115817785,
-0.1614275873,
0.1191820353,
0.2447829694,
-0.118782185,
-0.8430650234,
0.4056662321,
0.1111067235,
-0.4265512824,
-0.1157654896,
1.433967948,
-0.6115850806,
0.2384709865,
0.5479307175,
0.7822600603,
0.0163707193,
-0.3430315852,
-0.0511845388,
0.1664965898,
-0.3483199775,
-0.3395659626,
0.4809011221,
0.7601802349,
-0.3428007364,
-0.0162717719,
0.9319863915,
0.1414491683,
0.1038114354,
-0.0723216161,
1.1573945284,
-0.50258255,
-0.3645024896,
-0.713098526,
0.2641437352,
-0.4348133802,
-0.0863279179,
0.4880048633,
0.3481044769,
0.977191925,
-0.3108955026,
0.8355984092,
-0.1977390647,
0.1688573211,
-0.501865983,
0.4498976767,
-0.2425079644,
-0.1679453999,
0.0180077571,
-0.8777412772,
-0.350497514,
0.2056669146,
-0.2118095607,
-0.391143322,
0.6953542233,
0.4533440173,
-0.3513671756,
0.0452467836,
0.5131733418,
-0.0403379835,
0.4043826163,
0.5939839482,
0.7071182132,
-0.3410739005,
0.6880634427,
-0.1069373116,
-0.4865755737,
-0.5362779498,
-1.1929814816,
-0.9416194558,
-0.6238822341,
-0.6756685376,
-0.2550581396,
0.2913336754,
0.6998820305,
1.2057999372,
-0.9999158978,
0.0722940415,
0.3354988396,
0.100907661,
-0.4274471998,
-0.3028556406,
0.4396808147,
-0.5316061974,
-0.4716329873,
0.3529142737,
0.3715442419,
-0.013600653,
0.2183068246,
0.2733794153,
-0.4102984965,
-0.0249302797,
0.8353981972,
0.4763716757,
-0.2980396748,
-0.679390192,
-0.1171462014,
-0.1146740839,
-0.0009263342,
1.0164983273,
-0.6948508024,
0.1768302768,
0.432187289,
0.6492514014,
0.5912633538,
-0.2460177839,
0.4051803052,
-1.1037635803,
0.2028977722,
-0.0762679502,
0.1426795423,
0.0223066937,
-0.6565474272,
0.7216302752,
0.5183403492,
-0.1987271011,
-0.7368241549,
0.2393993884,
-0.9116590023,
-0.2722007334,
1.1928952932,
-0.3481122255,
-0.3452750444,
-0.2794929743,
-0.1880965233,
0.4131374359,
-0.5223913789,
0.4048082232,
0.6591238379,
-0.2709446251,
0.0420640633,
-0.5632714033,
0.6165336967,
-0.2563537359,
-1.1442370415,
0.0655010343,
0.395165801,
0.2284508198,
0.5649341941,
0.5589292049,
0.0378837213,
0.4965419173,
-0.2673871815,
0.3684566915,
-0.2088594437,
-0.6375688314,
-0.1500836164,
0.4240801334,
-0.2299078256,
-0.6907966733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14160v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14160v4 | Label Words are Anchors: An Information Flow Perspective for Understanding In-Context Learning | 2023-05-23T15:26:20 | 2023-12-19T15:13:52 | Lean Wang, Lei Li, Damai Dai, Deli Chen, Hao Zhou, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Xu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In-context learning (ICL) emerges as a promising capability of large language
models (LLMs) by providing them with demonstration examples to perform diverse
tasks. However, the underlying mechanism of how LLMs learn from the provided
context remains under-explored. In this paper, we investigate the working
mechanism of ICL through an information flow lens. Our findings reveal that
label words in the demonstration examples function as anchors: (1) semantic
information aggregates into label word representations during the shallow
computation layers' processing; (2) the consolidated information in label words
serves as a reference for LLMs' final predictions. Based on these insights, we
introduce an anchor re-weighting method to improve ICL performance, a
demonstration compression technique to expedite inference, and an analysis
framework for diagnosing ICL errors in GPT2-XL. The promising applications of
our findings again validate the uncovered ICL working mechanism and pave the
way for future studies. | [
-0.2172156274,
-0.5619463921,
0.5232180357,
-0.07574898,
-0.4449282885,
0.190043509,
-0.1406860203,
-0.2952901423,
-0.4503132701,
0.2021628022,
-0.4292832911,
-0.4303245544,
-0.7160872817,
-0.0502577089,
-0.463344872,
1.3147237301,
-0.2558684051,
-0.079980813,
-0.4669480324,
-0.1151300296,
-0.3779884875,
-0.2216904312,
-0.7597287893,
-0.6265923977,
0.4044055343,
0.7035395503,
0.452208817,
0.9045473933,
0.1496222317,
0.1766777337,
-0.0420461968,
-0.0739251897,
-0.5967192054,
-0.0154154971,
-0.2069544941,
-0.5856618881,
0.0973486826,
0.0954922065,
1.0195471048,
0.9057257175,
0.0889480785,
0.140562728,
0.6976107955,
0.5018746853,
-0.668340981,
0.3261751235,
-0.6597254276,
-0.1152354032,
-0.2783617973,
-0.1896584034,
-0.669634521,
-0.0440393277,
0.2684850395,
-0.3499939442,
-0.1001439542,
0.0856615975,
0.8097682595,
0.3857935071,
-0.380579114,
-0.6152696609,
-0.2948687673,
0.6317828298,
-0.6547745466,
0.284396261,
0.2089476287,
0.1323787123,
-0.1656251401,
-0.8481874466,
-0.389318496,
-0.1412075758,
-0.185407564,
-0.0361775868,
0.0462966226,
0.0233176295,
0.3829846382,
-0.0929679722,
-0.1995131671,
0.2186604589,
-0.3346409202,
0.0320422091,
0.198189199,
-0.2125264704,
0.1979397833,
0.2545300424,
-0.7831639647,
-0.1228444651,
-1.1368666887,
0.2780169845,
-0.1276808381,
0.186175704,
-0.4386156499,
0.2526885569,
0.0179827083,
0.7187492847,
0.1856830865,
-0.3734457195,
0.2070863843,
0.2438998818,
-0.2605892718,
0.6482866406,
0.309458971,
0.1925193816,
-0.0153581193,
-0.2115599662,
-0.1944620013,
-0.3014322519,
-0.1065865979,
-0.7090297937,
-0.1326106191,
-0.0096292561,
-0.2362768799,
-0.1062156186,
0.2148557305,
-0.3158529699,
-0.1968102306,
-0.3042685986,
0.585711658,
-0.2926726043,
-0.1172159314,
-0.2749183476,
-0.2353540808,
0.4177321792,
0.1411601603,
-0.4564720094,
0.2133796662,
0.7910479903,
0.7445803881,
-0.2063859552,
-0.3084750772,
-0.7588266134,
0.5840035677,
-0.3461767137,
0.6433002353,
-0.626832664,
-0.2232168019,
0.2290595621,
0.0550844818,
-0.1133632511,
-0.5122959018,
0.3782551587,
-0.5598427653,
-0.186580047,
-0.3360432982,
-0.8122864962,
-0.3425147533,
0.1474905908,
-0.4694534242,
0.8413894773,
0.036164932,
-0.724255681,
0.6553609371,
-0.6157262325,
-0.3663259447,
0.2886398137,
-0.1594638079,
-0.3046473265,
0.2341644466,
-0.2339044064,
0.4937363863,
-0.228577584,
0.2695482373,
-0.2330496758,
-0.5766763091,
0.5822778344,
-0.2836296558,
0.52688241,
0.0297648907,
-0.6283159256,
-0.2535474002,
-0.5151928067,
-0.0788741559,
-0.310228169,
-0.5876207948,
-0.4525466859,
0.1869431585,
-0.4753866494,
0.3104310632,
-0.1671174616,
-0.4359153211,
0.3092089891,
-0.162717849,
0.3560969532,
0.689788878,
-0.0944991559,
0.4183154702,
0.0678210258,
0.2892444432,
0.1841078699,
-0.0994045883,
-0.3453405499,
-0.538626194,
-0.7647400498,
-0.0935694501,
0.0734652579,
0.2510988116,
-0.9331220388,
-0.2588998377,
-0.2041575909,
-0.1439254731,
-0.445535779,
0.1991262585,
0.8543118834,
1.182071209,
0.3192577064,
0.0319831185,
-0.1053151935,
-0.785458982,
-0.3653833568,
-0.2635269165,
0.0582133047,
0.2264365107,
0.4595653117,
0.0165232196,
0.9566532969,
-0.3056603074,
-0.0618330911,
-0.2148163617,
0.5660796762,
0.1568223834,
0.3649604619,
0.3214955926,
-1.0199745893,
-0.5897232294,
-0.1500793695,
-0.7181423306,
-0.3569743931,
0.1591780633,
-0.026823163,
0.1077985242,
0.952637434,
-0.1847179383,
0.5104156137,
0.4402751625,
-0.3469215333,
0.364470154,
-0.1869320124,
-0.2945023179,
-0.5988430381,
-0.3793390095,
0.0309988279,
0.0489331819,
-0.5404962301,
-0.0016804012,
0.3576422632,
0.0621408597,
-0.6360481977,
0.5507126451,
-0.6044023633,
-0.0552375726,
-0.6593943238,
0.2526883483,
0.0400137119,
0.2874083817,
-0.0158542767,
0.7567929029,
0.764939487,
-0.9035026431,
-0.0570529997,
-0.2525389194,
-0.3455344737,
0.6019307971,
-0.354177475,
0.1772153825,
-0.4895816445,
0.2460419983,
-1.2778110504,
-0.251234293,
0.3016758561,
-0.1649340838,
0.8632968664,
-0.2801592946,
-0.4158888757,
-0.1859742999,
-0.1372275949,
0.5589160323,
0.3481630981,
-0.8440265059,
0.2486453503,
0.4751478732,
0.2034215629,
-0.5294060111,
-0.7828463316,
0.0681624189,
-0.5444114804,
-0.3196278811,
0.5550350547,
0.0372581109,
-0.3755170703,
0.1337916851,
0.0669627339,
-0.1489396244,
0.2861055434,
0.3339598179,
0.0123671042,
-0.2852756083,
0.5754624605,
0.1215720624,
-0.1451640427,
0.21064125,
-0.6977362037,
0.0331424624,
-0.2369864285,
-0.3284695446,
-0.347998023,
0.1732780188,
0.4066805243,
0.1380372196,
0.7856767774,
0.477624774,
-0.295180887,
-0.4060096741,
-0.3351526856,
-0.1971368492,
-0.451811254,
0.3115537465,
-0.3390305042,
-0.7813878059,
0.1072576642,
-0.4596387744,
-0.2038190812,
0.2683849335,
0.238228634,
-0.3242971897,
0.7628743649,
0.7608582973,
-0.0798772126,
0.2325408757,
-0.2535687685,
0.388120234,
-1.1582896709,
-0.3044230044,
-0.292758137,
-0.4232481122,
-0.2415522039,
-0.4916702509,
0.5927763581,
0.7097414732,
-0.190081656,
0.1682109982,
-0.2824774086,
0.4598418176,
0.4598623812,
-0.0198423099,
0.1834805012,
-0.0799803287,
-0.4280321002,
0.1043581516,
-0.7170295119,
-0.5037891269,
0.750772953,
0.3047307134,
0.9299655557,
-0.1008313075,
0.4040333331,
0.1334783137,
0.8418406844,
-0.54708606,
0.4624785781,
0.0597318225,
-0.1914370358,
-0.1827094108,
0.1936872303,
-0.6328214407,
0.0927481726,
0.0880130306,
-1.0187669992,
0.1319878101,
0.2958394289,
0.2029214203,
0.3867057264,
-0.7423105836,
0.6034278274,
-0.3099558949,
-0.6030353904,
-0.0399150439,
-0.7051683068,
0.2823527455,
-0.1016404703,
0.3344764709,
0.032087706,
-0.2485215515,
0.6733212471,
-0.4767963588,
0.9111478329,
-0.2958365977,
-0.239014253,
0.555364728,
-0.0975275189,
0.6064795852,
-0.0191832855,
0.0224607121,
0.0542233139,
-0.54567343,
-0.1226752475,
-0.6679093838,
0.6888534427,
-0.259039849,
-0.4866758883,
-0.1347138584,
-0.4492563307,
-0.1405870318,
-0.2558025718,
0.4799950123,
0.810485363,
0.527885139,
0.4318246543,
0.6931484342,
-0.0025573801,
0.7110984325,
0.5659326315,
0.0830495954,
0.082136929,
0.834485054,
0.2157805413,
0.4130868018,
0.657521069,
0.3029887378,
-0.3235951662,
-0.6306918263,
-0.3430696428,
0.2353869379,
-0.9764217138,
-0.226834327,
-0.3597948551,
-0.0753977224,
-0.0206920877,
-0.3197188377,
-0.0831828266,
-0.0075652064,
0.0086578848,
-0.2977006435,
0.1467978954,
0.7708007693,
0.0357031114,
0.4237405956,
-0.5034601688,
-0.2343404144,
0.2774333954,
0.1883666515,
0.1983384192,
-0.4226741195,
-0.6423567533,
-0.057181377,
-0.3721733689,
-0.8814325929,
-0.004948209,
0.4668053687,
0.6490157247,
0.766597867,
-0.0121000065,
0.7429920435,
-0.3984716833,
0.7196436524,
-0.1505697519,
-0.9956381321,
0.5428278446,
0.0457946807,
0.35386765,
0.3410540819,
0.5755361319,
-0.341612488,
-0.6212679148,
-0.5162275434,
-0.9582301974,
0.5341217518,
-0.1167152673,
-0.1444848925,
-0.1977711469,
0.5609360337,
0.0243563782,
0.3479265273,
-0.7976660132,
-0.3201369643,
0.2944268584,
-0.1083696187,
0.1162003055,
-0.5045810938,
-0.02416352,
-0.154777348,
0.6519538164,
-0.5031524301,
0.0932831168,
0.269690752,
-0.4544719458,
0.1587660015,
0.0941377208,
0.4377766252,
0.8325199485,
0.0769913271,
0.3233276904,
0.2304216772,
-0.2622646093,
0.1293003857,
-0.2046113312,
-0.3467993736,
-0.1141212657,
0.6855684519,
0.940061748,
0.8707199097,
-0.6259095669,
0.5972506404,
0.1400131583,
0.1485357583,
-0.1008143947,
-0.0460952632,
-0.0598351285,
0.3157454729,
0.6266514063,
-0.3299435973,
0.3082842827,
-0.6717127562,
0.5081939101,
0.531273663,
-0.9180508256,
-0.3075414002,
0.6944542527,
-0.1709634513,
-0.1703607738,
0.5440198779,
-0.2053290606,
-0.6329508424,
0.5721238852,
0.8776432872,
0.8681286573,
-0.0467130877,
0.1446003616,
0.2372760475,
0.0330687016,
0.0201405492,
-0.119872041,
-0.409912467,
-0.594807744,
-0.6674519777,
-0.4002314806,
-0.2911012173,
-0.0900716707,
-0.6422677636,
0.2223518789,
-0.1465272158,
0.1673801243,
-0.3737825751,
-0.4043937922,
-0.5476525426,
0.262938112,
0.5453192592,
1.0262571573,
-0.8565943837,
0.9479581118,
0.7169113159,
-0.0973867178,
-1.0070807934,
0.3244027197,
0.1728463769,
-0.6952117085,
1.3707283735,
0.4469630718,
-0.3745073974,
-0.0151072191,
-0.9471527934,
-1.0970181227,
1.127809763,
0.2437260598,
-0.1092138439,
0.0074945455,
0.1018040329,
0.1679086834,
-0.8268523812,
0.3187494576,
0.3854861259,
0.410482645,
0.1523384601,
-0.5500931144,
0.1221624017,
0.0182643496,
-0.1456790715,
0.0889312401,
-0.5024664402,
0.8834821582,
-0.2635275424,
-0.3481147587,
-0.1710045785,
0.6015154123,
0.2619624734,
0.4337773919,
0.4784557521,
0.4863110781,
0.8411902785,
-0.2804724276,
1.1809004545,
-0.381462723,
0.2697724998,
1.1807341576,
-0.1690438837,
0.8164770603,
0.6221202612,
0.1065792963,
0.8458663821,
0.4268401563,
0.3793957829,
0.6869245768,
0.3057956398,
-0.3642026782,
0.0274610836,
-0.4277241528,
-0.1010818854,
0.4057734609,
0.7318873405,
-0.3654059768,
-0.492754668,
0.3923617601,
0.2060322016,
-0.2894359529,
-0.6074437499,
0.7644604445,
0.2847662568,
-0.8933396935,
0.4562556148,
-0.2787063122,
0.2905185521,
-0.5406545401,
-0.4192938805,
0.1658490151,
0.3221985102,
-0.054325249,
-0.976883769,
0.0351342708,
-0.2847042382,
-0.0446450636,
-0.3165001869,
0.8225842118,
-0.5495577455,
-0.0793005452,
0.50947541,
-0.07148844,
0.3523096442,
-0.0047136149,
-0.4805116355,
0.027028488,
-0.119320862,
0.0380700417,
0.4163016677,
0.6506764889,
-0.2827419937,
0.8545029759,
0.2390266955,
-0.0308108199,
0.2745746374,
-0.1464623064,
0.8308825493,
-0.3510006666,
-0.4584329724,
-1.0281074047,
0.8184608817,
-0.1832541525,
-0.3219854534,
0.7094720602,
0.4940959513,
1.1812041998,
-0.0009949952,
0.7129086256,
0.1841283888,
0.3382799029,
-0.8695222139,
0.3966905773,
-0.4808885753,
0.2295511067,
-0.3294756114,
-0.7208675146,
-0.1803453267,
0.2280595154,
-0.2136626691,
-0.4100497961,
0.8813903928,
0.5219174027,
0.0808078945,
-0.1997082382,
0.1157316342,
0.3551984727,
0.291973412,
0.5881265402,
0.6429770589,
-0.3750033975,
0.3897116184,
-0.3241223693,
-0.4083218575,
-0.3389541209,
-1.2190808058,
-0.7153099775,
-0.7866169214,
-0.5681170821,
-0.351785481,
0.0976969376,
0.6419137716,
0.7890087962,
-0.479816258,
-0.3380763829,
-0.053825479,
0.4053618908,
-0.2744284868,
-0.257316947,
0.4893005788,
-0.6201487184,
-0.5765185356,
0.4975604713,
0.5933110118,
-0.1172762886,
0.0373384133,
-0.1928816587,
-0.0979248434,
-0.3716868162,
0.5978100896,
0.4524243176,
-0.6377874613,
-0.217680335,
-0.667316854,
0.0981397256,
0.072407715,
0.9076587558,
-0.9892591238,
0.5584180951,
0.335088253,
0.7430530787,
0.332999438,
0.1535288543,
0.5667408109,
-0.7718128562,
0.1953792721,
-0.1004413813,
0.4207827151,
0.33624506,
-0.2599170506,
0.4160936475,
0.1296875924,
-0.3796245158,
-0.6738843918,
0.2239555866,
-0.3804494143,
-0.2090706378,
1.0888211727,
-0.2484273314,
-0.572163105,
-0.161303848,
-0.0285773464,
0.244902879,
-0.171245113,
0.4413923621,
0.6765549183,
-0.1836335361,
-0.1141020283,
-0.5797388554,
0.6647960544,
-0.0180200692,
-0.4010980129,
-0.2437433153,
0.0363093168,
0.1750324667,
0.1682980359,
0.4560462534,
-0.0175254475,
-0.0008401387,
-0.3604228795,
-0.3992427886,
0.0919279754,
-0.5652391911,
-0.2845400274,
0.2584314644,
0.186495468,
-0.2770487666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14150v1 | WYWEB: A NLP Evaluation Benchmark For Classical Chinese | 2023-05-23T15:15:11 | 2023-05-23T15:15:11 | Bo Zhou, Qianglong Chen, Tianyu Wang, Xiaomi Zhong, Yin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To fully evaluate the overall performance of different NLP models in a given
domain, many evaluation benchmarks are proposed, such as GLUE, SuperGLUE and
CLUE. The fi eld of natural language understanding has traditionally focused on
benchmarks for various tasks in languages such as Chinese, English, and
multilingua, however, there has been a lack of attention given to the area of
classical Chinese, also known as "wen yan wen", which has a rich history
spanning thousands of years and holds signifi cant cultural and academic value.
For the prosperity of the NLP community, in this paper, we introduce the WYWEB
evaluation benchmark, which consists of nine NLP tasks in classical Chinese,
implementing sentence classifi cation, sequence labeling, reading
comprehension, and machine translation. We evaluate the existing pre-trained
language models, which are all struggling with this benchmark. We also
introduce a number of supplementary datasets and additional tools to help
facilitate further progress on classical Chinese NLU. The github repository is
https://github.com/baudzhou/WYWEB. | [
-0.4412088692,
-0.6433976889,
0.1505656242,
0.5285845399,
-0.119794637,
-0.2379696518,
-0.4930455387,
-0.6218581796,
-0.0903175548,
0.1398889124,
-0.3753248155,
-0.3371576369,
-0.2427478582,
0.193578124,
-0.4439879656,
0.8533927202,
0.2985053658,
0.0816144422,
-0.0711761862,
-0.1665366143,
-0.1917400062,
-0.1156634837,
-0.4577377141,
-0.4794741273,
0.5573115349,
-0.0516435802,
0.5915662646,
0.6461939216,
0.5480863452,
0.3892272115,
-0.1412639022,
0.1122223511,
-0.2945735157,
-0.2190261036,
-0.4295317233,
-0.1779938638,
-0.3625639379,
0.0788804963,
0.4588756561,
0.9180999398,
-0.3610842228,
0.6121944785,
0.1838837266,
0.7949602604,
-0.8454349041,
0.0752329379,
-0.4967193604,
0.0425288044,
-0.356210351,
0.0156211695,
-0.3101738393,
-0.5924455523,
0.5128993392,
-0.6708969474,
0.079523392,
0.000381787,
0.9174305201,
-0.0360961519,
-0.3497635722,
-0.0803047642,
-0.1890113056,
0.6857148409,
-1.0739636421,
0.3794788718,
0.1888376623,
0.2049808055,
-0.2190900892,
-1.00360322,
-0.5840529203,
-0.302808404,
0.0298890192,
0.3112292886,
-0.18114838,
0.0726551563,
0.2130706459,
0.4639761746,
-0.9793199897,
0.1572913826,
-0.1846786588,
-0.1093407348,
0.5602986813,
0.0270464774,
0.4140591919,
-0.1979235709,
-0.3934379816,
-0.2629486024,
-0.0859063193,
0.2325990349,
0.2690273523,
0.2043566555,
0.1152461469,
0.140003249,
-0.5027886033,
1.0801224709,
-0.1894466281,
-0.3429959714,
0.2006109059,
-0.0964061692,
-0.241179347,
-0.0863059983,
0.9291373491,
0.4655492306,
0.3077885807,
-0.3675134778,
-0.1733873487,
0.0970504656,
0.1404620707,
-0.6668045521,
-0.2573874295,
0.1341745704,
-0.7883397341,
-0.0217702743,
0.2755397558,
-0.5957003236,
-0.2962840199,
-0.2711313963,
0.415204376,
-0.4760224819,
-0.4166701436,
0.1829892099,
-0.4981504679,
0.3358347714,
0.1873497218,
-0.792265594,
0.4110017121,
0.7432257533,
0.631949544,
-0.1082267165,
-0.6907459497,
-0.2594070435,
-0.0530031621,
-0.5012822747,
0.6814427972,
-0.2972609699,
0.0734029114,
0.1789605319,
-0.0842221379,
-0.0033151105,
-0.4701124132,
0.7166856527,
-0.4237214625,
0.1227463111,
-0.1562748998,
-0.3752755821,
-0.5381190181,
0.2554292679,
-0.65292418,
0.8125125766,
0.0394591317,
-0.7991195321,
0.0241075102,
-0.4314955473,
-0.6750750542,
0.2919834852,
0.4385179877,
0.1057899147,
0.2607194185,
0.0578932688,
0.1779224277,
-0.5925473571,
0.4048776925,
-0.3419981897,
-0.4603759348,
0.2175641507,
-0.398838222,
0.9121081829,
0.1753870696,
-0.437916398,
0.1550232619,
-0.8910530806,
0.4738986194,
-0.0423810743,
-0.231887117,
-0.6404716969,
-0.1188955307,
0.5186020732,
0.1450691521,
0.547308743,
-0.3490546644,
0.2859923542,
-0.3616944849,
0.2908118963,
0.6869532466,
-0.4641164243,
-0.0040338365,
-0.0736180395,
0.3758083582,
-0.5863982439,
0.1763946414,
0.0704956874,
-0.3318626583,
-0.8285247087,
0.3135948181,
0.7667376399,
0.5879330635,
-0.7471776009,
0.5313313603,
-0.1927646846,
-0.7539715767,
-0.6407884955,
0.1558711827,
0.6164875627,
0.3086377978,
0.4163826406,
-0.2015576214,
-0.4451293945,
-0.9612218738,
-0.4166793227,
-0.2002080828,
-0.2309176773,
-0.1922046393,
0.2841871083,
-0.2037685812,
0.5608910918,
-0.3535064459,
-0.2858593166,
-0.4738239646,
0.396633774,
0.3015237749,
0.3106897473,
0.196493715,
-0.7652285099,
-0.4406060278,
0.1886267811,
-0.6432434916,
-0.3436649144,
-0.1808086485,
-0.2261248827,
-0.0684858412,
0.2318175584,
-0.3464384377,
0.1369026303,
0.8301074505,
-0.1313522309,
0.9229854345,
-0.1699743569,
0.0536847338,
-0.8283539414,
0.406804353,
0.3316873014,
-0.0725641325,
-0.4651807249,
0.5022721887,
0.3840945065,
0.0640123785,
-0.4099898934,
0.40450719,
-0.4951981604,
0.030541053,
-0.4070727229,
0.655825913,
-0.0764822215,
0.4612593353,
0.1542022824,
0.3444984257,
0.2325647473,
-0.6574646235,
0.5410594344,
-0.0136842094,
-0.3837177753,
0.3283328712,
-0.6358611584,
-0.0406601578,
0.3150981665,
0.0369788818,
-0.4549248815,
0.1490916312,
-0.2610177696,
-0.2417809814,
0.123865515,
-0.0184361711,
-0.5573769808,
-0.5079930425,
-0.4653978944,
-0.0097072804,
0.3082081676,
-0.5471459627,
0.225813657,
0.135720253,
0.2244240195,
-0.9117905498,
-0.5606633425,
0.192302376,
-0.0598226227,
-0.62531811,
0.490618825,
-0.0091453055,
-0.1895234436,
0.0645035729,
-0.1932645291,
-0.1465578377,
0.2100203633,
-0.2424716353,
0.221076116,
-0.4760207534,
-0.1078193709,
-0.1222882792,
-0.2380055785,
-0.0055408059,
-0.3965317607,
0.5424052477,
-0.4423006475,
-0.0473321266,
-0.5673884749,
-0.0729275793,
0.124208957,
-0.4680205882,
0.4646579027,
0.9743002653,
-0.5072462559,
-0.2547214925,
-0.5576114058,
0.0047988566,
-0.5000041127,
0.4290545583,
-0.3238450885,
-0.3815454543,
0.2178739309,
-0.2856182754,
0.2792471647,
0.504016459,
0.2854779363,
-0.0894345343,
0.59327209,
0.6768528223,
-0.3668905795,
0.2666601539,
-0.1570369303,
-0.0553470217,
-0.9020557404,
0.1660192311,
-0.5379061699,
-0.4121427238,
-0.8189157248,
-0.0953668207,
0.039307598,
0.5633647442,
0.1384916604,
0.6320322752,
-0.3583169281,
0.2439894229,
0.7267211676,
-0.0516936332,
0.4042418599,
-0.5011003017,
-0.0239489097,
-0.064695403,
-0.5647835732,
-0.6038517952,
0.8230483532,
-0.0419443361,
0.6264041662,
0.1925738305,
0.4726633728,
0.2740696967,
0.2424618453,
-0.5519167781,
0.5213059187,
-0.3020322919,
-0.4310528636,
-0.3709601164,
-0.3664124012,
-1.0886495113,
0.675683856,
-0.1111276671,
-0.9138051867,
-0.0820487142,
-0.0322920643,
-0.1228701994,
0.2350180894,
-0.5876852274,
1.3339164257,
-0.366625458,
-0.4486135542,
-0.3508267105,
-0.4977511764,
0.626939714,
0.2233075947,
0.3041442037,
0.0324535742,
0.0787865072,
0.7590662837,
-0.1949364841,
0.5318090916,
-0.0554632619,
-0.0213062521,
0.1681000739,
-0.089598611,
0.2442527115,
0.0025835466,
-0.0392108895,
-0.0030046683,
0.5083616376,
-0.3490815759,
-0.4174556434,
0.6477920413,
-0.4316857755,
-0.4358781278,
-0.6372640133,
-0.3993763328,
-0.1754241586,
0.3298264146,
0.0169511065,
0.527041018,
-0.449410826,
0.2669343948,
0.459869504,
-0.4966932833,
0.8237266541,
0.7597560287,
-0.3992502689,
-0.0991392583,
1.0223792791,
-0.0310670994,
0.1288643032,
0.5402034521,
0.4398020506,
-0.308131516,
-0.6777128577,
-0.5560634136,
0.035174448,
-0.5913036466,
-0.1116779968,
-0.3649712503,
-0.1164035648,
-0.2698703408,
0.1745162904,
-0.3341160417,
-0.3124711812,
0.1814485937,
0.1287513822,
0.0310145747,
0.6544476151,
-0.2546543181,
0.0516396016,
-0.8385077715,
0.5901864767,
0.2012356222,
0.3588002324,
0.3951389194,
-0.3817636371,
-0.3838618398,
-0.1425886899,
-0.4331790805,
-0.663300395,
0.2603423297,
0.2529238462,
0.7816190124,
0.7034363747,
0.3747799397,
0.8771880865,
-0.5989536047,
0.6577095389,
0.1643904448,
-1.1695792675,
0.4556600451,
-0.1623881608,
0.367347151,
0.4901985824,
0.3023200333,
-1.1594434977,
-0.2926945984,
-0.4734638035,
-0.7670947909,
0.3854342103,
-0.0857506022,
-0.001758994,
0.1625554115,
0.0358195528,
0.1608343422,
0.1680407077,
-0.9758208394,
-0.3969206512,
-0.196796909,
-0.0786616281,
0.0361359604,
-0.002183279,
0.0855577067,
-0.1799940318,
0.6407826543,
-0.2037099153,
-0.2219224125,
0.1186167523,
-0.5565485954,
0.2090633214,
0.3339506686,
0.3158954084,
1.0265399218,
-0.2300470769,
-0.0905426443,
0.112440072,
-0.5042894483,
-0.3263065219,
0.3486854732,
-0.1382634789,
-0.0330497287,
0.837449491,
0.4386879206,
0.1263762116,
-0.8193275928,
0.3253228664,
-0.0839122385,
0.0685672462,
-0.1209644005,
-0.0380080044,
0.3419682086,
0.1923846602,
0.6893004179,
-0.2959297597,
0.68028301,
-0.6767769456,
0.1487780511,
0.3501743078,
-0.3968229592,
-0.2806491852,
0.5026994944,
0.2136287987,
-0.1687245518,
0.4528233111,
-0.5595683455,
-0.6483521461,
0.4554169178,
0.6401237845,
0.7192378044,
-0.0895063728,
0.2426083833,
0.4705205858,
0.5612050891,
-0.1173823401,
0.2145274132,
0.076278761,
-0.5228474736,
-0.367254585,
-0.8552308679,
-0.4193611443,
0.2910785973,
-0.9726312757,
0.0969898179,
-0.35904634,
-0.0447403975,
-0.1491657346,
0.2670481503,
-0.522629261,
0.3186141551,
0.1785252541,
1.0580450296,
-0.4880355597,
1.0375974178,
0.511400044,
-0.346037358,
-0.4520561993,
0.2474363893,
-0.033767622,
-0.3512111604,
0.488869518,
0.391551286,
-0.0274668206,
-0.0084584933,
-0.1618657261,
-0.6229357123,
0.7942178845,
0.0839205831,
-0.7697841525,
0.0687591061,
-0.2247867584,
0.7288232446,
0.2139755636,
0.3805593252,
0.6669325233,
0.7088532448,
-0.6646066308,
-1.147446394,
0.0475920774,
-0.5281208158,
0.1979268044,
-0.0514660105,
-0.6789654493,
0.590945065,
-0.048604887,
-0.2329975516,
0.3388294578,
0.774433136,
0.1584860831,
0.2199160755,
0.514885664,
0.5095480084,
0.6862801313,
-0.3635137081,
0.9964836836,
-0.2908896208,
0.2652331293,
0.9861751795,
0.0503308773,
1.0930159092,
0.2599212229,
-0.6151844859,
0.5321916342,
0.7813176513,
-0.0887465551,
0.5073602796,
0.6283012629,
0.0884582922,
-0.0444791615,
-0.1786116958,
-0.5660007596,
0.3615881205,
0.2206555605,
0.2254729867,
-0.0658503622,
-0.111006014,
-0.1279428899,
0.3375644088,
-0.2550505102,
0.6773088574,
0.0799172148,
-0.6042125225,
0.7160518169,
0.3558807373,
1.0546457767,
-0.9260267615,
0.0393578783,
-0.1912588328,
0.2976082265,
-0.253046304,
-0.4675786793,
-0.118033126,
-0.2155154645,
0.0668877661,
0.1010906249,
0.4486303031,
-0.3094605505,
-0.4785467088,
0.6739185452,
0.3964891434,
0.1175030619,
-0.1573100835,
-0.8826889992,
-0.0741448104,
0.0033685344,
-0.3773199022,
0.3506360352,
0.6491931081,
-0.0646141618,
0.6251769662,
0.8624059558,
0.1095532924,
0.0022030089,
0.4235488176,
0.4701136351,
-0.8943667412,
-0.3193824589,
-0.7870508432,
0.4012688398,
-0.154569611,
-0.586925745,
0.8076642156,
0.5688745975,
0.9261251688,
-0.0620425902,
0.7875259519,
-0.2768943608,
0.259465605,
-0.4589714408,
0.9027804732,
-0.6500723362,
-0.1427915692,
-0.7310759425,
-0.9732146859,
-0.0629207641,
0.7062687874,
0.1464419961,
-0.2895998657,
0.9741438031,
0.2491413802,
0.0945931524,
0.1427377611,
0.3167253435,
-0.0337899886,
0.1107547432,
0.5343229175,
0.8312170506,
-0.6208404303,
0.6439720988,
-0.6123117208,
-0.3982708752,
-0.0272889528,
-0.9918059707,
-0.9585570097,
-0.5914213061,
-0.1201683506,
-0.1797950566,
0.122559242,
0.8000997305,
0.4336497486,
-0.8285501599,
-0.5668594241,
0.191688329,
0.1923349053,
-0.9519941807,
-0.1996974498,
0.6724380851,
-0.6075240374,
-0.9565101862,
0.4562844336,
0.1157366335,
-0.2459338456,
-0.3748522997,
0.0645267293,
-0.4857735932,
-0.3104625046,
0.5558851957,
0.2132868618,
-0.9588257074,
0.0407759696,
-0.0090536587,
-0.1199322492,
-0.2716525793,
0.6202580929,
-0.5970033407,
0.3817171156,
0.4004453123,
0.7409120202,
0.5021953583,
-0.0235108398,
0.7988926172,
-0.2530920506,
0.1892650425,
-0.0776071772,
0.5158027411,
0.3215842545,
0.1400226206,
0.7278324962,
0.2379469126,
-0.1817422658,
-0.711099267,
-0.2107589096,
-0.8216662407,
-0.6317635775,
0.7235097289,
-0.3338271677,
-0.0697423369,
-0.0492890254,
-0.0494074002,
0.231005013,
-0.1828767657,
0.8041213751,
0.7980946898,
0.2184253782,
-0.1140002161,
-0.7938050628,
0.442491442,
0.3459632993,
-0.8149555326,
0.131506741,
0.2924832106,
0.0011452071,
0.3017292023,
0.2227479219,
0.1267946661,
0.4492465556,
0.0579681955,
0.4319953024,
0.1725257635,
-0.1637577266,
0.0502016991,
0.0311312713,
0.076583229,
-0.1180097684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14128v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14128v1 | Dr.ICL: Demonstration-Retrieved In-context Learning | 2023-05-23T14:55:25 | 2023-05-23T14:55:25 | Man Luo, Xin Xu, Zhuyun Dai, Panupong Pasupat, Mehran Kazemi, Chitta Baral, Vaiva Imbrasaite, Vincent Y Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning (ICL), teaching a large language model (LLM) to perform a
task with few-shot demonstrations rather than adjusting the model parameters,
has emerged as a strong paradigm for using LLMs. While early studies primarily
used a fixed or random set of demonstrations for all test queries, recent
research suggests that retrieving semantically similar demonstrations to the
input from a pool of available demonstrations results in better performance.
