id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15718v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15718v1 | Towards Higher Pareto Frontier in Multilingual Machine Translation | 2023-05-25T05:01:33 | 2023-05-25T05:01:33 | Yichong Huang, Xiaocheng Feng, Xinwei Geng, Baohang Li, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual neural machine translation has witnessed remarkable progress in
recent years. However, the long-tailed distribution of multilingual corpora
poses a challenge of Pareto optimization, i.e., optimizing for some languages
may come at the cost of degrading the performance of others. Existing balancing
training strategies are equivalent to a series of Pareto optimal solutions,
which trade off on a Pareto frontier. In this work, we propose a new training
framework, Pareto Mutual Distillation (Pareto-MD), towards pushing the Pareto
frontier outwards rather than making trade-offs. Specifically, Pareto-MD
collaboratively trains two Pareto optimal solutions that favor different
languages and allows them to learn from the strengths of each other via
knowledge distillation. Furthermore, we introduce a novel strategy to enable
stronger communication between Pareto optimal solutions and broaden the
applicability of our approach. Experimental results on the widely-used WMT and
TED datasets show that our method significantly pushes the Pareto frontier and
outperforms baselines by up to +2.46 BLEU. | [
-0.6140598655,
-0.4760794044,
0.6023851037,
0.4480414689,
-0.3638890982,
0.3142109513,
-0.6853330731,
-0.1099319309,
0.195083186,
0.2715221345,
-0.4531558156,
-0.1693699956,
-1.0230306387,
0.2140162736,
0.1337248683,
0.9981528521,
0.030024074,
0.2292342186,
-0.1927771717,
-0.5733468533,
-0.6747528315,
-0.7268174291,
-0.5648543835,
-0.7074775696,
0.9533875585,
0.2703331113,
0.6205049157,
0.7697390318,
0.5922181606,
0.3420375884,
-0.2205020934,
0.2346946597,
-0.4127222598,
-0.0674296319,
-0.132359162,
-0.6082572937,
-0.4105234742,
-0.1516152322,
0.3783491254,
1.0758641958,
-0.5423848629,
0.0455125608,
0.230213508,
0.8949976563,
-0.4671469033,
-0.0032901207,
-0.8150178194,
0.2044443488,
-0.2361448854,
-0.2504117787,
-0.2436957955,
-0.2856621146,
-0.0268175211,
-0.503934443,
-0.0722126812,
-0.0261739101,
0.8256390691,
0.2279746383,
-0.4501337707,
-0.1673898101,
-0.3098182976,
0.8126968145,
-0.4915823638,
0.4084959924,
0.3536600471,
0.5759046674,
0.1480271667,
-0.5560558438,
-0.4223404229,
-0.0562933534,
0.1639067829,
-0.0093335891,
-0.415454179,
-0.2284768075,
-0.1639827937,
0.3159120381,
-0.2121184915,
0.1443220824,
-0.407184571,
-0.0466352217,
0.2493587434,
-0.0575764999,
0.0335953012,
0.4353612065,
-0.8083657622,
-0.239287436,
-0.483186841,
0.0336007997,
0.3826921582,
0.2782996595,
-0.1095640287,
0.3485263288,
-0.168088451,
0.6064653993,
0.081525974,
0.0286032986,
0.6124007702,
-0.2717445195,
-0.0478087105,
-0.0190982427,
0.7900848389,
0.6447435021,
-0.042084001,
-0.2621735334,
-0.3311524689,
-0.2295086384,
-0.006857398,
-0.6066488624,
-0.0007643729,
-0.1528160125,
-0.3313093185,
-0.0568903163,
-0.3951377869,
-0.8471674323,
-0.2349884361,
-0.7280054092,
0.5197734237,
-0.3769180477,
-0.3266488314,
0.2716629803,
-0.289072156,
-0.1867298335,
-0.1153724194,
-1.0763653517,
0.1762030572,
0.6463927031,
0.9708276391,
0.0806301311,
-0.8450277448,
-0.6368788481,
0.2282035202,
-0.4084978104,
0.5077232718,
-0.0863197818,
-0.0622908436,
-0.152608633,
-0.2749415636,
-0.3019340932,
-0.6554500461,
0.508579433,
-0.426935792,
0.2265974432,
-0.7193576694,
-0.2751075625,
-0.1167256609,
0.4952113926,
-0.4279654622,
0.6449589133,
-0.1074810177,
-0.7240324616,
0.4647708237,
-0.4404241443,
-0.4475010633,
-0.1893745214,
-0.0511183031,
-0.3710539639,
0.2222221047,
0.343527317,
0.4765729904,
-0.4661902189,
0.8089900613,
-0.4158552289,
-0.0414720736,
0.167766273,
-0.5386894941,
0.8475728631,
0.4828257263,
-0.3238234222,
0.1650045067,
-0.4763222933,
-0.3467388451,
0.0486370437,
-0.3646759689,
-0.5741547942,
-0.2177577615,
-0.334500581,
0.3615023792,
0.3676182032,
-0.276076436,
-0.0299086012,
-0.2287006974,
0.6095849276,
0.7319481969,
-0.1339760423,
0.6052530408,
-0.3930710256,
0.3031307161,
0.1691371948,
0.3028979599,
0.3057705164,
-0.2478998005,
-0.7598702312,
-0.3204804063,
0.2376199365,
0.5252835751,
-1.0097185373,
0.5336546302,
-0.3739796281,
-0.2373559922,
-0.5969408751,
0.3934779465,
0.4969650805,
0.6742229462,
0.6325682402,
-0.0406573303,
-0.2127347887,
-1.0844573975,
-0.0859683827,
0.2686890662,
0.1731599867,
-0.1761008948,
0.0875562653,
-0.2316346765,
0.4561521411,
-0.5126960278,
-0.4826126099,
-0.4212225676,
0.1991895288,
0.5859926939,
0.4362749755,
0.6937178969,
-0.8365219831,
-0.660120368,
0.4140011966,
-0.559466064,
-0.072926268,
-0.078080222,
-0.3920533061,
0.0196457021,
0.4836591482,
-0.2893384099,
-0.585806489,
0.8374934793,
0.0354773365,
-0.1400211006,
-0.6283851862,
0.2118188292,
-1.4716620445,
-0.0138817569,
-0.0251106322,
-0.1735260636,
-0.5625019073,
0.1892006844,
0.1202326119,
-0.0389231667,
-0.4677639008,
0.0366375931,
-0.4590581357,
0.1674170494,
-0.1852229983,
0.1174112037,
0.0863060132,
0.6494367123,
-0.109062165,
0.6412261724,
0.5205374956,
-0.5418961048,
0.2878130674,
0.2337116897,
0.021028053,
0.7248787284,
-0.414857924,
-0.1064305156,
-0.2486627102,
-0.0960830972,
-0.521799624,
0.1206171662,
0.0685180798,
-0.3844899237,
0.4513061643,
-0.1538242698,
-0.3084395826,
-0.1375825852,
-0.2445964664,
0.0937663317,
0.5105550885,
-0.6670414209,
0.3125541806,
0.4194917679,
-0.1336906999,
-0.7741594911,
-0.8554141521,
0.3321362734,
-0.6789054871,
-0.5891054273,
0.2411415428,
0.1327058822,
-0.1440176368,
-0.2257821411,
-0.1217904836,
-0.2887206376,
0.0895602256,
-0.2984440625,
-0.0682047382,
0.0193952434,
-0.1330093443,
0.5016188622,
-0.3066602349,
-0.1107247323,
-0.5021202564,
0.8412910104,
-0.1383809,
-0.0735044181,
-0.1324552,
0.4222147763,
0.3655317426,
-0.4615191221,
0.9674944282,
0.8686897755,
-0.1627227515,
0.0874968842,
-0.408012718,
-0.0069051045,
-0.4559174478,
0.3473985493,
-0.75740242,
-0.7176291347,
0.3982956707,
-0.2579002678,
-0.0272647068,
0.4641209543,
0.7737931609,
0.0155949695,
0.8382467628,
0.6658108234,
-0.1770620644,
0.2773862779,
-0.345254004,
0.0697452351,
-0.6855675578,
-0.3038460612,
-0.513444066,
-0.445163101,
-0.3331081569,
-0.546200633,
0.6004142761,
0.3613478243,
0.0578932837,
0.6175956726,
-0.2280961424,
0.5183511972,
0.9544407129,
0.1419089884,
0.2793306112,
0.2036363333,
-0.3767419457,
-0.1756778359,
-0.9055767059,
-0.0012206977,
0.9573438168,
0.3724100888,
0.2519719005,
0.1242977902,
1.0349346399,
-0.0363915674,
0.0359621905,
-0.2893872559,
0.2278849632,
-0.2470917702,
-0.3938220739,
-0.1987724304,
-0.9286117554,
-0.795285821,
0.6951043606,
-0.1493852288,
-0.0566751249,
0.2285911292,
0.115805164,
-0.0790331662,
0.3036893904,
-0.733543396,
1.0179513693,
-0.426112026,
-0.4706798494,
-0.388138026,
-0.8871186376,
0.1626044214,
-0.2908667028,
0.5993213654,
-0.2609527409,
-0.0275216457,
0.3397753835,
-0.2693477571,
0.5515529513,
-0.3382488191,
-0.2961573303,
-0.0348447226,
-0.0885373428,
0.2902247012,
0.0775482506,
0.111349389,
0.5113753676,
-0.1879648119,
-0.6414126158,
-0.2859378755,
0.7589296699,
-0.6965453029,
-0.4136177599,
-0.3962813318,
-0.6651165485,
-0.3570043743,
0.4391890764,
0.5451446772,
0.0952620208,
0.0202348195,
0.2145721167,
0.5747253895,
-0.1584858298,
0.5181418061,
0.2410801202,
-0.0552599579,
-0.989608705,
1.0939595699,
-0.0349051729,
0.4808324873,
0.8176571131,
0.4926795959,
-0.4441171587,
-0.7472774982,
-0.7231360078,
-0.0800056458,
-0.5524400473,
-0.3340261579,
-0.6841365099,
0.3863814175,
-0.2184844613,
-0.1351536214,
-0.3612213731,
-0.3229688108,
0.0305691585,
0.0151519533,
0.0112342536,
-0.0247029774,
-0.478038758,
0.3454643786,
-1.0022135973,
0.2286978066,
0.222830832,
0.2163611799,
-0.2826374769,
-0.287176162,
-0.5445803404,
0.4483984709,
-0.4578228593,
-0.7012635469,
0.4094023108,
0.2086232454,
0.5738142133,
0.0594041348,
-0.059131369,
0.9011665583,
-0.7950127721,
0.2471850961,
0.8158350587,
-1.0524373055,
0.079492256,
-0.4716958106,
0.1756343246,
0.8720844388,
0.5619946122,
-0.7225841284,
-0.3056564927,
-0.120349817,
-0.9108285904,
0.4442441165,
0.2841565311,
0.3439718783,
0.0801669061,
-0.0479407832,
0.2881733477,
0.5355740786,
-0.7828240991,
-0.1068654209,
-0.0284551587,
-0.2600600123,
-0.3436840773,
0.0732302442,
-0.3966203034,
-0.2385385334,
0.5461530089,
-0.2021006197,
-0.0599728636,
-0.0690572932,
-0.1296191514,
0.0324348435,
0.2235318124,
0.5218054652,
0.7280341387,
-0.1149389222,
0.2643894851,
0.2479071915,
-0.0109942434,
0.1873798966,
0.2804360986,
0.1013654172,
-0.0926536694,
0.2866229117,
1.1212668419,
-0.0496882088,
-0.4140199721,
0.4641054273,
0.0334676951,
-0.6728576422,
0.2099511474,
-0.2953885496,
0.4667639732,
0.4436742961,
0.2613064945,
0.4105704427,
0.1473935694,
-0.3592668474,
0.185176596,
0.2273085415,
-0.2103083283,
-0.1206999943,
0.7360075116,
0.2425620258,
0.0611823723,
0.1730390191,
-0.3402921557,
-0.6960911155,
0.3277199566,
0.4501012862,
0.594121635,
-0.1051098779,
0.176971823,
0.0902026221,
0.4552440643,
-0.2227002978,
0.1029145271,
-0.0364535488,
-0.443854332,
-0.4729400575,
-0.6448899508,
-0.2797966897,
-0.2447796464,
-0.5940273404,
0.2262855917,
0.026102582,
-0.2582950592,
-0.0817511529,
-0.1557885259,
-0.2863482535,
-0.1695384383,
0.0496088825,
0.4591931105,
-0.8530733585,
0.9280001521,
0.5942804813,
-0.5344765186,
-0.2981145084,
-0.0730293244,
-0.2631169856,
-0.7225251794,
0.3860858381,
0.0734328851,
0.123892799,
0.0102607841,
0.1510156244,
-0.6200646758,
1.1005488634,
0.85757792,
-1.0072720051,
-0.0758944675,
0.4813293815,
0.5136021376,
0.043018356,
-0.3774517775,
0.2889484167,
0.3441977501,
-0.0101948557,
-0.974519968,
-0.2882914841,
0.031705942,
0.1331269443,
0.7520809174,
-0.7776491642,
0.9642174244,
0.1357642859,
0.126534164,
-0.2579118311,
0.4664568007,
0.0190105755,
0.5302753448,
0.5269818902,
0.7987359166,
0.6059961319,
-0.0094872909,
0.6044800878,
-0.3553199768,
0.5370708108,
1.1016408205,
-0.2415732741,
0.7044703364,
0.9575426579,
-0.2233760506,
-0.0645586103,
0.484975338,
0.0465027578,
0.8058372736,
0.1611413062,
-0.1953319162,
-0.1427306533,
-0.032877855,
-0.5498817563,
0.004995882,
0.0376550481,
-0.1772214919,
-0.4150715172,
0.3692136109,
0.2577492297,
0.6615881324,
-0.0848499462,
0.7883075476,
0.169289425,
-0.658531785,
1.0182127953,
0.2379619926,
0.7638991475,
-0.4130633175,
0.2833903432,
-0.6391923428,
0.5403112769,
0.2445988506,
-0.339809984,
0.5222092867,
-0.0742032826,
-0.0943747684,
-0.6302555203,
0.104017213,
-0.973708272,
-0.430149585,
0.6718791723,
0.7999606729,
-0.2541731,
-0.2010322958,
-0.7816482782,
0.0151555333,
0.1219437644,
0.203139469,
0.6311304569,
0.7778291702,
0.1574256271,
0.4392082095,
0.6592398286,
0.1966715604,
0.3446334004,
-0.0249262918,
0.8589746952,
-0.2652280331,
-0.576430738,
-1.0331203938,
0.2652369142,
-0.1699333787,
-0.2918860018,
0.6055458784,
0.6802665591,
1.0776591301,
-0.0906699151,
0.3971634805,
-0.0009736101,
0.3285697103,
-0.6935449243,
0.7291098237,
-0.7128204107,
0.1663623303,
0.0071932035,
-1.2586654425,
-0.2398816794,
0.1753417701,
0.0073784599,
-0.421980083,
0.7995309234,
0.2766241133,
-0.3455578387,
-0.3775009811,
0.3598309755,
-0.1702288538,
0.2665352523,
0.9707098007,
0.6290106177,
-0.2913502157,
0.5375422239,
-0.6437053084,
-0.3210760653,
0.1795953363,
-0.8845956326,
-0.897906661,
-0.5752817988,
-0.1015251875,
-0.0589281805,
0.3093027771,
1.0695472956,
0.5275825262,
-0.4356969893,
-0.6295695901,
-0.3082606494,
-0.0327955373,
-0.4561757445,
-0.0380129814,
0.0252809953,
-0.8180639148,
-0.8400173187,
0.3977452219,
0.227948755,
-0.1074120328,
0.0797049478,
-0.2784182131,
-0.4012673199,
-0.2594474554,
0.5109157562,
-0.1585273296,
-0.2996798158,
0.2859613299,
0.0165181197,
-0.0598548986,
0.2926819623,
0.704407692,
-0.1271196902,
0.2481495887,
0.3846197426,
1.0869956017,
0.5004656911,
-0.2429527342,
0.7473019361,
-1.0056655407,
0.5381675959,
-0.016460415,
0.3403258324,
0.3182156384,
-0.0809944868,
0.3366536498,
0.3566925228,
-0.3223798871,
-0.7955654263,
0.013820827,
-0.625117898,
-0.3403493166,
0.9649072289,
-0.2493824661,
-0.042998068,
0.3756635487,
-0.2258572876,
0.4028261304,
-0.2992599905,
0.6169847846,
0.6860016584,
0.1528916359,
0.0359644555,
-0.4248869717,
0.2786124349,
0.7382516265,
-0.808244288,
0.0523180515,
0.4889184237,
0.053299699,
0.2418522239,
0.4765404463,
0.0283045061,
-0.1378378868,
-0.0594178922,
-0.0999022946,
-0.1913178712,
-0.5868204832,
-0.6244021654,
0.1561197639,
0.1924275756,
-0.4889195263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15717v1 | The False Promise of Imitating Proprietary LLMs | 2023-05-25T05:00:12 | 2023-05-25T05:00:12 | Arnav Gudibande, Eric Wallace, Charlie Snell, Xinyang Geng, Hao Liu, Pieter Abbeel, Sergey Levine, Dawn Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | An emerging method to cheaply improve a weaker language model is to finetune
it on outputs from a stronger model, such as a proprietary system like ChatGPT
(e.g., Alpaca, Self-Instruct, and others). This approach looks to cheaply
imitate the proprietary model's capabilities using a weaker open-source model.
In this work, we critically analyze this approach. We first finetune a series
of LMs that imitate ChatGPT using varying base model sizes (1.5B--13B), data
sources, and imitation data amounts (0.3M--150M tokens). We then evaluate the
models using crowd raters and canonical NLP benchmarks. Initially, we were
surprised by the output quality of our imitation models -- they appear far
better at following instructions, and crowd workers rate their outputs as
competitive with ChatGPT. However, when conducting more targeted automatic
evaluations, we find that imitation models close little to none of the gap from
the base LM to ChatGPT on tasks that are not heavily supported in the imitation
data. We show that these performance discrepancies may slip past human raters
because imitation models are adept at mimicking ChatGPT's style but not its
factuality. Overall, we conclude that model imitation is a false promise: there
exists a substantial capabilities gap between open and closed LMs that, with
current methods, can only be bridged using an unwieldy amount of imitation data
or by using more capable base LMs. In turn, we argue that the highest leverage
action for improving open-source models is to tackle the difficult challenge of
developing better base LMs, rather than taking the shortcut of imitating
proprietary systems. | [
-0.2844790816,
-0.6174947023,
0.4620498419,
-0.0931881964,
0.0185034573,
0.2677253485,
-0.0633428097,
-0.6691949964,
0.304840982,
0.6393523812,
-0.3267142475,
0.0630672723,
-0.5665823817,
-0.1310648918,
-0.4845969677,
0.8845104575,
0.026901871,
0.0685705617,
0.0209857821,
-0.2311866879,
-0.293266803,
-0.5673013926,
-0.3715597689,
-0.5026957989,
0.1927000582,
0.2946594954,
1.0605306625,
0.6905797124,
0.226342842,
0.2442153692,
-0.0538531542,
0.2722179294,
-0.8235532641,
-0.5370504856,
-0.0703610107,
-0.4772774279,
-0.309748292,
0.5611038804,
0.5515358448,
0.5507375598,
-0.1795698404,
0.2593871951,
0.5665254593,
0.6148933172,
-0.403955549,
0.3474690914,
-1.0591455698,
-0.1515143216,
-0.0332331657,
0.1619308144,
-0.5756255984,
-0.4607720673,
0.0840450302,
-0.2780006826,
0.2070041746,
-0.0337199271,
0.9843414426,
0.0595579669,
0.2553027272,
-0.6194990873,
-0.9186288714,
0.7501179576,
-1.1175923347,
0.055708304,
0.1613342464,
0.2819477022,
-0.1574490815,
-0.7909491062,
-0.4853598773,
-0.7231754661,
-0.1384098381,
0.066800788,
-0.483923465,
-0.0919769332,
0.2271436006,
0.5869160891,
-0.3386818171,
0.2663991153,
-0.7390242815,
0.0205215532,
0.1639706641,
-0.0195476282,
0.2776287496,
-0.164571926,
-0.4807880819,
-0.0261579975,
-0.9136144519,
0.014441737,
0.2879136205,
0.5870963335,
0.0702653006,
0.6645615101,
-0.3259370327,
0.4380153716,
0.1978276223,
0.0944104269,
0.1907031983,
-0.1789978296,
-0.4087170959,
0.0256136619,
0.6427502632,
0.1346926093,
0.3228262663,
-0.3058271706,
-0.4869903922,
0.2433864027,
0.2471806854,
-0.5656814575,
-0.1226573661,
0.2670086324,
-0.5702394843,
-0.3170653582,
0.0262423102,
-0.6189827919,
-0.5176659822,
-0.4801591933,
0.9501791,
-0.4337548614,
-0.2285112888,
0.0194132738,
0.0810318887,
0.2920966148,
0.3256754279,
-0.6199397445,
0.4753255248,
0.8304227591,
1.3472679853,
-0.1319730431,
-0.4500590563,
-0.4976551235,
-0.1737942696,
-0.4342429638,
0.6270865798,
-0.1229414046,
-0.5880607367,
-0.2094173282,
-0.0987259597,
-0.0067488896,
-0.8848581314,
0.415125221,
-0.3324266374,
0.1572802216,
-0.1902870387,
-0.6729349494,
-0.0459745564,
0.0978394374,
-0.7214322686,
0.6991680264,
0.0871149972,
-0.4935888946,
0.1769186705,
-0.7523100972,
0.1968209147,
0.0348049849,
-0.0131136999,
-0.2765458822,
0.0765109286,
0.2007105052,
0.4484065175,
0.0278163143,
0.1325914562,
-0.6138366461,
-0.8154062033,
0.3000402749,
-0.7306367159,
0.7202070951,
0.2990289032,
-0.4832397103,
-0.0902869329,
-0.686432302,
0.0599078275,
0.2095122188,
-0.2223844528,
-0.4358003736,
0.0117633352,
-0.5020138621,
-0.0305789001,
0.2592337728,
-0.4130889773,
0.177297011,
-0.8432859182,
0.5579084754,
1.0008341074,
-0.199063912,
0.7209708095,
-0.8735132217,
0.4309408069,
-0.4265349507,
0.2744750679,
-0.1975700408,
-0.4630388021,
-0.6835932732,
-0.2831028104,
0.0789580643,
0.4418641329,
-0.4521054924,
-0.1583265811,
-0.3604122698,
-0.8839859366,
-0.8627450466,
0.1757950932,
0.2542999089,
0.2800378501,
0.3810360134,
-0.429944247,
-0.3759481311,
-1.0087724924,
-0.6206207871,
-0.3430790901,
0.00243944,
0.0446330719,
0.2395144552,
0.1051114798,
1.0409870148,
0.0067192172,
-0.3138675094,
-0.1472176164,
0.1354471147,
0.6007031202,
0.488485992,
0.6136184335,
-0.3935568631,
-0.4608018398,
-0.111589469,
-0.35241732,
-0.1351429373,
-0.1408704668,
0.2057177126,
0.2072120607,
0.3300537467,
-0.645999074,
0.2133356184,
0.8132510781,
-0.076488696,
0.8978212476,
-0.3071966767,
0.0841650292,
-0.8041700125,
-0.0403831936,
-0.367688477,
-0.0371621586,
-0.5869408846,
0.382104218,
-0.1114899367,
-0.1917493492,
-0.6306731105,
0.5076709986,
-0.5171486139,
-0.1253317595,
-0.5066033006,
0.0592323802,
-0.1628810465,
0.4063886404,
-0.3804435432,
0.8899323344,
0.1529955864,
-0.5216083527,
0.2090958953,
-0.0351761654,
-0.7596611381,
0.2213362604,
-0.9136227965,
0.2108396888,
-0.080266051,
0.0597199649,
-0.84863168,
-0.1049920842,
0.4450423419,
-0.4046928287,
-0.0178139862,
-0.5300071836,
-0.6154891253,
-0.3312028348,
-0.2271782309,
-0.0481385291,
1.0457289219,
-0.855440259,
0.5189680457,
-0.0154099287,
-0.0445327163,
-0.6594420075,
-0.9694429636,
0.1140500307,
-0.1955656856,
-0.4674211442,
0.1528501958,
-0.0396483317,
-0.4052920938,
-0.0233702157,
0.0278085265,
0.0032204054,
0.0269576833,
0.215377152,
0.156817615,
-0.490521729,
-0.1842740178,
-0.3502849042,
0.2248645872,
-0.0169429444,
-0.3014249802,
0.5478200912,
-0.3812204003,
-0.7845355868,
-0.5362166762,
-0.0839377791,
0.9028050303,
-0.0526844114,
0.5838586092,
0.3512305021,
-0.1130307689,
-0.3099655211,
-0.6175037026,
-0.2191593349,
-0.5590224266,
0.2447582632,
-0.2490514368,
-0.5249047279,
0.3160796463,
-0.0353238657,
0.4386187196,
0.180271402,
0.4487615228,
0.019415075,
0.5902343392,
0.3141724765,
-0.1518375874,
0.4727199078,
-0.2892630994,
-0.1156548411,
-0.3537745476,
0.0187006015,
-0.4490106106,
-0.2330610603,
-0.6285201311,
-0.7676581144,
0.1279509515,
0.2339174002,
-0.1272856742,
0.5135636926,
-0.4579806924,
0.5380555987,
0.9374417663,
0.3116386533,
0.6013368368,
0.1352377832,
0.1853543222,
-0.1562528908,
-0.9686675072,
-0.9383644462,
0.990444243,
0.5501980186,
0.9077410102,
0.0662660748,
0.6708748937,
0.4114742279,
0.7515829802,
-0.8118931055,
0.507617712,
-0.197496593,
-0.2138117552,
-0.1821434349,
-0.4020397961,
-0.8049063683,
0.337798506,
-0.0700563639,
-0.667668879,
0.1719033867,
0.4659703672,
-0.1875461191,
0.6808066964,
-1.0051795244,
0.6225516796,
-0.0251772702,
-0.2883478105,
-0.3357485831,
0.075546369,
0.7473129034,
-0.0259295888,
0.4108863473,
-0.222461164,
0.1273730546,
0.4642365873,
-0.5975210071,
1.2752668858,
-0.198857531,
-0.160069719,
0.5662205219,
0.5919702649,
0.8839024305,
-0.3603861034,
-0.294279784,
0.1679797173,
-0.025293434,
-0.6404997706,
-0.6035925746,
0.7479429841,
-0.7080056667,
-0.8135434985,
-0.0287541039,
-0.2651719451,
-0.2031132579,
0.0328876413,
0.13817738,
0.5213151574,
-0.532438159,
0.0553333089,
0.3067879677,
-0.1801753044,
0.4022496641,
0.4029523432,
-0.1795354784,
-0.3362858891,
0.7995633483,
0.2674767673,
0.8811095953,
0.1064349189,
0.3296327889,
-0.0891800746,
-0.397310406,
-0.5791197419,
0.1515705287,
-0.5967606306,
0.0416363329,
-0.4951020479,
-0.0926078111,
-0.2255331725,
-0.1283626258,
-0.8370394111,
-0.4423346221,
-0.2748585939,
0.1543079168,
0.1365212351,
1.0341631174,
-0.2278221101,
0.3512853384,
-0.7822922468,
0.0091876211,
0.3193083405,
0.4673682451,
0.4543982744,
-0.8912523985,
-0.1891001314,
0.4753523469,
-0.4407801926,
-0.6428555846,
0.3233467638,
-0.0340484604,
0.7551635504,
0.4268585145,
0.0636000931,
0.6981897354,
-0.6810777187,
0.7731647491,
0.1198152751,
-1.0599107742,
0.0911292732,
-0.1157595739,
0.2386085987,
0.2920294404,
0.2562704682,
-0.4457404017,
-0.6847148538,
-0.7286202908,
-0.4930179417,
0.634268105,
0.3904536068,
0.4673258066,
0.224222362,
0.3111013174,
0.3136682212,
0.0133593157,
-1.0974236727,
-0.0049983542,
-0.2134018689,
0.0375767052,
-0.0693732426,
-0.1204241216,
0.2552537322,
0.2781639993,
0.63716048,
0.0194422957,
0.2816382945,
0.2379379421,
0.0448881723,
0.0396185294,
0.288488239,
0.3738411367,
0.5899690986,
-0.0236754101,
0.1770493835,
0.318238318,
-0.070940055,
0.1448905468,
-0.1390275061,
-0.3935845792,
0.3541717529,
0.1703674495,
0.7068653107,
0.1109489053,
-0.7064232826,
0.3109063506,
0.6027491093,
-0.0462540649,
-0.1196241528,
0.1004511267,
0.1908871233,
0.4707393646,
0.2239336073,
0.3483824134,
0.0260133669,
-0.7329149246,
0.2741991282,
0.6941685677,
-0.4764126837,
-0.3549674153,
0.6407877803,
-0.1417028904,
-0.5295021534,
0.2578271329,
-0.0251546632,
-0.3419492543,
0.6369836926,
0.2835603952,
0.5315992832,
-0.2671834528,
0.3027374148,
0.2847145498,
0.7527138591,
-0.743304193,
-0.1056071669,
0.2330680639,
-0.5699282289,
-0.7038679123,
-0.3123504817,
-0.7350659966,
0.3442503214,
-0.3730893433,
0.5870073438,
-0.4214920998,
0.0628920868,
-0.3369712234,
-0.4082050622,
-0.4925592244,
-0.2824473679,
-0.0370583795,
1.0043859482,
-0.3984827399,
0.723231256,
0.1340266913,
-0.5948998332,
-0.6824680567,
0.1033054814,
-0.2374958545,
-1.1542476416,
0.4691697955,
0.0584859215,
-0.1440996081,
-0.1113118008,
-0.7390457392,
-0.7760584354,
0.8618315458,
0.4637740254,
-0.5659648776,
-0.3740553856,
0.3029079437,
0.443202287,
-0.2366688699,
0.1316315979,
0.1143505126,
0.1979176849,
-0.1954248548,
-1.2924048901,
0.0690808371,
0.3204538226,
-0.1762088686,
-0.0660956204,
-0.8292587399,
0.8410775661,
-0.4501357973,
-0.4250879288,
0.5597748756,
0.4738511741,
0.3094706535,
0.2768871784,
0.4370530844,
0.2246836573,
0.5424905419,
0.2375646979,
1.01029706,
-0.1610743105,
0.4878081977,
1.3491975069,
-0.1053986102,
0.9437954426,
0.4420555532,
-0.1556117535,
0.4567291439,
0.2849576175,
-0.3387392759,
0.3998829424,
0.3695532978,
0.0951630846,
0.1487252414,
0.2309276164,
-0.1634603143,
0.3486143649,
0.2978896201,
-0.5966974497,
-0.3779481053,
-0.1868394613,
-0.0814481452,
0.3281878829,
-0.3529787064,
0.5945737362,
0.2232747078,
-0.5199916363,
0.8640180826,
0.0815628842,
0.8456447124,
-0.5338814259,
0.0282359496,
-0.3140814304,
0.1369338781,
0.168547824,
-0.3352072835,
0.4009426534,
-0.0117379613,
0.1273022294,
-0.3638271689,
0.6121254563,
-0.1572770625,
-0.0968036205,
0.260892272,
0.928815186,
0.3321349025,
-0.2350642681,
-0.7264281511,
-0.2149374783,
0.0724263042,
-0.1822245568,
0.3045051694,
0.2091023922,
0.2526400387,
0.7642561793,
0.6982260942,
0.3120583892,
-0.0444916561,
-0.398034811,
0.5358689427,
-0.5051453114,
-0.4288812876,
-1.0850347281,
0.1328222901,
0.0423905663,
-0.0156948119,
0.6283401251,
0.4357616305,
1.0011694431,
-0.2840107083,
0.7910074592,
0.2373158932,
0.6667648554,
-0.6369231343,
0.822865665,
-0.438931793,
0.5474480987,
-0.320931226,
-0.9141044617,
0.2944880724,
0.170294553,
-0.190671742,
-0.0339440964,
0.285165906,
1.0521916151,
-0.5198196769,
0.0462826528,
0.6586488485,
0.4717869163,
0.1504897922,
0.4326226711,
1.2170200348,
-0.2580412924,
1.024205327,
-0.1665394008,
-0.3253428638,
-0.1430144459,
-0.6505117416,
-0.7207651138,
-0.3246095181,
-0.1667152941,
-0.7768216729,
0.1235057041,
1.0906621218,
0.7013572454,
-0.6897616386,
-0.457651794,
-0.046676401,
-0.1105249301,
-0.4263807237,
-0.2980640829,
0.1081263646,
-0.314640522,
-1.0985081196,
0.5938251615,
0.0240541771,
0.5059065223,
-0.6516512036,
-0.0312108807,
0.2584322095,
0.4324662089,
0.5341051817,
0.425522387,
-1.0146914721,
-0.1770246923,
0.0483927839,
-0.2849767506,
0.1676162034,
0.8824526072,
-0.9617492557,
0.1275416315,
0.151312843,
0.6851326227,
0.1981544644,
-0.0508766212,
0.6448213458,
-0.3138426244,
-0.0902223587,
0.1599686593,
0.3234776258,
0.3251100481,
-0.0850573331,
0.390705049,
0.3509934247,
-0.3642123342,
-0.8378517032,
0.3071651161,
-0.6548731923,
-0.5600255132,
1.1569815874,
-0.2283772677,
-0.1095770895,
-0.0300905835,
-0.3193942606,
-0.0325197279,
-0.5566261411,
1.0543841124,
0.6299737692,
-0.1768160909,
0.1567186564,
-0.6593983173,
0.3165000379,
0.4757119715,
-0.407022506,
0.2496998161,
0.2960602343,
0.4007199407,
0.2383213341,
0.6194568276,
-0.3279698193,
0.0484986864,
0.1788282692,
0.0713576525,
-0.0825446695,
0.3475131392,
-0.3994445801,
0.3504691422,
0.3693886101,
-0.1438236833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16355v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16355v1 | PandaGPT: One Model To Instruction-Follow Them All | 2023-05-25T04:16:07 | 2023-05-25T04:16:07 | Yixuan Su, Tian Lan, Huayang Li, Jialu Xu, Yan Wang, Deng Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | We present PandaGPT, an approach to emPower large lANguage moDels with visual
and Auditory instruction-following capabilities. Our pilot experiments show
that PandaGPT can perform complex tasks such as detailed image description
generation, writing stories inspired by videos, and answering questions about
audios. More interestingly, PandaGPT can take multimodal inputs simultaneously
and compose their semantics naturally. For example, PandaGPT can connect how
objects look in an image/video and how they sound in an audio. To do so,
PandaGPT combines the multimodal encoders from ImageBind and the large language
models from Vicuna. Notably, only aligned image-text pairs are required for the
training of PandaGPT. Thanks to the strong capability of ImageBind in embedding
data from different modalities into the same space, PandaGPT displays emergent,
i.e. zero-shot, cross-modal behaviors for data other than image and text (e.g.,
video, audio, depth, thermal, and IMU). We hope that PandaGPT serves as an
initial step toward building AGI that can perceive and understand inputs in
different modalities holistically, as we humans do. Our project page is at
https://panda-gpt.github.io/. | [
-0.5226103663,
-1.1356873512,
0.5320371985,
0.4432604909,
-0.1405889392,
-0.1894610375,
-0.1711123735,
-0.1778072566,
0.0671094581,
0.4125321209,
-0.6192933321,
-0.4864860475,
-0.4783619642,
-0.2908478379,
-0.5164681673,
1.2266591787,
-0.2313820124,
0.0702740997,
0.0737815425,
0.1000713781,
-0.5069252253,
-0.3331136703,
-0.6297009587,
-0.0714093819,
0.3811187148,
0.1454644352,
0.8029073477,
0.7966079116,
0.1926507205,
0.1938486099,
0.1411207169,
-0.2033918649,
-0.1106647924,
0.0593325868,
0.0209813565,
-0.2151211947,
-0.396160543,
-0.032125704,
0.6883944869,
0.6791251898,
-0.3242799342,
0.0451751985,
0.1155215204,
0.3637232184,
-0.4249474108,
0.6272712946,
-0.0808610991,
0.1876108646,
0.1483387202,
-0.2003660947,
-0.3604775667,
-0.1436309218,
0.1697272658,
-0.8685364723,
0.1769717187,
-0.0717644468,
0.4852579832,
0.5442125797,
-0.4239115715,
-0.3310675919,
-0.5443503857,
0.4177984595,
-0.3784801662,
0.6571087241,
0.4833638072,
0.2867518365,
-0.0584958941,
-0.7273173332,
-0.6870142817,
-0.3554020524,
0.0817002282,
0.3727698028,
-0.0350471623,
0.2363451421,
0.3277005553,
0.1624055654,
-0.684533596,
-0.122128211,
-0.3333097994,
0.1045881137,
0.2350996882,
0.0394736566,
0.6364459991,
0.0440611355,
-0.3105263412,
-0.2733830214,
-0.5871751308,
0.0477365069,
0.2770842314,
-0.1117474884,
-0.1930499673,
0.6956769228,
-0.0209662635,
0.850782156,
0.2038600296,
0.1324829161,
-0.0572847873,
-0.4810403585,
-0.2348399907,
0.4369828701,
0.8737869859,
0.2356572449,
-0.1073805615,
-0.2130333632,
-0.2452427,
0.1630702764,
0.3000975251,
-0.9964648485,
-0.4843698144,
-0.054652378,
-0.4218874872,
-0.1512031555,
-0.0253662765,
-0.9574915767,
-0.4111396372,
-0.5066798329,
0.669467628,
-0.808606863,
-0.4491316378,
0.1683382094,
-0.1665562242,
0.487646997,
0.5236660838,
-1.4205332994,
0.4920355082,
0.9106202126,
0.8938393593,
0.0709782466,
-0.5800142884,
-0.7916386127,
0.3429375887,
-0.4148799777,
0.6903143525,
-1.0094959736,
-0.3085765243,
-0.1747968942,
-0.0212034062,
-0.1696000993,
-0.1581824273,
0.3288260996,
-0.2776015401,
0.1087508351,
-0.1258768141,
-0.5101650357,
-0.4918748438,
0.10830006,
-0.6810752749,
0.6597777605,
0.1096497104,
-0.609963119,
0.2435479909,
-0.9948707223,
-0.5468571782,
-0.0843427852,
-0.3358703852,
-0.1404828727,
-0.0025409749,
0.4595554471,
0.5002572536,
-0.2007255107,
-0.019889975,
-0.2862273157,
-0.4612166286,
0.02570091,
-0.8622013927,
0.7486470342,
-0.0634856224,
-0.481700331,
0.2264247239,
-0.8729909658,
-0.2123570442,
-0.014324965,
-0.5497038364,
-0.0179393254,
-0.0086660627,
0.3650928438,
-0.0169951618,
0.1134777591,
-0.51221174,
0.5135017037,
0.272035718,
0.7283504605,
0.8714032769,
-0.1957969368,
0.5367339849,
-0.0707780048,
0.7658960819,
-0.0565198809,
0.1207911372,
-0.8362514973,
-0.4141477346,
-0.6893728375,
-0.4278999269,
0.2065509558,
0.7578528523,
-0.851113081,
0.0825089887,
-0.1597676724,
-0.4936598241,
-0.7048156857,
0.3282065094,
0.1952325404,
0.3647482395,
0.3294914961,
-0.3936955333,
-0.2758014202,
-0.563954711,
0.2961582243,
-0.1757053286,
-0.1705495119,
0.0815654024,
0.3699958026,
-0.3651572168,
0.6599727869,
-0.439468652,
-0.2462205738,
-0.1264842302,
0.328354001,
0.0760368779,
0.6354427934,
0.656223774,
-0.9583110809,
-0.531863451,
0.3862305284,
-0.7223647833,
0.0890851319,
-0.3136814237,
-0.0349689946,
0.0326000713,
0.4618998766,
-0.9707223177,
0.2787078917,
0.6358445287,
-0.1645746231,
0.6538173556,
-0.2046927065,
0.2897505462,
-1.0552922487,
-0.2317156792,
0.1363476366,
0.0609313175,
-0.5308001041,
-0.0082124481,
0.0188351218,
-0.2539144158,
-0.2569477558,
0.2948244214,
-0.4450866878,
-0.1059763283,
-0.1217885166,
-0.1774600148,
-0.0198613908,
0.7580227256,
0.3276081085,
0.891479373,
1.321973443,
-0.4418869019,
0.9083898664,
0.2288676202,
-0.4606289566,
0.6769641638,
-0.8372564912,
-0.0147681739,
-0.174477905,
0.4058709443,
-0.9412357211,
-0.4892160892,
0.437936753,
-0.3344785273,
0.5905538201,
-0.3155788183,
-0.7843737602,
0.0435707271,
-0.0770300478,
0.32292521,
0.5249641538,
-0.7291122675,
0.9615653753,
0.1089322492,
-0.4135240018,
-0.4102978408,
-0.6963325739,
0.1612567306,
-0.0393834263,
-0.4682461321,
-0.1393517107,
-0.2290145755,
0.2016250789,
0.2993883491,
0.0078997593,
-0.3511112034,
-0.1902282089,
0.4065570533,
0.345875293,
-0.4685878158,
0.2068559676,
0.1319728941,
0.088009797,
0.0141700581,
-0.4124520123,
0.607907474,
-0.4803602993,
-0.6328250766,
-0.5794767737,
0.5537208915,
0.5947603583,
-0.6595737338,
0.4710376561,
1.1376481056,
-0.1117367595,
0.0049791276,
-0.3240222931,
-0.0755910352,
-0.4763583839,
0.6532575488,
-0.4003895521,
-0.5702751875,
0.266706109,
0.0979396477,
0.2822930515,
-0.1923613697,
0.5403586626,
-0.106417343,
1.3087266684,
0.6440010071,
0.1406864822,
0.957313776,
-0.3285163343,
0.0976444334,
-0.9459322691,
0.0138373394,
0.0815921053,
-0.0588280335,
-0.4513830543,
-0.3899939954,
0.2802540064,
0.0881315544,
-0.2422236502,
0.4835632443,
-0.5877895951,
0.5411587954,
0.9222583771,
0.1465573311,
-0.0851161927,
-0.0380787961,
0.1534289718,
0.228350386,
-0.8367863297,
-0.2925735712,
0.9517580271,
0.2347551137,
1.2901992798,
0.0797212273,
0.6014422774,
-0.1001841128,
0.2996121049,
-0.945127666,
0.558250308,
-0.0807090327,
-0.3336976171,
-0.2885706723,
-0.1878499389,
-0.784881711,
0.3560036719,
-0.0310205817,
-0.5924152136,
-0.0334535837,
0.2020020634,
-0.3264125586,
0.2540552616,
-0.9991676211,
1.1008975506,
-0.4700297713,
-0.5264333487,
-0.1472568661,
-0.5940541029,
0.3059177101,
0.0281458702,
0.0426752567,
0.3260458708,
-0.0879143104,
0.4922914207,
0.1005214751,
1.1656930447,
0.0498673543,
-0.2264584899,
0.39289397,
0.1928221285,
0.0937736407,
-0.0144519173,
0.2055786252,
-0.0481057018,
0.1784209907,
-0.2826592624,
-0.8222429156,
0.7053318024,
-0.657130301,
-0.639167428,
-0.2698897719,
-0.686434567,
0.0738905519,
0.3185831606,
-0.0611211993,
0.6576621532,
-0.2994009852,
0.2369233817,
0.8795393109,
-0.2646832466,
0.3423823118,
0.2930406928,
-0.1816926152,
-0.3133428991,
1.2074356079,
0.074428983,
0.269284606,
0.543610692,
-0.0372802615,
-0.187554121,
-0.0038394739,
-0.9280471206,
0.0431512259,
-0.942581594,
0.184340626,
-0.6382901669,
0.0229995549,
-0.5362915993,
-0.2260236442,
-0.3743654788,
-0.4169921875,
-0.4449858367,
-0.1225671172,
0.1956692934,
0.7608518004,
-0.1281978041,
0.5574358702,
-0.8217887878,
0.5076708198,
0.7873082757,
0.469453603,
-0.0594065525,
-0.1782275885,
-0.1213524938,
0.213184908,
-0.6434555054,
-0.8853192329,
0.2105037421,
0.3900456131,
0.6565602422,
0.5691902041,
-0.2962790132,
0.728484571,
-0.9561293721,
0.7539077997,
0.498233974,
-0.9734348655,
0.6440837383,
-0.3087798953,
0.2331800163,
-0.0845891535,
0.4336754978,
-0.7094259262,
-0.1135877296,
-0.3831140399,
-0.4848664403,
0.6918638349,
-0.0659399182,
0.1037878022,
0.0688877702,
0.0657051355,
0.1646891832,
0.1810853928,
-0.602407515,
0.0836194754,
-0.9692369103,
-0.3361417353,
-0.0500836261,
0.0884562805,
-0.3374547362,
-0.1923725754,
0.4313535988,
-0.3753732145,
0.374099046,
-0.0801923648,
-0.0319826007,
-0.0169587061,
0.3621476591,
0.4664839506,
0.4237308502,
0.0857853591,
0.1252010614,
-0.1997843385,
-0.4297664762,
0.0217219982,
0.3518408537,
-0.1295005679,
-0.1732747853,
0.4735696316,
1.360408783,
0.2970345914,
-0.7455043197,
0.6147062778,
-0.1754013747,
-0.0488810651,
-0.3454197645,
0.3113273382,
0.1903523505,
0.4016292393,
0.0390348695,
0.1343394518,
0.3038257062,
-0.7425606847,
0.1205549017,
0.4303054512,
-0.5299717188,
-0.6175746322,
0.9720734358,
-0.0415610597,
-0.033166185,
0.716014564,
0.0712073743,
-0.5201479197,
0.5903714299,
0.688149333,
0.789542377,
-0.2382737845,
0.4655095935,
0.1091831848,
0.3899054825,
-0.203259632,
-0.049838528,
-0.5206153393,
-0.4384575188,
-0.4962772727,
-0.557459414,
-0.4857257903,
-0.2565803826,
-0.7129915953,
0.3275226653,
-0.5003445745,
0.2635504305,
0.1062104404,
-0.4729986787,
-0.6840350032,
-0.0835727826,
0.1981518418,
0.5638687015,
-0.8156663775,
0.8247460723,
1.0556855202,
-0.7600389123,
-0.6543334723,
-0.0934166536,
0.0115321325,
-0.8233221769,
0.708652854,
0.3585896492,
0.0786989555,
0.1125196144,
-0.9306988716,
-0.4655774534,
1.0695517063,
0.4158971906,
-0.3328184783,
-0.1296596974,
-0.1368360519,
0.4387523532,
-0.3412863314,
0.2188257426,
0.5096821189,
0.5469002724,
0.2961475849,
-0.9539454579,
-0.2040599138,
-0.2063641548,
-0.118173331,
0.0202140678,
-0.6692165732,
0.9061966538,
-0.5036600828,
-0.2523787618,
0.056794133,
0.6365221739,
0.0385204889,
0.1480313241,
0.4887576401,
0.6203055382,
0.2989169061,
0.0211549196,
1.1594849825,
-0.1593313962,
0.0260707177,
1.0028010607,
-0.0326661058,
0.6341667175,
0.3890410066,
0.0683707148,
0.1212852299,
0.661961019,
-0.2506147325,
0.6816135049,
-0.106298089,
-0.3969350755,
-0.2919825017,
-0.126376912,
-0.3337693512,
0.4067249894,
0.5623045564,
-0.0880022943,
-0.0906016678,
0.4130873382,
-0.2164447457,
-0.2966798246,
-0.3368658125,
0.7836757898,
-0.0318058357,
-0.6075004339,
0.5216149688,
-0.490988344,
0.4787360728,
-0.7252137661,
-0.6943258643,
0.0248668008,
0.0955707952,
-0.0473827086,
-1.1184046268,
-0.161523208,
-0.1972912848,
-0.0764287636,
-0.301977694,
0.1723522097,
-0.8102359176,
-0.5468662977,
0.0242424067,
0.0669981167,
0.1443355232,
-0.0706243441,
-0.4048571885,
0.1822508723,
-0.0458024181,
-0.388409704,
0.3532327414,
0.7376015186,
-0.0549154021,
0.85808146,
0.566624999,
0.0805030242,
0.436114639,
-0.0451313369,
0.9094318151,
-0.36039868,
-0.5038785338,
-0.5508211851,
0.1335150003,
0.2588460445,
-0.0529609434,
0.4860958159,
0.3883446157,
0.9243712425,
-0.2653596103,
0.9992468953,
-0.2130398005,
-0.0236551519,
-0.581360817,
0.5619737506,
-0.5457170606,
-0.0416075997,
-0.3291960359,
-1.1779084206,
-0.1723979563,
0.840395391,
-0.0467078686,
-0.1106383801,
0.5357425809,
0.7094599605,
-0.4194454253,
0.2989646792,
0.2914833426,
0.2321968675,
0.6377879381,
0.4870805442,
0.8942268491,
-0.2449273616,
0.7573488355,
-0.3100480437,
-0.4828063846,
0.0436578766,
-0.5363171697,
-0.8660494685,
-0.67235744,
-0.3276959062,
0.1366507262,
-0.0750815272,
0.8587952852,
0.720097363,
-0.5732836127,
-0.1346326768,
-0.0717595369,
-0.1322848201,
-0.6041750312,
-0.219393,
0.5711883903,
-0.1747816354,
-1.0979632139,
0.3059342206,
0.344088167,
0.2607583404,
-0.3683089018,
-0.1643553525,
-0.0161740407,
-0.2006076127,
0.840466857,
0.328458488,
-0.6939368248,
-0.2322608531,
0.0574448258,
0.069942154,
-0.0533937365,
0.7401357293,
-0.5236737728,
0.6053761244,
0.377115041,
0.9538994431,
0.6412684321,
-0.1534299552,
0.5280846357,
-0.3685913384,
0.1617194712,
0.049651444,
0.4383856952,
0.4151474237,
-0.1293869466,
0.5741865039,
-0.0252055787,
-0.5455574393,
-0.6270019412,
0.3007853031,
-1.2523369789,
-0.1123780757,
1.2078586817,
-0.2732871473,
-0.2656166852,
0.1898174733,
-0.7423346639,
0.3221345842,
-0.4510110319,
0.5785021186,
0.8765488863,
-0.2774851918,
-0.9123339057,
-0.9463093281,
0.0734933242,
0.1340537369,
-0.5722081065,
0.1466051638,
0.7218154073,
0.2698277831,
0.2105692625,
0.4218291938,
0.0018015291,
0.6425661445,
0.3563798368,
0.1413011849,
-0.2149148434,
-0.3426860571,
-0.147743836,
0.0104517154,
-0.2732107639,
-0.5105723143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15689v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15689v2 | Zero-shot Approach to Overcome Perturbation Sensitivity of Prompts | 2023-05-25T03:36:43 | 2023-07-01T23:02:18 | Mohna Chakraborty, Adithya Kulkarni, Qi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent studies have demonstrated that natural-language prompts can help to
leverage the knowledge learned by pre-trained language models for the binary
sentence-level sentiment classification task. Specifically, these methods
utilize few-shot learning settings to fine-tune the sentiment classification
model using manual or automatically generated prompts. However, the performance
of these methods is sensitive to the perturbations of the utilized prompts.
Furthermore, these methods depend on a few labeled instances for automatic
prompt generation and prompt ranking. This study aims to find high-quality
prompts for the given task in a zero-shot setting. Given a base prompt, our
proposed approach automatically generates multiple prompts similar to the base
prompt employing positional, reasoning, and paraphrasing techniques and then
ranks the prompts using a novel metric. We empirically demonstrate that the
top-ranked prompts are high-quality and significantly outperform the base
prompt and the prompts generated using few-shot learning for the binary
sentence-level sentiment classification task. | [
-0.5333834887,
-1.0022666454,
0.6443665624,
0.1043561846,
-0.3693835735,
-0.1030768901,
-0.0847232938,
0.0391145237,
0.0241618957,
0.4841420054,
-0.6836330295,
-0.7945485711,
-0.4183756113,
0.3730106056,
0.2362041771,
1.23582232,
0.260068953,
-0.1513251066,
-0.2040823549,
-0.0791162103,
-0.6670925021,
-0.5808171034,
-0.4142346978,
-0.0431473926,
0.8022835255,
0.7303670049,
0.3629282713,
0.1495258957,
0.4347490966,
0.145334512,
-0.1768722832,
-0.2536354363,
-0.4169313312,
0.5405623317,
-0.0961829573,
-0.4300250709,
-0.091958411,
0.0216900259,
0.618288517,
0.6196090579,
0.2921909094,
0.3638227582,
0.1197127476,
0.2227893174,
-0.8270741701,
-0.0940565541,
-0.5871449709,
0.1616069824,
-0.1543694139,
-0.3949265182,
-0.5001302958,
-0.3462349474,
-0.0970971435,
-0.2301311046,
0.3407636583,
-0.1854842305,
0.7203842998,
0.2712435424,
-0.3293901682,
0.0716803372,
-0.5286484361,
0.9655634761,
-0.8128781915,
-0.24283503,
0.0712416545,
0.2893952131,
-0.0486444458,
-0.0966041088,
-0.4710924327,
-0.2922706902,
0.1107194796,
0.1790736765,
-0.19837147,
-0.0142906718,
0.6269842982,
-0.1306297928,
-0.561372757,
0.178473115,
0.2314675748,
-0.4047636986,
0.2983499467,
0.4253098071,
0.0329256095,
-0.6229614615,
-0.4720908403,
-0.151413694,
-0.5970203876,
0.5266976953,
0.5379654169,
0.7265517712,
0.2023519278,
0.6043865681,
-0.3344442844,
0.7689431906,
0.389239341,
-0.1887573749,
0.3103575706,
-0.3437456191,
-0.0364805982,
0.2061589509,
0.8728196025,
0.3825009763,
0.0255626328,
0.1016017273,
-0.2079616934,
0.2953330278,
0.2626162767,
-0.7465747595,
0.0528885461,
0.0708562881,
-0.1951718032,
-0.6195331216,
-0.0996865556,
-0.9171497822,
-0.4862302244,
-0.1461438388,
0.6666640043,
-0.3698837757,
0.1041363999,
-0.192930311,
-0.1321904063,
0.2463812083,
0.421831131,
-0.6876248121,
-0.0899474323,
0.4611573517,
0.8465048075,
-0.0098918062,
-0.1178914458,
-0.8419097662,
-0.2188860029,
-0.3954754472,
1.1591228247,
-0.6214533448,
-0.491718024,
-0.0988798365,
-0.440338999,
0.1896010786,
-0.3048543334,
0.6451554894,
-0.1159263104,
0.385761559,
-0.3599894047,
-0.3522372544,
0.0004916107,
0.5735115409,
-0.218226254,
0.7686159611,
0.1393768489,
-0.9083106518,
0.242923677,
-0.561032176,
-0.4201473892,
0.1966377348,
-0.1322572827,
-0.3519834876,
0.2973658741,
0.2294137329,
0.60066998,
0.0755500272,
-0.1221355796,
-0.2924377024,
-0.4868885279,
0.1790671796,
-0.5604399443,
0.768091619,
-0.0296323616,
-0.3323912024,
0.1895012408,
-0.7515433431,
-0.077764146,
-0.1357177794,
-0.1904890835,
-0.4212010205,
-0.4908385873,
-0.2525632083,
0.3358770907,
0.1511936933,
-0.8211334944,
0.2067065537,
-0.6588997841,
-0.0801173896,
0.6549765468,
0.6684199572,
0.4334911108,
-0.1769820601,
0.8649386764,
0.2941422462,
0.1809532493,
-0.6196673512,
-0.3939792216,
-0.4569707811,
-0.1517379135,
0.1691208631,
0.6717393398,
-0.8341847658,
0.6696766019,
-0.0097619537,
-0.5539966822,
-0.5092853308,
0.0838276595,
0.3260802627,
1.1748404503,
0.5278906822,
-0.2147453129,
-0.0694629475,
-0.6019160151,
-0.3530113399,
-0.1438520998,
0.0270416979,
0.3709857166,
0.0975059718,
0.0655300021,
1.1085871458,
-0.6344280243,
-0.2188550532,
-0.0834524184,
0.6619457006,
0.5482361913,
0.363724947,
0.6504371762,
-0.2505410314,
-0.6880865097,
-0.3167008758,
-0.5039963126,
-0.2878923714,
-0.2515889108,
-0.2551281452,
0.3258731067,
0.1138527021,
-0.563663125,
0.3472982347,
0.0142144887,
-0.477573663,
0.8179887533,
0.2319324762,
0.1852107048,
-0.9840394258,
0.0978531614,
0.3046121895,
-0.208051011,
-0.6150324345,
-0.2688907385,
-0.1750700623,
-0.233003661,
-0.6048926711,
0.4925685525,
-0.0723770633,
0.3662679195,
-0.2915751338,
-0.1333912611,
-0.0656742677,
0.5113474727,
0.0004292754,
0.476407975,
0.8825941682,
-0.495182544,
0.4592538774,
0.2840047479,
0.0394931771,
0.9055339098,
-0.549341321,
0.2440780848,
-0.4585916102,
0.1961466521,
-1.4222106934,
0.0630901456,
0.4665280581,
-0.7931584716,
0.2602799237,
-0.1955755502,
-0.1598391235,
-0.0718026012,
-0.7984458804,
0.1416906714,
0.4750849903,
-0.1838045567,
0.3121628463,
-0.1683446765,
-0.3807623386,
-0.8225673437,
-0.4193109572,
0.0536566526,
-0.29592821,
-0.1664841473,
-0.0151363406,
-0.271530956,
0.0223600678,
-0.2101532817,
-0.1929323375,
0.3078019619,
0.1539127529,
0.3719599545,
0.3184532821,
-0.2673151493,
0.0177093465,
0.1548113525,
-0.3837488294,
0.0778270438,
-0.1606824994,
0.5650995374,
-0.030358782,
0.0431237072,
-0.6645165682,
0.3179855049,
0.4234403074,
-0.0157703869,
0.5306488276,
0.6417367458,
-0.2094603926,
-0.1632650942,
-0.4171716571,
-0.3558950126,
-0.4220628142,
-0.0877733976,
-0.3571969271,
-0.6652258039,
0.2644129395,
0.0638955012,
0.1179641187,
0.3199172616,
0.5061695576,
-0.2768407762,
1.0983195305,
0.4341324866,
-0.2462432384,
0.6428846717,
-0.0519489311,
0.0876392871,
-0.4289865792,
0.116050534,
-0.7806897163,
-0.2544931769,
-0.4320842326,
-0.0880617276,
0.5256204009,
-0.0313501209,
-0.5061584115,
0.3234706819,
-0.5518875122,
0.4567850232,
0.6677544713,
0.1112701744,
0.0738760084,
0.2674454153,
-0.3271717131,
0.008176744,
-0.5232639909,
-0.6631549001,
0.8866131306,
0.1885184199,
0.6332002282,
-0.061523404,
0.9917125702,
0.3603956699,
-0.0206663236,
-0.8861157894,
0.5582711101,
-0.0581392162,
-0.4467666447,
-0.4443031251,
-0.6004437208,
-0.792103827,
-0.0496612191,
-0.4296177328,
-0.6994324923,
0.1050237194,
0.1757909358,
-0.9387859106,
-0.1463653296,
-0.5210902691,
0.8650256395,
-0.1160129979,
-0.4374606311,
0.148537606,
-0.8286113739,
-0.0254238229,
0.1000104994,
-0.0316812396,
-0.3200923502,
-0.1743524969,
0.3159052134,
-0.0770546272,
1.0385508537,
-0.6132314801,
-0.0161560513,
0.3525524735,
0.2827097476,
0.3293197453,
0.2060007602,
-0.3014883101,
0.1844008565,
-0.0595107973,
-0.5557041764,
-0.6341173053,
0.722278893,
-0.7003265023,
-0.4541004002,
-0.441709727,
-0.1842599511,
-0.5113783479,
0.1736620069,
0.6824761629,
0.4224058986,
0.024209749,
-0.0006751176,
0.4916183054,
-0.4184141755,
0.6972873807,
0.402941972,
0.2182070166,
-0.4225616753,
0.7858392,
0.1818053424,
0.1240926757,
0.4311375022,
0.4569815397,
-0.3576869071,
-0.4412495494,
-0.4716941714,
0.0779650807,
-0.5676496625,
-0.6473132968,
-0.5211898088,
0.0861543715,
-0.6513568759,
-0.3252790272,
0.01667374,
-0.4599165618,
-0.5149319172,
-0.1407688856,
0.2952229083,
0.4084611535,
0.1380648613,
0.375639677,
-0.9302449226,
0.3414125741,
0.1098807901,
0.376914233,
-0.1710183471,
-0.6783376932,
0.1376657337,
-0.1417652518,
-0.3452414274,
-1.07886374,
0.4018659294,
-0.085442476,
0.5044694543,
0.5167866945,
0.499820441,
0.3556476831,
-0.2891454399,
1.2228143215,
0.5787004232,
-1.0582060814,
0.9415271282,
-0.4993894398,
0.6185511351,
0.884790957,
0.6607628465,
-0.3588233888,
-0.5177653432,
-0.510070622,
-0.909362793,
0.7073426843,
-0.0700207502,
0.5598681569,
-0.0919071361,
0.5274628997,
0.4158692062,
0.3220994473,
-0.6560433507,
-0.2856033742,
-0.3987216949,
-0.4044323564,
-0.0337166823,
-0.2892355621,
0.090067178,
-0.1899863631,
0.5353324413,
-0.4721530974,
0.1279020756,
0.1226453707,
-0.1005504578,
-0.3673386574,
0.4765565395,
0.4626235664,
0.2505760789,
-0.2151433229,
0.143934235,
0.2063038647,
-0.2064496726,
0.3733429313,
-0.2206104994,
-0.6921704412,
0.1925389767,
0.3282424808,
0.998939395,
0.0286316853,
-0.3821815252,
0.6540349126,
0.02135933,
-0.1118921414,
0.0969165117,
0.2320108861,
-0.4283420444,
0.0422539413,
0.2771672904,
0.242730692,
0.2015419602,
-0.5129925609,
0.0639059693,
0.4363170564,
-0.5011370778,
-0.3787589371,
0.3224059939,
0.299141407,
-0.3754383326,
0.5618359447,
-0.3371052146,
-0.4502489269,
0.3062020838,
0.4569047689,
0.818587482,
-0.2011686414,
0.5615805984,
0.6492832303,
-0.0200836863,
0.1898528785,
0.3909897804,
-0.2208565623,
-0.7347391248,
-0.415441066,
-0.6188880801,
-0.581807673,
0.0005415324,
-0.6346779466,
0.5230057836,
-0.8815172315,
-0.5150632858,
0.088001132,
0.0934099853,
-0.5161725283,
0.0889297724,
0.4699889123,
0.6589161754,
-1.0056669712,
0.3332064152,
1.0421537161,
-0.8007870913,
-0.66302073,
0.3883892596,
0.0096586924,
-0.2403223217,
0.3740943968,
0.3616915047,
-0.2475693226,
0.2673274875,
-0.7429869771,
-0.4649350345,
0.6302924752,
0.5642573237,
-0.4768317938,
0.2228441983,
0.0277753435,
0.7057857513,
-0.156478256,
0.4527156651,
0.3376193941,
0.4846447408,
0.1909337491,
-0.6017302871,
0.1119695678,
-0.0787710398,
-0.064415656,
0.0069978018,
-0.4475921988,
0.7003718615,
-0.1195812225,
-0.0924598575,
-0.1094342768,
0.5051695108,
0.2266242206,
0.3971207738,
0.5538799167,
0.2763715982,
0.5517007709,
0.0445447937,
0.8056437969,
-0.200000897,
0.410854578,
0.841108501,
-0.5077596307,
0.8472245336,
0.4641554058,
0.0514249317,
0.7390109301,
0.4560602009,
-0.1165578291,
0.4817227721,
0.1505864114,
-0.5898128748,
-0.3507304192,
-0.243105635,
-0.0240065902,
0.3453960121,
0.1371286511,
-0.0597084351,
-0.4235681593,
0.3300703764,
-0.1030060947,
0.1587345302,
-0.4477674365,
1.0699952841,
-0.0774276704,
-0.7205657959,
0.6667436361,
-0.1541511118,
1.0828566551,
-0.3883937299,
-0.0521317571,
-0.3193674684,
-0.1017781422,
-0.2883165181,
-0.8738334775,
0.1112102717,
0.3713540137,
-0.2052776963,
-0.3449995518,
0.8231717348,
-0.1725346446,
-0.560808897,
-0.0578715503,
0.3729259968,
0.0986041054,
-0.3191750944,
-0.5149309039,
-0.2992610037,
-0.1919220537,
-0.4303120375,
0.3859902024,
0.5361942053,
0.0756570473,
0.1716448963,
0.6001132727,
0.1134487316,
-0.1277594119,
0.2011226565,
0.6577312946,
-0.9355080724,
-0.4647148848,
-1.0075395107,
0.4865596294,
0.0581461266,
-0.4129269719,
0.7364540696,
0.2589183748,
0.5171582699,
-0.2257574648,
0.861623466,
0.1706864238,
0.7386727929,
-0.1869158745,
0.4769467115,
-0.214627713,
0.1803277731,
-0.4335169196,
-0.7979812026,
-0.8188439012,
0.7138521671,
-0.3407941461,
-0.0984825492,
0.4404045045,
0.7985566854,
0.347507596,
-0.3684981465,
0.4732884765,
0.0735938177,
0.221599102,
0.4266138077,
0.9053291678,
-0.0908188671,
0.7031354308,
-0.3946343362,
-0.2465475798,
-0.2041738778,
-1.0971006155,
-0.7718024254,
-0.1611887217,
-0.4957641065,
-0.3860824108,
-0.0200656857,
1.1351547241,
0.4783026278,
-0.9799240232,
0.1944964677,
-0.0100155575,
0.1509004384,
-0.1983350962,
-0.3352376223,
0.0398819819,
-0.796431601,
-0.5915148258,
0.3078660071,
0.3335301578,
-0.0443796292,
-0.1631451547,
0.2536815405,
-0.0127112241,
0.2302260697,
0.7157134414,
0.1644642651,
-0.391443938,
-0.4396617413,
0.2010938972,
-0.2316633314,
0.1335237771,
0.7050468922,
-1.1098152399,
0.2756514549,
0.8020820618,
0.3980521262,
0.1054149121,
0.4695056677,
0.3146425784,
-1.3440430164,
-0.1037165821,
0.5294928551,
-0.0000687799,
0.3266696036,
-0.6309732199,
0.1277746111,
0.2684476376,
-0.3437279165,
-0.7809204459,
0.1305613071,
-1.1004464626,
-0.4089669287,
1.3438327312,
-0.2806386948,
-0.0625761002,
-0.0390629955,
-0.5901221633,
0.2655720115,
-0.7195658684,
0.7439920306,
0.60799402,
-0.473844409,
-0.2924830616,
-0.1461518109,
0.266492486,
0.4560347199,
-0.6745610833,
-0.0716345608,
0.7127271891,
0.3393648863,
0.3211515844,
0.3810740113,
0.0143483374,
0.3123613596,
-0.0636846796,
0.0448810197,
-0.1288023889,
-0.4707389474,
-0.8215594888,
0.6278117299,
0.2449435592,
-0.3595927358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15685v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15685v2 | RewriteLM: An Instruction-Tuned Large Language Model for Text Rewriting | 2023-05-25T03:26:26 | 2023-12-19T23:57:01 | Lei Shu, Liangchen Luo, Jayakumar Hoskere, Yun Zhu, Yinxiao Liu, Simon Tong, Jindong Chen, Lei Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities in
creative tasks such as storytelling and E-mail generation. However, as LLMs are
primarily trained on final text results rather than intermediate revisions, it
might be challenging for them to perform text rewriting tasks. Most studies in
the rewriting tasks focus on a particular transformation type within the
boundaries of single sentences. In this work, we develop new strategies for
instruction tuning and reinforcement learning to better align LLMs for
cross-sentence rewriting tasks using diverse wording and structures expressed
through natural languages including 1) generating rewriting instruction data
from Wiki edits and public corpus through instruction generation and
chain-of-thought prompting; 2) collecting comparison data for reward model
training through a new ranking function. To facilitate this research, we
introduce OpenRewriteEval, a novel benchmark covers a wide variety of rewriting
types expressed through natural language instructions. Our results show
significant improvements over a variety of baselines. The public repository is
available on GitHub under Google Research
(https://github.com/google-research/google-research/tree/master/rewritelm). | [
0.2230281085,
-1.0023114681,
0.3305471539,
0.1051875204,
-0.0706048831,
0.1059917137,
-0.5277169347,
-0.0071571623,
0.0533652529,
0.7714712024,
-0.8541457057,
-0.6766634583,
-0.3582161069,
0.1399724036,
-0.1604022086,
1.1755472422,
-0.5239438415,
-0.0118498569,
-0.3868508637,
0.1019632518,
-0.3568224311,
-0.2392017394,
-0.5543009639,
-0.2390660495,
0.8466069102,
0.4637701809,
0.4257250726,
0.6212534308,
0.4022173882,
0.3477790952,
0.2161979973,
0.4748756289,
-0.8735292554,
0.3492957652,
-0.487998426,
-0.6244521141,
-0.3721818626,
-0.0037150066,
0.7312255502,
0.5539143682,
-0.3340317309,
0.342658937,
0.1032780036,
0.6992000937,
-0.7471573949,
-0.0503265522,
-0.7636830211,
-0.0708570033,
-0.1568878591,
-0.4751508236,
-0.6941413879,
-0.8806992173,
-0.0173408836,
-0.710765779,
0.2677116692,
0.3424240649,
0.6147527695,
0.3730666637,
-0.2809837759,
-0.3500792682,
-0.4180293083,
1.0482959747,
-0.696590662,
0.4428578019,
0.0763959587,
0.3001030982,
-0.543939054,
-0.8082257509,
-0.268992126,
-0.2309669405,
0.1269386858,
-0.0121703511,
-0.0988957584,
-0.0769756585,
0.0601642393,
0.3974683881,
-0.4088020921,
0.2524027228,
-0.2466982603,
-0.1939341277,
0.6447372437,
0.4145054221,
0.123521328,
0.0654532388,
-0.2804264426,
-0.1522531807,
-0.7945793271,
0.2268086374,
0.4901511371,
0.3490337729,
0.1745769531,
0.6566727757,
-0.2521620691,
0.6837456226,
0.0637967288,
-0.2140128762,
0.2203768194,
-0.2813051641,
-0.4604305625,
0.2044746727,
0.4724297822,
0.3779894412,
0.2527098358,
-0.4242580831,
-0.2439388037,
-0.2588995695,
0.6505394578,
-0.8360083699,
-0.0639929026,
-0.0653903335,
-0.4011582136,
-0.4047191441,
-0.0107748285,
-0.39062801,
-0.1480213553,
-0.5336289406,
0.4411691725,
-0.6299141645,
0.1948507726,
0.1703666151,
-0.037687216,
0.1537810117,
0.399436146,
-0.9508131742,
0.3192091882,
0.8647732139,
0.5902715325,
-0.1707775444,
-0.6004844308,
-0.8688677549,
0.2339816689,
-0.3963673413,
0.5923884511,
-0.6706806421,
-0.0924168974,
0.1914555132,
0.1791661233,
-0.3524286151,
-0.3927986324,
0.6579003334,
-0.4123976529,
0.4520862401,
-0.079726167,
-0.7298983335,
-0.1930761486,
0.305663228,
-0.6341294646,
0.9849928617,
0.1440715343,
-0.5453836322,
0.3805951774,
-0.3629740477,
-0.75347507,
-0.2155823559,
0.2292620838,
-0.5662997365,
0.4681558311,
0.240904063,
0.2136089653,
-0.3288332522,
0.2640367448,
-0.1098036245,
-0.3612571657,
0.1753307283,
-0.607480824,
0.4057979286,
-0.1667609811,
-0.3058488965,
0.636310637,
-0.4939692318,
0.473721087,
-0.0341212638,
-0.7025565505,
-0.2681995928,
-0.0870117471,
-0.0936668217,
0.0578617603,
0.2498045862,
-0.7167788148,
0.5402827859,
-0.4351656437,
0.4277612567,
0.6877686977,
0.0087818997,
0.2850982547,
-0.3711336851,
0.4099660516,
-0.3759074211,
0.1520871669,
-0.2266096026,
-0.2447508276,
-0.6982351542,
-0.155750528,
0.1834423095,
0.4066799581,
-0.8078753948,
0.2475598305,
-0.3242995739,
-0.459027648,
-1.113202095,
0.3564145565,
0.812301755,
0.4265005887,
0.6296104789,
0.2371912897,
-0.5532873273,
-0.829986155,
-0.7302877307,
0.2300615907,
-0.0334648266,
0.0748157948,
0.4097158015,
-0.0500340462,
0.5225633383,
-0.4661642313,
-0.198974818,
-0.2840428352,
0.2757664025,
-0.0183947627,
0.1688943952,
-0.0581631809,
-0.4472635984,
-0.4828461707,
-0.04110232,
-0.5540935993,
-0.1701032668,
-0.140705049,
-0.2160323709,
0.4929393232,
0.8212031722,
-0.1971736848,
0.4410590529,
0.3916940093,
-0.1858130544,
0.5285716057,
-0.4697778523,
0.2370624542,
-0.8438063264,
-0.1778348535,
-0.1612190604,
-0.2058357894,
-0.3904149532,
0.164312765,
0.2276169956,
0.2273369879,
-0.484780252,
0.3119790256,
-0.6141059995,
0.1242306009,
-0.4022116959,
0.0984476358,
-0.0842171237,
0.6874761581,
0.0058716587,
0.5266392827,
0.1571305543,
-0.412745893,
0.3336456716,
0.0991042629,
-0.480037868,
0.3407785892,
-0.5730367899,
0.1429729164,
0.0099203419,
0.480537653,
-0.7036603093,
-0.0602712408,
0.0759850889,
-0.1541508287,
0.1759839207,
0.041343797,
-0.3916344941,
-0.1908538193,
-0.4365481138,
0.1285075992,
0.3502228558,
-0.6700442433,
0.4567580521,
-0.1256510913,
-0.0822835043,
-0.4368270934,
-0.4464434683,
-0.0312626958,
0.0150299864,
-0.6527697444,
0.7672122717,
0.1364326775,
0.0042644786,
0.1391738951,
-0.082853511,
0.3208601177,
-0.0635661483,
0.2794401944,
0.1400831342,
-0.3171144724,
0.2672643065,
0.2877451181,
-0.0300782192,
0.0586524084,
-0.3815663755,
0.484170109,
0.0533906519,
-0.3713767529,
-0.3768401444,
0.2623113692,
0.3418352008,
-0.419398725,
0.7306794524,
0.555916667,
-0.0300823953,
-0.7263224125,
-0.3644980192,
-0.0721494108,
-0.466206938,
0.4383630157,
-0.2636661828,
-1.0169048309,
-0.0492883064,
-0.0644754842,
0.5786776543,
0.2522036135,
0.7912157774,
0.0440446734,
0.8122990727,
0.6359872818,
-0.0099935019,
0.4043043852,
0.0944869667,
0.1680151373,
-0.884344995,
-0.3485264182,
-0.3509503901,
-0.6536961794,
-0.5562288761,
-0.6712027788,
-0.0434202589,
0.1348187625,
-0.411632061,
0.304163307,
-0.4322471023,
0.5270907879,
0.7909262776,
0.0372280367,
0.2628052831,
0.0777796209,
-0.2782313228,
-0.1351078153,
-0.6962470412,
-0.5215364099,
1.1781716347,
0.1502465308,
1.0074472427,
0.0828095675,
0.8736952543,
0.001045545,
0.5203893781,
-0.4815669358,
0.3859547079,
-0.35294047,
-0.2540533245,
-0.6702996492,
-0.417673409,
-0.9353551865,
0.2593907416,
-0.1729823798,
-0.4940764904,
-0.3977520764,
0.133250922,
-0.063844122,
0.4287989736,
-0.5943632722,
0.9419364333,
-0.5782513618,
-0.5867738128,
-0.3686877787,
-0.3110730648,
0.3104157746,
0.1471034735,
-0.0560747646,
0.0242034514,
-0.1981144249,
0.442625016,
-0.5438429713,
0.8769091368,
0.0485265777,
-0.2380823791,
0.1310593039,
0.1455089301,
0.5890873671,
-0.0721204504,
-0.1658823937,
-0.2096057087,
-0.3384241462,
-0.3210504949,
-0.6782506108,
0.9366455674,
-0.4765302539,
-0.5621160865,
-0.0455424376,
-0.6557847857,
-0.1858611405,
0.1648225784,
0.3442851305,
0.3209884763,
-0.4869901538,
0.3311232328,
0.6627539992,
-0.4020158648,
0.2947216332,
0.5917878151,
-0.291655302,
-0.3972610533,
0.9932892919,
-0.1132167503,
0.3962492049,
0.7193439603,
0.1043235958,
-0.2849725187,
-0.4368373156,
-0.4930937588,
0.1265448928,
-0.4330660403,
-0.1106851771,
-0.3886955678,
-0.082183294,
-0.5996011496,
-0.3815856874,
-0.2273955941,
-0.2060720325,
0.0190334972,
-0.0214813463,
0.2555293739,
0.5801100731,
0.390124619,
-0.0307457931,
-0.5547548532,
0.2913690507,
0.1159114838,
0.5492581129,
0.2031300664,
-0.6020821333,
-0.2269234955,
0.0514241159,
-0.2909663022,
-0.4061261415,
0.3784748316,
0.1863605827,
0.6963332891,
-0.0525296554,
0.0491892472,
0.7309914231,
-0.9669051766,
0.3675554097,
0.0687134191,
-0.8204830289,
0.5150837302,
-0.0595169254,
0.4794110358,
0.6825858355,
0.3441553414,
-0.8048529029,
-0.5124034286,
-0.3847450316,
-0.7973396182,
0.6214456558,
0.1108791903,
-0.0246551484,
0.0898624584,
0.1515199244,
0.254719317,
0.2328361124,
-0.4231438339,
0.1885170639,
-0.2728734612,
-0.3690243959,
-0.1948948205,
-0.0323835351,
-0.0468523838,
-0.1602926403,
0.7898427844,
-0.0865632147,
-0.1041549221,
0.0270249695,
-0.3826559782,
-0.2284824401,
0.3924378455,
0.6670128107,
0.2982458174,
-0.0882865936,
-0.0762148425,
0.0734981075,
-0.250928551,
-0.0100642079,
-0.1566655636,
-0.1556475163,
-0.1272482574,
0.8030538559,
0.9667860866,
0.9384806752,
-0.6876062155,
0.1854260117,
0.0382086523,
-0.5409075022,
-0.063119933,
0.3884953558,
0.3340489268,
0.1275169402,
0.0259388927,
-0.4723516703,
-0.2200831175,
-0.6521963477,
0.1234747395,
0.298872143,
-0.403393209,
-0.1776683033,
0.5339613557,
0.3629769683,
-0.7266128659,
0.8881685138,
-0.057714954,
-0.4126755595,
0.2552050948,
0.7640358806,
0.9335830808,
-0.1954730153,
0.2501020432,
0.3483621478,
0.4496559203,
0.0521241091,
0.2862593532,
0.1225768626,
-0.3448853195,
-0.5609793067,
-0.7798269987,
-0.4407004714,
-0.0422946699,
-0.6173440814,
0.2006008774,
-0.4517315328,
0.3844254017,
0.2211058438,
-0.0882545635,
-0.4884283841,
-0.0434441119,
-0.1842771322,
1.0021715164,
-0.592754662,
0.8933332562,
0.6203350425,
-0.4164479077,
-0.7763507366,
0.0493289195,
0.0945856124,
-0.7077068686,
0.665600419,
0.1644479036,
-0.285097748,
-0.018835526,
-0.5515795946,
-0.7541449666,
1.0865534544,
0.2278756052,
-0.7099350095,
-0.2754587531,
0.1775228232,
0.5958801508,
-0.5689852834,
0.0652625337,
0.3650907874,
0.4789890945,
-0.0729624256,
-0.7462652922,
0.0977220833,
-0.113698557,
-0.0349416211,
0.5855844617,
-0.4468491077,
0.8346716762,
-0.2862232029,
-0.0323569849,
0.1775752902,
0.5979766846,
0.2130324244,
0.2292447537,
0.321743995,
0.6514357328,
0.7794297338,
-0.0711893737,
1.0720740557,
0.0378663391,
0.0013688906,
1.4631686211,
-0.3923042715,
1.0563155413,
0.4958004951,
0.1315490752,
0.8265953064,
0.353387028,
-0.0367796682,
0.3561423123,
0.6509479284,
0.0339496769,
-0.3332666159,
0.0771203563,
-0.0939598158,
0.3010982573,
0.0347776338,
-0.4783228338,
-0.390761286,
0.1357363462,
-0.0796775892,
0.5206009746,
-0.4051029384,
0.7617823482,
-0.0632362068,
-0.9736952186,
0.5918907523,
0.3319695592,
0.7477090955,
-0.6057376266,
-0.1934888363,
-0.171727851,
0.430672437,
-0.2128377706,
-0.6458851695,
0.1853066385,
0.1744912118,
-0.2916404605,
-0.4320080876,
0.507342875,
-0.6579877138,
-0.5426127911,
0.164720878,
0.0939172059,
-0.0092052585,
-0.0871829689,
-0.5603762269,
0.001464593,
0.2418231964,
-0.3719582558,
0.4774729908,
0.6106467843,
-0.4447362125,
0.767768383,
0.7842209935,
-0.1068487316,
0.2467016429,
0.2701381743,
0.6499189138,
-0.8085352778,
-0.4446127117,
-0.6028706431,
0.3839277029,
-0.2848744392,
-0.6299530268,
1.0520060062,
0.7403646708,
0.9698399901,
-0.0695802122,
0.4951702058,
0.263492763,
0.688670814,
-0.7405555248,
0.4311561584,
-0.4743391275,
-0.0419134237,
-0.097426109,
-0.9315766692,
-0.1007928476,
0.2476389855,
-0.5402163863,
-0.1893194765,
0.6770913005,
0.8108343482,
0.0996059626,
0.0743631497,
0.1843204051,
-0.1192614585,
0.3046267033,
0.7496961355,
0.6462207437,
-0.1795288622,
0.6242670417,
-0.0601860061,
-0.002212038,
-0.4396479726,
-0.8655879498,
-0.9163957238,
-0.2473994344,
-0.2480564117,
-0.1491623372,
0.3050077856,
0.8052384257,
0.3204518259,
-0.652987659,
-0.1534198523,
-0.1210597605,
0.2665799856,
-0.613476336,
-0.1689531803,
0.3660628796,
-0.6975674629,
-0.6390852928,
0.6336613297,
0.3352852166,
-0.456718713,
-0.2986886799,
-0.3162088692,
-0.3042368889,
0.2244660705,
0.5505290627,
0.1518286765,
-0.8824639916,
-0.2350282818,
0.1704111695,
-0.3866905868,
-0.1984654814,
1.1350867748,
-0.5905393362,
0.3102591932,
0.5884628892,
0.8499902487,
0.444855243,
0.0473913327,
0.652071178,
-0.6994488835,
-0.3166311979,
0.1411599964,
0.068377465,
0.337811172,
-0.1721130461,
0.3732362092,
-0.1761300266,
-0.5553552508,
-0.6770967841,
0.1791360825,
-0.5360588431,
-0.5567070246,
0.9666750431,
-0.0667091832,
-0.5118737817,
0.1931948215,
-0.2428036034,
0.2956358492,
-0.1427970827,
0.6496171355,
0.5423847437,
0.0493482091,
-0.0489054285,
-0.3178543448,
0.446151942,
0.4511396587,
-0.8076232672,
0.4221352935,
0.5393618345,
0.3956866264,
-0.1588991433,
0.269719094,
-0.0295490436,
0.3932108879,
-0.0801373869,
0.1802432984,
-0.4536258876,
-0.419675082,
-0.2384734303,
0.1117976531,
-0.1551912129,
-0.0839743093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15684v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15684v1 | Perturbation-based Self-supervised Attention for Attention Bias in Text Classification | 2023-05-25T03:18:18 | 2023-05-25T03:18:18 | Huawen Feng, Zhenxi Lin, Qianli Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL | In text classification, the traditional attention mechanisms usually focus
too much on frequent words, and need extensive labeled data in order to learn.
This paper proposes a perturbation-based self-supervised attention approach to
guide attention learning without any annotation overhead. Specifically, we add
as much noise as possible to all the words in the sentence without changing
their semantics and predictions. We hypothesize that words that tolerate more
noise are less significant, and we can use this information to refine the
attention distribution. Experimental results on three text classification tasks
show that our approach can significantly improve the performance of current
attention-based models, and is more effective than existing self-supervised
methods. We also provide a visualization analysis to verify the effectiveness
of our approach. | [
-0.3779991269,
-0.9761542678,
0.5848906636,
0.4174986482,
-0.2915794253,
-0.484252125,
-0.1018748134,
-0.4758623838,
0.4448672235,
0.9734255672,
-0.7766842246,
-0.4292767644,
-0.603173852,
0.1978870332,
-0.4042047858,
1.1852992773,
0.0407703072,
-0.2324238271,
-0.3461157084,
0.0721075311,
-0.2925215065,
-0.7501692772,
-0.3840741813,
-0.1994208544,
0.6526827812,
0.3924865723,
0.2263957262,
0.8718689084,
0.5403791666,
0.2730119526,
-0.2374579906,
0.0291666426,
-0.6325299144,
0.2843458951,
-0.0089202691,
-0.3349550664,
-0.3311395645,
0.1898420155,
0.5859213471,
0.5803567171,
0.1483580172,
0.2463388294,
0.3516860604,
0.5992974639,
-0.7726268768,
0.1755875349,
-0.2718346715,
0.2465587854,
-0.2204858214,
-0.3459950089,
-0.3579548597,
0.0763130635,
0.1794445515,
-0.6060807705,
0.275616467,
-0.0284041353,
0.4145335555,
0.9266211987,
-0.4182725251,
-0.0648498833,
-0.7581946254,
0.8411231637,
-0.3646088243,
0.4106175005,
0.4545131922,
-0.2224639952,
-0.0760620013,
-0.6459349394,
-0.2041428089,
-0.1907303333,
0.0515577495,
0.4465771019,
0.1357557029,
0.3276483715,
0.6604033709,
0.3135602772,
-0.2104394734,
-0.0927260891,
-0.0324716903,
-0.1531784683,
0.5444668531,
0.003847332,
0.0099970847,
0.0383208618,
-0.6030154228,
-0.0748429373,
-0.3214585781,
-0.0421405472,
0.4204781353,
0.1753500998,
0.0667430982,
0.3855635822,
-0.4534245133,
0.7238240838,
0.454048425,
-0.000472324,
0.1467448026,
-0.3380474448,
-0.3224844933,
0.354711175,
0.6276594996,
0.2159941792,
0.2329313606,
-0.2321350127,
-0.0189474765,
0.0322104357,
0.3858858943,
-0.9023808837,
-0.5287624598,
0.065245524,
-0.4805165529,
-0.7038368583,
-0.1845737845,
-1.1361249685,
-0.3281722963,
-0.2843721807,
0.61464715,
-0.0758260414,
0.2174022496,
0.0550483987,
0.0883183479,
-0.3200617135,
0.3120667338,
-1.0028605461,
0.1760644764,
0.107782118,
0.6338438392,
-0.1613877863,
-0.212575987,
-0.5780145526,
0.3488899171,
-0.2519100904,
1.127617836,
-0.6692683697,
-0.1929104924,
-0.1279906034,
-0.2090727836,
0.0280510206,
-0.1482145488,
0.6027802229,
-0.2938157916,
0.2440114021,
-0.2176758647,
-0.5768482685,
-0.2704286873,
0.1149941608,
-0.5309227705,
0.8472357988,
-0.0816500187,
-1.1364637613,
0.2810048461,
-0.8352587819,
-0.6989512444,
-0.1230094209,
-0.0801654235,
-0.6599101424,
0.0011648795,
0.5162932277,
0.4262154996,
0.1082040668,
-0.098524712,
-0.3500494361,
-0.4469412267,
0.2995916903,
-0.5676296949,
0.5011426806,
0.11763376,
-0.5780156255,
0.2694905996,
-0.8795962334,
-0.2558785677,
-0.1078635976,
-0.1946659535,
-0.551178813,
0.2081319988,
0.0661062747,
0.0965252593,
0.2670611739,
-0.5051193833,
0.2486692369,
-0.5523840785,
0.1482782364,
0.8300254345,
0.3046946228,
0.5014619827,
-0.0960347578,
0.4714990854,
0.033618778,
0.2071252763,
-0.3836726546,
-0.2234413177,
-0.8850644231,
-0.507658124,
0.3805221617,
0.1935513169,
-0.3698220253,
0.3817978799,
0.2439360172,
-0.0977698416,
-0.4381611645,
0.4068990052,
0.2278423011,
0.6808686852,
0.5641337037,
-0.2000436187,
-0.4709410667,
-0.8143036962,
-0.3860673904,
0.2209032774,
0.0872023702,
0.3037054539,
0.1454649121,
-0.4399146438,
0.6847290397,
-0.6915934682,
-0.8456172943,
0.1035059541,
0.3749424219,
-0.1961154938,
0.3768236935,
0.3582620621,
-0.6040782332,
-0.4211353958,
-0.3331420422,
-0.4060126841,
-0.5671126246,
-0.3383573592,
-0.0451368354,
0.097503446,
1.0158159733,
-0.0442975499,
0.6284786463,
0.404573828,
-0.2311745882,
0.3632413149,
0.0659541711,
-0.2197671831,
-0.620814383,
-0.0023041661,
0.3140283823,
-0.2705278695,
-0.7416589856,
-0.1980075091,
-0.0459327884,
0.1547828466,
-0.058765091,
0.482167691,
-0.5163964629,
0.3181370795,
-0.6747375727,
0.067886658,
-0.2070995718,
0.5835069418,
0.2332289368,
0.4228546917,
0.565072298,
-0.7354717851,
0.2502673864,
0.204420656,
0.0606199503,
0.3694987893,
-0.5060946941,
0.2411698997,
-0.5096482038,
0.4441295266,
-1.2965428829,
-0.2905892432,
0.3421860337,
-0.3612434268,
0.2666270137,
0.082176581,
-0.3473195732,
-0.1748472303,
-0.5298135877,
0.3740803003,
0.0938946009,
-0.6115158796,
0.4958066046,
0.3218751848,
0.0877999365,
-0.5507166386,
-0.8353765011,
-0.0564101227,
-0.2764562666,
-0.1288617104,
0.2999236286,
-0.1776705384,
-0.0547164194,
-0.1051510945,
-0.3591666818,
-0.060167145,
0.1664716005,
0.4797742963,
0.0164552424,
0.2023993582,
0.5666812658,
-0.0639787465,
-0.1613555998,
0.0671104789,
-0.4370701611,
0.3253605664,
0.3728789985,
0.0505592786,
-0.845367074,
0.1674085408,
0.3781248629,
-0.4203536212,
0.2185924053,
0.6631454229,
-0.255227536,
-0.2496101409,
-0.7572062612,
-0.5269209743,
-0.5201298594,
0.3590881526,
-0.1666587889,
-0.9340524077,
0.1346269548,
0.0002560812,
-0.0410475805,
0.4000962675,
0.430855751,
-0.3788990676,
1.087395668,
0.7327292562,
-0.2669324279,
0.9265246987,
0.194736436,
-0.0419057496,
-0.8580350876,
0.0554008037,
-0.4758485258,
-0.4281063378,
-0.5487211943,
-0.0921350569,
0.1874276102,
-0.3779300451,
-0.2135920376,
-0.1734469682,
-1.0404660702,
0.2864707708,
0.6285780668,
0.3130879998,
0.2745465338,
0.3248446882,
0.3713554144,
-0.2740446329,
-0.6428707242,
-0.1226197332,
1.2148832083,
0.3973410726,
0.9806665778,
-0.385540694,
0.7365984917,
0.1965577453,
0.428804338,
-0.7229384184,
0.2986798584,
-0.1496686637,
-0.6609147787,
-0.6002908945,
-0.54060781,
-1.0893113613,
0.187526226,
-0.3136840761,
-0.8565573096,
0.1707680821,
0.2578507066,
-0.3391192853,
-0.0320368633,
-0.6526145339,
0.8025963306,
-0.1111152321,
-0.4728643596,
-0.1157613844,
-0.4470645785,
0.1498875022,
-0.2453904301,
0.4167810678,
0.1703172922,
-0.1356698573,
1.0401073694,
-0.08705578,
1.1426390409,
-0.1103647426,
-0.1376880258,
0.3952006698,
-0.2342334986,
0.5760223866,
-0.1110594124,
0.3346807659,
-0.1165870428,
-0.2206380665,
-0.363597095,
-0.4895431101,
0.7635047436,
-0.7096069455,
-0.6155100465,
-0.3680568039,
-0.551094532,
-0.2478711307,
0.1994968802,
0.3674268723,
0.1292719841,
0.2607086003,
0.246295765,
0.9370996952,
0.1594973505,
0.4168072343,
0.3131973445,
-0.16213274,
-0.3143074811,
0.7518205643,
0.5271005034,
-0.0799585208,
0.3256478608,
0.3197731972,
-0.452136755,
-0.409721911,
0.1537911594,
0.1005138978,
-0.493750006,
-0.0898637027,
-0.9598882198,
0.0415673703,
-0.519974947,
-0.0773181394,
-0.2304185778,
-0.1951117367,
-0.5204928517,
0.0685595348,
0.3905180097,
0.6459317207,
0.1411655694,
0.6258658171,
-0.2985173762,
0.3605604172,
0.6149792671,
0.6670906544,
-0.0183639638,
-0.7391447425,
-0.1682671458,
-0.2735895514,
-0.5148910284,
-1.1321872473,
0.2830370367,
-0.0154421227,
0.4708030224,
0.5293359756,
0.3031480312,
0.5961705446,
-0.3101485372,
0.4463844895,
0.1890527159,
-0.9131792784,
0.6296944022,
-0.4282392263,
0.4790694714,
0.514367044,
0.1341832727,
-0.2483250946,
-0.5688124895,
-0.7881544828,
-0.7635982633,
0.7757467628,
0.0909355059,
0.2260423303,
0.1788750887,
0.69943434,
-0.1694600135,
0.1325209737,
-0.9454823136,
-0.3482095897,
-0.3542090058,
-0.3105677366,
-0.2146824598,
-0.4735682011,
0.0668588057,
-0.1789187789,
0.599665761,
-0.0993935764,
0.1887082309,
0.7722482085,
-0.1353348345,
-0.2656403184,
0.0505186766,
0.4648607671,
0.0521995313,
-0.2278577983,
0.223867625,
0.3192228675,
-0.7338279486,
0.1092232391,
0.1293800771,
-0.4692128897,
-0.0950077176,
0.1260531843,
0.5365357995,
0.2255170196,
-0.2811188698,
0.4685434699,
0.0209666695,
-0.4832213521,
-0.105192937,
0.1241810098,
-0.1340114623,
0.2871423662,
0.3468011618,
-0.1186773628,
0.585067153,
-0.1860716045,
0.2901874185,
0.3756239712,
-0.7394073606,
-0.0108560966,
0.8790522814,
0.2661791444,
-0.0666648746,
0.2176527083,
0.0821321756,
-0.4748292267,
0.5060625672,
0.5687760115,
0.840862155,
-0.4793976843,
-0.0787550956,
0.3048983812,
0.4265132248,
-0.1183118224,
0.040561229,
-0.2411819696,
-0.3206510246,
-0.8353338838,
-0.3222770095,
-0.4365618229,
0.443341881,
-0.466219455,
0.1626965702,
-0.7619361281,
-0.2386562079,
0.2918022871,
0.0486201383,
-0.1850651205,
0.6290761828,
0.1271200031,
0.3892620206,
-0.7905626297,
0.6687614322,
0.9946876168,
-0.240333423,
-0.2976774275,
0.5539205074,
-0.25699386,
-0.2194273174,
0.5463969111,
0.4322219491,
-0.1943199635,
0.2661074996,
-0.9647223949,
-1.0844455957,
0.3966099322,
0.203593269,
-0.6973532438,
0.3474713564,
-0.2372416258,
0.6729975343,
-0.0113131478,
0.0202559307,
0.1132044867,
0.6306104064,
-0.0151773384,
-0.4206858873,
-0.0229408201,
0.1224137694,
-0.0877184942,
0.1122928634,
-0.9672736526,
0.4850575924,
0.0056907227,
-0.1801402569,
-0.3888687491,
0.9600093961,
-0.3736588061,
0.3384446204,
0.448402673,
0.3509648144,
0.6230995059,
0.0514099449,
0.8785386086,
-0.2378191948,
0.6053749323,
1.2349324226,
-0.0018338063,
0.4619754255,
0.6280866861,
-0.1499791741,
0.2065891922,
0.3905739188,
-0.1967983246,
0.4806676209,
0.2806997597,
-0.013715365,
-0.4782122374,
-0.0637665391,
-0.1014972776,
0.4405749142,
0.1984432936,
-0.349280268,
-0.065131411,
0.0417543426,
-0.196720928,
0.2744575441,
-0.4705720842,
0.7448120117,
-0.149503842,
-0.4693002701,
0.5079247355,
-0.3045932651,
0.9150887728,
-0.1408240795,
0.0618477762,
0.0057212505,
0.2886570096,
-0.3287675381,
-0.4554792643,
0.2598683834,
-0.189622134,
-0.3265220523,
-0.1808990091,
0.8657375574,
-0.4994622171,
-0.5614611506,
0.2045051605,
0.0154597703,
0.1276582778,
-0.5305097103,
-0.3005613685,
-0.2083455771,
0.256831795,
-0.4880545735,
0.4863402545,
0.3440983593,
0.1412725449,
0.623495996,
0.4945245981,
-0.2109970152,
0.0940520093,
-0.1922980994,
0.7589948773,
-0.6514880657,
-0.5596681833,
-0.9309211373,
0.1550085396,
-0.1080522314,
-0.2539803982,
0.8086966276,
0.3441230059,
0.5491044521,
-0.071691595,
0.8905822635,
0.5344675779,
0.6388610005,
-0.3555688858,
0.4859504104,
-0.6155187488,
0.0087198876,
-0.4906423986,
-0.8323728442,
-0.7886861563,
0.9405725002,
-0.5162032843,
0.1148622185,
0.5937697887,
0.4493272305,
0.1622661799,
-0.0371849351,
0.3986689746,
0.4737259448,
0.0065912823,
0.2352182567,
0.6383524537,
-0.3180357516,
0.8162650466,
-0.3672657907,
-0.433036536,
-0.5234194398,
-0.7052544355,
-1.1337217093,
-0.2231206745,
-0.5641235113,
-0.374684155,
0.3036836386,
0.6235436797,
0.5077449083,
-0.5649163723,
0.2134556472,
-0.1804702431,
0.0107657425,
-0.2877987325,
-0.1999673247,
0.4996118844,
-0.8549520373,
-0.9086807966,
0.1475043446,
0.2338316143,
0.243191123,
-0.127559796,
0.4765657187,
-0.1132042632,
0.1266872138,
0.5172182918,
0.1218911782,
-0.3032428324,
-0.1562783718,
-0.0526969954,
-0.1784870774,
0.2174781561,
0.6051746607,
-0.6846407056,
0.5843433142,
0.2944787741,
0.5466624498,
0.9161740541,
0.311031431,
0.0776732415,
-0.767668426,
0.3737674057,
0.1785793602,
0.0104430225,
-0.050728485,
-0.7116211057,
0.3053138554,
0.2181569785,
-0.7585688829,
-0.5266301036,
0.1119313762,
-0.8401210308,
-0.3632040918,
1.3411134481,
0.0628627986,
-0.3449701369,
-0.3225927055,
-0.5655118227,
0.2953829467,
-0.5927863121,
1.1112833023,
0.7664582133,
-0.1796265841,
-0.2454421073,
-0.4434616566,
0.6321997046,
0.7889870405,
-0.64328897,
0.3953193724,
0.5836167932,
0.240738079,
0.3200788498,
0.4438243508,
-0.01568304,
0.1904745847,
-0.1765563041,
0.1512208581,
0.0616327003,
-0.4056665301,
-0.5610846877,
0.2512806952,
-0.0333888344,
-0.2600703239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15678v1 | Revisiting non-English Text Simplification: A Unified Multilingual Benchmark | 2023-05-25T03:03:29 | 2023-05-25T03:03:29 | Michael J. Ryan, Tarek Naous, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in high-quality, large-scale English resources have
pushed the frontier of English Automatic Text Simplification (ATS) research.
However, less work has been done on multilingual text simplification due to the
lack of a diverse evaluation benchmark that covers complex-simple sentence
pairs in many languages. This paper introduces the MultiSim benchmark, a
collection of 27 resources in 12 distinct languages containing over 1.7 million
complex-simple sentence pairs. This benchmark will encourage research in
developing more effective multilingual text simplification models and
evaluation metrics. Our experiments using MultiSim with pre-trained
multilingual language models reveal exciting performance improvements from
multilingual training in non-English settings. We observe strong performance
from Russian in zero-shot cross-lingual transfer to low-resource languages. We
further show that few-shot prompting with BLOOM-176b achieves comparable
quality to reference simplifications outperforming fine-tuned models in most
languages. We validate these findings through human evaluation. | [
-0.1342162937,
-0.2494620979,
0.3836046755,
0.52681005,
-0.3890746832,
0.0865091383,
-0.4509281218,
-0.4703227282,
0.0954453647,
-0.1171416044,
-0.5967587233,
-0.4099111259,
-0.4866362214,
0.7040436268,
-0.0877563283,
0.7727760077,
-0.2110304981,
0.5177411437,
-0.2168072909,
-0.3922925293,
-0.2852879465,
-0.3090610802,
-0.4498256147,
-0.5639904737,
0.6216827631,
0.6436635256,
0.4605214298,
0.5042752028,
0.6550782919,
0.316106379,
-0.1021657586,
0.4034620523,
-0.297580719,
-0.1037453637,
0.0580755658,
-0.5541295409,
-0.2887819707,
-0.1146855354,
0.9589682817,
0.908082068,
0.0699534714,
0.1563519686,
0.11316479,
0.6068504453,
-0.8634805679,
0.0658211485,
-0.3552831113,
0.0253803041,
-0.208224088,
-0.2474415898,
-0.524099648,
-0.2853161395,
-0.3675011992,
-0.662003994,
0.0265502967,
-0.035270188,
0.6781382561,
0.1941902786,
-0.7306550145,
-0.0323345996,
-0.6972056627,
1.2864598036,
-0.3731631935,
0.5367605686,
0.0450380333,
0.1800055355,
-0.0463541299,
-0.5862669945,
-0.1288686097,
-0.0744603723,
-0.3107942343,
0.1153794453,
-0.2037931234,
-0.0901202559,
0.353055954,
0.126265496,
-0.503554225,
-0.1998714209,
-0.5173677802,
-0.2450378537,
0.660245955,
0.0216505714,
0.2362739295,
-0.2959968448,
-0.4530139565,
-0.0564431734,
-0.8012555838,
0.0322865844,
0.2914524376,
0.468354553,
-0.2179479301,
0.5127350688,
-0.4734506905,
0.3739635646,
-0.5801923275,
-0.3731421232,
0.4963002801,
-0.7522613406,
-0.1868325025,
-0.1787464768,
0.8473806977,
0.3231606483,
0.3032243252,
-0.2842735648,
-0.1648132503,
0.029054828,
-0.0711678863,
-0.8345315456,
0.0557444468,
-0.1448995769,
-0.5148478746,
0.119415611,
0.1112585068,
-0.6048334241,
0.0305517539,
-0.2489007562,
0.3530547321,
-0.4876380563,
-0.1479829103,
0.2739342749,
-0.130792439,
0.0513472408,
0.4951640069,
-0.4329059124,
0.4078082442,
0.6145474911,
0.6917328835,
-0.2329490632,
-0.8353178501,
-0.4339359701,
0.1779886037,
-0.4367082119,
0.8899046183,
-0.3635217845,
-0.3014941514,
-0.172315672,
-0.0061136251,
0.1301023066,
-0.642338872,
0.7016211152,
-0.0038742376,
0.2425069362,
-0.3716338277,
-0.2737423182,
-0.0616211779,
0.2645529509,
-0.547395885,
1.1392095089,
-0.4184724987,
-0.4363714457,
0.5269803405,
-0.7386248112,
-0.7280045748,
0.1052574515,
-0.1399692595,
-0.4641460478,
0.2325132042,
0.0912683904,
0.0939636976,
-0.526350379,
0.1213169843,
-0.2151356339,
-0.6465498209,
-0.0754958019,
-0.8228780031,
0.6312211752,
0.323510021,
-0.1165748909,
-0.1081531793,
-0.7491074204,
0.4924663007,
-0.0585288145,
-0.4790694118,
-0.3336531222,
-0.461512506,
0.2488808781,
0.2812858224,
0.2679572701,
-0.5034670234,
0.0557023473,
-0.0854885951,
0.1081361175,
0.1581603438,
0.0070369234,
0.4804005027,
-0.3576479256,
0.5309079885,
0.1015509814,
0.1380144954,
-0.6568168998,
-0.3464316726,
-0.7559994459,
-0.5839802623,
0.4350630343,
0.4416137934,
-0.5518916249,
-0.0650569722,
-0.3377788365,
-0.4623188078,
-0.673232615,
0.3692554235,
0.7269715071,
-0.0907314643,
0.6506431699,
-0.1869563013,
-0.5136320591,
-1.0974529982,
-0.7998461723,
-0.1190247908,
-0.0357046537,
0.0194145776,
0.3878792822,
-0.0143856872,
0.5666738153,
-0.2322923243,
-0.1749214232,
-0.2554015219,
0.7203946114,
-0.1723614484,
0.3865113258,
0.293010056,
-0.8030714393,
-0.7086830735,
-0.1664138436,
-0.765547514,
-0.2394792587,
-0.1295603216,
0.1291236877,
0.1774485856,
0.7188553214,
-0.4810983837,
0.4022023976,
0.3405171335,
0.0551316552,
0.4049548209,
-0.5011401772,
0.5499541759,
-0.9651176333,
0.2458764315,
-0.0140156681,
-0.3762398362,
-0.5410320759,
0.0440295525,
0.476546526,
-0.2237832546,
-0.8890622854,
0.6335052252,
-0.8985016346,
-0.2068762332,
-0.0075019822,
-0.0545803122,
0.1200603247,
0.2895104885,
-0.2180695832,
0.905660212,
0.3388051093,
-0.3543855846,
0.1856168211,
0.0466599055,
-0.1846057773,
0.5544987321,
-0.4449427426,
-0.1984653473,
-0.3133427203,
0.2379680574,
-1.0691142082,
-0.0414501205,
-0.2120323479,
-0.1357931942,
0.1800079793,
-0.0522494055,
-0.7290940285,
-0.04340804,
-0.5473346114,
0.7547623515,
0.3519201875,
-0.4527184963,
0.5291677713,
-0.1243943274,
-0.2514700592,
-0.501663208,
-0.8792930245,
0.3175817728,
-0.1393787265,
-0.4641505182,
0.3552200496,
-0.3000843823,
-0.4417008162,
-0.2351561636,
0.0119920168,
-0.1160854325,
0.1717593074,
-0.0737277791,
0.1660077721,
-0.1793856025,
0.0884641632,
0.0378426202,
-0.3349377811,
-0.3311595023,
0.2418615073,
0.2750371099,
-0.1763518155,
-0.6681582928,
-0.6094446778,
0.7104515433,
0.5457263589,
-0.1439380646,
0.3631823659,
0.4909663498,
-0.4402622283,
0.0299867075,
-0.5331242681,
-0.3105976582,
-0.4112635851,
0.2863637209,
-0.7347853184,
-0.487291038,
0.260533601,
-0.4386954904,
0.1558146328,
0.4751240313,
0.274538964,
0.0250650905,
0.9237157702,
0.7189928293,
0.1230073348,
0.2083681077,
0.1737587154,
0.2126859128,
-0.1903961301,
-0.1930296272,
-0.6256024837,
-0.2561364174,
-0.6498904228,
-0.3466128707,
0.3663934469,
0.4410432577,
0.2414862812,
0.3531973958,
0.1007982418,
0.9415755868,
0.2747058868,
-0.1807207018,
0.6801533103,
0.0372483768,
-0.1600700021,
-0.3510317504,
-0.6816937923,
-0.6250010729,
1.078861475,
0.0688504428,
0.7935506701,
0.2992813885,
0.8710232973,
0.1609511524,
0.3804106116,
-0.5575253963,
0.5580928326,
-0.3990452886,
-0.3237722218,
-0.1952087283,
-0.5293961167,
-0.841923058,
0.3727319241,
-0.293823123,
-0.317104131,
-0.2745936215,
0.0060223946,
-0.334415108,
-0.0293573197,
-1.0806214809,
0.7173967957,
-0.1618396044,
-0.448692739,
-0.3996460736,
-0.4731928706,
0.1730696857,
-0.1675790101,
0.3700149059,
-0.0809147283,
-0.2438589782,
0.4270483255,
-0.2642128468,
0.5609644055,
0.193459332,
0.0883520246,
-0.1393427551,
-0.1166278198,
0.3882803321,
-0.0281424057,
-0.1459642202,
0.2556242347,
-0.208798781,
-0.5990310907,
-0.3761401176,
0.7552341819,
-0.6172782779,
-0.3052672148,
-0.3264792562,
-0.4480769932,
-0.2356233448,
0.4662770033,
0.330731988,
0.4458188713,
-0.4387248456,
0.287207514,
0.3307183087,
-0.1056899205,
0.627825737,
0.6348233223,
0.0304668397,
-0.404286027,
0.6765366793,
0.1188661307,
0.3096694648,
0.4854766726,
0.002224311,
-0.2858200967,
-0.3209249973,
-0.6598677039,
0.396258086,
-0.8344231844,
-0.2766268253,
-0.6020832658,
0.1198064536,
-0.5225669146,
-0.1030287668,
-0.4525615871,
-0.4347393811,
-0.0562162437,
0.1601491272,
-0.11839398,
0.7442603707,
-0.1424718648,
0.0572477281,
-0.7457319498,
0.4506250918,
0.2106998563,
0.3074733913,
-0.2918304205,
-0.3281829953,
-0.2993575633,
-0.0715254396,
-0.3162733316,
-0.6819642186,
0.0987623483,
0.4367824197,
0.6612992883,
0.1854418963,
-0.2044799924,
0.9836619496,
-0.8362538218,
0.694817245,
0.4453022182,
-0.9640755653,
0.1123926491,
-0.0960184038,
0.7458951473,
0.663895607,
0.4065063,
-0.7994733453,
-0.3705834746,
-0.6619173288,
-0.8279331923,
0.7679883838,
0.2144978046,
-0.0220494512,
0.1552496701,
0.1982775927,
0.1246966049,
0.3116632104,
-0.7598618865,
-0.530123353,
0.1061183512,
-0.2757214308,
-0.341917187,
-0.3461600542,
-0.1038588807,
0.0193193275,
0.8100401163,
-0.229245916,
0.0450413711,
-0.0421445481,
-0.3574596047,
-0.3288893402,
0.6990882754,
0.7963196039,
0.5221400857,
0.2080713511,
0.2055561543,
0.5646995306,
-0.1031367257,
0.3281523585,
0.1773914099,
-0.322116226,
0.3524857759,
0.5567664504,
0.4777793288,
0.4325505197,
-0.635839045,
0.6556137204,
-0.2158578485,
-0.2155491412,
0.0268036667,
-0.2411260158,
0.0098146843,
-0.1012948975,
0.4942557216,
0.157541275,
0.2706508338,
-0.5344222784,
0.2595972717,
0.4336207807,
-0.1603291929,
-0.3430425823,
0.351454705,
0.2672218978,
-0.3599191308,
0.023397943,
-0.3782911897,
-0.3822115958,
0.3880474269,
0.4397184849,
0.6921821237,
-0.2640327811,
0.1240708455,
0.5528514385,
0.5710813999,
-0.3817149103,
0.5430527925,
-0.054402668,
-0.3672831357,
-0.4564200938,
-0.3654787838,
-0.5915865302,
0.1315592527,
-0.604352355,
0.8042223454,
-0.2931430042,
0.1911824048,
0.2576852441,
0.1223472953,
-0.6573348045,
0.3241835535,
0.2422872484,
1.0158176422,
-1.1933529377,
0.6388425231,
0.9755824208,
-0.2879476249,
-0.5961709619,
0.1738284826,
0.164425537,
-0.4272738695,
0.5269755125,
0.3549282253,
-0.4533345997,
-0.2129600048,
-0.2883597016,
-0.6561363339,
0.8485902548,
0.5906538963,
-0.2974409461,
0.2556637526,
0.5671409965,
0.6772378683,
-0.2524145842,
0.6501719356,
0.3037636876,
0.6470457315,
-0.0251448248,
-0.9324032664,
-0.1707971245,
-0.3862426281,
0.0377722196,
0.3885633945,
-0.8195253611,
0.8577981591,
-0.1717127115,
-0.4190308452,
0.1651475877,
0.5664684772,
-0.058620818,
0.1843508035,
0.4897666872,
0.3603985906,
0.6487172246,
-0.1886416227,
0.7453651428,
-0.311322242,
0.2853280306,
1.0196946859,
-0.3104945123,
0.8922177553,
0.9383990765,
-0.0905818939,
0.356231004,
0.3203470707,
0.2654468715,
0.4795746505,
-0.0043056412,
-0.4341763556,
-0.4396849275,
-0.3748789728,
-0.1430686116,
0.359292239,
-0.0892457366,
-0.08770933,
-0.6402973533,
0.046380423,
0.0223536436,
0.3065515161,
-0.1984628886,
0.9954788089,
-0.0467521362,
-0.8994163871,
0.5674566031,
0.4117791653,
0.919654429,
-0.8284685612,
0.0060583698,
-0.3650843203,
0.3836798668,
-0.2219635397,
-0.5424186587,
0.3680970073,
0.126570493,
-0.1574537456,
-0.6091391444,
0.5391789675,
-0.9197802544,
-0.4939816892,
0.4724455476,
0.688303113,
0.3125292957,
0.1553713977,
-0.7035198808,
0.0216028076,
0.0890569463,
-0.0352112986,
0.1350566745,
0.674465239,
-0.120608516,
0.623110652,
0.6015251279,
0.0730229393,
-0.0027729769,
0.2486254126,
0.5922705531,
-0.6202951074,
-0.5505289435,
-0.8468291759,
0.4113101661,
-0.1269582212,
-0.5043521523,
0.9686918855,
0.9846004844,
1.0174454451,
0.0342243537,
0.6806496978,
0.4281920195,
0.5118044615,
-0.4107638299,
0.5247500539,
-1.1025122404,
0.0016405638,
-0.1836751252,
-0.7584665418,
-0.5512481332,
0.2610759437,
-0.0250195507,
0.0242857486,
0.9942870736,
0.7302212715,
-0.3046814203,
-0.04791978,
0.6308925152,
-0.166273281,
0.1126724333,
0.380797863,
0.5424028635,
-0.7885305285,
0.9364638329,
-0.2856579423,
-0.1160657853,
-0.1440594047,
-1.0360484123,
-0.6939293742,
-0.3209801912,
-0.3828494847,
-0.0043948069,
0.0189500712,
1.2410010099,
0.5679155588,
-0.790273428,
-0.3996668756,
0.1904668063,
-0.102852352,
-0.4118813574,
-0.0861777589,
-0.1523299962,
-0.5759171844,
-0.8577774167,
0.6143264771,
0.5086061954,
0.2224107832,
-0.2517099082,
-0.1980199516,
-0.3019385636,
0.1366044879,
0.4449429214,
0.1676613539,
-0.6166246533,
0.1275575906,
0.0125202611,
-0.520950377,
0.1720850319,
0.9305182099,
-0.3851644099,
0.3369888663,
0.4323090017,
0.4661644995,
0.2966959178,
-0.1268532127,
0.5678902864,
-1.1673318148,
0.5181669593,
-0.0306693334,
0.5735676885,
0.7527769804,
-0.0232300367,
0.4637426138,
0.2124376148,
-0.0701178238,
-0.8583546281,
0.2251394093,
-0.3723194897,
-0.2199286073,
1.2830221653,
-0.2617175579,
-0.1346057653,
-0.0966570452,
-0.0720113143,
0.1072281748,
-0.3931111395,
0.5939990282,
0.8959329128,
0.204261288,
-0.1963406354,
-0.0646720901,
0.6471738815,
0.9675768018,
-1.2045502663,
0.2081772238,
0.4395070374,
0.2179784328,
0.3655503094,
0.6375566721,
-0.0714312568,
0.52999717,
-0.1598350555,
0.3042076826,
0.0664057359,
-0.6718673706,
-0.7801294327,
0.0126881534,
0.111482501,
-0.0051259925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15676v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15676v2 | Enhancing Grammatical Error Correction Systems with Explanations | 2023-05-25T03:00:49 | 2023-06-10T05:41:34 | Yuejiao Fei, Leyang Cui, Sen Yang, Wai Lam, Zhenzhong Lan, Shuming Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grammatical error correction systems improve written communication by
detecting and correcting language mistakes. To help language learners better
understand why the GEC system makes a certain correction, the causes of errors
(evidence words) and the corresponding error types are two key factors. To
enhance GEC systems with explanations, we introduce EXPECT, a large dataset
annotated with evidence words and grammatical error types. We propose several
baselines and analysis to understand this task. Furthermore, human evaluation
verifies our explainable GEC system's explanations can assist second-language
learners in determining whether to accept a correction suggestion and in
understanding the associated grammar rule. | [
-0.1163026839,
-0.8639256358,
0.7854219079,
0.1701712757,
0.0579059459,
-0.1738649756,
-0.327460885,
-0.3891507983,
0.0202358607,
0.0865873694,
-0.6412620544,
-0.1692942679,
-0.6680058837,
0.3637673557,
-0.3041050732,
0.9535546899,
-0.1657540649,
0.2859009504,
-0.3079169095,
0.1533108652,
-0.8241346478,
-0.4782130718,
-1.028686285,
-0.3022311628,
0.3747025132,
1.0938886404,
0.7789894342,
0.5178453922,
0.4601559937,
0.3742390871,
0.0108831907,
0.3902882934,
-0.329911679,
0.0102630034,
-0.2534138858,
-0.6717071533,
-0.6665520072,
-0.3596672714,
0.5539081693,
0.7523437738,
-0.1337734461,
-0.1722135246,
0.1848667562,
0.69201684,
-0.672840476,
0.2734766304,
-0.1425873339,
-0.0664575696,
-0.2266644388,
-0.2668038309,
-0.5633306503,
-0.5658971071,
-0.1598667651,
-0.71197474,
0.3992203474,
-0.333676666,
0.7275468707,
-0.1037674546,
-0.2695070803,
-0.5091319084,
-0.8728328943,
0.295686543,
-0.6063033938,
0.2157792598,
0.4007441998,
0.228137061,
-0.444580704,
-0.4061692059,
-0.5562217832,
-0.0073818862,
-0.3936864734,
0.3701603413,
-0.1270634681,
0.4356313348,
0.3737927377,
0.4138340056,
-0.6778435707,
0.0492639244,
-0.1784959435,
-0.4657493234,
0.4869915545,
-0.0219648127,
0.5566214323,
-0.0000989938,
0.2218687683,
-0.0594090298,
-0.7335425615,
0.1772405803,
0.6034796238,
0.1559993029,
0.0529098362,
0.4019484222,
-0.2544323504,
0.7500627041,
-0.0131497169,
0.2619068027,
-0.0280244034,
-0.3272149265,
-0.3335522413,
0.0048984955,
0.1727076769,
0.5573328137,
0.3385155499,
-0.0927786827,
-0.1680827588,
0.6039696336,
-0.0007511447,
-0.3064852357,
-0.1857470423,
0.0702465251,
-0.4242143631,
-0.2557148933,
0.5290961266,
-1.0335403681,
-0.2672205865,
-0.5250715613,
0.5018646121,
-0.2473288476,
-0.3802006245,
0.2493213415,
-0.4913049638,
-0.1107193008,
0.5255758762,
-1.3285617828,
0.6559490561,
0.6188952327,
0.4836299121,
0.2643220425,
-0.2706786394,
-0.4647143781,
-0.2243471891,
-0.5056880713,
1.2304329872,
-0.3126647472,
-0.4062445164,
0.4326387346,
0.3378737271,
0.0431912541,
-0.4412280917,
0.6773579717,
-0.2696222961,
0.5558567047,
-0.728289187,
-0.6596951485,
-0.2770335078,
-0.1723673791,
-0.4312212169,
0.9383782744,
0.1259301901,
-0.5255154371,
0.5049734116,
-0.8237748146,
-0.632248342,
0.1408630759,
0.2050095052,
-0.0258404724,
0.4350970685,
0.3706888556,
0.4135384262,
0.1182226166,
0.1942933947,
0.036963243,
-0.4840178192,
0.2903033197,
-0.253389895,
0.6425971985,
0.2031064034,
-0.4989494979,
0.0985736176,
-0.7123352289,
0.0893520117,
0.1054323316,
-0.558149457,
-0.1582871079,
0.434312284,
-0.1326443106,
-0.2827592194,
0.0657038242,
-0.3469953239,
-0.0397690833,
-0.1944176853,
0.3123080432,
0.7531728148,
0.004758948,
0.3905597031,
-0.2433291376,
0.5938134193,
-0.2088067979,
0.157492429,
-0.4951482713,
-0.4103553295,
-1.0334699154,
0.3236215115,
0.0458951965,
0.7225267887,
-0.6260015368,
0.2156576514,
-0.2199179381,
0.0028196047,
-0.1691704541,
0.1801716983,
0.640743196,
0.5434744358,
0.2932263315,
-0.0636696965,
-0.9785470366,
-0.6313511133,
-0.4468865693,
-0.5987293124,
-0.0208759122,
-0.0488925576,
0.2406851202,
-0.0478470959,
0.7289158106,
-0.3097308576,
0.2459380478,
-0.1993796974,
0.0011959812,
-0.1149517223,
0.2392853051,
0.3574230969,
-0.4588609934,
-0.2219452262,
-0.0101513565,
-0.7035877109,
-0.5532239676,
-0.2244337052,
-0.0146021191,
0.3305137455,
0.7434815764,
0.0114861624,
0.4513559043,
0.3659168482,
-0.7850732207,
0.7319179177,
-0.4989199936,
0.2122055441,
-0.6025960445,
-0.4473496675,
-0.0331166312,
-0.437112093,
-0.6066886187,
-0.135755986,
0.0656887665,
0.2122449726,
0.2516175508,
-0.0739451423,
-0.4481644928,
-0.1104173064,
-0.273850888,
0.4068770111,
0.0932453051,
0.0110687353,
-0.1633702368,
0.5866215825,
0.4653367996,
-0.4846076965,
0.6138884425,
0.045980908,
0.02183,
0.7315903902,
-0.5885952115,
0.0507499538,
-0.4547793865,
0.0142702451,
-1.2565416098,
-0.7045200467,
0.2209183127,
-0.6618021727,
0.2956458926,
0.0084979078,
-0.304902643,
-0.461322844,
0.1304325759,
-0.3076408207,
0.2564022839,
-0.8019863367,
0.2831527889,
0.0554093383,
-0.401263386,
-0.6169752479,
-0.6903238893,
0.3077913523,
0.0730097368,
-0.6809010506,
0.0666639134,
0.1209658012,
-0.6358644366,
0.2021561861,
0.2259561568,
0.1075853333,
0.3612508178,
0.3419112563,
0.3695760667,
-0.4663665295,
0.6913874149,
0.1857876778,
-0.1910675913,
0.2394116074,
-0.2642987072,
0.2207751274,
-0.3980979323,
-0.1941128969,
-0.5370230675,
0.5680930018,
0.2597668171,
0.2627341747,
0.4726420045,
0.1351659,
-0.5659976006,
0.0374209881,
-0.6699784994,
-0.1459263116,
-0.421574533,
0.4906984866,
-0.3093473911,
-0.581567049,
0.4826834202,
0.1718024909,
-0.1247653961,
0.7163079977,
0.3667811155,
-0.1118706539,
0.8820915818,
0.6198360324,
0.0957850963,
0.5418928862,
0.3208701313,
0.023660915,
-0.2253822386,
-0.2499883324,
-0.7241850495,
0.0301604122,
-0.3213145137,
-0.0521298684,
-0.1908389032,
0.3806719184,
-0.219812274,
0.2338080555,
-0.3861741424,
0.6770945191,
0.5053339601,
0.1254196465,
0.3096215725,
0.1815909445,
-0.1113464013,
-0.0860499814,
-0.495542407,
-0.7492708564,
0.7502285242,
0.3264423311,
0.8012806177,
0.2454367876,
0.4539832473,
0.3759205341,
0.3515824676,
-0.7249574065,
0.3126078844,
-0.2987614572,
-0.5440891385,
-0.3212222159,
-0.1534630805,
-0.4067492485,
0.0233340394,
-0.3385737836,
-0.8075316548,
0.3873016834,
0.6023514867,
-0.3398731649,
0.0293360632,
-1.2429397106,
0.722502172,
-0.2171436548,
-0.0120214103,
-0.1149805486,
-0.456923306,
0.1773300171,
0.4323999882,
0.2741387188,
0.4366341233,
0.1928254962,
0.7128443718,
-0.6820962429,
0.8451674581,
-0.5135740638,
-0.02779717,
0.3640170395,
0.0142190382,
0.6606553197,
-0.1216693223,
-0.1775904,
-0.2941384614,
-0.3529825211,
-0.2142721415,
-0.7233033776,
0.3104555011,
-0.5351969004,
-0.469455868,
-0.1945644915,
-0.2125487626,
-0.2549099028,
-0.2667581439,
0.5014663935,
0.4275596142,
-0.3042880893,
-0.044514101,
0.4722893536,
0.1241625175,
0.4896632433,
0.4127729535,
-0.1824660301,
-0.1941039711,
0.5704597831,
0.0153317871,
0.276062578,
0.1490498781,
0.1340753138,
-0.2583397329,
-0.6054165959,
-0.5417749286,
-0.0477007963,
-0.9813194275,
-0.035199482,
-0.4754404128,
0.2062144876,
-0.7136811614,
-0.2527574599,
0.1568724513,
-0.4563812912,
-0.4303387403,
-0.6598131657,
0.52947402,
1.02818501,
-0.5130444765,
0.818467617,
-0.5648306608,
0.1511163414,
0.403732419,
0.3384822905,
-0.1423345208,
-0.7037016749,
-0.1468740702,
0.1535828859,
-0.1797375977,
-1.0276123285,
-0.0866739005,
0.4475086927,
0.4587588608,
0.7147471309,
-0.7671330571,
1.0517693758,
-0.5453520417,
0.8528780341,
0.1120537296,
-1.3122866154,
0.9546335936,
-0.2357539833,
-0.0297682807,
0.2623820901,
-0.0450102314,
-1.0702525377,
-0.1978723258,
-0.6580016017,
-0.3814996779,
0.7284216881,
0.0185727235,
-0.005695086,
-0.1669527739,
0.8928611279,
-0.070250161,
-0.4600950778,
-0.6309539676,
-0.0069859959,
-0.2151287645,
-0.3748633564,
-0.3084351122,
-0.7480532527,
-0.1439903975,
0.1987429559,
0.9369385839,
-0.2788948715,
0.490457207,
0.540805161,
-0.3527448773,
-0.5165252686,
0.6421589851,
1.0993692875,
0.7992002964,
0.3038360775,
0.2406969965,
0.2541335523,
-0.4684157372,
0.1194798797,
0.1448104531,
0.0823538378,
0.1501001418,
0.723534584,
0.6851665378,
-0.1459252089,
-0.3240330219,
0.4379399717,
-0.1717521697,
-0.0971431136,
-0.2568175197,
0.2175984681,
0.1769597977,
-0.0479808897,
0.2406298071,
0.1614531279,
0.1038537845,
-0.551595211,
0.0537879542,
0.186963439,
-0.3736850917,
-0.494153142,
0.3404330015,
0.1083224788,
-0.4821382463,
0.3140413761,
-0.2341725379,
-0.6383229494,
0.7810122371,
0.7795212865,
0.3811740577,
-0.6142631173,
0.6286684275,
0.2275119424,
0.4764046371,
-0.4478220046,
0.6454938054,
0.2271256,
-0.8530164957,
-0.5660007596,
0.0077195358,
-0.297390759,
-0.1216156334,
-0.7734891176,
0.2173409164,
-0.4199456871,
0.0913685262,
0.2558219433,
-0.347461015,
-0.456505537,
0.4385575056,
0.2237826586,
0.6692078114,
-1.395095706,
0.2617050707,
0.8611527681,
-0.2748882473,
-0.9836307764,
-0.3893287778,
0.3825010657,
-0.8367062807,
0.7743890882,
-0.0984254032,
-0.2116183043,
-0.4856237471,
-0.5460479856,
-0.4653999805,
0.5242621899,
0.3356131613,
-0.7397227287,
0.068356514,
0.0670837164,
0.832287848,
-0.3133353889,
0.3469779193,
0.648060739,
0.6303902864,
-0.2791957855,
-0.6073397398,
0.2066989839,
-0.1701053828,
0.1040101424,
0.2285117656,
-0.0174828116,
0.5247809291,
-0.4534941316,
-0.3130381405,
0.2375218123,
0.5507327914,
-0.3300964832,
0.3086612821,
0.6605154872,
0.5795884132,
1.1188111305,
-0.5731998682,
1.1126137972,
0.4750353992,
0.3971327245,
1.3328562975,
0.050036598,
0.6189416647,
0.4045846164,
-0.3604712486,
0.991696775,
0.9780228734,
0.1376519203,
0.0756679252,
0.1062747836,
-0.3957949281,
-0.2928756475,
0.041798953,
-0.3051382899,
0.3828472197,
0.7215628624,
-0.5977264047,
-0.1727831066,
0.0889622346,
0.0209849924,
0.1929154098,
-0.4443292022,
0.9767181277,
-0.3983972669,
-1.0495131016,
0.336601764,
-0.0408446714,
0.245998323,
-0.197784096,
-0.1784478426,
-0.2606698871,
0.4660915434,
-0.7074543238,
-0.7703353167,
0.2493245453,
0.144885093,
-0.4431604445,
-0.0202306882,
1.0641032457,
-0.3411423862,
-0.3662914932,
0.1815677285,
0.2667062283,
0.2405470461,
0.014788745,
-0.2622629106,
-0.214095816,
0.0205453895,
0.1527461112,
-0.3338728547,
0.4732929766,
-0.119020015,
0.2845976055,
0.4497458935,
0.2757265866,
0.1062230542,
0.2261217833,
0.5245181918,
-0.4850717485,
-0.4644512236,
-0.8830135465,
0.7322232723,
-0.2621077299,
-0.1276570261,
0.5148477554,
0.2990353107,
0.6394996047,
-0.2658889592,
0.8542084694,
-0.1445780993,
0.5808376074,
-0.6133391261,
0.2061202079,
-0.1442032754,
0.0410740823,
-0.2107046992,
-0.6193313599,
-0.4709266126,
0.6294516325,
-0.1902326345,
-0.1246534511,
1.1131329536,
0.8641628623,
0.2312779725,
0.659391284,
0.1422179192,
0.3457981646,
0.1238442436,
0.3627529144,
0.9651767612,
-0.5019202828,
0.4418314993,
-0.070291318,
-0.6261711121,
-0.3816376925,
-0.7406213284,
-0.4476947784,
-0.3611935973,
-0.3460276425,
-0.6942350268,
0.515853405,
0.596657455,
0.5383399725,
-1.0998073816,
0.0546699986,
-0.6528174877,
0.3135949671,
-0.4622829556,
-0.2859791219,
0.2050009668,
-0.7458449602,
-0.5807138085,
0.3835889101,
0.1430299282,
0.1688028723,
0.1671752334,
-0.1138363481,
0.1194929257,
-0.3044811189,
0.5717120171,
0.4305849075,
-0.7464404106,
-0.8532758951,
0.0713221952,
0.016829554,
0.0767740831,
1.1784101725,
-0.4388359785,
0.7120534182,
0.6455110908,
0.5438420773,
-0.1995403022,
-0.0771027431,
0.6980045438,
-0.5356938243,
0.0184848066,
-0.1906111538,
0.7075734138,
0.4656946957,
-0.8775219917,
0.647782445,
0.4382322431,
-0.6594240665,
-0.3458889127,
0.031723462,
-0.7453212738,
-0.0528958738,
1.0570777655,
-0.595531702,
0.0514385104,
-0.3381638229,
-0.3158378899,
0.2932978272,
-0.2775722742,
0.6227391958,
1.3807992935,
-0.1966890693,
-0.0584220216,
-0.5246537328,
0.4927180707,
0.532135129,
-1.3093541861,
0.0845859721,
0.96488446,
0.4091767669,
0.2325052768,
0.3570058644,
-0.3101685047,
0.8588772416,
0.0040819421,
-0.0525869392,
0.3250109851,
-0.3335177004,
-0.7955884337,
-0.2068145275,
0.0012034783,
-0.216711238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09194v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09194v1 | Undetectable Watermarks for Language Models | 2023-05-25T02:57:16 | 2023-05-25T02:57:16 | Miranda Christ, Sam Gunn, Or Zamir | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in the capabilities of large language models such as GPT-4
have spurred increasing concern about our ability to detect AI-generated text.
Prior works have suggested methods of embedding watermarks in model outputs, by
noticeably altering the output distribution. We ask: Is it possible to
introduce a watermark without incurring any detectable change to the output
distribution?
