id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15033v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15033v2 | SmartTrim: Adaptive Tokens and Attention Pruning for Efficient Vision-Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:18:00 | 2024-02-26T15:26:20 | Zekun Wang, Jingchang Chen, Wangchunshu Zhou, Haichao Zhu, Jiafeng Liang, Liping Shan, Ming Liu, Dongliang Xu, Qing Yang, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite achieving remarkable performance on various vision-language tasks,
Transformer-based Vision-Language Models (VLMs) suffer from redundancy in
inputs and parameters, significantly hampering their efficiency in real-world
applications. Moreover, the degree of redundancy in token representations and
model parameters, such as attention heads, varies significantly for different
inputs. In light of the challenges, we propose SmartTrim, an adaptive
acceleration framework for VLMs, which adjusts the computational overhead per
instance. Specifically, we integrate lightweight modules into the original
backbone to identify and prune redundant token representations and attention
heads within each layer. Furthermore, we devise a self-distillation strategy to
enhance the consistency between the predictions of the pruned model and its
fully-capacity counterpart. Experimental results across various vision-language
tasks consistently demonstrate that SmartTrim accelerates the original model by
2-3 times with minimal performance degradation, highlighting the effectiveness
and efficiency compared to previous approaches. Code will be available at
https://github.com/kugwzk/SmartTrim. | [
-0.2245521545,
-0.5430372357,
0.3129584193,
0.3186824322,
-0.5628913045,
-0.0022782444,
-0.3264586627,
-0.2188541889,
0.2192969024,
0.4899860322,
-0.4315189123,
-0.2755868137,
-0.5844560266,
-0.0232292432,
-0.4928790629,
0.9677584171,
0.1243026853,
-0.0486994348,
-0.4314523339,
-0.5919789672,
-0.7155612111,
-0.3289729357,
-0.4669403732,
-0.0390564799,
0.5652446151,
0.5070626736,
0.568013072,
1.0594689846,
0.938818872,
0.3917788863,
-0.1087486222,
0.1235298589,
-0.3451236486,
0.0159207042,
-0.256381005,
-0.5013868809,
-0.6161452532,
-0.301450938,
0.6831464767,
0.3321076035,
-0.2922635972,
0.4695752859,
0.0030940794,
0.7596259117,
-0.8294984102,
0.1432878077,
-0.8035419583,
-0.064511627,
-0.0759453699,
-0.0257057324,
-0.2156392485,
-0.1923324764,
0.1995562762,
-0.629617095,
0.3106245995,
-0.0273071509,
0.6079727411,
0.6984975934,
0.1394057721,
0.3381676674,
-0.6812238693,
1.0178905725,
-0.5585452318,
0.3478227854,
-0.0971785113,
0.302200526,
0.1858754754,
-1.1629937887,
-0.6117135286,
-0.0837490261,
-0.1665677726,
0.2530960739,
-0.1904400736,
0.1547016948,
0.1061928421,
0.0424846113,
-0.5870019794,
-0.119221352,
-0.550203681,
-0.2567487061,
0.3976514935,
0.3252735436,
0.1372759789,
0.09245646,
-0.5384843349,
-0.0580829233,
-0.3123427331,
-0.2646442056,
0.2378835529,
0.2235396206,
0.0904302746,
0.3401954174,
-0.1171635911,
1.2090427876,
0.0575528778,
-0.0783353969,
0.3502781689,
-0.5894241333,
-0.2442989349,
0.036611449,
0.5425420403,
0.4778907001,
0.5052239895,
-0.1965910196,
-0.1292448044,
0.2684931159,
0.5763038397,
-0.8586408496,
-0.5571272373,
0.3608720601,
-0.1847099811,
-0.1162228361,
-0.2464099675,
-0.7407031059,
-0.1488954872,
-0.3525654972,
0.3751084507,
-0.1408984214,
-0.2323363423,
0.3117528856,
-0.2380114198,
0.1083275005,
0.2185379714,
-0.7917894721,
0.2831674814,
0.64229846,
0.7596790791,
-0.5894351006,
-0.4839972258,
-0.8378997445,
-0.0654217601,
-0.0713235438,
0.6332023144,
-0.585588932,
-0.0771111697,
-0.4275879264,
-0.0781281292,
-0.2720713615,
-0.9204841852,
0.6160743833,
-0.2801873386,
-0.0098924888,
-0.0349627212,
-0.1739056706,
-0.1938295066,
0.4542596042,
-0.6268421412,
1.0791056156,
0.1059210896,
-0.7506856322,
0.2846598327,
-0.8257369995,
-0.3908873796,
0.4601201415,
0.0803630427,
-0.8182712197,
0.5288670063,
0.112811774,
0.328068912,
-0.0916111395,
0.4651804864,
-0.2139109373,
-0.5975450873,
-0.0420775041,
-0.3064734936,
0.4704172015,
0.1586484313,
-0.3171766102,
0.6064822078,
-1.0289950371,
-0.1064506918,
0.3300656676,
-0.2103733867,
-0.3238189518,
0.2431265414,
0.3231722116,
0.0938769355,
0.4959901273,
-0.5085952878,
0.1173753142,
-0.3333181143,
0.6096109152,
0.7205595374,
-0.4394353926,
0.4903112352,
-0.0152985035,
0.483951956,
0.4207212329,
0.468498975,
-0.3226262331,
-0.2069335282,
-1.2346749306,
-0.3974327445,
0.2723133862,
0.4581637383,
-0.7402143478,
0.158360973,
-0.4872035682,
-0.3336919546,
-0.606564939,
0.2247155607,
0.3727658689,
0.7534498572,
0.534160912,
-0.6115416884,
-0.5852245092,
-0.9210857749,
-0.6886240244,
-0.34607324,
0.3297055662,
0.0608593114,
0.2688749433,
-0.2100757211,
1.3511886597,
-0.3945303559,
-0.334256053,
-0.4179010689,
-0.0721931681,
-0.0984394029,
0.5879999995,
0.726413548,
-1.1232242584,
-0.3782216012,
-0.0539116338,
-0.4083596766,
-0.211917758,
0.1463920772,
0.1610132009,
-0.1128854454,
0.3577501774,
-0.4921361208,
0.4501180947,
0.6240014434,
-0.2537332177,
0.7859631181,
-0.2227500081,
-0.3095091283,
-0.8552687764,
0.2063633949,
0.0881869718,
-0.508150816,
-0.8339760303,
0.2163667232,
0.2247531712,
-0.0973012224,
-0.9054260254,
0.8708550334,
-0.3226993084,
-0.1083906889,
-0.4960042834,
0.246186018,
0.1263785064,
0.8291713595,
0.1426669508,
0.6300445795,
0.7797028422,
-0.6541035175,
0.5895204544,
-0.2247487307,
-0.1026870236,
0.4273100793,
-0.6654589176,
0.032937862,
-0.3332601488,
-0.2623934448,
-0.885178566,
-0.0989526287,
0.3230706751,
-0.069674626,
0.1175105721,
-0.0880492777,
-0.3389481306,
-0.5432298183,
-0.2537486553,
0.7403632998,
0.4392737448,
-0.3971688449,
1.2036786079,
0.2938021421,
-0.0937064141,
-0.4570116699,
-0.7344741821,
0.1221235096,
-0.5185833573,
-0.2336511314,
0.4207991064,
-0.1516459137,
-0.1679961234,
0.2400582731,
-0.1598989666,
0.0265623387,
0.3254066706,
0.0828962177,
0.2255186439,
0.0208013449,
0.1874821335,
-0.402153939,
-0.3585695922,
-0.1225203499,
-0.7627631426,
0.4495139718,
-0.2561526,
-0.2300618589,
-0.5307607651,
-0.0017070712,
0.9647088647,
-0.6343775392,
0.5863637328,
0.9496849179,
-0.2733571529,
0.0132889878,
-0.5672650337,
-0.3064939678,
-0.5484400392,
0.8837667704,
-0.1681345999,
-0.8608981371,
0.6981588602,
-0.0737541988,
0.3393794596,
0.2945691347,
0.688500464,
0.1711598039,
0.9275867343,
0.9484046102,
-0.1638952643,
1.0407145023,
0.0021426824,
0.2500376701,
-0.6826944947,
-0.2457516342,
-0.2909175456,
-0.5943100452,
-0.3077124953,
-0.5444279909,
0.2728897333,
-0.128585875,
0.0189280566,
0.4395220578,
-0.816781044,
0.4449602962,
0.4991739988,
-0.1369217783,
0.2308692634,
0.0768259466,
0.1450648159,
-0.075558871,
-1.2114380598,
-0.146460399,
0.7314971685,
0.2199187428,
0.7199611068,
-0.1205723733,
0.292320013,
0.133348003,
0.4606648684,
-0.9433134794,
0.838093996,
-0.3078821301,
-0.3545128703,
-0.0869853869,
-0.5488234162,
-0.5909386277,
0.3540388644,
0.1264838874,
-0.7693669796,
0.1192695647,
0.7365096807,
-0.5562824011,
0.2040072531,
-0.8693994284,
1.1404401064,
-0.4949581921,
-0.6476463079,
-0.2151788771,
-0.5871266127,
0.1761105061,
-0.3382647038,
-0.0593465045,
-0.1159509718,
-0.0181832407,
0.9198669791,
-0.4609619975,
0.7381455302,
-0.3492676914,
0.2109342813,
0.5839161277,
-0.0069827945,
0.7104208469,
-0.3244884014,
0.1307288259,
0.0629343092,
-0.1706084609,
-0.5143570304,
-0.6975023746,
0.5870358944,
-0.2588436902,
-0.6859547496,
-0.170735687,
-0.6490709782,
-0.0262027197,
0.2767193317,
-0.1440704167,
0.5732731819,
0.2434803993,
0.2716331482,
0.4563318789,
-0.0462074913,
0.653868854,
0.4350318909,
-0.2935872376,
-0.2515341938,
1.2310984135,
0.0795791671,
0.2795593739,
0.1885990053,
0.2678711712,
-0.2584911287,
-0.9054903388,
-0.5152729154,
0.051087223,
-0.4887892306,
-0.2131452858,
-0.7210149169,
0.1211231872,
-0.2317083925,
0.1410838366,
-0.722774446,
-0.4146601856,
-0.3399160802,
-0.0636334047,
0.5807150006,
0.1723134816,
0.2542438209,
0.5756160617,
-0.8156175613,
0.4803186655,
0.4848882854,
0.443690002,
-0.0364507698,
-0.6031695604,
-0.5957034826,
-0.1600100249,
-0.1314577758,
-0.3136539757,
0.4560519755,
0.3775233328,
0.3980407715,
0.2200075537,
-0.0014191527,
1.1069972515,
-0.5089025497,
0.7615373731,
0.3717533052,
-0.7510261536,
0.3020380437,
0.0221727695,
0.732313931,
0.5735958219,
-0.2201162279,
-0.3513693511,
-0.4104866982,
-0.4235810339,
-1.0246616602,
0.7633756995,
0.0601360463,
0.1371766925,
0.1269781142,
0.397339046,
-0.348107934,
0.197466746,
-0.6715564132,
-0.0848530158,
-0.3814051151,
-0.7953264713,
0.0635112301,
-0.2225105315,
-0.0364007093,
-0.2784100771,
0.3381772041,
-0.4629508853,
0.0942483023,
0.2062211931,
-0.2569898963,
0.1016160622,
-0.1194556653,
0.7063369155,
0.7644674778,
0.0899878591,
0.3193866611,
0.2832205594,
-0.950075984,
-0.0916173235,
0.028224254,
-0.045936536,
-0.1197101697,
0.1188577712,
1.0417342186,
0.2143522948,
-1.1038877964,
0.4233094454,
-0.4008535743,
-0.0205743853,
0.0790623054,
0.2663303018,
0.0116402349,
0.1424013227,
0.5597586632,
0.3586947322,
-0.0987202972,
-0.3074234426,
0.217738986,
0.3507571518,
-0.71851933,
-0.4681769907,
0.8733754158,
0.3523333669,
-0.4793964326,
0.3681300879,
0.0756059363,
-0.7548893094,
0.6863495708,
0.3419412673,
1.1572490931,
0.0750048533,
-0.1791997105,
0.0863841921,
0.3509627283,
-0.1366205215,
0.2089804709,
-0.1682245582,
-0.6791047454,
-0.5909241438,
-0.9497852921,
-0.1759211123,
-0.0335378386,
-0.3754245639,
0.1487784982,
-0.3384775221,
-0.4506171942,
-0.2914185524,
-0.2590051889,
-0.6128230095,
0.4338078201,
-0.1019480675,
0.8230050802,
-0.5494501591,
0.840822041,
0.7761666179,
0.2180334479,
-0.5896016359,
-0.1204774827,
-0.3031992614,
-0.4173912406,
0.4466063082,
0.1501849443,
-0.3643134236,
0.2813694775,
-0.2560481727,
-0.7158320546,
0.7747765779,
0.6128240824,
-0.9025244117,
0.080366537,
0.099072732,
0.4515144527,
-0.1384638548,
-0.0698565692,
0.4891152382,
0.5543569326,
-0.1506057084,
-0.8738097548,
-0.3379832804,
-0.2110749036,
0.0206712186,
0.2530402243,
-0.8529400229,
0.574016273,
-0.2789543271,
-0.255425632,
0.062710762,
0.8128165007,
0.2258455306,
0.2060116976,
0.5436859131,
0.6694193482,
0.3297512829,
-0.2544049919,
0.6717125773,
-0.7429136634,
0.4755204618,
1.0828734636,
-0.2595618069,
0.4233932197,
0.8363077641,
0.1245557517,
0.1358848959,
0.309104383,
0.0821496919,
0.5689368248,
0.0252239369,
-0.0641330928,
-0.2393769622,
-0.0660393685,
0.078766644,
0.6032195687,
0.1189865023,
-0.2588072717,
-0.1364183873,
0.2152522057,
-0.4306401312,
-0.0473103896,
-0.5776410103,
0.7123894095,
-0.0543063506,
-0.8749876022,
0.4487912357,
0.1950520128,
0.6360740066,
-0.6318538785,
0.1475912333,
-0.1636054218,
0.6138534546,
-0.0150300572,
-0.4129211605,
0.4819980562,
0.1317177713,
-0.1508654356,
-0.3435501158,
1.0836564302,
-0.5539324284,
-0.7135297656,
0.2131990194,
0.3834824562,
-0.1000721604,
-0.0354018509,
-0.8445181847,
0.3958109319,
-0.0911426544,
-0.2998572588,
0.2472954392,
0.2528867126,
-0.2331458479,
0.8863118887,
0.5913829207,
0.0797371119,
0.3746017814,
0.0537746698,
0.9167842269,
-0.5568188429,
-0.3938378394,
-1.2167305946,
0.5561560988,
0.0726651624,
-0.2118667513,
0.6907163262,
0.5650303364,
0.74595505,
-0.1112379953,
0.3843939006,
0.1752080172,
0.0456003509,
-0.2646679282,
0.554704845,
-0.6385221481,
-0.0546696931,
-0.1584398448,
-1.093170166,
-0.6468597054,
0.4872840047,
-0.1533437967,
0.104998149,
0.2340941876,
0.7501932383,
-0.344747901,
-0.424007684,
0.3201421499,
0.1416025907,
0.1883447021,
0.3433961272,
0.4382698536,
-0.2689573467,
0.5416610241,
-0.082920894,
0.0173861478,
-0.4390909672,
-1.021835804,
-0.5310009718,
-0.3152745366,
-0.6600459814,
0.0883077234,
0.088391304,
0.5740555525,
0.9361814857,
-0.5711512566,
0.0106156319,
-0.3952432871,
0.0480641797,
-0.5720952749,
-0.2229341567,
0.316909194,
-0.182907775,
-0.9762423635,
0.1280386299,
0.8188377619,
-0.0214591809,
-0.481908381,
-0.0618006364,
0.1397973299,
0.1387886703,
0.6250272393,
0.3148693144,
-0.6520943642,
-0.2583872378,
-0.0411477312,
0.0466501676,
0.0787597895,
0.7635147572,
-1.2439243793,
0.7293093204,
0.5057644844,
0.6979196072,
0.418027401,
0.3069838583,
0.3590279818,
-0.8008207679,
0.6006415486,
0.3814501762,
0.3624167144,
0.4904232323,
0.0430589728,
0.201471135,
0.673238039,
-0.1143473238,
-1.11188972,
0.301201731,
-1.071670413,
-0.1914036721,
0.8399288058,
-0.1024546325,
-0.7252257466,
-0.0297912695,
-0.1816134751,
0.1433712989,
0.055179406,
0.6860901117,
0.3594860733,
0.1461251229,
-0.4309839308,
-0.1852109432,
0.3960700035,
0.7827851176,
-0.5222942233,
0.4430909157,
0.1097658947,
0.2920408845,
0.3631309867,
0.4521438777,
-0.125293076,
0.4117109478,
-0.3008405566,
0.1075244397,
-0.3639540076,
-0.7648800611,
-0.4005512297,
0.3223834336,
-0.057200782,
-0.3789215386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15032v1 | How to Distill your BERT: An Empirical Study on the Impact of Weight Initialisation and Distillation Objectives | 2023-05-24T11:16:09 | 2023-05-24T11:16:09 | Xinpeng Wang, Leonie Weissweiler, Hinrich Schütze, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recently, various intermediate layer distillation (ILD) objectives have been
shown to improve compression of BERT models via Knowledge Distillation (KD).
However, a comprehensive evaluation of the objectives in both task-specific and
task-agnostic settings is lacking. To the best of our knowledge, this is the
first work comprehensively evaluating distillation objectives in both settings.
We show that attention transfer gives the best performance overall. We also
study the impact of layer choice when initializing the student from the teacher
layers, finding a significant impact on the performance in task-specific
distillation. For vanilla KD and hidden states transfer, initialisation with
lower layers of the teacher gives a considerable improvement over higher
layers, especially on the task of QNLI (up to an absolute percentage change of
17.8 in accuracy). Attention transfer behaves consistently under different
initialisation settings. We release our code as an efficient transformer-based
model distillation framework for further studies. | [
-0.3013088405,
-0.4128274918,
0.6905290484,
0.373339951,
-0.1788432151,
0.0337933265,
-0.2260616273,
-0.321092546,
-0.3415669501,
0.1100957245,
-0.2889137566,
0.058141835,
-0.9409384727,
-0.2659490705,
-0.6071892381,
1.3791906834,
0.0106511163,
0.100491479,
-0.2677795589,
0.4400504827,
-0.3527417481,
-0.5953564048,
-0.7538148165,
-0.6769577861,
0.6359343529,
0.393658191,
0.2960438728,
0.2694675326,
0.5741758347,
0.2938978374,
-0.3852312863,
-0.1844296753,
-0.7959040999,
-0.0559640378,
-0.0637529194,
-0.5834859014,
0.0999630615,
0.1115148291,
0.2985820174,
0.8366488814,
-0.2063447237,
0.3430201411,
0.6211475134,
1.0841687918,
-0.7526967525,
0.0901998132,
-0.551923275,
0.1597526371,
0.2507321239,
0.2088347673,
-0.524408102,
-0.318982482,
0.8235451579,
-0.2951865196,
0.3204243779,
-0.1722521037,
0.8193924427,
0.5135322213,
-0.4548439085,
-0.2961488664,
-1.0306185484,
0.889721632,
-0.5316391587,
0.1647288203,
0.2102874517,
0.5111985207,
0.124490343,
-1.0823228359,
-0.3723271489,
0.0019834295,
-0.0516082719,
0.1060470641,
-0.1629700065,
0.3098312914,
0.4345517159,
0.3957107067,
-0.0167382937,
-0.3234560192,
-0.7086420655,
0.049281124,
0.373970747,
-0.3110557795,
-0.0217746757,
0.075017184,
-0.7334023714,
-0.2871330082,
0.0250208266,
0.1611074209,
0.4726742208,
0.2477558404,
0.0350043215,
0.4414995313,
-0.1081383452,
0.4598849714,
0.6187301278,
-0.1699783206,
-0.0276981127,
-0.1552910805,
-0.1630176753,
0.4157371521,
-0.0006509096,
0.2111884356,
0.4541343153,
-0.2450880408,
-0.2031362057,
-0.2271178961,
0.5194334388,
-1.0389375687,
-0.7429326177,
0.2469242066,
-0.7019636035,
-0.6347311735,
-0.0224824082,
-0.133441776,
-0.1871804595,
-0.659350276,
0.7608974576,
-0.6330990195,
-0.025325017,
0.0879612565,
-0.6004248857,
0.2544570267,
0.3568055928,
-1.0352495909,
0.3330197632,
0.4794433713,
0.7014258504,
-0.1280670464,
0.1079448611,
-0.0845893472,
0.2850328982,
0.1239548922,
0.3449744582,
-0.1112626642,
-0.1279313713,
-0.2293682247,
-0.2118355185,
0.1785660833,
-0.4566208124,
0.7459518909,
-0.4034639597,
0.1498486996,
-0.6233127713,
-0.5685176253,
-0.3081540763,
-0.0321156457,
-0.4646217525,
1.127371788,
0.2257902026,
-0.6697936058,
0.5361407399,
-0.6192730665,
-0.5983030796,
-0.1819512248,
0.2867815495,
-0.1814938039,
0.4970227182,
0.3411050439,
0.4337410629,
-0.0047351504,
0.3086073399,
-0.0196717903,
-0.3043946028,
0.0379191674,
-0.4118568003,
1.0997365713,
0.4217103124,
-0.2857622802,
-0.3721930385,
-0.747107327,
0.2418593317,
-0.2139045,
-0.3188507855,
-0.5512171388,
0.021957621,
0.1982263476,
0.0085490374,
0.5311655998,
-0.637440443,
0.1004709229,
0.1572847664,
0.6582388282,
0.8380423784,
0.0597511604,
0.3902849257,
-0.2406188548,
-0.0912433192,
0.2883874476,
0.4992555976,
0.227461338,
-0.3435340524,
-0.7397516966,
-0.3206301033,
0.6006172895,
0.2632815242,
-0.7978932858,
0.4370404184,
0.0702244714,
-0.4466497898,
-0.5910181403,
0.0936253816,
0.4197413921,
0.8932311535,
0.2706933916,
-0.1656341106,
-0.3756416142,
-1.2620630264,
0.2298836112,
-0.423107177,
-0.1505436897,
0.2452359349,
0.2047866434,
0.3068682849,
0.9553878903,
-0.7390069366,
-0.4144061804,
-0.2470136136,
0.4056653678,
0.5111548305,
0.5891677737,
0.9837103486,
-0.7868938446,
-0.9780224562,
-0.0772510469,
-0.5232003927,
-0.1904755682,
-0.0519947894,
-0.4764760733,
-0.1977015436,
0.1328240186,
-0.388893187,
0.2139728218,
0.433341831,
0.0380419418,
0.3858349323,
-0.4076008797,
0.2364249378,
-0.8245692849,
0.2135139406,
0.0019550491,
-0.1837555915,
-0.8124937415,
-0.1959611475,
0.1404336691,
-0.0976977199,
-0.6496887207,
-0.0482821688,
-0.3322938085,
-0.0754668117,
-0.3048282862,
-0.2685036361,
0.3477396369,
0.5712859631,
-0.0797123834,
0.6292588115,
0.4476531148,
-0.4870070815,
0.3423787355,
0.0033398224,
-0.5936672091,
0.5282227397,
-1.0808666945,
0.16723077,
-0.1769555211,
0.003434753,
-1.2905030251,
0.2366216183,
-0.0562984012,
-0.3119859397,
0.6151978374,
-0.1803303957,
-0.3721580803,
-0.5389630198,
-0.0799903199,
0.1622432619,
0.9205110073,
-0.6800715923,
0.5770822763,
-0.0338954479,
0.0441842675,
-0.6759576797,
-0.7938479781,
-0.1223636568,
-0.3987925351,
-0.4574649036,
0.5846832991,
-0.2749044895,
-0.0769517943,
0.3159353733,
-0.424081713,
-0.4931510687,
0.1620092541,
-0.0249901488,
0.1695876569,
0.0208965838,
-0.0744221956,
0.3593293726,
0.2073571831,
0.277449131,
-0.4774218202,
0.1990015805,
0.2014151216,
-0.1179256588,
-0.6992034912,
0.1446350217,
0.4565176368,
0.1403359473,
0.8478999138,
0.6293538213,
-0.2782373428,
-0.278883338,
-0.7660473585,
-0.4628902674,
-0.4831685126,
0.3509692252,
-0.4658733904,
-0.268581003,
0.6171248555,
-0.0192127693,
0.1926885247,
0.1288498044,
0.2777939439,
-0.6941347122,
0.9268345833,
1.0570944548,
-0.2588943839,
0.708976388,
-0.3371831775,
0.2351910472,
-0.9025455713,
-0.1655665636,
-0.4324203432,
-1.0704653263,
0.0630819276,
-0.0595076755,
0.5492104292,
0.447773695,
0.0454436615,
0.3172373772,
-0.8925816417,
0.6834920645,
0.6442872286,
0.4892870784,
0.0911009014,
0.0545002893,
0.0149995619,
-0.1247036159,
-0.7054127455,
-0.2695947886,
1.3224346638,
0.4753260612,
0.7389965057,
-0.0075225378,
1.0220142603,
0.5680309534,
0.2743743658,
-0.6997646093,
0.3129081428,
-0.3632976115,
-0.7959581017,
-0.4656258225,
-0.173399359,
-0.5003618002,
0.2659295201,
0.053481292,
-0.6128946543,
0.3691808283,
0.1551135629,
-0.4539440572,
0.1983594149,
-1.2876435518,
0.5328650475,
-0.3941527903,
-0.3251269162,
-0.1168337241,
-0.8099246025,
0.4726062119,
-0.1610571891,
-0.2419463694,
-0.1605316997,
0.2213508487,
0.6004333496,
-0.3480439782,
0.8420516253,
-0.7825386524,
-0.256031841,
0.4072404504,
-0.3776710629,
0.2768443525,
-0.2199351937,
-0.1064500883,
0.1890368462,
0.1966991425,
-0.3497202992,
-0.8370041847,
0.4961506128,
-0.9654762745,
-0.7554143071,
-0.1863906384,
-0.8203982711,
0.1038697287,
0.1607259512,
0.0141576212,
0.2111203074,
-0.0269567277,
0.459944129,
1.0937267542,
0.0741226077,
0.4606578052,
0.4150517285,
-0.0374137573,
-0.0042998116,
0.6898646355,
0.2850072682,
0.5150714517,
0.3889536858,
0.3029047251,
-0.3327724636,
-0.6507880092,
-0.3462211192,
-0.2511832118,
-0.7794584036,
-0.0268349964,
-0.381631881,
-0.5139284134,
-0.3597473204,
-0.1175239384,
-0.4885720313,
-0.4755767882,
-0.4046417773,
0.0712621436,
0.1795711964,
0.4980475307,
-0.1990455091,
0.3230232596,
-0.5384252667,
0.3558609188,
0.5346992016,
0.0140470611,
0.147808671,
-0.7307398915,
-0.3486672044,
0.1241538301,
-0.3506459594,
-0.5165759325,
0.1277781278,
0.5433005691,
0.692805171,
0.664753139,
0.5695464015,
0.6875714064,
-0.6356990933,
0.6257532239,
0.4098547101,
-0.9985359907,
0.6191197038,
0.133688882,
0.2203698009,
0.6952604651,
0.4809040725,
-0.062206734,
-0.2502858043,
-0.4176742136,
-0.8985111713,
0.7311089635,
0.3186777234,
0.1923360974,
0.2446856946,
0.6275745034,
0.242332384,
0.2241484225,
-0.6631349325,
-0.3936462104,
0.1239447743,
-0.1737243235,
0.1817563325,
-0.3878390789,
-0.3514519632,
-0.453692317,
0.518370688,
0.1691438556,
0.0580073483,
0.3649251461,
-0.1792377383,
0.1293103993,
-0.0783452243,
0.2644496262,
0.5693909526,
-0.6190706491,
0.2032835931,
0.111970529,
-0.5495229959,
0.2516363561,
-0.0285368711,
-0.1153896973,
-0.038156528,
0.2009577155,
0.7721007466,
0.2253333628,
-0.2681301534,
0.3149098158,
-0.1097697392,
-0.5317621827,
-0.0247397926,
0.2537330985,
-0.0556844808,
0.6016813517,
0.6541067362,
-0.1325638592,
0.4952417314,
-0.5360220671,
0.2237208486,
0.2264070362,
-0.2043527514,
-0.1109853387,
0.7887684107,
0.4188354611,
0.2622746229,
0.7868123055,
0.1790761352,
-0.2568729818,
0.8029463887,
0.348731935,
0.9929342866,
-0.2741441131,
0.0867264345,
0.2312440127,
0.3015366197,
0.0485867001,
0.2564007044,
-0.5100480914,
-0.6038720012,
-0.3480974138,
-0.6770552397,
-0.235305503,
-0.0937751681,
-1.198735714,
0.1177219748,
-0.2408673614,
-0.4670191407,
0.4259677231,
0.0101478631,
-0.6795170307,
0.0577287413,
0.3047503531,
0.6707487702,
-0.8520649672,
1.1105338335,
0.6056057215,
-0.2405829877,
-0.6399738789,
-0.1613715738,
-0.4222554266,
-0.6810469031,
1.1789875031,
-0.0231450144,
0.2075039744,
0.1496506184,
-0.4947231114,
-0.8752481341,
1.2551635504,
0.4152072072,
-0.8574160933,
-0.2550368607,
0.1467591673,
0.4963063896,
-0.1469964683,
0.2612715662,
0.7282110453,
0.4638889134,
0.3858988285,
-0.9680787325,
-0.3452878892,
0.0173613466,
0.435798794,
0.0093052546,
-0.5086268783,
0.951892972,
-0.4168716371,
-0.2088635415,
-0.2108235359,
0.6602168083,
-0.2917992473,
0.0720376372,
0.7491053939,
0.727124095,
0.4915250838,
-0.2284792662,
0.9348962903,
-0.6061778069,
0.3283344507,
1.1135956049,
-0.3400724828,
0.5624198914,
0.950899601,
-0.4866958857,
0.2628473341,
0.4516232908,
-0.0079194997,
1.1463077068,
0.4683342874,
-0.2036444843,
0.2737582624,
-0.1097733825,
-0.4183740318,
0.2444257885,
0.003119705,
-0.4757013321,
-0.2781136036,
0.2841005623,
-0.3162959218,
-0.1053697839,
-0.2644160092,
0.8975497484,
-0.1003675014,
-0.6231640577,
0.5092630386,
-0.298671931,
0.4853408933,
-0.6435062289,
-0.0056152903,
-0.0930157527,
0.3445594609,
-0.1130483225,
-0.7318198085,
0.2217100412,
-0.0653673187,
-0.6611202359,
-0.6010110974,
0.7131664157,
-0.7233468294,
-0.4915431738,
0.1370272487,
0.3240789771,
0.2922154665,
0.0202821288,
-0.6016937494,
0.0836629942,
0.2005575448,
-0.2909133136,
0.3760699034,
0.6587520242,
0.4611133933,
0.3591043651,
0.4802157581,
0.0644313991,
0.1795572191,
0.2674447,
1.1149492264,
-0.0993065909,
-0.3685005903,
-0.6990483999,
0.6500598192,
-0.1063651815,
0.0011166324,
0.6463677287,
0.4565325975,
0.8352410197,
-0.2741296589,
0.7667179704,
-0.3662162125,
0.1440541148,
-0.3551591933,
1.0324857235,
-0.3203686774,
0.0929864496,
-0.2283942252,
-1.3826050758,
0.4139343798,
0.5948799849,
-0.2090034038,
-0.0225929674,
0.5662923455,
0.1169807836,
0.0163707361,
-0.1652212888,
0.3589578569,
0.0606527142,
0.3880093992,
0.7261821032,
0.7208929062,
-0.4591553211,
0.333773315,
-1.0302349329,
-0.3671045303,
-0.0864679813,
-1.0049146414,
-0.9393228292,
-0.5711501241,
-0.6014603972,
0.0490323491,
0.2074259818,
0.4129299819,
0.9801957011,
-0.6691583991,
-0.2184665948,
0.0379766114,
-0.1415999979,
-0.4479959011,
-0.2657528818,
0.3572389781,
-0.6879891157,
-1.0716513395,
-0.0687933788,
-0.045144476,
0.0647187606,
-0.328443557,
0.2390659004,
-0.2426266521,
0.034455955,
0.747308135,
-0.0930755809,
-0.6738557816,
-0.5346950293,
-0.3789300025,
-0.0813751295,
-0.142242223,
0.7819503546,
-0.6005206108,
0.5397355556,
0.3780751228,
0.55560112,
0.7186880112,
0.0732389092,
0.4263161123,
-1.1285572052,
0.296192199,
0.2174856961,
0.0902751461,
-0.1753512919,
-0.5421594381,
0.5218202472,
-0.0963029265,
-0.5674348474,
-1.0575420856,
-0.2647476792,
-0.9113171101,
-0.2198739797,
0.7231243849,
-0.4463521242,
-0.1740115732,
0.1911273748,
-0.4277745485,
0.4368609488,
-0.3692797124,
1.1520290375,
1.1090043783,
-0.3471922278,
-0.1091645807,
-0.6184678674,
0.5000784397,
0.4608287215,
-0.4862611592,
-0.0030002794,
0.3255918324,
0.3212087452,
0.1789241582,
0.1521793902,
0.011328727,
-0.1788722724,
-0.0448502451,
0.3814103007,
-0.1620892435,
-0.6021342874,
0.0412211306,
0.1347661167,
-0.1341024488,
-0.6014062166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15028v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15028v2 | ImageNetVC: Zero- and Few-Shot Visual Commonsense Evaluation on 1000 ImageNet Categories | 2023-05-24T11:14:31 | 2023-10-20T20:41:46 | Heming Xia, Qingxiu Dong, Lei Li, Jingjing Xu, Tianyu Liu, Ziwei Qin, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have been serving as general-purpose
interfaces, posing a significant demand for comprehensive visual knowledge.
However, it remains unclear how well current LLMs and their visually augmented
counterparts (VaLMs) can master visual commonsense knowledge. To investigate
this, we propose ImageNetVC, a human-annotated dataset specifically designed
for zero- and few-shot visual commonsense evaluation across 1,000 ImageNet
categories. Utilizing ImageNetVC, we benchmark the fundamental visual
commonsense knowledge of both unimodal LLMs and VaLMs. Furthermore, we analyze
the factors affecting the visual commonsense knowledge of large-scale models,
providing insights into the development of language models enriched with visual
commonsense knowledge. Our code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/hemingkx/ImageNetVC. | [
-0.5579094291,
-0.3898194134,
0.2362728864,
-0.068416886,
-0.2293470353,
-0.2486921549,
-0.1192767248,
-0.3344458044,
-0.0672108904,
0.8174910545,
-0.2319498509,
-0.6700268388,
-0.4841063917,
0.1028627977,
-0.3196932971,
0.4360789657,
0.2941683233,
0.092907317,
-0.5791168809,
-0.3994227946,
-0.2651996911,
-0.03051164,
-0.5263518691,
-0.2361926585,
0.7496307492,
0.5845879912,
0.4979491532,
0.5681528449,
0.5708364844,
0.2835520506,
-0.0399210639,
0.2005494833,
-0.4989723563,
-0.2315379828,
-0.190162614,
-0.2254158109,
-0.2879678309,
-0.0966701135,
0.4971868098,
0.6081866622,
0.2843622267,
0.5531759858,
-0.0836109594,
0.7108128071,
-0.9461310506,
-0.0959381685,
-0.7407799959,
0.0576635338,
-0.2294188589,
-0.2400227785,
-0.2699935138,
0.2062783241,
0.1933709681,
-0.6801787615,
0.0958560184,
0.2803327739,
0.5740377307,
0.3594343364,
-0.4923447669,
0.3501755893,
-0.161962539,
0.7023339868,
-0.5276454091,
0.2876755595,
0.4034861922,
0.3296530545,
-0.0101872738,
-0.7268742919,
-0.8158588409,
-0.3674148619,
0.1091467664,
0.0416621789,
-0.5354678035,
0.0703584775,
0.3751792014,
0.070886068,
-0.5815850496,
0.4300014675,
-0.5169913769,
-0.1230636835,
0.4331911206,
0.2888818979,
0.4979220331,
-0.5039361715,
-0.7248352766,
0.1105121821,
-0.8217408657,
0.0098431278,
0.3502454162,
0.1977913678,
-0.1549324691,
0.7419784665,
-0.4812478721,
1.0404543877,
-0.3615354598,
0.1423337013,
0.1706670672,
-0.2468326837,
-0.3824880123,
-0.0940945148,
0.9245867133,
0.7270448804,
0.4956103861,
-0.0293641854,
-0.2526643574,
-0.0175419264,
0.3359402716,
-0.7211768627,
-0.1656869799,
-0.0130688809,
-0.4576329291,
-0.6656748652,
-0.2017644197,
-0.4717746079,
-0.824388206,
-0.4593398571,
0.6097674966,
0.008820042,
-0.3533982038,
0.0444370434,
-0.4120811522,
0.3435923457,
0.4084555507,
-0.6018457413,
0.2758274376,
0.7419501543,
0.8591526151,
-0.3263401091,
-0.4931150973,
-0.5800329447,
-0.3350290954,
-0.5049926043,
0.8177864552,
-0.5743675232,
0.087047711,
-0.0012241967,
-0.0293103848,
0.4167006612,
-0.6761586666,
0.0457132719,
-0.5314804912,
-0.4433487058,
-0.2352693677,
-0.4024195373,
-0.0216788836,
0.5633724332,
-0.912671268,
0.6557614803,
0.0158889014,
-0.8367192745,
0.4776417017,
-0.7102302313,
-0.1359735429,
0.4565186501,
-0.1856832802,
-0.1059278771,
0.0997199044,
0.1702174097,
0.7130130529,
-0.3319301903,
0.1324013472,
-0.4453423917,
-0.5929040313,
0.5275334716,
-0.6571470499,
0.8195661902,
0.2134307921,
-0.0554849915,
-0.0117541701,
-0.7916002274,
-0.2975342274,
-0.0772288293,
-0.0103196893,
-0.487634778,
-0.4335748255,
0.2402495146,
0.1576512158,
0.1261538565,
-0.6971757412,
0.109200418,
-0.007351697,
0.3975501657,
0.8111972809,
0.0619747899,
0.4545245767,
0.0323101133,
0.468693912,
0.2800509334,
0.2687749565,
-0.1928331703,
-0.5561355352,
-0.6911123991,
-0.1484128684,
0.2200442702,
0.3817259371,
-1.2662457228,
-0.0255896021,
-0.3834430873,
-0.1878996789,
-0.4942175746,
0.5681721568,
0.7588718534,
0.5552911162,
0.2367297858,
-0.5054243207,
-0.3485933244,
-1.0863006115,
-0.1394064128,
0.0106293689,
-0.0824897587,
0.4498875439,
0.6634718776,
-0.1023645252,
0.925470233,
-0.2729547322,
-0.364110738,
-0.1224530935,
0.2720546722,
-0.0387410484,
0.2263592333,
0.4269291759,
-0.6778864861,
-0.1976300031,
0.1141858101,
-0.8360060453,
-0.0664776042,
-0.0359763578,
-0.176980868,
0.1403030157,
0.5858302116,
-0.030990582,
0.6280341744,
0.6987432241,
-0.2509628236,
0.6099500656,
0.0065176091,
0.2923444211,
-0.8001679778,
0.1477316022,
0.519215703,
-0.1714324951,
-0.6576756835,
-0.0703695193,
0.0579070486,
-0.1503938884,
-1.1054940224,
1.0271208286,
-0.4172597229,
-0.3910226822,
-0.1816549897,
0.0797415376,
-0.0546400882,
0.7187946439,
0.2248942107,
0.69940418,
0.8301287293,
-0.3801672757,
0.671508491,
0.0434076041,
-0.6963372827,
0.8743759394,
-0.7292611599,
-0.0503233634,
-0.1446548849,
-0.2025762647,
-0.9995473623,
-0.310980469,
0.0222361349,
-0.4987652302,
0.0399240889,
-0.5463636518,
-0.4906770289,
-0.2950624526,
-0.1779267937,
0.5553947091,
0.2356846482,
-0.8464269638,
0.2420215309,
0.3049266934,
0.2913123667,
-0.809099257,
-1.0139300823,
0.5794776082,
-0.0431487449,
-0.5582642555,
-0.3506873548,
0.3066634238,
-0.2919667959,
0.1598068178,
0.1964570582,
-0.2858450413,
-0.0371591412,
0.3667801619,
0.3841123283,
-0.1407149285,
0.2415443808,
-0.4402473569,
-0.1777950525,
-0.1999400854,
-0.4856319726,
0.0952470079,
-0.4129906595,
-0.4527980983,
-0.3691338897,
0.0272704177,
0.5196914673,
-0.2086243033,
0.3688630462,
0.6367387772,
-0.2805598974,
-0.1259332448,
-0.6983386278,
0.2201371342,
-0.4488942921,
0.5311555266,
-0.2417292595,
-1.0888780355,
0.2910770476,
-0.0094864592,
-0.0942454487,
0.1680313945,
0.3473190367,
-0.1788463145,
0.4758525491,
0.3694507778,
0.0838617459,
0.3510806561,
-0.4159083068,
-0.2900373936,
-1.1745480299,
-0.066337958,
0.0251580197,
-0.5892099142,
-0.7175667882,
-0.67344594,
0.4409410357,
-0.166474387,
-0.5101709962,
0.4162071645,
-0.4187664986,
0.8767481446,
0.699083209,
0.3261658251,
0.3365523517,
0.1556439102,
0.1046931222,
0.1380180866,
-0.6754894853,
-0.4122049809,
1.1965640783,
0.2949849665,
0.763551116,
0.0470487066,
0.4789135158,
0.3336861134,
0.2222478241,
-0.768969655,
0.6143782735,
-0.6240603328,
-0.6303280592,
-0.3742669225,
-0.5527908802,
-0.8544886112,
0.0118793324,
-0.2929162383,
-0.6155434847,
0.4656382799,
0.3879235387,
-0.2722919881,
0.5418208241,
-0.6653285027,
1.1632919312,
-0.4860166907,
-0.6287059188,
0.059641201,
-0.5619299412,
0.682837069,
0.2033948153,
-0.101399079,
-0.1248196736,
-0.320184499,
0.5980798006,
-0.2736618817,
1.1862125397,
-0.107373856,
0.2552147806,
0.41304636,
0.1374263316,
0.0726900697,
-0.1069462821,
0.3663335443,
0.5346946716,
-0.2471820265,
-0.5665783882,
-0.5169044137,
0.8380360007,
-0.7049546242,
-0.1117952913,
-0.169859916,
-0.1658766419,
-0.2430886179,
0.1852660477,
0.1989641786,
0.8954104185,
-0.1894796938,
0.376703769,
0.7701798677,
-0.6037254333,
0.4081135392,
0.2598618567,
-0.1604477614,
-0.523103416,
1.0358089209,
-0.0414600857,
0.4200323224,
0.4144619107,
0.1845258176,
-0.1021921188,
-0.4526031017,
-0.6047821045,
-0.0779503584,
-0.8801250458,
-0.4093975723,
-0.2726840675,
-0.0188919194,
-0.1982096881,
-0.1789734066,
-0.5136113167,
-0.3830726147,
-0.2799648046,
0.1163133085,
0.5759184361,
0.7951764464,
-0.0134246005,
0.140319705,
-0.4903350472,
0.502879858,
0.7961441278,
0.8167986274,
0.1742853671,
-0.630197525,
-0.043551743,
-0.119239077,
0.2992156148,
-0.3681580126,
0.2540167868,
0.0536824837,
0.409168005,
0.5641281009,
-0.1225118488,
0.7478410006,
-0.3091959655,
0.8989607692,
0.6473553777,
-0.6835673451,
0.2669518292,
-0.2244163156,
0.5473710895,
0.6125341058,
0.2802004516,
-0.7295429707,
0.0151814213,
-0.3770472109,
-0.6255837083,
0.3467586339,
0.0686674267,
0.2069128156,
-0.1002587155,
0.043400269,
-0.0912803784,
0.114166297,
-0.5818496943,
-0.168726474,
-0.296844095,
0.0909668058,
0.1716706902,
-0.2952497602,
-0.0659324229,
-0.2370557487,
0.2962369919,
-0.2491867244,
0.11074806,
-0.0536386296,
-0.3211416006,
0.0168399867,
0.2572748661,
0.7223203778,
0.6053728461,
-0.0694399104,
0.5105767846,
0.2089371085,
-0.4576386213,
-0.0357410721,
-0.4111662507,
-0.1550423056,
-0.2271855026,
0.6548842192,
1.0914349556,
0.407638669,
-0.8043044209,
0.898794055,
-0.1452273577,
-0.3766804934,
-0.250050813,
-0.035664387,
0.1296155304,
0.185072735,
0.1703695208,
0.2666338384,
0.1660962105,
-0.3635260761,
0.2809758484,
0.3804361224,
-0.4060742557,
-0.0731925815,
0.3909807503,
0.4139697254,
-0.0648673102,
0.7272943258,
-0.3757225275,
-0.3589105606,
0.6403349042,
0.0496659018,
0.9149390459,
0.3659956753,
0.2774312496,
0.558924973,
0.3990289569,
0.0890087262,
-0.0782219693,
-0.1204150617,
-0.7753795981,
-0.4891669452,
-0.6083338857,
-0.2898321748,
0.1074097008,
-0.5368488431,
0.3552203774,
-0.3612440825,
0.0938568488,
-0.024163764,
-0.2176896483,
-1.0273374319,
0.0913455114,
0.513236165,
0.9209951758,
-0.9183472395,
0.6673571467,
0.6591468453,
-0.5582657456,
-0.5208108425,
-0.515258193,
0.1820421815,
-1.0903873444,
0.9815307856,
-0.0754543543,
-0.118343927,
-0.0614500828,
-1.1555523872,
-0.5469347835,
1.0528360605,
0.0997175649,
-0.8106714487,
0.4269959629,
0.3847119808,
0.5093403459,
-0.2796228826,
0.3158220351,
0.3978543282,
0.4777890742,
0.6462001801,
-0.8054214716,
-0.2485577166,
-0.3849171698,
0.3090161681,
-0.1493267268,
-0.3159926236,
0.4529095292,
-0.2678833306,
0.0274721552,
-0.0608318932,
0.4363312125,
0.1009489074,
0.418910563,
0.5418177843,
0.9031117558,
0.2964461446,
0.0677295774,
0.87977314,
0.0380968675,
-0.0235638116,
1.1958879232,
0.0036032647,
0.9898707867,
0.3979101181,
0.0192630608,
-0.0804669484,
0.3726572096,
-0.2626019716,
0.2524586916,
0.372248292,
-0.335490346,
-0.6012512445,
-0.2836391628,
0.0676907003,
0.7004221082,
0.1657214016,
-0.1974918842,
-0.1489432454,
0.3422623873,
-0.3230997324,
-0.1528126597,
-0.6610993743,
0.8235933781,
0.0428219996,
-0.4940832555,
0.6247981191,
-0.3605904877,
0.8925810456,
-0.0996803865,
-0.1761469841,
-0.4236235917,
-0.1727224141,
-0.3207968473,
-1.2396597862,
-0.1343234777,
0.4053997695,
0.1454785466,
0.0532230586,
0.9167739749,
-0.4119537473,
-0.5525746346,
-0.0940179452,
0.2227625847,
0.4144937396,
-0.0816816017,
-0.5026890039,
0.1192114279,
-0.2244584113,
-0.0080992179,
0.381305337,
0.4473657906,
-0.0997042805,
0.6513013244,
0.6242349744,
0.2592269182,
0.1274261326,
0.3371042907,
0.7472020984,
-0.6400778294,
0.1542726904,
-0.6516717672,
0.6829481125,
-0.2329716831,
-0.5333461165,
0.4018696249,
0.3912406862,
0.8917142749,
-0.19458884,
0.7374832034,
0.0675955638,
-0.1308489889,
-0.3986275792,
0.6846686006,
-0.7678444386,
0.2053906471,
-0.3235672712,
-0.6777234077,
-0.5755875111,
0.3211932182,
-0.236985445,
-0.1659379005,
0.2065645307,
1.1014027596,
-0.1193593666,
-0.3612521291,
0.9181771874,
-0.0621591844,
-0.0395196639,
0.5391702056,
1.0654988289,
-0.257417649,
0.5259090662,
-0.4531730115,
-0.238595888,
0.0018254737,
-1.3323246241,
-1.0094983578,
-0.5599056482,
-0.4843937755,
0.0821823105,
0.0355447009,
0.7775044441,
0.6867938638,
-0.5301670432,
-0.1525056809,
-0.1599334478,
-0.0677702725,
0.0103649283,
-0.1834075451,
0.1422989368,
-0.0735649988,
-0.3639423549,
-0.0780258849,
0.5416808128,
-0.0749693364,
-0.6525914073,
-0.1580858827,
-0.2001633793,
-0.1794838458,
0.6904201508,
0.4198697209,
-0.7629234791,
-0.1760622412,
0.1038829833,
-0.1119581163,
-0.0059451554,
0.7492426634,
-0.8292086124,
0.9532387853,
0.6229717135,
0.5347885489,
0.2662411928,
0.0690595433,
0.0651475713,
-1.0254369974,
0.1288346499,
0.03657021,
0.3823631406,
0.5304825902,
-0.0869994909,
0.3834727407,
0.1656868458,
-0.4695453048,
-0.6534304023,
0.0884903371,
-1.1642547846,
-0.1580399126,
1.3575962782,
0.0041022305,
-0.4861690104,
-0.0176420733,
0.0836012661,
-0.171183452,
-0.1865644753,
0.287137419,
0.3487567902,
0.12061809,
-0.7190183997,
-0.718942821,
0.1479861736,
-0.0541224852,
-0.6444833875,
0.1108842418,
0.584271431,
0.3050085306,
-0.0132380631,
0.5523836017,
0.0140384911,
0.6018667817,
0.1934233457,
0.4286371768,
-0.5424684882,
-0.293998003,
-0.430968076,
-0.1397044212,
0.0936274156,
-0.2767812908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15025v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15025v2 | Dior-CVAE: Pre-trained Language Models and Diffusion Priors for Variational Dialog Generation | 2023-05-24T11:06:52 | 2023-10-23T18:51:10 | Tianyu Yang, Thy Thy Tran, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current variational dialog models have employed pre-trained language models
(PLMs) to parameterize the likelihood and posterior distributions. However, the
Gaussian assumption made on the prior distribution is incompatible with these
distributions, thus restricting the diversity of generated responses. These
models also suffer from posterior collapse, i.e., the decoder tends to ignore
latent variables and directly access information captured in the encoder
through the cross-attention mechanism. In this work, we propose Dior-CVAE, a
hierarchical conditional variational autoencoder (CVAE) with diffusion priors
to address these challenges. We employ a diffusion model to increase the
complexity of the prior distribution and its compatibility with the
distributions produced by a PLM. Also, we propose memory dropout to the
cross-attention mechanism, which actively encourages the use of latent
variables for response generation. Overall, experiments across two commonly
used open-domain dialog datasets show that our method can generate more diverse
responses without large-scale dialog pre-training. Code is available at
https://github.com/UKPLab/dior-cvae. | [
-0.5275496244,
-0.7464994788,
0.3872195184,
0.0367293656,
-0.102762714,
0.059029717,
0.1073325351,
0.1518680155,
-0.0572688878,
0.3906184137,
-0.642967999,
-0.5005393028,
-0.5296291709,
-0.0981826261,
-0.1741428375,
1.0048458576,
0.0769643337,
-0.1384874135,
-0.3010207415,
0.0461611301,
-0.2935367525,
-0.5606118441,
-0.5630680323,
-0.0460275188,
0.4373118579,
-0.0076201386,
0.5083625913,
0.175480485,
0.3347807229,
0.369531095,
-0.1776660681,
0.0688366592,
-0.4715704918,
-0.0170136541,
-0.1216096207,
-0.5622831583,
-0.6048401594,
-0.2207513899,
0.5919271708,
0.8070535064,
-0.4601852298,
-0.4089684784,
-0.0296671074,
0.5044384599,
-0.8763872385,
-0.0155364554,
-0.5414178967,
0.079696171,
-0.0009983488,
-0.2593410611,
-0.1982336789,
-0.1224133149,
0.6680519581,
-0.508746326,
0.3483450711,
-0.2978538871,
0.6969816089,
0.4159353375,
-0.435980469,
-0.4484310746,
-0.9004330039,
0.6376131773,
-0.8442496061,
0.2402427942,
0.4292280376,
0.3702261746,
-0.1974978596,
-0.6669557691,
-0.8202340603,
-0.3534950912,
0.1371545196,
0.442946732,
-0.3791582882,
0.2196081281,
0.0574710742,
0.8594671488,
-0.5699851513,
0.075588055,
-0.1098763272,
-0.0941606462,
0.0570562445,
0.393343538,
0.1976933777,
0.0152771398,
-0.1411475092,
-0.1400994509,
-0.5112748146,
-0.1256664395,
0.5457638502,
-0.0047354717,
-0.4278460741,
0.2238975167,
-0.0202050339,
0.687531352,
0.4830890298,
0.0103487857,
0.3516570628,
-0.3420423269,
-0.5818699002,
-0.4910883307,
0.8253669739,
-0.030165825,
-0.2542918324,
0.052051723,
-0.0282753631,
0.0353492796,
0.1619989425,
-0.8882411718,
-0.3651498556,
0.2052986175,
-0.3919795156,
-0.1131698787,
-0.0896393582,
-0.9089617729,
0.0322272331,
-0.0719936416,
-0.0100282216,
-0.1700927615,
-0.3967315853,
0.1867929995,
0.1310232878,
0.0450307205,
0.3563182056,
-0.8768382668,
0.5873401165,
0.0402496904,
0.450415343,
-0.1529606134,
-0.0421745181,
-0.7239427567,
0.0779661983,
-0.0873003229,
0.3415619731,
-0.7811205983,
-0.7003494501,
0.2773627043,
-0.2925254107,
-0.02991057,
-0.6747485995,
0.2090113759,
-0.6301394701,
0.6789602637,
-0.1583425403,
-0.5461921096,
-0.0757117867,
0.0521883965,
-0.5279186368,
0.662658751,
0.3551333547,
-1.0471634865,
0.2034804076,
-0.3497357666,
-0.3354389369,
0.1066582203,
-0.5587636828,
-0.2705841064,
0.1171475127,
0.4092643559,
0.255417794,
-0.6795711517,
0.248879388,
-0.2135889828,
0.1948710531,
-0.0117531484,
-0.7493863702,
0.4486041069,
0.3938629925,
-0.4366371334,
-0.2439109832,
-0.7683048844,
-0.4314377308,
0.0357333161,
-0.2280496806,
-0.3645690084,
-0.0427765138,
-0.1601617783,
0.3661590219,
0.1427789927,
-0.1801348031,
0.1302282214,
-0.4613176286,
0.2183309644,
0.563467741,
0.1303589642,
0.7126585245,
-0.1608631909,
0.8151555657,
0.7019819617,
0.0084118741,
-0.3338284791,
-0.250041604,
-0.8570258617,
-0.4805654883,
0.1319672018,
0.6186762452,
-0.9283812642,
0.643504262,
0.0736732036,
-0.1869016439,
-0.1835357547,
0.0745814368,
0.388040781,
0.6141352654,
0.0608061478,
-0.5982073545,
-0.4693570435,
-0.8590093851,
0.4752901196,
-0.3320150077,
-0.1432126313,
0.6101358533,
0.3885809183,
-0.6204691529,
0.9898036122,
-0.6944833398,
-0.1496975571,
-0.133857578,
0.471121937,
-0.0412273481,
0.3627466559,
0.8492221236,
-0.8519332409,
-0.3817141056,
-0.1065634415,
-0.4566552639,
-0.2158333361,
-0.0716629997,
-0.0390514918,
0.0518407933,
0.3494638503,
-0.570843339,
0.5943176746,
0.7756991982,
0.186239481,
0.2096017152,
-0.4719089866,
0.1689387411,
-1.326363802,
-0.0678415895,
0.1072232649,
-0.206802249,
-0.5508667827,
-0.5008593202,
-0.4017695487,
-0.0605547242,
-0.3996473849,
0.3529481292,
-0.580126524,
0.1302209347,
-0.3087894917,
-0.016834097,
-0.2409203053,
0.5496165156,
0.4841418266,
0.6369905472,
0.8416492343,
-0.8222228289,
-0.1093739718,
0.2473669499,
0.0943256691,
0.5248725414,
-0.7542164922,
0.1039068028,
-0.4657069743,
0.4788933396,
-1.1801468134,
-0.2269133329,
0.3788175881,
-0.1650669575,
0.446144253,
-0.243184492,
-0.1624393165,
-0.4118308723,
-0.1319603473,
0.5925258994,
0.5792309046,
-0.4214136302,
0.8314537406,
0.4710945189,
-0.3669146895,
-0.5864956975,
-0.609437108,
-0.4255618155,
-0.1147294044,
-0.5084569454,
0.2432264537,
-0.5628221631,
-0.0378055423,
-0.1221888885,
-0.1565194279,
-0.3510032296,
-0.3244570494,
0.2402817607,
0.1445575505,
-0.2649444938,
-0.2053014934,
0.3826198876,
0.0703274384,
-0.0732241124,
-0.3285675347,
0.7003079653,
-0.0632534102,
-0.3863182664,
-0.4690674841,
0.5000321865,
0.6059168577,
-0.2577202022,
0.6687784791,
0.3067050874,
-0.3026168048,
-0.0757030025,
-0.454987973,
-0.0007292225,
-0.5322750807,
0.2327910066,
-0.3985586762,
-0.9498041272,
0.5716130733,
-0.1590123475,
-0.1098931804,
0.3023516536,
1.0675178766,
0.0640187934,
0.7817793489,
0.7588596344,
-0.0824408755,
0.7463763356,
-0.2564976215,
0.0847186223,
-0.6598237157,
0.0679910481,
-0.2415126413,
0.3299214542,
-0.6107873917,
-0.8061663508,
0.1487692297,
0.0267327931,
0.145055145,
-0.043306604,
-0.3341023326,
0.3187008202,
0.2603700161,
-0.4254680276,
-0.0275423471,
0.0581414551,
-0.132339403,
-0.0730150789,
-0.7572056651,
-0.4439094663,
0.7839637995,
0.3690341413,
0.9790756702,
-0.0236463994,
0.8105531335,
0.3321379423,
0.2719685733,
-0.2703095376,
0.2564538121,
-0.145107314,
-0.339542985,
-0.069613114,
-0.6614966393,
-1.0022373199,
0.3578161895,
0.1870137155,
-0.7719894052,
0.6293376088,
0.3600148559,
-0.4941361845,
0.0461178832,
-0.4289919436,
0.5856926441,
-0.0142701389,
-0.1287624985,
0.0478130318,
-0.7856302261,
0.3290381134,
-0.0096668769,
0.0701536238,
0.1676201224,
0.2303708792,
0.371997565,
-0.6079255939,
1.0969871283,
-0.2650768161,
-0.3396964073,
0.45769912,
0.0539843701,
0.4274151921,
0.3687764108,
0.432502985,
0.0175181255,
-0.1513028294,
-0.2731349766,
-0.5233909488,
0.5505051613,
-0.9213367701,
-0.5061635375,
-0.4360561669,
-0.5251989365,
-0.2286125422,
-0.0831350386,
0.6956198215,
0.358628422,
-0.4719650745,
-0.013890964,
0.8808073997,
-0.368078649,
0.2177048922,
0.6408317685,
0.0320153758,
-0.4582142532,
0.7691189647,
-0.0775293782,
0.4165428579,
0.6938393712,
0.0029518111,
-0.2071819305,
-0.6160411835,
-0.1885054857,
0.0574370883,
-0.5762684941,
0.0312166102,
-0.8476750255,
-0.2969575226,
-0.4466588199,
-0.0992925093,
-0.3429675102,
-0.1187405363,
-0.5331817865,
0.0524308048,
-0.1544017792,
0.7540673018,
-0.3050681949,
0.5900720358,
-0.6724014878,
0.5118821263,
0.5818865299,
-0.0794744343,
0.1091468036,
-0.4929096699,
0.0573714897,
0.1854228675,
-0.3261737525,
-0.7962787747,
0.5358595848,
0.1599973291,
0.7730984688,
0.4407479465,
-0.0731008798,
0.330057919,
-0.6055340171,
0.7251422405,
0.4429444671,
-0.9738361239,
0.5407837629,
-0.5917156935,
0.3844082952,
0.5000866652,
0.446560055,
-0.1982462108,
-0.6671452522,
-0.5977469683,
-1.0449219942,
0.6104679704,
0.6023689508,
0.2465056926,
-0.3770498633,
0.274377197,
0.4607324302,
0.4062406123,
-0.479768604,
-0.3968822956,
-0.3665949404,
-0.2676418722,
-0.0191839114,
-0.3219901919,
-0.1177867875,
-0.0269415565,
0.398211658,
0.0320060886,
0.0938192084,
0.2129940242,
-0.234784767,
0.0266321898,
0.1948550344,
0.6770066619,
0.6387938857,
-0.2673793435,
-0.1536994278,
0.0570732988,
-0.5926448703,
0.1663790047,
0.2332989275,
-0.1239539608,
-0.0299720094,
-0.0602047369,
0.8658819795,
-0.2111866474,
-0.4497638941,
0.6173210144,
-0.6139042974,
-0.1988032013,
-0.1980737001,
-0.1047488451,
0.0114328498,
0.0654596239,
0.2979408205,
-0.1881319135,
0.2927618325,
-0.3525871336,
0.30495736,
0.1553901732,
-0.1106165722,
-0.4294353426,
0.7524428368,
0.4814082086,
-0.1346707642,
0.4258639514,
-0.118397586,
-0.1814614385,
0.4705636501,
0.4068320692,
0.9756618738,
-0.4113665521,
0.4091379344,
-0.0003244656,
0.1519978046,
0.2311484665,
0.1021867692,
-0.3710622787,
-0.6036149859,
-0.2813080251,
-0.5786219239,
-0.4086647034,
0.2911325097,
-0.856146276,
-0.2424546927,
-0.4812082946,
-0.2083824724,
-0.076768294,
-0.4098914564,
-0.9989308119,
0.5209626555,
0.3104881942,
0.4750922024,
-0.8919517398,
0.7273920178,
0.400840193,
-0.6045485139,
-0.3359557092,
0.5372730494,
-0.163190186,
-0.2776426077,
0.6896063089,
-0.1191387549,
-0.2973512709,
-0.2273444384,
-0.3573987186,
-0.755918324,
0.7184725404,
0.5236740112,
-0.9214436412,
-0.0345328636,
0.1925118864,
0.7051548362,
-0.6880002618,
0.4261897802,
0.4571642578,
-0.1044676527,
0.4061765969,
-0.7229499817,
-0.2524220645,
-0.2683043182,
0.3684228063,
0.0033943516,
-0.6041832566,
0.9548713565,
0.0428940505,
-0.1618312448,
0.2097454071,
0.9373105168,
0.1208240837,
0.1039454192,
0.5745062232,
0.6496017575,
0.7170370221,
0.2658106089,
1.1520931721,
-0.1589758694,
0.2246907502,
1.3535041809,
-0.4433244467,
0.5692347884,
0.3124061525,
-0.0417320766,
0.7508127093,
0.5739971399,
0.4325176179,
0.9801293612,
0.3698300421,
-0.5051090717,
-0.2159507126,
0.1777706295,
-0.5489180088,
0.2762947083,
0.487934649,
-0.2434325814,
-0.2823015153,
-0.0240644664,
-0.2406934798,
-0.0776615441,
0.0260844622,
0.7459793687,
0.1339689046,
-0.4701322317,
0.6987964511,
-0.2539739013,
0.6741044521,
-0.7084823251,
-0.0243832655,
-0.5013974309,
0.0687865019,
0.0900653973,
-0.1965663433,
0.0959043577,
-0.0559879541,
-0.4374368787,
0.1654251367,
0.4757800996,
-0.59874475,
-0.2327223569,
0.2324558496,
0.6803085804,
0.0395655409,
0.2901669741,
-0.5560878515,
-0.0441340208,
-0.1568214446,
-0.3569202423,
0.3906519115,
0.4726244509,
0.076683104,
0.4283569753,
0.5459033847,
-0.2588471472,
0.3515425324,
0.418195039,
1.209341526,
-0.2194702476,
-0.5777471066,
-0.5793223977,
0.5973864794,
0.0440446101,
-0.3515587747,
0.4195145667,
0.2966923714,
0.6175511479,
-0.0838634521,
1.0165098906,
-0.0588350408,
0.2034680098,
-0.3307897747,
0.3970562518,
-0.6025233865,
0.3370046616,
-0.4579431117,
-0.9684060216,
-0.0294457972,
0.5803871751,
-0.3525371552,
0.3906930089,
0.6082552075,
0.6889370084,
-0.1741559952,
-0.296503216,
0.4071955681,
0.2236099839,
0.5369589925,
0.7781724334,
0.9690545797,
-0.1817729622,
0.4970113337,
0.0535363667,
-0.4376558959,
-0.1124001443,
-0.831710875,
-1.1745730639,
-0.5569586158,
-0.4539328218,
-0.09905947,
0.1064645946,
0.4547677636,
0.8539295793,
-0.6968390942,
-0.0249202251,
-0.4959633052,
-0.15247114,
0.3472177386,
-0.1843418181,
0.1371579319,
-0.2923747599,
-0.9803075194,
0.2510946393,
0.5887246132,
0.5463311076,
-0.4627577662,
-0.1594108194,
0.0369268693,
0.4311853349,
0.3696517646,
0.4688869715,
-0.6859014034,
0.1451366544,
-0.2174879909,
-0.2180009037,
0.1913582385,
0.8748713732,
-0.7326936126,
0.5969316959,
0.6112349629,
0.6154316068,
0.7556413412,
-0.237646088,
1.0184073448,
-0.8482608199,
0.5988305211,
0.3971475065,
0.4434992373,
0.2476281673,
-0.279142648,
0.0733460709,
0.0969096124,
-0.4153329432,
-0.6411648989,
0.5245400667,
-1.0406199694,
-0.0692861527,
0.9372107983,
-0.332637012,
-0.3103091121,
-0.0979956239,
-0.3399246931,
0.0639093444,
-0.459978193,
0.5312519073,
0.534081161,
0.1628642976,
-0.2610760033,
-0.17458947,
0.4670183361,
0.6184705496,
-0.998965323,
0.0156945698,
0.7025375366,
0.3210500479,
0.1316093802,
1.1109247208,
0.0676866695,
0.4498936236,
0.2490154803,
0.0307728667,
0.3489682078,
-0.3393436372,
-0.2638388872,
0.0858873799,
-0.0687990636,
-0.3008978069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15024v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15024v1 | ChatAgri: Exploring Potentials of ChatGPT on Cross-linguistic Agricultural Text Classification | 2023-05-24T11:06:23 | 2023-05-24T11:06:23 | Biao Zhao, Weiqiang Jin, Javier Del Ser, Guang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the era of sustainable smart agriculture, a massive amount of agricultural
news text is being posted on the Internet, in which massive agricultural
knowledge has been accumulated. In this context, it is urgent to explore
effective text classification techniques for users to access the required
agricultural knowledge with high efficiency. Mainstream deep learning
approaches employing fine-tuning strategies on pre-trained language models
(PLMs), have demonstrated remarkable performance gains over the past few years.
Nonetheless, these methods still face many drawbacks that are complex to solve,
including: 1. Limited agricultural training data due to the expensive-cost and
labour-intensive annotation; 2. Poor domain transferability, especially of
cross-linguistic ability; 3. Complex and expensive large models
deployment.Inspired by the extraordinary success brought by the recent ChatGPT
(e.g. GPT-3.5, GPT-4), in this work, we systematically investigate and explore
the capability and utilization of ChatGPT applying to the agricultural
informatization field. ....(shown in article).... Code has been released on
Github
https://github.com/albert-jin/agricultural_textual_classification_ChatGPT. | [
-0.4244233072,
-0.6516655087,
0.1844224483,
0.0654946193,
-0.0379383713,
0.3208939731,
-0.5262314081,
-0.8631293178,
-0.1199216321,
0.3805782497,
-0.127517283,
-0.6659615636,
-0.8819806576,
-0.0046798252,
-0.4997232854,
1.5517555475,
-0.2314793468,
0.0411303416,
-0.164996773,
-0.1167626381,
-0.3301476538,
-0.6818708181,
-0.831572473,
-0.1837259531,
0.4832173884,
0.4733608663,
0.6586244702,
0.0804760903,
0.564871192,
0.3838281929,
0.0245667472,
0.2531370819,
-0.4022788107,
0.1196892634,
-0.0173266698,
-0.3922486007,
-0.2115439028,
0.3397713602,
0.3830961883,
0.4035566747,
-0.0461260341,
0.169986397,
0.1771303266,
0.4010022283,
-0.4116335809,
0.6176579595,
-0.7516098022,
0.3392364979,
-0.3431042433,
-0.3395552933,
-0.398217082,
-0.4565356076,
0.3815691471,
-0.6452204585,
0.3469729424,
0.0726391822,
1.3009468317,
0.198364377,
-0.3311017752,
-0.3704219759,
-0.6641175151,
0.601099968,
-0.5488945842,
-0.0182145797,
0.5837450624,
0.6773419976,
-0.1466614455,
-0.9446431398,
-0.6167657375,
-0.0765931681,
-0.1257806122,
0.3721528351,
0.0985975191,
-0.0293967109,
-0.0670045614,
0.6132956743,
-0.416859597,
0.0936710089,
-0.1419851482,
-0.061270237,
0.4951795936,
-0.060013596,
0.2768256962,
0.1848063469,
-0.4335702062,
-0.1427316219,
-0.3570986688,
0.2658045888,
0.3696280122,
0.274695158,
-0.0182976518,
0.3285614848,
-0.2521468103,
0.5179595351,
-0.1779838204,
0.1562448591,
0.3701411188,
-0.4607855976,
-0.0623889752,
-0.1893836409,
0.9068322182,
0.3073013425,
0.3375377953,
0.1942558438,
-0.1450484544,
0.2176703215,
0.1909074932,
-0.6763135791,
-0.4564804733,
-0.0522344783,
-0.3984467983,
-0.5217155814,
-0.0238618329,
-0.9765419364,
-0.5111274719,
0.0272291005,
0.3141052127,
-0.4697216153,
-0.0018280093,
0.0626075715,
-0.0274521858,
0.6179413199,
0.358341217,
-0.8627346754,
0.1230961978,
0.8692802787,
0.8375549912,
0.0575979464,
-0.2813201845,
-0.1866877377,
-0.1738706231,
0.0387794524,
0.9737850428,
-0.8658735156,
-0.2235369384,
0.0341970921,
-0.0471292958,
-0.4483110011,
-0.2873140872,
0.700399518,
-0.5755957961,
0.2889660001,
0.0352804698,
-0.6249611974,
-0.5010800362,
0.6591948867,
-0.4081636965,
0.7934780121,
-0.0558729656,
-0.8192036152,
0.5204976201,
-0.5517186522,
-0.4893931448,
0.3410597444,
-0.2217196226,
-0.8609635234,
-0.5109515786,
0.0205713045,
0.6498554945,
-0.3834257126,
0.2873687744,
-0.1864232123,
0.0116431015,
0.3314030766,
-0.6991124749,
0.4543936253,
0.3957933486,
-0.2430171967,
0.0821587369,
-0.5860034823,
-0.0349358246,
0.15493837,
-0.4333750904,
-0.1855656207,
0.0518855304,
0.2299901694,
-0.1309712827,
0.197737515,
-0.4195174873,
0.2900253832,
-0.3157944381,
0.3729082346,
0.4851886034,
-0.2220373154,
0.3659091592,
-0.4554302096,
0.5704308152,
0.0520891175,
0.2385930568,
-0.2023214251,
-0.8089851737,
-0.8434694409,
-0.1152531654,
0.9132757187,
0.8536108136,
-0.8760020733,
0.2141772658,
-0.2406001091,
-0.6891945004,
-0.3604247868,
-0.1810299605,
0.1680699438,
0.4072660506,
0.3392798603,
-0.3729459345,
-0.3927848637,
-0.7020152211,
-0.2697852552,
0.1299674958,
0.1498022228,
0.261693716,
0.4707480073,
-0.4797123969,
0.9232798219,
-0.5131201148,
-0.5586340427,
-0.3286749125,
0.3822845817,
0.2360855937,
0.3166996539,
0.6497347951,
-1.0007573366,
-0.7977200747,
0.7368921638,
-0.5128232837,
-0.2933671176,
-0.0488824919,
-0.0095294965,
0.2325258553,
0.0856465176,
-0.8488817215,
0.6493126154,
0.6532016397,
-0.3688718081,
0.617492795,
-0.0415004194,
0.2396211624,
-0.9927625656,
-0.1685450375,
0.1444487572,
-0.4618757069,
-0.5140287876,
-0.0339818038,
-0.3232583404,
-0.1411112398,
-0.2483948767,
0.3519164026,
-0.2769972086,
0.1353657097,
-0.4246174395,
-0.0991016626,
-0.1015320271,
0.4706965089,
0.003230188,
0.8989455104,
0.665501833,
-0.3892198205,
0.3792998791,
0.2585980296,
-0.0508843884,
0.3950408995,
-0.2516051829,
-0.2919227183,
-0.1108972654,
0.5091969967,
-0.7388216853,
-0.1636736542,
0.8900856376,
-0.5826507807,
0.3873539567,
-0.1371988952,
-0.3147673309,
-0.0612613298,
-0.2928937376,
0.3067998588,
0.5637251139,
-0.3998550475,
0.8148130774,
0.4461990595,
-0.2757513523,
-0.1059413105,
-0.4555033147,
0.1145763919,
-0.2665856183,
-0.4641830921,
-0.0070330878,
0.129803434,
0.1131493077,
0.081616953,
-0.02324396,
-0.2145434469,
-0.0749646947,
0.2162576318,
-0.1079039946,
-0.2366269827,
0.2460473776,
-0.0336001404,
-0.1921285689,
-0.0481149107,
-0.6305518746,
0.515640676,
-0.4742183685,
-0.1029792279,
-0.2911886871,
0.2246791124,
0.1306571066,
-0.5338714719,
0.7313825488,
0.7482542992,
-0.113879174,
-0.292837292,
-0.3435407877,
0.3151500523,
-0.4706366956,
0.2552675009,
-0.2389211506,
-0.8407864571,
0.2055565566,
-0.5492743254,
-0.02032944,
0.5887108445,
0.3098644912,
-0.1566000581,
0.6305571198,
0.5015698671,
-0.014360412,
0.3738089204,
-0.5042389631,
0.0950667113,
-0.4077706039,
-0.4499346912,
-0.6944553852,
-0.2560341656,
-0.8721166849,
-0.7521260977,
0.0990368053,
-0.4204139709,
-0.0040408857,
0.1390997171,
-0.3425524533,
0.6681876779,
0.6138295531,
-0.0665753409,
0.3363981545,
0.0182905663,
0.1008838415,
0.2565600872,
-0.8719245195,
-0.6331676841,
0.7115672827,
0.4026067853,
0.739713788,
-0.2972444296,
0.4287595451,
0.4552194178,
0.5343668461,
-0.9438098073,
0.5973943472,
-0.5636959076,
-0.0813455358,
-0.1872861534,
-0.525650084,
-1.3585083485,
0.2647666931,
-0.3394625783,
-0.4827032387,
0.124458909,
0.1743981242,
-0.0584195517,
0.3682159185,
-1.0943650007,
0.9994109869,
-0.4584530592,
-0.0830038711,
0.0224889666,
-0.7184806466,
-0.1556956917,
-0.1964845806,
0.2271169573,
-0.1500514299,
0.0380885266,
0.5806455016,
-0.4714854062,
1.2521225214,
-0.0995393023,
-0.0173751675,
0.3542028964,
-0.246984154,
0.5048270226,
0.1509601921,
0.1841742396,
0.6043946743,
-0.0482871532,
-0.3757983148,
-0.3370920718,
0.6804768443,
-0.7426787019,
-0.4467481971,
-0.9288173318,
-0.382217139,
-0.2844851613,
0.1203947663,
0.2119259536,
-0.0400149636,
-0.0850101262,
0.1660435051,
0.5520945787,
-0.3106490672,
0.2913598716,
0.3348916173,
-0.3385581374,
-0.2321570516,
1.0826045275,
0.2445383966,
-0.0996460915,
0.4517523348,
0.2612637877,
0.0768095404,
-0.6999989152,
-0.2632617056,
-0.2898628116,
-0.5414628386,
-0.6385542154,
-0.643675983,
-0.6069772243,
-0.0531268939,
-0.0165926255,
-0.2634963691,
-0.2390671074,
-0.5134194493,
-0.0049181194,
0.4893087447,
0.674471736,
0.4206776023,
0.5361191034,
-0.9166312814,
0.0031130102,
0.1976334751,
0.6704344153,
-0.0277037248,
-0.1296213269,
-0.3097116649,
0.2229542136,
-0.5246796608,
-0.9171916842,
0.5317364335,
0.4474043846,
0.4350973964,
0.0960270911,
-0.11720597,
0.3477522135,
-0.5474054813,
0.5072035193,
0.0023722304,
-0.7887574434,
0.3722307384,
-0.3894863725,
0.4121848941,
0.4717666209,
0.6182805896,
-0.5290200114,
-0.3584516943,
-0.3697729409,
-1.1977027655,
0.5015141964,
0.4709920287,
-0.0515847765,
0.2989614904,
0.0075725275,
0.7747174501,
0.040483214,
-0.7462864518,
0.1760494411,
-0.3956589699,
-0.3564939201,
-0.0012010775,
-0.1403750479,
0.2186562121,
-0.1852882653,
0.9115571976,
-0.0573614985,
-0.0112601388,
0.2153818756,
-0.1864626259,
0.2342199981,
0.3768836856,
0.14579615,
0.2921924889,
0.2792190611,
0.1864825934,
0.2610549033,
-0.6042898297,
0.1013377383,
0.5777779222,
-0.5078774095,
-0.1104343534,
0.2054696381,
0.874509871,
0.0747257769,
-0.4062567353,
0.4574554861,
-0.2095124722,
-0.2581128478,
-0.4976370931,
0.0190959312,
-0.1669822037,
0.5409020782,
0.3179391623,
0.3578539193,
0.4044824243,
-0.1585706621,
0.131443128,
0.3169265389,
-0.1581172198,
-0.2381118983,
0.4390790164,
0.4767871201,
-0.2285256088,
0.3033046722,
-0.310986191,
-0.8423306346,
0.5482156277,
0.289871335,
0.7940439582,
-0.0347294435,
0.5982352495,
-0.0780956596,
0.0878403783,
-0.0252461731,
0.0863305554,
0.0011661159,
-0.7348242402,
-0.4683050811,
-0.8469384909,
-0.5083024502,
0.0420140997,
-0.0524210855,
0.1482739896,
-0.2793594301,
-0.2529247105,
0.259868741,
-0.0333141908,
-0.6972488165,
0.2117769718,
0.2899241447,
0.7180131674,
-0.7350246906,
0.759285748,
0.9172356129,
-0.2566253245,
-0.5783870816,
0.1665409803,
-0.2198224068,
-0.5217956901,
0.4777201116,
0.4139527977,
-0.0489914678,
-0.0544231832,
-0.628934145,
-0.5335182548,
0.7143641114,
-0.1358089894,
-0.6311935782,
0.3948035836,
0.4500296116,
0.8240089417,
-0.1025743186,
0.157000646,
0.2495838106,
0.7139898539,
0.1577994525,
-1.0678262711,
-0.2726558149,
-0.4044068754,
-0.0201524049,
0.4661981761,
-0.853488028,
0.5744698048,
0.2350310087,
-0.2986530662,
0.0611942671,
0.6989434958,
-0.3260922432,
0.6430091262,
0.4121928811,
0.6198892593,
0.6125596762,
-0.3983240426,
0.9780783057,
-0.0140433013,
0.6804643273,
0.9602901936,
-0.361836493,
0.6423409581,
0.265119642,
-0.2614913285,
0.3768310249,
0.7539102435,
-0.3489316404,
0.3946845233,
0.1912112385,
-0.3825974166,
-0.0353627205,
-0.285954535,
-0.5536105633,
0.7388073206,
0.4273600876,
-0.2283745259,
-0.3575105071,
0.1815406084,
0.0676328987,
0.1265649348,
-0.3729127645,
0.7264040112,
0.0704197437,
-0.4351841211,
0.0635844767,
-0.0532273017,
0.7347009182,
-0.7558877468,
-0.2818829715,
-0.0916527808,
0.1543586403,
-0.1900196075,
-0.978529036,
0.3804143071,
0.0383460447,
0.0193927623,
-0.3995502293,
1.1993206739,
-0.5241516232,
-0.431398958,
0.1969046593,
0.255921483,
0.1838199496,
0.0174996741,
-0.5202422142,
-0.1670413166,
-0.1783237457,
-0.3206253052,
0.2794530392,
0.6357596517,
-0.2136264145,
0.5272368789,
0.7308329344,
0.1027235165,
0.1283729821,
-0.1491064131,
0.9185171127,
-0.6727292538,
-0.4993627667,
-0.7368745804,
0.0712828487,
-0.3029100597,
-0.2322053164,
0.7854966521,
0.7123484612,
1.1993893385,
-0.296312809,
0.980050683,
-0.2509904504,
0.1812249571,
-0.5205453634,
0.773794353,
-0.2446058691,
0.2191649079,
0.0890324116,
-0.6477808952,
-0.360512197,
0.3107548356,
-0.6139187217,
0.0496279597,
0.6024372578,
0.3616327047,
0.0541520864,
0.2949633598,
0.2052800655,
0.2589429319,
0.0786172897,
0.6677193642,
1.1312994957,
-0.1645894498,
0.8112892509,
-0.0615858547,
-0.3084611297,
-0.1149912402,
-0.8794746399,
-0.7653027773,
-0.4008741677,
-0.2625132203,
0.0792501494,
0.4125144482,
0.7530456185,
0.6054044366,
-0.9392209053,
-0.0426768735,
-0.0807722434,
-0.1185598671,
-0.0705589503,
-0.2253453434,
0.2808559835,
-0.3818145096,
-0.6449872255,
-0.0952259451,
0.2818363905,
0.1557785869,
0.0666248947,
-0.0118543077,
-0.4716445208,
-0.2322883457,
0.6747324467,
0.4159078896,
-0.3178233206,
-0.1907888353,
-0.3977357745,
0.0513369851,
0.1704280078,
0.5779497027,
-0.7786237001,
0.1916856021,
0.5994697213,
1.118208766,
0.5051746964,
0.0727068633,
0.4291568398,
-0.6959266663,
0.190496251,
0.3814154863,
0.1234055832,
0.3176827133,
-0.4969568551,
0.661452651,
0.2308831811,
-0.7795510888,
-0.1849347651,
0.195270434,
-1.1084675789,
-0.2221936136,
1.175160408,
-0.3438425362,
-0.2955375612,
-0.0470065549,
-0.6525359154,
0.3635662496,
-0.3927965462,
0.7672874928,
0.5730596185,
0.0924918056,
-0.1917743087,
-0.723846972,
0.425748229,
0.3405624032,
-1.1471871138,
-0.2927313447,
0.3023455739,
-0.0157436412,
0.0598092265,
0.4111446142,
0.1370275617,
0.017558543,
0.0400103964,
0.1871664077,
0.0520041324,
-0.2668325305,
0.0531052686,
0.2910950482,
-0.0082633886,
-0.4767285883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15020v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15020v3 | An Efficient Multilingual Language Model Compression through Vocabulary Trimming | 2023-05-24T11:00:33 | 2023-10-19T10:30:02 | Asahi Ushio, Yi Zhou, Jose Camacho-Collados | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual language model (LM) have become a powerful tool in NLP
especially for non-English languages. Nevertheless, model parameters of
multilingual LMs remain large due to the larger embedding matrix of the
vocabulary covering tokens in different languages. On the contrary, monolingual
LMs can be trained in a target language with the language-specific vocabulary
only, but this requires a large budget and availability of reliable corpora to
achieve a high-quality LM from scratch. In this paper, we propose
vocabulary-trimming (VT), a method to reduce a multilingual LM vocabulary to a
target language by deleting irrelevant tokens from its vocabulary. In theory,
VT can compress any existing multilingual LM to build monolingual LMs in any
language covered by the multilingual LM. In our experiments, we show that VT
can retain the original performance of the multilingual LM, while being smaller
in size (in general around 50% of the original vocabulary size is enough) than
the original multilingual LM. The evaluation is performed over four NLP tasks
(two generative and two classification tasks) among four widely used
multilingual LMs in seven languages. Finally, we show that this methodology can
keep the best of both monolingual and multilingual worlds by keeping a small
size as monolingual models without the need for specifically retraining them,
and even limiting potentially harmful social biases. | [
-0.5691550374,
-0.6990067363,
-0.1243601441,
0.0927638561,
-0.4163867235,
0.1701981723,
-0.5971179605,
-0.2351359129,
0.5236986279,
0.278224349,
-0.5260846019,
-0.4213723242,
-0.3002672493,
0.1741187721,
-0.1602805853,
0.629570365,
0.1715627015,
0.0752163455,
-0.0729681179,
-0.3021186292,
-0.6461771131,
-0.786768198,
-0.7774215937,
-0.1153556183,
0.6455435753,
0.3345988989,
0.5618720055,
0.847442925,
0.236089766,
0.3293614388,
-0.4692366421,
0.5363553762,
-0.5316081047,
-0.0555418469,
0.051169835,
-0.3658290803,
-0.2980300784,
-0.2336177975,
0.8067857623,
0.8897621632,
-0.296402812,
0.2289907038,
0.3668834865,
0.4386049509,
-0.6480287313,
-0.0228694472,
-0.6223127842,
0.1087537184,
-0.086526528,
-0.269171536,
-0.5589703918,
0.0861093327,
-0.4390215874,
-0.4315750003,
0.1391843408,
0.0630341768,
0.9372175932,
0.0410881899,
-0.2421512455,
0.110588178,
-0.5020711422,
0.9959587455,
-0.6549532413,
0.7273596525,
0.296620518,
-0.0908143818,
0.1929094791,
-0.2223968506,
-0.372292906,
-0.0571870357,
0.0607809834,
0.0117794275,
-0.0381986313,
0.0442614034,
0.0215867385,
0.2634119093,
-0.6119213104,
0.4193557203,
-0.5997277498,
-0.43642658,
0.2181675285,
-0.1551785022,
0.2960555553,
-0.2884238958,
-0.5236737728,
-0.0106038582,
-0.7363770008,
-0.2175330818,
0.4878552854,
0.7040219903,
-0.0524772853,
0.4490341246,
0.2734206021,
0.6623056531,
-0.4689758718,
-0.571285069,
0.1468560845,
-0.5081625581,
-0.0854630917,
-0.1207839251,
0.6378959417,
0.5204459429,
0.3145418763,
-0.2168632746,
-0.011731131,
0.0928138942,
0.0060489755,
-0.6304809451,
0.1609438956,
0.1499864757,
-0.5466365814,
0.0830371007,
-0.3407257199,
-0.7180512547,
0.1286761612,
-0.2561023831,
0.0387279019,
-0.7468548417,
-0.4690715969,
0.2415994406,
-0.0020420812,
0.0289029181,
0.1929215342,
-0.6303431988,
0.2995066047,
0.703389287,
1.2819068432,
-0.2158024162,
-0.4740759432,
-0.6476319432,
0.1672774851,
-0.3933411241,
0.4168585539,
-0.1725571901,
-0.4878537059,
0.2209561318,
-0.1216338798,
0.080666557,
-0.4961380064,
0.5213457346,
-0.4624996483,
0.1095550954,
-0.0291152522,
-0.6884333491,
-0.1500190347,
0.7339360714,
-0.8478070498,
0.9375990033,
-0.1611459404,
-0.495595485,
0.3147159219,
-0.2524490654,
-0.2059849501,
0.2206298411,
0.1570965797,
-0.2350518852,
0.1037428901,
0.2412011772,
0.3334164619,
-0.161775887,
0.0667578727,
-0.3370550275,
-0.163109526,
-0.1497908235,
-0.5078167319,
0.6733088493,
0.2296745926,
0.4327554703,
0.013529378,
-0.5408030748,
0.2946529984,
-0.073769547,
-0.5515930653,
-0.5674483776,
-0.2400988191,
0.4007343352,
0.5861126781,
0.3845853806,
-0.5898708105,
0.2854061723,
-0.7110823989,
0.2804855406,
0.5583521128,
-0.2562776804,
0.5984939337,
-0.3911857903,
0.7728697062,
-0.1688015759,
0.1419542581,
-0.1853459775,
-0.2956841588,
-0.9777162075,
-0.7351964116,
0.7286109924,
0.4985641539,
-0.9414870739,
0.5216993093,
-0.5367996097,
-0.3010901809,
-0.5433706641,
0.3301373422,
0.4804315865,
0.1998828202,
0.2940298915,
-0.2457452118,
-0.4719825685,
-0.9901162982,
-0.2883054018,
-0.0779108554,
0.0807329044,
-0.1626089513,
0.2853417695,
0.2426161766,
0.673820436,
-0.299263984,
-0.3486886919,
-0.5826488733,
-0.0918943733,
0.0512412079,
0.5356181264,
0.4311171472,
-0.7635635138,
-0.4917800128,
-0.0428129584,
-0.2620081007,
0.0937739462,
-0.0109617114,
0.0646790043,
0.2621843219,
0.5541684031,
-0.5993710756,
0.3074342906,
0.6441796422,
-0.0609531403,
0.4921478331,
-0.5537991524,
-0.2011730969,
-1.2418706417,
0.0791432336,
-0.1115421578,
-0.544234395,
-0.8534625173,
0.3487599492,
0.2472784817,
-0.0631034523,
-0.9184113145,
0.9388446808,
-0.6867530942,
0.3337619603,
-0.2148996741,
0.0807737336,
0.0139457965,
0.5953953862,
0.1502235532,
0.5815125108,
0.4000510871,
-0.8374861479,
-0.0247683153,
0.1713890433,
-0.4172036946,
0.1891446263,
-0.2243398577,
0.0302837845,
-0.3420172036,
-0.0585287213,
-0.4967434108,
0.1549776793,
0.0246488359,
-0.2281005234,
0.5476610661,
-0.2824138403,
-0.7079304457,
-0.1448040158,
-0.4649074674,
0.375107199,
0.4481578469,
-0.4544201195,
0.4535209239,
0.4280440509,
-0.08678177,
-0.7131547332,
-0.7524819374,
0.3388844132,
-0.5012707114,
-0.5005775094,
0.5211404562,
-0.2339283526,
-0.0024042276,
-0.2030715942,
0.1261075884,
-0.1203030199,
0.0607622974,
-0.2054209262,
0.3309803903,
0.0712881684,
0.5215438604,
-0.0362898596,
-0.1484368294,
-0.4431709945,
-0.2987559438,
1.0030477047,
-0.031445127,
-0.3547936678,
-0.141720593,
0.7725141644,
0.3363383412,
-0.4025572836,
0.9664694071,
0.6415741444,
-0.540607512,
-0.3784153461,
-0.485493809,
-0.0974835157,
-0.4352419972,
0.5228995681,
-0.5050190687,
-1.0483552217,
0.6066834927,
-0.1643572301,
0.1519251615,
0.3574829996,
0.5927175879,
0.4363380373,
0.8422742486,
0.878385067,
-0.2524745464,
0.5093952417,
-0.272125721,
0.1348950565,
-0.5452039838,
0.0425709598,
-0.6107001901,
-0.1744632125,
-0.6501442194,
-0.7286544442,
0.4850321412,
0.222616747,
0.1176890582,
0.2919413447,
-0.4794220626,
0.6731069684,
0.6385279894,
-0.0176825579,
0.1758061349,
0.325966835,
-0.2528330684,
-0.0446491316,
-1.1892169714,
-0.4069179893,
0.7678644657,
0.3184902668,
0.3800846636,
0.3182689846,
0.8433037996,
-0.0908283889,
0.2007455379,
-1.077298522,
0.4297920167,
-0.3969653845,
-0.5703815818,
-0.3195019066,
-0.7062072754,
-1.0453556776,
0.4756293595,
-0.0308747012,
-0.7842424512,
0.0216501504,
0.118051149,
-0.3308493495,
0.5635593534,
-0.6042975187,
0.6411038637,
0.0215007216,
-0.2777235508,
-0.2821471095,
-0.4744122028,
0.2069223374,
-0.2652778327,
0.7139884233,
-0.1797581017,
-0.3177637756,
0.7649373412,
-0.8061347604,
0.7931088805,
-0.0234803371,
-0.1117761061,
0.1779410392,
0.234167695,
0.1662806869,
-0.1051919982,
-0.0331025198,
0.477611661,
0.2715574503,
-0.4929872751,
-0.5098292232,
0.6787573099,
-0.4799689054,
-0.3062925041,
-0.2778188586,
-0.6521230936,
-0.1830064356,
0.2481407672,
0.3102861345,
0.4000512362,
-0.353659451,
-0.0368191078,
0.3331984878,
-0.3983965516,
0.6125118732,
0.4155499339,
-0.3992246985,
-0.3283113241,
1.0980120897,
0.4404303133,
0.2250618339,
0.646371007,
0.2838588357,
-0.3516163528,
-0.4009669125,
-0.4453077018,
0.3312428296,
-0.7572205067,
-0.4412170351,
-0.491920203,
0.0039810417,
-0.3157143295,
-0.0543560982,
-0.5460113287,
-0.5673979521,
-0.0096475519,
0.1675249636,
0.0983502939,
0.2046337575,
-0.3168571889,
0.2552478015,
-1.0752309561,
0.1261993349,
-0.0636166111,
0.2703051865,
-0.0086863963,
-0.5124781728,
-0.4885982275,
0.1285285205,
-0.034996938,
-0.7036268711,
0.893754065,
0.6012285948,
0.2087905556,
0.2592065632,
-0.1032616422,
0.8558160067,
-0.7121839523,
0.7515429258,
0.5223963261,
-1.0659995079,
0.0103854062,
-0.0838240013,
0.655133009,
0.4011613727,
0.1707561463,
-1.0556414127,
-0.3097861409,
-0.3933857679,
-0.9971273541,
0.6423349977,
0.0620830432,
0.4000376165,
-0.3552853167,
0.3360888362,
0.1518746912,
0.1591631621,
-0.7896511555,
-0.3429972827,
0.0674479827,
-0.2511891425,
-0.2385185808,
-0.3225696385,
0.0282957498,
-0.2327150404,
0.685456872,
-0.1143675894,
0.1375553161,
-0.1211160868,
-0.1237674579,
0.191044271,
0.3927122056,
0.4816627502,
0.313429445,
0.0209080577,
0.3334506154,
0.4632000029,
-0.3439792097,
0.2357715368,
-0.1794680357,
-0.0796009451,
0.3214294016,
0.4499501288,
0.4105676115,
0.1457672566,
-0.7570346594,
0.3952326179,
-0.1383012086,
-0.1413743347,
-0.1503957808,
-0.3060306013,
0.1933726519,
-0.2554436922,
-0.042693913,
0.0343896672,
-0.0817878619,
-0.3692141175,
0.0688815713,
0.4613577724,
-0.1647905558,
-0.1277873069,
0.3271968365,
-0.0703563392,
-0.3847540021,
0.4976212978,
-0.2361142635,
-0.6029676199,
0.426936239,
0.5167114735,
0.5564208627,
-0.5573278069,
0.0160444565,
0.5285144448,
0.5794283152,
-0.1676070988,
0.273355037,
0.1483630389,
-0.8613547087,
-0.8861755729,
-0.7309061289,
-0.1627752334,
0.2887538671,
-0.7039310336,
0.4780189693,
-0.2313143462,
-0.1646067798,
-0.0051895389,
-0.112852402,
-0.7437061071,
0.1910665929,
0.1935738474,
1.2282978296,
-0.5470981002,
0.9844070673,
0.4968005717,
-0.2350084782,
-0.8385428786,
-0.3355295658,
-0.0532098562,
-0.7118852139,
0.5662432909,
0.2965438366,
-0.185174644,
-0.1267938763,
-0.3213740587,
-0.9923297763,
0.403496474,
0.6798213124,
-0.5503711104,
-0.147518307,
0.2637576759,
0.4834243655,
-0.1068621054,
-0.0549278632,
-0.005160355,
0.2991857827,
-0.0854025334,
-1.0826810598,
-0.1934140772,
-0.3583971262,
0.1135359854,
0.4975652397,
-0.69955796,
0.9457082748,
0.2163918167,
-0.3248131871,
0.2268604487,
0.6746032238,
-0.1419130713,
-0.271792531,
0.697794497,
0.4569446146,
0.856541574,
0.0088954223,
0.9568446279,
-0.7623835206,
0.4997198284,
0.9462822676,
-0.1257098466,
0.8232899308,
0.6293919683,
0.1017613932,
-0.1242477968,
0.6062368751,
0.2141423225,
0.4031711221,
0.4038697779,
-0.2711271048,
-0.509362936,
-0.3190362751,
-0.2695820928,
0.8018192053,
0.3533438444,
-0.0392731801,
-0.327177912,
0.1698126942,
0.3832811713,
-0.0044324258,
-0.3854710758,
0.59509027,
0.0894512162,
-0.7084787488,
1.0133746862,
0.5533823371,
0.8855963945,
-0.7956851721,
0.1453155726,
-0.209140256,
0.1779730618,
0.134466961,
-0.1948092878,
0.5500136018,
0.0193130672,
-0.0398019366,
-0.5345217586,
0.6941255927,
-0.8946866989,
-0.7554174662,
0.4895801544,
1.0262186527,
0.4366641641,
0.099739112,
-0.6536367536,
-0.0496826433,
-0.1178677008,
-0.0615658537,
0.4540261626,
0.207149297,
0.0914965421,
0.7612127662,
0.5770856142,
0.429207027,
0.0075546741,
0.1695464551,
0.7598122358,
-0.4461701512,
-0.6493151188,
-0.9100503325,
0.1534184664,
-0.1009721309,
-0.3413826227,
0.9212091565,
0.8129452467,
0.9980577826,
-0.0394370519,
0.5805769563,
0.2193182558,
0.5580294132,
-0.6329945326,
0.6977519393,
-1.0052870512,
0.1231965572,
-0.0705986395,
-0.7459981441,
-0.5128408074,
0.4645444155,
0.1084400043,
0.1512836665,
0.5657513142,
0.7303781509,
-0.0900369734,
-0.3762482107,
0.7648926973,
-0.1128815338,
0.0975830704,
0.2888506353,
0.6074448228,
-0.077020444,
0.6620396972,
-0.4133000374,
-0.0871454924,
0.1096391603,
-0.8023570776,
-0.9382687807,
-0.4837940037,
-0.3245080411,
-0.332891196,
-0.2392595559,
1.1087223291,
0.8634509444,
-0.5892421007,
-0.5333755016,
0.1793187708,
0.2392884046,
-0.5132597685,
-0.1417888701,
0.5425206423,
-0.366289705,
-1.0506976843,
0.458014667,
0.2548268437,
-0.1511315554,
-0.3689750731,
0.0170114562,
-0.4989607334,
0.0876055136,
0.6898645163,
0.0029704818,
-0.7210493088,
-0.1386297047,
0.0162506085,
0.1417232752,
0.1837944537,
0.6154837012,
-0.5251374245,
0.5906766653,
0.2581475377,
0.2147963941,
0.3901981413,
-0.3527548015,
0.4774980843,
-1.4663034678,
0.5000526905,
0.1662472785,
0.6454070807,
0.4998527765,
-0.0835049301,
0.2972319424,
0.0912221745,
-0.0742652044,
-0.8723735809,
0.2920264304,
-0.7910678387,
-0.6539506316,
1.2598638535,
-0.2180790901,
-0.3671888411,
-0.1770347953,
-0.2069295794,
0.4369242787,
-0.2493328452,
0.566950202,
0.8548141718,
0.547026813,
-0.2040160596,
-0.2266604453,
0.4335767329,
0.5542080402,
-0.6089413166,
0.080926843,
0.3188712001,
0.1251714528,
0.4352220893,
0.4504620433,
0.1473823041,
0.0318181738,
0.0145850349,
0.5584580898,
-0.1877534986,
-0.2676960826,
-0.4381597042,
0.6052530408,
-0.0401976332,
-0.1904891133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15017v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15017v2 | Calc-X and Calcformers: Empowering Arithmetical Chain-of-Thought through Interaction with Symbolic Systems | 2023-05-24T10:58:20 | 2023-10-23T15:23:22 | Marek Kadlčík, Michal Štefánik, Ondřej Sotolář, Vlastimil Martinek | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite outstanding performance in many tasks, language models are
notoriously inclined to make factual errors in tasks requiring arithmetic
computation. We address this deficiency by creating Calc-X, a collection of
datasets that demonstrates the appropriate use of a calculator in reasoning
chains. Calc-X is suitable for teaching language models to offload computations
to a symbolic system. We survey and unify several existing chain-of-thought
datasets into a proposed format, resulting in a standard collection of over
300,000 samples requiring arithmetic reasoning. Finally, we use the new Calc-X
collection to train open-source calculator-using models we call Calcformers and
show that these models approximately double the accuracy of generating correct
results compared to vanilla language model baselines. We make all Calc-X
datasets, source code and Calcformers models publicly available. | [
-0.082249634,
-0.3534183502,
0.6164808273,
-0.0099516753,
0.2076451778,
0.1596401781,
0.141343534,
-0.3004554808,
0.2484988123,
0.5570431948,
-0.4567036331,
-0.2315829247,
-0.581623435,
0.0224935189,
-0.6261762977,
0.901601553,
-0.326574862,
0.3326950073,
-0.3558177352,
-0.1425879002,
-0.126009956,
-0.7901269794,
-0.6121758819,
-0.253769666,
0.3994664848,
0.1282303333,
1.078435421,
0.5838826299,
0.3570269942,
0.3042738736,
0.4696802795,
0.0794385076,
-0.4617433548,
-0.0218293741,
-0.3381878138,
-0.9436087608,
-0.5846514702,
-0.0806917474,
0.6597601175,
0.8396844268,
-0.3161854148,
0.3141249418,
-0.6779305935,
0.74734056,
-0.9769551754,
0.6975156665,
-0.413579613,
-0.0822737291,
-0.0863588303,
0.1428264678,
-0.5950712562,
-0.9404793978,
-0.1904317886,
-0.794885397,
-0.1634507775,
0.1105735525,
0.2838867009,
0.1217988133,
-0.4295315146,
-0.4264823496,
-0.7691498995,
0.7305240631,
-0.5473176241,
0.5895214677,
0.6053408384,
0.5034832954,
0.0819200724,
-0.6472207904,
-0.510990262,
-0.1278513223,
0.0781969205,
-0.016749924,
-0.5225076079,
0.0054830639,
0.6007688046,
0.553778708,
-0.2042337805,
-0.1573861092,
-0.5968413353,
0.1820048839,
0.5228304863,
0.2965721786,
0.3170480728,
0.2294947654,
0.0926908776,
-0.3554923236,
-1.0810658932,
0.0459759943,
0.2382638901,
0.0432043485,
0.0214374568,
0.7683022618,
-0.0569342822,
0.6265152097,
-0.1304081231,
0.1641232818,
-0.0270881653,
-0.1081997603,
-0.4612769485,
0.3938306868,
0.6981553435,
-0.0519883707,
0.3878434896,
0.0263043512,
-0.414604634,
0.4433524907,
0.330524385,
-0.6529448032,
-0.6100853086,
-0.1183758602,
0.2023845762,
-0.4696111977,
0.2330409288,
-0.1593655944,
0.0307736192,
-0.6684710383,
0.5031208396,
-0.0540467016,
0.0245446693,
0.2528007925,
-0.2670269608,
-0.4091910124,
0.3159634769,
-0.8112827539,
0.9944183826,
0.6207399964,
0.5958998799,
0.4341576397,
0.0759560764,
-0.6013969183,
0.0316350274,
-0.617559731,
0.509011507,
-0.5904545188,
-0.3423113227,
-0.1573875546,
-0.0373687819,
-0.0281161256,
-0.3272236884,
0.5491091013,
-0.5031422973,
0.1711301953,
-0.6208029985,
-0.6060174108,
-0.148998037,
0.1074219272,
-1.1436784267,
1.0912731886,
0.3444425464,
-0.6042234302,
-0.1756593287,
-0.5940385461,
-0.1839842498,
-0.0226313472,
-0.5282266736,
0.0220270287,
0.4047386348,
0.139356181,
-0.0799659267,
-0.6506603956,
0.1750401109,
-0.3689651787,
-0.2472569942,
0.3686792552,
-0.461499691,
1.0559877157,
0.0474713258,
-0.4956348538,
-0.0995931551,
-0.7688766122,
0.2733018994,
0.0675678775,
0.1599392742,
-0.5826179385,
0.129002586,
-0.3954975009,
0.6382141113,
-0.0671843141,
-0.6567750573,
0.0674307421,
-0.3723443747,
0.334384501,
0.7567611933,
-0.509208262,
0.1849404126,
-0.5440268517,
0.6578961611,
-0.0912132412,
-0.1377118826,
-0.2778384089,
-0.3152672946,
-0.7990401387,
0.3102751374,
0.1607126445,
0.5527818203,
-0.8725265265,
0.2710545957,
-0.3324655294,
-0.6636689901,
-0.2478670925,
-0.0663429126,
0.7170203924,
0.447608918,
0.0631472319,
-0.0696698278,
-0.4916684926,
-0.5955658555,
-0.1129982695,
-0.2283706665,
0.0161744356,
0.2963114381,
0.5073797107,
0.4025385082,
0.9344367385,
-0.7671135664,
0.2559700012,
0.0800829157,
0.0289927684,
-0.0269233175,
0.3226374388,
0.3200984597,
-0.5991994143,
-0.2147864401,
0.0730474442,
-0.9065633416,
-0.0790042579,
0.1005440131,
-0.2097709328,
0.1354799569,
0.0768847391,
-0.4168618619,
0.5420537591,
0.6030769348,
-0.2401521504,
0.8750645518,
-0.3687001169,
0.1458634436,
-0.7036027908,
-0.1143261641,
0.1536684781,
-0.3376084864,
-0.4303246439,
0.1078591123,
0.2258912921,
-0.1546395719,
-0.5053123236,
0.3878139257,
-0.2346698046,
0.0312540643,
-0.0427079536,
0.1352839619,
0.1028528064,
0.2265156209,
0.0309914891,
0.823651433,
0.6083274484,
-0.2452499121,
0.4732549489,
0.1901013106,
-0.1654071957,
0.3779994249,
-0.5961185694,
0.0814277977,
-0.001267458,
0.424831003,
-0.4872804582,
-0.0554845221,
0.1511174142,
-0.0937626585,
-0.1415787339,
0.0981912017,
-0.4919097424,
-0.6069615483,
-0.3054304719,
0.6370524764,
0.4663562477,
-0.6638180017,
0.4112497568,
0.4827449322,
-0.0582144186,
-0.4743047655,
-0.5567299128,
-0.079107143,
0.3864831626,
-0.5574794412,
-0.0516755506,
0.0159975681,
-0.4949707985,
-0.0540807806,
-0.3490576148,
-0.2532001436,
-0.2786511779,
0.455866158,
0.4620881081,
-0.2546043694,
0.3069289625,
0.242712155,
-0.0535687692,
0.8493462205,
-0.5179972649,
0.1517063528,
-0.2201140076,
-0.7349435091,
-0.2321046293,
0.2728376091,
0.7118985653,
-0.2342462242,
0.5112765431,
-0.1627758592,
-0.7291308641,
-0.0170063619,
-0.4087519348,
-0.0596008562,
-0.4257401228,
0.1867823005,
-0.2948987782,
-0.7124124169,
0.1398333609,
0.0957375094,
0.164100036,
0.2665096521,
0.4884221256,
0.3004751503,
1.4964983463,
0.423517853,
0.0064347382,
0.1238080636,
-0.3391743302,
0.4557763338,
-0.3025608361,
-0.1233755499,
-0.5395262837,
0.0620199852,
-0.508656919,
-0.5138346553,
0.189811945,
-0.1128073409,
-0.5325245261,
0.4140310287,
-0.3090012372,
0.7598699927,
0.4967526197,
0.1252928823,
0.2809765041,
-0.0076468922,
-0.039213527,
0.0475164019,
-0.6605211496,
-0.5687013865,
1.0397161245,
-0.0015054838,
1.0873323679,
0.0613665022,
0.426879853,
0.1642740071,
0.3878087699,
-0.5846722722,
0.4033441842,
-0.4130428135,
-0.6778318882,
0.0300872065,
-0.6508457065,
-0.3617327511,
-0.0929281265,
0.163905412,
-0.7506389618,
0.215887323,
0.3857073188,
-0.359346658,
0.7003756762,
-0.6617459059,
0.7284079194,
-0.3761371076,
-0.239007771,
-0.3082434833,
-0.4994263649,
0.6903368235,
-0.3421861529,
0.3585678339,
0.0769071728,
0.2267719805,
0.6504961848,
-1.0428854227,
0.8393499851,
0.1085184962,
-0.4188214839,
0.455290556,
0.335921973,
0.6329117417,
-0.1856787801,
-0.219854787,
0.130512014,
0.2701204419,
-0.2900609076,
-0.8625730872,
0.6468583941,
-0.7778803706,
-0.5072025657,
-0.4626722932,
-0.6005033255,
-0.0294530466,
0.0892233923,
-0.1312419772,
1.021478653,
-0.1120673865,
0.0008335758,
0.4630466998,
0.4480621815,
0.1013405621,
0.1682120115,
-0.4376079142,
-0.5247943997,
1.1015950441,
0.3418116271,
0.6417884827,
0.5130432248,
0.1649021953,
-0.2146571428,
0.3316739202,
-0.5072227716,
0.0660508201,
-0.9094001055,
-0.2837513387,
-0.5667836666,
-0.2546918988,
-0.3250167668,
-0.2620532811,
-0.3802629113,
-1.1864055395,
0.0723608434,
-0.2685378194,
0.3368339241,
1.0073275566,
-0.2694697678,
0.3793618083,
-0.8298469782,
0.1306298971,
0.2240274101,
0.2469469458,
0.1349677294,
0.044562716,
-0.3276963532,
0.6044183373,
-0.5217922926,
-0.8688881397,
0.4489642084,
-0.0027805411,
0.1847584993,
0.4693126678,
0.0817895308,
0.5817584395,
-0.4059211612,
0.5353104472,
0.5661635995,
-1.2767956257,
0.4699803889,
-0.0754473209,
0.24268803,
0.2066163272,
0.9248262644,
-0.5149300694,
-0.4187785089,
-0.6886125803,
-0.332600385,
0.8800373077,
0.521448493,
-0.0943094864,
-0.3637365699,
0.1962718517,
0.1089770347,
0.175605014,
-0.591190815,
-0.4798783064,
-0.4292826653,
-0.295062691,
0.1629414558,
0.130307436,
-0.1318828464,
-0.3557957411,
0.7778534293,
-0.1679625511,
-0.0189156439,
-0.1623865515,
-0.1597867906,
-0.4507568777,
0.274478972,
0.4075586498,
0.8702407479,
-0.1478034705,
0.5052983761,
0.183924824,
-0.7186559439,
0.3969343901,
0.1495471299,
-0.1020331755,
-0.1360123456,
-0.1630271673,
0.7266046405,
0.6658844352,
-0.9000954628,
0.2825160325,
-0.092796959,
-0.0482687689,
-0.4192366898,
0.3424268961,
-0.0181596205,
-0.2839313447,
0.0860763937,
0.2480911016,
0.0582775846,
-0.4084196985,
0.1105133295,
0.1528746933,
-0.5938242078,
-0.62054497,
0.5686571598,
-0.0133419819,
-0.4163113534,
0.9037882686,
-0.1536719054,
-0.6063807607,
0.6595144868,
0.879599154,
0.5658061504,
-0.1796962172,
0.1303742677,
0.4092433155,
0.1985778064,
-0.3146475852,
0.4054947197,
-0.3132327795,
-0.5577788949,
-0.5603585839,
-0.2294711024,
-0.6722637415,
-0.4731014073,
-0.8382572532,
0.3883114159,
-0.4545880854,
-0.1478462219,
0.1614872962,
-0.1182680205,
-0.5081816316,
0.2546207905,
0.2585862875,
1.1073315144,
-1.02977705,
0.7829943895,
0.655382812,
-0.5602062345,
-1.0341047049,
-0.805573225,
0.1450381279,
-0.7469981909,
0.9435822964,
0.1395609975,
-0.4023643136,
0.1221278384,
-0.4325642586,
-0.882058084,
0.9760637283,
0.4755015373,
-0.8050240874,
-0.4171172082,
0.5512979031,
0.1789103001,
-0.2919974923,
0.8312891722,
0.6402612925,
0.2673627734,
0.2558449507,
-0.8609939218,
0.2462072521,
-0.347741276,
-0.2910735905,
0.7203933597,
-0.3590116501,
0.9673716426,
-0.3393782377,
-0.1035485119,
0.1921158433,
0.3044607043,
0.5069872737,
0.2400764972,
0.3393458724,
0.9056904912,
0.8044006824,
-0.2159730792,
1.0921138525,
-0.250764668,
0.2226834446,
1.2249211073,
-0.3395993114,
0.7711909413,
0.1387006193,
-0.5539926887,
0.6938681602,
0.1351882964,
0.2274511606,
-0.0752824545,
0.4474344254,
-0.6057708263,
-0.51225245,
0.1168324724,
-0.2669229209,
0.0617589913,
0.5756284595,
-0.3163578808,
-0.5999638438,
-0.3289857507,
0.1397208571,
-0.0889488086,
-0.3334961236,
0.2683149576,
0.279933095,
-0.4996533692,
0.3451708257,
-0.3394005895,
0.0751626268,
-0.5937634706,
-0.3674404919,
0.1973224431,
0.4004864991,
-0.2312776148,
-0.7630062103,
0.2513231039,
-0.0292196926,
-0.3536171317,
-0.1109181866,
0.5832721591,
-0.1851321459,
-1.1147459745,
-0.0932487175,
0.5786851048,
0.2366848588,
-0.2087691277,
-0.4609083831,
-0.0687365606,
-0.1815716624,
0.2814021409,
0.1196238026,
0.5478402376,
-0.5573970079,
0.6329067349,
0.8653898835,
0.0263944734,
0.2769032121,
0.2391563654,
0.9854102135,
-0.7235699892,
-0.4148159325,
-0.7348130941,
0.2607591748,
0.078740485,
-0.1987002045,
0.7793903947,
0.6201117039,
0.8874337673,
0.0562369637,
0.6940334439,
-0.0301316045,
-0.0360853523,
-0.121757403,
0.6234495044,
-0.1702957451,
0.0956312194,
-0.0775744021,
-0.6496118903,
-0.2033017278,
0.3618851006,
-0.549492836,
0.0474376939,
0.897352457,
0.6973707676,
-0.1546191573,
0.8270591497,
0.2869783342,
0.0314234383,
0.4512143731,
0.6636068225,
0.8983332515,
-0.7349437475,
0.4217427671,
-0.6824455857,
-0.4066580534,
0.2943688631,
-0.8805806637,
-0.5782361627,
-0.3531830907,
-0.4563491642,
-0.1746358275,
0.2017882913,
1.1532803774,
0.7116680741,
-0.8106763363,
-0.6032558084,
-0.5204725862,
0.2155872732,
-0.164761126,
-0.1634697616,
0.2780970335,
-0.3734099567,
-0.5517612696,
0.0039214655,
0.2495129406,
-0.0681195408,
-0.4170674384,
0.0279580448,
0.0838726461,
0.1906030774,
0.7624347806,
0.3817074597,
-0.5674953461,
0.1555414647,
0.2872703969,
0.0525998287,
0.0666708574,
1.1717861891,
-1.1238906384,
0.6042715907,
0.4044543505,
0.3825964332,
0.2058564126,
-0.1946289837,
0.7703269124,
-0.3759331405,
-0.3146774769,
0.0185981505,
0.5320679545,
0.0494824275,
-0.2647362053,
0.3302166462,
0.1125009134,
-0.5325712562,
-0.7676059604,
-0.0100710699,
-0.8246279955,
0.1366132498,
0.5930255651,
-0.2202397287,
-0.5629396439,
0.1072344184,
-0.1721999496,
-0.0061230878,
-0.3313568532,
0.6533620358,
0.4517870247,
-0.1220110655,
0.0885993764,
-0.3562988043,
-0.0282563791,
0.1435044408,
-1.0305759907,
0.359330982,
0.6956703663,
0.0333232433,
0.3823298812,
0.3329473734,
-0.2888532877,
0.5571787953,
0.2782446146,
0.0882332772,
0.0081669418,
-0.1910348833,
-0.1327780336,
-0.030986486,
-0.0814190581,
0.1831114441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15014v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15014v1 | Unlocking Temporal Question Answering for Large Language Models Using Code Execution | 2023-05-24T10:57:53 | 2023-05-24T10:57:53 | Xingxuan Li, Liying Cheng, Qingyu Tan, Hwee Tou Ng, Shafiq Joty, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have made significant progress in natural
language processing (NLP), and are utilized extensively in various
applications. Recent works, such as chain-of-thought (CoT), have shown that
intermediate reasoning steps can improve the performance of LLMs for complex
reasoning tasks, such as math problems and symbolic question-answering tasks.
However, we notice the challenge that LLMs face when it comes to temporal
reasoning. Our preliminary experiments show that generating intermediate
reasoning steps does not always boost the performance of complex temporal
question-answering tasks. Therefore, we propose a novel framework that combines
the extraction capability of LLMs and the logical reasoning capability of a
Python solver to tackle this issue. Extensive experiments and analysis
demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework in handling intricate time-bound
reasoning tasks. | [
-0.0661422908,
-1.0244332552,
0.9217126369,
0.4193256199,
-0.1380623132,
0.3865623176,
-0.17275621,
-0.5728438497,
-0.4312228858,
0.5260119438,
-0.7073855996,
-0.3092641234,
-0.4434609115,
0.2773413658,
-0.4494022131,
0.6406112313,
-0.1866615117,
-0.0976889506,
-0.1965292841,
-0.0303202104,
-0.3377612233,
-0.5882820487,
-0.7665891051,
-0.4154370427,
0.4286266267,
0.1388307214,
0.7429919243,
0.6802383661,
0.4369445741,
0.3037617505,
-0.2438126951,
0.1823124737,
-0.074236095,
0.1910553426,
-0.411880374,
-0.7528729439,
-0.3581701219,
-0.2442266345,
0.7615724206,
0.7652047276,
-0.2064891905,
0.2925756276,
-0.3683278859,
0.3689652383,
-0.5640433431,
0.2367181331,
-0.8458508253,
0.1285837442,
-0.0138310464,
-0.4793590903,
-0.4113067091,
-0.4157209098,
0.1245610267,
-0.2782954276,
-0.0848330557,
-0.0774560198,
0.568980217,
0.4084176123,
-0.3182926774,
-0.320979923,
-0.8445636034,
0.8409560919,
-0.9533314705,
0.0633961782,
0.0327019282,
0.4148946702,
-0.2359933853,
-0.7666649222,
-0.7685443759,
-0.1014278755,
0.0953511894,
-0.3897277713,
-0.0359516069,
0.0903772116,
0.827778995,
0.1114769503,
-0.7366074324,
0.0720606446,
-0.1401656419,
0.0790421739,
0.3415070772,
0.6594013572,
0.3786366582,
-0.0297597479,
-0.2223026752,
0.3163380623,
-0.6621614695,
0.1747296751,
0.0065798513,
0.0346497223,
0.0435901545,
0.863406539,
-0.3632356822,
0.8108115196,
-0.2679543197,
-0.0198575072,
-0.1347164959,
-0.1369745731,
-0.2191021293,
-0.0033806039,
0.4899243116,
0.1247999445,
0.4498872161,
-0.1907647699,
-0.2284199744,
0.1537253261,
-0.0378988683,
-0.9619528651,
0.0670681447,
0.683108151,
-0.1258151829,
-0.1800102741,
-0.148119688,
-0.6296171546,
-0.0769720376,
-0.3843903542,
0.1483242214,
-0.2904229164,
-0.2107903212,
0.2787835598,
-0.0606734529,
0.6451181173,
0.3494852185,
-0.5953267813,
0.3301168978,
1.0152703524,
0.8240416646,
-0.0103192339,
-0.207403928,
-1.0039658546,
0.3317499757,
-0.5572952032,
0.571081996,
-0.9608195424,
0.0225647036,
-0.0623151064,
-0.0191885643,
-0.1479633898,
-0.5500041246,
0.1679325253,
-1.007895112,
-0.050185848,
-0.1823948622,
-0.5999854207,
0.1614839584,
0.3846272826,
-0.4701459706,
1.0759860277,
-0.0494115949,
-0.6023542285,
-0.1379541457,
-0.6088368893,
-0.3353957236,
0.0608086139,
-0.3768970668,
-0.185079962,
0.067594327,
0.524520576,
0.4423846304,
-0.4225027859,
0.3763590753,
-0.4022933543,
-0.3688210249,
0.661644876,
-0.4241494238,
0.8521365523,
0.308267206,
-0.411247462,
-0.0020312092,
-0.5372896194,
0.3626659214,
0.3390967548,
-0.3627382219,
-0.0600010306,
0.2451484054,
-0.3443511724,
0.4746469855,
0.3554252386,
-0.542776823,
0.5412505269,
-0.2815596759,
0.6530620456,
0.9429123402,
0.0691954792,
0.3972387612,
-0.3095950186,
0.7046139836,
-0.020109266,
0.0482382104,
-0.1790652275,
-0.2625237107,
-0.7119236588,
0.0266876277,
0.0716974512,
0.67047894,
-1.1056568623,
0.2140350342,
-0.3114981651,
-0.395108819,
-0.0957784802,
0.1315165758,
0.5794406533,
0.4168156981,
0.2931717038,
0.4370349944,
-0.3489189148,
-0.559538424,
-0.4669831097,
-0.2975552678,
-0.1361415684,
0.2225477844,
0.584349215,
-0.1457795501,
0.9754030108,
-0.92204988,
0.2366200536,
-0.414367944,
0.2101205885,
0.623752594,
0.4723081887,
0.2697980106,
-0.8669921756,
-0.0376452133,
-0.2080391645,
-0.7887772918,
-0.3915981948,
-0.4651868641,
-0.1106285825,
0.3405297697,
0.7558961511,
-0.7156640887,
0.2773796916,
0.4691878855,
-0.3519956768,
0.9758236408,
-0.1643005908,
-0.0288427714,
-0.8277210593,
0.0283732396,
-0.3085632622,
-0.3127628863,
-0.4582572579,
0.219367981,
0.1363194883,
-0.3235016167,
-0.4411673546,
0.5077947974,
-0.3576160669,
-0.1449087709,
-0.2671217918,
0.0264066756,
0.0596419312,
0.5763685107,
0.4061384499,
0.6593843102,
0.328086704,
-0.6000592709,
0.2902216315,
-0.0728882998,
-0.406814754,
-0.0174149778,
-0.9405059218,
0.4604724646,
-0.0123729566,
0.3076010346,
-0.537479341,
-0.0977248028,
0.0081731938,
-0.3303385079,
0.1497393101,
-0.4192071855,
-0.7632498741,
-0.313238889,
0.0410843007,
0.6178673506,
0.3383921385,
-0.5502186418,
0.7124590278,
0.1303243786,
-0.4378662109,
-0.6665924788,
-0.5352897048,
0.1543268859,
-0.1125615686,
-0.4440065324,
0.2505736947,
-0.086881727,
-0.4935828447,
-0.0009415865,
-0.3666766882,
-0.1307474375,
0.0815646276,
-0.193193987,
0.418645978,
-0.2397734225,
0.0899126306,
0.2424767017,
-0.2405646145,
0.4171710312,
-0.3381082714,
0.7924816608,
-0.334860146,
-0.4426518977,
-0.294680059,
0.5199136138,
0.7375265956,
-0.6055696607,
0.8077064753,
0.3335298002,
-0.606471777,
-0.4575989544,
-0.5821903348,
0.0606077649,
-0.4778559208,
0.356325984,
-0.429046154,
-0.8647094965,
0.5179331899,
-0.1201198772,
0.2168507427,
0.1000889838,
0.6098864079,
-0.1022886187,
1.1798696518,
0.1629929692,
0.0017819364,
0.5534159541,
-0.2507554889,
0.1033722162,
-0.7930122614,
-0.1926820576,
-0.5890875459,
-0.0164251104,
-0.2416160405,
-0.7390680909,
0.4205090404,
0.366622448,
-0.3580287099,
0.2260196358,
-0.1609148383,
0.6888373494,
0.2668741643,
0.1211663783,
0.4321096241,
-0.3248464465,
-0.0008836664,
0.2884068489,
-0.5286621451,
-0.5966261029,
0.922152102,
0.1059782654,
0.8777431846,
0.1638024449,
0.4156840742,
0.0435233861,
-0.1033282578,
-0.4001395106,
0.7470337152,
0.0694651008,
-0.6291274428,
-0.368925482,
-0.7674714923,
-0.6699998975,
0.298986882,
0.0209671929,
-0.9026045203,
-0.2235491127,
-0.0886180401,
-0.381269604,
0.4211630821,
-0.6477932334,
0.7710245848,
-0.3432134688,
-0.3068804145,
-0.2198531628,
-0.739513278,
0.2120081037,
-0.0038235937,
0.1527234465,
-0.2893331647,
-0.1788805127,
0.6825361252,
-0.5710211992,
0.6352558732,
-0.1434684992,
-0.1421699673,
0.4133693874,
0.3760160506,
0.730383575,
0.4231877327,
-0.0358102508,
-0.0105001964,
0.4335443676,
-0.5147147179,
-1.0075751543,
0.6209515333,
-0.4011942744,
-0.7760421038,
-0.6287621856,
-0.9520587921,
-0.1898739338,
0.0660036653,
-0.2125363201,
0.837723732,
0.2785216868,
-0.0066965171,
0.6092760563,
-0.3405918479,
0.6929737926,
0.5769154429,
-0.4303274155,
-0.1263271123,
0.5544635057,
-0.0136209736,
0.6026995182,
0.6521492004,
0.3343963921,
-0.4328300655,
-0.5546145439,
-0.3089277744,
0.2522196472,
-0.7362259626,
0.0074455207,
-0.795797646,
-0.3798047304,
-0.3082176745,
-0.12885952,
-0.2890630364,
-0.6553359628,
-0.1278192103,
0.1406622678,
0.251495719,
0.3731041253,
0.3487822115,
-0.037990123,
-1.0116878748,
0.6901881695,
0.3118887842,
0.1709713787,
-0.0381664485,
-0.34292081,
-0.0097764488,
-0.0412674695,
-0.1317724288,
-0.5597552657,
0.256824255,
0.0526380092,
0.3727735281,
0.2131472081,
0.2997306287,
0.9221566319,
-0.6782162786,
0.637206316,
-0.1531185955,
-1.0001348257,
0.618001163,
-0.3933907747,
0.647716403,
0.0611451194,
0.294064045,
-0.4987922907,
-0.453271389,
-0.4353186488,
-0.7049634457,
0.5240271688,
0.4150695801,
-0.16855672,
-0.1385120451,
0.3855574727,
-0.1283930689,
0.0935599208,
-0.6370587945,
0.0443970747,
0.3491772115,
0.0395180173,
0.0121020349,
-0.113845326,
0.0361903161,
-0.339718461,
0.2813252211,
-0.2975157797,
0.2843655348,
0.30997172,
-0.3571827412,
-0.0356586017,
0.4948174953,
0.3142956197,
0.9755754471,
-0.1805573702,
0.182803899,
0.2607699037,
-0.1444548666,
-0.0501277708,
0.0302570127,
0.0665066615,
-0.2336014062,
0.8514538407,
0.2503229082,
0.0995361656,
-1.0593011379,
0.3614668846,
-0.1187678203,
0.1926540285,
-0.5697270036,
0.0914306566,
0.1851495802,
0.6784645319,
0.4641507864,
-0.1006306857,
-0.2017841935,
-0.5932583809,
0.1134825349,
0.2654286027,
-0.0882170945,
-0.1719887853,
0.6926685572,
-0.0620881654,
-0.3625389636,
0.8681064248,
-0.0388527773,
-0.8226730824,
0.9741446376,
0.8337579966,
0.8191048503,
0.109393537,
-0.0967686698,
0.1613060832,
0.2472161055,
0.0973057896,
0.5503981113,
-0.1492046863,
-0.6122385263,
-0.9828492999,
-0.7154901028,
-0.4839929342,
-0.1650716364,
-0.7039480805,
0.1096795946,
-0.4042474031,
0.1548931301,
-0.2194440514,
0.0072121019,
-0.5516589284,
0.0767334402,
0.2369991243,
1.0086292028,
-0.4833346903,
0.9720396399,
0.3830062449,
-0.1074273065,
-0.6829465628,
0.1028467044,
-0.2598802447,
-0.5265128613,
0.6649019718,
0.2495553643,
-0.2772493958,
-0.0193870496,
-0.551713407,
-0.6453225017,
1.0616265535,
0.4720192552,
-0.6604425311,
-0.4161939323,
0.332841903,
0.5014898777,
-0.263319701,
0.1772663742,
0.7231242657,
0.1427559555,
0.1913317442,
-0.6800512075,
0.2255721539,
-0.3341422379,
-0.0196702834,
0.2195154876,
-0.2673982084,
0.8741692305,
-0.618444562,
-0.199761197,
0.3393464088,
0.649299562,
0.672530055,
0.2560049295,
0.5825658441,
0.3477028608,
0.729940474,
-0.1915440559,
1.3586121798,
-0.2081582248,
0.2579879463,
1.2688535452,
-0.4467430711,
0.8746097088,
0.5508370399,
-0.2851423919,
0.5179461837,
0.5051462054,
0.4348224401,
0.2139396816,
0.2480666637,
-0.3879894018,
-0.6762385368,
-0.0020512431,
-0.3252831101,
0.3465416133,
0.4882685244,
-0.0106056798,
-0.2271925509,
-0.2696906924,
0.1002838388,
-0.0518783145,
-0.3724608421,
0.5354239345,
0.1209967658,
-0.7001955509,
0.5282869339,
-0.1737452596,
0.2021267861,
-0.6640034914,
-0.3573497534,
-0.0118445912,
0.3548870683,
-0.0642440021,
-0.9425593019,
0.3899375796,
0.3073518276,
-0.0552171543,
-0.1497511715,
0.3070683181,
-0.3112797737,
-0.6103565097,
0.3611320853,
0.4000013173,
-0.1076418608,
-0.2369725853,
-0.6919644475,
0.0885439515,
-0.3921743035,
-0.3773935437,
0.1392453164,
0.6383336782,
-0.0728543624,
1.1441212893,
0.8216770887,
0.124076657,
0.3497102559,
0.112997368,
1.1382306814,
-0.7900694013,
-0.3959490955,
-1.1487983465,
0.2297771275,
-0.0325818583,
-0.152856186,
0.4389234185,
0.5984820724,
0.768212378,
0.0613897815,
0.5754550695,
-0.1945540905,
0.3565427363,
-1.0096395016,
0.3754570186,
-0.3618406057,
0.6536266804,
-0.4810816348,
-0.8926918507,
-0.4284999371,
0.280364871,
-0.499458313,
-0.2396544516,
1.003210783,
0.8171830773,
0.2789565027,
0.0805436596,
0.1341853291,
0.2724560201,
0.7973920703,
1.0646713972,
1.2608309984,
-0.1272906661,
0.8065592051,
-0.390098691,
-0.1373459995,
0.2689819634,
-1.0713742971,
-1.0582455397,
-0.3782939017,
-0.1837361306,
-0.42413643,
0.0605966225,
1.2044434547,
0.2686772048,
-0.7476232648,
-0.1406420469,
-0.0882326216,
0.2264438123,
-0.4642569721,
-0.2570179105,
0.502119422,
-0.5094556808,
-0.8293308616,
0.4064709544,
0.2525544465,
-0.3552393913,
0.0708075091,
-0.0091628842,
-0.4349027872,
0.0517133921,
0.6730545163,
0.2331717312,
-0.737324059,
-0.4446713626,
0.1495012343,
0.0941860974,
-0.0789537355,
1.1602070332,
-0.6716077328,
0.327039361,
0.6319792867,
0.8388863802,
0.5748294592,
-0.0380758196,
0.6541680098,
-0.4943427444,
-0.002198224,
0.4894247949,
0.574215591,
-0.1628735512,
-0.2031141073,
0.4759338498,
0.2046941221,
-0.5857981443,
-0.9266287684,
0.3646055162,
-1.0352584124,
-0.5037190914,
1.3049603701,
-0.2162893265,
-0.4060525894,
-0.2659279406,
-0.0977231413,
0.2662936747,
-0.2302205563,
0.578646183,
0.4970242381,
-0.2621038258,
-0.070342131,
-0.4584542513,
0.0424039364,
0.2274940461,
-0.8875204325,
0.3290858269,
0.3175614774,
0.3127243817,
-0.0246751457,
0.547279954,
-0.4435362518,
0.3055341542,
-0.1837661564,
-0.2952272296,
-0.2620184422,
-0.5174310803,
-0.281437248,
0.2129057497,
-0.0434651226,
0.0453821234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15011v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15011v2 | Bactrian-X: Multilingual Replicable Instruction-Following Models with Low-Rank Adaptation | 2023-05-24T10:50:31 | 2023-10-10T07:46:44 | Haonan Li, Fajri Koto, Minghao Wu, Alham Fikri Aji, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning has shown great promise in improving the performance of
large language models. However, research on multilingual instruction tuning has
been limited due to the scarcity of high-quality instruction-response datasets
across different languages. To bridge this gap, we present Bactrian-X, a
comprehensive multilingual parallel dataset of 3.4 million instruction-response
pairs across 52 languages. Leveraging this dataset, we train a set of adapters
using low-rank adaptation (LoRA), which are lightweight components that
seamlessly integrate with large language models. These adapters have a
substantially lower parameter count than the base model, making them easily
replaceable and usable as plug-ins for different languages or language groups.
Extensive experiments in various multilingual evaluation settings demonstrate
that models derived from LoRA-based training over Bactrian-X outperform both
the vanilla models and existing instruction-tuned models. The code and models
are publicly available at https://github.com/mbzuai-nlp/bactrian-x | [
-0.0980494916,
-0.5253241658,
0.3053023517,
0.1735640019,
-0.1114304736,
0.2720890641,
-0.544467926,
-0.2330803871,
0.2333549559,
0.3966575861,
-0.498722285,
-0.4779193997,
-0.5557894111,
-0.0439103581,
-0.188860938,
0.9884148836,
0.0914934799,
0.1826446503,
0.0591619574,
-0.4856517017,
-0.6524775624,
-0.3520077169,
-0.5834249258,
-0.0942911133,
0.8949035406,
0.8192483783,
0.7593840957,
0.8394224644,
0.1514316201,
0.2599237859,
0.0785915181,
0.334846288,
-0.6550428867,
-0.0836591721,
-0.2649680972,
-0.5168774128,
-0.7074840069,
-0.2379719168,
0.9737223983,
0.9421752691,
-0.2707450986,
0.3042758405,
0.0802438259,
0.4958932102,
-0.6819727421,
0.1881261766,
-0.3964529634,
-0.193973884,
-0.1373777688,
0.0282538366,
-0.8099971414,
-0.5298461318,
-0.2001311928,
-0.7277145386,
-0.01991014,
0.0601123087,
0.23198241,
0.1565781087,
-0.3395230472,
-0.0476463251,
-0.5576019287,
0.7586858273,
-0.6755888462,
0.5025135279,
0.4044075608,
0.2800273895,
0.1006585285,
-0.4574169219,
-0.3486556411,
0.0000916248,
-0.1666596234,
0.2228024751,
-0.1318294108,
-0.3304530382,
0.2400243729,
0.3380627036,
-0.8152856827,
0.3119693696,
-0.2478944212,
0.3202771842,
0.2046011984,
0.1886918843,
0.1629439741,
0.140246585,
-0.1060229763,
-0.3686302304,
-0.8420904875,
0.138967365,
0.2153615505,
0.5459573269,
-0.4421281219,
0.1475310922,
-0.1003613025,
0.9008443356,
0.0741706714,
-0.1159340367,
0.18914029,
-0.3087283075,
-0.1125329956,
0.3741235733,
0.6167446375,
-0.0469358563,
-0.1318249553,
-0.0881806687,
0.1111086458,
0.1104135737,
0.0319819413,
-0.96385777,
-0.3931589723,
-0.1382108182,
-0.313393414,
-0.2481326163,
-0.1960663199,
-0.5682819486,
-0.307351619,
-0.1156630665,
0.3588096499,
-0.5001491904,
-0.2145130783,
0.2364684045,
0.2417093664,
0.1594991982,
0.4208879173,
-1.1694275141,
0.6127693057,
0.703506887,
0.8866579533,
-0.1468489617,
-0.6118129492,
-1.0616904497,
0.1873261333,
-0.5268856883,
0.7291398644,
-0.8507354856,
-0.513643086,
-0.2378376275,
0.5087639093,
-0.3360853791,
-0.3811825514,
0.3840555549,
-0.3725946546,
0.1983189285,
-0.5077822804,
-0.2829313576,
-0.2353936136,
0.0752863213,
-0.7096478939,
0.827636838,
0.2933273315,
-0.6752399206,
0.1148696095,
-0.5133572221,
-0.6742326021,
0.1210850999,
-0.0748710483,
-0.2890454829,
0.2523882091,
0.2353923023,
0.0744392946,
-0.529240489,
-0.5409649611,
-0.307184279,
-0.5866898894,
0.010114667,
-0.4625525475,
0.820311904,
-0.0708061382,
-0.3660151064,
0.1740095913,
-0.8088209629,
0.1207031012,
-0.0792978108,
-0.4160471857,
-0.565210402,
0.186044082,
-0.1234178618,
0.1202443317,
0.1716685295,
-0.5794535279,
0.4095171392,
-0.1802782118,
0.4110689461,
0.7210363746,
-0.3536278307,
0.3497329056,
-0.4162341952,
0.6339107752,
-0.0087229712,
0.1197261661,
-0.5495272279,
-0.3935635984,
-0.8023433685,
-0.476793617,
0.2744549513,
0.6327316165,
-0.6339359283,
-0.1737578362,
-0.5282949805,
-0.6591733098,
-0.7071765661,
0.2660617232,
0.6313401461,
0.5233511329,
0.4559347928,
-0.1939995438,
-0.1477092355,
-0.3738269806,
0.0772757009,
-0.1051043049,
0.5303173661,
0.2956673801,
0.0822515488,
-0.1351604611,
0.2544971704,
-0.5170392394,
0.0449501798,
-0.2590717375,
0.2076630294,
0.4665312767,
0.4618879259,
0.7155430913,
-0.3926137984,
-0.8951778412,
0.6943820715,
-0.6737786531,
0.1203942522,
0.0561805367,
-0.1454480439,
0.3352949917,
0.3327311873,
-0.1981022209,
0.1255498677,
0.8447512984,
-0.0262145791,
0.6303036809,
-0.5227725506,
0.2863073349,
-1.3222873211,
0.0922156796,
-0.2721580565,
-0.3814691007,
-0.438336432,
0.2302688956,
0.4385114014,
-0.211513713,
-0.4413517118,
0.68340379,
-0.5307462215,
-0.0290395617,
-0.3825101852,
-0.1184156984,
-0.0471059494,
0.4085416198,
0.3208796084,
0.9326928854,
0.7053715587,
-0.3082559705,
0.4107971489,
0.450766474,
-0.6119573116,
0.6281206012,
-0.7163324356,
0.157756865,
0.1575736552,
0.101649493,
-0.7377206087,
-0.2283743173,
0.1841988564,
-0.1971452236,
0.1048302501,
-0.5941463709,
-0.4646143615,
-0.1692850441,
-0.1819029152,
0.667784512,
0.5754146576,
-0.9318163395,
0.4722510576,
-0.0789609402,
-0.5787767172,
-0.9951888323,
-0.4804882705,
-0.0962186754,
0.0243646763,
-0.2624120414,
0.1450669765,
-0.3705440462,
0.0821646899,
-0.1253991872,
-0.0019711419,
0.0565618873,
0.0018385018,
0.2767144144,
0.328263402,
-0.6099894047,
-0.2679675519,
0.5035136342,
-0.0170414783,
-0.0859936997,
-0.2877342105,
0.3444150686,
-0.0331932791,
-0.3435804248,
-0.3509394228,
0.438912183,
0.6614966989,
-0.4453829527,
0.7091034651,
0.4448483288,
-0.2284451425,
-0.5463433862,
-0.1705920547,
0.0426067524,
-0.4780706763,
0.5422811508,
-0.3817781508,
-0.6137409806,
0.2882551849,
0.08694686,
0.1031320095,
-0.2531196177,
0.6933581829,
0.1097073406,
1.1669611931,
0.7796514034,
-0.2781614363,
0.4008084238,
-0.1076044887,
-0.1151707619,
-0.5266479254,
0.0543667786,
-0.3711265028,
-0.1583937556,
-0.7023748755,
-0.4711810946,
0.4369761646,
-0.2364419401,
-0.1037734821,
0.5919780731,
-0.150845021,
0.6789782643,
0.5937814713,
0.0174421463,
0.258309871,
0.04643251,
-0.0293896757,
0.2469760627,
-0.8119668365,
-0.1529343724,
0.9647808075,
-0.07689064,
1.0994038582,
0.5401960611,
0.5713048577,
0.1946450323,
0.3057564497,
-0.7208701372,
0.3819458783,
-0.7495136857,
-0.3786148131,
-0.0687673315,
-0.618098557,
-0.8154737353,
0.240833953,
-0.1695058495,
-0.6749498844,
0.2542610765,
0.231488198,
-0.682657361,
0.3236255646,
-0.7957676053,
1.126079917,
-0.3791718185,
-0.7151757479,
-0.5805137753,
-0.5686535239,
0.2883087099,
-0.3906708956,
0.3161223233,
0.1994274259,
0.1821286529,
0.4167114496,
-0.5056883097,
0.7762234211,
0.0135854753,
-0.2084726393,
-0.2188398093,
0.1499698907,
0.3420375288,
0.2697299123,
-0.1771441102,
-0.0652625933,
0.3224790692,
-0.6156664491,
-0.599470973,
1.1546139717,
-1.1141502857,
-0.4150084257,
-0.4657467604,
-0.7913043499,
-0.1583990157,
0.3777130246,
-0.0031488554,
0.8004365563,
-0.4708699882,
0.0975877941,
0.7114294171,
-0.3643109202,
0.4033623338,
0.6997056603,
-0.3082965612,
-0.5534154773,
1.346278429,
0.1051677689,
0.3115987778,
0.5996609926,
0.0614705943,
0.0923884064,
-0.1354909688,
-0.8715755343,
0.3835122883,
-0.5560729504,
-0.0978432149,
-0.3215687573,
-0.0509204306,
-0.3418456316,
-0.1741940081,
-0.3832012117,
-0.4828716218,
-0.2419553697,
0.1505022347,
0.1492754966,
0.9507963657,
-0.2197660804,
0.6712042689,
-0.7566060424,
0.3817853928,
0.3760424852,
0.2596023679,
0.0095497211,
-0.7377234697,
-0.7907685637,
0.0523377173,
-0.0704744831,
-0.6293475628,
0.3869014084,
0.3937964141,
0.42525208,
0.3983472884,
-0.0808450356,
0.690492034,
-0.8699775934,
0.3067738414,
0.1094115973,
-0.8656930327,
0.2355542779,
-0.3863278031,
0.4154065847,
0.4593198597,
0.6272271276,
-0.6700351834,
0.1273459792,
-0.0060442854,
-0.5272327065,
1.1275624037,
-0.2948362231,
0.2095160037,
0.0045406264,
0.2838599384,
0.5511440039,
-0.051879514,
-0.5133444071,
-0.2901610434,
-0.5138301253,
-0.1899723709,
-0.4003997743,
-0.0763250887,
-0.0416151285,
-0.1555997282,
0.854932189,
-0.3320625722,
0.056974031,
-0.579883635,
-0.5246124864,
-0.0994411483,
0.2078779489,
0.7219573259,
0.7249093652,
-0.4180426896,
0.1366396546,
0.1692139506,
-0.5292275548,
0.2812350094,
0.3786192536,
0.0458736084,
-0.1390182376,
0.2675512433,
0.8717244267,
0.3577159345,
-0.5080448389,
0.4115529954,
-0.32328704,
0.1957972497,
-0.2728756964,
0.2404711246,
0.1535395682,
0.1010008901,
0.0696989819,
0.0689944103,
-0.1581200212,
-0.6604399085,
0.0082440907,
0.1409650743,
-0.4842492938,
-0.7445026636,
0.7324250937,
0.0964800492,
-0.1328117102,
0.5625950694,
-0.1124745607,
-0.0868102089,
0.3320792317,
0.791158855,
0.3940146267,
-0.5070962906,
0.4857277572,
0.4648798108,
0.2661840916,
-0.1018260941,
0.3152937591,
-0.1620714962,
-0.4329472184,
-0.6265391707,
-0.3329495788,
-0.7383062243,
-0.0588039979,
-0.9854940772,
0.4454897046,
-0.6122178435,
0.1113124043,
0.1153114662,
-0.1630508602,
-0.3312998116,
0.1314771175,
0.3604569435,
0.9725949764,
-0.9683598876,
1.277889967,
0.8810563684,
-0.4087539017,
-0.5060088634,
-0.2181311995,
-0.1345736235,
-0.9033191204,
0.4774532318,
0.0297315028,
-0.3866138756,
0.0857838616,
-0.2735654414,
-0.7368252277,
0.9852964282,
0.7146551609,
-0.578982532,
-0.154430449,
0.2703456581,
0.3013591468,
-0.2844556272,
0.4762292802,
0.4312513471,
0.2071521133,
-0.1656590551,
-0.6741060615,
-0.0536692291,
-0.3424997926,
-0.2085481584,
0.1162407547,
-1.0208518505,
0.874776721,
-0.2082657814,
0.249588266,
0.5796441436,
0.5892086029,
0.240093261,
-0.1252026409,
0.3352816701,
0.6362555027,
0.7437440157,
0.0574052297,
0.8894526958,
-0.5387739539,
-0.0184697472,
1.5578122139,
-0.4810254276,
1.0613313913,
-0.0269429367,
0.2000420243,
0.9455515146,
0.4821768999,
0.1929628104,
0.5993198752,
-0.2002243698,
-0.4596709311,
-0.4732851684,
-0.050615605,
-0.4878693819,
0.4190845788,
0.4207425416,
-0.1975532472,
0.0176074672,
-0.0265463907,
0.1980059594,
-0.0041825552,
-0.4735687971,
0.5615800023,
-0.0388642997,
-0.6179817319,
0.9220533967,
0.0768451393,
0.3590332568,
-0.759683907,
-0.2157002538,
-0.5928693414,
0.4448657334,
-0.0576656908,
-0.3824685216,
-0.2454359382,
-0.0054062572,
-0.4878801107,
-0.0260323118,
0.1714674681,
-0.3967900574,
-0.760042429,
0.4420250654,
0.6125918031,
0.0036530062,
0.3895310462,
-0.5310286283,
0.144039169,
-0.1993380189,
0.0352086909,
0.5074350834,
0.4049511552,
-0.3055864573,
0.5718836188,
0.5575568676,
0.1774209589,
0.1205536798,
0.0725151822,
0.9652395844,
-0.6009243131,
-0.4605097473,
-0.4812848866,
0.2816590369,
0.2351750433,
-0.232792154,
0.7647256255,
0.6985214353,
0.9208652973,
-0.021195773,
0.9394038916,
0.1353687346,
0.6649333835,
-0.291261971,
0.8965401053,
-0.6839762926,
0.1553438008,
-0.3087002337,
-0.8901290894,
-0.0576638058,
0.4705497921,
-0.3498217463,
0.0628770143,
0.7190461755,
0.8192100525,
-0.7297691107,
-0.1398680657,
0.5291777849,
0.3692907393,
-0.2318194211,
0.6464444995,
0.8723735809,
-0.3931649625,
0.5211069584,
-0.2382997572,
-0.4486188293,
-0.1827594191,
-0.7561643124,
-0.92549932,
-0.3209713101,
-0.3133159876,
-0.1455262303,
0.4691597521,
0.92114079,
0.99037534,
-0.9699966311,
-0.7496910691,
0.3778837323,
0.1744763404,
-0.6920554042,
-0.0504791886,
0.4813583791,
-0.2953397334,
-0.8115046024,
0.8529539704,
0.1197694913,
-0.3369054794,
-0.0368920565,
-0.297696054,
-0.0781712905,
0.212358579,
0.6698676944,
0.5931714773,
-0.2369792461,
-0.0849346668,
0.2593018115,
-0.005221663,
0.1856823564,
0.5530653596,
-0.7657555342,
0.4605736434,
0.234701857,
0.6385685205,
0.4592569768,
-0.070218727,
0.5071021318,
-0.697652936,
0.1449463814,
-0.3911794126,
0.4937973619,
0.4390428662,
0.0525232591,
0.3295641541,
0.1162908748,
-0.4682245553,
-0.8965938091,
0.1040233597,
-1.1135772467,
-0.2086131424,
1.013151288,
-0.5163007379,
-0.3800188601,
0.232599929,
-0.1840863824,
0.0988027081,
-0.2738393247,
0.5779676437,
0.3310737312,
0.1595539451,
-0.4181596637,
-0.4040668607,
0.033688318,
0.5275636315,
-0.8540019989,
0.2915315628,
0.5562660098,
0.4429861009,
0.0439683199,
0.270604074,
0.1243031472,
0.7796850801,
-0.1316803396,
0.0848743767,
0.0069911662,
-0.4483051002,
-0.3618609607,
-0.0746551752,
0.4418722093,
-0.1600410193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15010v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15010v1 | Injecting Knowledge into Biomedical Pre-trained Models via Polymorphism and Synonymous Substitution | 2023-05-24T10:48:53 | 2023-05-24T10:48:53 | Hongbo Zhang, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) were considered to be able to store
relational knowledge present in the training data. However, some relational
knowledge seems to be discarded unsafely in PLMs due to \textbf{report bias}:
low-frequency relational knowledge might be underexpressed compared to
high-frequency one in PLMs. This gives us a hint that relational knowledge
might not be redundant to the stored knowledge of PLMs, but rather be
complementary. To additionally inject relational knowledge into PLMs, we
propose a simple-yet-effective approach to inject relational knowledge into
PLMs, which is inspired by three observations (namely, polymorphism, synonymous
substitution, and association). In particular, we switch entities in the
training corpus to related entities (either hypernyms/hyponyms/synonyms, or
arbitrarily-related concepts). Experimental results show that the proposed
approach could not only better capture relational knowledge, but also improve
the performance in various biomedical downstream tasks. Our model is available
in \url{https://github.com/StevenZHB/BioPLM_InjectingKnowledge}. | [
-0.1096929535,
-0.510810554,
0.8638604879,
-0.0803268999,
-0.4287103117,
0.0710856915,
0.013559957,
-0.6783350706,
0.3708895147,
0.5504208207,
-0.1112487018,
-0.3619865775,
-0.4820665121,
0.0982398391,
-0.4222135842,
1.0458756685,
-0.034696158,
0.6481541991,
-0.856204927,
-0.2974036038,
-0.0770609081,
-0.8388180733,
-0.1226393059,
-0.8075413704,
0.6358675957,
0.0375304706,
0.5960206389,
0.7370372415,
0.546135962,
0.2112252414,
-0.2196940631,
0.2963550687,
-0.3509003222,
-0.3038102686,
-0.5685074925,
-0.6188217402,
-0.6323470473,
0.2164025158,
0.6910836101,
1.3106489182,
-0.2902566493,
-0.0745756328,
0.0355665721,
0.6040396094,
-0.6294515729,
0.0665977523,
-0.739356041,
0.0822663009,
-0.4720538259,
-0.1272609681,
-0.3999358118,
-0.2551207542,
0.4389504492,
-0.8074523211,
0.040304333,
-0.0795472041,
0.7988908291,
0.1739156991,
-0.3354488015,
-0.0660742074,
-0.6715192199,
0.4813731015,
-0.6451225877,
0.4765455425,
0.3075155616,
0.1036957949,
-0.2829835117,
-0.757920742,
-0.6626875997,
-0.0409931093,
-0.4475971758,
0.2422617823,
0.2530894876,
0.4378763735,
0.2503461838,
0.2416994423,
-0.366438359,
-0.2180152237,
-0.2619855702,
-0.013040171,
0.2276296616,
-0.0624967404,
0.3248364031,
0.0767070428,
-0.4727518559,
0.2197026759,
-1.221321702,
-0.3717107475,
0.1307804137,
0.1954686195,
-0.0540846698,
0.4784253836,
-0.0206694994,
1.0330269337,
-0.0081081316,
-0.0722950622,
0.5763399601,
-0.4252111316,
-0.1642576158,
-0.0965521187,
0.782926321,
-0.1469953358,
0.1822159886,
-0.3421708643,
0.264719069,
0.0317442641,
0.3115365505,
-0.594135046,
-0.1279866397,
0.0710725412,
-0.4887942672,
-0.1046561897,
0.1572217941,
-0.5245236158,
-0.1999769062,
-0.368484199,
0.6963731647,
-0.8533049226,
-0.1834920496,
0.5435763597,
-0.3999569416,
-0.0761615857,
-0.0342711359,
-0.7528168559,
0.2024107873,
0.575425446,
0.6793759465,
-0.2382710874,
-0.3967774808,
-0.293515861,
0.754999876,
0.1664632708,
0.7163997293,
-0.5193277001,
-0.5027458072,
0.0002578876,
-0.3329916298,
-0.1204025298,
-0.7871454358,
-0.1972190738,
-0.551533699,
0.1376270652,
-0.3372901976,
-0.882671833,
0.0467261858,
-0.1095099375,
-0.3217101693,
0.5587682724,
0.2795777917,
-0.8705152273,
0.4846905768,
-0.6523199081,
-0.542735517,
0.2069101781,
-0.3227256835,
-0.4019764364,
-0.1025172621,
-0.0573622398,
0.1968344599,
-0.0827220231,
0.1742544025,
-0.5884053111,
-0.2467606813,
0.4587352574,
0.4776196778,
0.9464355111,
-0.0162281487,
0.1228307113,
-0.2118756473,
-0.6706517339,
-0.1976968348,
-0.2144968063,
-0.2067763507,
-0.7437897921,
-0.0318088755,
-0.5237599611,
0.1238965318,
0.2008493692,
-0.7360876799,
0.2544803023,
-0.7871400118,
0.3281501532,
0.3258953989,
0.101245001,
0.6696808338,
-0.5498172045,
0.2244278193,
0.4126979113,
0.2176803201,
0.4179313481,
-0.3810413182,
-0.5192920566,
-0.4810923636,
0.3086485267,
0.4162335098,
-1.0480704308,
0.3322075903,
-0.238169387,
-0.3444448113,
-0.4285432696,
0.4570922256,
0.4870831668,
0.7226876616,
0.8330792189,
-0.527377367,
-0.6718500853,
-0.7151351571,
-0.5052367449,
-0.3685523868,
-0.0708047375,
0.2153874636,
0.4074476361,
-0.5438058972,
1.1022007465,
-0.3493927717,
-0.2804877758,
-0.1346359253,
0.1439239532,
0.283629179,
0.6321169138,
0.5974713564,
-0.5536491871,
-0.3606367409,
-0.232027337,
-1.0018962622,
-0.0522021726,
-0.0250875819,
-0.3571887314,
-0.358802557,
0.4706824124,
-0.9356885552,
0.1295692921,
0.2964704037,
0.0473279841,
0.5753008723,
-0.2430602312,
-0.3950831592,
-1.0179774761,
0.0358481854,
-0.3654699624,
-0.2435880899,
-0.7539060116,
0.0241507571,
0.0708176792,
0.2246208787,
-0.6009174585,
0.6087035537,
-0.443383038,
-0.0143300639,
-0.0121081267,
-0.3420929611,
0.0077499957,
0.0357294157,
0.3918643892,
0.548663497,
0.5778118968,
-0.6702358127,
0.1269617975,
0.5913259387,
-0.307279259,
0.4220614135,
-0.4407695532,
0.2206160128,
-0.3018144965,
0.311858952,
-0.3145161271,
-0.2379522175,
0.4499145448,
-0.2851075232,
0.394708395,
-0.1218962595,
-0.5150952935,
-0.3166997135,
-0.0779288635,
0.6051152349,
0.572301507,
-0.531588316,
0.6097537875,
0.4680625796,
-0.0431903005,
-0.4400548637,
-0.7822386026,
-0.3208559155,
-0.1843475252,
-0.2277346551,
0.7997376323,
0.0825225264,
0.0744006708,
0.1070296317,
0.0674325079,
-0.0773597136,
-0.2815497816,
0.0963848904,
0.401001811,
-0.0649304762,
0.3938806951,
0.1194600984,
-0.0602309257,
0.1062611416,
-0.3343756497,
0.3061406016,
0.0326419547,
-0.4698605239,
-0.2395537347,
0.367195785,
0.4741258323,
-0.2760042846,
0.9969860911,
0.192718327,
-0.4541369975,
0.0115546072,
-0.3543189466,
-0.4108087718,
-0.4261938334,
0.2125589252,
-0.1621018648,
-0.5377278924,
0.1863041967,
-0.3912781477,
-0.3316127062,
0.0219162367,
0.5116063952,
-0.6740944386,
0.6673677564,
0.4543477297,
0.3462863863,
0.5776942968,
-0.4021691978,
0.2883455455,
-0.6928164959,
-0.1637613326,
-0.1476092041,
-0.0268186275,
-0.300537169,
-0.5992797017,
0.6484886408,
0.1717623323,
-0.2805104852,
0.2781908512,
-0.0162035078,
0.3804080188,
0.6446418762,
0.765617609,
0.3684788048,
-0.074338451,
-0.2681162655,
0.1197897792,
-0.9864647985,
-0.2886889577,
1.2764968872,
0.2071540803,
0.6185989976,
-0.1622481197,
1.1974657774,
-0.3461258709,
0.8132553697,
-0.6329627037,
0.4773843884,
-0.384868741,
-0.5263668299,
0.0355091318,
-0.5434879661,
-0.7291554213,
-0.276245892,
-0.5130592585,
-0.4665096998,
0.428651154,
0.6114090085,
-0.6790124178,
0.2879241407,
-0.5449257493,
0.7396348119,
-0.1823305041,
-0.2913665771,
-0.2778976262,
-0.8738310337,
0.3344082534,
-0.2759803236,
0.1536363959,
0.2662236094,
0.0768139511,
0.5269957781,
-0.6801054478,
0.6978396773,
-0.1871572435,
0.3614334464,
0.1656240076,
-0.0789748356,
0.1691306382,
-0.0485212803,
-0.007816745,
0.3064998984,
0.1890871972,
-0.4945473671,
-0.5263337493,
0.2827661335,
-0.8975684643,
-0.4177313149,
-0.5034466982,
-0.6869933605,
-0.7517914176,
0.1261647493,
0.3923347592,
0.1114439592,
-0.0260673575,
0.1672208607,
0.7816875577,
-0.3522370458,
-0.0730635449,
0.6319436431,
-0.197969541,
-0.1499452591,
0.9592887163,
-0.0504452884,
0.6040196419,
0.5273780823,
0.1240938753,
-0.3408989012,
-0.5998910069,
-0.0323060118,
0.6981109381,
-0.3103229403,
-0.4248473942,
-0.8342643976,
-0.3209647536,
-0.293825537,
-0.0102790231,
-0.4092097878,
-0.1733159125,
-0.3014707863,
-0.0144415498,
0.3296233118,
0.5998100042,
-0.3113630414,
0.4761330187,
-0.9860613346,
0.5184677243,
0.4703134298,
0.4497670233,
-0.4265581965,
-0.3579338193,
-0.3298651576,
0.3750067353,
-0.0723338127,
-1.2158226967,
0.2313867956,
0.4062494934,
0.6349654794,
0.3955424726,
-0.4491786361,
0.5564447641,
-0.5048907399,
0.3609583676,
0.323567003,
-0.8121186495,
0.4632903636,
-0.445196867,
0.1313258559,
0.6257768869,
0.7683410048,
-0.2472093552,
-0.506415844,
-0.6027625203,
-0.6043960452,
0.3805731535,
-0.0014657179,
0.0018890772,
-0.2015947104,
0.5251105428,
0.211509943,
0.4796930254,
-0.6163887382,
-0.325609535,
-0.2503114343,
-0.3232033253,
0.1077240631,
-0.2942942977,
-0.3628760576,
-0.691424489,
0.7033783197,
0.1230677664,
0.4451093078,
0.1263039112,
-0.36025244,
0.1380856186,
0.0213362128,
0.0916617364,
0.5980600715,
-0.4941337705,
0.2372620106,
-0.0177508108,
-0.3697993159,
0.1998203248,
0.0877142772,
-0.2601400614,
0.046247378,
0.2482124418,
0.2632870972,
0.0337618329,
-0.6158034205,
0.432018429,
0.3499459624,
-0.011329419,
-0.0162729714,
0.0140214209,
0.4222425222,
-0.1500213891,
-0.0822793841,
0.1512273997,
0.1212672293,
-0.7069794536,
0.3050991893,
0.4191407263,
-0.0859685317,
-0.2015299797,
0.50073874,
0.2198819071,
0.0121454597,
0.4805215597,
-0.105032824,
-0.3525871038,
0.2013074905,
0.7616738081,
0.4475885928,
-0.3409614861,
0.2809791267,
0.3017443419,
-0.3468241692,
-0.1896368563,
0.3095715344,
0.2717642188,
-1.1976296902,
-0.442851007,
-0.8155338764,
-0.3605492115,
0.0215387866,
-0.6897307634,
0.25263381,
-0.3918544054,
-0.2758590281,
0.3493525684,
-0.646109879,
-0.7974300385,
-0.1044420376,
-0.0012330593,
0.7530975342,
-0.9386481047,
1.2913296223,
1.0400584936,
-0.6548759937,
-0.5752401948,
-0.2591638565,
-0.2128433734,
-0.6821311116,
0.8672916889,
-0.3057399392,
0.0566574447,
0.0604896322,
-0.4467473924,
-0.7310554385,
0.731960535,
0.5109010339,
-0.4385607243,
-0.3412262797,
0.5681382418,
0.7158158422,
-0.4054331183,
0.0688591152,
0.6383085251,
0.1940414906,
-0.1088527516,
-0.9452477694,
-0.1266168058,
-0.1036668196,
0.0149641596,
0.0306404922,
-0.2109462172,
0.8973035216,
-0.2007260025,
0.0082963733,
0.1165519059,
0.4940218031,
0.324819684,
0.0746463239,
0.4308281839,
0.7429746985,
0.5610212088,
0.1770185977,
1.0731924772,
-0.3050719798,
0.1962803453,
1.2418078184,
-0.334258914,
0.6740260124,
0.9104912281,
-0.3877899945,
0.7460152507,
0.275226444,
0.3234801292,
0.66641289,
0.2013964653,
-0.5085952878,
-0.4128678143,
-0.2371163517,
-0.6124039292,
0.4996797442,
0.6344197392,
-0.4216646254,
-0.1239605844,
0.0953142941,
-0.1506055146,
0.1402672231,
-0.0573268086,
0.9488914609,
0.383389622,
-0.4572244585,
0.5610521436,
-0.320315212,
0.5117014647,
-0.758872211,
-0.2061513811,
-0.2639681101,
0.1455389559,
-0.158398211,
-0.4109629393,
0.3891693056,
-0.4316449761,
-0.2819690108,
-0.4713085592,
0.7652670741,
-0.8626592159,
-0.2554075718,
0.2913807333,
0.8184842467,
-0.024557421,
-0.0948870629,
-0.4929296374,
-0.3518808186,
-0.3016110659,
0.3711229861,
0.4512082934,
0.1218972877,
0.2299995422,
0.5519470572,
0.7108699679,
0.7128484249,
-0.0709632188,
0.0130342972,
0.907471776,
-0.396353662,
-0.2988875806,
-0.7369223833,
0.1677748561,
-0.0811529085,
0.121400252,
0.3889957666,
0.49726668,
0.8386541009,
-0.418281734,
0.8066227436,
0.1075711325,
0.8425325751,
-0.4873243868,
0.8152218461,
-0.38335976,
0.130725801,
-0.3745448887,
-0.5467643142,
-0.3510816097,
0.6646587849,
-0.3245973885,
-0.1463810503,
0.8288883567,
0.8585151434,
-0.2124729604,
-0.098217003,
0.1256210804,
0.418107152,
0.0836607888,
0.7204532027,
0.9515379667,
-0.2077402025,
0.2196011394,
-0.3498250842,
-0.2840712368,
-0.1079334244,
-0.8739956617,
-0.8794212341,
-0.4428198636,
-0.3237023056,
-0.4410479665,
0.4445978701,
1.0103982687,
0.8512840271,
-0.8102386594,
-0.199089542,
-0.2483210564,
0.133490473,
-0.232450515,
-0.122671105,
0.0559935905,
-0.2854842544,
-0.3613840342,
0.4066283405,
0.2223821133,
0.5205461383,
0.0543409847,
-0.0339885876,
-0.5324475765,
-0.2352645099,
0.5740906,
0.4126429558,
-0.4667351246,
-0.3290250301,
-0.0890998766,
-0.1887414604,
-0.0224831011,
0.9928399324,
-1.067389369,
0.4252514541,
0.6032807231,
0.7194164395,
0.4673494995,
0.0397354439,
1.1070611477,
-0.797850728,
0.4446553588,
0.4455839396,
0.5299821496,
0.2838341892,
-0.2829705477,
0.3586938381,
0.6972261071,
-0.199001044,
-0.7094439268,
0.3302035034,
-1.0430742502,
-0.2849728465,
1.2335687876,
-0.160574615,
0.0422663651,
-0.2571703196,
0.1209875047,
0.5276438594,
0.0399218872,
0.8666002154,
0.4699722528,
-0.392830044,
0.3159634173,
-0.2447669953,
0.8958488107,
0.7561004162,
-0.9814308882,
-0.2565877736,
0.2499675304,
0.4100751281,
0.1186779514,
0.8195937872,
-0.3418964148,
0.3738155067,
-0.2939835489,
0.1615280509,
-0.0131097473,
-0.2327489108,
0.0822215974,
-0.2630593479,
0.024625767,
-0.1301245093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15008v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15008v1 | Are Chatbots Ready for Privacy-Sensitive Applications? An Investigation into Input Regurgitation and Prompt-Induced Sanitization | 2023-05-24T10:48:05 | 2023-05-24T10:48:05 | Aman Priyanshu, Supriti Vijay, Ayush Kumar, Rakshit Naidu, Fatemehsadat Mireshghallah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | LLM-powered chatbots are becoming widely adopted in applications such as
healthcare, personal assistants, industry hiring decisions, etc. In many of
these cases, chatbots are fed sensitive, personal information in their prompts,
as samples for in-context learning, retrieved records from a database, or as
part of the conversation. The information provided in the prompt could directly
appear in the output, which might have privacy ramifications if there is
sensitive information there. As such, in this paper, we aim to understand the
input copying and regurgitation capabilities of these models during inference
and how they can be directly instructed to limit this copying by complying with
regulations such as HIPAA and GDPR, based on their internal knowledge of them.
More specifically, we find that when ChatGPT is prompted to summarize cover
letters of a 100 candidates, it would retain personally identifiable
information (PII) verbatim in 57.4% of cases, and we find this retention to be
non-uniform between different subgroups of people, based on attributes such as
gender identity. We then probe ChatGPT's perception of privacy-related policies
and privatization mechanisms by directly instructing it to provide compliant
outputs and observe a significant omission of PII from output. | [
-0.059492778,
-0.8025524616,
0.2604594529,
-0.0628483742,
0.018040644,
-0.0020601496,
0.2233002037,
-0.4247646332,
-0.1931640506,
0.7047523856,
-0.5337844491,
-0.3231833279,
-0.4080595374,
-0.0300851483,
-0.6225165129,
1.1407501698,
0.3357075453,
-0.1550971866,
-0.2694038451,
0.2574661374,
-0.4547958076,
-1.013286829,
-0.3023279309,
0.0050904108,
0.3773256242,
0.5179046392,
0.6134821773,
0.4417442679,
0.3884510696,
0.2716822624,
-0.3602651656,
-0.1823518872,
-0.6541125774,
0.4358554184,
-0.2029540539,
-0.6243575215,
-0.0896719843,
-0.0277493987,
0.5842033625,
0.3972821832,
-0.0823009908,
0.1989536881,
0.3696958125,
0.4392096996,
-0.5344481468,
0.0335928984,
-0.7191120982,
0.1963224858,
0.1219531372,
-0.306504786,
-0.6131297946,
-0.4839364886,
0.0835446864,
-0.170857355,
0.5164391994,
0.0105123743,
0.8093416691,
0.2088638395,
-0.3164279163,
-0.2105245888,
-0.8708893061,
0.3780273199,
-0.3762600124,
0.3401499093,
0.6286494136,
0.2565010488,
-0.2849900424,
-0.6948307157,
-0.265656054,
-0.2893921137,
-0.189323023,
0.1355545819,
-0.367770195,
0.2962690294,
0.4937698841,
0.2403484136,
-0.5655243397,
0.4024451077,
-0.6377198696,
-0.3636088967,
0.5812959671,
0.0258672666,
0.2988851666,
0.0169957168,
-0.4067110419,
-0.1341078281,
-0.5965560079,
0.2281447798,
0.4650587142,
0.12538068,
-0.1212712228,
0.680272758,
-0.3135102689,
0.4883517325,
0.1202791333,
0.2369183153,
0.0961573496,
-0.4857775271,
-0.2864487767,
-0.0082919979,
0.9914502501,
0.1715670228,
0.373324275,
-0.0293495897,
0.0818526223,
-0.2275443971,
0.5849384665,
-0.7691560388,
-0.3212202191,
0.4821916521,
-0.3674973249,
-0.5532996058,
-0.0516303666,
-0.6784214377,
-0.6722046137,
-0.0007179457,
0.2803424299,
-0.3161666393,
0.1299441308,
-0.1261341274,
-0.3528572023,
0.1739342064,
0.3788211942,
-0.947455287,
0.1229026616,
0.7225553989,
0.6309629083,
-0.1659062058,
-0.1401956677,
-0.2357788831,
-0.0609529987,
0.0987343639,
0.4875946641,
-0.4379012585,
-0.8149977922,
0.0660551935,
0.0847687498,
-0.2202531695,
-0.5718206763,
0.4090922177,
-0.5053934455,
0.4068213403,
0.1885789782,
-0.5111872554,
-0.1751321554,
0.2350655794,
-0.467659086,
0.4661712646,
-0.0452182144,
-0.6450190544,
0.2562617958,
-0.4840120673,
-0.2791962922,
0.1103130728,
-0.1604682803,
-0.6173496842,
-0.1247422993,
0.030893987,
0.6133382916,
0.1763599366,
0.1619576216,
-0.2565540671,
-0.4462858737,
0.8031870723,
-0.7593256831,
0.7407125235,
0.1759524941,
-0.0971480608,
0.601886332,
-0.4527561069,
-0.1589277089,
-0.0651707202,
-0.0893227607,
0.0366638526,
-0.2553777695,
-0.3493234515,
0.1099514142,
0.277757585,
-0.4205804765,
-0.0470170006,
-0.0591379255,
0.4479709268,
0.9947998524,
0.3366308212,
0.5515575409,
-0.4971237481,
0.729357481,
-0.0801155642,
0.5157065988,
-0.3514550924,
-0.6658217311,
-0.1578371823,
-0.4779143333,
0.1843900979,
0.8165468574,
0.0153613314,
0.5071879029,
-0.0003455385,
-0.614577055,
-0.3389194906,
0.0131248292,
0.2975812852,
0.761623919,
-0.186301887,
-0.1568996012,
-0.2757321596,
-1.0960618258,
-0.3165249825,
-0.2008925825,
-0.1336990744,
0.5702138543,
0.2446126193,
-0.2320955694,
0.9218825698,
-0.1863118559,
-0.1964433491,
-0.1820134372,
-0.1857842058,
0.0299879014,
0.6056526303,
0.1020476148,
-0.8985926509,
-0.0866205096,
-0.1368219703,
-0.696906209,
-0.1245846301,
-0.2199324667,
-0.2706602216,
-0.0646761358,
0.3816687465,
-0.4986484945,
0.6164934635,
0.5856646895,
-0.2201705575,
0.3944006562,
-0.2600429058,
0.0245642439,
-0.9727679491,
0.172436282,
-0.1073263735,
-0.3606931567,
-0.8270975947,
-0.0809356272,
0.0256597996,
-0.544798255,
-0.616856575,
0.4714360833,
-0.1650380045,
0.1080113128,
-0.2139376849,
0.0557600483,
-0.0836139098,
0.446965158,
0.0639598668,
0.9544720054,
0.2577107251,
-0.8057044744,
-0.1675824821,
0.4297102392,
-0.1303419173,
0.0949231982,
-0.6380455494,
0.298530668,
-0.0045098038,
0.214713484,
-1.1288987398,
-0.5963072777,
0.4724667966,
-0.6924684048,
-0.0073314318,
-0.1243560836,
-0.4023970068,
-0.1048069075,
-0.2211125493,
0.2108907998,
0.8591487408,
-0.2281829268,
0.4186066389,
0.7501990795,
-0.3509279788,
-0.5222089291,
-0.8181946278,
-0.2914701402,
-0.2453553975,
-0.4239917994,
-0.0072021028,
0.1070227996,
-0.0873689726,
-0.2293085903,
-0.0126133617,
-0.468631655,
0.5193459988,
0.6880329251,
0.3668930829,
0.412209481,
-0.0811250582,
0.0737330168,
0.0751141086,
0.0647290498,
0.3605621755,
0.6771563292,
-0.0843175054,
-0.4800542891,
-1.1307269335,
0.4274280667,
0.4612542689,
-0.1203042716,
0.581158936,
0.420204252,
-0.2367545068,
0.2504146099,
-0.430418998,
-0.5381986499,
-0.5018259883,
0.2555950284,
-0.0136084221,
-1.2656277418,
0.7336281538,
0.0112696644,
0.3386786878,
0.1373447627,
0.7664142251,
-0.209939003,
0.7682373524,
0.5701321959,
-0.0635839179,
0.8429195285,
0.0960644484,
0.0556389876,
-0.4710279405,
-0.3399574757,
-0.6053696275,
-0.1729080081,
-0.9075416327,
-0.156115815,
0.2437179685,
-0.2132599056,
-0.0222245362,
0.1701051742,
-0.7543973327,
0.3554261029,
1.0294417143,
0.3759975135,
0.1970452964,
-0.2010059357,
0.4572761059,
0.1538712978,
-0.7417650819,
-0.7095543742,
0.8541581035,
0.4024420381,
0.7952688336,
0.0386276245,
0.8515355587,
0.5317764282,
0.1885802001,
-0.5552970171,
0.6552972794,
0.1113626212,
-0.7268306017,
-0.3198500872,
-0.2847847342,
-1.3295068741,
0.1379623413,
-0.0333331302,
-0.97236377,
0.4113417566,
0.4416522682,
-0.4934192002,
0.0940446332,
-0.9688238502,
0.792832911,
0.0361538157,
-0.4435713291,
-0.0755630359,
-0.8521748185,
0.4403454065,
-0.0304962806,
0.0080267377,
-0.1030378416,
0.2214500904,
0.4213972986,
-0.3180936277,
1.3022258282,
-0.1328105628,
-0.1036902294,
0.3720960617,
0.2349903733,
0.302436024,
-0.0416686311,
-0.0553684495,
0.4008328915,
0.1497666389,
-0.0318248607,
-0.4276458025,
0.2244034857,
-0.5660973191,
-0.7735620141,
-0.3237206042,
-0.4447366297,
-0.0542527065,
0.2651273906,
0.3913002014,
-0.0594446696,
-0.2555812001,
0.3613435924,
0.654766798,
-0.2948002219,
-0.0014744888,
0.3461198807,
-0.0329352133,
0.1622413099,
0.7011988163,
-0.0085240975,
0.2976259291,
0.3115863502,
0.3194618821,
-0.1568927467,
-0.2315065116,
-0.2249315083,
-0.0171472523,
-0.4563782513,
-0.0897272751,
-0.6457162499,
-0.5187388062,
-0.49251315,
-0.1673819274,
0.0021907163,
-0.2886176705,
-0.531673789,
-0.0573796667,
0.3728717566,
0.5305445194,
0.0951192901,
0.3198969066,
-0.8734452724,
0.2239105105,
0.1592743844,
0.0654801279,
-0.3405201435,
-0.63479954,
0.1379171014,
0.0473136827,
-0.2148927599,
-0.840077877,
0.1938126087,
0.0594426692,
0.4277231991,
0.3269456625,
0.1363113225,
0.2052642256,
-0.3187147379,
0.8679219484,
-0.282335788,
-0.5332182646,
0.5247913003,
-0.3235043883,
0.2064401209,
0.7257242203,
0.1520913541,
-0.6627140045,
-0.6253157258,
-0.7188547254,
-0.6878478527,
0.6951736212,
0.1755522341,
0.5995978117,
0.071672298,
0.2745597959,
0.3864895105,
0.2931147814,
-0.3100502789,
0.0374512225,
0.0929711983,
-0.1813412756,
0.5159975886,
-0.616904676,
-0.188751772,
0.2917824388,
0.2740953267,
0.3634421825,
0.4259144962,
0.1195362583,
0.0708514005,
0.6602410078,
0.4386800528,
0.6722215414,
0.09686777,
-0.16870597,
-0.2347310781,
-0.1370061934,
-0.6470316648,
0.0666478798,
-0.0386505537,
-0.3456310332,
-0.110060066,
-0.1042775586,
0.5229585767,
0.0689826533,
-0.762493372,
0.6590678692,
-0.2686363161,
-0.1804009378,
-0.4389594495,
0.4138477743,
-0.376719296,
0.1009942964,
-0.0028918961,
0.1472875625,
0.4063346386,
-0.4361206293,
0.3243905306,
0.4232933819,
-0.3571421504,
-0.2084291577,
0.7904648185,
0.2496876568,
-0.4576625228,
0.8120239973,
0.1685218513,
-0.3505038023,
0.35531196,
0.3894709051,
0.9461446404,
-0.4319361448,
-0.0135671431,
0.1928713173,
0.1366051435,
0.1090267673,
0.2813481987,
-0.4113776982,
-0.7672559619,
0.0768134147,
0.1319812536,
-0.9852010012,
-0.1854001135,
-0.8165118098,
-0.0192488618,
-0.8433436751,
-0.3598192334,
-0.3084546924,
-0.7678727508,
-0.7195090652,
-0.093390204,
-0.0743070766,
0.4727600813,
-0.5844445229,
0.3772303462,
0.148337543,
-0.2783192694,
-0.4786147773,
-0.0053588781,
0.2435358018,
-0.902703464,
0.4403411746,
0.2334368229,
-0.0782112181,
-0.3611670434,
-0.5080848932,
-0.5221372247,
0.690467298,
0.5079699159,
-0.5685940385,
-0.1218733639,
0.1659317613,
0.395347178,
0.2686618268,
0.0904193521,
0.368075639,
0.081802085,
-0.2166688293,
-0.9916629791,
-0.0046566022,
-0.3498368561,
-0.2838505208,
-0.2457885742,
-0.7431793809,
0.5891507864,
-0.1040483043,
-0.3676402867,
-0.0135028642,
0.4136031866,
0.3970569372,
0.2999410927,
0.1517512947,
-0.1116961315,
1.1089849472,
0.0240124352,
1.3734941483,
-0.4718176723,
-0.0920170099,
1.1806589365,
-0.4161010385,
0.7337146997,
0.2763957679,
0.1241316497,
0.261051625,
0.6503311396,
-0.1092069522,
0.3035764098,
0.2010066956,
-0.4179077148,
0.1936287731,
-0.3048365712,
-0.2122323364,
0.5589116216,
0.3303534985,
-0.7344337106,
0.1882771701,
0.1935707331,
0.1678601801,
-0.1506505311,
0.0175426845,
1.0813395977,
0.0251339152,
-0.6206944585,
0.2327724993,
-0.1974084824,
0.487103045,
-0.5800722837,
0.0114925457,
-0.0782043412,
0.1889694035,
-0.1747729331,
-0.9745791554,
0.2962495983,
0.1497336328,
-0.1908796579,
-0.4433591068,
0.9027189016,
-0.156258598,
-0.1755556315,
-0.2288766652,
0.3454502821,
0.5350760221,
-0.2615763247,
-0.6427124739,
-0.0207899492,
0.152260989,
-0.2012270242,
0.3531431854,
0.1845482588,
-0.2116356045,
0.7515849471,
0.6657335162,
0.0165038183,
0.110920921,
0.2588233054,
0.5994463563,
-0.4455512762,
-0.5952789187,
-1.0252090693,
0.486005038,
-0.219173789,
-0.3283573389,
0.8158073425,
0.5896853209,
0.7119400501,
-0.074946776,
1.0169222355,
0.3169994056,
0.5413587689,
-0.4172345996,
0.8482046127,
0.1002083197,
0.0954001769,
0.0473775193,
-0.3998482227,
-0.2780679464,
0.3360053599,
-0.2332463562,
0.0641605929,
0.0706198215,
0.9185727239,
0.2876676917,
0.1217918098,
0.291636169,
-0.1183774322,
0.5193510652,
0.2360752225,
0.538331151,
-0.0993420258,
0.4234270155,
-0.3211286962,
-0.1883829683,
-0.4322353005,
-0.4365513623,
-0.6787263155,
-0.4701030254,
-0.3178962469,
-0.3961471617,
-0.0650716349,
0.5816864967,
0.6281427741,
-0.5878830552,
-0.0344400108,
-0.043967206,
0.1218448952,
-0.0031921,
-0.2644960284,
0.1715090275,
-0.0776001215,
-0.7198749781,
0.3307707012,
0.1374981552,
0.3948756456,
-0.1482434422,
0.5236523747,
0.1271491051,
-0.0084731225,
0.3145915568,
0.6453918815,
-0.5032144785,
-0.1752264649,
0.0292064752,
-0.1666831076,
-0.0183996893,
0.7479663491,
-0.6080268025,
0.6050739884,
0.5996326804,
0.8044634461,
0.1205532104,
0.655908823,
0.6681509614,
-0.8394237161,
0.3332993984,
0.4846153557,
0.2714116573,
0.1301986724,
-0.7530625463,
0.3624333143,
-0.1291183829,
-0.8304579258,
-0.8639523387,
0.1435974836,
-0.8333031535,
-0.0747661665,
1.0691730976,
-0.1813943386,
-0.3482290208,
-0.1350129545,
-0.568677783,
0.3202346563,
-0.7089618444,
0.8974074721,
0.4483494163,
-0.3551653624,
-0.2828510404,
-0.406730473,
0.4368709326,
0.3606894612,
-0.7075023055,
0.4108614624,
0.4502738714,
0.1578597575,
-0.051344607,
0.8305965066,
-0.3713087738,
0.4198001325,
0.0177045763,
0.0422585681,
-0.1331058443,
-0.0718838647,
-0.6227080822,
0.2823714912,
0.0698044449,
-0.6540974975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15005v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15005v1 | Sentiment Analysis in the Era of Large Language Models: A Reality Check | 2023-05-24T10:45:25 | 2023-05-24T10:45:25 | Wenxuan Zhang, Yue Deng, Bing Liu, Sinno Jialin Pan, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis (SA) has been a long-standing research area in natural
language processing. It can offer rich insights into human sentiments and
opinions and has thus seen considerable interest from both academia and
industry. With the advent of large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT,
there is a great potential for their employment on SA problems. However, the
extent to which existing LLMs can be leveraged for different sentiment analysis
tasks remains unclear. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive investigation
into the capabilities of LLMs in performing various sentiment analysis tasks,
from conventional sentiment classification to aspect-based sentiment analysis
and multifaceted analysis of subjective texts. We evaluate performance across
13 tasks on 26 datasets and compare the results against small language models
(SLMs) trained on domain-specific datasets. Our study reveals that while LLMs
demonstrate satisfactory performance in simpler tasks, they lag behind in more
complex tasks requiring deeper understanding or structured sentiment
information. However, LLMs significantly outperform SLMs in few-shot learning
settings, suggesting their potential when annotation resources are limited. We
also highlight the limitations of current evaluation practices in assessing
LLMs' SA abilities and propose a novel benchmark, \textsc{SentiEval}, for a
more comprehensive and realistic evaluation. Data and code during our
investigations are available at
\url{https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/LLM-Sentiment}. | [
-0.3806812167,
-0.594565928,
0.5269610882,
0.4385447204,
-0.3543402851,
0.1702173203,
-0.5277652144,
-0.5439536572,
0.0210546497,
0.4091767073,
-0.4906229973,
-0.7008654475,
-0.7911751866,
0.1874221712,
-0.1167041659,
1.0990576744,
0.1417112797,
0.276173681,
-0.4191441238,
-0.3085260987,
-0.2657432556,
-0.858019352,
-0.6875323653,
-0.3252429962,
0.5561922193,
0.2366706878,
0.4107972085,
-0.1537695974,
0.8710690141,
0.2327949554,
-0.4048505723,
0.1404852569,
-0.3566847146,
0.2860845923,
0.0647140965,
-0.4672370851,
-0.6139642,
0.1634994447,
0.7686337233,
0.7459530234,
0.1824976653,
0.2649721205,
0.2507179379,
0.8609983921,
-0.4826805294,
0.2995515764,
-0.5817428231,
0.0317851231,
-0.2779182196,
0.1372089386,
-0.3693499863,
-0.4206914306,
0.2050507218,
0.0565597005,
-0.0957388133,
-0.0229737014,
0.6466452479,
0.2415735722,
-0.2343861908,
-0.5394560099,
-0.5655997396,
1.1265716553,
-0.9363120794,
0.2782607079,
-0.1402118355,
0.2464669794,
0.1393534243,
-0.5515446067,
-0.3940786123,
-0.3875476122,
0.0608314611,
0.202007696,
-0.2593270838,
0.0921420529,
0.3089790642,
0.6039203405,
-0.3398101032,
0.3064619005,
0.0114742452,
0.0274362173,
0.5359532237,
0.2137315124,
0.0892403424,
-0.6647193432,
-0.3796994984,
0.0409961231,
-0.6459893584,
0.2256025672,
0.2599645853,
0.4152324498,
-0.1420060843,
0.6485432982,
-0.2157518417,
0.5064206123,
-0.2870395184,
-0.0985519588,
0.3014086783,
-0.0871001929,
-0.3731714189,
-0.4080595672,
1.0372283459,
0.334497124,
0.2758639455,
-0.0008134484,
-0.5408913493,
0.0067179836,
0.21608603,
-0.7193474174,
0.0296484735,
0.2975230813,
-0.5497172475,
-0.3931825757,
-0.1923821121,
-1.0264735222,
-0.7528350353,
-0.2507601976,
0.2139988542,
-0.1073771715,
-0.2196772993,
-0.0686785579,
-0.0016615597,
0.4610107243,
0.3203762472,
-0.4228554666,
0.1575713456,
0.943768084,
1.0994241238,
-0.3370573521,
-0.2015533894,
-0.3148461878,
-0.5763641596,
-0.2039899677,
0.9202777743,
-0.6884657145,
-0.4688505232,
0.135891363,
-0.3161009252,
-0.160754323,
-0.6347647309,
0.6845612526,
-0.5672151446,
0.0257083755,
-0.5176008344,
-0.5277698636,
-0.2293151319,
0.6330682635,
-0.5509572625,
1.092361927,
-0.0250501949,
-0.799454391,
0.2317878753,
-0.7353658676,
-0.3980437815,
-0.0728713423,
-0.1605491042,
-0.3246590197,
0.3845768869,
0.201778546,
0.8541530967,
-0.5757192969,
0.0436225757,
-0.4319376051,
-0.2644364834,
0.6792408228,
-0.4944413602,
0.379205972,
0.1405361295,
-0.1885649562,
0.0617911294,
-0.511734426,
-0.0842793956,
-0.1068504155,
-0.3382868767,
-0.2147611231,
0.0227006152,
0.0689812005,
0.3014834821,
0.3451418579,
-0.6545612812,
0.2740278542,
-0.5042617917,
0.4460417926,
0.5869889259,
0.0182412174,
0.4073674977,
-0.0139538245,
0.6844005585,
0.0528966039,
0.1175294966,
0.0284013785,
-0.3421058655,
-0.8397702575,
-0.4185362458,
0.3378969133,
0.4298410714,
-0.531981051,
0.2591663301,
-0.4998175204,
-0.5417123437,
-0.496486783,
0.0628302544,
0.1541010141,
0.0232947376,
0.1384385079,
-0.3223834038,
-0.4027481079,
-0.8836280107,
-0.3445799351,
-0.1607029885,
0.0191117059,
0.3238181174,
0.4506183267,
-0.1583261937,
0.8411007524,
-0.5047821999,
-0.3367163837,
-0.5064998269,
0.2420935631,
0.2613625824,
-0.0606257282,
0.4645289183,
-0.4682801366,
-0.2244612724,
0.0097037274,
-0.8763977885,
-0.2461943179,
-0.0558768064,
0.1458819956,
0.3660404682,
0.3382862806,
-0.8010726571,
0.0073295478,
0.756788969,
0.115924485,
0.6468584538,
0.1881726384,
0.1497115046,
-0.8205288649,
0.1183123142,
0.3443818986,
-0.2185693085,
-0.5508934855,
0.0773966983,
-0.1825215816,
-0.1798138171,
-0.4344245493,
0.4181998372,
-0.4535242021,
-0.2372721285,
-0.5738335848,
0.2588947415,
-0.1792483032,
0.4561469853,
-0.0146766547,
0.644407928,
0.5698902011,
-0.2680616677,
0.3652028441,
-0.0555998385,
-0.3788237572,
0.596691072,
-0.6829372048,
0.2875950336,
-0.0694269389,
0.1896390021,
-0.9977424741,
-0.1075209975,
0.2106014639,
-0.4082366526,
0.2287956476,
-0.2701497078,
-0.6294014454,
-0.2699961662,
-0.5201934576,
0.0846536607,
0.5136501193,
-0.3802801371,
0.7926828861,
0.3741114438,
-0.4388326705,
-0.5892186761,
-0.5847731233,
0.2933752239,
-0.3983854949,
-0.4369214773,
-0.1967418343,
0.1027195454,
-0.4863572717,
-0.2324140817,
-0.0630509108,
0.0011466844,
-0.0025674663,
0.5035067201,
0.396140635,
-0.1487413645,
0.1191714853,
-0.1311115772,
-0.0114339218,
0.1658683568,
0.0181514937,
0.6446628571,
-0.5748924613,
-0.4031158984,
-0.1233659089,
0.2074003667,
0.7295593619,
-0.2960623503,
0.6799309254,
0.559022069,
-0.1809291691,
-0.1955103725,
-0.7498804927,
0.1021498218,
-0.3992215097,
0.3911119998,
-0.2533189654,
-1.0532989502,
0.437325269,
-0.1529634893,
0.1644478887,
0.4329901338,
0.6640913486,
-0.2269462645,
0.7877522707,
0.4262073636,
-0.5266253948,
0.2964078188,
-0.125496015,
0.4238619506,
-0.9375266433,
-0.1250021011,
-0.5215606093,
-0.1833574027,
-0.6827857494,
-0.4307915866,
0.3691550195,
-0.063004896,
0.0448107123,
-0.1357557327,
-0.2153871208,
0.2750559747,
0.1674647778,
-0.0608924143,
0.2103509158,
-0.106859006,
0.3147805929,
-0.0510019176,
-0.611518383,
-0.891552031,
1.0191152096,
0.6239318252,
0.658727169,
-0.1295647174,
0.608222425,
0.4125542343,
0.4773215353,
-1.2897746563,
0.8609763384,
-0.4971095026,
-0.2178553194,
-0.1267175078,
-0.3458116055,
-0.6028254628,
0.4717174172,
-0.2006031126,
-0.5818589926,
-0.0853855386,
-0.1229866594,
-0.1747537106,
0.2151213288,
-0.5941063762,
0.7379848361,
-0.0708735436,
-0.1172924861,
-0.3101019263,
-0.3514016867,
0.2994781733,
-0.1593145579,
0.3258484602,
-0.2731854022,
0.0460734218,
0.6443029642,
0.0375190005,
1.1240562201,
-0.266156584,
-0.2030955553,
0.3119370639,
-0.0464428365,
0.2942607403,
-0.0242921636,
-0.2296456546,
0.4433567524,
0.0512649566,
-0.2285957187,
-0.5655673146,
1.0022439957,
-0.5951318741,
-0.4449208379,
-0.5288186669,
-0.2785573006,
-0.4490751326,
-0.1628176719,
0.0597961657,
0.3673483133,
-0.3330936134,
0.237093091,
0.5155116916,
-0.1534104347,
0.5325824022,
0.1894187629,
-0.1103724241,
-0.2557914257,
0.8610050082,
0.1184644848,
0.1357036531,
0.2098894417,
0.1730293185,
-0.3197781146,
-0.645371139,
-0.2927406132,
0.2657946646,
-0.9791319966,
-0.2096257508,
-0.5260758996,
-0.0545212179,
-0.2166921049,
0.1096299663,
-0.5131757855,
-0.2111437172,
-0.1042181477,
0.1781409532,
0.1384295523,
0.7652159929,
0.2893551588,
0.308826983,
-0.9710533619,
0.0534914397,
0.2110351473,
0.4122544527,
0.157200098,
-0.3297718167,
-0.1422138214,
-0.0378154218,
-0.1380213797,
-0.7197262645,
0.2497240752,
0.0742330849,
0.4016641378,
0.1321297735,
-0.1946392059,
0.312512666,
-0.3034923077,
1.1822228432,
0.0197074525,
-0.9112796187,
0.3277431428,
-0.2521985173,
0.348415941,
0.4993388057,
0.248731181,
-0.7458830476,
-0.3801574707,
-0.3930214345,
-0.7588415146,
0.51514256,
0.1254760176,
0.2412974387,
0.0193057954,
0.4002110362,
0.2002265602,
0.3619648814,
-0.7570778131,
-0.0283108763,
0.0402313359,
-0.3531561792,
-0.141684413,
-0.4268038869,
0.1167181358,
0.0343285128,
0.5946212411,
-0.1348080188,
0.2816691399,
0.0234183874,
-0.3392756581,
0.2430316061,
0.6200810075,
0.2542156279,
0.3985867202,
0.0240780916,
0.0380530283,
0.3803113997,
-0.3327219784,
-0.1454952657,
0.0222968999,
-0.0527108535,
-0.049539011,
0.4776658118,
0.8238403797,
0.23866871,
-0.7366883159,
0.7245599627,
0.0660806373,
0.0651777834,
-0.2431355864,
-0.0378712602,
0.0341605544,
0.4140768945,
0.2345578372,
-0.0440092906,
0.1719821244,
-0.5211727619,
-0.2870906293,
0.7056428194,
-0.4572088122,
-0.4834315777,
0.0836314633,
0.1835140437,
-0.0101318387,
0.4113742709,
-0.1726835966,
-0.6354284883,
0.3989508748,
-0.0562012568,
1.0016487837,
0.2121176869,
0.2061432451,
0.0018369858,
0.2573432922,
-0.114271462,
0.1519853771,
0.1460884213,
-0.6943687201,
-0.7247811556,
-0.8915814757,
-0.6352779269,
0.2072671056,
-0.6193296909,
0.085866794,
-0.43407166,
-0.3049945831,
0.054116223,
0.0737049654,
-0.8110976815,
0.3294261098,
0.3269740641,
0.654216826,
-0.8521529436,
0.5411099792,
1.0362919569,
-0.2761678696,
-0.4948205948,
0.2794389427,
-0.0399500243,
-0.5962218046,
0.6447033286,
0.3094884753,
-0.3565161824,
-0.2967276573,
-0.5317333937,
-0.2951514125,
0.6969806552,
-0.0841429159,
-0.5179463029,
0.1618760377,
0.3930663466,
0.9237082005,
-0.4027738869,
0.2979913652,
0.8040409684,
0.2568303645,
-0.0685138553,
-0.8035430908,
-0.1591810286,
-0.0570971146,
-0.0090786638,
0.1537565291,
-0.8444888592,
0.5882179141,
0.1873892099,
0.0267640445,
-0.0928639024,
0.7645758986,
0.1582298577,
0.3041087985,
0.620472014,
0.2949944735,
0.6469817162,
-0.2022531778,
1.0571746826,
-0.2011324614,
0.4701080918,
0.7402852178,
-0.4577943385,
1.1297062635,
0.4136344194,
-0.3311184943,
0.3495977819,
0.5546064973,
-0.0169196874,
0.1833310872,
0.1556950212,
-0.3986943066,
-0.379535675,
-0.0614780933,
0.0033341779,
0.7398245335,
0.2720603943,
-0.1338054389,
-0.1096639335,
0.233866781,
-0.0432353653,
-0.1011550799,
-0.5302516222,
0.8296740651,
0.3674025834,
-0.4115040898,
0.0689320415,
-0.0802182257,
1.0113313198,
-0.5479025245,
0.2660115361,
-0.2427738607,
0.124879919,
-0.1784221828,
-1.1185183525,
0.2537052631,
0.3851840496,
0.0145709831,
-0.0982139632,
1.0151698589,
0.0076352209,
-0.4976742268,
0.2287367135,
0.6721884012,
0.2012540251,
-0.3309183419,
-0.6295357943,
0.287861079,
-0.1248688027,
-0.6035453677,
0.4647586942,
0.4696390927,
0.0690517798,
0.7466976047,
0.3938120306,
0.2614814341,
-0.2432879359,
0.4349402189,
0.8426248431,
-0.7689023614,
-0.2184448689,
-1.0837271214,
0.3117816746,
-0.0987195522,
-0.314763993,
0.9288647771,
0.5119229555,
0.5516651869,
-0.1283645183,
1.0002250671,
0.0938556269,
0.5990222692,
-0.578122139,
0.4501612782,
-0.4319595993,
0.4013222754,
-0.3576441705,
-1.0488424301,
-0.3185984492,
0.3768722415,
-0.5950648785,
0.0453578308,
0.5149262547,
0.5569114089,
0.1960750073,
0.2933802009,
0.2081831247,
0.0323889963,
0.3341264129,
0.2301784009,
1.2389602661,
-0.1139140651,
0.3011707664,
-0.123916164,
-0.1063993871,
-0.1025857627,
-0.8979153633,
-1.0845936537,
-0.2771547437,
-0.2273883224,
-0.1553323418,
-0.1462742835,
1.0706230402,
0.3351128399,
-0.7100186348,
-0.2295063734,
0.3423609734,
-0.1522541642,
0.0405986272,
-0.2346988469,
0.3160013855,
-0.5834813714,
-0.7815226912,
0.2660139203,
0.3436525762,
-0.1656728685,
-0.4295885265,
0.2229842693,
0.211831674,
0.1718375087,
0.9887560606,
-0.0987389758,
-0.6896885633,
-0.4183141589,
0.0904622525,
-0.192953378,
0.2118521929,
0.9518173337,
-0.4151559174,
0.1622010171,
0.4490209222,
0.683229208,
0.4204885364,
-0.055674646,
0.1761216521,
-0.8551912904,
-0.0720368922,
0.356756866,
0.3469672501,
0.6137470007,
-0.1590986103,
0.2631294429,
0.0002595624,
-0.6688825488,
-0.7317237854,
-0.0005227735,
-1.1699734926,
-0.2422957271,
1.4916266203,
-0.0893323272,
-0.1206172407,
0.2849144638,
-0.2712064385,
0.0749861524,
-0.398452729,
0.6343603134,
0.9858097434,
-0.2196512371,
-0.1496944726,
-0.627979219,
0.32746014,
0.4715388119,
-0.9227234721,
0.2854645848,
0.6610810161,
0.243561253,
0.0294027049,
0.5635026693,
-0.078840673,
-0.1109197438,
-0.3129574358,
0.0530090928,
0.2563831806,
-0.1545632482,
-0.7688189149,
0.4798450768,
0.5083946586,
-0.1897911578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15004v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15004v3 | LLMDet: A Third Party Large Language Models Generated Text Detection Tool | 2023-05-24T10:45:16 | 2023-11-03T14:31:09 | Kangxi Wu, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generated texts from large language models (LLMs) are remarkably close to
high-quality human-authored text, raising concerns about their potential misuse
in spreading false information and academic misconduct. Consequently, there is
an urgent need for a highly practical detection tool capable of accurately
identifying the source of a given text. However, existing detection tools
typically rely on access to LLMs and can only differentiate between
machine-generated and human-authored text, failing to meet the requirements of
fine-grained tracing, intermediary judgment, and rapid detection. Therefore, we
propose LLMDet, a model-specific, secure, efficient, and extendable detection
tool, that can source text from specific LLMs, such as GPT-2, OPT, LLaMA, and
others. In LLMDet, we record the next-token probabilities of salient n-grams as
features to calculate proxy perplexity for each LLM. By jointly analyzing the
proxy perplexities of LLMs, we can determine the source of the generated text.