This work expands the applicability of retrieval-based ICL approaches by
demonstrating that even simple word-overlap similarity measures such as BM25
outperform randomly selected demonstrations. Furthermore, we extend the success
of retrieval-based ICL to instruction-finetuned LLMs as well as
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting. For instruction-finetuned LLMs, we find that
although a model has already seen the training data at training time,
retrieving demonstrations from the training data at test time yields better
results compared to using no demonstrations or random demonstrations. Last but
not least, we train a task-specific demonstration retriever that outperforms
off-the-shelf retrievers. | [
-0.4144921899,
-0.8691999316,
0.4476335645,
0.135656178,
-0.3013760448,
-0.0843098164,
-0.4111978114,
-0.3587446809,
-0.2680705488,
0.2206555456,
-0.2862428427,
-0.5524107218,
-0.4824744165,
-0.0932347849,
-0.908922255,
0.8403998613,
0.0451571383,
0.2820643187,
-0.4912178218,
-0.1679933071,
-0.3291517496,
-0.4551452398,
-0.5345193148,
-0.6650918126,
0.3372609019,
0.7703309059,
0.1267811209,
0.3882191479,
0.3473339677,
0.115027979,
-0.0365869626,
0.2462137789,
-0.594004333,
-0.046539586,
-0.2853904366,
-0.5022298694,
0.301528275,
0.1050013602,
0.7532533407,
0.8968441486,
-0.2510206401,
0.0640882552,
0.5364555717,
0.4483324885,
-0.730764389,
-0.0749580413,
-0.9693690538,
0.179495573,
-0.0805582628,
-0.2160590589,
-0.832106173,
-0.2547555566,
0.3616444767,
-0.2217623293,
0.0889511108,
0.1905994564,
0.6479966044,
-0.0185474232,
-0.5629891753,
-0.5310486555,
-0.78909868,
1.0371063948,
-0.6517751217,
0.4766877294,
0.3255285025,
0.392334342,
-0.1786641181,
-0.9867539406,
-0.5926772952,
-0.6489685178,
-0.1182592586,
0.0710260645,
0.2043319792,
0.0220451858,
0.4315854907,
0.3499259353,
-0.1662963033,
0.3421727717,
-0.1738338321,
0.033134561,
0.38763538,
0.1942367852,
0.0736029446,
0.0123979039,
-0.7951025963,
-0.1707804054,
-1.2166004181,
0.2343875468,
-0.2341993451,
0.2799860239,
-0.0025362638,
0.400585711,
-0.35300228,
0.7780431509,
0.2325079888,
0.0042458996,
0.0754662827,
-0.1176067516,
-0.3252851963,
0.0475839302,
0.5480191112,
0.0019847387,
-0.0495768972,
-0.3976954222,
-0.3538984954,
-0.4740291238,
0.0757106245,
-0.7960342765,
-0.1540872008,
-0.1517783701,
-0.5316089988,
0.0165562276,
0.2557277083,
-0.5468335748,
-0.1360361576,
-0.5766586065,
0.7773372531,
-0.5699585676,
0.2088876814,
-0.0797985196,
-0.1363210231,
0.5310818553,
0.3163630068,
-0.8543419838,
0.6418407559,
0.7988629937,
0.6962900758,
-0.6029601097,
-0.3062060475,
-0.9305281639,
0.1808837503,
-0.4773645699,
0.5818917155,
-0.4829032123,
-0.3357073963,
0.149397701,
-0.1565431058,
-0.0969156399,
-1.0191891193,
-0.0624739937,
-0.5518978834,
0.1819557548,
-0.3215241134,
-1.0122036934,
-0.0683009252,
0.4366136193,
-0.3406925797,
0.9901717305,
-0.0974824652,
-0.4504266679,
0.6394356489,
-0.5945854783,
-0.3667208552,
0.0555593595,
-0.5616964102,
-0.124033615,
0.0948166922,
-0.0804526731,
0.6987243295,
-0.1717359722,
0.0457836166,
-0.338708967,
-0.8296437263,
0.3361943662,
-0.5849556327,
0.4849675596,
0.1740695089,
-0.7032238841,
0.019395018,
-0.5959151387,
0.1131182536,
-0.1904289871,
-0.4758326411,
-0.4709720016,
0.1382695585,
-0.2125532925,
0.2072015405,
0.0889325291,
-0.6104534864,
-0.0637362823,
-0.5975925326,
0.1265763938,
0.5749655366,
-0.0210521575,
0.3412286937,
-0.345060885,
0.2403431088,
0.0126378946,
-0.0294919983,
-0.1227435768,
0.0239593089,
-0.6105569005,
-0.2441131026,
0.0931625217,
0.3069726527,
-0.7613430023,
-0.0796329379,
-0.0953389555,
-0.3978736699,
-0.302090168,
0.1910722256,
0.7870005965,
0.7514324188,
0.4091717005,
-0.3181831837,
-0.2062332779,
-0.91723001,
-0.1677930206,
0.037917342,
0.0404618867,
0.6018191576,
0.3300756514,
0.0945260599,
0.7960012555,
-0.2975838184,
-0.134057641,
-0.3887941837,
0.1197213456,
-0.0016853072,
0.4142634869,
0.4152625501,
-0.7198578119,
-0.7571185231,
0.0412928574,
-0.7293990254,
0.1566785127,
0.0375358723,
0.0331802592,
0.1453583986,
0.7796485424,
-0.3552809358,
0.4634093344,
0.1106638536,
0.0735520497,
0.5999704003,
-0.3469626009,
0.0737229809,
-0.9960722923,
-0.1624045819,
-0.2002080828,
-0.2377422005,
-0.4135497808,
0.290528357,
0.3574986756,
0.1431733668,
-0.8610234261,
0.7495058179,
-0.5348183513,
-0.3549432755,
-0.3638173044,
0.3404029608,
-0.2450160235,
0.2775117159,
-0.0678398013,
1.1195255518,
0.5177356601,
-0.8541033268,
0.0135697555,
0.2414219826,
-0.6916386485,
0.4731625319,
-0.3936081231,
0.2773183882,
-0.1204176024,
0.1067758873,
-0.961235702,
-0.0816171542,
-0.138180241,
0.0482446589,
0.4510871172,
0.0646896511,
-0.5373155475,
-0.1304867119,
-0.2620860636,
0.1444395185,
0.6340587735,
-1.1707139015,
0.0777612403,
0.0675300956,
0.3054077029,
-0.7249924541,
-0.6382879615,
-0.1189406589,
-0.461137414,
0.0086339377,
0.5189948082,
-0.2989661992,
-0.3714063466,
-0.2862618864,
-0.0943515375,
-0.0515928008,
0.32315889,
0.1623057574,
-0.0623599812,
-0.1872223765,
0.5270524621,
-0.0717394724,
0.2849494219,
0.027669007,
-0.1846182048,
0.5819649696,
-0.1207172796,
-0.7339782715,
-0.4421343207,
0.3968617618,
0.1491516382,
-0.0022040941,
0.6917600632,
0.3451907635,
-0.3669617474,
-0.4283128977,
-0.480288595,
-0.4840026498,
-0.4392592311,
0.4290089309,
-0.3649456203,
-0.8732633591,
0.1912712604,
-0.305051446,
0.1049256697,
-0.0595961809,
0.3323197067,
-0.3901367486,
1.1454956532,
0.7020668387,
-0.0428824872,
0.7854772806,
-0.3971966207,
-0.038102217,
-1.0006797314,
-0.3365920484,
-0.3386160731,
-0.3947196603,
-0.1586108953,
-0.1988491267,
0.2203260958,
0.3395529091,
-0.379386723,
0.1056918055,
-0.2048035115,
0.5651295781,
0.7079419494,
0.3974790573,
0.3178658187,
0.2058154792,
-0.4533881247,
-0.1146316975,
-0.6244409084,
-0.6250522733,
1.0160326958,
-0.1541278511,
0.7983393073,
0.0860229209,
0.9480085969,
0.1170108393,
0.6101250052,
-0.7144448161,
0.6455425024,
-0.2902500331,
-0.3143957853,
-0.2170336694,
-0.111783348,
-1.0276691914,
0.3363011777,
0.1194371134,
-0.9999344945,
-0.0731372237,
0.2810783088,
-0.1130371913,
0.2488338053,
-0.6146366596,
0.7109087706,
-0.2133555859,
-0.3336565197,
-0.5130677819,
-0.5450966954,
0.2927458882,
0.1091456711,
-0.0837207884,
0.1984487772,
-0.0799534172,
0.5504280925,
-0.3873125613,
0.8098074794,
-0.2168336362,
0.0764217302,
0.3774472177,
0.072511144,
0.4553999901,
-0.1272688806,
-0.1918105483,
-0.5692444444,
-0.0451369397,
-0.317094326,
-0.9475579262,
0.941141367,
-0.4943139553,
-0.7763692737,
0.0057469076,
-0.596683085,
-0.3410207927,
-0.0766957402,
0.1996647418,
0.9207844138,
-0.246658802,
0.6651222706,
0.9770841599,
-0.0296664517,
0.5992500782,
0.6685222983,
-0.0908267796,
0.0062349425,
0.8664426804,
0.1070819646,
0.6654052734,
0.6806107759,
0.2297819704,
-0.2652475238,
-0.7191819549,
-0.1394812614,
-0.1493702829,
-1.0578179359,
-0.1491883099,
-0.5937225819,
-0.2303657532,
0.0982702672,
-0.1277686208,
-0.1225623786,
-0.175940454,
-0.3921324015,
-0.1960956901,
0.169470638,
0.7210489511,
0.1098272875,
0.3828613758,
-0.4483351707,
-0.0622759759,
0.4550951123,
0.200521633,
0.4027259648,
-0.5667905211,
-0.2988291085,
0.1015715972,
-0.5531090498,
-0.6825864315,
0.2782981694,
0.4248837531,
0.7657197714,
0.3737372756,
0.0229094382,
0.9643131495,
-0.4767116904,
0.8864942193,
-0.0272550806,
-0.7891728282,
0.6087090969,
0.0855278075,
0.2395063639,
0.5911642313,
0.558714211,
-0.3749403358,
-0.4010927677,
-0.6432934403,
-0.7925786972,
0.6214725375,
-0.2553615272,
0.292485863,
-0.4635426104,
0.5036429167,
0.3287151158,
0.2039699107,
-0.5515909791,
-0.1618081927,
0.2125058919,
-0.4594532549,
0.0514727272,
-0.089067325,
-0.1684788913,
-0.2148226202,
0.6001184583,
-0.4097605646,
0.2295529097,
0.2465260476,
-0.5122695565,
0.2065187842,
0.3576544225,
0.520347178,
0.8217030168,
-0.1021752283,
0.3572447002,
0.5718708038,
-0.1609503031,
0.0465177745,
-0.0123494836,
-0.1927327961,
-0.2157976776,
0.2755513489,
0.7558903098,
0.6575236917,
-1.1094683409,
0.6949403286,
0.0607983992,
-0.0136477482,
-0.3920866847,
0.2860155702,
-0.0939326733,
0.446587503,
0.5079467297,
-0.3038444221,
0.4057757258,
-0.6709048748,
0.6156606078,
0.7402576208,
-0.8877817392,
-0.1140709296,
0.6243630052,
-0.2998006642,
-0.3760072887,
0.7106305957,
-0.2092244178,
-0.2158013284,
0.7676983476,
1.0234917402,
0.5242624879,
0.1876859963,
0.0300205201,
0.1739040464,
-0.1653480232,
-0.2495520562,
0.3311184347,
-0.3823314905,
-0.5175861716,
-0.288571775,
-0.1430411041,
-0.5114499331,
0.1388567239,
-0.8720932007,
0.3412317038,
-0.4472282827,
0.3158217072,
-0.3400600255,
0.1412276924,
-0.7245443463,
0.1584646106,
0.1047423929,
1.2186157703,
-0.4974258244,
0.9548802376,
0.6188674569,
-0.3870702684,
-1.043282032,
0.2288770825,
-0.0638532192,
-0.7439770103,
0.9353115559,
0.3102659583,
0.028545985,
0.2060944736,
-0.8641533852,
-0.7764947414,
1.4351991415,
0.3495458364,
-0.5032561421,
0.1321543306,
-0.195494324,
0.4523702264,
-0.7249876857,
0.4477342963,
0.3662873805,
-0.1675183326,
0.0912170708,
-0.7074349523,
0.0069411965,
0.2528639734,
-0.0294546541,
0.0291461926,
-0.7615913749,
0.5138836503,
-0.1796482354,
-0.1529503167,
0.4403875172,
0.85623914,
0.6667156219,
0.6358487606,
0.495061636,
0.2684325278,
0.7526120543,
-0.0082586631,
1.3031848669,
0.0279820506,
0.2431554645,
1.4174077511,
-0.3917726278,
1.2840678692,
0.6336721778,
0.078558214,
0.5228354335,
0.6454464793,
0.377268523,
0.7839878201,
0.2325333357,
-0.3557300866,
-0.1529394984,
-0.2758111954,
-0.0744304657,
0.3226556778,
0.4634329677,
-0.367292881,
-0.268524617,
0.4502566755,
-0.2665436566,
0.3705091178,
-0.2310535312,
0.940353632,
0.2755911052,
-0.7202700377,
0.5211045146,
-0.4945428073,
0.646900475,
-0.4879056215,
-0.2647792101,
-0.2986646593,
0.2332784832,
0.1237694621,
-0.6559720039,
0.1062993556,
-0.2665524781,
-0.1181508303,
-0.2396801561,
0.5902903676,
-0.7202668786,
0.0439304784,
0.3815183043,
0.4161892831,
0.3786445558,
0.2555366755,
-0.4968457818,
-0.3107046783,
-0.1678422689,
-0.0339098535,
0.7496776581,
0.4219700694,
-0.2404727787,
0.8787911534,
0.2681177557,
-0.143781364,
0.1868112832,
0.2882028818,
0.6911844015,
-0.5895521045,
-0.1301201433,
-0.8186336756,
0.2724725306,
-0.2371592075,
-0.1400606781,
0.678283453,
0.6786637902,
1.3312987089,
-0.0496351197,
0.5624403954,
0.0332529135,
0.649053812,
-0.7559221983,
0.3888639808,
-0.6498578787,
0.3112454414,
-0.0919104964,
-0.6790075898,
-0.1017093882,
0.447447896,
-0.2962282598,
-0.0174246058,
0.8151289225,
0.8099076748,
-0.3689695001,
-0.0746295154,
0.5395413637,
0.001219101,
0.4242860079,
0.5417113304,
1.2289178371,
-0.3223193884,
0.5213939548,
-0.4173419774,
-0.0945980176,
-0.2714188099,
-0.7813609242,
-0.9189759493,
-0.5291817784,
-0.2307014167,
-0.0248214509,
0.1339370012,
1.2857505083,
0.8217190504,
-0.696587801,
-0.5149606466,
0.0099011743,
0.1964703649,
-0.5510943532,
-0.2454973757,
0.3545244336,
-0.7342913747,
-0.8663079739,
0.6020712256,
0.114698045,
0.072955437,
-0.1257783771,
-0.2186733633,
-0.2596975565,
-0.1525884271,
0.7868716717,
0.2533734143,
-0.9197140932,
-0.549392283,
0.0339388177,
-0.1870380491,
0.0646619275,
0.777407527,
-1.0200737715,
0.3447546661,
0.3229953945,
0.9208511114,
0.647968173,
-0.1140610129,
0.4820635319,
-0.9059693217,
0.1768272966,
0.0675784796,
0.4035728872,
0.3593941629,
-0.2578121424,
0.3373933434,
-0.1141561344,
-0.4555808008,
-0.7825120091,
0.2434061319,
-0.6554086804,
-0.159196049,
1.0768216848,
-0.2415919155,
-0.0754383653,
0.0961547717,
-0.1626594365,
0.1144799292,
-0.1259656101,
1.0201505423,
0.5441838503,
-0.2202758491,
-0.2041032314,
-0.6076794267,
0.4388427734,
0.6227930188,
-0.6965411305,
-0.1670477837,
0.188576445,
0.35966748,
-0.2640668154,
0.4777241647,
-0.1807902455,
0.2588388622,
-0.5498749614,
-0.2548330426,
0.223280713,
-0.3350099325,
-0.4515175521,
0.2271125317,
0.4666383266,
-0.2724944949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14126v1 | To Copy Rather Than Memorize: A Vertical Learning Paradigm for Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-05-23T14:53:20 | 2023-05-23T14:53:20 | Rui Li, Xu Chen, Chaozhuo Li, Yanming Shen, Jianan Zhao, Yujing Wang, Weihao Han, Hao Sun, Weiwei Deng, Qi Zhang, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Embedding models have shown great power in knowledge graph completion (KGC)
task. By learning structural constraints for each training triple, these
methods implicitly memorize intrinsic relation rules to infer missing links.
However, this paper points out that the multi-hop relation rules are hard to be
reliably memorized due to the inherent deficiencies of such implicit
memorization strategy, making embedding models underperform in predicting links
between distant entity pairs. To alleviate this problem, we present Vertical
Learning Paradigm (VLP), which extends embedding models by allowing to
explicitly copy target information from related factual triples for more
accurate prediction. Rather than solely relying on the implicit memory, VLP
directly provides additional cues to improve the generalization ability of
embedding models, especially making the distant link prediction significantly
easier. Moreover, we also propose a novel relative distance based negative
sampling technique (ReD) for more effective optimization. Experiments
demonstrate the validity and generality of our proposals on two standard
benchmarks. Our code is available at https://github.com/rui9812/VLP. | [
-0.1368115097,
-0.5415050387,
0.6275559068,
-0.2292850018,
-0.0812716782,
0.0206596497,
0.1386544704,
-0.4151160419,
0.063718833,
0.231848225,
-0.4795682728,
-0.7505975962,
-0.4149965346,
-0.1981772035,
-0.1014086679,
0.9654756784,
-0.2102352679,
-0.0313439704,
-0.6090071797,
-0.3792151511,
-0.5708218813,
-0.4581547081,
-0.3982617259,
-0.4528761208,
0.6225820184,
0.244963944,
0.2772776484,
0.8664605618,
0.0837157369,
0.1935725063,
-0.140157938,
0.549139142,
-0.9112246633,
-0.1500444859,
0.0284034796,
-0.5701216459,
-0.4627454579,
-0.0735738426,
0.6839162111,
0.9513390064,
0.0827119723,
0.1000920981,
-0.1155327335,
1.014121294,
-0.7889069915,
0.5666290522,
-0.6544943452,
0.4544062614,
0.2397882789,
-0.1306638569,
-0.4372252226,
-0.6491660476,
0.4241532087,
-0.807293117,
0.0896062553,
0.1261377484,
0.7332668304,
0.020141229,
-0.5744543672,
-0.144079715,
-0.762856245,
0.5208538175,
-0.2221122384,
0.7243200541,
0.5735399723,
0.2560461462,
0.1857469082,
-0.675122261,
-0.210928902,
-0.295817852,
0.0436866097,
0.0649280772,
0.0556073748,
-0.0316463821,
0.3287600279,
0.0281943232,
0.0626690909,
-0.3583993912,
-0.9814186692,
-0.1135434434,
-0.0124286134,
0.011981681,
0.0108680483,
-0.1045948118,
-0.5654668808,
0.2118099481,
-1.0451151133,
-0.0898089036,
0.2024759054,
0.3710196316,
-0.040144816,
0.6140059233,
-0.2735759914,
0.5716115832,
-0.1241239831,
-0.3423988521,
0.7895388603,
-0.5106488466,
-0.1072264388,
-0.0004142935,
0.1997367889,
0.35184744,
0.3296806514,
-0.3741743267,
0.3824046254,
-0.3364141583,
0.6447336078,
-0.4767799675,
-0.3714153767,
0.0156537499,
-0.2804950476,
0.0090642422,
-0.1383853704,
-0.275529474,
-0.0336736888,
-0.6918135285,
0.3418700099,
-0.8906804919,
0.1095024943,
-0.1062898338,
-0.375533551,
-0.1244477183,
0.5973433852,
-0.4841250181,
0.2481816262,
0.6627570391,
0.9292344451,
0.3386691809,
-0.6470689178,
-0.6345431805,
0.8382003903,
-0.1681031883,
0.3339028656,
-0.3011609614,
-0.2607977092,
0.0243404116,
-0.3733410537,
0.0234768651,
-0.1880874634,
0.1366577446,
-0.7848406434,
0.1149491891,
-0.8549355865,
-0.7645307183,
-0.4739637375,
0.5349575281,
-0.5976160169,
0.7209535241,
0.1800204813,
-0.9761689901,
0.6462436914,
-0.0325837247,
-0.3803097606,
-0.0018250962,
-0.1944707781,
-0.5667830706,
-0.34729743,
0.1685831845,
0.4737193286,
0.0375714675,
-0.0748241916,
-0.8667214513,
-0.2545936406,
-0.6387198567,
0.2729260325,
0.4734301567,
-0.1347562373,
-0.0842021406,
-0.1395054013,
-0.6826761365,
-0.0492828749,
0.023112122,
-0.5485195518,
-0.6805148721,
0.1067462713,
-0.7371779084,
0.2838935554,
0.0442024358,
-0.248555392,
0.4555850625,
0.0633069202,
0.1899907589,
0.8500905037,
0.0921275765,
0.6122630239,
-0.4406562746,
0.2868942618,
-0.0707473308,
0.0654679909,
0.2844496965,
-0.4801857769,
-0.3555153608,
-0.3619104028,
0.1533049941,
0.405457288,
-0.7760908008,
0.1358363777,
-0.5938082933,
-0.5792974234,
-0.2296080142,
0.4653179646,
0.5986524224,
1.0482382774,
0.7519114614,
-0.1111097559,
-0.5860473514,
-0.5392305851,
-0.0309233144,
-0.495411545,
0.0995002091,
0.7539784312,
0.5113712549,
-0.2840372026,
0.8069545031,
-0.6922288537,
-0.6798918247,
-0.2919630408,
-0.0776558071,
-0.0358950496,
0.1763499826,
0.5329337716,
-0.8925381303,
-0.5361698866,
-0.1426867098,
-0.9068639278,
0.3408171535,
0.3121924102,
-0.0991049856,
0.109822996,
0.8294301629,
-0.6659685373,
0.2705565393,
0.2196192443,
-0.1358069777,
0.3920126855,
-0.3345262706,
-0.1973029673,
-0.7895831466,
-0.0012523425,
0.0858763456,
-0.1201479658,
-0.3741475344,
-0.2340569347,
0.2573111355,
0.2766979635,
-0.4769646227,
0.161484167,
-0.5679782629,
0.0074208635,
0.304751575,
0.2025680542,
-0.0680487081,
0.689334631,
-0.0961129144,
0.2281311601,
0.1708832532,
-0.7680651546,
0.1385646313,
0.3750981688,
-0.1173656359,
0.4178449512,
-0.4075861275,
-0.0161615349,
-0.5948621631,
0.5233032703,
-0.9011155963,
0.1274831593,
0.2064816356,
-0.2388210744,
0.6270080805,
-0.5992922783,
-0.2442439049,
-0.445726335,
-0.6009102464,
0.4653582275,
0.7757882476,
-0.540830791,
0.6229718924,
0.3771539629,
0.3010834754,
-0.9232728481,
-0.2976226807,
-0.552239418,
-0.2212837338,
-0.3441901803,
0.3737229109,
0.2482526153,
0.2581949532,
0.3401064277,
-0.3310122192,
0.2357159406,
-0.0778477862,
0.322838366,
0.1964021027,
-0.0959959254,
0.372887373,
-0.2052823156,
-0.0688393638,
-0.0565237403,
-0.6969393492,
0.3696550131,
-0.1745646149,
-0.3871489763,
-0.2218754739,
-0.1465695947,
0.6132270098,
0.1686936617,
0.8745535016,
0.5164862275,
-0.4348188043,
-0.1676090658,
-0.5869154334,
0.1115874648,
-0.3906004429,
0.4451925755,
-0.4875168204,
-0.6385889053,
0.2293784916,
-0.3716955483,
-0.3625418246,
0.2924920917,
0.0092617441,
-0.2324485928,
0.4647168815,
0.7805152535,
-0.6173000932,
0.4108641744,
-0.5434426069,
0.0539571308,
-1.014415741,
-0.6668826342,
-0.4140999615,
0.0276401602,
-0.4515399039,
-0.4061751366,
0.462887615,
0.5601696372,
-0.4401115477,
0.5597241521,
-0.0443845466,
0.2986162305,
0.7442747355,
0.163460359,
0.31808725,
0.4057230055,
-0.6797651052,
-0.186485514,
-0.8035257459,
0.0242621917,
1.2903370857,
0.4041002393,
0.3997253776,
0.0478851162,
0.849060297,
0.1410282701,
0.1235186756,
-0.633987546,
0.2898095548,
0.0720532462,
-0.325020045,
-0.3182047904,
-0.7489125133,
-0.5491299033,
0.2135914564,
-0.1387595683,
-0.9834516048,
-0.0760438889,
0.3820991218,
-0.172004208,
0.7630477548,
-0.5628100634,
0.4866079092,
0.2556319535,
-0.5996278524,
-0.09478008,
-0.652430594,
0.2732650042,
-0.0643964633,
0.2246138752,
0.0561205037,
0.0444481336,
0.4349579811,
-0.5020776391,
0.8424939513,
-0.4176744819,
0.0968931541,
0.237317875,
-0.006171505,
0.6841736436,
0.0573001169,
-0.0744341388,
0.1392500401,
-0.4705274701,
-0.4904307425,
-0.4161787629,
0.5947175622,
-0.9956912398,
-0.3938325942,
0.0401929058,
-0.2067305148,
-0.3811743855,
0.3160337508,
0.1416661292,
0.2633762062,
0.000529469,
0.2875694335,
0.6043046117,
-0.0320832655,
-0.0617193319,
0.1585689634,
-0.0537835956,
-0.6305254102,
1.0402238369,
0.4835466743,
0.3754735291,
0.7278028131,
0.0888960585,
-0.3540762365,
-0.5850217342,
-0.1153175086,
0.4383038282,
-0.9384421706,
-0.1646140367,
-1.2294288874,
-0.2366570681,
-0.3474893868,
-0.3332229555,
-0.6240139008,
-0.1898958981,
-0.1368943155,
-0.3303489089,
0.224789694,
0.7428263426,
-0.2850332558,
-0.3064812124,
-0.7343732119,
0.6355928183,
0.4126570523,
0.2963514328,
0.2483307123,
-0.1146940961,
-0.2075538188,
-0.0219195839,
-0.2696029246,
-0.5404567719,
0.2489223778,
0.04193151,
0.4868444502,
0.2126067877,
-0.0119255576,
0.8748774529,
-0.6314766407,
0.3993054628,
0.4150747359,
-0.7420939803,
0.4169181287,
-0.3480696976,
0.125833571,
0.7002236247,
0.9848609567,
-0.2891325951,
-0.1483683586,
-0.5265829563,
-1.2032103539,
0.5518445969,
0.0471591242,
-0.0916264206,
0.1006343216,
0.4108429551,
0.0847101435,
0.3357033432,
-0.7769611478,
-0.4342292845,
-0.0976357684,
0.0756815821,
0.0561845079,
-0.4732326865,
0.0029520486,
-0.6044273973,
0.8282515407,
-0.1668165922,
0.36178267,
0.2520574927,
0.0457674041,
-0.1733210385,
-0.2707358301,
0.2051827312,
0.8530635238,
-0.5927024484,
-0.0221774168,
0.4242483377,
-0.4592064619,
0.0014628302,
0.0181361716,
-0.3523926735,
-0.1874315143,
0.7025011778,
0.6331439614,
0.0359736755,
-0.0341249257,
0.682174921,
0.1254383177,
-0.3753180504,
-0.5936219692,
0.0161623619,
0.3309639692,
0.2402238548,
0.3087214828,
0.2701628506,
-0.0979492813,
-0.443992734,
0.2075037211,
0.221715346,
-0.8129336834,
-0.1598321497,
0.6332944632,
-0.0930529237,
0.0505244955,
1.0558444262,
-0.1655378193,
-0.7638552189,
0.5550656319,
0.4139543772,
0.5332555771,
0.2502852082,
0.188331902,
0.6834267974,
0.252165705,
-0.0948594287,
0.1939599514,
-0.3026088178,
-0.6434400082,
-0.3309671283,
-0.2561315894,
-0.2019558698,
0.111339584,
-0.5404729843,
0.4262267351,
-0.663493216,
0.1033212543,
-0.0569015518,
0.209478721,
-0.8228487968,
0.0590560399,
0.1398027241,
0.7617459297,
-0.5816888809,
1.1749215126,
0.5164340138,
-0.542629838,
-0.8753553033,
-0.0773880482,
0.2611903846,
-0.6745659709,
0.9598237872,
0.2723964453,
-0.1662116498,
-0.2934707999,
-0.2500266135,
-0.8541058898,
1.503098011,
0.1534921229,
-0.3361830711,
-0.3990819156,
-0.1443685442,
0.4518208206,
-0.3667164743,
0.1074388027,
0.1657502055,
0.1979439259,
0.4325661361,
-0.5553693175,
0.2592350543,
-0.115180105,
0.0067336322,
0.2178860605,
-0.7282617092,
0.9613454938,
-0.6589326859,
0.0773670152,
-0.3072656095,
0.544873476,
0.4219815731,
0.2987646163,
0.3342199922,
0.824647069,
0.8354914188,
0.3385368586,
1.2427031994,
0.0510280952,
0.4306793511,
1.3862179518,
-0.3148285747,
0.6460979581,
0.5450646281,
-0.2384961396,
0.4847131371,
0.083579123,
-0.1250750422,
0.9693136811,
0.1789261699,
0.034043584,
-0.015932031,
-0.0167619418,
-0.8169344068,
0.248428002,
0.2458538264,
-0.4537599683,
-0.213292703,
-0.5268404484,
0.1087753028,
-0.1296635866,
-0.3262130916,
0.7432575226,
0.167767629,
-0.4702990353,
0.5269297957,
-0.2080823481,
0.3129004836,
-0.6844115853,
-0.2457950264,
-0.0430432074,
0.3545817435,
-0.0262718592,
-0.200001806,
0.1351948082,
-0.7270964384,
-0.289028883,
-0.1405172646,
0.7752049565,
-0.3677558899,
-0.1959076226,
0.869400084,
0.5656741858,
-0.311105907,
0.2462042719,
-0.4388146102,
-0.3687272072,
0.24027659,
-0.1984935254,
0.1882480234,
0.4618591666,
-0.0296971519,
0.9348865151,
0.5941644311,
0.1960842162,
0.0086331526,
-0.148221612,
0.8442753553,
-0.6820474863,
-0.3333010077,
-0.8660660386,
0.2881918252,
-0.1241607442,
-0.0938737839,
0.7665646076,
0.4465877116,
1.3789337873,
-0.3744208515,
0.8025420904,
0.118711412,
0.4175896943,
-0.5957483053,
0.5096148252,
-0.5608478189,
0.2434173524,
-0.6715759039,
-0.901974678,
-0.1789132059,
0.2714245915,
-0.4985748231,
0.2449031323,
0.822424829,
0.2901490927,
-0.3688479364,
-0.0570726842,
0.2061726749,
0.1151553541,
0.1744528413,
0.8193935752,
0.8257142901,
-0.4712015688,
0.6894389987,
-0.5132867098,
0.1120316461,
-0.1804102808,
-1.0020034313,
-1.0334162712,
-0.5463094115,
-0.4905492961,
-0.4984150231,
0.0321253054,
0.8427986503,
0.9288881421,
-0.3923904598,
0.1300977319,
-0.2664522529,
0.5531079173,
-0.1573821008,
-0.1173508838,
0.5659707785,
-0.3359822035,
-0.3064235151,
0.1196341813,
0.1941809952,
0.2007757276,
0.1859057546,
-0.2727597654,
-0.5131930709,
-0.3894551992,
0.5820547938,
0.378347367,
-0.4023717642,
-0.3377268016,
-0.4775408506,
0.0136449877,
0.0712317303,
0.5381121039,
-0.9243323207,
0.3896934986,
0.5439658761,
0.7072907686,
0.8978725672,
0.0363072157,
0.6192723513,
-0.8415779471,
-0.0322391428,
-0.0014847362,
0.4203385711,
0.2961941957,
-0.3911126554,
0.7212443948,
0.5559819937,
0.0555412732,
-0.4619191587,
0.2534309328,
-0.7359095216,
-0.3987590373,
1.1900699139,
-0.5254237652,
-0.3891815245,
-0.2259608656,
0.0225043129,
0.444845438,
-0.2797562778,
0.6730946302,
0.4231880903,
0.1616377532,
0.2764514685,
-0.5865421295,
0.5778832436,
0.22997953,
-0.2986905873,
-0.3169981241,
0.6235775352,
0.5369924903,
0.3220210373,
0.8107261062,
-0.1651603281,
0.1371726692,
0.1259608865,
-0.2188129872,
-0.4904466867,
-0.7875393033,
0.1185667291,
0.7174543738,
0.0325785615,
-0.060016714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14124v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14124v3 | When Does Monolingual Data Help Multilingual Translation: The Role of Domain and Model Scale | 2023-05-23T14:48:42 | 2024-03-30T08:49:04 | Christos Baziotis, Biao Zhang, Alexandra Birch, Barry Haddow | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual machine translation (MMT), trained on a mixture of parallel and
monolingual data, is key for improving translation in low-resource language
pairs. However, the literature offers conflicting results on the performance of
different methods of including monolingual data. To resolve this, we examine
how denoising autoencoding (DAE) and backtranslation (BT) impact MMT under
different data conditions and model scales. Unlike prior studies, we use a
realistic dataset of 100 translation directions and consider many domain
combinations of monolingual and test data. We find that monolingual data
generally helps MMT, but models are surprisingly brittle to domain mismatches,
especially at smaller model scales. BT is beneficial when the parallel,
monolingual, and test data sources are similar but can be detrimental
otherwise, while DAE is less effective than previously reported. Next, we
analyze the impact of scale (from 90M to 1.6B parameters) and find it is
important for both methods, particularly DAE. As scale increases, DAE
transitions from underperforming the parallel-only baseline at 90M to
converging with BT performance at 1.6B, and even surpassing it in low-resource.
These results offer new insights into how to best use monolingual data in MMT. | [
-0.5057496428,
-0.4338727295,
0.1306500882,
0.4004429877,
-0.2997799218,
0.0171342976,
-0.1739356667,
-0.4246180356,
-0.081409961,
0.3710592389,
-0.5610160828,
-0.3206523359,
-0.9617407322,
0.3498990834,
-0.3876338899,
1.0586732626,
-0.1964851469,
0.2282183915,
-0.2380584627,
-0.5965710878,
-0.6388661861,
-0.8633440733,
-0.8503796458,
-0.3541849256,
0.7212815285,
0.5107549429,
0.8470846415,
1.0677535534,
0.8027843237,
0.2696188986,
0.1766879559,
0.1218359023,
-0.3590307534,
0.0087887207,
0.0655236542,
-0.494269222,
-0.8342913985,
0.2297043353,
0.7597308755,
1.0954990387,
-0.1063314825,
0.178466171,
0.1324833483,
0.8133070469,
-0.1816559583,
0.2495651692,
-0.2242186368,
0.0807294622,
-0.2487799525,
0.0442827269,
-0.3248007596,
-0.0051810229,
-0.0111308731,
-0.4454530478,
0.2362361103,
0.1480792612,
0.6380773783,
0.4134631455,
-0.929551959,
-0.1835598499,
-0.7842429876,
0.9670877457,
-0.7873182297,
0.5687225461,
0.3648813069,
0.2426502407,
0.1284552813,
-0.350112021,
-0.2633029521,
0.0811918378,
-0.3086631298,
0.1020421162,
-0.2465441227,
-0.1079784259,
0.294041574,
0.5359818339,
-0.672354877,
0.1904743463,
-0.5171225667,
-0.0562427528,
0.3991777301,
0.1614969373,
0.289174825,
-0.231964916,
-0.3107109964,
-0.3517488837,
-0.5836128592,
-0.0827065781,
0.1360148191,
0.5561585426,
-0.3499322534,
0.4401434958,
0.156306386,
0.5961008072,
-0.0705590695,
-0.2032931745,
0.3363729417,
-0.7423885465,
-0.2211522758,
-0.0756308362,
0.6091394424,
0.3875972331,
0.3725268245,
-0.2190567106,
-0.1529224515,
-0.0803402364,
0.0427922234,
-0.9435161352,
-0.0482374877,
-0.0926284268,
-0.5190144777,
0.0907974094,
-0.0530550964,
-0.7738197446,
-0.2145791799,
-0.5882663727,
0.2822312713,
-0.1477364451,
-0.5211206675,
0.1676737368,
-0.0147833107,
-0.1182865724,
0.226301983,
-0.7504380345,
0.4760529399,
0.1898503155,
0.9662901163,
-0.191809833,
-0.6752104759,
-0.3334495425,
-0.081907846,
-0.4386256337,
0.3434399068,
-0.0372500941,
-0.4955530465,
-0.4032300115,
0.1894599348,
-0.5317515135,
-0.7019131184,
0.2430211753,
-0.3405556679,
-0.0074341167,
-0.4383621812,
-0.2715006769,
-0.3045710325,
-0.0144624487,
-0.9976688027,
0.5748975873,
0.0206421074,
-0.6363596916,
0.7720354795,
-0.5898785591,
-0.7363137007,
-0.3077772558,
0.0047903578,
-0.4068041444,
0.2635424733,
0.1655860692,
0.2931275666,
-0.3137409091,
-0.0541143864,
-0.21467264,
-0.0513321012,
0.0710769668,
-0.7708474398,
0.5927497149,
0.2871226668,
-0.2211683393,
-0.4358203411,
-0.6835126877,
-0.1149435267,
0.1810041368,
-0.2388651073,
-0.5284517407,
-0.1140089482,
0.0254051834,
0.4976277351,
0.0032732,
-0.5067715049,
0.1184853762,
-0.1056233123,
0.2635349333,
0.4268769324,
-0.0571648329,
0.5003277063,
-0.2451034039,
0.672362268,
0.3531332612,
-0.0299022868,
-0.0592281558,
-0.6154527068,
-0.4337542653,
-0.3764627874,
0.5987657905,
0.4717174172,
-0.5847596526,
-0.2515673041,
-0.4026351273,
-0.3694649637,
-0.8675928116,
0.1959304512,
0.3006456792,
0.4830981493,
0.5816764235,
-0.4577296674,
-0.4512291849,
-0.9563471079,
-0.1907850504,
-0.0121383779,
0.1754722297,
0.1601021886,
0.325774163,
-0.193150714,
0.7301971316,
-0.2387330383,
-0.3105750978,
-0.0756419152,
0.5057237148,
0.0843369812,
0.7144999504,
0.6718034744,
-1.035600543,
-0.6800764203,
0.3303826749,
-0.8262524009,
-0.0974437296,
-0.1148928925,
0.2349395752,
0.3095529675,
0.2845678627,
-0.2684911788,
0.4256759882,
1.0824006796,
-0.1416646242,
0.3115513623,
-0.690869987,
0.5902035236,
-0.9562571049,
0.0417291112,
0.0116977505,
-0.2319465429,
-0.728284657,
-0.2638180554,
0.2761197686,
-0.0007067797,
-0.1488936096,
0.3628686965,
-0.4815701842,
0.0342984721,
-0.1595995575,
-0.1041710749,
0.1739702076,
0.1750834137,
-0.0617765747,
0.9870399833,
0.2595454454,
-0.4452389181,
0.015489609,
0.1428157389,
-0.0929717794,
0.6077290177,
-0.4095702767,
0.0787407756,
0.0151333418,
-0.2329105139,
-1.0407651663,
0.0550275259,
-0.1697179377,
-0.4493610561,
0.6705346107,
-0.358271271,
-0.7605796456,
-0.3305079341,
0.0407689549,
0.7098733783,
0.2035323232,
-0.3788748384,
0.039025344,
0.3644876182,
-0.1371261925,
-0.3812522888,
-1.1431133747,
0.1622253805,
-0.2803735435,
-0.613329649,
0.0190952457,
-0.3058632016,
-0.2009328455,
-0.1878600419,
-0.304096818,
-0.470028311,
0.0532297418,
0.0693390742,
0.1544380933,
-0.3556634486,
0.091748096,
0.2229164988,
-0.1286498904,
0.097363852,
-0.2071443647,
0.2404809594,
-0.1300232857,
-0.1152631119,
-0.2599385083,
0.5290268064,
1.0191714764,
-0.3150539398,
1.0401237011,
0.4955275059,
-0.133479476,
-0.0296953544,
-0.2878111899,
-0.2032212466,
-0.3542954326,
0.2238550484,
-0.8219059706,
-0.3475147188,
0.5907207727,
-0.0978715569,
-0.0781561136,
0.5828472376,
0.4617068768,
-0.0305851493,
1.0836087465,
0.8092579842,
-0.2018934786,
0.2830345929,
-0.3770916462,
0.1752634346,
-0.6496399045,
0.1210060492,
-0.3936716318,
-0.3606414199,
-0.9307402372,
-0.3227156699,
0.4559258223,
0.0127112092,
0.2459675223,
0.5505161285,
-0.1169671193,
0.1760079712,
0.4006505311,
-0.1055599228,
0.6226997375,
0.178269431,
-0.1074148342,
-0.5354703069,
-1.0116032362,
-0.2212107182,
1.2949930429,
0.2478751093,
0.6316663623,
-0.0043792268,
0.5116940737,
0.2242902964,
0.3562247753,
-0.5977187157,
-0.0099743651,
-0.5421165228,
-0.7995167375,
-0.4034370482,
-0.8223353624,
-1.0535498857,
0.6718864441,
0.1001322865,
0.0572413281,
0.3787741363,
0.0337150767,
-0.1733820885,
0.2952610552,
-1.0002976656,
1.1295125484,
-0.0023789657,
-0.1954201609,
-0.2927011251,
-0.6090074182,
-0.0014064057,
-0.5432735682,
0.7579120994,
-0.0133659123,
-0.0412174873,
0.7092558146,
-0.1934714019,
0.72226125,
-0.0490716919,
-0.304751128,
-0.0371841043,
0.2982322574,
0.2736397982,
-0.0791248381,
-0.1201354712,
0.6681978106,
0.2440283448,
-0.5586820841,
-0.5073485374,
0.6748685241,
-0.8290593028,
-0.383623898,
-0.2008558512,
-1.0176771879,
-0.108543694,
0.2447553873,
0.2684318423,
0.5101519823,
0.0635517985,
0.2228069454,
0.4242319465,
0.2425746471,
0.3984919488,
0.6421732903,
0.0278591979,
-0.3690991402,
0.8642303944,
0.7064862847,
0.67541188,
0.1873260587,
0.0892015621,
-0.0513591915,
-0.5686433315,
-0.8850093484,
0.5024471879,
-0.6794451475,
-0.0504468903,
-0.5223412514,
0.004108225,
-0.4941354394,
0.0502347499,
-0.6485955715,
-0.5461181402,
0.1214985475,
-0.0206646603,
0.0014271769,
0.6152526736,
-0.4182794392,
0.1970860511,
-0.8532028794,
0.1669275761,
0.0736804381,
0.056541644,
-0.1390091777,
-0.5673717856,
-0.8577105403,
0.2240082026,
0.1659581363,
-0.6193526983,
0.5246661305,
0.0327862389,
0.4145304263,
-0.0098357657,
-0.1657160223,
0.8168045282,
-0.690621376,
0.3482742608,
-0.0197147503,
-0.6961910725,
0.1869202852,
-0.2939591706,
0.6968774199,
0.466830492,
0.4981275201,
-0.8804157376,
-0.4082355499,
-0.2710539103,
-0.5994421244,
0.7553955913,
0.3284662962,
-0.0866650566,
0.2224738747,
0.3346986175,
0.4187500477,
0.4992207587,
-0.7121086717,
-0.5663599372,
-0.037393257,
-0.0452343933,
-0.6069853902,
-0.169805333,
0.0043856478,
-0.3794508576,
0.2141151726,
-0.0052365237,
-0.0974726155,
0.1935009658,
-0.2664592564,
-0.461958915,
0.0786818415,
0.4932895601,
0.5515188575,
-0.2859762907,
0.0429031998,
0.0726607591,
-0.4724977016,
0.226286754,
0.0640577227,
0.0201127734,
0.000567995,
0.4930206239,
0.4781154692,
0.003582756,
-0.1571424603,
0.2414596528,
0.0315522179,
-0.2006760687,
0.2609862387,
-0.4687120616,
-0.1799398214,
-0.038283512,
0.0789317191,
0.2803576291,
0.080704838,
-0.3671367466,
0.2401630133,
0.1163411289,
-0.1557806879,
-0.5858077407,
0.6204891205,
0.0310118925,
0.0909171924,
0.6379115582,
0.0516386628,
-0.2199477851,
0.8032603264,
0.4721887708,
0.6335977316,
-0.5966047049,
0.0718143657,
0.3553604186,
0.835626781,
0.0201405343,
-0.0835630149,
0.0262295827,
-0.5160437226,
-0.5830776691,
-0.4291310608,
-0.2181577086,
-0.1548426598,
-0.7196295857,
0.0527554713,
0.0846671313,
-0.1965301633,
0.0402839184,
0.0199096799,
-0.7105947733,
0.3039974868,
0.0991818532,
0.5453414917,
-0.9997757077,
1.1995066404,
0.7059583664,
-0.5113868713,
-0.5135839581,
-0.1913661808,
0.3150402009,
-0.4780634642,
0.8917402625,
-0.0911877453,
-0.2191410661,
0.3037733734,
0.1794304103,
-0.9745850563,
0.9397355914,
0.3398988545,
-0.3789447546,
-0.101650916,
0.6676480174,
0.5448111296,
-0.3406631052,
-0.1057850644,
0.5756756067,
0.6636374593,
-0.0408409759,
-1.3993341923,
-0.1069711074,
0.1619501561,
-0.0797556639,
0.398158282,
-0.6555761099,
1.1616700888,
-0.0527223535,
-0.2137219459,
-0.2358754724,
0.1744004935,
-0.5291237235,
0.3015784323,
0.4227755368,
0.4954564571,
0.5196471214,
0.1367663443,
1.207493782,
-0.3088837862,
0.4215868711,
0.9695258141,
-0.0467007682,
0.5256460309,
0.5464789867,
-0.1393156052,
0.1621131748,
0.6289336681,
0.097832337,
0.4665289521,
-0.0792457461,
0.0833927691,
-0.1232008934,
0.1537136734,
-0.4488483965,
0.2755077779,
0.1891523153,
-0.2296989411,
-0.3915000856,
0.5358592272,
0.2169581801,
0.0227488857,
-0.1571481675,
0.5905948281,
0.2819350362,
-0.3408298194,
0.9207315445,
0.0486686528,
0.2581302226,
-0.5062366128,
0.1523585469,
-0.7405577302,
0.5046252608,
-0.0157126132,
-0.3028814197,
0.5894339681,
-0.2437432259,
-0.5878700614,
-0.5866064429,
0.2738741934,
-0.6728613973,
-0.40593943,
0.6417623162,
1.0603021383,
0.186811015,
-0.2825708985,
-0.6591860056,
-0.0230020937,
-0.0532962829,
-0.2822425365,
0.5114411712,
0.8020900488,
-0.0292475633,
0.6291092038,
0.5262886882,
0.4113552272,
0.2142926008,
-0.1150542647,
0.6175267696,
-0.6344290376,
-0.018632669,
-0.8643230796,
0.261002481,
0.0999365896,
-0.0776560605,
1.288376689,
0.732717216,
1.0240414143,
-0.0258458592,
0.4388926923,
0.1102746949,
0.3004344702,
-0.2627466917,
0.7178942561,
-0.9213004708,
0.0639967471,
0.054574836,
-0.7166964412,
-0.4788868725,
0.0583658926,
-0.3603262305,
-0.0631760806,
1.0902947187,
0.5680909157,
-0.1423782408,
-0.2424556166,
0.7672035098,
0.2025511414,
0.176031366,
0.3013646305,
0.1371957958,
-0.6903176308,
0.6956410408,
-0.3175319433,
-0.3389617205,
0.0282389615,
-0.4543944895,
-0.8127532005,
-0.5089761019,
-0.4615555406,
-0.152326107,
-0.0383609459,
0.5666422248,
0.8871317506,
-0.7057489753,
-0.7843974829,
0.0951724052,
0.066324912,
-0.5956396461,
-0.1235813871,
0.2000012845,
-0.6082974076,
-1.0329426527,
0.4909740686,
0.3756660521,
0.365375489,
-0.158337757,
0.0137640703,
-0.2504934967,
0.015776867,
0.7753812671,
0.0503328405,
-0.3904716372,
0.099653177,
0.0190105475,
-0.4454809725,
0.3283663392,
0.9035096169,
-0.4558830559,
0.6875684857,
0.1327252537,
0.5034751296,
0.5278781652,
-0.2425660044,
0.8784829378,
-0.6954665184,
0.3796247542,
-0.0700183436,
0.1658386439,
0.2543075979,
-0.2688073814,
0.6322697401,
0.6291930676,
-0.5419068933,
-0.705673337,
0.0041914494,
-0.4760534465,
-0.2814331055,
0.9513167739,
-0.2445417196,
-0.1589107662,
-0.0557078943,
-0.0208745692,
0.2063673139,
-0.0655456558,
0.6188918948,
1.2052266598,
0.1423149556,
-0.2076811045,
-0.9823775291,
0.4906470776,
0.5862834454,
-0.4907080829,
0.3170443773,
0.3645582497,
0.0108575784,
0.1021740437,
0.4220118225,
-0.1616448164,
0.0606617182,
0.3278014958,
-0.1005821526,
0.0603349134,
-0.3491357863,
-0.517783463,
0.0490498617,
0.1291088015,
-0.2781939209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14106v1 | Better Zero-Shot Reasoning with Self-Adaptive Prompting | 2023-05-23T14:27:16 | 2023-05-23T14:27:16 | Xingchen Wan, Ruoxi Sun, Hanjun Dai, Sercan O. Arik, Tomas Pfister | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Modern large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities
at sophisticated tasks, often through step-by-step reasoning similar to humans.