To this end we introduce a cryptographically-inspired notion of undetectable
watermarks for language models. That is, watermarks can be detected only with
the knowledge of a secret key; without the secret key, it is computationally
intractable to distinguish watermarked outputs from those of the original
model. In particular, it is impossible for a user to observe any degradation in
the quality of the text. Crucially, watermarks should remain undetectable even
when the user is allowed to adaptively query the model with arbitrarily chosen
prompts. We construct undetectable watermarks based on the existence of one-way
functions, a standard assumption in cryptography. | [
-0.1823882312,
-0.7641503215,
0.6855435967,
-0.0180135071,
-0.6729553938,
0.1148384809,
0.0748165622,
-0.4435212314,
0.081614159,
0.8698101044,
-0.4499172568,
-0.5187552571,
-0.8045080304,
-0.23323448,
-0.7806816101,
1.0643869638,
0.2413071394,
-0.340972811,
-0.11216636,
-0.2728099525,
0.2618773878,
-0.7660633922,
-0.4400296211,
-0.3657391071,
0.1267304718,
-0.0514750071,
0.9524311423,
1.0379891396,
0.402834028,
0.2716970742,
-0.1457432956,
-0.1044479683,
-0.3146120608,
0.2392338365,
-0.0455089472,
-0.4065496325,
-0.1123481467,
0.0920633748,
0.7213764191,
0.245651111,
0.2272978723,
-0.0440958478,
0.0901802629,
0.7318771482,
-0.6672101617,
0.4321501851,
-0.9383910894,
0.096791707,
-0.7218584418,
-0.3634747565,
-0.3374334276,
-0.1939494461,
-0.1180012897,
-0.5436380506,
0.2186440676,
0.007131103,
1.0470563173,
0.1797227114,
-0.0548609309,
-0.2692796886,
-1.1416584253,
0.6029248834,
-0.9109774232,
0.2488752902,
0.6757701039,
0.2352758646,
-0.0765262991,
-0.8077673912,
-0.6326314807,
-0.3022292554,
0.2527180612,
0.1577996165,
-0.3413689733,
0.0345545746,
0.2868706882,
0.3683914542,
-0.2952664793,
-0.2924910188,
-0.0274328403,
-0.1965932846,
0.610021472,
0.1092301086,
0.5423887968,
0.2515694499,
-0.2462997437,
-0.049565535,
-1.0133668184,
-0.0694486871,
0.7327763438,
0.3009791374,
-0.0115973679,
0.325617522,
0.0968214944,
0.2011944503,
-0.219097361,
0.2428650409,
-0.1366342753,
-0.0337390788,
-0.0302074067,
-0.130369395,
0.9389050603,
-0.3779479563,
0.4655398726,
-0.2680094242,
-0.4575174153,
0.0299120564,
0.022656912,
-0.6235776544,
-0.6859105825,
-0.1214357987,
-0.2710750103,
-0.5144097805,
0.1382574141,
-0.5148162246,
-0.7202269435,
0.3436924815,
0.7131410241,
-0.1847026348,
-0.462787658,
-0.0823101923,
-0.1036882401,
-0.1206846461,
-0.0363867804,
-1.0028597116,
0.5280433893,
0.5565055609,
0.5167298913,
0.0305038225,
-0.1314756125,
-0.2993189692,
0.3069140613,
-0.5998066664,
0.7879087329,
-0.9393614531,
-0.2922030389,
-0.017620977,
-0.0891431123,
0.1624833494,
-0.3851375282,
0.2526913285,
-0.7440260053,
0.3306496441,
-0.2943078578,
-0.9457392097,
-0.1690307558,
-0.0996106938,
-0.7576726079,
0.6234701872,
0.1002445444,
-0.8971854448,
0.0543635786,
-0.9888691306,
-0.2879239917,
0.4706636965,
-0.1759989262,
-0.7321442366,
0.0497657135,
0.2209573537,
0.0189599581,
-0.1433383524,
0.1604643166,
-0.4029828608,
-0.3512370288,
0.4889824092,
-1.1291182041,
0.7314164042,
-0.097177878,
-0.6615640521,
-0.1075466126,
-0.7301657796,
0.1790368855,
0.4060439169,
-0.2438431829,
-0.4679501355,
0.1102182195,
-0.1033955142,
-0.2401994914,
0.3891164362,
-0.5310565829,
0.0315553956,
-0.427860409,
0.6303878427,
0.9363103509,
0.2735190094,
0.4704420865,
0.0640858039,
0.7467144728,
0.1725603491,
0.2734832466,
-0.3077495992,
-0.8126651049,
-0.623485744,
-0.4553828239,
0.6327379942,
0.2849149108,
-0.6706115007,
0.1435263455,
-0.00439132,
-0.4614530504,
-0.4864023626,
0.2089683264,
0.4766384959,
0.3397490978,
0.3029202819,
-0.0719411522,
-0.0950134918,
-0.8562110066,
-0.5787996054,
-0.2917742133,
0.1170194149,
0.3063791692,
0.5269399881,
-0.0340771452,
0.7823203206,
-0.5413896441,
-0.077403985,
-0.1696490347,
0.3229172528,
-0.15408279,
0.5847852826,
0.4036513865,
-0.8913130164,
-0.3218396604,
0.0514371581,
-0.7550953031,
-0.2260564268,
0.1822760105,
0.1478222162,
0.0931711346,
0.5969152451,
-0.5159183145,
0.757296443,
0.7033552527,
-0.3694095314,
0.3335454166,
-0.537104249,
-0.0602604151,
-0.761343658,
0.1543399245,
-0.311624378,
-0.1954007447,
-0.6779118776,
0.0900633186,
0.3173772991,
-0.2831428349,
-0.1704015434,
1.0139149427,
-0.343433857,
0.2071413994,
-0.5018206835,
-0.3079479039,
0.066400893,
0.4122744203,
-0.0971653983,
0.6358624697,
0.7749964595,
-0.3988538682,
-0.0195386149,
0.0058806376,
-0.1448698789,
-0.0179459304,
-0.7535866499,
0.3014532626,
-0.1219844073,
-0.1642461121,
-1.1401370764,
0.0446040221,
0.4639763534,
-0.3909827769,
0.3091050684,
-0.4970643818,
-0.4400489032,
0.0485661402,
-0.1796189696,
0.2981489003,
0.6708188653,
-0.4138318896,
0.3825504184,
0.3381685317,
-0.1589145362,
-0.4291887283,
-0.6188527346,
0.0321589522,
-0.2646384537,
-0.2657731771,
0.3774410188,
-0.233014822,
-0.0126830032,
0.3107267022,
-0.243430689,
-0.6599680185,
0.3169320226,
0.5968803763,
0.2015815824,
-0.1160506159,
0.1512338221,
0.244264096,
-0.2246148288,
0.0404412076,
-0.2898620069,
0.1975737363,
-0.0811276436,
-0.6535071135,
-0.4690671563,
0.3781566024,
0.7550133467,
-0.6823147535,
0.5488628149,
0.4474299848,
-0.7258791327,
-0.2229619771,
-0.2435126305,
-0.2907836139,
-0.5596837997,
0.1548317224,
-0.1130834743,
-0.8264608383,
0.7399071455,
0.0646713898,
0.0347904898,
0.3752289712,
0.0930579752,
0.076491639,
1.1943256855,
0.8493987322,
-0.1329825968,
0.5776046515,
-0.0231967475,
0.366839081,
-0.6419890523,
0.0618041158,
-0.6123503447,
0.0772420615,
-0.714589417,
0.0548554733,
0.1767538339,
0.265111655,
-0.3187347949,
0.3019225597,
-0.4950948358,
0.6970667243,
0.8067396283,
0.0206119455,
0.2160741985,
-0.0037219438,
-0.1881851703,
-0.0644897372,
-0.4322209358,
-0.5515653491,
1.1168937683,
0.2063209563,
0.6341152191,
-0.1367280483,
0.9434774518,
0.5837718248,
0.4297463,
-0.1665363461,
0.4200335145,
-0.025014976,
-0.787144959,
-0.6108449697,
-0.4591519535,
-0.9979311228,
0.0761635974,
-0.1420694441,
-0.8047745824,
-0.1537914425,
0.2839373946,
-0.2337336987,
0.4981833994,
-0.4648075402,
0.9766135812,
-0.1781317741,
-0.3375940025,
0.0889035463,
-0.2253981531,
0.0798999518,
-0.2579057515,
0.3469306529,
-0.3185788989,
-0.034433227,
0.8000822663,
-0.336927563,
0.6444654465,
-0.533692956,
-0.1861880571,
0.4342489243,
0.5006118417,
0.7788220644,
0.2303836644,
0.1517868191,
0.2283475697,
-0.0491854288,
-0.3376998603,
-0.7128123641,
0.5888443589,
-0.5552076697,
-0.7500886321,
-0.3268964589,
-0.3950805068,
-0.1536983401,
0.5497495532,
0.3476362228,
0.4329637885,
-0.0329484418,
-0.1979032904,
0.4917962849,
-0.2336664498,
0.85129565,
0.6786602736,
0.0676631629,
-0.2851097882,
1.1998826265,
0.0882060081,
0.1866556555,
0.2410205752,
0.5289724469,
-0.4817651808,
-0.8060550094,
-0.4068158567,
0.1744826287,
-0.7672182918,
-0.0159128197,
-0.3735485673,
-0.4597788155,
-0.0236721355,
0.1188841239,
-0.753981173,
-0.5103278756,
-0.389102757,
0.040606413,
0.3342597187,
0.9356122017,
-0.0183065925,
0.2145307958,
-0.7247266769,
0.2945432067,
0.462140888,
0.5250791907,
-0.2286813259,
-0.7274035215,
0.0461198613,
0.3416239917,
-0.3394262195,
-0.6556860805,
0.4187901914,
0.236827001,
0.4462654889,
0.7156119347,
0.2370739728,
0.4180637896,
-0.6027499437,
0.7739054561,
0.0143042756,
-1.281244278,
0.388438642,
-0.3219909072,
0.3302687109,
0.1696237177,
0.1831770241,
-0.1962765753,
-0.7733749151,
-0.877450943,
-0.7870138884,
0.37852934,
0.4168823063,
0.6075125933,
0.0250835251,
0.3061028123,
0.1452094465,
0.3618714809,
-0.9357671738,
-0.3347891271,
-0.4809427857,
-0.0453030802,
0.1365716308,
-0.2501341701,
0.0106647108,
-0.0642084926,
0.6416383982,
-0.0889072493,
0.2798059881,
-0.0402603224,
0.1641221195,
-0.2753902972,
0.341858685,
0.6686270833,
0.6595881581,
-0.025564041,
0.3517990112,
-0.4409445226,
-0.3314115405,
0.0407126956,
0.0609543063,
-0.4695470035,
0.0148125691,
0.4371903837,
0.6212093234,
0.0525354706,
-0.514511466,
0.7354230881,
-0.0406467542,
-0.0974967331,
-0.287820071,
0.1070975065,
0.3427798152,
0.1859723032,
0.5133370757,
0.11957407,
-0.0444182828,
-0.3329173923,
0.2844681144,
0.71416682,
-0.6667401195,
-0.7162718177,
0.9870978594,
0.0103685707,
-0.3169045746,
0.6082738638,
-0.3733740449,
-0.6891419291,
0.4425704479,
0.5830830932,
1.0780818462,
-0.3823812604,
0.2368021905,
-0.0813051686,
0.5829151869,
-0.0227267388,
0.3234047592,
-0.0185550638,
-0.9980322123,
0.243269071,
-0.3966287076,
-0.4297789633,
0.5357215405,
-0.4194135964,
-0.1199457273,
-0.6876805425,
-0.023365695,
0.3673804402,
-0.4307834208,
-0.4325298965,
0.1178119108,
0.2929306328,
0.3208897114,
-0.9457017183,
0.9245681167,
0.3665135205,
-0.2205446064,
-0.4335187376,
0.0530551001,
-0.2740993798,
-0.8828362823,
0.24074848,
-0.0538769662,
0.0543441698,
0.1241332814,
-0.9189175367,
-0.851698041,
0.5716658831,
0.9050732851,
-0.1461572349,
0.2385561615,
0.4844976068,
0.6061269045,
-0.1445077807,
-0.0852092728,
0.1086283103,
0.6597707868,
-0.4880219996,
-0.6035786867,
0.1394194067,
-0.3217460811,
-0.1076834872,
0.3119070232,
-0.3073106408,
0.9405183792,
-0.1167494506,
-0.525341928,
0.0507102348,
0.3823410869,
-0.0544408672,
0.0245300569,
0.1433676928,
0.2624947727,
0.6954737902,
-0.2370044887,
0.9957033992,
-0.4855554998,
0.4476043284,
1.0099546909,
-0.2784337997,
0.6623623967,
0.4361523986,
-0.066400744,
0.2981678843,
0.1222193316,
-0.129049167,
0.7979029417,
0.2276809663,
-0.4389185905,
-0.4193533957,
-0.0137859359,
-0.2802207172,
0.4423229098,
0.2865487039,
-0.513774991,
-0.2209299654,
-0.1072367579,
-0.0462614596,
0.2313972414,
-0.0958717242,
0.6484804153,
0.112878643,
-0.1616052836,
0.6624422073,
0.084245272,
0.4527968466,
-0.7646477818,
-0.3139367998,
-0.3078861237,
0.1792840213,
0.0568865165,
-0.6876211166,
0.0420567989,
-0.218261987,
-0.1744582355,
-0.136122182,
0.8257616758,
-0.541323483,
-0.533038795,
0.1804143041,
0.5625051856,
0.1699378341,
-0.5428481102,
-0.8288305998,
-0.0083577875,
-0.0923407599,
-0.4977147877,
0.2986539304,
0.4447350204,
-0.1509922594,
1.1011730433,
0.6488464475,
0.1546699256,
0.0864597559,
0.0062218383,
0.6621899605,
-0.5124176145,
-0.5552917719,
-1.1107910872,
0.0122173047,
0.2052984387,
-0.222767964,
0.7429841161,
0.3614730835,
0.5318850279,
-0.1481357366,
1.2783205509,
0.2659834027,
0.1085318178,
-0.2112053484,
1.1748589277,
-0.3319895566,
0.2893987596,
-0.5835313797,
-0.6625478864,
-0.3090533316,
0.2529122531,
-0.0077906507,
0.1138225719,
0.6454119086,
0.861779213,
-0.0594609939,
0.2458481044,
0.6347560287,
-0.1668881625,
0.433706671,
0.3030310571,
0.8672800064,
-0.5703889728,
0.6442233324,
-0.38479653,
-0.0977764651,
0.2059496343,
-1.059690237,
-0.8983003497,
-0.7647861838,
-0.5056848526,
-0.1165887713,
0.3498016,
0.3362335861,
0.5347341299,
-1.0858721733,
0.1144379005,
-0.4218617976,
0.185283497,
-0.3156719208,
-0.2000671476,
0.5859623551,
0.1946067959,
-0.5902635455,
0.4079600871,
0.5164143443,
0.7058216929,
-0.3042022884,
-0.0542673059,
0.220725745,
0.3491566479,
0.0435802005,
0.5261082649,
-0.5638632774,
-0.5027281046,
-0.1749765873,
0.121876657,
-0.0474607088,
0.6803587675,
-0.4549587667,
0.3942565918,
0.1512390822,
0.6238746643,
0.4617477953,
-0.062705569,
0.3570458293,
-0.7111047506,
0.0347935297,
0.2690634131,
0.3184912801,
0.4891768992,
-0.3821610808,
0.1832669526,
0.4144825935,
-0.3104422688,
-0.8083278537,
0.1170311123,
-0.4165452123,
-0.1590546668,
0.9248642325,
-0.6379586458,
-0.1133723632,
-0.1601455361,
0.1287288517,
0.1050727367,
-0.3918252289,
0.9269310832,
0.6717387438,
0.0868002623,
-0.0557219312,
-0.3200364709,
0.7528908849,
0.3414445221,
-0.760184288,
0.4967823625,
-0.1063831896,
0.5867983699,
0.1057095155,
0.5955389738,
-0.5271402597,
0.2758640349,
0.218117401,
-0.0269587636,
-0.3855078816,
-0.2972581685,
-0.272064656,
0.3004834354,
0.132691592,
-0.2383746356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16353v1 | Betray Oneself: A Novel Audio DeepFake Detection Model via Mono-to-Stereo Conversion | 2023-05-25T02:54:29 | 2023-05-25T02:54:29 | Rui Liu, Jinhua Zhang, Guanglai Gao, Haizhou Li | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL | Audio Deepfake Detection (ADD) aims to detect the fake audio generated by
text-to-speech (TTS), voice conversion (VC) and replay, etc., which is an
emerging topic. Traditionally we take the mono signal as input and focus on
robust feature extraction and effective classifier design. However, the
dual-channel stereo information in the audio signal also includes important
cues for deepfake, which has not been studied in the prior work. In this paper,
we propose a novel ADD model, termed as M2S-ADD, that attempts to discover
audio authenticity cues during the mono-to-stereo conversion process. We first
projects the mono to a stereo signal using a pretrained stereo synthesizer,
then employs a dual-branch neural architecture to process the left and right
channel signals, respectively. In this way, we effectively reveal the artifacts
in the fake audio, thus improve the ADD performance. The experiments on the
ASVspoof2019 database show that M2S-ADD outperforms all baselines that input
mono. We release the source code at \url{https://github.com/AI-S2-Lab/M2S-ADD}. | [
-0.7596520185,
-0.6735513806,
0.5989641547,
0.0237241182,
-0.1087255776,
0.1522610039,
0.2339971364,
-0.3814657927,
0.4150859416,
0.3701288998,
-1.13625741,
-0.2320442647,
-0.5512498021,
-0.202723369,
-0.6622463465,
0.6700544357,
0.1769501865,
0.1970407367,
-0.1025769487,
-0.2453607768,
-0.6332124472,
-0.4845362008,
-0.8880293369,
-0.1232260689,
0.0557807274,
0.3057175279,
0.5442982912,
0.1797745228,
0.1601991653,
0.2799332738,
0.2187327743,
0.1959677339,
-0.2140128464,
0.0308294725,
-0.0642345846,
-0.157741949,
-0.6616286635,
0.2962932587,
0.4269981086,
0.1245801225,
0.1824878305,
0.380815506,
-0.0768420771,
0.4511023164,
-0.4632587731,
-0.2805697918,
-0.5723404288,
0.0790881962,
-0.0633963197,
-0.1777213812,
-0.5988451838,
0.0636057854,
-0.1604479104,
-0.2888438106,
0.2146086991,
-0.3744559586,
0.4002676308,
0.6006759405,
-0.289201349,
-0.4027564228,
-0.8533019423,
0.2299637198,
-0.8241867423,
0.537776053,
0.098069787,
0.4800036252,
0.0706019402,
-0.5882589817,
-0.6707215309,
-0.3110220134,
0.0331606194,
0.1945370287,
0.0149274338,
-0.0584474653,
-0.0418074131,
0.5954137444,
-0.2992258966,
-0.1050210223,
-0.0950543806,
-0.7185342312,
0.7529950738,
-0.009356712,
0.480378449,
0.0977613851,
-0.6482564807,
-0.0090074362,
-0.4288377166,
0.1232043952,
0.5609184504,
0.1805657744,
-0.2672670484,
0.575273931,
0.0246752147,
0.1387352049,
0.3518044651,
0.0473980084,
0.1583986282,
-0.5886841416,
-0.0921247154,
0.4611590505,
0.8410766125,
0.0664175153,
0.1948139369,
0.3216601312,
-0.3752094209,
0.2837353349,
0.1946088821,
-0.7765961885,
-0.2966859341,
0.2287839949,
-0.2002746463,
-0.5560389757,
0.0143042514,
-0.3552417159,
-0.4298542738,
-0.5120679736,
1.061283946,
-0.7752518654,
-0.4185959101,
0.0028179211,
-0.2034224272,
-0.1947075129,
0.3601513505,
-0.4253267646,
0.3850876689,
0.72905159,
0.9818807244,
0.0235684961,
-0.3993414938,
-0.7313506007,
0.1503766626,
-0.4570506215,
0.5689240694,
-0.1268227398,
-0.1938339174,
-0.2819135785,
-0.2284727991,
0.4712645411,
-0.3255728781,
0.4916260242,
-0.4088742733,
0.1207704768,
-0.0740846023,
-0.3698976636,
0.1262212247,
-0.1758014709,
-0.677421689,
0.9174509645,
-0.0991715267,
-0.5421820879,
0.3535012603,
-0.754325211,
-0.6853223443,
-0.229281947,
-0.1715711802,
-0.4621445537,
0.2267304063,
0.2236033082,
0.4030339122,
0.2311586142,
0.2976959944,
-0.6003516316,
-0.484059602,
0.4506226778,
-0.773003459,
1.0259782076,
0.1399871409,
-0.4674393237,
0.0277211759,
-0.7154236436,
-0.414986819,
-0.0874276161,
-0.1455952078,
-0.3821325302,
-0.2527212501,
-0.0184163302,
0.3921710253,
0.0250607431,
-0.6373771429,
-0.0580979362,
-0.3895704746,
-0.0232082158,
0.8755872846,
-0.1740957648,
0.5142848492,
-0.0265080985,
0.3190784454,
0.0917093083,
0.0288856551,
-0.2950310111,
-0.4773766696,
-0.5317229033,
-0.7214711308,
0.4049135447,
0.4521365166,
-0.4704635143,
0.6247307062,
-0.0522251576,
-0.3963709772,
-1.0333813429,
-0.0186785571,
0.3218996525,
0.4579741955,
0.4135308564,
-0.6187015176,
-0.7660788894,
-0.9426385164,
-0.4367090166,
-0.0504345484,
-0.2978405058,
0.0035369531,
0.4748874605,
-0.5316856503,
0.833206594,
-0.0938006565,
-0.6841805577,
0.4329882264,
0.3880952001,
-0.2028762251,
0.6375667453,
0.5631101727,
-0.3979046345,
-0.1951205134,
-0.3289678991,
-0.7597126365,
-0.0401616916,
-0.4065497816,
0.1105017662,
0.1421946287,
0.7853358388,
-0.4635329843,
0.5518016219,
0.8890784979,
-0.5717484355,
0.6903662682,
0.114382647,
0.3747051358,
-1.0948687792,
-0.1744440049,
-0.4122516811,
-0.402351737,
-0.4999488294,
-0.2148732394,
-0.0676342696,
-0.2371847332,
-0.2601055503,
0.3520880044,
-0.3670232296,
-0.2947624922,
-0.4033550024,
-0.2494500279,
-0.0697862506,
0.2287608087,
-0.1802335531,
0.9718900919,
0.5422959328,
-0.3413977325,
0.4044159949,
0.1665630937,
-0.1639594436,
0.3309921324,
-0.3675282598,
0.4735736847,
0.0600598678,
0.4062477946,
-1.4455219507,
-0.1046851128,
0.176104933,
-0.9563029408,
0.5229645371,
-0.4889668524,
-0.4762851596,
-0.0833757743,
-0.1885050684,
0.5736601949,
0.3384509981,
-0.6299896836,
0.8326380849,
0.4186296463,
0.0073903985,
-0.4849059582,
-0.9747052789,
0.3132208288,
0.121391885,
-0.7953008413,
0.3519001305,
-0.2948458493,
0.0995588079,
-0.0918162242,
-0.3779613078,
-0.0521244071,
0.1473378986,
0.3981857598,
0.1101128682,
-0.5142478943,
-0.1988478899,
0.511495471,
-0.3989937305,
0.483163476,
-0.2160194516,
0.4611053467,
-0.1590524465,
-0.3616227806,
-1.0776838064,
0.5408741832,
1.2524620295,
-0.1128322482,
0.3384601772,
0.7675048113,
-0.2489020228,
-0.4627577662,
-0.5555703044,
-0.6690536141,
-0.6000007391,
0.2751138806,
-0.7126870155,
-0.737498045,
0.359087348,
-0.2646914721,
-0.3045437932,
0.1258367002,
0.4545943141,
-0.3589025736,
1.0066221952,
0.3303025961,
-0.1978669763,
0.2173264027,
-0.224918142,
-0.0407124832,
-0.4736470878,
-0.0761890709,
-0.0351210386,
-0.2691726387,
-0.3447566926,
-0.6270263791,
0.3061358333,
-0.3223956227,
-0.1053534225,
0.4863325953,
-0.3157217801,
0.3051586151,
0.643933177,
0.229039818,
0.3446173072,
0.1000299677,
-0.2064097971,
-0.1586238593,
-0.3254497349,
-0.051713936,
1.0508010387,
0.7861807346,
0.4350190759,
0.1517793685,
0.9070034027,
0.5972639918,
0.0729174837,
-0.7780117989,
0.4333822429,
-0.0431332998,
-0.9988396168,
-0.3975228071,
-0.0561333448,
-0.1260962486,
-0.1041001305,
-0.281598717,
0.0864006057,
0.2013768107,
0.3135072887,
-0.2298158407,
0.2780194879,
-0.6534654498,
0.5831433535,
-0.4631677866,
-0.3597732782,
-0.3004284501,
-0.4993895292,
0.6197724938,
-0.2182443887,
0.6369710565,
-0.1991006136,
0.0658457652,
0.6334924698,
-0.1755154431,
0.7740782499,
-0.439501822,
-0.3275038004,
0.3184291422,
0.9270631075,
0.462472111,
0.5760421753,
0.1288442612,
0.5496019125,
-0.2429499775,
-0.1485597193,
-0.5735542774,
0.7295677066,
-0.5905001163,
-0.4688972533,
-0.2788785696,
-0.4362813532,
-0.3933601081,
0.1732618511,
0.3740525246,
0.4661502242,
-0.3588258028,
-0.0345763862,
0.6830950975,
0.0555607751,
0.2782194614,
0.441305548,
-0.229394421,
-0.7133525014,
0.7318714261,
-0.2187982053,
0.3370098174,
-0.10012196,
0.2178240716,
-0.0881164074,
-0.6229140162,
-0.5561372042,
0.2690249085,
-0.4394409955,
-0.120366089,
-0.3849879503,
-0.2519301772,
-0.7398936749,
-0.1549659669,
-1.2652431726,
-0.4428329468,
-0.2503393292,
-0.2026239038,
-0.0613241121,
0.5212785006,
-0.5258446932,
0.0564681664,
-0.6546326876,
0.9309229255,
0.7023857832,
0.4110226035,
-0.4410139024,
-1.1128951311,
0.0090348786,
0.1761632711,
0.2393396944,
-1.0503228903,
0.12811701,
-0.0402889512,
0.3071272969,
0.7976520061,
-0.0006068631,
0.7692358494,
-0.5670747757,
0.3566894531,
0.2703910768,
-1.2775204182,
0.5303884149,
-0.3957164884,
-0.0351145044,
0.9510407448,
0.228847906,
-0.2876453698,
-0.2627876699,
-0.5938161016,
-0.515024662,
0.8428196907,
0.4562804699,
0.3593944609,
0.6477658749,
0.0592950806,
0.246367842,
0.1880235821,
-0.8866759539,
-0.6241512895,
-0.3219590187,
-0.2171231061,
-0.027045913,
-0.4019629657,
-0.2008796781,
-0.5927919149,
0.6672543883,
-0.0578715131,
0.6685227156,
0.4409015179,
0.0124602588,
-0.0532083996,
-0.1022348925,
0.5296088457,
-0.0444839112,
-0.3997970223,
0.3680444658,
0.0845397115,
-0.3443243206,
0.4721976221,
-0.1741530448,
-0.0580205582,
0.4208452702,
0.4043163359,
0.5773644447,
0.0369654,
-0.2900200784,
0.7256614566,
0.0343378186,
-0.3607600033,
-0.6873250604,
0.0063759387,
0.3301536441,
0.1342692822,
0.3389553428,
0.7648872137,
0.598256588,
-0.8001035452,
0.6286014318,
0.4651158154,
-0.7363086343,
-0.3900991976,
0.7158308625,
0.3112690449,
-0.5342206359,
0.1924905926,
-0.0870301425,
-0.5363314152,
0.3752135634,
0.3468540311,
1.1892287731,
-0.8716389537,
0.1392711103,
0.3787944913,
0.6363816857,
0.2905130088,
-0.0682611018,
-0.4211019576,
-0.6967507601,
-0.3466714919,
-0.5365655422,
-0.0165543277,
0.3141812682,
-0.4664317966,
0.4812258482,
-0.6056233048,
0.0274040289,
0.1042566299,
-0.6265711784,
-0.3096408844,
0.2922299504,
0.7287943363,
0.8493531346,
-1.1328907013,
0.9247101545,
0.2564883232,
-0.1885437369,
-0.4494988024,
0.1314407587,
0.4618065059,
-0.6785060167,
0.3607036173,
0.2800214291,
-0.717777133,
-0.0796831921,
-0.5030754805,
-0.9215154648,
0.745801568,
0.5105140209,
-0.4659807086,
-0.1564507484,
0.2838509381,
0.3515247107,
-0.4767021835,
0.0200812165,
0.5930771232,
0.5252422094,
0.0731053427,
-0.7085068822,
0.2924544811,
-0.1722712815,
-0.5690439939,
-0.1160408854,
-0.3818920851,
0.7742668986,
-0.0968935862,
-0.0320695564,
-0.2359368354,
0.659875989,
0.2202232629,
0.8177485466,
0.638902247,
0.5091145635,
0.4018518925,
0.2859199941,
0.5241602659,
0.1321337968,
0.1019932926,
1.3748315573,
-0.006578831,
0.5189843178,
0.5289310217,
-0.1933277398,
0.6649150252,
0.1422605366,
-0.0526196286,
0.6820229888,
-0.4358107448,
-0.2512886226,
-0.4806634486,
0.6150023937,
-0.3978921473,
0.734241426,
0.5821083784,
-0.5105230808,
0.2917095423,
0.1894008368,
0.1045626849,
-0.086766541,
0.0298061762,
0.9784947634,
0.0282541998,
-0.5325220227,
0.6072935462,
-0.198785454,
0.735247016,
-0.3726686835,
0.0003720343,
-0.2102622986,
0.236248076,
-0.2384794354,
-0.5257000327,
0.4626608193,
-0.4409758151,
-0.1597409695,
0.0003542506,
0.6271641254,
-0.3175579011,
-0.5302920341,
0.8305954933,
0.1710723042,
-0.2059987187,
-0.4804729521,
-0.8313094974,
-0.0071332534,
0.194122389,
-0.0602121837,
0.1480468363,
0.5230932236,
0.4642895162,
0.3452487886,
0.9255880713,
-0.041316241,
0.2091415524,
-0.2687263191,
0.662938416,
-0.5554504395,
-0.5702690482,
-0.7498185039,
0.6937281489,
-0.2192736417,
-0.1250109524,
0.9139650464,
0.7774941325,
0.8117954731,
-0.3871099055,
0.8019586802,
0.2742570043,
0.5056471229,
-0.5271689892,
0.9961192012,
-0.7575823069,
0.3302768767,
-0.6566588283,
-0.2813337743,
0.0588733405,
0.265865922,
0.2101704627,
-0.1499686837,
0.6889105439,
1.0690646172,
-0.3954963386,
-0.1114474535,
0.3982836604,
0.3408133388,
0.1307819039,
0.3506750762,
0.818811655,
-0.9471595287,
0.6465699077,
-0.4843508601,
-0.2142930031,
-0.527187705,
-0.4110024869,
-0.9668486118,
-0.8453603387,
-0.4837837517,
-0.6479843259,
-0.0764487088,
0.4277213514,
0.8476515412,
-1.0904979706,
-0.1516492814,
-0.3028792143,
-0.0624551997,
-0.218455106,
-0.2385570556,
0.1516491473,
-0.0368223898,
-0.529135108,
1.2673969269,
0.2601343095,
0.2429775447,
-0.1586119533,
-0.2165468633,
-0.2466145605,
0.4061872959,
0.5512520075,
0.0039958921,
-0.5998959541,
-0.2364628762,
-0.2022876292,
0.0612687133,
0.0804804713,
1.1745724678,
-0.7805417776,
0.6604654789,
0.3464212418,
0.5384622812,
0.7950453162,
-0.1127719656,
0.4962958992,
-0.8619242907,
0.3590162098,
0.2978882194,
0.1451424658,
0.1033994779,
-0.5306323171,
0.1898440868,
0.5480545163,
-0.2144035995,
-0.9657056928,
0.2999976873,
-1.1347154379,
-0.7077338696,
0.9288075566,
0.2714903355,
-0.0850126892,
-0.3686323762,
-0.4075529575,
0.5099046826,
-0.3534590006,
0.7822384238,
0.3581539989,
-0.05418019,
0.0894153789,
-0.2447357178,
0.9032428861,
0.5575909019,
-0.3579651713,
0.2238458842,
0.8314359188,
0.509319663,
0.4612710476,
0.624453187,
-0.1829000711,
0.7760551572,
0.3570283055,
0.0243086126,
-0.6300113201,
-0.8457351327,
-0.6198229194,
0.4985590279,
-0.2724547386,
-0.4167644382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15673v1 | BookGPT: A General Framework for Book Recommendation Empowered by Large Language Model | 2023-05-25T02:45:22 | 2023-05-25T02:45:22 | Aakas Zhiyuli, Yanfang Chen, Xuan Zhang, Xun Liang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | With the continuous development and change exhibited by large language model
(LLM) technology, represented by generative pretrained transformers (GPTs),
many classic scenarios in various fields have re-emerged with new
opportunities. This paper takes ChatGPT as the modeling object, incorporates
LLM technology into the typical book resource understanding and recommendation
scenario for the first time, and puts it into practice. By building a
ChatGPT-like book recommendation system (BookGPT) framework based on ChatGPT,
this paper attempts to apply ChatGPT to recommendation modeling for three
typical tasks, book rating recommendation, user rating recommendation, and book
summary recommendation, and explores the feasibility of LLM technology in book
recommendation scenarios. At the same time, based on different evaluation
schemes for book recommendation tasks and the existing classic recommendation
models, this paper discusses the advantages and disadvantages of the BookGPT in
book recommendation scenarios and analyzes the opportunities and improvement
directions for subsequent LLMs in these scenarios. | [
-0.3678020239,
-0.6035624146,
0.5015013814,
-0.0063187489,
-0.583143115,
-0.0900619701,
-0.2420023531,
-0.139218688,
-0.2655133605,
0.5924594402,
-0.6280276179,
-0.5009236932,
-0.3266250789,
-0.3396544158,
-0.4948152006,
1.4630813599,
0.0389239751,
0.1617227942,
0.0562375784,
0.3543926775,
-0.7685570717,
-0.7565645576,
-0.6887837648,
-0.6167345643,
0.3226192296,
0.2393760383,
0.8533031344,
0.19384709,
0.6455640197,
0.3154004514,
0.0973144248,
-0.3599288762,
-0.3964169919,
0.0473615341,
-0.2092230916,
-0.3681243956,
-0.641422987,
-0.1066184714,
0.5409876704,
0.4083134234,
-0.4867756367,
-0.1698599607,
0.3792921603,
0.7457634211,
-0.0990050733,
0.4556624889,
-0.344696492,
0.1888822317,
-0.0251529682,
-0.259600997,
-0.2976341546,
-0.2521070242,
0.5524392128,
-0.4526456594,
0.3921872675,
0.4817535877,
0.4273733795,
-0.0948146656,
-0.3560158014,
-0.449710995,
-1.1858032942,
0.6396970153,
-0.4906380475,
0.5376467109,
0.3191100955,
0.692328155,
-0.263580054,
-0.6693314314,
-0.6401265264,
-0.7271897197,
-0.1048030332,
0.0849074051,
0.1080847085,
-0.0228238553,
-0.0304965395,
0.6825504899,
-0.473869741,
-0.1614907533,
-0.1495779306,
0.1418459266,
0.2452569753,
-0.0367694795,
0.3644483089,
-0.0741489902,
-0.5001621842,
-0.2278219461,
-0.5512406826,
-0.2874678373,
0.2431959957,
0.3092316389,
0.0318275951,
0.4491291344,
-0.0746376589,
0.6082243919,
-0.1713338792,
0.0475386605,
-0.0049950681,
-0.2139739692,
-0.2714315355,
-0.0177885555,
0.5548508167,
0.527368784,
0.5467553735,
-0.2895216346,
-0.0797226578,
-0.3729708493,
0.230506584,
-0.7873367071,
-0.0742272884,
-0.2434100807,
-0.4940422177,
-0.1217266396,
0.0058589722,
-0.5500032902,
-0.6737344265,
-0.314892143,
0.3721794784,
-0.7564368248,
-0.6034128666,
0.3458391726,
0.0574603714,
0.3630984128,
0.3743002415,
-1.1547118425,
0.2949439585,
0.848054111,
0.961447835,
-0.0751467794,
-0.2675098777,
-0.0458138399,
0.2127298713,
0.0047801281,
1.1521501541,
-0.4507170916,
-0.8088911772,
0.2867163122,
0.1424693018,
0.1408015192,
-0.2361168563,
0.6509225368,
-0.5910948515,
0.1501537412,
-0.0617761612,
-0.6834304929,
-0.4425261915,
0.5560242534,
-0.4386349916,
0.798832953,
0.2880440652,
-0.4350741208,
0.5187754631,
-0.6341609359,
-0.2804866135,
0.5935692787,
0.1138428077,
-0.2546872497,
-0.3538635671,
0.1628624797,
0.5524831414,
-0.5404960513,
0.3904522061,
-0.2351388633,
-0.5977397561,
0.0376241989,
-0.5489794016,
0.248277247,
0.1842934936,
-0.0712531582,
0.0227037389,
-0.5154778361,
-0.108398594,
0.0258130357,
-0.4467405677,
-0.2447452843,
0.2595995367,
0.2848848701,
-0.2147245556,
0.3190674186,
-0.3195215166,
0.7728012204,
-0.2433831841,
0.4909349978,
0.6085857749,
-0.0967808217,
0.445160985,
-0.5808445811,
0.6515854597,
-0.3195712864,
0.1984336674,
-0.2431957126,
-0.4473985732,
-0.7142899036,
0.0136301974,
0.4082069695,
0.6483076811,
-0.7520771623,
0.3962911665,
-0.2973435819,
-0.7388855219,
-0.020254679,
0.0062939227,
0.201862976,
-0.0738502964,
0.177248925,
-0.2004058212,
-0.4023697078,
-0.6691073179,
-0.1373016387,
-0.4356625378,
-0.1319386512,
0.1759218276,
0.0333542489,
-0.3612321913,
0.7138981819,
-0.3295824826,
-0.3985534906,
-0.5209985375,
-0.3466039896,
0.6588093638,
0.4524566531,
0.4222344756,
-0.6609963775,
-0.5419790745,
0.348857373,
-0.3741389513,
0.109193556,
0.1268866509,
-0.2306049913,
-0.1452688426,
0.6212847233,
-0.4351112247,
0.101025641,
0.4712696075,
-0.3925165832,
0.6570081115,
-0.3047048748,
0.2982923687,
-1.1839540005,
-0.4630500078,
0.1748201549,
-0.0984188691,
-0.3000508845,
-0.2115776986,
-0.222815305,
-0.3746197522,
-0.1052313522,
0.7373675108,
-0.2389746904,
0.1113202497,
-0.3454803228,
0.1167130545,
-0.4079298675,
0.5144836307,
-0.0698940903,
0.6498026252,
0.4242483377,
-0.4725470245,
0.6328910589,
0.3239368498,
-0.6069554687,
0.4910377264,
-0.5441706181,
0.1847987473,
0.0682573169,
0.2456564158,
-1.057187438,
0.0775527284,
0.3597911596,
0.2758941054,
0.2771901786,
-0.4368644357,
-0.6763114333,
-0.4234414399,
0.0711311921,
0.1418355554,
0.7067293525,
-0.5010165572,
0.6608305573,
0.0248585604,
-0.6401445866,
-0.3325327337,
-0.3350074291,
-0.003984706,
0.0037315467,
-0.4779031575,
0.4589579105,
-0.4502418041,
0.1382311583,
-0.0167800728,
0.0920887887,
0.14148359,
-0.4232487977,
0.4736921489,
0.4719176888,
-0.3397581875,
0.5635359287,
-0.3622617424,
-0.2335912883,
-0.4055491686,
-0.5458917022,
0.8464218378,
-0.5421873331,
-0.6254298091,
-0.1460102201,
0.1455125064,
0.1608055383,
0.1076916307,
0.3713360429,
0.7861449122,
0.1263226867,
-0.1879688501,
-0.8276949525,
0.0277088843,
-0.5519342422,
0.6860276461,
-0.3051704764,
-1.0547088385,
-0.0054120678,
-0.1606474966,
-0.0051965988,
0.2253813148,
0.8442828655,
0.209185034,
0.6000672579,
0.8756682873,
-0.2269435525,
1.0448145866,
-0.0802060217,
0.4507177174,
-0.6158969998,
-0.0366581678,
-0.3472408056,
0.0651709884,
-0.7125385404,
-0.1524449587,
0.2438208908,
0.3668501377,
-0.5051522851,
0.4297525585,
-0.6335440874,
0.6117207408,
0.8548585176,
0.2324233651,
0.5907387137,
0.1617874205,
-0.1004411206,
0.2640038133,
-0.5362972021,
-0.7575861812,
0.9508666396,
0.2003373802,
0.7217446566,
0.2447155714,
0.2059132606,
0.535433948,
0.5851123333,
-1.119915247,
0.6892867088,
-0.3089453876,
-0.6126343608,
-0.3897390664,
0.1349578798,
-0.6161628366,
0.1252808273,
-0.0806289613,
-0.5650359988,
-0.1017198488,
0.0156773757,
-0.3437881172,
0.3131293952,
-0.9854796529,
0.79938972,
-0.0864644945,
-0.1046406403,
-0.220257476,
0.1443428695,
0.104575105,
-0.1378972381,
0.0417114273,
-0.0138639947,
0.1616567969,
0.668797195,
-0.3731423914,
0.7687433958,
0.0274193734,
-0.0422850847,
0.5865193009,
0.2913240492,
0.551630795,
-0.0140415607,
-0.5005414486,
-0.0031948553,
0.3042795956,
-0.1303919703,
-0.597135067,
0.5560386181,
-0.7360889316,
-0.9486805797,
-0.4295822084,
-0.3187532723,
-0.4021722376,
0.4106828868,
-0.0227486864,
0.3090187311,
-0.4398099184,
0.2255494893,
0.0349500701,
-0.2883903384,
0.5108668208,
0.6752886176,
-0.6173701286,
-0.2520123124,
0.9029653072,
-0.112122409,
-0.069451414,
0.270996362,
0.1999265403,
-0.2654610872,
-0.6951079369,
-0.3029038608,
0.0665019006,
-0.7068089843,
0.0621477552,
-0.4663738012,
-0.4042375088,
-0.2365980893,
-0.2166327834,
-0.1186891049,
0.0850796178,
0.1593123376,
-0.0983712673,
0.517957747,
1.0808182955,
0.2355053127,
0.910752058,
-0.7517439723,
-0.0604953729,
0.638720274,
0.779283464,
0.2271803468,
-0.4746810198,
-0.4681548476,
-0.318436116,
-0.6098071933,
-0.2543229461,
0.4457475841,
-0.0098648425,
0.4040639699,
0.3212630451,
-0.1520687044,
0.0552961603,
-0.9255569577,
0.8025387526,
0.2235701829,
-0.6210892797,
0.0471980795,
-0.7315604091,
0.1734891087,
0.1616764218,
0.2290459722,
-0.8417541385,
0.1605090946,
-0.3934587836,
-0.5506823063,
0.5707504153,
-0.0079364665,
0.4165115952,
0.236906305,
0.3429405689,
0.3600444496,
0.2378938645,
-0.8614513278,
0.2728693783,
-0.3451974988,
0.0849583969,
-0.4622483552,
-0.6066554785,
0.3113444149,
-0.1002463773,
0.9001017213,
0.2020517737,
0.2682909667,
-0.0476825573,
0.1949095875,
0.1094883755,
0.6835776567,
0.0764593706,
0.3656952381,
-0.4161229432,
-0.4562717378,
-0.0321420766,
-0.4776506722,
0.2196160108,
0.2168381661,
0.0167591833,
-0.3002058268,
0.2708402872,
0.8506678939,
0.3840820491,
-0.2532618344,
0.4047061801,
0.0391686,
0.0336457826,
-0.5978665948,
0.3133353591,
0.4930035174,
0.4728324115,
0.2445014268,
-0.1100995988,
-0.0566808321,
-0.6688396335,
0.0455067568,
0.492601335,
-0.6948459744,
-0.054640796,
0.2451840043,
0.2539469302,
-0.7750793695,
0.5237116218,
-0.0553915836,
-0.5348115563,
0.3123293519,
0.613142848,
0.9334671497,
-0.1259147674,
0.3257910907,
0.1172285601,
0.1388431638,
-0.3867189288,
-0.1806953251,
-0.1610842794,
-0.9007799625,
-0.1329285949,
-1.1235661507,
-0.6911653876,
0.1065797657,
-0.0130280359,
0.6939964294,
-0.4958726168,
-0.1053149775,
-0.0196067411,
-0.1393883973,
-0.762996316,
-0.0717422292,
-0.0977930352,
0.5158689022,
-0.1636092216,
0.9599167109,
0.5600504875,
-0.4690471292,
-0.7769009471,
0.1376524121,
-0.2641692162,
-0.8346768022,
0.617202878,
-0.0681780055,
-0.1356727481,
0.3088019788,
-0.289001137,
-0.4630085528,
1.0078966618,
0.1912336349,
-0.9012126327,
-0.1749001294,
-0.0449441895,
0.6089651585,
-0.4405497909,
0.5049993992,
0.350279063,
0.4829193056,
0.3818311989,
-0.9249360561,
-0.0777470246,
-0.1778889745,
0.2846930027,
0.1172723174,
-0.7459759116,
0.8751634955,
0.0091637019,
-0.134399429,
0.3821558356,
0.1844841689,
-0.0139064956,
-0.0439331457,
0.5141735673,
0.035014715,
0.2223633528,
0.0714573935,
1.4801434278,
-0.3039791584,
0.4672145247,
0.9813441634,
-0.3521725833,
0.6682582498,
-0.0192468893,
-0.6291496754,
0.582531333,
0.7281434536,
-0.420401603,
0.3368085325,
0.2614765167,
-0.5856688023,
-0.4415394366,
-0.1054118201,
-0.755551219,
0.1214083955,
0.1875862479,
-0.2066327482,
-0.3858056366,
0.1409800202,
-0.2405594438,
-0.2874336541,
-0.241291225,
0.7826209068,
0.3534866571,
-0.5589587092,
0.3479076624,
-0.0425017364,
0.7966820002,
-0.7596815825,
-0.2155380547,
0.0690978691,
0.4293404222,
0.0878388584,
-0.6627056599,
-0.4358194768,
-0.2210048437,
-0.4298030734,
-0.1808845401,
0.7872771025,
-0.1894420981,
-0.8060564399,
0.3641588688,
0.5491299629,
0.1916183084,
-0.2994357944,
-0.5345122814,
-0.2376978099,
0.0680239052,
-0.5162890553,
0.4279093444,
0.6790500283,
0.052792646,
0.7693597078,
0.7554424405,
0.1501959562,
-0.3817051649,
0.3264818788,
0.6358579993,
-0.9098599553,
-0.629200995,
-0.9456472993,
-0.0311907362,
0.2266703844,
-0.1308904588,
0.6313610077,
0.10245689,
0.6085278392,
-0.2517597377,
0.9794765711,
0.0456605442,
0.5787894726,
-0.4567849934,
0.8821053505,
-0.2490024865,
0.5477845073,
-0.4068528414,
-1.5163792372,
-0.1524405181,
0.2907809913,
-0.6474425793,
0.5690696239,
0.8668525815,
0.8347651362,
-0.0931262672,
0.4474374354,
0.6754432917,
0.0696431473,
0.3746877611,
0.3940937519,
0.7476277351,
-0.2966009378,
0.8795704842,
0.1108223796,
-0.3470640182,
-0.3810572028,
-1.1248605251,
-0.9307524562,
-0.7740259767,
-0.2172221839,
-0.2962549925,
0.2262030989,
0.933054328,
0.6785138249,
-0.7209847569,
-0.2894136012,
-0.1810193956,
-0.0780635923,
-0.128922075,
-0.2342533171,
0.6074680686,
-0.2456947416,
-0.8406449556,
0.1824724078,
0.2357978672,
0.2497058958,
-0.26647982,
0.0002451256,
0.0504192263,
-0.2373369485,
0.7463591099,
0.0179841742,
-0.3879802823,
-0.3076580167,
-0.4883340299,
-0.0163052212,
-0.0784308314,
1.0619152784,
-0.7429144382,
0.2925626338,
0.0037523685,
0.5220874548,
0.6918135285,
-0.2110126764,
0.8966878057,
-0.0842400119,
0.2463802397,
-0.0664824918,
0.3709672391,
0.3726209104,
-0.3145772219,
0.6916081905,
0.1969971806,
-0.7620946169,
-0.3519096971,
0.2908954322,
-0.9934458137,
-0.0871424302,
1.3246744871,
0.0015004674,
0.005323567,
-0.2185795456,
-0.7376926541,
0.2026905864,
-0.514695704,
0.8020889759,
1.2594847679,
0.2400220186,
-0.1489539295,
-0.8962333202,
0.4166421294,
0.357431978,
-0.2765878141,
0.0463835932,
0.1760752648,
0.3207769096,
0.0920829102,
0.6105003357,
-0.0022087891,
-0.0920461193,
-0.0106767658,
0.2532958984,
-0.2282264084,
0.1880915314,
-0.02069306,
0.1694974601,
0.4057898819,
0.0651998892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15663v1 | Mixture-of-Expert Conformer for Streaming Multilingual ASR | 2023-05-25T02:16:32 | 2023-05-25T02:16:32 | Ke Hu, Bo Li, Tara N. Sainath, Yu Zhang, Francoise Beaufays | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | End-to-end models with large capacity have significantly improved
multilingual automatic speech recognition, but their computation cost poses
challenges for on-device applications. We propose a streaming truly
multilingual Conformer incorporating mixture-of-expert (MoE) layers that learn
to only activate a subset of parameters in training and inference. The MoE
layer consists of a softmax gate which chooses the best two experts among many
in forward propagation. The proposed MoE layer offers efficient inference by
activating a fixed number of parameters as the number of experts increases. We
evaluate the proposed model on a set of 12 languages, and achieve an average
11.9% relative improvement in WER over the baseline. Compared to an adapter
model using ground truth information, our MoE model achieves similar WER and
activates similar number of parameters but without any language information. We
further show around 3% relative WER improvement by multilingual shallow fusion. | [
-0.4364765286,
-0.3483747542,
0.151289016,
0.1450064182,
-0.214235574,
-0.011004366,
-0.3855929375,
-0.4742873013,
-0.0179224499,
0.3717327416,
-0.2096395791,
-0.0176265445,
-0.8665918112,
0.0226113312,
-0.1786963195,
0.468947649,
0.1368783116,
0.1145559251,
0.0479566641,
-0.1665467322,
-0.4167798758,
-0.2063651979,
-0.6736788154,
-0.4409274459,
0.42161116,
0.4845584929,
0.4465125203,
0.6000723839,
0.1615937352,
0.4943501651,
-0.0734897628,
0.1449442804,
-0.323759079,
0.2649412155,
-0.1060035005,
-0.219050914,
-0.4848477244,
-0.200856939,
0.7673305273,
0.4801316261,
-0.5620237589,
-0.1408762187,
-0.0499653332,
0.6844557524,
-0.7289189696,
0.1053143516,
-0.9526529312,
-0.2152075619,
-0.0671630725,
0.1988320053,
-0.4385800958,
0.0541133583,
0.3222587109,
-0.6320043206,
0.1978558004,
-0.253772527,
0.5035644174,
0.5645725727,
-0.5599120259,
0.0093723768,
-0.8048026562,
0.7481797934,
-0.671903491,
1.1970990896,
0.3547905087,
0.562775135,
0.1471584886,
-0.4946931005,
-0.6646203995,
0.0078808805,
0.3490751386,
0.3152810931,
0.042343393,
-0.0950265676,
-0.0804879069,
0.3119744062,
-0.4944613278,
0.0482554659,
-0.7363304496,
-0.480215013,
0.9212096334,
-0.4147322774,
-0.0005149454,
0.4116649032,
-0.3361624479,
-0.0783865973,
-0.3533265293,
0.032495331,
0.1983047277,
0.1481377482,
-0.2242418677,
0.191725105,
-0.1521318108,
0.8840548396,
0.4289579988,
-0.4342231154,
0.377427876,
0.140458256,
-0.0041081598,
0.4267479181,
0.7710335851,
0.043806117,
0.2711764574,
-0.2896921933,
-0.3816090524,
-0.1109417528,
0.1629377455,
-0.6619112492,
-0.403108716,
0.1858586967,
0.012777755,
0.3872618377,
0.2658583224,
-0.4137474,
-0.3115178049,
-0.397957027,
0.5387961268,
-0.5826430917,
-0.6163734794,
0.2018209547,
-0.2961615324,
0.1574563682,
0.2877283096,
-0.6891753078,
0.1768205017,
0.3332030177,
0.5622925162,
0.0407275781,
-0.3585954607,
-0.7827340961,
0.733848989,
0.0387096889,
0.976778388,
-0.7235264778,
-0.4669393301,
-0.3601687551,
-0.2811641097,
-0.3043988347,
-0.6355786324,
0.5610596538,
-0.640491724,
0.0360552929,
-0.0838656873,
-0.6432483196,
-0.5068617463,
-0.083958365,
-0.6777258515,
0.746997714,
-0.2157887071,
-0.2553881109,
0.4479504526,
-0.4414435625,
-0.5747174025,
0.2152226269,
-0.2121374607,
-0.2861842811,
-0.0198450889,
0.3695890605,
0.4180701375,
-0.045334924,
0.2815041244,
-0.1147794798,
-0.1462227851,
0.2997829318,
-0.630243361,
0.4593664408,
0.3194567263,
-0.3132005632,
0.1720978618,
-0.9301766753,
-0.1117189527,
-0.2399532199,
-0.7192088366,
-0.0949853733,
0.0645251274,
0.2878576517,
0.2645493448,
0.1451158226,
-0.7275887728,
-0.2666870654,
-0.1608660519,
0.4596039057,
0.6356189251,
-0.1830897033,
0.6201270223,
-0.3206278682,
0.3151401579,
0.3087264895,
-0.1270929873,
-0.0139516117,
-0.6938940883,
-0.8041449189,
-0.7667174935,
0.4565403461,
0.6107890606,
-0.7214360237,
0.6857950687,
-0.3547011614,
-0.4848921895,
-0.941085577,
0.5545372963,
0.6527727842,
0.5655310154,
0.4664600492,
-0.1553949267,
-0.2559556365,
-0.8382072449,
-0.2447997928,
-0.0690023229,
-0.1471117735,
0.1979761869,
-0.1127057821,
-0.1860484034,
0.9168453217,
-0.2605543733,
-0.4919442534,
-0.2945697308,
-0.0100822169,
0.0916439593,
0.5419350863,
0.432352066,
-1.1353218555,
-0.9108783603,
0.2619672716,
-0.5008143187,
0.037169598,
0.0161122847,
-0.0692476481,
0.0183992386,
0.2827591598,
-0.2062848061,
-0.1871699095,
0.7262051702,
-0.0317514651,
-0.0718043223,
-0.447014004,
-0.1035600007,
-0.8946178555,
-0.1909731477,
0.3334074616,
-0.3531501591,
-1.0222007036,
0.1279185414,
0.1740591824,
-0.0101962583,
-0.4863620102,
0.7182188034,
-0.6028546095,
0.2597625256,
-0.2161705941,
0.1029850543,
-0.0289642252,
0.4547052383,
0.3003259599,
0.7563200593,
0.9278647304,
-0.7301774025,
0.2343060672,
0.2008458227,
-0.1364342123,
0.5273211002,
-0.659384191,
0.3979720771,
-0.2414603829,
0.3007861078,
-0.9910132289,
-0.3634181917,
-0.1158094183,
-0.4345838428,
0.6097525954,
-0.2365152836,
-0.1417877823,
-0.1544840783,
-0.0963314623,
0.3218073249,
0.641321063,
-0.2675028741,
1.1049543619,
0.704156518,
-0.2403128445,
-0.3088337481,
-0.7641124725,
-0.11692442,
-0.082192868,
-0.7600531578,
0.179663837,
-0.3073754013,
-0.0445612222,
-0.3728408813,
-0.3306580484,
-0.5850044489,
-0.1799180359,
0.1135533899,
-0.1222464293,
-0.4491857588,
-0.2577228546,
0.4025558829,
-0.35130319,
-0.2365750521,
-0.4323576987,
0.1696997583,
-0.1649568677,
-0.5430162549,
-0.6413397789,
0.5356150866,
0.5882997513,
-0.5048350692,
0.591268599,
0.8858768344,
-0.3033246696,
0.0160801876,
-1.084535718,
0.0296391826,
-0.529709518,
0.2657642961,
-0.7284268737,
-0.7187910676,
0.551400423,
0.2316274047,
0.1741930991,
0.4266552925,
0.4206294119,
0.0320427641,
0.9058740139,
0.3415195942,
-0.2645608783,
0.3935025334,
-0.2129440308,
-0.0269562807,
-0.8151537776,
-0.2967845798,
-0.2615706623,
-0.3300842643,
-0.167333141,
-0.455181241,
0.8317831755,
0.0554802343,
-0.1043486297,
-0.0064782966,
-0.3585117161,
0.4516840279,
0.674939096,
0.5392076373,
0.2608965337,
-0.0275700074,
0.1321673989,
0.1386385709,
-0.889770329,
-0.1226937622,
0.8932834864,
0.2906211019,
0.6494532824,
0.5523856878,
0.3824014962,
0.0886300206,
0.1370769888,
-0.5542100668,
0.398070246,
-0.3606478274,
-0.7310588956,
-0.3735719919,
-0.3618731797,
-0.4533288777,
0.5177752376,
-0.1293962747,
-0.3015022278,
0.3121859431,
0.4952203929,
-0.3329116702,
0.1643511951,
-0.998762548,
0.437582463,
-0.0836460069,
-0.2189278603,
-0.252850771,
-0.8301737309,
0.2008076608,
-0.3781438768,
0.4122111499,
-0.1498374492,
-0.0843953267,
0.6171008348,
-0.2554932535,
0.7403866649,
-0.5612936616,
-0.2028703988,
0.3060851991,
-0.2325969189,
0.3655843437,
0.0376229919,
-0.5206675529,
0.3057635128,
-0.4077880681,
-0.4218461812,
-0.4618255198,
0.5028083324,
-1.0377385616,
-0.6292991042,
0.058226563,
-0.5759632587,
-0.3691692352,
0.1695066541,
0.1951709986,
0.6891165376,
0.1774142832,
0.3061058819,
0.8627849817,
0.1456114054,
0.3443469703,
0.845764339,
0.1696159095,
-0.5120238066,
1.1842688322,
0.1450886726,
0.4416322112,
0.4736929536,
0.4167994559,
-0.4036742747,
-0.6338771582,
-0.92661798,
0.2373647839,
-0.6201320291,
-0.0025131807,
-0.8503686786,
-0.3997974396,
-0.4535638988,
-0.2193216532,
-0.5060108304,
-0.2873751521,
-0.2901727557,
0.0867582411,
0.4176911116,
0.4840834737,
-0.0797724202,
0.5395204425,
-0.9383092523,
0.5843974352,
0.6490187049,
0.3289400339,
-0.0046667033,
-1.013417244,
-0.2242044359,
0.2827338874,
-0.2405010909,
-0.6267375946,
0.162700817,
1.1496890783,
0.9450640082,
0.8719306588,
0.0663252026,
0.8928545713,
-0.838154614,
0.5405563116,
0.1782666296,
-0.9571920037,
0.0995698571,
-0.3751722872,
0.4509352446,
0.5377913117,
0.2998920381,
-0.2950939536,
-0.6452242136,
-0.1375938356,
-0.6475292444,
0.57084167,
-0.1116797924,
0.2500606179,
0.3592863083,
0.3045710325,
0.3889002204,
0.0243969336,
-0.5087262988,
-0.3657472432,
-0.4444395304,
-0.2107954025,
-0.2038027048,
-0.1199395135,
0.0710386708,
-0.5455285907,
0.7679389715,
-0.1770717651,
-0.0071999156,
0.0151230823,
-0.4298622012,
-0.2384640127,
0.3204686344,
0.5399627686,
0.6440901756,
-0.0891739428,
0.1726183891,
0.3218221068,
-0.4947430789,
0.0191025846,
0.3316210806,
-0.0921161249,
-0.0566351861,
0.2785032988,
0.9113503695,
0.4990376532,
-0.6366363168,
0.404592067,
0.2056840807,
-0.4046846628,
-0.2575647831,
0.3638722897,
0.158132419,
0.3643731177,
0.6366901398,
0.328887701,
0.3001495004,
-0.246592328,
0.3782213032,
0.3166950643,
-0.5118669868,
-0.4787105322,
0.9573674202,
0.5356953144,
-0.1366838962,
0.3546096981,
-0.029092744,
-0.6675096154,
0.1721386313,
0.5231021643,
0.6772925258,
-1.0004104376,
-0.1005403996,
0.0380396098,
-0.0371509343,
0.0081543503,
0.3974657059,
-0.2143415213,
-0.9937905073,
-0.3973502815,
-0.4907340407,
-0.3383458257,
-0.1353264004,
-0.7296009064,
0.3104922771,
-0.0923840404,
0.1042822078,
0.1868768185,
-0.5142641664,
-0.403077662,
0.2254222631,
0.40076074,
0.8357878327,
-0.7871510386,
1.1012670994,
0.9018767476,
-0.1097538769,
-0.5942267179,
-0.1550032943,
0.0284745302,
-0.7354178429,
0.2821597457,
0.0431963168,
-0.3328519464,
0.2211972922,
-0.0978117511,
-0.8190605044,
0.8900385499,
0.5564301014,
-0.6289643049,
0.1411571354,
0.029566003,
0.2834353745,
-0.110750556,
0.218941167,
0.1698839962,
0.5655480027,
0.5950139761,
-1.1895430088,
-0.4204079807,
-0.3607117534,
-0.0565429665,
0.0975626782,
-0.70275563,
0.7799677849,
-0.0633034632,
0.1522364914,
-0.4744225144,
1.0421285629,
0.2206136435,
0.1427644491,
0.8920621276,
0.1813499629,
0.7333764434,
0.3920921385,
0.7718719244,
-0.4980427027,
-0.023910217,
0.958211422,
-0.4871844947,
1.1471898556,
0.3207908869,
-0.0091223205,
0.3780420721,
0.3700766265,
0.2817901969,
0.7454445958,
-0.2814218104,
-0.4940814674,
-0.5252001286,
0.1142021343,
-0.3595602214,
0.4459044337,
0.4133705199,
0.1039763018,
-0.0256102756,
0.1663519442,
-0.2537845075,
0.1078181788,
-0.4101985395,
1.1087213755,
0.0680378303,
-0.3247938156,
0.522921145,
0.0122247832,
0.8399482369,
-0.6266191006,
0.2035713792,
0.0909616724,
0.3584082127,
-0.1708593071,
-0.5517727137,
0.1781713516,
0.0183838662,
-0.3749240935,
-0.1802198738,
0.5682796836,
-0.9178648591,
-0.8322505951,
0.2192044556,
0.557489574,
0.1867358536,
-0.3315093219,
-0.5198651552,
-0.2045809776,
-0.0399233624,
-0.1644944102,
0.1911367178,
0.4806263745,
0.0101515763,
0.6653876901,
0.6449142098,
0.0987652391,
0.6524822712,
0.1435266733,
0.9304308891,
-0.1260765195,
-0.690639019,
-0.5236868858,
0.9362303019,
0.0750518888,
-0.0449365638,
0.5411133766,
0.6800211072,
0.8974149227,
-0.0876450837,
0.9419717193,
0.1859127879,
0.5875747204,
-0.5710388422,
0.9094318151,
-0.6436430812,
0.0095213261,
-0.0759288073,
-0.8092101216,
-0.2454172075,
0.66755867,
-0.0195420068,
0.0699800923,
0.0955646411,
0.4931633174,
-0.6148982048,
0.1037092134,
0.5818758607,
0.3265137076,
0.3214042187,
0.3391140103,
0.5803383589,
-0.4511017501,
0.412129283,
-0.165333569,
-0.3524196148,
-0.1367623061,
-0.5599814057,
-0.9125857949,
-0.7422522306,
-0.3319930732,
0.2203476876,
-0.0374426097,
1.0278234482,
1.0259732008,
-1.0033075809,
-0.3426536322,
0.3855328858,
-0.1625967771,
-0.3054922521,
-0.0836578906,
-0.0317738168,
-0.1515762061,
-0.7091328502,
0.7187537551,
0.1108284965,
-0.240991354,
-0.1732518226,
-0.4022100568,
-0.1156964079,
0.0694194734,
0.5294113159,
0.1793341041,
-0.897513926,
-0.1909412146,
-0.1392581463,
0.3293858171,
0.21329844,
0.5562121868,
-0.5590952039,
0.6894642711,
0.2070136666,
0.7500359416,
0.5235332847,
0.0519430526,
0.8013740182,
-0.8434920311,
0.3302278519,
-0.0149707915,
0.5317578912,
0.3491792977,
-0.2379316688,
-0.0070595201,
0.1249041036,
-0.3905233145,
-0.5990309715,
0.0324137136,
-1.0869123936,
-0.0723354667,
1.240489006,
-0.2443018407,
0.0944260284,
-0.3870063722,
-0.2120804787,
0.2725767195,
-0.8742854595,
0.5228580236,
0.4266342521,
-0.0658103377,
-0.4229058325,
-0.4808344245,
-0.0586357601,
0.0610206574,
-0.4083990455,
-0.1550825387,
0.3982448578,
0.4089542329,
0.1260609627,
0.5060720444,
0.305306226,
0.2544090152,
-0.1140082628,
0.0617065467,
-0.3863343596,
-0.4403243661,
-0.4756426811,
0.0944434553,
0.1290596277,
-0.2242187411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15645v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15645v3 | ConvGQR: Generative Query Reformulation for Conversational Search | 2023-05-25T01:45:06 | 2024-01-27T17:42:14 | Fengran Mo, Kelong Mao, Yutao Zhu, Yihong Wu, Kaiyu Huang, Jian-Yun Nie | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | In conversational search, the user's real search intent for the current turn
is dependent on the previous conversation history. It is challenging to
determine a good search query from the whole conversation context. To avoid the
expensive re-training of the query encoder, most existing methods try to learn
a rewriting model to de-contextualize the current query by mimicking the manual
query rewriting. However, manually rewritten queries are not always the best
search queries. Training a rewriting model on them would limit the model's
ability to produce good search queries. Another useful hint is the potential
answer to the question. In this paper, we propose ConvGQR, a new framework to
reformulate conversational queries based on generative pre-trained language
models (PLMs), one for query rewriting and another for generating potential
answers. By combining both, ConvGQR can produce better search queries. In
addition, to relate query reformulation to retrieval performance, we propose a
knowledge infusion mechanism to optimize both query reformulation and
retrieval. Extensive experiments on four conversational search datasets
demonstrate the effectiveness of ConvGQR. | [
-0.395858258,
-0.8829448819,
0.4149373472,
-0.2980496585,
-0.3425451815,
0.0660427585,
-0.1100479588,
0.1570160687,
0.2139392942,
0.9651151299,
-0.7860879302,
-0.4038048387,
-0.0288845878,
-0.0882707089,
-0.4405229092,
0.7579343319,
0.3879333436,
0.1936515868,
-0.5980085731,
0.0068025021,
-0.6354259253,
-0.7205236554,
-0.9063465595,
-0.3003968596,
0.1685751528,
0.3499854803,
0.6779409647,
0.1370031387,
0.5023089051,
0.2646866441,
-0.0730821043,
0.3811182678,
-0.9942839742,
0.5938490629,
0.0558122024,
-0.8085030317,
0.204993844,
-0.2417503744,
0.3671554029,
0.682620585,
-0.7028406858,
-0.3114365041,
-0.0334375836,
0.6754993796,
-0.5652590394,
0.067242153,
-1.0558592081,
0.0670110509,
-0.0122243082,
-0.5900470018,
-0.2987263501,
-0.7253423929,
0.3526219428,
-0.7774538994,
0.6706320643,
0.1313164681,
0.6869728565,
0.2215621471,
-0.4359494448,
-0.3248795271,
-0.8167036176,
0.5643485188,
-0.69243294,
0.6784778833,
0.2783429921,
0.7437284589,
-0.6455041766,
-1.1575572491,
-0.6891107559,
-0.239237994,
-0.3122861385,
0.0970062912,
-0.1390516311,
0.2952409983,
0.0634643808,
0.4714989066,
-0.6259530783,
-0.3211680353,
-0.4764404893,
-0.0878342912,
0.6162291169,
0.306312114,
0.2894426286,
0.0350780003,
-0.4336984754,
-0.2009572983,
-0.8240408897,
0.2350157797,
0.0256002005,
0.1442390978,
0.4951633811,
0.3747393787,
-0.6272216439,
0.9277515411,
0.3548686802,
-0.1498090923,
-0.0798829645,
-0.565186739,
-0.2140758485,
0.0973240361,
0.7682275176,
0.5832443237,
0.2165896893,
-0.2909807861,
-0.0930762738,
-0.2433715463,
0.3539182246,
-0.9627628326,
-0.2845667601,
0.1181078404,
-0.4625909626,
-0.0342498235,
0.1730668545,
-0.4549179673,
-0.1641646177,
-0.3158221841,
0.3771957159,
-0.6451335549,
-0.0061403904,
0.4991235137,
-0.1945163161,
0.5477562547,
0.1748412848,
-0.7951512337,
0.2955393493,
0.7681235075,
0.3787877262,
0.2037086636,
0.1452419907,
-0.7077932358,
-0.0502035506,
-0.116781652,
0.5909153819,
-0.8984704614,
-0.8688670993,
0.2391903996,
0.1103724837,
-0.1150659472,
-0.7291263342,
0.6427727938,
-1.0669670105,
0.5219000578,
-0.3261294365,
-0.8609958887,
-0.3201209009,
0.5496775508,
-0.5431996584,
0.8287280798,
0.0560317896,
-0.454603225,
0.3162234128,
-0.4888656735,
-0.3189806342,
0.4518872797,
-0.1955552697,
-0.418613255,
-0.0496733747,
0.3578778803,
0.2294117212,
-0.4771918356,
0.4759545326,
-0.0102185821,
-0.5351161361,
0.3724755645,
-0.1699535847,
0.5728884935,
0.2636787295,
0.226008743,
0.0312545933,
-0.4625930488,
0.3403893113,
-0.0231520534,
-0.306435138,
-0.4657972455,
0.1095352396,
-0.5192340016,
-0.0802659839,
0.2250629365,
-0.5501902699,
0.2850746214,
-0.7185612321,
0.4441154599,
0.0222588424,
0.3746712506,
0.5773188472,
-0.3652336895,
0.7448043227,
-0.1619042009,
0.3022620082,
-0.3523001373,
-0.2964638174,
-0.9040200114,
0.1647112668,
0.1751857996,
0.4326965213,
-1.1551618576,
0.1541688144,
-0.231895864,
-0.5617877841,
-0.74498564,
-0.0087344032,
0.5285481215,
0.6038575172,
0.3687425852,
-0.2720028758,
-0.6219656467,
-0.6944394112,
-0.4322934747,
-0.0437364914,
-0.0982842371,
0.4954871535,
0.139274776,
-0.023984421,
0.9615423083,
-0.7469297647,
-0.312987119,
-0.2419483066,
-0.0393076614,
0.0921308994,
0.4640747309,
0.2239990234,
-1.074251771,
-0.4040057361,
-0.1624538153,
-0.44068259,
0.1403148472,
-0.0571636818,
-0.4192156494,
-0.2655693293,
1.0022702217,
-0.775831759,
0.1575010717,
0.1426804364,
-0.0558702983,
0.4224887788,
-0.2639796138,
0.2504299581,
-1.015460372,
-0.139928177,
-0.2180694938,
-0.1154431179,
-0.7019798756,
0.0741125941,
-0.1078317761,
-0.2896131873,
-0.4258618057,
0.3625159264,
-0.4029906392,
0.4282783568,
-0.1181543171,
0.0874931067,
0.1601303965,
0.4871468246,
-0.1243395731,
0.8101089001,
0.3775374889,
-0.8938226104,
0.597256124,
0.6322367191,
-0.4523131847,
0.366615057,
-0.806615591,
0.3426322937,
-0.3782272041,
0.440838933,
-1.089635849,
-0.1390855908,
0.0820556283,
-0.3466751873,
0.1024442464,
-0.4318783879,
-0.3413745165,
-0.2222759575,
-0.2367804497,
0.4713641107,
0.490848124,
-0.6743931174,
0.4735479951,
0.3129120469,
-0.0170158073,
-0.2944828272,
-0.3220504224,
-0.1089233235,
-0.1729807407,
-0.7471681833,
0.82859236,
-0.0744386762,
0.007489868,
-0.2274973989,
0.0375998393,
-0.0472741053,
-0.1609338522,
-0.1985162944,
-0.0693120137,
-0.1266339421,
0.1478080451,
-0.0422774665,
0.065656215,
-0.0035355799,
-0.2803933918,
0.9307046533,
0.1887519062,
-0.4929772615,
-0.3165504336,
0.3899662495,
0.3761699498,
-0.7195362449,
0.6025978327,
0.3999965191,
-0.068096295,
-0.113175489,
-0.6967768669,
-0.4911322594,
-0.5058889389,
0.139525786,
-0.4586805999,
-1.2171051502,
0.3317555487,
-0.1681790203,
-0.3709803224,
0.0357463695,
0.4279958606,
-0.1507040709,
1.151979208,
0.538934052,
0.3904767334,
0.699919939,
-0.3041435182,
0.3436235487,
-0.760332942,
-0.7691341639,
-0.4203594625,
-0.1391586959,
-0.8979692459,
-0.2999531925,
0.5011885762,
0.0263989735,
-0.1543028951,
0.0590397418,
-0.5623825192,
0.5057742,
0.803409636,
0.3019477725,
0.1281782687,
-0.059737131,
0.0652288422,
-0.1507831514,
-0.7505710721,
-0.1857741475,
0.9584157467,
-0.343326956,
0.8544802666,
0.0697628558,
0.5409870744,
-0.228080526,
0.0696249008,
-0.7952002287,
0.6178510785,
-0.1244299859,
-0.4734046459,
-0.335231781,
-0.4019938111,
-1.3039125204,
0.4193530977,
-0.160060823,
-0.4088430107,
0.239388451,
0.1317994595,
-0.3942540884,
-0.1278409064,
-0.6181978583,
0.8876451254,
-0.2577912509,
-0.0507076904,
0.018533593,
-0.7403792739,
0.2960439324,
0.3279674351,
-0.2762092948,
0.0873106197,
0.3463799357,
0.4569716454,
-0.5743445754,
0.5784083605,
-0.3354358375,
0.2231203616,
0.4160143733,
0.2100581676,
0.7353231311,
0.1166944578,
-0.0832521021,
-0.5063115954,
0.1923734248,
-0.0797648653,
-0.9804126024,
0.3957997561,
-0.2274288386,
-1.0642209053,
0.0249048397,
-0.2925205231,
-0.2792382538,
0.2536172271,
0.4036256075,
0.3368124068,
-0.6715713739,
0.6142265201,
0.9453188181,
-0.2193067074,
0.0017471506,
0.6741936207,
-0.2711822391,
-0.1670485586,
0.6112068892,
-0.1223268211,
0.1114281565,
0.8168563247,
0.0916469619,
-0.5264773369,
-0.5282134414,
0.0084828446,
0.1233799383,
-0.4083456099,
-0.4066878855,
-0.5857509971,
-0.2849647403,
-0.4205327034,
0.0221059136,
-0.1486192048,
0.0259763151,
-0.2599597871,
0.1530561894,
0.3403707147,
-0.0310557056,
0.4901176393,
0.6250319481,
-0.6830518246,
0.2233173996,
0.5918560624,
0.1845326871,
-0.2851068377,
-0.4645584822,
-0.0274917763,
0.2591229379,
-0.4766741097,
-0.6402968168,
0.7678039074,
0.4192639291,
0.7103084326,
0.2974341512,
0.2942352891,
0.6029581428,
-0.4564884305,
0.6434047222,
0.135510087,
-0.5262442827,
0.6633498073,
-0.1603234857,
0.2628205419,
0.7884458303,
0.2780572772,
-0.8458336592,
-0.1494059414,
-0.545979917,
-0.7970145345,
0.369342804,
0.258461535,
0.4056906998,
-0.0551272519,
0.5500671268,
0.0888345689,
0.3192833662,
-0.0430568643,
-0.0671146438,
-0.3455661833,
-0.0755844563,
0.0723124966,
-0.4623734355,
-0.1094584018,
-0.2815493941,
0.4827006757,
-0.0936800316,
0.2089800239,
0.2208726555,
0.0547817685,
0.3359365761,
0.3083716035,
0.1532649845,
0.374800235,
-0.3609432578,
-0.0801786184,
0.0746643543,
-0.2239673138,
-0.0099613527,
0.2940403223,
-0.3387272656,
-0.0079076327,
-0.2540873885,
0.8281921148,
0.2817356884,
-0.7244367003,
0.5974705815,
-0.5017645359,
-0.2027570605,
-0.4549018741,
0.3693218529,
0.168201521,
0.1569820195,
0.2818261385,
-0.3572188914,
0.542073369,
-0.4727233052,
0.2432738692,
0.8073803186,
-0.3511460721,
-0.0278555118,
0.7173141241,
0.3045355082,
-0.5236667395,
0.9266222715,
-0.3104007244,
-0.5314511061,
0.240137592,
0.6905529499,
0.7013494372,
-0.4308500886,
0.2862210274,
0.37100178,
-0.0071253092,
-0.2437788248,
0.4460823834,
-0.1209577844,
-0.9115771055,
-0.2922881246,
-0.5744795203,
-0.4236175716,
0.3383364975,
-0.724547863,
0.2971918583,
-0.0635094494,
0.0816042796,
-0.0863577127,
-0.1080955192,
-0.7565688491,
0.4163261652,
-0.2909608185,
0.6214613914,
-0.0930211619,
0.7410969138,
0.6927866936,
-0.4851737022,
-0.6178584099,
0.0272486284,
-0.3711543977,
-0.7184160352,
0.4332564771,
0.0095757013,
-0.2045398355,
0.2428658456,
-0.88890481,
-0.8121204376,
1.2082257271,
0.6221430898,
-0.691064775,
-0.1453162581,
0.1377500147,
0.5571137071,
-0.4399602413,
0.0418799855,
0.6178092957,
-0.0015861815,
0.323952198,
-0.7738455534,
0.1312122792,
-0.2227035463,
0.3491663337,
0.2659422457,
-0.6628593802,
0.6850787997,
0.0089979973,
-0.4232202172,
0.1297305971,
0.6731414795,
0.3399568796,
0.2848020792,
0.3051577508,
0.4614710808,
0.7609288096,
-0.2608715296,
1.1789021492,
-0.3780677915,
0.2466704845,
0.997348249,
-0.0738445595,
0.6925812364,
0.4100610018,
-0.053692475,
0.2485972494,
0.4599729478,
0.1609231681,
0.9197418094,
0.4273194671,
-0.5897426605,
-0.4343101084,
-0.0212991983,
-0.3305727243,
0.6699492335,
0.409576565,
-0.2124986947,
-0.2115122229,
0.0067588324,
0.2369616479,
0.2181446254,
-0.0049051191,
1.0136750937,
0.0317008793,
-1.072103858,
0.859003067,
-0.0273462217,
0.6620557904,
-0.5418303609,
-0.1479177475,
-0.6929123998,
0.1593786329,
-0.0691792145,
-0.5362169743,
0.2122499049,
-0.4449385703,
-0.1131944284,
0.0150538655,
0.8778267503,
-0.8101329207,
-0.284355551,
-0.0771833137,
0.597625792,
0.1817576885,
-0.4220575094,
-0.6889749169,
-0.2455623746,
0.1935743392,
0.010057128,
0.1352895349,
0.6015710235,
0.0363518335,
0.8418751359,
0.8554123044,
-0.38326478,
0.0649342015,
0.3253199458,
0.9506712556,
-0.7474792004,
-0.4188679457,
-0.5453326106,
0.224993363,
0.0104095628,
-0.092828162,
0.5440219045,
0.6659463644,
1.0931907892,
0.0337493755,
0.8502592444,
0.2706512511,
0.4738245308,
-0.7708779573,
0.6304911971,
-0.4967367351,
0.3832080066,
0.1846690029,
-0.6948943734,
-0.1841486841,
0.3742401004,
-0.2451809049,
0.0872638747,
0.3647298217,
1.3274124861,
-0.071762234,
0.0095756445,
0.3332413733,
-0.0516625047,
0.5652039051,
0.5079702139,
0.9876580238,
-0.3745613992,
0.8832776546,
-0.0034705386,
0.1603758633,
-0.5811718106,
-0.5293469429,
-0.518214941,
-0.7125291824,
-0.178422913,
-0.246160686,
0.1903211474,
0.5408679247,
0.5474620461,
-0.558473289,
-0.0934247896,
-0.3610805273,
0.0467556044,
-0.1899946034,
-0.2251789868,
0.1739807874,
-0.5715348721,
-0.6864994168,
0.6689020395,
-0.0614831038,
-0.1012660339,
-0.1490123421,
-0.0671406314,
-0.2505460382,
0.046742361,
0.5421474576,
0.3054292202,
-0.5608102083,
-0.1117979735,
0.186296314,
-0.126980409,
0.2679984272,
1.1180969477,
-1.0557014942,
0.8258339763,
0.5139786005,
0.5997591019,
0.9998620152,
0.2390055358,
0.9058493972,
-0.8737018704,
-0.0813605934,
0.3762101233,
0.0982677191,
0.6347936988,
-0.4853157103,
0.3255507052,
-0.0057538114,
-0.5159441829,
-0.6104570031,
0.398245275,
-0.9274097681,
-0.2069913596,
1.1628317833,
0.1586078703,
-0.0391557813,
-0.1594429165,
-0.4895248711,
0.3015922606,
-0.3899003267,
0.6124221683,
0.2648889422,
-0.3082911372,
-0.2182103992,
-0.418249011,
0.7391975522,
0.3613193035,
-0.4542957842,
-0.1145921201,
0.3981769979,
0.3988045156,
-0.1862735748,
0.8238581419,
-0.235072419,
0.1582728475,
-0.1290926635,
0.1067169309,
0.0303659998,
0.1896112561,
0.0829397216,
0.3837818503,
-0.0123508563,
-0.4040538371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15637v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15637v1 | Morphological Inflection: A Reality Check | 2023-05-25T01:27:29 | 2023-05-25T01:27:29 | Jordan Kodner, Sarah Payne, Salam Khalifa, Zoey Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Morphological inflection is a popular task in sub-word NLP with both
practical and cognitive applications. For years now, state-of-the-art systems
have reported high, but also highly variable, performance across data sets and
languages. We investigate the causes of this high performance and high
variability; we find several aspects of data set creation and evaluation which
systematically inflate performance and obfuscate differences between languages.
To improve generalizability and reliability of results, we propose new data
sampling and evaluation strategies that better reflect likely use-cases. Using
these new strategies, we make new observations on the generalization abilities
of current inflection systems. | [
-0.3395989835,
-0.972057879,
0.2653583884,
0.6098225117,
-0.4328425527,
0.1617205739,
-0.0940368623,
-0.5921779275,
0.333529979,
0.4252311289,
-0.4139140248,
-0.2727856934,
-0.5598896146,
0.2073675543,
-0.6560926437,
0.7523409128,
0.2827950716,
0.1852693111,
-0.3789249659,
-0.3502118587,
-0.2683062553,
-0.7365635037,
-0.4599203765,
-0.5429201722,
0.1387712955,
0.2494737804,
1.2193892002,
0.7767579556,
0.8107101321,
0.2558966875,
-0.2862874866,
0.3303684592,
-0.1186364964,
0.4450775683,
-0.2749813795,
-0.5112469196,
-0.259829998,
-0.5338234305,
1.000534296,
0.9189792275,
-0.1222786233,
-0.2351799309,
0.0868188739,
0.6814457774,
-0.5145580769,
-0.0684213191,
-0.6316094995,
0.163578406,
-0.7681929469,
-0.0457367264,
-0.1524053365,
-0.4153791368,
0.0155464718,
-0.3925193846,
0.3344967067,
-0.326877594,
1.0881848335,
0.3428747654,
0.0043215309,
-0.4956248999,
-0.9097341299,
0.4376168549,
-0.8015545011,
0.6496073604,
0.2738652229,
0.1446638107,
-0.4406276047,
-0.7168171406,
-0.6454817057,
-0.263853699,
0.3334056139,
0.0853078216,
-0.2636965513,
-0.0393155962,
0.2995427549,
0.5716713071,
-0.5771253109,
0.3373591304,
0.0134073524,
0.0261432603,
0.4821886122,
0.2127874941,
0.3853799403,
-0.0104232589,
0.0439100936,
-0.3604812622,
-0.6894239187,
-0.0181002822,
0.5859439969,
0.5512080789,
0.1068226472,
0.981379807,
-0.1697000563,
0.4923155904,
0.0514350347,
0.0998295993,
0.436445266,
-0.5479951501,
-0.3182600737,
-0.4056288898,
0.4611090422,
0.0799332634,
0.3456938267,
-0.1188564152,
-0.343151927,
-0.0269928686,
0.0822969526,
-0.3936984837,
0.0157385655,
0.2005964965,
-0.0758848339,
-0.0977627411,
0.0417191535,
-1.1870331764,
-0.4299262762,
-0.1607443243,
0.1577047408,
-0.7324821353,
-0.4135801792,
0.5092893243,
-0.3423285484,
-0.0039248932,
0.1659251451,
-0.996301055,
0.8054204583,
0.7691105008,
0.8950666785,
-0.433673203,
-0.2404846996,
-0.3471597433,
-0.1889419109,
-0.5212934613,
0.885956049,
-0.734573245,
-0.3960704505,
0.3155809641,
-0.344915688,
-0.01735029,
-1.1256154776,
0.4093405008,
-0.0807423517,
-0.0313000008,
0.0861499459,
-0.8034462333,
0.270052731,
-0.1307149231,
-0.5947092175,
1.2775930166,
0.2618126571,
-0.527338624,
0.9103173614,
-0.664540112,
-0.4467967749,
0.4467400908,
-0.1983910203,
-0.4108601213,
0.5115867853,
0.1077792943,
0.2147404402,
-0.0878073275,
0.0897468776,
-0.0217048042,
-0.2238177359,
0.3174549341,
-0.3962606192,
0.690263629,
0.0701595992,
-0.2862073481,
-0.1368962824,
-0.8032634258,
0.1285703778,
-0.1829280704,
-0.5180387497,
-0.5323975086,
0.1622611731,
0.0431128889,
-0.0612224489,
-0.0139642432,
-0.5065703988,
0.331741035,
-0.7465877533,
0.1479432434,
0.3061499,
0.1498432308,
0.2220283449,
-0.1389401853,
0.4193129241,
0.2887565792,
0.1960689723,
0.1562773138,
-0.7933940887,
-0.740041852,
-0.4695171118,
0.4687345922,
0.3733119965,
-0.8799433112,
0.3894333243,
-0.1488568634,
-0.7169857621,
-0.444532752,
0.1279485673,
0.4152218401,
0.291182071,
0.429503262,
-0.4720354378,
-0.3825844824,
-1.0376551151,
-0.4194566309,
-0.2204911113,
-0.0871438161,
0.0893069878,
0.4359206557,
-0.2854142487,
0.842238009,
-0.4013254642,
0.1187651306,
-0.271843195,
0.2198859155,
0.4629791975,
0.6150940657,
0.5527549982,
-0.7546665072,
-0.0906395018,
-0.0199746881,
-0.5576041937,
-0.0690277964,
-0.1472190917,
-0.092691116,
0.4140025675,
0.6050087214,
-0.5552591681,
0.481027782,
0.442558974,
-0.2950668931,
0.6785757542,
-0.482683301,
-0.0927287266,
-0.6715999246,
-0.2315293401,
0.2991097867,
-0.0262798853,
-0.7003275156,
0.2560194731,
0.141726777,
0.3059732616,
-0.4462588727,
0.2900897861,
0.0134395435,
-0.0349614471,
0.1187958345,
-0.2690963149,
-0.4179803133,
0.2406475395,
-0.1770215333,
0.5220586658,
0.6410166621,
-0.9168447256,
0.6241452694,
0.1312013417,
-0.3873432279,
0.6012870669,
-0.5321499705,
0.0173576567,
-0.1299326271,
-0.0360772721,
-1.099232316,
-0.5914771557,
0.1609421968,
-0.2616410255,
0.3700527251,
-0.1180179864,
-0.8707649112,
-0.2744995356,
-0.0130576333,
0.3737669289,
0.3839634657,
-0.482226193,
0.185419485,
0.4899356961,
0.0863078162,
-0.3330319524,
-0.6933274865,
0.1550337225,
-0.380073607,
-0.5269526839,
0.1882174313,
-0.0799215212,
-0.6179007888,
-0.1146004945,
-0.0955577865,
-0.4901579618,
-0.0465022549,
0.0093761804,
-0.1080084518,
-0.1805426329,
0.6608177423,
0.1370042711,
0.2064957619,
-0.2000544071,
-0.2582986653,
0.8712563515,
0.0016106992,
-0.675242722,
-0.1724116951,
0.2243178785,
0.6031777859,
0.1581008732,
0.2490717173,
-0.0175950453,
-0.6798067689,
-0.1168550104,
-0.3803882301,
0.1311012805,
-0.4461168349,
0.6687802672,
-0.5709921122,
-0.3463970721,
0.381300807,
-0.110330075,
0.1792913377,
0.6678431034,
0.6203529835,
-0.1971895248,
0.9269471169,
0.5682397485,
0.1632963121,
0.4220380485,
-0.1452868581,
-0.0998785719,
-0.3254138827,
-0.3771384656,
-0.8256897926,
-0.1459304988,
-0.8756452203,
-0.2794397175,
0.254537344,
-0.1501641721,
0.1956143379,
0.245040521,
-0.3455290496,
0.4326292276,
0.3629361391,
-0.0111050243,
0.2335185856,
0.2086585015,
-0.2300502509,
-0.3454115093,
-0.5930040479,
-0.379072696,
0.8597104549,
0.300534606,
0.7299676538,
0.1218100339,
0.3610141575,
0.3521030247,
-0.2441260815,
-0.86495924,
0.5235869884,
-0.6211308837,
-0.2541588247,
-0.6473169923,
-0.2610389292,
-1.2822116613,
0.3379976451,
-0.2839193344,
-0.518956244,
0.337449193,
0.1316812783,
0.0550966933,
0.3464010358,
-0.5099891424,
0.2756684721,
0.0679280534,
-0.1600188166,
-0.147888422,
-0.3339766562,
-0.0326482952,
-0.1238056272,
0.0762246177,
0.0993191004,
-0.269426018,
0.4093929529,
-0.4248198271,
0.6857233644,
-0.0550847203,
-0.2227818668,
-0.0565665923,
0.1785735488,
0.1819654256,
0.0589430332,
-0.2509571314,
0.2974342704,
-0.1450068802,
-0.3135834336,
-0.824895978,
0.4245195687,
-0.464168191,
-0.3090386987,
-0.3690096736,
-0.5762065649,
-0.5471730232,
-0.0618803985,
0.5372558832,
0.6889523268,
-0.403599143,
0.2607690394,
0.7621148229,
0.0607627183,
0.417214334,
-0.0564806275,
-0.2650324106,
-0.1884129643,
0.8821057677,
0.5291801691,
0.3535732925,
0.3374055624,
0.2976818979,
-0.3249759972,
-0.7693391442,
-0.7121779919,
0.4702939689,
-0.4425605834,
0.1358148605,
-0.2827893198,
-0.2131700516,
-0.4421496093,
0.1407634318,
-0.3971768618,
-0.7769340277,
0.0447103083,
0.1505042911,
0.0680586621,
1.0929586887,
-0.0143976994,
0.1434337646,
-0.4452694952,
0.2220965177,
0.0634722039,
0.4255782962,
-0.5381664038,
-0.3942613006,
-0.2953780591,
0.160759747,
-0.341424942,
-0.8994475603,
0.4474983811,
0.5085635781,
0.6856614947,
0.4087198377,
-0.5788469911,
0.7124817371,
-0.23160927,
0.8803305626,
-0.0638971999,
-0.9754661322,
0.4902321398,
-0.2061760426,
0.4245617688,
0.2294366956,
0.359539628,
-0.7021313906,
-0.8232809305,
-0.9531555176,
-1.0210959911,
0.2723402977,
0.4854333401,
0.2474073917,
-0.0332123339,
0.5766156912,
0.3873731494,
0.3632414639,
-0.0394343883,
-0.0806577876,
-0.1312501878,
-0.1524317712,
-0.1599860936,
-0.1905710548,
-0.0267314669,
-0.3544711471,
0.3137770891,
-0.2606602311,
0.0774276182,
0.1483082771,
-0.2219466567,
-0.0729977638,
0.0596374236,
0.7553096414,
0.8235647678,
-0.0322058983,
0.1953798532,
0.3142848909,
-0.9949189425,
-0.0463257357,
-0.4449081421,
-0.1156136543,
0.4655518532,
0.5392588973,
0.446513772,
0.1574112624,
-0.6070324183,
0.2630206048,
0.0769401565,
-0.2855479717,
-0.0633373708,
0.1412207931,
-0.2444402277,
0.0863063112,
0.2904632986,
0.3093021214,
0.1368243992,
-0.5951244235,
0.1674148589,
0.2876829505,
-0.2259410769,
-0.459544003,
-0.0461448133,
-0.2038702816,
-0.4202927649,
0.7859036922,
0.1486006081,
-0.2991293073,
0.7311273217,
0.6560637951,
0.7423396707,
-0.3508655429,
0.166170314,
0.2035680711,
0.243828401,
-0.0021903447,
0.7413401604,
0.2066707164,
-0.8589469194,
-0.224927485,
-0.3949307501,
-0.6622762084,
0.3025364578,
-0.758946836,
0.2111343741,
-0.5184389353,
-0.311580807,
0.1323265582,
-0.2244462222,
-0.4958672822,
0.4569292963,
-0.2436450273,
1.0306899548,
-0.8856437206,
0.5176653266,
0.9016680121,
-0.4145474136,
-0.2205213755,
0.3271242678,
-0.1288788319,
-0.7577603459,
0.7392415404,
-0.3821368515,
-0.1905229986,
-0.4385693967,
-0.7001187801,
-0.8706042171,
0.2542411983,
0.5618453622,
-0.1339054555,
-0.0851970315,
0.6472798586,
1.0362715721,
-0.3781149387,
0.1386223137,
0.6716012955,
0.5006249547,
-0.0700102225,
-1.0583000183,
-0.1934543401,
-0.2593243122,
0.1347344369,
0.1660381705,
-0.388492018,
0.8323763013,
0.2860719264,
-0.401851058,
-0.0134554496,
0.590141058,
0.1445070803,
0.1586151123,
0.5513242483,
0.4647670686,
1.0463328362,
-0.388196677,
1.1568403244,
0.0314778462,
0.0750154629,
0.8728976846,
0.0002018313,
0.8439869881,
0.7565939426,
-0.2344272882,
0.3329303265,
0.6014945507,
-0.0270949006,
0.3109116852,
0.4553732276,
-0.0451241136,
-0.2213316411,
-0.1570954472,
-0.1922365576,
0.6333158612,
0.7663087845,
0.0693193749,
-0.2617007792,
-0.0639098361,
-0.033180844,
0.0891952813,
-0.1579263657,
0.6491167545,
-0.4291404188,
-0.6017851233,
0.5747872591,
-0.2805447578,
0.6616150737,
-0.6882296205,
-0.2063236237,
-0.3681581914,
0.2031561583,
-0.3621953726,
-1.1432567835,
0.6229346395,
-0.1561321169,
-0.0100576058,
-0.019485021,
0.4102356732,
-0.2565464079,
-0.2793336213,
0.1315430105,
0.6485020518,
0.625895679,
0.0322952829,
-0.3789292872,
-0.0646493435,
-0.2278914601,
0.0033149153,
0.2204406261,
0.6332347393,
-0.4032289684,
0.7664509416,
0.4536346197,
0.6575917602,
0.3475718498,
0.3473044634,
0.8813699484,
-0.3421237469,
-0.2085393965,
-0.9362821579,
0.3096556067,
-0.1809418947,
-0.9292300344,
0.7768070102,
0.8311526179,
1.0735857487,
-0.0519291498,
0.6152114272,
0.1519210935,
0.3825595975,
-0.6467207074,
0.2791730464,
-0.6138784885,
-0.1499998868,
-0.4428794682,
-0.7956884503,
-0.6378293633,
0.3584482074,
0.1612805128,
-0.0953942761,
0.7853847742,
0.6434203386,
-0.1208423302,
0.0429243818,
0.6925051212,
0.1767236441,
0.4232096076,
0.0839550421,
0.8925863504,
-0.1791458428,
0.2393862307,
-0.2733642459,
-0.2919824123,
-0.2301361561,
-0.6648439169,
-0.3399673104,
-0.9612988234,
-0.2227165848,
-0.3552094102,
0.1332065314,
0.8255797625,
0.6121228337,
-0.7376533747,
-0.5959035158,
-0.211929962,
0.0146136014,
-0.6313949227,
-0.1869908869,
0.2313728929,
-0.60340029,
-1.1127825975,
0.5654243231,
0.3792946637,
0.2666991949,
-0.2146242559,
0.227309227,
-0.0903486237,
0.3262866437,
0.2554273903,
0.3897789717,
-0.4902062118,
-0.0594339631,
-0.1265247464,
-0.0816939622,
0.334344238,
1.018042326,
-0.488165915,
0.5337067842,
0.7204548717,
0.4840602279,
0.4481106102,
-0.0630053058,
0.5757969022,
-0.8939723372,
0.091905944,
0.2790268064,
0.4934462011,
0.305066824,
-0.5224969983,
0.6747606993,
0.4079375267,
-0.2258646041,
-0.908552289,
0.4730123281,
-0.5983192325,
-0.1475046575,
1.0501792431,
0.1293469816,
0.0020770202,
-0.4844733775,
-0.1076370701,
0.2085815966,
-0.4014951289,
0.7052116394,
0.958591938,
-0.5577843189,
0.4619026482,
-0.3571673334,
0.684461236,
0.4302508831,
-0.8646572232,
-0.0718235224,
0.2650483847,
0.1136848107,
0.4308276176,
0.3106057644,
-0.3364147544,
0.1438796222,
0.1322579533,
-0.1036985144,
0.1985688806,
-0.496212095,
-0.6503199339,
0.2749938965,
-0.0424753726,
-0.0406207293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15605v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15605v1 | Revisiting Sentence Union Generation as a Testbed for Text Consolidation | 2023-05-24T22:34:01 | 2023-05-24T22:34:01 | Eran Hirsch, Valentina Pyatkin, Ruben Wolhandler, Avi Caciularu, Asi Shefer, Ido Dagan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tasks involving text generation based on multiple input texts, such as
multi-document summarization, long-form question answering and contemporary
dialogue applications, challenge models for their ability to properly
consolidate partly-overlapping multi-text information. However, these tasks
entangle the consolidation phase with the often subjective and ill-defined
content selection requirement, impeding proper assessment of models'
consolidation capabilities. In this paper, we suggest revisiting the sentence
union generation task as an effective well-defined testbed for assessing text
consolidation capabilities, decoupling the consolidation challenge from
subjective content selection. To support research on this task, we present
refined annotation methodology and tools for crowdsourcing sentence union,
create the largest union dataset to date and provide an analysis of its rich
coverage of various consolidation aspects. We then propose a comprehensive
evaluation protocol for union generation, including both human and automatic
evaluation. Finally, as baselines, we evaluate state-of-the-art language models
on the task, along with a detailed analysis of their capacity to address
multi-text consolidation challenges and their limitations. | [
-0.6339533925,
-0.6422423124,
0.3709894419,
0.340613991,
-0.3331076503,
0.063839592,
-0.4986179471,
-0.1995335966,
0.0446362123,
0.5889250636,
-0.5527334809,
-0.1136621311,
-0.5383074284,
0.6362189651,
-0.5283081532,
1.1969852448,
-0.3008807302,
-0.4514938891,
-0.7659273744,
-0.197066009,
-0.9091198444,
-0.4874171913,
-0.3354835212,
-0.2914746404,
0.1877469569,
0.4044697583,
0.3295374811,
0.0041424781,
0.6324467063,
0.3990541399,
-0.0281699263,
0.5032718182,
-0.6532713771,
0.3340731263,
0.0428531617,
-0.2858609557,
-0.2175881863,
0.1982322931,
0.6651220918,
0.7047120333,
-0.2090324014,
0.1359152794,
0.3241453469,
0.4109957218,
-0.654307425,
0.2082184255,
-0.3583497703,
0.0088066533,
0.0754469708,
0.0214950815,
-0.6273204088,
-0.5436232686,
0.1714063138,
-0.4518181682,
0.2649247348,
-0.1019186154,
0.7543390989,
0.2721063793,
-0.7685890794,
-0.1536707431,
-0.6176972389,
0.6229161024,
-0.5500432253,
0.1892345995,
0.2713668942,
0.1229020804,
-0.217316702,
-0.7406293154,
-0.7278434038,
-0.059968248,
-0.530377388,
0.3643929064,
-0.4130890667,
-0.091554977,
-0.1884605438,
0.6298878789,
-0.4735672176,
-0.0208366141,
-0.623362422,
-0.2817468047,
0.6044322252,
-0.0062982282,
0.2895992398,
-0.5451668501,
-0.4576433003,
-0.1619800329,
-0.1034994349,
0.0325719006,
0.4288669229,
0.3721580207,
0.01457028,
0.7008854747,
-0.4716083705,
0.6812644005,
-0.154775396,
0.2443594038,
0.4807799459,
-0.8732323647,
-0.3715334535,
-0.1285420507,
1.1386888027,
0.5967742801,
0.0072584422,
-0.2427716553,
-0.1072261781,
0.3202134669,
0.7134054899,
-0.5940961838,
-0.1359227747,
0.514701426,
-0.4678262174,
-0.4818833768,
0.0477287956,
-0.6715175509,
-0.0111702625,
-0.450453788,
0.0415677689,
-0.2486628294,
-0.3563358784,
0.1101607606,
-0.3511742055,
-0.1957538426,
-0.0041950578,
-0.5940369964,
0.1119327173,
0.6644124985,
0.6908314228,
-0.1982007474,
-0.4482177496,
-0.8040028811,
-0.3173549771,
0.000699338,
0.9601683617,
-0.3202033937,
-0.4980664551,
0.2644435465,
0.0372244529,
0.0161439013,
-0.2592271864,
0.7268354297,
-0.0348272771,
0.7905724645,
-0.1473876089,
-0.6002446413,
-0.1222143844,
0.6292080283,
-0.8558946848,
1.1121151447,
0.4546296597,
-0.6526655555,
0.5221153498,
-0.6236926317,
-0.5113699436,
0.0936409608,
-0.1105901003,
-0.6807969809,
0.161686182,
0.1978749782,
0.6504976749,
-0.1475488245,
0.6472713947,
-0.0881170854,
-0.2794518769,
0.3769963384,
-0.2539928854,
0.7290854454,
0.1262807101,
-0.1808252782,
0.0579611249,
-0.5222683549,
-0.1319958121,
-0.196707502,
-0.6363531351,
-0.2927170098,
-0.2096918523,
0.1184438094,
-0.0092175435,
0.1866244227,
-0.4859682918,
0.4900960028,
-0.0378082544,
0.565949142,
0.3275076449,
0.2022051215,
0.4951464236,
-0.3187608719,
0.5263361931,
0.0533112697,
0.2521749139,
-0.2432768792,
-0.3670339286,
-0.5574548841,
0.0240705349,
0.5173973441,
0.4006227553,
-0.6674242616,
0.8090010881,
-0.3816049993,
-0.5341147184,
-0.7652103305,
0.3151554763,
0.5376557708,
0.2162557542,
0.6014952064,
-0.4129483998,
-0.7532045841,
-1.0280530453,
0.0674337074,
-0.2924489081,
0.2490416765,
0.0875928923,
0.2810705006,
-0.2723977268,
1.0114842653,
-0.392287761,
-0.4006126821,
-0.5011438727,
0.7392495871,
-0.2909990549,
0.4716348052,
0.1004043221,
-0.9413975477,
0.0115747517,
-0.2198570818,
-0.6869128942,
-0.1697284132,
-0.4799585342,
-0.2324357927,
0.0038966048,
0.6509506702,
-0.6575875282,
0.1621072441,
0.9052987695,
-0.4444379807,
0.608894825,
-0.0859816968,
0.4749108851,
-1.4018182755,
0.0335221738,
-0.065839842,
-0.2049248219,
-0.4024270475,
0.3834391832,
0.0878590047,
0.0006738252,
-0.3657479584,
-0.0417831652,
-0.5738148093,
0.1130309552,
-0.358823657,
0.5647661686,
0.0900902376,
0.3269310892,
-0.3958140314,
0.5729533434,
0.036476925,
-0.4589543045,
0.4899264276,
0.6337090135,
-0.2176463604,
0.5711352229,
-0.3061913848,
0.0296802763,
-0.2492399067,
0.6572875977,
-1.3760071993,
-0.133880496,
-0.0721821114,
-0.3358131349,
-0.2047737241,
0.1204300597,
-0.5471353531,
-0.3929446638,
-0.1663326174,
0.3865518272,
0.4705934227,
-0.386680305,
0.6178620458,
0.1328765303,
-0.1147467941,
-0.4277905822,
-0.6533182263,
0.3949100375,
-0.2686249018,
-0.5086050034,
0.3335727155,
-0.0522791967,
-0.347823292,
0.0789661556,
0.3511363864,
0.143153131,
0.1435464472,
0.3696007431,
0.363314569,
-0.0247152671,
0.2759402692,
0.1860121638,
0.0715959743,
-0.0174432453,
-0.0041477131,
0.4937762618,
0.0243597645,
0.0230946951,
-0.2006242126,
0.5275186896,
0.4355912805,
-0.6083933115,
0.3981727362,
0.7339028716,
-0.1661081612,
-0.1388631016,
-0.7604056001,
-0.0630374327,
-0.3552563787,
0.0943997279,
-0.1624570489,
-1.0918642282,
0.1956814677,
-0.2143335193,
0.552616775,
0.5178695321,
0.3910698593,
-0.0033366517,
0.2168173045,
0.5602892637,
-0.0081042275,
0.0579890944,
-0.182291016,
0.0406872407,
-0.8037618995,
-0.1986885816,
-0.5070202351,
-0.5775809288,
-0.5103772283,
-0.2832682729,
-0.2217528224,
0.2549577653,
0.3141864538,
0.7129598856,
-0.6554346681,
0.3921467066,
0.5414717793,
0.2488695234,
0.455671221,
-0.2654525638,
0.1770674437,
0.157308653,
-0.4090677798,
-0.3950386345,
1.0176742077,
-0.0257613957,
-0.1147166714,
0.1302928478,
1.0514707565,
0.2759227157,
0.4896578491,
-0.5403795838,
0.5765020847,
-0.4048801661,
-0.2986715436,
-0.4078025222,
-0.4120761156,
-1.0850089788,
0.3307457268,
-0.6059017777,
-0.3305914104,
-0.0384306125,
-0.1477596313,
-0.6304808259,
-0.0996704623,
-1.0578640699,
0.955432415,
0.2106102705,
-0.004135754,
-0.0410872623,
-0.4025815427,
0.7193896174,
-0.1468762904,
0.0583791547,
0.2521925569,
0.1105832011,
0.6003005505,
-0.1173930243,
0.9640517831,
0.2317991853,
-0.0782022029,
0.4324416816,
0.006869263,
0.2963751554,
-0.050797198,
0.2072973847,
-0.0710404068,
-0.3536640108,
-0.2327216417,
-0.6294745803,
0.4826332629,
-0.4773287177,
-0.298789531,
0.1312960535,
-0.5249454975,
-0.14149037,
0.1395968646,
0.2782431543,
0.462453872,
-0.402476579,
0.4271374345,
0.2188237756,
0.0991863385,
0.6690959334,
0.109961465,
-0.3390068114,
-0.4814094007,
0.6163232327,
-0.1523506641,
0.1782227308,
0.0303094331,
-0.0926788077,
-0.3224628866,
-0.5137372613,
-0.2227565199,
-0.0537104718,
-0.2961276472,
-0.2451332659,
-0.7386645675,
0.0639525428,
-0.4533416331,
-0.1832076013,
-0.1638102978,
-0.2253516167,
-0.2736796141,
-0.4592396021,
0.0611219369,
0.5908902287,
0.0789789855,
0.2601382434,
-0.9146414995,
0.4125481248,
0.2519354522,
0.2029100657,
-0.2876179516,
0.041399911,
0.0156961661,
-0.3086617291,
-0.310710609,
-0.9050924182,
-0.0302645676,
-0.1889692694,
0.3534851074,
0.0174984951,
0.2133542448,
0.5059518814,
-0.3201656044,
1.0418584347,
0.3469218016,
-0.7604001164,
0.4692890346,
-0.0776958242,
0.4080572724,
1.0561966896,
0.0006140388,
-0.4618929029,
-1.0490009785,
-0.9060112238,
-0.831494391,
0.1467578858,
0.6414582133,
0.1962876618,
-0.2132270783,
0.3398063779,
0.2339669615,
0.1651062816,
-0.7110106349,
0.1507166624,
-0.0289993007,
-0.0873836651,
-0.3934920132,
-0.2173324674,
-0.1609993428,
0.1486927122,
0.3410466313,
0.1320731789,
-0.0096741831,
0.2827326059,
-0.1898093671,
0.0804406404,
0.7842900753,
0.4559954107,
0.2181488425,
-0.0181688461,
0.0135854566,
0.0908841118,
-0.2629170716,
0.1973538995,
0.4700775743,
-0.1119977906,
0.2829232216,
0.518987,
0.6038837433,
0.3302695453,
-0.5498653054,
0.5809366703,
-0.2734877765,
-0.7559335828,
-0.2854191661,
-0.0666321591,
0.0265757758,
0.3396955729,
0.170559451,
0.0651488975,
0.2818362117,
-0.6099559069,
0.44441998,
0.1575477868,
-0.3155518174,
0.2618241012,
0.3736284375,
0.6564400196,
-0.1697567105,
1.02219522,
-0.5966916084,
-0.562037766,
0.5185681581,
0.1367100179,
0.849832952,
0.0343804657,
0.4119666815,
0.4522920251,
0.57068187,
-0.3928448856,
0.1365832835,
-0.0230817739,
-0.6817371845,
-0.9043388963,
-0.3414942324,
-0.2755341828,
0.1410243213,
-0.8653976917,
0.2694567442,
0.1236433759,
-0.3992156386,
-0.2345085442,
0.008002365,
-0.6058594584,
0.2603903711,
0.1065427065,
0.6475976706,
-1.0286351442,
0.2146055996,
0.5437663794,
-0.7165856361,
-0.8243281245,
-0.0014192413,
-0.2366019338,
-0.1412443817,
0.2708160877,
0.3845039904,
0.3925818503,
-0.1568967253,
-0.1505938619,
-0.1429948956,
1.1078031063,
0.0969214216,
-0.6426387429,
-0.14224343,
-0.0764869303,
0.6370304823,
-0.325448066,
0.2473112792,
0.7401885986,
0.5334513783,
-0.3812409639,
-1.072473526,
0.370908469,
-0.3069559634,
-0.1012672484,
0.368989557,
-0.7162313461,
0.9076280594,
0.0168041363,
-0.2301054746,
-0.0966563299,
0.7856075764,
0.221684292,
0.0823073238,
0.9050281048,
0.720711112,
0.6807652712,
-0.2098517418,
1.0528147221,
0.0591529533,
0.4092939794,
1.3106188774,
-0.0075299265,
1.1033409834,
0.5332545042,
0.1037784815,
0.5878182054,
0.3484992087,
-0.3838806152,
0.1268778294,
0.3646204174,
-0.0563930199,
-0.389408946,
-0.1479521394,
-0.295910418,
0.7442658544,
-0.2948430181,
-0.360047102,
-0.3527496755,
0.0691261664,
-0.1790834367,
0.4088314474,
0.0048156325,
0.9342406392,
-0.2724348605,
-1.1619436741,
0.1825505793,
-0.1858807355,
0.6943533421,
-0.1784798503,
-0.1221397743,
-0.4437935054,
-0.16109474,
-0.286172539,
-0.8664588928,
0.2575411499,
-0.0078369081,
-0.0253658369,
-0.4118764997,
0.4417548776,
-0.7653515339,
-0.2935248911,
0.1781753451,
0.5767483711,
0.022463426,
-0.1697102189,
-0.2789928317,
0.1921557039,
0.1154274195,
-0.1270238906,
0.0872771442,
0.4076863527,
0.2973124683,
0.2412052006,
0.7076944709,
-0.1028574482,
-0.248906821,
0.283744961,
0.700674057,
-0.3865426183,
-0.7038818002,
-0.7824646831,
1.0257691145,
-0.3942544162,
-0.644103229,
0.6265032887,
0.8255242705,
0.9774284959,
0.1509946585,
1.0479469299,
-0.1183910966,
0.3055332601,
-0.5337588787,
0.6194218993,
-0.5326646566,
-0.1578378379,
-0.2112133503,
-0.939273417,
-0.1690276861,
0.1015013158,
-0.021405112,
-0.2273014039,
1.0031579733,
0.2958750129,
-0.1403919011,
0.3440975547,
0.0142313521,
-0.0879980475,
0.2658225894,
0.6741437912,
0.8770389557,
-0.5716180801,
1.171676755,
-0.1885172278,
-0.1642790437,
-0.1555048078,
-0.8818680644,
-0.9815071225,
-0.8972766399,
-0.4247840643,
-0.488460362,
-0.2228098512,
0.6730176806,
0.3515992463,
-0.4408489466,
-0.0949248746,
-0.1451455355,
-0.2879312634,
-0.2292166948,
-0.2553451955,
0.0050686174,
-0.686952889,
-0.770914495,
0.3321167231,
0.0069561335,
-0.039004676,
-0.5125616789,
0.3345048726,
-0.2751851976,
-0.175223127,
0.7077932358,
-0.0694517046,
-0.5463322997,
-0.1682775021,
-0.2267142087,
-0.3847163022,
-0.2148674428,
1.1125451326,
-0.7312726974,
0.430685401,
0.4041989148,
0.8149837255,
0.1523088068,
0.3588614464,
0.7397363186,
-1.0056899786,
-0.0480842926,
-0.0271237269,
0.4901587367,
0.4104452133,
-0.2718408406,
0.7125672698,
0.0351535045,
-0.3682842851,
-0.8782209754,
0.0490413792,
-1.1810346842,
-0.4615149796,
1.2107548714,
0.0043545822,
0.0506066903,
-0.132163018,
-0.4783000052,
0.4956759214,
-0.4121525586,
1.0411533117,
1.1619058847,
0.1718480885,
-0.1801111698,
-0.3573383987,
0.226518482,
0.5340556502,
-1.1115812063,
0.391869694,
0.7636908293,
-0.1743112355,
0.5430899858,
0.6422716379,
0.0209494606,
0.3589482903,
-0.0511377119,
0.2432831526,
-0.2910220027,
-0.1105940193,
-0.3011610806,
0.5140600204,
-0.3717704713,
-0.270386219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15597v1 | Text-Augmented Open Knowledge Graph Completion via Pre-Trained Language Models | 2023-05-24T22:09:35 | 2023-05-24T22:09:35 | Pengcheng Jiang, Shivam Agarwal, Bowen Jin, Xuan Wang, Jimeng Sun, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The mission of open knowledge graph (KG) completion is to draw new findings
from known facts. Existing works that augment KG completion require either (1)
factual triples to enlarge the graph reasoning space or (2) manually designed
prompts to extract knowledge from a pre-trained language model (PLM),
exhibiting limited performance and requiring expensive efforts from experts. To
this end, we propose TAGREAL that automatically generates quality query prompts
and retrieves support information from large text corpora to probe knowledge
from PLM for KG completion. The results show that TAGREAL achieves
state-of-the-art performance on two benchmark datasets. We find that TAGREAL
has superb performance even with limited training data, outperforming existing
embedding-based, graph-based, and PLM-based methods. | [
-0.5075256824,
-0.516400218,
0.6230043769,
-0.2177022547,
-0.2124614716,
0.5178645849,
-0.3243489563,
-0.3901189864,
0.1487966776,
0.702347815,
-0.3150998056,
-0.8064814806,
-0.5911866426,
0.0572363622,
-0.1077880263,
1.0333986282,
-0.3495562077,
-0.1917475611,
-0.5611408353,
-0.1397683918,
-0.539588213,
-0.2111250758,
-0.3601780236,
-0.5740402937,
0.5138567686,
0.500477314,
0.718755722,
0.6123148799,
0.3158218563,
0.175469473,
0.2697412968,
0.7896926403,
-0.5269621611,
-0.1002629697,
-0.2048624456,
-0.4300871789,
-0.4068193436,
0.2898443341,
0.744032681,
0.7642765045,
0.1054021344,
0.0397786796,
-0.0643154457,
0.6625466347,
-0.3899398744,
0.3941187561,
-0.4460133314,
-0.1468294561,
-0.226332739,
-0.3098312616,
-0.598516643,
-0.7379767895,
0.32612589,
-1.0270345211,
0.1153056771,
0.4165456295,
1.0944187641,
0.3588996828,
-0.5484304428,
-0.6747974157,
-0.5532050729,
0.4168506861,
-0.3554945886,
0.5602796674,
0.8187683821,
0.3136484325,
-0.218048647,
-0.9256424308,
-0.5320028067,
-0.2580940723,
-0.5709522963,
0.1803264767,
-0.1251332611,
0.2021086961,
0.3949933946,
0.1083018482,
-0.5845347643,
-0.2108817548,
-0.2205845863,
-0.3083054423,
0.2509109676,
-0.2342692316,
0.4345549643,
-0.4114195406,
-0.3923334777,
-0.1582764536,
-0.8060613871,
0.0435503833,
0.4725229442,
0.250654012,
0.2465496957,
0.708501339,
-0.3640552759,
1.1905424595,
-0.4778659046,
-0.1765956283,
0.3468779325,
-0.3942062259,
-0.0373965092,
0.1236859411,
0.8142009377,
0.1156799942,
0.4249753952,
-0.5358707309,
-0.0027177751,
-0.0482248701,
0.0566039905,
-0.7654445171,
-0.5862381458,
0.0526551157,
-0.0304386932,
0.3152841628,
-0.0349845327,
-0.5929763317,
-0.3842119277,
-0.2916535139,
0.4764096737,
-0.8744146824,
-0.3072573245,
0.2481502593,
-0.2976318002,
-0.0810564011,
0.4282636046,
-0.3000629246,
0.0459828377,
0.5261625648,
0.6774116158,
0.0872821286,
-0.07221587,
-0.6123220921,
0.2433577031,
-0.5043829083,
1.0100787878,
-0.7231998444,
-0.3019063473,
-0.0792422369,
-0.3598312736,
-0.1428870857,
-0.5018464923,
0.6308256388,
-0.9968218803,
0.1921018362,
-0.4985772371,
-0.9427588582,
-0.2959288359,
0.2468717396,
-0.6629093289,
1.318837285,
0.1302718073,
-0.9380900264,
0.58659935,
-0.6841264367,
-0.3729543388,
0.4144523442,
-0.1631556898,
0.0577097088,
-0.3019094169,
0.4404012263,
0.454788655,
-0.2989431024,
0.2855776548,
0.0135864113,
-0.1206755564,
-0.0488069691,
0.2993633151,
0.3265186846,
0.1328526735,
0.1543732435,
0.0453152917,
-0.9176118374,
0.0627020895,
0.0587272681,
-0.4578119218,
-0.6040015817,
0.0752241611,
-0.5395831466,
0.0635958612,
0.4204231203,
-0.6817615032,
0.4543244541,
-0.6778048277,
0.1004223898,
0.4478207529,
-0.0929403007,
0.4339702129,
-0.1842448711,
0.5334981084,
-0.3259509206,
-0.4050093889,
-0.3073193431,
-0.6069278121,
-0.5850511789,
-0.507938683,
0.6899492145,
0.4584009051,
-1.1859676838,
0.2937072515,
-0.4821635485,
-0.6247651577,
-0.6582408547,
0.2267281711,
0.4914583564,
0.8239386082,
0.3701528609,
-0.1952149421,
-0.5689136386,
-0.5063954592,
-0.1890563965,
-0.2041950822,
0.0088551901,
0.5749559999,
0.3572622836,
0.0247520246,
1.5428779125,
-0.9239435792,
-0.4698528647,
-0.2108463645,
0.3299016953,
0.1160894409,
0.2584061921,
0.5399578214,
-0.8142517209,
-0.4781104326,
0.1345171183,
-0.7198691368,
-0.2685006559,
0.4435921013,
-0.4459355772,
0.0211264044,
0.5189186931,
-0.6958943009,
0.3558993638,
0.4737096727,
-0.4268869758,
0.4256488085,
-0.1764465719,
0.1807982326,
-1.1529340744,
0.3423535228,
-0.2807147205,
-0.5818676949,
-0.4082636237,
-0.2623410523,
0.001494916,
-0.1436090171,
0.0072397483,
0.7517907619,
-0.4037414193,
-0.1553198546,
-0.3201556504,
0.6779344082,
0.1778393835,
0.3540720046,
0.0555438586,
0.767616868,
0.2894198895,
-0.4902274013,
0.3781083524,
0.6069595814,
-0.5415569544,
0.204706341,
-0.629978478,
-0.0668111444,
-0.3230832517,
0.2500706613,
-1.4073617458,
-0.6574833989,
0.2361624539,
-0.8004200459,
0.3056176007,
-0.340172708,
-0.8784819841,
-0.4505046606,
0.2016449422,
0.4347180724,
0.5984138846,
-0.6676394343,
0.6436036229,
0.3339631557,
-0.0848078951,
-0.6643246412,
-0.2171927989,
-0.0567570366,
0.3685546517,
-0.5071325898,
0.2627524436,
-0.00346968,
0.3238119781,
0.4064163566,
-0.0120061869,
0.0633023679,
-0.0396713167,
0.1717041731,
0.1687138081,
-0.0001423141,
0.3572213352,
-0.1693965942,
-0.2112075686,
-0.1335773319,
-0.4822457433,
0.8204841018,
0.0597899333,
-0.3599428535,
-0.1714437604,
-0.0278167464,
0.1829909086,
-0.7403850555,
0.6252220869,
0.5366544724,
-0.4790415466,
-0.1805450022,
-0.4356600344,
0.1407217234,
-0.4115047753,
0.1031415984,
-0.2964746356,
-1.2580406666,
0.3527494967,
-0.4822281599,
-0.1137607545,
0.3747876883,
0.1767228246,
0.0570234843,
1.2035560608,
0.5250952244,
0.1801141649,
0.286652267,
-0.1875620782,
0.2225218266,
-0.5338228345,
-0.4184648991,
-0.6269257665,
0.101332061,
-0.380787015,
-0.4798049033,
0.4750966728,
0.5121080279,
-0.1023619473,
0.4113159478,
-0.4054374993,
0.4508439004,
0.703448236,
-0.0090601267,
0.4614733756,
-0.031209033,
-0.4649502635,
0.0082356958,
-0.8816731572,
-0.3872773349,
0.9452536106,
-0.0078050308,
0.582840085,
0.0419437997,
0.598459065,
0.1930006891,
0.5655212998,
-0.6727963686,
0.4953649342,
0.1500052363,
-0.608201623,
0.0013807352,
-0.6946707964,
-0.9406875968,
-0.0966776162,
-0.276871562,
-0.6619384289,
-0.3136654794,
0.2078187168,
-0.1803964972,
0.1166783273,
-0.688893497,
0.9139744043,
0.1054278538,
0.0713613182,
0.0022546796,
-0.6395319104,
0.2993499041,
-0.1063308939,
0.1328743398,
-0.2990843654,
0.0054342104,
0.961247921,
-0.4659763575,
0.6246178746,
-0.4402549565,
-0.0292311516,
0.4214482903,
-0.0180356726,
0.5240532756,
-0.040765997,
0.0296257064,
-0.2665335536,
-0.2914376259,
-0.3923600614,
-0.7377482057,
0.5035783052,
-0.7981125116,
-0.3545459211,
-0.1999543756,
-0.6301986575,
-0.5220929384,
0.5789672136,
0.1632153243,
0.707395792,
0.0113289449,
-0.0082544256,
0.6759285331,
-0.350494951,
0.2035882175,
0.5126966238,
-0.6764441729,
-0.6559375525,
1.0469830036,
0.364674896,
0.0475892574,
0.4482035935,
0.0465672463,
-0.5370838642,
-0.5056088567,
-0.6476354003,
0.3248640597,
-0.7610900402,
-0.4694916904,
-0.9717507362,
-0.1754064709,
-0.4667369127,
-0.0971112177,
-0.383154422,
-0.2603108883,
-0.015339572,
-0.2417954952,
0.662735343,
0.8250848055,
0.0665352046,
0.4661904573,
-0.9886090755,
0.3199680448,
0.1886489242,
0.6224433184,
-0.0671315938,
-0.0460164584,
-0.3905661702,
-0.1922641098,
0.2382057011,
-0.8179166913,
0.2482443601,
0.1974703819,
0.5606321096,
0.2056577057,
0.2294275463,
0.415571183,
-0.5335470438,
0.6595653296,
0.0925957859,
-0.7160509825,
0.784799397,
-0.596259594,
0.2385100126,
0.5684583783,
0.9043382406,
-0.1501816809,
-0.221445784,
-0.4156283438,
-0.7094637156,
0.9203552008,
0.1190333515,
-0.2710708678,
-0.1550312489,
0.3275997937,
0.1179126129,
0.5007463694,
-0.3320878446,
-0.1147661507,
-0.1806589812,
-0.3664016724,
-0.1227658913,
-0.2412037849,
-0.1720811129,
-0.327280879,
0.8352806568,
-0.4083448052,
0.1761448532,
0.2911177576,
-0.2708445787,
0.1022500992,
-0.0118202763,
0.1417516768,
0.7768312097,
-0.2945804298,
0.1094439998,
-0.1877477914,
-0.2729488015,
-0.073271282,
0.5242992043,
-0.117912434,
0.0328571871,
0.2711702287,
0.8547638059,
-0.0122416737,
-0.9569065571,
0.6619905829,
0.0392351598,
-0.0410282835,
0.0062632035,
-0.0353588164,
0.0954445675,
0.1268084198,
0.3825009167,
0.0480944775,
-0.1696759462,
-0.2249088436,
0.3602424562,
0.1720026731,
-0.3155183792,
-0.1577234715,
0.6258891821,
0.009239818,
0.039151039,
0.5257200599,
-0.6124510169,
-0.7953005433,
0.2161933482,
0.4741024673,
0.2113842368,
0.017090315,
0.5009014606,
0.3956092894,
0.2358983904,
-0.0095574753,
0.4536934793,
-0.1136354432,
-0.841540277,
-1.018056035,
-0.9513274431,
-0.309948504,
-0.3874762058,
-0.4332303405,
0.0912804529,
-0.4020539224,
-0.1788774133,
-0.0526616797,
0.2525915205,
-0.7533764839,
0.3287515938,
-0.1244879887,
1.1132155657,
-0.5905663371,
0.8469369411,
0.9606184363,
-0.5880855322,
-1.0190143585,
-0.211821869,
-0.4272816479,
-0.9103285074,
0.7697583437,
0.222357884,
-0.0285752248,
0.4923532903,
-0.4736745954,
-1.0066621304,
0.9862263799,
0.4808541238,
-0.0172443707,
-0.1714295894,
0.2570056021,
0.4852271676,
-0.2150230855,
0.1702852398,
0.4898167253,
0.5260047317,
0.3193727136,
-0.8019703031,
0.0377475694,
-0.1375551373,
-0.2166714072,
0.5797313452,
-0.47670573,
0.4683668613,
0.028185863,
-0.2872379422,
-0.020956818,
0.8229568005,
0.0685613304,
0.2194305509,
0.4695779979,
1.0463051796,
1.2242090702,
-0.2238362283,
1.1212636232,
-0.5342260003,
0.2836691439,
1.1097724438,
-0.3464370966,
0.7000678182,
-0.1648847908,
0.0403252095,
0.5988308191,
0.583501637,
0.2561444044,
0.5849477053,
-0.074794516,
-0.2376606911,
-0.4617820978,
-0.6646772623,
-0.3171987832,
0.5823069811,
0.4237961173,
-0.1523171961,
-0.4181111753,
0.2540123761,
0.1914058179,
0.1720996499,
-0.3345191181,
0.7845970988,
-0.1613562405,
-1.0336643457,
0.33112517,
-0.0775090903,
0.3337543905,
-0.8064061403,
-0.1454841495,
0.1411382258,
-0.1506653428,
-0.1628611535,
-0.8140946031,
0.1781735569,
-0.0190858487,
-0.2385159582,
-0.2811630368,
1.2544785738,
-0.5925513506,
-0.1483877003,
0.4509802759,
0.7829512954,
0.0999310166,
-0.0421927422,
-0.15734905,
-0.2027416676,
-0.1577098668,
-0.2089978307,
0.0498993285,
0.353712827,
0.1452228129,
0.5432437658,
0.6694312096,
-0.039637953,
0.083649464,
-0.0154255247,
1.091378808,
-0.3965007961,
-0.395467937,
-0.5600727797,
0.2654709816,
-0.2680939734,
-0.1362421215,
0.7808314562,
0.6326202154,
1.1233999729,
0.2655465603,
0.9957095981,
-0.2392710149,
0.7995247841,
-0.642721951,
0.8544740677,
-0.5746619701,
-0.2022624612,
-0.1388508826,
-0.7027570009,
-0.1858437806,
0.2643551528,
-0.46676144,
0.0088319881,
0.588545382,
0.7087718844,
0.0078780968,
0.1199674904,
0.1377505213,
0.1322341263,
0.2397685945,
0.494024843,
0.8302001953,
-0.1143315136,
0.7000988126,
0.133636266,
-0.3619695306,
-0.0605605356,
-0.8696484566,
-1.0605381727,
-0.6470720172,
-0.1856082827,
-0.4513548017,
-0.1257237494,
1.0967378616,
0.6217608452,
-0.4255330563,
0.3515510261,
0.0278719831,
0.2112946808,
0.3339486122,
-0.1961773634,
0.5825082064,
-0.5141976476,
-0.5318809152,
0.5478074551,
0.0974368006,
-0.2458813637,
0.0977624133,
-0.0697482824,
-0.4104392231,
0.0192863904,
0.5039652586,
0.2877312899,
-0.2809448242,
-0.4586322606,
-0.0849798024,
-0.042458348,
0.1753026545,
0.8701887131,
-1.0896223783,
0.8039409518,
0.8054397702,
1.1135774851,
0.4004140794,
0.0592292286,
0.5263379216,
-1.2546108961,
-0.078038007,
0.1666571647,
0.3174391389,
0.3971517384,
-0.0182887521,
0.6206606627,
0.4624434412,
-0.4925989211,
-0.7030931711,
0.3859142065,
-0.8185053468,
-0.1641423851,
1.0690770149,
-0.3416480124,
-0.2855647206,
-0.0431067422,
-0.4102827609,
0.6831187606,
-0.2583893538,
0.0741825029,
0.8497388363,
-0.1206749305,
0.2041934878,
-0.6231556535,
0.7581769228,
0.2528623641,
-0.7238172293,
-0.0898021385,
0.6987646222,
0.13690871,
0.3362290561,
0.9783930779,
0.0184587501,
0.0166365206,
-0.1633354723,
0.1575537622,
-0.3825947642,
-0.6222636104,
0.3505888581,
0.5383096933,
0.2022850066,
0.1766662747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15594v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15594v1 | Flocks of Stochastic Parrots: Differentially Private Prompt Learning for Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T22:06:08 | 2023-05-24T22:06:08 | Haonan Duan, Adam Dziedzic, Nicolas Papernot, Franziska Boenisch | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Large language models (LLMs) are excellent in-context learners. However, the
sensitivity of data contained in prompts raises privacy concerns. Our work
first shows that these concerns are valid: we instantiate a simple but highly
effective membership inference attack against the data used to prompt LLMs. To
address this vulnerability, one could forego prompting and resort to
fine-tuning LLMs with known algorithms for private gradient descent. However,
this comes at the expense of the practicality and efficiency offered by
prompting. Therefore, we propose to privately learn to prompt. We first show
that soft prompts can be obtained privately through gradient descent on
downstream data. However, this is not the case for discrete prompts. Thus, we
orchestrate a noisy vote among an ensemble of LLMs presented with different
prompts, i.e., a flock of stochastic parrots. The vote privately transfers the
flock's knowledge into a single public prompt. We show that LLMs prompted with
our private algorithms closely match the non-private baselines. For example,
using GPT3 as the base model, we achieve a downstream accuracy of 92.7% on the
sst2 dataset with ($\epsilon=0.147, \delta=10^{-6}$)-differential privacy vs.
95.2% for the non-private baseline. Through our experiments, we also show that
our prompt-based approach is easily deployed with existing commercial APIs. | [
-0.0703173429,
-0.5332805514,
0.4858654737,
0.4133201838,
-0.1010805517,
0.0743996128,
-0.3996858299,
-0.2303574234,
-0.2329272181,
0.3237262368,
-0.7094812989,
-0.66704458,
-0.5617163777,
0.1486497372,
-0.1787835509,
0.9666121602,
0.4966481626,
-0.042324096,
0.0595618971,
-0.1484126449,
0.1494007558,
-0.6046783924,
-0.7837722898,
0.3320687711,
1.0087333918,
0.2536256015,
0.5297170281,
0.7535860538,
-0.0299548917,
0.3443020582,
-0.2072327286,
0.0545838326,
-0.7246334553,
0.3861032128,
-0.1676965207,
-0.4570012093,
-0.0225596279,
-0.0366836116,
0.7804656625,
0.7229864001,
-0.0825678408,
-0.0416689031,
0.3267474174,
0.820409894,
-0.500656426,
0.3817628622,
-0.6735349894,
0.2044209689,
-0.4684199095,
0.0271117873,
-0.5122354627,
-0.5480619073,
0.156826973,
-0.2799240649,
0.1757691652,
-0.0397689603,
0.362332046,
0.1478506774,
-0.551263392,
-0.0907867476,
-0.3056052029,
0.9261428714,
-0.545394659,
0.3289803565,
0.5811260343,
0.2500980198,
-0.4649425447,
-0.6787109375,
-0.2737267613,
-0.4862390757,
0.1708235294,
-0.0403089039,
-0.1361836642,
0.0335775428,
0.1870495081,
0.5858340263,
-0.4621807635,
0.5608164668,
-0.31191203,
-0.2405341715,
0.8217135072,
0.1282298863,
-0.0011716363,
0.2278339714,
-0.41415295,
-0.0867514312,
-0.7864285111,
0.5646244287,
0.7811920643,
0.6472298503,
-0.4638463259,
0.3108695447,
-0.206119895,
0.4580581486,
0.2896977663,
0.1442716569,
-0.0179769881,
-0.0089202058,
-0.1418297589,
-0.2107067704,
1.1605687141,
-0.0931382477,
0.2447333634,
-0.1987413168,
-0.1594996601,
-0.1867190301,
-0.2754014134,
-0.5476647019,
-0.212391302,
0.3766886294,
-0.2386702299,
-0.6227222681,
-0.0521949902,
-0.8181361556,
-0.8914785385,
-0.2210143507,
0.1289289445,
-0.0762614906,
-0.1811075509,
-0.1915358901,
0.0923298299,
0.1029163077,
0.5407836437,
-1.0473448038,
0.224626869,
0.8285844922,
0.8537795544,
-0.0540783554,
-0.3164122105,
-1.0940518379,
0.0514305718,
-0.4336846173,
0.348634392,
-0.6452140808,
-0.6670767665,
0.2093603313,
0.2440445423,
0.0235461947,
-0.2028054744,
0.0655696765,
-0.6226284504,
0.4448760748,
-0.3638181686,
-0.493549794,
-0.0164940171,
-0.0525353588,
-0.3663326204,
0.6324523091,
0.1034345776,
-0.6256693006,
0.0074401195,
-0.4536945522,
-0.4053038657,
0.0436615609,
-0.3936146796,
-0.2137143165,
0.1351224184,
0.1270518303,
0.6526231766,
0.1404108107,
0.1295236945,
-0.5951368809,
-0.2458487898,
0.3168332577,
-0.4813427627,
1.2340372801,
0.26681903,
-0.4597580135,
0.3596836627,
-0.6140662432,
-0.2014352381,
-0.182461217,
-0.3450800776,
-0.1719703823,
0.0208349675,
-0.5409122109,
-0.1296191961,
0.256213218,
-0.2418819368,
0.2687731981,
-0.4893992245,
0.5233219266,
1.4269294739,
0.022084292,
0.7607063055,
-0.2631616294,
0.5854073763,
0.0820743367,
0.3723946512,
-0.1222996712,
-0.8396596909,
-0.1152375042,
-0.5694413781,
0.2349351197,
0.2373457551,
-0.2257724702,
0.3939992785,
0.0239040796,
-0.5103009939,
-0.0920376256,
0.1354083568,
0.2906223536,
0.301903069,
-0.0876288563,
-0.0324551016,
0.0217041168,
-0.6029888391,
-0.3119901121,
-0.2832567692,
-0.2132974565,
0.5649390817,
0.0074885054,
-0.1218903884,
0.5575734377,
-0.0435646363,
-0.2157093734,
0.0203069597,
-0.0341300443,
0.170410037,
0.5524912477,
0.3171922565,
-0.6296881437,
-0.5087566376,
-0.0590566061,
-0.5425388217,
-0.0958258584,
0.1520329416,
0.0203930605,
0.2570485175,
0.4152181447,
-0.4453586042,
0.2895462811,
0.7935749888,
-0.2080427706,
0.4096508026,
-0.1099068299,
-0.1546499133,
-0.9625200033,
-0.2341297567,
-0.0220130775,
-0.3505130708,
-0.4279873073,
0.1790596992,
0.0070169098,
-0.2782277763,
-0.7491232753,
0.5497145057,
-0.5102555156,
-0.0211536214,
-0.0036157037,
-0.1316850334,
-0.3030423522,
0.6401006579,
0.0446916409,
0.9257004261,
0.909827292,
-0.9869306087,
0.2458066642,
0.1879926175,
-0.2020370662,
0.1890208125,
-0.5146951675,
0.5048622489,
-0.1715292484,
0.3185937405,
-1.0349551439,
-0.3584987223,
0.4739592373,
-0.4358876646,
0.3525332212,
-0.36427477,
-0.1873445213,
0.1245797724,
-0.5302230716,
0.1367736012,
0.5783227086,
-0.7810188532,
0.3980616331,
0.4344617724,
-0.3393163085,
-0.8022438288,
-0.6971889138,
0.0733066872,
-0.2759611607,
-0.519795239,
-0.1491625756,
-0.0405484922,
-0.3465504348,
-0.2369500846,
0.0754737779,
-0.1032469645,
0.2974306047,
0.4512343407,
-0.228172645,
-0.2892400026,
0.0945798829,
0.0810330883,
0.0351353288,
0.0784740523,
-0.5288532376,
0.3801626265,
-0.3163928688,
-0.2652275562,
-0.6571407914,
0.4540020525,
0.4696760774,
-0.3108443022,
0.7707605362,
0.2470467836,
-0.1400726438,
-0.5335150957,
-0.2717493773,
-0.4043442011,
-0.5995700359,
0.0157718416,
-0.1809546649,
-1.2324385643,
0.4933897853,
-0.0801616311,
0.2683109641,
-0.0340717845,
0.5256868005,
-0.0524498932,
1.0055617094,
0.6740151644,
-0.3679610491,
0.6187145114,
0.0094347885,
0.0212233122,
-0.4134996533,
-0.0691216439,
-0.7335758209,
-0.2576167881,
-0.8248146772,
-0.3704178929,
0.3127557337,
-0.0135431504,
-0.3129988909,
-0.055329483,
-0.3160476089,
0.6417145729,
0.7025382519,
0.2040092945,
0.2061438113,
0.1731757522,
0.0348868221,
0.0111512728,
-0.6190336943,
-0.5309940577,
0.8628826737,
0.4744036198,
0.9004601836,
0.3428388834,
0.8165886998,
0.26647681,
0.2511464059,
-0.6789258122,
0.5886278152,
-0.1356827766,
-0.3614477217,
-0.4839312434,
-0.5651649833,
-1.0582587719,
0.1001897231,
0.2063206583,
-0.9980152845,
0.6086987257,
0.0794414282,
-0.564648807,
0.2262216061,
-0.6551195979,
0.693931222,
0.0491639487,
-0.8201622963,
0.0930180475,
-0.9006453156,
0.4976525605,
-0.2117031813,
0.2871958315,
-0.0178018417,
-0.2327692956,
0.6743946075,
-0.6697748303,
1.4311108589,
-0.4273539186,
-0.3353989422,
0.1811775863,
0.226425603,
0.9770240188,
0.4186830223,
-0.3657218516,
0.3337533772,
-0.0929700956,
-0.4540745616,
-0.4736122787,
0.8558606505,
-0.8377341032,
-0.8981024623,
-0.529270947,
-0.294696629,
-0.4086561501,
-0.0607400797,
0.1925719827,
0.5370658636,
0.1646175981,
0.3655124307,
0.6388418078,
-0.3489101827,
0.498740375,
0.802898407,
-0.0820009783,
-0.1512291431,
0.7322506905,
-0.0489634946,
0.1741028726,
0.1452760994,
0.7384083271,
-0.915241003,
-0.6841549277,
-0.4439795017,
0.2034548819,
-0.5523051023,
0.0025267527,
-0.6653648019,
0.0152135221,
-0.5258067846,
-0.0726452619,
-0.1871112883,
-0.3177105486,
-0.5213890076,
-0.17866458,
0.5891494155,
0.7782711983,
-0.4315013289,
0.2671736181,
-0.9614995718,
-0.1467352659,
0.5489580035,
0.276756227,
-0.040193703,
-0.5068872571,
0.1981867701,
0.0994257778,
-0.0344478264,
-0.8517712951,
0.1930866838,
0.3668501973,
0.4019527435,
0.6713107228,
0.5998890996,
0.5867971182,
-0.5792722106,
1.2080928087,
-0.0556058101,
-1.0221856833,
0.4797494709,
-0.7572420835,
-0.1447541267,
0.705227375,
0.4304269254,
-0.3451694548,
-0.7774718404,
-0.636511445,
-0.6621014476,
0.7891513109,
-0.0830278546,
0.5388943553,
0.0385050401,
0.2771610618,
0.3795409799,
0.4702623487,
-0.7257189751,
-0.1920864433,
0.0675174296,
-0.2357880622,
-0.2719949186,
-0.1337538958,
-0.2043385506,
-0.0779856443,
0.4520703256,
-0.0783539042,
0.0172101986,
0.1476798654,
0.2687629461,
-0.1878558397,
0.1727802902,
0.5513314009,
0.5803871155,
0.169726491,
0.2666636407,
-0.0162786208,
-0.262549907,
0.3178270757,
-0.1659088433,
-0.0589130521,
-0.1040779948,
0.2133301795,
0.5932657719,
0.1694885343,
-0.3852380812,
0.9492712617,
-0.2359791845,
-0.2606801093,
-0.2654210925,
0.2006000429,
-0.0475876294,
0.3517432511,
0.115047574,
0.0559253693,
-0.0535992011,
-0.4105933905,
0.2163760066,
0.4175205827,
-0.5322058201,
-0.5293220878,
0.7676793933,
0.3289965987,
-0.4508534968,
0.4011925459,
-0.3019633889,
-0.329515785,
0.4130884409,
0.3085430861,
0.7673936486,
-0.6369029284,
0.3349568248,
-0.0575611554,
0.1455379128,
-0.194277361,
0.1689123958,
-0.5399373174,
-0.4009730518,
-0.2799650431,
-0.400236994,
-0.6177517176,
0.4981402457,
-0.5424732566,
0.0869402364,
-0.8973745704,
0.1475600451,
-0.3854391277,
0.0448063426,
-0.3456201851,
-0.1224175245,
0.0888532326,
0.7889598608,
-0.5209155679,
0.8112192154,
0.419503361,
-0.0732065961,
-0.9841810465,
0.1748990715,
0.1667181551,
-0.855432272,
0.7018271685,
0.2957466245,
-0.1742051095,
0.2729126513,
-0.6962111592,
-0.547588408,
0.5589387417,
0.4559916258,
-1.1215009689,
0.2063547224,
0.0293962006,
0.4133470654,
0.0588446856,
-0.1243750155,
-0.044559598,
0.3789937794,
-0.1639377922,
-0.6558664441,
0.0898578018,
0.0994726494,
-0.2134228647,
-0.258997947,
-0.9965128303,
1.0173422098,
-0.1516389698,
-0.5158402324,
0.0274295006,
0.7791283727,
0.2996170819,
0.503877461,
0.64152807,
-0.0661289319,
1.3390338421,
0.2199297249,
1.1193927526,
-0.2642702162,
0.0985661298,
0.9377005696,
-0.5692514181,
0.7500389218,
0.4763116539,
-0.30825001,
0.2922641039,
0.9064716697,
0.2249415368,
0.7582457662,
0.4550174773,
-0.7139133215,
-0.1208474264,
0.0608582646,
-0.6309672594,
-0.0105557963,
0.2088135034,
-0.3139657676,
-0.0132271452,
-0.0413977914,
-0.1056483388,
0.1432178915,
-0.3652658761,
0.8959578872,
0.4524139166,
-0.438833952,
0.4206409454,
-0.1914097816,
0.6171061397,
-0.6876030564,
0.417991966,
-0.3593578339,
0.1997814476,
-0.1567223072,
-0.3486923575,
0.0431843325,
0.1493667066,
0.0781937093,
-0.1466108263,
0.2632587254,
-0.3845553994,
-0.2840053737,
0.1970126331,
0.4816610515,
0.3569963574,
-0.1848148704,
-0.6299183965,
-0.0390352048,
-0.0709721074,
-0.4604528248,
0.5242855549,
0.6421672702,
-0.1603108943,
0.5924465656,
0.8445760608,
0.1846203357,
0.1873394996,
0.2856636345,
0.966355145,
-0.4737040699,
-1.0941243172,
-1.02526474,
0.3039659858,
0.0237075649,
-0.2111915052,
0.9715601802,
0.3057304323,
0.8179285526,
-0.13875404,
0.9665486217,
0.5365316272,
0.4769431055,
-0.6409888864,
0.9104648829,
-0.4677533805,
0.4738170803,
0.0626855195,
-0.5882551074,
-0.2858990431,
0.5322958827,
-0.5263114572,
-0.078744866,
0.4923417568,
1.2384397984,
0.0763806254,
0.4037175179,
0.259727627,
0.1512098908,
0.438231647,
0.4703997672,
1.5590718985,
-0.0923338756,
0.2099331021,
-0.3037148416,
-0.3127063811,
-0.066969648,
-1.0077505112,
-1.0937144756,
-0.4695755243,
-0.4748408496,
-0.359559536,
0.2818158269,
1.1194796562,
0.8697306514,
-0.950509727,
-0.2213985026,
-0.3512395322,
0.2029291093,
-0.2018797249,
-0.1881025136,
0.4046791494,
-0.4887936711,
-0.8795617223,
0.8096964359,
0.0919272676,
0.1838383377,
-0.3839079738,
-0.1969696581,
0.3316499591,
-0.0097160488,
0.2971215546,
0.4046474397,
-0.5873608589,
-0.2245667428,
-0.2416983545,
-0.21084629,
-0.0772513747,
0.7857140899,
-0.4654980004,
-0.0221686251,
0.4517988265,
0.7410960197,
0.1568039954,
0.1441315711,
0.63177526,
-1.0846666098,
0.4280052483,
0.3554995358,
0.0958222821,
0.2964524031,
-0.7590281367,
0.1710190922,
0.300875932,
-0.6751639843,
-1.0574481487,
0.2477727234,
-0.8935911655,
-0.1856903583,
1.2305831909,
-0.4839961827,
-0.6932529211,
-0.2781343162,
-0.1779675633,
-0.0578660443,
-0.8368885517,
0.7414454818,
0.2977706492,
0.1691292524,
-0.2070971578,
-0.1541710347,
0.8233927488,
0.158085838,
-0.4407454133,
0.4666071534,
0.4334793687,
0.2408905476,
-0.2748880088,
0.8079102635,
-0.2062718868,
0.0608039945,
-0.1826108992,
-0.6091951132,
-0.5075734258,
-0.2256238014,
-0.9942375422,
0.4520611167,
0.0461852662,
-0.4218813777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15587v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15587v1 | How do humans perceive adversarial text? A reality check on the validity and naturalness of word-based adversarial attacks | 2023-05-24T21:52:13 | 2023-05-24T21:52:13 | Salijona Dyrmishi, Salah Ghamizi, Maxime Cordy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural Language Processing (NLP) models based on Machine Learning (ML) are
susceptible to adversarial attacks -- malicious algorithms that imperceptibly
modify input text to force models into making incorrect predictions. However,
evaluations of these attacks ignore the property of imperceptibility or study
it under limited settings. This entails that adversarial perturbations would
not pass any human quality gate and do not represent real threats to
human-checked NLP systems. To bypass this limitation and enable proper
assessment (and later, improvement) of NLP model robustness, we have surveyed
378 human participants about the perceptibility of text adversarial examples
produced by state-of-the-art methods. Our results underline that existing text
attacks are impractical in real-world scenarios where humans are involved. This
contrasts with previous smaller-scale human studies, which reported overly
optimistic conclusions regarding attack success. Through our work, we hope to
position human perceptibility as a first-class success criterion for text
attacks, and provide guidance for research to build effective attack algorithms
and, in turn, design appropriate defence mechanisms. | [
-0.3512913287,
-1.1666252613,
0.2689044476,
-0.0489920303,
-0.1161362678,
-0.016892422,
-0.0332194231,
-0.6178148985,
-0.0737712383,
0.4981342852,
-0.4997909367,
-0.218720302,
-0.7184780836,
0.2867083848,
-0.4930057824,
1.016135335,
0.2316333503,
-0.0941851139,
-0.1126357242,
-0.0775796324,
-0.2446427345,
-0.9479932785,
-0.6111178994,
-0.2838110328,
0.4205940962,
-0.0978395939,
1.2173215151,
0.3916377723,
0.7452192307,
0.294084698,
-0.2578705251,
0.0097735981,
-0.4578975737,
-0.0193534102,
-0.243067503,
-0.531385839,
-0.3815973401,
0.2556598186,
0.2259886414,
0.6549262404,
0.1150828004,
-0.066278033,
0.372782141,
0.6483650208,
-0.5799580812,
-0.5414447784,
-0.9334994555,
0.4521184564,
-0.1072139144,
-0.0754741132,
-0.5803672671,
-0.1614529341,
0.3568910658,
-0.5016174316,
0.4243389666,
0.0694947615,
0.9496796727,
0.3554320335,
-0.3956359625,
-0.4016310871,
-0.7023125887,
0.4739361107,
-0.5747826695,
-0.0109732915,
0.5935146213,
0.1687066108,
-0.5506364107,
-0.5545556545,
-0.6042601466,
-0.6465831399,
0.0367121622,
0.1363713592,
-0.5411842465,
0.2058327794,
0.3195320368,
0.1801016182,
-0.833162725,
-0.0523073785,
0.0118530383,
-0.3210737705,
0.5227832794,
-0.0486752018,
0.7545408607,
0.1129121333,
-0.570507586,
-0.1745371819,
-0.5469409227,
-0.0413556397,
0.7053622603,
0.1288867444,
0.0975374058,
0.5955195427,
0.0819654092,
0.7162513733,
-0.1132653952,
0.264971137,
-0.3455733061,
-0.3777296245,
-0.4337414503,
-0.0161784571,
0.8980515003,
0.3525983393,
0.3027691543,
-0.6352903247,
-0.1147759408,
0.5438707471,
1.0213124752,
-0.4958782494,
-0.3721446693,
-0.0585262664,
-0.3677422404,
-0.8103619218,
0.1784273088,
-0.7236320376,
-0.8929365277,
0.2892870903,
0.6422985196,
-0.4386233091,
-0.056451004,
0.0696936697,
-0.2150686681,
-0.1171514913,
0.1088589504,
-0.63708812,
0.5527979136,
0.4316862524,
0.5522298813,
-0.1072718799,
-0.506523788,
-0.2347258329,
-0.460229665,
-0.3875537217,
0.6410956383,
-0.0954945087,
-0.4526221752,
-0.1392877996,
-0.2263341546,
-0.0664915815,
-0.5043094754,
1.0876883268,
-0.5759345889,
0.2626445889,
-0.0924229398,
-0.361541599,
-0.3365913332,
0.6140159369,
-0.6737783551,
0.383639425,
-0.1585545689,
-1.0476347208,
0.2795152068,
-0.6106623411,
-0.6411488056,
-0.1603474468,
0.1229966581,
-0.3199868798,
0.0550991371,
0.2074414194,
0.1343011707,
-0.0753479898,
-0.0265322402,
-0.4207921326,
-0.254490912,
0.900208652,
-1.2851490974,
0.8712259531,
0.2818794847,
-0.5228222609,
0.0811447427,
-0.6853129864,
0.0709231943,
0.4337326586,
-0.1906189471,
-0.2825402319,
0.1960859448,
0.0167263411,
0.2368332148,
0.0807522982,
-0.5005148053,
0.172191456,
-0.9496531487,
0.3917714655,
0.5825271606,
0.0149272606,
0.3081316054,
-0.4154949784,
0.4758427739,
-0.1308195293,
0.3593282104,
0.0684191287,
-0.5021260977,
-0.456800431,
0.209109664,
0.245479241,
0.7044836879,
-0.7598705888,
0.4282316566,
0.0471129045,
-0.6049910188,
-0.3671484888,
0.0936233029,
0.5639910102,
0.5771833062,
0.2555879951,
-0.1204676405,
-0.5309912562,
-0.8405660391,
-0.7114825249,
-0.3575095832,
-0.1895209104,
-0.0126435384,
0.7436413169,
-0.211567387,
0.7877990603,
-0.4025031626,
-0.0255892128,
-0.1060349941,
0.2496747226,
-0.2076839358,
0.2854826152,
0.386908561,
-1.091961503,
-0.19445391,
-0.3255978823,
-0.9271910787,
0.2924776971,
-0.1247260794,
0.0088583399,
0.1381218135,
0.142303437,
-0.3101385534,
0.6733633876,
0.6481318474,
-0.6873073578,
0.531283319,
-0.3169273138,
0.1643827707,
-0.6108148098,
0.1237323806,
0.0635362864,
-0.1992220283,
-0.8893686533,
0.2496126145,
-0.0289951358,
-0.2997531593,
-0.3488130271,
0.4673327506,
0.050359834,
0.1204896644,
-0.4666846097,
0.0872919038,
0.2712108493,
0.289147228,
-0.3399282992,
0.7243618965,
0.3265123963,
-0.4831998348,
0.3465359807,
0.0383293331,
-0.2859955728,
0.7966579795,
-0.7296158671,
0.1896322519,
-0.0294932108,
0.2991069257,
-0.7999258637,
-0.2278534621,
0.6062628627,
-1.0016967058,
0.258836478,
0.1985544711,
-0.3441797793,
-0.1497091204,
-0.3845103383,
-0.0649101809,
0.2295822054,
-0.5469846725,
0.3346039951,
0.4235839844,
0.1514224112,
-0.619384408,
-0.8172685504,
0.8093568087,
-0.1240852103,
-0.6222892404,
0.1448651552,
0.017558217,
-0.4941593707,
-0.1008561701,
-0.1042583212,
-0.3426826298,
0.8224484324,
0.3377198875,
0.2335166633,
0.1810683012,
-0.191150263,
-0.6403918266,
0.1461063772,
0.3116101921,
-0.0792559236,
0.2859271467,
-0.0998134688,
-0.3941955566,
-0.6117014885,
0.1221191883,
0.5555379987,
-0.1529018283,
0.7680106163,
0.496963948,
-0.7147813439,
-0.0873761401,
-0.1569503099,
-0.2222963572,
-0.4427803457,
0.5867924094,
-0.1946440786,
-0.4356292486,
0.2021329552,
0.2500881255,
-0.1030084118,
0.5529322624,
0.1807181984,
-0.1926845163,
1.3038133383,
0.3605360985,
-0.1112757176,
0.0641545132,
-0.0802555531,
0.035652332,
-0.5432602763,
0.0371118002,
-0.6332648993,
-0.1341496706,
-0.5159313083,
0.1183103323,
0.0920649841,
0.0780829489,
-0.1554288566,
0.247657299,
-0.6078368425,
0.112438716,
0.448417604,
0.2347030938,
0.0438785404,
-0.0420818478,
-0.0874013603,
-0.2083568573,
-0.7636547685,
-0.7700780034,
1.1055796146,
0.4744808078,
0.4684453905,
0.0743087903,
0.1931537539,
0.7267203927,
0.3723171353,
-0.621724844,
0.4534594417,
-0.2496965826,
-0.8667199612,
-0.2164762169,
-0.4854385555,
-1.0590965748,
0.2561593354,
-0.6801633239,
-0.7218710184,
-0.3177350461,
0.1805415303,
-0.2235563397,
0.6561979651,
-0.6586099863,
0.8706671596,
-0.4690230489,
-0.1087739468,
0.0629967004,
-0.7020972967,
0.247949481,
-0.0784076005,
0.2706998885,
0.3835031092,
0.0073870127,
0.7295954823,
-0.2258460671,
0.8608807921,
-0.0857748166,
-0.0916743204,
0.1943349987,
0.15861018,
0.5973566771,
-0.2069633901,
-0.0213670619,
0.1007291973,
-0.4181825817,
-0.4490459561,
-0.6261677146,
0.4777880907,
-0.7063808441,
-0.3375565708,
-0.6384813786,
-0.2500639856,
-0.2098164409,
0.2331106514,
0.6072157621,
0.5628592372,
-0.7351585627,
0.0706096366,
0.6816419363,
-0.3330497444,
0.117799446,
0.2343736142,
0.0663545877,
-0.5254960656,
1.045358181,
0.0520555787,
0.2821876705,
0.4044060409,
0.2821464539,
-0.3556752503,
-0.793759048,
-0.6158986092,
-0.2765974998,
-0.5341885686,
0.1784581989,
-0.4017002583,
-0.1096667647,
-0.4095572829,
-0.1626689136,
-0.3267824352,
-0.0086742425,
-0.264008075,
0.1080177501,
-0.1298101246,
0.8400499821,
0.3973044157,
0.3391228914,
-0.5937744975,
0.4676768184,
0.5091715455,
0.1318040192,
-0.1402039528,
-0.549480319,
-0.1470903307,
0.4072774649,
-0.5059687495,
-0.8501212001,
0.2850194275,
-0.0222723056,
0.2979743183,
0.4364143908,
0.3441642225,
0.134415552,
-0.3150146306,
0.9199698567,
0.1028036326,
-0.668432653,
0.442281574,
-0.2463274151,
0.2472420335,
0.5634510517,
0.2282448113,
-0.3988160789,
-0.4183599353,
-0.9077923894,
-0.5048642755,
0.4449017048,
0.5967604518,
0.0568555072,
0.2305584252,
0.2776445448,
-0.0740968287,
0.0391427241,
-0.704970181,
-0.434976846,
-0.5213785172,
-0.0753653124,
-0.0990694314,
-0.1165698767,
-0.244176954,
0.2184893191,
0.4339791536,
0.0505458266,
0.1143517494,
0.3713105321,
-0.0959861949,
-0.0180161912,
0.3656436503,
0.6570099592,
0.4893699884,
-0.3116092682,
0.3779254854,
0.3382889926,
-0.9393870831,
0.2839257121,
0.1082192436,
-0.4719021916,
-0.2221945226,
0.6643185019,
0.6718413234,
0.1228524968,
-0.7084794044,
0.6038439274,
-0.6684663892,
-0.2483840138,
-0.2449979037,
0.0114354324,
-0.3277996778,
0.0026374788,
0.3847033978,
0.7156722546,
0.1439573318,
-0.5865381956,
0.1276853234,
0.6927903295,
-0.690272212,
-0.4395909011,
0.8668286204,
0.0938810408,
-0.497292012,
0.228288278,
-0.2476225644,
-0.9427993894,
0.6226647496,
0.5329986215,
0.9451060891,
0.0980842113,
0.120502457,
0.0676231533,
0.8119754195,
-0.1201643273,
-0.0868689194,
0.2689847946,
-0.7432168722,
-0.0499692783,
-0.4648915231,
-0.6239001155,
0.2928778231,
-0.5067783594,
-0.0811263993,
-0.7190256715,
-0.3450888991,
0.0655727908,
0.2056439519,
-0.3861584365,
0.7163901329,
0.3342914879,
0.9203204513,
-0.603553772,
0.5601180196,
0.9218770266,
-0.0996582285,
-0.2558476925,
0.398026377,
0.1844388098,
-0.4107213616,
0.3087392449,
0.1281850189,
-0.2817577422,
-0.2582562864,
-0.5919661522,
-0.3557264805,
0.4583847821,
0.2999114096,
-0.0790494382,
-0.0070256251,
0.1020276323,
0.663357079,
0.12778005,
0.0336955003,
0.2603009343,
0.434491992,
-0.3323273957,
-0.5367234349,
0.0149926357,
-0.2827374339,
-0.181641072,
-0.0173957925,
-0.3384585083,
0.545656085,
0.05640563,
-0.3520170748,
0.010636271,
0.5858911276,
-0.1099479273,
0.4234108329,
0.6746113896,
0.6726797223,
0.6165548563,
-0.0606268346,
1.3958092928,
-0.1834000349,
0.0613156296,
0.8084525466,
-0.0149779264,
0.7624649405,
0.0846341476,
-0.3909528255,
0.035100352,
0.2629655004,
0.00591153,
0.2477436662,
0.3057861328,
-0.1908568442,
-0.007389613,
0.0375770181,
-0.0866692066,
0.5716415048,
0.2443245798,
-0.1609927118,
-0.0264898278,
0.2302289009,
0.3158221841,
0.6545311213,
-0.1702712625,
0.7140456438,
-0.1847629249,
-0.6028137207,
0.5647069216,
0.1963909119,
1.1211684942,
-0.6436525583,
0.2609793842,
0.2228015065,
0.2460338473,
-0.1898133904,
-0.7041480541,
0.4328316152,
0.3588420451,
-0.2191446126,
0.0996517465,
0.954364717,
0.1366388351,
-0.3810828924,
0.1329626143,
0.0327625573,
0.0260269418,
-0.5230893493,
-0.819241643,
-0.1255425662,
0.0100548295,
-0.2631177902,
0.5893809795,
0.0936511084,
0.2889801562,
0.8027151227,
0.6628964543,
0.4496306181,
-0.1859062761,
-0.2995130122,
0.5643737912,
-0.5582585931,
-0.2233438045,
-1.2309644222,
0.1246791109,
-0.2240289152,
-0.513931334,
0.9410230517,
0.2976275384,
0.6591373086,
0.3615393341,
0.9451273084,
0.180009678,
0.4987961352,
-0.2751973867,
1.1495811939,
-0.3804199994,
0.1301752925,
-0.3916169703,
-0.4131633043,
-0.4776703417,
0.4165747166,
-0.2100538015,
-0.2558666766,
0.4770134985,
0.5474820733,
0.2687437832,
0.2314487249,
0.4421364069,
0.2189024985,
0.3724714816,
0.3661719859,
0.9505381584,
-0.5694567561,
0.8652426004,
-0.3328075707,
-0.3777822852,
-0.1707024425,
-0.8179647326,
-0.8762198687,
-0.2026616782,
-0.142571941,
-0.5564669967,
0.2945216298,
0.6273548603,
0.2190945596,
-0.5784145594,
0.1802410334,
-0.2502872944,
0.1765792519,
-0.1672210097,
-0.219875291,
0.4230179787,
-0.1247302368,
-0.4223780334,
0.410598129,
0.1363118589,
0.219139576,
-0.4407731295,
0.0349989794,
-0.0788500905,
0.2074102759,
0.413947165,
0.4299380779,
-0.6355294585,
-0.2140419781,
0.0488349162,
-0.5241358876,
-0.2256372124,
0.2778599262,
-0.7285251021,
0.7068368793,
0.3551214933,
0.7663164139,
-0.3898414969,
0.0966857746,
0.5568220615,
-0.553027451,
0.1166650951,
0.4348628521,
0.1425959766,
0.4775815308,
-0.4391658306,
0.2945514619,
0.3081548214,
-0.5785784125,
-0.9097352624,
0.2453809381,
-0.4899578989,
-0.5624064207,
0.7059093714,
-0.3203504086,
-0.32860443,
-0.3103378415,
-0.467227757,
0.2217617631,
-0.0218614899,
0.9887401462,
0.730971694,
0.2100774646,
0.5070741773,
-0.6480858922,
0.5890261531,
0.2832982838,
-0.678237021,
-0.0296684429,
0.0593326725,
-0.1726188064,
0.1561286449,
0.1775324196,
0.1538787633,
0.3177847266,
0.3576900959,
-0.1578493267,
-0.1353076845,
-0.2715258598,
-0.5366583467,
0.3462671936,
0.1381566226,
-0.1795040369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15582v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15582v1 | Balancing Effect of Training Dataset Distribution of Multiple Styles for Multi-Style Text Transfer | 2023-05-24T21:36:15 | 2023-05-24T21:36:15 | Debarati Das, David Ma, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text style transfer is an exciting task within the field of natural language
generation that is often plagued by the need for high-quality paired datasets.