Experimental results show that LLMDet yields impressive detection performance
while ensuring speed and security, achieving 98.54% precision and x5.0 faster
for recognizing human-authored text. Additionally, LLMDet can effortlessly
extend its detection capabilities to a new open-source model. We will provide
an open-source tool at https://github.com/TrustedLLM/LLMDet. | [
-0.0852785558,
-0.8044601679,
0.945987463,
0.0649102926,
-0.6177782416,
0.0766717643,
0.0216641109,
-0.5058736801,
0.1186915636,
0.845687151,
-0.4993468225,
-0.8213319182,
-0.6628944874,
0.2112808973,
-0.5660809875,
0.678935647,
0.0206749346,
-0.3624752164,
0.0487045608,
0.206056878,
-0.1705945432,
-0.498316288,
-0.5151315331,
-0.3738150597,
0.4687893093,
0.1395646781,
0.4282495081,
0.7020814419,
0.571939528,
0.2502996624,
-0.0607192963,
0.2042294294,
-0.5614678264,
0.2334220856,
-0.3127146065,
-0.5092794895,
-0.6996654272,
0.0155229997,
0.5221461058,
0.0624436177,
0.0135359718,
0.1180811971,
-0.1248649284,
0.2873002589,
-0.5214529634,
-0.1928189248,
-1.0019390583,
-0.1145772934,
-0.7372821569,
-0.3225468099,
-0.4790030122,
-0.3419708014,
-0.1644607633,
-0.2764344811,
0.0248245709,
-0.0920939744,
0.5853294134,
0.0265415367,
-0.6014377475,
-0.2592793703,
-0.057510253,
0.7347200513,
-0.8850961924,
0.2838909924,
0.2533668578,
0.2294986099,
-0.4035921097,
-0.8824637532,
-0.7241755128,
-0.1644292027,
0.2718149722,
0.0145851709,
-0.2790863216,
-0.1053292453,
-0.0251845773,
0.2111629993,
-0.5312812328,
0.5063956976,
0.167209968,
-0.4420786798,
0.5279021263,
0.0847701877,
0.6112781763,
-0.2431669533,
-0.3083917201,
0.0413280055,
-1.0306600332,
-0.6608231664,
0.852034688,
0.174494952,
-0.1092302427,
0.7918062806,
-0.0373827107,
0.4612647891,
-0.3818057179,
-0.3053091168,
0.1769444793,
-0.0256852526,
-0.0086925905,
0.0899984837,
0.9575877786,
0.2414935231,
0.3774652779,
0.0821292996,
-0.4873434901,
0.047673557,
-0.0535763875,
-0.9637691379,
-0.3066932261,
0.1402839273,
-0.4914770424,
-0.860856235,
-0.010419012,
-0.5862777233,
-0.7623848915,
-0.1161983982,
0.1664755344,
-0.1695324481,
-0.5794981718,
-0.0290750414,
-0.0370272733,
0.001603848,
0.2061914951,
-0.5922383666,
-0.0414312296,
0.9192178249,
0.9618809819,
-0.5995044112,
-0.1699019521,
-0.7195339203,
0.3739081323,
-0.31448403,
0.95402807,
-0.5461162329,
-0.4614381194,
0.0007018713,
0.0558141246,
0.4595127404,
-0.4127556682,
0.6085608602,
-0.7726021409,
-0.0077001718,
-0.109736301,
-0.6048785448,
0.0834018961,
0.2209259868,
-0.777864635,
1.0412840843,
-0.0272704009,
-1.0756504536,
0.2258337587,
-0.5151535273,
-0.3805254698,
0.3743462265,
-0.2647683024,
-0.455919683,
0.141517818,
0.3816356361,
0.5949941874,
-0.5146553516,
0.2902487218,
-0.4036517143,
-0.4706998765,
0.2372796535,
-0.930642724,
0.8570311666,
0.0629190579,
-0.196728617,
0.176652357,
-0.9503000975,
-0.0858515725,
0.394852668,
-0.5362378955,
-0.4839156568,
-0.1039242297,
0.2952891588,
-0.0440977775,
0.5309228897,
-0.6516039371,
0.0418052934,
-0.3709503412,
0.3851428926,
1.1038695574,
0.0944217816,
0.0672969669,
0.0516552813,
0.6426802278,
-0.1686689854,
-0.1931280196,
-0.2078399658,
-0.6956192851,
-0.2191071808,
-0.5735476613,
0.2883113027,
0.6673631072,
-0.8918166757,
0.325879693,
-0.1685356647,
-0.3921992779,
-0.3220110536,
0.2279904038,
0.4696495235,
0.3524028659,
0.0960294232,
0.1034674942,
-0.5648790598,
-0.9027382135,
-0.5861513019,
-0.2410234809,
-0.4132652283,
0.11719767,
0.6742877364,
-0.4795440435,
0.8152768612,
-0.6554302573,
-0.0758677572,
-0.2009583116,
0.0939778537,
0.2549162805,
0.2418722957,
0.4388785362,
-0.6633545756,
-0.4754285216,
0.2500249743,
-0.7791814804,
-0.7372540236,
0.1690735221,
-0.1150523573,
0.1740967631,
0.7528354526,
-0.3625950515,
0.0396087021,
0.8907812238,
-0.2989034653,
0.7751768231,
-0.058639884,
-0.203455314,
-1.3834221363,
0.0186161175,
-0.0901477933,
-0.4436909258,
-0.4666535854,
0.0618074276,
0.2777830064,
0.1444151849,
-0.4236886799,
0.7979763746,
-0.3020498157,
-0.1129650027,
-0.4933440983,
0.4353696108,
-0.0276738945,
0.0317441747,
-0.0730257779,
1.0878293514,
0.0881484523,
-0.2650538087,
0.3706406653,
0.1039422378,
-0.44670555,
0.707541585,
-0.5731509328,
0.3371105492,
0.1603477448,
0.1648608446,
-0.8592723012,
-0.3742925525,
0.1802050918,
-0.3339680433,
-0.0217785779,
-0.4063116312,
-0.7322254777,
-0.1106477603,
-0.3520846963,
0.2345294356,
0.2600796819,
-0.8669492006,
0.5349415541,
0.5135859847,
-0.3093977869,
-0.6521388292,
-0.7742060423,
0.4732981026,
0.0086039351,
-0.5821086764,
0.2877238989,
0.1012333781,
-0.3774718344,
-0.0430578925,
-0.1134734899,
-0.132329151,
0.1338648349,
0.1303877234,
0.4386870265,
-0.2453377694,
0.0396864302,
0.2983320057,
-0.1968926489,
0.093018353,
-0.4211759567,
0.5157262087,
0.146146372,
-0.4742618203,
-0.3887992799,
0.2699719071,
0.713691175,
-0.187300235,
0.4463272691,
0.7436821461,
-0.2622687519,
-0.4506901503,
-0.6074410081,
-0.1856851876,
-0.5546650887,
0.6101188064,
-0.4714868069,
-0.9074729681,
0.2625524402,
-0.1210755557,
-0.1417720169,
0.2995062172,
0.7695255876,
0.3531585634,
0.9666360617,
0.6529883146,
-0.1328672916,
0.4067664742,
0.2703059018,
0.0558242798,
-0.7729052901,
0.0832407326,
-0.2627726495,
0.1805664301,
-0.6348137856,
-0.3643654287,
0.0572946854,
-0.2753855288,
-0.0883840322,
0.3589002192,
-0.3938748837,
0.8247388601,
0.5130567551,
0.049565617,
0.5447750092,
0.0131118027,
-0.3146259487,
0.1541087329,
0.018908048,
-0.8103915453,
1.309486866,
0.5261467695,
0.6355427504,
0.2507675588,
0.7638173699,
0.4645697773,
0.4298301041,
-0.5193663239,
0.7715014815,
-0.1307218373,
-0.4817689061,
-0.0068107424,
-0.4874945581,
-0.652148366,
0.4534807503,
-0.0036106498,
-0.7408901453,
-0.064428404,
-0.1346864402,
0.2025652081,
0.5552565455,
-0.5965810418,
0.6280537844,
-0.0616201833,
-0.3972335756,
0.1693594456,
-0.1244003624,
0.6568444371,
-0.4227730334,
0.010384066,
-0.4191713929,
-0.3802152872,
0.6481365561,
-0.4382519722,
0.8485575318,
-0.0914837867,
-0.8726650476,
0.2927055955,
0.4081280828,
1.0216515064,
0.3286311924,
-0.0668344125,
0.3549722135,
-0.2093838006,
-0.1754290164,
-0.0891153738,
0.8637734652,
-0.4691584706,
-0.5934391022,
-0.2564025521,
-0.6087799668,
0.1254345477,
0.6136902571,
0.2196130157,
0.2492140979,
-0.0048568081,
-0.0187060293,
0.6192473173,
-0.3323804736,
0.2318527848,
0.6365089417,
-0.4312159419,
-0.3797938824,
1.0453417301,
-0.3083739579,
0.184509173,
0.4276791811,
0.2109180987,
-0.2830885649,
-0.849129498,
-0.2864239216,
0.3480502069,
-0.8936904669,
-0.3416424394,
-0.6421582699,
-0.058046259,
-0.2093786597,
-0.2134590745,
-0.2594258785,
-0.1647260934,
-0.4266945422,
-0.1313084215,
0.3856753111,
0.6694902778,
0.0598992035,
0.5711284876,
-0.6344793439,
0.4074089825,
0.4272385836,
0.3525807261,
-0.2687873244,
-0.4036630988,
0.2855297923,
-0.1735304445,
-0.1225383207,
-0.8216991425,
0.5044624805,
-0.2438215166,
0.306376338,
0.5075210333,
-0.038461946,
0.1275868863,
-0.5309027433,
0.6946621537,
0.0684536546,
-1.0302470922,
0.3612431288,
-0.6290400028,
0.1772917658,
0.2113144696,
0.0072633796,
-0.340731591,
-0.5057805777,
-0.125781551,
-0.6611347198,
0.6289444566,
0.299377203,
0.1281116754,
-0.1451271474,
0.3174951971,
0.1591864228,
0.1135305986,
-0.7931790352,
0.0958577991,
0.1123045385,
-0.4464791715,
0.2353856415,
-0.5551467538,
0.0046666288,
0.4505198598,
0.6340857744,
-0.235681802,
0.1006097496,
0.0469581895,
-0.2209585011,
0.0269679744,
0.3083684444,
0.5206021667,
0.5052776933,
-0.3451895118,
0.2631921768,
0.2555977106,
-0.9484132528,
0.0924667418,
0.0379609726,
-0.1375384033,
-0.0400036126,
0.6011021733,
0.2548775971,
-0.1560239792,
-0.8452970386,
0.7824854851,
-0.0978023037,
-0.27455616,
-0.3282261193,
-0.1038182676,
0.2444039285,
0.4005617201,
0.296642065,
-0.1882931292,
0.1842983514,
-0.2583030164,
0.2041128576,
0.3995709419,
-0.3020882607,
-0.3067715466,
0.7105592489,
0.2385199517,
-0.2955519259,
0.4137943983,
-0.2319644541,
-0.632586062,
0.5310077071,
0.8196113706,
0.9173271656,
-0.0537397191,
0.1953567713,
-0.1461223811,
0.4394890666,
-0.1330584884,
0.3691576123,
0.2190159708,
-0.7776053548,
-0.5609127879,
-0.586904645,
-0.3599619567,
0.3063289225,
-0.0678988323,
0.4763607383,
-0.3301887512,
-0.0889028683,
-0.1049880385,
-0.1525067687,
-0.2626009881,
-0.2789033949,
0.3466709554,
0.8920755982,
-0.7071405053,
1.0146250725,
0.4834292531,
-0.045893956,
-0.3116585016,
0.1528974175,
0.3352744579,
-1.0873869658,
0.6780739427,
0.307094574,
-0.4327246845,
0.1828715801,
-0.6162288785,
-0.5844992399,
1.1793892384,
0.5401697159,
-0.7189406157,
0.0741357654,
0.0923969522,
0.1871768683,
-0.1771903634,
0.2689475119,
0.5235231519,
0.4811188579,
-0.0328401886,
-0.6956302524,
0.4302707016,
-0.0605846271,
0.1104461923,
0.3020837307,
-0.3040408492,
1.056024313,
0.0323579684,
-0.2135311514,
0.040476311,
0.4361104071,
0.5192123652,
0.1102300584,
0.3142760992,
0.4131551087,
0.8641486764,
0.1542448103,
0.9435146451,
-0.0950944871,
0.1623602808,
1.0308961868,
-0.5477598906,
0.806897819,
0.3373585045,
-0.1466880739,
0.3393319249,
0.2793723941,
-0.1649822444,
0.4035728872,
0.3436186314,
-0.4807008505,
-0.2530530393,
-0.0347752906,
-0.2563565373,
0.3474819064,
0.429137677,
-0.4414218962,
-0.2284516692,
-0.0975566953,
0.2700291872,
0.0637400076,
-0.263716042,
0.4472037852,
0.1408676058,
-0.1995084137,
0.3080097139,
0.2685098648,
0.8725818992,
-0.5248558521,
-0.1362800002,
-0.0566889681,
0.3905289471,
-0.15157336,
-0.8284758329,
-0.1021848843,
0.193880111,
0.0900020376,
0.0863128528,
1.0479021072,
-0.2465347797,
-0.4466052949,
0.2987771034,
0.5141015053,
0.2050300092,
-0.3946523368,
-0.4572355747,
0.3698221743,
-0.063415885,
-0.4389467835,
0.2409826964,
0.6945743561,
-0.0306838267,
0.7005265355,
1.0141023397,
0.161827758,
-0.1264410615,
0.1513588279,
0.8336319923,
-0.3944720328,
-0.4429613054,
-1.1727919579,
0.0378205366,
-0.3611001372,
-0.1961462349,
0.7939095497,
0.4207473695,
0.5895839334,
-0.0414194092,
1.0201966763,
0.2795311213,
0.4768720269,
-0.7439637184,
0.8923788071,
-0.4365032315,
0.7190264463,
-0.3480039537,
-0.9660873413,
-0.4900605083,
0.2967230976,
-0.2489522845,
-0.1527393162,
0.6427948475,
0.8493089676,
-0.1221897155,
0.0316499248,
0.2988575995,
0.216319114,
0.834992528,
0.3167346716,
0.7255114913,
-0.188374415,
0.7874459624,
0.1421681046,
-0.2449742258,
-0.3873285055,
-1.2149908543,
-1.3075524569,
-0.2869642079,
-0.1358272135,
-0.2703789771,
0.1333860159,
0.8336450458,
0.3836122155,
-0.611762464,
-0.0241673179,
-0.3946466446,
0.2852110267,
0.2148430049,
-0.2320758551,
0.4932172,
-0.0840791836,
-0.7056481838,
0.5731381178,
0.2937192023,
0.2453511059,
-0.3235783875,
0.1246480197,
-0.1662704498,
0.2325403392,
0.7288751006,
-0.0222716462,
-0.7254029512,
-0.232434988,
-0.1920332611,
-0.1668739617,
-0.3220483065,
0.715000093,
-0.5080987215,
0.1507293433,
0.5538604856,
0.64916116,
0.2211547941,
-0.2416319102,
0.5452796817,
-0.8447209597,
0.1597747505,
0.1570625007,
0.3352344036,
0.2725987732,
-0.4493335187,
0.502887249,
0.3326040506,
-0.5902425647,
-1.2110801935,
0.4288353324,
-0.7302627563,
-0.4838458896,
1.3024420738,
-0.1611181647,
-0.3913771808,
-0.1820597649,
-0.4657178819,
0.0448638648,
-0.5384341478,
0.4081331491,
0.436178416,
0.5028238893,
-0.0256524514,
-0.7723487616,
0.2533136904,
0.0262714475,
-0.8484547734,
0.2790716588,
0.3141645789,
0.4406341612,
-0.1394475251,
0.5868575573,
-0.2552958727,
-0.0478532612,
0.113196291,
0.1675996482,
-0.306613028,
-0.071257621,
-0.0160102081,
0.2193450928,
-0.0697946474,
0.0588779151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15002v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15002v2 | A RelEntLess Benchmark for Modelling Graded Relations between Named Entities | 2023-05-24T10:41:24 | 2024-01-31T03:56:22 | Asahi Ushio, Jose Camacho Collados, Steven Schockaert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Relations such as "is influenced by", "is known for" or "is a competitor of"
are inherently graded: we can rank entity pairs based on how well they satisfy
these relations, but it is hard to draw a line between those pairs that satisfy
them and those that do not. Such graded relations play a central role in many
applications, yet they are typically not covered by existing Knowledge Graphs.
In this paper, we consider the possibility of using Large Language Models
(LLMs) to fill this gap. To this end, we introduce a new benchmark, in which
entity pairs have to be ranked according to how much they satisfy a given
graded relation. The task is formulated as a few-shot ranking problem, where
models only have access to a description of the relation and five prototypical
instances. We use the proposed benchmark to evaluate state-of-the-art relation
embedding strategies as well as several recent LLMs, covering both publicly
available LLMs and closed models such as GPT-4. Overall, we find a strong
correlation between model size and performance, with smaller Language Models
struggling to outperform a naive baseline. The results of the largest Flan-T5
and OPT models are remarkably strong, although a clear gap with human
performance remains. | [
-0.3887847364,
-0.5536570549,
0.8628302813,
0.1817561239,
-0.0161056332,
0.0866697282,
-0.2974600196,
-0.6311715841,
-0.0166931096,
0.4796514511,
-0.1666267961,
-0.597215116,
-0.6830921173,
-0.0723837689,
-0.2155403197,
0.8827385902,
-0.0539184883,
0.100983493,
-0.4207693338,
-0.4706714153,
-0.0691266283,
-0.5204375982,
-0.6105419397,
-0.7077840567,
0.684180975,
0.0734453052,
0.7760375142,
0.801543951,
0.8965204954,
0.243803978,
-0.2807989717,
0.0200711805,
-0.747155726,
0.1699926555,
-0.1893409342,
-0.4646074176,
-0.6159619689,
0.3474066257,
0.8803021908,
1.0955332518,
-0.2125122994,
0.2688829005,
-0.1936502755,
0.6086522937,
-0.7118330002,
0.4761772752,
-0.6708188057,
-0.0498511605,
-0.4000165462,
0.0561473966,
-0.4356688857,
-0.3197985291,
0.0291903019,
-0.5241678953,
-0.2218737602,
0.224058494,
1.0092852116,
0.1819623709,
-0.4934637547,
-0.1486214995,
-0.5866324306,
0.5219718814,
-0.5301836729,
0.6091113687,
0.3516326249,
0.3763063848,
-0.2892615795,
-0.6802471876,
-0.1196394637,
-0.6058808565,
-0.0870831683,
0.0008478945,
-0.045513723,
0.2468385696,
0.4203753173,
0.5491963625,
-0.1480053961,
0.1854996979,
-0.0380497202,
0.1325009167,
0.5000162125,
0.1825459749,
0.2206086963,
-0.0783012956,
-0.6134876013,
0.0686843321,
-0.8360497355,
0.0013710883,
0.3673115671,
0.3076069355,
0.1133918613,
0.6904044151,
-0.1686297059,
0.5796059966,
-0.1066359282,
-0.3084390163,
0.0850980207,
-0.1308378875,
-0.1218015477,
-0.0640174598,
0.7082697153,
0.4276576936,
0.6310772896,
-0.4558805823,
-0.5046668053,
0.3444288969,
-0.1051784307,
-0.9202200174,
-0.3396363854,
-0.2600878477,
-0.2066473216,
-0.0916215926,
-0.234704718,
-0.4016666412,
-0.3821047544,
-0.1421145797,
0.4023064375,
-0.3184174895,
-0.3525426984,
-0.1895470917,
0.1081670746,
0.142652005,
0.0577240549,
-0.8769652247,
0.5933978558,
1.0840904713,
0.9044854641,
0.0744240731,
-0.1906733513,
-0.5200937986,
0.3505966067,
-0.5137186646,
0.9118859768,
-0.8412508965,
-0.2570870817,
0.0029989835,
-0.4148896039,
0.050556615,
-0.6386986971,
0.4724772274,
-0.6975440979,
-0.1179295182,
-0.2274959385,
-1.2095745802,
0.2107841522,
0.3477495909,
-0.6844402552,
1.082349062,
0.2980237305,
-0.7825422883,
0.4507766962,
-0.2303773314,
-0.1238512546,
0.2810189724,
-0.3125443459,
-0.2877492905,
0.0105079515,
-0.0087481262,
0.5947039127,
-0.5731663704,
0.3679374158,
-0.7952502966,
-0.3342573941,
-0.0575046577,
0.078964822,
0.373705864,
-0.1620400548,
0.0773881599,
-0.3484684229,
-0.7315317988,
-0.0902548283,
0.0674029961,
-0.3915078044,
-0.7108083367,
-0.167824626,
-0.2616413534,
0.3922760487,
0.2946405113,
-0.5794104338,
0.4304566085,
-0.2418771684,
0.4034953415,
0.7628496289,
0.0202076584,
0.628805995,
-0.23878254,
0.5161357522,
0.0722454563,
-0.1722284704,
0.0381325893,
-0.3906301558,
-0.7500662208,
-0.184900403,
0.7314744592,
0.1918525696,
-0.5314362645,
-0.0226998162,
-0.8588389158,
-0.5397320986,
-0.5690453053,
0.3326842487,
0.5451375842,
0.3501932323,
0.2914492786,
-0.3981416523,
-0.0429508537,
-1.1048909426,
-0.5483486056,
-0.3222679198,
0.0545959249,
0.5966515541,
0.3023860455,
0.1448680907,
0.81351161,
-0.5195819139,
-0.5204494596,
-0.0347219445,
-0.0855014026,
0.0460443906,
0.2606140077,
0.5920356512,
-0.3962149918,
-0.3712396622,
-0.1040743962,
-0.781733036,
0.1817342937,
0.3209146559,
-0.2295899093,
-0.0014339203,
0.4004692137,
-0.4839458466,
0.0072645661,
0.6529520154,
-0.169768557,
0.1117631122,
-0.1128179878,
-0.1309348047,
-0.7896082997,
-0.1744123697,
0.4844487607,
-0.5213140845,
-0.4834099412,
0.1593228877,
0.1580379158,
0.0287288129,
-0.3368378878,
0.6641677618,
-0.44227615,
-0.421207875,
0.3087699413,
0.5346781015,
-0.3118848503,
0.5021414757,
0.0557195693,
0.5880492926,
0.4416306913,
-0.5050154328,
0.1911758035,
0.1916689873,
-0.482308954,
0.8162226081,
-0.501203537,
0.2089713961,
-0.0027265123,
0.3890835941,
-0.7864179611,
-0.1592501253,
-0.213566184,
-0.1349893212,
0.3444007933,
-0.6951007843,
-0.7480216026,
-0.2882731259,
-0.3173406124,
0.4550170898,
0.3144093454,
-0.5662800074,
0.5968282819,
0.4641131163,
0.0133594805,
-0.3272221982,
-0.5939289331,
0.0787038207,
-0.2724333704,
-0.8966796994,
0.6075491905,
0.1547020227,
-0.3471784294,
0.2594422996,
-0.0601345524,
-0.0477287658,
-0.0225412566,
0.282990694,
0.121726498,
-0.456840992,
0.4093001783,
-0.3516125083,
-0.1303069741,
0.0769380555,
-0.1088503525,
0.4137586653,
-0.2019072026,
0.0704262406,
-0.1673984826,
0.0400704741,
0.6305584311,
-0.2985293865,
1.0416120291,
0.1503012329,
-0.5518317223,
-0.1907206327,
-0.730299592,
-0.0449561179,
-0.4460159242,
0.2969002128,
-0.6988122463,
-0.7970154881,
0.4372130632,
-0.2281604111,
-0.0729289725,
0.2985628843,
0.3207417727,
0.062199384,
0.9766192436,
0.8292845488,
-0.3680357933,
0.368070513,
-0.3530017734,
0.2879519165,
-1.0569854975,
-0.1956138313,
-0.3260405362,
-0.3079250157,
-1.005736351,
-0.2506854236,
0.2923385501,
0.3872144818,
-0.4708563387,
0.3737312555,
-0.0290527549,
0.4344080091,
0.4418016374,
-0.0077223042,
0.5513291955,
-0.1790689677,
-0.3636102676,
-0.0395068638,
-0.6306023598,
-0.6551951766,
1.1132919788,
0.5057500005,
0.6451064348,
0.3187512755,
0.9625654817,
-0.0001368869,
0.7246677876,
-0.8290849328,
0.6050772667,
-0.3684256375,
-0.6728098392,
-0.2098836899,
-0.7521303892,
-0.8181307316,
0.2316819429,
-0.0835830867,
-0.7032536864,
-0.1325052232,
0.0227251835,
-0.2157432586,
0.4355628192,
-0.4944275022,
0.7200998664,
-0.1502869278,
-0.6999662519,
-0.1281985343,
-0.3172136247,
0.654840827,
0.1260355264,
0.1561674625,
-0.5637814999,
-0.0413019806,
0.827103436,
-0.3700554669,
0.1632128954,
-0.0813555047,
-0.1750317961,
-0.076013118,
0.1549066752,
0.5705631971,
0.0362542085,
-0.2531763613,
-0.1288324445,
-0.053211838,
-0.5806634426,
-0.566550076,
1.1386936903,
-0.631403327,
-0.5229059458,
-0.174863115,
-0.3104639649,
-0.7021690011,
0.1014081761,
0.0303850006,
0.4675414562,
-0.1474644095,
0.1421376169,
0.4633773267,
0.0517561324,
0.4638363123,
0.4477936924,
-0.390152365,
-0.2061821222,
0.7796369195,
0.3287627697,
0.3444604576,
0.3321820498,
-0.0314100161,
-0.2958500385,
-0.2511584759,
-0.3772593737,
0.6151864529,
-0.6887977719,
-0.3404228985,
-0.7093691826,
-0.1089623719,
-0.1617483497,
0.155698061,
-0.5618362427,
-0.4391746223,
0.1087129116,
-0.0585708395,
0.3415035307,
1.0731089115,
0.2731803954,
-0.1480584741,
-0.5167740583,
0.1988051683,
0.4122280478,
0.8900329471,
0.173630774,
-0.3799086809,
-0.065326564,
-0.2662729919,
-0.3058018982,
-0.6569488645,
0.0712678283,
0.1496329904,
0.5712692142,
0.3716534376,
-0.1083281636,
0.6464461088,
-0.6476433873,
0.5991332531,
0.1410778016,
-0.7305032611,
0.3144976199,
-0.4011036158,
-0.1219644845,
0.6302987337,
0.4994027615,
-0.318215698,
-0.4646984339,
-0.7930940986,
-0.7006138563,
0.5472379327,
0.1814030409,
0.1078875139,
-0.0731679648,
0.4055353701,
-0.4820940793,
0.2517001033,
-0.9513879418,
-0.3856811821,
0.3457756639,
-0.1025799438,
-0.1841234863,
-0.3214896023,
0.1431952566,
-0.0344481952,
0.6098772287,
0.2057012767,
0.0774502382,
-0.2117607147,
-0.2057202309,
-0.1568471193,
0.245230794,
0.32716766,
0.5899033546,
-0.3235245347,
0.2744940221,
0.0261800811,
-0.1459289491,
0.1702043265,
0.2449159324,
0.0697147548,
-0.2370075285,
0.3705156744,
0.6485361457,
0.5654353499,
-0.3312249482,
0.5797237158,
0.1539116502,
0.0746297911,
0.0113433916,
-0.0548273474,
0.4382227659,
0.2731940746,
0.222194314,
-0.2824296951,
-0.068180643,
-0.8116177917,
0.0953741446,
0.5051051378,
-0.5005690455,
-0.1494666189,
0.5922679901,
0.3103190064,
-0.3690673709,
0.6523783207,
-0.4072489738,
-0.7442768216,
0.3968051374,
0.238883242,
0.2584368289,
-0.0257037524,
0.1070331112,
0.3002103269,
0.2497760504,
-0.3122048676,
-0.2300562561,
0.0830091164,
-0.6834381819,
-0.2095198482,
-0.7411601543,
-0.4069493115,
0.1315661669,
-0.6802951694,
0.3332220018,
-0.5684414506,
-0.4269254804,
0.1922446638,
0.3294219971,
-0.912794888,
0.0662507191,
0.2814151645,
0.7991041541,
-0.6608713269,
0.8008010983,
0.699242413,
-0.684868753,
-1.0157825947,
-0.035353452,
-0.2698338926,
-0.6016700268,
0.8665226698,
0.2475673109,
-0.0812830776,
0.2877064347,
-0.1634503603,
-0.8529432416,
1.0338948965,
0.5528762937,
-0.7235978246,
-0.2590614259,
0.0508913137,
0.7157170773,
-0.4669665098,
0.3538261056,
0.8195744753,
0.3952079713,
-0.2554156482,
-0.817332685,
-0.0830656365,
-0.0126366373,
0.1683919579,
0.5580118299,
-0.9904706478,
0.7252411246,
-0.0323093981,
-0.1546001732,
0.123837918,
0.6176528335,
0.3190687299,
0.1815859228,
0.4198792875,
0.8772830963,
0.636130631,
-0.2672188282,
1.3155469894,
-0.5359199643,
0.5357316732,
1.2088218927,
-0.4425531328,
1.1078457832,
0.1722881645,
-0.4943451583,
0.7081772089,
0.5566820502,
-0.1056906432,
0.3977848291,
0.5177775025,
-0.1586085558,
-0.5382820368,
-0.3299455643,
-0.3568847179,
0.4277944863,
0.3832633495,
-0.5516918898,
-0.1822315603,
-0.3816606998,
0.0755345747,
0.2849046588,
-0.4609735608,
0.6826461554,
0.3249231279,
-0.730004549,
0.3949985206,
0.1016993821,
0.6779465675,
-0.2076332867,
0.1464008093,
-0.5427763462,
0.1344263107,
-0.0640966445,
-0.6688911319,
-0.4818763733,
-0.0277087409,
-0.0608920194,
0.0381685086,
0.3888928592,
-0.6250498891,
-0.5835158229,
0.7206170559,
0.4457524121,
-0.0057778317,
0.1993756592,
-0.4111622274,
-0.085763149,
-0.5478731394,
-0.3649948835,
0.3466127217,
0.4604223371,
-0.1086395308,
0.8757751584,
0.2501923144,
0.1805420518,
0.1671700776,
0.2985064983,
0.8146935701,
-0.5213151574,
-0.1461697817,
-0.724992156,
0.0395044088,
-0.0936284736,
-0.2534534335,
0.6168599129,
0.6785966754,
0.7105469704,
0.4076927006,
0.2557014823,
0.4839992523,
0.3696541488,
-0.4981538057,
0.5225167274,
-0.5469269753,
0.4133190215,
-0.5154564977,
-1.3433138132,
-0.229611963,
0.3987071514,
-0.488756448,
0.4099464715,
0.6408030987,
0.5910686851,
-0.1919366568,
-0.2128153592,
0.5622172356,
0.2214702219,
0.2066631615,
0.9274571538,
0.946420908,
-0.2837976813,
0.5560014248,
-0.3937374353,
-0.0356526636,
-0.1873896569,
-0.9028233886,
-1.1309921741,
-0.3094324172,
-0.4093277752,
-0.1552819163,
0.2781759799,
0.8402132988,
0.7580748796,
-0.3577513993,
-0.1342221498,
-0.1155326962,
0.0703416467,
0.1412034631,
-0.1819367558,
0.1992179304,
-0.1543253213,
-0.8005696535,
0.1684336513,
0.3654987812,
0.0519598238,
-0.6086772084,
0.1432421654,
-0.2457103133,
0.1206875145,
0.5330471992,
-0.1092539951,
-0.7824125886,
-0.2550725341,
-0.2254827172,
-0.3371487856,
0.0865104496,
0.8798447847,
-0.8949666023,
0.1098156422,
0.0677998886,
0.5741699338,
0.7045657039,
0.1050893217,
0.4490302503,
-0.9075204134,
-0.1243529618,
0.2338901907,
0.4840462208,
0.7712239623,
-0.1598681509,
0.7828058004,
0.0656816214,
-0.5284051299,
-0.9295966029,
0.2159131616,
-0.6464497447,
0.0756554157,
1.3100423813,
-0.4504088759,
0.0667724609,
0.2398625612,
0.4603383839,
0.1301537305,
-0.4903106093,
0.521641016,
0.9369950294,
-0.0296215657,
-0.1401304603,
-0.5577282906,
0.536670208,
0.4374099076,
-0.5741257668,
0.018523505,
0.3030230999,
0.3069094419,
0.1364259869,
0.4646536708,
0.0640511215,
-0.0119695887,
-0.058166489,
-0.3105637729,
0.0123877702,
-0.2576157153,
-0.091307275,
0.2734815478,
0.4233098924,
0.231170252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14999v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14999v2 | The Art of SOCRATIC QUESTIONING: Recursive Thinking with Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T10:36:14 | 2023-11-02T02:40:48 | Jingyuan Qi, Zhiyang Xu, Ying Shen, Minqian Liu, Di Jin, Qifan Wang, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting enables large language models to solve
complex reasoning problems by generating intermediate steps. However, confined
by its inherent single-pass and sequential generation process, CoT heavily
relies on the initial decisions, causing errors in early steps to accumulate
and impact the final answers. In contrast, humans adopt recursive thinking when
tackling complex reasoning problems, i.e., iteratively breaking the original
problem into approachable sub-problems and aggregating their answers to resolve
the original one. Inspired by the human cognitive process, we propose SOCRATIC
QUESTIONING, a divide-and-conquer style algorithm that mimics the recursive
thinking process. Specifically, SOCRATIC QUESTIONING leverages large language
models to raise and answer sub-questions until collecting enough information to
tackle the original question. Unlike CoT, SOCRATIC QUESTIONING explicitly
navigates the thinking space, stimulates effective recursive thinking, and is
more robust towards errors in the thinking process. Extensive experiments on
several complex reasoning tasks, including MMLU, MATH, LogiQA, and visual
question-answering demonstrate significant performance improvements over the
state-of-the-art prompting methods, such as CoT, and Tree-of-Thought. The
qualitative analysis clearly shows that the intermediate reasoning steps
elicited by SOCRATIC QUESTIONING are similar to humans' recursively thinking
process of complex reasoning problems. | [
-0.6427178383,
-1.1207844019,
0.7937986255,
0.1220570877,
-0.3369832337,
0.8819895387,
-0.0037300773,
-0.3728725314,
0.0708413273,
0.3541702032,
-0.7229321599,
-0.2160697728,
-0.4508226216,
0.0855811387,
-0.207307294,
0.693383038,
-0.112075083,
0.1972037852,
-0.0545376316,
0.0126883229,
-0.306853503,
-0.5931574702,
-0.9190481901,
-0.4330098927,
0.3934971988,
0.4591127932,
0.7999366522,
-0.1844496429,
-0.0187131576,
0.2410234213,
-0.2117886692,
0.3818202019,
-0.5790444613,
0.2472828478,
-0.4315108359,
-0.8090615273,
-0.025767548,
-0.1160522699,
0.353972286,
0.745246172,
-0.232305482,
0.2379315346,
-0.2829897106,
1.0528503656,
-0.4889330864,
-0.1232210621,
-0.5589454174,
0.1226799935,
0.2577587962,
-0.2929512858,
-0.3633221388,
-0.6738190055,
0.2390458137,
-0.0508433841,
0.4751676619,
0.1424711645,
0.2064193338,
0.0381089412,
-0.3315844238,
-0.3605076671,
-0.782276988,
0.6040410995,
-0.2354058176,
0.3713172078,
0.2730356157,
0.236289829,
-0.4190999269,
-0.4293778539,
-0.7872519493,
-0.2449207604,
0.097134307,
0.0141135985,
-0.0568320937,
-0.0723298192,
0.2795349956,
0.3460808992,
-0.5015664101,
-0.5813257694,
-0.7879366279,
0.0376085117,
0.6340996623,
0.3208555579,
0.3358143568,
0.074016273,
-0.3252132237,
0.1232515574,
-0.9074519277,
0.4467591941,
-0.0240940768,
-0.0275822692,
0.300617218,
0.3003915846,
-0.1643385291,
0.7167772055,
0.2002665997,
0.0434912033,
-0.2263543606,
-0.4070053101,
-0.052229818,
0.0640245676,
0.5997666121,
0.2166918665,
0.4875060022,
0.005582551,
-0.1042178124,
0.0888441354,
0.3740871251,
-0.3250287771,
-0.3517377079,
0.3435632288,
0.086291939,
-0.3526747823,
-0.1933113337,
-0.7399446368,
-0.3985033333,
-0.3535010219,
0.3833082616,
-0.5564706922,
-0.1250702441,
0.3464172482,
-0.0004971072,
0.4299713373,
0.6562730074,
-0.7056179643,
0.4476570487,
0.7813476324,
0.8774163723,
0.0069895587,
-0.2182426453,
-0.5526880622,
-0.2071306705,
-0.6336886287,
1.0489759445,
-0.6991855502,
-0.4505704939,
-0.2688260972,
0.0234449003,
-0.1742180437,
-0.4898498058,
0.1042886153,
-0.5638398528,
0.1128277406,
-0.6046560407,
-0.1362164468,
-0.2683689594,
0.6419652104,
-0.5631777048,
1.1113009453,
0.074571006,
-0.5645062327,
0.0455722474,
-0.5972437263,
-0.4118794501,
0.2108258754,
-0.5278193951,
0.0173702203,
0.0736358389,
0.2515601516,
-0.0032668936,
-0.7967741489,
0.1000626981,
0.0033276621,
-0.3361311853,
0.4105668962,
-0.1490872353,
1.1048156023,
0.1825231016,
-0.70936656,
-0.0630946159,
-0.2702062726,
0.1440469921,
0.3536322415,
0.0499629341,
-0.2235920876,
0.1091838405,
-0.6594296098,
0.2741784751,
0.0718434304,
-0.7145894766,
0.3706339598,
-0.3839634955,
0.6119037867,
0.78829211,
0.3200098872,
0.2902008295,
-0.7043550611,
0.9793165326,
-0.05655054,
0.3466541767,
0.1400006711,
-0.6592304111,
-0.6501806974,
0.1802437603,
-0.0575171039,
0.49163118,
-0.8807245493,
-0.1127066761,
0.2180830687,
-0.7466885448,
-0.6628599167,
-0.0870241597,
0.354183346,
0.2046153545,
0.0730610788,
-0.3884691894,
-0.3183256984,
-0.3286930919,
0.221365124,
-0.3483454883,
0.358274579,
0.1498459131,
0.6290434003,
0.1688566655,
0.6492088437,
-0.8662527204,
0.4082416296,
-0.3214501739,
0.4119226336,
-0.0461074524,
0.3309659064,
0.1894410551,
-0.871071279,
-0.3321337998,
-0.1048995256,
-0.4282797873,
0.0196503513,
-0.1569952816,
-0.4158421457,
-0.0139694102,
0.5611599088,
-0.6759821177,
0.4649778306,
0.1892455071,
-0.3575031161,
1.261944294,
0.0011411969,
0.3468182683,
-0.8120083809,
-0.0220873915,
-0.6812250018,
-0.1228463873,
-0.4177798629,
0.3330815434,
-0.350358665,
-0.1557538509,
-0.3582608402,
0.1492981315,
-0.5469567776,
-0.1876894534,
-0.1666843891,
0.4667959511,
0.3258267045,
0.3703340292,
-0.1154569536,
0.8621993661,
0.5418224931,
-0.6699169278,
0.6988880038,
0.0101609314,
-0.4354482591,
0.498042196,
-0.7100910544,
0.5958983898,
-0.4362251759,
0.3444952071,
-1.4603908062,
0.3564958274,
0.2129768729,
-0.6237710714,
-0.2197429836,
0.2550911605,
-0.4259247184,
-0.4231156409,
-0.4762865901,
0.8091343641,
0.3030534089,
-0.4492563903,
0.6259275675,
0.1821547002,
-0.4072779715,
-0.7222216129,
-0.1373483241,
-0.1190640628,
0.3142637312,
-0.6177281141,
0.1371855289,
-0.408166796,
-0.459536314,
-0.1534536779,
-0.1579912603,
0.1530610621,
0.0094682602,
0.0720061734,
0.4427188635,
-0.079160668,
0.2182495743,
0.0365812704,
0.0931925923,
0.3861046433,
-0.1644368321,
1.0898914337,
-0.3421344757,
-0.2812863886,
-0.1222227439,
0.5199231505,
0.9952245951,
-0.6199436784,
0.3811728358,
0.1324069351,
-0.1966063082,
-0.2491281629,
-0.550072968,
-0.1350067705,
-0.3866006136,
-0.0439322516,
-0.6387957335,
-0.7923427224,
0.4372803867,
-0.3051455915,
0.2407077104,
-0.0160509441,
0.575504005,
-0.128678292,
1.1443659067,
0.3625451028,
0.0724729747,
0.1494028717,
-0.6108720303,
0.5764297843,
-0.9938221574,
-0.3944283128,
-0.5616338849,
-0.3665717244,
-0.2370172441,
-0.7767893672,
0.1743904054,
-0.0327831209,
-0.4304054976,
0.1093895882,
-0.7119323015,
0.6359960437,
0.4965695441,
0.140625149,
0.4941415489,
-0.2216967046,
-0.3881180882,
0.4895328283,
-0.6287258267,
-0.4082579911,
0.713588655,
-0.1682980508,
0.8238115311,
0.0435130857,
0.7290328741,
0.2978753746,
0.1979849339,
-1.0031912327,
0.7080014348,
0.320943743,
-0.7135319114,
-0.4329693913,
-0.2136851102,
-1.0839960575,
0.3684062064,
-0.0856350511,
-0.7959094644,
0.4234209955,
-0.066835627,
-0.7204371095,
0.4843741357,
-0.4851507246,
0.3975417018,
-0.3131740689,
-0.2360992879,
-0.4913384318,
-0.7423703074,
0.3076090813,
0.1402448863,
0.1640178263,
0.1824519187,
0.2106739432,
0.6686440706,
-0.2978096008,
0.7282186151,
0.0313271321,
-0.0208050646,
0.8830088973,
0.7425178289,
0.3830815256,
-0.1169372797,
0.2823345661,
-0.4613597989,
0.4522560835,
-0.6504213214,
-0.9298460484,
0.478191942,
-0.7757512927,
-0.9840836525,
-0.7462314963,
-0.3757815957,
-0.306912303,
-0.0753050074,
0.2850806713,
0.3817806244,
-0.2701199651,
-0.0925455093,
0.6194761992,
0.00477895,
0.0255726576,
0.4502729475,
-0.4975653887,
-0.455989629,
0.3970866501,
0.0897631571,
0.7314115763,
0.2795228064,
0.14408122,
-0.2712112367,
-0.321343869,
-0.2877625823,
0.4933346808,
-0.5547854304,
-0.1297785044,
-0.591460526,
-0.2703935802,
-0.2853649855,
-0.4794979095,
-0.3020816445,
-0.2719089389,
0.3537971377,
-0.3660821617,
0.0368445739,
0.9194125533,
0.1977529526,
-0.2200176418,
-0.5753340721,
0.2301252484,
0.8850897551,
-0.0661436394,
0.5608280301,
-0.0781154409,
0.2318238169,
0.1535785645,
-0.5888087153,
-1.009550333,
-0.0181631148,
-0.3336981237,
0.2213951349,
0.3191716075,
0.3257370889,
0.7030870318,
-0.3464446068,
0.8949760199,
0.1842752993,
-0.8482695818,
0.4762261808,
0.1540913433,
0.5282750726,
0.5701731443,
0.6047931314,
-0.658554256,
-0.4680199623,
-0.6363159418,
-0.5787250996,
0.4633731246,
0.1496088505,
-0.2107268423,
-0.2691274583,
0.3734467924,
0.1463159919,
0.1329108626,
-0.4894776344,
0.0373422541,
0.1355734169,
0.2799480855,
-0.08787065,
-0.1180343404,
-0.2274837792,
-0.3237147629,
0.5068190098,
-0.0266376436,
0.2684382498,
0.7710736394,
0.035869576,
-0.6210939884,
0.5261085033,
0.5590848327,
0.8882421255,
-0.085501641,
0.4948731065,
0.2728715837,
-0.4447492063,
0.469491303,
-0.5204999447,
-0.2106126845,
-0.2418798506,
0.0481697619,
0.371273458,
-0.0802111849,
-0.9891853333,
0.2370471209,
-0.1467317343,
-0.289347142,
-0.4288597405,
0.1060547084,
0.2086981982,
0.5247144699,
0.4044341147,
0.0586341731,
0.2012755126,
-1.2452147007,
0.0628156811,
0.3375549018,
-0.3894686103,
-0.2889001667,
0.2384842485,
-0.0084362999,
-0.7547139525,
0.731590569,
-0.2971278429,
-1.0412113667,
0.71790272,
0.7390816212,
0.7697931528,
-0.4225460887,
0.7729173899,
0.4177038968,
0.5530770421,
-0.0045882133,
0.7385014892,
-0.5229293108,
-0.7646189332,
-0.5899591446,
-0.3981485665,
-0.5901947021,
0.0938797221,
-0.5217773914,
0.0394848175,
-0.8703433871,
-0.0884606764,
0.0197578538,
0.037612915,
-0.371296674,
0.3681241274,
0.0589939468,
0.9416422248,
-0.5871187449,
0.3892172277,
0.6355090737,
-0.2564766407,
-0.8432718515,
0.0280485544,
-0.1490735859,
-0.7767755985,
0.4502653182,
0.1473931968,
-0.9043251276,
-0.114504315,
-0.9319455028,
-0.7223217487,
1.0620406866,
0.0484218448,
-0.4205321968,
-0.0838135108,
-0.190220207,
0.5321820974,
-0.5492360592,
0.0925003737,
0.7431905866,
0.1021730974,
0.6264660358,
-0.7347494364,
0.464047879,
-0.2774329484,
-0.2983579338,
0.6749670506,
-0.7970438004,
1.0256259441,
-0.8273813128,
-0.3167157173,
0.061920695,
0.3202899098,
0.5961235166,
0.5979496241,
0.821401298,
0.2852658629,
0.9470661283,
0.0629967377,
0.7060338855,
-0.1181973144,
0.2060213834,
1.0316114426,
-0.2781508863,
0.7962468863,
0.3053914905,
-0.307148397,
1.0072399378,
0.508392334,
0.40167588,
0.2961713076,
0.325820893,
-0.5456985235,
-0.4398997426,
0.0488174446,
-0.2713981867,
0.4315813482,
0.4180319905,
-0.0688714162,
-0.0874037519,
-0.2031056881,
0.0589507595,
0.1116048694,
-0.376005888,
0.6853605509,
0.1020092741,
-1.2630946636,
0.8346853256,
-0.4147571921,
-0.0097492496,
-0.27991274,
-0.1924995631,
-0.1386087239,
-0.1910155565,
-0.0264782943,
-0.9949772954,
0.1328202486,
-0.1355291605,
0.1001676917,
0.1786452681,
0.4209538102,
-0.342174232,
-0.3055081367,
0.3487758636,
0.5461156964,
0.30530864,
-0.1064902097,
-0.7706643939,
-0.2494923323,
0.1683689654,
0.2034156919,
0.0110983485,
0.6071520448,
-0.1639577746,
0.8554327488,
0.5482925177,
-0.0846125633,
-0.1200401336,
0.0739154592,
0.9181854725,
-0.9918122292,
-0.5734421611,
-0.7705647945,
0.3272631168,
-0.1146316007,
-0.0492093824,
0.1180304214,
0.3756503463,
0.6639298201,
0.0936074033,
0.7344398499,
-0.153483063,
0.2631872296,
-0.2879700661,
0.2990809679,
-0.2785896063,
0.0411519334,
-0.3391418159,
-0.7952211499,
0.0073568481,
0.6406351924,
-0.7057477832,
-0.1141526774,
1.1079403162,
0.7417802811,
0.4080443382,
0.5057354569,
0.3084042668,
0.3427073359,
0.3266163766,
0.9209774137,
1.1854959726,
-0.1187996119,
0.3947895169,
-0.1949603558,
-0.6097459793,
-0.0107745137,
-0.1692297459,
-0.9574179649,
-0.8473801613,
-0.1035483629,
-0.4787005782,
0.1259033531,
1.2064796686,
0.2752857804,
-0.6285156012,
-0.3452672064,
-0.356261909,
0.3831166327,
-0.517516315,
-0.2497062683,
0.3132402003,
-0.3392410874,
-0.5027132034,
0.1377540082,
0.386820823,
-0.0867987424,
-0.4861953259,
0.1369906813,
-0.6500067711,
0.4572093487,
0.9589681029,
0.2393491119,
-0.7298254967,
-0.361222446,
0.3172965944,
0.172732681,
0.0519147031,
1.1202054024,
-0.7659392953,
0.9376671314,
0.6920260787,
0.3151317537,
0.6732812524,
0.2125241011,
0.6542940736,
-0.0793671235,
-0.1985338777,
0.5332491994,
0.2431333959,
0.1799173504,
-0.4524670541,
0.5707548261,
0.1315511763,
-0.6945268512,
-0.6398770213,
0.5747221112,
-0.9937419295,
-0.495975405,
0.682945013,
0.0341581143,
-0.5378917456,
-0.4230280221,
-0.9423186779,
0.002730876,
-0.2150720805,
1.3289361,
0.9139110446,
-0.4725060761,
-0.373634845,
-0.0745531172,
0.4181099236,
0.5133609772,
-0.5079810619,
0.1887275279,
0.2903306782,
0.2928067744,
0.5139607787,
0.9044944048,
-0.3477272987,
0.7815814614,
0.0200248808,
-0.1092821062,
0.4018152058,
-0.4113005698,
0.1765865088,
0.4602389336,
0.2500370741,
-0.0436423458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14998v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14998v2 | An Examination of the Robustness of Reference-Free Image Captioning Evaluation Metrics | 2023-05-24T10:36:12 | 2024-02-06T04:20:15 | Saba Ahmadi, Aishwarya Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Recently, reference-free metrics such as CLIPScore (Hessel et al., 2021),
UMIC (Lee et al., 2021), and PAC-S (Sarto et al., 2023) have been proposed for
automatic reference-free evaluation of image captions. Our focus lies in
evaluating the robustness of these metrics in scenarios that require
distinguishing between two captions with high lexical overlap but very
different meanings. Our findings reveal that despite their high correlation
with human judgments, CLIPScore, UMIC, and PAC-S struggle to identify
fine-grained errors. While all metrics exhibit strong sensitivity to visual
grounding errors, their sensitivity to caption implausibility errors is
limited. Furthermore, we found that all metrics are sensitive to variations in
the size of image-relevant objects mentioned in the caption, while CLIPScore
and PAC-S are also sensitive to the number of mentions of image-relevant
objects in the caption. Regarding linguistic aspects of a caption, all metrics
show weak comprehension of negation, and CLIPScore and PAC-S are insensitive to
the structure of the caption to a great extent. We hope our findings will guide
further improvements in reference-free evaluation of image captioning. | [
-0.6486975551,
-0.071127072,
0.4818559289,
0.1859992594,
-0.7713952661,
0.0550646968,
-0.1177434847,
-0.6056234837,
-0.048471164,
-0.027736241,
-0.1430555135,
-0.232004568,
-0.7439041734,
0.44758448,
-0.4315603673,
1.0113934278,
-0.3714829683,
0.1812243015,
-0.7252449989,
-0.8199847341,
-0.4960471988,
-0.1679825336,
0.0832029656,
0.1465305835,
0.1430222541,
0.3675384223,
1.2390714884,
0.8282129765,
1.1074229479,
0.1081432775,
0.0383369997,
0.1472395211,
-0.1170530096,
-0.2507252991,
-0.4065461457,
-0.2329639941,
-0.2081503868,
0.1123675331,
0.6200401783,
0.3418130577,
0.3913171887,
0.3598405719,
0.0212290287,
0.9875466228,
-0.9192278385,
0.4088226557,
-0.8964355588,
0.0083054686,
-0.0993835926,
-0.2010389119,
-0.0737783685,
-0.1106595024,
0.0900488645,
-0.489934355,
0.5076692104,
0.3996371627,
1.5618413687,
0.6753931642,
0.1395968944,
-0.1790388077,
-0.225797534,
0.6232769489,
-0.3408561647,
0.1616092324,
0.200683713,
0.6798630953,
0.4063630104,
-0.2516566515,
-0.3993835151,
-0.2552057207,
-0.0504432581,
0.2429050505,
-0.5871911645,
-0.2050659955,
0.2579039633,
0.6480172276,
-0.1088703796,
-0.0017949094,
-0.530426383,
-0.4774172008,
0.3540436029,
0.0093027577,
0.2756046355,
-0.49331972,
-0.7109755278,
-0.0408788025,
-0.6420125365,
-0.0830814838,
0.261811465,
0.1321442127,
-0.3789644539,
0.5678232312,
0.0311282445,
0.2922324836,
0.0225262325,
0.1555058807,
0.2228312045,
-0.5135368705,
-0.1414461434,
-0.3765681386,
1.0092029572,
1.0915409327,
0.545468986,
-0.4403252006,
-0.0969078019,
0.407022059,
0.3058313131,
-0.5464853048,
-0.2020519376,
-0.0512864143,
-0.3377854526,
-0.329017669,
0.549329102,
-0.6755004525,
-0.2519713938,
0.0232388712,
0.4910298586,
-0.4357870519,
0.3172333539,
-0.277526468,
-0.3513421714,
0.4047216773,
0.1702204943,
-0.4173006415,
0.4520498514,
0.307561487,
1.0759741068,
-0.6308147311,
-0.3914776742,
-0.6906151175,
-0.0875221342,
-0.3317090869,
1.2376117706,
-0.3792877793,
-0.1341481358,
-0.1785091907,
0.2982775867,
-0.0281643663,
-0.7792482972,
0.6293430328,
-0.4402970672,
-0.3128042221,
-0.3322416246,
-0.321958065,
-0.0658318549,
0.136580646,
-0.9503608346,
0.5372613072,
0.3312832713,
-1.0733034611,
0.5361548662,
-0.4556924999,
-0.0564270616,
-0.0998055264,
-0.337626785,
-0.6972976327,
0.1715090871,
0.5638589263,
0.1581366062,
-0.5321736336,
-0.0318082273,
-0.4037746191,
-0.6246396303,
0.5199552774,
-0.2409634441,
0.3361822069,
0.1966871023,
-0.2823666334,
0.1485517174,
-0.5248616338,
0.0007237933,
0.1782497913,
0.2598437965,
-0.2207756937,
-0.1677137166,
-0.2967881858,
0.0231773425,
-0.0524457209,
-0.4286628962,
-0.3931642771,
0.1377630234,
0.4105216265,
0.5963851213,
0.1233173087,
0.4233121276,
-0.4624650776,
0.4894061089,
0.2047314793,
0.1396860033,
-0.4379663467,
-0.4287493229,
-0.6587746143,
-0.33157143,
0.3254875541,
0.5248615146,
-0.634524107,
0.4196855426,
-0.4394744635,
-0.5834777951,
-0.2263444215,
0.2598767281,
0.6967648268,
0.4001187086,
0.2903386354,
-1.1278717518,
-0.2793650031,
-1.0671141148,
-0.2528524101,
-0.2356134802,
-0.0616156757,
0.5059091449,
0.5296499133,
0.1782052368,
0.8127081394,
-0.334767431,
-0.278586179,
0.3513619006,
-0.1808205098,
-0.0322801732,
0.2926276922,
0.868946135,
-0.5329464674,
-0.4919191003,
-0.3378259242,
-0.5446462631,
-0.1888693273,
-0.2247731537,
-0.1513974071,
-0.0798171982,
0.3522997499,
-0.3896740675,
0.4143873155,
0.2076596171,
-0.0713279843,
0.9265693426,
-0.078084901,
0.2325831354,
-0.2838798761,
0.1356499046,
0.0478914455,
-0.0561210997,
-0.0744436756,
0.3845148385,
0.3044030368,
0.0326635838,
-0.5097405314,
0.1197994947,
-0.6088373661,
-0.5098249316,
-0.0021730224,
0.5483915806,
0.1176481843,
0.2530672848,
-0.0924935937,
1.0895619392,
0.6705046892,
-0.3623473644,
0.2093705088,
0.2981415987,
-0.7794373035,
1.021576643,
-0.7290586233,
0.2440235019,
-0.1358989775,
-0.0597781725,
-1.2170472145,
-0.1650339365,
0.2416799515,
-0.6277526021,
0.0497852452,
-0.053514488,
-0.5120596886,
-0.3629349172,
-0.5760370493,
0.6126983166,
0.1310241222,
-0.4781918824,
-0.0700256154,
0.1257094294,
0.2220426053,
-0.5640033484,
-0.5487397909,
0.0921599567,
-0.3745691478,
-0.2827962637,
-0.0425534472,
-0.1156886518,
-0.2822630703,
0.1532905996,
-0.4030954242,
-0.3041085303,
0.0115167731,
0.5495852828,
0.3969785869,
-0.0523477234,
-0.0481657349,
-0.2017560005,
-0.075352475,
-0.069614388,
-0.0493028425,
0.0224266127,
-0.699826479,
-0.4885846078,
-0.3058062196,
0.164040789,
0.9612936378,
-0.2350351363,
0.2717582583,
0.7100717425,
-0.1780103296,
0.4730759263,
-0.4046381414,
0.3055095971,
-0.3153845072,
0.1164745241,
-0.2020868212,
-0.6115339398,
0.7360057235,
0.3369054496,
-0.1135096624,
0.6440104842,
0.2466098666,
0.0119590554,
0.5009634495,
0.2852761149,
-0.0287357606,
0.1871466339,
-0.1139286906,
0.0114664873,
-0.9698903561,
0.116009295,
-0.6389169097,
-0.1646809578,
-0.3115424812,
-0.6945079565,
0.1938759983,
0.0250909664,
-0.0900838599,
0.5827906728,
-0.4726795852,
0.7936247587,
0.2418841124,
-0.1961221695,
0.2263153195,
0.2759875953,
-0.3357424736,
-0.2677208781,
-0.359970957,
-0.7415878773,
0.8941376209,
0.3873434365,
0.5839059949,
-0.0741094276,
0.0902946368,
0.4323423207,
0.3491904736,
-0.9641619325,
0.2858652771,
-0.3404138386,
-0.5924006701,
-0.0359545909,
-0.2450359464,
-0.628691256,
0.3206119537,
-0.3060696423,
-0.6549335718,
0.0332009196,
-0.0004415692,
-0.4826372564,
0.4383454323,
-0.7109702826,
0.7531254292,
-0.2503264248,
-0.2526969612,
0.1497780234,
-0.8026307225,
0.1505316645,
0.0169978924,
0.4755986631,
-0.388014257,
-0.3653867841,
0.5523759723,
-0.1193352863,
0.5554320812,
0.0781815052,
0.3180061579,
0.6679340601,
0.3459724486,
-0.1126981899,
-0.0337922126,
0.2936418653,
0.3853489161,
0.4087592959,
-0.4673853815,
-0.5364693999,
0.3559871018,
-0.6854792237,
-0.3011678755,
-0.3277650476,
-0.5667150617,
-0.3771004975,
0.178780809,
0.358872354,
0.3473067582,
-0.1333097517,
0.2885206342,
0.0626153052,
-0.1989514679,
0.3104197979,
0.4404088259,
0.3847806156,
-0.9155802727,
0.6518663168,
-0.1251786649,
0.4554877579,
0.2322084755,
0.143846035,
-0.1368611306,
-0.6025189757,
-0.7604116797,
0.3838849366,
-0.7415982485,
-0.6367743611,
-0.0078733498,
0.0660569072,
-0.022245001,
-0.2337007821,
-0.2899388969,
-0.5289752483,
-0.1849939078,
-0.1269287616,
-0.0311492812,
0.3308782876,
0.0257998537,
0.2327888608,
-1.007904768,
0.2520198226,
0.0560038239,
0.6461988688,
-0.0426225662,
-0.5935011506,
-0.1612892896,
-0.491885066,
-0.4235865176,
-0.9160881639,
-0.0435351767,
0.5400261283,
0.5271610022,
0.8462219238,
0.1675042957,
0.6654275656,
-0.525423646,
1.0738860369,
0.3655166626,
-1.0650963783,
0.4157878757,
-0.2307005078,
0.3159513474,
0.8100090027,
0.2666608095,
-0.2324293703,
-0.6790848374,
-0.7498742342,
-0.7197210193,
0.2298368663,
0.2190543711,
0.3152941465,
-0.0929313898,
0.4008174837,
0.3695195019,
0.1629499793,
-0.6588418484,
-0.0213689283,
-0.3303911984,
0.2390216887,
0.0223039873,
-0.2074034214,
-0.3388660252,
-0.3265567124,
0.1427736282,
-0.3518328965,
0.3887246847,
0.3722952604,
-0.213621974,
-0.3003165722,
0.3152150214,
0.4936920404,
0.6661339402,
-0.2974848747,
0.3910477757,
0.2710869312,
-0.3685588241,
-0.0783181041,
-0.2852806449,
-0.0932532102,
0.2143133134,
0.5152027011,
0.824716568,
0.4167904854,
-0.8650846481,
0.8767135143,
0.0094763562,
-0.2889592052,
-0.214578703,
-0.1691400856,
-0.4133842587,
-0.280161947,
0.097837396,
0.5703123808,
-0.0188125037,
-0.4409481585,
0.38197124,
0.4359189272,
-0.8114231229,
-0.348857969,
0.7565430403,
0.0528764389,
0.2226708233,
0.1893357635,
-0.3865604997,
-0.5591263771,
0.6889774799,
0.3156894147,
0.8369138241,
0.3223382831,
0.1514364034,
0.5625457168,
0.5942115188,
0.1953161806,
-0.1104008481,
-0.3288703263,
-0.7622385621,
0.0525875129,
-0.196781069,
-0.6864491105,
-0.2436324209,
-0.9558337927,
0.1433003098,
-0.6379824877,
-0.116907768,
0.096751295,
-0.2829363644,
-0.643620491,
0.1265419424,
0.1040907353,
1.1266150475,
-0.9524678588,
0.2091152072,
0.9499921203,
-0.565430522,
-0.7214236259,
-0.0669029728,
0.0307972282,
-0.6327677965,
0.2445289493,
0.4450575411,
-0.1434640437,
-0.7428519726,
-0.7527027726,
-0.7839795351,
1.0609612465,
0.4120228589,
0.006647557,
0.1354461014,
-0.0701863393,
0.5316359997,
-0.5602661967,
0.2748199701,
0.5549894571,
0.2161652893,
0.1815914959,
-1.1114401817,
0.1686341763,
-0.2157903761,
-0.0647651181,
-0.1376700699,
-0.9309213758,
0.3980783522,
-0.5189888477,
-0.6395248175,
0.5611234903,
0.512625277,
-0.0626092553,
0.401650697,
0.8848968148,
0.540578723,
0.4788265526,
-0.2789691985,
0.9336620569,
-0.2334992737,
0.3673255742,
0.9775217175,
0.0285510719,
0.8908367753,
0.5570160151,
-0.4335183203,
0.4599172473,
0.4424113035,
-0.6641307473,
0.4769669175,
0.1363906562,
0.1840871423,
-0.1638991386,
-0.1114113107,
-0.0961803123,
0.4764194489,
0.2110300362,
-0.4020808339,
-0.4048060775,
-0.3389365077,
-0.1928929985,
0.2864404619,
-0.0986776426,
0.502415061,
0.1315390766,
-0.6166642904,
0.6177810431,
-0.4454223514,
0.4505025148,
-0.2216347307,
0.3681022823,
-0.0354731865,
0.0147634493,
-0.3176892102,
-0.9039147496,
0.6500976086,
0.4888553321,
-0.070689328,
0.389234513,
0.5257490277,
0.129671365,
-0.0392818637,
0.1078226045,
0.4526393712,
0.6678830385,
-0.0914996192,
-0.6954869628,
0.1687546074,
-0.1040174663,
0.6539531946,
0.0425924174,
-0.0273372978,
-0.2173072249,
0.4813966155,
0.2691464424,
0.0469244719,
-0.0761939362,
0.2601214945,
0.6031315327,
-0.4243782461,
-0.3743419647,
-0.4719216228,
0.1831449717,
-0.087690413,
-0.1973952353,
0.6260182858,
0.6176401973,
0.7803797126,
-0.3674398065,
0.5015036464,
-0.0689131916,
0.108360596,
-0.2756173015,
0.5657557845,
-0.4465258718,
0.1261115074,
-0.7350440621,
-1.0860167742,
-0.5545253754,
0.364436239,
-0.1859966815,
-0.3475449681,
0.8740189075,
0.6333290935,
-0.0221896712,
-0.0860393122,
0.2849583626,
-0.2195660174,
0.0359371416,
0.5080509186,
0.950204432,
-0.5861054659,
1.0980021954,
-0.4381027222,
-0.2404021919,
0.0887169763,
-1.1509226561,
-0.6749236584,
-0.6278617382,
-0.6188985109,
-0.2516415119,
-0.1429583877,
0.5022445321,
0.5268419385,
-1.0665168762,
0.0603915714,
0.2164631635,
0.1007928476,
-0.4609828293,
-0.1987991929,
0.5434087515,
-0.2510252893,
-0.5840185285,
-0.2084453404,
0.4351454377,
0.2319179177,
-0.001201892,
0.0281225983,
0.4402483404,
0.2185969204,
0.2563793659,
0.473670572,
-0.8689402342,
-0.6830410361,
-0.1129648462,
-0.0631762594,
0.396620512,
0.7099221945,
-0.3764338791,
0.6620748639,
0.324889034,
0.4778770506,
-0.0806317106,
0.4587088227,
0.1265600473,
-0.6094991565,
0.2510588765,
-0.2249418646,
0.5581948757,
0.7556010485,
0.0582440048,
0.6587699056,
0.4415626228,
-0.3920411766,
-0.7349441648,
0.0921922699,
-1.4385985136,
0.2206674963,
0.9476041794,
-0.4425103664,
-0.1869834363,
0.2642176151,
-0.2378019691,
-0.0764547065,
-0.1156653017,
0.9546987414,
1.0961182117,
-0.1219364405,
-0.1401189864,
-0.3952440321,
0.180443868,
0.3900519907,
-0.5478000641,
-0.0878575072,
0.6830788851,
0.4556110799,
0.7285146117,
0.1667337418,
-0.8464633822,
0.7513797879,
0.0893539488,
-0.3591824174,
-0.2553184032,
-0.2015676945,
-0.3909842074,
0.064910844,
0.3414867818,
-0.5799770355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16344v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16344v2 | Enabling and Analyzing How to Efficiently Extract Information from Hybrid Long Documents with LLMs | 2023-05-24T10:35:58 | 2024-03-07T13:44:27 | Chongjian Yue, Xinrun Xu, Xiaojun Ma, Lun Du, Hengyu Liu, Zhiming Ding, Yanbing Jiang, Shi Han, Dongmei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional performance in textual
understanding and tabular reasoning tasks. However, their ability to comprehend
and analyze hybrid text, containing textual and tabular data, remains
underexplored. In this research, we specialize in harnessing the potential of
LLMs to comprehend critical information from financial reports, which are
hybrid long-documents. We propose an Automated Financial Information Extraction
(AFIE) framework that enhances LLMs' ability to comprehend and extract
information from financial reports. To evaluate AFIE, we develop a Financial
Reports Numerical Extraction (FINE) dataset and conduct an extensive
experimental analysis. Our framework is effectively validated on GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, yielding average accuracy increases of 53.94% and 33.77%, respectively,
compared to a naive method. These results suggest that the AFIE framework
offers accuracy for automated numerical extraction from complex, hybrid
documents. | [
-0.1364376545,
-1.0349377394,
0.4821941853,
0.3691837192,
-0.355886519,
0.6516658068,
-0.2294207066,
-0.8859450221,
0.1758864969,
0.7004566193,
-0.2678346932,
-0.622030139,
-0.6355883479,
0.1748991758,
-0.6647282839,
1.1987315416,
-0.2222865969,
0.0905967727,
-0.1397483945,
0.2135718763,
-0.0450984947,
-0.2755242586,
-0.6680448055,
-0.2715509236,
0.1714396179,
0.2922553718,
0.3801428676,
0.7185319662,
0.8119860291,
0.3668911457,
0.2025312036,
0.347933799,
-0.4057494998,
-0.241334796,
-0.1338561326,
-0.3925072551,
-0.7509790063,
0.0844369829,
0.6749922633,
0.3237772882,
-0.2206936032,
0.1135792956,
0.0791826099,
0.8593215346,
-0.3267234266,
0.7323616743,
-0.4971745312,
-0.1982058585,
-0.3908915818,
-0.572527051,
-0.4911431372,
-0.4247432947,
0.5380881429,
-0.8682154417,
0.1832625419,
0.1498806328,
0.9226827025,
-0.0557170399,
-0.5243874788,
-0.5191631913,
-0.8381540179,
0.5346663594,
-0.5969359875,
0.3839504719,
0.3195139468,
0.3487339914,
0.0294671096,
-0.8512348533,
-0.4846462309,
-0.1783813536,
-0.2584897578,
0.2979606688,
-0.2114945501,
0.2474269569,
0.0599682517,
0.8022282124,
-0.3471548557,
0.3146561086,
-0.4467408359,
-0.2655556798,
0.7925212383,
0.0917809457,
0.156988427,
-0.0310290288,
-0.5863198638,
-0.168774724,
-0.2817821503,
-0.1780821681,
0.2642544508,
0.078329578,
-0.3595138788,
0.6275288463,
0.0871058479,
0.524099052,
-0.0968891233,
-0.6488742828,
0.2485511005,
-0.5056710839,
-0.445874393,
-0.0321935527,
0.5966405869,
0.3040839732,
0.4696707129,
-0.2740977108,
-0.6889663935,
-0.2165125459,
-0.0323741324,
-0.3818552494,
0.0810000077,
0.1790421158,
-0.5431007147,
-0.4063540697,
0.3818914592,
-1.0505485535,
-0.2741528153,
-0.5519771576,
0.277443707,
-0.6327936053,
-0.0930788517,
0.1843221486,
-0.5715533495,
0.4869285822,
0.4396992326,
-0.9436069131,
0.6952789426,
0.8735969067,
0.668400228,
-0.5047501326,
0.0403914675,
-0.8605588675,
0.5357970595,
0.0433924943,
1.070630312,
-0.4444983602,
-0.6196292043,
-0.1980493665,
-0.2516551614,
-0.340700537,
-0.7748380303,
0.441742897,
-0.6958616972,
0.170333609,
-0.051171232,
-0.7786297798,
-0.3276817501,
0.1326872408,
-0.8916691542,
0.9620179534,
0.3348115385,
-0.7503752112,
0.3077482283,
-1.0430356264,
-0.5922201872,
0.195380345,
-0.3514341414,
-0.3724261522,
-0.1129557565,
0.3326547742,
0.3075174093,
-0.7663026452,
0.3344569206,
-0.1289558411,
-0.1982849091,
0.2164521813,
-0.6509371996,
0.392023474,
-0.0424968451,
-0.3615376651,
0.1227463409,
-0.8982149363,
-0.3928843737,
0.3543812335,
-0.5111303329,
-0.4439786673,
-0.1311994493,
0.273316294,
-0.2354997545,
0.4503198266,
-0.5312043428,
0.0693105683,
-0.5753204823,
0.2326342016,
0.956428051,
-0.0669169202,
0.4904858768,
-0.5117974281,
0.72265625,
-0.022634374,
-0.3217214346,
-0.113583222,
0.0758493319,
-0.4579966366,
-0.7868237495,
0.6454365849,
1.0109843016,
-0.6558117867,
0.459233135,
-0.332372278,
-0.2165797651,
-0.2696038783,
0.3983121514,
-0.0041151643,
0.5956614017,
0.2502266169,
0.1168042496,
-0.4860332608,
-1.1659836769,
-0.1379154474,
-0.0774549693,
-0.0367832258,
0.1279946715,
0.5511427522,
-0.1090723947,
1.1320952177,
-0.5694541931,
-0.1192711592,
-0.4486978352,
0.4780880809,
0.2318917662,
0.3081026077,
0.4335922003,
-1.1341371536,
-0.405587256,
0.36831671,
-0.8394437432,
-0.0365113355,
-0.590257287,
-0.072071895,
0.0952896103,
0.33333987,
-0.5097961426,
0.4906531274,
0.2479418069,
-0.3273315132,
0.6382433772,
-0.1934005022,
-0.045526281,
-0.9501696229,
0.1766235381,
0.6257244349,
-0.3483958542,
-0.2571987212,
-0.2001752406,
0.1997698843,
0.201194033,
0.0798420757,
0.6930605173,
-0.4391672909,
-0.3562538028,
-0.0879985541,
0.2367642671,
0.1963299662,
0.0591983944,
0.0528122261,
1.053565383,
0.1187266037,
-0.172120139,
0.4144207537,
0.0240068119,
-0.4664466381,
0.1910589039,
-0.4123491347,
-0.1812252551,
-0.0922337025,
0.4346889555,
-0.8263903856,
-0.1476442665,
0.0504318364,
0.0442418829,
0.5966723561,
0.2801395655,
-0.7750409245,
-0.3378169239,
-0.3547688127,
0.02816494,
0.0721966922,
-0.4893352985,
1.2638901472,
0.4351795614,
-0.6542550325,
-0.3379455209,
-0.3497312665,
-0.0286429133,
-0.3630043268,
-0.8755758405,
0.4518507421,
0.136147052,
-0.7291887999,
-0.2089876384,
-0.2119054645,
-0.1361467987,
0.2844183445,
-0.0753520578,
1.0113303661,
-0.5152697563,
-0.0879464895,
0.1308019012,
-0.3851383924,
0.1464311779,
-0.235321492,
0.3929504454,
-0.3425121009,
0.013729021,
-0.4644260705,
0.4801399708,
0.7163609862,
-0.5095481277,
0.5291694999,
0.4606688619,
-0.3829960525,
-0.1877009273,
-0.7795980573,
0.0608601905,
-0.5478788614,
0.2877351642,
-0.1406556517,
-0.8508082032,
0.7891713381,
-0.1500723511,
0.3964565396,
0.9596485496,
0.3690631688,
-0.1626363546,
0.458893925,
0.8044399619,
-0.153292954,
0.3879066706,
-0.3238634169,
0.0243914668,
-0.3360810578,
-0.533288002,
-0.4933549464,
-0.0873820633,
-0.0949015766,
-0.1803069711,
0.4376158118,
0.0100872172,
0.3579488695,
-0.0973476693,
0.0699782893,
0.6514179707,
0.1608337015,
-0.0647298619,
0.5128802657,
0.2110655457,
-0.0897163451,
0.0423643515,
-0.1580521017,
-0.4798525274,
0.8861038089,
0.7697307467,
0.66703403,
-0.1104800701,
0.6127040386,
0.5140447021,
0.6229043007,
-0.8036037683,
0.2937425673,
-0.4338622987,
-0.5339314938,
-0.1779409796,
-0.7669693232,
-0.4460258782,
0.2088942975,
-0.1553316563,
-0.7644718289,
0.0120490193,
-0.1796323806,
-0.7323920727,
0.1807055771,
-0.9077136517,
0.5118517876,
-0.524202764,
-0.1223315001,
-0.1654331535,
-0.3139557242,
0.5528208017,
-0.7814311981,
0.5686089993,
-0.0227087401,
-0.2368663102,
1.0210206509,
-0.4019199908,
0.8052015901,
0.1663742214,
-0.5767996311,
0.3811429739,
0.0627791733,
0.7193083763,
0.1679273248,
-0.3761527538,
-0.0537148044,
-0.0160008334,
-0.2618276179,
-0.7173454762,
0.3943560421,
-0.3628885448,
-0.4724859595,
-0.4491592646,
-0.8483754396,
-0.3208356202,
0.1197305843,
-0.1055383831,
0.4710159004,
-0.0327666216,
0.1221935153,
0.3772586286,
-0.0893579051,
0.509198606,
0.832498312,
-0.1671718657,
-0.6317070723,
1.0042632818,
0.1944407374,
0.1204266623,
0.4364466369,
0.2656432092,
-0.6395628452,
-0.6361188293,
-0.4406336248,
0.54589504,
-0.7509061694,
-0.2347480357,
-0.512308836,
-0.3334595561,
-0.2283883989,
-0.3712370396,
-0.1315475404,
-0.3589543104,
-0.5404946804,
-0.5013501644,
0.5680940747,
0.8116288185,
-0.1384308487,
0.3691170216,
-1.3727829456,
0.3888595104,
0.0699521899,
0.2638038993,
-0.0033174166,
-0.3378861547,
-0.2516971231,
-0.259624064,
-0.0943394452,
-0.5709539056,
0.393532306,
0.0440264456,
0.520204246,
0.5009018779,
-0.1409344524,
0.7502043247,
0.054102391,
0.4530034363,
0.2065309882,
-0.8277799487,
0.1866698861,
-0.6373176575,
-0.0347640216,
0.7384366393,
0.3089229763,
0.0276882984,
-0.2918315828,
-0.6396843791,
-0.8260911703,
0.5884351134,
0.1446976215,
-0.3853521645,
0.0793239325,
0.4947546721,
0.5895078182,
0.1098777056,
-0.7102326155,
-0.0279531348,
0.4914995432,
-0.4272657335,
0.0228158552,
-0.1747352779,
-0.0004495795,
-0.2619617879,
0.5602647662,
-0.1033538729,
-0.1552099884,
0.1989506036,
0.0992717743,
-0.2131136209,
-0.0351741575,
0.25217098,
0.8631097674,
-0.3149710298,
-0.2316695452,
0.1995118707,
-0.4980831742,
-0.2429776043,
0.7075266242,
0.03199609,
-0.1305779815,
0.7495132089,
0.2168930769,
0.4329872727,
-1.0297669172,
0.3969359994,
-0.1257413328,
-0.4052970409,
-0.4651414156,
-0.1478066444,
-0.0163105875,
0.2572016716,
0.7776333094,
-0.1811768264,
0.2453813851,
-0.4944089651,
0.6227972507,
0.3474473953,
0.1680537462,
-0.0581205785,
0.291041106,
0.4409877956,
0.0531478748,
0.6794481874,
0.258238554,
-0.3447569311,
0.7594069242,
0.8069800138,
0.8090344667,
0.2744960785,
0.2668026686,
-0.1196187213,
0.1224802434,
-0.1206513122,
0.339205265,
-0.1172629222,
-0.410646528,
-0.7863208055,
-0.9484800696,
-0.2097085714,
0.2006600797,
-0.6899313331,
0.2104841024,
-0.6145324707,
0.0481129959,
0.4879809022,
0.0794216469,
-0.4053691626,
0.1679419577,
0.3197677732,
1.207536459,
-0.5788745284,
0.6796263456,
0.1617437154,
-0.1712189615,
-0.8142240047,
-0.2804686725,
0.1899595261,
-0.870524168,
0.5018312931,
0.0834832191,
-0.2152032256,
-0.0138117708,
-0.363335371,
-0.6868553162,
1.0842864513,
0.2885721326,
-0.8182278275,
-0.4485960305,
0.1613387167,
0.2793266177,
-0.5022607446,
0.0096535096,
0.9981714487,
0.7114754915,
0.226640746,
-1.0238898993,
-0.2613098621,
-0.1936034411,
-0.553416431,
0.4822876453,
-0.5177681446,
0.4950606227,
-0.0020800137,
-0.0735350102,
-0.1933977455,
0.8122057915,
0.1107810959,
0.5685546398,
0.5327495337,
0.3147630394,
1.0371650457,
0.0643175766,
1.2490096092,
-0.0673306659,
0.1372415274,
1.0333139896,
-0.3948539197,
0.8760719895,
0.3357926607,
-0.0064287833,
0.4495038986,
0.57452631,
-0.1550368369,
0.13844347,
-0.0348112881,
-0.4250975847,
-0.2700166702,
0.1372677386,
-0.1881055534,
0.6087016463,
0.6234855652,
-0.7198812366,
-0.3055548668,
-0.2514852881,
-0.0990243852,
-0.0593954362,
-0.2124738693,
0.9543519616,
0.4794467092,
-0.3020195663,
0.1329791695,
0.2615499794,
0.4430003762,
-0.9560653567,
-0.0669325143,
0.0678523257,
0.0177029427,
-0.203220427,
-0.599832952,
0.3724496365,
0.2323911339,
-0.248744607,
-0.2401408106,
0.7469360828,
-0.1484491974,
-0.7677094936,
0.4083127379,
0.5804107785,
-0.251275301,
0.0678198934,
-0.5885725021,
-0.0703382194,
0.268042773,
-0.269449234,
0.3718721271,
0.462582171,
0.0807895139,
0.5440586209,
1.1268266439,
0.0850607306,
-0.328340739,
-0.1230640113,
1.0843997002,
-0.8901433945,
-0.7578558326,
-1.1930211782,
0.4858339131,
-0.3306627572,
-0.2327340096,
0.5980457664,
0.9761188626,
0.3298547864,
0.1709737629,
0.9292205572,
0.3982776999,
0.3879925907,
-0.8849167228,
0.599599719,
-0.4355568588,
0.6227151155,
-0.2020778209,
-0.8716384768,
-0.2062110752,
0.3874453306,
-0.6714594364,
-0.4613155723,
0.5636839867,
0.3754701316,
-0.1794215441,
0.7084785104,
-0.1809802502,
0.1221903563,
0.4272909462,
0.0239763577,
0.5569811463,
-0.0364536904,
0.601264298,
-0.1495808512,
-0.3596528172,
-0.0211174656,
-0.844094038,
-0.7012299299,
-0.2286976129,
-0.2252191007,
-0.3426314294,
-0.2999613583,
0.9044094086,
0.1899599284,
-0.4792321622,
-0.4452935159,
0.2341922671,
-0.0209958144,
0.230931133,
-0.2905188203,
0.4641905725,
0.042302303,
-0.444577843,
0.7179340124,
0.7215588689,
0.5018487573,
-0.1071433648,
0.0736317188,
-0.0042514801,
0.1886491776,
0.5119965076,
0.2222336382,
-0.3682424426,
-0.0476662368,
-0.1535371542,
-0.0089100432,
0.0978449509,
0.9144481421,
-0.3426428139,
0.0512424111,
0.3220430017,
0.8615761399,
0.5895988941,
0.4566593766,
0.9441052079,
-0.0377772413,
-0.0100463219,
0.3627256155,
0.3846910298,
-0.0324215665,
-0.5082972646,
0.3648862839,
0.3275741637,
-0.1899305582,
-0.530185163,
-0.4125556648,
-1.2153065205,
-0.1902353615,
1.1955143213,
0.0586423911,
-0.6842049956,
-0.1237867326,
-0.2323320955,
-0.0706163049,
-0.6365466714,
0.5039634109,
0.7945374846,
0.0192703381,
0.1494570971,
-0.5853050947,
0.1972435117,
0.1793615967,
-1.0159351826,
0.2098046243,
0.4994673431,
0.3457826972,
0.0685340613,
0.7572652698,
-0.361405313,
0.2336091548,
0.0060770013,
-0.4864985645,
-0.077662304,
-0.2059985399,
-0.1620205045,
0.3417533338,
-0.3391400576,
0.2726534903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14996v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14996v2 | The ACL OCL Corpus: Advancing Open Science in Computational Linguistics | 2023-05-24T10:35:56 | 2023-10-24T05:18:32 | Shaurya Rohatgi, Yanxia Qin, Benjamin Aw, Niranjana Unnithan, Min-Yen Kan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | We present ACL OCL, a scholarly corpus derived from the ACL Anthology to
assist Open scientific research in the Computational Linguistics domain.
Integrating and enhancing the previous versions of the ACL Anthology, the ACL
OCL contributes metadata, PDF files, citation graphs and additional structured
full texts with sections, figures, and links to a large knowledge resource
(Semantic Scholar). The ACL OCL spans seven decades, containing 73K papers,
alongside 210K figures.
We spotlight how ACL OCL applies to observe trends in computational
linguistics. By detecting paper topics with a supervised neural model, we note
that interest in "Syntax: Tagging, Chunking and Parsing" is waning and "Natural
Language Generation" is resurging. Our dataset is available from HuggingFace
(https://huggingface.co/datasets/WINGNUS/ACL-OCL). | [
-0.4749570489,
-0.8564298153,
0.4418198764,
-0.0570465326,
0.0590407774,
0.2915741801,
-0.5527228117,
-0.8039075136,
0.2677272558,
0.5237549543,
-0.0292175431,
-0.6318024993,
-0.3910109997,
0.2316151112,
-0.7487986684,
1.0886089802,
0.1672429144,
-0.2174149454,
-0.5145346522,
-0.2228415608,
0.4382989705,
-0.5038345456,
-0.640987277,
0.2142672539,
0.6948404908,
0.1310962588,
0.7346385121,
1.0014175177,
0.4970595539,
0.2434570044,
-0.2912935615,
0.1345503926,
-0.22981897,
0.2105469257,
-0.0330001041,
-0.2894968092,
-0.646078527,
0.0325656459,
0.9347632527,
1.0011621714,
-0.0562837757,
-0.0124874795,
-0.2188938707,
0.7578822374,
-0.7325584888,
0.2502370775,
-0.5351677537,
-0.2240391821,
-0.5826091766,
0.1950360388,
-0.5825840235,
-0.2813856006,
-0.0478487983,
-0.9355461597,
0.3705232143,
0.1092427447,
0.4914340079,
0.2607304752,
-0.0025800536,
-0.4592804015,
-0.4642674029,
0.5262827873,
-0.4849128127,
0.6383185387,
0.5375555754,
0.2725485861,
0.0137805426,
-1.1937737465,
-0.7219067812,
-0.4473170638,
0.0149348415,
-0.1860204786,
-0.3830664456,
-0.0339499675,
0.0584240407,
0.344858855,
-0.5783339739,
-0.1540769041,
-0.6360305548,
-0.0942346007,
0.8597026467,
-0.1079864725,
0.4879203141,
0.2981062233,
-0.0272955783,
-0.1121673211,
-0.6355913281,
-0.1993067265,
0.489928335,
0.4151137769,
-0.1192929,
0.63041538,
-0.0963741988,
0.7627726197,
-0.1438606679,
0.2505410016,
0.2951986492,
-0.436942637,
-0.0403214209,
0.4755617082,
1.0864739418,
-0.1807893664,
0.1000111997,
-0.147822544,
0.1634837836,
0.1829903722,
0.475690186,
-0.2485489398,
-0.5855951309,
0.2019874901,
-0.3265812993,
-0.1568454802,
0.3595535457,
-0.8793163896,
-0.5343186259,
-0.3059524298,
-0.4801028371,
-0.3752729595,
-0.338835001,
0.1161421537,
-0.1759305894,
-0.2091245949,
0.2463342249,
-0.6572550535,
0.5037834644,
0.7387140989,
0.8481245637,
-0.4510298669,
-0.2980469465,
-0.4695906937,
-0.0838728398,
-0.3356116712,
0.6510033011,
-0.7297719717,
-0.2615751326,
0.2268956751,
-0.1397311538,
0.0201379769,
-0.2579912245,
0.5552282929,
-0.7402485609,
0.0615840405,
0.0587091669,
-0.1677557528,
-0.0425120257,
-0.0224177614,
-0.8347010612,
1.1946760416,
0.1657938659,
-0.7450995445,
0.1644598842,
-1.2536169291,
-0.3225892782,
0.217718035,
-0.1448977441,
-0.09347184,
-0.074363783,
-0.193733871,
-0.169343546,
-0.2781647742,
0.3433767259,
-0.5746129751,
0.14127855,
0.3612180948,
0.0150879361,
0.9290124178,
0.6521645784,
-0.0073727882,
0.24746418,
-0.8184981942,
-0.3012634218,
0.0127859935,
-0.2337686718,
-0.4029524028,
0.1563458592,
0.22698237,
0.0999330431,
0.4181328714,
-1.0124534369,
0.4455699921,
-0.5502732992,
0.7072704434,
0.2876406908,
-0.2369757593,
0.4825467467,
-0.1858768761,
0.4451527894,
-0.0835762918,
-0.1051896587,
-0.179725647,
-0.513723135,
-0.6484066248,
-0.2994476557,
0.4015368223,
0.1324142665,
-0.6210332513,
0.5563907623,
-0.1860385984,
-0.4503028095,
-0.9163252711,
-0.0653896779,
0.262935549,
0.4590574801,
0.6832259893,
-0.3335524797,
-0.5953568816,
-0.5835724473,
-0.1108326763,
-0.3655071855,
0.3232663274,
0.1468988806,
0.3016315699,
0.0664394572,
1.2788954973,
-0.5818186402,
-0.3434333503,
-0.0535082892,
0.2772083879,
-0.1209382489,
0.3717982769,
0.578164041,
-0.7899613976,
-0.5806024075,
0.2779970765,
-0.6641840935,
-0.2370551676,
0.4040388763,
-0.168763712,
0.8976584673,
0.9916387796,
-0.5556583405,
0.3571383059,
0.2838515043,
-0.653965652,
0.491433084,
-0.0202752873,
0.0213780571,
-0.6027238369,
0.4937696755,
-0.28410694,
-0.0310170352,
-0.4411878884,
0.4074241519,
-0.1637438834,
-0.0091132969,
-0.7558387518,
0.5546753407,
-0.3745912611,
0.1322640926,
-0.2974347472,
0.2936914861,
-0.0772697628,
-0.0575550869,
0.2247863561,
0.603928566,
0.6331117749,
-0.3627792895,
0.1500950605,
0.4379771948,
-0.060591571,
0.1816416383,
-0.4851567745,
0.1624879986,
-0.1573359817,
0.2565056384,
-0.7545836568,
-0.1812379062,
0.2891724408,
-0.6068934202,
0.1869006902,
0.0610636584,
-0.6834084988,
-0.1926272362,
-0.2454515249,
0.6037272811,
0.2769378126,
-0.4489373565,
0.414167136,
0.6371649504,
-0.1647856981,
-0.4412790537,
-0.6219858527,
0.0497523174,
0.0954998583,
-0.641864121,
0.2413663119,
-0.2445951402,
-0.6450886726,
0.5297395587,
0.1853029132,
-0.1060502902,
0.1188690066,
0.0653107837,
0.2170595229,
-0.5113418102,
0.2257746458,
0.004014486,
0.1864746362,
0.081807889,
-0.6612805724,
0.7708562016,
-0.2609080672,
-0.277153641,
0.0303173047,
0.3483490646,
0.368103981,
-0.416154027,
0.5926290751,
0.4226174951,
-0.0832352415,
-0.1418455094,
-0.2828318775,
0.1760935783,
-0.3919156492,
-0.0985466316,
0.0628080592,
-1.1378027201,
0.2047184855,
0.5340543985,
0.22042045,
0.8654981256,
0.3898441792,
0.2322327048,
0.7006590962,
0.623706758,
-0.1675889492,
0.4051416814,
-0.2027752548,
-0.0010347645,
-0.7813081145,
-0.1227506474,
-0.9467925429,
-0.03704511,
-0.5014398098,
-0.3778917193,
0.1687716991,
0.1433582157,
-0.3288125694,
0.4658279717,
-0.7501488924,
0.2851766348,
0.5183521509,
-0.3119471371,
0.6798049212,
-0.1685369313,
-0.1211274266,
0.4167605639,
-0.4379132688,
-0.4864369035,
1.036539793,
0.1849286556,
0.3708312511,
0.119494006,
0.6316901445,
0.5342044234,
0.2313094884,
-0.5832680464,
0.6039971113,
-0.1904139817,
-0.7081192136,
-0.2762238681,
-0.2214396447,
-1.3603810072,
0.0348747484,
-0.2293864638,
-0.8779494166,
0.1154804528,
0.1444281787,
-0.0913604423,
0.0868783668,
-0.1690467447,
0.817065835,
0.0138953757,
-0.3599273264,
-0.0502942577,
-0.8727329373,
0.2983154058,
-0.0118679805,
0.4989995956,
-0.0138950665,
-0.3611038923,
0.7576707602,
-0.2481476963,
0.7577424049,
0.0604938604,
0.0110614598,
0.7054800391,
0.0937399119,
-0.0127158109,
-0.02625525,
-0.1563635468,
0.1986077726,
0.1226021051,
-0.231998235,
-0.2292716652,
0.9728735685,
-0.7561535239,
-0.1137997955,
-0.7576358914,
-0.5375943184,
-0.0727258846,
0.4145664573,
0.0199020859,
0.2390003353,
-0.4421333373,
0.1905076057,
0.3047652543,
-0.1982370317,
0.6720501781,
0.4560155869,
-0.4750914276,
-0.4833433032,
1.0832244158,
-0.2100263089,
0.26169765,
0.2084488422,
0.1626811177,
-0.2651487887,
-0.6594862342,
-0.4563598633,
0.3991150856,
-0.6227173805,
-0.1140326783,
-0.9784392715,
-0.240398407,
-0.947021842,
-0.2499457449,
-0.2004577368,
-0.841680944,
-0.5072664618,
0.0369889736,
0.5097141862,
0.9128332734,
-0.0390581712,
0.0869122818,
-0.6913421154,
0.3315294385,
-0.4858002663,
0.2724873126,
-0.1211860031,
-0.1650504321,
-0.170285359,
-0.1248987466,
-0.52199471,
-0.5062396526,
0.5723853111,
0.4842567742,
0.4554056227,
0.2387551814,
0.2648099959,
0.2820007503,
-0.454361707,
1.2140693665,
0.1986338049,
-0.82410568,
0.4140065014,
-0.5487587452,
0.4350634813,
0.7638469934,
0.6869023442,
-0.4863931239,
-0.7701340318,
-1.1180434227,
-0.9465078115,
0.666493237,
-0.0607099533,
-0.2508443892,
-0.4090182781,
0.0152574917,
0.1196571216,
0.3626628816,
-0.4195190966,
-0.3483968079,
-0.2984194756,
-0.4427337348,
-0.1802916229,
0.19632487,
-0.1972843856,
-0.2546392977,
0.6637436748,
-0.5186666846,
0.223149851,
0.3876992166,
-0.012709178,
-0.1564378887,
0.0981564224,
0.7038418055,
0.5399438143,
0.1268959939,
0.3658865392,
-0.3715904057,
-0.6378799677,
-0.5496168733,
0.3513132334,
-0.2991479635,
-0.1532277465,
0.410533756,
0.4453441799,
-0.0875102878,
-0.9775223136,
0.2732381225,
0.3925415277,
-0.3053691983,
-0.5434619784,
0.0057173166,
0.129688397,
-0.1217934266,
0.2648843229,
0.0330242403,
0.4027671218,
-0.7358141541,
0.4321421385,
0.4531734884,
-0.7274676561,
-0.3645126522,
0.692284584,
-0.2102481276,
-0.0338856429,
0.4443059862,
-0.1802870631,
-0.3979584873,
0.4310313463,
0.5489454865,
0.7401289344,
0.1502296478,
0.0934787095,
0.3862537146,
0.0680813938,
0.0238755047,
0.2071187496,
-0.1645795554,
-0.3764988482,
-0.3321200907,
-1.0524586439,
-0.2186586857,
-0.1409346312,
-0.5607786775,
0.4458477199,
-0.4760998487,
0.1757932156,
0.4244479239,
-0.186888352,
-0.1901370138,
-0.2024869919,
0.2195113748,
1.3004549742,
-0.4918771684,
1.1030296087,
0.8124550581,
-0.6036732197,
-0.3079422414,
-0.3181985915,
0.3799123168,
-0.5709918737,
0.695250988,
-0.2633688748,
-0.038151633,
0.0574534088,
-0.9198083282,
-0.9380788803,
0.7615341544,
0.2509571016,
-0.113980934,
0.0393790007,
0.1115344465,
0.9146004915,
-0.6374444962,
0.0470420197,
0.7010731101,
0.6014381051,
0.2022042871,
-0.9793596864,
-0.1042919829,
-0.5149257183,
-0.4226739109,
0.6680124402,
-0.3884336948,
0.8886561394,
0.012852177,
-0.3243061304,
0.398797214,
0.8591708541,
0.08945705,
0.4672932923,
0.2638579011,
0.6442630291,
0.7169079185,
-0.0833467692,
1.1286916733,
-0.1891191602,
0.0834921449,
1.1879709959,
-0.2350706309,
1.0695211887,
0.3957131207,
-0.0549045876,
0.6307771206,
0.2342693508,
-0.0297855586,
0.2343122661,
0.2904168069,
-0.3572819233,
-0.0047282889,
-0.5571522713,
-0.4338209927,
0.4198537767,
0.5191947222,
-0.5481223464,
-0.2130170316,
0.0447279848,
0.0160869509,
0.5934864283,
-0.2079194337,
0.9432350397,
0.0320128202,
-0.8402551413,
0.531180501,
-0.2819445431,
0.2837416828,
-0.4706281126,
-0.0643713102,
0.2307589799,
-0.0241988618,
-0.2849679589,
-0.9093376994,
0.7212237716,
-0.1265366971,
-0.0585179366,
-0.2037997991,
0.6512005925,
-0.6392083764,
-0.3511690199,
0.4122687876,
0.2788265646,
0.3091313839,
0.1768776029,
-0.3380970359,
0.4328872859,
-0.4699441493,
0.0761596933,
0.5510447621,
0.2841515541,
-0.1432230175,
0.3961589336,
0.9547199607,
0.284006387,
0.1417234838,
-0.2901744246,
1.1432124376,
-0.5805444717,
-0.3339243531,
-0.541034162,
0.4649834931,
-0.1222358271,
-0.4698425233,
0.6076803207,
0.7909595966,
1.0299686193,
-0.0468051545,
0.9426143169,
-0.6098483801,
0.5083698034,
-0.3884868622,
0.9909701347,
-0.5654173493,
-0.0138592422,
-0.0762524381,
-0.6389601827,
-0.7641941309,
0.430768162,
-0.24948515,
-0.3669164777,
0.8810294867,
0.4637672603,
-0.0767391697,
0.4720244706,
0.0233800318,
0.3239098191,
0.1572106779,
0.0877915025,
0.7643458843,
0.0644049942,
0.4492518306,
-0.2382586002,
-0.1884284467,
-0.1444442719,
-1.0699830055,
-0.5821610093,
-0.9482834935,
-0.4784567952,
-0.4965343177,
0.0906683952,
1.1460859776,
0.3682134151,
-1.0076779127,
-0.3916628957,
-0.3054932058,
-0.0659527332,
-0.2104302347,
-0.2931733131,
0.3422298431,
-0.6592966318,
-0.6144061685,
0.7233969569,
0.0936003551,
-0.3524571061,
-0.2875060737,
0.028003104,
-0.6156409383,
-0.1335386932,
0.7147800326,
0.7601010203,
-0.6870567203,
-0.1900800169,
0.1729059517,
-0.1342315525,
0.1582871377,
1.0285338163,
-0.7205601931,
0.3841058612,
0.5858741999,
0.6602198482,
0.3109437823,
-0.0996948704,
0.4782600701,
-0.5053288937,
-0.0348529853,
0.5516626835,
0.3887194991,
0.2300906479,
-0.0793198645,
0.7061415911,
0.3336564898,
-0.5515912771,
-0.8708652258,
0.0946099907,
-1.60524261,
-0.3435940146,
1.1997556686,
-0.1175854802,
-0.4990271032,
-0.5014252067,
-0.2659543157,
0.1828018874,
-0.8258705139,
0.480344981,
0.4623556733,
-0.285166502,
-0.0663575009,
-0.4476805627,
0.699311316,
-0.1261111349,
-0.907189548,
0.2100241035,
0.7970249057,
-0.2697788477,
0.8764576912,
0.5694730878,
-0.4900839627,
0.370909065,
-0.0792741999,
0.2181692123,
-0.3103524446,
-0.6364834309,
-0.3912385404,
0.6622723937,
0.4165320992,
0.2074044496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14994v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14994v3 | RefGPT: Dialogue Generation of GPT, by GPT, and for GPT | 2023-05-24T10:30:42 | 2023-10-19T00:45:51 | Dongjie Yang, Ruifeng Yuan, Yuantao Fan, Yifei Yang, Zili Wang, Shusen Wang, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have attained the impressive capability to
resolve a wide range of NLP tasks by fine-tuning high-quality instruction data.
However, collecting human-written data of high quality, especially multi-turn
dialogues, is expensive and unattainable for most people. Though previous
studies have used powerful LLMs to generate the dialogues automatically, they
all suffer from generating untruthful dialogues because of the model
hallucination. Therefore, we propose a method called RefGPT to generate
enormous truthful and customized dialogues without worrying about factual
errors caused by the model hallucination. RefGPT solves the model hallucination
in dialogue generation by restricting the LLMs to leverage the given reference
instead of reciting their own knowledge to generate dialogues. Additionally,
RefGPT adds detailed controls on every utterance to enable high customization
capability, which previous studies have ignored. On the basis of RefGPT, we
also propose two high-quality dialogue datasets generated by GPT-4, namely
RefGPT-Fact and RefGPT-Code. RefGPT-Fact is a dataset with 100k multi-turn
dialogues based on factual knowledge and RefGPT-Code has 76k multi-turn
dialogues covering a wide range of coding scenarios. Our code and datasets are
released in https://github.com/mutonix/RefGPT. | [
-0.4527528286,
-0.7641577125,
0.6732061505,
-0.0154510103,
-0.0846866965,
0.0340111442,
-0.2455271035,
-0.1795587242,
0.1314763427,
0.8434513211,
-0.6967184544,
-0.4638292491,
-0.1550570577,
0.1819862127,
-0.2546575069,
1.359243989,
0.2117816955,
0.0579431094,
0.0651339293,
0.0105668437,
-0.4208649993,
-0.7646893263,
-0.5475050807,
-0.3782506883,
0.2672431767,
0.336951524,
0.8379958868,
0.3402458727,
0.2995535433,
0.2960723639,
0.3764108121,
0.4185062051,
-0.5245783925,
0.2400005609,
-0.2887208462,
-0.0722916871,
-0.3933285773,
0.0050110174,
0.4081879556,
0.197894156,
-0.4780132771,
0.0047881673,
-0.0715275034,
0.5583418012,
-0.058353547,
0.4221189022,
-1.0162608624,
0.0209334772,
0.0428328104,
-0.3176584542,
-0.4501028657,
-0.707362175,
0.1850600541,
-0.4379134178,
0.6970472336,
0.0217104107,
0.7891923189,
0.4577575624,
-0.1037914902,
-0.4227849841,
-0.8961200118,
0.6080097556,
-1.1158393621,
0.3314078152,
0.0599231645,
0.4565675557,
-0.3322927654,
-0.8520659804,
-0.8233605623,
-0.4554840326,
-0.0232336298,
0.1145353466,
0.0745901093,
0.1520281285,
0.3988108635,
0.3369684815,
-0.6584094167,
-0.3980918229,
-0.148829639,
-0.2183675915,
0.6253235936,
0.2002985179,
0.098623015,
-0.2850337923,
-0.1730370075,
0.021108726,
-0.8277890682,
-0.6105484962,
0.3951221108,
0.3099496961,
0.2357032746,
0.53167665,
-0.3934904635,
0.5051671267,
0.1500943899,
-0.3670561314,
0.217705518,
-0.5875196457,
-0.186382845,
0.0910042226,
0.8930153251,
0.3558508754,
0.3677805066,
-0.2350616008,
-0.2645078003,
-0.1708195806,
0.4026497304,
-1.0621675253,
-0.4074382186,
0.1715974212,
-0.1220527291,
-0.3713814616,
-0.020826783,
-0.9454600215,
-0.2806188166,
-0.4648983777,
0.1444355845,
-0.3703366518,
-0.1916332245,
0.1213457882,
0.2624642551,
0.1609277874,
0.4479773939,
-0.8351280689,
0.1493696719,
0.4172447324,
0.6109756231,
-0.137473464,
-0.0815317333,
-0.6757103801,
0.1629597843,
-0.1226296052,
0.5090453029,
-0.5023556948,
-0.1999383122,
0.0419209227,
-0.1609976739,
0.1078827158,
-0.5131690502,
0.5376014709,
-0.332287997,
0.368188113,
-0.3190882504,
-0.3860586882,
-0.3045505583,
0.3108970225,
-0.4413379133,
0.7487779856,
0.0997003317,
-0.7525717616,
0.0976204574,
-0.641484201,
-0.2487897873,
0.1532459706,
-0.5611277223,
-0.3852109909,
0.0190570615,
0.3119885623,
0.4164943695,
-0.5162997842,
0.7424559593,
0.0729317889,
-0.1271715164,
0.3753390908,
-0.5621742606,
0.1720250845,
0.2473695576,
-0.6052148342,
0.1212419942,
-0.666021049,
0.1649249345,
0.1944041103,
-0.2896200716,
0.4161858857,
-0.1005444899,
-0.1144194901,
0.228847295,
-0.0365142748,
-0.5253811479,
0.3364011049,
-0.185944736,
0.5897681713,
0.6678140759,
0.2417802215,
-0.1427066326,
-0.3056392968,
0.4941131771,
-0.2393934876,
-0.0318236724,
-0.256809175,
-0.6536736488,
-0.8151747584,
-0.0101026753,
0.233337298,
0.7300695777,
-0.9649584889,
0.4205406308,
-0.1808651239,
-0.321708709,
-0.520334959,
-0.0107469391,
0.3707100153,
0.5802562833,
0.3479422629,
-0.4002185762,
-0.452177316,
-0.7863095999,
0.0079025421,
-0.2303709686,
-0.1071258485,
0.5559668541,
0.3398062289,
-0.3911238015,
1.0772111416,
-0.6542830467,
-0.1026763245,
-0.2557456195,
0.2028176785,
0.1538205296,
0.3769664764,
0.1539209783,
-0.5711104274,
-0.3607464731,
-0.1802843213,
-0.7169691324,
-0.1721109748,
-0.4130115211,
-0.1011710092,
0.2323384136,
0.3075003922,
-0.9056773782,
0.2682831883,
0.5529651046,
0.1002393961,
0.7727521062,
-0.2053350806,
0.1376268268,
-1.1231976748,
-0.0276142042,
-0.2198673189,
-0.2968924344,
-0.6730379462,
-0.0537870899,
-0.4323937893,
-0.3425669968,
-0.2352203876,
0.214630425,
-0.2745042443,
0.0124909561,
-0.1403659284,
0.3737661242,
-0.1371522248,
0.8242886662,
0.3252910972,
0.7969989181,
0.079678826,
-0.356655091,
0.8339782357,
0.4575007558,
-0.3745304942,
0.1875745058,
-0.6734333634,
0.5867366791,
0.1521810144,
0.4568912089,
-0.846861124,
-0.4055699408,
0.3216004968,
-0.3948524296,
0.2351443619,
-0.2328554839,
-0.60315907,
-0.0613155738,
-0.1264214665,
0.1159352213,
0.5742580295,
-0.566896677,
0.3515189886,
0.2594308853,
-0.5569184422,
-0.4229097366,
-0.4133693278,
0.2994589508,
-0.089608334,
-0.7481995821,
-0.0040210481,
-0.2883254886,
-0.0486342125,
-0.2451864183,
0.0033117868,
0.0639870986,
-0.5724147558,
0.1795538217,
0.1808306426,
-0.2667448223,
0.0884004012,
-0.1004836485,
-0.3917576671,
0.0420478284,
-0.4546820521,
0.7363705039,
-0.2846924663,
-0.5487065315,
-0.3314668834,
0.3661541939,
0.490784198,
-0.1462343484,
0.3062680364,
0.8028905392,
-0.066078648,
-0.2055531293,
-0.9051316381,
-0.4810092747,
-0.4774111211,
0.4690413475,
-0.4069330394,
-0.8710560203,
0.2069733292,
-0.1181253195,
0.3275512755,
0.0571928248,
0.8118552566,
0.514318049,
0.9250924587,
0.2344307452,
-0.0572375208,
0.139814958,
0.0325888172,
0.5936771035,
-0.7290591002,
-0.1058489084,
-0.4032485485,
0.1365380585,
-0.7710884213,
-0.4867947698,
0.2185615152,
-0.0559715703,
-0.2978860438,
0.1295929402,
-0.8980455995,
0.5289363861,
0.6271827221,
0.0057044714,
0.5608061552,
0.2097634375,
-0.0019199548,
-0.350040555,
-0.6874684691,
-0.7633761168,
1.1064822674,
0.2263539135,
0.9322369695,
0.0889992863,
0.6460484862,
0.0347412266,
0.3195807636,
-0.5916307569,
0.6116585135,
0.174569428,
-0.5316635966,
-0.3099046648,
-0.7027183771,
-0.5653490424,
0.1814287454,
-0.0704279765,
-0.5909506679,
-0.2173304856,
0.2315748334,
-0.4516209364,
0.3309381902,
-0.7307286859,
0.6948190331,
-0.1327836066,
-0.2536217272,
-0.0540838316,
-0.6118177772,
0.5553837419,
-0.1950734258,
-0.1377349049,
-0.0208805874,
0.3827342093,
0.4501899779,
-0.5415658355,
0.9227711558,
-0.1820339411,
-0.2339458019,
0.4939429164,
0.2557767332,
0.9355341196,
0.5050159693,
0.0542379469,
0.011830898,
-0.3091518581,
0.0300915167,
-0.5799661279,
0.7801429033,
-0.5616292357,
-0.7997990251,
-0.3276396096,
-0.5863444209,
-0.2954212725,
-0.0179171152,
0.3743582964,
0.4791365564,
-0.1413584054,
-0.0638603717,
0.828204155,
-0.4931948781,
0.0948217437,
0.4865581989,
-0.366396904,
-0.5693616867,
1.2422654629,
-0.0434244499,
0.4486911595,
0.131592989,
0.208365351,
-0.3371811211,
-0.5710619092,
-0.6630256176,
0.4383520186,
-0.5671742558,
-0.260767132,
-0.5693505406,
-0.433411032,
-0.469614774,
-0.052400779,
-0.3849231899,
-0.4555853307,
0.2153269202,
-0.1735105366,
0.4955019057,
0.9365674853,
-0.0556180142,
0.1168506742,
-0.8393210769,
0.4741186202,
0.6427730918,
0.1885101944,
-0.1787545383,
-0.4146618843,
-0.018470291,
0.1488130987,
-0.5620521307,
-0.6268043518,
0.5823020339,
0.0235051364,
0.2521523833,
0.2403921038,
0.0655304044,
0.4749735594,
-0.7443161011,
0.8846474886,
0.2539028525,
-0.8091852665,
0.3494203985,
-0.3897574246,
0.1874668598,
0.4726411402,
0.0545265712,
-0.7280871272,
-0.495195806,
-0.7982178926,
-0.6203199625,
0.8016792536,
0.4896880686,
0.1760771871,
0.1108965799,
0.4977017939,
0.2599696517,
0.4693607986,
-0.7002213001,
-0.0359097719,
-0.5737397671,
-0.1186885685,
-0.0127088772,
-0.289096415,
-0.303447932,
-0.116147384,
0.7665714622,
-0.2228472382,
0.4282059669,
0.208337605,
0.2369190156,
0.0266329013,
0.3362511098,
0.7997251153,
0.5849961042,
-0.2161143273,
-0.0440982282,
0.2055886388,
-0.594912231,
0.0529031791,
-0.0504659377,
-0.3568587899,
0.3833379149,
0.1860154867,
0.9051480293,
-0.1841380596,
-0.5309762359,
0.3957051337,
-0.0828512162,
-0.150096193,
-0.4289080799,
0.2112438828,
0.1307656914,
0.1613290608,
-0.0110485675,
0.1415818036,
0.0067539448,
-0.4775476456,
0.3651398122,
0.3127663732,
-0.1726203412,
-0.3084619641,
0.6055203676,
0.5439956784,
-0.2835644186,
1.0729243755,
-0.306722343,
-0.576747179,
0.1063126475,
0.5549098849,
1.0559506416,
-0.344285816,
0.4103546739,
0.5108815432,
0.3283292353,
-0.1316135675,
0.0162008349,
0.1493287981,
-0.9692441225,
-0.6889615059,
-0.5338541865,
-0.7281241417,
0.6953622103,
-0.3301748633,
0.1061131284,
-0.4723239541,
-0.0655728057,
-0.3323970437,
-0.0710939094,
-0.3708924949,
0.1241636276,
-0.0503318869,
0.4230425656,
-0.4800450504,
0.9557866454,
0.0429118797,
-0.4835319519,
-0.8551307917,
0.1465379596,
-0.0150474161,
-0.7745326757,
0.5104628801,
0.1203089803,
-0.3244845569,
0.0175254624,
-0.7102763057,
-0.4848067462,
0.825316906,
0.5924862623,
-0.6577852964,
-0.2144853473,
0.459459573,
0.343496114,
-0.5629492998,
0.1989589036,
0.7357924581,
0.5392023325,
0.3438042998,
-0.8647816777,
0.2536670864,
-0.0667873621,
-0.0436546654,
0.0175567474,
-0.6611536741,
0.6317534447,
-0.3615477681,
-0.117061384,
-0.0500579327,
0.3534447253,
0.3945619464,
-0.0362806022,
0.2417370379,
0.4688948989,
0.7830472589,
-0.3025410473,
0.9257053733,
-0.2542058825,
0.2823668718,
1.372759819,
-0.3720584512,
0.4158845544,
0.1863402575,
-0.0303558707,
0.1994723529,
0.4382229447,
-0.1980912238,
0.3697789311,
0.5045573115,
-0.5591704249,
-0.3156509995,
0.1155149862,
-0.5071925521,
0.1010470912,
0.2640922666,
-0.1034303308,
-0.1279974431,
-0.2420259267,
0.1710165143,
-0.2275632322,
0.2744696438,
0.8954328299,
0.0728154555,
-0.7200168371,
0.7722581625,
-0.0878455862,
0.4513420463,
-0.697462976,
-0.3971662819,
-0.3825380206,
0.0809608996,
-0.3680968583,
-0.5699301362,
0.1520851403,
0.1840940267,
-0.0638404265,
-0.1842352897,
0.4869304299,
-0.7117915154,
-0.2743100226,
-0.1287850142,
0.4362749457,
0.5647996664,
-0.2620275319,
-0.707198143,
-0.0071748686,
0.6370458603,
-0.3798313439,
0.1349328756,
0.6776573658,
0.0886780918,
0.6731692553,
0.7436058521,
0.122177653,
0.0321777984,
0.2867029011,
0.8324383497,
-0.6926758289,
-0.0477967486,
-0.6777874827,
0.3540042043,
-0.1066355035,
-0.2669751048,
0.5818853974,
0.6194632053,
0.7664949298,
-0.2157672793,
1.1770689487,
0.0246049371,
0.6065604687,
-0.7117618918,
0.5472953916,
0.0145026641,
0.2806738317,
-0.4125215113,
-1.2055381536,
-0.1030824929,
0.7795916796,
-0.1130279154,
0.1774009168,
0.7333384752,
1.1344252825,
0.0143402545,
0.2603153288,
0.387960732,
0.3327076733,
0.6878687143,
0.600453198,
0.8071155548,
-0.2762552798,
0.8378593922,
-0.0024516913,
-0.1958469898,
-0.1431516558,
-0.788933754,
-0.8449041247,
-0.5682708025,
-0.3848682642,
-0.5150502324,
-0.2072342038,
0.7655290961,
0.7859377265,
-0.8797931075,
-0.1158236936,
-0.216060251,
-0.0617254451,
0.117123194,
-0.2597155571,
0.2923905551,
-0.5145400167,
-0.8671768308,
0.5007559061,
0.1639252454,
0.0821863338,
-0.410931617,
-0.3984989822,
0.2099215239,
0.2262687385,
0.5322654843,
0.1724781245,
-0.6899064183,
-0.4224704504,
-0.222628206,
0.0677846298,
0.2342397869,
1.1417931318,
-0.6218239069,
0.4730065167,
0.3212127686,
0.5887364149,
0.8339162469,
0.0938328281,
0.8470457196,
-0.7202468514,
0.0493706092,
0.2584494948,
0.1547569782,
0.5196741819,
-0.4117465317,
0.7502452135,
0.3472452462,
-0.8307133913,
-0.7432249784,
0.5514544845,
-0.9490237832,
0.1002629325,
1.1175657511,
-0.0988993943,
0.2683794498,
-0.2611598969,
-0.6254146695,
0.2306881547,
-0.7246515155,
0.9657541513,
0.7855623364,
-0.3958673477,
-0.1345672011,
-0.840197742,
0.9114406705,
0.2252539545,
-0.9273133278,
0.5081287622,
0.590182066,
0.2489062548,
0.3573852777,
0.5329756141,
-0.233000353,
-0.046138417,
0.0323601142,
0.3138283193,
-0.1501089483,
-0.2575727403,
0.0802251175,
0.1508568823,
0.0738484338,
0.08651416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14993v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14993v2 | Controlling Pre-trained Language Models for Grade-Specific Text Simplification | 2023-05-24T10:29:45 | 2023-11-30T14:14:31 | Sweta Agrawal, Marine Carpuat | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text simplification (TS) systems rewrite text to make it more readable while
preserving its content. However, what makes a text easy to read depends on the
intended readers. Recent work has shown that pre-trained language models can
simplify text using a wealth of techniques to control output simplicity,
ranging from specifying only the desired reading grade level, to directly
specifying low-level edit operations. Yet it remains unclear how to set these
control parameters in practice. Existing approaches set them at the corpus
level, disregarding the complexity of individual inputs and considering only
one level of output complexity. In this work, we conduct an empirical study to
understand how different control mechanisms impact the adequacy and simplicity
of text simplification systems. Based on these insights, we introduce a simple
method that predicts the edit operations required for simplifying a text for a
specific grade level on an instance-per-instance basis. This approach improves
the quality of the simplified outputs over corpus-level search-based
heuristics. | [
-0.2120581716,
-0.8007419109,
0.6719940901,
0.1146329343,
-0.2879389822,
-0.1426217556,
-0.1278999001,
-0.1792452633,
-0.2010238022,
0.2396420836,
-0.6242309809,
-0.625588119,
-0.7078759074,
0.2447662055,
-0.3930037022,
1.0729315281,
-0.3406404257,
-0.3880959749,
-0.1482219994,
0.2197229415,
-0.1375977397,
-0.7313981056,
-0.6438475847,
-0.5451298952,
0.8446431756,
0.745285511,
0.9085106254,
0.9958644509,
0.6198042035,
0.3465411961,
-0.5085923672,
-0.1678367257,
-0.4833793938,
-0.0554313771,
-0.0940918922,
-0.5703734159,
-0.648163259,
-0.1209561825,
0.615095973,
0.9377677441,
-0.1174606085,
-0.0344156325,
0.3419688046,
0.5721923709,
-0.7386386991,
0.1033547819,
-0.2213747054,
0.0461469442,
-0.05956598,
-0.4032161236,
-0.5559203029,
-0.4862783253,
0.0138771208,
-0.8335977793,
0.2236131728,
-0.1695254445,
0.82440418,
0.3729729652,
-0.5162103772,
-0.3978743553,
-0.8122377992,
0.8836368918,
-0.6860195398,
0.0538112484,
0.412448436,
-0.1122418568,
0.178059414,
-0.7415179014,
-0.2177494615,
-0.0742536485,
-0.5580229759,
0.1001919508,
-0.0502160043,
0.4639187157,
0.4545047283,
0.2168260217,
-0.2273701578,
0.1544634998,
-0.5774447918,
-0.1966080964,
0.2858532667,
0.1591312289,
0.3417288661,
-0.2022139132,
-0.1916148216,
-0.087727353,
-0.5214313269,
0.4603281021,
0.3202936053,
0.3342846632,
0.2513422966,
0.6222481728,
-0.5158010721,
0.3099260032,
0.003207478,
-0.1090082601,
0.1187501326,
-0.395629406,
-0.3208906054,
0.0775387213,
0.6561044455,
-0.0494749211,
0.3102149069,
-0.0739901736,
-0.6050871015,
0.0395670459,
0.3663592339,
-0.7783108354,
0.1544481814,
0.1737726182,
-0.2928906381,
-0.5871716142,
-0.1689415127,
-0.2636820674,
0.0469622426,
-0.5652757883,
0.8443535566,
-0.533611834,
0.1064310893,
0.2756899297,
0.0978320763,
-0.1760884672,
0.8485786319,
-0.8240025043,
0.5656389594,
0.574236095,
0.6230706573,
-0.1808895171,
-0.5817742944,
-0.5052220821,
0.3182375133,
-0.3176092207,
0.4333926141,
-0.5595142841,
-0.3067892492,
0.0076528103,
-0.3160507977,
-0.0208791643,
-0.1222966537,
0.7817977667,
-0.5733372569,
0.1780877113,
-0.0711999834,
-0.6489252448,
0.0586137734,
-0.0165313929,
-0.5843225121,
0.7774406075,
-0.3470990062,
-0.8067349195,
0.491884023,
-0.4307540655,
-0.5854334831,
-0.3330204189,
0.2733284533,
-0.5547263026,
0.3418815732,
0.3007268608,
0.2732165158,
0.1026530787,
0.2358768433,
0.0712154657,
-0.5559686422,
-0.143741414,
-0.5183995962,
0.4132651985,
0.2673414648,
-0.1585083753,
0.4014443755,
-0.5507706404,
0.3562574685,
-0.4020076096,
-0.6898222566,
-0.4850299954,
-0.0032534176,
-0.1160042584,
0.118513912,
0.4753594995,
-0.3323974013,
0.3463690281,
-0.0814966783,
0.2870676816,
0.6329835057,
-0.0755449682,
0.8545024991,
-0.3333725929,
0.6230403781,
0.0767118856,
0.3543421626,
-0.4361861944,
0.0950278565,
-0.9017477036,
-0.2151255906,
0.5905955434,
0.5534434915,
-0.4117370546,
0.1141227633,
-0.0323512852,
-0.4963423908,
-0.5438944101,
0.3158669472,
0.6089506149,
0.298445344,
0.3586495519,
0.0160130635,
-0.1668510884,
-0.7795479298,
-0.5397025347,
-0.0712819621,
0.0367878564,
-0.2173752189,
0.1807918847,
0.0572080724,
0.7873805165,
-0.48758322,
-0.2425949425,
-0.5324343443,
0.5488413572,
0.0907500237,
0.8074400425,
0.1783259362,
-0.8206659555,
-0.2956544459,
-0.1674336344,
-0.673985064,
-0.4831874371,
-0.0959958211,
-0.0477820858,
0.0481945984,
1.0680010319,
-0.285497129,
0.925840795,
0.2053118199,
-0.088084206,
0.2802398205,
-0.7047924995,
0.1442050338,
-0.5568103194,
-0.092667602,
-0.0900015533,
-0.3841141164,
-0.9032998085,
0.2275236994,
0.4161503911,
-0.0425415784,
-0.4551301003,
0.2216767073,
-0.4273436964,
0.0739076436,
-0.1583379805,
-0.1477804929,
0.0296740774,
0.7259452343,
0.0799057186,
0.6088677049,
0.2859782875,
-0.8418880701,
-0.4191678166,
-0.1656269282,
-0.1021157354,
0.2132804692,
-0.9402518272,
-0.0729167163,
-0.4590542912,
0.0350927152,
-0.9620550275,
-0.1025512889,
-0.2644107044,
-0.2742443383,
0.1373949051,
0.0202653185,
-0.5181746483,
0.1115750968,
-0.1560325772,
0.3269670606,
0.3316971958,
-0.2721195221,
0.751655221,
-0.2288629115,
-0.4074513614,
-0.5841715932,
-0.7868082523,
-0.3526422083,
-0.0382943414,
-0.1495759487,
0.3624953926,
-0.2628237009,
-0.0657624304,
-0.1194388121,
-0.329931736,
-0.2838274837,
0.2720528245,
0.2083788216,
0.0639112443,
-0.0959731042,
0.1767792255,
0.7494911551,
-0.2114691436,
-0.2478193045,
0.2627642453,
0.479640305,
-0.0327268504,
-0.4157660604,
-0.8797578216,
0.4486226141,
0.5750563145,
-0.2349293977,
0.4671578705,
0.1937610358,
-0.2004746497,
-0.2217787057,
-0.2119940817,
-0.3002440035,
-0.5224654675,
0.2270247042,
-0.8118736148,
-0.758482933,
0.4866268635,
-0.1675319821,
0.2541454434,
0.3823209703,
0.2402833849,
-0.1881202012,
1.1281421185,
0.8464466929,
0.3167217076,
0.6353549361,
0.0408415459,
0.0656175986,
-0.3637751341,
-0.0866976827,
-0.7902330756,
-0.4655049741,
-0.6211292744,
-0.001604886,
0.2266835868,
0.7513296008,
-0.3184505999,
0.1525364667,
-0.2333473414,
0.810598135,
0.894748807,
0.2771178782,
0.7436620593,
0.0710121319,
-0.2501606047,
0.0161909778,
-0.7048798203,
-0.8132594228,
0.9519554377,
0.3562890887,
0.8848792911,
0.2104635984,
1.1185896397,
0.2800979614,
0.4236410856,
-0.70853585,
0.5472732782,
-0.3904511034,
-0.3452482224,
-0.6469932199,
-0.5567936301,
-0.7361952066,
0.2984356582,
-0.0915642753,
-0.3824751377,
0.225012511,
0.4046852291,
-0.2176111788,
0.1806515455,
-1.1310751438,
0.7216101289,
0.1726707965,
-0.3807117939,
-0.1992699504,
-0.4708075523,
-0.0027859332,
-0.3369662762,
0.3533464074,
0.1677123755,
-0.2748250067,
0.3714270592,
-0.7767536044,
0.8959336281,
0.0515579805,
0.0194668267,
0.1609885842,
0.3276948631,
0.4711486697,
-0.0047249752,
-0.2822209001,
-0.1672382802,
0.054967083,
-0.6479919553,
-0.5096544623,
0.5182528496,
-1.0305696726,
-0.733499527,
-0.3588080704,
-0.4583561122,
-0.0292243902,
0.6568299532,
0.4270364642,
0.5218426585,
-0.2668991983,
0.1526902914,
0.6860932708,
-0.1809945107,
0.6211107969,
0.5031673312,
-0.3212285042,
-0.0827235729,
0.5291208029,
0.2454455942,
0.6688832045,
0.5218550563,
0.3365441263,
-0.0666641369,
-0.4575251639,
-0.2268995047,
-0.1294465661,
-0.7981389165,
-0.066155903,
-0.6474657655,
-0.0997452959,
-0.4720978439,
-0.3747183084,
0.0174798239,
-0.5697913766,
-0.5566464663,
-0.2265042216,
0.034875121,
0.9389331937,
-0.1212429926,
0.9126543403,
-0.3296729326,
0.392962724,
0.4759756029,
0.5126304626,
-0.2383928597,
-0.5608664155,
0.0370550454,
-0.1313889176,
-0.1263599247,
-0.8185532093,
0.2741261423,
0.219999969,
0.2615750432,
0.1184974015,
-0.0379472673,
0.5047089458,
-0.5541021228,
0.3908355832,
0.1349058598,
-1.5159963369,
0.5907757282,
-0.3182052672,
0.6121697426,
0.7030775547,
0.1915720999,
-0.3704917431,
-0.548361063,
-0.4900448918,
-0.7184473872,
1.1105837822,
0.2905035317,
0.1781262308,
0.540150404,
0.5981753469,
0.0093553355,
0.2975891829,
-0.7229693532,
-0.2503384054,
-0.2230184525,
-0.4167762697,
-0.1270305961,
-0.4353532493,
0.1269554347,
-0.0886105075,
0.4825260043,
0.1808530688,
-0.3374001682,
0.1602340341,
-0.2795675695,
-0.1235674843,
0.7728626132,
0.7493842244,
0.5035420656,
-0.2776030898,
0.2206292599,
-0.0142810494,
-0.5609071255,
0.3268791139,
-0.2166642547,
-0.6559256911,
0.106735684,
0.4076895416,
0.8075681329,
0.0084336819,
-0.3077169657,
0.3923152089,
-0.101489678,
-0.3893205523,
0.0786115229,
0.2829904556,
-0.2079898119,
-0.1750519425,
0.2596158683,
0.1951302886,
0.0774385259,
-0.3534089625,
0.0501106344,
-0.2136746347,
-0.2205774784,
-0.248516202,
0.5200616717,
0.1029159352,
-0.3566160798,
0.243448168,
-0.0796600357,
-0.3189529181,
0.7366895676,
0.4224996567,
0.5625098944,
-0.3445316553,
0.249838084,
0.3024131954,
0.7561069727,
-0.2995353937,
0.3085885942,
0.1052830368,
-0.5790585279,
-0.6489857435,
-0.6167137027,
-0.6294597983,
0.0005523766,
-0.8068804145,
0.491504848,
-0.7612585425,
-0.0565767847,
0.174295783,
-0.0610267483,
-0.7775539756,
0.6406260133,
-0.178504467,
0.9098703861,
-1.0042706728,
0.7999368906,
0.7683756948,
-0.6369765401,
-1.0606220961,
-0.0582923293,
-0.1139583662,
-0.3088983297,
0.7160460353,
-0.0277532917,
-0.2413252741,
0.1611234993,
-0.510222435,
-0.8907148838,
0.6213001609,
0.2516369522,
-0.6569513083,
-0.3788128793,
0.2695863247,
0.7482068539,
-0.1670302451,
0.341358304,
0.5466726422,
0.6072559953,
-0.0602062605,
-0.9872425199,
-0.2109246254,
-0.1838428527,
0.0563000515,
0.2047019154,
-0.230034709,
0.9929065704,
-0.235281229,
-0.0893494189,
-0.1445254683,
0.7354120016,
-0.0470055491,
0.3958573639,
0.5559917092,
0.5375798345,
0.677981317,
-0.1872722954,
1.0630940199,
-0.1405561566,
0.2536329627,
1.2415150404,
0.0977236405,
0.831680119,
0.6089992523,
0.1339730322,
0.5048237443,
0.4713585675,
0.5506349206,
0.3936710656,
0.3369161785,
-0.1437854618,
-0.3806911111,
0.0622092821,
0.0262733307,
0.2282999009,
0.285705775,
-0.276982367,
-0.0982538834,
0.04409362,
0.2036290169,
0.3883533478,
-0.7344646454,
0.9213259816,
-0.2485255301,
-0.7747527957,
0.3755219281,
0.1402252167,
0.727314949,
-0.6390689611,
0.2842707932,
-0.4432611167,
0.2611629665,
-0.333121419,
-0.6701718569,
0.1728170216,
0.223724708,
-0.5164087415,
-0.6104608774,
0.5317975879,
-0.5713144541,
-0.5361289978,
-0.0873269066,
0.6052128673,
0.0306662545,
0.0842085555,
-0.3552933633,
0.1820514649,
0.1465027183,
-0.4793432951,
0.1220149249,
0.8614320159,
-0.1588132083,
0.5919656157,
0.5016865134,
0.2966122627,
0.1869529188,
0.1645182967,
0.7321000695,
-0.6330530047,
-0.5688579082,
-0.5640352368,
0.2495460957,
0.0432348475,
-0.4886995852,
0.3661996126,
0.4457704723,
0.9010248184,
0.070555225,
0.8116563559,
0.2830039561,
0.6358137131,
-0.4228873551,
0.5843287706,
-0.8635661602,
0.3683266938,
-0.4185164273,
-0.6958546042,
-0.4698384702,
0.2847462296,
-0.4510101378,
0.1167831942,
0.8021522164,
0.6637565494,
-0.2143226415,
-0.1937755793,
0.3583684564,
0.0685177594,
0.2093830854,
0.2188233435,
0.5292822123,
-0.2108827233,
0.7971065044,
-0.4721603692,
-0.1680042148,
-0.0459418818,
-0.9835389256,
-0.6689301729,
-0.1547516733,
-0.4161398113,
-0.0719788,
0.0966234058,
0.6464275718,
0.365098089,
-0.7041647434,
-0.257401228,
-0.4043576419,
0.1776780933,
-0.3437640965,
-0.1436990201,
0.4808550477,
-0.8046256304,
-1.0423206091,
0.0666508749,
0.1140714213,
0.1988993138,
-0.0567327589,
0.1618591249,
0.1118188649,
0.3622811437,
0.3637045026,
0.0942205265,
-0.6913895011,
0.0458399355,
0.0524247736,
-0.7173472643,
0.0105918767,
1.0490891933,
-0.5541730523,
0.343739748,
0.8177860975,
0.3120589554,
0.3442729414,
0.2008404583,
0.6409373879,
-0.9447616935,
0.0739960223,
0.0253466424,
0.1756434739,
0.1476664841,
-0.2311776578,
0.2433890998,
-0.178138867,
-0.4778032005,
-0.6953590512,
0.1638854295,
-0.7383397222,
-0.5978278518,
0.9911942482,
-0.1894682944,
-0.2453208119,
0.0476137772,
-0.4212327003,
0.4152982533,
-0.4597504139,
0.5734769106,
0.6599628329,
0.1193813384,
-0.3147363067,
-0.1946546882,
0.8809010386,
0.9492768049,
-0.8885360956,
0.0892448947,
0.4699831605,
0.2445576042,
0.1262708455,
0.6219731569,
0.0446465425,
0.2397892922,
-0.4774810076,
0.3193741739,
-0.01931783,
-0.3847061396,
-0.6289351583,
0.5236299038,
0.0399920009,
0.2816289365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14992v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14992v2 | Reasoning with Language Model is Planning with World Model | 2023-05-24T10:28:28 | 2023-10-23T07:24:28 | Shibo Hao, Yi Gu, Haodi Ma, Joshua Jiahua Hong, Zhen Wang, Daisy Zhe Wang, Zhiting Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable reasoning capabilities,
especially when prompted to generate intermediate reasoning steps (e.g.,
Chain-of-Thought, CoT). However, LLMs can still struggle with problems that are
easy for humans, such as generating action plans for executing tasks in a given
environment, or performing complex math, logical, and commonsense reasoning.
The deficiency stems from the key fact that LLMs lack an internal
$\textit{world model}$ to predict the world $\textit{state}$ (e.g., environment
status, intermediate variable values) and simulate long-term outcomes of
actions. This prevents LLMs from performing deliberate planning akin to human
brains, which involves exploring alternative reasoning paths, anticipating
future states and rewards, and iteratively refining existing reasoning steps.
To overcome the limitations, we propose a new LLM reasoning framework,
$\underline{R}$easoning vi$\underline{a}$ $\underline{P}$lanning
$\textbf{(RAP)}$. RAP repurposes the LLM as both a world model and a reasoning
agent, and incorporates a principled planning algorithm (based on Monto Carlo
Tree Search) for strategic exploration in the vast reasoning space. During
reasoning, the LLM (as agent) incrementally builds a reasoning tree under the
guidance of the LLM (as world model) and task-specific rewards, and obtains a
high-reward reasoning path efficiently with a proper balance between
exploration $\textit{vs.}$ exploitation. We apply RAP to a variety of
challenging reasoning problems including plan generation, math reasoning, and
logical inference. Empirical results on these tasks demonstrate the superiority
of RAP over various strong baselines, including CoT and least-to-most prompting
with self-consistency. RAP on LLAMA-33B surpasses CoT on GPT-4 with 33%
relative improvement in a plan generation setting. | [
-0.2820034921,
-0.7945815325,
0.8997655511,
0.3101587296,
0.1274645329,
0.3013156354,
-0.2517520785,
-0.3026565015,
0.0278555453,
0.5401711464,
-0.7004356384,
-0.4899687767,
-0.4359809756,
-0.0489849411,
-0.0585441329,
0.5750375986,
-0.2375095487,
-0.1199913695,
-0.1134465337,
0.1536031514,
-0.3532752693,
-0.6059052348,
-0.7446218729,
-0.6671948433,
0.5156655908,
0.454947263,
0.7095896006,
0.4720446467,
0.4256731868,
0.2555352449,
-0.2380156815,
0.3733842969,
-0.5128762126,
0.2525023818,
-0.3604780436,
-0.3035179675,
-0.2867471278,
-0.1650095433,
0.3772140443,
0.5826374888,
-0.1395821422,
-0.1302643865,
-0.4188701808,
0.5794613361,
-0.5059841275,
0.1928442568,
-0.860237956,
0.0902162567,
0.0695518777,
-0.2892566025,
-0.4416728914,
0.0587398484,
0.0329936408,
-0.4784032702,
-0.2514061332,
0.2742694318,
0.7195308805,
0.3239973783,
-0.4553401768,
-0.3559918702,
-0.936583221,
0.7611438632,
-0.5516839027,
0.2964303493,
0.3026663065,
0.3725894094,
-0.6280862093,
-0.5713649988,
-0.6506657004,
-0.383030206,
0.2552171648,
0.0393023007,
-0.0892620087,
0.0215310659,
0.5306012034,
0.0307559781,
-0.2743339241,
0.0298253298,
-0.180434823,
-0.1764743626,
0.6407610774,
0.1266656518,
0.3365366161,
-0.1271781623,
-0.5333665013,
0.0056399936,
-1.084908843,
0.2525622249,
0.0633532181,
0.1893667877,
0.0568398945,
0.6084218025,
-0.107967943,
0.7117922306,
-0.4172673821,
-0.5406965017,
-0.1870812625,
-0.0236942619,
-0.2323114723,
-0.1874106228,
0.6342192292,
0.1377169937,
0.4318454266,
-0.0355474427,
-0.3345257342,
0.3020787835,
0.0482113026,
-0.4274182618,
-0.1585956514,
0.2284226716,
-0.1101212054,
0.0458169244,
-0.2706563473,
-0.2588986158,
-0.1667730361,
-0.5149927735,
0.2388603538,
-0.6881279945,
-0.2432690114,
0.2728844285,
0.0088229561,
0.360450089,
0.490840137,
-0.5773044825,
0.3363044262,
0.8400942683,
0.8044911027,
-0.1102430001,
-0.3187520206,
-0.5440306664,
0.4282439053,
-0.6218772531,
1.0846707821,
-0.7088900208,
-0.4946664274,
-0.3044474125,
-0.3214332163,
-0.01412981,
-0.3768497705,
0.7379683256,
-0.4414302111,
-0.1112959087,
-0.488802284,
-0.6296090484,
-0.1688542515,
0.4867807329,
-0.4315823019,
0.8817249537,
-0.022240499,
-0.5586561561,
0.2856430709,
-0.9213231206,
-0.1799184084,
0.0015840274,
-0.3380694091,
0.1115181297,
-0.1343075335,
0.4191284776,
0.2664527297,
-0.4505987465,
0.5071547031,
-0.2312252074,
-0.5903794169,
0.1912721694,
-0.211711973,
0.7853066325,
0.3860689104,
-0.2230246514,
0.2121797055,
-0.4038307965,
0.1998661608,
0.3666500151,
-0.3209219277,
-0.1538618654,
0.3086178303,
-0.4145551324,
0.4277186394,
-0.0473927483,
-0.4744182527,
0.4421395957,
-0.4443347752,
0.5316261649,
0.6973977089,
0.0940132439,
0.4637449086,
-0.4506772459,
0.6034226418,
-0.0946811661,
-0.1066613346,
-0.1251375973,
-0.4864244461,
-0.6685703397,
-0.2519585192,
0.0237793494,
0.6621943712,
-0.7242257595,
0.1264551431,
-0.2594098449,
-0.3223023415,
-0.0800481215,
0.1173619777,
0.241557762,
0.3716591001,
0.2597412765,
0.2851212323,
-0.71652776,
-0.6654562354,
-0.0941577926,
-0.2590405345,
0.1370896399,
0.2465858608,
0.5814046264,
-0.2829263508,
0.9341858625,
-0.3137924969,
-0.1156897098,
-0.7334067822,
-0.0056791794,
0.1911884248,
0.2968717217,
0.1736242175,
-0.7850142717,
-0.3085428178,
-0.2116209716,
-0.7424553037,
-0.1675573885,
-0.2041370422,
-0.3253262937,
0.1041604057,
0.6818525195,
-0.7619277239,
0.4149635732,
0.3524910212,
-0.3288858831,
0.6118654609,
-0.129152894,
-0.1457713842,
-0.7886102796,
-0.1269785017,
-0.0790793151,
-0.0890827626,
-0.4265128076,
0.2764085233,
-0.1910636723,
-0.2187051177,
-0.278059572,
0.7631106377,
-0.5227057338,
-0.2562413514,
-0.4993310273,
0.2403384149,
0.1179291904,
0.5942101479,
0.1760107875,
0.790520072,
0.5626208186,
-0.6658545136,
0.3818666041,
0.206943363,
-0.1677119583,
0.3318123221,
-0.5851112008,
0.1343385279,
-0.147937268,
0.5756825805,
-0.5355021954,
0.0040805996,
0.2440351844,
-0.3617971241,
0.1143365279,
-0.1100332662,
-0.5192674398,
-0.4831687212,
0.0675412714,
0.1656099856,
0.3984525502,
-0.5230602026,
0.7712979317,
0.3647927344,
-0.0564188212,
-0.5975940228,
-0.5175457001,
0.3767329752,
-0.0991858542,
-0.7071380019,
0.3524866402,
-0.1661242247,
-0.8668062687,
0.0157032553,
-0.1949097067,
0.0970283374,
-0.0525220484,
0.2407002002,
0.3609176576,
-0.0285026766,
0.343798548,
-0.0620457493,
-0.2664720714,
0.2315572351,
-0.256760329,
0.5473214388,
-0.3083046377,
-0.5155640841,
-0.0213143975,
0.4637887776,
0.3888343275,
-0.2765038311,
0.479939878,
0.0897102505,
-0.3128157556,
-0.3731222451,
-0.3187537193,
0.0222087111,
-0.4017397165,
0.0795319453,
-0.7781230211,
-0.8420598507,
0.4096508026,
-0.3597478569,
0.1108035967,
0.3111574054,
0.4844738841,
-0.083188124,
1.1538617611,
0.5252842903,
0.1112266853,
0.1002222672,
-0.4353801906,
0.4238013029,
-0.9647926688,
-0.330539614,
-0.2522040308,
-0.3130548596,
-0.3296258152,
-0.7154417038,
0.24985753,
0.1584724933,
-0.5296167731,
0.0436412506,
-0.3462274075,
0.6675721407,
0.5210216641,
-0.1262995154,
0.4232476056,
-0.1471431255,
-0.5188224912,
0.0868121311,
-0.7297286391,
-0.798492372,
1.0059252977,
0.3138756752,
0.8233019114,
0.0912996307,
0.7828074098,
0.0470885485,
0.2852058113,
-0.9011785388,
0.820691824,
0.1283705384,
-0.5016123056,
-0.3344462216,
-0.4788804352,
-0.6957930326,
0.3588601351,
-0.2262413651,
-1.0247483253,
-0.0254709981,
0.0664719269,
-0.273314178,
0.6017121077,
-0.6137993336,
0.5817660689,
-0.3890845776,
-0.3058648705,
-0.1790041625,
-0.4588908255,
0.5440106392,
0.1232908815,
0.3194656074,
-0.4632951021,
-0.0187597144,
0.374910295,
-0.4629514515,
0.53633219,
-0.1744742095,
-0.1269809306,
0.5646493435,
0.3584888279,
0.7483027577,
0.1358873099,
-0.0203608461,
-0.0547138974,
-0.0940832198,
-0.2890594602,
-0.7209540606,
0.8126061559,
-0.5750281811,
-0.9544778466,
-0.5961661935,
-0.9807928801,
-0.4324970245,
-0.0343921036,
0.0179844648,
0.2702019811,
-0.061412286,
-0.1200435385,
0.6207661629,
-0.3212649822,
0.2676573992,
0.3586393893,
-0.7133243084,
-0.1038369089,
0.5903050303,
-0.1535949409,
0.3505963087,
0.4381474853,
0.3834421933,
-0.3864827752,
-0.4754599929,
-0.1954016238,
0.2850690186,
-0.9044572711,
-0.1847895235,
-0.7426902652,
-0.4930830896,
-0.1110510826,
-0.2306081206,
-0.1818378568,
-0.2696754634,
0.2380538285,
-0.1418040991,
0.3495926559,
0.6741762161,
-0.1240038499,
0.1464556754,
-0.4196714461,
0.5045070648,
0.3198525012,
0.0509897061,
-0.0787618384,
-0.3824481964,
0.1896792799,
0.2154090852,
-0.3022942841,
-0.7047758698,
0.356393218,
-0.0124391746,
0.6134107113,
0.1252732873,
0.0034135175,
0.8384165764,
-0.5054665804,
0.4480148256,
-0.0256107412,
-0.9868368506,
0.7070170641,
-0.2734360993,
0.359780997,
0.1577908099,
0.2351899147,
-0.540686667,
-0.4688606858,
-0.6723422408,
-0.7319751978,
0.533487916,
0.1864276528,
-0.103295356,
-0.1161001399,
0.3340450823,
-0.1976133436,
-0.1151715294,
-0.9524931312,
0.0766734406,
-0.0626228303,
0.1319106668,
0.0847872868,
-0.232734412,
-0.2772721946,
-0.4342057109,
0.6858543754,
-0.313803792,
0.344720602,
0.2236133516,
-0.0135499267,
-0.2132391632,
0.393137008,
0.5062943101,
0.7895144224,
-0.1225582436,
0.288190484,
0.1944634169,
0.1187230498,
0.2989739478,
-0.1095883697,
-0.2142235786,
-0.3422958255,
0.3914805949,
0.7227686644,
0.2279815376,
-1.1056076288,
0.3497681022,
0.0854409486,
-0.3236632347,
-0.550925374,
0.2682185471,
0.4407449663,
0.4123714864,
0.2705701292,
0.0856739357,
-0.0951530039,
-0.7431969047,
0.0385889709,
0.4233891368,
-0.1614103764,
0.0613556094,
0.4362277389,
-0.1300610751,
-0.459239006,
0.5342103243,
-0.4600796998,
-0.6089454293,
0.645311594,
0.8278834224,
0.5002017021,
0.0363811478,
0.32831949,
0.3115334511,
0.3652614951,
-0.2287545055,
0.5417901278,
0.0475174598,
-1.0766642094,
-0.9172814488,
-0.5687306523,
-0.515089035,
0.1689893752,
-0.120376952,
0.083081387,
-0.6611377597,
0.0697853044,
-0.32139346,
-0.0194782969,
-0.436381042,
0.1752094775,
0.1290777326,
1.171233058,
-0.5331271291,
0.8347976208,
0.6934899092,
-0.3180137575,
-1.1622935534,
0.0624837726,
0.0930480808,
-0.9141495228,
0.9511526227,
0.2601115704,
-0.3971884549,
-0.0843983889,
-0.7091292143,
-1.1017688513,
0.9936178923,
0.4277519584,
-0.6562724113,
-0.1659326702,
-0.1865785718,
0.4584161043,
-0.6873992682,
-0.0602271967,
0.6343715191,
0.5901757479,
0.706763804,
-0.6331156492,
0.0243651401,
-0.1996583045,
0.0965832546,
0.2593088746,
-0.3671598434,
0.8610610366,
-0.7332777381,
-0.2829090357,
-0.0160998162,
0.5416226983,
0.8399043679,
0.2155489028,
0.5780947208,
0.6906782985,
0.7469317317,
-0.2165038586,
1.1027518511,
-0.2172897607,
-0.0606240742,
1.2419977188,
-0.6124666333,
0.8672263622,
0.39747262,
-0.119019188,
0.7790818214,
0.4805163443,
0.2745246589,
0.2810612321,
0.4023540318,
-0.2719817162,
-0.6021295786,
-0.0868954808,
-0.1107273847,
0.8071627617,
0.5293415785,
-0.0141657023,
-0.2220987976,
-0.0922037214,
0.0953120366,
0.4107629955,
-0.3635888398,
0.5811190605,
0.2823794484,
-0.8466362357,
0.4224392772,
0.0039615547,
0.3470929265,
-0.6728007197,
-0.1442820132,
-0.0721392184,
0.0365297161,
-0.0101929251,
-0.7778467536,
0.4282618761,
0.0663021579,
0.0859515443,
-0.3678117096,
0.8222939372,
-0.2186692506,
-0.5353419185,
0.5017678142,
0.779692173,
0.0863257051,
-0.0799578801,
-0.8592213988,
0.1814616472,
-0.1563958675,
-0.2308596671,
0.1076391414,
0.6897056699,
-0.2694262564,
1.2812297344,
0.7976632118,
0.42137748,
-0.2780445516,
0.2195979953,
0.8930253983,
-1.0428277254,
-0.4735838175,
-0.7966572642,
0.1563653499,
-0.067377001,
-0.0110173561,
0.3984235525,
0.4140606821,
0.6094337106,
0.3325496018,
0.7807711363,
-0.1174994856,
0.576297462,
-0.7618727684,
0.1352159083,
-0.3013274372,
0.6617560387,
-0.1536779106,
-0.9083393812,
-0.2062145025,
0.8563784361,
-0.5990670919,
0.0561065041,
0.8525118828,
0.6426463127,
0.1321896464,
-0.1001552269,
0.3842177987,
0.1066990197,
0.539952457,
0.9738947749,
1.0728669167,
0.1095086634,
0.6016315818,
-0.0934755206,
-0.1625572145,
0.1141371503,
-0.9380064011,
-0.7779936194,
-0.3553855121,
0.0352295227,
-0.1014193818,
-0.0147028612,
1.1770416498,
0.5179639459,
-0.5386637449,
-0.3838687837,
-0.3929667473,
0.4125286937,
-0.2568489015,
-0.2619603872,
0.0444839336,
-0.461712122,
-0.4816394448,
0.7137226462,
0.5501722097,
-0.0015394179,
-0.4197584689,
-0.4368478954,
-0.3800531328,
0.1968424618,
0.6576027274,
0.3979127109,
-1.1160917282,
-0.4290534258,
0.064222306,
-0.0209847819,
0.1153720319,
0.9211790562,
-0.9267810583,
0.3378950059,
0.1085115299,
0.4964587092,
0.529892087,
-0.1569266766,
0.7590482235,
-0.3883040249,
0.1806493551,
0.4704819024,
0.6743748188,
0.3573488295,
-0.1761661172,
0.6810160875,
0.1088210568,
-0.5334989429,
-0.5465478301,
0.6684362888,
-0.8817834258,
-0.5022785068,
1.3001717329,
-0.0572050624,
-0.2259250879,
-0.115860641,
-0.5047393441,
-0.022830924,
-0.3910191059,
0.6287485957,
0.6691402197,
-0.4765537381,
-0.4200638831,
-0.4556333423,
0.43947649,
0.2043232769,
-0.8668882251,
0.0386623777,
0.5845983624,
0.1279258579,
0.1923798621,
0.9336286187,
0.0099942572,
0.1325851381,
0.0256458633,
0.034573853,
-0.1851634383,
-0.5326240659,
0.1815174967,
0.150397256,
0.2926893532,
0.4322209656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14991v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14991v2 | MuLER: Detailed and Scalable Reference-based Evaluation | 2023-05-24T10:26:13 | 2023-11-29T10:47:58 | Taelin Karidi, Leshem Choshen, Gal Patel, Omri Abend | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a novel methodology (namely, MuLER) that transforms any
reference-based evaluation metric for text generation, such as machine
translation (MT) into a fine-grained analysis tool. Given a system and a
metric, MuLER quantifies how much the chosen metric penalizes specific error
types (e.g., errors in translating names of locations). MuLER thus enables a
detailed error analysis which can lead to targeted improvement efforts for
specific phenomena. We perform experiments in both synthetic and naturalistic
settings to support MuLER's validity and showcase its usability in MT
evaluation, and other tasks, such as summarization. Analyzing all submissions
to WMT in 2014-2020, we find consistent trends. For example, nouns and verbs
are among the most frequent POS tags. However, they are among the hardest to
translate. Performance on most POS tags improves with overall system
performance, but a few are not thus correlated (their identity changes from
language to language). Preliminary experiments with summarization reveal
similar trends. | [
-0.1745048612,
-0.8111704588,
0.3120838106,
0.4028440118,
-0.3045770526,
0.1064562798,
-0.1470385641,
-0.270233959,
-0.0175013412,
0.2396543771,
-0.0953019783,
-0.4280772805,
-0.647505343,
0.4793216586,
-0.5301818252,
1.3055580854,
-0.2685143054,
0.1977532953,
-0.3284520805,
-0.3901450932,
-0.624663949,
-0.5808944702,
-0.4509657025,
-0.3351720273,
0.663228035,
0.3152841032,
0.6207273602,
0.6436564326,
1.2120665312,
0.3259633183,
-0.1350703388,
0.3641047478,
-0.3370203674,
0.1203620583,
-0.4714734852,
-0.1713366657,
-0.802403152,
-0.0867560059,
0.8639271855,
0.8487630486,
-0.1507748216,
0.5500327349,
0.0097676693,
0.7197701335,
-0.8045663834,
-0.0856592059,
-0.5889749527,
0.0443020798,
-0.2478525639,
-0.3299844265,
-0.5266349316,
-0.3200621307,
0.0583095811,
-0.3950487673,
0.507954061,
0.1772922128,
0.9161913991,
0.2909473777,
-0.5265827775,
-0.1059486419,
-0.9180477262,
1.0543386936,
-0.5071923137,
0.2878581882,
0.1040468216,
0.4731984735,
-0.3503770232,
-1.0136401653,
-0.4501442313,
-0.0943347216,
-0.3395594656,
0.2205278873,
-0.3330631852,
-0.156020239,
0.0668383911,
0.5849875808,
-0.349366188,
-0.295227915,
-0.361087501,
-0.1439298689,
0.4712834656,
0.5862007141,
0.1696592122,
-0.1226078272,
-0.1959781349,
-0.1123752967,
-0.3182478547,
-0.1898518652,
-0.0572664328,
0.1746979058,
0.1505298465,
0.7933991551,
-0.2867285311,
0.883607924,
0.0633471757,
-0.2102283388,
0.3394280374,
-0.6297017932,
-0.3326335251,
-0.2513979375,
1.0860215425,
0.7093108296,
-0.2335224897,
-0.4571308792,
-0.5491748452,
0.0062894165,
0.287668258,
-0.9777698517,
0.0383734182,
0.2795126736,
-0.5423743725,
-0.4345298707,
0.1823657304,
-0.4904818535,
-0.4689587057,
-0.0651492253,
0.351614207,
-0.3872383535,
-0.0826029256,
0.1391520798,
-0.6149508357,
0.2764438689,
0.3781013489,
-0.5171166658,
0.4142783582,
0.5129841566,
1.0223100185,
-0.4459574521,
-0.4940363765,
-0.8567415476,
0.3285117149,
-0.3200383782,
1.0047161579,
-0.3249907792,
-0.5169836879,
-0.2226946652,
-0.1034201309,
0.0348849706,
-0.6353579164,
0.5190059543,
-0.3648922741,
0.216831848,
-0.0223180521,
-0.2566720843,
0.0956192836,
0.4649400711,
-0.6721704602,
1.2664031982,
0.3678290546,
-0.9491361976,
0.3954249918,
-0.9521358609,
-0.5813437104,
-0.0858267546,
0.2314660251,
-0.4378163517,
0.4217139184,
-0.1308172494,
0.4562593102,
-0.7088218927,
0.4890416265,
0.1964694411,
-0.4242952168,
0.3716232181,
-0.0608912595,
0.2675662339,
0.5204151869,
-0.1836068481,
0.4137437344,
-1.0647763014,
0.0048710825,
0.0603029206,
-0.4052270055,
-0.4023635685,
0.2040635496,
0.1829870194,
-0.0645469576,
0.2737357914,
-0.3549053669,
0.0775336549,
-0.1611381322,
0.2374831587,
0.219523266,
-0.0181599017,
0.4662017226,
-0.1812731773,
0.4258289337,
0.0059768856,
0.0158308279,
-0.4167793691,
-0.259519428,
-0.8868695498,
-0.0317881666,
0.553766489,
0.5198864341,
-0.5934665799,
0.5287159085,
-0.5069619417,
-0.8414625525,
-0.3982582092,
-0.1204274371,
0.5853966475,
0.634657979,
0.5278890729,
-0.5466294289,
-0.6636923552,
-0.855605185,
-0.5854321718,
-0.1863746345,
-0.3225459754,
-0.2672262788,
0.4315964282,
-0.3415181935,
1.1647052765,
-0.3977214694,
-0.2534641922,
-0.3185347915,
0.4506165087,
-0.011034146,
0.6440239549,
0.3200044334,
-0.6256254911,
-0.4060293734,
0.3371466994,
-0.6237000227,
-0.3073476851,
-0.1144164726,
-0.1129255816,
-0.1699592024,
0.4009434879,
-0.2612015009,
0.1750583947,
0.4705505967,
-0.3961056173,
0.5118486285,
-0.3210353851,
0.1439029127,
-1.2000139952,
0.3566580415,
-0.1500053704,
-0.3134665191,
-0.4683825076,
0.2605240345,
0.096270375,
0.013918248,
-0.3694159091,
0.4960338473,
-0.4768163264,
-0.0051423861,
-0.2259106785,
0.4754639268,
0.0577120446,
-0.0471560657,
-0.1939581931,
0.8325318694,
0.1324868947,
-0.7147709131,
0.429681778,
0.083336778,
-0.1603322923,
0.7854042649,
-0.9525496364,
0.20734106,
-0.1652629673,
0.1607762426,
-0.9326190948,
-0.1827931106,
0.0532649942,
-0.5276489854,
0.256903559,
0.0510339402,
-0.6362432837,
-0.1352878809,
-0.2370452881,
0.1457605809,
0.4003244042,
-0.0639297441,
0.6866170168,
0.2642631829,
0.1925226301,
-0.3858706951,
-0.5930647254,
0.2806262672,
-0.1456476599,
-0.495134145,
0.076698415,
0.0300504379,
-0.4253056347,
0.0673110783,
-0.075945653,
-0.1237598509,
0.2961919606,
-0.076345019,
0.00446977,
-0.2716558576,
0.1200299114,
-0.047710903,
-0.383631289,
-0.1284821182,
-0.4529177845,
0.4179465771,
-0.5454103351,
-0.0599576831,
-0.2388228029,
0.3029994369,
0.5090758204,
-0.5797616839,
0.6840681434,
0.7441701889,
-0.0860048532,
0.1707762331,
-0.4808511734,
0.1853635311,
-0.3976173103,
0.485770911,
-0.652453959,
-0.5323740244,
0.4237493873,
-0.3965171278,
0.2338174134,
0.714859426,
0.4473891258,
-0.076564841,
0.9130396247,
0.7539291978,
0.4218354523,
0.4827061296,
-0.1797499359,
-0.0532139577,
-1.0392032862,
-0.2521690726,
-0.7984268069,
-0.4736172557,
-0.6830205917,
-0.6115494967,
0.0812503844,
0.2050582618,
-0.0839053839,
0.4865499437,
-0.5262294412,
0.5447205901,
0.4260558784,
-0.5176378489,
0.5542220473,
-0.1641149968,
-0.3056135774,
-0.1918730736,
-0.4850166142,
-0.9161147475,
0.9058662057,
0.021862017,
0.5752515793,
0.1653110087,
0.4243307114,
0.323723495,
0.8623542786,
-1.0082463026,
0.4591095746,
0.0186321307,
-0.491553098,
-0.2925281227,
-0.4833079278,
-1.170157671,
0.6211001277,
-0.2159828693,
-0.5009426475,
-0.2570771873,
0.2404669374,
0.1483299434,
0.2418980747,
-0.7975638509,
0.8297992349,
-0.0400869921,
-0.3532759249,
0.1158799753,
-0.8214258552,
0.1970478147,
-0.301366806,
0.2114901245,
0.015140661,
-0.3523768783,
0.7623786926,
-0.5635056496,
0.5158376694,
0.0684195757,
-0.0249208603,
0.2047907114,
0.1799475849,
0.6186993718,
-0.3573756814,
-0.3854581416,
0.0282670744,
0.112454392,
-0.517170608,
-0.9114381075,
0.2997688353,
-0.5096117854,
-0.4738048911,
-0.471609354,
-0.4344727397,
-0.2879758775,
0.4651058018,
0.2963810265,
0.2764624953,
-0.5562318563,
0.4033793807,
0.2655345798,
0.0022947341,
0.2833823562,
0.6588662267,
-0.3982158303,
-0.6883383989,
0.8418698311,
-0.0327563807,
0.2074895948,
0.6281800866,
0.4910057187,
0.108158417,
-0.7664842606,
-0.7968191504,
0.1593812853,
-0.4087714255,
-0.2515416145,
-0.6313766241,
0.211712569,
-0.032393191,
-0.1554325819,
-0.6356891394,
-0.6064969301,
0.1059110835,
-0.0754043385,
0.0591214187,
0.8159723282,
0.301312387,
0.6699466705,
-1.0536113977,
0.0400191769,
-0.2278220803,
0.397823602,
-0.1955194026,
-0.4328236282,
-0.536873281,
-0.1456426233,
-0.537550509,
-0.7044399977,
0.1612413079,
0.0232553147,
0.3908583224,
0.2795946002,
0.1467386782,
1.0296882391,
-0.8066128492,
0.960282445,
0.4151943028,
-1.119135499,
0.6805249453,
-0.2816095948,
0.4248891175,
0.5368467569,
0.0579965301,
-0.908164978,
-0.6907376647,
-0.5782904029,
-0.9227443337,
0.4653570652,
0.4306646883,
0.2524928749,
0.001278501,
0.2042782605,
0.1452936381,
0.2899315655,
-0.4148544669,
-0.4164269269,
-0.2145011127,
-0.1320457608,
-0.1864783019,
-0.2228737324,
-0.0688108206,
-0.0971746445,
0.5026276708,
-0.0789529085,
0.05500881,
0.3348204195,
-0.2508303821,
-0.0137267215,
0.4273400009,
0.6068834662,
0.9444280267,
-0.2052175999,
0.3999867737,
0.4160620272,
-0.64370507,
0.1142190099,
-0.1672390252,
-0.331864208,
0.3728453219,
0.3554164469,
0.5745138526,
0.11648684,
-0.6885952353,
0.4919876456,
-0.1898498237,
0.1378202289,
-0.1537213624,
-0.1505637914,
-0.0298381746,
-0.2231836617,
0.3517855704,
0.2475355417,
0.3575752676,
-0.3533507884,
0.0255619977,
0.298066467,
-0.6868241429,
-0.5511123538,
0.7002262473,
0.5434036851,
-0.4175052047,
0.1407676041,
-0.4185023308,
-0.2152357101,
0.2830739319,
0.8343838453,
0.9794054627,
-0.3109292984,
-0.0849947929,
0.4066914916,
0.4631929696,
0.0261878185,
0.0252805911,
-0.0334263183,
-0.5167917013,
-0.4274546206,
-0.6446128488,
-0.5471619368,
-0.0071005612,
-0.7890759706,
0.5492110848,
-0.2659909725,
-0.3796010315,
-0.0385249481,
-0.1147702411,
-0.4216184318,
0.2655890882,
-0.5322941542,
0.8123783469,
-0.4459792972,
0.5061937571,
1.2617692947,
-0.4529352784,
-0.4709270597,
0.0318142995,
-0.1386104673,
-0.1848676652,
0.557054162,
-0.0841046795,
-0.5954846144,
-0.0560281686,
-0.3094016612,
-0.7976697087,
1.1416738033,
0.1265931576,
-0.2074691355,
0.072452046,
0.0036865149,
0.814078033,
-0.1696287245,
0.3908066452,
0.4895924032,
0.4519445002,
0.2225037515,
-1.1514656544,
0.0174162779,
-0.3967055678,
0.3211466372,
0.5846705437,
-0.802847445,
0.5668256879,
-0.2472865582,
-0.3197889626,
0.149797529,
0.7630056143,
-0.0363869444,
0.4644449055,
0.236883834,
0.1693022549,
0.9609088898,
-0.1014700308,
1.1681172848,
-0.0592087731,
0.3774499297,
1.2852543592,
-0.0721480101,
0.9873343706,
0.7683300376,
-0.2755089402,
0.5596928596,
0.350337714,
-0.1842640489,
0.2382093966,
0.4426995814,
0.0166919213,
0.0482239537,
-0.1873280108,
-0.3153056502,
0.4554449916,
0.1765604317,
-0.2814660668,
-0.2636565268,
-0.1871507317,
0.2918501496,
0.0787323639,
-0.0893679187,
0.7843128443,
-0.1603931636,
-0.5915565491,
0.4499494135,
0.4862854779,
0.6013928652,
-0.5808736086,
0.0966730341,
-0.3435235322,
0.3024036288,
-0.2958624065,
-0.3560089469,
0.6393541694,
0.3569970131,
-0.2485096157,
-0.1925915331,
0.6923398972,
-0.0457988977,
-0.6224182844,
-0.0194002818,
0.7385585904,
0.4148464203,
0.0613219477,
-0.1451619416,
-0.1398412883,
-0.1694906503,
-0.2632599175,
0.0901497081,
0.8232988715,
-0.3451289535,
0.6534408927,
0.6596873999,
0.1201670691,
0.0232403483,
-0.0144143598,
0.6750920415,
-1.0574756861,
-0.1902381629,
-0.8557008505,
0.7753587365,
-0.3177473247,
-0.430159837,
0.949760437,
1.0298603773,
0.8234883547,
-0.2002570182,
0.799968183,
-0.1619900018,
0.4383704364,
-0.2364667654,
0.6863523126,
-0.4897099137,
0.2241761982,
-0.5214245915,
-1.0085016489,
-0.6555172801,
0.4079031646,
-0.1341124326,
-0.2250611633,
1.0787055492,
0.3526524901,
0.0292050205,
-0.3723237514,
0.5015612245,
0.0455428064,
0.3689086139,
0.0069242348,
1.2206676006,
-0.7869973183,
0.9346920848,
0.1137695834,
-0.246166721,
-0.2700884342,
-1.0841559172,
-0.7636199594,
-0.5442224145,
-0.3494834304,
-0.3682539165,
-0.2504756451,
0.614254415,
0.3630368114,
-0.7979264259,
-0.3635539412,
-0.0309076943,
0.1681421846,
-0.3207156956,
-0.181447044,
0.2054178715,
-0.7240656018,
-1.0267552137,
0.0434525199,
0.3105379045,
0.0758980513,
-0.0857511237,
-0.1449183375,
0.2991698086,
0.0236417316,
0.9006026387,
-0.2340661138,
-0.6262735724,
-0.1200496554,
0.178729102,
-0.3086373508,
0.0531445928,
1.1125702858,
-0.6631845236,
0.5705546141,
0.4707499146,
0.5771508813,
0.4148512483,
0.1315274984,
0.7719214559,
-0.727026999,
0.0347164907,
0.016565714,
0.2743216157,
0.5508274436,
0.0468855985,
0.840944171,
0.3977539837,
-0.3579000831,
-0.88547194,
0.0833864436,
-0.9150508642,
0.0784128532,
1.1732624769,
-0.1851394475,
-0.1424798816,
-0.2245294899,
-0.4470582306,
0.2726052701,
-0.1779278368,
0.6754857898,
0.8234260678,
-0.1192105412,
0.3093875945,
-0.3112932146,
0.3167007565,
0.2465658486,
-0.8165151477,
0.0790137649,
0.5595749021,
0.3015268743,
0.5920928121,
0.5919184685,
-0.3682799339,
0.2100763619,
0.1415004283,
0.1781736463,
-0.0636126176,
0.0637918115,
-0.1160896495,
0.0198391844,
0.3306908309,
-0.3094449639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04657v1 | Improving Empathetic Dialogue Generation by Dynamically Infusing Commonsense Knowledge | 2023-05-24T10:25:12 | 2023-05-24T10:25:12 | Hua Cai, Xuli Shen, Qing Xu, Weilin Shen, Xiaomei Wang, Weifeng Ge, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xiangyang Xue | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In empathetic conversations, individuals express their empathy towards
others. Previous work has mainly focused on generating empathetic responses by
utilizing the speaker's emotion. Besides, external commonsense knowledge has
been applied to enhance the system's understandings of the speaker's situation.
However, given an event, commonsense knowledge base contains various relations,
potentially leading to confusion for the dialogue system. Consequently,
inconsistencies arise among the emotion, generated response and speaker's
contextual information. To this end, we propose a novel approach for empathetic
response generation, which incorporates an adaptive module for commonsense
knowledge selection to ensure consistency between the generated empathetic
responses and the speaker's situation. This selected knowledge is used to
refine the commonsense cognition and empathy expression for generated
responses. Experimental results show that our approach significantly
outperforms baseline models in both automatic and human evaluations, exhibiting
the generation of more coherent and empathetic responses. Moreover, case
studies highlight the interpretability of knowledge selection in the responses
and the effectiveness of adaptive module in our model. Code:
https://github.com/Hanscal/DCKS. | [
-0.3321435153,
-0.6260257363,
0.763474822,
0.0110701164,
-0.1940879971,
-0.1644974649,
-0.1483871341,
-0.1351352632,
0.2079843581,
0.1406424493,
-0.6219083071,
-0.2109190971,
-0.3253026307,
0.3120426238,
0.2592853308,
0.8267561197,
0.1793938577,
-0.0768230334,
-0.3102724254,
-0.4008646607,
-0.5175312161,
-0.1107178405,
-0.7788384557,
-0.3714785576,
0.4079573452,
0.5942311883,
0.3053233922,
0.2094712704,
0.2395762801,
0.3121837676,
-0.2206975073,
0.435313791,
-0.3927121162,
0.4396332204,
-0.2972680032,
0.0476933755,
-0.6611261964,
-0.3336918056,
0.1519092917,
0.2425219417,
-0.4934294224,
-0.0516580753,
0.1475227624,
0.4144929945,
-0.6729000807,
-0.1072396412,
-0.7608308792,
0.3192424476,
0.3911272883,
-0.4174748063,
-0.394202292,
-0.1671308875,
0.3323565423,
-0.7786023617,
0.0871698484,
-0.0143171465,
0.2337805629,
0.1992330849,
-0.3717710972,
-0.3969946504,
-0.2774217427,
0.7166867852,
-0.955973208,
0.1310890466,
0.1970059872,
0.3408259451,
0.0407526791,
-0.3908785582,
-0.727729857,
-0.3902308643,
-0.1149446145,
0.6568270922,
-0.2088601738,
-0.0121384384,
0.3338783085,
-0.0161886644,
-0.3445815146,
-0.0647317916,
0.0494617745,
0.0627862662,
0.6332860589,
0.5781030655,
0.1663241833,
-0.3524028659,
-0.2376227081,
0.0252629779,
-0.2778054774,
-0.2240046263,
0.4290992022,
0.2517866194,
-0.3148137629,
0.1750677973,
-0.2731016874,
0.8191742301,
0.576806426,
-0.1242177933,
0.1019986942,
-0.1281027198,
-0.2149986476,
0.1644816846,
0.4169721007,
0.8812114,
0.0595141239,
0.1885032356,
0.0673903674,
-0.0866879821,
0.4772784114,
-0.823338449,
-0.3083781898,
0.4797769189,
-0.3039307594,
-0.5855824351,
-0.2653424442,
-1.0863537788,
-0.594579339,
-0.3041101992,
0.0848405063,
-0.4498528838,
-0.6768907905,
-0.1802433282,
-0.3475186527,
-0.0319305696,
0.6395667195,
-0.9108218551,
0.2832716703,
0.3815310895,
0.7096067667,
0.0887699351,
-0.0733872801,
-0.7369961739,
0.3221210241,
0.0933482125,
0.727442801,
-0.6864085793,
-0.400829047,
0.048722107,
-0.323314935,
0.0345663875,
-0.467363745,
0.302555263,
-0.1133586839,
-0.0258852094,
-0.4058339,
-0.4863936007,
0.3443552554,
0.5777796507,
-0.4545552433,
0.3762640059,
0.2492051274,
-1.0837144852,
0.4013653398,
-0.7621768713,
-0.2562290728,
0.0873553306,
-0.049640961,
-0.1732578725,
0.2299696207,
0.2702237964,
0.4792000353,
-0.0152805494,
0.1912546903,
-0.452449739,
0.0691807866,
0.4152970612,
-0.2762988806,
0.4360946417,
0.5001319051,
-0.1254624873,
-0.0674371719,
-0.7623416781,
-0.279080838,
0.0293755922,
-0.1076576114,
-0.2854748368,
-0.1317108721,
-0.1963104457,
0.0602124371,
-0.1224690378,
-0.8842003942,
-0.1960757375,
-0.3718532324,
0.2484531254,
0.9410881996,
0.3512335718,
0.6434825659,
-0.4805153608,
0.3106442094,
0.4349769652,
0.273226887,
-0.2434393018,
-0.3509414196,
-0.4949724376,
-0.0251241904,
-0.482367456,
0.3777340055,
-0.6874523759,
0.3467885852,
-0.1437886953,
-0.5286663175,
-0.3808591962,
0.002330319,
0.4791198075,
0.9235268831,
0.4023446441,
-0.3743431568,
-0.3947804272,
-0.4639950991,
-0.4163803458,
-0.1697941571,
0.066654548,
0.8149477243,
-0.044030115,
-0.0918472782,
0.8841495514,
-0.6450372934,
0.1325649321,
-0.214431107,
0.156227082,
-0.092393443,
0.4728626311,
0.2572938204,
-0.6855072379,
-0.5301693678,
0.3881189525,
-0.5529587865,
-0.2914590836,
-0.2447182685,
-0.2660005689,
0.2923722565,
0.2122589499,
-0.3858833015,
0.2744429708,
0.4908941686,
-0.4228730798,
0.2122551352,
-0.091785118,
0.3334983289,
-1.4621026516,
0.1165295839,
-0.117783986,
0.0439475998,
-0.680850327,
-0.4289058745,
-0.1270961165,
0.0110891564,
-0.6029154062,
0.8933242559,
-0.2152538747,
0.2052648664,
-0.0455307327,
0.4876151979,
0.0118827643,
0.5193101168,
0.0990151614,
0.0369684957,
0.4401586652,
-0.6440826058,
0.8881288171,
0.7814068198,
-0.0564927347,
1.2242438793,
-0.1937776208,
0.1909418553,
-0.0237828009,
0.338912487,
-0.7373949289,
-0.5645719171,
0.3115175068,
-0.4076084793,
0.3486117125,
-0.2414040118,
-0.0653756782,
-0.2263458669,
-0.0200109202,
0.4348400533,
0.5325658321,
-0.7491118908,
0.8598302603,
0.1098565832,
-0.5169604421,
-0.3958151042,
-0.7319126129,
0.0060838377,
-0.2625307143,
-0.567913115,
-0.2678588033,
-0.2677672505,
-0.5108344555,
-0.0714550018,
-0.1450208277,
0.0054979888,
-0.0598579794,
-0.0587282926,
-0.1961826384,
0.1404133588,
0.3794851005,
0.5201098323,
-0.0933816135,
0.0035679368,
0.1363281459,
0.3489513993,
0.1620217711,
-0.5158835053,
-0.587536931,
0.4660717249,
0.488627553,
0.0458473861,
0.4626079202,
0.6326820254,
0.0293182265,
-0.3351453543,
-0.4863356352,
-0.5071339011,
-0.4833656251,
0.332911551,
-0.3060887456,
-0.7743281722,
0.516946733,
-0.212126866,
0.0045519411,
0.0175632592,
0.7680055499,
0.0964358598,
0.8789128661,
-0.0147518702,
0.3066700697,
0.5307751298,
0.3388519287,
0.3916574121,
-1.187833786,
-0.1297538728,
-0.0011440553,
-0.1795827597,
-0.5327857137,
-0.0937870219,
0.4303386509,
-0.5580655932,
-0.4189993739,
0.0156334974,
-0.5280403495,
0.1387821883,
0.1853843033,
0.4878854752,
0.2082167268,
-0.181599021,
0.0192138944,
0.1000596434,
-0.9505138397,
-0.3283416629,
0.9212622046,
0.2214906663,
0.7510152459,
0.3239436746,
0.9603194594,
0.1155612692,
0.6351767778,
-0.5954526067,
0.4079961181,
0.1798504889,
-0.1745348722,
-0.2041666806,
-0.6788370013,
-0.7219638228,
0.0137147438,
-0.1796650589,
-0.764234066,
0.0415742621,
0.5479211211,
-0.7512456775,
0.2393611968,
-0.7517605424,
0.5544678569,
-0.0676707029,
-0.5902497768,
-0.3346464932,
-0.7101597786,
0.2375110537,
-0.1745289713,
0.0429585539,
-0.1803491116,
0.308872968,
0.4784807265,
-0.3622206151,
1.099463582,
-0.4720271826,
-0.1850856245,
0.3184555769,
0.3745484948,
0.491547972,
0.472124666,
-0.2462092936,
-0.4051433206,
-0.1859487444,
-0.381290555,
-0.8362928033,
0.7679299116,
-0.5164616704,
-0.6511886716,
-0.0074922033,
-0.7570652962,
-0.4061549604,
-0.183876425,
0.0794767216,
0.6239193678,
-0.6380850673,
-0.2051629424,
0.6698212028,
-0.6494381428,
0.2998259068,
0.4615421593,
0.4408256114,
-0.6242162585,
0.5884417892,
-0.3739666939,
0.5665565133,
0.303337723,
0.4953382909,
-0.0461479612,
0.0907776281,
-0.4285325706,
-0.0551680401,
-0.7153193951,
-0.6444663405,
-0.8781838417,
0.2210801542,
-0.7060775757,
-0.5965646505,
-0.2620940208,
-0.3768917918,
-0.2079651207,
-0.360188514,
0.769310534,
0.8528510928,
-0.3788306713,
0.1446226388,
-0.9665902853,
0.1479460001,
0.6924120188,
0.2516119778,
0.4172856808,
-0.5993455052,
-0.1553558409,
0.0995579958,
-0.5614897609,
-0.8513609171,
0.4411584139,
0.1476282626,
0.4712409973,
0.5461597443,
0.3120087683,
0.5544323921,
-0.3817010224,
0.7277925611,
0.5002589822,
-0.9913876057,
0.7103892565,
-0.5426838994,
0.2793671787,
0.3867225349,
-0.1127888411,
-0.5676524639,
-0.5729057789,
-1.0981445312,
-0.741925478,
0.6849611402,
0.3074931204,
0.6786549687,
-0.1835443974,
0.1196442768,
0.2537871897,
0.0313151926,
-0.2698263526,
0.316739887,
-0.4208446145,
-0.5034469366,
0.1121740714,
-0.3312779367,
-0.6306367517,
-0.2046031505,
0.419516027,
-0.2684262395,
0.4285758436,
0.3471693099,
0.0909496546,
-0.493912369,
0.2345271409,
0.6994240284,
0.2836982608,
-0.1143483594,
0.0537241958,
0.666605711,
-0.2186411172,
-0.1712337136,
-0.1212229505,
0.4565792978,
-0.2526189089,
0.3331697583,
0.7684005499,
0.2790756226,
-0.6411005259,
0.6403318644,
-0.0698637292,
-0.0372927673,
-0.0772380456,
0.1339586377,
0.1415852159,
0.491761446,
-0.1933519244,
0.1591261774,
0.0336674303,
-0.3646447062,
0.4540978968,
0.0457171649,
-0.0971999094,
-0.3227199614,
0.2217247188,
0.7864979506,
-0.2043081969,
0.6280527711,
-0.031646803,
-0.5435224175,
0.4174994826,
0.6472948194,
0.9839559197,
-0.5310155153,
0.361000061,
0.6186510324,
-0.2221431881,
0.3121169806,
0.2103094757,
-0.5511403084,
-1.0837380886,
0.2266359925,
-0.5887993574,
-0.7731134892,
-0.4381262064,
-0.8274307251,
-0.1217475682,
-0.4178063273,
-0.0593210943,
-0.519924283,
-0.1862326562,
-0.7012145519,
0.2563221753,
0.0392022766,
0.9225662351,
-1.0748482943,
0.4017442167,
0.5688530207,
-0.3338885903,
-0.7430651784,
0.1833744347,
-0.0351745449,
-0.7516265512,
0.4560042024,
-0.1760662645,
0.0156793483,
0.0236827936,
-0.4804195464,
-0.5031083822,
1.2616910934,
0.126725018,
-0.3222123682,
0.4748620987,
-0.0015383132,
0.5341433883,
-0.6131417751,
0.4472048283,
0.4660131633,
0.6173840761,
0.3766694069,
-0.8971569538,
0.2758771777,
-0.3255677819,
0.0519152358,
-0.0632317886,
-0.7243849635,
0.3231323659,
-0.2785042524,
-0.0124342311,
0.3801549971,
0.3100663424,
0.5902134776,
0.6458679438,
0.4138440788,
0.6995791197,
0.7450906634,
0.0472934879,
0.8446187973,
-0.1735768318,
0.0171845648,
1.2135925293,
-0.4534405768,
0.7203933001,
0.6258672476,
0.378637284,
0.4415307045,
0.3572431207,
-0.0001367603,
0.4613126814,
0.0927711949,
-0.7178915739,
-0.1792330295,
-0.3483895063,
-0.0043435474,
0.4242019653,
0.2701380253,
-0.284828186,
-0.2418383509,
0.0440831445,
-0.0045717089,
0.0927525014,
-0.1872582287,
1.1794172525,
0.2378242165,
-0.7762297392,
0.2660780549,
-0.48807621,
0.3484347761,
-0.3365635872,
-0.1284673512,
-0.5074120164,
0.0338163041,
-0.276307404,
-0.8649750948,
0.256102562,
0.2403140813,
0.1339460462,
-0.2761636674,
0.7061198354,
-0.5253593922,
-0.0283852015,
0.2262837738,
0.5593337417,
-0.0737434924,
0.2823249102,
-0.4879775047,
0.0931123421,
-0.0118245194,
-0.3407835662,
0.1939587444,
0.8827770352,
0.4182184041,
0.442459166,
0.4987009764,
-0.1670494229,
-0.2589735985,
0.2446483672,
1.1351866722,
-0.4251790643,
-0.4533424675,
-0.5163434148,
0.9546993971,
-0.4840603471,
-0.3391346335,
0.4052259922,
-0.0284568015,
0.6224064827,
-0.2154126763,
0.8458833694,
-0.2330907136,
0.3321872056,
-0.4052165747,
0.6506165862,
-0.4906677008,
-0.0040370538,
-0.6276423335,
-0.5940012336,
-0.2413562685,
0.599406302,
-0.2783651948,
0.2037832588,
0.5340493321,
0.9252259731,
-0.0695441365,
0.1151869595,
0.7153917551,
0.3623146415,
0.1914559007,
0.7404043674,
1.0894502401,
-0.0122902924,
0.1138561442,
-0.0001249426,
-0.382235527,
-0.1363240778,
-1.1055958271,
-0.729359448,
-0.5200945735,
-0.2167793661,
-0.3629271686,
0.1017322242,
0.9382248521,
0.292134732,
-0.595335722,
-0.0033811484,
-0.2555961907,
-0.1762647182,
-0.0131175099,
-0.2458776385,
0.0607747473,
-0.5029405355,
-0.6247168779,
0.1623090953,
0.3633297086,
-0.0719683766,
0.3251073062,
-0.5681606531,
0.1863339096,
0.3125581145,
0.482491076,
0.0913588479,
-0.4091584682,
-0.3946941197,
-0.2878379822,
0.1870320737,
-0.0042489581,
0.8038604259,
-0.513574779,
0.7078749537,
0.3885357976,
0.4373113215,
0.1182930395,
0.1129377335,
0.8121773005,
-0.7144298553,
0.0287552048,
0.3901558816,
0.2358283699,
0.6066086888,
-0.6253948212,
0.2248034924,
0.2256829441,
-0.4778859019,
-0.7278525829,
0.8078462481,
-1.3327646255,
0.0076840254,
1.4557021856,
-0.1753183305,
0.0022043365,
-0.0659000129,
-0.3951698244,
0.4937064648,
-0.6862891912,
0.9608274102,
0.2842694819,
-0.4684533477,
-0.2310652137,
0.1970486343,
0.6084252596,
0.4517036974,
-0.7765473127,
0.4239840209,
0.499789834,
0.2166187614,
0.056513276,
0.5022166967,
0.1336927712,
0.3933399022,
0.2545246482,
-0.0855636895,
0.0073525719,
0.0549695529,
-0.1195869818,
-0.1016914919,
-0.1081883386,
0.2464695275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14989v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14989v2 | Dolphin: A Challenging and Diverse Benchmark for Arabic NLG | 2023-05-24T10:24:10 | 2023-10-24T17:48:43 | El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, AbdelRahim Elmadany, Ahmed El-Shangiti, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Dolphin, a novel benchmark that addresses the need for a natural
language generation (NLG) evaluation framework dedicated to the wide collection
of Arabic languages and varieties. The proposed benchmark encompasses a broad
range of 13 different NLG tasks, including dialogue generation, question
answering, machine translation, summarization, among others. Dolphin comprises
a substantial corpus of 40 diverse and representative public datasets across 50
test splits, carefully curated to reflect real-world scenarios and the
linguistic richness of Arabic. It sets a new standard for evaluating the
performance and generalization capabilities of Arabic and multilingual models,
promising to enable researchers to push the boundaries of current
methodologies. We provide an extensive analysis of Dolphin, highlighting its
diversity and identifying gaps in current Arabic NLG research. We also offer a
public leaderboard that is both interactive and modular and evaluate several
models on our benchmark, allowing us to set strong baselines against which
researchers can compare. | [
-1.0137578249,
-0.7578575611,
-0.1286989003,
0.41304335,
-0.3955203593,
0.2506984174,
-0.1503429413,
-0.7129372954,
-0.1305797696,
0.5043482184,
-0.5179145336,
-0.7803090215,
-0.8716518283,
0.7112594247,
-0.1727708578,
1.1668186188,
0.2740184069,
-0.1974623203,
0.4432682395,
-0.6657236218,
-0.3407457173,
-0.1058917344,
-0.9757634997,
-0.0079177087,
0.5580080152,
0.0494065508,
1.0347651243,
0.5367352962,
0.1718126535,
0.2202434838,
-0.1624360085,
0.6417763829,
-0.2488116175,
0.3259555995,
-0.2470834255,
0.1611443311,
-0.3499124348,
-0.1667850763,
0.6024365425,
1.1405900717,
-0.0523122251,
0.454490155,
-0.0858287439,
1.1534757614,
-0.9577094316,
0.040617045,
-0.4713914096,
0.2748373449,
-0.2353169173,
0.3147596419,
-0.0951118097,
-0.6806034446,
0.424672693,
-0.3524415493,
0.1716827303,
0.0257056709,
0.701446116,
0.1571677476,
-0.9243912101,
-0.399900049,
-0.4060020149,
0.8707177639,
-0.7312182188,
0.3058466315,
0.2177060395,
0.5221511722,
-0.2014019489,
-0.7235795259,
-0.4079967737,
-0.4685455263,
0.5469741225,
0.2545542717,
-0.2786487937,
-0.0294995569,
-0.0208528601,
0.4530931413,
-0.6067290306,
-0.1231985986,
0.114408344,
-0.0356730409,
0.7137328386,
-0.0247741714,
0.5235263705,
0.0107218735,
-0.1245502159,
-0.2622461915,
-0.8211244941,
-0.0621226244,
0.7695526481,
0.6149788499,
-0.1241437122,
0.6361777186,
-0.2853854299,
0.927454412,
-0.3443001211,
0.2380237728,
0.2190612853,
-0.2802496254,
0.0777043104,
0.44582057,
0.8764768243,
0.6390303373,
0.1806294769,
-0.0502790064,
-0.259516418,
-0.2879069746,
0.4810716212,
-0.686681807,
0.1317599565,
0.0303607304,
-0.4586521983,
-0.2267862409,
-0.0173252486,
-0.9526260495,
-0.4421008527,
0.2254045159,
0.1239823475,
-0.2213250846,
-0.4647502601,
0.2799576819,
-0.1081097871,
0.2328424901,
0.2076491416,
-0.8202028275,
0.6109893322,
0.6954935789,
0.7887390852,
-0.363145411,
-0.1503611952,
-0.5603225827,
0.1507757306,
-0.6485751867,
0.395008415,
-0.4757375717,
-0.5624498129,
0.4169436693,
-0.5647419095,
0.1297284663,
-0.8408370614,
0.8264634013,
-0.481177479,
0.232188642,
-0.2681789696,
-0.6209191084,
-0.4690431356,
0.201456517,
-1.0015977621,
1.2006084919,
0.1478976905,
-0.8066052794,
0.47785905,
-0.8143178821,
-0.4729841948,
0.2365523726,
-0.107355915,
-0.5428595543,
0.2484170645,
0.328356266,
0.0454330444,
-0.7936249971,
0.3813888133,
-0.2253252417,
-0.2894714475,
0.170489952,
-0.2905245721,
0.6815732718,
0.4363947511,
-0.4756751657,
0.0513572358,
-0.9930887818,
0.2978977859,
-0.0680857599,
-0.4772973061,
-0.0809043199,
0.0173467267,
0.3348930776,
0.1085506901,
0.2666589618,
-0.6332403421,
0.2459421009,
-0.2986260056,
-0.076457724,
0.2951056361,
0.073211588,
-0.0780507028,
-0.624787271,
0.5909034014,
-0.3071282506,
-0.148342222,
0.0902430713,
-0.9294195771,
-0.6291162968,
-0.1724624634,
0.3928686082,
0.2149381042,
-0.4683914781,
0.5196020007,
-0.1016070545,
-0.5721650124,
-0.8214842677,
0.0291055795,
0.474958688,
0.3504678011,
0.4954506457,
-0.5159593225,
-0.7032572627,
-1.0452359915,
-0.4951967299,
-0.0451673307,
-0.0963234603,
0.5211004019,
0.3570211232,
-0.2738037705,
0.7324547172,
0.0923211575,
-0.1811833084,
-0.6505567431,
0.7059160471,
0.4595429599,
0.3667995036,
0.5628753901,
-0.7921228409,
-0.5150431395,
0.1546937525,
-0.7448843122,
-0.317984432,
0.1215054244,
0.2213480622,
0.3798976541,
0.1726709455,
-0.4131051302,
0.2955830693,
0.7739722133,
-0.2417424172,
0.7198748589,
-0.2072753161,
0.2014773041,
-0.8062194586,
0.2238459885,
-0.1964112818,
0.1292927414,
-0.7353750467,
0.1996723711,
-0.2557100058,
-0.250521332,
-0.4512343407,
0.7562802434,
-0.1873141527,
-0.3378278911,
-0.3795337081,
-0.0005208393,
-0.2512878776,
0.0438347608,
0.0317687616,
1.0057100058,
0.4588192403,
-0.7257640958,
0.2099420428,
0.2127903849,
-0.5078644753,
-0.0159492325,
-1.0043879747,
0.4038377106,
0.1283097863,
0.0682326481,
-0.7760760188,
0.0183291771,
-0.0294800699,
-0.1760149151,
-0.1038029864,
-0.2014824897,
-0.5128970146,
-0.0591235943,
-0.2491415441,
0.6868540645,
0.4634566903,
-0.4127789736,
0.6073818207,
0.2873308063,
-0.3400014043,
-0.8935477734,
-0.1928858012,
0.3698843122,
-0.288454026,
-0.5907335877,
0.4134272635,
0.1776308417,
-0.320183903,
-0.0486427806,
-0.2574861348,
0.0377691835,
0.282816112,
0.1137784123,
-0.0746886507,
-0.5734360218,
-0.0874380246,
0.1700627953,
-0.0293579008,
0.0298835505,
-0.3917699158,
0.7334963083,
-0.4545647204,
-0.361936748,
0.1126138344,
0.4885185063,
0.3926920593,
-0.4757409394,
0.7153475285,
0.9411637187,
-0.1536049396,
-0.268861562,
-0.5127928853,
0.245594874,
-0.4625778794,
0.4966420233,
-0.4441125393,
-0.787895143,
0.4712421894,
-0.3491846025,
0.0853836089,
0.3549775183,
0.4616499245,
0.3428217471,
1.1846210957,
0.5824472904,
-0.1833472252,
-0.1820114404,
0.1229515448,
0.1345129907,
-0.7519536614,
0.0343144946,
-0.5657829642,
-0.1914983541,
-0.9243118167,
-0.1876930892,
0.3245812953,
0.4608168006,
-0.32277897,
0.1036379114,
-0.3422346413,
0.3128875792,
0.5253295302,
-0.4816689491,
0.2413461357,
-0.2063980401,
-0.5777955055,
-0.0828075781,
-0.5538368821,
-0.9563269019,
1.3800961971,
-0.0991659984,
0.2213906646,
0.7094516754,
0.8625953197,
0.8232973218,
0.2721883059,
-0.3395752013,
0.5799517035,
-0.1629249454,
-0.5751698613,
-0.3189301491,
-0.330019325,
-1.3394885063,
0.4476488233,
-0.1121801734,
-0.7282506227,
-0.3842047453,
-0.3114717007,
-0.129313916,
0.2728257775,
-0.1009000316,
0.8997149467,
-0.1019058526,
-0.4258080721,
-0.1636875123,
-0.4945943654,
0.3171196282,
-0.0717243627,
0.1544581354,
-0.6455645561,
-0.4207600057,
0.7774912715,
-0.3956657946,
0.4546115696,
-0.2118419558,
-0.0522017069,
0.3379903734,
0.1784105897,
0.050968416,
0.0592775345,
-0.3947457373,
0.0751770437,
-0.3579231799,
-0.6711649299,
-0.2642776668,
0.4246069789,
-1.0995055437,
-0.3320129514,
-0.6482329369,
-0.5896998048,
-0.5631611347,
0.2272377163,
0.0686998218,
0.1291875243,
-0.4654324651,
0.03521467,
0.3220432699,
-0.7645925879,
0.4566083252,
0.6658907533,
-0.6087151766,
-0.6631394625,
0.9309514165,
-0.3870328367,
0.0332045406,
0.1844113916,
0.1451539844,
-0.7294816971,
-0.9916494489,
-0.5876976848,
-0.0255829617,
-0.5768460035,
0.0975609496,
-0.4280973375,
-0.1539085656,
-0.1775367856,
0.0684559569,
-0.5444076061,
-0.352040261,
0.1776779443,
0.0510375984,
0.1050962359,
1.1139775515,
-0.0646437705,
-0.0338517055,
-0.9474412203,
0.4531906247,
0.4339778125,
0.1227834374,
-0.0688309371,
-0.3007487357,
0.1248658746,
-0.0358136743,
-0.369859755,
-0.6817312837,
0.4833008945,
0.5814138651,
0.6282305717,
0.265693903,
0.1864494234,
0.5207235217,
-0.4686942101,
0.91591084,
0.1813874543,
-1.103320241,
0.6114634275,
-0.5742615461,
0.5645090342,
0.6642481089,
0.5727582574,
-0.8998569846,
-0.5640165806,
-0.4743655324,
-1.2183058262,
0.3167437911,
0.4189153016,
0.0317703187,
-0.303678304,
0.1627813131,
0.4962974787,
0.4244874418,
-0.4187245667,
-0.4188325107,
-0.2957710028,
-0.1041724831,
-0.0434664413,
-0.1319668293,
-0.0321196318,
0.0564461537,
0.5087606311,
-0.2871723175,
-0.1010816619,
-0.0682281777,
-0.2307598293,
0.0881623328,
0.3072890639,
0.7207531333,
0.6680941582,
-0.4084555507,
0.1519988328,
0.212863028,
-0.5201662779,
0.2394144237,
0.1857967228,
-0.233318761,
0.2032788098,
0.5901899338,
0.4863438308,
0.1991811395,
-1.0247733593,
0.0917870775,
-0.2947446704,
-0.0914112404,
-0.0454549417,
0.13389346,
0.0869194344,
-0.0629649535,
0.7586293817,
-0.0245822892,
0.2502431273,
-0.3715849817,
0.3278939426,
0.1081263721,
-0.3146737814,
0.0408938341,
0.677603662,
0.2262843549,
-0.3506285548,
0.7148805857,
-0.5134472251,
-0.2312476486,
0.7503247857,
0.606477499,
0.9601979852,
-0.0071147275,
0.4143707156,
0.6050673723,
0.0543146282,
0.1453538686,
0.4856797457,
-0.1730026007,
-0.9746073484,
-0.3269077837,
-0.8150119781,
-0.7565444112,
0.2141585797,
-0.9764782786,
-0.2991473973,
-0.6355340481,
-0.4691518247,
0.1006732285,
0.3240738511,
-0.4985727966,
0.0499100909,
0.3764781058,
0.9197708964,
-0.4855853617,
0.8405718207,
0.8795858026,
-0.4005203843,
-0.2921911478,
-0.1419626325,
0.0857428983,
-0.7857146859,
0.9243448973,
0.4280599058,
-0.5082283616,
-0.1418866068,
0.0176431853,
-0.7125829458,
0.6442106962,
0.2540304363,
-0.331830591,
0.3692097962,
0.5976523161,
0.6112323403,
-0.6149277091,
0.3754765093,
0.5496122241,
0.5619565845,
-0.2617521286,
-0.9162880778,
0.0363853462,
-0.592589438,
0.4053558707,
-0.0207344424,
-0.4431584775,
0.8734112978,
-0.1196768507,
-0.1445851475,
0.4264396727,
0.6722884774,
0.6492554545,
0.0383517109,
0.383489728,
0.5575767159,
0.7682134509,
-0.2665384114,
1.1409885883,
-0.5941776633,
0.0652747229,
1.1576032639,
-0.6659908891,
0.669829011,
0.2311302125,
-0.3394246399,
0.3143765628,
0.4781394899,
-0.0042583547,
0.6124579906,
0.5523943901,
-0.7316628695,
-0.0397073776,
-0.5786173344,
-0.6160921454,
0.4871065319,
0.2095704675,
0.0330844112,
-0.5120714903,
-0.1684394181,
-0.1789973378,
0.2819047272,
-0.1848397851,
0.7825644612,
-0.1187622324,
-0.8295176029,
0.8114694953,
0.181295678,
0.4858908057,
-0.7316036224,
-0.1597425938,
-0.3448792696,
0.1511212587,
0.150063768,
-0.6664193273,
0.2658675611,
0.1183946505,
0.364035219,
-0.1372916102,
0.4106306434,
-0.1963102221,
-0.3014281988,
0.4451350868,
0.6684152484,
0.1801923066,
-0.0257565528,
-0.8547406197,
0.3879607618,
0.0632640123,
-0.0959084705,
0.1850462556,
0.4962492585,
0.1212314889,
0.9909673333,
0.5987536907,
0.2568345666,
0.4254374206,
0.4824552834,
0.3871047795,
-0.8147613406,
-0.2171875238,
-0.7275429964,
0.2862524688,
-0.2635244429,
-1.0006974936,
0.9475488067,
0.8977311254,
0.8580541015,
-0.1460039616,
0.9215611815,
0.0469075516,
0.3177008033,
-0.3175193667,
0.8216531873,
-0.302128315,
0.1053981408,
-0.2224639952,
-1.0167437792,
-0.2440249175,
0.6524851322,
-0.0233329702,
0.233569026,
0.4623890519,
0.409591645,
0.2677949369,
0.4691899717,
0.3532806933,
-0.2167185098,
0.4948272407,
0.534937501,
1.2026875019,
-0.4147951901,
0.289231956,
-0.1870496273,
0.2175171822,
-0.1466783881,
-1.0136047602,
-0.9792327285,
-0.4717792869,
-0.4847453237,
-0.0828219578,
0.4062465131,
1.1481580734,
0.5874443054,
-1.0380246639,
-0.681368947,
-0.3644227087,
0.0340219326,
-0.5155438185,
-0.1555399299,
0.3662558496,
-0.4270483851,
-0.6442786455,
0.493005693,
0.3944268823,
0.1846351922,
-0.0594813377,
-0.3558373451,
-0.2941398919,
-0.0729015917,
0.4650842249,
0.4932635725,
-0.8063963652,
-0.1984398365,
-0.510266602,
-0.1086857468,
-0.1159499511,
0.507615447,
-0.6825088859,
0.4524598718,
-0.1412953287,
0.9680814147,
0.7923206687,
-0.314450711,
0.8815361857,
-0.7978290915,
0.2372582406,
0.6234146953,
0.3107046187,
0.3867114484,
0.4710685909,
0.7163591385,
-0.2572154105,
-0.2446048111,
-0.7410746217,
0.4649004936,
-0.8502043486,
-0.1184699759,
0.7307456136,
-0.3908793032,
0.1486968249,
-0.4554930627,
-0.1336112022,
0.265422672,
-0.4652961791,
1.0294469595,
0.6708376408,
-0.0748914182,
-0.0760627016,
-0.571475625,
0.7100145817,
0.6450064182,
-0.8658087254,
-0.1165920645,
0.2284424454,
0.0520698689,
0.1334882826,
0.2495121211,
-0.0353733301,
0.498524487,
0.1058392972,
0.1108673885,
-0.0065456918,
-0.0505919494,
-0.1877301037,
0.4647949338,
0.3131479919,
-0.0000850738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14987v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14987v2 | Investigating Table-to-Text Generation Capabilities of LLMs in Real-World Information Seeking Scenarios | 2023-05-24T10:22:30 | 2023-10-30T22:00:25 | Yilun Zhao, Haowei Zhang, Shengyun Si, Linyong Nan, Xiangru Tang, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tabular data is prevalent across various industries, necessitating
significant time and effort for users to understand and manipulate for their
information-seeking purposes. The advancements in large language models (LLMs)
have shown enormous potential to improve user efficiency. However, the adoption
of LLMs in real-world applications for table information seeking remains
underexplored. In this paper, we investigate the table-to-text capabilities of
different LLMs using four datasets within two real-world information seeking
scenarios. These include the LogicNLG and our newly-constructed LoTNLG datasets
for data insight generation, along with the FeTaQA and our newly-constructed
F2WTQ datasets for query-based generation. We structure our investigation
around three research questions, evaluating the performance of LLMs in
table-to-text generation, automated evaluation, and feedback generation,
respectively. Experimental results indicate that the current high-performing
LLM, specifically GPT-4, can effectively serve as a table-to-text generator,
evaluator, and feedback generator, facilitating users' information seeking
purposes in real-world scenarios. However, a significant performance gap still
exists between other open-sourced LLMs (e.g., Tulu and LLaMA-2) and GPT-4
models. Our data and code are publicly available at
https://github.com/yale-nlp/LLM-T2T. | [
-0.1945839077,
-0.9792998433,
0.7635394931,
-0.001836199,
-0.3415403068,
-0.1413101256,
-0.1766821742,
-0.6014043689,
-0.1600613445,
0.5109605789,
-0.6614727974,
-0.7919386625,
-0.2045523226,
0.2641861439,
-0.618362546,
1.1143336296,
-0.1080953777,
-0.2837027907,
-0.2451862395,
0.2985957265,
-0.7174936533,
-0.5779895782,
-0.2736857831,
-0.1462707371,
0.6605485082,
0.682887435,
0.7043446898,
0.5531736016,
0.4856108129,
0.1014524996,
0.2307968438,
0.2702063322,
-0.7194977403,
0.3515274227,
-0.0708620921,
-0.6095446944,
-0.2615749836,
0.0413701683,
0.6544906497,
0.2338797897,
-0.1744277179,
0.2288903743,
0.0653525069,
0.8486337662,
-0.3968948722,
0.3271814585,
-0.9042236805,
0.3936012685,
-0.4706044495,
-0.2880358994,
-0.5023611784,
-0.6497611403,
0.3182527125,
-0.6769084334,
0.1790887415,
0.3960967064,
0.7020930052,
-0.0147525081,
-0.4663505554,
-0.725759685,
-0.7543528676,
0.5012194514,
-0.7776787877,
0.6372923255,
0.3453414738,
0.2186243236,
-0.5034874678,
-0.9461405277,
-0.7684102058,
-0.3783897161,
-0.1281502247,
0.1729050577,
-0.0852544531,
-0.2236931324,
0.3402436078,
0.34437868,
-0.8412123919,
0.0148689812,
-0.0224217046,
0.0865297318,
0.3367179036,
0.2495119125,
0.0583896451,
-0.3240995705,
-0.2913377285,
-0.0108327242,
-0.8915022016,
-0.190448001,
0.2287711799,
0.3109738231,
-0.0321017466,
0.8117657304,
-0.2410023212,
0.7072508335,
-0.2982448936,
0.0921240821,
0.0170852672,
-0.6005718708,
-0.1076229736,
-0.0298773199,
0.6265806556,
0.3268473446,
0.1605083346,
-0.4204018414,
-0.4152859449,
-0.1822622567,
0.3076558709,
-0.7883880138,
-0.0585425422,
0.0589697622,
-0.320032984,
-0.3965895772,
0.1005665585,
-0.8312955499,
-0.4073862135,
-0.1776891798,
0.4405249059,
-0.2167070508,
-0.1081176177,
-0.219946444,
-0.041087646,
0.4355129898,
0.3151189387,
-0.6630636454,
0.1198197827,
0.5888390541,
0.9805682898,
-0.5769350529,
-0.0017269508,
-0.6330525279,
0.417296499,
-0.3986063004,
0.8532643318,
-0.3801547885,
-0.5308121443,
0.3422261775,
-0.3437393904,
0.0742587298,
-0.6757971048,
0.6611477137,
-0.7150192857,
0.2696441114,
-0.54775846,
-0.4949797988,
0.1719515771,
0.5501862168,
-0.8415468335,
1.1617777348,
0.0606516637,
-0.7401723862,
0.6392496824,
-0.7731792331,
-0.4467911124,
0.1876112819,
-0.6187935472,
-0.6520379782,
0.1599994451,
0.056799192,
0.5653435588,
-0.7765116692,
0.383310765,
0.0075198123,
-0.3599675894,
0.5714156628,
-0.5877871513,
-0.1509288847,
0.2291915864,
-0.4119872153,
-0.084626317,
-0.6749383807,
0.0693411827,
0.4428385198,
-0.726556778,
0.0882497206,
0.394240886,
0.141356796,
0.2760779858,
0.1510762572,
-0.3912811875,
0.1109406352,
-0.2179497778,
0.2999663949,
0.5110915303,
0.0977513641,
0.0976054892,
-0.4282512367,
0.5229354501,
0.0932063311,
-0.2187753469,
-0.0112114446,
-0.3220423758,
-0.5528952479,
0.3007358015,
0.3987961113,
0.4862406254,
-1.0291941166,
-0.0442304946,
-0.3597483933,
-0.2697598338,
-0.1549662948,
-0.0125524402,
0.3657217324,
0.6222579479,
0.2916772068,
0.2734409273,
-0.3338720202,
-0.8191961646,
-0.4522946775,
-0.1179707199,
-0.2222643793,
0.5996079445,
0.2887919843,
-0.1635409147,
1.0628858805,
-0.5968956351,
-0.2825434208,
-0.5993933678,
0.0016581358,
0.2568858564,
0.1334140003,
0.2064287663,
-0.8555501103,
-0.3885191679,
0.083159633,
-0.8247782588,
-0.0317538008,
-0.0023390236,
-0.1586811244,
0.4075686634,
0.2689383328,
-0.5587347746,
0.5902725458,
0.3831467032,
-0.1406486779,
0.6177764535,
-0.0437176153,
0.0629978254,
-1.1306781769,
0.2678536177,
0.1320774555,
-0.1018355489,
-0.7925111651,
-0.1232564822,
0.0286177378,
-0.2473542541,
-0.3353182375,
0.4618317485,
-0.6061131954,
-0.3702547252,
0.0024388628,
0.5418854356,
-0.0767065957,
0.3524371684,
-0.004814507,
1.0460801125,
-0.025556853,
-0.724828124,
0.1602692902,
0.3492124379,
-0.5610489249,
0.2368121743,
-0.4450517893,
0.1845561415,
0.0320423096,
0.2835341096,
-0.9438883066,
-0.4237031639,
0.1626105011,
-0.2837909162,
0.1562302113,
0.1333691031,
-0.8350017667,
-0.381845504,
-0.4303277433,
0.2213143408,
0.2394549698,
-0.6393598914,
0.3723034859,
0.3138357401,
-0.2476466298,
-0.5088261366,
-0.7565606833,
0.3674379587,
-0.2223529071,
-0.5601485968,
0.3226984441,
0.148295179,
-0.1543967575,
-0.308136642,
-0.2933985591,
0.3079066277,
-0.1730950475,
0.0659734234,
0.3192591965,
0.0243682098,
0.3290130794,
-0.052039016,
0.117112726,
0.1397275031,
-0.3981121182,
0.669184804,
-0.0625163987,
-0.2005668283,
-0.1773343831,
0.1704031527,
0.0384956673,
-0.1142432243,
0.4915745556,
0.5116415024,
-0.3655737638,
-0.3655474782,
-0.7145832181,
-0.2177744955,
-0.5083904266,
0.5231859088,
-0.4348688424,
-0.8511444926,
0.485910207,
-0.2072190791,
0.3101131618,
0.1876301616,
0.536360383,
-0.2669407129,
0.6247433424,
0.2960637212,
0.2392153144,
0.4372070432,
-0.1971291602,
0.1659711748,
-0.6684930921,
-0.4903654456,
-0.5967832804,
-0.3707261086,
-0.7578644156,
-0.2937336862,
0.6182540655,
-0.2314193696,
0.2678704858,
0.044685699,
-0.3166401982,
0.3709688783,
0.5420134068,
0.1992025822,
0.519872725,
0.3061673045,
-0.2406677604,
-0.1204877198,
-0.8401070237,
-0.5395648479,
1.1038774252,
0.1588865072,
0.7732334733,
0.1863871813,
0.4029273987,
0.4961613715,
0.252353549,
-0.6907957792,
0.7689498067,
-0.2251980603,
-0.54902035,
-0.440508157,
-0.7200631499,
-1.0457570553,
0.0685313046,
-0.2824226916,
-0.506062448,
-0.1605313867,
0.3158446252,
0.093628034,
0.1930265725,
-0.4612518549,
0.8470930457,
-0.4105497003,
-0.7436324358,
0.0033560761,
-0.5986149311,
0.3036886156,
-0.283533752,
0.1469400674,
-0.0114103751,
0.0258522518,
0.6489320397,
-0.2826582491,
0.4443054199,
-0.2036872208,
-0.4130442441,
0.3643142283,
0.2254802585,
0.9324225187,
0.18212457,
-0.3831778765,
0.0802944452,
-0.3497178853,
0.1282847375,
-0.4373205602,
0.8199924827,
-0.4635082483,
-0.5603583455,
-0.2926750779,
-0.6292774677,
-0.4127849936,
0.2180937827,
0.417787075,
0.4791921675,
-0.130871281,
0.2942073941,
0.5982551575,
-0.4108264446,
0.4211794436,
0.4708753526,
-0.3961482346,
-0.1070623994,
0.9693036675,
0.3723831475,
0.0658712462,
0.6266795993,
0.1011414155,
-0.6972474456,
-0.6008279324,
-0.6281934381,
0.0912405103,
-0.3411757052,
-0.3393175006,
-0.4408480823,
-0.1147906333,
-0.0913156196,
0.1876747459,
0.0585613474,
-0.3073290884,
-0.5023853183,
-0.1744281203,
0.4766978621,
0.8596957922,
0.388961792,
0.3634076715,
-0.7082957625,
0.3254313767,
0.1925956458,
0.6128036976,
-0.015778007,
-0.3316612244,
-0.3745608032,
0.0406203568,
-0.3675958812,
-0.9973959923,
0.3328199983,
0.1505858898,
0.3582804501,
-0.1038461179,
0.0135839926,
0.4350813031,
-0.3880501688,
0.6044974923,
-0.1439095438,
-0.6445634365,
0.5662304163,
-0.5960378051,
0.336801827,
0.4807939529,
0.2666167915,
-0.5888229012,
-0.2076311111,
-0.027042212,
-0.9519514441,
0.969596386,
0.4414230585,
-0.2530242801,
0.1203449592,
0.7717012763,
0.2810657024,
0.5121716857,
-1.024764657,
0.0946460962,
0.0255256277,
-0.1959747523,
0.3300786018,
-0.1957885325,
0.2284266949,
0.3637017906,
0.5999191999,
-0.038575884,
0.378000468,
0.1331922561,
-0.1703294516,
-0.0871954784,
0.4770118296,
0.4401219487,
0.5737500787,
-0.2101675272,
-0.0024413287,
0.1225489154,
-0.563087821,
-0.0644195676,
0.0957918316,
-0.2927817106,
0.0733635053,
-0.0977555886,
0.8716034293,
-0.0166599452,
-0.7036031485,
0.3289929926,
-0.2442530692,
-0.3188925087,
-0.3716274798,
0.1524189413,
0.0962718725,
0.0778342336,
0.5647451282,
-0.6654899716,
0.2792177796,
-0.6816197634,
0.0929215476,
0.6110441089,
-0.0795779452,
-0.0551079698,
0.6835911274,
0.0636881366,
-0.2947584093,
0.8217150569,
-0.1808376014,
-0.104228206,
0.3150908649,
0.784610033,
0.6409106255,
0.1417089105,
0.0997715294,
-0.0221398734,
0.2826441228,
-0.002980673,
0.4905559719,
-0.1294295192,
-0.5087557435,
-0.2929099798,
-0.5419812799,
-0.5674222708,
0.3714350164,
-0.407381475,
0.3397781849,
-0.1663516015,
-0.4469775259,
-0.2638148367,
-0.002116981,
-0.7396112084,
0.1222865134,
-0.0534323193,
0.6279624104,
-0.2356209457,
0.7318193913,
0.5694403648,
-0.1808594763,
-0.8527539372,
0.2560539246,
-0.0966307819,
-0.6398362517,
0.4387405217,
0.246370405,
0.0841617808,
0.0187832601,
-0.4057629704,
-0.7379994392,
1.3508921862,
0.1979769468,
-0.8816303015,
-0.4766871631,
0.8512001634,
0.4943274856,
-0.0719116181,
0.0573398992,
0.7573994398,
0.5796587467,
-0.0164299216,
-0.7350560427,
0.0758628994,
-0.0825461298,
0.0988259539,
0.4470649958,
-0.5540776253,
0.4643582106,
-0.0545756817,
-0.2158387452,
-0.2701819241,
0.5708730817,
0.551699996,
0.4989239872,
0.3315711617,
0.3431698382,
0.4890090525,
-0.2661339939,
0.8259077072,
-0.1362286657,
0.0125197116,
1.0711727142,
-0.5881461501,
0.9430290461,
0.3264598846,
-0.0903908163,
0.1929261535,
0.4328397512,
-0.1259913594,
0.3658896685,
0.3185394108,
-0.2316057533,
0.2829858959,
-0.0625249967,
-0.2778063416,
0.3040052354,
0.6618350148,
-0.2789925635,
-0.1126546413,
-0.1251627952,
-0.1565627903,
-0.090680778,
-0.182933569,
0.9456992149,
-0.0514799841,
-0.6191096306,
0.3520345986,
0.0420621522,
0.4698903561,
-0.5486814976,
-0.1900949031,
-0.2791486681,
-0.0870132148,
-0.2856321633,
-0.9689930081,
0.0374686979,
0.4097735882,
0.0143615576,
-0.0163516868,
0.8354700208,
-0.3486534655,
-0.3628916442,
0.0771456957,
0.6132728457,
0.2326698154,
0.0071996031,
-0.3898837566,
0.141616717,
0.1998703331,
-0.5358840227,
0.40804106,
0.5747758746,
-0.0815005526,
0.6133868694,
0.6271110773,
0.0369407088,
0.139743343,
-0.0328424908,
0.7881448269,
-0.7867715359,
-0.3726664782,
-0.8558517098,
0.1953065693,
0.1350298077,
-0.2361999005,
0.6344942451,
0.9359232783,
0.6946894526,
-0.0619461723,
0.9255334735,
0.0870643035,
0.6780054569,
-0.7648102045,
0.6285735965,
-0.5691891909,
0.512329638,
-0.4033806026,
-1.1239184141,
-0.1106116325,
0.3198562562,
-0.2282468081,
0.1556968987,
0.4508851767,
0.5994176865,
0.1807861626,
0.2473948896,
0.2785619497,
0.2667063773,
0.5767831802,
0.4286962152,
0.9253809452,
-0.213812843,
0.8645865917,
0.2144958377,
0.0288557243,
-0.3171820045,
-0.8613780141,
-0.6538522243,
-0.4563729167,
0.2566002607,
-0.2260021567,
0.2435148209,
0.8002361059,
0.1847442687,
-0.3952776194,
-0.3921143413,
-0.4028539658,
-0.1590737849,
0.4377280772,
-0.2651653588,
0.3841672242,
-0.2025341392,
-0.3609127104,
0.2912960947,
0.2670401037,
0.1453905255,
-0.1894116998,
0.136588037,
-0.1071975306,
0.0146589372,
0.6154753566,
0.1082527339,
-0.4503308237,
-0.0045024552,
0.1725698262,
-0.0893318206,
0.1946018189,
0.7824049592,
-0.8407241106,
0.0498188213,
0.3350273073,
0.6841542125,
0.9685661197,
0.2055638283,
0.5886489153,
-0.8657838106,
-0.2540480196,
0.2621824443,
0.0193814058,
0.2267111242,
-0.527656436,
0.6763160229,
-0.0842764452,
-0.7963930964,
-0.8076150417,
0.0911325738,
-0.7923089862,
0.0335964411,
1.1927047968,
0.2243681997,
0.1118860543,
0.0708218738,
-0.1916662157,
0.3790048957,
-0.6497892141,
0.9240761399,
0.4732385874,
-0.3353582323,
0.0521955043,
-0.915332675,
0.5893651843,
0.3153501749,
-1.2688145638,
0.3747315407,
0.7070578933,
-0.0493584722,
-0.1733057946,
0.3701163232,
-0.1469936967,
0.2009585202,
-0.2926187217,
-0.1087420732,
0.012249792,
-0.2887672782,
0.052913703,
0.2478976101,
0.184684217,
0.1672185361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14985v1 | IdealGPT: Iteratively Decomposing Vision and Language Reasoning via Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T10:19:57 | 2023-05-24T10:19:57 | Haoxuan You, Rui Sun, Zhecan Wang, Long Chen, Gengyu Wang, Hammad A. Ayyubi, Kai-Wei Chang, Shih-Fu Chang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | The field of vision-and-language (VL) understanding has made unprecedented
progress with end-to-end large pre-trained VL models (VLMs). However, they
still fall short in zero-shot reasoning tasks that require multi-step
inferencing. To achieve this goal, previous works resort to a
divide-and-conquer pipeline. In this paper, we argue that previous efforts have
several inherent shortcomings: 1) They rely on domain-specific sub-question
decomposing models. 2) They force models to predict the final answer even if
the sub-questions or sub-answers provide insufficient information. We address
these limitations via IdealGPT, a framework that iteratively decomposes VL
reasoning using large language models (LLMs). Specifically, IdealGPT utilizes
an LLM to generate sub-questions, a VLM to provide corresponding sub-answers,
and another LLM to reason to achieve the final answer. These three modules
perform the divide-and-conquer procedure iteratively until the model is
confident about the final answer to the main question. We evaluate IdealGPT on
multiple challenging VL reasoning tasks under a zero-shot setting. In
particular, our IdealGPT outperforms the best existing GPT-4-like models by an
absolute 10% on VCR and 15% on SNLI-VE. Code is available at
https://github.com/Hxyou/IdealGPT | [
-0.5435882211,
-0.7001932263,
0.9717229605,
-0.1790906936,
-0.3924703598,
0.1016145423,
-0.1663962156,
-0.3760174513,
-0.2707591653,
0.5345447659,
-0.4355631173,
-0.3757825792,
-0.5379999876,
-0.281637013,
-0.5147078633,
0.8929453492,
-0.3466790915,
-0.0288466886,
-0.3149799407,
-0.0179555602,
-0.1765462756,
-0.511015296,
-0.5962339044,
-0.5553645492,
0.1454634517,
0.3201812804,
0.3911214471,
0.6912825704,
0.5048146248,
0.1687515974,
-0.0928801894,
0.1129014269,
-0.5482552648,
-0.0482702851,
-0.1688999385,
-0.3701317906,
-0.0994129628,
-0.1610907316,
0.6593953967,
0.5682940483,
-0.2239970565,
0.1696339697,
-0.1665650606,
0.4990037978,
-0.6870132685,
0.2832264006,
-0.7736142278,
0.1706762463,
-0.0298926346,
-0.0552620739,
-0.4039818048,
-0.0523994379,
0.0240214914,
-0.4711709321,
0.2318058908,
0.0286725052,
0.9324523807,
0.3256899416,
-0.2085226625,
-0.0110607129,
-0.7397003174,
0.6257303357,
-0.5790604353,
0.4336695373,
0.1961589754,
0.3335882425,
0.2204097807,
-0.6165353656,
-0.7551016212,
-0.3556304574,
0.2152104378,
0.3407864571,
-0.2975557745,
0.1683591008,
0.17784895,
0.3019125164,
-0.7484712005,
-0.0137445861,
-0.4218891859,
0.0319159888,
0.2233567685,
0.2412626743,
0.1587459594,
-0.0515389293,
-0.3867700398,
0.0210726652,
-0.8974990845,
-0.0059904852,
0.1040325686,
0.0238973349,
0.3126453459,
0.7072740793,
-0.2564221323,
0.9640347958,
-0.0825213119,
0.025980955,
-0.1483899653,
-0.2712086737,
-0.3657419086,
-0.0818730518,
0.4294713438,
0.2759237289,
0.5333319306,
-0.1037302017,
-0.1697221994,
0.2410144955,
0.2543822527,
-0.74528265,
-0.4263880253,
0.3425169885,
-0.1161700934,
-0.023394445,
-0.1106872112,
-0.1865659058,
-0.0174003746,
-0.4364956319,
0.593177557,
-0.6788449287,
-0.2838961184,
0.5056007504,
0.1450566053,
0.5267133117,
0.684347868,
-0.6035223007,
0.1024616659,
0.8644036651,
0.6738842726,
-0.0211745016,
-0.280829519,
-0.450301528,
-0.1083518639,
-0.5078371167,
0.744641602,
-0.5308291912,
-0.0890492871,
-0.1109614,
-0.2855653167,
-0.3508689106,
-0.6321358681,
0.5367088914,
-0.5626669526,
0.1997798979,
-0.1420050561,
-0.8184656501,
-0.190724507,
0.8903799057,
-0.1936879903,
0.3526368141,
-0.0894895121,
-0.7160057425,
0.1565695852,
-0.5852217674,
-0.1437658817,
0.1379409134,
-0.2680889368,
-0.3027539253,
0.1250315756,
0.3412038386,
0.3853507042,
-0.3590263128,
0.0737428516,
-0.2593996525,
-0.3726072311,
-0.1434444785,
-0.4307389855,
0.7627484798,
0.1677206457,
-0.1383355558,
0.1406500936,
-0.5804015398,
0.183089152,
0.3904020786,
-0.2191018462,
-0.1423711926,
-0.0158173814,
-0.1580587178,
0.1300230175,
0.086738959,
-0.813103497,
0.3372038901,
-0.2490936816,
0.3913211226,
0.7398508191,
-0.2315093279,
0.3131914735,
-0.0399509259,
0.6415353417,
-0.02190754,
0.333807528,
-0.3522280753,
-0.3218087554,
-1.0939270258,
-0.1738803238,
0.0553006902,
0.707141757,
-1.1571705341,
-0.0942829102,
-0.3923548758,
-0.3487773538,
-0.5091067553,
-0.2833709121,
0.5496189594,
0.5328794718,
0.3871994615,
-0.2863844037,
-0.2797966003,
-0.7290301919,
-0.0961114988,
-0.460292697,
-0.0943391621,
0.1074627116,
0.5140177608,
-0.0664870888,
0.7962163091,
-0.5654913187,
-0.3582088649,
-0.4262740314,
-0.1705481708,
0.1318257302,
0.2986636162,
0.3674869537,
-0.8392727375,
-0.4745719433,
0.1191562861,
-0.8323037624,
0.1299488544,
0.0345696025,
0.1192910746,
-0.0920016542,
0.2551605999,
-0.8173963428,
0.4262736738,
0.4462311864,
-0.2128651291,
0.8221734166,
-0.1682714373,
0.111971058,
-0.8092395067,
-0.1606201679,
-0.0286509525,
-0.2975281477,
-0.6764476895,
0.4661259055,
-0.04593895,
0.0372441262,
-0.3282093704,
0.3177493513,
-0.3513631225,
-0.0724884495,
-0.2357950956,
0.0619011521,
-0.0955165774,
0.3642206192,
0.2466106713,
0.5066593289,
0.6653820872,
-0.2094521224,
0.4730842412,
0.0825612247,
-0.3589577377,
0.5082787871,
-0.6413698792,
0.1356770992,
-0.3460747004,
0.1271591187,
-0.9655112028,
-0.1672855616,
0.261259824,
-0.4397318661,
0.2033219039,
-0.4387009442,
-0.3669923842,
-0.3668027222,
-0.1212293208,
0.5441825986,
0.6590288877,
-0.6748301983,
0.3899954557,
0.0908747762,
0.033816535,
-0.6443997025,
-0.468359381,
0.3445092738,
-0.0272138473,
-0.6932029128,
0.2126141787,
-0.1136543602,
-0.4522481561,
0.3702607751,
-0.2881295681,
-0.159831956,
-0.5091474056,
0.0533590801,
0.107081309,
-0.3104449809,
-0.0404925048,
-0.4283403158,
-0.3108727932,
-0.1666616499,
-0.8756420612,
0.6155692935,
-0.5169475675,
-0.7679969668,
-0.0507909916,
0.433229804,
0.561851263,
-0.5384376049,
0.4927136302,
0.5621473789,
-0.2155655175,
-0.2865190208,
-0.5662232041,
0.0772527382,
-0.3521830142,
0.4605433047,
-0.6270215511,
-1.1830121279,
0.3781492412,
0.1383262575,
0.2039359957,
0.2158926576,
0.5477207303,
-0.1025025323,
0.968316853,
0.8197700381,
0.2939456403,
0.3204745352,
-0.4565384984,
0.5251144767,
-0.6310330629,
-0.2195202708,
-0.1431794167,
0.1776832491,
-0.0973405391,
-0.7127492428,
0.4602225423,
0.0955190584,
-0.1815516055,
0.2605328262,
-0.4067213237,
0.7917336822,
0.6403627396,
0.0848769322,
0.4005457461,
0.069668062,
-0.092650339,
0.1184348017,
-0.8698298335,
-0.2594798207,
0.8069264293,
0.1565588415,
0.6937360168,
-0.0789254755,
0.6967211962,
-0.1233033538,
0.2033753842,
-0.9609316587,
0.5981388092,
-0.3467122316,
-0.3902596235,
-0.3644725382,
-0.4397117198,
-0.4803620875,
0.6434279084,
0.3242095411,
-0.8073379397,
-0.0348136127,
0.2842382789,
-0.4114301503,
0.696195662,
-0.5601513982,
0.9256895185,
-0.0274566468,
-0.3771639764,
-0.0834388882,
-0.6521145105,
0.668982029,
-0.0601199456,
-0.0972085595,
-0.047942929,
0.2617572844,
0.2900647819,
-0.6481470466,
0.5997251272,
-0.0680917874,
-0.1215565875,
0.4399348199,
0.3576097786,
0.3274476528,
-0.2128516138,
0.1843242198,
-0.0003788112,
0.0375803933,
-0.4764338434,
-0.5614555478,
0.4687866271,
-0.4000931382,
-0.6225621104,
-0.3285447955,
-0.3937386572,
-0.1522602886,
0.0493050031,
0.4932959378,
0.5922536254,
0.1029405296,
0.0367131755,
0.7975620031,
-0.0912854373,
0.3482573628,
0.2893301249,
-0.3761270344,
-0.1869002283,
0.849496305,
0.1056102365,
0.6380109191,
0.4469864666,
-0.0004673393,
-0.3640801609,
-0.8911194801,
-0.7264934778,
0.138090685,
-0.9706789255,
-0.0339346863,
-0.5206387043,
-0.3549202681,
-0.1203607544,
-0.1054488644,
-0.6544485688,
-0.2630005479,
0.1282357275,
-0.1627990454,
-0.0518006384,
0.6795796156,
-0.1309431642,
0.1797498912,
-0.6362104416,
0.3858184218,
0.5362710953,
0.284860611,
-0.111709334,
-0.5856753588,
-0.1566330492,
-0.069542855,
0.0016138216,
-0.5997952223,
0.3884664774,
0.0616169497,
0.351763308,
0.2040657848,
0.0641637743,
0.8527382016,
-0.6857039928,
0.8812723756,
0.3077858686,
-0.876314342,
0.3224182725,
-0.2740945816,
0.5143661499,
0.2871638536,
0.230339244,
-0.5399112701,
-0.3268259466,
-0.5120434761,
-0.9666948318,
0.5940163732,
0.3641371727,
-0.1408427954,
0.3039667904,
0.3619503677,
-0.065506041,
0.027005516,
-0.8065685034,
0.0855776593,
-0.2346480638,
-0.128411755,
-0.0389431827,
-0.3357546031,
-0.0795306489,
-0.3541477621,
0.5660295486,
-0.2086520195,
0.305873394,
0.242085129,
-0.1539954841,
0.0465231165,
0.3173902631,
0.4735581577,
0.7744218707,
-0.2083410621,
0.4702380896,
0.0312937461,
-0.269800514,
0.1625560373,
-0.0271965731,
-0.3395341933,
-0.1481987536,
0.5540741682,
0.9507645369,
-0.4838331044,
-0.7663112879,
0.5495688319,
-0.1914538294,
-0.3954418004,
-0.3828733563,
-0.12678352,
0.0517449491,
0.3766594529,
0.1915108711,
0.1870502234,
0.0008522929,
-0.5051347613,
0.3917923868,
0.304972291,
-0.5950027704,
-0.267778784,
0.7021589279,
-0.1890252382,
0.0045384085,
0.7205327749,
-0.4045580029,
-0.879571259,
0.5921609402,
0.3964894414,
0.9812943935,
0.0318768546,
0.3242225647,
0.2035225779,
0.5205552578,
-0.1383931488,
0.1930672228,
-0.1244781464,
-1.0432527065,
-0.9364545345,
-0.6391651034,
-0.4189794958,
0.0885687247,
-0.247133866,
-0.1802182198,
-0.3807614446,
0.3019200861,
-0.163024053,
-0.3969853222,
-0.5155938864,
0.2690520883,
0.2604819536,
0.6126911044,
-0.5724698305,
1.1010863781,
0.6604723334,
-0.4878996313,
-0.9663805366,
0.246222958,
-0.0527235307,
-0.9294667244,
0.6738210917,
0.1757963598,
-0.3819468319,
0.0970815197,
-0.6611285806,
-0.5001232624,
0.6055471897,
0.6302247047,
-0.4798196256,
0.0562724583,
0.2233020067,
0.4390540421,
-0.3253815174,
0.0860889852,
0.6463077664,
0.3145109713,
0.5077046752,
-1.1769602299,
-0.169060573,
-0.2049759179,
-0.196545884,
0.1947188824,
-0.4098064601,
1.1043055058,
-0.6485280991,
-0.0628389716,
0.0198719278,
0.2109335065,
0.1373443305,
0.210900262,
0.6365725398,
0.863953948,
0.2578054965,
-0.2333821654,
1.1409689188,
0.0240338463,
0.6773611307,
0.99435848,
-0.1872079074,
0.8266098499,
0.486738503,
-0.0837520733,
-0.0737904757,
0.615447998,
0.3266156912,
0.5145258307,
0.2929022908,
-0.4970678687,
-0.769162178,
-0.0983461142,
-0.2211838067,
0.7395384908,
0.2009330392,
-0.0420763642,
-0.521535337,
0.1471489966,
0.0133384643,
-0.1158436686,
-0.2527114749,
0.7146643996,
0.140503943,
-0.699147284,
0.8495561481,
-0.1900960207,
0.4248166978,
-0.6368111372,
-0.1218591109,
-0.3347241282,
0.6079670787,
-0.0096443547,
-1.0365111828,
0.305519402,
0.1073313579,
0.0696748793,
-0.3798354566,
0.7025997043,
-0.6676881313,
-0.3569212258,
0.2729320228,
0.6116833687,
0.1552071273,
-0.5048240423,
-0.5116164088,
0.0985215902,
0.4077836871,
-0.3732467294,
0.2200817466,
0.3405334949,
0.1110405996,
0.8767542243,
0.4447672069,
0.0973834246,
0.1749258786,
0.074884221,
0.7606009245,
-0.3602916002,
-0.2351545542,
-1.0291881561,
0.5074090362,
0.0389223024,
0.0211517736,
0.5769026875,
0.4715560079,
1.13975811,
-0.1224045604,
0.9234331846,
-0.173526302,
0.205414474,
-0.7023245692,
0.3943050802,
-0.8377703428,
0.1916019469,
-0.2670264244,
-0.9398937225,
-0.6697831154,
0.7507191896,
-0.2483783662,
-0.1337046325,
0.5033054948,
0.6099416018,
-0.2200534344,
-0.1104395911,
0.7084712386,
0.151691094,
0.6993970871,
0.9162171483,
1.0107718706,
-0.127746135,
0.7027672529,
-0.3429742455,
-0.2147502303,
-0.0567878857,
-0.7928636074,
-0.5510321259,
-0.5351173878,
-0.3283268213,
-0.0684076026,
0.3083392382,
0.7922605276,
0.7922983766,
-0.5910553336,
-0.1507890671,
-0.3060866892,
-0.0238814149,
-0.1762581468,
-0.1609667093,
0.4151687324,
-0.2253489345,
-0.6913366914,
0.3470211327,
0.6485266685,
-0.0119062113,
-0.276486367,
0.0616294965,
0.0795208961,
-0.061849948,
1.0071425438,
0.386380285,
-0.887655139,
-0.6312126517,
0.0880311653,
0.3283042014,
0.093236506,
0.6712853312,
-0.683005929,
0.7119880319,
0.6131329536,
0.7149228454,
0.8302579522,
0.076822035,
0.5357772112,
-0.5600193143,
0.0600971393,
0.4489241242,
0.5298373699,
0.3408892751,
0.0814245641,
0.7769926786,
0.3781601787,
-0.4239885211,
-0.6825566888,
0.5897821784,
-0.9695615768,
-0.4713515043,
1.1728055477,
-0.3006243706,
-0.1133938581,
-0.0193386842,
-0.3668783903,
0.0134351933,
0.0589051247,
0.5523773432,
0.5407235026,
-0.5308887959,
-0.6419348717,
-0.7181594968,
0.1989432871,
0.4996118546,
-0.6315377355,
0.2069108188,
0.517282486,
0.2716289461,
0.1778439134,
0.8277019858,
-0.0631935522,
0.0527860858,
0.1712896675,
0.1697703451,
-0.2278608531,
-0.5833665133,
-0.144855231,
0.5565886497,
0.0543886758,
-0.3843539953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14982v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14982v2 | LAraBench: Benchmarking Arabic AI with Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T10:16:16 | 2024-02-05T07:27:18 | Ahmed Abdelali, Hamdy Mubarak, Shammur Absar Chowdhury, Maram Hasanain, Basel Mousi, Sabri Boughorbel, Yassine El Kheir, Daniel Izham, Fahim Dalvi, Majd Hawasly, Nizi Nazar, Yousseif Elshahawy, Ahmed Ali, Nadir Durrani, Natasa Milic-Frayling, Firoj Alam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
influenced the landscape of language and speech research. Despite this
progress, these models lack specific benchmarking against state-of-the-art
(SOTA) models tailored to particular languages and tasks. LAraBench addresses
this gap for Arabic Natural Language Processing (NLP) and Speech Processing
tasks, including sequence tagging and content classification across different
domains. We utilized models such as GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4, BLOOMZ,
Jais-13b-chat, Whisper, and USM, employing zero and few-shot learning
techniques to tackle 33 distinct tasks across 61 publicly available datasets.