This is made possible by their strong few and zero-shot abilities -- they can
effectively learn from a handful of handcrafted, completed responses
("in-context examples"), or are prompted to reason spontaneously through
specially designed triggers. Nonetheless, some limitations have been observed.
First, performance in the few-shot setting is sensitive to the choice of
examples, whose design requires significant human effort. Moreover, given the
diverse downstream tasks of LLMs, it may be difficult or laborious to handcraft
per-task labels. Second, while the zero-shot setting does not require
handcrafting, its performance is limited due to the lack of guidance to the
LLMs. To address these limitations, we propose Consistency-based Self-adaptive
Prompting (COSP), a novel prompt design method for LLMs. Requiring neither
handcrafted responses nor ground-truth labels, COSP selects and builds the set
of examples from the LLM zero-shot outputs via carefully designed criteria that
combine consistency, diversity and repetition. In the zero-shot setting for
three different LLMs, we show that using only LLM predictions, COSP improves
performance up to 15% compared to zero-shot baselines and matches or exceeds
few-shot baselines for a range of reasoning tasks. | [
-0.184752807,
-0.7261071801,
0.8432807922,
0.388967216,
-0.1616231799,
-0.012910475,
-0.3273477554,
-0.2784252465,
-0.0302093476,
0.3136649132,
-0.8269386292,
-0.450833112,
-0.4215176404,
0.4792816341,
0.0948864222,
0.5962020755,
-0.0527303554,
-0.3616520166,
-0.2527286112,
-0.2260228246,
-1.0312265158,
-0.1971504986,
-0.7197798491,
-0.4250328839,
0.6161500812,
0.9408305883,
0.362041831,
0.5126793385,
0.1552165896,
0.1996707171,
0.0721073449,
0.2215080708,
-0.3936240971,
0.5620689988,
-0.5103386641,
-0.3703608513,
-0.3741818964,
-0.1625253111,
0.2896759808,
0.451264292,
-0.0623108335,
0.1144892946,
0.2432571501,
0.4658176601,
-0.788808763,
-0.0395801328,
-0.6320035458,
0.014643372,
0.1559153199,
-0.307616204,
-0.5876013637,
0.0520329885,
-0.0274317563,
-0.7783508897,
0.1429971009,
0.0406680293,
0.4962525666,
0.4424576163,
-0.0699602365,
-0.2914392054,
-0.6399752498,
0.9291298985,
-0.7838630676,
0.4108959138,
0.1714771241,
0.3894229233,
-0.4767657518,
-0.2032286227,
-0.559217453,
-0.3008549511,
0.2036475688,
0.209763214,
-0.2273876965,
-0.1335887015,
0.4617569745,
-0.110928528,
-0.6967710853,
0.3980106711,
0.055961933,
-0.2752783597,
0.4925607443,
0.2990072966,
0.0736005828,
-0.1312398165,
-0.3508734703,
-0.0097638182,
-0.9357895851,
0.2442625463,
-0.0255331807,
0.5264430046,
-0.147317484,
0.414521575,
-0.4731708765,
1.1107840538,
0.5486440659,
-0.2425421476,
-0.0562546849,
-0.2070804089,
-0.2764522135,
-0.0094633792,
0.7407719493,
0.3841471672,
0.3697075546,
0.1076847538,
0.0319827832,
-0.0351130553,
0.0496984385,
-0.612205267,
-0.1964460611,
0.398876816,
-0.0502356067,
0.0900451094,
-0.5372440219,
-0.6416024566,
-0.5047318339,
-0.3772850037,
0.6414294243,
-0.4726608992,
0.0228145141,
0.3296716511,
-0.1356098801,
0.2744989097,
0.8119980693,
-0.9411306977,
0.0716445446,
0.478282094,
0.8256013989,
-0.2439361811,
-0.3769056499,
-0.7138724327,
0.2257944047,
-0.4065811634,
1.1259349585,
-0.4068837166,
-0.39262712,
-0.3409286141,
-0.3079299629,
0.129498601,
-0.5666261315,
0.4702119827,
-0.1430577487,
0.4037518799,
-0.62388587,
-0.7406511903,
0.0655326247,
0.4795815945,
-0.1028231457,
0.8167220354,
0.0053752493,
-0.3635116518,
0.5799869895,
-0.6365991235,
-0.3163641393,
0.2626624405,
-0.4478264749,
-0.1897387356,
0.0894284174,
0.3832796812,
0.5171140432,
-0.0591078289,
0.1677919775,
-0.5383320451,
-0.5032006502,
-0.107623823,
-0.4845788777,
0.7510102987,
0.1963415891,
-0.4834289551,
0.0680827424,
-0.7013534307,
0.0459621064,
0.1681017429,
-0.0443987474,
-0.0557280593,
0.0047392696,
-0.837012887,
0.2845696211,
0.1605089903,
-0.5871487856,
0.2971244454,
-0.2466748655,
0.0306351222,
0.8858072758,
0.0822818875,
0.5763841867,
-0.5520244837,
0.4621536136,
0.0484668128,
0.0216535795,
-0.7857971191,
-0.459913373,
-0.8581773639,
-0.414226234,
-0.1534707397,
0.6503579617,
-0.675147891,
0.540905416,
0.0469639227,
-0.3510445058,
-0.267175287,
0.3143969476,
0.1784421951,
0.9546440244,
0.5314255953,
-0.1853479743,
-0.5450279713,
-0.5048725009,
-0.4614683986,
-0.2119953781,
-0.1021199897,
0.3511148393,
0.2305637449,
0.3335244358,
1.1867656708,
-0.4799670875,
-0.1342481226,
-0.2523228526,
0.2415669411,
0.372801125,
0.3270119131,
0.4398621917,
0.0464071184,
-0.7524088025,
-0.3688807786,
-0.9032984972,
-0.5287769437,
-0.4861612618,
0.0139447246,
0.2049203813,
0.3493017554,
-0.5112508535,
0.3910603225,
0.3462879658,
-0.5035639405,
0.6742434502,
-0.292958647,
-0.0360033959,
-0.9016569257,
-0.1521506608,
0.1483976245,
-0.2751553357,
-0.5907949209,
-0.1360380948,
0.0966293067,
-0.0616719164,
-0.5239841342,
1.0371674299,
-0.5843629837,
0.0930339023,
-0.501969099,
0.0874179378,
0.3103885651,
0.4149691463,
0.2250355482,
0.8428167701,
0.8295331001,
-0.8596500754,
0.3965602517,
0.0999074727,
-0.2047330886,
1.0320148468,
-0.8387798667,
0.211515516,
-0.1813896149,
0.4315747023,
-0.9884200692,
-0.2300069481,
0.5594299436,
-0.3721096218,
0.2871065736,
-0.0604549907,
-0.163282305,
-0.3351415396,
-0.2303958237,
0.2081453651,
0.6002700329,
-0.733920455,
0.4970107675,
-0.3427853584,
-0.3061881661,
-0.4863693118,
-0.4790443182,
0.1989853233,
-0.0809817389,
-0.5247169733,
0.1396939605,
-0.5114207268,
-0.1481937617,
-0.3034076989,
-0.2511520684,
0.1428401768,
0.1839207858,
0.1842396408,
0.2650845647,
-0.207592845,
0.2169332802,
-0.0395728648,
-0.1527472287,
-0.2497849017,
-0.2646962404,
0.4654666483,
0.0361000672,
-0.6361733079,
-0.7520437837,
0.3547863364,
0.3398386836,
0.1321582943,
0.4958467484,
0.2801096141,
-0.1176357195,
-0.4285835624,
-0.5895380974,
-0.3388962746,
-0.51137501,
-0.1654943973,
-0.5319106579,
-1.1239286661,
0.3942835331,
-0.0306407195,
0.2371763438,
0.2489467561,
0.7790436745,
-0.4602890313,
0.7449200749,
0.447091043,
0.1592154652,
0.4321501851,
0.1821326762,
0.0107602933,
-0.636506021,
-0.2020815909,
-0.4836706519,
-0.2147103697,
-0.0832118765,
-0.4949464202,
0.3217951655,
0.0973996669,
-0.5122473836,
0.3368762434,
-0.6307346821,
0.5985127091,
0.5965172052,
0.0305681992,
0.3795118928,
0.0738144666,
-0.2826762497,
-0.0002241569,
-0.8933426738,
-0.44325158,
0.7502856851,
0.2596878409,
0.991307497,
0.0152696399,
1.0060926676,
0.2133565098,
0.141484499,
-0.7535313368,
0.5721870065,
0.082585454,
-0.5614702702,
-0.4454679489,
-0.282155633,
-0.9853628874,
0.0513385646,
-0.2016614377,
-0.7738038301,
0.3129047453,
0.592817843,
-0.8682441711,
0.0525855012,
-0.6248114109,
0.6790255904,
-0.2554609179,
-0.4867333174,
0.0091749178,
-0.3890504241,
0.1174903512,
0.0879686996,
0.0265765805,
-0.5717609525,
-0.0123422118,
0.295349896,
-0.2346900254,
1.1648344994,
-0.2905391753,
-0.1606499702,
0.5504458547,
0.3918290734,
0.5309892893,
-0.2659859359,
-0.2726185918,
0.0624518581,
-0.1975315809,
-0.5584029555,
-0.8983099461,
0.586428225,
-0.5282014608,
-1.043634057,
-0.4550817609,
-0.5671104789,
-0.2937131524,
0.1637388617,
0.3589808643,
0.3388940394,
-0.1158487871,
-0.0166247878,
0.6367521882,
-0.1764784902,
0.7625223398,
0.9070305824,
-0.0100636436,
-0.2410332412,
0.7050668597,
0.2350053638,
0.358404547,
0.2292600423,
0.3909240067,
-0.5041612387,
-0.497799933,
-0.8436941504,
0.0327036902,
-0.6069272757,
-0.4840568602,
-0.4617421329,
0.0470244698,
-0.506393075,
-0.4524226785,
-0.1212250218,
-0.4820791483,
-0.5541630387,
0.2548369467,
0.3733449876,
0.4509287179,
-0.2608965933,
0.1982289106,
-0.7293652892,
0.4182635546,
0.5513009429,
0.4798516631,
0.0207194388,
-1.1026462317,
0.1135181412,
-0.0447586067,
-0.4510506094,
-0.889555037,
0.1336457878,
0.3258697093,
0.6976921558,
0.1835299581,
0.2799514532,
0.8389046192,
-0.6823239326,
0.918178618,
0.4460290372,
-0.9639576077,
0.727774322,
-0.399834305,
0.842691958,
0.5297169089,
0.3562306166,
-0.6170679927,
-0.3506843448,
-0.4879637361,
-0.3586099744,
0.5699037313,
-0.0739253089,
0.2044716179,
-0.1998580843,
0.5550698638,
0.2708810568,
-0.2335142791,
-0.6339831352,
0.0313218348,
-0.2963829339,
-0.4082456827,
0.0634434447,
-0.2690653205,
-0.0013727073,
-0.1984215528,
0.5652083158,
-0.562592566,
0.1470680237,
0.434512645,
-0.0495348312,
-0.2635510862,
0.5227019191,
0.8912843466,
0.6082738042,
-0.000319736,
0.3224156499,
0.5162922144,
0.0664583296,
0.5952093601,
-0.3333696425,
-0.4019599557,
-0.1853631884,
0.4060334563,
0.8112695813,
0.0874647796,
-0.6059203148,
0.4563772678,
0.0843510106,
-0.1102789044,
-0.0438278988,
0.4727090299,
0.014267467,
0.3753355145,
0.2899879217,
0.0311658252,
-0.1615021229,
-0.4737564027,
0.2474800497,
0.3897714615,
-0.2729253769,
-0.3336727321,
0.4488759637,
0.1101829484,
-0.5315437317,
0.3736820519,
-0.3997583985,
-0.1381794065,
0.3756357133,
0.8797029853,
0.9444727302,
-0.3412662745,
0.4378666282,
0.5626292229,
0.0778479651,
-0.2424999475,
0.4124475718,
-0.2624964416,
-0.8479478955,
-0.6745358706,
-0.5339801311,
-0.8274888396,
-0.1107993871,
-0.3344568908,
0.3781104088,
-0.8465796113,
-0.0146504752,
-0.2009290904,
-0.2128458619,
-0.4186422825,
0.2778379321,
0.2479082197,
1.1864830256,
-0.774479866,
0.5923451781,
0.449305594,
-0.2731788754,
-0.7876737714,
-0.0331929438,
0.1745018065,
-0.9060800672,
0.3666586578,
0.0105035165,
-0.1854890734,
-0.0614788979,
-0.69727391,
-0.814963758,
1.1148905754,
0.6822282672,
-0.8748775125,
0.1304289699,
0.0298831351,
0.5327855945,
-0.4451673627,
0.2713929415,
0.2876649201,
0.3625984192,
0.6378403306,
-0.8333791494,
0.1629371047,
0.1859729439,
-0.2289238423,
-0.102517575,
-0.7225327492,
0.651373744,
-0.3859150708,
-0.2408934683,
0.1101793051,
0.7520285249,
0.8670784831,
0.5116257668,
0.5100003481,
0.6078308225,
0.8168630004,
0.1122749895,
0.7746169567,
-0.1708732545,
0.145585686,
1.6556646824,
-0.5966722965,
0.9087057114,
0.2939791977,
0.0091509791,
0.8282641768,
0.5725698471,
0.0169554297,
0.254211545,
-0.0665489361,
-0.503277719,
-0.6242387295,
-0.1917748153,
-0.0760841593,
0.5504859686,
0.1366341561,
0.0029257226,
-0.5887724757,
-0.1659206599,
-0.0246110428,
0.1403033137,
-0.3395501673,
0.8472834229,
0.1657218784,
-0.9634386897,
0.7455868721,
-0.2625932992,
0.6876627207,
-0.388797462,
-0.1012049541,
-0.3124661744,
-0.1508123577,
-0.1049255058,
-1.036831975,
0.3309689462,
0.1714061201,
-0.2826890349,
-0.3898220956,
1.1060745716,
-0.3383802176,
-0.2815952003,
0.0681544021,
0.6810250878,
0.1221885681,
-0.0805547163,
-0.8338577151,
0.2230794877,
-0.1141994596,
0.0217267517,
0.3202697933,
0.4458896816,
-0.0500494391,
0.7910454273,
0.6004594564,
0.0071153496,
-0.0024765264,
0.0631239191,
0.6507737041,
-0.8749097586,
-0.2605309188,
-1.1258974075,
0.4603374004,
-0.0740534961,
-0.1258972138,
0.7648004293,
0.2456613481,
0.5945754647,
-0.0156731494,
0.7147427201,
0.1800107807,
0.6330923438,
-0.3749636114,
0.2514355779,
-0.4608774483,
0.2364899814,
-0.0547115989,
-0.7309402823,
-0.4759206176,
0.7356402874,
-0.2781892419,
0.011064522,
0.4292432964,
0.8272122145,
0.0768753067,
-0.1439800709,
0.7878542542,
0.1340472549,
0.2860963047,
0.6499359012,
0.8761847615,
-0.0098280534,
0.3536244631,
-0.084035866,
-0.2732416391,
-0.2358069569,
-1.3992933035,
-0.8873111606,
-0.0912987664,
-0.3831376135,
-0.3103255332,
0.0151557224,
1.1809072495,
0.6561555862,
-0.9469204545,
-0.1959860623,
-0.2626375556,
0.2701121867,
-0.0963831022,
-0.2057207972,
-0.1266656518,
-0.7089884281,
-0.4729483724,
0.7045542002,
0.8060083389,
0.1516061276,
-0.1996663064,
-0.3115237951,
-0.0487121567,
0.4154403806,
0.6453644037,
0.7680324912,
-0.8772659302,
-0.8326970935,
0.2867763042,
-0.0355284102,
0.2950927913,
0.553168118,
-1.0674973726,
0.767359972,
0.5534316897,
0.4685238302,
0.1284149885,
0.0318294019,
0.5312299132,
-0.7447932363,
-0.0143823484,
0.229078114,
0.2226615101,
0.5072207451,
-0.3726499379,
0.2457125038,
0.378757447,
-0.588567853,
-0.5335896015,
0.5587027669,
-1.0946851969,
-0.2373354584,
1.130030632,
-0.366931051,
-0.188272804,
-0.3437767625,
-0.2853606343,
0.0572142005,
-0.5004973412,
0.8579522967,
0.5896255374,
-0.6721062064,
-0.6245492697,
0.0555120222,
0.3006418347,
0.6821473837,
-0.738471806,
0.1188680604,
0.6476746202,
0.6265566945,
0.0594051816,
0.9569242001,
0.2673702538,
0.4575736821,
-0.1214970127,
-0.0148287453,
-0.1033577397,
-0.5485911965,
-0.5237547159,
0.1768538505,
0.355268091,
0.1228086799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14105v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14105v2 | CTQScorer: Combining Multiple Features for In-context Example Selection for Machine Translation | 2023-05-23T14:26:17 | 2023-10-21T14:22:02 | Aswanth Kumar, Ratish Puduppully, Raj Dabre, Anoop Kunchukuttan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models have demonstrated the capability to perform on machine
translation when the input is prompted with a few examples (in-context
learning). Translation quality depends on various features of the selected
examples, such as their quality and relevance, but previous work has
predominantly focused on individual features in isolation. In this paper, we
propose a general framework for combining different features influencing
example selection. We learn a regression model, CTQ Scorer (Contextual
Translation Quality), that selects examples based on multiple features in order
to maximize the translation quality. On multiple language pairs and language
models, we show that CTQ Scorer helps significantly outperform random selection
as well as strong single-factor baselines reported in the literature. We also
see an improvement of over 2.5 COMET points on average with respect to a strong
BM25 retrieval-based baseline. | [
-0.2875704169,
-0.5880978703,
0.6389377117,
0.1510789096,
-0.6696186662,
-0.227016151,
-0.1625023335,
-0.2199266702,
-0.0548327416,
0.7670839429,
-0.0861765295,
-0.6100147963,
-0.630659759,
0.1336357296,
-0.7600249648,
1.1946107149,
0.1156552732,
0.2513911426,
-0.1927864403,
-0.5355444551,
-0.6980420351,
-0.7883870006,
-0.6384778619,
-0.2130336314,
0.2079458088,
0.5214220285,
0.7811743617,
0.4476852715,
0.4699662924,
0.2448693812,
0.0736556351,
0.4401412308,
-0.3993745446,
0.6062718034,
0.0026216786,
-0.3202656209,
-0.2373580486,
0.262183845,
0.8084801435,
0.4303870499,
0.2375896126,
-0.0292636938,
0.3661964834,
0.3593932688,
-0.485829711,
-0.2157553136,
-0.5244941115,
0.0476429872,
0.1581933796,
-0.1874652654,
-0.5075305104,
-0.5412968397,
0.1061732098,
-0.43953982,
0.2800951898,
-0.0748002306,
0.6698512435,
0.1331197023,
-0.9851229191,
-0.2118435353,
-0.4995114803,
1.1086709499,
-0.6114547849,
0.3652197123,
0.3095946908,
0.6188806295,
-0.037312232,
-0.6573957205,
-0.2266263515,
-0.2075854838,
-0.2843493521,
0.4819885492,
-0.0051677087,
-0.2261695117,
-0.0666415021,
0.3593243062,
-0.534209013,
-0.2112913728,
-0.1328561306,
-0.1366194189,
0.4297488332,
0.1354032606,
0.0713153556,
-0.1233753264,
-0.4415873587,
-0.6075087786,
-0.5575113893,
0.3802713454,
0.0459411182,
0.4765187502,
-0.0482357107,
0.4947479665,
-0.3455066979,
0.8322325349,
-0.0713832229,
-0.251621902,
0.2696083188,
-0.7026488781,
-0.2237953991,
-0.14976421,
0.8170998693,
0.3329707086,
-0.2299892008,
-0.1498375982,
-0.3687276542,
-0.4014616311,
0.1782867014,
-0.8341582417,
-0.0692562535,
0.4083613157,
-0.7731174827,
-0.1988499463,
0.3791569769,
-0.623344481,
0.0530987456,
-0.2166786641,
0.3443925381,
-0.7386853099,
0.0317414403,
-0.1649359614,
-0.6179792285,
0.2105288208,
0.3178172708,
-0.4958519638,
0.193151176,
0.4802892208,
0.7442148924,
-0.1860351562,
-0.4753398597,
-1.201639533,
-0.1121858209,
-0.2390919477,
0.6734071374,
-0.7082187533,
-0.51711303,
0.1102378815,
-0.3324800134,
0.0816888884,
-0.3947592378,
0.7536367774,
-0.3241531551,
0.5956690907,
-0.1993902922,
-0.4586892724,
-0.5506659746,
0.1525336206,
-0.5373473167,
1.2524379492,
0.506074369,
-0.326887697,
0.7432444096,
-0.394462347,
-0.4649352133,
0.1857764125,
-0.1418833584,
-0.4749954641,
0.4148342013,
0.380320698,
0.5935170054,
-0.2876397669,
0.0457580499,
-0.2033916414,
-0.3948248625,
0.4469536245,
-0.3301416039,
0.7809680104,
0.4829751551,
0.1598487645,
0.2499355227,
-0.4335950613,
0.3244367838,
-0.1831984073,
-0.6837064028,
-0.4855526984,
-0.2121371776,
0.4286462069,
0.642823875,
0.0586772263,
-0.0880406648,
0.246277988,
-0.0350529924,
0.3165158927,
-0.1330161393,
0.2610881627,
0.5348279476,
-0.3702214062,
0.6762294173,
0.2433396876,
0.1768546849,
-0.1853095293,
-0.5876514316,
-0.4131478369,
-0.5105139017,
0.5303815603,
0.4872229695,
-0.9182462692,
0.4960863292,
-0.1450241804,
-0.3916389048,
-0.7004756331,
0.4123671949,
0.8293524981,
0.3320427835,
0.7071717978,
-0.415184468,
-0.2255284339,
-0.8432222605,
-0.3043557405,
-0.0706582442,
-0.2326217443,
0.0783984885,
0.2245626301,
0.3086500466,
0.8916921616,
-0.2241210341,
-0.3686690629,
-0.5145458579,
0.2155514807,
0.3155258,
0.4092496634,
0.8938834071,
-1.247071743,
-0.3149269223,
0.0450789891,
-0.5787066817,
0.0445035361,
-0.1876531541,
-0.1978490651,
-0.1041372567,
0.3766405582,
-0.2976902127,
0.1856970936,
0.5645179152,
-0.310967952,
0.3145546615,
-0.3664671183,
0.7154570222,
-1.3496079445,
-0.1291891336,
0.4016849697,
-0.5221472383,
-0.7102127075,
0.4194657207,
0.4864776731,
0.1845984608,
-0.9337189198,
0.4379467666,
-0.2042997628,
-0.0176420845,
-0.3373889625,
0.4194363058,
0.0905156136,
0.1172000989,
-0.1105655506,
0.7840053439,
0.185844928,
-0.6532506943,
0.0797353536,
0.3915267289,
-0.2509200275,
0.6698054075,
-0.3740338981,
0.0359490402,
0.2029953152,
0.0883552507,
-1.0018490553,
-0.1571132988,
-0.1116574034,
-0.567789793,
0.0553165227,
-0.2952952385,
-0.6756389141,
-0.1631805003,
-0.306843549,
0.2308232337,
0.6046869755,
-0.5547747612,
0.5858213305,
0.1686068773,
0.1176818311,
-0.4235864282,
-0.4747669399,
0.2066495419,
-0.4784578681,
-0.3063671887,
0.5757036209,
-0.0304785781,
-0.0307631306,
-0.07624989,
0.1245816946,
-0.049987454,
0.3153803349,
0.0323961228,
0.1354914457,
-0.171987012,
0.1121558547,
0.4461141229,
0.0218042992,
-0.5142175555,
-0.2994688451,
0.4173615277,
-0.100763157,
0.0047027306,
-0.1711127162,
0.6567077041,
0.4856112599,
-0.3661570549,
0.6447641253,
0.5611753464,
-0.168095693,
-0.2435865551,
-0.4423257411,
-0.2360389233,
-0.3615992069,
0.5095288157,
-0.6746746898,
-0.9976608753,
0.3701582849,
0.1278003901,
-0.0400243923,
0.4087692499,
0.5062888861,
-0.0983830094,
1.3037325144,
0.7223541737,
-0.1387295276,
0.6055401564,
-0.0147914933,
0.0895155668,
-0.9400916696,
0.047197666,
-0.8204149008,
-0.1863348186,
-0.7473454475,
-0.334551543,
0.5769206285,
0.5110087991,
-0.1078290939,
0.7504411936,
-0.4042915106,
0.431771189,
0.908498168,
0.3653047383,
0.4865235686,
-0.1199299917,
-0.5642859936,
0.0954307988,
-0.6667291522,
-0.7063719034,
0.8571364284,
-0.04367451,
0.1180757061,
0.4360771477,
0.7276427746,
0.1733736098,
0.1941621453,
-0.6541107893,
0.4267469049,
-0.560669601,
-0.5120635033,
-0.2773348093,
-0.3666786551,
-0.6692009568,
0.7459878325,
-0.5559096932,
-0.5820438862,
0.0122037493,
0.2227839679,
-0.2252292186,
-0.3486432433,
-0.6153362989,
0.8862427473,
-0.4066120684,
-0.2112523764,
-0.1794672161,
-0.5135580897,
0.3228077292,
-0.1213618517,
-0.0254444368,
0.2293859273,
-0.0162701532,
0.2504067123,
-0.0921795815,
0.489546746,
0.1015804783,
0.3022561073,
0.1546258926,
0.2338638902,
0.3216817081,
0.1326012164,
-0.3604427576,
-0.0582248569,
0.1945526451,
-0.3866198659,
-0.6354739666,
0.537958622,
-0.5846431255,
-0.5346747041,
-0.0813113227,
-0.5122206807,
-0.177244857,
0.1672310084,
0.3640706539,
0.397402674,
-0.1552280337,
0.6763320565,
0.1016424671,
-0.0971889719,
0.6846264601,
0.2320511192,
-0.1966981292,
-0.6433572769,
0.6604480147,
-0.0933878347,
0.3680552244,
0.5901886821,
0.2253444791,
-0.2982389629,
-0.8876605034,
-0.5329042673,
-0.0955708176,
-0.9598709941,
-0.4314561486,
-0.5814822912,
-0.2163269222,
-0.3056556284,
-0.1843879372,
-0.1443335563,
-0.5472322702,
-0.0951093286,
0.0573478453,
0.1065392569,
0.3856350482,
0.4682477713,
0.3912376761,
-1.1053907871,
0.1825897098,
0.203128472,
-0.1668155193,
-0.1610193998,
-0.8071042299,
-0.556860745,
-0.0687205046,
-0.7581686378,
-0.8684036732,
0.7574284077,
0.1906549186,
0.9783919454,
0.4517793357,
-0.0097531723,
0.5137277842,
-0.1835534126,
0.9892773032,
0.2273442447,
-1.0132293701,
0.6684496403,
-0.239456743,
0.575769484,
0.7886808515,
0.4006847739,
-0.6784142852,
-0.9469367266,
-0.2732715309,
-0.6642890573,
0.4616295397,
0.4370860755,
-0.0028786394,
-0.057775721,
0.1215142161,
0.3301316202,
0.1431121677,
-0.7370396256,
-0.1206537634,
-0.4087616503,
-0.3829992712,
-0.3046327829,
-0.0648644343,
-0.0604196601,
-0.1532233208,
0.5270938277,
-0.3499802053,
-0.0606290586,
0.0595945343,
-0.3630537093,
0.1800743639,
0.4585731626,
0.6176431775,
0.559931159,
-0.2976866364,
0.0690040886,
0.2183535695,
-0.2968029976,
0.0378542505,
-0.0021400452,
-0.2553830743,
-0.0138773359,
0.373380512,
0.4165794551,
0.3235629499,
-0.3593283594,
0.4710024893,
-0.043325834,
-0.1729459018,
0.013188187,
0.3305526972,
-0.1425299793,
0.4815321267,
0.6402334571,
-0.0161261987,
0.4925452769,
-0.5871617198,
0.3606387079,
0.4138564169,
-0.6461616158,
-0.0369315706,
0.5520934463,
0.1275399625,
-0.2820316553,
0.7059976459,
-0.2364424914,
-0.5906199813,
0.5597196221,
0.5775426626,
0.8385319114,
-0.0763452426,
0.1166734993,
0.4667277932,
-0.0000064874,
-0.4011239409,
0.1412311643,
-0.0130387861,
-0.7960528731,
-0.3216564655,
-0.4214151204,
-0.5384843349,
-0.1107907519,
-0.7502778769,
0.5947592258,
0.1308561414,
-0.2526556849,
-0.1095319539,
0.0181002263,
-0.8923805952,
0.3698598146,
-0.0654843897,
0.6674038768,
-0.8786426187,
1.3097754717,
0.7822346687,
-0.821082592,
-0.5691024065,
0.0620559938,
0.1163639426,
-0.2227009535,
0.6097745895,
0.1273364872,
-0.0295883417,
-0.0903278738,
-0.3992707133,
-0.7027662396,
1.1947824955,
0.133626461,
-0.155366987,
0.3231109679,
-0.1358425319,
0.5353271961,
-0.9744685292,
0.5505456924,
0.6085107923,
0.199900046,
0.0518178791,
-0.7478484511,
0.1540633887,
-0.0845577195,
0.2152191252,
0.192851916,
-0.6853521466,
0.648771286,
0.0890091658,
0.0462477095,
0.2043139488,
0.5736319423,
0.4930732548,
0.0728125423,
0.3075297475,
0.1977999806,
0.4890005291,
-0.059106417,
1.1903135777,
-0.2988530695,
0.301915735,
1.2930033207,
0.0755630732,
1.1870596409,
0.4533292949,
0.071940951,
0.1826859713,
0.6757897139,
-0.0893749073,
0.8103080988,
-0.3388854265,
-0.1570312679,
-0.5219239593,
0.0916913822,
-0.2105377614,
0.8414872885,
0.2057367861,
-0.8064249754,
-0.1714402884,
0.088086389,
-0.1444417983,
0.1711936742,
-0.0456564389,
0.6336194873,
0.1991107166,
-0.9050236344,
0.3740015924,
0.1213513017,
0.4645520747,
-0.2459360957,
-0.4020345211,
-0.4850894809,
-0.1346622556,
0.0631621778,
-0.9217939973,
0.0351211093,
-0.2481386662,
-0.2406388521,
-0.5331279635,
0.2693731487,
-0.419552654,
-0.5598210692,
0.3407426476,
0.7380705476,
0.2057230175,
-0.2016526461,
-0.5499850512,
-0.1980913579,
-0.0854330808,
-0.1376139224,
0.4399847388,
0.5905297995,
-0.1418251544,
0.4988570511,
0.5208540559,
-0.0594341941,
-0.2591495514,
0.1943814307,
0.7456521988,
-0.8992190957,
-0.4560433924,
-0.7313645482,
0.7917233706,
-0.3845358193,
-0.7590182424,
0.8619412184,
0.6839643717,
0.948255837,
-0.1155177578,
0.7166569233,
0.229124397,
0.295122683,
-0.7398194671,
0.7475612164,
-0.6485739946,
0.1520280689,
-0.1914762706,
-1.2070046663,
-0.5603502393,
0.4659957886,
-0.167392984,
0.1904808134,
1.1127222776,
0.468319416,
-0.1861870289,
-0.2648068368,
0.9573754668,
-0.2024217993,
0.3077991903,
0.5634664893,
0.6288586259,
-0.6593416333,
0.8388238549,
-0.1550078541,
-0.0936186761,
-0.5591288805,
-0.9492851496,
-0.9947652817,
-0.9356811047,
-0.3196102679,
-0.3399299979,
-0.0853189304,
1.1280206442,
1.0110765696,
-1.0000020266,
-0.1789031774,
0.4479282796,
0.2627089024,
-0.8010520339,
-0.1622434258,
0.1387607455,
-0.60360533,
-0.8096501231,
0.5213050842,
0.2476910055,
-0.0333777778,
0.2229568809,
-0.0413136072,
-0.0572860241,
-0.0976479426,
0.7264597416,
-0.0976970643,
-0.7830238938,
-0.4757157564,
-0.0862963051,
-0.3802871704,
0.2406335026,
0.8397911787,
-0.8275774717,
0.3932100534,
0.4153594077,
0.4684107304,
0.5998423696,
0.2289135307,
0.6877982616,
-0.7060579062,
0.2020433247,
0.2434759736,
0.5333015919,
0.3051961958,
-0.2737837732,
0.4931564331,
-0.234321028,
-0.4950692058,
-0.4187840819,
0.143758148,
-1.1345244646,
-0.4247216284,
1.0729953051,
-0.2183689326,
0.0253155418,
-0.1231497526,
-0.07639952,
0.3316100538,
-0.6119422913,
0.7885576487,
0.7294668555,
-0.109697707,
-0.5162218809,
-0.8289954662,
0.334987551,
0.2832487822,
-0.5277937055,
-0.4211128056,
0.5563086867,
0.1314997822,
-0.053861618,
0.0443279743,
-0.2124100178,
0.4926970899,
-0.1202196181,
0.0425281897,
0.0269140285,
-0.3278290629,
-0.5094595551,
0.5148993134,
0.3200817108,
-0.1403826177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14104v1 | Out-of-Distribution Generalization in Text Classification: Past, Present, and Future | 2023-05-23T14:26:11 | 2023-05-23T14:26:11 | Linyi Yang, Yaoxiao Song, Xuan Ren, Chenyang Lyu, Yidong Wang, Lingqiao Liu, Jindong Wang, Jennifer Foster, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Machine learning (ML) systems in natural language processing (NLP) face
significant challenges in generalizing to out-of-distribution (OOD) data, where
the test distribution differs from the training data distribution. This poses
important questions about the robustness of NLP models and their high accuracy,
which may be artificially inflated due to their underlying sensitivity to
systematic biases. Despite these challenges, there is a lack of comprehensive
surveys on the generalization challenge from an OOD perspective in text
classification. Therefore, this paper aims to fill this gap by presenting the
first comprehensive review of recent progress, methods, and evaluations on this
topic. We furth discuss the challenges involved and potential future research
directions. By providing quick access to existing work, we hope this survey
will encourage future research in this area. | [
-0.2889031768,
-0.6399441957,
0.3510800898,
-0.0667129457,
0.0183507521,
-0.1065943912,
-0.3509145677,
-0.6052659154,
-0.1694778353,
0.5642482638,
-0.326662302,
-0.5345917344,
-0.8369262218,
0.2454044223,
-0.4720450044,
1.1487071514,
-0.3850909173,
-0.167649433,
-0.2659034729,
-0.4962868392,
-0.4033243358,
-1.0857179165,
-0.2428469658,
-0.1576364785,
0.2016937584,
0.1340470761,
0.4321988225,
0.3387488425,
0.869797945,
0.2675895691,
-0.3092458844,
0.0782502368,
-0.2161827981,
0.4428901374,
-0.1971591562,
-0.6341374516,
-0.3262511194,
-0.0196851827,
0.9977862835,
1.1492156982,
-0.1026513055,
0.0456649177,
0.170595482,
0.791146934,
-0.8714401722,
0.1047915295,
-0.6099606752,
0.30678913,
-0.2220472842,
-0.0849506855,
-0.5533538461,
-0.3038526177,
0.4674509168,
-0.3111578226,
0.6286231875,
0.1195606068,
0.5399184227,
0.3371210992,
-0.6163226962,
-0.7396659255,
-1.0565831661,
1.1143547297,
-0.4428845942,
0.2699649334,
0.419719249,
0.4937179089,
-0.1599710435,
-0.6623649001,
-0.2999460697,
-0.0448001511,
0.209929809,
-0.0221402831,
-0.2105651647,
0.0402817205,
0.0258401204,
0.6056153774,
-0.4557147324,
0.1931506395,
-0.1992874295,
0.1866583377,
0.7248518467,
0.0199908037,
0.2096747309,
0.1648991406,
-0.3148530424,
-0.1513658315,
-0.3509439826,
-0.1851490289,
0.33381778,
0.0480816066,
0.1600100398,
0.6826190948,
-0.0877609849,
0.5873779058,
-0.1486424357,
0.2333845049,
0.4522618353,
-0.4951735735,
-0.3657723665,
-0.0841044039,
0.7962792516,
0.2087784857,
-0.0616321564,
0.0092781568,
-0.1945146173,
-0.133632496,
0.2164567858,
-0.4564580321,
0.1605559886,
0.2302533686,
-0.7119873166,
-0.4259273708,
0.2156959325,
-1.0372086763,
-0.4878016114,
0.0772399753,
0.0074007995,
-0.0614842437,
-0.3266800642,
0.3525043428,
-0.3026502132,
-0.0493770801,
0.2326322943,
-1.1796686649,
0.4029494524,
0.4629723728,
0.8461750746,
-0.3693187833,
-0.0878949389,
-0.2323326468,
0.0246392246,
-0.2782485783,
0.7214387059,
-0.4208979309,
-0.2107565552,
0.3411412537,
-0.2601605058,
-0.3428667188,
-0.875941515,
0.5922264457,
-0.3763612211,
0.5261437297,
0.1079375893,
-0.5940657258,
0.0313703679,
0.3976727128,
-0.3954477906,
1.0982704163,
0.2908968329,
-1.0803725719,
0.4497146308,
-0.6991852522,
0.00103777,
-0.3255980015,
-0.167299822,
-0.5763053298,
0.2987029254,
0.2296233773,
0.5018420219,
-0.2594440877,
0.1953319311,
-0.3801296353,
-0.2215107083,
0.1670589894,
-0.5224443078,
0.784670651,
0.2448292971,
-0.4412205815,
-0.1125605851,
-0.8353351355,
-0.104473941,
0.0444178022,
-0.2423109561,
-0.611433804,
0.2288975418,
-0.0766051486,
-0.0090456493,
-0.0053245388,
-0.517380178,
0.5408802032,
-0.6077254415,
0.6315203905,
0.5263077021,
-0.0237498023,
0.903640151,
-0.1862115115,
0.5980147719,
0.010045954,
0.3584520817,
-0.2013216615,
-0.9538313746,
-0.4137115479,
-0.0782387331,
0.4689674079,
0.7151319981,
-0.6154588461,
0.81657511,
-0.1098610163,
-0.4814070761,
-0.1983038038,
0.0021230408,
0.2388553619,
0.3817644119,
0.5241344571,
-0.1029824167,
-0.4581816196,
-0.4532467425,
-0.0725268349,
-0.4815894365,
-0.1125892997,
0.1438179612,
0.5799706578,
-0.7042752504,
1.2331563234,
-0.5681385994,
-0.6252560616,
-0.5511394143,
0.1700576246,
-0.0471034609,
0.4849039018,
0.5693168044,
-0.9998884201,
-0.3737719655,
0.3222526312,
-0.8750561476,
0.0143047431,
0.1542566866,
0.1689895093,
0.4392352998,
0.634783566,
-0.5289760828,
0.6378932595,
0.602037847,
-0.0743315741,
0.4254327714,
-0.3855481446,
-0.1783493161,
-0.8460134268,
0.0538450405,
-0.113612853,
0.074598901,
-0.8069759607,
0.0073628393,
-0.047296159,
-0.0174059011,
-0.119332388,
0.4964203537,
-0.2822179198,
0.0673054233,
-0.1357612461,
-0.0515359566,
-0.2429564297,
0.0008403865,
0.0043232534,
0.2402739823,
0.3932661116,
-0.7960112691,
0.438082695,
0.3204721808,
-0.1960168779,
0.4373100102,
-0.3670319021,
0.1213942096,
-0.6355527043,
0.5260688066,
-0.9857208133,
-0.1314475089,
0.4754501283,
-0.5196347833,
0.2987950444,
-0.0364684984,
-0.3939697742,
-0.4116339684,
-0.3398568332,
0.6593988538,
0.7367302179,
-0.3889077008,
0.3978493214,
0.4097755253,
-0.0402946658,
-0.8087875247,
-0.8752567172,
-0.1873958856,
-0.3458742201,
-0.3892796636,
0.3251217902,
-0.0823024809,
-0.4983693957,
-0.1437781453,
0.0150216846,
-0.4291251004,
-0.0439479947,
-0.1294539571,
0.0051214169,
-0.0739620104,
0.3663410246,
0.0931920782,
0.0967118368,
0.0376799442,
-0.4609112442,
0.4511876404,
0.1065213308,
-0.2797231078,
-0.2486691475,
0.4612465799,
-0.0384029336,
-0.0702949017,
0.6211876869,
0.5430233479,
-0.3393122554,
-0.4557461143,
-0.3231832385,
0.064332433,
-0.3806058466,
0.4454069734,
0.0312990136,
-0.6884225607,
0.174634248,
-0.0589442514,
0.2588655651,
0.5238074064,
0.382368654,
-0.2710934877,
1.1345502138,
1.0049951077,
-0.0774137154,
0.5301756859,
-0.4411455095,
0.0630545318,
-0.4714640379,
-0.1124957055,
-0.9309303164,
-0.0739498958,
-0.6744322181,
-0.1943595409,
0.0900398716,
0.0843062699,
0.2425334007,
-0.0911255702,
-0.5046137571,
0.2566663027,
0.3789283931,
-0.1728034765,
0.3524184525,
0.0801471397,
0.0091131376,
0.1357693672,
-0.6039081812,
-0.492970109,
1.3413852453,
0.5720290542,
0.3572033942,
-0.0671990365,
0.7993068695,