Furthermore, training a model for multi-attribute text style transfer requires
datasets with sufficient support across all combinations of the considered
stylistic attributes, adding to the challenges of training a style transfer
model. This paper explores the impact of training data input diversity on the
quality of the generated text from the multi-style transfer model. We construct
a pseudo-parallel dataset by devising heuristics to adjust the style
distribution in the training samples. We balance our training dataset using
marginal and joint distributions to train our style transfer models. We observe
that a balanced dataset produces more effective control effects over multiple
styles than an imbalanced or skewed one. Through quantitative analysis, we
explore the impact of multiple style distributions in training data on
style-transferred output. These findings will better inform the design of
style-transfer datasets. | [
-0.3907976449,
-0.306681782,
0.0995233133,
0.6163676977,
-0.3444321454,
0.1090121493,
-0.3598511815,
-0.5009317398,
0.2552261949,
0.3525816798,
-0.5185292959,
-0.2131782025,
-0.8205177784,
0.1962967962,
-0.4228948951,
1.3452841043,
-0.316318661,
0.1536983848,
-0.1439357102,
-0.5855998993,
-0.8282868862,
-0.6178671718,
-0.3801967502,
-0.3956751227,
0.3768624365,
0.4425032139,
0.69187814,
0.3533513844,
0.6524794102,
0.3015360832,
0.298140347,
-0.0926639065,
-0.7604029179,
-0.0276763532,
-0.1886131912,
-0.4481914043,
-0.2917259037,
0.035186436,
0.9164914489,
0.6254730225,
-0.0574276,
-0.0289652552,
0.2038781792,
0.8331587911,
-0.4885707498,
-0.2974945307,
-0.2362750024,
-0.0185436904,
-0.5647196174,
-0.1714153886,
-0.2673478425,
-0.3910811543,
0.1564331949,
-0.4985859096,
0.2565581203,
0.110516414,
0.7901043892,
-0.0485094823,
-0.519778192,
-0.2284715921,
-0.9426677823,
0.8538838029,
-0.4973757267,
0.2498262227,
0.0863402635,
0.3695670962,
0.3706518412,
-0.4665986598,
-0.776019454,
0.3001767695,
-0.2796850502,
0.2284571379,
0.0484678969,
-0.3372737169,
-0.0057660779,
0.4386997819,
-0.4675697684,
0.0176109988,
-0.4379887581,
-0.001735684,
0.7824822664,
0.2083750218,
0.5539289713,
-0.0277563389,
-0.3165719211,
-0.6069867015,
-0.2854825556,
0.218191579,
0.7990971804,
0.4062835276,
-0.3011208773,
0.4559926987,
-0.2812196612,
0.5415357947,
-0.1244265884,
-0.3956124485,
0.3722651303,
-1.1082013845,
0.0416686907,
0.0736877918,
0.8586784005,
0.5614947677,
0.3831444085,
-0.0421369523,
-0.2796799839,
-0.1996907592,
0.4276640713,
-0.7965947986,
-0.4085102677,
-0.2214719206,
-0.546158731,
-0.463483274,
0.1865257472,
-0.9995610118,
-0.2434251755,
-0.6695013642,
0.3846670985,
-0.3390011191,
-0.2609268427,
0.2450403571,
-0.4643388689,
0.0166015606,
0.2386969477,
-1.1188572645,
0.2461923361,
0.0233762506,
0.7673359513,
-0.4647714794,
-0.2311811298,
-0.0583958551,
0.1565093696,
-0.195445776,
0.6688127518,
-0.4421724379,
-0.2446660846,
-0.1030350775,
-0.2171650976,
-0.2118232101,
-0.3098520339,
0.5052389503,
-0.1053756326,
0.2153820395,
-0.496897459,
-0.2750663161,
0.3286162913,
-0.1682820171,
-0.76600945,
0.8394374847,
0.1967690289,
-0.926676631,
0.5776681304,
-0.2533675432,
-0.910289526,
-0.0903385058,
-0.0353404544,
-0.7696564198,
-0.0858295634,
0.2079491913,
0.1709887087,
-0.1907102317,
0.0519896336,
-0.7273988128,
-0.3000667691,
0.4486885071,
-0.4087636471,
0.856050849,
0.1324369162,
-0.2608691454,
-0.0762207508,
-0.8121995926,
-0.034121871,
0.0668348446,
-0.1812637448,
-0.4687162042,
-0.3580595255,
0.3862254322,
0.3406326473,
-0.0592677258,
-0.3383061886,
0.2478026599,
0.1081224307,
0.1245627105,
0.697900176,
-0.0465689227,
0.8870381117,
-0.7833315134,
0.4125876129,
-0.2310898453,
0.0878506601,
0.251414299,
-0.2828300893,
-0.5803617239,
-0.4312614202,
0.1813534051,
0.6114090681,
-0.7514294386,
0.2317708284,
-0.0135003515,
-0.411388725,
-0.6090639234,
0.2486296892,
0.2048891783,
0.3218549192,
0.4078924954,
-0.3399703801,
-0.3866243362,
-0.9448565841,
-0.3909717202,
0.2270455658,
0.107011728,
0.0046664709,
0.2802616656,
0.1295159906,
0.9756136537,
-0.4176300764,
-0.3680742979,
-0.3921313584,
0.5680004358,
-0.066642575,
0.8278931975,
1.172016263,
-0.5935383439,
-0.5633134842,
-0.2491643876,
-0.5692695975,
-0.4264049232,
-0.5260208845,
-0.6067889929,
-0.0298495814,
0.2610943317,
-0.2511000633,
0.2523652315,
0.6421050429,
-0.0777387694,
0.73580724,
0.0659096763,
0.3682615161,
-1.3317571878,
0.0974827781,
0.2080400437,
0.028714342,
-0.6537773609,
-0.2962285876,
0.0116816359,
0.078021206,
-0.1880749762,
0.4980941117,
-0.3957070112,
-0.1574080735,
-0.2242985964,
-0.1827343255,
0.3888433278,
0.3889641166,
-0.1536083966,
0.797326088,
0.4457076788,
-0.2958006561,
0.4449986815,
0.2770273685,
-0.1255996227,
1.262082696,
-0.5455759764,
0.071326755,
-0.1429809034,
0.1994268149,
-1.2520544529,
-0.0023928585,
0.1242543608,
-0.0964597985,
0.4827971756,
-0.0300528221,
-0.6550898552,
-0.2731011808,
-0.4351637661,
0.3416738808,
0.3011781275,
-0.5190089941,
0.1884034574,
0.0468507372,
-0.4037452042,
-0.4607978463,
-0.634575665,
-0.1184113324,
-0.4100252986,
-0.6660721898,
0.5154981017,
-0.3862168193,
-0.1495733559,
0.0285975076,
-0.1357575506,
-0.1440371275,
0.0318624564,
-0.1921637356,
0.3907188773,
-0.1310032904,
-0.0426658392,
0.3203243315,
0.3955576718,
-0.0167749412,
-0.2390625328,
0.4866250455,
-0.0279538743,
-0.3170860112,
-0.6506853104,
0.4665316939,
0.5623628497,
-0.1984433234,
1.1333487034,
0.7301085591,
0.0619113371,
-0.3726429939,
-0.1391573399,
-0.1912967116,
-0.4696484506,
0.1613055915,
-0.2871879041,
-0.4247210324,
0.4368970692,
0.390191257,
0.2607086003,
0.4803721905,
0.4115451276,
-0.4952672124,
0.9075030684,
0.6595309377,
-0.143268764,
0.9870100021,
-0.0536104105,
0.0053369971,
-0.387561202,
-0.1315488219,
-0.6530433297,
-0.9249415994,
-0.7575703859,
-0.0444925986,
0.1272605956,
0.23263596,
0.0931605771,
0.2586030066,
-0.2746224999,
0.3455958962,
0.7606967092,
0.2568610609,
0.219928354,
0.4199172556,
0.1167783365,
-0.0369448178,
-0.5301745534,
-0.241877377,
1.2232037783,
0.0025090887,
1.0373673439,
0.3022195399,
0.6861593127,
0.2770189643,
0.1747809201,
-0.4487642646,
0.0635485202,
-0.6706015468,
-0.0902660787,
-0.374358505,
-0.7032014132,
-0.6330904961,
0.0511886664,
-0.6806916595,
-0.2312814593,
0.3890767097,
0.316734463,
0.0449621305,
0.1927416325,
-0.7838134766,
0.8117960691,
-0.2496508807,
-0.5352248549,
-0.0575992763,
-0.5967902541,
0.447543323,
-0.2304565609,
0.0121221216,
0.1666737795,
0.5245438218,
0.8369219303,
-0.2964116931,
0.6578271389,
0.3521432579,
0.0082696211,
0.2238562703,
-0.1947068572,
0.4637825787,
-0.0983133242,
0.0571826175,
0.1793563962,
-0.1352808326,
-0.6242425442,
-0.5997130275,
0.4930610359,
-1.1787778139,
-0.1019288525,
-0.144934535,
-0.7693783641,
-0.3575301468,
0.2325965166,
0.6287989616,
0.7046830654,
0.0281308722,
0.2949543595,
0.4295325577,
-0.0869529545,
0.4902795851,
0.0598074757,
0.0848322511,
-0.6082286835,
1.046156764,
0.48699826,
0.8654294014,
0.0216299854,
0.2622786462,
-0.2989754379,
-0.4233107865,
-0.7798482776,
0.0881889611,
-0.6409710646,
0.006064801,
-0.4981529415,
-0.2804905176,
-0.5494022369,
-0.3580356538,
-0.1862255037,
-0.4357564151,
-0.4472901225,
0.1477441341,
0.490676254,
0.7302049398,
0.2485722899,
0.8059703708,
-0.6751010418,
0.3805138171,
0.5179428458,
0.54078269,
-0.2706970572,
-0.5799421668,
-0.1492025703,
-0.0339856967,
-0.3031742275,
-1.1287289858,
0.3638576269,
0.1433521211,
0.5610134602,
0.1288484037,
0.0279250015,
0.5331934094,
-0.3020298481,
0.2941681445,
0.5036467314,
-0.6536266208,
-0.0490379594,
-0.4014650285,
0.3555324376,
0.8474754095,
0.2406787276,
-0.6878011823,
-0.5951519608,
-0.5332251787,
-0.6614635587,
0.9990080595,
0.6368100643,
0.1118789911,
0.4926775396,
0.1153420731,
0.3657377064,
0.4479454756,
-0.5767202377,
-0.2409837991,
-0.743471384,
-0.4589907527,
-0.0051741032,
0.0259476695,
-0.1773102134,
-0.1912959069,
0.3503249288,
-0.051164031,
0.1706356406,
-0.2617408037,
-0.1903756112,
-0.0337161869,
0.3712310791,
0.728192687,
0.3726727664,
-0.1523753107,
0.235386923,
-0.0865653679,
-0.4585204124,
0.0615113229,
0.1286575496,
-0.2268423736,
0.0915464163,
0.3484420478,
1.1650286913,
-0.2496932894,
-0.0163592491,
0.4263058901,
-0.0783251897,
-0.1848205924,
0.345209837,
0.1489521563,
-0.0097793806,
-0.0102596181,
0.1636967808,
0.5260070562,
0.1079937965,
-0.5648550391,
0.3637228012,
0.3718169332,
0.2162724435,
-0.3184917271,
0.29769665,
0.2968003154,
-0.1335936487,
0.6695955396,
-0.01754421,
-0.37837556,
0.7913944125,
0.7733043432,
0.6102313399,
0.0148792723,
0.1953930259,
0.4063221216,
0.4434062839,
-0.3837572038,
0.0219218433,
0.146348089,
-0.7158746123,
-0.2872205377,
-0.7252127528,
-0.4671773016,
0.0116618201,
-0.6904338598,
0.5881785154,
-0.3241384625,
-0.1464508623,
-0.0720976889,
-0.4373281896,
-0.7814117074,
0.0311082434,
0.1950257719,
0.2893306911,
-1.5497339964,
0.5660310984,
0.6771723032,
-0.4789475203,
-0.7555760145,
0.1957609951,
0.0210508257,
-0.5291125178,
0.4887973964,
0.182491675,
-0.1036588922,
-0.0554890782,
-0.3688335717,
-1.0476852655,
0.6646025777,
0.382188648,
-0.6227840185,
0.1919725239,
0.3025745153,
0.7325316072,
-0.1342116743,
0.1212055311,
0.5573593378,
0.3203811347,
0.2490769178,
-1.0353431702,
-0.2636307478,
-0.309050262,
0.051059112,
0.2909174263,
-0.5711954832,
0.9352250695,
0.1457867175,
-0.1569179744,
-0.1502227038,
0.683981657,
0.2818557918,
0.1473516375,
0.4170822501,
0.5403556228,
0.5561144948,
0.0357338041,
1.0513515472,
-0.0773048997,
0.2354614884,
1.129224062,
-0.1578727216,
0.5030408502,
0.3705289662,
-0.1588512361,
0.3929978907,
0.2889577746,
-0.0223200992,
0.5980706215,
0.1410786211,
-0.1243336499,
0.1423839629,
-0.1370304823,
-0.393807143,
0.3126146495,
-0.086406514,
-0.1713622957,
-0.1188926548,
0.3556663692,
0.0173236895,
0.1662026495,
-0.023029374,
0.6733167171,
-0.1930492222,
-0.6048933864,
0.4045131505,
-0.1123908535,
0.8361961246,
-0.4586000144,
-0.0127359442,
-0.581979692,
0.0730129406,
-0.2508161664,
-1.1038742065,
0.3419132829,
-0.1818172634,
-0.4110075533,
-0.7870980501,
0.6357042789,
-0.7847671509,
-0.6307448149,
0.0935711116,
0.2249139249,
-0.1032911167,
0.143158704,
-0.6719420552,
-0.0120143192,
-0.1685605943,
-0.0460155345,
0.6325244904,
0.5478928089,
-0.3093562126,
0.1399758756,
0.7273780107,
0.1887524128,
0.3280572891,
0.3703541756,
0.7738024592,
-0.1900653243,
-0.5919395685,
-0.7848678231,
0.328001678,
-0.2842505276,
-0.4927848279,
0.6627032161,
0.2349698842,
0.7709020972,
0.047160197,
0.8393924236,
-0.0354319438,
0.1186857894,
-0.4936564863,
0.8279880285,
-0.5814195275,
0.038746316,
-0.5560379028,
-0.8900187016,
-0.1782429069,
0.4428828657,
-0.0302419923,
0.2468070835,
0.6237825155,
0.4663308263,
-0.0682081431,
0.0731729791,
-0.0676946715,
-0.1980011314,
0.2479021847,
0.2550013065,
0.5902056694,
-0.0991473272,
0.5777862668,
-0.7243925333,
-0.1754897982,
-0.2935733497,
-0.8394478559,
-0.7823334932,
-0.3977547884,
-0.1004496738,
-0.3858136237,
-0.0027735985,
0.6628902555,
0.6264888644,
-0.7074822783,
-0.4399318993,
-0.0320223793,
-0.0377510525,
-0.4746663272,
-0.2608349025,
0.2312365919,
-0.372445941,
-0.7731457353,
0.0270431805,
0.103570804,
0.315677911,
0.0443836264,
0.1363620609,
-0.2125724703,
-0.0938089937,
0.6668026447,
0.0780917406,
-0.1589027196,
-0.1987148821,
0.1245474443,
-0.6113523841,
0.1691087782,
0.8492131829,
-0.3079108894,
0.5313779116,
0.8431892991,
0.7767671347,
0.2638890445,
0.0510641709,
0.7529469132,
-1.2623198032,
0.0562830828,
-0.2130708396,
0.2839972079,
0.3532366157,
-0.3963406086,
0.213614881,
0.7193946242,
-0.2380134165,
-0.5698825717,
-0.053348612,
-0.9657069445,
-0.2656317055,
1.1229423285,
0.29069525,
0.0357851312,
0.0598850325,
-0.3988033831,
0.4718201756,
-0.4372430444,
0.5565460324,
0.9342362285,
-0.2124129236,
-0.24633421,
-0.4345534444,
0.467697978,
0.7082327604,
-1.162967205,
-0.0164654497,
0.4761020839,
0.3520318866,
-0.0573253371,
0.472653389,
0.1653842181,
0.2034904063,
-0.2331677824,
0.3482735455,
0.2399227917,
-0.5299972296,
-0.2514346838,
0.188397184,
-0.1341428757,
-0.1491073519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15542v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15542v2 | TOAST: Transfer Learning via Attention Steering | 2023-05-24T20:03:04 | 2023-07-11T17:57:06 | Baifeng Shi, Siyu Gai, Trevor Darrell, Xin Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Transfer learning involves adapting a pre-trained model to novel downstream
tasks. However, we observe that current transfer learning methods often fail to
focus on task-relevant features. In this work, we explore refocusing model
attention for transfer learning. We introduce Top-Down Attention Steering
(TOAST), a novel transfer learning algorithm that keeps the pre-trained
backbone frozen, selects task-relevant features in the output, and feeds those
features back to the model to steer the attention to the task-specific
features. By refocusing the attention only, TOAST achieves state-of-the-art
results on a number of transfer learning benchmarks, while having a small
number of tunable parameters. Compared to fully fine-tuning, LoRA, and prompt
tuning, TOAST substantially improves performance across a range of fine-grained
visual classification datasets (e.g., 81.1% -> 86.2% on FGVC). TOAST also
outperforms the fully fine-tuned Alpaca and Vicuna models on
instruction-following language generation. Code is available at
https://github.com/bfshi/TOAST. | [
-0.1671891958,
-0.5557433963,
0.294455111,
0.3045158684,
-0.0235573724,
-0.1031731442,
-0.4360888302,
-0.3316840231,
-0.0509209521,
0.5656232834,
-0.5332971811,
-0.1851606667,
-0.8395671248,
-0.4974441826,
-0.489009738,
1.3032386303,
-0.0948510766,
-0.4876959324,
-0.3822707534,
0.2268111855,
-0.8333536983,
-0.0930522457,
-0.586818397,
-0.2044238299,
0.6391525865,
0.9422575235,
0.2746833563,
0.3766689897,
0.6104733944,
0.1997325867,
0.2815803885,
0.0929063112,
-0.9911878109,
-0.0042489357,
-0.4083832204,
-0.4891187251,
-0.1031601578,
0.0102034584,
0.0865711644,
0.5536397099,
0.0615384541,
0.4122075438,
0.3444043398,
1.0580326319,
-1.0642904043,
0.2601507306,
-0.86826545,
-0.0011092277,
-0.13800174,
0.0327060595,
-0.7190765738,
-0.4062430263,
0.4058384299,
-0.7425154448,
0.4220102131,
-0.0401589684,
0.6751558185,
0.5367099643,
-0.2042982131,
-0.1387112141,
-0.6551247835,
0.8628445864,
-0.0812926665,
0.6722554564,
0.403056711,
0.482011646,
0.2102857977,
-0.8555338979,
-0.1574179977,
-0.2168714404,
0.1364489943,
0.0679129958,
-0.3241001368,
-0.3730433881,
0.019082319,
0.3877097666,
-0.2495244294,
-0.2428751588,
-0.5286381841,
0.0038505516,
0.1443900019,
-0.3480541408,
0.1733077914,
0.38626495,
-0.7175909281,
-0.3434836566,
-0.4162473679,
0.3185029924,
-0.3954855204,
0.445397079,
-0.1620244384,
0.0807397962,
-0.2155295014,
0.7129399776,
0.5895792842,
-0.0689028352,
0.2637394369,
-0.2002144903,
-0.4393278062,
0.162168175,
0.1241030619,
0.4432965815,
0.516035378,
-0.2501007617,
0.1797839403,
0.0765942633,
0.6207491159,
-0.4511323571,
-0.6954774261,
-0.2436758876,
-0.2884791195,
-0.4349558353,
-0.1645966321,
-0.5660346746,
0.0063609718,
-0.1861529648,
0.2406328917,
-0.38086918,
-0.1066691205,
0.1980277449,
0.0723202601,
0.2104606479,
0.4911872447,
-1.1708625555,
0.2568502128,
0.5811833143,
0.6830880046,
-0.6126103401,
-0.2617851198,
-0.7686340213,
0.5761144757,
-0.0873389095,
0.9395647049,
-0.6759119034,
-0.2029281557,
-0.1461161822,
0.0594121702,
-0.4157456756,
-0.3138521016,
0.4294114411,
-0.4505164623,
0.0749433041,
-0.3916685581,
-0.1034911424,
-0.3445496857,
0.2652651072,
-0.2681425214,
0.9240569472,
0.1796476096,
-0.6755815148,
0.112007089,
-0.3827274144,
-0.8640958667,
-0.3351434469,
0.222623229,
-0.3141518235,
0.2105071843,
0.4525404572,
0.4054409862,
-0.1930211335,
-0.1014172882,
-0.0788112655,
0.0653529093,
-0.0311257858,
-0.0986753479,
0.2497576922,
0.3389822245,
-0.3209389746,
0.2908954322,
-0.5512380004,
-0.0301399324,
0.0803678557,
0.0151936486,
-0.0995641798,
-0.4495970309,
0.0639947876,
0.1610503495,
0.3388811052,
-0.4472103119,
0.291007489,
-0.1200036034,
0.5277071595,
0.5161702037,
-0.2577276826,
0.6948335767,
-0.4690005481,
0.4529424608,
0.1090957671,
0.0730015486,
-0.5510615706,
-0.518558681,
-0.8728420734,
0.0599670298,
0.4348703623,
0.7109209895,
-0.6021262407,
-0.0152673358,
-0.2215375751,
-0.4328499734,
-0.6274792552,
0.1301820278,
0.7091343999,
1.1236723661,
0.4446651936,
-0.4720499516,
-0.2886513174,
-0.8376569748,
-0.0149404062,
0.1339124292,
0.1962095201,
0.3605623245,
-0.1541033536,
-0.1641002595,
0.4777387977,
-0.7659035921,
-0.7097190619,
-0.2647772133,
-0.0187916998,
-0.2297151834,
0.5818392038,
0.4701798856,
-0.6189742088,
-0.6552558541,
0.443790257,
-0.3716345429,
-0.0415868647,
-0.1356386095,
-0.4700529575,
-0.1126995161,
0.5562743545,
-0.4588029385,
0.4326457977,
0.3951428235,
-0.0015493598,
0.2749986649,
0.0302601829,
0.3150601983,
-0.9743461609,
0.1008608788,
0.0341112316,
-0.2731947899,
-0.4311185777,
-0.1373212487,
0.1788464636,
-0.2163842618,
-0.6864528656,
0.477224797,
-0.3279660046,
-0.3280113935,
-0.3797155023,
-0.0245320238,
0.226964727,
0.8543617725,
0.0298023019,
0.7781456709,
0.6889881492,
-0.4997859895,
0.1793074012,
0.3624659181,
-0.2882761061,
0.5447993875,
-0.2651188374,
0.3855777085,
0.3358952701,
0.129856199,
-1.4029740095,
-0.0897622108,
0.2766151726,
-0.3542838097,
0.5474678874,
0.0351836383,
0.2680614293,
-0.3491848707,
-0.1105924621,
0.5049436092,
0.554358542,
-0.502543807,
0.448761493,
0.2711309791,
-0.2304573059,
-0.4632061422,
-0.800162971,
-0.3139127195,
0.1280802339,
-0.4997434914,
0.6594639421,
0.2575517893,
0.3436145186,
0.1525716484,
-0.1810671389,
0.0132551659,
0.0369322188,
0.1575957388,
-0.0067031272,
-0.2892198265,
-0.0240724143,
0.1061020643,
-0.1783435047,
-0.3228001893,
-0.4836080372,
0.2589542866,
-0.0409511924,
-0.2175049484,
-0.7021253109,
0.0479284488,
0.727835536,
-0.4354147911,
0.1984015703,
0.5396046638,
-0.0642647967,
-0.2555188537,
-0.5463728905,
-0.3622308969,
-0.460390985,
0.3985858262,
-0.391472578,
-0.6703955531,
0.3996888995,
-0.2628395557,
0.2938696742,
-0.0014185711,
0.3327252567,
-0.3014186621,
0.5368231535,
1.0529069901,
-0.2751220763,
0.958407402,
-0.1001867801,
0.06228761,
-1.0190678835,
-0.276383996,
-0.3681393564,
-0.8636268973,
-0.1791804433,
-0.5146792531,
0.1210226119,
-0.1686685979,
-0.1766908318,
0.3244627714,
-0.6452707052,
0.688602984,
0.6620146036,
0.4246792495,
-0.0279446244,
0.2071116269,
-0.109889254,
0.0100267194,
-0.7220867872,
0.0959359482,
1.0038181543,
0.2664272785,
0.9358825684,
-0.4282256663,
0.3766178191,
0.5019090176,
0.3396421373,
-0.552495718,
0.4403948784,
-0.5102570057,
0.0450287163,
-0.2336813807,
-0.1764160842,
-0.725269556,
-0.0075785685,
0.0787638575,
-0.6355918646,
0.1591212302,
0.3647229671,
-0.3987697959,
0.4314060807,
-1.0251065493,
0.9272464514,
-0.4328841865,
-0.6108083725,
-0.1456847936,
-0.6063413024,
0.4296592176,
0.1865637004,
-0.014633704,
-0.0687553287,
0.2526571453,
0.5692999363,
0.2374361008,
1.0119278431,
-0.0882613659,
-0.1932551116,
0.0426123254,
0.4415807724,
0.6635840535,
-0.4158627391,
0.2309439033,
-0.0136775458,
-0.425727427,
-0.3959400952,
-0.6999648809,
1.0430947542,
-0.6830207109,
-0.8243532181,
-0.1222434714,
-0.6698537469,
-0.5050264597,
0.2320529521,
0.1465638727,
0.0935406014,
-0.0548279621,
0.1518805325,
0.8254548907,
0.1828893572,
0.2250926197,
0.1967990845,
-0.2880990207,
-0.3331685662,
1.2032824755,
-0.1702186763,
0.4217771292,
0.5628715754,
0.0598279312,
-0.0216292534,
-0.4227838218,
-0.4642023146,
-0.0672689974,
-0.5285935998,
-0.2009581476,
-0.5004012585,
-0.2209156305,
-0.4547491074,
-0.6231709719,
-0.7402133942,
-0.479801029,
-0.4998488426,
-0.1161149815,
0.1162730604,
0.3631332815,
0.2087311745,
0.3307903707,
-0.6756812334,
0.3999432623,
0.6029958725,
0.1429363042,
0.3065600395,
-0.8862435222,
-0.2376224399,
-0.2154561877,
-0.6680243611,
-0.5756978989,
0.3250207901,
0.3286731839,
0.3929455876,
0.4669145346,
0.1382536888,
0.7242375016,
-0.5330890417,
0.5348179936,
0.5902706385,
-0.9393683672,
0.8321436048,
-0.0150232352,
0.7443697453,
0.8343191743,
0.3814985752,
-0.4353768229,
-0.2421815544,
-0.3017686009,
-0.587443471,
0.9050149918,
-0.0034801583,
0.0382263139,
0.2140761614,
0.234073624,
0.4108029008,
0.0823091492,
-0.3386060297,
-0.0332398564,
-0.3117832243,
-0.2552838922,
0.0855537578,
0.0005078783,
0.0468751155,
-0.3521476388,
0.5028194785,
-0.2243306637,
0.2935531437,
0.1031019539,
-0.1832103431,
-0.4295247495,
0.051839944,
0.8908216953,
0.5556192398,
-0.0728721842,
0.2614001036,
0.1271095276,
-0.5631479621,
0.2118032426,
-0.1525377035,
-0.2460039556,
-0.5239879489,
0.1652012765,
1.2286198139,
1.1240348816,
-0.136310339,
0.2039742023,
-0.0883969069,
-0.0796911865,
0.3541483879,
0.3483014107,
0.0666381791,
0.2956059277,
0.3099713624,
0.4630590975,
0.0956009924,
-0.4248265922,
0.5026257038,
0.2269591093,
-0.5079370737,
-0.4910262823,
0.6724395156,
0.7319062352,
-0.1551542133,
0.6344433427,
0.486325264,
-0.5114053488,
0.6989892125,
0.6877691746,
1.1836842299,
-0.1908725649,
0.2307567447,
0.1814464182,
0.2163715214,
0.131059438,
0.000751074,
-0.6749972701,
-0.5694362521,
-0.2361953706,
-0.4569557011,
-0.4968754649,
-0.1565995067,
-0.8730500937,
0.1827089638,
-0.2998794317,
-0.1071109548,
0.0033488327,
-0.4168227911,
-0.7356785536,
0.2030768842,
0.5541129112,
0.8367304206,
-0.7828748822,
1.0852521658,
0.6787776947,
-0.0142410547,
-0.2410963029,
0.1918404549,
-0.4596191347,
-1.0284913778,
0.7694196701,
0.3671266139,
-0.2823807597,
0.169829607,
-0.394939363,
-1.045840621,
0.8605287671,
0.5536885262,
-1.0708150864,
-0.2954788208,
-0.1013221666,
0.037844941,
-0.611030519,
0.1468720138,
0.5148897171,
0.2331060618,
0.5927332044,
-1.116292119,
-0.0831864774,
0.1059773117,
-0.0822852105,
0.0592977814,
-1.0401681662,
0.5059054494,
-0.6700409055,
-0.2115814686,
-0.4805494249,
1.0357582569,
0.0018324769,
0.6587547064,
0.386965245,
0.864644587,
0.708969593,
-0.067951642,
0.9346333146,
-0.3645849526,
0.1849678606,
1.2824010849,
-0.4721978009,
0.8936995864,
0.5809056759,
-0.0332063809,
0.5054782629,
0.4639774859,
0.3968999684,
1.250328064,
-0.1683873236,
0.234778583,
-0.2317121923,
0.0537486449,
-0.4440140724,
0.174807936,
0.2379627675,
-0.4333644807,
-0.4269276857,
0.6884573698,
-0.3484989107,
-0.0604794472,
-0.6338467598,
0.9078257084,
0.154090479,
-0.9902604222,
0.7829244137,
-0.5238131881,
0.535286963,
-0.603066206,
-0.1804681569,
-0.2506997287,
0.4182946384,
-0.0698954836,
-0.82421875,
0.1648839563,
-0.1865099519,
-0.5568734407,
-0.3596175313,
0.8299188018,
-0.4594686627,
-0.4025044441,
0.0518952347,
0.1786867976,
-0.178692162,
0.1528167129,
-0.6121925712,
0.3799625933,
0.454226613,
-0.2257421762,
0.5905734897,
0.289406985,
-0.1472659111,
0.8952975869,
0.6318371892,
-0.2209669799,
0.234668836,
-0.2692231536,
1.0115129948,
-0.5986531973,
-0.7962016463,
-0.4151097834,
0.3263573349,
0.3302540183,
-0.4210900664,
0.548995316,
0.2559814453,
1.1046690941,
-0.4948896766,
0.7702482343,
0.1311795861,
0.2252583653,
-0.5310078263,
0.4671452641,
-0.2174229175,
-0.1529599577,
-0.1156627685,
-0.9353607893,
-0.0021239121,
0.4764300883,
-0.7522557974,
0.0110132014,
0.5473844409,
0.2359189838,
-0.5231505036,
-0.024881497,
0.6227603555,
-0.0760587081,
-0.0817812383,
1.1605234146,
0.5330477953,
-0.3416497409,
0.4393144846,
-0.6329903603,
-0.2245838046,
-0.5142339468,
-0.7283798456,
-0.7504855394,
-0.5070151091,
-0.5092805624,
-0.0213622265,
0.3315283954,
0.4566511512,
1.1899633408,
-1.0634614229,
-0.0441182703,
-0.111886248,
0.1397493035,
-0.5708429813,
-0.2109788358,
0.5201997161,
-0.6981229782,
-0.5250698924,
0.2644795179,
0.2085756958,
-0.2799614072,
-0.0741173252,
0.1335182339,
-0.1948698461,
-0.0037142569,
0.5762551427,
0.5921478868,
-0.6520693898,
-0.3318985999,
-0.0519441031,
-0.1223148257,
0.1927247196,
0.9423410892,
-0.9729011655,
0.4284320474,
0.3275284171,
1.0457751751,
0.9142686725,
0.2451942265,
0.3249431551,
-0.763653636,
0.2681778967,
0.0220304951,
-0.0257843714,
0.3424059153,
-0.5146166086,
0.2776179612,
0.1510133743,
-0.6318805814,
-0.6250041127,
0.1424378306,
-1.2698863745,
-0.0697037205,
0.8742429018,
-0.2434234619,
-0.6976906061,
0.2728346884,
-0.4923220873,
0.1320710629,
-0.5174913406,
0.960255146,
0.4031636417,
-0.3575678468,
-0.5846930742,
-0.2512632012,
0.5173193216,
0.6181352735,
-0.7131534219,
0.445836395,
0.192745313,
0.3062867522,
0.2922508121,
0.2153383791,
0.1474258453,
0.596175909,
-0.4257948697,
0.0130080963,
-0.3941241205,
-0.8099697232,
0.025766762,
0.3951242566,
-0.2183418125,
-0.8217951059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15541v1 | Harnessing the Power of Large Language Models for Natural Language to First-Order Logic Translation | 2023-05-24T19:59:51 | 2023-05-24T19:59:51 | Yuan Yang, Siheng Xiong, Ali Payani, Ehsan Shareghi, Faramarz Fekri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Translating natural language sentences to first-order logic (NL-FOL
translation) is a longstanding challenge in the NLP and formal logic
literature. This paper introduces LogicLLaMA, a LLaMA-7B model fine-tuned for
NL-FOL translation using LoRA on a single GPU. LogicLLaMA is capable of
directly translating natural language into FOL rules, which outperforms
GPT-3.5. LogicLLaMA is also equipped to correct FOL rules predicted by GPT-3.5,
and can achieve similar performance as GPT-4 with a fraction of the cost. This
correction ability was achieved by a novel supervised fine-tuning (SFT) +
reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) framework, which initially
trains on synthetically perturbed NL-FOL pairs to encourage chain-of-thought
reasoning and then fine-tunes with RLHF on GPT-3.5 outputs using a FOL verifier
as the reward model.
To train LogicLLaMA, we present MALLS (large language $\textbf{M}$odel
gener$\textbf{A}$ted N$\textbf{L}$-FO$\textbf{L}$ pair$\textbf{S}$), a dataset
of 34K high-quality and diverse sentence-level NL-FOL pairs collected from
GPT-4. The dataset was created by implementing a pipeline that prompts GPT-4
for pairs, and dynamically adjusts the prompts to ensure the collection of
pairs with rich and diverse contexts at different levels of complexity, and
verifies the validity of the generated FOL rules. Codes, weights, and data are
available at $\href{https://github.com/gblackout/LogicLLaMA}{{\small
\text{https://github.com/gblackout/LogicLLaMA}}}$. | [
-0.0984332561,
-0.8641318679,
0.5955873132,
0.209647432,
-0.3862039149,
-0.1357080191,
-0.2164678723,
-0.5294392705,
0.0834442228,
0.8274770379,
-0.6368029714,
-0.6000371575,
-0.589602232,
0.1819906682,
-0.6601959467,
1.1937599182,
-0.0444745012,
-0.3050051928,
0.2940684855,
-0.208557725,
-0.3712356687,
-0.5654702187,
-0.6171144247,
-0.3975793123,
0.5392529368,
0.1129242182,
0.8535352945,
0.3124592304,
0.3644669056,
0.3188551664,
0.005418377,
0.4573990703,
-0.5596747994,
-0.2913369834,
-0.30781883,
-0.4437131286,
-0.739669919,
0.0454413258,
0.2771448493,
0.2740756273,
-0.4407972097,
0.2228736132,
-0.3528472781,
0.9123365283,
-0.4546071887,
0.5261250734,
-0.7637812495,
0.1985460669,
-0.2003915161,
-0.3400856555,
-0.6247056723,
-0.7178031206,
0.0239173155,
-0.9666027427,
-0.2979515791,
0.4384667277,
1.0894702673,
0.6149400473,
-0.2118418813,
-0.3709581494,
-0.6876283288,
0.6180529594,
-0.9836102724,
0.0630305409,
0.2326076776,
0.617566824,
-0.2801963687,
-0.6752227545,
-0.7980517149,
-0.1281964928,
-0.2221785635,
0.033245489,
-0.4132933617,
0.0000024577,
0.2895413935,
0.5416151881,
-0.374384433,
-0.1270425469,
-0.4957055151,
0.2246972322,
0.752794981,
0.1854595691,
0.2407265007,
0.0378849506,
-0.4929112196,
-0.0417374261,
-0.7858965397,
0.1001620889,
-0.0803138539,
0.4307862818,
0.1360883862,
0.4228129387,
-0.4527502954,
0.9577720761,
0.1266560704,
-0.368175894,
0.2499032319,
-0.532414794,
-0.6029071808,
0.3236884475,
0.7692705393,
0.2594536543,
0.4323974252,
-0.1500986814,
-0.5047819018,
0.1795310825,
0.2656860948,
-0.6651616693,
-0.015059947,
-0.0235466976,
-0.0246398561,
-0.2657791078,
0.0056257532,
-0.4882829785,
-0.1889185607,
-0.5694642067,
0.5619686246,
-0.2770725489,
-0.0014688108,
0.7713928223,
0.5915828943,
0.4741563499,
0.5269991159,
-0.9298101068,
0.581093967,
0.7705333233,
0.6783539653,
0.1757779717,
-0.2451192439,
-1.0365837812,
-0.0272116046,
-0.4468856454,
0.6185159087,
-0.1139193699,
0.3097872734,
0.0795890316,
-0.2785202563,
-0.0902711973,
-0.6115311384,
0.7639303803,
-0.6425813437,
0.1593343318,
-0.0479650013,
-0.3293654323,
-0.2695949376,
0.2239868343,
-0.525778234,
0.7905185819,
0.2484934628,
-0.389964968,
0.2702066898,
-0.5452290773,
-0.607187748,
-0.1600628495,
-0.0736302733,
-0.0799708441,
0.1879117042,
0.4232790172,
0.3628976643,
-0.3946996629,
0.509264946,
0.1258242577,
-0.3125226796,
0.128431648,
-0.1522034109,
0.7069529295,
0.1671989858,
-0.4553199708,
0.4571944773,
-0.6845825315,
-0.0619963259,
0.2955667078,
-0.3642213345,
-0.1530690938,
-0.052626241,
0.1664733589,
0.8521097302,
0.2273721099,
-0.4462827146,
0.4406401813,
-0.9147676229,
0.6162605286,
0.865540266,
-0.4642017782,
0.2818215191,
-0.2850291729,
0.5552248955,
-0.1446523666,
0.3630637527,
0.1562950462,
-0.7494541407,
-0.788126111,
0.0294745527,
-0.0847646892,
0.7360767126,
-0.7316375971,
0.4182643592,
-0.4503138363,
-0.3229025006,
-0.7467182875,
0.478813529,
0.2687498033,
0.5768774152,
0.7000852227,
0.1534719318,
-0.2405890524,
-0.8777999282,
-0.0060667386,
-0.094582215,
0.0302197356,
-0.0584488623,
0.3868119717,
-0.2757503986,
0.9133076668,
-0.5211113095,
-0.9254245758,
-0.5044829249,
-0.1826290786,
0.7795433998,
0.2472332418,
0.5778326988,
-0.5464497805,
-0.1895638555,
0.3589001596,
-0.6351997256,
-0.2800317109,
-0.1103174388,
-0.3270381391,
0.4066090286,
0.3984166682,
-0.6279425621,
0.5644437671,
0.6816411614,
-0.4051391184,
0.2136236578,
-0.3695432842,
-0.0368122682,
-0.99693501,
0.1101840958,
-0.1417702138,
-0.2489436716,
-0.5443122387,
0.3226699233,
-0.2538719475,
0.1493110061,
-0.4586456716,
0.6425367594,
0.0756683797,
-0.0001197705,
-0.3440135419,
0.3304018974,
0.0548455045,
0.6836410165,
-0.0239973459,
0.4250749648,
-0.0979684815,
-0.3902463317,
0.3290183246,
0.3581048846,
-0.6328161359,
0.3697835803,
-0.7529031634,
0.0660927594,
0.2131478935,
0.5367191434,
-0.5931298733,
-0.1233455911,
0.4229994118,
-0.0305587575,
-0.1700522602,
0.0596419722,
-0.9373738766,
-0.2556054294,
0.1506499201,
0.235528186,
0.5427468419,
-0.7090162039,
0.7180976868,
0.2630448043,
0.0225609727,
-0.3141134381,
-0.6917860508,
-0.0102935657,
0.0474685244,
-0.8222552538,
0.1881172508,
-0.0978045091,
-0.1342934668,
-0.2838254571,
-0.2594979703,
-0.0040391181,
0.1950587779,
0.1842616647,
0.2894423902,
-0.266125828,
-0.1155595407,
0.1678455621,
-0.2884370983,
0.1640552878,
-0.5928422213,
0.5216944218,
-0.573371768,
-0.1277751178,
-0.3175156415,
0.1114054695,
0.5456011295,
-0.4841939807,
0.6401874423,
0.4675290287,
-0.6025223136,
-0.3998659849,
-0.3696270287,
0.0326261669,
-0.4918247759,
-0.0360507034,
-0.4165948927,
-0.9451107383,
0.1749079525,
0.1734432131,
0.3808469176,
0.3549858034,
0.5324068666,
0.3594662249,
0.9015347958,
0.4163093865,
-0.3066182733,
0.1657681465,
-0.0986521244,
0.6165056825,
-0.3814077973,
-0.1815617234,
-0.2613071203,
-0.4343129694,
-0.240823403,
-0.4665558934,
0.224668324,
0.1614378989,
-0.2261809558,
0.1977292895,
-0.4122624099,
0.6834353209,
0.5378768444,
0.0787189454,
0.7476141453,
-0.0098687224,
-0.0618846677,
-0.0025185479,
-0.6602619886,
-0.4492664337,
0.7752271891,
0.1860592216,
0.6628490686,
0.3599932194,
0.629830718,
0.0441484153,
0.504753232,
-0.8103601336,
0.6485407352,
-0.4930670857,
-0.2605053484,
-0.013682832,
-0.3275673091,
-0.7126364708,
0.1283026487,
-0.3111609221,
-0.6353304386,
-0.1172156334,
0.3120754659,
-0.5777236223,
0.3383943141,
-0.4446131885,
0.9367958903,
-0.5277001262,
-0.4060281515,
-0.2511586249,
-0.6128749251,
0.7214183211,
-0.1968377531,
0.3556060791,
-0.1885502487,
0.3196364343,
0.3839289844,
-0.6372404695,
0.4395953417,
-0.0343184173,
-0.5313873291,
0.0248522516,
0.2492198199,
0.4376017153,
0.1118080243,
-0.0205520913,
0.0238695052,
-0.1418914944,
-0.416246444,
-0.7888064981,
0.7510880828,
-0.6893857718,
-0.6449686885,
-0.6193362474,
-0.6652564406,
-0.1295912862,
0.195139423,
-0.047304973,
0.1949970871,
0.2459440231,
0.0544149391,
0.5112419724,
-0.2746954858,
-0.0819232538,
0.3638008237,
-0.8917095661,
-0.2235311866,
0.8850505948,
-0.1510074884,
0.3975801468,
0.6224344373,
0.4253900647,
-0.3512233198,
-0.5388706923,
-0.4492047131,
0.1007428616,
-0.707291007,
-0.2241652459,
-0.3936012387,
-0.2576714456,
-0.2783676088,
-0.456823945,
-0.3597696424,
-0.374586612,
0.0995198414,
-0.1683998257,
0.5391349196,
0.9015128016,
0.1190366969,
0.2862416804,
-0.480753243,
0.4556491673,
0.3718871474,
0.1196366847,
-0.217121616,
-0.6140309572,
-0.1200146228,
-0.0812857375,
0.0963254794,
-0.5151752234,
0.6717091799,
0.1747537255,
0.228530854,
0.3292525411,
0.0539709404,
0.7517268658,
-0.6890304089,
0.3934220672,
0.045118399,
-1.1680604219,
0.9527071714,
-0.4675199389,
0.3337331414,
0.7556526065,
-0.1414756328,
-0.4952152967,
-0.286020726,
-0.3826925159,
-1.0483294725,
0.7991575599,
0.1932072192,
-0.1734599322,
0.0568404645,
0.3964465559,
-0.1040338129,
0.2583633363,
-0.9053381681,
-0.0077260742,
-0.39602229,
-0.347835511,
-0.307005316,
0.3215173185,
-0.054630924,
-0.4801026881,
0.7175053358,
-0.335064292,
-0.2447310686,
0.1129958481,
-0.3262233436,
-0.0054231766,
0.4566608667,
0.9246540666,
0.6266083717,
-0.4441200793,
-0.1643529087,
-0.1126743853,
-0.1146387234,
0.1777633578,
0.2115389258,
-0.3253858089,
-0.1806315631,
0.1701812893,
0.8890972137,
0.4772726297,
-0.8516485691,
0.5041350722,
-0.0085144294,
-0.2590811253,
-0.2718003988,
0.2183408588,
-0.0941025689,
0.212367624,
0.412845552,
0.1475530714,
-0.0652171969,
-0.5363307595,
0.1408399791,
0.0635023415,
-0.1285082549,
-0.2715108991,
0.9613056779,
0.0514525138,
-0.1010641307,
0.62710464,
-0.2646824419,
-0.6288666725,
0.3147224784,
0.6278063655,
0.6907233596,
0.0877738819,
0.2422194183,
0.524297595,
0.7369112968,
-0.2574233413,
0.0980078205,
0.1401011199,
-0.5147000551,
-0.5806046724,
-0.9861887693,
-0.3426426351,
0.0879986882,
-0.5277107954,
0.0282690413,
-0.9271069765,
0.2490484864,
-0.1956131309,
0.035373982,
-0.736859858,
0.0451128446,
0.2919810712,
1.0020810366,
-0.8228262067,
1.2708617449,
0.5751835704,
-0.5936194062,
-0.9874337912,
-0.2861348987,
0.0845645666,
-0.7542259693,
0.950297296,
0.1830507517,
-0.378490001,
-0.0267128441,
-0.4264370501,
-0.5730708241,
1.2710850239,
0.5437759161,
-0.6658027768,
-0.1312072128,
0.2524434626,
0.7001789808,
-0.5200258493,
-0.1703148484,
0.7622218132,
0.4966760278,
0.0235058777,
-0.8798163533,
0.189226985,
-0.3840157092,
-0.0883213654,
0.2079145461,
-0.5056166649,
0.9374170303,
-0.2261668146,
-0.0728116482,
0.1825199574,
0.7570099831,
0.5770542026,
0.1951886415,
0.6137906313,
0.6635742784,
0.7471664548,
-0.2903187573,
1.1723223925,
-0.198960647,
0.301856935,
1.350733757,
-0.5529232025,
1.2158700228,
0.6651607752,
-0.0692576021,
0.5679712892,
0.2125206888,
0.3092805445,
0.4522903562,
0.6217152476,
-0.0980014354,
-0.3199803233,
-0.0084027844,
-0.2147912383,
0.318801105,
0.5459013581,
-0.0980059057,
-0.2405760586,
-0.1068647057,
-0.0235469881,
0.3725684285,
-0.3262273967,
0.4782229066,
0.1574573815,
-0.6444880366,
0.7055502534,
0.0647946224,
0.7266821265,
-0.7854345441,
-0.0232621301,
-0.5348715186,
0.5555831194,
-0.2123630792,
-0.4402117431,
0.2298243344,
0.0657647774,
0.0428246967,
-0.4183034599,
0.4558406174,
-0.3665765822,
-0.6843522191,
0.556638062,
0.2736607492,
-0.1893929392,
-0.0312529132,
-0.6756466627,
0.0349800289,
-0.0999241546,
-0.161878556,
0.2366777211,
0.344589591,
-0.110948205,
0.6911279559,
0.7763890624,
0.1038057134,
0.3854986131,
0.0585041456,
0.6746322513,
-0.5314454436,
-0.490590483,
-0.6704013944,
0.282025516,
0.1623093933,
-0.50283885,
0.3766528368,
0.4015865326,
1.0164952278,
-0.0718936548,
0.352212429,
0.051053986,
-0.0152656827,
-0.9626147151,
0.5910481215,
-0.6505019665,
0.3213523328,
-0.3325358927,
-0.7456548214,
-0.4434862137,
1.0814790726,
-0.3040746748,
-0.423997432,
0.6036078334,
0.6995056868,
-0.1850841343,
0.067256555,
0.2765153348,
0.4323219657,
0.4378916919,
1.1870981455,
0.6113471389,
-0.7197262645,
0.506383419,
-0.2767343819,
-0.1568415016,
-0.2788046896,
-0.7809407711,
-0.6736018062,
-0.4260026813,
-0.2095995545,
-0.3299764693,
0.0976010188,
1.2975720167,
0.5458927751,
-0.9342753291,
-0.3116723597,
-0.1598505825,
0.130898416,
-0.3464899063,
-0.1836719662,
0.2207956463,
-0.3040344417,
-0.5888382196,
0.5933848619,
0.5160034895,
-0.3023464382,
-0.3134698868,
-0.3080778122,
-0.5006950498,
0.1177205145,
1.0630688667,
0.2039639205,
-1.2463356256,
-0.2443736047,
0.0544724539,
-0.1529071778,
0.1225238442,
0.5899642706,
-0.9622254372,
0.1409516633,
0.3074945807,
1.0318727493,
0.3193539977,
-0.2293527722,
0.5890341401,
-0.6053000689,
0.1031255424,
0.0387231484,
0.4011415541,
0.0338971429,
-0.0305440798,
0.7209272981,
0.0749013722,
-0.420304507,
-0.5157649517,
0.2138977051,
-1.4237158298,
0.0297056492,
0.9741527438,
-0.0278868712,
-0.2828405499,
0.1605225354,
-0.3824407756,
-0.1242675409,
-0.4504997432,
0.7960616946,
0.7223725915,
0.0991073474,
-0.097630769,
-0.9247139692,
0.4774363339,
0.5741645098,
-1.1772422791,
-0.0661387593,
0.6826158762,
-0.009221578,
0.1375686973,
0.8525828123,
-0.0479550287,
0.4063471258,
-0.7016611099,
-0.3565386832,
0.0029209584,
-0.2574595511,
-0.3250977397,
0.1291704327,
0.103698276,
0.1912344247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15533v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15533v1 | Automated Refugee Case Analysis: An NLP Pipeline for Supporting Legal Practitioners | 2023-05-24T19:37:23 | 2023-05-24T19:37:23 | Claire Barale, Michael Rovatsos, Nehal Bhuta | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce an end-to-end pipeline for retrieving,
processing, and extracting targeted information from legal cases. We
investigate an under-studied legal domain with a case study on refugee law in
Canada. Searching case law for past similar cases is a key part of legal work
for both lawyers and judges, the potential end-users of our prototype. While
traditional named-entity recognition labels such as dates provide meaningful
information in legal work, we propose to extend existing models and retrieve a
total of 19 useful categories of items from refugee cases. After creating a
novel data set of cases, we perform information extraction based on
state-of-the-art neural named-entity recognition (NER). We test different
architectures including two transformer models, using contextual and
non-contextual embeddings, and compare general purpose versus domain-specific
pre-training. The results demonstrate that models pre-trained on legal data
perform best despite their smaller size, suggesting that domain matching had a
larger effect than network architecture. We achieve a F1 score above 90% on
five of the targeted categories and over 80% on four further categories. | [
-0.4664100111,
-0.1765380502,
0.4523495436,
-0.0575054623,
-0.3687663376,
0.2322794795,
-0.1074768603,
-0.3376540542,
0.6180841923,
0.5983225107,
-0.277867943,
-0.5840342641,
-0.7945780158,
0.1811124235,
-0.8708732724,
1.0455029011,
0.0235878304,
-0.1912985444,
-0.0236226209,
-0.286360085,
-0.4665468931,
-0.6663845181,
-0.8281541467,
0.0866972432,
0.627063334,
0.2042962909,
0.410685122,
0.4803594947,
0.4833976924,
0.2111166567,
-0.0013132868,
-0.4191791415,
-0.2057254314,
-0.0779740289,
-0.4199958444,
-0.3434606791,
-0.4148459733,
0.012374714,
0.0984186232,
0.3494733274,
-0.5264049172,
0.3042330146,
-0.5051077008,
0.5058566928,
-0.5978620052,
0.0619677827,
-0.8014042377,
0.4646114111,
-0.2457096279,
-0.21799393,
-0.4179218709,
-0.0114635564,
0.2244705856,
-0.5357899666,
0.6671258807,
0.3218334615,
0.8936476707,
0.4266856015,
-0.4042016566,
-0.4894501567,
-0.4651456773,
0.5388657451,
-0.6267346144,
0.4130762815,
0.1763422638,
0.4880797267,
-0.1993407756,
-1.1518064737,
-0.6455131173,
-0.0170250367,
-0.0612131655,
0.1999298334,
-0.507237196,
-0.0846838132,
0.3380946517,
0.0623124875,
-0.6824188828,
0.2370302975,
-0.59447366,
-0.4213703573,
0.7015151381,
0.0443057604,
0.5881085992,
-0.1210558563,
0.0645136908,
0.2601453364,
-0.6364458799,
0.1442133039,
0.5277943611,
0.4368381202,
-0.1794707477,
0.6174231768,
0.0514597408,
0.7796527147,
-0.0826575756,
0.2841847241,
0.1041845977,
0.1434178501,
-0.0850286931,
0.2090213299,
0.6240081787,
0.4023327231,
0.2335012853,
-0.2909376919,
-0.5429799557,
-0.3544126153,
0.5738891959,
-0.767342031,
-0.2047652751,
0.2650757134,
-0.8076014519,
0.0807477012,
0.1540659517,
-0.9247543812,
-0.3990914822,
-0.5694393516,
-0.1545404047,
-0.0372675397,
-0.3609683812,
0.3269990981,
-0.2220985144,
0.8077711463,
0.2935369611,
-0.6901746392,
0.5694922209,
0.7420095205,
0.7916055918,
-0.3030962646,
0.3280549049,
-1.0078736544,
-0.2802905142,
-0.0703533366,
0.8264304399,
-0.7789439559,
-0.124197796,
0.0842880011,
0.3464920521,
-0.1308480799,
-0.7671555281,
0.785802722,
-1.0220768452,
-0.0235093199,
-0.0800468698,
-0.4573840201,
-0.1507649571,
0.1906933039,
-0.7774376869,
0.36336115,
0.3690100312,
-0.6049851775,
0.6926269531,
-0.807131052,
-0.2878535092,
0.371791631,
-0.4009431899,
-0.565364182,
0.1653002799,
0.1415530145,
0.3325641155,
-0.4066970348,
0.6970933676,
-0.0353252329,
-0.2371709198,
-0.2938354611,
0.0506686084,
1.0686640739,
0.3235996068,
-0.1412948668,
-0.0790136904,
-0.6174284816,
-0.270449698,
0.1849966347,
-0.597584486,
-0.1959347278,
0.0373619124,
0.1996370852,
0.2981524765,
-0.1958118528,
-0.8195958138,
0.0256622694,
-0.2191048563,
0.4135586917,
0.2540094256,
-0.1940561235,
0.1085299104,
-0.0076083653,
0.9622251987,
0.1599955112,
-0.1826218963,
-0.1181648374,
-0.6834257841,
-0.6903570294,
-0.2596877515,
0.9407036304,
0.6935428381,
-0.4660122395,
0.3072670102,
-0.3636354506,
0.1342256516,
-0.705350101,
-0.162753135,
-0.1035209224,
0.4514564276,
0.4611074924,
-0.6288943291,
-0.9769641757,
-0.9892397523,
-0.5716587901,
-0.2295465767,
-0.2559522688,
0.2672018707,
0.8687279224,
-0.3300198615,
1.3943482637,
-0.3084337711,
-0.3541613817,
-0.3436719775,
0.2505407035,
0.4456608295,
0.2596780956,
0.6891012192,
-1.1814699173,
-0.6006696224,
0.1916994601,
-0.7237734199,
-0.1345402002,
-0.1915858239,
0.1435489506,
-0.1549990028,
0.4734818637,
-0.6125084758,
0.736623168,
-0.1204097569,
-0.7181218266,
0.2842024267,
0.0834242851,
-0.2032833248,
-0.8670483828,
0.0928068161,
0.1482269317,
-0.1172093302,
-0.7152085304,
0.0582021587,
0.0483416207,
-0.2312041372,
-0.6315065026,
0.7193908691,
-0.4040136337,
-0.1211414114,
-0.3369376659,
-0.1065084487,
-0.1546846777,
0.1666475981,
0.2445511222,
0.4292918742,
0.4210421145,
-0.2242955565,
0.6527450085,
0.2686205208,
-0.1711349636,
0.7816281915,
-0.3321349323,
0.1244265586,
-0.5359706879,
0.0191169456,
-0.3398183286,
-0.2208426595,
0.3904366493,
-0.2683959305,
0.3098751009,
-0.7021847963,
-0.4329009056,
-0.5654925108,
0.2322466671,
0.5973470211,
0.3934269547,
-0.4398173094,
1.1205719709,
0.5970345736,
-0.2798676193,
-0.5566802621,
-0.3476932049,
0.4054712355,
-0.7527410388,
0.0486432649,
0.5515277982,
0.2186363786,
-0.3698391616,
0.307336241,
0.0447139479,
-0.6806124449,
-0.0503855087,
0.3060410321,
0.0334833749,
-0.3940699399,
-0.1456285566,
0.0375211984,
-0.1293444932,
0.3959845603,
-0.3854517341,
0.3736654222,
-0.0259769019,
-0.4046326876,
-0.2624067664,
0.6171018481,
0.4356531799,
-0.2099587768,
0.5765827894,
0.2997639179,
-0.7146710157,
-0.0363691337,
-0.5677512288,
0.1913399696,
-0.429474622,
0.1081309468,
-0.2964249551,
-0.7021154761,
0.7025721669,
-0.0623567067,
0.3352376521,
0.5996636748,
0.3230697513,
0.0970863774,
0.3254966438,
0.946320653,
-0.398679018,
0.1271009743,
-0.0581385233,
0.7556083798,
-0.567596674,
-0.4249244928,
-0.4104101658,
-0.2311442494,
-0.2872175276,
-0.0933232978,
0.0117943203,
-0.0171029847,
0.0952295065,
0.744993031,
-0.4345068038,
0.5667706132,
0.49289307,
-0.2441704124,
0.1883414686,
0.0338850282,
-0.1502250135,
-0.1219250783,
-0.6537263989,
-0.4104380608,
1.1899569035,
0.227849707,
0.0858135,
0.061742574,
0.653991878,
0.6135578156,
0.6056047082,
-1.0872702599,
0.4718076289,
-0.1651769131,
-0.5485788584,
0.0143092833,
-0.2020033598,
-1.2607527971,
0.1843203455,
-0.1067748964,
-0.7142799497,
0.3731397092,
-0.2804259658,
-0.8870790601,
0.2941793203,
-0.3717463911,
0.5860603452,
-0.2423425317,
-0.0093941083,
0.1111552715,
-0.5315979123,
0.1023792401,
-0.6511053443,
0.2232242376,
-0.0355628878,
0.2815745771,
0.79060179,
-0.3779603839,
0.4801829457,
-0.3068220317,
0.0503648296,
0.5183685422,
-0.1174706742,
0.0705890059,
0.1729274243,
-0.247966826,
0.1234486774,
0.1183543801,
-0.1521890014,
-0.6501372457,
0.3443310559,
-0.1317089796,
-0.6887035966,
-0.3971667588,
-0.6363976002,
0.2909398675,
0.276830703,
-0.0566952899,
0.1800038815,
0.1050997302,
0.292129159,
0.2949565351,
-0.430763036,
0.692404151,
1.0112714767,
0.0835924894,
-0.0790236667,
0.8035750985,
0.256690383,
-0.7861577272,
0.3667536676,
-0.0989286378,
-0.3206399679,
-0.8074470162,
-0.3404879272,
0.081089735,
-0.6363683343,
-0.3542440832,
-0.8752822876,
-0.517157495,
-0.1849438846,
-0.0381688923,
-0.4044232368,
-0.2630187571,
-0.087346971,
-0.06535469,
0.1554953754,
0.5642508268,
0.1169217527,
0.1871074289,
-0.6705530882,
0.510314703,
0.0934273452,
0.3669236004,
-0.4440058172,
-0.8036420941,
-0.1244331375,
-0.3681507409,
-0.0944556147,
-0.6433573961,
0.6475718021,
0.2045360506,
0.6301846504,
0.4480074942,
0.2360585183,
0.603446424,
-0.8334765434,
0.5680254102,
0.0783295408,
-0.6485341191,
0.67559582,
-0.0700826123,
-0.1383864731,
0.5549154878,
0.5456229448,
-0.4335704744,
0.0067833709,
-0.5940163732,
-0.9972485304,
0.5544748902,
0.4656116962,
0.3170503974,
-0.0283648502,
0.8904219866,
0.1044060066,
0.3559575081,
-0.7332019806,
0.1544192433,
0.0267474744,
-0.3280899525,
0.4638363421,
-0.0087850802,
-0.1812123209,
-0.5925773978,
0.2855775654,
-0.0050107241,
0.3873676062,
-0.0209926181,
-0.0798912048,
0.2070614249,
-0.0212819725,
0.2549501956,
0.5981696844,
-0.0407785214,
-0.0406959504,
0.2393678278,
-0.4034854472,
0.161028564,
0.3282487094,
-0.1038755924,
0.3958859146,
0.352168709,
0.4091846347,
-0.2134582549,
-0.9434319139,
0.7391760349,
-0.5507060289,
-0.3117399812,
-0.7908233404,
-0.1302836388,
-0.1130458936,
0.4768972695,
0.4635344744,
-0.149586767,
0.349888891,
-0.3793545067,
0.6451502442,
0.5582716465,
-0.2350866646,
-0.3132741451,
0.6664004922,
0.03840876,
-0.7196622491,
0.8898398876,
-0.1200613007,
-0.2533592284,
0.8183569312,
0.4126556516,
0.8375449777,
-0.12064147,
0.134097591,
0.2140162587,
0.1101081744,
-0.1797312051,
0.2772296667,
-0.2223880887,
-0.7017495036,
-0.2247366607,
-0.7653790116,
-0.1531642526,
0.4548372626,
-0.9899630547,
0.4014090002,
-0.2961623669,
-0.2953481972,
-0.1275203228,
-0.3506467938,
-1.0179667473,
0.2785593271,
0.0724223107,
0.9264720678,
-0.7656258941,
0.6726320982,
0.6247730851,
-0.2077038288,
-0.2969943881,
0.089241989,
0.0319111235,
-0.4126972556,
0.9742792845,
0.3724309206,
-0.0286542289,
0.101011835,
-0.3860487044,
-0.7757652402,
0.9651483297,
0.5418533683,
-0.7251564264,
-0.3250049353,
0.4385439754,
0.6288831234,
-0.7284499407,
0.2205587924,
0.936329484,
0.1044636741,
-0.0121455574,
-0.6586568356,
-0.0228625908,
-0.6186101437,
-0.2354758829,
0.0366778858,
-0.0716090649,
0.3864821494,
-0.0715938956,
-0.4329409301,
-0.2528026402,
0.551184833,
0.0893167779,
0.5207547545,
0.5082902312,
0.7171400189,
0.6681388617,
-0.2037469596,
0.8088415265,
-0.5307483673,
0.3528660834,
1.1074050665,
-0.3304467201,
0.7069135904,
0.7155231833,
0.0398365706,
0.3842411339,
0.5794036984,
-0.2311630696,
0.5533512235,
0.7824963331,
-0.2842333615,
0.0201586243,
-0.2886824906,
0.0987964422,
0.3919466138,
0.4674143493,
-0.6877122521,
-0.4012863636,
0.058607243,
-0.3450827599,
-0.0523692332,
-0.1599002182,
0.622487843,
0.2566618621,
-0.4927507937,
0.1535096765,
0.1552884728,
0.3154270053,
-0.0859463885,
-0.2496985346,
-0.359836787,
-0.2046375573,
-0.3905852139,
-0.6717428565,
0.6503425241,
0.359021008,
-0.0521329232,
-0.2655866444,
0.6085978746,
-0.0490484983,
-0.3217045963,
0.6592415571,
0.6200929284,
0.4449692667,
-0.1249506101,
-0.86124897,
-0.0350203365,
-0.3780388832,
-0.2688073516,
0.2493109703,
0.5264650583,
-0.1474110633,
0.6455593705,
0.4550990164,
0.2443196326,
0.3135071099,
0.2466244549,
0.9297683835,
-0.7578436136,
-0.2550331652,
-0.9214421511,
0.6403446794,
-0.221755445,
-0.1401213259,
0.0623972043,
0.7503350973,
0.8868566155,
-0.02285113,
0.6696023941,
-0.3923200071,
0.3648461103,
-0.5453395844,
0.4058480263,
-0.4180160761,
0.4447895885,
0.1917737126,
-0.9562420845,
-0.5461066961,
0.5294781327,
-0.1977144331,
-0.3528656662,
0.4719187021,
0.668377161,
-0.5860962868,
-0.1679029316,
0.3217305541,
-0.4834585488,
0.3872114122,
0.4162223637,
0.7739213705,
-0.4501242042,
0.3211480379,
0.1820564866,
0.1604759544,
-0.0679014176,
-0.7452061772,
-0.8977896571,
-0.4344658256,
-0.3684345186,
-0.1329960078,
0.1145965084,
0.9033434987,
0.8516895771,
-1.0875917673,
-0.091659233,
-0.2843469381,
-0.0948808864,
0.0721023679,
-0.2701704204,
0.2218204141,
-0.1598405391,
-0.6003751159,
0.4957235157,
0.2792315781,
-0.1356111169,
0.2085597217,
0.0412479565,
0.0420505293,
0.001830349,
0.4821822047,
0.6355230808,
-0.8852995634,
-0.1038516238,
-0.5111072659,
0.2324755192,
0.2657213509,
1.2348185778,
-0.7428968549,
0.4506242573,
0.0137248896,
1.2043344975,
0.3736360669,
0.0810059533,
0.7386434078,
-0.5939140916,
0.2079676092,
0.5332144499,
0.7268038392,
0.0977743715,
-0.491235137,
0.6109995246,
0.1596235037,
-0.0812009424,
-0.7785010338,
0.2277913392,
-0.519171536,
-0.1477006376,
0.7774003744,
-0.5429368019,
0.0066196537,
-0.6616621017,
0.0551076829,
0.32281515,
-0.2949578166,
1.0502603054,
0.7215087414,
-0.2465192825,
-0.453171432,
-1.0949919224,
0.353174746,
0.2974179089,
-0.7997127175,
-0.3513919711,
0.1694657952,
0.3862522542,
0.3060570657,
0.6945073009,
-0.3128766119,
0.0329519808,
-0.4256702662,
0.1280206591,
0.2422840595,
-0.6551254392,
-0.4569498599,
0.4088953435,
-0.4152040184,
0.1675002724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15525v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15525v1 | Large Language Models are Few-Shot Health Learners | 2023-05-24T19:25:16 | 2023-05-24T19:25:16 | Xin Liu, Daniel McDuff, Geza Kovacs, Isaac Galatzer-Levy, Jacob Sunshine, Jiening Zhan, Ming-Zher Poh, Shun Liao, Paolo Di Achille, Shwetak Patel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) can capture rich representations of concepts
that are useful for real-world tasks. However, language alone is limited. While
existing LLMs excel at text-based inferences, health applications require that
models be grounded in numerical data (e.g., vital signs, laboratory values in
clinical domains; steps, movement in the wellness domain) that is not easily or
readily expressed as text in existing training corpus. We demonstrate that with
only few-shot tuning, a large language model is capable of grounding various
physiological and behavioral time-series data and making meaningful inferences
on numerous health tasks for both clinical and wellness contexts. Using data
from wearable and medical sensor recordings, we evaluate these capabilities on
the tasks of cardiac signal analysis, physical activity recognition, metabolic
calculation (e.g., calories burned), and estimation of stress reports and
mental health screeners. | [
0.2123294473,
-0.7879989147,
0.79904145,
0.0904476419,
-0.0128821637,
-0.1860156804,
-0.4075787365,
-0.5076535344,
0.1705694199,
0.4482715726,
-0.4295507967,
-0.6562480927,
-0.5229003429,
-0.118099913,
-0.1912493855,
1.0190868378,
0.3405002654,
0.3105930388,
-0.0536144078,
-0.1616763622,
-0.3492860794,
-0.5098324418,
-0.5326164365,
-0.8162895441,
0.5997841954,
0.2593766153,
0.5338677764,
0.4467963576,
0.4986877441,
0.1341927052,
0.0620383509,
-0.0250637475,
-0.5230389833,
0.0281598307,
-0.1136188433,
-0.4425957203,
-0.5276176333,
-0.1386482716,
0.7032285929,
1.0098547935,
0.1491932869,
0.3822411001,
-0.1562650353,
0.6332702041,
-0.4465997815,
0.3025153577,
-0.1788631678,
-0.0419837572,
-0.1254455745,
0.0123341912,
-0.4107375443,
-0.0147686657,
0.0915254578,
-0.3251031339,
-0.1475461721,
-0.1398804933,
0.6380742192,
0.5761118531,
-0.6424784064,
-0.0103843221,
-0.8968997598,
0.7378946543,
-0.9044994116,
0.6392319202,
0.8147505522,
0.056608811,
-0.1657098681,
-0.331453383,
-0.2871134281,
-0.3004070818,
0.0111115547,
0.0165891517,
0.0147309238,
0.2207761705,
0.4073125422,
0.1760737002,
-0.5285083055,
0.3013396263,
-0.1473017335,
0.0635060146,
0.713930428,
0.3723151386,
0.4135546386,
-0.3217899799,
0.2292202562,
0.0076667559,
-0.5791680813,
0.0517524332,
-0.311006695,
0.4422208667,
-0.7157742381,
0.774944067,
-0.0805205628,
0.7828225493,
-0.1670927554,
-0.9080462456,
0.2594192326,
-0.0411420316,
-0.5293998718,
-0.0028339804,
0.6610620022,
0.3246738911,
0.0964436904,
-0.4275826514,
-0.0346875712,
0.1563664526,
0.1429725885,
-0.8255249858,
-0.2038134187,
0.4364030957,
-0.4074963331,
0.0045554871,
-0.2771015763,
-0.7254142165,
-0.6037710309,
-0.4129397571,
0.1251268685,
-0.4309846461,
-0.2815063596,
0.3686177433,
0.0435270704,
0.1417982429,
0.0400820114,
-0.8761906028,
0.4420314729,
0.7008485198,
0.955437839,
-0.0912249684,
0.043684721,
-0.4178889096,
0.134685114,
-0.3793055415,
0.5908358693,
-0.5938559771,
-0.4531115592,
-0.1109068692,
0.1185346618,
-0.1855284125,
-0.413962841,
0.4006337523,
-0.3148687184,
-0.2608658075,
-0.2091784924,
-0.5823559761,
0.1841368675,
0.2390326262,
-0.6049141884,
0.8973449469,
0.0136109535,
-0.680234313,
0.3606723845,
-0.5290060639,
-0.8476330042,
0.0047068535,
-0.271535337,
-0.4715645015,
0.297706157,
-0.1231253818,
0.6737194657,
-0.4166538119,
0.3249348104,
-0.5154423714,
-0.2786875069,
0.4515949786,
-0.4245124459,
0.4087892771,
0.092637226,
-0.1750804782,
-0.1200061664,
-0.9907016158,
0.0438962206,
0.039636571,
-0.618473649,
-0.5041911006,
0.3495228887,
0.2496133447,
0.1608574539,
-0.0234625153,
-0.5282992721,
0.0909276083,
-0.4846334457,
0.5068627596,
0.1351353824,
-0.0338789597,
0.274228543,
-0.5135473013,
0.4937942624,
-0.1907493919,
-0.2223855108,
-0.1710438579,
-0.3833537102,
-0.3048935831,
-0.757375896,
0.0068700104,
0.737179935,
-0.3008113205,
0.4113341868,
-0.6861155629,
-0.6085557342,
-0.2856057584,
0.1023476124,
0.2484986335,
0.696146965,
0.2581560612,
0.1828334332,
-0.2947880626,
-0.4402005672,
-0.2039539814,
-0.092840381,
-0.1055512205,
0.3385799229,
0.4319272935,
-0.5137584805,
0.6620742083,
-0.5219311714,
-0.0251990035,
-0.3653382659,
0.0114866709,
0.2587125003,
0.4696202278,
0.6331614256,
-0.5332667828,
-0.0515898466,
0.1306249052,
-0.9817281961,
-0.0767146349,
-0.0713182539,
0.0634104237,
-0.3282650709,
0.3994735181,
-0.6587318182,
0.2799327374,
0.7753593326,
-0.2775010169,
0.3411647081,
-0.1189221963,
-0.0492848754,
-0.9972871542,
0.3510522544,
0.3252826333,
-0.4953230321,
-0.7797498107,
-0.0517641418,
-0.0285143331,
-0.4503002167,
-0.3306914866,
1.0407050848,
-0.1588606536,
0.1580885202,
-0.591996491,
-0.3906608224,
-0.0141722504,
0.0427205935,
0.3059329391,
0.3097182214,
0.6372837424,
-0.7752070427,
0.2185722739,
0.0245668832,
-0.4455647767,
0.4672665,
-0.8695056438,
-0.0817860365,
-0.2808543444,
0.1168398559,
-0.8043096066,
-0.9576600194,
-0.1041635871,
-0.2613688111,
0.3785908818,
-0.0818182379,
-0.4962272048,
-0.4408861101,
-0.0285536684,
0.4807629287,
0.5683705807,
-0.2208039314,
0.3701147735,
0.6802556515,
0.0735426471,
-0.1082585379,
-1.0279117823,
-0.1971953362,
-0.4201132357,
-0.3734928071,
0.0775416791,
0.0604701862,
-0.4120610654,
-0.1977272481,
-0.1803465486,
-0.2892462909,
0.2707457542,
0.6451568007,
0.3552211225,
-0.2096167654,
0.8268812299,
-0.1293403506,
-0.0186959282,
0.0550105385,
-0.3586378992,
0.2730973363,
0.0555457585,
-0.5369954705,
-0.3982669115,
0.4250043929,
0.8681302071,
-0.1006405205,
0.9456403852,
0.3028401732,
-0.9349038005,
0.0310710371,
-0.3888125122,
-0.1240830272,
-0.3562019765,
0.4638646543,
-0.0422394872,
-0.7961196303,
0.3019354939,
-0.127827242,
0.0184983443,
0.1783029288,
0.6698051095,
-0.12488015,
1.0727087259,
0.5534837842,
-0.2697445452,
0.3802549541,
-0.0462903231,
0.3082450628,
-0.674012959,
-0.0881417096,
-0.4728114903,
-0.3032595515,
-0.5659261346,
-0.3314614594,
0.7988414764,
-0.1958156824,
-0.6117124557,
-0.1951084435,
-0.2325716615,
0.2846776843,
0.2583626211,
0.66585356,
0.1204505563,
-0.055108469,
0.0389426872,
-0.2938655317,
-0.6498135328,
-0.5744291544,
0.9740728736,
0.4972232282,
1.3914868832,
0.0184619706,
0.4599603713,
0.0125968801,
0.5029170513,
-1.2246586084,
0.1073055267,
-0.4340987802,
-0.6951600909,
-0.3661598563,
-0.3115441203,
-0.8927245736,
0.0447442159,
-0.4105817676,
-0.8425215483,
-0.077377677,
0.4454056621,
-0.6606144905,
0.2147308886,
-0.768283844,
0.831620276,
-0.5800582767,
-0.5896804929,
-0.0600916408,
-0.4597358406,
0.4887244999,
-0.3359903991,
0.5321726203,
-0.4617114961,
0.1514383405,
0.6291617155,
-0.311614126,
1.3182188272,
0.0719359219,
-0.0647077337,
0.0919763446,
-0.1190161407,
0.1967850775,
0.2006192356,
-0.2571719587,
0.0581481978,
0.3815155923,
-0.5139278769,
-0.424215436,
0.790612042,
-0.6608560085,
-0.2680110335,
-0.4810526967,
-0.393889755,
-0.740901947,
0.2655954361,
0.1177350357,
0.5240472555,
-0.3344264328,
0.212026149,
0.7160809636,
-0.3123705089,
0.1326935589,
0.5273852348,
-0.0721924007,
-0.0573336296,
0.7265115976,
-0.1680143028,
0.2967377603,
0.5131548643,
0.570083797,
-0.1095229462,
-0.2329712063,
-0.099380441,
0.6465728283,
-0.5567718148,
-0.1335444748,
-0.6414414048,
0.0598349981,
-0.4294671118,
-0.1759031564,
-0.4596685767,
0.0009155583,
-0.2516065538,
-0.1894586384,
0.5897894502,
0.6980174184,
-0.139214471,
0.3891981542,
-1.0251668692,
0.6967434883,
0.4411097765,
0.4197372198,
-0.0230662338,
-0.3586381376,
-0.4789501429,
0.1846338362,
0.0264068153,
-0.9282674193,
0.3514725268,
0.4636103213,
0.3599702418,
0.4130163491,
-0.2070406973,
0.7173702121,
-0.6847204566,
0.7911584377,
0.3273305297,
-0.786439836,
0.700802505,
-0.376188755,
0.6429712772,
0.5633177161,
0.4491924345,
-0.7636891007,
0.072239615,
-0.2905661166,
-0.504769206,
0.3191928267,
-0.2625360191,
0.263365984,
-0.3797810972,
0.4653054774,
-0.2604883611,
0.1268463582,
-0.6820604205,
-0.0379596092,
-0.1423648298,
-0.5112906098,
-0.2194226533,
-0.003694779,
-0.235254854,
-0.4476305842,
0.4020684958,
-0.4478437304,
0.2394358814,
0.1937318742,
-0.0872591808,
-0.2430799007,
0.3444809914,
0.4645288885,
0.3369532228,
-0.0587606616,
0.415702343,
0.1363161951,
-0.4547351599,
0.2882010639,
-0.0945081264,
0.0026173664,
-0.0159228481,
0.7919555306,
0.728800714,
0.7866926193,
-1.2063992023,
0.3801924288,
0.2510840595,
0.2726842165,
-0.0815063715,
0.1616279781,
0.3742878139,
0.184687525,
-0.137098521,
-0.2426574826,
-0.0596955344,
-0.6940934062,
0.1638963521,
0.5044634938,
-0.3840356171,
-0.60159266,
0.8085438013,
0.1332476735,
0.0066017723,
0.4048493207,
0.1015506014,
-0.1153832898,
0.5588175654,
0.63156569,
0.5048939586,
-0.2203444242,
0.0580106862,
0.5092427731,
0.1872394532,
-0.4929579496,
0.319091171,
0.2443654686,
-0.6695695519,
-0.6671246886,
-0.7667963505,
-0.2705043852,
0.3933237493,
-0.7402229309,
0.2858336568,
-0.4391682744,
-0.4869085848,
0.2950597405,
-0.2452325225,
-1.0363987684,
0.5982862115,
0.483003974,
0.6789518595,
-1.1431127787,
0.9024716616,
0.7781843543,
-0.1916825622,
-0.7602217197,
-0.1138822511,
0.161582768,
-0.8819510341,
0.8606455326,
0.0169180203,
-0.1067934409,
-0.2403642386,
-0.6592897177,
-0.7407572865,
0.5674297214,
0.6881133318,
-0.6368521452,
-0.3627410233,
0.1837810427,
0.7993885279,
-0.1369713247,
0.0361175835,
0.6312353611,
0.4178754687,
-0.1429771632,
-1.0675911903,
-0.1935266703,
-0.068707794,
-0.2226064652,
-0.0224624835,
-0.6629538536,
0.6816644073,
-0.364895016,
-0.0049905782,
-0.234238565,
0.2591562271,
0.245435074,
0.3924284577,
0.1576104611,
0.5305925012,
0.9756885767,
0.107497327,
1.5017814636,
-0.321467489,
0.4232888222,
1.2104762793,
-0.4937814474,
0.7841156721,
0.0920228139,
-0.213467598,
0.1796350628,
0.5907168984,
0.3135435581,
0.4349694848,
0.2520344257,
-0.5540844202,
-0.6141550541,
-0.0616823211,
-0.1830720603,
0.5201202035,
0.8472783566,
-0.5705761909,
-0.0823491365,
0.3157543242,
0.1993554831,
-0.0804434866,
-0.2893894613,
0.6426830888,
0.528159976,
-0.4385459125,
0.5774478912,
-0.0892159045,
0.2998223007,
-0.7716531157,
-0.0605032481,
0.1475498676,
0.0550511405,
-0.2160060853,
-0.3993576169,
0.3350250423,
0.2039633393,
-0.2700174749,
-0.1185875759,
0.8124656677,
-0.2252977937,
-0.7389529347,
0.1496376097,
0.6197767258,
0.199500531,
-0.1002998427,
-0.2472182959,
0.0435300954,
-0.4351839423,
-0.2335514873,
0.1760498732,
0.3772176504,
0.0620678924,
0.673050642,
0.3783880174,
0.4804753959,
-0.0021521489,
-0.0105190203,
0.5358886123,
-0.9784006476,
-0.3704787195,
-0.8895837665,
0.1537888944,
0.2571133375,
-0.2677251399,
0.3821965754,
0.3390364051,
0.2758518755,
-0.0898442343,
1.0817933083,
0.2361226827,
0.6393449903,
-0.7435172796,
0.577483654,
-0.592859149,
-0.0845845267,
0.0294512119,
-0.3420764208,
-0.5505495071,
0.7628638744,
-0.4829537272,
-0.1083502695,
0.7081480622,
0.282415092,
-0.0729874894,
-0.3026022315,
0.5205407739,
0.1464352757,
0.3143487275,
0.6532876492,
0.2947018743,
-0.1217606068,
-0.2529794872,
0.1049548909,
-0.1839354187,
-0.310457617,
-0.8754068613,
-1.2277251482,
-0.1500008106,
-0.3196521401,
-0.3038651347,
-0.1118414104,
1.2382333279,
1.0992679596,
-0.7788345218,
-0.0135958837,
0.1679749936,
-0.1434609443,
-0.152405411,
-0.1568240672,
0.1964084208,
-0.1067445949,
-0.5839805603,
0.6591509581,
0.3566127717,
0.2081253827,
-0.2273434401,
0.1647847593,
0.1349014342,
0.1065544486,
0.8530098796,
0.6673249602,
-0.5872272849,
-0.3292032778,
0.099104315,
-0.3084188402,
0.0874364972,
0.9595099092,
-0.7169654965,
0.3455708623,
0.3189071119,
0.920896709,
0.3888383806,
-0.1303362995,
0.2563064992,
-0.7608475685,
0.47377038,
0.284565866,
0.4929657876,
0.469027102,
-0.3621626794,
0.3587537408,
0.2296652496,
-0.446595192,
-0.6484180093,
0.1499719769,
-1.0298267603,
-0.1661334634,
1.3909728527,
0.064352192,
-0.3756964505,
-0.0671389326,
0.0377232954,
0.235624209,
-0.1278452128,
0.7007632256,
0.7978438139,
-0.3099980652,
0.0281037055,
-1.0662503242,
0.4274462759,
0.3298832774,
-1.1728432178,
-0.1211823672,
0.5058652163,
0.5146428347,
-0.0017564396,
0.7597145438,
0.0978687033,
0.1825550199,
-0.2150119096,
-0.1680162847,
0.4386402965,
0.0039598979,
-0.3438671231,
-0.1212591827,
0.2192452848,
0.0055921311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15520v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15520v1 | Exploring Automatically Perturbed Natural Language Explanations in Relation Extraction | 2023-05-24T19:17:13 | 2023-05-24T19:17:13 | Wanyun Cui, Xingran Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous research has demonstrated that natural language explanations provide
valuable inductive biases that guide models, thereby improving the
generalization ability and data efficiency. In this paper, we undertake a
systematic examination of the effectiveness of these explanations. Remarkably,
we find that corrupted explanations with diminished inductive biases can
achieve competitive or superior performance compared to the original
explanations. Our findings furnish novel insights into the characteristics of
natural language explanations in the following ways: (1) the impact of
explanations varies across different training styles and datasets, with
previously believed improvements primarily observed in frozen language models.
(2) While previous research has attributed the effect of explanations solely to
their inductive biases, our study shows that the effect persists even when the
explanations are completely corrupted. We propose that the main effect is due
to the provision of additional context space. (3) Utilizing the proposed
automatic perturbed context, we were able to attain comparable results to
annotated explanations, but with a significant increase in computational
efficiency, 20-30 times faster. | [
-0.4379167557,
-1.0660401583,
0.6885766983,
0.2094227523,
-0.5057016015,
-0.4043914676,
-0.3949818611,
-0.5469867587,
-0.1172305346,
0.4963175952,
-0.7446981072,
-0.1665310562,
-0.5079351068,
0.585426271,
-0.3815371692,
0.9794978499,
-0.1057021767,
0.0875601023,
-0.3017953038,
0.0970472917,
-0.6116566658,
-0.5006603003,
-0.3817395568,
-0.7028098702,
0.4389984906,
0.4045407474,
1.2743741274,
1.0209242105,
0.3866052032,
0.2643700838,
-0.1200116128,
-0.0485227816,
-0.4278876483,
0.4073647857,
-0.0981936082,
-0.1818188131,
-0.181016475,
0.1489114612,
0.531799674,
0.8818778992,
-0.011737355,
-0.191983968,
0.021096332,
0.5893717408,
-0.6520195007,
0.1839827448,
-0.7942294478,
0.0634517223,
-0.2358433008,
-0.5740169883,
-0.3792006671,
-0.2334508896,
0.4654611051,
-0.6239856482,
0.5218701363,
-0.1478438526,
1.2157582045,
0.5301974416,
-0.3322116733,
-0.5012342334,
-1.0245860815,
0.6902350187,
-0.7235975266,
0.3458302319,
0.3603093326,
0.3468062878,
-0.5232751369,
-0.5758061409,
-0.4721529782,
-0.1156663373,
-0.430301398,
0.0381646492,
-0.1249060482,
0.2042974532,
0.5119895935,
0.5946143866,
-0.2527016103,
0.0618240424,
0.0892011002,
-0.2406497002,
0.789177835,
0.1268273741,
0.447268486,
-0.2995426953,
-0.2612452507,
0.1333051771,
-0.7692664266,
0.0659999102,
0.5045959353,
0.2767637074,
-0.0215226002,
0.353726536,
0.0274567269,
0.807218492,
-0.008820287,
0.1972430497,
-0.1476617903,
-0.39453426,
-0.3778029978,
0.1291240007,
0.9982152581,
-0.0068008984,
0.5260182619,
-0.6308194399,
-0.0670575052,
0.0264647044,
0.0497885421,
-0.6458564401,
-0.6275389791,
0.0951823518,
-0.3156384528,
-0.1319267005,
0.1963030249,
-1.0333760977,
-0.468976289,
-0.3234441578,
0.0602167659,
-0.4880796075,
-0.3301422,
0.0162415076,
-0.3246980309,
0.0970226899,
0.3634393513,
-1.157682538,
0.2892152965,
0.5509727001,
0.3851100504,
-0.0899944752,
0.0049622753,
-0.6136038899,
-0.2297554016,
-0.3332762122,
0.9870443344,
-0.7798303366,
-0.130544886,
0.076028429,
-0.1021084115,
0.1364953071,
-0.7226611972,
0.5457220674,
-0.7410616279,
0.3692204654,
-0.5368919969,
-0.4236280024,
-0.2450253218,
-0.0809197649,
-0.7655970454,
0.8890121579,
-0.1766777337,
-0.9338798523,
0.6629647017,
-0.6806797385,
-0.611567378,
-0.1522374153,
-0.1423368454,
-0.3123328686,
0.0592914298,
0.5742744803,
0.3383309543,
-0.4925231934,
0.2722125053,
-0.3988928795,
-0.3545612693,
0.547503829,
-0.4572018087,
1.1546754837,
0.1246967688,
-0.539183259,
-0.1422903091,
-0.6962983012,
-0.3606842458,
0.3988961577,
-0.2968014181,
-0.5764308572,
0.1614915282,
-0.4238267541,
0.0558777526,
-0.1086862907,
-0.335911721,
-0.0502050258,
-0.7387072444,
0.218037039,
0.5859873891,
0.4443871975,
0.6357955933,
0.250069499,
0.7187271118,
0.0138727436,
0.0040429384,
-0.4089565873,
-0.3478185236,
-0.3488566875,
-0.2472777367,
0.3474478126,
0.1383988559,
-0.4825920463,
0.07782913,
-0.1292817444,
0.0117809428,
-0.4822566807,
0.294578582,
0.3753431737,
0.7688451409,
0.3682784736,
0.0030787927,
-0.7813161016,
-1.0156747103,
-0.8494558334,
0.089283146,
-0.1608301252,
0.2644746304,
0.2456918508,
-0.2445659935,
1.3453712463,
-0.2708236873,
0.1418905258,
0.0590128787,
0.1232189909,
0.4355991781,
0.1622316688,
0.3827102184,
-0.9176965356,
-0.5564113855,
-0.3195814192,
-0.7341349721,
-0.2896893322,
-0.3377051353,
-0.2689870894,
0.037999928,
0.4242324531,
-0.5098981261,
0.545278132,
0.2657374442,
-0.2307426184,
0.8667302728,
0.099557355,
-0.2630585134,
-0.5604764819,
-0.1731558144,
0.1223951653,
-0.2135714442,
-0.6115213037,
-0.042875018,
-0.0664412677,
0.3186216652,
0.0095551852,
0.2025292665,
-0.9079917073,
0.1015316397,
-0.073552303,
0.4887862802,
-0.0540613756,
0.1834626347,
-0.2043082416,
0.6137014031,
0.5155337453,
-0.9473848343,
0.3704520762,
0.3287022412,
0.2724497914,
-0.0162757058,
-0.5353249311,
0.281739682,
-0.3197990954,
0.2210463583,
-1.2254246473,
-0.5026599765,
0.2866565883,
-0.5952160954,
0.3847611845,
-0.4528260529,
-0.4996863008,
-0.1293103993,
-0.3334563673,
0.0757811442,
0.1588889211,
-0.8958739042,
0.555146277,
0.2351492941,
0.2421703041,
-0.6600607038,
-0.6324916482,
0.1714721024,
-0.3863318264,
-0.573702991,
0.4000155032,
-0.0036394431,
-0.718565166,
0.1068477482,
-0.424364984,
-0.1308940202,
0.4714359343,
0.3524454534,
0.3050841689,
-0.335326761,
0.4497275054,
0.0343889259,
-0.1424372494,
0.518712163,
0.1794611067,
0.4302482009,
0.082135506,
0.2357923537,
-0.4954250157,
0.0619149618,
0.5500794649,
-0.1061884239,
0.9384123683,
0.2619955838,
-0.3688795865,
0.0590633936,
-0.6051862836,
-0.5026782155,
-0.4780209363,
-0.0424825288,
-0.4993939996,
-0.4801824987,
0.7507487535,
0.0312531926,
0.2208738029,
0.7245387435,
0.1316854805,
0.0884553567,
1.2987169027,
0.4766528308,
-0.0840178877,
0.4811315238,
-0.0683428794,
0.4063007534,
-0.7452862859,
-0.1790193468,
-0.6618289948,
0.1725972742,
-0.774892807,
0.1211574674,
0.0340089053,
0.2931204736,
-0.0897682384,
0.2244438827,
-0.513787806,
0.4185079038,
0.1561305672,
-0.2600519657,
0.5608528852,
0.1819443852,
-0.1987786144,
-0.3058565557,
-0.814548552,
-0.5486637354,
0.7708047032,
0.3977897763,
0.7053566575,
-0.0712415427,
0.6441608071,
-0.1390110403,
0.5905823112,
-0.7254104614,
0.04523715,
0.0006873278,
-0.8426911235,
-0.562258184,
-0.4599246979,
-1.084036231,
0.3571694791,
-0.3785011172,
-0.9224907756,
0.1485209018,
0.4644418359,
-0.2755823433,
-0.0737991408,
-0.7442380786,
0.6989739537,
-0.1308973134,
-0.540256083,
0.0535328723,
-0.5679243803,
0.6895445585,
0.1398525983,
0.3623515069,
-0.0276241954,
0.2621956766,
0.7061821818,
-0.6268200874,
0.3588840067,
-0.305088371,
-0.2170294374,
-0.0376445055,
0.2498049885,
0.5791355968,
0.2435941696,
-0.480613023,
0.0000351784,
-0.3532772362,
-0.2994792759,
-1.0046622753,
0.5613838434,
-0.4539384842,
-0.7607089877,
-0.0386521742,
-0.4788045287,
-0.2519605458,
0.0385147296,
0.4120486081,
0.5531485677,
0.1158634201,
0.115343973,
0.7150707245,
-0.338290751,
0.4828224778,
0.4201977253,
-0.1536664665,
-0.1764128208,
0.3505544066,
-0.0699143633,
-0.0260398891,
0.2462434024,
0.4998968244,
-0.2824518979,
-0.461717993,
-0.4224722683,
0.436632067,
-0.6795733571,
-0.1156224385,
-0.7644121051,
0.1258788556,
-0.493935734,
0.0326566137,
-0.2413304895,
-0.223239392,
-0.4854176342,
-0.1950136423,
0.3982750475,
0.754283905,
0.1210952774,
0.152783826,
-0.5806950331,
0.3957893848,
0.255374223,
0.4275155962,
0.264785111,
-0.5228677392,
-0.1613727808,
0.0534579866,
0.0407505892,
-1.3919426203,
0.3773445487,
0.1699498147,
0.5590833426,
0.7617074847,
0.1820648015,
1.1485288143,
-0.2821075618,
0.6847047806,
-0.0977723598,
-0.8015347719,
0.6542540193,
-0.3613621294,
0.4818842113,
0.506916225,
0.4868526459,
-0.3737550676,
-0.6104541421,
-0.7401218414,
-1.1597745419,
0.8696493506,
0.1114592403,
0.1793080121,
0.0633172989,
0.9821816683,
0.2938182354,
-0.126614511,
-0.6322738528,
-0.5831835866,
-0.1035441682,
0.2971058786,
0.1065783501,
-0.666204989,
-0.0366951823,
-0.2204364538,
0.7791829705,
0.1267686039,
0.2921879888,
0.7062125802,
-0.3906958401,
-0.6119815111,
0.1306936592,
0.4847838283,
0.9016007185,
-0.076588653,
0.3278900683,
0.0346303992,
-0.2263599783,
-0.306018889,
0.4863102436,
0.1293364167,
0.3700937629,
0.71128124,
0.6576155424,
0.1378827542,
-0.390626967,
0.2852828801,
-0.3919126689,
-0.074770689,
-0.4192432761,
-0.0049623572,
-0.0471266396,
-0.1392817348,
0.7128921747,
-0.2404668629,
0.3448879421,
-0.6635385752,
0.2048686594,
0.6761108041,
-0.4668980241,
-0.5109242797,
0.7739294171,
-0.0162876602,
-0.4340967238,
0.7644225359,
-0.0016945957,
-0.7451350093,
0.3950187266,
0.5416074991,
0.7327193022,
-0.1108182296,
0.0722725019,
0.3251150548,
0.3867180347,
0.214737013,
-0.2714454532,
-0.3801967204,
-0.8312200904,
-0.733112216,
-0.4026867449,
-0.3442149162,
0.4869203568,
-0.7432681322,
0.0171108544,
-0.3542677462,
0.0945496485,
0.4405843914,
-0.0346681587,
-0.688164711,
0.2135214508,
-0.0307560731,
0.81268543,
-0.8548049331,
0.5904866457,
0.8400684595,
-0.5587843657,
-1.1854668856,
0.4265481532,
0.0724723861,
-0.4324377179,
0.5737169385,
0.074528113,
-0.2073702067,
-0.4059748352,
-0.642311275,
-0.8874602914,
0.5261535048,
0.7781406045,
-0.3847832382,
0.0579200462,
-0.0511191897,
0.9102250338,
-0.179690823,
0.271081835,
1.0427320004,
0.5936937332,
-0.2102699578,
-0.7284289598,
0.4540313184,
-0.2492594719,
-0.1238755658,
0.3177697361,
-0.0139854522,
0.545537591,
0.0217030924,
-0.4394687116,
-0.1974075884,
0.5011795759,
-0.2906521261,
0.1489788592,
0.6266580224,
0.155733034,
0.7221698761,
-0.1158994809,
1.396735549,
-0.2179798037,
0.3174532354,
1.1010710001,
0.0575689934,
0.2582146525,
0.6788076162,
-0.0434134714,
0.9634795189,
0.7340196371,
0.2541864216,
0.3186097741,
0.0098019438,
-0.0299893748,
-0.2739847302,
0.0877118185,
-0.0208259095,
0.4360817075,
0.314907074,
-0.7035937905,
-0.3218774796,
-0.1050066799,
0.2636470199,
0.2239701599,
0.1212594509,
0.7860763669,
0.0354087017,
-1.02716434,
0.837012887,
-0.2355306894,
0.3794552386,
-0.25770244,
-0.2046718448,
-0.2843617499,
0.1002893671,
-0.5300206542,
-0.3359444737,
0.3281927109,
0.0266123023,
-0.187838763,
-0.3376349807,
0.8977679014,
-0.4116571248,
0.163306132,
0.4336849749,
0.1602663696,
0.1676907539,
-0.2476480156,
-0.5510111451,
-0.0991248116,
0.0878203139,
-0.4069315493,
0.061621327,
0.5852134824,
0.013204488,
0.395536691,
0.5007565022,
0.0879582837,
-0.08539249,
-0.0715078264,
0.9001050591,
-0.591288507,
-0.1521092951,
-1.3214776516,
0.677384913,
-0.3077482581,
-0.1893123239,
0.9755792618,
0.521710217,
0.4974961281,
0.0821095333,
0.6092671156,
0.175595507,
0.502281785,
-0.5564406514,
0.3581738472,
-0.3601276278,
0.6967422366,
-0.5001687407,
-0.9335905313,
-0.5217337608,
0.5565464497,
-0.5740664601,
-0.2361025512,
1.0129292011,
0.5451546907,
-0.0101461066,
0.2302970588,
-0.0483728386,
0.6086038351,
0.3725863099,
-0.2076678425,
0.6531547308,
-0.3773402572,
0.6774489284,
-0.449855715,
-0.2198946178,
-0.2654760182,
-1.0772670507,
-0.7506251335,
-0.467454344,
-0.4375753701,
-0.3926939368,
0.1423999965,
0.7937742472,
0.5837419629,
-0.7433691621,
-0.0541183576,
-0.4867542684,
0.5715532899,
-0.1436171532,
-0.3847950399,
0.2791424096,
-0.6102965474,
-0.4862782955,
0.4608454704,
0.285759896,
-0.2605749965,
-0.1527777761,
0.0848412737,
-0.2067890167,
-0.0197000932,
0.4197386205,
0.2573425174,
-0.728977561,
-0.2741137743,
-0.1425779611,
0.2291217595,
0.4385021627,
1.111323595,
-0.9286249876,
0.7898920774,
0.4809624255,
0.318549782,
0.5760278106,
0.1967258453,
1.164943099,
-0.576218307,
0.0285234954,
0.1916007996,
0.2178092897,
0.4924859703,
-0.8346452713,
0.468350172,
0.0805797726,
-0.3969249129,
-0.9319493175,
0.1237342805,
-0.4375405908,
-0.1756365746,
1.3249922991,
-0.1487918943,
-0.0881244987,
-0.3982041776,
-0.0786650106,
0.6619166136,
-0.6164736152,
1.1485108137,
0.7846221328,
-0.4048132896,
-0.0769188255,
-0.5530174375,
0.907684207,
0.5360520482,
-0.6690841913,
0.4214449823,
0.5666059852,
0.2746703923,
0.1032068059,
0.2758060992,
-0.3403156698,
0.4855370522,
-0.278718859,
-0.2748799622,
0.1098702624,
-0.0670652464,
-0.8525844812,
-0.0173490662,
0.201567784,
0.1223791316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15516v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15516v1 | Free Lunch for Efficient Textual Commonsense Integration in Language Models | 2023-05-24T19:14:57 | 2023-05-24T19:14:57 | Wanyun Cui, Xingran Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent years have witnessed the emergence of textual commonsense knowledge
bases, aimed at providing more nuanced and context-rich knowledge. The
integration of external commonsense into language models has been shown to be a
key enabler in advancing the state-of-the-art for a wide range of NLP tasks.
However, incorporating textual commonsense descriptions is computationally
expensive, as compared to encoding conventional symbolic knowledge. In this
paper, we propose a method to improve its efficiency without modifying the
model. We group training samples with similar commonsense descriptions into a
single batch, thus reusing the encoded description across multiple samples. One
key observation is that the upper bound of batch partitioning can be reduced to
the classic {\it graph k-cut problem}. Consequently, we propose a spectral
clustering-based algorithm to solve this problem. Extensive experiments
illustrate that the proposed batch partitioning approach effectively reduces
the computational cost while preserving performance. The efficiency improvement
is more pronounced on larger datasets and on devices with more memory capacity,
attesting to its practical utility for large-scale applications. | [
-0.3961632848,
-0.2512311339,
0.6281219721,
0.1074262708,
-0.4576593041,
-0.1203424484,
-0.4498094618,
-0.264367193,
0.1820399612,
0.6220345497,
-0.36173594,
-0.6018670201,
-0.5856460333,
-0.1203930974,
-0.4918193817,
0.7640196681,
0.1692925692,
-0.0375657789,
-0.4548346996,
-0.317165792,
-0.6175548434,
-0.3026505709,
-0.5237208009,
-0.0604227781,
0.6650152206,
0.2886736393,
0.3658433259,
0.9082974195,
0.5199090242,
0.3438943028,
-0.1136446744,
0.3281784356,
-0.416987747,
-0.0059751323,
-0.2128457278,
-0.3019559085,
-0.148617655,
-0.0408323668,
0.9302192926,
0.8302286267,
-0.1352797747,
-0.0472264253,
0.113853097,
0.567581892,
-0.8377737999,
0.0835621133,
-0.8264704347,
-0.0292997658,
-0.177224502,
0.0353665315,
-0.6479291916,
-0.3682205677,
-0.0331140943,
-0.8391960263,
0.2292402834,
-0.1096117869,
0.6909617186,
0.4041109681,
-0.3254989088,
-0.0848976672,
-0.2710202932,
1.035384655,
-0.8619365096,
0.550391674,
0.3708483279,
0.3205785751,
0.0362982377,
-0.8220971823,
-0.6599521041,
-0.0031910907,
-0.4873102605,
-0.1693191975,
-0.3214789033,
0.0637877211,
-0.1938048601,
0.2388789505,
-0.3413710296,
0.18539612,
-0.5007174611,
-0.015976619,
0.4944653213,
0.1487118006,
0.341507405,
-0.1140723377,
-0.3761896193,
-0.2200680524,
-0.2762259841,
-0.4041438699,
0.1554272771,
0.7723878622,
0.0643347651,
0.3964790702,
-0.0547476225,
0.5490632057,
-0.1813774556,
-0.006122719,
0.2399378121,
-0.3867201805,
-0.1576653123,
0.1101000682,
0.6226981878,
0.3883605301,
0.0677597001,
-0.4332531691,
-0.0604114942,
0.1796411872,
0.3341330886,
-0.8776413798,
-0.2170472145,
0.5008188486,
-0.2988505363,
-0.2635367215,
-0.4061884284,
-0.8937349319,
-0.4952603579,
-0.3560979068,
0.0975732878,
-0.5503844619,
-0.2923514545,
-0.0834876001,
-0.4751099646,
-0.0989942253,
0.1931772828,
-1.0064888,
0.5745285153,
0.9073491693,
0.9886546731,
-0.2807143927,
-0.2076563984,
-0.6150608063,
0.2958880961,
-0.1634322405,
0.7494785786,
-0.678224206,
-0.4227811098,
-0.2753593922,
-0.0883815959,
-0.3545748591,
-0.5808736086,
0.2055676877,
-0.5426783562,
0.1581016481,
-0.4026777446,
-0.7539407015,
-0.0746903867,
0.1271965057,
-0.8563943505,
0.9857444763,
0.0612408966,
-0.8985039592,
0.3859615028,
-0.8603251576,
-0.4034698904,
0.1275474578,
0.0596167408,
-0.2306713611,
0.051407963,
0.570192337,
0.381591022,
-0.2261390239,
0.2738353014,
-0.3364389539,
-0.2463880926,
0.2490570396,
-0.1792718619,
0.8603037596,
0.3625850379,
-0.0328941755,
0.0659264624,
-0.6515033841,
0.1525182575,
-0.062410526,
-0.1180485412,
-0.7506611943,
-0.1598027796,
0.3375838995,
-0.2114255875,
0.0950890481,
-0.559132874,
0.1844285429,
-0.3991943896,
0.2702421248,
0.9847040176,
-0.0180499703,
0.7235912085,
-0.0307320431,
0.1350034475,
0.0216357354,
0.0840156451,
-0.0257509574,
-0.3469088972,
-0.5092609525,
-0.6049253941,
0.4464805424,
0.4541393518,
-0.6818177104,
0.3136172593,
-0.3571799695,
-0.5732545257,
-0.3877243102,
0.1969854981,
0.3708480895,
0.3966163397,
0.5848765969,
-0.1913055629,
-0.3978396654,
-0.8845912814,
-0.4419783652,
0.254681468,
-0.0673969463,
0.2258675992,
0.406086266,
0.0203248542,
1.1064497232,
-0.9279711843,
-0.3006979823,
-0.1995732933,
-0.0780811235,
0.2387934029,
0.7095612884,
0.3412345648,
-0.7249027491,
-0.5721756816,
0.2079651505,
-0.5897041559,
-0.1454221904,
0.053541258,
-0.1492742747,
0.0345145799,
0.455958277,
-0.5060351491,
0.0520258546,
0.5172614455,
-0.2176607698,
0.3015345037,
-0.2796472311,
0.1014377773,
-1.1499065161,
0.0783282667,
0.0937285051,
0.0891391709,
-0.7289105058,
0.1352464855,
0.1790514737,
-0.2157775313,
-0.5908825397,
0.8216226697,
-0.4384921491,
-0.0809087828,
-0.0645755753,
0.3299342394,
-0.0795650855,
0.8087908626,
-0.0884438455,
0.5726652741,
0.4097958803,
-0.6751972437,
0.0861131325,
0.04471476,
-0.3088817,
0.7886164188,
-0.3827139437,
0.2197605669,
-0.250451833,
0.3222254813,
-0.8730207086,
-0.1574227661,
0.134085834,
-0.1301626563,
0.2272218764,
-0.2240280062,
-0.5274544954,
-0.0633906871,
-0.2708167732,
0.5248253942,
0.4870614409,
-0.8464941978,
0.641278863,
0.4913367927,
-0.0483033918,
-0.7336079478,
-0.7694582939,
0.0813646093,
-0.4446977675,
-0.6124783158,
0.3912404776,
0.3556739688,
-0.2373777926,
0.3979308903,
-0.1155792624,
-0.4233753681,
-0.1201854274,
-0.2589222193,
0.1325270087,
-0.0721555054,
0.3164816797,
0.4498448074,
-0.3594305217,
-0.3799776435,
-0.744956851,
0.4057353735,
0.1104389131,
-0.2994700372,
-0.5279719234,
0.6387833953,
0.5249261856,
-0.2967793941,
0.8786715865,
0.546756506,
-0.3605054021,
-0.616309166,
-0.4658685327,
-0.1398544759,
-0.5358487368,
0.3789682984,
-0.0494719893,
-0.8696860075,
0.3978930116,
-0.0594452396,
0.2092048079,
0.3650141954,
0.0724795088,
-0.1779116988,
0.5992649198,
0.3973175883,
0.1908656508,
0.4638091028,
-0.2114244103,
0.2321952879,
-0.7213666439,
0.053992372,
-0.5459028482,
-0.3904038966,
-0.4736898541,
-0.7634946704,
0.4867560267,
-0.33112064,
-0.158487916,
0.3451446295,
-0.6675479412,
0.8070867062,
0.5434153676,
0.192374751,
0.3054508269,
0.2399789393,
-0.0196331497,
-0.034497425,
-0.8363420963,
-0.1206818148,
1.0498085022,
0.1283428222,
0.4088210762,
0.1567326039,
0.8756034374,
0.3136819005,
0.374324739,
-0.4898785055,
0.7459340692,
-0.9243791699,
-0.3098736107,
-0.4636998773,
-0.7073481083,
-0.9236923456,
0.5093677044,
0.0739184394,
-0.9197611809,
0.2894288003,
0.2938696146,
0.0438229144,
0.5218414068,
-0.877364397,
0.8835267425,
0.168366164,
-0.2821738124,
-0.3721356094,
-0.316719979,
0.4703530967,
-0.0218146201,
0.5034765005,
-0.0635981485,
-0.0233415645,
1.0376321077,
-0.8613586426,
1.0480391979,
-0.5703365803,
-0.084770374,
0.3145794868,
-0.2722771466,
0.6590508223,
-0.4805634916,
0.2578467131,
0.0824310333,
0.1577910632,
-0.5218527913,
-0.7484685183,
0.6906476617,
-0.4380697608,
-0.1851695329,
-0.0149213029,
-0.6846474409,
-0.4440102577,
0.1273206323,
0.0466766246,
0.5976088643,
-0.0066058412,
0.0554487742,
0.7505329847,
-0.3214677572,
0.4693663418,
-0.1204605103,
-0.0860846192,
-0.8410918713,
1.1576622725,
0.2370361537,
0.4817393422,
0.3733029068,
0.4703371823,
-0.5847754478,
-0.3956750035,
-0.5331388116,
0.3047316372,
-0.9135224223,
-0.2064463198,
-0.8671113849,
0.279494524,
-0.4456329942,
-0.452806592,
-0.4453681409,
-0.7263981104,
0.0319412649,
0.0618828125,
0.6417768002,
0.3120165765,
-0.1387614906,
0.6023681164,
-0.9875594378,
0.2235703766,
0.3803468645,
0.615205884,
0.4764587581,
-0.1423006803,
-0.4399290681,
-0.1605324149,
0.2048391849,
-0.9728069901,
0.2455127388,
0.081383191,
0.5774458051,
0.0985385925,
0.0682696998,
0.5780397058,
-0.3926328719,
0.7039895058,
0.3799371421,
-1.0369706154,
0.1104625836,
-0.4542992711,
0.3561864495,
0.7516385317,
0.1183918715,
-0.8237418532,
-0.3514297009,
-0.3863707483,
-1.0141903162,
0.6449554563,
0.1118217036,
0.1501784325,
-0.0539816916,
-0.0795861408,
0.011363578,
-0.00841753,
-0.5772635937,
-0.1754148155,
-0.1332921982,
-0.4357978404,
0.1766363978,
-0.0504434668,
-0.1883250624,
-0.2192632109,
0.8162109852,
-0.0601232313,
0.1463542283,
-0.1435258985,
-0.2222900093,
0.4402245581,
0.4338088036,
0.1950129867,
0.1842554063,
-0.0304138474,
0.4124803543,
0.3892208934,
-0.6251685023,
0.0948916078,
-0.0459213071,
-0.0727346167,
0.1630828977,
0.1667686254,
0.4652462006,
0.4787707329,
-0.6035102606,
0.3804922104,
0.1760254353,
-0.2471568882,
0.2296537012,
-0.058580488,
0.3006331921,
0.2421068847,
0.228680104,
-0.0958500504,
0.1127217188,
-0.1438115686,
0.3550846577,
0.3044741452,
-0.0989723206,
0.3067041039,
0.4486714602,
0.2114176452,
0.0216764528,
0.7693439126,
-0.1934817433,
-0.5541681647,
0.5863353014,
0.5840232968,
1.0315808058,
-0.1340537071,
0.1451290548,
0.4662848115,
0.2503690124,
0.0246713217,
-0.1513872445,
-0.2692068219,
-0.7261369824,
-0.5924775004,
-0.5059449673,
-0.3517083526,
-0.3546683192,
-0.4028793275,
0.1426979154,
-0.4118461013,
0.1273531467,
-0.0943495929,
-0.3079277575,
-0.4322220981,
0.2514838278,
0.0008616253,
0.9177849293,
-0.8663297892,
0.8045185208,
0.2286322266,
-0.2117136717,
-0.695329845,
-0.3704771101,
-0.1510167569,
-0.7194235921,
0.6038561463,
0.1336956173,
-0.0031501746,
-0.1335317194,
-0.4538913965,
-0.9045478702,
0.8922054768,
0.2411648184,
-0.4077375829,
0.0090393182,
0.2735245526,
0.2732779086,
-0.0727678165,
-0.1528585106,
0.5221458673,
0.7234367132,
0.3848448098,
-0.8439126611,
0.3216455877,
-0.3447395265,
0.0812703073,
0.5940533876,
-0.2716232836,
0.6343479156,
-0.0449255556,
-0.4678374231,
-0.3160045147,
0.6608096361,
0.1721045673,
0.4836967885,
0.7685846686,
0.7197542191,
1.1527385712,
0.1523706764,
0.8214845657,
-0.0821385235,
0.3378539085,
1.3265134096,
-0.0150797684,
0.7921733856,
0.499871105,
-0.2969368994,
0.3372257948,
0.2615898252,
-0.0425628498,
0.7362447977,
0.2210711241,
-0.4931155443,
0.0744184479,
-0.1498248279,
-0.4360265732,
0.2363725752,
0.2154780179,
-0.3195738494,
-0.4507283866,
-0.0035388875,
0.335481137,
0.1711685061,
-0.3645245731,
0.7907435894,
-0.0667583868,
-0.5956196189,
0.596801281,
0.0495634191,
0.7831977606,
-0.6034885645,
0.0567682832,
-0.2405984849,
0.0485203825,
-0.2916253209,
-0.4947651327,
0.6194257736,
0.0761916488,
-0.0824151263,
-0.2971937656,
0.6431930065,
-0.5674322844,
-0.4786557257,
0.0197854936,
0.3500858545,
0.2050747871,
-0.0442996882,
-0.1800859272,
0.0412756875,
-0.0425734967,
0.2557530999,
0.3938914835,
0.3108501434,
0.0234918781,
0.2656798065,
0.8555934429,
-0.2699296474,
0.0731429756,
-0.1038609967,
1.0278978348,
-0.5779426694,
-0.8548070788,
-0.7517566085,
0.724296093,
-0.4384780228,
-0.0499739498,
0.5373691916,
0.5640786886,
0.6763846874,
-0.0170090944,
0.8010408282,
0.0969523489,
0.1711326838,
-0.6472736597,
0.8262263536,
-0.5193969607,
0.3489676416,
-0.5090676546,
-0.8272345066,
-0.39390558,
0.3042729497,
-0.313685745,
-0.165421471,
0.8740400672,
0.7835710645,
-0.2828373015,
0.2825095952,
0.2053143382,
-0.0503463261,
0.2294218391,
0.4141711891,
0.4897159636,
-0.0328125246,
0.4246342182,
-0.3709277511,
-0.2613560259,
0.1956891119,
-1.0297245979,
-0.629368484,
-0.7372093797,
-0.2320820987,
-0.2707488239,
-0.0701416433,
0.8289037943,
0.58672297,
-0.5797157884,
-0.2285519391,
-0.0554508157,
0.2303856164,
-0.5083858967,
-0.2443666905,
0.7521696687,
-0.6013630629,
-0.7455103993,
0.3558114171,
0.1113597378,
-0.2884213328,
-0.0046605244,
0.2060643137,
-0.0455921404,
0.2007985264,
0.5852375627,
0.0394255519,
-0.4680527449,
-0.2245955169,
-0.0513848551,
0.2028233409,
-0.0389528312,
0.9355283976,
-0.7077658772,
0.3946250975,
0.2661075294,
1.1036895514,
0.7102560401,
-0.3441317379,
0.4211053848,
-0.9344015121,
0.0038865265,
0.0797097608,
0.2507932484,
0.389267534,
-0.2917326391,
0.5668897033,
0.3556085825,
-0.1476919651,
-1.0442043543,
0.0470804945,
-1.2031928301,
-0.6365161538,
1.042770505,
0.0633132309,
-0.2623522878,
-0.0896084979,
0.0109414449,
0.1533712447,
-0.4490953684,
0.4363953769,
0.4717222154,
0.0972398594,
-0.1698533744,
-0.1794339418,
0.2548510432,
0.2839820385,
-0.9412430525,
0.4763852954,
0.6264246106,
0.1272587478,
0.1109839901,
0.709736824,
0.0143085141,
0.1740685999,
0.4723305702,
0.0292414594,
-0.1503096223,
-0.0555235073,
-0.0883484408,
0.5174636841,
-0.3235292137,
-0.3996617794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16349v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16349v1 | Lexinvariant Language Models | 2023-05-24T19:10:46 | 2023-05-24T19:10:46 | Qian Huang, Eric Zelikman, Sarah Li Chen, Yuhuai Wu, Gregory Valiant, Percy Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Token embeddings, a mapping from discrete lexical symbols to continuous
vectors, are at the heart of any language model (LM). However, lexical symbol
meanings can also be determined and even redefined by their structural role in
a long context. In this paper, we ask: is it possible for a language model to
be performant without \emph{any} fixed token embeddings? Such a language model
would have to rely entirely on the co-occurence and repetition of tokens in the
context rather than the \textit{a priori} identity of any token. To answer
this, we study \textit{lexinvariant}language models that are invariant to
lexical symbols and therefore do not need fixed token embeddings in practice.
First, we prove that we can construct a lexinvariant LM to converge to the true
language model at a uniform rate that is polynomial in terms of the context
length, with a constant factor that is sublinear in the vocabulary size.
Second, to build a lexinvariant LM, we simply encode tokens using random
Gaussian vectors, such that each token maps to the same representation within
each sequence but different representations across sequences. Empirically, we
demonstrate that it can indeed attain perplexity comparable to that of a
standard language model, given a sufficiently long context. We further explore
two properties of the lexinvariant language models: First, given text generated
from a substitution cipher of English, it implicitly implements Bayesian
in-context deciphering and infers the mapping to the underlying real tokens
with high accuracy. Second, it has on average 4X better accuracy over synthetic
in-context reasoning tasks. Finally, we discuss regularizing standard language
models towards lexinvariance and potential practical applications. | [
-0.1192767099,
-0.6119008064,
0.6823197603,
0.1609228104,
-0.5352365971,
0.08485163,
-0.24565126,
-0.1327630579,
0.2462403476,
0.3715754151,
-0.2994346917,
-0.5209852457,
-0.551602602,
0.1736398935,
-0.5262721777,
0.7567588687,
-0.2792536318,
0.1770864427,
-0.2264062017,
-0.3779031634,
-0.3983913362,
-0.9819846153,
-0.4065605402,
-0.1142615974,
0.5628945231,
-0.1200819016,
0.9046034813,
0.6541487575,
0.35835132,
0.2014714926,
-0.3454529941,
-0.0778443888,
-0.3206340373,
0.1484538466,
-0.3442626894,
-0.5883598328,
-0.3342728019,
0.0271761157,
0.701031208,
0.8965505362,
-0.0666011274,
-0.0577146597,
-0.0271637961,
0.1830217391,
-0.5069019198,
0.2332056463,
-0.543240726,
0.1288314015,
-0.1827646494,
0.1606397927,
-0.2018378526,
-0.2390249074,
0.1691625565,
-0.4008933008,
0.0860325247,
0.2425599545,
0.7266825438,
-0.0126284938,
-0.4260820746,
-0.3274061084,
-0.64377141,
0.8835099339,
-0.8602327108,
0.6560310125,
0.1826415211,
0.0775203258,
-0.3357570767,
-0.6659411788,
-0.594725132,
-0.5246584415,
-0.0056396048,
0.0704498813,
-0.0249196086,
0.3262954354,
0.2463080883,
0.2816505432,
-0.2957317233,
-0.0877799764,
-0.0544622168,
-0.0039809453,
0.0540679581,
0.249915123,
0.4986847341,
-0.2147868723,
-0.5253785849,
0.0101816775,
-0.7149868011,
-0.1714416891,
0.2897450924,
0.5682019591,
-0.1639389098,
0.6897543669,
0.3120606244,
0.5715202093,
0.0197152682,
0.0473430641,
-0.0665303096,
-0.2927492857,
-0.3236743212,
-0.1340214461,
0.4039658308,
-0.1874107569,
0.4010988772,
-0.4660445154,
-0.4032021165,
0.2014417648,
0.2720564902,
-0.6259524226,
0.0657086819,
0.1281760931,
-0.3795568049,
-0.1553257853,
0.161602959,
-0.225739792,
0.0555523336,
-0.4972036481,
0.463888675,
-0.6222151518,
-0.4136847854,
0.1413048506,
-0.1654288918,
0.1365201324,
0.1297607869,
-0.6654166579,
0.4818416536,
0.9752690196,
0.9665253758,
-0.226181075,
-0.3075352907,
-0.1744421273,
0.0014087486,
-0.6969500184,
0.2118663788,
-0.7929129004,
-0.2029522657,
0.3006645739,
0.0841099322,
-0.2522165179,
-0.1536351442,
0.2493795902,
-0.6037310362,
-0.0747984052,
-0.4770416319,
-1.0044285059,
-0.3054059744,
0.295127213,
-0.5056626201,
0.5668151379,
-0.0364443101,
-0.7684523463,
0.2805054486,
-0.4654813111,
-0.035083551,
-0.0631051213,
-0.3725981116,
-0.0767891631,
0.6433950663,
-0.0822608769,
0.3370187879,
-0.1997041553,
0.2769637108,
-0.3845356107,
-0.5039330721,
0.4036147892,
-0.6873064637,
0.5760353208,
0.1129266471,
-0.2879807949,
-0.29567191,
-0.6026618481,
-0.2877553701,
-0.0398689546,
-0.3864310682,
-0.5423075557,
0.0278300699,
0.1744311452,
0.0847632959,
0.1397930831,
-0.8014262915,
0.1985752732,
-0.5295915008,
0.156192556,
0.6383905411,
-0.2969204187,
0.5315645337,
-0.2081348151,
0.6622463465,
0.2380258292,
-0.16952461,
0.0143374875,
-0.5104541779,
-0.7773092389,
-0.6381562352,
0.637861073,
0.3520435989,
-0.6211766005,
0.1537266374,
-0.4084952176,
-0.0244188979,
-0.1551811993,
-0.2015306801,
0.5025359392,
0.1980811954,
0.172700569,
-0.4068756998,
-0.4952801764,
-0.8089341521,
-0.3834685981,
-0.2415917367,
-0.0361863822,
0.1970862299,
0.4701950848,
-0.1552340239,
1.0341585875,
-0.0841839314,
0.1115075648,
-0.1818879992,
0.1559774727,
0.2559489906,
0.3665921688,
0.5337833762,
-0.5537430048,
-0.2549941242,
0.0290441886,
-0.8492305279,
0.0086122341,
0.1004355401,
0.086753659,
0.3503324389,
0.6155026555,
-0.6071730256,
0.6064043045,
0.6334552765,
-0.6061537266,
0.3976942599,
-0.3176409006,
-0.2012252659,
-0.9265819788,
0.1155483797,
-0.517459929,
-0.5177901983,
-0.8635918498,
0.3497931361,
0.1938087642,
-0.1419161111,
-0.5487192273,
0.8124944568,
-0.3732364476,
-0.0316201746,
-0.2385980636,
-0.0770228133,
-0.2423756123,
0.5122838616,
0.0035794945,
0.5346763134,
0.4255359769,
-0.5693920255,
-0.1137492135,
0.0849421322,
-0.170663625,
0.4293398857,
-0.6253553033,
0.0229159631,
-0.4157253206,
0.142229259,
-0.7814037204,
0.0618417412,
0.2928268611,
-0.1004397199,
0.3996923566,
-0.3783996701,
-0.4749035239,
0.0779884234,
0.0212782733,
0.7189360857,
0.4670141339,
-0.4312536716,
0.6990112066,
-0.0028345911,
0.2261206061,
-0.3679593503,
-0.7346035242,
0.0771149099,
-0.1263629645,
-0.3222114742,
0.276227802,
0.2480347306,
-0.2778465152,
0.3011921644,
-0.0596884787,
0.0882103294,
-0.0187838897,
0.2924229503,
0.1505825967,
-0.3714630902,
0.5205890536,
-0.0790161714,
-0.0565168485,
-0.2934938073,
-0.5527635813,
0.6002821922,
-0.2506031692,
-0.6132060289,
-0.2383076251,
0.5374776125,
0.814935565,
-0.1051204801,
0.9538168907,
0.4308353662,
-0.5689587593,
0.1892720461,
-0.3877384365,
-0.0135600446,
-0.4187781215,
0.3162002861,
-0.597669661,
-1.1018733978,
0.7581496239,
0.1707672328,
0.0621100143,
0.5078580976,
0.6407154799,
0.2079184353,
1.0246990919,
0.6177283525,
0.0156110767,
0.5236174464,
0.029113993,
0.2960399389,
-0.7808678746,
0.0776868984,
-0.1198466569,
-0.0215454884,
-0.8579612374,
-0.5637165308,
0.1684601605,
0.1471568197,
-0.4967238009,
0.3546658158,
-0.1489603966,
0.2061035037,
0.2068579197,
-0.2219857723,
-0.0604445152,
0.0580099896,
-0.8711668253,
0.0128247309,
-0.8333878517,
-0.4980145395,
1.0388706923,
0.5068789124,
0.6760216951,
0.2522953153,
0.7970677018,
-0.0633972958,
0.2073229998,
-0.6443667412,
0.2581417561,
-0.4732634425,
-0.5991262197,
-0.2258102894,
-0.3025811613,
-0.9228720665,
0.314311862,
-0.0052172453,
-0.7896744013,
0.5302435756,
-0.0422294438,
-0.2718705237,
0.4207765758,
-0.4991540909,
0.6315627098,
0.0496127605,
-0.1447224319,
0.0747026876,
-0.0612309985,
0.1552762538,
-0.0228305105,
0.235906437,
-0.1258111745,
-0.2372311503,
0.6209497452,
-0.8257533312,
0.9624364972,
-0.1416975707,
0.0360277519,
0.2629702985,
0.3556648195,
0.6260272861,
0.1469641924,
-0.0679616407,
0.2514463961,
0.4625087976,
-0.6071985364,
-0.7161116004,
0.6152684093,
-0.6752910614,
-0.6152144074,
-0.5127570629,
-0.5010419488,
-0.014994109,
0.1226048991,
0.035023313,
0.6871254444,
-0.2857193351,
0.0735500455,
0.4765340686,
-0.1719706953,
0.4067184031,
0.0902494863,
-0.4325231016,
-0.2817064524,
0.8084504604,
0.3954055607,
0.2834353447,
0.3467344642,
0.2729386687,
-0.2559788823,
-0.284160912,
-0.3032137156,
0.2024226189,
-0.7824419141,
0.0728067681,
-0.552315414,
-0.2785126269,
-0.1222078875,
-0.0554530509,
-0.6754795313,
-0.6030287743,
-0.214912042,
-0.0468386821,
0.3566655517,
0.8013290763,
-0.1360541582,
0.0908495709,
-0.5781155229,
-0.0920100734,
0.4159157872,
0.3212357461,
0.2080448717,
-0.4293902814,
-0.2022372335,
0.201140359,
0.1835775375,
-0.7548444867,
0.378983289,
0.1782163531,
0.4673450589,
0.3689930737,
-0.2770259976,
0.5887651443,
-0.6373446584,
0.821228683,
0.0999328047,
-1.1502690315,
-0.1723508239,
-0.4164500833,
0.3435311317,
0.3040136993,
0.2565716505,
-0.7946200967,
-0.5600238442,
-0.4645136595,
-0.7358645797,
0.1640042663,
0.4103496969,
0.6066167355,
-0.5564376116,
0.7050272822,
0.0265817791,
0.1553104222,
-0.3984074891,
-0.0236762483,
-0.4075193107,
-0.3781979084,
-0.0780540109,
-0.5136068463,
0.0338912979,
-0.3056579828,
0.1339021176,
-0.056681931,
0.7170090079,
0.2284207195,
-0.2616254687,
0.225984171,
0.0470782369,
0.7580897808,
0.7626398802,
-0.2656313777,
0.5130017996,
0.3896466196,
-0.3745568693,
0.2173790783,
-0.2646755576,
-0.0907248333,
0.2535892427,
0.4852745235,
0.8017075062,
0.6735050678,
-0.2736567557,
0.632519424,
-0.2554124594,
-0.018229384,
-0.4264162481,
-0.3019104302,
0.2558184564,
0.1540737152,
0.0560000427,
-0.1837872118,
-0.2457818389,
-0.6220014095,
0.2022367567,
0.5190178752,
-0.638682127,
-0.6016950011,
0.5815336108,
-0.2373031229,
-0.3306336999,
0.4442513287,
-0.1500713527,
-0.6373303533,
0.4639183581,
0.7206252813,
1.1155785322,
-0.0346597619,
0.0219694227,
0.1728145182,
0.0587909818,
-0.2688275576,
0.215675652,
0.0523437075,
-0.9251604676,
-0.2137597054,
-0.9403849244,
-0.3387941718,
-0.1223321781,
-0.4506211877,
0.1696555167,
-0.6888955832,
-0.1859799922,
-0.2220366299,
-0.4233663678,
-0.9238954186,
0.1626694202,
0.0986947343,
0.7662768364,
-0.7719538212,
0.7492241859,
0.6156572104,
-0.4748210311,
-0.6698623896,
0.1944002807,
-0.3100843728,
-0.6285614371,
0.6832252741,
-0.0164227895,
-0.0017359543,
-0.0740417391,
-0.4679876268,
-1.245577693,
0.7692238092,
0.3999181092,
-0.4309832752,
-0.1856976748,
0.3236975372,
0.6551553607,
-0.5121697187,
0.1959326565,
0.3248922527,
0.2298695147,
0.0567333177,
-0.7019084096,
0.2931792736,
0.159210369,
0.5741362572,
0.09420719,
-0.3923313022,
1.2332816124,
0.4544098079,
-0.3797576725,
0.2372199893,
0.5583084822,
0.0690418929,
-0.2975486219,
0.2776376009,
0.6356129646,
0.568240881,
0.0775344819,
1.3464238644,
-0.5401087999,
0.4221034348,
0.7316877246,
0.0344051868,
0.8484519124,
0.6408481598,
-0.0994887799,
0.5526425242,
0.2934150696,
0.3773951828,
0.534681797,
0.3786514699,
-0.369990766,
-0.542124033,
0.1408634633,
-0.1082145646,
0.5137959719,
0.2991114259,
-0.4758447409,
-0.3969306946,
0.0411302969,
0.1543073654,
-0.0588283986,
-0.1099911183,
0.4290023446,
0.5240110159,
-0.3916708827,
0.7841956019,
0.2967394292,
0.6705183387,
-0.5229965448,
0.1219629273,
-0.226205036,
0.2364749908,
0.1575253755,
-0.1682296544,
0.5703513622,
-0.1128592193,
-0.0454693735,
-0.0642956495,
0.5687649846,
-0.4892227948,
-0.8257434964,
0.2168392539,
0.5770345926,
0.1757480949,
0.1274705529,
-0.3187812567,
-0.0692652017,
-0.4682022333,
-0.3027716577,
0.3725246787,
0.4885551631,
-0.2749429941,
0.4700505137,
0.6533415914,
0.0692414865,
0.1825525016,
0.0517188311,
0.5749192238,
-0.6372993588,
-0.4605476856,
-1.0191121101,
0.3067391813,
0.2560421526,
-0.2486332506,
0.641394794,
0.3156931102,
0.6850447059,
-0.1760103554,
0.6303904057,
0.1582034528,
0.1874290556,
-0.5200189948,
0.8194074631,
-0.5749323368,
0.0588885397,
-0.2128458768,
-0.7015581131,
-0.6100111604,
0.7151938677,
-0.3188009262,
-0.1018692702,
0.6925493479,
0.787212193,
-0.293048799,
-0.207495749,
0.7820775509,
0.0461092889,
0.3331673443,
0.2188832313,
0.7987343073,
-0.4049166143,
0.0469911955,
0.1272667646,
-0.0046534361,
-0.2169414461,
-0.8708146811,
-1.1014558077,
-0.5050595403,
-0.1294555813,
-0.1354850978,
0.3395707607,
1.1192444563,
0.2317473888,
-0.9146772623,
-0.2275581509,
-0.5252506733,
0.2853388786,
-0.1510632336,
-0.1719593555,
0.4835197628,
-0.6082218885,
-0.7817921638,
0.1967277378,
0.4010492861,
0.2606999278,
-0.3267386854,
-0.0646156818,
-0.1767235547,
0.7090588212,
0.5865374804,
0.1587230265,
-0.8841692209,
-0.9883517623,
0.0510212742,
-0.1144893393,
-0.0386797749,
0.7664706707,
-0.634331882,
0.4590125978,
0.6021675467,
0.5738610029,
0.4625377357,
-0.3124345541,
0.8428084254,
-0.7203664184,
0.3494358957,
0.1824753582,
0.5258473754,
0.2102200985,
-0.0063684192,
0.1233683079,
0.4037910998,
-0.1897657961,
-0.804861486,
0.4640393853,
-0.5602078438,
-0.2013565153,
1.2196654081,
-0.4162984788,
-0.4959647059,
-0.1958084702,
0.1331205666,
0.4702242315,
-0.0003619542,
0.5767390728,
0.7887588739,
0.1905589402,
0.0604579821,
-0.3342261612,
0.5393608809,
0.5611411333,
0.0928299204,
-0.0099764476,
-0.0468465723,
0.577621758,
0.0871658921,
0.4005918801,
-0.3181312084,
0.115619652,
0.2471403927,
0.015973473,
-0.1303789467,
-0.1526639313,
-0.4255890846,
0.2060546428,
0.190355286,
-0.2814275026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15507v1 | The Larger They Are, the Harder They Fail: Language Models do not Recognize Identifier Swaps in Python | 2023-05-24T18:54:39 | 2023-05-24T18:54:39 | Antonio Valerio Miceli-Barone, Fazl Barez, Ioannis Konstas, Shay B. Cohen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have successfully been applied to code
generation tasks, raising the question of how well these models understand
programming. Typical programming languages have invariances and equivariances
in their semantics that human programmers intuitively understand and exploit,
such as the (near) invariance to the renaming of identifiers. We show that LLMs
not only fail to properly generate correct Python code when default function
names are swapped, but some of them even become more confident in their
incorrect predictions as the model size increases, an instance of the recently
discovered phenomenon of Inverse Scaling, which runs contrary to the commonly
observed trend of increasing prediction quality with increasing model size. Our
findings indicate that, despite their astonishing typical-case performance,
LLMs still lack a deep, abstract understanding of the content they manipulate,
making them unsuitable for tasks that statistically deviate from their training
data, and that mere scaling is not enough to achieve such capability. | [
-0.0484725833,
-0.2921458781,
0.7163378596,
0.1282841265,
0.06580396,
0.0794541314,
-0.209070906,
-0.3553441763,
-0.3079123199,
0.3285401464,
-0.4277387261,
0.093564257,
-0.90645504,
0.1140104905,
-0.5980530977,
1.0200138092,
-0.0795233771,
0.0238961857,
-0.4455773234,
-0.1649686992,
-0.1097080708,
-0.5106464028,
-0.349286139,
-0.6269351244,
0.4905127883,
0.4136448205,
0.9228617549,
0.7310636044,
0.5309057236,
0.2730288208,
0.0450443178,
-0.1126382425,
-0.5160235763,
-0.1480928808,
0.0630301312,
-0.8270488977,
-0.0415842347,
0.0383664407,
0.7508432269,
1.0655835867,
-0.0348235555,
0.2006938607,
-0.0930232406,
0.7623586059,
-0.3791134655,
0.2875923216,
-1.0013246536,
-0.1631527692,
0.0042860564,
-0.0382497422,
-0.2939590216,
-0.3215658665,
-0.1361646056,
-0.3441279531,
0.1855288595,
0.1139582619,
0.7747677565,
0.3656812012,
-0.3014934957,
-0.5422621369,
-0.8049493432,
0.8593639731,
-0.7840170264,
-0.0250903107,
0.2715444565,
0.1450892687,
-0.4764938653,
-0.5359409451,
-0.619471252,
-0.2158019543,
0.0607432574,
-0.5321211815,
-0.3805680275,
-0.0382797122,
0.654153049,
0.2109227628,
-0.4580616057,
0.3839440644,
-0.5545517206,
-0.0122307744,
0.5911400914,
0.396461755,
0.4961225092,
0.1625631303,
-0.0405727141,
-0.023046758,
-1.1137609482,
0.110140875,
0.5583603382,
0.3658418357,
0.0148967421,
0.5661416054,
0.2118354589,
0.8168482184,
0.0560681522,
-0.3463082314,
0.1065814197,
-0.128749609,
-0.4834913313,
-0.0732749999,
0.5468363762,
0.1390062124,
0.4149242342,
-0.1560352296,
-0.127248913,
-0.0001752673,
0.1680176854,
-0.775003612,
-0.4811965227,
0.3151833713,
-0.404679209,
-0.2654848695,
0.0760651678,
-0.1498644948,
-0.4165635109,
-0.2429332882,
0.6446511149,
-0.189040035,
-0.4211831391,
0.0512905568,
-0.2782160044,
0.3341433704,
0.3735746145,
-0.774038434,
0.1104705185,
0.7651006579,
0.5799289346,
-0.0750164092,
-0.5279360414,
-0.2348017842,
-0.1127618179,
-0.6398761868,
0.4464161396,
-0.5592484474,
-0.0349813774,
-0.1695610434,
0.0139253791,
-0.1173277348,
-0.8245081902,
-0.0207445659,
-0.3087600768,
-0.1346377879,
-0.1700227857,
-0.3780739009,
-0.0087590292,
-0.0113335224,
-0.3276709616,
0.4722842276,
0.2361966819,
-0.7184156179,
0.3988307714,
-0.0513487794,
-0.3651142716,
-0.2497721165,
-0.0936043039,
-0.6374961734,
0.5138844252,
-0.3281768858,
0.5046592951,
-0.3554292321,
0.1457078606,
-0.4512553513,
-0.6906597614,
0.578258574,
-0.3310271204,
0.8078583479,
0.046932213,
-0.0393052399,
-0.1446188539,
-0.7006061673,
0.0737041384,
0.2941211164,
-0.4058882892,
-0.4354973733,
0.129306823,
-0.1194722503,
0.2313610762,
0.0836284012,
-0.4411634803,
0.4426165819,
-0.167087391,
0.7852950692,
0.8509281278,
-0.5457358956,
0.6441830993,
-0.3079945445,
0.5285494328,
0.2521266043,
-0.2333022654,
-0.1979764998,
-0.4897818267,
-0.7068688273,
-0.0498446003,
0.1536276639,
0.2684982121,
-0.4082636237,
0.1490712017,
-0.4899902046,
-0.5509223342,
-0.3445585668,
0.4085780084,
0.2452139258,
0.3046916425,
0.157867223,
-0.0495416373,
-0.5099423528,
-0.907795012,
-0.741795063,
-0.4414610863,
-0.0829024762,
0.1968462169,
0.5879709721,
-0.6316114664,
0.6762681007,
-0.1502381712,
0.0660906285,
-0.3974534869,
0.1933088899,
0.4597938657,
0.5143770576,
0.2891164124,
-0.6810246706,
-0.2595219016,
-0.1024228781,
-0.4037166536,
-0.0636167973,
-0.346185118,
0.5559583306,
0.2180794924,
0.5830094218,
-0.3952839673,
0.1644520164,
0.6663951874,
-0.2153517902,
0.7275653481,
-0.4161609113,
-0.37813133,
-0.6701164842,
-0.113043122,
0.0323730819,
-0.1111512855,
-0.5447559357,
0.0659275651,
0.3799059689,
0.0052653756,
-0.331014365,
0.4608038962,
-0.5926138163,
-0.2347821146,
-0.3206707537,
-0.2265647799,
-0.2846774161,
0.241857782,
-0.2352631986,
0.7203375697,
0.4510497451,
-0.6452236176,
0.3186763525,
-0.2871668935,
-0.417883575,
0.3229347467,
-0.6204175949,
0.0377965756,
-0.1899825633,
0.028196238,
-1.0776541233,
-0.4163922369,
-0.1451708376,
-0.3782803714,
0.5624101162,
-0.3844847679,
-0.4785358906,
-0.5594261885,
-0.1749868393,
0.5069162846,
0.6310122013,
-0.7138811946,
0.1900672764,
0.1851843446,
0.0483299345,
-0.7102045417,
-1.0962861776,
0.1260331571,
-0.4352271557,
-0.3328950703,
-0.0134273963,
-0.0651143044,
-0.6583787799,
-0.1234942153,
-0.2324348539,
-0.2150760293,
0.2507191002,
0.3824353814,
0.05182283,
-0.2718072832,
0.3767682016,
-0.0376341343,
0.0367455631,
0.3026111722,
-0.224193275,
0.4279830754,
-0.1958823651,
-0.430540055,
-0.3358677328,
-0.1453484893,
0.8294636011,
0.2312293649,
0.7518115044,
0.084353134,
-0.2995421588,
-0.208136633,
-0.375714004,
0.1814779788,
-0.4414186478,
0.5553601384,
-0.4530034363,
-0.5625117421,
0.411380738,
-0.1738574505,
-0.1056892797,
0.4305622876,
0.4876163006,
-0.1508322209,
1.0727562904,
0.6353740692,
-0.1172303259,
0.2830579877,
-0.1274845004,
0.5264518857,
-0.6734970212,
0.1397480816,
-0.6946650743,
-0.3180634677,
-0.7930634618,
-0.4384304285,
0.1558226347,
0.1650186032,
-0.5728515983,
0.5352290273,
-0.2795338929,
0.7170314789,
0.3551850617,
-0.3514881134,
0.3624121249,
0.0625333488,
0.2673313022,
-0.0604853928,
-0.6260085702,
-0.5215992332,
1.3542786837,
0.2557412982,
1.2118656635,
-0.010170972,
0.6472738981,
0.0994616151,
0.2700335681,
-0.7423018217,
0.2779357433,
-0.0680567399,
-0.263759613,
-0.3713613153,
-0.6107327342,
-1.0235594511,
0.3142747283,
0.1955929101,
-0.616961062,
0.211336866,
0.0992400348,
-0.1463870257,
0.5496336222,
-0.8140082955,
0.7399010062,
-0.1245650351,
-0.1877821088,
-0.161600098,
-0.3575984538,
0.3958414793,
-0.2450700104,
0.4327406585,
-0.1696827561,
-0.0253158733,
0.4017528296,
-0.3445574939,
0.8885258436,
0.0511258245,
-0.1833694428,
0.0432286635,
0.4649378955,
0.4657668769,
0.0899885595,
-0.1405837834,
0.1980533451,
0.0827113241,
-0.536664784,
-0.5484164357,
0.8777390122,
-0.7687206864,
-0.6001958251,
-0.4181694984,
-0.5697197914,
0.0236645825,
0.0054902043,
0.3767989874,
0.2975416183,
-0.1208250076,
0.0645897016,
0.4868046343,
-0.2464804947,
0.4052232206,
0.3058853447,
-0.0890244171,
0.1159489006,
1.1498372555,
0.2755945027,
0.4705460966,
0.0975329876,
0.0626228377,
0.1635789722,
-0.5145740509,
-0.3484915495,
0.2358106226,
-0.6289359331,
-0.2160017341,
-0.4805571437,
-0.1269081235,
-0.199582532,
-0.2277261913,
-0.3444644511,
-0.5998834968,
-0.3307510614,
-0.0414338335,
0.0358800143,
0.974162817,
-0.1830413193,
0.1163152084,
-0.4846365154,
0.0031052888,
0.4043984711,
0.1455649287,
0.0383167788,
-0.840420723,
-0.2126894295,
0.0941907316,
-0.3044813573,
-0.6263279915,
0.4254211783,
0.2663063705,
0.4218230247,
0.4009181559,
-0.2005738765,
0.5436292291,
-0.3252376914,
0.7419028282,
0.168221578,
-0.9960954189,
0.3589475453,
-0.0426547229,
0.403765291,
0.058805652,
0.3979598284,
-0.5816074014,
-0.4623308182,
-0.6625186205,
-0.650622189,
0.7501319647,
-0.1182823703,
0.5389754772,
0.0263383426,
0.4074293077,
0.4736510515,
0.2699968219,
-0.998693347,
-0.1503057033,
-0.0433561206,
-0.0986181572,
-0.3635760844,
-0.2664741576,
0.1277070493,
-0.3763540983,
0.4137971997,
-0.3115529716,
0.4075068533,
-0.1580494493,
-0.2403469384,
-0.4026673138,
0.2291050553,
0.6167876124,
0.8920943737,
0.0071173119,
0.3079658747,
-0.1138658226,
-0.2037826777,
0.1966228932,
-0.3005212843,
0.0528226718,
-0.2908233702,
0.6155190468,
0.6264187694,
0.2088331282,
-0.8350598216,
0.5096784234,
0.051575359,
-0.1643895507,
-0.5254496932,
0.2930377424,
0.244565621,
0.1231369153,
0.3619031906,
0.2197129577,
-0.1419990808,
-0.7876991034,
-0.2582136989,
0.6122058034,
-0.299608916,
-0.5339186192,
0.5603425503,
-0.0953904986,
-0.3450088501,
0.8854982853,
-0.0363402776,
-0.411020577,
1.2192262411,
0.7168977857,
0.8182376027,
0.1197312027,
0.0638101324,
0.3938934803,
0.5205269456,
-0.3327556252,
-0.0925647989,
0.1646857709,
-0.9341474771,
-0.1844162643,
-0.5170610547,
-0.2689204812,
0.162760973,
-0.4024780989,
0.1091034636,
-0.558955431,
0.0211730413,
-0.1921168566,
-0.2810645103,
-0.7500777841,
-0.0232820157,
0.0413980484,
0.7263050675,
-1.0048388243,
0.917495966,
0.8444507718,
-0.4160283208,
-0.6765722036,
0.1636466086,
-0.1413245201,
-0.7479482293,
0.956065774,
0.3256873786,
0.1912579536,
-0.2131366581,
-0.7490274906,
-0.8958180547,
0.8501959443,
0.5141457319,
-0.3998962343,
-0.2844188511,
0.3442067206,
0.7248151302,
-0.4571718872,
0.355861932,
0.5860549808,
0.4851881862,
-0.206745863,
-1.138962388,
-0.125579372,
0.0936606452,
0.1785829812,
0.1365372837,
-0.5583985448,
1.3777772188,
-0.9123850465,
-0.1307812184,
0.2059419006,
0.3062755466,
-0.0781022161,
0.1461228877,
0.2055016756,
0.4153260887,
0.7010604143,
-0.1531044096,
1.3067326546,
0.0492744483,
0.3470806479,
1.057795167,
-0.2082087994,
0.7880121469,
0.6713027358,
-0.4741251767,
0.5147544146,
0.3940437436,
-0.0282127801,
0.2301945686,
0.4950536489,
0.1836346984,
-0.4903661609,
0.5095658898,
-0.2813232243,
0.4627839327,
0.524967432,
-0.5602374077,
-0.1285026819,
0.039830815,
-0.1191493645,
0.1703706384,
-0.3881952763,
0.5468004346,
0.1383248568,
-0.3960457742,
0.8875294924,
0.0010817061,
0.7900061607,
-0.3460180163,
-0.0783931091,
-0.250308156,
0.4916223586,
-0.2606399059,
-0.8003982902,
0.3038335741,
-0.3164802194,
-0.2292165458,
-0.1935292631,
0.5032274723,
-0.2257389426,
-0.4475815594,
0.1935911775,
0.352270335,
0.2495302856,
-0.165806964,
-0.4718218744,
0.0492239036,
0.0774344727,
-0.1211203635,
0.621409595,
0.3616399765,
0.0824037716,
1.0748558044,
0.3736619651,
0.2675676644,
0.3129072189,
-0.4869265258,
0.6150781512,
-0.5090356469,
-0.0312151797,
-0.9040104151,
0.03995125,
0.1612853706,
-0.2224701494,
0.6919388175,
0.4145831168,
1.1817713976,
-0.4456491172,
0.7575449347,
0.0450968929,
0.3023271561,
-0.2155014426,
0.7376093268,
-0.7531414628,
0.3668620586,
-0.1243846938,
-0.9247549176,
-0.3025447428,
0.5514247417,
-0.4350120127,
-0.0575329661,
0.427488625,
0.8278992772,
-0.132283628,
-0.2995847464,
0.5613042116,
0.6232569814,
0.4012522399,
0.6646458507,
0.8638269305,
-0.4811041653,
0.5099745989,
-0.1511226892,
-0.1125525385,
-0.3742692769,
-0.8082151413,
-0.9100697041,
-0.6123380065,
-0.3615004122,
-0.3462325633,
0.0615579002,
0.8454514146,
0.4285351336,
-0.7487578988,
-0.3237066567,
-0.3220357597,
0.4422731102,
-0.2639355361,
-0.2094143033,
0.0701731667,
-0.5522450209,
-0.9177519083,
0.1517666727,
0.1909321845,
0.0849117935,
-0.310975939,
-0.1220778152,
0.2437099367,
0.1444243342,
0.3352305889,
0.7732514143,
-0.9768395424,
-0.179354623,
-0.5085070729,
-0.4655808806,
0.0545036122,
0.8824873567,
-0.8686754107,
0.2882418931,
0.5916981697,
0.5017327666,
-0.0522456765,
-0.3721452057,
0.5890549421,
-0.3468704522,
0.1733897477,
-0.0709338039,
0.3852689862,
0.3402530551,
-0.2637903988,
0.2971860766,
0.2898614109,
-0.6490121484,
-1.0825220346,
0.3347926736,
-0.4239045382,
-0.5449373126,
1.241776824,
-0.027728403,
-0.2578048408,
-0.0675337911,
-0.0303502772,
-0.1945562065,
-0.0340148285,
0.8366280794,
0.6326952577,
-0.1666068882,
0.1989948601,
-0.3797730505,
0.5328994393,
0.340674758,
-0.2917713821,
0.4885860682,
0.2905262411,
0.6557114124,
0.1592479646,
0.5073113441,
-0.15294303,
0.2752926052,
0.0478323326,
-0.0629244372,
-0.0104466425,
-0.233793959,
-0.6009203792,
-0.0342583433,
0.5522788167,
0.2806289792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15501v1 | Deriving Language Models from Masked Language Models | 2023-05-24T18:42:45 | 2023-05-24T18:42:45 | Lucas Torroba Hennigen, Yoon Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Masked language models (MLM) do not explicitly define a distribution over
language, i.e., they are not language models per se. However, recent work has
implicitly treated them as such for the purposes of generation and scoring.
This paper studies methods for deriving explicit joint distributions from MLMs,
focusing on distributions over two tokens, which makes it possible to calculate
exact distributional properties. We find that an approach based on identifying
joints whose conditionals are closest to those of the MLM works well and
outperforms existing Markov random field-based approaches. We further find that
this derived model's conditionals can even occasionally outperform the original
MLM's conditionals. | [
-0.1696620286,
-0.7279624939,
0.6465667486,
0.2126911134,
-0.1054939851,
0.1577820629,
-0.3162538409,
-0.6308473945,
0.228355214,
0.837310493,
-0.5073720217,
-0.7633885741,
-0.6473329663,
-0.0856826827,
-0.3319449723,
0.9577705264,
-0.106925264,
-0.0634812042,
-0.2160801142,
-0.3728630841,
-0.2149781436,
-0.6903085113,
-0.2156782001,
-0.3491491675,
0.1907157153,
-0.2958788872,
0.6351920962,
0.8077021837,
0.4796620309,
0.2980132699,
0.0544804037,
-0.0987310186,
-0.2746264338,
0.1221013814,
0.0259139575,
-0.5471907854,
-0.1282871813,
0.3378744125,
0.6931484342,
1.1585280895,
0.097384654,
0.1669270694,
-0.0657264888,
0.5969367623,
-0.9640532732,
0.4177126884,
-0.6810798645,
0.3873424828,
-0.2029536813,
-0.2621673346,
-0.6507531404,
-0.2595485151,
0.0682456791,
-0.3219686747,
0.4258430898,
0.0662842542,
0.7836204767,
-0.2891709208,
-0.5028046966,
-0.2683128417,
-0.9028294086,
0.7831773162,
-0.3971070051,
0.380281657,
0.5938088298,
0.4693456292,
-0.2746015489,
-0.6490558386,
-0.4166832864,
-0.4742570221,
-0.2430084795,
-0.1537533253,
-0.1453025639,
0.1490423232,
0.3562856913,
0.2330828905,
-0.3726550937,
-0.0283424705,
-0.318292886,
0.0449849032,
0.7131069899,
0.2727223337,
0.4735461473,
-0.1049197689,
-0.7491725087,
-0.0355269648,
-0.8965391517,
0.1097867414,
0.8031961322,
0.3959017098,
-0.3999422193,
0.799747467,
-0.1477619559,
0.5861626863,
-0.2093493342,
-0.2709335983,
0.1308002919,
-0.0175101832,
-0.4164380133,
-0.2620407939,
0.8002276421,
0.0839982554,
0.1584518999,
-0.4769572914,
-0.5720088482,
-0.1339826435,
-0.1443777531,
-0.356520921,
-0.5870337486,
-0.0896404833,
-0.6096348166,
-0.4947600663,
0.2522646487,
-0.2893122137,
-0.4419209659,
-0.1670580059,
0.7169035673,
0.0004447862,
-0.597063303,
-0.0704177395,
-0.4655070603,
0.1873760819,
-0.153582409,
-1.0290361643,
0.613847971,
0.8755121231,
0.6495591998,
-0.2516574562,
0.0586139336,
-0.399929136,
0.25414446,
-0.6907280087,
0.6564668417,
-0.6587126255,
-0.0411063582,
0.3885581493,
-0.0614835955,
-0.1483142078,
-0.6818128824,
0.034785077,
-0.5359477401,
0.2670938373,
-0.2163951099,
-0.7066344023,
-0.133801803,
-0.0299515445,
-0.6751371622,
0.8629962206,
0.2125912905,
-0.8051437736,
0.668462038,
-0.5849875808,
-0.365760684,
0.2806304395,
-0.4075844586,
-0.2566537261,
0.0862571821,
-0.1295555681,
0.5435015559,
-0.052736219,
0.4227228165,
-0.6034619808,
-0.0530468002,
0.3472049832,
-0.5656474829,
1.0047574043,
0.2222412229,
-0.4021512866,
-0.0104996283,
-0.8076077104,
-0.0875475779,
0.0846067369,
-0.059805382,
-0.3967562616,
0.0443834364,
0.1006168947,
0.2810958624,
-0.0743376464,
-0.2733199298,
0.0695287809,
-0.6814201474,
-0.0562954955,
0.7238181233,
-0.0675660521,
0.7394199967,
-0.1316900402,
0.6490138173,
-0.0442472585,
0.0211230684,
-0.0021403849,
-0.6925160289,
-0.7839172482,
-0.6081195474,
0.4335047007,
0.5088683963,
-0.650346756,
0.5932902694,
0.1244064271,
-0.1709271818,
-0.540689528,
0.1583049446,
0.7038393617,
0.0782975852,
0.0182299651,
-0.2332199961,
-0.5330848098,
-1.0934972763,
-0.4797536731,
-0.3332391679,
-0.0511217415,
0.0727459416,
0.2110988945,
0.1656013876,
1.0113780499,
-0.5354976654,
-0.0905178264,
-0.54467237,
0.0195873417,
0.1086102128,
0.4599813819,
0.7043760419,
-0.6677259803,
-0.5221600533,
0.0195910316,
-0.8434138894,
-0.1291132718,
0.0866147876,
-0.1141455919,
0.3977691829,
0.4636527598,
-0.8461636901,
0.6112766266,
0.6964800358,
-0.3644059002,
0.4423354864,
-0.1035629436,
-0.3220632076,
-1.0135579109,
0.2177777439,
-0.0343209729,
-0.7188948989,
-0.9558302164,
0.3143271804,
-0.149253279,
0.03808669,
-0.4363512993,
0.925583899,
-0.7724792957,
-0.4510496557,
-0.2802587152,
-0.0750408173,
-0.1032351702,
0.5033626556,
0.1985139102,
0.1543146074,
0.6456254125,
-0.3470274806,
0.2627096772,
-0.2795821428,
-0.4581089914,
0.1321920305,
-0.4611530602,
-0.0785971954,
-0.2298468351,
0.2132624984,
-1.0527120829,
-0.195681408,
0.7336289287,
-0.1313650161,
0.5442774892,
-0.557936132,
-0.4118346274,
-0.1643325686,
-0.2687839866,
0.3945615292,
0.6470566392,
-0.6381559968,
0.3918373287,
0.818864584,
-0.0154785002,
-0.7537446618,
-0.6288126111,
-0.1437687427,
-0.2712788582,
-0.4633788168,
0.1045240536,
-0.0104918191,
-0.7301480174,
0.1838096827,
-0.0601897761,
-0.1647522599,
0.0331726745,
0.3903900683,
0.1158131212,
-0.3203471005,
0.232409507,
-0.1365596354,
-0.1687538475,
0.1573067158,
-0.1304644197,
0.5153496265,
0.3515228033,
-0.3538107872,
-0.1352271438,
0.6250193715,
-0.006714331,
0.0502921268,
1.0864844322,
0.4652226865,
-0.5373395681,
-0.4671086371,
-0.6792168617,
-0.1475944817,
-0.4960585535,
0.1393073648,
-0.6710246205,
-0.5921593904,
0.6772370338,
0.3179446161,
-0.0213968772,
0.5714839101,
0.8034569025,
0.0447670631,
1.2778965235,
0.8426840901,
0.2329964936,
0.4007128477,
-0.1970095336,
0.3620729744,
-0.3122529685,
-0.5496184826,
-0.4039523304,
0.0474795699,
-0.8617002368,
-0.4972919524,
0.0714908391,
0.3165560961,
0.1841283292,
0.3123079538,
0.024675142,
0.7704393268,
0.6637910604,
-0.1439512968,
0.0525061674,
0.1315221637,
-0.449031353,
0.3250878453,
-0.5767849684,
-0.5471134186,
0.9181069732,
0.5420921445,
0.216269955,
0.2182807177,
0.7992907166,
0.2640519738,
0.6090662479,
-0.4025647342,
0.4809738994,
-0.1120367721,
-0.8370726109,
-0.118377015,
-0.5324463844,
-0.9449224472,
0.3050382435,
-0.4527356029,
-0.9064563513,
0.1582286805,
-0.0692630559,
0.1194772124,
0.4650138021,
-0.8224251866,
0.8281196952,
0.3575256467,
0.1622254699,
0.3957947493,
-0.7442706227,
0.8461092114,
-0.0342823341,
0.2560296357,
-0.4745921791,
0.1351478994,
0.7362598777,
-0.5870116949,
0.7334583998,
-0.2917081416,
0.0840928853,
0.3127861917,
0.3017897904,
0.5232173204,
0.0541919507,
0.0167121459,
0.0669485107,
0.0550456904,
-0.5338216424,
-0.7428869605,
0.7504100204,
-0.8120747209,
-0.5212335587,
-0.2137768567,
-0.5306783319,
-0.1574175209,
0.2006978244,
0.1497340053,
0.4476791024,
-0.0991067588,
-0.1803888828,
0.0918289125,
-0.2541805208,
0.6761542559,
0.56688416,
-0.4755539298,
-0.2031679153,
0.7540183663,
-0.0362755693,
0.395042181,
0.4160307646,
0.1337031126,
-0.671233654,
-0.4012832344,
-0.3695266247,
0.2651167512,
-0.9921818376,
-0.0884822384,
-0.8458068371,
-0.4292839766,
-0.5237220526,
0.1452286839,
-0.3813031316,
-0.7629108429,
0.0274713561,
-0.2913534641,
0.1986216158,
0.9505786896,
-0.190683797,
-0.0518980548,
-0.4826572537,
0.52199018,
0.3127889335,
0.4858120084,
-0.3318967521,
-0.2756125629,
-0.0390963666,
0.0550716817,
0.0084178876,
-1.032648325,
0.5426589847,
0.0765508115,
0.691013515,
0.4192293584,
0.062022876,
0.5637559891,
-0.448647052,
0.7075414062,
0.4162629545,
-0.8597334027,
0.1132133082,
-0.2636313736,
-0.2996868491,
0.2456339449,
0.341361165,
-0.1717201918,
-0.8249678612,
-0.776448369,
-0.6973204017,
0.7721039057,
0.621828258,
0.4337327182,
-0.2041843086,
0.2221956998,
0.315045625,
0.1001550853,
-0.9854890704,
-0.7922303081,
0.2433267534,
-0.3141518533,
-0.2118828893,
-0.1566225737,
-0.0402378142,
-0.042268075,
0.3966276348,
0.1324229091,
0.247634843,
-0.3519537449,
-0.2383452803,
-0.3265069127,
-0.0609310642,
0.7127627134,
0.8345673084,
-0.3284969926,
0.5417718887,
-0.0798543394,
-0.1604969054,
0.2432865798,
0.042462863,
-0.1779220402,
0.3237745464,
0.4276531041,
1.0962408781,
-0.1267924607,
-0.6967827082,
0.9361039996,
0.164322868,
-0.1415291876,
-0.2725833356,
0.1452475339,
0.2108482867,
0.3925168216,
0.268001169,
0.1032302901,
0.1119541004,
-0.6522455215,
0.3639856577,
0.6967750788,
-0.4334215224,
-0.437648505,
0.4548549354,
-0.198467508,
-0.635633409,
0.2329918295,
-0.5056505203,
-0.2196932286,
0.5229849219,
0.7528586388,
1.1458281279,
-0.0869513676,
0.4699127972,
-0.0602791868,
0.1837174743,
-0.0081985258,
0.0096110953,
-0.0219496153,
-0.7166901231,
-0.3123457134,
-0.7324464917,
-0.0198292024,
0.1625564098,
-0.5654779673,
0.3594490886,
-0.2668694258,
-0.0168335028,
0.3086555898,
-0.1382322758,
-0.9330574274,
0.1489300281,
0.3201167285,
0.4040122032,
-1.2031099796,
0.8817458749,
0.3966884911,
-0.2933152914,
-0.9639050961,
-0.1199506372,
-0.1714856327,
-0.9160036445,
0.9377681017,
0.0592302941,
0.2875659466,
-0.3044949174,
-0.2592545748,
-0.6495845318,
0.4793559611,
0.5452830791,
-0.2919763327,
0.2450983822,
0.5897629857,
0.6050118804,
-0.6115745306,
0.424484849,
0.3743492663,
0.0765324458,
-0.0466099828,
-0.7898139954,
0.0053297789,
-0.1281643361,
0.1080260649,
0.395550251,
-0.0433442593,
0.8214296699,
-0.0516969115,
-0.4198465347,
-0.0298722312,
0.4641173184,
0.4395431876,
0.46224159,
0.4533998072,
0.329051435,
0.4188634753,
0.2456404567,
1.1613115072,
-0.3697339594,
0.5691735744,
0.6313418746,
-0.2857269645,
0.9673715234,
0.3212957084,
-0.3376601934,
0.3756914437,
0.2952196896,
0.1944676638,
0.6173914075,
0.3466112018,
-0.6006010175,
-0.3372294307,
0.0006587673,
-0.1862923652,
0.4899975061,
0.1039968506,
-0.7452476025,
-0.2269427478,
-0.0900636762,
-0.1020257026,
0.0765566975,
0.040717978,
0.8975636363,
0.2723922431,
-0.5263559818,
0.550611794,
0.5110685825,
0.2496148944,
-0.2258678824,
-0.1554554999,
-0.382778734,
-0.0833827853,
0.130632773,
-0.7496206164,
0.3544902802,
0.0852374583,
-0.3079552352,
-0.177521199,
0.8548388481,
-0.7602571845,
-0.8026804328,
0.1743961275,
0.5561314821,
0.4101409614,
0.2159784138,
-0.6535198689,
0.0208168998,
-0.3319562674,
-0.2706362605,
0.5128350258,
0.2628508508,
-0.1632798612,
0.6656492352,
0.7926115394,
0.2089904696,
0.5352735519,
0.1349791437,
0.5091982484,
-0.6220759749,
-0.4561161101,
-1.0274343491,
0.3439028561,
-0.0191407148,
-0.063701354,
0.5674626231,
0.5197002292,
0.6537605524,
-0.2599180043,
0.706707418,
0.2566887736,
0.4183293879,
-0.7496333122,
0.7279042006,
-0.397323221,
0.5278807878,
-0.2997595966,
-1.189132452,
-0.6977671981,
0.3699256182,
-0.1896723807,
0.1882977188,
0.5084043145,
1.0002465248,
-0.1781281084,
-0.3867371678,
0.6603676677,
-0.0831756443,
0.3865725398,
0.3488140702,
0.9789784551,
-0.4455302656,
0.2567775846,
-0.5269441009,
0.0769657195,
-0.1550351083,
-0.9263477325,
-1.2446171045,
-0.5055644512,
-0.3960044682,
-0.2705821097,
0.2437080145,
1.0656933784,
0.9090374708,
-0.9209485054,
-0.0425551273,
-0.2799277604,
0.3974583447,
-0.0555722117,
-0.2404869944,
0.5845405459,
-0.3033392429,
-0.6096533537,
0.3293729424,
0.455427289,
-0.0061906506,
-0.4669887424,
-0.1951250136,
0.1948062032,
0.2288412005,
0.6024922132,
0.1477878094,
-0.9469971657,
-0.4317003191,
-0.3329297602,
-0.3489582837,
-0.0952297747,
0.8282316923,
-0.6230139136,
0.4512425959,
0.7389019728,
0.1046015322,
0.4102710485,
-0.113739565,
0.7631806731,
-1.2431960106,
0.4354511201,
0.2305278927,
0.1434233338,
0.14086622,
0.0825439245,
0.1350999027,
0.4402204156,
-0.0820046812,
-1.1948647499,
0.271199286,
-0.8646916151,
-0.2409861386,
1.3916121721,
-0.4410752356,
-0.1124926805,
-0.376903832,
0.2267323434,
0.3085154593,
0.2599438727,
0.5912217498,
0.2313831747,
0.2477552593,
-0.2268250585,
-0.457051903,
0.7325550318,
0.20525527,
-0.5451171994,
-0.1079563722,
0.0028829691,
0.7119236588,
-0.1954733878,
0.781434834,
0.0973928943,
0.0842039585,
0.2202671468,
0.0992226973,
-0.0049523809,
-0.346429199,
-0.1720880717,
0.4258237779,
0.1809022427,
-0.1654768884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15498v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15498v1 | Large Language Models for User Interest Journeys | 2023-05-24T18:40:43 | 2023-05-24T18:40:43 | Konstantina Christakopoulou, Alberto Lalama, Cj Adams, Iris Qu, Yifat Amir, Samer Chucri, Pierce Vollucci, Fabio Soldo, Dina Bseiso, Sarah Scodel, Lucas Dixon, Ed H. Chi, Minmin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities in natural
language understanding and generation. Their potential for deeper user
understanding and improved personalized user experience on recommendation
platforms is, however, largely untapped. This paper aims to address this gap.