This involved 98 experimental setups, encompassing ~296K data points, ~46 hours
of speech, and 30 sentences for Text-to-Speech (TTS). This effort resulted in
330+ sets of experiments. Our analysis focused on measuring the performance gap
between SOTA models and LLMs. The overarching trend observed was that SOTA
models generally outperformed LLMs in zero-shot learning, with a few
exceptions. Notably, larger computational models with few-shot learning
techniques managed to reduce these performance gaps. Our findings provide
valuable insights into the applicability of LLMs for Arabic NLP and speech
processing tasks. | [
-0.4381190538,
-0.836979568,
0.4551162422,
0.1579593271,
-0.0724665225,
0.3950479627,
-0.1409041882,
-0.643016398,
0.0788798034,
0.3466996551,
-0.431986481,
-0.8851830363,
-0.6600547433,
0.1891043186,
-0.5302419662,
0.8279489279,
-0.1460551769,
0.1150829941,
0.2045343965,
-0.3741748333,
-0.4723716974,
-0.3197306395,
-0.6925752759,
-0.4211352468,
0.4073552489,
0.5799406171,
0.6829558611,
0.7425697446,
0.346621424,
0.1899455488,
0.2075578868,
0.0707355663,
-0.3653234243,
0.3222528398,
-0.1552295685,
-0.2578437924,
-0.2804595828,
-0.2421268076,
0.8797651529,
0.6012313962,
-0.2935104072,
0.4574948549,
-0.201979652,
0.5445830822,
-0.9051249027,
0.2644773126,
-0.5790864229,
0.0161331091,
-0.7080595493,
0.2042951435,
-0.2229733616,
-0.2551774979,
-0.0119304126,
-0.1517658681,
-0.0533274747,
0.1201522425,
0.6742321253,
0.2462839782,
-0.1714549214,
-0.131811142,
-0.7346714735,
0.8429074883,
-0.8502873182,
0.3743257225,
0.3701694906,
0.4226331413,
0.0242011584,
-0.693066299,
-0.674900651,
-0.2377032936,
0.3976250589,
-0.1153488979,
-0.5624539852,
0.1149172038,
0.398624897,
0.0755473375,
-0.9043504,
0.4998311996,
-0.0338610969,
-0.171371758,
0.6619526148,
0.1637082249,
0.3975175917,
0.0490016825,
-0.2040515393,
-0.1660797,
-0.8852421641,
-0.1412414759,
0.2164162844,
0.3861102164,
-0.1280838251,
0.4867773354,
-0.4134877026,
0.709949255,
-0.3006641567,
-0.061535757,
0.2989230454,
-0.0165487025,
-0.1890531033,
0.2674937844,
0.8787633777,
0.0955391675,
0.3337239623,
-0.1873732209,
-0.1084463522,
0.1361965239,
0.0545591339,
-0.9166458845,
0.0361482203,
0.0032110142,
-0.0991642699,
0.1535782367,
-0.2427760065,
-0.6424087286,
-0.4225043952,
0.0026755333,
0.3696180284,
-0.2828038335,
-0.1356088668,
0.1375333071,
0.3335711956,
0.424985379,
0.0676163808,
-0.9359083772,
0.6081349254,
0.6109868288,
1.1432777643,
-0.5860626698,
-0.4478012919,
-0.8515603542,
0.1273786724,
-0.5270003676,
0.8900519013,
-0.5242656469,
-0.2774653733,
0.2654984593,
-0.7010897398,
-0.0289313793,
-0.8091314435,
0.6170732379,
-0.7823053002,
-0.2685456872,
-0.13520585,
-0.5395712256,
-0.3373375237,
0.2120998353,
-0.6747708321,
1.2269432545,
0.1648045033,
-0.5541825294,
0.1416220367,
-0.6596595049,
-0.4875595272,
0.1291580498,
-0.4942089319,
-0.4940098822,
0.1294849515,
0.136769101,
0.3812886477,
-0.8219122887,
0.2764198482,
-0.179419443,
-0.6799477935,
0.0769730583,
-0.2277906239,
0.5087167621,
0.2727808952,
-0.6252282858,
0.4375289977,
-0.6688276529,
0.2348069102,
-0.0194878224,
-0.0455863215,
0.0376575813,
-0.1766101569,
0.4031856656,
0.3251777887,
-0.1034348682,
-0.4943831563,
0.0748290196,
-0.66196841,
0.4479928911,
0.4130997062,
-0.1449419856,
0.0680342689,
-0.2332577109,
0.723849237,
-0.1491978317,
-0.1874132603,
-0.0868138596,
-0.2721765041,
-0.8917893767,
-0.3856571615,
0.5327643156,
0.4881985784,
-0.6419700384,
0.1145788059,
-0.3826053143,
-0.5305945277,
-0.6731629372,
0.1787027419,
0.4540892541,
0.2883739173,
0.4980895519,
-0.5810697675,
-0.5260674357,
-1.0277241468,
-0.5131415129,
-0.0932489261,
-0.0876225755,
0.0764430538,
0.5907511115,
-0.2131541669,
1.0345343351,
-0.2949289382,
-0.2895587087,
-0.5119803548,
0.4012004137,
0.1428879052,
0.1582329422,
0.5161578655,
-0.4939671457,
-0.8125523925,
-0.1766911894,
-0.6215370893,
-0.2900315225,
0.2441652864,
0.172380656,
0.4918476343,
0.3624165058,
-0.8051348329,
0.5749204159,
0.5476955771,
0.0755895078,
0.4778704047,
0.2273594588,
0.0546978824,
-0.7639507055,
0.1301897615,
-0.1132932827,
-0.3073170483,
-0.6543582082,
0.1427680701,
-0.2412969768,
-0.0507036783,
-0.5477790833,
0.6749487519,
-0.2440724671,
-0.4001115263,
-0.4077604115,
0.0841529667,
-0.3769697845,
0.4318768978,
-0.0275612362,
1.2115397453,
0.687714994,
-0.3713195324,
0.2394222915,
0.161700651,
-0.5428019166,
0.3152842522,
-0.8488222957,
0.5393211842,
0.1783530265,
0.1170052812,
-0.9462277293,
-0.2005741894,
0.089161858,
-0.1689714342,
0.154792726,
0.0535895862,
-0.8063361049,
0.1102311462,
-0.5101877451,
0.6053539515,
0.511249125,
-0.2511798441,
0.8516216874,
0.4478628039,
-0.4598773122,
-0.6395944357,
-0.4825108647,
0.2699573636,
-0.2475491762,
-0.4028889835,
0.4726305604,
0.2063568383,
-0.3290688694,
-0.3322603106,
-0.3114267588,
0.012524385,
0.0382520035,
0.5227640867,
-0.0440395437,
-0.3393355012,
0.1807828248,
-0.0684332997,
-0.2950356901,
-0.0017735615,
-0.30700472,
0.9693573713,
-0.2364684045,
-0.5643739104,
-0.4950652421,
0.4013832808,
0.3160688877,
-0.417863369,
0.9297759533,
0.6712371111,
-0.3493029177,
-0.1522252113,
-0.7213121653,
0.0205052774,
-0.4064686596,
0.4927106798,
-0.2462951094,
-0.9157598019,
0.3906869888,
-0.1960415244,
0.003159103,
0.4654961824,
0.6775513291,
0.0753483027,
1.0350431204,
0.6746279001,
-0.6448924541,
0.4803666472,
-0.275906682,
0.2204556167,
-0.3991157413,
0.1469800025,
-0.6554560065,
-0.3112778664,
-0.5224310756,
-0.4754276276,
0.4033011496,
0.0152464146,
-0.6288904548,
0.130649209,
0.0775977299,
0.4699071944,
0.559351325,
-0.3758451939,
0.4668256938,
0.1471603811,
0.0164365266,
-0.0708241537,
-0.7246450782,
-0.6797215343,
1.1043919325,
0.1335853636,
0.5642857552,
0.1998177022,
0.6437922716,
0.5929541588,
0.3646261692,
-0.5904843807,
0.5694189072,
0.120545581,
-0.4601328075,
-0.1799802929,
-0.2797910869,
-0.7802560925,
0.0552926809,
-0.0382887982,
-0.8947603106,
-0.3368162811,
-0.0276392885,
-0.3676921129,
0.1025023982,
-0.3912100792,
0.8756819963,
-0.1153025031,
-0.5977813601,
-0.3923332989,
-0.6973269582,
0.1026926711,
-0.1212515831,
0.1126601771,
-0.4018580914,
-0.0491621643,
0.9036698341,
-0.1505744457,
0.6830458045,
-0.0226527564,
0.0327570625,
0.3826520443,
0.0832057744,
0.2975711226,
-0.0697505772,
-0.2197744399,
0.489690572,
-0.0099174697,
-0.5229215622,
-0.3811962605,
0.7772195339,
-0.8832033873,
-0.4214554727,
-0.770717144,
-0.5070021152,
-0.5473045707,
0.2741951048,
0.1861415058,
0.1409153789,
-0.3283026516,
-0.0128331296,
0.5029249191,
-0.1127939075,
0.3945823908,
0.7747089863,
-0.4306350052,
-0.1182853803,
0.721663475,
0.2093143165,
0.0596371889,
0.3054141998,
-0.1825942397,
-0.2976610661,
-0.9852014184,
-0.6564454436,
0.1602543443,
-0.6242003441,
-0.4340087771,
-0.5317490697,
-0.2046602666,
-0.136686191,
0.2756697237,
-0.5038548708,
-0.2642956674,
0.0678130686,
-0.0640598908,
0.4371655285,
0.7767336369,
0.2226841301,
0.5840898156,
-0.744251132,
0.3490109444,
0.1153125539,
0.3634151816,
0.1472798884,
-0.5543419719,
-0.3682685792,
0.0396655016,
-0.4411380887,
-0.8391614556,
0.3510600924,
0.3889809251,
0.2177810669,
0.1792852134,
-0.0137982508,
0.7579445839,
-0.6796700358,
0.690962255,
-0.0434024595,
-1.167658329,
0.3964938819,
-0.3151567578,
0.4256514311,
0.71541363,
0.4650976956,
-0.531771183,
-0.1141521782,
-0.4448924363,
-0.8507922292,
0.631251514,
0.2985525131,
0.0232710261,
0.1548942477,
0.3862425089,
0.1339583546,
0.4056307673,
-0.3586394191,
-0.2721701264,
0.3119855821,
-0.5015329123,
-0.2738772333,
-0.1552296579,
-0.0136294244,
-0.0895017758,
0.6531892419,
-0.1776869893,
-0.1301921159,
-0.2929542959,
-0.4564839602,
-0.0898627937,
0.3243048191,
0.4916323423,
0.7974014878,
0.0752854869,
0.1661500335,
0.5431926847,
-0.4417699575,
0.1259784251,
0.2962237298,
-0.3147663772,
0.0402832218,
0.6165347695,
0.6997057199,
0.1472209692,
-1.2491428852,
0.2778035104,
0.0503089726,
0.1672564,
-0.200666666,
0.2343114167,
0.1689061522,
0.3834889233,
0.3529258668,
-0.0478884764,
0.3039085865,
-0.5958204865,
0.071546413,
0.4043275118,
-0.3254249394,
-0.3525584936,
0.4568962753,
-0.1232004836,
-0.5095044374,
0.6236327887,
-0.0100396946,
-0.353048563,
0.2807251513,
0.3368248045,
0.7875534892,
-0.3073210716,
0.1600235999,
0.0705524832,
-0.0098422309,
-0.2033791989,
0.3976934552,
-0.1188023463,
-0.5260533094,
-0.4927248359,
-0.7084497213,
-0.69358325,
0.1440669596,
-0.7295267582,
0.076079227,
-0.4444592893,
-0.3303695321,
0.1521428674,
0.2942752242,
-0.8140648603,
-0.0890332982,
0.1323332787,
0.8961423635,
-0.8691079617,
0.8677644134,
0.5140555501,
-0.4345244765,
-0.7679044008,
0.1232791319,
0.0499832928,
-0.8546879292,
0.548899889,
0.2805690169,
-0.7681111693,
0.2602397799,
-0.4236785471,
-0.8749780655,
0.7670655251,
0.7826954126,
-0.6688570976,
0.0972089991,
0.3750911951,
0.7147507071,
-0.2941951752,
0.378331542,
0.9255868793,
0.2381433547,
-0.0419951342,
-1.0508532524,
-0.2435944676,
-0.1600914896,
0.1656518281,
0.1524478644,
-0.5686571598,
0.7539889216,
0.0213607494,
-0.2942844331,
0.2243510336,
0.7523291111,
0.4061877429,
0.4218303263,
0.2118910104,
0.4232299924,
0.4953022301,
-0.0465596989,
0.8600159287,
-0.2823421657,
0.1785939038,
1.1907954216,
-0.9145277739,
1.3209656477,
0.3905878067,
-0.3626868129,
0.5686432719,
0.524330318,
0.2101159245,
0.3905883729,
0.4454374015,
-0.388830632,
-0.1237321049,
-0.5719317794,
-0.3987928629,
0.7944815159,
0.2349767834,
-0.0364325009,
-0.2230331898,
0.04175473,
0.0568497851,
0.2167139351,
-0.1340931952,
0.8493633866,
0.008435417,
-0.6020822525,
0.6739194393,
0.3919653594,
0.5142735839,
-0.819922924,
-0.1081288531,
-0.1560716927,
0.20596008,
-0.0952774361,
-0.4454719424,
0.2788248658,
0.3967901468,
-0.0194572769,
-0.1336874068,
0.5550635457,
-0.2572114468,
-0.3704843819,
0.3569939733,
0.7404640317,
0.2097565681,
-0.2198324651,
-0.5305531025,
0.7102391124,
-0.341227442,
-0.0843952522,
0.5057449937,
-0.06450665,
-0.317310214,
0.7064836621,
0.3570207059,
0.1352944672,
-0.0786855593,
0.2211671472,
0.8476079702,
-0.7144193649,
-0.3961842358,
-1.2217692137,
-0.0378704108,
-0.008232356,
-0.3555667996,
0.9039996266,
0.8625026941,
0.8603272438,
0.0817305222,
0.6828715205,
0.2372701764,
0.6889122725,
-0.5886403918,
0.6399273276,
-0.2633101642,
0.3012369871,
-0.1660661101,
-0.9566381574,
-0.386459291,
0.7906565666,
-0.4596637487,
0.3386898935,
0.4439327717,
0.6830332875,
0.114000313,
0.1127379835,
0.197751075,
0.2202911377,
0.3202775419,
0.604639411,
0.9240341187,
-0.3893753886,
0.2198469937,
0.082699053,
0.01953738,
-0.3030511141,
-0.7860677838,
-0.8793209791,
-0.4684411883,
-0.3120933473,
-0.0272435881,
0.4066942632,
1.0760831833,
0.8079907298,
-1.022282362,
-0.6743412614,
0.0023072527,
-0.0166052319,
-0.2832192481,
-0.0934771523,
0.5263031125,
-0.0157269519,
-0.5870541334,
0.3763059378,
0.5690470338,
-0.1699144244,
-0.2810879946,
-0.0373254679,
-0.333078146,
0.0228952579,
0.3911937475,
0.4767040014,
-0.7845782638,
-0.1639929861,
-0.1152823195,
-0.1252255589,
0.2203774154,
0.6275504231,
-0.9568812251,
0.1753775775,
0.1218142882,
0.8292979598,
0.904366672,
-0.0751327202,
0.4882853329,
-0.7866948843,
0.1051149666,
0.5184960365,
0.0288961809,
0.4563159645,
0.3486209214,
0.5034603477,
-0.183164224,
-0.3514800966,
-1.065991044,
0.2781448364,
-0.7079725266,
0.1166771576,
0.8060275316,
-0.1486137211,
0.0480130501,
-0.1421677768,
-0.2582058012,
0.3772253096,
-0.3629432619,
0.8564687967,
0.7493544221,
-0.308640182,
-0.1314802915,
-0.975589335,
0.5255838633,
0.6693496704,
-0.9726402164,
-0.0517793484,
0.2323898822,
0.2182217389,
0.0169735756,
0.6981743574,
0.3594910204,
0.3895842135,
-0.0923183486,
-0.0034264163,
0.0128777269,
-0.3778651953,
-0.4851418436,
0.2361246794,
0.4720900059,
-0.0961312577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14981v1 | Improving Factuality of Abstractive Summarization without Sacrificing Summary Quality | 2023-05-24T10:15:17 | 2023-05-24T10:15:17 | Tanay Dixit, Fei Wang, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Improving factual consistency of abstractive summarization has been a widely
studied topic. However, most of the prior works on training factuality-aware
models have ignored the negative effect it has on summary quality. We propose
EFACTSUM (i.e., Effective Factual Summarization), a candidate summary
generation and ranking technique to improve summary factuality without
sacrificing summary quality. We show that using a contrastive learning
framework with our refined candidate summaries leads to significant gains on
both factuality and similarity-based metrics. Specifically, we propose a
ranking strategy in which we effectively combine two metrics, thereby
preventing any conflict during training. Models trained using our approach show
up to 6 points of absolute improvement over the base model with respect to
FactCC on XSUM and 11 points on CNN/DM, without negatively affecting either
similarity-based metrics or absractiveness. | [
-0.3895703852,
-0.3331762552,
0.6366209984,
-0.3101563454,
-0.455978483,
0.0474198386,
-0.0367216058,
-0.4952088892,
0.5711480975,
0.0899748057,
0.0104781482,
-0.5841935277,
-0.9305555224,
0.203354001,
-0.3713731766,
1.6892489195,
0.0716620609,
-0.0907197073,
-0.5810579658,
-0.508174479,
0.0839298368,
-0.4279575348,
-0.5300427079,
-0.2151862532,
0.6485826969,
0.4998777807,
0.8392828703,
0.8230559826,
0.4842041135,
0.3141138256,
-0.3747912347,
0.6419975162,
-0.8280497193,
-0.028332483,
-0.2942118347,
-0.4638109207,
-0.7344219089,
0.0981680825,
0.6524356008,
0.8440355659,
-0.3159620464,
0.1451368034,
0.0028636514,
0.7972986102,
-0.6720212102,
0.0945640877,
-0.3492690623,
-0.0223791916,
0.2550303638,
-0.423235476,
-0.3225041032,
-0.7233486772,
0.1770498604,
-0.5806387663,
0.9075399637,
0.0486664698,
1.2137970924,
0.0881146863,
-0.5502948761,
-0.1964200735,
-0.5539460182,
0.5645655394,
-0.9175217748,
0.1856266558,
0.3307040334,
-0.009997285,
0.1680627316,
-0.5483186841,
-0.381118536,
-0.2351596951,
-0.4239746332,
0.524260819,
0.1101175547,
0.1482470483,
0.2276488096,
0.6636067629,
-0.4326306283,
-0.2818140388,
-0.4704515338,
-0.2754517496,
0.6344257593,
0.2038915455,
0.0330915265,
0.1597459763,
-0.1204790398,
-0.1014074981,
-0.7165477276,
0.0042520831,
0.2242684066,
0.2857062221,
-0.2900019884,
0.429688096,
-0.6767299771,
0.5206078887,
0.1711299717,
-0.4373230338,
0.3675209284,
-0.7140572071,
0.0284711942,
0.1917104721,
0.0343673155,
0.6581214666,
-0.2499804199,
-0.3447825909,
-0.2615557611,
0.1314525157,
0.0270241145,
-1.1525475979,
-0.5183116198,
0.3599268198,
-0.5423083901,
-0.4144782126,
0.5068947077,
-0.4607559741,
-0.0524929166,
-0.583106339,
0.4759803116,
-0.3820814788,
-0.2486057729,
-0.1262345165,
-0.4012721479,
0.0335008092,
0.681566298,
-1.1187583208,
0.4043856263,
0.6927973032,
0.9875852466,
-0.074093774,
-0.1531710476,
-0.7694792747,
0.2728810012,
-0.6636559963,
0.9508076906,
-0.1225548536,
-0.1837037504,
-0.1834667772,
-0.4526546299,
0.038859643,
-0.6277749538,
0.4637735784,
-0.4277701378,
0.1614009738,
-0.5047643781,
-0.7097412348,
-0.3688676357,
0.4742176533,
-0.6223986745,
0.7264331579,
-0.3061371744,
-0.8132712245,
0.6581124663,
-0.3927437663,
-0.5417561531,
-0.5656166673,
-0.221942991,
-0.7196553349,
0.4243169427,
0.207258448,
0.4947252274,
0.3939173222,
0.2318574488,
0.0419734716,
-0.4371296167,
-0.0486100465,
-0.0589837804,
0.2423867881,
0.0970268622,
-0.1330513209,
0.0243749823,
-0.6855735779,
-0.3795540929,
-0.1341004968,
-0.5837387443,
-0.1787324548,
0.0838104337,
-0.3397054374,
0.1812177747,
0.0442621298,
-0.5084738135,
-0.317719698,
-0.5475760102,
-0.3023450971,
0.5492156744,
0.005779176,
0.2693837583,
-0.9251197577,
0.0503905714,
0.2115619183,
-0.3158245981,
-0.3732415438,
-0.2256805599,
-1.1055269241,
-0.5012772083,
0.4916061461,
0.3607313633,
-0.6603884697,
0.4262969792,
-0.4316847324,
-0.5282654166,
-0.1250096411,
0.0182659458,
0.5630857348,
0.7778273225,
0.4260567725,
-0.3504489958,
-0.2764401138,
-0.8200369477,
-0.3832433522,
-0.3320310712,
0.0841043964,
-0.1060224101,
0.5380917788,
0.1517798752,
0.8247484565,
-0.7852398157,
-0.1753035188,
-0.2357711941,
0.5242324471,
0.1772506088,
0.5469316244,
0.655898273,
-0.9991393685,
-0.1945172995,
-0.2303266823,
-0.7330000997,
0.0378691629,
-0.1171043813,
-0.0102319932,
0.2997322977,
0.4905895889,
-0.4420829415,
0.2686722279,
0.2328352034,
-0.4758386612,
0.5509821773,
-0.4169965386,
0.6595231295,
-1.1455762386,
0.2405474037,
0.0370353498,
-0.7835285068,
-0.5785896182,
0.2057175338,
-0.0834482312,
-0.0241676588,
-0.3912757039,
0.1090620458,
-0.2613301575,
-0.0666598976,
-0.3024567068,
0.3093975782,
0.1829783618,
0.4305782914,
0.2013834864,
0.7107117772,
0.0167000555,
-0.8877466321,
-0.0022615599,
0.4259566963,
-0.2587607801,
0.6529552341,
-0.5926957726,
-0.2700758278,
-0.5574634671,
0.4001077712,
-1.1777276993,
-0.1802225858,
-0.2214172333,
-0.6407088637,
0.5173496008,
0.3062566817,
-0.2305743843,
0.5252393484,
-0.6783485413,
0.2480134368,
0.3458869755,
-0.7890616059,
0.594768405,
0.0285127237,
-0.605677247,
-0.5727117062,
-0.3762211502,
0.1990760267,
-0.1013729349,
-0.3907391429,
0.7099354267,
-0.0419443659,
-0.2565667927,
0.068872042,
-0.3478472829,
0.0756667852,
0.0405053683,
-0.2630369961,
0.3535539508,
-0.1445628554,
0.1479855925,
0.226895228,
-0.3315449357,
-0.0177510083,
0.213700369,
-0.1098659113,
-0.1418529302,
0.0434422903,
-0.4337479174,
0.3782221973,
0.299603045,
-0.2444367409,
0.8163591027,
0.3257814944,
-0.2757377923,
0.0625929385,
-0.6201793551,
-0.2518409789,
-0.3739456236,
0.6382390261,
-0.1603571922,
-0.8225419521,
0.5182554126,
-0.177470997,
0.5887107849,
0.636169672,
0.1663198918,
-0.2658775151,
1.0289890766,
0.8227311373,
0.0571174584,
0.4499044716,
-0.2357830852,
-0.0560867712,
-0.4116717279,
-0.3650561571,
-0.4954394102,
-0.0000014068,
-0.3685954213,
-0.17516312,
0.4937895536,
-0.1766306907,
0.0119007267,
0.0827557221,
-0.0193094965,
0.7178829908,
0.1581433564,
0.3975515664,
0.7097853422,
0.2620727122,
0.0948025659,
-0.0741694346,
-0.8631281257,
-0.5647640824,
0.93000108,
0.1952085346,
0.3867040277,
0.6473268867,
0.9242597818,
0.5143439174,
0.4330757856,
-0.46476385,
0.3579207063,
-0.2187376767,
-0.5108194351,
-0.2481896728,
-0.8203827739,
-0.3417702019,
0.6963713765,
-0.5638301969,
-0.1746229082,
0.1691681594,
0.4655279219,
-0.5908920765,
0.2716746926,
-0.419257015,
0.4174130559,
-0.0046102214,
-0.2835510075,
-0.6411144137,
-0.7155641913,
0.4928178787,
0.1292458177,
0.2014962584,
0.0005754742,
-0.331391871,
0.8146232963,
-0.6541507244,
0.6751492023,
0.1240056753,
0.0401369929,
-0.0829950571,
-0.058062654,
0.4197204113,
0.1885873824,
-0.0490851253,
0.0000709301,
-0.1439895481,
-0.8644784093,
-0.7275718451,
0.5269110799,
-0.6375209093,
-0.6219205856,
-0.6514393091,
-0.3407430053,
-0.1562902629,
0.0068161204,
0.3551018536,
0.8739414215,
-0.5988525748,
-0.0425857492,
1.0528277159,
0.1274265498,
0.2010747641,
0.3244572282,
0.1955740005,
-0.5709789991,
1.1615085602,
0.1789239198,
0.5394538641,
0.4107542336,
0.1128466278,
-0.2527267933,
-0.6405246258,
-0.5049502254,
0.4012672901,
-0.9039522409,
-0.2355604917,
-0.7089335918,
-0.0382150486,
-0.4126009345,
-0.3729218543,
-0.4250207543,
-0.7959083319,
-0.1636286527,
-0.5548386574,
0.1471894681,
0.7492133975,
-0.2703183293,
0.096984297,
-0.6582654715,
0.5822257996,
0.274374783,
0.2389995307,
0.0182965733,
-0.991712451,
-0.6189261079,
-0.1575205922,
-0.3420778215,
-0.4605573714,
0.0189268906,
0.6303291917,
0.5935923457,
0.7930217385,
0.1507796794,
0.4702473879,
-0.2284792364,
0.694884181,
0.4650002122,
-0.822624445,
0.4477953613,
-0.2654160261,
0.0918570384,
1.0812832117,
0.344926089,
-0.144198209,
-0.5623064041,
-0.645282805,
-0.679580152,
0.5845451951,
0.469448477,
0.1220204532,
0.0895654261,
0.2952673733,
0.2434172779,
0.3569415212,
-0.4868484735,
-0.4054853618,
-0.4187221229,
-0.1905029416,
-0.2257474661,
-0.350423038,
-0.3420032561,
-0.4383672774,
1.0818260908,
-0.0470507815,
-0.1078023985,
0.5658177137,
-0.1631538868,
0.2184021622,
0.0557806306,
0.9232756495,
0.9904366732,
-0.4824304879,
0.3119399548,
0.4892827272,
-0.3602362573,
0.2367045432,
0.102630049,
-0.1840382516,
0.4287067652,
0.5448254347,
0.4788882136,
0.2714455426,
-0.4918645322,
0.6274957061,
-0.1092347652,
-0.3017654419,
-0.0886580423,
0.2049713731,
0.0023544463,
-0.0961238071,
0.327098906,
0.3352286518,
0.4690514505,
-0.6139975786,
0.2656853199,
0.017112283,
-0.1364589334,
-0.1297823638,
0.4889501035,
0.6282641888,
0.2632998228,
0.3421311677,
-0.2209901512,
-0.5851039886,
0.8024904132,
0.5358541012,
0.4146853089,
-0.189220652,
0.3362756371,
0.7415180206,
0.2093805373,
-0.3127228022,
0.0627601296,
-0.2296625972,
-0.6488071084,
-0.3162508607,
-0.1547227204,
-0.7825713158,
-0.3852386475,
-0.6377215981,
0.3000051677,
-0.5457504392,
0.0610140525,
-0.0366853885,
0.0452154465,
-0.156245783,
0.7157158256,
0.0263231806,
0.6745502353,
-1.1611862183,
0.1186448261,
0.643327415,
-0.5365288854,
-0.411550492,
0.0899164826,
0.0131094167,
0.1623329073,
0.140133217,
0.2873778939,
-0.5434520841,
-0.2157379687,
-0.3923619688,
-0.9031047225,
1.2365351915,
0.4946511388,
-0.1914906353,
0.3126332462,
-0.2378877252,
0.3700608611,
-0.4154343009,
0.4528369009,
0.4245554507,
0.1486474872,
0.1490610838,
-0.4264411628,
0.0515863597,
-0.337890774,
-0.2103702277,
0.1043483093,
-0.8887901306,
0.6191505194,
-0.782473743,
-0.353910774,
0.181050092,
1.1852612495,
0.4100087583,
0.5997042656,
0.3815125525,
0.7397978902,
1.0100185871,
0.100340575,
1.0750929117,
-0.010529872,
0.2573587596,
1.299388051,
0.0376854315,
0.6244467497,
0.2772405744,
-0.0144534232,
0.5877605677,
0.7072585225,
0.1272792369,
0.6177349091,
-0.2394624949,
-0.3289733529,
-0.530351162,
-0.0756665468,
-0.5849782825,
0.3630651236,
0.1068875641,
-0.4828363657,
-0.4895756543,
-0.5476971269,
0.2848391831,
0.5771134496,
-0.2135043889,
0.8491443992,
0.111328505,
-0.5077866316,
0.4735323787,
0.1577221006,
0.7128174901,
-0.4920069873,
-0.4246685803,
-0.4886166453,
-0.099026911,
-0.5740081072,
-0.0789767057,
0.36069116,
0.0979875997,
-0.5189717412,
0.3162449002,
0.2388277948,
-0.5279767513,
-0.6883660555,
-0.1866935939,
0.4371488094,
0.1965051144,
0.285523802,
-0.2537511289,
-0.3819448352,
-0.2452737987,
-0.0807013661,
0.2867165506,
0.1130316034,
0.2971531153,
0.2841443121,
0.6963372827,
0.2428140938,
-0.5898052454,
-0.1278438717,
0.8521509767,
-0.6239978075,
-1.0343372822,
-0.7965362668,
0.4475282133,
-0.6083288789,
-0.4449781775,
0.6950473785,
0.9405548573,
0.8622791767,
0.0792433843,
0.6355271935,
0.1321476102,
0.6546208858,
-0.707695961,
0.9796067476,
-0.5303304195,
0.1639188379,
-0.3217386603,
-1.0186402798,
-0.3555984497,
0.5776882768,
-0.0501132458,
0.1437681019,
0.7123971581,
0.8366258144,
-0.2747547925,
-0.0708353519,
0.5060084462,
0.054549858,
0.2644770741,
0.2378157079,
0.6328909397,
-0.576775372,
0.3700490892,
-0.1156848669,
-0.4977470636,
-0.2685320973,
-0.9256916046,
-0.9307036996,
-0.3438035846,
-0.7345663905,
-0.3449972868,
0.3190707266,
1.0476696491,
0.7604128122,
-0.9343750477,
-0.057345394,
0.2455914766,
0.1808033884,
-0.3265464306,
-0.0756834149,
0.5604048371,
-0.2633235753,
-0.5531006455,
0.1300964504,
0.0561826192,
-0.0065662824,
0.3349176049,
-0.2177140415,
-0.1735650301,
0.418285042,
0.7885600328,
0.2547262311,
-0.3559242487,
-0.2825585008,
-0.5017641783,
-0.1163699701,
0.1277470142,
0.7667588592,
-0.59285146,
0.4063107967,
0.5374460816,
0.608273685,
0.4503240585,
0.6530575752,
0.6288763285,
-0.6256747842,
0.0128230695,
-0.0436157696,
0.3754392266,
0.6791755557,
-0.4891361296,
0.5490242243,
0.2126512825,
-0.3026807904,
-0.5456230044,
0.0987946987,
-0.7945920825,
-0.2342646569,
0.8053811789,
-0.3511053324,
0.164251864,
-0.2510243058,
-0.1748169065,
0.4805136919,
-0.4562960267,
1.2131376266,
0.4626564682,
-0.2930651605,
0.2331702709,
-0.1473294348,
0.6507126689,
0.8149644732,
-0.8710647225,
-0.0405528396,
0.8018563986,
0.4060996771,
0.1219409853,
0.4757251143,
-0.1934565008,
0.7175334096,
0.0546368659,
-0.0390250534,
-0.3903832138,
-0.5436733365,
-0.4858285785,
0.0785836354,
0.0986489654,
-0.0716003478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14976v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14976v2 | GPTAraEval: A Comprehensive Evaluation of ChatGPT on Arabic NLP | 2023-05-24T10:12:39 | 2023-10-21T05:16:24 | Md Tawkat Islam Khondaker, Abdul Waheed, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | ChatGPT's emergence heralds a transformative phase in NLP, particularly
demonstrated through its excellent performance on many English benchmarks.
However, the model's efficacy across diverse linguistic contexts remains
largely uncharted territory. This work aims to bridge this knowledge gap, with
a primary focus on assessing ChatGPT's capabilities on Arabic languages and
dialectal varieties. Our comprehensive study conducts a large-scale automated
and human evaluation of ChatGPT, encompassing 44 distinct language
understanding and generation tasks on over 60 different datasets. To our
knowledge, this marks the first extensive performance analysis of ChatGPT's
deployment in Arabic NLP. Our findings indicate that, despite its remarkable
performance in English, ChatGPT is consistently surpassed by smaller models
that have undergone finetuning on Arabic. We further undertake a meticulous
comparison of ChatGPT and GPT-4's Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) and Dialectal
Arabic (DA), unveiling the relative shortcomings of both models in handling
Arabic dialects compared to MSA. Although we further explore and confirm the
utility of employing GPT-4 as a potential alternative for human evaluation, our
work adds to a growing body of research underscoring the limitations of
ChatGPT. | [
-0.3581020236,
-0.6747533083,
0.2597136199,
0.3878089786,
-0.2617422342,
0.3790903389,
-0.3054117858,
-0.632550478,
-0.0784745067,
0.1373727471,
-0.3200922906,
-0.6619116068,
-0.8995091915,
0.1576039344,
-0.4995970428,
1.2813696861,
0.1579501033,
-0.0953204483,
0.3718997836,
-0.1471481621,
-0.5525485873,
-0.6824013591,
-0.9357162118,
-0.2081357986,
0.1875503361,
0.2531757653,
1.2118009329,
0.113900356,
0.5314741135,
0.2924441993,
-0.2124441266,
0.1264935285,
-0.3185231686,
0.0761591122,
0.0491139628,
-0.0773057267,
-0.4445050061,
-0.1893045008,
0.6848157048,
0.6261026263,
-0.6863905191,
0.0325383134,
0.1860350966,
0.9664337635,
-0.5260918736,
0.0746042877,
-0.8637977242,
0.1442587525,
-0.3479318023,
0.3180410564,
-0.1654856503,
-0.3884471059,
0.4715217054,
-0.3035763204,
0.208043769,
-0.0066065476,
0.7613425255,
0.1183336005,
-0.4851386547,
-0.4590793252,
-0.7200359106,
0.5514630079,
-0.785403192,
0.2085465938,
0.4242860377,
0.5509938598,
-0.0143067222,
-1.0267680883,
-0.3889431953,
-0.649430871,
0.1472945362,
0.2496749908,
-0.3416924179,
0.1330062896,
-0.0248147603,
0.4200294316,
-0.8578795791,
-0.206007719,
-0.2461136132,
-0.2137497216,
0.3885106146,
-0.0204082858,
0.5228684545,
-0.1148989573,
-0.25918594,
0.1188301668,
-0.8495511413,
-0.220981583,
0.2779067755,
0.2779507041,
-0.0472366028,
0.4491437972,
-0.1078987718,
0.4884520471,
-0.288597554,
0.3061921895,
0.1340573728,
-0.4584203959,
-0.1987969428,
0.0776939094,
0.8286126256,
0.3231836855,
0.2988298535,
-0.2644709349,
-0.1203109026,
-0.058253549,
0.4085018933,
-0.9236494303,
-0.3986531198,
0.1023718491,
-0.2379618138,
-0.0308504868,
-0.1718920022,
-0.7965074778,
-0.345310837,
0.0633271635,
0.3010642827,
-0.674503386,
-0.3711943924,
0.2493879348,
0.1765315384,
0.4180668592,
0.3304368556,
-1.0494155884,
0.5031884909,
0.6913381219,
1.1314818859,
-0.2773160636,
-0.431107372,
-0.0942959338,
-0.132269904,
-0.3253703117,
0.5574892163,
-0.6539962292,
-0.5206671953,
0.306437701,
-0.464448601,
-0.196559906,
-0.6376532912,
0.862367332,
-0.6928710341,
0.190864861,
-0.1811414808,
-0.3398359418,
-0.2561305761,
0.3123487234,
-0.5327926278,
0.8961334825,
0.1626989394,
-0.7217588425,
0.4137165844,
-0.7804709673,
-0.1563657969,
0.2117065936,
-0.1090925783,
-0.4017978609,
-0.0840250477,
0.349570632,
0.0484135933,
-0.3255463839,
0.2826226056,
0.2648678422,
-0.3131173253,
0.0809189752,
-0.7464285493,
0.6009826064,
0.2300880551,
-0.5501599312,
0.1162357554,
-0.4648410678,
0.2388055474,
-0.0287337396,
-0.2069032639,
0.1849044561,
0.0993355662,
0.4444057941,
0.3372907937,
0.2919848263,
-0.3854383826,
0.2237740904,
-0.5538577437,
0.4112201631,
0.5650845766,
-0.1688233614,
0.0725320876,
-0.1043643281,
0.7268408537,
-0.2753250301,
0.1210430935,
0.1514518857,
-0.8145589232,
-0.7471228242,
-0.0687633753,
0.5284876227,
0.5639154911,
-0.6678133607,
0.2995581627,
-0.1726559401,
-0.6113313437,
-0.5640141368,
0.0642793253,
0.4425350428,
0.1981552392,
0.5371729732,
-0.6209278703,
-0.3849473298,
-1.1029446125,
-0.3593313098,
-0.3058181405,
-0.1185729429,
0.1889451295,
0.4161507785,
-0.4078102112,
0.7973980308,
-0.0758423954,
-0.2915248573,
-0.4302073717,
0.2695279717,
0.2356285453,
0.2732109427,
0.5297791362,
-0.6283919811,
-0.8661130667,
0.3859736323,
-0.3704277575,
-0.1213006601,
0.039531555,
0.0897503942,
0.2024747878,
-0.0230550133,
-0.626139164,
0.432579577,
0.8253047466,
-0.6015865207,
0.8885099292,
-0.2190949023,
0.2598800361,
-0.8060058355,
-0.0200586282,
-0.3040801585,
-0.1898214668,
-0.7913469672,
0.0133810733,
-0.2176884413,
-0.1889803708,
-0.215741694,
0.2446903288,
-0.2538695931,
-0.0628861338,
-0.2903598845,
0.1971036643,
-0.3354858458,
0.3303326964,
0.0714796558,
1.3014358282,
0.4177951813,
-0.1386524886,
0.1737919897,
0.3123967946,
-0.4651409388,
0.0303452536,
-0.9423537254,
0.4779520929,
0.2932266891,
0.0030237457,
-1.0694881678,
-0.0462608486,
0.2463816702,
-0.3781599998,
0.2341648489,
-0.3056900501,
-0.3132182956,
0.1035568267,
-0.1178863794,
0.4494611621,
0.6973546147,
-0.3085118234,
0.4409125447,
0.250861913,
-0.5917844176,
-0.6917173266,
-0.1831014603,
0.625875175,
-0.2809269428,
-0.672352612,
0.2998984456,
0.2905391753,
-0.2261476368,
-0.3092845976,
-0.21440503,
-0.21199058,
-0.0233858787,
0.1164379045,
0.0510587655,
-0.2177997082,
0.0265136268,
-0.0623040497,
-0.1594506502,
0.0693143383,
-0.3083396256,
0.761739254,
-0.7395522594,
-0.5892736912,
-0.3836466372,
0.4225748777,
0.2442523241,
-0.3152779341,
0.8016101122,
0.8598416448,
-0.0280606393,
0.057250943,
-0.4892418981,
0.1249116361,
-0.4792683125,
0.8357830048,
-0.2129610926,
-0.7592353821,
0.3967029154,
-0.0903281346,
0.0442431346,
0.6394184232,
0.6849584579,
0.1760821044,
0.9194322228,
0.5481036901,
-0.4445828199,
0.1177895665,
0.0125292279,
0.1444064826,
-0.5324329138,
0.0151430406,
-0.6018840671,
0.0222056415,
-0.7865670323,
-0.2736948133,
0.4757323563,
0.060358651,
-0.2769634128,
0.1317529082,
-0.3312912285,
0.4254739583,
0.2385812104,
-0.0852171779,
0.4752390385,
0.0939199775,
0.0226728749,
-0.2569861412,
-0.758077383,
-0.9270452857,
1.1444597244,
0.2728288174,
0.2372128814,
0.5708225369,
0.4165956974,
0.5686450601,
0.3941178322,
-0.6062141657,
0.303029269,
-0.0222839285,
-0.5106041431,
-0.3388161659,
-0.204574585,
-1.1790310144,
0.5203085542,
0.0905834958,
-0.8197515607,
-0.3925771713,
0.0832088664,
-0.2279977202,
0.1031688377,
-0.8870484233,
0.9886105061,
-0.0851021558,
-0.274913311,
-0.3797006607,
-0.6826976538,
0.2095370293,
-0.0817347988,
0.1055170447,
-0.0990952402,
-0.2288553417,
0.79862535,
-0.466381222,
0.6671415567,
-0.1844211668,
-0.0751597881,
0.2193612605,
0.0930063948,
0.2656275034,
0.085854806,
0.0152562903,
0.4680027068,
0.2022321969,
-0.590262711,
-0.58312428,
0.4429285228,
-0.8760602474,
-0.4917679131,
-0.5702690482,
-0.3931127191,
-0.5952923298,
-0.0056197424,
0.080524087,
0.3159100413,
-0.5360860825,
-0.0894057676,
0.0861838013,
-0.1633569002,
0.3412259221,
0.3294958472,
-0.5344958901,
-0.3723114431,
0.8113278151,
-0.1641621739,
0.3790151179,
-0.0930270627,
0.0826669559,
-0.4207025468,
-1.0345389843,
-0.6635296345,
0.0040462338,
-0.5217064023,
0.1877735704,
-0.145978719,
-0.2654610872,
-0.0047175321,
0.1196064055,
-0.5643396974,
-0.4680726826,
0.369466871,
0.1658225805,
0.1626408249,
1.0188552141,
0.09636572,
0.5070881844,
-0.7636756897,
0.0008971631,
0.3792783916,
0.1158283576,
-0.0263569187,
-0.705917418,
-0.2825041413,
0.1262886077,
-0.5200785398,
-0.8703577518,
0.5455922484,
0.526853621,
0.2177114934,
0.4320493042,
-0.3552217782,
0.5521230102,
-0.9399434328,
1.0353424549,
0.0404737107,
-0.9555265903,
0.4071640968,
-0.4798581898,
0.2658722699,
0.6321700811,
0.4913892746,
-0.9081057906,
-0.3482842445,
-0.6848857999,
-1.0966538191,
0.3617706597,
0.839622736,
0.1926918179,
0.0225897878,
0.2926053107,
0.0812147111,
0.2802498639,
-0.53406322,
-0.3232696056,
-0.1912082434,
0.0078992546,
-0.0732250288,
-0.401024133,
-0.105245769,
-0.1895024627,
0.5831009746,
0.0887281522,
0.3886709213,
0.1198377311,
-0.154234007,
0.513893187,
0.4982654452,
0.611274004,
1.0359399319,
-0.2683039308,
-0.0579355918,
0.3306452632,
-1.0060836077,
0.0621421412,
0.2880427837,
-0.0328413621,
0.1722815484,
0.6363102794,
0.4915577173,
0.0501930751,
-0.6410350204,
0.449478209,
-0.1702415645,
-0.00484529,
-0.3842014074,
-0.0434273928,
0.086092934,
0.109058097,
0.5287032723,
0.14637281,
0.2622544765,
-0.4168305695,
0.19432877,
0.520999074,
-0.4425971806,
-0.3371459842,
0.334631592,
0.196164161,
-0.3426932096,
0.7562969327,
-0.3110250533,
-0.7631711364,
0.5317091942,
0.5340744853,
0.9135958552,
-0.4070636034,
0.3176436126,
0.2715640962,
0.4416593313,
0.2707926929,
0.096550487,
-0.157504186,
-0.7835304141,
-0.6787606478,
-0.5812287927,
-0.7128216624,
-0.0189261064,
-0.5455302,
-0.2739062905,
-0.2043648809,
-0.1843961179,
-0.2105530351,
0.0986263379,
-0.4609033763,
0.0501085334,
-0.1066856533,
0.7976447344,
-0.5779282451,
0.791156888,
0.4951442182,
-0.3079914749,
-0.606852591,
0.2292253673,
-0.01274506,
-0.9106560946,
0.6280714273,
0.1464293599,
-0.3979052305,
0.1407297254,
-0.2765309513,
-0.6505443454,
0.8667609692,
0.2646480501,
-0.3619396985,
0.0559212044,
0.4307209253,
0.6082729101,
-0.0098399296,
0.7219480872,
0.8340036869,
0.3611962795,
0.0099684913,
-1.3688927889,
-0.2413931042,
-0.2142046243,
0.093048349,
0.1151896417,
-0.4721684158,
0.4490163624,
0.0322286449,
-0.3567465544,
0.220832631,
0.6338647604,
0.037477266,
0.0286113005,
0.2944985628,
0.3429176509,
0.7559641004,
-0.1504917145,
1.0624452829,
-0.2277226448,
0.3949840069,
0.9644551277,
-0.2690478861,
1.02906394,
0.3250517249,
-0.880120039,
0.4771640301,
0.4995623231,
0.5084314942,
0.4991075695,
0.1999331266,
-0.734862864,
-0.0386552922,
0.0208918042,
-0.6911271214,
0.6272679567,
0.4155863225,
0.0001379568,
-0.5280047655,
-0.3135038018,
0.1585909724,
-0.0210037753,
-0.2035319954,
0.7547700405,
-0.0572806634,
-0.5404894948,
0.8011330366,
0.1485893428,
0.53103894,
-0.8729606271,
-0.0829312652,
-0.2167901695,
-0.0587028489,
-0.0806251839,
-0.6153247356,
0.6155115962,
0.1460967809,
0.3331680596,
0.0117307147,
0.6989774108,
-0.3144291639,
-0.2741111815,
0.0722483695,
0.6896765828,
0.3799005151,
-0.3167590797,
-0.8197119832,
-0.0277547464,
0.1900147051,
-0.2002425939,
0.5043795705,
0.3455313444,
0.2612521648,
0.6457576156,
0.5514764786,
0.2209608108,
-0.0502267592,
0.1882030219,
0.7071614265,
-0.6572095752,
-0.1755668521,
-1.159148097,
0.3672816455,
-0.1259604841,
-0.5132772923,
0.8967345357,
0.6211248636,
0.5158664584,
-0.0311743338,
0.7067014575,
-0.0428783409,
0.2486323416,
-0.7005348802,
0.8974218965,
-0.1038844287,
0.2403563857,
-0.3319986761,
-0.9112544656,
-0.2885591686,
0.7741997838,
-0.3819594085,
0.365532726,
0.8163371086,
0.7136628032,
0.1888503134,
0.3591809571,
0.5002321601,
0.187489897,
0.4208690524,
0.6149103045,
1.1735031605,
-0.3585144281,
0.4622063339,
-0.053545326,
-0.1999081075,
0.1287444532,
-0.9557049274,
-0.7460178733,
-0.63353163,
-0.0835729539,
-0.2006224245,
0.3728589118,
0.9201388359,
0.5940522552,
-0.816090405,
-0.412725538,
-0.1504558921,
-0.1304065287,
-0.2560310066,
-0.1590251923,
0.7079643011,
-0.5499344468,
-0.6762278676,
0.3687791824,
0.2686510086,
-0.1658070236,
-0.231709078,
-0.1421801448,
-0.0711952895,
-0.2710042596,
0.7830198407,
0.2255467027,
-0.7505184412,
-0.2299688756,
-0.3151466548,
0.0556610823,
0.2103790343,
0.5922346115,
-0.7249358296,
0.2940217257,
-0.0176304877,
0.8515613079,
0.5915842652,
0.0514179319,
0.6439689994,
-0.579347074,
0.0578419715,
0.4179657996,
0.2638973296,
0.3643259108,
0.0745615214,
0.6217118502,
-0.0611764751,
-0.9302428365,
-0.4420268536,
0.2425151467,
-0.88703233,
0.2207880616,
1.0184499025,
-0.1661876887,
0.3738566339,
-0.4651204646,
-0.6910925508,
-0.1417666376,
-0.5168229342,
1.0133942366,
0.963906467,
-0.1763097942,
-0.0456371345,
-1.0699902773,
0.7802019715,
0.8676779866,
-0.7446577549,
0.0110962112,
0.4275202751,
0.0189491063,
0.0362447836,
0.6993952394,
0.0466006026,
0.3625330627,
-0.0093289595,
0.0077789542,
0.1835889518,
-0.1218597516,
-0.4578515291,
0.227596283,
0.6552704573,
-0.0845396146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14975v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14975v2 | Just Ask for Calibration: Strategies for Eliciting Calibrated Confidence Scores from Language Models Fine-Tuned with Human Feedback | 2023-05-24T10:12:33 | 2023-10-24T04:27:42 | Katherine Tian, Eric Mitchell, Allan Zhou, Archit Sharma, Rafael Rafailov, Huaxiu Yao, Chelsea Finn, Christopher D. Manning | cs.CL | cs.CL | A trustworthy real-world prediction system should produce well-calibrated
confidence scores; that is, its confidence in an answer should be indicative of
the likelihood that the answer is correct, enabling deferral to an expert in
cases of low-confidence predictions. Recent studies have shown that
unsupervised pre-training produces large language models (LMs) whose
conditional probabilities are remarkably well-calibrated. However, the most
widely-used LMs are fine-tuned with reinforcement learning from human feedback
(RLHF-LMs), and some studies have suggested that RLHF-LMs produce conditional
probabilities that are very poorly calibrated. In light of this perceived
weakness, we conduct a broad evaluation of methods for extracting confidence
scores from RLHF-LMs. For RLHF-LMs such as ChatGPT, GPT-4, and Claude, we find
that verbalized confidences emitted as output tokens are typically
better-calibrated than the model's conditional probabilities on the TriviaQA,
SciQ, and TruthfulQA benchmarks, often reducing the expected calibration error
by a relative 50%. | [
-0.3381587863,
-0.5494786501,
0.6481432915,
-0.1684005409,
-0.016892314,
0.009486571,
-0.4912055731,
-0.4246580601,
0.0318256132,
0.5922815204,
-0.5219312906,
-0.5299760103,
-0.30567348,
-0.017298121,
-0.1213151366,
0.9689630866,
0.2409339845,
0.3508272469,
-0.1072450653,
0.3170591593,
-0.3667145371,
-0.5518311262,
-0.4670336246,
-0.5919531584,
0.5083117485,
0.7097496986,
0.7267512083,
0.1809074879,
0.1987034529,
0.2002859414,
0.2471854389,
0.1429678053,
-0.5799661279,
0.0327971205,
-0.1318036914,
-0.6351835728,
-0.2241757363,
0.5201025009,
0.3409874737,
0.6440209746,
-0.3314464986,
0.2806655169,
0.144726336,
0.4770715535,
-0.8242354989,
0.2816542387,
-0.4292696714,
-0.0068198121,
0.1154238507,
-0.4973599017,
-0.6960413456,
-0.6911996007,
0.2549390495,
-0.5173925161,
0.0095289852,
0.1511384994,
0.8787344098,
0.2170875967,
-0.0871004239,
-0.2036402225,
-0.8328872919,
1.0277793407,
-0.6725449562,
0.2076769322,
0.7335743904,
0.4995375276,
-0.2485489994,
-0.6936218739,
-0.3127265573,
-0.4875248671,
0.0611413531,
0.2460191548,
0.196717158,
0.2210602462,
0.0834944621,
0.1482729167,
-0.3170184791,
-0.0926836208,
-0.3133875728,
-0.5562852621,
0.786555469,
-0.1793767065,
-0.1469805539,
-0.231622532,
-0.1179585904,
-0.6757164598,
-0.7798056602,
0.3010542989,
0.4928081334,
0.3910384178,
0.2470554113,
0.4131738245,
-0.2511798143,
0.7524005175,
0.1757205129,
-0.1084604859,
0.0405511297,
-0.3170171082,
-0.0444104448,
0.0599061213,
0.830365777,
0.3815189004,
0.7902926207,
-0.2388318777,
-0.4382252991,
0.0493267104,
0.3238619864,
-0.8153262138,
-0.4884911478,
0.2007694095,
-0.1515625417,
-0.4230582416,
0.4013748169,
-0.7400248051,
-0.2594105601,
-0.1397408098,
0.697365582,
-0.186841473,
-0.0115594268,
0.0401938818,
-0.1306941211,
0.342147857,
0.2928975224,
-0.7706624866,
0.2965663373,
0.4810251892,
0.2272611111,
-0.1897887588,
-0.0816398785,
-0.865801394,
-0.3787247241,
-0.5962992311,
0.7058396339,
-0.4182919264,
-0.5517305136,
0.0794066414,
-0.0745504647,
0.0046825502,
-0.4586654902,
0.6892338395,
-0.5261513591,
0.460903585,
-0.4908540845,
-0.52286309,
-0.1374817789,
0.4484106302,
-0.4669230878,
1.1175426245,
0.1170032844,
-0.5248440504,
0.2708863318,
-0.2413583547,
-0.1472965032,
0.1115486249,
-0.3214630485,
-0.1330866367,
0.0825094804,
0.2432683557,
0.5085423589,
-0.2816551626,
0.3098754287,
-0.4832675159,
-0.5170894265,
0.549661696,
-0.7879720926,
0.2057816684,
0.2938463986,
-0.3262629211,
-0.2224478722,
-0.6095304489,
0.8321600556,
-0.207300663,
-0.4950577915,
-0.1556650549,
-0.0073062624,
0.0839774683,
0.1315311342,
0.1153311506,
-0.7667093873,
-0.3168429136,
-0.7182266116,
0.2259067893,
0.6288419366,
0.1020571217,
0.2992575169,
-0.5613479614,
0.6937125325,
-0.3075306118,
0.0693304613,
0.0258608554,
-0.408447057,
-0.6230653524,
0.0656064376,
0.600497365,
0.6237384081,
-0.6922066808,
0.4290976226,
-0.2238270938,
-0.6486461759,
-0.6303243041,
0.2002943456,
0.7260653973,
0.5877820253,
0.1122078747,
-0.5096551776,
-0.3908790946,
-0.7592426538,
-0.5500144958,
-0.4466280937,
-0.0048882635,
0.2551079988,
0.3327449262,
0.4029014409,
1.1254663467,
-0.5083708763,
0.0087305177,
0.0203602035,
0.318195045,
-0.0353442542,
0.2490634173,
0.1280393749,
-0.7281366587,
-0.4760778248,
-0.1664562672,
-0.219061926,
-0.0240251385,
0.3433963358,
0.095554404,
0.0915039852,
0.3206338286,
-0.4495429993,
0.6566661596,
0.6334062219,
0.0131841097,
0.742039144,
-0.3807916343,
0.4825256765,
-0.8922596574,
0.1147167534,
-0.0091957524,
-0.8366878033,
-0.637042582,
-0.000491344,
0.0213818531,
0.1398270577,
-0.4054740369,
0.4650439322,
-0.1517273635,
-0.0502422228,
-0.221916303,
0.2605600357,
0.167473942,
0.3900016844,
0.1598966569,
0.8353316784,
0.1667549163,
-0.6516216397,
0.3647521138,
-0.0651156902,
-0.4889050424,
0.5254198313,
-0.6803376675,
0.2607337236,
-0.0828942209,
0.3389872313,
-1.1008549929,
-0.2849780023,
-0.0009695501,
-0.7393626571,
0.2332552522,
0.0883805752,
-0.2481361926,
-0.4287339151,
-0.3718503416,
0.1560038328,
0.5648226738,
-0.4075546265,
0.3751474321,
0.5237973332,
-0.1592505723,
-0.6941734552,
-0.9117245078,
-0.1983955652,
0.0753898323,
-0.3381288648,
0.2516821027,
-0.3415610492,
-0.0226077083,
-0.1968394667,
-0.0345229916,
-0.0211918186,
0.0982174799,
0.430911392,
0.2865457833,
-0.0813606605,
0.2792337239,
-0.2677482665,
-0.1758771837,
0.2225252241,
-0.1268070787,
0.5191954374,
-0.3345138133,
-0.5197120309,
-0.4568817317,
0.0479589142,
0.4294767678,
-0.0386727341,
0.4132562578,
0.4613370597,
-0.4365493953,
-0.133924678,
-0.7274067998,
-0.694355607,
-0.4456584752,
0.3369540572,
-0.2178163975,
-0.7852575183,
0.2562836111,
-0.0937104523,
0.0698201284,
0.118588753,
0.7144357562,
-0.2643667161,
1.3962078094,
0.4363504648,
-0.012973058,
0.240907535,
0.0022325481,
0.3095434308,
-0.2931052446,
-0.1598785222,
-0.7218534946,
-0.0625219941,
-0.6599403024,
-0.4208183289,
0.2125811577,
-0.1006052196,
-0.0746936426,
0.1598759145,
-0.3951246142,
0.6241931319,
0.7630102038,
0.1797495186,
0.1275182515,
-0.1912809759,
-0.4018623531,
-0.098366119,
-0.6073170304,
-0.6656962633,
1.0325815678,
0.2758462131,
0.9127247334,
-0.1068801954,
0.7914165258,
0.2051101774,
0.5933340192,
-0.8137732744,
0.398019284,
0.1095144898,
-0.8139368892,
-0.4058643878,
-0.6179534793,
-0.6267576814,
0.0169776566,
-0.2678060234,
-0.7010132074,
0.1724912524,
0.4924074113,
-0.8194684982,
-0.2015704513,
-0.8653441668,
0.7372480631,
-0.1229302064,
-0.1809127033,
-0.0656632036,
-0.6761530042,
0.2886744738,
-0.1739130318,
0.386411041,
-0.1881562322,
0.224627763,
0.6402769089,
-0.2953637838,
0.8543304801,
-0.2036463767,
0.0328701623,
0.4011226594,
0.1253682822,
0.4908368587,
0.1802928001,
-0.3934198022,
-0.4255960584,
0.6927959919,
-0.2238113135,
-0.6293231845,
0.6096692085,
-0.869500041,
-0.5242276788,
-0.3550855517,
-0.3511231542,
-0.6642247438,
-0.0167038143,
0.5194153786,
0.2792377174,
-0.4844599962,
0.1709920615,
0.5655217767,
-0.021960197,
0.2477542013,
0.4754355848,
-0.2286703289,
-0.3689494431,
0.7340124249,
-0.0821677446,
0.5459973216,
0.3144082129,
0.4051184952,
-0.490398109,
0.0813542157,
-0.2093921304,
0.0589079075,
-0.8665403724,
-0.2632956505,
0.0277723018,
-0.3079925478,
-0.5169554949,
0.129868865,
-0.5758867264,
-0.4513794184,
-0.2784518898,
-0.2671030164,
0.1621832699,
0.6865469813,
-0.1402108371,
0.1807834953,
-0.8438190222,
-0.0753889158,
0.5852305889,
0.1827263683,
-0.2292503119,
-0.6766263247,
-0.039604947,
0.5768232942,
-0.1962710917,
-0.8891485333,
0.4759926796,
0.4403794408,
0.4628198445,
0.1871949136,
0.3433291912,
0.7528494,
-0.2669925392,
0.6430698037,
0.176293835,
-0.7527404428,
0.4239442647,
0.0842917487,
0.2530716956,
1.082773447,
0.3081392944,
-0.5674481392,
-0.2094600797,
-0.4419713318,
-0.2591375411,
0.6996002793,
-0.1235668361,
0.3750760257,
0.0462439209,
0.530585587,
-0.0203636158,
0.2420302629,
-0.6170225739,
-0.0433568507,
-0.213765502,
-0.4493373632,
-0.3456273377,
-0.1675986201,
-0.2210362405,
-0.1317315102,
0.7107674479,
-0.3001076579,
0.0684094876,
0.2999399006,
-0.1100612208,
-0.3402130306,
0.4032272696,
0.4440664649,
0.6825374365,
-0.4601117671,
0.1566677094,
0.0778321326,
-0.4789710939,
0.1169229299,
-0.0037460132,
-0.2544158995,
-0.1824021637,
0.0328888446,
0.732647419,
0.4099548161,
-0.7988552451,
0.9119920731,
-0.3900659978,
-0.3142648637,
-0.3736968637,
0.2310860455,
0.0459718555,
-0.1175667569,
0.2032384872,
-0.0875498652,
-0.1795054227,
-0.53958565,
0.3590511084,
0.457362175,
-0.9354116917,
-0.311006546,
0.2341992557,
0.2135743946,
-0.4943310618,
0.5563345551,
-0.1194576025,
-0.6701577306,
0.1538882554,
0.3208909035,
0.5094588995,
-0.4113457501,
0.5300414562,
0.4490712583,
0.2759973705,
-0.4492265582,
0.3930583596,
-0.0871037394,
-0.8082489371,
-0.5920855403,
-0.6650400162,
-0.7840948105,
-0.1665212959,
-0.8026859164,
0.2444741279,
-0.4560088515,
-0.4285311103,
-0.1857069433,
0.2835074961,
-0.7865260243,
0.4703649282,
0.1568584442,
0.8050892353,
-0.8835830092,
0.7677462697,
0.5917393565,
-0.4020119607,
-1.3541889191,
-0.1653483361,
-0.041988913,
-0.9756301045,
0.4386086464,
0.1846769005,
-0.1960935891,
0.2021307498,
-0.7211455703,
-0.6204942465,
0.9351900816,
0.4954456091,
-0.467500031,
-0.1670999527,
0.2443237901,
0.4545853734,
-0.3504380882,
0.5291001797,
0.8533462882,
0.5304628611,
0.2530286312,
-0.8722686172,
-0.1150574237,
-0.0121983681,
-0.1055233032,
-0.1347932667,
-0.2163753659,
0.480958879,
-0.2535257041,
-0.1845641583,
0.2466595322,
0.525189817,
0.426531285,
0.071014978,
0.5942681432,
0.4962722659,
0.8729521632,
-0.2557355464,
1.2100012302,
-0.4028674066,
0.3177636266,
1.0098923445,
-0.1064887866,
1.2149019241,
0.574970305,
-0.1170736179,
0.4743202925,
0.8183233738,
0.4158308506,
0.5748137236,
0.3581666648,
-0.0868634731,
-0.7301337719,
0.1134768426,
-0.0648940429,
0.5375096798,
0.3794810474,
-0.0695672184,
-0.1974747479,
-0.0322335474,
0.035563346,
0.2181966752,
-0.1038588881,
0.5047250986,
0.4556964636,
-1.3570762873,
0.4249102771,
0.1501285285,
0.4095255733,
-0.6622804403,
-0.0375373028,
-0.0964225009,
0.3138033152,
-0.1267654002,
-0.6524995565,
-0.1230898052,
-0.0613519251,
0.0148144811,
-0.1290216446,
0.6963945627,
-0.491417557,
-0.3828255832,
0.1070351228,
0.5139142871,
0.2452457696,
-0.1985570639,
-0.6781586409,
-0.2700313926,
0.0040308395,
-0.4885690212,
0.3034633398,
-0.0452534594,
0.2280958742,
0.5907042623,
0.7820721269,
0.3049751818,
0.0131062539,
0.1687292904,
0.4935253561,
-0.434602499,
-0.3353497982,
-0.4585711658,
0.2822471559,
-0.0048502851,
-0.4010667503,
0.5680878162,
-0.024255123,
0.6978829503,
0.1685248762,
0.6220008731,
0.354282409,
0.7427699566,
-0.3487729132,
0.6224142313,
-0.4549599588,
0.2966661751,
-0.1244582832,
-0.8808066845,
-0.2688208222,
0.8686674833,
-0.4000425935,
0.3357491493,
0.621157825,
1.1242852211,
0.3038114607,
0.2039519697,
0.5197803378,
-0.0414885096,
0.2685380578,
0.5694707632,
0.8129924536,
-0.4765531421,
0.6556354761,
-0.3472486734,
-0.2736193538,
-0.2782315612,
-1.0725728273,
-0.5593191981,
-0.3729221821,
-0.2367321253,
-0.5293671489,
0.0334412716,
0.9378858805,
0.933021903,
-0.9931235909,
-0.2463104427,
0.0072088107,
-0.1455935687,
0.0055521918,
-0.2280645072,
0.0826640353,
-0.2854909003,
-0.6021360159,
0.2497561872,
0.082969971,
-0.1129386798,
-0.5161280632,
-0.4588758647,
0.0873858184,
0.5005342364,
0.0766484514,
0.6370777488,
-0.6341460943,
-0.7191218734,
0.1806957871,
-0.4897752404,
-0.1286926866,
0.4109314978,
-0.9196203351,
0.6332241893,
0.545699358,
0.6181541085,
0.3622612953,
0.1760716289,
0.8695610762,
-0.8929653764,
-0.1092142835,
0.4406051934,
0.1053437218,
0.4423414171,
-0.1206029505,
0.2153201103,
-0.1733919233,
-0.8174328208,
-0.8593474627,
0.2007867098,
-0.6982220411,
0.040361654,
1.0162233114,
-0.3622560501,
-0.2619272172,
-0.0459155701,
-0.0772508457,
0.0677186549,
-0.2456855923,
0.7589065433,
0.9632642865,
0.13147071,
-0.0987493321,
-0.5699511766,
0.696814239,
0.6825301051,
-0.6277637482,
0.0053217062,
0.2490009815,
0.3699697852,
0.3040164411,
0.6473227739,
-0.0952727124,
0.6705889702,
-0.3884322643,
0.1101465449,
0.2435766011,
-0.1430050731,
-0.2683824003,
0.0299109891,
0.5760926008,
-0.0550709926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14973v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14973v2 | OverPrompt: Enhancing ChatGPT through Efficient In-Context Learning | 2023-05-24T10:08:04 | 2023-12-14T16:17:20 | Jiazheng Li, Runcong Zhao, Yongxin Yang, Yulan He, Lin Gui | cs.CL | cs.CL | The remarkable performance of pre-trained large language models has
revolutionised various natural language processing applications. Due to huge
parametersizes and extensive running costs, companies or organisations tend to
transfer the models to the target task by zero-shot prompting techniques.
However, the prohibitive costs of tokens and time have hindered their adoption
in applications. We propose OverPrompt, leveraging the in-context learning
capability of LLMs to handle multiple task inputs, thereby reducing token and
time costs. This approach could potentially improve task performance during API
queries due to better conditional distribution mapping. Evaluated across
diverse classification datasets, our experiments show that OverPrompt can
achieve cost-efficient zero-shot classification without causing significant
detriment to task performance, and in some cases, even improving it. An
ablation study conducted on various LLMs, along with an investigation into the
robustness of our prompting strategy to different input ordering, offers
valuable insights into the broader applicability of our method across diverse
tasks. These findings also suggest a more seamless integration of our method
with LLMs through an API. | [
-0.3538417518,
-0.9634441137,
0.6243946552,
0.242832914,
-0.4233285189,
-0.0289000738,
-0.3688306212,
-0.4903509617,
-0.1289418936,
0.5014699697,
-0.6371036172,
-0.5660338402,
-0.7867212296,
-0.131043151,
-0.4236468971,
1.0244828463,
0.1142758504,
-0.1575266868,
-0.1874334067,
-0.1474916488,
-0.6278845072,
-0.7283149958,
-1.1653727293,
-0.4916904271,
0.4423018694,
0.5014470816,
0.3076928556,
0.033030767,
0.2408646196,
0.273881346,
0.0969233438,
0.3513740003,
-0.5238569379,
0.6953241825,
-0.1606188715,
-0.6073648334,
-0.1398047656,
-0.1288198084,
0.352537334,
0.4947942495,
-0.3849786818,
0.2442885786,
0.3639557958,
0.4778022468,
-0.9539035559,
0.4005787671,
-0.8120634556,
-0.1024186835,
-0.2126195431,
-0.5498619676,
-0.4851305485,
-0.085659489,
0.0793366283,
-0.3249669671,
0.0711950809,
0.0879969895,
0.5326003432,
0.576189518,
-0.2565789223,
-0.3662985265,
-0.5434821248,
0.9009476304,
-0.5545045137,
0.4781293869,
0.3480345309,
0.4042077065,
-0.3095363975,
-0.7452577949,
-0.5139294267,
-0.2152637988,
-0.0157201868,
0.2951908112,
-0.3411475122,
0.0151778813,
0.2567651272,
0.1045077369,
-0.6252116561,
0.2083126605,
-0.1825157553,
-0.0686548725,
0.1732818186,
0.2533408403,
0.1608459502,
0.1272833645,
-0.395819366,
0.1610032022,
-0.7784538269,
0.2107894868,
0.0751729831,
0.6146490574,
0.0547600985,
0.4938681424,
-0.3525078595,
0.9438655376,
0.0155120417,
0.0711366385,
0.1247470602,
0.0129559664,
-0.4613665342,
0.2794783115,
0.7604829669,
0.2156570256,
0.2421517074,
-0.2121108025,
0.0195983611,
0.1179974228,
0.3737552762,
-0.9423859715,
0.0328775644,
0.5327932835,
-0.0132656824,
-0.0490779839,
-0.5171477795,
-0.6539205909,
-0.5611393452,
-0.4286375344,
0.4526255727,
-0.6490267515,
-0.1438666135,
0.1797195524,
-0.1411643922,
0.1809485704,
0.3574748635,
-0.9045922756,
0.3112521172,
0.9254745245,
1.1410669088,
-0.1596554816,
-0.2980311513,
-0.6060966849,
-0.0331224538,
-0.2113131583,
0.8916791081,
-0.4821541011,
-0.4195015728,
0.1066649556,
-0.3361917436,
-0.3287605941,
-0.6502968669,
0.5501411557,
-0.4233247638,
0.4391523302,
-0.3259596825,
-0.848895967,
0.015007697,
0.6959022284,
-0.1809320301,
1.2709138393,
0.2276234031,
-0.5927745104,
0.8324807286,
-0.9498208761,
-0.4837906063,
0.1767016649,
-0.173164621,
-0.2076963931,
-0.0364768691,
0.4907149076,
0.7106550932,
-0.1266658008,
0.1386893988,
-0.1536727399,
-0.3054502606,
0.1436239034,
-0.3726749122,
0.7482404113,
0.3702608347,
-0.3217162192,
0.2257535309,
-0.418427676,
-0.068317458,
-0.1219749227,
-0.1454559267,
-0.2885727286,
-0.1142053381,
-0.2250240147,
0.2148885876,
-0.0715176538,
-0.7045933008,
0.4178078175,
-0.6549537778,
0.5413333178,
0.4343168437,
0.1686585546,
0.4996185601,
-0.2374509275,
0.5724585056,
-0.0447367989,
0.3769088387,
-0.2622772455,
-0.5748151541,
-0.6591485143,
-0.6083248854,
-0.060622476,
0.7213132381,
-0.8922609687,
0.3544525802,
-0.0818224549,
-0.4027510285,
-0.4154079258,
0.259213686,
0.3772848248,
0.776776135,
0.422077626,
-0.4235880971,
-0.5003265738,
-0.2561010122,
-0.1710939407,
-0.128615737,
-0.366025269,
0.2716057301,
0.193739146,
-0.0560417064,
1.1559956074,
-0.5647317171,
-0.6968400478,
-0.5646479726,
0.3594151139,
0.3444706798,
0.2849410176,
0.6551689506,
-0.5080777407,
-0.6493643522,
-0.160268724,
-0.3795006573,
-0.2894174457,
-0.1752531528,
-0.265933007,
0.6143504977,
0.7305403352,
-0.9654411077,
0.2567530572,
0.3989715576,
-0.2087549418,
0.4073364139,
-0.0852628574,
0.1414142847,
-1.0157375336,
-0.0214509461,
0.0021416438,
-0.3067950904,
-0.6689172387,
-0.0546102561,
0.0235228483,
-0.2537966967,
-0.7219275832,
0.7447881103,
-0.2723537087,
0.2273079902,
-0.4612813592,
0.0934417993,
0.0194727592,
0.6584538221,
0.1153934002,
0.7356809378,
0.8198972344,
-0.7684218884,
0.4251020849,
0.1187321618,
-0.1709328592,
0.8819497824,
-0.485345602,
-0.0531260967,
-0.2039656788,
0.460239321,
-1.1212089062,
-0.1739399284,
0.6453906298,
-0.6566686034,
0.5320341587,
-0.383810252,
-0.4730411172,
-0.1713726819,
-0.3265169859,
0.1290087104,
0.6997324228,
-0.6895132661,
0.458425194,
-0.00823275,
-0.0575552359,
-0.5595018268,
-0.6595861912,
0.0636963099,
-0.4949842095,
-0.1283844411,
0.3005551994,
0.1516639143,
0.0828564167,
-0.0944348574,
-0.0764889121,
-0.1793237627,
-0.1193278357,
0.3828422427,
0.0374154113,
0.0146798464,
0.1869608909,
-0.2434895784,
-0.2079933137,
0.027300477,
-0.4780471325,
0.7996662259,
0.3460843563,
-0.6464275718,
-0.478263706,
0.12385533,
0.5034365058,
-0.0437738076,
0.9166108966,
0.809710145,
-0.2038422972,
-0.4217357635,
-0.5523440838,
-0.2989509106,
-0.5378965735,
0.1189247221,
-0.1698573381,
-0.7573409677,
0.5484139919,
-0.1171601787,
0.3004857898,
-0.0840711445,
0.7074875236,
-0.1351922899,
0.9591405392,
0.5120744109,
-0.4287345707,
0.8452836275,
-0.142939195,
0.3031205535,
-0.6101494431,
-0.1951678991,
-0.4748999476,
-0.2045761645,
-0.2849565446,
-0.3284891546,
0.377358228,
-0.0982123911,
-0.2853505611,
0.2681151927,
-0.458012253,
0.4567147195,
0.7827581167,
0.2547293305,
-0.0451163054,
-0.086118564,
0.189106822,
0.1255559921,
-0.8474136591,
0.0046452791,
0.9990329146,
0.0706646889,
0.5687142015,
0.037002746,
0.8056638837,
0.085193865,
0.313264668,
-1.2477637529,
0.3031798303,
-0.0529605336,
-0.6283562183,
-0.4566998482,
-0.3993530869,
-1.2623397112,
0.2493461221,
-0.1103228182,
-1.061871767,
-0.018448431,
0.528034091,
-0.7596668601,
0.1553861797,
-0.8556928635,
0.8059208989,
-0.0671287253,
-0.2504090071,
-0.0248087868,
-0.5664057136,
0.3224307597,
0.0555644557,
0.155317083,
-0.1563521177,
-0.0018802012,
0.3075339496,
-0.3625454903,
1.1140477657,
-0.2995576859,
0.0282666888,
0.2899342477,
0.0735005289,
0.5502658486,
-0.0999111235,
-0.0773291066,
0.0050054179,
-0.1321731806,
-0.4853583872,
-1.001081109,
0.6392301917,
-0.413589865,
-0.4149285257,
-0.3064337075,
-0.4797262251,
-0.4998131692,
-0.0184007622,
0.5855652094,
0.6983731389,
0.1838044822,
0.1056625322,
0.629993856,
-0.2674334049,
0.458758384,
0.5054027438,
-0.0462253988,
-0.0828626752,
0.8532736897,
0.1829249859,
0.3812690377,
0.2785425484,
0.2520874739,
-0.6316873431,
-0.599275589,
-0.4524685442,
-0.1943337023,
-0.6474834085,
-0.4443913102,
-0.6898543835,
-0.1644516289,
-0.6256399751,
-0.3500185907,
-0.4546770751,
-0.0865746215,
-0.3975194395,
0.10097076,
0.6452525854,
0.2436345667,
0.1930361539,
0.645234704,
-0.8543235064,
0.210626021,
0.1848272681,
0.4821953773,
-0.0343721285,
-0.7411226034,
0.0196562801,
-0.2425952852,
-0.4352466464,
-0.767917037,
0.6347926855,
0.4628431797,
0.7552075386,
0.5582842231,
0.5138702989,
0.8544463515,
-0.4734769464,
0.9354968071,
0.1575819701,
-0.9493020177,
0.4427716136,
-0.1676717252,
0.5553219318,
0.4992571771,
0.7959681153,
-0.7609497309,
-0.7120378613,
-0.6422675848,
-1.219730854,
0.7382923365,
0.2446654439,
0.3891341984,
-0.0836596787,
0.3694880903,
0.1667151153,
0.0925000459,
-0.4638672471,
-0.189306736,
-0.1343237907,
-0.245771572,
-0.0873646662,
-0.3239604235,
0.0441039093,
-0.3306366503,
0.6246452928,
-0.0962548703,
0.1712252498,
0.2026648074,
-0.2724725008,
0.0138828661,
0.3831135035,
0.494571358,
0.7225823402,
-0.1644015461,
0.1406061202,
0.5267243981,
-0.1746243089,
-0.228830412,
-0.1214976832,
0.1824707687,
0.007882813,
0.4781678915,
0.9654973149,
0.4000220895,
-0.6165471673,
0.4871783257,
0.020829048,
-0.1889063865,
-0.1907209605,
0.3320711553,
-0.2143293619,
0.3830088079,
0.293161571,
-0.210603863,
0.3562888205,
-0.7176892161,
0.1970905066,
0.4701387286,
-0.4489949644,
-0.0048314398,
0.4089563191,
0.0412955321,
-0.3259722888,
0.6165933609,
-0.361810714,
-0.639318645,
0.2533922195,
0.5597494841,
0.6850842237,
-0.1837542802,
0.1331838369,
0.2240581065,
-0.0187170636,
-0.1514428705,
0.2881502509,
-0.2875979543,
-0.6481336355,
-0.7345889807,
-0.4811768234,
-0.7076600194,
0.1751025915,
-0.5470873117,
0.480706811,
-0.2926694453,
-0.2589960992,
-0.0444010086,
-0.1719610393,
-0.5304250717,
-0.019413,
0.2719007432,
0.7288472652,
-0.8142715096,
0.8462176323,
0.5742490292,
-0.2515167296,
-0.4543989599,
-0.1674384922,
0.2007966936,
-0.8759157658,
0.5118866563,
0.1640886813,
0.1053361669,
0.0663146675,
-0.5077494979,
-0.6885047555,
0.6730673909,
0.5439784527,
-0.3166201413,
0.2719216943,
0.1393903196,
0.6375837922,
-0.0474034399,
0.5091125965,
0.7065653205,
0.2260659188,
0.5695427656,
-1.0912919044,
0.033559937,
0.1232899874,
-0.4718794227,
0.4672662914,
-0.2478159964,
0.6262415051,
0.075273186,
-0.3263542056,
-0.355394721,
0.1936773807,
0.33959952,
0.4556163549,
0.4807578921,
0.3389803171,
0.5325776339,
0.0632871836,
0.9499186873,
-0.1829306036,
0.30066818,
1.1854050159,
-0.4293185771,
0.9810510278,
0.5812560916,
-0.1876265556,
0.1562655717,
0.7879784107,
0.2992363274,
0.552195251,
0.1825491339,
-0.3591147959,
-0.2481836826,
-0.1752156317,
-0.1591791064,
0.4608159959,
0.6095852852,
-0.0262354389,
-0.7590924501,
0.3037716448,
0.1674960405,
-0.0218101889,
-0.2343405932,
0.9503116608,
0.2115609199,
-0.6674489379,
0.7860518098,
-0.4457091093,
1.0530430079,
-0.7571927905,
0.0518007092,
-0.2203994691,
0.0839714333,
-0.1944612563,
-0.7506873608,
0.5529311299,
-0.0284656901,
0.154560402,
-0.6511030197,
0.720903933,
-0.4275726378,
-0.3063714802,
0.2839137316,
0.4318964481,
0.3500513732,
-0.6819692254,
-0.7603719831,
-0.0773492157,
-0.3174879849,
-0.4751447439,
0.4709673226,
0.5736071467,
-0.0928064957,
0.8995339274,
0.7426454425,
0.1855925322,
0.0505220294,
0.2514405847,
0.8038583398,
-0.406301409,
-0.3908023238,
-1.3491005898,
0.3692600429,
-0.096798569,
-0.257994622,
0.7356768847,
0.2953227758,
0.8022834063,
0.1421929002,
0.5668549538,
-0.0707081631,
0.5667380691,
-0.5364549756,
0.6813318729,
-0.5044421554,
0.1421402544,
-0.1522949785,
-0.6164140701,
-0.597374022,
0.1424532682,
-0.4315343201,
-0.2861220539,
0.592903614,
0.7205328941,
-0.0245962385,
-0.2244153917,
0.5116948485,
-0.3189716041,
0.3477498591,
0.5488000512,
0.8828113675,
0.1139300838,
0.6128444672,
-0.2500415444,
-0.1609687507,
-0.3565433025,
-0.9887656569,
-0.9348495603,
-0.4710597396,
-0.3359539807,
0.0359021686,
0.1830780059,
1.1766867638,
0.9485066533,
-0.8999167681,
0.0336097628,
-0.2028193772,
-0.0973283276,
-0.199888885,
-0.224993825,
0.2258589566,
-1.109675765,
-0.8047108054,
0.3621712327,
0.0487454012,
-0.1208266914,
0.0201597512,
0.2000272423,
0.0239660088,
-0.038382709,
0.9477081299,
0.3619436622,
-0.4809958637,
-0.1315992624,
-0.1510057449,
0.0867823213,
0.0841133595,
0.8623740077,
-0.8597991467,
0.2782872319,
0.5718292594,
0.686123848,
0.5248331428,
0.0776582286,
0.6020541191,
-1.3031600714,
0.5139568448,
0.2157467604,
0.3225146532,
0.1563178599,
-0.7264626622,
0.3887340724,
-0.1354124844,
-0.5591702461,
-0.8601338863,
0.1781098992,
-0.8348243237,
-0.5151305795,
1.2420188189,
-0.2032785714,
-0.0758077726,
-0.4525184929,
-0.4977377355,
0.4068934023,
-0.7017768025,
0.9458118081,
0.5425060987,
-0.6305276155,
-0.2153615355,
-0.9460690022,
0.6634642482,
0.5569626689,
-0.7320962548,
0.1679510474,
0.3614428043,
0.2034517974,
-0.1236038879,
0.7611273527,
0.1414430737,
0.0336521529,
-0.2035668194,
0.1297219545,
-0.1384316832,
-0.2236325592,
-0.282327652,
0.2298209667,
0.1889052838,
-0.4917801619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16343v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16343v1 | A Distributed Automatic Domain-Specific Multi-Word Term Recognition Architecture using Spark Ecosystem | 2023-05-24T10:05:59 | 2023-05-24T10:05:59 | Ciprian-Octavian Truică, Neculai-Ovidiu Istrate, Elena-Simona Apostol | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic Term Recognition is used to extract domain-specific terms that
belong to a given domain. In order to be accurate, these corpus and
language-dependent methods require large volumes of textual data that need to
be processed to extract candidate terms that are afterward scored according to
a given metric. To improve text preprocessing and candidate terms extraction
and scoring, we propose a distributed Spark-based architecture to automatically
extract domain-specific terms. The main contributions are as follows: (1)
propose a novel distributed automatic domain-specific multi-word term
recognition architecture built on top of the Spark ecosystem; (2) perform an
in-depth analysis of our architecture in terms of accuracy and scalability; (3)
design an easy-to-integrate Python implementation that enables the use of Big
Data processing in fields such as Computational Linguistics and Natural
Language Processing. We prove empirically the feasibility of our architecture
by performing experiments on two real-world datasets. | [
-0.5603189468,
-1.0058788061,
0.4439428747,
0.476313591,
-0.1796423048,
0.1603106558,
-0.1079727709,
-0.3548998237,
0.5699377656,
0.4053789973,
-0.3485019505,
-0.5206531882,
-0.6876434684,
0.6250964403,
-0.6253689528,
0.6415606141,
-0.1101751253,
-0.4278667867,
-0.5298666358,
-0.2273927033,
-0.4510376751,
-0.5634495616,
-0.4636611342,
-0.1484648138,
0.4897383451,
0.2061251551,
0.4344691634,
0.7866433859,
0.7840617299,
0.4401529729,
0.1073875427,
0.4299364686,
-0.0477119647,
0.3873753846,
-0.1096537113,
-0.0003187553,
-0.6586723328,
-0.0748278648,
0.7700157762,
0.4920488596,
-0.2429596484,
0.25107795,
-0.0632719994,
0.3781028092,
-0.6410844326,
0.3378514051,
-0.5540198088,
-0.1436072737,
-0.563613236,
-0.3868430257,
-0.3675577044,
-0.2393893898,
0.1546183378,
-0.8640713096,
0.2198582292,
0.0701023489,
0.7918093204,
0.105460152,
-0.096326597,
-0.4204303622,
-0.3818853199,
0.6159318686,
-0.2401154339,
0.2882766128,
0.1586476415,
0.3265811205,
0.019287385,
-1.0440983772,
-0.7130069733,
0.4462229609,
-0.2446126342,
-0.023792373,
-0.0633101538,
-0.1135034189,
0.0560766459,
0.2927888036,
-0.7759850025,
0.1433493793,
-0.0772498399,
-0.0779588893,
0.6228018999,
0.4260913134,
0.1042699814,
-0.1061941087,
-0.1128949597,
-0.0198804829,
-0.6584308147,
-0.1523009837,
0.036379613,
0.6882708669,
0.3940164745,
0.3376876414,
-0.4703640938,
0.7691783905,
-0.0699985698,
0.2424590588,
0.5745872259,
-0.1133532822,
-0.4318094254,
0.164289847,
0.7502162457,
-0.0982218906,
-0.2839046121,
-0.2705004811,
-0.2539410591,
0.0452953577,
0.3910145462,
-0.7749343514,
-0.2140529156,
0.467563808,
-0.3386459947,
-0.1171388775,
-0.0582489222,
-1.0466042757,
-0.6111814976,
-0.3564896286,
0.5752057433,
-0.1409428418,
-0.4311393499,
0.1593222022,
-0.412748754,
0.0957289264,
0.2034267336,
-0.8350997567,
0.5359508395,
0.9089035392,
1.0556381941,
-0.5613048077,
-0.391674459,
-0.6903142929,
-0.0195819233,
-0.2497940063,
1.0424289703,
-0.7708451748,
-0.15702039,
0.1395211667,
-0.0003248522,
-0.4025537074,
-0.58274436,
0.3335861862,
-0.7781689167,
0.226497829,
-0.0406959243,
-0.8227600455,
-0.159953326,
0.3137875795,
-0.7093651295,
0.8700873852,
-0.1933467537,
-0.8488482237,
0.4538954496,
-0.8687590361,
-0.3555455208,
0.8498583436,
-0.1096663624,
-0.5071059465,
0.0329484716,
0.4674935639,
0.7160106897,
-0.2395943105,
0.2907681763,
-0.2513976395,
-0.5761899352,
-0.0794686228,
-0.0700981468,
0.8249316812,
0.1866431534,
-0.1506772935,
0.200805217,
-0.7312058806,
0.1415445656,
0.1800544411,
-0.1362631917,
-0.7100039721,
0.1552469581,
0.1069151834,
-0.1011271998,
0.499876529,
-0.5775927901,
0.3906679153,
-0.3782403767,
0.2450793087,
0.6055137515,
-0.2338411063,
0.413403362,
0.1466635317,
0.3960610628,
-0.1181451008,
-0.0986528248,
-0.1637224853,
-0.4816834033,
-0.6325890422,
-0.9435093403,
0.4536861777,
0.4003759623,
-0.8209799528,
0.7874547243,
-0.6029770374,
-0.4916257262,
-0.6024509072,
-0.1155741215,
0.0492060594,
0.1575826108,
0.3419094086,
-0.1977596283,
-0.6397165656,
-0.5857778788,
-0.1879638284,
0.2067722529,
0.0607390217,
0.2351476252,
0.5198072195,
-0.5474042892,
1.5031969547,
-0.9042015672,
-0.4552417994,
-0.0966920853,
0.4753703475,
0.3487719297,
0.0323468894,
0.2239879072,
-1.0461548567,
-0.5838606954,
0.2685571313,
-0.8207169771,
-0.1917161196,
0.2179574817,
0.1040288508,
-0.0012987003,
0.2201282829,
-0.6438246369,
0.1153633073,
0.6332498789,
-0.3703808486,
0.604411006,
-0.2910555601,
0.1573043168,
-1.0367872715,
0.1622603238,
-0.1617899984,
-0.2507117093,
-0.5943312049,
0.3428126872,
0.0659181997,
-0.0323978439,
-0.3269326091,
0.6852835417,
-0.2802227139,
-0.1758571714,
-0.5267215371,
0.1266336888,
0.0659206435,
0.242880404,
0.4179615974,
1.1339539289,
0.7413215041,
-1.0118960142,
0.7779537439,
0.3475969136,
-0.4576933086,
0.6055692434,
-0.5676422715,
0.0876247734,
-0.0059777508,
0.2096100897,
-0.6720505357,
-0.3090059459,
-0.1518917829,
-0.3446210623,
-0.1240557507,
0.3716729879,
-0.5471604466,
-0.3808609247,
-0.0212024953,
0.3499984145,
0.1963167489,
-0.9211310744,
0.6211996675,
0.863101542,
-0.4132654071,
-0.4829533696,
-0.4379374683,
0.2391592711,
-0.2617400289,
-0.3441497087,
0.4561507404,
0.170684889,
-0.1583501548,
0.0297840238,
0.2769502103,
-0.3989398181,
0.0238617174,
0.3401510119,
0.0306857135,
0.0226988811,
0.4385633469,
0.0592175946,
-0.0649406984,
-0.2127497047,
-0.4028707743,
0.5171172619,
-0.183021754,
0.0101114996,
-0.2486508489,
0.497700572,
0.4508779645,
-0.469584316,
0.6401433945,
0.4878266454,
-0.6012391448,
-0.5797380805,
-0.2407611758,
0.1481262147,
-0.5586231947,
0.2915710509,
-0.6093626618,
-1.014066577,
0.457810849,
-0.4181599915,
0.0855479985,
0.8843625784,
0.7952709198,
-0.0685792863,
0.7780986428,
0.6721897125,
-0.0626590103,
0.1718080044,
-0.1349092573,
0.4107091725,
-0.5934542418,
0.0690380782,
-0.7616512775,
0.0616598055,
-0.4241326451,
-0.2291099876,
0.0471437164,
-0.4579973221,
-0.2523955703,
0.7460445762,
-0.828666985,
0.3504440486,
0.3891727626,
-0.3708689809,
0.2100799084,
0.0769297183,
-0.2702012658,
0.0314168893,
-0.4835300446,
-0.3913983703,
0.7277421951,
0.2360526919,
0.139617458,
-0.1854172796,
0.9151465893,
0.7477465272,
0.2991556525,
-0.7291042805,
0.5435464382,
-0.3632793427,
-0.5134824514,
-0.3141703904,
-0.6415436268,
-0.9850949645,
0.4263131022,
-0.2041099966,
-0.3591303825,
0.2306638807,
-0.3352931142,
-0.1979127973,
-0.0099427011,
-0.5546534061,
0.7976150513,
0.1165494397,
0.1496353596,
-0.2411434054,
-0.0352441221,
0.0679188892,
-0.5266234875,
0.448658675,
-0.0141598694,
0.0222272836,
1.0174239874,
-0.2384697497,
0.5231771469,
-0.2333063334,
0.0266371388,
0.2683936357,
-0.0714771897,
0.2682429552,
-0.0004780774,
-0.1879584938,
0.4786528349,
-0.0458311662,
-0.0569014326,
-0.4567189515,
0.7317123413,
-0.6370431185,
-0.2265630811,
-0.7648758292,
-0.3651649654,
-0.1390616596,
0.48357898,
-0.0216932166,
0.3784529567,
-0.4909559786,
0.0941757485,
0.4297253191,
-0.0729088485,
0.6366074085,
0.5176258087,
-0.1109308526,
-0.5948985219,
1.177411437,
0.0389668867,
-0.3695923388,
0.4721090198,
0.0230096672,
-0.4992509186,
-0.424507916,
-0.2997145653,
-0.1021621302,
-0.5581403971,
-0.4782758057,
-0.8436133862,
-0.1538497806,
-0.4509553611,
-0.2328163236,
-0.3216131926,
-0.2941397429,
-0.2762751877,
0.0308167469,
0.4229097962,
0.7221750617,
0.3339905143,
0.4912653267,
-0.9289443493,
0.3075374663,
0.4168241918,
0.5030218363,
-0.2382811159,
-0.1390029788,
-0.324367851,
-0.1641682237,
-0.0206202269,
-0.3088836074,
0.7160664797,
0.6085580587,
0.3069224656,
0.2512871921,
0.0096895453,
0.6680148244,
-0.784758985,
0.7114495039,
0.1381745934,
-1.0978642702,
0.282749474,
-0.1161035374,
0.287404269,
0.5350632668,
0.23902224,
-0.6430248618,
-0.3962215781,
-0.4238049686,
-0.5804032683,
0.5029504299,
-0.0512573905,
0.0936925709,
-0.1189781502,
0.3071213961,
0.5507100224,
0.203581959,
-0.2654415965,
-0.2029241472,
0.1129688695,
-0.2775854468,
-0.154237166,
0.0763312429,
-0.1106290668,
-0.1815492064,
0.5149019957,
-0.3074983358,
0.3789359927,
-0.0240196493,
-0.06886857,
0.2511752844,
0.128824234,
0.0589094423,
0.5158376098,
-0.0859652683,
0.0977419317,
-0.0653864592,
-0.7447712421,
0.0649292618,
0.2546095252,
-0.1947051883,
0.1623395383,
0.3378750682,
0.5965328813,
-0.3067798913,
-0.6458560228,
0.5506231785,
-0.4508266151,
-0.3667935729,
-0.0816487446,
-0.0620864034,
-0.0322574601,
0.2430532128,
0.4440873563,
0.1097922623,
0.352602005,
-0.1161417514,
0.6298729777,
0.3858348131,
0.1027759239,
-0.0406903699,
0.4384907186,
0.3442518413,
-0.3497289419,
0.7420325875,
-0.3572306335,
-0.5959224701,
0.5020267963,
0.3842700124,
1.106990099,
-0.0943492204,
0.3305638731,
0.1373304278,
-0.1606733203,
-0.2406578362,
0.0942648798,
-0.1685935408,
-0.8090385795,
-0.4801607728,
-1.0188415051,
-0.572601378,
-0.4105033875,
-0.3254997134,
0.3516055644,
-0.3516737819,
-0.2546468079,
0.1616490781,
0.3483448029,
-0.6047731638,
0.3876730204,
0.0964916497,
0.7033275962,
-0.8310413361,
0.9894015789,
0.544801414,
-0.0351363346,
-0.3838993311,
-0.1719345003,
-0.2176862508,
-0.5293449163,
0.6789017916,
0.3167360127,
-0.1081825793,
-0.0046957787,
-0.1691248119,
-0.8435601592,
1.0302699804,
-0.0765442923,
-0.4406178296,
0.280460149,
0.2157110274,
0.6965361238,
-0.559491694,
0.2517187595,
0.460393399,
0.3919990957,
0.0494062118,
-0.972859621,
-0.0824123099,
-0.2175122947,
-0.1988774389,
0.1899358332,
-0.1162763536,
0.858882606,
0.4322118759,
-0.3323230147,
-0.3408921957,
0.8773446679,
0.1330491155,
0.5009332299,
0.4545146227,
0.6670032144,
1.024369359,
0.035499759,
0.7665799856,
-0.1330757737,
0.6765213609,
0.7069348693,
-0.5930410624,
1.18747437,
0.0458197072,
-0.1092257947,
0.3455417752,
0.6415509582,
0.0909471884,
0.7440763116,
-0.027111223,
-0.4528156519,
-0.0630233288,
-0.1087423116,
-0.1528401971,
0.6426921487,
0.6934114695,
-0.0040001795,
-0.144038409,
0.056321606,
-0.461358726,
-0.0635158643,
-0.4549684823,
0.9044733047,
0.062093854,
-0.4255075753,
0.4957103729,
0.1294998825,
0.9356584549,
-0.5489033461,
0.0109041315,
0.0877074823,
0.3886522949,
-0.4027247727,
-0.5640261769,
0.6139811277,
0.0809524879,
-0.0855381116,
-0.4661839306,
0.7725194097,
-0.3489680588,
-0.3797356784,
0.3669215739,
0.520709455,
0.0322430916,
-0.2421407551,
-0.5440536737,
0.0897555277,
-0.5944515467,
-0.1928434372,
0.3623539805,
0.375226289,
0.062787585,
0.4460509121,
0.5060554743,
0.2975497842,
0.0546404794,
-0.1232312247,
0.7552337646,
-0.3572214246,
-0.7119016051,
-0.6883326173,
0.1073616669,
-0.4274369776,
-0.3063137233,
0.7513739467,
0.5091920495,
0.5779582858,
0.0226564985,
0.7856130004,
-0.3416420817,
0.5014889836,
-0.016652083,
0.7912798524,
-0.622518599,
-0.1641140878,
-0.1535788924,
-1.178673625,
-0.8268981576,
0.5002639294,
-0.2060226649,
-0.5186574459,
0.9071505666,
0.6136542559,
0.0184541829,
0.2429121584,
0.1435825825,
-0.0850791559,
0.5543709397,
0.1345402598,
0.1396083981,
-0.2848624885,
0.1121775806,
0.0939847603,
-0.4026221633,
-0.1166934147,
-0.7919661403,
-0.5918311477,
-0.8941634297,
-0.3485296667,
0.009337334,
0.0747711137,
0.7784701586,
0.4915044904,
-0.9006981254,
-0.2203264087,
-0.1834945083,
-0.0634747818,
-0.6063920259,
-0.2426572591,
0.8252629638,
-0.5625325441,
-0.6732836962,
0.4789091945,
0.5268267393,
-0.8859090805,
-0.0697622597,
0.0760314837,
-0.2069457471,
0.141158402,
0.6576646566,
0.1209188402,
-0.1803268045,
-0.1500776112,
-0.1591680199,
-0.3571648896,
-0.0581431426,
0.7336513996,
-0.8190416694,
0.5680375695,
0.7172330022,
1.2451478243,
0.1937945187,
0.0195475854,
0.5186268687,
-0.7532517314,
-0.0743463114,
0.3296792805,
0.2759869397,
0.228272438,
-0.3312136829,
0.2134191096,
0.5472944379,
-0.7098449469,
-0.5148439407,
-0.0770595521,
-0.5771893859,
-0.3636428714,
0.9250983,
-0.2197233588,
-0.3031305373,
-0.2223588377,
-0.0660968795,
-0.0073657655,
-0.1860163063,
0.777633667,
0.7101777792,
0.0626978725,
0.0335013308,
-0.0982028916,
0.5637376308,
0.0102246311,
-0.8894572854,
0.4243687987,
0.3547363281,
-0.0123039987,
0.2726291418,
0.89120996,
0.1544806957,
0.102891773,
0.1253851205,
0.2373018265,
-0.0801937208,
-0.5462028384,
-0.60145998,
0.6487190723,
-0.3679104447,
-0.4095836282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14970v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14970v2 | Getting Sick After Seeing a Doctor? Diagnosing and Mitigating Knowledge Conflicts in Event Temporal Reasoning | 2023-05-24T10:04:06 | 2024-04-08T14:59:53 | Tianqing Fang, Zhaowei Wang, Wenxuan Zhou, Hongming Zhang, Yangqiu Song, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Event temporal reasoning aims at identifying the temporal relations between
two or more events from narratives. However, knowledge conflicts arise when
there is a mismatch between the actual temporal relations of events in the
context and the prior knowledge or biases learned by the model. In this paper,
we propose to detect knowledge-conflict examples in event temporal reasoning
using bias indicators, which include event relation prior bias, tense bias,
narrative bias, and dependency bias. We define conflict examples as those where
event relations are opposite to biased or prior relations. To mitigate
event-related knowledge conflicts, we introduce a Counterfactual Data
Augmentation (CDA) based method that can be applied to both Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs) and Large Language Models (LLMs) either as additional
training data or demonstrations for In-Context Learning. Experiments suggest
both PLMs and LLMs suffer from knowledge conflicts in event temporal reasoning,
and CDA has the potential for reducing hallucination and improving model
performance. | [
-0.2037039101,
-0.7522249818,
1.1254349947,
-0.0431763604,
-0.1928881705,
-0.0412286818,
0.2936795056,
-0.6093619466,
0.1050277352,
0.24416098,
-0.621501267,
-0.1592513621,
-0.5752046704,
-0.1360303015,
-0.1965988576,
0.7831211686,
-0.1976005137,
0.3407764435,
-0.4267998338,
-0.1013342664,
-0.3745123744,
-0.9371713996,
-0.8793306351,
-0.7958824039,
0.3205475807,
0.1650066823,
0.7023007274,
0.1108333692,
0.3611969054,
0.2250867933,
-0.0143411187,
0.3507463336,
-0.2723477483,
0.2186375409,
-0.4590165317,
-0.3415815532,
-0.4309313297,
0.0697908327,
0.2051057965,
0.5785072446,
0.0939248949,
0.0196840595,
-0.3939837515,
0.3905060887,
-0.6356530786,
0.0185561068,
-0.4133452475,
0.3491411805,
-0.3341783881,
-0.4443932474,
-0.1892021298,
-0.2860531509,
0.3956213295,
-0.7121170759,
0.0821525007,
-0.0668279901,
1.0877655745,
0.4649558961,
-0.7296955585,
-0.0020819395,
-0.6094830036,
0.6047269702,
-0.7811111212,
0.4099275768,
0.5783068538,
0.0625636429,
-0.1166169643,
-0.4502885342,
-0.9850826263,
0.1697968245,
-0.1670609862,
0.2577374279,
-0.2981164753,
-0.23823376,
0.5201512575,
-0.1593503207,
-0.7171587348,
0.235370934,
-0.0752966851,
-0.0633643866,
0.4954351485,
0.4381165802,
0.726319015,
-0.0731838793,
-0.1574118584,
0.1608764678,
-0.918634057,
-0.081809096,
0.156670332,
-0.4721364975,
-0.1726245135,
0.267451793,
-0.069333747,
0.6643801332,
0.2104844004,
-0.1029035449,
0.2460440397,
-0.3860169053,
-0.264729172,
0.1879685819,
0.4452513754,
0.5849928856,
0.3168253601,
-0.0332035348,
0.0704201832,
0.247179985,
0.179608047,
-0.6830531359,
-0.3412441313,
0.3747022152,
-0.5521891117,
-0.1063803509,
-0.3423750699,
-0.8096740246,
-0.61383003,
-0.3943242729,
0.4520207942,
-0.3665309548,
-0.4454030395,
-0.0741129667,
-0.4041338861,
0.1213797852,
0.3869562447,
-0.399717629,
-0.075656414,
0.4405623674,
0.4927392602,
0.0083441725,
-0.0265556723,
-0.6731304526,
0.4836869538,
-0.4598402381,
0.9204594493,
-0.6880479455,
-0.4442877769,
-0.0743198842,
-0.089588128,
-0.2354872823,
-0.7428424358,
0.3216305673,
-0.512824297,
0.4281088412,
-0.407251507,
-0.5909151435,
-0.0719826445,
0.0773673132,
-0.3775460422,
0.6881120205,
0.1162841693,
-0.6656387448,
0.8352508545,
-0.4765499234,
-0.6802339554,
-0.0059586032,
-0.4170837104,
-0.6229286194,
-0.0400823914,
0.369265765,
0.1716496199,
-0.2056757212,
0.603992641,
-0.2924489975,
0.0056627472,
0.1250123531,
-0.0984830931,
0.6553380489,
0.2763904035,
-0.2917213738,
0.1580878049,
-0.7319634557,
-0.2419012785,
0.3029658496,
-0.1075467095,
-0.7677023411,
0.4183931649,
-0.3420237601,
0.3996471763,
0.0186683945,
-0.2766944468,
0.2751773,
-0.3728031516,
0.0238249525,
0.5181885958,
0.4297734499,
0.1944312304,
-0.5790468454,
0.318118453,
0.8738976717,
0.2339399159,
-0.1101322174,
-0.6067547798,
-0.596775353,
0.2708304822,
-0.2271959782,
0.6324984431,
-1.1830155849,
0.3040370047,
-0.0488295592,
-0.1036665514,
-0.1403442174,
-0.0476295128,
0.352591604,
0.8891158104,
0.4801078737,
-0.25966838,
-0.827891171,
-0.3836997747,
-0.2877426445,
-0.377027303,
0.0098140072,
0.1725761145,
0.213584736,
-0.3319292963,
0.9745946527,
-0.3946306407,
-0.2360737175,
-0.1058217958,
0.3710641265,
-0.1294829398,
0.535105288,
0.7563417554,
-0.7453859448,
0.0310506858,
0.1172549874,
-0.9552410841,
-0.5026731491,
-0.3180225492,
0.2020197958,
0.5273279548,
0.5567886233,
-0.364212513,
0.8271828294,
0.3465979397,
-0.7912536263,
0.5367363095,
-0.0260504223,
0.328148067,
-0.8638985753,
-0.243355453,
0.0339951254,
-0.1940931678,
-0.758026123,
-0.3115774691,
-0.001547498,
0.0559686981,
-0.3896150887,
0.766099751,
-0.2768703103,
0.3021719754,
-0.1828430593,
0.2171367109,
0.2842349708,
0.0545062609,
0.4291636944,
0.3554147482,
0.3610803783,
-0.7697736025,
0.1625799984,
0.1961466968,
-0.2515972555,
0.7477917671,
-0.3816894591,
-0.1512280852,
-0.152697444,
0.0057234596,
-0.4245420992,
0.0736985505,
0.273663193,
-0.1990838647,
0.1341044307,
-0.2473826408,
-0.454667747,
-0.2973273695,
0.0946589634,
0.6563490629,
0.3104594946,
-0.6588948965,
0.7035799026,
0.2461050004,
-0.1608199924,
-0.5227872729,
-0.6369437575,
-0.041365914,
-0.2844094336,
-0.4526239932,
0.2724421024,
0.0295522772,
-0.585529387,
0.1022992656,
-0.2157365531,
-0.2807220221,
0.0166210122,
0.1536593884,
0.3590841889,
-0.2345557809,
0.4549620748,
0.2703550756,
-0.0342468657,
0.0869355127,
-0.1079319641,
0.5300514698,
0.3287324905,
-0.5961261392,
-0.3406611979,
0.413172543,
0.2872399986,
0.0238571931,
0.6880927086,
0.4817620516,
-0.5903254747,
0.1678153425,
-0.9399974346,
-0.3592401147,
-0.3404936194,
0.2721205652,
-0.2412492931,
-0.4078354836,
0.75119555,
-0.1785371751,
-0.2394664437,
0.4173826277,
0.4262559116,
0.0822629258,
0.9399697781,
0.1168692186,
-0.1088535488,
0.4439153969,
0.1553366035,
0.4449230731,
-0.5416759849,
-0.2332781404,
-0.356670171,
-0.0149633065,
-0.1725028306,
-0.3599829078,
0.5123049021,
0.211468786,
-0.4569589198,
0.0100831278,
-0.1248411313,
0.4282102585,
0.31223315,
0.0374114662,
0.5048441291,
-0.5698076487,
-0.266567111,
-0.1190593243,
-0.8708446026,
-0.1961760223,
0.7928072214,
0.1333623827,
0.6480756402,
0.0820085332,
0.5480086803,
0.0289359242,
0.0693314597,
-0.2700254917,
0.1711773723,
0.0338085927,
-0.5607320666,
-0.0456378423,
-0.5731083751,
-0.8489500284,
-0.017817853,
-0.26619187,
-0.9155964255,
0.7602159977,
-0.0370164923,
-0.4173418283,
0.3201479316,
-0.9871260524,
0.7834625244,
-0.2904984355,
-0.2294019461,
-0.284114033,
-0.3983196616,
0.3118294477,
0.0189724229,
0.3716948032,
0.170649752,
0.3481736183,
0.8707842231,
-0.5234393477,
0.7776566148,
-0.0950527042,
-0.1035241783,
0.0957005918,
0.2443904132,
0.4824179113,
0.3741222024,
0.1503586322,
0.1022709236,
0.3012115657,
-0.3530749083,
-0.4349137843,
0.6514530182,
-0.7508754134,
-0.8065181971,
-0.5685018301,
-0.5612438321,
-0.3678922355,
-0.019629376,
0.1370280087,
0.5712017417,
-0.0726361573,
-0.4272166789,
0.7794953585,
-0.5709385276,
0.5987058282,
0.980150342,
-0.2241044641,
0.1826376319,
0.6465656757,
0.1313050687,
0.0832759067,
0.2930283844,
0.1372863054,
-0.0377061106,
-0.503447473,
-0.3651153743,
-0.0067736278,
-0.5823970437,
-0.3621677756,
-0.8277426362,
-0.2059080303,
-0.6768039465,
-0.1992232651,
-0.1399852037,
-0.2894446552,
-0.3773262501,
-0.2311464995,
0.5162557364,
0.7918704748,
-0.2970166504,
0.2044143826,
-0.7193154097,
0.5032028556,
0.2724074721,
0.123226203,
0.1197344437,
-0.3251248896,
-0.1190217361,
-0.2556958497,
-0.5249439478,
-1.1813679934,
0.5395088196,
-0.0471781716,
0.5730440617,
0.9895341396,
0.1247609407,
0.7799270749,
-0.2993006706,
0.8061820269,
0.2321219295,
-1.1640995741,
0.7675364614,
-0.059924677,
0.2445536852,
-0.1126253009,
0.5099868178,
-0.6015864611,
-0.5410897732,
-0.7751936913,
-0.7454606891,
0.5255046487,
-0.156507194,
-0.4841406047,
-0.2498216182,
0.2255029678,
-0.1197419614,
-0.0618837252,
-0.6229693294,
-0.358517319,
-0.143141523,
-0.0642095879,
0.0000398854,
-0.3898292184,
-0.4835365415,
-0.3040384948,
0.6923231483,
0.1272839308,
-0.0772148445,
0.5503175259,
-0.214828074,
-0.4768670499,
0.3725044429,
0.5972858071,
1.1149019003,
-0.0263898354,
0.3581175506,
0.4131035805,
-0.185173586,
0.1119555309,
0.4187669158,
-0.082594201,
-0.0354238488,
0.5554248691,
0.5548721552,
0.2231881469,
-0.7378307581,
0.477816999,
0.0393223986,
0.1914287508,
-0.0661921874,
-0.2115825117,
0.1139106229,
0.4175408781,
0.4938763082,
-0.1059060171,
0.1094193682,
-0.6523830295,
0.3831793666,
0.4208800793,
-0.2784664035,
-0.1905763,
0.5401000977,
0.1254590452,
0.0246859659,
0.4648965001,
-0.3783204854,
-0.6708596945,
0.7133566141,
0.5108533502,
0.2533200979,
-0.4468608201,
0.1932266504,
0.1191981509,
0.347671926,
0.2553951442,
0.4006514549,
0.2606191039,
-0.896443665,
-0.6200851202,
-0.1648083031,
-0.2809695303,
0.4321121275,
-0.5638691783,
0.0764249787,
-0.134770751,
-0.2583377361,
0.0395866372,
0.0264944788,
-0.8397153616,
0.3554903865,
0.0723287612,
0.5590478182,
-0.9915156364,
0.8520283103,
0.5296722054,
-0.5040079355,
-0.537274003,
0.0556437299,
0.140616715,
-0.7470696568,
0.9493554831,
-0.2435560375,
0.3298962116,
-0.6084799767,
-0.131196484,
-0.5041525364,
0.6300397515,
0.1284250468,
-0.7339021564,
-0.0672288388,
-0.151561752,
0.453961134,
-0.3270908892,
0.345415324,
0.6403447986,
0.6035353541,
-0.1919782162,
-1.0224473476,
0.2380202413,
-0.0940410122,
-0.292635113,
0.2824805081,
-0.0664176419,
0.5293453336,
-0.434785068,
-0.355009526,
-0.2905217707,
0.303322494,
0.207827583,
1.0622297525,
0.3565812111,
0.8979148269,
0.7180111408,
-0.4960756898,
1.0464406013,
-0.0823010504,
-0.1394737214,
1.1843631268,
-0.6174003482,
0.3497319818,
0.5777259469,
-0.0478307232,
0.6234238744,
0.6195251942,
0.2267747521,
0.4316569865,
-0.0234840885,
-0.317288518,
-0.4998379052,
-0.196077764,
-0.9183890224,
0.07271979,
0.6590816975,
-0.1676230133,
-0.4312895834,
0.2226660997,
0.3000409603,
-0.0158923417,
-0.288172096,
1.0470862389,
0.0420563258,
-0.5289718509,
0.3009471893,
-0.2847584784,
0.3022564352,
-0.419781059,
-0.0914863274,
-0.1374686509,
0.0661835074,
-0.2080341578,
-0.5856819749,
0.4410818517,
-0.2584488094,
-0.440882653,
0.0956191495,
0.74420017,
-0.474704206,
-0.3208653331,
0.5340708494,
0.982865572,
-0.0201658159,
-0.03533848,
-0.4389800727,
0.0966334864,
-0.3684768975,
-0.1094657108,
0.4255927503,
0.751085341,
-0.384524554,
0.5829065442,
0.4707383513,
0.3160244524,
-0.174938187,
0.4125266969,
0.840087235,
-0.5243089795,
-0.5380720496,
-0.8391132355,
0.0505271032,
-0.1728613526,
-0.1086701676,
0.3125506341,
0.3381049931,
0.659398675,
-0.1313418895,
0.7437895536,
0.1216844693,
0.6335583329,
-0.633038044,
0.745808363,
-0.499434799,
0.1955023408,
-0.2631135285,
-0.0236507561,
-0.1222754344,
0.3483541906,
-0.6954423189,
0.1008042321,
0.838334024,
0.4729545414,
0.2420836985,
0.0523221679,
0.4280572832,
0.3424381912,
0.2936541736,
1.0018832684,
1.0067182779,
-0.1783338487,
0.2139036506,
-0.170144394,
-0.2696248293,
-0.0876035318,
-1.0180528164,
-0.8855640292,
-0.8615218997,
-0.6928945184,
-0.3973170519,
0.6323549151,
0.8031694889,
0.6773033738,
-0.8870456219,
0.2668913305,
0.2039090544,
0.6630703211,
-0.4618184865,
-0.3185796142,
0.3063023984,
-0.3772735298,
-0.5014443398,
0.5565825701,
0.1505785882,
0.2457444221,
0.2675769329,
0.1571742147,
-0.3472138047,
0.1067666709,
0.6983891726,
0.3439436555,
-0.5226759911,
-0.353267014,
-0.672391057,
0.2105225474,
-0.1789448708,
1.1970491409,
-1.1294630766,
0.3877829015,
0.3389707208,
0.3958634734,
0.2589022815,
-0.1828917116,
0.8509887457,
-0.6732848287,
0.1053613201,
0.1019546241,
0.5312969685,
0.0559071004,
-0.6636314392,
0.3266063631,
0.4088956416,
-0.5312843919,
-0.7426207662,
0.398077786,
-0.9295063019,
-0.4885833859,
0.9447560906,
-0.0285964143,
0.290728718,
-0.5385236144,
0.0868102983,
0.3675299585,
-0.2150600255,
1.2728550434,
0.6595535874,
-0.3053956926,
0.0027363368,
-0.4439184368,
0.9520967603,
0.4812817872,
-1.0372480154,
-0.1585623622,
0.3573789597,
0.1423056275,
0.1107101515,
0.6093342304,
-0.1955901533,
0.553374052,
-0.2478751689,
-0.0969782397,
-0.0982593819,
-0.2917901278,
-0.0907813087,
-0.1120264307,
-0.3499754071,
0.1586308777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14965v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14965v4 | Tricking LLMs into Disobedience: Formalizing, Analyzing, and Detecting Jailbreaks | 2023-05-24T09:57:37 | 2024-03-27T04:38:44 | Abhinav Rao, Sachin Vashistha, Atharva Naik, Somak Aditya, Monojit Choudhury | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent explorations with commercial Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown
that non-expert users can jailbreak LLMs by simply manipulating their prompts;
resulting in degenerate output behavior, privacy and security breaches,
offensive outputs, and violations of content regulator policies. Limited
studies have been conducted to formalize and analyze these attacks and their
mitigations. We bridge this gap by proposing a formalism and a taxonomy of
known (and possible) jailbreaks. We survey existing jailbreak methods and their
effectiveness on open-source and commercial LLMs (such as GPT-based models,
OPT, BLOOM, and FLAN-T5-XXL). We further discuss the challenges of jailbreak
detection in terms of their effectiveness against known attacks. For further
analysis, we release a dataset of model outputs across 3700 jailbreak prompts
over 4 tasks. | [
-0.1396527737,
-1.1079955101,
0.8154556155,
0.3265041113,
-0.1987773925,
0.4042001367,
-0.1209021732,
-0.3926574588,
0.2591703236,
0.5988166928,
-0.5157731771,
-0.4254836142,
-0.884129703,
0.0340361521,
-0.6050057411,
0.8315370083,
-0.0828274265,
-0.045426596,
-0.0501489453,
0.0977391452,
-0.6675483584,
-0.5152437687,
-0.2626550794,
0.0866343603,
0.5753427148,
0.3956862688,
0.4714634418,
0.2476260364,
0.6340125799,
0.3501161337,
-0.3846446872,
-0.086524412,
-0.4594814777,
0.1427467465,
-0.2271115482,
-0.390868187,
-0.2393962145,
0.0852395743,
0.1487053633,
0.2270221263,
-0.0958103463,
0.0589673705,
-0.1439119875,
0.8896520138,
-0.6297470331,
-0.2139071226,
-0.792301178,
-0.12844491,
-0.5268722177,
0.0308572333,
-0.5433057547,
-0.4273508191,
-0.5148686171,
0.0097577106,
-0.0859697163,
0.0002826858,
0.2942046821,
0.4139515758,
-0.1146952435,
-0.6935135126,
-0.5825529695,
0.5819429159,
-1.0861618519,
0.2443744987,
0.4985354245,
0.2956120372,
-0.3583722711,
-0.6325290203,
-0.4729292393,
-0.7384305,
0.0704730749,
-0.3131864965,
-0.3566633463,
0.0800655112,
0.4769241214,
0.400434047,
-0.3744547963,
0.3646619916,
-0.4515671432,
-0.0958197787,
0.7953990102,
0.1374204755,
0.5209955573,
-0.1448832452,
-0.4500381351,
0.3233705759,
-0.9349555969,
-0.0849695206,
0.7737374306,
0.0811065659,
-0.0879070684,
0.5725291371,
0.1209040806,
0.8081729412,
-0.0521004312,
-0.044653926,
-0.2082077414,
-0.2087883353,
-0.0922283679,
0.0158580821,
0.8266830444,
0.2541207373,
0.1649320573,
-0.3842401206,
-0.4495255947,
0.0638562515,
0.1751555204,
-0.6173948646,
-0.3966537714,
0.4583275914,
-0.2209938765,
-0.7726200819,
0.1689182669,
-0.6823736429,
-1.1148153543,
-0.011530824,
0.2923778594,
-0.3746559024,
-0.2028758973,
0.2125197202,
-0.2194326818,
0.0086443899,
0.1871559471,
-0.8496693969,
0.5158563852,
0.6263000965,
1.0692266226,
0.0671604797,
-0.1427668333,
-0.3982211947,
0.0487159267,
-0.056592159,
0.4362818003,
-0.3078258038,
-0.432333976,
-0.1327078789,
-0.2123981118,
0.1556978226,
-0.5034161806,
0.3812724948,
-0.7880921364,
-0.3608038425,
-0.2723980546,
-0.6686442494,
0.2129279375,
0.2821975946,
-0.874446094,
0.5496791005,
-0.1141861975,
-0.9058413506,
-0.0326677412,
-0.6521716118,
-0.4202564359,
-0.1534856409,
0.0818516612,
-0.238216877,
0.3167173266,
0.0218033455,
0.4278530478,
0.0670742467,
0.4291437864,
-0.2861526608,
-0.3333035707,
0.7181609869,
-0.2705441415,
0.889977634,
0.4974210262,
-0.5043858886,
0.0378698781,
-0.5191068053,
-0.5119681358,
0.4505208135,
-0.1465386599,
-0.5093792081,
0.338883549,
-0.1810383797,
0.0915444493,
0.4492649436,
-0.6760422587,
0.4580108225,
-0.1788415164,
0.9906517863,
1.0121767521,
0.085284844,
0.0511258282,
-0.1232624277,
0.4815228581,
0.0259967968,
0.3871353269,
-0.157413736,
-0.2676440179,
-0.1575138867,
-0.2200081944,
0.2844747603,
0.5298754573,
-0.4440787435,
0.0224134643,
0.117717579,
-0.6758044362,
-0.390119642,
0.4097076356,
0.3539116979,
0.3677219152,
0.2657155991,
-0.0645041391,
-0.5589338541,
-0.5415549278,
-0.6674544811,
-0.3392452598,
0.2711035013,
0.1024744436,
0.3997651339,
-0.1842771173,
0.8419898152,
-0.5570259094,
-0.0800645649,
-0.2448016405,
0.157789126,
0.21808815,
0.2246006429,
0.5261157751,
-0.6767016649,
-0.122500591,
-0.5660312176,
-0.5445731878,
-0.3799455166,
-0.0922598466,
0.5318345428,
0.1045660749,
0.9256107211,
-0.3652312458,
0.2725478709,
0.5262109637,
-0.5148373246,
0.8837037683,
0.018922301,
0.1594898254,
-0.8483322263,
-0.3152890801,
0.0210637078,
-0.2775397599,
-0.6210664511,
0.3373425007,
0.010800289,
0.0453155488,
-0.6859694123,
0.2257377058,
-0.3176092207,
-0.0015055829,
-0.3243164122,
0.2010735273,
-0.2877780199,
-0.0944495797,
-0.2485410273,
0.7276165485,
0.3197618723,
-0.4134381115,
0.5976480246,
0.0886223763,
-0.3427973688,
0.0002584469,
-0.8838787675,
0.3505839407,
0.005974784,
-0.0596241578,
-1.2660118341,
-0.2063805014,
0.3934175074,
-0.4522852302,
0.1559403837,
-0.5373708606,
-0.7395022511,
-0.3048915863,
-0.5174859762,
0.275857538,
0.5186054111,
-0.5034831762,
-0.0745310783,
0.4903383553,
-0.1742651016,
-0.4837176502,
-0.7983056903,
0.4094463289,
-0.4411310554,
-0.6657343507,
0.235855639,
-0.2251418829,
-0.817348659,
-0.235893324,
-0.0162928812,
0.0396343395,
0.6281173825,
0.2696094215,
0.2135577947,
0.1456246525,
-0.2927223444,
-0.0842083618,
0.1726255566,
0.406797111,
-0.0203805324,
0.5408598185,
-0.2414168864,
-0.551833868,
-0.1561113149,
0.0439141095,
0.761290431,
-0.2498547435,
0.5651361346,
0.0755371824,
-0.1535298228,
-0.0153716467,
-0.3955212831,
-0.2545540929,
-0.5733332038,
0.0648773164,
-0.1313524991,
-1.0140498877,
0.4967992306,
-0.4596397281,
0.1569824666,
-0.2396004796,
0.5399900675,
-0.0556736551,
0.7444992065,
0.5837461948,
-0.2836503685,
0.5433561802,
0.1557473689,
0.3626154959,
-0.4870782793,
-0.1211294383,
-0.4364935756,
-0.3559883833,
-0.6776658893,
-0.352155596,
0.1537855566,
0.4168689251,
0.0232497025,
0.4577761889,
-0.287117362,
0.7136493921,
0.0579789244,
0.0826996267,
0.5790001154,
-0.4166529179,
-0.1315110922,
0.0184373781,
-0.3084788322,
-0.7489237785,
0.9284875393,
0.6603044868,
1.1067500114,
0.5755829811,
0.9823738933,
0.6850228906,
0.2472827137,
-0.8359724283,
0.6035331488,
0.1570237577,
-0.6359968781,
-0.2195207775,
-0.29266271,
-0.6239302754,
-0.1808914244,
0.2600764334,
-1.1059510708,
-0.0632251576,
0.3327774107,
-0.1665142477,
0.5532436967,
-0.596020937,
0.674159646,
-0.424482733,
-0.5805185437,
-0.1193760708,
-0.67191118,
0.951510787,
-0.0800013468,
0.7738411427,
-0.2493486851,
0.0842215791,
0.5532160997,
-0.5919494033,
1.2029153109,
-0.4401055872,
-0.4414678812,
0.3420567214,
0.4819234014,
0.7219877839,
0.2795834839,
0.228716433,
0.0467337407,
0.0416293703,
-0.2145617902,
-0.4879446328,
0.7829295397,
-0.5258871317,
-0.8198533058,
-0.305983603,
-0.3467891812,
-0.1518146843,
-0.0156124569,
0.2227635533,
0.0645687506,
-0.2481066138,
-0.4491635859,
0.9380021691,
-0.1239769161,
0.521247685,
0.7171017528,
-0.5416615009,
-0.2951560915,
0.8058594465,
-0.0194371864,
0.1240241602,
-0.0519388765,
0.2680090964,
-0.2503497005,
-0.9057007432,
-0.2909041941,
0.2109462023,
-0.5462907553,
-0.1634771377,
-0.2809661329,
-0.1706233025,
-0.4415753186,
-0.1734696925,
-0.331864655,
-0.4971086383,
-0.0943136439,
-0.2614838481,
0.6823626161,
1.0984811783,
-0.2140816897,
0.3502030671,
-0.8894196153,
0.398554951,
0.1823408902,
0.308105886,
-0.1236735284,
-0.5431734324,
0.0222908277,
-0.2160243094,
-0.3045205176,
-1.4852734804,
0.1216880679,
-0.2317857742,
0.3611072302,
0.4478715658,
0.294000268,
0.4333999753,
-0.6439311504,
0.8438442945,
0.2557301819,
-1.251331687,
0.9650971889,
-0.3515723944,
-0.3048779368,
0.5340189338,
0.3767653704,
-0.7615650892,
-0.7640362382,
-0.5803077817,
-1.0313512087,
0.3685798645,
0.0635906309,
0.3308941722,
-0.1308446527,
0.3514756262,
0.0999986455,
0.2434479147,
-0.8773631454,
-0.2398649603,
-0.1723617762,
-0.0070359795,
0.0292651374,
-0.4108017087,
-0.1279657036,
-0.2554500997,
0.448638916,
0.3432412744,
-0.1513665766,
0.0853709728,
-0.5892541409,
0.2067693323,
0.6119859815,
0.832801044,
0.6127361655,
-0.1606685072,
0.348983258,
-0.1775745749,
-0.5748705864,
0.5139330029,
-0.0367699154,
-0.1778435707,
0.0753835142,
0.1745113581,
0.4639597833,
0.0548498146,
-0.8868758678,
0.6023357511,
-0.1091835946,
-0.1110723391,
-0.4503308833,
0.1234759539,
0.1074359044,
0.2978515923,
0.0098612662,
-0.1282899827,
0.2547554374,
-0.4852486551,
0.2999436557,
0.3435903192,
-0.4600450993,
-0.4746800661,
0.6846740842,
0.1700097024,
-0.2512359321,
0.4610059261,
-0.2278899401,
-0.418661803,
0.4728907049,
0.6751515269,
0.7470437884,
-0.3132390678,
0.2455261648,
0.0237517301,
0.7344325781,
-0.0554609746,
0.3161717355,
-0.0456449613,
-0.6447236538,
-0.4712473154,
-0.4811953008,
-0.5407009721,
0.3810124993,
-0.6526622772,
0.3573732674,
-0.8228757977,
-0.1412694007,
0.0244858358,
-0.2935706675,
-0.0180877112,
-0.4267911613,
0.4502272904,
1.3101254702,
-1.0907512903,
0.6926683187,
0.8101953268,
-0.3925888836,
-0.3831276596,
0.027752433,
0.2922445238,
-0.5404921174,
0.5013949871,
0.1767294705,
-0.1177712902,
0.0239217803,
-1.0079630613,
-0.3648842871,
0.8488075137,
0.4171889424,
-0.9864200354,
0.2048915625,
0.2181369066,
0.090921469,
0.2078812271,
-0.1185148731,
1.0265175104,
0.6779757142,
-0.108867608,
-0.5861610174,
0.254499346,
-0.1039795503,
-0.1931891441,
0.4679133296,
-0.5933737159,
0.6611038446,
-0.6057271957,
0.0360518694,
0.0468243323,
0.3805702627,
0.5797591805,
0.4865517318,
0.4494901896,
0.596596241,
0.7248554826,
-0.0593189448,
0.7404785752,
-0.2518861294,
0.1933828294,
0.981882453,
-0.4240687191,
0.5564460158,
0.9197247028,
-0.2609881461,
0.5210633278,
0.7098784447,
-0.1203671098,
0.6690316796,
0.7778193951,
-0.3911022842,
0.0245997421,
0.1646003723,
-0.0856512636,
0.2666210532,
0.5449692011,
-0.1848029345,
-0.3186982274,
0.1052486971,
0.4936859906,
0.3038311005,
-0.4272464514,
0.885293901,
0.3376227617,
-0.229385674,
0.4610049427,
0.4314031601,
0.8005259037,
-0.4774006009,
0.200415194,
-0.1595076919,
-0.1050930619,
-0.3061126471,
-0.7740851045,
0.4168919027,
0.5284867287,
-0.038931407,
-0.0991570577,
0.9223656654,
0.0645172521,
-0.1496920437,
0.3305817544,
0.3784554601,
0.1894860715,
-0.1740945876,
-0.6182337403,
0.3389052451,
-0.1878634691,
-0.2672887743,
0.372259438,
0.1340410113,
-0.0050474741,
0.5339395404,
0.6356656551,
0.0537182987,
0.3372491598,
-0.0034035612,
1.1638776064,
-0.7985493541,
-0.2324060947,
-1.578512311,
0.5395064354,
-0.0929220691,
-0.0307006147,
0.7900297046,
0.3380992413,
0.6586487293,
-0.0172949061,
0.9749262929,
-0.284409821,
0.0343507081,
-0.8903775215,
0.6986903548,
-0.2395802736,
0.8943843246,
-0.4870983958,
-0.3636013865,
-0.0508537926,
0.1706001908,
-0.5735327005,
-0.3431617618,
0.3771930337,
0.6756632924,
0.0664158612,
-0.0264008716,
0.2870693505,
0.3559865654,
0.4210239351,
0.3318620324,
1.4003546238,
-0.1444475204,
0.3108431995,
-0.1259466559,
-0.4062485099,
-0.2462626845,
-1.0117640495,
-0.8061615229,
-0.302715987,
-0.331155628,
-0.3444054425,
0.2027464062,
0.6105960608,
0.2630626857,
-0.6928808093,
-0.2185721546,
-0.362929076,
0.4486144185,
-0.0482009202,
-0.2070407122,
-0.1652154028,
-0.5598611832,
-0.3711535931,
0.734791398,
0.1818058342,
0.2023361772,
-0.3915015757,
0.0524122342,
0.0430360697,
0.3427449763,
0.5507258177,
0.3251565695,
-0.5634740591,
-0.0304313712,
-0.1161434054,
-0.0261641741,
-0.1459673345,
1.0444047451,
-0.5341603756,
0.1523012966,
0.3793179393,
0.435464263,
0.0654116645,
-0.0225305986,
0.2824500501,
-0.9540151358,
0.170041129,
0.3206607699,
0.3723532856,
0.1978081912,
-0.4944097102,
0.2263389528,
0.2123973966,
-0.5677719116,
-1.0435833931,
0.6864760518,
-0.5668660998,
-0.7433547974,
1.0466542244,
-0.3326047063,
-0.3591350615,
-0.1871515661,
-0.0996382236,
-0.1892803162,
-0.2379688323,
1.0191996098,
0.8014631867,
-0.0583253652,
-0.1285826564,
-0.6762607098,
0.5065624118,
-0.0159687512,
-0.7012979388,
0.4818970561,
0.5229295492,
0.5441092849,
0.0031660951,
0.5265202522,
-0.5813783407,
0.1151175275,
-0.2634045482,
-0.0968038365,
-0.410564959,
-0.3209732771,
-0.633228004,
-0.0303511564,
0.6340959072,
-0.0136267319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14964v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14964v2 | Detecting Multidimensional Political Incivility on Social Media | 2023-05-24T09:57:12 | 2023-11-14T22:41:40 | Sagi Pendzel, Nir Lotan, Alon Zoizner, Einat Minkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rise of social media has been argued to intensify uncivil and hostile
online political discourse. Yet, to date, there is a lack of clarity on what
incivility means in the political sphere. In this work, we utilize a
multidimensional perspective of political incivility, developed in the fields
of political science and communication, that differentiates between
impoliteness and political intolerance. We present state-of-the-art incivility
detection results using a large dataset of 13K political tweets, collected and
annotated per this distinction. Applying political incivility detection at
large-scale, we observe that political incivility demonstrates a highly skewed
distribution over users, and examine social factors that correlate with
incivility at subpopulation and user-level. Finally, we propose an approach for
modeling social context information about the tweet author alongside the tweet
content, showing that this leads to improved performance on the task of
political incivility detection. We believe that this latter result holds
promise for socially-informed text processing in general. | [
-0.3851564229,
-0.7236456275,
0.6436541677,
0.3660872281,
-0.2446113378,
0.505012095,
-0.343365103,
-0.1096046194,
0.5342127681,
0.2043569386,
-0.4737980962,
-0.3425799012,
-1.006370306,
-0.1837778538,
-0.3356765807,
0.8035379052,
0.3701373339,
-0.313320905,
-0.182222411,
-0.6612325311,
0.0094280327,
-0.9503291845,
-0.2211147398,
-0.4294166863,
0.4604896605,
0.6772158742,
0.5106253624,
0.3076127172,
0.3070164323,
0.3054014742,
-0.1169230491,
-0.0844904929,
-0.7115750909,
0.3174574673,
-0.2535765171,
-0.2076703608,
-0.1522289962,
0.2672672868,
0.4056313932,
0.0083439732,
0.0681754872,
0.2676996887,
-0.0382604189,
0.5624954104,
-0.4624345601,
0.1256877184,
-0.8776315451,
-0.1960282028,
-0.5322111845,
-0.5197451115,
-0.1523229033,
-0.4223897159,
-0.2580857873,
-0.4044700563,
0.1893886328,
-0.3802665472,
0.4225202203,
-0.0644945875,
-0.4643412828,
-0.4217436314,
-0.5276165605,
0.5529578924,
-0.3521798253,
0.2285300344,
0.2414213866,
0.2437443286,
-0.0367444828,
-0.2639571726,
-0.9905511737,
0.0089568524,
0.2232857198,
0.0491531603,
0.0726256743,
-0.4368736446,
0.2092631757,
0.2771125734,
-0.3196474016,
-0.1959266812,
-0.0693979189,
0.0676088482,
0.5738655925,
-0.0932047814,
0.2293276042,
-0.5501744151,
-0.3278736472,
-0.1463310272,
-0.3015110791,
0.3640567362,
0.8460348248,
0.5567791462,
-0.3312458992,
0.7761861086,
-0.0199415367,
-0.2218873501,
0.2045522779,
0.1206961572,
0.3048190773,
-0.5316633582,
0.0463463441,
-0.2325734198,
0.6873613596,
0.2178717554,
0.2983907163,
0.3309497237,
-0.0697971061,
0.2404210269,
0.0776473656,
-0.6082224846,
-0.2156301439,
0.3275409341,
-0.7907074094,
-0.4113937914,
0.1631916165,
-1.046577096,
-1.2648254633,
-0.1735857725,
0.2139160782,
-0.4080988765,
-0.9773848057,
-0.4554149508,
-0.4103268683,
0.0632080585,
0.3154549897,
-0.4621770382,
-0.1400635391,
0.7905132174,
1.0920485258,
0.103415221,
-0.0582547896,
-0.5524605513,
-0.0615158416,
-0.2174864858,
0.6852520704,
-0.8341059685,
0.1373749375,
0.1156690344,
-0.1704826802,
0.1405040622,
-0.4646561146,
0.4788623154,
-0.4233864248,
-0.295956552,
-0.4898532927,
-0.3101248443,
-0.0706582069,
0.3964083195,
-0.5760045052,
0.9400838017,
0.4352295697,
-0.7781159878,
0.8851779103,
-0.8605917692,
-0.1733743995,
0.1829860955,
-0.2967256904,
-0.457909286,
0.3793053329,
-0.1165660173,
0.5096026659,
0.1797359586,
0.4332990646,
-0.7757012844,
-0.0596430674,
0.2603863776,
-0.2821716666,
0.9327685237,
-0.199064672,
-0.3817376196,
0.5408803821,
-0.6515004635,
-0.4145126641,
0.0017389037,
-0.168969363,
-0.4805357456,
0.2375951409,
0.0375704058,
0.8237116933,
0.0357142948,
-0.6566605568,
-0.19392775,
0.0142492112,
0.6177319288,
1.069265604,
-0.0073354752,
0.570863843,
-0.2670366466,
0.3385166526,
0.3215917945,
0.1987717152,
0.3902829587,
-0.3139517307,
-0.5413574576,
-0.2376787364,
-0.4505958855,
0.4687530696,
-0.8986703753,
0.0206094366,
-0.4292106032,
-0.4449720979,
-0.3780360818,
0.0702524856,
-0.1167501733,
-0.0300608277,
0.1959124953,
0.3738634288,
-0.2429011017,
-0.7001972198,
-0.6810295582,
-0.3114193976,
0.2465645075,
0.215214923,
0.7197932601,
-0.0055264151,
0.4853106737,
0.2560236752,
-0.2823212445,
-0.1634278595,
0.3673845828,
-0.1793728173,
0.216799289,
0.4713509679,
-1.1683160067,
-0.5643537045,
0.1111177206,
-0.3988066614,
-0.0918130577,
0.111447297,
-0.0807513669,
0.3306474388,
0.7165074944,
-0.2656807601,
0.6079298854,
0.4988239706,
-0.5742839575,
-0.049590271,
0.120469816,
0.6217475533,
-0.7795202732,
-0.2312097549,
0.2681433856,
-0.285533756,
-0.5952216387,
-0.2616058886,
0.0398639999,
0.2659649551,
-0.3400810659,
-0.0582389832,
-0.0798191503,
0.5034521818,
-0.0281886831,
-0.0334500037,
-0.3242807984,
0.0104092807,
-0.1440222263,
0.1880581826,
0.1996684968,
-0.220781669,
0.2759822607,
-0.2085409909,
-0.3678761721,
0.9494794607,
-0.2320504934,
0.2430453449,
-0.6036235094,
0.1106031984,
-1.5663349628,
-0.5498535633,
0.3480996192,
-0.5179236531,
0.0281604677,
-0.1463591903,
-0.7528321743,
-0.231243372,
-0.7669315934,
0.3461246192,
-0.2631396353,
-0.4909962416,
0.7190513611,
0.9025602341,
0.0228826459,
-0.212922886,
-0.4207012653,
-0.0156431701,
-0.482681334,
-0.4395323396,
0.0337334946,
-0.0838219002,
-0.3994571269,
-0.0174515508,
0.0849204287,
-0.1204429492,
-0.3063112795,
0.2758887112,
-0.2521630526,
0.1998755932,
0.270092696,
-0.0888302922,
0.1803222746,
0.0452960767,
0.1183066368,
0.6897379756,
-0.0470138192,
0.0403156579,
-0.6390628219,
0.7357158661,
1.0746650696,
0.0129376333,
0.9973828197,
0.6295537949,
-0.2843070924,
-0.0687493607,
-0.6585634351,
-0.0587841719,
-0.4436987936,
0.2554015517,
-0.2521835268,
-0.8900806904,
0.7276513577,
0.1921446621,
0.0620022304,
0.4086162448,
0.6208812594,
0.2233686745,
1.0100021362,
0.8829900622,
0.0481810234,
0.3362193704,
0.071732685,
0.5435623527,
-0.2855166197,
-0.48117432,
-0.7533191442,
-0.3291420937,
-0.9072303176,
-0.3078047335,
-0.0109504079,
-0.5688140988,
-0.4429427385,
0.0696189031,
-0.8192666173,
0.328667134,
0.2240010947,
0.082496956,
0.0675982386,
0.0654223114,
0.6152765155,
-0.272010088,
-0.5186131001,
-0.2199644893,
0.5938405395,
0.3312336504,
0.3586055636,
0.3345339596,
0.2409040183,
0.4529921412,
0.8364080787,
-0.6747891903,
0.2898927629,
-0.2400683761,
-0.5615983009,
-0.3600280285,
-0.6948814988,
-0.4771274924,
0.222814247,
-0.3360302746,
-0.651674509,
0.562255621,
0.1050843447,
-0.0859375969,
0.6425468326,
-0.5514265895,
0.7031862736,
0.0239359457,
-0.1873850226,
-0.2047256678,
-0.5725811124,
0.3919858038,
-0.0709594414,
0.6637519002,
-0.596457839,
-0.261836797,
0.2475701123,
-0.229513675,
0.711910367,
-0.5754413009,
0.100666441,
-0.0053232643,
-0.0453744568,
0.32387802,
0.0714813247,
-0.2562544942,
0.2399863452,
-0.018852992,
-0.3599929512,
-0.0357433371,
1.0316531658,
-0.5190965533,
-0.09411221,
-0.3380436003,
-0.7398818135,
0.1477626413,
-0.1543744206,
0.6015635133,
0.023609275,
-0.142844364,
0.5072349906,
0.4690436423,
-0.0031057396,
0.4782834649,
0.0723622888,
0.1239245981,
-0.2925688922,
0.9869265556,
0.8763911128,
0.0047133346,
0.160296455,
0.2591319084,
-0.4050133526,
-0.2499666661,
-0.2110432386,
0.0912537053,
-0.380384922,
-0.3536207676,
-0.6944534183,
0.1257746965,
-0.4085600376,
-0.2104899436,
-0.3055303097,
-0.5208738446,
-0.2832197547,
0.3638045192,
0.4667380452,
0.9728155136,
-0.0628545731,
0.4848834872,
0.082623519,
0.353569746,
-0.1041555032,
0.5628399849,
-0.1226557717,
-0.7679982781,
0.1451284885,
-0.2347485572,
-0.2951014638,
-1.0953549147,
0.1610996574,
0.1713316292,
0.1531545669,
0.483363241,
0.5212712288,
0.63444525,
-0.2269372046,
0.6309531927,
-0.0921924859,
-0.7585818172,
0.5005743504,
-0.410692811,
-0.1639843583,
0.5877058506,
0.3971169591,
-0.2382223904,
-1.0142530203,
-0.7262839675,
-1.0805727243,
0.6405733824,
0.0295519773,
0.7146112919,
-0.0018547069,
0.4094074965,
0.2309824675,
0.4211998582,
-1.0477519035,
-0.2297188789,
-0.6130441427,
-0.1846278608,
0.0405959077,
-0.5021727681,
-0.3333641291,
-0.423514545,
0.5074508786,
-0.0352496319,
-0.1760681272,
0.021576196,
0.1012951732,
-0.2223649472,
0.1270902604,
0.6363102198,
0.8767302632,
-0.174123019,
0.2256700695,
-0.4031772017,
-0.2565612197,
0.264726311,
-0.1380295008,
0.1799456775,
0.0726947114,
-0.0173212197,
0.0366015509,
-0.3278379142,
-0.0339949802,
0.9148745537,
-0.1969871372,
-0.2803395391,
-0.6365012527,
-0.240694657,
0.2415472418,
0.4145175219,
0.5123172402,
0.0760968924,
-0.0269831549,
-0.8083704114,
0.0785257593,
0.8742005229,
-0.2585055232,
-0.449622333,
0.652998209,
0.1316534132,
-0.4424486756,
0.029241994,
-0.4430979788,
-0.5389906764,
0.4384145737,
0.235733673,
0.6885035634,
-0.4450573921,
0.4072962105,
0.1763408631,
0.6497689486,
0.3857810497,
0.4293675125,
-0.1692739129,
-0.758859992,
-0.1450192481,
-0.2423030138,
-0.1402281523,
0.6862570643,
-0.2987143993,
0.0168901179,
-0.8701697588,
-0.5164718032,
0.4111938179,
0.1938565075,
-0.5399689674,
-0.329880774,
-0.105867058,
0.7718515396,
-1.1981770992,
0.5080108643,
0.6010412574,
-0.0382919125,
-0.17035155,
0.4069020152,
0.4919770658,
-0.3736073673,
0.3751170337,
0.4682092965,
-0.2794926763,
-0.3801911175,
-0.9871581197,
-0.3070967495,
0.5849424601,
0.5469337106,
0.0698122308,
0.5507641435,
0.1515806168,
0.2753021419,
-0.4139475822,
-0.0368909948,
0.6709173918,
0.6306455135,
-0.2828931212,
-0.3506835699,
0.2207327932,
-0.5517240763,
-0.0275743883,
0.4276743829,
-1.0706665516,
0.9125477076,
0.3566874564,
-0.4195809066,
-0.2841673493,
0.4988185465,
-0.1214597002,
0.7527048588,
0.8143379688,
0.1671450883,
0.6776251197,
-0.3202806711,
0.7640487552,
-0.1662795842,
0.172129944,
0.7227219343,
-0.1594094485,
0.596193552,
0.6004158258,
0.3495213091,
0.4404798448,
0.2907077074,
0.347210288,
0.2444649935,
0.0689145848,
-0.6377439499,
-0.2539412379,
-0.5238842964,
-0.0811246857,
0.4353313446,
0.6245235205,
0.0140458411,
-0.2448499799,
0.1769410521,
0.2489269525,
0.5629963279,
-0.2986700833,
0.453771323,
-0.2326058,
-0.3680334091,
-0.0016457299,
-0.1878532469,
0.6942321062,
-0.3265825808,
0.0116138952,
0.122510761,
0.2319552302,
-0.3891318738,
-1.2081053257,
0.517762959,
-0.052873306,
-0.4247559011,
-0.322101742,
0.5932613015,
-0.426468879,
-0.1547791064,
0.7540678382,
0.5330526829,
-0.0470258109,
-0.4464305937,
-0.6203833222,
0.3686931133,
-0.1824888736,
-0.4743768573,
0.2084025592,
0.9929260612,
0.005485978,
0.5117617846,
0.8332634568,
-0.0017898692,
-0.2409343272,
0.1740387976,
0.9822401404,
-0.327547878,
-0.3050522804,
-1.0510714054,
0.4349088371,
-0.6862220168,
-0.404674679,
0.8696009517,
0.3749143481,
0.8585702777,
0.477129668,
0.7688215375,
-0.3939124346,
0.7493233681,
0.1227880418,
0.6907770038,
-0.6570725441,
-0.0131344693,
-0.1749921739,
-0.2245871872,
-0.4017389119,
0.5670555234,
-0.1955323815,
0.071702823,
0.093166396,
0.8645268679,
-0.2331584096,
-0.072929211,
0.1826994419,
0.2581141293,
0.3610564172,
0.3498494923,
0.9119003415,
0.2983916402,
0.7106512785,
-0.5989232063,
-0.5344073176,
-0.4637774229,
-0.854861021,
-1.1099132299,
-0.8062167764,
-0.1056846529,
-0.8459240198,
-0.1945503801,
0.8664819598,
0.7997268438,
-0.5514826775,
-0.2378079891,
0.0949860588,
0.3742588758,
0.0244492851,
-0.421628952,
0.3533349931,
-0.1291256845,
-0.6492492557,
-0.1960332394,
0.6035447121,
-0.2724902928,
-0.1341142356,
0.3162157834,
-0.5021888614,
0.4980838001,
0.96254915,
0.2486990839,
-0.2639757395,
-0.6305654049,
-0.1161169037,
0.0391595066,
0.3847919703,
0.9287184477,
-0.3568582535,
0.4827870727,
0.8565612435,
0.022312535,
0.0015324781,
0.3971475363,
-0.0351703241,
-0.8777170181,
0.3802255392,
0.3733031452,
-0.0460448191,
0.6561877131,
-0.5965207219,
0.1226292327,
0.3250766993,
-0.673279345,
-0.8820165396,
0.3342698514,
-0.6111912131,
-0.0505649559,
0.8231600523,
0.2548080087,
0.0935411826,
-0.392568171,
0.1139393374,
0.3009283841,
-0.7637189627,
0.9276817441,
1.0555973053,
-0.2790156603,
-0.3315962255,
-0.927098453,
0.527035594,
0.0763653964,
-0.6889169812,
0.3644275069,
0.2063556612,
0.0066137039,
0.3000377119,
0.911342144,
-0.1358924806,
0.106291309,
-0.1657043844,
-0.5247131586,
0.3194299638,
-0.3337527812,
-0.2229868174,
0.5710725784,
-0.4417989254,
-0.0500365831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14963v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14963v1 | PESCO: Prompt-enhanced Self Contrastive Learning for Zero-shot Text Classification | 2023-05-24T09:57:06 | 2023-05-24T09:57:06 | Yau-Shian Wang, Ta-Chung Chi, Ruohong Zhang, Yiming Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present PESCO, a novel contrastive learning framework that substantially
improves the performance of zero-shot text classification. We formulate text
classification as a neural text matching problem where each document is treated
as a query, and the system learns the mapping from each query to the relevant
class labels by (1) adding prompts to enhance label matching, and (2) using
retrieved labels to enrich the training set in a self-training loop of
contrastive learning. PESCO achieves state-of-the-art performance on four
benchmark text classification datasets. On DBpedia, we achieve 98.5\% accuracy
without any labeled data, which is close to the fully-supervised result.
Extensive experiments and analyses show all the components of PESCO are
necessary for improving the performance of zero-shot text classification. | [
-0.0431972221,
-0.5614013076,
0.6533982754,
0.0616858378,
-0.2331517935,
0.2620957792,
0.0202777907,
-0.3122853339,
0.2577846646,
0.4863671362,
-0.4232723415,
-0.8225429058,
-0.4707506299,
0.2314641327,
-0.2566637695,
1.1755487919,
0.0947675779,
-0.0859825462,
-0.3200726509,
-0.0769909099,
-0.3248903453,
-0.4608511925,
-0.651842773,
-0.0862074941,
0.7051199675,
0.7171109915,
0.0546951331,
0.5316959023,
0.2490093708,
0.3409374952,
0.0067717233,
0.0520046465,
-0.3485652208,
0.6314269304,
-0.3102662563,
-0.4702081084,
-0.4083892703,
0.1322098821,
0.5507019758,
0.5356782675,
0.1123353466,
-0.2129815668,
0.2736174464,
0.4140538871,
-1.0497158766,
-0.0608904809,
-0.56345433,
0.2759611607,
-0.1993469596,
-0.4695882201,
-0.4829519987,
-0.15987432,
0.2416764498,
-0.9462023377,
0.42935431,
-0.0196037516,
0.7517493367,
0.2061789781,
-0.6434301138,
-0.332978487,
-0.3424979448,
0.7281038165,
-0.2302894443,
0.0433115028,
0.3913159668,
0.2952935398,
0.3382925689,
-0.8762758374,
-0.5370302796,
-0.0732326359,
0.0242779721,
0.5229461193,
0.0982120708,
0.1371238232,
0.1013263613,
0.4934878647,
-0.5689124465,
0.1896336824,
-0.2556171715,
-0.1973318905,
0.3557883501,
0.2593230903,
0.1290958822,
-0.013243611,
-0.433252275,
-0.1077950597,
-0.4716186523,
-0.0226298962,
0.3436369896,
0.2042086869,
0.1343986541,
0.0805421323,
-0.49482283,
0.8375926018,
0.2577423751,
-0.0302457325,
0.553578198,
-0.2439627498,
-0.3619173169,
0.4031194746,
0.9433423281,
0.3466250896,
-0.2020976394,
-0.1857374907,
-0.0819993466,
0.0122512262,
0.1634384096,
-0.8564356565,
-0.5619883537,
-0.0609911121,
-0.0782228261,
-0.8395608664,
-0.0861510411,
-0.8097082973,
-0.5996923447,
0.02154015,
0.659394145,
-0.1971793622,
0.2249217629,
0.0881991759,
-0.14598234,
0.2915351093,
0.6712703705,
-1.0197142363,
0.2712242901,
0.3863631189,
0.8578342199,
-0.2078873664,
-0.3950688839,
-0.6324930787,
0.0804709047,
-0.571213305,
1.2784764767,
-0.5889092684,
-0.3468788862,
-0.1699309945,
0.0314838737,
0.0551301278,
-0.3845615089,
0.8597990274,
-0.1067895591,
0.6825190187,
-0.1852979809,
-0.5044751167,
-0.1077757403,
0.5847465992,
-0.325589776,
1.0415902138,
0.0054175365,
-0.6493979692,
0.3347633481,
-0.4275641143,
-0.3754914701,
0.3429825604,
-0.1284268945,
-0.5128713846,
-0.0365719944,
0.2200574726,
0.4753542542,
-0.1834284067,
-0.1097361967,
-0.2920045257,
-0.5105711222,
0.058283776,
-0.286161989,
0.5870397687,
0.1792865396,
-0.3935190737,
-0.0170826651,
-0.8024892211,
-0.0156073561,
0.1102197319,
-0.2966724634,
-0.5814250112,
-0.38909778,
-0.2994235754,
0.1558913291,
0.2879426479,
-0.648296535,
0.2727201879,
-0.515244782,
0.0903802514,
0.7143576741,
0.0247851238,
0.8197586536,
-0.2414723635,
0.5740934014,
-0.0637405217,
0.2864515185,
-1.0248152018,
-0.4224762321,
-0.9142789841,
-0.1967005432,
0.4731986821,
0.5852294564,
-0.720638454,
0.4669600129,
0.3004857898,
-0.5893959999,
-0.2744022608,
0.0350105874,
0.5591022372,
1.2982671261,
0.505746901,
-0.1727174073,
-0.3753876984,
-0.7646089792,
-0.0259973668,
-0.0121389125,
-0.1417629719,
0.6595343947,
0.2880669832,
0.0517077036,
0.4798243642,
-0.5717849731,
-0.5685312152,
0.2543879747,
0.4238016307,
0.1993676275,
0.3903558254,
0.6905232072,
-0.6571065187,
-1.0324361324,
0.1240454838,
-0.8140047193,
-0.6538587809,
-0.2201442569,
-0.0341481008,
0.153650403,
0.4606800675,
0.0770501569,
0.2154185176,
0.3298223615,
-0.6005806923,
0.4244900048,
-0.3441663384,
0.5102891922,
-1.0077471733,
0.0905009061,
-0.0406465754,
-0.2332358211,
-0.5370922685,
-0.23972027,
0.3965705037,
-0.3250997066,
-0.4961207509,
0.4001924694,
-0.4212210476,
0.0916636586,
-0.4964120984,
0.2660778761,
0.5111714602,
0.381591022,
0.0649836957,
0.8695306182,
1.0614281893,
-0.720701158,
0.4080130756,
0.2826459408,
-0.0484943613,
1.1057088375,
-0.6174653172,
0.3116249442,
-0.1890297383,
0.2639227808,
-1.1182744503,
-0.0849251822,
0.4728072286,
-0.6055060029,
0.3841126859,
0.0888832882,
0.004583864,
-0.0967763066,
-0.5170558095,
0.2732717395,
0.295196116,
-0.6751404405,
0.4036000073,
0.158415854,
-0.221634239,
-0.7870456576,
-0.4906896055,
0.1734353155,
-0.0522281006,
0.0115300529,
0.7575713396,
-0.1531146467,
0.2612084746,
-0.0609948039,
-0.1252164692,
-0.36040923,
0.2866771817,
0.2982007563,
0.1460092217,
-0.0342969038,
0.4402554333,
0.2868877351,
-0.1812590659,
-0.1706839055,
-0.3336234689,
0.2773807645,
-0.0753525645,
0.1171352193,
-0.6527489424,
0.2707743645,
0.2472370714,
-0.1656601429,
0.5418668985,
0.0835497379,
-0.0917809159,
-0.3771255612,
-0.2474458963,
0.0069289617,
-0.501557529,
0.0420721844,
-0.5151873231,
-0.6871604323,
0.2872940302,
-0.1532443315,
-0.2657782733,
0.4951958656,
0.2102104574,
-0.5113435388,
0.7389371395,
0.6577551961,
0.2311757803,
0.6696226597,
-0.1965334564,
-0.3348397613,
-0.5356839299,
-0.7377681732,
-0.8060438037,
-0.3605394959,
-0.3180514276,
-0.1833457947,
0.0596503988,
0.0170979425,
-0.3694961667,
0.2983117104,
-0.9550676346,
0.8763998747,
0.4953751862,
0.2077895403,
0.2436246574,
-0.0682791099,
-0.2585853636,
-0.1441666633,
-0.5322445035,
-0.1892287135,
1.2111917734,
-0.1314008832,
0.7938498259,
-0.38372311,
0.9030692577,
0.4808585942,
0.1139612719,
-0.786037147,
0.384199053,
-0.0371366739,
-0.4245834053,
-0.0460223518,
-0.4467474818,
-1.0232120752,
0.1053405255,
-0.6370317936,
-0.278844893,
0.4738769233,
0.12640284,
-0.4214129746,
-0.0386825539,
-0.7767625451,
0.9990872741,
-0.5986660719,
-0.4092323482,
0.0695055053,
-0.5072318316,
-0.0319166705,
-0.4289132953,
-0.3718765378,
-0.0099924812,
-0.6839948893,
0.7446221113,
-0.1285734624,
0.7554872632,
-0.0969867706,
0.0893959627,
0.1157600209,
0.0790996701,
0.2130278945,
-0.282299906,
-0.0694117472,
0.067998521,
-0.1932933331,
-0.5727030635,
-0.7874807715,
0.9336040616,
-0.5808315873,
-0.3394917846,
-0.9206386805,
-0.1001836509,
-0.0672991574,
0.3431760073,
0.3967162073,
0.274730593,
-0.171890378,
0.4417217672,
0.7755189538,
-0.4443202615,
0.4878773093,
0.8390448093,
-0.0031732526,
-0.7427912951,
0.8018934131,
0.1316114664,
-0.1291273832,
0.6039453149,
0.2195276022,
-0.5260803699,
-0.4934536815,
-0.2172133178,
0.1437524408,
-0.5933692455,
-0.468172431,
-0.5926989317,
0.0784718841,
-0.4718553424,
-0.4944312871,
-0.1821155399,
-0.3348260224,
-0.5992601514,
-0.1304226369,
0.0373083688,
0.7796563506,
0.181600064,
0.5188271403,
-0.5648722649,
0.0664127395,
0.4786736965,
0.3761663139,
-0.4114638269,
-0.7177808881,
0.0062940326,
-0.5258050561,
-0.5985763073,
-1.1730256081,
0.4127979875,
0.4854710102,
0.6153620481,
0.3968605101,
0.4275491834,
0.3539270759,
-0.4336312413,
0.7131019235,
0.5134532452,
-0.9995392561,
1.0468443632,
-0.2896463275,
0.244268924,
0.7895171642,
0.7331300378,
-0.3179956675,
0.0378504917,
-0.6267433763,
-0.6778764725,
0.7934986949,
0.0292887688,
0.1710392982,
-0.0595993958,
0.5109876394,
0.215001896,
0.1552334279,
-0.6453941464,
-0.1411531568,
-0.4265704453,
-0.280197829,
-0.1742533147,
-0.380682677,
0.2299461365,
-0.2297576517,
0.6268532872,
-0.4669089317,
0.0929725394,
0.4861682355,
-0.0704303831,
0.1465369761,
0.0930911377,
0.3326170743,
0.3078809381,
-0.1148447022,
0.202009514,
0.2791334093,
-0.2469821423,
0.3085682392,
0.0796958432,
-0.3810644746,
-0.0353705101,
-0.0588530414,
0.6510079503,
0.4052357078,
-0.4488798678,
0.7321066856,
-0.2808507383,
-0.3040215373,
-0.020493269,
0.2056684941,
-0.443579942,
0.2007990181,
0.519125104,
-0.0648946017,
0.4944521189,
-0.4938709736,
0.2876952887,
0.1457092315,
-0.4835399389,
-0.1218408346,
0.6391429901,
0.6090722084,
-0.4564549327,
0.2327498198,
-0.0975434929,
-0.5068321228,
0.574290812,
0.7150691748,
0.7699074745,
-0.4552465081,
0.5683128834,
0.5271787643,
-0.0973677486,
0.1586160362,
-0.0158773027,
-0.7997841835,
-0.4333089292,
-0.2144111991,
-0.4728757441,
-0.8671591282,
-0.0615783259,
-0.4350539148,
0.4348545969,
-0.6951792836,
0.0722909421,
0.1324013323,
0.3112182915,
-0.1871156991,
0.4092760086,
0.2105876952,
0.8052215576,
-0.9093344212,
0.8123955131,
0.745605886,
-0.3889611065,
-0.3362943232,
0.0239852834,
-0.3280192614,
-0.3955071867,
0.4395648241,
0.474357605,
-0.1350106448,
0.1159355193,
-0.6019514203,
-0.3891174197,
1.1547282934,
0.4856235087,
-0.5738646388,
0.1704871655,
-0.2702301741,
0.592748642,
-0.4010293484,
0.399235189,
0.1995109171,
0.1009523571,
0.2091123462,
-0.6404127479,
-0.2564120293,
-0.3065622449,
-0.3436623216,
0.0888192356,
-0.6227895021,
0.7838020921,
0.0799939036,
-0.1398790479,
0.0212168787,
0.5124628544,
0.0722604692,
0.9254558682,
0.3251385689,
0.585827589,
1.1631891727,
-0.1908361763,
1.0485783815,
-0.1354465485,
0.5199419856,
1.1113166809,
-0.3042756915,
0.6752593517,
0.0589157417,
-0.0166343413,
0.7767792344,
0.6609372497,
-0.0842033997,
0.6666693091,
-0.4254949093,
-0.6097735167,
-0.3536626697,
-0.2898461819,
-0.3675482273,
0.5274573565,
0.1718114167,
-0.6603122354,
-0.3634711504,
0.0375163183,
-0.2007407695,
0.4857391119,
-0.500685215,
0.8480370641,
-0.0316318125,
-0.57108289,
0.5191171169,
-0.1985188574,
0.9022607207,
-0.5184724331,
-0.0653861463,
-0.4136467278,
0.2536151409,
-0.2174532562,
-0.9852644205,
0.1272877306,
0.0499970876,
-0.2191754431,
-0.3190627098,
1.0176156759,
-0.391725719,
-0.10254132,
0.267095834,
0.1860253513,
0.2123284638,
-0.2299514264,
-0.9922044277,
-0.3388830721,
-0.2116948217,
0.0141877113,
0.3869750202,
0.6358596683,
0.3829423785,
0.4750884175,
0.552436173,
-0.1456063539,
-0.135308221,
-0.2620342076,
0.8142933249,
-0.7895430923,
-0.7564352751,
-0.7287414074,
0.1787558943,
-0.4796906412,
-0.4977753758,
0.9545458555,
0.7208734155,
0.7147411108,
-0.1201772094,
0.5164415836,
0.2488361895,
0.4764472842,
-0.1831861734,
0.6691555381,
-0.5720096827,
-0.0630628169,
-0.161754325,
-0.9160359502,
-0.5543322563,
0.7039986253,
-0.3865360618,
-0.1185880676,
0.8067483306,
0.6074240208,
-0.0238621626,
-0.2888732553,
0.6672012806,
-0.0352611355,
0.001635631,
0.7404506207,
0.7693730593,
-0.7025619149,
0.973700583,
-0.5038511753,
-0.3425598443,
-0.1703916937,
-0.929700315,
-0.9302369952,
-0.4935699701,
-0.4476305544,
-0.2620565295,
0.230172798,
0.3798880577,
0.8156635165,
-0.8435274959,
0.2539082468,
-0.2664318681,
0.1021914929,
0.136942178,
-0.2377196252,
0.1669469476,
-0.6003555655,
-0.9841589332,
0.5624532104,
0.612837255,
0.1292234212,
0.1138130724,
-0.2466045469,
-0.0737359375,
0.0660216212,
0.5502044559,
0.5231166482,
-0.088475436,
0.1463594586,
0.1692988873,
-0.3203713596,
0.3405174017,
0.7515729666,
-1.318759203,
0.8102594018,
0.7839170694,
0.7221387625,
0.6750553846,
0.0350490324,
0.2369494736,
-0.916020155,
0.2343358248,
0.3980463445,
0.2040064484,
0.4352684319,
-0.4869270027,
0.4261789322,
0.548422277,
-0.7585391998,
-0.6820542216,
0.0518104173,
-1.008191824,
-0.3789705634,
0.7278153896,
-0.2957482636,
-0.4252937138,
-0.0989820734,
-0.5759314299,
0.083396934,
-0.4291199744,
0.7767763734,
0.3101491928,
-0.0675801784,
-0.5336508155,
-0.0004847627,
0.2808092237,
0.4558241367,
-0.9765589833,
-0.3988816142,
0.6190933585,
0.3320946991,
0.1202585995,
0.7883020043,
-0.0146382982,
0.5782808065,
0.0957878307,
-0.0159709584,
-0.2684984505,
-0.7741600871,
-0.7143504024,
0.461250633,
-0.2018283755,
-0.5019201636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14956v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14956v3 | Editing Common Sense in Transformers | 2023-05-24T09:50:54 | 2023-10-26T15:38:38 | Anshita Gupta, Debanjan Mondal, Akshay Krishna Sheshadri, Wenlong Zhao, Xiang Lorraine Li, Sarah Wiegreffe, Niket Tandon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Editing model parameters directly in Transformers makes updating open-source
transformer-based models possible without re-training (Meng et al., 2023).
However, these editing methods have only been evaluated on statements about
encyclopedic knowledge with a single correct answer. Commonsense knowledge with
multiple correct answers, e.g., an apple can be green or red but not
transparent, has not been studied but is as essential for enhancing
transformers' reliability and usefulness. In this paper, we investigate whether
commonsense judgments are causally associated with localized, editable
parameters in Transformers, and we provide an affirmative answer. We find that
directly applying the MEMIT editing algorithm results in sub-par performance
and improve it for the commonsense domain by varying edit tokens and improving
the layer selection strategy, i.e., $MEMIT_{CSK}$. GPT-2 Large and XL models
edited using $MEMIT_{CSK}$ outperform best-fine-tuned baselines by 10.97% and
10.73% F1 scores on PEP3k and 20Q datasets. In addition, we propose a novel
evaluation dataset, PROBE SET, that contains unaffected and affected
neighborhoods, affected paraphrases, and affected reasoning challenges.