0.4400243163,
0.4152840376,
-0.6158589721,
0.2992309332,
-0.2792756557,
-0.728230834,
-0.5059868693,
-0.6875278354,
-1.2296310663,
0.2948864102,
-0.0940054804,
-0.5306396484,
0.4642769098,
0.2473185211,
0.0090356106,
0.4504404664,
-0.897085309,
0.7473579645,
0.1441186517,
0.4595070183,
0.3019884825,
-0.7908374071,
0.3359839022,
-0.128867954,
0.4762584865,
0.0917197615,
-0.1576909721,
0.6824982166,
-0.3467817903,
0.7146354914,
-0.3205899894,
-0.2616290748,
0.3924424648,
-0.6947901845,
0.3914004862,
-0.1590352356,
-0.0247379243,
0.1850816905,
0.122948803,
-0.4962309599,
-0.7034363151,
0.0929537788,
-0.6774302721,
-0.1011275426,
-0.6980460286,
-0.3824020326,
-0.341091007,
0.0830698311,
0.7347135544,
0.3439221084,
-0.2748659551,
0.1759417653,
0.9855895042,
-0.3266664445,
0.4595431685,
-0.128929317,
-0.4628326893,
-0.63370049,
0.9192174673,
0.3307332993,
0.2784358561,
0.5804935694,
0.3582252562,
-0.4152414501,
-1.0167245865,
-0.4445712864,
-0.0422492437,
-0.7269022465,
0.0976066887,
-0.6585581303,
-0.0779919177,
-0.5750311613,
0.020790996,
-0.1945298612,
-0.2591130733,
-0.5953928828,
0.0968000814,
-0.1442322135,
1.2116559744,
0.3366968334,
0.254204005,
-0.6156980395,
0.3318446279,
0.1164344102,
0.372570008,
-0.2030586451,
-0.5353969336,
-0.2321900576,
-0.066074118,
-0.4011433423,
-0.7687190771,
0.2584000826,
0.3692829013,
0.5716252327,
0.4191737771,
0.4176237583,
0.2239451408,
-0.3785003126,
0.7143412828,
0.2593118548,
-0.6019442081,
0.5373615026,
-0.2361280024,
0.0358032361,
0.5272397995,
0.5080652833,
-0.4592625201,
-0.364076674,
-0.5800976753,
-0.8624656796,
0.5509412289,
0.3615941405,
0.1537777781,
0.1030941457,
0.4291409552,
0.4861826599,
0.3059750795,
-0.4817216992,
-0.3142929673,
-0.0217692219,
-0.4543554187,
-0.4186374843,
-0.2260996252,
0.2948406339,
-0.1169073582,
0.4022178948,
-0.1381816715,
0.2886476219,
0.3334909678,
-0.3299997449,
0.0757074207,
0.516954422,
0.5956612229,
0.5582767725,
-0.4599329829,
0.091041021,
0.1411095262,
-0.923461318,
0.394715935,
0.080536902,
-0.4506308734,
0.2162818909,
0.344024986,
0.4896540344,
-0.1508429348,
-0.6034824848,
0.6980450153,
-0.1575438678,
-0.4238146245,
-0.324976325,
-0.0969125926,
-0.6344757676,
0.018463932,
0.5981587172,
0.3784809709,
0.2884435654,
-0.5694476366,
-0.2446514219,
0.322455287,
-0.4962085187,
-0.2756130397,
0.4661135077,
-0.049904149,
-0.0314250141,
0.4550224543,
-0.2674144804,
-0.2185443044,
0.4279152155,
0.3949560225,
0.9962180257,
-0.1064309329,
0.2141986489,
-0.1695015281,
0.3172119558,
-0.4480235875,
0.178894341,
-0.1157762706,
-0.66550982,
-0.2431966513,
-0.3936684132,
-0.7651236653,
-0.0827297643,
-0.7986084819,
0.252251178,
-0.4228429794,
-0.4229629934,
-0.2014205903,
-0.0444572382,
-0.3328977227,
0.2399024963,
0.0709348097,
0.7862402797,
-0.6655318737,
0.6652644873,
1.1268330812,
-0.2194269598,
0.2513818443,
0.133714363,
-0.3457572162,
-0.2032289207,
0.4962843657,
0.2476074249,
0.1901339591,
-0.0925178006,
-0.5026632547,
-0.5876346827,
0.736374557,
0.3038291037,
-0.2779472768,
-0.3868905008,
0.465813607,
0.6951023936,
-0.1604431868,
0.2000238001,
0.5878072977,
0.2450169921,
-0.2683120668,
-0.9612762332,
-0.579241395,
-0.1702223718,
0.2131351382,
0.3160287142,
-0.4623625576,
0.7894206047,
0.0186315104,
-0.1615017653,
0.0316778421,
0.6654306054,
0.1589419246,
0.7192161679,
0.4656748474,
0.4431373775,
0.7661089897,
-0.0162909832,
0.8972225189,
0.4859271944,
0.53949368,
0.791911006,
-0.4130524099,
0.9718753099,
0.290196836,
-0.5214149356,
0.384799242,
0.5095542669,
0.1516518295,
0.3612087369,
0.3752917647,
-0.2395590544,
0.2429836392,
-0.015301778,
-0.6797679067,
0.2973662019,
0.214733243,
-0.4795244634,
-0.1729779691,
0.3531372845,
-0.3366746008,
0.2485813349,
-0.4110286832,
0.8080029488,
-0.1049241051,
-0.2987039685,
0.3777382672,
0.073699601,
1.0627487898,
-0.5478496552,
0.1372788399,
-0.1794700623,
0.4851410389,
-0.2070608437,
-0.5908370018,
0.4743036926,
-0.0288411994,
-0.4470183551,
-0.4634466469,
0.7436717153,
-0.192604214,
-0.3498300016,
0.2230132371,
0.2591249347,
0.2701852918,
-0.3059681654,
-0.4041420221,
0.0254432131,
-0.1971537769,
-0.2463869154,
0.5501109362,
0.5151544213,
-0.0961001813,
0.6229397058,
0.2982460856,
0.0490175299,
0.6194499731,
-0.1516519338,
0.5757341385,
-0.6825110316,
-0.5931993127,
-0.8259518743,
0.2575677633,
0.0184571892,
-0.5771062374,
0.7090940475,
0.3817432821,
1.0610963106,
-0.2455366105,
1.1116610765,
0.001100624,
0.6491035819,
-0.4194521308,
0.5661631227,
-0.5286964774,
-0.0440662466,
-0.3500876725,
-0.9948607087,
-0.608335495,
0.2732245326,
-0.2517141402,
0.0800603926,
0.8504108787,
0.1404225975,
0.1922504902,
0.1037446782,
0.2846000493,
-0.1808529794,
0.2939575613,
0.3375736177,
1.0396971703,
-0.6601211429,
0.8072152734,
-0.4408657253,
-0.2100013047,
-0.3001594841,
-0.7498418093,
-0.9115533233,
-0.7384220958,
-0.3364115059,
-0.0360891223,
0.0286702588,
0.884103477,
0.536740303,
-1.1078867912,
-0.2438411862,
-0.5010643601,
0.2536304891,
-0.3063165247,
-0.1582939178,
0.3135235608,
-0.690675199,
-0.7735812664,
0.0601540767,
0.2207324505,
0.2197725475,
-0.2874053717,
0.0958247483,
0.0004372191,
-0.2480331808,
0.8229575753,
0.4100388885,
-0.2977522612,
0.0929329619,
-0.0568309985,
-0.0200776327,
0.0861428529,
0.7536324263,
-0.4152497947,
0.4033016264,
0.7298697829,
0.7455388904,
0.0583508722,
-0.031345997,
0.496642828,
-0.794711113,
0.0767890513,
0.4632725418,
0.1400091201,
0.0677831322,
-0.1226893812,
0.5233190656,
0.5105155706,
-0.7533414364,
-1.3072412014,
0.2510810792,
-0.6412212253,
-0.0698866919,
1.1354304552,
-0.1680435985,
-0.1110288948,
-0.6704711318,
-0.3077320755,
0.0548908301,
-0.1921072155,
0.6032438278,
0.7647938132,
-0.1557890326,
-0.0319277272,
-0.5767082572,
0.4548996389,
0.2807869017,
-1.0395194292,
0.1092883274,
0.2561605573,
-0.0802417472,
0.175338015,
0.6592704058,
-0.041916728,
-0.0958982632,
-0.1769082993,
0.0620468371,
0.3523850143,
-0.3297838569,
-0.6953155398,
0.5387266278,
0.0978233293,
-0.171596989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14091v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14091v3 | Revisiting Acceptability Judgements | 2023-05-23T14:16:22 | 2023-09-28T02:58:48 | Hai Hu, Ziyin Zhang, Weifang Huang, Jackie Yan-Ki Lai, Aini Li, Yina Patterson, Jiahui Huang, Peng Zhang, Chien-Jer Charles Lin, Rui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we revisit linguistic acceptability in the context of large
language models. We introduce CoLAC - Corpus of Linguistic Acceptability in
Chinese, the first large-scale acceptability dataset for a non-Indo-European
language. It is verified by native speakers and is the first acceptability
dataset that comes with two sets of labels: a linguist label and a crowd label.
Our experiments show that even the largest InstructGPT model performs only at
chance level on CoLAC, while ChatGPT's performance (48.30 MCC) is also much
below supervised models (59.03 MCC) and human (65.11 MCC). Through
cross-lingual transfer experiments and fine-grained linguistic analysis, we
provide detailed analysis of the model predictions and demonstrate for the
first time that knowledge of linguistic acceptability can be transferred across
typologically distinct languages, as well as be traced back to pre-training.
Our dataset is publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/huhailinguist/CoLAC}. | [
-0.2304708809,
-0.4468253851,
0.3215612769,
0.407363236,
0.1208171695,
-0.1834418625,
-0.7799600959,
-0.8111540675,
0.153977409,
0.1925553977,
-0.096142903,
-0.1648107767,
-0.8157017827,
0.0639364868,
-0.6333219409,
0.7324454188,
0.0428876132,
-0.0291923918,
0.107377857,
-0.3040909469,
-0.3542567194,
-0.6572282314,
-0.7398760319,
-0.4704479873,
0.4620613754,
0.233739987,
1.0551381111,
0.2766164839,
0.19454512,
0.2137327641,
-0.4350607693,
-0.223962307,
-0.7378408313,
-0.2844800055,
-0.3226050138,
-0.4240849018,
-0.4172385633,
0.2303258628,
0.7658279538,
0.8120371699,
-0.1851247698,
-0.251796037,
0.2827192545,
0.523887217,
-0.468871206,
0.3943121731,
-1.0428347588,
-0.1116962433,
-0.1249062791,
0.3476400673,
-0.9290533662,
-0.4558075964,
0.3121436238,
-0.8299392462,
0.0827234238,
-0.093332395,
0.8214933872,
-0.0487744063,
-0.3443927169,
-0.6653530598,
-0.4624987245,
0.5154346824,
-0.4743191302,
0.6356666684,
0.60388273,
0.5285853744,
-0.312073648,
-0.7498325706,
-0.5881625414,
-0.4841325879,
-0.1189108714,
0.0388172567,
-0.2693846822,
-0.0300524645,
0.1484912932,
0.5487330556,
-0.6231618524,
0.3397769928,
-0.270242244,
-0.263725251,
0.4887095392,
-0.1707636416,
0.5337256193,
-0.0665511638,
-0.1354062706,
0.1899075806,
-0.7116677761,
0.2059110403,
-0.0815247148,
0.755595088,
-0.128129065,
0.5690859556,
-0.3224491775,
0.7038667202,
-0.0062361145,
0.5356377959,
0.1771961153,
-0.3059199154,
-0.153286159,
0.1673594862,
0.6168429255,
0.0645753518,
0.8331827521,
-0.3098710775,
0.0654731765,
-0.1132052168,
0.1979415864,
-0.5499395728,
-0.6498824358,
0.1589875668,
-0.5299578309,
0.0974810347,
-0.0094533293,
-0.3792905807,
-0.6446438432,
-0.2597251534,
0.1484749913,
-0.6145419478,
-0.3761094511,
0.1618857533,
0.1936976314,
0.6176953912,
0.5109479427,
-1.0085527897,
0.0721749961,
0.8842739463,
0.9557047486,
0.0719536096,
-0.6798182726,
-0.3960126936,
-0.1641886979,
-0.4104219675,
0.652135849,
-0.415543139,
-0.3780082762,
-0.0126139,
0.1256587654,
-0.3311604559,
-0.611322403,
0.6374664307,
-0.7092866302,
-0.1423449069,
-0.1399548501,
-0.404219389,
-0.0977993906,
0.407461226,
-0.6981961727,
0.5314216018,
0.1908173114,
-0.7732465863,
0.709105134,
-0.4228363633,
-0.5887365937,
0.1118148118,
0.278934747,
-0.052883666,
-0.0676744878,
-0.0385299549,
0.1670100242,
-0.0441653989,
0.4565560222,
-0.7079125047,
-0.3081164658,
0.3525953591,
-0.6236976385,
1.3665442467,
0.6069779396,
0.1211135164,
-0.0345894732,
-0.735265553,
0.1845479906,
-0.1345409751,
-0.5417714119,
-0.3186942041,
-0.0968152434,
0.187861219,
0.4016603827,
0.141312927,
-0.6139754057,
0.2947708368,
-0.4746334553,
0.7669881582,
0.6242550015,
-0.7597045898,
0.3446573615,
0.0256261248,
0.1594093591,
-0.274843663,
0.0155221764,
0.0625572354,
-0.4093380272,
-0.7012785673,
-0.2762362957,
0.544757843,
0.5468994975,
-0.8120625019,
0.1723498404,
-0.2189156711,
-0.7744060159,
-0.4304850996,
-0.0684737861,
0.0880758837,
0.0868624672,
0.1100644842,
-0.3163923621,
-0.5939098597,
-0.8262462616,
-0.5952045321,
-0.6781176925,
-0.1770878285,
0.3817055821,
0.2870601118,
-0.0974503085,
0.8316662312,
-0.3017059863,
0.0690362453,
-0.356040746,
0.1118091866,
0.4050033092,
0.4474597573,
0.6694762111,
-0.7880909443,
-0.510025084,
0.234092325,
-0.7091324925,
0.0886124074,
0.1030527875,
-0.0480677374,
0.280764401,
0.3780215383,
-0.4813041389,
0.4402557909,
0.8312329054,
-0.4563839138,
0.6026483774,
-0.3156577945,
0.1902338266,
-0.8862604499,
-0.0133717051,
-0.1422199309,
-0.2178487331,
-0.6147061586,
0.072097674,
0.1128058657,
0.0911023393,
-0.5818744302,
0.534001112,
-0.1867335439,
-0.0222608428,
-0.2203523368,
0.0832941607,
-0.391718626,
0.1686997563,
0.2621150911,
0.5964146852,
0.7740423083,
-0.712798655,
0.1776268184,
0.3201659024,
-0.6568297148,
0.7403741479,
-0.8275778294,
-0.0447888635,
-0.1556367874,
0.557151556,
-1.2793328762,
-0.3201325536,
0.3521367311,
-0.8004556298,
0.0049332762,
-0.1949518919,
-0.3005304635,
-0.1936587244,
0.3006630242,
0.6582655907,
0.2850599587,
-0.9521300197,
0.4493460357,
0.325175494,
-0.114771083,
-0.3831418157,
-0.7090262175,
0.1865181774,
0.0573291518,
-0.6901516318,
-0.2098902613,
-0.2908636928,
-0.2903834283,
-0.3226668835,
0.4478705227,
-0.4571177363,
0.1307173967,
0.328541249,
0.2226336449,
-0.123776868,
0.0613037869,
-0.5812918544,
-0.1450675726,
-0.0795774385,
-0.2964875996,
0.4981451929,
-0.3376076818,
-0.2557562888,
-0.2211115956,
-0.0275442377,
0.5142637491,
-0.1321249902,
0.768121779,
0.4657895565,
-0.4947719872,
0.1179362908,
-0.1177625954,
0.3059439063,
-0.3707571924,
0.2484710664,
-0.5498073697,
-0.8105568886,
0.448338151,
0.3331384361,
0.2270873487,
0.568338573,
0.667062819,
0.2713430822,
0.7232481241,
0.3881126344,
-0.3903896213,
0.3462883532,
0.131957978,
0.3502902687,
-0.3878619075,
0.045809146,
-0.9517017603,
0.0054176734,
-1.0232254267,
-0.3108582199,
-0.1123097688,
-0.0440875068,
-0.2784674466,
0.6250414252,
0.0528202467,
0.4334765673,
0.2872835994,
-0.0145037072,
0.5497485995,
-0.3752791882,
0.1659365147,
0.0718999058,
-0.7670944929,
-0.2124880105,
0.7312153578,
0.4692913592,
0.655696094,
0.290325731,
0.2063181102,
0.1153633818,
0.8119462132,
-0.8970189691,
0.2803790271,
-0.6066914201,
-0.8019046783,
-0.2210135907,
-0.5698730946,
-0.9338706732,
0.4178890884,
-0.1722864062,
-0.9342682958,
0.1081393212,
0.224457413,
0.0055512539,
0.35702461,
-1.0076960325,
0.7899280787,
-0.0330546275,
-0.1863854527,
-0.0115928836,
-0.5032570362,
0.5559647679,
-0.0513180196,
0.5515491962,
0.0868068412,
0.4016799331,
0.4749961793,
-0.1191871762,
0.646381557,
-0.0330394618,
-0.3043401539,
0.4693615437,
0.3229499459,
0.3239842057,
0.021973107,
-0.3738240302,
0.5319545865,
0.2010282278,
-0.5796186328,
-0.4739715457,
0.6624424458,
-0.6398640275,
-0.2271908373,
-0.3779720664,
-0.5563366413,
-0.1350363195,
0.2492483109,
0.3545649946,
0.1698302329,
-0.4374301136,
0.1382559389,
0.3281618953,
-0.5234726071,
0.1263653636,
0.6247998476,
-0.5668905377,
-0.107038036,
1.0281652212,
0.3596895933,
0.4743925333,
0.2253322601,
0.1705463082,
-0.2925178409,
-0.4807086885,
-0.223735854,
0.1476995349,
-0.4623397291,
0.398521632,
-0.4548555017,
-0.5734336376,
-0.5859894156,
-0.1779365838,
-0.6423617005,
-0.3201746047,
0.0518007912,
0.0454999842,
-0.0316870771,
0.9094814658,
-0.1937914938,
0.1842937171,
-0.6687579751,
0.2855172753,
0.1848640442,
0.968403101,
0.1237900555,
-0.8564167619,
-0.0682009682,
0.2210247368,
0.184044227,
-0.3240519464,
0.2096958458,
0.0089100022,
0.4434528947,
0.283195436,
0.0757206455,
0.5126048923,
-0.2909373045,
0.865960896,
0.056274645,
-0.9244892597,
0.325288713,
-0.3091175854,
0.3438743651,
0.5713932514,
0.4059479833,
-1.0382996798,
-0.3824321628,
-0.6274939179,
-0.9034304023,
0.7983959913,
0.2115983963,
0.0358757712,
0.0271128137,
0.1426541358,
0.3648296893,
-0.1396854073,
-0.8112319708,
-0.0012649709,
-0.1671674103,
0.1098085567,
-0.6106743813,
-0.1789420098,
0.4831672609,
-0.1124621555,
0.6515630484,
0.0567620955,
-0.0853910521,
0.0169451907,
-0.3159531653,
0.3943119347,
0.5420350432,
0.256141156,
0.6802656054,
-0.3684269488,
0.2082612813,
0.0592517368,
-0.5714212656,
-0.1160945892,
0.0768650621,
-0.1863135695,
-0.1423705965,
0.4007577002,
0.3950787187,
0.108726792,
-0.8166092038,
0.3131282926,
-0.3785442412,
-0.1661071181,
-0.4625323415,
-0.1954748183,
-0.0637794957,
-0.0794283003,
-0.2135498226,
-0.0116521353,
0.1679179519,
-0.5488610864,
0.4045518339,
0.403187722,
-0.821858108,
-0.3850007653,
0.7532881498,
0.0339339525,
-0.0892266482,
0.9452329874,
-0.1707092971,
-0.4352276027,
0.5197600722,
0.4766276181,
0.7007254958,
-0.145629257,
0.3375718296,
0.6717258692,
0.3845480084,
-0.1012401879,
-0.2498968691,
0.130575493,
-0.9949358106,
-0.3273259401,
-0.3563681543,
-0.4802618623,
-0.2015320063,
-0.5373146534,
0.4024070799,
-0.3798519969,
0.2522989213,
0.2191217989,
-0.3934896588,
-0.6666249633,
0.0058946474,
0.1330631822,
1.2227119207,
-1.0501353741,
0.9226908088,
0.5276466608,
-0.3296982348,
-1.0439527035,
-0.076203458,
0.1340653747,
-1.2242535353,
0.4866545498,
0.1595223844,
0.1481618434,
-0.315712899,
-0.5109217167,
-0.5251808167,
0.687523663,
0.2739267349,
-0.297273308,
0.2261581421,
0.1622720063,
0.7869988084,
-0.0943583772,
0.6460584998,
0.9028670788,
0.5689327121,
0.4414129555,
-1.3265318871,
-0.2670442462,
-0.2112088501,
-0.1522256732,
-0.0755317509,
-0.8634980917,
1.0507502556,
-0.3544006646,
-0.1671456248,
0.2324727774,
0.7369282246,
0.2460858375,
0.5710496306,
0.8360670209,
0.3479839861,
0.6898703575,
-0.1180519238,
1.1452027559,
-0.015012987,
0.527600646,
1.3186172247,
-0.2311022431,
1.0075685978,
0.3721113503,
-0.5535206795,
0.0507030487,
0.8227168322,
0.3929100931,
0.0834934115,
0.3781521022,
0.0587676726,
-0.1929598898,
-0.5485036373,
-0.3197408319,
0.9274814129,
0.2320698351,
-0.366930455,
-0.3362663388,
-0.0446511582,
0.1166521758,
0.1159256771,
-0.541223526,
0.5623980165,
-0.0114902528,
-0.7116801739,
0.7878741622,
-0.316197753,
0.7354614735,
-0.4450917542,
-0.0149491662,
-0.1398753077,
0.2007425278,
-0.372197926,
-1.242701292,
0.2915169299,
-0.0209851395,
-0.2234981358,
0.0419606455,
0.656442523,
-0.53943187,
-0.3694031835,
0.3862938583,
0.4627110064,
0.5166951418,
-0.0962857679,
-0.1646539569,
-0.0861398205,
0.1821094155,
-0.0242389049,
0.3881232738,
0.3857523501,
-0.0006715337,
0.7634208798,
0.2757659554,
0.2986110151,
-0.0469148867,
0.1073201373,
0.55623734,
-0.576946795,
-0.5806378722,
-0.5326348543,
0.2670277655,
0.3266074955,
-0.2797977924,
0.5734969974,
0.472109139,
1.1154932976,
0.0817728192,
1.0235579014,
-0.5763556361,
0.5078237653,
-0.4135487974,
0.7934240103,
-0.3452927172,
0.2597752512,
-0.3608839214,
-0.627089262,
-0.3072891831,
0.3525866866,
-0.5434927344,
0.2040303648,
0.3720038235,
0.6810364723,
0.0543025099,
0.5640167594,
0.3477907777,
0.5425994396,
0.5315925479,
0.9901257753,
0.9281932712,
-0.1744316071,
0.7095660567,
-0.0313259065,
-0.3492310941,
-0.1069805399,
-0.6890004873,
-0.5745766759,
-0.7321432829,
0.022370059,
-0.6507976055,
-0.0303149056,
0.9180001616,
0.488458097,
-0.8919098973,
-0.1930824816,
0.1601298898,
0.2492643893,
-0.2821298242,
-0.2613659203,
0.3254570365,
-0.1900547743,
-0.8379954696,
-0.0460476875,
-0.2125965655,
-0.0863130689,
0.0014525118,
-0.2252072692,
-0.1886691451,
-0.2998213172,
0.9311913848,
0.7503419518,
-0.5331097245,
-0.8434004784,
-0.248263225,
-0.1662144512,
0.0370591506,
0.9505744576,
-0.5926432014,
0.6139076352,
0.4334648252,
0.759277761,
-0.161257714,
-0.1508726627,
0.5326039791,
-0.2261337787,
0.1869793981,
-0.2193762213,
0.4082361162,
0.2350551188,
-0.1490193605,
0.5797897577,
-0.0184885412,
-0.6098127961,
-0.5041919351,
0.3292989433,
-1.2646547556,
-0.233488068,
1.155036211,
-0.4587920606,
-0.0152898133,
-0.2195622474,
-0.4162776172,
0.1706031412,
-0.3595909774,
0.7272886634,
1.207482934,
-0.2422825843,
0.04156987,
-0.5820754766,
0.0955010131,
0.1957378685,
-0.6617501378,
0.6087779999,
0.52913481,
0.3643548787,
-0.0568689406,
0.7699459195,
-0.1948546022,
0.3133745492,
0.171561271,
-0.0598309003,
0.2135274112,
-0.2317089587,
-0.4603553116,
0.1644371003,
0.7676805854,
-0.0012752707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14087v1 | BM25 Query Augmentation Learned End-to-End | 2023-05-23T14:11:42 | 2023-05-23T14:11:42 | Xiaoyin Chen, Sam Wiseman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Given BM25's enduring competitiveness as an information retrieval baseline,
we investigate to what extent it can be even further improved by augmenting and
re-weighting its sparse query-vector representation. We propose an approach to
learning an augmentation and a re-weighting end-to-end, and we find that our
approach improves performance over BM25 while retaining its speed. We
furthermore find that the learned augmentations and re-weightings transfer well
to unseen datasets. | [
-0.4645504951,
-0.3385629356,
0.2413858473,
0.2508642673,
-0.2522737384,
0.344134748,
-0.2754073441,
-0.3959804475,
0.3489989042,
0.417555362,
-0.697673142,
-0.2306756526,
-0.5687406063,
0.1106277183,
-0.3081926405,
0.6808012724,
0.3752338886,
0.1641710997,
-0.5464536548,
-0.5583817959,
-0.5927959681,
-0.4332451522,
-0.6072817445,
-0.4244399071,
0.6202177405,
0.569786787,
0.6549435258,
0.7196484804,
0.6773295403,
0.2485203594,
-0.0590287521,
0.4981279373,
-1.1246811152,
0.3055891097,
-0.5657693744,
-0.8570104241,
-0.146445021,
-0.2664467692,
0.8191629052,
1.0991560221,
-0.2099152952,
0.2056898773,
0.0115191918,
0.9648917913,
-0.7871447206,
-0.2884022295,
-0.8142376542,
-0.1429647952,
-0.3126217127,
-0.6471412182,
-0.5743697882,
-0.0077504781,
-0.2219849229,
-0.8005964756,
0.3126298189,
0.4627901912,
1.0160011053,
0.3587441444,
-0.5637587905,
0.0737417489,
-0.6638134122,
0.8672037721,
0.0025259627,
0.8345784545,
0.2748197019,
0.638612926,
-0.1988569945,
-1.111050725,
-0.2122559994,
0.0110832686,
0.2428411692,
0.3640055358,
-0.1984420121,
-0.1237329096,
0.5532671213,
0.4892275631,
-0.5076757073,
-0.0745680854,
-0.7746752501,
-0.0735226646,
0.8268930316,
0.205538705,
-0.0477467775,
0.0850567594,
-0.4798986614,
-0.1157319471,
-0.8703094125,
-0.0054160748,
0.3185732961,
-0.0133274375,
0.4267924726,
0.8224022985,
-0.5449510813,
0.7562066317,
0.2333622575,
0.4298349321,
0.5571676493,
-0.550447166,
-0.0912645906,
0.1150651649,
0.2147451788,
0.6670902967,
-0.0151079465,
-0.4490925372,
-0.4877665639,
-0.2309205532,
0.6214446425,
-0.9823762178,
-0.2175159603,
0.1766536385,
-0.6490598917,
0.1007900387,
0.2140651345,
-0.4581668675,
-0.2543274462,
-0.5792607069,
0.8260448575,
-0.551533699,
0.2379941791,
-0.0061255954,
-0.593552649,
0.5214116573,
0.4018724859,
-0.7680059075,
0.482565701,
0.7056236863,
0.7086207867,
-0.0848290399,
0.0888122171,
-0.6839686632,
0.2486768067,
-0.6161942482,
0.723418653,
-0.8219867349,
-0.6695373654,
-0.2779346108,
0.2240666002,
0.2688124478,
-0.8619686365,
0.6266869307,
-0.8180845976,
0.2287294716,
-0.7971032858,
-0.7817838192,
-0.2175226361,
0.0375981145,
-0.4988847375,
1.2649650574,
0.0036809945,
-0.4828608334,
0.6991565824,
-0.1473210752,
-0.3802720904,
0.4134902954,
0.1035668999,
-0.2992800176,
0.5041358471,
0.4164447188,
0.1140687913,
0.0898104906,
-0.5903393626,
-0.4239530563,
-0.8663251996,
-0.0378704667,
-0.0859985352,
0.6617010236,
0.1206424609,
0.2302622795,
-0.20979397,
-0.6770008802,
-0.1007872969,
0.0019351209,
-0.5661415458,
-0.3349315822,
-0.059325546,
-0.3010678291,
-0.1795127988,
0.6491609812,
-0.9338723421,
0.1833459884,
-0.4069940448,
-0.0660515428,
0.5444959402,
0.2698410153,
0.4957227409,
-0.7115591764,
0.2032099366,
-0.1256656349,
-0.0288247708,
-0.3417853713,
-0.4596356452,
-0.7675774097,
-0.277007401,
0.5878967643,
0.6130943894,
-0.8946163654,
0.2381732017,
-0.4697854519,
-0.3705762029,
-0.7529605627,
0.482912302,
0.117222406,
0.3778872788,
0.6967061758,
-0.4298764467,
-0.8404869437,
-0.7081788182,
-0.3413693607,
0.2531170249,
-0.1721994579,
0.5394694209,
0.0906422064,
-0.3491187394,
0.5341510177,
-0.7423672676,
-0.3005209863,
0.0659873113,
0.2247536331,
0.1732873023,
0.4844213426,
0.4200502932,
-0.8974822164,
-0.2616803944,
0.0899365917,
-0.6287358403,
-0.0645978451,
0.1092148572,
-0.3748760819,
-0.0901140422,
0.6667349935,
-0.475515604,
0.2542648017,
-0.2284657806,
0.0271456949,
0.2892736793,
-0.4831463993,
0.2293582559,
-1.0179326534,
-0.0499321744,
-0.0382551029,
-0.4615970254,
-0.2213583142,
0.0047223591,
0.3559422791,
-0.1667011678,
-0.1420301199,
0.4325351119,
-0.6084032059,
-0.4870268106,
-0.3779602051,
0.1730851531,
0.2088596374,
0.2122471929,
-0.4219182134,
0.9422245622,
0.439312458,
-0.6135117412,
0.5850833654,
0.3108449578,
0.0146823972,
1.1337065697,
-0.6304276586,
-0.0307240486,
-0.7998896837,
0.1531955302,
-1.2828730345,
0.0082612047,
-0.3616427779,
-1.0999814272,
0.5622018576,
-0.4787802398,
-0.2576074898,
-0.1951277256,
-0.4768944383,
0.1579519957,
0.5894371867,
-0.7714204192,
0.4164670408,
0.1289811432,
-0.0586990789,
-0.5929793715,
-0.6730854511,
0.2212820351,
0.011350913,
-0.4548820555,
0.9157469273,
-0.0105064083,
0.1534968466,
-0.0611415505,
-0.1757448614,
0.0764078945,
-0.1328515708,
0.1471922249,
0.0210084766,
-0.0258301552,
0.2884295285,
0.0761900693,
-0.0013269156,
0.013496886,
-0.4181830287,
0.3941406012,
0.3297160268,
-0.3398402929,
0.014032606,
0.0798090845,
0.2614194155,
-0.4815940857,
0.710564971,
0.818579793,
-0.6650556922,
-0.2163603604,
-0.5635763407,
-0.237774834,
-0.5214511156,
0.2830585241,
-0.4568513632,
-0.4502747655,
0.625598371,
-0.1093887016,
-0.0060699517,
0.5708940029,
0.3690515161,
-0.3563533723,
1.2814413309,
0.6797689795,
0.1968466491,
0.8189894557,
-0.4712817073,
-0.378993839,
-1.1316558123,
-0.9641441107,
-0.5071405172,
-0.6366041303,
-0.5911528468,
-0.4468642771,
0.2160541266,
0.1584565341,
-0.0758796483,
0.3953614235,
-0.3360479772,
0.2380066216,
0.5404680967,
0.7049008012,
0.0825314894,
0.2832644284,
-0.2931798995,
-0.1260956824,
-0.5079737306,
0.2245157212,
1.4749294519,
0.1089223176,
0.801115036,
0.4151230156,
0.7935410142,
0.5784417987,
0.2636445761,
-0.5519510508,
0.1936793327,
-0.3281089664,
-0.3813511133,
-0.1437060088,
-0.7102102041,
-1.1502934694,
0.1892700791,
-0.3798599243,
-0.5705338717,
0.5568319559,
-0.218881622,
-0.0829276815,
-0.3272798657,
-0.6843203902,
0.5645386577,
-0.2424560785,
-0.6844910979,
-0.3922244012,
-0.6601068974,
0.1499568969,
0.0679324046,
-0.1662710309,
0.0915162116,
-0.6028979421,
0.6497144699,
-0.4875156581,
0.0710399225,
-0.1858708411,
0.5033931136,
0.016368445,
-0.3012286723,
0.4433097541,
-0.017828932,
-0.1810130328,
-0.340002805,
-0.0578493588,
-0.8456677198,
-1.0030953884,
0.5169509053,
-0.5304979682,
-0.4410161376,
-0.036296349,
-0.5539993644,
-0.1619193703,
0.3032565713,
0.1768648773,
0.7791672349,
0.0267789587,
0.8907205462,
1.0298221111,
-0.0380729139,
0.2892583013,
0.6120222807,
-0.3013130426,
-0.5942538977,
1.2702460289,
0.5345792174,
0.0751079544,
0.7857789397,
-0.1698874533,
-0.8574613333,
-0.698435545,
-0.5727279782,
0.1886071861,
-0.7052519917,
-0.2405949533,
-0.6108296514,
-0.195317626,
-0.378033191,
0.0771204755,
-0.0424375944,
-0.5543145537,
-0.161626637,
-0.1832755208,
0.3542290628,
0.435208559,
-0.2319932431,
0.4548044205,
-0.64399755,
0.3317197263,
0.1354816556,
0.3296752274,
-0.2877112627,
-0.7913193107,
-0.3104073703,
0.2427298278,
-0.3914530873,
-0.7036457658,
0.2205839455,
0.4915311933,
0.9447804689,
0.431722492,
0.1232956946,
0.7297539115,
-0.2174554169,
0.4906177819,
-0.0525358282,
-0.5308648348,
0.2982438207,
-0.1128986552,
0.2781368196,
0.7385587096,
0.7239561677,
-0.1202238351,
0.198303178,
-0.5622979403,
-0.9327810407,
0.2177436501,
0.2654094994,
0.184071213,
0.1331241131,
0.5313412547,
-0.2758747041,
0.396455884,
0.1030100361,
-0.1604640186,
-0.2557681203,
-0.2421500236,
-0.0481164381,
-0.2135299742,
0.0584892146,
-0.3104561269,
0.5332978964,
-0.226502791,
0.2629981041,
0.1343454272,
-0.533439815,
-0.0505884103,
-0.3260206282,
0.3061538041,
0.9095926881,
-0.6612966061,
0.1016262621,
0.626619339,
-0.472247541,
-0.1308104098,
0.41221416,
0.1111193597,
-0.0850402266,
0.1578617394,
0.6505324244,
0.2113293856,
-0.5159362555,
0.4697203338,
0.0544286147,
-0.012383095,
0.1432691962,
-0.0401992314,
-0.1536835432,
0.2510436475,
0.9340072274,
-0.2821272612,
0.4935781062,
-0.7476221919,
0.947709024,
0.7527307868,
-0.5338059664,
0.1676160097,
0.818939209,
-0.0097659836,
-0.0807605758,
0.4899534881,
-0.2833326459,
-0.4710679948,
0.4733429551,
0.3116602898,
0.2694737315,
-0.3591074944,
-0.2017214745,
0.2930873036,
0.476305604,
0.0430978313,
0.7296667099,
-0.3027529418,
-0.4426595867,
-0.4447954595,
-0.5757434964,
-0.5280947089,
-0.4557728767,
-0.880015254,
0.4867658317,
-0.4550655484,
-0.1952152401,
0.1210228428,
0.6243432164,
-0.5855793953,
0.5859998465,
-0.1174979061,
1.086815834,
-0.3375273049,
0.2357268482,
0.9295985103,
-0.6966117024,
-0.2521069646,
-0.2361044437,
-0.3361892998,
-0.9461176395,
0.4040076137,
0.2491841316,
0.1928508282,
0.1441421509,
-0.560136497,
-0.9377040863,
1.3725879192,
0.0774791762,
-0.3174814284,
0.1571491659,
-0.0730672628,
0.4344851673,
-0.2132833302,
0.5848841071,
0.1443375945,
0.1061630622,
0.6747895479,
-0.4104012251,
0.117102921,
-0.0591384023,
0.063846238,
0.1799496263,
-0.7073794007,
0.573985517,
-0.0857678801,
-0.1943375915,
-0.0764755383,
1.1227886677,
-0.0281223282,
0.5507449508,
0.0263243224,
0.979922235,
0.9524447918,
-0.2157497704,
0.9045457244,
-0.573872149,
0.3806283772,
0.7024006844,
-0.1864633709,
0.8439490795,
0.096764259,
-0.2094772905,
0.3261355162,
0.9098841548,
-0.1170796975,
0.52687639,
0.1737923324,
-0.2555915415,
-0.3120016456,
-0.282423228,
-0.4364395142,
0.3557560742,
0.7220443487,
-0.1880580336,
-0.4372260571,
-0.0858134404,
-0.1854988039,
-0.1168635339,
-0.7023693323,
0.763518095,
0.1214578152,
-0.616091609,
0.6393126249,
0.1809913516,
0.3988678157,
-0.4149726033,
-0.1911043376,
-0.3943718374,
0.3003359139,
-0.4497303963,
-0.8815666437,
0.42577824,
-0.6670504808,
-0.2360217273,
-0.0538676195,
1.0619033575,
-0.5973656774,
-0.5997986197,
0.1423193663,
0.3689816892,
0.1630398929,
-0.18690449,
-0.5993443131,
0.1081347167,
-0.2430695593,
0.1297224611,
0.4538099766,
0.5917619467,
-0.0168043468,
0.9491578341,
0.9943355322,
-0.1243399978,
0.4433611333,
-0.1721963286,
1.0935368538,
-0.5343475342,
-0.3390195966,
-0.432696104,
0.2324709892,
-0.4308114052,
0.111616753,
0.9447395802,
1.0849345922,
0.7935386896,
0.526057601,
0.5554533601,
0.2835329771,
0.5314046741,
-0.4982576668,
0.6151592135,
-0.8211833835,
0.189744994,
0.1547776759,
-1.0476197004,
0.0830027834,
0.319167912,
-0.0390326492,
0.3790846765,
0.2390079349,
0.9586077929,
-0.118028447,
-0.1507366449,
0.4749529362,
0.0979223549,
-0.1514056623,
0.3618120551,
0.4948566556,
-0.4295924306,
0.5623629093,
-0.2156254053,
-0.3341568708,
-0.5483016372,
-0.5517203808,
-0.6527547836,
-0.3253737986,
0.0270124823,
-0.5173301101,
0.4334678948,
0.6672074795,
0.7668619156,
-0.4871097207,
-0.0971073955,
0.2820355892,
0.3568912148,
-0.2246465236,
-0.2044275701,
0.0081796534,
-0.6440546513,
-0.6006949544,
0.4565351903,
0.2410646677,
-0.2383778691,
-0.2061732709,
-0.0221294314,
-0.3123197854,
0.3645814657,
0.7011247277,
0.2792370617,
0.0083378069,
-0.0408035889,
0.1809361726,
0.1900859922,
0.1847134084,
0.655905962,
-1.0141341686,
0.6425461173,
0.7971533537,
1.1783854961,
1.0527477264,
0.7281186581,
0.7151537538,
-1.1527252197,
-0.2279233187,
-0.1508222371,
0.3713709116,
0.5765168667,
-0.3914268315,
0.4552989602,
0.604952395,
-0.4150796235,
-0.8835166097,
-0.023677364,
-0.9011725783,
-0.0229774956,
1.0190287828,
0.1262160987,
-0.2264863253,
-0.1490090042,
-0.1767506897,
0.2754043639,
-0.318973124,
0.2471607625,
0.3692292571,
-0.1302819252,
-0.5137158036,
-0.5730233192,
0.2027597725,
0.4890903234,
-0.4958152771,
-0.4532798827,
0.4145656526,
0.4463187456,
-0.0695780292,
0.2456759512,
-0.0586831644,
0.2241319567,
0.0561816581,
-0.3019830585,
-0.2927661538,
-0.5056248903,
-0.2020241618,
0.1188783199,
-0.0482589565,
-0.5224465728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14083v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14083v2 | Counterfactual Augmentation for Multimodal Learning Under Presentation Bias | 2023-05-23T14:09:47 | 2023-10-30T22:05:11 | Victoria Lin, Louis-Philippe Morency, Dimitrios Dimitriadis, Srinagesh Sharma | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In real-world machine learning systems, labels are often derived from user
behaviors that the system wishes to encourage. Over time, new models must be
trained as new training examples and features become available. However,
feedback loops between users and models can bias future user behavior, inducing
a presentation bias in the labels that compromises the ability to train new
models. In this paper, we propose counterfactual augmentation, a novel causal
method for correcting presentation bias using generated counterfactual labels.