Recommender systems today capture users' interests through encoding their
historical activities on the platforms. The generated user representations are
hard to examine or interpret. On the other hand, if we were to ask people about
interests they pursue in their life, they might talk about their hobbies, like
I just started learning the ukulele, or their relaxation routines, e.g., I like
to watch Saturday Night Live, or I want to plant a vertical garden. We argue,
and demonstrate through extensive experiments, that LLMs as foundation models
can reason through user activities, and describe their interests in nuanced and
interesting ways, similar to how a human would.
We define interest journeys as the persistent and overarching user interests,
in other words, the non-transient ones. These are the interests that we believe
will benefit most from the nuanced and personalized descriptions. We introduce
a framework in which we first perform personalized extraction of interest
journeys, and then summarize the extracted journeys via LLMs, using techniques
like few-shot prompting, prompt-tuning and fine-tuning. Together, our results
in prompting LLMs to name extracted user journeys in a large-scale industrial
platform demonstrate great potential of these models in providing deeper, more
interpretable, and controllable user understanding. We believe LLM powered user
understanding can be a stepping stone to entirely new user experiences on
recommendation platforms that are journey-aware, assistive, and enabling
frictionless conversation down the line. | [
-0.3430006206,
-0.5551973581,
1.0933463573,
0.0344246589,
-0.0513669774,
0.1120709404,
-0.318980068,
-0.4761718214,
0.4968154728,
0.7713369727,
-0.8459178805,
-0.7004932761,
-0.3359161913,
-0.3036406934,
-0.2966522574,
0.9056079388,
-0.2083966285,
-0.3309393823,
-0.1959251016,
0.0017960018,
-0.5369362235,
-0.5786124468,
-0.417075485,
-0.5340575576,
0.9666068554,
0.3439241052,
0.5562731028,
0.3502900302,
0.4158534408,
0.2305181026,
-0.2813033462,
0.0381342508,
-0.721370697,
0.3088039458,
-0.1909351349,
-0.5307989717,
-0.0488723032,
-0.0872100368,
0.2921695411,
0.9357716441,
0.0496209972,
-0.0608717501,
-0.0400330871,
0.7082452774,
-0.2505534291,
0.1280408204,
-0.5412759185,
0.1717998534,
-0.2032628357,
-0.2665747404,
-0.3555490375,
-0.1700083464,
0.1754458398,
-0.3479849398,
0.1543511003,
0.2260341942,
0.611921072,
-0.2010100782,
-0.6845721602,
-0.4803557694,
-0.8247306347,
0.8007127047,
-0.4559375346,
0.339589417,
0.4029371142,
0.5161673427,
-0.3870279491,
-0.5889189839,
-0.246784851,
-0.3940896392,
-0.1014914736,
-0.1825155467,
-0.1058044657,
-0.056470681,
0.1412080973,
0.5808183551,
-0.5797253251,
0.2691940367,
-0.1894298345,
-0.0256647095,
0.6044167876,
0.4580213428,
0.3338592052,
-0.0438093692,
-0.3871672451,
0.111295484,
-0.9224769473,
0.3857727945,
0.3607104719,
0.2398886085,
-0.1481929719,
0.7669142485,
-0.4926775098,
0.5823953152,
0.1905816793,
-0.0006109373,
-0.0135067813,
-0.2254025787,
0.0062452066,
0.0054165833,
0.6597698331,
0.4942923188,
0.4854989946,
-0.5148932934,
-0.1639033109,
-0.0350246392,
0.121912919,
-0.9300251603,
-0.1966316998,
0.3428841233,
-0.5254478455,
-0.2859238386,
0.1774409413,
-0.6157476306,
-0.7897655964,
-0.3503910303,
0.0630014762,
-0.2625841498,
-0.1160736158,
0.4488684833,
0.1126549244,
0.0120029813,
0.3998222649,
-1.209318161,
0.1251393259,
0.822678864,
0.8228322268,
-0.2911424339,
-0.1619319916,
-0.4875534475,
0.111092791,
-0.1628314257,
0.7214369774,
-0.7543657422,
-0.6349197626,
0.2459864765,
0.1221381351,
0.3313587606,
-0.2744562626,
0.2271566391,
-0.7459621429,
0.2430503666,
-0.5146788955,
-0.4773241282,
-0.4468124509,
0.3206558824,
-0.2596005499,
0.7080699801,
-0.009858991,
-0.3068195283,
0.3406606615,
-0.9161493182,
-0.5797812939,
0.093115069,
-0.0969723389,
0.1853418797,
0.3243967593,
0.0535673611,
0.7148551345,
-0.3222299516,
0.5160391331,
-0.3731616437,
-0.3224841058,
0.3657292724,
-0.3825049996,
0.4506278336,
0.1016568989,
-0.2427041084,
0.3441134989,
-0.4712512791,
-0.3678522706,
0.0156102749,
-0.4268587232,
-0.3723251522,
0.0918357968,
0.2765149772,
0.1476768106,
0.5725458264,
-0.4685821831,
0.4608705938,
-0.7957309484,
0.5871728063,
0.912743628,
0.174053207,
0.3620889485,
-0.2688649297,
0.6616771221,
0.0004330379,
-0.1577089578,
-0.7703223228,
-0.3693794906,
-0.8041164279,
0.2543469667,
0.0093101403,
0.0767438412,
-0.2843622267,
0.4010955989,
-0.3410966992,
-0.3343125582,
-0.0734969676,
0.3443042934,
-0.0146451965,
0.1980325133,
0.2591729462,
-0.3045557141,
-0.3334681988,
-0.6319255233,
-0.2241074443,
-0.2403423488,
-0.1999778599,
0.8195780516,
0.1585907042,
-0.5209105611,
0.8446100354,
-0.7219612598,
-0.2157649696,
-0.3770403564,
0.0482259803,
0.5571532249,
0.0788539276,
0.4375231266,
-0.9270120859,
-0.6743597984,
0.2806061208,
-0.5961462855,
0.0370765403,
-0.3298805952,
-0.2051775903,
-0.2446268201,
0.2525422275,
-0.5702004433,
0.2328614891,
0.2454672456,
-0.5113930106,
0.0902580991,
-0.2169218808,
0.1701230258,
-1.0116920471,
-0.0256461799,
0.2351042777,
-0.3856871128,
-0.3711958528,
-0.213460952,
-0.3887277246,
-0.1243493408,
-0.3340775371,
0.7103248239,
-0.3795932829,
-0.0593745783,
-0.426739037,
0.1048381552,
-0.0013403693,
0.4765721858,
-0.0337415561,
0.5262181759,
0.6941949725,
-0.5812395811,
0.3617940843,
0.3539747,
-0.3669446707,
0.2511979342,
-0.5353746414,
0.3721826077,
-0.0204330254,
0.1747205257,
-1.147906065,
-0.3835426271,
0.0073961369,
-0.1089858189,
0.0788397267,
-0.269423455,
-0.36654374,
-0.2293549031,
-0.1932584941,
-0.0443234518,
0.4558928013,
-0.6481758356,
0.6705733538,
0.3551886678,
-0.1327132136,
-0.3561322987,
-0.5855724812,
0.3783527613,
-0.5669992566,
-0.5792737603,
0.3939499855,
-0.251376003,
-0.2737796009,
-0.1463941038,
0.0156289656,
0.172668308,
0.286732465,
0.8039764166,
0.1908244193,
-0.220443964,
0.053350646,
-0.107230112,
-0.2084337175,
0.1088488474,
-0.4763914645,
0.8542032242,
-0.0124505227,
-0.4372495711,
-0.3331663013,
0.4148494005,
0.8642216921,
-0.0962178186,
0.4629190266,
0.6685307622,
-0.1512015313,
0.1001733243,
-0.5638744235,
-0.2502651513,
-0.5089197755,
0.1823775917,
-0.3821339011,
-1.3824646473,
0.4247199893,
-0.3253031969,
0.3084819317,
0.2751219869,
0.8858353496,
-0.3813148737,
1.0377933979,
0.9581011534,
-0.1642332524,
0.4963762164,
-0.1767887622,
0.2739317417,
-0.7783041,
-0.2809458971,
-0.184844166,
-0.5815045238,
-0.4693720043,
-0.0477092117,
0.1893022358,
-0.0406469442,
0.0983824879,
0.0790078714,
-0.0934540182,
0.448802799,
0.1350159049,
0.0291266274,
0.1867499202,
0.0797003955,
-0.0148693817,
-0.0947791412,
-0.3215833008,
-0.7158100009,
0.9664139748,
0.3591883183,
0.8014295101,
0.1872320324,
0.4901366234,
0.5861776471,
0.3213491142,
-1.1249319315,
0.521419704,
-0.2369915843,
-0.4780005813,
-0.2005519122,
-0.0830437168,
-1.0952917337,
-0.1120089889,
-0.2390468866,
-1.1285778284,
0.2799950242,
0.3264886439,
-0.5234475732,
0.3628423214,
-0.4439222515,
0.8658383489,
-0.5860573649,
-0.6210639477,
-0.3916679621,
-0.4609587193,
0.3656767607,
-0.0931435376,
0.1142389551,
-0.1484726965,
0.1480537206,
0.4647161663,
-0.0349254608,
1.0176619291,
-0.0222774725,
-0.0453258194,
0.0060526375,
0.3909884393,
0.4955756664,
0.0109677706,
-0.1878015697,
0.0690014139,
-0.2959158421,
0.0130385719,
-0.4891424477,
1.0876276493,
-0.4172070324,
-0.8797900677,
-0.063484408,
-0.4673877656,
-0.2065322548,
0.1822404563,
-0.0773431435,
0.3231245279,
-0.3967994153,
0.5535387397,
0.5968635678,
-0.15466021,
0.3324682415,
0.5429250002,
-0.6097815633,
0.1067356467,
0.8742226362,
-0.1340838671,
-0.1129375473,
0.5526621342,
0.3462336063,
-0.53792274,
-0.6161926389,
-0.3786138594,
0.2773408592,
-0.7114908099,
0.2329049259,
-0.9497243762,
0.384571135,
-0.2425448298,
-0.3602141142,
-0.0482133701,
-0.1156333536,
-0.5804478526,
-0.0727935955,
0.5233991742,
0.9589707851,
0.284879595,
0.5928893089,
-0.7104446888,
0.3780538738,
0.242995277,
0.2616051733,
-0.0187729523,
-0.5186461806,
-0.4074570239,
-0.1653226614,
-0.3362527192,
-0.5469783545,
0.521255374,
0.0401954763,
0.5479712486,
0.8867678046,
-0.1190149635,
0.426422894,
-0.538749814,
0.8524164557,
0.2854716182,
-0.7143521309,
0.5901786685,
-0.4300596118,
0.0142572979,
0.6734879613,
0.7373784781,
-0.7431952357,
0.3065207303,
-0.3981997371,
-0.9140470028,
0.5700643659,
-0.1638273448,
0.4340585768,
0.2726100087,
0.5390099883,
0.2693862319,
0.2477066815,
-0.6844229102,
0.0213982426,
0.1140432954,
-0.1640971899,
-0.3407886028,
-0.4345671535,
0.0090853972,
0.2357593775,
0.48527354,
-0.0674452335,
-0.1891082078,
-0.241493836,
0.0960010663,
-0.3678309321,
0.2808748186,
0.2037375569,
0.8850321174,
-0.2684794068,
0.1049783826,
-0.0322835445,
-0.1415049285,
0.1372141987,
-0.1902627945,
-0.0059552416,
-0.162794143,
-0.0227975454,
1.0214169025,
0.3387663662,
-0.7861444354,
0.4567353427,
-0.1799328476,
0.0857039392,
-0.3427430987,
0.3902873099,
0.4293542802,
0.2306729108,
0.0784640014,
0.0132971145,
0.242557317,
-0.8011244535,
-0.1047540009,
0.477347672,
-0.8065145016,
-0.3813868165,
0.5494099855,
0.2961232364,
-0.7567808628,
0.1426134408,
0.1852841377,
-0.2881736159,
0.2413129508,
0.272004962,
1.041803956,
0.0528174043,
0.0023220861,
-0.0147269787,
0.0757437274,
-0.1742672473,
-0.0534538031,
-0.3709235787,
-0.7152014375,
-0.3146784008,
-0.7670893073,
-0.533829987,
0.2735701501,
-0.4896076918,
0.584345758,
-0.3580210805,
-0.0742020905,
0.1281794459,
-0.2001346648,
-0.59787184,
-0.0206348673,
0.1148630828,
0.5934645534,
-0.9113420844,
0.6246948838,
0.8669546843,
-0.146505326,
-0.4115155935,
0.1599372923,
-0.2325092256,
-0.4135020077,
0.6526079774,
0.415168643,
-0.2483392954,
0.0178221613,
-0.3262078464,
-0.6455783844,
0.9744163156,
0.0917722881,
-0.7759726644,
-0.0166594982,
0.1044425741,
0.561575532,
-0.5869205594,
0.1953050345,
0.3754147589,
0.4436465204,
0.2775611281,
-0.3659491241,
-0.1986167133,
-0.1214437634,
-0.0676108673,
0.1954387724,
-0.6027997136,
0.4980204403,
-0.2413655668,
-0.0740894899,
0.0665689781,
0.5696033835,
0.2359383106,
0.5333498716,
0.7218739986,
0.0158255976,
0.4895529449,
0.0222665314,
1.1583244801,
-0.4000170529,
0.2137838006,
0.7348454595,
-0.5501967669,
0.6280539632,
0.6333853006,
-0.1812554747,
0.5533652902,
0.8529564738,
0.1375341117,
0.4149807096,
0.1830203384,
-0.0429126993,
-0.6049110889,
-0.1593352705,
-0.1825282276,
0.4770923853,
0.4151871502,
-0.475618422,
-0.0908668041,
0.1140989959,
-0.1957833916,
0.1194334105,
-0.0629671216,
0.7467426062,
0.1589920968,
-0.5906242728,
0.3255280256,
0.1298176646,
0.7287218571,
-0.7905064225,
-0.1546585262,
-0.1418325454,
-0.0723090619,
-0.1468108445,
-0.8714230657,
-0.0202397909,
0.2265018672,
-0.4425988197,
-0.5583190322,
0.7409205437,
-0.1724402606,
-0.4278313816,
0.2087437212,
0.3654215038,
0.4465081394,
0.00440457,
-0.5207355618,
-0.0655852631,
0.3766413331,
-0.4375602603,
0.4315148592,
0.4953297377,
-0.0865174755,
0.7860937119,
0.8932561278,
0.0686473995,
-0.3591277897,
0.1532679498,
0.8187064528,
-0.7377954125,
-0.7289263606,
-0.9089004993,
0.4937489629,
0.2822886705,
-0.4121047854,
0.6844443679,
0.5185885429,
0.4429948628,
-0.0158475526,
0.7359786034,
0.2144855559,
0.3419653475,
-0.6552935839,
0.4518481791,
-0.7088976502,
0.7967116237,
0.037946742,
-0.8081307411,
0.0423617028,
0.4950473905,
-0.542137742,
0.1232357323,
0.2552424073,
0.5835579038,
-0.343367219,
-0.0043771085,
0.4192766845,
0.2719606757,
0.5516858697,
0.6662128568,
1.0516082048,
0.1169457361,
0.2889608741,
-0.0754156485,
-0.0995390862,
-0.5259826779,
-0.8083344698,
-1.0182174444,
-0.3760606349,
-0.1620859802,
-0.1941690892,
-0.127481848,
1.0240736008,
0.6926654577,
-0.8320596218,
-0.4900645018,
-0.2892395258,
0.1737052202,
0.2570270896,
-0.2062472552,
0.2639599442,
-0.0479435623,
-0.8113508821,
0.8069733381,
0.5930660963,
-0.0284522567,
-0.9270482063,
-0.0047256793,
0.0680737272,
-0.1254728138,
0.5464030504,
0.2912377417,
-0.9135668278,
-0.1925188303,
0.2196558863,
0.109720692,
0.1615482569,
1.1216827631,
-0.7646878958,
0.4096251726,
0.4483397007,
0.7157590985,
0.9588686228,
-0.04060103,
0.5135182738,
-0.3100250661,
0.065666616,
0.1404560208,
0.5089402199,
0.3987386823,
-0.8258826733,
0.2721731365,
0.0762577802,
-0.4818290472,
-0.7723652124,
0.3463725448,
-1.2332320213,
-0.1896116436,
1.3889740705,
-0.2427024245,
-0.0864018574,
-0.2322148383,
-0.423707962,
-0.1448169798,
-0.4389776886,
0.9257478714,
0.5688145757,
-0.3348043561,
0.1123769134,
-0.6705012918,
0.0267346743,
0.2998584211,
-0.5722894073,
0.3329804242,
0.5622499585,
0.2227725834,
0.2300396264,
0.4000629187,
0.1783473045,
-0.1004126891,
-0.7535768747,
-0.1474220455,
-0.1125457659,
-0.4438094795,
-0.3248392344,
0.3563437164,
0.1281894445,
0.0950037315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15408v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15408v5 | Towards Revealing the Mystery behind Chain of Thought: A Theoretical Perspective | 2023-05-24T17:59:21 | 2023-12-23T02:39:56 | Guhao Feng, Bohang Zhang, Yuntian Gu, Haotian Ye, Di He, Liwei Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CC, cs.CL, stat.ML | Recent studies have discovered that Chain-of-Thought prompting (CoT) can
dramatically improve the performance of Large Language Models (LLMs),
particularly when dealing with complex tasks involving mathematics or
reasoning. Despite the enormous empirical success, the underlying mechanisms
behind CoT and how it unlocks the potential of LLMs remain elusive. In this
paper, we take a first step towards theoretically answering these questions.
Specifically, we examine the expressivity of LLMs with CoT in solving
fundamental mathematical and decision-making problems. By using circuit
complexity theory, we first give impossibility results showing that
bounded-depth Transformers are unable to directly produce correct answers for
basic arithmetic/equation tasks unless the model size grows super-polynomially
with respect to the input length. In contrast, we then prove by construction
that autoregressive Transformers of constant size suffice to solve both tasks
by generating CoT derivations using a commonly used math language format.
Moreover, we show LLMs with CoT can handle a general class of decision-making
problems known as Dynamic Programming, thus justifying its power in tackling
complex real-world tasks. Finally, an extensive set of experiments show that,
while Transformers always fail to directly predict the answers, they can
consistently learn to generate correct solutions step-by-step given sufficient
CoT demonstrations. | [
-0.728433013,
-1.0384703875,
1.2294647694,
0.2436481416,
-0.1651932299,
0.7168991566,
-0.259503752,
-0.4039110243,
0.1205356047,
0.2925286889,
-0.759331882,
0.0208502859,
-0.6501126289,
0.1836258918,
-0.6874972582,
0.7961279154,
-0.3477548659,
-0.2791300714,
-0.0785996541,
0.303576678,
-0.3856198788,
-0.5756802559,
-0.6205477715,
-0.2955209613,
0.6317526698,
0.4440694749,
0.7225784659,
0.2476616502,
0.426058054,
0.2849603593,
-0.2230639607,
0.3598921597,
-0.4241704047,
0.2522175908,
-0.2897188067,
-0.8440029025,
-0.2913531065,
-0.0805772394,
0.4990486503,
0.7777397037,
-0.1555875391,
0.1337919384,
-0.033816129,
1.0729568005,
-0.6992917657,
-0.0134811457,
-0.8347573876,
0.1849307865,
0.2415993214,
-0.197104916,
-0.5142046213,
-0.2637138963,
0.2576517463,
-0.2287597507,
0.139103502,
0.1968607605,
0.506382823,
0.2907991707,
-0.4599500597,
-0.6449977756,
-1.1657413244,
0.650074482,
-0.2428511679,
0.1714664698,
0.1793257594,
0.2567988634,
-0.3268663287,
-0.6836304665,
-0.9204146862,
-0.0871520266,
-0.0019427992,
0.0432532988,
-0.2252528965,
0.2438078374,
0.7572264671,
0.6269559264,
-0.1154851988,
-0.185583204,
-0.3876023889,
0.0555333272,
0.4110179842,
0.3688547313,
0.2307387888,
-0.0569648743,
-0.4079439938,
-0.0768844932,
-0.7034161091,
0.1619914174,
0.2764681876,
-0.0065041692,
-0.0795226842,
0.39169842,
0.1961212307,
0.6538879871,
0.2728051543,
0.2131411284,
-0.3139158189,
-0.0815494135,
-0.2521261573,
0.0676885098,
0.7438906431,
-0.2249754369,
0.5078220963,
0.0378225371,
-0.2994760573,
0.1671947688,
0.4506761134,
-0.2675438225,
-0.3002043962,
0.2658622563,
0.0271033831,
-0.367275387,
0.0904741138,
-0.6917389035,
-0.061380595,
-0.3970867991,
0.3596291244,
-0.0395697132,
-0.4249737263,
0.2773231864,
0.066189833,
0.1471512616,
0.3074851036,
-0.921544075,
0.5163701177,
0.5579814911,
0.7358230352,
-0.2452328503,
-0.0104777897,
-0.3215135038,
-0.0494752079,
-0.8708400726,
0.7690893412,
-0.4038870335,
-0.3138566911,
-0.0816846341,
-0.1791378856,
-0.0534239151,
-0.4656180739,
0.2050139159,
-0.6548844576,
-0.0720214173,
-0.6264185309,
-0.2695253789,
0.2134966701,
0.3569975495,
-0.7274304032,
0.9817169905,
-0.0261298306,
-0.5749095678,
0.053235136,
-0.4969591796,
-0.3536100388,
-0.2463743538,
-0.4365414977,
-0.090165399,
0.5040736198,
0.0825295672,
0.1645184457,
-0.5735273361,
0.4496271312,
-0.0375476293,
-0.2071584165,
0.6700432897,
-0.791384697,
0.5600979328,
0.226825431,
-0.4725729227,
-0.1040938944,
-0.4952534139,
0.1700304002,
0.2480126023,
-0.0340473354,
0.0295069013,
0.0199111439,
-0.6741176844,
0.5295600295,
0.1025616676,
-0.4968437552,
0.3056692183,
-0.2718263865,
0.5897737741,
1.0722007751,
-0.0314729027,
0.3824490607,
-0.1575693786,
0.8339495659,
-0.079440318,
0.1456469595,
-0.0157275237,
-0.400272578,
-1.0569778681,
0.0981455743,
0.3119271994,
0.2986924946,
-0.9517970681,
0.3258878589,
-0.0179695971,
-0.2513414025,
-0.2534064651,
-0.0627104416,
0.3722461164,
0.4416075349,
0.2644123137,
-0.0949029326,
-0.4036082029,
-0.8686074018,
-0.1971342713,
-0.2693269551,
0.1349781752,
0.2609730065,
0.4750882983,
0.0441156738,
1.0019634962,
-0.7667629123,
0.1766917259,
-0.4607831836,
0.0647229105,
0.5833030343,
0.2567578852,
0.0295981225,
-0.6433907151,
-0.2711485922,
-0.094577834,
-0.7569751143,
0.0100411261,
-0.2918750346,
-0.3409004211,
-0.0443086214,
0.3938715756,
-0.8085224032,
0.6184542179,
0.3877950311,
-0.0622203387,
0.862637043,
-0.2883973718,
-0.1673775315,
-0.603220582,
-0.1748318523,
-0.4588139355,
-0.2062896788,
-0.4791718721,
-0.0380447358,
0.0924334899,
-0.1101458147,
-0.4348311424,
0.2538257837,
-0.4927525222,
-0.1900610477,
-0.4141029119,
0.3736524284,
0.008698565,
0.6846500039,
-0.1653571725,
0.8771208525,
0.5980559587,
-1.0462145805,
0.3745723665,
0.1291093081,
-0.2429280281,
0.1219655201,
-0.5938193202,
0.3111887276,
-0.0439334027,
0.3974197507,
-0.8968016505,
0.05134774,
0.0179485418,
-0.148156032,
0.1485916823,
0.153620854,
-0.6104309559,
-0.932226181,
-0.0941945538,
0.6642766595,
0.5470699072,
-0.7375575304,
0.570867002,
0.2430050075,
0.1650811881,
-0.538205564,
-0.7350289226,
-0.0126955407,
0.221448794,
-0.3237409592,
0.2674894631,
-0.1165830642,
-0.3840384483,
-0.2988933027,
-0.6268130541,
0.149634704,
-0.0784821138,
-0.114452064,
0.4367907047,
0.0818625167,
0.4187855422,
0.226762563,
-0.2434537858,
0.5997308493,
-0.3913647532,
0.8839735389,
-0.5024155378,
-0.4449289441,
-0.2648179531,
0.1933834255,
0.7300665975,
-0.1473667026,
0.444578141,
-0.0153401587,
-0.1930342764,
-0.5174173117,
-0.4689119458,
-0.0861166865,
-0.5749108195,
-0.0047138422,
-0.5684075952,
-0.6244951487,
0.507602334,
-0.4211551845,
-0.172934562,
0.3914957345,
0.5657917261,
-0.0106690247,
1.0727567673,
0.5647630692,
0.2144754976,
0.3371384144,
-0.8054196835,
0.7957398891,
-1.0531789064,
-0.2619916797,
-0.1799522787,
-0.5309564471,
-0.6022924185,
-0.3674329817,
0.4968709648,
0.1762040406,
-0.2783679068,
0.3374176025,
-0.7087563872,
0.8490931988,
0.2658719718,
0.2542051971,
0.2440771013,
-0.1414763629,
-0.5645315647,
0.2554139495,
-0.9470707774,
-0.4159142077,
0.8182942867,
0.1564986557,
0.9620574713,
-0.0387387052,
0.5589814782,
0.2179630846,
-0.0713271275,
-0.9043752551,
0.6663808823,
0.1501439065,
-0.579782486,
-0.2343064398,
-0.249305144,
-0.9379748106,
0.0095222229,
-0.1559121907,
-0.7189745307,
0.3370964527,
0.3087563515,
-0.369814992,
0.6595708728,
-0.5987680554,
0.314214021,
-0.5647334456,
-0.6149926782,
-0.3826191425,
-0.529950738,
0.3684749603,
-0.1066788286,
0.2744649947,
0.1251511276,
-0.020471273,
0.7087100148,
-0.5703950524,
0.5880210996,
0.2457420826,
-0.5318782926,
0.7008411288,
0.5529274344,
0.635997057,
0.1566258818,
0.1397496909,
-0.2167214453,
-0.166716367,
-0.3196623027,
-1.0210206509,
0.8241209984,
-0.5577899814,
-1.0629349947,
-0.539467454,
-0.5031847954,
-0.3744782805,
0.1097206473,
0.3409709334,
0.5264182091,
0.2394402027,
-0.1402100027,
0.8949517012,
-0.0807929784,
0.5976707935,
0.0173524227,
-0.4729433954,
-0.3074652255,
0.6658329368,
0.0327793844,
0.7209992409,
0.3286299706,
0.2630685568,
-0.3335661888,
-0.0858594254,
-0.3683196902,
0.2193553299,
-0.9550006986,
-0.1838826984,
-0.6680654883,
-0.3970744908,
0.3063181043,
-0.4138150513,
-0.480196178,
-0.6694180369,
0.0523173511,
-0.3931239843,
0.3398993611,
1.1919649839,
0.1196371168,
0.0011442796,
-0.3629990816,
0.4467669427,
0.6577504277,
0.4380565584,
0.5964853168,
-0.0518314727,
-0.1367406845,
0.0746189803,
-0.6389969587,
-0.7298976779,
0.0668257028,
-0.5029335618,
0.3059516549,
0.3111156523,
0.2342010438,
0.8792798519,
-0.454736203,
0.8204525709,
0.4258314073,
-1.2707699537,
0.636715889,
0.0266954303,
0.3414635062,
0.2138126194,
0.3870358765,
-0.1516798884,
-0.5043024421,
-0.869446218,
-0.8483304977,
0.4798924029,
0.4143420458,
0.1054306254,
-0.373319,
0.3453569412,
0.1132921055,
0.2514612377,
-0.5910607576,
-0.2980381846,
0.2024786323,
0.0374186262,
0.2453015149,
-0.1099962741,
0.0769196525,
-0.4469965994,
0.3354258835,
0.0257310811,
0.6354349256,
0.6339023709,
0.0054187826,
-0.3753991723,
0.3545616269,
0.5709291101,
1.0970156193,
0.204151243,
0.5607402921,
0.4188220501,
-0.2693967819,
0.4159273803,
-0.8039642572,
0.1466454268,
-0.1676480472,
0.3672257066,
0.7120159268,
0.1004637256,
-0.7119398117,
0.3124130666,
-0.0248308461,
-0.2714297175,
-0.4619826674,
0.3097909391,
-0.1065791324,
0.1482419819,
0.5827764869,
0.233160153,
0.0321970992,
-0.8055636883,
-0.0535637774,
0.4532900751,
-0.4301765561,
-0.2520771623,
0.4912954271,
0.0099715814,
-0.7755805254,
0.621917963,
0.2178579122,
-0.8976432681,
0.8826147914,
0.7294165492,
0.9055110812,
0.2011124343,
0.1278073043,
0.1721182615,
0.2053452581,
-0.1281828284,
0.2514364719,
-0.4410334229,
-0.4740895927,
-0.476513952,
-0.4290190041,
-0.5240863562,
-0.0407547243,
-0.7779694796,
0.224604696,
-0.817433238,
-0.2739964426,
-0.277660042,
-0.1823409051,
-0.7520267367,
0.1896703541,
0.0702438504,
0.8994327784,
-0.4012742639,
0.5795411468,
0.1336346269,
-0.1295907944,
-1.0171551704,
0.2479409277,
-0.4218826592,
-0.7708368301,
0.6654518247,
0.113084279,
-0.7307751775,
0.0644712746,
-0.8258592486,
-0.8841335773,
0.9416639805,
0.2403167784,
-0.7814745307,
-0.2596579492,
0.0577573292,
0.6298157573,
-0.4434226155,
0.245221898,
0.5236728787,
0.3303003311,
0.1443501562,
-0.8844594955,
0.1998057663,
-0.0519634001,
0.0517554618,
0.6310979724,
-0.588312149,
0.9688404202,
-0.5318428278,
-0.1605908424,
-0.1249412447,
0.4746934175,
0.3050615191,
0.1618737727,
0.5655590296,
0.2157729566,
0.8372462392,
-0.0228640791,
1.1115649939,
-0.3484174609,
0.3786977828,
0.7483331561,
-0.2458167076,
0.6447011828,
0.5974641442,
-0.4746152759,
1.0629161596,
0.2970489562,
0.3213339746,
0.3584749401,
0.5095478296,
-0.3007436395,
-0.393862009,
0.2541466951,
-0.2370586693,
0.1305979788,
0.590719223,
-0.4182401896,
0.0844539851,
-0.0290262662,
-0.2437406629,
0.1533803046,
-0.4858055711,
0.6797127128,
0.3484025598,
-0.9209213257,
0.8710349202,
-0.5757434368,
0.246037364,
-0.5106828213,
-0.0865135044,
0.0793061703,
0.177264303,
-0.0602633022,
-1.0279202461,
0.2296231836,
0.0167258158,
-0.2516158819,
-0.2745507658,
0.5483388305,
-0.0582403168,
-0.5786955357,
0.334166199,
0.5859519839,
-0.0512748957,
0.2140176892,
-0.341861546,
0.1141213253,
-0.1274921447,
-0.0548224114,
0.0408994481,
0.6714298129,
-0.0682480037,
1.0583431721,
0.6271051764,
0.1236083806,
-0.0437058844,
-0.1378190368,
1.1397386789,
-0.9224486351,
-0.5641157627,
-1.1520801783,
0.2734239697,
-0.0148217399,
-0.0962965861,
0.2978137136,
0.2793412209,
0.7567842007,
-0.1798332632,
0.7792822719,
-0.0295342803,
-0.037626151,
-0.7107161283,
0.3275736868,
-0.2197487056,
0.5932626724,
-0.4005399644,
-0.847058177,
-0.1368087828,
0.5560314059,
-0.5320936441,
-0.042616684,
1.3859356642,
0.3883758187,
0.0603241511,
0.2377322614,
0.3050563633,
0.257586062,
0.4071069658,
0.8743973374,
1.1366465092,
-0.2582044005,
0.6093584299,
-0.2210833728,
-0.3024521768,
0.1359741688,
-0.6775452495,
-1.0014027357,
-0.509788394,
-0.0562395081,
-0.3620994687,
-0.0668234155,
1.0348825455,
0.4278754592,
-0.6253480911,
-0.2932510376,
-0.7845420837,
0.462993741,
-0.2249806225,
-0.2307644784,
0.3000692427,
-0.5032598376,
-0.407833904,
0.0787871256,
0.4049301445,
0.1227544993,
-0.4702745378,
0.0328142755,
-0.2177246809,
0.4314528108,
0.7952190638,
0.0712589994,
-0.9625865817,
-0.1612847,
0.1593238562,
0.0694935992,
0.0719460174,
1.2762355804,
-1.2070955038,
0.4182709455,
0.4064767957,
0.3933344781,
0.598875165,
-0.2486342788,
0.7695710659,
-0.3649522662,
-0.0160198789,
0.2748431563,
0.3448747694,
-0.0791296363,
-0.4940245748,
0.3352636397,
-0.0349527821,
-0.5692234039,
-0.8270376921,
0.6803312898,
-0.8544585109,
-0.3306673765,
0.8230020404,
0.1914579123,
-0.4977753162,
-0.0459085219,
-0.4604877234,
0.0910809413,
-0.1590845436,
1.0215166807,
0.8307430148,
-0.4116882682,
-0.1943681091,
-0.2700962722,
0.4538051784,
0.3770551682,
-0.4506191015,
0.3313526213,
-0.099161759,
-0.1166713163,
0.3906040788,
0.5040389895,
-0.0013505958,
0.2819667757,
-0.0551425628,
-0.3399582505,
0.1038321406,
-0.5470240712,
-0.0404609293,
0.0134743918,
0.2066254765,
0.1231613457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15405v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15405v2 | Textless Low-Resource Speech-to-Speech Translation With Unit Language Models | 2023-05-24T17:59:05 | 2024-02-20T18:55:52 | Anuj Diwan, Anirudh Srinivasan, David Harwath, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Existing speech-to-speech translation models fall into two camps: textless
models trained with hundreds of hours of parallel speech data or unsupervised
models that leverage text as an intermediate step. Both approaches limit
building speech-to-speech translation models for a wide range of languages, as
they exclude languages that are primarily spoken and language pairs that lack
large-scale parallel speech data. We present a new framework for training
textless low-resource speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) systems that only
need dozens of hours of parallel speech data. We reformulate S2ST as a
unit-to-unit seq2seq translation task, and start by pretraining a model on
large-scale monolingual speech data. Then, we finetune it with a small amount
of parallel speech data ($20-60$ hours). Lastly, we improve model performance
through an unsupervised backtranslation objective. We train and evaluate our
models for English-to-German, German-to-English and Marathi-to-English
translation on three different domains (European Parliament, Common Voice, and
All India Radio) with single-speaker synthesized speech data. Evaluated using
the ASR-BLEU metric, our models achieve reasonable performance on all three
domains, with some being within 1-2 points of our supervised topline. | [
-0.1487641484,
-0.3648405671,
0.4524008036,
0.2000103444,
-0.5892264843,
-0.0220899843,
-0.5393478274,
-0.211832881,
0.0735923722,
0.6089760661,
-0.600744307,
-0.3428163826,
-0.5594756007,
0.0484512672,
-0.6071344614,
1.1426422596,
0.0895788372,
0.3190206289,
-0.296200484,
-0.3719120622,
-0.2832004428,
-0.4368540049,
-0.4560026824,
-0.4749049842,
0.3307391703,
0.6557379365,
0.4239278436,
0.6002610922,
0.1436393112,
0.1418423951,
-0.0854268298,
-0.0712384731,
-0.4864012897,
-0.1294977367,
-0.2010738552,
-0.2799220979,
-0.4115158021,
-0.0675462484,
0.8415046334,
0.9524199367,
-0.1784861684,
0.4346370399,
0.0775154009,
0.5912680626,
-0.3845068514,
0.1878053695,
-0.6632264256,
-0.0791414529,
-0.4373521805,
0.1630270034,
-0.5617765784,
-0.0854872987,
-0.0568965711,
-0.4019041359,
0.1553484499,
-0.1337009966,
0.4824078083,
0.5411270261,
-0.5954666138,
0.0849606767,
-0.9214348197,
0.7572314143,
-0.5334784389,
0.7070345283,
0.4518723786,
0.2213975489,
0.2448518872,
-0.5860542059,
-0.4773883224,
-0.0426046886,
-0.1828837395,
0.2381485999,
-0.4380308092,
-0.0379185528,
0.2033913285,
0.1749386191,
-0.6726815701,
0.3121327758,
-0.4375521839,
0.0682650059,
0.650265336,
0.0133069465,
-0.1218069792,
-0.3495772779,
-0.4579199553,
0.0451812372,
-0.5592428446,
0.0001896218,
0.0474513024,
0.7036845684,
-0.4319728315,
0.6544980407,
-0.3556320667,
0.3813101053,
-0.0552561022,
-0.0855383724,
0.1210888177,
-0.363935411,
-0.1735899448,
0.2995173633,
0.7613776922,
0.0241864379,
0.0597887263,
-0.6047517657,
-0.4447112978,
0.3197541535,
-0.1200780421,
-0.9222593904,
-0.0662804544,
0.0971307233,
-0.4023447633,
-0.1254573017,
-0.6182174683,
-0.4757617414,
-0.0911931992,
-0.304923594,
0.4014347792,
-0.2562175095,
-0.3605138958,
-0.1078158543,
0.2338937074,
-0.0284082536,
0.1892602146,
-0.8204063773,
0.631049931,
0.3365733922,
0.9819303155,
-0.4882583916,
-0.2484573424,
-0.7517965436,
0.1215728223,
-0.3425646424,
0.7130627632,
-0.2673020363,
-0.4881709516,
-0.2303281575,
-0.0362189114,
-0.1736650765,
-0.2669452131,
0.4996523857,
-0.2771970332,
0.098064892,
0.0396084338,
-0.5790623426,
0.1514076889,
-0.2303769141,
-0.5173444748,
0.9451104999,
-0.0450381376,
-0.4297391772,
-0.0876668766,
-0.7044081688,
-0.696388185,
0.2046344727,
-0.1941032112,
-0.2535839677,
0.2883058786,
0.1710994244,
0.3691237271,
-0.6390773058,
0.2283919603,
0.0143213365,
-0.2573306859,
0.1332079321,
-0.6467609406,
0.7154112458,
0.3288926482,
-0.1347401142,
0.0570704415,
-0.8293277025,
0.0831884816,
0.2526059151,
-0.2975901663,
-0.218874529,
-0.0180763025,
0.4840185642,
0.1889118701,
0.3088114858,
-0.7766197324,
-0.1426897347,
-0.3685111105,
0.5229492784,
0.4745802581,
-0.3680030406,
0.7538022399,
-0.1500954479,
0.2902726531,
-0.0448281653,
-0.1844467968,
-0.0311812386,
-0.3865865469,
-0.7813563347,
-0.2352075577,
0.3252977729,
0.6433739662,
-0.8483419418,
0.2050113827,
-0.681078136,
-0.5378218889,
-0.6736552715,
-0.0112551395,
0.5574277043,
0.4531960487,
0.6054347754,
-0.2222999483,
-0.2153558582,
-0.772282362,
-0.2295208573,
-0.0708580539,
-0.156854108,
0.146810621,
0.3499346375,
-0.2252966166,
0.749858737,
-0.220033586,
-0.4720627367,
-0.466853857,
0.0058526658,
0.0074158804,
0.4596396387,
0.0983836725,
-0.6575461626,
-0.3959923983,
0.1316746324,
-0.474673301,
-0.099005267,
0.04480749,
0.168582961,
0.4495349824,
0.602609396,
-0.6522692442,
0.4549432993,
0.9260134697,
-0.1223737895,
0.2364558429,
-0.2360714227,
-0.1698487848,
-1.2875436544,
0.3183479011,
-0.1355407983,
-0.477492094,
-0.9713743925,
-0.1843901873,
0.1061543822,
-0.6556525826,
-0.5431014299,
0.6501306891,
-0.2364058793,
-0.4218660295,
-0.3146795034,
0.3032936454,
-0.3100510836,
0.5656822324,
0.2403983176,
0.9458242059,
0.1622104794,
-0.3854453266,
0.1886132807,
0.4655712545,
-0.2817791104,
0.4891246855,
-0.5196844339,
0.3858201206,
0.01881616,
0.3598133922,
-0.8338094354,
-0.2796775103,
0.0718130469,
-0.5339359641,
0.0591925308,
-0.2949450314,
-0.5109494925,
-0.0613582171,
0.3490694463,
0.6251592636,
0.5160133839,
-0.4879294336,
0.3980594277,
0.4136056006,
-0.4671647251,
-0.187370196,
-0.8302760124,
0.1111858487,
0.0944741964,
-0.4966165423,
0.4644517601,
0.1548034549,
0.1858023107,
0.1800059378,
-0.2068885714,
-0.3285969794,
-0.1677698791,
0.2456886768,
0.0861554295,
-0.225759998,
0.2555373609,
0.113418296,
-0.276232928,
-0.2155674696,
-0.519703567,
0.5722956657,
-0.1428221017,
-0.2083481848,
-0.5760362744,
0.7450934649,
0.6200215816,
-0.4929705262,
0.4825357199,
0.4571269751,
-0.5132135749,
-0.0751177743,
-0.419180423,
-0.1836018115,
-0.3893751204,
0.5958640575,
-0.4302896857,
-0.9145088792,
0.1455892771,
-0.0065586912,
-0.0766208693,
0.3673075438,
0.4391879141,
0.0288343839,
0.9843687415,
0.667322576,
-0.0329080075,
0.3741052151,
-0.0371939391,
0.1900029182,
-0.5076642036,
-0.111470513,
-0.3996678591,
-0.0301870443,
-0.7014657855,
-0.6174432635,
0.3732768893,
-0.0215230994,
-0.2574151456,
0.5556599498,
-0.2346727252,
0.3672425449,
0.4907458723,
0.0676272288,
0.352455467,
0.4297860265,
0.1651903987,
-0.1192736402,
-0.8761098385,
-0.3527716696,
1.0981109142,
0.2380570918,
0.4368088841,
0.05655884,
0.6484234333,
0.1595363915,
0.2442058772,
-0.9439695477,
0.5252497792,
-0.8122569323,
-0.4338392317,
-0.643184185,
-0.7465536594,
-0.7338111997,
0.2609948814,
-0.2142067552,
-0.4955877364,
-0.0362330601,
0.0668444857,
-0.2974871099,
0.3700929284,
-0.609967649,
0.7690600753,
-0.4158495367,
-0.2516323626,
-0.4282861054,
-0.5576490164,
0.1570875049,
-0.3366631269,
0.2563387752,
-0.1797982305,
0.0228091814,
0.7849149704,
-0.3508071601,
0.6026998162,
-0.210361287,
0.0264355801,
0.0086132921,
-0.0079940446,
0.6304700375,
-0.048311308,
-0.0289795864,
0.516720295,
-0.0013649472,
-0.6171760559,
-0.2786736488,
0.4943213165,
-0.9076256752,
-0.3814885914,
-0.3574751616,
-0.6440347433,
-0.4115766585,
0.3171906471,
0.539501965,
0.2954371274,
-0.295173198,
0.3329818249,
0.5281366706,
-0.0118545527,
0.3811487257,
0.6032201648,
0.0119371014,
-0.4317621887,
0.9580655694,
0.2094260007,
0.4709986448,
0.3301906586,
0.0163162164,
-0.4999933839,
-0.4570095837,
-0.8080353737,
0.3860729337,
-0.3990046382,
-0.1518336087,
-0.7055987716,
-0.3363222182,
-0.5489845872,
0.1785712689,
-0.9069035053,
-0.6049970984,
-0.2510686219,
0.2085573673,
0.2835891545,
0.5740368366,
-0.168537125,
0.6332527995,
-0.7330310345,
0.4234478474,
0.2041026801,
0.1850468665,
-0.3297996521,
-0.8507755995,
-0.4970423579,
0.1922352314,
-0.0065225381,
-0.6819343567,
0.3860678077,
0.1816578656,
0.1056909263,
0.0258515626,
0.1383438557,
0.7239882946,
-0.9453793764,
0.4814994633,
0.627137959,
-1.0567978621,
0.4790088236,
-0.3357440531,
0.2841240466,
0.4455818236,
0.1400790662,
-0.8378271461,
-0.10601262,
-0.2186595052,
-0.7227829695,
0.9892125726,
0.4645544887,
0.1777405143,
0.2977334559,
0.0698298961,
0.0242540725,
0.2351304442,
-0.6499242783,
-0.2709205151,
-0.3569267392,
-0.0697590709,
-0.5625988245,
-0.0105038388,
-0.0979565755,
-0.1583170593,
0.6178205013,
-0.0863377675,
0.3418188691,
-0.0079794973,
-0.2166415155,
-0.1893173009,
0.5039311051,
0.5906181931,
0.0959685817,
-0.2031461447,
-0.0709543824,
0.381862998,
-0.1554784924,
0.5059025288,
0.5095167756,
-0.1997396052,
0.1679922342,
0.0169313662,
1.107391715,
0.2240947336,
-0.3822085261,
0.7478758693,
0.0306969658,
-0.1911081076,
-0.3065758944,
-0.3636415899,
0.1987271458,
0.2416523397,
0.1798852682,
0.3484804332,
-0.1971078068,
-0.2386058271,
0.1863539964,
0.0888847187,
-0.4720964432,
-0.4029756486,
0.9192469716,
0.4037784934,
-0.3386958838,
0.3536570668,
-0.2126240581,
-0.1485143751,
0.2263641804,
0.5919417143,
0.9901353121,
-0.2514593899,
0.3059811592,
0.1477331817,
0.2876323462,
-0.3878287077,
-0.0032355138,
-0.2116787732,
-0.4252483249,
-0.5577692389,
-0.6299678683,
-0.4045867026,
0.3509267867,
-0.8498130441,
0.2291576713,
-0.1538499296,
-0.0080991946,
-0.1107539833,
-0.2086370885,
-0.7562075257,
0.2789479196,
0.3249213696,
0.8532892466,
-0.9940303564,
1.3108724356,
0.6255871058,
-0.3494740129,
-0.7557077408,
0.0877770185,
-0.1366771013,
-0.6354584098,
0.5503300428,
-0.0070553259,
-0.3539700508,
0.3933589458,
-0.1694924384,
-1.0044083595,
0.9926642776,
0.670380652,
-0.7823729515,
-0.207390666,
0.4437987506,
0.4563268423,
-0.3160432875,
-0.3493071198,
0.5036686063,
-0.0270411298,
-0.0687512904,
-1.0885932446,
-0.1064620763,
-0.10110116,
0.0902752057,
0.0818864852,
-0.7417539954,
0.9642230272,
-0.0206046794,
-0.4235836864,
0.3501936197,
0.6539064646,
0.004874947,
0.4622227252,
0.5391665101,
0.5425994396,
0.6659122705,
0.0180699099,
0.7496853471,
-0.3288619816,
0.3805582523,
1.287071228,
-0.3888325095,
1.156226635,
0.4874900579,
0.0088062864,
0.0061740791,
0.3122004271,
0.2511124611,
0.7519430518,
-0.1247678548,
-0.5066019893,
-0.5398251414,
-0.3569688499,
-0.5016354918,
0.7855783701,
0.2568518817,
0.0236046985,
-0.2611414194,
0.2380771339,
-0.0590028912,
0.2435383648,
-0.2867988944,
0.6690812707,
0.247119993,
-0.4706164896,
0.8191665411,
0.274733156,
0.5395080447,
-0.4465457499,
0.424633801,
-0.5230804086,
0.2107479274,
-0.0360357538,
-0.3748439252,
0.2315183431,
0.5348218679,
-0.2633029222,
-0.4744039774,
0.4984924197,
-0.7715349197,
-0.5448693633,
0.4709143937,
0.7516791224,
0.2801072896,
-0.139885053,
-0.4765788317,
-0.1749553233,
-0.046227742,
-0.0340693295,
0.3179751635,
0.3327125609,
-0.1990219206,
0.3974192142,
0.6985010505,
0.359639287,
-0.107660085,
-0.0180276129,
0.7126879692,
-0.5283530951,
-0.640130043,
-0.5348180532,
0.2561424077,
0.0972265601,
-0.1771229208,
0.560320437,
0.7160161734,
1.0355750322,
0.0184689406,
1.0271663666,
0.259907186,
0.7049570084,
-0.4541657865,
0.9058191776,
-0.8356798887,
-0.0349818133,
-0.0254148226,
-0.7579117417,
-0.108096242,
0.4040584266,
-0.2914521396,
-0.3532831073,
0.5622116923,
0.7431246042,
-0.1741447449,
0.0675310045,
0.5771389008,
-0.0221393332,
0.067639783,
0.5148562789,
0.6427131891,
-0.5279249549,
0.989692688,
-0.22808294,
-0.1573143154,
-0.2124448717,
-0.5159687996,
-0.7162113786,
-0.5430468917,
-0.2147939205,
-0.4001637101,
0.1091845855,
1.0660277605,
0.7522982955,
-0.8877152205,
-0.571983695,
-0.1606324613,
-0.2307875454,
0.0309559982,
-0.0483932495,
0.3171050847,
-0.2154046446,
-0.6335081458,
0.7814358473,
0.2764339745,
0.1068566665,
0.1095725447,
-0.2897898853,
0.0628671199,
0.184784323,
0.7272674441,
0.345135808,
-0.678830564,
-0.1827234924,
0.0125926901,
-0.2715943754,
0.0486200936,
0.7725495696,
-0.5053862333,
0.314796716,
0.1744640619,
0.8334507942,
0.8746500015,
-0.1887741238,
0.2642607391,
-1.0817986727,
0.6152948737,
0.2034579813,
0.1403723806,
0.4127359688,
0.0300533865,
0.3405392468,
0.4766297042,
-0.4068296254,
-1.0684565306,
0.4275328219,
-0.8196538091,
-0.1115906835,
1.2821449041,
-0.0331152305,
0.0515048094,
0.1459905207,
0.1345621198,
0.59983778,
-0.4542114139,
0.3944513798,
0.3694224358,
0.019223541,
-0.0868997127,
-0.5735955834,
0.4841786325,
0.6232190132,
-0.6493288875,
0.3477097452,
0.4382170737,
0.2022007406,
-0.0867199078,
0.8521743417,
0.0344583057,
0.303997606,
0.0837487131,
0.0529181361,
0.0022142681,
-0.3140368164,
-0.504545033,
-0.10408739,
-0.1792130619,
-0.4967884123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15403v1 | AV-TranSpeech: Audio-Visual Robust Speech-to-Speech Translation | 2023-05-24T17:59:03 | 2023-05-24T17:59:03 | Rongjie Huang, Huadai Liu, Xize Cheng, Yi Ren, Linjun Li, Zhenhui Ye, Jinzheng He, Lichao Zhang, Jinglin Liu, Xiang Yin, Zhou Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Direct speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) aims to convert speech from one
language into another, and has demonstrated significant progress to date.
Despite the recent success, current S2ST models still suffer from distinct
degradation in noisy environments and fail to translate visual speech (i.e.,
the movement of lips and teeth). In this work, we present AV-TranSpeech, the
first audio-visual speech-to-speech (AV-S2ST) translation model without relying
on intermediate text. AV-TranSpeech complements the audio stream with visual
information to promote system robustness and opens up a host of practical
applications: dictation or dubbing archival films. To mitigate the data
scarcity with limited parallel AV-S2ST data, we 1) explore self-supervised
pre-training with unlabeled audio-visual data to learn contextual
representation, and 2) introduce cross-modal distillation with S2ST models
trained on the audio-only corpus to further reduce the requirements of visual
data. Experimental results on two language pairs demonstrate that AV-TranSpeech
outperforms audio-only models under all settings regardless of the type of
noise. With low-resource audio-visual data (10h, 30h), cross-modal distillation
yields an improvement of 7.6 BLEU on average compared with baselines. Audio
samples are available at https://AV-TranSpeech.github.io | [
-0.1911814809,
-0.798912704,
0.432084918,
0.2231491208,
-0.7905721068,
-0.124395676,
-0.2370804399,
-0.1622409075,
0.0137899481,
0.2724012733,
-0.5415987372,
-0.4615108371,
-0.9055656195,
0.0786147118,
-0.8024629951,
0.6631456017,
0.0724387914,
0.4161554873,
-0.2136671245,
-0.1052227169,
-0.6614953876,
-0.1809784174,
-0.3100100458,
0.1515120566,
0.0466704592,
0.2301372886,
0.4966309965,
0.8731836677,
0.3437206447,
0.1962103844,
0.0976867378,
-0.0121890046,
-0.3621031344,
0.3001333773,
-0.246658802,
-0.2759913802,
-0.170692414,
-0.1763994843,
0.7585209012,
0.5028306246,
0.0081748888,
0.4231398702,
0.1655464619,
0.5126984119,
-0.4243295789,
0.4322302043,
-0.5038696527,
-0.0277087651,
-0.4834754765,
-0.1338232309,
-0.3945742846,
0.1897855699,
0.0001731037,
-0.3259017467,
-0.173239395,
-0.0799767897,
0.4681573212,
0.9120639563,
-0.4170820415,
0.2006002069,
-0.8665764928,
0.6473678946,
-0.3686377406,
0.9272248149,
0.6852192879,
0.5165012479,
0.2480395287,
-0.9857258797,
-0.5591141582,
-0.1338737458,
0.2573149502,
0.131720677,
-0.5886024833,
-0.2372606844,
0.142110303,
0.1764870733,
-0.6665213108,
-0.1600245535,
-0.4293492734,
-0.2049443573,
0.3419605196,
-0.0768254474,
0.2851495743,
-0.173628211,
-0.5251781344,
-0.0670303404,
-0.3442801535,
0.0381906256,
-0.1573245376,
0.3374817371,
-0.2929139733,
0.6487088203,
-0.0300138257,
0.5821641088,
-0.0026601451,
-0.1507102102,
0.3299676776,
-0.8566651344,
-0.1451853365,
0.3044183254,
0.7431801558,
0.2182174325,
-0.1042762324,
0.0682779402,
-0.1799086034,
0.0761190131,
0.1981342733,
-0.6494830847,
-0.0298677143,
-0.1444827616,
-0.3064157069,
-0.1576287299,
-0.3984164894,
-0.4049272835,
-0.0306809563,
-0.4360954463,
0.5828254819,
-0.2940000296,
-0.3014976978,
-0.3177408874,
-0.0292718615,
0.0893415138,
0.6515263915,
-0.5770568252,
0.3329492211,
0.4216446579,
1.1205203533,
-0.4100601673,
-0.2449315637,
-0.8568981886,
0.1506689489,
-0.5655543208,
0.7117872834,
-0.3219865859,
-0.412443459,
-0.0949544013,
-0.207790941,
0.2900086045,
-0.4238667488,
0.3336706758,
0.0301832501,
-0.0544391796,
-0.2102603912,
-0.1420876533,
0.2165829986,
-0.098162584,
-0.5226489305,
0.91092664,
0.1768001914,
-0.5975914001,
0.3257759809,
-0.2163501382,
-0.5313766599,
0.093132928,
-0.3423295319,
-0.3672864139,
0.070640862,
0.2877347469,
0.1213499084,
-0.398903966,
0.0753134117,
-0.0708473548,
-0.2085394263,
-0.074723281,
-0.7224003077,
0.5557383895,
0.3535080254,
-0.3677627146,
-0.0632240027,
-0.4857595861,
-0.4173260927,
0.041277431,
-0.09895619,
-0.2915490866,
-0.219224602,
0.1915195584,
0.2778036296,
0.1176173687,
-0.5514777899,
0.1652895659,
-0.0569993369,
0.6658688784,
0.5676540732,
-0.4039183259,
0.6019557714,
0.0057281787,
0.3625791669,
0.11217466,
0.1801756471,
-0.139490068,
-0.4551429152,
-0.5840615034,
-0.494939357,
0.2818014026,
0.5765210986,
-1.0555689335,
0.1743683666,
-0.5270438194,
-0.2833516598,
-0.8173888326,
0.0857547149,
0.2660372555,
1.0540553331,
0.5834699273,
-0.3502243161,
-0.3378437161,
-0.9706451893,
-0.1212970614,
-0.2664431632,
-0.0442655049,
0.1046872288,
0.1077222973,
-0.4568861127,
0.6226919889,
0.1303708106,
-0.5897573829,
-0.2162654996,
0.0256279483,
-0.0928463116,
0.2960303426,
0.4024817348,
-0.6182162166,
-0.4838062823,
0.0324501842,
-0.4421858191,
-0.292024076,
0.0020602071,
0.0121423276,
0.1708061099,
0.7293895483,
-0.3860045969,
0.8470994234,
0.6621990204,
-0.1709568501,
0.2623278797,
0.0047966875,
0.1385646015,
-1.1339482069,
0.0546734892,
-0.2718004286,
-0.8399580717,
-0.6290776134,
-0.4964268208,
-0.0209652483,
-0.4348348975,
-0.8607019782,
0.4618588686,
-0.1547103673,
-0.3256470561,
-0.3030038178,
-0.0571653284,
-0.1358638406,
0.314691931,
0.3649820983,
1.0759164095,
0.7242771387,
-0.262384057,
0.4434150457,
0.6938823462,
-0.3866533935,
0.5207720399,
-0.4098643064,
0.2027840316,
-0.0113912625,
0.254950732,
-0.9544432759,
0.109151803,
0.2567656636,
-0.5475920439,
0.2553321421,
-0.264475137,
-0.206216082,
0.0951066688,
-0.0125405416,
0.6846514344,
0.577557385,
-0.521170795,
0.6972747445,
0.3595507145,
-0.6770266294,
-0.5145958066,
-1.0992500782,
0.3453364074,
0.1028937846,
-0.6153706908,
0.2331888378,
0.2245984972,
-0.0166166406,
0.0637380481,
-0.450846076,
-0.2114367783,
-0.4860796034,
0.1789572984,
0.1321317703,
-0.037869405,
0.1457286924,
0.1699535698,
-0.1699227542,
-0.0982495099,
-0.3622209728,
0.407063365,
-0.2499605566,
-0.2764433026,
-0.7380483747,
0.6874308586,
0.5420017838,
-0.2164608091,
0.1989726126,
0.5907751918,
-0.1678447723,
-0.1580971926,
-0.4654534459,
-0.0260347445,
-0.4270395935,
0.6544166803,
-0.414658159,
-0.648896277,
0.0914481506,
-0.2731437087,
-0.1939325035,
0.401176542,
0.5815002322,
-0.3037904203,
0.9075490832,
0.4119029641,
0.1399002522,
0.8694555759,
-0.2603980303,
0.0098930858,
-0.5976185203,
-0.2810509205,
-0.1983508766,
-0.214123264,
-0.347944051,
-0.7148557305,
0.6094760299,
-0.2099136561,
-0.1466769576,
0.5212795138,
-0.3303537667,
0.1629442573,
0.5830816031,
-0.0050331187,
0.2993891239,
0.3650171757,
0.2327166945,
-0.2574100196,
-0.6385358572,
-0.1633696556,
0.8933581114,
0.4197922349,
0.8431845903,
0.0040630442,
0.568700254,
0.5681296587,
-0.3357330561,
-0.7969946861,
0.4389683306,
-0.4744815528,
-0.2718240023,
-0.5664867163,
-0.4130212367,
-0.6869187951,
0.1704333276,
-0.174756065,
-0.3511984646,
0.309738338,
0.1848091483,
-0.2018152922,
0.1547800899,
-0.4457730055,
0.7721450925,
-0.6151322126,
-0.6176332235,
-0.3290663958,
-0.8596163392,
-0.0571336523,
-0.1414789557,
0.4218476713,
0.0006453461,
-0.1329290569,
0.447376579,
-0.4792603254,
0.4840720296,
-0.0990685821,
0.076466307,
0.397485435,
0.4760604799,
0.5161775947,
0.0780827552,
0.3167354465,
0.7257059813,
0.1804202795,
-0.2846310437,
-0.4214875102,
0.5079053044,
-0.7646211982,
-0.5506934524,
-0.437988013,
-0.3599505126,
0.0078448653,
0.430164665,
0.2731738091,
0.3076837063,
-0.1655637324,
0.4137026072,
0.4101492763,
-0.0352478139,
0.338055402,
0.2880080044,
-0.2972187996,
-0.4691073596,
1.0157585144,
0.0488248691,
0.3988003135,
0.324654758,
0.209868297,
-0.6464385986,
-0.442658782,
-0.6936362982,
-0.0653498396,
-0.6091809273,
-0.1277552992,
-0.537756443,
-0.1329837292,
-0.7097777128,
0.0714132115,
-1.0166021585,
-0.5570563674,
-0.3291630149,
-0.0765933618,
0.1821181625,
0.4731683731,
-0.4556625187,
0.1697778106,
-0.6440141201,
0.7275691032,
0.6949490905,
0.0761274993,
-0.7068952918,
-0.8112260103,
-0.1237228438,
-0.0181872528,
-0.0349800028,
-0.7834303975,
0.6310904026,
0.4248825908,
0.2222815156,
0.1181662753,
-0.0274086241,
0.8474606872,
-0.5905691385,
0.8255967498,
0.3935797513,
-1.0787398815,
0.8274234533,
-0.2481387556,
0.4029030502,
0.7582886219,
-0.035904441,
-0.5912818313,
-0.0628410652,
-0.2775395215,
-0.8785351515,
0.6491732001,
0.4535259604,
0.052984003,
0.3260176182,
-0.0405802503,
0.3251745105,
0.3051987588,
-0.4799205661,
-0.0025101285,
-0.9360377789,
-0.110144861,
-0.1723718792,
0.1087735519,
0.0423242003,
-0.4863521457,
0.4419729114,
0.1420769691,
0.18574287,
0.3631111383,
-0.4088492095,
-0.0964604318,
0.1390845627,
0.4986250103,
0.2315043658,
-0.0553427674,
0.5095908642,
0.2479273528,
-0.5143702626,
0.3367140591,
0.0757719725,
-0.0957739204,
0.1875063628,
0.4344261587,
1.1750050783,
-0.0799533874,
-0.5298286676,
1.0616775751,
-0.1720763296,
-0.1288073361,
-0.3760884702,
-0.3813062608,
-0.1071335822,
0.2048549354,
0.1587857157,
0.3038923144,
0.3094932735,
-0.5663800836,
0.3901540935,
0.1468383819,
-0.650999248,
-0.2435647398,
0.9414135814,
0.4205643535,
-0.3777346015,
0.6454694867,
0.2749375403,
0.0568745695,
0.0475567579,
0.3974993527,
0.9973449707,
-0.4344832897,
0.1004966795,
0.1278095245,
0.3015544415,
-0.1286074966,
0.1925157905,
-0.6114040613,
-0.1503963172,
-0.3934583962,
-0.6090806723,
-0.2196507454,
0.0953549072,
-0.5541419983,
0.4485971928,
-0.2536881864,
-0.2893493176,
-0.2403186709,
-0.5938301682,
-0.8187717199,
-0.0301769488,
0.4759495258,
0.7774577737,
-1.0192104578,
1.0136014223,
0.3962788582,
-0.4600417614,
-0.5375053287,
-0.3133859634,
-0.0865927339,
-0.8889980316,
0.6876971722,
-0.1939399093,
-0.3877361119,
0.0634246394,
-0.531884253,
-0.7911037803,
0.9198858738,
0.7586972713,
-1.0090998411,
0.0760522112,
0.6286099553,
0.3273776472,
-0.1394922137,
-0.0064739622,
0.4746492207,
0.4777571261,
0.2944115996,
-1.2599669695,
-0.3342776597,
-0.2968535125,
0.0527808182,
-0.1324297488,
-0.613771379,
0.6771247983,
0.0816968083,
-0.1884515584,
-0.2825501561,
0.6855541468,
-0.1514857709,
0.2719755173,
0.5717257857,
0.5067659616,
0.1913408786,
0.0294054914,
0.8684285283,
-0.0503163747,
-0.0958939642,
1.2066053152,
-0.0243564881,
0.8612827063,
0.9048851728,
-0.0204366669,
0.0827999339,
0.368252039,
0.213218689,
0.9546670914,
-0.2858735919,
-0.1692619324,
-0.6760885715,
-0.3530560136,
-0.4812953472,
0.8313010931,
0.1790398806,
-0.2117976397,
-0.1693410873,
0.2470175624,
-0.5497967601,
0.0638456494,
-0.2052431405,
0.9319914579,
0.3998824358,
-0.1912792623,
0.6796460748,
-0.4978195131,
0.3910012841,
-0.6320303679,
-0.2314533144,
-0.212428242,
-0.0693760961,
0.0599758662,
-0.6524326205,
0.3670905232,
0.0795703828,
0.0362988114,
-0.5332914591,
0.596137464,
-0.6991822124,
-0.5880722404,
0.2558642626,
0.5343137383,
0.2603670657,
-0.0815319419,
-0.4965590835,
0.2935006022,
0.0185822584,
-0.159673363,
0.1888974905,
0.3130912185,
-0.1525695622,
0.5700364113,
0.519334197,
0.3038353622,
0.0674441829,
-0.1119611785,
0.6117249727,
-0.3764391243,
-0.7900539637,
-0.7260220647,
0.6020562053,
0.2227627486,
-0.0937898532,
0.5097324252,
0.6200383306,
0.8786195517,
-0.1389325857,
0.965934217,
0.2190865427,
0.3978059888,
-0.3101886809,
0.6187185645,
-0.6979687214,
-0.0354997367,
-0.1708289683,
-0.9352737069,
-0.0475801639,
0.5369916558,
-0.0755598247,
-0.3647603095,
0.538073957,
0.6322337985,
-0.2341142297,
-0.3307100534,
0.5257018209,
0.2192651182,
0.2511139512,
0.3502497375,
0.8946207166,
-0.4969218671,
0.8510715961,
-0.2217734754,
-0.2615887225,
-0.2087651193,
-0.5792197585,
-0.6223852038,
-0.8061944246,
-0.316591233,
-0.2048059106,
0.2255942672,
0.8187943697,
0.800074935,
-0.5809963346,
-0.1384390742,
-0.0820658281,
-0.3253197968,
-0.2404611856,
-0.0132538741,
0.2676039636,
0.1185685396,
-0.7133440375,
0.9505820274,
0.4972294867,
0.2808274329,
-0.0531736612,
-0.1977488846,
0.0479692593,
0.0590957813,
0.4869630635,
0.2862204313,
-0.7451892495,
-0.2129118145,
-0.1806051731,
-0.0054893256,
0.2085958719,
0.595302999,
-0.6663202643,
0.9032526016,
0.7330390811,
0.6299628019,
1.1283531189,
0.0127331596,
0.4873348773,
-0.793210268,
0.5429247618,
0.3532692194,
0.2298545837,
0.2532413006,
-0.1277806163,
0.2970343232,
0.2664875686,
-0.328900665,
-0.9440396428,
0.2955189347,
-1.284378171,
-0.1707245857,
1.2438542843,
0.3281850815,
-0.3473270833,
-0.0387361497,
-0.4622848928,
0.6731069088,
-0.5850223899,
0.5599287748,
0.331133604,
-0.0283051357,
-0.4125705659,
-0.4426042438,
0.5319098234,
0.4425982237,
-0.381162107,
0.2525844872,
0.4645541012,
0.3160958886,
-0.1790469587,
0.671220541,
-0.1684952527,
0.4146897495,
0.2330123931,
0.0136162126,
-0.5592296124,
-0.4443113506,
-0.4334207177,
-0.1242107898,
-0.1084073409,
-0.5033321381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15389v1 | Comparing Humans and Models on a Similar Scale: Towards Cognitive Gender Bias Evaluation in Coreference Resolution | 2023-05-24T17:51:44 | 2023-05-24T17:51:44 | Gili Lior, Gabriel Stanovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Spurious correlations were found to be an important factor explaining model
performance in various NLP tasks (e.g., gender or racial artifacts), often
considered to be ''shortcuts'' to the actual task. However, humans tend to
similarly make quick (and sometimes wrong) predictions based on societal and
cognitive presuppositions. In this work we address the question: can we
quantify the extent to which model biases reflect human behaviour? Answering
this question will help shed light on model performance and provide meaningful
comparisons against humans. We approach this question through the lens of the
dual-process theory for human decision-making. This theory differentiates
between an automatic unconscious (and sometimes biased) ''fast system'' and a
''slow system'', which when triggered may revisit earlier automatic reactions.
We make several observations from two crowdsourcing experiments of gender bias
in coreference resolution, using self-paced reading to study the ''fast''
system, and question answering to study the ''slow'' system under a constrained
time setting. On real-world data humans make $\sim$3\% more gender-biased
decisions compared to models, while on synthetic data models are $\sim$12\%
more biased. | [
-0.5009369254,
-0.5682168007,
0.464468807,
0.0413210839,
-0.039371796,
0.1154928803,
-0.3640914857,
-0.7271521688,
-0.050640855,
0.3610664308,
-0.6681015491,
0.1314892173,
-0.4323507845,
0.1764162481,
-0.3758107722,
0.6506057978,
0.4058584571,
0.5612171888,
-0.4441753924,
-0.0371689275,
-0.7100369334,
-0.8363859057,
-0.5871980786,
-0.5991176367,
0.3486151695,
0.2272044569,
1.0239629745,
0.342025429,
0.4562107027,
0.1725565493,
-0.2495297492,
-0.1383840293,
-0.3628631234,
0.130445987,
-0.5730234385,
-0.5865148902,
-0.3974317312,
0.5365077853,
0.2835762799,
0.9019933939,
0.1923177391,
0.4570653439,
0.3876607418,
0.7461093068,
-0.627225399,
-0.0696069598,
-0.2909660339,
0.0342006683,
-0.1032583788,
0.0589399226,
-0.2148813009,
-0.0252182763,
0.442466706,
-0.2104330659,
0.8332930207,
0.3747489154,
0.4281800687,
0.2272284776,
-0.5988794565,
-0.332888335,
-0.8797931075,
0.8720610142,
-0.6045351028,
0.2083656639,
0.4620192945,
0.0927747935,
0.1638530642,
-0.2843661606,
-0.5484880805,
-0.5309776664,
-0.3206150234,
-0.1553387642,
0.0321492963,
-0.113353312,
0.7423672676,
0.0120956805,
-0.459415257,
0.0120381424,
-0.5590776801,
-0.397028327,
0.8543676138,
0.2030365467,
0.216094017,
-0.2965721488,
-0.0741165429,
-0.1326918751,
-0.2237208337,
0.0432545841,
0.6905085444,
0.4424687028,
0.0789581761,
0.4431139529,
-0.1249599904,
0.5222294331,
0.5619493127,
0.1712868065,
-0.009249609,
-0.4238088429,
0.1222505569,
0.1209287271,
0.622158289,
0.7192028761,
0.3856794834,
-0.0654282793,
0.087017253,
0.7390414476,
0.5311769247,
-0.5754447579,
0.01881532,
-0.0572261214,
-0.5704675913,
-0.2752663195,
-0.0763476416,
-0.767054677,
-0.4201541841,
-0.5700367093,
0.1896232069,
-0.0676049069,
-0.2459775507,
0.0487168655,
-0.2655207813,
-0.0395361483,
0.2562973499,
-0.6914883256,
0.5369624496,
0.615878582,
0.7068472505,
-0.1465058178,
-0.2494024038,
0.0055787647,
-0.2222598195,
-0.3348090351,
0.7347663045,
-0.3330559731,
-0.6317593455,
-0.5041698813,
-0.3652088046,
0.0956583545,
-0.6311542392,
0.831822753,
-0.1984659433,
0.3351418078,
-0.7507664561,
-0.2141483128,
-0.1697296202,
0.1142862812,
-0.665487051,
1.1019421816,
-0.3291789889,
-0.9624479413,
0.6241039038,
-0.6316610575,
-0.358276248,
-0.4362305403,
-0.1040223315,
0.0036860488,
-0.0867340639,
0.0965584293,
0.3809603751,
-0.8145466447,
0.5070498586,
-0.6281887293,
-0.2868079543,
0.3057623506,
-0.2519421577,
0.7635701895,
-0.0156595018,
-0.4999415278,
0.0732125863,
-0.4594490826,
-0.0811647549,
0.0355842188,
0.197333172,
-0.6184946299,
0.0149818128,
-0.1911097169,
0.6814653277,
0.0851033628,
-0.4145452976,
0.126841858,
0.0966339186,
0.5587095618,
0.7030526996,
-0.3344355524,
0.7067226171,
-0.5112991929,
0.2410276681,
-0.0448840894,
0.3465591073,
0.2984954715,
-0.6017439961,
-0.735574007,
0.0893637463,
0.279494375,
0.480787605,
-0.1595938355,
0.2864480019,
-0.0757492781,
-0.4528284371,
-0.3774513602,
-0.0654824674,
0.6306526661,
0.7820359468,
0.2975560129,
-0.7875581384,
-0.4154648781,
-1.2505931854,
-0.7178152204,
-0.4765622914,
-0.2950558662,
0.5215241909,
0.846573174,
-0.0069932989,
1.0771694183,
-0.3822261393,
-0.144474715,
0.1237278432,
0.5458404422,
0.0649606884,
0.641995132,
0.4918928444,
-0.8063849807,
0.1156591773,
-0.724856317,
-0.6628015041,
-0.1947418451,
0.0454456359,
-0.4232994318,
-0.0939202532,
0.3350857198,
-0.4382057488,
0.5761383772,
0.172753185,
-0.8037371635,
0.9178354144,
-0.0770928338,
0.2654578686,
-0.3929578066,
0.1630876064,
0.0797495618,
-0.067856431,
-0.5542659163,
-0.163774386,
0.089907147,
0.1030161977,
-0.3249251544,
0.5356011391,
-0.4931997955,
-0.5384094715,
-0.1101152748,
-0.0501949228,
0.0577821694,
0.4191218019,
0.2574198544,
0.769304812,
0.1558147371,
-0.8015924096,
-0.0527141318,
0.1795531362,
-0.2755143642,
0.7429360151,
-0.7393199205,
0.486982733,
-0.3220207691,
0.5075033307,
-0.7449803352,
0.0372019038,
0.0487919971,
-0.4187654257,
-0.0173907559,
0.1032950282,
-0.3523056209,
-0.6390835643,
-0.2505940199,
0.5808323622,
0.4435445964,
-0.1670301408,
0.5787206292,
0.2082828581,
0.042639602,
-0.598711431,
-0.7710078359,
-0.0504595041,
-0.0942114517,
-0.7134861946,
0.2288578302,
-0.298327744,
-0.7256836891,
-0.1776444316,
-0.1392593384,
0.0482858829,
0.1562138945,
0.5741738677,
0.4440904558,
0.0748541877,
0.1578169316,
-0.1693518907,
-0.0444189869,
0.1803248376,
0.0162497573,
0.5007131696,
-0.2213972807,
-0.2232006341,
-0.5070571899,
0.3932698071,
0.5380177498,
0.0546520427,
0.536888063,
0.3674401045,
-0.2724781632,
0.2200383991,
-0.7337244749,
-0.7186077237,
-0.3120484054,
0.0753637329,
-0.3466811478,
-0.6859195232,
0.5891592503,
0.1525983661,
-0.0422748365,
0.6384703517,
0.6046475172,
-0.1717304736,
1.2748093605,
0.4903092086,
-0.0488084555,
0.2213107497,
-0.1777457446,
-0.0358769968,
-0.9537004828,
-0.0122731132,
-0.7311496735,
-0.6287422776,
-0.4148752391,
-0.5868191719,
0.1692688614,
0.2170032561,
-0.4650673568,
0.1098520011,
-0.5382805467,
0.0857181922,
0.8508023024,
0.2033721507,
0.2709092796,
-0.4414666891,
-0.2558895051,
-0.2642760277,
-0.6709713936,
-0.8233454227,
1.0994136333,
-0.0244032703,
0.5087603927,
-0.1464406103,
-0.0021645301,
0.8375737071,
0.4651762843,
-0.3996231854,
0.595600009,
0.0411459506,
-1.3194824457,
-0.1054885313,
-0.155696854,
-0.6670069695,
0.4973406196,
-0.5800882578,
-0.6051674485,
0.3505580723,
0.3369709849,
-0.3995574117,
0.2704828084,
-0.668518126,
0.7340723276,
-0.2716998458,
-0.7481363416,
-0.4420445561,
-0.9227427244,
0.6463207006,
0.0701734051,
0.3827145994,
-0.5163349509,
0.0767112598,
1.1832665205,
-0.0965455249,
0.9826412797,
-0.0715122297,
0.2659876347,
0.238457948,
0.2791717947,
-0.0428108349,
0.0007413538,
-0.1766370386,
0.5022626519,
0.1058990061,
-0.4364178777,
-0.5168831944,
0.3834495544,
-0.871587038,
-0.7001826167,
-0.648432076,
-0.6038748026,
-0.0910743624,
0.0677809864,
0.1866578907,
0.317062974,
-0.5058930516,
-0.3251082897,
0.314485997,
0.0566480421,
0.3038355112,
0.5681034327,
-0.1965304613,
0.1953099072,
0.0190764386,
0.1773506999,
0.2850319445,
0.0913327411,
0.3255290091,
-0.2108062208,
-0.017904168,
-0.2108927071,
0.4001554549,
-0.4510766268,
0.0920921266,
-0.6297886372,
0.2255298793,
-0.6109695435,
-0.1931782067,
-0.4913867712,
-0.4918822646,
-0.3758016527,
-0.021906998,
-0.1127870157,
0.622394383,
-0.0949191004,
0.1553905755,
-0.3980900645,
0.4104231596,
0.613053441,
-0.0760984346,
0.2746823728,
-0.4604358673,
0.177806586,
0.233603999,
-0.354740113,
-0.9349127412,
0.2975877523,
-0.1276569366,
0.2448184937,
0.4527252316,
0.2357849926,
0.753831625,
-0.3357328475,
0.9658623338,
0.1282528937,
-1.1013916731,
0.4442438185,
-0.1256239265,
0.2714504004,
0.5659652352,
0.3969780207,
-0.7563149929,
-0.1385190934,
-0.6954646707,
-0.4972065985,
0.7181107402,
0.1211057901,
-0.1339047998,
0.1358910352,
0.5740443468,
0.2482764125,
0.2884385288,
-0.3062925041,
-0.3354038894,
0.0581225529,
0.3492304981,
-0.3448055387,
-0.4895424545,
-0.1821946949,
-0.1852276921,
0.4820688069,
-0.2045796067,
0.3382712901,
0.3629267216,
-0.2649947107,
-0.1647025794,
0.3221583366,
0.4758014083,
0.7895135283,
-0.3696503639,
0.2270926237,
0.1941228807,
-0.4476762414,
0.2894736826,
-0.328075707,
-0.3563553989,
-0.1731274128,
0.5569847822,
0.5496729016,
0.2566376925,
-0.6738767028,
0.3159029186,
-0.3789283633,
0.0127075454,
-0.2495782375,
0.0364885479,
-0.0246045273,
0.3786111772,
0.4514831603,
0.5998067856,
0.3778591454,
-0.7966991663,
-0.0087166373,
0.3708367348,
-0.4087692797,
-0.5184281468,
0.8674097061,
0.422749579,
-0.4496402442,
0.8285933733,
0.0088955285,
-0.6355981231,
0.6386478543,
0.1756879538,
0.807717979,
-0.169106245,
0.0311911684,
0.616545856,
0.3342117965,
-0.516854167,
0.1748109311,
-0.1998794675,
-0.9305658937,
-0.2701310515,
-0.3562032282,
-0.3703271151,
-0.3249411881,
-1.1304442883,
0.2322718352,
-0.2834076583,
-0.9230487943,
0.1669773608,
0.0903598741,
-1.0079084635,
0.2479744852,
0.3006448448,
0.7954230905,
-1.0118864775,
0.5764858723,
0.5503608584,
-0.2228801399,
-0.4567329288,
-0.0037052741,
0.2645029724,
-0.4484311938,
0.9350001812,
0.2211004496,
-0.17500332,
-0.5048872232,
-0.4462989569,
-0.8053653836,
0.953091979,
0.3085080087,
-0.5777411461,
-0.4690265656,
-0.2099033296,
0.5046303272,
-0.2225881815,
0.7067991495,
0.8413381577,
0.6046347022,
-0.4113427103,
-1.4313426018,
0.1748639196,
-0.0584115796,
0.1573032588,
-0.0779617727,
-0.6921493411,
0.9400904179,
-0.4198235273,
-0.2075952441,
-0.1688760221,
0.6540732384,
0.1356686503,
0.4624115825,
0.8504282236,
0.3288527429,
0.6613316536,
0.0388980024,
1.0692719221,
-0.2010556757,
0.3244016469,
1.1817889214,
-0.4534185529,
0.5943850279,
0.4944545925,
-0.4740685225,
0.3866035342,
0.4910613298,
0.414121002,
0.1760489047,
0.0743493885,
0.133891508,
-0.4049370289,
-0.2692610621,
-0.1956149936,
0.4294002652,
0.3910613954,
-0.3778425753,
0.0964674726,
-0.1411040723,
0.0580312237,
0.1182417125,
-0.4544036388,
0.4265362024,
0.0468044356,
-0.9199608564,
0.2253351957,
0.0088465456,
1.0580285788,
-0.3896329403,
0.2606168091,
0.0614409,
0.0212827027,
-0.0536751747,
-0.5782361627,
0.3299043179,
-0.0779665038,
-0.7159646749,
-0.325209856,
0.8415024877,
-0.1563357115,
-0.410256803,
0.5107824802,
0.7773298621,
0.0471134856,
-0.1740022451,
-0.9233031273,
-0.081461966,
-0.0856321454,
-0.2552152872,
0.2797931433,
-0.3664630055,
-0.3961850107,
0.7564719915,
0.6713852286,
-0.021188369,
0.1370481402,
-0.1589684188,
0.3903461695,
-0.8975082636,
-0.6309077144,
-0.8237735033,
0.1243173704,
-0.1906392872,
-0.3938993812,
0.6371418238,
0.3997639418,
0.8100247979,
0.0280761719,
0.6450107098,
-0.081417121,
0.7027244568,
-0.1340618134,
0.4418807626,
-0.2472547144,
0.020332396,
-0.317104727,
-0.8309755325,
-0.0878793001,
0.5235396028,
-0.660471499,
0.1943303198,
0.7347406745,
0.6723365784,
0.0201407094,
0.3168869913,
0.1883522421,
0.2126615345,
-0.0031704155,
0.3297429979,
0.9111938477,
0.0014076674,
0.0996198431,
-0.5606949925,
-0.1910967082,
-0.2824121714,
-0.7973425984,
-0.946415484,
-0.6248284578,
-0.3640887141,
-0.3932684958,
0.1473649144,
0.8881394863,
1.0283453465,
-0.4528772235,
-0.4592352509,
0.4190842211,
0.1480033249,
-0.5928487778,
-0.2177112103,
0.2709873021,
0.1725744009,
-0.7752916813,
-0.0630912036,
0.0542700812,
-0.2466575056,
-0.52180022,
0.0920758694,
-0.3630017638,
0.1937124133,
0.4201351106,
-0.0282861814,
-0.832682848,
-0.2823208869,
-0.1722989529,
-0.1613285094,
0.0064433147,
1.4861357212,
-0.988913238,
0.416436702,
0.5415816307,
-0.0895991325,
0.6023181081,
0.0583547689,
0.6076924205,
-0.3021038175,
0.3193324804,
0.4715620577,
0.2340838313,
0.3947783709,
-0.434158802,
0.5302402973,
0.367233485,
-0.6477959752,
-0.6738005877,
0.3028942347,
-0.8945103288,
-0.4935221374,
0.8049481511,
0.1638529152,
-0.2895745337,
-0.1337683797,
-0.3918165863,
0.4134790003,
-0.6160944104,
0.8542781472,
0.7838505507,
-0.4496942759,
0.3169484138,
-0.7498329878,
0.3697331846,
0.5214669704,
-0.2234780788,
0.0640106052,
0.5732028484,
0.3937466145,
0.4234012365,
0.607004106,
0.025737159,
0.2828668952,
0.0335947946,
0.2933861613,
0.1346267611,
-0.0095107621,
-0.249239102,
0.0837962702,
-0.1319596171,
0.2245962322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15387v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15387v1 | Peek Across: Improving Multi-Document Modeling via Cross-Document Question-Answering | 2023-05-24T17:48:40 | 2023-05-24T17:48:40 | Avi Caciularu, Matthew E. Peters, Jacob Goldberger, Ido Dagan, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The integration of multi-document pre-training objectives into language
models has resulted in remarkable improvements in multi-document downstream
tasks. In this work, we propose extending this idea by pre-training a generic
multi-document model from a novel cross-document question answering
pre-training objective. To that end, given a set (or cluster) of
topically-related documents, we systematically generate semantically-oriented
questions from a salient sentence in one document and challenge the model,
during pre-training, to answer these questions while "peeking" into other
topically-related documents. In a similar manner, the model is also challenged
to recover the sentence from which the question was generated, again while
leveraging cross-document information. This novel multi-document QA formulation
directs the model to better recover cross-text informational relations, and
introduces a natural augmentation that artificially increases the pre-training
data. Further, unlike prior multi-document models that focus on either
classification or summarization tasks, our pre-training objective formulation
enables the model to perform tasks that involve both short text generation
(e.g., QA) and long text generation (e.g., summarization). Following this
scheme, we pre-train our model -- termed QAmden -- and evaluate its performance
across several multi-document tasks, including multi-document QA,
summarization, and query-focused summarization, yielding improvements of up to
7%, and significantly outperforms zero-shot GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. | [
-0.3748439252,
-0.6097958088,
0.8423844576,
-0.1354582012,
-0.2665217221,
0.1986150891,
0.1561076939,
-0.4723451436,
0.1371360868,
0.4062823951,
-0.8144213557,
-0.5627973676,
-0.7787060142,
-0.0520843826,
-0.6072878242,
0.9947791696,
-0.1544613987,
0.0857496709,
-0.3189171255,
-0.0026688769,
-0.1740821451,
-0.4579167068,
-0.2617304325,
0.0751154423,
0.6127721071,
0.3396109045,
0.3595587313,
0.0683889538,
0.3210986555,
0.2508359253,
0.3126826882,
0.1747082472,
-0.3531089723,
0.0291213933,
-0.0716390237,
-0.9197658896,
-0.3856701255,
0.263215214,
0.817263782,
0.3649796546,
0.03438548,
0.0226892885,
0.0475302525,
0.2270103693,
-0.826459825,
-0.2273206562,
-0.6504068971,
-0.1079213545,
-0.1234172508,
-0.3433885872,
-0.0819065124,
-0.2014726251,
0.2514811456,
-0.7891545892,
0.693159461,
-0.1336575598,
1.085031271,
-0.0263649914,
-0.3240935206,
-0.3665854037,
-0.4114712477,
0.5067176223,
-0.697091043,
0.4618691802,
0.3764687479,
0.3099309504,
0.4226933122,
-0.9469780326,
-0.5886475444,
0.0315472856,
-0.0584358647,
0.6199752092,
0.1460561007,
-0.0710463151,
0.1605477929,
0.4976041019,
-0.6186478138,
-0.2699846923,
-0.3343370855,
-0.177429229,
0.2585008144,
0.0929377973,
0.2585684955,
0.0397273339,
-0.3556096554,
-0.2111837566,
-0.4997948706,
0.116947256,
0.4253109694,
0.0593415424,
0.0996859744,
0.4827366173,
-0.1937702894,
0.2026038617,
0.006708303,
0.0742455199,
0.1887256652,
-0.7692503333,
0.0070810732,
-0.1906590164,
0.4228510559,
0.2434274554,
-0.0442068093,
-0.0685087964,
-0.1416711211,
0.0921491235,
0.470179528,
-0.8405397534,
0.0255260617,
0.2117484212,
-0.4187657833,
-0.0526532121,
0.0567814112,
-0.4939879775,
-0.135955587,
-0.2906803787,
0.5194944739,
-0.5563724041,
-0.1733358651,
0.0771392956,
-0.3719445169,
0.5400137305,
0.5050570369,
-0.7003437877,
0.1553904563,
0.472744137,
0.7598101497,
-0.026239261,
-0.8279305696,
-0.7046425343,
0.229487747,
-0.25086537,
0.9560860991,
-0.6794729829,
-0.4666918516,
0.114183642,
0.0615791194,
-0.5125570297,
-0.183135733,
0.3522953689,
-0.5622751117,
0.7325738072,
-0.2247571349,
-0.475656569,
0.2022258937,
0.9100852609,
-0.5278596878,
1.1328718662,
0.372649014,
-1.100399971,
0.482989192,
-0.7136982679,
-0.3391087651,
-0.3692409098,
-0.1133515537,
-0.366537571,
0.0190618355,
0.6646298766,
0.2800529897,
-0.4061872065,
-0.1103617027,
-0.2148419172,
-0.2252389193,
0.0454752855,
-0.2608196139,
0.3499981165,
-0.2442090809,
-0.1604658514,
0.2875443399,
-0.6625466347,
0.0407143049,
0.0444670953,
-0.4359095991,
-0.4051234126,
-0.5824817419,
-0.0815707967,
0.420034796,
0.2746109366,
-0.5988476872,
0.0958980024,
-0.4515835047,
0.1027686372,
0.2052181661,
0.1484699547,
0.593378067,
-0.5508216023,
1.005510807,
0.1315024793,
0.546900332,
-0.6570647359,
-0.324095428,
-0.6217690706,
-0.2020818591,
0.3337705731,
0.4589519203,
-0.96106565,
-0.1293039918,
-0.1167472377,
-0.4059938788,
-0.845811367,
0.0270092599,
0.5606044531,
0.5441942811,
0.5879961252,
-0.2767878473,
-0.194452256,
-0.6908779144,
-0.3735571802,
0.0226815511,
-0.0092685521,
0.1068985686,
0.4579519928,
-0.2612614036,
0.775934279,
-0.6094722152,
-0.3031274676,
-0.4080681801,
0.5694624782,
-0.0992624089,
0.3363089263,
0.4570822418,
-0.9777774811,
-0.5922622681,
-0.2064395249,
-0.3552885354,
0.0966231823,
-0.1813027859,
-0.3762627244,
-0.0216141399,
0.6251862645,
-0.8365576267,
0.4273197055,
0.2922875583,
0.0585321262,
0.7710735798,
-0.3373723626,
0.4176650941,
-1.5378031731,
0.0682436004,
-0.2811502218,
-0.0528215803,
-0.5099055171,
0.1954555959,
0.4135206342,
-0.3330545127,
-0.6774699688,
0.6337621212,
-0.7505347729,
-0.1753316373,
-0.2673037648,
0.3004899919,
0.502804637,
0.3590119183,
0.1362156719,
0.798193872,
0.5691244602,
-0.4575025141,
-0.021139903,
0.3943199217,
-0.0237195585,
0.6739191413,
-0.5762140751,
0.1697588265,
-0.3826721609,
0.3346068859,
-0.890373528,
0.013914316,
-0.0007849133,
-0.6231753826,
0.4017128348,
-0.2106217742,
-0.3317241073,
-0.2434526533,
-0.6566895247,
0.3921041489,
0.0502763577,
-0.47181651,
1.0606211424,
0.1405915618,
-0.2837590277,
-0.6714690924,
-0.5052956343,
0.0103260027,
0.01667016,
-0.713983357,
0.548160255,
-0.0238623563,
0.3083140552,
0.065829359,
-0.1500255913,
-0.1824939549,
-0.1535131484,
-0.0719489977,
0.2727226615,
-0.3154886663,
0.2741034031,
0.3701738119,
-0.1342431903,
-0.0227286275,
-0.5719224811,
0.4895109832,
-0.0007014008,
-0.4450024664,
0.0944551155,
0.795501709,
0.3518317938,
-0.8390117884,
0.5558264256,
0.7493938804,
-0.1651084274,
-0.2660382986,
-0.5336872339,
-0.1856224388,
-0.3858771026,
0.491699487,
-0.8239668608,
-0.7611218691,
0.4722107053,
-0.0255978107,
0.3143100441,
0.4038047194,
0.2327197641,
-0.2276321352,
0.8441331983,
0.8838549256,
0.1316632926,
0.4959499538,
-0.4051554203,
0.0816374645,
-0.9551907778,
-0.0984688401,
-0.6627377868,
0.2091430724,
-0.1560574472,
-0.6930408478,
0.3297081888,
0.1620751172,
0.1741734445,
0.4194362462,
-0.1572516114,
0.3454922438,
0.6936148405,
0.0597064532,
0.193183139,
-0.4272845089,
-0.3584912121,
0.2453398257,
-0.8101887703,
-0.3855291605,
1.2838513851,
0.2153878659,
0.643279016,
-0.2208880633,
1.0226579905,
-0.1143154949,
0.4353807271,
-0.4256091416,
0.1692546606,
-0.1375805885,
-0.669565618,
-0.458809346,
-0.2579384446,
-0.9559102058,
0.5796917081,
-0.1423159242,
-0.4901078045,
0.0547229536,
0.0919301957,
-0.3673086166,
0.0644322932,
-0.746294558,
1.1255061626,
-0.3495092988,
-0.1616659164,
-0.1585973799,
-0.7700704336,
0.3298131526,
-0.2595396042,
-0.0368368365,
-0.0103923418,
-0.2009637207,
0.5692433715,
-0.1828643978,
0.608861804,
0.0131005822,
-0.0988075063,
0.3562123179,
-0.2350368798,
0.2658753395,
0.0596359149,
0.042138271,
-0.1778407693,
0.5016551018,
-0.5402574539,
-0.8426032662,
0.2586718798,
-0.6349201202,
-0.5366159678,
-0.3409908116,
-0.6657163501,
-0.5473242998,
0.4320560992,
0.4391445518,
0.7005864382,
-0.4641283751,
-0.121143207,
0.6734115481,
-0.1955960691,
0.271802634,
0.6556444764,
-0.137172088,
-0.1860527098,
0.7143434286,
-0.0686830431,
0.4473051727,
0.9152129889,
0.0224134345,
-0.8581943512,
-0.6184871793,
-0.3738811612,
0.3326761127,
-0.9334930182,
0.1416171193,
-1.0127345324,
-0.2860077024,
-0.7516949177,
-0.0305977464,
-0.2532365322,
-0.2388433963,
-0.2299817204,
-0.0285402574,
-0.2815810144,
0.3887051642,
0.2696199417,
0.4619264007,
-1.3308752775,
0.5739180446,
0.363114804,
0.1516332328,
-0.2659516335,
-0.5442997813,
-0.2362469137,
-0.0964876488,
-0.2285028398,
-0.8568282127,
0.1646623015,
0.1913675219,
0.8074581623,
0.103599906,
0.1215962768,
0.3391672671,
-0.3565346599,
0.4098232388,
0.1655977815,
-0.7924740314,
0.7105528116,
-0.4502576888,
0.740929842,
0.9221833944,
0.8178322911,
-0.3037266135,
-0.6129041314,
-0.6908066273,
-0.805876255,
0.616861403,
0.1571358889,
0.1663263142,
0.1366004497,
0.1330002099,
0.2273220271,
0.4451599121,
-0.4172217548,
0.3454270363,
-0.4037151039,
-0.1903603226,
-0.1396229863,
-0.0700072348,
-0.1752229333,
0.101518847,
0.6799362302,
-0.4976609051,
0.0469837263,
0.3549681008,
-0.4899696708,
0.4235469699,
0.4871944189,
0.4542956054,
0.8678418398,
-0.2873739004,
0.1012349203,
0.1110223234,
-0.6075704098,
-0.1324329376,
0.5771920681,
-0.1007740274,
0.0149462642,
0.3520981669,
0.6880270839,
0.2582643628,
-0.430793941,
0.601143837,
-0.4020345807,
-0.3916740417,
0.1313590109,
-0.0534873307,
0.11349383,
0.1846520752,
0.2677746415,
-0.2477888167,
0.1640441865,
-0.8400020599,
0.3554293513,
0.2362451255,
-0.2635479867,
-0.1018741578,
0.5883529782,
0.1789534688,
0.0161086004,
0.3839690685,
-0.0396639444,
-0.7619594932,
0.578546226,
0.4072654247,
0.8620170951,
-0.0729830116,
0.4079124928,
0.2158847749,
0.3779240251,
0.1043406203,
0.4052835703,
-0.3710003495,
-0.6636682153,
-0.1667789072,
-0.5578377247,
-0.5256345868,
-0.1980577856,
-0.5634922981,
0.0950044394,
-0.2046439499,
-0.1304925978,
0.0961531475,
0.1495246887,
-0.5980460048,
0.5179970264,
-0.138319537,
0.9918012619,
-0.6616271734,
0.9882386923,
0.6728783846,
-0.7618115544,
-0.7026298642,
0.4949140549,
-0.263551712,
-0.6881169081,
0.0786529332,
0.3261064887,
-0.1842166185,
0.0556459352,
-0.1284348816,
-0.8064747453,
1.0828949213,
0.137997061,
-0.4688983262,
-0.3822844923,
0.1346711814,
0.4568404257,
-0.4325124323,
0.6626976132,
0.5773382783,
0.3274260461,
0.1355550438,
-0.7176385522,
-0.0376143269,
-0.4719617963,
-0.1226813346,
0.2826608121,
-0.4104680717,
0.9096297026,
-0.1884108335,
-0.166402936,
0.0023050131,
0.5443080068,
0.255063951,
0.4768992662,
0.505400598,
0.4671058059,
0.8164584637,
0.0732252374,
1.3516856432,
-0.4139095545,
-0.0643462166,
1.4833804369,
-0.4201234579,
0.6918705106,
0.3827679753,
0.0559700131,
0.211112082,
0.6107668877,
0.215315029,
0.4512352943,
-0.0542338826,
-0.1426423043,
-0.2002631724,
0.0801524147,
-0.5958650708,
0.2777779102,
0.1101227701,
-0.1518126428,
-0.432064116,
0.0124384882,
-0.3993408084,
-0.0024463064,
-0.2726428211,
0.6595010757,
0.1045028493,
-0.9106075764,
0.1645674855,
0.1150934994,
0.526650548,
-0.9686974287,
0.0963111892,
-0.3076272309,
0.1320875436,
0.1002761722,
-0.7040653229,
0.2856756449,
-0.1296230555,
-0.3560529947,
-0.1247761771,
0.8689706922,
-0.687285006,
-0.4539176524,
0.3663769066,
0.748852253,
0.0004537193,
-0.5116406679,
-0.7788324952,
-0.3194101453,
-0.3303492367,
-0.0993023068,
0.5139836669,
0.4974066019,
-0.1614982337,
0.3185633421,
0.7605946064,
-0.1305101514,
0.4272586703,
0.5708681941,
1.1307173967,
-0.4878009558,
-1.0174970627,
-0.1917127222,
0.5061109662,
-0.2992305458,
-0.6100545526,
0.6103065014,
0.7342754006,
0.8100156784,
0.0263810586,
0.832999289,
0.2083946168,
0.7458382249,
-0.7068678141,
0.7018357515,
-0.7447592616,
-0.1075134873,
-0.1791380495,
-1.0751190186,
0.1370250434,
0.156055212,
-0.4824605584,
0.1457482129,
1.096832633,
0.8389348388,
-0.3124723434,
-0.0608238541,
0.3416014612,
-0.2344382405,
0.2951394022,
0.6329065561,
1.1484439373,
-0.5728011131,
0.8498522639,
-0.1307649016,
-0.1183043346,
0.1277819425,
-0.5902962685,
-1.0596933365,
-0.6068536043,
-0.1916634887,
-0.2565088272,
0.2183716297,
0.3301937282,
0.874946475,
-0.5973522663,
0.1712738425,
0.1092955992,
-0.0178317633,
0.1398056298,
-0.1715057641,
0.2965062857,
-0.6321695447,
-0.7067614198,
0.457624048,
0.2941509485,
0.1346408129,
-0.1407117993,
-0.0426153503,
-0.5843185782,
0.3348905742,
0.5132823586,
0.2165933251,
-0.1163568646,
0.1367086768,
0.1664512008,
-0.30047521,
0.1905539781,
1.0884512663,
-0.3696143925,
0.2689384222,
0.5932394862,
1.0617314577,
1.0703088045,
0.2318111211,
0.6437792778,
-0.8326693177,
-0.0436045825,
0.3260307908,
0.2480479032,
0.2460049391,
-0.2332817465,
0.2742749751,
-0.0180762392,
-0.0693620369,
-0.4328263104,
0.1773180962,
-0.6487733126,
-0.5576573014,
0.8419577479,
-0.4331296086,
-0.2100397944,
-0.2314775288,
-0.3642500341,
0.296775192,
-0.1835796386,
0.6866181493,
0.6188099384,
0.160994783,
-0.5867909789,
-0.3413636982,
0.2906427979,
0.599832952,
-1.4509414434,
-0.2983710468,
0.3941071928,
0.2079305798,
0.1583475769,
1.1064478159,
-0.3049357831,
0.498981148,
0.194637388,
-0.1121929735,
-0.099882409,
-0.6836906672,
-0.0712074861,
0.3520002961,
-0.1175458208,
-0.4615723491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15386v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15386v2 | Vistaar: Diverse Benchmarks and Training Sets for Indian Language ASR | 2023-05-24T17:46:03 | 2023-08-02T13:29:31 | Kaushal Santosh Bhogale, Sai Sundaresan, Abhigyan Raman, Tahir Javed, Mitesh M. Khapra, Pratyush Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Improving ASR systems is necessary to make new LLM-based use-cases accessible
to people across the globe. In this paper, we focus on Indian languages, and
make the case that diverse benchmarks are required to evaluate and improve ASR
systems for Indian languages. To address this, we collate Vistaar as a set of
59 benchmarks across various language and domain combinations, on which we
evaluate 3 publicly available ASR systems and 2 commercial systems. We also
train IndicWhisper models by fine-tuning the Whisper models on publicly
available training datasets across 12 Indian languages totalling to 10.7K
hours. We show that IndicWhisper significantly improves on considered ASR
systems on the Vistaar benchmark. Indeed, IndicWhisper has the lowest WER in 39
out of the 59 benchmarks, with an average reduction of 4.1 WER. We open-source
all datasets, code and models. | [
-0.043152485,
0.2169677764,
-0.2726838887,
0.4265946448,
0.0798594654,
0.3719561994,
-0.4922416508,
-0.8801107407,
-0.2576160431,
0.1713235229,
-0.1277446002,
-0.2385957837,
-0.6431795955,
0.1262253523,
-0.5169125795,
0.7791041136,
-0.0060136239,
0.2809831798,
0.05568121,
-0.6521351933,
-0.3734036684,
-0.3195849061,
-0.254270792,
-0.528433919,
0.0132051809,
0.265897125,
0.1618420184,
0.2978856862,
0.7050648928,
0.339450717,
-0.2496672273,
0.1694947034,
-0.284812212,
0.4280874729,
-0.1650624573,
-0.4016444981,
0.1120935082,
-0.2777237296,
0.578109622,
0.6562023759,
-0.372718513,
0.3032231629,
0.0211695898,
0.7469738126,
-1.018964529,
0.1553522348,
-0.7083984017,
-0.1686972082,
-0.485350281,
0.2159249336,
-0.0853603259,
-0.8814970851,
0.1630711108,
-0.3260806203,
0.1281307787,
-0.229651466,
0.6123703122,
0.3200649321,
-0.2182709277,
-0.4116080403,
-1.0148595572,
0.7385643721,
-0.624684453,
0.5725049973,
0.0023993354,
0.6789467335,
0.221317485,
-0.4645482302,
-0.3135127723,
0.0089070732,
0.3454145789,
0.0175500792,
-0.2483474612,
-0.2183638811,
0.2010885775,
0.7963947654,
-0.0308218859,
0.1324151307,
-0.8079544902,
-0.2311494797,
0.4734528065,
0.3381331563,
0.169980213,
0.1386911869,
-0.2897612751,
-0.2069101185,
-0.646535337,
0.4354715049,
0.4152980447,
0.4810437858,
-0.2974844575,
0.4969446361,
-0.4814923108,
0.7053937316,
0.108282581,
-0.3644548357,
0.5538648367,
-0.0266260132,
-0.0713362396,
0.0089601343,
0.5604071021,
0.252951771,
0.3727937639,
-0.2477968037,
-0.4292934835,
0.6854344606,
-0.101598613,
-0.564253509,
0.028415706,
-0.0119604031,
-0.4125008583,
0.0195608363,
-0.438488394,
-0.4615426064,
-0.5078920126,
-0.3827480078,
0.3374279737,
-0.6728211045,
-0.5768290758,
0.0707555562,
-0.324883014,
0.839219749,
0.314504385,
-0.8811629415,
0.6221686602,
0.5968552232,
0.5968654156,
-0.3925563097,
-0.3916085064,
-0.4424584508,
-0.0331097059,
-0.2549157441,
1.3526422977,
-1.0840480328,
-0.7479162216,
0.2113576531,
-0.5314391851,
-0.3512878418,
-0.8932388425,
0.6027745008,
-0.4317526817,
-0.008144754,
-0.3591122031,
-0.4892303944,
-0.2088964731,
0.2699529529,
-0.2827654183,
0.9367363453,
-0.1387105584,
-0.5498224497,
0.4819636047,
-0.8271697164,
-0.4967781901,
0.2158891857,
-0.3733260632,
0.1228345111,
0.3136049211,
0.4490548372,
0.0235706978,
-0.6046349406,
-0.1881717294,
0.2556298375,
-0.474085331,
0.1314688623,
-0.304692477,
0.6955134273,
0.6264035702,
-0.1331062168,
0.0791592002,
-1.0301686525,
0.3614004552,
-0.4998237193,
-0.6146400571,
-0.3085927665,
-0.1885583997,
0.5080570579,
0.1124075577,
0.1649683863,
-0.8159758449,
-0.2760128081,
-0.817157805,
0.0704441667,
0.4675933421,
-0.0878897607,
0.2690829635,
-0.2510887682,
0.6314880252,
0.0602645837,
0.1614500433,
-0.0062815631,
-0.1147786602,
-0.8116226196,
-0.4140968323,
0.2020054609,
0.4896654785,
-0.3431347609,
-0.1150159687,
-0.3050037324,
-0.607883215,
-0.9831426144,
0.0630131364,
0.9624608159,
0.3350302577,
0.2032515705,
-0.2224928439,
-0.4504618347,
-0.8455296755,
-0.5947942734,
0.0774358734,
-0.0577235669,
-0.1311716288,
0.1420453489,
-0.3585695326,
0.8269450068,
-0.0942809954,
-0.2437912077,
-0.1796525866,
-0.1833509952,
0.2013070881,
0.2242958993,
0.0641733557,
-0.6244091988,
-0.9223810434,
0.2304255813,
-0.5713992715,
-0.0353230946,
0.5369740129,
0.4065542519,
0.3422605395,
0.5459032059,
-0.2162759304,
0.3932751715,
0.5461991429,
-0.0504111983,
0.2066578418,
-0.2611103952,
0.2102722526,
-0.8511927128,
0.0067055463,
-0.1840888262,
0.0675589889,
-0.6433108449,
0.2162757516,
0.0515188538,
-0.2948839664,
-0.4860973954,
0.5714393258,
-0.7437224984,
0.0504024178,
-0.3931541741,
-0.1938980371,
-0.5137591958,
0.2017032355,
-0.0915864632,
0.8498641849,
0.940312922,
-0.5875310898,
-0.0038736148,
0.588414073,
-0.4574394822,
0.6902615428,
-0.860855937,
0.0379761271,
-0.0698866695,
-0.2017753124,
-0.9307757616,
-0.0201411489,
0.0695844293,
-0.3603234887,
0.3208254278,
-0.1216619685,
-0.251257807,
-0.034394525,
-0.3833391666,
0.1066600755,
0.7725566626,
-0.8993415833,
0.7479168773,
0.6132766008,
0.2189696729,
-0.7690310478,
-0.4621885717,
-0.0749697089,
-0.1237862855,
-0.5005005598,
0.0016047859,
-0.1842614412,
-0.4958480299,
-0.2738680542,
-0.476896137,
0.015917208,
-0.3479808569,
0.8387458324,
-0.2034206986,
-0.3120496273,
-0.093621701,
-0.1629497558,
-0.4983229637,
-0.2511918545,
0.1665350497,
0.4383250773,
-0.6607005,
-0.6460015774,
-0.2574589252,
0.2365166247,
0.5148214698,
-0.4728012681,
0.2851501107,
0.2881734371,
-0.365491122,
-0.2085539997,
-0.8681257963,
0.2500413954,
-0.4781517088,
-0.031761393,
-0.6690309644,
-0.8202483654,
0.7347359657,
-0.2319131345,
0.1682371348,
0.4860830605,
0.6342691183,
0.3753661513,
0.5452330112,
0.9632198215,
-0.3593015075,
0.2274582833,
-0.0670494735,
0.0421535969,
-0.9375690818,
-0.4674938023,
-0.7900370955,
-0.0358674042,
-0.8503828049,
-0.4108987153,
0.3431687951,
-0.2118344605,
-0.1483475864,
0.1094144732,
-0.784914434,
0.7740548253,
0.3934696019,
-0.2162294984,
0.4966884255,
0.1829017848,
-0.1647003442,
-0.2140993476,
-0.3920078576,
-0.4909350872,
0.9089379311,
0.2282301486,
1.2561748028,
0.1482873559,
0.3832346797,
0.1956577599,
0.3752428889,
-0.5389931798,
0.3251830637,
-0.4363841712,
-0.7421084642,
-0.1135008559,
0.1108548492,
-0.8374086618,
0.3723754287,
0.0446155034,
-0.5874730349,
0.4854803383,
0.0419131443,
-0.253276825,
-0.0480531193,
-0.6547006369,
0.3124292493,
-0.0623865575,
-0.0156348981,
-0.3070630431,
-0.7038930058,
0.2753452659,
0.1310535669,
-0.063415058,
-0.454246521,
-0.0909910202,
0.6212619543,
-0.6064840555,
0.7233132124,
-0.3086825013,
0.2680695355,
0.2668597698,
-0.2565284073,
0.2077456266,
-0.2573362887,
-0.3746120632,
0.4167761207,
0.031241186,
-0.2214484066,
0.0502141751,
0.7418895364,
-1.0666345358,
-0.1927650273,
-0.776290834,
-0.31884709,
-0.6763544679,
-0.0791373849,
0.4842326343,
0.7802557945,
-0.103333056,
0.1669726819,
0.6670296192,
-0.1205710843,
0.5351677537,
0.9302477837,
-0.1038869992,
-0.2533929646,
0.7868629098,
0.0155904414,
0.1391657293,
0.3093379736,
0.0277717765,
-0.4624062181,
-0.9379983544,
-0.2219216824,
0.1699109524,
-1.0100932121,
-0.2222091705,
-0.7319085598,
-0.5705548525,
-0.2649495602,
-0.1299747825,
-0.5699406266,
-0.3301020265,
0.2906044424,
0.2385058552,
0.7788667679,
0.7966448069,
-0.2533340156,
0.3125200868,
-0.5955582857,
0.3046182096,
0.2240041047,
0.7782019973,
-0.1320945919,
-0.8395301104,
-0.039488703,
-0.3298387229,
0.0886264145,
-0.1173110828,
0.3181644976,
0.438170135,
0.888774097,
0.1812183857,
-0.0675031692,
0.8606532812,
-0.6959864497,
0.6221628189,
0.2986912131,
-0.8277753592,
0.4916645885,
-0.2292772532,
0.5639368296,
0.9917452335,
0.2309636027,
-0.5542907119,
-0.4810120165,
-0.1423898935,
-0.8631084561,
0.5209617615,
-0.0716900676,
0.1761005819,
0.1811704487,
0.1319596916,
0.4962214231,
0.0853496566,
-0.2400547713,
-0.271341145,
-0.1292592138,
-0.1753787249,
0.1213262454,
-0.0650852695,
0.0010508231,
-0.2339720428,
0.5848956108,
0.0609589964,
-0.0410927348,
-0.1713080853,
-0.3318900764,
-0.1349835992,
0.4160239995,
0.3489753306,
0.8999036551,
-0.1539577097,
-0.2144736499,
0.351846844,
-0.7023929358,
0.1769908369,
0.3597963452,
-0.0642594546,
-0.024210602,
0.0461916067,
0.6119229198,
0.2118097991,
-0.932960391,
0.2881882787,
-0.4053837657,
0.2606078684,
-0.565120995,
0.4536887109,
0.2055349499,
0.4224634767,
0.4072549343,
0.5874559879,
0.3664422333,
-0.1346807182,
-0.177377671,
0.3317881823,
-0.5327911377,
-0.3698163033,
0.8561522365,
0.545535624,
-0.4075214565,
0.4838367403,
0.1959011108,
-0.1908303946,
0.1903369129,
0.4044784009,
0.8572103977,
-0.523509562,
-0.1746506393,
0.3473479152,
0.3372905254,
-0.3323116302,
0.4065666795,
-0.1192624867,
-0.6268546581,
-0.2347504199,
-0.979593575,
-0.887409687,
0.0255535766,
-0.6736224294,
0.3276299536,
-0.4427410066,
0.2379070967,
0.1784467548,
0.0572001897,
-0.8304103017,
0.1808418781,
0.2113395929,
1.0722782612,
-0.8227607608,
0.825737834,
0.683177948,
-0.5432866812,
-0.5802547932,
0.111504823,
-0.0326742418,
-0.8572429419,
0.714384377,
0.0596958287,
-0.6229250431,
-0.3410148025,
-0.2999831438,
-1.1278063059,
0.6395305991,
0.2174915522,
-0.7613325119,
0.5044987798,
0.0662700832,
0.9424715638,
-0.3740639091,
0.2121219784,
0.5858866572,
0.1254433095,
0.2080626041,
-1.1488827467,
-0.3248244226,
-0.6492012739,
0.4273418188,
0.2333791554,
-0.841902554,
0.6826619506,
-0.1563812792,
-0.2319174856,
0.0002860708,
0.5866251588,
0.2945688367,
0.2443072647,
0.5000273585,
0.1722927243,
0.6663632393,
0.177476272,
1.1123280525,
-0.3023791909,
-0.3094570637,
1.2917354107,
-0.6640719175,
1.1548752785,
0.3069789708,
-0.3010982871,
0.3344314992,
0.3391029835,
0.1551206857,
0.5692458153,
0.1688443869,
-0.4679477513,
-0.0291882865,
-0.0445108153,
-0.6504671574,
0.7690801024,
0.41577214,
0.3870117664,
-0.4165588021,
0.2805697322,
-0.0776897445,
0.4755107164,
-0.2761634588,
0.6592406034,
-0.015829457,
-0.3683964014,
0.7359588742,
-0.0941652656,
1.240319252,
-0.8718764186,
0.3330565989,
-0.3999455869,
0.6948606372,
-0.2562791109,
-0.3329117894,
0.4504959881,
0.4216950834,
-0.3685329258,
0.0062710699,
0.9347094893,
-0.3679139614,
-0.6242420077,
0.3194308877,
0.5066978931,
0.3584083021,
0.070242919,
-0.3516320288,
0.3542107642,
-0.1288135797,
-0.1192741916,
0.2948705256,
0.1806558371,
-0.2067275345,
0.679078877,
0.4924752712,
0.121310465,
0.2560162544,
0.2174254358,
0.9977160096,
-0.6873121262,
-0.3217308521,
-0.4415125847,
0.4265239537,
-0.1457518041,
-0.6647348404,
1.0339382887,
0.8325042129,
0.7869169116,
-0.1395659596,
1.0150797367,
-0.0251405332,
1.3067829609,
0.0155628221,
0.8144634366,
-0.2456352115,
0.3973392546,
0.1638779342,
-0.6578947902,
-0.2038785815,
0.4751617014,
-0.3103598952,
-0.0288355704,
0.3800626397,
0.8390378952,
-0.1738677472,
0.0590827428,
0.3211746216,
0.09122134,
0.2215929627,
0.2853026986,
1.1037499905,
-0.7516970634,
0.7201049328,
-0.0571847968,
-0.1143757477,
-0.1077583879,
-0.5757616758,
-0.8454700708,
-0.5906667709,
-0.4392630458,
-0.0597695485,
0.226239115,
1.1644073725,
0.5808041692,
-1.1636445522,
-0.6249908805,
0.4150311053,
-0.2298595458,
-0.1721096039,
-0.0629655942,
0.1167151779,
-0.5002032518,
-0.6569148302,
0.6583741307,
0.4402777851,
-0.3560464382,
-0.0797607228,
-0.2009541839,
0.0030433575,
0.1097484082,
0.5251225829,
0.6829560399,
-0.642323494,
-0.1945266128,
-0.1272185445,
-0.1283017844,
0.3228144646,
0.7522978783,
-0.9436653256,
0.5467262864,
0.3442871571,
0.545080781,
0.7515428662,
-0.2998136878,
0.3363505602,
-0.5523984432,
0.212781325,
0.2580735087,
0.0058927704,
0.8380545378,
0.0436300598,
0.7160196304,
-0.1404836476,
-0.388197571,
-0.9455496073,
-0.194183141,
-0.7936124802,
0.1356509924,
1.1380834579,
0.2316678017,
-0.1847731024,
-0.3955005705,
-0.0137654291,
-0.1542478055,
-0.4570113719,
0.6800116301,
0.2669421136,
-0.2648766041,
0.1656593233,
-0.3400069773,
0.5088832974,
-0.0722394362,
-0.8604966402,
0.1454147547,
0.4668711126,
0.8208927512,
0.1752158403,
1.0761269331,
-0.3641676307,
0.2066389471,
0.4268488586,
0.3149512708,
0.0918133855,
-0.0599021055,
-0.689625144,
0.1187950224,
0.3281029761,
-0.4210136235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15380v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15380v1 | Sentiment Analysis Using Aligned Word Embeddings for Uralic Languages | 2023-05-24T17:40:20 | 2023-05-24T17:40:20 | Khalid Alnajjar, Mika Hämäläinen, Jack Rueter | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present an approach for translating word embeddings from a
majority language into 4 minority languages: Erzya, Moksha, Udmurt and
Komi-Zyrian. Furthermore, we align these word embeddings and present a novel
neural network model that is trained on English data to conduct sentiment
analysis and then applied on endangered language data through the aligned word
embeddings. To test our model, we annotated a small sentiment analysis corpus
for the 4 endangered languages and Finnish. Our method reached at least 56\%
accuracy for each endangered language. The models and the sentiment corpus will
be released together with this paper. Our research shows that state-of-the-art
neural models can be used with endangered languages with the only requirement
being a dictionary between the endangered language and a majority language. | [
-0.0517560728,
-0.4903383255,
0.0396550559,
0.3798793554,
-0.5265705585,
-0.0335714445,
-0.4636146724,
-0.3675512969,
0.3954333961,
0.2893719077,
-0.2295012921,
-0.8369650841,
-0.6292184591,
0.0988657847,
-0.0418919176,
0.9667569995,
-0.0722432286,
0.3238152564,
-0.0117629189,
-0.8143801093,
-0.3185594976,
-0.4829377234,
-0.2191865146,
-0.1878816336,
0.3616812527,
0.0165288094,
0.9262256622,
0.4628484249,
0.6560388207,
0.3395855427,
-0.2196641713,
-0.1432775408,
-0.29413113,
0.2049250901,
-0.0968773961,
-0.2821575403,
-0.4192249775,
-0.0604474843,
0.5106506944,
0.6130616665,
-0.2059998512,
-0.010949254,
0.0746182799,
0.4203681648,
-0.6307278872,
-0.1043211445,
-0.4524682164,
0.2229916602,
-0.1819749922,
0.2202904373,
-0.2175791711,
-0.5857391953,
0.1371647716,
-0.3479050696,
-0.2695802152,
-0.1393721402,
0.6437536478,
0.2896543145,
-0.0799705833,
-0.1724334061,
-0.2278788239,
1.1931519508,
-0.9346119761,
0.1823528856,
0.0476538502,
-0.3016242683,
0.1563501209,
-0.3776756227,
-0.4034232795,
0.1113613769,
0.2034172416,
0.4318608642,
-0.3572353125,
0.0652453676,
-0.3150255382,
0.032198891,
-0.3905086815,
0.3252398074,
-0.0419684015,
-0.1756784618,
0.7224718928,
0.1452060044,
0.4316084981,
-0.3965493441,
-0.5555955768,
0.1386549175,
-0.4427506924,
-0.0924736112,
0.777135551,
0.6967315674,
-0.0587516204,
0.5464339852,
0.1273068488,
0.7669642568,
-0.3985413611,
0.0091804788,
0.346778214,
-0.094771713,
-0.1084636748,
-0.1039566547,
0.8997662663,
0.7572091222,
0.3814921677,
0.0489437394,
-0.3031836748,
0.2195637971,
0.3230349123,
-0.2348100841,
-0.0759876519,
-0.0266266912,
-0.6203636527,
-0.6009386778,
-0.3443365693,
-0.955868125,
-0.4373299479,
0.0729662403,
0.3014692068,
-0.4519436657,
-0.6095631719,
0.2051483542,
-0.2492006123,
0.2633391321,
0.0713814422,
-0.8534029126,
0.2488026321,
0.7375793457,
0.8421081901,
-0.2922607958,
-0.1483301967,
0.2922378182,
-0.1665948033,
-0.2238360792,
0.6527372599,
-0.8659698963,
-0.2606300116,
0.4491898715,
-0.2206507027,
-0.2241526842,
-0.2311279178,
0.9304991961,
-0.664319694,
-0.0548022427,
0.0070239869,
-0.5640641451,
-0.5746075511,
0.4524943829,
-0.6110880375,
0.990778029,
0.0432000048,
-0.9685978889,
-0.031230906,
-0.4324405491,
-0.2402697504,
0.1161316186,
-0.1035065055,
-0.419773221,
0.2496266067,
0.1416953653,
0.3150574565,
0.0940196365,
0.0620904341,
-0.6066852808,
0.0228455905,
0.3631179929,
-0.2988293171,
0.9944499135,
0.1746069342,
-0.3587564528,
-0.1193545535,
-0.1183509752,
0.2599992156,
-0.0642133653,
-0.465715766,
-0.8065440655,
0.0166938547,
0.4406495094,
-0.0089304456,
0.3964052796,
-0.9469556808,
0.1594006866,
-0.3867757618,
0.3387441039,
0.8177999854,
-0.1796666831,
0.4180862308,
0.2528809309,
0.8090046048,
0.1259457618,
0.1694895029,
0.4933669865,
-0.5766230226,
-0.6729120612,
-0.0917875245,
0.7065233588,
0.613099277,
-0.0537968092,
0.7339198589,
-0.3523941934,
-0.1115793809,
-1.0534814596,
-0.0086135995,
0.1586127281,
0.3127402663,
0.1182263717,
-0.247790426,
-0.7941343188,
-1.0702499151,
-0.2415469587,
-0.4135280252,
0.615465343,
-0.0109838927,
0.2908534408,
-0.2664341331,
0.7501670122,
-0.3092556596,
-0.1404687613,
-0.2113792598,
0.1286378205,
0.0540159382,
0.5900102258,
0.4407019615,
-0.8418649435,
-0.4518289864,
0.124465555,
-0.8497788906,
0.0391351841,
0.2793468237,
-0.2494849116,
0.4819191098,
0.272585839,
-0.2173200846,
0.4252885282,
0.8824646473,
-0.0046013114,
-0.034365844,
0.2703563571,
-0.1394997537,
-1.32467103,
0.0229832232,
-0.0047887824,
-0.1433270723,
-0.610665381,
0.1016430259,
0.0282212105,
-0.0138117373,
-0.3556811512,
0.3042035699,
-0.5064423084,
0.1063917801,
-0.3850943446,
0.2284564376,
-0.3806363046,
0.2540363073,
0.3066053391,
0.2089611739,
0.5076062679,
0.1043745652,
0.2720833123,
0.4415099919,
-0.2908683419,
0.2548308372,
-0.4033800364,
0.0243265238,
-0.100780651,
-0.2619283199,
-1.0425518751,
0.1562327892,
0.198678419,
-0.562687099,
0.2480914146,
-0.4071899056,
0.161034137,
-0.3023771346,
-0.3675090373,
0.3903310299,
0.4780177474,
-0.235883981,
0.660133481,
0.7642911077,
-0.539753139,
-1.1550784111,
-0.8046511412,
0.1408930719,
-0.4316157699,
-0.5968526602,
0.0989379659,
0.042890083,
-0.3589873016,
0.4361400306,
0.2658863664,
0.1170663908,
0.2844133973,
0.4019378424,
0.3947592974,
-0.3669926524,
0.2095471919,
0.0682357773,
0.0632590726,
-0.1392309815,
-0.2908432186,
0.5064092278,
-0.4685462117,
-0.1109986901,
-0.3551957607,
0.5512845516,
0.3995108306,
-0.1822083145,
0.7512270808,
0.3780209422,
-0.5104795694,
0.0106618712,
-0.3992791176,
0.2873041928,
-0.3745593131,
0.3871975839,
-0.2172254771,
-0.7882081866,
0.6103599668,
-0.0602215193,
0.2059495002,
0.62505126,
0.6653044224,
-0.0828554332,
1.2798802853,
0.8324986696,
-0.800352633,
0.4464087188,
-0.2194977254,
0.3586874604,
-0.8463871479,
-0.1421010196,
-0.4715821445,
-0.5585500002,
-0.635479331,
-0.0362915136,
0.1060468182,
0.1751207709,
0.2063233405,
0.2738142014,
-0.3614602089,
0.3853754103,
0.1784098297,
-0.021928167,
-0.0762807876,
0.3285425305,
-0.3639206886,
-0.2588987947,
-0.55302459,
-0.8146460652,
0.9696733952,
0.3646841645,
0.8877288103,
0.1858799458,
0.9771418571,
0.4417276382,
0.6480302811,
-1.20558393,
0.2851065397,
-0.2840221524,
-0.727153182,
-0.4744121134,
-0.0028004325,
-0.6307867169,
0.2485711724,
-0.0497049578,
-0.5901317596,
0.5166667104,
-0.393520385,
-0.5781843662,
0.3822105229,
-0.4729849696,
0.6653687358,
-0.2010264695,
-0.1912793368,
-0.1980536729,
-0.5605541468,
0.1249712631,
0.2079918981,
0.0103888009,
-0.1985335797,
-0.3860585988,
1.0290498734,
-0.12380483,
1.1370792389,
-0.2113994509,
0.0173147041,
0.2638289034,
-0.0732600391,
0.2626405358,
-0.1602859795,
-0.7807561159,
0.2444353402,
-0.401977092,
-0.4291171134,
-0.2874982953,
0.8063557744,
-0.9823621511,
-0.4454489946,
-0.5320982337,
-0.5712605119,
-0.1077352464,
0.1334924996,
0.2465310395,
0.1763697118,
-0.567630589,
0.0510171503,
0.2572728097,
0.2164708078,
0.7303105593,
0.464250803,
0.2123097628,
-0.7623227239,
0.6830046177,
0.3463525176,
-0.1676050276,
0.0980438963,
0.1940503269,
-0.5122431517,
-0.9033654928,
-0.4556897879,
0.1313335598,
-0.7099343538,
-0.4516437948,
-0.8757324219,
-0.019437883,
-0.5555753112,
-0.2702926695,
-0.2776646018,
-0.4155512154,
-0.2176271677,
-0.3824651837,
0.469538033,
0.7843447328,
-0.3652909398,
0.3505755961,
-0.9106297493,
-0.3983029723,
0.1422733217,
0.1615509391,
-0.0959662646,
-0.6568923593,
-0.1582859755,
-0.0298645571,
-0.244150877,
-0.9269251823,
0.6578202844,
0.24190256,
0.7093372941,
0.6519181728,
0.2336238325,
0.5067840815,
-0.2031383514,
0.659296453,
0.2430082411,
-0.8661398292,
0.251024574,
-0.4133969247,
-0.2910570204,
0.7766436338,
0.8250438571,
-0.7408458591,
-0.2830687165,
-0.5606750846,
-0.8216910362,
0.484613806,
0.0084460294,
0.5928564072,
-0.2151036859,
0.0588894598,
0.296217978,
0.1012889892,
-0.7588888407,
-0.0117041767,
-0.1623788178,
-0.847682178,
0.0726795942,
-0.288985014,
-0.3877803385,
-0.2231556475,
0.6436418891,
-0.184074074,
0.4115055799,
-0.0314016193,
-0.3324680328,
-0.1508408785,
0.1378439963,
0.3916861415,
0.2289973795,
-0.176089704,
0.0636833608,
0.1009129733,
-0.5406324267,
0.1719553918,
0.0469418019,
-0.2581517994,
0.0127461869,
0.289385736,
0.7567846775,
0.0192026366,
-0.2232768983,
0.6926945448,
-0.1225647703,
0.0474663712,
-0.4621296227,
-0.3583417237,
0.4341313243,
0.122613579,
0.0957475379,
0.2321422547,
0.0145408725,
-0.2896364927,
0.008070901,
0.5640138388,
-0.6084114909,
-0.5022277236,
0.0854953527,
0.6066423655,
-0.1842839271,
0.9455263615,
0.1652116477,
-0.9024261832,
0.5279162526,
0.7386218905,
1.0563124418,
-0.3984404504,
0.4526270032,
0.345398128,
0.487354964,
0.0049412963,
0.7119493484,
0.2845326066,
-1.1284697056,
-0.2440085113,
-0.8696247935,
-0.3597455621,
-0.0674142763,
-0.942482233,
-0.0394024476,
-0.3101987541,
-0.5319418311,
0.0855501816,
-0.1400556713,
-0.22691603,
0.0788089633,
0.3209367692,
0.8170895576,
-1.3823766708,
0.5494717956,
0.9603598118,
-0.3463411629,
-0.6315951347,
-0.191452831,
-0.099012211,
-0.9686253071,
0.5173874497,
0.1703587919,
-0.0712765306,
0.1562824398,
-0.6229364276,
-0.8492553234,
0.5683946609,
0.2394867092,
-0.3132559955,
0.5155866742,
-0.11667265,
0.739608407,
-0.6386637688,
0.1353929043,
0.4941044152,
0.4958716035,
-0.4940950274,
-0.1315084249,
-0.0898988768,
-0.6058081388,
-0.0412247255,
0.4383210242,
-0.6873427629,
0.6561871767,
-0.0632598251,
-0.2411349714,
0.4213024676,
0.8978379965,
-0.1615130752,
-0.1814127713,
0.6055235267,
1.0663436651,
0.6517617106,
-0.0969615355,
0.7905417085,
-0.1802189052,
0.310680151,
0.7642827034,
-0.4609585106,
1.2248644829,
0.5716933012,
-0.2762926519,
0.6967455149,
0.6274819374,
0.0135276262,
0.5689721704,
0.092918478,
-0.6427437663,
-0.4828620553,
-0.4644962549,
-0.2080570608,
0.6369245052,
0.4574273229,
-0.4968517721,
-0.1655274332,
0.1650903523,
0.0904920846,
0.1156253591,
-0.2511124909,
0.7260231972,
0.0662830994,
-0.5901173949,
0.5392565727,
0.1912121177,
0.9040760398,
-0.380086422,
0.2563024759,
-0.459387213,
0.2333264649,
-0.3724064529,
-0.8813245893,
0.2473774403,
0.1084293872,
-0.0649658367,
0.1446813196,
0.6958385706,
-0.4519777894,
-0.6757465601,
0.6065702438,
0.2911518812,
0.2825196385,
0.320635587,
-0.8219281435,
-0.0701220855,
0.2531474531,
-0.3855690062,
0.1536422819,
0.1510008723,
-0.3018308282,
0.4844306111,
0.4014142752,
0.3349776864,
0.3974629045,
0.2114157975,
0.9126704931,
-0.6461175084,
-0.5225054622,
-0.8507840633,
0.5805455446,
-0.2487609684,
-0.4164692163,
0.6682591438,
0.4014897645,
0.414152652,
-0.2058556229,
1.0750607252,
-0.1627478153,
0.2957231402,
-0.2222774327,
0.7573735118,
-0.3519945145,
-0.4642789662,
-0.3111281097,
-0.8237867355,
-0.4529880881,
0.7227480412,
-0.3262379467,
-0.2826893628,
0.4946435094,
0.9993857145,
0.0067051006,
0.2549262345,
0.3356703222,
0.0327473991,
-0.2499955148,
0.2577207088,
1.0235159397,
-0.4059826136,
0.3947193921,
-0.3188537955,
-0.3123682439,
-0.1810294986,
-0.9232552648,
-0.4751545191,
-0.3184604943,
-0.3337746561,
-0.2104572803,
0.0869692713,
0.7979903817,
0.3694472313,
-1.0247864723,
-0.2543309629,
0.1430486292,
0.1453417987,
-0.1873476952,
-0.1568456143,
0.4021302164,
-0.2898176312,
-0.9020574689,
0.240086481,
0.1787574589,
0.2243545353,
-0.33260414,
-0.1751857102,
-0.4380694032,
0.007184281,
0.3058827519,
0.2406293154,
-0.5450748205,
-0.2193012834,
0.0009242745,
-0.3288766742,
-0.0668878108,
0.6423339844,
-0.308891952,
0.4250643253,
0.7940517664,
0.7687783837,
-0.1615603715,
0.1674518734,
0.5836274624,
-0.5903638005,
0.2175722867,
0.5499436259,
0.6137887836,
0.5897554755,
-0.2620200515,
0.553653419,
0.1381862462,
-0.4098319709,
-0.6558449268,
0.1182928607,
-0.8493327498,
0.1305832863,
1.0494912863,
-0.5425227284,
-0.5537137985,
-0.3116725087,
-0.0244666282,
0.3730093837,
-0.4208090305,
0.6624053717,
0.7242497206,
0.097625874,
0.1917835325,
-0.0638410076,
0.2253927439,
0.7901014686,
-0.3716827333,
0.0464173853,
0.3055881262,
0.3013156652,
0.538333118,
0.3936017752,
-0.4505290389,
0.0410751328,
-0.1141878664,
0.522344172,
0.204046309,
-0.0066092862,
-0.9277181029,
0.1232043952,
0.1347481459,
-0.5697168708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15377v1 | Uncovering and Quantifying Social Biases in Code Generation | 2023-05-24T17:37:33 | 2023-05-24T17:37:33 | Yan Liu, Xiaokang Chen, Yan Gao, Zhe Su, Fengji Zhang, Daoguang Zan, Jian-Guang Lou, Pin-Yu Chen, Tsung-Yi Ho | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the popularity of automatic code generation tools, such as Copilot, the
study of the potential hazards of these tools is gaining importance. In this
work, we explore the social bias problem in pre-trained code generation models.
We propose a new paradigm to construct code prompts and successfully uncover
social biases in code generation models. To quantify the severity of social
biases in generated code, we develop a dataset along with three metrics to
evaluate the overall social bias and fine-grained unfairness across different
demographics. Experimental results on three pre-trained code generation models
(Codex, InCoder, and CodeGen) with varying sizes, reveal severe social biases.
Moreover, we conduct analysis to provide useful insights for further choice of
code generation models with low social bias. (This work contains examples that
potentially implicate stereotypes, associations, and other harms that could be
offensive to individuals in certain social groups.) | [
-0.3163512349,
-0.4682991505,
0.4928773642,
0.3642189503,
-0.106125176,
0.1937046647,
-0.0312853009,
-0.3254692256,
0.1760811508,
0.3986178339,
-0.6113215685,
-0.3706937134,
-0.7958692908,
-0.0552392304,
-0.2227467149,
1.2142534256,
0.2303609848,
0.2624176741,
-0.2059531063,
0.1618111879,
-0.5645440817,
-0.8157253861,
-0.3615748882,
-0.0905270129,
0.3875427246,
0.5868119001,
0.5759354234,
0.355480969,
0.1619690508,
0.2081999779,
0.116668418,
-0.116220966,
-0.5985552073,
-0.1831960827,
0.1253744215,
-0.4784041047,
-0.3310289383,
0.0992515162,
0.0388833322,
0.6664258838,
0.4067845941,
0.777764678,
0.2003425658,
0.6745302081,
-0.7016037703,
-0.055134505,
-0.7338358164,
0.0440326519,
-0.307798028,
-0.4605496526,
-0.4709283113,
-0.915358603,
-0.1972061992,
-0.3317370117,
0.4956977665,
-0.0520740747,
0.5159675479,
0.3412816525,
-0.4913636148,
-0.4733680785,
-0.5053305626,
0.7339417338,
-0.3457160592,
-0.1659979969,
0.2724865079,
0.2912875414,
0.0228336975,
-0.3765713573,
-0.2405041158,
-0.1687925756,
-0.0023314964,
-0.2341849059,
0.1881264746,
-0.141554296,
0.5575719476,
0.0910725892,
-0.5233092904,
-0.1122161075,
-0.7172462344,
-0.2411176115,
0.9140381217,
0.0213732198,
0.4783325195,
-0.4205538332,
-0.0964393914,
-0.043469172,
-1.0544725657,
0.0981686562,
1.2410515547,
0.0057693128,
-0.4850634634,
0.3027306795,
-0.0266072955,
0.4847643673,
0.3136323392,
0.3671643138,
0.3318197727,
-0.410590589,
0.1937678307,
0.1496906281,
0.6522188187,
0.5786068439,
0.8178037405,
0.3436459601,
-0.0527585782,
0.3085061312,
0.4517108798,
-0.6484783292,
-0.2127829939,
0.0965299457,
-0.8583593369,
-1.0936331749,
0.1044356376,
-0.8335847855,
-0.683056891,
-0.0999594331,
-0.143426463,
0.0704725683,
-0.2531866729,
-0.0303726438,
-0.5211378932,
0.2996849418,
0.0553635694,
-0.6256831288,
-0.2334743142,
0.4991030395,
0.5653531551,
0.0966618359,
-0.1224096045,
-0.576867938,
-0.0642868727,
-0.2732681632,
0.7505283952,
-0.5227171183,
-0.5270085931,
0.1172645241,
-0.1161555573,
0.3417868018,
-0.4879331589,
0.2938959599,
-0.167199865,
-0.1002218127,
-0.3891489208,
-0.1584001034,
0.7181866765,
-0.1196896061,
-0.4317271113,
0.9754071832,
0.3235277534,
-1.0916695595,
0.860545516,
-0.6454436779,
-0.4409536719,
0.2179825157,
-0.7581958771,
-0.4939684868,
0.2521985471,
0.0058398638,
0.4183831513,
-0.2141327858,
0.6112101674,
-0.5412111878,
-0.5299167037,
0.1702535897,
-0.2022386044,
1.4423989058,
0.3832222819,
-0.7442920208,
0.0255273581,
-0.5504148006,
-0.0326350406,
0.3126474023,
-0.4056420028,
-0.3514181674,
-0.0658414066,
-0.1215189099,
0.3488390446,
0.2062881887,
-0.5304944515,
0.0636501536,
0.1470643431,
0.3931097686,
1.1723629236,
-0.0553039275,
0.5346378088,
-0.4039039016,
0.7807484865,
-0.1068384349,
0.6013066173,
0.0829119533,
-0.4020712674,
-0.3629302979,
0.2571896017,
0.0378314629,
0.2246536911,
-1.0168012381,
0.4345806837,
-0.1696910709,
-0.4230537713,
-0.2234522998,
0.237724781,
0.6875995994,
0.0225240402,
-0.1410479099,
-0.2826591432,
-0.4632657766,
-0.8246814609,
-0.5150845647,
-0.1543177664,
-0.3916042745,
0.6839271188,
0.3542230129,
-0.3487360775,
0.8096986413,
-0.6876912117,
0.2512612939,
-0.0769255385,
0.2242733389,
-0.1919960827,
0.7435119152,
0.7994940281,
-0.6293236017,
-0.350066036,
-0.3835947514,
-0.4987998605,
-0.560421586,
-0.0668941364,
-0.3252458274,
0.0237739459,
0.7685998082,
-0.0876681581,
0.518801868,
0.5192875862,
-0.4619127512,
0.9692621827,
0.0653930977,
-0.0329408608,
-0.8423644304,
0.0045414641,
-0.0469230376,
0.0849986523,
-0.2156487107,
0.0459487624,
0.1146178767,
-0.3830218613,
-0.4744369388,
0.3668161035,
-0.5272993445,
-0.3062470555,
0.0377727039,
-0.1004072279,
0.0644376054,
0.4573220611,
-0.0545453131,
0.6608303189,
0.3604861796,
-0.5309189558,
-0.0088068526,
-0.1713247448,
-0.3602856398,
0.4148775935,
-0.8876963854,
0.5629187226,
-0.2039597034,
0.4460568726,
-0.7590558529,
-0.2194056809,
0.1024760902,
-0.8213194013,
-0.0899208114,
-0.3317232132,
-0.3919999897,
-0.587338984,
-0.4589695036,
0.8680462241,
0.701163888,
-0.4395598173,
0.003935412,
0.528618753,
-0.2215292007,
-0.4371490479,
-0.2850855291,
-0.3901950717,
-0.3213695586,
-0.7008767724,
-0.0619031563,
-0.2300407887,
-0.3246061206,
-0.5412866473,
0.0062186783,
0.0486357398,
0.089936167,
0.4617780745,
0.2382497191,
0.0012693326,
-0.0877998248,
0.3347104192,
-0.0039532506,
0.4132732451,
-0.2513130307,
0.811806798,
0.0806983784,
-0.23928608,
0.2460638732,
0.4186646342,
0.3372097611,
-0.3702412844,
0.2242835909,
0.3725406229,
-0.1713610739,
-0.3066491187,
-0.3892904818,
-0.0684772953,
-0.5768863559,
0.0613374598,
0.0312849917,
-0.6685022116,
0.4195152521,
-0.0818279982,
-0.0301723424,
-0.0664965212,
0.5217558146,
0.3686749637,
1.3534879684,
0.7243490219,
0.0772252679,
0.7566720843,
-0.1315068156,
0.1461821496,
-0.4616084397,
-0.0714192465,
-0.8712232113,
0.0017467567,
-0.7103318572,
-0.3601745069,
0.279761523,
-0.1931308657,
-0.3724496067,
0.2110198587,
-0.9734630585,
0.6982056499,
0.698897779,
0.2389579117,
-0.0949831307,
-0.1240426451,
-0.1845082939,
0.4601161182,
-0.7811304927,
-0.7986694574,
1.4222134352,
0.2349901944,
0.669159174,
-0.13082771,
1.0671035051,
0.6577433944,
0.5111783743,
-0.2278024107,
0.353856802,
-0.124609001,
-0.9690805674,
0.0111663491,
-0.5541776419,
-0.9308537245,
-0.4149969816,
-0.0117833493,
-0.602294147,
0.6332592964,
0.6411759853,
-0.7349782586,
-0.2644065619,
-1.170541048,
1.0094225407,
-0.3522964716,
-0.5738567114,
0.1180595607,
-0.8091859818,
0.5155915022,
-0.2216722816,
0.4464844167,
-0.0630457923,
0.5108762383,
0.6595141292,
-0.5949921012,
0.9925171733,
-0.5818418264,
-0.217547372,
0.3206145167,
0.0317983292,
0.3658227324,
0.2835702002,
-0.09775123,
0.2461519539,
0.1446878761,
-0.7605458498,
-0.2152686715,
0.4639464915,
-0.8019830585,
-0.2474640161,
-0.1005449891,
-0.3582134247,
0.0131453741,
0.1611738503,
0.8230424523,
0.5651208758,
-0.1931243241,
-0.091110982,
0.5103478432,
-1.0790640116,
-0.0287675019,
0.2943734229,
-0.0580645688,
0.1809781045,
0.9649472833,
0.020712249,
0.4800252616,
-0.3797016144,
0.1007730961,
0.332942009,
-0.2206942886,
-0.3566913307,
-0.1356339306,
-0.4778351486,
-0.1590203792,
-0.4339933693,
0.0225917716,
-0.7153733969,
-0.7568084002,
-0.1692557931,
-0.0757810548,
-0.0310182218,
-0.1429523081,
0.0409958363,
0.9673185945,
-0.0010813064,
0.6088166833,
-0.5371709466,
0.3813020289,
0.2141661644,
0.3587882221,
-0.0172320344,
0.038416639,
-0.2293522656,
0.0931601301,
-0.4255092144,
-0.9139606953,
0.086610578,
-0.4946650267,
0.3357259035,
0.4268851578,
0.4336616397,
0.1302063614,
-0.4344666898,
0.846699059,
0.2068507969,
-0.9690214992,
0.7737923861,
-0.6406165957,
0.3132760525,
0.5865767002,
0.1819481999,
-0.2118836939,
-0.7603822947,
-1.0522118807,
-0.8055531383,
0.6871170998,
0.1420426816,
0.2748422027,
-0.4310201705,
0.3403761685,
0.2589227259,
0.1713411659,
-0.9349347353,
-0.1643261909,
-0.4670166969,
-0.128001973,
0.0506882444,
-0.3254509568,
0.0795899779,
-0.0705411062,
0.237924099,
-0.1987399012,
0.4690735042,
0.0044364645,
-0.2273452133,
-0.306155473,
0.2189411521,
0.4891386032,
0.6143549681,
-0.1099026874,
0.1583471596,
-0.2035866231,
-0.415001303,
0.2624960244,
0.0153145818,
-0.282168895,
-0.0320911258,
0.2836257815,
0.3695790768,
-0.0118396496,
-0.6043508649,
0.9453088641,
-0.1970982701,
-0.1294158846,
-0.6270033121,
0.2344803065,
-0.1589478403,
-0.0898660719,
0.282304585,
0.277531147,
0.2992669046,
-0.5672593713,
0.1627117246,
0.5587841868,
-0.2317165136,
-0.2456702441,
0.723415792,
0.7355874181,
-0.4562712312,
0.1064123139,
-0.4707808197,
-0.6095040441,
1.184352994,
0.1426848024,
0.8349013925,
-0.1237751469,
0.4980396926,
0.3245445192,
0.4532001019,
0.2318667322,
0.2222723365,
-0.3118973076,
-0.7587729096,
-0.1768111438,
-0.4450449944,
0.0239876825,
-0.1840210706,
-0.8624072671,
0.3771752417,
-0.6607144475,
-0.3887291253,
0.1100598052,
-0.1065311134,
-0.9997106194,
-0.1340138763,
0.1783216149,
0.600769341,
-1.1013604403,
0.7130788565,
0.5345591903,
-0.3102433681,
-0.8981035948,
0.2433010936,
0.1741288155,
-1.0285624266,
0.9142790437,
0.3217493892,
-0.1706338525,
-0.1491298378,
-0.9677463174,
-0.3875775933,
0.6663331985,
0.4537064731,
-0.3695126474,
-0.2717471421,
0.1441132426,
0.3080387115,
-0.4101977348,
0.2511236668,
0.4855706692,
0.2778965533,
-0.5549060106,
-0.648439467,
0.2160651088,
-0.5951073766,
0.212281093,
0.0427601896,
-0.5618196726,
0.8222754002,
-0.2993260026,
-0.1207946241,
-0.1756253988,
-0.2159346044,
0.5050755143,
0.5777795911,
0.4758148193,
-0.3480971158,
0.48120749,
0.0736682042,
1.2183730602,
-0.5317708254,
0.0398815051,
0.9882051945,
-0.3158337772,
-0.1435764879,
0.3962824345,
0.0567375161,
0.3999074697,
0.6261951923,
0.226699546,
0.0908381715,
0.6343165636,
-0.0062457304,
-0.1133366078,
-0.1596249938,
-0.581297636,
0.1571633369,
0.1007864699,
-0.6388363242,
0.0784622431,
-0.0696525201,
0.1777579784,
0.0504649319,
-0.274038583,
0.6795794368,
0.1155289784,
-0.7179604769,
0.3766804338,
-0.1985155642,
1.0027863979,
-0.504791677,
-0.0434902832,
-0.4568869174,
0.1737669706,
-0.3567065895,
-0.3222698867,
0.1249457523,
0.2505352497,
-0.1962216944,
-0.4000057876,
0.7945675254,
-0.087184757,
-0.4145309031,
0.3940363526,
0.4791615009,
0.1192154512,
-0.054616943,
-0.5219504237,
0.1685171276,
0.2754704952,
0.0679512694,
0.266379714,
0.7381068468,
-0.1104310602,
0.3851963282,
0.6160492301,
-0.0231809076,
0.4047429264,
0.0960944071,
0.8216145039,
-0.4812824726,
-0.5884348154,
-0.732100606,
0.5081059337,
-0.2945049405,
-0.4508686662,
0.8214476705,
0.5484946966,
0.9564730525,
-0.2071582079,
1.0282901525,
-0.1398298889,
0.2143188566,
-0.2726923823,
0.7703008056,
-0.2803060114,
0.4406332374,
-0.9765187502,
-0.7071077228,
0.1855283678,
0.4792303741,
-0.6438672543,
0.3811471164,
0.3551098704,
0.9373074174,
0.1506943703,
-0.0522726551,
0.0541097336,
-0.1941718906,
0.2262674272,
0.5142327547,
1.1007809639,
-0.0401944518,
0.6079106927,
-0.2013698965,
-0.5820579529,
-0.2936948538,
-0.8320598602,
-0.9492771029,
-0.2769744694,
-0.157449007,
-0.5339822769,
0.1858886927,
0.8283078074,
0.8032041788,
-0.431378603,
-0.3195806444,
-0.1716635525,
0.299220562,
0.1597287953,
-0.3385019898,
0.0839994401,
-0.2991601825,
-0.351144582,
-0.3597894013,
-0.2736082673,
0.0287739206,
-0.1708997935,
-0.2734389901,
0.2976170182,
0.1849803329,
0.6695260406,
-0.0318476446,
-0.0799648389,
-0.4299605787,
-0.0452065691,
-0.0680594221,
-0.1784746945,
1.4054892063,
-0.4933385551,
0.0555661917,
0.375028789,
0.1669823825,
0.1454345286,
0.0997017547,
0.9965256453,
-1.0837390423,
0.2097379118,
0.0388562456,
0.3234366477,
0.1159622371,
-0.8879675865,
0.4473430514,
0.0532964468,
-0.7824469209,
-0.9357595444,
0.5194205642,
-0.4934587181,
-0.5432747602,
1.2876458168,
0.1248002946,
-0.0538479835,
-0.3452613056,
-0.4652730525,
0.2854771316,
-0.5258428454,
0.9218142629,
0.4258216918,
0.0228632055,
0.1426523924,
-0.6232534051,
0.799810648,
0.3773416579,
-0.8730058074,
0.3286719024,
0.9561315179,
0.3748441041,
0.2343706042,
1.0537189245,
-0.3744073212,
0.6614519954,
0.239630267,
0.3799729347,
0.029400548,
-0.1761673093,
-0.2868509293,
-0.0198704433,
0.2295640856,
0.1618684232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15374v1 | ASPER: Answer Set Programming Enhanced Neural Network Models for Joint Entity-Relation Extraction | 2023-05-24T17:32:58 | 2023-05-24T17:32:58 | Trung Hoang Le, Huiping Cao, Tran Cao Son | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A plethora of approaches have been proposed for joint entity-relation (ER)
extraction. Most of these methods largely depend on a large amount of manually
annotated training data. However, manual data annotation is time consuming,
labor intensive, and error prone. Human beings learn using both data (through
induction) and knowledge (through deduction). Answer Set Programming (ASP) has
been a widely utilized approach for knowledge representation and reasoning that
is elaboration tolerant and adept at reasoning with incomplete information.