$MEMIT_{CSK}$ performs well across the metrics while fine-tuning baselines show
significant trade-offs between unaffected and affected metrics. These results
suggest a compelling future direction for incorporating feedback about common
sense into Transformers through direct model editing. | [
-0.4976742268,
-0.6342862248,
0.6239756346,
0.0460817479,
-0.139185816,
-0.4300996363,
-0.3121748269,
-0.4520025253,
-0.0895126015,
0.5018824339,
-0.2831466198,
-0.2178725451,
-0.6182448268,
0.200082168,
-0.2144857049,
1.0114010572,
0.0026263911,
-0.3288020492,
-0.0907771662,
-0.4900712073,
-0.5989100337,
-0.2487906069,
-0.4572871029,
-0.2137281746,
0.589022398,
0.7232155204,
1.2896854877,
0.4485779703,
0.3674893677,
0.426953733,
-0.5161933899,
-0.018172795,
-0.2593078613,
-0.1112962812,
-0.7131273746,
-0.254609704,
-0.6267152429,
0.2330341935,
0.3450639546,
0.6300204992,
0.0132716652,
0.1026534587,
0.159425959,
0.5127544999,
-0.6829658151,
-0.1060868725,
-0.9314077497,
0.021520542,
0.0842073262,
-0.1543290168,
-0.4549949765,
0.016562786,
0.1547116041,
-0.9755420089,
0.5584631562,
-0.1258007288,
0.9202934504,
0.689273119,
-0.3239770234,
0.0281958859,
-0.8096579909,
0.8643813729,
-0.5766198039,
0.6961219907,
0.2298663408,
0.3654984534,
0.0451103523,
-0.9258903861,
-0.7076289058,
-0.1363090277,
-0.5595504045,
0.5553656816,
-0.6372452974,
0.2125136703,
0.6202697158,
0.02213802,
-0.0050219591,
0.1467522234,
-0.763763845,
-0.3365907669,
0.3147550821,
0.1855178922,
-0.0656001121,
-0.6929270029,
-0.3257630467,
-0.0675169826,
-0.4856646359,
0.1834333837,
0.4028110504,
-0.0511672087,
-0.0411361419,
0.462456584,
-0.4395682514,
0.8193759918,
0.3212750852,
0.2775787711,
-0.0389986001,
-0.1666604578,
-0.327927202,
-0.3238832355,
0.4899630249,
0.6722507477,
0.3258562982,
-0.1192590594,
-0.2434860319,
-0.219403252,
0.5100457668,
-0.3541583717,
-0.300817728,
0.0864273012,
-0.2686682045,
-0.3388658464,
0.0906435102,
-0.5961362123,
-0.3076489866,
-0.8027150035,
0.3473059237,
-0.2648480833,
-0.1698855907,
0.2085999548,
-0.5164504051,
0.1058475301,
0.7417420149,
-0.7614498138,
0.0486139245,
0.7083672881,
0.610963881,
0.274431318,
-0.7097735405,
-0.4089745283,
0.0391185321,
-0.0336686559,
0.8897243738,
-0.812448442,
-0.3224669993,
-0.4198356569,
0.0575646572,
-0.1141918525,
-0.6406950355,
0.7063323259,
-0.5381209254,
-0.1176001504,
-0.3737199008,
-0.1853105277,
0.0415741727,
0.0253137369,
-0.855941534,
0.8010888696,
0.2337306887,
-0.8112384081,
0.754533112,
-0.7992784381,
-0.3520309329,
-0.3111602962,
0.2780086994,
-0.201265797,
0.2198118269,
0.621067822,
0.6347796321,
0.0555565879,
0.5975066423,
-0.1960179359,
-0.4132661223,
0.3869603574,
-0.8448760509,
0.4865447581,
0.2507235408,
-0.10851679,
0.1772724837,
-0.7048288584,
-0.524130702,
-0.3684827983,
-0.1129442006,
-0.2395049781,
-0.1272565722,
-0.0290218741,
0.154970035,
-0.0279422197,
-0.6090191603,
0.0274518169,
-0.1937358081,
0.5063413978,
1.0954774618,
0.2811840475,
0.6657631993,
-0.4077059627,
0.2873651981,
0.185064435,
0.6303752661,
0.1869947165,
-0.6283671856,
-0.7530994415,
-0.0951034054,
0.2553872764,
0.3213081658,
-0.6044568419,
0.1498628259,
-0.3390448987,
-0.7646836638,
-0.559183836,
0.0466675684,
0.0155648524,
0.9376958609,
0.8350038528,
0.1803108603,
-0.0928917974,
-1.1587793827,
-0.9458299875,
0.2142317146,
-0.2619131207,
0.4818970263,
0.4230239987,
-0.1120035425,
1.0728439093,
-0.7125225067,
-0.0735093057,
-0.0797241032,
0.236325711,
0.4652529061,
0.4931708574,
0.3002915978,
-0.7206490636,
-0.3407904208,
-0.0384124406,
-0.4762999713,
-0.2563358843,
-0.3243514597,
-0.0431947559,
-0.1370912194,
0.6326124072,
-0.6043749452,
0.3342642188,
0.4309931993,
-0.3973158598,
0.5577111244,
-0.3453435302,
0.430978775,
-0.7209505439,
-0.0359346904,
0.0499575771,
-0.07405442,
-0.496610105,
0.0195656661,
0.2664960325,
-0.0474461839,
-0.8301454186,
0.6743556261,
-0.0375233889,
0.132233724,
0.0967583209,
0.2424079031,
0.0904313028,
0.592140615,
-0.1184028909,
0.7325110435,
0.2317846417,
-0.6990903616,
0.2113681734,
0.3111261725,
-0.4029075205,
0.7253545523,
-0.9125199914,
0.2064360082,
-0.1206933707,
0.1493620723,
-0.5211997628,
-0.2951148748,
0.2956144512,
-0.1834834218,
0.1130520627,
-0.1236382574,
-0.5260054469,
-0.1188313365,
0.0037751389,
0.2888367474,
0.2426387221,
-0.8420168161,
0.6120484471,
0.0765590668,
-0.031913612,
-0.757630527,
-0.5950521827,
-0.1841483861,
-0.133378759,
-0.8407819271,
0.199317053,
0.1639414728,
-0.3300251663,
0.1057397127,
-0.2613262236,
-0.1220238954,
0.2286379784,
0.0971114039,
0.0413478985,
0.1636813879,
0.2813423276,
0.6257327795,
-0.567471981,
-0.1993700117,
0.3524193466,
0.0261885487,
-0.1569090784,
-0.392871052,
-0.3245538175,
-0.0592949092,
0.5748136044,
-0.3368310034,
0.3000403643,
0.2917321324,
-0.0119154006,
-0.1373621076,
-0.5201093554,
-0.3371373713,
-0.5690435171,
0.3411071301,
-0.4537905753,
-1.1224883795,
0.4675951898,
-0.2235073894,
0.1090675816,
0.7896565199,
0.0485599637,
-0.2366979569,
0.6484066844,
0.0848895535,
0.143178463,
0.168341592,
-0.041368451,
0.1569694877,
-1.0029709339,
0.1969325542,
-0.5753896832,
-0.7268729806,
-0.6350784302,
-0.6285209656,
0.5226573944,
0.1691836715,
-0.3595210314,
0.3559930325,
-0.7157161832,
0.8462026715,
0.5586191416,
0.4878422022,
0.6449465752,
-0.3579272032,
-0.0105629852,
-0.2332707494,
-0.6760171056,
-0.4663135111,
0.9657762647,
0.3752085268,
0.4999549687,
0.0939774588,
0.2919102311,
0.2083015591,
0.5191745162,
-0.5226250291,
0.4422581494,
-0.301833272,
-0.7008333206,
-0.3877112269,
-0.3077614605,
-0.830591321,
0.1620162427,
-0.1435656846,
-0.5497370362,
0.3725329936,
0.4001879096,
-0.3606168032,
0.5261275172,
-0.7302004099,
0.8394100666,
0.1078566238,
-0.2939429879,
-0.5564437509,
-0.5123631358,
0.3035455942,
-0.0749880597,
0.0823456198,
0.1132302806,
0.042730052,
0.685945034,
-0.2811748385,
0.8541040421,
-0.3769900203,
0.1679163724,
0.2988892198,
-0.04705327,
0.5665963292,
0.3654249907,
-0.1862478703,
0.5220990181,
-0.1152273118,
-0.3007595539,
-1.0157123804,
0.6506162286,
-0.6793792248,
-0.7879471183,
-0.2326948792,
-0.5587636232,
-0.2804788351,
0.000947643,
0.4031193554,
0.5082708597,
-0.0160928406,
0.3361050189,
0.3621539772,
-0.5727527738,
0.3386992514,
0.4941956103,
0.3314024508,
-0.2815291584,
0.557072103,
0.2663481236,
0.3605612218,
0.2704376578,
0.4639453292,
-0.111183919,
-0.221422717,
-0.3925153315,
0.0294842832,
-1.0463222265,
-0.3859143555,
-0.6754344106,
0.0990768746,
-0.0096977456,
-0.6407343745,
-0.3373170197,
-0.6324060559,
-0.0657047033,
-0.3341284692,
0.6173030734,
0.8254010081,
-0.3329624534,
0.2881288826,
-0.8957880735,
0.6631288528,
0.6041693687,
0.7092057467,
0.0171465911,
-0.6908897758,
-0.1469351649,
0.0630628243,
-0.4461562634,
-0.8641602993,
-0.2445208132,
-0.1597537547,
0.5019983053,
0.2859043181,
0.1446368545,
0.8444138169,
-0.3137114346,
0.8363450766,
-0.0897678956,
-1.260201335,
0.4419419467,
-0.4689691365,
0.457534641,
0.5738869905,
0.0192530956,
-0.6871173382,
-0.8099586368,
-0.9541522264,
-0.5062105656,
0.7269105911,
0.1132420897,
0.514778018,
-0.1119665504,
0.2465553433,
0.184849292,
0.0404660888,
-0.560742557,
-0.1955272406,
-0.4672821462,
0.2276094109,
0.1574489027,
-0.1371578127,
0.0064670751,
-0.7795832753,
0.5109896064,
0.0720478222,
0.1147406846,
0.4024243057,
-0.2145269513,
-0.0243813489,
0.675537467,
0.7202101946,
0.7160491347,
-0.1467501074,
-0.0283452831,
0.5202764273,
-0.328145355,
-0.171082601,
-0.1900966316,
-0.3318147063,
0.0153697021,
0.2917696238,
0.7832422853,
0.7807153463,
-0.1747338921,
0.4035544991,
-0.0017290736,
-0.3226116896,
0.1374269873,
0.2410692126,
-0.1048035771,
0.2330317944,
-0.0375067331,
0.9931884408,
0.1578426063,
0.0201364476,
0.3573018312,
0.1483630836,
-0.3320146799,
-0.2781159878,
0.6384940147,
0.2686181068,
-0.0537789874,
0.7338318229,
-0.0004439162,
-0.4445042908,
0.4709065855,
0.1348386705,
0.8050251603,
-0.1562681198,
0.2824052274,
0.6482343674,
0.5415018201,
0.0794580504,
-0.3083073199,
-0.1642614603,
-0.9712058902,
-0.4340384901,
-0.4219789207,
-0.6029270291,
0.1395237446,
-0.5993290544,
0.5972058773,
-0.5350689292,
0.179076612,
-0.1213002279,
-0.4688773751,
-0.9936246872,
0.491235733,
-0.542706728,
0.98835814,
-0.8406493068,
0.5210511088,
0.5396938324,
-0.3046011925,
-1.1737635136,
-0.082787402,
-0.2860583067,
-0.4715780318,
0.3538813293,
-0.1039874628,
0.0944852903,
-0.017980136,
-0.6162437797,
-0.7288995981,
1.0392203331,
0.2842604816,
-0.6126009822,
0.372009933,
0.1549374759,
0.4537178278,
0.3853591681,
0.5204259157,
0.7473409176,
1.0217891932,
0.0605822764,
-0.9334357977,
0.0322372392,
-0.0673199818,
-0.5372905135,
0.4119955599,
-0.7397505641,
0.6484505534,
-0.1985361129,
-0.0257283915,
-0.2662307322,
0.547680378,
0.0711314753,
0.4419573545,
0.6293162704,
0.8440682292,
0.7385324836,
-0.132929042,
1.035705328,
-0.2233644873,
0.3500959575,
1.2551267147,
0.1886731833,
0.7740516067,
0.5203416944,
-0.1031619832,
0.2130906135,
0.1125731319,
-0.3506501913,
0.3579312563,
-0.1543395221,
-0.0681132376,
-0.1029724851,
0.2350909859,
-0.1658417732,
0.7410232425,
0.0291601308,
-0.2282043546,
-0.4313524663,
-0.2135089189,
0.2189323902,
0.1755640805,
-0.2638226748,
0.6404598355,
-0.0722193494,
-0.8822999597,
0.314330548,
0.16030173,
0.5993676186,
-0.106778644,
-0.1199212596,
-0.4186291397,
-0.1494871229,
-0.3132555187,
-0.9818981886,
0.6711958647,
0.1862953752,
-0.2496025115,
-0.4460047185,
0.8213237524,
0.1594599038,
-0.4085022509,
0.0589086674,
0.3212375939,
-0.2005316913,
-0.2987193763,
-0.6102184653,
-0.2837342918,
0.0370091274,
-0.2726649046,
0.0067128073,
0.5944785476,
-0.0043343296,
0.3329554796,
0.787723124,
0.0601097979,
-0.1253272444,
0.1079047248,
0.8093187213,
-0.7968614101,
-0.2191145122,
-0.4956658483,
1.0277163982,
-0.1525804102,
-0.7227455378,
0.4892890751,
0.1959098876,
0.9429107904,
-0.307028681,
0.7026838064,
0.1626124978,
0.4242153168,
-0.5738689899,
0.8854749799,
-0.3808548152,
0.3539338708,
-0.553817153,
-1.0178291798,
-0.2578190267,
0.3352501094,
-0.7083187699,
-0.0863057375,
0.7297043204,
0.9232854247,
-0.4470146,
0.2712992132,
0.5085411668,
0.5131021142,
0.2449564934,
0.2455419302,
0.8925295472,
-0.501126945,
0.3341248333,
-0.5499286652,
-0.0978035554,
0.2427828014,
-0.9045990109,
-0.6108030677,
-0.4926912785,
-0.1129663885,
0.0662693828,
-0.2758737504,
0.4279522598,
0.1923469305,
-0.5465489626,
0.3593115509,
-0.2666492462,
0.2768549621,
-0.3194849491,
-0.2672228813,
0.2747794092,
-0.2542239726,
-0.6928912997,
0.280146271,
0.2254424244,
-0.364967972,
0.3412818909,
-0.1577119827,
0.2030812353,
0.0880650282,
0.4857924283,
-0.0043019592,
-0.7988143563,
-0.7904044986,
0.0643447936,
0.1932497323,
0.0594506748,
0.7660184503,
-0.9562778473,
0.5612819791,
0.3696908057,
0.3422685862,
0.1908344775,
0.1974095702,
0.514128983,
-0.7522429228,
0.2652513385,
0.2900216281,
0.4583351016,
0.3875245452,
-0.3106710613,
0.4447756112,
0.1883609891,
-0.7053212523,
-0.3801248074,
0.212013647,
-0.9027761221,
-0.1975076795,
1.133015871,
0.2202152163,
0.0975760967,
-0.2072581947,
-0.2458997816,
0.336836338,
-0.3400267363,
0.7133582234,
0.6767643094,
0.0124061974,
-0.245010227,
-0.5610980988,
0.4411345124,
0.6588730216,
-0.4550496936,
0.0581978709,
0.5431757569,
0.1663757712,
0.084517248,
0.196988523,
-0.000072855,
0.5953407288,
-0.0617523193,
-0.372471422,
-0.260191977,
-0.3499444425,
-0.2814313173,
-0.0291625094,
0.0315682553,
0.201665774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14950v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14950v2 | Adversarial Demonstration Attacks on Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T09:40:56 | 2023-10-14T05:03:53 | Jiongxiao Wang, Zichen Liu, Keun Hee Park, Zhuojun Jiang, Zhaoheng Zheng, Zhuofeng Wu, Muhao Chen, Chaowei Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | With the emergence of more powerful large language models (LLMs), such as
ChatGPT and GPT-4, in-context learning (ICL) has gained significant prominence
in leveraging these models for specific tasks by utilizing data-label pairs as
precondition prompts. While incorporating demonstrations can greatly enhance
the performance of LLMs across various tasks, it may introduce a new security
concern: attackers can manipulate only the demonstrations without changing the
input to perform an attack. In this paper, we investigate the security concern
of ICL from an adversarial perspective, focusing on the impact of
demonstrations. We propose a novel attack method named advICL, which aims to
manipulate only the demonstration without changing the input to mislead the
models. Our results demonstrate that as the number of demonstrations increases,
the robustness of in-context learning would decrease. Additionally, we also
identify the intrinsic property of the demonstrations is that they can be used
(prepended) with different inputs. As a result, it introduces a more practical
threat model in which an attacker can attack the test input example even
without knowing and manipulating it. To achieve it, we propose the transferable
version of advICL, named Transferable-advICL. Our experiment shows that the
adversarial demonstration generated by Transferable-advICL can successfully
attack the unseen test input examples. We hope that our study reveals the
critical security risks associated with ICL and underscores the need for
extensive research on the robustness of ICL, particularly given its increasing
significance in the advancement of LLMs. | [
-0.5768507123,
-1.1000698805,
0.1814204901,
-0.0682518557,
-0.2034471929,
0.1609102935,
-0.0180186611,
-0.6025032997,
-0.4306251109,
0.4628244936,
-0.3035648465,
-0.3112755716,
-0.8048262596,
-0.2343911827,
-0.6060751081,
1.2668228149,
-0.1306319386,
-0.1046997383,
-0.1306026578,
-0.1887006909,
-0.226123631,
-0.8118819594,
-0.7304708362,
-0.2387730181,
0.2070689648,
0.0061257593,
0.7897930741,
0.210411787,
0.309356302,
0.2574034333,
-0.102271311,
-0.1502374709,
-0.4897250235,
0.1555786878,
-0.0183357578,
-0.5810189843,
-0.2306155711,
0.0176062901,
0.6212937236,
0.6694604158,
0.2610109746,
0.0432941616,
0.2213940322,
0.4369389117,
-0.6317135692,
0.0642213523,
-0.891071856,
-0.0027336695,
-0.3424625397,
0.0860690475,
-0.6583994031,
-0.2237638384,
0.0366433226,
-0.404907763,
-0.1366248578,
-0.1647206247,
0.6367179155,
0.2462008595,
-0.5026637316,
-0.3430905342,
-0.8113943934,
0.5544293523,
-0.6403250098,
0.1490031034,
0.2725034654,
0.4815317392,
-0.434907943,
-0.8648178577,
-0.5704444051,
-0.5670831203,
-0.2237273902,
-0.080159381,
-0.4268523455,
0.032234095,
0.571693182,
0.0073039867,
-0.4243545234,
0.0703026578,
-0.3023900092,
-0.0277888607,
0.3605257869,
-0.072813794,
0.5780543685,
0.2272236645,
-0.7403470278,
-0.3096657693,
-1.2102272511,
0.3871857822,
0.2523586154,
0.0983531103,
-0.0542959906,
0.381817013,
0.2953195572,
0.6215458512,
0.1233209148,
0.063125588,
-0.1389361471,
-0.1425066441,
-0.3863198161,
0.2226573527,
0.8802419901,
-0.0763861015,
-0.0902723745,
-0.2008756399,
-0.151555568,
0.0919585824,
0.3429109156,
-0.8331229091,
-0.324736625,
0.0657193884,
-0.1190777346,
-0.6264621019,
0.1683590561,
-0.7240757346,
-0.5230785012,
0.1474159658,
0.6288878322,
-0.54923594,
0.0523309335,
-0.1665863693,
0.2465791404,
0.1205180138,
0.2540471554,
-0.701914072,
0.5202770233,
0.6540160775,
0.595454514,
-0.1143594608,
-0.3019807041,
-0.6671833396,
0.3014132082,
-0.448628515,
0.4675351977,
-0.4107860327,
-0.5951067209,
-0.1011648998,
-0.0944286287,
-0.1054386944,
-0.4316653609,
0.2607011795,
-0.9755039215,
0.1110407263,
0.0377029628,
-0.4454093575,
-0.1910399944,
0.3640479743,
-0.7108321786,
0.6434282064,
-0.1391191036,
-0.8554412723,
0.1814839542,
-0.8072032928,
-0.7475258112,
0.0363078378,
-0.424099952,
-0.5306608081,
-0.25662902,
0.3250210583,
0.4087950885,
-0.0070576323,
0.0568552092,
-0.6001422405,
-0.5347135663,
0.858815074,
-0.8711377382,
0.9455936551,
0.2499849945,
-0.6554508805,
-0.0094261374,
-0.6370618939,
-0.0773266181,
0.1983887255,
-0.2746268213,
-0.3990563154,
-0.1570615321,
-0.3802407682,
0.1717321575,
0.1720749885,
-0.4837139547,
0.3531989455,
-0.6153609753,
0.3257828355,
0.8073732257,
0.2018397152,
0.5232607126,
-0.2031809539,
0.7623373866,
-0.1781004965,
0.449588269,
-0.0906174928,
-0.2608733177,
-0.2595422566,
-0.4191126227,
0.2427266389,
0.363466084,
-1.0209361315,
-0.1179388687,
0.0755849928,
-0.5171154141,
-0.3883829117,
-0.0696665943,
0.6534096599,
0.3584148884,
0.2047641128,
0.3298157156,
-0.3144445121,
-0.7893867493,
-0.256824702,
-0.2658161819,
0.0828096122,
0.2441543192,
0.4007325172,
-0.103430748,
0.5982611775,
-0.3733412027,
0.0047464008,
-0.2582938969,
0.116538614,
-0.0372021459,
0.496545881,
0.9128888845,
-1.0225154161,
-0.6087219715,
-0.020934226,
-0.4954086244,
-0.0050418777,
-0.253138572,
0.0028602239,
0.027525939,
0.7158988714,
-0.5814136267,
0.6015005708,
0.5224335194,
-0.1967479289,
0.5868632197,
-0.1626582891,
0.115252696,
-0.9704412222,
-0.2063729614,
-0.3299860954,
-0.144566223,
-0.8126174212,
0.3893217146,
0.2854875922,
-0.3993268311,
-0.8460218906,
0.5584846735,
-0.1193277314,
0.0109967245,
-0.327840358,
-0.1821724176,
0.0550259613,
0.3190963268,
-0.3356406093,
0.9922878742,
0.9049513936,
-0.8062446117,
0.3895047307,
0.1252342314,
-0.2945452929,
0.3561555445,
-0.5649101734,
0.2952491641,
0.1809620261,
0.4132913947,
-0.944270432,
0.0491225794,
0.468095392,
-0.5357974172,
0.6636375189,
-0.2049095929,
-0.2662705779,
0.0484277532,
-0.3892033994,
0.3160227239,
0.4175665081,
-0.9618434906,
0.3682596982,
0.1798986942,
0.0211257767,
-0.7068763375,
-0.7801092267,
0.2583344281,
-0.5784168243,
-0.4053611755,
0.3940059543,
-0.2553243637,
-0.3165820837,
-0.2625279129,
0.1102545336,
0.0046426984,
0.6760409474,
0.3363056481,
0.3875223696,
-0.0145503366,
-0.1853268892,
-0.1360625923,
0.0833976939,
0.2000347674,
-0.0948906764,
0.2899000943,
-0.1573962122,
-0.7752504349,
-0.4622115493,
0.3595553041,
0.90440768,
-0.0892593712,
0.7399527431,
0.4678395987,
-0.3846089542,
-0.2560403645,
-0.0860487595,
-0.0967198536,
-0.5264954567,
0.5538340807,
-0.5274257064,
-0.5516254902,
0.3208041787,
-0.2319089472,
0.1499933004,
-0.0535710938,
0.2783596814,
0.0745705068,
1.4239057302,
0.2239119112,
-0.1454429477,
0.6040038466,
-0.1811443418,
0.1601739824,
-1.0023691654,
-0.0570592731,
-0.3597147167,
-0.1177118868,
-0.3373209536,
-0.0876970068,
0.3617147803,
0.0396724343,
-0.3034525514,
0.3397441208,
-0.099689275,
0.3703986704,
0.5045294166,
0.0700677782,
0.0058129607,
-0.1838584244,
-0.2170295864,
-0.0460296087,
-0.3806150854,
-0.5453923941,
1.1840635538,
0.2157386541,
1.0648392439,
0.5455739498,
0.4243914485,
0.4554280341,
0.292235285,
-0.5489471555,
0.6880624294,
-0.1677628756,
-0.3301721513,
-0.145968616,
-0.2599775195,
-0.9160763025,
0.4111519158,
-0.1414577216,
-0.8245726824,
0.0078578833,
0.1151208952,
-0.2926131785,
0.5231369734,
-0.7447313666,
0.672629118,
-0.5017794967,
-0.2925887406,
0.0489809699,
-0.5082302094,
0.4374327362,
-0.3082383573,
0.3383343816,
0.4322495162,
0.1982565522,
0.5510964394,
-0.339536339,
1.0615785122,
-0.2666626275,
-0.1319012195,
-0.0505429395,
0.4766081274,
0.9814922214,
0.1872908622,
0.1839272678,
-0.2663581371,
-0.0973229632,
-0.3845182359,
-0.9798043966,
0.8636155725,
-0.7658866048,
-0.9714769721,
-0.3769987524,
-0.2810736895,
-0.2898759842,
-0.0634837747,
0.2517650127,
0.7784038186,
-0.28995502,
0.2639812529,
0.6807057858,
-0.2502449453,
0.3379036486,
0.5170851946,
-0.0697997585,
-0.1926203072,
0.9226457477,
-0.0692676231,
0.8311786056,
0.2952699065,
0.1344369501,
-0.3124090135,
-0.7448580265,
-0.6463546753,
-0.1779796183,
-0.8087613583,
0.0283055827,
-0.5120838881,
-0.1559524089,
-0.560626626,
-0.3810674548,
-0.4309469163,
-0.3296198845,
-0.3808700144,
-0.0961686522,
0.0230014194,
0.8106870055,
0.249759391,
0.1175854057,
-0.4641730189,
0.1736407131,
0.6891030669,
-0.0771040022,
0.0005313939,
-0.6906268001,
-0.057585489,
0.1664640903,
-0.3621588945,
-0.8213258982,
0.2176274061,
0.0578040741,
0.6360778213,
0.686668694,
0.4883208275,
0.6522998214,
-0.4583647549,
0.965403676,
0.0302331261,
-0.8820492625,
0.4606580734,
0.015994424,
0.2487358153,
0.2550092041,
0.2876895368,
-0.2532478273,
-0.6822732687,
-0.836088419,
-0.6674663424,
0.7340226173,
0.1289290041,
0.1082028896,
0.1772628576,
0.1680043489,
0.0663896948,
-0.0587433837,
-0.8349208236,
-0.4920039475,
-0.3226080537,
0.058798302,
0.2141584754,
-0.1507118046,
-0.331638515,
0.0273787174,
0.7881831527,
0.0806869864,
-0.0091291666,
-0.0574416891,
-0.1698527336,
0.3716820478,
0.4195962548,
0.683676362,
0.4643666148,
0.0632444024,
0.479154855,
0.3752821386,
-0.4965963662,
0.4213627875,
0.2617317736,
-0.3394767642,
-0.3596385121,
0.4597209096,
1.047731638,
0.2926665246,
-0.6897361875,
0.7471243143,
-0.3523628414,
-0.1712714136,
-0.4977600873,
0.0179276615,
-0.3306058943,
0.3498158157,
0.2871361375,
0.3868735731,
0.0334481299,
-0.4895227253,
0.2911622524,
0.6672099233,
-0.7438161373,
-0.4500915706,
0.7571619153,
-0.2955884933,
-0.20657067,
0.0951107368,
-0.21299088,
-0.7444649935,
0.6930565238,
1.0291116238,
0.5094709992,
-0.3681135178,
0.1021488607,
-0.20027861,
0.3297898471,
0.2252392024,
-0.4692823589,
0.0155964987,
-0.6501101255,
-0.1262107641,
-0.0412158966,
-0.5568609238,
0.4964342117,
-0.7384169698,
0.2149380594,
-0.5311050415,
0.0872960836,
-0.0251378156,
-0.3215378821,
-0.2836050391,
0.0947520137,
0.3267702758,
0.4695894122,
-0.7991626263,
1.016702652,
0.9486996531,
-0.0030679125,
-0.5459786654,
0.1517007798,
0.0453281514,
-0.7078499198,
0.8663201928,
-0.0266844686,
-0.2701529562,
-0.1506214887,
-0.5637719035,
-0.7756400704,
0.8587049842,
0.5686449409,
0.0413413681,
0.212253198,
0.0522654988,
0.2594429553,
-0.2845676541,
0.0483726226,
0.4157297313,
0.2233051658,
0.2502886951,
-0.537304759,
0.2731631696,
-0.1387805492,
-0.039264638,
0.0903183669,
-0.5464522243,
0.9453929663,
-0.1563765109,
-0.4689041972,
-0.129369095,
0.5102558136,
0.2395283431,
0.0708622038,
0.6707646251,
0.2372762114,
0.7284147143,
0.1623223126,
1.2838238478,
-0.0885918215,
0.030307861,
1.1104365587,
-0.3761877716,
0.6049807668,
0.3675350249,
-0.3109805286,
0.116966486,
0.395045191,
0.1106936485,
0.7158584595,
0.1811259687,
-0.6001930833,
0.0616566353,
0.0785823688,
-0.3607171476,
0.4415817857,
0.5845150948,
-0.1762899011,
-0.1072352529,
0.6567520499,
0.3748467565,
0.1702264994,
-0.2070306093,
0.8439019322,
-0.0645540804,
-0.4828925729,
0.8833256364,
-0.1462439895,
0.5653104782,
-0.7819953561,
-0.080523096,
0.1591379195,
0.3918502927,
0.149805814,
-0.4994868934,
0.1402414292,
-0.0518080331,
0.1823419333,
-0.0698714405,
0.693941474,
-0.2883689702,
-0.2774886191,
0.5024515986,
-0.0455710478,
0.0351722836,
-0.0839951932,
-0.6589840055,
-0.0585130677,
0.23217538,
-0.2957740426,
0.8699388504,
0.2730458379,
-0.0963967368,
0.8843559623,
0.555373311,
0.3004548848,
0.0457535349,
0.1170760915,
1.0813142061,
-0.2054982185,
-0.4502971768,
-1.1640683413,
0.0037837343,
-0.0367183797,
0.0953567103,
0.8117307425,
0.3252133131,
0.9219642878,
0.0413552374,
1.2030478716,
0.1905933022,
0.3529103994,
-0.677179873,
0.8825144768,
-0.2987270057,
0.5828601718,
-0.3414254487,
-0.2853355408,
-0.2458165437,
0.1731643379,
-0.2738723159,
-0.2232180685,
0.8307036757,
0.6483200788,
-0.0934145153,
0.1300745904,
0.5585429668,
0.3624961078,
0.8367869258,
0.6048102975,
0.9212600589,
-0.3579453528,
0.9465845227,
-0.3822850287,
-0.2840468585,
-0.0868726596,
-0.7377485037,
-1.1336553097,
-0.4619568586,
-0.3937191367,
-0.3798530698,
0.2078555226,
0.7094805241,
0.5028398633,
-0.8114961982,
0.0871460587,
0.1380639821,
-0.0221961644,
-0.3107335865,
-0.249043867,
0.6922342181,
-0.1139902994,
-0.739520669,
0.7666988969,
-0.0210133344,
0.5148661137,
-0.3672539294,
0.1906799674,
-0.1808272302,
-0.1359654814,
0.4561997652,
0.4371519387,
-0.6193455458,
-0.3460165858,
-0.4121771455,
0.0024943205,
-0.1390281618,
0.6563014388,
-0.7186406851,
0.3886900544,
0.0501930863,
0.9706306458,
0.3054056168,
0.1434933245,
0.6573447585,
-0.8564946055,
0.3204176724,
0.1001287922,
0.4582367539,
0.32308954,
-0.6706274748,
-0.0371522307,
0.1367863417,
-0.4218148887,
-0.6935331225,
0.5579135418,
-0.5829940438,
-0.5661226511,
1.0978420973,
-0.5672733784,
-0.2971678078,
-0.3087006211,
-0.3843746781,
0.054198727,
-0.3458055258,
0.8700962663,
0.5255568624,
-0.1093284413,
0.1485290825,
-0.6807578206,
0.6880239248,
0.2684727311,
-0.6139255166,
0.197187826,
-0.0251250304,
0.0769758448,
-0.0610121824,
0.1910937876,
-0.3728264272,
0.2208116949,
-0.1750202626,
-0.2279735655,
-0.409054786,
-0.1019207388,
-0.5474056005,
0.4809087217,
0.2105748206,
-0.522090137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14949v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14949v2 | Cross-lingual Data Augmentation for Document-grounded Dialog Systems in Low Resource Languages | 2023-05-24T09:40:52 | 2023-09-20T07:39:19 | Qi Gou, Zehua Xia, Wenzhe Du | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper proposes a framework to address the issue of data scarcity in
Document-Grounded Dialogue Systems(DGDS). Our model leverages high-resource
languages to enhance the capability of dialogue generation in low-resource
languages. Specifically, We present a novel pipeline CLEM (Cross-Lingual
Enhanced Model) including adversarial training retrieval (Retriever and
Re-ranker), and Fid (fusion-in-decoder) generator. To further leverage
high-resource language, we also propose an innovative architecture to conduct
alignment across different languages with translated training. Extensive
experiment results demonstrate the effectiveness of our model and we achieved
4th place in the DialDoc 2023 Competition. Therefore, CLEM can serve as a
solution to resource scarcity in DGDS and provide useful guidance for
multi-lingual alignment tasks. | [
-0.4995291233,
-0.7120293379,
0.3658553064,
-0.2255436778,
-0.2764707506,
0.3075853586,
-0.137144044,
-0.1049182117,
0.0975304246,
0.6471087337,
-0.7102621794,
-0.5844181776,
-0.5101541281,
0.0134054283,
-0.1629574895,
0.8583456874,
0.0801987052,
0.3350865245,
-0.2742180228,
-0.3613719046,
-0.7825907469,
-0.4915625155,
-0.3979103267,
-0.1918341368,
0.1357115656,
0.6397021413,
1.1484596729,
0.7355621457,
0.2318184078,
0.3050248027,
-0.0462087058,
0.3053515851,
-0.710170269,
-0.0121208588,
-0.3322307467,
-0.3479925096,
-0.5968204737,
-0.2722518742,
0.7307820916,
0.9241262674,
-0.0247996915,
-0.3790725768,
0.2113892138,
0.4284193516,
-0.3231365681,
0.2073646933,
-0.6379686594,
-0.0134110739,
-0.0564918928,
-0.2476026118,
-0.2347760797,
-0.1890490502,
0.3191123307,
-0.9299910665,
0.2301048338,
0.069022581,
0.7877413034,
0.3697306514,
-0.2964582145,
-0.4092734754,
-0.4717572629,
0.7170189619,
-0.5908606052,
0.6459456086,
0.1379442066,
0.0841976404,
-0.0048865285,
-0.3971151114,
-0.5182914734,
0.1410602927,
-0.1025091261,
0.041160617,
0.1727210283,
0.2640878856,
0.2674002647,
0.6400845647,
-0.5627346039,
0.1065701991,
-0.2408855259,
-0.262873292,
0.434096694,
0.2032147497,
0.3213554621,
-0.0803940892,
-0.4793767929,
-0.1576557606,
-0.6619520187,
-0.3028710186,
0.4395458102,
0.2217520326,
-0.1925731897,
0.4212459028,
-0.2033639848,
0.7800421715,
0.296982944,
-0.245558098,
0.2055371851,
-0.7316317558,
-0.2884669602,
0.2284245938,
0.5659236312,
0.4066959321,
-0.1928248405,
0.0062115025,
-0.1790023744,
-0.1420626193,
-0.0785689354,
-0.6888073087,
0.0458847024,
0.0205821898,
-0.322281301,
-0.3193909228,
-0.227368027,
-1.0045723915,
-0.5358198285,
-0.3873563409,
-0.0671945885,
-0.5149325728,
-0.2238958925,
0.1298774928,
-0.0297805909,
-0.1210537851,
0.4209913611,
-0.8414326906,
0.1757953465,
0.61819309,
0.7843953967,
0.0385183282,
-0.2677001059,
-0.6875487566,
0.0489919037,
-0.2193109989,
0.2978316545,
-0.6615855098,
-0.6283434629,
0.2405590862,
0.1676282287,
-0.0669941828,
-0.5815444589,
0.7851142287,
-0.4968286455,
0.461781323,
-0.2789860666,
-0.4652737081,
-0.2069580257,
0.1753784567,
-0.7055882812,
0.955589354,
0.4899088144,
-0.7771149278,
0.3618069887,
-0.5501533747,
-0.1826612651,
0.3193184435,
-0.172761783,
-0.0795689151,
-0.1663882136,
0.4414478242,
0.1431387067,
-0.7740319371,
0.5512524247,
-0.3328546584,
-0.2672364712,
0.0148449959,
-0.7181603909,
0.7692590952,
0.4645846784,
-0.1844107807,
-0.0444908775,
-0.733934164,
-0.0103669595,
-0.024327198,
-0.2521011233,
-0.4468156993,
-0.3104224205,
0.0673151463,
0.4457102716,
0.3917914331,
-0.6216682196,
0.2884784043,
-0.562045455,
0.373967886,
0.5277360678,
-0.1250570863,
0.699405551,
-0.2412959337,
0.6771672964,
0.2156837434,
-0.0941283554,
-0.5260224342,
-0.0982814506,
-0.8185427785,
-0.5409961939,
0.3744978607,
0.7387086749,
-1.1366837025,
0.5976630449,
-0.5404935479,
-0.2202265412,
-0.9216247797,
0.4169017076,
0.5245444179,
0.6395812035,
0.1159467548,
-0.3801959455,
-0.5455607176,
-0.9296780229,
0.3054151237,
-0.0693213865,
0.0514755659,
0.5999131799,
0.0277562812,
-0.2797403932,
1.0411168337,
-0.3614271581,
-0.2573370039,
-0.3440839052,
0.115135394,
0.042326767,
0.5170161128,
0.4334982038,
-0.7995179892,
-0.4746439755,
0.3151319921,
-0.8265390396,
-0.4270511568,
-0.1512339562,
-0.19716461,
0.3393217623,
0.3509955406,
-0.6747318506,
0.1683159918,
0.6179270148,
-0.1376456022,
0.062501587,
-0.0729589388,
0.2704707682,
-1.1696004868,
-0.0391085409,
-0.286691159,
-0.2160977274,
-0.6380900145,
-0.1722975671,
-0.2338160127,
-0.8501517177,
-0.5221149921,
0.7350924015,
-0.4325973392,
-0.2867313027,
-0.2505676448,
0.4946880937,
0.3474310338,
0.5274554491,
0.3777178228,
0.8223346472,
0.5411829948,
-0.2393837124,
0.559001565,
0.5580444932,
-0.2356421649,
0.903670311,
-0.4183132052,
-0.0026930068,
-0.1292919517,
0.4559913278,
-0.7272095084,
-0.2328043282,
0.177295506,
-0.15803276,
0.3455307186,
-0.3488268554,
-0.4116383493,
-0.2427117527,
0.0415419973,
0.6523430943,
0.2933010161,
-0.6931849122,
0.481228292,
0.4676690698,
-0.6164224148,
-0.6438915133,
-0.27114591,
0.1015209258,
-0.2469318211,
-1.1675745249,
0.1786909699,
0.0090926532,
-0.133850351,
-0.0427876934,
0.1722463965,
-0.0936520696,
-0.0469479449,
0.091984421,
0.2872568369,
-0.2139781117,
0.11295598,
0.0333007984,
-0.151582554,
-0.2663392723,
-0.6081101894,
0.7641924024,
-0.1084436625,
-0.6251910329,
-0.3286243379,
0.7207355499,
0.8284998536,
-0.0884283409,
0.3867095113,
0.4524210989,
-0.2351793796,
0.0178419519,
-0.5503831506,
-0.0572974123,
-0.4646296203,
0.307885915,
-0.3510555625,
-0.8575571179,
0.5702354312,
-0.1679798216,
-0.1210115477,
0.2400253117,
0.5936030746,
0.2237335294,
1.0485670567,
0.4279853404,
-0.239986673,
0.4548582435,
-0.1411678791,
0.2375414371,
-0.6388599277,
0.1890903562,
-0.1046061292,
-0.0457883663,
-0.5519762039,
-0.584610641,
0.5052635074,
0.2685266435,
0.0841766894,
0.1849298179,
-0.4832884371,
0.1441115737,
0.6029942036,
-0.3802898526,
0.3872199059,
-0.0305821281,
-0.2837176621,
-0.2599751949,
-1.1308015585,
-0.5476704836,
0.7613624334,
0.4222070873,
0.7723631263,
-0.2298599631,
0.5401987433,
0.3249277472,
0.0286902729,
-0.6737680435,
0.5395322442,
0.0811049864,
-0.608479917,
-0.356187284,
-0.2381381691,
-0.715759933,
0.5272799134,
-0.0646698102,
-0.5225146413,
0.4914350212,
0.0004245948,
-0.264811337,
0.2486298978,
-0.750277698,
0.9192278981,
-0.3279274404,
-0.553760469,
-0.1768475622,
-0.6035119295,
0.3711123765,
-0.2162166089,
0.2500705123,
0.1244351938,
0.2496920079,
0.3835812807,
-0.8407855034,
0.7890177369,
-0.3512169421,
-0.4107076526,
0.5652290583,
-0.1119544059,
0.7419599891,
0.3016079664,
-0.1146466732,
0.2254185975,
-0.1431247443,
-0.3308755457,
-0.5836681128,
0.813801229,
-0.4947325289,
-0.7469820976,
-0.3865159154,
-0.9077430964,
-0.2052503675,
0.2768704891,
0.1743321419,
0.4792604744,
-0.4784434736,
0.1965793967,
0.6363580823,
-0.3514206111,
0.1671029925,
0.6455881596,
0.171057418,
-0.7390435338,
1.0828286409,
0.0354592428,
0.589086473,
0.1520636827,
-0.2257395983,
-0.2878618538,
-0.3435615003,
-0.896067977,
0.0796618164,
-0.8223600388,
-0.0690766573,
-0.6485651135,
-0.2094173282,
-0.4604505002,
-0.6427815557,
-0.4425560236,
-0.2978937924,
-0.2826263011,
-0.1762533486,
0.1336672753,
0.2640657127,
-0.1321801841,
0.3572721183,
-1.1062144041,
0.0459344462,
-0.0324057117,
0.1216107979,
-0.279504925,
-0.2795471549,
-0.4619167745,
0.3525102139,
-0.3271811008,
-0.4567171335,
0.6411581039,
-0.1724102199,
0.4292019308,
0.3834372759,
0.1686149091,
0.6200933456,
-0.4719035327,
0.8074494004,
0.2364096045,
-0.8970063925,
0.3592953384,
-0.7129247189,
0.3157566786,
0.5097786188,
0.0893066972,
-0.7235342264,
-0.368653059,
-0.7564960718,
-0.7572518587,
0.9694319963,
0.0632517114,
-0.0590709671,
0.0289018787,
-0.1687876135,
0.2458556443,
0.3191133738,
-0.2820940614,
0.1808650792,
-0.3922579587,
-0.3901215792,
0.218873322,
-0.1569543183,
-0.5306561589,
0.2169415951,
0.7684832811,
-0.4481300712,
0.053901162,
0.2467112988,
-0.1788543761,
-0.0950738192,
0.5904579163,
0.4565793872,
0.363982141,
-0.1702402085,
-0.3663280606,
0.1969966441,
-0.2169827372,
0.1735743135,
0.3873189986,
-0.3219470978,
0.186384365,
0.1564742625,
1.201196909,
0.3331767917,
-0.7997851372,
0.4349676669,
0.1889105588,
-0.1073743775,
-0.0954763815,
-0.2612290978,
-0.1476552039,
0.2170273811,
0.2645153701,
-0.1479500979,
0.0034891223,
-0.4803754389,
0.2694683671,
0.5911377072,
-0.3951309621,
-0.1714509428,
0.5581066012,
0.8793512583,
-0.0848775804,
0.4189513922,
-0.2195772082,
-0.6084406376,
0.3718091547,
0.3918612301,
0.6994791627,
0.130841434,
0.2253303975,
0.1664080769,
0.1113642827,
0.0822814256,
0.1637829691,
-0.1779550314,
-0.6913512945,
-0.2522093356,
-0.3312426209,
-0.4457609057,
0.2059748024,
-0.5473533869,
0.4726696014,
-0.2128575295,
0.0332126878,
-0.4142977595,
0.0346792527,
-0.6388423443,
0.1477057338,
0.1988382936,
0.6596364379,
-0.703691721,
0.8827747703,
0.2643618286,
-0.2211506218,
-0.3717009723,
-0.1739944965,
0.2762676775,
-0.7326264977,
0.8915132284,
-0.1888748854,
-0.1206504628,
0.019579526,
-0.0650044456,
-0.9969644547,
1.1540317535,
0.4242250919,
-0.5704159737,
-0.1383945942,
0.3033456504,
0.4467044771,
-0.7045070529,
0.1940024346,
0.5014648438,
0.4867338538,
0.1860780418,
-1.0446363688,
-0.0891567841,
-0.1582725048,
0.0594862811,
0.213323459,
-0.7415097356,
0.5697661638,
0.011949949,
-0.5321662426,
0.1352011263,
0.4463961124,
0.0822509453,
0.3158928454,
0.5661779046,
0.7428306341,
0.7772216797,
-0.1935710758,
1.0249004364,
-0.7184128761,
0.2230706364,
1.1168174744,
-0.7780972123,
0.1312143058,
0.3424228728,
0.294510901,
0.163403064,
0.4765974879,
0.1116259694,
0.6357808113,
-0.1690752953,
-0.3485186398,
-0.2558799982,
-0.7765403986,
-0.4117100835,
0.3823388517,
0.5669320822,
-0.3485837579,
-0.2930113673,
0.0761857629,
-0.1517819911,
0.1262581348,
-0.1348254979,
0.8043875694,
-0.1278526932,
-0.8616380095,
1.0302729607,
-0.171829924,
0.4994785786,
-0.4625582993,
-0.0369980708,
-0.2285887003,
0.1549014151,
-0.0585953891,
-0.6583780646,
0.0796791613,
-0.0822224021,
-0.3039882183,
-0.4448492229,
0.7640411854,
-0.9273696542,
-0.2551746964,
0.3376664519,
0.6774550676,
-0.1644327641,
0.4432812035,
-0.68718189,
0.0899738222,
0.0885279626,
0.1495175362,
0.4628614187,
0.7644085288,
-0.146965906,
0.537702024,
0.6438708305,
-0.0683048293,
-0.0138820801,
0.176802054,
1.028326869,
-0.3401536047,
-0.5980885029,
-0.2623154521,
0.5156877637,
-0.3512080014,
-0.1996789575,
0.6453338265,
0.6074967384,
0.9747052193,
0.0001515606,
1.165784955,
-0.0532775857,
0.6301572323,
-0.627012074,
0.3363155723,
-0.4280924499,
0.4071824551,
-0.1619789004,
-0.8554154038,
0.238462761,
0.2520468235,
-0.1514123529,
-0.3289050162,
0.7227751017,
1.001916647,
-0.1570232511,
0.0284328312,
0.4210741818,
-0.0729939044,
0.2678181231,
0.5853942633,
0.7209760547,
-0.4530740976,
0.7374819517,
-0.007468788,
-0.1358549148,
-0.3454400003,
-0.5092833042,
-0.7119877338,
-0.6258985996,
-0.1970778257,
-0.3904958665,
0.0252346396,
0.8827523589,
0.6363368034,
-0.5295212269,
-0.1106814519,
-0.0485092439,
0.3273408711,
0.0701304749,
-0.2939225435,
0.0784913078,
-0.4680855572,
-1.2388882637,
0.7667090893,
0.4106281996,
0.0784017891,
-0.4244242311,
-0.3653868735,
-0.2313117832,
0.0616248772,
0.2746686041,
0.4091237187,
-0.7890827656,
-0.2871856689,
0.0204167943,
-0.3361309767,
0.1548846811,
1.0651825666,
-0.6333972216,
0.8060801029,
0.7038450241,
0.9025393128,
0.1461379975,
0.3142566681,
1.1768422127,
-0.8527151346,
0.6346409917,
0.1862393171,
0.5791951418,
0.5703662038,
-0.5188616514,
0.5894126892,
0.4272570014,
-0.4412343204,
-0.8840175271,
0.4054293334,
-0.8178560734,
0.0328571387,
1.2081054449,
-0.2810744345,
0.2015376836,
-0.3867818117,
-0.4905484915,
0.19271864,
-0.6476055384,
0.4205864668,
1.1975882053,
0.4172296226,
-0.0780953616,
-0.5055928826,
0.6122577786,
0.6091417074,
-0.6688482761,
0.3814663589,
0.9344972372,
-0.1107903346,
0.410752207,
0.7374075651,
-0.1445014179,
0.2268530726,
0.0297839604,
-0.0748897046,
0.0209465604,
-0.0717595741,
-0.2877385914,
0.011160465,
-0.201213941,
-0.020160757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14947v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14947v2 | How Predictable Are Large Language Model Capabilities? A Case Study on BIG-bench | 2023-05-24T09:35:34 | 2023-10-31T17:27:07 | Qinyuan Ye, Harvey Yiyun Fu, Xiang Ren, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We investigate the predictability of large language model (LLM) capabilities:
given records of past experiments using different model families, numbers of
parameters, tasks, and numbers of in-context examples, can we accurately
predict LLM performance on new experiment configurations? Answering this
question has practical implications for LLM users (e.g., deciding which models
to try), developers (e.g., prioritizing evaluation on representative tasks),
and the research community (e.g., identifying hard-to-predict capabilities that
warrant further investigation).
We study the performance prediction problem on experiment records from
BIG-bench. On a random train-test split, an MLP-based predictor achieves an
$R^2$ score greater than 95%, indicating the presence of learnable patterns
within the experiment records. We then formulate the problem of searching for
"small-bench," an informative subset of BIG-bench tasks from which the
performance on the full set can be maximally recovered. We find a subset as
informative as BIG-bench Hard for evaluating new model families, while being
$3\times$ smaller. Additionally, we find competitive subsets by clustering task
representations learned by our MLP-based predictor and selecting tasks close to
cluster centroids, highlighting the importance of task diversity in
constructing "small-bench." | [
-0.4237217903,
-0.4948529899,
0.9069074988,
0.2746541798,
0.1073295623,
-0.0057597556,
-0.6184232831,
-0.636367023,
-0.1168627068,
0.3294463158,
-0.4466216564,
-0.2086070627,
-0.7544033527,
-0.0480352193,
-0.5414922237,
0.5866346359,
-0.012714061,
0.1053176746,
-0.2889536619,
0.0426964983,
-0.5823687315,
-0.5213996768,
-0.3601523042,
-0.4658172131,
0.6106958389,
0.5496764779,
0.4567643404,
0.8417468667,
0.479097724,
0.2800096273,
-0.1330423653,
-0.2686038911,
-0.5486508012,
0.1627253592,
-0.099894546,
-0.7613287568,
-0.1182910725,
-0.0698431432,
0.71440202,
0.8092475533,
-0.1348884702,
0.1509739757,
0.2050927579,
0.5386537313,
-0.3985945582,
0.3976564705,
-0.8696035743,
-0.0402022935,
-0.3551047146,
0.0740836039,
-0.437480092,
0.0964388549,
-0.0043924451,
-0.3739798367,
0.3025621176,
0.1632871628,
0.451146841,
0.1558004469,
-0.191313073,
0.0534478463,
-1.0952059031,
1.0423002243,
-0.5088930726,
0.3186426461,
0.5911969543,
0.8120946884,
-0.3703220487,
-0.5568739176,
-0.3611026704,
-0.392986089,
-0.0082559399,
-0.0433613732,
0.0867261887,
-0.2160539329,
0.440290451,
0.2721364796,
-0.5178135037,
0.5716226697,
-0.2170293778,
0.0433585793,
0.6504814625,
0.3396056294,
-0.1207645237,
0.0471936874,
0.003853536,
-0.0213299729,
-0.6340098977,
0.104112789,
-0.026327651,
0.557382822,
-0.0386254862,
0.7101647258,
-0.2443480939,
0.5419328809,
-0.1286008656,
-0.3455129266,
0.0870590955,
-0.2153285444,
-0.099354066,
-0.1541787535,
0.546451509,
-0.2064099908,
0.3113709092,
-0.306827873,
-0.4993349314,
-0.2046518326,
0.1058641523,
-0.6059682965,
-0.0795455649,
0.1669291258,
-0.4393387139,
0.0028160447,
-0.1398996562,
-0.560082674,
-0.6214517951,
-0.4017261565,
0.2888608277,
-0.5082999468,
-0.2053692639,
-0.2057714164,
0.0137887923,
0.1176458076,
0.2402452826,
-0.9778750539,
0.4203858972,
0.9615316987,
0.6682314277,
-0.3470631242,
-0.5493140221,
-0.6273338199,
0.0641590208,
-0.2922388613,
0.3318376839,
-0.4477447569,
-0.3999110162,
0.0110459086,
-0.0684174001,
-0.1044165641,
-0.5312873721,
0.2384800762,
-0.3863888979,
-0.3124165535,
-0.3895809948,
-0.6046969891,
0.1469259113,
0.1114851609,
-0.809245646,
0.6755071878,
0.0074303383,
-0.5629355907,
0.5164043307,
-0.2612403333,
-0.4521751404,
-0.0251248777,
-0.3034591079,
-0.2726294994,
0.3543225527,
-0.1091898158,
0.6695078611,
-0.3666343391,
0.0752740502,
-0.6281536818,
-0.5161172748,
0.546857059,
-0.2964467704,
0.2765296102,
-0.01861904,
-0.501491785,
0.0075088744,
-0.7810996175,
0.0918368846,
0.0237991083,
-0.3683591485,
-0.0752974674,
0.1654492319,
-0.0376368426,
0.2413286567,
0.1565139592,
-0.4459353685,
-0.1062389761,
-0.2823086381,
0.1772397906,
0.9123216271,
-0.3570827246,
0.4977594316,
-0.4805119932,
0.6266922951,
-0.3578471243,
0.1970478594,
0.2417384833,
-0.5828686953,
-0.4715510607,
-0.3087182939,
0.4787654579,
0.3283175826,
-0.3753572106,
0.2647230923,
-0.3371888101,
-0.8036993146,
-0.0544885136,
0.3905625045,
0.5180712938,
0.0892317966,
0.1602525264,
-0.0452635437,
-0.5288569927,
-1.0905455351,
-0.0912887529,
-0.0011473309,
0.034939453,
0.4359953403,
0.6335899234,
-0.1465765238,
0.8134121299,
-0.4321037829,
-0.1876378059,
-0.4721494615,
0.1091042757,
0.5472860336,
0.341581136,
0.4244710207,
-0.8323101401,
-0.6825829744,
0.1554167122,
-0.3453755081,
0.059530627,
0.2842564583,
0.0898614004,
0.2504332364,
0.5605509877,
-0.668610394,
0.1331667155,
0.7320775986,
0.1539080143,
0.6874989271,
-0.1261746734,
-0.2876053751,
-0.8636504412,
0.2473296672,
-0.0582220033,
-0.0576353297,
-0.3262957036,
-0.1187864915,
0.0105591482,
0.0938335508,
-0.0229268745,
0.5738651752,
-0.336386621,
-0.5127476454,
-0.2711391747,
-0.1284744889,
-0.5065438151,
0.2047045529,
-0.0602970719,
0.8553818464,
0.4970437884,
-0.5429471135,
-0.0436405428,
-0.1136824414,
-0.8184648752,
0.0223907381,
-0.5447503328,
-0.2004983872,
0.1323132515,
0.163006857,
-0.8918493986,
-0.5131950974,
-0.4822704196,
-0.3794169426,
0.5233136415,
-0.1816081107,
-0.6701411605,
-0.5881584883,
0.1603965908,
0.2416541427,
0.564099133,
-0.4537283182,
0.4091667533,
0.4612771273,
-0.2337555736,
-0.7957533002,
-0.7837049365,
-0.2210477889,
0.0732355341,
-0.3674724996,
0.3236642182,
-0.2014029324,
-0.2690287828,
-0.0793111995,
-0.0950052589,
-0.0872729346,
0.4554702044,
0.7299156189,
0.1000694931,
-0.2233915627,
0.3628175259,
-0.4770778716,
-0.0641320646,
0.1047372147,
-0.0182768181,
0.6734634638,
-0.2511602938,
-0.5392807722,
0.2723063529,
0.137411803,
0.5974623561,
-0.1239896342,
0.8361716866,
0.5867439508,
-0.4371240735,
-0.5324972868,
-0.7076258063,
-0.2482502311,
-0.4147327244,
0.5278870463,
-0.3549082279,
-0.9803237319,
0.6864047647,
0.147910893,
-0.0485161655,
0.3564863801,
0.5910470486,
-0.1354069114,
1.1332781315,
0.7716328502,
-0.1235664114,
0.4597843587,
-0.2347122431,
0.0299691278,
-0.6080155373,
-0.0672708899,
-0.5134529471,
-0.5315533876,
-0.7070791125,
-0.5155023336,
0.2872165442,
0.0677899867,
-0.1800450534,
0.1654534638,
-0.070604749,
0.4785035253,
0.7929677963,
-0.1179390997,
0.2224358469,
-0.0241618101,
-0.1660630554,
-0.0750837699,
-0.5665961504,
-0.2593831122,
1.3446038961,
0.3305360973,
0.6189442277,
-0.0021146559,
0.8022040129,
-0.079586491,
0.4841477275,
-0.7535057664,
0.6143191457,
-0.3341233134,
-0.7490814924,
-0.4591000974,
-0.4985651672,
-1.0396149158,
0.0774369538,
-0.3058038354,
-0.9009844065,
-0.0216105841,
0.0009127468,
-0.317060262,
0.2028735727,
-0.5384161472,
0.6576827765,
-0.3042483628,
-0.3545516431,
-0.3949313462,
-0.4535263777,
0.4101147354,
-0.3900481761,
0.4253336191,
-0.1085288376,
0.0919744819,
0.5705482364,
-0.0737237707,
0.7722759247,
-0.0823341012,
0.3625215888,
0.0055774678,
0.2257238328,
0.4389828444,
-0.0399832912,
-0.3431836069,
-0.1524004787,
-0.043939665,
-0.2559999228,
-0.4859141111,
0.9285371304,
-0.8670996428,
-0.806535542,
-0.263800621,
-0.5955718756,
-0.7232626677,
0.2900309861,
0.1131471023,
0.2660927474,
-0.362167418,
0.5818780661,
0.5619802475,
-0.0217075963,
0.5463396311,
0.5448492765,
-0.3853793144,
-0.003392793,
0.8364472389,
0.3446401954,
0.0975327119,
0.4628998935,
0.3812032938,
-0.1186206639,
-0.9955901504,
-0.1098356321,
0.3243070841,
-0.5397213697,
-0.023049755,
-0.3467062712,
-0.2575387359,
-0.086181663,
-0.1167448685,
-0.4012588561,
-0.4587827623,
-0.1432373822,
-0.1250798106,
0.0389242209,
0.871366024,
-0.1122484356,
0.2180499583,
-0.7178950906,
-0.0324117988,
0.422786206,
0.5439700484,
0.0527214184,
-0.5078255534,
-0.5450058579,
-0.1433774978,
-0.036134921,
-0.3287870884,
0.2774885297,
-0.1165435389,
0.7973243594,
-0.0205510445,
-0.1379638612,
0.2036727965,
-0.4452660084,
0.5504257083,
0.1963626444,
-0.5557281971,
0.2875893116,
-0.4919482768,
0.2218105793,
0.5715397596,
0.2893286347,
-0.1038125381,
-0.3906437755,
-0.6855390668,
-0.6683331132,
0.6650491357,
-0.0519476421,
-0.0512157753,
0.2403840125,
0.1676552743,
0.3140105605,
0.4179968238,
-0.6753391623,
0.0202026181,
0.2527447343,
0.0269007087,
-0.6593518853,
-0.3856524825,
-0.2607298195,
-0.2537104189,
0.5138400197,
-0.1301570535,
0.1286931634,
-0.3265624344,
0.0340698436,
-0.3021148741,
0.2506524622,
0.4400756955,
1.0488624573,
-0.4546528459,
0.0168534648,
0.101255171,
-0.2358879447,
-0.0282506943,
0.3089008331,
0.1170190349,
-0.164620772,
0.4946204722,
0.7481865287,
0.2751453221,
-0.8503804803,
0.4997876287,
0.1002894491,
-0.1409694701,
-0.7652053833,
0.2103778273,
0.3320571482,
0.5300401449,
0.4035775959,
-0.0330701433,
-0.0119746048,
-0.6069973111,
0.1052328721,
0.4924791157,
-0.2545909286,
-0.1067642421,
0.4639276564,
0.0218740813,
-0.2300015241,
0.4945307374,
-0.0351079442,
-0.4375662506,
0.931743443,
0.5200114846,
0.619206965,
-0.2082859278,
0.0799842849,
0.2963337898,
0.226866588,
-0.3712438047,
0.1414425224,
0.3527699411,
-0.662021637,
-0.5735405087,
-0.7788822651,
-0.4851011634,
0.359302789,
-0.550942719,
0.0525191985,
-0.5765839815,
-0.2839534283,
0.1176094189,
0.1151351929,
-0.8734042048,
0.2055728137,
0.3625477552,
0.9734944105,
-0.6737274528,
0.9931340814,
0.3646243811,
-0.0790660828,
-1.0570942163,
-0.0419871695,
-0.0179893915,
-0.8584320545,
0.8419623971,
0.2332821041,
0.2403595001,
-0.3721212745,
-0.254553467,
-1.1443805695,
1.2695326805,
0.3277694881,
-0.7709278464,
0.0591006912,
0.1085826531,
0.6277236938,
-0.3715653121,
0.106939204,
0.594134748,
0.5694234967,
-0.0135490997,
-1.186806798,
0.1014254764,
-0.0749226958,
0.0720359236,
0.2374094874,
-0.4927699268,
0.9385678172,
-0.3163375258,
0.0279220585,
0.2587125301,
0.4552021623,
0.3328744173,
0.3682538569,
0.5438033342,
0.3042519093,
0.8219286799,
-0.1429058313,
1.5329829454,
-0.1761499792,
0.1120697558,
1.2146424055,
-0.2712014914,
1.2737549543,
0.4655153453,
-0.2916963696,
0.3553785384,
0.4377891421,
-0.1253614277,
0.5341636539,
0.4042046368,
-0.0958184823,
-0.5106296539,
0.0527735725,
-0.2375258654,
0.5721451044,
0.3527803719,
-0.5192787051,
0.2381242663,
-0.0647484511,
-0.2606620789,
0.1224762574,
-0.4065123498,
0.4517088234,
0.1440996528,
-0.8563661575,
0.4333344996,
-0.0577121675,
0.3872294426,
-0.7132424712,
0.1729151309,
0.0318240039,
0.5336816311,
0.0585749932,
-0.9981439114,
-0.0166667849,
-0.5158694386,
-0.5464295745,
-0.0579078533,
0.6958934665,
-0.274368763,
-0.4236007929,
0.5463849306,
0.7693505287,
-0.2218388915,
-0.0432828888,
-0.4881096184,
0.1564375013,
-0.0818294436,
-0.4037052095,
0.9345546961,
0.2029340863,
0.0864731222,
0.8579643369,
0.4090664685,
0.2275697142,
0.0912032276,
-0.0815347508,
0.6800953746,
-0.4041428268,
-0.2235643268,
-0.6180754304,
0.2827692628,
-0.0960364938,
-0.062863417,
0.6084856987,
0.3939464986,
0.6909615993,
-0.1950787902,
0.9375299811,
0.1062094048,
0.7929727435,
-0.439665556,
0.5696465373,
-0.4975377619,
0.1777720302,
0.0165848471,
-0.956097126,
-0.0535712019,
0.2469178289,
-0.5819659829,
0.2553719878,
0.7588397861,
0.7152269483,
-0.1668664515,
0.0382675752,
0.4626996517,
0.5006254911,
0.2104117423,
0.6079298854,
0.6112782359,
0.1113336831,
0.6684022546,
-0.6368101239,
-0.3158099055,
-0.431289345,
-0.766919136,
-0.8061419725,
-0.5837323666,
0.1869517863,
-0.385094285,
-0.06399744,
0.6179904938,
0.7078754306,
-0.8818318248,
-0.5724223256,
-0.1328461021,
0.1353993565,
-0.3108892143,
-0.1837675571,
0.2005057484,
-0.263798058,
-0.5698114038,
0.5348665714,
-0.0903334171,
-0.14597179,
-0.2190070003,
-0.1153166145,
0.0026347144,
-0.1542414278,
0.4212465584,
0.4816099405,
-0.5813043118,
-0.3274529278,
0.0246532932,
-0.3261728585,
-0.4491719007,
0.8173063397,
-0.5188951492,
0.2376719266,
0.3226616681,
0.8568207026,
0.8446878195,
-0.2744342685,
0.8747181296,
-0.720164597,
-0.0461937711,
0.3546609282,
0.7065672874,
0.2145935595,
-0.1092107743,
0.7425294518,
0.1465994865,
-0.7470715642,
-0.8875632286,
0.1959571093,
-0.9689646363,
-0.3410403132,
1.4050860405,
-0.1121739894,
-0.137404561,
-0.0005623486,
0.1129556671,
-0.0914274901,
-0.146811679,
0.7747194171,
0.9169015884,
-0.1795555353,
-0.171920076,
-0.95483917,
0.4913119078,
0.5042832494,
-0.4592354,
0.3006320298,
0.4065509737,
0.2699174285,
0.4055326879,
0.44840011,
0.1471208632,
0.3634873331,
0.0009609182,
-0.2259065211,
-0.2135127634,
-0.3484450579,
0.0636553764,
0.3022657037,
0.6266906857,
0.2275728583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14938v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14938v2 | Do LLMs Understand Social Knowledge? Evaluating the Sociability of Large Language Models with SocKET Benchmark | 2023-05-24T09:21:06 | 2023-12-07T23:13:50 | Minje Choi, Jiaxin Pei, Sagar Kumar, Chang Shu, David Jurgens | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have been shown to perform well at a variety of
syntactic, discourse, and reasoning tasks. While LLMs are increasingly deployed
in many forms including conversational agents that interact with humans, we
lack a grounded benchmark to measure how well LLMs understand \textit{social}
language. Here, we introduce a new theory-driven benchmark, SocKET, that
contains 58 NLP tasks testing social knowledge which we group into five
categories: humor & sarcasm, offensiveness, sentiment & emotion, and
trustworthiness. In tests on the benchmark, we demonstrate that current models
attain only moderate performance but reveal significant potential for task
transfer among different types and categories of tasks, which were predicted
from theory. Through zero-shot evaluations, we show that pretrained models
already possess some innate but limited capabilities of social language
understanding and training on one category of tasks can improve zero-shot
testing on others. Our benchmark provides a systematic way to analyze model
performance on an important dimension of language and points to clear room for
improvement to build more socially-aware LLMs. The associated resources are
released at https://github.com/minjechoi/SOCKET. | [
-0.1115242466,
-0.8035404682,
0.8726237416,
0.3059210777,
-0.3028592169,
0.4605517983,
-0.3887426853,
-0.6386310458,
0.2938449979,
0.3316595256,
-0.2553354204,
-0.5928128958,
-0.6468356848,
0.0489576235,
-0.5344269872,
0.6398451328,
0.2863001823,
-0.0579832792,
-0.6318544149,
-0.0992467403,
-0.1241340041,
-0.3795955479,
-0.6792197227,
-0.6315612793,
0.6478231549,
0.5483714342,
0.4271301925,
0.2577871382,
0.5095784068,
0.275447011,
-0.3853089213,
0.0031238687,
-0.9233033061,
0.0135714766,
-0.2410082966,
-0.5038663745,
-0.5343443751,
-0.2002473474,
0.7108316422,
0.8419162035,
-0.0230304189,
0.5485690236,
0.0344686992,
0.6472330689,
-0.5188566446,
0.3135326505,
-0.9840756059,
-0.097301282,
-0.1480788887,
-0.146355927,
-0.5568630695,
-0.3177690208,
-0.0557519011,
-0.4006626904,
0.1896378398,
0.0086335326,
0.520293951,
-0.0781435892,
-0.5324241519,
0.3435411751,
-0.6568042636,
0.5424727798,
-0.4718694985,
0.3431162238,
0.3250204325,
0.3947511613,
-0.036823824,
-0.4397688508,
-0.5629594326,
-0.1635359228,
0.1971478611,
-0.0193451177,
-0.0168872625,
-0.0280223899,
0.3319319189,
-0.0218786076,
-0.4027169943,
-0.1187251732,
-0.4909039438,
0.0912666917,
0.8690205812,
0.0842640176,
0.1480802447,
-0.1910919994,
-0.381973654,
0.146096155,
-0.8255656958,
0.2539561093,
0.1226436198,
-0.0097028399,
-0.3680422008,
0.3950490654,
-0.3826591074,
0.3875373602,
-0.2538720965,
0.0218668822,
0.2018580735,
-0.2262684703,
-0.0625331253,
-0.0880433843,
0.7711796761,
0.4087476134,
0.7571097016,
-0.4108415246,
-0.1205094755,
0.2076631039,
0.1872637421,
-0.3647537827,
-0.0223127697,
-0.0993247703,
-0.4337953329,
-0.6127074361,
-0.4045965672,
-0.1302218288,
-0.6858343482,
-0.0810236707,
0.2297079414,
-0.3721878827,
-0.6873497367,
0.4136997461,
-0.2862448096,
0.4218652546,
0.3851443231,
-0.6201965213,
0.6183490157,
1.0664355755,
0.9346584678,
-0.1602988243,
-0.3821345866,
-0.4130696356,
0.0845430046,
-0.2416145653,
0.9382815361,
-0.4672289789,
-0.17351529,
0.0833578184,
0.0955164582,
-0.2035142928,
-0.3626722395,
0.0374396145,
-0.6403943896,
-0.5405957103,
-0.5780746937,
-0.5137581825,
-0.0172960758,
0.3591765761,
-0.2827834487,
0.8293349147,
-0.1268718243,
-0.7545608282,
0.0924122781,
-0.3852434158,
-0.66986835,
0.2806507051,
-0.0608629137,
0.2003154159,
0.3356640637,
-0.4049914777,
0.780272603,
-0.5029582977,
0.3734473586,
-1.0546729565,
-0.6298026443,
0.560915947,
-0.1258260161,
0.7805451155,
-0.1491583735,
-0.2782157063,
-0.0976834521,
-0.680803597,
-0.1330769509,
0.3435337842,
0.0311494563,
-0.2414507121,
0.2225055844,
-0.2210749984,
0.0758189708,
0.290365845,
-0.7484407425,
-0.2614211142,
-0.3376866579,
0.5876251459,
1.0357527733,
-0.2792384624,
0.2707617283,
-0.3756050169,
0.4098081291,
-0.22091043,
0.2936486602,
0.3649464846,
-0.4864273965,
-0.7282277942,
0.2971487045,
0.0069185309,
0.5182014108,
-0.7125523686,
0.1714367568,
-0.402834028,
-0.7527756095,
-0.3067693114,
0.3298474252,
0.4042813182,
0.3174644411,
-0.0238262992,
-0.5683068633,
-0.1776752919,
-0.7102083564,
-0.3173315525,
-0.5519015789,
0.195980221,
0.520578444,
0.370919317,
-0.0174040999,
0.5946112275,
-0.322119683,
0.1537560672,
-0.4516068399,
0.0349036306,
0.2172276676,
0.0504566953,
0.4239469171,
-0.2987613082,
-0.4769726694,
0.1409806311,
-0.902785182,
-0.1583331078,
0.3959249854,
-0.0914441794,
-0.0985255465,
0.5851469636,
-0.6839956045,
0.1685833782,
0.5500411987,
-0.3705230057,
0.6688312888,
-0.0165387206,
-0.1164081544,
-0.813773632,
0.0562379025,
0.0118813552,
-0.5843171477,
-0.5797126293,
-0.0300532281,
0.0887673423,
-0.0549617745,
-0.7158119082,
0.633410275,
-0.4998377562,
-0.5090789199,
-0.0738304183,
0.5126515031,
-0.1634960473,
0.1634663939,
-0.024628548,
0.3574245274,
0.6908186674,
-0.3945210874,
0.4379846752,
-0.1934238672,
-0.4295924604,
0.5984185934,
-1.0558378696,
0.451962322,
-0.2500739992,
0.0858154967,
-1.1638991833,
-0.063208133,
-0.0644337013,
-0.5437234044,
0.0621657036,
-0.1581412107,
-0.489204824,
-0.1242996827,
-0.2691723704,
0.2689210176,
0.5540164709,
-0.1448646635,
0.4194219708,
0.6356229782,
-0.0788190141,
-0.5753782392,
-0.3341165483,
-0.0114783728,
-0.0460725389,
-0.9197959304,
0.1771354675,
-0.2055187821,
-0.4992935658,
-0.0780697763,
0.1015622169,
0.0013673872,
0.5182750225,
0.2665448189,
0.197170347,
-0.2461130917,
0.3118489683,
-0.1474582404,
0.0347234644,
0.4741854668,
0.3042616844,
0.7133187652,
-0.335858196,
-0.4328561723,
-0.1457968354,
-0.1618649811,
0.5200898051,
-0.1035964265,
0.6654577851,
0.6163256168,
-0.2171740681,
-0.1553985476,
-0.9057890177,
-0.1955101192,
-0.4698072374,
0.2672709823,
-0.3002991378,
-1.1231149435,
0.6423611045,
-0.0445414744,
-0.1123606786,
0.1571121663,
0.1115357503,
-0.2376737893,
0.8712287545,
0.5678864121,
-0.3016060889,
0.4029392898,
0.0418370664,
0.1739180088,
-0.7477070689,
0.1568493992,
-0.3797804713,
-0.3191210926,
-0.4349865615,
-0.5301908255,
0.2043684572,
-0.0436859652,
-0.1353482902,
0.1448606402,
-0.0145114437,
0.7146089077,
0.2113733143,
0.3145875931,
0.3649720848,
-0.209134832,
0.2333525121,
0.408929348,
-0.5857669115,
-0.4822048545,
1.0843297243,
0.4871139824,
0.6901990175,
0.1665365696,
0.8748921156,
0.3222644925,
0.3667268753,
-0.5646228194,
0.9497522116,
-0.2782403827,
-0.4347265363,
-0.2036885619,
-0.3918639123,
-0.6571910977,
0.0068181218,
-0.3329157531,
-0.8344430327,
-0.0190981366,
0.0944020599,
-0.2365999967,
0.173034206,
-0.7518273592,
0.8514690399,
-0.1877436042,
-0.5188359022,
-0.5640354753,
-0.6772816181,
0.5460695028,
0.172828123,
0.3585827947,
-0.7171909809,
0.1751720458,
0.6371645927,
0.0906475857,
1.1635099649,
-0.2264332473,
0.2736637294,
0.0807683691,
0.0954168364,
0.4993770421,
0.1891836524,
-0.1541980058,
0.3448682725,
0.2767910361,
-0.545486033,
-0.4491534531,
0.567835927,
-0.7943277955,
-0.7022948861,
-0.2109644115,
-0.2104610205,
-0.2014835328,
0.054032784,
-0.2442225367,
0.1722290367,
-0.5571987629,
0.4900281131,
0.857915163,
-0.1687522233,
0.0764663592,
0.7945934534,
-0.1634476334,
0.1430914849,
0.6727818847,
-0.0396751873,
0.6119208336,
0.1722151488,
0.1443106681,
-0.0913117602,
-0.3757643998,
-0.0367108025,
0.5884158015,
-0.8000764251,
0.0210216306,
-0.8181649446,
-0.3174285293,
-0.7233738899,
-0.2554519176,
-0.3756454587,
-0.3441470563,
-0.1686543077,
-0.1273677498,
0.3778320849,
1.0125397444,
-0.0343933292,
0.2483610064,
-0.6454716325,
0.1849014312,
0.3514932394,
0.4806320071,
0.1484964788,
-0.5296205878,
-0.0711730197,
-0.1189007834,
0.04541279,
-0.9875527024,
0.0012754445,
0.1773017049,
0.4351853728,
0.3601126373,
0.095568493,
0.4234315753,
-0.5225249529,
0.5920710564,
0.1460442543,
-1.0319046974,
0.3107684851,
-0.4197453558,
0.0721200854,
0.4807069302,
0.2894645035,
-0.8184579015,
-0.5281313062,
-0.781128943,
-0.5540506244,
0.4927040339,
-0.1403754205,
0.3466820717,
-0.2629123926,
0.4176684618,
-0.1540032029,
0.0936593935,
-0.8433099389,
-0.1510755122,
0.2478891313,
-0.0124769527,
-0.3524601161,
-0.600956738,
0.0352698639,
-0.2840385437,
0.5349402428,
-0.2201325297,
0.2734222114,
-0.0379164405,
-0.2240672261,
-0.1540842503,
0.2922963798,
0.273788929,
0.8454903364,
-0.3655865788,
0.489574343,
0.4028604627,
-0.1961131543,
0.1381189376,
-0.0568976253,
0.0497927777,
-0.1830212176,
0.4486201406,
0.5221461058,
0.4346777499,
-0.5138545036,
0.8147943616,
-0.3360949457,
-0.1113148034,
-0.4404144287,
0.3719907403,
0.575273037,
0.408269316,
-0.0959535167,
-0.2444933057,
0.0888815373,
-0.5780901909,
-0.0089628873,
0.7787427306,
-0.4241624177,
-0.6704160571,
0.4014062881,
0.3559756875,
-0.3424628079,
0.1871618927,
-0.4411918223,
-0.4587982595,
0.5722107291,
0.6621240973,
0.8578110337,
-0.0603948347,
0.6185168028,
0.1716944873,
0.5053785443,
-0.063628301,
0.5043919086,
-0.1980796754,
-1.1255571842,
-0.4129712284,
-0.5716456175,
-0.5088973045,
-0.1985925734,
-0.4538309574,
0.2376869768,
-0.5706369877,
-0.119125165,
0.1877671182,
-0.1157648191,
-1.0037533045,
-0.2270581722,
0.0733391866,
0.8785432577,
-1.1280726194,
0.8011381626,
0.6509345174,
-0.0209624246,
-0.6351386905,
-0.4451335371,
0.0289621465,
-1.233915329,
0.8001045585,
0.1176165342,
-0.3262457848,
-0.042255614,
-0.6246611476,
-0.8562535048,
0.9753223062,
0.4203771949,
-0.5513066053,
0.1449653059,
0.2145963758,
0.5958141088,
-0.3959579468,
0.4717781246,
0.4935352504,
0.1667231917,
-0.0535289273,
-0.8516258001,
0.2065618932,
-0.4722630382,
0.0362865068,
-0.140137434,
-0.8418050408,
0.5906563997,
-0.0412378199,
-0.1632769108,
-0.3179847002,
0.3910147548,
0.210420236,
0.5693641901,
0.783932507,
0.2335940152,
0.6553023458,
0.0344041288,
0.9930124879,
-0.5369967818,
0.2335261852,
0.9747752547,
-0.8424134254,
1.0765188932,
0.33693102,
-0.1886793226,
0.4590582252,
0.476365447,
0.5384993553,
0.0476789288,
0.2955105901,
-0.3954979479,
-0.5175488591,
-0.3802905381,
-0.2476559877,
0.5097607374,
0.2751584351,
-0.3244407475,
0.1795537621,
-0.4104861915,
-0.0025158459,
-0.0780706406,
-0.0533593334,
0.9359771609,
0.2886295319,
-0.4772587419,
0.5368471742,
-0.2658139467,
0.6058288217,
-0.4247768521,
0.1603025198,
-0.227808699,
0.028683031,
-0.0227968898,
-0.7801144123,
0.2539820373,
-0.0629278868,
0.0706808493,
-0.1481456906,
1.3666049242,
-0.2147858143,
-0.4171234965,
0.6860688925,
0.5590949655,
0.3908142447,
-0.1288771182,
-0.5116372705,
0.0617856458,
-0.1937808394,
-0.0230626278,
0.3573846519,
0.635802865,
0.3071596622,
0.6667149067,
0.5962884426,
0.3990163207,
-0.1586177349,
0.2466640472,
0.8405222893,
-0.7273960114,
-0.0546004064,
-0.9981967211,
0.2883868515,
-0.3755500317,
-0.139574632,
0.6340549588,
0.1634097397,
0.7826960087,
0.1706035584,
0.5818535686,
0.1554898769,
0.4907742739,
-0.1819490641,
0.8087943196,
-0.5378411412,
0.2071584314,
-0.4614389837,
-0.763256669,
-0.0073173977,
0.5592594147,
-0.5697247982,
-0.3108963072,
0.5971000195,
0.8042056561,
-0.0626387447,
0.1574277282,
0.523207128,
0.3047459126,
0.1398139894,
0.5362378359,
1.0468806028,
-0.0129615078,
0.2941597998,
-0.3145998716,
-0.393586874,
-0.0874541849,
-0.8821269274,
-1.1569422483,
-0.2062931508,
-0.260152638,
-0.3624469638,
0.412340194,
0.8439432979,
0.6232430339,
-0.2650406659,
-0.6670229435,
0.0374165252,
0.5226862431,
-0.0475888588,
-0.2527579963,
-0.1423885971,
-0.5124259591,
-0.0534922332,
0.2734554112,
0.4747336209,
-0.3308841884,
-0.314150244,
0.0150523735,
-0.223619923,
0.1035278216,
0.9693070054,
0.001574729,
-0.4997910261,
-0.6464568973,
0.4621346295,
0.0973221362,
-0.2238325626,
0.5934582949,
-0.4711191058,
0.4024401903,
0.6330273747,
0.5845719576,
0.422162205,
-0.342800647,
0.5128213763,
-0.6238551736,
-0.0916630477,
-0.0740127042,
0.5038167238,
0.3348674774,
-0.3285658956,
0.5807692409,
0.5147470236,
-0.7475888133,
-0.8826842904,
0.2049206644,
-0.8714742661,
-0.0347493626,
1.3290922642,
-0.1272823662,
-0.6239073873,
-0.1947598159,
0.1883691251,
0.2086129338,
-0.2850946486,
1.006898284,
0.7577156425,
0.1271827072,
-0.3422484398,
-0.5498741269,
0.2662801743,
0.5619432926,
-0.7663998008,
0.2946094871,
0.2446717918,
0.3903036714,
0.0901359916,
1.2368879318,
0.14015387,
0.4667720199,
-0.3449079692,
0.0389048308,
0.3948123157,
-0.1150895953,
-0.0559522882,
-0.0343585685,
0.4429959357,
0.1846543849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14937v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14937v2 | A Fair and In-Depth Evaluation of Existing End-to-End Entity Linking Systems | 2023-05-24T09:20:15 | 2023-11-17T15:28:00 | Hannah Bast, Matthias Hertel, Natalie Prange | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing evaluations of entity linking systems often say little about how the
system is going to perform for a particular application. There are two
fundamental reasons for this. One is that many evaluations only use aggregate
measures (like precision, recall, and F1 score), without a detailed error
analysis or a closer look at the results. The other is that all of the widely
used benchmarks have strong biases and artifacts, in particular: a strong focus
on named entities, an unclear or missing specification of what else counts as
an entity mention, poor handling of ambiguities, and an over- or
underrepresentation of certain kinds of entities.
We provide a more meaningful and fair in-depth evaluation of a variety of
existing end-to-end entity linkers. We characterize their strengths and
weaknesses and also report on reproducibility aspects. The detailed results of
our evaluation can be inspected under
https://elevant.cs.uni-freiburg.de/emnlp2023 . Our evaluation is based on
several widely used benchmarks, which exhibit the problems mentioned above to
various degrees, as well as on two new benchmarks, which address the problems
mentioned above. The new benchmarks can be found under
https://github.com/ad-freiburg/fair-entity-linking-benchmarks . | [
-0.833990097,
-0.6560117006,
0.5887765884,
0.185716331,
-0.3323340416,
-0.0787546113,
-0.1913858354,
-1.0297027826,
0.3369863033,
0.0748376995,
-0.1711889505,
-0.3310568333,
-0.3937827945,
0.3165827394,
-0.6271981597,
1.1203371286,
-0.3220695555,
0.1501656026,
-0.7625316381,
-0.5597616434,
-0.1837109774,
-0.1558615565,
-0.7009881139,
-0.3022671342,
0.295253545,
0.2857173383,
0.6819152832,
0.4518601298,
0.7443493605,
0.1844038963,
-0.1312722862,
-0.0616523176,
-0.5850898027,
0.0562323928,
-0.5352964997,
-0.0910694227,
-0.667362988,
-0.1286757737,
0.8855685592,
1.0690006018,
-0.0434053577,
0.459277153,
0.0457582623,
0.8376454711,
-0.8616238832,
0.0322186314,
-0.4317447841,
-0.0992740467,
-0.2918956876,
0.0691119507,
-0.1920715719,
-0.6334049106,
0.246887207,
-0.6061851978,
0.0839865208,
0.3122090697,
0.900788188,
0.2023163885,
-0.55960536,
-0.569211483,
-0.5487626195,
0.5713678002,
-0.4533528984,
0.5524466634,
-0.1460187882,
0.5536027551,
-0.037420515,
-0.6897768378,
-0.2343784869,
-0.3126098216,
0.0302528925,
0.0801507309,
-0.3675777316,
-0.0511735827,
0.3469201326,
0.7209428549,
-0.3768334985,
0.0285816137,
-0.3962030411,
-0.0814032108,
0.5879312754,
0.0689336285,
-0.0476278998,
0.2336330265,
-0.7248905897,
0.130922243,
-0.9154630899,
-0.0962793157,
0.608836174,
-0.1958244443,
0.0708059594,
0.5991258621,
-0.5021165609,
0.4474487901,
0.2138177603,
0.4454130232,
0.4455735087,
-0.2357226461,
-0.2470904142,
0.03461482,
0.4781071842,
0.5930269361,
0.4346425235,
-0.7265853882,
-0.4911154211,
0.094682619,
0.2686343789,
-0.7771697044,
-0.0922394991,
0.2550894022,
-0.5859916806,
0.028444238,
0.1440366954,
-0.5715145469,
-0.1470647156,
-0.4059872627,
0.534840107,
-0.3908497095,
-0.06757579,
-0.0447374322,
-0.1883745492,
0.1586185694,
0.3917942941,
-0.4337857664,
0.8299862742,
0.6563410759,
0.7304223776,
-0.435233742,
-0.3272184432,
-0.4668930173,
0.1770470291,
-0.0860652253,
1.1457980871,
-0.3784339428,
-0.3576873243,
-0.1025458127,
0.1210575327,
0.30493325,
-0.8176786304,
0.837454617,
-0.5365880728,
-0.1160545722,
-0.5501872301,
-0.8276474476,
-0.0221712291,
0.0711634234,
-0.8952337503,
0.8061169386,
0.1857506335,
-0.7654649615,
0.7350757122,
-0.3441033065,
-0.6348305941,
-0.2117183357,
-0.2144932598,
-0.2733016908,
0.3871512413,
-0.1442475617,
-0.1034743041,
-0.808596015,
0.3715797961,
-0.597276926,
-0.6227711439,
0.0284901746,
-0.4693384767,
0.6748579144,
0.2517346144,
-0.3586612642,
-0.0520288423,
-0.8340901732,
0.0247766115,
0.0325024165,
-0.3454058766,
-0.1671406627,
-0.197790727,
0.0156045631,
0.0210819207,
0.3663378954,
-0.5817902088,
0.0147459647,
-0.1949739009,
-0.1173410267,
0.6396229267,
-0.1146549582,
0.6866113544,
-0.3951902092,
0.2115972787,
0.1730587482,
0.1169289351,
0.044431258,
-0.4206318259,
-0.80186975,
0.1861321032,
0.3538386226,
0.2248920798,
-0.4619712532,
0.2451773435,
-0.5596781969,
-0.6080357432,
-0.3559056818,
0.0507253744,
0.5042100549,
0.4483174384,
0.3733588457,
-0.9354975224,
-0.2717721462,
-1.0580435991,
-0.3929525018,
-0.1997114122,
-0.3236916661,
0.5214794874,
0.6992888451,
0.2702579796,
0.728172183,
-0.054743886,
-0.1185071543,
0.262791127,
-0.0948651209,
0.0793195069,
0.2937146425,
0.5098569989,
-0.7319473624,
-0.2872265577,
-0.1566048115,
-0.8432724476,
-0.0511183105,
0.106963031,
-0.0662419125,
0.0291278493,
0.1706913412,
-0.5630280972,
0.1383440644,
0.0825729594,
-0.3733162284,
0.5051924586,
-0.1806285232,
0.2282632589,
-0.4563939273,
0.3151138425,
0.1679047495,
0.0397390798,
-0.1355242878,
0.2251913697,
-0.0871494859,
0.1322872192,
-0.3003025651,
0.4289495349,
-0.7955708504,
-0.6227864623,
0.0689484179,
0.3688676953,
0.0897068158,
0.2397659421,
-0.1815175712,
0.5877386332,
0.540088892,
-0.6659535766,
0.5947723985,
0.0123861684,
-0.3311570585,
1.1748182774,
-0.9083370566,
0.0430672243,
-0.1437940896,
0.2007725686,
-0.383150965,
0.017893903,
0.2073938996,
-0.3275973499,
0.4818538129,
-0.0431158468,
-0.3930535913,
-0.0510481633,
-0.3920579553,
0.3568266332,
0.2904618382,
-0.5512447357,
0.2943999469,
0.6096608639,
0.1987288445,
-0.4474918544,
-0.4665075243,
0.2569007874,
-0.1821449697,
-0.6693632603,
0.3174270391,
-0.0666220784,
-0.308929652,
0.3881516159,
-0.4177267849,
-0.322640866,
0.1252501011,
0.3145907521,
0.0026991798,
-0.4302800298,
0.2414363027,
0.0351228043,
-0.334918797,
0.2883487642,
-0.3702128232,
-0.0483908542,
-0.3758195341,
-0.9677217603,
-0.0867281407,
0.4063037038,
0.5005840063,
-0.2292562276,
0.5105608702,
0.3847663403,
-0.6272550821,
0.244579792,
-0.5706427693,
0.0472463109,
-0.2982924581,
0.2386650592,
-0.4347169399,
-0.6179571152,
0.5487973094,
-0.2675060928,
0.1200611889,
0.5639041066,
0.2182839364,
0.0714728832,
0.5550951362,
0.4682305753,
0.0702745318,
0.0126613285,
0.1076545566,
0.3122876287,
-0.8244026899,
-0.3846081495,
-0.732714951,
-0.4271666706,
-0.6472306252,
-0.1501142979,
0.0231809095,
0.4333673716,
-0.2564570904,
0.4027905166,
-0.2320212871,
0.3153834045,
0.5274167061,
-0.0731807724,
0.5135858655,
-0.0083990013,
-0.1390796751,
0.1677690744,
-0.4158858061,
-0.8218714595,
1.1334245205,
0.3334254622,
0.909196794,
0.2413113713,
0.6849945188,
0.2127364725,
0.6209713817,
-0.5899627209,
0.3337073922,
0.1172108576,
-0.7882131338,
-0.3636465669,
-0.3476519287,
-0.6427128911,
0.0164668988,
-0.2846928537,
-0.7167542577,
0.4828803539,
0.157665208,
0.0904498547,
0.3870505393,
-0.6004508734,
0.8836269975,
-0.0874965936,
-0.6931220293,
-0.0800780654,
-0.5476372242,
0.0853449702,
-0.0544256531,
0.0286908988,
-0.1646210551,
-0.2053596377,
0.4823257327,
-0.3117750287,
0.1320956647,
-0.0775755718,
-0.1444562376,
0.5461484194,
-0.1131482273,
0.4665951133,
0.3667981029,
-0.2716601193,
0.3012239933,
-0.1027989984,
-0.5595598221,
-0.5524742603,
1.0016925335,
-0.3507598639,
-0.3915080726,
-0.2096312344,
0.1608464867,
-0.1955653131,
0.2204788476,
0.2154065669,
0.435082674,
-0.6000558138,
0.3377670348,
0.8076103926,
0.0530986786,
0.1834906489,
0.5027130246,
0.1092165262,
-0.2007568628,
0.6969154477,
0.0147735691,
0.2312127799,
0.2644037306,
-0.5820042491,
-0.3954775035,
-0.5651094317,
-0.7966581583,
-0.0872248486,
-0.8697183132,
-0.2999057472,
-0.4501809478,
0.1370294988,
-0.2300176769,
-0.0076224306,
-0.5099474192,
-0.4144762754,
-0.0144960936,
-0.0499041341,
-0.0769822448,
0.6898705959,
-0.0592262857,
-0.0795935839,
-0.5428943634,
0.2142392546,
0.0819653869,
1.1082689762,
0.2765761316,
-0.151734814,
-0.4867779613,
-0.1064316779,
-0.3308741748,
-1.0429331064,
-0.4941898882,
0.1547632217,
0.8272123933,
0.4302641153,
0.139577508,
0.5239244103,
-0.577262044,
0.3877079189,
0.0648378953,
-0.8486659527,
0.3241519928,
0.2090623081,
-0.1061931998,
0.7843443155,
0.364944458,
-0.1881643236,
-0.2872075438,
-0.6404759288,
-0.9446325898,
0.2069656104,
0.382337451,
-0.1198958606,
-0.3298951089,
0.3870362639,
0.002738816,
0.196994096,
-0.596701324,
-0.6922128797,
0.099808678,
0.1548684388,
0.2037692517,
-0.31142506,
-0.0138862301,
0.287787348,
0.7777841091,
0.0663575158,
0.1443597823,
0.4163150191,
-0.50246346,
-0.3063542843,
0.4083260298,
0.0579151623,
0.9376109242,
-0.2673914731,
0.0267258175,
0.5341541767,
-0.2253738791,
0.1656924486,
0.173778072,
-0.2088623345,
0.3788937628,
0.2667151093,
0.6258994937,
0.6062991023,
-0.4769934416,
0.5755456686,
-0.054535903,
0.1287565827,
-0.369780153,
-0.162310645,
0.1893831789,
0.2203806639,
0.3615623116,
0.0326583982,
0.6578167677,
-0.4397501647,
0.2734970748,
0.5779943466,
-0.6799731255,
-0.183791548,
0.8100427389,
0.424551636,
-0.031904418,
0.3781986833,
-0.5108203292,
0.0063817576,
0.5978032947,
0.3825575411,
0.8738169074,
0.119262889,
-0.1266860664,
0.2884663641,
0.5352221727,
0.0745491832,
0.0183937829,
-0.237220034,
-0.3418842852,
-0.2604428828,
-0.6749161482,
-0.4884677827,
-0.269084543,
-0.9667267799,
0.5271327496,
-0.1003547087,
-0.2063686103,
-0.0057798889,
0.1178311259,
-0.8169261217,
0.3635116816,
-0.0318537168,
1.2941304445,
-0.7721236348,
0.3072628379,
1.0970752239,
-0.7062526345,
-0.1729521304,
-0.3376900554,
-0.250093013,
-0.2941475213,
0.2488405108,
-0.0045839096,
-0.0793686137,
-0.2313539684,
-0.0585583188,
-0.8178142905,
1.1310787201,
0.4322660267,
-0.5653259754,
-0.2734108269,
-0.0073954994,
0.4952450991,
-0.4079760611,
0.6919063926,
0.4210189581,
0.3629131019,
0.0009536068,
-1.1130070686,
0.3409787416,
-0.3420044184,
-0.1313243657,
0.3584341705,
-0.5170151591,
0.6562139392,
-0.2796084881,
-0.510406971,
0.0150585016,
0.6815721989,
0.0656278953,
0.82090801,
0.4585615098,
0.8302083611,
0.5707956553,
-0.1437304169,
0.9559555054,
-0.437934339,
0.5362440944,
1.3720686436,
-0.4191524386,
0.7021754384,
0.5139722824,
-0.5100365281,
0.1726687998,
0.5391406417,
-0.1704785228,
0.1938775778,
0.5600375533,
-0.2079581022,
-0.0290977582,
-0.2180430144,
-0.6110260487,
-0.0466684438,
0.0339467339,
-0.3215592802,
-0.6143615246,
-0.634675622,
-0.3258045614,
-0.1084289402,
-0.108385548,
0.6482304335,
0.1819798797,
-0.3883783221,
0.176492691,
-0.1854102463,
0.4856066406,
-0.0632008612,
-0.182684049,
-0.2731280625,
-0.1112840772,
-0.3005825579,
-0.8568060398,
0.3151215315,
0.0627581701,
-0.2263480425,
0.0980302617,
0.7582464218,
0.0615150779,
-0.080524005,
0.4525928795,
0.6946225762,
0.5362996459,
-0.1049954817,
-0.3168636858,
-0.1343591064,
-0.2364317626,
-0.2727538347,
0.2961790264,
0.7062767744,
-0.2090020627,
0.5861496925,
0.5309679508,
-0.0346905328,
-0.0797081366,
0.2929588556,
0.8111568689,
-0.6195132136,
-0.1561740339,
-0.5955101252,
0.2964205742,
-0.3205615282,
-0.4018344581,
0.6120091081,
1.1299513578,
1.1265889406,
0.2976894975,
0.4306754768,
0.0148915043,
0.2774951458,
-0.2840172946,
0.5249235034,
-0.546510458,
0.4098163247,
-0.347186774,
-1.4708112478,
0.1405966729,
0.1654301733,
0.1668520421,
0.2531381547,
0.6636086106,
0.2631003559,
-0.153787896,
0.1243237182,
0.3171797097,
-0.0225559231,
0.0430910923,
0.6570910811,
0.807600379,
-0.5694143176,
0.6038510203,
-0.169634074,
-0.1809716821,
-0.2542322576,
-0.9449375272,
-0.4668360353,
-0.3434368968,
-0.4461560547,
-0.267362833,
0.4363878667,
0.4422391951,
0.2909136713,
-0.8280416727,
-0.0325900726,
-0.0096078077,
0.3671352565,
0.1758319288,
-0.1448771954,
0.2177698314,
-0.1766077578,
-0.6971928477,
-0.1811444014,
0.5126107335,
0.0931123644,
-0.1669307053,
-0.0872860178,
0.1672836691,
-0.2226690799,
0.3134026825,
0.2126732171,
-0.5534729958,
-0.2427110672,
-0.0617300235,
-0.1484881192,
0.1005066261,
0.6434314847,
-0.8193744421,
0.1493994743,
0.3315525651,
0.6179823279,
0.3374323845,
-0.1510118693,
0.4701877236,
-0.2609002888,
-0.3409738243,
0.1019208878,
0.6516086459,
0.4391546249,
-0.1812323928,
0.7058087587,
0.0466474369,
-0.447656095,
-0.7413181663,
0.1441966295,
-0.6493319869,
0.0453171395,
0.7179328203,
-0.365411222,
-0.1469266713,
-0.0629883334,
0.201579079,
0.4242993295,
-0.3402057886,
0.5249603391,
0.7369877696,
-0.1708537787,
0.4397196472,
-0.5836874247,
0.1801818013,
0.3093525171,
-0.8166556954,
-0.1632874757,
0.7170358896,
0.3135222793,
0.1941347122,
0.4705486596,
-0.2559439242,
0.4871988595,
0.1265739501,
-0.0716248304,
0.1853949577,
-0.2860916853,
-0.3196214736,
-0.0522837155,
0.2784428,
-0.0123281041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14936v1 | Trade-Offs Between Fairness and Privacy in Language Modeling | 2023-05-24T09:18:28 | 2023-05-24T09:18:28 | Cleo Matzken, Steffen Eger, Ivan Habernal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Protecting privacy in contemporary NLP models is gaining in importance. So
does the need to mitigate social biases of such models. But can we have both at
the same time? Existing research suggests that privacy preservation comes at
the price of worsening biases in classification tasks. In this paper, we
explore the extent to which this tradeoff really holds when we incorporate both
privacy preservation and de-biasing techniques into training text generation
models. How does improving the model along one dimension affect the other
dimension as well as the utility of the model? We conduct an extensive set of
experiments that include bias detection, privacy attacks, language modeling,
and performance on downstream tasks. | [
-0.3625908494,
-0.6315851808,
0.3611401618,
-0.0405348316,
0.0303254742,
-0.2352163047,
-0.1698285341,
-0.579493165,
-0.1333649457,
0.8425269127,
-0.3832530081,
-0.0531472638,
-0.7580251098,
-0.2292059511,
-0.3393488228,
1.2842903137,
0.4584400356,
0.1664636731,
-0.3893442154,
-0.1165489554,
-0.3963938951,
-0.9733765721,
-0.9710373282,
-0.3117207289,
0.2540322244,
-0.0222926363,
0.9791947603,
0.6696695685,
0.4425686896,
0.3061077595,
-0.4076500237,
-0.2661945522,
-0.4361235797,
0.3107159138,
-0.3636059761,
-0.4050705135,
-0.3742460907,
0.2837947905,
0.6461094618,
0.8549402356,
0.0620734468,
0.1622010916,
0.1697863191,
0.8297597766,
-0.8533759713,
-0.0802972093,
-0.7464880943,
0.2011924535,
-0.1737665981,
-0.1568977237,
-0.4563480616,
-0.5705164075,
0.3016244173,
0.0133033218,
0.4984913766,
-0.108034499,
0.7628074288,
0.3096200526,
-0.2886252701,
0.0255908929,
-0.7240806222,
1.0648634434,
-0.7927662134,
0.3373701572,
0.734596014,
0.0798313096,
0.1358754337,
-0.5536141992,
-0.4572300315,
-0.0670915246,
-0.2026403695,
-0.1357609481,
-0.1516875774,
0.1212697998,
0.5211777091,
0.4304593205,
-0.2527556717,
0.3397014439,
-0.4484961629,
-0.1704121232,
0.7991870046,
-0.0234607253,
0.3744065166,
-0.3348741531,
-0.2293674052,
-0.2392155379,
-0.6791085005,
0.2142582536,
0.6911558509,
0.334232688,
0.1308644414,
0.2856736481,
-0.0108123915,
0.5673401952,
-0.0470724963,
0.0034609837,
0.1297908127,
-0.1114702076,
-0.2058483064,
0.0590504818,
0.6596058011,
0.6005997062,
0.2558378875,
-0.2380875349,
-0.0481829792,
0.1746485233,
0.344881773,
-0.6697944403,
-0.0400032662,
0.1407288164,
-0.8735964298,
-0.686316967,
-0.0969090015,
-0.9215767384,
-0.4809842706,
-0.2428437918,
0.1962661445,
0.0629291236,
-0.3181782067,
0.30013901,
-0.2685452402,
-0.001018467,
-0.0783943832,
-1.277330637,
0.515381813,
0.7118620276,
0.6338179111,
0.0313752629,
-0.165231213,
-0.5976172686,
0.1693963706,
-0.1014268175,
0.4024224877,
-0.5707167387,
-0.5299656391,
0.0851021484,
-0.1540346742,
-0.0083418731,
-0.4548508525,
0.5137112737,
-0.3832432032,
0.6670906544,
-0.428293258,
-0.4986236691,
-0.0262524635,
0.0962279439,
-0.7284708619,
0.7868062258,
-0.1466815174,
-1.2608439922,
0.4912910461,
-0.5511345267,
-0.4646018147,
-0.1293479353,
-0.1103076786,
-0.7639175057,
0.3494168222,
-0.0244884938,
0.5135393143,
-0.1389290243,
0.3410591781,
-0.3342788517,
-0.1521002948,
0.5127744079,
-0.5349083543,
1.0878733397,
0.3605307043,
-0.5114663839,
-0.2967855632,
-0.7176424861,
-0.0665371716,
0.0812945962,
-0.3306947052,
-0.6108236909,
0.1794593036,
-0.079806067,
0.394985199,
0.1358125061,
-0.5654427409,
-0.3811558783,
-0.6843653917,
0.4522856176,
0.8922460079,
-0.0996757224,
1.1028559208,
-0.3916295767,
0.6008957028,
-0.0636564195,
0.4446230829,
0.2673109472,
-0.6248403788,
-0.6476829052,
-0.0287166592,
0.5397017002,
0.5104702115,
-0.3229633868,
0.4004764259,
-0.0663012266,
-0.1454600692,
-0.4882990122,
-0.1233892739,
0.4858128726,
0.2659158707,
0.0183882713,
-0.4846635461,
-0.2370573133,
-0.9781348109,
-0.7435839176,
0.160502404,
-0.0351930372,
0.2279495895,
0.1649386287,
0.0435762852,
1.0660133362,
-0.3608460426,
-0.1122261211,
-0.1650705189,
-0.3057841063,
-0.3077575564,
0.827449441,
0.8691575527,
-1.07323277,
-0.2606574893,
-0.3116444647,
-0.5742492676,
-0.2000472844,
-0.0666729957,
-0.1879024357,
0.2900107801,
0.3813888729,
-0.4755427241,
0.7076715231,
0.6961364746,
-0.402974695,
0.0053879833,
-0.1107773706,
0.0930337384,
-1.0013405085,
-0.0756220669,
-0.1472218335,
-0.3676027358,
-0.9567227364,
0.1498559862,
-0.1194004267,
-0.3223804533,
-0.5080845952,
0.7607927918,
-0.3240008354,
-0.102132611,
-0.4663848877,
-0.0248443764,
0.3671110272,
0.1976030469,
0.1556918025,
0.369109571,
0.5498108268,
-0.6482304335,
-0.2993284166,
0.1537139863,
-0.102226764,
0.3143159151,
-0.5581067204,
0.354960382,
-0.2515887916,
-0.0566029474,
-0.5236411691,
0.0455954149,
0.1553713679,
-0.5752963424,
0.4426008761,
-0.1470954269,
-0.4272145331,
-0.0617613457,
-0.6362640858,
0.2214103639,
0.5548866987,
-0.6414170265,
0.570432663,
0.7250676751,
-0.3672299087,
-0.8369218111,
-0.9817052484,
-0.0521334074,
-0.3731339574,
-0.6457515359,
0.3311203122,
0.1094923168,
-0.5356029868,
0.0102274306,
0.0031449224,
0.0239454582,
0.3230362535,
0.3469817638,
0.0721422136,
0.4173277617,
0.1040623337,
0.4356781542,
-0.2698367834,
0.1836422533,
-0.2183072567,
0.550756216,
0.1902187616,
0.0608475097,
-0.2372992784,
0.6849955916,
-0.0421506017,
-0.4140639007,
1.1731132269,
0.1688380837,
-0.4891733527,
-0.282019943,
-0.51810956,
-0.2817073464,
-0.5322298408,
0.2058571577,
-0.0137562985,
-0.8801652193,
0.4181239903,
0.1867846847,
0.2450926304,
0.0852236301,
0.3961515129,
0.2492868602,
1.1234570742,
0.9470651746,
-0.0631626472,
0.6679031253,
-0.0858615562,
0.669048965,
-0.5730230808,
-0.0499967299,
-0.8311702013,
-0.0428826138,
-0.9338800907,
0.0040103081,
-0.0252679121,
0.0045501795,
-0.0396444909,
0.2259762138,
-0.8776138425,
0.7014353871,
0.7775275707,
0.1222463101,
0.2505654395,
0.1477566063,
0.4497520626,
-0.2326622605,
-0.6997042298,
-0.8168410063,
1.0806611776,
0.546656251,
0.4705827236,
0.0320540741,
0.9059420228,
0.1176352799,
0.3089199364,
-0.257013917,
0.5960071683,
-0.5026721954,
-0.9920333624,
-0.2989794612,
-0.6774204373,
-0.8203763366,
0.3214994371,
-0.2772920728,
-0.8667353392,
0.3937057257,
0.389867872,
-0.1886110008,
0.4335257113,
-0.7855929136,
0.9839625955,
-0.0247014426,
-0.5790629983,
-0.0591795556,
-0.7582886219,
0.3596541584,
0.0076410077,
0.373736769,
0.035055384,
0.3988389671,
0.8259974122,
-0.2059327811,
0.675368309,
-0.3738751709,
-0.0609601997,
-0.12159729,
0.2058269829,
0.2450739145,
0.0937517136,
-0.3712033331,
0.2359799445,
-0.0442183949,
-0.428044945,
-0.4820500314,
0.7346581221,
-0.5336824656,
-0.5580480099,
-0.4194753468,
-0.6175739765,
-0.1127958596,
0.068436712,
0.5045945048,
0.238206163,
-0.0603811592,
0.0055229338,
0.7139557004,
-0.8033022881,
0.5004903674,
0.0690555498,
-0.1749203652,
-0.0743855834,
0.7928416729,
0.089436546,
0.6881991625,
0.1922441721,
0.4708372056,
-0.3625294268,
-0.4284575582,
-0.0362819582,
0.0248541553,
-0.8709509969,
-0.1237593889,
-0.9715975523,
-0.2105604261,
-0.6612874269,
-0.328784883,
-0.1832562089,
-0.8336611986,
-0.2033766955,
-0.384475857,
0.2235726416,
0.5292415023,
-0.4318050742,
0.2992280424,
-0.604442656,
0.2041587532,
0.3338509798,
0.2014493346,
0.0686338246,
-0.4434840679,
0.0446329825,
0.0398568623,
-0.3811461627,
-0.5998312831,
0.4709326327,
-0.0561422184,
0.3579674959,
0.1788975447,
0.0308273584,
-0.1013221741,
-0.5945507884,
0.9318805933,
0.2211360633,
-1.1534651518,
0.5478975177,
-0.2542929351,
0.1046840101,
0.5172707438,
0.1537038684,
-0.3808456063,
-0.6592149734,
-0.8718104959,
-0.791138649,
0.7236530781,
0.3271303177,
0.5937428474,
0.0013589949,
0.3231810927,
0.2875026166,
0.4333665669,
-1.1766465902,
-0.2019446045,
-0.3447185457,
-0.1092543229,
0.0879582614,
-0.3253319561,
-0.0517706871,
-0.1246547401,
0.5667001605,
0.3290399611,
0.1115415245,
-0.2796974182,
0.1395332664,
0.246882081,
0.4276462197,
0.38533023,
0.4337201715,
-0.0466633923,
0.0429575481,
-0.0340297781,
-0.3922302723,
0.0666075051,
0.2795499563,
-0.7468608618,
0.1307191253,
-0.1279271543,
0.8029314876,
-0.0428016558,
-0.3166911304,
0.6559768915,
-0.0718778074,
-0.3205219209,
0.0231301859,
0.222862184,
0.0632371306,
0.0073260795,
-0.0989796892,
0.2804387212,
0.4928141534,
-0.4567361176,
-0.0085152844,
0.5624478459,
-0.0217762254,
0.0001043379,
1.0457053185,
0.215535596,
-0.661136508,
0.2908791304,
-0.0945843607,
-0.6399859786,
0.5502867699,
0.2940632403,
0.9410858154,
-0.3569054902,
0.268832624,
0.0573128946,
0.1705237925,
-0.1306180805,
0.0833691508,
-0.1581026167,
-0.6560015678,
-0.1881628931,
-0.6385651231,
-0.3708922565,
0.0060285819,
-0.8200517297,
-0.0594244264,
-0.4960261285,
-0.4749075472,
0.1944160163,
-0.0724462569,
-0.7343568206,
0.2750501633,
0.1364786029,
0.3809714913,
-0.8089440465,
0.6133484244,
0.1988458782,
-0.2155032605,
-0.4841037989,
0.0152248256,
-0.1234705448,
-0.2215705961,
0.7144076228,
0.249813661,
-0.1295810938,
-0.3258401155,
-0.5918543935,
-0.5916294456,
0.5302903652,
0.6008120775,
-0.6036536098,
-0.0155880256,
0.3857371211,
0.5828985572,
0.038739685,
-0.3532247245,
0.5736296177,
0.1525473893,
-0.6443834305,
-0.8411167264,
0.0070539191,
-0.0475017242,
0.322532177,
0.2832485735,
-0.4723463655,
0.8270621896,
0.0718990713,
-0.3113732934,
-0.1138092726,
0.1535475254,
0.1115207151,
0.3741509914,
0.4889787734,
0.4932033718,
0.5385012627,
0.0092205303,
1.4332171679,
-0.1105252877,
0.3684059083,
1.0665587187,
-0.4398046434,
0.4550351799,
0.4306005836,
-0.0563891158,
0.0884437561,
0.4349634051,
0.2205473185,
0.7976709604,
0.3805927038,
-0.3659546077,
0.0699990764,
-0.1892768145,
-0.4401170909,
0.2671619654,
-0.0610520095,
-0.5530725718,
0.0277550779,
0.1886637062,
0.3106280267,
0.5696797371,
-0.1209183112,
0.772521615,
0.2046936303,
-0.6577428579,
-0.0307868272,
0.145881325,
0.7435541153,
-0.3669367731,
0.1510535181,
-0.2782328427,
0.3952555656,
-0.1272848099,
-0.4672936797,
0.4174194038,
0.0065032318,
-0.4699575901,
-0.5975780487,
0.8756837249,
-0.5646355152,
-0.3792442977,
0.4996699393,
0.3378155231,
-0.0295905769,
0.1460679471,
-0.6926524639,
0.0031058837,
-0.053092625,
-0.3474329412,
0.6326358914,
0.1949698329,
0.1985182762,
0.4362700284,
0.6240840554,
0.2142766714,
0.3126166463,
0.4841606915,
0.7151522636,
-0.5035364628,
-0.7055515647,
-1.0371392965,
0.4660197794,
-0.462390691,
-0.1750284284,
0.8542599678,
0.4555382431,
1.031264782,
-0.0522416197,
0.9603323936,
0.136552006,
0.8177346587,
-0.6440491676,
0.9055531025,
-0.3288724124,
0.3255431652,
-0.5343829989,
-0.968680799,
-0.3785896301,
0.6668362617,
-0.4126477838,
0.3111061752,
0.5161466599,
0.7405811548,
0.1111079082,
0.2493153363,
0.2250108868,
-0.287327081,
0.4210300148,
0.3520703912,
0.8598284721,
-0.5744291544,
0.1781555712,
-0.547791779,
-0.1257115006,
0.3753407896,
-0.873998642,
-1.1157001257,
-0.3803209364,
-0.3630701005,
-0.4139289856,
0.1951095611,
0.3875977993,
0.7899668217,
-0.5755877495,
-0.0549185425,
-0.094237484,
0.1287811548,
-0.0227024499,
-0.2523353696,
0.3553002179,
-0.2695847154,
-0.7640103102,
-0.1396440417,
0.1849891394,
0.2031146586,
-0.3284753859,
0.0386510305,
0.0425352491,
0.2258044779,
0.5650072694,
0.0407590754,
-0.3078624904,
-0.2757686079,
-0.0204234552,
-0.0006535609,
-0.1965005547,
1.0548200607,
-0.5960673094,
0.3344294429,
0.4371176362,
0.7612853646,
0.4428264201,
-0.0897465795,
0.7887325287,
-0.9213810563,
0.4284340739,
0.2919126451,
0.2357003689,
0.6575300694,
-0.6553815603,
0.5168635845,
-0.0770704448,
-0.8902127147,
-1.1172873974,
0.3130348325,
-0.5599318743,
-0.4929761589,
0.9294607043,
0.0532738492,
-0.0774182752,
-0.1407335103,
-0.1359454691,
0.0529571958,
-0.1517651677,
1.0175615549,
0.6994898319,
0.3019866645,
-0.1048095971,
-0.6849623322,
0.9706799388,
0.5919423103,
-0.8293706179,
0.2763702571,
0.3144105375,
0.1587407291,
0.1236554533,
0.8309490681,
-0.2601421475,
0.3317324519,
-0.1049944833,
-0.1006253287,
0.2112662196,
-0.2376814336,
-0.5961045623,
-0.0432291999,
-0.0314102322,
-0.2849634588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14935v1 | Modeling Appropriate Language in Argumentation | 2023-05-24T09:17:05 | 2023-05-24T09:17:05 | Timon Ziegenbein, Shahbaz Syed, Felix Lange, Martin Potthast, Henning Wachsmuth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online discussion moderators must make ad-hoc decisions about whether the
contributions of discussion participants are appropriate or should be removed
to maintain civility. Existing research on offensive language and the resulting
tools cover only one aspect among many involved in such decisions. The question
of what is considered appropriate in a controversial discussion has not yet
been systematically addressed. In this paper, we operationalize appropriate
language in argumentation for the first time. In particular, we model
appropriateness through the absence of flaws, grounded in research on argument
quality assessment, especially in aspects from rhetoric. From these, we derive
a new taxonomy of 14 dimensions that determine inappropriate language in online
discussions. Building on three argument quality corpora, we then create a
corpus of 2191 arguments annotated for the 14 dimensions. Empirical analyses
support that the taxonomy covers the concept of appropriateness
comprehensively, showing several plausible correlations with argument quality
dimensions. Moreover, results of baseline approaches to assessing
appropriateness suggest that all dimensions can be modeled computationally on
the corpus. | [
-0.6632379293,
-1.2842236757,
0.4151794314,
0.3645889461,
-0.4027953446,
-0.1329874843,
-0.2817907631,
-0.4690627754,
-0.0505562909,
0.1596231461,
-0.0589585342,
-0.1222630069,
-0.5231041908,
0.2150401324,
-0.4476638436,
0.9889560938,
-0.0247445181,
0.1451849639,
-0.3302517831,
-0.6791294813,
-0.381469667,
-0.4294933677,
-0.5273097157,
-0.0272745695,
0.5271726847,
0.3746517301,
0.7344709039,
0.9153695703,
0.4391852319,
0.5210333467,
-0.256308198,
0.0971729234,
-0.5319311619,
0.1474390179,
-0.5789788365,
0.0213494599,
-0.6490325332,
0.091127567,
0.5495932102,
0.5529036522,
-0.1347345561,
0.0601246916,
-0.207413137,
0.2313465029,
-0.4467298985,
-0.2414535284,
-0.8008747101,
-0.203134656,
-0.056004975,
-0.2509857714,
-0.1738583297,
-0.6175909638,
0.2730847299,
-0.5505869389,
-0.0034789385,
-0.2226454616,
0.9107254744,
-0.0834461525,
-0.2270772159,
-0.9285545349,
-0.7352616191,
0.5696552396,
-0.8307245374,
0.1407392919,
0.3738228381,
0.1361632347,
0.0948840678,
-0.9884355664,
-0.5752873421,
-0.0270856302,
-0.0021722498,
-0.0538333319,
-0.631382525,
0.0640660077,
0.178843081,
0.2813794613,
-0.3474501967,
0.3373355269,
-0.5077067614,
-0.0611560121,
0.5373601913,
0.1128596365,
0.2230233699,
-0.393086046,
-0.3591566384,
0.2937675118,
-0.1460301727,
0.0040083202,
0.8108184934,
0.46117872,
0.0021966714,
0.429074198,
0.2172876298,
0.7006490827,
0.2593508661,
0.1044313908,
-0.3913529813,
-0.3249116242,
-0.1236855313,
-0.1420783699,
0.6583808064,
0.5340178013,
0.1758372635,
0.2661934495,
0.1305318326,
0.3520178497,
0.8888581395,
-0.6576891541,
-0.268458128,
0.4767731726,
-0.6073476672,
-0.420539856,
-0.0579816774,
-0.9661474228,
-0.5038301945,
-0.1581925601,
0.2879239023,
-0.3143569529,
-0.3698086739,
-0.0509996563,
-0.1298118085,
-0.0679467767,
0.1395307779,
-0.5729976296,
0.5537540317,
0.6164452434,
0.4956037104,
-0.0378631614,
-0.0672867745,
-0.2884211838,
-0.221853137,
-0.5779704452,
0.8773223758,
-0.7858053446,
-0.2325975448,
0.1977141649,
-0.2153045833,
0.0649734363,
-0.4635057449,
1.3310596943,
-0.5624201894,
0.5215973854,
-0.2178464085,
-0.7740001082,
-0.4486955404,
0.2860150039,
-0.5330165029,
0.5143516064,
0.0939983651,
-0.8757732511,
0.4305876493,
-1.034486413,
-0.2942367494,
0.3741183579,
-0.1334073246,
-0.6106055975,
-0.0126552191,
0.0042220769,
0.3558553457,
0.0407921299,
0.5453894734,
-0.3085605204,
0.0541302636,
0.4201590121,
-0.2329725623,
0.8390139937,
0.5287703276,
-0.356402725,
0.2946452498,
-0.9303575754,
0.265112251,
0.0410699993,
-0.3441282809,
-0.4399640858,
0.3801226914,
-0.0280202627,
0.2229959965,
-0.0221712682,
-0.4962944388,
-0.3408889771,
-0.7499414682,
0.8449615836,
0.7005123496,
-0.1273210049,
0.4669711292,
-0.1514663249,
0.5165912509,
-0.2900410593,
0.0673752576,
0.2105717957,
-0.3507199883,
-0.5861725807,
-0.2732428312,
0.1628248245,
0.4338710904,
-0.2770331204,
0.2778313458,
-0.0036283853,
-0.5582096577,
-0.2964495718,
-0.3196562529,
0.2435757965,
0.0984015986,
0.1144656166,
-0.1281648278,
-0.7727434039,
-0.9187811017,
-0.3443872631,
-0.7190135717,
0.2244066745,
0.4660133123,
0.0164491087,
0.1154470295,
1.0440814495,
-0.0834535882,
0.1292484403,
-0.1909811348,
0.5727779865,
-0.4010067582,
0.396409899,
0.7687504292,
-0.5552891493,
-0.252766788,
-0.0034142784,
-0.7597677112,
-0.4233335853,
-0.1566804498,
-0.2403487265,
0.2130485028,
0.1958171725,
-0.3897179663,
0.2166190445,
0.6220222712,
-0.1698846668,
0.1666180938,
-0.1800406873,
0.1038258001,
-1.0637480021,
0.1397229433,
0.1308857054,
-0.1954568774,
-0.8803376555,
0.4334068894,
-0.1319098175,
-0.2311834246,
-0.3809344172,
0.4965912104,
-0.0380560346,
0.4349687994,
-0.4653804004,
0.4584911466,
0.1756422818,
-0.0930012017,
0.126751706,
0.3428937793,
0.3221587539,
-0.6414915919,
0.3441472054,
0.1143623441,
-0.3599592447,
1.0276055336,
-0.6341593862,
0.2312681079,
-0.1060105339,
-0.0402506962,
-0.8976179957,
-0.211008057,
0.2220229954,
-0.4969499409,
0.0250552353,
-0.0453061908,
0.1173650175,
-0.2964545786,
-0.2254014164,
0.5388259292,
-0.1073177904,
-0.3811501861,
0.6239190698,
0.8748128414,
-0.2542123497,
-0.4238442481,
-0.1107017845,
0.0851674229,
-0.6966935992,
-0.5736959577,
0.2271255553,
-0.217715621,
-0.6813158393,
-0.1764688343,
0.3635310233,
-0.4369319975,
0.0844166502,
0.1162150204,
-0.0628013238,
-0.1990486979,
0.0730106011,
-0.2934199572,
0.2528288066,
0.3099225163,
0.1396059543,
0.4520890415,
-0.3256593645,
-0.0622453839,
-0.0709430948,
0.589240849,
0.4360015988,
0.0792923123,
0.3772726655,
0.6485357881,
-0.7021752596,
-0.1146219522,
-0.5780100226,
-0.0813080668,
-0.4813912213,
0.5576335788,
-0.1754814982,
-0.9372538924,
0.6236547828,
0.0342536531,
0.4673399627,
0.5848070979,
0.6427235603,
-0.0599808805,
1.0659514666,
0.4785979986,
0.5493359566,
0.1224738732,
0.2286271751,
0.7866600156,
-0.5142205358,
-0.1535215676,
-0.9870441556,
-0.0180921406,
-0.6827477217,
-0.3667555451,
-0.1806386113,
0.2437452674,
-0.253084749,
0.5086140633,
-0.4499789774,
0.2973329723,
-0.2017449439,
-0.3403756022,
-0.138763532,
0.0302523617,
-0.322086215,
-0.5017675161,
-0.6951510906,
-0.892824769,
0.1800849289,
0.6782047153,
0.5116371512,
0.1332004815,
-0.0708331764,
0.2307976782,
0.3544469774,
-0.873377502,
0.4371903539,
-0.0320029967,
-1.0105875731,
-0.3495011628,
-0.7085351944,
-1.021329999,
0.250852406,
-0.1713589877,
-0.846154511,
0.3066953719,
0.2413885444,
-0.4914628863,
0.5897104144,
-0.526242137,
0.9078066349,
-0.2231566012,
-0.3794716895,
-0.1369913518,
-0.5671906471,
0.3002083302,
-0.0255787242,
0.782772541,
-0.133709833,
0.1829745919,
0.794054389,
-0.1457409412,
0.5470879078,
-0.0377420448,
-0.2626636624,
0.6824154258,
0.428191781,
0.0128044458,
-0.1763174534,
-0.2053018212,
0.2006137371,
0.3286690414,
-0.1601319164,
-0.3442770541,
0.6252540946,
-0.7841252089,
-0.518632412,
-0.2817597985,
-0.3072091043,
-0.1219923347,
-0.0696883872,
0.0994572788,
0.4722677767,
-0.7130510211,
0.0670720935,
0.4112652838,
-0.5912094116,
0.3073884845,
0.4273880422,
-0.2687722743,
-0.4239073098,
1.2551003695,
0.1705114692,
0.2517421544,
-0.0399880782,
0.6987351179,
-0.4937264919,
-0.3999233842,
-0.4557203054,
-0.0466118567,
-1.037209034,
-0.2472769767,
-0.9251081944,
-0.1729909331,
-0.2570933402,
-0.3557024002,
-0.513184309,
-0.5422267914,
-0.3418718576,
-0.1506793648,
0.1478350461,
0.9176840186,
-0.3573842049,
0.1439028084,
-0.5761835575,
-0.0318477862,
0.3087361455,
0.5761169791,
0.0208838806,
-0.8695257902,
0.1181278303,
-0.0524021089,
-0.5428307056,
-0.6957882643,
0.0992943645,
0.2522702217,
0.931573689,
0.8292463422,
0.1487827003,
0.6838578582,
-0.3711025715,
1.0589940548,
0.1242618859,
-1.0861471891,
0.6230516434,
-0.3937862515,
-0.071667172,
0.1201434582,
0.7180917859,
-0.5095604658,
-0.4723029137,
-0.8709492683,
-0.9249624014,
0.5616627336,
0.2510430813,
0.6314635277,
-0.5480895638,
0.1936325133,
0.257032305,
-0.0650667325,
-0.9627532363,
0.1334732026,
-0.3695116937,
0.1512260586,
0.4285718501,
-0.5485619903,
-0.4347885549,
-0.2687628865,
0.4687484801,
-0.1118114069,
0.4062359035,
-0.2587713897,
0.1063951999,
-0.407930851,
0.4132591486,
0.9850549102,
1.2913030386,
0.0251654834,
0.1296124756,
0.3073558211,
-0.2641270757,
-0.0260768496,
-0.185927853,
0.1575755626,
0.0109268548,
0.2004230767,
0.6994167566,
0.073528938,
-0.3856791854,
0.4697286189,
-0.3176068068,
-0.264839381,
0.0279359259,
-0.2890483141,
0.1277561337,
0.0227532145,
-0.1874938458,
0.0938232914,
-0.0345843919,
-0.6881508231,
0.1812866032,
0.3471836746,
-0.4560442865,
-0.1706151664,
0.5755953789,
0.4402166009,
-0.4965011775,
0.3254607618,
-0.0009148392,
-0.5546389222,
0.3204757869,
0.5159407854,
0.5536407828,
-0.2774150074,
0.4371095598,
0.6675326824,
0.3570850492,
0.3849592209,
0.3630418479,
0.4905165136,
-0.8730506301,
-0.1755661815,
-0.7742471099,
-0.3677636385,
0.2952959836,
-0.4890126586,
0.1740888655,
-0.8807281852,
-0.39848423,
0.3278947473,
-0.1567154676,
-0.2362117171,
0.2246873379,
0.1191298291,
0.5142819285,
-0.8667215705,
0.2547758818,
0.7919408679,
-0.3205757439,
-0.5559818149,
-0.3118373752,
0.069494687,
-0.5091634989,
0.0782803744,
-0.2665525079,
-0.1965979338,
-0.404997915,
-0.7769727707,
-0.6001902819,
0.1817887723,
0.5217550993,
0.054388117,
0.435875833,
0.0680045113,
0.7890713215,
-0.3423091769,
0.343958348,
0.2049936205,
0.2940927446,
0.0970912874,
-0.6831400394,
-0.0564274713,
-0.265491128,
0.0961409286,
-0.1325560957,
-0.5106638074,
0.764692843,
0.0230933148,
-0.4499610066,
0.1477913409,
0.6533593535,
-0.0434232429,
0.0303423386,
0.3917440176,
0.3994620144,
0.6887594461,
-0.216992557,
0.9767253995,
-0.2172659785,
0.089459911,
0.8973542452,
-0.1665875018,
0.833057642,
0.1385467201,
-0.1531223059,
0.4290507436,
0.8051461577,
0.2937521636,
0.0304430015,
0.5706143975,
-0.1719510704,
-0.3143894076,
-0.3769775033,
-0.2005069256,
0.7589296699,
0.6552611589,
-0.3060667813,
-0.213033855,
-0.1139263436,
0.2155264914,
0.8410168886,
-0.0949095786,
0.8971384764,
-0.0563514642,
-0.5758875608,
0.4099638164,
0.6721398234,
0.4081000388,
-0.3183833063,
-0.0224152561,
-0.1928998381,
-0.1409797221,
-0.3141951263,
-0.9590660334,
0.5073789358,
0.3332007527,
0.0008711516,
0.0650391579,
0.8053981066,
-0.1585009098,
-0.5236951113,
0.319477886,
0.4885828793,
0.4558311701,
0.5465634465,
-0.6151541471,
0.3870767951,
-0.435346812,
0.1217871606,
0.2294970304,
0.8028577566,
-0.173349902,
0.3502146006,
0.4544370472,
0.1586735696,
0.1903195828,
0.3609261215,
0.8527780771,
-0.1348886937,
-0.3714172542,
-0.8275465369,
0.6005424261,
-0.2452850193,
-0.5812686682,
0.4868661463,
0.4045240283,
0.720493257,
0.3760976791,
0.5354577303,
-0.2558585703,
0.5924153328,
-0.1150047556,
0.637950182,
-0.3401669264,
-0.0396703668,
-0.7228346467,
-0.7996283174,
-0.2339234203,
1.3992532492,
-0.1202278659,
0.2555889785,
0.6973268986,
0.6387689114,
-0.1324891597,
0.6452805996,
0.4035227597,
0.2651825249,
0.3705329597,
-0.1340684891,
1.0942852497,
-0.2519904077,
0.4688692391,
-0.2102348059,
-0.1992415637,
0.0272850376,
-1.3244328499,
-0.7955946922,
-0.5393198133,
-0.5410599709,
-0.3403770626,
0.0038504431,
1.1266121864,
0.5875412822,
-0.7644408941,
-0.4690530896,
0.1413836032,
-0.0562405139,
-0.1333965212,
-0.2225327343,
0.0177244227,
-0.2607702017,
-0.4912237227,
0.2288796008,
0.2000464201,
-0.3809547722,
-0.3484119475,
-0.1278222054,
-0.4941486418,
0.5840232372,
0.985705018,
0.3323435783,
-0.8603094816,
-0.7874597311,
-0.3464238942,
-0.0735107735,
0.2056520581,
0.8957980871,
0.0155577296,
0.8732907176,
0.3304219544,
0.6389836073,
-0.2574807703,
0.3423050046,
0.6831370592,
-0.6619938612,
-0.1005596519,
0.424413234,
0.1591580957,
0.5225618482,
-0.1766540408,
0.1378350258,
0.1024264321,
-0.8342532516,
-0.6793630123,
0.0415860526,
-0.7457587719,
-0.3848973513,
1.0622006655,
-0.4571135342,
0.1729788035,
-0.2608895898,
-0.3958021104,
0.2250034213,
-0.1954665333,
1.2348912954,
1.1801956892,
-0.0432290323,
-0.2909890115,
-0.519969821,
0.5644337535,
0.3437332809,
-0.8360314965,
0.3292143047,
0.6888482571,
0.0350032635,
0.245546326,
0.4833408594,
-0.3577326834,
0.1711519063,
0.102743797,
-0.4214083552,
0.2899315357,
-0.3014001846,
-0.2404906601,
0.4222711623,
0.4875593781,
0.2441354543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14934v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14934v2 | GRACE: Discriminator-Guided Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2023-05-24T09:16:51 | 2023-10-24T01:21:05 | Muhammad Khalifa, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Moontae Lee, Honglak Lee, Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the context of multi-step reasoning, e.g., with chain-of-thought, language
models (LMs) can easily assign a high likelihood to incorrect steps. As a
result, decoding strategies that optimize for solution likelihood often yield
incorrect solutions. To address this issue, we propose Guiding chain-of-thought
ReAsoning with a CorrectnEss Discriminator (GRACE), a stepwise decoding
approach that steers the decoding process towards producing correct reasoning
steps. GRACE employs a discriminator trained with a contrastive loss over
correct and incorrect steps, which is used during decoding to score next-step
candidates based on their correctness. Importantly, GRACE only requires
sampling from the LM, without the need for LM training or fine-tuning. Using
models from FLAN-T5 and LLaMA families, we evaluate GRACE over four math and
two symbolic reasoning tasks, where it exhibits substantial performance gains
compared to greedy decoding, verifiers, and self-consistency in most settings.
When further combined with self-consistency, GRACE outperforms all the
baselines by sizeable margins. Human and LLM evaluations over GSM8K show that
GRACE not only improves the final answer accuracy but also the correctness of
the intermediate reasoning. Our implementation can be accessed at
\url{https://github.com/mukhal/grace}. | [
-0.1192036048,
-0.4728582203,
0.8725308776,
0.340400219,
-0.2375090271,
0.2531219721,
-0.031138476,
-0.2589048445,
0.1004775092,
0.6334178448,
-0.6796223521,
-0.3815563023,
-0.5472425818,
0.3361662626,
-0.1998921484,
1.0429986715,
-0.3741207421,
0.2853733301,
-0.0547296889,
-0.2837159932,
-0.5905910134,
-0.3091948628,
-0.7001991868,
-0.405951649,
0.5448838472,
0.2771178484,
0.7072404623,
0.8117121458,
0.4311736226,
0.1976710856,
-0.1756653488,
0.606862545,
-0.4355131388,
0.0645847246,
-0.4471585155,
-0.7621147633,
-0.6253231168,
-0.0569092594,
0.3488548696,
0.6907603145,
-0.3536128104,
0.0799083337,
0.0745427459,
0.9071132541,
-0.8885578513,
-0.0312689543,
-0.5553456545,
0.0085568596,
-0.1400509179,
-0.3458088934,
-0.5850984454,
-0.5300793052,
-0.3812279701,
-0.7831272483,
0.2114568949,
0.2611402571,
0.7253237367,
0.7387278676,
-0.1707251966,
-0.6705858111,
-0.5576669574,
0.964297533,
-0.2944633961,
0.6370262504,
0.5852364302,
0.1059039235,
-0.3904413283,
-0.388831526,
-0.587944448,
0.0446962155,
0.0921334624,
0.3799076974,
0.044719521,
0.2279677689,
0.6383180022,
0.4531563222,
-0.3807092011,
-0.4069479406,
-0.1902835518,
-0.1455478668,
0.6066310406,
0.0827132016,
-0.0002445861,
0.0705854595,
-0.231129542,
-0.2165825516,
-0.5543656945,
-0.1673738807,
0.2880263627,
0.2809207439,
0.0463773534,
0.2415813655,
-0.0641765445,
0.8158450127,
0.4177332222,
-0.1776267141,
0.1819747686,
-0.216207549,
-0.2294230908,
0.1454804838,
0.5431798697,
0.1511477232,
0.2310397476,
0.1465237588,
-0.3493328094,
0.3346607983,
0.4269691408,
-0.5073570609,
-0.4475267231,
0.1994899958,
-0.4089900553,
-0.0769620165,
-0.1182724535,
-0.5378235579,
-0.2477751523,
-0.3021833301,
0.1396252215,
-0.7191941142,
-0.1543898135,
0.5026962161,
-0.0235134047,
-0.0291551445,
0.5675526857,
-0.6990174651,
0.2966872752,
0.6847078204,
0.7311514616,
0.0749649554,
-0.0486645624,
-1.0563026667,
0.0465698279,
-0.7368587852,
0.3954742849,
-0.5211895704,
-0.2028562874,
-0.1417832077,
-0.1592706442,
-0.1660198867,
-0.3633437753,
1.1807724237,
-0.7573620081,
-0.1773552597,
-0.9622874856,
-0.7414948344,
-0.1231370345,
0.2657930851,
-0.8025497794,
0.820114851,
-0.0105425604,
-0.7874312997,
0.5014383793,
-0.60715276,
-0.3832575679,
0.1820833236,
-0.2081657499,
-0.3252716959,
0.2555657029,
0.2603571713,
0.1256213784,
0.0537088029,
0.1230602041,
-0.2933480442,
-0.6199121475,
0.0188770108,
-0.5411758423,
0.8694497943,
0.4270916879,
-0.1900458783,
-0.2774249911,
-0.8571178913,
0.1256379634,
0.2758140266,
-0.4448421001,
-0.5879297256,
0.141507417,
-0.5890581012,
0.3219236135,
0.1118468642,
-0.6073650718,
0.2433827072,
-0.0936566666,
-0.0595228933,
0.7330684662,
-0.269092828,
0.2624407709,
-0.3355929554,
0.4532751143,
0.1869782507,
0.1282681972,
-0.3590311408,
-0.3616560996,
-1.086777091,
-0.0358317606,
0.2883341312,
0.6263038516,
-0.9780815244,
0.4070759416,
-0.220418632,
0.1553615481,
-0.5898340344,
0.2033821642,
0.7796307802,
0.3384001851,
0.6647667289,
-0.33745417,
-0.3567586839,
-0.3912695944,
-0.3904295266,
-0.3065848649,
0.3235803545,
-0.1359622926,
0.6664941907,
0.047576122,
0.5975450277,
-0.63396734,
-0.0352574475,
-0.1815422922,
0.2322843522,
0.2959372997,
0.5547813773,
-0.0261571016,
-0.7888638973,
-0.127866134,
-0.1708866656,
-0.7986470461,
-0.1015762463,
-0.3813782334,
-0.4209503829,
0.0178127829,
0.1802810133,
-0.4036442339,
0.5218694806,
0.3918530643,
-0.403627485,
0.5888496041,
-0.3871964514,
0.1966133118,
-0.8725126982,
-0.2154845148,
0.1518373638,
-0.3232724965,
-0.6348682642,
0.1842508614,
0.2781899571,
0.4535003901,
0.1246549189,
0.0902507901,
-0.4533596039,
0.0029990352,
-0.2504464984,
-0.0003921448,
0.2275509536,
0.4791509807,
0.1933175325,
0.9630618095,
0.17634359,
-0.7927438021,
0.2281208336,
0.4780703485,
-0.0163029525,
1.1008913517,
-0.3523668051,
0.3644097447,
-0.1735584289,
0.5150442123,
-0.7221417427,
-0.0568550006,
0.3537270129,
-0.1497116089,
0.2278960943,
-0.1162215173,
-0.5451512337,
-0.771972239,
-0.1372050047,
0.5721742511,
0.2546129227,
-0.9707477093,
0.5804011822,
-0.110858731,
0.383859694,
-0.7727466226,
-0.8861421347,
-0.0658797473,
0.0171584357,
-0.4995286763,
0.4512780309,
-0.3941392004,
-0.3328973055,
-0.3192706108,
-0.5369613767,
-0.0511824451,
-0.1684150249,
0.0493467785,
0.1981732547,
0.1012503505,
0.1247090548,
0.2112115771,
-0.1700803787,
0.1880968958,
-0.5863261819,
0.4513828754,
-0.3768437803,
-0.6602540016,
-0.287166357,
0.1726358235,
0.3014029562,
-0.2284407318,
0.5080342293,
0.3374453783,
-0.1686704457,
-0.5715042949,
-0.4817071259,
0.100058727,
-0.4678339064,
-0.1541785002,
-0.7626191378,
-0.6488938332,
0.3268113434,
-0.145265013,
0.1734897196,
0.0352286398,
0.0913324952,
-0.2280052155,
0.9946130514,
0.4355949461,
0.0804594085,
0.117904827,
-0.2317272425,
0.2545318007,
-0.9708163738,
-0.1117990166,
-0.1390359998,
0.0235911254,
-0.313547343,
-0.5536881685,
0.1712089032,
0.4690991342,
-0.299503237,
0.3919466436,
-0.6224036813,
0.6377214789,
0.5085341334,
0.3469545245,
0.4311938584,
-0.1614610702,
-0.484359026,
-0.0142926667,
-0.6130062938,
-0.5537416339,
0.8424474001,
0.2633886933,
0.9210008383,
-0.026310375,
0.980933547,
0.4358950257,
0.1080268323,
-0.5842112303,
0.6701564193,
-0.2188317925,
-0.2609360814,
0.0727986172,
-0.630931139,
-0.5192384124,
0.2513191104,
0.2929139435,
-0.4725665152,
0.2406845093,
0.4073057771,
-0.4992852509,
0.3692427278,
-0.1198358908,
0.5809672475,
-0.3264144957,
-0.5060350299,
-0.3964923918,
-0.7326601744,
0.6263272762,
-0.0995539501,
0.1693069786,
0.1916786134,
0.2672133446,
0.5336466432,
-0.713378191,
0.5654848218,
-0.1885179877,
-0.5994147062,
0.3217579722,
0.3414229453,
0.6860313416,
-0.3665241003,
0.0227250513,
0.0626863465,
-0.150195241,
-0.2523331046,
-0.6411200762,
0.5225011706,
-0.197818324,
-0.6290260553,
-0.5381711721,
-0.6110636592,
-0.1652170718,
0.0678187981,
0.0991588011,
0.2522653341,
0.1536917239,
-0.3462229669,
1.1213076115,
0.0565200932,
0.3239596486,
0.3114987314,
-0.143481493,
-0.4706797302,
1.0122499466,
-0.0454232469,
0.6015670896,
0.4443767369,
0.0061433949,
-0.4339770377,
-0.2875562012,
-0.6171935797,
0.2791966796,
-1.1266410351,
-0.1085974276,
-0.3570332229,
-0.2149498016,
0.2564489841,
-0.1718811691,
-0.3559211791,
-0.1721738577,
-0.0982270315,
-0.0457479395,
0.0138189308,
0.4939093888,
-0.1332172155,
0.2398462743,
-0.6654424071,
0.4621261656,
0.320094347,
0.3230065107,
-0.1565035135,
-0.4377801716,
-0.1471274197,
0.1980954409,
-0.6016801,
-0.8013612628,
0.0005748829,
-0.0963300765,
0.3251297474,
0.5511875153,
0.1397068799,
1.0890643597,
-0.3998220265,
0.6208555102,
0.4139722884,
-1.3059777021,
0.7018456459,
-0.123424314,
0.2963894308,
0.6583843231,
0.1506099403,
-0.3693775535,
-0.4355386496,
-0.5225316882,
-0.1676208526,
0.7122583985,
0.4751729071,
-0.3011850417,
-0.2527368963,
0.3392276764,
-0.0553442687,
0.1030567512,
-0.5512353182,
-0.1711138487,
-0.2856541574,
-0.3778355718,
0.6022655368,
-0.1471421868,
-0.2026887983,
-0.1657380164,
0.8098526001,
-0.4660298228,
0.254956007,
0.2546009719,
-0.1075388417,
-0.4309239686,
0.2634438872,
0.4980644286,
0.8085107803,
0.1474725753,
0.2339581996,
0.4611901641,
-0.4992223084,
0.1184068471,
0.0472389348,
-0.3876840472,
-0.0499737747,
0.4023575485,
0.7291687727,
0.0040402147,
-0.4084833562,
0.586578548,
-0.075534232,
-0.2385523915,
-0.1374955326,
0.3208416402,
-0.2287227213,
0.3261737227,
0.2179103643,
0.3166694939,
0.0704928935,
-0.0948715955,
0.2602350414,
0.3456785679,
-0.2134366035,
-0.3098291755,
0.8372132182,
0.0194876436,
-0.1093247533,
0.6744265556,
-0.488026768,
-0.744985342,
0.3916447759,
0.6786957979,
0.8798591495,
-0.5047044158,
0.3961570561,
0.4623285532,
0.1667399853,
-0.6223270297,
0.7805558443,
-0.5588104129,
-1.0369268656,
-0.6037600636,
-0.8825052381,
-0.3082543314,
-0.05611296,
-0.8806154132,
0.1433984041,
-0.4935753345,
-0.114019908,
-0.3169273436,
-0.0125583643,
-0.5406197906,
0.526309967,
0.3719654977,
0.9607951641,
-0.6063734889,
0.8212836385,
0.3007797599,
-0.5686292052,
-0.9321507812,
0.388471514,
-0.0571857989,
-0.7446358204,
0.7187848091,
0.3144630194,
-0.746810317,
-0.1966218948,
-0.6087143421,
-0.8382484913,
1.1802303791,
0.3948066235,
-1.0147690773,
-0.0473030396,
0.0631636754,
0.3024178445,
-0.2252316028,
0.2283740491,
0.7427366376,
0.4034068584,
0.5931124687,
-0.8432476521,
0.1694829613,
-0.0827736631,
0.1882562637,
0.3513361216,
-0.7645510435,
0.7114492059,
-0.4886685312,
-0.4702207744,
0.2660472989,
0.8676456809,
0.8614726663,
0.4498248994,
0.7621762156,
0.9221919179,
1.2315731049,
-0.2611965835,
0.9984135032,
-0.4637316167,
0.1490281075,
1.1204227209,
-0.2832565606,
0.5344519615,
0.438657701,
-0.3458718657,
0.9422195554,
0.4333835542,
0.1500773877,
0.5034692287,
0.2508933842,
-0.3255029619,
-0.6300733685,
-0.0469365418,
-0.0181450192,
0.1896290332,
0.4928897917,
-0.5223284364,
-0.1355609447,
-0.2671765387,
0.1868321449,
0.282797575,
-0.5644557476,
0.2671796679,
0.2676893771,
-0.8812444806,
0.8313407898,
-0.0772091448,
0.45736292,
-0.6394402385,
-0.4154632092,
-0.1608951837,
0.4301798046,
-0.3667704165,
-0.9441793561,
0.2851016521,
0.030118851,
-0.108858712,
-0.2895840704,
0.569481194,
-0.4506456554,
-0.4622512758,
0.3878825605,
0.3218347728,
0.1114481762,
0.1271275878,
-0.7789871097,
0.2474467307,
-0.0570878088,
0.0666016564,
-0.2489415705,
0.4026098251,
-0.2152688354,
0.8390110135,
0.697491467,
0.0119421333,
-0.0184679013,
0.5258484483,
0.8821736574,
-0.6335514188,
-0.7341276407,
-0.9612428546,
0.3340087831,
-0.2299837321,
-0.3260636628,
0.8542364836,
0.4725011587,
0.8532535434,
0.1107777655,
0.6598977447,
0.0932049453,
0.2041246295,
-0.7666627765,
0.0619010292,
-0.4253028631,
0.4130112827,
-0.4626156092,
-0.6823014617,
-0.2776417434,
0.9830489755,
-0.2826619744,
0.082926847,
0.9190667868,
0.626426816,
-0.0643714964,
0.481308192,
0.2665801942,
-0.0044153784,
0.3117183745,
0.9905279875,
1.0236731768,
-0.4603908956,
0.3644498289,
-0.013272169,
-0.2260121554,
0.2742053568,
-0.8158735037,
-0.9542961121,
-0.3731808364,
-0.3432206213,
-0.6613257527,
0.2551089823,
0.9334951639,
0.6054380536,
-0.7564641833,
-0.1033792272,
-0.8545348644,
0.2208199948,
-0.7551047206,
-0.2024243325,
0.2135645747,
-0.5871167183,
-0.5570801497,
0.5334222913,
0.3580196798,
-0.2946987152,
-0.2422530204,
-0.5903386474,
0.0380711667,
0.2145274878,
0.3976318538,
0.1504500359,
-0.9500581622,
-0.2844158113,
-0.2249129713,
0.0238094572,
0.1861862391,
0.7436013222,
-0.6859762073,
0.5568103194,
0.1897248477,
0.5195985436,
0.4335190654,
0.3594225943,
0.5411092639,
-0.5760617256,
-0.473859489,
0.1744166017,
0.61364007,
0.4360467494,
-0.5065146089,
0.5949326754,
0.4239746034,
-0.579069078,
-0.4784102142,
0.5992131233,
-0.8548420072,
-0.0046473774,
1.135081768,
-0.3145492971,
-0.4706299901,
-0.0999866426,
-0.1072707921,
0.1836843193,
-0.3797832727,
0.5666984916,
0.7622428536,
-0.1286598295,
-0.2191962749,
-0.1595638394,
0.5016058683,
0.4675369263,
-0.6562018991,
0.2109799683,
0.5901344419,
0.2618647218,
0.5788262486,
0.7756773233,
0.1366401166,
0.3322556615,
0.2090875208,
-0.2441409826,
0.0050566546,
-0.7045962811,
-0.2909993529,
0.0644126534,
-0.3099189699,
-0.486828953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14930v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14930v2 | In-Context Impersonation Reveals Large Language Models' Strengths and Biases | 2023-05-24T09:13:15 | 2023-11-26T18:36:30 | Leonard Salewski, Stephan Alaniz, Isabel Rio-Torto, Eric Schulz, Zeynep Akata | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In everyday conversations, humans can take on different roles and adapt their
vocabulary to their chosen roles. We explore whether LLMs can take on, that is
impersonate, different roles when they generate text in-context. We ask LLMs to
assume different personas before solving vision and language tasks. We do this
by prefixing the prompt with a persona that is associated either with a social
identity or domain expertise. In a multi-armed bandit task, we find that LLMs
pretending to be children of different ages recover human-like developmental
stages of exploration. In a language-based reasoning task, we find that LLMs
impersonating domain experts perform better than LLMs impersonating non-domain
experts. Finally, we test whether LLMs' impersonations are complementary to
visual information when describing different categories. We find that
impersonation can improve performance: an LLM prompted to be a bird expert
describes birds better than one prompted to be a car expert. However,
impersonation can also uncover LLMs' biases: an LLM prompted to be a man
describes cars better than one prompted to be a woman. These findings
demonstrate that LLMs are capable of taking on diverse roles and that this
in-context impersonation can be used to uncover their hidden strengths and
biases. | [
-0.2420811206,
-0.7416349053,
0.6620137095,
0.1186745912,
0.1149064302,
0.5659732223,
-0.2647789121,
-0.7886070013,
0.026612537,
0.4572109282,
-0.3611520529,
0.0784864128,
-0.7151181102,
0.2047952861,
-0.2599032819,
0.6646575332,
0.1305316389,
0.1372814178,
-0.8458015323,
0.0032110948,
-0.5888153911,
-0.8028281927,
-0.5393018723,
-0.256506294,
0.3792721927,
0.3660399914,
0.6560976505,
0.3138442039,
0.2910058796,
0.3801633418,
0.0545570925,
0.2196800262,
-0.4849771857,
0.3395563662,
-0.4925422668,
-0.4623124301,
-0.0535523295,
0.3820141852,
0.4518537223,
0.7045090795,
0.1144380569,
0.1764363497,
0.312732935,
0.2991661429,
-0.3321871161,
0.209808588,
-0.9629532695,
-0.2020187676,
-0.144718796,
-0.3561661839,
-0.4086130559,
-0.1954873055,
0.3400124013,
-0.4550337195,
-0.0391920619,
0.1558243036,
0.9320857525,
0.2276583165,
-0.4584144056,
-0.4306852818,
-0.7324799895,
0.7275094986,
-0.4832558632,
-0.0676863566,
0.0663894191,
0.286614269,
-0.1988871694,
-0.5026139617,
-0.7447885871,
-0.3444356918,
-0.4813002348,
-0.2409223765,
-0.1170983166,
-0.0618749745,
0.5830965638,
0.2187673002,
-0.239259854,
0.1276172698,
-0.2419489771,
-0.1282972246,
0.471011579,
0.0001982876,
0.6138168573,
0.0614390448,
-0.5662232041,
-0.0762343034,
-0.8862942457,
0.3358324766,
0.442405045,
0.1845575273,
0.0548074841,
0.3813548088,
0.0272145551,
0.606755197,
0.1647112519,
-0.3532274961,
0.027365854,
0.1213826984,
-0.3070160747,
0.0512013473,
0.3399005532,
0.2529983521,
0.6758559942,
-0.2163340896,
-0.0099478215,
-0.1928806007,
0.4113019705,
-0.4939564764,
0.1960218698,
-0.0514064692,
-0.3833755553,
-0.2746384442,
0.1276746541,
-0.5867134929,
-0.6821122169,
-0.4984252453,
0.8408021331,
-0.4181118309,
-0.0839523897,
-0.1633927971,
-0.3515953124,
0.6823846102,
0.5073543787,
-0.814945519,
0.5566657186,
0.6094845533,
0.588758111,
-0.2303703278,
-0.5371217728,
-0.4097730219,
0.3233023584,
-0.2705579996,
0.6380844712,
-0.7011373043,
-0.2673475444,
-0.0467086248,
-0.0006287157,
-0.2422278225,
-0.7502589226,
0.1035004631,
-0.4564981461,
0.19313775,
-0.3434638977,
-0.5533162951,
-0.1973206699,
0.2875786424,
-0.3253404796,
0.9817006588,
0.2942561507,
-0.5740090609,
0.3864827752,
-0.5982421637,
-0.406447798,
0.3354169428,
-0.5075351596,
0.0712176561,
0.1826516539,
0.2341102064,
0.7119262218,
-0.0866236314,
0.0608476102,
-0.2740859985,
-0.3959287703,
0.9280099273,
-0.2148590535,
0.9182795882,
-0.1771726608,
-0.4053151906,
-0.1172126755,
-0.4587602317,
-0.2112635374,
0.1596293598,
-0.0304506533,
-0.6623883843,
0.0451674238,
-0.4542407393,
0.3083481193,
0.3894996941,
-0.5271482468,
0.0860438645,
-0.4735299647,
0.3856707215,
0.8731940389,
0.1234127581,
0.5546327233,
-0.6497575641,
0.5538428426,
-0.1091088429,
0.0463226028,
-0.2275369167,
-0.515507102,
-0.5964455605,
-0.3847033679,
-0.2217289805,
0.6997249126,
-0.8656519055,
0.1275150627,
-0.4368233085,
-0.3001910448,
-0.1907753497,
0.1210874692,
0.4163937569,
0.6614407301,
0.1357637197,
-0.292549938,
-0.281514138,
-1.1857905388,
-0.6923138499,
-0.3063168228,
-0.1213528514,
0.6592376828,
0.5166509748,
0.0205898378,
1.0663058758,
-0.1770024151,
-0.2818152308,
-0.342110306,
-0.1518133134,
-0.0227055587,
0.4073444307,
0.7726647258,
-0.8339474201,
-0.5551776886,
-0.2085846364,
-0.7931882739,
-0.1651206464,
-0.355661869,
0.0201101303,
0.002819808,
0.6997525692,
-0.6265354753,
0.295458436,
0.3159378171,
-0.3349642754,
0.4471719265,
-0.2095395774,
0.0585278086,
-0.7858445048,
-0.2343224883,
-0.0388285331,
-0.2778713107,
-0.7302211523,
0.1646444798,
-0.1118789315,
0.0003137333,
-0.5315636396,
0.8014001846,
-0.6826560497,
-0.2840670049,
-0.0741871819,
0.1192359924,
-0.1494819671,
0.4520328939,
-0.1535686702,
0.8460283279,
0.9091703892,
-0.6023266912,
0.187754035,
0.064877294,
-0.5855769515,
0.8238213062,
-0.4649324715,
0.4957932532,
-0.3694548905,
0.2604102492,
-1.297165513,
-0.4022009671,
0.2628596425,
-0.4435140491,
0.6141346097,
-0.113354966,
-0.7300722599,
-0.1159250811,
-0.1763599366,
0.3901346624,
0.341543138,
-0.6848819256,
0.7858603597,
0.6809028983,
-0.3212138712,
-0.4686320722,
-0.7629474401,
0.5325282216,
-0.6395475864,
-0.4750756919,
0.6572450995,
-0.2576186061,
-0.7082449794,
-0.3181832731,
0.2285457402,
-0.0782708004,
0.252551049,
0.3277413249,
0.3414994776,
0.2031083554,
-0.1270037591,
-0.1046889424,
0.2785196602,
0.110413745,
-0.0662383586,
0.2149021626,
0.0662305728,
-0.2986955941,
-0.1559310704,
0.4454022944,
0.6247169971,
0.032541573,
0.702659905,
0.0624622293,
-0.4039098024,
-0.2834993005,
-0.6669214368,
-0.3000438809,
-0.503292501,
0.1048048437,
-0.3649653196,
-1.1110600233,
0.4772916436,
-0.0137260109,
0.1122443005,
-0.0760017559,
0.5360535383,
-0.2735494375,
0.7114072442,
0.7711622715,
0.0541949719,
0.3726185262,
0.1129197702,
0.1824966669,
-0.8310473561,
-0.4010443091,
-0.2239725441,
-0.6875283122,
-0.5338935256,
-0.5193980336,
0.4181139767,
-0.3120085001,
-0.0754833966,
0.3757466376,
-0.5258315802,
0.5502207875,
0.5640403628,
0.1433728039,
0.0770774931,
-0.0712769479,
0.2280162126,
-0.35567379,
-0.5896095037,
-0.8462838531,
0.9492689967,
0.3665271997,
0.5976771712,
0.324018091,
0.4594912529,
0.2446607798,
0.7228707671,
-0.7077237964,
0.8727340698,
0.1927309334,
-0.6912404299,
-0.1126079932,
-0.1443531513,
-0.5892962813,
0.2578418851,
-0.0938374028,
-1.0743153095,
0.2980538607,
0.1082536951,
-0.3712692559,
0.2295475751,
-0.7157856822,
0.5917184949,
-0.3040829599,
-0.387039721,
-0.0002315981,
-0.7753712535,
0.4483644962,
0.0999641567,
0.3377616107,
-0.0514281914,
-0.3922055364,
0.5234840512,
-0.0727196932,
1.2129369974,
-0.2818993628,
-0.124197036,
0.1254493445,
0.4267927706,
0.5425953269,
-0.0428657345,
0.1613005698,
0.1053029895,
-0.096104674,
-0.2532662451,
-0.8228019476,
0.7726225257,
-0.5600364804,
-0.905459702,
-0.3997189403,
-0.566214025,
-0.5087219477,
-0.1706767827,
0.0473467298,
0.3202265203,
-0.3315609992,
0.211319074,
0.8909048438,
-0.4216356575,
0.5483340025,
0.5210498571,
0.0541805066,
-0.0440300778,
0.7221958637,
0.1302962899,
0.4475011826,
0.6941082478,
0.1027451754,
-0.166181758,
-0.2319526076,
-0.4644989073,
0.131269142,
-0.8127989769,
0.0281297341,
-0.7517443299,
-0.1014731452,
-0.2223535329,
-0.3415758014,
0.1384189129,
-0.4092458487,
-0.2396802604,
-0.0589832254,
0.2096056193,
0.6559523344,
0.1453372836,
0.3187890351,
-0.3667359352,
0.0625095516,
0.8417735696,
-0.1213139296,
0.0514660962,
-0.7713343501,
-0.1167887822,
-0.176827997,
-0.2486545295,
-1.0274795294,
0.3515473604,
0.2790303528,
0.8902181387,
0.3112853467,
-0.2776201665,
0.5363224149,
-0.5798751712,
1.0292174816,
-0.2911368608,
-0.8583964705,
0.0830332935,
-0.2487329692,
-0.1080335006,
0.306750834,
0.2088358849,
-0.4379424155,
-0.6589996219,
-0.6946594715,
-0.7154307365,
0.6693114638,
0.1301774979,
0.6924093962,
0.0016686865,
0.4485683739,
0.165074572,
0.4728643,
-0.9968239665,
-0.3809727132,
-0.0853375196,
0.0746387318,
0.025877405,
-0.4244501889,
-0.3398832381,
-0.3878276944,
0.323154062,
-0.2895679176,
0.4210494459,
0.3352303207,
-0.2595893443,
0.0669502318,
0.1396350265,
0.7274005413,
0.8363205791,
0.1417464465,
0.508369565,
0.3548595905,
-0.1393192261,
0.0897052512,
-0.1762617975,
0.0888697281,
-0.1599720716,
0.548078835,
0.6437543035,
0.6044638157,
-0.8194558024,
0.6516618729,
0.0864917487,
-0.1269102693,
-0.3319575787,
0.25324139,
0.083950229,
0.2508322299,
0.7294408679,
0.022979591,
-0.1838367432,
-1.0256214142,
0.0150548182,
0.69699651,
-0.1184944138,
-0.2992860973,
0.7239689231,
-0.0359990485,
-0.5731742978,
-0.0273867361,
-0.1008593217,
-0.6186915636,
0.7677200437,
0.5197712779,
0.9658600688,
-0.2008231431,
0.1308206916,
0.0520083793,
0.3621431887,
0.1787856817,
-0.1319839805,
-0.0888102502,
-1.0652022362,
-0.3105745018,
-0.3526901305,
-0.6537979245,
0.1288251728,
-0.3153426051,
0.0324093476,
-0.3440010846,
0.1771805286,
0.0128104109,
-0.2073039711,
-0.7655261159,
0.1147983447,
0.0934424773,
0.7328410745,
-0.5595523119,
0.7108156681,
0.8185980916,
-0.043169599,
-0.6306586266,
0.3046635091,
0.0293514188,
-0.8935988545,
0.8599245548,
0.2725606561,
0.0042905109,
0.1102186367,
-0.8993701935,
-0.824139595,
1.1651363373,
0.5449252725,
-0.2789926231,
-0.0422758572,
0.1717142761,
0.5798305869,
-0.9096124172,
0.2957326472,
0.4004426003,
0.4296398461,
-0.1690098941,
-0.9532496929,
0.1886032373,
0.0924292952,
-0.0100428881,
-0.4597438276,
-0.7366762161,
0.9875974655,
-0.1241335049,
-0.209353283,
-0.1312515736,
0.5223865509,
0.162795499,
0.1386198848,
0.6793954372,
-0.0438228622,
0.8284494877,
0.224833101,
1.072514534,
-0.2658162713,
-0.2003414631,
1.0559520721,
-0.4353713095,
0.4024785757,
0.645257771,
-0.0145641835,
0.7854153514,
0.3825701177,
0.2815586627,
0.3803158402,
0.0771979317,
-0.2538909316,
-0.1348148286,
-0.080163233,
0.0769096017,
0.4918913245,
0.4661604762,
-0.4197422862,
-0.0162483938,
0.1699025184,
0.22677131,
0.364156127,
-0.1762175411,
0.8096969128,
0.1796742827,
-0.6266717911,
0.1466761678,
-0.1152957082,
0.6725149751,
-0.4465454519,
-0.0478699207,
-0.0513029471,
0.0337863974,
0.017917892,
-0.8553378582,
0.2069553882,
-0.1431619078,
-0.2060459852,
-0.8310500383,
0.9239476919,
-0.4704575539,
-0.2779803276,
0.2630544305,
0.6987611651,
0.261102736,
-0.2143113166,
-0.5540943742,
-0.3457483351,
-0.1469276696,
-0.1614394039,
0.7363240123,
0.5614108443,
-0.2645904124,
0.8504533172,
0.5520968437,
0.0885512456,
-0.0276221894,
-0.1180528104,
0.7967358232,
-0.5240365267,
-0.3052801192,
-1.1638474464,
0.2100337297,
-0.4266646802,
-0.1838082224,
1.0630159378,
0.5676277876,
0.9407440424,
-0.1358403563,
0.8218193054,
-0.072649084,
0.7247298956,
-0.3153712749,
0.6373313665,
-0.5933660269,
0.2581386566,
-0.4490977228,
-0.5876885056,
0.0277364738,
0.3763082027,
-0.234229818,
-0.0945315063,
0.4395924807,
1.0805134773,
0.012593504,
-0.2426442802,
0.4819547832,
0.2063633502,
0.3425370455,
0.5230590701,
1.1014339924,
0.0600203983,
0.2789516747,
-0.1847156733,
-0.365562886,
-0.1456199586,
-0.8091285229,
-1.1485096216,
-0.6386095881,
-0.1593072414,
-0.129687041,
-0.3391078413,
1.0116084814,
0.7342106104,
-0.2416288108,
-0.3382076919,
0.2744849026,
0.3524719179,
-0.3320301473,
-0.3415826559,
-0.0722072423,
-0.1839675158,
-0.9238514304,
0.7625330091,
0.4928781092,
0.0426798873,
-0.6226882339,
0.1284707487,
0.0502209552,
0.5720489621,
0.7218446732,
0.1614675522,
-0.7251163125,
-0.6752106547,
0.0743544176,
-0.2591456771,
0.1654680222,
1.0676974058,
-0.9784856439,
0.3722905517,
0.282261163,
0.481297195,
0.1470782459,
0.1877302974,
0.599738121,
-0.8837224245,
0.2141485214,
0.3059846461,
0.1500672251,
0.5752643943,
-0.6532520652,
0.222721979,
0.4223405421,
-0.4277496338,
-0.9036659598,
0.2298474163,
-0.8170983195,
-0.4118520021,
1.3184655905,
0.0254691895,
-0.2089476585,
-0.3324762583,
-0.374486804,
-0.2280820906,
-0.292809695,
0.7787041068,
0.8940865397,
-0.3126016557,
-0.2166216224,
-0.8155009747,
0.7900133133,
0.2146398425,
-0.8478097916,
0.0385499261,
0.2023581713,
0.4312583506,
0.0527527034,
0.7409572601,
0.0642454177,
-0.0808531716,
-0.3455965519,
-0.3580381572,
-0.0311704371,
-0.2865926027,
-0.0721644014,
0.1183854938,
-0.0554396287,
0.0057636602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14929v1 | Aligning Language Models to User Opinions | 2023-05-24T09:11:11 | 2023-05-24T09:11:11 | EunJeong Hwang, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Niket Tandon | cs.CL | cs.CL | An important aspect of developing LLMs that interact with humans is to align
models' behavior to their users. It is possible to prompt an LLM into behaving
as a certain persona, especially a user group or ideological persona the model
captured during its pertaining stage. But, how to best align an LLM with a
specific user and not a demographic or ideological group remains an open
question. Mining public opinion surveys (by Pew Research), we find that the
opinions of a user and their demographics and ideologies are not mutual
predictors. We use this insight to align LLMs by modeling both user opinions as
well as user demographics and ideology, achieving up to 7 points accuracy gains
in predicting public opinions from survey questions across a broad set of
topics. In addition to the typical approach of prompting LLMs with demographics
and ideology, we discover that utilizing the most relevant past opinions from
individual users enables the model to predict user opinions more accurately. | [
-0.4124066532,
-0.2873349488,
0.7987542748,
0.178619802,
-0.0467420146,
0.2437819988,
-0.2965766191,
-0.3702363968,
0.1740128547,
0.6101615429,
-0.610029757,
-0.6456506252,
-0.3183847964,
-0.1539143026,
-0.1799482554,
0.9220026135,
0.2565845847,
0.3072913885,
-0.5644571781,
-0.1675432026,
-0.2691901624,
-0.7929553986,
-0.5931103826,
-0.664277792,
0.6986119151,
0.4482319355,
1.044950366,
0.4557723701,
0.2269078493,
0.2720178962,
0.0269552488,
0.0933779329,
-0.6748571396,
0.0836558938,
-0.3616224825,
-0.5063308477,
-0.4400846362,
0.1168917641,
0.1894447207,
0.5961873531,
-0.14478679,
0.1320967972,
0.1423483044,
0.378016144,
-0.2069949955,
-0.0703799725,
-0.7090861797,
-0.2564818263,
-0.336630106,
-0.2338592112,
-0.3483773172,
-0.6824443936,
0.1661669761,
-0.1702503115,
-0.0314603224,
0.2384545803,
0.8604024053,
0.1272754669,
-0.5919619799,
-0.0766258687,
-0.7312112451,
0.9649701118,
-0.9251380563,
0.3113791049,
0.2775939703,
0.1850207895,
-0.2620612979,
-0.1400130838,
-0.7924010754,
0.1361203939,
-0.2001618147,
0.1227100417,
-0.0393953547,
0.0709490627,
0.1248378828,
-0.047667563,
-0.5401149988,
0.3377273381,
-0.4889090955,
-0.0969102755,
0.8137180805,
0.4816685319,
0.3646762669,
-0.5486734509,
-0.7433261871,
0.1352189332,
-0.8977897167,
0.2540490925,
0.8479409218,
0.3763692081,
-0.0852108747,
0.7579616308,
0.0471655466,
0.7128574848,
0.2675848007,
-0.2147673815,
0.2069233805,
-0.1757484376,
-0.0289605465,
-0.0822558329,
0.9417911172,
0.9221086502,
0.5182445645,
0.1304795891,
-0.1951930523,
0.2269936353,
0.426253885,
-0.4936170578,
-0.0895704776,
0.2518736124,
-0.6668896675,
-0.306901902,
0.1740248352,
-0.9144285321,
-0.866810143,
-0.6238350272,
0.178725034,
-0.0313001685,
-0.4488171637,
-0.1449399441,
0.074887909,
0.3062759936,
0.4154098332,
-1.2271083593,
0.3503557444,
1.000959754,
0.624915123,
-0.2502512634,
-0.1699914187,
0.0155735463,
0.1439294964,
-0.1933620721,
0.981248498,
-0.7872632146,
-0.3933491111,
-0.0103200227,
-0.1830730289,
0.0475430712,
-0.4022567868,
0.2842504382,
-0.4696562886,
0.6471418738,
-0.5901101828,
-0.7316997051,
-0.1072908491,
0.215107426,
-0.3232157826,
0.9305925965,
0.1633687317,
-0.7119163871,
0.3637518883,
-0.6060319543,
0.0065471092,
0.0278099421,
-0.3950642943,
-0.2144643217,
0.2680141032,
0.2987472713,
0.4994877577,
-0.2141432762,
0.3918423951,
-0.7286069393,
-0.2077188343,
0.4911623895,
0.0304822419,
0.8828103542,
0.3169649541,
0.1896238178,
0.3309390247,
-0.1718074083,
-0.0095074438,
-0.1860430539,
-0.4179019332,
-0.3565333188,
0.4557225406,
0.1256365478,
0.2436354905,
0.4584490359,
-0.4573915303,
0.46369645,
-0.6386389732,
0.19156003,
1.0146677494,
-0.0366755575,
0.6275843978,
-0.5392923951,
0.6125485301,
-0.1353240162,
0.018513687,
0.2726414502,
-0.677241981,
-0.5540031791,
0.0415791869,
0.1437562555,
0.6011378765,
-0.1602721512,
0.6129704714,
-0.3411695063,
-0.5026268363,
-0.5871969461,
0.4820764959,
0.1343075484,
0.6355339885,
0.0135166412,
-0.369282037,
-0.8324956298,
-0.8880748749,
-0.5354344845,
-0.8402549624,
-0.1939664632,
0.356220752,
0.0497785956,
-0.1591432393,
1.1757632494,
-0.4345497787,
0.0817711726,
-0.3417538702,
0.2580791414,
0.2678378224,
0.1740150005,
0.4012315273,
-0.7282015085,
-0.7435248494,
0.0535919964,
-0.5491504669,
-0.3775962591,
0.2263286859,
-0.0918771178,
0.1423805654,
0.3041845262,
-0.3737460375,
0.143058449,
0.7475507259,
-0.2746892571,
0.0386749022,
0.2112706453,
0.2038645148,
-1.4220497608,
-0.1683603972,
0.3000060916,
-0.2072751224,
-0.7405692935,
-0.4589836299,
-0.0685696006,
-0.0779423118,
-0.4570251703,
0.8420194387,
-0.3017192483,
-0.0198000968,
-0.4357516468,
-0.0584691092,
-0.1097071469,
0.2630571723,
0.1479754001,
0.8289837241,
0.4200574458,
-0.3458602726,
0.2683880031,
0.2448215485,
-0.5195046663,
0.9090496302,
-0.4495112598,
0.3621317446,
-0.2998458147,
-0.084754616,
-1.1443897486,
-0.4083955586,
0.1988145113,
-0.6506737471,
0.0250150468,
-0.3139119446,
-0.2848307788,
-0.1928139925,
-0.3137018979,
-0.0096255103,
0.6919310689,
-0.4017870724,
0.8624507189,
0.7606590986,
-0.3378717005,
-0.6156694293,
-0.3085398674,
-0.0098130181,
-0.7096802592,
-0.8015979528,
0.3593345284,
-0.1311037689,
-0.6108692288,
0.1304436475,
0.1557558179,
0.0418659262,
-0.0154244527,
0.452524513,
0.4901702702,
-0.222509861,
0.2174238861,
-0.2993324995,
-0.0386296473,
0.057989087,
0.0415506847,
0.6657028794,
-0.0003766508,
-0.4269789457,
-0.3297325969,
0.2291209251,
0.5375873446,
0.0562027767,
0.6375970244,
0.2814710736,
-0.3869739473,
0.1486370564,
-0.829785049,
-0.163443327,
-0.474365741,
0.2735096812,
-0.1496400386,
-0.7304614782,
0.496973902,
-0.0583683252,
0.1812051535,
0.164675355,
0.9816051722,
-0.6035957932,
1.5294669867,
0.6938456297,
-0.47719118,
0.5312281847,
0.3930410147,
0.337788552,
-0.7763764262,
-0.3664015532,
-0.5767332315,
-0.6696325541,
-0.5718483925,
-0.1568814218,
0.132379055,
-0.0723339766,
-0.1095955744,
0.2814922035,
-0.1554269046,
0.502104342,
0.4127304256,
-0.0182243548,
0.0935329571,
0.2214095443,
0.128289938,
-0.3759161532,
-0.280911535,
-1.0148494244,
1.1697157621,
0.3597128391,
1.1836891174,
0.3588860333,
0.7862119675,
0.2682892382,
0.6261737943,
-0.8026385903,
0.4819636941,
-0.0805227086,
-0.8603388667,
-0.2259026021,
-0.3107072413,
-0.9303376675,
0.0974207371,
-0.4216626585,
-1.0849854946,
0.1502474844,
0.2268019021,
-0.284511596,
0.1852453649,
-0.7143554091,
0.6982892156,
-0.4091628492,
-0.1495313197,
-0.1381226927,
-0.5914426446,
0.4055671394,
0.0488456078,
0.1047048122,
-0.5452154875,
-0.1333223283,
0.6843953729,
-0.3971616328,
1.1141990423,
-0.2432771474,
-0.0279751495,
0.1005757451,
-0.2156468332,
0.1463233829,
-0.1458285898,
-0.3195581138,
0.1655732095,
-0.2643491328,
-0.1619931757,
-0.7774497867,
0.9470487833,
-1.0759350061,
-1.0664408207,
-0.2997408509,
-0.623716414,
-0.3453950286,
-0.0916963369,
0.0775591806,
-0.0119952578,
-0.2380566001,
-0.1403307915,
0.6017825007,
0.1545856893,
0.0418129005,
0.477049768,
-0.5284507275,
-0.4858140647,
0.6581363678,
-0.0049690539,
0.2657567859,
0.2618495524,
0.4197572768,
-0.6995541453,
-0.3493217826,
-0.3398317993,
0.3453465402,
-0.8081752062,
-0.2158259153,
-0.493760705,
-0.0465361699,
-0.3831095397,
-0.1906060129,
-0.043401096,
-0.2187654972,
-0.2943646908,
-0.1085969582,
0.3154940307,
0.8565229177,
0.2182672322,
0.6131333113,
-0.6281890869,
0.1370319277,
0.4237028062,
0.1173145398,
-0.1851004064,
-0.5305649638,
0.1581833959,
0.018015353,
-0.3276931942,
-1.1604378223,
0.2560938597,
0.0003929214,
0.7103655338,
0.7223805189,
-0.0733263493,
0.9248844981,
-0.2306959778,
0.801074028,
0.300733,
-0.9802082181,
0.5309709311,
-0.1354878992,
0.0608590059,
0.6347423792,
0.7319699526,
-0.7791959047,
-0.4015458226,
-0.4698902369,
-0.401450634,
0.6219161153,
-0.1465976834,
0.4869202971,
0.1459328234,
0.1516018808,
0.1371632963,
0.1395466477,
-0.9581363797,
-0.1048217714,
-0.1709512323,
-0.7045772076,
0.0538449064,
-0.2484711558,
-0.2977803051,
-0.1954516023,
0.5278005004,
-0.0826676562,
-0.0904916674,
-0.3893002272,
0.1496730149,
-0.4185515046,
0.3356845081,
0.5015568733,
1.1159029007,
-0.1981908381,
0.2716603279,
0.1170438528,
0.0623517185,
0.2539032698,
-0.1543377638,
-0.2257936001,
-0.1734749824,
0.166279763,
0.6305416226,
0.0475277454,
-0.3741574883,
0.6506739855,
-0.2183712125,
0.0479973815,
-0.2408903837,
0.2065151632,
0.6350404024,
0.2206881344,
0.1067825109,
0.0517778918,
-0.3342656493,
-0.6926212311,
-0.2418462634,
0.7873489857,
-0.4722152352,
-0.496899128,
0.5901379585,
0.4097028673,
-0.697916925,
0.6035547853,
0.2630910277,
-0.6229997277,
0.2482872754,
0.4624722898,
0.6867915988,
-0.5651452541,
-0.0528354459,
0.3682699502,
0.081584774,
0.0282873921,
0.4914928675,
0.2166799754,
-1.0044804811,
-0.4169216752,
-0.6158772707,
-0.4918536544,
0.125439167,
-0.5500504375,
0.7420296669,
-0.3314374983,
-0.460429728,
0.0803783908,
0.0914218053,
-0.4540612698,
0.1570582688,
0.2770825624,
0.5978600383,
-1.1284950972,
0.9024578929,
0.785366714,
-0.3385685682,
-0.8316685557,
0.0074048969,
0.3864727914,
-1.000980854,
0.5448690057,
0.0731320307,
-0.2011293769,
-0.1905700862,
-0.6846444607,
-0.7664937377,
0.8506118059,
0.3909358382,
-0.6451882124,
0.0616545491,
0.0719201118,
0.5358434319,
-0.7072991133,
0.1410788596,
0.1941092014,
0.5300735235,
0.044077415,
-0.674559474,
-0.1266378015,
-0.095154278,
-0.0147220111,
0.3916586041,
-0.3464448452,
0.8366715312,
-0.1749137938,
-0.4296465814,
-0.0470661484,
0.9244369864,
0.2162764966,
0.3751020432,
0.8933644891,
0.4051274061,
1.0335885286,
0.0873793513,
0.9002685547,
-0.534930706,
0.0998301283,
0.9225748777,
-0.6585866809,
0.8442656994,
0.6569223404,
-0.2151503712,
0.7724227309,
0.7820598483,
-0.1272231638,
0.3391972482,
0.0506859794,
-0.4033061266,
-0.3958072066,
-0.2021782845,
-0.2973160744,
0.4047216475,
0.3602834344,
-0.3461654782,
0.0522237606,
-0.3970120251,
0.2328903377,
0.5206760764,
-0.1719818562,
0.9287735224,
0.0212271977,
-0.9291324615,
0.1083439067,
0.0644098222,
0.6630871892,
-0.6076546311,
0.101264298,
-0.1964089423,
-0.1413082778,
-0.5519906282,
-0.9998521805,
0.2350624204,
0.2371263951,
-0.411629647,
-0.3132931292,
0.7437055111,
-0.4879771471,
-0.5502077937,
0.1737231314,
0.7323144674,
0.2836217284,
0.2786085606,
-0.5956029892,
0.0592456013,
0.1913951933,
-0.1177066863,
0.376640588,
-0.0318618156,
-0.1730936468,
0.5682970881,
0.7363188863,
0.3066898286,
-0.2352619022,
0.2272776961,
0.7103223205,
-0.7791398168,
-0.0892603919,
-1.2718273401,
0.5265595317,
-0.2915743291,
-0.1644384563,
0.8618789911,
0.6370154619,
0.854177177,
0.0626723021,
0.8567242622,
0.0529015288,
0.727810204,
-0.419403553,
0.6530659795,
-0.3921385407,
0.4220127165,
0.0378681459,
-1.122541666,
0.0339068212,
0.6465117335,
-0.4781882167,
-0.0568680651,
0.3370571434,
1.2390863895,
-0.0452262238,
-0.0122036384,
0.2223445177,
-0.1016062498,
0.3064211905,
0.3408314586,
1.260682106,
0.3010232449,
0.3991725147,
-0.1708961874,
-0.1223432198,
-0.1156614199,
-1.0454801321,
-0.9871280789,
-0.4026618004,
-0.1736018956,
-0.3725058734,
-0.2994674742,
1.2197560072,
0.8523275852,
-0.7642800808,
-0.8102995753,
0.4024884105,
0.3989622593,
0.0897092149,
-0.2920866013,
-0.0794234052,
-0.1451642513,
-1.132646203,
0.2678776085,
0.2549878955,
0.0294447541,
-0.8081637025,
-0.3087086976,
-0.0620253272,
0.363304019,
0.1869384944,
0.2230499387,
-1.1556087732,
-0.5095764995,
0.0548879914,
-0.3287704289,
0.3790302575,
0.8813023567,
-0.5986754894,
0.470616132,
0.5463149548,
0.3220533431,
0.1762936115,
0.7330539823,
0.8303464651,
-0.6865712404,
-0.2523037791,
0.3319720626,
0.3458334506,
0.6393424273,
-0.4371264577,
0.2161483318,
-0.168501094,
-0.6702082753,
-0.6375430822,
0.4623464048,
-1.0073624849,
-0.0321929865,
0.9460396171,
-0.0224240813,
-0.1853944212,
-0.2013578713,
-0.2173723131,
-0.2056936026,
-0.5300071239,
0.7586354017,
0.8986539245,
-0.4762710035,
-0.0682883039,
-0.1695102304,
0.342708081,
0.2371724397,
-0.8049691916,
0.0092989653,
0.4250993729,
0.4812765419,
0.0690301284,
0.7982771397,
0.1582216918,
-0.125519678,
-0.4776348472,
0.0452161469,
0.1967994273,
-0.1157015339,
-0.3567957878,
0.1555950791,
0.4141090512,
0.1734286547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14928v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14928v3 | Towards Reliable Misinformation Mitigation: Generalization, Uncertainty, and GPT-4 | 2023-05-24T09:10:20 | 2023-10-31T07:19:01 | Kellin Pelrine, Anne Imouza, Camille Thibault, Meilina Reksoprodjo, Caleb Gupta, Joel Christoph, Jean-François Godbout, Reihaneh Rabbany | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Misinformation poses a critical societal challenge, and current approaches
have yet to produce an effective solution. We propose focusing on
generalization, uncertainty, and how to leverage recent large language models,
in order to create more practical tools to evaluate information veracity in
contexts where perfect classification is impossible. We first demonstrate that
GPT-4 can outperform prior methods in multiple settings and languages. Next, we
explore generalization, revealing that GPT-4 and RoBERTa-large exhibit
differences in failure modes. Third, we propose techniques to handle
uncertainty that can detect impossible examples and strongly improve outcomes.
We also discuss results on other language models, temperature, prompting,
versioning, explainability, and web retrieval, each one providing practical
insights and directions for future research. Finally, we publish the LIAR-New
dataset with novel paired English and French misinformation data and
Possibility labels that indicate if there is sufficient context for veracity
evaluation. Overall, this research lays the groundwork for future tools that
can drive real-world progress to combat misinformation. | [
-0.1059725657,
-0.9358362556,
0.7026318312,
0.1466536969,
0.1904674768,
0.0716949478,
-0.1518031061,
-0.3931823969,
-0.2769588828,
0.1275045276,
-0.3340931237,
-0.3893753886,
-0.8597270846,
-0.1064653844,
-0.4763508141,
1.19769907,
-0.012191995,
-0.0537762456,
0.0474153459,
-0.0017893895,
-0.5809099674,
-0.6925957799,
-0.5590186715,
-0.0733210593,
0.3345413804,
0.6175321937,
1.0425721407,
0.2803726196,
0.6075543165,
0.214508608,
0.3556070626,
-0.0828362927,
-0.614679873,
0.1077122092,
-0.2733497322,
-0.5649548769,
-0.0628201291,
0.229516685,
0.7072592378,
0.683460772,
-0.358312428,
-0.0188934505,
0.0006374732,
0.4150563478,
-0.6525412202,
-0.0191532746,
-0.7880071402,
-0.1297243536,
-0.1078246459,
-0.1423737854,
-0.1897280365,
-0.6717169881,
0.3191302121,
-0.6217788458,
0.5699813962,
0.1148823425,
1.0365909338,
0.2404937744,
-0.382072717,
-0.5587132573,
-1.263011694,
0.8437446356,
-0.5718510151,
0.363315165,
0.74858284,
0.6412515044,
-0.0798934326,
-0.7518069744,
-0.4256338477,
-0.0896071568,
0.3029444218,
0.0354568884,
-0.548625052,
-0.1647346616,
0.1317345649,
0.1217548624,
-0.5703668594,
-0.2041129172,
-0.4503528774,
-0.6927362084,
0.2779930532,
-0.3577702343,
0.3185290396,
0.0441339388,
-0.2173590213,
-0.0455344655,
-0.8383219838,
-0.588624239,
0.6499424577,
-0.0828639567,
0.0257624313,
0.3586933315,
-0.1185857654,
0.4027752876,
-0.0036801582,
-0.0922289193,
0.2112594694,
-0.5855355263,
-0.2525206804,
-0.1597092003,
0.4674199224,
0.3886706233,
0.0911807343,
-0.3055668771,
-0.1424397081,
0.1283531934,
0.3238716722,
-0.5185451508,
-0.2772657871,
0.3512074947,
-0.0310312398,
-0.2076204419,
0.1729085594,
-0.8407922387,
-0.3309776187,
-0.1408764273,
0.7183957696,
-0.5881994963,
-0.2861299515,
0.0747698322,
-0.3424106836,
0.0524645522,
0.5473380685,
-0.7083705664,
0.029008545,
0.466935426,
0.6714206934,
0.2151432186,
-0.1929602772,
-0.2528385222,
0.5124431849,
-0.4965418875,
0.6157178879,
-0.6364890337,
-0.2107185274,
0.0715668276,
-0.1210317835,
-0.0127101969,
-0.3215580285,
1.0478856564,
-0.3373637199,
0.5290071964,
-0.4134435356,
-0.4739627242,
-0.3327492476,
0.5521912575,
-0.84308213,
0.6501478553,
0.2129179686,
-1.1150484085,
0.2715421915,
-0.4148375988,
-0.0380821526,
-0.0606232993,
-0.1485451758,
-0.5619240999,
0.125147,
0.0612108409,
0.3606119752,
-0.360362649,
0.3927919269,
-0.23229599,
-0.3860027194,
0.2374225259,
-1.123042345,
0.1238924488,
0.26759547,
-0.5178275704,
-0.2483365387,
-0.3191909194,
-0.0338874459,
-0.0792941079,
-0.2469093055,
-0.3491382897,
-0.1104180664,
-0.158749938,
0.0210133996,
0.3398511112,
-0.2352461368,
0.0162621886,
-0.1301323175,
0.3053268492,
0.5976315737,
0.187951982,
0.3961756825,
-0.5210553408,
0.4353557527,
-0.0076105716,
0.6053955555,
0.1911439598,
-0.6885166764,
-0.6098813415,
0.3032451868,
0.5700773597,
0.7651558518,
-1.0867679119,
0.0089644715,
-0.4865025878,
-0.5717731118,
-0.4062043726,
-0.0937185511,
0.4440155625,
0.5674037337,
0.4256867468,
0.0626291856,
-0.4595686197,
-1.0322123766,
-0.5822951198,
-0.2397623509,
-0.1329583824,
-0.1597758532,
0.2956304252,
-0.432713002,
0.861119926,
-0.1945494711,
0.1299356967,
-0.1506019682,
0.4788665473,
0.0315337293,
0.3985320032,
0.4474278688,
-1.2280470133,
-0.2564383149,
0.1134570614,
-0.6275652051,
0.2980803251,
-0.1308646202,
0.2081345022,
0.2787993848,
0.066602312,
-0.5876110792,
0.5916636586,
0.5060673952,
-0.0378971286,
0.7186733484,
-0.4062674642,
0.6113102436,
-0.8543046713,
-0.0547233485,
0.2448230684,
-0.0549368374,
-1.0176496506,
-0.2020665854,
0.187890321,
0.2643128335,
-0.273172766,
0.3026984632,
-0.4432779551,
0.1798835695,
-0.0963812247,
0.0480707996,
-0.3980664313,
-0.121425122,
-0.4422488511,
0.6152942777,
0.4851405323,
-0.5410127044,
0.3517410457,
-0.1111373827,
-0.1890687793,
0.6226972342,
-0.5639305711,
-0.0015611653,
-0.2465122193,
0.2962591648,
-0.7662928104,
-0.8673077822,
0.5331386924,
-0.6825521588,
0.4262826443,
-0.3605037332,
-0.6758517623,
-0.6053464413,
-0.3003235757,
0.2243016958,
0.3956457078,
-0.0926095396,
0.4006890059,
0.2294197828,
-0.3398802876,
-0.7968866825,
-0.9094488025,
0.278629154,
-0.546628654,
-0.5604928732,
-0.0875223279,
-0.4221161008,
-0.2913435698,
-0.0021032412,
-0.5567371845,
-0.4746243656,
0.0810380206,
0.0453433618,
0.1274611652,
0.1095165014,
0.5104553699,
-0.0491257198,
-0.1549250484,
-0.0606724657,
-0.4739611149,
0.3132615685,
-0.3866582215,
-0.5282685161,
-0.2147970796,
0.2464571148,
0.1727013141,
0.288045615,
0.6460216045,
0.7856780887,
-0.6609542966,
0.0127001889,
-1.0821936131,
-0.1579793841,
-0.4247306883,
0.3575921059,
-0.178818956,
-0.8793622255,
0.1991562694,
-0.193221435,
-0.0483775437,
0.5696538091,
0.1993878186,
0.0948863924,
0.6277397871,
0.7742581367,
-0.2974469364,
0.0091704158,
0.0075588012,
0.4237723649,
0.0111202244,
-0.0264945347,
-0.7378119826,
0.1597080976,
-0.5178868175,
-0.7339372039,
0.5900347829,
0.2149016261,
-0.1216161251,
0.0321764462,
-0.3682219386,
0.6270660758,
0.4728458822,
-0.1349201053,
0.4136932194,
0.2753934562,
0.1354092807,
-0.0552727208,
-0.8301972747,
-0.6817225814,
1.2265912294,
0.6387881041,
0.6996914744,
0.3812876344,
0.3876319826,
0.3437095582,
0.5093008876,
-0.2372454703,
-0.0078532025,
0.1625265628,
-0.8975756764,
-0.5950547457,
-0.7369670868,
-0.7674977183,
-0.008738107,
-0.1892547756,
-0.6681728959,
0.0182847623,
0.3101402223,
-0.271936655,
0.3447545767,
-0.9096559882,
0.5437908173,
-0.105282858,
-0.0422633328,
-0.0913044736,
-0.8997579813,
0.4634182751,
-0.6346077919,
0.8523697257,
0.0838470832,
-0.0999460816,
0.4533038139,
0.0627257377,
0.9259046316,
-0.0892939866,
-0.1620765179,
0.2671054006,
-0.0191329923,
0.6444599628,
0.0421687849,
-0.0473799743,
0.2744668722,
0.0081793657,
-0.4415112138,
-0.655644536,
0.6540703773,
-0.7601359487,
-0.4534974098,
-0.4394849241,
-0.3223491907,
-0.4637291133,
0.1555835158,
0.8229205608,
0.0996461436,
-0.3593720496,
0.0179769304,
1.0604934692,
-0.1345254481,
0.2219799906,
0.477971226,
0.0670399517,
-0.4340175986,
1.03129673,
0.4186165631,
0.3424038887,
0.2801833153,
0.2342650145,
-0.2661345005,
-0.7628533244,
-0.1250035763,
0.2723073363,
-0.9838345051,
-0.2744746804,
-0.4800719619,
-0.3952568471,
-0.3356268704,
0.1853023618,
-0.304726094,
-0.4789370298,
-0.0749164373,
-0.3657382727,
0.0769778341,
1.1514371634,
-0.3718997538,
0.4031468928,
-0.8514877558,
0.1844086796,
0.326623559,
0.2702741921,
-0.2882083058,
-0.389970541,
-0.3325545192,
0.5869466066,
-0.2987392545,
-1.0148897171,
0.2073310912,
0.0805910975,
0.9038425684,
0.2701403201,
0.0235904288,
0.293271631,
-0.2805041671,
0.7624177337,
0.3206816316,
-1.0065644979,
0.6180911064,
-0.5754384398,
-0.1207967475,
0.5175394416,
0.9909461141,
-0.6590228081,
-0.5324825048,
-0.9535042644,
-0.8390064836,
0.2424409091,
0.5959479213,
-0.0380604938,
0.0465279147,
0.4119600058,
0.2671846449,
0.3722690344,
-0.7024578452,
-0.2393144518,
-0.225364089,
-0.2041663826,
-0.2231580168,
-0.4274501503,
-0.4186439216,
0.0542581715,
0.8651947379,
-0.1472601146,
0.2394993603,
0.2420949489,
-0.0248884577,
-0.0614847615,
0.5136641264,
0.6241149902,
0.9128828645,
0.0130234817,
0.2050561309,
0.1267566383,
-0.7322185636,
0.2080928832,
0.0940669253,
-0.3801591992,
0.1220109612,
0.4000090957,
0.4618647695,
0.2354528904,
-0.1914523244,
0.7016641498,
-0.170791015,
-0.4266977012,
-0.4729528129,
-0.0892453268,
-0.0018724934,
-0.0220422745,
0.6164491773,
0.2841737866,
0.2033771425,
-0.4795235395,
0.2445507497,
0.1989307553,
-0.2994723916,
-0.3918017149,
0.3578109145,
-0.0015659498,
0.2353456616,
0.4154903889,
-0.3522896469,
-0.3531373143,
0.3959787488,
0.3861150742,
0.6025490761,
-0.7204531431,
0.6000464559,
0.20340693,
0.9066178799,
-0.602429688,
0.144874081,
0.4169626236,
-0.8054172397,
-0.4619250894,
-0.3040483296,
-0.5300026536,
0.2539166808,
-0.2572855055,
-0.0611514151,
-0.3718862534,
-0.2026907504,
-0.2546577156,
-0.2096746117,
-0.6959142685,
0.2699352801,
-0.2152400315,
0.6922754645,
-1.0168142319,
0.6779862046,
0.4550628662,
-0.4143961966,
-0.96102494,
0.5606044531,
0.3213610947,
-0.4090445638,
0.1763203144,
0.1018681377,
0.060121078,
-0.2644895315,
-1.0656604767,
-1.1610136032,
1.1020666361,
0.5606653094,
-0.6822342277,
0.0136853727,
0.2368877828,
0.384468466,
-0.0386833064,
0.2363071144,
0.7708088756,
1.0114504099,
0.2729327381,
-1.1413807869,
-0.1735870838,
0.1400907934,
-0.0814115778,
-0.0092979902,
-0.4659395814,
0.7885597348,
-0.1013637707,
-0.3984233439,
0.0171577986,
0.455521822,
-0.121694997,
0.5416498184,
0.3678747118,
0.4342918098,
1.3898347616,
-0.3625283539,
1.0307620764,
0.0230052192,
0.5158140063,
1.0924168825,
0.0793102756,
0.512029767,
0.1931654364,
-0.1123199761,
0.1792867184,
0.5400546193,
0.1323046982,
0.29152596,
0.1453231722,
-0.4269158244,
-0.1974912733,
0.1595693678,
-0.5442442894,
0.203769356,
0.7573688626,
0.0017570388,
-0.3153438866,
0.1239921972,
0.221194014,
-0.1319747418,
-0.1751592308,
0.3527982235,
-0.1487175375,
-0.3946065605,
0.5808463693,
0.0618963987,
0.6849136949,
-0.7077389359,
0.0144368736,
-0.1226864904,
-0.0667452738,
-0.1766810119,
-0.6720770597,
0.5347229838,
-0.1484357119,
-0.2848007679,
0.2674280405,
0.9014590979,
-0.4868979454,
-0.5510617495,
0.0023999384,
0.6519367695,
0.3142990768,
-0.3392378986,
-0.5354064703,
0.1920674145,
0.3603055179,
0.1651421934,
0.0588274412,
0.8054834008,
-0.1248089373,
1.0265078545,
0.3967619538,
0.1478270143,
0.1282836497,
0.0091587342,
0.7994073629,
-0.5252646804,
-0.2421127707,
-0.5456168652,
0.3484814763,
-0.317863971,
0.0061449646,
1.0779211521,
0.2830988467,
0.7689097524,
-0.0477665588,
1.5330169201,
0.0092445044,
0.7185021639,
-0.422757417,
0.7176176906,
-0.1355186701,
0.4661931396,
-0.4623327553,
-1.0486872196,
-0.4614236355,
0.3536241651,
-0.3787178993,
0.2719500065,
0.6868836284,
0.5475376844,
-0.0566706732,
0.1672159135,
0.4681685567,
0.5121065378,
0.5047014952,
0.4610724151,
0.8373222947,
-0.5140146613,
0.8398236036,
-0.0817462355,
-0.5321421027,
-0.1897533983,
-0.9298239946,
-0.4483184218,
-0.5692157149,
-0.2689253092,
-0.3518750072,
0.4844002724,
0.1958365738,
0.6762978435,
-0.5991886854,
0.4454826117,
-0.1897137463,
0.2423440218,
0.1794661134,
-0.2051342577,
0.1076915488,
-0.3269280493,
-0.5342450142,
0.3041222692,
0.1922745854,
0.5614774227,
-0.1996014416,
-0.084806554,
0.1977676451,
0.2956291735,
0.1970635355,
0.4121192098,
-0.5817901492,
-0.6617882848,
-0.5031451583,
-0.0131617896,
-0.2808140218,
0.4152399898,
-0.3370810449,
0.3627665639,
0.0666377693,
0.641145587,
0.1597319841,
0.1652830243,
0.7085097432,
-0.8004946709,
-0.2485011071,
0.3121507168,
0.0629025772,
0.6351044774,
-0.425062865,
0.6881629229,
0.3215121627,
-0.781154573,
-0.403436929,
0.2329361439,
-0.5768170953,
-0.2970200777,
1.2788963318,
-0.0848394632,
-0.0744272098,
-0.6268418431,
-0.080184646,
0.0575331226,
-0.4333835244,
0.8067843914,
1.1834236383,
0.2798039317,
0.1130235791,
-1.0152467489,
0.5324495435,
0.1630841047,
-0.8351739645,
-0.0032453537,
0.7603547573,
0.6959678531,
0.4818636477,
0.6086567044,
-0.0436855666,
0.2840842903,
0.1253455579,
-0.1070732921,
0.3065321743,
-0.5880155563,
-0.3336163759,
0.1887860447,
0.0207092576,
0.1511630416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14926v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14926v2 | Universal Self-Adaptive Prompting | 2023-05-24T09:09:48 | 2023-10-21T02:25:33 | Xingchen Wan, Ruoxi Sun, Hootan Nakhost, Hanjun Dai, Julian Martin Eisenschlos, Sercan O. Arik, Tomas Pfister | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A hallmark of modern large language models (LLMs) is their impressive general
zero-shot and few-shot abilities, often elicited through in-context learning
(ICL) via prompting. However, while highly coveted and being the most general,
zero-shot performances in LLMs are still typically weaker due to the lack of
guidance and the difficulty of applying existing automatic prompt design
methods in general tasks when ground-truth labels are unavailable. In this
study, we address this by presenting Universal Self-Adaptive Prompting (USP),
an automatic prompt design approach specifically tailored for zero-shot
learning (while compatible with few-shot). Requiring only a small amount of
unlabeled data and an inference-only LLM, USP is highly versatile: to achieve
universal prompting, USP categorizes a possible NLP task into one of the three
possible task types and then uses a corresponding selector to select the most
suitable queries and zero-shot model-generated responses as
pseudo-demonstrations, thereby generalizing ICL to the zero-shot setup in a
fully automated way. We evaluate USP with PaLM and PaLM 2 models and
demonstrate performances that are considerably stronger than standard zero-shot
baselines and often comparable to or even superior to few-shot baselines across
more than 40 natural language understanding, natural language generation, and
reasoning tasks. | [
-0.2051111013,
-0.728084445,
0.6428479552,
0.4541381001,
-0.2659082115,
-0.1976390034,
-0.1549437493,
-0.2698118091,
-0.1619396806,
0.1790324748,
-0.5999217033,
-0.5256979465,
-0.1790485829,
0.5355626345,
0.0113192638,
0.8077408671,
-0.0044973572,
-0.2523825765,
0.0640964657,
-0.1632757336,
-1.0867414474,
-0.2106076777,
-0.6704403162,
-0.2980784178,
0.5351326466,
0.8752146363,
0.3121200502,
0.3262723088,
-0.2479203641,
0.1828581244,
0.0813842416,
-0.0707195327,
-0.0006995432,
0.4339904487,
-0.5280314684,
-0.3505687714,
-0.2394744456,
-0.0910516679,
0.4799189866,
0.4888049066,
-0.0974971578,
0.1572092175,
0.3848505616,
0.6142082214,
-0.820818007,
-0.0846370161,
-0.8302941322,
0.1106502265,
0.1991217583,
-0.2905348837,
-0.5308812857,
0.1303680241,
0.1250454634,
-0.5871736407,
0.1650204957,
0.0018178562,
0.2940568924,
0.305460602,
-0.2459048778,
-0.4101149738,
-0.5277314782,
0.6252802014,
-0.5686331987,
0.1143768653,
0.0550592951,
0.3881651461,
-0.2987226844,
-0.1636563689,
-0.4686697423,
-0.3953988254,
0.3098890781,
0.2684035599,
-0.4694525599,
-0.0418007001,
0.2477493882,
-0.259305954,
-0.7889398336,
0.6220526695,
-0.0641394258,
-0.1107606143,
0.3383091688,
0.225637868,
0.3442772627,
-0.3707270324,
-0.4346764088,
0.0722178593,
-0.9034966826,
0.4448129535,
-0.1189419925,
0.5983241796,
-0.2118930221,
0.2065882087,
-0.4432735741,
1.2128534317,
0.2344884425,
0.0495895371,
-0.3061798215,
0.0554218441,
-0.4170562029,
0.0700745657,
0.9480162263,
0.3241479695,
0.3834602535,
-0.0041172234,
-0.0554106124,
-0.1816851944,
0.1033102721,
-0.5525446534,
0.001466478,
0.310437113,
0.0039115744,
-0.0775028616,
-0.4249677956,
-0.611009419,
-0.2905068398,
-0.3214310706,
0.7936527133,
-0.2759055495,
0.0936393067,
0.2245406359,
-0.0454935133,
0.2915229499,
0.5258545876,
-1.1427276134,
-0.0197894853,
0.1229643449,
0.9096881151,
-0.2929130793,
-0.3982107937,
-0.509172678,
0.1716285199,
-0.4153044522,
1.0734539032,
-0.3606841862,
-0.5786570311,
-0.0575171113,
-0.2126955837,
-0.0873213261,
-0.3238118291,
0.5331858993,
-0.3402171135,
0.3977134526,
-0.5322748423,
-0.4410122931,
-0.1192016602,
0.2180145234,
-0.01965685,
0.8264223933,
0.2075331062,
-0.579477489,
0.5000605583,
-0.998093605,
-0.2459258437,
0.2581418753,
-0.323113203,
0.0424561724,
0.2197918743,
0.6752104759,
0.7490825653,
-0.3069044054,
0.3636344671,
-0.2133185267,
-0.5166969299,
0.0089453114,
-0.7175851464,
0.9883907437,
0.1781297177,
-0.5528756976,
0.1845213473,
-0.7251090407,
-0.0945908725,
0.3416955173,
-0.1181027293,
-0.0760702193,
-0.4059721231,
-0.3730858862,
0.3465760052,
-0.0440769866,
-0.4825305343,
0.6587440968,
-0.3183920979,
0.1297801137,
0.984279573,
0.1027423143,
0.6230683923,
-0.1997688264,
0.7079271674,
-0.151945278,
0.0729671419,
-0.6773585677,
-0.3757755458,
-0.6739830971,
-0.2259060293,
0.1759739369,
0.8312030435,
-0.6615361571,
0.5153999329,
-0.0264986753,
-0.1212803051,
-0.3105523884,
0.3644021451,
0.3692084551,
1.1202905178,
0.5128504038,
-0.1330359876,
-0.3694334328,
-0.5809035897,
-0.2320513427,
-0.1581381112,
-0.4761037529,
0.3898692131,
0.1928652227,
0.0912235826,
1.197348237,
-0.2204506397,
-0.3040335178,
-0.4382444322,
0.2410906851,
0.3819353282,
0.2018886656,
0.669377327,
-0.0375541598,
-0.8856820464,
-0.471875608,
-0.9215833545,
-0.6235842705,
-0.493299216,
0.1686146855,
0.335772872,
0.279274404,
-0.4187996387,
0.3886159658,
0.3740604818,
-0.4396767318,
0.7030537128,
-0.5372610688,
-0.0792169124,
-1.0437687635,
-0.0639822632,
0.0429341905,
-0.0785746574,
-0.5491848588,
-0.1044639423,
0.2999700904,
-0.1495816857,
-0.6106519699,
1.094727397,
-0.6399576068,
-0.1027866602,
-0.5277148485,
0.2222564965,
0.1088051423,
0.5469210744,
0.0690499693,
0.9672048688,
1.0605763197,
-1.0926392078,
0.1872464567,
0.1640443355,
0.0271132682,
0.9878213406,
-0.8119280934,
0.1776840538,
-0.3294245005,
0.5308941603,
-1.1130900383,
-0.3390266001,
0.3085898757,
-0.3639093637,
0.3821811676,
-0.1082708016,
-0.1181638837,
-0.4988779426,
-0.3333875537,
-0.037395943,
0.6006963849,
-1.0334703922,
0.4252581596,
-0.2256004363,
-0.3182664216,
-0.5367032886,
-0.3186774552,
0.3099700212,
-0.1925789118,
-0.3214617372,
0.1537499279,
-0.4561224282,
0.1139825583,
-0.5755867958,
-0.1244948357,
0.1864802688,
0.2338068038,
0.3828986585,
0.4121860862,
-0.1229296476,
0.166321367,
0.1125754192,
-0.3939988613,
-0.2671363354,
-0.4235236943,
0.4489418864,
0.0685871616,
-0.2764509618,
-0.9465269446,
0.2182923108,
0.2012063712,
0.2201045305,
0.3552747667,
0.3219981492,
0.0061316928,
-0.3778924942,
-0.3917642832,
-0.1660880148,
-0.5351529121,
-0.0921860263,
-0.495324105,
-0.9245536327,
0.2929491699,
-0.0141294049,
0.4908784926,
0.3200873435,
0.6432709694,
-0.3397967815,
1.0330513716,
0.6001834869,
-0.3901357353,
0.4540130496,
0.0240706317,
-0.2685444057,
-0.7787135243,
0.046928037,
-0.5383403301,
-0.1936663687,
0.0048338119,
-0.1625554711,
0.3199209273,
0.3437900245,
-0.4316503108,
0.3675985634,
-0.7564327121,
0.638625145,
0.6354759932,
-0.1593326926,
0.1814476103,
0.0760638341,
-0.5392628908,
0.0452254489,
-0.8287578821,
-0.5537110567,
1.0948821306,
0.1450440735,
0.7687243819,
-0.07235834,
0.7699383497,
0.4182246327,
0.4048309922,
-0.698407352,
0.3989510536,
0.1303059012,
-0.4675008357,
-0.4030436575,
-0.0846554935,
-1.120451808,
0.1774508357,
-0.0366256125,
-1.0732398033,
0.0275722574,
0.6152558923,
-0.9545346498,
0.0153810456,
-0.6390960217,
0.6463555694,
-0.2926338017,
-0.1552839279,
0.2548242509,
-0.6350522041,
0.1348050982,
0.0788108334,
0.1620080024,
-0.3013088703,
-0.1484439671,
0.3999660015,
0.1860467196,
1.0548779964,
-0.4715140164,
-0.2173452377,
0.4636499882,
0.4114741981,
0.3878252804,
0.0004580942,
-0.3232489824,
-0.1223813891,
-0.2538781464,
-0.4857830405,
-0.6561250687,
0.5803989768,
-0.5698076487,
-0.7560816407,
-0.364587456,
-0.5240416527,
-0.416967988,
0.1039922759,
0.4410413802,
0.5002619028,
-0.229850173,
-0.0812505111,
0.4064309001,
-0.3655324578,
0.9804990292,
1.1781477928,
-0.2132861018,
-0.1313056201,
0.7238577008,
-0.0257668216,
0.2631516159,
0.3460983336,
0.5046350956,
-0.5807273984,
-0.4525088668,
-1.0933612585,
-0.0741124749,
-0.6547262669,
-0.5248718858,
-0.7230338454,
0.0685027167,
-0.4810394347,
-0.659383297,
0.0205064528,
-0.4926400781,
-0.6214777231,
-0.0819187537,
0.2894122005,
0.6178891063,
-0.3675171733,
0.5129316449,
-0.8870536685,
0.4164230824,
0.7225016952,
0.1070415154,
-0.0211988855,
-1.2343202829,
0.3383586109,
-0.1541445702,
-0.5323228836,
-0.8565045595,
0.2281641066,
0.4441892803,
0.489789933,
0.4483080804,
0.2398114502,
0.5905693769,
-0.7693689466,
1.0745871067,
0.38573578,
-0.8725337386,
0.7464246154,
-0.5015794039,
0.9196732044,
0.6082215309,
0.5635901093,
-0.6344518065,
-0.1977432668,
-0.5899204612,
-0.4177330434,
0.7479910851,
-0.3207272887,
0.5791785717,
-0.0051883478,
0.6743656397,
0.2151087075,
-0.2124928385,
-0.8945208192,
-0.262393117,
-0.1646487564,
-0.3400051296,
0.151657775,
-0.3406466842,
0.0701563656,
-0.1409728974,
0.5649244785,
-0.6604560018,
0.1601551026,
0.3354673982,
-0.2760863602,
-0.0924404413,
0.6884620786,
0.6360399127,
0.6701744795,
-0.0451883078,
0.0257590748,
0.5352700949,
0.1164087877,
0.4916813672,
-0.142926842,
-0.5257613659,
-0.1448115408,
0.2518813908,
0.8573850989,
0.3372857869,
-0.5005508065,
0.5024191141,
-0.1318443418,
-0.2069600672,
0.2436315715,
0.4664995968,
-0.0440381728,
0.1026294529,
0.6061012745,
-0.1776538044,
0.040673703,
-0.3978459239,
0.2051253021,
0.505028069,
-0.5778009892,
-0.4910913706,
0.7025972605,
0.2030382603,
-0.4448062479,
0.3696094453,
-0.4193390012,
-0.3766370714,
0.211195305,
1.0387085676,
0.8832879066,
-0.5861424804,
0.6892580986,
0.5186808705,
0.0647377223,
0.0711365342,
0.2780471444,
-0.5137081146,
-0.6353364587,
-0.2830164433,
-0.5810462236,
-0.5426973104,
0.0421866924,
-0.3908026814,
0.1260071397,
-0.7258567214,
0.1650495529,
-0.1190883443,
-0.2949727476,
-0.6048837304,
0.3454448581,
0.1213300154,
1.0731759071,
-0.8689724803,
0.7069805264,
0.4105684459,
-0.3338321745,
-0.7876939178,
-0.0137402574,
0.3385714889,
-1.0965722799,
0.4769599438,
0.2719114721,
0.0445492603,
0.148130402,
-0.7591739893,
-0.5847026706,
0.9886567593,
0.5578563213,
-0.6433877945,
-0.1390272379,
-0.0296705663,
0.3989493847,
-0.4066871107,
0.4273501635,
0.441233933,
0.1996513456,
0.4145184159,
-0.9098106027,
0.1070827022,
0.2591922879,
-0.0567679591,
-0.1329189092,
-0.5279952288,
0.5740384459,
-0.3225475848,
-0.2378778458,
-0.0179250054,
0.6370546818,
0.5218121409,
0.1669331789,
0.6170886755,
0.1463333517,
0.5937995315,
0.3119487464,
0.8717951179,
-0.2760620713,
-0.1100630015,
1.3346579075,
-0.3176125586,
0.8785856962,
0.2593781352,
-0.1426049769,
0.5195256472,
0.655913651,
0.3074483871,
0.2649566531,
0.0573131144,
-0.4784471095,
-0.3003096282,
-0.1965962946,
-0.0425093174,
0.5594565272,
0.2868929505,
0.0467766747,
-0.6495341063,
0.1272154748,
-0.0891737863,
-0.0590114743,
-0.3664823771,
0.8507990241,
0.1580236256,
-0.9101542234,
0.8108853698,
-0.1499822736,
0.8912808299,
-0.5949802399,
-0.0433795713,
-0.2431122214,
-0.2826293111,
0.0510740988,
-0.8146570325,
-0.0560149588,
0.2307407856,
-0.0682717338,
-0.4145573974,
0.7622925043,
-0.148068428,
-0.3052077293,
0.2859626412,
0.3431768715,
0.1633265167,
-0.2671489716,
-1.1690785885,
-0.1097253338,
0.1573651433,
-0.1748436391,
0.4623523355,
0.3106079698,
-0.0305327997,
0.7822288275,
0.7383087277,
-0.140494898,
-0.0734657273,
0.2307080775,
0.667353034,
-0.8313031793,
-0.4229997993,
-0.9147526026,
0.6259523034,
0.1368551254,
-0.3685747385,
0.6834074855,
-0.0023824053,
0.3853493631,
0.0045073871,
0.7713138461,
0.1048056483,
0.5888504982,
-0.5700007081,
0.3367684484,
-0.5613776445,
0.2129084915,
-0.2385987043,
-0.7690519094,
-0.4666784406,
0.6505573392,
0.0110354787,
-0.0738989413,
0.278644532,
0.6241230965,
0.0675443634,
-0.0610940941,
0.7357038856,
-0.0643133372,
0.379858315,
0.6081416607,
0.6098757386,
-0.0152546465,
0.3727727234,
-0.0994812697,
-0.4923786223,
-0.3135586679,
-1.2533414364,
-0.9620995522,
-0.4063867033,
-0.0878727585,
-0.0344520584,
-0.0957971886,
1.2653391361,
0.5538558364,
-0.8939795494,
-0.1115369201,
-0.1947309673,
0.0758059174,
0.1391314715,
-0.2060734034,
0.2979035079,
-0.7235808969,
-0.5553660989,
0.8743394613,
0.6872540712,
0.3399743736,
-0.2186214924,
-0.0606092103,
-0.007202243,
0.18283692,
0.6265971065,
0.8970885277,
-0.7523803711,
-0.4108636081,
0.1230408698,
-0.0181429293,
0.1659894139,
0.6468536258,
-1.0150101185,
0.7358403802,
0.2389351577,
0.5391197205,
-0.0526319779,
0.0480413996,
0.7576674223,
-0.8728939891,
0.3068265021,
0.0997486562,
0.2579683065,
0.4513351619,
-0.3119404018,
0.2827902138,
-0.0570136271,
-0.6573260427,
-0.5151972771,
0.279428184,
-0.7736232281,
-0.3011398315,
1.0010123253,
-0.1573572159,
-0.1497138888,
-0.3530988097,
-0.5798571706,
-0.0168218669,
-0.5779861808,
0.92885077,
0.3935295343,
-0.5598291159,
-0.2926959097,
-0.3918192983,
0.4609503746,
0.5237407088,
-0.7578439116,
0.1496022046,
0.5288331509,
0.4908499122,
0.0394078307,
1.0789138079,
0.4113280475,
0.5150284767,
-0.3634839952,
0.0378211178,
-0.0026986853,
-0.6863481402,
-0.839286983,
-0.0120722903,
0.2984798849,
-0.0621580295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14919v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14919v2 | Frugal Prompting for Dialog Models | 2023-05-24T09:06:49 | 2023-11-05T06:05:19 | Bishal Santra, Sakya Basak, Abhinandan De, Manish Gupta, Pawan Goyal | cs.CL | cs.CL | The use of large language models (LLMs) in natural language processing (NLP)
tasks is rapidly increasing, leading to changes in how researchers approach
problems in the field. To fully utilize these models' abilities, a better
understanding of their behavior for different input protocols is required. With
LLMs, users can directly interact with the models through a text-based
interface to define and solve various tasks. Hence, understanding the
conversational abilities of these LLMs, which may not have been specifically
trained for dialog modeling, is also important. This study examines different
approaches for building dialog systems using LLMs by considering various
aspects of the prompt. As part of prompt tuning, we experiment with various
ways of providing instructions, exemplars, current query and additional
context. The research also analyzes the representations of dialog history that
have the optimal usable-information density. Based on the findings, the paper
suggests more compact ways of providing dialog history information while
ensuring good performance and reducing model's inference-API costs. The
research contributes to a better understanding of how LLMs can be effectively
used for building interactive systems. | [
-0.5391829014,
-0.826177299,
0.7736225128,
0.2197418213,
-0.2210494578,
-0.2981583178,
-0.2999746799,
-0.1538151354,
-0.1102640331,
0.5937357545,
-0.9011312723,
-0.153165102,
-0.0241557565,
0.4107476473,
-0.0156987328,
0.7925806642,
0.1764376312,
0.0169314295,
-0.3097006977,
0.0658274367,
-0.9106185436,
-0.4171617329,
-0.8708150983,
-0.3105694652,
0.6123725176,
0.4095531702,
0.7962427735,
0.401686728,
-0.1559757888,
0.2809159756,
-0.2821154892,
0.4620236754,
-0.3156913221,
0.3653953373,
0.065743871,
-0.5449811816,
-0.2423332036,
-0.0898478702,
0.3151475191,
0.6828526855,
-0.1616656184,
0.0915209129,
0.2684702575,
0.3645778,
-0.3465506434,
0.1890309602,
-0.5345516205,
0.0673388913,
0.1783456653,
-0.7168135047,
-0.7094305754,
-0.325247854,
0.312752068,
-0.6971600652,
0.0924077854,
0.274687618,
0.6613230109,
0.2362898886,
-0.2084085643,
-0.706517756,
-0.5553947091,
0.8291298151,
-0.7887080908,
0.322350502,
0.5091667771,
0.1370294243,
-0.4697679579,
-0.1869158149,
-0.3277096748,
-0.6260166764,
-0.1706982702,
-0.1937870979,
-0.2604711652,
0.1883413196,
0.4546781182,
0.2579890192,
-0.3322203457,
0.3135496378,
0.0833299235,
-0.0948022902,
0.2831729054,
0.444381386,
0.1628859341,
-0.4001150727,
-0.3844697773,
0.0809999406,
-0.786907196,
0.2318430096,
0.2378319204,
0.5961972475,
-0.112672925,
0.5909647942,
-0.2139573544,
1.0469927788,
0.2098108232,
-0.2031824887,
-0.2782413661,
-0.4342037141,
-0.2831784785,
-0.1816615015,
0.5833803415,
0.6229192019,
0.4067304134,
0.0472200848,
-0.4207988083,
-0.4592266679,
0.1527974755,
-0.7165836096,
0.1343291253,
0.2076434046,
-0.4698856473,
-0.0685348511,
-0.5307530165,
-0.6824496388,
-0.5331096053,
-0.6531096697,
0.243266046,
-0.426279217,
0.1196984202,
0.0386318192,
-0.0405863822,
0.013953845,
0.6967418194,
-1.002390027,
0.0304154269,
0.4311777055,
0.9858936667,
0.1816266924,
0.2026267052,
-0.745154798,
-0.0059261443,
-0.15633367,
0.707608521,
-0.579421401,
-0.7681794763,
0.2497275025,
-0.1364695877,
0.0472069383,
-0.5142540336,
0.5857432485,
-0.4974091649,
0.3499055505,
-0.5563845038,
-0.6607757807,
-0.165128231,
0.0092145195,
-0.4923786223,
0.7713697553,
0.0514817126,
-0.6048280597,
0.2520421445,
-0.640953958,
-0.1771559864,
0.3146597445,
-0.0701584816,
0.2877767682,
0.3477565348,
0.4788260758,
0.8477844,
-0.5001556277,
0.4714554846,
-0.125387162,
-0.2964950502,
0.318443805,
-0.6146591306,
0.763563633,
0.5618293881,
0.1525486559,
-0.0220813639,
-0.4971106946,
-0.364320606,
-0.011988407,
-0.6072602868,
-0.3266347349,
0.0757304356,
-0.3056399822,
-0.1719050854,
0.2801235616,
-0.1737848073,
0.2411623448,
-0.4411702752,
0.4322731197,
0.9104164839,
-0.0292265844,
0.4567988515,
-0.5493868589,
0.6885681152,
-0.3757639825,
0.0671999976,
-0.7427903414,
-0.3993826509,
-0.6845027208,
-0.2017378062,
0.175309673,
0.6605013609,
-0.7145164013,
0.3414412439,
0.0983021259,
-0.0933767781,
-0.1174219921,
0.2430685461,
-0.0084321573,
0.6257426143,
-0.0080703925,
0.3361415863,
-0.4337387681,
-0.7280994058,
-0.0759540498,
-0.3204006553,
-0.4502501786,
0.778526485,
0.0197287928,
0.1631722152,
1.1000250578,
-0.5753989816,
0.2256542742,
-0.4759428203,
0.0492660999,
0.4224448502,
0.1309942305,
0.5642213225,
-0.4898420274,
-0.3626638949,
-0.1518787146,
-0.4542815387,
-0.5544540286,
-0.3649120629,
0.1176553145,
0.3103242517,
0.5103779435,
-0.7614626288,
0.1358956099,
0.5359561443,
-0.1720438749,
0.5728311539,
-0.1551446319,
0.0836049914,
-0.8946992159,
0.0263006426,
0.1686984003,
-0.2580225766,
-0.6766675711,
-0.1994040757,
-0.2349766642,
-0.2510595918,
-0.2692498267,
0.8613577485,
-0.5543688536,
0.1502917856,
-0.1255733967,
0.2555373609,
0.0693043992,
0.5192753673,
0.0313322544,
1.0832508802,
0.2677821517,
-0.8888269067,
0.1762524247,
0.2251831293,
-0.2549467087,
0.5684501529,
-0.802085042,
0.0110926535,
-0.2071878314,
0.2150194794,
-1.0306785107,
-0.331202507,
0.2884366214,
-0.3052991927,
0.2293639332,
-0.2857559919,
-0.4897430241,
-0.2162137926,
-0.1783331037,
-0.1007053033,
0.5162833333,
-0.6059789062,
0.7613920569,
0.1469596177,
-0.6398075819,
-0.2573425472,
-0.2641296983,
0.0560373403,
-0.4365607798,
-0.7185787559,
0.0120753292,
-0.2899809182,
-0.2039016485,
-0.4867771268,
-0.0536893941,
0.0951205194,
0.1551739275,
0.2418936938,
0.4366748035,
-0.2861066759,
0.4187923372,
-0.1910491586,
0.0122392792,
-0.060455773,
-0.0165238995,
0.7645606399,
0.1168386266,
-0.0882420093,
-0.7491416335,
0.5056934953,
0.418122381,
0.2077042162,
0.6453368068,
0.0452047512,
-0.1521752328,
-0.153522715,
-0.8359962106,
-0.4310407043,
-0.5394638181,
-0.1452305466,
-0.1963186413,
-1.2241592407,
0.434807688,
-0.2407451719,
0.4343781173,
-0.0024467842,
0.6328288317,
-0.1143022701,
1.1152614355,
0.4425650239,
0.1148284003,
0.785956502,
0.2899771333,
0.2537196577,
-0.6769223213,
-0.2423494458,
-0.7667689323,
0.0836571604,
-0.2324133515,
-0.4748043716,
0.3405908942,
0.1474011242,
-0.0791886374,
0.0663235262,
-0.257676214,
0.267418772,
0.4721819758,
0.0090533029,
0.3067641258,
0.1547702253,
-0.2285001874,
-0.003637169,
-0.9669351578,
-0.9008818865,
0.7022687197,
0.4591200948,
0.945851028,
-0.1937690079,
0.2821549177,
0.2362458408,
0.0352222025,
-0.9222611785,
0.7053838372,
0.0397273228,
-0.3246410489,
-0.2932630777,
-0.4500781298,
-1.0419976711,
0.1066252366,
-0.2129723579,
-1.0235526562,
0.0414631031,
0.5908219814,
-0.7947132587,
-0.0617265776,
-0.8154720068,
0.4702432156,
-0.1050007418,
-0.1343204528,
-0.1013541892,
-0.2888351083,
0.2145086378,
0.2304202765,
0.1941907257,
-0.1681820899,
-0.0281638131,
0.3804333508,
-0.492506355,
1.0897239447,
-0.2339185178,
-0.2203064561,
0.1953673363,
0.1081700921,
0.6918029785,
0.2771036327,
-0.116601713,
-0.2226657122,
-0.1688038856,
-0.0490216799,
-0.6232204437,
0.6917907,
-0.3997794986,
-0.9254863858,
-0.0875421166,
-0.7259251475,
-0.4566344619,
-0.0835576206,
0.0891815349,
0.8292378187,
-0.0369746052,
0.1164297983,
0.9214303493,
-0.5062046051,
0.4372920692,
0.4502090812,
-0.2739153206,
-0.0441762693,
0.3851903677,
0.0509308204,
0.2723967135,
0.3841971159,
0.459215194,
-0.3312904537,
-0.568431735,
-0.5698745847,
0.3230002224,
-0.5762528777,
-0.2755973339,
-0.8491492271,
0.1509646624,
-0.3103259802,
-0.4088965058,
0.110801436,
-0.2940273881,
-0.7014381886,
-0.0313352644,
0.7177008986,
0.6122428775,
0.0905790851,
0.5392064452,
-0.9009760022,
0.183149606,
0.4488280714,
0.1752880365,
0.3673167527,
-0.3884680271,
-0.050206285,
0.0604439005,
-0.0280895233,
-0.8184301853,
0.2669737637,
-0.0564734079,
0.6886265278,
0.4059375525,
0.1498815119,
0.4968239069,
-0.4513904452,
1.0467698574,
0.0610015541,
-0.7685793638,
0.601700902,
-0.658362031,
0.5228785276,
0.4628819227,
0.3841265142,
-0.6155900359,
-0.1921189129,
-0.1944542527,
-0.8549233675,
0.8627517223,
-0.0472614504,
0.4564994276,
-0.1131098047,
0.4968067706,
0.2458486408,
0.2669465244,
-0.3899526894,
0.0408945195,
0.1394452155,
-0.0698021576,
0.1451239586,
-0.4620787501,
-0.0215611439,
0.1093924493,
0.5516985059,
-0.2194914818,
0.2250235975,
0.1666166782,
-0.0646314174,
0.1843550801,
0.3935293257,
0.6660106182,
0.4590327144,
-0.1975271553,
-0.1734656841,
0.3616968095,
0.0481987074,
-0.032619182,
-0.1340492964,
-0.2510969937,
0.0209729113,
0.0531256273,
1.1421376467,
0.277485162,
-0.9258423448,
0.2774295807,
-0.2111778557,
0.0542721525,
-0.0313162655,
0.2059095055,
0.3356721401,
0.2695935667,
0.2444938272,
-0.2780467868,
0.1906057149,
-0.48091048,
-0.2883996069,
0.6473280787,
-0.2059996426,
-0.0343973301,
0.3070126176,
0.5752091408,
-0.6029247046,
0.6021701694,
0.0872441009,
-0.1701116413,
0.1608528942,
0.4839073718,
0.6205980778,
-0.1184879839,
0.3912739158,
0.2765449584,
0.0252156183,
-0.1112202853,
0.0960980579,
-0.5030361414,
-0.597823143,
-0.5716525912,
-0.6039506197,
-0.476916641,
0.1522636861,
-0.4319143891,
0.2584158182,
-0.5459602475,
-0.3180742562,
-0.1377346963,
-0.1940640509,
-0.710028708,
-0.0684642792,
0.129148826,
1.1279027462,
-0.5668629408,
0.1149443984,
0.4107414782,
-0.0912964866,
-0.8838323355,
-0.1734898984,
0.1723363698,
-0.7764093876,
0.527109921,
0.0812039524,
-0.2575168908,
-0.1724285632,
-0.6773662567,
-0.5012311935,
0.7563939691,
0.436396867,
-0.6926110983,
-0.3568837047,
-0.2183178961,
0.339816004,
-0.4697778523,
0.2342652529,
0.4723624885,
0.4793942571,
0.2294023037,
-0.7891930342,
0.2474557459,
-0.0380205736,
0.1755959392,
0.1484032124,
-0.5660322309,
0.6581460834,
-0.0774183497,
-0.4784162641,
0.4161522388,
0.430937767,
0.452291429,
0.2724207938,
0.7227475643,
0.0054367394,
0.8578335643,
-0.0221756622,
1.1983187199,
-0.0652348995,
-0.0878084898,
0.9091216326,
-0.3262089193,
0.5608055592,
0.6045510173,
-0.0904459283,
0.2319869697,
0.6476825476,
0.1220432967,
0.2287862748,
0.1762440354,
-0.3587581217,
-0.3882198334,
-0.5168763399,
-0.0892949328,
0.1577523351,
0.5897818804,
-0.2650790215,
-0.3008025885,
0.037373025,
0.2784087062,
-0.1334583908,
-0.2791600525,
0.8804729581,
0.1709610522,
-0.9266178608,
0.4425320327,
-0.2232061923,
0.7289887071,
-0.7051999569,
0.0105216959,
-0.3456995785,
-0.4658434987,
-0.016239712,
-0.5651224256,
-0.0269006882,
0.2218529433,
-0.2932468057,
-0.5157790184,
0.5704753399,
-0.10578686,
-0.2298618704,
-0.0658146963,
0.5044725537,
0.1555268019,
0.1404694468,
-0.4843413532,
0.1001225114,
0.1737601757,
-0.3665382564,
0.2711126506,
0.4036803246,
-0.0100851087,
0.7804211974,
0.7473323345,
0.0570986271,
-0.1170447767,
0.2453742325,
0.7115557194,
-0.6248133183,
-0.4691375196,
-0.7493915558,
0.5234771371,
-0.1001472175,
-0.3255904913,
0.6302009821,
0.0510463417,
0.3361789286,
0.0399749726,
0.7319790721,
0.1881006062,
0.6623190641,
-0.9856550694,
0.1729260832,
-0.4848976731,
0.5693714619,
-0.059407182,
-0.7841500044,
-0.0957003087,
0.6127558351,
-0.1014631763,
0.1245254576,
0.2806468308,
0.9113708138,
0.2698014677,
0.4174742103,
0.2797538042,
-0.0028545463,
0.2379665226,
0.2217778265,
1.1410849094,
0.3699011207,
0.3256933093,
0.0744034275,
-0.2599186897,
-0.6237187982,
-1.0689918995,
-1.0401203632,
-0.4201339483,
-0.0156654231,
-0.0863856897,
0.0056590838,
1.2005519867,
0.5482376814,
-0.5600363016,
-0.3148593903,
0.0932523012,
0.1447088122,
0.1381262541,
-0.2553990483,
-0.0696370751,
-0.5849316716,
-0.7082538605,
0.6082434058,
0.4270797968,
0.256886363,
-0.2149011493,
0.0862439945,
-0.0218673274,
0.5071461797,
0.6559488177,
0.2066105902,
-0.8497315645,
-0.3784028888,
0.2426904142,
0.1178797111,
0.034392789,
1.2070065737,
-0.7108552456,
0.4288117886,
0.7207677364,
0.521655798,
0.092425175,
0.0728125125,
1.0518823862,
-0.6309046745,
0.0222742986,
0.1290032417,
0.421533674,
0.5225222707,
-0.6712526679,
0.2504713833,
-0.3713355064,
-0.7458065748,
-0.8639242053,
0.3308845162,
-0.8961564898,
-0.3377970457,
1.0907175541,
-0.0440143719,
0.0823036358,
-0.3421525061,
-0.6396124363,
0.0907570496,
-0.8576537967,
0.4480758905,
0.9323065877,
-0.4966735244,
-0.3487235904,
-0.7584332824,
0.5497626066,
0.4185315967,
-0.4964163005,
0.448818922,
0.8335436583,
0.1195526272,
0.0474988893,
0.7323942184,
0.2466576397,
0.0524082258,
-0.1968118548,
-0.4602302015,
0.0030230219,
-0.2513252497,
-0.393134892,
0.2253231704,
0.3113678992,
0.2453797162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14917v1 | Structural Ambiguity and its Disambiguation in Language Model Based Parsers: the Case of Dutch Clause Relativization | 2023-05-24T09:04:18 | 2023-05-24T09:04:18 | Gijs Wijnholds, Michael Moortgat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper addresses structural ambiguity in Dutch relative clauses. By
investigating the task of disambiguation by grounding, we study how the
presence of a prior sentence can resolve relative clause ambiguities. We apply
this method to two parsing architectures in an attempt to demystify the parsing
and language model components of two present-day neural parsers. Results show
that a neurosymbolic parser, based on proof nets, is more open to data bias
correction than an approach based on universal dependencies, although both
setups suffer from a comparable initial data bias. | [
-0.0631228387,
-1.0047975779,
0.6659700274,
0.2344764173,
-0.1433832794,
-0.0273377094,
-0.0846194997,
-0.5116311908,
0.2377400249,
0.2523444593,
-0.4163891971,
-0.2562531531,
-0.7264236808,
0.0407268517,
-0.1054350287,
0.4006281197,
-0.1573800743,
0.3335300684,
-0.2626106143,
-0.2947567701,
-0.4175486863,
-0.8919162154,
-0.3998425305,
-0.5635446906,
0.2536298931,
0.1381849945,
1.1542049646,
0.5954982638,
0.3338367641,
0.3321149647,
-0.7839514017,
0.0179616138,
0.2636948526,
0.3976356089,
-0.5108900666,
-0.9603796601,
-0.4345505238,
-0.1572492719,
0.3752495348,
1.3444507122,
0.0125261433,
0.0329191349,
-0.1929702163,
1.0416715145,
-0.6966474652,
0.1215456128,
-0.5119281411,
0.1773439795,
-0.1196073666,
-0.1549731493,
-0.4195773304,
-0.1171416715,
-0.0245079827,
-0.3245531619,
0.2633502185,
-0.0130630145,
1.2489439249,
0.3688452244,
-0.541347146,
-0.0701545179,
-0.3922713697,
0.5305613279,
-0.619586885,
0.4573982656,
0.5358675122,
0.3358290792,
-0.4118311107,
-0.5547636747,
-0.3570342958,
-0.1543608606,
-0.2708034515,
-0.2899601758,
-0.2289788127,
0.1603517383,
0.5734711885,
0.4365469813,
-0.5002719164,
-0.183537811,
-0.3881866336,
-0.1140287295,
0.1297592521,
-0.0867141113,
0.2454294264,
-0.6364381909,
-0.0023690446,
0.123687692,
-0.8635081053,
0.132870838,
0.7127562165,
0.368404001,
-0.0583958961,
0.706314981,
-0.4617734253,
1.107993722,
0.2840499282,
0.3386261463,
0.4525325894,
0.0592371374,
-0.2716257274,
0.3313197196,
0.0235791653,
0.4238726795,
0.4101616144,
-0.0572423227,
-0.0607461594,
0.2969307601,
0.3228819966,
-0.1295694411,
-0.2345239967,
0.3253389597,
-0.6317468286,
-0.2077934593,
-0.0027230915,
-0.2847615182,
-0.1138342544,
-0.7499389648,
0.0591438301,
-0.3330172896,
-0.3178310096,
0.4728201926,
-0.2372708172,
0.0781016126,
0.1402039528,
-0.8220012188,
0.1681251824,
0.6680052876,
0.6631138921,
0.581964612,
0.0607901961,
-0.138571322,
0.2096439749,
-0.3685265481,
0.6582553387,
-0.6518580914,
0.1626301259,
-0.0686215609,
0.1706219167,
0.2378478795,
-0.6114575267,
0.3274585605,
-0.6669576168,
0.3287239671,
-0.457867831,
-0.3502658606,
-0.3252251744,
0.4129920006,
-0.5238322616,
0.7182223797,
0.1310347617,
-1.0240197182,
0.4926302135,
-0.2718225121,
-0.4019550681,
-0.3937703073,
-0.4993157983,
-0.1302178353,
0.4495393932,
0.2550575137,
0.2034163177,
-0.0610803738,
0.8257066607,
-0.3331717849,
-0.3371231556,
-0.0469574593,
-0.3477493823,
1.2465360165,
0.2664489448,
-0.2554858029,
0.0137025528,
-1.0185233355,
-0.1005297825,
0.1020575315,
-0.2174120545,
-0.7398359179,
0.2179797888,
-0.4763895571,
0.3692701161,
0.1575638801,
-0.3842021823,
0.3351339996,
-0.7753333449,
0.5942282081,
0.616543293,
-0.0911560059,
0.3163549304,
0.091015704,
0.3085745573,
0.5259513259,
-0.0414815545,
-0.2975390553,
-0.4246556461,
-0.9336807132,
0.3813912272,
0.6179897785,
0.6221984029,
-0.6872338057,
0.6450505257,
-0.1725260466,
0.0636160523,
-0.2574179471,
-0.4255740345,
0.408408314,
0.6087687016,
0.4225318432,
0.1517034471,
-0.950381875,
-1.4994961023,
-0.1295175105,
-0.4365804493,
-0.1475054622,
-0.2072094381,
0.3395006955,
0.1588611305,
1.0220783949,
-0.5014646649,
0.1515643746,
0.0918909758,
0.1383370906,
0.5443669558,
0.613894701,
0.6318062544,
-0.9012343287,
-0.2114502788,
-0.1499797702,
-1.0254951715,
-0.0977446213,
-0.0187778734,
0.0582374334,
-0.0359840952,
0.8515886068,
-0.562174201,
0.3799429834,
0.277549684,
-0.3268669248,
0.4260623455,
-0.1857310236,
-0.0269594193,
-0.9892289042,
-0.0444450304,
-0.1335946172,
-0.397570014,
-0.4662432969,
0.0953047648,
0.2736642957,
0.2713027894,
-0.4248118401,
-0.0795753449,
-0.8340733051,
-0.0938320681,
-0.30161798,
0.0267008394,
0.1798682213,
0.4355516434,
-0.0212887041,
0.4836579263,
0.8443799615,
-0.4858781993,
0.1742847562,
0.3131402731,
-0.1310293525,
0.5864473581,
-0.7852348089,
-0.1180296689,
-0.6570932269,
0.2718981802,
-0.9605145454,
0.023208132,
0.6190050244,
-0.3698209226,
0.3739156127,
-0.607088685,
-0.3033982515,
-0.3320328593,
0.0724552125,
0.5944943428,
0.1478815228,
-0.6221930981,
0.4074002504,
0.1676264405,
0.1428539604,
-0.9609801173,
-1.0412718058,
0.1953154951,
-0.2376848906,
-0.947637558,
0.4540973902,
0.4710044265,
-0.7069352269,
0.085365802,
-0.7055255175,
-0.087450102,
0.0121808676,
0.3490700722,
-0.0062436853,
-0.5774875879,
0.2314766198,
0.2999154627,
-0.3613634706,
0.2665822208,
-0.2295832634,
0.3891727328,
-0.0570407026,
-0.3902615011,
-0.1098977923,
0.4104042053,
0.1278346181,
0.0920376554,
0.6191068292,
-0.3492165506,
-0.4725612402,
0.0510936119,
-0.5424076319,
-0.0759935305,
-0.5083867311,
0.0962672234,
-0.9490479827,
-0.8281657696,
0.7476225495,
-0.0380824357,
-0.3587004542,
0.4141176045,
0.2330222577,
0.0162159391,
0.93840909,
0.5176374912,
0.2203009725,
0.2549130917,
0.1893427372,
0.2019007057,
-0.6903162599,
0.0639255121,
-0.7130079865,
-0.3253083825,
-0.4734994471,
-0.1788282841,
-0.1290205121,
0.3860562742,
-0.1679314226,
0.5035898685,
-0.494489938,
0.8078123927,
0.285235852,
0.1938983351,
0.1151670069,
0.0316986293,
-0.4080518484,
-0.1852015257,
-0.5678179264,
-0.7175396085,
0.8165047169,
0.2865889072,
0.329334259,
0.244739145,
0.2623904049,
0.050244879,
-0.1199405566,
-0.4092227221,
0.2793910801,
-0.2016634494,
-0.7615635395,
0.026158208,
-0.3281732202,
-0.880438745,
0.7877278328,
0.1462069005,
-0.9279842973,
0.7609291077,
0.1967485845,
-0.2135440111,
0.2713895738,
-0.8425608277,
0.7880115509,
0.086504437,
-0.2966367602,
0.0857320428,
-1.1185631752,
0.4669326842,
0.3780835569,
0.123178713,
-0.0729855523,
0.2838799655,
0.3573175073,
-0.3346997499,
0.861790359,
-0.2531275451,
-0.1962935925,
0.205536902,
0.2200440168,
0.4834825099,
-0.0168567114,
-0.3277401924,
0.4660843909,
-0.0700862408,
-0.5581771731,
-0.8148142695,
0.4670163393,
-0.4229385555,
-0.953137219,
-0.5091712475,
-0.2349950224,
-0.4391950369,
0.1538051516,
0.0510099791,
0.253018707,
0.1425484717,
0.2141504437,
0.6527609229,
-0.0451692753,
0.334322989,
0.5281536579,
-0.0650707632,
0.0329023749,
0.2618340552,
0.1135304272,
0.0677326694,
0.6491355896,
-0.0826454833,
-0.0716808662,
-0.5254141092,
-0.1668041199,
0.1963657588,
-1.1010243893,
-0.0950209126,
-0.7229459882,
-0.0314688757,
-0.3521933854,
-0.2103652209,
-0.25543648,
-0.8113563657,
0.0150597449,
-0.439032793,
-0.090702042,
0.4469285607,
-0.1083113849,
0.4390668273,
-0.4752499461,
0.3586709499,
-0.2367496789,
0.3197817504,
-0.2765589654,
-0.3232059479,
-0.0262635443,
0.2570827305,
-0.0419458598,
-1.3766764402,
-0.116348736,
-0.3606190979,
0.607478857,
0.2064978629,
-0.1203060895,
0.789265573,
-0.5817562938,
0.8155658245,
0.1744311005,
-1.1742199659,
0.7935782075,
-0.272854656,
0.2302271277,
0.551194787,
0.2705816627,
-0.5153035522,
-0.3710798919,
-0.7688788176,
-1.0768784285,
0.7238525152,
0.0339514315,
0.0134896468,
-0.1947426349,
0.8144032955,
-0.1056426689,
0.227717638,
-0.8591403365,
-0.5881037116,
-0.2017762512,
0.1738162935,
0.2136100978,
-0.6200605035,
-0.0741327703,
-0.2776254416,
0.4395062327,
-0.0794142336,
0.0106352186,
0.2865698338,
-0.3220564127,
-0.1056631953,
0.1669054627,
0.5198896527,
0.9513713717,
-0.2390413433,
0.5745138526,
-0.0304213464,
0.0190447103,
0.3674989641,
-0.2966767848,
-0.2442470491,
0.3238579929,
0.285464108,
0.7254437208,
0.2585059702,
-0.2232706249,
0.4389863014,
0.2212074995,
-0.286806494,
-0.1833799183,
-0.1066182777,
0.0563638061,
0.3080558479,
-0.0073140576,
0.367043823,
0.1411578357,
-0.2234418988,
0.4208273292,
0.1381265819,
-0.2620159388,
-0.1835343987,
0.6868228912,
-0.2168338448,
-0.0858677179,
0.5206714869,
0.1063356325,
-0.4006320536,
0.6940656304,
0.4466751218,
0.7389822602,
-0.189391464,
0.082295008,
0.1705610752,
0.5636252761,
-0.1103718579,
0.353274256,
-0.0412982665,
-0.9175297022,
-0.6971179247,
-0.2625142634,
-0.2022631019,
-0.0458295941,
-0.7839760184,
0.2403528392,
-0.2905685306,
-0.1484325975,
0.378690958,
-0.5303156972,
-0.0601907857,
0.2783201933,
-0.0823279768,
0.7896853089,
-0.9803213477,
1.0428158045,
1.0999926329,
-0.6775883436,
-0.5486778021,
0.0912515894,
-0.006724318,
-0.4867201149,
1.1405078173,
0.067009598,
0.0372184142,
-0.5694829226,
-0.4300554395,
-0.8505795002,
0.5009274483,
0.7899009585,
-0.4953483641,
-0.2370419353,
0.1950517744,
0.6002579331,
-0.0657806918,
0.1747934222,
0.407984823,
0.6584631205,
0.0263432115,
-0.5682342052,
0.1764066517,
-0.4069717228,
0.113154985,
0.3606075644,
-0.3788763583,
1.1011301279,
0.4875922203,
-0.0107359057,
-0.4349744022,
0.8622157574,
0.0383777469,
0.0046793604,
0.5083734393,
0.5051025152,
0.7268691659,
-0.1798543185,
0.813131392,
-0.341697067,
0.2499457747,
1.4341039658,
-0.2597266138,
0.5278638601,
0.8456504941,
-0.3242480457,
0.596363008,
0.6391841769,
0.230252251,
0.3269450366,
0.5701649189,
0.0656125769,
-0.3713152111,
0.3238402307,
-0.6059755683,
0.3983782232,
0.3400137424,
-0.4197384119,
-0.8172209859,
-0.195862636,
0.0885838047,
0.3866989315,
0.0434760749,
0.2263343781,
0.0009673561,
-0.5192395449,
0.5476434231,
0.456177175,
0.4003325701,
-0.6107916236,
-0.183111012,
-0.225472942,
0.1323653609,
-0.3348497748,
-0.4153524339,
0.963470459,
-0.3153761923,
-0.6548737884,
-0.370969981,
0.5893729925,
-0.106552124,
-0.1644706726,
0.2410764545,
0.5537246466,
0.0367393047,
-0.2768083513,
-0.8014614582,
0.0345062204,
0.1900374591,
-0.4099822044,
0.2363096625,
0.5893121362,
-0.3582089245,
0.6098499298,
0.3932246268,
-0.0144401705,
0.223113969,
0.0225105379,
0.9059393406,
-0.8305697441,
-0.7114332914,
-0.955260396,
0.4985980093,
0.0242887214,
-0.2855874002,
0.7336546779,
0.5617441535,
0.8125503659,
-0.0118476376,
0.3374445438,
-0.1904798895,
0.197299391,
-0.7168437839,
0.240697816,
-0.496581018,
0.4104545116,
-0.1483742595,
-1.1407198906,
-0.798257947,
0.9363157153,
-0.6166234612,
-0.0979910567,
0.966535449,
0.8091785908,
-0.2814198732,
0.2873184383,
0.3470842838,
0.4004060626,
0.1880690008,
0.2822434008,
0.9349989891,
-0.5113815069,
-0.1005484611,
-0.3616545796,
-0.0225442704,
0.056531772,
-1.0146311522,
-0.6633552313,
-0.4851450026,
-0.4642173648,
-0.3410137892,
0.5626701713,
0.846901834,
0.6598485112,
-0.8972833157,
-0.1081396118,
-0.4865355492,
0.4272008836,
-0.3550248742,
-0.2457427979,
0.4038241804,
-0.5920376778,
-0.5692091584,
0.7048194408,
0.1581439674,
-0.0302010402,
-0.1516058147,
0.3431750536,
-0.5369725823,
-0.0364880189,
0.3633159697,
0.0338372551,
-0.717797935,
-0.4699940383,
-0.4733178616,
-0.0367767662,
0.4333578348,
0.9266827106,
-0.7396222949,
0.1815348119,
0.622492671,
0.3835947812,
0.2266533375,
0.0579445697,
0.635928154,
-1.1437646151,
0.6886234283,
-0.1551571935,
0.6527258158,
0.1581121832,
-0.5139867067,
0.6516349316,
0.2833197415,
-0.1645533592,
-0.850510478,
0.4218928218,
-0.8256164789,
-0.7645698786,
0.8256379962,
-0.1609931886,
-0.4246973693,
-0.452218473,
-0.1782646924,
0.1571213007,
0.0625057518,
0.5383289456,
1.0551047325,
0.1235121638,
-0.0052693961,
-0.3976220191,
0.1692714542,
0.7192433476,
-0.2740175426,
0.1009183154,
0.8612381816,
0.2247666419,
0.3459236026,
0.2644668221,
-0.1873958707,
0.040866252,
0.3877369761,
0.1549589783,
-0.1655684412,
-0.3777601123,
-0.5331443548,
0.6765260696,
-0.1209864318,
-0.2770744264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14913v1 | CoLaDa: A Collaborative Label Denoising Framework for Cross-lingual Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-24T09:03:01 | 2023-05-24T09:03:01 | Tingting Ma, Qianhui Wu, Huiqiang Jiang, Börje F. Karlsson, Tiejun Zhao, Chin-Yew Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual named entity recognition (NER) aims to train an NER system that
generalizes well to a target language by leveraging labeled data in a given
source language. Previous work alleviates the data scarcity problem by
translating source-language labeled data or performing knowledge distillation
on target-language unlabeled data. However, these methods may suffer from label
noise due to the automatic labeling process. In this paper, we propose CoLaDa,
a Collaborative Label Denoising Framework, to address this problem.