Our empirical evaluations demonstrate that counterfactual augmentation yields
better downstream performance compared to both uncorrected models and existing
bias-correction methods. Model analyses further indicate that the generated
counterfactuals align closely with true counterfactuals in an oracle setting. | [
-0.4185034931,
-0.9300059676,
0.4026024938,
0.0188726,
-0.2622413933,
-0.164588213,
0.2602434456,
-0.4909463525,
0.3030084372,
0.5180754662,
-0.8898862004,
0.0895609632,
-0.6384743452,
-0.1646961123,
-0.1726378649,
0.992205441,
0.0720862672,
0.2985232174,
-0.7554543614,
-0.3583263755,
-0.6943291426,
-0.5823584199,
-0.1187749654,
-0.8726360202,
0.4212436974,
0.3600728214,
0.7286523581,
0.2770173252,
-0.0299608372,
0.2889435291,
0.5210450292,
0.5234581232,
-0.3026627898,
0.2757692933,
-0.4792161882,
-0.431309104,
-0.4052935243,
0.2112406045,
0.4613482058,
0.5565786362,
0.1420102119,
0.0758950859,
0.0446330234,
0.4392598867,
-0.8896241188,
0.0629672483,
-0.3196949363,
0.1554047316,
0.0236804634,
-0.3672803044,
-0.7021840215,
-0.1657841355,
0.2764803767,
-1.0372835398,
0.2549578249,
0.050378181,
0.6149821877,
0.4757072031,
-0.6530224681,
0.0943460166,
-0.6817553043,
0.8157951832,
-0.4826328158,
0.4247335792,
0.1452904046,
0.1715729535,
0.0809466019,
-0.5864275694,
-0.7579408884,
-0.1322742999,
-0.3038681746,
0.1763505638,
-0.4006560445,
0.0704763234,
0.6093578339,
-0.2174609154,
-0.6760263443,
0.2604975998,
-0.136562556,
-0.4337906539,
0.4220955074,
0.1064694077,
0.3846102655,
0.0843965486,
-0.616202116,
-0.4525534511,
-0.8346414566,
-0.1874400377,
0.204376176,
0.1668108851,
-0.0498295575,
0.5509731174,
-0.0510938875,
0.6665176749,
0.3647190332,
-0.0011880439,
0.566944778,
-0.2908612192,
-0.285273999,
0.5005249977,
0.2590662539,
0.6041235924,
0.163981989,
0.1105772331,
-0.0174057111,
0.4309345782,
0.441136986,
-0.8482820988,
-0.2949136496,
-0.0122164655,
-0.3627390563,
-0.3564239144,
-0.0637727678,
-0.6141749024,
-0.6076945662,
-0.5541057587,
0.8973476887,
-0.2386781871,
-0.2780525386,
-0.5536680818,
-0.2511496544,
-0.368616879,
0.2883606255,
-0.6150141358,
-0.2563393712,
0.2578932643,
0.5999087095,
0.148757264,
-0.4294601381,
-1.0671019554,
0.3571757078,
-0.4878903031,
0.7309191227,
-0.8870741725,
-0.483789295,
-0.04252249,
-0.0597156249,
-0.2022649199,
-0.6695838571,
0.2148732394,
-0.4669206142,
0.4395252764,
-0.5042719245,
-0.5297536254,
-0.1497330815,
0.2672770917,
-0.4930735528,
0.9342368841,
-0.0157004781,
-0.7327763438,
0.9305592179,
-0.8857518435,
-0.5097204447,
0.0083074272,
-0.2778525949,
-0.7098481059,
-0.0525115617,
0.4410218596,
0.1165442616,
0.3593598604,
0.6540646553,
-0.5624830127,
-0.2737639248,
0.3400710523,
-0.6564192176,
0.6388483644,
0.1912402809,
-0.5260485411,
0.4454732835,
-0.8081273437,
-0.263725549,
-0.3261428773,
-0.018959377,
-0.7390711904,
-0.1688194871,
-0.0043406151,
0.4977569878,
0.027312262,
-0.6339006424,
0.1943609118,
-0.2385098487,
-0.0539528169,
0.8584704995,
-0.035095524,
0.3711116016,
-0.2711063325,
0.3540183008,
0.5272061825,
0.1482183635,
-0.6706445813,
-0.3948431611,
-0.72411412,
-0.1561139822,
0.0139236329,
0.4424990118,
-1.2669439316,
0.0186871327,
0.0748374835,
-0.2794286311,
-0.0954066142,
0.0343916044,
0.6237695813,
1.0314441919,
0.7247818112,
-0.2374038696,
-0.9626020193,
-1.0354181528,
-0.361266464,
-0.2087489367,
-0.0725193471,
0.5148991942,
0.437201798,
-0.4357050657,
0.9331735969,
-0.5204854012,
-0.3178806305,
0.1671173871,
0.9235535264,
-0.1335297525,
0.7551586628,
0.7145552039,
-0.8194995522,
-0.0808806047,
-0.2521925271,
-0.9743291736,
-0.4401493967,
-0.4877859056,
0.1318772137,
0.5866983533,
0.6759495735,
-0.4658661783,
0.5732020736,
0.3011275828,
-0.351547122,
0.6399434209,
-0.347997427,
0.3115381896,
-0.6335073113,
0.1022676378,
0.1878907084,
-0.1146873832,
-0.5387796164,
-0.1601829529,
0.0585899577,
-0.0440997072,
-0.4951944351,
0.6184758544,
-0.1620815247,
0.0039221528,
-0.3712553978,
0.0209714621,
0.165543884,
0.4100881517,
0.203627333,
0.7911502719,
0.4561140835,
-0.5871865749,
0.372731775,
0.1340044886,
-0.1295562536,
1.1481815577,
-0.4473798573,
-0.1491969228,
-0.3648059666,
0.6833977103,
-1.0263533592,
-0.1288719326,
0.3048710227,
-0.299274981,
0.1778532267,
-0.1192919612,
-0.1094681248,
-0.2694195211,
-0.2658533156,
0.3093550205,
0.1937989444,
-0.8594870567,
0.747354269,
0.0502794348,
0.1756257266,
-0.8142743111,
-0.8385840654,
0.0611862615,
-0.2468606532,
-0.5490617752,
0.3369678259,
-0.1313222647,
-0.1116810068,
-0.1734662503,
-0.1225203574,
0.2365843803,
-0.1610444039,
0.4339964986,
0.5013914108,
-0.1174744889,
0.4314996898,
0.3028591275,
-0.1842951179,
0.0902694091,
-0.4522042274,
0.2048265636,
0.2883425355,
-0.5713362694,
-0.2800802588,
0.3545536697,
0.2903163135,
0.1065023616,
0.716571033,
1.1919034719,
-0.2952682972,
0.0171909984,
-0.664255619,
-0.5756653547,
-0.4871914387,
0.4759910405,
-0.2820254266,
-0.5376405716,
0.3397316337,
-0.0609343946,
-0.0319573209,
0.3688173592,
0.5061358213,
-0.0716679543,
1.2905938625,
0.6028331518,
0.3794357479,
0.7141570449,
-0.0457357839,
0.1731669158,
-0.5958558917,
-0.6022918224,
-0.1371081769,
-0.3798001409,
-0.5305273533,
-0.2182119787,
0.5597561598,
-0.2365805358,
-0.3905130029,
-0.0050085438,
-0.2225552648,
0.2648732662,
0.8298734426,
0.4270077348,
0.2255416512,
0.0364959948,
-0.4006767869,
-0.4088026881,
-0.6624882817,
-0.2209976315,
0.9573615193,
0.0157987643,
0.7400135994,
0.1212092936,
0.3202406466,
0.6583305597,
0.7023767829,
-0.1802916378,
0.3359205127,
-0.1723092943,
-0.7391964197,
-0.2510354519,
-0.3006490171,
-0.578105092,
0.4142544866,
-0.7504249215,
-0.8318865895,
0.7629933953,
0.8613915443,
-0.1100677699,
0.1582013369,
-1.0660517216,
0.8641112447,
-0.1714532971,
-0.9138644934,
-0.4157859385,
-0.6899833083,
0.4091406465,
-0.1164466515,
0.2030477822,
0.4886070192,
0.2475989759,
0.7608648539,
-0.5070365667,
1.1711759567,
-0.5391152501,
-0.0845168531,
-0.0196247995,
0.0567793176,
0.6282611489,
0.0914330557,
0.2270200849,
-0.0938232318,
-0.314357847,
-0.3851988912,
-0.727232337,
0.8170239925,
-0.687943697,
-0.6071086526,
-0.5252231359,
-0.6180129647,
-0.4727776349,
0.207163617,
0.2173737288,
0.6962134242,
-0.3119677603,
-0.0549737327,
0.8376700282,
-0.4017199576,
0.5499888062,
0.5801478028,
-0.2576940954,
-0.1414238214,
1.1134775877,
0.3251706958,
0.1852582097,
0.3430396914,
0.1577102691,
-0.5867260695,
-0.2075625956,
-0.726066649,
-0.1869218647,
-0.6275241375,
0.058744289,
-0.6327888966,
0.1461493224,
-0.4606487751,
-0.0990930349,
-0.2173339427,
-0.5304371119,
-0.3556717932,
-0.1399008483,
0.032750506,
0.5090457201,
-0.548668623,
0.480712682,
-0.5617886186,
0.404945761,
0.7447903156,
0.2226834744,
0.2160775065,
-0.5669013262,
-0.2247155905,
0.3283421397,
-0.7415608764,
-0.6160700321,
0.3575286865,
0.2265017182,
0.6870093346,
0.6364543438,
0.1377869248,
0.8828415275,
-0.1779266596,
0.7434491515,
0.497729063,
-0.884662509,
0.6579522491,
-0.2391875535,
0.4021932185,
0.0356070586,
0.4534642994,
-0.4287822843,
0.0165294353,
-0.6180157661,
-0.8685975075,
0.8664128184,
-0.1060749441,
0.0373526812,
0.2093387991,
-0.1587613672,
0.2311197072,
0.3194734454,
-0.8178650737,
-0.3063283265,
-0.9408691525,
0.1113889441,
-0.1667052805,
-0.2570260167,
-0.3060571849,
0.0275558922,
0.8648905754,
-0.1950463057,
-0.2356521487,
0.2616252601,
-0.633548975,
-0.4346297979,
0.2443956286,
0.9021071792,
0.938159585,
-0.2861419618,
0.2875954509,
0.1587785482,
-0.280438453,
0.1162717268,
0.2845174372,
-0.3888296485,
-0.1044961214,
0.4806684852,
0.9673707485,
0.1595586389,
-0.6560900807,
0.3668145537,
0.18736054,
-0.1843335479,
0.0593451373,
0.0287392586,
-0.3018978238,
0.4463337064,
0.6107299328,
0.4405559301,
0.2401039898,
-0.5388900638,
0.4814155698,
0.4345399737,
-0.6359750628,
-0.1183437407,
0.921924293,
0.3306456208,
-0.0539279766,
0.6131424904,
0.1637701243,
-0.4457255602,
0.3823254108,
0.7334121466,
0.5590527058,
-0.4595041573,
0.4199736714,
0.3887565434,
0.2222640514,
0.2794947624,
-0.089861244,
-0.1741476506,
-0.6660854816,
-0.589196682,
-0.0966709554,
-0.5309557915,
0.1228496209,
-0.4476168454,
0.1077309102,
-0.0706531629,
-0.2080100477,
0.1484466344,
-0.3620708883,
-0.3649524748,
0.5430924892,
0.3259513378,
0.335665375,
-1.4662247896,
0.7262581587,
0.8811155558,
-0.5091631413,
-0.1273856461,
-0.2463842034,
0.279248327,
-0.7521088123,
0.9926954508,
0.1372141391,
-0.135809958,
-0.5962608457,
-0.5125054717,
-0.5089196563,
0.6869968176,
0.4904588163,
-0.6011298895,
0.2453401387,
0.204364866,
0.5787055492,
-0.4163583815,
0.6415301561,
0.076244913,
0.6183688641,
0.1383902729,
-0.743584156,
0.1263367385,
-0.2684860528,
-0.0976710096,
-0.1239123344,
-0.3026849926,
0.6748074293,
-0.2643248141,
0.2254449874,
-0.4184422493,
0.6262158155,
0.4878649116,
0.7639683485,
0.688167274,
0.6781704426,
0.5272634029,
-0.0794361904,
0.7626582384,
0.1781007946,
0.0555876009,
1.2341585159,
-0.1952706873,
0.1544585824,
0.6927048564,
-0.0514708273,
0.5900621414,
0.5260592103,
-0.0346522592,
0.6048522592,
-0.2021163702,
-0.0971395746,
-0.668161273,
-0.6260980964,
-0.5942055583,
0.2350656539,
0.3366680145,
-0.3367505372,
-0.1532735378,
0.3395084739,
0.0367252566,
0.1867411733,
-0.2840071917,
0.5913364291,
-0.0953073427,
-0.890552938,
0.4167417884,
-0.3869226873,
0.7678411603,
-0.3226727843,
-0.4169975221,
-0.20199579,
0.3446476758,
-0.4344057441,
-0.4750009179,
0.251421392,
-0.3922838867,
-0.4598674476,
-0.2699469924,
0.5486326218,
-0.4762177467,
-0.4867133796,
0.1560057253,
0.3394468427,
-0.3491151333,
0.1144545153,
-0.5072968006,
-0.0338375866,
-0.1268965602,
0.0038285083,
0.4526877999,
0.0258331522,
-0.42731902,
0.6748630404,
0.6099210978,
-0.3379531801,
0.0136045227,
0.3980133533,
0.8160464168,
-0.269448489,
-0.7700589895,
-0.8819814324,
0.3634316325,
-0.2202033401,
-0.1538215727,
0.7816739082,
0.4434976578,
0.9719901085,
-0.1512485445,
0.7523961663,
0.2268050909,
0.4867367446,
-0.3976474106,
0.3402461112,
-0.7250352502,
0.4196448028,
-0.6642642021,
-0.7296050191,
-0.1335022748,
0.3162516356,
-0.4670830071,
0.1830224991,
0.4192537665,
0.8024921417,
-0.22055237,
0.1617059261,
0.3323320448,
0.3991119862,
0.3261985481,
0.3471723795,
0.788367331,
-0.3165813684,
0.4651720226,
-0.2359496653,
-0.3267299533,
-0.4411318898,
-1.0201752186,
-0.8208264709,
-0.5117039084,
-0.4552668631,
-0.3108939826,
0.4696053565,
0.7762359977,
0.8162515759,
-0.8807746172,
0.2234461755,
0.2531834841,
0.3987294436,
-0.3544383049,
-0.2448796779,
0.2686222196,
-0.0811655074,
-0.6454902291,
0.2589586377,
0.2409501523,
0.0581406802,
-0.2780942917,
-0.173539266,
-0.4737580419,
0.10197106,
0.7747932076,
0.2554001808,
-0.6381177306,
-0.3683993816,
-0.3012821376,
0.3493314981,
0.1043848023,
0.8554314971,
-1.3194916248,
0.8116029501,
0.4672864377,
0.2771832645,
0.7554456592,
0.0768421441,
0.6462159753,
-1.0121312141,
0.2304096967,
-0.2286530435,
0.2541110218,
0.2573885024,
-0.3695138693,
0.1724891365,
0.4853095412,
-0.1711344719,
-0.9104464054,
0.3463546932,
-0.7527905703,
-0.5041389465,
0.5205358267,
0.0038452768,
0.2171806246,
-0.3044922352,
-0.1879555434,
0.409342885,
-0.4273162782,
0.9460204244,
0.3687774241,
-0.3497426808,
-0.1626953185,
-0.0415724702,
0.1970226914,
0.699185133,
-0.6366012692,
-0.0691096932,
0.783316493,
0.0317975916,
0.37008214,
0.2792831957,
0.0576642714,
0.5168016553,
0.1770644188,
0.023426706,
-0.4960408211,
-0.3448084891,
-0.0745207518,
0.114357233,
-0.3521212041,
-0.2211337984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14081v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14081v2 | How to Solve Few-Shot Abusive Content Detection Using the Data We Actually Have | 2023-05-23T14:04:12 | 2024-05-06T07:41:19 | Viktor Hangya, Alexander Fraser | cs.CL | cs.CL | Due to the broad range of social media platforms, the requirements of abusive
language detection systems are varied and ever-changing. Already a large set of
annotated corpora with different properties and label sets were created, such
as hate or misogyny detection, but the form and targets of abusive speech are
constantly evolving. Since, the annotation of new corpora is expensive, in this
work we leverage datasets we already have, covering a wide range of tasks
related to abusive language detection. Our goal is to build models cheaply for
a new target label set and/or language, using only a few training examples of
the target domain. We propose a two-step approach: first we train our model in
a multitask fashion. We then carry out few-shot adaptation to the target
requirements. Our experiments show that using already existing datasets and
only a few-shots of the target task the performance of models improve both
monolingually and across languages. Our analysis also shows that our models
acquire a general understanding of abusive language, since they improve the
prediction of labels which are present only in the target dataset and can
benefit from knowledge about labels which are not directly used for the target
task. | [
-0.2230002433,
-0.991949141,
0.2617438138,
-0.0349610895,
-0.2100957483,
-0.1042308137,
-0.1584146172,
-0.6329216957,
-0.0148784947,
0.655430913,
-0.5688146353,
-0.5306909084,
-0.9983049631,
0.0520657152,
-0.4875892699,
1.3735188246,
0.1692122817,
-0.0579708107,
0.3713023365,
-0.363910526,
-0.15907152,
-0.3387049139,
-0.5985421538,
-0.1248571575,
0.6932016611,
0.4731217623,
0.5840368271,
0.5472213626,
0.8107486963,
0.2340083569,
0.107918568,
0.1896960139,
-0.9603698254,
0.1856045425,
-0.1167455688,
-0.3242447674,
-0.1843948364,
-0.1409321427,
0.2820711732,
0.2472160906,
0.1862472445,
0.4055313468,
0.0513809696,
0.3675149679,
-1.0308312178,
-0.0622576214,
-0.9599179626,
-0.0241122879,
-0.5226073265,
-0.1089050397,
-0.4004176855,
0.0933874175,
-0.2559964955,
-0.6535154581,
0.0682898983,
-0.0286726374,
0.5077470541,
0.1081169322,
-0.2206785232,
-0.3773086071,
-0.653290987,
0.8253999949,
-0.502487123,
0.3368380368,
0.7632762194,
0.1549149454,
-0.181330815,
-0.3320982754,
-0.4547536671,
-0.168093726,
-0.0701298118,
-0.1315647066,
-0.6632703543,
-0.1763007492,
0.3972817063,
-0.3346384168,
-0.4461457431,
0.4187297225,
-0.452434361,
-0.2701946199,
0.622151196,
0.1981878877,
0.2960508466,
-0.4276940525,
-0.4887276292,
0.1176953986,
-0.5697999001,
-0.0492242239,
0.6074159145,
0.8931440115,
-0.1027200669,
0.4338085353,
0.0496793203,
0.3152865171,
-0.0094656143,
-0.4249751568,
0.1748212576,
-0.3560217023,
-0.0791016817,
-0.1226869598,
0.8301939964,
0.3346185088,
0.5355799794,
-0.0565013513,
-0.2551941872,
0.5161705017,
0.5637407303,
-0.7167627811,
-0.1885042042,
0.2601509094,
-0.3275511861,
-0.5379072428,
-0.5835806131,
-0.7491024137,
-0.8155351877,
-0.1690787673,
0.4569709897,
-0.6250002384,
-0.5022819042,
-0.1181813627,
-0.198350966,
0.029347565,
0.1882358044,
-0.8095681071,
0.45938465,
0.6011567712,
0.7266338468,
-0.2848912776,
-0.2892626524,
-0.908205688,
0.033272732,
-0.3440827131,
0.9739496112,
-0.7671526074,
0.0761579201,
0.2922164798,
-0.0693052784,
0.2919121087,
-0.6381222606,
0.6130421162,
-0.6311361194,
-0.2774272859,
-0.2351922989,
-0.1441149861,
0.015822202,
0.3393191695,
-0.6336299181,
1.0631961823,
0.2454565316,
-0.9624872208,
0.4631010592,
-0.8836484551,
-0.4068041742,
0.1077149659,
0.3681334853,
-0.5940493345,
-0.1177485511,
0.1122941151,
0.4360092878,
0.2775871456,
0.0764578432,
-0.6073632836,
-0.279119581,
-0.027825864,
-0.2167914957,
0.8831804395,
0.2471358776,
-0.1234815642,
0.1121993884,
-0.4781140685,
-0.3352654874,
0.2466081977,
-0.1796984375,
-0.6853419542,
-0.0393739417,
0.4333635569,
0.2187940627,
-0.14994739,
-0.6682460308,
0.0022025185,
-0.0999937132,
-0.2045952529,
0.7317150831,
0.0642423183,
0.4373520017,
-0.3646349609,
0.6965191364,
0.192403838,
0.1911826432,
-0.0472431555,
-0.222220391,
-0.4216311574,
-0.3559524119,
-0.1603555083,
0.5298572183,
-0.6915222406,
-0.085892871,
-0.1506936401,
-0.376157105,
-0.568985641,
0.615188241,
0.5704812407,
0.2131478488,
0.6811616421,
-0.2562389076,
-0.8707926273,
-0.8570972085,
-0.5964920521,
-0.2335987985,
0.1187490225,
0.0132844159,
0.7499022484,
0.0621942133,
0.7678568363,
-0.39944911,
-0.5933474898,
-0.3249605,
0.5083733797,
-0.1432673186,
0.1239901483,
0.8655242324,
-0.6558333039,
-0.6477272511,
-0.1618936062,
-0.662381351,
-0.3345842361,
0.0736692622,
-0.2206807882,
-0.2032757401,
0.3837255538,
-0.0378539898,
0.2718648016,
0.5140792131,
0.0299519151,
0.636728704,
0.5150313973,
0.0892931744,
-0.8090239167,
-0.244390741,
0.3532802761,
-0.481492877,
-0.9659004807,
-0.0862508491,
-0.2747179866,
-0.040085528,
-0.9959213138,
0.5408908129,
-0.1675809771,
0.2968480885,
-0.5757648945,
0.1139211506,
-0.4145946205,
0.711314261,
0.1110717878,
0.4644344747,
0.5155674219,
-0.5223291516,
0.3275578916,
0.2261365503,
-0.0849199221,
0.7753872871,
-0.0986621529,
0.453803122,
-0.5694456697,
0.0299935434,
-0.830039978,
-0.2528504431,
0.6041747332,
-0.2803075612,
-0.0255885534,
-0.7257633805,
-0.4919576347,
-0.2303298861,
-0.4757255316,
0.3270010352,
0.0157006625,
-0.5381397605,
0.3861560225,
0.6416729093,
-0.1384641081,
-0.6546065807,
-0.466547519,
0.0006656665,
-0.3548470438,
-0.344571352,
0.1212385893,
-0.0534691624,
-0.3520413935,
0.0201333854,
0.0620348901,
-0.5516709685,
0.1237531751,
0.3251069486,
0.0373280458,
-0.209673211,
0.3261851668,
0.0187407956,
0.0598674379,
-0.035800308,
-0.0847193822,
0.4049168527,
-0.0662975013,
-0.1772157848,
-0.3540429473,
0.7547547817,
0.4314127266,
-0.2590236664,
0.4858104289,
0.8042217493,
-0.6357904077,
-0.4566638172,
-0.2745227814,
-0.1693422496,
-0.4363010526,
0.7046067119,
-0.3731343746,
-0.6943544149,
0.3471998274,
0.035557244,
0.2538872063,
0.0734083503,
0.7058055401,
-0.1294994354,
0.7614563704,
0.5677999258,
-0.3750288785,
0.734588027,
-0.0647592545,
0.1478179693,
-0.3472259343,
0.1978896856,
-0.4198388755,
-0.3692778945,
-0.5629149675,
-0.2274360806,
0.4327230453,
0.0311798993,
-0.1895882934,
0.8211099505,
-0.2867786586,
0.6469761133,
0.1629692465,
0.3426688015,
0.3802829683,
0.1717094928,
0.3430071771,
-0.1085593402,
-0.633117795,
-0.7418869734,
1.2141389847,
0.4666952193,
0.6441848874,
0.2553646863,
0.5594590306,
0.5226601362,
0.7655226588,
-1.0435599089,
0.188981846,
-0.4661113322,
-0.9867883325,
-0.1745165735,
-0.0092401914,
-1.0398459435,
0.3958543241,
-0.3599147797,
-0.8535467386,
0.0760557503,
0.2772772312,
-0.4786697924,
0.4342731535,
-0.6875988841,
0.8600487709,
-0.1742723733,
-0.5557637811,
-0.0989842415,
-0.3861628175,
0.5805319548,
-0.3887182176,
0.5751069188,
-0.4207384884,
0.09900143,
0.9963794351,
-0.1076061726,
1.2582370043,
-0.4038989842,
-0.0686987117,
0.5428255796,
0.2341362983,
0.3625653982,
-0.2220957577,
-0.2203723639,
-0.0203097928,
0.0493514724,
-0.3865829706,
-0.3163292408,
0.2497830093,
-0.5124956369,
-0.1113834009,
-0.1840745062,
-0.6367375255,
-0.2188055813,
0.2128788233,
0.21463947,
0.2768909633,
-0.3129723072,
-0.1313260943,
0.3107474446,
0.0937856063,
0.3529655635,
0.5991362929,
-0.1502381563,
-0.0231942944,
0.6367991567,
-0.0971754268,
0.1602413654,
0.1273017228,
0.2302318513,
-0.0563750453,
-0.5649854541,
-0.2023487538,
-0.0110895336,
-0.6687789559,
-0.5514419675,
-0.8325862288,
0.1374939531,
-0.4414081573,
0.0539872274,
-0.5735256672,
0.1901076585,
-0.0706019402,
0.0095294667,
0.53180933,
0.7607824206,
-0.3809438348,
0.7307001352,
-0.7226811647,
0.8943959475,
0.13732858,
0.3589294255,
-0.3494936228,
-0.9504230022,
-0.1666368544,
0.2056073844,
-0.3651145101,
-1.1901279688,
0.3383815885,
0.1952224225,
0.2102749944,
0.5419105887,
0.2393945903,
0.6858840585,
-0.4798336327,
0.3142625988,
0.0954485387,
-0.6337710619,
0.6849720478,
-0.3844813704,
-0.129518345,
0.8268396854,
0.7502972484,
-0.7242367864,
-0.4871353805,
-0.3432537019,
-0.38611269,
0.8170491457,
0.2395833731,
0.6079368591,
-0.0901004076,
-0.0320086293,
0.3351275921,
-0.014060243,
-1.1033689976,
-0.1639868766,
-0.1272055954,
-0.095781967,
0.4008933902,
-0.2528707981,
-0.2317255139,
-0.1747194082,
0.6575732827,
-0.2629362345,
0.1977156103,
-0.5416653156,
-0.5786669254,
-0.2932493091,
0.4320667088,
0.2207774818,
0.31425789,
-0.1535729468,
0.0921493769,
0.2051449567,
-0.5219619274,
0.2241412699,
-0.2108515799,
0.0272031892,
0.1858229786,
0.5272678733,
0.8747032881,
0.252627492,
-0.5335382819,
0.8979508281,
0.3798560798,
-0.1138636991,
-0.205207482,
0.0285802186,
-0.1506251395,
0.2583607435,
0.1237134486,
0.0169087723,
0.0995756239,
-0.5352092981,
0.550203681,
0.3235436082,
-0.3804204166,
-0.3340903819,
0.3661053181,
0.037101876,
-0.3373000026,
0.3903731108,
-0.6974133253,
-0.7654196024,
0.3368906081,
0.7118804455,
0.6247878671,
-0.2076071054,
0.4814678729,
0.4790661931,
0.3622632027,
0.1085627228,
0.1189846992,
0.0933823586,
-1.1354188919,
-0.201266557,
-0.6732907891,
-0.2158023268,
0.4927709997,
-0.5792924166,
0.5967075825,
-0.6333228946,
-0.1127323508,
0.4449037015,
-0.2024818957,
-0.8994432092,
0.0156858135,
0.3719935417,
0.5473310947,
-1.616643548,
0.6254875064,
0.4899237454,
-0.5586740375,
-0.446903497,
-0.2131087184,
0.4275199473,
-1.0032119751,
0.6562937498,
-0.0243740734,
-0.2353854179,
-0.2059069574,
-1.0509598255,
-0.4795183539,
0.2609966099,
0.3978908062,
-0.4474166036,
0.1046072468,
0.0854272768,
0.6745109558,
-0.315961808,
-0.0031092819,
0.7405079603,
0.411010325,
-0.0682725087,
-0.6432288885,
-0.24063842,
-0.2250086814,
-0.4904360473,
0.3045174479,
-0.1885818392,
0.4097230136,
-0.1308430433,
-0.223342225,
-0.1937641054,
0.3494566381,
0.1514651477,
0.3388581872,
0.740832448,
0.2980525494,
0.5638705492,
0.1907714009,
1.0240238905,
0.2035511285,
0.3032742739,
1.4959589243,
-0.1712793708,
0.8726285696,
0.3122029901,
-0.28737095,
0.3962322176,
0.4656047821,
-0.4209997058,
0.4262864292,
0.3350116909,
-0.3286717534,
-0.4253902733,
-0.6817851067,
0.0801101029,
0.9717795253,
0.2850014567,
-0.2138228714,
-0.6268264651,
0.475620985,
0.3616428673,
0.2251730263,
-0.2547479868,
0.8424854279,
-0.0005124095,
-0.223395288,
0.5564038157,
0.1071421728,
0.9190545082,
-0.6042913795,
0.109248288,
-0.0435334668,
-0.2144882679,
-0.3710379303,
-0.5584766865,
0.4307588339,
0.6340194941,
-0.0699685663,
-0.3901891112,
0.9860554338,
-0.4958350956,
-0.5042777658,
0.4694778323,
0.4460872114,
0.4760799706,
-0.50829494,
-0.6405369043,
0.1564224958,
-0.2796462178,
0.1175884381,
0.2522295713,
0.2561796308,
-0.2549315989,
0.3418493271,
0.6930966973,
0.1874439865,
0.2881119847,
0.1860582978,
0.8439497948,
-0.3341112733,
-0.2110844553,
-0.7833411098,
0.3300432265,
0.080819428,
-0.3023317158,
0.18946217,
0.4734075963,
0.9440205097,
0.0140157938,
0.8921183944,
0.0113163209,
0.5218362808,
-0.2674064338,
0.5122801065,
-0.441912055,
-0.0524234474,
-0.6106382608,
-0.6527122855,
-0.5039089322,
0.4793047309,
-0.328428328,
-0.1555485874,
0.694116354,
1.0044854879,
-0.385430783,
-0.1737459451,
0.451625973,
0.1678859144,
0.2407552302,
0.5392523408,
0.7839392424,
-0.5399310589,
0.8931735158,
-0.4250989854,
-0.0106649976,
-0.0050643976,
-0.8730776906,
-0.8089861274,
-0.3681335449,
-0.5603431463,
-0.3196558654,
0.2735349238,
0.9579704404,
0.8236966729,
-1.0796570778,
-0.0034255295,
0.3973350823,
0.1124216169,
-0.2119743973,
-0.179553628,
0.1336010396,
-0.3671036363,
-0.8332032561,
0.3519110382,
0.2039095163,
-0.2188242227,
0.1439475566,
0.1909461617,
-0.5125201941,
-0.1498090178,
0.8979945779,
0.2653933465,
-0.5308277607,
-0.5252788663,
-0.0346843675,
-0.2175594717,
0.3782128096,
0.7837017775,
-0.4602647126,
0.3945735395,
0.3386361301,
0.8021581769,
0.4019325078,
0.0818520039,
0.0526537001,
-1.1657714844,
0.1225028262,
0.2463110834,
0.131547004,
0.3679383695,
-0.2785227299,
0.2976131737,
0.2260872424,
0.1006817743,
-0.7430118322,
0.3456934094,
-0.7529885173,
-0.3686752915,
1.260615468,
-0.1193442419,
-0.211648196,
-0.505332768,
-0.2101922035,
0.3522720337,
-0.5216184258,
0.7569060922,
0.7428307533,
-0.0790057853,
-0.1162515953,
-0.6255431175,
0.4904017448,
0.2510697544,
-0.9171161056,
0.3193817139,
0.5031637549,
0.4875773787,
0.1740036905,
0.7738189101,
-0.0981022194,
0.3476460278,
0.0251129419,
-0.0274249706,
0.096823439,
-0.4508447051,
-0.2934266031,
0.4170964658,
-0.230666846,
-0.4432231486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14071v1 | Disentangled Variational Autoencoder for Emotion Recognition in Conversations | 2023-05-23T13:50:06 | 2023-05-23T13:50:06 | Kailai Yang, Tianlin Zhang, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In Emotion Recognition in Conversations (ERC), the emotions of target
utterances are closely dependent on their context. Therefore, existing works
train the model to generate the response of the target utterance, which aims to
recognise emotions leveraging contextual information. However, adjacent
response generation ignores long-range dependencies and provides limited
affective information in many cases. In addition, most ERC models learn a
unified distributed representation for each utterance, which lacks
interpretability and robustness. To address these issues, we propose a
VAD-disentangled Variational AutoEncoder (VAD-VAE), which first introduces a
target utterance reconstruction task based on Variational Autoencoder, then
disentangles three affect representations Valence-Arousal-Dominance (VAD) from
the latent space. We also enhance the disentangled representations by
introducing VAD supervision signals from a sentiment lexicon and minimising the
mutual information between VAD distributions. Experiments show that VAD-VAE
outperforms the state-of-the-art model on two datasets. Further analysis proves
the effectiveness of each proposed module and the quality of disentangled VAD
representations. The code is available at
https://github.com/SteveKGYang/VAD-VAE. | [
-0.5440876484,
-0.4295591116,
0.310375452,
0.2770115733,
-0.3079665899,
-0.0374327525,
-0.0061598704,
-0.2660999894,
0.4744545519,
0.0007509707,
-0.5334852338,
-0.4219100773,
-0.6351591349,
0.0632240549,
-0.259894222,
0.691695869,
-0.1468238682,
-0.0388993286,
-0.3180004954,
-0.2687379122,
-0.1627120376,
-0.7279623747,
-0.2605780661,
-0.2068004757,
0.3564324677,
0.1401780993,
0.1052813455,
0.0980124399,
0.2915271521,
0.3840909004,
-0.4681370854,
0.147943005,
-0.4314795732,
0.3444918394,
0.2891492248,
-0.4091339111,
-0.5118386149,
-0.3023205101,
0.2349301875,
0.2519552112,
-0.5310497284,
-0.5628623962,
0.1753901541,
0.7285267115,
-0.8814193606,
0.2616988719,
-0.30889979,
0.2330993712,
0.2369304448,
0.0116294762,
-0.1885962635,
0.0053042551,
0.273449719,
-0.1025325879,
0.0358668491,
-0.2540488541,
0.6679512858,
0.3088037968,
-0.6921155453,
-0.290428251,
-0.8321428895,
0.2646017075,
-0.8281663656,
0.3616899848,
0.302898109,
0.2183204144,
0.0604779311,
-0.2627080083,
-0.7014526129,
0.0385867208,
0.0313035585,
0.6345621943,
-0.4115317464,
0.2412307113,
0.191422224,
0.8094649315,
-0.4794658124,
0.080959253,
0.1600515246,
0.2430322021,
0.4068893492,
0.4400119185,
-0.0519525222,
-0.344787091,
-0.3360564411,
-0.2726723254,
-0.245054394,
0.0067563471,
0.3088749349,
-0.1430001557,
-0.3163845837,
0.1176465675,
-0.115726687,
0.3096847832,
0.3483807147,
0.4664024711,
0.3439108133,
0.2219916731,
-0.3345139623,
-0.1009896323,
0.9184080958,
0.4129418433,
-0.3463888764,
0.158922568,
-0.2228330225,
0.051066909,
0.3428713679,
-0.7581025958,
-0.1487877369,
0.3383175433,
-0.3717172444,
-0.1746529341,
0.057832364,
-1.14072299,
-0.586237371,
-0.2634908855,
0.1803510934,
-0.2945330143,
-0.6481020451,
0.260086745,
-0.0121289892,
0.2941174805,
0.228022486,
-1.121147275,
0.4344179332,
0.2811227143,
0.7935546637,
-0.1593398303,
-0.0181945115,
-0.1043456793,
-0.2717297375,
-0.1600705683,
0.3149821758,
-0.269181937,
-0.6995190382,
0.03024056,
-0.0449758396,
0.2608811855,
-0.4783538878,
0.3759627938,
-0.5699286461,
0.1852550209,
-0.281471163,
-0.7575232983,
-0.1041479111,
0.2453153878,
-0.7652779818,
0.6489757299,
0.18712084,
-1.025139451,
0.0737940818,
-0.4621165097,
-0.2830255628,
-0.1357804239,
-0.2630182207,
-0.5163118243,
0.4190040529,
0.269231081,
0.5003051758,
-0.1108625755,
-0.0404728055,
-0.4877246916,
-0.1157337129,
0.3277558684,
-0.760799408,
0.4562063217,
0.3253830671,
-0.5242744088,
-0.2125124335,
-0.6466275454,
-0.4565422833,
0.0527226999,
-0.1722478718,
-0.6014326811,
0.0111634461,
0.0526665375,
0.16226466,
0.1057817712,
-0.5234777331,
-0.0715730488,
-0.4740451276,
0.2370036542,
0.8655723929,
0.0684635565,
0.4530606568,
0.1363310069,
0.4712893963,
0.6113556623,
0.0564976074,
0.0538515113,
0.0853959024,
-0.8797791004,
-0.3001966476,
-0.0016754122,
0.4227845073,
-0.4397422969,
0.8088436127,
0.09230382,
-0.3108015358,
-0.4496783316,
-0.3257403672,
0.2154325694,
0.3962627649,
0.1899031401,
-0.4964298606,
-0.5539161563,
-0.7077069879,
0.0919081643,
-0.1538346261,
-0.0863100141,
0.6451550126,
0.3321069181,
-0.3496680558,
0.8428221941,
-0.5474737883,
-0.0735619292,
0.2613914013,
0.6467237473,
0.0771590471,
0.2794534564,
0.4145211875,
-1.0192662477,
-0.4698471427,
-0.0411218256,
-0.7878248692,
-0.1072280332,
0.0138047161,
-0.2196458578,
0.0321762785,
0.351131022,
-0.3964027166,
0.5268104076,
0.5276255608,
-0.2559160292,
0.1823521107,
-0.1533442289,
0.567482233,
-1.3180382252,
-0.2040023804,
-0.033370249,
-0.3572564721,
-0.488938123,
-0.7086848021,
0.055566296,
0.0912709758,
-0.288490504,
0.1321761757,
-0.5267525315,
0.0224090926,
-0.34911865,
0.0489317179,
-0.01859718,
0.607108295,
0.3065198064,
0.356189549,
0.627415359,
-0.50161165,
0.6558774114,
0.282756865,
-0.0814470947,
0.98116225,
-0.5493655801,
0.2715654075,