This paper proposes a new approach, ASP-enhanced Entity-Relation extraction
(ASPER), to jointly recognize entities and relations by learning from both data
and domain knowledge. In particular, ASPER takes advantage of the factual
knowledge (represented as facts in ASP) and derived knowledge (represented as
rules in ASP) in the learning process of neural network models. We have
conducted experiments on two real datasets and compare our method with three
baselines. The results show that our ASPER model consistently outperforms the
baselines. | [
-0.5047399998,
-0.7110083103,
0.1873435676,
0.1301410347,
-0.0055255326,
-0.1732409298,
-0.4284401536,
-0.8223140836,
0.1890121549,
0.6616669297,
-0.4450650811,
-0.1674952656,
-0.540536046,
0.1196387485,
-0.1673441082,
0.8976458907,
0.0432558209,
0.0849354267,
-0.648329556,
-0.1740956753,
-0.3546001911,
-0.2906014025,
-0.7144548893,
-0.6903871894,
0.191585511,
0.3475821912,
0.4989658594,
0.7022750974,
0.681419313,
0.3088059127,
0.038219884,
0.4061441422,
0.145932585,
0.376163274,
-0.3481296599,
-0.2828607857,
-0.3615340889,
-0.0351166539,
0.3457265794,
1.0353537798,
-0.0425678678,
0.4074479043,
0.0600163452,
0.4957278073,
-0.8249434233,
0.3735258579,
-0.835313201,
0.0456541814,
0.2190682739,
-0.2100748271,
-0.2027223557,
-0.238395229,
0.2341755182,
-0.8263232708,
0.1098028496,
0.0727768764,
1.0345790386,
0.3207700253,
-0.4034008086,
-0.5998268127,
-0.6469302177,
0.58261621,
-0.3721731007,
0.3646115661,
0.4070014656,
0.3144637346,
0.1014030203,
-0.8230808377,
-0.6617164612,
-0.0624662749,
-0.1262596548,
0.1864446551,
0.1562851965,
-0.131929189,
0.6358392835,
0.3151821494,
-0.2526108921,
-0.0441970564,
-0.3599275351,
0.1982923895,
0.7529329658,
-0.0866391659,
0.4084074497,
-0.3369021416,
-0.6853426695,
0.1579718888,
-0.7858261466,
0.0553692579,
0.0796473771,
0.5154312253,
0.2915712297,
0.501523912,
-0.2077255845,
0.674357295,
-0.1812999845,
0.3586239219,
0.043215394,
-0.1393561959,
-0.398842454,
-0.0334695578,
0.736869514,
0.2799065709,
0.4888546467,
-0.4765590429,
-0.2895362973,
0.2031995952,
0.0948380828,
-0.4644456208,
-0.4512392581,
0.1471394151,
-0.5567589998,
-0.1620143205,
0.0038972879,
-0.7615469098,
-0.1642620862,
-0.625246644,
0.4906927943,
-0.5494073033,
-0.6226557493,
0.0366180316,
-0.2961198986,
0.2357435375,
0.4420340359,
-0.7367214561,
0.8027815819,
0.8262668252,
0.5428521633,
-0.1404266804,
-0.2128225267,
-0.6218173504,
0.3374128938,
-0.0500601232,
0.8135911822,
-0.7104667425,
-0.1694940329,
-0.1765670627,
-0.4868130386,
-0.1944487393,
-0.6498645544,
0.2494908273,
-1.0074630976,
0.1148147509,
-0.4083316922,
-0.8866987824,
-0.2186725885,
0.3585585654,
-0.7235879898,
0.8241303563,
-0.2513834536,
-0.8659250736,
0.4194556773,
-0.8709655404,
-0.4289106429,
0.1313159615,
-0.4443985224,
-0.2716861963,
-0.200364247,
0.4231316745,
0.4092260003,
-0.5295547247,
0.255341351,
-0.3265243471,
-0.1830424368,
0.1819075942,
-0.0364642888,
1.1085258722,
0.1028057933,
-0.1579108238,
-0.2160552144,
-0.8877362013,
0.2158884853,
0.207512334,
-0.3998251557,
-0.5848513246,
-0.0994495973,
-0.1631201506,
0.4187746942,
0.1470368356,
-0.5860974789,
0.2070914656,
-0.3776486814,
-0.0289033037,
0.5785652399,
0.4106178582,
0.40112409,
-0.1565692574,
0.3313544691,
0.1003848538,
-0.3952597082,
0.0733885318,
-0.3598853648,
-0.9485173821,
0.2876439691,
0.5883063674,
0.6365414262,
-1.0807033777,
0.561670959,
-0.4871051908,
0.0256280545,
-0.2595843077,
-0.0283413939,
0.5864780545,
0.7748407722,
0.6543903947,
-0.3536222875,
-0.6680324078,
-0.6715313196,
-0.3899927139,
-0.2343667448,
-0.1098746136,
0.3837273121,
0.5504578948,
0.2417210639,
0.8184602857,
-0.6778718829,
-0.1747786403,
-0.1710771173,
-0.1275370419,
0.1193502545,
0.5507830381,
0.1457981765,
-1.0230351686,
-0.6035599113,
-0.0902557224,
-1.1733785868,
0.1442929804,
0.0303427037,
-0.1641491354,
-0.0541267842,
0.3215416372,
-0.6385053396,
0.5355091691,
-0.0928726047,
-0.2698098719,
0.4994082153,
-0.0253170412,
-0.0035253759,
-1.0089563131,
0.2450044602,
0.232481271,
-0.4361239672,
-0.5821275115,
0.3930448592,
0.0326862521,
-0.2234390825,
0.049215965,
0.2418170124,
-0.9226725101,
-0.4042243063,
-0.1859909296,
0.0632036254,
0.2049595118,
0.6272382736,
0.5664950013,
0.4959741831,
0.6470736265,
-0.7792126536,
0.7074013352,
0.8725078106,
-0.0883791819,
0.5436617136,
-0.5380858779,
0.2768971324,
-0.1155248061,
-0.0986043811,
-0.3156727254,
0.0110645108,
0.4194659889,
-0.5118396282,
0.5531354547,
-0.4214815199,
-0.3873488009,
-0.1684048027,
-0.0727970004,
-0.1137696207,
0.3674082756,
-0.8162584901,
0.6648825407,
0.5046541095,
-0.1539733261,
-0.8593851328,
-0.4505157471,
-0.0170475245,
-0.0564933978,
-0.5859174132,
0.2961123288,
0.2595939338,
-0.436692059,
0.389895916,
-0.3610353172,
-0.497397691,
0.04509091,
0.3675013185,
0.3457628787,
-0.3530055881,
0.4566145539,
-0.1313333809,
-0.3366990685,
0.2943463027,
-0.1143553033,
0.4005954862,
0.0902700648,
-0.3891228735,
-0.3151078224,
0.5721751451,
-0.0162784215,
-0.5484575033,
0.827549994,
0.1818705946,
-0.8438218832,
-0.2539229691,
-0.3877498209,
-0.2830497622,
-0.4195419848,
0.3500175774,
-0.6860796809,
-0.301402986,
0.4268363416,
-0.2451716065,
0.2023354322,
0.4153977633,
0.1238921806,
-0.0299746878,
0.4405600131,
0.4991996288,
0.0439566262,
0.206960395,
-0.4208725095,
0.0865533501,
-0.8968364,
-0.397092104,
-0.5271169543,
-0.1946551651,
-0.1310245097,
-0.2078173012,
0.1423370987,
0.2887254953,
-0.2690661252,
0.5068297982,
-0.3405573666,
0.491941154,
0.7418377995,
0.4832523763,
0.5383630991,
0.1386272311,
0.1993219703,
0.0390422344,
-0.5410624743,
-0.388238281,
1.2330327034,
0.1286808997,
0.3046426475,
0.0366687216,
0.7294167876,
0.0573788173,
0.1661831439,
-0.6772868037,
0.6748402119,
-0.0822249725,
-0.6129490733,
-0.3656098247,
-0.6354095936,
-0.6231322289,
0.0717654079,
-0.3745161593,
-0.7798222303,
0.1798064262,
0.2642608881,
-0.5192956924,
0.3981065154,
-0.5804952979,
0.6040317416,
-0.0038674758,
-0.4217072129,
-0.0484465063,
-0.8700550795,
0.1107755974,
0.1968527883,
-0.2721334696,
-0.1195780858,
-0.0715582594,
0.7301870584,
-0.3529668748,
0.3416395783,
-0.4513977766,
0.414467603,
0.3542572558,
-0.102619864,
0.5356196165,
0.4363421798,
-0.3264833093,
-0.0673609152,
-0.170101136,
-0.2066704482,
-0.8896245956,
0.6485331655,
-0.6924382448,
-0.4618798792,
-0.3084199429,
-0.4524335861,
-0.4392234385,
0.0654468015,
0.0867284089,
0.6464467049,
0.1210284382,
0.0172007065,
0.7352894545,
-0.1638081819,
0.5276041031,
0.4314206243,
-0.2137846053,
-0.1938355416,
0.756863296,
0.1869148612,
0.1668659598,
0.3859983683,
-0.2080393434,
-0.4301501215,
-0.4107045233,
-0.3879864216,
0.0197120141,
-0.7496240735,
-0.5471123457,
-0.9435864687,
-0.5526996255,
-0.4425241947,
0.2282806784,
-0.4179105759,
-0.7679628134,
-0.1105172262,
-0.0276801605,
0.2547774315,
0.4121631086,
-0.0451623537,
-0.1382648498,
-0.7473453879,
0.6156182289,
0.5002044439,
0.3833220005,
-0.0178133342,
-0.139039889,
0.0460586436,
0.1864591241,
-0.1452614814,
-1.1445224285,
0.1892950833,
0.5180940628,
0.4342198074,
0.2619826496,
0.1900669187,
0.7809931636,
-0.3566448092,
0.2865360379,
0.0925577357,
-0.7322558165,
0.7204095125,
0.005507295,
-0.1890671104,
0.6344516277,
0.6545315981,
-0.4012627006,
0.1633782983,
-0.9113171101,
-0.7518145442,
0.8195335865,
0.4007724226,
-0.0776090324,
0.1656201035,
0.5391612649,
0.1065045968,
0.4868098497,
-0.7539097071,
-0.5108295083,
0.1726248711,
-0.0518882647,
0.4192464352,
-0.1481588334,
0.0193934422,
-0.2257427871,
0.8669785857,
0.0257600732,
0.5437859297,
0.06006312,
-0.3065992296,
-0.1476500332,
0.0303931367,
-0.3137873113,
0.7642543316,
-0.1687326282,
0.2209339738,
0.2196195722,
-0.2102734149,
-0.1481388956,
0.5010856986,
-0.1810884625,
-0.0941531956,
0.3943850696,
0.5559061766,
-0.2433665246,
-0.3995549679,
0.7904560566,
-0.0373760015,
0.0748553723,
-0.589224577,
0.1906583756,
0.210797444,
0.3024230003,
0.1599787325,
0.5401217341,
0.3625606894,
-0.3981970847,
0.5347821116,
0.3364102244,
-0.4925290644,
-0.1422480047,
0.5754388571,
0.217145443,
-0.3292036653,
0.9732330441,
-0.2048356384,
-0.5189440846,
0.8213610053,
0.7902451158,
0.4048766494,
-0.0792994499,
-0.0263414104,
0.4184050858,
-0.1298705637,
-0.0627262294,
0.3914811015,
-0.3147420585,
-1.2161545753,
-0.435387224,
-0.5014052987,
-0.2345497757,
0.1273906827,
-1.1741269827,
0.3852584064,
-0.4704342186,
0.1616905183,
0.3475512862,
0.1947694123,
-0.8665931821,
0.4630815685,
0.088944003,
0.8558685184,
-0.9605724812,
0.7616456151,
1.0437927246,
-0.719843924,
-1.0128685236,
0.0096387742,
-0.2759687901,
-0.7342885733,
0.793933928,
0.3769899905,
0.3354366422,
0.1937136948,
-0.4412672818,
-0.6484618783,
0.8479726911,
0.300006181,
-0.3395018578,
-0.2227665335,
-0.080801703,
0.3289414048,
-0.4081921875,
0.2946073115,
0.5629386306,
0.0888948217,
0.1965878904,
-0.7861514091,
0.0807138532,
-0.6278870106,
-0.1741463393,
0.3494699597,
-0.347512722,
0.4565156698,
-0.0785696134,
-0.1613718718,
-0.3982614875,
0.820713222,
0.2916441858,
0.3815862536,
0.6323412657,
0.6510388255,
0.5752507448,
0.044585377,
0.7631133199,
-0.1112090498,
0.3089171946,
1.5882662535,
-0.3722783923,
0.9605106711,
0.4682794213,
-0.3614820242,
0.3053694069,
0.3625930548,
0.0252370033,
0.3722437322,
0.0083766496,
-0.3634912074,
-0.4428814054,
-0.24753052,
-0.3240435123,
0.5709207058,
0.4139247835,
-0.476330936,
-0.0657298714,
-0.3046290278,
-0.113736853,
0.3307195604,
-0.4290789366,
1.0016896725,
0.2158671319,
-0.7322908044,
0.118397139,
-0.133315742,
0.35679546,
-0.3025191128,
-0.3027828634,
0.0891497955,
-0.0200969893,
-0.2722797394,
-0.7029620409,
0.5853729844,
-0.0031868394,
-0.3761782646,
-0.1885909736,
1.302849412,
-0.5432841778,
-0.3530731201,
0.2662340999,
0.837947607,
-0.0630612001,
-0.2942916751,
-0.7393143773,
-0.5570795536,
0.0979870334,
-0.3148733079,
-0.0114873573,
0.3444982171,
0.1510658413,
0.7384474874,
0.4984212518,
0.4179419875,
0.0115631837,
-0.1320751011,
1.0796107054,
-0.3909991384,
-0.4125306606,
-0.7470445037,
0.5374195576,
-0.7715057135,
0.0013319622,
0.4566891491,
0.6350524426,
0.7295059562,
-0.0030571774,
0.8718435764,
-0.3552202582,
0.8367022276,
-0.4919419885,
0.541780293,
-0.2450413257,
0.5019833446,
-0.1937496811,
-1.0695427656,
-0.3569047451,
0.7698565722,
-0.498714149,
0.0190934334,
0.5848380327,
0.5128335953,
-0.3174507618,
0.3764205873,
0.0241570864,
-0.3261777759,
0.0760989338,
0.7760254741,
0.948186934,
-0.6569145918,
0.4680528045,
-0.5395120978,
-0.0988467932,
0.2879180312,
-0.5711270571,
-0.9739319682,
-0.5233699679,
-0.6660553217,
-0.3058964908,
0.2220999897,
1.3688139915,
0.4974632561,
-0.7759008408,
0.0362548418,
-0.1770290434,
0.0071365451,
-0.2437200397,
-0.1536460817,
0.5205765367,
-0.2281239331,
-0.5509871244,
0.1224499047,
0.2002449185,
-0.0919217318,
0.2264534831,
0.0445311926,
-0.4709044993,
-0.4013308883,
0.0470724143,
0.1846175194,
-0.0477302484,
-0.2934061289,
-0.3453913927,
0.0785082057,
0.2423851341,
0.6937493086,
-0.6933304667,
0.4515441358,
0.5024033189,
0.791467011,
0.3899670243,
0.3034388125,
0.8212331533,
-0.9775171876,
0.1123223752,
0.4017895758,
0.3012813926,
0.3551126122,
-0.4507217705,
0.7402216792,
0.1968448311,
-0.5428436995,
-0.5882980824,
0.4459833503,
-0.6073778868,
-0.163924545,
1.0623676777,
-0.6777947545,
-0.0265335981,
-0.3328236043,
0.2069226652,
0.5938486457,
-0.2288748473,
0.6688892841,
0.1544682384,
-0.3172631264,
-0.1947036237,
-0.4125844836,
0.5742153525,
0.1069975793,
-1.015591979,
-0.1140404567,
0.3952232003,
0.2895150185,
0.3074136376,
0.606895566,
0.1023381129,
0.26522699,
0.294546634,
0.1837239861,
-0.4728699923,
-0.447696656,
-0.0569584332,
0.3697174489,
0.1215815842,
-0.3391421735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15358v1 | Context-Aware Transformer Pre-Training for Answer Sentence Selection | 2023-05-24T17:10:45 | 2023-05-24T17:10:45 | Luca Di Liello, Siddhant Garg, Alessandro Moschitti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Answer Sentence Selection (AS2) is a core component for building an accurate
Question Answering pipeline. AS2 models rank a set of candidate sentences based
on how likely they answer a given question. The state of the art in AS2
exploits pre-trained transformers by transferring them on large annotated
datasets, while using local contextual information around the candidate
sentence. In this paper, we propose three pre-training objectives designed to
mimic the downstream fine-tuning task of contextual AS2. This allows for
specializing LMs when fine-tuning for contextual AS2. Our experiments on three
public and two large-scale industrial datasets show that our pre-training
approaches (applied to RoBERTa and ELECTRA) can improve baseline contextual AS2
accuracy by up to 8% on some datasets. | [
-0.6228716373,
-0.5688549876,
0.5623783469,
0.1251188517,
-0.1096063033,
-0.2408428937,
-0.2375737429,
-0.4147948325,
-0.0746289492,
0.6875396371,
-0.8466379046,
0.0082100779,
-0.5028805137,
0.2072308064,
-0.5596524477,
1.082695365,
-0.1034327447,
-0.0143273929,
-0.3565101922,
-0.0699454173,
-0.6967226267,
-0.1922725439,
-0.7416680455,
-0.2850857079,
0.4405353367,
0.709675014,
0.5493347049,
0.3818755746,
0.3941170573,
0.2782664001,
0.0396712944,
0.0425657406,
-0.2964796126,
0.2494883239,
-0.2575057149,
-0.6349631548,
-0.1707580835,
0.1227901578,
0.3006034195,
0.5033470392,
0.2107740641,
0.51023525,
0.0967339426,
0.5021178126,
-0.6492047906,
-0.2317636609,
-0.8943420649,
0.0199889299,
-0.0038314771,
-0.3786514401,
-0.4383145571,
-0.2912606895,
0.2914786935,
-0.5349594951,
0.3559113443,
0.0241356958,
0.8528692722,
0.8067829609,
-0.6706238985,
-0.227715835,
-0.7027993798,
0.4911494851,
-0.2554974556,
0.2060172707,
0.4198978245,
0.47564587,
0.5034092665,
-1.101973772,
-0.5368098021,
0.316978544,
-0.51731354,
0.4700812697,
-0.1489135325,
0.0153098544,
0.3568859994,
0.1476370096,
-0.4978803098,
0.1335735023,
-0.5578658581,
0.0355432443,
0.4167653024,
-0.0505386218,
-0.0910053775,
-0.1325783581,
-0.3797613382,
0.0357508324,
-0.8040961623,
0.2682076693,
0.1804968566,
0.3263492584,
0.2039967924,
0.4097228646,
-0.4213720262,
0.7297552228,
0.1366908848,
0.5027241111,
0.1877804995,
-0.3681169152,
-0.2088842988,
0.1998711079,
0.4003203511,
0.2860363126,
0.4955155849,
-0.1634323448,
-0.1871714294,
0.1270141453,
0.7025316954,
-0.9041750431,
-0.0184352286,
0.4264687896,
-0.1881887615,
-0.2999386787,
0.2430004179,
-0.3904403746,
-0.079696998,
-0.4801307023,
0.6317026019,
-0.0806422681,
0.1564413905,
-0.0127180358,
-0.1998887062,
0.4245756865,
0.287972182,
-0.8314367533,
0.0934435651,
0.4907153249,
0.4605578184,
0.0071631372,
-0.2871403694,
-0.9333329201,
0.2045871168,
-0.0677824914,
1.1570236683,
-0.5168420076,
-0.2349027097,
0.1021058932,
0.0917763487,
-0.1541420519,
-0.6993772388,
0.712341845,
-0.8190709949,
0.3920958042,
-0.2743341327,
-0.3018339574,
0.0371217504,
0.2411509305,
-0.4191296101,
0.9122601151,
0.1763448715,
-0.8168666363,
0.4418587685,
-0.8149476051,
-0.7383230329,
-0.1759184897,
-0.0511514135,
-0.3467163444,
0.0736801103,
0.546598196,
0.4708692729,
-0.1401063651,
0.1078320742,
0.2113495916,
-0.5528538227,
0.1320974082,
-0.3174267411,
0.546574533,
0.3113877773,
-0.3845693171,
0.5340594649,
-0.3862243295,
0.1295754313,
-0.2265482694,
-0.2173582911,
0.0286552813,
-0.0805639848,
0.1991159171,
0.2110562027,
0.2462483644,
-0.4479814172,
-0.0326612666,
-0.5381302834,
0.5297138095,
0.635358572,
-0.0921149626,
0.6064747572,
-0.3133554757,
0.5461028814,
0.0071871448,
0.0215063449,
-0.2920183241,
-0.2532729208,
-0.9869347215,
0.1029569954,
0.2963887453,
0.8512230515,
-0.8602385521,
0.6958265901,
-0.4467918277,
-0.4052844644,
-0.5689966083,
0.0576233268,
0.3057830632,
0.7333241105,
0.6999930143,
0.1388022453,
-0.6925426722,
-0.9665317535,
-0.4753535688,
0.2491387278,
-0.4474833012,
0.2579467297,
0.2175571918,
-0.3956700265,
1.400919795,
-0.8311576843,
-0.5669246316,
-0.333296746,
0.0947378129,
0.2105557472,
0.3408504426,
0.2889446616,
-1.0552546978,
-0.6686326861,
-0.1859785914,
-0.5144033432,
-0.212606445,
-0.0827237368,
-0.0629022792,
0.0504175201,
0.9479818344,
-0.6678619981,
0.3338138461,
0.2944652736,
-0.4455849826,
0.1434154361,
-0.2807582617,
0.0269660521,
-1.4193868637,
0.3242994845,
-0.2477091402,
-0.4930495024,
-0.7937458158,
-0.0367629454,
0.1923951358,
-0.1191994622,
-0.4613551199,
0.4091513157,
-0.218023181,
-0.1851706505,
-0.261321038,
0.2409300208,
-0.0318888091,
0.2242999524,
0.2358753979,
1.0355759859,
0.2929669917,
-0.5247626305,
0.1786244214,
0.7687146068,
-0.4981060326,
0.480532676,
-0.8257203102,
0.2617930174,
-0.3612760305,
0.4201111197,
-0.9792814851,
-0.1347340792,
-0.2667236626,
-0.4370368719,
0.0984826535,
0.1468974054,
-0.3036691546,
-0.448366642,
-0.0004776576,
0.1389030367,
0.5073067546,
-0.5113651752,
0.586181283,
0.1816203296,
-0.1971039325,
-0.5456334352,
-0.6482550502,
-0.3906146884,
-0.3152285814,
-0.5669262409,
0.3625915051,
-0.0915352404,
0.1147666276,
-0.2776477933,
-0.3156085014,
-0.0833072364,
0.2447658926,
0.1765590012,
0.0473006219,
-0.1580467969,
0.099636443,
0.1883578151,
-0.5426300764,
0.0589829087,
-0.1610216051,
0.6355128288,
-0.0877990574,
-0.0736058652,
-0.3921421468,
0.2504668832,
0.2071304768,
-0.5632535815,
0.5058033466,
0.7063874602,
-0.2390790284,
-0.0795677826,
-0.5587047338,
-0.448573947,
-0.5648280978,
0.3654085696,
-0.4374367893,
-1.0210131407,
0.3743119538,
-0.0309817493,
0.0101973899,
0.4098760486,
0.2589354813,
-0.3111285269,
0.8382533193,
0.4550342262,
-0.0107588507,
0.6170930862,
-0.2845940292,
0.3765181303,
-0.7694137692,
-0.0058843084,
-0.560649097,
-0.5771166682,
-0.3284777701,
-0.4276094139,
0.6253339648,
0.1603042185,
-0.5798630714,
0.466248244,
-0.4671797454,
0.5749391317,
0.7368395925,
0.1934927851,
0.1366349161,
-0.1246775091,
0.4813258946,
0.2094902545,
-0.4820900261,
-0.4840976894,
0.9367655516,
0.1867333502,
0.3645876646,
-0.1734889746,
0.3303327858,
-0.0252171736,
0.3334554136,
-0.6313589215,
0.3345955908,
-0.2823596597,
-0.7466982007,
-0.5793429017,
-0.11640881,
-0.9956770539,
-0.0906566083,
-0.2660589814,
-0.6265066266,
-0.1036776975,
0.3665015399,
-0.8227228522,
-0.1744484752,
-0.7121645808,
1.1080003977,
-0.0363852978,
0.0627560392,
-0.2350352257,
-1.1608178616,
-0.2804034352,
-0.0439810231,
-0.121994786,
0.1527432054,
0.1059066951,
0.5330952406,
-0.1022695005,
0.4105153084,
-0.376108855,
0.1849255264,
0.3167670965,
-0.3791155219,
0.4977821112,
0.2227383405,
-0.0381224602,
-0.1355949044,
-0.0465005115,
-0.1875478625,
-0.7926823497,
0.4361385703,
-0.8004179597,
-0.7116203904,
-0.0694624633,
-0.3710411489,
-0.5467435718,
0.2040628642,
0.8042790294,
0.5144512653,
0.0906198174,
0.6834384203,
0.7249533534,
-0.0028769257,
0.4544278383,
0.3680124879,
0.0977183282,
-0.1420254707,
0.4487687349,
0.0870114863,
0.2118027806,
0.6510067582,
-0.0016223938,
-0.4372721314,
-0.290530175,
-0.3478774726,
-0.298096925,
-0.7682222128,
-0.5540419817,
-0.8951132298,
-0.5545883775,
-0.4123772085,
-0.5555090904,
-0.2779800892,
-0.2103121877,
-0.3921654522,
-0.3498408496,
0.3118188977,
0.5059894323,
0.4315258861,
0.7171465755,
-0.5340852141,
0.4474290013,
0.6415068507,
0.3633548617,
-0.4258296192,
-0.566860497,
-0.0437060222,
0.1988132596,
-0.3350369036,
-0.5307580829,
0.063743487,
0.3136894107,
0.3495400846,
0.3956729174,
0.1227152869,
0.6558259726,
-0.7028623223,
0.7071796656,
-0.0883129835,
-0.9171865582,
1.0934859514,
-0.306991607,
0.5290842056,
1.0296429396,
0.3801121712,
-0.3566771448,
-0.189253971,
-0.4360601306,
-0.9586877227,
0.8722817302,
0.2754895389,
0.4098308682,
0.1332021356,
0.3893076777,
0.161551699,
0.232322529,
-0.6576327682,
-0.2596875429,
-0.2956914604,
-0.3652280569,
-0.5110923052,
-0.1267830133,
-0.0757484511,
-0.3236029148,
0.5706719756,
-0.3802871406,
0.2720600367,
0.2727911472,
-0.3285034895,
0.05434357,
0.2939088345,
0.4462916255,
0.4427081048,
-0.2217126489,
0.1289582253,
0.5506094098,
-0.3868338168,
-0.0174795017,
0.1899574995,
-0.2146259993,
-0.2517898679,
0.1602390707,
1.0230242014,
0.1222093925,
-0.7550345659,
0.6985952854,
-0.058266487,
-0.01599673,
-0.8075145483,
0.2129864544,
0.0504508838,
0.3686505556,
0.5005105138,
0.4303846359,
0.3349935412,
-0.5385997295,
0.3802288175,
0.3255341053,
-0.6911587715,
-0.1257857829,
0.8633145094,
0.2652388811,
-0.4168944955,
0.702934742,
0.1210002601,
-0.5533490777,
0.5179816484,
0.6324141622,
0.7603678107,
-0.2608640492,
0.0140191726,
0.2798636258,
0.1808684617,
0.0136404252,
0.2697831988,
-0.1454438567,
-0.9300363064,
-0.2705595195,
-0.5810025334,
-0.1463104188,
0.0347879268,
-0.8458083272,
0.7474723458,
-0.1804072261,
0.0527166128,
-0.112752609,
-0.1003898755,
-0.8471586704,
0.709728539,
0.0255154334,
0.9762539268,
-0.8980779648,
0.7457259893,
0.8492749333,
-0.2695562243,
-0.7902982235,
0.3207985759,
-0.6299078465,
-0.6574725509,
0.5774360895,
0.6865006089,
-0.115758419,
0.4596515894,
-0.4711827934,
-0.8418985605,
1.401566267,
0.3988885283,
-0.1464565396,
-0.1323343366,
0.2036230862,
0.5379056334,
-0.5552161336,
0.556291163,
0.7153948545,
0.2885482311,
0.1758971661,
-0.9766375422,
-0.1131278947,
-0.2690585256,
0.0537941791,
0.0117052384,
-0.603213191,
0.4142028987,
-0.0102736726,
-0.0353468396,
-0.0035342623,
0.7374651432,
0.1024771184,
0.2141807824,
0.8257601261,
0.3124845326,
0.4862597585,
-0.2839362621,
0.8820023537,
-0.4488733709,
0.1986399442,
1.3168444633,
-0.1337078512,
1.2228467464,
0.4415917993,
0.1252258122,
0.4627192318,
0.5940505266,
0.212575689,
0.7054316401,
-0.0675179362,
-0.0664857849,
-0.2761859894,
0.0741303712,
-0.2887375951,
0.7822176218,
0.2159672081,
-0.210482955,
0.0335180387,
0.1379121393,
-0.0532912798,
0.1874113083,
-0.3453557789,
0.868450582,
-0.1656130254,
-1.0808039904,
0.2698279619,
-0.2212403864,
0.6481320858,
-0.4822112024,
0.4330856502,
-0.2492721379,
0.2430133075,
-0.3239482343,
-0.8493626714,
0.6743394136,
0.0039650095,
-0.3450231254,
-0.7215003371,
0.6901464462,
-0.4736805558,
-0.297046572,
0.0380525999,
0.2699966133,
-0.21357961,
-0.4975601733,
-0.2153055817,
-0.3655023873,
0.0045980792,
-0.4161312878,
-0.1082109436,
0.1296056807,
0.0399653614,
0.5878190398,
0.2906071246,
-0.2653589845,
-0.2103153914,
0.0435064137,
0.8770347834,
-0.4812454283,
-0.8022050261,
-0.38367185,
0.9536309242,
-0.3421099484,
-0.5091215372,
0.4900372326,
0.7247400284,
0.9393664598,
-0.2128662616,
0.7220914364,
-0.0209687781,
0.7752463818,
-0.4722302854,
0.7783790231,
-0.5038598776,
0.0756439194,
-0.0358827598,
-1.1973633766,
-0.2058459818,
0.8312727213,
-0.5684523582,
-0.0209783874,
0.7278341651,
0.6269552708,
-0.3011646867,
0.2477872223,
0.0910847634,
0.0825698674,
0.1119443178,
0.3881345391,
0.7273272276,
-0.6294948459,
0.5272157192,
-0.0002488456,
0.0176123716,
-0.1258610785,
-0.5864674449,
-0.891022563,
-0.6408124566,
-0.1914444864,
-0.1192272976,
-0.2994258702,
0.8616073728,
0.7604888678,
-1.0183731318,
-0.0056810044,
-0.2784769833,
-0.3226852119,
-0.0354476385,
-0.1738191992,
0.196217373,
-0.5451970696,
-0.5679583549,
0.3949383795,
0.1106496975,
-0.2250436991,
0.1260529011,
0.1246728301,
-0.0962223932,
0.0676398352,
0.6365250945,
-0.183596909,
-0.4984329343,
-0.6945182085,
0.1374875307,
0.0853878558,
0.1826919019,
0.8826867938,
-0.8958244324,
0.2946472168,
0.3507458568,
0.6513378024,
0.6171756387,
0.3845908344,
0.659224093,
-1.0629954338,
0.3548939824,
0.2825368941,
0.1849809736,
0.3237603307,
-0.3595839441,
0.6551026702,
-0.1545142233,
-0.6196679473,
-0.6198260784,
0.4206755161,
-0.8437583447,
-0.2055754811,
1.2106224298,
-0.0085334769,
0.3174220622,
-0.0835194141,
-0.322109133,
0.4160353243,
0.1039877608,
0.5790928006,
0.3145423234,
-0.0183065403,
-0.1110544652,
-0.5971029401,
0.8108884692,
0.5829288363,
-1.0213638544,
-0.1494373381,
0.1899257153,
0.2659692466,
0.2518565953,
0.647390008,
0.3956270814,
0.2013527602,
-0.3746509552,
-0.2434701174,
0.0898498222,
-0.4625566304,
-0.3153642118,
0.2862399817,
-0.0441187732,
-0.0346046276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15344v1 | Learning Answer Generation using Supervision from Automatic Question Answering Evaluators | 2023-05-24T16:57:04 | 2023-05-24T16:57:04 | Matteo Gabburo, Siddhant Garg, Rik Koncel-Kedziorski, Alessandro Moschitti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent studies show that sentence-level extractive QA, i.e., based on Answer
Sentence Selection (AS2), is outperformed by Generation-based QA (GenQA)
models, which generate answers using the top-k answer sentences ranked by AS2
models (a la retrieval-augmented generation style). In this paper, we propose a
novel training paradigm for GenQA using supervision from automatic QA
evaluation models (GAVA). Specifically, we propose three strategies to transfer
knowledge from these QA evaluation models to a GenQA model: (i) augmenting
training data with answers generated by the GenQA model and labelled by GAVA
(either statically, before training, or (ii) dynamically, at every training
epoch); and (iii) using the GAVA score for weighting the generator loss during
the learning of the GenQA model. We evaluate our proposed methods on two
academic and one industrial dataset, obtaining a significant improvement in
answering accuracy over the previous state of the art. | [
-0.4376003742,
-0.8867888451,
0.804680109,
-0.1150182411,
-0.0320647545,
-0.0121453274,
0.3207007945,
-0.2732338607,
-0.1470046341,
0.4576482475,
-0.6196480393,
-0.2227353603,
-0.3377852738,
0.1012502909,
-0.4049138427,
1.0124543905,
-0.0503258184,
0.217092216,
-0.8006469607,
0.2012307048,
-0.4759501219,
-0.5479293466,
-0.8805649877,
-0.3160384893,
0.1803401709,
0.2831471562,
0.307582885,
0.5217421651,
0.1800552756,
0.2349125296,
0.086385183,
0.4663535655,
-0.1569260359,
-0.0098892869,
-0.0342768095,
-0.6517103314,
-0.2727980912,
0.0905635431,
0.2302153111,
0.505038321,
-0.285163492,
0.6617000103,
-0.0429219194,
0.3916120827,
-0.6369942427,
0.2316799462,
-0.5653188825,
0.0103709623,
0.3597524762,
-0.4918145537,
-0.5741644502,
-0.740657866,
0.0619538911,
-0.680960536,
0.3179805577,
-0.1820790768,
0.8301183581,
0.4060863554,
-0.5868600607,
-0.4369639754,
-0.6468637586,
0.4845187068,
-0.5503702164,
-0.1754723638,
0.3722460866,
0.6797385812,
0.2289834619,
-0.6936487556,
-0.3243351877,
0.1728411019,
0.0557376519,
0.4362336993,
-0.117601864,
-0.0063288189,
0.2772840858,
0.2530739009,
-0.2541773915,
-0.0941487625,
-0.6752470136,
0.1932804734,
0.875161469,
0.2238385379,
0.2368355989,
-0.1902015209,
-0.4424106777,
-0.1314164847,
-0.5816184878,
0.4255783558,
0.3593638241,
0.0517493263,
0.331186682,
0.3103660643,
-0.5461401343,
0.5665441751,
0.3609457612,
0.4276499152,
0.2058925331,
-0.268782407,
-0.2475467622,
-0.2259419411,
0.6155074239,
0.2767419219,
0.3024622798,
-0.3897138536,
0.04115187,
-0.1160846651,
0.6718983054,
-0.5803738236,
-0.5087817311,
0.1629223078,
-0.2207925767,
-0.6756762862,
0.1528578848,
-0.8248738647,
-0.2567237616,
-0.2249006182,
0.7815976739,
-0.1346200854,
0.0250023194,
-0.0119684534,
-0.1026703268,
0.7062812448,
0.2572441697,
-0.934281826,
0.2377410084,
0.3703982234,
0.3723545372,
0.22434479,
0.1135107279,
-1.1849310398,
0.1093666777,
-0.5070128441,
0.7163134813,
-0.2492757142,
-0.3766871691,
0.0564249717,
-0.2260666043,
-0.2594676614,
-0.5499356985,
0.2080870569,
-0.7834803462,
0.6533635855,
-0.0205064733,
-0.5677577257,
-0.2442993373,
0.0559273399,
-0.2900258303,
1.0634329319,
0.3670622408,
-0.4814161062,
0.3485535979,
-0.5044430494,
-0.047031004,
0.0569296293,
-0.1264593005,
-0.4667463601,
0.0519311875,
0.8212114573,
0.3033876121,
-0.1951191872,
0.1871070713,
0.08936432,
-0.1804421246,
0.1600931734,
-0.1667761058,
0.9080546498,
0.1465802789,
-0.2087471485,
0.2184093446,
-0.7636049986,
0.4275381565,
0.0319296047,
-0.3255601525,
-0.2409482896,
-0.1380010992,
-0.4593012929,
0.4737370908,
0.0073122154,
-0.5672572851,
0.1832745075,
-0.4096844792,
0.2397983968,
0.7540301681,
0.6487609744,
0.3184142709,
-0.4184576273,
1.068721056,
-0.2398770452,
0.2344495803,
0.0128981452,
-0.5061746836,
-0.8368886709,
0.1927334964,
0.1557567269,
0.7028433084,
-1.2002618313,
0.2454156131,
-0.1324050426,
-0.4980289638,
-1.0243935585,
0.3861121833,
0.694878459,
0.8100424409,
0.6947349906,
-0.0780314803,
-0.5595706105,
-0.8384308815,
-0.218329519,
-0.5008632541,
-0.3199781775,
0.2193296105,
0.1743610799,
0.2284100503,
0.9889361858,
-0.6759410501,
-0.0359554924,
-0.2578715682,
0.2507882118,
-0.1299880743,
0.3032653928,
0.4268900454,
-0.7099481225,
-0.3349765241,
-0.150079146,
-1.1189571619,
-0.2175162435,
-0.1630122513,
-0.2261912525,
-0.1416984797,
0.7198776603,
-0.3018584549,
0.2924229801,
0.1735451818,
-0.2951256037,
0.7075211406,
0.0087108435,
0.0963705108,
-1.3942970037,
-0.0777634457,
-0.0775542036,
-0.4176065326,
-0.7168614268,
0.3825627863,
0.0616367534,
0.0778521374,
-0.4554225802,
0.4388894737,
-0.3871722519,
0.1390124857,
-0.0822656006,
-0.022797225,
0.2552521229,
0.6033160686,
-0.1909636557,
0.9452105761,
0.2582853138,
-0.5124269128,
0.6765203476,
0.8851873875,
-0.2461023629,
0.2777248323,
-0.749160111,
0.4053780437,
-0.2552869022,
0.108122237,
-1.0082502365,
-0.1549136788,
0.1476317346,
-0.7776520252,
0.0537306704,
-0.2999481857,
-0.3171114028,
-0.4762753248,
-0.2056604922,
0.1518201679,
0.7835153937,
-0.6246298552,
0.4802526236,
0.0467818528,
-0.5704664588,
-0.3958966732,
-0.6387811899,
-0.1756189018,
-0.3661936522,
-0.5166944265,
-0.2017295957,
0.1515907943,
-0.1363413185,
-0.0152385207,
-0.0904390439,
-0.0833822191,
0.2987679839,
0.1268951744,
0.2723159492,
-0.0742397085,
0.3548002243,
0.1939799935,
0.0806996971,
0.7359308004,
-0.0876761898,
0.1879462302,
0.0204070061,
-0.1371811628,
-0.4226116836,
0.437733084,
0.0671390444,
-0.6213315129,
0.7103613019,
0.3547501862,
-0.0760262311,
-0.4927198589,
-0.3145574927,
-0.2789718807,
-0.4827972353,
0.25113976,
-0.3210283816,
-0.5397428274,
0.3425120413,
0.2195196897,
0.1395982057,
0.3777127266,
0.4194471538,
-0.2437113374,
1.353230238,
0.5240174532,
0.2318820506,
0.4586982429,
-0.437703222,
0.0671158209,
-0.9142922759,
-0.2887534201,
-0.2843548357,
0.1101156697,
-0.2081727237,
-0.3809688389,
0.5466656685,
0.2179229707,
-0.1970358491,
-0.0360645279,
-0.4677077234,
0.2044099271,
0.8289055228,
0.2060712725,
0.226285249,
-0.0760217458,
0.0781169906,
0.5393378139,
-0.7814415097,
-0.5623072982,
1.3831249475,
0.2927804887,
0.4460683763,
-0.0780987367,
0.8689454198,
0.2201912701,
0.3240312934,
-0.5997586846,
0.4462205768,
0.1404351294,
-0.4315147102,
-0.3879250884,
-0.6549426317,
-0.5953277349,
0.2000659555,
-0.0802727789,
-0.5558555126,
0.0419168174,
0.1510730833,
-0.7603210211,
0.0349998586,
-0.8504143357,
0.6654132605,
0.0178550445,
-0.1525919884,
0.2009526342,
-0.7800081372,
0.4891753495,
0.0869308338,
-0.00170334,
0.2434506565,
0.2901921272,
0.7477490306,
-0.3406999409,
0.4579473138,
-0.5929157734,
-0.3139000833,
0.6146988273,
-0.3338366747,
0.3131193519,
0.3088053167,
-0.0041332883,
-0.6059718132,
0.1196929142,
-0.5847779512,
-0.9080981016,
0.1629849225,
-0.8587702513,
-0.7305620909,
-0.0467751399,
-0.5771275759,
-0.796839416,
-0.2534913421,
0.4077835381,
0.538905561,
0.06046056,
0.1142845228,
0.8280387521,
-0.2510409653,
0.0393488742,
0.2206042409,
-0.3110698462,
-0.4020777345,
0.570371747,
-0.0322323255,
0.5089392662,
0.1847893298,
-0.0931750461,
-0.3499324918,
-0.426740557,
-0.8639864326,
-0.101864405,
-0.7269563675,
-0.2432110161,
-0.8184931874,
-0.588113904,
-0.5105160475,
-0.0737342983,
0.2381067872,
-0.3990812302,
-0.2347462028,
-0.5054155588,
0.2608080506,
0.5288532972,
0.2375146598,
0.4484255612,
-0.7850821018,
0.6604003906,
1.018478632,
-0.0751477629,
0.1089627445,
-0.4753950536,
-0.3076465428,
0.3153820038,
-0.4103614092,
-0.9435863495,
0.2444414645,
0.3434764147,
0.4349695146,
0.2018427849,
0.1103532761,
0.4483585954,
-0.2648576498,
0.8697832823,
-0.054542575,
-0.6216232777,
0.8052448034,
-0.3909424543,
0.4910154641,
0.7442666292,
0.1967415214,
-0.2345961481,
-0.654802382,
-0.5998339653,
-0.91732651,
0.6442911029,
0.053728804,
0.3812124729,
-0.1055732667,
0.5180808902,
0.1019241437,
0.2662306726,
-0.2792312503,
-0.0688819215,
-0.1394669563,
-0.3583212495,
0.0591933653,
-0.0190956704,
-0.1982951909,
-0.1099958941,
1.0622944832,
-0.4436563253,
0.2293738276,
0.2234145403,
-0.1942215711,
-0.153418228,
0.3778656125,
-0.1646056473,
0.7016016841,
-0.1930821836,
-0.1243602633,
0.2629748583,
-0.2288729399,
0.359454155,
0.2961838543,
-0.5962665081,
-0.2702723444,
0.1025392339,
0.8208864927,
-0.3772802651,
-0.4911983311,
0.514354527,
-0.1220474914,
-0.4970355034,
-0.3322587311,
0.3978905678,
0.0893876329,
0.227497682,
0.6984542012,
-0.2495696992,
0.3487437069,
-0.4809472859,
0.3604348302,
0.3457515538,
-0.3541525304,
-0.1594883502,
1.0768488646,
0.0903255343,
0.0451764166,
0.7483229637,
-0.1300050765,
-0.3097681403,
0.8672301173,
0.3643321097,
0.903848052,
-0.2706488371,
0.6008656025,
0.3618715405,
-0.0282000601,
0.1433457434,
0.5773134232,
-0.1880504936,
-0.4074586928,
-0.5472716093,
-0.8577743769,
-0.4625692368,
0.0809232071,
-1.3400870562,
-0.0560243726,
-0.3229621053,
0.1358511597,
0.109729439,
0.0268570334,
-0.6687476039,
0.6116283536,
0.1609434038,
0.6963889003,
-1.0958848,
0.6384140253,
1.0940693617,
-0.7781613469,
-1.0632648468,
0.0078283669,
-0.3103978038,
-0.5727904439,
0.3303898871,
0.2035727948,
0.025249308,
0.438534081,
-0.7032731175,
-0.5320578814,
1.110021472,
0.2324202657,
0.1134376898,
-0.4868627787,
0.0418291204,
0.764115572,
-0.3068653941,
0.2045605481,
0.4065006971,
-0.0964774713,
-0.033495035,
-0.6474881172,
-0.0405350849,
-0.629144311,
-0.0345571525,
0.0575556532,
-0.6285479069,
0.4204515815,
-0.1387986243,
-0.1820162386,
0.4304117858,
0.8776389956,
0.1900444925,
0.2252850384,
0.3657929599,
0.4343214333,
0.530098021,
-0.0040544998,
0.9695142508,
0.0716083646,
0.1965449899,
1.364743948,
0.071170494,
0.7722612619,
0.4686412215,
-0.1031143218,
0.6553279757,
0.5202945471,
-0.1456672549,
0.6096701622,
0.2706439793,
-0.2148402184,
-0.4202129543,
-0.0291423779,
-0.1167035624,
0.4360044897,
0.0150530795,
-0.3945755959,
-0.2610744238,
0.2391780317,
-0.233461529,
0.4523407221,
-0.4187248945,
1.2881256342,
-0.0154144159,
-0.8275067806,
0.6589747667,
-0.2580778301,
0.1065713912,
-0.4214890003,
-0.1704417467,
-0.2689617276,
-0.1033207029,
-0.1831013709,
-0.6661540866,
0.2005396485,
0.3261297047,
-0.2666867375,
-0.3944106698,
0.3031332195,
-0.5555554032,
-0.532720089,
0.0274634548,
0.7996515632,
-0.122089535,
0.0797692686,
-0.2411847264,
-1.0585916042,
-0.0622638762,
-0.3032441735,
0.2007544041,
0.217866987,
-0.1912565827,
0.7053804994,
0.4408637583,
-0.0883607343,
0.5849610567,
-0.0926056951,
0.9255719781,
-0.2552621067,
-0.7468045354,
-0.2959540486,
0.5008180141,
-0.1488521844,
-0.3826943636,
0.74540025,
0.430580616,
0.7875426412,
-0.1649063081,
1.1914086342,
0.0038727007,
0.7312782407,
-0.5692415237,
0.5633271337,
-0.4689715505,
0.0908984393,
-0.1164319515,
-0.7917297482,
0.0953907371,
0.2702639401,
-0.5959050059,
-0.087894246,
0.3022973239,
0.4939524531,
0.17924954,
-0.1288685948,
0.0302890949,
-0.1708735377,
0.4290018082,
0.8054090738,
0.9858333468,
-0.60472399,
0.677868247,
-0.3011518419,
-0.1140405014,
0.0391923636,
-0.2085051835,
-0.7445409298,
-0.507286787,
-0.2770546079,
-0.2149687409,
0.2590645552,
0.6250231862,
0.4404844642,
-0.8546712399,
0.1525374651,
-0.1614249349,
-0.3353340328,
-0.5411901474,
-0.2754567564,
0.4691335857,
-0.7163096666,
-0.5941495895,
0.4697699547,
-0.310284704,
-0.2147156745,
-0.2353872359,
0.1979424655,
-0.3508868814,
0.2943198979,
0.27681306,
0.1524791121,
-0.3793007731,
-0.3696737885,
0.0333636552,
-0.0482565463,
0.0657039732,
0.2163978368,
-1.0875023603,
0.6553884149,
0.5219541788,
0.9893337488,
0.3304726481,
0.9540679455,
0.9252387285,
-0.9398053885,
-0.5083880424,
0.2643075585,
-0.1343354583,
0.3701715469,
-0.4994920492,
0.6386734843,
-0.254865855,
-0.5867766738,
-0.6469939351,
0.2652925551,
-0.5319396257,
-0.071421355,
1.2005422115,
-0.3154307008,
-0.0259282533,
-0.0730056763,
-0.216796428,
0.5386148095,
-0.0448538512,
1.094669342,
0.4119299054,
-0.2026418895,
-0.3010236025,
-0.8354030848,
0.6713874936,
0.546261549,
-1.1533521414,
-0.0439786017,
0.5485300422,
0.3729075491,
0.0189121496,
0.40560323,
-0.0358970501,
0.6934533119,
-0.0510762967,
0.167933017,
-0.4392308295,
-0.1501022279,
-0.5785552859,
0.36785689,
0.1443467587,
-0.5609429479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15338v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15338v1 | Measuring and Mitigating Constraint Violations of In-Context Learning for Utterance-to-API Semantic Parsing | 2023-05-24T16:50:36 | 2023-05-24T16:50:36 | Shufan Wang, Sebastien Jean, Sailik Sengupta, James Gung, Nikolaos Pappas, Yi Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In executable task-oriented semantic parsing, the system aims to translate
users' utterances in natural language to machine-interpretable programs (API
calls) that can be executed according to pre-defined API specifications. With
the popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), in-context learning offers a
strong baseline for such scenarios, especially in data-limited regimes.
However, LLMs are known to hallucinate and therefore pose a formidable
challenge in constraining generated content. Thus, it remains uncertain if LLMs
can effectively perform task-oriented utterance-to-API generation where
respecting API's structural and task-specific constraints is crucial.
In this work, we seek to measure, analyze and mitigate such constraints
violations. First, we identify the categories of various constraints in
obtaining API-semantics from task-oriented utterances, and define fine-grained
metrics that complement traditional ones. Second, we leverage these metrics to
conduct a detailed error analysis of constraints violations seen in
state-of-the-art LLMs, which motivates us to investigate two mitigation
strategies: Semantic-Retrieval of Demonstrations (SRD) and API-aware
Constrained Decoding (API-CD). Our experiments show that these strategies are
effective at reducing constraints violations and improving the quality of the
generated API calls, but require careful consideration given their
implementation complexity and latency. | [
-0.4229563475,
-0.7586348653,
0.5418334603,
0.1809104979,
-0.1838238239,
-0.153445214,
-0.3303131163,
-0.4608669579,
-0.1977284402,
0.7319325209,
-0.891489923,
-0.7349730134,
-0.4591427743,
0.3295349777,
-0.23734653,
0.8052418828,
-0.2339884043,
0.0154614616,
-0.7613334656,
-0.0869892016,
-1.0541932583,
-0.5012796521,
-0.210757032,
-0.1877692491,
0.0688228384,
0.4591764808,
0.1805322617,
0.6138525009,
0.2630804181,
0.2429280728,
-0.1158812493,
0.3493192196,
-0.3895898461,
0.214680627,
-0.2677829862,
-0.4216795564,
-0.0244917125,
-0.3071660697,
0.521271646,
0.971342206,
0.1764394194,
0.2340807021,
0.3748381734,
0.3400834799,
-0.8281702399,
0.2839305699,
-0.8162388206,
0.1842955351,
-0.1250718832,
-0.4354488552,
-0.5263875723,
-0.0718091875,
0.2955142856,
-0.6905556321,
0.0214969683,
0.0091098314,
0.8308374882,
0.7957578301,
-0.3636841476,
-0.7063402534,
-0.6538538933,
1.0924803019,
-0.713509798,
0.537088275,
0.5016634464,
0.056030646,
-0.3936772943,
-0.53452003,
-0.4332408607,
-0.1403477192,
-0.0568494312,
-0.0268018767,
-0.0662848502,
0.0084513947,
0.3441355526,
0.1637894362,
-0.490536958,
0.1428984553,
0.0951239541,
-0.3969658613,
0.1514337063,
0.2618834078,
0.1952258497,
-0.4080413282,
-0.4793241024,
-0.1107694879,
-0.7908213139,
0.1474818885,
0.3050077856,
0.4344682693,
0.1334989816,
0.526677072,
-0.2916629314,
0.5043447018,
-0.1973480135,
-0.0283595026,
0.1850277483,
-0.3516260684,
-0.217034325,
0.0127385743,
0.2904873192,
0.2229458988,
-0.1024919674,
-0.369276464,
-0.3648356795,
0.1012975723,
0.2156575918,
-0.6130625606,
0.3029030859,
0.2479101866,
-0.3312136531,
0.1009416655,
-0.137184456,
-0.4919759631,
-0.2275384665,
-0.6780768037,
0.5368244052,
-0.5314871073,
-0.0499257818,
0.2065439969,
-0.1021723449,
0.430896163,
0.090070352,
-0.7147855759,
0.5075569153,
1.0095515251,
0.6796405911,
-0.1642872989,
-0.3165856004,
-0.6776676774,
0.3742384613,
-0.1853666455,
0.6095873117,
-0.403015852,
-0.4538605511,
0.1613119394,
-0.0705963373,
-0.1252026707,
-0.899890244,
0.8865692616,
-0.3928880692,
-0.3476507366,
-0.4868872464,
-1.0739513636,
0.0278981421,
0.4146846533,
-0.283406347,
0.8011610508,
0.2559182048,
-0.5021731257,
0.6322663426,
-0.3846114874,
-0.4983388782,
0.0676175952,
-0.3766709864,
-0.2915434539,
0.336186409,
0.1297553033,
0.1895213723,
-0.2196285278,
0.1677207053,
-0.0529987887,
-0.2436846793,
0.2689348459,
-0.3534913361,
0.5316689014,
0.1781056672,
-0.527977109,
0.3165850937,
-0.8242377639,
0.0086998716,
-0.0554305464,
-0.2652264833,
-0.4560045302,
0.2771463692,
-0.0850714296,
0.1722985059,
0.1265743524,
-0.6148183346,
-0.1315692216,
-0.6069688797,
0.6011605263,
0.8071655035,
-0.0277065877,
0.3522273302,
-0.0170671698,
0.1653667837,
-0.1319027394,
0.3469690681,
-0.0529541858,
-0.0553795695,
-0.6368502378,
-0.112485148,
0.1290828437,
0.4596885741,
-0.6299597621,
0.6487820745,
-0.3664366305,
-0.0567900501,
-0.3911338747,
0.3348980546,
0.627866745,
0.9328623414,
0.4160040617,
-0.2425474226,
-0.4925768673,
-0.8425318599,
-0.2583855391,
-0.0232327916,
-0.1278596818,
0.6421449184,
0.440294683,
-0.3428692818,
1.1395062208,
-0.1454516053,
-0.4966568947,
-0.1053499132,
0.005641243,
-0.1113875434,
0.6276887655,
0.3672276139,
-0.7102034092,
-0.2284324169,
-0.2838713229,
-0.6184197068,
-0.4169510305,
-0.0822448507,
-0.089482829,
0.3326759338,
0.6631453633,
-0.6486507654,
0.5720958114,
0.3552402556,
-0.3059155941,
0.6896733046,
-0.0091990791,
-0.2356348485,
-0.6179813743,
-0.2258082628,
-0.3270993233,
-0.2068105638,
-0.5123130083,
0.128333509,
0.1627259403,
-0.0554544516,
-0.5664684772,
0.4056712985,
-0.2428946495,
-0.2676225603,
-0.3578760028,
0.0916577429,
0.0766454563,
0.5279442072,
0.1984580904,
0.6289409399,
0.4283716083,
-0.8273162246,
-0.0992798433,
0.4569758773,
-0.397095412,
0.6518583298,
-0.5767598748,
0.0840440169,
0.0698943138,
0.3072488308,
-0.9178785086,
-0.2600177824,
0.377076298,
-0.3566196561,
0.0626720265,
-0.1950722188,
-0.6900072098,
0.018186653,
-0.219343558,
0.6254729629,
0.1996044666,
-0.8143641353,
0.6053252816,
0.1858969629,
0.1845051497,
-0.6253271699,
-0.6571245193,
0.0413996801,
-0.2228783965,
-0.6005083919,
0.4824721813,
-0.0558233671,
-0.1070829481,
0.083213605,
-0.3854113221,
0.3433322012,
0.1839581728,
0.4076833427,
0.070818834,
-0.0171515159,
-0.0123862056,
0.2650569081,
-0.0839173645,
0.3935464323,
-0.4518769681,
0.9542319775,
-0.1056164652,
-0.7104128599,
-0.6530136466,
0.374353081,
0.3733239174,
-0.1159026325,
0.5815142393,
0.2582790256,
-0.3331623971,
-0.4418517947,
-0.4328752458,
-0.2312776595,
-0.4914392829,
0.3011077642,
-0.5420139432,
-0.8419350386,
0.6575305462,
-0.3197690845,
0.0476074889,
0.1892600805,
0.386939168,
0.1311405152,
0.942094326,
0.2789055109,
0.0965207964,
0.3924580812,
-0.2794135809,
0.0140807638,
-1.0492939949,
-0.2125286907,
-0.4786453545,
-0.2245920748,
-0.3956743479,
-0.306022495,
0.3079019785,
0.066369243,
-0.1270403415,
0.3406888545,
-0.3259288669,
0.4671231806,
0.6732341647,
0.0105957724,
0.0657219514,
-0.101120472,
-0.0793281719,
0.0181839839,
-0.3425887525,
-0.5112755895,
1.1090561152,
0.3424150944,
0.5979456902,
0.1080665439,
0.7101919055,
0.0497784242,
-0.1532787085,
-0.8906041384,
0.6357553005,
0.0025435395,
-0.3333956301,
-0.2551146746,
-0.6488739848,
-0.7483635545,
0.1089981049,
0.0731946826,
-0.7648798823,
0.2923675478,
0.1677745432,
-0.1103962585,
0.0997394994,
-0.728997767,
0.96910429,
-0.181790635,
-0.4169705212,
-0.1073862389,
-0.7795192599,
0.0305288583,
0.1749478877,
0.0852674693,
-0.0855979919,
-0.0937526226,
0.3096235693,
-0.4866571724,
1.0242363214,
-0.3606490791,
-0.3202635348,
0.261120379,
0.1698207557,
0.6376461983,
0.1295409501,
0.1746103764,
0.2014375925,
0.1200465187,
-0.3863826692,
-0.3837737441,
0.7159215808,
-0.744407177,
-0.5425409675,
-0.1061873883,
-0.8462460041,
-0.4951051474,
0.0653106347,
0.4994919002,
0.6098520756,
-0.1545611769,
0.1102480665,
0.791187346,
-0.3858734369,
0.3354693949,
0.3948225677,
0.0230541695,
-0.1621641517,
1.028309226,
0.016274523,
0.4370940328,
0.3286559284,
0.2630408406,
-0.5228515267,
-0.7898851037,
-0.4316976964,
0.0371715613,
-0.8822764754,
-0.2099284828,
-0.4544664919,
-0.059225902,
-0.6565826535,
-0.0079292487,
-0.3559119105,
-0.2161048651,
-0.4556133151,
0.1131191552,
-0.1030906066,
0.2253917754,
0.0959780738,
0.2664872408,
-0.6426799297,
0.0070928237,
0.0515500344,
0.3820864558,
-0.1048717797,
-0.5119329691,
-0.0990942419,
-0.1367075145,
-0.3034134805,
-0.6293168664,
0.2414169014,
0.2429881096,
0.5048271418,
0.4576383233,
0.2843849063,
0.6621966362,
-0.5185694695,
0.7070863247,
-0.219268471,
-1.2671345472,
0.751529932,
-0.0526417531,
0.1364714056,
0.5189673305,
-0.0216530915,
-0.4190146923,
-0.5286409259,
-0.2111108601,
-1.0380907059,
0.6413154602,
0.214885205,
0.335842818,
-0.1773456782,
0.5029013157,
0.2947199941,
0.180709362,
-0.5202109218,
-0.0375255048,
-0.1362735927,
-0.2108992785,
0.2371617854,
-0.2424371392,
-0.3383824825,
-0.1363206357,
0.5186536908,
-0.1965640187,
-0.1583167017,
0.2495005429,
-0.5792226791,
0.0501759388,
0.371950388,
0.6848749518,
0.7140021324,
-0.2741276324,
0.1766864955,
0.1228806153,
-0.3215032816,
-0.0973558724,
-0.0065016467,
-0.4367441535,
-0.1024361253,
0.2972221375,
0.9703413844,
0.2703385651,
-1.2861399651,
0.4220376313,
-0.0303338077,
-0.2047514468,
-0.4391935766,
0.067024827,
-0.3358721435,
0.2278115302,
0.1314271837,
-0.1141604409,
0.2352086157,
-0.3433375955,
0.1409540474,
0.6523983479,
-0.2585637569,
-0.2267102152,
0.4859055579,
0.1699757576,
-0.125106886,
0.5939260721,
-0.2324653119,
-0.3742942512,
0.5510039926,
0.8539389968,
0.8824586272,
0.1210430637,
-0.0916986391,
0.0797894225,
0.1926943064,
0.1785782874,
0.1352702379,
-0.4306994379,
-0.7833404541,
-0.4155382216,
-0.6818989515,
-0.4323764741,
0.1238776073,
-0.9110758305,
0.1822878867,
-0.3591881394,
-0.0981861204,
-0.2422641665,
-0.0752586499,
-0.5355216861,
-0.1729781628,
0.1087073162,
0.9097827077,
-0.6338134408,
0.5255515575,
0.4863063097,
-0.2960492671,
-0.6676885486,
0.1084429473,
0.1823413819,
-0.5602734089,
0.6701080799,
0.2800646722,
-0.2967644632,
-0.033942353,
-0.4224330783,
-0.6168318987,
0.8979075551,
0.4607085288,
-0.4379404783,
0.1631130278,
0.6869045496,
0.3542888165,
-0.3132299185,
-0.2431193739,
0.7212368846,
0.308172226,
-0.0110273063,
-0.8109691739,
-0.0055274437,
0.0385594368,
0.0366479941,
0.24879013,
-0.3510482609,
0.7028906345,
0.2914097607,
-0.3510064185,
0.1703893989,
0.6118540764,
0.3606451452,
0.6265844107,
0.7462930679,
0.8420976996,
0.584842205,
-0.0835685879,
0.8958696723,
-0.1898617297,
0.2457460314,
1.2491258383,
-0.4666048288,
0.9232890606,
0.9261221886,
0.1870953888,
0.1731276065,
0.6939349174,
0.1835996211,
0.6209541559,
0.4135876,
-0.3605760634,
-0.1226786375,
-0.4896892905,
-0.0561261512,
0.4421975315,
0.6189944744,
-0.0528553277,
-0.1834807247,
0.4358870983,
-0.1935860217,
0.3199429214,
-0.2883417606,
1.0330986977,
-0.1384456307,
-0.6138362288,
0.6012897491,
-0.1979355961,
0.6508601904,
-0.396787256,
0.0621142015,
-0.1691074669,
0.2934947312,
-0.123511076,
-0.5162390471,
0.4706470668,
0.1072793007,
-0.1964095682,
-0.203943193,
0.6163229346,
-0.2946595848,
-0.1430163234,
0.5652753115,
0.3395628333,
0.0352801383,
-0.1574586183,
-0.4440242946,
0.4517738819,
-0.2535342872,
-0.1146722734,
0.5283074379,
0.4974991381,
-0.0218844619,
0.6176196933,
0.3596785665,
0.0716477484,
0.32837075,
0.275386095,
0.8690561056,
-0.333965838,
-0.424551636,
-0.8166043758,
0.1296188831,
0.0711379275,
-0.1837013513,
0.7262282968,
0.7230573893,
1.3784016371,
-0.0934064537,
0.5839412808,
-0.0556264631,
0.5212163925,
-0.7333331108,
0.3217782974,
-0.6505576372,
0.6509168148,
-0.2020206153,
-0.8236041665,
-0.2261177599,
0.3059941232,
-0.2354377955,
-0.4160940945,
0.4169051051,
0.9291276336,
-0.0317311697,
0.0186027214,
0.0821864381,
-0.2109955847,
0.5195447803,
0.7035554051,
1.1547853947,
-0.1771966666,
0.8184626698,
-0.4911292195,
-0.2010937482,
-0.1503778994,
-0.7377876043,
-0.7059779167,
-0.6087436676,
-0.2092833072,
-0.4368333817,
-0.192018345,
1.1027808189,
0.6671594977,
-0.8050926924,
-0.3669866025,
-0.5158228874,
0.0988990888,
-0.4190195203,
-0.2292659879,
0.483959794,
-0.8439335823,
-0.9114155173,
0.4683134556,
0.2433278263,
-0.1603243202,
-0.0764827803,
-0.2954993844,
0.1146157235,
0.0945505649,
0.7493436933,
0.4057944715,
-1.0118041039,
-0.5449672937,
0.0539151281,
0.0117977066,
0.0029167065,
1.0262275934,
-0.6672024727,
0.3288837671,
0.4167931378,
1.036517024,
0.1914808899,
0.0243397877,
0.2840638757,
-1.342408061,
0.1592805088,
0.3120321333,
0.208889544,
0.1429566592,
-0.2453587204,
0.3766806424,
0.2058902383,
-0.5901697278,
-1.1302484274,
0.4594729543,
-1.0204489231,
-0.4627460539,
1.0468555689,
-0.0875016376,
-0.2447130531,
-0.1308248788,
-0.1425252557,
0.3063056767,
-0.1364170909,
0.7313223481,
0.6422067881,
-0.3899033368,
0.0183849558,
-0.6563748717,
0.6031538248,
0.6115682125,
-0.8282858729,
0.4202871323,
0.6899879575,
0.2168050706,
0.1275087744,
0.0930380225,
-0.1759402603,
0.0854163989,
-0.1478954554,
-0.1800229251,
0.0285170637,
-0.2911476791,
-0.2764134705,
0.0819042251,
-0.0412236974,
-0.4397131801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15334v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15334v1 | Gorilla: Large Language Model Connected with Massive APIs | 2023-05-24T16:48:11 | 2023-05-24T16:48:11 | Shishir G. Patil, Tianjun Zhang, Xin Wang, Joseph E. Gonzalez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have seen an impressive wave of advances
recently, with models now excelling in a variety of tasks, such as mathematical
reasoning and program synthesis. However, their potential to effectively use
tools via API calls remains unfulfilled. This is a challenging task even for
today's state-of-the-art LLMs such as GPT-4, largely due to their inability to
generate accurate input arguments and their tendency to hallucinate the wrong
usage of an API call. We release Gorilla, a finetuned LLaMA-based model that
surpasses the performance of GPT-4 on writing API calls. When combined with a
document retriever, Gorilla demonstrates a strong capability to adapt to
test-time document changes, enabling flexible user updates or version changes.
It also substantially mitigates the issue of hallucination, commonly
encountered when prompting LLMs directly. To evaluate the model's ability, we
introduce APIBench, a comprehensive dataset consisting of HuggingFace,
TorchHub, and TensorHub APIs. The successful integration of the retrieval
system with Gorilla demonstrates the potential for LLMs to use tools more
accurately, keep up with frequently updated documentation, and consequently
increase the reliability and applicability of their outputs. Gorilla's code,
model, data, and demo are available at https://gorilla.cs.berkeley.edu | [
-0.3464326262,
-0.875652492,
0.5380828381,
0.6378471255,
-0.1554540545,
0.1204281524,
-0.4036886394,
-0.6631451249,
0.1125159338,
0.3914652169,
-0.3469116986,
-0.4644653499,
-0.6404106021,
0.1456224918,
-0.4889164567,
0.9296174049,
-0.053591948,
0.0528919771,
-0.0669181272,
-0.0574539527,
-0.5323828459,
-0.6658992171,
-0.6144717932,
-0.686785996,
0.6248226762,
0.0377615839,
0.9214569926,
0.6216276288,
0.4138067067,
0.2615734637,
-0.2463803291,
-0.1355640888,
-0.4847645462,
-0.0135962525,
-0.1931007206,
-0.4006952345,
-0.7220142484,
-0.0002862701,
0.3471421897,
0.8195654154,
-0.1906553954,
0.1383494437,
0.1780742556,
0.2198874205,
-0.1868292242,
0.3890220821,
-0.6462731957,
0.0375303999,
-0.3482914269,
0.0890199915,
-0.197696358,
-0.4101723731,
0.1213542521,
-0.4001303017,
-0.1396134049,
-0.1667485535,
0.7321463823,
0.2369945496,
-0.1879539937,
-0.4989827573,
-0.4527379274,
0.6190314889,
-0.7477716804,
0.4948785007,
0.6368733048,
0.2565716505,
-0.5582332611,
-0.8504327536,
-0.5279257298,
-0.5346691012,
0.3336827159,
-0.1072434857,
-0.0289535038,
-0.0962293968,
0.2307932675,
0.5994101167,
-0.3821589947,
0.3357022107,
-0.2688927352,
-0.2985103428,
0.3828601837,
0.0361498371,
0.2390538007,
-0.253163904,
-0.0080147693,
0.1010336801,
-0.7448779345,
-0.1766757667,
0.5211094022,
0.3175306618,
-0.0471394733,
0.7285553813,
0.0828882977,
0.6353180408,
-0.134828195,
-0.0417434238,
0.1982369274,
0.2226452529,
-0.0644878522,
-0.2034495175,
0.7107477188,
0.2136712521,
0.1387986988,
-0.3529520631,
-0.4489387572,
-0.00389435,
0.1905262917,
-0.9220824838,
-0.4202440977,
0.2937248945,
-0.4393565357,
-0.1637465805,
-0.4387285113,
-0.7027137876,
-0.6627894044,
-0.4220090806,
0.2502326965,
-0.406219691,
-0.239788115,
0.1269313991,
0.0589078777,
0.360860765,
0.283513099,
-1.0157976151,
0.3278359473,
1.0581943989,
1.1050322056,
-0.2278583646,
-0.3715033233,
-0.6547685862,
0.115803957,
-0.6093930602,
0.6514168382,
-0.5739747286,
-0.5243824124,
-0.0434111841,
-0.0900149867,
0.4500064552,
-0.7056245208,
0.5526984334,
-0.51670748,
-0.097117953,
-0.1548441947,
-0.4386590421,
-0.1136053577,
0.3803808689,
-0.6322081089,
1.1045540571,
0.2509904504,
-0.2145250738,
-0.0408591889,
-0.4914056659,
-0.363129586,
0.1158323735,
-0.1638518572,
-0.3419753015,
0.1591709405,
0.100988932,
0.4089843929,
-0.4800075889,
0.3527030945,
-0.7082597017,
-0.3909369409,
0.1451272368,
-0.2114804387,
0.8679209352,
0.1319116205,
-0.0405167714,
0.0340948217,
-0.760925293,
-0.1988718361,
0.2541815937,
-0.7074626684,
-0.1913431287,
-0.0332767889,
0.0132741909,
0.0599444211,
0.3962868452,
-0.3571042418,
0.5161979198,
-0.027894428,
0.7944610119,
0.9163006544,
-0.5119238496,
0.2435726374,
0.0414252169,
0.4558776319,
-0.5571898222,
0.1183655858,
-0.2228695899,
-0.5104871392,
-0.446456641,
-0.3828124106,
0.4585650265,
0.4633624554,
-0.3522655666,
0.3774596751,
-0.148620218,
-0.6806401014,
-0.2787551582,
0.3902103305,
0.168642655,
0.609813869,
0.1989914775,
-0.3831321299,
-0.4894498587,
-0.6901473999,
-0.1077918857,
-0.2829499245,
-0.458142072,
0.4148885906,
0.3380800486,
-0.6860482097,
0.7296664119,
-0.5411539078,
-0.3044992089,
-0.2334181666,
0.1795522273,
0.5359510779,
0.3786931932,
0.55273664,
-0.5472972393,
-0.0672911704,
-0.0660500154,
-0.8602025509,
-0.5726965666,
-0.0208257381,
-0.2402255088,
0.0868371427,
0.5059723258,
-0.8053124547,
0.0369761996,
0.8559721112,
0.032823246,
0.8323469162,
-0.04596496,
-0.3517615795,
-0.8555043936,
0.1329754144,
-0.0902202949,
-0.2852423787,
-0.2442754358,
0.1058269814,
0.2072070986,
-0.3991034925,
-0.1049631387,
0.6220005155,
-0.4088247418,
-0.3743486106,
-0.5054321885,
0.1388775557,
-0.1259511858,
0.4781321585,
-0.1637357622,
0.8523481488,
0.7392525077,
-0.6280506849,
0.5728014708,
0.5109778047,
-0.2979725599,
0.2622836828,
-0.7878656387,
0.3980273604,
0.2388075441,
0.5323493481,
-0.6685797572,
-0.5020455718,
0.2292983383,
-0.3197431564,
0.2646583021,
-0.1912107468,
-0.7232083678,
-0.6157487035,
-0.3837667108,
0.1956963837,
0.3697844744,
-0.8111090064,
0.8738164902,
0.684048295,
-0.6112220287,
-0.5099109411,
-0.6849396825,
0.5964060426,
-0.0549122132,
-0.4338946044,
0.2716549337,
-0.15863581,
-0.046720542,
-0.0948218927,
-0.2658033669,
0.0015184679,
0.1299433261,
0.2648832202,
0.4598825872,
-0.1673239022,
0.1622624546,
-0.3074234426,
-0.0654402971,
0.1628436744,
-0.3448738754,
0.9359907508,
-0.236949414,
-0.4023936987,
-0.1940730214,
0.1050792262,
0.4691349268,
-0.1321984679,
0.4302174449,
0.279517442,
-0.4084278643,
-0.1002503484,
-0.554923594,
-0.0593592599,
-0.5070881248,
0.373601526,
-0.4681213498,
-0.8429003358,
0.8488617539,
-0.3603326082,
0.1890118718,
-0.0237607397,
0.6137633324,
0.1667919755,
1.0049118996,
0.6571751833,
-0.3966213763,
0.5802335143,
-0.0518987812,
0.1959781796,
-1.040938139,
-0.1803507507,
-0.4946963191,
-0.2158129215,
-0.3824810982,
-0.2394690663,
-0.0051570563,
0.2843953669,
-0.3650164604,
0.4223946631,
-0.3303713799,
0.5465655327,
0.556648612,
-0.1507966816,
0.1976964176,
-0.1545129567,
-0.1670918167,
0.1090818495,
-0.3560013175,
-0.7268440723,
1.0843297243,
0.4092410207,
1.062396884,
0.210745573,
0.2280838042,
0.1139124632,
0.516716361,
-0.9498562217,
0.7071598172,
0.0445652828,
-0.4939868152,
-0.0116703315,
-0.3895132244,
-0.8771730065,
0.4553647935,
0.0510228761,
-0.8382518291,
-0.1887914985,
0.0093872882,
-0.239240244,
0.2266055048,
-0.5996058583,
0.7207751274,
-0.3570539653,
-0.4013317525,
0.0124157835,
-0.356690228,
0.5434621572,
-0.6764219403,
0.0253852345,
-0.1838520169,
-0.1297227293,
0.373498261,
-0.4955296814,
0.8291566372,
0.119649224,
-0.562032342,
0.2721746862,
0.3169032037,
0.7022673488,
0.1166652068,
-0.5174486041,
0.6525556445,
-0.4132004082,
-0.2395275682,
-0.3584080637,
0.9408791065,
-0.7451120615,
-0.9230157733,
-0.3132358789,
-0.7504295111,
-0.1728774607,
0.3621221483,
-0.1275048703,
0.3308919668,
-0.0125662787,
0.1201670989,
0.2350162864,
-0.5812640786,
0.3912706375,
0.3775156438,
-0.752623558,
-0.3625485301,
0.7317075133,
0.1376613528,
-0.1131151393,
-0.2344495952,
0.2172344029,
-0.4685131013,
-0.6522698998,
-0.4893402755,
0.3810663819,
-0.7149235606,
-0.2256172299,
-0.6111160517,
-0.077213496,
-0.414080143,
-0.1783197373,
-0.2214217484,
-0.3546029627,
-0.1831499338,
-0.1013400182,
0.3780421913,
0.6014324427,
-0.1595775932,
0.4356722236,
-0.8129170537,
0.4801250398,
0.2700219452,
0.7443689704,
0.0248646755,
-0.4462145567,
0.0113475844,
-0.2972541153,
-0.5558434129,
-0.8070614934,
0.386672318,
0.0500163995,
0.4220758975,
0.2968102098,
-0.1999937445,
0.9154116511,
-0.7539638877,
0.7670484781,
0.0191961993,
-1.1850236654,
0.3383478224,
-0.6087905169,
0.1624838263,
0.1686077565,
0.1957902312,
-0.6149371862,
-0.5239350796,
-0.1373841017,
-0.9711833,
0.6722398996,
0.019073667,
0.4586960971,
-0.0357696004,
0.3970088363,
0.2538940907,
0.2111147195,
-0.8326207399,
0.3518210053,
-0.2255322039,
-0.0467506386,
0.1451242566,
-0.0863234773,
-0.0555187911,
-0.1103098467,
0.6885592341,
-0.2537985742,
-0.0633072034,
-0.2041360587,
-0.1283257455,
-0.0262159444,
-0.045012515,
0.1792355776,
0.9325205088,
-0.1672926098,
0.1041347086,
0.3066800833,
-0.5463277102,
-0.2385959774,
0.3269304335,
-0.0154434778,
-0.0406327955,
0.1578258574,
0.5135129094,
0.1955649704,
-0.8988380432,
0.3218204379,
0.0771955326,
0.0632451028,
-0.4761922359,
-0.0792128369,
0.3291472495,
0.3792409897,
0.4750533104,
-0.1277159303,
0.0378361084,
-0.4596715868,
0.0659934431,
0.3935000598,
-0.065504916,
-0.3518767059,
0.8843917251,
0.3120147884,
-0.4709253907,
0.7246726751,
0.0268500522,
-0.5112785101,
0.4398248196,
0.679776907,
0.6436878443,
-0.1945410222,
-0.0467491746,
0.0527662933,
0.21366328,
-0.3482117355,
0.041887071,
0.0524285547,
-0.3654421866,
-0.6555466652,
-0.6501675248,
-0.6246820688,
0.4681896865,
-0.3670962453,
0.479631871,
-0.639776051,
-0.2601253092,
-0.0662621036,
-0.0895013362,
-0.2555791438,
-0.2886530757,
0.3643120527,
1.0491113663,
-0.3937675357,
0.7625885606,
0.5552492142,
-0.4426771998,
-0.7152107954,
-0.0176205784,
0.2614311576,
-0.8114048839,
0.5347623229,
0.3873616755,
-0.1572826654,
-0.0975840911,
-0.6915810108,
-0.7305839062,
0.8766179681,
0.7412901521,
-0.5798236728,
0.136199072,
0.0739799961,
0.5074526668,
0.0574539006,
0.1807157695,
0.5324492455,
0.3667072654,
0.1687424183,
-1.0010663271,
-0.0093399668,
-0.0826334581,
0.1215417236,
0.1274808645,
-0.7489688396,
1.0656526089,
-0.1321442276,
-0.0193182491,
0.2642186284,
0.7210386395,
0.5552299619,
0.0488907993,
0.2631739974,
0.5412423611,
1.0926918983,
-0.0476611666,
1.2684440613,
-0.1957425773,
0.2070782632,
1.0692253113,
-0.7426441312,
0.8607150316,
0.2711978257,
-0.0479899719,
0.3793695867,
0.9101003408,
-0.2414679229,
0.26536268,
0.4009290636,
-0.2173313648,
-0.1896855831,
0.0301633514,
-0.2776536047,
0.340551585,
0.4170933962,
-0.0827181041,
-0.3193838,
-0.0233590323,
0.1092322543,
-0.1903686672,
-0.429006964,
0.5531449914,
0.3467529118,
-0.6086523533,
0.669290781,
0.0287345219,
0.7557067871,
-0.6118036509,
-0.0303654689,
-0.4127161205,
0.3643514812,
-0.1534075439,
-0.8378976583,
0.2145381123,
0.3654954135,
0.0478241742,
-0.0500444174,
0.6209430099,
-0.130866468,
-0.3185774386,
0.5590993166,
0.2611244917,
0.392729789,
-0.1407631487,
-0.690729022,
0.4335855246,
-0.281167835,
-0.394510746,
0.3173214793,
0.5355573893,
-0.2348829806,
1.0427451134,
0.9028776288,
0.2533400953,
0.1368884593,
0.2635529041,
1.0376285315,
-0.5887237787,
-0.3470398486,
-0.9418256879,
-0.0856417343,
-0.0444843471,
-0.2169926167,
0.7838107944,
0.8061234951,
0.7145982385,
-0.0089829592,
0.8507695794,
0.011940184,
0.3337096274,
-0.2670124173,
0.6226283908,
-0.3506368101,
0.4275570214,
-0.2815389633,
-1.2545260191,
-0.4983021021,
0.6184229255,
-0.3552707136,
-0.1899826825,
0.3893250823,
0.8240773678,
-0.2293182015,
0.1263368279,
0.059454523,
0.3153647482,
0.7072345614,
0.349773705,
0.9068191648,
-0.1090942919,
0.9764884114,
0.2960713208,
-0.2858076096,
-0.3050530553,
-0.950458765,
-0.7530522346,
-0.184335798,
-0.1680983454,
-0.312223047,
-0.042357944,
0.8229897022,
0.5506857634,
-0.5421552658,
-0.2776694596,
-0.0422595814,
0.0115628904,
-0.0508284345,
-0.1352247894,
0.2639807463,
-0.4638289511,
-1.0268502235,
0.3811130822,
0.2537600398,
0.0953219682,
-0.2635084391,
-0.1581533551,
0.1649883986,
0.1351672113,
0.7860847116,
0.5100218654,
-0.6862891316,
-0.3200554252,
-0.1192248017,
-0.2383111268,
0.0657240376,
0.6618558764,
-0.7088840604,
0.1608332843,
0.3257322013,
1.0647523403,
0.5184598565,
-0.0906695351,
0.6371921897,
-0.5385650992,
0.1605236679,
0.1304927021,
0.5788756013,
0.5861491561,
-0.1317345798,
0.753493607,
-0.096781522,
-0.7468273044,
-0.9497041702,
0.1509079784,
-0.948149085,
-0.4393335283,
1.2455123663,
-0.1395566016,
-0.3093953133,
-0.1326670051,
-0.4428192079,
0.2361568063,
-0.363086015,
1.1884459257,
1.1283413172,
-0.1177215576,
0.0072488352,
-0.7844397426,
0.0993144587,
0.2567194104,
-0.7893210053,
0.3092210293,
0.8071244955,
0.3234688342,
0.2950071096,
0.4731420577,
-0.3312019706,
-0.0394283049,
-0.0936398953,
0.1164165065,
-0.1562884003,
-0.053190507,
-0.3746087849,
0.0849839374,
0.1266566962,
-0.0470746271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15328v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15328v2 | Visual Programming for Text-to-Image Generation and Evaluation | 2023-05-24T16:42:17 | 2023-10-27T01:44:27 | Jaemin Cho, Abhay Zala, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | As large language models have demonstrated impressive performance in many
domains, recent works have adopted language models (LMs) as controllers of
visual modules for vision-and-language tasks. While existing work focuses on
equipping LMs with visual understanding, we propose two novel
interpretable/explainable visual programming frameworks for text-to-image (T2I)
generation and evaluation. First, we introduce VPGen, an interpretable
step-by-step T2I generation framework that decomposes T2I generation into three
steps: object/count generation, layout generation, and image generation. We
employ an LM to handle the first two steps (object/count generation and layout
generation), by finetuning it on text-layout pairs. Our step-by-step T2I
generation framework provides stronger spatial control than end-to-end models,
the dominant approach for this task. Furthermore, we leverage the world
knowledge of pretrained LMs, overcoming the limitation of previous
layout-guided T2I works that can only handle predefined object classes. We
demonstrate that our VPGen has improved control in counts/spatial
relations/scales of objects than state-of-the-art T2I generation models.
Second, we introduce VPEval, an interpretable and explainable evaluation
framework for T2I generation based on visual programming. Unlike previous T2I
evaluations with a single scoring model that is accurate in some skills but
unreliable in others, VPEval produces evaluation programs that invoke a set of
visual modules that are experts in different skills, and also provides
visual+textual explanations of the evaluation results. Our analysis shows that
VPEval provides a more human-correlated evaluation for skill-specific and
open-ended prompts than widely used single model-based evaluation. We hope that
our work encourages future progress on interpretable/explainable generation and
evaluation for T2I models. | [
-0.0765409842,
-0.4695469141,
0.7717111707,
0.5199087858,
-0.1606907398,
-0.1026518643,
-0.21241723,
-0.4389565289,
-0.4945884049,
0.5666337013,
-0.5129037499,
-0.7311916947,
-0.5748355985,
-0.0134049207,
-0.353502959,
0.6135665178,
-0.1853458583,
0.0897657573,
-0.4352770448,
0.0086942473,
-0.6808466911,
0.0381338745,
-0.4945982397,
-0.3059070408,
0.2422839552,
0.6188585162,
0.5602706075,
0.6413740516,
0.5285643935,
0.3148122728,
0.2901218832,
0.0179614369,
-0.6606377363,
-0.3158996105,
-0.2763843536,
-0.5007293224,
-0.1452824175,
-0.2314959913,
0.3443679512,
0.5612279177,
0.0746186376,
0.0593585446,
-0.0001997494,
0.6027032733,
-0.6596428156,
0.2685672939,
-0.3441428244,
0.2297417969,
0.1022115722,
-0.52634269,
-0.680428803,
-0.2546357214,
0.3073046505,
-0.6507885456,
0.0429823659,
-0.0809440389,
0.8563608527,
0.1799421161,
-0.3008401394,
-0.3188915849,
-0.6173907518,
1.0798528194,
-0.3402766585,
0.3263557255,
-0.0021067432,
0.5750446916,
0.1536020935,
-0.975810647,
-0.4475549459,
-0.2209156007,
0.0312498659,
0.5089298487,
-0.1294261217,
-0.0267817266,
0.1626690775,
0.2030522525,
-0.7165967226,
0.2481462955,
-0.3753509223,
0.1275446713,
0.4626985788,
0.1546066701,
0.6827276349,
-0.3636719584,
-0.6591826081,
-0.0496345907,
-0.726113677,
0.0076174717,
0.0106874853,
-0.1836357564,
-0.3692354858,
0.7778744698,
0.1704440266,
0.8362236023,
-0.2142934501,
-0.1000763699,
-0.1581504345,
-0.2761610448,
-0.2874396741,
-0.3355500698,
0.7880817652,
0.9246349335,
0.6672201753,
-0.2700699866,
-0.0736087412,
0.1764129102,
0.2919604778,
-1.1385536194,
-0.287433058,
0.1563474238,
-0.9124622345,
-0.8783016205,
0.0485253967,
-0.9870191216,
-0.3447367251,
-0.4538468421,
0.5414099693,
-0.5181081295,
-0.2842529714,
0.0982445031,
-0.5245161653,
0.5480440855,
0.4085411429,
-0.766079545,
0.2501295507,
0.7242333889,
0.8188377619,
-0.181620717,
-0.2785072625,
-0.3979305327,
0.1190164983,
-0.5886028409,
0.7546688318,
-0.767793715,
-0.3981421292,
0.213280499,
-0.374809742,
0.1510892212,
-0.3974083662,
-0.1799029112,
-0.3323982656,
0.521304965,
-0.1686569154,
-0.3848066032,
0.024340244,
0.0148654329,
-0.2786884904,
0.7139738798,
0.2066983879,
-0.7952458858,
0.6658684015,
-0.6170383096,
-0.2956770062,
0.2981132269,
-0.5818427801,
-0.413474381,
0.200573504,
0.1518190354,
0.3845737278,
-0.404610604,
0.1670496017,
-0.3272253573,
-0.3756979108,
0.0821514353,
-0.1992651224,
0.7334470153,
0.0674698427,
-0.462100178,
0.3289751709,
-0.6754412651,
0.293245852,
0.2438691854,
-0.1798851639,
0.0196709558,
0.3894758821,
0.2740758955,
0.2196536213,
0.2172662765,
-0.2555770576,
0.0013158668,
-0.1610352695,
0.4867676497,
0.5024970174,
0.0021188252,
0.6269777417,
0.1761795282,
0.6430793405,
-0.1734434515,
0.0864676833,
-0.4715698659,
-0.3709177971,
-0.736000061,
-0.1258288473,
-0.2013873458,
0.7420884967,
-1.3717622757,
0.0901617929,
-0.3760029376,
-0.3900762796,
-0.1088607162,
0.1009870023,
0.6773904562,
0.7277658582,
0.2279545516,
-0.1443570107,
-0.3575952649,
-0.9038371444,
-0.2576315105,
-0.3408132195,
-0.2854776978,
0.4563533962,
0.5411753058,
-0.0320795439,
0.7646334171,
-0.4601011276,
-0.0647290424,
-0.5170478821,
0.3654095829,
-0.2006394416,
0.4888830185,
0.8507836461,
-0.6977522969,
-0.3824993372,
0.097079508,
-1.0696547031,
-0.2689439952,
-0.2448676378,
-0.324390471,
0.0729231834,
0.6006453633,
-0.2506203055,
0.7483978868,
0.3686149418,
-0.5832322836,
0.4768542647,
-0.2226083279,
0.1971278191,
-0.9780092835,
0.1045861542,
0.1602021605,
-0.3040597141,
-0.5759772658,
0.1757838428,
0.0744772106,
-0.4912826717,
-0.429672122,
0.550034523,
-0.4402480125,
-0.4190365374,
-0.3008292913,
0.1131808832,
0.1401114464,
0.3808078766,
0.4255867898,
0.6224460006,
0.8354522586,
-0.4542543888,
0.2974640429,
0.2926625311,
-0.6489759088,
0.4875687957,
-0.8861132264,
-0.0600848645,
-0.3256951272,
-0.0636218041,
-0.8868786693,
-0.2142786682,
0.2517950237,
-0.4270046949,
0.4048955441,
-0.1353028119,
-0.2440768331,
-0.3152357042,
-0.2697647214,
0.2087985426,
0.6270875335,
-0.8694161177,
0.5064421296,
-0.0396808684,
-0.0159627721,
-0.4522022307,
-0.8966332674,
0.2887674272,
-0.1269655079,
-0.8142310381,
0.2320869118,
0.1267141104,
-0.3045310378,
0.1334062964,
0.1224797964,
-0.0141406516,
-0.0076811272,
0.2617504001,
0.2969852686,
-0.2740935087,
0.0825299323,
0.0290421639,
-0.3531010151,
0.0845851228,
-0.5749010444,
0.1850974262,
-0.1456891447,
-0.3136486709,
-0.4663882554,
0.4988388121,
0.3983539343,
-0.5070493221,
0.547111392,
0.6439480186,
-0.2369734198,
-0.3239805996,
-0.1255580336,
0.2516938746,
-0.4209607244,
0.6595060229,
-0.5664865971,
-0.6704304814,
0.0149131874,
-0.2807002068,
0.1674356759,
0.3140205145,
0.5964002609,
-0.307654351,
1.1443246603,
0.955843389,
0.4921577275,
0.7048702836,
-0.3117830753,
0.0879501551,
-0.3867408633,
-0.4455156922,
-0.2865564823,
-0.2600083053,
-0.4788845778,
-0.6797734499,
0.3844580352,
0.272927016,
-0.0765856877,
0.1910284162,
-0.5259646773,
0.7495536208,
0.2617537379,
0.259499073,
-0.0527836643,
0.3484096527,
0.1399252564,
-0.257512033,
-0.7287645936,
-0.6653502584,
1.010089159,
0.315325886,
0.7357067466,
-0.0016566004,
0.4496599436,
0.1506700516,
0.398049593,
-0.7985990644,
0.5773451328,
-0.4787929952,
-0.0319121592,
-0.2255102396,
-0.3397133946,
-0.6179816127,
0.2005331516,
-0.2570841014,
-0.9129905701,
0.1933327764,
0.3200002015,
0.1238716021,
0.17880629,
-1.0693513155,
1.2267632484,
-0.6013738513,
-0.601087451,
-0.2741925716,
-0.4186994731,
0.4145262539,
0.2893893719,
-0.1463578343,
0.3181752264,
-0.1215767562,
0.3706373572,
-0.6377971172,
0.7457748652,
-0.3070386648,
0.0749808699,
0.3754291534,
0.1538559496,
0.1891525239,
0.033670377,
-0.1103026494,
0.1071098074,
-0.1288934946,
-0.4314453006,
-0.7304933667,
0.6511047482,
-0.5456286669,
-0.3618330359,
0.0616224967,
-0.3457015455,
0.0984390453,
0.1920730472,
0.5494996309,
0.6469060183,
-0.2770428956,
0.1683735251,
0.4399086237,
-0.8257459998,
0.3005208373,
0.1401095241,
-0.567181468,
-0.2512130439,
1.2392970324,
-0.4223330319,
0.2774496078,
0.7598834634,
0.1283978075,
-0.1891543567,
-0.4259000421,
-0.6724785566,
-0.0474043824,
-0.6713389158,
0.109216854,
-0.3450941443,
0.0776991397,
-0.1033465713,
-0.4184384048,
-0.1445818096,
-0.2450269908,
-0.3906770051,
0.0512587093,
0.0730561614,
0.7376210093,
0.1686055064,
0.3105608523,
-0.3433107436,
0.5788111091,
0.3038544953,
0.5364480019,
-0.1018721238,
-0.1703916192,
-0.0732479319,
-0.3066341877,
-0.18698062,
-1.0922076702,
0.2595184743,
0.2011116147,
0.1052306369,
0.6303243041,
-0.5367715359,
0.8069882393,
-0.6211858392,
0.6996946931,
0.5687267184,
-1.0709042549,
0.8540552855,
-0.2395367622,
0.3814440072,
0.1972661018,
-0.0632318035,
-0.2908023596,
-0.1393796802,
-0.2252093256,
-0.6675496697,
0.7996669412,
0.3608731627,
-0.1748134345,
0.1886489987,
0.301674217,
0.1367290616,
0.1226899698,
-0.7008549571,
0.1721500754,
-0.6377221346,
-0.3630273044,
-0.0860759243,
-0.4635087252,
0.0526209921,
0.0004042013,
0.1996720731,
-0.1467550695,
0.3803490102,
0.0871894732,
-0.3388700783,
-0.0746691748,
0.1054488793,
0.5530952811,
0.9933907986,
0.0131410528,
-0.0153818093,
-0.2145089209,
-0.0481709503,
-0.2780754268,
-0.1653468609,
-0.250046581,
-0.0083956951,
0.8353167772,
1.2178498507,
0.0682484061,
-0.8181452751,
0.877176106,
-0.1207034066,
-0.4142982364,
-0.3559505939,
-0.0166498609,
-0.0411702991,
0.2564706206,
-0.0230060462,
0.122594364,
0.1762907803,
-0.3990611136,
-0.0396436639,
0.2728255987,
-0.4430361092,
-0.3444925249,
0.9619033337,
0.4432103634,
-0.323733598,
0.59568578,
0.0174505487,
-0.5031285286,
0.883630693,
0.5035113692,
0.8423521519,
0.1604217887,
0.5465462208,
0.3308555186,
0.4107832909,
0.2940997779,
0.6285445094,
-0.253939569,
-0.4124511778,
-0.5050902367,
-0.4028273225,
-0.2685230076,
0.1822081208,
-0.6578733325,
0.3918921947,
-0.4384604394,
0.2206107825,
0.0331659988,
-0.5062357783,
-0.8382310867,
0.3722637296,
0.2985289693,
0.8189819455,
-0.9068564177,
0.3565192819,
0.9224030375,
-0.4584439993,
-0.5175030231,
-0.0463045575,
-0.0398193784,
-0.7734674811,
0.7429407835,
0.3135613799,
0.0706954375,
-0.1717559695,
-0.8807598948,
-0.352222383,
1.2557482719,
0.2031799257,
-0.484348923,
-0.0007803246,
0.2198271602,
0.7301189899,
-0.431741029,
0.3445868492,
0.5013329983,
0.5261772871,
0.1351415217,
-0.4097857475,
-0.060768377,
-0.3184618652,
0.5391796827,
0.0245300066,
-0.3825153112,
0.2609960139,
-0.6360407472,
-0.3373636901,
0.3052995503,
0.6693826318,
0.2702794969,
0.5156966448,
0.3377476037,
0.3815016448,
0.2668654919,
-0.2661415339,
1.4422514439,
-0.2447566688,
0.0176187288,
0.9537239075,
0.0419408157,
0.686888814,
0.5377601385,
0.0758222044,
0.3911647201,
0.4399065971,
-0.3113263249,
0.4114486873,
0.1501938403,
0.0277528297,
-0.467980653,
-0.0619115569,
-0.0360389277,
0.4624846578,
0.3615367115,
-0.6280344725,
-0.3709478378,
0.1447273195,
-0.3484173119,
0.2909460068,
-0.2361091077,
0.5725045204,
0.0803276375,
-0.6964013577,
0.2008396834,
0.1714883298,
0.2039305568,
-0.334137857,
-0.3436961174,
0.0050539216,
0.2102164328,
-0.3228119612,
-1.1954835653,
0.1534574777,
0.3827057183,
-0.2583424151,
-0.6084500551,
1.0769797564,
-0.549926281,
-0.616389811,
0.2224084884,
0.4172370136,
0.2637934983,
0.1193385944,
-0.6291752458,
0.0857995152,
0.2764321268,
-0.2245258838,
-0.0730134472,
0.5406560302,
-0.3028965294,
0.7112173438,
0.3193483651,
-0.0229092464,
-0.0353265218,
0.4418241978,
0.5075109601,
-0.46952191,
-0.2443114072,
-0.6482079625,
0.7600136995,
-0.1112346873,
-0.1874781549,
0.2898691893,
0.5691782832,
0.6047331691,
-0.4589000642,
0.8535544872,
-0.196609661,
0.0959219187,
-0.6160219312,
0.79532516,
-0.7186715007,
0.0928779393,
-0.2312077582,
-0.920463562,
-0.2544028461,
0.5146113634,
-0.5162786245,
0.1242267191,
0.6115379333,
0.6185801029,
-0.0634433776,
-0.3661478758,
0.3941015601,
0.2129864097,
0.5419385433,
0.6859769821,
0.929089129,
-0.3480961621,
0.8351249695,
-0.2576078475,
-0.4444577098,
0.0352214985,
-0.9228718877,
-1.0886266232,
-0.3047878146,
-0.5025842786,
-0.16072914,
0.0500063077,
0.1496102512,
0.7286411524,
-0.4526701868,
-0.2210729867,
-0.5103666186,
0.0192967951,
-0.1424280405,
-0.2985422313,
0.2807255387,
-0.1815053821,
-0.7873779535,
0.3490066826,
0.6818743944,
0.0350154564,
-0.094519563,
-0.2703799307,
0.4516257346,
-0.203196466,
0.9228815436,
0.3278544545,
-0.8067981005,
-0.1369543374,
-0.2004832476,
-0.117233254,
-0.118511878,
0.7620098591,
-0.711753428,
0.8502739668,
0.7376421094,
0.3462155163,
0.538579464,
0.1632161438,
0.8588377237,
-0.5575670004,
0.2336315364,
-0.0835636631,
0.1910856962,
0.3790563643,
-0.0481695868,
0.462144345,
0.0163318478,
-0.2049337327,
-0.6288480163,
0.4689756334,
-1.0178720951,
-0.2942617238,
0.9689024091,
-0.0676341727,
-0.1615551412,
0.4609618485,
-0.2374030203,
0.1894144714,
0.0525434054,
0.578097403,
0.4232543707,
-0.0567908213,
-0.5126903057,
-0.5092707872,
0.3233035207,
0.4083400071,
-0.9960152507,
-0.2869393528,
0.7315732837,
0.2437572181,
-0.1537025422,
0.3453846574,
-0.3765569925,
0.5262477398,
0.0960710347,
0.3412739933,
-0.1755376756,
-0.5128250122,
-0.1468812525,
0.0497724824,
-0.1155539155,
-0.3430571258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15321v1 | Towards Foundation Models for Relational Databases [Vision Paper] | 2023-05-24T16:37:35 | 2023-05-24T16:37:35 | Liane Vogel, Benjamin Hilprecht, Carsten Binnig | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | Tabular representation learning has recently gained a lot of attention.
However, existing approaches only learn a representation from a single table,
and thus ignore the potential to learn from the full structure of relational
databases, including neighboring tables that can contain important information
for a contextualized representation. Moreover, current models are significantly
limited in scale, which prevents that they learn from large databases. In this
paper, we thus introduce our vision of relational representation learning, that
can not only learn from the full relational structure, but also can scale to
larger database sizes that are commonly found in real-world. Moreover, we also
discuss opportunities and challenges we see along the way to enable this vision
and present initial very promising results. Overall, we argue that this
direction can lead to foundation models for relational databases that are today
only available for text and images. | [
-0.3619726002,
-0.7267867327,
0.7691417336,
-0.0431775004,
-0.1402982324,
-0.151513651,
-0.043276079,
-0.5437964201,
0.3988624215,
0.8794312477,
-0.5169371963,
-0.5447910428,
-0.4549685717,
-0.0960642174,
-0.6985222697,
0.7372376323,
-0.0004126376,
0.0575584359,
-0.6469963193,
-0.2280027866,
-0.5748925209,
-0.2022956312,
-0.0787006244,
-0.3430106342,
0.3712955415,
0.7574241161,
0.6533123255,
1.0338840485,
0.6976425648,
0.1594215333,
0.2178533673,
-0.3010671735,
-0.5963667631,
0.2759109139,
-0.0650672168,
-0.4485029578,
-0.224540472,
-0.1775338948,
1.1222248077,
1.4583133459,
-0.2819755375,
0.0267648958,
-0.2511835396,
1.2949073315,
-0.3709362447,
0.6124232411,
-0.6904876232,
0.5578042269,
-0.1134393588,
0.352386564,
-0.599509418,
-0.2589867115,
0.1828897595,
-0.571410656,
0.0048461491,
0.0478002317,
0.6342536211,
-0.1294701546,
-0.8602249622,
-0.0757622123,
-0.7272321582,
0.3184383214,
0.1978923529,
0.6633550525,
0.0600462928,
0.860014677,
-0.1010162383,
-0.8633904457,
-0.2426713854,
-0.3288576305,
-0.1591148376,
-0.2236197889,
0.1604248583,
-0.0421621613,
0.3708224297,
0.5112763047,
-0.6517551541,
-0.4148753285,
-0.0433377326,
0.3293359876,
0.2724479437,
0.2472746521,
0.1078168228,
0.0075405724,
-0.3893103898,
-0.2107074112,
-1.0571061373,
0.0470057279,
-0.4892564714,
0.4413102269,
-0.0025869855,
0.5221278071,
-0.2184455991,
1.1281074286,
-0.0660430193,
0.2502948344,
-0.2198807001,
-0.0876477361,
-0.5171092749,
-0.1132531762,
0.5612689853,
0.0431286842,
0.0419566147,
-0.46517241,
-0.0135733346,
0.2025123388,
0.2761955261,
-0.8202730417,
-0.3598454595,
-0.0044637579,
-0.4088089466,
-0.2287995666,
0.380382508,
-0.8314295411,
-0.7185538411,
-0.2389520854,
0.4419968724,
-0.183160156,
-0.5243108273,
-0.2657828033,
0.2943736017,
0.1532586515,
0.3403261602,
-1.0347502232,
0.6975408196,
0.4153048098,
0.6846869588,
0.0355242305,
-0.0568746515,
-0.2230432928,
0.3540021777,
-0.7581264377,
0.8007035851,
-0.4947061539,
-0.5273678303,
-0.0286354963,
-0.0594907701,
0.1939458102,
-0.602035284,
-0.0217401069,
-0.4826103747,
-0.359680146,
-0.8430927396,
-0.3773384392,
-0.0544806048,
0.266504705,
-1.1601353884,
0.4232963026,
0.6207091808,
-0.6603357792,
0.6448309422,
-0.379751265,
-0.5437827706,
-0.0710899383,
-0.6384384036,
-0.6013666391,
0.1927520633,
0.0519673638,
0.5603845716,
-0.4185550213,
0.4010788202,
-0.3073778749,
-0.2791134715,
0.0765476152,
0.3322483301,
0.618991971,
-0.0976317152,
-0.1038235873,
0.0184936244,
-0.7741811275,
-0.079847604,
0.1342411935,
-0.2004744858,
-0.1314523667,
-0.0051357029,
0.1439796239,
0.0693730041,
-0.0659275949,
-0.3573768735,
0.3263513148,
-0.2460955977,
0.1567218155,
0.3368949592,
-0.1407261342,
0.9560905099,
-0.1606157422,
0.3950079978,
0.2025844902,
-0.3277272284,
-0.1984360963,
-0.1986271739,
-0.5335105062,
-0.1515646428,
0.5767516494,
0.2425024211,
-0.4948276281,
0.0376057848,
-0.706848681,
-0.3767464161,
0.1850688308,
0.0832192823,
0.1014010906,
0.7035579681,
0.3615739346,
-0.5629143715,
-0.7443282604,
-1.1145070791,
-0.2680561244,
-0.0453052483,
0.3020278513,
0.471701622,
0.7916396856,
0.0839489251,
1.1762647629,
-0.2823009193,
-0.7658922672,
-0.2523024082,
-0.1800020635,
0.3644860387,
0.5659299493,
0.63379848,
-1.5292286873,
-0.9011366963,
0.3380958438,
-1.1443498135,
0.5485137701,
-0.0050151688,
0.0348892733,
-0.091622971,
0.4914869368,
-0.8787109852,
0.5558512211,
0.1750681996,
-0.4350172877,
0.291316539,
0.2583549619,
0.0528269708,
-0.8365758657,
-0.0919927657,
0.2133691758,
-0.529415071,
-0.6137077808,
0.1740739346,
0.2795021534,
-0.6666618586,
0.062188942,
0.3841976523,
-0.8576734066,
-0.5895125866,
0.271047622,
-0.120719716,
-0.1348452121,
0.1019873917,
0.3672701418,
0.5036269426,
0.6325822473,
-0.3818590343,
0.4491471648,
0.4817135334,
-0.5042976737,
0.9893961549,
-0.2797054052,
-0.47434026,
-0.2532508969,
0.5917814374,
-0.9001429081,
-0.7464566231,
-0.0052981107,
-0.3864388764,
0.7654593587,
-0.3825104833,
-0.1660072803,
-0.3345801234,
-0.0298224948,
-0.1387096196,
0.1730157733,
-0.6810981035,
1.0401383638,
0.6850201488,
0.295283556,
-0.8306552172,
-1.1014939547,
0.1651423872,
-0.0573338233,
-0.8200289011,
0.5523566008,
0.5939244628,
-0.3670629561,
0.4914432168,
-0.4614783227,
-0.4488176405,
-0.0741510466,
0.5442993045,
-0.043752674,
-0.5513026714,
0.4594365656,
-0.1273383945,
0.0595145188,
0.0796633959,
-0.5246502161,
0.0676135346,
-0.4139231145,
-0.0284662675,
-0.2014876008,
0.5182350874,
0.3637158573,
-0.2627809942,
1.1162775755,
0.0781152546,
-0.9111606479,
-0.2288686633,
-0.2888187468,
-0.2180546969,
-0.376624018,
0.598064065,
-0.6141002774,
-0.6318885088,
0.4268518388,
-0.2445046455,
-0.0568072982,
0.2610829473,
0.2988228798,
-0.2144722641,
0.4494403899,
0.9880434275,
0.3145575821,
0.5149117112,
-0.7573800087,
-0.0653369203,
-0.5444027185,
-0.3674703538,
-0.6098979712,
-0.2077491581,
-0.2513509095,
-0.2340582758,
0.3251941204,
0.1580953002,
-0.3075993061,
0.4280200899,
-0.5358822346,
0.7701083422,
0.2786887884,
0.444711417,
0.399959594,
0.4926581681,
-0.1095169038,
-0.1756677926,
-0.5344991684,
-0.2474764735,
1.140609622,
0.0728995726,
0.5298873186,
0.087587364,
0.8409715891,
0.2053355575,
0.724815309,
-0.6557246447,
0.5245515704,
-0.06055611,
-0.9767456055,
-0.483217895,
-0.7535822392,
-0.8403104544,
0.5871313214,
-0.5036737919,
-0.7025745511,
0.6115781069,
0.1852199286,
0.0550471209,
0.3752546906,
-0.6693902016,
1.4341859818,
0.0883137584,
-0.5374501944,
0.074495472,
-0.7659337521,
0.4619073868,
0.1551371515,
0.4142076671,
0.2198921144,
0.026955286,
0.5455984473,
-0.4029884636,
0.6529506445,
-0.4581581354,
0.3710925877,
0.541662693,
0.3694010675,
0.3638686836,
0.2241257429,
0.1549357474,
-0.4233681262,
-0.0211234409,
-0.4602456987,
-0.5041323304,
0.7535433173,
-0.549628377,
-0.3741138875,
-0.5078841448,
-0.3869394362,
-0.6698753834,
0.4004559517,
-0.1124577671,
0.3761779368,
-0.5084844828,
0.9261542559,
0.8529418111,
0.4244069159,
0.0922678411,
0.0620936826,
-0.5644181371,
-0.2009257227,
0.828915,
0.396266818,
-0.1873754412,
0.9132980108,
-0.0363194235,
-0.3311401904,
-0.4906582832,
-0.4907177687,
0.1980760545,
-0.9813365936,
-0.3645946085,
-0.5594224334,
0.2440622747,
-0.3194871843,
-0.09319105,
-0.3027915657,
-0.7893234491,
-0.358092308,
-0.2700200379,
0.1549645811,
0.8869264722,
-0.0033491354,
0.3963938653,
-0.40929088,
0.2513503134,
0.5804126859,
0.5901628733,
0.1547555029,
0.0873657539,
-0.4358391464,
-0.0541958474,
-0.338863939,
-1.2274788618,
0.1426318139,
0.3862296939,
0.3390855193,
0.2116974592,
-0.1625692248,
0.5884631872,
-0.4497051537,
0.3152171671,
0.3036164343,
-0.6792900562,
0.4098845124,
-0.4767320752,
-0.0894083828,
0.8765096068,
0.7204377055,
-0.3172524571,
0.634771347,
-0.3384257257,
-0.4714137614,
0.4450365007,
-0.1195860878,
-0.1082244217,
0.3617468476,
0.7176736593,
-0.0692376792,
0.2890462577,
-1.334823966,
0.03884748,
-0.3620118201,
-0.3397596776,
0.2613903284,
-0.1474665552,
0.0047301655,
-0.0083835311,
0.2973893881,
-0.1220622733,
0.311963886,
0.2156897187,
-0.3234328032,
-0.521684289,
0.0945473164,
-0.1746578366,
1.0079262257,
-0.2881684005,
0.0427136905,
-0.2732512355,
-0.3814203441,
0.1304633915,
0.036454726,
-0.0799595341,
-0.0649276599,
0.3294892907,
0.7353805304,
0.193034783,
-0.477029264,
0.6775667667,
-0.022890646,
-0.2869246304,
-0.349240005,
-0.3123474419,
0.4783676267,
0.2374685407,
0.4942488074,
-0.1576308757,
0.1293179989,
-0.9710393548,
0.4321897626,
0.6860765815,
-0.8261403441,
-0.0056810626,
0.7816290855,
-0.1588265002,
0.0328111649,
0.5363506079,
0.1042600572,
-0.2418603301,
0.8591416478,
0.5990638137,
0.1382648796,
-0.1097794771,
0.2668014765,
0.3352985084,
0.2738155127,
-0.3923402727,
0.2049775571,
-0.1485204995,
-0.5768535733,
-0.089877367,
-0.5821677446,
-0.4977576435,
-0.2724167109,
-0.5606362224,
0.1782710105,
-0.7156199813,
-0.2005953193,
-0.1875879765,
0.182661593,
-0.4952144921,
0.4494075477,
-0.0867625549,
0.9433872104,
-0.8025583625,
0.8966672421,
0.9170368314,
-0.5211690664,
-0.6170600653,
-0.5736432672,
-0.2429893166,
-0.3068842888,
0.6191379428,
0.3924541771,
0.3710351884,
-0.0000174608,
-0.6226171851,
-0.7425259352,
1.0841575861,
0.4323750734,
-0.6496976614,
-0.6148238182,
0.1948925555,
0.3862321079,
-0.8518095613,
-0.3561120331,
0.4491392076,
0.4118592739,
0.1626659483,
-0.3889018595,
0.048566252,
-0.0099847782,
0.245844245,
0.2755632401,
-0.2037321329,
1.08958745,
-0.1970771551,
-0.394328177,
0.0546615534,
0.8203457594,
0.0115865357,
0.1516689956,
0.3139253557,
0.7060821652,
0.3692860603,
-0.4867290556,
1.2632832527,
0.1880857944,
0.5536817908,
1.0963646173,
-0.2252339572,
0.7321704626,
0.5269256234,
-0.5121942759,
0.6563321948,
0.5309188962,
0.0049166279,
0.6534225345,
0.0588398799,
-0.0416119993,
-0.4162994623,
0.0391561463,
-0.5880924463,
0.2206261456,
0.7800156474,
-0.4117209911,
-0.2129040658,
-0.131965518,
-0.6511720419,
0.5390660167,
-0.4397464693,
0.4675575793,
0.2807646394,
-0.0488493405,
0.3330681622,
-0.3416977823,
-0.0746321231,
-0.3938069642,
-0.4468096197,
-0.0730644539,
-0.0721433759,
-0.2756820917,
-0.5348566175,
0.2966670394,
-0.5709120631,
-0.2716702521,
-0.1402990818,
0.8253219128,
-0.3687893748,
-0.4682603478,
0.1935969591,
0.535797894,
-0.2274916321,
-0.2435085624,
-0.3608883619,
-0.1396109909,
-0.2074994147,
-0.3805407882,
0.4296538234,
0.6623144746,
-0.1670722067,
0.5788451433,
0.2354280502,
0.0431848764,
-0.054802943,
-0.6299503446,
0.7618791461,
-0.7938326597,
-0.5784792304,
-0.5957295299,
0.4002455771,
-0.1640235484,
0.3225150704,
0.1801775396,
0.4752638638,
0.6560332775,
-0.295327127,
0.4638939202,
-0.3076699376,
0.6172429919,
-0.3245224953,
0.736303091,
-0.6363244057,
-0.0633256808,
-0.3783555329,
-1.2437480688,
-0.7694187164,
1.1425909996,
-0.1067496985,
-0.0317835882,
0.7299312353,
0.3069089949,
-0.048996605,
0.2344002277,
0.4441037178,
0.4071048498,
0.0920903385,
0.7096070051,
0.6570659876,
-0.40189448,
0.694868207,
-0.2538918555,
-0.3256452382,
-0.2255509645,
-0.8633238673,
-0.990572989,
-0.7127391696,
0.1213364154,
-0.4471020997,
0.0874583498,
0.5906282663,
0.7905408144,
-0.7531256676,
-0.4555748105,
-0.4111590385,
0.3481362164,
-0.0923219547,
-0.1192781329,
0.5736913085,
0.2620809376,
-0.073182404,
-0.0046071452,
0.1535645425,
0.1759350002,
-0.3234884143,
0.2833452225,
-0.1751188636,
-0.5714387298,
0.4776873291,
0.5947387218,
-0.3853829205,
-0.0792348012,
-0.0386226401,
-0.0627839789,
0.5888348818,
0.8684731722,
-1.1705070734,
0.1622980684,
0.2665419281,
0.8944427967,
1.0209021568,
-0.182726115,
0.4279553592,
-0.702526927,
0.2071176618,
0.3971074224,
0.6049901843,
0.647508502,
-0.2724333107,
0.8761531711,
0.2889579535,
-0.1582542211,
-0.9755701423,
0.4863691926,
-0.9771577716,
-0.2136529684,
0.4148389697,
-0.0792987421,
-0.5687248707,
0.1173865795,
0.1223202199,
0.0657847747,
-0.2568176389,
0.4784779847,
0.6642051339,
-0.0540671721,
-0.5490648746,
-0.4282809198,
0.4016335607,
-0.0444438308,
-0.9956429005,
0.2517389357,
0.7214366794,
0.0829301029,
0.3654279411,
0.7638068199,
-0.4242788553,
0.5578880906,
0.2612398565,
-0.2104707509,
0.078100495,
-0.9312188029,
-0.1729709953,
0.4909398258,
0.0919625759,
0.5702465177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15299v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15299v4 | Science in the Era of ChatGPT, Large Language Models and Generative AI: Challenges for Research Ethics and How to Respond | 2023-05-24T16:23:46 | 2023-07-29T12:54:20 | Evangelos Pournaras | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models of artificial intelligence (AI), such as ChatGPT, find
remarkable but controversial applicability in science and research. This paper
reviews epistemological challenges, ethical and integrity risks in science
conduct in the advent of generative AI. This is with the aim to lay new timely
foundations for a high-quality research ethics review. The role of AI language
models as a research instrument and subject is scrutinized along with ethical
implications for scientists, participants and reviewers. New emerging practices
for research ethics review are discussed, concluding with ten recommendations
that shape a response for a more responsible research conduct in the era of AI. | [
0.0044099684,
-0.7850772738,
0.4924121499,
0.1249691173,
0.1787063479,
0.0853718817,
-0.0409961827,
-0.6205685139,
-0.3104309142,
0.5437483788,
-0.2915110588,
0.3079552352,
-0.7244133353,
0.0913607478,
-0.5797266364,
1.1946510077,
0.0666227788,
0.4330683351,
-0.5879739523,
-0.1818317622,
-0.0604910888,
-1.0082809925,
-0.956319809,
-0.4108925462,
0.4332680702,
-0.1234908402,
0.8228217363,
0.2956041992,
0.9928151369,
0.4059536159,
-0.2168462276,
-0.1489932984,
-0.6029083133,
0.3123185933,
-0.1023770347,
-0.478305012,
-0.3539837003,
0.2813231051,
0.2736602426,
0.513127923,
-0.2567501962,
0.1788541526,
-0.1182380021,
0.3229786158,
-0.2001331896,
0.424259603,
-0.2154797167,
0.1021923274,
-0.2299138755,
-0.3116819263,
-0.4815957248,
-0.6335685253,
0.1552211791,
-0.8046320081,
0.1866134405,
0.274877429,
0.6272510886,
0.4586718082,
-0.1099415049,
-0.4284499884,
-1.1674932241,
0.8324697018,
-0.6106878519,
0.0880942568,
0.3902180791,
0.3031697273,
-0.1025246307,
-0.9670234919,
-0.8696403503,
-0.6034716964,
0.3073934913,
0.0549048148,
-0.0765618756,
0.0130920894,
0.2776477635,
0.3511499166,
-0.2593356073,
-0.0032344044,
-0.6276667714,
0.0093595181,
0.7709097266,
0.0676079765,
0.575083375,
0.1593405306,
0.0371943042,
-0.245603919,
-0.8621400595,
-0.0663101077,
0.6379501224,
-0.1274226904,
0.2445751131,
0.8129984736,
0.1394011974,
0.1721561402,
-0.1889564842,
0.4487076402,
0.1367269903,
-0.5813827515,
-0.0365442932,
0.0806548968,
0.8510557413,
0.2162160724,
0.4955841005,
0.1799863577,
0.1783259511,
0.1174123958,
0.4505178928,
-0.4823129177,
-0.2811741233,
0.4578363597,
-0.5518384576,
-0.4889052212,
-0.1149460152,
-0.4926797748,
-0.3913381398,
-0.1971700937,
0.3120519519,
-0.4777908325,
-0.398368001,
0.1312841624,
-0.1517909616,
0.4005634189,
0.5902733207,
-0.6318395734,
-0.0367604122,
0.9659073949,
0.3980495334,
0.3555499017,
-0.471901089,
-0.1526023597,
0.1256933808,
-0.3217769563,
0.5921221972,
-0.791854322,
-0.6757993102,
-0.2297188789,
-0.1699763238,
0.0172391608,
-0.1221320853,
0.4465930164,
-0.3756584525,
0.3489840925,
-0.169033736,
-0.3523477018,
-0.1719525456,
0.156098783,
-0.3678290546,
0.8119233847,
-0.00156118,
-0.779951334,
0.2767091691,
-1.2452611923,
-0.4002186358,
0.4179587364,
-0.2106467783,
-0.3830505908,
-0.1068540439,
-0.1078197211,
0.1223400608,
-0.2059506923,
0.3155647218,
-0.2607444227,
0.0024700605,
0.4831776321,
-0.6724344492,
1.200286746,
0.3468587101,
-0.4086184204,
0.2667807937,
-0.5544270277,
0.0625182092,
0.2038696408,
-0.0743139312,
-0.3315536678,
0.4795133173,
0.2459837794,
-0.1041020826,
-0.1504223049,
-0.7411304712,
-0.0443398468,
-0.1577507257,
1.2723149061,
0.665951848,
-0.0616559796,
0.2562735975,
-0.4260389507,
0.4037333131,
-0.4571791589,
0.6828841567,
0.0574215576,
-0.6134153008,
-0.6365751624,
0.2101009339,
0.2790027857,
0.6061933041,
-0.4322259128,
0.3296780884,
-0.1229000464,
-0.5422377586,
-1.0642293692,
-0.5114328265,
0.1721271873,
0.2315181047,
0.2457508892,
-0.0791450813,
-0.183018893,
-0.8050662279,
-0.1341577023,
-0.4846380055,
-0.0225437935,
0.5077804327,
0.7019579411,
-0.0491451472,
0.7941285968,
0.0121587915,
0.2621090114,
0.0713356957,
0.5420622826,
-0.491481185,
0.7887693048,
0.1592633426,
-1.260949254,
-0.0697755739,
0.1577477157,
-0.9059559107,
0.2914020717,
0.0708226636,
0.0668128952,
-0.0951357037,
0.6298387647,
-0.9740150571,
0.2927924991,
0.2104815394,
-0.2974946797,
0.3917434216,
0.014400145,
0.6235047579,
-0.9129552245,
0.303209722,
-0.2378731519,
0.0073804604,
-0.5993373394,
0.2991306186,
-0.3260858059,
-0.2695884407,
-0.4445448518,
0.2984197438,
-0.2339099497,
0.1512362063,
-0.3529424369,
-0.2657511532,
-0.1780968457,
-0.4262617528,
-0.0976642445,
0.6894085407,
0.4232232273,
-0.474905163,
0.6111989617,
0.6427595019,
-0.3892586827,
0.5242639184,
-0.9645632505,
0.2513908744,
-0.5226945281,
0.3849889636,
-0.3686380684,
-0.3119523227,
0.2564757466,
-0.9509255886,
-0.0205281228,
0.08517389,
-0.5463081598,
-0.303720206,
-0.1954976171,
0.639898777,
0.7226815224,
-0.0268156156,
0.4115398824,
0.4351554811,
-0.6576581001,
-0.6423714161,
-0.6859928966,
0.1932883561,
-0.1555236131,
-0.5505191088,
0.1262851954,
-0.1779568493,
-0.7558102012,
0.2289862186,
0.4577227533,
0.1322960407,
0.2265010476,
0.0792649388,
0.2034062743,
-0.19759956,
-0.1599292755,
-0.3087048233,
0.142537117,
0.3183063567,
0.2857267559,
0.6106384397,
-0.0753357634,
-0.3709228039,
-0.1851969361,
0.6168242097,
0.7499954104,
-0.3257859051,
0.5806583762,
0.5694696903,
-0.2526481152,
0.2684676647,
-0.4580614567,
-0.4960657656,
-0.4312998652,
0.5045242906,
0.2425540537,
-1.1033962965,
0.1970638633,
0.3027626574,
0.222868219,
0.5158365965,
0.6969347,
-0.3109227121,
0.8888396025,
0.7031568885,
-0.1099953502,
0.2066446245,
0.0556071214,
0.8258369565,
-0.8779073358,
-0.3635380864,
-0.8701807261,
0.2080123872,
-0.81731534,
-0.337161839,
0.5050179958,
-0.2201483846,
-0.467218101,
-0.107011579,
-0.6656511426,
0.4073752165,
0.6753920317,
-0.220335409,
0.3095477521,
-0.133713156,
0.6283240914,
0.39491871,
-0.6257459521,
-0.6951300502,
0.8349063993,
0.4987251163,
0.856510818,
-0.0655632615,
0.2873787284,
0.4855197072,
0.2104022056,
-0.5363792181,
0.4505427778,
0.3158408105,
-0.8859875202,
-0.6596646309,
-0.3717263639,
-0.9485854506,
0.0697852299,
0.0184896588,
-0.6169930696,
0.1041021645,
0.0262634791,
-0.3381571174,
0.2569847405,
-0.4418602288,
0.241623193,
-0.2638607025,
-0.2296112627,
-0.5268732309,
-0.9828221798,
0.3361923695,
0.4072465897,
0.1848809868,
-0.2420134991,
0.4461202323,
0.6667692065,
-0.2232839912,
0.7388572693,
0.2990529835,
0.1864667386,
0.5328243971,
-0.0053350925,
0.3069940209,
0.1622014195,
0.0807035565,
0.1614331901,
0.4205708504,
-0.3155328631,
-0.0447008386,
0.6439549923,
-0.840189755,
-0.8732293248,
-0.8851307631,
-0.6470729709,
-0.2161866277,
-0.0322793908,
0.4114880264,
0.0779527649,
-0.4331420064,
0.264026165,
0.8733335137,
-0.4552585185,
0.2634714842,
0.1334187686,
0.1316641122,
0.0884689465,
0.8688136935,
-0.2041969001,
0.2719998062,
-0.0000691961,
0.17168805,
-0.0640567839,
-0.5015039444,
-0.5663175583,
-0.083456926,
-0.492166549,
0.0496536382,
-0.7360083461,
-0.7310585976,
-0.6320775747,
-0.1437998265,
-0.4718166292,
-0.2360365987,
-0.2026058435,
0.0291504487,
0.5738861561,
0.9051137567,
0.037043266,
-0.2366795689,
-0.6397031546,
-0.0936839208,
0.1409603953,
0.0707458779,
-0.0815984905,
-0.1500528008,
0.4004325867,
0.0504355654,
-0.2080339491,
-0.143577069,
-0.0458656289,
-0.081710428,
0.5495312214,
0.0535321571,
-0.0860662907,
0.0776805729,
-0.7355206013,
1.0409127474,
-0.0230504088,
-0.6274391413,
0.4576701224,
-0.5266464353,
-0.2247039378,
0.3290529549,
0.7575731277,
-0.787247777,
-0.3462994397,
-0.759528935,
-0.9433792233,
0.3466476202,
0.5878348947,
0.5024615526,
0.1978162527,
0.2159588039,
0.2783884704,
0.3552301228,
-0.8187474608,
0.0411763638,
-0.4414730668,
-0.0807100087,
0.0656431913,
-0.0667063966,
-0.6481266618,
-0.1656543165,
0.4545124173,
0.0182859041,
0.5066851377,
0.2978097796,
0.2034714371,
-0.245106712,
0.5680552721,
0.5528489351,
0.6557663083,
0.210202843,
-0.2338632941,
-0.3546871841,
-0.3784509301,
0.2071205229,
0.2901496291,
-0.6297214031,
-0.5872049332,
0.4907901883,
0.4571075439,
-0.2264894098,
-0.6190808415,
0.2517918348,
0.081580013,
-0.2149775624,
-0.5008367896,
0.0318296775,
-0.1367406249,
0.1640232056,
0.2698467076,
0.1938897669,
0.321955204,
-0.9219552875,
-0.138774544,
0.5528547168,
0.0233620405,
-0.2274112999,
0.688457787,
0.2455962598,
-0.2796589136,
0.7598760128,
0.0715617463,
-0.4616497457,
0.9464999437,
0.2216855735,
0.5151299238,
-0.3613876998,
0.456887126,
-0.0262078606,
0.4938381612,
-0.356159538,
0.3110304475,
0.2502698898,
-0.7023434043,
-0.3323796391,
-0.4890336096,
-0.8857896328,
0.2195576727,
-0.3818252087,
-0.2219685912,
-0.5056347251,
-0.0997447073,
0.2423524261,
-0.3269058466,
-0.2970290184,
0.0004050443,
0.0226483606,
0.3241454065,
-0.4595004618,
0.5013652444,
0.6418378353,
-0.6347208023,
-0.405515939,
-0.1306888014,
0.1144942492,
-0.7699725032,
0.5048546195,
-0.2122628242,
-0.0540333204,
0.0506382734,
-1.0333687067,
-0.9690842628,
0.7592179775,
0.1029187962,
-0.1564323902,
0.0213416889,
0.0402664989,
0.7334877849,
-0.0609755069,
0.3355897069,
0.4612720609,
0.6332979798,
-0.0978315771,
-1.0444158316,
-0.2946943939,
-0.3589685559,
-0.1126230806,
0.049254179,
-1.1434770823,
1.0520961285,
-0.146401599,
-0.1993400604,
0.335577786,
0.4855191708,
0.3020714819,
0.4344832301,
-0.0198549163,
0.1408419758,
0.5331462622,
-0.2013287395,
1.217687726,
-0.0234862156,
0.1823803037,
0.4893781841,
-0.6457638144,
0.4488992393,
0.4191304147,
-0.3942851722,
0.0882268399,
0.6797720194,
-0.4119948745,
0.2703723311,
0.4701996446,
-0.2567100823,
0.1116446629,
-0.5562372804,
-0.5299232602,
0.5588681102,
0.568340838,
-0.0404549688,
0.2053463906,
0.3084586561,
0.2036736906,
0.1407334954,
-0.369769007,
0.5460482836,
0.0860915184,
-0.6540218592,
-0.27693367,
-0.0205699373,
0.5577101707,
-0.4090442061,
-0.3071518242,
0.1747277826,
-0.0303108953,
-0.0606879592,
-0.8974513412,
0.2648637295,
-0.0711434484,
-0.0109541202,
-0.1414018422,
0.4757621288,
-0.1216233596,
-0.6183314919,
-0.0851840153,
0.4632559121,
0.0151541373,
0.2996199727,
-0.6158788204,
0.1722406745,
-0.2253692597,
-0.447606653,
0.2603332698,
0.249672085,
-0.205080241,
1.1993676424,
0.6622347236,
0.0998453423,
0.2058653682,
-0.0137711344,
0.6510339975,
-0.6226599813,
-0.1537707895,
-0.7430306077,
0.0169880297,
-0.138077423,
-0.4874084294,
0.3941515386,
0.2127912939,
0.7367374897,
0.0217206031,
1.2324676514,
-0.6178537607,
0.2756548822,
-0.6137332916,
1.069863081,
-0.1435611695,
-0.2595762014,
-0.0481573083,
-0.5660247803,
-0.1222350523,
0.6647534966,
-0.3085439205,
0.6712315679,
0.6040703058,
0.3735821843,
0.2479287386,
0.3441316783,
0.2072838247,
0.3596121669,
0.5063866377,
0.1059998944,
1.1235151291,
-0.2309244275,
0.1935156882,
-0.0634170324,
-0.0433634631,
-0.2189818174,
-0.7556056976,
-0.6502208114,
-0.7338888645,
-0.241000399,
-0.3479342759,
0.2337801009,
0.855032444,
0.5845332146,
-0.874668777,
-0.0765744969,
-0.0592147186,
-0.302796185,
-0.260435313,
-0.3147351444,
0.467407465,
-0.1031370237,
-0.8900789618,
0.2429322898,
0.3469676673,
0.0852839947,
-0.4774993062,
0.0962355956,
-0.1373796165,
0.294239521,
0.7392913103,
0.6130338907,
-0.7553727031,
-0.6413263083,
-0.1181113347,
-0.1092913896,
-0.1092979908,
1.0241531134,
-0.1592838317,
0.2069255263,
0.3158009946,
0.7704942226,
0.0927021056,
0.0260525756,
0.8840001822,
0.0165289808,
0.0269289166,
1.1054317951,
0.2591834068,
0.4458396435,
-0.6499193311,
0.7795280218,
0.1182999089,
-1.0825355053,
-1.032384634,
0.2983170748,
-0.8583051562,
-0.2132263482,
0.9109503031,
-0.052704785,
-0.1501444876,
-0.2971610427,
-0.2447636127,
0.1376695037,
-0.2601691186,
1.1468471289,
0.8985883594,
-0.5536486506,
-0.4313586354,
-1.0192027092,
0.8827981353,
0.5561335683,
-0.983269155,
0.2322311848,
0.2680303454,
0.1289505213,
0.0933975205,
0.5952694416,
-0.5586596727,
0.414652735,
0.2091767639,
0.2635315955,
-0.0318162926,
-0.179877162,
0.0599785633,
-0.0238428712,
0.3631328046,
0.2410186976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15294v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15294v2 | Enhancing Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models with Iterative Retrieval-Generation Synergy | 2023-05-24T16:17:36 | 2023-10-23T09:58:13 | Zhihong Shao, Yeyun Gong, Yelong Shen, Minlie Huang, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models are powerful text processors and reasoners, but are
still subject to limitations including outdated knowledge and hallucinations,
which necessitates connecting them to the world. Retrieval-augmented large
language models have raised extensive attention for grounding model generation
on external knowledge. However, retrievers struggle to capture relevance,
especially for queries with complex information needs. Recent work has proposed
to improve relevance modeling by having large language models actively involved
in retrieval, i.e., to improve retrieval with generation. In this paper, we
show that strong performance can be achieved by a method we call Iter-RetGen,
which synergizes retrieval and generation in an iterative manner. A model
output shows what might be needed to finish a task, and thus provides an
informative context for retrieving more relevant knowledge which in turn helps
generate a better output in the next iteration. Compared with recent work which
interleaves retrieval with generation when producing an output, Iter-RetGen
processes all retrieved knowledge as a whole and largely preserves the
flexibility in generation without structural constraints. We evaluate
Iter-RetGen on multi-hop question answering, fact verification, and commonsense
reasoning, and show that it can flexibly leverage parametric knowledge and
non-parametric knowledge, and is superior to or competitive with
state-of-the-art retrieval-augmented baselines while causing fewer overheads of
retrieval and generation. We can further improve performance via
generation-augmented retrieval adaptation. | [
-0.1794517934,
-0.6934050322,
0.6570476294,
-0.0356662981,
-0.2037639171,
0.1078832597,
-0.4046878815,
-0.3302566409,
0.2978628278,
0.533248961,
-0.2178002298,
-0.2663540542,
-0.4910769463,
-0.0261767507,
-0.4772790074,
0.672010541,
0.0592654943,
-0.22018525,
-0.3601623774,
-0.1206035018,
-0.4683582187,
-0.6233702302,
-0.3990241289,
-0.4070013165,
0.4218494296,
0.2767958045,
0.6743558645,
0.4490068555,
0.4177869856,
0.3823747039,
-0.0559001788,
-0.0006769791,
-0.6309467554,
0.560588479,
-0.6114525199,
-0.2427098006,
-0.1468371153,
-0.3199131191,
0.8216301799,
0.7792288661,
-0.3276246488,
0.1494704783,
0.0446874127,
0.5805639029,
-0.7458165884,
0.0740040168,
-0.8340924978,
-0.2570739388,
-0.3132682443,
-0.5734621286,
-0.4948822558,
-0.338301748,
-0.0318149403,
-0.5790301561,
0.2575117648,
0.256041646,
0.6238189936,
0.1237472519,
-0.4410921931,
-0.0909538716,
-0.7485778928,
0.8611887693,
-0.7235668898,
0.7937090993,
0.2332392633,
0.4580795169,
-0.2648189366,
-1.0195176601,
-0.5685456395,
-0.4201930463,
0.0340843871,
0.101746574,
0.0014341592,
-0.0013902128,
0.463016808,
0.6881742477,
-0.2645660639,
-0.2110818326,
-0.4066892564,
-0.1616482586,
0.5258769989,
0.113115944,
0.0873333439,
-0.1746353656,
-0.1638592184,
-0.2815316617,
-0.6601834297,
-0.1048119664,
0.1650829464,
0.4078529477,
0.5103408098,
0.781316638,
-0.4630185664,
0.7805463076,
0.0059368545,
-0.0558511987,
0.3284106255,
-0.570581615,
0.1601494849,
-0.1797929108,
0.6091905832,
0.0856888965,
-0.1386841089,
-0.415555656,
-0.3351986408,
-0.2935366333,
0.2929714322,
-0.8538845181,
-0.0818097517,
0.0700285807,
-0.5148929954,
0.0248528905,
-0.049793493,
-0.8312919736,
-0.1512367576,
-0.25260216,
0.6013146043,
-0.4880022109,
-0.4455365241,
0.0480778702,
-0.3464559913,
0.2732868791,
0.136522606,
-0.602910161,
0.2278426141,
0.6260415316,
0.6023871899,
-0.0018895965,
-0.2600666881,
-0.9211130142,
0.1473793834,
-0.1720399708,
0.6580415368,
-0.8438178301,
-0.2139627486,
-0.0572216436,
-0.2860763073,
-0.1243508309,
-0.5783082843,
0.6163421869,
-0.9085007906,
0.395285368,
-0.4674414992,
-0.6551319361,
-0.2249333411,
0.3758607507,
-0.7748633623,
0.9889037013,
0.0975977629,
-0.8304640055,
0.3059818149,
-0.3763081133,
-0.5861129165,
0.0798852071,
-0.092529811,
-0.1827989817,
0.3123660386,
0.0967437625,
0.1139870733,
-0.7772327662,
0.4175694883,
-0.2109421492,
-0.2026571482,
-0.2010783255,
-0.178483516,
0.560742557,
0.2129220068,
-0.1844904721,
0.1422975808,
-0.7553455234,
0.2163155973,
0.185283348,
-0.6314662695,
-0.2606923878,
0.0593292601,
-0.1306452751,
0.2575340867,
0.2503325939,
-0.5420444012,
0.106548883,
-0.411434263,
0.290500015,
0.3241073191,
0.1814813167,
0.4832369685,
-0.2698573172,
0.3616382182,
-0.1343997419,
-0.1111181006,
-0.2572254539,
-0.3016915321,
-0.5355423689,
-0.0380825698,
0.4122894704,
0.3542203903,
-1.1400835514,
0.3356445432,
-0.3050307631,
-0.3445780575,
-0.5294354558,
0.275359869,
0.1754753292,
0.7023608685,
0.4436113238,
-0.1779845208,
-0.4958636165,
-0.6291934848,
-0.4246106744,
-0.1696092784,
0.0834329277,
0.2562577724,
0.2725575864,
-0.1543692797,
0.5866991878,
-0.2901899815,
0.0114366477,
-0.3807920218,
0.1066671237,
0.2430450469,
0.3475392759,
0.1511993706,
-0.994799912,
-0.2367624342,
-0.0429893695,
-0.6732198596,
-0.0317100212,
0.1545964777,
-0.0859831348,
-0.0038003835,
0.4980316162,
-0.5528850555,
0.0844449252,
0.2446576357,
-0.1915805042,
0.3974274993,
-0.3350524306,
0.3480779529,
-1.2373356819,
0.4668214321,
-0.2931737304,
-0.2746242583,
-0.563228488,
0.4380741119,
0.0479492694,
-0.0939469486,
-0.0255699567,
0.5903266668,
-0.5020085573,
-0.2300293893,
-0.4867084622,
0.332271874,
0.1089821607,
0.0878748149,
0.1014420539,
0.8221639395,
0.4936795235,
-0.5774546862,
0.3435828984,
0.1593843251,
-0.2017594874,
0.157486558,
-0.5196934938,
0.03762234,
-0.1556868851,
0.154777512,
-0.8028901815,
-0.2936769426,
-0.2774365544,
-0.3442463577,
0.3792559206,
0.2130206525,
-0.8038449287,
-0.3975009918,
-0.3072372079,
0.6262296438,
0.4740267396,
-0.7798796892,
0.9001672864,
0.169079721,
-0.1706178486,
-0.5410523415,
-0.1499664634,
0.2342363298,
-0.093540214,
-0.7015954256,
0.4113352895,
0.1060511619,
-0.3085460067,
0.0528018586,
-0.2159324437,
0.1688536853,
0.0480900034,
-0.2646690309,
0.0456582904,
-0.1761045903,
0.3902024627,
-0.1030149907,
-0.1456566751,
-0.2052102983,
-0.3055573106,
0.5755904913,
0.0720910653,
-0.3905231357,
-0.0229578521,
0.5187181234,
0.6069475412,
-0.5712348819,
0.8385269046,
0.5725831985,
-0.3137502074,
0.0282124989,
-0.8792072535,
-0.4924863279,
-0.4337485433,
0.2993163466,
-0.5484932661,
-1.0975430012,
0.4839369655,
-0.3301371038,
0.1622844785,
0.6344478726,
0.4817436635,
0.1554816216,
1.0733869076,
0.6403674483,
-0.0387267582,
0.6588525772,
0.0072829789,
0.3179662824,
-0.8724611402,
-0.2927613854,
-0.5548525453,
-0.0013632089,
-0.5619587898,
-0.4304063916,
0.2123901397,
0.3077773154,
-0.11868117,
0.3428627551,
-0.3132281601,
0.287642777,
0.7214542031,
0.0930806026,
0.5537718534,
-0.0400936268,
-0.1469124854,
0.0100917984,
-0.9675267935,
-0.1908440143,
0.9115893245,
0.0125673395,
0.8326225281,
0.2941660881,
0.8251066208,
0.0327553526,
0.1788239032,
-0.4852291048,
0.5235214829,
-0.1973892152,
-0.4543138444,
0.0186551157,
-0.7870414257,
-0.8217329979,
0.3092699051,
-0.2176764458,
-0.8246036768,
0.0975282341,
0.2396205962,
-0.2618483901,
0.2176690996,
-0.6203600168,
0.7085012197,
-0.145983845,
-0.7370845675,
-0.4340839982,
-0.572504878,
0.4893826544,
-0.0217931308,
-0.1007080302,
0.3725892305,
0.0423438773,
0.5856400728,
-0.3757201731,
0.3908093572,
-0.1344704628,
-0.1942421198,
0.392367661,
0.1437553912,
0.7285506129,
-0.098732613,
-0.432888329,
-0.2605959475,
-0.2324739695,
-0.363181442,
-0.5959040523,
0.8025712967,
-0.3683302999,
-1.1920528412,
-0.0520312563,
-0.8142658472,
-0.2308670729,
0.3749211431,
0.3018521369,
0.4197851121,
0.0829513222,
0.5019812584,
0.5812234879,
-0.3143979907,
0.1533914059,
0.218020156,
-0.3660363555,
-0.431440264,
1.0188690424,
0.1136497259,
0.4241324365,
0.576777041,
0.2315553427,
-0.6259482503,
-0.439663887,
-0.1639033854,
0.2817165256,
-0.8020278811,
-0.3292833269,
-0.8534156084,
-0.184307456,
-0.4877308309,
0.1091827601,
-0.2810340822,
-0.6705787778,
0.0669572502,
0.0342300795,
0.3514034152,
0.4265902936,
-0.1209208742,
0.0362486653,
-0.8165717125,
0.3896053433,
0.3394097388,
0.2942828536,
0.085915029,
-0.5953454375,
-0.0619819984,
-0.2357364446,
-0.2884658873,
-0.849029243,
0.0990517959,
0.2333290875,
0.7655838132,
-0.0192132704,
0.0918815136,
0.6566835642,
-0.2961437106,
0.6348446012,
-0.0334084183,
-0.8051681519,
0.5740455985,
-0.3276690841,
0.2939627767,
0.6182285547,
0.0204134919,
-0.3148291111,
-0.274087131,
-0.6715322733,
-1.170442462,
0.5271748304,
0.2195125371,
-0.0245901681,
-0.0865139142,
0.4730474353,
0.0243387576,
0.4695083499,
-0.5086655617,
0.1415169537,
-0.2946063578,
-0.0901829824,
0.0963270143,
-0.2573985159,
-0.0544611923,
-0.2140262127,
0.9091972113,
-0.2129311562,
0.2671102881,
0.0915074348,
-0.2471845597,
-0.1806760132,
0.3374499381,
0.2196127623,
0.6469337344,
-0.1275125444,
0.2021128684,
0.1159326807,
0.0267612748,
-0.0279661715,
0.4205412865,
-0.0988798663,
-0.0334857851,
0.3363288045,
0.6329681873,
0.1165477186,
-0.7355014086,
0.4021251798,
0.0434802994,
0.0063200435,
0.0434643142,
0.1617899388,
0.2263149917,
0.6412003636,
0.4752105772,
-0.1610316336,
0.3323518336,
-0.7352718115,
0.464161694,
0.5732725859,
0.1538412571,
-0.1624305099,
0.7459653616,
0.0825840384,
-0.2116409242,
0.7407618165,
-0.2442328632,
-0.678861022,
0.2974358201,
0.8943271637,
0.7406828403,
-0.1705113351,
-0.0956653506,
0.8074324727,
0.0566002652,
-0.4205721021,
0.4212650657,
-0.4348225594,
-0.6209465861,
-0.6796137094,
-0.5806312561,
-0.2152564526,
0.0656044185,
-0.6096348763,
-0.0835635662,
-0.2988330424,
-0.1364770383,
-0.2152697593,
0.0026435754,
-0.5806934237,
-0.0517510548,
-0.148610875,
1.1216398478,
-0.5729137063,
0.6735664606,
0.704385519,
-0.5278037786,
-0.6506425142,
0.3094525933,
-0.280579865,
-0.5266724229,
0.7622874975,
0.1103000194,
-0.0634328723,
0.3496112525,
-0.301900208,
-1.0794961452,
1.2394247055,
0.3157896996,
-0.6657093763,
0.0617130026,
-0.2424523383,
0.5434098244,
-0.2161907405,
0.1753600389,
0.5282233953,
0.3573527932,
0.4706630707,
-0.8439790606,
0.283379972,
-0.2885908484,
0.1672904044,
0.49826473,
-0.6610196829,
0.6809586883,
-0.361276567,
-0.2978090346,
0.2331591547,
0.7104186416,
0.5102943182,
0.1237837225,
0.4227945209,
0.7266475558,
0.8370250463,
-0.0353881121,
1.0559561253,
-0.4486102164,
0.2623445988,
1.2058156729,
-0.4599090219,
0.9946473837,
0.5960637331,
0.1691991091,
0.3864929676,
0.2206492424,
0.2173947841,
0.4986615777,
0.0005262188,
-0.506062448,
-0.5526499748,
-0.3345265985,
-0.315135777,
0.2767776847,
0.2621652484,
-0.4224638045,
-0.5532312989,
0.0832451507,
-0.2783690691,
0.2162912339,
-0.2101520002,
0.9031187296,
-0.0601243265,
-0.9856254458,
0.4862328172,
-0.1358083934,
0.4185878634,
-0.4306440949,
-0.1787685305,
-0.0828774348,
0.2782098353,
-0.0368655324,
-0.8110020757,
0.2503346801,
-0.0271596909,
-0.3182373941,
-0.157620877,
1.1781653166,
-0.4968453348,
-0.3562916815,
0.4896015227,
0.6851258278,
-0.0994202346,
-0.173492372,
-0.6128783822,
0.0216707177,
0.080878593,
-0.3679172397,
0.212568447,
0.5355389118,
-0.1082135811,
0.6887927055,
0.6321899295,
0.023142796,
0.1159425378,
0.3002232909,
1.106077075,
-0.8333716393,
-0.119370617,
-0.6172019243,
0.4076415896,
-0.184690401,
0.2126455605,
0.715033412,
0.5914324522,
0.725438714,
0.3353027701,
0.6939529181,
-0.4347967207,
0.47448349,
-0.3774214387,
0.2527794242,
-0.6962002516,
0.3319307566,
-0.0268674605,
-1.1333494186,
-0.2312363684,
0.3762772381,
-0.4746450782,
0.3686496913,
0.4799278378,
0.8102476001,
-0.1116750687,
-0.0340695679,
0.3632102311,
0.2902074456,
0.4360873699,
0.4268585742,
0.8248646855,
-0.554685533,
0.5433803797,
-0.1630215496,
-0.121313192,
-0.1214757785,
-0.7144368887,
-0.6306347847,
-0.7060127258,
-0.1160273179,
-0.4525727332,
0.0730233788,
0.8575191498,
0.4342609346,
-0.5225746632,
-0.0284616239,
-0.2195172608,
0.0263102707,
-0.1339966953,
-0.2717652321,
0.2251333743,
-0.7655326128,
-0.5046710372,
0.4686267376,
0.0902902037,
-0.3562677503,
-0.0609941706,
0.0152170267,
-0.476080507,
-0.1916044205,
0.7405212522,
0.433878243,
-0.4944721162,
-0.2542375922,
0.156037882,
0.2006418258,
0.0174920298,
0.9306085706,
-1.0131782293,
0.6429108381,
0.8351365328,
0.9869912863,
0.5614164472,
0.2551577687,
0.7555391192,
-0.8724334836,
-0.1778007299,
0.2226252109,
0.4664866924,
0.5545470119,
-0.2831646204,
0.451217711,
0.2013382614,
-0.6927000284,
-0.6755987406,
0.2798692286,
-0.5244002342,
-0.2093985081,
1.1913181543,
0.1441358626,
-0.1425537765,
-0.0053633461,
-0.1126898378,
0.457672894,
-0.4087423384,
0.7999066114,
0.451253891,
-0.0333909988,
-0.2809882462,
-0.4948255122,
0.1985554546,
0.6127670407,
-0.79347229,
0.298239857,
0.5430144668,
0.2459873408,
0.4884625375,
0.5376341343,
-0.2515219748,
0.3375910223,
-0.0179494936,
-0.0257604271,
0.130268231,
-0.2947725952,
-0.0756860897,
0.399974674,
0.3696282804,
0.0626828745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15282v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15282v2 | A Simple and Effective Framework for Strict Zero-Shot Hierarchical Classification | 2023-05-24T16:04:26 | 2023-05-26T13:57:52 | Rohan Bhambhoria, Lei Chen, Xiaodan Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have achieved strong
performance on benchmark tasks, especially in zero or few-shot settings.