Specifically, we first explore a model-collaboration-based denoising scheme
that enables models trained on different data sources to collaboratively
denoise pseudo labels used by each other. We then present an
instance-collaboration-based strategy that considers the label consistency of
each token's neighborhood in the representation space for denoising.
Experiments on different benchmark datasets show that the proposed CoLaDa
achieves superior results compared to previous methods, especially when
generalizing to distant languages. | [
-0.5926098824,
-0.5016003251,
0.0597363375,
0.1595317572,
-0.1203084737,
0.3866355419,
-0.2228964418,
-0.5314708352,
0.5916959047,
0.3866634071,
-0.2775816917,
-0.4430141747,
-0.6350899339,
0.4636568129,
-0.3910167515,
1.0442414284,
-0.037498612,
0.1856628507,
-0.3130397797,
-0.1793914139,
-0.4960906506,
-0.412115097,
-0.8265644908,
-0.4713586271,
0.5328940749,
0.3054497838,
0.4581478536,
0.2915634811,
0.2242846936,
0.2732477486,
-0.136649251,
0.1811672002,
-0.840105176,
0.1461407095,
-0.0965236574,
-0.3368496299,
-0.4682553113,
-0.1293603033,
0.4746187627,
1.0650416613,
-0.1818910986,
-0.2743257284,
-0.051015798,
0.3793615699,
-0.5668587685,
0.2953581214,
-0.4334895909,
0.0304401387,
0.0558079146,
0.2880937159,
-0.4744983315,
-0.371537149,
0.2765177786,
-0.994799614,
0.2580891252,
0.3119885027,
1.1315329075,
0.236831978,
-0.0597084947,
-0.4451357424,
-0.6205434203,
0.8230167627,
-0.1395990551,
0.7438041568,
0.4221079051,
-0.1328592002,
-0.1870785654,
-0.846812129,
-0.4594356418,
0.134119153,
-0.0925033092,
0.0836501643,
-0.5052499175,
0.02463682,
-0.1202255338,
0.2889226377,
-0.3789672256,
0.1409714222,
-0.4552085102,
-0.2117820978,
0.403906405,
-0.4190245569,
0.4819755554,
0.0183869172,
-0.6669558883,
0.0796485022,
-0.6995391846,
-0.4126945138,
0.0631129444,
0.2185981274,
-0.0372540243,
0.0481699631,
-0.1772748679,
0.4123606384,
0.3757074475,
0.0293149296,
0.417512238,
-0.2315831631,
-0.46566239,
0.5001609921,
0.6876341701,
0.2673798203,
-0.0005691328,
-1.0446329117,
-0.0520200916,
0.0080932984,
-0.2054544538,
-0.8305587769,
-0.7626586556,
-0.055258844,
-0.0707443729,
-0.0190954823,
-0.0948059708,
-0.7786155939,
-0.4425809383,
-0.4116046727,
0.2785950601,
-0.1165517718,
-0.3912624717,
-0.1482861191,
-0.1363292783,
-0.2200676054,
0.1660318077,
-0.9105738401,
0.6440245509,
0.5365466475,
0.6176267266,
-0.3333475888,
-0.3910475671,
-0.8782225251,
0.5765757561,
-0.2781567276,
0.8225463033,
-0.3828592896,
-0.7846642137,
-0.7949357033,
0.0591441654,
-0.0956671387,
-0.8346642852,
-0.0340971388,
-0.7411814332,
0.0341996774,
-0.5509243608,
-0.7309606671,
-0.3065849841,
0.1519192308,
-0.9385924339,
0.7115658522,
0.1963268965,
-0.5975370407,
0.6629580855,
-0.3174521029,
-0.2894669175,
0.5924639106,
-0.215986371,
-0.4195718169,
-0.2191948742,
0.3890627027,
0.0710176304,
-0.6517871022,
0.6771429777,
-0.1091261581,
-0.2163897008,
-0.1681322157,
-0.1572215855,
0.9502192736,
0.2841770947,
-0.2281324714,
-0.1456894875,
-0.7336101532,
-0.0566626601,
-0.1256581694,
-0.1900495142,
-1.0087376833,
-0.5374936461,
0.0570321977,
-0.1980022043,
0.1466946751,
-0.543189168,
0.3330346048,
-0.3680545986,
0.3182653785,
0.3121517003,
0.1758962423,
0.8079665303,
-0.1548978239,
0.4835019112,
0.1067835763,
-0.0925507173,
0.4312877953,
-0.6604242325,
-0.7829136252,
-0.7375587821,
0.6685587764,
0.3430455029,
-0.9365634918,
0.2805936337,
-0.3287276328,
-0.3382983208,
-0.5392708182,
0.5844265819,
0.388147831,
0.7773641348,
0.4976229072,
-0.6552891135,
-0.8930827379,
-0.8101364374,
0.3182673156,
-0.1599250138,
0.0806461945,
0.1636152267,
0.2837993801,
-0.5611993074,
1.3508900404,
-0.2678132951,
-0.5551603436,
-0.1311062574,
0.6938934326,
-0.1026524827,
0.3737913966,
0.5316284299,
-1.1294513941,
-0.7242256999,
-0.089470543,
-0.6732551455,
-0.3567222953,
0.1823814362,
-0.0299508609,
0.2779389024,
0.47859478,
-0.1378700882,
0.1695037633,
0.7858225703,
-0.0311658792,
0.0101748761,
-0.358661592,
0.0815697238,
-1.1807726622,
-0.103463158,
-0.2217949182,
-0.0202057268,
-0.4985912144,
-0.2533348501,
-0.2546264529,
-0.0670299977,
-0.215485692,
0.4830439389,
-0.985096395,
-0.0886050463,
-0.0875557289,
0.1797939092,
0.282115072,
0.2104476541,
0.5306655765,
0.7373670936,
0.6826264262,
-0.4375529885,
0.3313405812,
0.3334364891,
-0.1678390205,
1.0199183226,
-0.6383259892,
0.133029893,
-0.0858098269,
0.0899035931,
-0.7406184077,
0.0627704114,
0.4088746011,
-0.2605086863,
0.2036582083,
-0.4964905381,
-0.3585860133,
0.0822807699,
0.1830464303,
0.3670882583,
0.2030788809,
-0.7826361656,
0.6169387102,
0.9520388842,
-0.1733063906,
-0.3744275272,
-0.7668852806,
0.2774570584,
-0.1203868389,
-0.4295110106,
0.5222805738,
-0.1480297297,
-0.1537390053,
0.321500957,
0.1455933899,
-0.8025507331,
-0.1756415814,
0.5238708258,
0.3955449462,
-0.0524615459,
0.2705287635,
-0.0326364674,
-0.1553885043,
-0.0272055399,
0.0566007197,
0.4018681645,
-0.2361756414,
0.1509343833,
-0.0962410793,
0.3316012919,
0.2469419688,
-0.0634425208,
0.7142141461,
0.7430686355,
-0.4627500176,
-0.3341522813,
-0.3917510808,
-0.0024863966,
-0.457313776,
0.083231248,
-0.4967367947,
-0.7016323805,
0.5776171088,
-0.39569664,
-0.4722096026,
0.0678180382,
0.2884361446,
0.040388044,
0.181395337,
0.7786139846,
-0.4565288723,
0.1248043105,
-0.6482208967,
0.4652541578,
-0.8139981031,
-0.4770407379,
-0.4080806077,
-0.0694582388,
-0.4162527919,
-0.6373961568,
0.2830510437,
0.1870465279,
0.2257150114,
0.739030242,
-0.6613001227,
0.4685275853,
0.719689548,
-0.0427512266,
0.4870258868,
0.1973958313,
-0.0393140055,
-0.2591240108,
-0.9436880946,
0.0917133465,
0.593028605,
-0.1545550078,
0.641320765,
-0.1512214988,
1.249861002,
0.2432106584,
0.3194164634,
-0.6589291692,
0.413271755,
-0.0195678435,
-0.5508052111,
-0.3292590678,
-0.6279901266,
-1.2178938389,
0.1372898519,
-0.1299320608,
-0.5554689765,
0.7359623313,
-0.1338233501,
-0.0988192558,
0.3390366435,
-0.8687323332,
0.6561990976,
-0.0854597166,
-0.4981001914,
-0.0935854465,
-0.3245127499,
0.1393773854,
-0.3266039193,
0.483531028,
0.2392178774,
-0.0814660192,
1.1103378534,
-0.4213866293,
0.8390550017,
-0.0759478137,
-0.2071587592,
0.4783864617,
0.1624714434,
0.4760920405,
0.1482471675,
0.0495384932,
0.5537623167,
-0.150580138,
-0.0074827797,
-0.2237327397,
1.0732085705,
-0.697026372,
-0.0710710809,
-0.4184869826,
-0.746108532,
-0.1302948147,
0.4644047916,
0.301543504,
0.2937141061,
-0.2442897111,
0.2257374376,
0.6271721125,
0.0007808549,
0.4498290122,
0.5144979358,
-0.1131053194,
-0.7844061852,
1.2937580347,
0.4743424058,
-0.1419514418,
0.2722267509,
-0.1397049874,
-0.3114454746,
-0.391623348,
-0.4031837881,
0.2652202249,
-0.6600884199,
-0.0875180289,
-0.6286999583,
0.1168725118,
-0.4159415364,
-0.4577961266,
-0.6656016707,
-0.1910346299,
-0.4537491798,
0.2381030172,
0.2715314627,
0.8802500963,
-0.3054478467,
0.0716052726,
-0.6852779388,
0.6988881826,
0.3267549872,
0.4361056685,
-0.1714106649,
-0.0408734009,
0.0596075282,
0.1445982456,
0.3423883617,
-0.7201189995,
0.6452283263,
0.0115672266,
0.7007852197,
-0.0465514436,
0.5006600618,
0.9349129796,
0.014820205,
0.2820591629,
0.4302819073,
-0.9399219751,
0.2704416811,
0.1370349973,
-0.0711956471,
0.6888097525,
0.5554605722,
-0.5538794398,
-0.1582101732,
-0.5765628815,
-1.0395590067,
0.6257214546,
0.1450500488,
-0.414835304,
-0.0575737394,
-0.1751230508,
0.2436899841,
0.4060746729,
-0.6335306168,
-0.2221625149,
0.0610244684,
0.0061652521,
0.0288140718,
-0.1324121952,
-0.0088768695,
-0.3336860836,
0.6671219468,
0.2441513985,
-0.0646916702,
0.2596356869,
-0.4049162269,
-0.1053680182,
0.2401754856,
-0.1040739492,
0.3708502948,
-0.0856997892,
-0.1004200652,
0.1335983574,
-0.449322015,
0.2256748825,
0.2431132793,
-0.6751938462,
0.2173931301,
0.0464197285,
0.5711971521,
0.2451167852,
-0.3196516633,
0.1988310069,
-0.0255648158,
-0.1071185991,
-0.0547000803,
-0.1767134368,
0.3200861514,
0.0188866127,
0.1695742756,
0.1256626099,
0.3451770246,
-0.3195347786,
0.387552321,
0.194402501,
-0.4204881489,
-0.1610119045,
0.6557719111,
0.3910888135,
-0.2560383081,
0.7729471922,
-0.4188013375,
-0.4619874656,
0.8000445962,
0.3886856437,
0.6549175978,
-0.0644634888,
0.4353132248,
0.4683460593,
0.1044927388,
-0.162202999,
-0.0279216673,
-0.291115135,
-0.6565481424,
-0.0601747707,
-0.5261419415,
-0.7481983304,
0.0406718813,
-0.5629953742,
0.2677341104,
-0.3161294758,
-0.0746928826,
0.0698089525,
0.0379659049,
-0.3866357207,
0.24470222,
0.1184928566,
0.2819958031,
-0.7853836417,
1.0719885826,
0.6462324858,
-0.6097235084,
-0.9204135537,
-0.4744057655,
-0.0848649144,
-0.4083097875,
1.0833812952,
-0.1519788653,
-0.4480109811,
0.2191696912,
-0.0863125399,
-0.8742344975,
0.9479330778,
0.4250845015,
-0.8857620955,
0.050693877,
0.2256557196,
0.6423285604,
-0.3752554357,
-0.0964900777,
0.2440223396,
0.6253427863,
0.3504322469,
-0.9993265867,
-0.1880904585,
-0.0879811719,
-0.1600656658,
0.0735720396,
-0.5085843205,
0.8530165553,
-0.3140611053,
-0.1287501901,
-0.1898947507,
0.4234619737,
0.15065898,
0.5202530026,
0.5850262046,
0.66956985,
1.1991831064,
-0.0700406209,
0.4998739362,
-0.2080271244,
0.4813180864,
1.4844295979,
-0.6005126834,
0.413784951,
0.7601649165,
-0.0433860347,
0.4628576636,
0.2143945843,
-0.4050676227,
0.6735506654,
0.0917483047,
-0.150643453,
-0.1218249127,
-0.5825099945,
-0.3724746108,
0.2764228284,
0.1944962293,
-0.2998766303,
-0.3093484342,
0.2483626157,
0.1147074103,
0.0302355457,
-0.161312893,
0.7519308925,
-0.0231145974,
-0.4687456191,
0.8706415296,
-0.1954092681,
0.8051412702,
-0.2172257602,
-0.079840064,
-0.3832218349,
0.1850154102,
-0.1397392303,
-0.3346164525,
0.142937541,
-0.1594426632,
-0.2789844573,
-0.2861624062,
0.5859443545,
-0.8419621587,
-0.3673746884,
0.7386716008,
0.3721904755,
0.2689803541,
0.1873315424,
-0.4199826419,
0.1961433142,
-0.1603571624,
0.1951473802,
0.22389476,
0.2986544073,
-0.1175882965,
0.7572740316,
0.4528065622,
0.4036957324,
0.1606993526,
0.0992881879,
0.7543571591,
-0.0294003151,
-0.5358417034,
-0.2753248215,
-0.1969220936,
-0.1069801599,
-0.1045243517,
0.6502937675,
0.7695188522,
1.2914170027,
-0.079963997,
0.6782823205,
-0.3334426284,
0.3324636817,
-0.0655102953,
1.0160423517,
-0.4145137668,
0.4997784793,
-0.3235581517,
-0.8360595703,
-0.3906083703,
0.4820461869,
-0.3608987629,
-0.0389698222,
0.4004658163,
0.9603806734,
-0.1696276963,
-0.0824138448,
0.4577612281,
0.2008774132,
0.0744988769,
0.7954288125,
0.4311641157,
-0.6125942469,
0.8768348694,
-0.8048260808,
0.1685261428,
0.0033228265,
-0.6205028892,
-0.9215269685,
-0.6503133774,
-0.7255669832,
0.0812920183,
0.3780198097,
0.72332412,
0.9272924066,
-0.8578026891,
-0.2534500659,
-0.35115394,
0.177822426,
-0.0515949354,
-0.1867465973,
0.383025378,
-0.0153748225,
-1.0302736759,
0.4868306518,
0.0846606493,
0.073755078,
0.0419837162,
-0.459764272,
-0.3177576065,
-0.458766222,
0.2315329611,
0.406110853,
-0.4321111143,
-0.0445545577,
-0.0925843865,
-0.1824433059,
0.1399639845,
0.4424394965,
-1.0758936405,
0.8680880666,
0.4891158938,
0.6303325295,
0.3515385985,
-0.1932305247,
0.4922876954,
-0.7080482841,
0.3147853911,
0.0783532485,
0.331363529,
0.4439144433,
-0.3120585084,
0.7187562585,
0.6110724211,
-0.2753185928,
-0.8077579141,
-0.332757622,
-0.9570013881,
-0.2785660625,
0.8906777501,
-0.4203706086,
-0.1954097748,
-0.4471774697,
-0.1800390631,
0.4532113671,
-0.5001475215,
0.7612500787,
0.6475471854,
0.1550960839,
-0.2837050557,
-0.0171107985,
0.2288086712,
0.1904929429,
-0.6727539897,
0.0182146262,
0.6384158731,
0.4290392697,
0.3225610554,
0.6303177476,
0.2437279373,
0.2699995637,
0.2260915488,
0.268794775,
-0.3710123897,
-0.5827313662,
-0.0681428313,
0.3742369115,
-0.0691868439,
-0.1863542497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14910v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14910v3 | From Shortcuts to Triggers: Backdoor Defense with Denoised PoE | 2023-05-24T08:59:25 | 2024-04-02T23:01:17 | Qin Liu, Fei Wang, Chaowei Xiao, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Language models are often at risk of diverse backdoor attacks, especially
data poisoning. Thus, it is important to investigate defense solutions for
addressing them. Existing backdoor defense methods mainly focus on backdoor
attacks with explicit triggers, leaving a universal defense against various
backdoor attacks with diverse triggers largely unexplored. In this paper, we
propose an end-to-end ensemble-based backdoor defense framework, DPoE (Denoised
Product-of-Experts), which is inspired by the shortcut nature of backdoor
attacks, to defend various backdoor attacks. DPoE consists of two models: a
shallow model that captures the backdoor shortcuts and a main model that is
prevented from learning the backdoor shortcuts. To address the label flip
caused by backdoor attackers, DPoE incorporates a denoising design. Experiments
on SST-2 dataset show that DPoE significantly improves the defense performance
against various types of backdoor triggers including word-level,
sentence-level, and syntactic triggers. Furthermore, DPoE is also effective
under a more challenging but practical setting that mixes multiple types of
trigger. | [
-0.0690403804,
-0.7367824316,
0.2923199534,
-0.0275654607,
-0.0185486395,
0.5062401891,
0.1237017289,
-0.1876150072,
0.0565415062,
0.3906129599,
-0.5315040946,
-0.7190989852,
-0.5950936079,
0.0388468467,
-0.5823354721,
1.0336122513,
0.3103387058,
-0.6246256232,
0.5236830711,
0.2040480077,
-0.3474510908,
-0.6067018509,
-0.6271598339,
0.0648315474,
0.4696610868,
0.3142511249,
0.60391289,
0.0078006107,
0.3210926056,
0.1882451177,
0.0294088349,
-0.4632456899,
-0.514478147,
0.2026062161,
-0.4189311564,
-0.5067914128,
-0.58639431,
-0.0495590381,
0.3608396649,
0.1183137298,
-0.2528568506,
-0.0563773997,
-0.1458714753,
0.6715349555,
-0.8880703449,
-0.5621449351,
-1.0195333958,
0.1185521707,
-0.1662991941,
0.0996140987,
-0.5099746585,
-0.0536965728,
-0.1307191998,
-0.386934489,
0.0868108869,
0.002586517,
0.4225271642,
0.1118247807,
-0.2886708975,
0.0562438779,
-0.4293361306,
0.5507774949,
-0.7891563177,
0.4571942091,
-0.0737351775,
0.2198239565,
-0.512123704,
-0.4908922017,
-0.7439550161,
0.0461411923,
0.1159021035,
0.3195628822,
-0.5395290852,
0.4561678171,
0.2723128796,
0.2673246562,
-0.6198992133,
0.4589092433,
-0.1901917607,
-0.1883984804,
0.8363004327,
0.0476329364,
0.4243859947,
0.0261031147,
-0.4906250536,
-0.3252367377,
-0.7861435413,
0.0416287817,
0.614225328,
0.1166985109,
0.1352939606,
0.2022358477,
-0.1279964,
0.6555948257,
0.1832484305,
-0.129547298,
-0.0205869041,
-0.02519539,
-0.1743496954,
0.2046847194,
0.7316297293,
0.5019285083,
0.0181333609,
-0.4815487564,
-0.424177438,
0.0015887476,
0.1802197993,
-0.8206297159,
-0.1397072673,
0.5839179158,
-0.3870355189,
-0.8607863188,
-0.0759121478,
-1.3378494978,
-0.1632710099,
0.4702295363,
0.7083542943,
-0.2395182848,
-0.2981044948,
0.1830995679,
-0.5651772022,
0.1234484985,
0.0248933341,
-0.8295150399,
0.6553881764,
0.8931009769,
0.891884923,
-0.2135823816,
-0.2866874039,
-0.7826203704,
0.2705838978,
-0.3111094534,
0.4340903163,
-0.6280109286,
-0.7641854882,
-0.1132279485,
-0.1723173261,
-0.0706757903,
-0.3506738544,
0.4419148862,
-0.6310642362,
0.3185629547,
0.1108254269,
-0.3983685076,
-0.2478859425,
0.223459214,
-0.65308249,
0.8218845725,
-0.2282512188,
-0.7654121518,
0.2846088111,
-0.6499252319,
-0.7147855163,
0.1359045357,
-0.2473044544,
-0.4460972846,
0.1550484002,
0.2393152267,
0.3568096459,
-0.0193101186,
-0.0124533996,
-0.3547089696,
-0.3092566729,
-0.2384004444,
-0.4449314177,
0.7580697536,
0.0571084991,
-0.3389443755,
0.0412349738,
-1.0068737268,
-0.3046689034,
0.1030862778,
-0.1211543605,
-0.5017904043,
-0.0557745583,
-0.4126743078,
0.2701435387,
0.0423560403,
-0.9973718524,
0.4476593733,
-0.7267966866,
0.3626057506,
0.6733961701,
0.5185282826,
0.4578063488,
-0.1371839643,
0.5357670784,
0.0981045067,
0.4031660855,
-0.1996978819,
-0.8441467881,
0.1410349607,
-0.5612498522,
0.1272665113,
0.9587781429,
-0.5924608707,
0.510979712,
-0.086914517,
-0.4365898073,
-0.2661886811,
0.0574283004,
0.3170856833,
0.6090176702,
0.2974505126,
-0.1513297856,
-0.2678708732,
-0.7611873746,
-0.3684274256,
-0.2197374105,
-0.3086082041,
0.0170801822,
0.6116684079,
-0.1700090021,
1.018592,
-0.6130370498,
-0.1718924642,
-0.0285982564,
0.0757185146,
0.3320887089,
0.3328913152,
0.7205289602,
-0.5736873746,
-0.3092559576,
-0.2531938255,
-0.4398016632,
-0.2500688434,
-0.1877769977,
-0.0159603301,
-0.124833487,
0.2279997617,
-0.7227582335,
0.6070606112,
0.4335189462,
-0.0695075169,
0.4702283442,
0.1668005437,
0.152596578,
-1.2079472542,
-0.1161212176,
-0.2572535276,
0.1419991553,
-0.839443028,
0.1977196187,
-0.0886523873,
-0.7809609175,
-0.6338365078,
0.7075669765,
0.0361112431,
-0.0994769186,
0.0554476827,
-0.0091502042,
0.2660796046,
0.5644073486,
-0.0398158282,
0.7838146687,
0.7783632874,
-0.5122300386,
0.5851582289,
0.2368772626,
-0.0992831141,
0.3515437245,
-0.7963986397,
0.3452253938,
0.1820296198,
0.5192017555,
-1.0828232765,
-0.0096929464,
0.5526224375,
-0.3649241626,
0.4948610067,
-0.6368268728,
-0.4977677464,
-0.407803297,
-0.8100171685,
0.3012179136,
0.6769121289,
-0.8449751735,
0.5904548764,
-0.0319165513,
-0.1188958511,
-0.7381855845,
-0.6450286508,
0.426985234,
-0.3861406147,
-0.8981832862,
0.5950607657,
-0.1078189611,
-0.3394222558,
-0.3434807658,
-0.0343625695,
-0.1709914804,
0.3117670417,
0.1610241532,
0.0408362113,
-0.0939210579,
0.398856461,
0.2500457168,
0.0825973526,
0.0262069721,
-0.5293508172,
0.331064254,
0.2431331426,
-0.5126511455,
-0.4679315388,
0.782941401,
0.7170450091,
-0.2198697031,
0.4502254725,
0.1851269901,
-0.3231424689,
-0.1832200289,
-0.4202227592,
-0.7832978368,
-0.511767447,
0.3863161802,
-0.5129712224,
-0.4563357532,
0.7207416296,
-0.0848064572,
0.298083961,
0.1253858358,
0.3639643192,
0.1284125894,
0.7701193094,
0.4246413112,
-0.3906136155,
0.4402040541,
-0.2510258257,
0.5163801312,
-0.7423522472,
0.0199987441,
-0.1193314046,
-0.3804274201,
-0.5305948257,
0.0998959318,
0.2905128598,
0.1691084355,
0.1465856731,
0.3377830684,
-0.6550266147,
0.3882954419,
0.3525241613,
0.1044952273,
0.1624437124,
0.0299753938,
0.0597766005,
0.3637447655,
-0.7540804148,
-0.2541404665,
1.1077033281,
0.5631846786,
1.1058157682,
0.2292316258,
1.1748385429,
0.414298594,
-0.2088147104,
-0.5815086961,
0.5904211402,
-0.166452989,
-0.7265667319,
-0.3857547939,
-0.1556647867,
-0.8948275447,
0.2449260056,
0.0515045486,
-1.0853785276,
0.6642428041,
0.2016277313,
-0.823553443,
0.5820242167,
-0.8004723191,
0.8289771676,
-0.3472411036,
-0.4930663407,
-0.2957565784,
-0.6096010208,
0.6125180721,
-0.1729932874,
0.2651939392,
-0.0486020073,
0.1153099388,
0.9326769114,
-0.3305790424,
1.1340782642,
-0.2658423185,
-0.4914601445,
0.3735552132,
0.3473502696,
0.728631258,
0.3848699331,
-0.0912251696,
0.2880128622,
-0.0597496927,
-0.273437798,
-0.5962336659,
0.4796139896,
-0.328889221,
-1.0282348394,
-0.1868056357,
-0.2007664293,
-0.0382147096,
0.1080636829,
0.6087936759,
0.5282561183,
-0.1760949939,
-0.2263344675,
0.7340700626,
-0.4663434029,
0.8935353756,
0.767419219,
0.0518309325,
-0.2873954475,
0.8443126082,
0.0279990733,
0.4247862995,
0.6949782372,
0.5287356973,
-0.2012253404,
-0.411921531,
-0.2863242924,
-0.3318736851,
-0.5792753696,
-0.3780881166,
-0.7099595666,
-0.0731964707,
-0.751727283,
-0.0937106535,
-0.3225758076,
-0.535820961,
0.0933919773,
-0.0944743752,
0.7286065817,
0.3597670794,
-0.3937349021,
0.4579855204,
-0.818333149,
0.4589680433,
0.7950521708,
0.1890393794,
-0.0361334346,
-0.4406737089,
0.1552788317,
0.0714394897,
-0.288353622,
-1.3312473297,
0.2880167067,
0.310603857,
0.5826172829,
0.1929668188,
0.3976469934,
-0.2017560154,
-0.4478533268,
0.8352389932,
0.1532573104,
-0.8741154075,
0.8204264045,
-0.2357521355,
0.012536264,
0.2838530838,
0.0632852241,
-0.5603076816,
-0.3112127185,
-0.624019444,
-0.8374564648,
0.1807760149,
0.176626265,
0.0195608977,
-0.0986847132,
0.1478266865,
0.2020717263,
0.5179101229,
-0.3683928847,
0.378413111,
-0.3801932335,
-0.1215968952,
0.3230726719,
-0.1816180348,
-0.3178046644,
0.1154103801,
0.53503263,
0.1289380342,
0.0381408781,
0.2290840596,
-0.1773876697,
0.0837857574,
0.6814600229,
0.6174875498,
-0.0179059841,
-0.2570004463,
-0.0580643751,
0.3471351266,
-0.5717893839,
0.3143369853,
-0.0468923002,
-0.2726991177,
-0.1674804688,
0.5553007722,
0.6161258817,
0.1487252712,
-0.4437042177,
0.689627409,
0.0863495618,
0.0557955056,
0.1422595084,
0.1874366254,
-0.6273431778,
-0.0435656607,
0.4318485558,
-0.0764242336,
0.4041777849,
-0.5980815291,
0.4753392041,
0.3403197825,
-0.079161793,
-0.4895060658,
0.3567020297,
0.5228136778,
-0.5079036355,
0.5223999023,
0.0941802263,
-1.0744211674,
0.6122114062,
0.2819635272,
1.2496188879,
-0.5446337461,
-0.1340710968,
-0.0200039446,
0.552704215,
0.2478704005,
0.1815778315,
-0.263897568,
-0.6561377048,
-0.1316359639,
-0.4056797028,
-0.2293619066,
0.2031994909,
-0.3334401846,
0.1755018979,
-0.6746937037,
0.0514779612,
-0.2419876754,
-0.204240784,
-0.2339558303,
0.1292651296,
-0.1819553375,
1.0741863251,
-0.9860700369,
0.6846256852,
0.2469600141,
-0.3952271044,
-0.2799127996,
0.3459029496,
0.1790961325,
-0.8389419317,
0.860626936,
-0.1391299367,
-0.3635354936,
0.017848108,
-0.337875545,
-0.4151589572,
0.607244432,
-0.011833231,
-0.9139658809,
0.040938396,
-0.0996740162,
0.4329687953,
-0.2613947093,
-0.202026695,
0.6661425233,
0.3140975833,
-0.0937731937,
-0.6386229396,
0.0460390262,
-0.1749736816,
-0.4046993852,
0.1339208782,
-0.6511586308,
0.6184786558,
-0.3358040452,
-0.2374207526,
-0.3789313138,
0.1928903461,
0.2007484585,
0.530187428,
0.4847659171,
0.9631953239,
0.3322107792,
0.1969133765,
0.8898766041,
-0.5076985955,
-0.2085979581,
1.1654388905,
-0.6107987165,
1.0192751884,
0.3298203647,
-0.0597277768,
0.5020347238,
0.5142264366,
-0.3442637026,
0.8835909963,
0.201415807,
-0.3719866872,
0.0475583263,
0.2267437875,
-0.6098276377,
0.4062062204,
0.4171709716,
-0.1604335308,
-0.2753572762,
0.2474473566,
-0.1509374082,
0.0538537279,
-0.1834012121,
1.0624408722,
0.0188904926,
-0.4051620364,
0.3712484837,
-0.2078243494,
0.6247066855,
-0.4500808418,
0.0882655084,
-0.2795490623,
0.1245242804,
-0.2577141225,
-1.0485399961,
0.1913724691,
-0.1792131513,
-0.1528721005,
-0.0789528936,
0.8959765434,
-0.3257972598,
-0.2062690407,
0.4422629476,
-0.1401855797,
-0.0177878104,
-0.3082126975,
-0.4734887481,
0.1200870052,
-0.2855529189,
-0.1913491338,
0.2475032806,
0.2048213035,
-0.0207484793,
0.5754388571,
0.4870583415,
-0.0649495125,
0.2893785834,
0.1435304731,
0.7904891968,
-0.2582242191,
-0.8027496934,
-0.9978629351,
0.3530800343,
-0.3941069245,
-0.1404333562,
0.6224493384,
0.6080307961,
0.375833571,
0.031684909,
0.9114564061,
0.2408403307,
0.5564607978,
-0.4306090772,
0.809373498,
-0.3695810735,
0.38346228,
-0.3453940451,
-0.68331182,
0.0106444983,
0.086724028,
-0.2390260696,
-0.1263308972,
0.2676061094,
0.8373244405,
0.027566243,
-0.0096285157,
0.5167344213,
0.3774450123,
0.7223985195,
0.826079905,
0.7904452682,
-0.5570158958,
0.6320787668,
-0.329217732,
-0.6248711348,
-0.2051395625,
-0.8527805209,
-1.153273344,
-0.2983554006,
-0.4223665595,
-0.2002182603,
0.5562106967,
0.4723317921,
0.6663290262,
-0.7958564758,
0.1120186895,
-0.168817848,
0.4107263386,
-0.2649833262,
-0.1882888526,
0.2397751063,
-0.1890248358,
-0.1407345086,
0.676920712,
0.6029304862,
0.1331772953,
-0.121738717,
0.2144467831,
-0.111755766,
0.2683110237,
0.4955400527,
0.6304867864,
-0.7929154038,
-0.3658185601,
-0.2208592892,
0.0028817768,
-0.260329932,
0.6809834242,
-0.7616762519,
0.3734394908,
0.8901669979,
0.5323405266,
0.0663025677,
-0.2408295572,
0.828773737,
-1.1733372211,
0.5302717686,
0.3671217859,
0.2173592001,
0.062134739,
-0.7134033442,
0.3681707978,
0.4383804798,
-0.2195196748,
-0.9729166031,
0.5865027905,
-0.6191888452,
-0.4564334452,
0.8990035057,
-0.1146017238,
-0.3525528312,
-0.0302218087,
-0.1440384686,
0.0504818745,
-0.5910351276,
1.1550192833,
0.5035222769,
0.2279902846,
-0.2059294432,
-0.0680098236,
0.6275615096,
0.1980727017,
-0.7479779124,
0.3606084287,
0.0142527707,
0.1904126704,
0.3358640969,
0.0925792158,
0.0075049102,
0.3841973841,
0.2453925014,
-0.0287790671,
0.0841673091,
-0.4659996033,
-0.2794586122,
0.2371451408,
-0.3026664257,
-0.6704169512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14908v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14908v1 | PURR: Efficiently Editing Language Model Hallucinations by Denoising Language Model Corruptions | 2023-05-24T08:59:00 | 2023-05-24T08:59:00 | Anthony Chen, Panupong Pasupat, Sameer Singh, Hongrae Lee, Kelvin Guu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The remarkable capabilities of large language models have been accompanied by
a persistent drawback: the generation of false and unsubstantiated claims
commonly known as "hallucinations". To combat this issue, recent research has
introduced approaches that involve editing and attributing the outputs of
language models, particularly through prompt-based editing. However, the
inference cost and speed of using large language models for editing currently
bottleneck prompt-based methods. These bottlenecks motivate the training of
compact editors, which is challenging due to the scarcity of training data for
this purpose. To overcome these challenges, we exploit the power of large
language models to introduce corruptions (i.e., noise) into text and
subsequently fine-tune compact editors to denoise the corruptions by
incorporating relevant evidence. Our methodology is entirely unsupervised and
provides us with faux hallucinations for training in any domain. Our Petite
Unsupervised Research and Revision model, PURR, not only improves attribution
over existing editing methods based on fine-tuning and prompting, but also
achieves faster execution times by orders of magnitude. | [
-0.0926473588,
-0.9878852367,
0.4839161932,
0.3056429923,
-0.2233466208,
-0.110018231,
-0.4992874265,
-0.2691795826,
0.1334971339,
0.8962817788,
-0.2620180547,
-0.1515604258,
-0.4970120788,
0.3551727831,
-0.525721252,
1.0119485855,
0.3466805816,
0.0422235541,
-0.0069047022,
0.1682867259,
-0.5255377889,
-0.6198479533,
-0.5631569028,
-0.2372369319,
0.2709926963,
0.3500436544,
0.9180002213,
0.596123457,
0.4801760614,
0.3124801517,
-0.4104631841,
0.334607929,
-0.6387090683,
0.1742080301,
-0.2472041547,
-0.3307024837,
-0.3588327765,
-0.1592792571,
0.5863138437,
0.7214946151,
-0.2381822169,
-0.1474979371,
0.1025596112,
0.7968127728,
-0.6795508862,
0.0392133817,
-1.0753901005,
-0.0493634492,
-0.2807943225,
-0.2656539679,
-0.7000456452,
-0.3152493834,
-0.208679378,
-0.7413118482,
0.5465177298,
0.0353524089,
0.747554481,
0.5098038316,
0.0728659928,
-0.4059944749,
-0.8313632011,
0.6194534302,
-0.4246823788,
0.3935077786,
0.4836395681,
-0.0137976371,
-0.4020889997,
-0.8519335389,
-0.598896265,
-0.2729096711,
-0.1968450844,
-0.150312826,
-0.3171998858,
0.1750280261,
0.4606697559,
0.49622491,
-0.553116262,
-0.0676766336,
-0.3291046619,
-0.2377376556,
0.5362817049,
0.0749494359,
0.2971102297,
-0.1443725228,
0.1770902127,
-0.1736177653,
-0.5662654042,
-0.3822131157,
0.576654315,
0.3545021117,
0.2793130279,
0.6189717054,
-0.2139547765,
0.5242751837,
0.3660079837,
-0.1378158629,
0.0931662768,
-0.1928115934,
-0.3276759088,
0.1069516614,
0.7159931064,
0.2732499838,
0.3332977891,
-0.2782726288,
-0.3131608367,
0.2646702528,
0.4082103372,
-0.7755744457,
-0.7057759166,
0.2069482952,
-0.3560197353,
-0.498562336,
-0.0667600855,
-1.0678688288,
-0.9671393633,
-0.2091859132,
0.3937029541,
-0.3138227761,
-0.3061519861,
0.6085048914,
-0.2041636854,
-0.2738258839,
0.5758078694,
-0.6779338121,
0.2287846804,
0.5541216135,
0.6988967657,
-0.0234010536,
-0.3063797653,
-0.7576926351,
-0.0495064221,
-0.375259012,
1.0482771397,
-0.8266134262,
-0.5812096,
0.0545408241,
-0.0175149478,
-0.0142009985,
-0.7895282507,
0.5391533971,
-0.2325931489,
0.146848008,
-0.0359108895,
-0.3785907924,
0.0297972709,
0.0301760621,
-0.649925828,
1.1937304735,
0.0062118769,
-0.771494627,
-0.0729795918,
-0.6773866415,
-0.3927275538,
-0.1416497976,
0.1863182336,
-0.5204472542,
0.4323324859,
0.4199791551,
0.2464295179,
-0.0595346503,
0.4788943231,
0.0617527366,
-0.3637849092,
0.3087286651,
-0.3981180489,
0.8658232689,
0.2147692442,
-0.1888749301,
0.3462271094,
-0.8676290512,
-0.4149888754,
0.1034961715,
0.0004208542,
-0.6323742867,
-0.3121017516,
-0.01196039,
-0.151622802,
0.076360777,
-0.3877312839,
0.5193027258,
-0.4146021307,
0.4250573218,
0.5366278887,
0.1690025926,
0.4956020415,
-0.4271279573,
0.4502915144,
0.0230818726,
0.3315367997,
-0.202790156,
-0.3699742556,
-0.7635817528,
-0.2038201243,
0.4077741504,
0.4061555564,
-0.520978868,
0.2218759656,
-0.133533746,
-0.6196172833,
-0.7200498581,
0.0832547769,
0.2927569449,
0.5630090833,
0.4267300665,
-0.0681100413,
-0.7803063989,
-0.6678518653,
-0.4290322065,
-0.316463083,
-0.0256854016,
-0.1584327966,
0.639059782,
-0.4289347827,
0.6487492323,
-0.3194204569,
-0.5431885719,
-0.2312191278,
0.3750019968,
-0.1148480251,
0.6663463712,
0.1757677943,
-0.54139781,
-0.3962554932,
-0.1826741993,
-0.3984202445,
-0.4873281121,
-0.5796390176,
-0.0152340354,
0.2137226462,
0.7414752841,
-0.6410797238,
0.4401943088,
0.3821896911,
-0.3273486793,
1.1418852806,
-0.2885081768,
0.1214936897,
-0.6736305356,
0.1365953535,
-0.3983260095,
-0.1227366477,
-0.6463025808,
0.0732176006,
0.0473097749,
-0.1750746518,
-0.1657463461,
0.6630076766,
-0.5715928674,
0.2294152528,
-0.3033403158,
0.1298765242,
0.2184870541,
0.4493134022,
0.1727340668,
0.7496615648,
0.402294755,
-0.3957751393,
-0.0869920477,
0.5741582513,
-0.4480538964,
0.313192457,
-0.5188364983,
0.2617842555,
-0.1549738646,
0.114435792,
-0.6349197626,
-0.2050488144,
0.2377268076,
-0.3793232143,
0.2307724208,
-0.203641966,
-0.6110036373,
0.0709456429,
-0.4179363847,
-0.0201595034,
0.4387986958,
-0.6939421296,
0.3863674402,
0.4520635307,
-0.1047766805,
-0.4923785031,
-0.7489155531,
0.3278154433,
-0.2065891325,
-0.2711906433,
0.4123797119,
-0.0909663141,
-0.5822909474,
-0.1335539669,
0.0186796077,
-0.2477373034,
0.0573852919,
0.2616422474,
0.0993628204,
0.0491516031,
0.062024828,
0.1415742785,
-0.0655218437,
-0.0234035067,
0.2322131246,
0.4288920164,
-0.0655254647,
-0.0677202493,
-0.6295246482,
0.2838198245,
0.6482341886,
-0.339756012,
0.583922267,
0.2514485419,
-0.3780082464,
-0.320990473,
-0.7430170178,
-0.4441073537,
-0.4554369748,
0.445533216,
-0.2797566652,
-0.8245102167,
0.523080647,
-0.0398925282,
0.1597307026,
0.1683793217,
0.4150669873,
0.3332482576,
0.927500844,
0.6132707596,
0.2286882997,
0.5690176487,
-0.0509009771,
0.1071600541,
-0.7984455824,
-0.0522977859,
-0.8202686906,
0.204746142,
-0.3458588123,
-0.6678580642,
0.1320023239,
0.3695237935,
-0.1293699443,
0.0403990932,
-0.7843084335,
0.796361208,
0.4635474682,
0.0025983264,
0.7434141636,
0.0445618965,
0.1859793216,
-0.2401568741,
-0.7226851583,
-0.6898101568,
1.0141333342,
0.2632728517,
0.9451034665,
-0.1459956467,
0.354657501,
0.4303994477,
0.2869294286,
-0.705650568,
0.4220785201,
-0.0817994997,
-0.4055015743,
-0.3304329813,
-0.1913635731,
-0.7834318876,
0.3377488256,
-0.3985830545,
-0.663338542,
0.5145902038,
0.4896886349,
-0.4323207736,
0.5094826221,
-0.6586818099,
0.9144166112,
0.2866879404,
-0.2139390409,
-0.2475974411,
-0.3618148863,
0.5451624393,
-0.2263193429,
0.1550123096,
0.3621097803,
0.3444025815,
0.7103084922,
-0.54581815,
0.9784640074,
-0.0932447016,
-0.0934482366,
0.2986492813,
0.5346574187,
0.937114656,
0.1915926486,
-0.1136376411,
0.2949452996,
-0.1215851754,
-0.0470761396,
-0.7101919055,
0.4778134823,
-0.5388708115,
-0.5959725976,
-0.3658561707,
-0.5882381797,
-0.1773500592,
-0.0078593232,
0.3216119111,
0.52992028,
-0.1981441528,
0.0833462477,
0.7266443372,
-0.3473644555,
0.3027012944,
0.4094329178,
-0.4765226245,
-0.3329758644,
0.8678274155,
-0.1201972961,
0.0913332254,
0.2074313313,
0.4105531275,
-0.3631855249,
-0.7795103788,
-0.2892767787,
0.3787704408,
-0.4851353467,
-0.1914639026,
-0.9602927566,
-0.0338145159,
-0.5215197206,
-0.3189822137,
-0.707860589,
-0.4730301201,
-0.3307015002,
0.2616610527,
0.4756027758,
0.6345978975,
-0.3835614324,
0.7143839598,
-0.6561937928,
0.4035829604,
0.2345475852,
0.2235876173,
-0.0741740018,
-0.9854435325,
-0.240670383,
0.0677489266,
-0.3290625513,
-0.8633601069,
0.5661153197,
0.1682799011,
0.0241596773,
0.3928821981,
0.4254909754,
1.1727343798,
-0.5003750324,
0.7683399916,
-0.0168682281,
-1.1845853329,
0.5411076546,
-0.1160156503,
0.0651315525,
0.6040652394,
-0.0836274326,
-0.6533181667,
-0.8550312519,
-0.6751873493,
-0.3338054121,
0.4620931447,
0.1009879187,
-0.0175305046,
-0.0981071293,
0.3505333662,
0.2674624324,
0.2205163538,
-0.6276442409,
0.0151787465,
-0.332142204,
0.0766206905,
0.1691078842,
-0.5192834735,
0.0344729573,
-0.3214755654,
0.8791670799,
-0.0532782264,
0.1709093451,
0.5277980566,
-0.452037394,
-0.3309266865,
0.384783864,
0.6821560264,
0.5840063691,
-0.1254083514,
0.1654345542,
0.0147678703,
-0.6285868883,
-0.0935027301,
-0.199315697,
-0.3116001487,
0.4109807014,
0.3174885213,
0.7910849452,
0.1586768925,
-0.8731103539,
0.3722127974,
-0.1546170413,
-0.1175335348,
-0.2860401273,
0.0557585396,
-0.3035755754,
0.1524688154,
0.009233078,
0.2627089918,
0.1971590519,
-0.3238611519,
0.1449665725,
0.3025297821,
-0.2998172939,
-0.5147909522,
0.761672318,
-0.023949869,
-0.3860968947,
0.7327413559,
-0.2269002497,
-0.3992258608,
0.1487689316,
0.5636045337,
0.8271077275,
-0.40105775,
0.4147332311,
0.5282556415,
0.5593955517,
-0.5875544548,
0.0415588953,
0.2820017636,
-0.7077643275,
-0.6668332815,
-0.6463018656,
-0.6010442376,
0.7027338743,
-0.7281760573,
0.2402080595,
-0.3794218302,
0.1531825513,
-0.1260308921,
-0.074594602,
-0.081479378,
-0.1433845162,
-0.264069438,
0.8189724088,
-0.8410181403,
0.948761344,
0.6055455208,
-0.2335696071,
-0.4614126086,
-0.1355254799,
-0.0828156695,
-0.461052835,
0.3864084482,
0.1137478575,
0.0402416997,
0.1659757346,
-0.6481738687,
-0.3416574895,
0.1641585231,
0.5796892643,
-0.7559010983,
-0.1148669645,
0.0638768151,
0.503059566,
-0.1832464337,
-0.0260801148,
0.766700983,
0.6271628737,
-0.1904353499,
-0.9078699946,
-0.0254800022,
-0.1772463024,
-0.1702524871,
0.0412446856,
-0.2592297196,
0.83939147,
-0.4560067058,
-0.3107872009,
0.1385840178,
0.5421170592,
0.1827446967,
-0.1256340444,
0.6432951689,
0.4875575304,
1.014688611,
0.0552137196,
0.7568387389,
-0.2310606539,
0.3115273416,
1.5130957365,
-0.1757877916,
0.615236342,
0.6609038115,
0.0916768461,
0.41407305,
0.3976203203,
-0.1973864287,
0.4148681164,
0.115015544,
0.0182674583,
-0.387567848,
-0.1991582662,
-0.206414476,
0.3548704386,
0.2939794064,
-0.0351628549,
-0.2451063693,
0.2728588283,
0.2292347848,
0.5071722865,
-0.2874293625,
0.6992951632,
-0.166394189,
-0.6170834303,
0.6662727594,
-0.1175887659,
0.695638597,
-0.3573546708,
-0.3125739098,
-0.3827451766,
0.1181996465,
-0.0529945306,
-0.4566973448,
0.7018148303,
0.2547239065,
-0.2012279481,
-0.3614240885,
0.6084951758,
-0.527548492,
-0.3191460967,
-0.0612468794,
0.420085609,
0.2991866767,
-0.7686526775,
-0.7037782669,
0.3123688996,
0.0581055358,
-0.1570443362,
0.1575500518,
0.614556551,
-0.100002028,
0.5795137882,
0.724371016,
0.4362872839,
-0.043902386,
-0.0139558353,
0.629937768,
-0.665329814,
-0.5245173573,
-0.8191423416,
0.5244365931,
-0.0193986986,
-0.4307854474,
0.5930992961,
0.5529373288,
0.8004510403,
-0.279722333,
0.6789108515,
0.1044476256,
0.5324939489,
-0.500200212,
0.9899476171,
-0.5100003481,
0.2381658703,
-0.4130663574,
-0.6352189779,
-0.5999411345,
0.8626740575,
-0.1648214757,
-0.4178177714,
0.8344643116,
1.3880831003,
0.0572914667,
0.1312202662,
0.4688408673,
0.7454660535,
0.144823432,
0.1147281975,
0.9396743774,
-0.4250479937,
0.5715293288,
-0.6458938122,
-0.0760405809,
-0.3664822578,
-0.8127216101,
-1.1552523375,
-0.6189092994,
-0.6125950813,
-0.4239459634,
0.1581064314,
0.73730129,
0.3306365609,
-0.8512679338,
-0.1049358696,
-0.2649208903,
0.2868438661,
-0.358818233,
-0.2514365613,
0.5767273307,
-0.4971468747,
-0.9392331839,
0.4319738448,
0.1200611889,
0.1071017459,
-0.2725034356,
0.0634452924,
0.0747999921,
0.0818644315,
0.5204889178,
0.233122766,
-0.7281087041,
-0.23770684,
-0.0944846943,
0.0047729625,
0.1524865776,
0.9317296147,
-0.7271934748,
0.593520999,
0.2177957445,
0.4822875857,
0.031634368,
-0.0048031788,
0.3341478705,
-0.5705349445,
0.4394288361,
0.1301073879,
0.25463292,
0.4725417495,
-0.4244937003,
0.5079600215,
0.3349220753,
-0.6272871494,
-1.4983661175,
-0.0773113221,
-0.9093862772,
-0.4550856352,
1.1770029068,
0.0845807418,
-0.2758118808,
-0.3633559048,
-0.5883747935,
0.2624041736,
-0.3377391994,
1.3467303514,
0.4496343136,
0.0013240722,
-0.0763218775,
-0.4412735403,
0.8861727118,
0.4136675298,
-0.681329906,
0.8176534772,
0.6904906034,
-0.0212240405,
0.1584090441,
0.497965008,
-0.1983236372,
0.2395011038,
0.2966569066,
0.3903116584,
-0.310577929,
-0.5295503139,
-0.6044797301,
0.2027818859,
-0.0397105366,
0.1652182341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14907v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14907v3 | Coverage-based Example Selection for In-Context Learning | 2023-05-24T08:58:28 | 2023-11-06T20:32:31 | Shivanshu Gupta, Matt Gardner, Sameer Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL), the ability of large language models to perform
novel tasks by conditioning on a prompt with a few task examples, requires
these examples to be informative about the test instance. The standard approach
of independently ranking and selecting the most similar examples selects
redundant examples while omitting important information. In this work, we show
that BERTScore-Recall (BSR) selects better examples that demonstrate more of
the salient aspects, e.g. reasoning patterns, of the test input. We further
extend BSR and many standard metrics to easily optimizable set-level metrics,
giving still better coverage of those salient aspects. On 15 datasets spanning
6 tasks and with 7 diverse LLMs, we show that (1) BSR is the superior metric
for in-context example selection across the board, and (2) for compositional
tasks, set selection using Set-BSR outperforms independent ranking by up to 17
points on average and, despite being training-free, surpasses methods that
leverage task or LLM-specific training. | [
-0.5657884479,
-0.2667579651,
0.3477909267,
0.240884915,
-0.2318239063,
-0.1847555786,
-0.2561831772,
-0.4870570004,
-0.1814721972,
0.2651655972,
-0.3315733671,
-0.5165590048,
-0.3991129994,
-0.0150250746,
-0.4546386898,
1.2379775047,
-0.1522813141,
-0.126916334,
-0.6270736456,
-0.2738304436,
-0.4391130209,
-0.3213980794,
-0.527833879,
-0.5081532001,
0.5704770088,
0.6669158936,
0.0014494394,
0.2314373255,
0.5130082965,
0.1488696337,
-0.2445030957,
0.404871285,
-0.4745908976,
0.3635885417,
-0.1767027527,
-0.2343611121,
0.1899810284,
-0.1101213098,
0.6482064724,
0.8384442925,
0.1806645542,
0.0486753881,
0.2638087869,
0.4747327268,
-0.7760182023,
0.2214579433,
-0.6473172903,
0.085832648,
0.277864486,
-0.0593600683,
-0.6325704455,
-0.2649081647,
0.3311265409,
-0.4539839029,
0.2959555686,
-0.0590728,
0.5684190989,
0.0379431546,
-0.384265542,
-0.4000088274,
-0.5999961495,
1.05055511,
-0.5631337166,
0.3619834781,
0.6833856106,
0.3956198692,
-0.0655277818,
-0.3813707829,
-0.1499404609,
-0.2525462508,
-0.4056781232,
0.4150351286,
0.0383863412,
-0.0918691307,
0.2631243765,
0.3180040717,
-0.277828604,
0.1138510928,
-0.4560439289,
-0.2301309854,
0.4291934669,
0.0066422243,
-0.0641001984,
-0.1019766182,
-0.3386012018,
-0.2540349662,
-0.981359899,
0.3800036311,
-0.1267690212,
0.2964725494,
-0.0082243141,
0.4112435579,
-0.3445632458,
0.7916550636,
0.0793255717,
-0.1455088407,
0.1910316348,
-0.3696147501,
-0.2842132449,
0.0339586586,
0.2241569757,
-0.0038746996,
-0.1491851807,
-0.3633343279,
-0.4039731622,
-0.1624597758,
0.079397507,
-0.8108533621,
-0.2296461612,
0.0972363278,
-0.3313312232,
0.1612938643,
0.2083539516,
-0.173742786,
0.0144474646,
-0.3146964908,
0.3135366142,
-0.8425294161,
0.2812993526,
-0.0951857194,
-0.2714541554,
0.5481836796,
0.4290688932,
-0.6151891947,
0.2417919338,
0.7228960991,
0.533462286,
-0.1501921266,
-0.3107277751,
-0.7084924579,
0.237867564,
-0.4809152782,
0.6819012761,
-0.5735158324,
-0.4684296548,
-0.0980697274,
-0.1365915984,
0.0513784587,
-0.5421401262,
0.250672698,
-0.4607621729,
0.3928927481,
-0.6539658308,
-0.7231019735,
-0.389511168,
0.3948673308,
-0.4702606201,
1.1419688463,
0.2805164754,
-0.7136908174,
0.8755640984,
-0.2888913751,
-0.6687250733,
0.0057795355,
-0.4387105405,
-0.5365918875,
0.0635896549,
0.2443122268,
0.8022105694,
0.0835095271,
-0.153175056,
-0.2195711434,
-0.80926615,
0.1580903977,
0.0163411461,
0.5938258767,
0.0071637891,
-0.4886299968,
0.1436595619,
-0.4056471586,
0.1378939748,
-0.2111620456,
-0.5247481465,
-0.7571591139,
0.0905879736,
-0.1199486181,
0.2818422616,
-0.1510545164,
-0.5574803352,
-0.2298129201,
-0.2543669641,
0.0462704524,
0.6577718258,
0.2413926572,
0.3579844236,
-0.7236065269,
0.2341510952,
0.1306061447,
-0.1272029728,
-0.3254359663,
-0.1558346599,
-0.8362112045,
-0.8632796407,
0.1539583802,
0.4208288789,
-0.4612766206,
0.6032761335,
-0.1674308479,
-0.5294809341,
-0.2687770724,
0.081573084,
0.8724503517,
0.5236608982,
0.4095943868,
-0.3842119873,
-0.319026947,
-1.0969883204,
0.064237006,
-0.0202696268,
0.0308551453,
0.6626976728,
0.438496232,
0.150401324,
0.9665209055,
-0.2700830996,
-0.1966881454,
-0.5189810991,
-0.0747648552,
0.1914725602,
0.428024292,
0.6603469849,
-0.8068498969,
-0.5727612972,
-0.0646640137,
-0.586306572,
0.0301672276,
-0.1909787059,
-0.2134960294,
0.2670198083,
0.4615416527,
-0.1714519262,
0.4180951416,
0.179894045,
-0.3654586077,
0.3114070892,
-0.3151062429,
0.1441232413,
-0.873859942,
0.0044809831,
0.0570146702,
-0.3764993846,
-0.3113951981,
0.0658790544,
0.4710358977,
0.2988871932,
-0.322409302,
0.6730685234,
-0.5743391514,
-0.2805110514,
-0.1183930263,
0.0192663185,
0.0663657412,
0.3720717728,
-0.0230751596,
0.855261445,
0.6003252268,
-0.7962042689,
-0.2072667927,
0.4562809467,
-0.8666474819,
0.4063507318,
-0.4318103492,
0.0251684226,
-0.2153882831,
0.4228892028,
-1.030859828,
-0.0653343201,
-0.1178900376,
0.0691519901,
0.1953431666,
0.0639730841,
-0.5379881263,
-0.0600371175,
-0.171892181,
0.2726691961,
0.7584106922,
-0.9034010172,
0.2451144755,
0.0862731263,
-0.1619239748,
-0.6955665946,
-0.6572303176,
-0.4731569886,
-0.2965810299,
0.050000295,
0.5053644776,
-0.2741393149,
-0.2372001112,
-0.1430852264,
-0.4562346041,
-0.0251538511,
0.1406005323,
0.2587639987,
0.124676913,
0.0902402997,
0.2420907468,
0.2525207996,
0.238114506,
-0.1436706781,
0.11293865,
0.285169363,
-0.2213264555,
-0.7248407602,
-0.0170376822,
0.6725846529,
0.2270957232,
-0.219622612,
0.4031187892,
0.103766568,
-0.3102114499,
-0.6923644543,
-0.5463256836,
-0.3804419041,
-0.3677174151,
0.5458289981,
-0.381054461,
-0.9155669212,
0.4702560008,
0.3962647915,
0.2772791386,
-0.0290849283,
0.2859322727,
-0.3638681173,
0.6532076597,
0.5240596533,
-0.3518649936,
0.7898199558,
-0.3763554394,
-0.0878194794,
-0.8727065325,
-0.2977554202,
-0.315190047,
-0.3955806792,
-0.2501817346,
-0.3309030831,
0.5507671833,
-0.029841993,
-0.3760460615,
0.3440142274,
-0.4540448487,
0.828309834,
0.8546113968,
0.5045949817,
0.2388036102,
0.0731763989,
-0.2394976467,
0.1082012877,
-0.5980491638,
-0.1722348779,
1.0188512802,
-0.2211584449,
0.4664469063,
0.1253196895,
0.8626349568,
0.0575373843,
0.4568734467,
-0.6376786828,
0.7105112076,
-0.2977162898,
-0.6179884076,
-0.2821070254,
-0.2997356951,
-0.8587957025,
0.5513800979,
-0.0016880938,
-0.4908287823,
0.2209579796,
0.2382960767,
-0.1393581629,
0.1647841632,
-0.5377959013,
0.402280122,
-0.1291071475,
0.0179766435,
-0.3307453096,
-0.7544637918,
0.2436213344,
-0.0068524308,
-0.0557671078,
-0.1087804586,
0.1086040363,
0.3444572091,
0.077972725,
0.9773655534,
-0.1627137065,
0.3046149611,
0.1730858386,
0.106603913,
0.3961922526,
-0.0714456886,
-0.178897053,
-0.104030028,
-0.1802635044,
-0.457672447,
-0.5347598195,
0.6168454885,
-0.4115274847,
-0.4552433491,
-0.4029590786,
-0.8131674528,
-0.3765152097,
0.0600037649,
0.1974541247,
0.5255604982,
-0.2490003854,
0.6654440761,
0.9875385761,
-0.0836702213,
0.597881794,
0.3821949959,
0.0841127411,
-0.1591897607,
0.6908528209,
-0.0057156147,
0.5064733624,
0.6987286806,
0.0923903063,
0.0556210689,
-0.687441051,
-0.1430174261,
0.0261111874,
-0.9806576967,
-0.2648749053,
-0.5691674352,
-0.2914281487,
0.0526846722,
-0.4328508675,
0.1660810709,
-0.3419645131,
-0.0642533973,
-0.1944915205,
0.2056308091,
0.3787637353,
0.0498863012,
0.0480311587,
-0.2056664377,
0.1085990369,
0.3544722795,
0.2944419384,
-0.0616469048,
-0.5118048191,
-0.2682778239,
-0.3351090252,
-0.2739285827,
-0.5161501765,
0.1002849191,
0.3770153821,
0.9794682264,
0.4247042239,
-0.0032965632,
0.5845944285,
-0.3029560149,
0.4402522445,
0.0260265432,
-0.669250071,
0.5508909225,
-0.1427191198,
0.414254725,
0.8589379191,
0.4659828842,
-0.5511388779,
-0.5980109572,
-0.5943983793,
-0.8786742091,
0.5868102312,
0.1080947816,
-0.0373382643,
-0.2118682861,
0.1275905073,
0.4208099544,
0.0790116638,
-0.6456869245,
-0.0970958099,
-0.0629450455,
-0.2802105248,
-0.1594296843,
-0.1252416819,
-0.3383281231,
-0.3623540401,
0.7256231904,
-0.2326582223,
0.2033453733,
0.4330452085,
-0.2469008565,
0.3869226873,
0.4178372324,
0.4747548401,
0.7872583866,
-0.3905674517,
0.1705756485,
0.3208758235,
-0.2468655258,
-0.0349150598,
0.1049418598,
-0.3767932057,
-0.0397942588,
0.3661529124,
0.6614073515,
0.5917198062,
-0.9696381092,
0.608566165,
0.3538156748,
-0.0707166865,
-0.3722584546,
0.2989002764,
-0.2008991688,
0.3338245451,
0.3050512671,
-0.15894638,
0.2126466781,
-0.5408897996,
0.3407725394,
0.6647648215,
-0.7426009178,
0.0323590338,
0.0630344152,
-0.1841802746,
0.1067305505,
0.5886690617,
-0.2819164693,
-0.3447121978,
0.8298496604,
0.8831986785,
0.5288390517,
0.0763369799,
0.0816486999,
0.273131609,
0.2474234253,
-0.1522430927,
0.4742361307,
-0.3189312518,
-0.8219508529,
-0.2807669044,
-0.151667133,
-0.6425078511,
0.1180864498,
-0.7909924984,
0.0558470786,
-0.5113183856,
0.4062816203,
-0.2781560421,
-0.1143537089,
-0.6793114543,
0.4360979795,
-0.0343056656,
1.0686416626,
-0.7273133993,
0.7306857705,
0.6809756756,
-0.3547596633,
-0.7496079206,
0.0756029934,
-0.2150457352,
-0.5022016764,
0.6699589491,
0.3048558235,
0.0784111917,
-0.3065990508,
-0.3659066558,
-0.7533039451,
1.2856760025,
0.2782031,
-0.2861901522,
0.1178054959,
-0.3938881159,
0.2390984893,
-0.6963841319,
0.4143574536,
0.380610317,
0.1325686574,
0.157245487,
-0.6904222965,
0.0368728489,
-0.0379614234,
0.0309120119,
0.2821125984,
-0.759760797,
0.6103572249,
-0.1990722269,
0.1342637241,
-0.0036218339,
0.5855000615,
0.9512068033,
0.3678167164,
0.7174868584,
0.3075766265,
0.7629044056,
-0.0221899264,
1.2254269123,
0.177903831,
0.0638787895,
1.3423192501,
-0.123550199,
0.8559479713,
0.4862182736,
0.1655689776,
0.5079289079,
0.8329433799,
-0.0522995256,
0.9884767532,
0.2130686492,
-0.3875266314,
-0.410320878,
0.0876859799,
-0.1812474877,
0.4077305794,
0.2551480234,
-0.4495738149,
-0.3008334935,
0.1367134452,
-0.0072143232,
-0.0062380936,
-0.4193761647,
0.8436772227,
0.0137766311,
-0.73387146,
0.2716124654,
-0.3729341328,
0.5701080561,
-0.8080840111,
-0.1588797718,
-0.4873744547,
0.1995733827,
-0.0019305144,
-0.6208488941,
0.1258589923,
-0.2488136739,
-0.5345441699,
-0.3973721862,
0.6464874744,
-0.392585367,
-0.4942520261,
0.3082493246,
0.456147939,
0.2451926768,
0.0493021496,
-0.3096129894,
-0.5107861161,
-0.0481832959,
-0.2134324759,
0.5423777699,
0.3411172628,
-0.4131488502,
0.691233933,
0.4835605621,
0.1160384119,
-0.091035068,
-0.0142711895,
0.8918190598,
-0.6736655831,
-0.6084081531,
-0.4753294587,
0.4234291315,
-0.3874684572,
-0.2428237647,
0.6442809105,
0.9242482781,
1.312941432,
-0.0453365147,
0.9931522012,
-0.0917531848,
0.7088722587,
-0.4881846011,
0.5526601672,
-0.5623725057,
0.1975039095,
-0.2676889896,
-0.7040196061,
-0.2959228456,
0.7028496265,
-0.3723435998,
0.1555343121,
0.7732628584,
0.5940715075,
-0.5231841207,
-0.0805514902,
0.4004300833,
-0.115112029,
0.2091451585,
0.7583140135,
0.6847786307,
-0.1174741015,
0.4976350963,
-0.3312885463,
-0.3411082923,
-0.2757853866,
-0.981566906,
-1.1225025654,
-0.714106977,
-0.111126788,
-0.1898082793,
0.0397986509,
0.9827786684,
1.0807781219,
-1.0289384127,
-0.2445726991,
0.2309570014,
0.3053656816,
-0.7910194993,
-0.1253883094,
0.4508772194,
-0.5458694696,
-0.5636128187,
0.700571239,
0.1312462538,
-0.0076243635,
0.1024700254,
-0.0113469558,
-0.001085804,
0.1019748375,
0.5996661186,
0.2878876925,
-0.7931900024,
-0.5796991587,
-0.1482670009,
-0.1376830935,
0.0316659249,
0.9089409113,
-0.8923983574,
0.1998424828,
0.3993667066,
0.904350698,
0.7061002254,
-0.0942428038,
0.2528743446,
-0.9872711897,
0.2032619268,
0.4302482009,
0.5311963558,
0.352494508,
-0.2554658055,
0.5477414131,
-0.0952926576,
-0.4985337257,
-0.7760077119,
0.3510498106,
-1.1499487162,
-0.4328860343,
1.183870554,
-0.3559598029,
0.074534446,
-0.1532234997,
0.0166147035,
-0.0852688625,
-0.3385171294,
0.9696592093,
0.7379410267,
-0.3258750737,
-0.1909876615,
-0.3740379512,
0.2781761289,
0.6174924374,
-0.8670445085,
-0.1685010642,
0.5651582479,
0.5269395709,
-0.152773872,
0.5426002741,
0.0437429808,
0.2586074173,
-0.5064167976,
-0.0312219113,
-0.1545737982,
-0.5327140689,
-0.0134975398,
0.1374998838,
-0.0339246579,
-0.1693448871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14904v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14904v1 | Identifying Informational Sources in News Articles | 2023-05-24T08:56:35 | 2023-05-24T08:56:35 | Alexander Spangher, Nanyun Peng, Jonathan May, Emilio Ferrara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | News articles are driven by the informational sources journalists use in
reporting. Modeling when, how and why sources get used together in stories can
help us better understand the information we consume and even help journalists
with the task of producing it. In this work, we take steps toward this goal by
constructing the largest and widest-ranging annotated dataset, to date, of
informational sources used in news writing. We show that our dataset can be
used to train high-performing models for information detection and source
attribution. We further introduce a novel task, source prediction, to study the
compositionality of sources in news articles. We show good performance on this
task, which we argue is an important proof for narrative science exploring the
internal structure of news articles and aiding in planning-based language
generation, and an important step towards a source-recommendation system to aid
journalists. | [
-0.0128039839,
-0.4168011248,
0.803994596,
0.2280037403,
-0.2666783035,
0.0609944873,
-0.2982132733,
-0.6649309397,
0.1352472752,
0.4062661529,
-0.4536930323,
-0.3386189342,
-0.5970814228,
-0.0371223874,
-0.7120189667,
1.0401005745,
-0.1190360114,
0.2212206274,
-0.2972037196,
-0.0520825647,
-0.3666544259,
-0.386672318,
-0.444462508,
-0.0264917314,
0.8380680084,
0.3105677664,
0.6531271338,
1.0713481903,
0.3922140598,
0.2622872293,
0.0479383357,
0.1224219203,
-0.3405247033,
0.1467588544,
-0.2031521201,
-0.7335392237,
0.4670597613,
0.2877903879,
0.6389585733,
0.5453997254,
0.1285089403,
0.3731331229,
-0.2031386942,
0.5252925754,
-0.6545271277,
0.1875640452,
-0.5672991276,
-0.071329385,
-0.4429739714,
-0.331248045,
-0.3968613446,
-0.5202874541,
-0.0779428408,
-0.671362102,
0.2317647636,
-0.0665076226,
0.5531781316,
0.1321174204,
-0.6405369639,
-0.5020412207,
-0.7651850581,
0.5386546254,
-0.4862442017,
0.5037455559,
0.4495801926,
0.1656273454,
0.1119083688,
-0.4539248645,
-0.5057047606,
-0.3227913082,
-0.1511220932,
-0.0259997621,
-0.0540091805,
-0.4728756249,
0.1560859233,
0.0063166451,
-0.5754405856,
-0.2362760752,
-0.6917430758,
0.0486878082,
0.6085156202,
-0.0559989773,
0.2607639134,
-0.3105841279,
0.1071650833,
0.0576356463,
-0.6669746041,
0.0713028759,
0.600643456,
0.3606214225,
0.0622037388,
0.9096786976,
-0.2224903703,
0.9076786041,
-0.1345573813,
-0.3762714565,
0.0670012981,
-0.5676937103,
0.1738690585,
0.7122654915,
0.5537356138,
0.4512133002,
0.1323985606,
-0.0258920249,
0.049161382,
-0.0681349486,
0.3679483831,
-0.5279417038,
-0.1960267574,
-0.1755457669,
-0.4961888194,
-0.7322443724,
0.2804633975,
-0.1592793465,
-0.661670208,
-0.4617765546,
0.1846300364,
-0.2349706441,
-0.1385756433,
-0.2378927916,
-0.4155452251,
-0.2000641376,
0.2363277525,
-0.6676594019,
-0.1466722041,
0.4041529,
0.7936484814,
0.0111580715,
-0.2675139606,
-0.5719335079,
0.5419121981,
-0.5579158068,
0.9381938577,
-0.5299301147,
0.2312694043,
0.0441306122,
-0.1418334842,
0.3943730891,
-0.3662514687,
0.6297358274,
-0.3935683966,
0.334580034,
-0.4584492445,
-0.5162731409,
-0.2366755158,
-0.0014362745,
-1.2313315868,
0.6429572105,
0.3533005118,
-1.0033259392,
0.5748345256,
-0.4261452854,
-0.6898351908,
-0.1159748435,
-0.059808854,
-0.1976905465,
0.4973430037,
0.2263829261,
0.1980560422,
-0.20755817,
0.475951463,
0.1478242427,
-0.0349060595,
0.4727339447,
-0.1809704453,
0.5341473818,
0.2150156945,
0.1156839728,
0.0198216997,
-1.0661820173,
-0.4519998431,
0.2295170724,
-0.6375129223,
-0.5786722898,
0.2398122102,
0.1489554644,
-0.0522607788,
0.0414428934,
-0.5871782899,
-0.0193479601,
0.1116157994,
0.3490416408,
0.4366025925,
0.177880764,
0.4707911909,
-0.2291047275,
0.1739473194,
0.1148609668,
0.0219743047,
-0.4954677224,
-0.1306411028,
-0.489255935,
0.0675906613,
0.3945144415,
0.2828870714,
-0.705052793,
0.3152636588,
0.1716359407,
-0.6249656081,
-0.3903220892,
0.1482452303,
0.1277648509,
0.7274266481,
0.1826300472,
0.2272825986,
-0.9815408587,
-0.7303565145,
-0.7644794583,
-0.3010226786,
0.0338832028,
-0.3605553508,
0.0272062235,
0.4330488741,
0.9471319914,
-0.3972858787,
0.1581846476,
-0.3533421159,
0.3121799827,
0.3785949349,
0.3895733058,
0.4989513159,
-1.0496604443,
-0.2969820499,
-0.1461310238,
-1.033241868,
-0.1098139137,
-0.2225279659,
-0.0575630888,
-0.0737743601,
0.6126835942,
-0.3893844485,
0.2411254942,
0.4850412309,
-0.4872978926,
0.5142014623,
0.3110167682,
0.0590419546,
-1.0653110743,
0.0821119547,
0.3865835667,
-0.2637612522,
-0.4740097225,
-0.3827170432,
0.1365443915,
-0.2410385758,
-0.22766909,
0.4186815619,
-0.4504970908,
-0.1280077398,
-0.4108750522,
-0.3060126603,
0.1765612513,
-0.0173421167,
0.1885751635,
0.5582491159,
0.2417237461,
-0.3566309512,
0.5490753055,
0.1578233838,
-0.8866468668,
0.5151945353,
-0.2923520505,
-0.3477015197,
-0.5289841294,
0.2796473801,
-0.6090092063,
-0.5160803199,
-0.1102349758,
-0.4220223725,
0.0602135547,
-0.0747799054,
-0.6942727566,
-0.1983894408,
-0.0226319879,
0.2821125984,
-0.2073449939,
-0.4358491302,
0.3497002721,
0.3815643489,
-0.4553323686,
-0.564261198,
-0.7921500206,
0.0445580706,
-0.1483617127,
-0.480797559,
0.1696662605,
-0.100939557,
-0.4633024335,
0.4103794694,
-0.1341936141,
-0.2113699615,
0.1060586721,
0.2831690311,
0.305375874,
-0.358748734,
0.4611011744,
-0.0334328413,
-0.0568417311,
0.0631539598,
-0.1281947196,
0.2212255299,
0.3480169773,
-0.3013708591,
-0.3805451393,
0.7111667991,
0.3684693277,
-0.426993221,
0.777913928,
0.6634217501,
-0.3414001763,
0.0692902431,
-0.6253065467,
-0.1681349277,
-0.3615458608,
0.6092708111,
0.0217241887,
-0.5040680766,
0.2306577265,
0.3725428283,
-0.0762310326,
0.4776222408,
0.2777733505,
0.0405311435,
0.9490369558,
0.5878766179,
-0.4068667591,
0.8603742123,
-0.0168819688,
0.1009109467,
-0.3361005485,
-0.2646021247,
-0.412161231,
-0.3062545657,
-0.1758231968,
0.1093032584,
0.3128795922,
0.1269873232,
-0.0544271022,
0.2696138322,
-0.3524745107,
0.8419350982,
0.9830995202,
0.0635386705,
0.7210729718,
-0.0099736322,
0.4940062463,
0.2473264784,
-0.4427719116,
-0.3075135946,
0.9694455266,
0.3002924323,
0.7930844426,
-0.196262747,
0.4784606695,
0.1341128051,
0.3403928578,
-0.5985026956,
0.2404534519,
0.0878060386,
-0.5122462511,
-0.0335417576,
-0.2381863296,
-0.6616051793,
-0.1764625013,
-0.3276105821,
-0.300219655,
0.2069338709,
-0.2962307334,
-0.3954305649,
0.0674027503,
-0.6910862923,
0.4942516983,
-0.2329922915,
-0.0033409928,
0.0124077108,
-0.5167785287,
0.2171128392,
0.0825213492,
0.2305493951,
-0.1636223793,
0.1201034486,
0.8560299873,
0.058180429,
0.4418065846,
-0.1148101315,
-0.0822978094,
0.4712518752,
-0.1448903829,
0.4021641016,
0.3748183846,
-0.2894818783,
0.0528720319,
-0.315006882,
-0.1246167645,
-0.4629787207,
0.4746772647,
-0.5935809612,
-0.3065188825,
-0.443336904,
-0.8939727545,
-0.107194446,
0.1521518528,
0.6173453927,
0.5848998427,
-0.027806811,
0.3763094246,
0.2305017859,
0.4297481775,
0.6062777042,
0.6651674509,
0.0035108803,
-0.2630913854,
0.8180410862,
0.2793964744,
-0.2632063031,
0.3655019104,
0.1827935278,
-0.1853488833,
-0.6447703242,
-0.3662057221,
0.1802650988,
-0.6893547773,
-0.5047579408,
-0.2937841117,
-0.471485883,
-0.0795071721,
-0.1582743376,
-0.3503282666,
-0.410728544,
-0.6015803814,
-0.5724272132,
0.1151766032,
0.9329093099,
-0.1342701763,
0.3159907758,
-0.7561604381,
0.2077907622,
0.2193696201,
0.0769902617,
-0.3827141523,
0.0980239362,
-0.7539981604,
-0.125799492,
-0.2887367606,
-1.130320549,
0.2497701794,
-0.0553174652,
0.7143211961,
0.3763753474,
-0.038338434,
0.0789086148,
-0.3145931065,
0.711976409,
0.132281363,
-0.6949970126,
0.8635554314,
-0.5093564391,
0.1381597221,
0.7340203524,
0.5625200868,
-0.3443186879,
-0.6056982875,
-0.4696024358,
-0.516597867,
0.5504817963,
0.049325645,
-0.0343454108,
-0.0680754781,
0.285530597,
0.2506532669,
0.5423403382,
-0.9720774293,
0.1340681463,
-0.1582554579,
-0.4936104715,
-0.1634358913,
-0.411103934,
-0.372792244,
-0.1397519112,
0.5760273337,
-0.0994802713,
0.185536176,
0.1707649231,
-0.2476552874,
-0.6296790242,
-0.1242795214,
0.5539976358,
1.0995564461,
-0.0383127853,
0.2967341542,
-0.4833949208,
-0.3762634397,
0.1082046703,
0.2891049087,
-0.14949359,
0.3666457236,
0.6257100701,
0.8966095448,
0.0502791442,
-0.7046965957,
0.6501647234,
0.0681611896,
0.0501387566,
-0.4777005613,
0.1105663329,
0.1723637283,
0.7850054502,
0.8557968736,
0.1747789234,
0.2204004973,
-0.8871052265,
0.0820344612,
0.248672694,
-0.294238925,
-0.417189002,
0.3879526556,
-0.0383558609,
0.115376018,
0.4310895801,
0.0249507241,
-0.2964370549,
0.498996526,
0.6486529112,
0.511572659,
-0.3313489258,
0.3194355667,
0.3913359344,
0.0632007122,
-0.2882841229,
0.2034817785,
0.1882935762,
-0.6102157235,
-0.5630669594,
-0.5378379226,
-0.1224612892,
0.2242794931,
-0.4749486744,
0.2747123837,
-0.1299545467,
0.1848439276,
0.4724216163,
-0.0507740825,
-0.3237882853,
0.2214503139,
0.5519348383,
0.7996711135,
-1.1141182184,
0.6070632935,
0.6001417637,
-0.5093795061,
-0.6670725942,
0.1582954973,
0.0417675748,
-0.5102564692,
0.7309622765,
0.2314578891,
0.5740364194,
-0.1650667489,
-0.8565015793,
-0.96948421,
0.9932444692,
0.8885980248,
-0.1951502264,
-0.3506864607,
-0.0790980682,
0.1080145687,
-0.6448722482,
0.1275464892,
0.2737554312,
0.7455461025,
0.0939655527,
-0.6892071962,
0.0513902903,
-0.2798034847,
-0.1100367904,
0.0457773469,
-0.3748838305,
1.2471641302,
-0.3111715019,
-0.0263867378,
-0.131862998,
0.9412181377,
0.1940722466,
0.470212698,
0.3361418247,
0.2931734324,
0.8222311735,
0.0040054787,
0.9505942464,
-0.127523303,
-0.0554644167,
1.1833381653,
0.2099522352,
0.6405329704,
0.3420318365,
0.1461081505,
0.7501556873,
0.5446650982,
-0.2446426004,
0.9022160172,
-0.0332911983,
-0.4242512286,
0.1044575647,
-0.5946547985,
-0.3153277636,
0.7097776532,
0.1464624852,
-0.8006639481,
-0.33323282,
0.3572734594,
0.0543726087,
0.0465079695,
-0.534499526,
0.9125144482,
-0.2798298895,
-0.6781970859,
0.016610669,
-0.0804052278,
0.1089802682,
-0.5884209275,
-0.0586095825,
0.0408363566,
-0.107202448,
-0.3705568314,
-0.9722977281,
0.354156673,
-0.1230779439,
-0.4973703921,
0.0826146826,
1.0018775463,
-0.7136074305,
-0.6416000128,
-0.099497363,
0.4278861284,
-0.3086081445,
-0.734893322,
0.0271296147,
0.1765344888,
-0.0016095754,
-0.4795648754,
0.191081509,
0.5022065639,
-0.0086339414,
0.1768661141,
0.7502426505,
0.2494667619,
0.0064197774,
-0.1742989719,
0.9754303694,
-0.8133520484,
-0.7768536806,
-0.7721890807,
0.5129968524,
-0.4122147858,
-0.1994675696,
0.5346819162,
0.9715249538,
0.8529907465,
-0.1251847595,
1.1812993288,
-0.0164994188,
0.5685268641,
-0.5886238813,
0.5049311519,
-0.2768576145,
-0.2228800803,
0.0491743535,
-0.9411991239,
-0.1670147926,
0.5197452307,
-0.011707562,
-0.1426323354,
0.8118343353,
0.3368002176,
-0.1053270325,
0.4942572713,
-0.108632572,
-0.0272992961,
0.1771088094,
0.2724799216,
0.9800910354,
-0.0281630438,
0.4813073277,
-0.5469506383,
0.0113356346,
-0.3429196775,
-0.9822817445,
-0.6325385571,
-0.9697300196,
-0.1740563512,
-0.1486611217,
0.1669781655,
0.6373499632,
0.702891171,
-0.6748843193,
-0.057686504,
-0.379175812,
0.1682334095,
-0.139944315,
-0.1741581559,
0.0947203264,
-0.3948154151,
-0.5706915855,
0.6294341683,
0.0823632628,
-0.0691370443,
-0.2345968336,
0.3311493993,
-0.322149545,
-0.0829354078,
0.4728884995,
0.2119506449,
-0.2548514605,
-0.3776243031,
-0.3269536793,
-0.1899151504,
0.0373060629,
1.243191123,
-0.59706074,
0.3111046553,
0.5818424225,
0.4477959573,
0.5010214448,
0.1525119096,
0.576489687,
-1.1732754707,
0.308144927,
0.2276510447,
0.2200170159,
0.4843091369,
-0.6354661584,
0.6141608357,
0.1655825675,
-0.2858318388,
-0.7305498123,
-0.0496308021,
-0.9107829928,
-0.2078685313,
1.1311131716,
0.0801636428,
-0.3477624059,
0.0548330694,
-0.2885691822,
0.4766813815,
-0.4268166423,
0.4448828697,
0.8696343303,
-0.1521288306,
-0.4306897819,
-0.6437652111,
0.4981610775,
-0.2519796193,
-0.9089821577,
-0.0484632663,
0.7016413808,
0.1134765595,
0.4422013462,
0.5255488157,
0.1024515703,
0.1113444939,
-0.0423530079,
-0.2718676031,
-0.4593659639,
-0.6311418414,
0.1527894884,
0.2908474207,
-0.1372116208,
-0.0370177031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14902v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14902v2 | M4: Multi-generator, Multi-domain, and Multi-lingual Black-Box Machine-Generated Text Detection | 2023-05-24T08:55:11 | 2024-03-10T01:04:48 | Yuxia Wang, Jonibek Mansurov, Petar Ivanov, Jinyan Su, Artem Shelmanov, Akim Tsvigun, Chenxi Whitehouse, Osama Mohammed Afzal, Tarek Mahmoud, Toru Sasaki, Thomas Arnold, Alham Fikri Aji, Nizar Habash, Iryna Gurevych, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capability to
generate fluent responses to a wide variety of user queries. However, this has
also raised concerns about the potential misuse of such texts in journalism,
education, and academia. In this study, we strive to create automated systems
that can detect machine-generated texts and pinpoint potential misuse. We first
introduce a large-scale benchmark \textbf{M4}, which is a multi-generator,
multi-domain, and multi-lingual corpus for machine-generated text detection.
Through an extensive empirical study of this dataset, we show that it is
challenging for detectors to generalize well on instances from unseen domains
or LLMs. In such cases, detectors tend to misclassify machine-generated text as
human-written. These results show that the problem is far from solved and that
there is a lot of room for improvement. We believe that our dataset will enable
future research towards more robust approaches to this pressing societal
problem. The dataset is available at https://github.com/mbzuai-nlp/M4. | [
-0.4400610328,
-0.7599718571,
0.4522663355,
-0.0252888184,
-0.0935374498,
0.2385906279,
-0.11168015,
-0.6479253173,
-0.0920933336,
0.5520316362,
-0.5314520597,
-0.371586889,
-0.6819407344,
0.7649005651,
-0.5682549477,
0.8078870773,
-0.1147890985,
-0.2696400583,
0.0126549136,
-0.0897113681,
-0.5415459871,
-0.8988761902,
-0.4319978356,
-0.3382368982,
0.5462201834,
0.5113431811,
0.3289055824,
0.3208253384,
0.2538149357,
0.3256175518,
0.4426054955,
0.5039458275,
-0.5652678013,
0.095892027,
-0.0150498841,
-0.3852273524,
-0.2060955316,
-0.0527490452,
0.7682848573,
0.266644448,
0.2372457385,
0.2025321126,
0.1471743584,
0.3107946813,
-0.586728394,
-0.0246793386,
-0.9554694891,
0.0142971296,
-0.5326996446,
-0.4890545905,
-0.5703232884,
-0.0631141365,
-0.2596423626,
-0.4459647536,
0.2987573147,
0.296548754,
0.7602635622,
-0.0230214,
-0.6297111511,
-0.4601660371,
-0.5563029051,
1.0897939205,
-0.5883482695,
0.3558397293,
0.3989660442,
0.2892734408,
-0.2299489677,
-0.4735420346,
-0.7435386181,
0.283509165,
0.058950834,
0.0069915126,
-0.4058184624,
-0.3943128884,
0.3214211464,
0.116719991,
-0.6889607906,
0.2129873782,
-0.3151375353,
-0.6580018401,
0.4981222749,
0.2196941972,
0.2954833508,
-0.3188820183,
-0.2655242085,
0.2539187968,
-0.9231603146,
-0.3076119125,
0.6997857094,
0.2005792558,
0.0888914987,
0.6096284389,
-0.0569739565,
0.6003767252,
-0.3218049407,
-0.2783685923,
0.4726050496,
-0.5282200575,
-0.024594631,
-0.0928280801,
1.0338677168,
0.3254150152,
0.5650036931,
0.05452976,
-0.2848757207,
0.3507193029,
0.3988024294,
-0.8315335512,
-0.0349711329,
0.1267839372,
-0.2458414137,
-0.5494796038,
-0.2255051136,
-0.7527031898,
-0.1805538535,
-0.0774326622,
0.1651907563,
-0.2990151346,
-0.2092209458,
0.1825248897,
-0.0586314946,
0.1083096564,
0.0012806728,
-0.9197663069,
-0.0452270322,
0.5231609941,
0.6232413054,
-0.22186023,
-0.4309961498,
-0.4086483717,
0.2491457462,
-0.2405720353,
0.9699777961,
-0.3924062252,
-0.3693660796,
0.3180186152,
0.1445175558,
0.1429863721,
-0.6743978858,
0.880924046,
-0.5010864735,
0.3026009798,
-0.2389146388,
-0.435834825,
0.119231239,
0.4609750509,
-0.729747951,
0.9871560335,
0.0132262688,
-0.9442427158,
0.4186840653,
-0.4942231178,
-0.3550553918,
0.0434054285,
-0.2545512617,
-0.7794493437,
-0.1915521324,
0.2898539603,
0.5822037458,
-0.1537361145,
0.4738445282,
-0.2524280548,
-0.4425005317,
0.4738793373,
-0.7003206015,
0.5038784146,
0.1331307292,
-0.2806686163,
-0.1197152436,
-0.7342182398,
-0.1198811382,
0.1921255291,
-0.6645280123,
-0.2687699199,
-0.1176950634,
0.2799909115,
0.3122370541,
0.22815907,
-0.583206892,
-0.0423750132,
-0.1792271435,
0.3196924329,
0.8602547646,
-0.071882762,
0.1045284122,
-0.4176324606,
0.586545229,
0.2591663003,
-0.3047440946,
-0.488420248,
-0.661036551,
-0.4942727685,
-0.1977560818,
0.3663561344,
0.5761107206,
-1.1620205641,
0.3772043884,
-0.0988190249,
-0.0680912063,
-0.4913913012,
0.2569399476,
0.5705792308,
0.3764729202,
0.3445328176,
0.0075413501,
-0.6862342358,
-0.9936321974,
-0.5592771173,
0.0619412214,
-0.0357592516,
0.1418721825,
0.7981658578,
-0.701849103,
0.663474679,
-0.4880462587,
-0.2154654413,
-0.2519198358,
0.253839612,
-0.1880527139,
0.3055029511,
0.472248137,
-0.8308755159,
-0.1545422524,
-0.2459104359,
-1.1065837145,
-0.4535143971,
0.0393324643,
-0.1830075681,
0.417522192,
0.4372329712,
-0.4551390409,
0.1816000044,
0.6159229279,
-0.2215689868,
0.9941606522,
0.0128441276,
0.2354453504,
-1.1772664785,
0.1009332985,
0.2194076478,
-0.2849088311,
-0.6610795259,
-0.0679215342,
0.3156836033,
-0.1987264156,
-0.2952483892,
0.4886414409,
-0.4149591327,
-0.2156707346,
-0.4891578555,
0.2335523665,
0.2792674303,
0.3186179698,
-0.3781520724,
0.992138803,
0.132983312,
-0.5830756426,
0.1747054458,
0.2831289172,
-0.4671188295,
0.6638361216,
-0.4242780507,
-0.0222286284,
-0.0108409245,
0.2617183924,
-0.8099895716,
-0.334467262,
0.2976830304,
-0.653375268,
0.1306810975,
0.0736679211,
-0.9137669206,
-0.3928343058,
-0.3278562427,
0.4666888714,
0.0200273897,
-0.5049958229,
0.2842929363,
0.6302650571,
-0.1531797945,
-0.9096926451,
-0.6759005189,
0.4422934353,
-0.3094845414,
-0.4524253607,
0.2817284763,
-0.1942420602,
-0.074842304,
-0.2315773368,
0.0130038923,
-0.1639132351,
0.2071079761,
-0.048476629,
0.0894811153,
-0.1759860218,
0.1586944461,
0.1704587638,
-0.2900848985,
0.1939712167,
-0.1665563434,
0.4989865422,
0.1102714092,
-0.2150985003,
-0.3694968522,
0.5782768726,
0.5325590968,
-0.2827171087,
0.2912064791,
0.7298746705,
-0.5781465769,
-0.311716795,
-0.3977568746,
-0.1477577686,
-0.5036174059,
0.1581647992,
-0.5943157673,
-0.9594292641,
0.2747801244,
-0.0961319879,
0.1514211744,
0.4658062756,
0.6675338149,
0.0835429579,
1.0115480423,
0.4964940548,
-0.3036487103,
0.1782946289,
-0.2592157722,
0.3070339859,
-0.642521143,
-0.0210497677,
-0.7345153093,
-0.098462373,
-0.6349180341,
-0.2528631687,
0.1605020761,
-0.3378993571,
0.035769932,
0.3496932387,
-0.4275020957,
0.470245719,
0.4614420831,
-0.2683523893,
0.5811162591,
-0.0273257047,
-0.1905100793,
-0.1816098392,
-0.5170844793,
-0.9907109141,
1.281678319,
0.2005842328,
0.5526438355,
0.0900873393,
0.7876589298,
0.3830062747,
0.4145458341,
-0.6727576852,
0.4778761864,
-0.0501626097,
-0.82774508,
0.0420466773,
-0.4993100166,
-1.3858720064,
0.6438142061,
-0.4054349661,
-0.3964669704,
-0.1148251966,
0.0879872665,
0.0781138539,
0.2994940281,
-0.6730530262,
0.9298635721,
-0.2056126893,
-0.2057383955,
0.0360868871,
-0.2814935446,
0.6384471655,
-0.6775383949,
0.62669909,
-0.1904236376,
0.0965901613,
0.5689879656,
0.0641692281,
0.8703631163,
-0.044830665,
-0.372985363,
0.2710006237,
0.0168526992,
0.2539292276,
-0.0398931019,
-0.0625515729,
0.1866666973,
-0.2481296957,
-0.470279932,
0.0204727817,
0.7942078114,
-0.6301130056,
-0.1807022691,
-0.4322104454,
-0.4940274954,
-0.0689701512,
0.571559906,
0.4942053854,
0.7017611861,
-0.3504779935,
0.0513537377,
0.5765163898,
-0.3458376527,
0.3432998955,
0.4914563298,
-0.2973738015,
-0.180293262,
0.9314610362,
0.0687377378,
-0.099698782,
0.2375249267,
0.0635987222,
-0.2822341919,
-0.5907696486,
-0.8131071925,
0.1352098882,
-0.6996049881,
-0.4850252271,
-0.7965552807,
0.1083986312,
-0.3346287608,
-0.1171069741,
0.0928878486,
-0.0123844817,
-0.5165817738,
-0.0982522443,
-0.0688595772,
0.6535525918,
0.2511124909,
0.4732634425,
-0.8131745458,
0.7183983922,
-0.0596195534,
0.1609101146,
-0.3333249092,
-0.4314030707,
-0.3848583996,
0.0161389448,
-0.6606904864,
-0.7856113315,
0.5953532457,
0.0246135183,
0.6835775375,
0.3783475757,
-0.021916002,
0.1957704127,
-0.7681002021,
0.5873003006,
-0.0061651263,
-0.8648692369,
0.3183380365,
-0.4638179243,
0.369792223,
0.320016861,
0.4904960394,
-0.2543004751,
-0.736811161,
-0.5758232474,
-0.5676858425,
0.4415018559,
0.2781198919,
0.1690150499,
0.0685636103,
0.1287297159,
0.1961708069,
0.425175786,
-0.9438672066,
-0.1197652891,
-0.1303421259,
-0.3685865998,
-0.3399215341,
-0.2323684096,
0.0093057761,
0.2356563509,
0.6501255035,
-0.3041846454,
0.3060348332,
-0.131496802,
-0.3903550804,
-0.0516078845,
0.3265031278,
0.6259544492,
0.491514951,
0.0899945423,
0.2443896532,
-0.0796409026,
-0.3916128278,
0.2240977287,
0.0823121667,
-0.211087212,
0.303973645,
0.3431028724,
0.26717031,
0.4224997759,
-0.737323761,
0.416387856,
0.0078070695,
-0.4982253313,
-0.3250642419,
-0.0574487038,
0.0245245565,
0.0520072356,
0.512304306,
0.00465158,
0.4172956645,
-0.589006424,
0.4394543767,
0.5107791424,
0.0692339465,
-0.3794339895,
0.5759928823,
0.3526712954,
-0.341414839,
0.2043320835,
-0.2365432382,
-0.7898074389,
0.4567575157,
0.7419035435,
0.5893439054,
-0.0565742031,
0.1010582969,
0.2676160932,
0.4992974401,
-0.0450134687,
0.2475078404,
0.233698532,
-1.19455266,
-0.460360229,
-0.488442719,
-0.4760696292,
0.4374755919,
-0.2500811219,
0.3205737472,
-0.145550549,
-0.3510932326,
0.545222044,
0.0840997845,
-0.4768010974,
0.0639589205,
0.083122462,
0.5829914808,
-0.9124646187,
0.8167735934,
0.4328183532,
-0.1280459762,
-0.252530992,
-0.0129410876,
0.3427815437,
-0.6749664545,
0.3947120905,
0.6268125176,
-0.407192409,
-0.0573154241,
-0.6762176752,
-0.3857702017,
0.8088395596,
0.1708678007,
-0.3006989956,
0.1865551174,
0.1663966626,
0.4240213633,
-0.4773528576,
-0.1621510834,
0.625944972,
0.5752068162,
-0.4463407099,
-0.7145863771,
-0.0894998163,
-0.2117046118,
-0.3345217705,
0.466571629,
-0.4082568884,
0.8572489023,
0.022316359,
-0.2219850272,
-0.1029363573,
0.2956390977,
0.5052449703,
0.6274068952,
0.2518382072,
0.5865166783,
0.7264657617,
-0.0610167757,
0.8045227528,
-0.104058221,
0.1588688791,
0.7195909619,
-0.4805867672,
0.6633695364,
0.1966464967,
0.0353405215,
0.4736291468,
0.3607826233,
-0.1587957144,
0.1865811646,
0.3032317758,
-0.4935004711,
-0.0405746736,
0.1527402848,
-0.1913238466,
0.4870483279,
0.6860661507,
-0.2551234961,
-0.1624648869,
0.0533514433,
0.056168858,
0.1568030864,
-0.114410311,
0.5937975645,
0.1705376804,
-0.5889434814,
0.6487256289,
0.38992697,
1.1050693989,
-0.3129605055,
0.0397890918,
0.0400440618,
0.185511753,
-0.2064838111,
-0.6701897979,
0.2680846751,
0.2867196202,
-0.1999327838,
-0.2703738809,
1.2670624256,
-0.4795731902,
-0.3941822052,
0.2613858581,
0.8421026468,
0.3345666528,
-0.0609113649,
-0.670646131,
0.2544936538,
0.0277322903,
-0.013260901,
0.3029153049,
0.6604675055,
-0.1073198766,
0.7350608706,
0.8543453813,
-0.2013635635,
0.1242142096,
0.1023482829,
0.6540122032,
-0.6957967281,
-0.3236234188,
-0.8272591829,
0.2185335755,
-0.1537723243,
-0.2154128253,
0.833953619,
0.8324852586,
0.9466209412,
-0.190680325,
1.2206251621,
0.3864833117,
0.7156023979,
-0.502291441,
0.5016533732,
-0.4796520174,
0.1588721126,
-0.4143818021,
-0.8219822049,
-0.3369752765,
0.5229130983,
0.0468401909,
-0.101488784,
0.5936405659,
0.6871961951,
-0.1341507733,
-0.0358204953,
0.5028143525,
-0.0965973586,
0.50082165,
0.5249109268,
0.9736872911,
-0.5610051155,
0.8595637679,
0.2527526617,
-0.023495283,
-0.4939773679,
-0.8204208612,
-0.9099572897,
-0.506860137,
-0.1325275749,
-0.2604161203,
-0.1272199601,
0.3669490218,
0.4279553294,
-0.7114834785,
-0.2568261623,
0.3030257225,
0.2407657951,
0.1948941052,
-0.2153549194,
-0.1197911501,
-0.3246564865,
-0.8918893933,
0.4306302071,
0.1739626527,
0.2227337956,
-0.4007757902,
0.142019093,
-0.2714489698,
0.1359896958,
0.9101274014,
0.1014548242,
-0.5013407469,
-0.2886301279,
-0.176483497,
-0.2580593824,
0.0670804754,
0.9644151926,
-0.5320224762,
0.2911787331,
0.3307433128,
0.7407292128,
0.3798321486,
0.0053371983,
0.5891344547,
-0.9072819948,
-0.0533599742,
0.1122273877,
0.6196132302,
0.6493396163,
-0.2227780819,
0.3153499365,
0.3777337968,
-0.755094409,
-0.9463531971,
0.4364638031,
-0.6912204027,
-0.3741989732,
1.0914005041,
0.0211103242,
-0.026253067,
-0.6841003895,
-0.2937656045,
0.2108362168,
-0.5157400966,
0.5964870453,
0.8525442481,
0.2110428512,
-0.0904135555,
-0.9710398912,
0.3916453719,
0.0672385842,
-1.1120740175,
0.0862492323,
0.8950369358,
0.3202245831,
0.2354647517,
0.8882374167,
-0.1104797944,
0.01345025,
-0.1571696252,
0.0423289686,
0.14531371,
-0.4986145198,
-0.3554778099,
0.2173700929,
-0.1041051969,
-0.1383028328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14901v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14901v3 | Chain-of-Questions Training with Latent Answers for Robust Multistep Question Answering | 2023-05-24T08:55:08 | 2023-12-23T06:05:26 | Wang Zhu, Jesse Thomason, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We train a language model (LM) to robustly answer multistep questions by
generating and answering sub-questions. We propose Chain-of-Questions, a
framework that trains a model to generate sub-questions and sub-answers one at
a time by leveraging human annotated question decomposition meaning
representation (QDMR). The key technical challenge is that QDMR only contains
sub-questions but not answers to those sub-questions, so we treat sub-answers
as latent variables and optimize them using a novel dynamic mixture of Hard-EM
and MAPO. Chain-of-Questions greatly outperforms strong neuro-symbolic methods
by 9.0 F1 on DROP contrast set, and outperforms GPT-3.5 by 24.3 F1 on HOTPOTQA
adversarial set, thus demonstrating the effectiveness and robustness of our
framework. | [
-0.6157843471,
-1.2396484613,
0.3967591822,
-0.2655595243,
-0.2486654967,
0.5564532876,
0.1559646577,
-0.3009546697,
0.0765552297,
0.4940360188,
-0.8831109405,
-0.1142551005,
-0.3818568587,
0.0669150725,
-0.2875705361,
1.2581566572,
-0.0314761139,
0.1296497732,
-0.2983763516,
-0.2984004319,
-0.1364749372,
-0.8497485518,
-0.7626903653,
-0.2661501467,
0.9085245728,
0.2096457779,
0.6130412817,
0.5196096301,
0.551158011,
0.2072276026,
-0.2000448555,
0.0272003897,
-0.261417985,
0.3494684696,
-0.0212412197,
-0.4886622727,
-0.53080374,
-0.2786179483,
0.5007970333,
0.8267272711,
-0.3015041649,
0.3012840748,
-0.0874142051,
0.3770672381,
-0.7138239145,
-0.3346403539,
-0.7577731609,
0.0820080414,
0.066687949,
-0.000434356,
-0.146173656,
-0.3205024302,
0.0423240326,
-0.4654227197,
0.0700124651,
-0.0169067625,
0.7152835727,
0.3757925034,
-0.6043381691,
-0.1403677613,
-0.5827267766,
0.4688020051,
-0.3910436928,
0.31063357,
0.4184944928,
0.3635591269,
0.0550710186,
-0.5742585063,
-0.5036640167,
0.094864279,
0.0847133175,
0.2156674564,
0.2455982417,
0.0751252174,
0.2494304925,
0.5050199628,
-0.8926102519,
-0.0170240644,
-0.2986473441,
-0.2255147845,
0.3993541002,
0.4069015682,
0.1727912426,
0.0877390429,
-0.515149951,
-0.3123772442,
-0.6367979646,
0.1158997864,
0.3627747893,
0.0115670683,
0.216160953,
0.4208813608,
-0.0689459667,
0.6999973059,
0.0564225987,
-0.1011588797,
0.0010594563,
-0.5720338821,
0.190758124,
-0.2516317964,
0.6952508688,
0.051581163,
0.0900848657,
-0.1171797365,
-0.3134450912,
-0.0326559804,
0.212860778,
-0.6433827877,
-0.3024781346,
0.2577419281,
-0.1972361952,
-0.3502981365,
0.0852314234,
-0.8105978966,
-0.1299466342,
0.1251456738,
0.4461953044,
-0.1235123053,
-0.3970755339,
0.1668991894,
-0.1951437443,
0.3451056778,
0.3476593494,
-0.8163599968,
0.6808796525,
0.3742854297,
0.5102378726,
0.0258194283,
-0.3763576448,
-0.8118093014,
0.0223083775,
-0.3360980153,
0.5796123147,
-0.3500394225,
-0.0779765025,
-0.0535242222,
-0.0982201546,
-0.1726545393,
-0.498084873,
-0.0422878973,
-0.8958482146,
0.2294930667,
-0.2873046994,
-0.4254694581,
0.1649909317,
0.7380412221,
-0.7115761638,
1.128436327,
0.0694712326,
-0.9371124506,
0.0956736133,
-0.2818071842,
-0.3506315649,
-0.1927610934,
-0.2345817536,
-0.326153934,
-0.1383396685,
0.5530143976,
0.304112643,
-0.3219674826,
0.2370675504,
-0.3127255142,
-0.1298457384,
0.4929795861,
-0.3120038509,
0.5343580246,
0.1981318295,
-0.1038974747,
0.0854924545,
-0.7603669167,
0.2674366832,
0.2309368253,
-0.3906367719,
-0.2918159366,
-0.0784517005,
-0.0771156698,
0.6183233261,
0.2444397211,
-0.5048178434,
0.1908638626,
-0.3096942902,
0.2731375098,
0.7761148214,
0.2452774793,
0.2640990019,
-0.3324446678,
0.8987452388,
0.2492516786,
0.211376816,
-0.1333800703,
-0.533391118,
-0.7329362631,
0.1987835765,
0.201259613,
0.7008289695,
-1.1886497736,
0.3733654916,
0.0430007577,
-0.4693273306,
-0.3005428612,
0.0530732013,
0.5565699339,
0.7388163805,
0.3886785507,
-0.2389881611,
-0.3412993848,
-0.7255311012,
-0.0197669882,
-0.2815237343,
0.1181408316,
-0.0323771909,
0.9216683507,
0.1964390725,
0.7738264799,
-0.7434703112,
0.3070167005,
-0.30731076,
0.257722497,
0.044549562,
0.4605514705,
0.3021678925,
-0.8841997385,
-0.1966287345,
-0.1989049911,
-0.8185275793,
0.3640014529,
-0.0656491667,
-0.0637227744,
-0.1730870456,
0.3995454609,
-0.4373831749,
0.1866262257,
0.4737179875,
-0.0617227592,
0.5211650133,
-0.1010840461,
-0.0188202709,
-1.3852555752,
0.1460555643,
-0.3539372683,
-0.2236440033,
-0.4704607725,
0.2607467473,
-0.2340947688,
-0.356123358,
-0.5592122674,
0.3439848125,
-0.1869732738,
-0.0781102777,
-0.0410611592,
-0.0287131313,
0.1410569251,
0.6725363135,
0.0270985328,
0.752867341,
0.6114754677,
-0.6391125321,
0.4605728686,
0.3454723954,
-0.0859116316,
0.3002648354,
-0.8948045373,
0.6176950932,
-0.2315572351,
0.3490834832,
-0.9777387381,
-0.0857203528,
0.1462553889,
-0.1882653087,
0.0964744464,
-0.1031400561,
-0.6527414918,
-0.4636330605,
-0.3036214709,
0.585829854,
0.45590657,
-0.4535655379,
0.290383786,
0.3731786907,
-0.1327150613,
-0.7193749547,
-0.6479270458,
-0.3440621197,
-0.0554045811,
-0.4758747816,
-0.025163183,
-0.3100734055,
-0.0946960226,
-0.08398927,
-0.4200567603,
-0.5535547137,
0.231101945,
-0.210572958,
0.00756073,
-0.2323203534,
0.1829556078,
0.3282408416,
-0.1555934995,
0.284060061,
-0.3198986948,
0.7533352375,
-0.3143091202,
-0.4248102903,
-0.0849195719,
0.7157081366,
0.4071362317,
-0.5144307613,
0.6876755953,
0.5301312208,
-0.4288267195,
-0.017726345,
-0.0867671371,
-0.4428851902,
-0.4407638907,
0.4001549184,
-0.5414938331,
-1.1578563452,
0.8342937827,
0.0472592227,
0.046638526,
0.3356746733,
0.4750995934,
-0.1001725197,
1.2910826206,
0.3850068152,
0.0074116271,
0.2364352793,
-0.3191577792,
-0.0433642194,
-0.479747653,
-0.2079587132,
-0.4638068974,
-0.1875281781,
-0.5115603805,
-0.2966990173,
0.503683269,
0.369517833,
-0.4551341832,
0.18507725,
-0.4124952555,
0.469103843,
0.5551171303,
0.3212357461,
0.1939199269,
-0.2051024437,
-0.1456455439,
0.2371489555,
-1.0430703163,
-0.3608748019,
1.0262571573,
0.3764240742,
1.1335029602,
-0.0688928291,
0.7826938629,
-0.1119988263,
-0.1590234488,
-0.538854897,
0.5769791603,
0.155610159,
-0.9065293074,
-0.2889022529,
-0.601012826,
-0.6464527845,
0.3135277033,
-0.2026946992,
-0.66683954,
-0.0221198201,
0.1901486963,
-0.4249850512,
0.4982920885,
-0.2627975047,
0.7924289703,
-0.4102234244,
-0.255510658,
0.1256903857,
-1.1613559723,
0.2036533952,
-0.0702658594,
-0.0795288458,
0.1987432539,
-0.0525810085,
0.9409579635,
-0.6607984304,
0.6564463973,
0.0311984643,
-0.1333396137,
0.5422605276,
-0.0106563754,
0.4162041247,
0.2903340161,
-0.0072552813,
0.0370527431,
0.1689472497,
-0.481489718,
-0.8544792533,
0.3793605864,
-0.7532866597,
-0.4433435798,
-0.6593786478,
-0.5241943598,
-0.3085298538,
0.1459708363,
0.3400784433,
0.5546928048,
-0.0837465003,
-0.0650290623,
0.8959843516,
-0.1378289759,
0.4078986645,
-0.1106652617,
-0.2178927064,
-0.8161920309,
0.6554915905,
-0.1166530699,
0.6102164984,
0.6472833753,
0.2877143919,
-0.5906980038,
-0.28024441,
-0.6861982942,
0.0864917338,
-0.8879286051,
-0.0834197626,
-0.6372172832,
-0.3586075306,
-0.1667586416,
0.0800224766,
-0.433170706,
-0.4031642973,
-0.0386467651,
-0.1332360059,
0.2525264323,
0.7109473944,
0.1822389066,
0.1694222987,
-0.8517439365,
0.3994754255,
0.6470187902,
0.1877329051,
-0.1409365535,
-0.2545139194,
-0.2128234059,
0.2006467432,
-0.364643693,
-0.9124388695,
-0.0268463921,
0.1763005853,
0.4220660031,
0.2212765068,
0.2044011354,
0.7447379827,
-0.4999088943,
0.8575466275,
0.3430776,
-0.6948680878,
0.7771623135,
-0.4738404453,
0.3196898103,
0.7738358378,
0.7302008271,
-0.1665206105,
-0.6705527306,
-0.6218417883,
-0.7350317836,
0.3968382776,
0.1537221819,
0.1153956205,
-0.1249153763,
0.5150228739,
0.1459506005,
0.4297614396,
-0.7425951362,
-0.5164491534,
-0.2066470087,
-0.0722979903,
0.0890991613,
-0.128869772,
-0.2231038958,
-0.2800330222,
0.3660913706,
-0.358116895,
0.2519762516,
0.0947112814,
-0.1381098181,
-0.0941068083,
0.4148691595,
0.5545517802,
0.7751928568,
-0.3460668921,
0.3643633425,
0.2713345289,
-0.5520303845,
0.3329559863,
-0.1165702119,
-0.1601451635,
-0.2360829413,
0.362573117,
0.4815650284,
-0.1631387025,
-0.5567363501,
0.348703742,
-0.2333120108,
-0.4600411654,
-0.1414878368,
0.0011016893,
-0.0304944031,
0.0645601973,
0.3916217983,
-0.0164265987,
-0.0168111958,
-0.5800548792,
0.4697290063,
0.0986364558,
-0.5607225895,
-0.423469305,
0.8148496151,
-0.0999236777,
-0.1687631905,
0.6627573967,
-0.0705630109,
-0.7668097019,
0.6572433114,
0.6703674793,
0.5612970591,
-0.1230952591,
0.2314934731,
0.1902750432,
0.3906306922,
-0.0095936824,
0.807716608,
-0.075547792,
-0.5935404301,
-0.3938198686,
-0.4299696088,
-0.6301751733,
0.255741626,
-1.011053443,
-0.0878603607,
-0.671055913,
-0.0064186663,
-0.2886167765,
-0.1919071674,
-0.3888807297,
0.5325860977,
-0.1421709657,
0.5153931975,
-0.9130234122,
0.7913574576,
0.9680289626,
-0.8908822536,
-0.77771312,
0.2417955101,
-0.4441403151,
-0.3466466963,
0.5602552295,
0.0115771908,
-0.1187352538,
0.0985279307,
-0.5345101357,
-0.7999047637,
0.9742512107,
0.3785605431,
-0.3234800398,
0.0368929394,
0.2447909117,
0.535502553,
-0.1770837456,
0.3078120053,
0.0795802698,
0.0722876266,
0.2238109708,
-0.8065034747,
0.0227739308,
-0.3141734898,
-0.1999619007,
0.3192614019,
-0.4621121287,
1.168723464,
-0.1809108406,
0.1237767339,
0.1057857871,
0.50870502,
0.4010280073,
0.2961752713,
0.7474184632,
0.5208390355,
0.7601456642,
-0.0553746819,
1.0764546394,
-0.337243706,
0.4340072572,
1.1578667164,
-0.3333931863,
0.8850364685,
0.6802772284,
-0.0244019516,
0.5040100813,
0.8470193148,
0.4505053461,
0.6411707997,
0.526655972,
-0.2372711748,
-0.6647712588,
0.0330663361,
-0.4483326077,
0.4565549493,
0.0927216858,
0.0822480619,
-0.3320510983,
0.0585453957,
-0.1408750415,
0.0265855696,
-0.1147830635,
0.7895579934,
0.0737770051,
-0.6977429986,
0.6557008624,
-0.2959921062,
0.3122224808,
-0.6630348563,
-0.1150532588,
-0.3199611008,
0.1676505208,
0.1543391645,
-0.709651649,
0.2452061176,
-0.0652888268,
-0.1569868624,
-0.2668733597,
0.5661963224,
-0.4690555632,
-0.5587631464,
0.1030816287,
0.9332231879,
-3.277e-7,
-0.0461266488,
-0.9032928944,
-0.3682155013,
-0.5996962786,
-0.2454947531,
0.4409268498,
0.3546235859,
-0.0547392517,
0.8045477271,
0.6598668694,
-0.2382922918,
0.2262675762,
0.1298483163,
1.2023422718,
-0.5911493897,
-0.4752504826,
-0.7253828049,
0.5864405632,
0.0223923773,
-0.5989981294,
0.568189919,
0.5951253176,
0.8712331057,
0.0151652247,
0.6775801182,
-0.0407080576,
0.2833708227,
-0.5693858862,
0.7242724895,
-0.8849115372,
0.179215163,
-0.4698826671,
-0.7544136047,
-0.2556588948,
0.6167704463,
0.0156863481,
0.1755455285,
0.9508540034,
0.7112317681,
0.0015393205,
-0.1565870345,
0.3609994948,
-0.3018144965,
0.2611023188,
0.8529063463,
1.1680796146,
-0.8376364708,
0.6691111326,
-0.4865227044,
0.0359747969,
0.2753227949,
-0.6329723597,
-0.9965032339,
-0.6285067797,
-0.3815816343,
-0.4965533316,
0.1447035521,
0.7129894495,
0.5769969225,
-0.6786395907,
-0.2711342275,
-0.1585595757,
0.3775669336,
-0.4740027785,
-0.1497916132,
0.4122554958,
-0.2435051203,
-0.3116716743,
0.2612085938,
0.1903907061,
-0.0590357631,
-0.4414769411,
-0.0538805388,
-0.6508610845,
-0.1865534186,
0.49108392,
0.0331150778,
-0.4256647825,
-0.3011972904,
0.5299155712,
-0.0080578933,
0.065970242,
0.8853407502,
-0.4932625294,
0.2431635112,
0.5856580734,
0.8875213265,
0.513035059,
0.0314198211,
0.4522386193,
-1.0063294172,
0.0136570372,
0.5209388733,
0.1548792124,
0.0359690264,
-0.234089449,
0.3330869079,
0.3334328234,
-0.4152611196,
-0.579118669,
0.5053267479,
-0.9973837137,
-0.1848102808,
1.0673905611,
-0.2678438425,
-0.289465636,
-0.4166480005,
0.0489541143,
0.1837199926,
-0.0542635024,
0.4732160568,
0.4910109043,
-0.0732855201,
-0.5066122413,
-0.3131056726,
0.1602640301,
0.4724487066,
-1.0085216761,
-0.2266671509,
0.2934251428,
0.2558853328,
0.2026349604,
0.9282563329,
-0.0184178241,
0.3268791735,
0.1387131512,
-0.0506049097,
-0.0246305447,
-0.5227972269,
-0.2612544894,
0.4148083329,
0.05083289,
-0.479519248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14898v1 | PIVOINE: Instruction Tuning for Open-world Information Extraction | 2023-05-24T08:52:08 | 2023-05-24T08:52:08 | Keming Lu, Xiaoman Pan, Kaiqiang Song, Hongming Zhang, Dong Yu, Jianshu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We consider the problem of Open-world Information Extraction (Open-world IE),
which extracts comprehensive entity profiles from unstructured texts. Different
from the conventional closed-world setting of Information Extraction (IE),
Open-world IE considers a more general situation where entities and relations
could be beyond a predefined ontology. More importantly, we seek to develop a
large language model (LLM) that is able to perform Open-world IE to extract
desirable entity profiles characterized by (possibly fine-grained) natural
language instructions. We achieve this by finetuning LLMs using instruction
tuning. In particular, we construct INSTRUCTOPENWIKI, a substantial instruction
tuning dataset for Open-world IE enriched with a comprehensive corpus,
extensive annotations, and diverse instructions. We finetune the pretrained
BLOOM models on INSTRUCTOPENWIKI and obtain PIVOINE, an LLM for Open-world IE
with strong instruction-following capabilities. Our experiments demonstrate
that PIVOINE significantly outperforms traditional closed-world methods and
other LLM baselines, displaying impressive generalization capabilities on both
unseen instructions and out-of-ontology cases. Consequently, PIVOINE emerges as
a promising solution to tackle the open-world challenge in IE effectively. | [
-0.405023694,
-0.890145421,
0.1967856288,
0.0830877274,
0.072386086,
-0.3877591491,
-0.6981565356,
-0.199798584,
-0.1807689667,
0.7965211868,
-0.6316728592,
-0.8224323988,
-0.4994550347,
-0.287352711,
-0.277086854,
1.053258419,
0.2452605218,
0.1019745171,
-0.1219808385,
0.398981303,
-0.224992767,
0.0367488824,
-0.3337142766,
-0.1723181456,
0.3536978364,
0.9500033855,
0.4228636026,
0.6021897197,
0.5896573663,
0.1379131526,
0.1994052082,
0.4953069389,
-0.7585888505,
0.4346083105,
-0.4727295935,
-0.5400695205,
-0.4189935029,
0.0977111757,
0.4595250785,
0.5571404099,
-0.1452425122,
0.4027146101,
-0.0042873584,
0.5056505203,
-1.1590256691,
0.3220670223,
-0.8482554555,
0.2074846327,
-0.3417422771,
-0.2121932954,
-0.6853859425,
-0.207074523,
0.2972530723,
-1.0157809258,
0.3135515153,
0.3053465486,
0.7991431952,
0.1215069368,
0.1642574221,
-0.3939963579,
-0.882199049,
0.7326859832,
-0.3808276355,
0.2479430884,
0.4015415311,
0.1169807091,
-0.5559543967,
-0.9451546669,
-0.3873496056,
0.0103783291,
0.3695337176,
0.3509049714,
-0.2542686164,
0.0015381597,
0.2875376046,
0.6252325773,
-0.2086757123,
0.2695181072,
-0.4577037096,
-0.0319866687,
0.3879654109,
-0.0831045732,
0.440472424,
0.1911348552,
-0.1330974996,
-0.1440533996,
-0.8633923531,
0.0845541283,
0.3792124987,
0.3964958191,
0.4039745331,
0.812863946,
-0.2304410189,
0.7898003459,
0.1538508981,
0.062160179,
-0.185692817,
0.1682036221,
-0.3131877184,
0.284116298,
0.7818891406,
0.4045295417,
0.5043628216,
-0.4249145091,
-0.0604739189,
-0.6235899329,
0.6942027211,
-1.0648804903,
-0.3759626746,
0.1801580787,
-0.355350852,
-0.1720308065,
0.6653843522,
-1.273930788,
-0.2587431073,
-0.112044543,
0.4783297181,
-0.6847590208,
-0.3294174671,
-0.0160698425,
-0.0356242508,
0.408010751,
0.3720871508,
-1.2188968658,
0.2240010947,
1.0949181318,
1.0152558088,
-0.396427542,
-0.2230544388,
-0.9547536969,
0.1854763627,
-0.2355088145,
0.7844815254,
-1.0533238649,
-0.3704453409,
0.0560961291,
0.2483481318,
-0.0688424259,
-0.4823669195,
0.4648000002,
-0.4978747368,
0.4438798726,
0.0502980463,
-0.7713958025,
-0.0677540004,
-0.0733976066,
-0.8188956976,
0.9957782626,
0.0649148524,
-0.7889986634,
0.1722519696,
-0.9960520267,
-0.2346603125,
0.0449653566,
0.1184038967,
-0.4034649134,
0.5296550393,
0.2923661172,
0.2865112722,
-0.3595888615,
-0.4085673392,
-0.1207527444,
-0.5859032869,
-0.1225059405,
-0.4043904543,
0.7939705253,
0.1538211852,
-0.3795506358,
-0.195036158,
-0.7995311022,
0.3885866404,
-0.0432166755,
-0.2728036642,
-0.5108683705,
0.0569604114,
-0.3423229754,
-0.3806000948,
0.239127636,
-0.8796651959,
0.5969142914,
-0.7550669312,
0.4306526482,
0.5844555497,
0.2160627991,
0.5330119133,
0.1424579471,
0.4642241597,
-0.2784463465,
0.2648210227,
-0.2268700749,
-0.7116752863,
-0.7365879416,
-0.2959389687,
0.4367554486,
0.7043098807,
-0.5208435059,
0.5095044374,
-0.3627613783,
-0.5102624893,
-0.7764753699,
-0.1247624531,
0.3284740746,
0.4253790975,
0.3935346901,
-0.107798703,
-0.2613811493,
-0.6144490838,
-0.2573537827,
0.1707474589,
-0.1347860843,
0.2050883025,
0.2456560731,
0.1308668107,
0.9633551836,
-0.5392756462,
-0.168255344,
0.2375300974,
0.1492254138,
0.2795616388,
0.3006199002,
0.1441053152,
-0.9347090125,
-0.701926589,
0.4964214563,
-0.563207984,
-0.2137130797,
0.2189736068,
-0.6151050925,
-0.1543424726,
0.4017026424,
-0.5465337038,
0.5535539389,
0.3153004348,
-0.0642963424,
0.3743399084,
-0.302991271,
0.2581417859,
-0.9614441395,
0.0211583823,
-0.0443869159,
-0.1099442542,
-0.5972509384,
0.1215366721,
0.189381972,
-0.2057615072,
-0.7192664146,
0.3813312352,
-0.6151416898,
-0.0785977915,
-0.3452740312,
0.2125183493,
0.2095013857,
0.2990942001,
-0.0583572052,
1.3248823881,
0.7127970457,
-0.6371884346,
0.4984677434,
0.3145336807,
-0.387273401,
0.4136178792,
-0.4073428214,
0.1077379659,
0.0030489466,
-0.4204673767,
-0.2507112622,
-0.329862386,
0.3328461647,
-0.3670118153,
0.5944073796,
-0.4473290145,
-0.3616103232,
-0.0886380374,
-0.1534225196,
-0.2924984396,
0.4795745313,
-0.7321278453,
0.4064669311,
0.2975434363,
-0.1217283756,
-0.6147477627,
-0.3394311368,
-0.2352808863,
-0.0573394671,
-0.3724968433,
0.6140818596,
0.0789021626,
-0.3617877066,
0.0707405433,
-0.2825925052,
-0.2825535834,
0.0872970447,
0.4175127149,
0.186635077,
-0.5001378059,
0.4699527621,
0.1830929071,
-0.0475995354,
-0.112121582,
-0.82387501,
0.3317764401,
-0.2576572001,
-0.3614863753,
-0.2644928992,
0.5261934996,
0.4531649947,
-0.588809371,
1.0101454258,
0.6155208349,
-0.3130421042,
-0.3496784866,
-0.2687512636,
-0.0176790599,
-0.3999331892,
0.3903822899,
-0.4122241139,
-0.7333626151,
-0.0160637666,
-0.4148042202,
0.44641608,
0.6390637159,
0.6003240347,
-0.1330937296,
0.7477968931,
0.8740811348,
0.2430954874,
0.837028861,
-0.3056776226,
0.0015206918,
-0.8578142524,
-0.3071482182,
-0.5441818237,
-0.0051384638,
-0.5491518378,
-0.1156702042,
0.4145657122,
0.4275265634,
-0.1690083593,
0.1221777946,
-0.8311184049,
0.9891667366,
0.7951288819,
0.2381020635,
0.1334103793,
0.3953284621,
0.1024295241,
-0.051115308,
-0.5872110724,
-0.7341622114,
1.3574969769,
-0.1253386438,
0.8042840958,
0.0636458322,
0.6319766641,
0.3679004312,
0.3262147307,
-0.6797081828,
0.1113136485,
-0.5324516296,
-0.4697884917,
-0.4783551991,
-0.2251552045,
-1.0898104906,
0.1854861677,
-0.4237888455,
-1.0007307529,
-0.1174758673,
0.1067421287,
-0.3539160788,
0.4627748728,
-0.9946340322,
0.9100061655,
-0.1294872165,
-0.5741255283,
0.1042693704,
-0.3028686047,
0.1482367069,
0.0361718833,
-0.1280257106,
-0.1230240464,
-0.1951512992,
0.404751569,
-0.4783587456,
0.6848881841,
-0.1663508713,
-0.0913113803,
0.2862102389,
-0.0591477826,
0.3428243399,
0.0932574645,
-0.2684681416,
0.3094964921,
0.0504453853,
-0.3471319079,
-0.7254892588,
0.9375644922,
-1.0113571882,
-0.6713207364,
-0.1426802725,
-0.2271416336,
-0.0814882368,
0.4424422979,
0.8759996295,
0.3541558683,
-0.3958244026,
0.4260110855,
1.3719444275,
-0.1861281395,
0.5040388107,
0.5956001878,
-0.1481328309,
-0.1953834593,
1.0094007254,
0.1016920954,
0.1375210732,
0.7777202725,
0.2181034982,
0.1046530083,
-0.4204226136,
-0.552446723,
0.0235317647,
-0.572685957,
-0.2212955058,
-0.5313078165,
-0.3881601691,
-0.3624410331,
0.347556293,
-0.6188730597,
-0.4940600693,
-0.6392627358,
0.2669905126,
0.4459340274,
0.7239146829,
0.2753121555,
0.4421317279,
-0.9623795152,
0.109304972,
0.14469181,
0.4688637853,
-0.2636899352,
-0.3990633786,
-0.5258259177,
0.1210509911,
-0.3805244863,
-0.9464357495,
0.1846439987,
0.788988471,
0.7350908518,
0.3564221263,
0.2513577938,
0.4566298723,
-0.7877654433,
0.7425343394,
-0.0776421949,
-0.834328711,
1.0253196955,
0.0039982833,
0.1196628585,
0.4644317627,
0.6560263038,
-0.2745832503,
-0.3039382696,
-0.4867964089,
-0.7332903147,
0.860221982,
0.2103581429,
-0.0075893649,
-0.029543953,
0.7920457721,
0.6678031683,
0.1909891814,
-0.6401143074,
-0.0671988726,
-0.4886594117,
-0.3250959218,
0.2878472209,
-0.0476304777,
-0.1386244893,
0.096514985,
0.8975960016,
-0.0706892535,
0.3282673657,
0.1812344939,
-0.3636758626,
-0.2453243285,
0.2977266908,
0.4090493917,
0.7711085081,
-0.1403785944,
-0.0272489674,
-0.1829755157,
-0.7622459531,
-0.2109461576,
-0.0095907301,
-0.3220733106,
-0.1825966388,
0.5655119419,
0.874219954,
-0.0203006044,
-0.569016695,
0.6989247799,
-0.3119370043,
0.1894774288,
-0.4126344323,
0.7927666306,
-0.3249893486,
0.3460222781,
0.1840085387,
-0.1787877232,
0.0482947677,
-0.3237777054,
0.1244337186,
0.3034882843,
-0.4625181258,
-0.2993422151,
0.3743383586,
0.1512575299,
-0.7775840759,
0.8292195797,
-0.0744823143,
-0.0469421968,
0.2855481803,
0.4987308383,
0.8991751075,
-0.0947600156,
0.0545805581,
0.3015895486,
0.3924550116,
0.0072675324,
0.2299712449,
-0.1558193266,
-0.5420299172,
-0.4039546847,
-0.7334401608,
-0.6115060449,
-0.0019170006,
-1.0835819244,
0.1529033631,
-0.4222976267,
-0.0286964029,
-0.0362246782,
-0.0046188193,
-0.5598516464,
-0.0649562702,
0.0019443332,
1.0346970558,
-0.5030168295,
1.0702736378,
0.7945874929,
-0.5142244101,
-0.2835512161,
0.3272151053,
-0.2778191864,
-0.7404779792,
0.417449832,
0.3899402916,
-0.056306269,
0.2535569072,
-0.7285365462,
-0.5804675817,
1.1946218014,
0.4102931917,
-0.7871859074,
-0.1710155308,
-0.2208956629,
0.3691197932,
-0.6841464639,
0.2675022483,
0.5985943079,
0.3880801201,
-0.133375138,
-0.5855110288,
-0.5752123594,
-0.3584289253,
-0.1344914138,
0.3889641464,
-0.5597078204,
0.8530896306,
-0.0797614455,
-0.2222266644,
-0.0450117178,
0.7645807862,
-0.3222698867,
0.1129718795,
0.302693069,
0.4258594215,
0.9368523955,
-0.2364335656,
0.8920494914,
-0.3813094497,
0.2594235539,
1.1254394054,
-0.0404362343,
1.0552988052,
0.2726284862,
0.0382556617,
0.5586232543,
0.6508487463,
-0.0819205269,
0.6044764519,
-0.2350474447,
-0.2932937741,
-0.2803198099,
0.0803725272,
-0.2924670875,
0.7275658846,
0.6678220034,
-0.2414704561,
-0.1396633089,
0.2519927323,
0.0116432346,
0.0582943112,
-0.6783715487,
0.9099457264,
-0.2359143794,
-0.9226882458,
0.2357484251,
0.0432374887,
0.2904925048,
-0.5710654259,
-0.3061662912,
-0.0059967758,
0.1203844398,
-0.173676461,
-0.6665337682,
0.2118531466,
0.1406015307,
-0.5589629412,
-0.0605600253,
0.670159936,
-0.4462372065,
-0.4326601326,
0.0888004452,
0.2655593753,
0.2413375974,
-0.3355488479,
-0.50276196,
-0.1387808621,
0.1063744947,
-0.4014495313,
0.1829624921,
0.9527078271,
0.0017825273,
0.3946612775,
0.4607463181,
0.4330426455,
0.4684392512,
-0.1621338278,
0.8135937452,
-0.5619387031,
-0.3539890349,
-0.7030944228,
0.3437464535,
-0.3453949988,
-0.3061434031,
0.6648938656,
0.5281114578,
0.8300491571,
0.0295661259,
0.7524055839,
-0.0809008256,
0.5669186711,
-0.9492536187,
0.5736190081,
-0.4670348763,
0.2199191004,
0.2013473809,
-1.3256878853,
-0.1228239983,
0.5483198762,
-0.3647572696,
-0.3712282777,
0.603521347,
0.7802099586,
-0.2922991514,
0.4019823968,
0.24816145,
0.1734128445,
0.3372914195,
0.4767952263,
0.575429976,
-0.1441640109,
0.7776049972,
-0.1893343627,
-0.6834760308,
-0.1639664173,
-0.8168388605,
-0.9399831891,
-0.3222770095,
-0.1205177754,
-0.129934445,
0.1464059949,
0.8802211881,
0.6663572192,
-0.9208321571,
0.0429494381,
-0.1656144857,
0.0734572932,
-0.1487933844,
-0.2543121874,
0.2125989944,
-0.6266022325,
-1.0369693041,
0.6461277604,
0.6147409678,
-0.1877500862,
-0.3920117319,
0.1398617178,
-0.1307997406,
-0.0945976824,
0.3808922768,
0.3944161534,
-0.6381651759,
-0.3136661351,
0.0160081536,
0.069125019,
0.3221870959,
0.942250669,
-0.3118510246,
0.94335711,
0.2935579419,
0.5832800269,
0.6013501883,
-0.1190555021,
0.6461403966,
-0.9146473408,
0.2027733177,
0.0907299444,
0.1438602507,
0.070926331,
-0.430852592,
0.4837366939,
0.0291447043,
-0.547558248,
-0.5236769319,
0.1877334416,
-0.4558094144,
-0.3448340595,
0.9064223766,
-0.658016324,
-0.63607198,
0.2149353921,
-0.1393967569,
0.3131774366,
-0.3432842493,
0.6099318862,
0.6644409895,
-0.1487445533,
-0.1323327422,
-0.6195705533,
0.1705706567,
-0.1397187263,
-0.8437924385,
0.0911475345,
0.4340969324,
0.1135334373,
0.2392087132,
0.1225388646,
0.0025614973,
0.3734985888,
0.0304608811,
0.3320265412,
-0.4912286103,
-0.622995317,
-0.0801702365,
0.4881496727,
-0.0163559318,
-0.4970174432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14897v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14897v2 | Text encoders bottleneck compositionality in contrastive vision-language models | 2023-05-24T08:48:44 | 2023-10-30T17:57:47 | Amita Kamath, Jack Hessel, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Performant vision-language (VL) models like CLIP represent captions using a
single vector. How much information about language is lost in this bottleneck?
We first curate CompPrompts, a set of increasingly compositional image captions
that VL models should be able to capture (e.g., single object, to
object+property, to multiple interacting objects). Then, we train text-only
recovery probes that aim to reconstruct captions from single-vector text
representations produced by several VL models. This approach does not require
images, allowing us to test on a broader range of scenes compared to prior
work. We find that: 1) CLIP's text encoder falls short on more compositional
inputs, including object relationships, attribute-object association, counting,
and negations; 2) some text encoders work significantly better than others; and
3) text-only recovery performance predicts multi-modal matching performance on
ControlledImCaps: a new evaluation benchmark we collect and release consisting
of fine-grained compositional images and captions. Specifically, our results
suggest text-only recoverability is a necessary (but not sufficient) condition
for modeling compositional factors in contrastive VL models. We release our
datasets and code. | [
-0.3944977224,
-0.2976377308,
0.2385017276,
0.2659608126,
-0.4337731898,
0.0184359476,
-0.1712680459,
-0.6404509544,
0.0370136835,
0.7650462985,
-0.4013266265,
-0.1452538818,
-0.6147999167,
0.3149829805,
-0.5430663228,
0.8988357782,
-0.1051662341,
-0.0349082425,
-0.6612972617,
-0.3354379833,
-0.4316879213,
-0.4582942128,
-0.4052538872,
-0.2372910976,
0.1237808838,
0.246205166,
0.4542621374,
0.8177679777,
0.6769740582,
0.2838947773,
-0.0087201232,
0.2269503623,
-0.5454477668,
0.1423283815,
0.0946526006,
-0.5037972927,
0.0910227075,
-0.143822521,
0.5300448537,
0.6750164032,
-0.0790420398,
-0.3049719036,
0.3373612165,
0.637727797,
-0.9925675392,
0.1594226211,
-0.5514661074,
0.2462701201,
0.1002054736,
-0.010113827,
-0.5266706347,
0.0589575209,
0.4660000801,
-0.5938631296,
0.4297302365,
0.0551961549,
0.9125122428,
0.2436971515,
-0.2040924728,
-0.1158255488,
-0.6922255158,
0.9204062819,
-0.334184736,
0.4240601361,
0.2351519018,
0.1255712062,
0.3808144331,
-0.6545331478,
-0.5470458865,
-0.0659803674,
-0.1919308454,
0.3794364333,
-0.2259602547,
-0.0471162871,
0.1491923332,
0.4599101543,
-0.2845432162,
-0.0339764766,
-0.514205873,
-0.3481363058,
0.3115491271,
0.3697067201,
0.1775187254,
-0.1709971279,
-0.80567348,
-0.3129529059,
-0.7247543335,
-0.0614353232,
-0.1204166785,
-0.0699432194,
-0.4497054219,
0.5320962071,
0.0807064325,
0.6457782388,
-0.146710366,
0.022463901,
0.1390786171,
-0.610486865,
-0.1547134519,
-0.1150876135,
1.0234799385,
0.5768508911,
0.3820849955,
-0.0681623146,
-0.2767410576,
0.2012494951,
0.2528734505,
-0.7970688939,
-0.6012226939,
-0.0367724635,
-0.3415992558,
-0.0725698695,
0.3646070063,
-0.7376011014,
-0.558360815,
-0.1941642016,
0.3906157613,
-0.4849197865,
-0.0628403202,
0.326657176,
-0.3853427768,
0.3476502597,
0.381162256,
-0.7280454636,
0.4666103721,
0.5470295548,
0.9729739428,
-0.7561523318,
-0.3791026771,
-0.3732273281,
-0.0126445219,
-0.2352899909,
0.7510249019,
-0.464419961,
-0.4605389237,
0.1817321181,
0.0889261961,
-0.2185937762,
-0.8072821498,
0.3117650151,
-0.3305850327,
0.1132130474,
-0.5199719071,
-0.4946555495,
-0.0520177297,
0.3037497997,
-1.0686182976,
0.6099064946,
-0.1626290232,
-0.8315490484,
0.2516306639,
-0.232128486,
-0.4351246059,
-0.1612693071,
-0.4097055197,
-0.5360847116,
0.2121020406,
0.3105843365,
0.337521404,
-0.2928103805,
-0.2787804902,
-0.1796870083,
-0.4807829857,
0.5617069602,
-0.324450165,
0.4545896947,
0.0491763279,
-0.0588930286,
0.0193683766,
-0.5817444324,
-0.3444953561,
0.0856862962,
-0.3533357084,
-0.2799803317,
0.2934491336,
0.1319606155,
0.0556041971,
0.1703884602,
-0.6561532617,
-0.298889786,
-0.2286542803,
0.4134567082,
0.5534747839,
-0.0590159893,
0.4596398473,
-0.5002645254,
0.3602536619,
0.3375905156,
0.001125698,
-0.6244415641,
-0.1605207622,
-1.0232481956,
-0.5375996232,
-0.0491260551,
0.4638961852,
-0.9174726009,
0.0913576484,
-0.2165526152,
-0.2517998815,
-0.4075734317,
-0.1440264434,
0.6250072122,
0.5169588327,
0.0986630768,
-0.6048036814,
-0.5551716089,
-1.0540091991,
-0.0642806515,
0.0949176103,
-0.0770330429,
0.3464049399,
0.5221545696,
-0.0306094885,
0.8436524272,
-0.7532532215,
-0.451861918,
-0.3407827318,
0.0332506076,
-0.1223309264,
0.4491108656,
0.5144437551,
-0.9042024016,
-0.5030428171,
-0.0988643616,
-0.7908808589,
-0.0579383783,
0.0262762196,
0.1909431964,
0.2403525114,
0.6195326447,
-0.5001319051,
0.178694725,
0.6770843267,
-0.1789755672,
0.6529955268,
-0.1847550869,
0.1204943955,
-0.6634180546,
0.2172555625,
-0.0771917179,
-0.3102672696,
-0.5221079588,
0.1379949003,
0.0253565442,
-0.2006655037,
-0.437281549,
0.231626749,
-0.5521755815,
-0.0468678288,
-0.4778198004,
0.4342421293,
0.3794418573,
0.5226504207,
0.2471051961,
1.0109397173,
0.6780973673,
-0.80484128,
0.0777894258,
0.3976444006,
-0.2515087426,
0.5813271999,
-0.8943926692,
-0.0241997074,
-0.3828924596,
0.067112118,
-0.9903408289,
-0.3190686703,
0.3062638342,
-0.1381364614,
0.2171165943,
0.1673602909,
-0.202233851,
-0.0684876442,
-0.5616653562,
0.5197235346,
0.3714026511,
-0.4428862035,
0.610442996,
0.3950270712,
-0.0876268446,
-0.5702097416,
-0.8435660601,
-0.1991200596,
0.2406596541,
-0.1945914477,
0.3766318858,
-0.1396508068,
0.062590234,
0.1778580695,
-0.2389716655,
-0.3218102753,
-0.0219108444,
0.2738081813,
0.1916415095,
0.0151811587,
0.125047043,
-0.2735411823,
0.0561746396,
0.053325031,
0.0549584404,
0.5857827067,
-0.2044492364,
-0.3142613471,
-0.1166425794,
0.5280768275,
0.5763664246,
-0.5220581889,
0.5102382898,
0.3866750002,
-0.2251732051,
-0.1497931927,
-0.3159648776,
-0.1952093095,
-0.3980593979,
0.5692026019,
-0.276470989,
-0.8573318124,
0.6413401961,
0.2591130137,
-0.1340666413,
0.4521275759,
0.2504859865,
-0.1331967711,
0.6834099293,
0.8699496388,
-0.0071948105,
0.702008903,
-0.3134589493,
-0.0995635688,
-0.7453036308,
-0.4131642282,
-0.3792194724,
-0.0488552675,
-0.5377727747,
-0.364843905,
0.376121968,
-0.1351293176,
0.050533507,
0.3994604051,
-0.4791929424,
0.729768157,
0.5324236155,
0.3258044124,
0.3841370344,
0.1112538427,
0.1044331044,
-0.3241002262,
-0.7474602461,
-0.1454234272,
0.8923709393,
0.0334514976,
0.8607556224,
-0.0890989825,
0.5113441348,
-0.0477820225,
-0.0070742802,
-0.7614731789,
0.457054764,
-0.5574192405,
-0.3312357962,
0.1077214852,
-0.3718912005,
-0.8363259435,
0.483392179,
-0.3450442851,
-0.4465531111,
0.3417841494,
0.2071796507,
-0.1664362401,
0.0852542892,
-0.4292165637,
0.9556423426,
0.0434319861,
-0.492303431,
-0.0436333306,
-0.750800252,
0.3198320568,
-0.1063931063,
-0.0341951475,
0.1129406467,
-0.1977200359,
0.5565072298,
-0.2384487689,
0.77958709,
0.1646409631,
0.0547752231,
0.3346764147,
0.1927407533,
0.2087654918,
-0.4195354581,
0.3300973177,
0.1120261028,
0.232388556,
-0.2282189727,
-0.460188359,
0.4049751759,
-0.6315310597,
-0.1055334657,
-0.3326120079,
-0.3021355569,
0.0340217948,
0.0266594943,
0.6486769915,
0.6352649927,
-0.1675448716,
0.4759672582,
0.8698518872,
-0.2813012302,
0.6856757402,
0.3352437615,
-0.0201672185,
-0.6114855409,
0.9792465568,
-0.1841263771,
0.4183268249,
0.466550678,
0.0357141607,
-0.0768952817,
-0.3735844791,
-0.2755678296,
0.1144845411,
-0.7731351256,
-0.2784228623,
-0.458634764,
-0.2398082614,
0.0914436951,
-0.1057035178,
-0.6294046044,
-0.1998483837,
-0.4648807347,
0.1911958456,
-0.0183048882,
0.5214954019,
0.0718046501,
0.2924109995,
-1.0768464804,
0.4484090507,
0.1359904557,
0.3857795,
-0.0985542387,
-0.3991406858,
-0.3834288418,
-0.2532908916,
-0.3040382862,
-0.7485342026,
0.2910650074,
0.5135513544,
0.3229156137,
0.3926098347,
0.1842374504,
0.450478375,
-0.4550921321,
0.8502733707,
0.4027579129,
-0.8956475854,
0.2235835791,
-0.0386913829,
0.5277692676,
0.5202667713,
0.1544113308,
-0.5773245096,
-0.3498844504,
-0.0805470124,
-0.80906111,
0.6240208745,
0.1930907071,
0.2935526669,
-0.1320685595,
0.0521456935,
0.2821782231,
0.4413838089,
-0.9614771008,
-0.1064941958,
-0.2887007594,
-0.489947468,
0.1026147082,
-0.45198524,
-0.2601516247,
0.0013422469,
0.0349360071,
-0.1056374684,
0.4210038185,
0.4976820648,
-0.3510500193,
0.1229949668,
0.007770129,
0.6842657328,
0.4149420857,
0.0568608269,
0.399800241,
-0.1596571058,
-0.617212534,
-0.0484699607,
0.0948284268,
-0.2934606969,
-0.0227952022,
0.6013668776,
0.9011874795,
0.3408300281,
-1.0397219658,
0.9479171634,
0.0247418098,
-0.1691946685,
-0.2943722308,
-0.1223917678,
-0.3870229125,
0.0876469165,
0.1711261868,
0.3296613991,
0.2322738916,
-0.4041238129,
0.2577973008,
0.3914445937,
-0.5212530494,
-0.3582349718,
0.6996549368,
0.3288309872,
0.1287055016,
0.3346087933,
0.1366018504,
-0.6918619871,
0.508297801,
0.5130406022,
0.9578775764,
0.1900539845,
0.0286233276,
0.2430952638,
0.2763272226,
-0.2666752636,
0.2021880895,
-0.0684458762,
-0.9180707335,
-0.3610930443,
-0.249267742,
-0.5437436104,
-0.2846762836,
-0.6401839256,
-0.0010268334,
-0.2837792337,
0.1722280234,
-0.3235644698,
-0.3829279244,
-0.545245707,
0.1262651086,
-0.0762128159,
0.6681465507,
-0.8634810448,
0.3694405854,
0.5491787791,
-0.5391939282,
-0.3799247742,
-0.0546760708,
-0.3852465451,
-0.4662120938,
0.4240627289,
0.4182873964,
-0.2832042277,
-0.2942351103,
-0.8982805014,
-0.5536684394,
0.8355388045,
0.4864243567,
-0.5392935872,
0.2238862067,
0.1188709512,
0.4175496995,
-0.4084899426,
-0.1906003356,
0.4280390143,
0.0873807371,
0.0756912604,
-0.8626960516,
0.0643597394,
-0.0335518681,
-0.1271703541,
0.2106653899,
-0.6360928416,
1.0603117943,
-0.0563696884,
-0.4550005496,
0.1097223535,
0.4060364962,
0.1017975584,
0.3186440766,
0.283855319,
0.6124716997,
0.2790585756,
-0.2187530845,
1.330286026,
-0.2236163467,
0.2722444832,
1.0528342724,
-0.0447616316,
1.0856025219,
0.5908284783,
0.1234339774,
0.286773324,
0.2094424665,
-0.2279910296,
0.7774535418,
-0.0371975005,
-0.2593467832,
-0.3704621494,
-0.2924414277,
-0.030213559,
0.625169754,
-0.090839006,
-0.5002754927,
0.0188024808,
0.2614537477,
-0.1442919821,
0.3720884621,
-0.2097622752,
0.9011718035,
0.2175182104,
-0.6709811687,
0.3891828656,
-0.1316986829,
0.6186344624,
-0.3941420317,
-0.0052940939,
-0.3376265764,
0.3370550573,
0.0837544277,
-0.7392616868,
0.3450295925,
-0.2176763564,
-0.2437458932,
0.0311184172,
0.7673200965,
-0.7774568796,
-0.1092954203,
0.1479517817,
0.4175054729,
0.033565931,
-0.3338950276,
-0.2483249903,
0.4853243828,
-0.1157947853,
0.1763022691,
0.0574223883,
0.2685862184,
0.1803942919,
0.659096539,
0.0812792405,
-0.0455738455,
0.0843920335,
-0.0166085511,
0.9678973556,
-0.6243528724,
-0.1967796683,
-0.984189868,
0.5189659595,
-0.1366808563,
-0.1489620358,
0.5701008439,
0.7808597684,
0.984474659,
-0.5719957948,
0.6424454451,
0.2106595188,
0.1546944827,
-0.7492238879,
0.5511999726,
-0.5075132847,
0.0655303821,
-0.291960746,
-0.8751524687,
-0.4134714007,
0.4472911358,
0.2286447585,
-0.2493980527,
0.8397915363,
0.5699021816,
-0.0899580643,
-0.2128287852,
0.2749423087,
-0.0666318908,
0.1692429185,
0.6941680908,
0.8149334192,
-0.6970730424,
0.9924557805,
-0.0989965573,
0.0207946692,
-0.2695292532,
-0.7907954454,
-0.7251704335,
-0.5186482668,
-0.4120258689,
-0.095191963,
-0.1574091017,
0.5979175568,
0.5979889035,
-0.6849498749,
-0.2734242976,
-0.3173951805,
-0.0420275107,
-0.1884751916,
-0.1822729409,
0.1877946407,
-0.1589661241,
-0.7337344289,
0.133700043,
0.4449264407,
0.2257784605,
-0.0664744005,
-0.1439330727,
0.3264757693,
0.1386284679,
0.7648285627,
0.2335532308,
-0.6474540234,
-0.3085639775,
0.1891565621,
-0.2933340371,
0.3011838496,
0.9023681283,
-0.6001318097,
0.8259344101,
0.6223146915,
0.7847650647,
0.6354332566,
0.0085078636,
0.6717715263,
-0.9687430859,
0.2182245702,
-0.0063989954,
0.4327311218,
0.5979964733,
0.2971953452,
0.305824548,
0.4881906211,
-0.3411714137,
-0.5948575735,
0.5289312005,
-1.280074358,
-0.3116453588,
0.9391753674,
-0.2461588234,
-0.2651294768,
0.1440195441,
-0.5276508927,
-0.0674251467,
-0.1275884062,
0.5297481418,
0.5972123742,
-0.0060602091,
-0.7322950363,
-0.208926782,
0.5476296544,
0.3067134619,
-0.6200501919,
0.1124483794,
0.8087211251,
0.2121376395,
0.2418822944,
0.6423425078,
-0.2470356673,
0.3083511293,
0.3057819307,
0.0178597048,
-0.1671773642,
-0.4916774333,
-0.3520044684,
0.3884505928,
0.0110687092,
-0.6440041065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16342v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16342v2 | InterFormer: Interactive Local and Global Features Fusion for Automatic Speech Recognition | 2023-05-24T08:43:44 | 2023-05-29T11:28:27 | Zhi-Hao Lai, Tian-Hao Zhang, Qi Liu, Xinyuan Qian, Li-Fang Wei, Song-Lu Chen, Feng Chen, Xu-Cheng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | The local and global features are both essential for automatic speech
recognition (ASR). Many recent methods have verified that simply combining
local and global features can further promote ASR performance. However, these
methods pay less attention to the interaction of local and global features, and
their series architectures are rigid to reflect local and global relationships.
To address these issues, this paper proposes InterFormer for interactive local
and global features fusion to learn a better representation for ASR.
Specifically, we combine the convolution block with the transformer block in a
parallel design. Besides, we propose a bidirectional feature interaction module
(BFIM) and a selective fusion module (SFM) to implement the interaction and
fusion of local and global features, respectively. Extensive experiments on
public ASR datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed InterFormer
and its superior performance over the other Transformer and Conformer models. | [
-0.6957514882,
-0.2789546251,
0.164991051,
0.2283582985,
-0.1983072907,
0.2573361695,
-0.1647543609,
-0.7235432267,
0.2961632907,
0.3354920447,
-0.2422492951,
-0.0447807796,
-0.6812153459,
0.0072779539,
-0.6111621857,
0.6093096137,
-0.1702617407,
0.2881354392,
-0.5299949646,
-0.3909098208,
-0.4901771247,
-0.5954908133,
-0.5883883238,
-0.6826296449,
0.1538525075,
0.3107571304,
0.6114290357,
0.3885654509,
0.6200281382,
0.532094419,
-0.048550196,
-0.1270432174,
0.0423998199,
0.1640502065,
-0.0982342064,
-0.1185869277,
-0.2670532465,
-0.2195720077,
0.9596663713,
0.4235210419,
0.0848020017,
0.015544354,
0.1130027547,
0.2965510786,
-0.1330105513,
0.3091731966,
-0.3732825816,
-0.1579237878,
-0.3925619423,
0.2420983613,
0.1538060755,
-0.449959904,
0.3746494353,
-0.2577034235,
0.3871628046,
-0.0254292507,
0.6290252209,
0.4579008818,
-0.2480662912,
-0.178338185,
-1.1337907314,
0.398416549,
-0.4066684544,
0.6490064859,
0.0606248491,
0.7609951496,
0.0325999148,
-0.654661715,
-0.9252653122,
-0.3406869173,
-0.4694777131,
-0.0558346137,
-0.4476961493,
0.1400551051,
0.168397963,
0.6861186624,
-0.6139342189,
0.275298059,
-0.7141516209,
-0.4836994112,
0.8040838242,
0.0819378495,
0.2139290124,
0.039786756,
-0.4158897698,
-0.2090694159,
-0.5149599314,
0.4942267537,
0.2461660802,
0.459104687,
-0.4695232511,
0.2678586543,
-0.199285239,
0.6459257007,
0.25215137,
-0.0916123241,
0.3389743268,
-0.2329495549,
-0.0186811462,
0.6219815016,
0.8034163117,
-0.2503196597,
-0.0436892547,
-0.0316543207,
-0.0877854452,
0.2606111467,
0.1026655436,
-0.587652266,
-0.2066961378,
0.3001908958,
-0.2313706875,
0.1467817128,
0.5289521217,
-0.4630904198,
-0.2259491533,
-0.8418998718,
0.7277538776,
-0.2568646669,
-0.1594509631,
-0.1695126593,
-0.0203298368,
0.2412297577,
0.1189432442,
-0.7817636132,
0.7609341145,
0.5291861892,
0.7364433408,
-0.1306938976,
-0.3648127019,
-0.8283714056,
0.2398672104,
0.5594817996,
0.9847617745,
-0.6822155714,
-0.5134513378,
-0.3024398983,
0.0915152729,
-0.1332211792,
-0.895821631,
0.2746526003,
-0.1615719795,
0.1934206635,
-0.090521872,
-0.3394538462,
-0.3861178458,
-0.2842603922,
-0.8338980079,
0.7737847567,
-0.0920477733,
-0.5427160859,
0.1033409461,
-0.7354698181,
-0.6304305196,
0.2652441561,
-0.5480393767,
-0.6325410008,
-0.0983325616,
0.2918788493,
0.3602580428,
-0.3466014266,
0.3481206894,
0.007533025,
-0.775110662,
0.0896283165,
-0.4238472879,
0.3009986579,
0.0689510107,
-0.4711862504,
0.5151318312,
-0.8415990472,
-0.3496452868,
-0.1697417051,
-0.5591719747,
0.0999865159,
-0.0316618457,
0.2540948093,
0.1487332433,
0.0263228994,
-0.6780366898,
-0.1069526896,
-0.3390066922,
0.3847545385,
0.1700854748,
-0.0802619904,
0.5930600166,
-0.5272405148,
0.3131561279,
0.2263989598,
0.1010387316,
0.0705877766,
-0.5089795589,
-0.8162264824,
-0.5046790838,
0.3315863013,
0.7350313663,
-0.4830781519,
0.6471913457,
-0.2287132293,
-0.593672514,
-0.932480514,
0.1896265,
0.722743392,
0.2867790461,
0.4399777055,
-0.3106868267,
-0.7136150002,
-0.8769236803,
-0.0241823252,
0.086004667,
-0.4226762056,
0.1195996404,
-0.1720700413,
-0.1779699028,
1.0482150316,
-0.1559752226,
-0.5790735483,
-0.2005332708,
0.1637632847,
0.2837565839,
0.564571321,
0.356755048,
-1.0613641739,
-0.5796841979,
0.038953267,
-0.2361635566,
-0.0019896717,
0.2261300087,
0.2231930792,
0.1387592405,
0.4291954339,
-0.3667778671,
0.441308558,
0.4586399198,
0.0192282088,
-0.0541102178,
-0.232784912,
0.2923502922,
-0.861713171,
0.0090528652,
0.1225841567,
-0.1696912497,
-0.9277333617,
-0.494389087,
-0.0477961749,
-0.4413245916,
-0.5294625759,
0.517528832,
-0.2880556583,
-0.154718101,
-0.1546221375,
0.1061590984,
-0.1269702017,
0.1945445091,
0.0411807634,
0.7340682149,
0.6486752629,
-0.5104585886,
0.6423894167,
0.4728857279,
-0.313909322,
0.3946744502,
-0.6383467913,
0.1804096103,
-0.4030857086,
0.1214131191,
-0.9957367778,
-0.5025504827,
-0.0981254354,
-0.2856361568,
0.5792564154,
-0.0152620589,
-0.1553644687,
-0.579318285,
-0.1000230908,
0.3852927089,
0.5517525673,
-0.6817743778,
0.8662919998,
0.7387920022,
-0.3837183714,
-0.0419170558,
-0.4814943671,
-0.3604195118,
-0.218781352,
-0.7871502042,
0.6327592731,
-0.0628623739,
-0.3112755716,
-0.2167367488,
-0.0793011934,
0.1326909065,
-0.4850149453,
0.5823593736,
0.0753730386,
-0.2059238851,
-0.0529147051,
-0.055152528,
-0.5470599532,
-0.3537627161,
0.1722937226,
0.5559641719,
-0.3639923036,
-0.5984857678,
-0.6837783456,
0.5587597489,
0.7249362469,
-0.5191744566,
0.1290122569,
0.7476114035,
-0.4950356483,
0.283369571,
-0.8216987252,
-0.0217978675,
-0.5502649546,
0.2113503367,
-0.3745514154,
-1.1207867861,
0.5376036763,
-0.0412937328,
-0.3326847553,
0.1131787449,
0.4702528715,
-0.0705762357,
0.8732632995,
0.6255226135,
-0.4477329552,
0.4823923409,
-0.2000548542,
0.4032814205,
-0.8529333472,
-0.531981647,
-0.4078802168,
-0.7289553881,
-0.3305149674,
-0.476944834,
0.7540690303,
0.0455769859,
-0.2122485936,
0.3760221899,
-0.6788132191,
0.3328795135,
0.8864756823,
0.1152861491,
0.0686984435,
-0.1253584027,
-0.0473861694,
-0.1656416953,
-0.3893502355,
-0.2251909375,
0.076507926,
0.2286317796,
0.7361605167,
0.1866521686,
0.6009674072,
0.1035981253,
-0.0520246327,
-0.6797530651,
0.4817939401,
-0.5011592507,
-0.0070598163,
-0.337435782,
-0.0281201024,
-0.658631444,
0.0343903936,
-0.3479621112,
-0.6499969363,
0.4435145557,
0.3891325891,
-0.5263924599,
0.0899429098,
-0.6841707826,
0.579726398,
-0.1771883219,
0.2269404829,
-0.1719060838,
-0.8040328026,
-0.0425918289,
0.064456284,
0.0401996486,
-0.134065792,
0.5038190484,
0.3981110156,
-0.274423629,
0.7386872172,
-0.3162094951,
0.2743105292,
0.2829406261,
-0.2468435615,
0.3926352262,
-0.0107661774,
-0.2043193579,
0.3833335638,
-0.3866190314,
0.190653041,
-0.4501115084,
0.6658571362,
-0.7347306609,
-0.7114058733,
-0.1767142117,
-0.5722391605,
-0.2467547357,
-0.1078993455,
0.2548568249,
0.8664659858,
-0.0845067799,
0.1515778452,
0.4726499617,
0.1605979353,
0.5845237374,
0.4286942482,
0.0790114254,
-0.8609934449,
1.0719794035,
0.325394541,
0.159809798,
0.6524726748,
0.1642289162,
-0.188513726,
-0.4097810686,
-0.1917357594,
0.2573702931,
-0.494659096,
-0.3184815943,
-0.5402844548,
-0.9460155964,
-0.3429475427,
-0.3240335286,
0.0540188178,
-0.2993801832,
-0.094022572,
0.0782621205,
0.7245388031,
0.7334908247,
-0.1621409506,
0.4635760486,
-0.8404893279,
0.4429427087,
0.6613062024,
0.3479358554,
-0.1691923589,
-0.2575009465,
-0.204478547,
-0.285562247,
-0.2253046036,
-0.3023360968,
0.1623729467,
0.4291604161,
0.9037669301,
0.3835976124,
-0.1134810373,
0.7621465921,
-0.7215972543,
0.3429964781,
-0.0212576184,
-1.1000596285,
0.6398687363,
-0.0378249288,
0.572314918,
0.3904531598,
0.4556411505,
-0.4965715408,
-0.7202862501,
-0.3186812997,
-0.6559218764,
0.8514664769,
0.0976168662,
-0.1016670093,
0.357432574,
0.1381677538,
0.1963693351,
0.0860658437,
-0.3192064762,
-0.2779213786,
-0.273806721,
-0.4892912805,
-0.0431813784,
-0.0780728757,
0.0693834499,
-0.6257125139,
0.4943307042,
-0.0895393714,
0.2475170642,
0.17233935,
-0.020364305,
-0.1059297621,
0.1943807304,
0.3748503029,
0.1459043175,
-0.0216503479,
0.2501399517,
0.376578182,
-0.6487246156,
0.1056344882,
0.731471777,
-0.0412881039,
0.0163762942,
0.1396904886,
1.0585724115,
0.5121302605,
-0.3723078072,
0.4284401536,
-0.0654877126,
0.0259146709,
-0.290176034,
0.3481632769,
0.1786082685,
0.7904430032,
0.2065333426,
0.4022594392,
0.3271233737,
-0.3087553978,
0.4377248287,
0.2950865328,
-0.6314173341,
-0.3717287779,
0.7897106409,
0.2942036986,
-0.6938413382,
0.3287194073,
0.0760068446,
-0.7333782911,
0.4948700964,
0.761762917,
0.8312241435,
-0.7628839612,
-0.1233739108,
0.3014189601,
-0.1014659405,
0.250200212,
0.5362617373,
-0.4144324362,
-0.4794142246,
-0.1491212398,
-0.7860832214,
-0.7654436231,
-0.0403737314,
-0.5388991833,
0.6636219025,
-0.2229125351,
0.2190662622,
0.2004665732,
-0.0519503839,
-0.5858786702,
0.1251737475,
0.599398315,
0.5590741634,
-0.6161685586,
1.1484071016,
0.7872473598,
-0.3364647627,
-0.5344236493,
0.1027929187,
0.237007603,
-0.6191669106,
0.4477638602,
0.4829564691,
-0.3127015531,
-0.0482441112,
0.0657688752,
-1.1183209419,
1.1814075708,
0.4519627392,
-0.648417294,
0.2578473687,
0.5209097862,
0.1770923436,
-0.34452492,
-0.074081257,
0.535100162,
0.3588509262,
0.5077636242,
-1.3413047791,
0.166342631,
-0.3446842432,
0.2790364921,
0.4034927785,
-0.9284428358,
0.696390152,
-0.0088159554,
-0.1552052647,
-0.105417639,
0.6912466884,
0.2865092456,
0.1214321181,
0.5816425085,
0.2620098591,
0.702052772,
-0.2212968171,
0.363609314,
-0.1112497821,
-0.012985942,
0.9622296095,
-0.4905234575,
1.0572158098,
0.0329344347,
-0.2304238975,
0.4359628856,
0.0828828737,
-0.1648599952,
0.6755067706,
0.1940197796,
-0.7801560163,
-0.0325981975,
0.1238682568,
-0.1999923587,
0.8562702537,
0.4347072542,
0.223282963,
-0.2519686222,
0.4908193052,
-0.1112351567,
0.0346746482,
-0.324693799,
0.9734843373,
0.1220756546,
-0.1794489026,
0.3248457909,
-0.3822325766,
0.819021523,
-0.694226265,
-0.192705974,
0.0209730435,
0.4021191597,
-0.2376116514,
-0.7102844715,
0.6379134655,
-0.2368040532,
-0.4740903378,
-0.0536049604,
0.9729438424,
-0.7844402194,
-0.4176654816,
0.4849312305,
-0.0947702527,
0.0225943308,
-0.0281481147,
-0.3020784855,
0.2897734046,
-0.2983080447,
0.3196562231,
0.2526963949,
0.1559280306,
-0.1329929233,
0.5100849867,
0.5419267416,
-0.1419932097,
0.0882147998,
0.3665580153,
1.0421770811,
-0.6348130107,
-0.4693165421,
-0.5382555127,
0.8443128467,
-0.1825175136,
0.0677314848,
0.477992475,
0.5344695449,
0.9485651255,
0.2223916352,
0.7917755246,
0.0252098273,
0.7700755,
-0.384180218,
0.9472164512,
-0.0290631745,
0.0139521696,
0.0625244603,
-0.7655823231,
-0.5504059196,
0.4613972902,
-0.1371745765,
-0.2633384168,
0.2047204226,
0.6296001673,
-0.3499779403,
0.2646280527,
0.4702864587,
0.2601511478,
0.2600179613,
0.1864762157,
0.7208362222,
-0.4874830246,
0.4603038132,
-0.4454223812,
-0.2896266282,
-0.1091830134,
-0.4827584028,
-0.7933796644,
-0.920155406,
-0.2612811327,
0.0416960344,
-0.2173085809,
1.1784968376,
0.6610082984,
-1.2072027922,
-0.352658689,
0.2611588836,
-0.0344766788,
-0.1139510423,
-0.1670896411,
0.2474305481,
-0.2541644275,
-0.7893872857,
0.7461436391,
0.4712114036,
0.221472159,
-0.1702235192,
-0.2129019499,
0.0815047622,
-0.0482049584,
0.3455765247,
0.4284940362,
-0.8161543608,
-0.5438930988,
-0.3830735683,
0.3028432131,
0.4132157564,
0.8597351909,
-1.2480859756,
0.6150352359,
0.4382243454,
0.4551938176,
0.6138802767,
-0.0484911874,
0.7710938454,
-0.7128451467,
0.3436702192,
0.116422683,
0.6574656367,
0.4943335354,
-0.3509384692,
0.01736404,
0.0129846008,
-0.7569776773,
-0.5699019432,
0.1671791226,
-1.0081105232,
0.5197110772,
0.5956431031,
0.1088337526,
0.1018483564,
-0.3025483191,
-0.3752139211,
0.3156042099,
-0.2138534784,
0.5683730245,
0.2183402181,
-0.6196488142,
-0.1854558885,
-0.0989294946,
0.5758918524,
-0.3714990318,
-0.6348748803,
-0.1850582957,
0.2369168848,
0.1969632506,
0.3781996667,
0.5447473526,
-0.1127876714,
0.2524548471,
-0.0713813007,
0.2321954072,
-0.1002102718,
-0.4977313876,
-0.8512809873,
-0.0860092863,
-0.1676134765,
-0.3075285256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14891v1 | Extracting Psychological Indicators Using Question Answering | 2023-05-24T08:41:23 | 2023-05-24T08:41:23 | Luka Pavlović | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | In this work, we propose a method for extracting text spans that may indicate
one of the BIG5 psychological traits using a question-answering task with
examples that have no answer for the asked question. We utilized the RoBERTa
model fine-tuned on SQuAD 2.0 dataset. The model was further fine-tuned
utilizing comments from Reddit. We examined the effect of the percentage of
examples with no answer in the training dataset on the overall performance. The
results obtained in this study are in line with the SQuAD 2.0 benchmark and
present a good baseline for further research. | [
-0.5801178813,
-1.1141241789,
0.7979032993,
0.5557488203,
-0.0396263637,
-0.09292458,
-0.1548910737,
-0.6567286849,
0.2153646797,
0.2319194674,
-1.2464957237,
-0.3508161902,
-0.8562753201,
0.4476122558,
-0.3693636656,
1.4708058834,
0.0777222812,
0.0122907273,
0.0366957039,
0.0393304825,
-0.7445992231,
-0.4700542092,
-0.8571001291,
-0.0157971568,
0.5869312286,
0.4996631742,
0.1924358904,
0.2480827421,
0.7477972507,
0.2404289395,
0.057367716,
0.1869061142,
-0.5663669109,
0.3030491471,
-0.0200146083,
-0.5624602437,
-0.5548840761,
0.4670576453,
0.3552354276,
0.2074449062,
0.1368929446,
0.6448172927,
-0.3685973287,
0.4874055386,
-0.5595850348,
0.398347497,
-0.5279384851,
0.0438168794,
0.0420247987,
-0.259829998,
-0.4034696817,
-0.5819739103,
0.3184582591,
-0.4683401883,
0.3367715478,
-0.3229856193,
0.9517533779,
0.2508530617,
-0.3753665984,
-0.3559853733,
-0.631835103,
1.137450695,
-0.455006659,
-0.1813562065,
0.8518390656,
0.3649692237,
0.1943842918,
-0.3291372955,
-0.4313372076,
0.2519465983,
-0.1921651959,
0.5037963986,
-0.5094020367,
-0.2378766835,
0.1276156008,
0.1471801251,
-0.4608167112,
-0.0665167496,
-0.6316956878,
0.1549935341,
1.0734380484,
0.4464563727,
0.421084702,
0.0621941388,
-0.1325564384,
-0.0246694889,
-0.2884691358,
0.2779283822,
0.2242216319,
0.0922279358,
-0.3968138695,
0.658562839,
-0.0458099768,
0.4557327628,
0.2788990736,
0.0245712083,
0.2002993077,
-0.3508926034,
0.1251018792,
-0.2246015668,
0.4796945453,
0.6973599195,
0.7034902573,
-0.3108027279,
-0.0119155599,
0.1523682028,
0.3236793578,
-0.9425956011,
-0.2600428462,
0.4737882018,
-0.6557279825,
-0.4234274328,
0.3015621305,
-1.2625900507,
-0.1641441137,
0.1063512042,
0.2042792439,
-0.568821013,
-0.4153895378,
-0.1690212488,
-0.7750213146,
0.455180943,
0.2445748448,
-1.0336279869,
0.3228124082,
0.4569302499,
0.7528029084,
-0.1798847914,
0.0851660967,
-0.553802073,
0.0203584824,
-0.3243122697,
0.8620324135,
-0.5984358788,
-0.3614800572,
0.1098845452,
0.2549067438,
-0.2572532296,
-0.4021896124,
0.4097467065,
-0.3984753489,
0.6233453155,
-0.3579311967,
-0.6992932558,
-0.179608807,
0.3929900825,
-0.4638340175,
1.2814437151,
0.5307451487,
-0.6415259838,
0.2768187523,
-0.9451895952,
-0.3062351644,
-0.1451708227,
0.0301098339,
-0.4629616439,
0.2516806722,
0.4286051393,
0.5141650438,
-0.2367140353,
-0.1572722793,
-0.6658832431,
-0.3034892678,
0.8713268638,
-0.1278911233,
0.7917521596,
-0.0916002244,
-0.1667163223,
-0.1238701865,
-0.8301649094,
0.6882172823,
-0.1909815222,
-0.3180974722,
-0.2190793008,
-0.0507415794,
0.0846554339,
0.4787273109,
0.5017812252,
-0.8426178694,
0.1681826562,
-0.1282198727,
0.3887321651,
0.6536726952,
0.5636208653,
0.1162692606,
-0.4312630594,
0.811067462,
-0.0956752077,
0.0589405484,
0.2867805362,
-0.549497664,
-0.3313474357,
-0.7793226838,
0.0121347774,
0.5536315441,
-0.4213411808,
0.6155460477,
0.1470504254,
-0.6891974211,
-0.5690860152,
0.2432117611,
0.6908753514,
0.251057297,
0.4880854785,
0.0221568979,
-0.9752172232,
-0.9016737938,
-0.1745478064,
-0.4874721766,
-0.1277142018,
0.181075424,
0.7465336323,
0.2155009955,
0.9538009763,
-0.9932070971,
-0.1395930499,
-0.603372395,
0.3955269754,
0.0902596265,
0.223631531,
0.8504040241,
-0.7547595501,
-0.2178052813,
-0.3691545725,
-1.1282470226,
-0.2071551234,
0.2771958411,
-0.0097231399,
0.0198469684,
0.5202700496,
-0.651419878,
0.4613913,
0.3785120547,
-0.4257970154,
0.500469923,
-0.0162106976,
0.0958530009,
-0.9376390576,
0.0491372272,
0.4627176821,
0.2116939574,
-0.8403523564,
-0.0195938088,
-0.1086009443,
0.0162731241,
-0.076801002,
0.4582308531,
-0.1430390924,
-0.000069775,
-0.1204597875,
0.106272541,
-0.1020923853,
0.460689038,
0.1853189021,
1.0661308765,
0.1146513075,
-0.3886125684,
-0.0413271897,
0.4826743007,
-0.1619032323,
0.7899078727,
-0.9380069971,
0.0764794052,
-0.4712716043,
0.1030831411,
-1.4546227455,
-0.3608067334,
-0.0480580963,
-0.7029602528,
-0.2305111438,
-0.060790401,
-0.195304364,
-0.4912002385,
-0.3896230459,
0.0368981697,
0.6896693707,
0.1331524253,
0.1234812662,
0.4364944994,
-0.3581982255,
-0.0610780269,
-0.5859803557,
-0.4218960702,
-0.8056973219,
-0.2982214391,
0.030902205,
-0.2388329357,
-0.3663443029,
-0.3022502363,
-0.007065923,
-0.7277188897,
0.3133356869,
0.4068183005,
0.424549371,
-0.3569776118,
0.3499371111,
-0.2990693748,
-0.062627472,
0.3737935722,
0.261772871,
0.4917998016,
-0.2137903571,
0.4065593481,
-0.7440376878,
0.6004731655,
0.3953484595,
-0.5318511128,
0.7980341911,
0.7363883257,
-0.0939929932,
-0.149456203,
-0.2618561685,
-0.3733786643,
-0.4099492133,
0.4350054562,
-0.2433110476,
-0.7421703339,
0.5564796329,
0.2017870992,
-0.3031771481,
0.3736560643,
0.5403341055,
-0.7091410756,
1.4591400623,
0.8334277272,
-0.0385719649,
0.7138465047,
-0.1541231424,
0.3165283799,
-0.8043236732,
-0.261158675,
-0.8198699355,
-0.4982994795,
-0.5003370047,
0.0355596393,
0.5124205351,
0.0072930818,
-0.4479750991,
0.3323218226,
-0.4164926112,
0.27660501,
0.3558158875,
0.5075207353,
-0.0712105334,
-0.2481627613,
0.6749529243,
-0.2841432691,
-0.297012955,
-0.4712454677,
1.1493409872,
0.2139915526,
0.4175701737,
0.3926656544,
0.5009447336,
0.4114004672,
0.4239782691,
-0.5535706878,
0.577485323,
0.06847433,
-1.0755617619,
-0.5785914063,
-0.4249668419,
-0.81907022,
-0.2124478221,
-0.3585764468,
-1.2503089905,
-0.0300105568,
-0.1720489115,
-0.3689894676,
-0.2436246723,
-0.7972596884,
0.8116506934,
-0.0550392196,
0.028978724,
-0.0842995197,
-0.6177338362,
0.3260016739,
-0.0324077979,
-0.1658531576,
-0.4076698124,
0.0485766269,
0.9401217699,
-0.2302791625,
0.7394760847,
-0.4009684026,
0.0117794862,
0.4204858541,
-0.1382305324,
0.3134806156,
-0.1733182818,
-0.4477329552,
-0.3129529953,
0.4416437447,
-0.6733419895,
-1.0346405506,
0.2045799494,
-1.0725778341,
-0.2312354147,
-0.1896321028,
-0.6763513088,
-0.6163471341,
0.029366415,
0.1637021452,
0.2122943401,
-0.2161259353,
0.3106645644,
0.5024057627,
-0.072527051,
0.5903915167,
0.697514236,
-0.0017206838,
-0.2829349637,
0.6625881195,
0.0639346391,
0.2083535045,
0.2723705769,
0.0393147245,
-0.3812792599,
-0.3211930096,
-0.4029497802,
0.1873150617,
-0.2442845106,
-0.092565909,
-0.2859511971,
-0.1646883488,
-0.2984826267,
0.0204079691,
0.0073479819,
-0.4545000196,
-0.1298845261,
-0.4058350921,
0.7316833138,
0.9306669235,
0.342060864,
0.5740648508,
-0.4010959566,
0.2637667954,
0.2299290001,
0.1609791964,
0.0853360817,
-0.291482389,
-0.2745973468,
0.0240967199,
-0.4333336353,
-1.178661108,
0.3300647438,
0.0886828229,
0.2692531645,
0.3886460066,
0.0998431668,
0.9365963936,
0.1117449403,
0.8593105078,
0.0863538757,
-0.7055814862,
0.8201926947,
-0.6532806754,
0.0278931577,
0.7764000297,
0.5907559395,
-0.1843905449,
-0.537121892,
-0.7364776134,
-0.3983998895,
0.5557971597,
0.4384067953,
-0.0670663118,
-0.3675737679,
0.3877589405,
-0.2826918364,
0.3145684898,
-0.3832173347,
-0.2108860165,
-0.0137030948,
-0.5036497712,
-0.2229467779,
-0.2506119013,
-0.2647461295,
-0.4181220531,
0.4873571992,
-0.0694682598,
0.5110026002,
0.2248395532,
0.0978955999,
0.0980518237,
0.3068773746,
0.531563282,
0.6265001893,
-0.669908762,
-0.0259888414,
0.3208895326,
-0.2887399495,
0.2860416472,
-0.1797145903,
-0.1012613848,
-0.2501564622,
0.5853010416,
0.1950592101,
0.0348742194,
-0.8657173514,
0.6210430264,
-0.2219975442,
-0.2146037817,
-0.45453915,
0.2398613393,
-0.2400900424,
0.250616014,
0.3704375029,
-0.238064304,
-0.0231594108,
-0.9039131403,
0.2729329765,
0.4259457886,
-0.9505136013,
-0.4896280468,
0.3492436707,
0.0352430642,
-0.2529657781,
0.7101926804,
-0.0289610904,
-0.3771941066,
0.8953513503,
0.7488301396,
0.7271466851,
0.1921999604,
0.554916501,
0.2879082263,
0.14322263,
0.2656735778,
0.8635126352,
0.1624448448,
-0.5101438165,
-0.1157368794,
-0.436904788,
-0.1759899408,
0.1484491825,
-1.2053449154,
-0.0636040941,
-0.6105207205,
-0.2664722502,
0.2175788581,
0.2575657964,
-0.6876538992,
0.6876378059,
-0.295645535,
0.7267267108,
-1.1193568707,
0.5955070853,
0.7174248695,
-0.8705195189,
-0.9717394114,
0.0040496611,
-0.0258001983,
-0.9693672061,
0.7679091692,
0.0350598544,
0.0638997555,
-0.0942255929,
-0.6340417266,
-0.5158525109,
0.8547394276,
0.0613210537,
0.2377919108,
-0.085552454,
0.0850399956,
0.9907743931,
-0.482065618,
0.6942839622,
0.7206127644,
0.6163973212,
-0.4051818252,
-0.4220293164,
0.0883905292,
-0.5980085135,
-0.0851958469,
0.0798083916,
-0.8990812302,
0.7831173539,
-0.0632159784,
0.0191180985,
0.5603419542,
0.4790574908,
0.1488714814,
0.2459703535,
0.250736624,
0.473113358,
0.8941121697,
-0.2268583626,
1.1125403643,
-0.4053194821,
0.4187524021,
1.0806901455,
-0.2840922177,
1.0175964832,
0.6201406121,
-0.1055784896,
0.7530367374,
0.5077877641,
-0.249231264,
0.6018090248,
0.145026356,
-0.2893099487,
-0.2475870699,
-0.0653867349,
-0.263215363,
0.8303055763,
0.1892362535,
-0.481602639,
-0.3291043937,
-0.248894617,
0.2237529159,
0.1256895214,
-0.1530420482,
1.0402784348,
-0.3237977028,
-0.9492944479,
0.3608713448,
0.0975706279,
0.2848511338,
-0.5898144245,
-0.2354972064,
-0.4452254772,
0.3229574859,
-0.2134891003,
-1.0062942505,
0.3993727565,
0.4495227337,
-0.7342149615,
-0.2495307475,
0.5768231153,
-0.2260147184,
-0.6340332031,
0.0598979704,
0.7792230248,
0.3251200914,
0.0184165407,
-0.4382696748,
-0.3381110728,
-0.123314552,
0.0766475871,
0.3069502413,
0.6581787467,
-0.0757725313,
0.6919477582,
0.509195745,
0.0748365521,
-0.0816975832,
-0.2943529189,
0.4194844961,
-0.767103076,
-0.3214599788,
-0.9501281381,
0.4057509601,
-0.3970571756,
-0.9184917808,
1.2158582211,
0.6193458438,
0.3561010659,
-0.2502592206,
0.9697261453,
-0.3694773018,
0.8352855444,
-0.1756485552,
0.5471099019,
-0.3420339823,
-0.1856606603,
-0.5622910261,
-0.4929537177,
0.0627753064,
0.6939822435,
-0.6295050979,
-0.0351200588,
0.6327055693,
0.7318990231,
0.2075407356,
0.3935944438,
-0.0568191335,
0.2389221489,
0.2648075819,
0.6326978803,
0.8506866097,
-0.4996137619,
0.4891269803,
0.1058062762,
-0.1518761516,
-0.0241873581,
-0.445684731,
-1.1906411648,
-0.4274835587,
-0.2750177383,
-0.6125684381,
0.3253048658,
0.5758250356,
0.8336347938,
-0.6667919159,
-0.2188079655,
0.0232213866,
0.1413336247,
-0.5120700598,
-0.2591803372,
0.2530727088,
-0.2849233449,
-0.4241205454,
0.0532541275,
0.0609966405,
0.01119575,
0.065944165,
0.1913582236,
-0.3969999254,
0.0634989813,
0.6477199793,
0.3297830224,
-0.2528189123,
-0.9108569622,
0.1685850322,
0.0391187072,
0.0260438882,
0.596357584,
-0.4959622622,
-0.106429942,
0.1838396043,
0.5061530471,
0.6974547505,
0.439545691,
0.6654574275,
-0.9257224798,
-0.0072421748,
-0.0420832448,
-0.0587250255,
-0.0812586546,
-0.1755054295,
0.7710305452,
0.0032751653,
-0.3413636684,
-0.736612618,
0.1441530138,
-1.0445164442,
-0.0883124918,
0.8785616755,
-0.4295884371,
-0.2322291136,
-0.1633199602,
-0.3474853337,
0.0570648052,
-0.433950603,
1.1784352064,
1.048006773,
-0.4906471968,
-0.3585285842,
-0.6926161647,
0.516739428,
0.5280413032,
-1.1609202623,
-0.1125689074,
0.24518843,
0.5350100398,
-0.2115138322,
0.6147262454,
-0.1330348849,
0.4187166095,
-0.0783599168,
-0.2942967117,
0.236885637,
-0.2751014829,
-0.1096621081,
0.425896883,
-0.2219458371,
-0.2429529428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14889v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14889v2 | Evaluating Evaluation Metrics: A Framework for Analyzing NLG Evaluation Metrics using Measurement Theory | 2023-05-24T08:38:23 | 2023-10-23T01:02:48 | Ziang Xiao, Susu Zhang, Vivian Lai, Q. Vera Liao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We address a fundamental challenge in Natural Language Generation (NLG) model
evaluation -- the design and evaluation of evaluation metrics. Recognizing the
limitations of existing automatic metrics and noises from how current human
evaluation was conducted, we propose MetricEval, a framework informed by
measurement theory, the foundation of educational test design, for
conceptualizing and evaluating the reliability and validity of NLG evaluation
metrics. The framework formalizes the source of measurement error and offers
statistical tools for evaluating evaluation metrics based on empirical data.