-0.36313802,
0.1251006126,
-0.8478425741,
-0.2902562618,
0.1313619614,
-0.4376353025,
0.4650889933,
0.0371174924,
0.0237222984,
-0.3874917626,
-0.1436439306,
0.3514986336,
0.6512576938,
-0.8248357177,
0.9972230196,
0.4218206704,
-0.1451214552,
-0.5458699465,
-0.8723459244,
-0.1198205426,
-0.3622219563,
-0.1789872944,
0.2076809406,
-0.1586976796,
0.0556829311,
0.0230481755,
-0.204983592,
-0.056242343,
-0.0127642248,
0.5609341264,
0.1192001477,
0.0070657171,
0.2490020394,
0.1731791198,
0.0288726687,
0.3340881467,
0.0316198245,
0.3590106368,
-0.429456234,
-0.5057754517,
-0.2877767384,
0.7669659257,
0.815923512,
-0.1387144774,
0.6169587374,
0.6463835239,
-0.6027892828,
-0.2129360288,
-0.3014252186,
-0.1506550312,
-0.482229948,
0.6114600897,
-0.4443701804,
-0.9792926908,
0.5997371078,
-0.3306121826,
-0.3385637105,
0.4291314781,
0.9075743556,
-0.3311049342,
1.1670039892,
0.5463741422,
-0.3754852116,
0.8691006303,
-0.1564110368,
0.1661274284,
-1.0196049213,
-0.1264942139,
-0.247464329,
-0.162724942,
-0.5199961066,
-0.2825315893,
0.384570092,
0.108558014,
-0.050950367,
0.0560482964,
-0.5832944512,
0.431425035,
0.2388993055,
0.1203500554,
0.0058929157,
-0.106453523,
0.1518038064,
-0.258957237,
-0.4023609459,
-0.3901551664,
0.6600779891,
0.3769280016,
0.9761737585,
0.1178013608,
0.9557165504,
0.2592830062,
0.134607181,
-0.6980312467,
0.3139407635,
-0.169272989,
-0.2888365686,
0.0409047455,
-0.6810738444,
-0.7290095687,
0.2528591454,
0.0062340554,
-0.8612497449,
0.7030540109,
0.160848856,
-0.1698007882,
0.1509711444,
-0.7045568228,
0.6098365784,
-0.231442228,
-0.1523100883,
-0.2427746952,
-0.64969486,
0.1995216161,
0.2678031027,
-0.1089590639,
0.1027732641,
0.3901644051,
0.6516922712,
-0.3813975453,
0.8732652068,
-0.3782945275,
-0.1136780679,
0.1069657505,
0.0876426995,
0.3917123079,
0.2415240109,
0.1080613881,
-0.0405858345,
-0.1315336376,
-0.1631145477,
-0.8216506839,
0.6311147809,
-0.8013954163,
-0.276909858,
-0.4563373625,
-0.154506743,
-0.2767233849,
-0.2454167604,
0.4124231339,
0.3019843698,
-0.7258161306,
0.1820279956,
0.8283954859,
-0.0907418504,
0.4061713517,
0.4387637675,
0.0867743641,
-0.5007880926,
0.7565649748,
-0.3490628302,
0.2139226794,
0.4944839776,
-0.0672858134,
-0.308739543,
0.0609014966,
-0.092704311,
-0.0815567151,
-0.7701123357,
-0.2149507403,
-0.6647542119,
-0.1917729676,
-0.1993528306,
-0.0788040161,
-0.6561338902,
0.1066654623,
-0.7591647506,
-0.1986637115,
0.4573913515,
0.7324116826,
-0.5156010985,
0.0810156614,
-0.643152535,
0.4508538246,
0.7660315037,
0.3431909978,
-0.0181649197,
-0.3643806875,
-0.2232802659,
0.23760207,
-0.2019397169,
-1.0629678965,
0.5822965503,
0.1280792058,
0.1748279184,
0.458571583,
0.4229551256,
0.2511737049,
-0.16946733,
0.6672365069,
0.5917809606,
-1.2100986242,
0.3951980174,
-0.0924683437,
0.2748659253,
0.2763347626,
0.4555076063,
-0.6824200749,
-0.1683943421,
-0.5391689539,
-1.0453085899,
0.6933979988,
0.2600612044,
0.3271982968,
-0.131355688,
0.2517996728,
0.0452711992,
0.2870178819,
-0.5128675699,
-0.2720735967,
-0.4300029874,
-0.6934524179,
0.2048455626,
-0.5795871615,
-0.1099371016,
0.0956601501,
0.3233387768,
-0.0245766696,
0.8279885054,
0.5101233721,
0.0446382798,
-0.0990568921,
0.36186409,
0.1941449046,
-0.329606235,
-0.4296402037,
0.1890161783,
0.2157619596,
-0.3577466607,
0.2285750359,
0.2946977913,
0.4626489878,
0.0450367816,
0.0086215474,
1.2807630301,
-0.2231771797,
-0.3751755953,
0.7900050879,
-0.5514862537,
-0.1465741694,
-0.2090042084,
-0.2411334813,
0.2191111594,
0.667347312,
0.0571900271,
-0.1516009271,
0.5214335322,
-0.2299633175,
0.1627507359,
0.1107522622,
-0.5163747668,
-0.4097777307,
0.5766502619,
0.3846170306,
-0.2566160858,
0.5135179758,
-0.2860304117,
-0.8109409213,
0.5837457776,
0.332118541,
1.1214990616,
-0.4758579433,
0.0792949945,
0.1944086552,
-0.2105197012,
0.1884825677,
0.4190820158,
-0.3159819245,
-0.6488772035,
0.0157157611,
-0.3703455031,
-0.6617873907,
0.0034210035,
-1.0612787008,
-0.0367873646,
-0.1406939477,
-0.1783891916,
-0.3809699118,
-0.5284891725,
-0.6208977103,
0.3502432704,
0.5584891438,
0.1702441722,
-0.9314579368,
0.3786413074,
0.5507951975,
-0.253223747,
-0.6275131106,
-0.0467946455,
0.0650643706,
-0.2147613913,
0.198425591,
0.1061069742,
-0.4681996107,
-0.0183334984,
-0.392064631,
-0.3760011792,
1.0743080378,
0.3389396667,
-0.9946450591,
0.3526207209,
-0.0767452791,
0.6971979737,
-0.4535391033,
0.5891318917,
0.2736922204,
-0.1271845549,
0.115766637,
-0.6139629483,
-0.2606607974,
-0.4727892578,
0.0799317211,
0.0946647972,
-0.6264280677,
0.730043292,
0.2122608423,
-0.1408400834,
-0.2204065919,
0.7732303739,
-0.005918127,
0.2210725099,
0.7170968056,
0.4828363657,
0.7589533925,
-0.0969216228,
0.7092865705,
-0.1241769791,
0.6204950213,
1.1107017994,
-0.273571521,
0.8928915858,
0.3848337531,
-0.2351645976,
0.5130957365,
0.6978846192,
0.3064286411,
0.7282165885,
0.2364692241,
-0.6908035874,
-0.1344925314,
-0.0262676794,
-0.3086029589,
0.4556504488,
0.5125126243,
-0.2965465486,
0.0465867966,
0.4041649401,
-0.4280075431,
-0.162877813,
-0.0325692892,
1.0679752827,
0.3507685363,
-0.1020603776,
0.6674138308,
-0.3213522732,
0.7867978215,
-0.3745353818,
0.0004194979,
-0.4897588491,
0.1870756894,
-0.1086857095,
-0.6352231503,
0.2370978743,
0.13341932,
-0.2831655741,
-0.0596309081,
0.613493979,
-0.79466784,
0.1685614437,
0.6054437757,
0.2724839747,
0.0346894078,
-0.2349627316,
-0.5112740397,
0.0317620859,
-0.1200911254,
-0.6936337352,
0.2437900454,
0.8592451811,
0.4896802306,
0.2872338295,
0.0708052516,
-0.1628480107,
-0.1935622245,
0.226782769,
1.1109580994,
-0.704056263,
-0.6577066779,
-0.8116449714,
0.6716266274,
-0.1700502783,
-0.2194891572,
0.1976249516,
-0.0490557589,
0.48102355,
-0.1885892153,
0.7488687038,
-0.214744091,
0.2234466225,
-0.3628517687,
0.4973794222,
-0.8546490669,
0.0926856846,
-0.4691250324,
-0.5764601231,
-0.0408218279,
0.8161808252,
-0.0837409347,
0.0557988249,
0.5492832661,
0.6557757258,
-0.0790513456,
0.1743771434,
0.3483574092,
0.4015982747,
0.3698687255,
0.9309036136,
1.0873321295,
-0.3535330594,
0.2803607285,
-0.14511621,
-0.2803995609,
-0.4560756385,
-0.8798071146,
-0.6454123259,
-0.867185533,
-0.4076299965,
-0.3349329531,
-0.1250841618,
0.8258160949,
0.6635386348,
-0.6035510898,
-0.03431971,
-0.5259126425,
-0.1125089303,
0.0544623993,
-0.2448207885,
0.2525180578,
0.0774023905,
-0.8636552095,
0.2661589086,
0.4797033668,
0.3959730566,
-0.0572807752,
-0.3916139901,
-0.1007816419,
0.0886669904,
0.3194456697,
0.2152187675,
-0.3920579255,
-0.0257740878,
-0.1258458197,
-0.4033051729,
0.2755172253,
0.6159764528,
-0.3711079359,
0.9105734229,
0.4743337035,
0.7042371035,
0.8312749267,
-0.0832412392,
0.6676810384,
-0.8045420647,
0.1672713012,
0.4694666862,
0.4459632635,
0.3762528896,
-0.4417559505,
0.0666059256,
0.0651157722,
-0.6094279289,
-0.5722151995,
0.3626531363,
-1.1418530941,
-0.0310938098,
1.0043075085,
-0.5195781589,
-0.3176002502,
0.2092672884,
-0.4171046913,
0.4289625883,
-0.5542280674,
0.7276453972,
0.823684454,
-0.0820164829,
-0.3304262757,
0.0291669201,
0.3836147189,
0.6083903313,
-0.8610382676,
0.4022007883,
0.6483892202,
-0.0321773812,
0.0120356549,
0.7701259255,
-0.008048553,
0.209128648,
0.3507343829,
0.4484390616,
0.2140418142,
-0.0238046423,
-0.8033559918,
-0.1284167171,
-0.0090232138,
-0.4626960754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14070v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14070v2 | Assessing Linguistic Generalisation in Language Models: A Dataset for Brazilian Portuguese | 2023-05-23T13:49:14 | 2023-06-07T08:53:08 | Rodrigo Wilkens, Leonardo Zilio, Aline Villavicencio | cs.CL | cs.CL | Much recent effort has been devoted to creating large-scale language models.
Nowadays, the most prominent approaches are based on deep neural networks, such
as BERT. However, they lack transparency and interpretability, and are often
seen as black boxes. This affects not only their applicability in downstream
tasks but also the comparability of different architectures or even of the same
model trained using different corpora or hyperparameters. In this paper, we
propose a set of intrinsic evaluation tasks that inspect the linguistic
information encoded in models developed for Brazilian Portuguese. These tasks
are designed to evaluate how different language models generalise information
related to grammatical structures and multiword expressions (MWEs), thus
allowing for an assessment of whether the model has learned different
linguistic phenomena. The dataset that was developed for these tasks is
composed of a series of sentences with a single masked word and a cue phrase
that helps in narrowing down the context. This dataset is divided into MWEs and
grammatical structures, and the latter is subdivided into 6 tasks: impersonal
verbs, subject agreement, verb agreement, nominal agreement, passive and
connectors. The subset for MWEs was used to test BERTimbau Large, BERTimbau
Base and mBERT. For the grammatical structures, we used only BERTimbau Large,
because it yielded the best results in the MWE task. | [
-0.2515849173,
-0.9631596804,
0.2385148257,
0.5711400509,
-0.2023057044,
-0.1428323388,
-0.688152194,
-0.2943109572,
-0.0125083113,
0.3560859263,
-0.2416342795,
-0.5968227983,
-0.7403060794,
0.118598938,
-0.566691637,
1.0033296347,
-0.0769067183,
0.010594069,
-0.0743779242,
-0.2003240883,
-0.5116432309,
-0.6370267868,
-0.4665254951,
-0.2376242727,
0.2775027156,
-0.1877489686,
0.5895818472,
0.3281357586,
0.4018826485,
0.4380560219,
-0.3105190694,
0.1461360306,
-0.5544158816,
0.1107672229,
-0.468855381,
-0.3096366525,
-0.2331409454,
-0.2859352827,
0.7796861529,
0.7854195833,
0.1429472715,
0.273958087,
0.3214920163,
0.4506331086,
-0.597704947,
0.6426777244,
-0.6857260466,
-0.0626638457,
0.0520803593,
0.1297013313,
-0.3151161671,
-0.314448148,
0.2669271231,
-0.0015660201,
0.2964977622,
-0.3380969763,
1.030421257,
0.010866168,
-0.4044834971,
-0.4619740546,
-0.633076489,
0.6803039312,
-0.6007708907,
0.4963075817,
0.2318928391,
0.1436843723,
-0.0487746596,
-0.3215478361,
-0.3986015022,
-0.736102879,
-0.3570370972,
-0.033604227,
-0.5284352899,
0.2030865699,
0.0472666621,
0.4305446446,
-0.8398227096,
0.1336679459,
-0.3503869474,
-0.2401234508,
0.4177936614,
-0.2774012983,
0.0183667745,
-0.1738978028,
-0.1526331455,
-0.0023978425,
-0.6527741551,
0.0079696747,
0.6119443774,
0.3529027998,
-0.1351221204,
0.5075610876,
-0.2601670623,
0.9262952805,
-0.1543032378,
0.1518208832,
0.3486735821,
-0.3999167979,
-0.3351000547,
-0.3786545098,
0.7180531621,
-0.1114199162,
0.5434667468,
-0.4230023921,
-0.3871555924,
0.4477428198,
0.3092516065,
-0.3737102747,
0.0457814671,
0.378146112,
-0.2716111541,
-0.2088542581,
0.0139189195,
-0.4728921652,
0.1258482337,
-0.4455955029,
0.4245671332,
-0.4483945668,
-0.1721625924,
-0.0188778285,
-0.0706686825,
0.1745311618,
0.0809964538,
-0.7092923522,
0.3401959836,
0.7792431116,
0.4404722452,
0.0320245139,
-0.3412258327,
-0.2745112181,
-0.0079141902,
-0.2692261934,
0.6379220486,
-0.7039600611,
-0.1348951906,
0.2239138931,
0.1381427348,
-0.182702899,
-0.482134968,
0.8369963169,
-0.3875492215,
0.3399657607,
0.1111018062,
-0.5419594646,
-0.4545295537,
0.5052121878,
-0.4223451912,
1.1181105375,
0.2647726238,
-0.2976207733,
0.400488615,
-0.6641597748,
-0.4380011559,
0.0887571797,
-0.3191865087,
-0.3014602959,
0.3750466704,
0.2889614403,
0.6740176678,
-0.1178789213,
0.5962036252,
-0.2877959609,
-0.300647825,
0.1394939721,
-0.4002565742,
0.5301992893,
-0.0438367203,
-0.5074480772,
0.218521744,
-0.7518716455,
-0.0243715961,
-0.1040254459,
-0.3413916826,
-0.4074353576,
0.0130740497,
-0.0695943981,
0.0790644512,
0.261649847,
-0.4854883552,
0.2390273511,
-0.3867907226,
0.3945963979,
0.7879356742,
-0.1462502331,
0.2097558528,
0.0021023371,
0.4624917209,
0.1729691923,
0.0950252116,
-0.0004650961,
-0.5829700828,
-0.8403630257,
-0.306445837,
0.6471303701,
0.5099691749,
-0.6169676185,
0.8165599108,
-0.5774483085,
-0.527819097,
-0.6805010438,
0.1376353055,
0.7837275267,
0.2274369001,
0.2078279406,
-0.3467245996,
-0.263017118,
-1.2436003685,
0.0037325032,
-0.0752221271,
-0.1485414654,
0.3870692253,
0.7770687938,
-0.2770243585,
0.5457977057,
-0.2114967257,
-0.2319771498,
-0.1388138384,
0.2966705263,
0.5039960146,
0.4599783719,
0.7370567322,
-0.6513389945,
-0.1220659465,
0.2388673127,
-0.6928117275,
-0.1999589056,
0.0865493193,
0.1285794973,
0.0985200107,
0.0616098903,
-0.2884598672,
0.2090081275,
0.7141563296,
-0.2816188633,
0.5426007509,
-0.3205434084,
0.1204506606,
-0.4895157814,
0.1891425699,
0.14864254,
-0.092100203,
-0.5683161616,
0.4738307595,
0.1026758403,
-0.1177255735,
-0.3525819778,
0.4867711961,
-0.551196754,
-0.2640316784,
0.0382780954,
-0.0096468432,
-0.0839584619,
0.7782437801,
0.1754195988,
0.4853976071,
0.8048362732,
-0.6967867613,
0.3499578238,
-0.0025214979,
-0.4045504034,
0.4035078585,
-0.8230782747,
0.3465434015,
-0.4122368693,
-0.1883356571,
-1.1332746744,
0.1477473229,
0.0511645041,
-0.5747690201,
0.3062804937,
-0.3955297172,
-0.3955745101,
-0.3510536253,
-0.186396271,
0.0203723088,
0.0959383994,
-0.3274083138,
0.5390952229,
0.22963126,
-0.2780630887,
-0.7175856233,
-0.6111297011,
0.1989807934,
-0.2364172786,
-0.794208169,
0.163020134,
0.1077114642,
-0.3123055398,
0.0634278432,
0.1467119306,
-0.3156870902,
0.2165385634,
-0.0158808753,
0.1287824214,
-0.4656125009,
0.1575617492,
0.329251796,
0.2892957032,
-0.1566316932,
-0.4229234457,
0.6243370771,
-0.4098329246,
-0.0508785844,
-0.0055508902,
0.2928000093,
0.2247162163,
-0.4221513569,
0.6442810893,
0.6037403345,
-0.3544464111,
-0.151924029,
-0.6834185719,
0.1360336691,
-0.3804460764,
0.4415222406,
-0.5904044509,
-0.932715416,
0.5402582288,
0.3046160042,
0.0747542083,
0.433791548,
0.9045500159,
0.1254853904,
0.6081853509,
0.4956595898,
-0.177175954,
0.4170650244,
-0.369870007,
-0.0478318818,
-0.6484441161,
-0.0531007238,
-0.7935291529,
-0.2096067071,
-0.6584968567,
-0.3375037313,
0.3158169687,
-0.0706754625,
0.1094597578,
0.7259956598,
-0.4757906795,
0.388220489,
0.5035928488,
0.079149507,
0.1996370256,
0.0980119109,
-0.2964173853,
0.2070579529,
-0.4409635961,
-0.7937853932,
1.1796917915,
0.3514474928,
0.4237083197,
0.2614943385,
0.462023288,
0.5082376599,
0.4129461646,
-0.8058934212,
0.5176079273,
-0.4098967314,
-0.6293615699,
-0.2691209018,
-0.5788426399,
-1.2797404528,
0.7647595406,
-0.240829885,
-0.7435683012,
0.2993730605,
-0.0391141288,
-0.0088501209,
-0.2547655404,
-1.0464528799,
0.8981775045,
-0.2304915339,
-0.3804361522,
-0.2226537913,
-0.4761306047,
0.3063535392,
-0.0172980577,
0.2257834822,
0.0761701092,
0.0103585534,
0.6848683357,
0.1060140878,
0.741546452,
-0.1586583555,
-0.3240718246,
0.1220910475,
0.0641995743,
0.2734746933,
-0.1506751031,
-0.2487057447,
0.5009430647,
0.0284699462,
-0.4627583027,
-0.5903198719,
0.5228148699,
-0.6434862018,
-0.279094696,
-0.2690644562,
-0.3951227963,
-0.3566077054,
0.2481440753,
-0.0539838262,
0.4922037721,
-0.6194021106,
0.1970840842,
0.3346295953,
-0.2407703549,
0.232666865,
0.7921302319,
-0.0174779817,
-0.1565914601,
0.7719151974,
0.0325336903,
0.1451841593,
0.6046512127,
0.2336303592,
-0.3507641852,
-0.9648876786,
-0.501934886,
0.1459533274,
-0.5065717101,
0.1126968488,
-0.3838344812,
0.1360978782,
-0.7826536894,
0.2464209944,
0.1181286871,
-0.3023735285,
0.0303600803,
-0.1913229674,
-0.2164499164,
0.9133079052,
0.0945814252,
0.3790372908,
-0.6689611673,
0.2171173841,
0.1686480343,
0.1910572201,
-0.2135784179,
-0.4769532681,
-0.0514116287,
0.0736884475,
-0.2515668869,
-0.8527697325,
0.2807343304,
0.3811353445,
0.8216692209,
0.447994709,
-0.6074627638,
0.4217287302,
-0.4282573462,
0.6882393956,
-0.1420762241,
-1.0726290941,
0.6107567549,
-0.5102056265,
0.0014405366,
0.4032796025,
0.34281075,
-0.3928653896,
-0.5857189298,
-0.7135747671,
-0.6849949956,
0.3434121013,
0.558922112,
0.1320810467,
-0.0394749902,
0.3140969276,
0.1211801842,
0.5655327439,
-0.870341897,
-0.0195905827,
0.1505928636,
-0.012900996,
-0.2035778016,
-0.2238542438,
0.0421588533,
-0.0694899261,
0.5176233649,
-0.1891046762,
0.3877746165,
0.0095210699,
-0.5041940808,
0.3810818195,
0.6340544224,
0.5764003992,
0.764061749,
-0.243045032,
0.0953742787,
0.0634308755,
-0.2002965659,
0.0652266517,
0.1931797415,
-0.1326992214,
0.2681176662,
0.7649298906,
0.8553870916,
0.2293070704,
-0.5860735178,
0.5231518745,
0.0011748904,
0.0765293762,
0.0347785205,
-0.0535463989,
-0.1729760319,
-0.1243376657,
0.013456312,
-0.1880086064,
0.2927784026,
-0.8644623756,
0.157232821,
0.3360805809,
-0.4141703546,
-0.4381171167,
0.0477655493,
0.2574773133,
0.0113272844,
0.5050089955,
-0.3597780764,
-0.6041585207,
0.6529659629,
0.2302408218,
0.8162665963,
-0.4122396111,
0.0914337337,
0.2049553096,
0.7710513473,
0.2349933833,
0.454364121,
-0.1068414971,
-0.8853606582,
-0.5600981712,
-0.7295121551,
-0.375736475,
0.1706108898,
-0.7092834115,
0.1550959796,
-0.0585656203,
0.0117031457,
0.0998182595,
-0.204454273,
-0.752730608,
0.4392156005,
0.1750861853,
0.6653473973,
-1.0399991274,
0.8906705976,
0.7246540189,
-0.3515572846,
-0.3243994117,
-0.3232371807,
-0.2815195918,
-1.0597981215,
0.7834357619,
0.0105676325,
0.24102588,
-0.4605723321,
-0.2861994505,
-0.5021725893,
0.2849346995,
0.6281393766,
-0.5997164249,
-0.1781108528,
0.2956869304,
0.9624543786,
-0.2876398861,
0.5231253505,
0.7320138216,
0.6715684533,
-0.222036317,
-1.1729569435,
-0.1735370904,
-0.4027001262,
0.0357181989,
0.2926692963,
-0.3035306036,
0.6752756238,
0.2396855801,
0.0369072147,
-0.0792846978,
0.6710643172,
-0.0901909843,
-0.311784178,
0.5672010779,
0.5396296382,
0.7010688782,
-0.4222021401,
1.1229449511,
-0.2105737776,
0.566907227,
1.2014627457,
-0.1461518556,
0.7709954381,
0.1105153561,
-0.3675414026,
0.3743293583,
0.3871411681,
-0.3055192828,
0.1728114039,
0.7131609917,
-0.0307072513,
0.095831275,
-0.0816837028,
-0.3882416785,
0.6811333299,
0.6587469578,
-0.5638020039,
-0.4900899231,
0.0493174605,
0.0886344686,
-0.0322142541,
-0.3367411792,
0.6910668612,
-0.2156334966,
-0.7854871154,
0.6448382735,
0.0827718526,
0.7073480487,
-0.8266087174,
0.0223725792,
-0.1814414114,
0.3730820119,
-0.1369259804,
-0.8763309717,
0.5238283277,
0.1442913562,
0.15354608,
-0.2254510671,
0.6053696871,
-0.5762079954,
-0.705426991,
0.5447630286,
0.4296505153,
0.3629300892,
-0.3527575135,
-0.8327824473,
0.1278612763,
-0.2017493844,
-0.035952393,
0.1047407314,
0.3956746459,
-0.0759656206,
0.4772125483,
0.4116887152,
0.3012104928,
0.1194503829,
0.2552685738,
0.7321183085,
-0.5439658761,
-0.5367366076,
-0.772888422,
0.238652423,
0.0310545731,
-0.4998040497,
0.838163197,
0.7430570722,
0.866895318,
-0.1512724161,
0.676234901,
-0.1061705351,
0.3611916304,
-0.4935414195,
0.4569104612,
-0.3153878748,
0.0288771391,
-0.4964841902,
-0.9965507984,
-0.1262552887,
0.5546299219,
-0.426237911,
-0.0501177199,
0.6646175385,
0.8367945552,
-0.1465877146,
-0.1640666574,
0.4519450665,
0.5414848924,
0.2516227365,
0.6792316437,
0.8171982169,
-0.3189133704,
0.3674946427,
-0.2314391285,
-0.5473757982,
0.1191344634,
-0.837816298,
-0.9066412449,
-0.5629246235,
-0.3128798008,
-0.4003924131,
0.3148342967,
0.5989907384,
0.7137472034,
-1.0737506151,
-0.5659977198,
0.2078262717,
0.1086810008,
-0.4450222254,
-0.1913301647,
0.5226179361,
-0.2648399174,
-0.9124702811,
0.5933360457,
0.2841663063,
-0.2450096905,
-0.4295425713,
0.4557192624,
-0.2383140326,
-0.1147529036,
0.8955667615,
-0.0706009716,
-0.6024926305,
-0.3040331602,
-0.258231014,
0.2135074288,
0.089605324,
0.738748014,
-0.6870796084,
0.3111682236,
0.6115341187,
0.4472816885,
0.4607371688,
-0.3774999082,
0.6659422517,
-0.933783412,
0.3065276742,
0.3843359351,
0.7987799048,
0.2138396353,
-0.1186542213,
0.7859590054,
0.0427598245,
-0.2716401219,
-0.6257923841,
0.0584761947,
-1.1307595968,
-0.2103565484,
1.1980530024,
-0.4608184397,
-0.3033671975,
-0.1503573656,
-0.2243876755,
-0.0416189991,
-0.3664363325,
0.6213102937,
0.8726226687,
0.1774916649,
0.2995443642,
-0.3227431774,
-0.0543501563,
0.4280097485,
-0.814552784,
-0.0263104476,
0.459504813,
0.2815170586,
0.3171663582,
0.2310032248,
-0.2006215751,
0.0741688386,
-0.3786313236,
0.0648367628,
0.1034092307,
-0.2295142561,
-0.7060723305,
0.3864819407,
-0.1976453811,
-0.1716353297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14069v2 | Evaluating Factual Consistency of Summaries with Large Language Models | 2023-05-23T13:48:32 | 2023-10-12T06:20:42 | Shiqi Chen, Siyang Gao, Junxian He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting factual errors in summaries has been an important and challenging
subject in summarization research. Inspired by the emergent ability of large
language models (LLMs), we explore evaluating factual consistency of summaries
by directly prompting LLMs. We present a comprehensive empirical study to
assess the ability of LLMs as factual consistency evaluators, which consists of
(1) analyzing different LLMs such as the GPT model series and Flan-T5; (2)
investigating a variety of prompting methods including vanilla prompting,
chain-of-thought prompting, and a sentence-by-sentence prompting method to
tackle long summaries; and (3) evaluating on diverse summaries generated by
multiple summarization systems, ranging from pre-transformer methods to SOTA
pretrained models. Our experiments demonstrate that prompting LLMs is able to
outperform the previous best factuality systems in all settings, by up to 12.2
absolute points in terms of the binary classification accuracy on inconsistency
detection. | [
-0.1915607303,
-0.8720465302,
1.03307724,
0.4481284916,
-0.0508907251,
-0.002822455,
-0.4932729602,
-0.2206516266,
0.1158776358,
0.2079480141,
-0.4528106451,
-0.3261487782,
-0.7262173891,
0.6224472523,
-0.4234095514,
1.0667176247,
-0.2520096898,
-0.0155439675,
-0.4108013809,
-0.0322346799,
-0.6885962486,
-0.2030255795,
-0.3875809312,
-0.1470479518,
0.6633451581,
0.3162778914,
0.5303835273,
0.2990120947,
0.3643777668,
0.3746650517,
-0.1963704526,
0.6311335564,
-0.5770663619,
0.1944042891,
-0.0914748237,
-0.4251615107,
-0.3927406669,
-0.1403472871,
0.8626278639,
0.4656185806,
-0.2080502063,
0.2025069445,
0.1649481952,
0.4673972726,
-0.5164902806,
0.1622574925,
-0.6483683586,
-0.0569255836,
0.0483559519,
-0.1133582965,
-0.7250160575,
-0.7720191479,
0.0548455752,
-0.1390770078,
0.4145590663,
0.0854704604,
0.9027682543,
0.0571489707,
-0.5027874708,
-0.4124113321,
-0.7034729719,
0.5250382423,
-0.9503112435,
0.3460446,
0.1976917088,
0.0934382156,
-0.2034568638,
-0.5175867677,
-0.8055674434,
-0.4999444187,
-0.194785744,
0.2281519175,
-0.1924369931,
-0.1359818578,
0.4764448404,
0.2858040631,
-0.5198235512,
0.0954090357,
-0.2757197917,
-0.1828233004,
0.422765404,
0.1616524309,
0.3317976892,
-0.2322723418,
-0.2631373107,
0.0860895589,
-0.7344660163,
-0.0453856103,
0.2579013109,
0.2384411544,
-0.234691605,
0.8455432653,
-0.1644036025,
0.5129192472,
0.3328825533,
-0.3339740634,
-0.0006893046,
-0.5103526115,
-0.3538744748,
0.2554713786,
0.6623036861,
0.3782858551,
0.2920145988,
0.0562926531,
-0.3495023549,
-0.0418569446,
0.0472793207,
-0.5026416779,
-0.1782819331,
0.3919301033,
-0.1982929409,
-0.2154618353,
0.1648234278,
-0.4576726556,
-0.6189174056,
-0.4625510871,
0.7599690557,
-0.319441855,
-0.2888631821,
0.0732600316,
-0.0787190124,
0.2988965213,
0.6103723645,
-0.9844768643,
-0.0155631118,
0.7820573449,
0.961145103,
-0.0901747942,
-0.4114107788,
-0.6644603014,
0.0760043859,
-0.5795249343,
0.954451561,
-0.0082612019,
-0.3033145964,
0.0316596106,
0.0468107909,
-0.2690299153,
-0.5568301082,
0.4636762142,
-0.5308127403,
0.0838799998,
-0.7356681228,
-0.8357332945,
-0.132638678,
0.6252263784,
-0.562353313,
0.8029856682,
-0.1937620193,
-0.6601246595,
0.531024158,
-0.3240786791,
-0.2878835499,
-0.2649921775,
-0.1137603745,
-0.4290387332,
0.3103021979,
0.2885056138,
0.5056052804,
-0.0896951407,
0.6871926188,
-0.084613286,
-0.3590735793,
0.2538135052,
-0.7676978111,
0.6197496653,
-0.2565800548,
-0.2380041927,
0.2546548247,
-0.5231989622,
-0.3093664348,
0.0873835087,
-0.3710656762,
0.0080333659,
-0.1304110438,
-0.5122336149,
-0.0326092131,
0.2453579456,
-0.3733548224,
0.2783698142,
-0.1669628173,
-0.0836465955,
0.8155850768,
0.196066156,
-0.1509343535,
-0.4867485762,
0.3369243145,
0.0822627693,
-0.2450647056,
-0.7090154886,
-0.3147591352,
-0.8514134884,
-0.4292144477,
0.4360044301,
0.4522226751,
-0.4742814004,
0.6362002492,
-0.5198931098,
-0.374625206,
-0.0103495428,
0.0467509665,
0.2091695368,
0.5954864621,
0.1818480343,
0.2650800943,
-0.5951551795,
-0.6025897264,
-0.25413993,
-0.2536263466,
-0.1393895745,
-0.2719075978,
0.67402035,
-0.1643808335,
1.0088573694,
-0.2828319371,
0.2159364223,
-0.3710988164,
0.4015217721,
0.3363854289,
0.295853585,
0.3351536691,
-0.5395879149,
-0.5682556033,
-0.1347863525,
-1.0618072748,
-0.1480921209,
-0.0379784256,
0.3191904426,
0.3392795324,
0.4766936898,
-0.7979659438,
0.3783882856,
0.5430116653,
-0.1612038761,
0.9724789262,
-0.4309447706,
0.4473722875,
-0.6776148081,
0.1531016231,
-0.1933820546,
-0.4367953241,
-0.602257967,
-0.2057951987,
0.2909393311,
0.2709247768,
-0.1266538203,
0.3367471695,
-0.5625893474,
-0.078375496,
-0.1967799067,
0.2251015753,
0.073952876,
0.1438184083,
-0.0227397867,
0.6896209121,
0.3583598137,
-0.8157297969,
0.4023920596,
0.2787696421,
-0.4785622954,
0.6895421147,
-0.8052959442,
0.0286757406,
-0.4631735384,
0.4735991657,
-1.3422691822,
-0.5265547633,
0.0945729017,
-0.1925981939,
0.2921572924,
-0.1759088039,
-0.5469721556,
-0.2503572404,
-0.4508812726,
0.0580476969,
0.3788413703,
-0.7776477337,
0.7331232429,
-0.228585422,
-0.3843062222,
-0.701525867,
-0.2421548516,
0.2071308494,
-0.0249728933,
-0.6938679814,
-0.354054451,
-0.1527747363,
-0.4420831501,
-0.1626667529,
-0.3263335228,
0.3083767295,
-0.0940351039,
0.0560929365,
0.6034079194,
-0.4353041649,
0.0056088218,
-0.0580129102,
0.1452024281,
0.1493940651,
-0.1740582585,
0.3059534431,
-0.0927333087,
-0.5031068921,
-0.4885947406,
-0.1523807347,
0.5353492498,
-0.068731688,
0.7753442526,
0.3684411347,
-0.2085167766,
0.1344934106,
-1.012040019,
-0.1322048903,
-0.442668736,
0.1293248683,
-0.3206531405,
-0.8243501782,
0.6582573652,
0.082970418,
0.2393648624,
0.4382269084,
0.4900833666,
-0.1053728312,
0.926626265,
0.3873695135,
0.1912385821,
0.0368891619,
0.012756736,
0.0923461467,
-0.5129883885,
-0.2546204031,
-0.3312021792,
-0.0704056323,
-0.3098018765,
-0.2065336704,
0.6763606668,
-0.0511168316,
-0.1123634726,
-0.0925286412,
0.2174449563,
0.8597565889,
0.0918146446,
-0.014530899,
0.5333880782,
-0.0077703204,
-0.1510874778,
0.1303349584,
-0.5081204772,
-0.5848383307,
0.9245036244,
0.372834444,
0.6310093403,
0.3888421357,
0.3846521378,
0.3784728646,
0.5881051421,
-0.7653945088,
0.4567280412,
0.1397887617,
-0.4888410866,
-0.4260438681,
-0.4763869643,
-0.6539117694,
0.318320781,
-0.4435189664,
-0.6110926867,
0.0874747038,
0.2539786398,
-0.5555819869,
0.2461625934,
-0.5264530182,
0.6633489132,
-0.014842188,
-0.1761915684,
0.0257913396,
-0.5498452187,
0.8642645478,
-0.1390321553,
0.1593420804,
-0.1813956201,
0.0628383085,
0.4453954995,
-0.3153534234,
0.8607904315,
-0.1028742418,
-0.4977813959,
0.2684409022,
0.2719054222,
0.7981559634,
0.0563457906,
0.06810987,
0.0914253891,
-0.1129113361,
-0.2994721234,
-0.814044714,
0.4263647199,
-0.4365976155,
-0.737316072,
-0.580793798,
-0.3582972586,
-0.3784906864,
0.2592599094,
0.3419392109,
0.5774122477,
-0.3316011727,
0.1579012871,
1.0842622519,
0.0212182309,
0.3740851581,
0.7035874128,
-0.4439317882,
-0.1857697219,
0.6934953332,
0.1098167822,
0.3433901072,
0.2708561122,
0.4078164995,
-0.4698138833,
-0.6093331575,
-0.6316529512,
0.4842310846,
-0.6798289418,
-0.1616970301,
-0.6819831729,
-0.1570736021,
-0.4568635523,
-0.0250408351,
-0.1823567301,
-0.0362721942,
0.0533163883,
-0.4160924554,
0.1393457353,
1.1910104752,
-0.0589374453,
0.1200846732,
-1.075409174,
0.2689819038,
0.4398430586,
0.0660073161,
0.1687708944,
-0.806566596,
-0.0583733916,
-0.0926915184,
0.0951340124,
-0.829985857,
-0.033699479,
-0.1544959545,
0.3171138465,
0.6519753337,
-0.0010259567,
0.5747932196,
-0.6395183206,
0.9372122884,
0.2301381975,
-1.0884628296,
0.3328139484,
-0.5186551809,
0.3544381857,
0.4822621047,
0.3587574065,
-0.5884739161,
-0.5122417808,
-0.6181278825,
-0.4828576446,
0.4668652415,
0.0461987332,
-0.0434523076,
-0.0323485695,
0.297896713,
0.1311250925,
0.2815522552,
-0.5127215385,
-0.0570466891,
-0.0423632264,
-0.3156993687,
-0.1078057364,
-0.6195167899,
-0.2701702714,
0.1365697384,
0.6523306966,
-0.1825077087,
-0.1681219935,
0.3382892311,
-0.1579867303,
-0.0447995514,
0.2617824078,
1.0915398598,
1.1620466709,
-0.2099119276,
0.2862027287,
0.5103616714,
-0.3017654419,
0.344424516,
-0.173429504,
-0.2943790853,
0.2842573524,
0.5983617306,
0.6734613776,
0.3056681752,
-0.768070817,
0.677256763,
-0.1716804504,
-0.1065686718,
-0.2967033684,
0.0444049276,
0.0827291831,
0.0228366423,
0.3352162838,
0.0590091981,
-0.1303137094,
-0.5989140868,
0.0686565191,
0.249235034,
-0.0382301211,
-0.381842941,
0.4319375157,
-0.0585292876,
0.2079981863,
0.4453397989,
-0.2253528833,
-0.561739862,
0.5082187653,
0.5361737609,
0.610114634,
-0.2797117531,
0.2568022013,
0.4565828145,
0.4554975927,
-0.6865728498,
0.129975453,
0.1182441637,
-0.9159961343,
-0.5689960122,
-0.2791104913,
-0.6981246471,
0.0453513376,
-0.4700088203,
0.3811557293,
-0.4509267807,
0.1156614348,
0.0796500742,
-0.2656301558,
-0.2474734634,
0.280525893,
0.1470157206,
0.917719245,
-0.911613822,
0.2721393704,
0.4799799621,