However, these benchmarks often do not adequately address the challenges posed
in the real-world, such as that of hierarchical classification. In order to
address this challenge, we propose refactoring conventional tasks on
hierarchical datasets into a more indicative long-tail prediction task. We
observe LLMs are more prone to failure in these cases. To address these
limitations, we propose the use of entailment-contradiction prediction in
conjunction with LLMs, which allows for strong performance in a strict
zero-shot setting. Importantly, our method does not require any parameter
updates, a resource-intensive process and achieves strong performance across
multiple datasets. | [
0.1588018239,
-0.7583324313,
0.4766889215,
-0.0636424348,
-0.0125623429,
-0.0297290292,
-0.2046107203,
-0.6913666725,
-0.1496792436,
0.684427917,
-0.6932243109,
-0.6211422086,
-0.752206862,
0.0544597283,
-0.4626658559,
1.0630166531,
-0.3716677129,
-0.4560449719,
-0.1672410518,
-0.1277653724,
-0.3861950636,
-0.4114757776,
-0.434404552,
-0.6121498942,
0.6652821302,
0.6339033842,
0.7363119721,
1.0764437914,
0.416765064,
0.2496609986,
-0.0063190535,
0.1444867849,
-0.4781932831,
0.4489401281,
-0.0781692192,
-0.6284982562,
-0.3721038401,
-0.2543502748,
0.5679118037,
0.897384882,
-0.3363460898,
0.1421201676,
0.1617185771,
0.3962226212,
-0.8809626698,
0.3132486045,
-1.012524128,
0.2320581079,
-0.3156961799,
-0.3736529648,
-0.4883217216,
-0.0303013232,
-0.0650163665,
-0.6224576831,
0.2527328134,
0.2004183531,
1.1419484615,
0.4966454208,
-0.369045049,
0.1338646114,
-0.7920483351,
1.0685895681,
-0.7398896217,
0.2447456568,
0.4592325389,
0.5265868902,
-0.3524252772,
-0.4999033511,
-0.484697789,
-0.07338202,
0.0754784271,
0.0359873734,
-0.280490756,
0.1780267507,
0.3425646424,
0.240657568,
-0.4332259595,
0.4969068766,
-0.0580856763,
0.0261917748,
0.3275813758,
0.4371764362,
-0.0517039374,
-0.0376848727,
-0.1258741468,
0.2196461707,
-0.9278692007,
-0.1357957721,
0.1682438701,
0.7269831896,
-0.0953526497,
0.6417111754,
-0.7003139853,
0.6218239665,
0.1900369525,
-0.3669649065,
0.2917543054,
-0.0907924399,
-0.6372854114,
-0.0066445787,
0.4832226038,
0.1187092289,
0.1794179231,
-0.2732364833,
-0.3763487041,
0.3090699017,
0.0224870238,
-0.9085145593,
0.2155650109,
0.4467866719,
0.0477669314,
-0.4231688678,
-0.2540687323,
-0.6320263743,
-0.3618191183,
-0.4708651006,
0.5458325148,
-0.3055835366,
0.1191268712,
0.5257338285,
0.1775920987,
0.2337149084,
0.594999373,
-0.7339907289,
0.4935460985,
1.0093654394,
0.7404685616,
0.0056097154,
-0.4238823056,
-0.5913801193,
0.4779582024,
-0.5779560208,
0.6141146421,
-0.50135988,
0.1010876,
0.3286748528,
0.0018801281,
0.1317260563,
-0.7265677452,
0.7821524739,
-0.1470954716,
0.1221603379,
0.0909208059,
-0.4984380305,
-0.0957636386,
0.5768461227,
-0.2541864812,
0.7632834911,
0.0597842634,
-0.8983387351,
0.5283593535,
-0.1745782197,
-0.5932230949,
0.2899867892,
-0.3516794741,
-0.6489764452,
-0.0315735415,
0.0359642617,
0.675732255,
-0.3599836826,
0.5126056075,
-0.4484559298,
-0.5928475261,
-0.4209004343,
-0.3100785315,
0.6401826739,
-0.0194095727,
-0.5653086305,
0.1001266465,
-0.7720811963,
-0.0129310442,
0.175995782,
-0.1301408112,
-0.1720404327,
0.2019546032,
-0.4227527678,
0.100870207,
0.2277578712,
-0.5903493762,
0.3402267098,
-0.4150995016,
0.0597361326,
0.7556382418,
-0.1869243979,
0.3428894877,
-0.5948625803,
0.4802992046,
0.2244742215,
0.1329404712,
-0.2670892477,
-0.3344360292,
-1.0428665876,
-0.3208727241,
0.2339301407,
0.6566970348,
-0.8449867368,
0.6739405394,
-0.5099045038,
-0.4898526073,
-0.3565997183,
0.2341124564,
0.3268001676,
0.62221241,
0.3277622759,
-0.0099320682,
-0.7108764052,
-0.9487862587,
-0.0749257579,
-0.3162987828,
-0.1398700625,
0.1919399649,
0.6549808383,
-0.4081885517,
0.5870832205,
-0.4820924997,
-0.442369312,
-0.1048481017,
0.4552070796,
0.5211117864,
0.3668539822,
0.1999938935,
-0.364792645,
-0.3748913705,
0.1459422857,
-0.8630433679,
-0.131504342,
-0.1627147198,
0.0348686799,
0.2208602875,
0.4850419462,
-0.4884794354,
0.4467820525,
0.300938338,
-0.0552123748,
0.7192476392,
0.1512561738,
-0.0653518438,
-0.6975877285,
-0.2912685573,
0.2492738366,
-0.1691755801,
-0.7376700044,
0.4250488281,
-0.0708112568,
0.1072719693,
-0.3618287742,
0.4103026986,
-0.0645425692,
0.2267518789,
-0.1098812446,
-0.3120186329,
-0.3023163676,
0.4746019244,
0.1861407906,
0.2328469455,
1.1739305258,
-0.5318914652,
0.2682958543,
-0.0035394975,
-0.343036145,
0.5865709782,
-0.698251605,
-0.2339551002,
-0.4957279861,
0.3326481581,
-0.8106759191,
-0.5110951662,
0.0858656764,
-0.3034172654,
0.5994800925,
-0.2880547345,
-0.8966816068,
-0.1993675381,
-0.4888574183,
0.1850827634,
0.6013764739,
-0.5797854066,
0.4678437114,
-0.098121509,
-0.0052700974,
-0.7789967656,
-0.8610830903,
0.0034323027,
-0.2505635023,
-0.3544828892,
0.5073213577,
0.161612913,
-0.0603005327,
-0.1769272536,
-0.2787940204,
-0.1955226958,
0.0591038503,
0.4847775996,
0.3609225452,
-0.2571510971,
0.1165836006,
-0.2706874311,
-0.0354102924,
-0.2931388915,
-0.0365136787,
0.1753443629,
-0.1098239869,
-0.3623555303,
-0.4215486944,
0.0672640055,
0.7239274383,
0.1311237514,
0.6866729856,
0.2546073496,
-0.6796583533,
-0.6664830446,
-0.4973191619,
0.0015732264,
-0.5112128854,
0.3886752725,
-0.3626400232,
-0.9399579763,
0.294300139,
-0.1020013988,
0.3404865265,
0.38337183,
0.3310559094,
-0.056631498,
0.9623510838,
0.7418939471,
-0.1865857542,
0.123053208,
-0.1276471317,
0.0735663474,
-0.4213460982,
-0.3158071041,
-0.7585940957,
-0.1224209294,
-0.7737783194,
-0.4361968935,
0.1361750364,
0.246641323,
-0.8205059171,
0.4983795285,
-0.3320441842,
0.4985693693,
0.1383291185,
-0.1655557603,
0.3007803857,
0.1544659436,
-0.0150852064,
-0.0818152055,
-0.6864721775,
-0.3425961435,
0.9311566949,
0.6256850958,
1.013202548,
0.0513310023,
0.9280450344,
-0.0999438912,
0.2847077847,
-1.1469441652,
0.6229373813,
-0.4258070588,
-0.4028933644,
-0.3262238503,
-0.628393054,
-0.9640853405,
0.1832089722,
-0.1816633642,
-0.6856404543,
0.0269151144,
-0.1513043642,
-0.3294564486,
0.4166167378,
-0.3637408316,
0.6513260603,
-0.1437641978,
-0.4719448388,
0.0803200752,
-0.3818008304,
0.4724970758,
-0.2872989774,
0.2410411537,
-0.3824576139,
-0.2736715674,
0.4577655792,
-0.429462105,
1.0153217316,
0.0281153917,
-0.1128620878,
0.1881961673,
0.3883914053,
0.489290148,
-0.4074887037,
-0.3310291469,
0.2156465948,
-0.0141724832,
-0.464061141,
-0.6520779729,
0.5624685884,
-0.627622962,
-0.6100068092,
-0.613781631,
-0.4710437953,
-0.5524555445,
0.2035968304,
0.1271327138,
0.3617810905,
0.1135389283,
0.398378849,
0.4238176942,
-0.0166851077,
0.1576696932,
0.7047629952,
-0.1656016111,
0.019868806,
0.6664734483,
0.2253364772,
0.1692052186,
0.5238121748,
0.2172560841,
-0.243065685,
-0.8269853592,
-0.227091372,
0.1009177268,
-0.5793191195,
-0.5666639805,
-0.1236021221,
-0.411924392,
-0.3583741188,
-0.2259691507,
-0.2214000523,
-0.3191547394,
-0.0869304389,
0.0357432067,
-0.0145810004,
0.6192008853,
0.2561796904,
0.2194906324,
-0.4578095675,
0.4555660486,
0.3137979507,
0.7257782221,
0.0541312471,
-0.9947938919,
-0.1133512259,
-0.153990224,
-0.5970594287,
-0.402559191,
0.2634091973,
0.5447646976,
0.5030395389,
0.3606134951,
0.2115043402,
0.9656324983,
-0.9275425673,
0.5195889473,
0.4591197371,
-0.8559198976,
0.6061093807,
-0.438688755,
0.4018443823,
0.5583306551,
0.7335717678,
-0.4193103015,
-0.5826941729,
-0.516066134,
-0.8760694861,
0.6070873141,
0.2027364075,
-0.0010104356,
0.0086593144,
0.418325007,
0.1559377164,
0.1406082809,
-0.7475910187,
-0.2418121397,
0.1137824133,
-0.2321607322,
-0.0115900915,
-0.0101450905,
-0.0432551242,
-0.4707392752,
0.6067460179,
-0.2916428149,
-0.07791733,
-0.0823939368,
0.2475567609,
-0.5908679962,
0.5728523135,
0.1300072968,
0.6902084947,
-0.376514107,
0.3313144147,
0.3424969614,
0.1270675659,
0.155614391,
-0.1433816552,
-0.3868091702,
0.0347431451,
0.6723057628,
0.5381983519,
0.4657797813,
-0.6780739427,
0.5831230879,
0.4628466368,
-0.4814777374,
-0.0904552266,
-0.0516184457,
-0.146571517,
-0.0016957964,
0.248805061,
-0.0851610005,
0.1097749025,
-1.0771952868,
0.454459101,
0.3149192035,
-0.3872939646,
-0.1132567152,
0.3555367589,
-0.1408238858,
0.0891425237,
0.3508342505,
-0.2273995578,
-0.4781475961,
0.549269557,
0.651348114,
0.9672617912,
-0.274766624,
0.2281005234,
0.5305920243,
0.132208541,
-0.4954479933,
0.0871536657,
0.1412617415,
-0.8254839182,
-0.6408150792,
-0.8990789056,
-0.6860806346,
0.34512344,
-0.6035084128,
0.5516085625,
-0.8089001179,
0.1206381544,
0.3048371673,
-0.0058840499,
-0.4203922749,
0.2910815775,
0.4082057476,
0.8422188759,
-0.744184196,
0.8921698928,
0.3869774044,
-0.1753223985,
-0.5148724318,
0.097433798,
0.1922721267,
-0.6928940415,
0.7694560289,
0.2885562778,
-0.3238421977,
-0.5490114689,
-0.918627739,
-0.5223228335,
0.9534415007,
0.4061640799,
-0.7704744935,
-0.105720751,
0.2073294073,
0.7073026299,
-0.3802196681,
-0.055270005,
0.5174593329,
0.3486495614,
0.6226245165,
-1.1779373884,
0.0408260003,
0.0852053389,
-0.2089966536,
0.2255994081,
-0.4230229855,
0.8833891749,
-0.21279037,
-0.4117842615,
0.1789852083,
0.6280809045,
0.2700124681,
0.3574342132,
0.341447711,
0.7966498733,
0.6977534294,
-0.2354393601,
0.9443687797,
0.0256769396,
0.4661566913,
1.3687340021,
-0.7004847527,
1.4922101498,
0.16151537,
-0.3201502562,
0.7415009141,
0.4573381245,
-0.1342403889,
0.4254384935,
0.4651864171,
-0.1975296885,
-0.5701190829,
-0.3922403455,
-0.0840158388,
0.5336990952,
0.2529036403,
0.1194201633,
-0.556425035,
-0.6530184746,
0.0389130861,
0.172382623,
-0.6538072228,
0.5664610267,
-0.0051159016,
-0.6650708914,
0.9522239566,
0.2769691348,
1.2037227154,
-0.6480694413,
-0.1199720353,
0.116097562,
0.3958982527,
-0.5250100493,
-0.9518144131,
0.3703956008,
0.0338662602,
0.0764927119,
-0.227417618,
0.7899885774,
-0.5099067688,
-0.5363717079,
0.352008611,
0.4302267134,
0.0122480066,
-0.0686008483,
-0.7748256922,
-0.168657124,
-0.1644386053,
0.2535369992,
0.4866665304,
0.5581646562,
0.0046009007,
0.7944296002,
0.3738292456,
0.1935378164,
-0.1538074911,
0.1331582665,
0.6043242812,
-0.6914794445,
-0.3658566177,
-0.8971390128,
0.1421813965,
0.2309944779,
-0.052851934,
0.7022314668,
0.6405146718,
0.8470974565,
0.1605846882,
0.5884812474,
0.1838552803,
0.5892339349,
-0.2925736308,
0.3421544433,
-0.8352694511,
0.1261140704,
-0.1009410992,
-0.7143785954,
-0.5940364003,
0.3762401044,
-0.1556767523,
-0.0130418912,
0.7241088152,
0.6703720093,
-0.0130324401,
-0.0323417336,
0.7078192234,
0.340113014,
0.0720630959,
0.9314833283,
0.8309586048,
-0.5038225651,
0.5357303023,
-0.4320050776,
-0.2600909472,
-0.1060292199,
-1.125825882,
-0.7723518014,
-0.3032624722,
-0.6971042156,
-0.2245002538,
0.0968721882,
0.8311594725,
0.8075500727,
-0.9757090807,
-0.4261269569,
-0.0895509422,
-0.017489573,
-0.1860330701,
-0.2243770063,
0.0690629333,
-0.5112103224,
-0.6165903807,
0.2274168581,
0.4821132123,
0.1155339032,
-0.0181928258,
-0.13557522,
0.0758076385,
0.2289306223,
0.6575648189,
0.5265240669,
-0.9607872367,
-0.502640903,
-0.2354030013,
-0.1437736452,
0.0886452124,
0.5276919007,
-0.8021871448,
0.2075729519,
0.3524283767,
0.7103559375,
0.4558030963,
0.0149889849,
0.2873433232,
-0.9731637836,
0.0285942946,
0.4369170368,
0.5328811407,
0.3228614926,
-0.1678072512,
0.6271355748,
0.1907395273,
-0.3786637783,
-0.9419414401,
0.3068047762,
-1.0228648186,
-0.2737388909,
1.3782289028,
-0.2050270736,
-0.285207659,
-0.3158813119,
0.2376779467,
0.0439328775,
-0.0912685692,
0.667717576,
0.6454235315,
-0.1076190621,
-0.1289221644,
-0.6227488518,
0.2915638983,
0.4962695837,
-0.8099307418,
0.4089421332,
0.4180673957,
0.3573774397,
0.2287175357,
0.2953687906,
-0.2237310559,
0.1963762492,
0.0626903623,
-0.1205843538,
-0.0839313194,
-0.6333550811,
-0.4512541294,
0.3412189484,
0.2361297607,
-0.0143703762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15275v1 | Self-Evolution Learning for Discriminative Language Model Pretraining | 2023-05-24T16:00:54 | 2023-05-24T16:00:54 | Qihuang Zhong, Liang Ding, Juhua Liu, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Masked language modeling, widely used in discriminative language model (e.g.,
BERT) pretraining, commonly adopts a random masking strategy. However, random
masking does not consider the importance of the different words in the sentence
meaning, where some of them are more worthy to be predicted. Therefore, various
masking strategies (e.g., entity-level masking) are proposed, but most of them
require expensive prior knowledge and generally train from scratch without
reusing existing model weights. In this paper, we present Self-Evolution
learning (SE), a simple and effective token masking and learning method to
fully and wisely exploit the knowledge from data. SE focuses on learning the
informative yet under-explored tokens and adaptively regularizes the training
by introducing a novel Token-specific Label Smoothing approach. Experiments on
10 tasks show that our SE brings consistent and significant improvements
(+1.43~2.12 average scores) upon different PLMs. In-depth analyses demonstrate
that SE improves linguistic knowledge learning and generalization. | [
-0.4089859724,
-0.6996692419,
0.2368905097,
0.2150408179,
-0.5918155909,
0.2272836864,
-0.2759320736,
-0.1552079767,
0.2783251703,
0.5363602042,
-0.5961446762,
-0.5671198964,
-0.5157760382,
0.0277687497,
-0.1314676106,
0.946533978,
0.2534228563,
0.0912093595,
-0.0091039184,
-0.0694619045,
-0.591940105,
-0.5914822817,
-0.8425331116,
-0.0244322997,
0.4685765207,
0.342459023,
0.083387956,
0.786452949,
0.1460924745,
0.262640357,
0.1420653909,
0.1519781947,
-0.5162003636,
0.1523724645,
-0.1254805773,
-0.3535859585,
-0.1777882725,
-0.0604310818,
0.5497259498,
0.7876489758,
-0.2746163011,
0.1491313726,
0.0460242815,
0.5661839843,
-0.6668947339,
0.1832503229,
-1.011076808,
0.1028441191,
-0.3432449102,
-0.0000129288,
-0.3559437692,
-0.0412357636,
0.2171990126,
-0.6647503972,
0.3084714711,
0.0634319931,
0.4616326392,
0.3272047639,
-0.0941870213,
-0.3246486783,
-0.4542767704,
0.668540895,
-0.719137311,
0.5143899322,
0.4197650254,
0.2782903314,
-0.1273353547,
-0.858808279,
-0.4785775542,
-0.1060597301,
0.0607812814,
0.1614703834,
0.0670127496,
0.2095260322,
-0.0114920978,
0.1408355236,
-0.4387181997,
0.4560378194,
-0.3381296694,
-0.3038312793,
0.4927154779,
-0.2136645019,
0.2161758542,
0.0005209778,
-0.7112817168,
-0.2200090289,
-0.5873816609,
0.0224591959,
0.3901878893,
0.454064101,
0.0765492916,
-0.1815198958,
-0.0426773354,
0.6060959101,
0.1755286902,
0.1051586792,
0.5156156421,
0.083386451,
-0.1578502804,
0.088512972,
0.5670298338,
-0.2893978059,
0.1462434381,
-0.2731147707,
-0.3409584165,
-0.208202213,
0.181691438,
-0.6496524811,
-0.5370513797,
0.0828642175,
-0.3713383377,
-0.2740747333,
-0.0149448607,
-0.9093265533,
-0.2209562957,
-0.2573506832,
0.6223505735,
-0.2706825733,
-0.4117698967,
0.4399800301,
0.1128792465,
0.1349037439,
0.2374520004,
-1.0239377022,
0.396946311,
0.432320267,
0.5197400451,
-0.4367851913,
-0.2767374218,
-0.6947052479,
-0.0800797641,
-0.3678183854,
0.7023050189,
-0.4321181774,
-0.294531554,
-0.0051516653,
-0.1790857315,
-0.2746151984,
-0.4939543307,
0.4758285284,
-0.5689030886,
0.2298851758,
0.02625007,
-0.6410732269,
-0.1645404845,
-0.2011900097,
-0.6069795489,
1.221024394,
-0.0197502486,
-0.6290218234,
0.5637418032,
-0.7809850574,
-0.4107646048,
0.3480890393,
-0.1105195582,
-0.6745631695,
0.2612744272,
0.51612252,
0.5714580417,
0.312453568,
0.4322433174,
-0.3382343054,
-0.1262079775,
0.0265638251,
-0.1196246296,
0.8352556825,
0.4581128657,
-0.5401855111,
0.0204673242,
-0.9484702349,
-0.1063496321,
0.2270033658,
-0.2036602348,
-0.4379380643,
-0.014619072,
-0.3680867851,
0.3811170161,
0.1492725313,
-0.5061683059,
0.1028434336,
-0.5191857219,
0.3343448639,
1.083075285,
-0.0064396369,
0.4360380769,
-0.0545222983,
0.4395556152,
0.3403419554,
0.1629848629,
-0.2901996672,
-0.3967018723,
-1.108830452,
-0.4551066756,
0.8173191547,
0.3240896463,
-0.613763392,
0.6369624138,
-0.1135320216,
-0.3976686299,
-0.7496107817,
0.3584790528,
0.3131862283,
0.3966316283,
0.5650932193,
-0.5990617871,
-0.6141102314,
-0.6195480824,
-0.258641988,
-0.0851555169,
0.0830816478,
0.1805417836,
0.4232713282,
-0.2518932819,
1.0409582853,
-0.4502560496,
-0.3662229478,
-0.2382713556,
0.4110137522,
-0.1415614039,
0.6417404413,
0.5515906811,
-0.5496435165,
-0.3162468374,
-0.2590275109,
-0.3324777484,
-0.2749304473,
-0.3714531958,
-0.0542870089,
0.0739053935,
0.7043680549,
-0.18238765,
0.1744792759,
0.5104528666,
-0.1412103027,
0.4442231655,
-0.407278955,
-0.4730286896,
-0.9036312699,
-0.1206488609,
-0.035347987,
-0.4809700251,
-0.8682155609,
-0.0561962277,
0.0404515155,
-0.0519213974,
-0.5150362849,
0.8276746869,
-0.5228841305,
-0.0372965112,
-0.2778402865,
0.1395183504,
-0.2211551219,
0.7088458538,
0.189139232,
0.5404881835,
0.7675331235,
-0.8086265326,
-0.0604529567,
-0.0239236262,
-0.4682271779,
-0.0458692983,
-0.2238035798,
0.5830925703,
-0.3689269423,
-0.0102040758,
-1.0286527872,
0.2252086252,
0.2409475297,
-0.3444403708,
0.541633904,
-0.0300775208,
-0.2609067559,
-0.3460541368,
-0.106635116,
0.3568832874,
0.5654747486,
-0.8732392192,
0.7061522603,
0.4105394185,
-0.2760095,
-0.4652985334,
-0.3618548214,
0.0437164716,
-0.4168217778,
-0.2255771309,
0.4100294113,
-0.1868823171,
0.1876490861,
-0.221277982,
-0.1528564245,
-0.0902154967,
0.3957649171,
-0.2534193397,
-0.1213001013,
-0.1777802557,
0.4222011268,
0.1045008004,
-0.202011928,
-0.0523534119,
-0.5537334085,
0.6685785651,
0.1013111323,
-0.1172569767,
-0.2910983264,
0.0328784026,
0.0557164997,
-0.4929534197,
0.5869231224,
0.7181478739,
-0.3319021761,
-0.5729843974,
-0.7567310929,
-0.341612041,
-0.4969033897,
0.4017190039,
-0.6143593788,
-0.9294853806,
0.5627117753,
-0.3992399573,
-0.0704748407,
0.3965191543,
0.3956502378,
-0.0525016077,
0.9494172931,
0.7128841877,
-0.0985414311,
0.721462369,
0.0137860505,
0.1017136052,
-0.6031087041,
-0.1759815812,
-0.4619821608,
-0.0112758093,
-0.4599752724,
-0.3784980476,
-0.0600158945,
0.3341652453,
-0.2970588803,
0.1944556832,
-0.3926282823,
0.4439904094,
0.6275966167,
0.251426816,
0.1102144644,
0.2027819753,
-0.2793426514,
0.0071581956,
-0.7916029692,
-0.0760371014,
1.165667057,
0.5626116991,
0.8005654216,
-0.238396883,
1.0879969597,
0.3741165698,
0.1916326135,
-0.2428756952,
0.3238127232,
-0.2877681255,
-0.468067795,
-0.442737639,
-0.4793475866,
-0.9957920909,
0.2819705606,
-0.1844265312,
-0.6449768543,
0.4692924619,
0.2292174697,
-0.2597649992,
0.1145161986,
-0.8036778569,
0.8837928772,
-0.5460339189,
0.2087357938,
-0.0035698195,
-0.7656514645,
0.027076086,
-0.5741356015,
0.4007787108,
-0.0501972251,
0.0619475208,
1.1320762634,
-0.2204036564,
1.1317813396,
-0.571303606,
0.0913163647,
0.2145036757,
-0.0442109667,
0.4553601146,
-0.1665529013,
0.1396396607,
0.2111457586,
-0.270481199,
-0.5463933349,
-0.6587277651,
0.2176168114,
-0.7840491533,
-0.7446089983,
-0.3035210967,
-0.2238575667,
-0.1745358706,
0.3392772973,
0.0736346319,
0.1851873696,
-0.0984859392,
0.0547948368,
0.9343964458,
-0.2839843929,
0.366846025,
0.5440651774,
-0.2074657679,
-0.4521449804,
1.0768530369,
0.0454989895,
0.3303104639,
0.1909644008,
0.5576094985,
-0.4641510546,
-0.7401596308,
-0.2799535394,
0.291893065,
-0.6970874071,
-0.3047468364,
-0.7634763122,
-0.2247208059,
-0.5017467141,
0.0769592077,
-0.2388660312,
-0.3622300327,
-0.3561935127,
-0.236014694,
0.1053037196,
0.644993484,
-0.2465690672,
0.4855268002,
-0.3802903593,
0.1639334857,
0.6494364738,
0.4115097523,
-0.0822939649,
-0.6493475437,
-0.2099559754,
0.1377778947,
-0.1928531826,
-0.7398004532,
0.3358293772,
0.5929902196,
0.9203768969,
0.5136436224,
0.1083613709,
0.6766362786,
-0.499288708,
0.6534372568,
0.2473595738,
-1.1116428375,
0.6682026982,
-0.1185359731,
0.1523998082,
0.5703839064,
0.2299803942,
-0.3231619,
-0.3418065012,
-0.7021784186,
-0.7138302326,
0.682053566,
0.0599641949,
0.3317845762,
-0.1697150171,
0.4392386377,
0.3437880576,
0.1985422671,
-1.1011230946,
-0.3704959154,
-0.5983204246,
-0.3562075794,
-0.206120491,
-0.3524476588,
0.1920920759,
-0.3853404224,
0.7244767547,
-0.3199587762,
0.2764247954,
0.0258537307,
-0.4763157964,
0.2546600401,
0.1710551828,
0.5701254606,
0.4744242728,
-0.2120717317,
0.135724932,
0.4419799149,
-0.4981614053,
0.0084656049,
0.124917455,
0.0165040847,
-0.0436538346,
0.0965683311,
1.0247187614,
0.2596992254,
-0.4797559679,
0.6494445801,
-0.0308449548,
-0.2012485266,
-0.036726512,
0.0084425602,
-0.0796564445,
-0.0035572441,
0.4714490473,
-0.1991528422,
-0.0424346998,
-0.2794649601,
0.3734660149,
0.3010161519,
-0.3777971864,
-0.188008219,
0.5467427969,
0.2994321883,
-0.1355033815,
0.4226200283,
-0.3707254231,
-0.7222337127,
0.4499180317,
1.0050377846,
0.9219842553,
-0.6409338713,
0.359991312,
0.1308946759,
0.2021172643,
0.0277500134,
0.0646135584,
-0.2219983637,
-0.8518558741,
-0.4113332033,
-0.8597224951,
0.0237973519,
0.2694505751,
-0.4678536952,
0.3700224161,
-0.5133432746,
0.2094265521,
-0.0802448615,
-0.0590676479,
-0.8703834414,
0.4544832706,
0.2153076679,
1.0039032698,
-0.9691992998,
1.0852023363,
0.5047065616,
-0.3253156841,
-0.598623693,
-0.1040020585,
-0.4445766211,
-1.1199196577,
0.9807833433,
0.2987892032,
0.0469815806,
0.449007988,
-0.4809553325,
-0.9986689091,
0.7505276799,
0.3457926214,
-0.4844734371,
-0.0807363018,
0.2005658448,
0.469484508,
-0.7380716205,
-0.0341814309,
0.4006590247,
0.1177844629,
-0.0421740487,
-0.4874935448,
-0.108243458,
0.0076608015,
0.1800029278,
0.1484344751,
-0.4028058052,
0.6090825796,
0.0877529681,
-0.4275877476,
-0.1335784644,
0.7939401865,
-0.0696187988,
0.0498857126,
0.799481988,
0.7862794995,
0.8977903724,
0.0315702744,
0.4171742499,
-0.3125609159,
0.5041649938,
1.1579518318,
-0.1182582825,
0.6539691687,
0.1650130451,
-0.0345076434,
0.7095834613,
0.8011646867,
0.0169059746,
0.8464961648,
0.4773778319,
-0.1953172088,
-0.5566971898,
0.1964036375,
-0.2263638377,
0.5341444016,
0.4520843923,
-0.2191089392,
-0.2824649513,
0.3432202935,
-0.0694379434,
-0.1143729016,
-0.3482964933,
1.0869706869,
0.0212756917,
-0.4001812935,
0.4028649926,
-0.1681213826,
0.65426898,
-0.5635450482,
0.0025259522,
-0.3414894044,
-0.1067857891,
-0.0259052645,
-0.2919161618,
-0.0605944693,
-0.270945102,
0.0794283524,
-0.2618700564,
0.8737435341,
-0.549271524,
-0.4009516537,
0.3293049037,
0.4767967463,
0.1559640914,
0.1620081514,
-0.8985792398,
-0.1739935428,
-0.0690620914,
-0.0107470974,
0.3948806524,
0.4285230637,
0.0802366138,
0.697858572,
0.8129684329,
0.1311481446,
0.4736929238,
0.1591190845,
0.8527391553,
-0.4955340922,
-0.7517947555,
-0.7086315155,
0.4698909819,
-0.1950098127,
-0.2848563194,
0.4913544357,
0.4450528026,
1.0313367844,
-0.1040345058,
0.7069958448,
0.3686562181,
0.6121792793,
-0.7322226763,
0.5721935034,
-0.3249268234,
0.2576968372,
-0.233361274,
-0.922309339,
-0.4794341028,
0.8029593825,
-0.3299586177,
0.0959400535,
0.5034112334,
0.6008679271,
-0.0074650072,
-0.172771275,
0.362716794,
0.222992301,
0.2584312856,
0.2469493896,
0.6248455644,
-0.1589673311,
0.2947404087,
-0.2232463211,
-0.3408602476,
-0.1548980922,
-0.8559362888,
-1.1109137535,
-0.767968297,
-0.4489324391,
-0.0004022029,
0.3457879424,
0.9284778237,
0.9954940081,
-0.8556184769,
0.0041556093,
-0.3516018689,
-0.0016641617,
-0.1858419627,
-0.1362670809,
0.6047227979,
-0.9763435721,
-0.4201924205,
0.3433545232,
0.1200719699,
0.1328542382,
-0.2916730046,
-0.046585165,
-0.2797282338,
0.0872157663,
0.439665705,
0.4363048971,
-0.6566013694,
-0.4874231219,
-0.2086342126,
0.1448736489,
0.1906424612,
0.7855415344,
-1.072155118,
0.9348402619,
0.1517797709,
0.9527921081,
0.6623211503,
-0.047117617,
0.4936347306,
-1.104724884,
0.011158444,
0.1225890517,
0.3398431838,
0.3573477864,
-0.2665900588,
0.2927276492,
0.339292407,
-0.5152419806,
-0.807878077,
0.2601394951,
-0.6526121497,
-0.417381525,
0.9039655328,
-0.242326498,
-0.162170887,
-0.3458240628,
-0.0476607271,
0.2939041555,
-0.2773294151,
1.0782464743,
0.4179235995,
0.0467485264,
-0.2612341642,
-0.1326478571,
0.7601906657,
0.4800422788,
-0.8433095217,
0.0347765647,
0.0230648369,
0.5121532083,
0.0104712518,
0.7171241641,
0.0961435661,
0.1703772098,
-0.2942235172,
0.0611927211,
-0.0188425481,
-0.4741968513,
-0.5936550498,
-0.1598539501,
0.2022636384,
-0.4365222454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15273v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15273v1 | Revisiting Token Dropping Strategy in Efficient BERT Pretraining | 2023-05-24T15:59:44 | 2023-05-24T15:59:44 | Qihuang Zhong, Liang Ding, Juhua Liu, Xuebo Liu, Min Zhang, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Token dropping is a recently-proposed strategy to speed up the pretraining of
masked language models, such as BERT, by skipping the computation of a subset
of the input tokens at several middle layers. It can effectively reduce the
training time without degrading much performance on downstream tasks. However,
we empirically find that token dropping is prone to a semantic loss problem and
falls short in handling semantic-intense tasks. Motivated by this, we propose a
simple yet effective semantic-consistent learning method (ScTD) to improve the
token dropping. ScTD aims to encourage the model to learn how to preserve the
semantic information in the representation space. Extensive experiments on 12
tasks show that, with the help of our ScTD, token dropping can achieve
consistent and significant performance gains across all task types and model
sizes. More encouragingly, ScTD saves up to 57% of pretraining time and brings
up to +1.56% average improvement over the vanilla token dropping. | [
-0.3963872492,
-0.5965241194,
0.2254105657,
0.0839819163,
-0.6339488029,
0.209964186,
-0.3743520975,
-0.3699786365,
0.0976016298,
0.3715882003,
-0.9554718733,
-0.4483701289,
-0.8552548289,
-0.298435092,
-0.443472892,
1.1304849386,
0.0226534959,
0.196168527,
-0.25227952,
-0.0343152061,
-0.7722872496,
-0.6309301853,
-0.7757226825,
-0.1887142807,
0.6658471227,
0.3824017346,
0.3489461243,
0.9151875377,
0.5916141868,
0.1775393337,
-0.3266551793,
0.1484567821,
-0.6440410018,
0.0960255414,
-0.0762023106,
-0.5632102489,
0.1600540578,
0.0618088804,
0.6017785668,
0.9436612129,
-0.2936987877,
0.0500930585,
0.1018109918,
0.3481804729,
-0.888990581,
0.2332186699,
-0.8514381647,
0.1233416423,
-0.5497770309,
-0.0788126364,
-0.7056822777,
0.1137343943,
0.314815551,
-0.6827382445,
0.4175740778,
-0.1480576843,
0.975391686,
0.1136800274,
-0.2475608587,
-0.0714575797,
-0.5360028744,
0.7305494547,
-0.4808856249,
0.610347569,
0.4755128026,
-0.0515968651,
-0.1062377319,
-0.8848295212,
-0.5366923809,
-0.2176853269,
0.1286331713,
-0.0180868749,
0.0614967346,
0.3721555173,
0.3681124449,
-0.094279781,
-0.0746088997,
0.0870779231,
-0.3797501922,
-0.5824048519,
0.1419972628,
-0.056687966,
0.1846937239,
-0.125636071,
-0.6056728363,
-0.2266599536,
-0.9278154969,
0.0935174376,
0.1522419304,
0.6343794465,
0.3335624635,
0.2791666985,
-0.0255200975,
0.4381878078,
0.0828168392,
0.0604804568,
0.2205447257,
-0.2688700259,
-0.0130406125,
0.0245528314,
-0.0070763826,
0.1751789004,
-0.0089915888,
-0.3681013286,
-0.2593156695,
0.1631846726,
0.3270383477,
-0.7959635258,
-0.5087764859,
-0.0802049711,
-0.7200029492,
-0.1498188376,
-0.0443966091,
-0.0340691991,
-0.0329532027,
-0.325391531,
0.7577195168,
-0.7703005075,
-0.2380146086,
0.003222598,
-0.3476144671,
0.3556188643,
0.3781511784,
-0.8894275427,
0.5522287488,
0.8753702044,
0.7749668956,
-0.5152081847,
-0.2851247489,
-0.9892215729,
0.3139770329,
-0.3747698963,
0.5217474103,
-0.3968984187,
-0.4268777668,
0.0630008131,
-0.1411777586,
-0.3240598142,
-0.3351278901,
0.4270167947,
-0.4768614471,
-0.0108677391,
-0.5957638025,
-0.8812088966,
-0.1666131467,
0.0806180835,
-0.4734676182,
1.1697415113,
-0.1650251746,
-0.9249027967,
0.7794171572,
-0.6426906586,
-0.6763226986,
0.2008248568,
-0.0545781031,
-0.2872057259,
0.3070655763,
0.0639336631,
0.4411328137,
0.3240532279,
0.1251383126,
-0.1755141169,
-0.6270360351,
-0.2060405314,
-0.2518320978,
0.8639035821,
0.4208137393,
-0.5333076119,
-0.0448925607,
-0.7297145128,
0.1975522935,
0.0286024958,
-0.2297116965,
-0.596814096,
0.1738859564,
0.3698832393,
0.2825962305,
0.0104677966,
-0.8035852909,
0.0921499655,
-0.3405002654,
0.4397679865,
1.1854739189,
-0.3235757351,
0.3624715507,
-0.0178467166,
0.1715374887,
0.0915860832,
0.2798933983,
-0.1631722897,
-0.2676780224,
-1.099758625,
-0.8864472508,
0.6880918145,
0.2452539057,
-0.8759855032,
0.5476669669,
-0.2368010432,
-0.3734495938,
-0.4983541071,
-0.1067139655,
0.7713401318,
0.5496614575,
0.1943299472,
-0.6112715006,
-0.3501051664,
-0.7013393044,
-0.3996792436,
-0.1805655509,
0.0309122708,
-0.041232273,
0.4323545694,
-0.239555642,
1.2979964018,
-0.3453761935,
-0.2103352398,
-0.4141404927,
0.1844911277,
-0.2305483222,
0.96465379,
0.4972966909,
-0.5019423366,
-0.1277282089,
-0.3395109475,
-0.2728403807,
0.0998941585,
0.0611064099,
-0.4701011479,
0.4234633446,
0.5065166354,
-0.7996102571,
0.8573763967,
0.2354660034,
-0.1822805703,
0.4872643054,
-0.0981407166,
-0.3573972881,
-1.0399128199,
0.1389172822,
-0.6712438464,
-0.2515452802,
-0.7650085092,
-0.0677254647,
0.1700210422,
-0.0654489696,
-0.7629597783,
0.5053111315,
-0.2668788135,
-0.0289827846,
0.0834529921,
-0.0776523501,
-0.0502720848,
0.5170089006,
0.2329988182,
0.3411679268,
0.4262520373,
-0.5051066279,
-0.2977020741,
0.2830367684,
-0.2671974897,
0.2510285079,
-0.5558065772,
0.2991733253,
-0.1069123298,
0.326522857,
-1.0776667595,
0.1320386827,
0.1618924737,
-0.2486870289,
0.4163335562,
-0.1016116738,
-0.6945480108,
-0.2333699316,
-0.3800070882,
0.4146803617,
0.394040972,
-0.6218900681,
0.5704190731,
0.1410280317,
-0.0371687599,
-0.7381115556,
-0.7225340605,
0.0331564024,
0.0669735819,
-0.532299161,
0.5279473066,
-0.1068654433,
0.2605650425,
0.2059637606,
-0.5301757455,
-0.0488754436,
0.3319852948,
0.0496843569,
0.2090485692,
0.1918046474,
0.4912013113,
0.018163871,
-0.2451598197,
-0.0177835859,
-0.4453115761,
0.8367051482,
-0.0374774672,
-0.5651950836,
-0.758084476,
0.3972812593,
0.1018126979,
-0.1730790138,
1.0224581957,
0.8426622748,
-0.4009086788,
-0.1688417047,
-0.5563764572,
-0.5064695477,
-0.4732250273,
0.6672027707,
-0.5579612851,
-0.8993367553,
0.7106678486,
0.0096522393,
0.2337597162,
0.4913780689,
0.1512786001,
-0.1629807353,
0.9299222827,
1.1226735115,
0.1114346236,
0.9472638965,
-0.5744258165,
0.2349508703,
-0.5324504972,
-0.3992139995,
-0.5560450554,
-0.1216674447,
-0.4250765741,
-0.20885396,
-0.0910214931,
0.1893865317,
-0.3247327507,
0.1591376215,
-0.4905012548,
0.5969021916,
0.9235142469,
0.2542943656,
-0.0083962977,
0.0226808134,
-0.3895952404,
-0.1542216986,
-1.0103350878,
-0.0142995836,
1.0228179693,
0.2285600603,
0.4832067788,
-0.4335320294,
1.1884895563,
0.2861203849,
0.212074995,
-0.5109939575,
0.5523252487,
-0.0840207189,
-0.5550959706,
-0.3644608259,
-0.4530214369,
-0.8530071378,
-0.0250031408,
-0.1702023745,
-0.5278534293,
0.1230986789,
0.1867765039,
-0.111578621,
0.3524437547,
-0.6666924953,
0.9766158462,
-0.0510622039,
0.0012152959,
-0.3804684281,
-1.1884535551,
0.0102056116,
0.010891784,
0.004057901,
-0.1273695081,
-0.0924070328,
1.042694211,
-1.0174418688,
0.8086704612,
-0.6757788062,
0.1377420723,
0.0910551101,
0.1770349294,
0.7403572798,
-0.3913750648,
0.1667300016,
0.5042725205,
-0.0331282802,
-0.8741886616,
-0.6759926081,
0.2245239168,
-0.8912899494,
-0.2082407176,
-0.3643546104,
-0.392893672,
-0.1430837512,
0.3270595968,
0.4009027183,
0.5818744898,
0.0218347963,
0.1766530126,
0.6360598207,
0.0369685441,
0.6949614882,
0.1707250625,
0.1245359406,
-0.3782860339,
0.8193525076,
0.4081730247,
0.6465114951,
0.0654917508,
0.0676501244,
-0.5358443856,
-0.8808355331,
-0.0931512862,
0.1018930227,
-0.910251379,
-0.20303379,
-0.5684987307,
-0.4062823355,
-0.2659491301,
-0.2634502649,
-0.6288335919,
-0.6517289877,
-0.0265205782,
-0.1781205386,
0.3082197607,
0.5268517137,
-0.0976245552,
0.6451234818,
-0.7072565556,
-0.0926189274,
0.2786634862,
0.5166237354,
0.0712705702,
-0.4003747702,
-0.2440453172,
0.0239236318,
-0.0455709361,
-0.2614406049,
0.1520057321,
0.3147578835,
0.7939381003,
0.582167089,
0.2492502183,
0.9737411737,
-0.4900681376,
0.8143569827,
0.5518592596,
-1.2730259895,
0.5194655657,
-0.317944169,
0.1615922749,
0.7427705526,
0.0583959669,
-0.6516435742,
-0.3121207654,
-0.8433380127,
-1.2129685879,
0.9808516502,
0.4340201616,
0.2091495842,
-0.3929862678,
0.3631162643,
0.3332251906,
0.564109385,
-0.4557704329,
-0.3165872991,
-0.2651513219,
-0.2273752987,
0.0190004259,
-0.2177768946,
0.0435896888,
-0.3779253662,
0.6199638844,
0.0234959032,
0.4470620453,
0.0345480926,
-0.4350821674,
0.2874299586,
-0.2556556761,
0.5053097606,
0.6126825809,
-0.2025193572,
0.1668857038,
0.1768401861,
-0.6938915253,
-0.1491189003,
-0.1441536844,
-0.2527861595,
0.1852841973,
0.4298453331,
0.7762710452,
0.3741151094,
-0.6895622015,
0.7458844185,
0.0193582568,
-0.405317992,
0.0090650078,
-0.2272182852,
-0.0998176411,
-0.2512190938,
0.6198055744,
0.4399154186,
-0.0939526334,
-0.3625600338,
0.5089706779,
0.412927866,
-0.4881329536,
-0.0344644524,
0.5644606948,
0.3693783581,
-0.3203964531,
1.0609558821,
-0.0133250318,
-0.6807709932,
0.5678535104,
0.6388465762,
1.1216801405,
0.1241047755,
0.2374091446,
-0.2691290975,
0.2154195011,
-0.1022617146,
0.10473755,
-0.4387363493,
-0.6270231009,
-0.6611539125,
-0.5524740219,
-0.3131735325,
-0.2353948802,
-0.8329740167,
0.1585412025,
-0.4955566227,
-0.0895218328,
-0.2161707729,
0.257633388,
-0.8613188267,
-0.0099241864,
-0.0145790484,
0.9963883758,
-0.6733650565,
0.8337289691,
0.2742445767,
-0.2731425166,
-0.9213511944,
0.0559550673,
-0.3175400496,
-0.8375533819,
1.0003063679,
0.4532613754,
-0.1584530771,
0.0571147464,
-0.6664334536,
-1.0305278301,
0.6484941244,
0.6398122311,
-0.3719366789,
0.080294989,
-0.0085159596,
0.401035428,
-0.3554691672,
0.1379587054,
0.4370528162,
0.3798373342,
0.3444392979,
-0.8303405046,
-0.0306106191,
-0.3503623307,
0.361553371,
0.2568985224,
-0.6026927829,
0.8433833718,
-0.1493323594,
-0.3891757429,
0.200096339,
0.5852282047,
0.0798183903,
0.3801193535,
0.8441226482,
0.700525701,
0.8954722881,
-0.0937717706,
0.9039958119,
-0.3920039237,
0.3706085086,
0.6631883979,
-0.1619707197,
1.0505924225,
0.5277839303,
0.1112972498,
0.2973427176,
0.9810813665,
0.3386563361,
0.9780775309,
0.4122233987,
-0.2573427558,
-0.5534086823,
-0.0714058727,
-0.2711009681,
0.5343951583,
0.069415547,
0.1539394408,
-0.2700003088,
0.4039589763,
0.3205176294,
-0.1451279223,
-0.4073277414,
0.6904250383,
-0.2926135659,
-0.4193250835,
0.5155838132,
-0.2385875881,
0.7012125254,
-0.7210814357,
-0.0104720881,
-0.2684016824,
0.2523784637,
0.1091469899,
-0.0526678227,
0.223852396,
-0.4192162752,
-0.0653085411,
-0.4955359399,
0.7151942849,
-0.4419870079,
-0.4259510338,
0.23609218,
0.5567709804,
0.2822050154,
0.1479737312,
-0.6590141058,
0.2201919854,
-0.2060074806,
-0.0613354407,
0.4158265591,
0.4059889019,
-0.2511796951,
0.655169487,
1.0218034983,
0.0530290604,
0.3922378421,
0.0185047723,
1.183580637,
-0.6259791255,
-0.6837031245,
-0.6846053004,
0.2525064051,
-0.2191513628,
-0.2298880965,
0.7158882022,
0.4993616939,
1.1078783274,
0.0724988133,
0.6645855904,
-0.1993351877,
0.4950662553,
-0.4681886733,
0.8364523053,
-0.3574184477,
0.1791979373,
-0.4592739344,
-0.8123609424,
-0.4720878303,
0.6689258218,
0.0819158852,
0.0165543426,
0.7960374951,
0.5281847119,
0.2269178033,
-0.1106728688,
0.1120044142,
-0.0282112081,
0.444596678,
0.2146966457,
0.8629919291,
-0.3411312699,
0.6569066048,
-0.319781214,
-0.0984200984,
-0.3145281374,
-0.8828118443,
-0.8674142957,
-0.484909296,
-0.206088379,
-0.2095406801,
0.6950359344,
1.0753394365,
1.1153857708,
-0.6108546853,
0.1218692362,
-0.1968393922,
0.1248059943,
-0.5018797517,
-0.1838716567,
0.7136621475,
-0.8817219138,
-0.540964663,
-0.0973844454,
0.1136445552,
-0.2532669902,
0.0340290889,
-0.0874652117,
-0.2084222734,
0.1222786754,
0.6492858529,
0.1341036111,
-0.8043111563,
-0.8160836697,
0.0700456426,
-0.081084311,
-0.1700811833,
0.9668400288,
-0.9405145645,
0.5580592752,
0.4399953485,
0.9324035048,
0.8337663412,
-0.1282335222,
0.4714314044,
-1.1408550739,
0.4320521057,
0.1868588626,
0.0328171663,
0.0213603415,
-0.1151795983,
0.4435183406,
0.6504080296,
-0.1836276203,
-1.1581349373,
-0.0190389752,
-1.005387187,
-0.1990143359,
0.7723821998,
-0.4552753568,
-0.3865860701,
-0.2917200029,
-0.2321018577,
0.3176977932,
-0.393040359,
0.8782727718,
0.7353351712,
-0.0110063618,
0.0342870988,
-0.1412641257,
0.6904848814,
0.7565635443,
-0.2737908065,
0.241411224,
0.3847231269,
0.3500471115,
0.087463662,
0.8196114302,
0.1164992526,
0.4158950448,
0.1183207855,
0.2918791473,
-0.1824575961,
-0.5349795818,
-0.0676725134,
0.0009597696,
-0.122848548,
-0.8023383617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15269v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15269v3 | Testing the General Deductive Reasoning Capacity of Large Language Models Using OOD Examples | 2023-05-24T15:55:51 | 2023-11-03T18:45:56 | Abulhair Saparov, Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Vishakh Padmakumar, Nitish Joshi, Seyed Mehran Kazemi, Najoung Kim, He He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Given the intractably large size of the space of proofs, any model that is
capable of general deductive reasoning must generalize to proofs of greater
complexity. Recent studies have shown that large language models (LLMs) possess
some abstract deductive reasoning ability given chain-of-thought prompts.
However, they have primarily been tested on proofs using modus ponens or of a
specific size, and from the same distribution as the in-context examples. To
measure the general deductive reasoning ability of LLMs, we test on a broad set
of deduction rules and measure their ability to generalize to more complex
proofs from simpler demonstrations from multiple angles: depth-, width-, and
compositional generalization. To facilitate systematic exploration, we
construct a new synthetic and programmable reasoning dataset that enables
control over deduction rules and proof complexity. Our experiments on four LLMs
of various sizes and training objectives show that they are able to generalize
to compositional proofs. However, they have difficulty generalizing to longer
proofs, and they require explicit demonstrations to produce hypothetical
subproofs, specifically in proof by cases and proof by contradiction. | [
-0.4862101376,
-1.0812889338,
1.0722706318,
-0.0039208303,
-0.3000464141,
-0.2556796968,
-0.4035077393,
-0.4573319852,
-0.1176771894,
0.5143020153,
-0.262642622,
-0.3398844302,
-0.5117453337,
0.2997099459,
-0.4150362909,
0.5433504581,
-0.3741514385,
-0.1210306436,
-0.4291206002,
-0.1026537269,
-0.5320777297,
-0.4581798017,
-0.3316699862,
-0.1948643476,
0.2788391709,
0.3683052957,
0.5788902044,
0.546313405,
0.3907204568,
0.2899612784,
-0.0405857228,
0.3323852122,
-0.2506386638,
0.1541370004,
-0.4949751198,
-0.4486285746,
-0.5856884122,
-0.0734782964,
0.7470738888,
0.9159863591,
0.0844204202,
-0.1214163601,
-0.2890652716,
0.2873764038,
-0.6786199808,
0.1204537302,
-0.7743180394,
-0.0800563991,
0.2168540359,
0.0218443889,
-0.506485045,
-0.2941028178,
0.1308956146,
-0.4551463723,
0.0150508275,
-0.0080465823,
0.4349735975,
0.1011953577,
-0.4968687594,
-0.3624442518,
-1.092438221,
0.9705428481,
-0.7626157403,
0.3136516809,
0.4118534029,
0.4918245077,
-0.0989299566,
-0.5819516778,
-0.6664299965,
-0.6494826674,
-0.0368944742,
-0.2581017911,
-0.1239063293,
0.2169459462,
0.6884075999,
0.6444792151,
-0.5946140289,
0.0451847687,
-0.2599180341,
0.0419682935,
0.8353478312,
0.1882263869,
0.3104898632,
0.3112586141,
-0.0648711175,
-0.2360264659,
-0.7324616313,
-0.1392664015,
0.2376126498,
-0.0429529995,
0.0521059111,
0.735963285,
-0.3277944624,
0.9479810596,
-0.1002376899,
-0.1416987777,
-0.0257851016,
-0.448001951,
-0.4926767051,
0.0173878334,
0.5778726935,
0.0718237236,
0.3514586091,
-0.0208527651,
-0.2104139775,
-0.0258812737,
-0.1685842276,
-0.8033099771,
-0.0157817286,
0.3290194273,
-0.3373342156,
0.1722296178,
0.0196873508,
-0.4429045022,
-0.4883073866,
-0.5336021185,
0.4992251098,
-0.5181113482,
-0.3677233458,
0.9337502718,
-0.3438142836,
0.290504396,
0.1898966283,
-0.8973311782,
0.3072539568,
0.6863799691,
0.524451375,
0.0646968558,
-0.3410982192,
-0.4367745817,
0.0362348035,
-0.45050174,
0.6576863527,
-0.6047796011,
-0.0582748689,
0.0645298213,
-0.0828514099,
-0.1471604705,
-0.5689852238,
0.4607064426,
-0.48534742,
0.061388053,
-0.38939327,
-0.6148047447,
-0.1844415516,
0.469378531,
-0.5307906866,
0.3933022618,
0.1101452857,
-0.4908775985,
0.2297797799,
-0.5669420958,
-0.5793995857,
-0.2603735924,
-0.4283515215,
-0.0068647759,
0.4088221192,
0.0599905774,
0.4752338231,
-0.4864802361,
0.1845830083,
-0.4658904076,
-0.331912756,
0.3534269333,
-0.310144037,
0.7991637588,
-0.0161266085,
-0.4834592938,
0.0012354354,
-0.8246477842,
0.079837203,
0.3016253114,
-0.4754067957,
-0.6273168325,
0.0973894149,
-0.6407094002,
-0.0753224641,
-0.0668098927,
-0.6161735654,
0.6929075122,
-0.5939455032,
0.7704004049,
0.3593395948,
-0.0669612139,
0.3802878261,
-0.1546520144,
0.5347437263,
-0.0493397526,
-0.0446361937,
-0.2771071792,
-0.2786758244,
-0.6986680627,
-0.5577040911,
0.2275334448,
0.4527368844,
-0.4602246881,
0.7277609706,
-0.2802443504,
-0.2892974317,
-0.0310954414,
0.135824576,
0.1569986492,
0.1833313107,
0.3882025778,
0.0148697291,
-0.5448944569,
-0.8204402924,
-0.0498858094,
-0.0525905453,
-0.2982302904,
0.1985366344,
0.8202741146,
-0.5011856556,
0.9031820297,
-0.4453746974,
0.0710230693,
-0.6528314948,
-0.0909567699,
0.2809687257,
0.245255664,
0.4984318912,
-0.4858153164,
-0.0489156395,
0.0124586038,
-0.7283261418,
-0.2062833756,
-0.0647501871,
-0.096544899,
0.2439814955,
0.6390687823,
-0.6942861676,
0.3866956532,
0.437520057,
-0.6064191461,
0.7231046557,
-0.4283120334,
-0.1204812303,
-0.5554746985,
-0.2057653666,
-0.259852618,
-0.2565051913,
-0.3127673268,
0.0917759985,
-0.0554167628,
0.16318205,
-0.0889147371,
0.5587143302,
-0.5464786291,
-0.1025836244,
-0.2407828569,
0.1262269765,
0.22601147,
0.1055255011,
0.0913536474,
0.244392857,
0.6921840906,
-0.9127331972,
0.7159968019,
-0.077889666,
-0.6622425318,
0.4102550447,
-0.954259634,
0.010544179,
-0.2733883262,
0.3768585026,
-1.3071773052,
-0.3674750626,
-0.1532128155,
0.0303382576,
-0.0278099515,
0.0639018938,
-0.5695663095,
-0.4114301503,
-0.1644079089,
0.7278099656,
0.5657662153,
-0.6237665415,
0.8709532022,
0.0235109404,
0.0764072761,
-0.3186486363,
-0.8568018079,
-0.1681868732,
-0.3055161536,
-0.7704466581,
0.3618227243,
-0.1716215014,
-0.8117541075,
-0.2327976674,
0.0458719954,
0.0500856154,
0.1156787947,
0.063888669,
0.0254914705,
-0.3353937566,
0.3199764192,
0.1553802192,
0.3066089153,
0.3232457042,
-0.3600742221,
0.8499390483,
-0.39237082,
-0.8357063532,
-0.0204364192,
0.3141642511,
0.6789592505,
-0.3109489381,
0.5636193156,
0.1004623175,
-0.4290165305,
-0.5537640452,
-0.5930929184,
-0.1922170073,
-0.3780863285,
0.4123542309,
-0.5112755299,
-0.694845438,
0.6518685222,
0.0764357224,
0.1036219224,
0.427780956,
0.5711123347,
0.5549685955,
1.1017081738,
0.1930260062,
0.0788772926,
0.0216626748,
-0.6258714795,
0.2905241549,
-0.5771930218,
-0.049701795,
-0.3856723309,
-0.2145517021,
-0.2740393281,
-0.5856871009,
0.0708562881,
0.279293865,
-0.4402852058,
0.1604895741,
-0.16298002,
0.9446195364,
0.4899865687,
0.0317092426,
0.5602366924,
-0.0923744366,
-0.3002390862,
0.4183857739,
-0.3927003443,
-0.4871214032,
0.856233716,
0.4290674925,
0.8395262957,
0.204208225,
0.4236869514,
0.1297906339,
-0.0443556756,
-0.9478852749,
0.7271115184,
-0.0847048312,
-0.6516715884,
-0.5519915223,
-0.4323972166,
-0.8048933744,
0.2182212621,
0.1938706934,
-0.5076107383,
0.1617289335,
0.2027609795,
-0.4014233351,
0.4745164514,
-0.5875506997,
0.7821662426,
-0.3412182331,
-0.1459972411,
-0.317497313,
-0.2001443356,
0.5781906843,
0.2863710523,
0.1023167297,
0.0986277536,
0.1756280512,
0.3122025132,
-0.3507402539,
0.823146522,
-0.1426376849,
-0.5021307468,
0.612398386,
0.4536092579,
0.2404105961,
0.2197267413,
0.0132197132,
-0.0099880937,
0.0341302156,
-0.2140154243,
-0.4826152921,
0.6335472465,
-0.3960694969,
-0.7218236923,
-0.2298943996,
-0.6531584263,
-0.3067712188,
0.019048823,
0.1687658727,
0.439080745,
-0.3232529163,
0.4686793983,
0.8282361627,
-0.3192329407,
0.211338535,
0.2461977303,
-0.3368610144,
-0.2945817411,
0.5193956494,
-0.0503155775,
0.5389313102,
0.3394818008,
0.5928552747,
-0.4492377937,
-0.535136044,
-0.4267481267,
0.1324048489,
-0.7271228433,
-0.0928221643,
-0.3362725675,
-0.103190206,
-0.5293944478,
0.0180069171,
-0.0828822255,
-0.5644281507,
0.1478270143,
-0.207024917,
0.1458726674,
0.6991853118,
-0.1215167344,
-0.2404858768,
-0.3868841231,
0.4972878993,
0.8655014634,
0.3576962352,
0.1391528547,
-0.6110622287,
0.1404879093,
0.1848243922,
-0.3043116033,
-0.6291912198,
-0.000759367,
0.2994773984,
0.5025190115,
0.6554247141,
0.0386104807,
0.4000907242,
-0.3799074888,
0.5962402821,
-0.0470132865,
-1.0595207214,
0.5843482018,
-0.4507997632,
0.1670972556,
0.1397199929,
0.3361944854,
-0.2479110062,
-0.3101742268,
-0.3897391856,
-0.629978776,
0.2375945747,
-0.1516088694,
0.1652158052,
-0.2108442932,
0.3971246481,
0.2329681516,
-0.0892994925,
-0.678034246,
0.3452377915,
-0.070700027,
-0.1700475216,
-0.0031942327,
-0.3893785179,
-0.2886997163,
-0.3799360991,
0.3467227817,
-0.1900731325,
0.0998231322,
0.5272362828,
-0.0453402512,
0.1513087898,
0.519032836,
0.817727387,
1.0266880989,
-0.2222217619,
0.4790882766,
0.1947506219,
-0.1449498385,
0.1987013966,
0.0762686506,
-0.0372584984,
-0.1930315495,
0.6679806709,
0.7233213782,
-0.3433345854,
-1.151237011,
0.4530532658,
0.0102807237,
-0.5046533346,
-0.4746286869,
0.3193854988,
0.1621702313,
0.3714905679,
0.116440855,
-0.5909230113,
0.0608603247,
-0.9869416356,
-0.3039954007,
0.5865921974,
0.1685004383,
-0.289263308,
0.376491487,
-0.1694520712,
0.0977951363,
0.5869135857,
-0.4396509528,
-0.4260462224,
0.8433599472,
0.6998724937,
0.7610043883,
-0.0566437729,
-0.0062780711,
0.3564067483,
0.3232652545,
-0.4394251704,
0.3182801008,
-0.0163404085,
-0.8828314543,
-0.7094479799,
-0.4384214282,
-0.4127239883,
0.6085446477,
-0.3159425557,
0.1310800463,
-0.6277695298,
0.1926807463,
0.0056769727,
-0.2085439712,
-0.5325899124,
0.1151991412,
0.1861397028,
1.0521278381,
-0.7968854308,
0.4898074269,
0.6764569879,
-0.343578428,
-0.4411228895,
-0.1859502643,
-0.3646306396,
-0.6524030566,
0.9150803685,
0.3478675187,
-0.1520120203,
-0.5380883217,
-0.7043889761,
-0.5091465712,
1.0787022114,
0.5445266962,
-0.6296818852,
0.0094775083,
0.3938724101,
0.6402612329,
-0.6371681094,
0.1623233408,
0.8914781213,
0.4564627409,
0.0740631148,
-0.8956166506,
0.2515245974,
0.2231559455,
-0.09305235,
0.0207976773,
-0.213909179,
1.1742267609,
-0.4996024966,
0.0271863323,
0.1138797104,
0.4926083088,
0.6088468432,
0.361009866,
0.8355593681,
0.9052841067,
0.7466266155,
-0.0025454694,
1.2410907745,
0.096043393,
-0.079891175,
1.130500555,
-0.5701935291,
0.6529784799,
0.3071136773,
0.0260239746,
0.7948566079,
0.1490377039,
0.0857448876,
0.2695465982,
0.8653559685,
-0.2830088437,
-0.6944699883,
0.0083591603,
-0.4456661344,
0.4981183112,
0.3155237734,
-0.5705131292,
-0.0132090952,
0.1778610349,
-0.0876872316,
0.11561279,
-0.4368143082,
0.5917612314,
-0.0245858654,
-0.8537990451,
0.9718528986,
0.1686245501,
0.2917940617,
-0.4897012115,
-0.1870637238,
-0.2578099668,
0.6436403394,
-0.0027075391,
-0.7930299044,
0.30431512,
-0.0689615682,
-0.098562479,
-0.0174040645,
0.7518096566,
-0.3085158467,
-0.4460898638,
0.2669998109,
0.3266293406,
0.0481306873,
-0.4189900458,
0.1033058763,
0.0310525633,
-0.1857904047,
-0.2561142743,
0.2266031355,
0.7403298616,
-0.1133040041,
0.5781145692,
0.3208961785,
0.1849910468,
0.0159922205,
0.2302608639,
0.8500373363,
-0.5840989947,
-0.1900325119,
-1.1530029774,
0.2006890774,
-0.1350681931,
-0.0949843973,
0.6940691471,
0.5392062068,
0.9697585106,
-0.3778876364,
0.9294281602,
-0.1181246415,
0.3483132124,
-0.7246621251,
-0.0493369959,
-0.4971896112,
0.0946933851,
0.1932043731,
-0.7238973975,
-0.208749786,
0.8862002492,
-0.492159754,
-0.0342416763,
0.7470985651,
0.4723897576,
-0.3846795857,
-0.034869343,
0.3418143094,
0.5196151137,
0.4394822121,
0.9526863694,
1.0669964552,
-0.1821786463,
0.5472643971,
-0.1163952351,
-0.292260468,
-0.1339886338,
-1.0662068129,
-1.3302785158,
-0.4025160372,
-0.255215466,
-0.4341188073,
-0.3118934929,
0.7390078902,
0.5153659582,
-0.724452734,
-0.1716340184,
-0.4247154295,
0.1287029982,
-0.2930153608,
-0.2051776201,
0.2750041187,
-0.1332269162,
-0.5542137623,
0.505012095,
0.0996385589,
0.1394741088,
-0.5256555676,
-0.0213685632,
-0.0142260445,
0.392048806,
0.9386270046,
0.3252746761,
-0.6110860109,
-0.3448094726,
-0.0629128739,
0.1486610919,
-0.3738479018,
0.9197573066,
-0.5525590777,
0.1880944371,
1.0824190378,
0.6185039878,
0.1257417202,
-0.0578905158,
0.5602133274,
-0.5357874036,
0.1398485452,
0.2773544192,
0.7635003328,
0.050421536,
0.1311318576,
0.4336155355,
0.1217930689,
-0.6471710205,
-0.8023086786,
0.6554817557,
-0.9506614804,
-0.5604279041,
1.4968186617,
-0.1507036984,
-0.0169448555,
0.0049841627,
-0.3709717989,
-0.1528289616,
-0.0096719312,
0.8843124509,
0.8017323613,
-0.1640194654,
0.2895256579,
-0.4711970687,
0.3080347478,
0.2224821448,
-0.9295330644,
0.4448441565,
0.6623411179,
0.3247081041,
0.3493580222,
0.4923906028,
-0.0929968357,
0.1730516702,
-0.2532244325,
-0.1646282226,
-0.2704514861,
-0.4751767218,
-0.3415122628,
0.1068462729,
0.1291724592,
0.0267960299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15268v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15268v1 | EvEval: A Comprehensive Evaluation of Event Semantics for Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T15:55:40 | 2023-05-24T15:55:40 | Zhengwei Tao, Zhi Jin, Xiaoying Bai, Haiyan Zhao, Yanlin Feng, Jia Li, Wenpeng Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Events serve as fundamental units of occurrence within various contexts. The
processing of event semantics in textual information forms the basis of
numerous natural language processing (NLP) applications. Recent studies have
begun leveraging large language models (LLMs) to address event semantic
processing. However, the extent that LLMs can effectively tackle these
challenges remains uncertain. Furthermore, the lack of a comprehensive
evaluation framework for event semantic processing poses a significant
challenge in evaluating these capabilities. In this paper, we propose an
overarching framework for event semantic processing, encompassing
understanding, reasoning, and prediction, along with their fine-grained
aspects. To comprehensively evaluate the event semantic processing abilities of
models, we introduce a novel benchmark called EVEVAL. We collect 8 datasets
that cover all aspects of event semantic processing. Extensive experiments are
conducted on EVEVAL, leading to several noteworthy findings based on the
obtained results. | [
-0.2353254855,
-0.7772665024,
0.8073050976,
-0.0733904019,
-0.1307571679,
-0.2349130511,
-0.4587613642,
-0.8078563213,
-0.1129880026,
0.4523798823,
-0.5109183788,
-0.7683418393,
-0.4018441737,
0.0482184328,
-0.6616635919,
0.6861940622,
-0.0879847109,
-0.2989437878,
-0.412768662,
-0.2349080145,
-0.3123393059,
-0.4881949425,
-0.883580327,
-0.2566271424,
0.1500324607,
0.20720236,
0.3827157021,
0.4676054418,
0.5219743848,
0.3052145839,
-0.1254882663,
0.1910586208,
-0.2694404721,
0.4519711435,
-0.2183941901,
-0.3511010706,
-0.4983141124,
-0.0382635631,
0.9551002979,
0.8170716763,
-0.1122684255,
0.2597635388,
0.0641147196,
0.2798850834,
-0.8029620051,
0.232303977,
-0.8332061768,
0.0392699726,
-0.4436015189,
-0.1782547086,
-0.4157962501,
0.0439851247,
-0.0148447063,
-0.5050302744,
-0.0630942062,
0.1117593423,
0.5406849384,
0.1659118384,
-0.3521616161,
-0.1579197794,
-0.5816429257,
0.9379253387,
-0.5720238686,
0.5925617814,
0.3725593686,
0.2084358484,
-0.2528874278,
-0.9058648944,
-0.5966401696,
-0.1586578041,
0.2537900805,
-0.1495670378,
-0.4981517494,
0.2325953841,
0.1854123026,
0.0348382257,
-0.5453464985,
0.2723888755,
0.1291084439,
0.2071362585,
0.5978617668,
0.504784584,
0.3039723337,
-0.1774823368,
-0.4071651995,
0.0855467916,
-0.4587343335,
0.1244257912,
0.1260247529,
0.1827318668,
0.0451422408,
0.4757847488,
-0.4557125568,
0.879866302,
-0.4013461769,
-0.0552575402,
0.1904392689,
-0.4819593132,
-0.4290994108,
0.1331362575,
0.611656487,
0.480001241,
0.1519090533,
-0.4495334327,
-0.1206400096,
0.2174045742,
0.0577958785,
-0.9426727295,
0.3241370022,
0.3927955329,
-0.5426653624,
-0.3022660613,
-0.3079038262,
-0.6659806371,
-0.3387270272,
-0.4728043973,
0.2770651281,
-0.5072329044,
-0.0249219071,
0.3873054981,
-0.0288758427,
0.431886971,
0.4580137432,
-0.5359939337,
0.3661845922,
1.2550457716,
0.3987855315,
-0.2398470491,
-0.430760175,
-0.9600672722,
0.0835430473,
-0.3280382752,
0.9431065917,
-1.1645724773,
0.0296844654,
0.0311424211,
-0.0304112267,
0.1173610315,
-0.11026939,
1.1034923792,
-0.5194129944,
-0.3512811959,
-0.067305617,
-0.9736207724,
-0.253991127,
0.3360797465,
-0.3348741829,
0.7859185338,
-0.5204344392,
-0.6411501169,
0.856508553,
-0.3203500211,
-0.3726717234,
0.3907074928,
-0.3618274629,
-0.0749990121,
0.206895709,
0.3519848585,
0.4931978881,
-0.5621007681,
0.401253283,
-0.443326503,
-0.0124726174,
0.3773599863,
-0.5094383955,
0.2692470253,
-0.0323287435,
-0.1998622864,
0.0869274735,
-1.2553536892,
0.1939660311,
-0.1124582365,
-0.0312181823,
-0.6971058249,
0.4420507848,
0.1228982359,
0.1534513682,
0.2522150874,
-0.6387591958,
0.2145676762,
-0.5896731615,
0.3223308325,
0.4892405868,
-0.078941457,
0.5301965475,
0.2117181718,
0.3768927157,
-0.2265331596,
0.0743089318,
-0.5253859758,
-0.5362454653,
-0.6171417832,
-0.0453483053,
0.19488585,
0.1995474994,
-0.5648698211,
0.3677610755,
-0.1948912293,
-0.1667577028,
-0.3350787461,
-0.0824578181,
0.2237066627,
0.2113987207,
0.2154853642,
0.1713556051,
-0.765761137,
-0.6375542879,
-0.4547446072,
-0.3677205443,
0.0199536644,
-0.0104859332,
0.4060148597,
-0.2304762602,
0.8959267139,
-0.0819584429,
-0.2372564077,
-0.2325378954,
0.509128511,
0.0561571233,
0.1532846242,
0.4758640528,
-0.6579371691,
0.2061024755,
0.223987028,
-0.6007028818,
-0.2514347136,
-0.1309009939,
-0.0730582476,
0.3576306105,
0.7202170491,
-0.1953050494,
0.6715124846,
0.5705043674,
-0.8158449531,
0.2630751431,
-0.0094438717,
0.3841311932,
-0.6283466816,
-0.0616478324,
-0.4048555493,
-0.5313711762,
-0.4342161417,
0.1845327616,
-0.0301420782,
0.2744452953,
-0.3480440974,
0.8150026202,
-0.0734346956,
-0.3181220293,
-0.4331179857,
0.2259818763,
0.1789652407,
-0.0388192423,
0.2631492019,
0.3070036769,
0.3446197212,
-0.6041212678,
0.5522566438,
0.2582356632,
-0.6644997597,
0.827884376,
-0.6200096607,
-0.1528676003,
-0.1488295645,
0.1088026837,
-0.7289189696,
0.0088448739,
-0.3443181217,
-0.5357895494,
-0.0466826335,
-0.1768432558,
-0.6845094562,
-0.1355255991,
-0.0891666189,
0.3756796122,
0.2212932259,
-0.4746043086,
0.9079931378,
0.4244513512,
-0.0872118473,
-0.4192105234,
-0.6441499591,
0.4006356299,
-0.1481957436,
-0.8952255845,
0.2352401912,
0.1801903099,
-0.5196791291,
0.2459714413,
0.0757487714,
-0.0069861435,
0.0343612991,
0.3656820357,
-0.0134927686,
-0.3192697167,
0.3536473811,
-0.2262794226,
-0.3141335845,
0.1104899123,
-0.5589624047,
0.4908553362,
-0.4401001334,
-0.6376628876,
-0.2720548809,
0.3156568408,
0.3810513616,
-0.3743465543,
0.9285899401,
0.6990504861,
-0.7295480371,
-0.238689065,
-0.7150421143,
0.0214781929,
-0.3168002963,
0.5310655832,
-0.4571276903,
-0.8728683591,
0.6940397024,
0.1285876632,
0.1566595286,
0.7484338284,
0.5877770185,
0.0084475344,
1.1220960617,
0.4302508235,
0.2018273324,
0.1431235522,
0.1784512252,
-0.1100952923,
-0.8364440203,
-0.234229058,
-0.7560508847,
-0.1314154118,
-0.4617445171,
-0.6598690152,
0.1555150449,
0.1183863804,
-0.301207006,
0.2197664827,
0.0126086231,
0.4383743107,
0.2257275283,
-0.4547557235,
0.689509809,
-0.2854989767,
-0.0597426705,
-0.2605111301,
-0.5715487003,
-0.6790821552,
0.9115943313,
0.3302670419,
0.8010408282,
-0.1050742269,
0.5017597675,
0.1296206564,
-0.1324402392,
-0.4926207364,
0.492194891,
-0.1907815486,
-0.5328727961,
-0.4932471216,
-0.388554126,
-1.1429454088,
0.2387518287,
-0.3123479486,
-1.2073584795,
0.3350734115,
-0.3261555433,
-0.3517836034,
0.4168286026,
-0.1727909148,
0.9064791799,
-0.1837955713,
-0.2961812317,
-0.4044371545,
-0.249731198,
0.1181669235,
-0.1451036483,
0.5480880737,
-0.5651510358,
-0.1493806094,
0.8014093041,
-0.2801836431,
0.6207996607,
0.2798454762,
0.0453901179,
0.4215464294,
0.1719720364,
0.6901402473,
0.3330997229,
-0.2859899104,
0.0831190273,
0.3834685087,
-0.0205566939,
-0.4421466589,
0.6728730202,
-0.5249875188,
0.1595867425,
-0.3915109038,
-0.2003850192,
-0.2155386508,
-0.1896815747,
0.0915263444,
0.7927769423,
-0.5920289159,
0.2686930299,
0.3882004321,
-0.4240564704,
0.5748859048,
0.7715528607,
-0.6096936464,
-0.0851528719,
0.5327143073,
-0.0273023564,
0.0332710147,
0.4297421277,
-0.0639215186,
-0.2192654908,
-0.4506155252,
-0.4339468777,
-0.277266264,
-0.9793688655,
-0.3163478971,
-1.0335495472,
-0.0787180066,
-0.0852283612,
-0.2367543876,
-0.6410417557,
-0.2921633422,
-0.0514835715,
-0.0442586765,
0.4104774594,
0.5944139361,
0.0932461172,
-0.0185731612,
-0.9768724442,
0.3093536198,
0.3003283143,
0.5463116765,
-0.0408741087,
-0.3832967281,
0.1567220241,
-0.2104859054,
0.0637740567,
-0.5967187881,
0.3773024976,
0.4940810204,
0.7512168288,
0.270247519,
0.1723310798,
0.5363523364,
-0.7249701619,
0.7364386916,
0.0206356104,
-1.0988394022,
0.7553075552,
-0.1939038485,
0.1960906237,
0.6371756792,
-0.1833142191,
-0.7721116543,
-0.3544011116,
-0.9781823158,
-1.0956242085,
0.7060399652,
0.4744816422,
-0.1339507401,
-0.1965593398,
0.1979987621,
0.1404991597,
0.2606374323,
-0.4695727825,
0.0362685286,
0.5812494159,
0.0628674701,
-0.069225736,
-0.4636457264,
0.1262502372,
-0.1316114813,
0.4747375846,
-0.020462269,
0.0297788139,
-0.0483222194,
-0.3298754692,
-0.1631579995,
0.4826616943,
0.1981651783,
0.843626678,
-0.1798654944,
0.1505589187,
0.6523197889,
-0.1173083484,
-0.1495054215,
0.3635040224,
0.0173552521,
0.0080526406,
0.8960259557,
0.9570159912,
0.4960221648,
-0.8243504763,
0.6420948505,
-0.3419151008,
0.3383761644,
-0.3706761897,
-0.1269370466,
-0.0412327424,
0.5216340423,
0.3463332951,
-0.2408223152,
0.546636343,
-0.5989859104,
0.4843218327,
0.3120614588,
-0.4494789243,
-0.2800177634,
0.6684882045,
0.2954706848,
0.1638596505,
0.4606898129,
-0.5661244988,
-0.4184928834,
0.76116395,
0.2540806532,
0.8690471649,
-0.0741114691,
-0.101279594,
0.3672260344,
0.54263556,
0.2065422833,
0.2972581983,
0.1374639571,
-0.7513914108,
-1.0545525551,
-1.4712632895,
-0.3223938644,
0.1814800352,
-0.5437033176,
0.465064466,
0.0946320817,
-0.0384887233,
0.305114001,
-0.259724617,
-1.0656840801,
0.1865498126,
0.7451930046,
0.9241562486,
-0.7002058625,
0.4825539291,
0.844042778,
-0.1706722826,
-0.4623708725,
-0.2302167863,
0.0031265221,
-0.6876305938,
0.7257580161,
0.0755126402,
0.0619876124,
-0.286480397,
-0.2434799671,
-0.8300151229,
0.4751212001,
0.1509018093,
-0.7616496682,
0.1962394863,
0.3022249043,
0.6103861928,
-0.4968596697,
0.4751962423,
1.0217139721,
0.6717672944,
0.2174691409,
-0.9457075596,
-0.1926901489,
0.026115302,
0.0925592557,
0.2476556897,
-0.035229221,
0.5384752154,
0.0908453539,
-0.1202864721,
0.0101676704,
0.9031691551,
0.1066901833,
0.5171747804,
0.3832700551,
0.6481144428,
0.7298541665,
-0.2672861516,
1.22342062,
-0.2107066512,
0.3651542664,
1.2160146236,
-0.3853684962,
0.989310503,
-0.0446665995,
-0.4073251486,
0.1536800265,
0.4143153727,
0.4976428747,
0.2036318481,
0.0853728652,
-0.1994429529,
-0.7630966306,
-0.2123247087,
-0.3200159073,
0.9968408942,
0.6783196926,
-0.1472147554,
-0.6719811559,
0.3619709313,
-0.1191645488,
-0.0397406481,
-0.6163370013,
0.8821578026,
0.1758507937,
-0.475073278,
0.1191648245,
0.1534145325,
0.4052567482,
-0.4625325799,
-0.066248253,
0.2074345499,
0.3863142431,
-0.1046475843,
-1.0757668018,
0.5079939365,
0.1226399541,
-0.0295940693,
0.0845328867,
0.8402606845,
-0.3437856734,
-0.6355398893,
0.5934977531,
0.2333754301,
0.1457674652,
-0.249351263,
-0.409206599,
0.5073080659,
-0.3516519368,
-0.4582534432,
0.1740245223,
0.858915329,
-0.1884527653,
0.3861908615,
0.4249453247,
0.0579559691,
-0.0058772271,
0.3711660206,
0.5306418538,
-0.6341962218,
-0.5524532795,
-1.042806983,
0.4816443026,
-0.1492261589,
-0.4253875613,
0.442234695,
0.4378965795,
0.5809249878,
0.5406295061,
0.7324023843,
-0.0154586658,
0.438070327,
-0.5709614754,
0.246534273,
-0.6073557138,
0.2155597359,
-0.3687932193,
-0.9784888625,
-0.2556739151,
0.595661521,
-0.4975366592,
-0.1388198584,
0.5103931427,
0.0246973019,
0.0841938704,
0.3993759453,
0.5498719811,
0.2921760082,
0.3183652759,
0.5398269296,
1.1448833942,
-0.3825440407,
0.3295546472,
0.2083584964,
-0.1728992313,
-0.4033031166,
-1.2322230339,
-0.8150484562,
-0.9211070538,
-0.3404536247,
-0.2265466452,
0.3364343941,
1.1168930531,
0.5093563199,
-0.8822784424,
0.1788999885,
0.0847353488,
-0.13859047,
-0.0503429323,
-0.1183377281,
0.4155244231,
-0.781239748,
-0.7903782129,
0.4929902852,
0.594350636,
-0.3909669816,
0.0662241131,
0.111738801,
-0.0698691756,
0.1591379046,
0.8159372211,
-0.00035334,
-0.6407192349,
-0.419605583,
-0.3225423992,
-0.1341395527,
-0.2193553448,
0.4783017337,
-0.9099347591,
0.4766969979,
0.6369425058,
0.8546248078,
0.6138384342,
-0.2731833458,
0.6514866352,
-0.6904139519,
0.3743669987,
0.3486683667,
0.6367728114,
0.1288740486,
-0.1363604218,
0.6128820777,
-0.1381098926,
-0.6091407537,
-0.810941577,
0.0909846202,
-0.855102241,
-0.2537316382,
1.4547907114,
0.011089948,
-0.1689126492,
-0.0987658054,
0.1491602808,
0.0793452039,
-0.0837351903,
0.1274885237,
0.7481678724,
-0.0787062794,
0.0358242914,
-0.9026774168,
0.4686532915,
0.2429279387,
-0.8823673129,
0.1509505361,
0.488001436,
-0.0399799682,
0.0075175641,
0.292336762,
-0.0831577629,
0.221701771,
-0.0466294624,
0.3782739937,
0.1425939798,
-0.5031206012,
-0.3170460761,
0.1802597046,
0.0976315513,
-0.0069895084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15265v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15265v2 | Winner-Take-All Column Row Sampling for Memory Efficient Adaptation of Language Model | 2023-05-24T15:52:08 | 2023-12-09T17:32:13 | Zirui Liu, Guanchu Wang, Shaochen Zhong, Zhaozhuo Xu, Daochen Zha, Ruixiang Tang, Zhimeng Jiang, Kaixiong Zhou, Vipin Chaudhary, Shuai Xu, Xia Hu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | With the rapid growth in model size, fine-tuning the large pre-trained
language model has become increasingly difficult due to its extensive memory
usage. Previous works usually focus on reducing the number of trainable
parameters in the network. While the model parameters do contribute to memory
usage, the primary memory bottleneck during training arises from storing
feature maps, also known as activations, as they are crucial for gradient
calculation. Notably, neural networks are usually trained using stochastic
gradient descent. We argue that in stochastic optimization, models can handle
noisy gradients as long as the gradient estimator is unbiased with reasonable
variance. Following this motivation, we propose a new family of unbiased
estimators called WTA-CRS, for matrix production with reduced variance, which
only requires storing the sub-sampled activations for calculating the gradient.
Our work provides both theoretical and experimental evidence that, in the
context of tuning transformers, our proposed estimators exhibit lower variance
compared to existing ones. By replacing the linear operation with our
approximated one in transformers, we can achieve up to 2.7$\times$ peak memory
reduction with almost no accuracy drop and enables up to $6.4\times$ larger
batch size. Under the same hardware, WTA-CRS enables better down-streaming task
performance by applying larger models and/or faster training speed with larger
batch sizes. | [
-0.4726687074,
-0.4209940732,
0.1704244912,
0.2645043433,
-0.2770217657,
-0.2645750046,
-0.5580485463,
0.0178412367,
-0.0814143568,
0.346673876,
-0.4787105024,
-0.3874177337,
-0.5629588962,
-0.248737663,
-0.5504326224,
0.9914204478,
-0.0617394485,
0.2362089753,
-0.0040953783,
-0.1663873196,
-0.4441576004,
-0.0239600129,
-0.5854046941,
-0.4162899554,
0.6051895022,
0.3434685171,
0.547062993,
0.6686513424,
0.4490796924,
0.3153366745,
0.048422914,
0.0712481141,
-0.5138911009,
0.082083635,
0.0620752685,
-0.5905214548,
-0.1903994083,
-0.0505910031,
0.555801332,
0.7514070868,
-0.5965029597,
0.344327569,
0.0323273167,
0.6793479919,
-0.962022841,
0.0189697389,
-0.7268519402,
0.5309624672,
-0.1273928434,
-0.4559221268,
-0.6130034328,
-0.287078321,
0.1023832262,
-0.6119503379,
0.3913157284,
-0.0910949409,
0.7023037672,
0.4138389826,
-0.0633870065,
0.1962407827,
-1.0397197008,
1.0504227877,
-0.4526636899,
0.3522892296,
0.2829795778,
0.3393719196,
-0.2944002748,
-0.6575065255,
-0.4189205766,
-0.0670780614,
0.2769649327,
0.3313510418,
-0.5418403149,
0.0774348527,
0.1467479169,
0.3052793145,
-0.3656010032,
0.3098894954,
-0.3343217671,
-0.127340436,
0.3531048298,
-0.0335560143,
-0.0172842294,
0.3013189435,
-0.4194493592,
-0.1103703827,
-0.4484566748,
-0.002865484,
0.252956301,
0.4516669214,
0.0134879164,
0.2390428782,
-0.0490368977,
0.6938787103,
0.1383121908,
-0.003953476,
0.2505672574,
-0.1872424632,
-0.5721008778,
-0.3328975439,
0.5667039752,
0.1208408028,
0.3878743052,
-0.3328211308,
-0.1070535332,
0.0300545432,
0.4236869812,
-0.775388658,
-0.4956158102,
-0.0706131458,
-0.7604504824,
-0.3414478302,
-0.2269223034,
-1.0403032303,
-0.1282438785,
-0.3318711519,
0.3711784184,
-0.1179033592,
-0.119872652,
0.0381640382,
-0.2263955027,
0.1002624556,
0.3020940721,
-0.9302284122,
0.334803164,
0.0718788728,
0.5918315053,
-0.281401217,
-0.2158515155,
-0.8168798685,
-0.1774522215,
-0.6097889543,
0.7380904555,
-0.6591190696,
-0.5146504641,
0.1630850285,
-0.337706238,
-0.2073578537,
-0.6765708923,
0.4638974965,
-0.5929009914,
0.0678896904,
-0.4035693109,
-0.1524758041,
0.1997157484,
-0.2174188048,
-0.4910019636,
1.423730135,
0.3082797527,
-0.4588018358,
0.7045640349,
-0.5279954672,
-0.3630917072,
-0.402189672,
0.0695712268,
-0.6039956212,
0.3692518175,
0.2055358291,
0.0743146166,
-0.4603890479,
-0.1731880307,
-0.3776458204,
-0.5549200773,
0.2654877603,
-0.4857465625,
0.6007922888,
0.4024622738,
-0.3418186009,
0.3752561808,
-0.8160725832,
0.0715808496,
-0.2484409958,
-0.706268549,
0.0460090637,
0.1218930185,
0.1661301702,
0.2077080309,
-0.1385439932,
-0.4106568098,
0.1920562834,
-0.0023901374,
0.2174117267,
0.7535045743,
-0.2680903077,
0.8552388549,
-0.1447270066,
0.629799068,
0.3895024061,
0.2734486759,
0.1420735866,
-0.1433779597,
-1.2052913904,
-0.5702295303,
0.7498668432,
0.3204323649,
-0.6447139382,
0.3896149397,
-0.3263422251,
-0.6265954971,
-0.6343604922,
0.3105146885,
0.2939747572,
0.4611827135,
0.5966686606,
-0.3510074914,
-0.6188982129,
-1.0364146233,
-0.1569661349,
0.073829487,
-0.4546133876,
0.32349208,
0.286527127,
0.0416948535,
0.7327585816,
-0.3161843121,
-0.3662922382,
-0.3627521098,
0.4008851647,
0.010651608,
0.4782458842,
0.6885343194,
-0.401828438,
-0.2874022722,
-0.1524813324,
-0.2490638345,
-0.2042808533,
-0.1579818428,
-0.2819479108,
0.292103827,
0.3505649567,
-0.7570871115,
0.5991268158,
0.3771533072,
-0.0051631983,
0.3022413552,
-0.3120147586,
-0.0960111022,
-0.8955490589,
0.0319208577,
0.1222334728,
-0.0464259721,
-0.5870786905,
-0.2501663864,
-0.0062490748,
0.0854541287,
-0.2121791244,
0.0609010607,
-0.6479441524,
-0.4556574523,
-0.377227366,
0.1605934799,
-0.1855978221,
0.7011658549,
-0.0776435882,
0.8958414793,
0.5996186137,
-0.6845603585,
-0.0166047662,
0.2841886878,
-0.5429769754,
0.2681061327,
-0.2730782628,
0.0281123482,
-0.3777385056,
0.2757765055,
-0.9068405032,
0.3604763448,
-0.0717953146,
-0.4697323442,
0.5327051878,
0.0301583949,
-0.0977899209,
-0.4562753737,
-0.1246548072,
0.0579937175,
0.867487967,
-0.5921083093,
0.7002162337,
0.4896766245,
0.2367441058,
-0.871663928,
-0.783973515,
-0.1200786829,
-0.1723056734,
-0.1394073963,
0.3619214892,
0.2075778842,
0.0453405194,
-0.10715729,
-0.2821986973,
-0.119895421,
0.0444692783,
-0.1533019394,
0.2543746829,
-0.3772439361,
0.1911254525,
-0.2595148385,
-0.2810528278,
-0.1916303486,
-0.4640984237,
0.6584399343,
0.1925227344,
-0.1328317225,
-0.3482653797,
0.3279672861,
0.4406583607,
-0.2635273635,
0.6715939045,
0.9101153016,
-0.086758174,
-0.6647632718,
-0.3646545112,
-0.1554146111,
-0.4624880552,
0.7053633332,
-0.2385283113,
-0.6368184686,
0.7558174133,
-0.0334545746,
-0.0386836268,
0.2787331641,
0.6911420226,
-0.1022009924,
0.7940010428,
0.4185513556,
-0.4288904965,
0.6454057097,
-0.1518565714,
0.3370405138,
-0.7906562686,
0.1212443635,
-0.8904566169,
-0.8453344107,
-0.6395339966,
-0.6502556801,
0.1616391391,
0.0643504262,
-0.2628559172,
0.1426815093,
-0.3764927387,
0.2442311794,
0.909286797,
0.160457477,
-0.1642723531,
0.1912029684,
-0.0143879512,
-0.1295915395,
-0.8644630313,
0.0013106618,
1.0112870932,
0.0628244281,
0.8256092668,
-0.1603715569,
0.1826258302,
0.1795138866,
0.4075383246,
-0.5764285326,
0.4794998765,
-0.1714473367,
-0.4038374722,
-0.30795452,
-0.3685043156,
-0.9176848531,
0.2748473287,
-0.4330330789,
-0.8887130618,
0.4922605157,
0.2755004466,
-0.2529321313,
0.6039610505,
-0.294693172,
0.6472098231,
0.3678626418,
-0.3826547265,
-0.1851627231,
-0.3745038211,
0.0812031403,
0.0281036366,
-0.0965442806,
0.186018303,
0.1737244129,
0.5974968076,
-0.4553582072,
0.5980845094,
-0.5670173168,
0.2455152273,
0.4620206654,
0.0047904616,
0.7298865914,
-0.4868857265,
-0.165667057,
0.165815115,
-0.4459967017,
-0.5383952856,
-0.7755932212,
0.4581959844,
-0.8618856072,
-0.511533916,
-0.1107409671,
-0.724750638,
-0.3038222492,
-0.0757018253,
0.227916494,
0.3259489238,
0.0004762427,
0.5621043444,
0.492682755,
-0.2164300531,
0.8684708476,
0.308062762,
0.0275117531,
-0.0956677049,
0.6724435091,
0.2035674602,
0.1906187236,
0.3313038051,
0.0878587514,
-0.2002617419,
-1.0476287603,
-0.6365578771,
-0.4149933755,
-0.518845439,
-0.4031226635,
-0.4837821126,
-0.0711947307,
0.0585129447,
-0.0707034022,
-0.6404644251,
-0.3544388413,
-0.3831803203,
-0.248367697,
0.342980653,
0.2245267034,
-0.1689241976,
0.5156216025,
-0.5919071436,
0.0115705859,
0.318349272,
0.342633456,
0.1838229448,
-0.7451575994,
-0.3952328563,
-0.0439335108,
-0.2595635056,
-0.7088271379,
0.5126191974,
0.3657101095,
0.557405293,
0.3997654915,
-0.0427272059,
1.0059876442,
-0.5341964364,
0.6488337517,
0.1670924723,
-0.8906669617,
0.0875784308,
-0.5278779268,
0.091550447,
0.7307674885,
-0.0341765843,
-0.2084041238,
0.0029953043,
-0.1992751807,
-0.753886342,
0.7040403485,
0.2934093475,
0.2242974937,
0.007839581,
0.3853043914,
-0.0272036493,
0.3069550991,
-0.3933957517,
-0.398063004,
-0.1216770113,
-0.2988136113,
0.1775285602,
-0.1656769365,
-0.0304853935,
-0.3211829066,
0.7028071284,
-0.1147963107,
0.6261879206,
-0.018230442,
-0.0194665994,
-0.4250024259,
0.2608271837,
0.5574067235,
0.5779001713,
-0.0850692689,
0.0016436497,
0.5418779254,
-0.4825406671,
-0.045388557,
-0.1031320468,
-0.3885998428,
0.0501528569,
-0.1400809288,
1.0331166983,
0.5790128708,
-0.3585389853,
0.4857335389,
-0.0596003942,
-0.23622787,
-0.3840870559,
0.1501416713,
0.1581270546,
0.2586627901,
0.4875767827,
0.5986145735,
0.0551176257,
-0.282189846,
0.337213695,
0.6147198677,
-0.6560271382,
-0.1509217322,
0.6846445799,
0.1028337404,
-0.3420059681,
0.6196483374,
0.0263650566,
-0.1651424468,
0.5520605445,
0.7146071792,
0.8568044305,
-0.3368684053,
0.2010740936,
0.3202116191,
0.1743411571,
-0.1186364293,
0.3019447029,
-0.1371852756,
-0.9309133291,
-0.3745999932,
-0.8847355247,
-0.0798342153,
0.1372382343,
-1.0110862255,
0.1321713477,
-0.2925557494,
-0.2898148596,
0.0140257189,
-0.198899433,
-0.8534163237,
0.2836024165,
-0.0912617519,
0.9717638493,
-0.7041610479,
1.085168004,
0.1750850827,
-0.3020226359,
-0.5789828897,
-0.2539249361,
-0.2835379541,
-0.7455916405,
0.7300502658,
-0.2980311215,
0.0133545464,
0.1187005639,
-0.2654114664,
-0.9336804152,
0.9685975909,
0.331169486,
-0.4804554284,
0.0987015292,
0.0311631747,
0.4671061039,
-0.5489385724,
0.4073441327,
0.8181343675,
0.5173737407,
0.0184715819,
-0.7138405442,
-0.1713957787,
-0.3207178712,
0.3511874676,
0.2946017981,
-0.6441880465,
0.9704589844,
-0.1171529144,
-0.0858338997,
0.0854819492,
0.8029716015,
0.1982169151,
-0.1208921745,
0.6067506671,
0.6223273277,
0.7704647779,
-0.240367204,
1.0627678633,
-0.1826619953,
0.215549618,
0.9702177048,
-0.178427726,
0.9291666746,
0.6463486552,
-0.5000950098,
0.485838294,
0.6408882737,
-0.2454284579,
0.6304990053,
0.5239692926,
-0.1718412936,
-0.435376972,
0.0707204267,
-0.2040006369,
0.6824323535,
0.015622261,
-0.5922814608,
-0.1923349053,
-0.1588802785,
-0.0123929204,
-0.0460688919,
-0.3489006162,
0.5754485726,
-0.1494822502,
-0.6390847564,
0.4568320811,
-0.0685499161,
0.6090312004,
-0.5432158709,
0.2248021066,
-0.2439050674,
0.3794947267,
0.0374915525,
-0.0380815752,
0.0828763619,
-0.2199513465,
-0.3334730864,
-0.0812698305,
0.6568233967,
-0.5519581437,
-0.642783761,
0.3406322002,
0.4212775826,
0.011223156,
0.2080837786,
-0.3677669764,
-0.0461006872,
-0.024886908,
-0.6828129888,
0.6001366973,
0.0717447251,
0.1581066102,
0.5763444304,
0.7600752115,
0.348461777,
0.183053568,
0.1866353154,
0.8317928314,
-0.5039236546,
-0.426640749,
-0.6397805214,
0.5940671563,
-0.0867024511,
-0.4958784878,
0.604595542,
0.5321089625,
0.6416187286,
-0.2864735126,
0.8819931149,
0.3204059601,
0.2808123827,
-0.4621855021,
0.7750381231,
-0.5280998349,
0.0692285374,
-0.1694423109,
-1.0179940462,
-0.2122030109,
0.7638933659,
-0.1583139747,
0.4551502168,
0.568579495,
0.8111006618,
-0.0002765112,
0.2048620284,
0.3174099922,
0.151351288,
0.0223728232,
0.4995068014,
0.3851749301,
-0.6354979277,
0.6435094476,
-0.0261985809,
-0.1939193606,
-0.2201433927,
-0.7532722354,
-0.7567053437,
-0.4508618712,
-0.1987185925,
-0.2705931962,
-0.0340134911,
0.8306877613,
0.9293850064,
-1.07682693,
-0.0887375027,
-0.1756344885,
-0.2144443542,
-0.3893343508,
-0.1598332226,
0.5046239495,
-0.5802938938,
-0.9629446864,
0.4138883948,
0.2889333069,
-0.1914679408,
-0.3484646082,
0.0268470962,
-0.1551494747,
0.1914188713,
0.3899447918,
0.2139100879,
-0.3957363963,
-0.5905554891,
0.1049630493,
0.0830434114,
0.4085280001,
0.902539134,
-0.7066782713,
0.40214926,
0.5412761569,
0.6736395955,
0.8866990805,
-0.0805070847,
0.6812170744,
-0.7596180439,
0.4634512067,
0.0856728628,
0.5189647079,
0.1903042048,
-0.0541918576,
0.4019845128,
0.0627887025,
-0.5806651711,
-0.8485577703,
0.0938021988,
-0.9321303368,
-0.128963843,
0.9700870514,
0.0120571554,
-0.4478814006,
-0.2335973084,
0.0970856473,
0.4554694295,
-0.3903606236,
1.0921571255,
0.4681945443,
-0.0258957427,
-0.2182977349,
-0.6609973907,
0.7963950038,
0.6051734686,
-0.4785743058,
0.2634245157,
0.2738763988,
0.1681540012,
0.0497621521,
0.673545599,
-0.1053885147,
0.3024338484,
0.3042793572,
0.4063968062,
-0.0158599392,
-0.2454905212,
-0.1426515728,
0.3396268785,
-0.1844657362,
-0.463573277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15262v1 | Revisiting Parallel Context Windows: A Frustratingly Simple Alternative and Chain-of-Thought Deterioration | 2023-05-24T15:48:29 | 2023-05-24T15:48:29 | Kejuan Yang, Xiao Liu, Kaiwen Men, Aohan Zeng, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We identify two crucial limitations in the evaluation of recent
parallel-integrated method Parallel Context Windows (PCW), which extends the
maximum context lengths of language models, e.g., 2048 for LLaMA, by harnessing
window-wise attention and positional embedding techniques. We first show that a
simple yet strong baseline, weighted sum ensemble, is missing for the
in-context few-shot classification. Moreover, on more challenging
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning (e.g., HotpotQA), PCW would present unexpected
deterioration regarding question miscomprehension and false inference. Based on
our findings, we suggest that the existing PCW design may not guarantee
sufficient improvement and practicality in handling lengthy documents in
real-world applications. More community efforts on enabling language models'
long context understanding ability should be paid. | [
-0.5815337896,
-0.8792482018,
1.2352126837,
0.463876307,
-0.2830849588,
0.0146398321,
-0.4977950752,
-0.4911063313,
-0.16697447,
0.3503937423,
-0.4952625632,
-0.3171016276,
-0.4937694967,
0.2254508585,
-0.2653743327,
0.8863480687,
-0.4927127063,
-0.4634953439,
-0.6318093538,
-0.3908439577,
-0.6046341062,
-0.4535930157,
-0.3246799707,
-0.1494223773,
0.4023937583,
0.5299069285,
0.4553307891,
0.3733735979,
0.5927250981,
0.2226972878,
-0.0894077718,
0.1605728567,
-0.6660316586,
-0.0297277234,
0.0113811931,
-0.3588884473,
-0.3695066869,
0.0798409581,
0.6033968329,
0.8422937393,
0.0254418571,
0.0430032089,
0.3222310841,
0.7294411659,
-0.9428707957,
0.123720102,
-0.5722730756,
0.0007235234,
-0.3110431433,
-0.0834083185,
-0.6132712364,
0.2592756748,
0.3827533424,
-0.3880628645,
-0.1478573084,
0.0705847219,
0.3857050538,
0.4039235413,
-0.3983968794,
0.0137863234,
-0.5878510475,
1.1252688169,
-0.5631716251,
0.1196175218,
0.2745344341,
0.4986034334,
-0.2012345344,
-0.7314806581,
-0.5748146176,
-0.2436528951,
0.1193024069,
0.0490334742,
-0.1020544395,
0.1392707974,
0.2867328227,
0.2529040873,
-0.3623914421,
0.1352457702,
-0.3398547173,
0.1137507036,
0.2776090801,
0.4263713658,
0.0547932386,
0.2219957411,
-0.7890555263,
0.0306606703,
-0.8779250979,
0.0091380188,
0.0653735921,
0.3048786521,
-0.3885909617,
0.1403939128,
-0.2903798819,
0.9190279245,
-0.3182129562,
-0.2977001965,
0.1115042865,
-0.2046891898,
-0.4718897939,
-0.0709295869,
0.416839838,
0.4643962383,
-0.053798914,
-0.1694818884,
0.1665651798,
0.1436005384,
0.1547321975,
-0.4827369153,
0.1482379287,
0.4681161046,
-0.2930821478,
-0.1341111958,
-0.0440079123,
-0.2125237137,
-0.1247791871,
-0.128780812,
0.0973240286,
-0.0445180126,
0.1298866719,
-0.0101106204,
-0.2410530299,
0.2174119204,
0.5652700663,
-0.4471440315,
0.1245137304,
0.8220524788,
0.6846061349,
-0.3852664232,
-0.7246392369,
-0.062586695,
0.3030453324,
-0.0902793854,
1.0077171326,
-0.7646870017,
-0.3350527585,
-0.3187942803,
0.0917156711,
-0.1670142561,
-0.4263384044,
0.3149477839,
-0.1779636145,
0.3366579413,
-0.6390787959,
-0.3418714106,
0.0130869048,
0.4108665586,
-0.2960876822,
0.6537434459,
-0.0636465624,
-1.1640019417,
0.2586670816,
-0.1850605756,
-0.1725898385,
-0.0168276392,
-0.4449152946,
-0.1534477621,
0.2163775265,
0.1459923536,
0.2538533509,
-0.6127999425,
0.3543625176,
-0.6969676614,
-0.8181944489,
-0.0860643461,
-0.6985862255,
0.754609406,
0.1082243398,
-0.2336803526,
0.0203204155,
-0.6019669771,
-0.1964202523,
-0.0467323214,
-0.3563079834,
-0.500223875,
0.2242457271,
-0.0653430298,
0.2103290111,
0.3640302718,
-0.652982831,
0.1231689081,
-0.0885780603,
0.4337821305,
0.7405785322,
-0.2011580318,
0.2904286385,
-0.283572793,
0.382000953,
0.1535048336,
0.148495838,
-0.2845277786,
-0.5121056437,
-0.4876355231,
-0.0847282931,
-0.1964146495,
0.5098689795,
-0.7504670024,
0.0064985259,
-0.1528256387,
-0.0617949478,
-0.1058517098,
-0.0334696434,
0.6305094361,
0.7157295346,
0.3094823658,
-0.2678414285,
-0.6126950979,
-1.0948156118,
-0.2681185901,
-0.2039460838,
0.0876170695,
0.3700328469,
0.2118761539,
-0.4024715424,
0.8507040739,
-0.4390437901,
0.0252597146,
-0.2537291348,
-0.197759077,
0.1627728045,
0.2935827672,
0.476963222,
-0.2828688323,
-0.4463827312,
-0.1590510756,
-0.9025927186,
-0.041447714,
-0.084650144,
-0.0307041705,
0.1762365848,
0.5414939523,
-0.525152564,
0.6800791621,
0.4707713723,
-0.0804194584,
0.5443730354,
-0.1775001734,
-0.153804794,
-0.6722624898,
-0.222969681,
-0.019079119,
-0.2365825921,
-0.4466181695,
0.2884377539,
0.1332646757,
-0.0810212865,
-0.5655933619,
0.4301501811,
-0.4425928295,
-0.1072373986,
-0.8210511804,
0.3139511943,
-0.1107703447,
0.6185096502,
0.0170103051,
0.7650964856,
0.4119847119,
-0.4740377665,
-0.00191109,
0.0230178237,
-0.39088431,
0.5345730782,
-0.37195912,
0.4183057845,
-0.3586019576,
0.7610639334,
-1.0116633177,
-0.0961613208,
-0.0396465547,
0.1127837449,
0.095166482,
0.2831333578,
-0.2280679196,
-0.5736207366,
-0.6317813993,
0.7243664265,
0.2201995403,
-0.8056625724,
-0.1380473822,
0.2354031354,
0.1375159621,
-0.7389379144,
-0.9170057774,
0.1969303638,
-0.3616043031,
-0.5748569369,
0.4450538754,
0.2095723897,
-0.6115031838,
-0.0554530695,
-0.3533746898,
0.0949383378,
0.020418521,
-0.0100902859,
-0.0043695522,
-0.2326715291,
0.0923985764,
0.1914089471,
-0.1209925264,
-0.0514519028,
-0.0578278191,
0.1899286062,
-0.6242995858,
-0.2100624889,
-0.2349716723,
0.6097460389,
0.8049484491,
0.0798987225,
0.7333268523,
0.1565944254,
-0.3042753041,
-0.254212141,
-0.6635887623,
0.1205985472,
-0.4247686267,
0.2493956685,
-0.4288369119,
-1.1185501814,
0.5746964812,
-0.1335958391,
-0.1765866578,
0.4041456282,
0.5161732435,
-0.2254473716,
0.7088052034,
0.9545735121,
-0.0677405223,
0.2565672994,
-0.1832354963,
0.2616721988,
-1.1570768356,
-0.0147464015,
-0.0783318281,
-0.1579258591,
-0.6443396807,
-0.459323436,
0.5572306514,
0.1770080626,
-0.2975634336,
0.4120668471,
-0.2226920426,
0.4578430653,
0.0765781924,
0.3979822695,
0.2494617701,
-0.1694616079,
-0.1902647018,
0.2192736715,
-0.7529366016,
-0.6406893134,
0.8746029735,
0.4790222049,
0.5928329825,
-0.0094700018,
0.6929754615,
-0.1295085251,
0.4590295553,
-0.655218184,
0.541987896,
-0.1160256118,
-0.279907763,
-0.3858242631,
-0.1167500392,
-0.612013638,
0.4451600015,
0.4949925244,
-1.061571002,
0.4908226728,
0.1335899532,
-0.4497807026,
0.3182696998,
-0.6203045249,
0.8642382622,
0.0711193755,
-0.6476983428,
-0.3545161188,
-0.6669054627,
0.6496323943,
-0.070824638,
0.1644863039,
-0.206496954,
-0.1107907444,
0.4623357654,
-1.0335735083,
0.7795779705,
-0.0626299083,
-0.1022708863,
0.5183552504,
-0.3975807428,
0.4609645009,
-0.0576614887,
0.0350929312,
-0.126658693,
-0.0740575045,
-0.7081344128,
-0.4585193396,
0.9783701301,
-0.3026351631,
-1.1064412594,
-0.3146773279,
-0.6341637969,
-0.6201924086,
-0.1589873433,
0.1572390795,
0.3814335763,
-0.0845801905,
0.3271009028,
0.1696763039,
-0.3904307187,
0.8604931235,
0.1545620114,
-0.0230557006,
-0.1295423806,
0.5916160345,
-0.0590566583,
0.2143175751,
0.1733340472,
0.3424716294,
-0.0950587541,
-0.3816065788,
-0.3985491693,
0.0622555502,
-0.7886332273,
-0.0479180962,
-0.3747453094,
0.2458809167,
-0.0029995355,
-0.2492456138,
-0.2901566327,
-0.3973804116,
-0.1126761213,
-0.1493604928,
0.2760949433,
0.6579213738,
0.1235803664,
0.2226608992,
-0.3479062319,
0.0392512269,
0.3201342523,
0.3840200901,
0.5113106966,
-0.1980417818,
-0.266397357,
-0.3170695901,
-0.3976673484,
-0.9625064135,
0.0683471039,
-0.1162320524,
0.5771377683,
0.3739226758,
0.1467404068,
0.9339872003,
-0.5774177909,
0.7146382928,
0.2661830485,
-0.602829814,
0.338852644,
-0.316498518,
0.7786497474,
0.9035946727,
0.3619315922,
-0.2380441576,
-0.4552901089,
-0.3519413769,
-0.9726613164,
0.5720769763,
0.0336072072,
-0.0833447352,
-0.4443967044,
0.2427118123,
0.220443368,
0.0798247159,
-0.3972260654,
-0.1796727479,
0.1208665892,
0.0866229907,
0.0136057707,
-0.4054302573,
0.1024900675,
-0.4869293272,
0.335185945,
-0.1643985808,
0.3652932942,
0.4569275975,
-0.128671065,
0.2059589028,
0.4499067664,
0.7477149367,
1.1186442375,
-0.3761232793,
0.261767894,
0.488314122,
-0.2179586291,
0.0652709231,
-0.2029584497,
0.0964184031,
-0.3939278722,
0.3665599823,
1.060021162,
0.4220907688,
-0.6190574169,
0.5393663645,
-0.0347471274,
0.1137889996,
-0.3510605395,
-0.4352504611,
0.074406378,
0.1788602024,
0.277659148,
0.0152226212,
0.2130895704,
-1.0224188566,
0.107423313,
0.260579437,
-0.4388780594,
0.0104427775,
0.5268612504,
0.1586693525,
-0.0276653282,
0.474627018,
-0.0431321673,
-0.4970690906,
0.6161003113,
0.6496812701,
1.0370678902,
0.2044392526,
-0.2409495413,
-0.0506638102,
0.2559414208,
-0.2789610326,
0.265662998,
-0.7009672523,
-0.468183279,
-0.555997014,
-0.393003583,
-0.5756000876,
0.1070576608,
-0.5981470346,
-0.0043674358,
-0.5413210988,
-0.2266450077,
-0.3444916308,
-0.2524373829,
-0.6315932274,
-0.0995881483,
0.2066464126,
1.0199165344,
-0.6709893346,
1.0331526995,
0.5618103147,
-0.0707420185,
-0.3157617748,
0.4566797018,
-0.017579196,
-0.5096713901,
0.514341712,
0.6118894815,
-0.4232794344,
-0.397524178,
-0.5165275931,
-0.5994520783,
1.0850065947,
0.3666650355,
-0.7944646478,
-0.1053872257,
-0.0275634062,
0.6455518007,
-0.4523209035,
0.1325368881,
0.7816289067,
0.2867669761,
-0.2732304931,
-1.2473361492,
0.184281379,
-0.0485137552,
0.2083090693,
-0.1452792287,
-1.082894206,
0.8317498565,
-0.3165421486,
-0.2314540595,
0.0962914303,
0.4742622972,
0.6309198737,
0.6577195525,
0.3439359367,
0.8394184113,
0.525600493,
-0.0105727026,
1.6239449978,
-0.0597747117,
0.3719921708,
1.2013039589,
-0.3292570412,
1.0793162584,
0.7571771741,
-0.3663349748,
0.6542090178,
0.538720727,
0.5726973414,
0.748139143,
0.2269653976,
-0.4879570901,
-0.2554454207,
0.1407690644,
-0.3119392693,
0.4931880534,
0.4060707688,
-0.1871644706,
-0.2700810134,
0.2730416059,
-0.1455658674,
0.1782181561,
-0.2370316386,
0.4386161566,
0.5792444348,
-0.6780877709,
0.7003327012,
0.0993824527,
0.7833122015,
0.0748589411,
0.1997426748,
-0.284029752,
0.3901032209,
-0.0377600715,
-0.5516292453,
0.4789828062,
0.078346096,
-0.2240685225,
-0.2169595212,
0.6229157448,
-0.1022690609,
-0.2312056571,
0.3893332481,
0.4204984307,
0.2456833273,
-0.108481735,
-0.5064771175,
0.519693017,
-0.3315340579,
-0.1275011599,
0.3129236996,
0.1509384215,
-0.378387183,
0.5474763513,
0.0409885906,
-0.5210167766,
-0.0171718132,
0.1482953429,
0.8021405935,
-0.6916519403,
-0.4634747505,
-0.9943237305,
0.1384543777,
-0.0052035623,
-0.1606752574,
0.8851773739,
0.4480487406,
0.9425807595,
-0.0606083013,
0.7817760706,
0.2609319687,
0.2217952609,
-0.3992575705,
0.2724439502,
-0.5400885344,
0.5986219049,
-0.4232313037,
-0.8349019289,
-0.2157384455,
0.3881367147,
-0.6876899004,
-0.0747267604,
1.1742656231,
0.2410541773,
-0.0975372195,
0.0738749504,
0.4149354696,
0.083159484,
0.0045929165,
1.064723134,
0.9413101077,
-0.4163322151,
0.38700068,
-0.4676419497,
-0.3656674922,
-0.0841422081,
-0.987057507,
-0.8443701267,
-0.4462712705,
-0.3108058572,
0.0238283873,
0.2488781214,
0.6529827118,
0.5863321424,
-0.7670140266,
-0.3196598589,
-0.3990966082,
0.181857422,
-0.1486447901,
-0.1978048682,
0.3315698802,
-0.2938623428,
-0.4735403657,
0.7310249805,
0.6033196449,
-0.159653917,
-0.365464896,
0.0502565615,
-0.0269949343,
-0.0668748841,
0.9789090753,
0.5426231027,
-1.1668870449,
-0.5367454886,
-0.3461808562,
0.0360887535,
-0.0146049438,
0.8328440189,
-1.0507737398,
0.4089514613,
0.6316837668,
0.6175871491,
0.6521891356,
0.0149957556,
0.7276204228,
-0.6716171503,
0.5010986328,
-0.1208110154,
0.6533474922,
0.2832733989,
-0.2531053722,
0.2061164826,
0.2837266028,
-0.3154889047,
-0.9980839491,
0.2306375802,
-1.1561890841,
-0.6183611155,
0.8510310054,
-0.1601548344,
-0.4453749359,
-0.128008917,
-0.123489283,
-0.0784435645,
-0.0202408303,
0.6401828527,
0.6711240411,
-0.4850690067,
-0.2628737688,
-0.5045690536,
0.2919621468,
0.3687080443,
-0.6298630238,
0.2387884259,
0.3195271492,
0.1668607593,
0.1292903423,
0.80418998,
-0.26225245,
0.3717724979,
0.1632842273,
-0.4301652312,
-0.0756468028,
-0.5960946679,
-0.4238990843,
0.3516449034,
0.0314310528,
-0.1569028497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15255v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15255v4 | Spoken Question Answering and Speech Continuation Using Spectrogram-Powered LLM | 2023-05-24T15:39:43 | 2024-05-31T01:29:27 | Eliya Nachmani, Alon Levkovitch, Roy Hirsch, Julian Salazar, Chulayuth Asawaroengchai, Soroosh Mariooryad, Ehud Rivlin, RJ Skerry-Ryan, Michelle Tadmor Ramanovich | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | We present Spectron, a novel approach to adapting pre-trained large language
models (LLMs) to perform spoken question answering (QA) and speech
continuation. By endowing the LLM with a pre-trained speech encoder, our model
becomes able to take speech inputs and generate speech outputs. The entire
system is trained end-to-end and operates directly on spectrograms, simplifying
our architecture. Key to our approach is a training objective that jointly
supervises speech recognition, text continuation, and speech synthesis using
only paired speech-text pairs, enabling a `cross-modal' chain-of-thought within
a single decoding pass. Our method surpasses existing spoken language models in
speaker preservation and semantic coherence. Furthermore, the proposed model
improves upon direct initialization in retaining the knowledge of the original
LLM as demonstrated through spoken QA datasets. We release our audio samples
(https://michelleramanovich.github.io/spectron/spectron) and spoken QA dataset
(https://github.com/google-research-datasets/LLAMA1-Test-Set). | [
-0.3088223636,
-0.6157661676,
0.6708824635,
-0.24874942,
-0.4155017436,
0.6706816554,
-0.4035529792,
-0.3265650272,
0.4522902668,
0.8596583009,
-0.644815743,
-0.4524149299,
-0.0433916524,
0.2700632513,
-0.6260425448,
1.1219643354,
0.0985077396,
0.1480602622,
-0.4473958313,
0.3048535585,
-0.1787350774,
-0.5651143193,
-0.6112012863,
-0.2260002196,
0.3447439969,
0.6001154184,
0.4172734022,
0.1017605662,
0.216356039,
0.2396392524,
-0.1652640551,
0.282568723,
-0.6481455564,
0.3963017464,
0.0963694379,
-0.5173045993,
-0.5484597087,
-0.2042786479,
0.8997578025,
0.9048301578,
-0.2833524346,
0.1197272539,
-0.0505493693,
0.3073550761,
-0.2614642382,
-0.2167539299,
-0.5732375383,
-0.0636847243,
-0.0081860526,
-0.2974609733,
-0.5113456845,
-0.3250337243,
0.2701511681,
-0.7743649483,
0.0364834145,
-0.0217882767,
0.658415556,
0.4891594648,
-0.2481976151,
-0.191974625,
-1.0747680664,
0.3037039936,
-0.6715256572,
0.6437824368,
0.2002468705,
0.3538249731,
0.1182772145,
-0.9885597825,
-0.6129615307,
-0.6278829575,
0.2171545774,
0.666122973,
-0.1841979474,
0.2691346407,
0.0321765393,
0.2507704794,
-0.6489716172,
0.0969371349,
-0.6085165143,
-0.1606063545,
0.3342157602,
0.0561124571,
0.1756061018,
-0.089382574,
-0.3685230315,
-0.0573121756,
-0.351865381,
-0.0443949923,
0.4353216588,
0.1274245828,
-0.1061695516,
0.4544339776,
-0.2050830722,
0.6084542274,
0.1495627016,
0.3918888569,
0.2275735289,
-0.512272954,
-0.0861087069,
0.1274998635,
0.6670243144,
0.0468266606,
0.4404841959,
-0.4820874631,
0.0953849703,
-0.0530164279,
0.0820422694,
-0.4369669259,
-0.1018859297,
0.4283193648,
0.1745632291,
-0.0997423902,
0.0718157068,
-0.7381433249,
-0.1766324937,
-0.0961846039,
0.2513058782,
-0.3959642947,
-0.3842344582,
0.3959704041,
-0.1670644134,
0.4564208686,
-0.059841156,
-0.8010086417,
0.7971817255,
0.7868815064,
0.4989848435,
-0.1726906598,
-0.2692729533,
-0.6152532101,
0.1246058121,
-0.5199374557,
0.6225300431,
-0.4836939573,
-0.430496484,
-0.178079322,
-0.1518039554,
0.0257192347,
-0.57818681,
0.5435851216,
-0.8531489968,
0.4270232618,
0.021021707,
-0.7290335894,
0.0778909698,
0.2398121506,
-0.6265131235,
0.8956744075,
0.0264263246,
-0.3748787045,
-0.0819349438,
-0.5839723945,
-0.1980187446,
0.2467864156,
-0.1309785545,
-0.1434697956,
-0.1057211682,
0.1307573169,
-0.0060156463,
-0.2031934559,
0.1086814776,
-0.0627684891,
-0.1476690918,
0.409807682,
-0.1889775395,
0.2953765392,
-0.0043435334,
0.0928551853,
0.2233702838,
-0.9101789594,
0.0928201079,
-0.1540699005,
-0.2594876885,
0.0220682919,
0.0705339983,
0.0195815265,
0.0921614319,
0.6219869256,
-0.9023432136,
-0.2377626747,
-0.7185200453,
0.4576692581,
0.566270113,
0.0772063881,
0.4218547046,
-0.2233088464,
0.986525476,
-0.2536575496,
0.119736962,
-0.1444824785,
-0.295622617,
-0.8464986682,
-0.1343633085,
0.3440894783,
0.8731830716,
-0.6393764615,
0.2928711772,
-0.5371560454,
-0.3802617788,
-0.3483404815,
0.0507264286,
0.4559237957,
0.7530597448,
0.330312252,
-0.2742263377,
-0.8241522312,
-0.842351675,
0.026049532,
-0.2394114584,
-0.212298274,
0.3541224003,
0.1418223232,
-0.0317858532,
1.2608602047,
-0.4122901559,
0.0813003555,
-0.4529438615,
-0.4709832668,
0.5239457488,
0.2173193842,
0.0776677653,
-0.80573982,
-0.2216499001,
-0.0205214042,
-0.6804810762,
-0.0808008239,
0.1078147143,
-0.0299178958,
-0.1919676811,
0.7415006757,
-0.4054790437,
-0.2393993288,
0.7533156872,
-0.1930350661,
0.7817988396,
-0.0223407093,
-0.0053676427,
-1.5320196152,
-0.1014064476,
-0.5294235945,
-0.5318771005,
-1.0137181282,
-0.1354343444,
-0.353217572,
-0.5745241642,
-0.5624613762,
0.4433245659,
-0.2852886021,
-0.358137995,
-0.3109317422,
0.3641576171,
0.1263518631,
0.346822232,
0.0678430349,
0.9536537528,
0.707212925,
-0.4194622934,
0.6985845566,
0.4823616147,
-0.1171925068,
0.2144008279,
-0.7990638018,
0.5398461223,
0.0285778418,
0.3437660933,
-1.1408429146,
-0.1982385069,
0.1686320007,
-0.5648320913,
0.0045374585,
0.0538512245,
-0.3287213445,
-0.4768570065,
-0.0472263061,
0.3444967568,
0.6285204887,
-0.4080805779,
0.7789565325,
0.1650153995,
-0.3099859953,
-0.1814027578,
-0.6480004191,
0.3096528649,
0.1138626114,
-0.698292017,
0.2822669148,
-0.2109452337,
-0.1367182881,
-0.0463689603,
0.0269875806,
-0.2388468236,
-0.1108610779,
0.0715589449,
0.2866984308,
-0.2201038003,
0.3491228521,
-0.1741586775,
-0.0777242929,
0.1043731868,
-0.429623425,
0.9407820106,
-0.2143134326,
-0.2236634195,
-0.5137140155,
0.5425041914,
0.4423606694,
-0.3891473114,
0.1857747287,
0.3458427489,
-0.0786807984,
-0.1329266429,
-0.2739978731,
-0.4937309325,
-0.5510893464,
0.6804261804,
-0.3246006668,
-0.9616348147,
0.6471511126,
-0.0241652709,
-0.0305910669,
-0.0004999811,
0.4451088011,
-0.4962077439,
0.4421025515,
0.767626524,
0.0720875338,
0.7140422463,
-0.175884828,
-0.0758071989,
-0.870383203,
-0.0116117485,
-0.0423685387,
-0.0422880836,
-0.5661875606,
-0.390891701,
0.6358677149,
-0.2933329642,
0.0658919141,
0.1846578717,
-0.3806103766,
0.4549044371,
0.743186295,
0.5045797825,
0.245285064,
-0.112308003,
0.0764891282,
0.4164382517,
-0.7854815125,
-0.3746009767,
1.4064756632,
0.1367661804,
0.6562122703,
-0.1755589694,
1.1042295694,
0.0770033672,
-0.2167223692,
-0.7696015835,
0.7972081304,
-0.2979922295,
-0.4303851426,
-0.5083944201,
-0.3436501622,
-0.8517189026,
-0.0015417105,
0.1498969346,
-0.5180050731,
0.0738784075,
0.1672149599,
-0.6006656885,
0.2094949931,
-0.5250530839,
0.5049747825,
-0.130005762,
-0.011492148,
-0.2929895222,
-0.7284419537,
0.4285771847,
-0.0156652555,
-0.0190250278,
0.0970631763,
-0.1172048897,
1.1085693836,
-0.3118570745,
0.8087904453,
0.0062885666,
-0.4079355896,
0.2698502243,
-0.2396072,
0.259432435,
-0.0708811432,
-0.1308686584,
-0.1873098463,
0.2387700528,
-0.2117456645,
-0.5809153914,
0.1702440083,
-0.7226032615,
-0.7076997161,
-0.0835898221,
-0.6778458953,
-0.7222985029,
0.0178271066,
0.1703223735,
0.7289444208,
-0.3348460793,
0.0370550565,
0.7350511551,
-0.1930577606,
0.2852504253,
0.5457032919,
-0.2448996603,
-0.8591058254,
0.8281208873,
-0.1144239232,
0.7166998982,
0.5411618948,
0.109544009,
-0.1757211685,
-0.4066591859,
-0.149260655,
0.3145200014,
-0.7102032304,
0.1888675094,
-0.3738898635,
-0.4807370007,
-0.4569326341,
0.0464204252,
-0.416992873,
-0.3926047385,
-0.406624645,
-0.1292319149,
0.4336715341,
0.3699417412,
-0.002421695,
0.4627210796,
-0.7393456101,
0.5141468048,
0.7447718978,
0.0976311713,
-0.5382722616,
-0.77910918,
-0.2202527076,
0.0047428454,
0.1160145327,
-1.0358970165,
0.1292781979,
0.5127507448,
0.3614525497,
0.104422614,
-0.045462694,
0.1550869793,
-0.6821783781,
0.834407866,
0.1926558912,
-0.855533421,
0.5626721382,
-0.3802540004,
0.5034296513,
0.5006529689,
0.0619213954,
-0.8541312814,
-0.6315569282,
-0.4493100047,
-0.7630736232,
0.5335403085,
-0.0047285017,
0.2435302138,
0.1814723313,
0.3798182607,
-0.0386885554,
0.1385648996,
-0.2965992987,
-0.0807615221,
-0.3393552303,
-0.3923786581,
-0.3163253367,
-0.2552564442,
-0.5062825084,
-0.1093217134,
0.4639726579,
-0.2724170983,
0.2202985287,
0.3363037407,
-0.2577741444,
0.1390118003,
0.5690600276,
0.7413947582,
0.7459929585,
-0.3428938985,
0.1854631603,
0.3156496286,
-0.6534657478,
0.1431547403,
0.4745496511,
-0.0402517281,
-0.066469267,
0.2644446492,
0.7985957265,
0.3087269068,
-0.8746672869,
0.1778066605,
0.0912308767,
-0.3789541423,
-0.5800819993,
-0.058385767,
0.1600267291,
0.4332609773,
0.5147336125,
-0.2723249197,
0.0729681998,
-0.4506519437,
0.5905891657,
0.3099139035,
-0.3147481978,
-0.4191012084,
0.7215343118,
0.2699421942,
-0.3577979207,
0.3644944429,
0.1855727136,
-0.6790062785,
0.8233188391,
0.4939131439,
1.0746958256,
-0.0685220659,
0.3836472631,
-0.0957851931,
0.3059032857,
0.4742709696,
0.6864381433,
-0.3066994846,
-0.877366662,
-0.3905333877,
-0.5198343396,
-1.0490517616,
-0.2285917997,
-0.739035666,
-0.0087299813,
-0.4631477296,
-0.0555906557,
-0.1748104095,
-0.0339995995,
-0.4017585814,
0.1852122396,
0.5533769727,
0.8469067812,
-0.6384788752,
0.7856309414,
0.4570866525,
-0.2776515484,
-0.8390746713,
0.0058327634,
-0.4732772708,
-0.8412798643,
0.5080046654,
-0.2168118805,
-0.4051802754,
0.6353218555,
-0.571631074,
-1.0838462114,
1.0909912586,
0.5186238289,
-0.732213974,
-0.0426983014,
0.3178735971,
0.6339908242,
-0.1507540345,
0.2004261911,
0.6084318757,
0.2027181834,
0.1610961556,
-1.190657258,
-0.1160509512,
-0.0777017921,
-0.3720425367,
-0.112066634,
-0.6201182604,
0.6032884121,
-0.0899131298,
-0.1765743047,
0.1530424356,
0.7837252021,
0.360357672,
0.0443531871,
0.670176208,
0.5279963017,
0.8376419544,
0.0261136107,
0.8877162337,
-0.465852052,
0.1472022384,
1.260966897,
-0.4128207564,
0.9941876531,
0.4300408661,
-0.0984938368,
0.6366376281,
0.69675529,
0.0110344607,
0.4584223926,
0.0021025792,
-0.3896698952,
-0.5200046897,
-0.0842653513,
-0.3801517785,
0.6875543594,
0.1573456973,
-0.2654460073,
-0.2988363206,
0.3959935904,
-0.3400035799,
-0.0295241084,
-0.2425451428,
0.7586526871,
0.0594342984,
-0.5315603018,
0.8246244788,
-0.6464139223,
0.519780755,
-0.8610742092,
0.3958459496,
-0.2908704877,
-0.1003191248,
-0.0408799909,
-0.7699918151,
0.0705513507,
-0.0553402342,
-0.3185474277,
-0.2784469128,
0.4343343079,
-0.7283514738,
-0.4542324543,
0.1900262237,
0.5996777415,
0.3359083235,
0.1654730588,
-0.303865701,
-0.1173001826,
-0.3185877204,
-0.1794419885,
-0.2302434593,
-0.0508328155,
0.2268395573,
0.6993837953,
0.6944966912,
0.1272886097,
0.4466777742,
0.5714328885,
1.0350176096,
-0.5243718028,
-0.7623546124,
-0.64806813,
0.1761144847,
0.0863128826,
-0.2169235647,
0.6754103303,
0.7121628523,
0.4322532117,
0.0277363416,
0.7970943451,
0.2589132488,
0.7068633437,
-0.6297290921,
0.4021791816,
-0.2517385781,
0.0021486694,
-0.0408419594,
-0.4741566479,
0.072310701,
-0.1580814421,
-0.4230638742,
0.0285965875,
0.6016527414,
0.8692334294,
0.091731973,
-0.0326176025,
0.5347334743,
0.2201213688,
0.3128968477,
0.7927416563,
1.0612226725,
-0.2675325572,
0.9045103788,
0.0318757147,
-0.2617042363,
-0.017496163,
-0.2593125999,
-0.6461174488,
-0.5316979289,
-0.1279962212,
-0.1670419872,
0.1210007742,
0.6352453828,
0.8277779222,
-0.65486902,
-0.3711948097,
-0.3100695312,
-0.0583293475,
-0.1930528879,
-0.2338389307,
0.2629513741,
-0.3497451842,
-0.8316649795,
0.8271322846,
0.2246844321,
-0.0462320819,
-0.4352529943,
0.023949299,
-0.2132884413,
0.2827380598,
0.3839394748,
0.5541889071,
-0.6288571358,
-0.190367043,
0.4882935584,
0.1158782318,
0.1503005624,
0.4386932254,
-1.0288256407,
0.5316191316,
0.4866038561,
0.7368907928,
0.6669607162,
0.0558809824,
0.8665475845,
-0.7260447741,
-0.038637314,
0.6380519271,
0.1607195586,
0.3343434632,
-0.2762671113,
0.1459186524,
0.1261592656,
-0.4760459363,
-0.8936508894,
0.5903531909,
-1.3702168465,
0.0083697056,
1.3068714142,
0.1675878316,
-0.3365611136,
-0.020079853,
-0.0438725762,
0.565694809,
-0.1737079769,
0.304971993,
0.485688448,
-0.2571853697,
-0.62204355,
-0.4043623507,
0.4164184034,
0.6940780282,
-1.0731371641,
0.0203856789,
0.2968167067,
0.5294585824,
0.2299346775,
0.7093321085,
0.2692970335,
0.5843467116,
-0.0189709868,
0.2214704454,
-0.1642401963,
-0.2022368014,
-0.4596961737,
0.204939574,
-0.2289142609,
-0.8637151718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15233v1 | Boosting Cross-lingual Transferability in Multilingual Models via In-Context Learning | 2023-05-24T15:14:49 | 2023-05-24T15:14:49 | Sunkyoung Kim, Dayeon Ki, Yireun Kim, Jinsik Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing cross-lingual transfer (CLT) prompting methods are only concerned
with monolingual demonstration examples in the source language. In this paper,
we propose In-CLT, a novel cross-lingual transfer prompting method that
leverages both source and target languages to construct the demonstration
examples. We conduct comprehensive evaluations on multilingual benchmarks,
focusing on question answering tasks. Experiment results show that In-CLT
prompt not only improves multilingual models' cross-lingual transferability,
but also demonstrates remarkable unseen language generalization ability. In-CLT
prompting, in particular, improves model performance by 10 to 20\% points on
average when compared to prior cross-lingual transfer approaches. We also
observe the surprising performance gain on the other multilingual benchmarks,
especially in reasoning tasks. Furthermore, we investigate the relationship
between lexical similarity and pre-training corpora in terms of the
cross-lingual transfer gap. | [
-0.4447076321,
-0.6989547014,
0.4759234488,
0.418553859,
-0.2170956582,
0.1501220316,
-0.3076328635,
-0.4366709292,
-0.3188401759,
0.0058643697,
-0.5838916302,
-0.1745881587,
-0.2081449479,
0.2246033102,
-0.3675857782,
0.816506803,
-0.29437536,
0.2187999338,
-0.3960623145,
-0.0056020264,
-0.8677411079,
-0.4485957325,
-0.7361325026,
-0.1245089322,
0.2698018551,
0.7326315641,
0.2897806168,
0.0351049453,
-0.006135826,
0.1153972149,
0.2123945355,
0.0454784036,
-0.3016197085,
-0.1989599019,
-0.520755291,
-0.5356684327,
0.0241753217,
-0.41112113,
0.8031859994,
0.8067178726,
0.3259059489,
0.1097676307,
0.3348564208,
0.4561169446,
-0.3496101499,
0.1064779311,
-0.5870928168,
-0.0058934432,
0.0315875448,
-0.2634816766,
-0.6361634135,
-0.4220972955,
0.4774127007,
-0.7811392546,
0.1414469928,
-0.0042892084,
0.7138463855,
-0.126752004,
-0.3981830478,
-0.4075636268,
-0.2480373085,
0.5494700074,
-0.4883356988,
0.7004615068,
0.1583492607,
0.4818105996,
0.346619755,
-0.619535923,
-0.4451679587,
-0.4239214361,
-0.2733607292,
0.0443435945,
-0.1290722191,
-0.3966856003,
0.3088564575,
-0.092718564,
-0.8494259715,
-0.1675519198,
-0.3284836113,
-0.140637055,
0.1570565701,
-0.2261123657,
0.6593717933,
0.1794195026,
-0.8946124911,
-0.2184057087,
-0.8651204705,
0.4936827123,
0.0189583041,
0.5395189524,
-0.2810569704,
0.1387941837,
-0.1245534271,
0.8021230698,
0.2099823207,
0.1302439421,
-0.0777437836,
-0.7852099538,
0.1213752404,
0.3175068796,
0.283906132,
0.3057267368,
0.5510843396,
-0.1985537708,
0.1490955949,
-0.2846770585,
-0.3322655857,
-0.8367028832,
-0.1609426439,
-0.2726166844,
-0.2512438297,
0.2670229375,
0.0731496215,
-0.911647439,
-0.1137523353,
-0.2762843668,
0.6362506747,
-0.5250749588,
-0.3629933298,
0.2170562446,
-0.1397798806,
0.3931649923,
0.3635589182,
-0.817035079,
0.2861699462,
0.3323968649,
0.7640193105,
-0.4487420619,
-0.6090230942,
-0.8099162579,
0.2138878554,
-0.2905206382,
0.7707970738,
-0.5130718946,
-0.245216921,
0.1624550968,
0.0961437672,
-0.5125417113,
-0.5157927871,
0.056826055,
-0.3667270839,
0.5235538483,
-0.6523506045,
-0.4319117665,
-0.33796525,
0.3976098299,
-0.3482855856,
1.0789268017,
0.2611418962,
-0.5467771888,
0.3579900265,
-0.9223738313,
-0.5075387955,
0.0814122781,
0.1636277884,
0.3409031928,
-0.3538213074,
0.6275576949,
0.3062591851,
-0.2428915501,
0.0966571644,
-0.175213024,
-0.4572826922,
0.3293049335,
-0.3947712779,
1.0337725878,
0.07608179,
-0.4033786356,
-0.0483482555,
-0.5048814416,
0.1274228394,
-0.1353003085,
-0.1972938031,
-0.4981652796,
-0.9636858702,
-0.0005831875,
0.529671967,
0.2814104557,
-0.6087703705,
0.0842554867,
-0.2699509263,
0.2815786004,
0.4243228137,
-0.0503990278,
0.6727946401,
-0.3010768294,
0.8536241651,
-0.0533360243,
-0.1173887849,
-0.3023558855,
-0.4253690541,
-0.5429830551,
-0.1700463444,
0.480694741,
0.8352874517,
-1.1568033695,
-0.3058418036,
-0.3440349698,
-0.2733774781,
-0.543759048,
0.0320801437,
0.6518181562,
0.934591651,
0.3765584826,
-0.0227726735,
-0.191821456,
-0.7455164194,
-0.553063035,
-0.2044917047,
0.0843957439,
0.1249156147,
0.2148542851,
0.1808308661,
0.8265976906,
0.1081733555,
0.1811942011,
-0.559954226,
0.1102022678,
0.0797341838,
0.4676615,
0.7137266994,
-0.9170709848,
-1.2802064419,
0.4122807384,
-0.5110687613,
-0.3358947337,
-0.1925294846,
-0.2799349427,
0.2600409389,
0.7742493153,
-0.4345570505,
0.2054013163,
0.5783432722,
-0.3722147346,
0.6341048479,
-0.1131049693,
0.291441977,
-1.172072053,
0.1239324212,
-0.409820199,
-0.3344064653,
-0.6730567813,
-0.0051582856,
0.4189439416,
-0.2495247275,
-1.080560565,
1.1166132689,
-0.5103657246,
-0.1164363623,
-0.0196224377,
0.2742530704,
0.0872695521,
0.5968521237,
0.0089835087,
1.0297509432,
0.9032744765,
-0.76647228,
0.1569194049,
0.4199435711,
-0.2799635231,
1.0437898636,
-0.5549426079,
0.193546176,
0.0937142521,
0.3065151572,
-1.2076238394,
0.1463570595,
0.2810597122,
-0.3310841322,
0.3069441617,
-0.3608697057,
-0.4178012908,
0.0454545803,
0.0126467394,
0.8103397489,
0.2631254196,
-0.8511494398,
0.3970421851,
-0.3481144011,
-0.4487399161,
-0.5054135919,
-0.8465864062,
-0.0473849699,
-0.4049847126,
-0.6864198446,
0.3850423992,
-0.5078676343,
-0.0462772213,
-0.05447907,
0.143980056,
-0.0440189391,
-0.2243065834,
-0.3042751253,
0.3945088983,
-0.3243469,
0.1683063805,
0.1884784102,
0.0139875393,
0.0260651987,
-0.3942230642,
0.440422833,
-0.3328403533,
-0.4805112779,
-0.2424445003,
0.5187765956,
0.3534073234,
-0.2674704492,
0.2319135964,
0.6459239125,
-0.120018445,
-0.3058232069,
-0.2059374154,
-0.3051837385,
-0.3871055245,
0.266284734,
-0.8175681829,
-0.8269908428,
0.4235506058,
-0.2349888235,
0.0259521101,
-0.0105582466,
0.4063864052,
0.3276335597,
0.8558260798,
0.6442664266,
0.0312481076,
0.6098942161,
0.0824065581,
0.0930905491,
-0.6557571292,
0.1934005171,
-0.3186227977,
-0.0355172008,
-0.3592557311,
-0.3859932125,
0.4346890748,
0.1380768567,
-0.1783854663,
0.6836405396,
-0.132313028,
0.5573558211,
0.4757695496,
-0.1104080305,
0.3198181987,
0.0070653721,
-0.5993316174,
-0.0054352814,
-0.9843044877,
-0.0218666326,
0.6948310733,
0.0813347399,
0.4003098905,
0.2456700802,
0.4498422444,
0.0109855626,
0.3907990754,
-0.4275231957,
0.540399909,
-0.0358944423,
-0.5129758716,
-0.4197989106,
-0.2299539596,
-0.8269899487,
0.4886586368,
0.0429495499,
-0.8661932945,
0.3926404417,
-0.1053991094,
-0.2585256696,
0.2314828336,
-0.8246760964,
0.9491544366,
-0.3427128196,
-0.4550726116,
0.0086949719,
-0.7044945955,
0.1858136207,
-0.0644913912,
0.3289197683,
0.1289240271,
-0.010803272,
0.3297634125,
0.046735879,
0.7876142263,
-0.1892391443,
-0.1828855127,
0.0842155218,
0.4654977918,
0.5756982565,
0.1705719829,
-0.021005597,
-0.08584214,
0.1427514106,
-0.4102772474,
-0.903504014,
0.5755884647,
-0.2328172475,
-0.4415168464,
-0.1004144922,
-0.973798871,
-0.5743076801,
0.2647278607,
0.4096650183,
0.483050555,
-0.1754338443,
-0.038480673,
0.8248006105,
-0.3514946103,
0.5162180066,
0.6839392781,
-0.3447202444,
-0.1596811861,
0.9405543208,
-0.1172458157,
0.8152656555,
0.7620992661,
0.2864057124,
-0.6340895295,
-0.14380382,
-1.017108202,
0.3155849874,
-0.9732021093,
0.0208388772,
-0.5786473155,
0.0063765226,
-0.4980073571,
-0.5662363768,
-0.1320640892,
-0.3921006322,
0.0452856682,
-0.1138590425,
0.1132187247,
0.4954636991,
-0.0558949932,
-0.049497921,
-0.7976651788,
0.1436448991,
0.548017323,
0.0678219721,
-0.0068649063,
-0.7740005255,
-0.1625391841,
0.131981194,
0.0527410656,
-0.8318992853,
0.2857585549,
0.2559381723,
0.6305984855,
0.099715665,
0.1206274405,
0.88527143,
-0.2207398713,
0.7877286077,
0.0723879635,
-1.1520587206,
0.1923024058,
-0.3194989562,
0.5623855591,
0.5695423484,
0.557805717,
-0.8450549245,
-0.2120090872,
-0.496383667,
-0.5879418254,
0.6870459318,
-0.2122213989,
-0.0110738445,
0.2528940737,
-0.1691181213,
0.4900898039,
0.0619288869,
-0.7984556556,
0.1385112256,
-0.2018772364,
0.1161976308,
0.065324001,
0.2005960941,
0.0345246568,
-0.3685178757,
0.5433909893,
-0.5564776659,
0.0415031612,
0.45697245,
-0.5566248894,
0.0641637295,
0.5041382909,
0.7009159327,
0.8363186121,
0.0694132745,
0.1697004139,
0.8003871441,
0.0650960356,
0.1634830981,
0.2415131032,
-0.1861926764,
0.1152982935,
0.3045973182,
0.7712665796,
0.6961488128,
-0.6084910035,
0.5927232504,
-0.1215149462,
-0.2243737578,
-0.0225564931,
-0.4701001048,
0.1126073375,
0.2132886499,
0.232162267,
-0.1835182458,
0.2019765973,
-0.6360093951,
0.2148863673,
0.2949747145,
-0.5671421289,
-0.3202640712,
0.6135467291,
-0.128710568,
-0.0406010412,
0.451179266,
-0.048769787,
-0.7088775039,
0.4583851993,
1.050106287,
0.6728909612,
-0.1281642765,
0.3542771339,
0.5512840152,
0.1037033796,
-0.0254651103,
0.2387832552,
-0.3829351664,
-0.5176170468,
-0.3266162872,
-0.2131380439,
-0.5619425178,
-0.3281627297,
-0.5355392098,
0.363920629,
0.0760738924,
0.460380584,
-0.3131349087,
-0.252810657,
-0.700339973,
-0.0888585001,
0.2850233316,
1.1276450157,
-0.861766696,
0.877274394,
0.807792902,
-0.2947997451,
-0.9201574922,
-0.0805059597,
-0.317943722,
-0.7482435107,
0.6457321048,
0.1880274713,
-0.1531656533,
0.0915047452,
-0.3589460254,
-0.9000766277,
0.9454169273,
0.8044330478,
-0.2025135309,
0.0134243229,
0.3644121289,
0.3960605562,
-0.5981766582,
0.3633050919,
0.3813118041,
0.7945046425,
-0.0081893196,
-1.2165567875,
0.3894017041,
-0.2253653109,
-0.1283146292,
-0.1049370766,
-0.6199520826,
1.1173933744,
-0.2280012369,
-0.4408805072,
-0.008938089,
0.5310424566,
0.4537544549,
0.3787436187,
0.6295198798,
0.1204980016,
0.7155970335,
0.2297133505,
1.1150016785,
-0.2710694075,
-0.0793017596,
0.9076567292,
-0.3577075601,
0.6852687597,
0.5759711266,
0.1159213036,
0.7047342062,
0.5227512717,
0.2069325745,
0.5157846212,
-0.005027086,
-0.1146633327,
-0.2103701085,
-0.3048242927,
-0.5526996851,
0.0232417546,
0.2018790692,
0.0022501901,
-0.5254085064,
0.3929968476,
0.0968427807,
0.1587409079,
-0.27935794,
0.5872783661,
0.0957994312,
-1.1217190027,
0.9130373597,
-0.6020901203,
0.7505209446,
-0.8145127892,
-0.3843410611,
-0.2984413505,
0.0108306445,
-0.0144641753,
-0.768440783,
0.071085535,
-0.3203279972,
-0.0247967113,
-0.733699441,
0.6766391993,
-1.006308794,
-0.2286119461,
0.6298245192,
0.7558358908,
0.401368469,
-0.1605923772,
-0.6440982819,
-0.6046764255,
0.1783359498,
0.1491317749,
0.6405020952,
0.6925101876,
-0.6327537298,
0.6412601471,
0.735100925,
-0.0358160101,
0.278694272,
0.2207629383,
0.661783576,
-0.3169021904,
-0.670558393,
-0.5765100121,
0.393620342,
0.1914470792,
-0.4861946702,
1.0188840628,
0.497420758,
1.3772896528,
-0.342705965,
0.9173618555,
-0.1047290713,
0.6921670437,
-0.5753571987,
0.5983006954,
-0.7154868245,
-0.1019681543,
-0.2706597447,
-0.6891344786,
0.037750151,
0.0894964039,
-0.2283230871,
-0.1315637082,
1.0239388943,
0.9476068616,
-0.2622700036,
-0.0856679156,
0.5942374468,
-0.2859096229,
0.1341002584,
0.9966402054,
0.8941870928,
-0.2962679863,
0.8360595703,
-0.3299047649,
-0.1585336924,
-0.1205639392,
-0.8713691831,
-0.9932667613,
-0.7811959982,
-0.0802442804,
-0.1944012493,
0.1974550486,
0.8840842247,
0.7463197112,
-0.8372718096,
-0.4969965518,
0.1079579219,
0.0252038389,
-0.7538415194,
-0.2547214329,
0.4579795301,
-0.4821267724,
-0.7954443693,
0.7806028128,
-0.1735030711,
0.0964096263,
-0.1426610798,
-0.1891139597,
-0.3925318122,
-0.0987521708,
0.556866765,
0.5484089255,
-0.3964059651,
-0.1986502707,
0.3336614966,
0.0022023877,
-0.0399721749,
0.9605489373,
-0.7503358126,
0.4611565769,
0.8016496301,
0.8583568335,
0.5385972261,
0.0700850263,
0.8826756477,
-0.8211021423,
0.2259160429,
0.0911350697,
0.3274095058,
0.5287764668,
-0.4172001779,
0.4973917902,
0.1863619983,
-0.302716285,
-0.6761876941,
0.2299621105,
-0.8327547908,
-0.3953033686,
1.2163922787,
-0.2896810472,
-0.2116575986,
-0.3250206709,
-0.3961771131,
0.2192040533,
-0.3789142966,
0.3243077695,
0.8759079576,
-0.1553617269,
-0.4065846503,
-0.5741693377,
0.4854988158,
0.7254332304,
-0.7851744294,
0.1796765029,
-0.0191830229,
0.435649097,
0.0609127246,
0.5333883762,
-0.2316863388,
0.7753331065,
-0.1928834319,
-0.0633385628,
-0.0955630615,
-0.399767071,
-0.4879811704,
0.0716600865,
-0.1778906733,
-0.0576032288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15225v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15225v2 | SAIL: Search-Augmented Instruction Learning | 2023-05-24T15:07:30 | 2023-06-25T17:56:37 | Hongyin Luo, Yung-Sung Chuang, Yuan Gong, Tianhua Zhang, Yoon Kim, Xixin Wu, Danny Fox, Helen Meng, James Glass | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been significantly improved by instruction
fine-tuning, but still lack transparency and the ability to utilize up-to-date
knowledge and information. In this work, we propose search-augmented
instruction learning (SAIL), which grounds the language generation and
instruction following abilities on complex search results generated by in-house
and external search engines. With an instruction tuning corpus, we collect
search results for each training case from different search APIs and domains,
and construct a new search-grounded training set containing
\textit{(instruction, grounding information, response)} triplets. We then
fine-tune the LLaMA-7B model on the constructed training set. Since the
collected results contain unrelated and disputing languages, the model needs to
learn to ground on trustworthy search results, filter out distracting passages,
and generate the target response. The search result-denoising process entails
explicit trustworthy information selection and multi-hop reasoning, since the
retrieved passages might be informative but not contain the
instruction-following answer. Experiments show that the fine-tuned SAIL-7B
model has a strong instruction-following ability, and it performs significantly
better on transparency-sensitive tasks, including open-ended question answering
and fact checking. | [
-0.3600063324,
-0.8002727032,
0.5214042068,
0.0405711234,
-0.3502015173,
0.3843651712,
-0.3527750373,
-0.4229538739,
0.1383353323,
0.7716809511,
-0.4797447324,
-0.6460526586,
-0.738078475,
-0.0479249395,
-0.3036063612,
0.8870151639,
0.0115775773,
-0.0708086565,
0.089655377,
0.1785191596,
-0.7194859982,
-0.2127002627,
-0.701957047,
0.0179631766,
0.433647424,
0.6622850895,
0.5084935427,
0.9740768671,
0.2157233655,
0.1995072812,
-0.1491413265,
0.8285580277,
-0.7323970795,
0.3261835575,
-0.3474549353,
-0.6452814341,
-0.4141663313,
0.1012265831,
0.6144032478,
0.4667582512,
-0.0812635124,
0.2233426869,
0.2461323589,
0.755443275,
-0.8213419914,
0.5630278587,
-0.9643493295,
-0.2944065332,
0.0232414827,
-0.305652529,
-0.6725651622,
-0.4723148346,
-0.1666589379,
-0.8194533587,
0.2532390654,
0.3960825205,
0.7108389139,
0.3446572423,
-0.2836719453,
-0.6409044862,
-0.3890700936,
0.721391201,
-0.5764569044,
0.5096793771,
0.8287478089,
0.1231017485,
-0.2846696079,
-0.4183605611,
-0.2821400464,
-0.2825589776,
0.0187456943,
0.2062081993,
0.4025274813,
0.2378672063,
0.106113635,
0.2863027751,
-0.4077336788,
0.0565138422,
-0.4714569151,
0.0243766513,
0.6040052176,
-0.0498957522,
0.2986943722,
0.1367630363,
-0.1082360893,
-0.1871821284,
-0.9633017778,
0.1258352846,
0.2180520743,
0.4610128999,
-0.2404901385,
0.7164965868,
-0.2687866092,
0.824826479,
0.4358465075,
-0.0828762054,
-0.0716923103,
0.0696583614,
-0.1029421166,
0.3161953092,
0.1802170724,
0.1318670362,
0.1343015581,
-0.2666864395,
-0.420053035,
-0.0399637595,
0.452837497,
-0.6116806269,
-0.0807792842,
-0.118425265,
-0.1548019052,
-0.365116924,
0.0528708249,
-0.4476468563,
-0.2935795188,
-0.4822135568,
0.585296154,
-0.3453170955,
0.2047503442,
0.1518989354,
0.0540138558,
0.3479813635,
0.3502496183,
-0.8590898514,
0.1883469075,
0.7845581174,
0.6071301699,
-0.1263447404,
-0.2347338647,
-1.0013490915,
0.3358537257,
-0.5999086499,
0.5478446484,
-0.9878535271,
-0.2476070523,
0.0657583103,
0.0883461833,
-0.2059231848,
-0.2810838819,
0.4328546524,
-1.1014997959,
0.2667334676,
-0.1582098901,
-0.7465384603,
-0.6660517454,
0.2940850854,
-0.7062501311,
0.9680765271,
-0.0661111549,
-0.4902140498,
0.1050254256,
-0.4259634912,
-0.6465066075,
-0.0794810206,
-0.0575992167,
-0.4674332142,
0.167408064,
0.4526195526,
0.5231243968,
-0.3128978312,
0.2600229979,
-0.187404424,
-0.8558834195,
-0.3409703374,
-0.4275422096,
0.6047228575,
-0.080103673,
-0.8130276203,
-0.0884636939,
-0.7898651958,
0.0259559229,
-0.0281048901,
-0.732212007,
-0.497251451,
-0.0500844866,
-0.5340500474,
-0.1991155893,
0.4312411249,
-0.4225309193,
0.3418985605,
-0.6214432716,
0.0474955775,
0.9088270068,
0.0998135135,
0.3976432383,
-0.2901346982,
0.5154941678,
-0.1985615641,
0.0009135921,
-0.4903494716,
-0.5384716988,
-0.9388039112,
-0.1864905506,
0.0870734304,
0.4188076556,
-0.8329361677,
0.2075539976,
-0.1425713748,
-0.504229486,
-0.7348993421,
0.2086423486,
0.7780246139,
0.5063773394,
0.5750413537,
0.0164606087,
-0.4710050821,
-0.4747883379,
-0.2584833205,
0.1715946198,
0.2721628547,
0.5393580198,
0.2737123966,
-0.2716217935,
0.3522687852,
-0.5386446714,
-0.0834341943,
-0.0464247055,
0.1356539577,
0.1106805503,
0.2840428054,
0.1900961548,
-0.8652484417,
-0.6515467167,
0.2322918922,
-0.6080960035,
0.0200406481,
0.1485172957,
-0.1052935719,
0.2634509802,
0.4969158769,
-0.4036223888,
0.4029364586,
0.5987477899,
-0.1696926206,
0.4999251366,
-0.2794909775,
0.3413585722,
-1.1057009697,
-0.134861052,
-0.3703029454,
-0.0476172566,
-0.2363312542,
0.3135854602,
0.130984664,
-0.0577431247,
-0.0965581238,
0.5911352634,
-0.8041274548,
-0.0976946056,
-0.5716736913,
0.272034198,
0.2311897725,
0.5470246673,
0.1661276072,
1.118326664,
0.5642309785,
-0.8773164749,
0.175470978,
0.3939951956,
-0.2191116363,
0.0806244165,
-0.4093918204,
0.3404869437,
-0.3195023239,
0.0592711754,
-1.0115698576,
-0.3694928885,
-0.0822719038,
-0.318798244,
0.4754521549,
-0.3795245886,
-0.1070231944,
-0.0461642481,
-0.4390466213,
0.2127576619,
0.3396331668,
-0.9468170404,
0.6287651062,
0.2991659343,
-0.1321431398,
-0.9559059143,
-0.3058174253,
-0.1672140211,
0.1210744306,
-0.3751533926,
0.3403216302,
-0.0257547591,
0.1443580538,
-0.1142724231,
-0.3350116014,
-0.2687432766,
0.1956060231,
0.2927958667,
0.3653274179,
-0.3399684727,
0.0377383344,
0.5582885146,
0.1962867081,
-0.0929017588,
-0.2245543599,
0.464458406,
-0.1561443061,
-0.4954933524,
-0.1997874081,
0.1239144504,
0.5395323038,
-0.5862864256,
0.8420551419,
0.3690363169,
-0.1787284762,
-0.458876878,
-0.7558639646,
-0.4718614519,
-0.5241453648,
0.185509339,
-0.2795932889,
-1.2388197184,
0.2126494795,
-0.0756476521,
0.2612787783,
0.1718571186,
0.3633950651,
-0.1219707727,
0.8951649666,
0.7040851116,
-0.0442608707,
0.3817043304,
-0.2121088803,
0.1232084185,
-0.8482531309,
-0.3513192534,
-0.4828661382,
-0.1190110222,
-0.6815288067,
-0.4569439292,
0.3669909835,
0.2209333032,
-0.4489421248,
0.4345723987,
-0.5814719796,
0.6606134176,
0.8216243982,
0.4231411815,
0.3787254393,
0.0678359568,
-0.2327462584,
0.1179398149,
-0.8239849806,
-0.3585897982,
1.1949430704,
-0.0210903268,
0.9766311646,
-0.120510608,
0.7392219901,
0.3313029706,
0.2493170351,
-0.3981057703,
0.4624445438,
-0.194962427,
-0.4904440939,
-0.237483874,
-0.4018462896,
-0.8902192116,
0.0573106743,
-0.2433076054,
-0.2855621278,
-0.1010668203,
0.2804852724,
-0.0830324441,
0.2771054804,
-0.6324048042,
0.3917800784,
-0.3374761641,
-0.598035574,
-0.3192182481,
-0.6220272183,
0.4515802264,
-0.0087551111,
0.2278480083,
0.3340644836,
-0.0048719002,
0.4184823334,
0.1436715722,
1.0689589977,
-0.0409618653,
-0.1537543833,
0.3664703071,
0.3945257366,
0.8587714434,
-0.0404717997,
0.0838596001,
-0.0967966616,
-0.5461063385,
-0.2010585368,
-0.6039530635,
0.7779648304,
-0.6395471692,
-0.7242424488,
-0.051840283,
-0.4602461457,
-0.2481047958,
0.311449945,
0.1454272866,
0.3356052041,
0.0727194548,
0.229461953,
1.0543373823,
-0.2749988735,
0.2145655155,
0.6807040572,
-0.0195802376,
-0.4293940067,
0.9489756227,
-0.0632334277,
0.1185063198,
0.7158256769,
0.0224584881,
-0.4312917888,
-0.5005345941,
-0.4197096825,
0.3781404793,
-0.5032535195,
-0.2370284498,
-0.2289510667,
-0.3924681246,
-0.2270775884,
-0.2894485891,
-0.5399538279,
-0.2479778975,
-0.307349503,
-0.0916823447,
0.1889327168,
0.8841840029,
0.2187038958,
0.3411902785,
-0.8037267327,
0.3804863095,
0.3254374862,
0.5726958513,
0.0246467721,
-0.8008800745,
-0.4312690794,
0.2650976181,
-0.2390930206,
-0.6428488493,
0.0363834277,
0.2474846095,
0.6128228307,
0.3164836168,
0.0309156422,
0.6536318064,
-0.5786997676,
0.5634141564,
-0.1998050958,
-0.7988861799,
0.6225101948,
-0.3537468314,
-0.0198394265,
0.4124419093,
0.4274909794,
-0.0916553289,
-0.5060021877,
-0.4645601809,
-0.7165954709,
0.7283606529,
0.0866732821,
0.0535392873,
-0.0146819772,
0.7222422957,
0.0306525473,
0.5039989352,
-0.6434592009,
-0.0798169449,
-0.0781526268,
-0.1909868419,
-0.0357018597,
-0.3746290803,
0.0272262674,
-0.0500693806,
1.0874707699,
-0.1932697743,
-0.0351020284,
-0.0607031249,
-0.2539886832,
0.0495670661,
0.2240051478,
0.704028666,
0.2682829797,
-0.0622911714,
0.2645800412,
-0.0719303191,
-0.6052213311,
0.1521112621,
-0.0183780659,
-0.2682259679,
-0.2766535282,
0.378623724,
0.8270861506,
0.3650690913,
-0.7967664599,
0.3994598687,
0.1922428608,
0.055798687,
0.0681150407,
0.5561986566,
0.200207293,
0.3165798485,
0.1745800674,
0.0126022138,
0.1351044923,
-0.3190135062,
0.1454174668,
0.5892473459,
-0.3461611271,
-0.1390351206,
0.7931287289,
0.2309128642,
-0.2493781,
0.5370439887,
-0.1773530543,
-0.5289906859,
0.4757983387,
0.6305785775,
0.7422552109,
-0.41421175,
0.1930327415,
0.4421979785,
0.6023729444,
-0.3921901286,
0.2589110136,
-0.2880938947,
-0.5210394859,
-0.7476594448,
-0.4879624844,
-0.552316308,
0.2246590406,
-0.6954075694,
0.2591097057,
-0.4756343663,
0.3078447878,
-0.399092257,
-0.0628495589,
-0.3615373671,
0.2830104828,
0.0551766604,
0.7873301506,
-0.5567597747,
0.5195013285,
0.7554482222,
-0.3340950012,
-0.928022027,
0.0024641617,
-0.3481916785,
-0.9466418624,
0.5344708562,
0.3122325242,
-0.5856629014,
0.1485139281,
-0.8358809352,
-0.9040744901,
0.9915704727,
0.733810246,
-0.7268366814,
-0.1946267188,
-0.0642092749,
0.2295770347,
-0.4613980353,
0.1444634348,
0.225552544,
0.3977359533,
-0.0743032768,
-0.706010282,
-0.1149786785,
-0.0460496992,
-0.1177709252,
-0.127627939,
-0.7934411168,
0.6779406071,
-0.2550420165,
0.0159819834,
-0.0643264949,
0.4657883942,
0.5114376545,
0.3236146867,
0.1273052394,
0.4471556246,
0.8100468516,
0.1546710283,
0.8364362717,
-0.4080926776,
0.2269594818,
1.4933598042,
-0.1298250258,
0.9346290827,
0.1732051671,
0.3791656792,
0.5518820286,
0.3647906184,
0.1718203574,
0.6059010029,
-0.1113306582,
-0.2327912301,
-0.3770049512,
0.0866599455,
-0.1968775094,
0.5756049752,
0.3288450539,
-0.4175230265,
-0.2651289105,
-0.0464805104,
-0.0729296207,
0.4478792548,
-0.5719922185,
0.7601866722,
0.0340361595,
-0.7849299908,
0.9151618481,
0.1717616171,
0.4719187021,
-0.4281822443,
-0.5427154303,
-0.1838887334,
-0.0004302137,
-0.1429098994,
-0.6955794692,
-0.0402058512,
0.055252783,
-0.3756847978,
0.061661385,
0.7222021818,
-0.6003411412,
-0.2673315108,
0.2381387502,
0.355063349,
-0.0093026068,
-0.1696959138,
-0.4635989666,
0.1958899498,
0.2246095389,
-0.4328079224,
0.2084477842,
0.3202810585,
-0.0726953074,
0.8448647857,
0.6240010858,
-0.0240289699,
0.2861306965,
-0.2325175703,
0.8999844193,
-0.4667315185,
-0.6140229702,
-0.5061052442,
0.3193765879,
0.0135739781,
0.0118802302,
0.7276132107,
0.8151157498,
0.914219141,
-0.1991299391,
0.7750684023,
0.3726291955,
0.6887848973,
-0.8339310288,
0.6005880237,
-0.4779475331,
0.4789968431,
-0.00306996,
-1.0540845394,
-0.1117408425,
0.7167080641,
-0.2744269669,
0.1768253893,
0.3366202116,
0.9102176428,
-0.4531807899,
0.108298637,
0.2987422049,
0.2571611106,
0.1224431992,
0.3831656873,
0.588547349,
-0.4673310518,
0.3816263378,
-0.0364776701,
-0.1752454638,
-0.3446243703,
-0.6971176267,
-1.120619297,
-0.4333305359,
-0.04605373,
-0.2622834146,
0.510201931,
0.8101655841,
0.5924144983,
-0.6294816136,
-0.1359636486,
-0.3899434209,
0.3987025917,
-0.2387511581,
-0.2043180317,
0.5613110662,
-0.5847501159,
-0.6405848265,
0.9093267322,
0.3588152528,
-0.0953091308,
-0.0767485574,
-0.2656766772,
-0.1524239779,
0.176406607,
0.5626254082,
0.249617517,
-0.5447679758,
-0.342726022,
0.232662797,
-0.0371929258,
-0.0528677106,
0.4268907309,
-0.7436751127,
0.6274308562,
0.0186944026,
1.1307837963,
0.7032915354,
0.1027822122,
0.4275165498,
-0.7694450617,
0.0210585129,
0.173226729,
0.0291869864,
0.26110816,
-0.5411230326,
0.4135997593,
-0.0379403755,
-0.5092205405,
-0.6732718945,
0.1156234443,
-0.7853522301,
-0.1044182181,
1.0991334915,
-0.193155095,
-0.2358617187,
0.0242866594,
-0.4442563653,
0.3409308791,
-0.3682659864,
1.1039386988,
0.5500457287,
0.1827593297,
-0.1104133353,
-0.4552527666,
0.3427366018,
0.2022707909,
-0.6896581054,
0.111731112,
0.5052354336,
0.3585807383,
-0.0195915326,
0.258394897,
0.0778500959,
0.5474479198,
-0.0925016999,
-0.0520039126,
-0.3998346329,
-0.7149011493,
-0.1232524812,
0.2431317866,
0.1993109584,
-0.2330043763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15222v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15222v1 | Neural Summarization of Electronic Health Records | 2023-05-24T15:05:53 | 2023-05-24T15:05:53 | Koyena Pal, Seyed Ali Bahrainian, Laura Mercurio, Carsten Eickhoff | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Hospital discharge documentation is among the most essential, yet
time-consuming documents written by medical practitioners. The objective of
this study was to automatically generate hospital discharge summaries using
neural network summarization models. We studied various data preparation and
neural network training techniques that generate discharge summaries. Using
nursing notes and discharge summaries from the MIMIC-III dataset, we studied
the viability of the automatic generation of various sections of a discharge