With our framework, one can quantify the uncertainty of the metrics to better
interpret the result. To exemplify the use of our framework in practice, we
analyzed a set of evaluation metrics for summarization and identified issues
related to conflated validity structure in human-eval and reliability in
LLM-based metrics. Through MetricEval, we aim to promote the design,
evaluation, and interpretation of valid and reliable metrics to advance robust
and effective NLG models. | [
-0.3288677335,
-1.0453989506,
0.1475802809,
0.391869843,
0.0222815741,
0.2792479098,
-0.2793336809,
-0.264858216,
-0.1809289008,
0.1139930785,
-0.4651583731,
-0.6053023338,
-0.4580133557,
0.0525393374,
-0.5096426606,
1.2261565924,
0.0959526375,
0.1542690247,
-0.530189395,
-0.0077119139,
-0.4860164523,
-0.2000130266,
-0.8396268487,
-0.4473858476,
0.1307261139,
0.3225111961,
0.6613180637,
0.4682532251,
0.9190762639,
0.1921258271,
-0.1496275812,
-0.022025805,
-0.4697490633,
-0.0932610407,
0.1039333567,
-0.3481741548,
-0.8185753822,
0.0410165228,
0.8637467027,
1.1598768234,
-0.4562974572,
0.6769500375,
0.3521185815,
0.6977734566,
-0.561106503,
-0.0574638881,
-0.2429238856,
0.2845692337,
0.0778496265,
-0.2194004506,
-0.1314765066,
-0.8605974913,
0.2589044869,
-0.3791705668,
0.3198089302,
0.0781342536,
0.569827795,
0.1137147769,
-0.2171169966,
-0.4946551025,
-0.7119627595,
0.9546754956,
-1.0594341755,
0.4234647751,
0.4955209494,
0.4052076042,
-0.1536152214,
-0.5240024924,
-0.3678581417,
-0.5673336983,
0.0422291867,
0.1939777881,
0.0168630891,
0.007588285,
0.0472859256,
0.6940284371,
-0.835694015,
0.1724506915,
-0.5598141551,
-0.1780980229,
0.7969989777,
0.3888241947,
0.4383648336,
-0.3736390173,
-0.4744198918,
0.1498953849,
-0.5368571877,
-0.1980924606,
0.5530371666,
0.2757413685,
-0.0572570562,
0.4880227149,
-0.0880507454,
0.6660587192,
-0.2276325673,
-0.2702981532,
0.3126632869,
-0.667576015,
-0.2359496355,
-0.0740453452,
0.8187302351,
0.7457798123,
0.1039692163,
-0.3687270582,
-0.3131221533,
0.3045657575,
0.507647872,
-0.5841907263,
0.1236980557,
0.1703726351,
-0.4701916873,
-0.7320644259,
0.1161360964,
-0.8793438673,
-0.1432827711,
-0.2665731907,
0.4865693152,
-0.3025502563,
-0.4447572529,
0.140570879,
-0.2653678358,
0.1002531126,
-0.1741755903,
-0.7900758982,
0.5836095214,
0.7711811066,
0.8126950264,
-0.266823411,
-0.4749716818,
-0.2116220593,
-0.2078000009,
-0.496335417,
0.5112931728,
-0.2126281857,
-0.6134831309,
0.0945945606,
-0.4630293548,
0.0023435177,
-0.6208933592,
0.9923707247,
-0.218415454,
0.4739457965,
0.0186097696,
-0.8577324748,
-0.0446930863,
0.5089236498,
-0.5655002594,
1.2911125422,
0.3536270857,
-0.6136466265,
0.7412213087,
-1.1098214388,
-0.336992681,
0.219848901,
0.1602968425,
-0.2803434134,
0.3173425198,
-0.0290457997,
0.3107253909,
-0.6334654093,
0.5640389323,
-0.0908772796,
-0.5215349197,
0.0572606586,
-0.5594028831,
0.7571316957,
0.0403268896,
-0.2670251131,
0.000019392,
-1.1553579569,
0.3616641462,
0.0984057933,
-0.5177575946,
-0.1584489644,
0.2520089746,
0.021086026,
-0.064723894,
0.1728601307,
-0.4209602475,
-0.2726343572,
-0.5719746947,
0.1093269587,
0.5410906672,
0.1963144839,
0.5216999054,
-0.2952328622,
0.9114823341,
-0.5417104959,
0.2209195346,
0.1034850627,
-0.197621569,
-0.7455037832,
0.2637216449,
0.3721075952,
0.3453293443,
-0.2440355569,
0.7861253023,
-0.4377060831,
-0.7805417776,
-0.4865873158,
0.2241279185,
0.557712853,
0.7855954766,
0.135465309,
-0.5080958009,
-0.5437420607,
-0.8156530857,
-0.4568972886,
-0.6286979914,
-0.3580963612,
-0.1096606776,
0.5249838829,
-0.0772680566,
1.0690633059,
-0.1829104424,
-0.0740275681,
-0.330229491,
0.3928041458,
0.1248219088,
0.4473441839,
0.7019124627,
-0.3461001813,
-0.1173791811,
-0.2265197039,
-0.9174777269,
-0.3428256214,
-0.0327003263,
-0.1170886084,
-0.1063929349,
0.1738760322,
-0.0509472452,
0.5297273993,
0.4804704189,
-0.4970568717,
1.2319492102,
0.0672394559,
0.1477805525,
-0.7707471848,
0.0036810513,
0.0197867919,
0.029672578,
-0.6278367639,
0.2480875403,
-0.2736177444,
0.0063217017,
-0.3127850592,
0.6606824994,
0.0428259373,
-0.1020909324,
-0.227492556,
0.5942853093,
0.2942751944,
0.0527888276,
-0.5062100291,
0.6531500816,
0.3478298485,
-0.8019511104,
0.3776655793,
0.2113876343,
-0.5540831685,
1.3021421432,
-0.8358986378,
-0.0656533912,
0.1472030133,
0.0068662819,
-0.6499618292,
-0.173792392,
0.0373475403,
-0.7689557076,
0.0131910508,
0.235264957,
-0.4977764487,
-0.3734076917,
-0.2552630901,
0.1196537092,
0.3542667627,
-0.549734652,
0.0957760587,
0.2159492821,
0.0653823763,
-0.4501162767,
-0.6886188984,
0.1225881726,
-0.5433522463,
-0.8255605102,
-0.0833854303,
-0.0979091972,
-0.5891775489,
0.0267924201,
-0.1003281996,
0.0110491719,
0.5054090619,
-0.0471097566,
0.2360524684,
-0.578245759,
0.2872099578,
-0.1814196706,
-0.1956175566,
0.5668965578,
-0.1575762182,
0.1593012065,
-0.3810060322,
-0.4723290205,
-0.2141064703,
0.2118782103,
0.1979952902,
-0.126423955,
0.5652734637,
0.7030310035,
-0.6336407065,
-0.278859973,
-0.3657811582,
-0.1046267077,
-0.4276417196,
0.691062212,
0.0401189663,
-0.6274908781,
0.266477108,
-0.0764834806,
0.3485883474,
0.5527163744,
0.41078493,
-0.2046961784,
0.8835123777,
0.7178292871,
0.1508754641,
0.1012175232,
-0.1648692936,
0.3222363591,
-1.1806775331,
-0.0767249912,
-0.3891169727,
-0.4274818599,
-0.174284175,
-0.1065114439,
0.3150274158,
0.4343709946,
-0.3101055324,
0.1404140443,
-0.4794847071,
0.548152864,
0.2014291435,
-0.281460911,
0.3779483736,
-0.1724136472,
-0.2259535193,
-0.2579206824,
-0.6262080669,
-1.0691659451,
1.1493703127,
0.4608668983,
0.5620329976,
0.3616954386,
0.6582839489,
0.3782560527,
0.4754008353,
-1.0439407825,
0.5324405432,
0.1142058596,
-0.7875349522,
-0.4400102198,
-0.5353491902,
-0.6920514107,
0.3221921027,
-0.1908468008,
-1.0167058706,
-0.2148090601,
0.0753772035,
-0.3208351731,
0.3355100751,
-0.7243319154,
0.9170393944,
-0.4541221261,
-0.1416994482,
-0.0324375629,
-0.3700688481,
0.6084759235,
-0.1274742037,
0.266572386,
-0.1218197644,
0.10989438,
1.1948102713,
-0.3860769272,
0.5787224174,
-0.0572908968,
-0.096359022,
0.4890601039,
0.3354885578,
-0.0823349208,
-0.0038056097,
-0.4262416363,
0.0606985651,
-0.0651950985,
-0.2622916698,
-0.8797061443,
0.4254612923,
-0.5148825049,
-0.2715105414,
-0.2596045434,
-0.3245891929,
-0.3926317394,
0.0309958197,
0.2378522754,
0.449164629,
-0.7409593463,
0.3048401177,
0.0620224439,
-0.0834599137,
0.3291729093,
0.2462390065,
-0.4620908797,
-0.3832191527,
0.9425497055,
-0.0612001643,
0.613274157,
-0.0077934554,
0.5410630703,
-0.4427691996,
-0.5738675594,
-0.3078737259,
-0.1180017069,
-0.8701498508,
-0.1591406316,
-0.120655112,
-0.3832509816,
-0.0892045051,
-0.2680104375,
-0.3624253869,
-0.4160404503,
-0.3089574873,
-0.5116975307,
0.0157663487,
0.8270213008,
-0.1400994211,
0.580389142,
-0.6109273434,
0.0699629262,
0.0104512498,
0.4519096315,
0.2152491957,
-0.7575204372,
-0.3666566014,
0.0691131353,
-0.4487527609,
-0.6800991297,
0.1537756622,
0.4054381251,
0.3985564113,
0.4298125207,
-0.2074338347,
0.7224787474,
-0.4570287168,
1.0290634632,
0.3818182051,
-1.0423536301,
0.6529269218,
-0.2404622585,
0.1014437079,
0.6936296821,
-0.0245056357,
-0.7522357106,
-0.4257013202,
-0.868727088,
-0.9822687507,
0.1984422654,
0.2524514496,
0.1103144214,
-0.0468069427,
0.3744433522,
0.0740951374,
0.137197122,
-0.5371286869,
-0.1017464325,
-0.0816271305,
-0.222598061,
-0.016394794,
-0.2044866383,
-0.2479409873,
-0.105420582,
0.613455236,
-0.1333890706,
0.0440510884,
-0.0582112372,
-0.2074360847,
-0.010044964,
0.5078524351,
0.4683479369,
1.3193153143,
-0.3162534833,
-0.065417476,
0.2804783583,
-0.5456556082,
0.2253458351,
-0.3348038793,
-0.0530367531,
0.0257987976,
0.6307322383,
0.6842911839,
0.3944405317,
-0.5339702964,
0.5053406358,
-0.1075083166,
-0.219935745,
-0.507094264,
0.1521921903,
-0.0017869726,
-0.173510775,
0.4671889544,
-0.1122562587,
0.1756337285,
-0.2323127687,
0.5451212525,
0.2604804933,
-0.5134695172,
-0.4479850829,
0.7190620303,
0.2735734582,
-0.7244624496,
0.5206968784,
-0.2397143841,
-0.3243715167,
0.7782133818,
0.8428578973,
0.9414150119,
-0.1127915233,
0.5839433074,
0.6103792787,
0.557516396,
0.0752162337,
0.1661449373,
0.2250287533,
-0.6423937082,
-0.3840833604,
-1.0660042763,
-0.4051750302,
0.0550274737,
-0.8908371329,
0.1466988474,
-0.5510795712,
-0.3307272196,
-0.2154257745,
0.0233762432,
-0.6813327074,
0.5479124188,
-0.1449258476,
0.7408248782,
-0.9086589813,
-0.0178846177,
0.5284889936,
-0.2864898145,
-0.7365387082,
-0.0134391785,
0.2923479378,
-0.6134570837,
0.4810194671,
-0.0248477273,
-0.2251464128,
-0.1361772269,
-0.2117829472,
-0.6212147474,
1.0880320072,
0.1778677553,
-0.2730914652,
0.0645619705,
0.1848619431,
0.8603506088,
-0.4153342545,
0.3717729747,
0.9497743845,
0.5402928591,
-0.0807838812,
-0.9591212273,
-0.0597687587,
-0.1416298747,
0.0297425278,
0.0282446556,
-0.31211254,
0.2012825161,
-0.305337131,
-0.3469862044,
0.2198534161,
0.4606210291,
0.4705687165,
0.264074862,
0.4352003634,
0.5561696291,
0.8430251479,
-0.2700966895,
1.1324716806,
-0.0123513173,
0.5876485109,
1.1586350203,
-0.0093186283,
0.7474853992,
0.3100884259,
-0.6163557172,
0.2224686295,
0.6808567047,
-0.1135493219,
-0.0145911807,
0.4563177824,
-0.2079383135,
0.1093041301,
-0.2517095804,
-0.2127017379,
0.6451312304,
0.3661450446,
-0.1869926006,
-0.3670809567,
-0.3553979397,
-0.060981296,
0.234895438,
-0.083515361,
0.5578827858,
0.1264240593,
-0.3351540267,
0.532158792,
0.0560627021,
0.4906262755,
-0.4783109725,
0.0665657073,
-0.1621316522,
-0.0535474047,
-0.4834326506,
-0.5585058331,
0.5671537519,
0.2180208117,
0.0975399613,
0.0531236865,
0.5107166171,
-0.0644313097,
-0.9033573866,
0.2630954981,
0.7106845975,
0.193238616,
0.403971076,
-0.6086885333,
-0.143826142,
-0.1822714657,
-0.2207833976,
0.0393427089,
0.1804050356,
0.148615703,
0.6245384812,
0.675311625,
0.3501955867,
0.124017559,
0.4019581974,
0.2244668752,
-0.5977538824,
-0.3483688533,
-0.9988555312,
0.7815346718,
-0.0783854648,
-0.52865237,
0.7058799267,
0.5583128929,
0.73919487,
0.3004652858,
0.8571138978,
-0.1262311339,
0.4529249668,
-0.3876570761,
0.9816621542,
-0.543071568,
0.4263749123,
-0.4938504994,
-1.2993267775,
-0.5474344492,
0.7578931451,
-0.1003649384,
0.1977649629,
0.860667944,
0.4716001153,
0.093073979,
0.1946118921,
0.3483490646,
-0.1352787167,
0.4543335438,
0.3060766757,
1.0507173538,
-0.5714623332,
0.3801390529,
-0.0841393098,
-0.3319863081,
0.1425749511,
-0.9048143625,
-0.6967971325,
-0.4058902264,
-0.4443004131,
-0.1846101433,
-0.126094386,
0.6198664904,
0.4938650727,
-0.4872073233,
-0.5347385406,
-0.0653786063,
0.2421202064,
-0.2449589521,
-0.3994100988,
0.3868285716,
-0.4309717715,
-0.6041680574,
0.3829366863,
0.2912393808,
-0.1202308834,
-0.7531859875,
-0.1783141792,
0.0750541538,
0.1063015163,
0.5939790606,
0.0742446929,
-0.713670373,
-0.5755583644,
-0.1499676704,
0.1569896787,
0.0349584855,
0.5288623571,
-0.4726704359,
0.5180708766,
0.3476788104,
0.669349134,
-0.1887971014,
0.146260336,
0.7633911967,
-1.0282816887,
-0.2275931239,
0.378932327,
0.1421042234,
0.5895901918,
-0.0488998257,
0.8427182436,
0.0338704735,
-0.6470597386,
-1.0339746475,
0.2656410038,
-0.504989922,
0.3043492436,
1.0046702623,
-0.0658897683,
-0.1310899407,
0.0929351524,
0.1373757571,
-0.0547826961,
-0.0277328789,
0.896217525,
1.0346409082,
-0.2349428236,
0.0548876226,
-0.8528158665,
0.3672397733,
0.3319887817,
-0.9086811543,
-0.1245204285,
0.3781889975,
0.3374635577,
0.4475357533,
0.4525713027,
-0.3704931736,
0.2351358831,
0.0906699151,
0.0033157645,
0.3048890829,
-0.0495667383,
-0.3113916516,
0.1027583107,
0.1638747752,
-0.0713938326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14888v1 | Privacy Implications of Retrieval-Based Language Models | 2023-05-24T08:37:27 | 2023-05-24T08:37:27 | Yangsibo Huang, Samyak Gupta, Zexuan Zhong, Kai Li, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Retrieval-based language models (LMs) have demonstrated improved
interpretability, factuality, and adaptability compared to their parametric
counterparts, by incorporating retrieved text from external datastores. While
it is well known that parametric models are prone to leaking private data, it
remains unclear how the addition of a retrieval datastore impacts model
privacy. In this work, we present the first study of privacy risks in
retrieval-based LMs, particularly $k$NN-LMs. Our goal is to explore the optimal
design and training procedure in domains where privacy is of concern, aiming to
strike a balance between utility and privacy. Crucially, we find that $k$NN-LMs
are more susceptible to leaking private information from their private
datastore than parametric models. We further explore mitigations of privacy
risks. When privacy information is targeted and readily detected in the text,
we find that a simple sanitization step would completely eliminate the risks,
while decoupling query and key encoders achieves an even better utility-privacy
trade-off. Otherwise, we consider strategies of mixing public and private data
in both datastore and encoder training. While these methods offer modest
improvements, they leave considerable room for future work. Together, our
findings provide insights for practitioners to better understand and mitigate
privacy risks in retrieval-based LMs. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/Princeton-SysML/kNNLM_privacy . | [
-0.0400630869,
-0.2837309837,
0.5503017306,
-0.096156612,
-0.1060205847,
-0.0596287139,
-0.1148304939,
-0.5600632429,
-0.0824467167,
0.9475687742,
-0.0559052937,
-0.6092296839,
-0.5694969893,
-0.1662779301,
-0.4793954492,
0.9416357875,
0.162089631,
-0.2034491301,
-0.1834234446,
-0.1257541776,
-0.1164269373,
-0.9319382906,
-0.1986466497,
0.0909073576,
0.6364325881,
0.0811462998,
0.9961310029,
0.7142234445,
0.4872843325,
0.2178229541,
-0.2174755037,
-0.1467976123,
-0.636424005,
0.5254587531,
-0.2140271664,
-0.6164115667,
-0.1090573967,
-0.2037746012,
0.698671937,
0.7157200575,
-0.3519265652,
0.2070898414,
0.2165250033,
0.9862590432,
-1.2372847795,
0.0462851413,
-0.5109524131,
0.0875890926,
-0.2530961335,
-0.1906946301,
-0.6663149595,
-0.6909529567,
0.2960153818,
-0.2290724516,
0.1390808225,
0.0740698203,
0.7135455012,
0.0453076102,
-0.4237155616,
-0.0439986885,
-0.6570457816,
0.7312198877,
-0.5914468169,
0.9025425911,
0.8363444209,
0.3782942295,
-0.0157877598,
-0.5929501057,
-0.0058472292,
-0.3734188378,
-0.4433627427,
-0.21471259,
0.0646560043,
0.0484129004,
0.149526,
0.5186963081,
-0.7054998279,
0.0935852602,
-0.2227829695,
-0.3027144074,
0.7785032392,
0.1453127414,
-0.0052013234,
-0.4282817841,
-0.2451324165,
-0.1285571456,
-0.7949790359,
-0.0789838657,
0.7774403095,
0.3686658442,
0.1287085414,
0.4613765478,
-0.3569718897,
0.3927533627,
-0.3371133208,
0.2164488435,
0.0648440048,
-0.4491938055,
-0.0923924297,
0.0405281857,
0.7411487103,
0.2685927749,
0.2362773567,
-0.6605345011,
-0.130351156,
-0.4819155037,
0.3387189806,
-0.7135628462,
-0.2109432071,
0.2217964828,
-0.6135433316,
-0.4429372251,
0.0722566396,
-0.9145943522,
-0.6144264936,
-0.0927227214,
0.5302155018,
-0.2017438859,
-0.2362247258,
0.2423146069,
0.0965110958,
-0.0699731559,
-0.1104133204,
-0.9619724154,
0.6907390952,
0.670052886,
0.5966218114,
-0.0127103776,
0.0633307174,
-0.3266379535,
0.3190224171,
-0.1744070798,
-0.0824454054,
-0.4013298154,
-0.7315517664,
0.3154973984,
0.0812007412,
0.0922506303,
-0.538462162,
0.3515618742,
-0.7843798995,
0.405346185,
-0.3135518134,
-0.6629029512,
0.0285076071,
0.072688289,
-0.7853985429,
0.801997602,
-0.0653473958,
-0.9206602573,
-0.0532675944,
-0.3753429651,
-0.3167656958,
0.0683619455,
-0.1077878922,
-0.4366011322,
0.0644641221,
-0.1560340971,
0.416846931,
0.1732688248,
0.2373332083,
-0.1884756684,
-0.4209939241,
0.601287365,
-0.3975122273,
0.8150740266,
0.3653511703,
-0.1606959254,
-0.4033733904,
-0.7230847478,
0.2122337073,
0.0625454038,
-0.3357767165,
-0.6852173209,
-0.1796480566,
-0.2476606518,
-0.1881617904,
0.6017989516,
-0.5662754178,
-0.4499870241,
-0.5071820021,
0.1897042543,
0.7476463914,
0.2220024019,
0.9612632394,
-0.1333378553,
0.478382796,
-0.1309925318,
0.710047543,
0.0655994564,
-0.3590561152,
-0.1742631942,
0.1452723891,
0.5408354998,
0.3201693594,
-0.2766645849,
0.1455424577,
-0.1275208443,
-0.3433839083,
-0.4610217512,
0.037462689,
0.6237028837,
0.2740028799,
0.011338518,
-0.1313585937,
-0.1941427588,
-1.0781704187,
-0.7190108299,
0.0563038401,
0.1992566884,
0.7437590957,
0.2276428938,
0.08871077,
0.6282727718,
-0.5281988978,
-0.1347429305,
0.2115442455,
-0.4759430885,
-0.0026035402,
0.6691391468,
0.2566455901,
-1.0285972357,
-0.6333020329,
-0.0638094619,
-0.6463115215,
0.1754920334,
0.2598367035,
-0.356695801,
0.2280753255,
0.1908281744,
-0.7016118169,
0.6376442313,
0.3566446006,
0.123711355,
0.351942569,
-0.3125809133,
-0.1206535846,
-0.8492393494,
0.1787713319,
-0.2594184577,
-0.4009981453,
-0.8182997108,
0.5072924495,
0.4018844962,
-0.4382559359,
-0.660723269,
0.537340343,
-0.4607801735,
-0.2090756893,
-0.2326672822,
0.0505911633,
0.1188875139,
0.3194923699,
-0.0236994028,
0.6216965914,
0.4547004998,
-0.8583012223,
-0.2206665426,
0.2564435899,
-0.26403144,
-0.0476003624,
-0.2412337363,
0.5847852826,
-0.2213099301,
-0.123398751,
-0.5162439942,
-0.1089475155,
0.4384889305,
-0.6081494689,
0.4899136126,
-0.1302144229,
-0.754791081,
0.1081930324,
-0.6140726209,
0.1651818305,
0.3922225237,
-0.5542314649,
0.3665516675,
0.5175136328,
-0.1059790328,
-0.8571623564,
-0.8329519629,
0.0196759515,
-0.1141449809,
-0.3415482342,
0.3943248391,
-0.0848035887,
-0.0298678149,
0.2454785258,
-0.2954058051,
-0.2593940496,
0.3546071947,
0.4044761956,
0.1730754822,
0.057950858,
-0.0237268209,
0.0697034895,
-0.3298760056,
0.1951926649,
-0.1806833297,
0.3782712221,
-0.1152745485,
-0.2760928571,
-0.5000267029,
0.5435036421,
-0.0375517197,
-0.2733004391,
1.2647321224,
-0.029044494,
-0.5533531904,
0.0736792535,
-0.3915497065,
-0.3834120929,
-0.5373686552,
0.2131574452,
0.1447709203,
-0.9636773467,
0.5239221454,
0.2071322799,
-0.029259393,
-0.1584136784,
0.335906148,
0.019283114,
0.8781787157,
0.6667939425,
-0.0890767202,
0.5965782404,
-0.0527261086,
0.4566732943,
-0.7881277204,
-0.5133215189,
-0.6246220469,
-0.2715575099,
-1.1288942099,
-0.0167682096,
0.1497793645,
-0.0720919296,
-0.2576701343,
0.3282463849,
-0.439999938,
0.7961764336,
0.5929936767,
0.3844588101,
0.4244063199,
-0.0109464107,
0.1370421648,
-0.2242511362,
-0.4295871258,
-0.439943701,
1.4079412222,
0.3612167835,
1.0290756226,
0.4840536416,
1.2585886717,
-0.0812378749,
-0.0114352144,
-0.2444185168,
0.6468783021,
-0.3109578192,
-0.9255923629,
-0.2097095251,
-0.6570169926,
-0.9451152682,
0.3110315502,
0.3008798957,
-1.1166994572,
0.5914471745,
0.0055224118,
-0.2604857087,
0.0208250694,
-0.6597262025,
0.7296695113,
-0.1412595361,
-0.7114029527,
0.0721233189,
-0.9644893408,
0.3634704053,
-0.0838889778,
0.0726343244,
0.1902832389,
-0.0455132611,
0.5049667954,
-0.2040898502,
0.7152933478,
-0.3405027092,
0.0273989365,
-0.1103374287,
0.4458017349,
0.5998367071,
0.2209949195,
-0.2191273123,
0.1613041162,
0.2492520809,
-0.2541252077,
-0.5865077376,
0.9799387455,
-0.525182426,
-0.7569437623,
-0.3751703799,
-0.5101905465,
-0.2844082713,
0.3369035423,
0.086469017,
0.2110262215,
0.172486648,
0.7151978612,
1.0053688288,
-0.5009295344,
0.1360778064,
0.8714108467,
-0.4607803524,
-0.2461517155,
0.922400713,
0.1868193597,
0.407105267,
0.4913608432,
0.4159085751,
-0.6789593697,
-0.6357138157,
0.1153406724,
0.3407042027,
-0.8751840591,
-0.2790474594,
-0.5895857811,
-0.4638152719,
-0.3576396704,
0.3221449852,
-0.4151979983,
-0.4169360399,
-0.3736474514,
-0.3233521283,
0.3630808592,
0.2142864466,
-0.137381047,
0.1471248418,
-0.8761406541,
-0.0494543873,
-0.0598505177,
0.6419487596,
-0.0186472367,
-0.354039669,
-0.2868955731,
-0.0728893504,
-0.0993071124,
-0.8465965986,
0.3315963149,
0.0738574117,
0.5598582625,
0.0135627389,
0.2805597186,
0.2287582606,
-0.457683295,
0.7284463644,
-0.3535231054,
-0.5504297018,
0.5317696333,
-0.1418018788,
-0.1346880049,
0.9409134388,
0.5234469175,
-0.5205006599,
-0.5481532216,
-0.7160000205,
-0.7783327699,
0.758677721,
0.4533208609,
0.6134088039,
-0.0357191414,
0.6641734242,
0.3175326288,
0.5839804411,
-0.6537857652,
-0.4579226375,
0.1003999412,
-0.1072377637,
0.2654317319,
-0.2884061933,
-0.0024614348,
0.0695537105,
0.5591713786,
0.3532906771,
0.1545447856,
-0.0810366571,
-0.1563218832,
0.1404851377,
0.1957808733,
0.2005178779,
0.3316715956,
-0.411247015,
0.1258259863,
-0.2879453003,
-0.473123312,
0.0364977457,
0.2569591701,
-0.5867402554,
0.2084603906,
-0.361035198,
0.5846709013,
0.4646081924,
-0.4904986322,
0.5138629675,
-0.1119188666,
-0.0916182324,
-0.0958530605,
0.1401329339,
0.1497843713,
0.1437638253,
0.0985237733,
-0.1991514564,
0.4855360091,
-0.219917208,
0.2456488013,
0.3832055926,
-0.0821940973,
-0.2284063399,
0.7293236256,
-0.1728722602,
-0.6187056303,
0.3758359849,
0.0248887073,
-0.2820366323,
0.1996973902,
0.3281870782,
0.7605027556,
-0.4758145213,
0.1771522164,
-0.0527658276,
0.2553617358,
-0.1086736321,
0.3441440761,
-0.1722999215,
-0.4617226422,
0.1081039235,
-0.4311041236,
-0.5343190432,
0.2762595713,
-1.1579719782,
-0.2337825447,
-0.5911127329,
-0.2467365563,
-0.392921418,
0.1590674669,
-0.4704406559,
-0.1371779591,
0.0595014542,
0.7101711631,
-0.2892027199,
0.6749079227,
0.1465235353,
-0.4083288014,
-0.523666203,
0.0085607357,
-0.2137524039,
-0.7148928642,
0.4758520424,
0.0759795383,
0.0431380607,
-0.0653145537,
-0.2553921938,
-0.8235034347,
0.9217571616,
0.7410482764,
-0.7708696127,
0.0414158367,
0.623706758,
0.5023639798,
0.3224388063,
-0.4344004095,
0.4041367471,
0.168507874,
-0.5772075653,
-0.7062137127,
0.1046842411,
0.1922914237,
0.2720288336,
0.5350081921,
-0.6468031406,
0.6507495642,
0.2211358696,
-0.3965061307,
0.2193679065,
0.3345380425,
0.1573102325,
0.4148756862,
-0.0321479477,
0.3602383733,
0.9280501008,
0.3496613503,
1.4352703094,
-0.5073388219,
0.5246242285,
1.182942152,
-0.4974667132,
0.9429972768,
0.4808273911,
-0.1887764186,
0.1248688847,
0.4374203086,
0.4618599415,
1.060313344,
0.1151876152,
-0.4138653874,
0.1685501188,
-0.1932894289,
-0.559239924,
0.0184441172,
0.1128263399,
-0.8291963935,
-0.2613738775,
0.0055383346,
-0.0598692633,
0.2203855664,
0.0379891247,
0.7071071863,
0.3716792464,
-0.1479770541,
0.1588449478,
-0.0012342724,
0.2755238414,
-0.6114535332,
0.4089309275,
-0.4108144939,
0.2500622869,
-0.2269318104,
-0.8261739612,
0.3931773007,
-0.1547546685,
-0.0181622077,
-0.2847628295,
0.8579320312,
-0.4431569874,
-0.1447179914,
0.3832117319,
0.3839562833,
0.3147110045,
-0.331309706,
-0.6255270243,
0.0907628462,
-0.2164487988,
-0.2565761507,
1.0271317959,
0.2505759299,
0.0300207827,
0.4644984007,
0.6578576565,
-0.0192542188,
0.3547197878,
0.3050077558,
0.6710319519,
-0.5742698312,
-0.6041883826,
-0.9042133093,
0.1679585278,
0.0016429222,
0.1030765995,
0.8626189828,
0.7090797424,
0.7238101959,
0.0274351407,
0.5031983256,
0.495233655,
0.5879034996,
-0.6544237733,
1.191088438,
-0.3353141546,
0.3317577541,
0.1041860059,
-0.7903836966,
-0.2799759507,
0.4406090379,
-0.3596721888,
0.1146803647,
0.6046049595,
1.0357786417,
0.1588750482,
0.3124417067,
0.3447357416,
-0.0986974314,
0.2090239823,
0.3684590161,
0.7913332582,
-0.5555201173,
0.4860637486,
-0.7110533118,
0.2574937344,
-0.1403058171,
-0.8415387273,
-0.4597767293,
-0.3203146458,
-0.3506213427,
-0.373493135,
0.4297526479,
0.2686906159,
0.5149571896,
-0.6593962908,
-0.0752935335,
-0.0128671993,
0.1755790859,
0.121804148,
-0.248220101,
0.3553696275,
0.0118005006,
-0.5288281441,
0.3524087369,
0.205522567,
-0.0293325838,
-0.2911661267,
-0.1674177498,
-0.1342349648,
-0.1617650092,
0.1904868633,
0.2754058838,
-0.4773818254,
-0.3699288964,
0.2886007428,
-0.221171543,
-0.0541266426,
0.6066339016,
-0.5517987013,
0.5208908319,
0.2838416696,
0.9979566932,
0.5879639387,
-0.0655408651,
0.4006397426,
-1.0443965197,
0.0477611423,
0.448707819,
0.1728343964,
0.4484733343,
-0.9930303097,
0.2975728214,
-0.1713837981,
-0.7136868834,
-1.3112159967,
0.1536880881,
-0.5307921171,
-0.0563381612,
0.9518409371,
-0.2332083732,
-0.4107458591,
-0.0677793398,
0.066376321,
0.0321333259,
-0.3679401577,
0.6966630816,
0.6543802023,
0.1000302359,
-0.207178846,
-0.998634398,
0.5280601382,
0.4584851563,
-0.4721699357,
0.3171861768,
0.1293192953,
0.4816141129,
0.0089077735,
0.58385396,
-0.5954086185,
0.3089845181,
-0.3635595441,
-0.4677944481,
-0.122577928,
-0.2995132804,
-0.6299538016,
0.0242202301,
0.0408899225,
-0.5874037743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14882v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14882v2 | Dynamic Clue Bottlenecks: Towards Interpretable-by-Design Visual Question Answering | 2023-05-24T08:33:15 | 2024-04-13T17:13:55 | Xingyu Fu, Ben Zhou, Sihao Chen, Mark Yatskar, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Recent advances in multimodal large language models (LLMs) have shown extreme
effectiveness in visual question answering (VQA). However, the design nature of
these end-to-end models prevents them from being interpretable to humans,
undermining trust and applicability in critical domains. While post-hoc
rationales offer certain insight into understanding model behavior, these
explanations are not guaranteed to be faithful to the model. In this paper, we
address these shortcomings by introducing an interpretable by design model that
factors model decisions into intermediate human-legible explanations, and
allows people to easily understand why a model fails or succeeds. We propose
the Dynamic Clue Bottleneck Model ( (DCLUB), a method that is designed towards
an inherently interpretable VQA system. DCLUB provides an explainable
intermediate space before the VQA decision and is faithful from the beginning,
while maintaining comparable performance to black-box systems. Given a
question, DCLUB first returns a set of visual clues: natural language
statements of visually salient evidence from the image, and then generates the
output based solely on the visual clues. To supervise and evaluate the
generation of VQA explanations within DCLUB, we collect a dataset of 1.7k
reasoning-focused questions with visual clues. Evaluations show that our
inherently interpretable system can improve 4.64% over a comparable black-box
system in reasoning-focused questions while preserving 99.43% of performance on
VQA-v2. | [
-0.2840458751,
-0.9034214616,
0.8470048308,
0.1852935255,
-0.6063475013,
0.432628125,
-0.0117537379,
-0.7132155299,
-0.412047714,
0.3636745811,
-1.1011615992,
-0.2675479949,
-0.227782771,
0.0901082382,
-0.1871920824,
0.5525135398,
-0.1722830981,
-0.3265898228,
-0.594337225,
-0.1167759895,
-0.7943271399,
-0.0655509382,
-0.421467036,
-0.0870305523,
0.4938433766,
0.4452875853,
0.7813802958,
0.8466633558,
0.4940031171,
0.3167861402,
-0.3240134418,
0.3143667579,
-0.7248902321,
0.2536777258,
-0.1845489591,
-0.8631672263,
-0.2894627154,
-0.2970870733,
0.1657647192,
0.6226290464,
-0.1353735328,
0.3717446327,
-0.0798480585,
0.5080918074,
-0.4861824811,
0.5873011947,
-0.8348047733,
-0.1169892922,
-0.2009381652,
-0.2956565917,
-0.3865973949,
-0.0933898687,
0.3933620155,
-0.9228252769,
0.1586371362,
0.1927501708,
0.8801215887,
0.6845547557,
-0.2255506516,
-0.425319463,
-0.4997147024,
0.6584365964,
-0.4185249209,
0.2537997365,
-0.2521904111,
0.6474556327,
-0.2382781357,
-0.6036219001,
-0.6834627986,
0.0625254586,
0.075177379,
0.2658376992,
-0.3368472159,
0.0059462213,
0.4129945636,
0.1949121803,
-0.6079884768,
-0.0777137801,
-0.2397632748,
-0.1035519242,
0.5008895993,
0.5281858444,
0.2927200794,
-0.2593286932,
-0.4774105251,
0.1463919878,
-0.7000883818,
0.5299984217,
-0.1209911108,
0.1433992386,
-0.1145781055,
0.4139975309,
-0.432466656,
0.7684262991,
0.1643946767,
0.0814743862,
-0.0087308828,
-0.5424503088,
-0.0407267734,
-0.1574236602,
0.3034590781,
0.583932817,
0.483882606,
-0.0587282367,
-0.1129795313,
0.217131421,
0.4505074918,
-0.7428151965,
-0.5708861947,
0.215500623,
-0.3121903241,
-0.5050073862,
-0.1323075145,
-0.9112619162,
-0.4028009474,
-0.2529364228,
0.3591340482,
-0.062857613,
-0.369905889,
0.1551196277,
-0.1583510041,
0.2208096981,
0.7423033118,
-0.3936971128,
-0.2350665927,
0.3301745951,
0.6917728782,
-0.119033739,
0.1893148571,
-0.297660172,
0.0940370634,
-0.3774386644,
0.737878561,
-0.4528321028,
-0.2005772889,
-0.0473590568,
0.074088186,
0.1690594852,
-0.5243893266,
0.3604218066,
-0.8517794609,
-0.168175295,
-0.6972689629,
-0.2363686711,
-0.1987182498,
0.1892064363,
-0.5607165694,
0.5319618583,
-0.2365297228,
-0.7225434184,
0.5127256513,
-0.5239541531,
-0.0429353006,
0.3259874582,
-0.4017765224,
-0.3049177229,
0.4393333197,
0.493868947,
0.0664563179,
-0.291421771,
0.1642273664,
-0.3903458416,
-0.529742837,
0.5292662382,
-0.558826685,
0.7595485449,
0.1911437064,
-0.5628423095,
0.1891333908,
-0.8064049482,
0.2418309748,
0.4652444124,
-0.2513785064,
-0.1965555549,
0.0844487622,
-0.3276407719,
0.2708685398,
0.2003313899,
-0.1950065047,
0.1300982833,
0.0111441417,
0.3393129706,
0.94181633,
-0.1149098724,
0.1439138502,
-0.0138684185,
0.9123489261,
0.0639434755,
0.1793096811,
-0.3449270725,
-0.5884289742,
-0.8343821764,
-0.4365246892,
-0.1080238074,
0.5327907801,
-1.3277322054,
-0.2839772999,
-0.1433160752,
-0.2547465265,
-0.5116055608,
0.0893536061,
0.6543544531,
0.5606518388,
0.1951500475,
-0.2013580054,
-0.1312985271,
-0.8930156231,
-0.4092838168,
-0.3503549993,
0.0848623812,
0.5892071724,
0.3128219247,
0.180291608,
0.6007999182,
-0.7714645267,
0.3372703493,
-0.1307706684,
0.3925971091,
0.3309400082,
-0.1604661494,
0.3456037045,
-0.7553032637,
-0.3324984312,
-0.379139334,
-1.02222085,
-0.3582805395,
-0.3676784635,
-0.2944301665,
-0.12363296,
0.6418016553,
-0.8353144526,
0.6462284327,
0.2012243867,
-0.5203701258,
0.8535958529,
0.0059911921,
-0.2111391574,
-0.3094404936,
-0.0447227657,
-0.1823228598,
-0.1204514652,
-0.3486054242,
0.2752048671,
-0.0393924564,
-0.1575181931,
-0.2839686573,
0.5204717517,
-0.8759527802,
0.1316186339,
-0.1890106946,
0.1006106511,
0.2548829913,
0.5264139175,
-0.1162623912,
0.7912151217,
0.5004901886,
-0.423754096,
0.365822345,
0.2725112438,
-0.6873447299,
0.763269186,
-0.9103294015,
0.0206806082,
-0.3940753937,
0.1397711486,
-1.3923788071,
-0.1997102052,
0.2620815933,
-0.3546403646,
0.3307286799,
-0.075814493,
-0.1181919053,
-0.6962518096,
0.0351841301,
0.5304176807,
0.2982462943,
-0.6629234552,
0.241213724,
-0.0226447079,
-0.0534453243,
-0.7705256343,
-0.4595168829,
0.0980063304,
-0.1984466761,
-0.7059349418,
0.0580129437,
-0.1365102828,
-0.2757549584,
0.1249076054,
-0.4336569905,
-0.1029232442,
0.1978417188,
0.3322581053,
0.4202155471,
-0.3111827672,
0.2694380581,
-0.2159448117,
-0.1204780713,
0.3755832613,
-0.1007080078,
0.0327172726,
-0.1400549859,
-0.1943837553,
-0.537573278,
0.2988220453,
1.0764443874,
-0.2549543679,
0.5516229868,
0.5954302549,
-0.0668725893,
-0.4314498901,
-0.2685356438,
-0.0904457793,
-0.5234941244,
0.4615295231,
-0.8189821839,
-0.7621839046,
0.6038329005,
-0.1967170984,
-0.0913163722,
0.0821025744,
0.6005461216,
-0.4285313487,
0.9892653227,
0.7305529118,
0.5899140835,
0.4250364602,
-0.0419019237,
0.1868424714,
-0.6198660135,
-0.3545832038,
-0.0251815505,
-0.2055187523,
-0.5181834102,
-0.5371080041,
0.5483111739,
0.2202017903,
-0.0010938589,
-0.030871449,
-0.5557530522,
0.320425272,
0.5686735511,
0.3067516088,
0.3801987767,
-0.1235008463,
-0.2210543156,
-0.1459326893,
-0.8694041371,
-0.3023747504,
0.914134264,
0.3081076145,
1.0209326744,
0.32569924,
0.0221769884,
-0.1921264082,
0.1929361075,
-0.6624392867,
0.4994599819,
0.2130248547,
-1.0101925135,
-0.4659309983,
-0.4787946045,
-0.7169018388,
0.2975010872,
-0.2594961226,
-0.7538390756,
0.3042315543,
0.6106097698,
-0.4759610295,
0.0244104546,
-0.5404066443,
0.9788659215,
-0.4976684153,
-0.833647728,
-0.1534227282,
-0.6747713089,
0.8424720168,
-0.053425543,
0.1038578674,
-0.0193069614,
0.0623009577,
0.3271899521,
-0.4083378613,
0.9015541077,
-0.2241647542,
-0.052034121,
0.3699452579,
0.0719916523,
0.6201810241,
0.1358054727,
0.0962343588,
0.0163360443,
-0.0259132478,
-0.4632876515,
-0.9567886591,
0.2696134448,
-0.4560385644,
-0.909794271,
-0.2921247184,
-0.7230708003,
-0.0841101781,
0.0442495123,
0.2437726855,
0.6682611704,
0.0988617912,
0.1115683317,
0.7799178958,
-0.5418781042,
0.2221855521,
0.4776805639,
-0.138043344,
0.0982470363,
0.808188796,
-0.006778636,
0.4219414592,
0.3041145802,
0.0649496093,
-0.6217553616,
-0.7479205728,
-0.8915531039,
0.1706653833,
-0.7512996793,
0.0315684266,
-0.3736772239,
0.0086160572,
0.3519171476,
-0.045299992,
-0.3143307269,
-0.2500152588,
-0.2222885042,
0.166132912,
0.2730041742,
0.6794565916,
0.1150615588,
0.1702560335,
-0.3231971264,
0.5656082034,
0.7632281184,
0.4761174619,
0.3135340512,
-0.5438442826,
-0.201125443,
-0.0635111928,
-0.147648707,
-0.8770286441,
-0.0078220898,
-0.0335585438,
0.6232869029,
0.4878926873,
0.3244345188,
0.8816350698,
-0.4194739461,
0.4756850302,
0.2054633796,
-0.6943877339,
0.3758529127,
-0.4664393067,
0.8159970641,
0.5665650368,
0.2570334077,
-0.1772651076,
-0.29536587,
-0.1827201545,
-0.8245601058,
0.3760686219,
0.1380297393,
-0.1028188542,
0.2908694148,
0.5504376888,
-0.009722692,
0.5273168087,
-0.4371267855,
-0.0833737627,
-0.2494548559,
-0.169359684,
0.1724370867,
-0.4795799553,
-0.0419501774,
-0.2660507858,
0.1398552656,
-0.2040649503,
0.4205179214,
0.0808514357,
-0.3378097117,
-0.3616805375,
0.0521870032,
0.6409839392,
1.2243123055,
-0.4738366604,
0.2713339031,
-0.1084572077,
-0.3386422098,
0.0577319153,
-0.1596131921,
-0.2774478793,
-0.0299856793,
0.6186623573,
0.8601452112,
0.1268981546,
-0.8682056069,
0.490013361,
-0.4179263413,
0.0296478607,
-0.2102499008,
0.1132718548,
0.1895351708,
0.6218088269,
0.3193250597,
-0.0421179086,
-0.0381784849,
-0.8701360822,
0.2219892293,
0.7273416519,
-0.5576339364,
-0.4251868427,
0.9530704618,
0.2716822326,
-0.1195560396,
0.7032071948,
-0.1726988107,
-0.6587924361,
0.5586423278,
0.160702318,
0.6051720381,
-0.0029675351,
0.4016145766,
0.2371883243,
0.3992570043,
0.3423706293,
0.5965591669,
-0.1330949068,
-0.4708631933,
-0.5954877734,
-0.4787336588,
-0.4108825326,
0.1441959143,
-0.7839552164,
0.1173240468,
-0.2692576647,
0.0251303595,
0.2507199347,
-0.1655143946,
-0.9262317419,
0.2634105086,
0.1567672193,
0.8074891567,
-0.5875974894,
0.5109502673,
0.5713545084,
-0.4207552969,
-0.5352196097,
0.1025382355,
0.3759137094,
-1.1241203547,
0.6065889597,
0.0706162974,
-0.2178540528,
-0.226173088,
-0.8053156137,
-0.8193457127,
1.085349679,
0.1797731817,
-0.7802711129,
-0.192679137,
-0.0436203666,
0.5933740139,
-0.1618607491,
0.188330248,
0.3552725017,
0.4608258307,
0.53408283,
-0.6560758352,
0.506192565,
-0.3111505508,
-0.2366506457,
-0.1307938248,
-0.5450947285,
0.6434671879,
-0.6654656529,
-0.4517642856,
0.2058233172,
0.3644680679,
0.2817694843,
0.4249562621,
0.7007844448,
0.3912835121,
0.9045273662,
-0.1885401607,
1.0252802372,
-0.0383020751,
0.012444865,
1.2291423082,
0.2692607045,
0.5800457597,
0.5737369657,
-0.0407155305,
0.4994459748,
0.5843958259,
0.1804141402,
0.7235832214,
0.584926486,
-0.1531390846,
-0.7763974071,
-0.2369064689,
-0.1914920956,
0.7236474752,
0.3963026106,
-0.2576286793,
-0.1436224878,
-0.3582850993,
-0.108347863,
-0.0873738825,
-0.0966883376,
0.5207680464,
0.2006793171,
-0.5671597123,
0.8408195376,
-0.5156740546,
0.289542079,
-0.2465399951,
-0.170499891,
-0.1154735759,
0.2855521142,
0.1032048613,
-0.8439436555,
0.1293133646,
-0.0414364971,
-0.3392485678,
0.0018611554,
0.445689559,
-0.3590995371,
-0.6202713251,
-0.0249959752,
0.8853527308,
-0.0023963067,
-0.153284356,
-0.9538479447,
0.3919687271,
-0.0226727705,
-0.0990372151,
-0.1520533562,
0.9001691341,
-0.2434784025,
1.1156436205,
0.5045745373,
-0.1833683997,
-0.0567133874,
-0.2044945061,
0.9085940719,
-0.6604213119,
-0.4682146013,
-0.6625913978,
0.862161696,
-0.0997572765,
-0.2376589328,
0.611795485,
-0.0811226889,
0.4315595329,
-0.0245031025,
0.7073461413,
0.275496453,
0.264056325,
-0.5135193467,
0.6497843266,
-0.8723669648,
0.397940129,
-0.4236166477,
-0.6315410733,
-0.1382608563,
0.3988237381,
-0.2094994783,
-0.2549875379,
0.6480669975,
0.7750508785,
0.0709609315,
-0.1131226867,
0.3229800463,
0.5176365376,
0.3988109231,
0.7777125239,
1.2523559332,
0.046726875,
0.9065061212,
-0.0071347598,
-0.3946632147,
-0.4703129232,
-0.9100990295,
-1.0424927473,
-0.3184952736,
-0.4192832112,
-0.1821377575,
0.2052712291,
0.0588074438,
0.7041816711,
-0.4072757065,
0.111774981,
-0.0874189958,
0.3981283605,
-0.3000352681,
-0.2533503473,
0.2933154702,
-0.1132600158,
-0.197783336,
0.1700584739,
0.2953211069,
-0.0994246975,
-0.4448311329,
0.2068462074,
0.0153882829,
0.290035218,
0.672439754,
0.2205346078,
-1.0654394627,
-0.5459676981,
0.3190509379,
0.2395680696,
0.0508178025,
0.5961275101,
-0.6739838719,
1.1274209023,
0.4184531868,
0.4998113811,
0.6802229285,
0.2058209777,
0.7667012215,
-0.3599484861,
-0.0557914935,
-0.1106777191,
-0.0096945809,
0.2325052023,
-0.4188418686,
0.3176886737,
0.3991056383,
-0.2157597989,
-0.8527578712,
0.4680423439,
-1.0495245457,
-0.5206489563,
0.6982031465,
-0.3144750297,
-0.3263127506,
-0.4296159148,
-0.1062754542,
0.1896339506,
-0.1998708695,
0.8786779642,
0.6903348565,
-0.2394825667,
-0.6491243243,
-0.8348947167,
0.6463732719,
0.2380491942,
-0.5139719248,
0.247159943,
0.4996635318,
0.1224010289,
0.0549848303,
0.3355979621,
0.0399993844,
0.5504594445,
0.2189664841,
-0.1672542542,
-0.1383466125,
-0.5141358972,
-0.1419834793,
0.2240401506,
0.2099609375,
-0.3413852453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14879v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14879v2 | ByteSized32: A Corpus and Challenge Task for Generating Task-Specific World Models Expressed as Text Games | 2023-05-24T08:31:30 | 2023-10-23T18:10:31 | Ruoyao Wang, Graham Todd, Eric Yuan, Ziang Xiao, Marc-Alexandre Côté, Peter Jansen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we investigate the capacity of language models to generate
explicit, interpretable, and interactive world models of scientific and
common-sense reasoning tasks. We operationalize this as a task of generating
text games, expressed as hundreds of lines of Python code. To facilitate this
task, we introduce ByteSized32 (Code: github.com/cognitiveailab/BYTESIZED32), a
corpus of 32 reasoning-focused text games totaling 20k lines of Python code. We
empirically demonstrate that GPT-4 can use these games as templates for
single-shot in-context learning, successfully producing runnable games on
unseen topics in 28% of cases. When allowed to self-reflect on program errors,
game runnability substantially increases to 57%. While evaluating simulation
fidelity is labor-intensive, we introduce a suite of automated metrics to
assess game fidelity, technical validity, adherence to task specifications, and
winnability, showing a high degree of agreement with expert human ratings. We
pose this as a challenge task to spur further development at the juncture of
world modeling and code generation. | [
-0.1887007505,
-0.7375586033,
0.7655500174,
0.2611955702,
0.1407732666,
-0.317119956,
-0.3097593486,
-0.3894321918,
-0.3704088926,
0.6002749801,
-0.4594403207,
-0.431201309,
-0.3497513831,
0.2475189418,
-0.1796284169,
1.1235438585,
-0.0607216768,
-0.2228248119,
-0.6638444662,
0.289839834,
-0.2822860777,
-0.4135202467,
-0.2619285285,
-0.4324990213,
0.1642058343,
0.4178251326,
0.4942151308,
0.4637750983,
0.6044132113,
0.3515448272,
0.0247607548,
0.082610473,
-0.3625658751,
0.3314218819,
-0.2836787403,
-0.450262785,
-0.3658189178,
0.1166220903,
0.3772456348,
0.4776688814,
-0.0228122473,
0.3277421594,
0.2632937431,
0.3059828579,
-0.3135922253,
0.4503147006,
-0.6796694398,
0.1663084179,
0.0743875727,
-0.0906053334,
-0.3272982538,
0.0008389641,
0.2753291428,
-1.1838879585,
0.3817921281,
0.0243025962,
0.5966737866,
0.2257678956,
-0.202209428,
-0.5490273833,
-0.5734286308,
0.7846212387,
-0.559061408,
-0.0467347056,
0.1677887589,
0.0903633833,
-0.3931137323,
-0.6529502869,
-0.4507299662,
-0.1531015337,
0.3655311167,
0.2114444524,
-0.3603980243,
0.1502867788,
0.6434203982,
-0.1497309953,
-0.3514406681,
-0.465811044,
-0.5433682799,
-0.2740342021,
0.6902630925,
0.4077753425,
0.3842108846,
-0.1439836323,
-0.0788512155,
0.1677345186,
-0.675994277,
0.130570218,
0.6071134806,
0.0347689018,
-0.2074713558,
0.7005085945,
-0.0577490479,
0.6082931757,
0.0693687797,
-0.1254152358,
-0.2076540738,
-0.3254672587,
0.1178953499,
-0.0560591333,
0.8166451454,
0.4493803978,
0.2430435866,
-0.3582271039,
-0.2266727984,
0.3251108229,
0.5610547066,
-0.9299072623,
-0.3127624094,
0.4466799498,
-0.3202536702,
-0.3815570176,
-0.2096638232,
-0.6328042746,
-0.3042584658,
-0.1176417321,
0.2820744514,
-0.8512765765,
-0.1477119923,
0.227975145,
-0.5203370452,
-0.0129639795,
0.4145474434,
-0.9117971659,
0.1950839907,
0.8296524286,
0.8780198097,
-0.3685074151,
-0.4545480907,
-0.0777006298,
0.2109178007,
-0.3356769085,
0.8519310355,
-0.5229828954,
-0.4693852961,
-0.3030094802,
-0.2745089531,
0.1849126965,
-0.4977301657,
0.3159557283,
-0.227956146,
-0.0495773107,
-0.2072850764,
-0.7207422256,
0.0878012627,
0.7371763587,
-0.5279629827,
0.8458848596,
-0.0860536397,
-0.8471474051,
0.3341668546,
-0.9519421458,
-0.2993564606,
0.3992660344,
-0.3141993582,
0.0747105554,
0.1225385293,
0.0510941781,
0.3355152011,
-0.2588734031,
0.4435568154,
-0.3732490838,
-0.572178781,
0.1071298793,
-0.3100275695,
0.4862618446,
0.2411529273,
-0.49741292,
0.0474278554,
-0.4838071465,
0.2425446212,
0.1464268416,
-0.5444591641,
-0.0915497988,
0.3576243222,
0.0067821071,
-0.0047665355,
0.225504756,
-0.8189074993,
0.3261194825,
-0.2468380183,
0.6861162186,
0.330524683,
-0.0435446389,
0.4269686937,
-0.5048725605,
0.5055066347,
-0.0267811753,
-0.0059522018,
-0.2724397182,
-0.8719335794,
-0.2858566046,
-0.078102313,
0.202738747,
0.5255660415,
-0.8287111521,
0.1781872213,
-0.4278291464,
-0.6909482479,
-0.1296344846,
-0.2567820549,
0.2790887058,
0.3981619775,
0.3331372738,
-0.0320838131,
-0.5553163886,
-0.5418972373,
-0.3615998924,
-0.1713399738,
-0.0080750799,
0.4396552444,
0.8645997047,
-0.1992164999,
1.1967302561,
-0.2775267363,
0.1389947534,
-0.1675578803,
0.2744095623,
-0.0048269127,
0.6757457852,
0.1847536713,
-0.7192581296,
-0.2133184522,
-0.0480368473,
-1.0219042301,
0.0599639975,
-0.1175046414,
-0.0531267971,
0.1569641531,
0.3972858191,
-0.5756577849,
0.2993302941,
0.4517973661,
-0.4595726132,
0.9936679006,
-0.5012048483,
0.3519506156,
-0.660761416,
0.281916976,
-0.0055470024,
-0.0992637053,
-0.3494790494,
0.4711002409,
0.0416926965,
-0.3787039816,
-0.3280582428,
0.5228949785,
-0.4911059737,
0.0008137043,
-0.1934042126,
0.178958267,
-0.084481284,
0.2628861964,
0.3381407261,
0.868424654,
0.4631656408,
-0.6875036955,
0.4884490967,
0.1291852444,
-0.6446245313,
0.4581612647,
-0.8418645859,
0.0840376541,
0.0736039802,
0.2330011874,
-0.553833127,
-0.2442284971,
-0.1277628094,
-0.4604797959,
-0.2747847736,
-0.2322368324,
-0.3365296423,
-0.286456883,
0.0215602554,
0.3931163847,
0.5284404755,
-0.244673565,
0.2710160315,
0.5344600081,
-0.0201543774,
-0.4617922902,
-0.7893076539,
0.0933864936,
-0.2064662427,
-0.6307826638,
0.6323747039,
-0.3342144191,
-0.2553330958,
0.1926450878,
-0.1224943697,
-0.0265081581,
0.1023064554,
0.4445613325,
0.0746431425,
-0.158224985,
-0.0873131081,
0.1080254689,
0.0906686038,
0.3622164726,
-0.5420034528,
0.2511104345,
-0.3721616268,
-0.2651011646,
0.200485304,
0.3870205879,
0.2424813509,
0.1031188816,
0.2315874398,
0.2809930146,
-0.4726148546,
-0.322514087,
-0.2297510207,
0.0146265095,
-0.4697995186,
0.5298729539,
-0.6852453947,
-1.0529335737,
0.6256846189,
-0.1395362467,
0.1446757168,
0.3832733035,
0.6413766742,
-0.0126616191,
0.8901385665,
0.4201719463,
0.4397941828,
-0.0368900448,
-0.0895191059,
-0.1154634506,
-0.5916767716,
-0.1968402117,
-0.2544507682,
-0.1629216522,
-0.4271665514,
-0.7164965272,
0.4304557145,
0.0894665122,
-0.5294597149,
0.355250597,
-0.8464810252,
0.8468910456,
0.5146285295,
0.1049154401,
0.1947160214,
-0.1832522154,
-0.4893979728,
-0.0375527926,
-0.7930850387,
-0.7634654045,
1.2200603485,
0.0710862353,
0.5412095785,
0.0241903588,
1.0006262064,
0.418135345,
0.2788874805,
-0.5414523482,
0.5669440627,
0.1956184953,
-1.0377851725,
-0.3433413506,
-0.5621271729,
-0.8850548863,
-0.0394971184,
-0.3221466839,
-0.809910059,
-0.3744620383,
0.1352037936,
-0.5740530491,
0.2430625111,
-0.7088546157,
1.1926578283,
0.0123082027,
-0.5756406188,
-0.1906780452,
-0.3509514332,
0.4785295129,
0.0860728025,
0.3701837063,
-0.0177492108,
-0.0559759475,
0.7109333277,
-0.1153288335,
0.7378868461,
-0.1357090026,
-0.1547515243,
0.7458407283,
0.4809026718,
0.2196042091,
0.3492334783,
-0.0450179465,
0.1170440838,
0.6551890373,
-0.4725574255,
-0.3838240206,
0.7257403731,
-0.6495981812,
-0.5475373864,
-0.5877962112,
-1.0298810005,
-0.1345069706,
0.3190709651,
0.4092846513,
0.4975127578,
-0.6809755564,
-0.0760921463,
0.6372470856,
-0.3077600896,
0.3913460374,
0.2275957912,
-0.1205751225,
-0.0441086106,
1.0908794403,
-0.0413751304,
0.0698986128,
0.2628138363,
0.1340118945,
-0.0996153355,
-0.5998960733,
-0.463259995,
-0.2809529901,
-0.6359708905,
-0.2355690897,
-0.5021898746,
-0.0518776737,
-0.3868097961,
-0.1333210021,
-0.2946875095,
-0.2773335278,
-0.0888497084,
0.2220650464,
0.1108594835,
1.2008548975,
-0.2255338728,
0.1354356408,
-0.9185898304,
0.0969755501,
0.0159440208,
0.2979204953,
-0.1840257943,
-0.2517889738,
-0.1960833073,
0.2186436951,
-0.4661620259,
-0.9280699492,
0.2693229318,
0.0430077836,
0.352096945,
0.0161124058,
-0.047129225,
0.452568084,
-0.793278873,
1.0821955204,
0.1432293504,
-1.2119992971,
0.2943747342,
-0.6881811619,
0.362342,
0.2162772864,
0.2928922772,
-0.4847660959,
-0.4196430445,
-0.7751749754,
-0.4181087017,
0.6733099222,
0.1790679246,
0.0862132385,
-0.3368959725,
0.3907739818,
0.1628384888,
0.0320186801,
-0.5347449183,
0.0992851704,
-0.2775730193,
-0.4186728299,
0.1778137237,
0.015863264,
-0.1002799124,
-0.0910143927,
0.5612244606,
-0.4503840804,
0.5194915533,
0.296580255,
-0.1951097846,
0.2355035245,
0.2467565536,
0.6176378727,
0.557382822,
-0.1075930446,
0.2099930942,
-0.0006557206,
-0.7303708792,
0.0649748445,
0.048240941,
-0.2630441785,
-0.4179151356,
0.3995007873,
0.4923523068,
0.2716943026,
-1.027038455,
0.4441380203,
-0.1408431679,
-0.4797966778,
-0.1378477067,
0.22073026,
0.4295383692,
0.4221072197,
0.2290827036,
0.0405419171,
0.1830120832,
-0.4614937305,
0.3676657379,
0.4550688565,
-0.3773307502,
-0.3000481129,
0.7792941928,
0.3036171198,
-0.1494275182,
0.5297166109,
-0.8066952229,
-0.5426620245,
0.9418610334,
0.956532836,
0.3641707003,
0.4112268686,
0.3237037957,
0.6051408052,
0.3390259445,
-0.2819774747,
0.3044169843,
-0.0274045486,
-0.8610175252,
-0.5503709912,
-0.4416613281,
-0.6917088032,
-0.0550824255,
-0.3993624747,
0.0543983988,
-0.305006206,
-0.3289678693,
-0.0864680037,
0.1325716078,
-0.5856345296,
0.1532432735,
0.3460813761,
0.7449644208,
-0.5372844934,
0.6699311137,
0.9877890944,
-0.4152483344,
-0.6860628724,
-0.2099275738,
-0.1865318418,
-0.368026644,
0.5622908473,
0.1047315076,
0.2143333554,
0.1186275557,
-0.8757526875,
-0.7786084414,
0.9487867951,
0.4340890348,
-0.3685992658,
-0.3156260252,
0.0880514234,
0.3870075345,
-0.4519500434,
0.634636879,
0.4966131151,
0.4191706777,
-0.2882294655,
-0.7498861551,
0.0818412304,
-0.3908171356,
-0.2166130245,
-0.0737939253,
-0.3530141115,
0.7222554684,
-0.5735787749,
-0.1243865937,
0.0697804615,
0.8426672816,
0.6797882915,
0.1649036109,
0.388245672,
0.4697948396,
0.680616498,
-0.2326373458,
0.936755836,
-0.3934889734,
0.4043865204,
0.8369174004,
-0.2349859476,
0.5372063518,
0.3615135252,
-0.2713522911,
0.4478668869,
0.5596892834,
-0.1723042876,
0.3458220959,
0.5118846893,
-0.063062422,
-0.5499790311,
0.2696786821,
-0.0922509134,
0.5016357899,
0.5079404712,
0.2675065398,
-0.3901147544,
-0.0221333522,
-0.0841573328,
0.1721490622,
-0.1392789483,
0.3731696308,
-0.1030101553,
-0.9811585546,
0.2953285575,
0.0414539203,
1.1675978899,
-0.5630668402,
-0.324637413,
-0.0455800146,
0.1812929809,
-0.0483285338,
-0.8311754465,
0.3831761479,
0.339787662,
-0.2860088348,
-0.0839371979,
0.5910040736,
-0.3931690753,
-0.3555934727,
-0.1093192771,
0.4885403514,
0.5070881844,
-0.3650463223,
-0.8883294463,
0.141533643,
0.0673298538,
-0.3939934671,
0.4821446538,
0.729532063,
-0.0124896821,
0.6247316599,
0.4555903077,
0.0320242867,
0.0743375272,
-0.6282036304,
0.4096354246,
-0.7142177224,
-0.5538506508,
-0.6412546039,
0.1086001843,
-0.0697799399,
-0.4757234454,
0.6120806932,
0.7902456522,
0.726478219,
-0.2844709158,
1.2089858055,
-0.5020544529,
0.0940405503,
-0.2365315557,
1.0143436193,
-0.3337729871,
-0.0783355087,
-0.2105039358,
-0.5599364042,
-0.0684557185,
0.5532912612,
-0.1557720006,
-0.1159843728,
0.7460990548,
0.5332593322,
-0.116072312,
0.192870602,
0.3206025958,
-0.2099372745,
0.4022893012,
1.0349289179,
0.7992743254,
-0.3863039911,
0.6751138568,
-0.2291368842,
-0.1938990355,
0.308042556,
-1.2358900309,
-0.9144118428,
-0.7099983692,
-0.42577371,
-0.5606023073,
0.0936322287,
0.786300838,
0.6169329882,
-0.567643106,
-0.3586937785,
-0.4473315477,
-0.0142112691,
-0.3417565525,
-0.2295327336,
0.1081576422,
-0.5402242541,
-0.9531815648,
0.4766620398,
-0.0617433079,
-0.1848441362,
-0.1820572317,
-0.0981773064,
0.160748601,
0.2029410601,
0.4686686397,
0.2493371516,
-0.5962282419,
-0.4406507015,
0.2068837136,
-0.2317067534,
-0.32183671,
0.8545002341,
-0.791503787,
0.3152399063,
0.4147782624,
0.5743901134,
0.5990170836,
-0.1135947108,
0.7249469757,
-0.5174847245,
0.221206665,
0.415098995,
0.230383262,
0.252271831,
-0.2870754302,
0.558047235,
0.3566209674,
-0.7143987417,
-0.8326914907,
0.1064519361,
-0.7737667561,
-0.358666271,
1.3000907898,
-0.4880341589,
-0.4367156327,
-0.1194536611,
-0.1469167769,
0.2260169536,
-0.3050870001,
0.5801609159,
0.9896580577,
-0.2274606973,
0.2191911787,
-0.5897244215,
0.7145928144,
0.2170736343,
-0.8778133392,
0.2566455901,
0.6035974026,
0.4437600076,
0.3192485571,
0.6352629066,
0.0450792201,
0.3174833357,
0.6045848131,
0.5215860605,
-0.3297475576,
-0.1849167496,
0.1105940938,
0.3309218884,
-0.227786079,
0.1672713161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14878v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14878v2 | Leveraging GPT-4 for Automatic Translation Post-Editing | 2023-05-24T08:30:05 | 2023-10-23T23:18:18 | Vikas Raunak, Amr Sharaf, Yiren Wang, Hany Hassan Awadallah, Arul Menezes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Neural Machine Translation (NMT) represents the leading approach to
Machine Translation (MT), the outputs of NMT models still require translation
post-editing to rectify errors and enhance quality under critical settings. In
this work, we formalize the task of direct translation post-editing with Large
Language Models (LLMs) and explore the use of GPT-4 to automatically post-edit
NMT outputs across several language pairs. Our results demonstrate that GPT-4
is adept at translation post-editing, producing meaningful and trustworthy
edits to translations that help improve its general quality as well as remove
different classes of major errors in translations. In particular, human
evaluations on assessing edit trustworthiness show that GPT-4 exhibits a large
improvement over the prior state-of-the-art LLM. Notably, we improve upon
state-of-the-art performance on WMT-22 English-Chinese, English-German,
Chinese-English and German-English language pairs using GPT-4 based
post-editing, as evaluated by state-of-the-art MT quality metrics. However, we
also show that GPT-4 could produce hallucinated edits, thereby urging caution
in its use as an expert translation post-editor. | [
-0.2862863541,
-0.5800562501,
0.7834960818,
0.104219757,
-0.4592564404,
0.1272087246,
-0.3791514635,
-0.4667637348,
-0.0215104893,
0.2607486844,
-0.237480104,
-0.6561065912,
-0.8894912601,
0.5796383619,
-0.2925940752,
1.1645927429,
-0.5721832514,
0.1455090195,
0.2780178487,
-0.0058589764,
-0.6693475246,
-0.7243213654,
-0.7401744723,
-0.2228668034,
0.7085635066,
-0.1318185031,
1.1145708561,
0.6694735885,
0.5942057967,
0.3428252637,
0.0362769477,
0.2684409916,
-0.2184831053,
-0.0629312322,
-0.2884289324,
-0.1232966259,
-1.2793812752,
0.261069268,
0.8291629553,
0.2420410812,
0.1996203959,
-0.1428667456,
0.1988196224,
0.4403130114,
0.0936689675,
0.1439810097,
-0.6993567348,
0.1457315087,
-0.1599577814,
-0.3402951062,
-0.0068834084,
-0.6037249565,
0.0158968735,
-0.7265993357,
0.1146445796,
-0.3107540011,
1.0009002686,
0.5365008712,
-0.287368685,
-0.0382844843,
-0.5064148307,
0.1278832406,
-0.8879586458,
0.5422893167,
0.5192147493,
-0.0874068961,
-0.0334203579,
-0.7354738712,
-0.5058842897,
0.0244599935,
-0.0652972534,
0.2772760391,
-0.0316537991,
0.2815217376,
0.3495952487,
0.4573788345,
-0.5515617132,
0.0171257034,
-0.1868084371,
-0.3398857713,
0.3528543115,
-0.0244909078,
0.4046475589,
-0.0651791841,
-0.0702377111,
0.3014298379,
-0.8290569186,
-0.420214802,
0.5081472993,
-0.1531310678,
0.2785019279,
0.6127981544,
0.071837604,
0.6769363284,
0.1762334853,
0.2877447903,
0.2428667396,
-0.69163692,
-0.278103739,
-0.1388082206,
1.1092237234,
0.6956958175,
0.0851843655,
-0.3384194076,
-0.7351908684,
-0.0333001055,
0.1976158768,
-0.7976943851,
-0.4126600623,
-0.1228539497,
-0.2295738161,
-0.3821697533,
-0.2216543853,
-0.3536026478,
-0.1916644871,
-0.5155612826,
0.6798844337,
-0.5133851171,
-0.1774803847,
0.2443075776,
-0.0024976924,
0.0653649718,
0.6117463708,
-0.7488949299,
0.223620981,
0.482277602,
1.0894001722,
-0.3711575568,
-0.6034069061,
-0.5773775578,
0.1830800772,
-0.7250267267,
0.5630019903,
-0.2812611163,
-0.2667790353,
-0.2619290948,
-0.024065787,
0.0428710617,
-0.317038089,
0.6563113928,
-0.9106516242,
0.247567296,
-0.5527259707,
-0.4025269747,
-0.3083515763,
0.4986979663,
-0.6247869134,
0.7815862894,
0.1460048556,
-0.5897952914,
0.2567361593,
-0.7575311065,
-0.5248544812,
-0.0235452075,
0.0627502501,
-0.2663216889,
0.202327475,
0.3384848833,
0.4306678474,
-0.1300167143,
0.3561168015,
0.2005330324,
-0.3966767788,
0.1183238477,
-0.5053032041,
0.1556382775,
-0.09707807,
-0.4283308089,
0.4130392969,
-0.3653104305,
-0.0852941647,
0.0085207997,
-0.5424526334,
-0.0721973106,
-0.4441591799,
-0.1685367823,
0.5758708715,
0.4624787867,
-0.4522453547,
0.5394784212,
-0.2673118412,
0.7587544918,
0.8710669279,
0.0499321334,
0.5153748989,
-0.0377474129,
0.553070724,
-0.1521446556,
-0.0222692098,
0.1293907166,
-0.6896729469,
-0.4428761899,
0.1521214545,
0.6672157645,
0.6692125797,
-1.2735916376,
0.1857108474,
-0.3389834166,
-0.219235003,
-0.6355192661,
0.2783400416,
0.4157485664,
0.4635037184,
0.543319881,
-0.3822545409,
-0.4077585936,
-0.7423993945,
-0.4653715789,
0.1423834413,
-0.0349154808,
-0.2272146344,
0.275113821,
-0.5241985917,
0.562012732,
-0.1966284364,
-0.2195141464,
-0.0189467184,
0.0864920095,
0.1725070179,
0.5890801549,
0.3978144825,
-0.4663259685,
-0.5171687603,
0.3833967149,
-0.851967752,
-0.1699301004,
-0.203416571,
-0.4633075595,
0.1915529072,
0.1994240135,
-1.0295126438,
0.2017180175,
0.6951532364,
-0.2090223283,
0.66634202,
-0.5840958357,
0.6272701025,
-1.0117410421,
-0.0815411434,
-0.2496152222,
-0.3698008657,
-0.6321319938,
-0.0471560955,
0.3332517445,
0.0403383076,
-0.1733933687,
0.0884972215,
-0.4474737048,
-0.414958626,
-0.2624377608,
0.1316993535,
0.1297455579,
0.3699069917,
0.0504201651,
0.906167686,
0.0176302474,
-0.1461116523,
0.2939746976,
0.4526299834,
0.056276869,
0.2801029086,
-0.6953452826,
0.5371319652,
0.3260605335,
0.2668601573,
-0.5909179449,
-0.2551192641,
0.4829446673,
-0.5223036408,
0.3822923005,
-0.1447316855,
-0.8326544762,
-0.1282622069,
-0.1622523963,
0.201618433,
0.2342895865,
-0.3133208454,
0.3285171688,
0.0874771774,
-0.4027712941,
-0.311447084,
-0.8791206479,
0.7549886107,
0.1032347083,
-0.6061410904,
0.5977215767,
0.0164309386,
0.0399015434,
0.1211189404,
-0.0854405388,
-0.1653354615,
-0.118580386,
-0.0685979798,
0.3868296444,
-0.1343463659,
-0.2619843185,
0.3578160703,
-0.4631009102,
-0.0194426458,
-0.4588228464,
0.2954045534,
-0.2994344831,
-0.1190050468,
-0.6777058244,
0.1891292632,
0.5880297422,
-0.6296509504,
0.2191807926,
0.7121809721,
-0.4091089666,
0.2145538032,
-0.4813814163,
-0.2817795575,
-0.480432272,
0.4426300526,
-0.7682629824,
-0.9329845309,
0.3887514174,
0.1134914458,
0.2600801289,
0.5165896416,
0.4361948073,
0.1415448934,
1.0587726831,
0.1671116799,
-0.004326012,
0.3240531683,
-0.0881107226,
0.2946759462,
-0.9882709384,
0.3488159776,
-0.0983011723,
-0.3598176837,
-0.5696232319,
-0.723523438,
0.2397842407,
0.0788312033,
-0.0412246473,
0.6075431705,
-0.5330435634,
0.5079320669,
0.5179991722,
0.1318630427,
0.6393305659,
-0.3481302261,
-0.0584139042,
-0.2875071764,
-0.5044226646,
-0.5797244906,
0.9657866359,
0.3053512573,
0.2223315835,
0.0256875362,
0.5975230932,
0.0618830062,
0.5337510705,
-0.5477164984,
0.3873529434,
-0.1420049667,
-0.3800589442,
-0.2067624331,
-0.5011316538,
-0.4421359301,
0.406039089,
-0.011761345,
-0.0035244322,
-0.2982026339,
0.4589309692,
-0.4249439836,
0.4737817049,
-0.7745546699,
1.1528953314,
-0.4257120788,
-0.3300830126,
-0.1377162337,
-0.6751946807,
0.3902813494,
-0.4761868119,
0.1038512215,
0.1914142519,
-0.3218567371,
0.4525564611,
-0.2606945932,
0.3508273065,
-0.1466809958,
-0.2950690091,
-0.0044042654,
0.443784982,
0.8598827124,
0.0336228944,
-0.1090849414,
0.5890455842,
-0.1713118404,
0.0037300438,
-0.7717898488,
0.7339949012,
-0.8656222224,
-0.6032919288,
-0.3510093093,
-0.6196956635,
-0.1696688086,
0.4871013761,
0.3944218755,
0.3034734726,
0.0002932619,
-0.1602226496,
0.3495593667,
-0.4094629288,
0.3467651904,
0.3291819096,
-0.2629887462,
-0.6506807804,
0.8823552132,
0.507312417,
0.431710124,
0.0381600857,
0.1738467515,
-0.2344075292,
-1.0954793692,
-0.8903387785,
0.2970640957,
-0.6224689484,
-0.1908496916,
-0.8424181938,
-0.1470004171,
-0.2810721397,
-0.360840857,
-0.3757822216,
-0.426512897,
0.0817618221,
-0.4864119291,
0.3367605805,
1.0177422762,
-0.2458029687,
0.3051579297,
-1.0539761782,
0.5613585114,
0.1827602088,
0.4993789792,
-0.554831326,
-0.5660310984,
-0.3236796856,
-0.0096462527,
-0.304000169,
-0.9954833984,
0.4887007475,
0.0525972247,
0.2942980528,
-0.149985224,
-0.4295053482,
0.6564232111,
-1.0452392101,
0.8120604157,
-0.0245128851,
-1.2158145905,
0.3376965821,
-0.8931968212,
0.4541895688,
0.4453059137,
0.1883467436,
-0.7459381819,
-0.4759929776,
-0.3079336584,
-0.5463122129,
0.568476975,
0.422582984,
-0.0527029335,
0.0314534977,
0.5194866061,
-0.004369318,
0.4111915529,
-0.7658357024,
0.1139756069,
-0.5548251867,
-0.0771593601,
-0.1955634356,
-0.162749961,
0.1369239241,
-0.4069030881,
0.7993589044,
0.0760643333,
0.2146599442,
0.3385745883,
-0.2887903154,
-0.1611157656,
0.0927452892,
0.6186023355,
0.542130053,
-0.1986577064,
0.1461125463,
0.4623409212,
-0.5467651486,
0.1661302745,
0.1526035666,
-0.1895542145,
0.109541811,
0.2008378655,
0.6984114647,
0.3052292168,
0.0442567281,
0.4577054977,
-0.2146130502,
-0.4142235816,
0.0539831892,
-0.2837176025,
0.1520355493,
-0.0201764386,
-0.1361692101,
0.6041531563,
0.2441570014,
-0.1090759411,
0.3205015957,
0.1352234483,
-0.2295485139,
-0.8252920508,
0.8441165686,
0.3639913797,
-0.3302889764,
0.3642731309,
-0.336564362,
-0.8930462003,
0.034748029,
0.3230276108,
1.0125627518,
-0.57432127,
-0.1457483023,
0.3481950164,
0.777575016,
-0.2021147609,
-0.0143120373,
0.2723732293,
-0.7395007014,
-0.9294666648,
-0.4103781581,
-0.4169253707,
0.1035727188,
-0.3413697183,
0.2186876237,
-0.4691332281,
-0.267062068,
-0.4113427401,
-0.2592365146,
-0.7785248756,
0.1128060967,
-0.1475440562,
0.4037854373,
-0.4926696122,
1.2021410465,
0.6657375097,
-0.3289985061,
-0.8632727861,
-0.0859717503,
0.2032207251,
-0.4852944016,
0.4267078638,
0.1370289475,
-0.2634147108,
0.4056732953,
0.0019399134,
-0.8134222627,
0.998072207,
0.4814796448,
-0.6523944736,
-0.1993250251,
0.196395427,
0.5575476885,
0.189527303,
0.0534948818,
0.8489108086,
0.6727552414,
-0.1824613661,
-1.0982798338,
0.2160595953,
-0.2604222,
-0.0123215094,
0.2770863771,
-0.3018899858,
0.7844009399,
0.1766799688,
0.1356948614,
-0.1194015816,
0.39396891,
-0.1788190603,
-0.2994466722,
0.4619521201,
0.6266892552,
0.6358418465,
-0.1468624622,
1.0187349319,
-0.3065835834,
0.0614785813,
1.274454236,
-0.1923687309,
0.6992435455,
0.2808349133,
0.0282320678,
0.0112033309,
0.80150491,
0.1518787742,
0.4230749905,
-0.0176212043,
-0.273378998,
-0.034100391,
0.5036341548,
-0.570417881,
0.2363730669,
0.3518488109,
-0.4234501123,
0.0467693247,
-0.029133644,
0.4560473859,
-0.1648762673,
-0.2016299963,
0.802067697,
0.1616814137,
-0.7550990582,
0.4757505357,
0.2379700094,
0.7491538525,
-0.405156523,
-0.1527583748,
-0.1718312502,
0.1275018454,
-0.2657927275,
-0.9257878661,
0.6655187607,
0.358160615,
-0.0636290759,
-0.745629251,
0.6723529696,
-0.5616030097,
-0.2442072183,
0.4578543007,
0.533405304,
0.142014876,
-0.566260457,
-0.6412459612,
0.2289739847,
0.053955812,
-0.478707552,
0.2449286133,
0.7434067726,
0.1225973293,
-0.0125818588,
0.7340124249,
0.3835303485,
0.0090299072,
0.0831506252,
0.7326050997,
-0.6875715852,
-0.317900449,
-0.9984177947,
0.4602563977,
-0.0358201452,
-0.3510770202,
0.8432059288,
0.4602622688,
0.8627960086,
0.0262914412,
1.1104305983,
0.2545073926,
0.1583908051,
-0.5159959197,
0.8981373906,
-0.1921504587,
0.0018578417,
-0.5815870762,
-1.2249596119,
-0.7265182137,
0.6568636298,
-0.6284937263,
-0.2180550247,
0.9054033756,
0.8115532994,
0.1002402753,
-0.1057320088,
0.5344008207,
0.437574625,
0.5494021177,
0.4538185,
0.6630240083,
-0.6098335981,
0.5636606216,
-0.1036126763,
-0.1658778191,
0.2429007888,
-0.791366756,
-0.7987225056,
-0.3077999353,
-0.1996408701,
-0.3807028532,
0.1516796499,
0.9603686333,
0.345959723,
-0.5183027983,
0.1612593085,
-0.2089101076,
-0.1481381804,
-0.2363537401,
-0.0679923519,
0.4036112428,
-0.2962135375,
-0.7809373736,
0.6212758422,
0.4719226062,
0.1158324853,
0.0793311968,
-0.3232688606,
-0.0168400183,
-0.2544682622,
0.7483139634,
-0.260194093,
-0.7798320651,
-0.49140504,
-0.000672975,
-0.2120666057,
0.2046525925,
0.6163867712,
-0.1986233145,
0.5675523877,
0.4495615363,
1.0371435881,
0.4743895829,
0.0571074709,
1.1027270555,
-0.4630224109,
-0.1183974072,
0.2056384683,
0.4754955769,
0.7054057121,
-0.4528861642,
0.5257067084,
0.4454908967,
-0.9339319468,
-0.435644865,
-0.0780686662,
-0.6666369438,
0.1679466963,
1.2340883017,
-0.3538039625,
0.1130695045,
-0.059659481,
-0.5861693025,
0.611336112,
-0.2211275846,
0.4889644086,
0.9831882715,
0.1378672272,
-0.2621012628,
-1.055395484,
0.7635377049,
0.2927962244,
-0.9433776736,
-0.1299220473,
0.7259613872,
0.3042404652,
-0.2876086533,
0.6803868413,
-0.3812159002,
0.4691520035,
-0.2617622316,
0.2555180788,
-0.2905467451,
-0.0723736435,
-0.496925354,
-0.2348414809,
0.2578263581,
-0.1080601886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14877v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14877v2 | Improving Probability-based Prompt Selection Through Unified Evaluation and Analysis | 2023-05-24T08:29:50 | 2024-03-08T18:51:03 | Sohee Yang, Jonghyeon Kim, Joel Jang, Seonghyeon Ye, Hyunji Lee, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous works in prompt engineering for large language models have
introduced different gradient-free probability-based prompt selection methods
that aim to choose the optimal prompt among the candidates for a given task but
have failed to provide a comprehensive and fair comparison between each other.
In this paper, we propose a unified framework to interpret and evaluate the
existing probability-based prompt selection methods by performing extensive
experiments on 13 common and diverse NLP tasks. We find that each of the
existing methods can be interpreted as some variant of the method that
maximizes mutual information between the input and the predicted output (MI).
Utilizing this finding, we develop several other combinatorial variants of MI
and increase the effectiveness of the oracle prompt selection method from
87.79% to 94.98%, measured as the ratio of the performance of the selected
prompt to that of the optimal oracle prompt. Furthermore, considering that all
the methods rely on the output probability distribution of the model that might
be biased, we propose a novel calibration method called Calibration by
Marginalization (CBM) that is orthogonal to the existing methods and helps
increase the prompt selection effectiveness of the best method to 96.85%,
achieving 99.44% of the oracle prompt F1 without calibration. | [
-0.4520051181,
-0.5338387489,
0.6923992634,
0.7925843,
-0.2368823588,
-0.2869033515,
-0.3654882312,
-0.0221403297,
0.0807110593,
0.2702327371,
-0.7481098771,
-0.5185298324,
-0.1993063539,
0.4253562689,
0.1978403628,
0.8712859154,
0.3230427802,
0.3810404539,
-0.3305919468,
-0.0066706268,
-0.9716412425,
-0.246836707,
-0.81204772,
-0.3733616173,
0.4964824617,
0.2376971543,
0.3723929226,
0.211950779,
0.5312351584,
0.2475186437,
-0.3264679313,
-0.0515156724,
0.0080328956,
0.1275005788,
-0.2460551113,
-0.378665626,
-0.04053469,
-0.0555899926,
0.5645111203,
0.9400296211,
-0.0803400651,
0.1559201777,
0.3249870837,
0.6182197332,
-0.8410099149,
0.3173217177,
-0.4189948142,
0.1772352755,
0.0821413398,
-0.4179655612,
-0.8044373989,
-0.5939723253,
0.0585418493,
-0.6518978477,
0.0291239526,
0.1264095306,
0.1546824574,
0.3548808992,
-0.4991113245,
-0.143327713,
-0.6134147048,
1.0447883606,
-0.5300752521,
0.1218405887,
0.1210554019,
0.5466886163,
-0.3256948888,
-0.3978981674,
-0.1168098599,
-0.5286149383,
0.1770638824,
0.2454509884,
-0.1669747829,
0.3871980309,
0.3829624057,
0.0463915505,
-0.6273913383,
0.1642146409,
0.0972961336,
-0.4880087376,
0.5711450577,
0.0364503786,
0.465909481,
-0.2818874121,
-0.3294708133,
-0.3773686886,
-0.5447323918,
0.4888622463,
0.4303860962,
0.4706885219,
0.4101181328,
0.4058652818,
-0.2771276236,
1.1027544737,
0.0448144488,
-0.0380723029,
0.103591837,
-0.3344002962,
-0.1568303108,
-0.0829654261,
0.8565043807,
0.5738594532,
-0.0285999049,
-0.0702331141,
-0.2234340459,
-0.0066048484,
-0.056606587,
-0.653172493,
0.0405829586,
0.264921248,
-0.4722861052,
-0.2099207789,
0.0573517047,
-0.985732615,
-0.5088715553,
-0.4109426737,
0.2705611289,
-0.3605714142,
0.0525226295,
0.1087787971,
-0.3691142201,
-0.0913496092,
0.4314459264,
-0.7781758308,
-0.0142534068,
0.588675499,
0.4823662639,
-0.2045784742,
-0.1508507133,
-1.1651471853,
-0.3670521975,
-0.3213392496,
0.9419993162,
-0.613512814,
-0.3733818233,
0.1655390114,
-0.333586365,
-0.1288176179,
-0.4033274055,
1.1408168077,
-0.3827679157,
0.34507671,
-0.6766203642,
-0.3376326263,
-0.1635572016,
-0.2020294368,
-0.6977951527,
0.8744748831,
-0.1791272014,
-0.6683120728,
0.7299428582,
-0.609433651,
-0.0690237433,
0.1596524119,
-0.1575849354,
0.0187703483,
0.1021005586,
0.5827772021,
0.3376216888,
-0.4511367679,
0.7039438486,
-0.3996691704,
-0.4971852601,
0.2040403485,
-0.5083889961,
1.3036452532,
0.1125989109,
-0.265604496,
0.2395268828,
-0.8391916156,
0.002510461,
-0.3860983551,
-0.2217385024,
-0.2880510688,
-0.1106477901,
-0.062820673,
0.118980512,
0.2506537437,
-0.7630633712,
0.1307302266,
-0.4276710749,
-0.2057098448,
0.9509814978,
0.0728737041,
0.7496873736,
-0.4579021633,
0.7864382267,
-0.2902860045,
0.4179982841,
-0.1418093741,
-0.721673429,
-0.3384789228,
-0.3203031123,
0.357296437,
0.8030025959,
-0.8199603558,
0.8284141421,
0.1198186576,
-0.3880279064,
-0.2296722978,
-0.0155631872,
0.2424677014,
0.7141735554,
0.2108414024,
-0.2411545962,
-0.4845462441,
-0.7071843743,
-0.53183496,
-0.3708229065,
-0.3179579973,
0.1908027679,
-0.1176064238,
0.1229787469,
1.3504351377,
-0.33656919,
-0.1974004954,
-0.3074902892,
0.2543147206,
0.8308624029,
0.3236657679,
0.7179272771,
-0.4527771473,
-0.4577823579,
-0.1912313849,
-0.5760275126,
-0.7818830013,
-0.4184177816,
-0.0831556097,
-0.1244067326,
0.2853611112,
-0.4291883111,
0.4594736397,
0.1554846168,
-0.4440142214,
0.7396119833,
-0.2362003326,
0.2784236968,
-0.7381716371,
0.1719286889,
0.3151043952,
0.0434950627,
-0.3362287581,
0.0670184493,
0.1368452013,
-0.0655892491,
-0.3363279104,
0.8726226091,
-0.4914246798,
0.1060003862,
-0.2221733332,
0.0427836552,
-0.2184791118,
0.3631111383,
-0.2432551235,
0.7522667646,
0.6371042132,
-0.6176655889,
0.6149625182,
0.2495342344,
-0.3632678986,
0.6108077168,
-0.7529503703,
-0.1138478667,
-0.4028608799,
0.4316341877,
-1.1459259987,
-0.0264009722,
0.1296117753,
-0.3978378773,
0.065224871,
0.0669100434,
-0.3999094069,
-0.4692978263,
-0.5476127267,
0.138231948,
0.6209256053,
-0.6688142419,
0.6551961899,
-0.0547152758,
-0.5147989392,
-0.974881351,
-0.3424105346,
-0.1323500276,
-0.1495504975,
-0.6554321647,
0.1549541056,
-0.4733836949,
-0.1890184879,
-0.4078285098,
-0.2591772974,
-0.0246330015,
0.1446421146,
0.3302715719,
0.5107953548,
-0.0010130269,
0.094682008,
0.6608608365,
-0.3423057497,
0.1866125315,
-0.1053211838,
0.4590001702,
0.2600720525,
-0.4610678554,
-0.5826646686,
0.3443526626,
-0.0509636924,
-0.1583499908,
0.4956154525,
0.6242882013,
-0.0639337748,
-0.4198499322,
-0.6242643595,
-0.2949907184,
-0.5026363134,
0.1910214424,
-0.2900165617,
-0.6521885991,
0.5096096992,
-0.1324079335,
0.2929776013,
0.3860649168,
0.1770786047,
0.1724611074,
1.0271878242,
0.6235272884,
-0.0500240065,
0.6733626127,
0.2631760836,
0.1714045554,
-0.6641122699,
-0.1897320151,
-0.9202629924,
-0.1160575747,
-0.1446699202,
-0.1295953542,
0.4880047441,
0.3181472719,
-0.1006067693,
0.1985262483,
-0.6707473397,
0.5495293736,
0.983558476,
0.1311778277,
0.2775780261,
0.1205728501,
-0.636280179,
-0.2806249857,
-0.5352339745,
-0.5220517516,
1.1935036182,
-0.0899991244,
0.4989806116,
-0.1877062768,
0.6420465708,
0.4099253118,
0.2370830625,
-0.3522494137,
0.7862278223,
-0.0202108864,
-0.4845969677,
-0.5015857816,
-0.5757875443,
-0.9775155187,
0.2103429288,
-0.1905317605,
-1.0969356298,
0.3066104054,
-0.0347891673,
-0.7385022044,
0.0200685393,
-0.5844607949,
0.7584269047,
0.1888112426,
-0.0152533008,
0.0333165452,
-0.4818052948,
0.1900024414,
-0.1814742833,
0.1030383632,
-0.0974879935,
-0.0037618626,
0.7116299868,
-0.2096168399,
0.7201850414,
-0.4399930537,
0.0426164828,
0.3703290224,
-0.0566363893,
0.3373070061,
0.3308165073,
-0.5413928628,
-0.0874798819,
-0.0193711054,
-0.2837235928,
-0.772580862,
0.4974957108,
-0.5046300888,
-0.5277501345,
-0.4638234079,
-0.5457610488,
-0.4068768024,
0.008975652,
0.3374808729,
0.5486836433,
-0.4120790958,
0.1353967488,
0.3501065969,
-0.6492254138,
0.8751360178,
0.3984653056,
-0.2604676187,
-0.475938797,
0.6699108481,
-0.3102820516,
-0.0636321977,
0.6094318628,
0.2436720431,
-0.515281558,
-0.2935326993,
-0.4381888509,
0.0602944456,
-0.7820239067,
-0.3892500699,
-0.6733199954,
0.0915487185,
-0.5040875077,
-0.1625967324,
0.0983370915,
-0.5373677015,
-0.2938497961,
-0.0169555862,
0.0051613352,
0.3359403908,
-0.389282167,
0.3979746103,
-0.644266963,
0.053848587,
0.4186570346,
0.0808036402,
-0.1482190192,
-0.4175972342,
0.4805573523,
-0.0193085503,
-0.3392188251,
-1.053910017,
0.2292795479,
0.0450757593,
0.7634741068,
0.2865415215,
0.3526039124,
0.1622243077,
-0.3931408823,
0.776444912,
0.5121834278,
-0.9899104238,
0.7250184417,
-0.2555581629,
0.3147095442,
0.732691586,
0.0137067717,
-0.5152407885,
-0.2021636665,
-0.433327049,
-0.7661713362,
0.6513035893,
0.1385669708,
0.0302540585,
0.1254271865,
0.1205317751,
0.4213114381,
0.1137641072,
-0.7082437277,
-0.4154250622,
0.3593401313,
-0.2688959837,
-0.069494918,
-0.1293940097,
0.0791313201,
-0.0529306903,
0.7246779799,
-0.1844592839,
0.3064502776,
0.0802177489,
-0.0086642038,
-0.0891140327,
0.513323009,
0.2429277599,
0.8418896794,
-0.3500925004,
-0.367865622,
0.1478893906,
-0.3543891907,
0.1485252529,
0.487711966,
-0.5849637389,
0.4388959706,
0.305848062,
0.7967548966,
-0.0065778922,
-0.5567011237,
0.9098237157,
-0.2958448827,
0.2148957103,
-0.003555327,
0.3674209714,
-0.3948088586,
0.1247515082,
0.7360239625,
0.2772186399,
0.4253055751,
-0.1632912606,
0.2981801331,
0.5454311967,
-0.4260018468,
-0.1238548681,
0.6145766973,
0.3948231936,
-0.3809823096,
0.4261289239,
-0.4999788702,
-0.1146736443,
0.7621212602,
0.4104685187,
0.9100186825,
-0.4963139296,
0.7583522201,
0.538936317,
0.3959154189,
0.0180822164,
0.4238525033,
-0.0341705382,
-0.4221605659,
-0.9099298716,
-0.6878857017,
-0.5008419156,
-0.1206323653,
-0.7661883235,
0.3786681592,
-0.2607006133,
-0.2753061056,
-0.0605256632,
0.0260547623,
-0.7621299624,
0.203106463,
-0.1554118991,
1.0446828604,
-1.0421276093,
0.2452858537,
0.8883040547,
-0.3429341912,
-0.7955135703,
-0.1636756659,
-0.1303136051,
-0.5443502665,
0.5366200209,
0.199624449,
0.5225067735,
-0.2302228957,
-0.4787504375,
-0.7313719392,
0.9505850673,
0.7618071437,
-0.5049970746,
-0.0178280901,
0.0436321795,
0.3205181062,
-0.2962695956,
0.9290193319,
0.3523038626,
0.4800775945,
0.0807791874,
-1.0879673958,
0.008791416,
-0.1544775665,
0.2793313563,
0.0623993538,
-0.2713648975,
0.5847575665,
-0.0479395464,
-0.1798851043,
0.3152335286,
0.7644852996,
0.6368607879,
0.6204449534,
0.7068759799,
0.048719734,
0.972918272,
-0.1411814839,
1.0611177683,
-0.1892454773,
0.3202214241,
0.9322568774,
-0.2883782983,
0.4819737673,
0.5765626431,
-0.2765493095,
0.3886485398,
0.6481075883,
0.2440008074,
0.5935047269,
0.3178026974,
-0.4485451579,
-0.3415848911,
-0.436059922,
-0.361374259,
-0.027410062,
-0.118877843,
-0.0903933644,
-0.4352092445,
0.1974395663,
-0.300116539,
-0.01971706,
-0.2920441031,
0.5943780541,
0.1047491953,
-0.9570595622,
0.1144014671,
-0.0781364515,
0.6966981292,
-0.3775064349,
0.0447459072,
-0.3879490197,
-0.0383452922,
0.0134745603,
-0.6225768328,
-0.1513957679,
-0.1716850698,
0.0177776664,
-0.2372735292,
0.8089091778,
-0.0806080028,
-0.4771234393,
0.2855788469,
0.5118921995,
-0.023417633,
-0.4457863271,
-0.6020585895,
-0.0285784509,
0.2630541027,
-0.1261920929,
0.106615372,
0.4969032109,
0.1562935114,
0.47076267,
0.742495358,
0.1602029204,
0.0336631574,
0.1729770303,
0.6144039035,
-0.5371396542,
-0.6459742188,
-0.6961384416,
0.7846541405,
-0.4414360821,
-0.596304059,
0.5184230804,
0.2886944413,
0.4044618905,
-0.162223205,
0.6852260828,
0.0841714367,
0.4480528831,
-0.3862919807,
0.2605257332,
-0.1907272935,
0.3354203105,
-0.6494363546,
-1.4457868338,
-0.4495829046,
0.5777257085,
-0.3162153661,
0.0550506674,
0.9029380679,
0.6073727012,
0.0585244261,
0.3685714602,
0.2863537073,
-0.2784264386,
0.1577917188,
0.6102921367,
0.8550345302,
-0.2190047354,
0.4768233895,
-0.415194422,
-0.7971714735,
-0.145301953,
-1.1009175777,
-1.0707024336,
-0.6076056361,
-0.3361522853,
-0.2280170619,
0.0790884122,
1.0283030272,
0.4970819056,
-0.7421099544,
-0.1722735614,
-0.0650862902,
0.156015873,
-0.2641167641,
-0.1980798692,
0.2751039863,
-0.6058785319,
-0.6894375086,
0.5395094156,
0.3805630505,
-0.3344166577,
0.1697353423,
0.1331177801,
0.1875125915,
0.0733732358,
0.3885127306,
0.185016796,
-0.577542603,
-0.0890451521,
0.1626616865,
-0.0364971124,
-0.1555789858,
0.6677364111,
-0.6455205679,
0.3755672872,
0.6956580281,
0.8913558125,
-0.1284442246,
0.0431556627,
0.8127471805,
-0.7592030764,
0.2112902403,
0.3984912336,
0.5131762624,
0.1650794595,
-0.3555059433,
0.5379400849,
0.0628003925,
-0.7394411564,
-0.7651025057,
0.1860559881,
-1.1668858528,
-0.2869871557,
1.301219821,
-0.0518863648,
-0.1571136862,
0.0639761537,
-0.6087939143,
0.2760545909,
-0.8279710412,
0.651307106,
0.7202451825,
-0.0045891078,
0.1543831527,
-0.3593534529,
0.4121368229,
0.9109705091,
-0.7541586757,
-0.3114626706,
0.729385674,
-0.0678107068,
0.1911225617,
0.624643743,
0.2387916297,
0.5218220353,
-0.3349688351,
0.1504109204,
0.2220781744,
-0.2549917996,
-0.7290152907,
0.2428362072,
-0.0779117793,
-0.0135084102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14874v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14874v2 | From Words to Wires: Generating Functioning Electronic Devices from Natural Language Descriptions | 2023-05-24T08:28:59 | 2023-10-13T23:47:33 | Peter Jansen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we show that contemporary language models have a previously
unknown skill -- the capacity for electronic circuit design from high-level
textual descriptions, akin to code generation. We introduce two benchmarks:
Pins100, assessing model knowledge of electrical components, and Micro25,
evaluating a model's capability to design common microcontroller circuits and
code in the Arduino ecosystem that involve input, output, sensors, motors,
protocols, and logic -- with models such as GPT-4 and Claude-V1 achieving
between 60% to 96% Pass@1 on generating full devices. We include six case
studies of using language models as a design assistant for moderately complex
devices, such as a radiation-powered random number generator, an emoji
keyboard, a visible spectrometer, and several assistive devices, while offering
a qualitative analysis performance, outlining evaluation challenges, and
suggesting areas of development to improve complex circuit design and practical
utility. With this work, we aim to spur research at the juncture of natural
language processing and electronic design. | [
-0.668438971,
-0.9652739167,
0.9156984687,
-0.1143773049,
0.0152748292,
0.2367112041,
-0.0611088127,
-0.6202682853,
0.087289162,
0.3365289569,
-0.4271645844,
-0.1420732737,
-0.2395448685,
0.0929946899,
-0.6472892761,
0.6626573801,
-0.1484488398,
-0.4140497446,
0.0453941002,
0.4437121451,
-0.3138824701,
-0.1584204137,
-0.3648294508,
-0.2962858081,
0.541783452,
0.3593626916,
0.3728652894,
0.2389846295,
0.3969361484,
0.2694388926,
0.0584253632,
0.216678977,
0.2678587139,
-0.1643600315,
-0.0190324001,
-0.0458348282,
-0.705878973,
0.2104922831,
0.2085701078,
0.7898881435,
0.015655553,
0.4393800497,
-0.0359657966,
0.4367904961,
-0.258676827,
0.0815206468,
-0.7637838125,
-0.0721605346,
-0.1230410859,
-0.2340649962,
-0.6564381123,
-0.2853552401,
-0.0303985085,
-0.62577492,
0.2522512376,
0.3005503416,
1.0974657536,
-0.414786756,
-0.3280400336,
-0.7741733789,
-0.9942311645,
0.4890982211,
-0.67014575,
0.4511078,
0.2905950546,
0.3117622137,
0.0496236794,
-0.9793747067,
-0.7541155815,
-0.4187045395,
0.1291501969,
-0.1045211107,
-0.347370863,
0.2863336504,
0.5974578857,
0.4437150657,
-0.3137536943,
-0.2661817372,
-0.746421814,
0.0425400659,
0.5954326391,
-0.051869195,
0.7869184613,
-0.2800633609,
-0.0337443836,
0.1570692658,
-0.8832364678,
0.1068565622,
0.7441134453,
0.3633825779,
-0.1950789541,
0.7357088923,
-0.3270092607,
0.9501758218,
-0.0681647658,
0.0509795174,
-0.0712539628,
-0.4787613153,
-0.3117619157,
-0.0631563738,
0.6506816745,
0.1161606088,
0.5575458407,
-0.3432253599,
-0.355830282,
-0.0525739528,
0.6008007526,
-0.6820261478,
-0.7028715611,
0.049486082,
-0.4967090786,
-0.2988327146,
0.2424017489,
-0.6190615296,
-0.2500266731,
-0.5201562643,
0.4517855346,
-0.1197512001,
-0.2128205299,
0.2102317363,
-0.3768773377,
-0.1378667802,
-0.1689926237,
-1.182115078,
0.6759418845,
0.5852447748,
0.7431904078,
0.4223021269,
-0.0057743369,
-0.2383097261,
0.0726785958,
-0.285556525,
0.8690511584,
-0.3450064361,
-0.3857847154,
-0.0711674094,
-0.0616186894,
0.0074987989,
-0.2302845865,
0.5145725012,
-0.310554117,
-0.087673761,
-0.1752313524,
-0.3436502218,
0.1674520671,
-0.194487527,
-0.7514286637,
0.584867537,
-0.1363838911,
-0.7337351441,
0.1613716185,
-0.598033905,
-0.9201295376,
0.0356374979,
-0.3252703249,
-0.2011137307,
0.3912039697,
-0.127717495,
0.4678441286,
-0.5899245739,
0.2612455487,
-0.1402100921,
-0.2331071943,
0.3421338797,
-0.4321933687,
0.6427569985,
0.2722944915,
-0.3307522833,
0.0358365327,
-1.0478310585,
-0.0492532365,
0.0353463218,
-0.2784581482,
-0.1686166227,
0.3950727284,
0.1859225631,
0.303042829,
0.158035472,
-0.9527506232,
-0.067015551,
-0.6175392866,
0.9184277058,
0.502790451,
-0.1736046374,
0.4071932435,
-0.4008921981,
0.5498774052,
-0.6393976808,
0.0351690985,
-0.4902278781,
-0.6933546662,
-0.9552334547,
0.1880954355,
0.158614412,
0.2490502298,
-0.8662624955,
0.7123137116,
-0.1153548062,
-0.7207832336,
-0.4135436714,
0.1266487837,
0.2077164054,
0.6663478613,
0.2317662388,
-0.0353427045,
-0.3669325113,
-1.0930449963,
-0.2909311056,
-0.3947413564,
-0.5060860515,
0.2088243663,
0.2266446799,
0.013931768,
0.6258283257,
-0.5008862019,
0.1140456051,
-0.4016115367,
0.457015276,
0.0700146109,
0.3635136783,
0.2303982377,
-0.4950416088,
-0.0388035439,
0.5330556035,
-0.5966074467,
-0.2245390713,
-0.3299945295,
0.033994507,
-0.0658122078,
0.4827227294,
-0.7809811234,
0.3473674655,
0.3018608689,
-0.2776558399,
0.4028197229,
-0.3057664037,
0.1992436051,
-1.0431917906,
0.2010020912,
0.2063462436,
0.1587380916,
-0.6650300622,
0.1120167673,
0.3180966973,
-0.3885630369,
-0.3231926858,
0.7574856281,
-0.551353991,
0.1059035137,
-0.228092283,
0.1764480621,
0.1704942733,
0.2096523196,
-0.2249811441,
0.6482239366,
0.2745037675,
-0.6302879453,
0.3317568898,
-0.1881481409,
-0.5265899301,
0.2775318027,
-0.9811903834,
0.0672456473,
0.2884723544,
-0.4349918664,
-0.8625876307,
-0.5376682281,
-0.261916846,
-0.4056310952,
0.1785259396,
0.1140227839,
-0.7933140397,
-0.8292407393,
-0.0555512756,
0.340135783,
0.6311535239,
-0.3918676078,
0.634247005,
0.5845961571,
-0.5536369085,
0.5036460161,
-0.7680698037,
0.0115987146,
0.1687579304,
-0.7595388293,
0.3705676794,
-0.1505750418,
-0.4310173094,
-0.2554686368,
0.0537033565,
-0.1408231705,
0.2297401726,
0.2195360959,
0.2889855504,
-0.0834732726,
0.5879130363,
0.2700941563,
-0.0500425212,
0.2929156125,
-0.0688135996,
0.5477178097,
-0.1429130435,
-0.6171429753,
-0.4582367241,
0.4073821902,
0.3472829461,
-0.4118235707,
-0.0249113087,
0.1083304584,
-0.6484497786,
-0.4135541618,
-0.3071217239,
-0.0411591269,
-0.5661416054,
0.2521766722,
-0.6921602488,
-0.6842520237,
0.3424965441,
0.0133782644,
0.05347424,
0.4305222034,
0.3462994695,
-0.3096452951,
1.1687476635,
0.8203600049,
0.3117291033,
0.4636602104,
0.1873126179,
0.8447133899,
-0.7732844949,
-0.0811848789,
-0.5372182727,
-0.1775951982,
-0.5563772917,
0.031044988,
0.1229107976,
-0.129562363,
-0.3409753442,
0.5189071894,
-0.7208530903,
0.3948220611,
0.5514034033,
0.1327767819,
0.2233554572,
0.2362306416,
-0.222015202,
0.12009193,
-0.6298689842,
-0.9705913067,
1.1507258415,
0.5046265721,
0.9145135283,
-0.2179421186,
0.5910638571,
0.1888623089,
0.2376718074,
-0.622179389,
0.3948686421,
0.0209813341,
-0.5530343056,
0.0561278984,
-0.318567723,
-0.7658591866,
-0.471080184,
0.0383308753,
-0.7054246068,
-0.0560357086,
0.0488647446,
-0.519430995,
0.3512901366,
-0.9855440259,
0.6836186051,
-0.3629986346,
-0.1772767901,
0.0921982303,
-0.177175492,
0.5878199339,
0.0952910483,
0.5078268647,
0.0231362786,
0.2624918818,
0.6961690187,
-0.20750539,
0.5817471147,
0.2554410696,
-0.329873383,
0.53582865,
0.1162753254,
0.0832172558,
-0.0240165535,
-0.0754222572,
-0.3682864606,
-0.0066303723,
-0.30155316,
-0.2609551847,
0.7533849478,
-0.334109962,
-0.4052055478,
0.1203684136,
-0.3471903205,
-0.2083001733,
0.3911803663,
0.2999391854,
0.7525476217,
-0.3750610054,
-0.0316846259,
0.8096902966,
-0.4628314972,
0.5009701848,
-0.0568987802,
-0.2748648524,
-0.2423920482,
1.0618350506,
0.1315632313,
0.45295313,
0.2011935115,
-0.1300908923,
0.1518345475,
-0.1483101398,
-0.6390730739,
0.1087123454,
-0.7191408277,
-0.1206981242,
-0.7188410163,
-0.4073065519,
-0.2973039448,
-0.3977120817,
-0.3097692728,
-0.4759304523,
-0.1901265234,
-0.3189176619,
0.2306880951,
1.1480166912,
0.3689577878,
0.1750862151,
-0.6615404487,
0.8879522681,
0.6573240161,
0.5826246142,
0.289625138,
-0.0896247104,
-0.2808927894,
0.0736340657,
-0.5770836473,
-0.903453052,
0.1759584099,
0.0494049676,
0.6130099297,
0.0265637599,
-0.0744215474,
0.3764763474,
-0.6406663656,
0.7643548846,
0.2923555076,
-1.0766079426,
0.7986990213,
-0.4235216081,
0.3827987015,
0.2094392627,
-0.0721630901,
-0.4296782911,
-0.408759743,
-0.8169528246,
-0.8198402524,
0.2902554274,
0.2591119707,
0.4705603421,
-0.2351344824,
0.0070099183,
-0.080347456,
0.3187446892,
-0.679592073,
-0.0909028351,
0.0625745431,
-0.6271877885,
0.413523972,
-0.0637535751,
0.0124162054,
-0.336463064,
0.5011925101,
0.0411796831,
0.7190574408,
-0.018212758,
0.0313405767,
-0.0763285309,
0.4156749547,
0.6998791099,
0.687697053,
0.062659733,
0.5675461888,
-0.3002019823,
-0.2624375522,
0.0262936428,
0.2725476921,
-0.1381110847,
0.0820944905,
0.3152331412,
0.5102611184,
0.2603591383,
-0.7174969316,
0.2322025895,
-0.2782030702,
-0.2957254648,
0.0648594797,
0.1019225195,
0.5579352975,
0.0175412614,
0.231964469,
0.0282076802,
0.3359504342,
-0.6011018157,
0.3944689035,
0.339045167,
-0.3279250562,
-0.6355688572,
0.7713654041,
0.5332736969,
-0.6655455828,
0.3109890521,
-0.423717767,
-0.191813767,
0.8369413018,
0.4381745756,
1.0516375303,
0.2021110803,
0.1588198245,
0.4012984335,
0.7559621334,
0.047470998,
0.5746533871,
-0.3329278231,
-0.323441565,
-0.0539831184,
-0.6841682792,
-0.1408423334,
-0.1432439238,
-0.4240388572,
0.5000548363,
-0.6680749059,
-0.1295098662,
0.2004065067,
-0.0892882273,
-0.8014127016,
0.2201047093,
0.1575250477,
1.0617823601,
-0.9718960524,
0.8870995045,
0.6673099995,
-0.7197653055,
-0.8824298978,
-0.2013714761,
-0.4517662525,
-0.1956559271,
0.5119381547,
0.0658282414,
-0.0426854119,
0.1151441857,
-0.2946516871,
-0.4612140059,
1.0550675392,
0.0658435076,
-0.5494701862,
-0.1172658131,
0.0817898884,
0.5662033558,
-0.3264501691,
0.2627018988,
0.4907477498,
0.3867080808,
-0.3570121527,
-1.038074851,
-0.0214691907,
-0.7572714686,
-0.0337552913,
0.2624746263,
-0.2683733702,
1.0166523457,
0.0537558049,
-0.3978732824,
0.5097683668,
0.3732073605,
0.4560817182,
0.3558053672,
-0.1263964921,
0.1207630709,
0.723040998,
-0.074154079,
1.1229822636,
-0.4529913068,
0.104373239,
0.9504545927,
-0.0210804138,
0.8347190619,
0.6292891502,
-0.0840248168,
0.3743423522,
0.303866148,
0.1427557766,
0.3413425982,
0.406951189,
-0.3780469298,
-0.2332276106,
0.0297430214,
-0.2282308638,
-0.1391270012,
0.3239267468,
-0.6905914545,
-0.0615113303,
0.2577940822,
-0.3146324754,
0.3042269647,
-0.1806604415,
0.50841856,
0.3143573105,
-0.3729799092,
0.1810382605,
0.1639667004,
0.5321030021,
-0.1826584041,
-0.2831202745,
0.0206511933,
-0.0505373143,
0.0122355102,
-0.6664072275,
0.3003188372,
0.3115699291,
-0.3782242835,
-0.4802700579,
0.9955679178,
-0.0285378117,
-1.2073398829,
0.018248722,
0.367477864,
-0.0217559449,
0.1228681579,
-0.1200230718,
0.1011543721,
-0.175718531,
-0.1731983423,
-0.0445559137,
0.6576998234,
0.1186531633,
0.6120276451,
0.4091269374,
0.4108608365,
0.3326781094,
-0.0804296285,
0.7196718454,
-0.7140318751,
-0.2958158851,
-0.5494933128,
0.6387184262,
-0.132810384,
-0.4816108644,
0.48427549,
0.4678599834,
1.0473806858,
-0.1672236174,
1.1670976877,
-0.3312931657,
0.4594201744,
-0.5957144499,
0.9565306306,
-0.2635251284,
0.4732306898,
-0.2670619786,
-0.7206158042,
-0.1396300197,
0.6235736609,
-0.2186907381,
0.0236380678,
0.6568912864,
0.6624458432,
-0.45524472,
0.2457375079,
0.4036852717,
-0.1615325361,
0.6155229807,
0.5749385357,
0.8821283579,
-0.8538149595,
0.2581525743,
-0.3938533068,
-0.0254457667,
0.1771456748,
-0.6939667463,
-0.9842713475,
-0.6400691867,
-0.1104024574,
0.2362542003,
-0.254855603,
0.5561932325,
0.6118277907,
-0.5732669234,
-0.496104151,
-0.7199463844,
0.2472631782,
0.181413427,
-0.1707710028,
-0.0613586009,
-0.4338075817,
-0.4514597654,
0.2931123674,
0.2498772889,
-0.0466296189,
-0.3046052754,
-0.0142390514,
-0.1092747524,
0.3284935653,
0.8791604638,
0.2313316017,
-0.8941354156,
-0.2941308618,
0.2648229003,
-0.1223055795,
-0.2824231386,
0.8528058529,
-0.6967101097,
0.6441531777,
0.6386224031,
0.5351805091,
0.0426247045,
-0.2591237724,
0.788631022,
-0.4631527066,
-0.2024659663,
-0.1284662634,
0.4158888161,
0.2952911556,
0.0634565502,
0.0365979783,
0.0290485173,
-0.5073782802,
-0.8409282565,
0.4125363827,
-0.8368074894,
-0.2610559165,
1.1694498062,
0.084276177,
-0.3066467047,
-0.1482598186,
-0.4319202304,
0.4360967278,
-0.083064191,
0.7650215626,
0.7704838514,
-0.1930644363,
-0.1938376129,
-0.9687170386,
0.3066069782,
-0.1495992392,
-1.0666379929,
0.1967321932,
0.3157888055,
0.0241254978,
0.2954836786,
0.3951393068,
0.0083403168,
0.4030351937,
0.1740700454,
0.4915674925,
-0.1401184499,
-0.5375648737,
-0.0178822931,
0.1941669434,
0.5009781122,
0.0409415551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14871v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14871v2 | ClusterLLM: Large Language Models as a Guide for Text Clustering | 2023-05-24T08:24:25 | 2023-11-03T19:40:21 | Yuwei Zhang, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce ClusterLLM, a novel text clustering framework that leverages
feedback from an instruction-tuned large language model, such as ChatGPT.
Compared with traditional unsupervised methods that builds upon "small"
embedders, ClusterLLM exhibits two intriguing advantages: (1) it enjoys the
emergent capability of LLM even if its embeddings are inaccessible; and (2) it
understands the user's preference on clustering through textual instruction
and/or a few annotated data. First, we prompt ChatGPT for insights on
clustering perspective by constructing hard triplet questions <does A better
correspond to B than C>, where A, B and C are similar data points that belong
to different clusters according to small embedder. We empirically show that
this strategy is both effective for fine-tuning small embedder and
cost-efficient to query ChatGPT. Second, we prompt ChatGPT for helps on
clustering granularity by carefully designed pairwise questions <do A and B
belong to the same category>, and tune the granularity from cluster hierarchies
that is the most consistent with the ChatGPT answers. Extensive experiments on
14 datasets show that ClusterLLM consistently improves clustering quality, at
an average cost of ~$0.6 per dataset. The code will be available at
https://github.com/zhang-yu-wei/ClusterLLM. | [
-0.185795635,
-1.1586028337,
0.7118433118,
0.1173105165,
-0.1873398274,
0.1881141961,
-0.6230022907,
-0.2297685444,
0.0422296338,
0.4407071173,
-0.2414772213,
-0.9315809011,
-0.4043098986,
-0.3676877916,
-0.7568677664,
1.1473255157,
0.3377866745,
-0.1576912105,
-0.5387719274,
0.0943721384,
-0.3030577898,
-0.5713962317,
-0.8328994513,
-0.219961375,
0.8326120377,
0.6135240793,
0.7154887915,
0.7465335131,
0.4901031256,
0.1851235926,
-0.5170474648,
0.1228788644,
-0.626609683,
-0.0232358109,
0.0273959655,
-0.7075892687,
-0.2918466628,
-0.1471828669,
0.8456128836,
0.904943943,
-0.395396024,
-0.0696053207,
0.3630408943,
0.7609363198,
-0.2039173394,
0.237143591,
-0.854483366,
-0.0345562287,
-0.1395121217,
0.0107847443,
-0.4484600723,
-0.5363026261,
0.163052693,
-0.2716857493,
0.4232506752,
0.4950679243,
0.3499892056,
0.3787584007,
-0.5278168917,
-0.3410311639,
-0.7096697092,
0.8242149949,
-0.4028879106,
0.0594630577,
0.33642295,
0.2084984928,
-0.1426962912,
-0.5998507738,
-0.2955688536,
-0.1123138741,
-0.2777838111,
0.0167070162,
0.0924050957,
0.0031144896,
-0.0690779537,
0.7192798257,
-0.7284883261,
0.3194082081,
-0.2142831981,
0.1327218264,
0.436296612,
0.0748283193,
0.1776209027,
0.2019259483,
-0.2585448325,
-0.0347249135,
-0.8971827626,
-0.2137889266,
0.1300115436,
0.315123558,
-0.0740195066,
0.5224019885,
0.1232042238,
0.744989574,
0.1895007938,
0.1348133534,
-0.0710433424,
-0.1699265838,
0.0917357355,
0.1795371324,
0.7622081041,
0.321486026,
-0.0353598744,
-0.2539101839,
0.0469652116,
-0.2136774361,
0.2896249592,
-0.9472231269,
-0.4138803482,
0.2081225812,
-0.4850441813,
-0.4194978774,
0.2794912755,
-0.8785356283,
-0.5974540114,
-0.0289635677,
0.2918283939,
-0.2280887663,
-0.1658515483,
0.0614483282,
0.2363052666,
0.410692066,
0.3597841561,
-1.1382850409,
0.3990401626,
1.0779103041,
1.0505999327,
-0.733956337,
-0.3013767302,
-0.5194122195,
0.0734583065,
-0.3674251139,
0.9731693864,
-0.7998685837,
-0.4884578884,
0.0475590043,
0.0245007463,
-0.2342529595,
-0.645041883,
0.0795366541,
-0.397292316,
0.3163802624,
-0.0111526083,
-0.754232347,
-0.2692506313,
0.3976965547,
-0.5641079545,
1.3461581469,
-0.1492680013,
-0.5935223699,
0.2414175272,
-0.616736412,
-0.4410946071,
-0.0454107411,
-0.1581881493,
-0.3660224378,
0.1162577197,
0.2578908503,
0.6147120595,
-0.3387928009,
0.2029040307,
-0.3306999207,
-0.2909566164,
0.2160283327,
-0.2019922584,
0.0868206993,
0.0098758219,
-0.2172562182,
0.3179169595,
-0.5456188321,
-0.0201136842,
-0.0300829001,
-0.4548045099,
-0.3008219898,
0.3969402313,
0.1039511338,
-0.2927293181,
0.4139030278,
-0.3539845943,
0.1659804732,
-0.4559627175,
0.5600277185,
0.5914594531,
-0.0912950858,
0.653608799,
-0.3871772289,
0.4483163357,
0.0143593876,
-0.0108085228,
-0.4224058986,
-0.6276519895,
-0.8225932121,
-0.028700117,
0.3558658957,
0.4823698401,
-0.3337554932,
0.6069819331,
0.0390384682,
-0.6202931404,
-0.3067792952,
0.0260232165,
0.1487638056,
0.0350655764,
0.3381710649,
0.020274967,
-0.2273317128,
-0.632576704,
-0.0738192201,
-0.0587760545,
0.1019708663,
0.253266573,
0.3633048832,
-0.3199472427,
1.0653612614,
-0.8799049854,
-0.2583203316,
-0.2428335398,
0.0640050471,
0.3131858408,
0.4658783674,
0.325609833,
-0.8339013457,
-0.834729135,
0.4848310053,
-0.375367552,
0.0295372158,
0.1541558951,
-0.0868571103,
0.0815548077,
0.8550177813,
-0.4219848216,
0.2010469288,
0.738122642,
-0.2342713028,
0.3927516043,
-0.319018364,
-0.1143691689,
-1.470823288,
-0.0606599152,
-0.2066867352,
-0.436124742,
-0.4234149754,
0.2039202303,
-0.0627721027,
-0.1356184185,
-0.2238267809,
0.5356205106,
-0.4287799001,
0.1412906051,
-0.5222098827,
0.3180764019,
-0.3205757737,
0.3925331831,
-0.0663956553,
0.7211051583,
0.5787999034,
-0.4937241971,
0.2899518609,
0.104204759,
-0.2574370205,
0.5609815121,
-0.7094889879,
0.3774082363,
-0.0880870521,
0.2696309388,
-0.9479404688,
-0.1279533058,
-0.0918989033,
-0.2236463428,
0.284781754,
-0.3634084761,
-0.5709382892,
-0.2658564746,
-0.2677829564,
0.4323991239,
0.6880473495,
-0.8305130005,
0.4576793313,
0.6108474731,
-0.2339224964,
-0.0768527091,
-0.5444108248,
-0.0193037111,
-0.4614759088,
-0.410612762,
0.3667452931,
-0.4369025528,
-0.0914659053,
0.1630350947,
0.0248247311,
-0.3216798007,
0.0635941029,
0.3452845514,
-0.0824302733,
-0.2559812963,
0.4307040572,
0.0372683369,
-0.3462993801,
-0.1661291867,
-0.6820427179,
0.7845276594,
-0.5448531508,
-0.5313852429,
0.0944188163,
0.4737631977,
0.1482256651,
-0.0614888407,
0.6470345855,
1.085292697,
-0.3205439746,
-0.3789342344,
-0.6226590276,
-0.2690604329,
-0.4678418338,
0.3071323931,
-0.0140595492,
-1.8491567373,
0.4179938138,
-0.1636220962,
0.0303153507,
0.4347651899,
0.827952981,
-0.2112345695,
1.1510554552,
0.7647195458,
-0.2747238874,
0.329136014,
0.0171048883,
0.4063580036,
-0.4194724262,
-0.054002665,
-0.7610689998,
-0.3858173788,
-0.7062236071,
-0.7529393435,
0.3970475197,
0.1424998045,
0.0935753509,
-0.1002714485,
-0.5891754627,
0.9865037799,
0.633738935,
0.0193623044,
0.4206955433,
0.0248604771,
0.0515736081,
0.0249126777,
-0.9679198265,
-0.4892131984,
0.7332877517,
0.2750837207,
0.9932494164,
-0.0488354452,
0.8103100061,
0.2052347958,
0.155287683,
-1.0164592266,
0.4675913751,
-0.3044071496,
-0.3695650995,
-0.2061216533,
-0.459010303,
-1.2520034313,
0.313631922,
-0.0898181647,
-0.8053116202,
-0.1528630704,
0.3660529256,
-0.3547171056,
0.4233984053,
-0.7005754709,
0.8292310834,
-0.0070945499,
-0.0962714106,
-0.4593740106,
-0.3156160414,
0.1301834583,
-0.2627751827,
0.2468467951,
-0.0183094572,
-0.0864796862,
0.7404462099,
-0.4730978608,
1.2302163839,
0.0406184308,
-0.1859221607,
0.4023780823,
-0.0319327861,
0.4695886075,
0.1973250359,
0.1495331675,
0.0229475498,
0.3516794145,
-0.3801130652,
-0.6323100328,
1.1025620699,
-0.482136488,
-0.6370561123,
-0.2589094639,
-0.5261682868,
-0.1546354294,
0.2929996848,
0.0074958787,
0.3652465641,
-0.3863027096,
0.8061425686,
0.9504489303,
-0.3517930508,
0.3742842674,
0.3940200806,
-0.6395555735,
-0.2029261887,
0.9860694408,
-0.277751714,
0.1380304247,
0.7524476051,
0.6207923293,
-0.1980232,
-0.5563898087,
-0.2697994411,
0.1843272448,
-0.4445947707,
-0.0761767328,
-0.7015590072,
-0.2257608324,
-0.02942398,
-0.1819283217,
-0.3966238201,
-0.2740161121,
-0.2246925086,
-0.1445189416,
0.5567985177,
1.0387101173,
0.0241248831,
0.7040492296,
-0.819842577,
-0.1779021919,
0.4664288461,
0.4654535651,
0.0854429528,
-0.1505229324,
-0.6763691902,
0.0038307849,
-0.0548273884,
-0.5563719273,
-0.0190488771,
0.1881801933,
0.3156254292,
0.4165560305,
-0.2002498507,
0.3865913451,
-0.7183468342,
0.8633631468,
0.0045893933,
-0.6255252957,
0.5043950081,
-0.5668785572,
0.495516777,
0.5243148208,
0.1453653127,
-0.7911826968,
-0.3314181268,
-0.45550102,
-0.8311111331,
0.6625391841,
-0.0504197627,
0.1904038787,
-0.1715413928,
0.2722643912,
0.1788341552,
0.1778260171,
-0.7262625694,
-0.1268950105,
0.2583296597,
-0.3814365864,
-0.1408388019,
-0.5351415873,
-0.1732831299,
-0.1964702457,
0.4745875299,
-0.3405828476,
0.2216499895,
-0.2702191472,
-0.2365653366,
0.0705116689,
0.2243161052,
0.3158449233,
0.4833174646,
-0.0753657594,
0.3305803835,
0.2108920068,
-0.4155376852,
-0.111055389,
-0.0057559148,
-0.2512186468,
-0.1201907322,
0.1566723734,
0.59893924,
0.4736289978,
-0.487026304,
0.5519529581,
-0.0524148606,
-0.2760774791,
-0.0568240248,
0.2024997175,
0.4099728465,
0.2529702187,
0.2901818156,
-0.4231537282,
-0.143140167,
-0.2758232951,
0.0873641297,
0.4295773506,
-0.6667314768,
-0.2272021472,
0.4719344079,
0.0554164536,
-0.2098408043,
0.153039813,
-0.1772233546,
-0.5325035453,
0.515704155,
0.6528483629,
0.7706218362,
-0.1204456314,
0.3672912121,
0.2284339219,
0.4118830264,
-0.3082091212,
-0.0101301111,
0.0420209765,
-0.597869575,
-0.444458425,
-0.6895535588,
-0.6045165658,
-0.1373683959,
-0.4849747419,
0.0216545667,
-0.3783177733,
0.2555500567,
-0.3804341853,
-0.0788470879,
-0.3920971155,
-0.0847417638,
-0.127646029,
0.6645278335,
-0.5194911361,
0.7137531042,
0.8393934369,
0.1085685119,
-0.5803703666,
0.072388947,
0.0267895423,
-0.8344143033,
-0.1448669881,
0.3428418934,
0.0000103918,
0.3430559337,
-0.6582864523,
-0.9724810719,
1.0014859438,
-0.1250018924,
-0.6232679486,
0.1657428145,
0.1174837872,
0.5564537644,
-0.3606030643,
-0.0058735912,
0.6456882358,
0.4963082373,
0.0532072298,
-0.6442480087,
-0.0296247229,
-0.0654815063,
0.0514170676,
0.5003532171,
-0.7333962321,
0.6003319621,
-0.1765295416,
-0.1396305263,
0.0588834994,
0.6278580427,
0.055276338,
0.3266746402,
0.600486815,
0.6011957526,
0.9438791275,
-0.1868513972,
0.9176717997,
-0.2977936566,
0.4880926907,
1.1237945557,
-0.1237991974,
0.8283738494,
0.3555059731,
-0.2751452029,
0.4507624209,
0.7339599133,
-0.0716191903,
0.2387386858,
0.1941109747,
-0.2739732265,
-0.1725449264,
0.0291877016,
-0.5038228035,
0.2768825889,
0.476808697,
-0.1353530139,
-0.2474937588,
-0.1135439277,
0.1353210211,
0.2496699989,
-0.2439036667,
1.1299856901,
0.3411195576,
-0.4576205611,
0.1499821246,
0.0946095437,
0.7344465852,
-0.4008721411,
0.1905520707,
-0.3348662853,
0.2443440109,
-0.3160685003,
-0.6351457834,
0.3841876984,
-0.0517599657,
-0.4187838137,
-0.1540482044,
0.7218971848,
-0.8687179685,
-0.70950526,
0.1503650993,
0.6036265492,
0.2378228903,
-0.3410620391,
-0.5596327782,
-0.1567152739,
0.000030512,
-0.0500650555,
0.5029146671,
0.4848792553,
-0.1015161872,
0.453233093,
0.7764581442,
-0.0110726031,
0.0023135794,
0.1679354906,
0.7442823052,
-0.8215242028,
-0.5963497162,
-0.9769103527,
0.1252798438,
-0.0153886052,
-0.0070436024,
0.7285655141,
0.6587741375,
0.6265221238,
0.0945953056,
0.7139900923,
-0.0180130899,
0.7064015269,
-0.7041165829,
0.7361834645,
-0.4676861763,
0.2698932886,
-0.0449012667,
-1.3000190258,
-0.4635699391,
0.546210587,
-0.4125101268,
0.090024814,
1.0116206408,
1.1652485132,
-0.1116874591,
0.1272362024,
0.1510631144,
0.3053036332,
0.3589125276,
0.3827931583,
1.0627647638,
0.099447526,
0.7299876213,
0.0010324914,
-0.3547890782,
-0.2861527503,
-0.8851900101,
-1.1685847044,
-0.5203878284,
-0.3290109634,
-0.0758108869,
-0.1942832023,
0.8066297174,
0.8062935472,
-0.8132172823,
-0.3651649356,
0.0024553437,
0.424166441,
-0.1313994378,
-0.2599464059,
0.4912989438,
-0.4867386222,
-0.6978299618,
0.4643988907,
0.4551837444,
-0.1625137627,
-0.2709570229,
0.0423394665,
0.0587404408,
-0.3550821543,
0.8186112642,
-0.0539135411,
-0.5238423944,
-0.2181365341,
-0.1692648381,
-0.0646506473,
0.1218685284,
0.9640452266,
-0.2823633254,
0.1437984705,
0.3346768618,
0.9000484347,
0.7935288548,
0.0637121201,
0.4477110505,
-0.8540018201,
0.068530634,
0.0851124674,
0.0556323603,
0.3185997903,
-0.3479058146,
0.5327991247,
0.0850572884,
-0.7718593478,
-0.602281332,
-0.0271702204,
-0.9983304143,
-0.2400873303,
1.3250296116,
0.184182331,
-0.2743819654,
0.1271259189,
-0.5159615874,
-0.2467179,
-0.2909477353,
0.7787848711,
0.6609946489,
0.2008173764,
-0.3101942539,
-0.3269618452,
0.4708025157,
0.497138679,
-1.0174849033,
-0.057978712,
0.416726768,
0.0148487119,
-0.1157315746,
0.5227627754,
-0.0544292666,
0.0351283923,
-0.2825441658,
-0.1408028901,
0.2421899885,
-0.3237665892,
-0.397154063,
0.3218146563,
0.317173779,
0.0277165119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14869v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14869v2 | CAR: Conceptualization-Augmented Reasoner for Zero-Shot Commonsense Question Answering | 2023-05-24T08:21:31 | 2023-10-20T04:49:21 | Weiqi Wang, Tianqing Fang, Wenxuan Ding, Baixuan Xu, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of zero-shot commonsense question answering evaluates models on
their capacity to reason about general scenarios beyond those presented in
specific datasets. Existing approaches for tackling this task leverage external
knowledge from CommonSense Knowledge Bases (CSKBs) by pretraining the model on
synthetic QA pairs constructed from CSKBs. In these approaches, negative
examples (distractors) are formulated by randomly sampling from CSKBs using
fairly primitive keyword constraints. However, two bottlenecks limit these
approaches: the inherent incompleteness of CSKBs limits the semantic coverage
of synthetic QA pairs, and the lack of human annotations makes the sampled
negative examples potentially uninformative and contradictory. To tackle these
limitations above, we propose Conceptualization-Augmented Reasoner (CAR), a
zero-shot commonsense question-answering framework that fully leverages the
power of conceptualization. Specifically, CAR abstracts a commonsense knowledge
triple to many higher-level instances, which increases the coverage of CSKB and
expands the ground-truth answer space, reducing the likelihood of selecting
false-negative distractors. Extensive experiments demonstrate that CAR more
robustly generalizes to answering questions about zero-shot commonsense
scenarios than existing methods, including large language models, such as
GPT3.5 and ChatGPT. Our codes, data, and model checkpoints are available at
https://github.com/HKUST-KnowComp/CAR. | [
-0.6733805537,
-0.91990906,
0.8352328539,
-0.0764684379,
-0.3937977552,
-0.0680079162,
-0.1309747547,
-0.5212621093,
-0.0699795857,
0.1821659654,
-0.4458093047,
-0.2180902362,
-0.1595615149,
0.0502970554,
-0.2355763763,
0.9741858244,
-0.0021609585,
-0.0985346213,
-0.6351462007,
-0.019377185,
-0.6489619017,
-0.3466830254,
-0.477966547,
-0.0207968671,
0.8650693893,
0.5171654224,
0.4854556024,
0.4935147762,
0.0009844038,
0.2605782449,
0.0300211944,
-0.0846158341,
-0.2736857235,
0.0987177044,
-0.5179843903,
-0.1671396196,
-0.0932703912,
-0.0954316482,
0.0119661829,
0.5415030122,
-0.0307043195,
0.086431548,
-0.4421951473,
0.0543690994,
-1.3147447109,
-0.0769026056,
-0.7437627316,
-0.3485124707,
0.1457968056,
-0.2009244114,
-0.0456183739,
0.0063287304,
-0.0074505215,
-1.1337776184,
0.4750487208,
-0.1380225718,
1.1520998478,
0.402926743,
-0.463111043,
-0.0906413645,
-0.6426872611,
0.7647733688,
-0.8094075918,
0.1620105654,
0.2459225059,
0.4881774783,
0.1468686312,
-0.3019433916,
-1.2486907244,
-0.1640523374,
-0.055550117,
0.3148675859,
0.0698884055,
0.1882680804,
0.1085221767,
0.4606547654,
-0.5000427365,
-0.090517275,
-0.5259925723,
-0.1360004991,
0.5929183364,
0.0773951709,
0.3751929998,
-0.1425447315,
-0.3729274571,
0.0805327073,
-0.5144920945,
-0.0517859571,
-0.0905067474,
-0.0475333631,
0.0331348032,
0.6250593662,
-0.7537205815,
1.1030926704,
0.0099597443,
0.1870254576,
0.0543716066,
-0.2398082912,
-0.2895913422,
0.1501572132,
0.4004707932,
0.4795176685,
0.1405314803,
-0.4194486141,
0.0860072076,
0.193206802,
0.1112692803,
-0.9198873639,
-0.0929784253,
0.5232178569,
0.2774223089,
-0.351123333,
-0.2271841317,
-0.5766938925,
-0.1784677953,
-0.6031602025,
0.4687522352,
-0.2631606758,
-0.3725671172,
0.3774655461,
-0.5192280412,
0.7469558716,
0.4875358939,
-0.6950370073,
-0.1048643291,
0.6483439803,
0.6131430864,
0.1839633137,
-0.3249914646,
-0.3007754982,
0.4274350107,
-0.4740066826,
1.1838593483,
-0.4463296533,
-0.1806415617,
-0.3378371,
-0.1087736562,
-0.0537091158,
-0.2581039071,
0.3962678611,
-0.7299743295,
0.3964930475,
-0.4710686207,
-0.6397978067,
-0.2708873451,
0.9050421119,
-0.2178502381,
0.6496472955,
0.1080188081,
-0.5836215019,
0.5799058676,
-0.8022617698,
-0.3947627544,
0.2711091936,
-0.1550636888,
-0.0156207662,
0.2143711597,
0.3179376125,
0.2582564652,
-0.2752092779,
0.4817225933,
-0.5225670934,
-0.3584239781,
0.1653403938,
-0.4095249176,
0.7145025134,
0.2873781323,
-0.0108486274,
0.029540997,
-0.8809021711,
-0.0154741192,
0.1870592535,
0.0136868097,
-0.6145141721,
-0.20931454,
-0.0254645366,
0.5407501459,
0.1978401542,
-0.8857980967,
-0.2356185466,
-0.3948302865,
0.3680784702,
0.5675107241,
0.3401812613,
0.2858668268,
-0.3985033929,
0.5738681555,
0.3128528297,
-0.0530242547,
-0.103042163,
-0.5023818612,
-0.7990939617,
-0.1015454307,
-0.0551268086,
0.6228163838,
-0.9695417285,
0.1320160776,
-0.1043273807,
-0.5244974494,
-0.2971506715,
-0.0619059354,
0.4627116024,
0.9254673719,
0.631342411,
0.0894528776,
-0.2764644027,
-0.7832522392,
-0.2799659967,
-0.1016838402,
-0.1193479747,
0.298099786,
0.4408720434,
0.258173883,
1.159055233,
-0.6664530635,
0.1382337958,
-0.3917742968,
0.0866968036,
0.0560906976,
0.4403605163,
0.3541171551,
-0.8291600943,
-0.2894904315,
-0.1218223944,
-0.6461597681,
-0.1306555122,
-0.2767275274,
-0.145777598,
-0.1552497447,
0.5571864247,
-0.9412555099,
0.3340368271,
0.0536504351,
-0.478450954,
0.6696674824,
0.0603094138,
0.0215451699,
-1.2103880644,
0.1922303885,
-0.0562490299,
-0.0730897933,
-0.7629227638,
0.2391282767,
-0.2707220018,
-0.2286440134,
-0.7111696005,
0.7843468785,
-0.0853106305,
0.2074053138,
-0.3673552871,
0.2935351729,
0.3458250463,
0.5394098759,
0.397416085,
0.8549470305,
0.5225669146,
-0.8683837652,
0.1936556399,
0.2607845068,
-0.1603728831,
0.7702310085,
-1.0220378637,
0.0932312831,
-0.6607763171,
0.0519643761,
-0.9979867339,
-0.5502407551,
0.213213101,
-0.395580858,
0.1028928235,
-0.1181636974,
-0.2614996135,
-0.1067363694,
-0.0069047064,
0.6827612519,
0.1163830087,
-0.4237635434,
0.2940338254,
0.3271745145,
0.0377456173,
-0.669239223,
-0.4557123184,
0.1358392686,
-0.1737045944,
-0.3481087685,
0.2080624998,
-0.1343308091,
-0.3622006476,
0.1511336863,
-0.3272757828,
-0.3939720392,
0.2997345328,
-0.018506499,
0.4745112956,
-0.1904945672,
0.3544684947,
0.1450972557,
-0.1392100453,
0.0538927577,
-0.0669986755,
0.3845034838,
-0.1705359966,
-0.0801088884,
-0.1263368875,
0.112424396,
0.536472857,
-0.255477041,
0.6687921286,
0.4258108437,
-0.1758205742,
0.0152530381,
-0.5030450225,
-0.1623480171,
-0.439218998,
0.3020833731,
-0.5577158332,
-1.2188205719,
0.2377967685,
0.2453668714,
0.0707263425,
0.477013588,
0.6144397259,
-0.0632563457,
0.6082111597,
0.1625995338,
0.1047771648,
0.0949772447,
0.0746680349,
0.3415805995,
-0.6809040904,
-0.1744496524,
-0.1978110373,
-0.061761111,
-0.3783643842,
-0.460793972,
0.3146503866,
0.2496679574,
-0.4610957205,
0.3663824797,
-0.6610742211,
0.9435639977,
0.5167712569,
-0.1519954652,
0.4187842011,
-0.541677773,
0.1302643567,
0.4780004025,
-0.8077499866,
-0.1946311146,
0.8527120948,
-0.0392855406,
0.2312361449,
0.0648579672,
0.4994517565,
-0.1955396086,
0.4395082891,
-0.9086334705,
0.5929799676,
0.2306945771,
-1.3955173492,
-0.2769298255,
-0.4686930478,
-0.6237277985,
0.2345918715,
0.0650125369,
-0.5066201687,
0.4054635763,
0.3341066539,
-0.7979708314,
0.1862818301,
-0.8020423651,
1.1840740442,
-0.0773723349,
-0.4608570039,
-0.1428719759,
-0.6019300818,
0.8252120614,
0.2200227231,
0.128543362,
-0.3127031028,
0.0023360744,
0.4340779483,
-0.4965019226,
0.6275072098,
-0.4014011323,
-0.1236368343,
0.6323568821,
-0.1164397001,
-0.0037442192,
0.3336224258,
0.4055056274,
0.0555684268,
0.3601665795,
-0.6330775619,
-0.8786737323,
0.6273318529,
-0.5724345446,
-0.7445238829,
-0.4514635801,
-0.614808023,
-0.386370182,
0.253805548,
0.2686460912,
0.2160390913,
0.0222753603,
-0.1473331749,
0.378549397,
-0.3915808201,
0.4123646021,
0.6079249978,
0.0234962385,
-0.333578527,
1.10128057,
-0.2210882753,
0.3713300228,
0.5997419357,
0.1978214383,
-0.4002918899,
-0.4266884029,
-0.7445094585,
0.0694040731,
-0.5349655747,
-0.3522279859,
-0.5059525371,
-0.3346642852,
-0.2727818191,
-0.2351484746,
-0.3030575514,
-0.8670448661,
-0.2632265985,
-0.129079178,
0.5393798351,
0.2240276486,
-0.0589980111,
0.2461780906,
-0.4481576979,
0.6691313982,
0.7755371928,
0.3533721864,
-0.0125460066,
-0.2933507562,
-0.1773671955,
-0.0271609351,
-0.3446935713,
-0.7600976229,
0.0664287657,
-0.0786203071,
0.217446968,
0.4982052743,
0.2687032521,
1.035336256,
-0.2065558583,
0.7458047867,
0.2618546188,
-0.7938779593,
0.4333281517,
-0.500135541,
0.3102543056,
1.0085530281,
0.1698623151,
-0.5358731151,
-0.3742725849,
-0.4883616269,
-0.7391056418,
0.4242992103,
0.1834157854,
0.1431426257,
-0.4130467474,
0.4410675466,
-0.125832215,
0.2409630865,
-0.6403173804,
-0.0646124929,
-0.6875343919,
0.0160997193,
0.0458446704,
-0.1251161098,
0.0195208453,
-0.4763292968,
0.8457444906,
-0.1812516004,
0.0861344934,
0.5719572306,
-0.1617496163,
0.1771247238,
0.7651407719,
0.7275894284,
0.5199172497,
-0.4702317417,
0.1725011766,
0.2260617763,
-0.18687509,
0.2543089688,
0.3030495346,
-0.4944810271,
-0.1368629336,
0.0393378139,
0.5939639211,
-0.0503635816,
-0.9113866687,
0.5117001534,
0.0918249488,
-0.2635667622,
-0.4289673865,
0.3021858931,
-0.0106438193,
-0.1774291545,
0.0575601012,
-0.0234203469,
0.2131015658,
-0.3830620944,
0.0550319143,
0.4909550846,
-0.4925179482,
-0.2983855605,
0.7550145984,
0.0893603042,
0.2490233332,
0.4163737595,
-0.7000645995,
-0.3968690336,
0.5826079249,
0.4000571072,
0.8027915359,
0.1163829714,
0.3201872706,
0.6112807393,
0.222119242,
0.2773579955,
0.2429111004,
-0.4797724783,
-1.1388857365,
-0.9381986856,
-0.480217427,
-0.4786691368,
0.5012854934,
-0.4903817773,
0.1456831694,
-0.6140814424,
0.1835164428,
-0.0304708332,
-0.2068946213,
-0.4631423652,
0.4838506281,
0.0781322867,
0.8881069422,
-0.5662180781,
0.6488058567,
0.7350726724,
-0.78861624,
-0.6346862316,
-0.267329067,
-0.1974559724,
-0.7172691822,
0.4275455177,
0.1435147077,
-0.082618311,
0.0599225797,
-0.6554300189,
-0.6984779239,
1.0504763126,
0.1216917709,
-0.5106574297,
-0.2039438933,
0.2238482982,
0.3269083202,
0.0352185071,
0.3653093576,
0.6356508136,
0.463332355,
0.6379067302,
-0.563708663,
0.1839775443,
-0.3317530155,
-0.201954186,
-0.0273729023,
-0.4842095375,
0.4041005969,
-0.3779719174,
-0.1822056919,
0.1748215705,
0.4423449934,
0.7132560015,
0.7334456444,
0.5339744091,
1.0970025063,
0.2510005534,
0.199290663,
0.8694896102,
-0.3086365163,
0.2303147316,
1.5620831251,
-0.1833989024,
0.6160719991,
0.6998333931,
0.0886473209,
0.5719835758,
0.3993908465,
0.0950554386,
0.4718317389,
0.2417240143,
-0.589297235,
-0.7456896901,
-0.2748709619,
-0.3494295478,
0.6920198202,
0.2199014872,
0.1687893867,
-0.7057385445,
-0.2269788235,
-0.0269543473,
-0.1698976755,
-0.3546514511,
0.8114168048,
0.006789152,
-0.7322291732,
0.6333118677,
0.0248080399,
0.3693338931,
-0.2876693606,
0.0662774593,
-0.209861055,
-0.083217375,
-0.0258093514,
-0.6375324726,
0.5345048904,
0.067683883,
-0.1057541519,
0.0819429755,
0.7520819306,
-0.3684193492,
-0.5386115909,
-0.3678667843,
0.6031757593,
0.0823344588,
-0.3390427232,
-0.6079137325,
-0.5755723119,
-0.3206525445,
0.0773316175,
0.1246045157,
0.49309358,
0.0624760538,
0.4782663584,
0.863399744,
-0.0152376322,
-0.1514437497,
0.0334940962,
0.9822660685,
-0.7340629101,
-0.3421669602,
-0.8079661131,
0.6891707778,
-0.2974683344,
-0.526606977,
0.8791714311,
0.7358042002,
0.9534489512,
-0.0520087816,
0.7683371902,
-0.2229686379,
0.5317296982,
-0.2400433421,
0.5942370296,
-0.6479483247,
0.2255542576,
-0.1700308621,
-0.7036076188,
-0.4625383615,
0.4653365016,
-0.6886935234,
-0.0567144379,
0.2536765039,
0.9528855085,
-0.249967441,
0.0229955558,
0.5144206882,
0.0667105317,
0.2744695246,
0.8095661998,
1.2377028465,
-0.3357644081,
0.5607588887,
-0.295065254,
-0.0406630188,
0.1880690753,
-0.8495752811,
-0.922241807,
-0.3769489527,
-0.5083360076,
-0.202661261,
-0.0771592185,
0.6037817597,
0.8098158836,
-0.8871233463,
0.1539571583,
-0.8290781379,
0.379858911,
0.0487782024,
-0.4009522796,
0.1471515,
-0.7691053152,
-0.3292114437,
0.2934911251,
0.2706101835,
0.0033275227,
-0.029713925,
0.0391631536,
-0.1618552804,
0.3211656213,
0.607116282,
0.6472575665,
-0.4794149697,
-0.2277792245,
0.0477414951,
0.3757184446,
-0.0638925955,
0.8866826892,
-1.1512823105,
0.5649263263,
0.2103652656,
0.6205757856,
0.4809361398,
0.2285358459,
0.3974864781,
-0.6305720806,
0.0909814984,
0.2346640974,
0.0484720916,
0.3410491943,
-0.2062882185,
0.1293646544,
0.4482094347,
-0.3665349483,
-0.5782311559,
0.4408473372,
-1.0473576784,
-0.6295418143,
1.1550563574,
0.2280509323,
-0.2232725173,
-0.5816421509,
0.0653732046,
0.2395512164,
-0.2895122468,
0.9398000836,
0.5486794114,
-0.0040374147,
-0.5069252849,
-0.4558185935,
0.561488688,
0.376073271,
-0.9316115379,
0.0860169381,
0.6720272899,
0.5223516822,
0.3060377538,
0.6004937887,
0.0303905178,
0.5709061623,
-0.1102256626,
-0.0062827184,
-0.3843525648,
-0.0896778032,
-0.1041993126,
0.2253187597,
-0.0692907423,
-0.3018532991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14864v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14864v2 | How To Train Your (Compressed) Large Language Model | 2023-05-24T08:18:35 | 2023-11-19T01:14:34 | Ananya Harsh Jha, Tom Sherborne, Evan Pete Walsh, Dirk Groeneveld, Emma Strubell, Iz Beltagy | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the increase in the size of large language models (LLMs), we need
compression methods that can reduce the model size while preserving the
generality and zero-shot promptability of the model. This goal is more
ambitious than the typical compression setup, which reduces the model's size at
the expense of specializing it to a specific end-task. To study this, we
develop a task-agnostic compression pipeline with a large-scale evaluation
comprising language modeling perplexity and 12 zero-shot end-tasks. Our results
show that a simple layer-wise pruning followed by continued language model
pretraining matches or outperforms three existing state-of-the-art baselines
while being 1.5x more computationally efficient. However, unlike typical
task-specialized compression, our best-compressed model significantly
underperforms a similar-sized model trained from scratch. We posit the
half-sized pretrained model as an upper bound for task-agnostic compression and
call for future work to bridge this gap under a reasonable token budget. Our
findings highlight the inadequacy of existing compression methods for LLMs and
establish a requirement for new methods that preserve a model's generality and
zero-shot promptability under compression. We release our code and evaluation
setup to facilitate reproducibility and help iterate on method design. | [
-0.2123340517,
-0.5151708126,
0.4984690249,
0.0088042822,
-0.360694468,
0.1116684303,
-0.4978487194,
-0.1765435487,
0.1664920449,
0.4822075069,
-0.7047258019,
-0.3637295365,
-0.7314016819,
0.0852763727,
-0.4978274703,
0.7444084883,
-0.0548733585,
-0.084841527,
-0.0645950064,
0.0968413278,
-0.4851938486,
-0.8450141549,
-0.6617584229,
-0.216949299,
0.4586822689,
0.3952064216,
0.3181495667,
0.7470831275,
0.2063712031,
0.278457284,
-0.23047553,
-0.1302131414,
-0.7561842203,
0.1049462259,
0.0082057007,
-0.341858983,
-0.2783403397,
-0.0020709522,
0.5875387192,
0.719694972,
-0.3674826622,
0.5340311527,
-0.0772523209,
0.3801998496,
-0.8046734333,
0.0883233845,
-0.7202813625,
0.2132263929,
-0.1465095133,
-0.2129771858,
-0.5795833468,
0.1205386072,
-0.2718144953,
-0.3271195292,
0.2578871846,
0.1462696642,
0.7875006795,
0.4631067812,
-0.2650912702,
0.1171044931,
-0.812030077,
0.7800802588,
-0.7735360265,
0.3841339648,
0.3039963841,
0.4578054249,
0.0555059686,
-0.5836811662,
-0.6176535487,
-0.4786821902,
0.2568428814,
-0.1208988577,
-0.1607682109,
0.1711733639,
0.4779298007,
0.4747860134,
-0.6395314932,
0.48166731,
-0.2270106226,
-0.3611866236,
0.5197944641,
0.0613484196,
0.1743552685,
0.2026725411,
-0.2154116631,
-0.1747715026,
-1.0340226889,
-0.1631358117,
0.5969921947,
0.2714306414,
0.2047705203,
0.5983710885,
-0.2768242061,
0.7996478081,
-0.1122584715,
0.0057184957,
0.1309292912,
-0.1084621176,
-0.3859993219,
-0.213660717,
0.6746147275,
0.0951364338,
0.4102352858,
-0.480062902,
-0.4782359898,
0.2082130313,
0.356680274,
-0.90720433,
-0.0215616394,
0.2983325124,
-0.2339348048,
-0.1254045218,
-0.3298579752,
-0.1405705065,
-0.1427123845,
-0.5176011324,
0.4424072504,
-0.2171218693,
-0.1982385814,
0.5259329081,
0.1386598647,
0.1132850125,
0.3053115308,
-1.0171399117,
0.2105865926,
0.7347703576,
0.7972019911,
0.0096827522,
-0.2911554575,
-0.735108912,
-0.0047791209,
-0.3305798769,
0.7332242727,
-0.3369272649,
-0.22325553,
0.1103537828,
-0.0687026009,
0.0548983105,
-0.6063653231,
0.7368735671,
-0.3351320028,
0.1166459173,
0.0169250369,
-0.6366040707,
0.0731295869,
0.4994469285,
-0.4220594168,
0.6504713893,
0.2154285312,
-0.4919317663,
0.1675834358,
-0.2752048373,
-0.2595318258,
0.0902168974,
-0.0774216354,
-0.2705546618,
0.4994187951,
0.2249553502,
0.6104903817,
-0.5692467093,
0.262893945,
-0.3068413138,
-0.5832628608,
-0.1533103585,
-0.3009474277,
0.7188104987,
0.259395659,
-0.0374853872,
0.1757921129,
-0.5693159103,
0.1233820096,
0.2032645494,
-0.4445206225,
0.0352682024,
-0.3574084938,
-0.072830759,
0.2648942769,
0.3614627421,
-0.7091539502,
0.5632949471,
-0.4775558114,
0.6649882197,
0.6700122356,
-0.2930946946,
0.423009336,
-0.1830683351,
0.7049584389,
-0.2546389103,
0.3620269001,
-0.2753292024,
0.082139641,
-0.997644186,
-0.1954877377,
0.4596592486,
0.5438220501,
-0.6701263785,
0.6647456288,
-0.4860174954,
-0.4827717245,
-0.4535726011,
0.2250849903,
0.391322732,
0.3089335561,
0.2335283011,
-0.5517386198,
-0.5806022286,
-0.9201523662,
-0.1159752607,
-0.0602850914,
-0.3220933974,
0.0200114567,
0.4176756144,
-0.0737872645,
0.8738534451,
-0.4113045931,
-0.1531030536,
-0.3913698792,
0.1702585071,
0.4116845131,
0.5951542258,
0.3598712683,
-0.3856521249,
-0.328322053,
-0.2538102269,
-0.4314843714,
-0.1565373987,
-0.0431249887,
0.1479921937,
-0.0171270147,
0.5602080226,
-0.8865953684,
0.2256555557,
0.6725592017,
-0.1620427966,
0.8048659563,
-0.3393263817,
-0.1404076666,
-0.9409029484,
0.1206386089,
-0.1092227846,
-0.3566663563,
-0.7872626781,
0.2721993923,
0.101132758,
-0.4216622114,
-0.4187836647,
0.5417757034,
-0.7008302808,
-0.0615530275,
-0.4035726786,
-0.3148240745,
-0.1637168676,
0.6226787567,
0.1286055297,
0.7336857915,
0.7385950089,
-0.4481566846,
0.3797181845,
0.0279186238,
-0.5010132194,
0.1683571786,
-0.9027169347,
0.5209131241,
-0.3196898699,
0.3469612002,
-0.7112636566,
-0.0947955623,
0.0407849289,
-0.2884542942,
0.6693303585,
-0.2117090076,
-0.7639594674,
-0.4606566429,
-0.2057407796,
0.373105973,
0.7634684443,
-0.4536094666,
0.4112649262,
0.2485444248,
-0.0738980696,
-0.6908018589,
-0.6186807156,
0.3541996777,
-0.1559619159,
-0.4414900541,
0.2880028188,
-0.3661823869,
0.126053676,
-0.279089123,
-0.2912154198,
-0.0470819175,
0.2201683372,
0.1804537028,
0.1323706359,
-0.0487033539,
0.0878267959,
-0.2104404718,
-0.2254980206,
-0.0925541222,
-0.5765354633,
0.8437712193,
0.1267547607,
-0.5596373081,
-0.2548317909,
0.2355217934,
0.4258853495,
-0.2180024683,
0.648111701,
0.3255853653,
-0.2766168714,
-0.3334225118,
-0.7325526476,
-0.1602370739,
-0.433794558,
0.3645380735,
-0.2586303353,
-1.3094877005,
0.4034622908,
-0.2986629009,
0.2214130014,
0.1639780402,
0.5062995553,
0.3032242954,
0.8551356792,
0.876254797,
-0.2459867746,
0.4009314775,
-0.2663786113,
0.3542130888,
-0.6737883091,
0.127437368,
-0.6329071522,
-0.2201762795,
0.0791734308,
-0.5966525674,
0.0897462666,
0.2565866411,
-0.5535787344,
0.4995825589,
-0.498260349,
0.7388259768,
0.3925003707,
-0.0764860064,
0.0627639145,
0.0565288849,
0.1603650451,
0.2344153225,
-0.8736020327,
-0.4119116068,
1.0261613131,
0.5685108304,
0.588986516,
0.0265254192,
0.7687957287,
0.0594258308,
0.2403331399,
-0.9599963427,
0.5512107611,
-0.2580198944,
-0.5028624535,
-0.3429022431,
-0.5508544445,
-0.786978066,
0.0791360512,
-0.1306839883,
-0.7880454659,
-0.1044002101,
0.3443270326,
-0.4156701267,
0.2393435836,
-0.8054766059,
0.7843077183,
-0.1680750251,
-0.1618445665,
-0.1016747728,
-0.5196051598,
0.3281607628,
-0.2353238016,
0.0609845668,
-0.062593326,
-0.0560293049,
0.5543339252,
-0.6343991756,
0.941819191,
-0.1921255589,
-0.1098261029,
0.0334271453,
0.1521459371,
0.5457384586,
-0.3236162066,
0.0380457304,
0.1861144155,
-0.2541636229,
-0.6065704823,
-0.7061606646,
0.4767390788,
-0.6500475407,
-0.788701117,
-0.105050005,
-0.674282372,
-0.2940898538,
0.1107509136,
0.315295279,
0.5857393146,
0.005144414,
0.0906553119,
0.647282064,
-0.2563255727,
0.3314833641,
0.4664641917,
-0.1264161319,
-0.0959449336,
0.750682354,
0.0170638636,
0.2419694811,
0.4814914465,
0.1691828519,
-0.2114609033,
-0.9838309884,
-0.423884958,
0.1493696272,
-0.676045239,
-0.2710106075,
-0.3747925162,
-0.2598573267,
-0.7173438668,
-0.0480507165,
-0.5416127443,
-0.469738692,
-0.1475408524,
0.0492406674,
-0.0006629613,
0.5802757144,
0.2060490251,
0.5283796191,
-0.7927540541,
-0.0744387582,
0.221931681,
0.2899737954,
0.1325598955,
-0.9762451649,
-0.333604902,
-0.1663624495,
-0.0094985859,
-0.5658396482,
0.5326910019,
0.2730374336,
0.5248353481,
0.3779257238,
0.0440374613,
0.6333283186,
-0.8614413738,
0.8058276772,
0.4852549136,
-0.9990229011,
0.2919123173,
-0.120921731,
0.6183838248,
0.4891802967,
0.4215619266,
-0.4490205944,
-0.2279772758,
-0.5899703503,
-0.9335343242,
0.4216229618,
0.0505769923,
0.394426018,
0.0752780139,
0.5621116161,
0.0784492865,
0.2948261499,
-0.8488017321,
0.0074288836,
-0.1140924394,
-0.1681431681,
-0.3465597928,
-0.4890856147,
-0.1396131217,
-0.1548753381,
0.5833736658,
-0.2250829786,
0.1883749366,
-0.1721523106,
-0.2058911324,
0.0867674053,
0.4410404861,
0.4119750559,
0.5501888394,
-0.1372282505,
0.2419485748,
0.290556401,
-0.3540177047,
0.3517610133,
0.0648515597,
0.0418471284,
-0.1509617418,
0.5525432229,
0.9695870876,
0.0692439526,
-0.8853183389,
0.6710962653,
-0.119933635,
-0.304199785,
-0.3062494099,
0.0653064176,
0.0932737738,
0.1184166521,
0.1632812023,
-0.1969769001,
-0.042053014,
-0.5894672871,
-0.1246860027,
0.4315445125,
-0.1886395961,
-0.2386527359,
0.4199482203,
0.0587014742,
-0.3475056291,
0.6194292903,
-0.2650282681,
-0.5608580112,
0.3281760216,
0.5555450916,
0.9216022491,
-0.2925072908,
0.0141477752,
0.4284961224,
0.464117676,
-0.4250059128,
-0.0158414748,
-0.2263031304,
-0.6085826159,
-1.0384106636,
-0.8094226122,
-0.3405537009,
0.3311544061,
-0.4482084513,
0.4259096086,
-0.5705680251,
-0.0218191724,
-0.2937869132,
0.0550429039,
-0.592341125,
0.2124015689,
0.2226336747,
1.27813375,
-0.800203383,
1.0023659468,
0.6129797101,
-0.2737092376,
-1.0786533356,
-0.1447952241,
-0.1791829467,
-0.8290793896,
0.634085238,
0.2390793711,
0.0597851798,
0.0116833644,
-0.733127892,
-0.8164494038,
0.9481186271,
0.8522875309,
-1.0412328243,
-0.2854934335,
0.0479339212,
0.5485329032,
-0.3991139829,
0.2818455398,
0.3938513696,
0.1029199287,
0.3756958246,
-1.0934169292,
0.0825012326,
-0.3065676689,
0.1806357503,
0.2009615153,
-0.3465232253,
0.9053287506,
0.0235107467,
-0.3579299152,
0.1128082946,
0.4361830056,
0.068300724,
-0.1737648845,
0.8290855885,
0.7390967607,
0.6621541977,
0.1616816372,
1.1826326847,
-0.4595136046,
0.4337810874,
1.1641227007,
-0.3865440786,
0.8699297309,
0.4394710958,
0.016221229,
0.083383657,
0.636026144,
0.0327977799,
0.3552272022,
0.7121939659,
-0.2636530697,
-0.5751206279,
-0.1777510047,
-0.1112883091,
0.3213586509,
0.0431688875,
-0.1198414713,
-0.2452132404,
0.006788888,
0.0081821168,
-0.1065739691,
-0.3634291887,
0.5590903759,
0.1363489926,
-0.6275618076,
0.9508495331,
-0.0768763721,
0.7837268114,
-0.7997714281,
0.3036931157,
-0.1323545575,
-0.0145719647,
0.0221951082,
-0.4676113725,
0.2857393026,
0.1464751363,
-0.083056435,
-0.5337045789,
0.7481539845,
-0.4977914393,
-0.216648221,
0.0593725629,
0.4000898004,
0.3641110063,
-0.3109580576,
-0.560993433,
0.3131265044,
-0.0070548821,
-0.2969167531,
0.5570505857,
0.2692849338,
0.1912210584,
0.7173737288,
0.6652238369,
0.4778231084,
-0.2244343162,
0.2507546544,
1.0241112709,
-0.4392849207,
-0.4022422731,
-0.769585371,
0.3315907121,
-0.0373107269,
-0.3030813038,
0.5573087335,
0.4126191139,
0.8603041172,
-0.0766559988,
0.6531864405,
0.1152438223,
0.384966433,
-0.6246331334,
0.5977187753,
-0.6062871814,
0.3377614617,
0.1594516933,
-1.0296857357,
-0.3511334956,
0.535451889,
-0.2960675657,
-0.0207512453,
0.5137550235,
0.6842091084,
-0.1442813575,
-0.2441422343,
0.5140685439,
0.1829724908,
0.2678235769,
0.781047225,
0.8159239888,
-0.0266989209,
0.5577912927,
-0.1698549837,
-0.2859330773,
-0.0133832805,
-1.1456953287,
-0.8874695301,
-0.5531075597,
-0.4104540348,
-0.1410451978,
0.0410516597,
0.9395743608,
1.0717413425,
-0.5221680403,
-0.3455004394,
-0.2445854545,
-0.4584299624,
0.0250482094,
-0.0537118874,
0.1481693834,
-0.4014066458,
-0.7361702323,
0.4231333137,
0.2402576357,
0.1140125319,
-0.5570297241,
0.0122123295,
0.051075995,
0.0202055871,
0.6280806661,
0.4248754978,
-0.4923969805,
-0.3751772642,
-0.1122268066,
0.1544678956,
-0.201139912,
0.8820767403,
-0.7579025626,
0.3075190783,
0.326369971,
0.8039448261,
0.4971987903,
-0.2438800931,
0.7092521191,
-1.0575158596,
0.4088147879,
0.3653348684,
0.5086262822,
0.447393626,
-0.2981815934,
0.533906281,
-0.0303196311,
-0.6986482143,
-0.9889987111,
0.4489619434,
-0.8850913644,
-0.4550889432,
1.1944776773,
-0.4058204889,
-0.3070557415,
0.1540861726,
-0.1732028574,
0.3250150979,
-0.1292098761,
0.7144141197,
0.8122640848,
0.1525984108,
-0.2727715075,
-0.4893622994,
0.2742017508,
0.6455640793,
-0.678480804,
0.3327567875,
0.4617221653,
0.1822579205,
0.125861764,
0.6297994256,
0.293213129,
0.0189474858,
0.0021938747,
0.3349782228,
-0.4044368565,
-0.3508680165,
-0.7572271824,
0.213206023,
0.3053001761,
0.0876828805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14859v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14859v2 | Utility-Probability Duality of Neural Networks | 2023-05-24T08:09:07 | 2023-05-25T09:25:24 | Huang Bojun, Fei Yuan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE | It is typically understood that the training of modern neural networks is a
process of fitting the probability distribution of desired output. However,
recent paradoxical observations in a number of language generation tasks let
one wonder if this canonical probability-based explanation can really account
for the empirical success of deep learning. To resolve this issue, we propose
an alternative utility-based explanation to the standard supervised learning
procedure in deep learning. The basic idea is to interpret the learned neural
network not as a probability model but as an ordinal utility function that
encodes the preference revealed in training data. In this perspective, training
of the neural network corresponds to a utility learning process. Specifically,
we show that for all neural networks with softmax outputs, the SGD learning
dynamic of maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) can be seen as an iteration
process that optimizes the neural network toward an optimal utility function.
This utility-based interpretation can explain several otherwise-paradoxical
observations about the neural networks thus trained. Moreover, our
utility-based theory also entails an equation that can transform the learned
utility values back to a new kind of probability estimation with which
probability-compatible decision rules enjoy dramatic (double-digits)
performance improvements. These evidences collectively reveal a phenomenon of
utility-probability duality in terms of what modern neural networks are (truly)
modeling: We thought they are one thing (probabilities), until the
unexplainable showed up; changing mindset and treating them as another thing
(utility values) largely reconcile the theory, despite remaining subtleties
regarding its original (probabilistic) identity. | [
-0.0472861789,
-0.3802292645,
0.366145134,
-0.2889036238,
-0.0599117614,
-0.1560714841,
-0.2176713645,
-0.035854172,
0.3042192161,
0.4962194562,
-0.44085446,
0.0804227144,
-0.4701600075,
-0.4787822068,
0.0728815496,
1.1404892206,
0.2594079971,
0.168069914,
0.059632577,
-0.4373573363,
-0.4901538491,
-0.6568694115,
-0.9417315722,
-0.7808278799,
1.0643997192,
0.0872196779,
1.0954780579,
0.4198559225,
0.326159507,
0.2986133099,
0.3344717026,
-0.2431521565,
-0.2646928728,
0.0612431392,
0.0610184148,
-0.8414389491,
-0.2829774022,
0.4379553199,
0.5148217082,
1.1583976746,
-0.0595437698,
0.0024946225,
0.246813789,
0.9951761961,
-0.6532872915,
0.007264792,
-0.5277926922,
0.5920681953,
0.1377536058,
-0.5610606074,
-0.2089014649,
-0.323815316,
0.2877940834,
-0.2512579858,
0.2770065069,
-0.4072096348,
0.5345227122,
0.389108032,
-0.573300004,
-0.1821789891,
-0.8213940263,
0.8635852933,
-0.2873878479,
0.1955969483,
-0.0345787145,
0.5953179598,
-0.0716650188,
-0.7589000463,
-0.4816787839,
-0.656144321,
0.1319623291,
0.1085638478,
0.2331268191,
0.1225526854,
0.3462350368,
0.3139297962,
-0.2498917133,
0.2755599022,
0.0343021937,
-0.0640475005,
0.9968628287,
-0.0112886978,
0.0231833104,
-0.016489692,
-0.4742313921,
-0.1655788869,
-0.5243791342,
0.6745939851,
0.9234582186,
0.1826662272,
0.1442377418,
0.4759173989,
0.3315508068,
0.2378727049,
-0.1593813896,
0.013439931,
0.3051477969,
0.1704385877,
-0.4680892825,
0.2067006379,
0.6048249602,
0.3102386296,
0.5348277092,
-0.3478096128,
-0.2370453626,
-0.1825388819,
0.4831833839,
-0.467473954,
-0.3603691459,
0.1963223666,
-0.7132104039,
-0.8259398937,
-0.0260133054,
-0.4791901708,
-0.58777982,
-0.6279064417,
0.3655713201,
-0.2010020465,
-0.6144493818,
0.2810662389,
-0.2279784381,
-0.2108937949,
-0.0735259354,
-1.0289998055,
0.2006749958,
0.6169125438,
0.4513979852,
0.0283507556,
-0.3656723201,
-0.4616033137,
-0.3489471376,
-0.4153136313,
0.3139707744,
-0.1962140501,
-0.1499021202,
-0.0983070955,
-0.1705123037,
-0.191773057,
-0.3607472777,
0.5174930096,
-0.6237334609,
-0.1320052147,
-0.2216360271,
-0.3920919597,
-0.3543541431,
-0.192444995,
-0.5979912877,
0.7070704699,
-0.1526791751,
-0.635907352,
0.8754401803,
-0.7507330179,
-0.370467335,
0.0397295542,
-0.0994740129,
-0.4207281172,
0.4118774533,
-0.6496591568,
0.6117437482,
-0.0747202113,
0.6312567592,
-0.7299644947,
-0.1548763365,
0.8248767257,
-1.0376439095,
0.9496217966,
0.2417224944,
-0.4935829341,
0.0587674901,
-0.8959138989,
0.077768378,
0.1870265901,
-0.1499784738,
-0.5122285485,
0.2181080282,
-0.1100464538,
0.1745200902,
0.2298166007,
-0.3003858626,
0.1398428679,
-0.5158612132,
0.488545835,
1.0140357018,
-0.3960161209,
0.7567306161,
-0.2021649331,
0.119360581,
-0.0247799307,
0.186301738,
0.3006478548,
-0.4032213986,
-0.706114769,
0.0900733694,
0.3081985712,
0.5158414841,
-0.4108897746,
0.4566624761,
-0.2207417041,
-0.0303933769,
-0.1681309193,
-0.0029361425,
0.1136221588,
0.4779292047,
0.081416592,
-0.3844781816,
-0.371483624,
-1.0611261129,
-0.5082841516,
0.0833120495,
-0.0659003183,
0.6107255816,
0.2893067002,
0.1536696106,
0.8886776567,
-0.225745827,
0.059380848,
-0.0894787312,
0.1941558123,
0.5636581779,
0.534367919,
0.3995688558,
-1.3052294254,
-0.108704783,
-0.0498566218,
-0.9347841144,
0.2328945994,
-0.4288797081,
0.0549033582,
0.2068353742,
0.2254551351,
-0.2415772378,
0.4157969058,
0.0774428025,
-0.0506628156,
0.5336067677,
-0.6074448824,
-0.2360902876,
-0.791536808,
0.0287536848,
0.1982673258,
0.1138132587,
-0.4784874022,
0.1103687063,
-0.0635518804,
0.0620206706,
-0.2266622335,
0.1151091829,
-0.2368693799,
-0.251991421,
-0.3643387854,
-0.3373550177,
-0.2653178573,
0.4813198745,
-0.0385470465,
0.7004255056,
0.7325842977,
-0.6381568313,
0.6090248823,
-0.4815216064,
0.0998026952,
0.4035230875,
-0.3580993712,
-0.0819536671,
-0.3172076941,
0.0155026047,
-0.88926512,
0.0483066328,
0.038686119,
-0.2815107405,
0.5566906929,
-0.2930343449,
-0.0438118242,
-0.4463357627,
-0.2424042523,
0.2882226706,
0.5960446,
-0.6504527926,
0.4500934184,
0.2480732054,
0.2367953956,
-0.9967325926,
-0.7708835602,
0.3382324278,
-0.2874130607,
-0.6795144677,
0.158565551,
0.0177846029,
-0.2782890499,
0.0649034306,
-0.097774066,
-0.0244731363,
0.4667414427,
0.3604291975,
0.4346110225,
-0.4876571,
0.3682055175,
0.0200268943,
-0.5741260648,
0.2729928493,
-0.868657887,
0.2249986976,
-0.0833965689,
-0.2361561656,
-0.1947855502,
0.2220809609,
0.3373047709,
0.0940245688,
0.795527637,
0.4424474835,
-0.2194451541,
-0.1493022591,
-0.3689133525,
-0.1549144983,
-0.476074487,
0.0764034688,
-0.6742231846,
-0.4791886806,
0.2944966555,
-0.1953706443,
0.1200284734,
0.5577628613,
0.2215758562,
-0.3283185065,
0.9217561483,
0.492480725,
0.239357084,
0.2680989802,
-0.6189976335,
0.495852977,
-0.5368369222,
-0.3571127057,
-0.0238750502,
-0.7794692516,
-0.9334738851,
0.1839699596,
0.2909195423,
0.0343958959,
-0.365760535,
0.11368718,
-0.5123026967,
0.2881593704,
0.744677484,
0.1842678189,
-0.0244614426,
0.1308808178,
-0.3300070167,
-0.0814016312,
-0.7659581304,
-0.5151398182,
1.4221895933,
0.2934773564,
0.4192274213,
-0.11955484,
0.703273952,
0.2546708584,
0.2963547409,
-0.9631922841,
0.4047271609,
-0.4560850263,
-0.3067552149,
-0.4173818827,
-0.5939638019,
-1.2003465891,
0.2813389301,
-0.371301949,
-0.6954536438,
0.3969946206,
0.3186688125,
-0.5380051136,
0.5572512746,
-0.8053487539,
0.9349284172,
-0.538002491,
-0.7065994143,
-0.4021912515,
-0.597873807,
0.5770920515,
0.0475790463,
0.0066543417,
-0.0334384814,
-0.0332561582,
0.556050837,
-0.3724874854,
0.7799145579,
-0.3910083473,
0.0404076017,
-0.0322158188,
-0.1053133607,
0.2467209697,
0.3677519858,
-0.2421354204,
0.2072095275,
-0.250451982,
-0.3776144683,
-0.7182449698,
0.8488704562,
-0.6965495944,
-0.5321105719,
-0.4989132285,
-0.6572006941,
-0.0329843126,
0.0239296313,
0.3734385967,
0.5815864205,
-0.1705190986,
0.1393088549,
0.7178841233,
-0.1890643537,
0.6934041381,
-0.0572634451,
0.0975229442,
-0.0482473262,
0.9148759246,
0.4091057777,
0.0886172652,
0.3043523431,
0.3038807213,
-0.384850502,
-0.5333837271,
-0.3051218092,
-0.1210988313,
-0.5129952431,
0.3667914867,
-0.6187614202,
-0.4245959222,
-0.0174577013,
-0.3103665411,
-0.3019091785,
-0.5331062675,
-0.2551692724,
-0.1578665972,
-0.1440737844,
0.3305192888,
-0.330843091,
-0.0215235855,
-0.3589070439,
0.2421733886,
0.781563282,
0.3150680363,
0.1564090401,
-0.2959137261,
-0.0166078079,
0.4239179194,
-0.4248462915,
-0.5605729222,
0.2242201418,
0.1267505139,
0.6281359792,
0.4553237855,
-0.1144657359,
0.0514265299,
-0.5364262462,
0.6854013801,
0.7118547559,
-0.4567193687,
0.2242794335,
0.0623799413,
-0.2932873368,
0.2649268508,
0.3750744462,
-0.3341597021,
0.2507217526,
-0.9355107546,
-0.6633113623,
0.4455954432,
0.0879974514,
0.6015329957,
0.4036383629,
0.4826978147,
0.5884453654,
0.4362299442,
-0.5861408114,
-0.7597905397,
-0.504113555,
0.1030586883,
-0.4360377789,
-0.3577454388,
-0.1951099038,
-0.167316407,
0.5636851192,
-0.1313240379,
0.3006911576,
-0.1375659853,
0.2469839007,
0.0272111576,
0.2608969808,
0.3430809081,
0.5540003181,
-0.2291008532,
0.3493778706,
-0.0064905062,
-0.3403512537,
0.41910851,
0.2324308902,
-0.154102698,
-0.0920414329,
-0.0127268042,
1.119130373,
0.2968592942,
-0.0826030746,
0.530813396,
-0.0175746083,
-0.4129624069,
-0.6805609465,
0.4533843398,
-0.1236227825,
0.2867815495,
0.6282985806,
0.9978724122,
0.5201097131,
-0.6365927458,
0.1443514079,
0.7679002285,
-0.3675712943,
-0.3058933914,
0.7143746614,
0.1228996441,
-0.6934497356,
0.2986001074,
-0.0488935672,
-0.3601543605,
0.9464048147,
0.1269557029,
1.220032692,
0.0918546095,
0.474152267,
0.2356511801,
0.044445999,
-0.0085356031,
0.1994096935,
-0.1089536622,
-1.0012475252,
-0.3436760902,
-0.6079139113,
0.0586617477,
0.2755161822,
-0.7293780446,
-0.0108378706,
-0.2661091387,
-0.4974316955,
0.4970224202,
-0.0386776403,
-0.7648072243,
0.3831093907,
0.1131211966,
0.685411036,
-0.7412149906,
0.9233646393,
0.4130019248,
-0.2971616983,
-0.902292192,
0.0136139439,
-0.2909924984,
-0.9340718985,
0.8581064939,
0.1933622658,
0.0407469012,
-0.0588499494,
-0.4270345271,
-0.620980978,
0.8851625323,
0.6228559613,
-0.3647708297,
0.0469179153,
0.0750325397,
0.4779283404,
-0.3267721534,
0.1929974109,
0.5301725268,
0.3621292412,
0.0274921264,
-0.56385535,
-0.1784659475,
-0.3092235029,
0.1687336415,
0.3933460414,
-0.3733447492,
0.627158165,
-0.6678419113,
0.0400063656,
-0.0152611732,
0.4399315119,
-0.1536986083,
0.6696959138,
0.6373095512,
0.3152822554,
0.725604713,
-0.0144805107,
1.2657030821,
-0.015717268,
0.2990320325,
0.6226086617,
-0.1016241238,
0.4613704383,
0.6088620424,
-0.4157240987,
0.3832906187,
0.6125142574,
0.1358142942,
0.6198521852,
0.4001781046,
-0.3103778958,
-0.493286401,
0.1614083946,
-0.3789929152,
0.206657365,
0.0039419211,
-0.7053198814,
0.0610267445,
0.2290788442,
-0.4451158345,
0.0046685361,
-0.2678114772,
0.5143138766,
0.3685041368,
-0.7552457452,
0.5525248647,
-0.2062799335,
0.6177604198,
-0.4843232036,
0.0710025951,
0.1102556437,
0.1780702323,
-0.1918962598,
-0.8765816092,
0.1339355558,
-0.5164504647,
-0.2908938527,
-0.3953158259,
0.6061745286,
-0.2026620358,
-0.460950911,
0.2988761663,
0.1861142814,
0.2235078067,
0.1421083361,
-0.8997767568,
-0.6718066335,
-0.0693700984,
-0.3095549941,
0.6192032099,
0.3190749288,
0.263610065,
0.6320255995,
0.7538003325,
0.1629627347,
0.1241380647,
0.0973387882,
0.4221806228,
-0.23663342,
-0.5171231627,
-0.8591746092,
0.5939770341,
-0.2507776618,
-0.3604793847,
0.2146419585,
0.2758089006,
0.6192674041,
-0.0920825452,
0.9779589772,
0.2430495322,
-0.0883840322,
-0.6669669747,
0.6708210111,
-0.7756123543,
0.3190470636,
0.1778497249,
-0.8725209236,
-0.1967468262,
0.5322110057,
-0.586658597,
0.1230126247,
0.883151412,
0.4902228713,
-0.3231371045,
0.375353843,
0.6912582517,
-0.1162419394,
-0.1428069323,
0.7463939786,
0.6032745838,
-0.3746988177,
0.2748661935,
-0.4728130698,
-0.4831502438,
-0.2254428416,
-1.0575453043,
-0.5928654671,
-0.657768786,
-0.2092057168,
-0.3881834149,
0.1710747182,
0.7964721918,
0.5896850228,
-0.7396346331,
-0.2280200422,
-0.4772958457,
0.0926684961,
-0.5046417713,
-0.191357702,
0.3097529709,
-0.5465064645,
-0.4247874916,
0.1670806408,
0.350096494,
-0.0986881703,
-0.2422287017,
-0.1570696235,
0.1796488762,
0.0296176709,
0.3503806889,
0.3860266805,
-0.464889437,
-0.2053150535,
-0.1457324624,
-0.1916830987,
0.1465261579,
1.0677807331,
-0.6002794504,
0.4414971471,
0.0912713408,
0.5578061938,
0.3982239664,
-0.6984601021,
0.7002707124,
-0.3078013361,
0.3307899833,
0.1365477145,
0.5158904791,
0.088623859,
-0.8438388109,
0.4486181438,
0.466565609,
-0.4814887047,
-0.6617701054,
0.4906962216,
-0.7903943062,
-0.3128702044,
0.9191479087,
-0.1347939521,
0.0143643916,
-0.0688102022,
-0.1431237459,
0.3469696045,
-0.2036186159,
0.851672411,
0.2406715006,
-0.1097556651,
0.0343618393,
-0.7336252928,
0.4687868059,
0.7503948808,
-0.1658633202,
-0.1850004941,
0.1201908365,
0.2122573853,
0.0604138151,
0.3344927132,
0.4424985051,
0.4476592839,
-0.0643602386,
-0.1192749813,
-0.1856724769,
-0.2585586905,
-0.5291774869,
0.6099313498,
-0.1577370018,
-0.401593864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14857v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14857v1 | BUFFET: Benchmarking Large Language Models for Few-shot Cross-lingual Transfer | 2023-05-24T08:06:33 | 2023-05-24T08:06:33 | Akari Asai, Sneha Kudugunta, Xinyan Velocity Yu, Terra Blevins, Hila Gonen, Machel Reid, Yulia Tsvetkov, Sebastian Ruder, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite remarkable advancements in few-shot generalization in natural
language processing, most models are developed and evaluated primarily in
English. To facilitate research on few-shot cross-lingual transfer, we
introduce a new benchmark, called BUFFET, which unifies 15 diverse tasks across
54 languages in a sequence-to-sequence format and provides a fixed set of
few-shot examples and instructions. BUFFET is designed to establish a rigorous
and equitable evaluation framework for few-shot cross-lingual transfer across a
broad range of tasks and languages. Using BUFFET, we perform thorough
evaluations of state-of-the-art multilingual large language models with
different transfer methods, namely in-context learning and fine-tuning. Our
findings reveal significant room for improvement in few-shot in-context
cross-lingual transfer. In particular, ChatGPT with in-context learning often
performs worse than much smaller mT5-base models fine-tuned on English task
data and few-shot in-language examples. Our analysis suggests various avenues
for future research in few-shot cross-lingual transfer, such as improved
pretraining, understanding, and future evaluations. | [
-0.2609839439,
-0.5713407397,
-0.144483462,
0.4118832052,
-0.0771332607,
-0.2605497241,
-0.2828469574,
-0.739405334,
-0.1532583982,
0.3924895227,
-0.5652250648,
-0.2788832188,
-0.5673909187,
0.2762008309,
-0.4037443697,
0.8367776275,
0.051110331,
0.3369847238,
0.1778361499,
-0.0476098135,
-0.5611598492,
-0.1453234106,
-0.6874324083,
-0.2430490553,
0.3378293812,
0.650377214,
0.3474229872,
0.29812482,
0.74262321,
0.1245343238,
0.2631954253,
-0.0342047811,
-0.9526565671,
-0.1405644119,
-0.3789474666,
-0.4675334096,
-0.369463563,
-0.3553778529,
0.7789980173,
0.9966118336,
0.0658609569,
0.1483990848,
0.2639333308,
0.5921933055,
-0.8764002323,
0.2858222723,
-0.7420887351,
0.2769756317,
-0.6120204329,
0.0409363657,
-0.5859362483,
-0.2702305913,
0.2497924566,
-0.5438076854,
-0.289182812,
0.1240016818,
0.590082705,
-0.1578092128,
-0.7366790771,
-0.0609232672,
-0.6293213367,
0.9125276208,
-0.6907340288,
0.6088402867,
0.3292653859,
0.791607976,
-0.2021427304,
-0.8053054214,
-0.3078118861,
-0.2241403311,
0.1505978703,
0.1327130347,
-0.3023072481,
-0.1094724312,
0.1137044504,
-0.0028365636,
-0.7503711581,
0.226674363,
-0.2381478101,
-0.1105367541,
0.677898705,
0.2158381194,
0.3058057129,
-0.1773171276,
-0.6310636401,
-0.1740194559,
-0.8497094512,
0.243017897,
-0.057461407,
0.6365451217,
-0.2881517112,
0.4655493498,
-0.4479010403,
0.8724654913,
-0.3674963117,
-0.1410507262,
-0.0168067254,
-0.7143386006,
-0.2633826137,
0.0827204809,
0.6862956882,
0.7072138786,
0.3579687178,
-0.1169384494,
-0.1366655529,
-0.1397729218,
-0.2096388042,
-0.8560240269,
-0.3155696988,
-0.3809870183,
-0.3754227459,
0.1067778915,
-0.303753674,
-0.8536812663,
-0.212964341,
0.1681602299,
0.3905536532,
-0.4764014781,
0.1180455983,
0.0007449692,
-0.1087905765,
0.548589766,
0.2290068716,
-0.984898746,
0.6495227218,
0.8343960643,
0.7118697166,
-0.4868813157,
-0.4848095179,
-0.9148856401,
0.3595712781,
-0.4134962559,
0.9669822454,
-0.6707078218,
-0.29374367,
0.2510151863,
0.0197917987,
-0.1343584955,
-0.4062934816,
0.5033733249,
-0.2030323893,
0.2213334739,
-0.6294263601,
-0.7256172895,
-0.278252542,
0.5172351599,
-0.3500992656,
0.908798039,
-0.0009049009,
-0.4544372559,
0.5022627115,
-0.4547481239,
-0.8592525721,
0.2199175954,
-0.0234794673,
0.171491906,
-0.055749286,
0.3539779484,
0.4705538452,
-0.5022621751,
-0.1633429378,
-0.4791625738,
-0.5324156284,
0.0570588335,
-0.5284976363,
0.7508567572,
0.0168875922,
-0.0423614495,
-0.2009169906,
-0.6216619611,
0.1257811487,
-0.1540762037,
-0.38133654,
-0.1980516315,
-0.3345023394,
0.4137020409,
0.3546999395,
0.1362711191,
-0.4057492316,
0.4077240527,
-0.6244069338,
0.2439550757,
0.3023312986,
-0.0191054009,
0.5843088031,
-0.4718231857,
0.5671660304,
0.0404021293,
0.0329529829,
-0.2740751207,
-0.4551387131,
-0.3773861527,
-0.2055033296,
0.355584532,
0.6573993564,
-0.9116786122,
-0.2489367276,
-0.5537706017,
-0.3798580468,
-0.402557075,
0.1964701861,
0.4658577144,
0.6621565819,
0.4031312168,
-0.8281111121,
-0.4534014463,
-1.1035294533,
-0.5366613865,
0.2089296281,
0.0288937818,
0.4142503738,
0.3072122633,
0.0407179706,
0.7447874546,
-0.1139076501,
-0.5245693922,
-0.5215099454,
0.2451529801,
0.2527513802,
0.4271956384,
0.7218823433,
-0.2703475654,
-0.9398913383,
0.3428553641,
-0.4200985134,
-0.0299325809,
-0.0034403675,
-0.2668627799,
0.2713959217,
0.3213415742,
-0.3870175779,
0.2126883715,
0.708257556,
0.1622462869,
0.2224028409,
0.1810364425,
0.270925194,
-0.9423226118,
0.1022310629,
-0.0751558021,
-0.4068697095,
-0.4821607172,
-0.227165848,
0.1505678892,
-0.0280853678,
-0.9886738062,
0.8440545797,
-0.3162713349,
-0.5934918523,
-0.1772763729,
0.3479592502,
-0.0791673884,
0.5454214215,
-0.191546157,
0.5666576624,
0.7657760382,
-0.4940775037,
0.3468997478,
0.184482649,
-0.5478845835,
0.8762857914,
-0.5147047043,
0.1138698608,
0.1817750186,
0.6075636744,
-1.318056345,
0.0917691067,
0.3834401965,
-0.0258426201,
0.2974842787,
-0.5266685486,
-0.1732731909,
-0.151194036,
-0.4122709334,
0.4430590272,
0.4706065655,
-0.2932243943,
0.2119600326,
0.1589450985,
-0.2248998284,
-0.5707103014,
-1.0422147512,
0.1202485636,
0.0863777176,
-0.6370003223,
0.4955709875,
0.0987207741,
0.0654766485,
-0.0447998121,
-0.255207777,
-0.2345441282,
-0.0425504632,
-0.2198815644,
0.1138407961,
-0.4777207971,
-0.0883246064,
0.0208011065,
-0.1105883345,
-0.2298244387,
-0.3563062251,
0.3986105025,
0.0242199693,
-0.2934680581,
-0.2645327151,
0.2130207717,
0.1873034537,
-0.1873476803,
0.4504894316,
0.6683423519,
-0.4920468032,
-0.2141067684,
-0.2318721414,
-0.1911855638,
-0.3670522273,
0.5986868143,
-0.7273606062,
-0.5645952821,
0.5596458912,
-0.1199714392,
0.3587931395,
0.4815719426,
0.4439845383,
-0.0406133533,
0.8340758085,
0.5775988102,
-0.3911007345,
0.4767719805,
-0.0892808288,
0.0851667523,
-0.680195272,
0.2473383248,
-0.5893676281,
-0.574026525,
-0.6150255799,
-0.4594728649,
0.1800560504,
0.0665624365,
-0.0720902085,
0.5838784575,
0.0891513601,
0.7609638572,
0.3134925365,
-0.2897956967,
0.4325518906,
-0.2550270855,
-0.274638623,
-0.0740437806,
-1.0339339972,
-0.3185650706,
1.0683313608,
0.0918448716,
0.8917863965,
0.2735690475,
0.6303617358,
0.2404142767,
0.4443859756,
-0.7903470993,
0.4472557604,
-0.5552530289,
-0.636367619,
-0.4250459969,
-0.4401407242,
-1.0457288027,
0.5250316262,
-0.0983519629,
-0.990185678,
-0.0410387069,
-0.0444617979,
-0.2644141018,
0.0880966336,
-0.6641262174,
1.2355006933,
-0.3185059726,
-0.6854435802,
-0.1517075449,
-0.6134233475,
0.6395091414,
0.0425830074,
0.2881597579,
-0.3526524901,
-0.027206162,
0.6639514565,
-0.0568952151,
0.8311648965,
0.018955037,
-0.1188330576,
-0.1116507351,
0.5166683197,
0.6225597262,
-0.185551703,
-0.1826273352,
0.194940418,
0.3216774762,
-0.5000270605,
-0.3911122084,
0.7787835598,
-0.5432716012,
-0.1426918507,
-0.238361463,
-0.5565693974,
-0.5174102187,
0.3118926883,
0.3973462284,
0.3926215172,
-0.5340907574,
0.2254520357,
-0.0473349206,
-0.0030158192,
0.6238957644,
0.4662909508,
-0.4526545703,
-0.0357804634,
0.7532645464,
0.2627791464,
0.2345828116,
0.728533864,
0.0866009369,
-0.2861635387,
-0.4895580113,
-0.5660643578,
-0.0399583131,
-0.8539502025,
-0.2723808587,
-0.3392846286,
0.0602772273,
-0.5321657658,
-0.3206465542,
-0.7452417612,
-0.3711560071,
0.1354261488,
0.2612191141,
-0.0865435675,
0.589890182,
0.1510908604,
0.1856618226,
-1.1495608091,
0.3232714534,
0.3931002617,
0.3760024607,
0.1106955037,
-0.7233024836,
-0.2742798328,
0.1783400774,
-0.2319587767,
-0.7712458372,
0.4334022701,
0.5478939414,
0.6509699225,
0.2457902133,
0.0680996105,
0.8536778092,
-0.5571603179,
0.8098033667,
0.2586902082,
-1.1594861746,
0.1375378668,
-0.1774614304,
0.5217796564,
0.7728161216,
0.5090462565,
-1.0132386684,
0.0198281128,
-0.1084718555,
-0.8024049401,
0.8681541681,
-0.0226144902,
0.0683467314,
-0.0064453967,
-0.3386268914,
0.4348953664,
0.071580112,
-0.7335528135,
0.0679244325,
0.1088850424,
0.0093382038,
-0.0667005181,
0.0191340391,
-0.0576498695,
-0.2463230491,
0.6199804544,
-0.3510725498,
-0.0511220433,
-0.1839600056,
-0.5366943479,
-0.2998354733,
0.3628666103,
0.5886686444,
0.6797095537,
-0.1326105446,
0.076094754,
0.5827978849,
-0.1375935078,
-0.1314327419,
0.2190356851,
0.151056543,
-0.220053643,
0.6659004688,
0.7410928011,
1.1259642839,
-0.6148375273,
0.5181320906,
0.0174145158,
0.0903330073,
0.1960926801,
-0.1009141281,
-0.0477164127,
0.2900650799,
0.2180437297,
-0.1780150086,
0.3996260166,
-0.7643976212,
0.2920660973,
0.4698442519,
-0.3678891063,
-0.3189153671,
0.3137807846,
0.4295689166,
-0.1862344146,
0.7737246752,
-0.2397763729,
-0.3823140562,
0.3631359339,
0.5957038403,
0.8682658672,
-0.0244838577,
-0.0188844968,
0.3240635097,
0.3679570854,
-0.0588152856,
0.2008060217,
-0.2439385951,
-0.8426264524,
-0.3681812584,
-0.4370971024,
-0.7016546726,
-0.2942322493,
-0.5629276037,
0.4385403395,
-0.121870555,
0.1142188758,
0.0605936907,
0.1503857374,
-1.0458458662,
-0.268391937,
0.4696375728,
1.0110743046,
-0.8143005371,
1.0106397867,
0.6173350215,
-0.1903446913,
-0.5823785067,
-0.0581417158,
0.1852793247,
-0.9046717882,
0.6501122713,
0.1085536703,
-0.1218690574,
0.0229281373,
-0.2416315377,
-0.8926042318,
0.9206684232,
0.3282440603,
-1.0166478157,
0.1830517799,
0.2112871706,
0.4518675506,
-0.4263941646,
0.5655685663,
0.6444694996,
0.5511928797,
0.4331390858,
-1.3067409992,
-0.180030182,
0.0088626472,
0.0956925079,
0.0817677528,
-0.5196745992,
0.8084929585,
0.0355158858,
-0.1523445249,
-0.1115587801,
0.4735899866,
-0.0035608432,
0.3690587282,
0.1910584271,
0.3427646458,
0.6702970862,
0.0253005009,
1.3189529181,
-0.32859689,
0.3366507888,
1.2997481823,
-0.9273460507,
1.1747920513,
0.39580971,
-0.3282881379,
0.1274222136,
0.4745647907,
0.1206689999,
0.6566873193,
0.1970309466,
0.1547036916,
-0.0386745855,
-0.2358127087,
-0.4286813736,
0.839704752,
0.0832642168,
-0.0275216084,
-0.6638336182,
0.1657836884,
-0.1186415628,
-0.3873034716,
-0.2382325083,
0.7899664044,
0.2287792712,
-0.7676419616,
0.7033343315,
-0.0000666544,
0.8998212814,
-0.6957204342,
-0.0095630325,
-0.4904919863,
0.1313140392,
-0.0922247916,
-0.7544155717,
0.1925816387,
-0.0001997892,
0.359079212,
-0.2654515505,
0.7287327647,
-0.5978884101,
-0.3549976647,
0.2367483079,
0.6168749928,
0.3393804729,
0.1707061827,
-0.6261529922,
0.1622098088,
-0.0889612511,
-0.2680180669,
0.4733957648,
0.3884369433,
-0.085189268,
0.4295883477,
0.4344073832,
-0.0469306409,
0.3238296807,
0.2985569239,
0.3669914007,
-0.7357412577,
-0.4927420616,
-0.8315309882,
0.3136611581,
0.19002527,
-0.6082873344,
0.9133748412,
0.75687325,
1.223192811,
-0.1618930697,
0.5462926626,
0.091961965,
0.0611485653,
-0.526199162,
0.5684298873,
-0.6034286618,
0.0875454918,
-0.3719737232,
-1.0267794132,
-0.2176377773,
0.5633141398,
-0.5087832212,
0.0326699279,
0.6898884177,
0.5054457784,
-0.2507900298,
0.0944161117,
0.6742156148,
0.2314148098,
0.2426692843,
1.127515316,
0.7310732603,
-0.5682467818,
0.5955220461,
-0.4970451891,
0.0700227469,
-0.6780068278,
-1.0307638645,
-0.6425641775,
-0.4178942442,
-0.3518855572,
0.2048948854,
0.1351901591,
1.038621664,
0.8805279732,
-0.7764171958,
-0.6579897404,
0.1602830738,
0.1993006021,
-0.5981576443,
-0.2043650746,
0.0014501254,
-0.402556777,
-0.7805953026,
0.5363258719,
0.5600062013,
-0.100529097,
-0.0794499367,
0.0567645989,
-0.4145776629,
0.0832945108,
0.8594113588,
0.388154,
-0.4833959937,
-0.2542871833,
-0.0741837323,
-0.40334934,
0.0587281138,
0.6134844422,
-0.712613821,
0.3385272324,
0.7325479984,
0.874943614,
0.8447358012,
-0.3213815689,
0.576983273,
-0.891269207,
0.1232192665,
0.304038167,
0.4179272354,
0.3393656611,
0.0942667648,
0.488653183,
0.0913049281,
-0.1852405667,
-0.8394065499,
0.1107871085,
-0.9422360659,
-0.1466075033,
0.9177229404,
-0.1843280047,
-0.2779651284,
0.0993128791,
-0.0334040262,
0.1630341113,
-0.203082785,
0.5204018354,
0.8636211157,
-0.1867130399,
-0.331137836,
-0.4920400679,
0.355722934,
0.5836461782,
-1.0366623402,
0.0409975164,
0.348910749,
0.272328347,
-0.3754665554,
0.6051242948,
0.0556242317,
0.4317049384,
0.0583591908,
-0.0894752145,
0.3198211789,
-0.3357919753,
-0.3997956514,
0.2399069369,
0.0619457811,
-0.3233930469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14847v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14847v1 | Drafting Event Schemas using Language Models | 2023-05-24T07:57:04 | 2023-05-24T07:57:04 | Anisha Gunjal, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL | Past work has studied event prediction and event language modeling, sometimes
mediated through structured representations of knowledge in the form of event
schemas. Such schemas can lead to explainable predictions and forecasting of
unseen events given incomplete information. In this work, we look at the
process of creating such schemas to describe complex events. We use large
language models (LLMs) to draft schemas directly in natural language, which can
be further refined by human curators as necessary. Our focus is on whether we
can achieve sufficient diversity and recall of key events and whether we can
produce the schemas in a sufficiently descriptive style. We show that large
language models are able to achieve moderate recall against schemas taken from
two different datasets, with even better results when multiple prompts and
multiple samples are combined. Moreover, we show that textual entailment
methods can be used for both matching schemas to instances of events as well as
evaluating overlap between gold and predicted schemas. Our method paves the way
for easier distillation of event knowledge from large language model into
schemas. | [
-0.2128387541,
-0.4489746392,
0.7009584904,
-0.0385364965,
-0.2108301073,
-0.0589115806,
-0.4228659272,
-0.7981507182,
0.4447341263,
0.7666045427,
-0.5492732525,
-0.565954566,
-0.4247367978,
0.1614460349,
-0.7139328718,
0.9817992449,
-0.2955141366,
-0.375613898,
-0.1041421592,
0.1671945006,
-0.1802535653,
-0.6334938407,
-0.4416701198,
-0.5786813498,
0.2665886879,
0.3626037836,
0.4529691339,
0.7112420201,
0.4954649806,
0.122100994,
-0.2648302317,
0.4581479728,
-0.5149961114,
0.3714745045,
-0.2497079968,
-0.4431614578,
-0.3657813668,
0.1698985994,
0.5864344239,
0.9688134789,
-0.4194544852,
0.0780722052,
-0.1190432981,
0.2302403003,
-0.5209403634,
0.4703396261,
-1.0270451307,
0.2620078921,
-0.3766192496,
-0.4652474523,
-0.5085420609,
0.014257567,
0.2007429898,
-0.7110974789,
0.4170932472,
0.1446652859,
0.6155228615,
-0.3583186567,
-0.2736707926,
-0.5778229237,
-1.1331377029,
0.6536414623,
-0.5680425167,
0.1509902775,
0.5284448862,
0.4160193801,
-0.248651281,
-1.0074329376,
-0.7014047503,
-0.2739522457,
-0.2636654079,
0.103886947,
0.0417598449,
-0.0608440489,
0.5564482212,
0.1572099179,
-0.4344219267,
0.1913412958,
-0.3737479746,
-0.117538929,
0.9345257878,
0.8276136518,
0.3270651698,
-0.2072036564,
0.0152176879,
0.2859432697,
-1.0697690248,
-0.4070845246,
0.3616254628,
0.4666324556,
-0.0350564942,
0.8603185415,
-0.6532953978,
0.5257475972,
-0.1225062981,
-0.3024042845,
-0.0735425651,
-0.6300318241,
-0.0510356091,
-0.0773385689,
0.5218167901,
0.5530230403,
0.4745633304,
-0.4953613877,
0.0745947659,
0.3251991868,
-0.047792308,
-0.6587816477,
-0.2332966626,
0.2385746837,
-0.5978832841,
-0.1263709962,
-0.0037042075,
-0.8398817778,
-0.5896439552,
-0.5875695348,
0.0391938537,
-0.3238780797,
-0.0905366987,
0.5249940157,
-0.4701644182,
0.2089330703,
0.6365036964,
-1.0232892036,
0.3361048996,
0.7142018676,
0.2476865202,
-0.198557511,
-0.5095908046,
-0.5026595592,
0.6313433647,
-0.2157488316,
0.6811147332,
-0.5503351092,
-0.4955215752,
0.2278242707,
-0.108059831,
0.2580244839,
-0.3623143435,
0.529307425,
-0.4921923876,
0.1249958724,
-0.163513422,
-0.7586100698,
0.0972317457,
0.1832356751,
-0.6090746522,
0.7609528303,
-0.2614866495,
-0.7798758745,
0.613045752,
-0.3217968047,
-0.6141180992,
0.3178018928,
-0.2615014017,
-0.1035763323,
0.0368702598,
0.2214571685,
0.4888449013,
-0.2153860033,
0.4473399222,
-0.3148646057,
-0.1828969866,
0.0751559287,
0.0724144801,
0.4124468863,
0.1153554171,
-0.0167034306,
-0.0314061046,
-0.7913097739,
-0.4248477817,
0.1782516539,
-0.3967803121,
-0.1640594304,
0.5048428774,
0.1239192933,
0.1142766178,
0.1761730611,
-0.2834812105,
0.527559042,
-0.4456093013,
0.3691227138,
0.3950634897,
0.1597379595,
1.0244307518,
-0.2785811424,
0.4706177711,
-0.0092834663,
0.0958994776,
-0.6168912649,
-0.4483443797,
-0.6540679932,
0.0968172252,
0.0532746129,
0.4198812842,
-0.566493094,
0.4622736275,
-0.2799006999,
-0.4408943355,
-0.074359566,
-0.0029713521,
-0.091725938,
0.0988517851,
-0.0260830689,
-0.1320268065,
-1.0206922293,
-0.6221117377,
-0.4751048386,
-0.3442632258,
-0.1175158098,
0.0961287841,
0.6160942912,
-0.0780774131,
0.8223896623,
-0.5180497169,
-0.2528153956,
-0.4988569617,
0.2986000776,
0.0389616378,
0.1986768097,
0.5600565076,
-0.5055459738,
-0.2117734551,
0.1129925773,
-0.7734292746,
0.0451584496,
-0.2064287812,
-0.1637421697,
0.3656035662,
0.6268552542,
-0.7759271264,
0.6896674633,
0.1373279691,
-0.5082420111,
0.6023538113,
0.0035221672,
-0.0724487454,
-0.9483258128,
-0.074509792,
-0.4243625402,
-0.0603719987,
-0.7247236967,
0.1766563058,
-0.0489227809,
-0.0062406417,
-0.2695669532,
0.7321146131,
-0.6225611567,
-0.0663587525,
-0.2322268337,
0.405949533,
0.2487661541,
0.0503155813,
0.3914384246,
-0.0411845073,
0.5958327055,
-0.568716526,
0.4605243504,
0.417811662,
-0.7068698406,
0.4404639006,
-0.1767778844,
-0.186503917,
-0.4039085805,
0.4993007779,
-0.651307106,
-0.4825255275,
0.0466347858,
-0.141651541,
0.2153614759,
-0.2823669016,
-0.8535141945,
-0.4586349428,
0.116185531,
-0.0045328303,
0.3591576815,
-0.2819566131,
1.0518709421,
0.4701520503,
-0.4319142997,
-0.3150593638,
-0.7027565837,
0.2183910906,
-0.2740807533,
-0.4607152641,
0.2689329386,
-0.1303399354,
-0.4658587277,
-0.0882369727,
0.1497783661,
0.1025499254,
-0.0259315241,
0.4019069374,
0.3791235685,
-0.0880832523,
0.3236035705,
-0.1420361102,
0.0661177114,
-0.0613183416,
-0.3944813907,
0.6100295782,
0.1631750613,
-0.7706880569,
-0.497333616,
0.6205331683,
0.5696571469,
-0.2120455354,
0.748624146,
0.2334610075,
-0.6809909344,
-0.1658413559,
-0.6564269066,
-0.3308551311,
-0.3453045785,
0.3351078928,
-0.3543982804,
-0.8326449394,
1.0630640984,
0.0912129134,
0.3072098494,
0.4530539215,
0.617962122,
-0.0769120231,
0.8972427845,
0.4353736043,
0.0534034856,
0.4241710901,
-0.1749287844,
0.0892870799,
-0.4698329568,
-0.365004003,
-0.6424416304,
-0.1996086687,
-0.1941992939,
-0.4992388189,
0.0042907489,
-0.0112076448,
-0.0642083287,
0.0493697599,
0.0602416098,
0.7371289134,
0.4740529358,
-0.1857873946,
0.7125768065,
0.0605141446,
0.21811378,
-0.1034597605,
-0.659148097,
-0.7537823915,
1.1132802963,
0.0183348041,
0.8943277597,
-0.397054255,
0.7609542012,
-0.1276251376,
0.2894354463,
-0.4045364261,
0.4513984025,
0.0972372293,
-0.7210947871,
-0.4752463698,
-0.1012035385,
-0.9435651898,
0.1137835905,
-0.5029883981,
-0.7380348444,
0.2978819609,
-0.1643074453,
-0.2701958716,
0.3430230319,
-0.2140676975,
0.4455849528,
0.1639425009,
0.2403525114,
-0.2326226681,
-0.5418540239,
0.3091953695,
0.0033212174,
0.4639694095,
-0.3268476725,
0.2373661101,
0.7664155364,
0.0115137128,
0.9461126924,
0.3375019133,
-0.0131105101,
0.523627162,
0.4772183001,
0.8552734256,
0.0624035224,
-0.4580846131,
-0.2127314061,
-0.0169783849,
-0.1606037021,
-0.4728386104,
0.4754932821,
-0.5642021298,
-0.3934999704,
0.0408697054,
-0.6321859956,
0.0614699833,
-0.0630653575,
0.2932648957,
0.6382918358,
-0.4823856652,
-0.100462541,
0.4222634733,
0.0029167144,
0.358211726,
0.8758260608,
-0.4324275553,
0.1025670022,
0.537842989,
0.2834132314,
0.2079587281,
0.3006088734,
-0.0527146645,
-0.0253627282,
-0.7227632403,
-0.2275244296,
0.2777689993,
-0.8873702288,
-0.1995878667,
-0.8382205367,
-0.1864646971,
-0.3838325143,
-0.3814516962,
-0.1110125929,
-0.7415151,
-0.4878093898,
-0.4691796303,
0.2848377526,
0.9058068395,
-0.0259147063,
0.3391623795,
-0.7484212518,
0.3630629778,
0.1104995161,
0.3298123181,
-0.0169819277,
-0.451197803,
-0.1158016175,
-0.0994669124,
-0.2590246797,
-0.9608068466,
0.4286643565,
0.2933974266,
0.8451576829,
0.5337830186,
0.1865660399,
0.489682138,
-0.5876681209,
0.8472114205,
0.0471961461,
-0.8564760089,
0.9053474069,
-0.5919362903,
-0.0099784415,
0.340007633,
0.1436391026,
-0.7619073987,
-0.8412591815,
-0.9836224318,
-0.9667443633,
0.83282727,
0.1974191964,
0.0876093879,
-0.2750554383,
0.3682388961,
0.2589125335,
0.1745297313,
-0.6576510668,
-0.1419444978,
0.2522564232,
-0.1646592319,
-0.1857546717,
-0.4031386971,
-0.4730598927,
0.0393399149,
0.2770573199,
0.0171189569,
-0.1550726742,
-0.1805770993,
0.0020350309,
-0.3555161059,
0.2327703238,
0.3979483545,
1.0076490641,
-0.028756069,
0.1561903358,
0.4558815062,
-0.1817965806,
-0.3980233669,
0.0722159296,
-0.1856069714,
0.0768969953,
0.718097806,
0.8226501942,
0.1436507404,
-0.9065115452,
0.3087359369,
-0.0600045733,
-0.357693851,
-0.2015686631,
-0.1449471861,
0.4756374657,
0.3223987818,
0.3875472546,
-0.4786028266,
0.1879656613,
-0.9046185613,
0.1113922,
0.3406665623,
0.0246860646,
-0.2335030288,
0.6258496642,
0.1973740458,
-0.1886398047,
0.6665407419,
-0.1843582094,
-0.2907556295,
0.7715415359,
0.5496851802,
0.3889272511,
-0.015785249,
0.0793861076,
0.3430130184,
0.4265522659,
-0.2767367661,
0.4649365842,
0.339496851,
-0.6941717267,
-0.5340243578,
-0.9830623269,
-0.4609127343,
0.0687011555,
-0.5816514492,
0.4211785793,
-0.0513426401,
0.0237915888,
0.1391212344,
-0.1024092361,
-0.8305114508,
-0.0184956864,
0.4220001101,
1.172986865,
-1.2498533726,
0.3503048718,
0.5398057699,
-0.4252032936,
-0.8115006685,
-0.211426869,
-0.179773435,
-0.4793781936,
0.5628226399,
-0.4072631598,
0.4670699537,
-0.3505206704,
-0.4519639611,
-1.0414197445,
1.0252441168,
0.0777586848,
-0.5983014107,
-0.2417106628,
0.2196012288,
0.6611596942,
-0.6558030844,
-0.053360194,
0.7122647762,
0.5398985744,
0.3364145458,
-1.0375401974,
-0.0389821641,
0.1053103432,
-0.2324944586,
0.2007287592,
-0.0566417426,
0.8418696523,
-0.3080135286,
-0.4513696432,
0.2053719014,
0.8280341029,
0.4470754862,
0.5620743036,
0.0999583229,
0.3067161441,
0.9767277837,
-0.2294037491,
0.9760130048,
-0.1425907761,
0.1852927804,
1.200471282,
-0.7290983796,
0.6845870018,
0.254219681,
-0.2825057805,
0.5060303807,
0.5078520775,
0.2287401259,
0.3334916234,
0.3238598108,
-0.10474208,
-0.5135484338,
-0.0449650921,
-0.4338478744,
0.5596143007,
0.6466040015,
-0.312210083,
-0.5473944545,
0.0835435465,
-0.1678634435,
0.1239675954,
-0.4539219439,
0.9772485495,
0.0072432319,
-0.6679130197,
-0.1234811693,
-0.0132266665,
0.2149570882,
-0.4720130563,
0.0447501875,
-0.2543173134,
0.0386263169,
0.0493647754,
-1.1127887964,
0.4788090289,
-0.387214303,
-0.4323745966,
-0.1427011937,
0.7971840501,
-0.754774034,
-0.5430689454,
0.1848649532,
0.5205991864,
0.133854568,
0.032790903,
0.0386811271,
0.0354934223,
-0.3497812748,
-0.213178277,
0.4443310201,
0.8181999326,
-0.4710286856,
0.6442658901,
0.5200644135,
0.3604672551,
0.1604728103,
0.2596321702,
0.7162253261,
-0.5760023594,
-0.7731253505,
-0.8585970998,
0.2980754077,
-0.1551547945,
0.1005363613,
0.4029328227,
0.6326380372,
0.6720690131,
-0.2431296706,
0.9305949211,
0.2231289446,
0.6281792521,
-0.4420936704,
0.5901654959,
-0.2565223277,
0.1177969053,
-0.1018244848,
-0.4884620309,
-0.3990774751,
0.3268834352,
-0.0591836609,
-0.3454224765,
0.3883747458,
0.5784363747,
0.0353351273,
0.4152705967,
0.0440805145,
0.1621871293,
0.2684064209,
0.5542070866,
1.272061348,
0.0000774797,
0.4917995334,
0.1850917637,
-0.0414417237,
-0.7257573009,
-1.1197443008,
-0.9016793966,
-0.8706898093,
-0.1553719342,
-0.3212036788,
0.0412168428,
0.7272818685,
0.5062177181,
-0.7762045264,
-0.2589687407,
0.3089573085,
0.2117099464,
0.0447548591,
-0.1818684042,
0.3001588583,
-0.1956762522,
-0.6445003152,
0.1163035259,
0.39886114,
0.3203783929,
0.0301772058,
0.0859600827,
0.1306892931,
0.386195004,
0.7941065431,
0.1944269389,
-0.901807487,
-0.3409397304,
-0.1731672436,
-0.2569431365,
-0.510768652,
0.8121319413,
-0.6667798162,
0.2265463024,
0.7553784251,
-0.0052651823,
0.7320914865,
-0.3046031594,
0.7302132249,
-0.7014985085,
0.2894124687,
0.2043808103,
0.7005057931,
0.0972915292,
-0.2469512522,
0.5493705869,
0.0730082616,
-0.3288677037,
-0.9985772967,
0.5861953497,
-1.0590847731,
-0.3000175059,
1.3893014193,
0.2034839094,
0.1453797221,
-0.3732236624,
-0.2690412998,
0.216901809,
0.155484736,
0.9221232533,
0.9212395549,
-0.2160571963,
0.14556095,
-0.2774778605,
0.6378917098,
-0.3418498039,
-0.7989762425,
0.5634636879,
0.590631187,
0.2517558038,
0.2117686868,
0.9257448316,
-0.0993511453,
0.2710318863,
0.0990662202,
0.2806092501,
0.086053811,
-0.5318089128,
0.143197462,
0.299628824,
0.0089957779,
0.3756562471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14843v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14843v2 | Meta-learning For Vision-and-language Cross-lingual Transfer | 2023-05-24T07:51:42 | 2023-10-24T13:08:27 | Hanxu Hu, Frank Keller | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current pre-trained vison-language models (PVLMs) achieve excellent
performance on a range of multi-modal datasets. Recent work has aimed at
building multilingual models, and a range of novel multilingual multi-modal
datasets have been proposed. Current PVLMs typically perform poorly on these
datasets when used for multi-modal zero-shot or few-shot cross-lingual
transfer, especially for low-resource languages. To alleviate this problem, we
propose a novel meta-learning fine-tuning framework. Our framework makes
current PVLMs rapidly adaptive to new languages in vision-language scenarios by
designing MAML in a cross-lingual multi-modal manner. Experiments show that our
method boosts the performance of current state-of-the-art PVLMs in both
zero-shot and few-shot cross-lingual transfer on a range of vision-language
understanding tasks and datasets (XVNLI, xGQA, MaRVL, xFlicker&Co) | [
-0.5721501112,
-0.4351456165,
0.3307303786,
-0.1616376638,
-0.3987376988,
-0.146394074,
-0.1797253489,
-0.485036552,
-0.053538762,
0.3336265981,
-0.6276981235,
-0.3436937928,
-0.4932199121,
0.2430077791,
0.1745694876,
0.8402274251,
-0.0511240177,
0.3025395274,
-0.0009320785,
-0.4566747844,
-0.3774751425,
-0.102247268,
-0.3858079314,
-0.0700797737,
0.8664134741,
0.5637239814,
0.538579762,
0.4024064839,
0.3226807415,
0.1421134621,
0.3784025013,
0.556781292,
-0.5161013603,
-0.3731402159,
-0.5900815129,
-0.2497974485,
-0.4599169493,
-0.336940527,
0.6040062904,
0.6443986893,
0.0203712564,
0.466929853,
0.1154695377,
0.4483376443,
-1.1264195442,
0.2555333376,
-0.7504739761,
0.2516568005,
-0.2176870257,
-0.4296990931,
-0.4971857071,
0.1942632794,
0.2679071128,
-0.9491586089,
-0.0355417505,
0.062993221,
0.7951115966,
0.2325279713,
-0.4546970725,
0.1942660958,
-0.4689757526,
0.8362742662,
-0.3893692791,
0.7041501403,
0.2335578352,
0.5883280039,
0.5037487745,
-0.3148844242,
-0.4749421477,
0.1788441092,
-0.1924230754,
0.0501918457,
0.1344033182,
-0.0114134494,
-0.0281485692,
-0.0014993664,
-0.6703023911,
-0.0561688952,
-0.402708441,
-0.1710647196,
0.4076268971,
0.3334528208,
0.2029958218,
-0.131146118,
-0.4621875882,
-0.1407408267,
-0.6062470675,
0.0101552559,
-0.0460630655,
0.5967678428,
-0.0977230445,
0.4147174358,
-0.2123718411,
1.2814092636,
0.0265535153,
-0.4249143004,
0.3715164959,
-0.8282316327,
-0.4091159105,
-0.283219099,
0.6738470793,
0.5597002506,
0.5071836114,
-0.0794734359,
-0.1941063553,
-0.3184606135,
0.0405536033,
-0.7078861594,
-0.1751646549,
-0.4015599787,
-0.3534974754,
-0.2619876564,
-0.1184971705,
-0.6961428523,
-0.1531015486,
-0.467136234,
0.9222002029,
-0.3641390502,
-0.2861408591,
0.3068166673,
0.2120049,
0.4505652487,
0.3234012127,
-1.0284103155,
-0.0643182844,
0.2775871754,
0.6587114334,
-0.2480930388,
-0.8629328609,
-0.8719076514,
0.3202348351,
-0.4884611368,
0.5485687852,
-0.6507838368,
-0.1842349172,
0.0820734873,
0.2900932729,
-0.4012697339,
-0.3917091489,
0.0614383854,
-0.2755988836,
0.4750771523,
-0.3043322265,
0.002433473,
-0.3395607769,
0.3568445444,
-0.3976725936,
0.6801299453,
0.1184086651,
-0.4791021645,
0.7516149282,
-0.5079053044,
-0.7573865056,
-0.0213832818,
0.0031238273,
-0.276653856,
0.0660870746,
0.163051948,
0.6680858135,
-0.2614504099,
-0.0741562098,
-0.2192003429,
-0.2557327747,
-0.1295865178,
-0.476674825,
0.5892156363,
0.1430059969,
-0.2430940717,
0.0876028836,
-0.9837996364,
0.1653093696,
-0.1404899359,
-0.2402075976,
-0.3717656732,
-0.2541577816,
0.2565728128,
0.6128088236,
0.1847828329,
-0.3352995217,
0.2058608681,
-0.2817003727,
-0.0544046238,
0.5491216183,
-0.3834085763,
0.7628484368,
-0.1841180623,
0.4334961772,
0.1633908451,
0.4446460307,
-0.4419369698,
-0.2089455426,
-0.8677486181,
-0.1808739901,
0.1477228403,
0.7120462656,
-1.4493211508,
-0.0622260459,
-0.3362277448,
-0.1586945802,
-0.6377350688,
0.3433386087,
0.6107009053,
0.6779015064,
0.6988484859,
-0.3426628709,
-0.3414679468,
-0.8236050606,
-0.2835648954,
0.1016745493,
0.1070657298,
0.8247036934,
0.1683847904,
-0.3231607974,
0.670366168,
-0.3038361967,
-0.4983457923,
-0.2094608396,
0.1812357455,
-0.0607137866,
0.1560263932,
0.7693072557,
-0.9202563167,
-0.9038100243,
0.4375641644,
-0.4981883168,
-0.2335288525,
-0.0819916427,
0.0411393642,
0.4370877743,
0.3338425159,
-0.2492444664,
0.1507205516,
0.8537492752,
-0.5682445168,
0.5460570455,
-0.2773979008,
0.3153551221,
-1.1569331884,
0.1880315095,
-0.2014060616,
-0.5935348272,
-0.5577808022,
-0.1194284484,
0.1868418306,
-0.0968148708,
-1.2173765898,
0.7074745893,
-0.4164999127,
-0.1536464542,
-0.347388953,
-0.1338554323,
0.0852568448,
0.6437860131,
0.21757406,
0.6972763538,
1.0859411955,
-0.8002881408,
0.2147584856,
0.0201952439,
-0.1377920061,
0.8070210218,
-0.2848073244,
-0.2878106534,
-0.1033256128,
-0.0972270891,
-0.6553044319,
0.0043453425,
0.5163925886,
-0.1581703424,
0.3714633584,
-0.4557318389,
-0.1912368983,
0.091970861,
-0.0528187007,
0.8197159171,
0.1657325476,
-0.5121691823,
0.8882141113,
0.0109695634,
0.2010270804,
-0.825936377,
-0.6631372571,
0.1499714851,
0.0874518678,
-0.4091751575,
0.2261493355,
0.0330940671,
0.0546653196,
0.077505812,
0.181640774,
-0.1536141634,
-0.0851671174,
-0.115237534,
0.2909350097,
-0.2660921812,
0.0375693478,
-0.2306521535,
-0.4455153048,
-0.2919550836,
-0.4901438355,
0.399263382,
-0.2238779962,
-0.3719662726,
-0.1896669716,
0.1059902087,
0.9228921533,
-0.5645745993,
0.8209255338,
1.0914115906,
-0.0998226032,
-0.20142138,
-0.2058732361,
-0.0557538792,
-0.4077112377,
0.4312733114,
-0.6995652914,
-0.7844474316,
0.1580064744,
-0.0759712383,
0.0997623578,
0.4459700882,
0.6619279981,
0.0083749602,
0.7605997324,
1.1032496691,
0.0543548465,
0.6613863707,
-0.1479231268,
0.0136106433,
-0.5686561465,
-0.1747578233,
0.2140119821,
-0.2505708039,
-0.5071080923,
-0.9141172767,
0.2452813983,
-0.2944091558,
0.1061736941,
0.5211170316,
-0.0213003289,
0.7217116356,
0.3067916334,
-0.0701587349,
0.3030409217,
-0.0369571149,
-0.3406901956,
-0.0010528992,
-0.9178975224,
0.0481774658,
1.0357419252,
-0.0680480599,
0.8689783216,
0.1174674332,
0.2219109386,
0.0010284175,
0.0047165663,
-0.4982474744,
0.4429630041,
-0.544470787,
-0.4897803366,
-0.4846663177,
-0.4477380216,
-0.7348841429,
0.7216515541,
-0.5243285894,
-0.3535633683,
0.5121727586,
0.1614528894,
-0.3401856422,
0.5688737035,
-0.531755209,
1.085299015,
-0.5060341954,
-0.7579441071,
-0.3393875062,
-0.8105168939,
0.3670071363,
-0.2940058112,
0.2002527416,
-0.1681458652,
-0.2005671263,
0.0834140778,
-0.0228781998,
0.9107654095,
-0.171887368,
-0.3487648368,
0.0997100472,
0.2736266553,
0.1545005888,
0.0486562103,
0.1946569234,
0.2222442031,
0.118931748,
-0.378487736,
-0.4762221575,
0.2456451505,
-0.4635311365,
-0.3058518171,
-0.2540153265,
-0.5977964997,
-0.2472141534,
0.318594873,
0.3400398195,
0.4793196023,
-0.241865769,
0.2351917326,
0.6949024796,
-0.382389009,
0.3897157609,
1.085496068,
-0.4653487206,
-0.3772013783,
1.1952462196,
0.1381076574,
0.5775327086,
0.7697066665,
0.1580319107,
0.0734337866,
-0.2276163697,
-0.8555033803,
0.1067366898,
-0.4758170545,
-0.2297127694,
-0.4509365857,
-0.1021135375,
-0.2301868498,
-0.2439838946,
-0.5899845958,
-0.1166177541,
-0.3620685339,
0.179072246,
0.0281080212,
0.311755538,
-0.2887170613,
-0.0577757694,
-0.8721091747,
0.7384756207,
0.6792727709,
0.523794651,
-0.1926167756,
-0.7149128318,
-0.4826505184,
0.0376017876,
0.1587875485,
-0.4178573489,
0.3654580116,
0.6828655005,
0.3930906951,
0.4241549373,
-0.0942240059,
0.8089389801,
-0.8771358132,
0.5216178298,
0.4002094865,
-0.8270714283,
0.3716592491,
-0.3409099579,
0.4767251611,
0.6559914351,
0.3322924376,
-0.7546331286,
0.1777660996,
-0.178197667,
-0.470374316,
0.7538736463,
-0.2389333248,
-0.0067529678,
0.4112966359,
0.1704121232,
0.3947530389,
0.1166695878,
-0.854283452,
-0.1605932415,
-0.2421418279,
-0.0874790698,
-0.4435123801,
-0.1325866729,
-0.097532101,
-0.6741105318,
0.393333137,
-0.727191627,
-0.3360722065,
-0.0040415092,
-0.629750371,
-0.2857680321,
0.0718763098,
0.8779056072,
0.8816745877,
-0.0105836987,
0.3235283494,
0.7406569123,
-0.2723027468,
0.2527433038,
-0.0916766375,
-0.1558770984,
-0.1085541025,
0.3117908835,
0.996851325,
0.5780023336,
-0.702267468,
0.7034936547,
0.0521445535,
-0.4182963967,
0.167029649,
0.1087086052,
-0.2633470297,
0.2067320943,
0.2259346247,
0.3541765809,
0.0407940075,
-0.6183302999,
0.3935272396,
0.4669958651,
-0.4088656902,
-0.611024797,
0.5146855712,
0.34499681,
-0.0578517802,
0.0139664765,
0.039193403,
-0.4607962966,
0.0818512216,
0.4747985601,
0.9065744281,
-0.2171550542,
0.3823530972,
0.3592021763,
0.4046352804,
0.1852244437,
0.2193946093,
-0.3462812304,
-0.6957489252,
-0.6561004519,
-0.8717809916,
-0.421561718,
-0.1744927317,
-0.3613650203,
0.5618424416,
-0.112590827,
0.2204267532,
-0.3900045753,
-0.2041728795,
-0.8574697971,
0.3208056092,
0.5257645845,
0.7760537863,
-0.966522038,
1.0192807913,
0.6317293048,
-0.1456606239,
-0.3786221743,
-0.066137366,
-0.1058203429,
-0.8575080633,
0.5728548765,
-0.071159102,
-0.6363758445,
-0.0569667369,
-0.0037512821,
-0.9961026311,
1.0819371939,
0.6026049852,
-0.689248383,
0.1015510038,
0.4926030636,
0.5249730349,
-0.3774560392,
-0.0559955798,
0.2186989784,
0.6226403713,
0.0789753497,
-1.3039441109,
-0.2930811942,
-0.0457325652,
-0.206971541,
0.2353418022,
-0.8521267772,
0.9011082649,
-0.3110428751,
-0.1686485559,
-0.3339170516,
0.3671587706,
-0.2850222886,
0.3426175714,
0.5017135739,
0.5971283317,
0.4421074688,
0.1671507657,
0.9225406647,
-0.4171471298,
0.2450919151,
1.081692338,
-0.2460274398,
0.8444365859,
0.5532381535,
0.1764926463,
0.3169889748,
0.3997412026,
-0.0665532872,
0.8119125962,
-0.2572911084,
-0.1611272395,
-0.6640301943,
-0.0783425346,
-0.2278262526,
0.6835055351,
0.1497974247,
-0.3068456054,
-0.3854575753,
0.5318089724,
-0.5695236325,
-0.3684618175,
-0.3447457552,
0.8491919637,
0.0781086162,
-0.4377082586,
0.7558194399,
-0.1032985672,
0.8230715394,
-0.6211726069,
-0.0123528326,
-0.0264254715,
0.1761928499,
-0.118317008,
-0.7256445885,
0.3684322238,
-0.179461658,
-0.2323168814,
-0.3956996202,
0.8815988898,
-0.9077374935,
-0.5398899913,
0.4804489613,
0.8083589673,
-0.1314072609,
0.1142970696,
-0.659088552,
-0.2270349264,
-0.11518953,
0.0895451009,
0.3775393367,
0.6215549111,
0.1635090858,
0.558185935,
0.5534912944,
0.0117587997,
0.1566911042,
0.2396043986,
0.5371781588,
-0.5382327437,
-0.3507546484,
-0.9639415741,
0.4789709449,
0.3105585277,
-0.4556409419,
0.7393425107,
0.5806793571,
1.0281410217,
-0.29979527,
0.5074198246,
0.0414323024,
0.1655382365,
-0.6836978197,
0.7050757408,
-1.1461802721,
-0.1635643691,
-0.2318321019,
-1.0459178686,
-0.4724544883,
0.4464598596,
-0.1002642289,
-0.1725566983,
0.412135601,
0.6890546679,
-0.4274391234,
-0.6848267913,
1.0089697838,
-0.053020183,
0.0624681711,
0.7950578332,
0.5843234658,
-0.4360898435,
0.738147974,
-0.1664689332,
-0.0087191267,
-0.5328260064,
-0.8249287605,
-0.8952285647,
-0.7571519613,
-0.1153425798,
0.1705113351,
0.1665859371,
0.555056572,
0.9110894203,
-0.6951246262,
-0.1060315818,
0.1781966537,
0.1385713518,
-0.299343586,
-0.163381815,
0.1049099341,
-0.5344334841,
-0.6787769794,
0.4515431225,
0.6316030622,
0.0911130458,
-0.4473437071,
-0.2985542715,
-0.2714114487,
0.0271388777,
0.9392934442,
0.3657900989,
-0.6419409513,
-0.3537794054,
0.0882723778,
-0.2438613474,
0.1121447682,
0.696385324,
-0.921634376,
0.6717876196,
0.562851131,
0.6229912639,
0.4267591834,
-0.285114795,
0.7593457103,
-0.7191336155,
0.2011032552,
0.0282629523,
0.3662161529,
0.2951576412,
-0.0506035872,
0.4586271942,
0.4311686456,
-0.1052502319,
-0.5039765835,
0.2321824431,
-0.8746694326,
-0.4061535895,
1.1569364071,
0.3177084327,
-0.2649852633,
-0.0034121259,
-0.2974349856,
0.1523599625,
0.2580847144,
0.4535937607,
0.4738291502,
0.1992130131,
-0.5287047029,
-0.2907032371,
0.5887176991,
0.5200198293,
-0.6895418763,
0.2280836254,
0.2934533656,
0.4466761053,
0.103628017,
0.2787290215,
0.0193896666,
0.7827333212,
-0.1789778471,
0.0295635071,
-0.2413876355,
-0.8618332744,
-0.4109561145,
0.0179675929,
-0.2194105834,
-0.3445423543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14842v1 | Exploring Sentiment Analysis Techniques in Natural Language Processing: A Comprehensive Review | 2023-05-24T07:48:41 | 2023-05-24T07:48:41 | Karthick Prasad Gunasekaran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Sentiment analysis (SA) is the automated process of detecting and
understanding the emotions conveyed through written text. Over the past decade,
SA has gained significant popularity in the field of Natural Language
Processing (NLP). With the widespread use of social media and online platforms,
SA has become crucial for companies to gather customer feedback and shape their
marketing strategies. Additionally, researchers rely on SA to analyze public
sentiment on various topics. In this particular research study, a comprehensive
survey was conducted to explore the latest trends and techniques in SA. The
survey encompassed a wide range of methods, including lexicon-based,
graph-based, network-based, machine learning, deep learning, ensemble-based,
rule-based, and hybrid techniques. The paper also addresses the challenges and
opportunities in SA, such as dealing with sarcasm and irony, analyzing
multi-lingual data, and addressing ethical concerns. To provide a practical
case study, Twitter was chosen as one of the largest online social media
platforms. Furthermore, the researchers shed light on the diverse application
areas of SA, including social media, healthcare, marketing, finance, and
politics. The paper also presents a comparative and comprehensive analysis of
existing trends and techniques, datasets, and evaluation metrics. The ultimate
goal is to offer researchers and practitioners a systematic review of SA
techniques, identify existing gaps, and suggest possible improvements. This
study aims to enhance the efficiency and accuracy of SA processes, leading to
smoother and error-free outcomes. | [
-0.4760398269,
-0.7924819589,
0.1785131693,
0.6388495564,
-0.5218438506,
0.5563221574,
-0.2152439207,
-0.6022443771,
0.3791528642,
0.1428990066,
-0.5629739761,
-0.758341074,
-0.6338746548,
0.3300068676,
-0.1776585728,
0.8074190617,
0.0330972373,
0.4435952008,
-0.2295107991,
-0.4068773389,
-0.148870647,
-0.6891896129,
-0.9339262843,
0.1608078927,
0.2685929239,
0.2129351497,
0.4853743911,
-0.1935020536,
0.6429879665,
0.3192486763,
-0.4574799538,
0.1013305932,
-0.1698028445,
0.2842021286,
0.0560973138,
-0.2193691581,
-0.2197521031,
-0.0816747695,
0.4656015635,
0.6575266123,
0.000659112,
0.3596685529,
0.1280991584,
0.9749450684,
-0.6726999879,
0.2376220971,
-0.2297072411,
0.2797446549,
-0.2352317125,
-0.1788000464,
-0.177017048,
-0.9426470399,
0.2149766982,
-0.0464864187,
0.0813687444,
-0.1054618582,
0.7655263543,
0.1659727842,
-0.2964314222,
-0.6401609182,
-0.6674079299,
1.0125023127,
-0.8741781712,
0.2843962312,
-0.1745265275,
0.6077554822,
0.2158988267,
-0.5471359491,
-0.4981436431,
0.0900904238,
0.0413693748,
0.2227665037,
-0.3166596591,
-0.0373291895,
0.1251227707,
0.5939131975,
-0.3474853635,
-0.0978798494,
0.0205886103,
-0.1718081534,
0.6585716605,
0.017124828,
0.3895486295,
-0.6713314652,
-0.342276603,
0.0127501069,
-0.0709950104,
0.3351052701,
0.3647353053,
0.337664634,
0.0296930093,
0.4595870376,
-0.4137819707,
0.5644128323,
-0.3624064028,
0.1518413723,
0.4436274469,
-0.4828191102,
-0.3606364131,
-0.0935596377,
1.0803983212,
0.5307972431,
0.4161290228,
0.112032488,
-0.2774203718,
0.2345370948,
0.2662781179,
-0.3457512558,
0.1338564754,
0.2863492966,
-0.6228593588,
-0.499535352,
0.0518594794,
-1.2919886112,
-0.6762809157,
-0.4849651754,
-0.0494417995,
-0.25632146,
-0.3853182495,
-0.0195463188,
-0.3606042266,
0.6070590019,
0.2611047626,
-0.2309956253,
0.3968437314,
0.7216405272,
1.1232321262,
0.0184260793,
0.2429883927,
-0.1257303059,
-0.4162026048,
-0.3081110716,
0.8976616859,
-0.5103479028,
-0.378813982,
0.398896426,
-0.3991880417,
-0.1188198701,
-0.429084152,
0.8647770286,
-0.5508905649,
0.1816699803,
-0.6540611982,
-0.4021720886,
-0.2590784729,
0.5865429044,
-0.6535317302,
1.159373641,
-0.0074471091,
-1.0028678179,
0.3423144221,
-1.1106938124,
-0.6834276319,
-0.0072023999,
-0.0197294205,
-0.3792929351,
0.3223344088,
0.5375220776,
0.5814734697,
-0.4317797124,
0.079816483,
-0.2897862196,
-0.2965601087,
0.4600492418,
-0.2187256813,
0.8559660912,
0.4880535007,
-0.3053501248,
0.0976355374,
-0.5338277221,
-0.0178928953,
0.0393761359,
0.0811128393,
-0.4113306701,
0.0863547027,
0.2791058719,
0.3859826922,
0.0925694108,
-0.6442624331,
0.0446856432,
-0.5923983455,
0.541519165,
0.549056828,
0.4125819802,
0.431063205,
0.1004305556,
0.777906239,
-0.1763198972,
0.5412955284,
0.218299523,
-0.6121848822,
-0.580835104,
-0.1777407676,
0.279972434,
0.5552588701,
-0.6062821746,
0.4516631961,
-0.3061444759,
-0.3948838413,
-1.0893596411,
-0.0136707611,
-0.1162296385,
0.4481523037,
0.324547261,
-0.2092988491,
-0.6528372765,
-0.8215510845,
-0.7376560569,
-0.0437510051,
0.3300623,
0.0162216444,
0.1106704697,
-0.2900407016,
1.1132459641,
-0.6497250199,
-0.2410753071,
-0.5859338641,
0.4694615602,
-0.0491343401,
-0.1730304211,
0.4998708367,
-0.9220762253,
-0.5815882683,
0.0104001509,
-0.864220202,
-0.0886440352,
-0.0207094569,
0.056613639,
0.6266089082,
0.23744452,
-0.4705225825,
0.4380727112,
0.359189868,
0.0338141322,
0.3604430258,
0.5515697598,
0.3434841633,
-0.9394600391,
0.2900417447,
0.5070192814,
-0.0473393165,
-0.6636407971,
-0.026715707,
-0.319935441,
-0.1258652508,
-0.36203596,
0.4267598689,
-0.2743301988,
-0.1403495073,
-0.3248640299,
-0.0012303325,
-0.0282004625,
0.0600092597,
-0.1627109349,
0.4325809181,
0.4948849082,
-0.3918612301,
0.356737107,
0.0647295192,
-0.3288493156,
0.6054050326,
-0.5103901625,
0.1443086863,
-0.3017427623,
0.2397949696,
-1.1728802919,
-0.0827533603,
0.6455661058,
-0.7484356761,
-0.1402284801,
-0.0607029945,
-0.5242835283,
-0.382021457,
-0.6795451045,
-0.1157214493,
0.4096812904,
-0.1936380267,
0.8120229244,
0.5039358735,
-0.4719470739,
-0.6717085242,
-0.8093242049,
0.3534995317,
-0.3197357357,
-0.564414382,
-0.2105187029,
0.3050090969,
-0.6857391596,
0.0699159577,
-0.1151772812,
-0.1312357932,
0.1444623321,
0.1000569835,
0.3346703649,
0.0361313,
-0.0341008194,
0.1230880395,
-0.1615201682,
0.2596861124,
0.152110219,
0.6488609314,
-0.4796537757,
-0.0878587887,
-0.6455791593,
0.4784539938,
0.5648214817,
-0.3604192138,
0.6701008081,
0.8678807616,
-0.506580174,
-0.0247764196,
-0.685570538,
0.1782410592,
-0.4203348458,
0.0246816371,
0.2461153567,
-0.5203360319,
0.4643485844,
-0.2923892736,
0.1467282325,
0.5133430362,
0.4128996432,
-0.2954742312,
1.0996816158,
0.5234302282,
-0.4072152078,
0.3613196015,
-0.2639914155,
0.7995757461,
-0.3598268926,
-0.2628932893,
-0.737724483,
-0.3436604142,
-0.4611349702,
-0.147088185,
0.0903750509,
-0.1111645624,
0.3616760671,
-0.0771491006,
-0.5277982354,
0.1610452235,
0.309494108,
-0.2191741914,
0.1461213678,
0.0427497812,
0.1385566741,
-0.0936407149,
-0.409655273,
-0.7217117548,
0.4812007248,
0.4768408537,
0.3172642887,
-0.1304691136,
0.8803862333,
0.5163208842,
0.2954397202,
-1.1822445393,
0.6948714256,
-0.2442164719,
-0.2466440499,
-0.2845928669,
-0.5883137584,
-0.6529194713,
0.1797539443,
-0.2444383204,
-0.3803850412,
-0.0025515102,
0.0127713922,
-0.2206277102,
0.166667968,
-0.8613328338,
0.7087337375,
-0.2442318052,
0.0479476228,
-0.1008388251,
-0.6525971293,
0.198263675,
0.2356640697,
0.5317655206,
-0.0177519713,
0.1382662803,
0.7676441669,
0.0308419075,
0.7922413349,
-0.4787043333,
0.0111421878,
0.5125876069,
-0.2508582771,
0.1721030027,
-0.0521565825,
-0.3692264557,
0.2013632357,
0.120467782,
-0.3660288751,
-0.5528606772,
0.7467141151,
-0.503467679,
-0.0145593891,
-0.7060989738,
-0.02511633,
-0.5861608386,
-0.1452768147,
0.1208762974,
0.0600162633,
-0.4547605515,
-0.0867907405,
0.3337555826,
-0.2131810337,
0.6253193617,
-0.064257592,
0.0481406599,
-0.4249797761,
1.0037049055,
0.2075971067,
-0.0577897243,
0.2106849104,
0.3801625669,
-0.5256937742,
-0.452409029,
-0.1964526772,
0.096799545,
-0.8463349342,
-0.0804855824,
-0.6628651023,
0.0155551592,
-0.8060991764,
-0.0888522863,
-0.2304699272,
-0.3164856434,
-0.1577347368,
-0.109574005,
0.3608863056,
0.6746321917,
0.1021860465,
0.2657499313,
-0.9115778804,
0.3322755992,
-0.0520399511,
0.4601783156,
0.2633499801,
0.2871602774,
0.0119362734,
-0.0269958228,
-0.0444654785,
-1.0758171082,
0.4871042967,
-0.081772007,
0.4090098441,
0.3905363083,
0.1182763875,
0.5620654225,
0.0980738625,
0.950450778,
0.1905822307,
-0.9847327471,
0.5895828009,
-0.0706785545,
0.1565045267,
1.0048811436,
0.5545325279,
-1.04220891,
-0.0750088841,
-0.4847954512,
-1.114580512,
0.3288590014,
0.1219266802,
0.0600905009,
-0.1031694114,
0.2865326405,
0.0310685225,
0.420848906,
-0.4267544746,
-0.1568156332,
-0.1286477298,
-0.550773561,
0.0847069174,
-0.0424363352,
0.0176994056,
-0.1699670702,
0.4726794958,
-0.054455474,
0.2379135638,
0.1105918884,
-0.2857055664,
0.0582613312,
0.4968973994,
0.0928022638,
0.4531654716,
-0.0993760154,
-0.1986479163,
0.116198808,
-0.26043275,
-0.3284213245,
-0.0051060435,
-0.2382580191,
0.2464643866,
0.0827377439,
0.5187243223,
0.0631565079,
-0.6019132733,
0.6295181513,
-0.2444990128,
-0.0976629704,
-0.3484249711,
-0.3576022685,
0.0101828286,
-0.0495356545,
0.3977640867,
0.3991499841,
0.6000916362,
-0.6583999395,
-0.1532161832,
0.5300167203,
-0.7345892191,
-0.2458869666,
-0.0969911367,
0.343664676,
-0.1898445934,
0.5023747087,
-0.1974917054,
-0.6349310279,
0.367417872,
-0.0336013809,
1.0988907814,
0.0141383568,
0.5982563496,
0.0831544399,
0.270517379,
-0.0887547657,
0.4851362109,
0.1636463255,
-0.5305882692,
-0.6520515084,
-0.7428295016,
-0.5110230446,
-0.1557939053,
-0.9208692908,
0.2460694611,
-0.538261652,
-0.4022756517,
0.0158108529,
0.0861432478,
-0.7138380408,
0.2896426022,
0.098754935,
0.916234076,
-1.0314136744,
0.2348340452,
1.0185940266,
-0.332362324,
-0.3399866521,
0.2407497466,
0.3176051974,
-0.4233674109,
0.0956801176,
0.3548606932,
-0.454436034,
-0.383438617,
-0.6748802066,
-0.2365047336,
0.5663866401,
-0.0483924523,
-0.1920564026,
0.1778093576,
0.2006265074,
0.9659976959,
-0.0497019626,
0.0180801861,
0.8231634498,
0.5255632997,
0.0019716709,
-0.4651098549,
-0.0881079584,
-0.4352250099,
-0.1855075061,
0.3147491813,
-0.5835024714,
0.3315253556,
0.3043613136,
-0.3358041942,
-0.2805071175,
0.4917655587,
-0.0444582663,
0.7516215444,
0.6603358388,
0.3780870736,
0.8245777488,
-0.1159557253,
1.105943799,
-0.1103892177,
0.3724806309,
0.3712867796,
-0.4887264967,
0.8183585405,
0.576151967,
-0.123392731,
0.5434893966,
0.4596028626,
0.0127464328,
0.1869044602,
0.1585955173,
-0.2466436028,
-0.0655130967,
-0.1355129629,
-0.1804343462,
0.4359582365,
0.4865610898,
-0.0470427424,
-0.1593559533,
0.0928700045,
-0.0794184506,
0.2188210338,
-0.2913790047,
0.9466859698,
0.0920080096,
-0.3337867856,
-0.1074103341,
0.0797229484,
0.8750566244,
-0.5678491592,
0.1362310052,
0.0032695893,
0.028339522,
-0.4078380764,
-0.8213005066,
0.6342395544,
0.1644532084,
0.2180258483,
-0.3296755552,
1.0841645002,
0.2935853601,
-0.506870389,
0.3830746114,
0.5690947771,
-0.0449864827,
-0.2665508986,
-0.9694488645,
0.2220276445,
-0.0293349419,
-0.3166861832,
0.2121248841,
0.4126123786,
0.0342904106,
0.5885446668,
0.6683573127,
0.2083602697,
-0.0373023711,
0.5715896487,
0.6612920165,
-1.0165143013,
-0.6252408624,
-0.8518995643,
0.4486319125,
-0.6058884859,
-0.4032289684,
0.9452738166,
0.3289359808,
0.4679290354,
0.0355298333,
1.0450925827,
-0.0684789494,
0.8014051914,
-0.3089912534,
0.5456973314,
-0.324378401,
0.2888183892,
-0.5958923101,
-0.7865274549,
-0.5707625747,
0.6298581958,
-0.4852059186,
-0.0994228274,
0.3871157765,
0.3547581732,
0.3780822754,
0.6439728737,
-0.3387435973,
-0.045392856,
0.2821270525,
-0.2413469106,
1.0463119745,
-0.2203054428,
0.437030226,
-0.3420655727,
-0.2128421366,
-0.2784397304,
-0.6974747181,
-0.6255011559,
-0.3089798391,
-0.2929771543,
-0.2456739396,
-0.0429297984,
1.0554485321,
0.2496001422,
-0.8600556254,
-0.1504997015,
0.0374975018,
0.0613192543,
-0.3763217926,
-0.4058521986,
0.1792846769,
-0.6298939586,
-0.5126878619,
0.174581781,
0.260061413,
-0.2312035859,
-0.1335126758,
0.2369553894,
-0.2927746177,
0.1783870906,
0.8627508283,
0.2109216005,
-0.4964253604,
-0.0500261784,
0.3345184922,
-0.1115022004,
0.0845631137,
0.934253931,
-0.4613998532,
0.3287023604,
0.7739630938,
0.8037217259,
0.1189249456,
0.1936286241,
0.3800595701,
-0.7269967198,
-0.2851754427,
0.6215326786,
0.2697583735,
0.6963083744,
-0.3487118483,
0.3194224238,
0.0718294233,
-0.2643820345,
-0.8705293536,
-0.0125566069,
-1.2542206049,
-0.5229655504,
1.152562499,
0.3368925452,
-0.1287824363,
-0.279502362,
-0.462590754,
0.3727423251,
-0.6725763679,
0.8444088101,
0.7740847468,
-0.2905756831,
0.0724487156,
-0.5290343165,
0.4682912529,
0.25539729,
-0.9076839089,
-0.0316205621,
0.3244652152,
0.1045264229,
0.1948418319,
0.7043508291,
-0.2954237759,
-0.0164415054,
-0.5442326665,
0.0453735217,
0.3910869062,
-0.0903435946,
-0.7521826625,
0.4758557677,
-0.0558261201,
-0.1661680639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14839v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14839v2 | PaCE: Unified Multi-modal Dialogue Pre-training with Progressive and Compositional Experts | 2023-05-24T07:43:29 | 2023-06-13T06:31:46 | Yunshui Li, Binyuan Hui, ZhiChao Yin, Min Yang, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Perceiving multi-modal information and fulfilling dialogues with humans is a
long-term goal of artificial intelligence. Pre-training is commonly regarded as
an effective approach for multi-modal dialogue. However, due to the limited
availability of multi-modal dialogue data, there is still scarce research on
multi-modal dialogue pre-training. Yet another intriguing challenge emerges
from the encompassing nature of multi-modal dialogue, which involves various
modalities and tasks. Moreover, new forms of tasks may arise at unpredictable
points in the future. Hence, it is essential for designed multi-modal dialogue
models to possess sufficient flexibility to adapt to such scenarios. This paper
proposes \textbf{PaCE}, a unified, structured, compositional multi-modal
dialogue pre-training framework. It utilizes a combination of several
fundamental experts to accommodate multiple dialogue-related tasks and can be
pre-trained using limited dialogue and extensive non-dialogue multi-modal data.