-0.3118296862,
-1.057045579,
0.1994619817,
0.3557019532,
-0.6903800368,
0.4795934558,
0.0784304366,
-0.2610658109,
-0.248522073,
-0.6891776919,
-0.7771167755,
0.9655503035,
0.4364100397,
-0.6421210766,
0.0334568955,
-0.2294469774,
0.3110422492,
-0.0956673846,
0.4735033214,
0.6703518629,
0.7677245736,
0.2443378866,
-0.9625266194,
0.1432809532,
0.1803223938,
-0.2688021362,
0.0191496499,
-0.6429697275,
0.7075192332,
-0.4584290683,
-0.2061259598,
0.0753334463,
1.0218156576,
0.6145834923,
0.4794334769,
0.6448343396,
0.1829341054,
1.2069312334,
-0.1816342026,
0.8422765136,
-0.002268194,
0.2894770205,
1.0838873386,
-0.512683332,
0.6752188802,
0.0689841211,
-0.1815457046,
0.5885902643,
0.334625423,
-0.1006306931,
-0.0534729995,
-0.1353195161,
-0.3617775142,
-0.1802346706,
0.0487139337,
-0.2771528363,
0.3119754493,
0.1631750464,
-0.0887929574,
-0.1711480469,
-0.2295944244,
0.335744679,
0.0092537124,
-0.3315675855,
0.68543154,
-0.0038576792,
-0.8657211661,
0.6042265892,
-0.1726205349,
0.5144784451,
-0.8167186379,
0.0773283094,
-0.3220150173,
-0.1674023569,
-0.3345148563,
-0.6811686754,
0.1296189129,
0.321670711,
-0.3032385409,
0.0746105984,
0.6468312144,
-0.6161785126,
-0.3723544776,
-0.2792776525,
0.5339112282,
0.1125090346,
0.0794098824,
-0.0789718553,
0.2271919101,
-0.0046158833,
-0.1668056399,
0.0434921198,
0.6510159373,
0.0602244809,
0.4498670399,
0.6059629321,
0.1196145043,
-0.0987734944,
0.1175276786,
0.409786135,
-0.6489685774,
-0.4268101454,
-1.141065836,
0.4493277371,
-0.1354304254,
-0.080505833,
1.2086129189,
0.5434962511,
0.3796801567,
-0.2132219225,
0.8305007815,
0.0715720132,
0.4397295713,
-0.8691241145,
0.4930388331,
-0.1282708049,
0.2914021015,
-0.0311743077,
-0.9599865079,
-0.1305144876,
0.2596076131,
-0.3756667674,
0.0723390952,
0.7363370657,
0.7091550827,
-0.0696736127,
0.4172773659,
0.3779232204,
0.6202260852,
0.2428625524,
-0.0371965766,
1.1689945459,
-0.0204151124,
0.2077321857,
0.3190923035,
-0.2506868541,
-0.3138573468,
-1.1808074713,
-0.8434081674,
-0.1229463145,
-0.3329193592,
-0.6142513752,
0.109983772,
1.1001131535,
0.1921274513,
-0.958437562,
-0.1344820857,
0.1106412336,
0.3299016654,
-0.18931669,
-0.1705684811,
0.3577991426,
-0.4075983167,
-0.6933585405,
0.5696083307,
0.3789375126,
0.2171130776,
-0.2880132198,
0.1742851883,
-0.093953535,
0.3123403788,
0.6304435134,
0.3034038842,
-0.668408215,
-0.4720152915,
-0.1609300524,
-0.0355837867,
0.0110631008,
0.8663285971,
-0.3762501776,
0.2910411656,
0.6076084971,
0.5120846033,
0.188874796,
0.3604049683,
0.6316304207,
-0.6914879084,
-0.2769830525,
-0.023145169,
0.4384417832,
0.4439946115,
-0.2919057012,
0.3392767012,
0.2415741086,
-0.6179938912,
-0.8964460492,
-0.0080062011,
-0.8134243488,
0.089572303,
1.1518560648,
-0.3254168332,
-0.1284713894,
-0.091733925,
-0.217877537,
0.0166512281,
-0.2178929597,
0.7436824441,
0.9268912077,
-0.1522328556,
0.0589280501,
-0.4313639998,
0.4276913702,
0.3228677213,
-0.6196601391,
0.3362086415,
0.6872348785,
0.5512193441,
0.30550915,
0.749415338,
0.1295353174,
0.3387336433,
-0.0918902382,
-0.2957749367,
0.0643325597,
-0.3925926387,
-0.5160773396,
-0.0121187046,
-0.0713038817,
0.3863464892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14066v2 | One-stop Training of Multiple Capacity Models | 2023-05-23T13:44:09 | 2023-05-24T09:37:47 | Lan Jiang, Haoyang Huang, Dongdong Zhang, Rui Jiang, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Training models with varying capacities can be advantageous for deploying
them in different scenarios. While high-capacity models offer better
performance, low-capacity models require fewer computing resources for training
and inference. In this work, we propose a novel one-stop training framework to
jointly train high-capacity and low-capactiy models. This framework consists of
two composite model architectures and a joint training algorithm called
Two-Stage Joint-Training (TSJT). Unlike knowledge distillation, where multiple
capacity models are trained from scratch separately, our approach integrates
supervisions from different capacity models simultaneously, leading to faster
and more efficient convergence. Extensive experiments on the multilingual
machine translation benchmark WMT10 show that our method outperforms
low-capacity baseline models and achieves comparable or better performance on
high-capacity models. Notably, the analysis demonstrates that our method
significantly influences the initial training process, leading to more
efficient convergence and superior solutions. | [
-0.6707556844,
-0.3122554123,
0.5067285299,
0.2670555711,
-0.2916602194,
0.0580303073,
-0.3001562059,
-0.2051942945,
-0.0076360605,
0.5184844732,
-0.7763289809,
0.0529822111,
-0.8800538182,
0.0388132632,
-0.1883220971,
0.6360062361,
-0.2596712708,
0.5297201276,
-0.3501310349,
-0.7407080531,
-0.7499714494,
-0.1112724915,
-0.6945640445,
-0.4048593938,
0.688297689,
0.4831793308,
0.3537100852,
0.4663403034,
0.4081405997,
0.2654763162,
0.2121021599,
0.3289384246,
-0.3816371858,
-0.0513873547,
0.0680984184,
-0.2918003201,
-0.176894486,
0.119181551,
0.7215203643,
0.9691860676,
-0.2125606835,
0.3403714895,
0.3020419478,
0.5740260482,
-0.7914736867,
0.0719010606,
-0.4981142879,
0.2829794586,
-0.0311659779,
-0.055208452,
-0.6558597088,
0.0521915853,
0.0248828959,
-0.8220051527,
0.1551139802,
0.157322675,
0.7200341225,
0.4132145345,
-0.6364986897,
0.3243008554,
-0.6722303629,
1.0816348791,
-0.583321631,
0.6172404289,
0.1168891117,
0.478127867,
0.4107530415,
-0.5389865041,
-0.667958498,
0.0871369615,
-0.197379142,
0.3210059404,
0.1410706341,
0.0143293068,
0.3611356914,
-0.0310175102,
-0.5211212635,
0.0938394591,
-0.620550096,
0.1935698092,
0.2444877774,
-0.1034504846,
0.060609892,
0.2930896282,
-0.9235897064,
-0.151795283,
-0.3322254717,
-0.3979132175,
-0.087363109,
0.5310029387,
-0.3229846954,
0.1945161521,
-0.2566054463,
0.4651634395,
-0.1315151453,
-0.2713370025,
0.1283426583,
-0.1061922535,
-0.2393086553,
0.031419497,
0.8638978601,
-0.1247890815,
-0.1223227978,
-0.5616187453,
-0.1457433701,
-0.2820033431,
0.4387490153,
-0.7379409075,
0.283775866,
0.0073310472,
-0.4114747047,
-0.0979587659,
0.0933284685,
-0.4091604352,
-0.1505918056,
-0.5817751288,
0.7500802875,
-0.443783313,
-0.5276039839,
0.227787897,
-0.0928236172,
-0.1371754557,
0.0561749786,
-0.737180829,
0.3367238641,
0.3686556518,
1.340906024,
-0.2454287857,
-0.6957086325,
-0.6112630367,
0.3418003321,
-0.1937622726,
0.4557163715,
-0.0348215103,
-0.029300252,
0.0377421081,
-0.1290276647,
-0.434704423,
-0.1707137525,
0.1699859947,
-0.6194115281,
0.1030636802,
-0.506816864,
-0.2982749939,
-0.2312769741,
0.5676854849,
-0.9820675254,
0.9918468595,
0.3872014582,
-0.8258235455,
0.7052704096,
-0.9189562201,
-0.5276449919,
-0.0164642092,
-0.1181046218,
-0.5282987952,
0.040922042,
0.1021480113,
0.377374351,
-0.5768889785,
0.2089623511,
-0.4461294413,
-0.1586164683,
-0.0444288775,
-0.5499400496,
0.7387989759,
0.2906089723,
0.1193922386,
0.0456990786,
-0.7712835073,
0.0169024561,
0.1388982534,
-0.5938922763,
-0.2270877063,
-0.4288496673,
0.2504931986,
0.5349194407,
0.2461614311,
-0.5147177577,
0.4559135139,
-0.0595143698,
0.4496704936,
0.2560403645,
-0.0356282964,
0.6079283953,
-0.4508291483,
0.5906460881,
0.1785561293,
0.1324784756,
-0.1448722035,
-0.1796782911,
-0.7303821445,
-0.2324021608,
0.3127219379,
0.4740662873,
-1.0657067299,
0.1961717606,
-0.3188749552,
-0.3314955831,
-0.4753976762,
0.0951981172,
0.4319716692,
0.45089674,
0.8048698306,
-0.408690691,
-0.6293711662,
-0.6266412139,
0.0902368873,
0.0792663842,
0.1675696224,
-0.1120495573,
0.590608418,
0.3509555757,
0.9114763141,
-0.1967273951,
-0.3026790023,
-0.6926178336,
0.1997380704,
0.1032998413,
0.6840960383,
0.6932641864,
-0.8575434685,
-0.7336274981,
0.0600403473,
-0.9081268907,
0.3131734133,
-0.4633526802,
-0.3444798291,
-0.0830075666,
0.328807205,
-0.6269031167,
0.0972969979,
0.5902972221,
0.1803128868,
0.2853063345,
-0.3441853523,
0.3772606254,
-1.3869791031,
0.205955714,
-0.3187624514,
-0.0466844663,
-0.6606730223,
-0.116571106,
0.1204468012,
-0.2590031326,
-0.5896977782,
0.4897961915,
-0.5517711043,
-0.3434329331,
-0.0151558882,
-0.1710590273,
0.404029429,
0.583353281,
-0.0382715389,
0.7855781317,
0.4432669878,
-0.6009420753,
0.1140724719,
0.5149059296,
-0.2914404869,
0.4366042316,
-0.3536383808,
-0.1263129115,
-0.0116412556,
0.2122025341,
-0.9200236797,
-0.3815571964,
0.0311380234,
0.0621181093,
0.5035601258,
-0.4767122269,
-0.4846764207,
-0.5344547033,
0.1309036314,
0.539860785,
0.1191176996,
-0.6671241522,
0.6747609377,
0.23053509,
0.3639838398,
-0.7334294319,
-1.211599946,
-0.1929950863,
-0.3225220144,
-0.5378952622,
0.2630388141,
0.3062371016,
0.3874557614,
-0.1624673158,
-0.312522769,
-0.5116301775,
0.0439202823,
0.1439191848,
0.1751527041,
-0.0395932943,
0.36396873,
0.2744012177,
-0.1364131272,
-0.3697073758,
-0.8324075341,
0.7540761828,
0.0542142317,
-0.5705519915,
-0.520106554,
0.5588613749,
0.5793142319,
-0.4335005879,
1.2551366091,
0.8230177164,
-0.3790339828,
-0.0205787513,
-0.5409497619,
-0.0975980982,
-0.3624092042,
0.3623985648,
-0.6595249772,
-0.4851505756,
0.3726409078,
0.0054098051,
0.2253871262,
0.3151406348,
0.4606903195,
0.1129568666,
0.8278613091,
0.7240105867,
-0.0655688271,
0.5561522245,
-0.6274697781,
0.1093644202,
-0.5289687514,
-0.2025444508,
-0.3554055393,
-0.2480064332,
-0.149778232,
-0.3844397068,
0.5646557212,
0.4432499409,
-0.4339221418,
0.816328764,
-0.4091427028,
0.5208626986,
0.5173844099,
0.2748160958,
0.3573293388,
0.1993202865,
-0.3037772775,
0.2392226309,
-1.4283833504,
-0.2046197355,
0.9537827969,
0.2460346073,
0.32882303,
0.0257967729,
0.7986539006,
0.0841277614,
0.3707831502,
-0.7017822266,
0.1417967975,
-0.3085535765,
-0.787586689,
-0.4551911354,
-0.6315615773,
-0.5166680217,
0.5247633457,
-0.3276587129,
-0.4726525545,
0.0817062706,
0.257707864,
-0.4038430154,
0.8098204136,
-0.766418457,
1.1518012285,
-0.1516487747,
-0.4166580737,
-0.3662016988,
-0.605527997,
0.4744548202,
-0.076954633,
0.1160794124,
-0.1357804537,
0.0168541092,
0.7428500056,
-0.4685225189,
0.6032335162,
-0.4877232611,
0.1644950062,
0.4209691584,
-0.0946507975,
0.2568389773,
0.0336480625,
-0.2929345071,
0.3283246756,
0.2646579444,
-0.7424079776,
-0.332085371,
0.1100389659,
-0.650310874,
0.0543061979,
-0.31180951,
-0.775380075,
-0.5153252482,
0.5963203907,
0.5363000035,
0.3095396459,
-0.1552060097,
0.2363961488,
0.4067126513,
-0.076869525,
0.534543097,
0.2870912254,
0.1891245097,
-0.3932230771,
0.6486601233,
0.2649330795,
0.6158941984,
0.4467453361,
0.049436193,
-0.2534989119,
-0.4366535544,
-0.7271066308,
-0.0013665642,
-0.6040854454,
-0.1864163429,
-0.7155429721,
-0.1578988135,
-0.3417681754,
-0.0863569081,
-0.8008071184,
-0.3570782542,
0.1207447425,
0.338106364,
0.0183214489,
0.4628615975,
-0.117829293,
0.7326951623,
-1.1170018911,
0.0674999282,
0.1742239445,
0.3761497736,
0.2897813618,
-0.4428432584,
-0.8878130317,
-0.0816874877,
-0.3966971338,
-0.6538667083,
0.1087209731,
0.2052961886,
0.3867364228,
0.5232471228,
0.0001651947,
0.6924288273,
-0.4280921817,
0.4173210859,
0.7716329098,
-0.6411114931,
0.1142897457,
-0.15604195,
0.5595000982,
0.9225842953,
0.7149163485,
-0.5233297348,
0.117412962,
-0.1924379468,
-0.5193273425,
0.9365518689,
0.0135918511,
-0.1167126745,
0.1688356251,
0.1990310252,
0.163472563,
0.2893872559,
-0.4056696296,
0.1824347228,
-0.1442510635,
-0.0744405687,
0.3164634407,
-0.109380357,
-0.2387385964,
-0.076563336,
0.8722430468,
-0.3470380902,
0.1307064146,
-0.3128013015,
-0.2432460934,
-0.1695862263,
0.3100604117,
0.1804768741,
0.6795325875,
0.0052531413,
-0.1738543957,
0.6588233709,
-0.3220220506,
0.3347735405,
-0.0664026216,
-0.0660424978,
-0.17705293,
0.6574004292,
1.0943216085,
0.2913658321,
-0.1748298258,
0.5139909387,
-0.083118178,
-0.5325259566,
-0.0090376064,
-0.0989919379,
0.0587939732,
0.3631973565,
0.1710825562,
0.4077004492,
-0.1052684486,
-0.2647261322,
0.2764230072,
0.1666579098,
-0.2786473632,
0.0295532625,
0.7019149661,
0.0219065323,
0.3484880328,
0.5475352407,
-0.4597192407,
-0.4361779988,
0.4583560526,
0.4163482785,
0.7258962393,
0.0208934117,
0.1315262467,
0.7198250294,
0.0210860558,
-0.6471864581,
0.1053768396,
-0.3310379982,
-0.8083705306,
-0.7779870033,
-0.8820903301,
-0.3393563628,
0.1498301327,
-1.0611457825,
0.3134225607,
-0.2374288291,
-0.1639288217,
-0.2076194435,
0.0511629768,
-0.8126059175,
0.110515371,
-0.0847787634,
0.8136950731,
-0.8020368814,
1.0444850922,
0.4841548502,
-0.7215547562,
-0.6735401154,
-0.083541587,
-0.0684810579,
-0.452249825,
0.4423893392,
0.4970539212,
0.1391612291,
0.0886708871,
-0.2725414932,
-0.7545168996,
1.3381236792,
0.3110002279,
-0.9140124321,
-0.3429452181,
0.2235237807,
0.0534484833,
-0.4729986191,
0.0093398718,
0.7197881937,
0.3496229947,
0.2571790218,
-0.9715347886,
-0.1380321532,
0.368773073,
0.2199409902,
0.2488889992,
-0.7434155941,
0.757073164,
-0.228567183,
-0.3786607683,
0.1225885823,
0.4604286253,
0.3251862824,
0.2455875725,
0.842641294,
0.7738288045,
0.4742070735,
-0.1251237839,
0.781673193,
-0.5868275166,
0.683414042,
1.3938928843,
-0.2871693075,
0.7185646296,
0.4703796506,
-0.3106530011,
-0.0681994259,
0.4037598372,
-0.0781533644,
0.5929119587,
-0.1389243007,
-0.5286391377,
-0.5881558061,
-0.0672387853,
-0.2801048756,
0.4201224148,
-0.0399915539,
0.0080569182,
-0.4095474482,
0.6366279721,
-0.173553735,
-0.1800219119,
0.0419743508,
0.5435839295,
0.1310212761,
-0.7361197472,
0.6217771769,
0.0077451039,
0.3062233329,
-0.6407891512,
0.241289705,
-0.087379165,
0.2278854847,
-0.0334103331,
-0.4232873917,
0.3952780962,
-0.1655797511,
-0.3780893385,
-0.5578722358,
0.4968915582,
-0.644341588,
-0.3353583515,
0.3720723689,
0.7061117887,
-0.0239643976,
-0.1081173867,
-0.6315236688,
-0.0172837656,
-0.2568930387,
-0.2329765409,
0.3001877069,
0.4399276376,
0.0480684638,
0.6071720719,
0.5780437589,
0.0545144752,
0.0778806731,
0.2155820727,
0.7545995712,
-0.2648063302,
-0.6321784854,
-0.586881876,
0.5625717044,
-0.1362119168,
-0.2687578201,
0.1197987571,
0.5879278779,
1.0146843195,
-0.179159835,
1.0510137081,
-0.4686171114,
0.2859577537,
-0.6829555035,
0.7975155115,
-0.8347730041,
0.1372027993,
0.2868770957,
-0.865662396,
-0.1176672876,
0.4098569453,
-0.2164776772,
0.1688864529,
0.7438644767,
0.4915991724,
-0.4977649152,
-0.2576810122,
0.4060520828,
-0.089020662,
0.1790105104,
0.7320094109,
0.4271257222,
-0.6813349724,
0.722533524,
-0.3151163757,
-0.0661288425,
-0.0313514136,
-0.6537982225,
-0.9826515317,
-0.6949718595,
-0.0593728721,
-0.3158046305,
-0.1351402253,
0.9070355892,
1.155174613,
-0.7028355598,
-0.0952690691,
-0.335308671,
-0.2819258571,
-0.4034812748,
-0.1419464797,
0.2396784872,
-0.7000553608,
-0.4445300996,
0.4627706707,
0.3427338004,
0.0765642077,
-0.567685008,
-0.4057523906,
-0.5398882031,
-0.0349103473,
0.6258705258,
0.2724243999,
-0.3234196901,
-0.0199616551,
-0.4490911067,
-0.1550005972,
0.034386605,
0.8759014606,
-0.6004111171,
0.4346978068,
0.562035799,
0.9083453417,
1.0767593384,
-0.2054371238,
0.3189781308,
-1.1517446041,
0.6425278187,
-0.1526001841,
0.3509618938,
0.1867084652,
0.1008744463,
0.8069967628,
0.3775307834,
-0.2025669068,
-0.7491005659,
0.2538614869,
-1.0229688883,
-0.1773217171,
0.7320778966,
-0.3530213237,
0.1771232784,
0.1039566323,
0.0802111104,
0.8085331917,
-0.1029373258,
0.5480983257,
0.797962606,
0.1761734635,
-0.3269192576,
-0.8837018609,
0.2358903438,
0.4332379401,
-0.8215216398,
-0.2245728076,
-0.040984381,
0.1187032312,
0.233354032,
0.4464586377,
0.174048245,
0.1790502369,
0.3690400422,
0.0305302758,
-0.4183056355,
-0.8068603873,
-0.0764330328,
0.2667622566,
-0.1641027182,
-0.4325369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14057v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14057v1 | Can Language Models Understand Physical Concepts? | 2023-05-23T13:36:55 | 2023-05-23T13:36:55 | Lei Li, Jingjing Xu, Qingxiu Dong, Ce Zheng, Qi Liu, Lingpeng Kong, Xu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Language models~(LMs) gradually become general-purpose interfaces in the
interactive and embodied world, where the understanding of physical concepts is
an essential prerequisite. However, it is not yet clear whether LMs can
understand physical concepts in the human world. To investigate this, we design
a benchmark VEC that covers the tasks of (i) Visual concepts, such as the shape
and material of objects, and (ii) Embodied Concepts, learned from the
interaction with the world such as the temperature of objects. Our zero
(few)-shot prompting results show that the understanding of certain visual
concepts emerges as scaling up LMs, but there are still basic concepts to which
the scaling law does not apply. For example, OPT-175B performs close to humans
with a zero-shot accuracy of 85\% on the material concept, yet behaves like
random guessing on the mass concept. Instead, vision-augmented LMs such as CLIP
and BLIP achieve a human-level understanding of embodied concepts. Analysis
indicates that the rich semantics in visual representation can serve as a
valuable source of embodied knowledge. Inspired by this, we propose a
distillation method to transfer embodied knowledge from VLMs to LMs, achieving
performance gain comparable with that by scaling up the parameters of LMs 134x.
Our dataset is available at \url{https://github.com/TobiasLee/VEC} | [
-0.3761988282,
-0.852658391,
0.8548865318,
0.0064660679,
-0.4421703219,
0.1964857429,
-0.1352566034,
-0.6505699158,
0.0214911234,
0.4155060649,
-0.4692045748,
-0.3507932723,
-0.5063593984,
0.0153216552,
-0.4703104794,
0.4310185015,
-0.1858925819,
-0.0783694535,
-0.3418999612,
-0.1731936038,
-0.4818965793,
-0.5173442364,
-0.2038601786,
-0.5211068988,
0.3991862535,
0.2057228386,
0.5766657591,
0.6526942253,
0.3221466839,
0.3687029481,
-0.2886475325,
0.2419333756,
-0.4716495275,
-0.0479340404,
-0.2724115252,
-0.56535393,
-0.3295468688,
-0.1443035007,
0.7116085291,
0.7985242605,
-0.1982977539,
0.1479203552,
0.074157469,
0.6324585676,
-0.7521160841,
0.1606466621,
-0.7195899487,
0.1631698906,
-0.0117554571,
-0.1207338646,
-0.386122942,
0.1479259282,
0.1479865909,
-0.7192054987,
0.1636689901,
0.1890276819,
1.0939879417,
0.3536902368,
-0.2720384002,
0.0791316703,
-0.7475424409,
0.6554988027,
-0.3987913132,
0.5089488029,
0.3412128091,
0.4269638658,
0.1643372923,
-0.7249261141,
-0.8583680987,
-0.2572263181,
0.0801404268,
0.0826263577,
-0.2200636417,
-0.0346526653,
0.4236578047,
0.3622516394,
-0.3771514893,
0.0513793007,
-0.6141702533,
-0.0570715256,
0.5244776607,
0.3995996714,
0.4001584053,
-0.1066353098,
-0.5977708697,
-0.3273408115,
-0.501518786,
-0.1690101922,
-0.1905478388,
0.2003756762,
-0.2431171089,
0.6677690148,
-0.1732784063,
0.8707593679,
-0.069379203,
-0.0227074847,
0.3558085263,
-0.4122827649,
-0.279435575,
-0.0688214749,
0.5187937617,
0.4608696997,
0.3437521458,
-0.0634926781,
0.0430767648,
0.0125004044,
0.56375283,
-0.9559727907,
-0.203453213,
-0.0898222178,
-0.226885438,
-0.1251373887,
-0.0573257357,
-0.3676427305,
-0.4331121743,
-0.8024578094,
0.6500294209,
-0.3263534606,
-0.4143089056,
0.4869030416,
-0.4173795581,
0.3555348516,
0.5276972055,
-0.9100012183,
0.6621222496,
0.6782818437,
1.0737584829,
-0.0230664108,
-0.3391324878,
-0.0224066433,
0.1794908196,
-0.3607860208,
0.7274799943,
-0.3676021099,
-0.5564312935,
-0.24276191,
-0.0301368758,
0.2233166248,
-0.5597373247,
0.2870477736,
-0.1062724516,
-0.2299062163,
-0.5045176148,
-0.5201553106,
-0.0156420469,
0.0934845805,
-0.4888499677,
0.9971331954,
-0.1062153503,
-0.8021631241,
0.5534662008,
-0.2633212507,
-0.2336401492,
0.171912089,
-0.3834594786,
-0.1194699407,
0.5904576778,
-0.0079310788,
0.4761990905,
-0.4062399864,
-0.0083703399,
-0.4407970309,
-0.2505221665,
0.327708602,
-0.3683928549,
0.2021493465,
0.3401000202,
-0.1442324817,
-0.1880752444,
-0.833378613,
0.0274844915,
0.1456833631,
0.020215394,
-0.6169355512,
0.0455329046,
-0.0943006575,
0.0108280657,
0.2136484683,
-0.5308775306,
0.2973726988,
-0.179840222,
0.4440259337,
0.6790322661,
-0.2373543531,
0.6611317992,
-0.0736189634,
0.1074551344,
0.0415697172,
0.0092158569,
-0.1263728142,
-0.3042910397,
-0.8311208487,
-0.4249088764,
-0.3323906958,
0.2111424208,
-0.9360425472,
0.2320643663,
-0.3185397089,
-0.644959867,
-0.3093960285,
0.1468649507,
0.354177326,
0.6731274724,
0.4034744501,
-0.1985118538,
-0.2567437589,
-0.8501338959,
-0.2716108859,
-0.3938519657,
-0.4164434075,
0.384696126,
0.3932695985,
0.07768289,
0.8934335113,
-0.783395946,
-0.0121071702,
0.0821285918,
0.4097684324,
0.1738625765,
0.143079415,
0.6379877329,
-0.8002722263,
-0.2704563439,
0.3865203559,
-0.9627601504,
-0.1926617771,
0.2675640881,
-0.1630859524,
-0.1039723903,
0.397992909,
-0.3209011555,
0.4947444201,
0.3446624577,
-0.4741688669,
0.4144504964,
-0.6040723324,
0.237671867,
-0.9758595824,
-0.0137209911,
0.2846621871,
-0.2143531144,
-0.6150417328,
-0.0691736117,
0.1922077984,
-0.0446684398,
-0.7789856791,
0.9348949194,
-0.589277029,
-0.1409882456,
-0.4913864732,
0.1396434158,
0.3392158747,
0.3839311302,
0.5786980391,
0.4671055973,
0.6969858408,
-0.9450085759,
0.4254058301,
-0.1111830547,
-0.3714754283,
0.9350000024,
-0.9316805601,
0.1515842974,
-0.3024009168,
-0.134914577,
-0.8261522651,
0.0215962287,
0.0954458863,
-0.2957253158,
0.3345675468,
-0.1062147319,
-0.4367086887,
-0.3248827755,
0.0003495757,
0.3364658356,
0.640401125,
-0.3361129761,
0.8141325116,
0.3877259791,
0.1346548945,
-0.3228242099,
-0.8915917277,
-0.0160357468,
-0.2505506575,
-0.4696436226,
0.1942474246,
-0.1370268613,
-0.4848533571,
-0.0397055782,
-0.2235770971,
-0.2877520025,
0.0528074577,
0.3351541162,
0.301638931,
-0.1874180138,
0.222573474,
-0.1242126077,
-0.0289330613,
0.0631185025,
-0.4394174814,
0.2115723342,
-0.2261338681,
-0.4779794812,
-0.4756835401,
-0.0711921602,
0.7417901754,
0.0859746784,
0.7457377911,
0.4855668247,
-0.5040462613,
-0.0651535988,
-0.5044265985,
-0.2907672524,
-0.4827567637,
0.4515366554,
-0.8026182652,
-0.6363780499,
0.4900587499,
-0.163170144,
0.001423199,
0.2746304572,
0.6560838819,
-0.2710860968,
0.7203890681,
0.7358100414,
0.0233519655,
0.55313766,
-0.35374403,
-0.1415825337,
-0.7162892222,
-0.3022561669,
-0.7156711817,
-0.4595951438,
-0.385651648,
-0.9067556858,
0.3260447979,
0.1855446845,
-0.2707509398,
0.5423759818,
-0.5256282091,
0.4156348705,
0.2734658122,
0.297415942,
0.3586599231,
0.1328222454,
-0.1378448308,
-0.0994056612,
-0.51804775,
-0.4725715518,
0.7905099392,
0.4225915372,
1.1191859245,
-0.0292191692,
0.5349849463,
0.3137386143,
0.2143699825,
-0.6021926403,
0.4217496812,
-0.1054206342,
-0.5977628827,
-0.4824499786,
-0.3731971681,
-0.5128237605,
0.5367847085,
-0.0831128955,
-1.0199922323,
0.2891062796,
0.244305402,
0.0578067079,
0.4577435553,
-0.7947531343,
0.7780013084,
-0.5073720217,
-0.8119283319,
-0.4210082889,
-0.5286457539,
0.1720922887,
0.022405507,
0.3987895846,
-0.3351306319,
-0.1711814851,
0.4194829464,
-0.6391433477,
0.9091008306,
-0.186048016,
-0.3048828244,
0.3949932158,
0.1267451048,
0.1669236273,
-0.1844438761,
-0.0425103083,
0.3438382447,
0.1446904391,
-0.6502638459,
-0.9583336711,
0.3406792283,
-0.8291406035,
-0.3846225441,
-0.2868314087,
-0.2214362621,
-0.1050101072,
-0.0497153029,
0.0574187897,
0.2337861061,
-0.3995645046,
0.1064766943,
0.8186243773,
-0.0362826921,
0.0499543361,
0.7700573802,
-0.3821134567,
0.0117346365,
0.9244816899,
0.0596688725,
0.5685697198,
0.692384541,
0.3724197447,
-0.403700918,
-0.3528990448,
-0.4929356277,
0.1161717698,
-0.6556873918,
-0.0138495304,
-0.5119172931,
-0.1374187022,
0.0659204945,
-0.1356005073,
-0.4884439707,
-0.0719729438,
-0.2786311209,
-0.2709736526,
0.6196203828,
0.7996125221,
-0.1361041516,
0.1230300963,
-0.8011419177,
0.6384648681,
0.3269649148,
0.2000731081,
0.0288808178,
-0.8815796375,
-0.2432367653,
0.4394365847,
0.0026495121,
-0.4945407212,
0.316804558,
0.2796876132,
0.5655118823,
0.4221413136,
-0.0376587771,
0.9581330419,
-0.6451941133,
0.6651515961,
0.5096806288,
-1.1540213823,
0.6112385988,
0.0433462001,
0.4980906546,
0.4325805306,
0.4964338541,
-0.6911761165,
-0.1203678697,
-0.4814188778,
-0.5688230395,
0.4830764532,
0.1525746733,
0.4789776802,
0.0947213918,
0.4269197583,
0.1486485153,
0.1895994693,
-0.3707273006,
-0.1466143727,
-0.2040243596,
0.0035247786,
-0.1226149276,
-0.1894881427,
0.1665282547,
-0.48374632,
0.2503299713,
-0.2926921844,
-0.1573821902,
0.2520991564,
-0.1643784791,
0.0141160935,
-0.1131882891,
0.5915999413,
0.6558568478,
-0.1330794245,
0.4807194471,
0.3699967563,
-0.4945841432,
0.2092874199,
-0.4647141993,
0.0827998593,
-0.0271409117,
0.4253698289,
1.0603837967,
0.522675097,
-0.6427356601,
0.219279781,
-0.2893162668,
-0.2713013291,
0.1499203444,
0.0804863647,
0.1802415848,
0.216694206,
0.2815920115,
-0.2356286347,
0.0386093855,
-0.7807103395,
0.1764486432,
0.1984010935,
-0.5215706825,
-0.6209851503,
0.6783242822,
0.29895854,
-0.0301053729,
0.4576074481,
0.2825236022,
-0.2616304755,
0.5075544119,
0.1946904957,
0.7469727397,
0.0362933688,
0.1768683493,
0.4795146585,
0.182047084,
-0.1069860756,
0.3381120265,
-0.5253911018,
-0.9491277933,
-0.3186453879,
-0.8379390836,
-0.473872304,
-0.3070352674,
-0.6943151355,
0.4309597015,
-0.4323582947,
-0.1533594131,
0.1550941914,
-0.1754033715,
-0.9546670318,
0.1482443064,
0.4683171213,
0.7604427338,
-1.0111205578,
0.7973226309,
0.6397426724,
-0.5977991819,
-0.7312554717,
-0.4342928529,
0.0468900427,
-0.9651425481,
0.9633567929,
-0.2741719186,
-0.3411280513,
-0.2246409655,
-0.5931231976,
-0.6122630835,
1.0424097776,
0.5409184694,
-0.8322464824,
0.0027869763,
0.2321895063,
0.8020333648,
-0.0605462492,
0.4751576781,
0.3251376152,
0.5012171865,
0.6522448063,
-1.2723299265,
-0.1981772631,
-0.1669743359,
0.1198612154,
-0.0530489869,
-0.6009112597,
0.7631605268,
-0.2258075774,
-0.238527596,
-0.0253315885,
0.7126569748,
0.2292680442,
0.3865804076,
0.2866101861,
0.6311101317,
0.6592644453,
-0.0140825631,
1.06051898,
-0.0455478616,
0.3304528296,
1.0733040571,
-0.5716234446,
0.880659163,
0.6571078897,
-0.4155043662,
0.2186398655,
0.3887734413,
0.3457009494,
0.4669883847,
0.7258527875,
-0.2872156501,
-0.3376353681,
-0.2337589115,
-0.3530141115,
0.3995061815,
0.5345886946,
-0.0948648825,
-0.1894112676,
0.2446967214,
-0.1921756566,
0.2864029109,
-0.3093892634,
1.0734198093,
0.3476949632,
-0.2286401838,
0.8026779294,
-0.3369757831,
0.4923236072,
-0.6736990809,
-0.1637448668,
-0.1111786067,
0.1421917081,
0.029571278,
-0.9731596708,
0.140533343,
0.0181335639,
-0.2236963511,
-0.317553848,
0.8168472052,
-0.3493687809,
-0.5988695621,
0.2272661179,
0.5686724186,
0.595012784,
-0.1561353803,
-0.4530867934,
0.4884237945,
-0.3636169732,
0.1007291824,
0.2614173293,
0.9411172271,
0.0518634617,
0.7929864526,
0.287374258,
0.2627381682,
0.1780411154,
0.2283850312,
0.8631239533,
-0.6292914152,
-0.1824121773,
-0.8733347654,
0.4819441438,
-0.2432235628,
-0.0980030522,
0.5038349032,
0.3745976388,
0.9787845612,
-0.190566197,
0.6756089926,
-0.0399002694,
0.1012092978,
-0.6964356303,
0.6961940527,
-0.7147372961,
-0.0326337926,
-0.3728593588,
-0.9302912951,
-0.0095090754,
0.624319911,
-0.1860108972,
-0.104981713,
0.5804365873,
0.4619569778,
-0.0970241725,
-0.264390856,
0.8318448663,
0.1256253272,
0.2571036816,
0.2794925272,
0.9650081992,
-0.2842358053,
0.0013895642,
-0.2139959484,
-0.1994030774,
-0.1720300019,
-0.9310984612,
-0.7704120278,
-0.7615391016,
-0.5048665404,
-0.0366369784,
0.1375206858,
0.5044317245,
1.0013626814,
-0.3317809105,
-0.3590859473,
-0.1637038589,
-0.0141097968,
-0.1400243491,
-0.1626344174,
0.0606065206,
-0.1593501866,
-0.8571017385,
0.1190378964,
0.5446896553,
0.222841382,
-0.4264111519,
-0.1858650893,
0.0143185016,
0.0544220917,
0.7311777472,
0.3915446997,
-0.8297075629,
-0.4525497258,
0.066397205,
0.029273482,
-0.0826831162,
1.0462568998,
-0.9653869271,
0.7638543248,
0.5465427637,
0.5095459223,
0.8400216699,
-0.1440700591,
0.6364616752,
-0.7360274792,
0.4305885732,
0.0089622084,
0.5241602659,
0.1443484873,
-0.0471653789,
0.404919982,
0.3452677131,
-0.0777940899,
-0.7206618786,
0.1820258349,
-1.0573447943,
-0.4597713351,
0.9762628675,
-0.0474639796,
-0.6450204253,
0.1988346428,
-0.506557107,
0.1261333078,
-0.0501608662,
0.6222165227,
0.6629270911,
0.0415947661,
-0.3593743742,
-0.4838209748,
0.1414594203,
0.1996827722,
-0.7802304029,
0.3212031126,
0.505253911,
0.2835917771,
0.1480827034,
0.4544047415,
0.0922176093,
0.0012265996,
0.1554311514,
0.3245186806,
0.0088958871,
-0.2521885335,
0.0103004249,
-0.2340632677,
0.2846772075,
-0.2715209723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14049v1 | Rethinking Speech Recognition with A Multimodal Perspective via Acoustic and Semantic Cooperative Decoding | 2023-05-23T13:25:44 | 2023-05-23T13:25:44 | Tian-Hao Zhang, Hai-Bo Qin, Zhi-Hao Lai, Song-Lu Chen, Qi Liu, Feng Chen, Xinyuan Qian, Xu-Cheng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Attention-based encoder-decoder (AED) models have shown impressive
performance in ASR. However, most existing AED methods neglect to
simultaneously leverage both acoustic and semantic features in decoder, which
is crucial for generating more accurate and informative semantic states. In
this paper, we propose an Acoustic and Semantic Cooperative Decoder (ASCD) for
ASR. In particular, unlike vanilla decoders that process acoustic and semantic
features in two separate stages, ASCD integrates them cooperatively. To prevent
information leakage during training, we design a Causal Multimodal Mask.