summary using four state-of-the-art neural network summarization models (BART,
T5, Longformer and FLAN-T5). Our experiments indicated that training
environments including nursing notes as the source, and discrete sections of
the discharge summary as the target output (e.g. "History of Present Illness")
improve language model efficiency and text quality. According to our findings,
the fine-tuned BART model improved its ROUGE F1 score by 43.6% against its
standard off-the-shelf version. We also found that fine-tuning the baseline
BART model with other setups caused different degrees of improvement (up to 80%
relative improvement). We also observed that a fine-tuned T5 generally achieves
higher ROUGE F1 scores than other fine-tuned models and a fine-tuned FLAN-T5
achieves the highest ROUGE score overall, i.e., 45.6. For majority of the
fine-tuned language models, summarizing discharge summary report sections
separately outperformed the summarization the entire report quantitatively. On
the other hand, fine-tuning language models that were previously instruction
fine-tuned showed better performance in summarizing entire reports. This study
concludes that a focused dataset designed for the automatic generation of
discharge summaries by a language model can produce coherent Discharge Summary
sections. | [
-0.09183231,
-0.3228824139,
0.6745977998,
0.1405945271,
-0.2359859049,
-0.2955903709,
-0.0254719295,
-0.3089112937,
0.4811399281,
0.5624496341,
-0.2459269613,
-0.707480371,
-0.3863347471,
0.1439702809,
-0.5552745461,
1.4588741064,
0.020242637,
0.085788779,
0.1196675822,
-0.0225658026,
-0.3839263916,
-0.7076716423,
-0.7346091866,
-0.5933650136,
0.6207647324,
0.0366763286,
0.1986090094,
0.8614544272,
0.6984519958,
0.2762970328,
0.0057003535,
0.331337899,
-0.3267346621,
0.1893440336,
0.2524210215,
-0.4494940937,
-0.9442646503,
-0.3304213583,
0.4354979694,
0.4904394448,
-0.1538213938,
0.185569033,
-0.0895464793,
0.9376143217,
-0.4524433613,
0.1430928558,
-0.3053556085,
0.1748539656,
0.1789551228,
-0.3761053979,
-0.4357737899,
-0.4658374488,
0.2156659514,
-0.5361040235,
0.5096106529,
-0.176230818,
0.9765308499,
0.0620996766,
-0.1966595948,
-0.2712346017,
-0.7249119282,
0.3236694336,
-0.9847641587,
-0.0520277806,
0.5026946664,
0.3255940676,
0.3946952522,
-1.0118528605,
0.0513464846,
-0.2109152675,
-0.3079707921,
0.5496386886,
0.0069567962,
0.4946497977,
0.2371989787,
0.5285538435,
-0.5242642164,
0.0542913005,
-0.4186434746,
-0.0417093709,
0.7834188938,
0.8316898346,
0.3058220148,
-0.5343890786,
0.0178880822,
0.00120433,
-0.4868834019,
-0.193264544,
0.2009321749,
0.2278297096,
-0.2948704362,
0.422357887,
-0.3581744432,
0.5468276143,
-0.0932534337,
-0.2412130386,
0.1422590315,
-0.5195229053,
-0.4530698359,
0.1750125736,
0.8323455453,
0.893215239,
0.3933737874,
-0.1834121197,
-0.6242258549,
-0.2235820144,
0.6816770434,
-0.7862007618,
-0.6420564055,
0.2186471075,
-1.0685468912,
-0.4581882954,
-0.0917279795,
-0.4022610188,
-0.308653146,
-0.7023791671,
0.1564393044,
-0.5637457371,
-0.0861716419,
-0.1793341339,
-0.2704827487,
-0.5717629194,
0.5651857853,
-0.8972183466,
0.5443466902,
0.6065052748,
1.0479767323,
-0.1400949657,
-0.1594279259,
-0.2938507795,
-0.0870883539,
-0.3008567393,
0.5510866642,
0.260694772,
-0.1802544892,
0.2034222782,
-0.2021653056,
-0.0855914205,
-0.8093348145,
0.0284273643,
-0.1768787652,
-0.0386996716,
0.1516206264,
-0.6324296594,
-0.1370645463,
0.2729384601,
-0.7693157792,
0.4189305007,
0.4018792212,
-0.6093372107,
0.1526477039,
-0.5020878315,
-0.4522044063,
-0.2727947831,
-0.0269633252,
-0.5227608085,
0.3382993639,
0.1091746464,
0.6685954332,
-0.1043349281,
0.2950340509,
0.3689996302,
-0.4191154838,
-0.0537745468,
-0.1491951644,
0.7354325652,
0.0381101221,
-0.0411883369,
0.111677587,
-0.8011333346,
-0.1082230508,
-0.0521275885,
-0.532438159,
-0.2163767219,
-0.1018194407,
0.1978029013,
0.0291713197,
0.0043957448,
0.0084502278,
-0.0449140556,
-0.7336977124,
0.1034266055,
0.4480053782,
0.4138124287,
0.4400146902,
-1.0328593254,
0.620056808,
0.0998145118,
0.1148098186,
-0.8728721142,
-0.4234018624,
-0.5643135309,
-0.0398720056,
0.4445493221,
0.5567729473,
-0.3274359703,
0.3176574111,
-0.2911007404,
-0.3264882565,
-0.2955414951,
-0.1821593046,
0.6153329611,
0.9965624213,
0.4343804419,
-0.1987018436,
-0.6961780787,
-1.0010462999,
0.0629869103,
-0.3305583,
-0.063496545,
0.2421413511,
0.3378553689,
0.1511152387,
0.4332101643,
-0.4416556954,
-0.3882847428,
-0.4911249876,
0.4367755055,
0.3276328444,
0.2559584677,
0.5007972717,
-0.3382357657,
-0.3990120292,
-0.0249347892,
-0.9231313467,
-0.1638588756,
-0.536223948,
0.1901841611,
0.1505567282,
0.3109408617,
-0.3646136522,
0.5964402556,
0.0335431173,
-0.0211656373,
0.7424997091,
-0.6230404377,
0.0790574178,
-1.293766737,
0.1249822527,
0.0636441633,
-0.3397315443,
-0.776687026,
-0.0586449169,
0.3222142458,
0.0384079739,
-0.235062629,
0.3827828467,
-0.3683741689,
0.2179128826,
-0.3736023009,
0.1038208231,
0.3360977769,
0.3411047161,
-0.0288828369,
0.2001394331,
0.1113914028,
-0.8557513952,
0.4184038341,
0.1900555193,
-0.0292655677,
0.1434679031,
-0.7049893737,
-0.4900420606,
-0.2798615992,
0.3085149527,
-0.7460364699,
-0.4058803618,
-0.0998675898,
-0.2423474342,
0.4505134523,
-0.0007146482,
-0.2718884349,
-0.1032676175,
-0.3006879687,
0.0501366481,
0.5699036121,
-0.0918962583,
0.5967721343,
0.1505805552,
-0.213657096,
-0.4244628251,
-1.0125733614,
0.1207094565,
-0.0498855561,
-0.3865002394,
0.6764910221,
0.2929946482,
-0.3925279081,
-0.1282858849,
0.1422728449,
-0.0913313627,
0.0571675748,
0.2419651449,
0.3546486795,
-0.4695819318,
0.3086456656,
0.0732763112,
-0.0937265828,
0.3418338001,
-0.0645296872,
0.5497953892,
0.1998930722,
-0.2279429734,
-0.735683322,
0.6301769018,
0.6385178566,
0.0179051477,
0.5452737808,
0.1039886251,
-0.6498200297,
-0.205038324,
-0.462210089,
-0.3490648866,
-0.3050505817,
0.3885613084,
0.1636519879,
-0.1478845924,
0.8626450896,
-0.0105879856,
0.4715138674,
0.3813125789,
0.4140792191,
-0.3322494924,
0.9303551316,
0.4044106305,
-0.0658865049,
0.4218469858,
-0.439987421,
0.0662969351,
-0.8720391393,
-0.2914226949,
-0.2826347649,
-0.3443212807,
-0.4333928823,
0.1075174063,
0.6208313107,
-0.0144441053,
-0.0296218079,
0.108151108,
-0.5944799781,
0.1024311706,
0.3992128968,
0.2903276682,
0.299020499,
-0.0315405764,
-0.0086283805,
0.0552907176,
-0.5787246823,
-0.5000610352,
1.1261726618,
0.3617714345,
0.6140322089,
-0.111877948,
1.1969662905,
0.3140038252,
0.2448928803,
-0.469222784,
0.2378789783,
-0.5044299364,
-0.1662596911,
-0.1158448458,
-0.443708688,
-0.6538002491,
-0.0492927842,
-0.0051803775,
-0.4362952113,
-0.0390130356,
0.4993487,
-0.8066233397,
0.1327179223,
-0.9570724368,
0.4639859498,
-0.3032967448,
0.1883491278,
-0.0146533279,
-0.6407775283,
0.5591523647,
-0.0012378769,
-0.156952098,
0.1545573026,
0.0297331344,
0.5573874712,
-0.743737042,
0.6783986092,
0.0767458528,
0.0554497354,
0.1013211459,
-0.0574654564,
0.3056904078,
0.108113721,
-0.1531416327,
-0.0742939115,
-0.3556619883,
0.063369222,
-0.6568239331,
0.448332876,
-0.5440614223,
-0.3182123303,
-0.0753060281,
-0.5822924972,
0.1343787014,
0.2753182948,
0.7862406969,
0.9953604937,
-0.2040679008,
-0.212586984,
0.7321469188,
-0.439637363,
0.6397410631,
0.277680248,
-0.4203529656,
-0.5169652104,
0.8969679475,
0.5296038389,
0.2966619432,
0.504855454,
0.1883880943,
-0.217371732,
-0.4858607352,
-0.7097076774,
0.2808607519,
-0.770244658,
-0.4147692919,
-1.0022187233,
-0.824054718,
-0.3997138441,
-0.2861221135,
-0.069151029,
-0.6514112353,
-0.5160593987,
-0.2316938788,
0.3640123606,
1.1064069271,
0.0361996703,
0.3477281332,
-0.8022978306,
0.6546599269,
-0.0710626915,
0.2358368486,
0.2801163495,
-0.494402647,
-0.3616454303,
-0.0834821463,
-0.2847128212,
-0.9826261997,
0.4870375395,
0.1017765105,
0.2548206747,
0.4987969995,
-0.1234584004,
0.4893070161,
-0.4957733452,
0.8971722722,
0.4237169623,
-0.457472533,
0.794659555,
-0.707346797,
0.5440885425,
0.6010210514,
0.0326920524,
-0.4493923485,
-0.5373618603,
-0.6968901157,
-1.1046779156,
0.8606480956,
0.1294635683,
0.1299005449,
-0.1552448571,
0.3540965915,
-0.1549763978,
0.0870189965,
-0.2558971643,
-0.621715486,
-0.3865472376,
-0.4844813347,
0.1244507208,
-0.2500760555,
-0.0285794847,
-0.1491034776,
0.5264478326,
0.1838331372,
0.2425947934,
0.1998160928,
0.1415987015,
0.0495508276,
-0.1815994382,
0.9632608891,
0.8595817685,
-0.1862637103,
0.0570454523,
0.0922007635,
-0.6109559536,
0.0025779335,
0.0142373173,
-0.4658387601,
0.6383027434,
0.4928087592,
0.8357632756,
0.0267352425,
-0.3553563058,
0.570950985,
-0.3694878519,
-0.3754770756,
-0.4667622745,
0.261169076,
0.3755611479,
-0.2283139974,
0.0855686441,
0.2415735126,
0.3950617611,
-0.2331493348,
0.3772995472,
-0.1701968312,
-0.0823325738,
-0.0775348023,
0.5586328506,
-0.0364975818,
-0.4158108234,
0.7783968449,
0.2814938426,
-0.1024681777,
1.0736949444,
0.8269934058,
0.8503470421,
-0.2986463606,
0.2630969882,
0.7433754206,
0.0959982648,
-0.2472868711,
0.3040058017,
0.0845793784,
-0.0901824012,
-0.1516384333,
-0.5513358116,
-0.1755619198,
0.414116919,
-0.9754107594,
0.2063174397,
-0.6441283226,
-0.2594574988,
-0.1319125593,
-0.485172689,
-0.3868943453,
0.5938318968,
0.2073663771,
0.8449600339,
-0.7512711287,
0.1752697676,
0.6213355064,
-0.7778444886,
-1.2161307335,
-0.0271369014,
-0.093397215,
-0.4546376467,
0.3337679505,
0.1521623135,
0.077698119,
-0.2246354073,
0.1443073452,
-0.4824854434,
1.0541918278,
0.2260522544,
-0.5772043467,
-0.4267085195,
0.077968128,
0.8850539923,
-0.4784120321,
0.7789655328,
0.4031794071,
0.0705190152,
-0.5747861266,
-0.9225164652,
-0.0546952374,
-0.5820562243,
0.0668888465,
0.1230634972,
-0.5359166265,
1.0114458799,
-0.0689691454,
0.0635804236,
-0.0892006755,
0.5321866274,
0.1860218197,
0.3705837131,
0.0480559394,
0.5268933177,
0.8026058674,
-0.0741670504,
1.3892817497,
-0.3654932082,
-0.1454102695,
1.3447879553,
0.0506736748,
0.4417995214,
0.084578298,
0.3884266317,
0.5132309794,
0.426630348,
0.1451946497,
0.3706102073,
0.3307754993,
-0.3197926581,
0.1160675883,
-0.1754294634,
-0.3783119321,
0.2937963903,
0.2702435255,
-1.3725280762,
-0.316780746,
-0.0465094522,
0.0103287697,
0.0660845339,
-0.4210863709,
1.2055660486,
0.3867937326,
-1.0805907249,
0.61668998,
0.0696877688,
0.122054249,
-0.5184537768,
-0.243489638,
-0.3878035545,
0.1111384705,
-0.5002087951,
-0.3410910964,
0.3814695776,
0.3364155889,
-0.6882133484,
-0.485583216,
0.4968038499,
-0.2112800479,
-0.4078677595,
0.0989348739,
0.3626131713,
0.1581552476,
0.0936446562,
-0.4785833657,
-0.300573349,
-0.1265465468,
-0.1698632538,
0.3410596848,
0.4363035858,
-0.0041359067,
0.3499915898,
0.285571903,
0.7159384489,
0.2009942234,
0.8533869982,
0.7565715313,
-0.3287111819,
-0.7445845008,
-1.0091872215,
0.7533737421,
-0.2538282275,
-0.6590811014,
0.1803467274,
0.7188706994,
0.4171161354,
-0.2146462053,
1.027492404,
0.2173168212,
0.734183073,
-0.6579068303,
1.2346994877,
-0.5842184424,
0.0630690157,
-0.1394061893,
-0.5235305429,
-0.3361155391,
0.3675125837,
0.0349261351,
0.1126048565,
0.7987592816,
0.5392788649,
-0.1724666655,
-0.2022818029,
0.2382655591,
-0.1228374615,
0.1482855231,
0.4487171769,
0.5582715273,
-0.5856121778,
0.1630825251,
-0.6050676703,
0.0182608776,
-0.395873338,
-0.6919201612,
-0.9234592915,
-0.4993903339,
-0.2185060233,
-0.4150972068,
0.1138404831,
0.6780372858,
0.6795548201,
-0.871823132,
-0.1628835201,
-0.2465530038,
-0.2171477824,
-0.2204596847,
-0.2049625963,
0.5185425282,
-0.4331054688,
-0.3259736598,
0.1968190372,
0.3580177724,
0.0088309525,
0.0546223968,
-0.0097597446,
0.077022776,
-0.2346556187,
0.3040958047,
-0.0005009576,
-0.6926961541,
0.3092109263,
0.0459447354,
-0.6034470201,
0.1768194586,
0.9612093568,
-0.4097786844,
0.5731927156,
0.7434028387,
0.6034088135,
0.227294758,
0.4307177961,
0.7598808408,
-0.838154614,
-0.441754669,
0.4700049758,
0.4989165366,
0.2764947414,
-0.72883147,
0.1666208655,
-0.1559501886,
-0.447868973,
-0.5944401622,
-0.1204476282,
-0.5884144306,
0.0632954985,
0.8886005878,
-0.2640017867,
-0.1648007631,
-0.3752904832,
-0.1642802805,
0.6633148789,
-0.2524813116,
0.8853876591,
0.3707365692,
-0.4916057885,
-0.0638952479,
-0.7180541158,
0.647660017,
0.3950808644,
-0.9338487983,
0.0370579697,
0.5171875954,
0.1996302903,
0.2042261064,
1.0057190657,
-0.0821709484,
0.7698930502,
-0.1031594947,
-0.0690722615,
-0.3747529089,
-0.5012969971,
-0.4169279635,
0.3042330146,
-0.3381792009,
-0.0678861961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15212v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15212v1 | Towards Adaptive Prefix Tuning for Parameter-Efficient Language Model Fine-tuning | 2023-05-24T14:51:01 | 2023-05-24T14:51:01 | Zhen-Ru Zhang, Chuanqi Tan, Haiyang Xu, Chengyu Wang, Jun Huang, Songfang Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-tuning large pre-trained language models on various downstream tasks
with whole parameters is prohibitively expensive. Hence, Parameter-efficient
fine-tuning has attracted attention that only optimizes a few task-specific
parameters with the frozen pre-trained model. In this work, we focus on prefix
tuning, which only optimizes continuous prefix vectors (i.e. pseudo tokens)
inserted into Transformer layers. Based on the observation that the learned
syntax and semantics representation varies a lot at different layers, we argue
that the adaptive prefix will be further tailored to each layer than the fixed
one, enabling the fine-tuning more effective and efficient. Thus, we propose
Adaptive Prefix Tuning (APT) to adjust the prefix in terms of both fine-grained
token level and coarse-grained layer level with a gate mechanism. Experiments
on the SuperGLUE and NER datasets show the effectiveness of APT. In addition,
taking the gate as a probing, we validate the efficiency and effectiveness of
the variable prefix. | [
-0.6008942127,
-0.8423345089,
0.3511502445,
-0.0636676252,
-0.5298487544,
-0.0400278792,
-0.2900552452,
-0.2005407214,
-0.0008180732,
0.2631067038,
-0.4096976519,
-0.2549063265,
-0.5577453971,
0.0678089783,
-0.040585272,
0.8861408234,
0.1219279766,
-0.1952023506,
0.1764624417,
-0.0817855597,
-0.8214455247,
-0.1968182474,
-1.0644227266,
-0.1692430079,
0.4340866804,
0.5328771472,
0.9777604342,
0.9789107442,
0.2844534814,
0.3566434979,
-0.1148223206,
0.4210489094,
-0.3661896586,
0.0073099467,
-0.5178641081,
-0.3169948757,
-0.6698989868,
-0.3093199134,
0.8124780655,
0.2972370982,
-0.1015565321,
0.0881067961,
0.0262026004,
0.5391808748,
-0.618793726,
-0.0019358,
-1.1306267977,
-0.3857046664,
-0.3693826795,
-0.2593085766,
-0.0807339773,
-0.115214549,
-0.1341941953,
-0.7802398801,
0.2731573582,
0.3435361087,
1.1962500811,
0.4754668772,
0.0900070295,
-0.0752294287,
-0.6367664337,
0.6394743919,
-0.7849972248,
0.8177756071,
0.359337002,
0.1932440102,
-0.1928060651,
-0.883343935,
-0.5037264228,
-0.1832866818,
-0.1643662304,
-0.162594527,
-0.2935333848,
0.2031637132,
0.1044789031,
0.1689240634,
-0.354956001,
0.4523151219,
-0.0941246301,
-0.3740106523,
0.2574062049,
0.216863513,
0.3393132091,
0.1228170544,
-0.244848609,
-0.1133642718,
-0.4646834731,
0.1330615133,
0.4100999534,
0.6824606061,
0.0903615728,
-0.0265463702,
-0.2480626851,
0.9648074508,
0.2380274236,
0.2570092678,
0.0803436562,
-0.4284677505,
-0.182887271,
0.1636691242,
0.4309946597,
0.2780319452,
0.4382653534,
-0.4284569621,
-0.4158660471,
-0.0606036931,
0.5097333789,
-0.8721370101,
-0.3633351922,
-0.098663196,
0.0107294209,
0.0644591749,
-0.1296066493,
-0.5180401206,
0.051511541,
-0.539840281,
0.5884295106,
-0.4024177492,
-0.2415370792,
0.4811960161,
-0.0880119503,
0.3725322485,
0.0547289401,
-1.0735094547,
0.4750162959,
0.9453003407,
0.7207143903,
-0.0746825635,
-0.5849511623,
-0.9592561722,
-0.0234291926,
-0.4533674121,
0.7696547508,
-0.840408206,
-0.2092378736,
-0.4288941026,
0.1561497897,
-0.2788869143,
-0.571403861,
0.5554149747,
-0.82392627,
-0.3325680196,
-0.1641352475,
-0.3347055912,
0.1159596741,
-0.0065471288,
-0.5059027672,
1.1665108204,
0.2471285313,
-0.3618512452,
0.4379229844,
-0.7341346145,
-0.3859037161,
-0.04476979,
0.3101725876,
-0.5195682049,
0.518650651,
0.49319157,
0.2902704775,
-0.3809976876,
0.2886011004,
0.1888142526,
-0.4867575765,
-0.0297268815,
-0.2232082486,
0.172812283,
0.1081432477,
-0.3159168065,
0.4171174169,
-0.8009100556,
0.1043469682,
-0.2753608525,
0.053239204,
-0.6086933017,
-0.00088192,
-0.1471013576,
-0.0102675026,
-0.0702761635,
-0.294672817,
0.2285024226,
-0.6202891469,
0.426560849,
0.9678506255,
-0.1218765676,
0.6893131733,
-0.1008016765,
0.4395229518,
0.1013323143,
0.2182344496,
-0.036222253,
-0.2133534849,
-0.9512454271,
-0.3953202367,
0.8594221473,
0.1393874288,
-0.7476982474,
0.4215345383,
-0.3323116899,
-0.4692362845,
-0.7465384603,
0.0911319256,
0.3621123731,
0.6182909608,
0.6451339722,
-0.3817330301,
-0.1644329876,
-0.7455857396,
-0.5344216824,
-0.063592419,
0.1219938695,
0.3724676669,
0.1865804344,
0.0689556822,
1.0287501812,
-0.5214620829,
-0.1349132955,
0.0338006094,
0.2678795755,
0.1292616576,
0.6293956041,
0.517498672,
-0.6648658514,
-0.3951309621,
0.0662198812,
0.0958636552,
-0.5810946822,
-0.1720685065,
-0.4008231163,
-0.0586818829,
0.8534654379,
-0.4176727831,
-0.0289881676,
0.3649393916,
-0.5095397234,
0.4600760043,
-0.3586318195,
-0.2570852637,
-0.883782208,
-0.1280939281,
-0.1245891675,
-0.4213348627,
-0.9206544757,
0.2493031025,
0.3714704812,
0.1437169164,
-0.5542397499,
0.7202264071,
-0.5154486895,
0.2311121672,
-0.6380808949,
-0.0260149166,
-0.0553408414,
0.4701054096,
-0.1126681119,
0.9809652567,
1.0429017544,
-0.8326383233,
0.0676449463,
-0.1709828377,
-0.2328964919,
0.4677242041,
-0.7781812549,
0.2627122402,
-0.254788965,
-0.1571298093,
-0.6183133721,
0.1786709279,
0.3339318037,
-0.0134811588,
0.4129309356,
-0.1820876449,
-0.3416652083,
0.0865133479,
-0.1833664477,
0.5623275042,
0.5987761617,
-0.5231599808,
0.8596925735,
0.0346244946,
-0.0257516559,
-0.23386693,
-0.1521370411,
0.0607923456,
-0.359950304,
-0.3312110901,
0.670648098,
0.0533467978,
0.1380050182,
0.1540871561,
-0.3934510648,
0.151514098,
0.3908710182,
-0.0182805341,
-0.1540527195,
-0.5149860382,
0.1703293771,
0.2092851847,
-0.5888978839,
-0.2465913296,
-0.5372771621,
0.7164079547,
-0.2213072628,
-0.2554062307,
-0.1638619155,
-0.0373630822,
0.5887383819,
-0.5772283077,
0.7625170946,
0.7777727842,
-0.1385176182,
-0.560528636,
-0.4042390585,
-0.2883047462,
-0.6038485169,
0.3469376564,
-0.7801609039,
-1.010592103,
0.7246838808,
-0.4103162587,
-0.0448667929,
0.3966968358,
0.3866583407,
0.4515261352,
0.7984047532,
0.7308256626,
-0.1331678033,
0.4733242095,
0.0442070477,
0.2727842033,
-0.9860724211,
0.1034957692,
-0.7024590969,
-0.4496125877,
-0.6850178838,
-0.4461107552,
0.2246752232,
0.5410359502,
-0.3987784982,
0.4710786045,
-0.4848880172,
0.5990458131,
0.5700888634,
-0.0225297995,
0.1091037169,
-0.178367123,
0.0163559597,
0.2460314482,
-0.7237653136,
-0.2331629843,
0.399800688,
0.2797602117,
0.579315722,
0.0918338448,
0.3114438355,
0.0655089319,
-0.1187358722,
-0.6532207727,
0.5033160448,
-0.217122376,
-0.2976877391,
-0.4563925862,
-0.3503507972,
-0.8691975474,
0.2062509954,
-0.0003451882,
-0.7193986773,
0.4140979946,
0.2725436985,
-0.383703649,
0.2782945633,
-0.6484328508,
0.9322915077,
-0.1386373043,
-0.1771307588,
-0.0677156523,
-0.5802654028,
-0.2951211929,
-0.503441453,
0.0123523166,
-0.2900786102,
-0.2400596589,
0.5081005096,
-0.5049549341,
0.6102341413,
-0.3078662455,
-0.0192945618,
0.0651881695,
0.067451641,
0.7840365171,
0.0767009333,
-0.4220824242,
0.2304717153,
-0.1894797236,
-0.5248062611,
-0.7225546837,
0.688046813,
-0.6912371516,
-0.808829844,
-0.1332765222,
-0.5620689988,
-0.322573632,
0.2838052213,
0.0106862709,
0.6308602691,
0.0200005118,
-0.0329982415,
0.4192939997,
-0.1149220839,
0.6608030796,
0.7919621468,
0.1059928909,
-0.0359461904,
1.0480049849,
-0.0027691857,
0.3769488931,
0.2962737679,
0.4960701764,
-0.2158014476,
-0.7689214945,
-0.802362144,
0.080106169,
-0.497145772,
-0.4624013901,
-0.4587050676,
-0.1588055342,
-0.0766629949,
-0.1670200229,
-0.4779627919,
-0.1620044708,
-0.4770399928,
-0.0676034987,
0.7857758403,
0.1194628552,
0.011632056,
0.7840431929,
-0.7485022545,
0.5323073268,
0.3856618702,
0.9286254048,
-0.0207474139,
-0.8356391788,
-0.3348785639,
-0.0331874453,
0.0666499212,
-0.3520546257,
0.0313545465,
0.761713028,
0.3904205263,
0.1681979001,
0.0349513628,
1.1938394308,
-0.8977722526,
0.7809188962,
-0.2339088172,
-1.2961961031,
0.3072886467,
-0.0878205821,
0.5402495861,
0.6618589163,
0.1743650585,
-0.3038760722,
-0.4049110115,
-0.41629228,
-0.946316421,
0.9296291471,
0.1480797827,
0.7872853279,
0.0388214663,
0.71650666,
0.2269043773,
-0.1301294565,
-0.2916960418,
-0.3362433612,
-0.1619795263,
0.021450473,
-0.0572864041,
-0.188000977,
0.2467670888,
-0.4760784209,
0.7901881933,
-0.2533278465,
-0.0908427089,
-0.1439192593,
-0.0660387352,
-0.2184518129,
0.3316379189,
0.48839432,
0.7558287978,
-0.0508939512,
0.3855452538,
0.520370543,
-0.5253810287,
0.1541096419,
0.1319836378,
-0.1624340564,
0.0181216355,
0.0379642434,
1.3563528061,
0.2168711722,
-0.3453502357,
0.163562417,
-0.1911884695,
-0.0569820851,
0.3862266839,
0.5228874087,
0.0393704288,
0.1825268716,
0.0867447779,
0.083502546,
-0.1996993721,
-0.2097112238,
0.3075772524,
0.4539397061,
-0.4187475741,
-0.4518968463,
0.6566349864,
-0.0332495421,
-0.4972022176,
0.5459795594,
-0.3200188279,
-0.3705843985,
0.386749953,
0.8164987564,
0.9911720157,
-0.4158787131,
0.014382665,
0.1275836974,
0.3322403431,
-0.1422009319,
0.2152561843,
0.01987895,
-0.8039116263,
-0.4683465362,
-1.0982563496,
-0.0776120424,
0.0828908309,
-0.3598730266,
0.4818875492,
-0.3350092173,
-0.1551118791,
0.1537401676,
-0.4778256118,
-0.5576146841,
0.3384193182,
-0.1078459397,
1.015027523,
-0.8833829165,
0.9605855942,
0.7804037333,
0.0221175402,
-1.0344318151,
0.2357872128,
-0.5802353621,
-0.7155357599,
0.3899293542,
-0.1949684322,
-0.379304558,
0.5961360931,
-0.0704466328,
-1.0610156059,
0.6302847862,
0.4627920389,
-0.5275582075,
0.0826404989,
0.3426747322,
0.5968142152,
-0.0452846065,
0.3219990134,
0.6915919781,
0.5412755609,
-0.1552934349,
-1.0981668234,
0.1838907003,
-0.2375287265,
0.439965874,
0.7283614278,
-0.6008378863,
0.6433731914,
0.4150345922,
-0.2854844928,
-0.1535516977,
0.7574365735,
-0.2949208915,
0.0737174079,
0.9087268114,
0.5996225476,
0.4902403951,
-0.2523486912,
0.7429126501,
-0.7078743577,
0.0856510699,
0.8714537621,
0.0097664502,
0.4509004354,
0.3810147345,
0.1347391903,
0.3641489446,
0.5139571428,
0.1449549198,
0.6826624274,
0.4138503075,
-0.0016543661,
-0.3099111617,
-0.2682617903,
-0.226878196,
0.6545994282,
0.2847704589,
-0.0037468001,
-0.3718566298,
0.1685055643,
-0.1112304926,
-0.1886072606,
-0.6131932735,
0.9458392859,
0.0599000119,
-0.6944919229,
0.8870633841,
0.458063215,
0.3793361783,
-0.6475277543,
0.1696364582,
-0.2147205621,
-0.0589871705,
-0.0510625653,
-0.2816600204,
0.3189791739,
-0.0120159863,
-0.0351302437,
-0.3055591881,
0.8868260384,
-0.2543230951,
-0.4437050819,
0.0898503214,
0.5676916242,
-0.0928184912,
-0.2329772115,
-0.6923030615,
0.2072006017,
-0.4708881676,
-0.2867085338,
0.2964708507,
0.5785682201,
-0.322095722,
0.3129178584,
0.7153199315,
0.2989341319,
0.1246618479,
0.3795208335,
1.1621730328,
-0.6563901901,
-0.6476246715,
-1.1508942842,
0.6051488519,
0.2801272869,
-0.4576322436,
0.588999033,
0.4029297829,
0.8736585379,
0.1254752874,
0.2030793428,
0.1037631854,
-0.0032597336,
-0.7845904827,
0.4440839589,
-0.6526375413,
0.3503835797,
-0.3178113103,
-1.2581523657,
-0.3804166615,
0.169764027,
-0.1505933553,
0.0932484418,
0.4591945708,
1.336856246,
-0.6682801247,
-0.0191136841,
0.2630361319,
0.1354249865,
0.141198203,
0.2039148211,
0.643541038,
-0.3070941865,
-0.0088983132,
-0.059561722,
-0.1418444216,
-0.0883963853,
-1.1326663494,
-0.6391798854,
-0.5495193601,
-0.4049677253,
-0.0410709046,
0.2356109917,
0.7506120801,
0.746887207,
-0.8397012949,
0.0721683875,
-0.3881047368,
0.1090117395,
-0.4269082248,
-0.1852988452,
0.7409944534,
-0.6782050729,
-0.708054781,
0.366500169,
0.3463927209,
-0.3205970228,
0.1115460768,
0.009793953,
0.1188129038,
0.2856151462,
0.3503222167,
0.0701694712,
-0.6044920683,
-0.6170101762,
0.0696180761,
0.0792825222,
0.172895968,
0.9607138634,
-0.7784008384,
0.5688197613,
0.4419497848,
0.8551781178,
0.2704748213,
0.319730401,
0.4507576227,
-1.0065952539,
-0.0508938655,
0.0250190236,
0.1022272035,
0.1064635441,
-0.2030948251,
0.0578956343,
-0.0251605418,
-0.4157547057,
-0.7576707602,
0.2601456642,
-0.724032402,
-0.4933445454,
0.9917462468,
0.2059993595,
-0.1108442172,
-0.2407851666,
-0.2016071826,
0.4638742805,
-0.3351390362,
0.7037547231,
0.3451189697,
-0.0290499851,
-0.2024432272,
-0.3555963635,
0.8414608836,
0.7674123645,
-0.6079908013,
0.146011591,
-0.0158952866,
0.1105377302,
-0.0298547167,
0.3768818378,
0.1443506926,
0.2374463826,
-0.320440799,
-0.3639407456,
-0.3861053884,
-0.4877760708,
-0.3873600364,
-0.0590001754,
0.3453116119,
-0.1198872477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15186v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15186v1 | SciReviewGen: A Large-scale Dataset for Automatic Literature Review Generation | 2023-05-24T14:26:30 | 2023-05-24T14:26:30 | Tetsu Kasanishi, Masaru Isonuma, Junichiro Mori, Ichiro Sakata | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic literature review generation is one of the most challenging tasks
in natural language processing. Although large language models have tackled
literature review generation, the absence of large-scale datasets has been a
stumbling block to the progress. We release SciReviewGen, consisting of over
10,000 literature reviews and 690,000 papers cited in the reviews. Based on the
dataset, we evaluate recent transformer-based summarization models on the
literature review generation task, including Fusion-in-Decoder extended for
literature review generation. Human evaluation results show that some
machine-generated summaries are comparable to human-written reviews, while
revealing the challenges of automatic literature review generation such as
hallucinations and a lack of detailed information. Our dataset and code are
available at https://github.com/tetsu9923/SciReviewGen. | [
-0.3505445421,
0.1404622942,
0.1572950929,
0.233243838,
-0.0849463046,
-0.1921323985,
0.0291134566,
-0.5287213326,
0.0804385468,
0.7492137551,
-0.409958601,
-0.3935011625,
-0.2874564826,
0.6759473085,
-0.652902782,
1.3217397928,
0.2258617878,
0.2682892978,
-0.0751752406,
0.1976261586,
-0.087586239,
-0.3661760092,
0.0614903867,
-0.4233521223,
0.4899403453,
0.0909049883,
0.5228651166,
0.15747118,
0.7584251761,
0.1987684369,
0.0754020885,
0.3458227813,
-0.5156046748,
0.3602778018,
-0.1997073293,
-0.2954939604,
-0.3335655034,
-0.0660326034,
0.7283668518,
0.6986113191,
0.057139989,
0.2260463238,
0.0852932259,
1.1024860144,
-0.4619063139,
-0.1325368583,
-0.4305833876,
0.398314029,
0.1797683388,
0.0558819324,
-0.5701848865,
-0.7756934762,
0.2653730512,
-0.4195612669,
0.5827131867,
0.4006172717,
0.7684637904,
0.2637818456,
-0.4850231409,
-0.4045971632,
-0.9772475958,
0.6867340803,
-0.2819884717,
0.0445894487,
0.1526153535,
0.3741131127,
-0.2299543768,
-0.6922053695,
-0.3718451858,
-0.1862736791,
-0.4248947501,
0.2347380668,
-0.2339424789,
0.0217537936,
0.4500882626,
0.641353488,
-0.7514532804,
-0.1613217741,
-0.8522390723,
-0.1852492541,
1.0134803057,
0.3818065822,
-0.0473507643,
-0.8327233195,
-0.0342369489,
-0.3041235209,
-0.6284950376,
-0.1355078071,
0.3396756351,
-0.31353724,
0.3181709349,
0.5329053998,
-0.1936545372,
0.5840950608,
-0.0655337498,
0.1410427541,
0.3997552693,
-0.5082877874,
-0.517568171,
0.3652120233,
1.0782709122,
0.7232698202,
-0.0108719543,
0.1336935014,
-0.148556605,
-0.1792927086,
0.3963055611,
-0.9547821283,
-0.2606048882,
0.4699709117,
-0.8138299584,
-0.6686406136,
0.2607368231,
-0.7694046497,
-0.6245270371,
-0.0832649991,
0.0833238438,
-0.3825084269,
-0.0810180977,
0.2312283963,
-0.4416304827,
0.2079601586,
0.2638812363,
-0.4300683439,
0.0999257043,
0.2669493854,
0.6196634769,
-0.2981042266,
-0.1430669278,
-0.1787982285,
0.1462647021,
-0.3674433827,
1.0538271666,
-0.2162745595,
-0.7721915841,
-0.1862020046,
0.0454874001,
0.0178722031,
-0.5366502404,
0.5877096653,
-0.1646753103,
0.7249490023,
-0.1517101973,
-0.4400154948,
-0.1432014704,
0.1234741807,
-0.8414946795,
0.8744671345,
-0.0258028563,
-1.049683094,
0.3626994491,
-0.6854795814,
-0.5488620996,
0.0047650947,
-0.1603369117,
-0.5037677288,
0.3394727707,
0.3647539318,
0.2458819002,
-0.5494911671,
0.4946810305,
0.1074663624,
-0.3218815923,
0.3420750201,
-0.1359801143,
0.8358424902,
0.6504141688,
-0.1491599381,
0.2086695731,
-0.6484549642,
0.0246191658,
0.0914233103,
0.1049370915,
-0.2851138115,
0.1072641388,
0.3969128728,
0.1770372838,
-0.1062402278,
-0.59647578,
0.2519562244,
-0.6429771781,
0.2866965532,
0.2624499202,
0.3010925651,
0.2769021392,
-0.3786028028,
0.4079005718,
-0.0190460067,
0.2091441602,
-0.6341167688,
-0.0532212667,
-0.4390804172,
0.2127339244,
0.5155754089,
0.3987035453,
-0.6553242803,
0.7893027067,
-0.3187758923,
-0.6989154816,
-0.4900342822,
-0.0712005645,
0.4846329987,
0.3670426607,
0.1592511684,
-0.2551446855,
-0.6205917001,
-1.1655337811,
-0.1813323945,
-0.1816491932,
-0.4274572432,
0.0988137573,
0.6754823327,
-0.3480435908,
0.942487359,
-0.8572100401,
-0.5075092912,
-0.4169514179,
0.2685630918,
0.0279820263,
0.2530894279,
0.230580017,
-0.7942296863,
-0.1749039888,
-0.0637442544,
-1.0598504543,
-0.1280197799,
-0.2533126175,
0.0514338948,
0.3233209848,
0.5611719489,
-0.3026115596,
0.1806065738,
0.2704940438,
-0.107215032,
0.4412355721,
-0.335927248,
0.2476923615,
-1.2459713221,
0.515987277,
0.1845510602,
0.0729172081,
-0.4161546826,
-0.2819868028,
0.1004955694,
-0.2875844836,
-0.0564577989,
0.0681561604,
-0.3624172211,
-0.1287815124,
-0.2790113389,
0.0051251929,
0.2830632627,
0.056121096,
0.1952504516,
0.3265709877,
0.1299197823,
-0.3240661323,
0.4301619232,
0.3014448285,
-0.4883379042,
0.2269951701,
-0.8228539228,
-0.3507072628,
-0.4560325146,
0.9163026214,
-0.8781490922,
-0.7482504249,
-0.0899745822,
-0.210793227,
0.1578359008,
0.2868143022,
-0.7076368332,
-0.5658839345,
-0.582627058,
0.0411899425,
0.543053925,
-0.2962925136,
0.5432276726,
0.5236939788,
-0.3430105448,
-0.3780505359,
-0.3880908787,
0.4284550846,
0.0454239473,
-0.4052308798,
0.3320422471,
0.1206117943,
-0.3675519228,
-0.0378597714,
0.1894878894,
0.3852398098,
-0.4121987224,
0.2728376985,
0.2984399796,
0.2029459476,
0.4100569785,
0.2045588493,
-0.0256448518,
0.2597309649,
-0.0433072932,
0.2623490691,
-0.1071617156,
-0.12685588,
0.0039347745,
0.3948782086,
0.6858119965,
-0.119550027,
-0.0746707097,
0.3417399228,
-0.2345859557,
-0.286247015,
-0.4881669283,
-0.2227648646,
-0.3507980406,
0.4920201302,
0.0252203885,
-0.5186499953,
0.0826626122,
0.017016314,
0.3925069273,
0.8833377361,
0.4599422216,
-0.1915546507,
1.2823064327,
0.4765532911,
-0.0925051346,
0.0525380857,
-0.0195552334,
0.2454448193,
-0.5780419707,
-0.4189240932,
-0.6149939895,
-0.3538352847,
-0.5912615061,
-0.0776107386,
0.6265866756,
-0.3158454299,
0.1900786161,
0.1405460387,
-1.027867198,
0.5106726885,
0.3416116834,
-0.2004193962,
0.6169276834,
0.1150831357,
-0.0520342514,
-0.0706527531,
-0.5876492262,
-0.5226894617,
1.0212007761,
0.2023160458,
0.8440957069,
-0.3961563408,
0.5724247098,
0.4721409082,
0.3178195655,
-0.4434470832,
0.5073328018,
-0.2988342345,
-0.5997030735,
-0.2084366977,
-0.2505013943,
-0.8409773111,
0.2827307582,
-0.3597801924,
-0.0276209116,
0.1876525134,
0.1038088873,
-0.2871598005,
-0.0554827191,
-0.5960642695,
0.414575547,
-0.3688350618,
-0.1822507828,
-0.3763074875,
-0.9171434641,
0.7904112339,
-0.3020076156,
0.0895736665,
0.2903274,
0.4781911075,
0.7896943688,
-0.4703404307,
0.7451269031,
-0.0181603357,
-0.0432455614,
0.2614558637,
0.0558244176,
0.2907440662,
0.055019673,
0.0545579866,
-0.1760088354,
0.0111820931,
-0.0242527667,
-0.1883565038,
0.6051792502,
-0.5363532305,
-0.254361093,
-0.8135535717,
-0.6049032211,
0.0028608597,
0.2147449255,
0.754942894,
0.4677694738,
-0.3789114058,
0.2226051092,
0.8834471703,
-0.6255828738,
0.3960811198,
0.192883268,
-0.628379941,
-0.5791584253,
0.9488425255,
0.0739342198,
-0.1823332161,
0.2103235871,
0.07295461,
-0.0418127067,
-0.3358452916,
-0.5695158839,
0.1976282001,
-0.4684976041,
-0.2316988856,
-1.0865104198,
-0.4839991629,
-0.3135989904,
-0.0476002023,
-0.1808506101,
-0.4051410258,
0.074641712,
0.0182908829,
0.2487293482,
1.2690266371,
0.1826126128,
-0.0103605427,
-0.9141206145,
0.399384588,
-0.0140879396,
0.2800459266,
-0.1470543891,
-0.1157582477,
-0.3642477989,
-0.381688118,
-0.4602717161,
-0.6335314512,
0.6154117584,
0.0834548622,
0.1639735252,
0.314342171,
0.3813312948,
0.3780117035,
-0.4008454978,
1.0103595257,
0.1696698517,
-0.5364736915,
0.7241811752,
-0.3968343139,
0.6790844798,
0.5376982689,
0.4039782882,
-0.3817065954,
-0.5229230523,
-0.6021938324,
-0.9242860675,
0.635145545,
0.1651805937,
-0.1504010707,
0.2703698575,
-0.0007024909,
0.4310645759,
0.180179432,
-0.6452525258,
0.114178963,
-0.4810245335,
-0.1168668494,
-0.22389476,
-0.062763676,
-0.2552556992,
-0.0537533872,
0.6969546676,
-0.1163375005,
0.1649755985,
0.504359901,
-0.3147650957,
-0.3364452124,
0.26376158,
0.6865667105,
0.3002687693,
-0.3935558498,
-0.1425149739,
-0.0674516335,
-0.7025958896,
-0.1754382551,
0.3420139849,
-0.397868216,
0.2549415827,
0.3190837204,
0.4287658036,
0.1034993753,
-0.910054028,
0.3329654038,
-0.4839408994,
-0.6768738627,
-0.6310243011,
0.0823009014,
-0.1251698881,
-0.1785263419,
0.7613301873,
0.1278665513,
0.5047795177,
-0.0925474539,
0.1999846995,
0.2971897125,
-0.3094399273,
-0.2061362267,
0.5075827837,
0.3099298775,
0.2115503103,
0.5996431112,
-0.0494473688,
-0.2810542881,
0.4713328481,
0.1790744811,
1.1454883814,
0.1350537241,
0.1631597728,
0.6095460653,
0.3907761872,
-0.2327140272,
-0.1212775186,
0.1400856674,
-0.2140646577,
-0.4463504851,
-0.7689054608,
-0.6666579843,
0.160409376,
-0.6581882834,
0.401768297,
-0.1087029278,
0.0542188101,
0.1746021807,
-0.0831229761,
-0.1482562721,
0.1919625849,
-0.1018017605,
0.8201627135,
-0.9030941725,
0.7393630743,
0.5249940753,
-0.3271994293,
-0.3492971659,
0.0829013512,
-0.1102925837,
-0.0088497372,
0.6767670512,
0.3835023642,
-0.274633795,
-0.3381799459,
-0.5032219291,
-0.5638815761,
1.070484519,
-0.1802673787,
-0.6686326265,
-0.2585711777,
-0.1460286081,
0.8936987519,
-0.562353611,
0.2373834997,
0.4728015661,
0.3628333509,
0.2109535784,
-0.6114387512,
-0.1180574074,
-0.720366478,
0.0369502679,
0.1434909701,
-0.4735493958,
0.5628436804,
-0.1421843767,
-0.0222973824,
-0.1886485517,
0.492480129,
0.2139011025,
0.3285425305,
0.5746203065,
0.1887507886,
0.544238925,
0.0087038428,
1.0835969448,
-0.3631752133,
0.0713324323,
0.925797224,
-0.7996588945,
0.4699613154,
0.2260302752,
0.1224430054,
0.3855035305,
0.5102018118,
-0.5558946729,
0.199816227,
0.2427546978,
0.0315448157,
-0.1445314437,
-0.1537927836,
-0.4690580964,
0.2838166356,
0.4098235667,
-0.9195952415,
-0.3085868955,
0.2207168937,
-0.1896217018,
0.0252549686,
-0.2984544039,
0.9651071429,
-0.08072225,
-1.0487049818,
0.5071404576,
-0.0697095618,
0.5962683558,
-0.5262058973,
-0.0618338026,
-0.0774170831,
0.1747767329,
-0.6144989133,
-0.8195413947,
0.369959116,
0.3069790602,
-0.4221836925,
-0.3974605203,
0.9463507533,
-0.0771438479,
-0.8131788373,
-0.034138944,
0.3552376628,
0.2595827878,
0.3634432554,
-0.2379164845,
-0.1974984556,
0.2304646373,
-0.536134243,
0.3828247786,
0.179398641,
-0.4029577076,
0.4706142247,
0.552672863,
0.0148235736,
-0.2902088463,
0.0424605533,
0.8843116164,
-0.8878166676,
-0.4465580583,
-0.5091818571,
0.2974449098,
-0.4667107165,
-0.4078108668,
0.700856626,
0.8944188952,
0.4306319654,
-0.2659446001,
1.2539528608,
-0.2552698851,
0.7028090358,
-0.1224839836,
0.9818152785,
-0.3041045368,
0.187883988,
-0.292804271,
-0.8334968686,
-0.6533248425,
0.4864842296,
-0.301276654,
-0.1439408362,
0.8419679403,
0.7394629717,
0.273761332,
0.4026646912,
0.0932698995,
0.263751626,
0.2842927873,
0.3441596925,
0.6753557324,
-0.4864855111,
0.7136746645,
0.0128414407,
-0.0109008467,
-0.4273017347,
-1.0018601418,
-0.9446176291,
-0.6177860498,
-0.1598350406,
-0.54605335,
-0.1427327693,
0.9827405214,
0.2351325452,
-0.8740093708,
-0.3025237918,
-0.1074136794,
-0.1565072536,
-0.0227311794,
-0.2052205801,
0.4557861984,
-0.3192898631,
-0.700337708,
0.0968093053,
0.2021731585,
-0.127337262,
-0.7422806025,
0.0404005572,
0.149696365,
-0.1352196932,
0.5415153503,
0.1132770032,
-0.4064131081,
0.2163098603,
0.1353880614,
-0.450455457,
-0.1809033453,
0.9659808278,
-0.8089464903,
0.5440798402,
0.6953632236,
0.1075572073,
0.6266053319,
-0.0805652738,
0.910095036,
-0.4392576814,
-0.2263905257,
0.4200001657,
0.2746681869,
0.2688839734,
-0.3335536122,
0.6221618056,
0.0502843037,
-0.7973325849,
-1.1745835543,
0.1625792235,
-0.8166709542,
-0.3056721091,
0.9310030341,
0.3539783955,
-0.257734865,
-0.1737854928,
-0.5254116058,
-0.0704978257,
-0.3317551911,
0.9193065166,
0.3968039453,
-0.3526528478,
0.1079970896,
-0.3317871392,
0.7278280258,
0.2610886693,
-0.9624369144,
0.3536305726,
0.855774343,
0.0475078039,
0.3857575953,
0.199896574,
-0.4624177217,
0.5216597915,
-0.1939579695,
0.5048879981,
-0.1540933251,
-0.1691716462,
-0.6558461785,
0.5906470418,
-0.1421258897,
0.5037254691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15183v1 | Are Pre-trained Language Models Useful for Model Ensemble in Chinese Grammatical Error Correction? | 2023-05-24T14:18:52 | 2023-05-24T14:18:52 | Chenming Tang, Xiuyu Wu, Yunfang Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Model ensemble has been in widespread use for Grammatical Error Correction
(GEC), boosting model performance. We hypothesize that model ensemble based on
the perplexity (PPL) computed by pre-trained language models (PLMs) should
benefit the GEC system. To this end, we explore several ensemble strategies
based on strong PLMs with four sophisticated single models. However, the
performance does not improve but even gets worse after the PLM-based ensemble.
This surprising result sets us doing a detailed analysis on the data and coming
up with some insights on GEC. The human references of correct sentences is far
from sufficient in the test data, and the gap between a correct sentence and an
idiomatic one is worth our attention. Moreover, the PLM-based ensemble
strategies provide an effective way to extend and improve GEC benchmark data.
Our source code is available at
https://github.com/JamyDon/PLM-based-CGEC-Model-Ensemble. | [
-0.1096689925,
-0.5483460426,
0.514387548,
0.2387549579,
-0.2146835625,
-0.0320288166,
-0.3572980165,
-0.2277388424,
-0.2964407504,
0.3736827374,
-0.3799296319,
-0.6067767143,
-0.226067394,
0.2512058914,
-0.4917213917,
0.9122315049,
0.1121341214,
0.2498906404,
-0.3759900033,
-0.0255824979,
-0.2422984987,
-1.0610833168,
-0.4738447666,
-0.1336282939,
0.3252031207,
0.4728693366,
0.5982925296,
0.3967246115,
0.4720664024,
0.4317178726,
-0.1908583045,
0.2925826311,
-0.3644686341,
-0.2018475235,
-0.0418909304,
-0.5607815385,
-0.6736164093,
0.0961738601,
0.8760871291,
0.8371835947,
-0.2973145247,
-0.2776464522,
0.2934685349,
0.4563702047,
-0.6213461161,
-0.0568164587,
-0.6271230578,
0.1579999775,
-0.5660899282,
0.0592056476,
-0.5376582742,
-0.0792977586,
0.1482553184,
-0.6960754395,
0.4692342579,
-0.0965433642,
0.8491841555,
0.026321128,
-0.1123397723,
-0.0274737682,
-0.7254649997,
0.6052100658,
-1.1649842262,
-0.2104042172,
0.095249787,
0.0313608944,
-0.3787069321,
-0.7577755451,
-0.6768291593,
-0.3299022019,
-0.1237854958,
0.4182222486,
0.106193006,
0.5457315445,
0.2632490993,
0.6082516313,
-0.4011153579,
0.336004734,
-0.0182228573,
-0.2287910283,
0.750631094,
0.136696294,
0.4940007329,
-0.028016502,
-0.2714578211,
-0.3017793298,
-0.7261152267,
0.1287213415,
0.7804456353,
0.3191812634,
-0.1608639956,
0.1495894045,
-0.0058953795,
0.6906176805,
-0.0234488565,
0.1807878166,
0.2719057798,
-0.4494488537,
-0.2483288199,
-0.0066335136,
0.6435095072,
-0.1322864741,
0.4073281288,
-0.1748794764,
-0.5391539931,
0.2179790735,
0.1945121586,
-0.2029465139,
-0.6733865142,
0.0039917645,
-0.1594223529,
-0.2510433495,
0.7798394561,
-0.5629184842,
-0.1634480506,
-0.1719781607,
0.3458378613,
-0.2604069412,
-0.3215340972,
0.1890046895,
0.1055544913,
0.0007737799,
0.3523781598,
-0.769250989,
0.3584106863,
0.6549723744,
0.6747398973,
0.0000177018,
-0.7116647959,
-0.474494487,
-0.2798247933,
-0.4871199727,
0.9664136171,
-0.2795940042,
-0.6707953215,
0.2211453766,
0.0247662961,
-0.5930927992,
-0.7252714634,
0.7459841371,
-0.273634702,
0.265373826,
-0.2429383695,
-0.7817978263,
-0.0858522356,
-0.1189752668,
-0.7496159077,
0.6592627168,
-0.269605875,
-0.689984858,
-0.0446422771,
-0.7457315922,
-0.7071670294,
0.1454986483,
0.0154513558,
-0.4369054437,
0.2012243718,
0.2889695764,
0.3949145079,
0.1001005992,
0.1914727986,
-0.4030412734,
-0.4625732899,
0.3611674011,
-0.4001162946,
0.6743760705,
0.3365331888,
-0.1020322293,
0.2938845754,
-0.6519348621,
0.1008706167,
0.0866109356,
-0.3689160049,
-0.1830502152,
0.2820186615,
-0.2318058759,
0.0413052067,
-0.0089501869,
-0.2223417014,
0.0302418005,
-0.5475718379,
0.4395524859,
0.9443336129,
-0.3634774089,
0.5540766716,
-0.4196867049,
0.5982007384,
0.0909025148,
-0.0349031761,
-0.3225443065,
-0.3613688946,
-0.7849327922,
-0.028778689,
0.5242273808,
0.7808208466,
-0.7766675949,
0.6905181408,
0.0946296453,
-0.2708187401,
-0.3788001537,
0.1316564083,
0.4720727205,
0.5091289878,
0.1351333261,
-0.4040968418,
-0.5255984664,
-0.5052418709,
-0.4376126528,
-0.445862174,
-0.0643162057,
0.1220613047,
0.3102838993,
0.2020399421,
0.7389816642,
-0.1102988198,
-0.0525695905,
-0.3940074742,
0.2523964047,
0.1417914629,
0.4813440442,
0.3882384896,
-0.8029551506,
-0.1485512555,
-0.0547835268,
-0.6376837492,
-0.3805882335,
-0.032607872,
-0.0236973744,
0.5154437423,
0.3200163543,
-0.4660699964,
0.1895871609,
0.7532134056,
-0.2426259071,
0.944957912,
-0.5147402883,
0.0801388994,
-0.8248534799,
0.0665323362,
0.0952907652,
-0.0805285126,
-0.8635343909,
0.0053991927,
0.0507513285,
0.0982306078,
-0.3287483156,
0.1759579629,
-0.4825556278,
-0.016716009,
-0.1815982163,
0.0367652215,
-0.3154741824,
0.3669086993,
-0.0843593255,
0.6916967034,
0.4776429236,
-0.6457426548,
0.2680828869,
-0.0258591082,
-0.455337882,
0.1310191453,
-0.3286240101,
0.4796650112,
-0.11995361,
0.1846975684,
-1.0311645269,
-0.4264691174,
0.198650226,
-0.3094611466,
0.3064861,
0.169641912,
-0.6027463675,
-0.4572093189,
-0.1254601777,
0.2435547709,
0.3932953477,
-0.6991735697,
0.4910496771,
0.1599056721,
-0.2312660962,
-0.3409142196,
-0.5692759156,
0.0252182744,
-0.163654834,
-1.0152882338,
0.3585143089,
-0.0496114753,
-0.4160627723,
-0.0910147205,
-0.0791186616,
0.1679587364,
0.4273515046,
0.0898863301,
0.4645165801,
-0.5075787306,
0.4019236565,
-0.3387274742,
0.0867416859,
-0.1836025566,
-0.4155422449,
0.5091496706,
-0.6233351827,
-0.4066146016,
-0.3871337175,
0.0728659406,
0.2742606103,
-0.2296286821,
0.4027170837,
0.0100512188,
-0.3222719431,
-0.1790592223,
-0.6484513879,
-0.1030063853,
-0.4423554838,
0.3928148448,
-0.2250367403,
-0.7399751544,
0.7579288483,
0.0888313055,
-0.2510809302,
0.5701115131,
0.1048955023,
-0.2865583003,
0.9792059064,
0.4454485178,
-0.3418642282,
0.3546409309,
0.057762973,
0.1068363562,
-0.1971594542,
0.2108672857,
-0.5983666182,
-0.0936968476,
-0.5163230896,
-0.053276673,
0.2595871687,
0.4035334587,
-0.1501174122,
-0.0575551912,
-0.1865277439,
0.3830175996,
0.5884831548,
-0.0103720902,
0.3492924571,
0.101002492,
-0.2196750492,
0.0629599169,
-1.0238708258,
-0.6140801907,
0.7053202391,
0.175527513,
0.6454088688,
-0.109257862,
0.3981502652,
0.0010117014,
0.1498010457,
-0.3732202947,
0.6546151042,
-0.8259044886,
-0.2964505553,
-0.2840859294,
-0.4912959635,
-0.6396351457,
0.3333727419,
-0.2821919322,
-0.5744776726,
-0.0235894322,
0.4838519692,
-0.7849080563,
0.4597137868,
-1.0232390165,
1.1658703089,
-0.5625516176,
-0.1107070297,
0.032386411,
-0.809053719,
0.3373009861,
0.0258165263,
0.0018820242,
0.2108644098,
0.2742769718,
0.7302988172,
-0.7637811899,
0.7341325879,
-0.1275754422,
-0.129757598,
0.4594210982,
-0.2940714955,
0.6235639453,
-0.3554821312,
-0.0831177756,
0.238228783,
-0.302654177,
-0.3483293056,
-0.4345170856,
0.5018337369,
-0.7932989597,
-0.9073759317,
-0.3598001301,
-0.4302439094,
-0.338378489,
-0.1188881472,
0.4601282477,
0.3957510889,
-0.0496518388,
0.1449332088,
0.414122045,
-0.0977146104,
0.554176569,
0.5159465671,
0.0839598402,
-0.1898434013,
0.6284356713,
0.3391414285,
0.3593487144,
0.3574346602,
0.1699139625,
-0.0015774382,
-0.8333646059,
-0.3460093737,
0.1473751366,
-0.4793806374,
0.1184718683,
-0.3888094425,
-0.2226090282,
-0.7204020023,
0.0768287405,
-0.2276923954,
-0.0726025403,
-0.4721697569,
-0.1619025767,
0.0256998297,
0.5854837894,
-0.0558083169,
0.5739105344,
-0.9978951216,
-0.2944541872,
0.1728679687,
0.133416459,
-0.1582079977,
-0.5577251315,
-0.197883606,
0.0877632275,
-0.1924081594,
-0.848827064,
0.3358081281,
0.160001561,
0.7125513554,
0.5375127196,
-0.1790546626,
0.7828078866,
-0.2690333128,
0.9642432332,
0.0704931244,
-1.1163288355,
0.383739233,
-0.4277435839,
0.394905895,
0.3229578435,
-0.1606253833,
-0.6883322001,
-0.3032205105,
-0.7399471998,
-0.7336879373,
0.9624195695,
0.1113882959,
-0.0345413946,
0.2368291467,
0.4629072845,
-0.1045568213,
0.1137126833,
-0.6356733441,
-0.0464296788,
-0.2003160417,
-0.3021380603,
-0.369662255,
-0.3511809707,
0.1328561604,
0.0541491993,
0.9666368961,
-0.1807766408,
-0.083317779,
0.3545798957,
-0.1875100285,
-0.2302288115,
0.3634739816,
0.6889653802,
0.4523144662,
0.0914927721,
0.0394686759,
0.4104772806,
-0.4033669531,
-0.0751459971,
0.3602675498,
0.0734364763,
-0.089782849,
0.5509546399,
0.8265779018,
0.209664762,
-0.6893317699,
0.4774764478,
0.2356565297,
-0.0910420492,
-0.4200521708,
0.0262640361,
0.0190949421,
0.0238518286,
0.3854054213,
0.317412585,
-0.1797446012,
-0.3956349194,
0.0793525428,
0.2242579907,
0.0925216079,
-0.5742222667,
0.421635896,
0.3793431222,
-0.1765950024,
0.7717226744,
-0.2115910947,
-0.8438087106,
0.8703562617,
0.420917064,
0.7334088683,
-0.6068956256,
0.2341510952,
0.1279986948,
0.2502018809,
-0.6132401228,
-0.2371507585,
0.1520598084,
-1.0964099169,
-0.5833546519,
-0.1959137619,
-0.1911726296,
0.1967105567,
-0.3502236903,
0.4265208244,
-0.4533104599,
0.1354556084,
-0.3222358525,
-0.0152264768,
-0.2795019746,
0.1486281306,
0.5004076362,
0.7163299918,
-0.8914484382,
0.9703728557,
0.9571812749,
-0.2712686062,
-1.3997114897,
0.0812927336,
0.0555140078,
-0.4204245508,
0.3771740496,
0.0564718805,
-0.1249417663,
-0.2038228363,
-0.6455830336,
-0.52185601,
0.8137022257,
0.3622302115,
-0.9288575053,
-0.1950374544,
0.0464992151,
0.8145984411,
-0.4891997874,
0.0775394365,
0.4393070638,
0.4106048644,
0.0284890961,
-1.0077923536,
-0.2923884988,
-0.4328713417,
0.211748302,
-0.0117885927,
-0.4740551412,
1.3602432013,
-0.2323025614,
-0.7080709934,
0.6082742214,
0.6368865371,
0.2064621449,
0.4081390798,
0.819737196,
0.6931561232,
1.0310801268,
-0.1596696526,
1.289110899,
-0.0505482256,
0.3935685456,
1.2051802874,
-0.6216518283,
0.7304776907,
0.2142435759,
-0.3541547358,
0.465528518,
0.6578547955,
-0.0210998822,
0.2890604734,
0.3331992626,
-0.3442301452,
-0.6266905665,
0.3277553022,
-0.275921315,
0.292064786,
0.251367569,
-0.227102533,
-0.1090021953,
-0.0115293376,
0.029942371,
0.4690527022,
-0.5685324073,
0.6982876062,
0.0099721421,
-0.917303741,
0.2760688961,
-0.0019709044,
0.9429248571,
-0.5432530046,
0.1005870774,
-0.3528055847,
0.5153214931,
-0.3929230273,
-0.3979386985,
-0.2252434194,
-0.0805431157,
-0.0395483784,
0.0455602668,
1.1996245384,
-0.6176236272,
-0.4025356472,
0.140682742,
0.4435738027,
0.1416182965,
-0.3002167344,
-0.361499697,
-0.4268790185,
0.0516843423,
0.0875540972,
0.1499563307,
0.1402946115,
-0.0776840746,
0.3319967091,
0.6481018662,
0.2033384591,
0.1785124987,
0.3849574029,
0.4910183847,
-0.4891653955,
-0.7013548613,
-0.845754683,
0.5416039228,
-0.0982036069,
-0.2557587922,
0.9001661539,
0.2855731547,
1.2271150351,
-0.2931720912,
0.9591364861,
0.3744334877,
0.5571343303,
-0.7585679889,
0.6214011908,
-0.3605609536,
0.486279726,
-0.2462709546,
-0.5744047165,
-0.5456217527,
0.5718129873,
-0.5747192502,
0.1979332119,
0.7395696044,
1.059941411,
0.3158996403,
0.5767279267,
0.4529700577,
0.4437773228,
0.0250131283,
0.5556873679,
1.2505027056,
-0.2644752562,
0.477473855,
-0.2867002189,
-0.0716210976,
-0.1833523512,
-0.6514850855,
-0.5586617589,
-0.4457138777,
-0.3046892583,
-0.3095092177,
0.412451148,
1.0548491478,
0.4273342788,
-0.9555363059,
-0.3504061997,
-0.4263107479,
0.0791511685,
-0.4375157356,
-0.1597788185,
0.242818132,
-0.6140268445,
-0.7876394391,
0.2927061915,
0.1052590311,
0.2487890422,
0.0116696376,
-0.2396186739,
-0.327907145,
-0.2402963489,
0.3600986302,
0.3513925076,
-0.7411810756,
-0.4251889884,
0.0737223849,
-0.1307968944,
0.1008736864,
1.1759201288,
-0.5140261054,
0.4377439916,
0.5508801341,
0.5975734591,
-0.0564339422,
0.1662169099,
0.7311325669,
-0.701961875,
0.067678757,
0.2979876399,
0.7175284028,
0.498902142,
-0.3459820747,
0.4789688289,
0.6675179601,
-0.6050956845,
-0.6627975702,
-0.1666121334,
-0.8339901567,
-0.3547396362,
1.2058154345,
-0.564911902,
-0.3108769953,
0.1285481304,
-0.1805249751,
0.2043950111,
-0.1592204571,
0.7031665444,
1.1965070963,
0.0602541417,
-0.002572654,
-0.0597839169,
0.3370624483,
0.9911653399,
-0.8933025599,
-0.1147528738,
0.4679116309,
0.1241507828,
0.2201548815,
0.3826261759,
-0.1787993908,
0.5227538943,
0.0066113421,
0.0915770978,
0.1156612039,
-0.2605546415,
-0.7587578297,
0.204555437,
0.1275797188,
-0.2920536995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15182v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15182v2 | HiTIN: Hierarchy-aware Tree Isomorphism Network for Hierarchical Text Classification | 2023-05-24T14:14:08 | 2023-06-09T08:53:14 | He Zhu, Chong Zhang, Junjie Huang, Junran Wu, Ke Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hierarchical text classification (HTC) is a challenging subtask of
multi-label classification as the labels form a complex hierarchical structure.
Existing dual-encoder methods in HTC achieve weak performance gains with huge
memory overheads and their structure encoders heavily rely on domain knowledge.
Under such observation, we tend to investigate the feasibility of a
memory-friendly model with strong generalization capability that could boost
the performance of HTC without prior statistics or label semantics. In this
paper, we propose Hierarchy-aware Tree Isomorphism Network (HiTIN) to enhance
the text representations with only syntactic information of the label
hierarchy. Specifically, we convert the label hierarchy into an unweighted tree
structure, termed coding tree, with the guidance of structural entropy. Then we
design a structure encoder to incorporate hierarchy-aware information in the
coding tree into text representations. Besides the text encoder, HiTIN only
contains a few multi-layer perceptions and linear transformations, which
greatly saves memory. We conduct experiments on three commonly used datasets
and the results demonstrate that HiTIN could achieve better test performance
and less memory consumption than state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods. | [
0.1615794301,
-0.4225718379,
-0.0490053073,
-0.0641727149,
-0.1942937076,
0.2386578023,
-0.0424428694,
-0.6378763318,
0.2073757797,
0.0590886399,
-0.2455651313,
-0.6641503572,
-0.4497026503,
-0.0697862059,
-0.0963248014,
1.0554189682,
-0.1161751747,
-0.4978611767,
-0.1279605925,
-0.1179188043,
0.005842804,
-0.7429105639,
-0.5180760026,
-0.2520494461,
0.6901037693,
0.2452645004,
0.7209401727,
0.9209147692,
0.64262712,
0.169872418,
-0.398486197,
0.0396001227,
-0.216252476,
0.1122901291,
0.3318197727,
-0.3700513244,
-0.5574162006,
-0.3970414996,
0.6006410718,
0.5018913746,
-0.0377523899,
0.1443373263,
0.3069023788,
0.5429624915,
-0.988132298,
0.3732644618,
-0.4374504089,
0.3681911528,
-0.2674558759,
-0.6041586399,
-0.5935445428,
-0.0563933812,
-0.0682263151,
-0.7128649354,
0.0195216313,
0.3730276525,
0.8325279355,
0.3324511647,
-0.5955548882,
-0.0237430893,
-0.626478076,
0.4532888234,
-0.5665340424,
0.4938250184,
0.6331820488,
0.1603193581,
0.1773127764,
-0.3544443548,
-0.1013197377,
0.0465336293,
-0.152077511,
0.4854056239,
-0.0361224636,
0.4086768329,
0.0901098326,
0.6458782554,
-0.5342755914,
0.2294224054,
0.1136262715,
-0.3379254043,
0.0193072092,
-0.0117224921,
0.4160848856,
-0.5079188347,
-0.3609345257,
-0.048468139,
-0.4623509347,
0.0396119803,
0.0755649358,
0.3600656688,
0.0259825233,
0.2263029367,
-0.0535315908,
0.4872607291,
0.0326006748,
-0.3289478123,
0.2835579813,
-0.4682254195,
-0.4278227389,
0.5342218876,
0.7819412351,
0.0099971443,
-0.0410003699,
-0.3094116449,
-0.1203240827,
0.0503919423,
0.2014223188,
-1.3829501867,
-0.3690579236,
0.0938369408,
-0.7512933612,
-0.4068668187,
-0.1126811951,
-0.5443834066,
-0.1642229259,
0.2133082598,
0.2528977394,
-0.5290095806,
-0.253262192,
0.0334306918,
-0.0542566888,
-0.1812023968,
0.2549139559,
-0.9060040712,
0.2636384368,
0.2991982102,
0.947152257,
-0.0489044152,
-0.1878166795,
-0.2761734724,
0.5662511587,
-0.1522151828,
0.4654628634,
-0.4901718497,
0.0971317068,
-0.1551580876,
-0.362862289,
-0.1932285279,
-0.5257285833,
0.289450556,
-0.6691191792,
0.0607958771,
0.2717084587,
-0.3681607544,
-0.1234688461,
0.6286559701,
-0.7241770625,
1.0789753199,
0.0242956504,
-1.6069896221,
0.3882989287,
-0.4971106946,
-0.6088058352,
0.3672145307,
-0.1405595392,
-0.6107980013,
-0.2390342653,
0.2677443326,
0.3820901215,
-0.3112683892,
0.4216879904,
0.0324536562,
-0.4288243353,
-0.2787321508,
-0.1523549259,
0.8308832645,
0.1775839329,
-0.2290400118,
0.0260709338,
-0.7334305048,
0.0848410428,
-0.1141902059,
-0.7806146741,
-0.9362898469,
-0.0937888846,
0.0954852998,
0.1359326541,
0.1867554188,
-0.7408510447,
0.2797761559,
-0.2331889272,
0.2587513328,
0.500728786,
0.013971257,
0.2982853949,
-0.1635661423,
0.2798154056,
0.5145215392,
-0.1179653555,
-0.2791638672,
-0.3246428072,
-0.5362606645,
-0.2600913048,
0.5231294632,
0.6728004217,
-0.9523296356,
0.6998935938,
-0.4178205729,
-0.2940410972,
-0.2848849297,
-0.0624490269,
0.4465303719,
0.4176986516,
0.3355022073,
-0.2744984031,
-0.8047549725,
-0.82076931,
-0.0974377766,
-0.5716689825,
-0.0120181758,
0.234750241,
0.6311810017,
-0.3544000983,
0.6454765797,
-0.3390808702,
-0.3583882749,
-0.196546033,
0.2121025473,
-0.1766013503,
0.5394433737,
0.1728218347,
-0.733017087,
-0.3230823874,
0.3575425744,
-0.8525643945,
0.0978396833,
-0.1703875065,
-0.0770540312,
-0.0796838924,
0.3194257617,
-0.2927163243,
0.4094002247,
0.6111308932,
-0.2291060984,
0.4058471322,
-0.2738217413,
0.1848317683,
-1.4781295061,
0.0966312662,
0.0007394063,
-0.1568246335,
-0.4607860446,
0.0663097128,
0.3831654489,
-0.057268098,
-0.0781407952,
0.0178678725,
-0.4356246591,
0.0819725245,
-0.0600153878,
-0.3976701498,
-0.0823861584,
0.8345214725,
0.02704251,
0.7029656768,
0.9284592271,
-0.7159935832,
0.0229790267,
0.2502008677,
-0.4024003446,
0.4581775069,
-0.3055148423,
-0.1183055043,
-0.2348822802,
0.4479263127,
-0.5849609375,
-0.1444076449,
0.1478680223,
-0.3702960312,
0.2279055119,
-0.2183053344,
-0.8736436367,
-0.2571153045,
-0.1785458773,
0.7878959775,
0.4683291018,
-0.7523248792,
0.3093340695,
0.4116357565,
0.3756056726,
-0.3078700006,
-0.7974592447,
0.1786857545,
-0.1901361346,
-0.3450406194,
0.7495241165,
0.018681854,
0.3907568157,
0.0053446642,
-0.5547101498,
-0.3833628297,
-0.0643389523,
0.4582394361,
-0.1917321533,
-0.4423264563,
0.5052676201,
0.1774717271,
-0.0180060659,
-0.2514771521,
-0.5840092301,
0.1681395918,
-0.1058362648,
0.0320733041,
-0.8255321383,
0.1431277096,
0.6744555831,
-0.3604550362,
0.6021418571,
0.1873621941,
-0.6908311248,
-0.1991837621,
0.0811432377,
0.0560892783,
-0.3955993354,
0.4269949496,
-0.6037783623,
-1.1320587397,
0.1877588183,
-0.5012890697,
-0.1884902865,
0.22305879,
0.2834609747,
-0.1869805157,
0.8819394112,
0.6258471608,
-0.213227272,
0.5547307134,
-0.289875567,
0.1169981286,
-0.7819156647,
-0.3958053589,
-0.632978797,
-0.4263324142,
-0.4422007203,
-0.2469088733,
0.2814230323,
0.0693535879,
-0.5102425218,
0.7908961773,
-0.6179125905,
0.3901086152,
0.3454618156,
0.2420392036,
0.5544600487,
0.272952646,
-0.1681281477,
-0.0494655594,
-0.9865691662,
-0.1299336106,
0.4211198986,
0.6047416329,
0.8649635911,
-0.1189718768,
0.7722191215,
0.077687107,
0.04895721,
-0.9307690859,
0.4457752407,
-0.2621382475,
-0.4635013342,
0.0016035137,
-0.9746602774,
-0.9106453061,
0.2041832656,
0.0108372979,
-0.7797798514,
0.3079477847,
0.1528726965,
-0.1393865347,
0.8917845488,
-0.5116984844,
0.8261846304,
-0.1356756687,
0.0467604399,
-0.0039283731,
-0.5442566276,
0.0748468563,
0.0050719799,
-0.0756211206,
0.3350913823,
-0.0384282768,
1.3053233624,
-0.4119745195,
0.9325782657,
-0.1495627761,
-0.023236366,
0.5180191994,
0.3235511184,
0.2591256201,
-0.3218124807,
-0.0909476057,
0.2071382105,
0.0364872962,
-0.2825478911,
-0.6888799667,
0.3602113426,
-0.6930004358,
-0.0544446632,
-0.3087338507,
-0.5483911633,
-0.1718439311,
0.3935634196,
0.3717816472,
0.5624749064,
-0.0944630951,
0.5016677976,
0.5107523799,
0.119588688,
0.2926724851,
-0.0790301487,
-0.0363772176,
-0.3052200079,
0.8024023771,
0.1431713551,
0.0041463994,
1.0766757727,
0.4769302607,
0.108045578,
-0.5359585285,
-0.589944005,
-0.3279500008,
-0.338159591,
-0.7075082064,
-0.788869679,
-0.4731900394,
0.0142213721,
0.1139977947,
-0.413228482,
-0.4479413033,
0.1893613636,
-0.2381832451,
0.3920381665,
0.5209211111,
0.273004055,
0.810972333,
-0.6507692337,
0.3986477554,
0.1560414881,
0.6188357472,
0.3608953953,
-0.4470550716,
-0.6911956668,
-0.0316061899,
-0.2270486206,
-0.7869993448,
0.1163462847,
0.2816507518,
-0.0095226169,
0.4733715653,
0.2330159992,
0.7275680304,
-0.3564188778,
0.1469853371,
0.3852024972,
-0.8251310587,
0.5802362561,
-0.2741301656,
0.5953844786,
0.6156879663,
0.4387235343,
-0.5090129972,
-0.4422755241,
-0.3394727409,
-0.6384336352,
0.8914781213,
0.522335887,
-0.2102685869,
0.2046695352,
0.1745128185,
0.0080347508,
-0.008581561,
-0.7036219239,
-0.0818971023,
-0.3576958179,
-0.3401265144,
0.4733828008,
-0.1766573638,
0.2305290103,
-0.4789181054,
0.2875187695,
-0.0306690708,
0.0810118243,
0.2224274576,
-0.1072475985,
-0.2824826837,
0.4610432684,
-0.3569965363,
0.2257383019,
-0.5533917546,
0.7207798362,
-0.0938627571,
-0.7357513905,
0.2387850881,
-0.2135144025,
-0.4716552198,
-0.2579093874,
0.4415711761,
0.8000156879,
0.3708889484,
-0.2175862789,
0.2594934404,
0.0348019265,
-0.147384733,
0.393098861,
-0.0905702859,
0.0711627007,
-0.3389042318,
0.1707220674,
0.3275827467,
0.2407229245,
-0.5912438631,
0.2734535336,
-0.0606659763,
-0.4330359697,
-0.3803996444,
0.4124425948,
0.2370792329,
-0.3274287283,
0.5481165051,
-0.1181352288,
-0.5961149335,
0.5583389401,
0.9752715826,
0.834535718,
-0.4124755859,
0.2302822471,
0.7373349667,
0.3430719674,
0.1339869499,
-0.1792744547,
-0.5437470078,
-0.7952197194,
-0.2290409356,
-0.5919710994,
-0.2974288762,
-0.0711654946,
-0.5348653793,
-0.3101223707,
-0.6102024913,
-0.0338908248,
-0.074844107,
-0.1805372238,
-0.2400723547,
0.3283616006,
-0.0880302191,
0.9635401964,
-0.6722984314,
1.0302240849,
0.8912619948,
-0.2849003077,
-0.5796611309,
0.3834768534,
-0.2518511117,
-0.3619203269,
0.7441110611,
0.5956759453,
-0.3365096152,
0.053027302,
-0.4169661403,
-0.5641263127,
0.9905259013,
0.0110124098,
-0.3953758776,
-0.373547256,
0.0201330818,
0.6975364685,
-0.3689289987,
0.2095164657,
0.2641773224,
0.3497268856,
0.3635638654,
-0.9023913145,
0.2639063895,
-0.5290057659,
0.2488745749,
0.3815858364,
-0.3978412151,
0.4521411061,
-0.0578488298,
-0.5452904701,
-0.3424634635,
0.5778542161,
0.1258640438,
0.3056988418,
0.5873817801,
0.788243413,
0.7330116034,
0.2583507597,
0.9698671103,
-0.272167474,
0.2005798817,
0.8413686156,
-0.0018477546,
0.8132185936,
0.1245035157,
0.0054053301,
0.6005525589,
0.7178357244,
0.3880993724,
0.3786633909,
0.3278222978,
-0.2353271544,
-0.4118215144,
-0.3246555626,
-0.3030058146,
0.4734812379,
0.1315398067,
-0.1005793735,
-0.39812392,
-0.1152576283,
-0.0029647376,
-0.144847244,
-0.3636155725,
0.778224349,
0.011495797,
-0.2181009352,
0.7259199619,
0.2570087016,
0.9475049376,
-0.5117502213,
0.148958683,
0.0190037861,
0.2824573815,
-0.4616938233,
-0.566909194,
0.37763381,
-0.0549549349,
-0.2917158008,
-0.415561229,
0.7565247416,
-0.5893481374,
-0.3064523339,
0.4211241901,
0.4112340212,
0.1772198677,
-0.2040388584,
-0.4981521368,
-0.1144353375,
-0.2081650794,
-0.0284253769,
0.3928140402,
0.7053949833,
-0.1682480276,
0.5971172452,
0.3406507075,
-0.0164395552,
-0.186693117,
0.12093696,
0.7418656945,
-0.8508252501,
-0.8204852939,
-0.6711709499,
0.1052350774,
0.1846770942,
-0.2280529588,
0.7261455655,
1.0412817001,
0.6573902965,
-0.0449752919,
0.5562465191,
-0.1489104629,
0.0311604068,
-0.3080204725,
0.9559517503,
-0.6109195948,
-0.2034356147,
-0.2741239965,
-0.6939899921,
-0.5903406739,
0.3440960348,
0.044329688,
0.1636882126,
1.0665992498,
0.5967498422,
-0.3950110972,
0.1274957657,
0.3496075869,
0.3460160792,
0.0699026436,
1.0955902338,
0.6524389982,
-0.7384983301,
0.8226228356,
-0.2103230953,
-0.468228817,
-0.1096899584,
-0.5922438502,
-1.0265190601,
-0.7112607956,
-0.5649575591,
-0.2504257858,
0.197407797,
0.4611431956,
1.0433138609,
-0.8075020909,
-0.2797985971,
-0.2058833987,
0.2502605021,
-0.194104895,
-0.1656494439,
0.8555139899,
0.0252101887,
-0.2142002136,
0.2198836654,
0.5518725514,
0.0129515817,
0.2249957472,
-0.1589394063,
-0.1685223579,
-0.3184688985,
0.6152967811,
0.2034503669,
-0.1514471173,
-0.1151358262,
-0.1299253106,
-0.2960470617,
0.551138103,
1.0526031256,
-0.8872228861,
0.378231436,
0.76568681,
0.937340796,
0.2793750167,
0.1444997638,
-0.0001652074,
-0.9032071829,
0.064293541,
0.2963796556,
0.1602173299,
0.1712599397,
-0.5206887126,
0.1961538941,
0.2585920393,
-0.2686800063,
-0.4830078781,
0.3108994961,
-0.9954243898,
-0.1840851903,
0.8777654171,
0.0311493203,
-0.5075719357,
-0.1021936983,
-0.29995507,
0.3174994886,
-0.3857925236,
0.5922169685,
0.3370933235,
-0.0815405175,
-0.4453425407,
-0.0790347606,
0.3822309971,
0.337035805,
-1.088737011,
0.3280892074,
0.1582758874,
-0.1787897199,
0.3772305548,
0.7531133294,
-0.1991889477,
-0.0241704676,
0.3012028337,
0.3584219813,
-0.2582402229,
-0.7621551156,
0.0404323675,
0.3771119118,
-0.1672472209,
-0.3996953368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15175v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15175v1 | Pre-training Multi-party Dialogue Models with Latent Discourse Inference | 2023-05-24T14:06:27 | 2023-05-24T14:06:27 | Yiyang Li, Xinting Huang, Wei Bi, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-party dialogues are more difficult for models to understand than
one-to-one two-party dialogues, since they involve multiple interlocutors,
resulting in interweaving reply-to relations and information flows. To step
over these obstacles, an effective way is to pre-train a model that understands
the discourse structure of multi-party dialogues, namely, to whom each
utterance is replying. However, due to the lack of explicitly annotated
discourse labels in multi-party dialogue corpora, previous works fail to scale
up the pre-training process by putting aside the unlabeled multi-party
conversational data for nothing. To fully utilize the unlabeled data, we
propose to treat the discourse structures as latent variables, then jointly
infer them and pre-train the discourse-aware model by unsupervised latent
variable inference methods. Experiments on multiple downstream tasks show that
our pre-trained model outperforms strong baselines by large margins and
achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) results, justifying the effectiveness of our
method. The official implementation of this paper is available at
https://github.com/EricLee8/MPD_EMVI. | [
-0.3429709971,
-0.4613294601,
0.6952061653,
0.213198185,
-0.4212776423,
0.3095621169,
-0.1200391725,
0.0797964036,
0.0865119025,
0.5630691051,
-0.7529498339,
-0.412280798,
-0.5061514378,
-0.2800045013,
0.1554478258,
1.1418694258,
0.3690707684,
0.3638823032,
-0.3262183368,
-0.1029201522,
-0.0637223423,
-0.8611545563,
-0.1982044876,
-0.3175089657,
0.4782901406,
0.4986374378,
0.2323911339,
-0.0234031249,
0.2336863279,
0.247217536,
-0.0035793923,
0.0918893367,
-0.4858923554,
0.0097009344,
0.0045657246,
-0.3536722362,
-0.6537690163,
0.1145055369,
0.6644501686,
1.0025388002,
-0.1726810336,
0.1116776764,
0.2631284893,
0.2652103007,
-0.9220417738,
0.4280254245,
-0.4684286714,
0.0393883772,
-0.2961402237,
-0.2076646835,
-0.7428897619,
-0.0693532005,
0.0749217272,
-0.6283258796,
-0.2544640303,
-0.1358375251,
0.4670815766,
0.2402086556,
-0.6147600412,
0.0940774456,
-0.8899503946,
0.4051853418,
-0.6661452651,
0.2696819305,
0.3209313452,
0.0437509604,
-0.2482262999,
-0.7182680368,
-0.3832977712,
0.1332210153,
-0.0838712081,
0.4502649307,
-0.0472307168,
0.3669307232,
0.3206759691,
0.078181304,
-0.2219364196,
0.2476483136,
-0.1460536867,
-0.0323838443,
0.2417394072,
-0.0809225291,
-0.1982424408,
-0.1517352909,
-0.5564826727,
0.0470798425,
-0.6841820478,
0.0438327156,
0.533064723,
0.4567932487,
0.0509572588,
0.405523926,
-0.0356750488,
0.4605567753,
0.105995357,
0.065978609,
0.292691052,
-0.5735195279,
-0.1603665948,
-0.0346902646,
0.9631695747,
0.0337838307,
0.1204616427,
0.1455066204,
0.0490617529,
-0.035442166,
0.1086319759,
-0.9690651298,
-0.5651447177,
0.0171982516,
-0.4618169665,
0.0284887366,
-0.0180162005,
-0.7906684875,
-0.3198993206,
-0.2320911735,
0.3987924159,
-0.1808703989,
-0.5327591896,
-0.2709802389,
0.2118472755,
0.1821059436,
0.3144267797,
-0.6666589975,
0.3439726233,
0.5417310596,
0.4806227386,
0.1325583607,
-0.2110118866,
-0.9361177087,
0.1567236185,
-0.2233363986,
1.0541937351,
-0.9560708404,
-0.2736857235,
-0.184602052,
-0.1145752221,
-0.3904308379,
-0.1550839841,
0.4167634547,
-0.2828113139,
0.4267980456,
-0.1539380699,
-0.7402300835,
0.1456261575,
0.0137203448,
-0.3548597693,
0.4185779095,
-0.0706470162,
-1.0545601845,
0.1827815324,
-0.5937492251,
-0.23308523,
-0.1138719171,
-0.369082123,
-0.6895800829,
0.2355698198,
0.5993952155,
0.5467680693,
-0.3350197375,
0.6225686669,
-0.5833707452,
-0.157975316,
0.1605736017,
-0.5205481052,
0.8278116584,
0.0094631938,
0.1051762179,
0.405054599,
-0.750438571,
-0.1043123603,
-0.2344870716,
-0.0117375599,
-0.3232760429,
0.0029772653,
-0.1692256331,
0.2234795392,
-0.0600207299,
-0.6330285072,
0.0671343952,
-0.4322294593,
0.4360819459,
0.7400242686,
0.1493507177,
0.5835219622,
0.0769571662,
0.4817908406,
0.4569072127,
0.1499425471,
-0.4863839149,
-0.4022436142,
-0.6025527716,
-0.3695226014,
0.6166467071,
0.5139026642,
-0.9653800726,
0.3965658545,
-0.0827100277,
-0.4741574228,
-0.3641025126,
-0.3454642296,
0.6834787726,
0.4799687266,
0.2534268498,
-0.5527614951,
-0.4971577525,
-0.7104879618,
-0.2153116316,
-0.4503450394,
-0.0934442431,
0.2217870057,
0.5275396705,
0.1186551005,
0.8673351407,
-0.4153834581,
-0.1243269071,
-0.0873325467,
0.6783208847,
-0.1404363066,
0.5751596093,
0.1278609335,
-0.7086170316,
-0.3441978097,
-0.367312789,
-0.3702332079,
-0.1838330925,
-0.1060767546,
0.0182833839,
-0.0226766467,
0.5956881046,
-0.3798844814,
0.5428558588,
0.6316643953,
-0.1967550367,
0.3889944553,
-0.3766564727,
0.059245944,
-1.240421772,
-0.0391973965,
-0.1969605833,
-0.3118399084,
-0.7712185383,
-0.5113854408,
-0.0486440174,
-0.2506513894,
-0.4625452459,
0.1328210682,
-0.5883839726,
-0.3532398343,
-0.0316136032,
-0.1419135779,
-0.1058744341,
0.9377014637,
0.1871606708,
0.7040825486,
0.3242579103,
-0.4364762306,
-0.1103208736,
0.2355849743,
-0.2678126991,
0.740791142,
-0.4915946722,
0.3599140346,
-0.1816071719,
0.5579664707,
-1.0926326513,
-0.0841056556,
0.3757026196,
-0.3321811259,
0.3625813723,
-0.4714991152,
-0.3889586926,
-0.0322083868,
0.0002635055,
0.377535224,
0.084835887,
-0.4090679586,
0.8098448515,
0.8188365102,
-0.331659168,
-0.6181426048,
-0.4074193835,
-0.1371319443,
-0.1986833364,
-0.2609807253,
0.342004329,
-0.1212909594,
-0.0056012878,
-0.185041815,
-0.1054952145,
-0.5314014554,
-0.0203216523,
0.4424793422,
0.081115894,
-0.105302006,
0.3534322977,
0.0399854705,
-0.3575479984,
0.1174488366,
-0.3997499943,
0.5079404712,
-0.2009172142,
-0.5296222568,
-0.4927234352,
0.397066772,
0.2577626109,
-0.5623236299,
0.8143610954,
0.4949951172,
-0.1196148768,
0.2691532969,
-0.4677805603,
-0.2664584816,
-0.3614780009,
0.2633084655,
-0.4717483521,
-0.96582371,
0.4893780053,
-0.6549657583,
-0.0537796691,
0.1328222454,
0.2917417288,
-0.2443928421,
0.9993651509,
0.5986278653,
0.3749129772,
0.4899870753,
0.0660847574,
0.2892397344,
-0.794611156,
-0.3581277728,
-0.5659708381,
0.2047943175,
-0.7148715258,
-0.7731189132,
0.1224497482,
-0.1381510347,
-0.3885882795,
0.0716209561,
-0.1473827213,
0.4776043296,
0.4638555348,
0.0044206958,
0.354074508,
-0.0665215477,
-0.1675204039,
-0.3132069409,
-0.7387107611,
-0.3937256634,
1.0680273771,
0.2120133638,
0.6643630266,
-0.1960278749,
0.6598572731,
-0.2058766335,
0.2389427423,
-0.4771698117,
0.5188704133,
-0.263635695,
-0.434605062,
-0.1184162721,
-0.6899236441,
-0.828915298,
0.461551249,
-0.2654369473,
-0.7863647938,
0.4758791327,
0.1059512421,
-0.5489650965,
0.3656828105,
-0.8106994629,
1.0149561167,
-0.027705539,
-0.2488388121,
0.0003691572,
-1.0071156025,
0.2710143924,
-0.1933548599,
0.1910835356,
-0.2317242324,
0.1153944507,
0.9182403684,
-0.5465813279,
1.0281318426,
-0.4921292961,
0.1065713242,
0.2589222193,
-0.4179973602,
0.2635740638,
0.1850613356,
0.2427594215,
0.206164971,
-0.0929852799,
-0.3714713454,
-0.5837481618,
0.2521396279,
-0.7871521711,
-0.474021852,
-0.4815562963,
-0.3938859105,
-0.3748025894,
0.0458561704,
0.2680008411,
0.3544293344,
-0.5158107281,
0.3120692372,
0.6294321418,
-0.1609614044,
0.4459804296,
0.5783715248,
-0.0495568253,
-0.3727970719,
0.6963516474,
0.2119145095,
0.2024932057,
0.4468485415,
0.0265238993,
-0.3243075311,
-0.2312332541,
-0.1396077573,
-0.0370149836,
-0.4818959534,
-0.1388789117,
-0.8927097321,
-0.2718155086,
-0.2566539645,
0.4321978092,
-0.8472627997,
-0.5125487447,
-0.4573575854,
0.1298106462,
-0.1523661613,
0.5763074756,
-0.1592237949,
0.7157913446,
-0.4591965973,
0.1669413298,
0.4514522851,
0.247725755,
-0.2583675981,
-0.5052418709,
0.1025886089,
0.1842179745,
-0.3340203762,
-0.9848155975,
0.2229242027,
0.2916043997,
0.416478008,
0.3740094304,
0.2992995083,
0.6604700685,
-0.632743299,
0.4541545212,
0.4491988719,
-0.9715302587,
0.768478334,
-0.3093723059,
0.3207190037,
0.6532729864,
0.4376975298,
-0.0099598709,
-0.2235715389,
-0.7029014826,
-0.7848920226,
0.7180651426,
0.2969564795,
-0.0582480691,
0.3025152683,
0.0474077351,
0.1773134768,
0.4231685996,
-0.7043356299,
-0.1282904148,
-0.3009954393,
0.0602391623,
-0.2307257056,
-0.2931264639,
-0.005004324,
-0.2491005212,
0.5061250329,
-0.2312173694,
0.4588892162,
-0.1589148045,
-0.1244243905,
0.1924698353,
0.5909318924,
0.3813634515,
0.7588247657,
-0.2412468195,
0.1528124213,
-0.0348940603,
-0.2323601544,
0.4455501437,
0.4425803125,
0.2258725017,
-0.2383888513,
0.1616392583,
1.0646215677,
0.3625158966,
-0.0569008961,
0.7599939108,
-0.5750746131,
-0.1896787584,
-0.3467238247,
-0.2323582768,
0.3166932464,
0.3951128423,
0.1362904906,
0.3084664643,
-0.0167732425,
-0.5513247252,
0.2383799851,
0.2514471114,
-0.6207902431,
-0.4560588002,
0.4789549112,
0.2917412519,
-0.3237892985,
0.6007524133,
-0.3637543023,
-0.392223835,
0.3405393064,
0.3633103967,
0.667752862,
-0.4859207571,
0.4855825305,
0.1168285906,
0.2136723846,
0.1119431779,
0.2592282891,
-0.1102347821,
-0.6174736023,
-0.878467679,
-0.3918414116,
-0.6281360984,
0.2120593488,
-0.6981114149,
-0.0311593134,
-0.3446134031,
-0.2500763535,
0.2182261646,
-0.0075022532,
-0.6142921448,
-0.0622416325,
0.1123034656,
0.2579624951,
-1.1455671787,
0.9037194252,
0.6242187023,
-0.4769573212,
-0.6461614966,
0.2670527697,
-0.1741857231,
-0.2940360606,
0.4437508583,
0.3520623744,
-0.0456624217,
0.1073069572,
-0.5128590465,
-0.6376744509,
0.5638993382,
0.8693030477,
-0.6984382868,
-0.0577626415,
0.0019760537,
0.4229851961,
-0.7535214424,
0.649295032,
0.2840625346,
0.2271752656,
0.2305494845,
-0.7584450245,
-0.2039349824,
-0.1065276414,
-0.0209832974,
0.0822397843,
-0.5877878666,
1.0048129559,
-0.1570084989,
-0.0752291307,
-0.3078667521,
0.9270287156,
0.2769749761,
0.3293027282,
0.8367535472,
0.4550943077,
0.9305866361,
-0.1180126518,
0.590726316,
-0.1277104169,
0.1308722794,
1.785084486,
-0.4057127237,
0.9100462794,
0.3303672373,
0.0743630007,
0.6134570241,
0.6719094515,
0.2591131628,
0.6051990986,
0.1944968402,
-0.2351365536,
-0.5698165894,
-0.3746777177,
-0.2651785314,
0.8987000585,
0.5667800307,
-0.149956584,
-0.1025521457,
0.2340607643,
0.0435224622,
0.0204523448,
-0.0749756396,
1.0218546391,
0.1146088317,
-0.7792326808,
0.1561019123,
-0.4483714104,
0.3136454225,
-0.3231205046,
-0.0686290711,
-0.0696600452,
0.2310370505,
-0.0169116948,
-0.5965921879,
0.1471666396,
0.0307026189,
0.0477773547,
-0.3346108496,
0.7103390098,
-0.5632291436,
-0.4120576382,
0.4951685667,
0.7677108049,
0.299184531,
-0.2535755336,
-0.6268364787,
-0.2866536081,
-0.0419315472,
-0.2792245448,
0.3899266422,
0.5600364208,
0.0297604706,
0.3307348788,
0.4640113711,
-0.064273037,
-0.2788066268,
0.5193870068,
1.1335527897,
-0.2301156074,
-0.6625099182,
-0.7900981307,
0.5660327077,
-0.2364263982,
-0.1346880347,
0.5208826065,
0.4522471428,
0.848672092,
0.2299539,
0.4605591297,
0.3266354501,
0.4602419138,
-0.3212531805,
0.5571323037,
-0.342448473,
0.2629026771,
-0.3429774046,
-0.9416713715,
-0.1543801129,
0.7975030541,
-0.3588225543,
0.1587584615,
0.7252607346,
0.6032652855,
-0.1698846817,
0.2843747735,
0.1734327674,
0.2453102916,
0.2669139802,
0.7529472113,
1.0621322393,
-0.1782897115,
0.7567760944,
-0.2352358997,
-0.2333032042,
0.0599988513,
-0.9758734703,
-1.1422581673,
-0.6956092119,
-0.4961735606,
-0.0752226114,
0.1731075495,
0.7013947368,
0.978104651,
-0.6866791844,
-0.1579339653,
-0.1766067445,
0.0401120223,
0.1316508502,
-0.0267526247,
0.2738497257,
-0.2994528115,
-0.5683355331,
0.3312851489,
0.3723368347,
-0.1048022062,
-0.2825054526,
0.0603323765,
-0.6657112241,
0.0822873861,
0.4089558423,
0.0275758393,
-0.41705212,
0.0027736363,
-0.3846821785,
0.1827119142,
0.3891063631,
0.9654067159,
-0.7461739779,
0.5286149979,
0.3410607278,
0.4086627662,
0.8562236428,
0.0576814599,
0.7758574486,
-1.3016079664,
0.2961951792,
0.276671648,
0.1594645381,
0.4503803849,
0.0052550421,
0.4559703469,
0.104838565,
-0.7080306411,
-0.8164582253,
0.3590677977,
-0.5135122538,
-0.424243331,
0.7029511333,
-0.777346015,
-0.1864292622,
-0.3019437492,
0.013263966,
0.7142631412,
-0.4788477123,
0.1532942653,
0.5199301243,
-0.0473649576,
-0.4048552811,
-0.4535617828,
0.4914185703,
0.5362755656,
-1.0569040775,
0.3026644588,
0.4249633253,
-0.1382719278,
0.1591235548,
1.203045845,
0.2283876836,
-0.0932962745,
0.0925807878,
-0.093212001,
0.146903038,
-0.7332581878,
-0.3155475855,
0.2943206131,
-0.1833567619,
-0.1938987523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15138v1 | Topic-Guided Self-Introduction Generation for Social Media Users | 2023-05-24T13:35:08 | 2023-05-24T13:35:08 | Chunpu Xu, Jing Li, Piji Li, Min Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Millions of users are active on social media. To allow users to better
showcase themselves and network with others, we explore the auto-generation of
social media self-introduction, a short sentence outlining a user's personal
interests. While most prior work profiles users with tags (e.g., ages), we
investigate sentence-level self-introductions to provide a more natural and
engaging way for users to know each other. Here we exploit a user's tweeting
history to generate their self-introduction. The task is non-trivial because
the history content may be lengthy, noisy, and exhibit various personal
interests. To address this challenge, we propose a novel unified topic-guided
encoder-decoder (UTGED) framework; it models latent topics to reflect salient
user interest, whose topic mixture then guides encoding a user's history and
topic words control decoding their self-introduction. For experiments, we
collect a large-scale Twitter dataset, and extensive results show the
superiority of our UTGED to the advanced encoder-decoder models without topic
modeling. | [
-0.3222464919,
-0.7666989565,
0.5541941524,
0.2549361885,
-0.6431542039,
0.210830614,
0.0147773838,
0.2490350008,
0.4858080149,
0.4897156954,
-0.889365375,
-0.6982575655,
-0.1395068616,
-0.044993978,
-0.6501573324,
1.1232845783,
0.1392204612,
-0.5256108642,
-0.2301110625,
0.0851439759,
-0.5300941467,
-0.4283846915,
-0.3655610681,
0.0956489593,
0.5875160694,
0.5033560395,
0.328925252,
0.7042730451,
0.1824047565,
0.1080894172,
0.144652158,
0.3074092269,
-0.7338603139,
0.1912805736,
-0.4160443842,
-0.0115344562,
-0.1552158892,
-0.1857107431,
0.5049207807,
0.5999013782,
-0.0237655323,
0.3297430575,
0.1872002035,
0.5804954171,
-0.3167026937,
-0.1955307722,
-0.4479335248,
-0.0650131255,
-0.3761646748,
-0.5933044553,
-0.1648007482,
-0.1072400957,
-0.1842281222,
-0.3193303347,
0.6662386656,
-0.1327180415,
0.6046671271,
0.0687944144,
-0.5487149358,
0.0099994969,
-0.6076750755,
0.3220044374,
-0.1605625451,
0.2513841987,
0.2991608083,
0.2798929811,
-0.2870433927,
-0.4695768654,
-0.4551295042,
0.3929916024,
-0.1971542686,
0.044625707,
-0.385033071,
-0.1141824871,
-0.1788809299,
0.2056503296,
-0.9263133407,
-0.1658104509,
-0.4144461751,
0.0654258654,
0.7729368806,
0.202209115,
0.3111858368,
-0.5961709023,
-0.1703134924,
0.2430121601,
-0.4411975145,
-0.1246722266,
0.4003517628,
0.3442453146,
-0.2071040571,
0.6679756045,
-0.5659658313,
0.3727473915,
0.4576644897,
0.1130193993,
0.0273192581,
-0.3188103139,
0.0364245325,
0.0937508419,
0.9742928147,
0.7380813956,
0.4466848969,
-0.3800558448,
0.1356095821,
-0.0445495546,
0.2386165857,
-0.8818030953,
-0.309325546,
0.2270463258,
-0.6430624127,
-0.2684189379,
0.1994629502,
-0.6781662107,
-0.3797433376,
0.097618036,
0.2253141552,
-0.4013842344,
-0.2503108978,
-0.0127480067,
0.0816080868,
0.0962278917,
0.2880260348,
-0.9994120598,
0.1986361742,
0.5486257672,
0.8925959468,
-0.2421583831,
-0.2226968408,
-0.4629778862,
0.2770430148,
-0.2259157449,
0.7389175296,
-0.370937556,
-0.5410988927,
0.2934889197,
0.1138930321,
0.4102967381,
0.0084017459,
0.1633426845,
-0.5562940836,
0.1799367964,
-0.5038276315,
-0.3817303777,
0.365365386,
-0.2028177083,
-0.0899976045,
0.8883516788,
0.0274297018,
-0.9348182082,
0.493727386,
-1.1724029779,
-0.6771201491,
0.4227476716,
-0.4006129801,
0.0569439493,
0.4104396403,
0.662943542,
0.9859533906,
-0.1036662683,
0.5359858871,
-0.243702352,
-0.1831585318,
0.184951067,
-0.3544813395,
0.4620266855,
0.5844154954,
-0.002601983,
0.0367437229,
-0.538220942,
-0.4660360813,
0.5272606015,
0.0013657783,
-0.3592577577,
-0.03686288,
-0.0511359833,
0.0312542319,
0.344836086,
-0.5584388971,
0.1615634859,
-0.0675676465,
0.6544384956,
0.8806598186,
0.5682284832,
0.5172749758,
-0.1363666952,
0.239776507,
0.0730769932,
-0.1171305478,
-0.6915066242,
-0.345433712,
-0.3411944807,
0.2563383281,
0.2200070471,
-0.0084448336,
-0.6445211172,
0.676145792,
-0.315600127,
-0.3343958557,
-0.3182624578,
0.3755553365,
-0.2027651072,
0.3609364033,
0.2392727435,
-0.0481011793,
-0.3314885795,
-0.7803598046,
-0.278875649,
-0.3002612293,
-0.241698727,
0.4480656981,
0.2165638506,
-0.468791306,
1.0804157257,
-0.8716191649,
-0.1259154379,
-0.3301041722,
0.358869046,
0.0284436159,
0.4960178733,
0.3810172081,
-0.777874589,
-0.6938641667,
-0.2831347287,
-0.7516505718,
-0.2199306935,
-0.3891089857,
-0.5480152965,
-0.1207291856,
0.4409956336,
-0.3135147393,
0.4323868155,
0.4413336813,
-0.4940950572,
0.0562767722,
-0.2530583739,
0.2097360641,
-1.7418903112,
-0.2677351534,
0.3525853753,
-0.1912614554,
-0.4517305791,
-0.3082492054,
0.0240254775,
-0.3173685372,
-0.1354859918,
0.6235377789,
-0.5942754149,
0.1355043501,
-0.4276219308,
-0.0304077771,
-0.0657632872,
0.3829575777,
-0.0609147251,
0.6499018073,
0.620423913,
-0.4613815248,
-0.098801963,
0.2331455499,
0.1065537557,
0.3651267886,
-0.552067101,
0.5535777211,
-0.3784590364,
0.2229327559,
-1.2982269526,
-0.6509977579,
0.2156663984,
-0.6603861451,
0.2964947224,
-0.4299755096,
-0.6183117628,
-0.5840524435,
-0.2680056989,
0.3172565401,
0.6501347423,
-0.9088640213,
0.6696735024,
0.2689338923,
-0.0699232444,
-0.1144771576,
-0.4947669506,
0.4643393159,
-0.3920516372,
-0.7199097872,
0.6277600527,
-0.279415071,
0.2930218577,
0.1618759036,
0.0029041974,
-0.068919912,
0.0449357964,
0.3799963593,
-0.2459553629,
-0.0844637603,
0.2994503081,
0.4269374907,
0.0481302775,
-0.043087177,
-0.3970190883,
0.8703858852,
-0.0892376602,
-0.2137438953,
-0.6074843407,
0.7015330791,
0.2379332781,
-0.2414221615,
0.6154384017,
1.0192023516,
-0.3521255851,
-0.2105349451,
-0.6075524688,
-0.2965191603,
-0.534260869,
0.1698545218,
-0.3989519775,
-1.2480225563,
0.4872258306,
-0.0282649808,
-0.011343468,
0.5549943447,
0.4985506833,
-0.6781791449,
0.8252775669,
0.9646835327,
0.0694620311,
0.4441476464,
-0.1001899615,
0.1092753336,
-0.5808419585,
0.0681496561,
-0.0961791575,
-0.2135391831,
-0.6357043386,
-0.0764072686,
-0.2054799497,
0.0850563273,
0.0824884698,
0.4027630091,
-0.8502637148,
0.3782885671,
0.4814305007,
0.2479260266,
-0.1386263222,
0.0977953747,
0.5175622702,
-0.2420263737,
-0.73057127,
-0.5166003108,
1.2480133772,
0.2549222708,
1.1136280298,
0.1183288693,
1.4137802124,
0.781239748,
0.144447878,
-0.3690260649,
0.5716696382,
-0.2464338392,
-0.509927094,
-0.4186608195,
-0.4544907808,
-1.0574975014,
-0.3103485405,
-0.1264093071,
-0.9004452229,
0.2465155721,
0.3866207004,
-0.5496483445,
0.1525339633,
-0.6446986794,
0.8780546188,
-0.5950495601,
-0.327742219,
0.2132008821,
-0.5950728655,
0.2274699062,
-0.2603333592,
-0.0150099806,
-0.213284567,
0.0432946309,
0.95022434,
-0.0980224609,
0.8817817569,
-0.3262839317,
0.1312626004,
0.2687217593,
-0.0180131868,
0.0615383126,
0.4220218956,
0.4819345772,
0.0209314786,
-0.3830508888,
-0.1674042493,
-0.5429239273,
0.7347943783,
-0.6520855427,
-0.7591086626,
-0.0712974221,
-0.279825747,
0.1238571256,
0.2518498898,
0.4215480387,
0.4268466532,
-0.5204973221,
0.2846536934,
0.6544538736,
-0.0762076005,
0.6174588799,
0.2291211635,
-0.1865482926,
-0.449737817,
0.9221416116,
0.0805072784,
-0.2689301074,
0.2681935728,
0.3675814569,
-0.4275508225,
-0.5944985151,
-0.4647427499,
0.4132606685,
-0.6100245118,
-0.1673368663,
-1.1489281654,
0.0011274663,
-0.7480661273,
-0.5445436239,
-0.3631015122,
0.0036821561,
-0.5899729133,
0.0955718756,
0.3944031,
0.6589439511,
-0.2300382107,
0.650223434,
-0.5930290818,
0.677003324,
0.473128438,
0.1744234115,
-0.3075355589,
-0.6434906125,
-0.1425905079,
-0.023734659,
-0.1263275594,
-0.963075161,
0.4734063447,
0.2501240671,
0.6741793752,
0.7865920663,
0.4741222262,
0.5600622296,
-0.5993119478,
0.6436217427,
0.1503160447,
-0.5506740212,
1.1249676943,
-0.5890760422,
0.2508296072,
0.6359069943,
0.4364574254,
-0.6054611206,
0.0338966176,
-0.6102341413,
-0.7920213938,
0.5812366009,
0.3775376081,
0.8006805182,
-0.2822678089,
0.6914681196,
0.2425735891,
0.1054334342,
-0.6459600329,
-0.3929801881,
-0.6623165607,
-0.2143503577,
-0.0724198148,
-0.5104315877,
0.0089251464,
-0.1821140796,
0.3523610532,
-0.3173859119,
0.4843275547,
0.0917545408,
-0.1137308404,
-0.1272451282,
0.1756467074,
0.1531186253,
0.4995653331,
-0.615075767,
-0.0322630033,
-0.2821654677,
-0.156452775,
0.152925685,
0.3625115752,
-0.1228640154,
0.1190072969,
-0.2615617216,
0.394438386,
-0.047494106,
-0.1358110458,
0.5237089396,
-0.4196678996,
-0.1279630512,
-0.2325742543,
0.0783755928,
0.297632128,
0.0442145765,
0.8616610765,
-0.3734978139,
0.1972553283,
-0.7246198654,
0.2290446013,
0.1474766135,
-0.3499430716,
-0.4608650804,
0.7770431042,
0.5103040338,
-0.6489462256,
0.0800670013,
-0.427004993,
-0.401063025,
0.2120206058,
0.5783530474,
1.3611346483,
-0.1249479651,
0.317673564,
0.3174671233,
0.2009240836,
0.2271715254,
0.2242058367,
-0.5718023777,
-0.6908537745,
-0.1645454168,
-0.6669096351,
-0.0634112507,
0.2687134743,
-0.6773814559,
0.176764667,
-0.2038779408,
-0.2075225711,
0.3611317575,
-0.1370959133,
-0.6392202973,
0.0947750732,
0.0305453911,
0.4946096241,
-0.9628294706,
0.5813000202,
0.7367069721,
-0.1924347281,
-0.3049649596,
0.5607916713,
-0.1359095126,
-0.2147466987,
0.3632811606,
0.3381079137,
0.0439058989,
0.342015475,
-0.6653041244,
-0.6324323416,
1.0467250347,
0.1088638455,
-0.1388949007,
-0.1356241405,
0.2193977535,
0.4428259432,
-0.8356356025,
-0.3308804333,
0.0129673295,
-0.0359226353,
0.0265235901,
-0.3217507005,
0.1202045232,
-0.3430125415,
0.0117388899,
0.1393009424,
-0.6152966619,
0.6198399663,
-0.1974009275,
-0.5597186089,
-0.2727308869,
1.1346888542,
-0.0590302981,
0.4487558007,
0.3506331444,
-0.0046796142,
0.3420135975,
0.013417935,
0.711165607,
-0.4881404936,
0.197891444,
1.1753252745,
0.0534835905,
0.4032747447,
0.3099989295,
0.1306669563,
0.2330909669,
0.8157098889,
-0.1572089493,
0.6960780025,
-0.172766,
0.1044365689,
-0.4157926142,
-0.2405900806,
-0.521635592,
0.5083396435,
0.2227140218,
-0.6002450585,
-0.3902368844,
0.0667103902,
0.0088609597,
0.1892335266,
-0.1630880386,
0.8334901333,
-0.1112452745,
-0.3494350016,
0.2359104455,
0.0759921446,
0.8754726052,
-0.4969600737,
0.0095499959,
-0.5604512691,
-0.4373161793,
-0.097027719,
-0.840184629,
0.1804582626,
0.2493952364,
-0.1375427842,
-0.3056056798,
1.1488599777,
-0.3200497329,
-0.342528522,
0.0911549479,
0.8014000058,
0.0976946652,
-0.2158174813,
-0.5355716348,
-0.3683388531,
0.1690987498,
-0.1177086085,
0.1143859997,
0.6383575797,
0.0486525744,
0.4561016262,
0.7028236389,
-0.6027140021,
-0.2417074889,
0.1620573103,
0.9874358773,
-0.9590783715,
-0.6568112373,
-0.9409703016,
0.3423666954,
-0.1172622442,
-0.3681663871,
0.9135258794,
0.5294761062,
0.6871983409,
0.1974887252,
0.8163095713,
-0.0582472831,
0.3527983725,
-0.0797323063,
0.9984372854,
-0.7862977982,
0.0954963937,
-0.4283294082,
-0.5660034418,
0.1356588155,
0.2081013471,
0.0837687626,
0.2506051064,
0.2029566616,
0.5375952125,
-0.1740718633,
-0.1788730323,
0.4690732658,
-0.1501616836,
0.2490846813,
0.1368165761,
0.8635582924,
0.0537813641,
0.4785921276,
-0.6536836624,
-0.2720145881,
-0.4234173596,
-0.7064707279,
-1.4374691248,
-0.8121262789,
-0.3736643791,
-0.4627244473,
0.3217960894,
0.9601777792,
0.6599367261,
-0.5092563033,
-0.105759725,
-0.0200710297,
-0.2318738848,
0.4006817341,
-0.1550921798,
0.5414063931,
0.0205315296,
-0.3760179281,
0.359603107,
0.2249689549,
0.2321612835,
-0.493056953,
0.0734979361,
-0.153961122,
0.1694307178,
0.2694655061,
0.313159287,
-0.5150960684,
-0.16761069,
0.266528666,
-0.0492019169,
0.2713013887,
0.7972527146,
-0.3773759604,
0.5011675954,
0.289083004,
0.657278657,
0.9110836983,
0.4618785679,
0.4492899776,
-0.8417699933,
-0.2810714245,
-0.0110710785,
0.2969224751,
0.4464292228,
-0.7816314697,
0.5031272173,
0.2508307993,
-0.2627256215,
-0.8289247751,
-0.0081371339,
-1.0702062845,
-0.2565797269,
1.0752800703,
0.2256798446,
-0.1212908998,
-0.2387336493,
-0.1350498945,
0.3527331054,
-0.821487844,
0.8181558847,
0.2313488126,
-0.1071473062,
-0.1958933175,
-0.3073889613,
0.2508083284,
-0.0720703304,
-0.6798804402,
0.1148742884,
0.4001799226,
0.2556533515,
0.0001200013,
0.9479973912,
0.3832336068,
0.3834919035,
-0.0632318705,
0.1017453969,
-0.291467905,
-0.4859178066,
-0.2999625206,
0.2429537028,
-0.2898353338,
-0.3102186918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15130v1 | On Degrees of Freedom in Defining and Testing Natural Language Understanding | 2023-05-24T13:25:20 | 2023-05-24T13:25:20 | Saku Sugawara, Shun Tsugita | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural language understanding (NLU) studies often exaggerate or
underestimate the capabilities of systems, thereby limiting the reproducibility
of their findings. These erroneous evaluations can be attributed to the
difficulty of defining and testing NLU adequately. In this position paper, we
reconsider this challenge by identifying two types of researcher degrees of
freedom. We revisit Turing's original interpretation of the Turing test and
indicate that an NLU test does not provide an operational definition; it merely
provides inductive evidence that the test subject understands the language
sufficiently well to meet stakeholder objectives. In other words, stakeholders
are free to arbitrarily define NLU through their objectives. To use the test
results as inductive evidence, stakeholders must carefully assess if the
interpretation of test scores is valid or not. However, designing and using NLU
tests involve other degrees of freedom, such as specifying target skills and
defining evaluation metrics. As a result, achieving consensus among
stakeholders becomes difficult. To resolve this issue, we propose a validity
argument, which is a framework comprising a series of validation criteria
across test components. By demonstrating that current practices in NLU studies
can be associated with those criteria and organizing them into a comprehensive
checklist, we prove that the validity argument can serve as a coherent
guideline for designing credible test sets and facilitating scientific
communication. | [
-0.4849069118,
-0.7772317529,
0.3172887564,
0.4196394682,
-0.217919156,
0.2719211876,
-0.3574453592,
-0.5387051702,
-0.0860553533,
0.2322016805,
-0.2446288466,
-0.2337649167,
-0.6640362144,
0.5214467645,
-0.5326154232,
0.6726443768,
-0.1964943707,
-0.2121749669,
-0.4634508193,
-0.615177691,
-0.2921133637,
-0.1582235545,
-0.4484140873,
-0.2794547975,
0.5864607692,
0.3040119708,
1.0341128111,
0.5246414542,
0.4236152768,
0.2944310009,
-0.0384155102,
-0.1343344003,
-0.0994712561,
-0.0392091833,
-0.0195270143,
-0.4355715513,
-0.1044088826,
0.1991090924,
0.6877804399,
1.0047661066,
0.1431269944,
-0.0029487216,
0.2665950656,
0.7545980811,
-0.3079744577,
0.0385619476,
-0.5038954616,
0.2000087649,
0.1682818085,
0.0172966085,
-0.5437221527,
-0.6106520295,
0.3209001124,
-0.8423612118,
0.2637561858,
-0.0540339127,
1.1287549734,
0.4043390453,
-0.4363430142,
-0.2779279053,
-0.6280245185,
0.7553408146,
-0.8049792051,
0.610794723,
0.6595518589,
0.1674948335,
-0.0711419433,
-0.3118089437,
-0.6245243549,
-0.3120408654,
0.0953915492,
0.0370751731,
-0.2513952851,
0.0524591282,
0.3441272676,
0.5366974473,
-0.7441728115,
0.1877779514,
-0.5472115278,
-0.0095616458,
0.4508928955,
-0.2506748736,
0.2780002654,
-0.2337347567,
-0.4200579822,
0.0319697633,
-0.331759274,
0.1875308901,
0.377148211,
0.4442533255,
-0.1139542684,
0.754899025,
-0.2122066319,
0.5687597394,
-0.2241231501,
0.1581172943,
0.2847836018,
-0.0200489368,
-0.5617061257,
-0.0559535064,
0.7168399096,
0.2939834595,
0.2531825602,
-0.5655092001,
-0.047483772,
0.1762910485,
0.5220595598,
-0.3871824145,
0.0143973008,
0.42852211,
-0.3403236568,
-0.290109396,
0.1763782054,
-0.5725937486,
-0.30749771,
-0.4490296841,
0.3512656689,
-0.5706424117,
-0.5973734856,
0.1465866864,
-0.2931497395,
0.5895846486,
-0.1133938357,
-0.7550098896,
0.2455902398,
0.9939463735,
0.6152584553,
-0.241510585,
-0.362621218,
-0.1836891472,
-0.3063246012,
-0.4760639668,
0.393381238,
-0.3880206645,
-0.6227040887,
-0.1697823405,
-0.0679740012,
-0.1531037837,
-0.330819577,
0.4202430546,
-0.473908484,
0.5321593285,
-0.4569436014,
-0.4851126969,
-0.2417627722,
0.3811166584,
-0.6056298614,
0.9752787352,
0.3610317409,
-0.6262146831,
0.748891592,
-0.8089527488,
-0.4118148685,
0.1906605214,
-0.2389283031,
-0.0436834209,
0.1251617223,
-0.237591967,
-0.0811764523,
-0.168661356,
0.5951182842,
-0.3108581603,
-0.0835008845,
0.4472374618,
-0.4549812675,
1.130898118,
0.0491727963,
-0.564263463,
0.2186936736,
-0.9857187271,
0.1085945293,
-0.2061712891,
-0.4798260927,
-0.4458555579,
0.1854712069,
-0.3168690205,
-0.0774552599,
-0.3957512081,
-0.666686058,
-0.3067200184,
-0.7553679347,
0.3929131925,
0.7646450996,
-0.3127316833,
0.6106275916,
-0.1871504486,
0.5659950972,
-0.4407259822,
0.168076992,
0.4284159243,
-0.6323545575,
-0.7907104492,
-0.0451075658,
0.3949774802,
0.4299555421,
-0.5862007737,
0.6688702703,
-0.1436878592,
-0.3792850077,
-0.8156273961,
0.0671351627,
0.1376946867,
0.5818618536,
0.3955714405,
-0.1620016396,
-0.6194164157,
-0.9132390618,
-0.4810395241,
-0.3906886578,
-0.3976734579,
-0.0164969638,
0.5608803034,
0.0350303799,
1.2714934349,
0.191436708,
0.1924569011,
-0.2578401864,
0.4408699274,
0.0546180904,
0.4111998081,
0.2730274498,
-0.8747369051,
-0.0618875511,
-0.0768545642,
-1.1282470226,
0.1479330808,
-0.0885679722,
-0.1583988518,
0.2179641277,
0.1407990605,
-0.5724651217,
0.7094596028,
0.3738212883,
-0.5808789134,
0.5264854431,
-0.0861361921,
-0.0369611681,
-0.6384674311,
0.119466953,
-0.0063333921,
-0.0138338069,
-0.675288558,
0.4268316329,
0.0863984376,
0.0288773235,
-0.2696298361,
0.3542533815,
-0.1386982054,
0.3872174323,
-0.402407527,
0.4087128639,
0.3437969685,
-0.1506205797,
-0.1742570847,
0.1702460945,
0.3783200085,
-0.7531317472,
0.1420363337,
0.2862923145,
-0.5800822377,
0.6347792149,
-0.7878846526,
0.171094656,
-0.2936231494,
-0.0264024679,
-0.8051486015,
-0.1139981598,
0.3349882364,
-0.7069377303,
-0.1700119823,
0.174196437,
-0.1882036179,
-0.3758730888,
-0.1429287195,
0.1010136157,
0.2087843865,
-0.3470151722,
0.7180504203,
0.1782177836,
0.3779823482,
-0.7884548903,
-0.9521238208,
-0.0404817797,
-0.5010759234,
-0.6081718206,
-0.0216400307,
-0.0988960639,
-0.8173581362,
0.0599658191,
-0.2528044879,
-0.0569230579,
0.7853016853,
0.6529725194,
0.2485638261,
-0.4253320992,
0.1867092252,
-0.0125331776,
-0.1870996952,
0.6118434668,
0.1924759746,
0.1358285099,
-0.1226571575,
-0.3735624254,
-0.2369502634,
0.4522786736,
0.3022408187,
-0.1948488653,
0.5414253473,
0.6160360575,
-0.5111346841,
-0.1691307873,
-0.3319388032,
-0.1040130332,
-0.4565467536,
-0.1123248413,
-0.4131928086,
-0.9842405319,
0.3212038875,
0.378054291,
0.4944229722,
0.5758926868,
0.1715690196,
0.0023643335,
0.4064329565,
0.6156430244,
0.1623112708,
-0.3541276455,
-0.0399757922,
0.6802060008,
-0.818911612,
-0.1939657778,
-0.8535055518,
-0.2868267298,
-0.5359917879,
-0.2590354681,
-0.2184153795,
0.1569408029,
-0.1136154979,
0.1325664669,
-0.502512753,
0.4112807214,
0.3642839491,
-0.2403550297,
0.2387701869,
-0.2576115131,
-0.3160062134,
-0.0987016484,
-0.212522909,
-0.8852726221,
0.6611071229,
0.5626240969,
0.2701194882,
0.2486935854,
0.5035597086,
0.0313813947,
0.5139076114,
-1.0356388092,
0.53993541,
0.3409960568,
-0.9378721118,
-0.4806568921,
-0.45370242,
-0.9012973309,
0.4392954111,
-0.1136731282,
-0.7176638842,
0.3305526674,
-0.2787494659,
-0.4048187137,
0.4580092728,
-0.5879309177,
0.7469027638,
-0.0836953223,
0.059145052,
0.1753932387,
-0.6072887778,
0.3167236149,
0.0718732253,
0.3962776065,
-0.5613221526,
0.1791020036,
1.02219522,
0.1087256297,
0.6756746769,
-0.2158260196,
-0.0506537035,
0.3308969736,
0.2847059667,
-0.3349409401,
0.2844619751,
-0.5850886703,
-0.0960720628,
0.0305394772,
-0.3964649439,
-0.4349055886,
0.4729487896,
-0.6070274115,
-0.7787758112,
-0.4870200455,
-0.5806128383,
-0.2667224705,
0.2993519604,
0.1302959472,
0.2560512125,
-0.5028888583,
0.5338385701,
0.5633149147,
-0.2536953092,
0.3792120218,
0.3617173731,
-0.2269562781,
-0.1271248609,
0.6867807508,
-0.1006869972,
0.406829834,
0.1428530961,
0.5079210997,
-0.4304388463,
-0.742719233,
-0.2737524211,
-0.0758142248,
-0.7412384152,
0.0433354527,
-0.5000792742,
0.0381598547,
-0.4558218718,
-0.2090266198,
-0.0376210101,
-0.3654559553,
-0.4852749109,
-0.4255691171,
0.3525105417,
0.6117241979,
-0.0506669991,
-0.2142155915,
-0.417958647,
0.6679528952,
0.1710986495,
0.3498329818,
-0.0500479154,
-0.4626091719,
0.1908026338,
0.1944027692,
-0.3093498945,
-0.8165255785,
0.1106513217,
0.1103566363,
0.6282731295,
0.3699190915,
0.374502629,
0.6242198944,
-0.0832067505,
0.8766856194,
-0.0552167557,
-1.127797246,
0.5653579235,
-0.0267913099,
0.2704403698,
0.863245666,
0.841599226,
-0.5087732077,
-0.819801271,
-0.714643836,
-0.9576413035,
0.2351721376,
0.0146352621,
0.1183624417,
-0.1038948819,
0.288004756,
0.5473567843,
0.0509671755,
-0.7352310419,
0.0280403197,
-0.2830502689,
-0.1509703696,
0.0369432978,
-0.0390698649,
-0.4453732073,
-0.3316732049,
0.4443206191,
-0.2021671236,
0.0403643548,
0.4208460152,
-0.231512025,
0.0033349227,
0.5754947066,
0.2403277904,
1.2973159552,
-0.2262195498,
0.320779413,
-0.000612649,
-0.3637652099,
0.093766734,
0.0951939672,
-0.3044348955,
0.0148374718,
0.2701131403,
0.6260367632,
0.0851731822,
-0.4527748823,
0.1170834899,
-0.2105483711,
-0.7392328978,
-0.125834018,
-0.0606887229,
0.0518195145,
-0.1222987771,
0.4943871796,
-0.0192166083,
-0.0500600971,
-0.3048042357,
0.3041700721,
0.3885087073,
-0.6231127977,
-0.1592468619,
0.6070007086,
-0.0003270051,
-0.4803027511,
0.8308067322,
-0.2248708755,
-0.1909347326,
0.5270349979,
0.417024821,
0.729608655,
-0.0183050353,
0.5015314817,
0.1301003098,
0.7659449577,
0.0492321141,
0.5549781322,
0.1080622077,
-0.8143743873,
-0.3835969269,
-0.57656461,
-0.6303300261,
0.2055092156,
-0.9028661251,
-0.2184028924,
-0.7649707794,
-0.0631220713,
0.262162447,
-0.0775048956,
-0.4519722164,
0.2439354658,
-0.1089501604,
1.1967144012,
-0.7194374204,
0.6943756938,
0.2916946411,
-0.2347519994,
-0.7767944932,
-0.2825108469,
0.2755776346,
-0.3260999918,
0.2243599743,
0.3962208629,
-0.1081871465,
-0.4549419582,
-0.2085042298,
-0.4708231986,
0.7325721979,
0.1757560521,
-0.1902317107,
0.0788730532,
0.270106405,
0.4877416193,
-0.2041910291,
0.0870098397,
0.7088972926,
0.757515192,
-0.2184376568,
-0.8454245329,
0.2324342877,
-0.2103601843,
-0.233724758,
-0.0824029222,
-0.0426907763,
0.5114473701,
-0.2894447446,
-0.4468050301,
0.0672963336,
0.9609425664,
0.1979621351,
0.5267826319,
0.7108502388,
0.5446155667,
0.8931615353,
-0.52453655,
1.0239490271,
0.3060241342,
0.2035248727,
0.8641446233,
-0.2377941459,
0.9026761651,
0.6888359189,
-0.1355874389,
0.4479117692,
0.6194874644,
-0.017518023,
0.1336262524,
0.5136556625,
-0.1497850865,
-0.0259718262,
-0.0171984248,
-0.2385033369,
0.4269053042,
0.2371260077,
-0.1935699135,
-0.1348195523,
0.0824804604,
-0.0116836345,
0.4036182165,
0.3161570728,
0.4567970037,
0.0904045254,
-0.5869823694,
0.7960119843,
-0.0294286758,
0.5210869312,
-0.4376033247,
0.316681385,
-0.0109629808,
-0.1689766049,
-0.3380729556,
-0.9365510345,
0.7426606417,
0.2821150422,
0.1151441932,
-0.2537406087,
0.4038735628,
0.0473460965,
-0.3749327362,
0.3490681946,
0.5666937232,
0.1889482886,
0.0148856491,
-0.7349056005,
0.2600992024,
0.0288773496,
-0.1864474267,
0.0454113744,
0.3900029063,
0.318784833,
0.5299678445,
0.5421645045,
-0.1223045588,
0.1791623682,
0.3497367203,
0.4565528631,
-0.652928412,
-0.0950082392,
-0.8857619762,
0.5449185967,
-0.0128045399,
-0.5708344579,
0.8629120588,
0.5913499594,
0.8104055524,
0.2311309874,
0.8350992203,
-0.3979050517,
0.2841746807,
-0.2463822514,
0.5195094943,
-0.2761128843,
-0.0254220348,
-0.0066654603,
-0.5657203197,
-0.712946713,
0.8071206212,
-0.3490636647,
-0.2158012837,
0.8021008372,
0.4287291765,
0.0096350443,
0.7309933305,
0.0547889881,
0.0503452048,
0.5968312621,
0.3182389736,
1.0008414984,
-0.4395819306,
0.2693653107,
-0.3772248924,
-0.1938523203,
0.2755175829,
-0.9458028078,
-0.810428679,
-0.5466584563,
-0.4289630651,
-0.6323853135,
-0.2745462358,
0.8455752134,
0.3746268451,
-0.6862992644,
-0.3899324834,
-0.169937104,
0.4683632553,
-0.3537396789,
-0.280268997,
0.1021348983,
-0.1790517122,
-0.3950867653,
0.6980633736,
0.1769685894,
-0.1786525548,
-0.4599058628,
-0.121081844,
-0.3183137774,
0.0618894435,
0.5580520034,
0.6349508762,
-0.9450665712,
-0.6015214324,
-0.0009467725,
0.1735319197,
0.2335247397,
0.6472156644,
-0.6721870303,
0.5060061812,
0.5715844631,
0.822666049,
-0.1844481677,
-0.1409582049,
0.4376941025,
-0.498118639,
-0.071501188,
0.3641911745,
0.0704193115,
0.4649911821,
-0.0118310377,
0.4452854991,
-0.083504416,
-0.4182981849,
-1.0943697691,
0.1810337156,
-1.256862402,
-0.1321113706,
1.1234920025,
-0.1945171058,
-0.2993974388,
-0.5846693516,
0.2311204076,
0.268307358,
-0.0609424002,
0.8250154853,
0.8283510208,
-0.0109846909,
0.0221724734,
-0.687296927,
0.4741201997,
0.3240014911,
-0.6971141696,
0.1882477403,
-0.125664264,
0.3724952936,
0.3793127537,
0.3047263324,
-0.3608036339,
0.0762974471,
-0.2367359549,
-0.2681299746,
0.1369411051,
-0.1432195157,
-0.3596488833,
0.2464193702,
0.4539773464,
-0.1890131831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15119v1 | Another Dead End for Morphological Tags? Perturbed Inputs and Parsing | 2023-05-24T13:11:04 | 2023-05-24T13:11:04 | Alberto Muñoz-Ortiz, David Vilares | cs.CL | cs.CL | The usefulness of part-of-speech tags for parsing has been heavily questioned
due to the success of word-contextualized parsers. Yet, most studies are
limited to coarse-grained tags and high quality written content; while we know
little about their influence when it comes to models in production that face
lexical errors. We expand these setups and design an adversarial attack to
verify if the use of morphological information by parsers: (i) contributes to
error propagation or (ii) if on the other hand it can play a role to correct
mistakes that word-only neural parsers make. The results on 14 diverse UD
treebanks show that under such attacks, for transition- and graph-based models
their use contributes to degrade the performance even faster, while for the
(lower-performing) sequence labeling parsers they are helpful. We also show
that if morphological tags were utopically robust against lexical
perturbations, they would be able to correct parsing mistakes. | [
-0.237369433,
-1.0452857018,
0.5826694369,
0.1364754736,
-0.4796427786,
-0.0346002989,
0.135965243,
-0.1363046765,
0.0524803698,
0.4719076157,
-0.4705670178,
-0.5166021585,
-0.6840934753,
0.2461174279,
-0.6985465288,
0.6936484575,
0.4271496534,
0.3247406781,
-0.1423971355,
-0.0936003327,
-0.400824517,
-0.8793210983,
-0.9436967969,
-0.3583919704,
0.7912191749,
-0.0886046812,
1.2039413452,
0.8877469897,
0.3821216226,
0.2807952464,
-0.6099997163,
0.0048169685,
-0.1005409881,
0.1888376921,
-0.2291076183,
-0.6109304428,
-0.543715179,
-0.2773249745,
0.5562871695,
0.8893567324,
0.0596332364,
-0.1763322204,
-0.0228471085,
0.2133203298,
-0.4192639887,
-0.2102073878,
-0.8658838272,
0.1044533029,
-0.5949708223,
-0.1663094759,
-0.5929246545,
-0.0046187565,
-0.3297505975,
-0.207084164,
0.0785663798,
-0.6240179539,
1.0845934153,
0.7681747675,
0.2489140034,
-0.0516841896,
-0.5084425211,
0.3722780645,
-0.8642085791,
0.1796171516,
0.4370843768,
-0.1135966107,
-0.6505607963,
-0.8022745848,
-0.3861198127,
-0.0547767691,
-0.0972713009,
0.1618563235,
-0.4424926341,
0.4352837205,
0.3088929057,
-0.0866754502,
-0.3006607592,
0.3040487766,
0.1440606862,
-0.2782528102,
0.212179333,
0.048090633,
0.7133162618,
-0.3607653677,
-0.2275598943,
-0.3576389849,
-0.7639001608,
-0.0007316656,
0.8213129044,
0.359905839,
0.338255316,
0.6930741072,
0.2885452211,
0.8873358369,
-0.0968031883,
-0.0511009172,
-0.3010333776,
-0.4230333865,
-0.1681402624,
0.2367347479,
0.6381103992,
0.166241318,
0.1469260007,
-0.1227244288,
-0.3565962911,
0.331750989,
0.3900710642,
-0.3477585912,
-0.3432772458,
0.2427268624,
0.0418681651,
-0.2430817038,
-0.2339183986,
-0.7874937057,
-0.5808243752,
0.190596953,
0.2509469986,
-0.608151257,
0.1217620671,
0.1528122723,
-0.4682188332,
-0.0092098489,
0.35939008,
-0.6344609261,
0.2732080519,
0.6866944432,
0.9306772947,
0.3592045307,
-0.3749943972,
-0.4009806514,
-0.1696976721,
-0.3409524262,
1.0032852888,
-0.7125635147,
-0.5909361243,
-0.0039989385,
-0.2619387805,
-0.2115905732,
-0.4110557139,
0.5880455375,
-0.3963083923,
-0.3474085033,
-0.2491455823,
-0.2611531019,
-0.1469373107,
-0.0139272781,
-0.6318463087,
0.6404898763,
0.0644710883,
-0.9399423003,
0.1085796207,
-0.3185606003,
-0.6857925653,
0.0837681442,
-0.2251859456,
-0.2038808018,
0.2788130939,
-0.0078979107,
0.2394562662,
0.1666599512,
0.2916226387,
-0.3393945098,
-0.1326612383,
0.3359027207,
-0.7521557212,
0.895565629,
-0.0116547681,
-0.2448365092,
-0.067117542,
-1.0383299589,
-0.181830436,
0.3196260035,
-0.5108245015,
-0.5981813669,
0.4156678021,
-0.2023265511,
0.0039562434,
-0.0586954094,
-0.662121892,
0.1332768798,
-0.4673261642,
0.6054139137,
0.8288327456,
-0.1193911359,
0.0741080791,
-0.1864775866,
0.4749519825,
0.0120445117,
0.0301045757,
-0.4794812202,
-0.6473506689,
-0.6181614995,
-0.2187570632,
0.8294302821,
0.5048617721,
-0.9800696969,
0.3914648294,
0.1438757032,
-0.6129251719,
-0.3945034444,
-0.1796716154,
0.4807412028,
0.6699245572,
0.3038385808,
-0.3816470206,
-0.5850086212,
-0.7880758643,
-0.369818151,
-0.3568422496,
0.0798599571,
-0.0395659991,
0.2934778035,
-0.3305257261,
0.9790513515,
-0.3360183537,
-0.0590327941,
-0.131735459,
-0.0115844244,
0.2086198628,
0.4104050398,
0.4379328489,
-0.6109172702,
0.0754056424,
-0.1972423345,
-0.4066521823,
-0.3913919926,
-0.1651409268,
0.1663910151,
-0.0297357906,
0.3741734028,
-0.7762776017,
0.5303191543,
0.609147191,
-0.2974595129,
0.4905444682,
-0.3459959924,
-0.392714709,
-0.8238781095,
-0.059192799,
0.0567147732,
-0.2270051837,
-0.8094026446,
0.0234198384,
-0.1232617572,
-0.1274565905,
-0.5938283801,
0.3617277741,
0.0509236492,
-0.0179602318,
-0.0249502286,
-0.0753912553,
-0.0599070191,
0.2258073986,
-0.2561410367,
0.8954131603,
0.5651900768,
-0.5803366899,
0.1317083091,
0.2627924085,
0.1668307632,
0.4878505766,
-0.8037472367,
0.0707459897,
-0.3095472157,
0.3290910721,
-1.3091598749,
-0.4338550866,
0.3851736784,
-0.8381978273,
0.4265215993,
-0.4328251183,
-0.7628656626,
0.0463398844,
-0.3415534794,
0.3667120039,
0.3336294293,
-0.5580602884,
0.5129105449,
0.4826785922,
0.0225640275,
-0.4393648803,
-0.9548034668,
0.3888163865,
-0.1586295813,
-0.7542532086,
0.2348880917,
0.2964322269,
-0.3068706393,
0.1293682903,
-0.2386274189,
-0.0968176946,
0.6441636086,
0.0741343424,
-0.0306162164,
-0.1136947125,
0.0054680607,
0.0377958231,
-0.0641668513,
0.2008817494,
-0.3103962243,
0.8783323169,
0.2210833579,
-0.5713033676,
-0.3032574654,
0.1489443332,
0.7119080424,
-0.1821684688,
0.3522410691,
0.3071435392,
-0.6591085792,
-0.0110568563,
-0.2138887197,
0.1307076663,
-0.4352035224,
0.6188938022,
-0.2696054578,
-0.3791861534,
0.6116350293,
0.0656537637,
-0.1019000784,
0.7002693415,
0.2433126867,
-0.1460111439,
1.1849554777,
0.3037496507,
0.2248938084,
0.3196198344,
-0.1169956252,
0.1745775044,
-0.7594791651,
-0.1557188332,
-0.77154392,
0.0238889195,
-0.52646029,
-0.1564894021,
0.1655323952,
0.0083178803,
0.2476002425,
0.5483917594,
-0.3759210408,
0.3486821055,
0.5246021152,
0.0240259692,
-0.0603055209,
0.0085158618,
-0.2544430494,
0.2787991762,
-0.878267467,
-0.6062874794,
0.5865573883,
0.5555046201,
0.9930737019,
-0.1030674428,
0.5526716709,
0.4048632681,
-0.2462776005,
-0.893563211,
0.5099487305,
-0.7168928385,
-0.2325539887,
-0.2850854993,
-0.2599354982,
-0.9879691005,
0.4159414768,
0.258700937,
-0.8934639692,
0.4213330448,
0.2504773438,
-0.5887123346,
0.6913156509,
-0.7471241951,
0.8008054495,
-0.2301275134,
-0.0274044909,
0.291257292,
-0.6202982068,
-0.0027991182,
-0.1290710568,
0.2449691743,
0.0118265329,
-0.1459702551,
0.8296564817,
-0.5612178445,
1.116974473,
-0.2025253922,
-0.1684949994,
0.2868965864,
0.2316137254,
0.2297099084,
0.0692707077,
0.1424885243,
0.4256029129,
-0.0092850951,
-0.2487396151,
-0.3945404291,
0.4258499444,
-0.6373118162,
-0.8700299263,
-0.5299882293,
-0.2917743325,
-0.2858281136,
0.1516206712,
0.5593582988,
0.7413221002,
0.0846547037,
-0.0260846801,
0.7721580267,
-0.0964920297,
0.5951228738,
-0.1719229966,
0.2468901128,
-0.4744744599,
0.7799296975,
0.3127938509,
0.3123694956,
0.1468446106,
0.213559255,
-0.3152299821,
-0.6748216152,
-0.8233033419,
0.172025308,
-0.9627885818,
-0.4026310146,
-0.6845985651,
-0.2808536291,
-0.4549437463,
0.1064654887,
-0.4661457241,
-0.3457586467,
-0.5713071227,
0.1110434309,
-0.0660637096,
0.9845918417,
-0.0221651439,
0.5765176415,
-0.932990551,
0.0041664089,
0.1346679181,
0.2772012055,
-0.1037948877,
-0.4803046882,
0.2506833971,
0.2515964508,
-0.113997601,
-1.2560920715,
0.0998585969,
0.1286306828,
0.3672073185,
0.2966151237,
-0.3142054081,
0.5735282898,
-0.7200385928,
0.8322612643,
0.0979609415,
-1.0186223984,
0.4862672985,
-0.3422877789,
0.5239522457,
0.4036991298,
0.3469683826,
-0.6968515515,
-0.5288254619,
-0.8963189721,
-0.9559180737,
0.8751806617,
0.2460390627,
0.3991571367,
-0.3085798919,
0.3765723407,
-0.066705063,
-0.0538220778,
-0.4025213718,
-0.3437469304,
-0.3149433434,
0.0739756525,
0.0392741077,
-0.551138103,
0.029413458,
-0.035813529,
0.5454370379,
-0.0364035815,
-0.099573493,
0.615683496,
-0.0196625963,
-0.0529575758,
0.2576319277,
0.6407180429,
0.6508936286,
-0.02280288,
0.5360835195,
0.0308735725,
-0.416245997,
0.2572191954,
0.1044478789,
-0.4837709069,
0.500764668,
0.2993373871,
0.673656106,
0.1486414373,
-0.6635209918,
0.387153089,
-0.2080369145,
0.1762218773,
-0.0033509962,
-0.0877419189,
-0.0183608104,
-0.0072791465,
0.0935552642,
0.4996292293,
-0.1465518922,
-0.5703023076,
0.2995679677,
0.4322070479,
-0.4982551634,
-0.650564611,
0.5146770477,
-0.0977179408,
-0.587844193,
0.1656055897,
-0.2196161747,
-0.8698661327,
0.572152555,
0.7073963881,
0.783722043,
-0.4497810304,
0.1562564373,
0.0653413832,
0.394713074,
0.1179208606,
-0.0612906329,
0.1446735859,
-0.6121148467,
-0.3609912992,
-0.7309929132,
-0.38921538,
0.1971175373,
-0.3294070065,
0.1919214576,
-0.8126946688,
-0.4650794864,
0.3434205651,
-0.8460206985,
-0.1707772464,
0.3654229343,
0.3043048084,
0.8510310054,
-0.6417855024,
0.5624513626,
1.1557754278,
-0.3963800967,
-0.434024483,
0.1006527394,
-0.0570991077,
-0.7730106711,
0.6169091463,
-0.128971085,
-0.2528791726,
-0.0501333661,
-0.2417685241,
-0.9445502162,
0.2094383538,
0.3526797891,
-0.1340671331,
-0.241284743,
0.2541913688,
0.6601526141,
0.2648833692,
0.1391877234,
0.702504456,
0.3759069145,
0.2455561012,
-0.6629473567,
0.0689320788,
0.0589326769,
0.2082371414,
0.3766748011,
-0.3855705857,
1.1747381687,
0.2653942406,
-0.6492508054,
0.104027383,
0.3506934941,
-0.3221060336,
-0.126770705,
0.4982800186,
0.9258192778,
0.5227870345,
-0.2422471941,
1.1700080633,
-0.061324209,
0.0879770219,
0.9757823348,
0.0872758701,
0.6582119465,
0.4486640692,
-0.3219278455,
-0.047774557,
0.8526130319,
-0.1964335144,
0.3432082236,
0.4837477207,
0.0314480253,
-0.1607675403,
-0.3305076957,
-0.2294175923,
0.6693770885,
0.5993070006,
-0.0141049856,
-0.7585319877,
-0.1953324825,
0.4629714787,
0.0721707344,
-0.1881109625,
0.7549303174,
-0.056264028,
-0.6169971228,
0.5739271045,
0.3527805805,
0.5875602961,
-0.6571974158,
-0.1501694471,
-0.3170959949,
0.1993873566,
-0.3788009286,
-0.7270562649,
0.4765255749,
-0.0074761175,
0.2168072462,
0.0964555815,
0.8033803701,
-0.1334096491,
-0.2566367686,
0.3784575462,
0.2589846849,
0.0269084238,
-0.2014886737,
-0.432264924,
0.1640246361,
-0.0351902023,
0.0435578823,
0.2902166247,
0.1001740545,
0.1257892847,
0.4607183337,
0.6274752021,
0.4836657047,
0.3550261855,
0.1323115826,
0.9891079664,
-0.4803977013,
-0.1849290282,
-1.2919347286,
0.4948851466,
0.105240941,
-0.4288769066,
0.7467086315,
0.2827969491,
1.2098748684,
0.2244535387,
0.66330266,
0.0902985707,
-0.1531150192,
-0.6604317427,
0.6216302514,
-0.5167714953,
0.1711478382,
-0.2594215572,
-0.7384049296,
-0.6445012689,
0.2159526497,
0.0662876219,
-0.228928715,
0.7924183607,
0.5118383169,
0.0746789351,
-0.1278248578,
0.6535428166,
0.298178494,
0.3738611639,
0.1310915053,
1.130271554,
-0.3374813497,
0.425272882,
-0.4779728949,
-0.1679966301,
0.0419372134,
-0.5844947696,
-0.8144960403,
-0.4995315373,
-0.1881390512,
-0.6415464878,
0.3648567498,
0.494633913,
0.2653902769,
-0.5226846933,
-0.0275997575,
-0.0765753165,
0.211019069,
0.3129858673,
-0.1430487484,
0.2790779769,
-0.7594177127,
-0.4983090758,
0.4839423299,
0.3778374195,
0.2116893828,
-0.2102932632,
0.5045346022,
-0.2917450964,
0.3327383995,
0.3791399002,
0.1815908104,
-0.8728874326,
-0.3154993951,
-0.2689489424,
-0.0438867845,
0.3723924756,
0.7215306759,
-0.3548796773,
0.2847034633,
0.4951610267,
1.064665556,
-0.2682409585,
0.1720528901,
0.3003958166,
-0.7693704367,
-0.0267592017,
0.3265102506,
0.8134723306,
0.4147460759,
-0.5254737735,
0.2859617472,
0.5504707694,
-0.1686232984,
-0.784778893,
0.3221817315,
-0.5911237597,
-0.4474156499,
1.2003451586,
-0.3212064207,
-0.7164874077,
-0.0534711815,
-0.3806975186,
0.2347452044,
-0.3782161772,
0.4401144087,
0.9278045297,
0.0527004004,
0.3209612072,
-0.1503060907,
0.5463569164,
0.579315722,
-0.5903864503,
0.0961129963,
0.3947933912,
-0.0179569945,
0.5302140117,
0.3236804307,
-0.1971665919,
0.3878389001,
0.4147672057,
-0.2703411877,
-0.0241221189,
-0.5142424703,
-0.7723978162,
0.2915371656,
0.3620806336,
-0.3044309318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15108v1 | The Role of Output Vocabulary in T2T LMs for SPARQL Semantic Parsing | 2023-05-24T12:55:04 | 2023-05-24T12:55:04 | Debayan Banerjee, Pranav Ajit Nair, Ricardo Usbeck, Chris Biemann | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we analyse the role of output vocabulary for text-to-text (T2T)
models on the task of SPARQL semantic parsing. We perform experiments within
the the context of knowledge graph question answering (KGQA), where the task is
to convert questions in natural language to the SPARQL query language. We
observe that the query vocabulary is distinct from human vocabulary. Language
Models (LMs) are pre-dominantly trained for human language tasks, and hence, if
the query vocabulary is replaced with a vocabulary more attuned to the LM
tokenizer, the performance of models may improve. We carry out carefully
selected vocabulary substitutions on the queries and find absolute gains in the
range of 17% on the GrailQA dataset. | [
-0.3663622737,
-0.7405917645,
0.3005425334,
-0.0646808296,
-0.1485527158,
-0.2430129349,
0.1791736484,
-0.4155426919,
-0.0579122938,
0.938292861,
-0.3769306839,
-0.4048271477,
-0.7522693276,
0.0052245744,
-0.5385972261,
0.9598181844,
0.033900924,
0.120787628,
-0.4606063962,
0.0205922835,
-0.6309258342,
-0.7267132401,
-0.9925776124,
-0.5860045552,
0.6514623761,
0.1887581348,
0.7978792191,
0.5006747842,
0.1991791427,
0.2133987099,
0.0365273245,
0.1258520335,
-0.5732346177,
0.1319964528,
-0.543035388,
-0.4897289276,
-0.3021679223,
-0.0956846997,
0.7069211006,
0.993950665,
-0.0122607481,
0.1716662496,
0.1780982167,
0.6558490992,
-0.3668057919,
0.1222428381,
-0.7542545199,
-0.1062051356,
-0.2783609927,
-0.2703182101,
-0.5065823197,
-0.006314598,
-0.0498407595,
-0.4901946485,
0.290042907,
0.22747235,
0.9519087076,
0.2595030069,
-0.6716502309,
-0.1866241246,
-0.4885896742,
0.6793145537,
-0.6306568384,
0.5003837347,
0.4569488168,
0.3170765042,
-0.3450103402,
-1.0925389528,
-0.4611570537,
-0.1000555083,
-0.5134888291,
0.1168268323,
-0.1417721957,
0.3010499477,
0.0160777345,
0.041924689,
-0.6037818789,
-0.0096052708,
-0.2624459863,
-0.1799051464,
0.3518939316,
0.2942647338,
0.4188570082,
-0.4130000472,
-0.209598124,
-0.0574463643,
-0.5962614417,
0.1189269722,
0.182863459,
0.3901081085,
0.616176486,
0.8860883117,
-0.3605614305,
1.0189493895,
-0.3945034742,
0.1649043113,
-0.2621088624,
-0.5063489676,
-0.1024311855,
-0.1451800466,
0.5762840509,
0.4492104948,
0.2775247693,
-0.4627858996,
-0.281131357,
0.0136849415,
0.2975118756,
-0.8794600964,
-0.2379023582,
0.1056731045,
-0.1334956288,
-0.0904053897,
-0.0155781386,
-0.4437547624,
-0.2634469569,
-0.1191862151,
0.7290478349,
-0.3506893814,
-0.3924775124,
0.4463472068,
-0.6571823359,
0.1582769156,
0.1719143987,
-0.6626501679,
0.9175774455,
0.7451374531,
0.6154944301,
-0.0480684265,
-0.2530774772,
-0.6785984635,
0.3780989647,
-0.493758142,
0.8095174432,
-0.2806744576,
-0.3737826347,
-0.0495885834,
-0.0851153731,
-0.4818224609,
-0.6113151312,
0.5016520619,
-0.9895325303,
0.4116036296,
-0.5454966426,
-0.9844684005,
-0.2478767335,
0.2182216495,
-0.5842949748,
1.1885213852,
0.3931441605,
-0.7126264572,
0.3214055896,
-0.8464027047,
-0.3107414544,
0.1612493098,
0.1522501409,
0.0701123253,
-0.1486319155,
-0.0409743898,
0.3093285561,
-0.2709254324,
0.1107447669,
0.0893957242,
-0.236831829,
0.5511910319,
0.0564344972,
0.4073170424,
-0.0549045242,
-0.1319171339,
-0.1123998687,
-0.3739339709,
0.343568325,
0.1345689446,
-0.2715609074,
-0.4635596275,
0.3217425644,
0.071172677,
0.3140996397,
0.1005816013,
-0.3445122242,
-0.0179481432,
-0.7105305791,
0.4733193517,
0.3165522218,
0.2520369291,
0.3897965252,
-0.2712452412,
0.4418798685,
0.0219179317,
-0.2252340913,
0.3278675675,
-0.679612875,
-0.7484968901,
0.0541712865,
0.6703649163,
0.4833499789,
-0.8304684162,
0.2210247219,
-0.3322533071,
-0.3873340189,
-0.3567198813,
0.2278254628,
0.4039451182,
0.7426457405,
0.2596071959,
-0.2511701882,
-0.4146929979,
-0.7979459763,
-0.7881135941,
-0.3136833012,
-0.0166787691,
0.2382442355,
0.3966124058,
-0.0318987072,
1.272338748,
-0.5933795571,
-0.4227843583,
-0.5490474105,
0.0464702137,
0.151581496,
0.3343292475,
0.5412896276,
-0.837723434,
-0.2748537362,
-0.1284869313,
-0.4154162109,
-0.38321051,
0.2704425752,
-0.6346231103,
0.2309865057,
0.4501001835,
-0.9060140252,
0.2947799265,
0.1990667433,
-0.821201086,
0.3291790485,
0.0551966354,
0.0366904512,
-1.2277559042,
-0.1134211943,
-0.2482683361,
-0.2966131866,
-0.9054178596,
-0.0159800518,
-0.1470050812,
0.1013612375,
-0.3958193958,
0.7745833993,
-0.1519038379,
-0.5883247256,
-0.153390795,
0.2205613703,
0.6024509072,
0.1640378833,
0.1245826036,
0.9747211337,
0.1607366055,
-0.7560970187,
0.2717458308,
0.3256816268,
-0.2026838362,
-0.1112714559,
-0.8382627368,
-0.1116429195,
-0.0541085638,
0.0408988483,
-1.3832176924,
-0.3204125464,
0.2302886099,
-0.7903180718,
0.2321968675,
-0.1847986579,
-0.7762029171,
-0.2763278484,
-0.1052556559,
0.1521181762,
0.4781475663,
-0.255859822,
0.5489204526,
0.3233046532,
0.1023576781,
-0.3822374046,
-0.9346656799,
0.0166254789,
-0.10713429,
-0.7648142576,
0.3741681874,
0.443849951,
-0.1253047436,
0.3130035102,
0.1689353138,
-0.1137779728,
0.2662929595,
-0.0531544983,
0.2269049436,
-0.3383675218,
0.5716481805,
0.1674746275,
-0.0220603738,
0.2826103866,
-0.4814135432,
0.8854648471,
0.1316511184,
-0.252805233,
-0.191374436,
0.3438897431,
0.0121051734,
-0.2562368512,
1.1203216314,
0.6444434524,
-0.2331258357,
0.0071047004,
-0.4015856981,
-0.2684239745,
-0.4510483742,
0.7800610662,
-0.3394134641,
-0.8839221597,
0.470339179,
0.0707132518,
-0.2223931402,
0.8171744347,
0.4502984583,
-0.1431210488,
0.875402391,
0.2596161962,
0.2026529014,
0.3138878047,
-0.2877851427,
0.1652318984,
-0.7357872128,
-0.0945616961,
-0.6063359976,
0.0228021294,
-0.4912418425,
-0.4211225212,
0.3763029873,
0.3733434677,
-0.4101474583,
0.1582168788,
-0.2932021618,
0.369261682,
0.6522103548,
-0.0193650294,
0.1797787547,
-0.0248403735,
0.2650935352,
-0.0488835685,
-0.9431146383,
-0.6293671727,
0.9442834854,
0.0384084359,
0.4278342724,
0.3120785356,
0.6800596118,
0.390502274,
0.0224114582,
-1.0670392513,
0.6804890037,
-0.1724606454,
-0.495461762,
-0.4070673883,
-0.3438259661,
-0.9972287416,
0.3750538528,
0.0660832226,
-0.5713477731,
-0.3291592896,
0.1265414357,
0.0618745573,
0.2679365873,
-0.8773594499,
1.2645868063,
0.1248094141,
-0.3437976837,
0.0396733135,
-0.4435784221,
0.1679213494,
0.2209346294,
-0.0396525748,
0.1313073784,
-0.4000174999,
1.0791355371,
-0.3905181885,
0.719035089,
-0.3335965276,
0.0577467419,
0.5020455718,
0.1375991702,
0.3118122816,
-0.0765037313,
-0.0819181353,
0.0630084574,
0.2420401424,
-0.5007837415,
-0.4564959705,
0.4172317982,
-0.9062502384,
-0.8858780265,
-0.2365943193,
-0.6429267526,
-0.5346178412,
0.2038357407,
0.2198836952,
0.6230592132,
-0.1300930083,
0.0735220239,
0.486436367,
-0.0114625283,
0.1278419644,
0.2401154786,
-0.4921737313,
-0.077694416,
0.7325387597,
0.3913289011,
0.5985409021,
0.5553984642,
0.1293001622,
-0.7340694666,
-0.4511797428,
-0.5934448242,
0.2366821617,
-0.9134069681,
-0.2543148696,
-1.0317666531,
-0.3331743181,
-0.8049246073,
0.1900200099,
-0.0965547487,
-0.7478064299,
-0.3613212109,
-0.0127832303,
0.4637678862,
0.8787798285,
0.3909350932,
0.4452329874,
-0.9450951815,
0.1764055192,
0.467464596,
0.0118091926,
-0.1249758229,
-0.634008944,
-0.0800374821,
0.0115941809,
-0.1990440041,
-0.942758441,
0.4452545047,
0.3974700272,
0.4766823947,
-0.0108215716,
0.0432466269,
0.5773871541,
-0.3476407826,
1.2195163965,
-0.037865974,
-0.8679065704,
0.4630954862,
-0.4203667641,
0.1904845685,
0.1907612532,
0.2035218179,
-0.8184772134,
-0.2999792695,
-0.4467143118,
-0.698438108,
0.794467628,
0.2075867504,
0.2235568911,
-0.1855977327,
0.3118387759,
-0.0464321189,
0.3708118498,
-0.3483177423,
0.0201776307,
-0.3513146043,
-0.0967054814,
-0.0278471801,
-0.5730834603,
-0.1104101613,
-0.1466648579,
0.6257006526,
-0.1251521558,
0.3925617039,
0.0228895694,
-0.0382748768,
-0.0224677175,
0.3457752168,
0.1784269959,
0.62383008,
-0.0531050302,
-0.0212308913,
0.0924549028,
-0.2050990611,
-0.2841863632,
0.0783908963,
-0.1449040622,
0.1553355306,
0.4217942059,
0.700848043,
-0.0016245464,
-0.5963884592,
0.5539954901,
0.0361633152,
-0.2989187539,
-0.240731746,
0.2674997747,
0.4819680154,
0.1246141642,
0.3596562445,
-0.1228296459,
0.3806880116,
-0.3661250472,
0.0438688248,
0.4640972018,
0.0128885796,
-0.1055799723,
0.64233917,
-0.3371825218,
-0.0731292963,
0.475232929,
-0.1562631428,
-0.7031448483,
0.7355804443,
0.7277971506,
0.3135814965,
-0.0100392243,
0.2667594254,
0.2403330803,
0.0913276672,
0.1243787706,
0.2923512161,
0.0483037718,
-0.9942386746,
-0.437102437,
-0.7583847642,
-0.259942323,
-0.1615395844,
-0.8377932906,
0.1243445799,
0.0924816653,
-0.2732636034,
0.0462316871,
0.1061871871,
-0.441606611,
0.3488233685,
-0.2466794252,
0.8031070828,
-0.6709624529,
0.9250881672,
0.8772704601,
-0.3963069022,
-1.0142865181,
-0.2393420339,
-0.4413068891,
-0.72951895,
1.1216818094,
-0.0285712704,
-0.0695571825,
0.2757689655,
-0.3207014799,
-0.7746115923,
1.1414666176,
0.0947566852,
0.1307985634,
-0.3234844208,
0.7849054337,
0.5896580815,
-0.3232509494,
0.0092680976,
0.5224783421,
0.3141155541,
0.2657372355,
-0.8063335419,
-0.1469606757,
-0.0602833182,
0.4319083691,
0.4965122342,
-0.4108082056,
0.955284059,
0.1750339419,
-0.1457463056,
0.2115354836,
0.6287927628,
0.0145097692,
0.2440485656,
0.3271421492,
0.4919947982,
0.5048940778,
-0.2336568534,
1.2274183035,
-0.216753751,
0.315061003,
0.9662752151,
-0.2105962783,
0.9165254831,
0.631324172,
-0.260528326,
0.2539167106,
0.6524293423,
0.399091512,
0.5666502118,
0.12075793,
-0.1302101016,
-0.3709150255,
-0.4217893183,
-0.3986686468,
0.4570942819,
0.643304646,
-0.3111679554,
-0.335708797,
-0.149333477,
0.1195985675,
0.1643259674,
-0.4250210524,
1.0100815296,
0.0371985137,
-0.7126772404,
0.6703426242,
0.081575267,
0.2241193205,
-0.6859332919,
0.00176131,
-0.1679537296,
0.223678261,
-0.2524626553,
-0.9463958144,
0.5852406025,
-0.2053693384,
-0.2705136836,
-0.159043625,
1.1847738028,
-0.4653461277,
-0.353744179,
0.4172744751,
0.9185730219,
0.1296034455,
-0.1912769228,
-0.5659840703,
-0.3638832271,
-0.2741384804,
-0.4869199991,
0.5815963149,
0.5596982837,
-0.0281406101,
0.432087332,
0.4634797275,
0.093919985,
0.3856019378,
0.0370483287,
1.1962339878,
-0.5518733263,
-0.4379504621,
-0.5715793371,
0.3129436076,
-0.1257193536,
-0.1423147917,
0.7684959769,
0.4530800581,
0.8204977512,
-0.1532045305,
0.6124001741,
-0.1529422998,
0.8359857798,
-0.6943321228,
0.7682803869,
-0.6495580077,
0.1049802005,
0.0306100734,
-0.698481977,
-0.0640073568,
0.0539535657,
-0.4380694628,
-0.0092988759,
0.5914016962,
0.9977904558,
0.1264882535,
-0.0817516297,
0.5559651852,
0.0356413014,
0.2533305287,
0.4224043787,
0.7166116238,
-0.5795726776,
0.5674136877,
-0.0740728229,
0.2192984968,
0.0807634816,
-0.616084218,
-0.8684771657,
-0.5649707317,
-0.0943906605,
-0.7191638947,
0.1162693426,
0.7037039995,
0.2548735142,
-0.6786591411,
-0.3961924613,
-0.1300996244,
-0.0635211021,
-0.0727783144,
-0.3523306847,
0.3654495478,
-0.7634934187,
-0.4702093005,
0.1349025965,
-0.1078450903,
-0.2250210345,
0.0593814626,
-0.0839129686,
-0.3402002454,
0.0018733863,
0.6559910774,
-0.1930932701,
-0.644384861,
-0.2817000449,
0.051111076,
-0.1573135704,
-0.0111447191,
0.5348662734,
-0.8424060345,
0.0869915262,
0.4920588732,
0.9189509153,
0.4332602322,
0.0232440066,
0.4877329469,
-0.9010386467,
0.0054457057,
0.2392870188,
0.2458521575,
0.381301254,
-0.3036969006,
0.6013767719,
0.421143651,
-0.4981598854,
-0.5360760689,
0.198487699,
-0.8001170158,
-0.2588320374,
1.4765523672,
-0.1176718026,
-0.5309312344,
-0.2595810592,
-0.3378905952,
0.4963989556,
-0.2984903157,
0.1479396522,
0.8065561652,
-0.0972271487,
-0.2038840204,
-0.7671860456,
0.6565667391,
0.4837714732,
-0.5909645557,
-0.0130845951,
0.5090571046,
0.3610929847,
-0.0558415465,
0.7895449996,
-0.1702785343,
0.2331299335,
-0.078171514,
-0.0222033393,
-0.0077157947,
0.2472921759,
0.0823423564,
0.3444676101,
0.4773796797,
-0.2126229852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15099v1 | Fourier Transformer: Fast Long Range Modeling by Removing Sequence Redundancy with FFT Operator | 2023-05-24T12:33:06 | 2023-05-24T12:33:06 | Ziwei He, Meng Yang, Minwei Feng, Jingcheng Yin, Xinbing Wang, Jingwen Leng, Zhouhan Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The transformer model is known to be computationally demanding, and
prohibitively costly for long sequences, as the self-attention module uses a
quadratic time and space complexity with respect to sequence length. Many
researchers have focused on designing new forms of self-attention or
introducing new parameters to overcome this limitation, however a large portion
of them prohibits the model to inherit weights from large pretrained models. In
this work, the transformer's inefficiency has been taken care of from another
perspective. We propose Fourier Transformer, a simple yet effective approach by
progressively removing redundancies in hidden sequence using the ready-made
Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) operator to perform Discrete Cosine Transformation
(DCT). Fourier Transformer is able to significantly reduce computational costs
while retain the ability to inherit from various large pretrained models.