Furthermore, we propose a progressive training method where old experts from
the past can assist new experts, facilitating the expansion of their
capabilities. Experimental results demonstrate that PaCE achieves
state-of-the-art results on eight multi-modal dialog benchmarks. | [
-0.4770417511,
-0.6191174388,
0.7873955965,
0.4313976169,
-0.2658770978,
0.2824026346,
-0.3208693564,
-0.2107881755,
0.1779356897,
0.0785503164,
-1.0361808538,
-0.3581303954,
-0.3299087286,
0.0837449655,
0.0747026056,
0.7944417,
0.0812132657,
0.5064889789,
-0.0174861997,
-0.2455652654,
-0.8195689917,
-0.3089178503,
-0.6165865064,
-0.1535183489,
0.3567517698,
0.3074264526,
0.5618720651,
0.2831695974,
0.1758479923,
0.3752788305,
0.2039414942,
0.1693252325,
-0.3373688459,
0.4286346436,
0.1149012372,
-0.1432559937,
-0.7016211748,
0.241940245,
0.6403009295,
0.5661278367,
-0.1821228713,
-0.1174010709,
-0.3028577268,
0.3875907958,
-0.4419677854,
-0.079829216,
-0.3928040266,
-0.0106561584,
-0.1901100278,
-0.3453074992,
-0.317242682,
-0.0081298621,
0.2254382968,
-0.8045571446,
-0.0214799456,
0.0068798307,
0.2766631842,
0.3595055938,
-0.3443992734,
0.0761803463,
-0.9250549078,
0.6078676581,
-0.4750141501,
0.5845218301,
0.1050552726,
0.289149642,
-0.1985441744,
-0.6643537283,
-0.5962494612,
-0.3780549467,
0.4536198974,
0.245840013,
0.2018444389,
0.3722635806,
0.0874175653,
0.4115603566,
-0.3708491027,
-0.0149596548,
-0.0111459168,
-0.2684762478,
0.5173084736,
0.4221689105,
0.0427298583,
0.346839875,
-0.554258287,
0.0666955113,
-0.2461109161,
0.2494765222,
0.4108827412,
0.068701379,
-0.1476502717,
0.1214882806,
-0.5643040538,
0.7956807017,
0.3797495961,
-0.5414717793,
0.3629338443,
-0.7912811637,
-0.0557647385,
-0.0331501961,
1.0049217939,
0.2595663369,
0.0396566018,
-0.2229847759,
-0.0348798968,
-0.1561995447,
0.410050869,
-0.6115864515,
-0.1600350887,
-0.0104153492,
-0.2918919623,
0.0102952104,
-0.0364972427,
-0.8667233586,
-0.1086132601,
-0.5656192303,
0.5427994728,
-0.4294895232,
-0.3405041397,
0.231262669,
0.0624483228,
0.1077296063,
0.7412533164,
-0.6788440943,
-0.0303675719,
0.296756357,
0.6649866104,
0.0196719039,
-0.5966795683,
-0.5460614562,
0.1443323493,
-0.113946192,
0.8872596025,
-1.050204277,
-0.7612443566,
-0.366127491,
-0.1811074466,
-0.2785093784,
-0.0035520368,
0.5363819599,
-0.2656908035,
0.3961068392,
-0.0723640472,
-0.1805215627,
0.0675768703,
0.3044752777,
-0.5050629377,
0.7967042923,
0.0990144238,
-0.62048769,
0.2731502354,
-0.8815270662,
-0.5559438467,
-0.0526133962,
-0.3156315982,
-0.1456320882,
0.2043112516,
0.2054104656,
0.1118751094,
-0.3904469907,
0.3663881421,
-0.2182101756,
-0.3057301342,
0.0458221659,
-0.724798739,
0.3070379198,
0.1538808197,
-0.2501318455,
0.5038461089,
-0.7848896384,
0.138938874,
-0.2657601833,
-0.3670239747,
-0.045802068,
-0.1959113628,
-0.217858538,
0.3648400307,
0.1650982201,
-0.499917239,
0.2680155933,
-0.070614934,
0.1572483331,
0.8106384277,
0.0665881932,
0.5617219806,
-0.5604350567,
0.7423084974,
0.0088062743,
0.4570219219,
-0.6916632652,
-0.6369193792,
-0.5964260697,
-0.3679115772,
0.013790668,
0.6360474825,
-0.6062986851,
0.5371785164,
-0.1551437974,
-0.5301911831,
-0.5842733383,
0.0819660276,
0.3691912591,
0.5060479641,
0.4286539853,
-0.7602480054,
-0.4154366553,
-0.4672980011,
-0.3033782244,
-0.1025548056,
-0.0285527892,
0.2816484571,
0.1377617419,
-0.2457450777,
0.9729453325,
-0.1279029995,
-0.0680492967,
-0.2590513527,
0.4793085158,
-0.0952469409,
0.6519442797,
0.037369553,
-0.8671178222,
-0.5229452848,
-0.4484322965,
-0.375079155,
0.1782689244,
-0.4593118429,
-0.2443791628,
-0.2683702111,
0.5345922112,
-0.8102814555,
0.2694610655,
0.4414668977,
-0.2134080827,
0.8151476979,
-0.228202492,
0.5402259231,
-1.2431367636,
-0.0103249243,
-0.1488087326,
-0.1429488212,
-0.7943280935,
-0.4805689454,
-0.2988966107,
-0.2540943921,
-0.4604705274,
0.5059534311,
-0.3401618302,
0.2031506002,
-0.0087148957,
-0.116961658,
-0.0247296188,
0.6856512427,
0.1733794808,
0.8802674413,
0.6478036046,
-0.6169787049,
0.3791818321,
0.4058469832,
-0.3228582144,
0.9194298387,
-0.5752602816,
0.4590797424,
-0.0363409221,
0.5725588202,
-0.9057551026,
-0.2649066448,
0.058679644,
-0.3577762246,
0.3414297402,
0.107392095,
-0.0881965309,
-0.3187438846,
-0.2462558299,
0.703448534,
0.4190633893,
0.0876467302,
1.003939867,
0.1469792873,
-0.3275950849,
-0.4890953898,
-0.0134479282,
-0.0667162463,
-0.153218016,
-0.5652599931,
0.3699205816,
-0.7334282398,
-0.0866474286,
-0.4202216268,
-0.2733165622,
-0.2471252829,
-0.0173107963,
0.4323271513,
0.1309053302,
-0.2003406435,
0.0455978476,
-0.0373382829,
-0.2656491697,
-0.0657812878,
-0.2222007811,
0.729290843,
-0.1028495952,
-0.4875243604,
-0.8902743459,
0.568377018,
0.9287523627,
-0.5386640429,
0.4390641153,
0.8702919483,
0.1861301661,
0.3066029847,
-0.807836771,
-0.0613335669,
-0.4285904169,
0.2386749089,
-0.4359291494,
-0.8516440988,
0.1550970227,
-0.6699057817,
0.0449939668,
0.1674346328,
0.7484884858,
-0.0777966231,
1.0817342997,
0.8482732773,
-0.067653656,
0.8385562897,
0.0064169266,
0.0568274744,
-0.9631635547,
-0.6205453277,
-0.3591727316,
-0.2952562571,
0.1132003143,
-0.6147661805,
0.5395203233,
0.1304099262,
-0.3573183417,
0.0301184785,
-0.2296331525,
0.3693808019,
0.5791743994,
0.1396609992,
0.3161614239,
-0.404188931,
-0.0567067042,
0.1518079787,
-0.4682012498,
-0.0615149662,
1.1463242769,
0.1433950365,
0.7848453522,
-0.1371310949,
0.4543548524,
0.3293108642,
0.0556366295,
-0.7063362002,
0.4972067773,
0.2757543325,
-0.5387727618,
-0.4106524885,
-0.2732833922,
-0.6166277528,
-0.1025608331,
-0.2481691688,
-0.4571818411,
0.1305122524,
0.1726299673,
-0.8080973029,
0.0723413751,
-0.3351014256,
1.0330036879,
-0.3991482556,
-0.1338730156,
-0.2999300063,
-1.2884545326,
0.1841448992,
-0.2277190983,
0.1868333966,
-0.3195825815,
0.1454752088,
0.6086235642,
-0.1204470247,
0.7820922136,
-0.299369514,
0.1614900231,
0.366892159,
-0.0707459748,
0.2797491848,
0.256755054,
0.2610346675,
-0.0208942629,
-0.3821546137,
-0.353705436,
-0.3936000168,
0.1692495793,
-0.7631546259,
-0.5892772675,
-0.1004938111,
-0.7448877692,
-0.6402134299,
0.238822341,
0.3707053363,
0.7315813303,
-0.5779880881,
-0.0153542515,
0.761691153,
0.197409749,
0.5031930208,
0.7072544098,
0.4117657542,
-0.4816685319,
0.4918974638,
-0.5206010938,
0.372425437,
0.3758498728,
0.0934390873,
-0.288321197,
-0.6186237931,
-0.5453978181,
-0.1652650535,
-0.2920594513,
-0.1717650592,
-0.8594904542,
0.0917741582,
-0.3434958756,
-0.1325134039,
-0.4953344762,
-0.2245539129,
-0.3145654202,
0.2393711507,
0.1424654573,
0.5470577478,
-0.1492188722,
0.5334687829,
-0.9924478531,
0.4706937671,
0.7113765478,
0.2135594338,
-0.2444585413,
-0.5081318617,
-0.243901059,
0.1912405193,
-0.4480115771,
-0.68396312,
-0.0343335979,
0.5532776713,
0.7988586426,
0.5975260735,
0.0210111309,
0.8019820452,
-0.9771655202,
0.9372128248,
0.5751317739,
-0.884095788,
0.677626431,
-0.3323341906,
0.40358302,
1.0809568167,
0.5841370225,
-0.4128375649,
-0.2487583011,
-0.4356311858,
-0.5124710202,
0.5099431872,
-0.2413970083,
0.192708075,
0.0323627405,
0.1475487351,
0.3791710734,
0.5026746988,
-0.2136862129,
-0.0328756757,
-0.5361042619,
-0.2354923934,
-0.1331692189,
0.0028965108,
-0.391063422,
-0.4075572789,
0.3536473811,
-0.1925525963,
0.4298789203,
0.1740181595,
-0.1434050649,
-0.0914994404,
0.4647318125,
0.9034340978,
0.8075435758,
-0.1214466169,
-0.2342363447,
0.0562108271,
-0.5163251758,
0.5323856473,
0.1613144279,
0.2485428751,
-0.1125121415,
0.2359808683,
1.0413480997,
0.3945662677,
-0.7139506936,
0.5703607798,
-0.2180638164,
0.0085015176,
-0.3859991133,
0.0454897769,
-0.2767608762,
0.5375562906,
0.2444376796,
0.630213201,
-0.0279381014,
-0.758607924,
0.2761929333,
0.2720650733,
-0.3247766495,
-0.6973759532,
0.8079581857,
0.6161836386,
-0.6258402467,
0.5650416613,
-0.25593853,
-0.5324091911,
-0.0110629275,
0.3706230819,
1.0475878716,
-0.5747978687,
0.2642801702,
0.0701520443,
-0.2383912355,
-0.3409402072,
0.2907680273,
-0.4045485556,
-0.7830216289,
-0.5954148173,
-0.6536755562,
-0.5011562109,
-0.0550527535,
-0.6033196449,
-0.0611821786,
-0.3388476074,
-0.3902625144,
-0.312934041,
-0.1998393983,
-0.8307238221,
0.1472222507,
0.1230349466,
0.9288147688,
-0.7089168429,
0.8118284941,
0.6676563025,
-0.4075673521,
-0.6412166953,
0.2202060372,
0.1119439229,
-0.7463997006,
0.474609822,
0.2589112818,
-0.3801390231,
0.1454481781,
-0.3364444077,
-0.6043244004,
1.1687169075,
0.2902766168,
-0.5413877368,
-0.4387725294,
-0.3427222967,
0.2656675875,
-0.6713126302,
0.31068784,
0.5376798511,
0.5142428279,
0.2601709664,
-1.2285078764,
-0.2295593917,
-0.3379946351,
-0.257224679,
0.117909804,
-0.7467519045,
1.1079124212,
-0.1990831643,
-0.0630200133,
0.4279879928,
0.7437744141,
0.0494222306,
0.3841461539,
0.7033265233,
0.615691483,
0.6927404404,
0.0066703972,
0.7987750173,
-0.6443158388,
-0.0838093087,
1.2340322733,
-0.3121012151,
0.5077650547,
0.1814318746,
-0.0591099858,
0.8253825307,
0.500416398,
0.164184764,
0.6296716928,
-0.2190098166,
-0.7678928971,
-0.7184464335,
-0.1888611466,
-0.4220655859,
0.5665564537,
0.2637347877,
0.006897497,
-0.0753743574,
0.1164756343,
-0.0400192514,
-0.0416055545,
-0.362598896,
0.9102042317,
-0.2930292189,
-0.6034864783,
0.3812806904,
-0.3035306633,
0.7239008546,
-1.0104529858,
0.0433966592,
-0.0540059693,
-0.1661928147,
0.1601428986,
-0.4003293216,
-0.2202926874,
-0.319278717,
-0.1297470033,
-0.3130690753,
0.3664193451,
-0.5860080123,
-0.145891428,
-0.0127405291,
0.9283689857,
0.1571535617,
-0.336278528,
-0.7017634511,
-0.0432924144,
-0.1192702278,
-0.1720785797,
0.3288939297,
0.6781084538,
0.1956635714,
0.4239022136,
0.5606400371,
-0.0795076638,
0.0693736374,
0.237397179,
1.1179974079,
-0.6962154508,
-0.5974154472,
-0.6752815843,
0.8232135773,
-0.0464890637,
-0.6131139994,
0.5781932473,
0.3557758033,
0.6054835916,
0.0214855559,
0.6002933383,
0.0314189829,
0.2879335284,
-0.6142683029,
0.3157372177,
-0.3824050725,
-0.2610454857,
-0.1487867832,
-0.982658565,
0.0739945471,
0.5893106461,
0.0126867155,
0.3118084371,
0.8062359691,
0.396990329,
0.0571153052,
0.2120952755,
0.3104972541,
0.0042712772,
0.3095113337,
0.7331690192,
1.0683598518,
0.1591186225,
0.4294137955,
-0.1021171063,
-0.3393604457,
-0.1011733562,
-0.7386264801,
-1.0587574244,
-0.5902304649,
0.0166498031,
0.0570498332,
-0.0168311726,
1.159484148,
0.9298205376,
-0.4334970713,
0.0278391335,
-0.09602613,
-0.3489270806,
-0.1999386996,
-0.0946815684,
0.0169920828,
-0.5962806344,
-0.658883512,
1.1987684965,
0.5296349525,
0.2534860075,
-0.4423832297,
-0.303273648,
-0.1184735671,
0.1244476512,
0.4147039056,
0.3809627593,
-0.4664232135,
-0.3286215663,
0.0128438231,
0.3261992335,
0.3014833629,
1.418820262,
-0.8880120516,
0.7342059612,
0.2293605655,
0.6710775495,
0.2599106729,
0.2550786734,
0.8181216121,
-0.6750302911,
0.3988656104,
0.506118834,
0.1295837015,
0.1655273736,
-0.1031781957,
0.2647311389,
0.4687538147,
-0.7330534458,
-0.5888333321,
0.6248486638,
-1.1936575174,
0.0154167311,
0.8013260961,
-0.2578993142,
0.2374204993,
-0.4676302969,
-0.2943322659,
0.2261485457,
-0.6866816282,
0.4916187525,
0.5049557686,
-0.4752566814,
-0.027623659,
-0.4012543261,
0.6448909044,
0.2981139421,
-0.7949616313,
-0.2022108287,
0.5551204681,
0.1059518605,
0.356787473,
1.1964328289,
0.1683998108,
0.3312016129,
0.132995531,
-0.1546984166,
-0.2923639119,
-0.9247572422,
-0.1602050811,
0.0999752507,
-0.1436951607,
-0.0618015826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14838v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14838v2 | ComSL: A Composite Speech-Language Model for End-to-End Speech-to-Text Translation | 2023-05-24T07:42:15 | 2023-10-14T08:47:43 | Chenyang Le, Yao Qian, Long Zhou, Shujie Liu, Yanmin Qian, Michael Zeng, Xuedong Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Joint speech-language training is challenging due to the large demand for
training data and GPU consumption, as well as the modality gap between speech
and language. We present ComSL, a speech-language model built atop a composite
architecture of public pretrained speech-only and language-only models and
optimized data-efficiently for spoken language tasks. Particularly, we propose
to incorporate cross-modality learning into transfer learning and conduct them
simultaneously for downstream tasks in a multi-task learning manner. Our
approach has demonstrated effectiveness in end-to-end speech-to-text
translation tasks, achieving a new state-of-the-art average BLEU score of 31.5
on the multilingual speech to English text translation task for 21 languages,
as measured on the public CoVoST2 evaluation set. | [
-0.1079858914,
-0.6214502454,
0.0662855357,
0.0235470086,
-0.5497691035,
0.2049600333,
-0.4908125699,
-0.3980065584,
-0.0219520442,
0.2538006902,
-0.4912520051,
-0.3356055915,
-0.5871064067,
-0.0055525308,
-0.4341859519,
1.068130374,
0.164513126,
0.2753332555,
-0.1846019924,
-0.0250239372,
-0.5492658019,
-0.6584327221,
-0.6701202989,
-0.2290526181,
0.3433940709,
0.3004289865,
0.5200445056,
0.3006507158,
0.328882575,
0.1764876097,
0.1907258481,
0.1447991133,
-0.5758947134,
0.0300074257,
-0.3403137922,
-0.5383132696,
-0.6314947009,
0.1249105334,
0.6918612719,
1.0323320627,
-0.2313201129,
0.2621184886,
0.049861636,
0.3520738184,
-0.6918864846,
0.1990990043,
-0.4918222427,
-0.0957514346,
-0.3232441247,
-0.1940691322,
-0.8759422898,
0.0956184119,
0.1836912632,
-0.7396121621,
-0.0315685011,
0.1039338931,
0.3759930134,
0.2961238325,
-0.6131545305,
-0.1963724792,
-0.6272130013,
1.0671559572,
-0.2159820497,
1.2507933378,
0.3423155248,
0.3473544419,
0.2367922962,
-0.7982459068,
-0.4666770101,
-0.337929666,
-0.0745059699,
0.4846473038,
-0.163631171,
-0.0387085676,
-0.1545202732,
0.0845779255,
-1.1377151012,
-0.1118129343,
-0.3098593354,
-0.115322195,
0.6194397807,
0.1227458045,
0.4082110822,
0.1121812314,
-0.554020822,
-0.1844160855,
-0.6842244864,
0.284318924,
-0.0596802644,
0.5453073382,
-0.7227056623,
0.2152628005,
0.0202996098,
0.8629106879,
-0.0979298577,
-0.0692106634,
0.2994556725,
-0.6467930675,
-0.3882196546,
0.1907322556,
0.5686299801,
-0.0154224178,
-0.0296621658,
-0.5841056705,
-0.2016089559,
0.2421462983,
-0.102350235,
-0.2599484622,
0.0646824762,
-0.1116687953,
-0.4237954319,
0.018401688,
-0.099705644,
-0.2523303926,
0.2399577498,
-0.6885412931,
0.2964113951,
-0.0311835967,
-0.1779441684,
0.1297920048,
0.0761480331,
0.1241188422,
0.5237567425,
-0.6667222381,
0.7057173848,
0.5850464702,
0.7464202642,
-0.6065066457,
-0.4320871532,
-1.0416293144,
0.6262909174,
-0.2929151356,
0.4785685539,
-0.7885427475,
-0.3052677214,
-0.0797341391,
-0.0056911455,
-0.4353681803,
-0.2065677196,
0.623136878,
-0.2867019773,
0.3756718636,
-0.0063955961,
-0.3043847084,
-0.064779453,
-0.0293402765,
-0.5466905832,
0.8636491299,
0.0393472537,
-0.2683708668,
0.0499280542,
-0.3523062468,
-0.7792313695,
0.173196137,
-0.3529346585,
-0.1124440879,
0.1813605875,
-0.0269429311,
0.4369541407,
-0.9791132808,
0.5002617836,
0.0982144699,
-0.2609183192,
0.4088068008,
-0.7342787981,
0.806294024,
0.3546585143,
-0.103063561,
0.0273461975,
-0.8442746401,
-0.1525273621,
-0.268091321,
-0.4689613283,
-0.3742834032,
-0.0729217827,
0.5696167946,
0.3514343798,
0.3987029493,
-0.6249468923,
-0.1446822137,
-0.1841376424,
0.3999812901,
0.2936332226,
-0.5800765753,
0.4345667064,
-0.5897069573,
0.3466203511,
0.0734893531,
0.1586050093,
-0.1839015782,
-0.4420919418,
-0.6011918187,
-0.2533486485,
0.2221212238,
0.6295947433,
-0.6033934951,
0.4599429369,
-0.4831310511,
-0.3608728945,
-0.4847359061,
-0.0913350359,
0.6407769918,
0.4619330466,
0.5354683399,
-0.4332425594,
-0.3582191765,
-0.4198120534,
0.0094186962,
0.0302178413,
0.2353168279,
0.0518181548,
0.2138022631,
-0.0158734117,
0.6202280521,
-0.0354742594,
-0.4611541629,
-0.3605098426,
0.2510761321,
-0.0810391232,
0.4811390042,
0.1774901748,
-0.8802713752,
-0.7976638079,
0.3690355718,
-0.4668983817,
-0.1170433462,
-0.333322674,
0.1949510723,
0.2684035003,
0.5092417002,
-0.6375607252,
0.102730602,
0.9777053595,
-0.1532935649,
0.3820962608,
-0.2190548182,
0.0907223672,
-1.2047787905,
0.4677594304,
-0.1133179292,
-0.6669409275,
-0.7261940241,
0.0142115941,
-0.22867167,
-0.5118729472,
-0.6222826838,
0.5249778628,
-0.4811117947,
-0.2034851909,
-0.066983521,
0.3236449063,
-0.237259239,
0.5066378117,
0.1615057737,
0.9816783667,
0.7617430687,
-0.3886865675,
0.4167590141,
0.4394997954,
-0.0505493358,
0.5465177298,
-0.40276438,
0.2772088051,
0.1073792204,
0.5153036714,
-0.9269337654,
-0.143708542,
0.1472247392,
-0.5180920362,
0.3778227866,
0.1807930022,
-0.0891379341,
0.3745569587,
0.135802567,
0.7122499347,
0.4113461971,
-0.3339020908,
0.6523942351,
0.3795513809,
-0.2783270478,
-0.4793572724,
-0.8620958924,
0.2596775591,
0.3605160415,
-0.5117591023,
0.7135107517,
-0.1079795659,
0.1678676009,
-0.04105426,
0.0866708979,
-0.349355489,
-0.1325205714,
-0.0211983528,
0.0699365363,
-0.065905422,
0.0285269581,
0.1309744567,
-0.3684216142,
-0.0836639479,
-0.1504177749,
0.6366639137,
0.1939619929,
-0.4865209162,
-0.5201472044,
0.7503572106,
0.7552582026,
-0.5317509174,
0.2092913985,
0.3932978511,
-0.243095994,
-0.1774980426,
-0.1867186129,
0.1592097878,
-0.3643077612,
0.5863887072,
-0.5601840615,
-0.7277103662,
0.2454412729,
0.0134191634,
0.034669105,
-0.0077638486,
0.7610369325,
0.1615718603,
0.9196766019,
0.4022529125,
-0.0621216111,
0.4258536398,
-0.0281436369,
0.1631460339,
-0.6274631023,
-0.3812891245,
-0.3830204308,
0.025769487,
-0.4884627461,
-0.783313632,
0.3007548749,
-0.1700296551,
-0.0097551318,
0.5040929317,
-0.1701354235,
0.0510280505,
0.4516681731,
0.2641255856,
0.4827023149,
0.0549690053,
0.1469289213,
0.04872844,
-0.7578659058,
-0.0982210934,
0.8383082151,
0.1943093538,
0.8940137625,
0.2091477215,
0.5528029203,
0.3782347739,
0.0330003351,
-0.6734655499,
0.5606234074,
-0.7040837407,
-0.4438782036,
-0.4102387726,
-0.3825375736,
-0.7348085642,
0.2805791497,
-0.1888806522,
-0.4006770849,
0.1300379485,
0.0922579616,
-0.0603864975,
-0.1846473366,
-0.4395200312,
0.7716940641,
-0.4446078539,
-0.5211648345,
-0.6971292496,
-0.8961160779,
0.0436846279,
-0.2631927431,
0.4475418925,
0.1296333522,
-0.2469008416,
0.5115875602,
-0.0393603109,
0.9575166106,
0.1249853,
-0.0278671458,
0.1280212849,
-0.1180584729,
0.5451218486,
-0.2234144509,
0.1238436028,
0.1917857975,
-0.0441357531,
-0.3846731484,
-0.5452768803,
0.4051335752,
-0.8864548802,
-0.1672203094,
-0.5126851797,
-0.7933952212,
-0.1871288866,
-0.0542559028,
0.273475647,
0.6650997996,
-0.3277423978,
0.2958926558,
0.5753298402,
-0.2232206464,
0.4541651309,
0.6213204861,
0.1933386773,
-0.6458795071,
1.2491742373,
0.1004557163,
0.5416987538,
0.7477765679,
0.0423573032,
-0.423728615,
-0.4161544144,
-0.5238904357,
0.1600653976,
-0.5619472265,
-0.0037145198,
-0.4177376926,
-0.2365682274,
-0.5599772334,
-0.2033901662,
-0.5159811974,
-0.3627226949,
-0.3133159876,
0.3489249051,
-0.4711019099,
0.4335199594,
-0.1423679292,
0.372315228,
-1.0091056824,
0.3159414828,
0.2952851057,
0.0343898386,
-0.2407742888,
-0.7805064917,
-0.4298273921,
-0.037814036,
-0.0846596137,
-0.801130414,
0.3285278082,
0.523527205,
0.7249954939,
-0.0447995849,
-0.041903805,
0.5984181166,
-0.5048034787,
0.7081742287,
0.8751211166,
-1.1613925695,
0.1153973415,
-0.2288703173,
0.207240656,
0.3937160671,
0.3780384362,
-0.8485030532,
-0.1509666592,
-0.2011732012,
-0.5633776188,
0.693582058,
0.1980842948,
0.183062464,
0.0726151392,
-0.0616900846,
0.2032403201,
0.1803010255,
-0.9355561733,
-0.2475913018,
-0.0074646948,
-0.42304492,
-0.1461559832,
0.0615929961,
-0.0834021941,
-0.3423342705,
0.6759625673,
-0.1646559834,
0.2988179326,
0.0659918264,
-0.6118000746,
-0.2108253241,
0.4594819844,
0.7775700688,
0.5547452569,
0.0120861428,
0.1289976686,
0.2057324499,
-0.4513924122,
0.4127681553,
0.270118475,
0.0269145612,
-0.0415215418,
0.4179138243,
0.9742436409,
0.4854232073,
-0.6663689613,
0.8488199115,
0.0727348104,
-0.1493813396,
-0.1577421725,
-0.2386363745,
-0.1029663458,
0.1460793614,
0.3089744449,
0.0518242531,
0.1566420048,
-0.7260462642,
0.4674085081,
0.3356829882,
-0.5388646722,
-0.6223478317,
0.6822429299,
0.6264448762,
-0.2659110427,
0.1124455705,
-0.018364327,
-0.3084615469,
0.022820076,
0.8637295365,
0.8416660428,
-0.4861457348,
0.2608052194,
0.0476035178,
0.1265295595,
-0.0544796474,
0.4382325113,
-0.2426265776,
-0.2282252312,
-0.9768255353,
-0.5557306409,
-0.4791710973,
0.0108242426,
-0.6712670326,
0.6175365448,
-0.0053473138,
0.1512265801,
-0.1979848593,
-0.3152902722,
-0.5256758332,
0.5521610975,
0.5359146595,
0.8848832846,
-1.1772915125,
1.1733783484,
0.9343717694,
-0.5161473155,
-0.5888956189,
-0.2813369334,
-0.3903698623,
-0.6089849472,
0.9507243633,
-0.1065992787,
-0.2608897686,
0.2913418114,
-0.2335806787,
-1.1207739115,
0.9341867566,
0.8437180519,
-0.971408546,
-0.3325847983,
0.6788374782,
0.3475102782,
-0.3180971742,
0.2022387087,
0.2747457325,
0.0830577686,
0.0638246387,
-1.187207818,
0.0038423249,
0.0880566835,
-0.2538000047,
0.1181856468,
-0.8150523901,
1.0024501085,
0.254701972,
-0.1571923494,
-0.1770658046,
0.65617311,
0.1244579479,
0.4158764482,
0.5439319611,
0.6211286187,
0.6087097526,
0.1775961369,
0.7061094642,
-0.5516443253,
0.4002444744,
1.3729600906,
-0.3681569993,
0.9411787987,
0.4442768395,
0.0553533509,
0.1491779983,
0.2868260443,
0.3751336038,
0.8691936135,
-0.0636279136,
-0.5509851575,
-0.6677334905,
-0.3930054903,
-0.2699716091,
0.7448191643,
0.2694017589,
-0.2122620791,
-0.5600576997,
0.3855672479,
-0.4396235049,
0.1750832796,
-0.055250369,
0.5437873602,
0.2675216794,
-0.6145473123,
0.5586799383,
-0.1557383239,
0.4425449073,
-0.6228283644,
-0.2569873631,
0.0037905304,
-0.1118366048,
-0.1047216728,
-0.3902222216,
0.3117800653,
-0.1671210676,
-0.0412648767,
-0.3661765754,
0.5590087175,
-0.9207937717,
-0.1894952506,
0.4465577304,
0.6977280974,
0.1848287433,
0.1975171566,
-0.9065375328,
0.2782421112,
-0.1898016036,
-0.0063992939,
0.3195990622,
0.1043756604,
-0.2069538683,
0.5606678128,
0.781018734,
0.0713021904,
0.2181669474,
0.1270980388,
0.7795111537,
-0.4100389183,
-0.8088388443,
-0.5259886384,
0.5239264369,
0.1242337301,
-0.4183214009,
0.3176616132,
0.9434493184,
1.1446154118,
0.108635962,
1.1299612522,
-0.2106722742,
0.518977046,
-0.5566028953,
0.4506036043,
-0.554525733,
-0.162475422,
0.1654271036,
-0.7459339499,
-0.1357370615,
0.6243894696,
-0.0953297243,
-0.2978158295,
0.8376203775,
0.5927817225,
-0.2605822086,
0.0167653617,
0.8608242869,
-0.2235325724,
0.3331909776,
0.8642796278,
0.7100326419,
-0.6228963733,
0.6037688255,
-0.0153164798,
-0.2122034132,
-0.0512213744,
-0.6191990376,
-0.7863152623,
-0.8387899399,
-0.2781239152,
-0.0631305054,
0.3803401887,
1.1338758469,
0.8797883391,
-0.6895197034,
-0.7785173655,
-0.2922281623,
-0.3946106732,
-0.3179161847,
-0.0239409488,
0.185969457,
-0.655487597,
-0.7440049648,
0.7013463974,
0.1698670983,
-0.0696281716,
-0.3486881554,
-0.3908009231,
-0.311478734,
-0.138553679,
0.7350725532,
0.0794315338,
-0.7071843743,
-0.1231272817,
0.0642392412,
-0.3636169732,
0.0562088825,
0.8938046694,
-0.5600265265,
0.3451879919,
0.5538553596,
0.9111719131,
0.6509001851,
-0.2422351241,
0.7837504148,
-0.876630187,
0.2095237374,
0.0727048665,
0.1276554912,
0.3592424989,
-0.0927927718,
0.3195489049,
0.4555581808,
-0.4107554257,
-0.8016510606,
0.2306306511,
-1.4618594646,
-0.2212304771,
0.9488842487,
-0.2197193801,
-0.1764303297,
-0.248788327,
-0.1049689651,
0.8300458193,
-0.4567305744,
0.3602734208,
0.2601836026,
-0.0481466986,
-0.4116361141,
-0.5437266231,
0.3419719636,
0.6475993395,
-0.858689785,
0.4006317258,
0.4324763119,
0.0680437014,
0.164827466,
0.4997729659,
0.1164004654,
0.5651899576,
-0.0842030868,
-0.0652442351,
-0.1115596145,
-0.4774887562,
-0.2911935747,
-0.0111704953,
-0.1669467539,
-0.3102042377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14835v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14835v2 | SummIt: Iterative Text Summarization via ChatGPT | 2023-05-24T07:40:06 | 2023-10-09T07:26:40 | Haopeng Zhang, Xiao Liu, Jiawei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text summarization systems have made significant progress in recent years,
but typically generate summaries in one single step. However, the one-shot
summarization setting is sometimes inadequate, as the generated summary may
contain hallucinations or overlook essential details related to the reader's
interests. This paper addresses this limitation by proposing SummIt, an
iterative text summarization framework based on large language models like
ChatGPT. Our framework enables the model to refine the generated summary
iteratively through self-evaluation and feedback, resembling humans' iterative
process when drafting and revising summaries. Furthermore, we explore the
potential benefits of integrating knowledge and topic extractors into the
framework to enhance summary faithfulness and controllability. We automatically
evaluate the performance of our framework on three benchmark summarization
datasets. We also conduct a human evaluation to validate the effectiveness of
the iterative refinements and identify a potential issue of over-correction. | [
-0.1932658106,
-0.5995524526,
0.2909429967,
0.5028406978,
-0.4719971716,
0.206118077,
-0.3211478889,
-0.0924343988,
0.3821862638,
0.4102517366,
-0.5805327892,
-0.6215504408,
-0.8172377944,
-0.0248448253,
-0.5695629716,
1.3494778872,
0.0771717578,
-0.4212919474,
-0.1005524471,
0.1642507166,
-0.4623862207,
-0.5273615122,
-0.5319937468,
-0.4561522901,
0.3067189753,
0.5891212225,
0.6459935904,
0.4214995205,
0.7565844655,
0.2599760592,
-0.1395079643,
-0.0292460881,
-1.0147732496,
0.1289672554,
-0.0265711285,
0.0616845302,
-0.4814596176,
-0.177979514,
0.8417648673,
0.7827919126,
-0.3619362116,
0.1899337769,
0.3958443105,
0.8458219171,
-0.3393229246,
0.2553175092,
-0.5404523015,
0.0468325019,
-0.0511749648,
-0.3523017168,
-0.0830517784,
-0.1514224261,
0.322373122,
-0.4712923169,
0.448196739,
0.0920683891,
0.8502438664,
0.2594498396,
-0.2422749698,
-0.2195858508,
-0.5630599856,
0.6443681717,
-0.8267636895,
0.1316524148,
0.3610823154,
0.4149980843,
0.0123232743,
-0.9421671033,
-0.3590839505,
-0.2921780944,
-0.2148603797,
0.4670117199,
-0.0684464872,
0.0591637157,
-0.0805672556,
0.689889133,
-0.6284791231,
-0.007357161,
-0.4847371578,
-0.0361235328,
0.5127540231,
0.457182765,
0.2364922315,
-0.3858529329,
-0.1252051294,
0.1721507758,
-0.5596289039,
-0.1025186405,
0.0392900407,
0.5613434911,
-0.0159852281,
0.6514309645,
-0.5613353252,
0.472194016,
-0.149124071,
-0.222910583,
0.1673812717,
-0.5199959278,
-0.0241566114,
0.0384959616,
0.9029698372,
0.9388695359,
-0.0334315859,
-0.5401916504,
-0.1398107409,
-0.3685424328,
0.2620866299,
-1.1993023157,
-0.4976354539,
0.4078876078,
-0.681375742,
-0.3293159902,
-0.1073494852,
-0.7861545682,
-0.4599327743,
-0.2398926616,
0.4796126783,
-0.3606038392,
-0.3628690541,
0.1268527806,
-0.4523535669,
-0.1239921972,
0.4951142967,
-0.8195051551,
0.413459748,
0.6800798774,
1.175865531,
-0.4347829819,
-0.5316664577,
-0.5210102201,
0.042782139,
-0.1263500899,
1.0714948177,
-0.2579125464,
-0.7146995068,
-0.2515046,
-0.2940861881,
-0.1309684813,
-0.3537739515,
0.3618348837,
-0.221829623,
0.2538557649,
-0.4853442907,
-0.639070034,
-0.015146615,
0.6502463818,
-0.3685468733,
0.8733744621,
-0.1153790057,
-1.0179136992,
0.3425037265,
-0.5822117329,
-0.5258999467,
0.0530072711,
-0.1774140596,
-0.4143423736,
-0.1499768049,
0.4744811654,
0.3317495883,
-0.3233066797,
0.2065959275,
0.2342894524,
-0.2568715215,
-0.1518756449,
-0.1395296901,
0.5916642547,
0.1168938428,
-0.1248746067,
0.3548564911,
-0.6898424029,
-0.0574421287,
-0.1057072654,
-0.2835694849,
0.0650254264,
0.1466701925,
0.0427582785,
-0.1521514654,
0.1464002579,
-0.3231912553,
0.3300306499,
-0.3776928484,
0.4406793118,
0.5779923797,
0.5468432307,
0.4577454627,
-0.5394915342,
0.4697453976,
-0.1213182211,
-0.0851415992,
-0.7878041863,
-0.2871463597,
-0.5775794983,
-0.4981548488,
0.5531409979,
0.5470798612,
-0.6174502969,
0.3493750691,
-0.5432260633,
-0.6089980602,
-0.2083298415,
0.164942652,
0.2635993361,
0.5237593651,
0.2145007849,
-0.355695039,
-0.3626364768,
-0.6132416129,
-0.3653103709,
-0.1858999282,
-0.3613656163,
-0.1749007106,
0.425252676,
-0.0815995187,
0.9207032323,
-0.4888910353,
-0.716786325,
-0.5347031355,
0.6410551667,
0.0177091099,
0.5218621492,
0.3186852932,
-0.6027631164,
-0.2589862943,
-0.0935687646,
-0.6741808653,
-0.1550596356,
-0.2909223437,
0.050359726,
-0.4149366319,
0.6083405614,
-0.3473990262,
0.4060109854,
0.2718054652,
-0.190850392,
0.4987048805,
-0.3372504115,
0.4840835631,
-1.1482344866,
0.2602581382,
-0.2031658441,
-0.3607096672,
-0.36522457,
0.0515595414,
-0.1905944049,
-0.2770186961,
0.3149750233,
0.3790003955,
-0.3323793113,
-0.0256392043,
-0.4470928013,
0.6355861425,
-0.0612171516,
0.4666275084,
-0.0254403893,
0.790123105,
0.350603044,
-0.7172113657,
0.1394247711,
0.5162386894,
-0.2839773893,
0.4714904428,
-0.7850446105,
-0.1144630685,
-0.3482435048,
0.3209719658,
-1.1240987778,
-0.3779710531,
0.0548937395,
-0.7672199607,
-0.0079137916,
-0.0458246283,
-0.5333009958,
-0.0549562201,
-0.5459718108,
0.0819494426,
0.4195780158,
-0.4220531881,
0.5502406359,
0.623799324,
-0.6136671305,
-0.2540791333,
-0.5113888383,
0.6695718765,
0.0997088924,
-0.4035360217,
0.6153835058,
-0.1487864256,
-0.3974989653,
-0.1508007795,
-0.1574055254,
-0.0737669617,
-0.10610874,
0.3305504024,
-0.0107621765,
0.1305061579,
0.1979634911,
0.055530075,
-0.2855765224,
-0.1725507975,
-0.1211197823,
0.3989403248,
-0.1250513792,
-0.075732924,
-0.4693222642,
0.6637396812,
0.3966675401,
-0.2707634568,
0.3241598606,
0.2469374985,
-0.3455878794,
0.1011489928,
-0.3307751715,
-0.1323058456,
-0.3867233098,
0.2880941033,
-0.4204317331,
-0.7680026293,
0.7985771894,
-0.1041738987,
0.5523026586,
0.615128994,
0.6309390664,
-0.1474424601,
1.0715750456,
0.9186908603,
-0.1847398579,
0.5469790101,
-0.1507972032,
0.2035568208,
-0.5129910111,
-0.1150749549,
-0.7055758238,
-0.1630989611,
-0.274300009,
0.0008758549,
0.5321058035,
0.0505706854,
0.0046198964,
0.2469429672,
-0.4494688213,
0.7459272742,
0.5330167413,
0.1776658148,
0.6950206757,
-0.0949587673,
0.1575919092,
-0.0998871624,
-0.8383626938,
-0.4969327748,
0.6630120873,
0.1476184577,
0.6816841364,
-0.0480789691,
0.6732445359,
0.500889957,
0.3949725926,
-0.7331110239,
0.3656301498,
-0.11241851,
-0.2763694525,
-0.3154691756,
-0.6385340691,
-0.6360499859,
0.2796322107,
-0.1254717559,
-0.8860647082,
-0.1938657761,
0.2062556148,
-0.4564305842,
0.0212271065,
-0.58536309,
0.7839835882,
0.2764373422,
0.0522032268,
-0.3852926791,
-0.6384721398,
0.3284633756,
0.2040678561,
0.1717044711,
-0.1211352423,
0.1523017287,
0.7460352182,
-0.6072025895,
0.8843066096,
0.0360671654,
-0.1498625129,
0.2611975968,
0.2325253934,
0.3275255263,
0.1682926416,
-0.0107497443,
0.1603535414,
-0.0039006488,
-0.4155960381,
-0.5272063017,
0.5848107934,
-0.4951924086,
-0.4734548628,
-0.1914407611,
-0.4318755865,
-0.18675901,
0.3991247118,
0.8133101463,
0.7179026604,
-0.404293716,
-0.0093775252,
0.3596709967,
-0.0421438366,
0.4043135047,
0.2005032301,
-0.6181166172,
-0.6957896352,
0.8652108908,
0.3147236109,
0.2148616463,
0.2920862436,
0.0248500854,
0.0923204273,
-0.7748538852,
-0.6662741303,
-0.0550416447,
-0.7641302347,
-0.2901269794,
-0.8267021179,
-0.2872556448,
-0.5341861844,
-0.3070799708,
-0.486079365,
-0.7872100472,
0.0934587643,
-0.061512474,
0.1308938861,
0.5923277736,
-0.0073951562,
0.7399269342,
-0.8917276859,
0.7034845352,
0.2258511931,
0.3507846594,
-0.1472593695,
-0.6838023663,
-0.0694727525,
-0.17633605,
-0.2793850601,
-0.5318971872,
0.3443067074,
0.2664443851,
0.3232012689,
0.2616694868,
0.1240296587,
0.794619143,
-0.5040342212,
1.0920940638,
0.2355240434,
-1.0111093521,
0.5750203133,
-0.534186244,
0.8175874949,
0.9578209519,
0.005936088,
-0.7557072043,
-0.6943378448,
-0.4443915486,
-0.9603078365,
0.3064776361,
0.6338513494,
0.08386641,
0.1193768829,
0.3049279451,
0.2812123597,
0.2611781061,
-0.3826972544,
-0.0017031922,
-0.4187318385,
-0.1399661452,
-0.0429445207,
-0.21877563,
-0.1462677866,
0.0713171959,
0.9039620757,
-0.1773479134,
0.1256636083,
0.3398348689,
-0.2822725475,
-0.0976415575,
0.0581941232,
0.5009581447,
0.9951589704,
-0.1994611025,
0.1031040028,
0.0904956907,
-0.4105429649,
-0.4912126958,
0.1067962945,
-0.2454513013,
0.2333684266,
0.515214622,
0.4047890604,
0.3544786572,
-0.7521837354,
0.6857100129,
-0.447503984,
-0.1848409921,
-0.0909266025,
-0.118670553,
-0.2353341728,
0.2043372393,
0.519431591,
0.0434405506,
0.5069413781,
-0.3415588737,
0.2464801073,
0.175974682,
-0.3868100941,
-0.2718335986,
0.5307399631,
0.4353561401,
-0.233978197,
0.5537839532,
-0.3019918501,
-0.7267787457,
0.3757289946,
0.2925129533,
1.0448694229,
0.1569382697,
0.2614039183,
0.719617486,
0.5053707361,
-0.1629587114,
0.027016839,
-0.351963073,
-0.4883824885,
-0.672295332,
-0.2501471043,
-0.7874455452,
-0.2223603725,
-0.444775492,
0.2989326119,
-0.2698051035,
-0.0201060511,
0.0402963981,
-0.1533280611,
-0.1108463854,
-0.0348885544,
-0.2021985054,
0.9989583492,
-0.3742560148,
0.262466073,
0.2574171722,
-0.4309603572,
-0.2592864931,
0.2840294838,
0.0449648313,
-0.5007129908,
0.081517145,
0.323777765,
-0.1929180324,
0.1865448207,
-0.4875641167,
-0.415972352,
1.0564616919,
0.027966382,
-0.4596430361,
-0.2414751351,
-0.1802785844,
0.3765672445,
-0.1170132905,
0.1710031331,
0.5957123637,
0.166457653,
0.3979308903,
-1.3121771812,
-0.2196926773,
-0.3834924102,
-0.2180211544,
0.1308247298,
-0.6008546948,
0.5135099292,
-0.447766006,
-0.3690394759,
0.0250366852,
0.8036352396,
-0.0254540909,
0.2278223783,
0.3071930408,
0.4518998861,
0.8157530427,
0.1022721082,
0.8999368548,
-0.2700524628,
0.4795044959,
1.4943324327,
-0.0288280845,
0.6126394868,
0.1981157064,
0.0298082214,
0.1496814936,
0.5245674849,
0.2355578244,
0.5898547173,
0.0325196609,
-0.1639605314,
-0.1551016271,
0.0329574794,
-0.2806923091,
0.4163832068,
0.1575410813,
-0.0996349379,
-0.879452467,
0.0648777336,
0.2254813612,
0.0894722566,
-0.5343413353,
1.1346292496,
0.0212480631,
-0.7537261248,
0.4152399302,
-0.0488051064,
0.4854629338,
-0.5437111259,
-0.0264172126,
-0.3279608488,
0.1757999957,
-0.0763056725,
-0.6815989614,
0.3102086186,
0.282202512,
-0.1714520156,
-0.4610427618,
0.792037189,
-0.4241787195,
-0.2709484696,
-0.2191833407,
0.3891463578,
0.0937962309,
-0.5255157948,
-0.508241117,
-0.028029846,
0.0163138323,
-0.3893920779,
0.1373474151,
0.4940057099,
0.194211632,
0.7635660768,
0.2733677328,
-0.0191520136,
-0.2481951267,
0.2341067791,
1.0072889328,
-0.7144473791,
-0.8490963578,
-0.9064903855,
0.5662115812,
-0.3936091661,
-0.4839915335,
0.7246614695,
0.6885878444,
0.4016294181,
0.2818704844,
1.0602357388,
-0.2469711453,
0.6845895648,
-0.4054507911,
0.895976007,
-0.1302192509,
0.3042527735,
-0.2355957776,
-0.7197210789,
-0.5248547196,
0.4770123959,
-0.2019892633,
-0.1668999493,
0.5798283219,
0.6547231674,
0.1755416244,
0.2362126857,
0.2285521924,
0.2133038491,
0.4539606273,
0.155346334,
0.6372139454,
-0.443795085,
0.6672331691,
-0.2962478697,
-0.5207850933,
-0.1634504199,
-1.1676473618,
-1.1164495945,
-0.758805573,
-0.4788834155,
-0.2982100844,
0.0090578627,
0.99498564,
0.5331606865,
-0.6706467867,
-0.1937981546,
-0.1496843696,
0.0526123084,
-0.2179598212,
-0.2231021672,
0.3284805119,
-0.7897468209,
-0.6218535304,
0.179532215,
0.4545735121,
-0.1334280074,
-0.1315876991,
0.2461529374,
0.3946159184,
-0.1807448715,
0.6148942113,
0.1451057494,
-0.2406369597,
-0.0943996906,
-0.0971033052,
-0.071377188,
0.20921278,
1.111528635,
-0.7588674426,
0.5528359413,
0.5479482412,
0.6667141914,
0.6269113421,
0.1467953771,
0.7379924655,
-0.6780589223,
-0.2229337245,
0.0947318599,
0.1421452761,
0.3097383082,
-0.2762556374,
0.4346135855,
-0.0520718731,
-0.7111222744,
-0.7862620354,
-0.1138391793,
-0.9968004227,
-0.2015531212,
0.9936478734,
-0.0309858005,
-0.0001809134,
0.0707669556,
-0.6421048641,
0.0533532239,
-0.3971523046,
1.3567516804,
0.7872861028,
-0.0373301134,
-0.2223304212,
-0.5336851478,
0.554084003,
0.1012384519,
-1.0527976751,
0.6331470609,
0.5145416856,
0.1318211704,
0.1397758275,
1.0556099415,
-0.185409531,
0.2822194397,
0.1111692786,
0.1262384355,
0.1526427716,
-0.2529931962,
-0.1484220028,
0.299037993,
-0.0015511049,
0.0448423326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15444v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15444v2 | PromptNER: Prompting For Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-24T07:38:24 | 2023-06-20T14:41:38 | Dhananjay Ashok, Zachary C. Lipton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In a surprising turn, Large Language Models (LLMs) together with a growing
arsenal of prompt-based heuristics now offer powerful off-the-shelf approaches
providing few-shot solutions to myriad classic NLP problems. However, despite
promising early results, these LLM-based few-shot methods remain far from the
state of the art in Named Entity Recognition (NER), where prevailing methods
include learning representations via end-to-end structural understanding and
fine-tuning on standard labeled corpora. In this paper, we introduce PromptNER,
a new state-of-the-art algorithm for few-Shot and cross-domain NER. To adapt to
any new NER task PromptNER requires a set of entity definitions in addition to
the standard few-shot examples. Given a sentence, PromptNER prompts an LLM to
produce a list of potential entities along with corresponding explanations
justifying their compatibility with the provided entity type definitions.
Remarkably, PromptNER achieves state-of-the-art performance on few-shot NER,
achieving a 4% (absolute) improvement in F1 score on the ConLL dataset, a 9%
(absolute) improvement on the GENIA dataset, and a 4% (absolute) improvement on
the FewNERD dataset. PromptNER also moves the state of the art on Cross Domain
NER, outperforming prior methods (including those not limited to the few-shot
setting), setting a new mark on 3/5 CrossNER target domains, with an average F1
gain of 3%, despite using less than 2% of the available data. | [
-0.5921539068,
-0.5545600057,
0.6218634248,
0.0585058779,
-0.2036307454,
0.0685735717,
-0.2392860502,
-0.3486820459,
0.1117599979,
0.0876177102,
-0.6530684829,
-0.4856542051,
-0.7645654082,
0.7294691205,
-0.163723141,
0.8818294406,
0.0585856661,
0.2263973504,
-0.0121089648,
-0.0910987481,
-0.5576008558,
-0.109623149,
-1.0345574617,
-0.2954278588,
0.8743163943,
0.5253430009,
0.4054049551,
0.3475596011,
0.5312863588,
0.2541981041,
-0.2924073637,
-0.0240892638,
-0.4096885026,
0.2952326238,
-0.2007350028,
-0.4942207336,
-0.0469074026,
-0.1878707856,
0.6987614632,
0.6697687507,
0.1901723146,
0.0234080702,
-0.0319649428,
0.4512369633,
-0.6441107392,
-0.1265691966,
-0.7638676763,
0.0301467516,
-0.5030443668,
-0.4171052575,
-0.4743059874,
-0.0484581962,
0.2453410327,
-0.633168757,
0.3490380943,
0.4300783873,
0.7984881401,
0.3904722333,
-0.2238378823,
-0.3462305069,
-0.5931395888,
0.7223087549,
-0.4248354733,
0.6466146708,
-0.0345967077,
0.5490019321,
-0.5572581887,
-0.677800715,
-0.741112411,
-0.0837221965,
0.0646115541,
-0.1962976158,
-0.6526508927,
-0.1168414578,
0.6297277212,
-0.0336907767,
-0.5061674118,
0.3546428382,
-0.2266317308,
-0.1068640947,
0.3252915144,
0.2351663262,
0.235781312,
-0.2514791191,
-0.5642653108,
0.0723568723,
-0.8846111298,
0.2215269655,
0.1205143407,
0.5677527785,
0.1624453515,
0.4895580709,
-0.2366517484,
0.6844654083,
0.4782033265,
-0.0912298113,
0.0068135699,
0.0285338908,
-0.2422718108,
0.4595790207,
0.7075027227,
0.2946092486,
0.1373930424,
-0.1377355009,
-0.2497669607,
-0.1726478487,
-0.2332239896,
-0.9471427202,
-0.3857373595,
0.1483668387,
-0.2949841022,
0.0777143538,
-0.1801929921,
-0.8140230179,
-0.638462007,
-0.2821516991,
0.1601071805,
-0.4066974521,
0.0976125002,
-0.3151539862,
-0.1575429887,
0.5660312176,
0.5359145999,
-0.7240129113,
0.2650796473,
0.6651272178,
0.9472917318,
-0.4432929456,
-0.279466033,
-1.0592979193,
-0.1022328511,
-0.4922235608,
1.212793231,
-0.7133082747,
-0.4086664617,
-0.1444294304,
-0.0239916854,
0.1358015537,
-0.5497758985,
0.3627505302,
-0.8129326701,
0.1552821398,
-0.3742067218,
-0.860031426,
0.019092191,
0.3412354589,
-0.7193382382,
0.9112608433,
0.053753078,
-0.7403640151,
0.8265454769,
-0.3667205572,
-0.2299761921,
0.4808801413,
-0.2835756242,
-0.3185754716,
0.0820060968,
0.3158886731,
0.5142363906,
-0.472442627,
0.2393415272,
-0.1529499441,
-0.1967269778,
0.1994998902,
-0.2585203052,
0.593182981,
-0.1518490762,
-0.0675162226,
0.1822495162,
-0.9480963349,
0.0027648348,
0.1241385341,
-0.1482806653,
-0.362201035,
-0.4880649149,
0.0039934134,
0.1902462393,
-0.0037836952,
-0.349999845,
0.2693581283,
-0.4095160067,
0.1558210105,
0.5660302639,
0.3743728995,
0.8196263313,
-0.1069041789,
0.7820256948,
-0.0337578952,
-0.2134305388,
-0.520891428,
-0.5325742364,
-0.8035128713,
-0.2828101218,
0.5293711424,
0.6561612487,
-0.7950046659,
0.2443315238,
-0.2514390647,
-0.3760516346,
-0.4297917783,
0.1764730662,
0.2530198097,
0.7034893036,
0.6009967923,
0.099396497,
-0.7115076184,
-0.7396113276,
-0.3207063377,
-0.0423282646,
-0.0145780556,
0.2887346447,
0.5271513462,
-0.0179570876,
1.1027628183,
-0.3438361585,
-0.4580453932,
-0.4231587052,
0.0431256741,
0.4616989195,
0.3405254483,
0.2915249765,
-0.6312913299,
-0.4908522964,
-0.2929923832,
-0.5474141836,
-0.0350436531,
-0.3285196722,
-0.0570330545,
-0.0462854169,
0.4724962711,
-0.7136466503,
0.1537739187,
0.1904871166,
-0.1321760863,
0.3095246255,
0.2508535981,
-0.0489657,
-1.0400550365,
-0.133188501,
0.1756656468,
-0.2774398625,
-0.6831052303,
-0.2563189566,
-0.1224466637,
-0.1643078178,
-0.7091013193,
1.0630389452,
-0.7934429049,
0.0318836384,
-0.3723336756,
0.2138549834,
-0.2391624749,
0.1273710281,
-0.0035787185,
0.8806170225,
1.0052316189,
-0.8275866508,
0.4503534436,
0.6203088164,
-0.2025545686,
0.8438498974,
-0.7664625645,
0.3040826321,
-0.3956954181,
0.2581219077,
-0.6386367679,
-0.2979343235,
0.5600655079,
-0.4549336433,
0.5653960109,
-0.4947073162,
-0.0962979123,
-0.2310936004,
-0.1286322176,
0.1745660901,
0.303113699,
-0.7595881224,
0.7927556634,
0.0909747109,
-0.2975072265,
-0.5091612339,
-0.4361077547,
0.4356126487,
-0.1152663082,
-0.3984467685,
0.5877557993,
-0.0136229834,
-0.0479383618,
0.0636882186,
-0.4052699208,
-0.0264753271,
-0.0771197304,
0.2328946739,
0.5000905395,
-0.3909684718,
0.1893697679,
-0.088941887,
-0.5913395882,
-0.128498286,
-0.1998392791,
0.3765182197,
0.0417454615,
-0.0759617686,
-0.5484783053,
0.2034862638,
-0.1551900804,
-0.1071449071,
0.6442154646,
0.4436996281,
-0.6193976402,
-0.4895031154,
-0.3819816411,
-0.2405979335,
-0.4232564867,
-0.0605129153,
-0.8616837859,
-1.0066030025,
0.3291405141,
-0.3785779476,
-0.0956308395,
0.4381295741,
0.2533653378,
0.0235517118,
0.634536624,
0.7208079696,
-0.0709797665,
0.5191331506,
-0.1275846362,
0.3875442445,
-0.8276354671,
-0.348908782,
-0.5820171833,
-0.4541014135,
-0.5893489718,
-0.3079095185,
0.2216568738,
0.353178978,
0.1043155417,
0.4969234467,
-0.3470516503,
0.6772232056,
0.5905050635,
-0.2693704069,
0.1888472736,
-0.2292201817,
-0.0734194443,
-0.0685217902,
-0.6419612169,
-0.6723570824,
0.7725630403,
0.0358644463,
0.7826536894,
-0.1304965913,
1.1368892193,
0.1568761468,
0.2093401402,
-1.0735439062,
0.6572272182,
0.1468973458,
-0.5784648061,
-0.3486963809,
-0.3303574324,
-0.9811016917,
0.0381295756,
-0.2977170348,
-0.6873272657,
0.3870869875,
0.2538386285,
-0.6895391345,
-0.0119120199,
-0.2443550527,
0.8187116981,
-0.1101827919,
-0.2126056105,
0.370300442,
-0.4792377949,
0.1510785967,
0.0327743776,
-0.268014431,
-0.4048989415,
-0.3407225907,
0.7815523148,
-0.0527070314,
0.5051294565,
-0.3113575578,
0.0233444422,
0.1925450712,
0.0842904821,
0.7837387323,
0.2894463241,
-0.0201242156,
0.1380923092,
-0.2110358775,
-0.1441996247,
-0.7812364697,
0.7227796316,
-0.2731809318,
-0.7387502789,
-0.5260253549,
-0.0622859821,
-0.0690626428,
0.4189605713,
0.6246743202,
0.2954326272,
-0.3896830082,
-0.0314414054,
0.744140327,
-0.1850570142,
0.531142056,
0.4471314549,
-0.0459867381,
-0.5675282478,
0.5999568701,
-0.1280677021,
-0.2916101813,
0.6503853798,
-0.0757372677,
-0.2439831495,
-0.624765873,
-0.5431838036,
0.1886820793,
-0.841098547,
-0.6795193553,
-0.8811113238,
-0.0865469053,
-0.2746914029,
-0.247456193,
-0.1441363394,
-0.327824235,
-0.5857004523,
-0.0657009259,
0.3771821558,
0.4154452384,
0.2591885328,
0.5551624298,
-0.78794837,
0.4735525548,
0.1978362352,
0.1560775191,
-0.3226851225,
-0.5287001133,
0.1620288342,
-0.5458245277,
0.0969201401,
-1.0491503477,
0.3164863288,
0.3966138363,
0.6672847271,
0.4582358301,
0.0878012925,
0.6961207986,
-0.8965356946,
0.574059248,
0.2897308469,
-0.901933074,
0.8000779748,
0.2222480923,
0.2434914708,
0.6611353755,
0.7042970061,
-0.7366173863,
-0.0091801072,
-0.3935623467,
-0.7011799216,
0.7125731111,
-0.0415650718,
0.1060861796,
-0.2175643593,
0.2177396268,
0.2593920231,
-0.0355362557,
-0.4812307954,
-0.3916796148,
0.1883021891,
-0.0973245054,
0.0146843409,
-0.2005264312,
0.2087249756,
0.0868379399,
0.8860161901,
-0.3941993713,
0.2245339751,
0.3044704199,
-0.4536509216,
-0.1495741606,
0.7223641276,
0.2792061567,
0.4938732684,
0.1434623897,
0.2664989829,
0.4680975974,
0.0397210419,
0.3073577881,
0.4765016437,
-0.4949973226,
0.3333822191,
0.4696507156,
1.0396779776,
0.419165045,
-0.4005533755,
0.5566422343,
0.0470483154,
0.1268178821,
-0.3906118572,
0.1997411102,
-0.1926285475,
0.5764471292,
0.5544070005,
0.2758386135,
0.2626665831,
-0.0710023269,
0.3405294418,
0.4559357762,
-0.4005770683,
-0.4091588855,
0.7068638802,
0.0434299335,
-0.4070980549,
0.5285896659,
-0.542955339,
-0.4883258045,
0.2576268613,
0.63940835,
1.0124082565,
-0.2267421186,
0.1659924388,
0.5176543593,
0.097311601,
-0.236269474,
0.263025701,
-0.0767616928,
-0.9026331902,
-0.1386518329,
-0.5377483964,
-0.4511293471,
0.0172450431,
-0.3596634269,
0.6863430142,
-0.7253692746,
-0.3605590761,
0.545394063,
-0.016328143,
-1.0176029205,
-0.037840724,
0.352807343,
1.1135259867,
-0.5659934878,
0.4553158879,
0.8038265109,
-0.5871691704,
-0.5889968872,
-0.0219521616,
0.2596168518,
-0.5991287231,
0.9555824399,
0.3407557607,
-0.1095705479,
0.4274072349,
-0.5099371672,
-0.9469761848,
1.0639628172,
0.2275817394,
-1.1361310482,
-0.3654385805,
-0.2731935084,
0.1518804431,
-0.5255204439,
0.3677279651,
0.5013763309,
0.5371536016,
0.270183295,
-0.4688089192,
0.2489607334,
-0.0883214995,
0.2539003193,
0.346288532,
-0.2697495222,
0.4672709405,
-0.6968577504,
-0.5192683935,
0.0999713093,
1.0018635988,
0.4249972403,
0.5887238979,
0.5070666671,
0.3475563526,
1.0560765266,
-0.0562825389,
0.8541790247,
-0.1922802776,
0.0425572284,
1.2713886499,
-0.6425474286,
0.7726735473,
0.5351381302,
-0.192397356,
0.4439114928,
0.5658046603,
-0.519513309,
0.4566422701,
0.1407706589,
-0.3097666502,
-0.315607518,
-0.3179929852,
-0.0124559598,
0.4391811788,
0.07021413,
-0.2939762473,
-0.4332807362,
0.3445920348,
-0.0478212461,
-0.2456887662,
-0.2548869848,
0.899936974,
0.3522373438,
-0.4867240787,
0.4358436763,
-0.0736857429,
0.7867724895,
-0.2933730781,
-0.1498305947,
-0.1385044307,
-0.0151518239,
-0.1897618771,
-0.5965543389,
-0.1609283984,
0.3325249255,
-0.1943331063,
-0.2109080851,
1.0293301344,
-0.3872952461,
-0.3567201197,
0.2484322786,
0.6908744574,
0.2487800121,
-0.0682331324,
-0.5035477281,
-0.0490525849,
-0.3361298442,
-0.2701616287,
-0.122264348,
0.6253665686,
-0.0115233716,
0.6679800153,
0.6210311055,
0.0953176022,
0.2081294358,
0.3970746398,
0.8165124059,
-1.0235681534,
-0.3697471917,
-0.8944165707,
0.2897407413,
0.0382754244,
-0.5348902941,
0.5827864408,
0.7274041772,
0.8423494101,
0.0221183617,
0.5747843981,
-0.0725766271,
0.4067623317,
-0.7011137605,
0.1866928786,
-0.148279056,
0.1363834143,
-0.1369416863,
-1.1420505047,
-0.5535907149,
0.3007146716,
-0.2419303954,
0.0023870517,
0.6714783907,
0.7583113909,
0.0142959999,
-0.0587936565,
0.4259775877,
0.0173313878,
0.2087741494,
0.490639478,
1.0254114866,
-0.4397455752,
0.6782960892,
-0.152297765,
-0.0453565344,
-0.1935205609,
-0.9680373073,
-1.0841975212,
-0.3511410356,
-0.5119944215,
0.0322626121,
0.1595852673,
1.3873633146,
0.565506041,
-1.0894957781,
0.4048441648,
-0.1130259708,
0.1899773628,
-0.090668194,
-0.1711410433,
0.1074623764,
-0.6169945598,
-0.8086268902,
0.7572106123,
0.2553176582,
0.1248304844,
0.0769678205,
-0.122089535,
0.0293602459,
-0.211769715,
0.4590815902,
0.2804621458,
-0.8758251667,
-0.0419990197,
0.3809070289,
-0.0238062292,
0.2371000648,
0.8699113727,
-1.1286095381,
0.1280267835,
0.5428027511,
0.9143606424,
0.3084177971,
-0.1559125185,
0.2637435794,
-0.6942150593,
-0.1985770315,
0.4153657556,
0.5168061852,
0.6387276053,
-0.4822823405,
0.2782838941,
0.1845598519,
-0.2662978172,
-0.5651126504,
0.1837004125,
-1.0122745037,
0.0481344908,
0.9762096405,
0.013280483,
-0.3017565012,
0.1767536551,
-0.0962806419,
0.3409687579,
-0.8359507322,
0.3246231675,
0.5582215786,
-0.1811431944,
-0.7719531059,
-0.2692866027,
0.6068595648,
0.0502333306,
-0.9231829643,
-0.2233265042,
0.589220643,
0.4449768662,
0.1113872901,
0.5688954592,
0.2635314167,
0.2163216472,
-0.0681266934,
-0.0284726471,
-0.0662033111,
-0.6575849652,
-0.6963347197,
0.0790832564,
0.1042101681,
-0.1039068401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14828v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14828v2 | Towards Few-shot Entity Recognition in Document Images: A Graph Neural Network Approach Robust to Image Manipulation | 2023-05-24T07:34:33 | 2024-02-23T05:36:02 | Prashant Krishnan, Zilong Wang, Yangkun Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Recent advances of incorporating layout information, typically bounding box
coordinates, into pre-trained language models have achieved significant
performance in entity recognition from document images. Using coordinates can
easily model the absolute position of each token, but they might be sensitive
to manipulations in document images (e.g., shifting, rotation or scaling),
especially when the training data is limited in few-shot settings. In this
paper, we propose to further introduce the topological adjacency relationship
among the tokens, emphasizing their relative position information.
Specifically, we consider the tokens in the documents as nodes and formulate
the edges based on the topological heuristics from the k-nearest bounding
boxes. Such adjacency graphs are invariant to affine transformations including
shifting, rotations and scaling. We incorporate these graphs into the
pre-trained language model by adding graph neural network layers on top of the
language model embeddings, leading to a novel model LAGER. Extensive
experiments on two benchmark datasets show that LAGER significantly outperforms
strong baselines under different few-shot settings and also demonstrate better
robustness to manipulations. | [
-0.2713444233,
-0.9762194157,
0.6806713939,
-0.8382814527,
-0.2785234153,
-0.1048674285,
-0.0669939891,
-0.5208425522,
0.386003077,
0.4892829955,
-0.189045921,
-0.6971204877,
-0.7865869403,
0.0376990996,
-0.5985594392,
0.6259174347,
-0.0430309847,
-0.1411089599,
0.1401744187,
-0.2829711437,
0.0678701475,
-0.3206746876,
-0.7861325741,
-0.3615543842,
0.6776413918,
-0.066397503,
0.8585505486,
0.9085431695,
0.6010084152,
0.4629487693,
-0.1706005037,
0.2500148118,
-0.3302941024,
-0.1806354374,
0.0774250478,
-0.5833225846,
-0.2788521051,
-0.0740088522,
0.8148085475,
0.646566987,
0.2338015288,
-0.2230048031,
-0.1169678196,
0.4602971375,
-0.346239239,
0.2568326294,
-0.8722205162,
0.151395306,
-0.5554827452,
-0.0418394506,
-0.3147668242,
-0.2680101991,
-0.1293593645,
-1.0502295494,
0.3508355916,
0.1158728302,
1.2367315292,
0.2004059851,
-0.3472393453,
-0.0950881839,
-0.4744500518,
0.0297768321,
-0.4323661625,
0.5562836528,
0.3946251869,
0.345692873,
-0.3514656126,
-1.0865627527,
-0.6906968951,
0.201219514,
-0.4267931283,
-0.2122450769,
-0.3884023726,
0.0408289097,
0.3295310736,
-0.0859693512,
-0.4683262408,
0.2308711559,
-0.4910457134,
-0.2138927281,
0.2276058942,
0.1078437939,
0.3846606016,
-0.1997214407,
-0.3206268847,
-0.2191068679,
-0.5860645175,
0.1165512502,
0.4811239541,
0.4940777123,
0.185413599,
0.548368156,
0.2699700296,
0.8646400571,
0.226236254,
-0.151449874,
0.031787876,
0.0067725857,
-0.163654685,
0.0277591422,
0.9955226183,
0.1274487078,
0.1777978688,
-0.2900705338,
-0.0995021313,
0.1187149659,
0.5702459216,
-0.6302790642,
-0.52446872,
-0.1500408202,
-0.5083976388,
-0.4607627988,
-0.0633854344,
-0.4011290669,
-0.5745116472,
-0.1739923656,
0.0542734638,
-0.6664457917,
0.0186249614,
-0.1977620572,
-0.0918056518,
0.0970429257,
0.5465641618,
-0.6970680952,
0.329313457,
0.663523376,
1.0830597878,
-0.2219032347,
-0.4379073679,
-0.4376850426,
0.4003222585,
-0.4809646904,
1.094207406,
-0.4708244801,
-0.3861885667,
0.017474832,
0.0987238586,
-0.0085762562,
-0.2951013446,
0.4088794887,
-0.7345209122,
-0.1065757796,
0.0564213693,
-0.5172048807,
-0.1070763543,
0.723602891,
-0.9491053224,
0.8824667931,
0.2102268189,
-1.1718480587,
0.305465728,
-0.343223691,
-0.4385465384,
0.1102389693,
-0.354963541,
-0.5734810233,
-0.0855432674,
0.2323137224,
0.2282697856,
0.1909859031,
-0.1737147123,
-0.4740357399,
-0.4267105758,
0.1455728859,
-0.2385480702,
0.7422295809,
-0.1879923195,
0.2868989706,
-0.19358702,
-0.7433493733,
0.02670132,
0.4505468011,
-0.3333768547,
-0.6208930016,
-0.3747401834,
-0.0088783428,
0.1605347991,
-0.0857384354,
-0.3322339356,
0.6650944352,
-0.4997297823,
0.277031064,
0.6207601428,
-0.0029164632,
0.9777118564,
-0.0398022048,
0.4100408554,
0.0983179361,
-0.2790470719,
-0.1376396567,
-0.2716605067,
-0.471311301,
-0.2945317924,
0.3695383072,
0.5952306986,
-0.9201096892,
0.326859653,
-0.5200681686,
-0.2612072825,
-0.1913053542,
0.2261545062,
0.1380797625,
0.8217312694,
0.201432541,
-0.6190237999,
-0.2185098082,
-0.8198724985,
-0.1059940979,
-0.4338238537,
0.02942154,
0.5519869328,
0.5212001204,
0.0286396164,
0.8568434119,
-0.716466248,
-0.6626244783,
0.0291722063,
0.1323848069,
0.3240704536,
0.4191744924,
0.7472560406,
-0.6893022656,
-0.4123976827,
0.2165073007,
-0.7878482342,
0.3071655035,
-0.0121140536,
-0.332835108,
-0.0282508172,
0.6537172794,
-0.8936172724,
0.6365300417,
-0.0494949743,
-0.0417169109,
0.3029827774,
-0.0074254125,
-0.1294888109,
-0.9713244438,
-0.1208845899,
0.0765681863,
-0.5833308697,
-0.7137756348,
0.0939025134,
0.1082150042,
-0.392639637,
-0.6009913683,
0.7283838391,
-0.486579597,
-0.3044148982,
-0.2140219957,
0.3244986534,
0.3373013139,
0.5270748734,
0.202724725,
0.3744339943,
0.5591322184,
-0.2686413825,
0.4110164344,
0.607493639,
-0.3600082397,
0.885242641,
-0.4129186571,
0.5610446334,
-0.2019491494,
0.4979225695,
-0.7140498757,
0.00865163,
0.4196536839,
-0.4351706207,
0.9678016901,
-0.6056127548,
-0.5985102654,
-0.2942369282,
-0.1475254148,
0.4729683399,
-0.0752502754,
-0.4934118986,
0.6637845039,
0.3642405868,
0.1658512652,
-0.4895966947,
-0.767185986,
0.0540900677,
-0.228783071,
-0.6380616426,
0.464179337,
0.5076911449,
0.0168021508,
0.3738957345,
-0.0913795382,
-0.2855697274,
0.0851853564,
0.2164726257,
0.2796033025,
-0.1800458282,
0.1605646312,
-0.32847175,
-0.3487688899,
-0.2795128524,
-0.7613081336,
0.3954292834,
-0.1757102907,
-0.2491201311,
-0.2682221532,
0.149135232,
0.2499761879,
-0.2344359457,
0.5561478734,
0.7049515843,
-0.8440775275,
0.1078674868,
0.0433310196,
-0.0273806993,
-0.4444515109,
0.4432640374,
-0.6448290348,
-0.4736948609,
0.559491396,
-0.2794345915,
-0.2976698875,
0.2953431904,
0.1966096908,
-0.4190812707,
0.4724109769,
0.5743414164,
-0.2356183529,
0.6195396185,
-0.7530072927,
0.3399314582,
-0.8282194734,
0.0532196797,
-0.6086263657,
-0.6491683722,
-0.5340691805,
-0.372897774,
0.5732774138,
0.4347310066,
-0.0125450483,
0.6170548797,
-0.358238101,
0.7521976233,
0.4298802316,
0.169300735,
0.0199575052,
0.0780625194,
-0.5136200786,
0.1041087359,
-0.6445777416,
-0.5008561611,
0.6590312719,
0.2661251724,
0.7650853395,
-0.0403327085,
0.8376455307,
-0.033383958,
-0.0243293941,
-1.0343147516,
0.40652439,
-0.3269906342,
-0.5043565631,
-0.6283171773,
-0.2489036769,
-1.1841030121,
0.1342853457,
-0.3193610609,
-1.2676481009,
0.1464965045,
0.0131087089,
-0.1993032992,
0.723444581,
-0.4800065756,
0.8520570993,
-0.2970816791,
-0.3542894423,
0.3510843813,
-0.5242189765,
-0.0655353293,
0.093842037,
0.0740550309,
0.0987306759,
0.108420983,
0.4015745521,
-0.5017771125,
0.7850683928,
-0.1417379081,
0.1665909886,
0.2426413447,
0.5842024684,
0.8625840545,
-0.0343303978,
-0.0382746533,
0.4104576111,
-0.0693040863,
-0.3016721606,
-0.8706952333,
0.6512655616,
-0.7154603601,
-0.4633910954,
-0.3924424648,
-0.5532957315,
-0.0146067236,
0.7043943405,
0.4945146441,
0.5212617517,
-0.3207184672,
-0.0495839305,
0.2746684253,
0.0915836617,
0.4062850773,
-0.0177561659,
-0.3049811423,
-0.1994417161,
0.6376571059,
0.4321649075,
-0.1942225546,
0.5216618776,
0.0531460084,
-0.3446402848,
-0.6294345856,
-0.6785248518,
0.1086668596,
-1.0131486654,
-0.4325734079,
-0.683282733,
-0.2620756924,
-0.3319067657,
-0.5315701962,
-0.3538169861,
-0.6478897929,
-0.4879356921,
-0.2461505383,
0.2734730542,
0.7337415814,
0.389094919,
0.483583957,
-0.8194455504,
0.3988890648,
0.1264217347,
0.4788631797,
-0.1308737695,
-0.3882507384,
-0.0998318419,
-0.3055863976,
-0.3284588158,
-1.1841728687,
0.2480736524,
0.3659643829,
0.5941098332,
0.5375888348,
-0.2586683631,
0.431604147,
-0.7076550126,
0.4900648594,
0.2162703276,
-0.6213900447,
0.4151647389,
-0.4211140573,
0.3183580041,
0.5173688531,
0.4065551162,
-0.4231333733,
-0.0878549889,
-0.6987407804,
-0.5922241807,
0.7924605012,
0.184496209,
0.0829456672,
0.1199458539,
0.5260142088,
-0.2162037343,
-0.0563712344,
-0.7792605758,
-0.2737261653,
-0.2573252022,
-0.1844049543,
0.212788865,
0.262596339,
-0.2019528598,
-0.1384675205,
0.4474746287,
-0.4572895765,
0.2387206107,
-0.0896652266,
-0.2636747062,
-0.0753077269,
-0.0364514701,
0.1487427652,
0.3285183012,
-0.0349809267,
0.4794044793,
0.2220512927,
-0.3501899242,
0.2083867341,
0.2173176855,
-0.44479388,
0.2180417329,
0.6051352024,
0.9793331027,
-0.0235830378,
0.3936714828,
0.5479869843,
-0.1291184574,
0.0389674753,
-0.0222693179,
-0.0983117297,
-0.0278193876,
0.2645992339,
-0.0271008257,
0.2657312751,
0.1343641877,
-0.4124155343,
0.206962049,
0.507085979,
-0.5111430883,
-0.2928429544,
0.4612810612,
-0.1908780634,
-0.6259684563,
0.665604353,
-0.5127744675,
-0.7124897838,
0.5988577008,
0.7389496565,
0.619608283,
0.096011214,
0.2318989336,
0.5930219293,
0.2583941221,
0.1909805089,
-0.2124018073,
-0.049904082,
-1.0642863512,
0.4596964419,
-0.4791006744,
0.0307516791,
-0.0392033458,
-0.2163612992,
0.6659998894,
-0.7079274058,
-0.4769361615,
0.412810266,
-0.1495280862,
-0.9305989146,
0.1363870203,
0.1736069918,
0.7237469554,
-0.5784565806,
1.1142618656,
0.9498972893,
-0.4907698333,
-0.707166791,
-0.0618910901,
0.2599190474,
-0.806684196,
0.5423765779,
0.189714089,
-0.0823192745,
-0.0644544736,
-0.4693202674,
-0.8211583495,
1.1180022955,
0.4054886401,
-0.4491202235,
-0.5296003222,
-0.0176621545,
0.5350266099,
-0.3822790384,
0.2007026523,
0.3390633166,
0.3169009686,
0.183355093,
-0.5030184984,
-0.141378656,
-0.3559668064,
0.0917702019,
0.5857648253,
-0.4403290451,
0.6822389364,
-0.0556486771,
-0.4549964368,
-0.1904215813,
0.3105843663,
-0.0161846709,
0.1607810855,
0.6866598129,
0.8012393713,
0.969576478,
-0.2385420501,
1.2808939219,
-0.264295876,
0.3482289612,
1.2805575132,
-0.2647536397,
0.625338316,
0.3603633344,
-0.2661750615,
0.3987476826,
0.4321973324,
-0.0713973343,
0.5629547834,
0.2087076604,
0.1002170816,
-0.0321417898,
-0.2965580523,
-0.1528980732,
0.6537074447,
0.4585419595,
-0.3474749029,
-0.2633307874,
-0.2297433764,
-0.0003615036,
-0.0485008284,
-0.2531001568,
0.8802204728,
0.3366565108,
-0.0929897428,
0.4713987112,
0.1220031604,
0.2438298911,
-0.510088563,
0.043417383,
0.0709102377,
0.0324185193,
-0.2649038136,
-0.8652873039,
0.3570458591,
-0.1622367352,
-0.0168307219,
0.0022969116,
1.3841377497,
-0.3186810315,
-0.7232759595,
0.3088097274,
0.2716393769,
0.2002752125,
0.2310821116,
-0.5835598707,
-0.1080455408,
-0.4636805654,
-0.0284505095,
0.193766281,
0.6733617187,
-0.1817423403,
0.153471455,
0.6219663024,
0.2968194783,
0.0450299047,
0.106113404,
0.8719413877,
-0.3501568437,
-0.6746063232,
-0.6549411416,
0.2608121336,
-0.0785440877,
-0.0807806477,
0.1346438229,
0.3761326969,
0.8947722912,
0.0991798863,
0.532917738,
0.2076367587,
-0.070552811,
-0.695743978,
0.9275074005,
-0.4496503174,
-0.0223218631,
-0.5082044005,
-1.0503730774,
-0.5887175798,
0.7905206084,
-0.3936225772,
-0.2281054407,
0.7736294866,
0.8275555372,
-0.488298893,
-0.311065793,
0.4988177419,
0.0713590756,
0.314457804,
0.4314995706,
0.658960104,
-0.596581161,
0.5053270459,
-0.3113244176,
0.2965723276,
0.0458871275,
-0.9067733884,
-0.8128405213,
-0.6358804703,
-0.3060758114,
-0.4966627061,
-0.0755879432,
0.6924118996,
0.8372315764,
-0.5648830533,
0.2795357704,
0.1117705107,
0.3401690423,
0.1829765886,
-0.1158801988,
0.5821174383,
0.0723425373,
-0.6161957979,
0.2538528442,
0.5044180751,
0.4114809036,
0.0321264006,
0.0079499437,
-0.405880183,
-0.2324019223,
0.1337026358,
0.3573866189,
-0.5569275618,
-0.4573653936,
-0.1119621918,
-0.3850370049,
0.51161623,
0.9617028236,
-0.5230477452,
0.6041482091,
0.6568162441,
0.8115803599,
0.7855727077,
0.0880597979,
0.0689468384,
-1.2452176809,
0.5780590177,
0.0726012066,
0.7945427299,
0.5372809768,
-0.6338076591,
0.5204640627,
0.2580555081,
-0.2222020477,
-0.5788189769,
0.2825398445,
-0.8169066906,
-0.2000239342,
0.8797307611,
-0.5172159076,
-0.4761645198,
0.1363872141,
-0.2350087464,
0.477275759,
-0.1898725927,
0.4691929817,
0.7495580912,
-0.0920093209,
-0.3152257502,
-0.1448896676,
0.2304550856,
-0.2154441476,
-0.744553864,
-0.4232121408,
0.5089896917,
0.0276642945,
0.6456336379,
0.8339781761,
-0.2279463112,
0.1026413813,
0.1475122422,
-0.2107325643,
-0.2802616954,
-0.5574333668,
-0.4257704914,
0.2069731951,
0.2305407524,
-0.2582035959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14827v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14827v2 | Pre-training Intent-Aware Encoders for Zero- and Few-Shot Intent Classification | 2023-05-24T07:34:32 | 2023-11-14T02:23:01 | Mujeen Sung, James Gung, Elman Mansimov, Nikolaos Pappas, Raphael Shu, Salvatore Romeo, Yi Zhang, Vittorio Castelli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Intent classification (IC) plays an important role in task-oriented dialogue
systems. However, IC models often generalize poorly when training without
sufficient annotated examples for each user intent. We propose a novel
pre-training method for text encoders that uses contrastive learning with
intent psuedo-labels to produce embeddings that are well-suited for IC tasks,
reducing the need for manual annotations. By applying this pre-training
strategy, we also introduce Pre-trained Intent-aware Encoder (PIE), which is
designed to align encodings of utterances with their intent names.
Specifically, we first train a tagger to identify key phrases within utterances
that are crucial for interpreting intents. We then use these extracted phrases
to create examples for pre-training a text encoder in a contrastive manner. As
a result, our PIE model achieves up to 5.4% and 4.0% higher accuracy than the
previous state-of-the-art text encoder for the N-way zero- and one-shot
settings on four IC datasets. | [
-0.1428755373,
-0.2698263526,
0.6398012638,
-0.1141993925,
-0.5502836704,
-0.2953335047,
-0.0781887174,
-0.0756958798,
0.3932971656,
0.6487578154,
-0.6913107634,
-0.6629594564,
-0.6895540357,
0.1405957341,
0.0124022663,
1.0944250822,
-0.0299102459,
0.0896671861,
-0.1963645667,
0.032709986,
-0.2922706008,
-0.4669781923,
-0.4876452386,
-0.1247192696,
0.2767620385,
0.571457386,
0.2172249854,
0.0291420687,
0.4033916295,
0.2278645486,
0.2357760966,
0.1624823511,
-0.5338772535,
0.1453665793,
0.14483504,
-0.352907896,
-0.2742566764,
0.1384906918,
0.2245768309,
0.503503263,
0.1726897806,
-0.1034441739,
0.1102498993,
0.3013685644,
-0.9476941824,
0.1909487695,
-0.5133060813,
0.1884316355,
-0.1110316589,
-0.3521211445,
-0.7558661699,
-0.3077311218,
0.3178008199,
-0.9061770439,
-0.0708893761,
-0.012567603,
0.5852556825,
0.3562108576,
-0.33675915,
-0.4849230349,
-0.7325006723,
0.6965824366,
-0.7111026645,
0.507912159,
0.46335572,
0.0209294595,
0.0433182903,
-0.8754196167,
-0.6695839763,
0.046143122,
-0.3450481594,
0.2871008217,
0.0543690249,
0.3283777535,
0.0481986627,
0.2644337118,
-0.3708603382,
-0.0855316073,
-0.1615429819,
-0.0917827636,
0.1928951889,
0.1843641549,
0.1032437831,
0.2167254388,
-0.408862263,
0.0234911535,
-0.5019683242,
0.2632656395,
0.1312318444,
0.3210961819,
-0.1330402493,
0.4852901399,
-0.3029690087,
0.6195800304,
0.5047272444,
-0.2333703339,
0.3291414976,
-0.345266223,
-0.3738320768,
0.6574557424,
0.9825974703,
0.1928528249,
0.1072058678,
-0.1368177831,
0.0567057543,
0.0441265963,
0.3838692009,
-1.2033002377,
-0.179071635,
0.0927094892,
-0.2436877936,
-0.2090745419,
0.0576141514,
-0.1090461835,
-0.3047662675,
-0.0687150732,
0.5965741873,
-0.4855096936,
0.0536153875,
0.5274783373,
0.1537025869,
0.4003322423,
0.3963238001,
-0.9160187244,
0.4859932363,
0.5255761147,
0.4454743862,
0.1579252034,
-0.2612093687,
-0.6668681502,
0.2816759348,
-0.3427101374,
0.803611517,
-0.8523612618,
-0.224378556,
-0.0809702873,
-0.1454101652,
-0.1510768086,
-0.0861803889,
0.8196514249,
-0.4514194727,
0.480900079,
-0.0142111573,
-0.7660571337,
-0.2981630266,
0.5758721828,
-0.3635093272,
0.5059349537,
-0.0318870209,
-0.891851604,
0.5054718256,
-0.8505156636,
-0.5922768116,
0.2819467783,
-0.4166120291,
-0.5280635953,
0.1520110965,
0.3128919303,
0.500086844,
0.0065115294,
-0.0284810215,
-0.0395085812,
-0.5602298975,
0.1975878477,
-0.4925532639,
0.537558794,
0.0761391819,
-0.3599351645,
0.0991826802,
-0.2176544368,
-0.0547476113,
-0.0593136251,
-0.0962260365,
-0.43108657,
-0.1308877319,
-0.3668753207,
0.1800733954,
0.1288282126,
-0.7244752645,
0.0888864398,
-0.5465982556,
0.1387013793,
0.4197810292,
0.0479825921,
0.5766419172,
-0.1047033966,
0.4554643035,
0.3188237846,
0.3033283949,
-0.6438746452,
-0.458081156,
-0.725654006,
-0.2437438071,
0.2308994979,
0.6043168306,
-0.6200797558,
0.7393460274,
-0.4621983171,
-0.3465035856,
-0.4919673502,
-0.0221277941,
0.6508390903,
0.5877594948,
0.3333409429,
-0.5989681482,
-0.2461486459,
-0.5453026295,
-0.1543845534,
-0.0112040797,
0.0484007187,
0.6344576478,
0.2314197719,
-0.2428279221,
0.9324308038,
-0.4258975387,
-0.5967310071,
-0.4511695504,
0.2417697012,
-0.0032265605,
0.4265418649,
0.2320898771,
-0.9158694744,
-0.7244897485,
-0.0800236017,
-0.454960674,
0.1443742812,
-0.2314610928,
-0.0906180292,
-0.1565469801,
0.6348727942,
-0.5639856458,
0.4889984429,
0.2959624231,
-0.2952107489,
0.2849854529,
-0.0724789798,
0.4763392508,
-1.1003087759,
-0.351942569,
-0.172589913,
-0.1518508047,
-1.0189807415,
-0.6874089837,
0.0484075285,
-0.2024360597,
-1.018691659,
0.5416442156,
-0.4011083543,
0.1733058244,
-0.0973677039,
-0.000497855,
0.1933922023,
0.6861460209,
0.4307432771,
0.6328803301,
0.5106295943,
-0.8419725895,
-0.1125070378,
0.4474517405,
-0.3485138714,
0.5611023307,
-0.3699198663,
0.3445668519,
-0.2030358762,
0.3922226727,
-1.0770529509,
-0.1379611641,
0.715395987,
-0.4184233248,
0.2734356523,
-0.2578797936,
-0.067698352,
-0.1383605748,
-0.2919687629,
0.6746505499,
0.3773645163,
-0.5451321602,
0.8990027308,
0.1823471785,
-0.2835496962,
-0.5999097228,
-0.5175977945,
-0.4261799455,
-0.1962184757,
-0.1185109541,
0.4430035949,
0.0097714569,
0.3886618316,
-0.0086478479,
-0.1368026286,
-0.2770465016,
-0.0883010551,
0.4618304372,
-0.0604671426,
-0.1713388562,
0.2823176086,
0.2561863959,
-0.1929727942,
-0.1865157783,
-0.3839346468,
0.6218120456,
-0.0593213178,
-0.5252848268,
-0.9256654978,
0.1807108968,
0.410951674,
-0.4915803373,
0.594373405,
0.4940613806,
-0.1992800385,
0.1773791462,
-0.4541103542,
-0.3050161898,
-0.5046768785,
0.2688353658,
-0.4989398718,
-0.8936839104,
0.0182376094,
-0.4556751847,
0.1427711993,
-0.0463850982,
0.065949358,
-0.2663713992,
0.7898705602,
0.6711634398,
0.0910964832,
0.7328361273,
-0.1311237216,
0.5498560071,
-0.82593894,
-0.2228078991,
-0.3043574691,
-0.27415061,
-0.2494658232,
-0.4547140002,
0.0179859903,
0.095264852,
-0.38736552,
0.2433170229,
-0.4923399091,
0.8462727666,
0.4358901978,
0.2159159333,
0.0960447937,
-0.1740534008,
0.1705852896,
-0.1430624127,
-0.5372780561,
-0.5755822062,
1.1309826374,
0.0377897993,
0.8344419599,
-0.2311460078,
1.249694109,
-0.0736031607,
0.4007589221,
-0.8956259489,
0.3414892852,
-0.4343788922,
-0.4561676383,
-0.3606269062,
-0.1471081227,
-0.8280238509,
0.041133903,
-0.291067183,
-0.5417665839,
0.3088440597,
0.3575986028,
-0.7145810127,
0.1804488301,
-0.9605858326,
1.1905673742,
-0.5869514346,
-0.0208628569,
0.1702599972,
-0.5302365422,
0.1101610437,
0.1978249848,
-0.0928726941,
-0.1381980926,
-0.0272199903,
0.8156908154,
-0.0644233301,
0.9801319838,
-0.4453275204,
0.2894530892,
0.4144530594,
-0.0236941259,
0.5813762546,
-0.0752072185,
0.1646147966,
-0.1628062278,
-0.5208042264,
-0.2236386538,
-0.5761685371,
0.2507642508,
-0.6026802063,
-0.3580481708,
-0.2543772459,
-0.0963331088,
-0.2576918006,
0.4038605988,
0.7127236724,
0.5581326485,
-0.5952147841,
0.3123398125,
0.9430211186,
-0.0853598863,
0.234974876,
0.3366669416,
0.2086026222,
-0.1340977401,
0.7248197794,
-0.372236371,
0.1213649362,
0.6700455546,
0.0825232193,
-0.3243510127,
-0.5507168174,
-0.0663835481,
0.0859491527,
-0.5661105514,
-0.2080730051,
-0.8927096725,
-0.1326889545,
-0.4551108181,
-0.685710907,
-0.6834147573,
-0.1004225984,
-0.46982342,
-0.0162326414,
0.0687122121,
0.5033420324,
0.4799308777,
0.8406515718,
-0.6198251843,
0.4706562459,
0.444409132,
0.4008347988,
-0.516975522,
-0.5718770027,
-0.2475090772,
0.0289437044,
-0.2011490464,
-0.7525010705,
0.2952208221,
0.3877853453,
0.6168195605,
0.8616866469,
0.5098848939,
0.381508857,
-0.5644900203,
0.654319346,
0.5613437295,
-0.8731985688,
0.7854560614,
0.0821249634,
0.4665611088,
1.224344492,
0.814119637,
-0.4167886674,
-0.1006093696,
-0.3770911992,
-0.6255704761,
1.0464785099,
0.174541682,
0.3726289272,
-0.0635449514,
0.2061881423,
0.3244419098,
0.1969404072,
-1.0119562149,
-0.2124121338,
-0.5869478583,
-0.5339161754,
-0.1898688972,
-0.3690330684,
0.000513319,
-0.0720132887,
0.5713807344,
-0.1326814294,
0.3959439397,
0.2289102972,
-0.5555186868,
0.3928662837,
0.6722003818,
0.5990552306,
0.1033079848,
-0.2739271224,
-0.0031767881,
0.0604212359,
-0.6913354993,
0.3942768574,
0.0678174049,
-0.1116523519,
-0.0866225287,
-0.0364389345,
1.1671607494,
0.3963851333,
-0.4167066813,
0.9174157977,
-0.5354395509,
-0.1478524208,
-0.2170653492,
0.0936670527,
-0.1295762211,
-0.0285855103,
-0.061835479,
-0.0283152331,
0.4968236983,
-0.3209986091,
-0.0743592381,
0.2138990611,
-0.7616743445,
-0.2354327887,
0.0815123767,
0.7291970849,
-0.4464545846,
0.6268543005,
-0.6870063543,
-0.7157250643,
0.2084208727,
0.5878788829,
1.2319231033,
-0.4549388289,
0.2945244312,
0.3463369906,
0.231125921,
0.2114944607,
0.1064923182,
-0.654122293,
-0.9802974463,
-0.1966820508,
-0.3920470774,
-0.5988498926,
0.0726045817,
-0.5396977067,
0.3050089478,
-0.2853077948,
0.0175674409,
-0.0126648946,
-0.2318692356,
-0.8909995556,
0.2838085294,
0.2699612081,
0.4178723991,
-0.9617426395,
0.7787239552,
0.7857034802,
-0.044630345,
-0.6114989519,
0.3051633239,
-0.2259252667,
-0.3090741336,
0.5551323295,
0.7473370433,
-0.5346956849,
0.0421497039,
-0.2961576879,
-0.5413922668,
0.9623733163,
0.2122610509,
-0.716489017,
-0.0343075655,
0.159319967,
0.2912735045,
-0.9068741202,
0.5011770129,
0.3886121809,
0.1276684403,
0.0752767846,
-0.5551879406,
-0.2259743065,
-0.1762345582,
-0.3395036757,
0.2740393281,
-0.2376089096,
0.4899844229,
-0.2008098811,
-0.302403897,
-0.2550466061,
0.4751449823,
0.1387791634,
0.494176805,
0.579253912,
0.5155978799,
0.5104296207,
-0.1802643389,
0.8651533723,
-0.2902451158,
-0.0197843965,
1.6044334173,
-0.4147414565,
0.7647187114,
0.3316019177,
0.2405759394,
0.5608380437,
0.4241905808,
0.4428126514,
0.9770453572,
-0.2461937368,
-0.4971463382,
-0.3781170547,
-0.0022482614,
-0.2206982076,
0.6884482503,
0.6244894266,
-0.3363173306,
0.0765959099,
0.23585473,
-0.1555701792,
-0.1468583792,
-0.3701625168,
1.2567584515,
-0.1225336343,
-0.5104048848,
0.134265244,
-0.4644773602,
1.0133613348,
-0.6839177012,
0.0688342303,
-0.0527721606,
0.2414856553,
-0.1955586672,
-0.7318840027,
-0.0180131849,
-0.0159163717,
-0.0017024884,
-0.2123851627,
0.7636900544,
-0.547059536,
-0.2563397288,
0.1567871869,
0.0706325024,
0.2812367082,
-0.1812076271,
-0.5090129972,
-0.1896928996,
-0.0882661417,
-0.162693575,
0.0248690527,
0.5914211869,
0.1654297858,
0.3587898612,
0.3130563498,
-0.2955343723,
-0.0114742033,
0.155639708,
0.9367499948,
-0.6671269536,
-0.9431781173,
-0.5713354349,
0.6059794426,
-0.0617741346,
-0.4035949111,
0.3928853869,
0.6105909944,
1.0582418442,
-0.1451653838,
0.6166706681,
0.1705248058,
0.4129346311,
-0.394877702,
0.5147132277,
-0.2628023028,
0.1064564213,
-0.2220751196,
-0.9057230949,
-0.1341494024,
0.6957350373,
-0.5818460584,
0.1371654123,
0.6437729597,
0.5372992158,
-0.3417259455,
0.0955357999,
0.3772715926,
-0.0686623752,
0.1410254389,
0.7025508881,
0.8940727711,
-0.4779914021,
0.7769503593,
-0.4774313867,
-0.1779741496,
-0.4506383538,
-0.7336155772,
-1.0064967871,
-0.4509215951,
-0.3898629546,
0.2592943013,
0.0970155969,
0.7520471215,
0.9848353863,
-0.852144897,
0.0621777922,
-0.2250030339,
-0.104027994,
0.0976154432,
-0.109310396,
0.1277531236,
-0.5618982911,
-0.5234425664,
0.2632218003,
0.4711930752,
0.2712543309,
0.4080150425,
-0.5274860263,
-0.0666573197,
0.2557007372,
0.5927559137,
0.2185729742,
-0.5259420872,
-0.0871441662,
-0.1264321655,
-0.1591900289,
0.2579033077,
1.0540574789,
-0.8226091862,
0.616553545,
0.1835613251,
0.6298642159,
0.7028108835,
0.1187221706,
0.1978836656,
-0.8725575805,
0.3559662104,
0.6465384364,
0.1179074347,
0.2895427942,
-0.4845944643,
0.0380396992,
-0.3639859259,
-0.3636099994,
-0.4768456817,
0.3854534924,
-1.0107401609,
-0.2140243798,
0.6948016882,
-0.4806597829,
-0.0935580358,
-0.3075933754,
-0.3241117895,
0.2591540515,
-0.5370913744,
0.4462674558,
0.3632750213,
-0.4344755411,
-0.3457879126,
0.2555273175,
0.7112045288,
0.3843149543,
-1.02082932,
-0.043436341,
0.3334629238,
-0.0898762345,
0.3113362789,
1.1274261475,
-0.0706926212,
0.5842192769,
0.1721393466,
0.147843048,
-0.1900993735,
-0.6193218827,
-0.3113166988,
-0.1041118428,
0.0618882477,
-0.5738631487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14825v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14825v2 | Large Language Models are In-Context Semantic Reasoners rather than Symbolic Reasoners | 2023-05-24T07:33:34 | 2023-06-08T16:38:51 | Xiaojuan Tang, Zilong Zheng, Jiaqi Li, Fanxu Meng, Song-Chun Zhu, Yitao Liang, Muhan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The emergent few-shot reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs)
have excited the natural language and machine learning community over recent
years. Despite of numerous successful applications, the underlying mechanism of
such in-context capabilities still remains unclear. In this work, we
hypothesize that the learned \textit{semantics} of language tokens do the most
heavy lifting during the reasoning process. Different from human's symbolic
reasoning process, the semantic representations of LLMs could create strong
connections among tokens, thus composing a superficial logical chain. To test
our hypothesis, we decouple semantics from the language reasoning process and
evaluate three kinds of reasoning abilities, i.e., deduction, induction and
abduction. Our findings reveal that semantics play a vital role in LLMs'
in-context reasoning -- LLMs perform significantly better when semantics are
consistent with commonsense but struggle to solve symbolic or
counter-commonsense reasoning tasks by leveraging in-context new knowledge. The
surprising observations question whether modern LLMs have mastered the
inductive, deductive and abductive reasoning abilities as in human
intelligence, and motivate research on unveiling the magic existing within the
black-box LLMs. On the whole, our analysis provides a novel perspective on the
role of semantics in developing and evaluating language models' reasoning
abilities. Code is available at {\url{https://github.com/XiaojuanTang/ICSR}}. | [
-0.3693848252,
-0.6418309212,
0.8653110266,
-0.1359988004,
-0.311420083,
-0.0917204395,
-0.2424055785,
-0.5661031604,
-0.293358624,
0.4609971941,
-0.4345442057,
-0.2612854242,
-0.7163633704,
0.3599827588,
-0.4591526091,
0.8497454524,
0.1610375196,
-0.0679727718,
-0.2717117071,
-0.1622147709,
-0.4167552888,
-0.4346236587,
-0.3361263871,
-0.6123564839,
0.5239602327,
0.3445245922,
0.637259841,
0.4116869271,
0.457437098,
0.3053286672,
-0.2440273911,
0.2182706147,
-0.3385186791,
0.1460020989,
-0.4762117863,
-0.6481972337,
-0.1255455166,
-0.0970102623,
0.660795331,
0.8797734976,
0.237703979,
0.0717138648,
-0.0508326404,
0.5019493699,
-0.5998104811,
0.1695069671,
-1.1246064901,
-0.2376190275,
-0.194883585,
-0.1934092343,
-0.5374389291,
0.075074859,
0.1223544851,
-0.4316518903,
-0.1821197718,
0.1459757984,
0.7777948976,
0.3611578345,
-0.6185463667,
-0.3415964544,
-0.5176228881,
0.7873932719,
-0.6780123711,
0.3294589221,
0.2434703857,
0.3084948957,
-0.5098106265,
-0.6450707912,
-0.7179562449,
-0.3328648806,
-0.2807490826,
-0.3532586396,
-0.1360221207,
0.1244358122,
0.4714298844,
0.097475782,
-0.0750057027,
0.3006837666,
-0.2378317565,
-0.0280282628,
0.2492621839,
0.1975982934,
0.5659974217,
-0.3166255355,
-0.4132326841,
0.2925850451,
-1.0096058846,
-0.0470975004,
-0.044867672,
0.3201598227,
-0.1124008223,
0.7032805681,
-0.0999227688,
0.7109920382,
-0.3143109977,
-0.358204037,
-0.0037486374,
-0.2367079109,
-0.1288015544,
0.2209751457,
0.4782586396,
0.1180680469,
0.4001479447,
-0.270848453,
-0.3077236414,
0.2033779174,
-0.0092381751,
-0.7279726863,
0.1221574768,
0.1176645756,
-0.5198655128,
0.0844526142,
0.1529546082,
-0.0414952636,
-0.2859919071,
-0.5448584557,
0.3587298095,
-0.5417212248,
-0.2631275356,
0.37650159,
-0.4238880575,
0.4477591813,
0.3061852753,
-0.8572393656,
0.3503060341,
1.236682415,
0.5817947984,
-0.034674421,
-0.4115859568,
-0.5787416101,
0.2320167422,
-0.3807976544,
0.6977730989,
-0.7813731432,
-0.0221678633,
-0.1630529761,
0.0081017222,
0.0591798946,
-0.4499747753,
0.4950526059,
-0.5570338964,
-0.2051640451,
-0.4617102146,
-0.6351069212,
-0.1374585181,
0.2553032637,
-0.4285725653,
0.7001454234,
-0.0812287554,
-0.8784707785,
0.688645184,
-0.5875569582,
-0.409889549,
0.3275588453,
-0.2634857595,
0.106852971,
0.3640850782,
-0.0199799631,
0.5168247223,
-0.5524740219,
0.1703496277,
-0.4594544172,
-0.5323648453,
0.7009883523,
-0.3238735199,
0.8346411586,
0.0965633616,
-0.3738669753,
-0.0463460498,
-0.7101367712,
-0.2257253826,
0.1028343067,
-0.2371130586,
-0.5889886022,
0.1628653556,
-0.5212675929,
0.5115089417,
-0.116570048,
-0.5207849741,
0.0046282099,
-0.7006599903,
0.7833814025,
0.747431159,
-0.1512735188,
0.6073506474,
-0.059197817,
0.1608404666,
0.1123596653,
-0.2266742587,
-0.2392255664,
-0.4374497533,
-0.8082033396,
-0.399284184,
0.071477361,
0.1338339895,
-0.5098053813,
0.2880584896,
-0.2977609038,
-0.2433319539,
-0.294100076,
0.2098316252,
0.2559827268,
0.4459329844,
0.2254213542,
0.2165947855,
-0.2765587866,
-0.8168410063,
-0.4234119058,
-0.196526289,
0.025621634,
0.1772788465,
0.8731176853,
-0.2339199036,
0.998662591,
-0.1407903731,
-0.0153930532,
-0.50397259,
-0.1716832072,
0.1057098657,
0.282366097,
0.402030319,
-0.5394439697,
0.1124657169,
0.0077513331,
-0.8610943556,
-0.2058021426,
-0.1283926666,
-0.4055504501,
0.2428519577,
0.5517049432,
-0.9819812775,
0.3443373144,
0.1681873649,
-0.5256201625,
0.5118521452,
-0.1485432386,
-0.295612067,
-0.5764818788,
-0.0316245779,
-0.3574163318,
0.0314803496,
-0.3332824111,
0.1970497072,
-0.1062778756,
0.0599079132,
-0.4277442694,
0.867069006,
-0.548940599,
-0.3273599148,
-0.3404669464,
0.4670117497,
0.0522838682,
0.2316552699,
-0.0482100286,
0.2838628888,
0.565617919,
-0.701749742,
0.2186849564,
0.000688187,
-0.4621408284,
0.4235042334,
-0.6095926762,
-0.0683841482,
-0.3293550014,
0.3619980216,
-1.0164889097,
-0.197310254,
0.067727454,
-0.2824292481,
0.0540386252,
-0.0897796452,
-0.8297656775,
-0.3841331005,
0.0714548305,
0.3815460205,
0.3320670426,
-0.5697421432,
0.6805336475,
0.3333761394,
0.2806200087,
-0.3849555552,
-0.8807789683,
0.1411370784,
-0.3231096566,
-0.5876639485,
0.2136313468,
0.281847626,
-0.8261638284,
0.1127240658,
-0.1057744995,
0.2324635535,
0.3807503581,
0.2582827508,
0.2430143505,
-0.1032545716,
0.6421536803,
0.0528449938,
-0.4063688219,
0.3575279117,
-0.5193251371,
0.3019249439,
-0.2677184641,
-0.6041359305,
-0.3329915404,
0.2043212503,
0.7445620298,
-0.3138158619,
0.9245564342,
0.2077787817,
-0.4500315785,
-0.4225986004,
-0.527954936,
-0.4922295213,
-0.3898952603,
0.2301050276,
-0.5734525323,
-0.9964542985,
0.4540174007,
0.0225311704,
-0.0960727632,
0.4858755469,
0.6152091622,
0.1605611444,
0.8940798044,
0.2647866905,
0.2564629614,
0.06615071,
-0.1331598759,
0.5232204199,
-0.7371928692,
-0.3804567456,
-0.5466139913,
-0.3210377097,
-0.5907547474,
-0.3459226787,
0.1952565014,
0.1338320374,
-0.570022583,
0.0983284488,
-0.3327790797,
0.6282523274,
0.3596169949,
-0.1001419425,
0.3585179746,
-0.1941017956,
-0.2863534987,
0.2563284338,
-0.6056485772,
-0.6711580753,
0.7253525257,
0.4490557015,
0.7317752242,
-0.002778494,
0.6464418769,
-0.2367458194,
0.1399907023,
-0.8871139288,
0.8177587986,
-0.0474415533,
-0.5204215646,
-0.1846293807,
-0.2529351711,
-0.8307278156,
0.4370619953,
-0.1912251413,
-0.8254233599,
-0.1292289346,
-0.1258571744,
-0.0930715948,
0.445997417,
-0.6115611196,
0.8614060283,
-0.2531575561,
-0.3533795774,
-0.3727960289,
-0.7003305554,
0.410049051,
0.205756247,
0.1372096241,
-0.3482725918,
-0.1702448279,
0.5646654963,
-0.5976960063,
0.7755396366,
-0.0566654876,
-0.2796084285,
0.4986136556,
0.3541177809,
0.450730145,
0.067897819,
-0.0245148521,
0.1251337379,
-0.0077470783,
-0.2472932488,
-0.78034091,
0.7195706367,
-0.5684392452,
-0.6966488361,
-0.2544638216,
-0.5014945269,
-0.1327634603,
0.1469506621,
-0.0242782328,
0.5123925209,
0.2242529541,
0.3432917595,
0.4331457615,
-0.0790762976,
0.4734955728,
0.3629545271,
-0.1081992313,
0.0426045172,
0.6119379997,
0.0107926307,
0.4503229558,
0.5318855643,
0.4472838938,
-0.2409671843,
-0.45239833,
-0.135940358,
0.4427671731,
-1.1546436548,
-0.1118418351,
-0.6178171039,
-0.1180994511,
0.0579434037,
-0.3310778737,
-0.1139334664,
-0.4558171332,
-0.1165864319,
-0.2645040154,
0.3391736448,
0.646658957,
0.1870183349,
-0.0028498953,
-0.7035303116,
0.2218623608,
0.4207087159,
0.1736773401,
0.3246065378,
-0.4305846989,
0.0065786974,
-0.0353535414,
0.065153107,
-0.5852000713,
0.0252922457,
-0.1161616817,
0.6683515906,
0.4985641837,
-0.116145283,
0.5810058117,
-0.3725976646,
0.7560163736,
0.0731236413,
-0.8854324222,
0.3877512515,
-0.3274944425,
0.4853076935,
0.3117823303,
0.0914347693,
-0.3766179085,
-0.5264848471,
-0.4978545606,
-0.6399676204,
0.6488096714,
0.1512470096,
0.2468802929,
-0.6261132956,
0.3321189284,
0.1869926304,
0.0727208704,
-0.7028610706,
0.1497779042,
0.087576583,
0.0488003492,
0.2728976011,
-0.4457474351,
-0.0438895188,
-0.3307204545,
0.3526485264,
-0.2686764598,
0.1742174625,
-0.0874101967,
-0.2369585335,
0.1524411142,
0.4553253353,
0.3932336867,
0.7849418521,
0.1108905897,
0.5220614672,
0.2843887508,
0.0832969844,
-0.0631471947,
-0.2028265446,
0.048643399,
-0.3545458317,
0.669246912,
0.7220875025,
0.4829263687,
-0.8759510517,
0.5549524426,
0.1677957028,
-0.0876808986,
-0.2322134525,
0.1202826351,
0.1811698824,
0.2128859758,
0.3559344411,
-0.0522695445,
0.0436165966,
-0.7241017818,
0.0244809985,
0.6786319613,
-0.1040183008,
-0.3260050416,
0.434684515,
0.1125015169,
-0.0867735073,
0.6896021366,
-0.3279835582,
-0.5919222832,
0.4521090388,
0.8280010223,
0.8363102078,
0.3849057257,
-0.1139841005,
0.2521173358,
0.2270599008,
-0.0370251909,
-0.0164906159,
-0.2359908074,
-0.9400067329,
-0.6309546232,
-0.6845943332,
0.0303151086,
-0.0731067806,
-0.0678211153,
0.4069113135,
-0.340519309,
0.1420194507,
-0.0635141432,
-0.3324955404,
-0.5758814812,
-0.0090167671,
0.3308058679,
0.9150823355,
-0.6324729323,
0.5997572541,
0.4010923803,
-0.3950258791,
-0.7461395264,
-0.0806641877,
-0.0141321803,
-0.7035450339,
1.3629598618,
0.4592292011,
-0.4495396614,
-0.1847319901,
-0.5039929152,
-0.7241144776,
0.7167322636,
0.4724636376,
-0.2802884877,
-0.1525552571,
0.146294564,
0.4193599522,
-0.5303928256,
0.3645742536,
0.792668283,
0.4726616144,
0.3046779931,
-0.733476162,
0.3134053648,
0.0312202144,
0.0179265607,
0.3942981064,
-0.2827069163,
0.7100108266,
-0.4455819726,
-0.2077101469,
-0.0330508165,
0.5537329912,
0.4249918163,
0.0451666676,
0.4535041153,
0.6970723271,
0.5843943357,
-0.1137722284,
1.1099479198,
-0.2583892941,
-0.1214093864,
0.8803895116,
-0.2441452295,
0.7190241814,
0.6599444151,
0.0758037865,
0.833701551,
0.1579318941,
0.3618005216,
0.2849496603,
0.4438893497,
-0.2726201117,
-0.6068943143,
-0.1389371008,
0.047290653,
0.8765016794,
0.544962585,
-0.295114249,
-0.4575741291,
0.0383489244,
0.1830585301,
0.0217294935,
-0.3700796068,
0.8115567565,
0.290735662,
-0.8381268978,
0.5656586885,
-0.102807723,
0.3600873053,
-0.5538625121,
-0.1904246509,
0.1716143787,
0.3412022591,
-0.2023156136,
-0.9076149464,
0.3136017621,
-0.1250035614,
0.0901503414,
-0.12411578,
0.9372855425,
-0.0478806235,
-0.2890476882,
0.5148555636,
0.4291552305,
0.1248504594,
0.1166521832,
-0.4708187282,
0.0629558712,
-0.4971998334,
-0.088764742,
0.3155259788,
0.9504979849,
-0.2885659039,
0.8456311226,
0.601918757,
0.1393433064,
-0.1330220848,
0.3067670763,
0.8416947722,
-0.7255333662,
-0.3091956079,
-1.2474745512,
0.5587801337,
0.0752896816,
-0.1999814361,
0.8115848303,
0.3030339479,
0.7845690846,
0.146819517,
0.5745710731,
-0.0316101275,
0.1965467632,
-0.6115717292,
0.4104169905,
-0.5188202262,
0.3006800413,
-0.3378284574,
-0.5940380096,
-0.4895279109,
0.5614483953,
-0.5715165734,
-0.0135488017,
0.8160507679,
0.7266533375,
0.0192512218,
0.0376949273,
0.1965644211,
0.1675686836,
0.3117046356,
0.5840784907,
1.176089406,
0.0459826626,
0.330185473,
0.0812056437,
-0.0974273682,
-0.1941091716,
-1.0785269737,
-1.144307375,
-0.5355167985,
-0.0216166936,
-0.2423673868,
-0.1415029019,
1.0417360067,
0.4028156102,
-0.4544872046,
-0.0548152737,
-0.4143715203,
0.5045250654,
-0.1494839787,
-0.2089568377,
0.2170274407,
-0.7161880732,
-0.4096597731,
0.1908071339,
0.5772291422,
-0.1105845198,
-0.2128913999,
-0.1298341304,
-0.1415353715,
0.0844828859,
0.9733750224,
0.0330910571,
-1.1793037653,
-0.4321712255,
-0.1276180893,
-0.104300119,
-0.276122123,
0.9458687305,
-0.9751750231,
0.3243655562,
0.7224550247,
0.658593297,
0.1798813343,
-0.2343157828,
0.2881404757,
-0.2226882726,
0.3626855314,
0.1250120997,
0.7336230278,
0.2376606762,
-0.039264258,
0.2789491713,
0.2928062677,
-0.4393737614,
-0.9061342478,
0.3369569778,
-0.665225625,
-0.5642769337,
1.4078395367,
0.1972321272,
-0.3601576984,
-0.1163138524,
-0.1740424484,
0.0421922244,
-0.1278329343,
0.4458000064,
0.7299759388,
-0.1242444739,
-0.0823330358,
-0.4007251561,
0.4448011518,
0.1496792883,
-0.5975182652,
0.1878878325,
0.4852530956,
0.1568336934,
0.0253993589,
0.477876395,
-0.2982887328,
0.1817893684,
-0.1372016519,
-0.3034189343,
-0.0537918136,
-0.4178829491,
-0.1542528719,
0.1641744524,
0.4095053077,
0.1179984212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14824v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14824v3 | Mitigating Temporal Misalignment by Discarding Outdated Facts | 2023-05-24T07:30:08 | 2024-03-05T16:32:58 | Michael J. Q. Zhang, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models are able to retain vast amounts of world
knowledge seen during pretraining, such knowledge is prone to going out of date
and is nontrivial to update. Furthermore, these models are often used under
temporal misalignment, tasked with answering questions about the present,
despite having only been trained on data collected in the past. To mitigate the
effects of temporal misalignment, we propose fact duration prediction: the task
of predicting how long a given fact will remain true. In our experiments, we
demonstrate that identifying which facts are prone to rapid change can help
models avoid reciting outdated information and determine which predictions
require seeking out up-to-date knowledge sources. We also show how modeling
fact duration improves calibration for knowledge-intensive tasks, such as
open-retrieval question answering, under temporal misalignment, by discarding
volatile facts. Our data and code are released publicly at
https://github.com/mikejqzhang/mitigating_misalignment. | [
-0.0743333399,
-0.9436600208,
0.7069525719,
0.0981421322,
-0.2215403616,
-0.1221633032,
0.008741281,
-0.5545048714,
-0.3303006887,
0.3503091335,
-0.6720155478,
-0.0233398266,
-0.4998401403,
-0.5484518409,
-0.1316493601,
0.9967520833,
0.0290201791,
-0.0906266272,
-0.5798186064,
-0.2808715999,
-0.7577174902,
-0.2811515331,
-0.4666827321,
-0.684802711,
0.5025373697,
0.6219801307,
1.0210891962,
0.8680074811,
0.3900217116,
0.1316992342,
-0.168343693,
0.1341910064,
-0.4712738693,
0.2601979673,
-0.1837282479,
-0.7500274777,
-0.0623514578,
-0.069974497,
0.6804070473,
0.7689144611,
-0.5252704024,
0.2399466634,
-0.1160600856,
0.8386271,
-0.7909963131,
0.2538528144,
-0.5585678816,
0.0893819183,
-0.5546218753,
-0.5060516,
-0.2467869222,
-0.5139725804,
0.2910841405,
-0.8214100003,
0.1996103972,
0.1984083802,
0.9134764075,
0.6020153761,
-0.2564015388,
0.1251442432,
-1.1284641027,
0.654902339,
-0.7294691801,
0.579348743,
0.639023006,
0.4322547913,
0.0158427116,
-0.3347191513,
-0.620832324,
-0.0007159319,
-0.1185998991,
0.0529641248,
-0.0769398957,
-0.2981902659,
0.6527984142,
-0.1555266976,
-0.7432397008,
0.065848358,
-0.5393010378,
-0.4092654586,
0.2514316142,
0.2628902793,
0.3058809042,
0.1001431644,
-0.3907696903,
0.1351999789,
-1.2294003963,
0.1633423567,
0.4531655014,
-0.0299281646,
0.026471518,
0.6564221382,
0.0211838428,
0.6006678939,
0.2111705691,
-0.224107191,
0.0982042998,
-0.2048746943,
-0.0616944432,
0.2921493053,
0.2978177071,
0.5955104232,
0.1804117411,
-0.4247918129,
0.1100701094,
-0.0114067495,
0.1706901193,
-0.7910838127,
-0.1029036716,
0.1231848821,
-0.1869544238,
0.0520071946,
-0.2329239249,
-0.7806965113,
-0.362739414,
-0.4687225223,
0.4183052182,
-0.4474058449,
-0.1397548169,
0.0689931884,
-0.1959638298,
-0.1740342975,
0.2639330328,
-0.5437509418,
-0.1340504736,
0.4130311906,
0.81719172,
0.2917631567,
-0.2272363454,
-0.600030303,
0.5052535534,
-0.4622140527,
0.5477415919,
-0.4800071716,
-0.269480437,
-0.2085270882,
0.0624623112,
-0.0701173916,
-0.3990740776,
0.3869793117,
-0.7764593363,
0.4530932605,
-0.2938397229,
-0.4112246037,
-0.1294798851,
0.2738623917,
-0.919238627,
0.7978956103,
-0.1810974628,
-1.1320072412,
0.3581961095,
-0.4678176045,
-0.3217331767,
-0.2911672592,
0.0917444974,
-0.7447747588,
0.0063799745,
0.2006880939,
0.0880437717,
-0.1654990166,
0.5987619162,
-0.1828636527,
-0.3841973245,
0.341245234,
-0.3718236089,
0.5463616252,
0.4865506589,
-0.1603621542,
-0.1652813107,
-0.4049713016,
-0.3950095475,
0.0695519075,
-0.274392277,
-0.3775309324,
0.5300586224,
-0.5907495618,
0.4058457315,
0.2476739138,
-0.6389224529,
0.0435640104,
-0.3253740966,
0.1227232814,
0.7320978045,
0.309486568,
0.5043591261,
-0.9503417015,
0.395635426,
0.5493422151,
0.2990711033,
0.0639205724,
-0.2051454782,
-0.8129535913,
0.3928967416,
0.1686746776,
0.6822361946,
-0.9729620218,
-0.0608636886,
-0.5511996746,
-0.5796288848,
-0.0285992734,
-0.0562971495,
0.3180885911,
0.7219424844,
0.3919197917,
-0.0596886128,
-0.6963679194,
-0.5554490685,
-0.5026011467,
-0.3258381784,
0.1033891588,
-0.0933943391,
0.2301973104,
-0.0627847761,
1.0384722948,
-0.6943241954,
0.1688561887,
0.2494128644,
0.5468397737,
-0.2128921449,
0.4905782938,
0.4702398777,
-0.7455707192,
0.1198263168,
-0.3242356181,
-0.4939309061,
-0.0375152454,
-0.3401651382,
-0.022831127,
0.5094019771,
0.8068175912,
-0.8095036149,
0.5100088716,
0.3290892541,
-0.2826887071,
0.6573162079,
0.0834183469,
0.0851681978,
-0.5869598389,
0.3721535802,
-0.0044366079,
-0.3053167462,
-0.3375278711,
-0.5595183969,
0.0903751925,
-0.2784885168,
-0.5668743253,
0.7342016101,
-0.3143107891,
0.3344257176,
0.1121434048,
0.2179034054,
0.0061882702,
0.2843757272,
0.0966404378,
0.7363659143,
0.1093856022,
-1.0068080425,
-0.1360601187,
-0.0135501493,
-0.6502506733,
0.1052962467,
-0.3366810083,
-0.1179410741,
-0.4689259827,
-0.0992593616,
-0.6631862521,
0.1319320649,
0.1998451501,
-0.5730566978,
0.5175414085,
-0.2657290399,
-0.3135452271,
-0.3001674414,
-0.0240357462,
0.3182646632,
0.3040452003,
-0.3152384758,
0.3895228207,
0.203490451,
-0.4383550286,
-0.9547412395,
-0.7298026681,
-0.5448365211,
-0.3078739941,
-0.4543938339,
0.3162169755,
-0.3817937076,
-0.3388814926,
0.2386660576,
-0.6376425028,
0.0127673857,
0.1699964702,
0.197498858,
0.2538274527,
-0.0608373396,
0.9216162562,
-0.1577123106,
-0.2820576131,
0.2075089663,
-0.1558329016,
0.4903704226,
0.2725087404,
-0.361525476,
-0.1098332554,
0.1190293804,
0.8395934105,
-0.2663792968,
1.0180424452,
0.6023517251,
-0.4688666463,
0.2473321706,
-0.874469161,
-0.1740552634,
-0.4053121805,
0.3183954358,
0.0809799805,
-0.7223929167,
0.4122659862,
-0.1636315137,
0.1988245547,
0.4759950936,
0.2137709409,
-0.1262278855,
0.9503396749,
0.6755609512,
-0.1495820284,
0.8718949556,
0.0120725222,
0.3543273807,
-0.5154101253,
-0.326358825,
-0.5251380801,
-0.1687994748,
-0.2766512036,
-0.4435067773,
0.2710133195,
0.2488921136,
-0.612318635,
-0.0924811736,
-0.0124468179,
0.5930943489,
0.2977605164,
0.1416401863,
0.193479687,
-0.204091534,
0.0047215587,
-0.2183255553,
-0.7056259513,
-0.3174626827,
1.0598431826,
0.2087753266,
0.869527638,
0.1713238955,
0.1887451708,
0.1277916878,
0.085921973,
-0.4112673402,
0.3182973266,
0.1485524625,
-0.8045393825,
-0.4599232376,
-0.7111687064,
-0.7058881521,
-0.2915733755,
-0.205556646,
-0.6261601448,
0.1632041782,
0.276568681,
-0.5036249161,
0.4923990071,
-0.601485908,
0.8082770705,
-0.2824519873,
-0.3746981323,
-0.2925175428,
-0.7804310322,
0.251216352,
-0.0325853936,
0.2533432245,
-0.3821827471,
0.1958902031,
0.8420476317,
-0.2892127931,
0.9244680405,
-0.4597843587,
0.2748833895,
0.2952761054,
0.3296356201,
0.5009268522,
-0.0304112639,
0.0538075231,
-0.0908382386,
0.2650402486,
-0.4650943279,
-0.7095846534,
0.5311363935,
-0.7038617134,
-0.580966115,
-0.5760538578,
-0.6983006597,
-0.2890583277,
-0.067270942,
0.2921249866,
0.4505463243,
-0.3380660117,
0.1240913123,
0.8608890176,
0.1136552319,
0.6820661426,
0.9257782698,
-0.1094989926,
-0.0255099423,
0.7251033187,
0.5161427855,
0.3662597835,
0.5914024711,
0.3975809216,
-0.4938389063,
-0.4290183783,
0.0529052205,
0.2608622313,
-0.5526385307,
-0.4282565713,
-0.4827336669,
-0.0941237807,
-0.3175077736,
0.1180616319,
-0.1032716036,
-1.032194376,
-0.2026598155,
-0.2246553302,
0.4691222906,
0.3142868578,
-0.2584241629,
0.4956603646,
-0.907908082,
0.0650525764,
0.2598067522,
0.3497100472,
0.0272505563,
-0.4427675009,
-0.4446066022,
0.224187389,
-0.5896228552,
-0.5980544686,
0.2505527735,
0.2003220022,
0.7362386584,
0.4571125805,
0.1928478628,
0.9171459675,
-0.4322027564,
0.8047727346,
0.2500109971,
-0.793446362,
0.6275267601,
-0.2171455026,
0.592284739,
0.2519934773,
0.5570554733,
-0.8810593486,
-0.3050783575,
-0.5155032277,
-0.7385163307,
0.6385130882,
-0.1635559499,
-0.3368290663,
0.0355096832,
0.4566795528,
0.0658134371,
0.2995525002,
-0.5967991352,
-0.1391011477,
-0.3684672713,
-0.0292132124,
-0.2470238209,
-0.4058597386,
-0.2769640386,
-0.1233680695,
1.0222415924,
0.0190867074,
0.2899859846,
0.090390943,
-0.4663930237,
-0.4425151348,
0.4715645313,
0.8839839697,
1.0210686922,
-0.2580007315,
-0.0262509324,
0.1606109738,
-0.4842397869,
0.0706483051,
0.1918819696,
-0.3122802973,
-0.0266256034,
0.2781383097,
0.631878376,
0.0849688873,
-0.4946652353,
0.3887417614,
0.1465532035,
0.1437386274,
-0.3754335344,
-0.103279151,
0.1964450628,
0.0996636599,
0.2137433738,
0.4180848897,
-0.262419194,
-0.4466899335,
0.1430473775,
0.0025339697,
-0.5124337673,
-0.3234878182,
0.5247782469,
0.0193075165,
0.1221015155,
0.7892513871,
0.0852162465,
-0.4226775765,
0.6605336666,
0.6143978238,
0.3686678112,
-0.6849639416,
0.1699641049,
0.5116285682,
0.2881435156,
-0.3313747048,
0.1590369642,
0.0610877685,
-0.6815678477,
-0.4708393812,
-0.3327422142,
-0.2180012614,
0.1190222278,
-0.5362889171,
0.114603892,
-0.3940967023,
-0.4666851461,
-0.3210186362,
0.0961010009,
-0.7557383776,
0.3107958734,
0.0032167034,
0.810174346,
-1.106210947,
0.6843132377,
0.2835662365,
-0.5006811619,
-0.5999376178,
0.1229230314,
0.2886326313,
-0.5376726389,
0.6367701888,
0.0199740436,
-0.1930203736,
-0.4620898366,
-0.5782463551,
-0.9893254638,
1.2738839388,
0.5911804438,
-0.7698543072,
-0.289241612,
0.0619860403,
0.2099433094,
0.1141842976,
-0.0493678376,
0.573759079,
0.5725519061,
0.1295001805,
-0.7745527029,
0.0017503289,
-0.3540522158,
-0.2020598501,
0.5586976409,
-0.4891248643,
0.9528977275,
-0.384884119,
-0.610644877,
0.0208094306,
0.4357091784,
-0.0413006544,
0.5401859879,
0.5162889957,
0.9024134278,
1.0319103003,
-0.39390558,
0.6172947288,
-0.2470279187,
0.1786297113,
1.3568563461,
-0.1453715861,
0.5738435984,
0.5681179166,
0.1542069912,
0.4639244378,
0.4821026623,
0.2878225744,
0.7439870238,
-0.0809668824,
-0.2619920671,
-0.427062571,
-0.0621908493,
-0.605868578,
0.3033514023,
0.5268731713,
0.1252895892,
-0.3890149891,
-0.0496345758,
0.3148669899,
-0.0416389816,
-0.20819965,
0.5569853783,
-0.1773604006,
-0.8635799289,
0.3766001463,
-0.356105566,
0.1619675457,
-0.7420045137,
0.0064236769,
-0.1378117055,
0.2784828544,
-0.127355665,
-0.8001160026,
0.6479166746,
-0.4579595923,
-0.5372956991,
-0.1308759898,
0.5714844465,
-0.6511338353,
-0.233148396,
0.0782917291,
0.6608785987,
-0.2830870748,
0.1286444813,
-0.4489971399,
-0.095720157,
-0.1892944872,
0.0401021913,
0.137445733,
0.6914618611,
-0.2808510661,
1.0496567488,
0.4787027836,
0.0219594799,
0.076220572,
-0.1079595312,
0.8476747274,
-0.8349599838,
-0.5014057755,
-0.7950400114,
0.4539795518,
0.0826806203,
-0.0515168011,
0.6186317801,
0.6296306849,
0.7125867605,
-0.0512272641,
0.5500171185,
0.0725469515,
0.7805740833,
-0.9370419383,
0.835467875,
-0.5338438749,
0.3637356758,
0.0838792622,
-0.6172718406,
-0.2337281257,
0.1642298102,
-0.6113572717,
-0.1418708861,
0.8781050444,
0.8582058549,
0.0037934151,
0.1063990369,
0.2070648968,
0.3007564843,
0.3966421485,
0.5475539565,
0.9835126996,
-0.0677984133,
0.7221963406,
-0.4476236105,
0.1285734028,
-0.3808576167,
-1.1605956554,
-0.5343084335,
-0.7253078818,
-0.530975163,
-0.1463102847,
0.4011609256,
0.475643456,
0.8255184293,
-0.6429184675,
0.1185817197,
0.1480109096,
0.2966395617,
-0.3218145669,
-0.218738988,
0.2517020702,
-0.3392125368,
-0.0222089253,
0.1358606368,
-0.0721848235,
0.4878807962,
0.2098609656,
0.1805676818,
-0.4844798446,
0.0892846808,
0.3626420498,
0.6440659761,
-0.5237157941,
-0.7333093286,
0.0315491483,
0.1152123958,
0.2281320989,
1.0435603857,
-0.8600131273,
0.5533248186,
0.567406714,
0.2404991686,
0.5580748916,
0.1568163931,
0.6196778417,
-0.9562402368,
0.2862958014,
0.2868296802,
0.3577234745,
0.4599263668,
-0.4955213368,
0.4159412682,
0.1782075763,
-0.7089463472,
-0.473628968,
0.2444771528,
-0.5694214702,
-0.3986954093,
0.5796519518,
-0.040964637,
-0.281880796,
-0.3548030257,
-0.0025900428,
0.5673407912,
-0.3188227415,
0.913069725,
1.0555560589,
0.0647565648,
-0.2324317396,
-0.5248767138,
0.602378726,
0.3670593202,
-0.6657304764,
0.3595710695,
0.6001557112,
0.5085147023,
0.4504203796,
0.4601813555,
-0.3514040112,
0.5297456384,
-0.114564307,
-0.1197851747,
-0.2355009764,
-0.7244147658,
-0.0884533599,
-0.3123647571,
0.0958246216,
-0.2109518796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18330v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18330v1 | #REVAL: a semantic evaluation framework for hashtag recommendation | 2023-05-24T07:10:56 | 2023-05-24T07:10:56 | Areej Alsini, Du Q. Huynh, Amitava Datta | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Automatic evaluation of hashtag recommendation models is a fundamental task
in many online social network systems. In the traditional evaluation method,
the recommended hashtags from an algorithm are firstly compared with the ground
truth hashtags for exact correspondences. The number of exact matches is then
used to calculate the hit rate, hit ratio, precision, recall, or F1-score. This
way of evaluating hashtag similarities is inadequate as it ignores the semantic
correlation between the recommended and ground truth hashtags. To tackle this
problem, we propose a novel semantic evaluation framework for hashtag
recommendation, called #REval. This framework includes an internal module
referred to as BERTag, which automatically learns the hashtag embeddings. We
investigate on how the #REval framework performs under different word embedding
methods and different numbers of synonyms and hashtags in the recommendation
using our proposed #REval-hit-ratio measure. Our experiments of the proposed
framework on three large datasets show that #REval gave more meaningful hashtag
synonyms for hashtag recommendation evaluation. Our analysis also highlights
the sensitivity of the framework to the word embedding technique, with #REval
based on BERTag more superior over #REval based on FastText and Word2Vec. | [
-0.5070995092,
-0.545422852,
0.3228629529,
0.2126074284,
-0.5793592334,
0.1111873165,
-0.262719214,
-0.4246509373,
0.4434797764,
-0.0848020241,
-0.5744799376,
-0.6443157792,
-0.4302760065,
-0.0580563508,
-0.3134172857,
1.0173585415,
0.0429087877,
0.1830153167,
-0.3414660096,
-0.0451473519,
-0.8706632257,
0.1561782062,
-0.3487750292,
-0.5344500542,
0.7788951993,
0.1883356124,
0.6817808151,
0.3104717135,
0.8882704377,
0.2472121418,
0.1132974103,
0.1181655526,
-0.7284789085,
0.3911041915,
-0.5161393881,
0.2174739838,
-0.2051051557,
-0.1797630936,
0.5124340057,
0.459996134,
-0.2228571475,
0.3972316086,
-0.2485914081,
0.8421695828,
-0.7130547166,
-0.1229198501,
-0.8334471583,
-0.2227799296,
0.1050023809,
-0.0976542756,
-0.0188176893,
-0.5952470899,
0.2289498746,
-0.5420343876,
0.1929077953,
0.1823777705,
0.9395232797,
-0.1103712469,
-0.0173561703,
-0.2577835619,
-0.4086427093,
0.683603406,
-0.3960403502,
0.6548025012,
0.3661923707,
0.6671606302,
-0.1555861533,
-0.6663158536,
-0.6870826483,
0.0979643241,
0.1554118693,
-0.1058082432,
-0.2948224247,
-0.0070669376,
-0.213395372,
0.5179028511,
-0.4980430007,
-0.2950249314,
0.101188466,
-0.1371357441,
0.3227846026,
0.1834810823,
0.1730080396,
-0.1055107117,
-0.6321376562,
-0.3435377479,
-0.2834143639,
-0.3532857895,
0.428763628,
0.4350164831,
0.2382612079,
0.3895931542,
-0.2616903484,
0.5027745366,
0.1504114866,
0.0891092718,
0.5951305032,
-0.6052303314,
-0.3159083128,
-0.1263861805,
0.7395854592,
0.7622395754,
0.4759521484,
-0.5152205825,
-0.3637823462,
0.2162771821,
0.6222111583,
-0.9125075936,
-0.2421402037,
0.0924116224,
-0.4378276467,
-0.5601626635,
0.483061403,
-0.5645799041,
-0.3440456092,
0.105153434,
0.8403801322,
-0.6374043226,
-0.2412853241,
0.2006186396,
-0.6118161678,
0.3827833831,
0.289422214,
-0.5070361495,
0.2477652878,
1.0285880566,
0.6803942919,
0.088346757,
-0.1828504354,
-0.2116985917,
-0.0058945436,
-0.2519969344,
1.1430200338,
-0.9341652989,
-0.5702255368,
0.241123274,
-0.0148031441,
0.2022122741,
-0.3065095842,
0.381829083,
-0.8921476603,
-0.1780105084,
-0.7425984144,
-0.6597151756,
-0.5457533002,
0.3709297776,
-0.5793802738,
0.7827111483,
0.0711199045,
-0.7261289954,
0.9161857963,
-0.4036138058,
-0.6216896176,
0.2430983037,
0.007961194,
-0.356117785,
-0.0393680967,
0.0086572655,
0.3875376582,
-0.4926936924,
0.3171792626,
-0.6895807385,
-0.625888288,
0.3767525554,
-0.0974551961,
0.3408924639,
0.0972856507,
0.0299532246,
0.2046080232,
-0.487357378,
0.3340884745,
0.119731918,
-0.0738603398,
-0.6293600202,
-0.197199434,
0.3944357634,
-0.1025730297,
0.116690591,
-0.6340764761,
0.1448375434,
-0.4407552481,
-0.0334044136,
0.9567212462,
0.2782818973,
0.2797718644,
-0.815895617,
0.2781495154,
-0.543921113,
-0.0959685519,
-0.12168587,
-0.6272783279,
-0.5504119992,
-0.2681545019,
0.5699108243,
0.0726676285,
-0.5074781775,
0.7025988698,
-0.5861331224,
-0.7071568966,
-0.8333376646,
0.1068684757,
0.6056970358,
-0.051783558,
0.2920297682,
-0.5255555511,
-0.6049740314,
-0.7429224253,
-0.6114310026,
-0.3223345578,
0.1820407212,
0.3012973666,
0.3348930478,
-0.4756632447,
0.7674875855,
-0.3112127483,
-0.6331264973,
0.051214084,
0.1729941815,
0.2105870396,
0.2641148865,
0.3340962529,
-0.5710371733,
-0.421127528,
-0.1746075004,
-0.2246470451,
-0.2625874877,
-0.0050377003,
-0.29426229,
-0.1393645555,
-0.0929745883,
-0.1305983067,
0.3438028693,
0.3695051372,
-0.4226396382,
0.1792881936,
0.0564896762,
0.2453421205,
-1.041377306,
0.1379753798,
-0.0880634785,
-0.3263436258,
-0.1586283296,
0.2632853687,
-0.0087554697,
0.3163135946,
-0.192945987,
0.6999168992,
-0.1752758026,
-0.0838831738,
-0.2639875412,
0.2120081335,
0.1623476297,
0.3266140521,
-0.2929520011,
0.4585852921,
0.1622988284,
-0.3866992295,
0.5181131363,
0.188093394,
-0.3784234226,
0.7201530337,
-0.899019599,
0.3705017567,
0.1744651943,
0.2292578965,
-1.5904989243,
0.1643769741,
0.1441945583,
-0.683175981,
0.2044827044,
-0.1994343102,
-0.7683193088,
-0.2565921545,
-0.8028119802,
0.5147303939,
0.5229925513,
-0.5466240048,
0.3438234627,
0.3451650143,
0.5512444973,
-0.5371021628,
-0.5268586278,
0.0060128812,
0.1842365414,
-0.5634058714,
0.6329004765,
-0.0507092699,
-0.207661435,
0.2550854683,
-0.0539540872,
0.1561323255,
-0.0251518805,
0.7217918634,
0.0780870318,
0.1225748211,
0.522187829,
-0.0831794888,
-0.1718439162,
-0.239133209,
-0.3659074605,
0.748814106,
-0.6327533126,
-0.3624367416,
-0.3446967602,
-0.0533937886,
0.2361628711,
0.0732946098,
0.4707708359,
1.1938818693,
-0.3999993503,
-0.0324958302,
-0.8177472353,
-0.1112001389,
-0.4660587609,
0.2360093445,
-0.3557665944,
-0.5591267347,
0.3231287301,
0.1045616567,
-0.02966539,
0.4482982755,
0.7453139424,
-0.040945705,
0.3999606669,
0.5887110233,
0.0123869199,
0.4246453941,
-0.344974488,
0.0458669066,
-0.8915076256,
-0.2772889435,
-0.3572520018,
-0.514732182,
-0.566824913,
-0.5432929397,
-0.2718803287,
-0.024763409,
-0.2070422769,
0.6494227052,
-0.5694965124,
0.3106702864,
0.4331695437,
0.1333097368,
0.3024665713,
0.0683072656,
-0.1208258495,
-0.0385939628,
-0.3111290932,
-0.2295227647,
1.0704009533,
0.2277951092,
0.9093017578,
0.3100008667,
0.7420930266,
0.6999812126,
0.5513210893,
-1.2588255405,
0.491663903,
0.0036066023,
-0.6492913961,
-0.1179597154,
-0.1825080067,
-0.9528501034,
0.1197291315,
-0.3099555075,
-0.2031119317,
0.1912355274,
-0.3261769414,
-0.1032953337,
0.1847581118,
-0.3446258903,
0.6528396606,
0.0131072896,
-0.1064908653,
-0.4414088726,
-0.5090347528,
-0.1166060716,
-0.0801955238,
0.1823793352,
-0.3472070396,
-0.2247086316,
1.0480525494,
-0.2877538204,
0.6791994572,
-0.0900909603,
0.0166579075,
0.2430644631,
0.3569941521,
0.1498564333,
0.1437823921,
-0.1235400811,
0.4033457637,
0.1618700176,
-0.0128992181,
-0.4990878403,
1.0937324762,
-0.5040061474,
-0.0996591747,
-0.4640938044,
-0.152630955,
-0.0897251293,
0.5422756076,
-0.1330959052,
0.2640054226,
-0.7106924653,
0.2291955352,
0.2188273668,
0.0529457591,
0.3865657747,
0.6240341067,
-0.6192703843,
-0.8637236357,
1.0174883604,
-0.0533402711,
-0.0782625452,
0.40194875,
0.3266494572,
-0.2531879544,
-0.1525091678,
-0.2333626896,
0.2872005999,
-0.6825900674,
-0.556423068,
-0.5496131778,
0.2672960758,
-0.5008170009,
-0.203021571,
-0.2298556119,
-0.2415591329,
0.1521262676,
-0.0395918787,
0.6937041879,
0.7508756518,
-0.0847224295,
0.0817291439,
-0.3908064663,
0.5206547976,
0.3900909126,
1.0156995058,
0.1387764364,
-0.6219069362,
-0.1138787791,
-0.0094900625,
-0.1114959419,
-0.8288334608,
0.0866661668,
0.3510973752,
0.4326091409,
0.4832639098,
0.1196366176,
0.8093652129,
-0.5331053734,
0.3377324939,
0.3183195591,
-0.6746487617,
0.2633731067,
-0.2446962744,
0.2279857844,
1.0965571404,
0.1907685548,
-0.561442256,
0.153202191,
-0.5761760473,
-0.8496323228,
0.1496945173,
0.2302865684,
0.4399311543,
-0.3942548931,
0.2454759032,
0.2995518148,
0.4111073017,
-0.2741267979,
-0.1351991445,
-0.0454736166,
-0.026669126,
0.2470070571,
-0.2707009912,
-0.2138215303,
-0.2673973143,
0.5983650088,
0.1773385406,
0.5403078794,
0.1475530267,
0.0519125573,
-0.4580290914,
-0.1141490862,
-0.0859631449,
0.5204427242,
-0.6305849552,
-0.208183229,
0.0658867434,
-0.5135481358,
-0.0810127184,
-0.024943376,
0.1741740257,
0.1994086355,
0.3414721191,
0.3410842419,
0.3289991915,
-0.6017292738,
0.9304258823,
-0.2514484823,
0.0850340948,
-0.4542844892,
-0.1503620446,
-0.0364951119,
0.0732575431,
0.26739797,
0.1183398888,
0.3603290021,
-0.6154215336,
0.5153421164,
0.6816940904,
-1.1338479519,
-0.2943181694,
-0.0016269024,
0.263928622,
-0.6139605045,
0.3890509903,
-0.220146507,
-0.5532401204,
0.3955205381,
0.5340830684,
1.4183998108,
0.0108227646,
0.0778552145,
0.2196326703,
0.2126578987,
0.0859590471,
0.5113220811,
-0.2289079428,
-0.849761188,
-0.2042127699,
-0.891563952,
-0.1211544722,
-0.3495564461,
-0.763892591,
0.4642072916,
-0.7307578921,
-0.3386645913,
0.1013054401,
-0.099082835,
-0.9509872198,
0.1526015401,
-0.0453095697,
0.9033289552,
-0.5571724772,
0.665292263,
0.918836534,
-0.5433935523,
-0.3859265745,
0.2885739505,
-0.1541989595,
-0.9932246208,
0.561760962,
0.3676888943,
-0.4756924808,
-0.1310697347,
-0.2487400472,
-0.3845247924,
1.0805339813,
-0.1957354248,
-0.3746953905,
0.3043141365,
-0.4780833125,
0.8084590435,
-0.3964085579,
0.3719293475,
0.0948959887,
0.5780866742,
0.3567112088,
-0.9402054548,
0.4457397163,
-0.3350440562,
0.1450293213,
0.2648509741,
-0.5222808719,
0.2998196781,
-0.4371439815,
-0.3613558412,
0.1578782499,
0.4557421803,
-0.0578021631,
0.4479159117,
0.482930541,
0.8318848014,
0.2660117745,
0.0175770838,
1.1076411009,
-0.0717705861,
0.6726569533,
1.1155222654,
-0.2368367612,
0.9642345309,
0.4952386916,
-0.4870827198,
0.7953050733,
0.5834436417,
-0.3076805174,
0.7617287636,
0.4312455654,
0.1649183035,
-0.3594432473,
-0.3124118745,
-0.6993089914,
0.2924130857,
0.1870575696,
-0.4160144329,
-0.3118893206,
-0.2979563773,
-0.1085331291,
0.1813227683,
0.1013962999,
1.1501005888,
0.0239945836,
-0.1937943846,
0.6469544172,
0.0812016428,
0.6170442104,
-0.3672266603,
-0.3902435303,
0.0097076334,
0.0564197823,
-0.1349540502,
-0.8679445982,
0.1064139009,
-0.4258059263,
-0.0847680345,
0.0971710086,
0.8183704019,
-0.2435618937,
-0.6305850744,
0.5996661186,
0.1940174848,
0.0390054099,
-0.2378910035,
-0.7579801679,
0.1650573909,
-0.3936133683,
0.0808900371,
0.2057801783,
0.3289368749,
0.2864534259,
0.6448569894,
0.8072365522,
-0.1150894463,
-0.5350157619,
0.33273983,
1.101968646,
-0.6080183983,
-0.3306321204,
-0.834839642,
0.0357835442,
-0.1176381409,
-0.2523952425,
0.8414444327,
0.3645161092,
0.8322830796,
0.2046362609,
0.739798665,
-0.219766736,
0.4353477061,
0.0344305374,
0.582457602,
-0.4837327898,
0.5317900777,
-0.8228031993,
-1.3138427734,
-0.3830983341,
0.5924614668,
-0.3870993257,
0.3357328475,
0.5552766919,
0.7737102509,
0.0174529254,
-0.0290414244,
0.3011822999,
-0.0804830194,
0.1516773552,
0.379024893,
0.6368054748,
-0.861497283,
0.4520944953,
-0.0563385077,
-0.2022385597,
-0.6741101146,
-0.8743519783,
-0.9863934517,
-0.6240011454,
-0.1097420156,
-0.8016566634,
0.5301163197,
1.0650107861,
0.3699862063,
-0.8329956532,
-0.0483640209,
0.0719866157,
0.3162202239,
-0.4045134485,
-0.2683897614,
0.3514662683,
-0.2167453021,
-0.2387909889,
0.1435171962,
0.2591512203,
-0.2378258556,
-0.2893284261,
-0.055933997,
-0.482411623,
0.1209324747,
0.2336489409,
-0.1724268496,
-0.8168885708,
-0.4830860496,
-0.1266400516,
-0.1749957055,
-0.2912324071,
0.7126179338,
-1.0056413412,
1.0759752989,
0.9668340087,
0.6568111777,
0.1876036823,
0.2258420736,
0.6430431008,
-0.3209993839,
-0.2695555687,
-0.0148371663,
0.1678764969,
0.4027977288,
-0.042052269,
0.4762980938,
0.4120772779,
-0.325235337,
-0.7915039062,
0.1084083244,
-1.0867593288,
-0.2595846653,
1.4683548212,
-0.035082601,
-0.0455013588,
-0.1568120718,
-0.2430426627,
0.3197813928,
-0.7264497876,
0.8923521638,
0.535439074,
0.4235736728,
0.3727145195,
0.0338275582,
0.2891685665,
0.2336716354,
0.1407709569,
-0.1398130655,
0.1454275399,
0.3599789441,
0.2027225643,
0.3755605817,
-0.2482886463,
0.4277900457,
-0.0337593295,
0.2550572455,
-0.4136945009,
-0.2268125862,
-0.3021510541,
-0.0546601154,
0.1170399338,
-0.3686114848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14815v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14815v4 | Machine Reading Comprehension using Case-based Reasoning | 2023-05-24T07:09:56 | 2023-12-05T20:59:58 | Dung Thai, Dhruv Agarwal, Mudit Chaudhary, Wenlong Zhao, Rajarshi Das, Manzil Zaheer, Jay-Yoon Lee, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Andrew McCallum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | We present an accurate and interpretable method for answer extraction in
machine reading comprehension that is reminiscent of case-based reasoning (CBR)
from classical AI. Our method (CBR-MRC) builds upon the hypothesis that
contextualized answers to similar questions share semantic similarities with
each other. Given a test question, CBR-MRC first retrieves a set of similar
cases from a nonparametric memory and then predicts an answer by selecting the
span in the test context that is most similar to the contextualized
representations of answers in the retrieved cases. The semi-parametric nature
of our approach allows it to attribute a prediction to the specific set of
evidence cases, making it a desirable choice for building reliable and
debuggable QA systems. We show that CBR-MRC provides high accuracy comparable
with large reader models and outperforms baselines by 11.5 and 8.4 EM on
NaturalQuestions and NewsQA, respectively. Further, we demonstrate the ability
of CBR-MRC in identifying not just the correct answer tokens but also the span
with the most relevant supporting evidence. Lastly, we observe that contexts
for certain question types show higher lexical diversity than others and find
that CBR-MRC is robust to these variations while performance using
fully-parametric methods drops. | [
-0.5065758824,
-1.1449444294,
0.7288036346,
-0.159264192,
-0.2644635737,
0.1786789894,
0.225184679,
-0.3481940329,
-0.0418907478,
0.6435705423,
-0.5010731816,
-0.3604183793,
-0.3730311692,
0.4440539181,
-0.4203992784,
0.86695683,
-0.0574695058,
-0.0262533575,
-0.6261737347,
-0.532438457,
-0.5949500799,
-0.7053412795,
-0.5757151842,
-0.2667661011,
0.6492293477,
0.535508275,
0.6873887777,
0.6892689466,
0.48292014,
0.1493885964,
-0.2903541625,
0.1444413066,
-0.0286746733,
0.1804005951,
-0.2187706977,
-0.505472064,
-0.0626967251,
-0.3136481345,
0.3733416796,
0.7166608572,
-0.2955487072,
0.1867313236,
-0.1607752442,
0.8250462413,
-0.5385004878,
0.0657176971,
-0.661771059,
-0.0384983979,
0.0656815246,
-0.3627063334,
-0.7065419555,
-0.187822625,
0.1191909835,
-0.4304741025,
0.4359741807,
0.1766562164,
0.7738654017,
0.4340031445,
-0.7804628015,
-0.5060071349,
-0.4655461013,
0.7585808635,
-0.5848971605,
0.3229340017,
0.7292408943,
0.7213645577,
0.0785757229,
-0.5852573514,
-0.8295040131,
-0.0868240893,
-0.1313287467,
0.5253278613,
0.1767199337,
-0.1918246597,
0.2705243826,
0.1431782991,
-0.8135296106,
-0.3326016366,
-0.4215112627,
-0.2224751413,
0.2885417938,
0.3403153718,
0.2348808795,
-0.3518848419,
-0.0710200146,
-0.13684313,
-0.5895349979,
0.297682941,
-0.0043132287,
0.2750865519,
0.3587969542,
0.8518896103,
-0.3240996003,
1.0188484192,
-0.0692692325,
0.034506321,
0.0170759615,
-0.4513341486,
-0.1278127432,
0.162257567,
0.2540902793,
0.1432869583,
0.3424560428,
-0.127157256,
0.0697629005,
-0.2911907434,
0.393509686,
-0.7305917144,
-0.1464459747,
0.4574044943,
-0.5771164894,
-0.0030215275,
0.2721032798,
-0.6840244532,
-0.1217129678,
-0.3219980299,
0.2316731811,
-0.4778607488,
0.0357065611,
0.1610617042,
-0.3411305845,
0.6386679411,
0.0807528496,
-0.6843987107,
0.1582113355,
0.5252590775,
0.6167769432,
-0.1279376745,
0.1175061762,
-0.8144353628,
0.307287395,
-0.2463977784,
1.0951266289,
-0.6549506783,
-0.322568208,
0.1039891466,
0.1936674565,
-0.2284120023,
-0.7450973988,
0.5071097016,
-1.0678759813,
0.3587727845,
-0.3210474551,
-0.5657049417,
-0.2764114141,
0.5213087201,
-0.7595895529,
0.9809284806,
0.0571323931,
-0.9786357284,
0.3072134256,
-0.471457839,
-0.7828302979,
-0.1701409668,
0.2060803175,
-0.5487615466,
-0.0837060735,
0.6348273158,
0.324256897,
0.0618666224,
0.0400066301,
-0.6391685009,
-0.3326425552,
0.4236071706,
-0.4272067249,
0.8587545753,
0.3793837428,
-0.1012344807,
-0.0280978493,
-0.5727421641,
0.2560696006,
0.0406582654,
-0.3175620735,
-0.4304266274,
0.1612780094,
-0.1724837869,
0.0420968309,
0.0827179179,
-0.4983049631,
-0.0210318491,
-0.1954566538,
0.5605100989,
0.4568602145,
0.2634623647,
0.2590414882,
-0.3724317551,
0.6280786395,
0.1247926876,
-0.1270937473,
-0.275960952,
-0.3546243012,
-0.5523251295,
-0.6259541512,
0.5712928772,
0.9740552306,
-0.8863286376,
0.3295438886,
0.041794844,
-0.1942551136,
-0.3942855597,
-0.1951964051,
0.2450970709,
0.8305155635,
0.6428171396,
-0.0015124778,
-0.2645074129,
-0.8251667023,
-0.3072450459,
-0.4031393528,
-0.1099766046,
0.4404512644,
0.3054269552,
-0.081726402,
1.1268900633,
-0.5260276198,
0.1514179111,
-0.3922937512,
0.184775129,
0.3387090266,
0.1678192019,
0.2675486803,
-0.8367111683,
-0.4722915888,
-0.029999109,
-0.9316176772,
-0.1638363451,
-0.214216277,
-0.3095625937,
0.3051746786,
0.6309973001,
-0.3520458937,
0.5793065429,
0.1248343363,
-0.4768584669,
0.4233566225,
-0.1227748394,
0.2278778851,
-1.2841846943,
0.2441165894,
-0.1071833149,
-0.473462373,
-0.2513954043,
0.06169682,
0.3557301164,
0.0947026312,
-0.1603814512,
0.6113933921,
-0.3471147418,
-0.1080719233,
-0.2779166698,
0.224207893,
0.1459213942,
0.1772734821,
0.1570078135,
0.8608122468,
0.1054780632,
-0.559474349,
0.3029692769,
0.4988341928,
-0.196066469,
0.6671928763,
-0.8075070977,
0.2471041828,
-0.3364135325,
0.3776243031,
-0.8143102527,
0.0340460166,
0.1609166861,
-0.6531755328,
0.1383678764,
-0.0887638181,
-0.523023963,
-0.4314818978,
0.2100974172,
0.4321888983,
0.3470668197,
-0.5482681394,
0.6470141411,
0.1685677916,
-0.4582543671,
-0.6931414008,
-0.7177804112,
-0.0521133617,
-0.2230126709,
-0.4287340343,
0.150531739,
-0.2315464914,
-0.2586715221,
0.0567766502,
-0.2145888507,
-0.5890395641,
0.0162052289,
0.0457424894,
0.3687473834,
-0.3202748001,
0.1422970444,
0.5681384802,
-0.0097551467,
0.0237064306,
-0.1086100265,
0.1464100033,
-0.1768631488,
-0.4420742989,
-0.2296604514,
0.6141593456,
0.5287591219,
-0.4834080935,
0.843298912,
0.2813091576,
-0.2782794535,
0.0489842184,
-0.2929054201,
-0.2902247906,
-0.3476120234,
0.287060231,
-0.7812181711,
-0.929341495,
0.6742610931,
0.3542328477,
0.0155442636,
0.3192424774,
0.6344711781,
-0.307860285,
1.1575243473,
0.374646306,
-0.0030064189,
0.4790221155,
0.0367191583,
0.1429478973,
-0.5633555055,
-0.2265334129,
-0.7379488945,
0.0744277984,
-0.1114427,
-0.234943524,
0.2515782118,
0.198172912,
-0.1286637634,
0.2156364024,
-0.4195269346,
0.4672254324,
0.6919531226,
0.1956731975,
0.5284337401,
-0.0237627793,
-0.4027553499,
0.3345977366,
-0.5547044873,
-0.5983313322,
1.1714988947,
0.0341229402,
0.2081237137,
0.1326519102,
0.4319369793,
0.4611330628,
0.3343107104,
-0.7229987383,
0.3283360302,
0.3115981221,
-1.1782664061,
-0.3184972703,
-0.540225029,
-0.9409554005,
0.2951252162,
0.0294638053,
-0.3460619748,
-0.0821774006,
-0.1119115651,
-0.3727924228,
-0.0906158388,
-0.7296751738,
1.0816092491,
0.0490069166,
-0.0859863684,
-0.2874391973,
-1.0309566259,
0.0194151513,
-0.0582766347,
0.0578025505,
0.2730954885,
0.0902889669,
0.639904201,
-0.4558299482,
0.4248937666,
-0.0973134339,
0.3656071424,
0.8686164618,
-0.0112897689,
0.1524429321,
0.3267236948,
-0.3851527572,
-0.0515985005,
0.9445589185,
-1.0029226542,
-0.8956900239,
0.129909426,
-0.5039122105,
-0.5778098106,
-0.7118367553,
-0.5658084154,
-0.3816433549,
0.2693190873,
-0.1765013039,
0.6680273414,
-0.1701085418,
0.3252139091,
0.6989485025,
-0.0712210834,
0.4083073139,
0.7414417267,
0.1192808077,
-0.4514237642,
0.5977940559,
-0.2464460731,
0.0177204628,
0.8236114979,
0.1180767789,
-0.6567170024,
-0.709068656,
-0.8112408519,
0.2259059399,
-0.6397526264,
-0.1932400465,
-0.5929484367,
-0.1918772459,
-0.3335327506,
0.0914213061,
0.2525279522,
-0.3470237851,
-0.2182907462,
-0.347009778,
0.2229067534,
0.3597614765,
0.2157956064,
0.1080990359,
-0.9213536978,
0.4424858391,
0.236053884,
-0.1033526883,
-0.4509456456,
-0.7149766684,
-0.2009291351,
0.0056415661,
-0.3431773782,
-1.1825473309,
0.1667879671,
-0.0892359689,
0.5087422132,
0.3559426069,
0.5051470399,
0.6589943767,
-0.5118560195,
0.5833077431,
-0.2518590987,
-0.8248586655,
0.4461173117,
-0.3260735571,
0.3266982436,
1.0098053217,
0.1639620513,
-0.4641537666,
-0.4464966953,
-0.4215558767,
-0.4737668335,
0.294284761,
0.0240782835,
0.0261517111,
-0.197281301,
0.7232443094,
0.2065041363,
0.0526150949,
-0.4301298261,
-0.0592546724,
-0.4371258914,
-0.7706449628,
0.0019160483,
-0.1248506531,
-0.053927701,
-0.2584420741,
0.5153172016,
-0.5735830665,
0.3097580075,
0.5236300826,
-0.2226161808,
0.2167135328,
0.2922294736,
0.4804383516,
0.7998534441,
-0.2529391944,
0.281208545,
0.2873497307,
-0.3110961914,
-0.1557815075,
0.2169511318,
-0.1369565874,
-0.1703121364,
0.5137653947,
0.2083944231,
-0.4830047786,
-1.1510868073,
0.3737406433,
-0.2789562345,
-0.209437266,
-0.2133593112,
-0.2874508798,
0.0273999479,
0.4565662742,
0.3244900405,
-0.1696450561,
0.304033488,
-0.4853543639,
0.5625429749,
0.4642891586,
-0.618900001,
-0.0142190615,
0.3834136128,
-0.056631539,
-0.1138855517,
0.8707922101,
-0.1663933694,
-0.6017725468,
0.9255322814,
0.5732240081,
0.5190988779,
0.2319525331,
0.2924259007,
0.3421948254,
0.204147771,
0.1568613648,
0.2771975994,
-0.2653278708,
-0.6056833267,
-0.4393906295,
-0.5684090853,
-0.5896217227,
-0.2251049876,
-0.9455493689,
-0.1070333794,
-0.3878749609,
0.1872896403,
-0.2324136198,
0.1467605084,
-0.242557466,
0.4109402597,
-0.1257642061,
0.9282547235,
-0.6705626249,
0.9071791172,
0.9842692614,
-0.5886769295,
-0.8224405646,
0.3543085754,
-0.33438164,
-0.7066658735,
0.1566554755,
0.3711393178,
0.1383382082,
-0.0796086118,
-0.2820748687,
-0.4791884422,
1.0529471636,
-0.0054435865,
-0.0971895158,
0.2071141005,
0.1167143658,
0.5666504502,
-0.195018217,
0.5270886421,
0.4578678012,
0.4245727062,
0.421030283,
-0.448222816,
0.1487549394,
-0.1325390339,
-0.2347218841,
0.0591288023,
-0.4159322977,
0.1819776595,
-0.2439097613,
-0.1124405265,
0.3016932011,
0.9931454062,
0.5619208217,
0.8879669905,
0.4833632112,
0.4351876676,
0.8893105984,
0.1356793791,
1.1160176992,
-0.2490015924,
0.2240076065,
0.7572811842,
-0.1355334222,
1.0224772692,
0.6531792283,
-0.1758648157,
0.8053764701,
1.1270776987,
0.2412146479,
0.6476905346,
0.1593508273,
-0.1694140732,
-0.4816715121,
0.2095439285,
-0.1364243478,
0.1566199958,
-0.0085244039,
-0.1636105478,
0.0928524062,
-0.1558933407,
-0.1536932886,
0.3465319276,
-0.0934202448,
0.7659407258,
0.0966961458,
-1.1101491451,
0.5131503344,
0.0893305093,
0.0625718459,
-0.1876250356,
0.0312003884,
-0.4156230688,
0.26776281,
0.0632162467,
-0.8087082505,
0.7581908703,
-0.0498809591,
-0.634608984,
-0.0156273767,
0.4590164423,
-0.2311240584,
-0.6538469195,
0.0295341332,
0.8774999976,
0.1265155077,
-0.278904587,
-0.8139835,
-0.4143639803,
0.0366441794,
-0.2097116113,
0.2387791574,
0.5253065228,
-0.0819503739,
0.6403400302,
0.5933505893,
-0.3046064973,
0.1754611284,
0.0059738131,
0.4880121946,
-0.8783230186,
-0.3866789341,
-0.6552841663,
0.2982032299,
-0.0901120976,
-0.1144059822,
0.3708315492,
0.5240724683,
0.4868432581,
0.0558806285,
0.6496270895,
0.0211068038,
0.9007575512,
-0.5476291776,
0.5483597517,
-0.6712329388,
-0.014272348,
-0.0094220666,
-0.804037869,
-0.4283170104,
0.6145576239,
-0.3706766069,
0.0792728141,
1.1763198376,
0.7646517158,
-0.0294709858,
0.3085255325,
0.1976466328,
-0.2217700779,
0.1851230115,
0.5312906504,
0.8714063764,
-0.2706539929,
0.9750717282,
0.1752052456,
-0.4426229,
-0.0921386406,
-0.6072523594,
-1.1901670694,
-0.5416246653,
-0.2695218623,
-0.5600246787,
0.2149042636,
0.1524309069,
0.5616466999,
-1.0303359032,
0.0401969925,
-0.2580810785,
0.5210570693,
-0.5425710678,
-0.3146860898,
0.3118772507,
-0.2999906242,
-0.6308141351,
0.2315312177,
0.0863294527,
-0.2837769687,
0.1418503672,
0.0364006162,
-0.1132350639,
0.4392415285,
0.5432866216,
0.5077952743,
-0.6201749444,
-0.4880799353,
0.3474746943,
-0.2325465232,
0.0677413791,
0.7320412397,
-0.9531320333,
0.2687830329,
0.6763054132,
1.0536488295,
0.6739903092,
0.4199484885,
0.3551035523,
-0.3406424224,
-0.070605129,
0.2169807702,
0.2516812384,
0.2554991841,
-0.0990221202,
0.3751730025,
0.3251301646,
-0.6102303267,
-0.7778328657,
0.3609727919,
-1.345774889,
-0.5720797181,
1.0834780931,
-0.1427410245,
-0.3868227601,
-0.4055315852,
-0.3150261045,
0.3572410643,
-0.2669051886,
0.7862847447,
0.8101113439,
-0.2528216243,
-0.3758323789,
-0.4911070466,
-0.1894073337,
0.8345102072,
-1.026175499,
-0.0471753068,
0.5170624256,
0.3991611898,
-0.0334502794,
0.3080310822,
-0.2347188443,
0.1578574181,
-0.0942732841,
-0.2337424159,
-0.1781815737,
-0.2971256971,
-0.195582673,
0.5082255602,
-0.1255719364,
-0.2408705205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14806v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14806v2 | AWESOME: GPU Memory-constrained Long Document Summarization using Memory Mechanism and Global Salient Content | 2023-05-24T07:00:00 | 2023-11-16T11:47:05 | Shuyang Cao, Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long document summarization systems are critical for domains with lengthy and
jargonladen text, yet they present significant challenges to researchers and
developers with limited computing resources. Existing solutions mainly focus on
efficient attentions or divide-and-conquer strategies. The former reduces
theoretical time complexity, but is still memory-heavy. The latter methods
sacrifice global context, leading to uninformative and incoherent summaries.