Moreover, a variant Semi-ASCD is proposed to balance accuracy and computational
cost. Our proposal is evaluated on the publicly available AISHELL-1 and
aidatatang_200zh datasets using Transformer, Conformer, and Branchformer as
encoders, respectively. The experimental results show that ASCD significantly
improves the performance by leveraging both the acoustic and semantic
information cooperatively. | [
-0.2394542396,
-0.3306125998,
0.1352332979,
0.3349416852,
-0.4020506144,
-0.0043208529,
-0.3817811012,
-0.6677433848,
0.2697673738,
0.3301840425,
-0.5569526553,
-0.4800572693,
-0.733653307,
0.149380967,
-0.2719581723,
0.658221662,
0.0484059229,
0.2282730788,
-0.2207393199,
-0.4205642641,
-0.3973803818,
-0.4986148775,
-0.8777110577,
-0.2336825877,
0.5480971932,
0.2051019073,
0.3895608485,
0.5922976732,
0.3140577078,
0.3201883137,
0.1278364062,
0.3566511571,
0.0485550575,
0.0604698323,
0.1348163486,
-0.0381586999,
-0.3765270412,
-0.0491261818,
0.6046993732,
0.5603177547,
-0.1731033623,
-0.0969748273,
0.0714358389,
0.238793239,
-0.7447835803,
0.6444234848,
-0.2878777683,
0.0770585313,
-0.0883256197,
-0.2178494334,
-0.4151876271,
0.0741752014,
0.1385688484,
-0.7105502486,
0.0248390138,
-0.1698654443,
0.3558285832,
0.4991827011,
-0.4740031362,
-0.5120295882,
-0.720035851,
0.6969901919,
-0.3399738073,
1.0067267418,
0.4938380122,
0.2377519459,
0.2910107374,
-0.4871802926,
-0.7551339865,
0.0964720845,
-0.0225272328,
0.4381301403,
-0.2841405869,
0.252895534,
-0.1503413916,
0.3223439157,
-0.4069378972,
-0.0601401292,
-0.2567877769,
-0.6699951291,
0.64570117,
-0.0114137772,
0.2250166833,
-0.0428506583,
-0.5744371414,
-0.4332180619,
-0.161299184,
0.3535486758,
-0.0560160801,
0.3516465724,
-0.5392079353,
0.4785257876,
-0.0644197017,
0.6322337389,
0.117124714,
-0.4430856407,
0.3902885616,
-0.6173278093,
-0.0202345904,
0.7123781443,
0.6972463727,
0.1848010868,
-0.1226111948,
-0.516046524,
-0.1515437067,
0.8015791178,
0.0147019979,
-0.3471138775,
-0.1868859231,
0.2035582066,
-0.4364938438,
0.1095109805,
0.0371065065,
-0.3841842115,
0.1982903332,
-0.6544924974,
0.4961867332,
-0.4598232508,
-0.1771327406,
0.4884670973,
-0.2639378607,
0.1870559454,
0.3390999138,
-0.6401911378,
0.4823696315,
0.5663070679,
0.5982297659,
0.0010342571,
-0.2731438279,
-0.7638035417,
0.5555955768,
0.1559875607,
0.6622351408,
-0.708814621,
-0.3883870244,
-0.207292065,
-0.0465908274,
-0.1076879576,
-0.2923308611,
0.5714091063,
-0.5755044222,
-0.1281502843,
-0.0127908261,
-0.4552825987,
-0.3481485248,
-0.0116023431,
-0.7538496256,
0.1741919667,
-0.3402819037,
-0.7029057145,
0.3521471322,
-0.5242551565,
-0.5874078274,
-0.1393448412,
-0.3510825932,
-0.4936847091,
-0.2105662078,
0.3328373134,
0.1511425376,
-0.3333921731,
0.1837921143,
-0.0902380049,
-0.0479749553,
0.2284165919,
-0.5755044222,
0.6863477826,
0.3704282939,
-0.1501784176,
0.0680247322,
-1.012507081,
-0.1523402035,
-0.3595224619,
-0.5269156098,
-0.2862798274,
-0.1154992804,
0.3152619898,
0.2892631888,
0.176211834,
-0.8511521816,
-0.5409062505,
-0.2925360799,
0.3249585629,
0.5799731612,
-0.0187570341,
0.7374390364,
-0.332164377,
0.1772934347,
0.2624371052,
-0.0074677304,
-0.0151883774,
-0.4007151127,
-0.5645250678,
-0.7458853722,
0.1949211657,
0.3393411338,
-0.8591398001,
0.5575557351,
-0.094371371,
-0.2485567331,
-0.9825572968,
0.0513403825,
0.83486408,
0.4308396876,
0.4737848639,
-0.5576247573,
-0.4219580889,
-0.6451670527,
-0.1237189472,
-0.1283235252,
-0.1376980692,
0.4337608814,
-0.135168165,
-0.2596288025,
0.9788320661,
-0.191716522,
-0.9359964728,
-0.0055228886,
-0.0011530652,
0.0006665834,
0.5780059695,
0.0437652916,
-0.8789483309,
-0.1761370301,
0.0659810752,
-0.6850235462,
0.1674766243,
0.1235120818,
0.0787937939,
0.0660820231,
0.3888333738,
-0.592805028,
0.2892409861,
0.6160157323,
-0.3381239176,
0.072952643,
-0.3203098178,
0.0258619469,
-0.8240460753,
-0.2341141552,
-0.3019534647,
0.0280319434,
-0.5833882093,
-0.1945704371,
0.0604530126,
-0.2349556983,
-0.1955640316,
0.1427636296,
-0.6127412319,
-0.2457915246,
-0.0198644213,
0.1229546517,
0.140112251,
0.5918685198,
0.3364129961,
0.4098339975,
0.7068284154,
-0.5391702056,
0.4768004417,
0.4928201437,
0.0717926621,
0.5044316649,
-0.6531784534,
0.3470652401,
-0.1946639717,
0.6229099631,
-0.7200995088,
-0.2479350418,
0.073731713,
-0.6160693765,
0.4277343154,
-0.0065763826,
-0.3860839903,
0.043077752,
-0.2029015422,
0.8175269961,
0.283560127,
-0.5766228437,
1.001127243,
0.6764671803,
-0.030535629,
-0.4282956719,
-0.7414944172,
-0.1236812174,
0.0266460702,
-0.9831034541,
0.3714886904,
0.0912251025,
-0.0246215723,
0.1675450057,
-0.3557672501,
-0.0262389705,
-0.3854576349,
0.4300806522,
0.0970943123,
-0.229042381,
0.197315976,
-0.0153030911,
-0.5191929936,
0.0446746498,
-0.4472359121,
0.3873663545,
0.069191277,
-0.4049254358,
-0.819434762,
0.6950250864,
0.4401965439,
-0.7893292308,
0.4638446569,
0.789203763,
-0.3808734417,
0.0268910993,
-0.6350367069,
-0.3311312497,
-0.4560877383,
0.0594547987,
-0.3584688008,
-1.1287660599,
0.4891333282,
0.133814171,
-0.2800606787,
0.1101828218,
0.4831632376,
0.0035124556,
0.5875594616,
0.5611839294,
-0.1470122784,
0.2111056596,
-0.2538692653,
0.2001527995,
-1.0200101137,
-0.7445750237,
-0.4682899117,
-0.0818254352,
-0.4234280288,
-0.6133415103,
0.7013781667,
-0.1557389349,
0.027342068,
0.1318094879,
-0.4057714641,
0.1934266984,
0.5978347063,
0.4637062252,
0.4638454914,
0.0167528093,
0.1321189702,
0.067971386,
-0.6332728267,
0.0310490429,
0.8811963201,
0.1204306111,
0.9678708911,
0.2097831964,
0.7304615974,
0.1370993704,
-0.4973750114,
-0.6017605662,
0.3705807924,
-0.2375296652,
-0.1995329708,
-0.4007143676,
-0.3154759109,
-0.8264900446,
0.2546690106,
-0.1065422297,
-0.1549373865,
0.7068419456,
0.130566746,
-0.4273077548,
-0.2203729004,
-0.7343127131,
0.5842409134,
0.1788074076,
-0.3330106437,
-0.560553968,
-0.9252945781,
-0.0360972434,
-0.0858281255,
0.4623217583,
0.046122063,
-0.0990310386,
0.8141573071,
-0.2501022518,
0.7300570607,
-0.2718870938,
-0.0298421644,
0.1906533837,
-0.2282654643,
0.4898127615,
0.2486711442,
0.0625596792,
0.3008453846,
-0.3292093575,
-0.1024105623,
-0.3811378479,
0.6697496772,
-1.0122445822,
-0.2409861088,
-0.2875596583,
-0.7175837159,
-0.2270257622,
0.0103053357,
0.1229552031,
1.0605678558,
0.1518203467,
0.2453397214,
0.6288742423,
-0.0897882506,
0.5248147249,
0.536973536,
0.4334637523,
-0.5975304842,
0.9296476245,
0.0370519534,
0.4206265211,
0.5024550557,
-0.0173866302,
-0.5567356348,
-0.2523296475,
-0.3146217167,
0.17565009,
-0.7855094075,
-0.2638682723,
-1.1001316309,
-0.3409764171,
-0.5374504924,
-0.3095694184,
-0.4210821688,
-0.3126606345,
-0.2686105371,
0.1468691826,
0.4860590994,
0.2637165189,
-0.598292172,
-0.1757796705,
-0.7114423513,
0.8045529127,
0.7189763188,
0.0668049455,
0.0627710074,
-0.1801934391,
-0.0927497521,
0.159244135,
0.1045622677,
-0.3917255104,
0.2753917277,
0.5552893877,
0.3783823848,
0.3127767742,
0.551360786,
0.6377889514,
-0.5579891801,
0.3731502891,
0.3672742844,
-0.9139905572,
0.3647950888,
0.003662619,
0.3828894794,
0.2445998341,
-0.0109639,
-0.4062562585,
-0.5698819757,
-0.3973411918,
-0.7542486787,
1.0841691494,
0.2556324601,
-0.1368657798,
0.0523929037,
-0.3139996529,
0.0042007761,
0.0281356592,
-0.3273418546,
-0.1571391225,
-0.5452471972,
-0.3293486238,
-0.2257372439,
-0.1994348466,
-0.1735738069,
-0.2415180355,
0.1660582721,
0.1126199812,
0.4092332423,
0.5295709372,
-0.1394229084,
-0.0289289448,
0.3336129487,
0.3221407235,
-0.0723346844,
-0.0291531887,
0.4883553386,
-0.0177433826,
-0.4572075605,
0.3210736513,
0.2057150751,
0.3280347884,
0.0849393234,
0.5138311386,
0.7023298144,
0.545532763,
-0.4208006263,
0.7365896106,
-0.1347962469,
0.095796451,
-0.4587092698,
-0.0682526082,
0.2781417072,
0.55819875,
0.1558379382,
0.4728171527,
0.6105100513,
-0.4873838127,
0.4496369958,
0.3223647475,
-0.3469832838,
-0.3664029837,
0.7300934792,
0.3732373714,
-0.2493856102,
0.5842881203,
-0.0827992484,
-0.3598124981,
0.4371413589,
0.6007891297,
0.7474241257,
-0.4541607499,
-0.0824516416,
0.1345092803,
0.0163497888,
0.24844639,
0.2613748014,
-0.7896187305,
-0.9761712551,
-0.372264564,
-0.715152204,
-0.3140799105,
-0.5120039582,
-1.004770875,
0.2234617472,
-0.2518332303,
0.1697822362,
0.1956271678,
-0.4356282651,
-0.4386191368,
0.2555058002,
0.1245779768,
0.3762968183,
-0.5099253058,
1.0611619949,
0.3894971311,
-0.2916972041,
-0.8947281241,
-0.209260717,
0.0839175954,
-0.7154371738,
0.6037956476,
0.0852222666,
-0.7373144627,
0.186025843,
0.0519865379,
-0.7020938396,
1.1407684088,
0.3331945539,
-0.5593314171,
-0.088268742,
0.0185776707,
0.2312028557,
-0.3291125298,
-0.174629584,
0.3072839081,
0.3148249686,
0.4079143703,
-1.2470936775,
-0.1374378949,
-0.3071814179,
0.055416856,
-0.0622441806,
-0.6713086963,
0.7976393104,
-0.2624720037,
-0.3362755775,
-0.3578028083,
0.5155777335,
0.2005896419,
0.5800562501,
0.5344006419,
0.5271111727,
0.2386181951,
0.0043263147,
1.0735342503,
-0.2096628696,
0.1549227387,
0.9780958891,
-0.2035449892,
0.8510292172,
0.3715418875,
0.0141222868,
0.1223262474,
-0.0143301534,
0.2623552084,
1.2252271175,
-0.384637922,
-0.7305393815,
-0.4720542729,
-0.4573185444,
-0.3736464083,
0.9295589924,
0.2935531437,
-0.0215428416,
-0.4096139371,
0.4931415915,
-0.0845226943,
0.1425849795,
-0.3792852461,
1.2281975746,
0.2606127858,
-0.0491441078,
0.4046797156,
-0.0195054151,
0.7412034869,
-0.6392043233,
-0.1952411532,
0.1569963396,
0.417365104,
-0.2610459924,
-0.3768345714,
0.3969259262,
-0.2395503819,
-0.3261241317,
-0.2020223737,
0.7928414345,
-0.9791765809,
-0.2109945863,
0.5908018351,
-0.0011766555,
-0.1440556943,
0.0528023429,
-0.1997755766,
0.6891877055,
-0.165130347,
0.5272060633,
0.1257465929,
0.5335255265,
0.1334506422,
0.4644564092,
0.8377132416,
-0.0914170295,
0.1789129674,
0.0424234644,
1.116494298,
-0.3395852745,
-0.9383925796,
-0.5154350996,
0.4966337383,
0.1239300445,
0.130536139,
0.8002301455,
0.4268417358,
1.0171159506,
-0.1238029748,
0.5710582733,
0.1299856752,
0.3577836156,
-0.6857280731,
0.8898236156,
-0.2473036349,
0.0743277594,
-0.3762794435,
-0.4809767306,
-0.4023549259,
0.8792937398,
0.2258812338,
-0.1788445711,
0.4551059008,
0.6549787521,
0.0066726338,
0.4409709871,
0.3407222331,
0.2234745175,
0.2780601978,
0.656480372,
0.8496029377,
-0.555757165,
0.3595208526,
-0.4151038826,
-0.2966251671,
-0.078490749,
-0.3236180246,
-0.6388027668,
-0.8430996537,
-0.3123826683,
-0.0561661832,
0.1294030696,
0.8787908554,
0.6971995234,
-0.6746394038,
-0.1581698209,
0.0930841118,
-0.1418120414,
-0.0544442087,
-0.1106907129,
0.4907498658,
-0.2455944717,
-0.470205605,
0.496093452,
0.6430794001,
-0.1967152506,
0.0315172561,
-0.499438554,
0.0137227019,
-0.1857417822,
0.6006986499,
-0.0861108527,
-0.8311076164,
-0.5133162737,
-0.2370791584,
0.1646223515,
-0.0505658798,
0.786119163,
-0.7335643768,
0.7600533366,
0.1245344281,
0.7073968649,
0.5664368868,
-0.3049935102,
0.586375773,
-0.6695409417,
0.6273179054,
0.3459299803,
0.2053533643,
0.2546524704,
-0.1522886604,
0.1136605516,
0.2920462191,
-0.2966490686,
-0.5413489938,
0.0841035247,
-1.3940736055,
0.1784723997,
0.9256260991,
-0.3471154571,
-0.1582683176,
-0.5690603852,
-0.1520363688,
0.4212742746,
-0.7790611386,
0.4408000708,
0.4096378088,
-0.0845653787,
-0.3486206234,
0.1183770001,
0.4033454359,
-0.0033010615,
-0.3698706031,
0.1476367265,
0.6695673466,
0.1257061213,
0.3321926296,
0.6983718276,
-0.3948714733,
0.7378273606,
0.4217967689,
0.1445339471,
-0.2958607674,
-0.5603879094,
-0.4655223489,
0.1635279208,
-0.1854392737,
-0.5416570902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14045v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14045v2 | The CoT Collection: Improving Zero-shot and Few-shot Learning of Language Models via Chain-of-Thought Fine-Tuning | 2023-05-23T13:14:59 | 2023-10-14T10:46:55 | Seungone Kim, Se June Joo, Doyoung Kim, Joel Jang, Seonghyeon Ye, Jamin Shin, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) with less than 100B parameters are known to perform
poorly on chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning in contrast to large LMs when
solving unseen tasks. In this work, we aim to equip smaller LMs with the
step-by-step reasoning capability by instruction tuning with CoT rationales. In
order to achieve this goal, we first introduce a new instruction-tuning dataset
called the CoT Collection, which augments the existing Flan Collection
(including only 9 CoT tasks) with additional 1.84 million rationales across
1,060 tasks. We show that CoT fine-tuning Flan-T5 (3B & 11B) with CoT
Collection enables smaller LMs to have better CoT capabilities on unseen tasks.
On the BIG-Bench-Hard (BBH) benchmark, we report an average improvement of
+4.34% (Flan-T5 3B) and +2.60% (Flan-T5 11B), in terms of zero-shot task
accuracy. Furthermore, we show that instruction tuning with CoT Collection
allows LMs to possess stronger few-shot learning capabilities on 4
domain-specific tasks, resulting in an improvement of +2.24% (Flan-T5 3B) and
+2.37% (Flan-T5 11B), even outperforming ChatGPT utilizing demonstrations until
the max length by a +13.98% margin. Our code, the CoT Collection data, and
model checkpoints are publicly available. | [
-0.5722647309,
-0.8093875647,
0.6591014266,
-0.3977905512,
-0.2776663899,
0.2805759311,
-0.4905219376,
-0.3533465862,
-0.2152804881,
0.6410636306,
-0.5971457362,
-0.6246663332,
-0.6623151898,
-0.1119745374,
-0.2696281374,
1.001978159,
0.0172675923,
-0.1199903488,
0.3153574169,
-0.1133943796,
-0.5527458787,
-0.0987129658,
-0.6778251529,
-0.1284743994,
0.664526403,
0.8856754899,
0.6376010776,
0.6178088784,
0.318055898,
0.1728843898,
-0.106223084,
0.6457140446,
-0.8644708991,
-0.1056290567,
-0.4098500907,
-0.6803330183,
-0.5009000301,
-0.1246901229,
0.4017933607,
0.4009437859,
0.0665782392,
0.2214705944,
-0.0660226047,
0.873411119,
-1.1468129158,
0.031418696,
-0.8879285455,
-0.0991175994,
-0.1553864628,
-0.1727534831,
-0.6588649154,
-0.0555868149,
-0.0038620753,
-0.5555006862,
0.3002409041,
0.1708076,
0.846587956,
0.1245466694,
-0.2481191307,
-0.2729833722,
-0.7927445769,
0.9808943868,
-0.6711567044,
0.2324463129,
0.5301637053,
0.3648135364,
-0.1578128338,
-0.3976496458,
-0.516518712,
-0.0832717344,
0.127058953,
-0.0776476637,
0.0087900283,
0.1933371723,
0.3243989348,
0.2817578316,
-0.4805155098,
-0.0343890451,
-0.5709983706,
0.0011461176,
0.6883733273,
0.1961264461,
-0.0192430429,
0.0893996581,
-0.2804046869,
-0.2250265777,
-0.8782306314,
-0.1800698638,
-0.0397695042,
0.6050820351,
-0.2354785502,
0.3412710726,
-0.3103619516,
1.0599654913,
0.1282598823,
-0.1906270385,
-0.0560685545,
-0.3516573608,
-0.4403038025,
0.0398319587,
0.6254412532,
-0.1221670881,
0.3525132239,
0.0790103152,
-0.3812057972,
0.0492314734,
0.0893608928,
-0.6191129088,
-0.3030122221,
0.2175784856,
-0.0621182211,
-0.2369948924,
-0.1034793109,
-0.4858548045,
-0.2662731707,
-0.515435338,
0.5302315354,
-0.6720309854,
-0.1309748292,
0.2623974681,
0.1011624262,
0.3418194652,
0.487773329,
-0.9320967793,
0.3648153543,
0.8151535988,
0.9347714186,
0.0108492682,
-0.2514385581,
-0.7358081341,
-0.0070733624,
-0.7377426624,
1.023617506,
-0.5952384472,
-0.2160260826,
-0.1199126542,
-0.1371820718,
-0.4156611264,
-0.4062900245,
0.2132027149,
-0.250153929,
-0.0418234132,
-0.3667595983,
-0.7176772952,
0.0940126404,
0.3773685694,
-0.5075169206,
0.8751983643,
0.1798727512,
-0.3336078227,
0.1703759432,
-0.4289364815,
-0.268604219,
-0.0336879976,
-0.3635590672,
-0.1190289557,
0.2351195961,
0.2911204398,
0.4049248695,
-0.3846498132,
-0.1586401016,
-0.1347064376,
-0.6756833792,
-0.0637795627,
-0.4228363037,
0.6400642991,
0.3770702183,
-0.5262563229,
0.0170687195,
-0.7370887399,
0.3546196222,
-0.0417836048,
-0.0169539321,
0.0133806774,
-0.2917895615,
-0.3186002374,
0.323679775,
-0.0322357789,
-0.3781727552,
0.169537738,
-0.5840904117,
0.1133817658,
0.6471782923,
0.0669983402,
0.4591894746,
-0.4917227328,
0.6664491892,
0.2608520985,
0.2193342,
-0.2484205365,
-0.3956126869,
-1.012953639,
-0.2953130007,
0.3668424785,
0.2499757856,
-0.9387198091,
0.256544143,
-0.1803808361,
-0.4654241502,
-0.5753753185,
0.429115206,
0.7607283592,
0.3825002313,
0.4950360954,
-0.2169050425,
-0.2035882622,
-0.61247015,
-0.1373800039,
0.0752417967,
0.1069313958,
0.3749235272,
0.4438771009,
0.0800144076,
0.7711774111,
-0.4695539176,
-0.3882965147,
-0.5318569541,
0.2873879969,
0.0388186797,
0.3926631212,
0.3443857729,
-0.2429024279,
-0.5125238299,
0.1530031115,
-0.3693148196,
0.2414509058,
-0.0954543576,
-0.3659472466,
0.5176272988,
0.3005566299,
-0.532679379,
0.5442305207,
0.3447189629,
-0.2935661376,
0.3833430111,
-0.2095347047,
0.1168823466,
-0.8664521575,
-0.2004373074,
-0.2683992088,
-0.3677066863,
-0.4813171625,
0.0833201483,
0.1367889643,
-0.075332962,
-0.7896098495,
0.4768064618,
-0.4292043746,
0.1182425097,
-0.6182178259,
0.7555961013,
0.1640749127,
0.7399283051,
0.0120199686,
0.684299171,
0.6294513345,
-0.6994376779,
0.059622664,
0.0869351029,
-0.4031409323,
0.2337617278,
-0.3617705405,
0.4759243727,
-0.150197506,
0.2171712518,
-0.6542111039,
-0.0049163937,
0.1363508254,
-0.216726169,
0.4138085544,
-0.1593216062,
-0.3120100796,
-0.0904969275,
-0.3256717622,
0.2758834362,
0.5407743454,
-0.5775476694,
0.2954695821,
0.0709209889,
0.2893835902,
-0.6648999453,
-0.6919341683,
-0.2554892302,
0.2352173626,
-0.2581041157,
0.0609453321,
0.1281176656,
-0.0732220337,
-0.0494952202,
-0.4775838554,
0.0991765931,
-0.1494761109,
-0.133237198,
0.1882663369,
-0.4676952064,
0.4432631135,
0.0355991609,
-0.1444438249,
-0.3824855983,
-0.3819305003,
0.6977869868,
-0.436827451,
-0.3185430467,
-0.1647949815,
0.0297507718,
0.2904853523,
-0.2996478081,
0.9781475663,
0.5549251437,
-0.3226210475,
-0.6544023752,
-0.3952305019,
-0.212339133,
-0.4446611106,
0.0270950906,
-0.5578941703,
-0.9094057083,
0.2263307124,
-0.1051110253,
0.0722202584,
0.418066144,
0.4613128006,
-0.0122954622,
0.9267993569,
0.5290797353,
-0.1731948406,
0.4679419994,
-0.7681638002,
0.3859254718,
-0.8351972699,
0.0473799556,
-0.5410942435,
-0.3963993788,
-0.6109828949,
-0.6658076644,
0.1720126867,
0.4664110541,
-0.4923768938,
0.588457644,
-0.4929875135,
1.0322226286,
0.4123520553,
0.4804109931,
0.3207628429,
-0.2324171662,
-0.1103194803,
0.5249494314,
-0.9521833658,
-0.7040376663,
1.1836327314,
0.0583592728,
0.8083769083,
0.0237421859,
0.9007098079,
0.1164818332,
-0.0042116297,
-0.748223424,
0.5447825789,
-0.292198807,
-0.7284451127,
-0.3736581206,
-0.3752155006,
-0.7697663307,
0.0769336075,
-0.1056503057,
-0.9262751937,
0.2699894905,
0.5237065554,
-0.5341374278,
0.3734318018,
-0.85124892,
0.8402904868,
-0.2364445627,
-0.6076279283,
-0.561506927,
-0.5840860009,
0.487179637,
0.1118717715,
0.1136282086,
-0.4040491283,
0.0552790314,
0.3244650662,
-0.5749177933,
0.7540380955,
-0.0746722743,
-0.1122476012,
0.6350173354,
0.3001560867,
0.5488033891,
-0.0620342754,
-0.0416582786,
-0.0444499403,
0.3506113291,
-0.7224633098,
-0.8103132248,
0.9047651291,
-0.6209923029,
-0.576212883,
-0.3666346669,
-0.4873803556,
-0.4395262301,
0.1416046917,
0.215222463,
0.6366336942,
0.0599190146,
0.2308283001,
0.7804585099,
-0.0084386598,
0.3692989051,
0.3568855524,
-0.1929363012,
-0.1499782801,
1.0874018669,
0.0014960904,
0.7978875041,
0.5943469405,
0.2394442856,
-0.0135720856,
-0.292658329,
-0.5885916352,
0.0752275661,
-0.7425752878,
-0.5138918757,
-0.2549874187,
-0.1943529248,
-0.2032925338,
-0.1873264313,
-0.6339328885,
-0.5806750655,
-0.1514743268,
-0.0199577231,
0.5415768623,
0.6898338199,
0.2867471874,
0.4808455706,
-0.598182857,
0.3669250906,
0.1049039215,
0.5418794155,
0.0609801076,
-0.5969108343,
-0.4465929866,
0.4147801995,
-0.5720909238,
-0.5114589334,
0.0881339982,
0.2803196311,
0.0311390217,
0.4134374559,
0.1570251584,
1.0688877106,
-0.4643006325,
0.7290445566,
0.0693326294,
-1.1345643997,
0.7425248623,
-0.2786268294,
0.5691560507,
0.8308031559,
0.2169220448,
-0.1665200591,
-0.4280405343,
-0.7521956563,
-0.4678599834,
1.1049706936,
0.2806624174,
-0.0722873807,
-0.2020993829,
0.2514493167,
-0.0586406142,
0.0401574112,
-0.3217552304,
-0.0747098252,
-0.0285658222,
-0.3812212348,
-0.2320360094,
0.0872870386,
-0.0558998547,
-0.3320025206,
0.9365330338,
-0.4283657372,
0.2020821273,
0.1215706319,
-0.3090124726,
-0.2996929884,
0.4418863356,
0.829567492,
0.7876606584,
-0.2101861835,
0.1500094384,
0.4257706106,
-0.2786686122,
-0.0894974619,
-0.3660347462,
-0.0194790382,
-0.0827270895,
0.3802259266,
1.2270776033,
0.4358908236,
-0.8940582275,
0.472345829,
0.0628033653,
-0.1499584168,
-0.0397178195,
0.5926598907,
-0.019541109,
0.1313927472,
-0.1155366376,
0.1998374462,
-0.1873498112,
-0.613075614,
0.0918163955,
0.3654051721,
-0.348180145,
-0.0762420669,
0.3094116151,
-0.0117162215,
-0.4285007715,
0.4943585992,
-0.1860993654,
-0.1392661482,
0.5944095254,
0.6102993488,
0.8110923171,
0.0913964659,
0.3209692538,
0.391226083,
0.3775382042,
-0.202489078,
0.350563854,
-0.4279999733,
-0.7602938414,
-0.2639223933,
-0.5923944712,
-0.609048903,
0.2006507069,
-0.6096752286,
0.7005239725,
-0.7462258339,
0.1091281548,
-0.185306415,
0.195271343,
-0.8415467143,
0.2419933528,
0.1708842069,
1.0480080843,
-0.5115946531,
1.0347964764,
0.2306542099,
-0.5333875418,
-1.0876054764,
0.0295109134,
-0.0315775163,
-0.7237989306,
0.1933467984,
0.0473043099,
-0.5356387496,
0.1202927828,
-0.5361488461,
-0.7731608748,
1.2229862213,
0.5047882199,
-1.1730781794,
0.0806956142,
0.1181160361,
0.6495411992,
-0.5806875229,
0.4408184886,
0.9012932181,
0.1062213778,
0.2367183119,
-0.7967374325,
-0.2536650598,
0.1100798175,
-0.0106946202,
0.4046830535,
-0.780302465,
0.6675872803,
-0.262172401,
-0.1141875312,
0.0858712122,
0.2972893715,
0.5321750045,
0.2967822552,
0.397439301,
0.3925805688,
0.766366303,
-0.0570228249,
1.162473321,
-0.422305882,
0.4134381413,
1.3827426434,
-0.2808302939,
1.08786273,
0.2747399509,
0.0105721727,
0.6628805399,
0.3868506253,
0.3974121511,
0.3617369831,
0.1800990701,
-0.4883180261,
-0.4236209691,
0.0736144185,
-0.0611693263,
0.4720055759,
0.5064623356,
-0.273206234,
-0.1980368793,
0.0769003481,
-0.0376993455,
0.092226088,
-0.4898866713,
0.8999788165,
0.2486142069,
-0.6560397744,
1.1013400555,
-0.1537134051,
0.3251554966,
-0.5721717477,
-0.0161143281,
-0.240742594,
0.4857131541,
-0.140130505,
-0.445559293,
0.1220387667,
0.2319077402,
0.0350276306,
-0.0335148014,
0.7749462724,
-0.5334213376,
-0.6064167023,
0.1805785447,
0.5045149922,
0.2022456229,
0.1888007522,
-0.5992565751,
0.2191569358,
-0.0776180699,
-0.2359671444,
0.3287247419,
0.4609709382,
-0.1560834199,
0.5935375094,
0.2984862328,
0.2038090676,
0.1059546173,
0.4521687925,
0.8518761992,
-0.7859303951,
-0.1361938715,
-0.717647016,
0.3302369714,
-0.0336552821,
-0.5180903077,
0.3528362513,
0.48411116,
1.2288466692,
-0.1596626937,
0.5754442215,
-0.0830271319,
0.4903051555,
-0.6504614353,
0.460100174,
-0.4431443214,
0.3951994777,
-0.1321640611,
-0.6712179184,
-0.1882811189,
0.6290842295,
-0.3855943978,
0.0777416527,
0.9889674783,
0.9844284654,
-0.1913536042,
0.228171289,
0.5695477724,
0.1192439124,
0.207923606,
0.8355814219,
0.5281652808,
-0.7451042533,
0.5330001712,
-0.5914536119,
-0.1980198771,
0.074058041,
-0.7145450711,
-1.1055674553,
-0.3712270558,
-0.3099317849,
-0.0806483254,
0.3689332306,
1.2530483007,
0.7636480331,
-1.2227584124,
-0.2762642801,
-0.6225660443,
0.2744434476,
-0.335918963,
-0.1864591688,
0.3600036204,
-0.8659839034,
-0.7044669986,
0.4347730279,
0.3396335542,
-0.3126626611,
-0.1096245646,
-0.2955122292,
-0.4641569853,
0.3282461464,
0.7355321646,
0.3511396646,
-0.7991425395,
-0.513502717,
-0.0040258183,
-0.0461942777,
-0.0802056715,
0.8667453527,
-1.0186623335,
0.5023003817,
0.3773277998,
0.5416330099,
0.7079604864,
-0.0944148079,
0.5120014548,
-0.8940019011,
0.2072199732,
0.2917988896,
0.3132936656,
0.009364049,
-0.2081979513,
0.4929350019,
0.0033901753,
-0.5222341418,
-0.8072769642,
0.2434587032,
-0.9578598142,
-0.2614368498,
0.9490709305,
-0.0610665046,
-0.3111801147,
0.0200272426,
-0.3602543175,
0.3000911772,
-0.2515455186,
0.7345481515,
0.6084825993,
-0.3054171205,
-0.5369727612,
-0.2854721546,
0.5254144073,
0.5917231441,
-0.7719228268,
0.1676015705,
0.3158880174,
0.1205851734,
-0.0182334743,
0.5692247152,
-0.1551493704,
0.532761395,
-0.0189967062,
-0.2167993337,
-0.0987420827,
-0.6904017925,
-0.3390831053,
-0.1091081947,
0.250017792,
-0.2326783538
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.