This work aims to leverage the memory-efficient nature of divide-and-conquer
methods while preserving global context. Concretely, our framework AWESOME uses
two novel mechanisms: (1) External memory mechanisms track previously encoded
document segments and their corresponding summaries, to enhance global document
understanding and summary coherence. (2) Global salient content is further
identified beforehand to augment each document segment to support its
summarization. Extensive experiments on diverse genres of text, including
government reports, transcripts, scientific papers, and novels, show that
AWESOME produces summaries with improved informativeness, faithfulness, and
coherence than competitive baselines on longer documents, while having a
smaller GPU memory footprint. | [
-0.6590652466,
-0.9878818393,
0.742866993,
0.0876479074,
-0.5211479068,
0.1311339736,
-0.3163615167,
-0.6126987934,
0.6021290421,
0.144241035,
-0.355052352,
-0.3624199033,
-0.3755007684,
-0.031166641,
-0.3835383356,
1.6367175579,
0.0124341166,
-0.3525997698,
-0.5920596719,
-0.3747782111,
-0.1650485992,
-0.6916487217,
-0.3100244403,
-0.2263925672,
0.5758709311,
0.2869490981,
0.8277199268,
0.7320857644,
0.7455555201,
0.2063562274,
-0.1913322508,
0.2354997844,
-0.7808498144,
0.2867601216,
-0.2148618698,
-0.1897934824,
-0.5731444359,
-0.3987216353,
0.762437284,
0.3985340297,
0.0726239234,
0.0793528855,
0.027184898,
0.5761425495,
-0.7583066225,
0.3162780106,
-0.3198716938,
0.0764278919,
-0.3591994345,
-0.2518340349,
0.0762738585,
-0.3360196352,
-0.0147805521,
-0.7722281218,
0.5159496069,
-0.0194895398,
0.8783717752,
0.19789657,
-0.0519955419,
-0.3398527801,
-0.6461104155,
0.4407773614,
-0.3632625341,
-0.067205444,
0.128016904,
0.0921038985,
0.1504934728,
-0.6888049841,
-0.5752305388,
-0.0533981845,
0.0313874222,
0.5226412416,
-0.2130800188,
0.2084554434,
0.2889588177,
0.9179226756,
-0.4900505841,
-0.0321035348,
-0.2377991527,
-0.1429163218,
0.4664097726,
0.1634310186,
0.7306275368,
-0.0392912216,
-0.269505769,
0.1654095799,
-0.4374533296,
-0.18364425,
0.2361525446,
0.0347884297,
-0.2976236939,
0.4307499826,
-0.1473174691,
0.3233547807,
-0.0310217012,
-0.0588123165,
0.0616462044,
-0.4402453005,
-0.2043799311,
0.1965065598,
0.5498377681,
0.3858941793,
-0.2426818311,
-0.4794305563,
0.0214467533,
0.1798051447,
0.2486436963,
-0.9225596786,
-0.2786479294,
0.2844121158,
-0.0455079302,
0.2245888561,
-0.1086557508,
-0.6217733026,
-0.118717514,
-0.2930286229,
0.5029597878,
-0.720023036,
0.1177038029,
-0.220106557,
-0.5159004927,
-0.0193632487,
0.5897349715,
-1.1630272865,
0.3255518377,
0.9561829567,
1.1437066793,
-0.3459867835,
-0.2957795858,
-0.8575874567,
0.4344299138,
-0.0591826588,
0.8748605847,
-0.4954319298,
-0.4908978343,
-0.3629158139,
-0.3022746146,
0.201572299,
-0.3571823835,
0.7229424715,
-0.5358791947,
0.3958229423,
-0.4318013787,
-0.5980190635,
-0.3555701971,
0.3066955507,
-0.7336767316,
0.8799865842,
0.1853551418,
-0.9450808167,
0.3147283792,
-0.5795066357,
-0.7249335647,
0.0938071087,
-0.2177460343,
-0.5471987724,
0.5663605928,
0.3876747787,
0.3102493882,
-0.0446873084,
0.1013666317,
-0.246915713,
-0.6094514132,
-0.2035426199,
-0.1748580039,
0.2463657111,
0.0779606774,
-0.1325901002,
0.3114798367,
-0.4379467368,
-0.2340698689,
0.1652230173,
-0.1710680425,
-0.6214430332,
-0.2456493825,
-0.0928815827,
-0.1187774241,
0.4093071818,
-0.3731728494,
0.496450007,
-0.1352685988,
0.293014884,
0.3516687155,
0.0515768938,
0.5589262843,
-0.3557924032,
0.5532791018,
-0.3511691689,
0.1510066688,
-0.6714305282,
-0.3729911745,
-0.4205892086,
-0.6675706506,
-0.0029146429,
0.3859617412,
-0.5894104838,
0.1858442724,
-0.5766531229,
-0.1916192025,
-0.0342090018,
-0.074102737,
0.3245580792,
0.5214709044,
0.430760622,
-0.5273370743,
-0.3624207377,
-0.6571779847,
-0.0413204208,
-0.2378892452,
-0.1443284154,
0.2230579257,
0.4994404614,
-0.0575642288,
0.781391561,
-0.5509671569,
-0.3500221372,
-0.3178678453,
0.0374165326,
0.1210738719,
0.1451139897,
0.6325293779,
-0.8937414289,
-0.3784196377,
0.0096560968,
-0.8382474184,
0.2972099185,
-0.3004944324,
-0.218545571,
0.1209837943,
0.4166360795,
-0.8985950351,
0.2698454857,
0.1346515715,
-0.1702120304,
0.5670013428,
-0.8114463091,
0.2342938781,
-0.8743689656,
0.2119473666,
-0.1610453129,
-0.2154468,
-0.4023869336,
0.5463531613,
0.3382150233,
-0.1475937814,
-0.0222771186,
0.4947696328,
-0.7966552377,
0.0788085833,
-0.3540334404,
0.1108668521,
0.1585306078,
0.5111452937,
-0.0900026932,
0.6360595822,
0.5205290914,
-0.4786746502,
0.2268969566,
0.3185228705,
-0.0234484673,
0.7090569139,
-0.3675695658,
-0.0491893031,
-0.4807794094,
0.5542880297,
-0.9564466476,
-0.6406984925,
0.1792111695,
-0.4335432649,
0.5052114129,
0.0070693563,
-0.4958046079,
-0.2276654691,
-0.6383299828,
0.3988983035,
0.4747381806,
-0.7090869546,
0.6395540833,
0.574791193,
-0.6534802914,
-0.3841397762,
-0.6289535165,
0.5005928874,
-0.2912631035,
-0.444770813,
0.6719109416,
-0.0416628458,
-0.1501260251,
0.188206926,
-0.354927808,
0.107912071,
-0.1314137727,
0.478143543,
0.4870236516,
-0.196236819,
0.0288116895,
0.3376021087,
-0.0079776952,
-0.0595967062,
-0.3497874439,
0.208828643,
-0.1493567973,
-0.1984216571,
-0.1627007425,
0.7962308526,
0.8286206722,
-0.1358188391,
0.4759808481,
0.5780984759,
-0.3124576807,
-0.1260132641,
-0.5158629417,
0.1667505652,
-0.389674902,
0.5228837132,
-0.1950424463,
-1.0786585808,
0.7402911782,
0.3251747191,
0.2292754799,
0.5132550597,
0.4275456071,
0.2311803997,
0.7573215961,
0.6966827512,
-0.5853489637,
0.430567652,
-0.1290203631,
0.2290300131,
-0.7267910242,
-0.2639285624,
-0.1908062547,
-0.2257112712,
0.0275219176,
-0.625315547,
0.5408408046,
0.4071776569,
0.1679588258,
-0.1368079334,
-0.597971499,
0.7721340656,
0.381944865,
-0.0130327316,
0.3979473412,
0.3075502515,
-0.0620437078,
-0.0091629159,
-0.5601374507,
-0.0204942785,
0.7992343307,
0.2006320059,
0.6983240843,
0.0426208638,
0.8019906878,
0.5095965862,
0.4835503101,
-0.6880232096,
0.5690185428,
-0.1206715479,
-0.2385213673,
-0.2959570885,
-0.5168574452,
-0.4735809863,
0.2655016482,
0.1506532729,
-0.6767368913,
-0.1587578654,
0.1883385032,
-0.6547167301,
0.4940183759,
-0.7474210262,
0.4965150952,
-0.1230622828,
-0.5745797157,
-0.4464268088,
-0.5826560259,
0.3239136934,
0.13841106,
0.0270551872,
0.0625628233,
-0.3037209213,
0.3299142122,
-0.5165917873,
0.3902384937,
-0.0558451116,
-0.2533636689,
0.2705112696,
-0.2066621482,
0.6166299582,
0.3502274156,
0.1231399253,
0.2040874064,
-0.5779569149,
-0.4371907711,
-0.5393052697,
1.014696002,
-0.5058749914,
-0.5650948286,
-0.4737143815,
-0.7346508503,
0.0195353832,
0.2284430116,
0.4450675845,
0.5757162571,
-0.4307718575,
-0.1642267406,
0.7187471986,
0.1053337455,
0.6869627237,
0.3070586026,
-0.268653363,
-0.5787526369,
1.2040278912,
0.2666765153,
0.1398263723,
0.6371445656,
-0.1823753715,
-0.2966660857,
-0.8717186451,
-0.5647802353,
0.2270881534,
-0.6214712262,
0.0265855957,
-0.960631609,
-0.225481391,
-0.2754236758,
-0.4617849886,
-0.1211567968,
-0.6729435921,
-0.2562907338,
-0.1094874889,
0.3247316778,
0.5427253246,
-0.2663319707,
-0.0458433628,
-0.57119596,
0.7632979155,
0.3296766877,
0.2830320001,
0.0752678216,
-0.3903512359,
-0.4605443478,
-0.3581891656,
-0.2302948087,
-0.3482900858,
0.459928304,
0.3135366738,
0.4133812487,
0.4581428468,
0.0469303578,
0.7145242691,
-0.3136515021,
0.7779793739,
0.3551182151,
-0.6829758883,
0.3810609281,
-0.5380578637,
0.7772486806,
0.5266312957,
0.4177539349,
-0.4158923328,
-0.7613126636,
-0.5220696926,
-1.4282405376,
0.6048298478,
0.3007178009,
0.0964453146,
-0.0470756963,
0.3742389083,
0.5108923316,
-0.0135677317,
-0.1158629805,
-0.1774438471,
-0.195596844,
0.1027939022,
-0.1119092777,
-0.3094776273,
-0.2611613572,
-0.0362348035,
0.681022048,
-0.1461825669,
0.1519103944,
0.4379161,
-0.1944600791,
0.2995662093,
0.4143139124,
0.6607350111,
0.686568439,
-0.3497060835,
0.1583324671,
0.0980335101,
-0.9390055537,
-0.2075665593,
0.4975008965,
-0.3286598623,
0.1688284427,
0.0860314146,
0.811342299,
0.1297612041,
-0.4348760843,
0.2091438472,
-0.5119334459,
-0.0386526473,
-0.1425870806,
0.2262308896,
0.0449577942,
0.0643865615,
0.6571749449,
0.1760345101,
0.2003512681,
-0.55486238,
0.1006848589,
0.3483445942,
-0.3069149256,
-0.406003207,
0.9272862077,
0.2706255615,
0.1366444528,
0.3422631323,
-0.42386356,
-0.2095198184,
0.4493404031,
0.5203183293,
0.8450857401,
0.2793529034,
0.1593970805,
0.2268395722,
-0.1563608199,
-0.1906400472,
0.1554204524,
-0.6837322712,
-0.059368521,
-0.5475935936,
-0.554361999,
-0.7948441505,
-0.0320106857,
-0.7732825875,
-0.2072507292,
-0.4085583389,
-0.0839765295,
0.1605977416,
-0.0911271498,
-0.2019960582,
0.1466759145,
0.5610073209,
0.6347032189,
-0.3846682608,
0.6109051108,
0.6137209535,
-0.2616247833,
-0.2310021371,
0.0662778914,
-0.0182621721,
-0.6000582576,
-0.0047456236,
0.4171118438,
-0.0396053158,
-0.1533524096,
-0.3556513488,
-0.6973994374,
0.8107376695,
0.6534218192,
-0.452256918,
-0.3964666426,
-0.1614571065,
0.4024094045,
-0.0008797825,
0.3878239691,
0.3292669356,
0.2859728038,
0.0471269935,
-0.6569755077,
0.0961342826,
-0.7734365463,
-0.1800756007,
0.4066918194,
-0.8341913223,
0.6400620937,
-0.6508207917,
-0.4145522118,
0.0828567818,
1.0121495724,
0.3192692697,
0.4893006682,
0.0097194528,
0.9389432073,
0.9685971737,
-0.1918766201,
1.3603355885,
-0.3553592861,
0.2535353303,
1.3113520145,
-0.1037952602,
0.4278297722,
0.3237775862,
0.0193933193,
0.2821632326,
0.2417461723,
0.0858415142,
0.421889782,
-0.0421100333,
-0.7185009718,
0.0282315593,
-0.2566941381,
-0.8725592494,
0.0061005708,
0.4113913774,
-0.0467265621,
-0.5728541613,
0.0785939023,
0.3502663374,
-0.2274474502,
-0.7090026736,
0.6695600748,
0.0847726688,
-0.9355579019,
0.5171800852,
-0.1703884155,
0.821780026,
-0.953971386,
0.1224967092,
-0.3473248482,
0.2943707407,
-0.240149647,
-0.7847516537,
0.2734774649,
0.1177578643,
-0.6247280836,
-0.2481977195,
0.6314511895,
-0.4205772877,
-0.256765902,
0.0246200673,
0.0063144132,
0.0648362562,
-0.4540464282,
-0.1711471826,
0.0763773024,
-0.0899780095,
-0.167435959,
0.7523165345,
0.5759872198,
-0.0576221161,
0.3804064393,
0.6140268445,
0.1296706498,
-0.1670341492,
0.0976322889,
1.0533168316,
-0.7231428623,
-1.3692861795,
-1.0244182348,
0.321287185,
-0.2863886356,
-0.3574373126,
1.2221529484,
1.0935848951,
0.5047611594,
0.0421243086,
1.1083648205,
-0.1207328215,
0.0612023287,
-0.385374397,
0.922665298,
-0.4415149987,
-0.0378843695,
-0.2428826243,
-0.7620421052,
-0.5306269526,
-0.0413720943,
-0.3275942802,
-0.4157020152,
0.5524837375,
0.3050080836,
-0.2474988848,
0.334859103,
0.2051810473,
0.0259530544,
0.3135383129,
0.6069571376,
0.5143877268,
-0.0094912332,
0.6710134149,
-0.0718315095,
-0.3010021746,
-0.3436468542,
-0.8296766877,
-0.7876942754,
-0.2308250815,
-0.4051468968,
-0.2014392316,
0.2576410174,
0.308917731,
0.5696718693,
-0.718878448,
0.2210256159,
-0.1517719626,
0.1640191972,
-0.0370190255,
-0.2144742161,
0.6867492795,
-0.2847785354,
-0.5073366761,
0.2845890224,
1.0679039955,
0.0292269606,
-0.055088345,
0.0225467496,
0.3893891573,
-0.0655372813,
0.7343527675,
0.9065954685,
-0.3225491345,
-0.0306350235,
-0.2305181623,
-0.0662197545,
0.290507555,
0.8484170437,
-0.7100537419,
0.5187560916,
0.659617126,
0.5781463385,
0.6197192669,
0.2382723391,
0.427300036,
-0.4244191647,
0.0884959996,
0.2224120796,
0.2762534022,
0.3388696015,
-0.6084308028,
0.2815871835,
0.1190572754,
-0.5311247706,
-0.6854470372,
-0.2553571761,
-1.2763286829,
-0.2232453674,
0.7346459627,
-0.2554844022,
-0.4293556213,
0.0030360396,
-0.2836250961,
0.1632716209,
-0.6421539187,
0.9667762518,
0.4421178401,
-0.37273404,
0.236487627,
-0.3769879341,
0.406793803,
0.3039087653,
-1.0380368233,
0.1511096805,
0.8213013411,
0.0373516828,
0.36564973,
0.8267322779,
-0.1754138917,
0.4793394506,
0.1648229659,
0.0004225799,
-0.3221511245,
-0.4342519343,
-0.3232572377,
0.7541300058,
-0.6100919843,
-0.0140296277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14802v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14802v2 | Estimating Large Language Model Capabilities without Labeled Test Data | 2023-05-24T06:55:09 | 2023-10-26T06:09:05 | Harvey Yiyun Fu, Qinyuan Ye, Albert Xu, Xiang Ren, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have the impressive ability to perform
in-context learning (ICL) from only a few examples, but the success of ICL
varies widely from task to task. Thus, it is important to quickly determine
whether ICL is applicable to a new task, but directly evaluating ICL accuracy
can be expensive in situations where test data is expensive to annotate -- the
exact situations where ICL is most appealing. In this paper, we propose the
task of ICL accuracy estimation, in which we predict the accuracy of an LLM
when doing in-context learning on a new task given only unlabeled test data for
that task. To perform ICL accuracy estimation, we propose a method that trains
a meta-model using LLM confidence scores as features. We compare our method to
several strong accuracy estimation baselines on a new benchmark that covers 4
LLMs and 3 task collections. The meta-model improves over all baselines across
8 out of 12 settings and achieves the same estimation performance as directly
evaluating on 40 collected labeled test examples per task. At the same time, no
existing approach provides an accurate and reliable ICL accuracy estimation in
every setting, highlighting the need for better ways to measure the uncertainty
of LLM predictions. | [
-0.3227755427,
-0.4543666244,
0.6688548923,
0.0569020361,
-0.1242144555,
0.1127930805,
-0.5710944533,
-0.4663012028,
-0.2355711609,
0.3446905613,
-0.4646292925,
-0.6990393996,
-0.7629129291,
0.0260667931,
-0.3701925278,
0.8483603001,
0.0901503637,
0.0646515563,
-0.3686466217,
-0.0472702496,
-0.4853911698,
-0.2247416675,
-0.0742263645,
-0.2708982229,
0.1678338498,
0.6234695315,
0.3023390174,
0.5261028409,
0.1117487177,
0.2048577815,
-0.267372191,
0.4879635274,
-0.2273930013,
-0.3142610788,
-0.0580379963,
-0.2947996259,
-0.5742735267,
0.1308219582,
0.9089698792,
0.8846046925,
0.169293493,
0.6089121103,
0.5553240776,
0.1884450465,
-0.9318495989,
0.4559845328,
-0.8393852115,
-0.0264176726,
-0.0626131296,
0.0526231676,
-0.7051997781,
-0.2010750175,
0.2803058624,
-0.3657530844,
-0.1355167031,
-0.0649337173,
0.595035553,
0.3080771565,
-0.4569213986,
-0.3012954295,
-0.6310857534,
1.0838066339,
-0.8653172851,
0.5114024878,
0.5955145955,
0.23591052,
-0.1556375027,
-0.5801972151,
-0.4177167118,
-0.5243582129,
-0.2812128663,
-0.0143056232,
0.0577117838,
0.0651387498,
0.303519696,
0.0794959888,
-0.2161161005,
0.1078896001,
-0.1157427356,
0.0096694408,
0.6727051139,
-0.0440081134,
0.1108543053,
-0.0205139928,
-0.3444818258,
0.099455528,
-0.5711174011,
0.1880915761,
-0.1742565632,
0.406062901,
-0.1044891328,
0.5863858461,
-0.0618975163,
0.6991344094,
0.15526627,
-0.7669433355,
0.4606026113,
-0.1515115798,
-0.288518697,
-0.0993146077,
0.6322386861,
-0.0222012382,
0.3144977391,
-0.3708215356,
-0.4494901299,
-0.3473763466,
-0.0479981229,
-0.5778175592,
0.0312509798,
0.0867427438,
-0.0375279114,
0.1664781123,
0.1692828089,
-0.6091835499,
-0.2682545483,
-0.4041462541,
0.4351237118,
-0.3775354028,
-0.0408699214,
-0.3034197092,
0.3448082209,
0.0284993239,
0.136715889,
-0.6044310331,
0.1072691754,
0.7067516446,
0.7967181206,
-0.2174137384,
-0.3544392586,
-0.7151080966,
0.2068465203,
-0.4431602657,
0.4672928751,
-0.5405136943,
-0.2175531387,
-0.0615501553,
0.0065661687,
-0.1295402348,
-0.4736099243,
0.5375450253,
-0.3945526779,
-0.2221379876,
-0.0091254786,
-0.9206863046,
-0.1669498682,
0.3175185323,
-0.5811008215,
1.0486725569,
0.0199702047,
-0.8048171401,
0.5424101949,
-0.4994602799,
-0.291202575,
0.1365397424,
0.0148007814,
-0.2100313455,
0.2224324048,
0.4211831689,
0.6592205763,
-0.2653019726,
0.654640913,
-0.3922163546,
-0.648883462,
0.4071258008,
-0.4669302106,
0.7714966536,
-0.075490199,
-0.640062511,
0.0422604866,
-0.6458811164,
0.2686941624,
-0.4827224612,
-0.6539312005,
-0.3745963871,
0.066738829,
-0.0234683901,
0.112011984,
0.4104734659,
-0.6362248063,
-0.0900733545,
-0.464381367,
-0.1180384606,
0.789422214,
-0.391053766,
0.3967368603,
-0.0168059953,
0.4858497977,
-0.2995268703,
0.1692151278,
0.2186075896,
-0.3367143273,
-0.6270125508,
-0.4737989604,
0.5301008224,
0.469671756,
-0.4316976964,
0.6145676374,
-0.5914355516,
-0.6176867485,
-0.2947833538,
0.3947761953,
0.7107291818,
0.5436991453,
0.4577088058,
0.1389774531,
-0.4299904108,
-0.7420668006,
-0.2955706418,
-0.1400675774,
-0.2237878144,
0.4928110838,
0.5102007985,
-0.1002680138,
1.0132206678,
-0.4227202833,
-0.1452900916,
-0.3881105781,
0.3880566955,
0.01728159,
0.4484788179,
0.1509340852,
-0.6884663701,
-0.7542102337,
-0.0514552146,
-0.6439714432,
-0.1878500432,
0.3313261271,
0.2321563512,
0.2887408733,
0.5381436348,
-0.3481371999,
0.2650641501,
0.885068357,
-0.1205722392,
0.3656311929,
-0.2273403406,
-0.123291485,
-0.9020252228,
0.3958843648,
0.140177846,
-0.1575742215,
-0.5698214173,
0.0289394911,
0.5823380947,
0.1102632061,
-0.4359996021,
1.057875514,
-0.5799941421,
-0.1795585603,
-0.2333561033,
0.1476599723,
-0.212408632,
0.3989562392,
0.1232651919,
0.9459521174,
0.39985919,
-0.4828906059,
-0.3066202104,
0.0161302816,
-0.9561222792,
0.3191661835,
-0.2447502762,
0.0280366167,
-0.1252726465,
0.3143064678,
-1.0431697369,
-0.2485176325,
0.03059691,
-0.3083955646,
0.3410907984,
-0.1921475679,
-0.3952264786,
-0.2609938085,
0.22625193,
0.3597506583,
0.5900751352,
-0.5621070862,
0.5568242073,
0.496824801,
0.1269693673,
-1.0385292768,
-0.6627383232,
0.0031470123,
-0.1747992188,
-0.132176429,
0.3295502961,
-0.2318256944,
-0.1592031717,
-0.0910117254,
-0.0306293461,
-0.4737267494,
0.276673317,
0.4213969707,
0.1442687958,
-0.1316709518,
0.5521477461,
-0.23015365,
-0.2302062958,
0.0001135552,
-0.1704198718,
0.2611357868,
-0.0776763931,
-0.4550737143,
-0.2518754303,
-0.0824815035,
0.7293195724,
-0.4089268744,
0.7513080835,
0.4721654356,
-0.5585288405,
-0.4212931693,
-0.7088992596,
0.0341599844,
-0.4254613519,
0.3841840625,
-0.1337283552,
-0.7142381668,
0.2580414414,
0.0351938941,
0.1774260104,
0.1853070706,
0.0988439918,
-0.1526774615,
1.0480276346,
0.7651082873,
-0.0381914414,
0.3051077724,
-0.0808113366,
0.1273287237,
-0.9294806719,
-0.2669304311,
-0.3652067482,
-0.3355424106,
-0.2939289808,
-0.5357916951,
0.6433655024,
-0.038053114,
-0.3112104833,
0.1996638924,
0.0094314367,
0.5104064345,
0.5891398191,
0.3092658818,
0.5105304718,
-0.2466825396,
-0.0737912804,
-0.0256319474,
-0.4765125513,
-0.4217995107,
1.3609278202,
0.2309725136,
0.5567073822,
-0.1703297347,
0.3681547344,
0.0180694517,
0.9192019105,
-0.6587238908,
0.4899296463,
-0.1364241987,
-0.7602448463,
-0.5325426459,
-0.4542406499,
-0.5089649558,
0.06128769,
-0.1495328546,
-0.7400665879,
-0.1310459822,
0.2511224747,
-0.3631627858,
0.4163508713,
-0.4260108471,
0.7577309608,
-0.382845372,
-0.118634358,
0.0993327126,
-0.4744044542,
0.563749969,
-0.4491513968,
0.2651103139,
-0.3045796752,
-0.3227515817,
0.5252532959,
-0.2592497468,
1.0558335781,
-0.191516906,
0.0021499479,
0.2802749276,
-0.078376174,
0.7483734488,
-0.1027168557,
-0.395745337,
0.1675320417,
-0.2053913176,
-0.3393629789,
-0.5961953998,
0.6123424172,
-0.4447755814,
-0.511947751,
-0.2216455191,
-0.8722962737,
-0.523244679,
0.0708155558,
0.1960774958,
0.417094171,
-0.1322441399,
0.2946008444,
0.5872192383,
-0.3756097555,
0.6296979189,
0.5959166288,
0.1565644741,
-0.267105788,
0.5510835052,
0.4817770422,
0.4039916992,
0.526694417,
0.3048393726,
-0.5997004509,
-0.6778934002,
-0.4067433476,
0.0799926594,
-0.7020489573,
-0.1833576113,
-0.798117578,
-0.1316643953,
-0.1337233484,
-0.1124418452,
-0.4918828309,
0.2415127754,
-0.2762943506,
-0.0940793753,
0.1573758721,
0.5871120691,
0.1284650713,
0.2824141979,
-0.6140073538,
-0.2369249761,
0.3461945653,
0.3906146586,
0.1778517812,
-0.8835296631,
-0.4048197865,
0.2860946655,
-0.0404578745,
-0.4527933896,
0.4218976498,
0.2357280403,
0.4356771111,
0.1921750158,
0.2341655046,
1.0482127666,
-0.5366445184,
0.4979223609,
-0.1541669816,
-1.3203042746,
0.3687694073,
0.0061102398,
0.3786021173,
0.7911975384,
0.4238849878,
-0.2619892955,
-0.3605153263,
-0.5993164182,
-0.4032820761,
0.4375075102,
-0.2826209664,
0.1045214981,
-0.0716874376,
0.3567004502,
-0.1855109334,
0.2956302166,
-1.0239838362,
-0.133159101,
0.443115592,
-0.394077599,
-0.529918611,
-0.3224977851,
0.1971375346,
-0.4020909071,
0.712653935,
-0.451677233,
-0.1864882559,
-0.0915752575,
-0.3736450076,
-0.068428576,
0.1612481922,
0.3801782727,
1.1209522486,
-0.3672769666,
0.2926003039,
0.861769259,
-0.2378994972,
0.2931005061,
-0.1133109927,
-0.1270179898,
0.0013764488,
0.6302337646,
0.4158966541,
0.7575910687,
-1.2096961737,
0.9619759917,
0.3569818735,
0.1235503033,
-0.5768657923,
-0.0838362351,
0.2651806474,
0.4356024265,
0.182649985,
-0.2067365348,
-0.0028437781,
-0.3308887482,
0.4642885029,
0.7532544136,
-0.8025483489,
-0.1193253994,
0.3948639333,
-0.092471607,
-0.0831925273,
0.6447662115,
-0.1420323998,
-0.2791527212,
0.5941417813,
0.6943930387,
0.8632406592,
-0.5061926246,
0.2060538977,
0.5827154517,
0.3306137919,
-0.2401217371,
-0.1119437739,
0.1396499425,
-0.6844415069,
-0.8017295599,
-0.7028961778,
-0.3362627923,
0.4187380075,
-0.4096456468,
0.3711057901,
-0.3779415786,
0.0236246567,
-0.3796887398,
0.1055908874,
-0.7043027878,
0.4037643075,
0.115619719,
1.0617645979,
-0.9688709378,
1.0582876205,
0.3090922832,
-0.0418130234,
-0.9536666274,
0.2626696527,
-0.1389170587,
-0.7596945167,
0.8407015204,
0.3503262997,
-0.044246383,
0.0375209525,
-0.3965493739,
-1.2466384172,
1.3278776407,
0.5846269131,
-0.5346636772,
0.1738862991,
0.0646193996,
0.3289653659,
-0.5321720839,
0.4204911888,
0.4656279385,
0.6526502967,
-0.0136316586,
-0.8848775029,
0.0310330596,
-0.0147287743,
-0.1535882354,
0.1677428335,
-0.3995352387,
0.8132026792,
-0.1813305318,
-0.3839094341,
-0.0019340392,
0.5835340023,
0.1874346584,
0.1868120879,
0.6662777662,
0.2964420021,
0.992714107,
0.14854002,
1.0518920422,
-0.3826694191,
0.3507360518,
1.4704395533,
-0.2089178264,
0.9598107338,
0.2410132587,
0.0385576449,
0.1420012563,
0.5902517438,
0.0437105112,
0.2780584693,
0.1354469359,
-0.4227331579,
-0.5491861701,
-0.2030919492,
-0.0232352279,
0.5537412763,
0.2252022624,
-0.5840069652,
-0.1104337797,
0.0638701916,
0.1032895446,
-0.0597400591,
-0.1733448952,
0.6003661156,
-0.0491701439,
-0.8150503635,
0.5403156281,
0.0465038009,
0.6863062978,
-0.4794035256,
0.059815824,
-0.1949019283,
0.1803518534,
0.0167448074,
-0.6755430102,
0.1538279951,
0.1569980383,
-0.0557347722,
0.0342615694,
0.3901783228,
-0.6796844602,
-0.9637545943,
0.4587486386,
0.6220499277,
0.1433211714,
-0.1355687529,
-0.4907290339,
-0.1385098845,
-0.1001776084,
-0.1720211208,
0.3429614902,
0.2444132417,
-0.033500798,
0.834335804,
0.4026440978,
0.0263469946,
-0.0333662294,
-0.4668549001,
0.4284762144,
-0.3559130728,
-0.1823489815,
-1.0371642113,
0.6656321287,
0.0203843229,
-0.4480647445,
0.685805738,
0.4762205482,
0.9723390937,
-0.0296253953,
0.9042736888,
0.0621576793,
0.6011607647,
-0.422091186,
0.5170761943,
-0.7302568555,
0.2382714152,
-0.4299093485,
-0.8579286933,
-0.4278548658,
0.3871720433,
-0.5595992804,
0.0032025224,
0.5700446963,
0.9750994444,
-0.5076822042,
-0.1311318278,
0.5005697012,
0.1783372015,
0.0544466712,
0.5919182301,
0.579595685,
-0.2070319355,
0.4067953229,
-0.545930028,
-0.4656909406,
-0.1861454993,
-1.2080535889,
-1.0354982615,
-0.5589995384,
-0.1645032912,
-0.1552875936,
-0.1623776704,
1.045170188,
0.8606601357,
-0.8062560558,
-0.5208384395,
0.1958979219,
0.225614354,
-0.4416892231,
-0.1364413798,
0.6299596429,
-0.3997923732,
-0.9238266945,
0.4985902011,
0.0507009476,
-0.036217384,
-0.2141294181,
-0.1044754982,
-0.2783851326,
-0.0701644048,
0.5729453564,
0.1055373326,
-0.9308708906,
-0.6566423178,
-0.1278023422,
-0.0871324018,
0.0123926755,
0.3526038229,
-0.4973917603,
0.3990086317,
0.1988146454,
0.8796371818,
0.4215562046,
0.0583110861,
0.4804294109,
-0.902100265,
-0.0305576604,
0.1401466578,
0.2075094879,
0.2956172228,
-0.2181295902,
0.6055364609,
-0.0453541651,
-0.4150964022,
-0.8601900339,
-0.0712587535,
-0.4501443505,
-0.3276994526,
1.0663956404,
-0.5779513121,
-0.1606530696,
-0.1030488163,
0.2776319683,
0.3025150001,
-0.0339673497,
0.6537889242,
0.6878764033,
0.0931475535,
-0.1487143338,
-0.913862288,
0.5768601298,
0.2748068273,
-0.7401010394,
0.206995368,
0.313711673,
0.4383476675,
0.0869932324,
0.2882523537,
0.0634118691,
-0.0439759716,
-0.3627895713,
0.2811207771,
0.0564600416,
-0.6504869461,
-0.0054312749,
0.3892302513,
0.2108528167,
-0.0256251059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14795v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14795v2 | MQuAKE: Assessing Knowledge Editing in Language Models via Multi-Hop Questions | 2023-05-24T06:48:41 | 2023-10-29T20:28:17 | Zexuan Zhong, Zhengxuan Wu, Christopher D. Manning, Christopher Potts, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The information stored in large language models (LLMs) falls out of date
quickly, and retraining from scratch is often not an option. This has recently
given rise to a range of techniques for injecting new facts through updating
model weights. Current evaluation paradigms are extremely limited, mainly
validating the recall of edited facts, but changing one fact should cause
rippling changes to the model's related beliefs. If we edit the UK Prime
Minister to now be Rishi Sunak, then we should get a different answer to Who is
married to the British Prime Minister? In this work, we present a benchmark,
MQuAKE (Multi-hop Question Answering for Knowledge Editing), comprising
multi-hop questions that assess whether edited models correctly answer
questions where the answer should change as an entailed consequence of edited
facts. While we find that current knowledge-editing approaches can recall
edited facts accurately, they fail catastrophically on the constructed
multi-hop questions. We thus propose a simple memory-based approach, MeLLo,
which stores all edited facts externally while prompting the language model
iteratively to generate answers that are consistent with the edited facts.
While MQuAKE remains challenging, we show that MeLLo scales well with LLMs (up
to 175B) and outperforms previous model editors by a large margin. | [
-0.1059897318,
-0.8323455453,
0.6997292638,
-0.0802253857,
-0.0954395756,
0.141142115,
-0.3311240077,
-0.2410573065,
-0.0106784739,
0.4502599537,
-0.2777537107,
-0.236166656,
-0.7276269794,
0.200699389,
-0.3532419205,
0.7447497249,
-0.1036338508,
-0.1658678651,
-0.3733751774,
-0.233327195,
-0.4566507936,
-0.4405656457,
-0.5336151123,
-0.2586497366,
0.4419471323,
0.5829459429,
1.0161447525,
0.4911813736,
0.3737914264,
0.2902945578,
-0.4192017913,
0.3417589366,
-0.2888014019,
0.067568101,
-0.0312541723,
-0.7503272295,
-0.5086014867,
0.2440897971,
0.7119714022,
0.4633119106,
-0.1259052157,
0.252566129,
-0.1563335061,
0.6654936671,
-0.9992008805,
-0.0024975087,
-0.9532462358,
-0.1871841103,
-0.1319618374,
-0.1376216859,
-0.4403358102,
-0.4702904522,
-0.0890292376,
-0.3711684644,
-0.1572351754,
0.2849270999,
0.5422365665,
0.2377680838,
-0.4638933539,
-0.2868584394,
-0.5112202168,
0.6212258339,
-0.8499610424,
0.7087837458,
0.2166348249,
0.2041182816,
-0.2404139489,
-0.38029778,
-0.6731341481,
-0.3883571625,
0.0166934151,
0.0557656847,
-0.2017229795,
-0.0406047702,
0.5440484881,
0.2632157505,
-0.2698185742,
-0.2455730885,
-0.3112779856,
-0.2252370566,
0.5071617365,
0.192882821,
0.2150820494,
-0.4446199536,
-0.2185582966,
-0.1785516888,
-0.8143927455,
0.2905194461,
0.4615341425,
0.07272093,
0.0604165718,
0.8532207608,
-0.192100212,
0.8727035522,
-0.0140367905,
-0.5775481462,
0.0720927864,
-0.1987532973,
-0.1798271388,
-0.0499217696,
0.7596335411,
0.6022145748,
0.3681519926,
0.0028501321,
0.1569964588,
-0.3002191186,
0.0256288592,
-0.6988484263,
-0.1688712984,
0.3812491,
-0.0048504602,
-0.354522109,
-0.1458853483,
-0.78622967,
-0.4686067104,
0.0552306026,
0.5017071366,
-0.5863549113,
-0.050559666,
0.2556679845,
-0.3530813456,
0.0002730046,
0.6680285931,
-0.5257992744,
-0.122285448,
0.4816893935,
0.76632303,
0.3281339705,
-0.6688941717,
-0.4389546812,
0.1806408316,
-0.4028898478,
0.8722968102,
-0.6010677218,
-0.2901641726,
-0.2537667453,
-0.1905699819,
-0.0670003295,
-0.4058041871,
0.2719844282,
-0.8392807245,
0.2550305426,
-0.4259142578,
-0.8353954554,
-0.1147694066,
0.5864078403,
-0.4988412857,
0.8808937669,
0.0337204486,
-1.1461430788,
0.3579550683,
-0.5284293294,
-0.239402324,
-0.5339394212,
0.0576223433,
-0.5069745183,
-0.0793207735,
0.2664005458,
0.1860023588,
-0.4512404501,
0.3193747401,
-0.4443843365,
-0.0435107425,
0.4829489589,
-0.2476099581,
0.7321110368,
-0.001875776,
0.1326509416,
-0.0448982343,
-0.8085403442,
0.0028758976,
-0.0657626092,
-0.8203135729,
-0.3907866776,
-0.0562696755,
-0.4741895199,
0.0865461007,
0.222813949,
-0.7192681432,
0.6242185831,
0.0227906257,
0.2046848089,
0.7465301752,
0.3235597014,
0.1424233764,
-0.6249108911,
0.4491366744,
0.0444102772,
0.3485513628,
-0.2667491138,
-0.847391367,
-0.5159163475,
0.052751828,
0.4905017018,
0.7325003743,
-0.5431789756,
-0.0622079708,
-0.3219786882,
-0.6440032125,
-0.7463642955,
0.3254432678,
0.1396399587,
0.49662292,
0.378952533,
-0.1538420469,
-0.397921145,
-0.7223231196,
-0.9381654263,
-0.4028965831,
0.2018833905,
0.3052029014,
0.4657305777,
-0.1280011833,
0.9573049545,
-0.6366176009,
0.3956458271,
-0.0956986025,
0.4219426215,
0.0632981211,
0.249809444,
0.1740045547,
-0.5410842299,
-0.2563385367,
-0.0708784834,
-0.5896441936,
-0.1819347888,
-0.2565079927,
0.0611197054,
-0.2114063054,
0.4777632058,
-0.6872730851,
0.1513583958,
0.5874054432,
-0.2155880332,
1.012838006,
-0.0907669365,
0.782572031,
-1.0146796703,
0.0584989674,
-0.6094201803,
-0.1964870989,
-0.615303278,
0.0982600972,
0.4438094497,
-0.0427932143,
-0.6049520373,
0.5951528549,
-0.3265782893,
-0.0409743153,
-0.1767716259,
0.2908590734,
0.099372983,
0.1960050464,
-0.4902590513,
0.8682054281,
0.2707870305,
-0.5140545964,
0.4119122326,
0.4242684245,
-0.5996085405,
0.3078185618,
-0.1933909208,
0.5282441378,
-0.3065937757,
-0.0091517167,
-0.9563335776,
-0.0249615256,
0.0435399972,
-0.3918041289,
0.2295641005,
-0.5499794483,
-0.5117530823,
-0.1342925429,
-0.4537627399,
0.3872715831,
0.1699269265,
-0.3226292133,
0.5259519219,
0.3670648336,
-0.2143601626,
-0.7519251108,
-0.5045698881,
0.3331100941,
-0.1842923611,
-0.8057876229,
0.1197411567,
-0.3360137641,
-0.5402044058,
0.1520274878,
-0.1526731104,
-0.0478360578,
0.0970010459,
-0.0865260288,
0.0729093552,
-0.0596726835,
0.1517216116,
0.1174173132,
-0.1045898199,
-0.1636447161,
0.1422028542,
0.3076601028,
0.0319953226,
-0.2739238143,
-0.1498765796,
0.0605324283,
0.9279908538,
-0.3283542991,
0.6214671135,
0.1709217131,
-0.2204230875,
0.152093038,
-0.8069359064,
0.1449066103,
-0.3864901364,
0.2859545648,
-0.6177240014,
-0.9707988501,
0.3986748755,
-0.4608634412,
0.270522058,
0.4918432534,
0.4359878302,
-0.0584699661,
0.6370289326,
0.5491404533,
-0.1875804216,
0.3009654582,
-0.137895152,
0.1273853183,
-1.0620024204,
0.0462757796,
-0.374255836,
-0.2206177562,
-0.4071058929,
-0.6037198901,
0.6582514644,
0.3716025352,
-0.1058886126,
0.3981337249,
0.2465520203,
0.5037643909,
0.505256474,
0.1443504542,
0.6497910023,
-0.6325810552,
-0.1856821775,
-0.0079450412,
-0.829726398,
-0.4085650146,
1.3443646431,
0.0357947648,
0.8836595416,
0.1643076837,
0.460519284,
0.219745934,
0.5135740638,
-0.6476122737,
0.3295843601,
0.0666175187,
-0.8513667583,
-0.3661190867,
-0.5272238851,
-0.5429783463,
0.3809093535,
-0.5017648935,
-0.499822855,
-0.0109243961,
0.3748079538,
-0.5584029555,
0.6734197736,
-0.5699189901,
0.8473856449,
-0.3473008871,
-0.2221948206,
-0.3001308143,
-0.4141937792,
0.7911323905,
-0.1799548417,
0.6859243512,
-0.1570299864,
0.1025441512,
0.8069676757,
-0.1596823037,
0.4298102856,
-0.1241549179,
0.1076331958,
0.3236629367,
0.4138504565,
0.5086752176,
0.0167400148,
-0.3108469248,
-0.0923788622,
0.2407175004,
-0.1905956715,
-0.8961387873,
0.4038800299,
-0.586805582,
-0.6746894121,
-0.2436411232,
-0.7841741443,
-0.3932992518,
0.0680057779,
0.0425296426,
0.3134272695,
-0.0555293113,
-0.097147353,
0.2408037931,
-0.5183041692,
0.1925154477,
0.5470718145,
-0.4298523664,
-0.6322050095,
0.3494680524,
0.3169264197,
0.5264509916,
0.3042374253,
0.6703778505,
-0.0944697484,
-0.269459635,
-0.5442066789,
0.1359009892,
-0.8327155113,
-0.2183830589,
-0.777449429,
-0.0827756375,
-0.3296738863,
-0.0402686223,
-0.5099483728,
-0.4786122739,
0.342487663,
0.1141698882,
0.5696720481,
0.7105310559,
-0.2324295789,
0.3102477789,
-0.8227247,
0.4390630424,
0.5979123116,
0.2653306127,
-0.1920457631,
-0.7173149586,
-0.3103927374,
0.013651452,
-0.3629823625,
-1.3954776525,
-0.1337594986,
0.2710416615,
0.3389395475,
0.2383183092,
-0.106716685,
1.0193734169,
-0.5948787928,
0.5946617126,
0.0089341514,
-0.9910535812,
0.7453672886,
0.010540206,
0.4095567465,
0.5613017678,
0.2411554307,
-0.9749827981,
-0.576295495,
-0.7318847179,
-0.4682665169,
0.2267820239,
-0.1553386897,
-0.111102514,
0.1712044626,
0.6186179519,
0.1225970164,
0.5145108104,
-0.6474887729,
-0.2365108281,
0.1991479248,
0.2691436112,
-0.0708625317,
-0.4758652747,
0.0040044878,
-0.323807627,
0.7117648721,
-0.005112987,
0.0387402959,
0.220524624,
-0.418304354,
-0.2784865499,
0.7032347322,
0.5288527012,
0.7294908166,
-0.4856026769,
0.3966404796,
0.4926799834,
-0.1593598425,
0.2404632568,
-0.3344281018,
-0.3310727775,
-0.0757375956,
0.5594927073,
0.5369151831,
0.5943906307,
-0.5554133654,
0.5626659989,
0.0814070702,
0.0088624619,
0.2357806712,
0.2171070129,
0.2021639645,
0.2042488158,
-0.0718327612,
0.3338282108,
-0.0986700282,
-0.801835835,
0.4163267314,
0.3631129861,
0.0457061566,
-0.2093852162,
0.5921698213,
-0.2533933818,
-0.2839021981,
0.496095866,
-0.247597903,
-0.7735952735,
0.1159716323,
0.3590180278,
0.6433108449,
-0.4952009916,
-0.0661880672,
0.5463263988,
0.7767528296,
0.0105466032,
0.4130108356,
0.1520904601,
-0.9714578986,
-0.5511082411,
-0.5017985106,
-0.8081037402,
0.1876678616,
-0.4268250465,
0.2792549729,
-0.4692112207,
-0.2522415817,
-0.0988266468,
-0.0428996757,
-0.6072298288,
0.2154142857,
-0.1539482325,
1.0802038908,
-1.0759994984,
0.8486579061,
0.5041704774,
-0.2570564151,
-0.4674339294,
0.0327184908,
0.1828775406,
-0.7984000444,
0.1232673302,
-0.1354460716,
-0.0214852579,
-0.0567181408,
-0.5973504186,
-0.9733181596,
0.934053421,
0.5701465011,
-0.511716187,
0.2107463032,
0.1242212281,
0.0606616363,
-0.036957074,
0.3479027152,
0.7505353093,
0.7350507379,
-0.1610231102,
-0.859010458,
-0.1914808899,
0.0106631294,
-0.4451017082,
0.1962133199,
-0.7031464577,
1.0133092403,
-0.6513730288,
-0.0341494605,
-0.2541976273,
0.3253275156,
0.2047552466,
0.1070604771,
0.8082476854,
0.9159523845,
0.9282202125,
0.164585948,
0.9590901732,
-0.5494653583,
0.4589097202,
1.3323041201,
-0.0142762391,
1.0543357134,
0.546833992,
-0.4755539298,
0.4771633446,
0.3451623023,
0.1881451011,
0.298048079,
0.1888321191,
-0.069107376,
-0.2437056899,
0.2898280323,
-0.1648077965,
0.7138971686,
-0.0355098136,
0.1216423735,
-0.3725295663,
-0.1435804665,
0.5242229104,
-0.2212233692,
-0.099310033,
0.6050983071,
-0.0014528288,
-0.6264343858,
0.3916667402,
0.2718107104,
0.3406048119,
-0.4736923575,
0.1260170937,
-0.1665545702,
-0.149358958,
-0.0403914377,
-0.8877139688,
0.3255720437,
0.3747705221,
-0.204944253,
-0.0002791092,
0.4432369471,
-0.5181167126,
-0.6300339699,
0.2291930169,
0.6937046647,
0.0834290087,
-0.2587686479,
-0.8078990579,
0.175840795,
-0.1244300008,
-0.3391067982,
0.0694487467,
0.3014907539,
0.1975971907,
0.8092961907,
0.668448925,
0.3063216805,
0.4500790238,
-0.0864433497,
0.6045396328,
-0.8153640628,
-0.3314515948,
-0.9604317546,
0.66241467,
0.121456556,
-0.4724135995,
0.8311584592,
0.6861319542,
0.6815136671,
0.0857113823,
0.859775722,
-0.2188700438,
0.4453513622,
-0.7456953526,
0.5737874508,
-0.6299670339,
0.0939597189,
-0.4353268147,
-0.6045837402,
-0.184850201,
0.2752985358,
-0.4719761312,
-0.193646431,
0.9433036447,
0.8516535163,
-0.0491647422,
0.0129478537,
0.528314352,
0.6505573392,
0.1982006729,
0.5385557413,
1.0463912487,
-0.7894619703,
0.3467590511,
-0.4986948669,
-0.3358578682,
0.0075145098,
-1.0164307356,
-0.6377948523,
-0.4666887224,
-0.4428143203,
-0.1215298772,
0.0888613164,
0.879971385,
0.5095728636,
-0.654396534,
-0.3163184524,
0.5421504378,
0.3808790445,
-0.2276840955,
-0.1065019518,
0.4512881041,
-0.3369286656,
-0.2996840775,
0.6552967429,
0.5247309208,
-0.1867479831,
0.0596783087,
0.1974361241,
-0.5019099712,
0.1270781457,
0.6394492984,
0.0595872141,
-0.6973534226,
-0.6817924976,
-0.1411068887,
0.2476698905,
0.2893489599,
0.8269523382,
-0.472691983,
0.8925942779,
0.4114588201,
0.7450154424,
0.3632039428,
0.1646803319,
0.390864253,
-0.4828796387,
-0.0824975148,
-0.1624245346,
0.5043088198,
0.4434791207,
-0.1893573552,
0.0594472326,
0.3283439279,
-0.6534742713,
-0.6644557714,
0.1164827645,
-0.7456054091,
-0.1760376394,
0.975813508,
-0.1022653207,
-0.3086315691,
0.0100388639,
-0.2394248396,
0.2377952039,
0.0317716971,
0.9639360905,
0.9965609908,
-0.1622202545,
-0.3890110254,
-0.7726478577,
0.508515954,
0.2825562954,
-0.8100554943,
0.427672863,
0.3244525492,
0.5775790215,
0.0620067753,
0.6844345331,
-0.0590948053,
0.3077886105,
0.0765238181,
0.1085469872,
-0.0414269827,
-0.5358817577,
-0.2000892758,
0.1637550145,
0.4023046494,
0.0339715555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14794v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14794v2 | Debiasing Made State-of-the-art: Revisiting the Simple Seed-based Weak Supervision for Text Classification | 2023-05-24T06:45:33 | 2023-10-23T11:22:58 | Chengyu Dong, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advances in weakly supervised text classification mostly focus on
designing sophisticated methods to turn high-level human heuristics into
quality pseudo-labels. In this paper, we revisit the seed matching-based
method, which is arguably the simplest way to generate pseudo-labels, and show
that its power was greatly underestimated. We show that the limited performance
of seed matching is largely due to the label bias injected by the simple
seed-match rule, which prevents the classifier from learning reliable
confidence for selecting high-quality pseudo-labels. Interestingly, simply
deleting the seed words present in the matched input texts can mitigate the
label bias and help learn better confidence. Subsequently, the performance
achieved by seed matching can be improved significantly, making it on par with
or even better than the state-of-the-art. Furthermore, to handle the case when
the seed words are not made known, we propose to simply delete the word tokens
in the input text randomly with a high deletion ratio. Remarkably, seed
matching equipped with this random deletion method can often achieve even
better performance than that with seed deletion. | [
-0.0726541653,
-0.4823164344,
0.500988245,
0.0702588782,
-0.5302267671,
-0.2329435945,
-0.0414576195,
-0.5643758774,
-0.0025451283,
0.1575377136,
-0.2504341006,
-0.480327189,
-0.8447847962,
0.1462043375,
-0.6328323483,
1.2089765072,
0.1688906401,
-0.163448751,
-0.3148218989,
-0.0489520952,
-0.112964794,
-0.39875108,
-0.4720157683,
-0.4966352284,
0.3030228317,
0.5778383017,
0.5696159005,
0.744360745,
0.7805510163,
0.2613060176,
-0.7119315863,
0.1666859239,
-0.8475615978,
0.0943058878,
-0.2075024843,
-0.4182872176,
-0.3139030039,
0.4154530764,
0.2375142425,
0.7954569459,
0.1659787744,
0.1032975614,
0.3637123108,
0.4341377318,
-0.9788210988,
-0.0682160407,
-0.797883749,
0.0708002076,
-0.3909644485,
-0.2121846676,
-0.574667275,
-0.3183114827,
-0.0114018517,
-0.5569788218,
0.5814594626,
0.2826146483,
1.1009523869,
0.3862810731,
-0.2400291711,
-0.3842261434,
-0.8940161467,
0.8670725226,
-0.4667692184,
-0.0477958396,
0.6440149546,
0.0229418539,
-0.2899170518,
-0.8354076147,
-0.4221845567,
0.3313039243,
-0.1585032344,
0.1336342245,
-0.2633756399,
0.1831956953,
0.4083972275,
0.6048762798,
-0.136119619,
0.1342407018,
-0.5677627921,
-0.3327953517,
0.3133504093,
-0.2322948575,
0.0746274889,
-0.3266710639,
-0.5842298269,
-0.1753670722,
-0.6172177792,
-0.0856659561,
0.0892397687,
0.3148449957,
0.263916254,
0.5637812614,
-0.0828330815,
0.4785861373,
0.3561088443,
-0.5171564817,
0.3096189797,
-0.2785848081,
-0.2839511931,
0.4082603157,
0.9293255806,
0.5830553174,
0.2408160865,
-0.2175428271,
-0.1412864476,
0.4454568326,
0.1588137448,
-0.7490435243,
-0.3451400101,
-0.1906625777,
-0.7536439896,
-0.710981369,
-0.0079499986,
-0.6244038939,
-0.5663547516,
0.0819701478,
0.5872032046,
-0.2807812393,
0.1607247144,
-0.0040507689,
-0.4824948013,
0.1735763848,
0.298225075,
-0.9361160398,
0.1842972189,
0.7140924335,
0.8431093693,
0.0311636105,
0.0938300714,
-0.3258794546,
-0.0589193068,
-0.4851131439,
0.6046039462,
-0.277777642,
-0.5308377147,
-0.3148138821,
-0.2675372362,
0.2672129571,
-0.5005805492,
0.804286778,
-0.3728960454,
0.4095309973,
-0.3127055466,
-0.6236801147,
-0.0153712444,
0.2660026252,
-0.3578799069,
1.0869693756,
-0.0861414596,
-1.246835351,
0.9363313317,
0.1358405203,
-0.546067059,
-0.0670068562,
-0.0432735011,
-0.8865859509,
0.1193075627,
0.2235841751,
0.3563988209,
-0.1771001369,
0.1392705292,
-0.5678747296,
-0.9011315703,
-0.3188892603,
-0.453843534,
0.829523921,
0.2701428831,
-0.5390715599,
-0.1311337501,
-1.0400787592,
-0.0591820702,
-0.1607487798,
0.003453485,
-0.9787951708,
0.166524604,
-0.2503627241,
0.2217494994,
0.0070838253,
-0.555698216,
0.2771452069,
-0.6477912068,
0.3327511251,
0.6832270026,
0.1303845346,
0.7061963677,
-0.2676933408,
0.0014293664,
0.1012800336,
0.2522880435,
0.0483567081,
-0.5487647653,
-0.7123282552,
-0.5139562488,
0.3709491491,
0.4650805295,
-0.7453246117,
0.3075178564,
-0.0871032029,
-0.5772892237,
-0.6630174518,
0.4258658588,
0.4315017164,
0.6431571841,
0.4975227118,
-0.1637818068,
-0.5769103765,
-1.004014492,
-0.249417454,
-0.2540633082,
0.0834377557,
0.0059269196,
0.3841903508,
-0.2879017293,
1.0278086662,
-0.6258199811,
-0.722276032,
-0.1817831248,
0.3627696037,
0.2410035431,
0.5476599336,
0.6752660871,
-0.7943283319,
-0.2779464722,
-0.4273395836,
-0.8554038405,
-0.2393503487,
0.1389952898,
-0.0355750583,
-0.3013641238,
0.5559577942,
-0.2323104292,
0.6128659248,
0.2621403337,
-0.1598961502,
0.1956183165,
-0.1627852023,
0.1511640102,
-1.1501085758,
-0.1106505543,
0.1446478665,
-0.0863978043,
-0.2442814112,
-0.1308861971,
0.2224554867,
0.0815246701,
-0.4843178093,
0.3478357792,
-0.468888253,
0.3485277593,
-0.8050552607,
0.1226021796,
-0.1094399467,
0.0452705845,
-0.1004837155,
0.6547339559,
0.6513499022,
-0.6348282695,
0.1109593958,
0.2680856884,
-0.2781682611,
0.4837025702,
-0.5421429276,
0.0028403737,
-0.3995229304,
0.2357262224,
-0.964473784,
0.0697846189,
0.3841454387,
-0.3030180335,
0.2358156145,
-0.3245248497,
-0.4489005208,
-0.5407967567,
-0.460628897,
0.4840448499,
0.8029121757,
-0.7386853695,
0.0917132124,
0.2058922201,
0.1190897375,
-0.5747310519,
-0.6969339252,
-0.0064617693,
-0.1956210732,
-0.0649876669,
0.3223454356,
0.3496322632,
-0.3005747497,
0.1173227355,
-0.3806373775,
-0.0844195485,
0.2354083061,
0.4112351239,
-0.0215619579,
0.2289539278,
0.1934069097,
0.2732612193,
-0.3940156102,
-0.1153794974,
-0.4080101848,
-0.2955618203,
0.2657610476,
-0.1652059853,
-0.3958905041,
-0.0759908706,
0.3873566091,
0.2676421404,
0.6726884246,
0.3845070899,
-0.5077090263,
-0.5589197278,
-0.2642623186,
-0.4136994183,
-0.5084845424,
0.0564296395,
-0.2850362957,
-0.6136569381,
-0.1395158172,
-0.3166847229,
-0.0502810739,
0.3976165652,
0.2371609658,
-0.409065038,
0.8237317801,
0.8797826171,
-0.3438786268,
0.2496745139,
-0.1615183949,
0.0957805067,
-0.4052462578,
-0.101520896,
-0.7186253667,
-0.5690726042,
-0.6924575567,
-0.2985023558,
0.0211597662,
0.3030686677,
0.2585928738,
0.4382232726,
-0.7241187692,
0.461706847,
0.9072937965,
0.0896318108,
0.271363914,
-0.1396563202,
-0.139370352,
-0.2705723941,
-0.6579557061,
-0.4840907454,
0.9750598073,
0.0804513693,
1.0027991533,
-0.2966820598,
1.107370615,
0.4627568126,
0.5099956989,
-0.6250618696,
0.4574905932,
-0.3138555288,
-0.5115326643,
0.0662984848,
-0.6646171212,
-0.721288681,
0.3926745355,
-0.488451153,
-0.638980329,
0.3204584122,
0.6273916364,
-0.0743133873,
0.4830032289,
-0.7986623049,
0.6252399087,
0.0837356895,
-0.3932289779,
0.1183766499,
-0.3857432306,
0.4981616437,
-0.0421554111,
0.3943755925,
0.1835625917,
0.2714835107,
1.086935997,
-0.5686526299,
0.8600527048,
-0.180487141,
-0.1067615971,
0.5689405203,
-0.0524191074,
0.5530368686,
-0.1167681441,
0.0564799123,
-0.0974116921,
-0.0583569482,
-0.4669121802,
-0.2934806645,
0.72808671,
-0.6828641891,
-0.5212911963,
-0.6948637366,
0.2053239942,
-0.1268719882,
0.3490668237,
0.67101264,
0.2423687279,
-0.249153465,
0.4173200428,
0.6583081484,
0.0149029717,
0.404920876,
0.2460557818,
0.0892550647,
-0.4375593364,
0.9059873819,
-0.0196154583,
0.0007720852,
0.4834121466,
0.3699543178,
-0.1401800066,
-0.715333879,
0.0457254313,
-0.1186742336,
-0.5962575674,
-0.3028983176,
-0.6016258597,
0.0780464113,
-0.4342519045,
-0.1440154314,
-0.2978609204,
-0.2710215151,
-0.3484089077,
-0.2275957763,
0.124552995,
0.7256711721,
-0.1565331072,
0.6390706897,
-0.5227916241,
0.5945615768,
0.2807751298,
0.3134655058,
-0.1359903812,
-0.415701896,
-0.0298647638,
-0.1579952836,
-0.3752079606,
-0.9875076413,
-0.0063105561,
0.1733547002,
0.2159441411,
0.7189003825,
0.4994910955,
0.419426918,
-0.3988319039,
0.5814219713,
0.2531419098,
-0.7961800694,
0.6371232271,
0.0583129078,
0.1492204517,
0.9515188932,
0.366117537,
-0.2841188014,
-0.5426838994,
-0.6973639131,
-1.1241332293,
0.7388067245,
0.3595601022,
-0.2744112015,
-0.166313678,
0.3918186128,
0.2057235688,
0.2633759677,
-0.586827755,
-0.4414205849,
-0.1597690731,
-0.4778387249,
-0.2034984678,
-0.5501701832,
0.1838173121,
-0.2385064214,
0.9871662259,
0.0188997742,
-0.1678659171,
0.1854922324,
-0.2163399905,
-0.0684314892,
0.3713691831,
0.2136199027,
0.1458503157,
-0.3525372148,
0.3981168866,
0.0453354716,
-0.6953887343,
0.4590716958,
-0.0343929008,
-0.9342635274,
-0.112692982,
0.4777130485,
0.5345038772,
0.4866597354,
-0.1416553706,
0.6518922448,
-0.0982556716,
-0.4943316877,
0.3567047715,
0.157559365,
-0.3205703199,
-0.1682006717,
0.5091069937,
0.5066304803,
0.2460192442,
-0.3874019682,
0.4384439588,
0.3270940483,
-0.7284476757,
-0.2151046395,
0.8027063012,
0.3915633261,
-0.0808851495,
0.3977222741,
-0.6136370301,
-0.6928934455,
0.2623679936,
0.411016047,
0.8162254691,
0.4250746667,
0.1540148556,
0.3599790037,
0.4515877068,
-0.5296909213,
-0.0533390008,
-0.2182059139,
-0.5164155364,
-0.4174422026,
-0.6562404633,
-0.3153068125,
0.197890535,
-0.4678645134,
0.0894274935,
-0.5397471189,
-0.4478529394,
-0.1278850436,
0.157636568,
-0.4972810149,
0.4775560796,
0.0661707297,
0.835824728,
-1.0333999395,
0.5682298541,
0.8115687966,
-0.274584353,
-0.5893266797,
0.1659263521,
0.2233623862,
-0.1233760491,
0.6453374028,
0.2339108586,
-0.109646,
-0.0859236568,
-0.6608570218,
-0.5688410997,
0.6796739101,
-0.1668329388,
-0.6901605725,
-0.0080610113,
-0.2955930233,
0.5026583076,
0.5098039508,
0.2765642107,
0.1277409941,
0.281460613,
0.1367787719,
-0.6733307242,
-0.0533198863,
-0.2383968234,
-0.1790689081,
0.2757821381,
-0.5568756461,
0.5862588882,
-0.117059052,
-0.4522078037,
0.1106806919,
0.9488777518,
-0.074134253,
0.5918878913,
0.5400094986,
0.7120730877,
0.8320530057,
-0.3961448669,
0.5254904032,
-0.0991844684,
0.596953392,
1.0906652212,
-0.2751893997,
0.5569878817,
0.6940199137,
-0.2037130743,
0.2256022841,
0.4419492483,
0.044933442,
0.7805478573,
0.255710423,
-0.0400386341,
-0.3138045967,
0.0893173367,
-0.3067401946,
0.4757041633,
-0.0580227375,
-0.4149244726,
-0.4569821358,
0.1390733421,
-0.2280184627,
0.4925030172,
-0.3257275522,
1.0152999163,
0.2863238156,
-0.3902673721,
0.2525359988,
0.106159769,
1.2162666321,
-0.4256695807,
0.0936466977,
-0.018230211,
0.7732194066,
-0.1313726008,
-0.4966146648,
0.0016342361,
0.1044872627,
-0.4645447433,
-0.3962359726,
1.0488251448,
-0.2165245563,
-0.3798834682,
0.4412530959,
0.2712390125,
0.0198278595,
0.1696710438,
-0.4410863519,
-0.1276081949,
-0.2136413455,
-0.1155791655,
0.3649860919,
0.6183510423,
-0.0644225329,
0.5268043876,
0.5106438994,
0.3149664998,
-0.2534431517,
-0.0092866635,
0.6066829562,
-0.7543186545,
-0.6027334929,
-0.8786135912,
-0.2141907364,
-0.2756837308,
-0.3751691878,
1.0248578787,
0.5825351477,
0.8904051185,
0.0287888478,
0.8736172915,
-0.1170916334,
0.457383126,
-0.216692403,
0.6262454987,
-0.4703934491,
0.1342455745,
-0.7409517169,
-0.9371433854,
-0.226749137,
0.5583776832,
-0.3499446511,
0.0821832195,
0.5395431519,
0.5169171691,
-0.1575771123,
-0.0021899412,
0.2522510886,
0.1674531847,
0.3008471429,
0.4072546363,
0.6751835346,
-0.7144506574,
0.7177535295,
-0.5995367765,
-0.5946466923,
-0.3501119912,
-0.9973019361,
-0.9077426791,
-0.2893235981,
-0.3883835077,
-0.37290892,
0.5605349541,
0.8323099017,
0.6159102917,
-0.8887276053,
0.4672302008,
-0.1512557119,
0.2837797999,
-0.5287557244,
-0.2637094855,
0.3290115297,
-0.2929992378,
-0.6661911607,
0.3541361988,
0.1289453506,
0.2806651294,
0.2095684111,
0.1644915342,
-0.0938548744,
-0.1432324648,
0.4562623203,
0.285005331,
-0.2222389877,
-0.2118004411,
-0.3089252114,
-0.5648626685,
-0.2977828681,
0.7285990119,
-0.9788018465,
0.3757059574,
0.7551970482,
0.5626980066,
0.320274502,
0.4766408205,
0.3498203456,
-0.902970016,
0.3689951897,
0.2175373137,
0.2590712011,
0.2792387605,
-0.1621312648,
0.1945195645,
0.6261783838,
-0.2941402793,
-0.8755201101,
-0.0632422864,
-0.7158815265,
-0.4263273478,
1.0477620363,
0.0721987262,
-0.5402199626,
-0.0423770882,
-0.4705739319,
0.2371813655,
-0.2339706868,
0.9729632735,
0.4613852203,
0.4393618703,
0.203704372,
0.205752328,
0.8152608275,
0.3582553267,
-0.3209042847,
-0.1677317917,
0.3503623307,
0.1576260924,
0.2548053563,
0.6947963238,
0.1451802403,
0.2711775601,
0.3238214552,
-0.0788910687,
-0.0928994417,
-0.3806862533,
0.0486020222,
0.5008633733,
0.2172673792,
-0.428668201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14793v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14793v2 | Faithful Low-Resource Data-to-Text Generation through Cycle Training | 2023-05-24T06:44:42 | 2023-07-11T16:15:00 | Zhuoer Wang, Marcus Collins, Nikhita Vedula, Simone Filice, Shervin Malmasi, Oleg Rokhlenko | cs.CL | cs.CL | Methods to generate text from structured data have advanced significantly in
recent years, primarily due to fine-tuning of pre-trained language models on
large datasets. However, such models can fail to produce output faithful to the
input data, particularly on out-of-domain data. Sufficient annotated data is
often not available for specific domains, leading us to seek an unsupervised
approach to improve the faithfulness of output text. Since the problem is
fundamentally one of consistency between the representations of the structured
data and text, we evaluate the effectiveness of cycle training in this work.
Cycle training uses two models which are inverses of each other: one that
generates text from structured data, and one which generates the structured
data from natural language text. We show that cycle training, when initialized
with a small amount of supervised data (100 samples in our case), achieves
nearly the same performance as fully supervised approaches for the data-to-text
generation task on the WebNLG, E2E, WTQ, and WSQL datasets. We perform
extensive empirical analysis with automated evaluation metrics and a newly
designed human evaluation schema to reveal different cycle training strategies'
effectiveness of reducing various types of generation errors. Our code is
publicly available at https://github.com/Edillower/CycleNLG. | [
-0.0011400939,
-0.6229165196,
0.5027233958,
0.1346826404,
-0.4986391962,
0.1290594786,
-0.4783628881,
-0.3435854316,
-0.2060913444,
0.4923561215,
-0.7768888474,
-0.4521777034,
-0.3063042462,
0.5188307762,
-0.5937988758,
1.2099047899,
-0.1574780941,
0.2361086309,
-0.5156143904,
0.0025510162,
-0.33483845,
-0.5611783266,
-0.4679301083,
-0.5524641275,
0.1545621902,
0.2591358125,
0.3328525722,
0.7066351771,
0.2925502658,
0.1992106736,
0.4374957979,
0.7320907712,
-0.8073303699,
0.3160311282,
-0.0132764736,
-0.0416916609,
-0.1543644369,
0.2882316113,
0.6250433326,
0.8779560924,
-0.1122421846,
0.1831511408,
0.4605059922,
0.9471510053,
-0.5187740326,
0.0658070445,
-0.9413956404,
-0.1112556309,
-0.3473928571,
-0.3242850602,
-0.6704326272,
-0.3736171424,
-0.1431484371,
-0.9310013056,
0.4150727391,
0.2865610421,
0.8699039817,
0.4008733928,
-0.3445705771,
-0.556362927,
-1.0255955458,
0.7569565773,
-0.6009075046,
0.3354794085,
0.5573986173,
-0.1931948811,
-0.15074642,
-0.8254865408,
-0.5818544626,
-0.0213228706,
-0.0586311705,
0.3901974261,
0.0442476794,
-0.2268674076,
0.3113796711,
0.2418792844,
-0.5702973008,
-0.0993217975,
-0.2157519162,
-0.1640722752,
0.6663253903,
0.2381858677,
0.0520757437,
-0.1713116318,
-0.3076715469,
-0.1833092868,
-0.7426730394,
-0.1337329298,
0.7948619127,
0.5439106226,
0.0512397476,
0.7506206632,
-0.235564813,
0.6365640759,
0.1421978623,
-0.0103830667,
0.1530096084,
-0.7092357278,
-0.162875101,
-0.0321885906,
0.9073026776,
0.3579943776,
0.4156660438,
-0.5289060473,
-0.2999194264,
0.1538840681,
0.505240202,
-0.91323632,
-0.2351591438,
-0.1003158167,
-0.3041199446,
-0.5227802992,
0.2666029334,
-0.6523195505,
-0.0711221397,
-0.381500423,
0.1627776772,
-0.5220727324,
0.2014088035,
-0.0916683227,
-0.0139781665,
-0.1773946434,
0.1731909513,
-0.6787880659,
0.3519768417,
0.3790727258,
0.7376496792,
-0.4387882948,
-0.0534885526,
-0.7915956974,
0.1999182999,
-0.5003899336,
0.6924852729,
-0.3650122583,
-0.3050400019,
0.2164821476,
0.0069670235,
-0.2232975364,
-0.4764634073,
0.5109896064,
-0.4679446816,
0.3237505555,
-0.1634667963,
-0.7715531588,
0.4704422653,
-0.0648706704,
-0.5567269325,
1.2471910715,
0.1749627739,
-1.001203537,
0.5422121882,
-0.455037117,
-0.5982854366,
-0.1916949749,
-0.0513463356,
-0.7929223776,
0.0478245243,
0.0711326078,
0.137962997,
-0.3505093753,
0.0231952574,
-0.0660234019,
-0.3472004235,
0.3288602531,
-0.5461343527,
0.5019339919,
0.0598712005,
-0.2429190874,
-0.3144109547,
-1.0769203901,
0.2649434507,
0.3791164458,
-0.6476737261,
-0.4113515019,
0.1017799899,
0.247274816,
-0.0255402625,
0.1103958711,
-0.633793056,
0.2904608846,
-0.6763570309,
0.5111798048,
0.6070663333,
0.1499482989,
0.6173006296,
-0.2124525458,
0.3207693398,
-0.0520836376,
-0.192087397,
-0.2898414433,
-0.3548003137,
-0.5789858103,
0.1754122823,
0.4075430334,
0.4073781669,
-1.1693161726,
0.3118064702,
-0.3559119999,
-0.1970250458,
-0.3528555632,
0.4601384699,
0.7504286766,
0.6412469149,
0.3494448066,
-0.4365974963,
-0.602455914,
-0.6588715911,
-0.3084660172,
-0.0724091753,
-0.0922540128,
0.2479119003,
0.443325609,
-0.2830820978,
1.0948318243,
-0.4822201133,
-0.0917569026,
-0.1207659766,
0.5227630734,
-0.233210355,
0.503780067,
0.202781707,
-0.398273617,
-0.5084903836,
-0.1695147902,
-0.5935565829,
-0.148095414,
-0.10718669,
-0.2709058523,
0.5795065165,
0.2557913959,
-0.2527807057,
0.5172265768,
0.6455564499,
-0.0593322664,
0.415589124,
-0.314301312,
0.0057242839,
-1.0853633881,
0.1726228744,
-0.1746237129,
-0.6050553322,
-0.6189903617,
-0.5666563511,
-0.0637987554,
-0.1842503995,
-0.096728608,
0.2827345729,
-0.3985622823,
-0.1233345345,
-0.3425179124,
0.2822512984,
0.268746376,
0.4567648172,
-0.2503546178,
1.0464376211,
0.014477645,
-0.4539228678,
0.1341070086,
0.5924116373,
-0.2703522742,
0.249617219,
-0.4835091233,
0.6923083067,
-0.0230533239,
0.2340888083,
-0.7798137665,
-0.4219451547,
0.2732681334,
-0.3608598113,
0.396389395,
-0.0797408074,
-0.6132370234,
-0.2484944165,
-0.339840591,
0.3739578724,
0.5038958788,
-0.5103232265,
-0.0253706183,
0.0670239478,
0.2064998597,
-0.2699432969,
-0.7368195653,
-0.1336691678,
0.1615154147,
-0.5150171518,
0.4176950753,
-0.0008597407,
-0.0530092157,
0.0605586208,
-0.1295246929,
-0.2723208964,
-0.0636053458,
0.2214126289,
0.1916020662,
-0.0551497862,
0.2116263509,
-0.0484138504,
-0.1950754076,
-0.0406018831,
-0.516264081,
0.5642009377,
0.0875822753,
-0.4819102585,
-0.4663003087,
0.2366753221,
0.1001133323,
-0.0140132187,
0.7364874482,
0.3878222704,
-0.3420117497,
-0.4589241743,
-0.0720441416,
-0.2153170854,
-0.4132325649,
0.2162835896,
0.192706421,
-0.3344584405,
0.0292599332,
-0.1404449791,
0.1097721085,
0.4144561291,
0.3454067707,
-0.4170236886,
0.99626261,
0.6517069936,
0.3339669406,
0.237623021,
-0.2635315061,
0.1835864931,
-0.7142365575,
-0.0947898999,
-0.5169597864,
0.043371588,
-0.5804607868,
-0.2214187086,
0.203729108,
0.2790010273,
-0.1872085333,
0.313257128,
-0.5668891668,
0.1253218204,
0.5921028852,
0.1887346059,
0.5271484256,
0.2499916553,
0.16767627,
-0.1844963282,
-0.8152222633,
-0.9064483047,
1.2866414785,
-0.1806439608,
0.5271909237,
-0.5092570782,
0.6808492541,
0.2065110952,
0.3049882948,
-0.4346217513,
0.172175467,
-0.4369940162,
-0.2431790829,
-0.449585706,
-0.6257150173,
-0.9310551286,
-0.3080042601,
-0.4261774123,
-0.2400981486,
-0.0132701108,
0.4518430531,
-0.1179366335,
0.1566519141,
-0.6390835047,
0.7520154119,
-0.1698788553,
-0.5389232635,
0.066945672,
-0.4359271824,
0.2711718976,
-0.4605639577,
0.150205195,
0.0945023447,
0.1895236224,
0.8805208206,
-0.7569208145,
0.8427562118,
-0.0847614631,
0.0906251073,
0.4660793841,
-0.21661219,
0.8625683784,
0.0499351807,
-0.0044867941,
0.1221046299,
-0.2755967975,
-0.3557742834,
-0.4475705922,
0.270106554,
-0.6926239133,
-0.1039027795,
-0.1801088005,
-0.5135699511,
-0.5048510432,
0.0966451988,
0.7780274153,
0.5529019833,
-0.3000381887,
0.2392891198,
0.5532898903,
-0.2075778693,
0.4739210904,
0.1210425198,
-0.0262801368,
-0.4773569107,
0.7861829996,
0.0928398892,
0.3785244524,
0.1116169691,
0.0318580307,
-0.0912949964,
-0.4587348998,
-0.7367367148,
0.0347544588,
-0.4350286722,
-0.5490996242,
-0.4138438404,
-0.412715435,
-0.2008469105,
-0.0346820615,
-0.7156195045,
-0.4262216985,
-0.4421312809,
0.068913728,
0.3602472544,
0.9275787473,
0.2429549992,
0.3898862004,
-0.7101958394,
0.1821004152,
0.3350620866,
0.1380548924,
-0.1894120872,
-0.2812486291,
-0.3594814837,
0.4833053052,
-0.5368897915,
-0.8105271459,
0.2042801827,
0.4601036608,
0.1589556634,
0.2037692815,
0.281147331,
0.6003113389,
-0.7735668421,
0.7371562123,
0.251509726,
-0.9859634042,
0.5446448326,
-0.3421345055,
-0.0052849888,
0.7132413983,
-0.0000603519,
-0.224778533,
-0.4686244726,
-0.5217787623,
-0.8984484076,
0.8497299552,
0.8487564325,
0.1712939143,
0.0127579421,
0.578142643,
0.384477973,
0.406195581,
-0.6788788438,
-0.1438012868,
-0.5602248907,
-0.3763416708,
0.139471963,
-0.0212170668,
-0.0596714728,
0.0873874053,
0.8820125461,
-0.2971555591,
0.1288410127,
0.3201515675,
-0.0340692513,
-0.4628811777,
0.1158189699,
0.4994215965,
0.7484461069,
0.0702811927,
0.0345118791,
0.1180829853,
-0.6543667316,
0.0826258659,
-0.0571983196,
-0.5520233512,
0.1232220903,
0.6833336949,
0.6784336567,
0.1598535627,
-0.5588265657,
0.65919137,
0.0593579561,
-0.2198183984,
-0.1817795485,
0.0363880768,
0.0091403387,
-0.1399855763,
0.3297984898,
0.1772163659,
-0.2188419253,
-0.4906182587,
0.192950353,
0.382824719,
-0.3185214102,
-0.4610493481,
0.8040450811,
0.2600524426,
-0.1887338161,
0.8889890313,
-0.4338737428,
-0.3686486185,
0.4121772051,
0.6044092178,
0.7427043915,
0.2251194715,
0.3123638034,
0.427079618,
0.307474196,
-0.1967511028,
0.0499575511,
0.1789467186,
-0.7662709951,
-0.5133671165,
-0.7399768829,
-0.3117902279,
-0.0047629606,
-0.6684551239,
0.0843507275,
-0.1858361214,
-0.2147560865,
-0.2008352429,
0.1251498014,
-0.8078251481,
0.074679479,
-0.1629401296,
0.5325937271,
-0.8580942154,
0.9424312711,
0.6413756609,
-0.5545892119,
-0.6711547375,
0.360082835,
-0.3852786124,
-0.7552328706,
0.6230401397,
0.0621618032,
-0.1130516604,
-0.0535182282,
-0.6570661068,
-0.4797794819,
1.1213334799,
0.4854803383,
-0.7753812075,
0.0498278067,
0.4222581983,
0.6275642514,
-0.5343828797,
-0.3572351933,
0.2455461174,
0.46055305,
-0.0010477505,
-0.6905890107,
-0.0190862026,
0.0487723649,
0.1129883453,
0.0743784383,
-0.4289171696,
0.5955511928,
-0.0598638356,
-0.5241554379,
0.1846854687,
0.5408520103,
0.2095196694,
0.6081731319,
0.5845558643,
0.5090250373,
0.9279590249,
-0.2468753606,
0.9833571315,
-0.3843411803,
0.5193468928,
1.0868064165,
-0.4668028057,
0.7245773673,
0.5034183264,
-0.0752235129,
0.3336863816,
0.3995473683,
-0.0614532344,
0.6809771061,
0.0074791252,
0.0869923234,
-0.3427772224,
-0.0686927736,
-0.1325583756,
0.2438315898,
-0.3007704616,
-0.3571694493,
-0.1429999918,
0.051159218,
-0.035626106,
0.5381149054,
-0.0086459955,
0.8410035372,
-0.0302237347,
-0.5750648379,
0.4416015744,
0.0115107931,
0.4059619308,
-0.4156205356,
-0.0708348453,
-0.2286965251,
0.0483209491,
-0.2320461273,
-0.3797599077,
0.5635317564,
0.4720714986,
-0.3953895271,
-0.6131187081,
0.7861337066,
-0.4814825356,
-0.5791631341,
0.0419278368,
0.5296756625,
-0.0206361655,
0.0348155499,
-0.2928898335,
-0.1272935569,
0.0284089018,
-0.3254584968,
0.1596630812,
0.5672826767,
0.0899632648,
0.1119163856,
0.854601562,
0.0863752514,
0.092612803,
0.0042373259,
0.9459093213,
-0.307995826,
-0.1033403948,
-0.7273853421,
0.3414517045,
-0.2959976494,
-0.423093766,
0.5926086307,
0.957801342,
0.9287577868,
-0.0028830697,
0.8724304438,
0.1074657738,
0.5215592384,
-0.8093205094,
0.5236400962,
-0.4011428654,
0.223775804,
-0.1538653225,
-1.0625472069,
0.1634246707,
0.4546039402,
-0.037127696,
-0.0006913795,
0.8540010452,
0.5103997588,
-0.0808539838,
0.0999737978,
0.1291624308,
0.1865963489,
0.1045596451,
0.4796830416,
0.8656719923,
-0.6598625183,
0.7237544656,
-0.3336394727,
-0.0262465272,
0.0938554481,
-0.9412496686,
-0.9607499838,
-0.6890423894,
-0.2535687089,
-0.5266644955,
0.2861509919,
0.9163337946,
0.6324199438,
-0.6365219355,
0.0981067494,
-0.594404161,
-0.2436051518,
-0.0949674398,
-0.1689674109,
0.3763059676,
-0.6469941735,
-0.7073966265,
0.3494553566,
0.1606642157,
-0.0026857895,
-0.2072278559,
-0.2195507586,
0.1604183018,
0.2001323402,
0.3877165616,
-0.010704522,
-0.2502073348,
-0.2998391092,
-0.039462775,
-0.3893467188,
0.233215645,
1.0602282286,
-0.6234270334,
0.2102192342,
0.3493658006,
0.6500262618,
0.7752148509,
0.2852872908,
0.6386691928,
-1.1574598551,
0.0260241311,
0.1426493376,
0.1459899098,
0.5859452486,
-0.3509483933,
0.6381687522,
0.5498797894,
-0.5392214656,
-0.8274049759,
0.1369976401,
-0.793771863,
-0.2400555164,
1.2416169643,
-0.0367368571,
-0.1558443308,
-0.1473114043,
0.0403812267,
0.564797461,
-0.2659295499,
0.8460128903,
0.6453090906,
-0.1313911378,
0.5215539336,
-0.7056494951,
0.7082450986,
0.0818795636,
-1.0290476084,
0.4350532591,
0.4073356688,
0.1373890042,
0.1290404201,
0.6760263443,
0.0153920343,
-0.1274773926,
-0.0780330524,
0.022464117,
-0.2278523594,
-0.1957514584,
0.0703714341,
0.0634763166,
-0.2444576472,
-0.1591889411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14791v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14791v2 | Prompting Large Language Models for Counterfactual Generation: An Empirical Study | 2023-05-24T06:44:32 | 2024-02-23T07:02:09 | Yongqi Li, Mayi Xu, Xin Miao, Shen Zhou, Tieyun Qian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have made remarkable progress in a wide range of
natural language understanding and generation tasks. However, their ability to
generate counterfactuals has not been examined systematically. To bridge this
gap, we present a comprehensive evaluation framework on various types of NLU
tasks, which covers all key factors in determining LLMs' capability of
generating counterfactuals. Based on this framework, we 1) investigate the
strengths and weaknesses of LLMs as the counterfactual generator, and 2)
disclose the factors that affect LLMs when generating counterfactuals,
including both the intrinsic properties of LLMs and prompt designing. The
results show that, though LLMs are promising in most cases, they face
challenges in complex tasks like RE since they are bounded by task-specific
performance, entity constraints, and inherent selection bias. We also find that
alignment techniques, e.g., instruction-tuning and reinforcement learning from
human feedback, may potentially enhance the counterfactual generation ability
of LLMs. On the contrary, simply increasing the parameter size does not yield
the desired improvements. Besides, from the perspective of prompt designing,
task guidelines unsurprisingly play an important role. However, the
chain-of-thought approach does not always help due to inconsistency issues. | [
-0.6555621028,
-1.2010862827,
0.82172966,
0.1818083078,
-0.2851724327,
-0.1093565226,
-0.1695900708,
-0.2027918249,
0.0956408754,
0.3363479674,
-0.9195448756,
-0.0625177026,
-0.5649923682,
0.4071010649,
-0.4648688138,
1.0799258947,
-0.0782531127,
-0.0718920454,
-0.4262517393,
0.0471885391,
-0.7994858623,
-0.4282791615,
-0.7272914648,
-0.5459241867,
0.6687352657,
0.3305079341,
0.6432080865,
0.3159799576,
0.1798103452,
0.3301254511,
0.1998595595,
0.1455224454,
-0.4935634434,
0.3288956881,
-0.4120377004,
-0.4091278315,
-0.3754470944,
0.1145889461,
0.605974853,
0.65901196,
-0.0310173742,
0.2048967779,
0.2042834759,
0.555354774,
-0.3744727373,
-0.0666335076,
-0.6307097077,
-0.0214205664,
-0.1224403083,
-0.2009620368,
-0.3638916612,
-0.2867731452,
0.3063079119,
-0.4941098988,
0.2302848399,
0.3777451813,
0.6200244427,
0.3490819931,
-0.5635895729,
-0.4566038847,
-0.5311163068,
1.0077189207,
-0.9097927213,
0.2688280046,
0.1708884835,
-0.1905494034,
-0.5363550782,
-0.4128725529,
-0.7394986749,
-0.5118271112,
-0.1365480572,
0.0768985972,
-0.4890651107,
-0.070609048,
0.5741393566,
0.1131987274,
-0.788398087,
0.4586487412,
0.111709021,
-0.0729528069,
0.5605274439,
0.5588054657,
0.3459523916,
-0.1869289875,
-0.2829017937,
0.0556437187,
-1.0269937515,
-0.0706812739,
0.4374855757,
0.3083336353,
0.007800858,
0.558344543,
-0.231871292,
0.695536375,
0.2771799266,
0.0759743601,
-0.0113528296,
-0.4641999602,
-0.2526613176,
0.0095105749,
0.8820044994,
0.4187604785,
0.2051618397,
-0.0509804599,
-0.3679850101,
0.2440674603,
0.5628297329,
-0.773208797,
0.1528951675,
0.3326549828,
-0.2880083621,
-0.3421049118,
-0.1527745426,
-0.6457378864,
-0.264526993,
-0.6160217524,
0.3505072594,
-0.1184690222,
-0.1816517115,
-0.2182852328,
-0.042177517,
0.1171373948,
0.3008182347,
-0.6886383891,
0.0538833104,
0.6118217707,
0.5929602385,
-0.2576960921,
-0.3338673115,
-0.8992287517,
-0.1370229125,
-0.6427753568,
0.6672754884,
-0.4726139307,
-0.5173075795,
0.1052485481,
0.0266748406,
-0.0371664353,
-0.5047465563,
0.4080530703,
-0.2271168381,
0.2168965191,
-0.7927441001,
-0.584196806,
0.0511160865,
0.408411622,
-0.6879367232,
0.8382042646,
-0.1883032322,
-0.6927600503,
0.5091357827,
-0.6500307918,
-0.6818600893,
0.0505068861,
-0.455494523,
-0.4045456648,
0.4116611183,
0.168853119,
0.4723139703,
-0.6742127538,
0.910603106,
-0.1532754004,
-0.2443171591,
0.5576954484,
-0.5351058245,
0.7472366691,
0.0767681897,
-0.5950625539,
0.3401843905,
-0.5847438574,
-0.2513433099,
0.261557281,
-0.3347356021,
-0.0774310082,
0.070474267,
-0.2418158501,
0.2728336751,
0.0949057788,
-0.5338131785,
0.0969925225,
-0.2738735974,
0.2818033695,
0.8397364616,
0.0831047818,
0.1633526981,
-0.4396151304,
0.7228015065,
-0.0859479979,
-0.0090587065,
-0.1899088472,
-0.4217030406,
-0.810336411,
0.0782860592,
0.1068027541,
0.4278663397,
-0.9902555346,
0.4102419913,
0.1479859352,
-0.4148646295,
-0.0896836072,
0.2957192361,
0.7348756194,
0.7123365402,
0.2089040577,
-0.0758578032,
-0.8470687866,
-0.8769640326,
-0.226546973,
-0.2167973667,
0.1386425495,
0.1720656008,
0.6342715621,
-0.1441331506,
0.9851439595,
-0.3000175953,
0.0261949915,
-0.38027969,
0.5119838119,
0.2250530869,
0.3998900056,
0.6576411128,
-0.6518194675,
-0.1436155289,
-0.4221046865,
-0.8110027313,
-0.4413328767,
-0.3087967932,
0.2580518425,
0.511844933,
0.792561233,
-0.8466932774,
0.2618120611,
0.5482326746,
-0.2858021557,
0.9042608738,
-0.0759372935,
-0.0617252402,
-0.8357778192,
0.1984492391,
0.1381837577,
-0.0031941738,
-0.8260771036,
0.0871085599,
-0.2510593534,
0.1283240616,
-0.3732343614,
0.6866453886,
-0.2258058488,
0.0492273644,
-0.3147031367,
0.2789853513,
-0.0435571112,
0.4231631458,
0.1376039982,
0.5355860591,
0.365437448,
-0.6632020473,
0.4035539925,
-0.0793146566,
-0.4154124558,
0.761326015,
-0.8226193786,
0.079693675,
-0.1554450691,
0.3836411238,
-1.0366902351,
0.015209402,
0.059826348,
-0.1849289536,
0.2102302015,
0.1881091148,
-0.5502471328,
-0.3699293435,
-0.2381006479,
0.0692631826,
0.284375906,
-0.3851850033,
0.5754568577,
-0.0914410874,
-0.2407517135,
-0.6004724503,
-0.5881931782,
0.2763661742,
-0.3386995494,
-0.2017692924,
0.0864648074,
-0.3086794019,
-0.4691128135,
-0.1247190312,
-0.0915556177,
0.593251884,
0.1589793861,
0.3669509292,
0.4662155211,
-0.2676333487,
0.1319007427,
0.016643675,
-0.1761244684,
0.3376517892,
-0.180544585,
0.4307212532,
0.0018129973,
-0.3156089783,
-0.0800656676,
0.4480181336,
0.2794060111,
-0.0760521889,
0.5330485106,
0.7094368935,
-0.1503194273,
-0.1437940001,
-0.6908694506,
-0.2268392295,
-0.4294084311,
0.5072575808,
-0.266928643,
-0.8930920362,
0.3814614415,
-0.0830814391,
0.3671230674,
0.4443966746,
0.8406957388,
-0.0456316397,
0.9582976699,
0.3472435474,
0.1582146585,
0.4143374562,
0.0448858999,
0.2100905478,
-0.7521134615,
-0.1080969349,
-0.4996461868,
-0.1294200271,
-0.4254725277,
-0.0396245308,
0.1397369057,
-0.0463082343,
-0.3033517301,
0.1239664182,
0.0064803651,
0.1205675676,
0.4949627519,
-0.1503786892,
0.0986211225,
-0.2218069583,
-0.3543410003,
0.0207296554,
-0.7887089849,
-0.6172868013,
0.9069266915,
0.2265289575,
0.5864899158,
0.208832413,
0.5014028549,
0.2478451878,
0.4855633378,
-0.7325980663,
0.7365070581,
-0.2158249617,
-0.6460387111,
-0.4914925992,
-0.416195333,
-0.9483642578,
0.1577198654,
-0.6078603268,
-0.6127964258,
0.1666664481,
0.3460144103,
-0.3352597058,
-0.0311382152,
-0.6262795925,
0.768522501,
-0.2745362222,
-0.3494162858,
-0.0790624991,
-0.4272538722,
0.3458505571,
-0.3191871643,
0.1987482011,
0.1517779827,
0.1087061688,
0.7564097047,
-0.2431757599,
1.1547620296,
-0.1700197905,
-0.5477522612,
0.2526189685,
0.2470442653,
0.7128487825,
0.0467045642,
-0.0348465219,
-0.0296444707,
-0.4068533778,
-0.1301322132,
-0.617153585,
0.7269459963,
-0.4700248241,
-1.0328419209,
-0.0969982967,
-0.7028303146,
-0.4573951364,
0.294290781,
0.472635448,
0.7135235071,
-0.6250302196,
0.1901986152,
0.7855671644,
-0.4500035942,
0.6086255312,
0.6104223132,
-0.3251131475,
-0.088336885,
0.9250700474,
0.2052148283,
0.2877745926,
0.314663887,
0.3226389587,
-0.420810461,
-0.5260954499,
-0.6516939998,
-0.0951730907,
-0.5893129706,
-0.2194614857,
-0.4534413517,
0.1386166215,
-0.3382211626,
-0.2413624525,
-0.1792844832,
-0.0957288966,
-0.3956888616,
-0.1866785139,
0.1290093213,
0.9707534909,
0.032879319,
0.1429615915,
-0.4844868183,
0.4530924261,
0.5511181355,
0.0364484563,
0.3539694846,
-0.4645060599,
-0.0663955286,
-0.121834971,
-0.1972804815,
-0.5865371823,
0.1637034267,
-0.142406404,
0.6886533499,
0.3585644364,
0.156465739,
0.4908266068,
-0.5842987299,
0.8301466107,
0.3189030886,
-0.9651088119,
0.4696374238,
-0.3528488874,
0.5000743866,
0.1600288749,
0.3360679746,
-0.3358772993,
-0.5480920076,
-0.5766606927,
-0.7820605636,
0.5834938288,
0.0678213984,
0.1852230877,
-0.175425455,
0.1939053386,
0.1908854842,
0.2195682973,
-0.5789266229,
-0.1793336421,
-0.3712461889,
-0.0589159839,
-0.2345814854,
-0.3474971652,
-0.2172278166,
0.230808869,
0.6279420257,
-0.136438787,
-0.1297621131,
0.2283655703,
-0.2343963534,
-0.3936548829,
0.5571424365,
0.9563428164,
0.7981930971,
-0.032274697,
0.1489745528,
0.370028317,
-0.1590976715,
0.1753322184,
-0.0433605984,
-0.2120473832,
-0.1283905655,
0.6864938736,
0.9338003397,
0.1482579261,
-0.6880775094,
0.3203223646,
-0.0115110595,
-0.3955455124,
-0.0648787543,
0.1753493696,
0.1500515044,
0.2656731606,
0.5390318036,
-0.2624952793,
-0.1043110266,
-0.7335569859,
0.0410007387,
0.6247994304,
-0.0985383838,
-0.2280289829,
0.4022902548,
0.1987617761,
-0.3489467204,
0.5774308443,
-0.2981106937,
-0.4920397699,
0.6307036877,
0.8032293916,
0.7667349577,
-0.281769067,
0.1395135522,
0.3694716394,
0.4744744599,
0.0075232554,
0.1463277489,
0.1535294801,
-0.7855473757,
-0.720726788,
-0.4794465303,
-0.4331311882,
0.4388933182,
-0.582705617,
-0.0346676782,
-0.4364484549,
-0.2403448522,
-0.0333476588,
0.0289091375,
-0.7019599676,
0.4062963426,
0.0890820622,
0.6083796024,
-0.9161607623,
0.5194122791,
0.6904230118,
-0.3227515817,
-0.6711790562,
-0.0035272373,
0.2687214017,
-0.6242803335,
0.8599384427,
-0.0533349849,
-0.1701457947,
-0.3406599462,
-0.5013355017,
-0.5982539058,
0.7187956572,
0.5551918745,
-1.0560511351,
-0.0741571784,
0.1538849175,
0.5789884329,
-0.5141746998,
0.1320786774,
0.464520067,
0.661534071,
-0.0574294664,
-0.9545701146,
0.6695398688,
-0.1594552696,
0.0794053376,
0.0307941064,
-0.4135421515,
0.7297739387,
-0.3097311556,
-0.0830895007,
0.0779861286,
0.5403479934,
0.5103581548,
0.153982535,
0.6971391439,
0.494326055,
0.4502926469,
-0.0521777198,
1.0293200016,
0.0711468235,
0.000736991,
1.172100544,
-0.3142542243,
0.6196815968,
0.5951179862,
-0.0428689197,
0.4980668128,
0.3817107975,
-0.1476122886,
0.0654500872,
0.2731339335,
0.1240639538,
-0.4919573665,
-0.354359746,
-0.1458204836,
0.3750574887,
0.4850625694,
-0.2635094821,
-0.2147851884,
-0.1049999371,
0.0236345418,
-0.046804402,
-0.2998386025,
0.7282123566,
0.2677487731,
-1.0175436735,
0.4405242205,
-0.2078751475,
0.5968217254,
-0.4078329504,
-0.2221053094,
-0.2031930983,
-0.2462722212,
-0.2525666952,
-0.6894540787,
0.199754104,
0.1393328607,
-0.2054609656,
-0.1847036034,
0.5786620378,
-0.1648403704,
-0.3399632871,
0.1206726804,
0.6046647429,
-0.091176033,
0.1137722805,
-0.6884251237,
0.2569006681,
-0.0312955007,
-0.4960358441,
0.4066933692,
0.4720130563,
-0.2072923779,
0.4877203405,
0.7521270514,
-0.0518546477,
-0.2731369436,
0.3654053807,
0.6268306375,
-0.7334232926,
-0.3180639446,
-1.0587072372,
0.3853045702,
0.1591728628,
-0.3390112817,
0.8798546195,
0.1488511115,
0.6949743032,
0.0522075854,
0.7688009143,
-0.0686576366,
0.3069350123,
-0.7317950726,
0.3108738065,
-0.5034171343,
0.2640166283,
-0.4576253295,
-1.0266110897,
-0.1152989939,
0.3278873265,
-0.3611159623,
0.143878445,
0.6096882224,
0.7018280625,
0.3149280846,
0.0242195502,
0.3890889287,
0.3350367546,
0.4275627136,
0.443964541,
1.0175306797,
-0.0367055275,
0.4511037767,
0.2367262542,
0.0088805985,
-0.2691960931,
-1.2162699699,
-1.0856552124,
-0.5237078667,
-0.3250598013,
-0.171919331,
-0.063503921,
0.9529809356,
0.3951633275,
-0.7276626825,
-0.0736331046,
-0.247086376,
0.2237047851,
-0.0337213129,
-0.216595903,
0.2776648402,
-0.3613866866,
-0.6959234476,
0.4924404323,
0.2459282279,
-0.0082464293,
-0.4863213301,
-0.123476401,
-0.2588216364,
0.3363347054,
0.7920765281,
0.2605007887,
-1.0654892921,
-0.2818448842,
-0.0824907422,
0.0479147211,
-0.2788078487,
1.0284104347,
-0.7484744787,
0.1611385345,
0.4080710113,
0.4852071106,
0.0551394895,
-0.1889234781,
0.8168268204,
-0.777574718,
-0.25612849,
-0.1035093665,
0.5887187719,
0.2282316387,
-0.2763101459,
0.2675014138,
-0.0578347072,
-0.4655317366,
-0.9608840346,
0.4737719297,
-0.6677278876,
-0.44344154,
1.1501356363,
-0.1593687385,
0.1255264282,
-0.336183846,
-0.1889530271,
0.279823035,
-0.3626176119,
0.5754651427,
0.7453858852,
-0.260086894,
-0.0970782265,
-0.4903920293,
0.3740820885,
0.795609653,
-0.646222353,
0.2505299747,
0.5262256265,
0.2313431054,
0.250906527,
0.4839954674,
0.2469659299,
0.2659048736,
-0.0361564234,
-0.2215203345,
-0.1010544822,
-0.2599291503,
-0.3831141591,
-0.0199198853,
0.2405157685,
0.389808625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14790v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14790v2 | Advancing Topic Segmentation and Outline Generation in Chinese Texts: The Paragraph-level Topic Representation, Corpus, and Benchmark | 2023-05-24T06:43:23 | 2024-03-26T11:29:21 | Feng Jiang, Weihao Liu, Xiaomin Chu, Peifeng Li, Qiaoming Zhu, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Topic segmentation and outline generation strive to divide a document into
coherent topic sections and generate corresponding subheadings, unveiling the
discourse topic structure of a document. Compared with sentence-level topic
structure, the paragraph-level topic structure can quickly grasp and understand
the overall context of the document from a higher level, benefitting many
downstream tasks such as summarization, discourse parsing, and information
retrieval. However, the lack of large-scale, high-quality Chinese
paragraph-level topic structure corpora restrained relative research and
applications. To fill this gap, we build the Chinese paragraph-level topic
representation, corpus, and benchmark in this paper. Firstly, we propose a
hierarchical paragraph-level topic structure representation with three layers
to guide the corpus construction. Then, we employ a two-stage man-machine
collaborative annotation method to construct the largest Chinese
Paragraph-level Topic Structure corpus (CPTS), achieving high quality. We also
build several strong baselines, including ChatGPT, to validate the
computability of CPTS on two fundamental tasks (topic segmentation and outline
generation) and preliminarily verified its usefulness for the downstream task
(discourse parsing). | [
-0.5741465688,
-0.6735559702,
0.3959239125,
0.4428545535,
-0.3617805839,
0.0253465995,
-0.1596488208,
-0.2069595754,
0.0460270792,
0.3583031893,
-0.1733740866,
-0.6094657779,
-0.3647057414,
-0.0575442985,
-0.409098804,
0.7826417685,
0.075642243,
-0.1088001654,
0.0653782114,
0.2691035271,
-0.3194571137,
-0.4344923198,
-0.8788049221,
-0.2622154355,
0.4901243448,
0.29453215,
0.4149152637,
0.9572301507,
0.393281579,
0.2279369235,
-0.3369920552,
0.2971235812,
-0.1972556561,
-0.0120781986,
-0.1056801006,
-0.0588693954,
-0.5619159937,
-0.094507806,
0.8927083015,
0.9427620769,
0.2808693945,
-0.2818564177,
0.4013531506,
0.4148834646,
-0.4953758419,
0.1105626747,
-0.4933166504,
0.1976573914,
-0.5466331244,
-0.2291948646,
-0.457585454,
-0.2352119237,
0.3408062458,
-0.6634209752,
0.3985359371,
0.1062368229,
1.1478326321,
-0.2160550058,
-0.3224747777,
-0.0813520178,
-0.156332925,
0.5081845522,
-0.4659189582,
0.089895539,
0.2382412553,
-0.0219564438,
0.0158680249,
-1.0111123323,
-0.0736162886,
-0.1592322886,
-0.2112037987,
0.238639012,
0.2244219333,
0.0941700339,
0.1126878783,
0.5732362866,
-0.6761322618,
0.2257356048,
-0.3011195064,
-0.3385158479,
0.5360996127,
0.1065158993,
0.5233408213,
-0.3837076724,
-0.4502020478,
-0.0572070666,
-0.7502348423,
0.041434627,
0.1238901764,
0.0911293328,
0.0909975469,
0.1611628234,
-0.2158564031,
0.3422978818,
0.2235633135,
-0.0882866457,
-0.0491203368,
-0.4965144098,
-0.1510630846,
0.1846633703,
0.7038710117,
0.2403159142,
-0.2623648345,
0.186188966,
0.0211014263,
-0.3409970105,
0.1598570496,
-0.9316620827,
-0.4869338274,
0.4364781082,
-0.7023260593,
-0.0805977136,
0.1845736653,
-0.6055626869,
-0.3745186925,
-0.0877970159,
-0.0762309581,
-0.7311576009,
-0.3426378667,
-0.2027461231,
-0.2813191414,
0.3617289364,
0.6300588846,
-1.0544806719,
0.1914938688,
0.9900443554,
0.9979367256,
-0.2914428711,
-0.551787436,
-0.3528750539,
0.357365787,
-0.6778919697,
1.1291754246,
-0.1072929949,
-0.1175208762,
0.0474318676,
-0.2018852681,
-0.0080466084,
-0.5084199905,
0.8866645694,
-0.1636672914,
0.4267138243,
-0.3168390989,
-0.6398501396,
0.0884823725,
0.3055419624,
-0.419837296,
0.8746277094,
0.0087140109,
-1.0859495401,
0.2935539782,
-0.5807258487,
-0.4636189342,
0.2108241022,
-0.2610112429,
-0.287763238,
-0.2013763934,
0.4367930293,
0.5704837441,
-0.2683312595,
0.3776025474,
0.214470312,
-0.2789311111,
-0.0337466523,
-0.1566213965,
0.8411893249,
0.2189510018,
-0.1750373095,
0.4692034125,
-0.5787315369,
-0.2269546986,
-0.0740332454,
-0.1350875944,
-0.3690165281,
0.1908132881,
0.1353079081,
0.1107205227,
0.5413115621,
-0.3419080973,
0.0184832253,
-0.3180797696,
0.4994832873,
0.5010080338,
0.3207310736,
0.3715916872,
-0.2272652239,
-0.0551946685,
0.0834517628,
-0.1856607795,
-0.8836997747,
-0.5227667093,
-0.7620933056,
-0.2141111195,
0.5254051685,
0.4003431499,
-0.5350754261,
0.8206933737,
0.1843413115,
-0.6289433241,
-0.0836464837,
-0.3667626679,
0.4087717831,
0.5473101735,
0.351447612,
-0.2247035801,
-0.4805059731,
-0.8719764948,
0.2144475579,
-0.4199501872,
-0.3177596331,
-0.3960160613,
0.3139374852,
0.3063342571,
0.6617357731,
-0.7006490827,
-0.1101492122,
-0.4758652449,
0.5131021142,
-0.2087927908,
0.7333769798,
0.2670646012,
-0.8965380788,
-0.5707215071,
0.1521420777,
-0.4234998822,
-0.2925022542,
-0.4030658007,
-0.4424339831,
-0.1590829939,
0.5361999273,
-0.1466529071,
0.0893781185,
0.0283753127,
-0.3150403798,
0.5990985632,
-0.2546266317,
0.0606094971,
-1.2121593952,
0.1346663237,
0.0675061569,
0.023125669,
-0.7267849445,
0.0102875875,
0.3013264239,
-0.3658395708,
-0.1607493311,
0.2524459362,
-0.4344400167,
-0.131695658,
-0.5652244687,
0.4614270926,
0.1863555908,
0.6135632992,
0.3326779306,
0.6199311614,
0.3995647132,
-0.4371958971,
-0.0756234303,
0.234024018,
-0.0858885869,
0.3638285995,
-0.6469909549,
-0.2331588119,
0.0024047855,
0.2997529507,
-1.1135377884,
-0.3088850975,
0.1941640377,
-0.2562454939,
0.0844997168,
0.2214858979,
-0.3132347465,
-0.0229934324,
-0.5896269679,
0.0103844218,
0.3333470821,
-0.3280054331,
-0.038061291,
0.4390894175,
-0.5602179766,
-0.3146880567,
-0.498214215,
0.2070876807,
-0.1266047508,
-0.8909237981,
0.9878160954,
0.2351903766,
-0.1052335128,
-0.089367494,
-0.0204215311,
-0.3725416362,
0.1454366595,
-0.0091994917,
-0.0013997169,
-0.4452715516,
-0.1381224096,
0.317369014,
-0.3008809686,
-0.1080203205,
-0.2464604676,
0.8115498424,
0.1810485423,
-0.3134105802,
-0.5187180638,
0.5441086888,
0.0614157878,
-0.4906977117,
0.2306938022,
0.5902209282,
-0.515735507,
-0.264313817,
-0.1992817074,
0.2091426849,
-0.3734357953,
0.3391834199,
-0.3235898614,
-0.901956439,
0.3972294927,
-0.1570523381,
0.3700842857,
0.8241385221,
0.5622891784,
0.2166410834,
0.5680810809,
0.5385286212,
-0.0311621483,
0.5329754353,
-0.0078706937,
-0.0756234229,
-0.8825571537,
-0.0688895732,
-0.7633000016,
0.1467943937,
-0.5284435749,
-0.5220940709,
0.0832726285,
0.249489367,
-0.2496671379,
0.4817929864,
-0.8026126027,
0.2754859924,
0.7304444313,
-0.1319029927,
0.266903609,
-0.0868773088,
-0.1049124822,
-0.0703940243,
-0.2894382477,
-0.7131837606,
0.3645777106,
0.5363246202,
0.1571852714,
-0.4248504639,
0.7030398846,
0.1856651455,
-0.0756554604,
-0.3849081099,
0.7006496787,
-0.4694671929,
-0.2690935731,
-0.5639451146,
-0.1034490988,
-0.7764758468,
0.79273808,
0.2467274964,
-0.8177289367,
0.2205022722,
-0.1734864414,
-0.2992689312,
0.1009173468,
-0.5859128833,
1.0599970818,
0.0676544234,
-0.2844447792,
0.0072458633,
-0.4452303052,
0.3216371834,
0.0113232415,
-0.2631542683,
-0.2278243452,
-0.2104987949,
0.8568957448,
-0.5171427131,
0.6182769537,
-0.1601759791,
-0.3570781648,
0.5498501062,
-0.3320277929,
0.0465892814,
0.2253474593,
-0.1924441308,
0.0474009216,
-0.1574836224,
-0.4057565928,
-0.2554315627,
0.2329985797,
-0.611646831,
-0.6704632044,
-0.3407852054,
-0.1935015768,
0.1185548156,
0.5404773951,
0.3718054593,
0.4751660228,
-0.5461642742,
0.1522364318,
0.6564509273,
-0.4270421863,
0.5278174877,
0.0167811681,
-0.0562452897,
-0.5224016309,
0.9771285057,
0.0274581145,
0.0185849313,
0.8401290774,
0.2237626612,
-0.0743513554,
-0.9153539538,
-0.4694607556,
-0.1078989878,
-0.4073263705,
0.139398545,
-0.7247530818,
-0.6747257113,
-0.4161948264,
-0.3745637238,
-0.3464615345,
-0.4213693142,
-0.1505222023,
0.0485112779,
-0.3217528462,
0.3890469372,
-0.1512472481,
0.3432838023,
-0.5316355824,
0.5469921827,
-0.0075491336,
-0.1984300017,
0.0447933227,
-0.183199808,
-0.2771528959,
-0.2997983396,
-0.7508451343,
-0.6328353882,
0.2881237864,
-0.1699483693,
0.4509563148,
0.686334312,
0.0542153195,
0.6718741059,
-0.5036680102,
1.1430191994,
0.1630893499,
-1.0424063206,
0.7138751149,
-0.5856073499,
0.3870997727,
0.3507017195,
0.1534799933,
-0.790252924,
-0.6278781295,
-0.3610730171,
-1.0668689013,
0.8887606263,
0.6079060435,
-0.1981119514,
0.2391741127,
0.1748546362,
0.2427392006,
0.0275726188,
-0.6156585813,
-0.2049024552,
-0.4070123732,
0.1478003263,
0.3280435801,
-0.3100383878,
0.0970105678,
0.0557534322,
0.5102466345,
-0.0998145714,
0.3604610562,
0.3856501579,
0.361831367,
0.1896915436,
0.4331858456,
0.5607446432,
0.6173225641,
-0.2544431388,
0.1836410463,
-0.0536294729,
-0.5293595195,
-0.0255777407,
0.4674850702,
-0.3955044448,
0.0722943768,
0.7820291519,
0.6008190513,
0.0149221653,
-0.3840625286,
0.3097025454,
0.0517078638,
-0.3144022226,
-0.2450862974,
0.0348197073,
0.3880810738,
-0.0779208839,
0.6311081648,
-0.4923698008,
0.2146447748,
-0.4181797802,
0.3767842352,
-0.0033115263,
-0.1432229429,
-0.0782357827,
0.5023064017,
0.4260900021,
0.0421312116,
0.3137890995,
-0.310195148,
-0.5379762053,
0.8690924644,
0.5567418337,
0.9428043365,
-0.0548083931,
0.4110721946,
0.6002937555,
0.1526983827,
-0.2693386674,
0.0140994294,
-0.1733784229,
-0.4481113553,
-0.3622874618,
-0.398801446,
-0.6849136353,
0.0756295696,
-0.3914703727,
0.2694238722,
-0.5357626677,
0.3620630503,
0.2285502851,
0.3157282472,
0.394954294,
0.2798737884,
0.2758149207,
0.9432803988,
-0.2159460783,
0.856565237,
0.6172049046,
-0.4367673397,
-0.5677603483,
0.6192117929,
-0.2014527172,
-0.3522034883,
0.4587209523,
0.3294239044,
0.2828876376,
-0.2538781464,
-0.217398122,
-0.6623711586,
1.1548181772,
-0.041166354,
-0.2745384574,
-0.3285603821,
0.2917327285,
0.5877825022,
-0.484129101,
0.1290401071,
0.1241018027,
0.3866720498,
0.1556276828,
-0.6817280054,
0.2516188622,
-0.1573079973,
0.2298646569,
0.0873465985,
-1.0002454519,
1.3780450821,
0.4353459179,
-0.3946258724,
0.2304041982,
1.1703437567,
0.363619417,
0.4352664948,
0.3180022538,
0.1762110442,
0.803304255,
-0.1897472143,
0.5128213763,
-0.3623009324,
-0.0617889203,
0.9275635481,
-0.2710758746,
0.6109852195,
-0.1302049458,
0.1076801941,
0.3540573418,
1.0183649063,
-0.0803353414,
0.4429119825,
0.283444047,
-0.116021052,
-0.0398129821,
-0.3031971753,
-0.6762706637,
0.1726465374,
0.5272281766,
-0.2830146849,
-0.4892467558,
-0.2899275422,
0.188007772,
0.1104369611,
-0.3223087788,
0.6934162974,
0.086820811,
-0.801063776,
0.3802222013,
0.4508188665,
0.5566235781,
-0.6273080111,
-0.0885423347,
-0.2810138464,
-0.1263789684,
-0.118073985,
-0.8502113819,
0.2501319349,
0.0384348556,
0.1260181069,
-0.4809582233,
1.0722185373,
-0.3191372752,
-0.1077591553,
0.0819213986,
0.4339317381,
0.0543472804,
-0.2461193651,
-0.5901443362,
0.0415624455,
0.0115947444,
-0.2604248524,
0.3331122994,
0.9514966011,
-0.2736318111,
0.0984772965,
0.403131783,
-0.0549924448,
-0.2998822629,
0.0607659779,
0.8501150608,
-0.922033906,
-0.8437914848,
-0.8639256358,
0.416896224,
-0.4736691713,
-0.6025927663,
0.6992172599,
0.8037427068,
0.8157464266,
0.3144174516,
0.8874238133,
-0.1846026033,
0.4974602461,
-0.4316155612,
0.8181214929,
-0.2636863887,
0.0154499179,
-0.497366637,
-0.7427050471,
-0.4628669918,
0.4250587523,
-0.133125633,
-0.2559426427,
0.9381361604,
0.3372425437,
0.128124252,
0.125360921,
0.2907291949,
-0.1471619606,
0.4207691848,
0.5975721478,
0.9942726493,
-0.217458874,
0.4946612418,
-0.4498673379,
-0.2318789661,
-0.0080065336,
-0.6307870746,
-0.9744201303,
-0.8636811972,
-0.4406000674,
0.0411979258,
-0.0007716072,
0.4676051438,
0.716905117,
-0.7741274834,
-0.4654684663,
-0.299076587,
0.200683713,
-0.2818002701,
-0.2355764955,
1.0302504301,
-0.5902131796,
-0.8860262632,
0.1566876173,
0.5273595452,
-0.1748628765,
-0.3847088814,
0.2093957961,
-0.2569266856,
-0.2479229569,
0.6366257071,
0.242427215,
-0.5711773038,
-0.0519149117,
-0.1491595358,
-0.4485780597,
0.3112473488,
1.1298449039,
-0.120360814,
-0.2110841572,
0.741078198,
0.6895292401,
0.3309442401,
0.2385597378,
0.6605702043,
-0.6694688797,
0.0695189536,
-0.0755041167,
0.4218805432,
0.3491007686,
-0.2426542789,
0.5932428837,
0.0917509571,
-0.4160127342,
-0.4822771251,
-0.0071849879,
-1.1130170822,
-0.7792611122,
0.9130442739,
-0.4083851576,
-0.2690261006,
-0.3481642604,
-0.8425270319,
0.4195468724,
-0.5881429315,
0.4921303093,
0.7822999954,
-0.4628035128,
-0.3008866906,
-0.1725645661,
0.5513472557,
0.267842561,
-1.1461385489,
0.2935797572,
0.5011078119,
-0.3490312397,
0.5392614603,
1.0162695646,
-0.1757601202,
0.2747518718,
0.4367464781,
-0.0766136795,
0.1397047937,
-0.2625778913,
0.1638977677,
0.8524821401,
0.1508567333,
-0.2581500709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14788v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14788v2 | Adapting Language Models to Compress Contexts | 2023-05-24T06:42:44 | 2023-11-04T04:09:43 | Alexis Chevalier, Alexander Wettig, Anirudh Ajith, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based language models (LMs) are powerful and widely-applicable
tools, but their usefulness is constrained by a finite context window and the
expensive computational cost of processing long text documents. We propose to
adapt pre-trained LMs into AutoCompressors. These language models are capable
of compressing long contexts into compact summary vectors, which are then
accessible to the model as soft prompts. Summary vectors are trained with an
unsupervised objective, whereby long documents are processed in segments, and
summary vectors from all previous segments are used in language modeling. We
fine-tune OPT and Llama-2 models on sequences of up to 30,720 tokens and show
that AutoCompressors can utilize long contexts to improve perplexity. We
evaluate AutoCompressors on in-context learning by compressing task
demonstrations and find that summary vectors are good substitutes for
plain-text demonstrations, increasing accuracy while reducing inference costs.
Finally, we explore the benefits of pre-computing summary vectors for large
corpora by applying summary vectors to retrievalaugmented language modeling and
a passage re-ranking task. Overall, AutoCompressors emerge as a simple and
inexpensive solution to extend the context window of LMs while speeding up
inference over long contexts. | [
-0.1997131109,
-0.4898020625,
0.4407713115,
0.1331401318,
-0.4142648876,
-0.1676710844,
-0.4879066348,
-0.2134499848,
0.0238716882,
0.5472225547,
-0.1932754368,
-0.1029054821,
-0.8469117284,
0.3698120415,
-0.7174688578,
0.88017869,
-0.1751527786,
-0.4429963231,
-0.1439158916,
-0.0149457203,
-0.5992116332,
-0.7646445036,
-0.340387255,
-0.2067215443,
0.1895249635,
0.3624375761,
0.6299955845,
0.5847250223,
0.0647962838,
0.5057708025,
0.130176425,
-0.0593648404,
-0.5877909064,
0.3873223662,
-0.1560591161,
-0.4785972834,
-0.3888739944,
-0.1350540519,
0.5717272162,
0.8889830112,
-0.1679592133,
-0.0345541686,
0.3798931241,
0.3872732222,
-0.5447255373,
0.3373042941,
-0.5954661965,
0.0357007831,
0.4142462611,
-0.3204301596,
-0.4998679161,
-0.0018321406,
0.1663670391,
-0.4216866493,
0.2982470095,
0.0482692085,
0.5853282809,
0.7551994324,
-0.3679487705,
-0.3231920004,
-0.7863381505,
0.8316137195,
-0.5487595797,
0.2603801191,
0.0567327552,
0.3404159844,
-0.2697324455,
-0.8865885139,
-0.489897877,
0.1158290505,
-0.4916698635,
0.0180251263,
-0.5699220896,
0.030289676,
0.2501550019,
0.4684836864,
-0.5619364977,
0.2251367867,
-0.4349497855,
-0.1186136901,
0.4549673498,
0.0980774239,
0.2410818189,
-0.2747511864,
-0.2672629654,
-0.3440485597,
-0.5334746838,
0.0504773222,
-0.0874069035,
0.0615241937,
-0.0953560024,
0.2775370479,
-0.1673196405,
0.9612021446,
0.1520320028,
-0.1007298827,
0.0965637714,
-0.1131072193,
-0.6982796192,
-0.276301682,
0.6425147653,
0.2202335447,
0.3053801954,
-0.2394998819,
-0.3584620059,
-0.0701291561,
0.3435726166,
-0.9552907348,
-0.2948799431,
0.1156537384,
-0.5185519457,
-0.0572385378,
-0.1357067972,
-0.6447500587,
0.0256403331,
-0.5717735887,
0.5150458813,
-0.2115615159,
0.0038947519,
0.3329249322,
-0.1316471845,
0.3260349929,
0.3627468646,
-0.7413793802,
0.5193872452,
0.4390480518,
0.7733307481,
-0.3787937462,
-0.373826921,
-0.522277832,
0.0467974767,
-0.0982751101,
1.0121440887,
-0.4393236339,
-0.5836715698,
0.0317560695,
0.3245487213,
-0.1407575458,
-0.5902485847,
0.5210669041,
-0.2661210001,
0.4374048412,
0.180080086,
-0.6228630543,
-0.0338809118,
-0.0786092654,
-0.6931837797,
0.9247208238,
0.2742295861,
-0.2739388645,
0.0213410333,
-0.6099142432,
-0.5355629921,
-0.0778886005,
-0.1325213462,
-0.0867812112,
0.3441105187,
0.5013995767,
0.6330478787,
-0.1986666173,
0.3660981953,
0.2082995176,
-0.4655170739,
0.1269929707,
-0.3809303939,
0.5088478923,
0.1216135025,
-0.2107490301,
0.2386419326,
-0.4367925227,
-0.3990956545,
-0.0524876863,
-0.3285073936,
-0.2887622118,
0.0000635453,
-0.1485986412,
0.2875572145,
0.0925155506,
-0.0705580637,
0.2551426291,
-0.3728829324,
0.5542444587,
0.5245659351,
-0.2483587861,
0.6761450171,
-0.1660932153,
0.709987998,
0.0538486913,
0.1678299308,
-0.6119366884,
0.0749716535,
-1.2523394823,
-0.3721803129,
0.1866131574,
0.4045437276,
-0.7938044667,
0.8157682419,
-0.594189465,
-0.1916294545,
-0.2513880432,
0.1130801216,
0.0957167447,
0.5554580688,
0.6031349897,
-0.2338730693,
-0.5033856034,
-0.9072244167,
-0.3245574236,
0.0172433965,
-0.236889407,
0.1827347875,
0.4687306881,
-0.1629196703,
1.0137603283,
-0.5057119727,
-0.3114814162,
-0.4351912141,
0.322352469,
0.3960177004,
0.4348997176,
0.507534802,
-0.7860047817,
-0.3170515001,
-0.6318348646,
-0.5787428617,
-0.3879954219,
-0.0920709968,
0.0910807028,
0.1780537516,
1.0846788883,
-0.3959296346,
0.4479278028,
0.7274366617,
-0.2902221978,
0.3306821287,
-0.491512537,
-0.1930069774,
-1.1126356125,
-0.0846333504,
-0.3316923976,
-0.6440349221,
-0.6588745117,
-0.0601259694,
0.1031870171,
-0.2740749717,
-0.4079330862,
0.5824155211,
-0.7313530445,
-0.0246827193,
-0.8082733154,
0.104117237,
0.1096589416,
0.3805212677,
0.2610561252,
0.7737193108,
0.5475311875,
-0.7290483117,
0.0600085407,
0.3050810695,
-0.3562489748,
0.1361550093,
-0.8530480266,
0.0270086825,
-0.5223886371,
0.9164602757,
-0.9472560883,
-0.2658003867,
-0.0174155328,
-0.1862918139,
0.4488757551,
-0.2166393101,
-0.3641944826,
-0.1665317863,
-0.2072516382,
0.5124378204,
0.6268063188,
-0.6851775646,
0.9953267574,
0.2899752855,
-0.4054457247,
-0.5035190582,
-0.7196165919,
0.4341917634,
-0.1298942864,
-0.1304788888,
0.5736994743,
-0.2821070254,
0.021970436,
-0.1012166142,
0.0962101072,
0.0872185156,
0.1328902543,
0.4228097498,
0.1445640922,
-0.0944556668,
0.2476895899,
0.3263215125,
-0.1743755639,
-0.0300646275,
-0.2700051963,
0.4652562439,
-0.0202668961,
0.0015664253,
-0.0332817398,
0.556540966,
0.4537926018,
0.0144287879,
0.5537871718,
0.2579160035,
-0.340331912,
-0.2800237834,
-0.5254073739,
-0.1989722997,
-0.4987183213,
0.4450414181,
-0.4118980467,
-1.1298857927,
0.2197080404,
-0.3140226305,
-0.0587209463,
0.4663240612,
0.6638047695,
0.1942581981,
0.6064867973,
0.9647504687,
-0.2617980838,
0.5141026974,
-0.137121439,
0.2809025645,
-0.7951930761,
0.1703546643,
-0.4406230152,
-0.2869010568,
-0.3905327916,
-0.7648274302,
0.3652138114,
0.348515898,
0.0671711192,
0.6115631461,
-0.4461191297,
0.7355929613,
0.1962913722,
-0.1979270726,
0.141944468,
0.0043701045,
0.1431861967,
0.2742842138,
-0.8641833663,
-0.5688480139,
0.7783233523,
0.3964586556,
0.7130611539,
0.1522970945,
0.5965397954,
0.1359107494,
0.645113647,
-0.9921680093,
0.398732096,
-0.3629631102,
-0.2221199721,
-0.2534774542,
-0.1583929509,
-0.8613566756,
0.3428948224,
0.0305103995,
-0.5833408833,
0.4805105627,
0.0480884835,
-0.5722201467,
-0.1607635468,
-0.6414421201,
0.6476430297,
0.0118293036,
-0.0313965194,
-0.0316876173,
-0.6086001992,
0.0696948618,
-0.1722709835,
0.3330602646,
0.1241641343,
-0.2337104678,
0.5949206948,
-0.5203267932,
1.0773142576,
0.0333555751,
-0.2703372836,
0.1396253705,
0.071484372,
0.4636305571,
-0.178640604,
-0.082917437,
-0.1448331177,
-0.1918850243,
-0.3201874793,
-0.9512499571,
0.6136344075,
-0.686833322,
-0.7599383593,
-0.2612508237,
-0.7049826384,
0.1025595739,
-0.0604217164,
0.3808631599,
0.6355231404,
-0.0956903026,
0.1336513609,
0.4092696607,
-0.3796518147,
0.8201447725,
0.5378303528,
-0.0226162113,
-0.3512854278,
0.5168028474,
-0.0930531472,
0.1902564168,
0.4821845293,
0.224349305,
-0.3248285353,
-0.3709273934,
-0.3844518065,
0.1056588367,
-1.1436389685,
-0.3940769434,
-0.9351419806,
-0.1409101039,
-0.5169318318,
-0.4030363858,
-0.1591556817,
-0.5323671699,
-0.3677284122,
0.0332198441,
0.1092311069,
0.6069285274,
-0.0820484087,
0.5165322423,
-0.6434360743,
0.3647116125,
0.4301834404,
0.0205220524,
-0.0751288235,
-1.0545909405,
-0.2462391704,
-0.4165747464,
-0.0342647247,
-0.7100278735,
0.6187409163,
0.466928333,
0.2542677522,
0.0623978227,
0.2248749286,
0.7099058032,
-0.6698404551,
0.7790130973,
-0.1321560591,
-1.1405674219,
0.2970397472,
0.0322321467,
0.5411536694,
0.4024490118,
0.4885257483,
-0.3331542313,
-0.4061688781,
-0.2789718509,
-0.922984004,
0.3433177173,
0.1357014775,
0.5171159506,
-0.0697720572,
0.6412426233,
0.2742545307,
-0.0975641981,
-0.9070539474,
-0.1414142549,
-0.5442819595,
-0.3633317053,
-0.393786341,
-0.511893034,
0.1423055977,
-0.361045599,
0.4915958643,
-0.4698907733,
0.2691925764,
0.4086428583,
-0.7585575581,
0.1298199445,
0.4886777401,
0.6041994691,
0.5330305099,
0.039294824,
0.3182290196,
0.4068834186,
-0.1000220999,
0.2921293974,
0.4421902895,
0.1215591431,
0.1256141663,
0.4602979422,
0.8583717346,
0.5747507215,
-0.5730034709,
0.5866405964,
-0.2890876532,
-0.0129855378,
-0.4850178957,
0.1224973872,
-0.0832588375,
0.2774888575,
0.470880419,
-0.4057023525,
0.3872169554,
-0.4983640909,
0.1268044561,
0.1386823356,
-0.2691977322,
-0.320717454,
0.479161799,
0.2945939302,
-0.1858923286,
0.2943011224,
0.1095286682,
-0.7472525835,
0.2901172638,
0.7210637331,
0.8933150172,
-0.4339421093,
-0.3215773106,
0.3057759404,
0.1272888184,
-0.2581321001,
-0.1673224419,
-0.3917482793,
-0.5159624815,
-0.7909728885,
-0.7265022993,
-0.259257555,
0.1242616028,
-0.6150223613,
0.3566269875,
0.0587740764,
0.0384096093,
-0.1036286131,
-0.3022833467,
-0.6430402398,
0.2787691653,
0.1017661616,
1.0804868937,
-0.8146369457,
0.9707855582,
0.4132272899,
-0.0457939692,
-0.4404984415,
0.0605911128,
-0.4345834553,
-0.3973630965,
0.7397550941,
0.269923836,
-0.3133216202,
0.1239928156,
-0.4354073107,
-0.7680494189,
1.0421073437,
0.383349359,
-0.720570147,
-0.204596743,
0.1954695433,
0.620392561,
-0.4743444622,
0.4010970294,
0.4826050997,
0.1469515115,
-0.2643728554,
-0.8652073741,
0.2596232891,
-0.1775978804,
0.051644709,
0.1090502068,
-0.4313855469,
0.7828374505,
0.1538350582,
-0.2406715751,
0.1913762838,
0.8845952153,
-0.2058328539,
-0.3194364011,
0.7881683707,
0.221400544,
0.3849150538,
0.2555241287,
1.1528124809,
-0.4691934884,
0.3295600116,
1.4040269852,
-0.0688005239,
0.86761868,
0.4551478922,
0.2592287064,
0.7889531255,
0.2981808186,
0.1891256869,
0.2589134574,
0.3052652776,
-0.2180393487,
-0.3522245586,
0.0087544741,
-0.0531503297,
0.545539856,
0.3393405676,
-0.5994770527,
-0.3106740713,
0.1965547651,
0.0094375741,
0.021807272,
-0.0533327945,
0.7553023696,
0.3228310347,
-0.9481372833,
0.8651517034,
0.1297838092,
0.755567193,
-0.2888458371,
0.1417961717,
-0.2835440636,
0.1091110632,
0.0691781789,
-0.3739436269,
0.4273913205,
0.1427775323,
-0.2551699579,
-0.6117605567,
1.0020489693,
-0.6300724149,
-0.488476783,
0.368722409,
0.5702959299,
0.2347549796,
-0.2165310383,
-0.4599330723,
0.1356938481,
-0.3721729219,
-0.4118775129,
0.2408368886,
0.3412392735,
0.0583137162,
0.4623775184,
0.3674401045,
-0.2889128029,
-0.2133275867,
0.1267612278,
1.0623835325,
-0.8002326488,
-0.3647925556,
-0.9107365608,
0.3115665317,
0.0569629483,
-0.005395737,
0.5509496927,
0.4827070832,
0.5939837694,
-0.1098773777,
0.8033222556,
0.1920483559,
0.4064274728,
-0.5083430409,
0.6517820358,
-0.529995501,
0.0548096634,
-0.0371455215,
-0.7448955178,
-0.3161393106,
0.5526890159,
-0.2107386738,
-0.0334903747,
0.5865482092,
0.5577093363,
-0.3638129234,
-0.1879244596,
0.4372125864,
0.3070302606,
0.4064434469,
0.6045770645,
0.6982769966,
-0.6432052255,
0.6198899746,
-0.1884654462,
-0.3481013179,
-0.3165617287,
-1.2591700554,
-1.0825150013,
-0.5526119471,
-0.3751065731,
-0.1015172675,
-0.1794482768,
0.9963710308,
0.7874759436,
-0.6087791324,
-0.3952974677,
0.0289979186,
-0.2111614347,
0.1956994087,
-0.2221513838,
0.458607018,
-0.6031826735,
-0.9042213559,
0.7189001441,
0.2778917849,
0.2159121782,
-0.2419393361,
0.0523887575,
0.1747554094,
0.2226260155,
0.9989259839,
0.1408570856,
-0.6179130673,
-0.3129270375,
-0.0402153321,
0.0719358027,
0.0673534572,
1.0088617802,
-1.25210917,
0.2198386788,
0.3695951104,
0.4535860419,
0.4338309169,
0.0325622745,
0.9294283986,
-0.6636009216,
0.4140311182,
0.0168081671,
0.632697463,
0.5337041616,
-0.1649931967,
0.2803671658,
-0.1525135636,
-0.5195305943,
-0.7717769742,
0.2651862204,
-0.6299808621,
-0.6513867378,
1.1418911219,
-0.2506319582,
-0.3733615875,
-0.1866538823,
-0.0798281208,
0.4596805274,
-0.1080818251,
0.7925005555,
0.5764796734,
-0.0132421497,
-0.2092579752,
-0.3492788076,
0.6572850347,
0.6274499297,
-0.9304884672,
0.2203762233,
0.3568480909,
0.3634895682,
0.0892488286,
0.3361610174,
0.0066802171,
0.0281858128,
-0.4576965272,
-0.0650347248,
0.01302859,
-0.299874872,
-0.9073209167,
0.0285630375,
-0.057671722,
0.2426140904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14785v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14785v2 | Simple Linguistic Inferences of Large Language Models (LLMs): Blind Spots and Blinds | 2023-05-24T06:41:09 | 2024-04-11T11:16:45 | Victoria Basmov, Yoav Goldberg, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We evaluate LLMs' language understanding capacities on simple inference tasks
that most humans find trivial. Specifically, we target (i)
grammatically-specified entailments, (ii) premises with evidential adverbs of
uncertainty, and (iii) monotonicity entailments. We design evaluation sets for
these tasks and conduct experiments in both zero-shot and chain-of-thought
setups, and with multiple prompts and LLMs. The models exhibit moderate to low
performance on these evaluation sets. Subsequent experiments show that
embedding the premise in syntactic constructions that should preserve the
entailment relations (presupposition triggers) or change them (non-factives),
further confuses the models, causing them to either under-predict or
over-predict certain entailment labels regardless of the true relation, and
often disregarding the nature of the embedding context. Overall these results
suggest that, despite LLMs' celebrated language understanding capacity, even
the strongest models have blindspots with respect to certain types of
entailments, and certain information-packaging structures act as ``blinds''
overshadowing the semantics of the embedded premise. | [
-0.3076394796,
-1.0475432873,
1.0680258274,
0.3722556233,
-0.1363528371,
-0.3621342778,
-0.3109627068,
-0.3772109747,
0.1199679375,
0.7225076556,
-0.465528965,
-0.3439001739,
-0.7212625146,
0.0672128126,
-0.4260890186,
0.6908615232,
-0.023678381,
-0.2112080753,
-0.1968272924,
-0.060300827,
-0.2553405762,
-0.237827003,
-0.1800431013,
-0.1385528743,
0.3857993782,
0.4790227413,
0.8205953836,
0.7113007307,
0.2342975289,
0.2882581055,
-0.2013463229,
-0.2193870544,
-0.2742297649,
0.1725384444,
-0.0761973485,
-0.6319831014,
-0.0468216874,
0.1784095764,
0.7042216063,
1.1836923361,
-0.0947447568,
0.0255180802,
0.1430528313,
0.4337138236,
-0.8047415614,
-0.0530024841,
-0.7886224389,
-0.096919328,
-0.0071784379,
0.1729412228,
-0.5999426842,
-0.0287059899,
0.3754529059,
-0.4162105024,
0.2476033419,
0.2395015806,
0.8229746819,
0.4873855412,
-0.458071202,
-0.3839791417,
-0.4355743229,
0.8967841864,
-0.7977202535,
0.2895563543,
0.5101432204,
0.1232219338,
-0.2511032522,
-0.3880878389,
-0.4437043369,
-0.4733343124,
-0.2368010134,
0.0662573799,
-0.3524568081,
0.3252268136,
0.5127086043,
0.212771222,
-0.4429703951,
0.3441313505,
-0.0394921638,
0.0781918019,
0.402698338,
0.0666147694,
-0.0787428468,
-0.4325000942,
-0.4407241046,
0.3111463487,
-0.8655993938,
-0.2635380328,
0.1001222581,
0.1925723106,
-0.1730455309,
0.7389217615,
-0.4321720302,
1.00476408,
0.011678895,
0.1378199458,
-0.1278038919,
-0.3824435771,
-0.5624412298,
-0.1908657551,
0.7035912275,
-0.0951410905,
0.3775629401,
-0.2053313106,
-0.1937791556,
0.1296160668,
-0.1111831814,
-0.3747965693,
-0.0101572191,
0.2298251539,
-0.0546041839,
-0.1906488687,
-0.0097089019,
-0.5407047272,
-0.5889040232,
-0.1816312224,
0.5180977583,
-0.2280342281,
0.0781175867,
0.3970041871,
-0.0974177793,
0.2848106921,
0.389059037,
-0.6434506178,
0.4799701869,
0.5533143878,
0.6117863655,
-0.0625060648,
-0.4477900267,
-0.2322512269,
0.1348459423,
-0.1644720882,
0.8149012923,
-0.5217123032,
-0.0893848091,
0.0587582104,
0.1721102893,
-0.2545296252,
-0.5602176785,
0.5386994481,
-0.2385332882,
0.1098700836,
-0.1514371485,
-0.6689310074,
-0.323027283,
-0.025178114,
-0.5816675425,
0.4420709014,
-0.3018541038,
-0.5584025979,
0.3170673847,
-0.3377643526,
-0.4111130238,
-0.2211682498,
-0.2327990979,
-0.1443423182,
0.511821568,
0.0612094998,
0.456378907,
-0.5308517814,
0.2578821778,
-0.3559835255,
-0.2890380621,
0.3888377249,
-0.6380247474,
0.814540267,
0.070928216,
-0.4674734175,
-0.0478140488,
-0.5705006123,
-0.1576188803,
0.1425155103,
-0.2072236091,
-0.542067647,
0.2146150321,
-0.3813744783,
0.0717245713,
0.0431285501,
-0.3519514799,
-0.005825772,
-0.4813131988,
0.4609046876,
0.5907435417,
0.066799514,
0.462221235,
-0.1510223299,
0.3888355196,
0.0877060369,
0.0365282856,
-0.1107767671,
-0.5729697943,
-1.0493377447,
-0.2392616123,
0.2210451812,
0.4296044409,
-0.5914789438,
0.2260401398,
-0.1673897803,
-0.1716711968,
-0.4367732704,
0.2852595747,
0.6130574346,
0.2070596963,
-0.0961376056,
-0.0866743028,
-0.2122010589,
-1.2160181999,
-0.4756120741,
-0.0267277658,
0.0187223274,
0.1670719683,
0.6727318168,
0.1552696377,
0.7505437732,
-0.6383964419,
0.0046406104,
-0.2167350054,
0.1948870569,
0.3667639792,
0.2676348388,
0.2905173004,
-0.7125735283,
-0.2969172895,
-0.4136930406,
-0.7057212591,
-0.1584020853,
-0.0851382315,
0.0811689869,
0.0413120836,
0.334192276,
-1.0011241436,
0.4143196642,
0.3637972176,
-0.5600340962,
0.64576298,
-0.0413824841,
-0.0232472233,
-0.5167980194,
-0.4483771324,
0.0941043198,
-0.2257627547,
-0.7369828224,
0.1345856786,
-0.0603211001,
0.1029890254,
-0.4607791901,
0.5629962087,
-0.7514445186,
-0.1368767023,
-0.1543136537,
0.573656261,
0.1765322387,
0.4307672083,
0.1091090366,
0.4926983118,
0.5979976058,
-0.648860395,
-0.0004012548,
-0.0492312647,
-0.6487263441,
0.3156503141,
-0.6287314296,
0.0364289545,
-0.1730822325,
-0.1730976701,
-1.1755470037,
-0.4196694493,
0.1471339762,
-0.1910136938,
0.2701285779,
-0.1163349152,
-0.5321199894,
-0.1790952682,
-0.3773333728,
0.3063855767,
0.4104714096,
-0.2438927442,
0.2057551742,
0.3669689894,
-0.060161721,
-0.5835755467,
-0.9648528099,
0.1433325261,
-0.2840490639,
-0.5625827909,
-0.1257302016,
0.1842926294,
-0.8399505615,
0.1078957319,
-0.0095036151,
-0.1227267757,
0.3662792742,
0.308568716,
0.0970408991,
-0.4716725945,
0.2784669399,
-0.0049762931,
0.0599780343,
-0.0508700684,
-0.3018823564,
0.152648434,
-0.2060965002,
-0.7038959861,
-0.0370191522,
0.2938795388,
0.4592381716,
0.1542028934,
0.7485206127,
-0.2417780012,
-0.5065405965,
-0.2898809016,
-0.7373536229,
-0.1350888163,
-0.3927913308,
0.4722387791,
-0.4487502277,
-0.8586441278,
0.3426520824,
0.0839600563,
-0.1444506347,
0.4140147269,
0.5447610617,
-0.2140886635,
0.8385406137,
0.6007595658,
0.1577094644,
0.2173175961,
-0.0636337176,
0.1443249583,
-0.7419441938,
0.2031242847,
-0.5780036449,
0.117282778,
-0.5114320517,
-0.5937708616,
0.1489174664,
0.3345573246,
-0.2171940058,
0.3899220526,
-0.1404477805,
0.6976609826,
0.301204741,
-0.0165046118,
0.5051460862,
-0.1062237769,
0.0247647967,
-0.1454573572,
-0.8833364844,
-0.7396902442,
0.9043031931,
0.3458956182,
1.0301061869,
0.2506502271,
0.4560450017,
0.1598403752,
0.4389702082,
-0.8912975788,
0.4508375525,
-0.1950862408,
-0.8931910992,
-0.4327965677,
-0.2486620396,
-0.8291152716,
0.5821834803,
-0.044189889,
-1.0026431084,
0.4093242288,
0.1054402292,
-0.2791226208,
-0.0090536475,
-1.0197645426,
0.9859166741,
-0.218491748,
-0.4368287027,
-0.1541982889,
-0.4857132733,
0.895619452,
-0.1881238967,
0.3198670149,
-0.2313884348,
-0.2515344918,
0.6881393194,
-0.192950815,
1.098880291,
-0.1034037769,
-0.0945281386,
0.3427105546,
0.1793792546,
0.4991647899,
-0.2085065395,
-0.2959812284,
0.0541755557,
-0.0898939744,
-0.3313128948,
-0.6383015513,
0.5358297825,
-0.4192793965,
-1.0485368967,
-0.2720879614,
-0.6412059069,
-0.2924129963,
0.1184457392,
0.2340460122,
0.291890204,
-0.1606493741,
0.0140889231,
0.6587171555,
-0.3333306611,
0.1837205589,
0.690087378,
-0.1603838354,
-0.0621659346,
0.5958296061,
0.1725472957,
0.7725204229,
0.1731937975,
0.142870903,
-0.353558749,
-0.6372579932,
-0.3246731758,
0.5594207048,
-0.9617943764,
0.0490683913,
-0.3610160947,
-0.0980419666,
-0.3626584709,
-0.0351960175,
-0.1501253545,
-0.5007228851,
-0.0368452817,
-0.0981257409,
0.16444619,
1.0243941545,
0.11082948,
0.5343332291,
-0.3376168013,
0.354455471,
0.2447531968,
0.1911808848,
-0.0588664673,
-0.8535882831,
-0.1953491867,
0.0138353724,
-0.1962939501,
-1.0311505795,
0.0304585546,
0.3398889601,
0.5800759196,
0.6107602119,
0.0705322921,
0.6419427991,
-0.5429040194,
0.5507923961,
0.1915634573,
-0.9697489142,
0.3930213153,
-0.2248344272,
0.2730984092,
0.5445861816,
0.3152364194,
-0.2888482213,
-0.873916626,
-0.5715714097,
-0.5465162396,
0.5981437564,
0.21225591,
0.031109089,
-0.0389092378,
0.2253761142,
0.1507949829,
0.3051356971,
-0.9209509492,
-0.1847985089,
0.3587432206,
-0.2224392593,
-0.3326955438,
-0.6108652949,
-0.0836615339,
-0.1648891866,
0.2500921488,
0.0622536577,
0.1903581619,
0.1993564367,
-0.4728964269,
-0.1004054919,
0.4804972708,
0.7756323218,
0.8891470432,
-0.2151930779,
0.6552808881,
0.286578387,
-0.1553212851,
0.2461985797,
0.0044261874,
-0.3290777206,
0.0199948065,
0.7813442945,
0.9373424649,
0.4977215827,
-0.5722785592,
0.5404233932,
0.2255849391,
-0.0832589045,
-0.1916358918,
-0.0637308881,
0.2847517133,
0.1150929406,
0.0986917913,
-0.0346039645,
0.1117274538,
-0.7888059616,
0.2063912451,
0.5779796839,
-0.4343766868,
-0.2172334343,
0.4565882087,
-0.1386336535,
-0.2537904382,
0.0892579108,
-0.1510586143,
-0.6152449846,
0.6331360936,
0.4731606841,
0.8984408379,
-0.0195123889,
0.1096458808,
0.0484738313,
0.7047720551,
-0.0989410058,
0.0485293344,
-0.1129883751,
-0.8350990415,
-0.6788057089,
-0.64222157,
-0.3807787001,
0.0561770052,
-0.4961684346,
0.2680120468,
-0.2568785846,
0.0889268517,
0.2087933272,
-0.3208016157,
-0.6014968753,
-0.0500604361,
0.1086223945,
1.1225144863,
-1.0566653013,
0.7871146798,
0.3068068624,
-0.3703458905,
-0.5598586798,
0.2413172573,
0.0809676126,
-0.8572526574,
0.6409751773,
0.056355115,
-0.238648653,
-0.0593149289,
-0.6892191172,
-0.8189681768,
0.566198647,
0.5882834792,
-0.579164505,
0.0736794323,
0.162668094,
0.3000716865,
-0.2900319099,
0.1571273804,
0.7970331907,
0.6230906844,
-0.0785009414,
-0.7961201072,
0.383035928,
0.3075974286,
-0.3357504904,
0.0755377486,
-0.3324259222,
0.8560934663,
-0.4093838334,
-0.3552373052,
0.0971321762,
0.332572341,
0.3260767758,
0.2562358677,
0.5231667757,
0.6575180888,
0.4499594569,
-0.1863516867,
1.2817496061,
0.1238810048,
0.3011539876,
1.1225465536,
-0.2197394818,
0.8078683019,
0.6318119764,
-0.334317565,
0.2253776044,
0.5370804071,
0.2239318043,
0.5348604321,
0.3311754465,
-0.080814153,
-0.4152559936,
-0.1437585652,
-0.0205235481,
0.4196001887,
0.51377666,
-0.2416038066,
-0.3300622404,
-0.0263889953,
0.0291235913,
-0.0573026538,
-0.0264547896,
0.6474460363,
0.5645520091,
-0.7890635133,
0.7870332003,
-0.0277873557,
0.5877602696,
-0.548982501,
0.0579366833,
-0.0942140296,
0.0335329995,
-0.062065836,
-0.9315459728,
0.1809898168,
0.105455853,
-0.0587573722,
0.0170954224,
0.7065333128,
-0.4186507165,
-0.4902018607,
0.4226031601,
0.5846816897,
0.4666038454,
-0.056561742,
-0.5474964976,
-0.0179950017,
-0.0724020377,
-0.4669060409,
0.1934677958,
0.6565901637,
0.067162618,
0.6126384735,
0.1761271805,
0.4448579848,
0.303300947,
0.1687491238,
0.5220835209,
-0.8290588856,
-0.1293943226,
-0.9957675338,
0.4206789732,
-0.0013383923,
-0.1857224107,
1.0664571524,
0.336501956,
0.4724983275,
-0.1585463285,
0.6221894622,
0.0994750559,
0.2430504858,
-0.7394996285,
0.4542621374,
-0.5974880457,
0.363371402,
-0.2141635865,
-0.899649322,
-0.3906175792,
0.5370317698,
-0.7030677795,
-0.1569144726,
0.7547104955,
0.7268926501,
-0.1232473999,
-0.1646340787,
0.7440481186,
0.6474153996,
-0.2129088938,
0.7214424014,
1.3430303335,
-0.1882750839,
0.2177522182,
-0.1310177147,
-0.221474871,
-0.1945285052,
-0.7984678745,
-0.6312965751,
-0.3414064348,
-0.2453512251,
-0.1218215302,
-0.0210814904,
0.5229656696,
0.493971467,
-0.8855712414,
-0.3929465711,
-0.1760999411,
0.6366663575,
0.0586223863,
-0.1924300492,
0.2812435329,
-0.3212584853,
-0.6310005784,
0.3751198053,
0.4405065179,
0.0622631274,
-0.4055407643,
-0.0651434511,
-0.4451381564,
0.2423995137,
0.5143742561,
0.2286021858,
-1.1685596704,
-0.5049128532,
-0.1374441236,
-0.0975341201,
-0.1639145911,
0.5771427751,
-0.5380067825,
0.3118349314,
0.4000035524,
0.3760644495,
0.3995129466,
-0.0659463853,
0.5079921484,
-0.6370648146,
0.4540805221,
0.0721689239,
0.6047429442,
0.1831842065,
-0.0739622116,
0.4010429382,
0.2736240327,
-0.2714141905,
-1.0718554258,
0.4348434508,
-0.7690143585,
-0.4934348464,
1.1595454216,
-0.2710671723,
-0.3260077536,
-0.3838040233,
0.2304243743,
-0.0697094947,
0.224913463,
0.5200053453,
0.9049168229,
-0.0954195485,
-0.05527924,
-1.0914237499,
0.3075233996,
0.6736511588,
-0.5602663159,
0.3651474416,
0.5682454705,
0.3487077057,
0.1309147477,
0.429690063,
0.1749130636,
0.14733316,
0.2338269055,
-0.1729799062,
0.2771242857,
-0.4196365774,
-0.6256355047,
0.0193258226,
0.490334481,
-0.1791062504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14784v1 | Anthropomorphization of AI: Opportunities and Risks | 2023-05-24T06:39:45 | 2023-05-24T06:39:45 | Ameet Deshpande, Tanmay Rajpurohit, Karthik Narasimhan, Ashwin Kalyan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Anthropomorphization is the tendency to attribute human-like traits to
non-human entities. It is prevalent in many social contexts -- children
anthropomorphize toys, adults do so with brands, and it is a literary device.
It is also a versatile tool in science, with behavioral psychology and
evolutionary biology meticulously documenting its consequences. With widespread
adoption of AI systems, and the push from stakeholders to make it human-like
through alignment techniques, human voice, and pictorial avatars, the tendency
for users to anthropomorphize it increases significantly. We take a dyadic
approach to understanding this phenomenon with large language models (LLMs) by
studying (1) the objective legal implications, as analyzed through the lens of
the recent blueprint of AI bill of rights and the (2) subtle psychological
aspects customization and anthropomorphization. We find that anthropomorphized
LLMs customized for different user bases violate multiple provisions in the
legislative blueprint. In addition, we point out that anthropomorphization of
LLMs affects the influence they can have on their users, thus having the
potential to fundamentally change the nature of human-AI interaction, with
potential for manipulation and negative influence. With LLMs being
hyper-personalized for vulnerable groups like children and patients among
others, our work is a timely and important contribution. We propose a
conservative strategy for the cautious use of anthropomorphization to improve
trustworthiness of AI systems. | [
-0.2975038588,
-0.6668040156,
0.4139107466,
-0.0666303933,
-0.2233629674,
0.1817705035,
-0.1344472319,
-1.0166203976,
0.0769068897,
0.2050973624,
-0.4845070243,
-0.0117594944,
-0.5409352779,
0.0415308103,
-0.2600284815,
0.8916426897,
0.0420275703,
-0.1233334616,
-0.3681131005,
-0.4038922787,
-0.2756629884,
-0.7645357251,
-0.3277927041,
-0.4692859054,
0.6088830233,
0.2122829109,
1.4002732038,
1.0931099653,
0.3022080362,
0.354885608,
-0.1806124896,
-0.3352881372,
-0.2141427994,
0.237768665,
-0.2367369235,
-0.5050339699,
-0.4718331099,
0.3440963626,
0.4609387815,
0.7197759748,
-0.3862694204,
0.1971931159,
-0.0759546906,
0.4475358129,
-0.4030754268,
0.0424351133,
-0.3353364766,
0.199049741,
-0.1860646755,
0.1456918418,
0.1007514745,
-0.1351200491,
-0.0298073161,
-0.6890340447,
-0.1430092156,
0.5003122687,
0.6712686419,
0.5304370522,
-0.2992316484,
-0.2097584307,
-0.9525702,
0.763536334,
-0.6539065242,
0.3290385306,
0.7030954361,
0.1120924503,
-0.1028529108,
-0.4003351927,
-1.0902814865,
-0.5568056703,
-0.1223642528,
-0.1874310076,
-0.1754561961,
0.1188722998,
0.3941168487,
0.3840482533,
-0.4581634402,
0.4780119956,
-0.2018319368,
-0.2069178671,
0.937302649,
0.2944724262,
0.8962644339,
-0.0975470319,
-0.2259582579,
-0.1469139755,
-0.5840594769,
0.0841485485,
0.4921961129,
0.1337849498,
-0.0257754233,
0.7060919404,
0.0252520815,
0.4287323356,
-0.1095095351,
-0.0148136346,
0.1891274601,
-0.0820088834,
-0.0386010893,
0.2132402807,
0.5141314864,
0.281222254,
0.4178491831,
-0.1501993537,
-0.0758088455,
0.2061832845,
0.4224120975,
-0.5227931738,
0.1394566,
0.1641848683,
-0.6529017687,
-0.4808402359,
-0.0648167729,
-0.5439234972,
-0.7537560463,
-0.6611453891,
0.134848386,
-0.5507611632,
-0.2822000682,
-0.0334995426,
0.1158261523,
0.3924907446,
0.2157547623,
-0.8859798312,
0.1673040539,
0.8648321033,
0.7157258987,
-0.09682668,
-0.5698433518,
-0.0506249182,
0.2756764591,
-0.500121057,
0.392043978,
-0.7210979462,
-0.6917160749,
-0.0478267595,
-0.1172264665,
0.0603365116,
-0.3317536712,
0.0678477064,
-0.2854204476,
0.1810651422,
-0.0064796787,
-0.4857672453,
-0.1323419064,
0.3280277252,
-0.4916705489,
0.5218991637,
0.0735380203,
-0.5881785154,
0.4310174286,
-0.7875950933,
-0.7442616224,
0.2133120447,
-0.1862802207,
-0.3907222748,
0.2257477045,
-0.1265838891,
0.0775698349,
-0.1597168893,
0.0865407363,
-0.6078913808,
-0.4502671659,
0.5443075299,
-0.1330089867,
0.8879072666,
0.4147148728,
-0.3495046794,
0.2544234395,
-0.231526807,
-0.2982685864,
0.2205422819,
-0.2554395497,
-0.4606016278,
0.1516551226,
0.1095996723,
0.298070699,
0.2609565854,
-0.3591476083,
0.1432487965,
-0.4738436043,
0.6972047091,
0.986335516,
-0.0750642046,
0.4389739931,
-0.7453631759,
0.7930492163,
-0.2456387579,
0.5859414935,
0.0357053168,
-0.4520577192,
-0.271052897,
-0.4470885694,
0.0943231881,
0.5509290099,
-0.6043256521,
0.4813384116,
0.0160967689,
-0.3432927728,
-0.5800619125,
-0.0797143206,
0.3603240252,
0.3654941916,
0.0606535114,
-0.3148311377,
-0.2844685912,
-0.8495954871,
-0.3441140354,
-0.7164417505,
0.0547103174,
0.5364404917,
0.4763452709,
-0.5799815059,
0.6178475618,
-0.1888279766,
-0.2020726949,
0.0180724338,
0.0001418128,
-0.147888273,
0.6565060616,
0.61328125,
-0.9659667015,
-0.1550648957,
-0.0097989338,
-0.5097821951,
0.283636421,
0.0515096784,
0.034307126,
0.3422475755,
0.4789766371,
-0.9280927181,
0.4931584299,
0.1473200321,
-0.5093846917,
0.4599195421,
-0.195755288,
0.3056503236,
-1.1425931454,
0.3271062672,
-0.222377196,
-0.1799949855,
-0.6895035505,
0.2886157334,
-0.5295941234,
-0.2404516488,
-0.4800057113,
0.6200418472,
-0.1984508634,
-0.1517779678,
-0.3514426053,
-0.0786207989,
-0.2471743971,
0.0234978851,
-0.1163780466,
0.5571498275,
0.5733080506,
-0.4646502435,
0.5902135968,
0.5308069587,
-0.2309208959,
0.7211136222,
-0.5910833478,
0.4058435559,
-0.2539600432,
0.2830659449,
-0.6732031703,
-0.399802655,
0.5419415236,
-0.4915064871,
0.2201702297,
0.3083482981,
-0.5588883162,
-0.3091587424,
-0.5025183558,
0.5464268327,
0.6251599193,
-0.1927134693,
0.4274824262,
0.7455540299,
-0.377055794,
-0.33863464,
-0.6267190576,
0.37333709,
-0.613519311,
-0.2921360731,
0.383431673,
-0.2159117758,
-0.4255169928,
0.2738351226,
0.188021943,
0.0523003377,
0.3643772006,
0.416726321,
0.2650274634,
0.0167403873,
0.2471503466,
-0.2624605298,
-0.0703935996,
-0.1020464152,
-0.0546468273,
0.3909135163,
-0.1409648955,
-0.345906496,
-0.6840963364,
0.5249892473,
0.853333056,
-0.101913102,
0.7524079084,
0.5758465528,
-0.6602045894,
0.3103573322,
-0.2220316976,
-0.3603101373,
-0.4259108901,
0.3014800847,
0.0254162736,
-0.7897882462,
0.4494724274,
0.0480450764,
-0.101439923,
0.1170672327,
0.7209752202,
-0.4210412204,
1.2270339727,
0.8454099894,
-0.4330319464,
0.7079450488,
0.2765174508,
0.2285458446,
-0.8030813336,
-0.2213010639,
-0.5586854219,
-0.5164487362,
-1.1223460436,
-0.1275679618,
0.1196945682,
-0.52063936,
-0.4861535728,
0.1105648875,
-0.3848046958,
0.2141759694,
0.6967879534,
0.3094109595,
0.1589416414,
-0.343614608,
0.3209604919,
0.087682128,
-0.5327244401,
-0.6485522389,
0.8294804692,
0.3522804976,
0.6598266363,
0.2650724351,
0.5515087843,
0.741640985,
0.4468059242,
-0.9857990742,
0.5037801266,
0.1373083144,
-0.9017535448,
-0.5414631367,
-0.1222651526,
-1.0870642662,
-0.1047337875,
-0.4961752594,
-1.0737973452,
0.4720072448,
0.4806535244,
-0.4015356004,
0.191700995,
-0.3414434493,
0.6569234133,
-0.3369149864,
-0.2753400803,
-0.5881393552,
-0.9019056559,
0.1543337256,
-0.0412047803,
0.3217056096,
-0.2010807395,
-0.2342878431,
0.4350829124,
-0.1142007783,
0.9921612144,
-0.0163869001,
0.0995429084,
0.0282454584,
0.2030696571,
0.4661337137,
-0.1446794271,
-0.144480601,
0.1180915982,
0.0550406203,
-0.5049185753,
-0.4577254653,
0.5905249119,
-0.9593396783,
-1.0001037121,
-0.6784060597,
-0.67786026,
-0.2474568188,
0.2394526601,
-0.047634393,
-0.1513610184,
-0.435566932,
0.0655347407,
0.3594197929,
-0.3668419719,
0.3085175157,
0.3476187885,
-0.1020728573,
-0.0794514418,
0.9194718599,
-0.1826584935,
-0.0178053193,
-0.0839172453,
0.4372982085,
-0.3072777987,
-0.4985096455,
-0.2470109612,
0.2184830606,
-0.4542435706,
0.0364974961,
-0.1925234497,
-0.0171873309,
-0.4433616996,
-0.2298329175,
-0.1258016229,
-0.4004083872,
-0.4516918659,
-0.0698961541,
0.2273474932,
0.8046066761,
-0.0494270436,
0.0360521264,
-0.4776399136,
0.3841311634,
0.3090348244,
0.3135994971,
-0.0769675523,
-0.4116480052,
-0.1948572397,
0.1470308453,
-0.1383657604,
-0.6914040446,
0.1345490962,
0.2883096933,
0.6567317843,
0.4704460502,
0.1524242312,
0.6382924318,
-0.6544085145,
0.6286460161,
0.041848924,
-0.9077753425,
0.413960129,
-0.3602725267,
-0.0205652583,
0.3917401731,
0.432208389,
-0.8853504658,
-0.285949856,
-0.6664636135,
-0.9162844419,
0.6792835593,
0.1435416192,
0.6185424328,
0.2145566493,
0.6229404807,
-0.0396724939,
0.5207303166,
-0.6046820283,
0.0207346454,
-0.3172965646,
-0.203787595,
-0.2331621051,
-0.1812020242,
-0.369507283,
-0.2372543067,
0.4897505343,
0.0937704146,
0.130461216,
0.0785148367,
-0.0657310858,
-0.3598080575,
0.1491494328,
0.6433752179,
0.5610517859,
0.0803889334,
0.1022015214,
-0.0824107453,
-0.3447493911,
0.3117200434,
0.1593210399,
-0.0307595506,
-0.5635070801,
0.5289105773,
0.6151175499,
-0.1208157316,
-0.6708644629,
0.1836818159,
0.0987577066,
0.1226166338,
-0.3752628267,
0.2366560102,
-0.1281317472,
0.4583745301,
0.149800241,
0.0021874376,
0.3560285866,
-1.0496667624,
0.2150372118,
0.5565494299,
-0.3036807477,
-0.4415630102,
0.7428600192,
0.1077410877,
-0.831913054,
0.610037148,
-0.0420945063,
-0.2844672501,
0.6027530432,
0.453189373,
0.8824449778,
-0.7247473001,
0.1770772934,
-0.0890575498,
0.4228807986,
0.0155752786,
-0.1686566025,
-0.0255550295,
-0.8713556528,
0.012671845,
-0.3340575099,
-0.690004468,
-0.1661305577,
-0.5880527496,
0.0746885687,
-0.397788167,
-0.3196186125,
0.0418582112,
-0.3532269001,
-0.4712785184,
0.0144174118,
0.4071190059,
0.2595057189,
-0.8408882618,
0.6630381942,
1.2431923151,
-0.236115247,
-0.4033740461,
0.5103116035,
0.1879220605,
-1.0261874199,
0.197121039,
0.0559076592,
-0.008549015,
-0.0585569553,
-0.4220985174,
-0.6274017096,
1.0490376949,
0.4932842851,
-0.2787271738,
-0.1233459488,
0.2302776426,
0.760360837,
-0.4993797541,
-0.2669187188,
0.7263079286,
0.5925763845,
-0.0235960037,
-0.9040017724,
0.3193885088,
-0.1737286448,
0.3697654307,
-0.1508162469,
-0.6798251271,
0.534781158,
-0.4376696944,
-0.1319272816,
-0.0216376483,
0.2220557481,
0.1966670156,
0.4510341883,
0.7347971797,
0.2967757583,
0.6279148459,
0.3324474096,
1.2876420021,
-0.3921352923,
0.09700609,
0.5955035686,
-0.4400146604,
0.5286008716,
0.6384715438,
-0.1505948305,
0.3238798976,
0.8218249679,
0.1727038026,
0.295991987,
0.416801542,
-0.2358862609,
-0.0647401512,
-0.4635867476,
-0.1732697487,
0.8047720194,
0.4468058646,
-0.1949351728,
0.2600112557,
0.2459271997,
0.0666840672,
0.2697919905,
-0.1111329272,
0.8603188992,
0.2231766731,
-0.5413794518,
0.134915024,
-0.152007848,
0.3043653667,
-0.1920496672,
-0.032665059,
-0.0276816338,
-0.0929155424,
-0.049499888,
-0.4856210053,
0.5980618596,
-0.110444963,
-0.0378856212,
-0.2618109584,
0.5573779345,
-0.0804651007,
-0.5636140704,
0.1031307355,
0.551471591,
0.1056398302,
0.1020680517,
-0.9187446237,
0.0677891448,
-0.2316539437,
-0.478001833,
0.4139061272,
0.1294977665,
-0.2696786225,
0.8567541838,
0.5895768404,
0.1871795356,
-0.4395860732,
-0.3390821517,
0.8553435206,
-0.731433332,
-0.5224801898,
-1.1010900736,
0.3573796153,
0.1598932743,
-0.19394961,
0.4209413528,
0.1538226753,
0.457706809,
0.1358455271,
0.6216635108,
-0.2531632185,
0.0471025482,
-0.207616657,
0.8887823224,
-0.7386442423,
0.1820178479,
-0.2950002551,
-0.724481523,
-0.4052559733,
0.6936685443,
-0.2553948462,
0.253611207,
0.2276726514,
0.5375876427,
0.2035582066,
-0.1701445132,
0.3945026696,
0.1899508387,
0.2816121876,
0.1288509071,
1.0391560793,
0.2168405652,
0.2317098975,
-0.1744209975,
-0.4548323154,
-0.4570323527,
-0.7720706463,
-0.6091598868,
-0.5845533609,
-0.4283869863,
-0.1883193105,
0.1894405335,
1.0864409208,
0.7453401089,
-0.5819150209,
-0.1895809919,
0.0003570781,
0.4001162946,
-0.2671143115,
-0.213051185,
0.1250941306,
-0.0965176001,
-0.8554121256,
0.0539755039,
0.2815819681,
0.3337033093,
-0.3818525374,
-0.1060719565,
0.0287740938,
0.3757098019,
0.4914057553,
0.4657157063,
-0.7186606526,
-0.5518368483,
-0.144244805,
-0.1295879781,
0.0979008526,
0.779186368,
-0.3677206933,
0.4764738977,
0.0783538222,
0.3939307928,
0.1128933281,
0.2447117269,
0.6706423163,
-0.3564301431,
0.6048483849,
0.7187307477,
0.3168289959,
0.3600366116,
-0.6511192322,
0.3271102905,
0.1643233597,
-0.5699692369,
-1.0585348606,
0.6642253995,
-0.492685765,
-0.4591999948,
0.8575506806,
-0.1079073101,
-0.2344852388,
-0.0887399912,
-0.2536211312,
0.4733834565,
-0.3367442191,
1.5275455713,
0.566313982,
-0.6353933811,
-0.1724195778,
-0.4818439782,
0.6073893309,
0.2089499235,
-0.8407178521,
-0.0026946198,
0.4310870469,
0.0693050697,
0.1639180034,
0.5472159386,
-0.0499509275,
0.2753549814,
-0.2072035372,
0.2338569611,
-0.1528931707,
0.056819547,
-0.359346807,
-0.3008473814,
0.5554142594,
-0.3220553398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14783v1 | Disentangled Phonetic Representation for Chinese Spelling Correction | 2023-05-24T06:39:12 | 2023-05-24T06:39:12 | Zihong Liang, Xiaojun Quan, Qifan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chinese Spelling Correction (CSC) aims to detect and correct erroneous
characters in Chinese texts. Although efforts have been made to introduce
phonetic information (Hanyu Pinyin) in this task, they typically merge phonetic
representations with character representations, which tends to weaken the
representation effect of normal texts. In this work, we propose to disentangle
the two types of features to allow for direct interaction between textual and
phonetic information. To learn useful phonetic representations, we introduce a
pinyin-to-character objective to ask the model to predict the correct
characters based solely on phonetic information, where a separation mask is
imposed to disable attention from phonetic input to text. To avoid overfitting
the phonetics, we further design a self-distillation module to ensure that
semantic information plays a major role in the prediction. Extensive
experiments on three CSC benchmarks demonstrate the superiority of our method
in using phonetic information. | [
0.059147127,
-0.3197543621,
0.4416409135,
0.2517738938,
-0.3864876628,
0.2249062061,
-0.4463900328,
-0.4240974188,
0.5142878294,
0.3832936585,
-0.5017499328,
-0.4873902202,
-0.4008519948,
0.2247058153,
-0.2166740596,
0.6290508509,
0.1094156802,
0.2745005488,
0.2271004766,
0.096767053,
-0.5773044825,
-0.9030476809,
-0.5636754036,
-0.3492137492,
0.8021813631,
0.3283421695,
0.627782464,
0.8011728525,
0.2255700082,
0.3714703918,
-0.3121295571,
0.2669641674,
-0.3614457548,
-0.0002752203,
-0.0145696346,
-0.5846650004,
-0.2531610727,
0.1131570861,
0.8103351593,
0.782587409,
-0.3782277107,
-0.1547745019,
0.4639548659,
0.6763930917,
-0.6492363811,
0.1621722132,
-0.6248086691,
0.21801278,
-0.451271534,
-0.2074307501,
-0.4961562157,
-0.0114208376,
-0.0631085113,
-0.6970598102,
0.1818731278,
-0.1067150161,
0.7992966175,
0.3613307476,
-0.2794649005,
-0.4157602489,
-0.9397987723,
0.6902112961,
-0.6769962311,
0.3721726537,
0.6415079832,
0.3536878228,
-0.2832492292,
-0.5809953809,
-0.6412828565,
-0.2310872823,
-0.2089743316,
0.5721416473,
0.1451510042,
0.4076391757,
0.2193855196,
0.3670639694,
-0.5048149824,
0.1417468786,
-0.2981286049,
-0.5364905596,
0.502440393,
-0.0196989439,
0.643938303,
-0.3440555036,
-0.2263446599,
-0.0955163836,
-0.3723885417,
-0.0485377125,
0.5108097792,
0.4885752499,
0.3757360876,
0.4272309244,
-0.0429700017,
0.2673711777,
0.7101472616,
-0.0340803564,
0.1934641153,
0.1146783009,
-0.3349678516,
0.8543807268,
0.5329911113,
-0.0728497356,
-0.1394210011,
-0.1732492447,
-0.1262951195,
-0.2341619432,
0.1254371256,
-0.3423798978,
-0.4823211432,
0.2753466964,
-0.5328544378,
-0.2554727495,
0.3437289298,
-0.4325833619,
-0.5131510496,
-0.5295186639,
0.3441873789,
-0.4227821529,
-0.4563316405,
-0.0399265476,
-0.3830576539,
-0.0242367927,
0.3027014732,
-1.3220800161,
0.036460381,
0.4471749365,
0.5992134213,
0.0221421812,
-0.4019983411,
-0.3362336755,
0.4009647667,
-0.2877039611,
0.6135386229,
-0.2461027801,
-0.2607284486,
-0.0331173874,
0.318218112,
-0.1141645238,
-0.7764599919,
0.4146670103,
-0.2959442139,
-0.0155802872,
-0.6603970528,
-0.5391845107,
-0.2850974798,
0.0066523338,
-1.1231087446,
0.9243919253,
-0.0144348443,
-0.8886908293,
0.2946620882,
-0.1856139153,
-0.4475792348,
0.27037251,
-0.060405083,
-0.1917761564,
-0.1086797938,
0.2449664176,
0.1014932245,
0.2873514891,
-0.0567901656,
-0.1572154015,
-0.5035213828,
0.3435523212,
-0.6212238073,
0.9822689891,
0.3009185493,
-0.4336384535,
-0.2099659443,
-0.9013488293,
-0.0494158044,
-0.0044201445,
-0.4944368303,
-0.6725875139,
-0.0600233339,
-0.1075890064,
-0.0866394266,
0.5062310696,
-0.5775851011,
0.0828808025,
-0.3853081763,
0.5065339804,
0.6145437956,
-0.3128540218,
0.5776142478,
-0.0509176441,
0.1205013916,
0.4006564617,
0.0841860473,
0.0991916433,
-0.3115279078,
-0.7383670807,
-0.3690071702,
0.6866448522,
0.6280879974,
-0.7804307938,
0.4734766781,
0.3245916069,
-0.2935853302,
-0.6710755229,
0.0929484069,
0.2858842015,
0.4982777834,
0.4311420619,
-0.1414334774,
-0.5399099588,
-0.403773874,
-0.3560761809,
-0.5342767835,
-0.1498300731,
-0.2387739122,
-0.0892175436,
-0.0254416894,
0.6535660028,
-0.373250097,
-0.7330981493,
-0.2705813646,
0.2867907286,
0.0226806086,
0.3281269372,
0.3537675142,
-0.7514536977,
-0.4716195166,
0.1521706283,
-0.5460984111,
-0.0907347128,
-0.1478917003,
-0.1903175563,
0.2695631385,
0.5633986592,
-0.1564869881,
0.8471720815,
0.2660906315,
0.1049647555,
0.6056233048,
-0.6623753309,
0.4720560312,
-0.8464077711,
0.0143567594,
-0.1152989268,
0.0035514683,
-0.8272383809,
-0.2076866329,
0.4909929633,
0.0585348979,
-0.4262492955,
0.1905047148,
-0.8016368747,
0.2639066577,
-0.4040828645,
0.319701463,
0.1560834795,
0.6283559799,
0.2225306481,
0.3033240736,
0.2590042651,
-0.5646674633,
0.6013860703,
0.0450128689,
-0.0351919234,
0.3430868089,
-0.4307421744,
0.0213499572,
-0.1605908126,
0.2039811164,
-1.1476911306,
-0.2855706215,
0.4668759406,
-0.5594533086,
0.4656851292,
-0.1020926535,
-0.6593031287,
-0.5006629825,
-0.2636420131,
0.5562837124,
0.3743368387,
-0.9106009603,
0.5153467059,
0.2826129496,
0.2720245123,
-0.672521174,
-1.2371040583,
-0.0629227459,
-0.2021274865,
-0.4566480815,
0.6027142406,
0.1571406573,
0.1723908186,
-0.0004470694,
-0.0259462614,
-0.5235623717,
-0.1459765732,
0.200230673,
0.2943696082,
-0.0486930609,
0.3429565728,
0.3395497203,
-0.0442555472,
-0.2070172578,
-0.2748878002,
0.1708170772,
0.5862576962,
-0.355009526,
-0.7195664644,
0.2412543744,
0.3458433151,
-0.3581033945,
0.5570073128,
0.4858698845,
-0.80416435,
-0.1978396326,
-0.6602628231,
-0.0070870211,
-0.5352079272,
0.2914201021,
-0.2220686674,
-0.5241639018,
0.8771244287,
0.0745586455,
-0.195338279,
0.443292886,
0.2543926835,
-0.3550648987,
1.0031508207,
0.4315605462,
-0.1486698985,
0.39149791,
0.1596408486,
0.2356102169,
-0.8402816653,
-0.3079369962,
-0.3469799757,
-0.2467412055,
-0.4949728251,
-0.286983639,
0.0332665704,
0.4223241508,
0.2035163194,
0.6330123544,
-0.9536194205,
0.3990488648,
0.6680358648,
0.3856554627,
0.3150798678,
0.0291684568,
-0.4234133363,
-0.3641719222,
-0.3638127446,
-0.1186228767,
0.5262687802,
0.3443968892,
0.8086128831,
-0.0257405005,
0.9657325745,
0.1511229277,
-0.4916658401,
-0.7562642694,
0.3380802572,
-0.6418414116,
-0.4917917252,
-0.5130844712,
-0.3288106918,
-0.6969650388,
0.126481995,
0.003322558,
-0.6637040377,
0.3924935758,
0.1900048107,
-0.4918412864,
0.387386471,
-0.6907668114,
0.5106734633,
-0.3285138607,
0.1488440186,
-0.182383284,
-0.5448467731,
0.2951251864,
0.0542690791,
-0.1554320306,
0.1544142067,
0.4111700356,
0.5545952916,
-0.7304145098,
0.8434181213,
-0.0264271311,
-0.2190195918,
0.5091352463,
0.0402762368,
0.1427873224,
-0.147669062,
-0.1398346573,
0.4389236271,
0.3008729517,
-0.015922863,
-0.6963753104,
0.5657487512,
-0.7119498253,
-0.4961120188,
-0.5850222707,
-0.0989447907,
0.2414534241,
0.2025578916,
0.4873767793,
0.3551993966,
-0.2963623703,
-0.3240373135,
0.584356308,
-0.2505603433,
0.3776543438,
0.3116369545,
-0.0410486087,
-0.458691448,
0.9782104492,
0.6889409423,
0.1881209016,
0.6643851995,
0.3357728124,
-0.5126705766,
-0.2582280636,
-0.3270870149,
0.3574260175,
-0.901478827,
0.1053674892,
-0.2785902321,
-0.7457893491,
-0.5868031979,
0.3599720597,
-0.2366287112,
-0.3409481049,
-0.7231687307,
0.20154652,
0.1117221266,
0.8359021544,
-0.5260619521,
0.2895483375,
-0.7884679437,
0.3936260045,
0.4372430444,
0.1391564757,
0.1239743531,
-0.6222726703,
-0.4928509891,
0.3136443794,
-0.3369031847,
-0.9207897782,
0.2806086242,
0.0181614123,
0.519079268,
0.5798978806,
0.3586786985,
1.0793780088,
-0.6738932133,
0.8125370145,
0.2761310637,
-1.1574442387,
0.6235242486,
-0.0030164793,
0.3349536359,
0.4035448432,
0.0343640372,
-1.0591990948,
-0.5752152205,
-0.1377079189,
-0.5077063441,
0.9016425014,
0.2359923869,
-0.214479655,
-0.0867842361,
0.5422775745,
-0.003707323,
-0.1998694688,
-0.4023162425,
-0.3005589843,
-0.3629828393,
-0.3994960189,
0.3215558529,
-0.4987633526,
0.1864891648,
-0.2625218928,
0.5724444985,
0.2291590869,
-0.0013628766,
0.5225403905,
-0.1736549437,
0.0585033521,
-0.0122526838,
0.5343334079,
0.2366018742,
-0.0489808917,
0.3000045419,
0.2668566704,
-0.9474204779,
-0.1100753695,
-0.0083757313,
0.2475089282,
0.2728217244,
0.2761978507,
0.3522851169,
0.0193633828,
-0.1225333959,
0.3557271659,
-0.2732549906,
-0.4068531096,
-0.2468221933,
-0.2106702775,
0.1666666865,
0.0546303652,
0.3976691961,
-0.1997097582,
0.3980082273,
-0.3279974461,
0.2386915535,
0.0472451523,
-0.5306286216,
-0.255158186,
0.6390094757,
0.2806884944,
0.0594413653,
0.6671749949,
-0.161167413,
-0.8002026677,
0.6357877254,
0.2807968557,
1.0268697739,
-0.7974494696,
0.3216803074,
0.6442683935,
0.1794074327,
-0.3506682813,
-0.220380798,
-0.1214297488,
-0.4470706582,
-0.1270549744,
-0.2099284083,
-0.3253386319,
-0.0750966817,
-0.7441173792,
0.6865706444,
-0.5900320411,
-0.0561143793,
-0.0973402262,
-0.0624991208,
-0.1932610422,
0.3256112039,
0.6304656267,
0.3190172911,
-0.3514772356,
1.0020303726,
0.2427774966,
-0.5490279794,
-1.3523631096,
0.201390326,
0.1043967307,
-0.8022637963,
0.8716682196,
0.2610396445,
-0.1844561696,
-0.3536818027,
-0.2350622416,
-0.6828249693,
1.0271475315,
0.4659046233,
-0.9959636331,
-0.0919157639,
0.5679647923,
0.4667755365,
0.0322303958,
0.421815902,
0.439550966,
0.4160328507,
0.3886699677,
-1.1396051645,
-0.0175548587,
0.0239095073,
0.1528941095,
-0.1281811893,
-0.7583004832,
1.0250884295,
0.0478211232,
-0.8456110954,
0.1536926478,
0.7682798505,
0.085578151,
0.1408316195,
0.6422742605,
0.3160819709,
1.1891363859,
-0.0443815924,
0.2010816336,
-0.2525646091,
0.4066191316,
1.3273175955,
-0.2993654609,
0.6874158978,
0.411119163,
0.0250989087,
0.5555699468,
0.944735527,
0.0960829332,
0.6565856338,
0.4428528249,
-0.2599229813,
-0.1872870326,
0.1451925337,
-0.3958007395,
0.5624529719,
0.1237738878,
-0.2433060557,
-0.1222585738,
0.0012563213,
-0.2733761966,
0.2530602813,
-0.3080863655,
0.8568338156,
0.0324347205,
-0.4997646809,
0.6021242738,
-0.0424316786,
0.6643874645,
-0.47367993,
-0.4596611261,
-0.1259971112,
0.262732327,
-0.4662823379,
-0.6753873825,
0.1572633386,
-0.4283737838,
-0.3317484856,
0.1631460339,
0.8427097201,
-1.0950474739,
-0.4808010459,
0.5744131804,
-0.2951976657,
0.2581959963,
-0.2415161878,
-0.5902176499,
0.0061196852,
0.0447076671,
0.4068102241,
0.0264855288,
0.8633935452,
0.1635053307,
0.2298106402,
0.393883884,
0.2697230279,
0.2652041316,
0.4104728103,
0.6201142669,
-0.7034244537,
-0.8153902292,
-0.9043892026,
0.4349305034,
-0.0612250231,
-0.0848108977,
0.6442478895,
0.1690440923,
0.6700996757,
-0.0548391975,
0.8698188663,
0.2394056618,
0.5048522353,
-0.5281940699,
1.2731273174,
-0.5445511341,
0.1691489369,
-0.3523789644,
-0.8213157654,
-0.2880364358,
0.4366941452,
0.2133617103,
-0.186577037,
0.8560626507,
0.7357048988,
0.1700643301,
0.0555707552,
0.6009953022,
-0.0127860075,
0.2305606008,
0.6164243817,
0.8808557391,
-0.6558687091,
0.5390855074,
-0.4392360747,
-0.3604807556,
-0.2568601966,
-0.5579372048,
-1.1226606369,
-0.7694106102,
-0.3807638586,
-0.4190335572,
-0.0019795697,
0.6523413062,
0.4678830206,
-0.6435735226,
-0.1253539324,
0.1193398163,
0.2333568484,
-0.4414470494,
-0.1369494051,
0.5170015097,
-0.3797256052,
-0.8901284933,
0.082502082,
0.3461568654,
0.1817181855,
-0.4304218888,
-0.0519695282,
0.0513114296,
0.0093347486,
0.2498987466,
0.3970020711,
-0.9717189074,
-0.4008883536,
0.1514110714,
-0.4309572875,
0.1020277739,
0.7843628526,
-0.289586544,
0.8574097753,
0.5439996123,
0.4869351983,
0.0424838625,
-0.1687345952,
0.4231694937,
-0.6931074262,
0.1968469173,
-0.0390761085,
0.3292498887,
0.3135043979,
-0.8801932335,
0.0225025788,
0.0821230635,
-0.5810497999,
-0.605420351,
-0.1041090414,
-1.1041038036,
-0.2236506194,
1.1017647982,
-0.2986419499,
-0.6917586923,
-0.1786581427,
-0.6580477953,
0.7993727922,
-0.3329471052,
0.7555219531,
1.0595896244,
0.2709701657,
-0.0480316356,
0.0854166076,
0.574562192,
0.3556925654,
-0.2356556952,
0.4227604866,
0.0886380672,
0.185759306,
0.3023283482,
0.4387628138,
-0.2929653823,
0.3485185206,
-0.0081413649,
0.3797465861,
0.1428372413,
-0.267786622,
-0.3282283843,
-0.380281508,
0.0800516829,
-0.6504656076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14779v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14779v3 | Alt-Text with Context: Improving Accessibility for Images on Twitter | 2023-05-24T06:35:26 | 2024-02-29T22:31:53 | Nikita Srivatsan, Sofia Samaniego, Omar Florez, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this work we present an approach for generating alternative text (or
alt-text) descriptions for images shared on social media, specifically Twitter.
More than just a special case of image captioning, alt-text is both more
literally descriptive and context-specific. Also critically, images posted to
Twitter are often accompanied by user-written text that despite not necessarily
describing the image may provide useful context that if properly leveraged can
be informative. We address this task with a multimodal model that conditions on
both textual information from the associated social media post as well as
visual signal from the image, and demonstrate that the utility of these two
information sources stacks. We put forward a new dataset of 371k images paired
with alt-text and tweets scraped from Twitter and evaluate on it across a
variety of automated metrics as well as human evaluation. We show that our
approach of conditioning on both tweet text and visual information
significantly outperforms prior work, by more than 2x on BLEU@4. | [
-0.1542485207,
-0.5614319444,
0.760841608,
0.3281582296,
-0.7438738942,
0.0347087607,
-0.3293564022,
-0.8988075852,
0.3374915421,
0.280305624,
-0.4606922567,
-0.4321897328,
-0.6263669729,
0.185115099,
-0.3592454791,
0.812698245,
-0.2659724057,
-0.157621786,
-0.0940393806,
-0.5159608722,
-0.3856092393,
-0.0591637045,
-0.744607687,
0.275162518,
0.7888928056,
0.3292579055,
1.0476020575,
0.5522191525,
0.8281203508,
0.2520490289,
0.3236419559,
0.0228411499,
-0.3393567801,
0.0688708797,
-0.4153194129,
0.0127369324,
0.0190674365,
-0.2155448198,
0.7024151683,
0.3319178224,
0.4438316524,
0.0539017245,
-0.137551412,
0.406555593,
-0.7044879198,
0.074367106,
-0.6686307192,
-0.1201737225,
-0.0622823499,
-0.6135194898,
-0.2177466452,
-0.1925966591,
0.086979948,
-0.9256939292,
0.295139879,
0.2700688541,
1.0422549248,
0.1598747969,
-0.5881386399,
-0.287566185,
-0.6218932867,
0.7112022638,
-0.2264155298,
0.4909586608,
0.4552916884,
0.5659009218,
0.5529958606,
-0.8371625543,
-0.5137897134,
-0.135281533,
-0.3534453809,
0.1104423478,
-0.216503948,
0.0770796239,
0.1873843968,
0.2576378584,
0.0191857126,
-0.1845769882,
-0.4673953354,
-0.3636656702,
0.3570890427,
-0.1877043098,
0.6434308887,
-0.5340729356,
-0.5124028325,
-0.1354119182,
-0.5608021021,
-0.0170029122,
0.1340692937,
0.2549651563,
-0.1703426838,
0.7419991493,
-0.1114942506,
0.407255441,
-0.353612572,
0.1448694766,
0.2758257389,
-0.6259922385,
0.0216007698,
-0.4218617678,
0.5466856956,
1.0213513374,
-0.0128195891,
-0.4919719994,
-0.3021814227,
-0.1160932109,
0.2757158875,
-0.8259637356,
-0.0333391204,
-0.0802182257,
-0.8509298563,
-0.0916784555,
0.1496787518,
-0.6235541701,
-0.7245787382,
-0.2911598682,
0.6309579015,
-0.587767601,
-0.0924024507,
-0.3344534338,
-0.7348297238,
0.113049522,
0.5790733695,
-0.3439279497,
-0.0041928808,
-0.0425130837,
1.0661430359,
0.0002899186,
-0.083781682,
-0.4710023403,
0.5487197638,
-0.1446017325,
0.7396301627,
-0.6236479878,
-0.0894080028,
0.240197584,
0.2873990536,
0.1226419359,
0.0411129482,
0.907735765,
-0.5890552998,
-0.1170331612,
-0.5460302234,
-0.1189687103,
-0.1627663374,
0.0256635174,
-1.2601715326,
0.5471931696,
0.1753750741,
-1.2138330936,
0.6016024351,
-0.9957331419,
-0.6711947322,
0.2088036984,
-0.1178726777,
-0.2176696062,
0.3455514312,
0.4338112175,
0.3544367254,
0.0554715171,
-0.2688934803,
-0.3970146775,
-0.3963119984,
0.3199283481,
-0.2265757024,
0.4410533011,
0.2182963043,
-0.1958715171,
0.0037318566,
-0.3353271484,
-0.0960145444,
0.130972743,
-0.2114694715,
-0.7226603627,
0.0150276404,
0.6318466067,
0.1525682211,
0.2973737419,
-0.4783926308,
-0.151947096,
0.1528942436,
0.6128804088,
0.695607543,
0.1194735318,
0.6182802916,
-0.2739155293,
0.4157337546,
-0.1410424411,
0.2618126571,
-0.5305517316,
-0.2332834899,
-0.4404719174,
-0.3153469861,
0.240395993,
0.2151683867,
-1.4991939068,
-0.099110283,
-0.3882766962,
0.1218132377,
-0.7269823551,
0.194647193,
0.3689787388,
0.4272595048,
0.5134003162,
-0.039980866,
-0.66812253,
-1.2960213423,
-0.5139070749,
-0.0797323883,
-0.0815946981,
0.5906953812,
0.4417929947,
-0.3163111508,
0.5861830115,
-0.1883717328,
-0.2155536711,
-0.1785717309,
0.1706616729,
-0.2936695516,
0.1747983247,
0.7496310472,
-1.1836928129,
-0.5856423378,
0.0020206771,
-0.4596105218,
-0.0700055584,
-0.1309990585,
-0.3786782622,
0.3432261348,
0.4644467533,
-0.3391231894,
0.6866652369,
0.310215205,
-0.2688260972,
0.092922397,
0.0498870462,
0.6878395081,
-1.0735874176,
0.0781190321,
0.3084851801,
-0.4448144138,
-0.4071051776,
0.132898733,
0.2224406153,
0.0060286489,
-0.3947448134,
0.8079140186,
-0.6933453083,
0.1189591438,
-0.2758310139,
0.1813282669,
0.0994524285,
0.188241303,
0.3010635972,
0.5433787704,
0.6132726073,
-0.0875578597,
0.2302172482,
-0.0465326421,
-0.3784037232,
0.7271057963,
-0.6242117882,
0.0904395431,
-0.4704505801,
0.5034806728,
-1.4395582676,
-0.549146235,
0.3079553843,
-0.4255280197,
0.0611118451,
-0.0517987981,
-0.8299587965,
-0.4468429685,
-0.6465389729,
0.7010397911,
0.3414563835,
-0.6366823316,
0.6646695733,
0.214361459,
0.0396764092,
-0.4359895289,
-0.7893892527,
0.4873777628,
-0.2915070057,
-0.6307316422,
0.5716956854,
0.0828649849,
-0.042348057,
0.4969117045,
-0.0537900701,
-0.3242478967,
-0.1040545925,
0.2356364876,
0.1056470126,
0.2581111193,
0.5436692834,
0.2283678651,
0.3490079939,
-0.3540835083,
-0.0779147968,
0.0496360324,
-0.0352704637,
-0.1499726921,
-0.7166181207,
0.6780030131,
0.1608405411,
0.2502057254,
0.7661944628,
1.0538252592,
-0.5330688357,
0.2613906264,
-0.4459365308,
-0.1028556898,
-0.4255999327,
0.1759463996,
-0.1674188226,
-0.7344048619,
0.3734337091,
0.154685989,
0.165373385,
0.3901204467,
0.2302376479,
-0.3723085821,
1.0174974203,
0.869079411,
0.3069976866,
0.8671473265,
0.0369531624,
0.2658934891,
-0.6980050206,
-0.034772709,
-0.2871872783,
-0.5279445648,
-0.5591150522,
-0.6474567652,
0.2220403999,
-0.0000629104,
0.169946,
0.4884169996,
-0.4806871414,
0.5960731506,
0.5466806293,
0.6268795133,
0.3490776718,
0.0953710601,
0.2982675731,
-0.103843458,
-0.4977729321,
-0.6420311332,
1.0567891598,
0.3055506349,
0.8587712049,
0.0993978381,
0.5846500397,
0.5724986792,
0.749774754,
-0.6021178365,
0.2574999928,
-0.1670107245,
-0.772970438,
-0.234363988,
-0.4702824056,
-0.8451231718,
0.0080176024,
-0.2278912663,
-0.6849234104,
-0.1314208061,
0.4752675593,
-0.3410045207,
0.1550878882,
-1.1279209852,
0.6096487641,
-0.2867218256,
-0.3721372783,
-0.0164395161,
-0.9173742533,
0.3262707591,
0.2026732564,
0.6463035941,
0.0211200118,
-0.6465494037,
0.6283650994,
-0.0113609489,
0.9791010618,
-0.1306075007,
0.2377264798,
0.2645095587,
-0.3120422959,
0.0675386861,
0.1525083929,
0.1575434357,
-0.1284388453,
0.0867675096,
-0.5343497396,
-0.5654367805,
0.6753115654,
-0.6960287094,
-0.3420153558,
0.0800329819,
-0.6959032416,
-0.1245710775,
0.2806309462,
0.4689661562,
0.5846722126,
-0.2145341337,
0.606725812,
0.2526718378,
-0.4215768278,
0.7890765071,
-0.0479339622,
-0.0800699517,
-0.643029511,
0.7138474584,
0.0515868366,
0.0481596813,
0.7427743077,
0.125382781,
-0.7405358553,
-0.2069734782,
-0.3800005615,
0.043946933,
-1.0995694399,
-0.4577608407,
-0.5989381075,
0.0685400069,
-0.5127565265,
-0.4114395082,
0.2590289116,
-0.8242630959,
-0.2000901103,
-0.2122854739,
0.5206906199,
0.5491303802,
-0.1447592378,
0.6467927098,
-0.4677608013,
0.6522356272,
0.2149377316,
0.4564287961,
0.034991961,
-0.3536212742,
-0.3982014656,
0.0856584832,
-0.3223971725,
-1.0682636499,
0.037448924,
0.3807797134,
0.5607395172,
0.4349620342,
0.340567559,
0.5045740604,
-0.4535865486,
0.6552157998,
0.566041708,
-0.8607075214,
0.5525695086,
-0.3644702137,
0.3208864927,
0.6234067678,
0.4118065536,
-0.5339951515,
-0.6199569106,
-0.5776994228,
-1.0277291536,
0.4724166393,
0.6827768087,
0.6825584769,
-0.0029317194,
0.2775556147,
0.0200865716,
0.3193692565,
-1.220729351,
0.024848571,
-0.587040782,
-0.2441755831,
0.0296213292,
-0.220233202,
-0.5423810482,
-0.305901438,
0.2015547454,
-0.1244065315,
0.308665365,
0.2491474599,
-0.5586409569,
-0.062210314,
0.1027465463,
0.3016764522,
0.7901458144,
-0.1599509269,
0.6282419562,
-0.0787132084,
-0.021558132,
-0.3137785196,
0.1802626103,
0.0333853327,
0.2521188557,
0.6274529099,
0.9103249907,
0.1613381952,
-0.5897896886,
0.5288752913,
-0.2051287591,
-0.0886261612,
0.0519380756,
-0.3242128193,
0.0542454869,
0.1305497885,
0.6411911249,
0.0526827425,
0.5209752917,
-0.7754747868,
0.1848836541,
0.4490533471,
-0.4910743535,
-0.3577893972,
0.6373775005,
0.3496521413,
-0.3475969732,
0.1591859013,
-0.0856826156,
-0.5068685412,
0.470829308,
0.36601457,
1.0192360878,
0.1547564566,
0.3414756656,
0.1938352734,
0.5706267357,
0.2709548473,
0.2110999823,
-0.3377519846,
-0.5227040648,
-0.2321985662,
-0.3257995844,
-0.1768012643,
-0.0187418144,
-0.4272231758,
0.1626089811,
-0.4093162715,
-0.5775132775,
0.1471712887,
-0.3322707117,
-0.9246917963,
0.2464340925,
-0.0009646886,
0.8243864179,
-1.0684108734,
0.3330672085,
0.969807446,
-0.5643730164,
-0.3865619302,
0.3628061116,
-0.4487320483,
-0.7947688699,
0.3692500591,
0.4995148778,
-0.0287698582,
-0.2412636131,
-0.9900185466,
-0.5682629347,
1.1131253242,
0.2954969108,
-0.0138164628,
0.0056734835,
-0.1386437416,
0.6903990507,
-0.2737401724,
0.2196523845,
0.0746249929,
0.7472552061,
0.3381485045,
-0.597258985,
0.3796470165,
-0.352356106,
0.4484798014,
-0.0083906874,
-0.5274240971,
0.3327473998,
-0.3448958695,
-0.6156834364,
0.1466241181,
0.4896047413,
-0.0626179352,
0.4918687642,
0.757555604,
0.3366313279,
0.3015652597,
-0.0688822865,
1.3209037781,
-0.072225064,
0.1642919928,
1.035856843,
0.2723776698,
0.5902087688,
0.854875803,
0.3696577847,
0.2802610099,
0.6945025325,
0.3280059695,
0.7566304803,
-0.0935054347,
-0.2168988585,
-0.267832309,
-0.558719933,
-0.2444095761,
-0.1729276478,
0.1450656205,
-0.7597724795,
-0.4213730991,
0.0993480608,
-0.2318773121,
0.1581927538,
-0.3515127003,
0.5958451033,
0.0588402934,
-0.4998696446,
0.2305295914,
0.0615079179,
0.3720168173,
0.0163780507,
0.0041951686,
0.033844471,
-0.2041669041,
-0.2792581618,
-1.0328302383,
0.5672814846,
-0.1300495714,
-0.1837070584,
-0.4667259753,
0.8360366225,
-0.3788998127,
-0.7135908604,
0.2459395826,
0.19911322,
-0.0732182041,
-0.0652792305,
-0.6723169088,
0.1480717957,
-0.2627003193,
-0.013274109,
-0.2231224328,
0.7902087569,
-0.3053076565,
0.3949467838,
0.298404634,
-0.4037861824,
0.1170707345,
0.3863113821,
0.9783630371,
-0.441621244,
-0.4601243734,
-0.7462855577,
0.5053691864,
-0.4878814518,
-0.1049738824,
0.6489067078,
0.3644701242,
0.4887242615,
-0.1368723363,
1.1378748417,
-0.5454873443,
0.3602771461,
-0.4820394516,
0.4477493763,
-0.9548126459,
0.0326832943,
-0.4764923751,
-0.6152398586,
-0.2898522615,
0.2868246138,
-0.2256220877,
0.2693766654,
0.82377249,
0.4013934731,
-0.2637260258,
-0.3114589751,
0.2172675431,
-0.2813935578,
0.0056721652,
0.4531069398,
1.1711454391,
-0.4212537408,
0.8876874447,
-0.2825123966,
-0.3722754419,
-0.2914252281,
-1.0498174429,
-1.0224374533,
-0.9100678563,
-0.227648437,
-0.5162680149,
0.076503396,
0.4982864559,
0.7328795195,
-0.4212729037,
0.1274111569,
0.138591677,
0.5164315701,
-0.00637906,
-0.2144351155,
0.5003858805,
-0.2509455383,
-0.6854845285,
-0.4360015392,
0.3311853707,
0.1208988726,
0.1216421276,
0.0200049523,
-0.1107936576,
0.2676909566,
0.773178041,
-0.0764292926,
-0.5290487409,
-0.6656963825,
0.0898035169,
-0.1137473136,
0.179142043,
0.8681861162,
-0.200024277,
0.4703704715,
0.6852277517,
0.5229111314,
0.2584505975,
0.4539989233,
0.4454239011,
-0.923083663,
0.1549755484,
0.1862327605,
0.441853404,
0.6765196323,
-0.4063304663,
0.3871695995,
0.1953841597,
-0.0681186542,
-0.7018544674,
0.2374071479,
-1.1477404833,
-0.3427236676,
1.3474767208,
0.0193187725,
-0.283611834,
-0.0124414703,
-0.3665263653,
0.2458846122,
-0.7150037885,
1.0685964823,
0.7494692802,
0.1636567712,
-0.581361115,
-0.4844651818,
0.4810786247,
-0.0668967292,
-0.7392510772,
-0.1790972948,
0.6076261997,
0.1877192408,
0.1225107983,
0.8879585266,
0.0103734611,
0.3842818141,
-0.3619660437,
-0.1058630347,
0.1949733794,
-0.424580127,
0.1085020229,
-0.1007091254,
-0.1543590575,
-0.5464153886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14775v1 | Measuring the Knowledge Acquisition-Utilization Gap in Pretrained Language Models | 2023-05-24T06:26:11 | 2023-05-24T06:26:11 | Amirhossein Kazemnejad, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Prasanna Parthasarathi, Sarath Chandar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While pre-trained language models (PLMs) have shown evidence of acquiring
vast amounts of knowledge, it remains unclear how much of this parametric
knowledge is actually usable in performing downstream tasks. We propose a
systematic framework to measure parametric knowledge utilization in PLMs. Our
framework first extracts knowledge from a PLM's parameters and subsequently
constructs a downstream task around this extracted knowledge. Performance on
this task thus depends exclusively on utilizing the model's possessed
knowledge, avoiding confounding factors like insufficient signal. As an
instantiation, we study factual knowledge of PLMs and measure utilization
across 125M to 13B parameter PLMs. We observe that: (1) PLMs exhibit two gaps -
in acquired vs. utilized knowledge, (2) they show limited robustness in
utilizing knowledge under distribution shifts, and (3) larger models close the
acquired knowledge gap but the utilized knowledge gap remains. Overall, our
study provides insights into PLMs' capabilities beyond their acquired
knowledge. | [
-0.5189415812,
-0.447802484,
0.8264615536,
0.0704438537,
-0.25222224,
0.0009747256,
-0.1812077165,
-0.2195306718,
-0.2279918343,
0.6503126621,
-0.3231712282,
-0.3916357458,
-0.7551100254,
-0.1673089862,
-0.3788686991,
0.780621767,
-0.0022411726,
-0.1302196681,
-0.5008111,
-0.0656055361,
-0.3758990467,
-0.3234410584,
-0.2260060161,
-0.1816055179,
0.3569407463,
0.5024321079,
0.5779591799,
0.5683730245,
0.3749951422,
0.3020178974,
0.2113410681,
-0.0204687156,
-0.260938108,
-0.0685995817,
0.0010151331,
-0.4602932632,
-0.5226187706,
0.1873850524,
1.0310356617,
1.2467906475,
-0.299115479,
0.339504838,
0.3999732733,
0.3932563066,
-0.8920118809,
0.1328510642,
-0.6726100445,
-0.1077002212,
-0.5526300073,
-0.1580114067,
-0.165521577,
-0.2589654624,
0.6408523321,
-0.8968989253,
0.0508793667,
-0.3633969128,
0.8006833196,
0.2041785419,
-0.4925402403,
-0.3264134824,
-0.724940002,
0.801966548,
-0.7697626352,
0.7358592749,
0.7776207924,
0.2853113115,
0.0582138337,
-1.0115560293,
-0.4919908941,
-0.4426724017,
-0.1778120697,
-0.0155180385,
0.1169269383,
0.0926643312,
0.2098538429,
0.4035156369,
-0.3795975447,
-0.0836415738,
-0.5111227632,
-0.1231077313,
0.3540801704,
0.0736700818,
0.502065599,
0.1977464408,
-0.5654613972,
0.1805796027,
-0.886849463,
0.1294921488,
0.3652379215,
0.0040924605,
-0.1872772723,
0.4536865652,
0.0255311243,
1.1322393417,
-0.4204108715,
-0.2228104174,
0.1365113556,
-0.5600767136,
-0.2704276741,
-0.5314223766,
0.5256304741,
-0.2372925282,
0.3080850244,
-0.3004193008,
-0.2024873197,
-0.4914695621,
0.2775737345,
-0.3848648667,
-0.2582046092,
-0.2895179391,
-0.2231085449,
0.2809848785,
0.1235450134,
-0.54716748,
-0.4457646906,
-0.1891231984,
0.3985590935,
-0.4459319115,
-0.6861871481,
0.1451651305,
-0.2845916152,
0.2431625724,
-0.1403070539,
-0.7258736491,
0.2096266001,
0.4146785438,
0.8990626931,
-0.0205124822,
-0.5932085514,
-0.0795302242,
0.1836363077,
-0.2753211558,
0.6635902524,
-0.3274692297,
-0.3650561273,
0.0974565595,
-0.3309880197,
-0.5615497828,
-0.6870370507,
0.3382695019,
-0.7237530351,
0.0533815585,
-0.3092770875,
-0.7831895351,
-0.0277488995,
0.1104228124,
-0.5753035545,
0.8038063645,
0.5645493269,
-0.7075883746,
0.6791551113,
-0.5244934559,
-0.3002396226,
0.322372973,
-0.0682751536,
-0.2557075322,
0.1687417477,
-0.1551856399,
0.3293321729,
-0.2213929594,
0.2859811485,
-0.3910016418,
-0.1824892312,
0.5049598813,
-0.1783592701,
0.8567506075,
0.2878374159,
-0.0615143217,
-0.2263723761,
-0.9109762907,
-0.0958376974,
-0.2459067255,
-0.4926124811,
-0.601513207,
0.1713692695,
-0.5230607986,
0.4027276635,
0.4461306632,
-0.4087836146,
-0.2937948108,
-0.5676106215,
0.3006998599,
0.4210639894,
0.086437352,
0.718352139,
-0.2029791474,
0.68115592,
0.1042327881,
0.153396368,
0.0029815575,
-0.0484260693,
-1.1229994297,
-0.1195848137,
0.3705609739,
0.154183358,
-0.6566964388,
0.5935625434,
-0.0857922658,
-0.3545389175,
-0.2627677023,
0.4549770355,
0.2129364014,
0.5952094197,
0.2782819867,
-0.185426563,
-0.3000275791,
-0.7157760262,
-0.3990629911,
-0.3370637894,
-0.2085432708,
0.2241446674,
0.1477303058,
-0.0862245858,
0.9378300905,
-0.2843189538,
-0.1121650115,
-0.4534273446,
0.3613975346,
-0.0573080666,
0.5066238642,
0.3820380867,
-0.4597633183,
-0.36325109,
-0.1939274222,
-0.7439590693,
-0.3874388635,
-0.0408722609,
-0.1964473128,
0.0272046812,
0.5686479807,
-0.5162452459,
0.179922685,
0.7250105739,
-0.4134416282,
0.4982930124,
-0.2731475234,
-0.2965717912,
-0.6552721262,
0.1747467667,
-0.1457952261,
-0.1802395731,
-0.8400732279,
-0.1910457015,
0.1692431271,
-0.0798919573,
-0.2642329633,
0.4467739165,
-0.8126766682,
-0.3173868954,
-0.2385840416,
0.1998915672,
-0.0955629498,
0.2396028936,
0.2187725157,
0.7363376021,
0.5542245507,
-0.9276775122,
-0.25723961,
-0.0911153406,
-0.7737078071,
0.3034443855,
-0.5059505105,
-0.0027597744,
0.1554785371,
-0.1650330126,
-1.0282058716,
-0.1958579272,
0.0484665409,
-0.2976664305,
0.1186690107,
-0.0572154038,
-0.2830568552,
-0.0984446928,
0.2268342227,
0.4635210335,
0.5642098188,
-0.1120785847,
0.6125463843,
0.5489060283,
-0.4449214339,
-0.4367140532,
-0.3604868948,
-0.2959369421,
-0.3073143065,
-0.6234251261,
0.0290763583,
0.338573724,
-0.0616088845,
-0.1743832976,
-0.3266080022,
-0.4912704825,
0.2984710038,
0.039109081,
0.0177191943,
-0.2928384244,
0.2856545746,
-0.0227495357,
-0.0021994046,
0.4603725076,
-0.4528228939,
0.5975486636,
0.1312157959,
-0.5496895909,
-0.2038114667,
-0.054052677,
0.6864129901,
-0.4098088145,
0.9236268997,
0.3880136013,
-0.2840015292,
-0.2207599282,
-0.6724892259,
-0.0466867015,
-0.4368182123,
0.2920897901,
-0.3505843878,
-0.6414783001,
0.5144962668,
-0.2541723251,
-0.0863346606,
0.3036587834,
0.077188313,
-0.1851386428,
0.831774056,
0.8706616163,
0.4670393467,
0.6612064838,
-0.4357218742,
0.15114218,
-0.7058342099,
-0.2586793005,
-0.4196890891,
0.0642794445,
-0.0949277207,
-0.5174644589,
0.2999208868,
0.7192302346,
-0.4300680459,
0.1560689211,
0.3240531981,
0.2588064969,
0.5326665044,
0.0363150053,
0.2945291698,
-0.2566052973,
0.0403044336,
-0.0583083518,
-0.8977536559,
-0.4836724102,
1.2448670864,
0.544726491,
0.3169721067,
-0.1178037822,
0.5385921001,
-0.0518403463,
0.3051710427,
-0.341167897,
0.4859899879,
-0.0634861141,
-0.550234139,
-0.4112197161,
-0.5456658602,
-0.6809979081,
0.0253523923,
0.201248616,
-0.4122614861,
0.3303012848,
0.3883289099,
-0.4675348699,
0.1275523603,
-0.8336206675,
1.0756651163,
-0.4942988455,
-0.0712947473,
-0.1644667834,
-0.6591305733,
0.3511373997,
-0.4181375206,
0.2206226736,
-0.1930529028,
-0.2042645067,
0.934104681,
-0.6375575066,
0.7151397467,
-0.6560929418,
-0.0421668142,
0.4407634437,
-0.1086617783,
0.2954401076,
0.0211974159,
0.0769238845,
0.2017423064,
0.0956187919,
-0.7064369917,
-0.650539279,
0.129492715,
-0.7649387121,
-0.5809012651,
-0.3694097102,
-0.5967863202,
-0.7994835973,
0.2077796757,
0.2960143983,
0.1596042663,
-0.3277137578,
0.2236581147,
0.5401223898,
-0.3169880807,
0.28883183,
0.9298340082,
0.0549148656,
0.0220098272,
0.8424839973,
0.3408493698,
0.656550467,
0.1823019832,
0.2451938391,
-0.7293333411,
-0.8941471577,
-0.150658682,
0.1184615567,
-0.4519912004,
-0.0534737334,
-0.542101562,
-0.3678808808,
-0.381316483,
0.1611976027,
-0.2661339045,
-0.1277413517,
-0.2545645833,
-0.0865189135,
-0.0603249259,
0.6657767892,
-0.1469571292,
0.7979194522,
-0.8922317624,
0.0546201356,
0.5486850142,
0.4766588807,
-0.0973370448,
-0.7695652843,
-0.5175434947,
0.1962646395,
-0.1533110887,
-1.0097881556,
0.4547421336,
0.2611490786,
0.9172433019,
0.5761991143,
-0.079065688,
0.656544745,
-0.0690543577,
0.8628510237,
0.1017945707,
-1.1229872704,
0.3286803365,
-0.4251048267,
0.2373933047,
0.4932361543,
0.5039042234,
-0.2104002535,
-0.5415025949,
-0.6995667815,
-0.7624291182,
0.8558660746,
0.0896626338,
0.1205717027,
0.2097504288,
0.1442094147,
0.1423278749,
0.4906716049,
-0.751670301,
0.0141628496,
-0.1394376308,
-0.112917468,
-0.2209009826,
-0.3883866072,
0.1257118583,
-0.3582027853,
0.4878564775,
0.2528512478,
0.0401633419,
-0.2729288638,
-0.7850983143,
0.2240894586,
0.274148494,
0.4292060137,
1.4816820621,
-0.2002483308,
0.2896625996,
0.1080080569,
-0.4675459266,
0.036618229,
0.2032122612,
-0.0228794664,
-0.0734051391,
0.2751337886,
0.8912941217,
0.1786457896,
-0.7811861634,
0.5772807002,
0.3169109225,
-0.0761377737,
-0.3640621006,
-0.0118439021,
0.1730003208,
0.1783883423,
0.1016980559,
-0.0261393059,
-0.1257717758,
-0.3311224878,
0.3347516358,
0.3059941232,
-0.2651207149,
-0.4488407969,
0.3053774536,
0.3995812535,
-0.0719989315,
0.6332236528,
-0.0353911668,
-0.3006675243,
0.4566911161,
0.6096442342,
0.5990814567,
-0.2543407083,
0.4546124041,
0.0323515423,
0.1682606786,
-0.0207203515,
0.1753158867,
-0.37189731,
-0.9682850838,
-0.2889362574,
-0.7528063059,
0.0288697947,
0.6055333614,
-0.7520469427,
0.1526510864,
-0.3413825333,
-0.1182315648,
-0.1604321301,
-0.1780735552,
-0.9029151797,
0.1225416362,
-0.097454831,
0.9048577547,
-1.0756003857,
0.9840478301,
0.7111445069,
-0.6154879928,
-0.9033057094,
0.147905305,
-0.4379837215,
-1.0632680655,
0.7558772564,
-0.1742230207,
0.0028600972,
0.1994567364,
-0.1099976227,
-0.8638666868,
0.9266638756,
0.5087608695,
-0.3729935288,
-0.0348927267,
0.5129552484,
0.5764357448,
-0.2836180925,
0.0651577264,
1.0845036507,
0.2820487022,
-0.2337207049,
-0.7196038961,
-0.3242729902,
-0.0057193786,
0.0669725463,
0.3604235649,
-0.1495254189,
1.0226229429,
0.1142919064,
-0.5567820072,
-0.0644168034,
0.5163253546,
0.2588554323,
0.3741860986,
0.8172978759,
0.5779643655,
0.6737509966,
0.0900358111,
0.808552444,
-0.4157868922,
0.133333236,
0.9174950719,
-0.1682748348,
0.7114208341,
0.5468122959,
-0.279201746,
0.4375571907,
0.4214480519,
0.4745386541,
0.470498383,
0.2241041809,
-0.4801869988,
-0.5198113322,
-0.0013241275,
-0.3859322071,
0.3920097053,
0.59364748,
-0.5210284591,
-0.2545407116,
0.1074510515,
-0.1104712784,
0.0501920432,
-0.252178967,
0.9330833554,
0.2932291031,
-0.9128860831,
0.648422718,
-0.1541410685,
0.2692527473,
-0.9011638761,
0.268075794,
-0.3218888044,
0.1339485198,
-0.007050938,
-0.7771984935,
0.3932624161,
0.0339229219,
-0.1009919345,
-0.3871194124,
0.9118656516,
-0.6847198009,
-0.3497251272,
0.312486887,
1.0924328566,
0.1816210002,
-0.171944052,
-0.271056205,
-0.2605412304,
-0.1346819252,
-0.0107245045,
0.4443382621,
0.4214251041,
0.1313534975,
0.4349998236,
0.3080877364,
0.4989693463,
0.700045228,
0.2508640587,
0.5574533343,
-0.3694177866,
-0.5828684568,
-0.7097585797,
0.6295241714,
-0.1215953231,
-0.4417793155,
0.8509485126,
0.3469213247,
1.0050922632,
-0.0570779368,
1.0506144762,
-0.041510921,
0.6831660867,
-0.5390110016,
0.7888863683,
-0.5930182338,
0.4867186248,
0.0310685877,
-0.8158323169,
0.097569339,
0.5225531459,
-0.6917462349,
-0.0129522001,
0.4838771224,
0.648937583,
-0.2683025897,
-0.064538233,
0.3622535467,
-0.1235914603,
-0.1680045724,
0.5445739627,
1.4257428646,
-0.0772803873,
0.6086606383,
-0.3211025596,
-0.3134016991,
0.126437664,
-0.6730549335,
-0.7715170383,
-0.7562205791,
-0.1434633881,
-0.0054352107,
0.0889478847,
0.3228834867,
0.7597543597,
-0.6977994442,
-0.6952055693,
-0.6181995869,
0.0402803458,
-0.1860568821,
-0.1607642025,
0.1827632636,
-0.9412735105,
-0.3362585306,
0.3104479313,
0.0468588285,
0.1942063421,
-0.3519184887,
-0.216238156,
-0.227453202,
-0.0543134436,
0.4296582043,
0.556872189,
-0.3938755095,
0.0471797772,
0.1341596544,
0.2010909468,
-0.1791560501,
1.3878815174,
-0.4688475132,
0.4242399633,
0.817477107,
0.7475816607,
0.4021322727,
0.1777185053,
1.0359882116,
-1.2499212027,
0.2195907384,
0.2178883404,
0.3220827281,
0.3294933736,
0.1288688034,
0.0418907516,
0.3366907537,
-0.4979374111,
-0.9456868768,
0.318626523,
-0.4609569609,
-0.2982628942,
1.1118364334,
-0.5110503435,
0.4842103124,
-0.5210491419,
0.4137902558,
0.4367503226,
0.0327852741,
0.4597662985,
0.7614741921,
-0.1471799463,
-0.2352187485,
-0.6970938444,
0.7783471942,
0.5032356381,
-0.747805953,
-0.0053071179,
0.3325151503,
0.547016263,
0.0487479791,
0.917180717,
-0.1516038626,
0.0365425013,
0.0280465726,
-0.3491438329,
-0.0892027393,
-0.5655763149,
-0.3181690276,
0.1988528073,
0.3838786483,
-0.4701646268
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.