Experiments show that our model achieves state-of-the-art performances among
all transformer-based models on the long-range modeling benchmark LRA with
significant improvement in both speed and space. For generative seq-to-seq
tasks including CNN/DailyMail and ELI5, by inheriting the BART weights our
model outperforms the standard BART and other efficient models. \footnote{Our
code is publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/LUMIA-Group/FourierTransformer}} | [
-0.52720505,
-0.6350863576,
0.3545572758,
0.4442754984,
-0.3855541348,
0.0792153627,
0.114165321,
-0.58317101,
-0.0535064042,
0.5026487112,
-0.6452825665,
0.1101707891,
-0.6516667604,
0.0017215571,
-0.9171952009,
0.8449388146,
-0.0039548008,
-0.2023075074,
0.009855086,
-0.0216279719,
-0.2423459888,
-0.1345328093,
-0.6029557586,
-0.3460727334,
0.4867465496,
0.1906417757,
0.7350324988,
0.6368224621,
0.8956900239,
0.3108318448,
0.068959631,
-0.4671840072,
-0.8175991774,
-0.0123741655,
-0.0615268014,
-0.2814492285,
-0.4844116569,
-0.3781856298,
0.6753826737,
0.5860376358,
-0.0545137562,
0.3079656065,
-0.1465824544,
1.0231461525,
-0.4603037238,
0.0208361521,
-0.2608616352,
0.1858331263,
-0.1766667664,
0.0535390154,
-0.246471107,
-0.4560279846,
0.2943785787,
-0.5241194963,
0.7356054187,
-0.0773199722,
0.4516129792,
0.7041563392,
-0.6140947938,
0.3348771632,
-1.3470973969,
0.6911141872,
-0.3915693462,
0.9298354387,
0.0727348849,
0.7553348541,
0.1010184735,
-1.0347678661,
-0.5731487274,
0.0364144109,
-0.1561286449,
0.3222960234,
-0.48736462,
0.0497961491,
0.5347597003,
0.5547161102,
-0.684315145,
-0.2375792712,
-0.5786893964,
0.1075894758,
0.6173698306,
-0.1081808507,
-0.167726174,
0.0422263779,
-0.5771905184,
-0.0938456953,
-0.7251769304,
0.111099951,
0.2708491683,
-0.3424664438,
-0.1431484967,
0.4221499562,
-0.3589758575,
0.4366387129,
0.6425514817,
0.2059617788,
0.0376929007,
-0.1482487768,
-0.4544112086,
-0.0444224477,
0.483089298,
-0.0826406628,
0.1324745268,
-0.0590938292,
-0.2657443881,
-0.1787920296,
0.5014067888,
-0.9921089411,
-0.5036051273,
0.1626527011,
-0.4423767626,
0.0337840877,
-0.1989701688,
-0.9010609984,
0.0567038208,
-0.2280460745,
0.5130239129,
-0.292852968,
-0.0894277617,
0.1249867976,
-0.0018415474,
0.2834136486,
0.4770556986,
-0.9141814113,
0.4735329449,
0.512180388,
0.5622941256,
-0.2335083634,
-0.0007469344,
-0.3893448114,
-0.1001110673,
-0.1562155634,
0.5231467485,
-0.1463007182,
-0.4566014409,
-0.482516557,
0.0442319401,
0.1058655307,
-0.3678793609,
0.5100344419,
-1.0447157621,
0.2826990485,
0.0036444773,
-0.4315633774,
-0.358168751,
-0.1923331171,
-1.0950616598,
1.1354085207,
0.4284454584,
-0.3821132183,
-0.0467886552,
-0.8559284806,
-0.624612391,
0.2060007304,
0.2074099481,
-0.7887865305,
0.1413989812,
0.3284404278,
0.3564448357,
-0.4358933568,
0.4560379386,
-0.1496000439,
-0.696797967,
-0.015472508,
-0.810279727,
0.5553062558,
0.2817840576,
-0.5194247365,
0.2532383204,
-0.9981327653,
-0.4771746993,
0.2776883245,
-0.1280577779,
-0.0476527959,
-0.1541597545,
0.1540088803,
0.2430050373,
-0.0569925942,
-0.5753220916,
-0.0592616573,
-0.6038997173,
0.417922169,
0.5560256243,
-0.1222159117,
0.7125363946,
-0.3214020729,
0.6815439463,
-0.1946234107,
0.3601077795,
-0.2927611768,
-0.1485897452,
-0.7647426128,
-0.5712534189,
0.0997321159,
0.3081018627,
-0.5807055235,
0.5021255612,
-0.6380774975,
-0.5533185601,
-0.4617822766,
-0.2035495639,
-0.0757067055,
0.4616581202,
0.6643416286,
-0.2963561416,
-0.3419855535,
-0.8259708285,
0.0618212,
0.4202657938,
-0.159503147,
-0.1256327331,
0.4445260763,
-0.1703941971,
1.06536448,
-0.5229249001,
0.0129097933,
-0.1590128392,
-0.041594144,
0.2238942385,
0.5125427842,
0.3631348908,
-1.0753535032,
-0.4859306514,
-0.2075538188,
-0.3680826724,
0.1796467602,
-0.2893743515,
-0.0587619431,
-0.1203038618,
0.4611945152,
-0.7027834058,
0.7354274392,
0.4430916011,
-0.0304543078,
0.3638127446,
0.0799636021,
0.0714126527,
-0.8733397722,
0.1950733364,
0.0040056333,
-0.4364297986,
-0.7946714163,
-0.0189229213,
0.4273173809,
-0.3357981145,
-0.6137058139,
0.4664151073,
-0.1860524267,
0.0236854739,
-0.128552109,
-0.472928375,
0.098473452,
0.7624564171,
0.1060314402,
0.6821076274,
0.0686655641,
-0.3722406924,
0.4686436951,
0.1798027158,
-0.2308000326,
0.469955653,
-0.9790487885,
0.0740213543,
-0.2984451354,
0.3680104017,
-1.0303903818,
-0.0360205695,
0.2678328454,
-0.0532442741,
0.3095108271,
-0.1253206879,
-0.0348109566,
-0.7299399376,
-0.2423118502,
0.9832109809,
0.5870110393,
-0.8397577405,
0.5170403123,
-0.1303277165,
-0.1888637692,
-0.5732134581,
-0.5155083537,
-0.14194341,
-0.238808468,
-0.5383651853,
0.6084490418,
-0.3578535616,
0.1094540954,
-0.149513796,
-0.2793033421,
-0.0672507808,
-0.0129867718,
0.268605113,
0.1861964613,
-0.1438612789,
0.3643918037,
0.1403953284,
-0.1976624578,
0.0253162961,
-0.1708914787,
0.5900084972,
-0.0541373305,
-0.5532232523,
-0.4803790748,
0.5635670424,
0.820374012,
-0.5654582977,
0.2247663289,
0.6728044152,
-0.3465020061,
-0.2522294223,
-0.5972726345,
-0.3081133962,
-0.5440564752,
0.6919907928,
-0.2677512169,
-1.0840275288,
0.3668713868,
-0.1980292648,
-0.3306427002,
0.7227647901,
0.2481429428,
-0.125873819,
0.596971333,
0.7333661318,
-0.0072992211,
0.6301594377,
-0.3503687084,
0.5052732229,
-0.5819951892,
0.0896849409,
-0.1443114281,
-0.3133520186,
-0.3246665597,
-0.4432177842,
0.4865718782,
-0.1622508466,
-0.6725901365,
0.5285781026,
-0.6364602447,
0.4573273063,
0.6079111099,
0.1014464125,
0.089587979,
-0.1078276709,
0.6513318419,
0.1581007987,
-0.5714055896,
0.1558136642,
1.0248484612,
0.645421803,
1.0748347044,
0.0065653999,
0.7163982391,
0.3403502703,
0.1696777344,
-0.8764491677,
0.3206514418,
-0.0858956799,
-0.4042406082,
-0.7085880637,
-0.3409731686,
-0.8539161086,
0.1326571554,
-0.033131443,
-0.1560316384,
0.5805623531,
0.0195542965,
-0.6849344969,
0.1569061428,
-0.3987524509,
0.7675030231,
-0.2132388204,
-0.3510919809,
-0.2527483702,
-0.7495202422,
0.4514083862,
-0.6338458657,
-0.1564821005,
0.0290804747,
0.4871185124,
0.7103742957,
-0.3714265823,
0.7588384748,
-0.0199437644,
-0.2120127976,
0.1897812486,
0.0105097238,
0.7329970002,
-0.070613429,
0.0634231046,
0.3737717271,
-0.0556981117,
-0.3079120219,
-0.5239142776,
0.272171706,
-0.5497528911,
-0.6216601133,
-0.2708916664,
-0.6255311966,
0.2080641389,
0.4139381051,
0.2717635334,
0.3332615197,
-0.3641056716,
0.2841998041,
0.6602732539,
0.0243783426,
0.7854081988,
0.2149180174,
0.0244180728,
-0.4271634221,
0.5817881823,
0.0843849331,
0.368291378,
0.6402668357,
0.0615747608,
-0.3494919538,
-0.3988116682,
-0.1459258497,
0.2121679634,
-0.5169790983,
-0.4057125151,
-0.5220629573,
-0.4304383993,
-0.3251591325,
-0.2603434026,
-0.70312953,
-0.5256288648,
-0.1194083244,
0.0733000785,
0.198627919,
0.6066820025,
0.23430866,
0.7429049611,
-0.8838560581,
0.726238668,
0.7526940703,
0.5606411695,
0.1144687831,
-0.4588679671,
-0.4681622982,
-0.0874416456,
-0.5212934613,
-0.5406589508,
0.6226689219,
0.1298437715,
0.3693998158,
0.3826067746,
0.1812296212,
0.6006013155,
-0.5970384479,
0.5012983084,
0.3302927017,
-1.2646137476,
0.1858254671,
-0.2194300741,
0.6170427203,
0.1148488671,
0.3587959707,
-0.5325543284,
-0.0443438664,
-0.2592234015,
-0.6539105773,
0.6627562642,
0.2559549809,
-0.0530492999,
0.1244283617,
0.3011237681,
0.1795746684,
0.0866573602,
-0.7889590859,
-0.1835442483,
-0.5334054232,
-0.2626793385,
-0.1697587818,
-0.3703343272,
-0.1322435886,
-0.4113583267,
0.4340171814,
-0.1902100146,
0.7907741666,
0.4711803496,
-0.3116891086,
-0.5497092605,
0.3858718574,
0.5889914632,
0.4535209239,
-0.2936089635,
0.1851374656,
0.2817882299,
-0.5366693735,
0.3162279129,
0.5043854713,
0.0385545082,
-0.3743751943,
0.3402101994,
0.6029341817,
0.3267950714,
-0.15480645,
0.5782835484,
-0.0809561834,
-0.1490941942,
-0.3509911895,
-0.0564266741,
0.2147707194,
0.5585513711,
0.5678554177,
0.481013,
0.339835614,
-0.1023745015,
0.3864195049,
0.1891025752,
-0.3071703315,
-0.3243663311,
0.9419699311,
0.1649711281,
-0.2091379762,
0.6552506685,
0.1026454195,
-0.4065329731,
0.7063171268,
0.6344184279,
1.0435426235,
-0.5628077984,
-0.0783924237,
0.1158929691,
0.2011324614,
-0.3095824122,
0.01647144,
-0.3169971704,
-0.3908549845,
-0.498985976,
-0.6029143929,
-0.0920798406,
-0.1177281067,
-0.6517013907,
0.1966677755,
-0.1898514628,
-0.0382960662,
0.2347238511,
-0.2063053995,
-0.8142031431,
0.3593346179,
0.1378867179,
0.8875827789,
-0.5907799602,
1.2540082932,
-0.1476632059,
0.0711119249,
-0.3538320363,
-0.0825815424,
-0.3864638209,
-0.6625285745,
0.7315650582,
0.1869956106,
-0.3231074214,
0.2199027389,
-0.2947252393,
-1.087630868,
1.2610763311,
0.3552422822,
-1.1092880964,
-0.1167404354,
0.3168891668,
0.5178285837,
-0.0414416566,
0.097448051,
0.4224924445,
0.3117292225,
0.3521847427,
-0.7223110795,
0.131137684,
-0.1530399024,
-0.0459104404,
0.4841282368,
-0.6828148365,
0.9499238133,
-0.1516270041,
-0.2585858703,
0.1005800441,
0.7827595472,
-0.3679959178,
0.5199762583,
0.567647934,
0.4747921824,
0.5090221763,
-0.0651754811,
0.7851765752,
-0.270830214,
0.6496667266,
1.0824762583,
-0.3687348366,
0.6064326763,
0.3938129842,
-0.5061351061,
0.1032705605,
0.3379930258,
-0.3334718049,
0.6776661277,
0.0415139124,
-0.275470823,
-0.0586644039,
0.5187655091,
-0.5089883208,
0.4365953803,
0.0377950221,
-0.320482254,
-0.2407756597,
0.094583638,
-0.3568733037,
-0.2065648437,
-0.2701035142,
0.4418268204,
0.0782658309,
-0.5601101518,
0.6944131851,
-0.1011415347,
0.6498279572,
-0.735214889,
-0.1513276249,
-0.2385427356,
0.2193098664,
-0.1145588905,
-0.4202328026,
0.6678438783,
-0.3861056864,
-0.3422133625,
-0.2876403332,
0.6566809416,
-0.603962779,
-0.6098390222,
0.3222981691,
0.2687058449,
-0.4010748565,
-0.42601946,
-0.3780400455,
-0.0910327211,
-0.0857885852,
-0.3855007589,
0.0548054837,
0.0171696227,
-0.1594166756,
0.64817518,
0.7721945047,
-0.3621927798,
-0.0009301676,
-0.1412420124,
0.745767951,
-0.9727008343,
-0.5362042785,
-0.7581862807,
0.2907591164,
0.2357086092,
0.1590047777,
0.6480864286,
0.6466374397,
0.687635839,
-0.4688307643,
0.5005534887,
0.349378109,
0.3017036319,
-0.0593733117,
0.8184548616,
-0.3758419454,
0.1093231812,
-0.1841519773,
-1.0577403307,
-0.6102540493,
0.3881548643,
-0.43440485,
0.1303831786,
0.6664409041,
0.5600445271,
-0.3025659323,
0.2727154791,
0.5583141446,
0.0313886255,
0.4511838555,
0.6005012989,
0.749596417,
-0.6294128895,
0.389618814,
-0.6196272969,
-0.033758454,
-0.2514480948,
-0.7672957182,
-0.6817376018,
-0.5172730684,
-0.1844295412,
0.0637185499,
0.0818707198,
0.8526527882,
1.0030460358,
-0.6755007505,
-0.1807774603,
-0.0861803368,
0.0530035719,
-0.4944140017,
-0.2305505872,
0.6488280892,
0.1588590592,
-0.787227869,
0.4344104528,
0.3413610458,
0.3462127149,
-0.0450377837,
0.0552017242,
-0.0855317861,
0.2199842781,
0.8901858926,
0.3346027136,
-0.4902579486,
-0.4326142073,
0.2045212984,
0.0409064554,
0.4071601629,
0.6030237079,
-0.8931615353,
0.5068592429,
0.3699480891,
0.4771817625,
1.0078828335,
0.0768502876,
0.5497415066,
-0.5048348308,
-0.1244000643,
0.29393363,
0.3104972839,
0.2091218978,
-0.785808146,
0.4924180806,
0.2662119269,
-0.8183665276,
-0.4079144001,
0.1447497457,
-1.3630720377,
-0.0811074898,
0.612870276,
0.086257264,
-0.3080766499,
0.0501751415,
-0.2527885437,
0.5820767283,
-0.2700799704,
0.8294239044,
0.1429917514,
-0.1286441535,
-0.3941844106,
-0.1857934445,
0.5602782369,
0.2690481842,
-0.6832848191,
0.1672973186,
0.1857906878,
0.4405643344,
0.1127623171,
0.4774186909,
-0.0716761276,
0.562790215,
-0.1294838488,
0.3922691643,
-0.1391958296,
-0.4495789111,
-0.8818206787,
0.4408097267,
-0.4320269525,
-0.2015074641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15098v1 | Referral Augmentation for Zero-Shot Information Retrieval | 2023-05-24T12:28:35 | 2023-05-24T12:28:35 | Michael Tang, Shunyu Yao, John Yang, Karthik Narasimhan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose Referral-Augmented Retrieval (RAR), a simple technique that
concatenates document indices with referrals, i.e. text from other documents
that cite or link to the given document, to provide significant performance
gains for zero-shot information retrieval. The key insight behind our method is
that referrals provide a more complete, multi-view representation of a
document, much like incoming page links in algorithms like PageRank provide a
comprehensive idea of a webpage's importance. RAR works with both sparse and
dense retrievers, and outperforms generative text expansion techniques such as
DocT5Query and Query2Doc a 37% and 21% absolute improvement on ACL paper
retrieval Recall@10 -- while also eliminating expensive model training and
inference. We also analyze different methods for multi-referral aggregation and
show that RAR enables up-to-date information retrieval without re-training. | [
-0.1241680607,
-0.5194302201,
0.544503212,
-0.346467346,
-0.0019489602,
0.1671488881,
0.1831700206,
-0.8358793855,
0.3892310262,
0.313816458,
-0.2516131699,
-0.0836554989,
-0.5774649978,
0.267445147,
-0.3841525018,
0.9769685268,
0.4454154968,
0.0365837961,
-0.4398533702,
-0.4849743843,
-0.2706595361,
-0.4492824078,
-0.4330138266,
-0.5387738347,
0.8814022541,
0.4789344072,
0.5649710894,
0.7462751865,
1.1285202503,
0.2463471442,
0.2269757986,
0.0866656676,
-0.4049286842,
0.3355836272,
-0.2135339826,
-0.4568251073,
-0.550126791,
-0.031144375,
0.6759694219,
0.7852770686,
-0.0546404906,
0.1374898851,
-0.2022436112,
0.9286903143,
-1.2882541418,
-0.1209492981,
-0.5423062444,
-0.1465409994,
-0.3189513385,
-0.7456427217,
-0.5063256621,
-0.5922634006,
-0.0612667501,
-0.6732473969,
0.7811669111,
-0.0426194556,
0.6155126691,
-0.0051202062,
-0.2365723997,
-0.1957553774,
-0.9308674335,
0.5431935787,
-0.1026377007,
0.3386313915,
0.4119259715,
0.467396915,
0.2359464318,
-0.9238972664,
-0.6023852229,
-0.0993819833,
-0.0891189352,
0.1878036261,
-0.3416658044,
0.177284047,
0.3436455727,
0.6774537563,
-0.4420855343,
-0.522295177,
-0.6760505438,
-0.0023554938,
0.4176204801,
0.0318138041,
0.1979185343,
0.2273615152,
-0.2259224653,
-0.4268282056,
-0.6197829843,
-0.2209163308,
0.2022885531,
0.2989031374,
0.203283146,
0.7937663794,
-0.354282707,
0.9992204309,
0.5300682187,
0.1706413627,
0.4983325005,
-0.5350890756,
0.0708185136,
0.4105150104,
0.4988989234,
0.2601478696,
-0.0444620326,
-0.3206559122,
-0.0540367588,
-0.0088691935,
0.4389584959,
-0.8686619401,
-0.0683259964,
0.0929517671,
-0.3231573701,
-0.2433288097,
0.4033620059,
-0.3911832869,
-0.4879506528,
-0.0449574292,
0.7454270124,
-0.6829018593,
-0.0582420975,
0.0015584651,
-0.6830579042,
0.3371165395,
0.4862516522,
-0.5739918351,
0.1318464577,
0.5774433017,
0.7794088721,
0.2242747247,
-0.332582593,
-0.9472740293,
0.4647445381,
-0.2172731757,
1.3394808769,
-1.241738677,
-0.5594328046,
0.1810481101,
-0.1984298527,
0.0704807788,
-0.5610020757,
0.4279720187,
-0.8473413587,
-0.0157573968,
-0.2257510126,
-0.4767435491,
-0.2230356634,
0.3609251082,
-0.849069953,
1.0394755602,
0.4079994857,
-0.6657705903,
0.3175802827,
-0.6975676417,
-0.4372826517,
0.3701448739,
-0.1244489178,
0.0088623986,
0.2118913233,
0.1358285099,
-0.0304494202,
-0.1517086625,
-0.594697237,
-0.3177195489,
-0.6137446761,
0.1032887176,
-0.2251854092,
0.3387928307,
0.245165363,
0.315102607,
-0.0275303982,
-0.8044861555,
0.1318046749,
0.0508601852,
-0.3638965487,
-0.7213113904,
-0.4109680951,
0.0459094979,
-0.1349999458,
0.4303053916,
-0.7006669044,
0.3720998168,
-0.496106714,
-0.2631973326,
0.2057928741,
0.4155201614,
0.6806162596,
-0.6082657576,
0.5434887409,
0.1104198843,
-0.0742026493,
-0.9390426278,
-0.2656264305,
-0.7047975063,
0.0653127581,
0.3233610392,
0.3101323545,
-0.7917928696,
0.1664585024,
-0.4587836266,
-0.4477135241,
-0.7549597025,
0.0747067854,
0.411377281,
0.6659944057,
0.5507968664,
-0.4583780766,
-0.4187531471,
-0.382599175,
-0.1896381229,
-0.1423722804,
0.0148423789,
0.2658618391,
0.0691542998,
0.1099427342,
0.8157457113,
-0.6704177856,
-0.5524650812,
-0.1927174628,
0.3526060879,
0.1568701714,
0.3282420337,
0.6464655399,
-0.7955465913,
-0.7286333442,
0.0893293247,
-0.6856927872,
0.0916413888,
0.0227512103,
0.225473702,
-0.2131056488,
0.2628315687,
-0.3997235298,
0.5232256055,
0.0442877375,
-0.1265731752,
0.195967108,
-0.5662060976,
0.4748174548,
-0.9695634842,
0.2197412848,
0.2262541056,
-0.1037685573,
-0.6189035177,
0.3810170889,
0.2526361346,
-0.4209925234,
-0.2261770666,
0.5541532636,
-0.7864406705,
-0.03915767,
-0.6068924069,
0.1862406582,
0.1583207399,
0.1099241823,
-0.0608668514,
1.2551248074,
0.5295987129,
-0.5506237745,
0.3239592016,
0.2617948353,
0.1085646376,
0.9555467367,
-0.6389626861,
0.3509349525,
-0.7274275422,
0.255962491,
-1.0386323929,
-0.1549218893,
0.1743485332,
-0.7246628404,
0.4650585651,
-0.1630152911,
-0.2045861781,
-0.1127542779,
-0.7142332196,
0.7591676116,
0.0513360165,
-0.5181208849,
0.6179819703,
0.3314219415,
-0.0383159146,
-0.7851490974,
-0.4626950324,
0.1318227947,
0.3805400729,
-0.2960143089,
0.5717847943,
-0.0462260619,
-0.088023968,
0.314589262,
-0.1084054485,
-0.3830025196,
-0.5067331791,
0.1516060978,
0.2513484359,
-0.2217558175,
-0.0931662321,
-0.2836097181,
-0.434846729,
-0.5360617638,
-0.0210691635,
0.4827735722,
-0.0267851688,
-0.5440931916,
-0.2832030952,
0.4545761645,
0.5728257298,
-0.3593400717,
0.6190730929,
0.4817920029,
-0.2494831085,
0.47903651,
-1.0434001684,
-0.1384814233,
-0.4317651987,
0.0478557236,
-0.375587374,
-0.6512086391,
0.3317270577,
0.2142366022,
-0.1677642018,
0.6114390492,
0.232493937,
0.0414077751,
0.7075052261,
0.7992998958,
-0.1216971427,
0.782347858,
-0.366351366,
0.097830005,
-1.0762040615,
-0.4509241581,
-0.8299936056,
-0.0873908773,
-0.4287496209,
-0.6304550171,
0.4416260123,
0.0430322737,
-0.0314595476,
0.464574188,
-0.7427322268,
0.6653874516,
0.5941905379,
0.1693252921,
0.5589962006,
0.2256590873,
0.1167387888,
0.0142551102,
-0.5108799934,
0.1980796158,
1.2314965725,
-0.257550776,
0.9802467227,
0.1349780262,
0.6698512435,
0.5877684355,
0.3509740531,
-0.982286334,
0.2637163699,
-0.0020040355,
-0.5240671039,
0.0309225693,
-0.1027025357,
-1.1257710457,
0.1476275623,
-0.4668824077,
-0.5134720802,
0.7107228041,
0.1150131971,
-0.5068926811,
0.036876753,
-0.6103996634,
0.1711478084,
0.1109757721,
-0.5629149079,
-0.5511758327,
-0.4975435138,
-0.0364223681,
-0.0773553401,
-0.182297945,
0.328917563,
-0.1814143658,
0.3981631696,
-0.635202527,
0.2651026249,
-0.0821550041,
0.3213224709,
0.3731454611,
-0.1483305693,
0.4598445594,
-0.3815290332,
-0.4625785351,
0.2098855078,
0.0626388043,
-0.2917174995,
-0.7875644565,
0.7300288081,
-0.5715517402,
-0.3528408706,
-0.9876360297,
-0.5436767936,
-0.1271389425,
0.3726953864,
-0.0522061251,
0.6136177778,
-0.0130601097,
0.7335337996,
0.5604421496,
0.1154018492,
0.4170652926,
0.9790209532,
0.2384258211,
-0.6396387815,
0.8597763777,
0.0920003653,
-0.0206922032,
0.8266850114,
-0.1579831988,
-0.507235527,
-0.3746446073,
-0.1779465526,
0.3645977676,
-0.4182317257,
-0.5163172483,
-0.6312385798,
-0.4184660017,
-0.6041320562,
-0.1842284054,
-0.0662884638,
-0.5238186717,
-0.0350126587,
0.0010178569,
0.5218647122,
0.4933942258,
-0.3973689973,
0.561817944,
-1.0357149839,
0.4546388388,
-0.0465111323,
0.4371803403,
0.1882563829,
-0.4772650003,
-0.3554992676,
-0.115363881,
-0.4381276667,
-0.8811805844,
0.060022112,
0.2426403612,
0.4672430456,
0.7166680694,
0.1634277105,
1.1298921108,
-0.7459710836,
0.5491325259,
0.532785356,
-0.1639299989,
0.6839104295,
-0.3460730016,
0.3838456571,
0.9577213526,
0.3068721294,
-0.2575954497,
-0.126545012,
-0.6045851707,
-0.8466783166,
0.785783112,
-0.0019441423,
0.3860855103,
-0.2322160751,
0.6900199652,
-0.3610699177,
-0.1047277823,
-0.2736003697,
-0.4697487354,
-0.0083808387,
0.0975389108,
0.1285140961,
-0.7941287756,
0.0094682807,
-0.1663608551,
0.4959934354,
-0.079681918,
0.4550599754,
0.5522898436,
-0.0571035407,
-0.4225888252,
0.215630576,
0.2884887755,
0.7724523544,
-0.702101171,
0.0324145705,
-0.1619781554,
-0.7612840533,
0.310180217,
0.3396382332,
-0.1651673466,
0.1567138284,
0.2400482446,
0.4749548435,
0.1983130574,
-0.2834693193,
0.6824055314,
-0.0184507314,
-0.2190048695,
-0.3847804666,
0.1956502944,
-0.5964595079,
0.1035323218,
1.095671773,
0.216564998,
0.4078271389,
-0.6656165123,
0.56270051,
0.684559226,
-0.8601578474,
-0.1380785704,
0.7693473101,
0.2208521068,
-0.4123663306,
0.4397262931,
0.2055198401,
0.2409273088,
0.2193421721,
0.8353083134,
0.963614881,
-0.2699881792,
0.0509463623,
0.6902528405,
0.1136279032,
-0.0157927815,
-0.0852256119,
-0.4230880737,
-0.703450799,
-0.4768389463,
-0.5255075097,
-0.5554491878,
0.0524087884,
-0.8871730566,
0.0940481052,
-0.4267849624,
-0.1252535433,
0.2991518676,
0.0717224777,
-0.336280942,
0.1703052968,
-0.3150061667,
1.0252883434,
-0.3775703311,
0.839802444,
0.9219462276,
-1.1167814732,
-0.3387750387,
0.2586322129,
-0.1306438297,
-0.8302432895,
0.5691275597,
-0.0366706811,
-0.4860703349,
0.1785024703,
-0.1495731324,
-0.7913709879,
1.0677011013,
0.1657151431,
-0.3440652788,
-0.0899936259,
0.0486368574,
0.4400272071,
-0.1677660793,
0.8561729789,
0.008032551,
0.2144343853,
0.7484735847,
-0.541423738,
-0.095837988,
-0.3989053965,
0.1678978354,
0.3456701338,
-0.4800651371,
0.4546059668,
-0.4257426262,
-0.1846138686,
0.0182173736,
0.6884219646,
0.0310046207,
0.3841183186,
0.1407628506,
0.5812540054,
0.5789483786,
0.0538214669,
1.4241927862,
-0.8054563999,
0.25454247,
1.1095027924,
-0.3901579678,
0.9498563409,
0.556877315,
-0.0828494281,
0.4529298544,
0.0607094094,
-0.0638925135,
0.5757076144,
-0.6432526708,
-0.8369070292,
-0.0597100668,
-0.5949538946,
-0.6750565171,
0.2570192218,
0.2191214114,
-0.1927930415,
-0.8600372672,
-0.3308811486,
-0.1928346604,
0.104903087,
-0.2943565249,
1.0901366472,
-0.1414304972,
-0.5035057664,
0.2974871397,
0.036067903,
0.4889836907,
-0.8299192786,
-0.4184324145,
-0.2411446273,
0.49682796,
-0.3324944675,
-0.6852301955,
0.3797259629,
-0.0960762277,
-0.5187684894,
0.0020107182,
1.0741460323,
-0.3784579337,
-0.6541498303,
0.0363358185,
0.464410007,
0.0650662705,
-0.1344341636,
-0.6066706777,
-0.2975330651,
-0.2702683806,
0.2421725392,
0.5835933089,
0.2915028632,
0.1196298972,
0.509224236,
1.0124332905,
0.2012971491,
-0.3211862445,
0.1969105154,
0.9504338503,
-0.6606853604,
-0.126630038,
-0.7368061543,
0.2692937553,
-0.245745644,
0.1957480907,
0.7065519691,
1.0676234961,
0.7481026649,
-0.0086325631,
0.8000688553,
-0.2049012631,
0.5653138161,
-0.0795987621,
0.6360757947,
-0.6688194871,
0.0301447269,
-0.2958114147,
-1.0630347729,
-0.55147475,
0.7530353069,
-0.1803591996,
-0.0112189827,
0.5537121892,
1.0728362799,
-0.2545341551,
-0.4068026841,
0.3936192989,
-0.2630763054,
0.0878669322,
0.1764059514,
0.494687587,
-0.9076490402,
0.8777242899,
-0.1458485574,
-0.2322149426,
-0.3538277149,
-0.6847437024,
-0.3669709861,
-0.4812663198,
-0.298979193,
-0.4738631248,
0.2346712053,
0.6923087835,
0.4820585549,
-0.6743466854,
-0.0706306025,
0.1393924654,
0.0180378444,
-0.1267117858,
-0.2734996974,
0.0896865502,
-0.642116487,
-0.6785534024,
0.4160420299,
0.6783987284,
-0.1871864349,
0.0517715849,
-0.0902462974,
-0.516492188,
-0.0241936371,
0.566675961,
0.6019125581,
-0.2891135216,
-0.1790206581,
0.0798268691,
0.0026482777,
0.5773774981,
0.9829030037,
-0.9698066711,
0.8559724689,
0.589363873,
0.7355008125,
0.677847743,
0.6077132225,
0.4723757505,
-0.7883377671,
0.3892933726,
0.0203349777,
0.0632736534,
0.3650565147,
-0.3279621005,
0.6605182886,
0.2678133249,
-0.2945908904,
-0.6105599403,
-0.066247046,
-1.1105606556,
0.1416122913,
0.8568693995,
0.1141000465,
-0.1244121641,
-0.0631770268,
-0.2247629315,
0.117052339,
-0.6738756895,
0.6276842952,
0.1633598655,
-0.3537011147,
-0.4133352339,
-0.2538997531,
0.207412377,
-0.0732846558,
-0.4437584281,
-0.2197692096,
0.9034180045,
0.3199873269,
0.6848683357,
1.1888954639,
-0.4438405633,
0.432050854,
0.087982215,
-0.0307628307,
-0.3520806134,
-0.2856602669,
-0.3990183771,
0.436183244,
0.2294149548,
-0.408236742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15096v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15096v3 | Dynamic Masking Rate Schedules for MLM Pretraining | 2023-05-24T12:24:12 | 2024-02-10T20:56:20 | Zachary Ankner, Naomi Saphra, Davis Blalock, Jonathan Frankle, Matthew L. Leavitt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Most works on transformers trained with the Masked Language Modeling (MLM)
objective use the original BERT model's fixed masking rate of 15%. We propose
to instead dynamically schedule the masking rate throughout training. We find
that linearly decreasing the masking rate over the course of pretraining
improves average GLUE accuracy by up to 0.46% and 0.25% in BERT-base and
BERT-large, respectively, compared to fixed rate baselines. These gains come
from exposure to both high and low masking rate regimes, providing benefits
from both settings. Our results demonstrate that masking rate scheduling is a
simple way to improve the quality of masked language models, achieving up to a
1.89x speedup in pretraining for BERT-base as well as a Pareto improvement for
BERT-large. | [
-0.4668901861,
-0.4640478492,
0.1401697397,
0.6147588491,
-0.1287631691,
0.4011189938,
-0.344848752,
-0.6095764637,
0.5026615262,
0.3769749105,
-0.8580943346,
-0.1335332841,
-0.730029881,
-0.2547039092,
-0.0807968304,
0.8062343001,
-0.0547415763,
0.0190987289,
0.0035730735,
0.2839184701,
-0.5364968777,
-0.7628804445,
-0.7320384383,
-0.3388065994,
0.5147609711,
0.1115528345,
0.7741088867,
0.9090932012,
0.7481711507,
0.267895788,
0.0056197052,
-0.1533848494,
-0.4509209991,
0.0859113485,
0.4474430382,
-0.7154213786,
-0.6049199104,
0.4823701084,
0.8615535498,
0.6823667884,
-0.4427226484,
0.1760231405,
0.0326824561,
0.8091053963,
-0.5869779587,
0.161279574,
-0.8408464193,
0.4350036383,
-0.0920211524,
-0.3464003503,
-0.5884036422,
-0.3197007477,
0.25313586,
-0.4850510657,
0.3994246721,
-0.2713169158,
0.9904827476,
0.3459382951,
-0.0445695482,
0.0792246535,
-0.7325152755,
0.8649728894,
-0.5087352991,
0.4321427345,
0.3927266598,
0.5649806857,
0.081995286,
-1.069444418,
-0.1735919416,
-0.2586450279,
-0.2189231217,
0.0563665256,
-0.176045537,
0.0966399834,
0.6896746159,
0.4250164628,
-0.3382888436,
0.1724966019,
-0.2974322736,
-0.2194592804,
0.6204913259,
0.1496164948,
0.2770828605,
0.4591097832,
-0.6495723128,
-0.1922877133,
-0.4515021741,
0.4812326729,
0.7761692405,
0.1906390041,
0.3636511564,
0.2092721909,
-0.151871413,
0.7340669632,
0.3036626875,
-0.3572942317,
0.3423123956,
-0.0809560418,
-0.3096999526,
0.154565841,
0.2173453122,
0.3746511042,
0.442101568,
-0.3188513517,
-0.5219306946,
0.2965463996,
0.6684425473,
-0.9969776869,
-0.3854153454,
-0.1017941982,
-0.4093854725,
-0.3714860976,
0.0336911008,
-0.3637966216,
0.0570266992,
-0.7100675106,
0.823613286,
-0.0592900254,
-0.1771327853,
0.2184194028,
-0.0629341677,
0.2918368876,
0.4568579793,
-0.7935290933,
0.3588674068,
0.3554657698,
0.707367599,
-0.3767901659,
-0.0356540084,
-0.7569298744,
-0.0065977378,
-0.3959428072,
0.6530771852,
-0.4138848782,
-0.0519211292,
-0.0631991103,
0.1097795293,
-0.4322568774,
-0.7443625331,
0.0913847089,
-0.5622602105,
0.1760491878,
-0.0547336042,
-0.4767225087,
0.0918515697,
0.0877382979,
-0.760506928,
1.0016824007,
0.1494910121,
-0.0814484954,
0.7084608674,
-0.6722892523,
-0.5193949342,
0.0185012668,
0.2476343364,
-0.6760022044,
-0.1692344248,
0.3216346502,
0.5111839175,
0.4984323978,
0.5565289855,
0.0200213231,
-0.7535748482,
0.2081428468,
-0.3949716389,
0.7346209288,
0.3333669007,
-0.8316231966,
0.0008021053,
-0.7132027745,
0.0191112049,
-0.3287316561,
-0.5280556083,
0.2384156287,
-0.1022562087,
-0.1083941907,
0.5125945807,
-0.0164591931,
-0.417522043,
0.3182240427,
-0.5992208123,
-0.0347301848,
1.1356444359,
-0.2051321566,
0.4826598167,
-0.6594538689,
0.7870877385,
-0.0484000184,
0.3497819901,
-0.2274332643,
-0.6160795689,
-1.3129419088,
-0.7274888158,
0.3260013759,
0.5486119986,
-0.6693235636,
0.4986127913,
-0.1206661016,
-0.5832657814,
-0.735755384,
0.1115813255,
0.5889331102,
0.2716527283,
0.3824101686,
-0.6576923132,
-0.696089983,
-1.0224814415,
-0.3365137577,
0.2576133907,
-0.268637687,
-0.0445474088,
0.1486946642,
0.1083141416,
0.9315086007,
-0.5822850466,
-0.5025043488,
-0.0552831292,
0.3269459307,
0.6095581651,
0.634411931,
0.6645249128,
-0.5442102551,
-1.1897431612,
-0.7782098651,
-0.0751211122,
-0.2283917218,
0.114380978,
-0.1574536264,
0.5771297216,
0.5657725334,
-0.4057140946,
0.7448939681,
0.7217747569,
-0.0665125772,
0.4304975569,
-0.0012623895,
0.0386678278,
-0.7529303432,
0.0551977046,
-0.2592519224,
-0.5876609683,
-0.8906279802,
-0.2523710132,
-0.2306767702,
-0.3402254581,
-0.9550514817,
0.2847885489,
-0.7005829215,
0.1028361022,
-0.3310368955,
-0.4435995519,
-0.123965919,
0.8528251648,
0.1970246881,
0.9953204393,
0.4748938978,
-0.7007346153,
0.0743467286,
-0.0744535103,
-0.8656636477,
0.0049583795,
-0.692142725,
0.2462607473,
0.1173545271,
0.4784362912,
-0.6541401744,
0.177183792,
0.1830402166,
-0.1921304464,
0.5912835598,
-0.075711146,
-0.3579753637,
-0.272862792,
-0.5529800057,
0.241512537,
0.9500135779,
-0.4311376214,
0.4652054012,
0.4136386216,
0.1805988401,
-1.0688412189,
-0.4380472898,
-0.0910188779,
-0.1471806765,
-0.612316072,
0.8101251125,
-0.3003247082,
0.0502346307,
-0.2381609529,
-0.3653262258,
-0.120381698,
0.1945451349,
0.134466812,
-0.0063068629,
-0.3573340178,
-0.2757078409,
-0.4610082209,
-0.5840844512,
-0.0278187003,
-0.3394488096,
0.8545874357,
0.0948796794,
-0.2209008634,
-0.6985411048,
0.1310673952,
0.2223255783,
-0.1496700644,
1.2250080109,
1.145118475,
-0.4705466628,
-0.0345430337,
-0.9069027305,
-0.4566982687,
-0.5184637308,
-0.0510990508,
-0.4564750195,
-0.8836324215,
0.5358691812,
0.4653943181,
-0.0863093883,
0.2893643677,
0.8469338417,
-0.3248202503,
0.9995641708,
0.9275470376,
0.0544422679,
0.8577944636,
-0.1536529511,
0.4696117342,
-0.429680109,
-0.1818727255,
-0.2568912506,
-0.5998049378,
-0.552310884,
-0.6037508845,
0.4043673873,
0.3559547961,
-0.018036183,
0.5113936067,
-0.5717724562,
0.6461473703,
1.0307177305,
0.3482277095,
0.1296154112,
0.1733371317,
0.2647240758,
-0.1117196977,
-0.7419852018,
-0.4212092757,
0.9632790685,
0.4977284968,
0.7500802279,
0.0230003484,
0.278672576,
0.1511820257,
0.5305820107,
-0.5335825682,
0.4156995714,
-0.1533885151,
-0.8731141686,
-0.4073852599,
-0.0862887129,
-0.948675096,
0.003108755,
-0.309112668,
-0.8273755312,
0.3547711074,
0.6210330725,
-0.263679117,
0.5362372398,
-0.6993237734,
0.7053490877,
0.1374177784,
0.0988705382,
0.0649697557,
-0.9696584344,
0.346649766,
-0.54797858,
-0.2607992887,
-0.5481786728,
0.233214125,
0.92299968,
-0.3032097518,
0.9972922206,
-0.3710841537,
0.2120601237,
0.2155496627,
-0.0997702554,
0.6579657197,
-0.1967123449,
0.0071246461,
0.3301134408,
-0.3195526302,
-0.5380266905,
-0.7271573544,
0.1442335397,
-0.6395301223,
-0.6082941294,
-0.4366906881,
-0.7850879431,
-0.1091240272,
-0.1800905019,
0.2773929536,
0.4526748359,
0.23817195,
0.344445169,
0.8205299377,
-0.290525794,
0.585528791,
0.6327091455,
-0.1491451859,
-0.1320738047,
0.8957273364,
0.2455885708,
0.7664532661,
0.5430167913,
-0.2187037617,
-0.1775236577,
-0.2066379786,
0.0142478151,
0.0425029509,
-0.4936998188,
-0.2424060404,
-1.0174267292,
-0.5820349455,
-0.6146253943,
-0.3075993061,
-0.4448198378,
-0.7646227479,
-0.0122707691,
0.08861994,
0.0477544665,
-0.021017598,
-0.1306305826,
0.6338841319,
-0.6724004745,
0.0932066888,
0.4723638892,
0.5143800378,
-0.3130252957,
-0.5486239791,
-0.4604735076,
0.0043136114,
-0.2813981175,
-0.2671954632,
0.2611611187,
0.2569881082,
0.9225260615,
0.2935525179,
0.0822199583,
0.7930883765,
-0.8572944999,
0.8374841213,
0.3414784968,
-0.9029909968,
0.4979832172,
-0.0979860201,
0.0783396959,
0.2603549361,
0.5172905922,
-0.3265374899,
-0.6291008592,
-0.6174980998,
-0.7766876817,
0.9807533622,
0.5359104872,
0.4065296352,
0.3775843382,
0.0008432114,
-0.0651814491,
0.3878231943,
-0.8365856409,
-0.5556542873,
0.01888269,
0.1432242095,
-0.3836171627,
-0.5642482042,
-0.1058524325,
-0.6061928272,
0.7984554172,
0.1645561308,
0.8099638224,
-0.1516542435,
-0.4010747373,
-0.235472858,
-0.0450975709,
1.0904145241,
0.93419379,
-0.8732688427,
0.0741105676,
0.1649695486,
-0.6358056068,
0.4366499782,
0.0696455687,
0.0722201914,
0.2805019021,
0.4141212702,
1.1703907251,
0.0413995795,
-0.4271619618,
0.6981559396,
0.0634729341,
-0.2736417651,
-0.2041127682,
0.3654507101,
-0.3024537861,
0.0844418406,
0.2559532225,
0.123369351,
-0.3050477207,
-0.4104014039,
0.519641161,
0.3467032611,
-0.4217885137,
-0.1608265042,
0.7177605629,
0.1014304683,
-0.6472699642,
0.7744749188,
0.1163631454,
-0.8777794838,
0.6877583861,
0.59698838,
0.8814023137,
-0.8048716187,
0.0773866028,
0.2562126517,
0.6303703189,
0.0671351105,
-0.1421142519,
0.146848917,
-0.7476232648,
-0.6897177696,
-0.9531840086,
-0.3116300702,
0.2566378713,
-0.6583566666,
0.6131794453,
0.0032543589,
-0.3106123805,
0.1922677457,
-0.0030063002,
-0.8052197695,
0.4222310483,
0.2363949716,
1.0541102886,
-0.7648568153,
0.9439115524,
0.4204496145,
-0.2028596997,
-0.8067013025,
-0.2609059811,
-0.2231804579,
-1.047763586,
0.898712635,
0.4880459905,
0.1054209173,
0.1323158294,
-0.2355667204,
-0.9705286026,
0.9246832132,
0.5582814217,
-0.4630637467,
-0.2426979542,
0.2827385068,
0.4876407087,
-0.6084961891,
0.1127354652,
0.5692662001,
0.4532429278,
-0.018739732,
-1.157209754,
-0.3577329814,
-0.2759684324,
0.0659931228,
0.4090747833,
-0.2354009598,
0.9595796466,
0.1608134806,
-0.1452031434,
-0.3504324257,
0.2861668169,
-0.2225945145,
0.2872327864,
0.7095873356,
0.5231567621,
0.3987843096,
-0.2352086306,
0.8519791961,
-0.595498085,
0.2704595923,
0.7511824965,
-0.0095930565,
0.3901929557,
0.4699340761,
-0.2996705174,
0.520074904,
0.6480049491,
-0.1122771651,
0.583994329,
0.4492062032,
-0.4356247783,
-0.3322609663,
-0.0916837305,
-0.476883024,
0.1209028438,
0.0127787497,
-0.4019880295,
0.023872396,
0.2874663472,
0.0898037255,
-0.1962378472,
-0.1403179914,
0.5693849921,
0.0892836004,
-0.6589363217,
0.7912843823,
-0.1812891811,
0.6908856034,
-0.772515595,
0.1195930764,
-0.1727886349,
0.2128243595,
0.0808155313,
-0.3602565229,
0.4414170086,
-0.2334654629,
-0.4855951667,
-0.80156672,
0.7354152203,
-0.6463884115,
-0.4054049551,
-0.0118787233,
0.2085048258,
0.2524165511,
-0.0435220934,
-0.6921772957,
-0.0263315346,
-0.1476300806,
-0.5326989293,
0.5314404368,
-0.3445455134,
0.0853069797,
0.6180892587,
1.0806347132,
-0.218883723,
0.4254805446,
0.0351309367,
0.9657318592,
-0.3533534706,
-0.3889150918,
-0.7534934282,
0.7668237686,
-0.1027114615,
0.1228693724,
0.4846985936,
0.5300691128,
0.9848050475,
-0.4446860552,
-0.0566021726,
0.2498566061,
0.3595982194,
-0.6892716289,
0.9287397861,
-0.3421398699,
0.2086563557,
-0.3773026764,
-1.5645171404,
-0.4153217375,
0.7774583101,
0.0162700675,
0.0054166792,
0.8277139664,
0.9381523132,
-0.1202639714,
-0.436227113,
0.4933696389,
-0.2473748177,
0.5685330629,
0.4390077591,
0.8528590202,
-0.3537049592,
0.4120668769,
-0.8981925249,
-0.1395445764,
-0.1256175041,
-1.2132567167,
-0.9157338738,
-0.3938462436,
-0.4779950082,
-0.433277607,
0.061210759,
0.7651788592,
1.0269589424,
-0.6636912823,
-0.2720597088,
0.3547918797,
-0.3142202497,
-0.441778779,
-0.3054730892,
0.3922304511,
-0.9957415462,
-0.9582458138,
0.2842080891,
0.3233185112,
0.1102368161,
-0.0162422024,
0.1275666952,
-0.334646821,
0.2164392173,
0.6449790597,
-0.1833549142,
-0.4895932078,
-0.2889029682,
0.105205074,
-0.366210252,
0.2713997066,
1.0213201046,
-0.7052686214,
0.4339636266,
0.0908611342,
0.590731144,
0.9040299654,
0.0233457778,
0.6408979893,
-0.9772957563,
0.5406262279,
0.3934884369,
-0.1152210459,
-0.060461551,
-0.2865798175,
0.71870327,
0.5240180492,
-0.559262991,
-1.3447422981,
0.1267666072,
-0.8792914152,
0.0653641447,
0.7070105076,
-0.3313398957,
-0.1108601838,
-0.0964830741,
0.0475503765,
0.3213187754,
0.1065841243,
0.6440858841,
0.6944769621,
-0.1223360375,
0.0459806919,
-0.5289633274,
0.857693851,
0.4431539178,
-0.4946056306,
-0.4609535038,
0.0355981924,
0.3394895196,
0.2173439711,
0.9836921692,
0.261377871,
0.110106051,
-0.2624942362,
0.3031415045,
-0.1339721829,
-0.6814116836,
0.0086860051,
-0.1879073232,
-0.2637882233,
-0.4044304192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15093v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15093v2 | C-STS: Conditional Semantic Textual Similarity | 2023-05-24T12:18:50 | 2023-11-06T18:48:43 | Ameet Deshpande, Carlos E. Jimenez, Howard Chen, Vishvak Murahari, Victoria Graf, Tanmay Rajpurohit, Ashwin Kalyan, Danqi Chen, Karthik Narasimhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Semantic textual similarity (STS), a cornerstone task in NLP, measures the
degree of similarity between a pair of sentences, and has broad application in
fields such as information retrieval and natural language understanding.
However, sentence similarity can be inherently ambiguous, depending on the
specific aspect of interest. We resolve this ambiguity by proposing a novel
task called Conditional STS (C-STS) which measures sentences' similarity
conditioned on an feature described in natural language (hereon, condition). As
an example, the similarity between the sentences "The NBA player shoots a
three-pointer." and "A man throws a tennis ball into the air to serve." is
higher for the condition "The motion of the ball" (both upward) and lower for
"The size of the ball" (one large and one small). C-STS's advantages are
two-fold: (1) it reduces the subjectivity and ambiguity of STS and (2) enables
fine-grained language model evaluation through diverse natural language
conditions. We put several state-of-the-art models to the test, and even those
performing well on STS (e.g. SimCSE, Flan-T5, and GPT-4) find C-STS
challenging; all with Spearman correlation scores below 50. To encourage a more
comprehensive evaluation of semantic similarity and natural language
understanding, we make nearly 19K C-STS examples and code available for others
to train and test their models. | [
0.0326072574,
-0.8794993758,
0.8167127967,
0.2555262446,
-0.4547717571,
0.043015305,
-0.4025426209,
-0.5481610894,
0.1698551476,
0.5354396105,
-0.438970983,
-0.6533227563,
-0.7773023248,
0.3296549022,
-0.9077435732,
0.8946775794,
-0.1673683077,
0.0350189842,
-0.3715107441,
-0.0045335889,
-0.3127119243,
-0.381085366,
-0.5261108875,
0.0690628737,
0.3546197712,
0.2743795812,
0.8569657803,
0.4512190521,
0.9278950691,
0.4496692717,
-0.1092902943,
-0.2506937087,
-0.4555375874,
0.1830656379,
-0.3391823769,
-0.5385089517,
-0.0725228488,
0.0760456771,
0.7100176215,
0.9259087443,
0.1527488828,
0.0962601826,
0.3292316794,
0.6514193416,
-0.5249729753,
0.0308226086,
-0.7490324378,
-0.1440703422,
-0.0893545896,
-0.1287728548,
-0.2272473574,
-0.5335031152,
0.4707909524,
-0.7027785182,
0.4511448145,
0.3993954957,
1.1509652138,
0.2847753763,
-0.6256123185,
-0.4111914337,
-0.3068305552,
0.8258728385,
-0.4645322263,
0.3487486839,
0.1826761365,
0.1374279559,
-0.2162379473,
-0.6331960559,
-0.9736320376,
-0.7302123904,
-0.3586651385,
0.2229892612,
-0.1700260341,
0.081143491,
0.1491515785,
0.3652257919,
-0.9297705293,
-0.095248349,
-0.2884884477,
0.0264058113,
0.3611975908,
0.2663154006,
0.4050036967,
-0.5223849416,
-0.8070511222,
-0.0434107855,
-0.4581334889,
0.1830284297,
0.4326637685,
0.4392499626,
-0.2860072851,
0.892699182,
-0.342530489,
0.5919929743,
-0.0616464913,
0.2534983456,
0.2170681655,
-0.5197077394,
-0.2382656485,
-0.0880156085,
0.5998805761,
0.5044818521,
0.2481838614,
-0.1835575402,
0.0497014597,
0.447912246,
0.3025850654,
-0.518476963,
-0.1558508426,
0.0222790204,
-0.6086878777,
-0.0492935628,
0.2214991152,
-0.290117234,
-0.1609292477,
-0.8588883281,
0.3774341345,
-0.7479732037,
0.0629685596,
0.2852140963,
-0.4416136444,
0.329451859,
0.0619909987,
-0.5291338563,
0.6995509267,
1.0953652859,
0.7795812488,
-0.7051275969,
-0.499304682,
-0.3950225115,
0.0239735469,
-0.1944164485,
0.7932332754,
-0.6582036018,
-0.3105694652,
-0.122168377,
-0.0011237473,
-0.1585348248,
-0.3641571999,
0.7395281792,
-0.1868151575,
0.2522729039,
-0.3648362458,
-0.829518199,
-0.0023800461,
0.4691467285,
-0.3142546117,
1.1395933628,
0.2019348443,
-0.8697071671,
0.5188896656,
-0.298409611,
-0.3795565367,
0.1683113575,
-0.1987768114,
-0.2246195376,
0.0409853049,
-0.3882031143,
0.3439913988,
-0.4442735016,
0.2022984624,
-0.5308625698,
-0.5468444228,
0.0824938715,
-0.0601043887,
0.5382010341,
0.1865461767,
-0.1560799479,
0.078624025,
-0.5583962202,
0.0359315015,
-0.0672495887,
-0.1140414923,
-0.8898049593,
-0.07312987,
0.1164444536,
0.0311926398,
0.3476049006,
-0.5803470016,
0.0708798766,
-0.7678945065,
0.1638704836,
0.3937767446,
0.0252711605,
0.6708629131,
-0.4254510105,
0.443320781,
-0.0936119556,
0.2261977941,
0.1525458246,
-0.4741925895,
-0.6653840542,
-0.3403990269,
0.4033094943,
0.6823825836,
-0.6420288682,
0.5174518228,
-0.5137374401,
-0.4411739111,
-0.3284788132,
-0.1427867562,
0.590585649,
0.4046875238,
0.5125166774,
-0.1611673683,
-0.6132071614,
-1.0016598701,
-0.8232691288,
-0.1324383467,
-0.1305058748,
-0.0097563723,
0.5730909705,
0.1929381788,
0.9908686876,
-0.5749971271,
-0.2833872139,
-0.2305659503,
0.1340492964,
0.2214111537,
0.4397731721,
0.7463857532,
-1.0039235353,
-0.5222916007,
-0.1810324788,
-0.4336053431,
-0.1262803078,
-0.0226436723,
-0.0267694276,
0.0508777946,
0.5531390905,
-0.7820442319,
0.6780039072,
0.4551736414,
-0.6133853793,
0.3978770971,
-0.2362842858,
0.6072584391,
-1.0483984947,
0.1433984786,
0.055589959,
-0.0391346328,
-0.4383505285,
0.2830001116,
0.0287901387,
-0.0303160176,
-0.5655859709,
0.6060054898,
-0.1659004837,
-0.0523171499,
-0.2671196759,
0.5607520938,
-0.0630648136,
0.2727218866,
0.1653242707,
0.3544971347,
0.4418159127,
-0.7996040583,
0.0573220327,
0.3392796814,
-0.3139580786,
0.8554380536,
-0.6109437346,
-0.3031395376,
-0.0847219676,
0.2927948534,
-0.7212055922,
0.2185219824,
0.181422025,
-0.5818750858,
-0.0371575765,
0.0105411662,
-0.3122508824,
-0.4251626134,
-0.5553653836,
0.4156619906,
0.2338670045,
-0.2559207082,
0.4480969906,
0.0753304362,
-0.2564464808,
-0.6134055853,
-0.6025292873,
0.2483168691,
-0.1343952119,
-0.4430261552,
0.7022016644,
-0.2034802586,
-0.3805026412,
0.3767009974,
-0.2155910283,
-0.0892138854,
0.1317165494,
0.3546687067,
0.4737023711,
-0.1918673068,
0.0653200001,
0.0752994046,
-0.0853931457,
-0.1537382901,
-0.3911451995,
0.4042564631,
-0.2031305581,
-0.4529239535,
-0.5070836544,
0.5346567631,
-0.1249638349,
0.1376730949,
0.5281655192,
0.3877031505,
-0.449121505,
0.0221477337,
-0.2704114616,
-0.0002271603,
-0.4489189684,
0.0826262236,
-0.6165047884,
-1.0962035656,
0.0818904936,
0.2402199656,
-0.1726700366,
0.6164986491,
0.4679319561,
-0.231464535,
0.7315167785,
0.6277878284,
0.1600278318,
0.1421815008,
0.0816365108,
0.4875845611,
-0.3700070977,
-0.1769641787,
-1.0679066181,
-0.2339043021,
-0.8786314726,
-0.348025769,
-0.0660156533,
0.1477900147,
-0.3969099224,
0.7681819201,
-0.4196550548,
0.5587979555,
0.4854340851,
-0.0227418728,
0.1002225131,
-0.4284394383,
-0.3521316946,
-0.1076641306,
-0.2814667523,
-0.5959661007,
0.6542521119,
-0.109227404,
0.3046464324,
0.1733290702,
0.8328181505,
0.4885750711,
0.0112583926,
-0.8169342875,
0.7445366383,
-0.5303298235,
-0.3700560629,
-0.040609736,
-0.3721143901,
-1.1490405798,
0.0673350021,
-0.5794070959,
-0.5416477919,
-0.1118299067,
0.1995049119,
-0.2298951149,
0.0417612083,
-0.8125077486,
0.6790806055,
-0.0656117052,
-0.0250353068,
-0.3712904155,
-0.8991461396,
0.1542936116,
0.1171189621,
0.196350053,
-0.1607201993,
-0.1323832422,
0.4946183562,
-0.3010237515,
0.6134279966,
0.094079189,
0.2710615396,
0.2444508225,
0.283307761,
0.2775624692,
-0.0382457227,
0.0125130648,
0.0358386301,
0.5283682942,
-0.5665528178,
-0.6322709322,
0.9400286078,
-0.468383193,
-0.5983871222,
-0.6232926846,
-0.210322395,
-0.0205581766,
0.2501384318,
-0.0884268954,
0.1243583485,
-0.4646127522,
0.1923052371,
0.2475054413,
-0.3146867752,
0.3082232773,
0.627479732,
0.0509468019,
0.0371386819,
0.5016156435,
-0.4872190654,
0.1710013151,
0.8994426727,
0.1937362552,
-0.3246029913,
-0.5491037965,
0.1528785825,
0.0392918177,
-0.6315746903,
-0.2451803088,
-0.7005695105,
-0.0916009098,
-0.5381039381,
-0.3640408814,
-0.0096773859,
-0.6662505269,
-0.3387957513,
-0.1314582229,
0.4075585902,
0.6379519701,
0.1472959816,
0.1782305837,
-0.6785997748,
0.6343115568,
0.0735934004,
0.3147963881,
-0.4431688786,
-0.6054545045,
0.146513164,
-0.0915025771,
-0.1904929131,
-0.6846336126,
0.2017392814,
0.3007265925,
0.4331916571,
0.0983016044,
0.1364451498,
0.630726397,
-0.7225684524,
1.1371122599,
0.3603894711,
-1.3351408243,
0.4978131354,
-0.2439892292,
0.1381787211,
0.8835253119,
0.4100131392,
-0.5214726329,
-0.7667098045,
-0.8014268875,
-0.7550522685,
0.3824369311,
0.4636237025,
0.1691510975,
-0.5037418008,
0.5123589039,
0.1052156687,
-0.0975505337,
-0.6670131683,
-0.1786021441,
-0.1310364753,
-0.6062092781,
-0.0922885239,
-0.0580336452,
0.2315790802,
-0.0590146929,
0.5464567542,
-0.0339643322,
0.1235981733,
0.2371328771,
-0.3326658905,
0.2106574625,
0.4885343015,
0.4429649115,
0.3604769111,
-0.1135258824,
0.4579169154,
0.5985561013,
-0.4452906549,
-0.1355212629,
0.1247209609,
-0.0187114738,
-0.0326721892,
0.4560187161,
0.3116878271,
0.6220935583,
-0.6772495508,
0.8251388073,
-0.0864859521,
-0.3788807392,
-0.233372435,
0.0632072911,
0.0608950518,
0.2174044549,
0.1499182433,
0.2791365385,
0.4459859729,
-0.5955367684,
0.4299647212,
0.3888501525,
-0.6476545334,
-0.1962187588,
0.4629375041,
0.007013232,
-0.480728507,
0.3321843445,
-0.4273605347,
-0.6999982595,
0.6408298016,
0.3499260843,
0.4288588762,
0.0603679568,
0.2023088783,
0.4401051998,
0.2621189952,
-0.1299076676,
0.4612054825,
0.0459695123,
-0.5734297633,
-0.2648370564,
-0.6546933055,
-0.3432428539,
-0.4651323855,
-0.7678725719,
0.6346251369,
-0.1253257394,
-0.020815827,
0.0492941141,
0.0656210259,
-0.9346910119,
0.4126884043,
0.0929435641,
0.8615375757,
-0.7441961765,
0.84117347,
0.4575632215,
-0.2999616861,
-0.6415851116,
-0.0280710999,
0.0503662191,
-0.6525607705,
0.6836616993,
0.1243945286,
-0.2461962253,
-0.2526710331,
-0.4107023478,
-0.5724408031,
1.101339221,
0.2193172723,
-0.6762714386,
0.0487466119,
0.2482839823,
0.8012026548,
-0.3311647177,
0.2893182933,
0.6613181829,
0.4964655042,
-0.0530971847,
-0.9055302739,
0.1803243905,
-0.1432999671,
0.1338395178,
0.3578668535,
-0.3286162913,
0.5917759538,
-0.2602882981,
-0.2178926766,
0.4854644239,
0.7128314376,
0.2432466447,
0.3992891312,
0.8111441731,
0.725938797,
0.6182108521,
-0.1647291034,
1.0836360455,
-0.2461329401,
0.4832286537,
1.2114285231,
-0.5001788735,
1.0292304754,
0.4024332166,
-0.096545659,
0.5788429379,
0.496201694,
-0.0742594823,
0.3689417839,
0.6040943265,
-0.0227902886,
-0.2218904197,
-0.0189074725,
-0.1986557692,
0.6544339657,
0.1886731982,
-0.2272241712,
-0.0996533036,
-0.1551297903,
-0.079850398,
0.749009788,
-0.0552136824,
0.6452724934,
0.2213058919,
-0.6693825126,
0.2536347508,
0.0398695692,
0.6720946431,
-0.6194957495,
-0.0394656062,
0.0201923084,
-0.1077415645,
0.0185927115,
-0.9278835654,
0.6544849277,
0.1344762295,
-0.18274571,
-0.2065362781,
0.5177631378,
-0.3243870437,
-0.3868828118,
0.5794372559,
0.3334757388,
0.2024906129,
0.060236685,
-1.0339169502,
-0.1328014582,
-0.2536845505,
0.042386476,
0.0708208606,
0.4257908463,
-0.0199400168,
0.627148807,
0.4741770625,
0.0605414882,
-0.0172245596,
0.3093726039,
0.5710366964,
-0.895057559,
-0.451266408,
-0.7748966813,
0.0461733378,
-0.251149863,
-0.5230992436,
0.6841984391,
0.9061239958,
0.6971313953,
0.0875437185,
0.5490249991,
-0.2630737424,
0.8664506078,
-0.6384108663,
0.4221418798,
-0.5435897112,
0.2603908181,
-0.4013223648,
-0.8295157552,
-0.5031757355,
0.2643527091,
-0.354113102,
-0.2394969463,
1.386239171,
0.6971055865,
-0.121168904,
0.2206482887,
0.2064938843,
0.124218531,
-0.0896816403,
0.5730341077,
1.0335640907,
-0.4181960523,
0.7861866355,
0.0037552405,
-0.0851772055,
0.1053340062,
-0.9571002126,
-0.84552598,
-0.9251703024,
-0.4094248116,
-0.2736158371,
0.2211057544,
1.0981283188,
0.3877074122,
-0.841121912,
0.0513508059,
-0.1130136773,
0.2323981375,
-0.2493984699,
-0.2349937558,
0.5251689553,
-0.3708700836,
-0.6314220428,
0.2797812819,
0.3418722451,
-0.021242043,
0.3573871553,
0.0522689819,
-0.3642341197,
0.1422795206,
0.5928326845,
-0.0921922177,
-0.8924560547,
-0.7751294374,
0.0421749204,
-0.2434589863,
-0.173257336,
0.9677565098,
-0.769471705,
-0.0700372085,
0.6392419934,
0.5503040552,
0.4220948219,
0.0347220823,
0.3291602135,
-0.6548523307,
0.1347839981,
0.3306598365,
0.353898406,
0.3155008852,
-0.2809747458,
0.3145319521,
0.1445907056,
-0.4355104268,
-0.5208435655,
0.3774141073,
-1.5613613129,
-0.4372290969,
1.1720733643,
-0.1308983117,
0.0604716837,
-0.2206619829,
-0.1176274791,
0.3132652044,
-0.1835624576,
0.7787944674,
0.3818887472,
0.233490482,
0.199597314,
-0.3209530115,
0.567414701,
0.5384100676,
-0.7714325786,
-0.2638581395,
0.1877002269,
0.4398856163,
-0.1374921948,
0.3131763339,
0.1030726507,
0.1372809261,
-0.2241731435,
0.024787657,
0.5352948308,
0.0105087161,
-0.0767313316,
0.1562772542,
-0.1506804675,
-0.1179625243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15090v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15090v3 | STAR: Boosting Low-Resource Information Extraction by Structure-to-Text Data Generation with Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T12:15:19 | 2024-02-20T20:00:21 | Mingyu Derek Ma, Xiaoxuan Wang, Po-Nien Kung, P. Jeffrey Brantingham, Nanyun Peng, Wei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Information extraction tasks such as event extraction require an in-depth
understanding of the output structure and sub-task dependencies. They heavily
rely on task-specific training data in the form of (passage, target structure)
pairs to obtain reasonable performance. However, obtaining such data through
human annotation is costly, leading to a pressing need for low-resource
information extraction approaches that require minimal human labeling for
real-world applications. Fine-tuning supervised models with synthesized
training data would be a generalizable method, but the existing data generation
methods either still rely on large-scale ground-truth data or cannot be applied
to complicated IE tasks due to their poor performance. To address these
challenges, we propose STAR, a data generation method that leverages Large
Language Models (LLMs) to synthesize data instances given limited seed
demonstrations, thereby boosting low-resource information extraction
performance. Our approach involves generating target structures (Y) followed by
generating passages (X), all accomplished with the aid of LLMs. We design
fine-grained step-by-step instructions to obtain the initial data instances. We
further reduce errors and improve data quality through self-reflection error
identification and self-refinement with iterative revision. Our experiments
show that the data generated by STAR significantly improve the performance of
low-resource event extraction and relation extraction tasks, even surpassing
the effectiveness of human-curated data. Human assessment of the data quality
shows STAR-generated data exhibits higher passage quality and better align with
the task definitions compared with the human-curated data. | [
-0.1580055803,
-0.8456087708,
0.4318349361,
-0.1697394103,
-0.2290983349,
-0.0616626926,
-0.533136785,
-0.5431674123,
0.2549555004,
0.6184876561,
-0.4672831893,
-0.470777452,
-0.3518300653,
0.0886573792,
-0.1992752254,
1.1139746904,
0.2435099632,
-0.2609608769,
0.0248112064,
0.2416920215,
-0.3590477705,
-0.442990154,
-0.5169091225,
-0.0503597371,
0.649815619,
0.8986682296,
0.5017454624,
1.3321686983,
0.4825164378,
0.1628972441,
0.1698591709,
0.421109587,
-0.5667380095,
0.1679288894,
-0.2918622494,
-0.3774560392,
-0.5591653585,
0.1138902679,
0.6357843876,
0.772459507,
0.2952048779,
0.7078062892,
0.2446653396,
0.6632359028,
-0.6844534278,
0.4987719655,
-0.9112133384,
-0.070666939,
-0.5897418261,
-0.4394840002,
-0.3553436697,
0.1025777459,
-0.2261990607,
-0.5239902139,
0.5319892764,
0.1760398,
0.9020391107,
0.2327404469,
-0.0079211323,
-0.276565522,
-0.8099215031,
0.7102812529,
-0.4732803106,
0.3862313032,
0.3805482686,
0.1939409226,
-0.2157912552,
-0.6169838905,
-0.5253568292,
-0.0725604817,
-0.1126862466,
-0.0681319088,
0.0059467102,
-0.1365022063,
0.4279551804,
0.2523180842,
-0.434551537,
0.1222335696,
-0.4241816401,
-0.0626670644,
0.7148213387,
0.1788023561,
0.0867723152,
-0.8835574985,
-0.1647190601,
-0.3392630816,
-0.9521213174,
0.0357323028,
0.2994170189,
0.8988051414,
0.1019627154,
0.7465119958,
-0.4859897792,
0.4913108349,
0.1135398746,
-0.2410305589,
-0.0400804542,
-0.6460337043,
-0.2246851176,
0.1043797508,
0.8778324127,
0.2813248336,
0.0339763872,
-0.293233484,
-0.273127228,
0.0981973186,
0.0048209336,
-1.154736042,
-0.4489123821,
0.0650453568,
-0.6377531886,
-0.4770246446,
-0.0238445103,
-1.0257601738,
-0.2747799456,
-0.3664091229,
0.1535030007,
-0.1349458396,
-0.1076956987,
-0.2591969967,
0.1431780159,
-0.2163985074,
0.164466247,
-0.8429291844,
-0.025232397,
0.4108411074,
0.5906177163,
-0.190313682,
0.0059479182,
-1.2603125572,
0.2265152186,
-0.3649775386,
0.651627183,
-0.5854338408,
-0.2272680998,
-0.2578533888,
-0.0789993852,
0.2838618755,
-0.5225792527,
0.592191875,
-0.2985790074,
0.047868859,
-0.4022239149,
-0.4468509555,
0.2536073923,
-0.0100669796,
-0.642878592,
1.0481026173,
0.0790471435,
-0.6551625729,
0.4630226195,
-0.5559614301,
-0.4003186226,
0.3728821576,
-0.6159840822,
-0.3737008274,
0.1616310179,
0.5529738069,
0.7848843932,
-0.5698184967,
0.2311075032,
-0.0856946334,
-0.0630410686,
0.0111193582,
-0.2988660336,
0.1956179887,
0.4006659985,
-0.3044026792,
-0.0723345429,
-0.9531467557,
-0.0242672414,
0.3844312429,
-0.6983996034,
-0.2788609862,
0.3292154372,
0.3579644561,
0.3084789515,
0.2986515462,
-0.6647852063,
0.4466785491,
-0.2481986135,
0.2383499593,
0.4718507826,
0.1393101066,
0.4636336267,
-0.1148400605,
0.3599081933,
0.1019488871,
-0.0049233008,
-0.3207124174,
-0.1390106827,
-0.7248579264,
-0.1850864291,
0.2969671786,
0.3112837374,
-0.9023413658,
0.5308035016,
-0.5563468337,
-0.4839846492,
-0.5297849774,
0.5330584645,
0.3885374069,
0.864330709,
0.3742842376,
0.086847119,
-0.6747789383,
-0.9093014598,
-0.0875560641,
-0.2469461858,
-0.0682130307,
0.4105858207,
0.2889039218,
-0.2035365254,
0.9758683443,
-0.6195064783,
-0.4496171176,
-0.4168340564,
0.1220186949,
0.2735235095,
0.4672898054,
0.2718895972,
-0.7137001753,
-0.3083210289,
0.108989343,
-0.721870482,
-0.1074804291,
-0.3403743804,
-0.182199806,
0.225879088,
0.4119399488,
-0.4497903883,
0.1532769799,
0.4043825865,
-0.4652530849,
0.4815633893,
0.0950290933,
0.0818760768,
-1.2219433784,
0.3617398739,
0.0776505321,
-0.2656964064,
-0.5097678304,
-0.2188346237,
0.137701124,
-0.3447939456,
-0.208264187,
0.5947576165,
-0.5857515931,
-0.1812506169,
-0.4451723397,
0.3289718032,
-0.0028778489,
0.4626566768,
0.1214438826,
0.6046224833,
0.3143482804,
-0.5539346933,
0.0349507928,
0.4163955152,
-0.4428754747,
0.2294438332,
-0.229815498,
0.1091335267,
-0.1464039534,
-0.0101357633,
-0.6630507708,
-0.5207004547,
0.1716012508,
-0.3944620192,
0.2003501356,
-0.3711078167,
-0.7667819262,
-0.0275989156,
0.0422241203,
0.1355138272,
0.4698674977,
-0.7225803137,
0.2566416562,
0.5753241181,
-0.5300428867,
-0.4865351915,
-0.3976324201,
0.2617448568,
-0.0449422002,
-0.5673484802,
0.3192753494,
0.1629530936,
-0.1051848456,
0.0591879897,
-0.216985032,
0.0419477038,
0.0772686154,
0.2420750409,
0.4571065903,
-0.2730051279,
0.4302528501,
-0.1382877231,
-0.0104104318,
-0.0615693294,
-0.1622059792,
0.3356912732,
0.0574932285,
-0.0979230031,
-0.4436025023,
0.4805353284,
0.3337157667,
-0.2736998498,
0.466719389,
0.5310014486,
-0.5480853915,
-0.4164723754,
-0.5682947636,
-0.4698337018,
-0.4272110164,
0.5535785556,
-0.4300805926,
-0.6043714285,
0.1628210992,
-0.0093077049,
0.3200906813,
0.6195703745,
0.3565178812,
-0.2638551593,
0.8144710064,
0.6511494517,
-0.2148456126,
0.5519931912,
-0.2105016261,
-0.0578664988,
-0.6682270169,
-0.0231104009,
-0.5959848762,
-0.4036337733,
-0.3074465692,
-0.4194870293,
0.3088527918,
0.5157316923,
0.187528953,
0.3233653605,
-0.5262693763,
0.2974986434,
0.3049242496,
0.0733678192,
0.4120492935,
0.2550953031,
0.4113287628,
-0.1470687389,
-0.9041223526,
-0.7706688643,
1.1967039108,
0.2401973903,
0.8472681642,
-0.2039528638,
0.8058814406,
0.2151650488,
0.3957113624,
-0.6015450358,
0.4521181881,
-0.295368135,
-0.3371361792,
-0.343324095,
-0.8132722378,
-0.9120466709,
0.0175611991,
-0.6576273441,
-0.6536947489,
0.1677007675,
0.3594713807,
-0.2581700683,
0.2449233383,
-0.6774849892,
0.8087932467,
-0.2140503824,
-0.4641673565,
-0.0019341041,
-0.2256928682,
0.3161883354,
-0.4207626879,
0.249937892,
-0.0965558961,
0.1641711742,
1.0176734924,
-0.3464562595,
0.8112251163,
-0.1659910232,
0.100471586,
0.4077466428,
0.1730791628,
1.12682271,
0.1599041373,
-0.0738038123,
0.079190731,
-0.3394221365,
-0.1332572997,
-0.4619424343,
0.6481570005,
-0.5194946527,
-0.4186369479,
0.1359366179,
-0.6401953101,
-0.1137205884,
0.1091817245,
0.3799085021,
0.4869281948,
0.0906035453,
0.3738281727,
0.2469285429,
-0.0498193875,
0.4914258718,
0.4296781123,
0.0619047433,
-0.2916402221,
1.0339016914,
0.111483857,
0.0596408658,
0.4676192701,
0.0833717063,
-0.2621969581,
-0.5299155116,
-0.5523572564,
0.2710926533,
-0.5790589452,
-0.4177370071,
-0.6968125105,
-0.1972494572,
-0.2161404043,
-0.0165731832,
-0.7350382805,
-0.5183938742,
-0.3892827332,
0.036850512,
0.1496025473,
0.562038064,
0.0748704448,
0.2794820964,
-1.0573593378,
0.3097890913,
-0.0842997506,
-0.0479726531,
-0.2246613204,
-0.1473319381,
-0.5697962642,
-0.1739541739,
-0.2346080244,
-0.6262919307,
0.362781167,
0.1710913181,
0.3721723557,
0.3023270071,
0.1050051302,
0.7589211464,
-0.3793743551,
0.6276931763,
0.2180932164,
-0.6378480792,
0.9056860209,
-0.3308592737,
-0.0075959177,
0.4917096496,
-0.0129244151,
-0.3435444534,
-0.2412708849,
-0.6719027758,
-0.7681005597,
0.7792932987,
0.4510703087,
-0.3773079813,
-0.040617995,
0.6433782578,
0.1869624555,
0.1757400632,
-0.6112261415,
-0.084768489,
0.097736828,
-0.3288553655,
-0.2691314816,
-0.1972561777,
0.0588826239,
0.2608982623,
0.5016943216,
-0.3613411784,
-0.0172953643,
0.3607269824,
-0.2311272025,
-0.4992432892,
0.365385592,
0.0803939179,
0.6088867188,
-0.1536549181,
0.2779001594,
-0.0223618466,
-0.4070954621,
-0.1051889881,
0.1932867765,
-0.2372515947,
-0.0225256328,
0.54388237,
0.597868979,
0.0027728009,
-0.6732589602,
0.317669481,
0.0739393234,
0.0439182892,
0.0030629323,
0.3303973973,
-0.1110351756,
0.445659548,
0.427574873,
-0.1444232464,
-0.1280186325,
-0.4542262256,
0.3925151229,
0.4225325286,
-0.1546026021,
-0.4414585531,
0.8475064635,
0.3992463052,
-0.1414271146,
0.656273663,
0.0083738798,
-0.0166916326,
0.3224615753,
0.3457725048,
0.7044619322,
0.1240368485,
0.0839218795,
0.6695142984,
0.2577137649,
-0.0133406967,
0.275823921,
-0.2953077257,
-0.5508057475,
-0.6240009069,
-0.9348208308,
-0.1178029105,
0.5808747411,
-0.5021121502,
0.2027088702,
-0.235864535,
-0.1416441351,
0.079659909,
0.2860890925,
-0.9500484467,
0.2015816271,
0.2805936933,
0.8259875178,
-0.8019702435,
0.9588388205,
0.4368138611,
-0.485127449,
-0.8478260636,
-0.0793727189,
-0.1959700137,
-0.3228674233,
1.0403703451,
0.0628250316,
0.2216743082,
-0.0354717597,
-0.2739227414,
-0.8517330289,
1.0490307808,
0.476043433,
-0.945845902,
-0.3257270157,
0.2742832899,
0.2307629883,
-0.6653756499,
-0.2274388969,
0.3357682228,
0.4076899886,
-0.021623807,
-0.606629014,
0.2667576373,
-0.2739432156,
-0.1954805702,
0.1151058003,
-0.2836610377,
0.8640922904,
-0.1764160097,
-0.5224779248,
-0.1861810088,
0.6755895019,
0.3627183735,
-0.1364072859,
0.6385836601,
0.1898141354,
0.9166256189,
0.0040273834,
0.9732202291,
-0.3848540783,
0.1691573113,
1.1779922247,
-0.110635981,
0.9005343914,
0.459089309,
0.2883844674,
0.0991718546,
0.504216671,
-0.1652531028,
0.2403576225,
-0.135717839,
0.0757905617,
-0.621186316,
-0.2162147015,
-0.041508995,
0.6536991596,
0.3571237028,
-0.5977474451,
-0.3805221319,
-0.2569925189,
-0.1357556731,
-0.168716073,
-0.3350513875,
0.6278175712,
-0.0758743137,
-0.7259458899,
0.5471651554,
0.0138283148,
0.3755993843,
-0.4401866496,
-0.192064479,
-0.1646174192,
0.1809869856,
-0.2345923185,
-0.5789267421,
0.0755613372,
0.4859486222,
-0.4981057346,
-0.2370928824,
0.8322258592,
-0.5733111501,
-0.5537415743,
0.0008194553,
0.6427168846,
0.3252612352,
-0.241230756,
-0.3418323398,
0.1194298789,
0.1277758777,
-0.4506071508,
0.3284176588,
0.2328669727,
-0.0924855918,
0.347031951,
0.9527640939,
0.6108264327,
-0.1586253792,
-0.1839897782,
0.8234211206,
-0.9200506806,
-0.5656078458,
-0.8773600459,
0.5519815683,
-0.2417954206,
-0.1998694986,
0.5062173605,
0.7630965114,
0.5793073773,
-0.0495648794,
0.9549921155,
-0.0587579012,
0.4868882298,
-0.6724644899,
0.7994604111,
-0.4981766045,
0.2909006476,
-0.1827343553,
-1.0717508793,
0.0959647819,
0.2699365616,
0.0205933955,
-0.3708649576,
0.4611268044,
0.8542802334,
-0.1594174504,
-0.1862430722,
0.2315467447,
0.2056532055,
0.6667526364,
0.7085884213,
0.6427150965,
-0.3872354627,
0.8899875283,
-0.1555069238,
-0.2729643881,
-0.2597578466,
-0.7322758436,
-1.0482805967,
-0.8161269426,
-0.3527888656,
-0.1662265807,
-0.1491256952,
0.9621294141,
1.0125901699,
-0.5378546119,
-0.0616002567,
-0.0276672486,
-0.1331823766,
0.0819741115,
-0.2365997732,
0.7011563182,
-0.6255216002,
-0.7253888249,
0.8593782783,
0.0709910691,
0.0068357857,
-0.094908379,
0.0424827412,
0.1875260323,
-0.2541478872,
0.5377435684,
0.2439495921,
-0.4919480085,
-0.4698961377,
-0.1090271249,
-0.3077548146,
0.0995265916,
0.5846046805,
-0.8176407814,
0.2964680195,
0.4396564662,
0.8413022161,
0.5751707554,
0.1947248578,
0.4674683213,
-1.1058605909,
-0.0599168465,
-0.0462834537,
0.3259242773,
0.3634727001,
-0.7388103604,
0.5303581357,
0.2494226992,
-0.4298920035,
-0.845166266,
0.2462111712,
-0.9490299821,
-0.1647999138,
1.269895196,
0.1999192387,
-0.4235288203,
0.2777108252,
-0.0914342329,
0.3330684006,
-0.4469050765,
0.8910847902,
0.406516552,
-0.2448096424,
-0.0270744432,
-0.5587599874,
0.8023109436,
-0.0103264591,
-1.1429665089,
0.5668757558,
0.6154473424,
0.349378854,
0.3596487939,
0.4337172806,
-0.0122323018,
0.0926630571,
0.0655567348,
0.267252773,
-0.3769821823,
-0.5238694549,
0.1531849802,
0.4517321289,
-0.1620657891,
-0.2640459538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05535v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05535v2 | Detecting Check-Worthy Claims in Political Debates, Speeches, and Interviews Using Audio Data | 2023-05-24T12:09:42 | 2024-01-17T19:39:42 | Petar Ivanov, Ivan Koychev, Momchil Hardalov, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Developing tools to automatically detect check-worthy claims in political
debates and speeches can greatly help moderators of debates, journalists, and
fact-checkers. While previous work on this problem has focused exclusively on
the text modality, here we explore the utility of the audio modality as an
additional input. We create a new multimodal dataset (text and audio in
English) containing 48 hours of speech from past political debates in the USA.
We then experimentally demonstrate that, in the case of multiple speakers,
adding the audio modality yields sizable improvements over using the text
modality alone; moreover, an audio-only model could outperform a text-only one
for a single speaker. With the aim to enable future research, we make all our
data and code publicly available at
https://github.com/petar-iv/audio-checkworthiness-detection. | [
-0.5490282178,
-0.6934671998,
0.7831981182,
0.0182460919,
-0.4575388432,
-0.115420863,
-0.3283526599,
-0.4730881155,
0.3382689655,
0.5786361098,
-0.1381108165,
-0.1290862411,
-0.7445850968,
0.1736123711,
-0.6969563365,
0.9501643181,
0.3258703351,
0.0821023658,
-0.2445272803,
-0.2356523871,
-0.2978919148,
-0.4956062436,
-0.394102484,
-0.5404292345,
0.3334198892,
0.5294428468,
0.7598646283,
0.6386942863,
0.2767840922,
0.3091911972,
-0.0970620885,
0.3943380117,
-0.1183397323,
0.2238359302,
-0.3282591999,
-0.4147250652,
-0.3573527932,
0.3000740707,
0.5901191235,
0.1672142744,
0.0186328944,
-0.0746513605,
-0.2902442813,
0.2779536545,
-0.5631176233,
0.1447639316,
-0.8812928796,
-0.0548516661,
-0.497874409,
-0.6837991476,
-0.3904806077,
-0.3461682498,
0.1378851086,
-0.4021251798,
0.2818772495,
0.0034005546,
1.0086874962,
0.1756984293,
-0.8717332482,
-0.4379405081,
-0.8829116821,
0.5625603199,
-0.6742140055,
0.5563046932,
0.7360847592,
0.2193696946,
0.0824065581,
-0.4560192227,
-1.1437274218,
-0.1580982506,
-0.0831001103,
0.2677691281,
-0.4815732539,
0.100442484,
0.2101659775,
0.5658819675,
-0.2968404293,
-0.2177038789,
-0.2498203218,
-0.5130149722,
0.5348438025,
-0.2440623492,
0.2311463952,
-0.7483815551,
-0.2401982844,
-0.2781524956,
-0.361230731,
0.0845265612,
0.5911067128,
0.214016974,
-0.1074277014,
0.644163847,
-0.2168922871,
0.3680076599,
0.0429299437,
-0.234964624,
0.202548787,
-0.9527555108,
-0.0055750478,
0.1172004044,
0.8561471701,
0.3018826246,
-0.138095662,
0.2533967495,
-0.2166223526,
0.4064157903,
-0.0624697097,
-0.6672636271,
-0.3594765365,
0.3244961798,
-0.5329428911,
-0.1638022363,
0.0403313972,
-0.7160789371,
-0.7256801724,
-0.3462972641,
0.5384079218,
-0.425981164,
-0.6254066229,
0.3229164183,
-0.3819633424,
-0.013657595,
0.2813805342,
-0.354889214,
0.0156585686,
0.6586440802,
0.8712741137,
-0.1301653236,
0.1775492877,
-0.979660213,
-0.1879959852,
-0.5119934678,
1.2694001198,
-0.8152403235,
-0.2415693849,
0.0600609481,
0.0804632008,
0.1071480066,
-0.5990386009,
1.2453621626,
-0.3309722245,
0.63192451,
-0.4664208889,
-0.6980435252,
-0.0326058492,
0.3006988168,
-0.986276269,
0.7338038683,
-0.3710784614,
-0.6707962751,
0.7767050266,
-0.6991453767,
-0.3679504097,
-0.2055522501,
-0.4513468444,
-0.5957093835,
0.0561551712,
0.1519558281,
0.3254285157,
-0.1605102867,
0.3559216559,
-0.1057375446,
-0.0739732683,
0.5526098013,
-0.4690421224,
0.7198833227,
0.1429229379,
-0.5462017655,
0.0745092407,
-0.9304872751,
-0.2399349958,
-0.1519140005,
-0.6007421613,
-0.4486192465,
0.4341794848,
0.2720586061,
0.2175668329,
-0.2725608349,
-0.9801988006,
-0.1395987868,
-0.2678122222,
0.244824335,
0.6163780689,
-0.0928018987,
0.0117354989,
-0.6533207893,
0.4043780863,
0.1099858508,
-0.2965246141,
-0.4651761651,
-0.2791730762,
-0.6148014069,
-0.5395668149,
0.544387579,
0.6972501874,
-0.6871944666,
0.3393756747,
0.0475834385,
-0.2241484523,
-0.4686922431,
-0.0897553638,
0.1405681223,
0.296996206,
0.2079952657,
-0.1808857769,
-0.8617704511,
-0.9085049629,
-0.4082250893,
-0.5049962401,
-0.0529234968,
0.37146613,
0.4820439219,
-0.0249790102,
0.9534307122,
0.0063858633,
-0.1150899529,
0.048684109,
0.3245389462,
0.0725016817,
0.4779188037,
0.5275670886,
-0.8691381812,
-0.0342560001,
0.0394394808,
-0.3096177578,
-0.2998939753,
-0.5438082218,
0.0081513431,
-0.0328158177,
0.3966587484,
-0.4095544815,
0.2343655527,
0.767765224,
-0.7706762552,
0.4284276664,
0.2229190022,
0.7546794415,
-1.0171747208,
-0.0526158512,
-0.0576723851,
-0.784011066,
-0.6718029976,
-0.6660478115,
-0.0917509496,
0.1680341214,
-0.231235683,
0.2125195712,
-0.0781602412,
0.2735593021,
-0.581273973,
0.3172203302,
0.146276176,
0.0208094176,
0.0136232842,
0.7779833078,
0.4897402823,
-0.4385880232,
0.3801210821,
0.2902702391,
-0.6405580044,
1.1245740652,
-0.760607779,
0.301962316,
-0.1992701143,
0.2834669352,
-1.4341028929,
-0.3932819664,
0.0896465704,
-0.5445752144,
0.0212502759,
-0.0459339172,
-0.3316082358,
0.0981896222,
-0.221220836,
0.3596207798,
-0.0365355052,
-0.5659610629,
0.6599640846,
0.8023972511,
-0.2918100655,
-0.1554856747,
-0.5190225244,
0.2897050381,
-0.1155005842,
-0.3740462363,
0.4679839313,
-0.1057973504,
-0.4540835619,
0.0673192814,
-0.2715451121,
-0.3506348133,
-0.2376520336,
0.1577124745,
0.1044897437,
-0.1197674572,
0.3769435883,
-0.0632031783,
-0.1260858178,
0.1157905608,
-0.0376997143,
0.2517628372,
-0.0493212044,
-0.4343741536,
-0.7927275896,
0.6877424717,
0.7565558553,
-0.2261902243,
0.2545308769,
0.6191758513,
-0.2915610373,
-0.0421253406,
-0.8674949408,
-0.242099762,
-0.4352388084,
0.3029878139,
-0.0076762517,
-0.865396142,
0.3102080226,
-0.1469283849,
0.3621324301,
0.4726185501,
0.4798149467,
-0.0530097112,
1.1023999453,
0.5185438395,
0.0456722155,
0.7279946804,
0.137808308,
0.121047765,
-0.1583684683,
-0.1078395173,
-0.9873119593,
-0.0340726338,
-0.4788915515,
-0.3647299111,
0.283721149,
-0.4472870529,
0.1807838082,
0.1703429222,
-0.4944687784,
0.543497622,
0.4215612411,
0.1008347124,
0.5377331972,
-0.0217480939,
0.2377206385,
-0.2488525361,
-0.3506950438,
-0.4088606536,
0.7557634115,
0.3332133591,
0.4028701782,
0.0918518007,
0.3170064688,
0.6151981354,
0.0140026473,
-0.804284513,
0.2766893804,
0.0727660209,
-0.9381622076,
-0.1642313898,
-0.530785203,
-0.8478093147,
0.4631311893,
-0.5877017379,
-0.2149578035,
0.5312913656,
0.3037325442,
-0.2273966968,
0.3680760264,
-0.3919350803,
0.5848212242,
-0.2482762337,
0.0269851014,
-0.3798979223,
-0.2246339768,
0.1696866155,
0.020949183,
0.5010159016,
-0.3078868091,
0.0470887423,
1.1093024015,
-0.1273147911,
0.5107789636,
-0.096265316,
-0.1238433644,
0.2814817131,
-0.2080999315,
0.3925463855,
0.1459378004,
0.0685842782,
-0.0495579988,
0.3786366582,
-0.2422550917,
-0.2678975761,
0.2228494585,
-0.5245193243,
-0.4177515507,
-0.6027806401,
-0.4220802784,
-0.1752819121,
0.3192110956,
0.2232044339,
0.6176970005,
-0.2585750222,
0.8825784922,
0.8239507079,
0.0366269499,
0.4107370377,
0.5077667832,
-0.0050031221,
-0.656894505,
0.8306031823,
0.0332596488,
0.1095636562,
0.1286667883,
0.5947048664,
-0.389452219,
-0.3147713244,
-0.2210164964,
-0.0051745926,
-0.4893765748,
-0.2368875891,
-0.7373573184,
0.2943835855,
-0.094169423,
0.1442482322,
-0.6795032024,
-0.6654068828,
0.1293124259,
-0.2242645323,
0.3807125986,
0.5191355348,
-0.5172646046,
0.0317274444,
-0.44291991,
0.629146874,
0.5806359649,
0.4054926038,
-0.8429096937,
-0.4823638499,
-0.0784190968,
0.1261034608,
-0.3879028559,
-1.2387075424,
-0.1494131982,
0.411498785,
0.5165029764,
0.4217009842,
0.1793066412,
0.3290853798,
-0.1910388172,
0.8856856823,
0.0878076926,
-0.9922964573,
0.6470227838,
-0.4740620852,
0.0875485688,
0.7493064404,
0.1756643355,
-0.5278909802,
-0.5033735037,
-0.4834180772,
-0.5310864449,
0.5114309192,
0.4694545865,
0.1668301821,
0.0157944448,
0.0304344017,
0.176490128,
0.2592635453,
-0.7308732867,
-0.1932362914,
-0.6093664765,
0.1204786524,
0.1289333552,
-0.3343479931,
-0.5740416646,
-0.2350197583,
0.6984239221,
-0.1794808507,
0.1576972753,
0.5668998957,
0.2720725536,
-0.0786574557,
0.868329525,
0.7563966513,
0.6519852281,
-0.0547600165,
0.5216667056,
-0.0244974643,
-0.4318185449,
0.1771065742,
0.1978948563,
-0.0724908784,
0.7231221199,
0.2207326442,
0.6913235188,
-0.0249841269,
-0.7120158672,
0.6720054746,
-0.2379564345,
-0.4338436127,
-0.1667202562,
-0.1658456475,
-0.0472668707,
0.3922685385,
0.2849530876,
0.2938868105,
0.3640032113,
-0.8598592281,
0.5669808984,
0.6027716398,
-0.2800374031,
-0.2608075738,
0.6425045133,
0.2664969265,
-0.4400174618,
-0.0911407098,
-0.1323549449,
-0.6661909223,
0.3394475579,
0.4441276491,
0.723878324,
-0.2402801663,
0.2958318591,
0.1809102297,
0.3848629892,
0.0205915924,
0.4865967929,
-0.2472278476,
-0.7009364963,
-0.5599359274,
-0.1107032746,
-0.9572187066,
0.3819821179,
-0.4104880989,
0.0329464078,
-0.310525775,
-0.5670590401,
0.4736924469,
0.107769452,
-0.5601531267,
-0.0470674783,
0.166588515,
0.4822522998,
-1.0584062338,
0.4972471595,
0.5256506205,
-0.0142027829,
-0.3504040241,
-0.1711567342,
0.4430611432,
-0.1581690609,
0.1316523999,
-0.1853360236,
-0.4372779727,
-0.6756843328,
-0.7613633871,
-0.4734157622,
0.5030671358,
0.7025176883,
-0.4985460639,
0.3553137481,
-0.0503677353,
0.1594067067,
-0.1694160253,
0.1378068328,
0.5879299641,
0.6452847123,
-0.0483202823,
-1.1247596741,
-0.1540121436,
-0.351323396,
-0.6076653004,
0.1817623526,
-0.4812423289,
0.9022194147,
0.3250808418,
-0.315905571,
-0.4336130917,
0.8341252208,
0.0790325254,
0.4760694206,
1.1828894615,
0.115067102,
1.0952664614,
-0.1888206303,
0.8940171599,
-0.2502171397,
0.1795919091,
0.9697887897,
0.1057605371,
0.6067394018,
0.3774021268,
0.0578562841,
0.390314132,
0.1706993878,
0.074126862,
0.1943526715,
-0.1892144829,
-0.4454449117,
-0.7558782697,
-0.6412275434,
-0.3882313073,
0.8604591489,
0.2922520041,
-0.0311333761,
-0.1234389842,
0.1744939089,
0.4412586987,
0.3356152475,
0.2290670425,
0.6085442305,
-0.1683835238,
-0.6493113637,
0.2412099391,
-0.3527782559,
0.8163311481,
-0.4165267944,
-0.2704693079,
0.0995870382,
-0.07475622,
-0.3689137995,
-0.6855942011,
0.2306064218,
0.0778686553,
-0.3295938373,
-0.2681106627,
0.6515418887,
-0.7030844092,
-0.1864582449,
-0.0080711171,
0.5607346892,
0.0358779058,
0.00610349,
-0.3145425916,
0.3005673885,
-0.0755328238,
-0.3173865676,
-0.1711916029,
0.4151589274,
0.3366824985,
0.2881338596,
0.8435669541,
0.3323895335,
-0.3138281703,
-0.0147772776,
0.8266419768,
-0.4843087494,
-0.4995203018,
-0.732888341,
0.2947162092,
-0.3797747791,
-0.4054344296,
0.8703956604,
0.7185502648,
0.7390537858,
0.3650962114,
0.9089553952,
-0.2499501109,
0.6951803565,
-0.5291598439,
0.637919426,
-0.5223981738,
-0.1312066615,
-0.5227778554,
-0.29984653,
-0.1651810408,
0.9036530852,
-0.0000418329,
-0.2553730905,
0.8076629043,
0.8609776497,
-0.1984956712,
0.3595720232,
0.2912822962,
0.1067960933,
0.7340754867,
0.247741133,
1.0076799393,
-0.3096282482,
0.8038686514,
-0.3104998469,
-0.1512267143,
-0.0407444276,
-1.12523067,
-0.9467023611,
-0.9179669023,
-0.5732907653,
-0.5953481793,
-0.205755651,
0.9545795918,
0.9819015265,
-0.9608560205,
-0.0315568298,
0.3470660448,
0.1863778681,
-0.1492206454,
-0.1896716356,
0.2651371062,
0.002641133,
-0.6822140217,
0.7928448319,
0.1997353733,
-0.254314214,
0.0758081451,
0.1194514111,
-0.4589010477,
0.6979301572,
0.5407625437,
0.3946908712,
-0.5965134501,
-0.824873507,
-0.2022761106,
-0.0171980187,
0.2534198463,
1.2952352762,
-0.5943869948,
0.9180363417,
0.7359791398,
0.7178183198,
0.3729502559,
0.1327791363,
0.4404990673,
-0.6336451173,
0.0816976354,
0.2847668529,
0.5504391193,
0.3539986312,
-0.05597803,
0.2804782391,
0.2915678322,
-0.7907488942,
-1.0945800543,
0.1861665845,
-1.2284277678,
0.1241862327,
1.0308372974,
0.2303751409,
0.1575108171,
-0.5363788009,
-0.6248424053,
0.2750962377,
-0.5900946259,
0.7714880109,
0.9486762881,
-0.1837963164,
-0.1526329368,
-0.7800607085,
0.7737545967,
0.5742732882,
-0.8775229454,
0.1258605123,
0.7997561097,
0.1056807041,
0.4169631898,
0.8665502667,
-0.063045904,
0.6447973847,
0.1245156676,
-0.4185888171,
-0.0197903421,
-0.4164326489,
-0.2785930634,
0.4048978388,
-0.2607070208,
-0.3530172706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15087v1 | Pento-DIARef: A Diagnostic Dataset for Learning the Incremental Algorithm for Referring Expression Generation from Examples | 2023-05-24T12:05:53 | 2023-05-24T12:05:53 | Philipp Sadler, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | NLP tasks are typically defined extensionally through datasets containing
example instantiations (e.g., pairs of image i and text t), but motivated
intensionally through capabilities invoked in verbal descriptions of the task
(e.g., "t is a description of i, for which the content of i needs to be
recognised and understood"). We present Pento-DIARef, a diagnostic dataset in a
visual domain of puzzle pieces where referring expressions are generated by a
well-known symbolic algorithm (the "Incremental Algorithm"), which itself is
motivated by appeal to a hypothesised capability (eliminating distractors
through application of Gricean maxims). Our question then is whether the
extensional description (the dataset) is sufficient for a neural model to pick
up the underlying regularity and exhibit this capability given the simple task
definition of producing expressions from visual inputs. We find that a model
supported by a vision detection step and a targeted data generation scheme
achieves an almost perfect BLEU@1 score and sentence accuracy, whereas simpler
baselines do not. | [
-0.0934051573,
-0.637476027,
0.5076589584,
0.3682100177,
-0.4463690519,
-0.408252418,
-0.2658138871,
-0.408077091,
0.1316897869,
0.3439671397,
-0.6741619706,
-0.5071299672,
-0.6288909912,
0.4752084613,
-0.583073318,
0.9976006746,
0.1094600111,
-0.1990806907,
-0.2449147403,
0.0245119091,
-0.729173243,
-0.1616063267,
-0.6682515144,
-0.1791618019,
0.5022746325,
0.4613597691,
0.467772305,
1.0482053757,
0.8094940782,
0.256278336,
0.3325141966,
0.1561611444,
-0.1924569011,
0.2154468298,
-0.1059611216,
-0.4645729661,
-0.2130528688,
-0.0513009317,
0.5086817741,
1.006960392,
-0.1580145508,
0.1117487401,
-0.0103830351,
0.6352712512,
-0.4100733399,
0.3655712306,
-0.6739715338,
0.0614838488,
-0.171134457,
-0.1948295534,
-0.2555040121,
-0.3407075405,
0.1531835198,
-0.7739533782,
0.6125568151,
-0.2747364938,
0.9709177017,
0.3071990013,
-0.0710540563,
-0.5818320513,
-0.7351180315,
0.5145412087,
-0.2901514173,
0.1369331628,
0.2521045506,
0.281812638,
0.0896591768,
-1.0198107958,
-0.6095017791,
-0.3157431781,
-0.2121093422,
0.207947582,
-0.2028836161,
-0.1938387305,
0.5620700717,
0.1368763596,
-0.7586793303,
-0.3246359825,
-0.5176828504,
0.1023530886,
0.5180479288,
0.4331464469,
0.0462744609,
-0.0645337775,
-0.3268828094,
0.0995588452,
-0.7604164481,
-0.1578474939,
-0.0907030031,
0.3088414669,
-0.1846654713,
0.4272354245,
-0.1705251932,
1.0571717024,
0.1908261478,
-0.0317193232,
-0.0090148719,
-0.3652662337,
-0.2410736382,
-0.0346450284,
0.5514504313,
0.220422253,
0.642845273,
-0.1433199495,
-0.1499195546,
0.5067484975,
0.38597247,
-0.6539849043,
-0.6064516902,
-0.0044574593,
-0.2322205454,
-0.3539662361,
0.1738643348,
-0.6296395063,
-0.2081476599,
-0.2577467859,
0.2497575432,
-0.631842792,
0.0178383775,
0.2195103019,
0.1038711742,
0.0636919662,
0.1515592933,
-0.7404595017,
0.4321067333,
0.4037712216,
0.6605555415,
0.0619061254,
-0.3208827376,
-0.5876505971,
-0.0033736697,
-0.7141920924,
0.7956129313,
-0.6732343435,
-0.2743713558,
0.0365843773,
0.0325381383,
-0.2758274376,
-0.7465565801,
0.3742724359,
-0.1463118792,
0.2298455983,
-0.0179466512,
-0.544649303,
-0.2695224583,
0.0311811659,
-0.6273439527,
0.8939681053,
0.3665010929,
-0.4896382391,
0.5430112481,
-0.6779618859,
-0.4827993512,
0.4252123833,
-0.3852261603,
-0.3171013296,
0.2690985203,
0.0620438829,
0.4625072181,
-0.433509469,
0.2126888037,
0.1420588195,
-0.2359670252,
0.0963266715,
-0.0750383511,
0.3901935518,
-0.0827477351,
-0.4514831305,
-0.1203999445,
-0.6954872608,
-0.1736937612,
0.3081951439,
-0.0898030773,
-0.308738023,
-0.1005982086,
-0.3101539016,
0.2344906479,
0.160696581,
-0.5506229997,
0.094583571,
-0.2753219604,
-0.0218183119,
0.5354354382,
0.2582542896,
-0.0871694833,
-0.4605253935,
0.519284308,
0.2570614815,
0.1273658574,
-0.5458790064,
-0.7664214969,
-0.8834841847,
-0.2023766637,
0.3280745149,
0.6705792546,
-0.880089283,
0.5676957965,
-0.4723663926,
-0.1623826474,
-0.3204825222,
0.2543966174,
0.3550556898,
0.9773535132,
0.2559139431,
-0.3408785164,
-0.3530921042,
-1.0928851366,
0.2680407465,
0.0111664645,
-0.2904164195,
0.2778559327,
0.341393292,
0.1355860084,
0.6824534535,
-0.3464167714,
-0.3817290962,
-0.1141077653,
0.2952794135,
0.513050139,
0.3660944998,
0.467269361,
-0.8060234189,
-0.5954828262,
0.0751338974,
-0.9733419418,
-0.285512656,
-0.4645105898,
0.2923700213,
-0.1866037846,
0.3237110078,
-0.5561791658,
0.5992201567,
0.1612754464,
-0.4587109387,
0.6166455746,
-0.2004260123,
-0.0703136697,
-0.8996836543,
0.2478526682,
0.5508033037,
-0.4348097742,
-0.603336513,
0.1972702146,
0.0416736677,
-0.0571683235,
-0.1465510279,
0.2363605052,
-0.2026804388,
0.1949660629,
-0.2440776676,
0.311635524,
-0.0103002237,
0.398429215,
0.2896075845,
0.6929273009,
0.7775190473,
-0.7924503088,
0.565087676,
0.2090910971,
-0.170844242,
0.651776731,
-0.7809894085,
0.0708664134,
-0.0802302659,
-0.4362210929,
-1.0357941389,
-0.1263490468,
0.1186328307,
-0.3706342578,
0.4418448806,
0.1582435369,
-0.4986717105,
-0.3731679022,
-0.069492124,
0.3153201044,
0.5955680013,
-0.5165478587,
0.256875664,
0.051711522,
-0.2314324081,
-0.3510347307,
-0.4697572589,
0.1458020359,
-0.2657562792,
-0.4242736101,
0.4067377448,
0.1866478175,
-0.0848011374,
-0.0611073188,
0.0013949833,
-0.0116361491,
-0.098111175,
0.0808252171,
0.3527630568,
-0.1471142471,
0.3098538816,
-0.2402772605,
-0.1636010706,
0.0049915491,
-0.0427994579,
0.3992473781,
-0.0734670311,
-0.0095208678,
-0.3251998425,
0.438411653,
0.2628572881,
0.0111785997,
0.0013495211,
0.4464159608,
-0.5297242403,
-0.2462626696,
-0.1549574286,
-0.3332820535,
-0.4710372388,
0.4046284854,
-0.5996371508,
-0.3976546824,
0.381627351,
-0.2929163277,
-0.0339989737,
0.4939818084,
0.4696944654,
-0.1210932061,
0.734831214,
0.8588832617,
0.2983979881,
0.1367959827,
-0.3419601917,
-0.0123811858,
-0.7580785751,
-0.1752320975,
-0.2638091445,
-0.3021050394,
-0.4826318026,
-0.2554739714,
0.4618729949,
0.0572304465,
-0.0279048923,
0.3765510023,
-0.8392629623,
0.2846663296,
0.4372185767,
0.3129704297,
0.16921404,
0.0356516093,
-0.3231429756,
-0.2192093134,
-0.8606110811,
-0.4179853797,
0.9928452969,
0.0389056429,
0.5197274089,
-0.2285893112,
0.4472825527,
0.3712171018,
0.5772017241,
-0.900759995,
0.6790398955,
-0.5539321899,
-0.1627631336,
-0.0315385759,
-0.4075492024,
-1.345792532,
-0.2982497513,
-0.1183664575,
-0.8667407632,
0.3968927264,
0.094826296,
-0.3549433649,
-0.0911948234,
-0.3755146861,
0.8805666566,
0.0035554133,
-0.268122226,
-0.0823158249,
-0.5877050757,
0.4095997512,
-0.0881171897,
-0.2562489212,
0.0658712536,
-0.2282619327,
0.6870587468,
-0.2752294242,
0.8073014617,
-0.2135859728,
0.1524775922,
0.2597400844,
0.3115569651,
0.3759637773,
-0.019742053,
0.1118245348,
-0.0996214226,
-0.1353103369,
-0.3583448827,
-0.8145253062,
0.4323636293,
-0.2061929703,
-0.4287694395,
-0.1068554074,
-0.4603792727,
-0.2492340654,
-0.0399499238,
0.3313044012,
0.5461253524,
-0.0598618686,
0.0532842502,
0.6091532111,
-0.0120482827,
0.471968621,
0.3476772606,
-0.0814353451,
-0.1664677858,
0.9858306646,
-0.080937244,
-0.071565412,
0.3742668033,
0.1804713011,
-0.1144207567,
-0.5026011467,
-0.4134612978,
0.4195794463,
-0.5681949854,
-0.3879883885,
-0.0244109817,
0.0654639825,
-0.0053198794,
0.0890512764,
-0.0955285951,
-0.5728610754,
-0.0265355874,
0.0102070486,
0.3825207651,
0.7606198788,
-0.175661549,
0.1930334568,
-0.6386393905,
0.4745709598,
0.4587679505,
0.1210254505,
-0.3345392048,
-0.4146566689,
-0.4053021073,
-0.0788127929,
-0.2657454312,
-0.9508169293,
0.3550690413,
0.4914412796,
0.2992172837,
0.5014853477,
-0.1751966178,
0.5364482999,
-0.4558848441,
0.6006985903,
0.2656596899,
-0.6773481965,
0.7191026211,
-0.240505904,
0.3829740584,
0.303991586,
0.6812636256,
-0.5709949136,
-0.32836923,
-0.7464566827,
-0.4747914076,
0.2911151052,
0.0771348104,
0.1153272316,
-0.4269698262,
0.8169865608,
0.3724845052,
0.205623731,
-0.5891107917,
-0.2059324682,
-0.1128313765,
-0.4463248551,
0.1209209859,
-0.0561139807,
-0.2765859962,
-0.276132822,
0.3911847174,
-0.327627033,
0.7172140479,
0.5662794709,
-0.0069753844,
-0.1041018218,
-0.2812672555,
0.5144261122,
0.8064141273,
-0.0762458667,
0.0033377882,
-0.2934246659,
-0.7183359265,
-0.0230258275,
0.1675445288,
-0.2208493799,
0.4006240666,
0.5050796866,
0.621737659,
-0.3536070585,
-0.6387215853,
0.6109808683,
0.0315380618,
-0.402818948,
-0.1574790627,
0.0138359936,
-0.2464122772,
0.0044790329,
0.540941298,
-0.0499574803,
0.1661302447,
-0.2290343344,
0.6764525175,
0.2657755315,
-0.5006569624,
-0.4917864799,
0.4237700403,
-0.0649763271,
-0.3584088981,
0.9171212316,
-0.1945609301,
-0.2245874554,
0.7462788224,
0.5260284543,
0.9394286871,
-0.2323228419,
0.2566325366,
0.3848668039,
0.4316105843,
0.2977658212,
0.4865463674,
-0.0966046602,
-0.9251752496,
-0.5034931302,
-0.4608498216,
-0.1247616559,
0.4002201855,
-0.6993032694,
0.1315841228,
-0.5341140628,
-0.1425312012,
0.3902747631,
-0.2684791684,
-0.8892682791,
0.6196966171,
0.0855867639,
0.8058602214,
-0.8875228167,
0.8642609119,
0.7102453113,
-0.5338133574,
-0.6234561801,
0.0723985285,
-0.5508552194,
-0.6862891316,
0.8220127821,
0.1334579587,
0.1807625294,
-0.1237663329,
-0.5549536943,
-0.4055199325,
0.7748157382,
0.4980911911,
-0.3793514669,
-0.0705682039,
0.1644639224,
0.5982900858,
-0.8017155528,
0.006581306,
0.5129316449,
0.4736326337,
-0.1085496396,
-0.9521009922,
0.3784583509,
-0.4737547636,
0.0076670446,
0.1346114278,
-0.3126786947,
0.714653492,
-0.2799377143,
-0.3448377848,
0.1656663567,
0.2366145849,
0.0315400772,
0.1198458597,
0.4599391818,
0.5713064075,
0.4272772074,
-0.2545619905,
1.3977985382,
-0.3359207213,
0.0954668373,
1.0949442387,
-0.0820380002,
0.5878733993,
0.4611488879,
-0.1855691224,
0.6181123257,
0.7046174407,
-0.1991032511,
0.69711411,
0.1725924164,
-0.3387487829,
-0.2405284196,
-0.073760666,
-0.0010783942,
0.5733229518,
0.6907964945,
-0.6650470495,
-0.6017317772,
0.0266180914,
-0.4607279301,
0.2867527604,
-0.2858087122,
0.9115626216,
-0.1126897708,
-0.4991950393,
0.9424287081,
-0.0062058144,
0.2864281833,
-0.5900654197,
-0.5321063399,
-0.2705357373,
0.0643023103,
-0.0143923536,
-0.7133752108,
0.5823556781,
-0.2531912327,
-0.141120106,
0.1021036729,
0.5463806987,
-0.3899410665,
-0.569539845,
-0.0629900917,
0.7204468846,
0.3483965397,
0.0408250429,
-0.763313055,
-0.4703526795,
-0.0360100195,
-0.0821917728,
0.0314346328,
0.5604473352,
-0.1615790129,
0.6055067182,
0.2607990801,
0.2985562086,
0.1107996479,
-0.0304595977,
0.7152741551,
-0.4124144316,
-0.2590508461,
-0.6709697843,
0.3366152346,
-0.068652831,
-0.4023676515,
0.3727284968,
0.5484269857,
0.6585954428,
-0.3232261539,
0.7589820027,
-0.1012470126,
0.414080292,
-0.3821872175,
0.1145722196,
-0.3581224978,
-0.0255664717,
0.05516674,
-0.7528313994,
-0.5723651648,
0.8774276972,
-0.1911304295,
-0.0570861697,
1.0166708231,
0.8422475457,
-0.1959222704,
-0.0361966044,
0.5545367599,
0.115188919,
-0.1923978925,
0.8622680306,
0.4772880673,
-0.4914110005,
0.5011729598,
-0.4724551141,
-0.4304215312,
0.28438586,
-0.737036705,
-0.705691874,
-0.7432579994,
-0.605725348,
-0.2202164233,
0.2178898752,
0.5901319385,
0.7342443466,
-0.7020404339,
-0.3486080468,
-0.5239108801,
-0.0566525236,
-0.7637991309,
-0.2472344339,
0.4597487748,
-0.6015345454,
-0.7794252634,
0.2340586782,
0.4527309239,
-0.0884414166,
-0.1109975651,
0.2728135288,
-0.2438045144,
0.0379682034,
0.4629781246,
0.3024208546,
-0.2402227223,
-0.301524967,
0.0200778339,
0.1251941472,
0.2710000873,
0.9769381881,
-0.938456893,
0.5782014728,
0.1173159182,
0.5363274217,
0.5269790888,
0.000219276,
0.6595665216,
-1.0043946505,
0.1776826531,
0.3917917311,
0.462344557,
0.4023445845,
-0.4535710812,
0.7493598461,
0.544634521,
-0.1525331438,
-0.4450921416,
0.4583239257,
-0.849132359,
-0.1281948835,
0.7518609166,
-0.4368981719,
-0.3597738743,
-0.1356201172,
0.02533409,
0.0656856894,
-0.0826239213,
1.0940445662,
0.434707284,
-0.4414716065,
-0.3711715937,
-0.3215442896,
0.5930691957,
0.3910496533,
-0.7324737906,
0.1507046372,
0.4230980277,
0.1077582166,
0.5604009628,
0.4529025555,
-0.1776530296,
0.7788259983,
0.2190292925,
-0.073194325,
-0.1426951885,
-0.5639455914,
-0.1723095775,
0.3190219998,
-0.082198143,
-0.5048811436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15083v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15083v4 | Eliciting the Translation Ability of Large Language Models via Multilingual Finetuning with Translation Instructions | 2023-05-24T12:00:24 | 2024-04-15T06:02:59 | Jiahuan Li, Hao Zhou, Shujian Huang, Shanbo Cheng, Jiajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale Pretrained Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and GPT4, have
shown strong abilities in multilingual translations, without being explicitly
trained on parallel corpora. It is interesting how the LLMs obtain their
ability to carry out translation instructions for different languages. In this
paper, we present a detailed analysis by finetuning a multilingual pretrained
language model, XGLM-7B, to perform multilingual translation following given
instructions. Firstly, we show that multilingual LLMs have stronger translation
abilities than previously demonstrated. For a certain language, the performance
depends on its similarity to English and the amount of data used in the
pretraining phase. Secondly, we find that LLMs' ability to carry out
translation instructions relies on the understanding of translation
instructions and the alignment among different languages. With multilingual
finetuning, LLMs could learn to perform the translation task well even for
those language pairs unseen during the instruction tuning phase. | [
-0.3781829774,
-0.4488184154,
0.5682491064,
0.1524349302,
-0.581309855,
0.0246681944,
-0.783888042,
-0.3704223633,
-0.2085384429,
0.4667716026,
-0.6703649163,
-0.4248137474,
-0.8635184169,
0.2488267273,
-0.4205085039,
1.3223131895,
-0.1462400556,
0.5041469336,
0.3497009873,
-0.1274884343,
-0.5114073753,
-0.5739527345,
-0.3744239807,
-0.2952027917,
0.5810040236,
0.3538945913,
0.7110351324,
0.5858151317,
0.5541062951,
0.378362298,
0.0766801164,
0.2662844062,
-0.8122278452,
-0.4744262695,
-0.1397851706,
-0.9191142321,
-0.4814473391,
0.1951909512,
0.9020569921,
0.6314101815,
-0.023272885,
0.1355998665,
0.2856179774,
0.2533668578,
-0.0854348242,
0.4288568795,
-0.6943310499,
-0.0041522598,
-0.292198956,
-0.2568426728,
-0.4908930659,
-0.4424429834,
-0.147349596,
-0.5767987967,
0.1657172292,
0.0927714929,
0.6715711355,
-0.033589758,
-0.3748667836,
-0.4628915787,
-0.5072666407,
0.7669276595,
-0.87532866,
0.4642369747,
0.2051965445,
0.3141289055,
0.1302073002,
-0.5106364489,
-0.5144150257,
-0.439732343,
-0.2732948959,
-0.0232112985,
0.3350280523,
0.1653533578,
0.3284342885,
0.5769394636,
-0.5948179364,
0.279645741,
-0.5761386752,
0.0347164124,
0.3060001731,
-0.0649740249,
0.4469206929,
0.0913346708,
-0.3518006802,
-0.1919666678,
-0.6306608915,
-0.0273914542,
0.2711714804,
0.5815887451,
-0.4798704088,
0.5663335323,
-0.0358772203,
0.6746190786,
-0.0145914722,
-0.2156547457,
0.3900243342,
-0.4810735583,
-0.0996703431,
0.2837288082,
0.7606647015,
0.2405748814,
0.4088628888,
-0.3207140565,
-0.3764795661,
-0.1512059271,
0.1237186417,
-0.8144283891,
0.2080263793,
-0.0540909208,
-0.4165324569,
0.1308254898,
-0.1510152519,
-0.3149650097,
0.0853043199,
-0.6963529587,
0.5539824963,
-0.4334188402,
-0.2426398993,
0.1776301563,
0.255941689,
0.5342767835,
0.261569351,
-1.0862326622,
0.0927503183,
0.7518920302,
0.8075010777,
-0.1182297766,
-0.8167539835,
-0.7468479276,
0.1479243934,
-0.4184673131,
0.3693557978,
-0.4073117077,
-0.0168066844,
0.0143835805,
0.2880974114,
-0.2788347006,
-0.2346213758,
0.2112153023,
-0.6331207752,
-0.0213675909,
-0.1848504543,
-0.40974015,
-0.2904882133,
0.3004405499,
-0.489105165,
0.3273006976,
-0.1010466069,
-0.4071068168,
0.2325600535,
-0.3662260473,
-0.440559119,
0.0266227387,
-0.1819566041,
0.0016690841,
0.3240609765,
0.1883727163,
0.7100863457,
-0.3587135971,
0.0266200528,
-0.3051175177,
-0.2768495977,
0.0347018652,
-0.6591833234,
0.5516803265,
0.1481472552,
-0.3048804998,
0.2023248225,
-0.5341615677,
0.1871055216,
0.0756301731,
-0.4540178478,
-0.0810958445,
-0.4342910647,
-0.1731119007,
0.5177220106,
0.2668489218,
-0.3515172899,
0.3853747547,
-0.516990304,
0.358024776,
0.5465496182,
-0.4793614149,
0.556843102,
-0.1083666384,
0.6710256338,
-0.258315593,
0.0121922884,
-0.2806136012,
-0.3046528101,
-0.600196898,
-0.1222524792,
0.2937214673,
0.7697911263,
-0.7609152198,
-0.0960642472,
-0.3816589713,
-0.4121851325,
-0.7629594207,
0.5085356832,
0.8784480691,
0.0606812984,
0.4650581181,
-0.1614331603,
-0.0786485597,
-0.6571487784,
0.0253200531,
0.3122014403,
0.1693534553,
-0.0700156093,
0.1444105357,
-0.0152792362,
-0.2092348784,
-0.21536991,
-0.2725655437,
-0.5089369416,
0.0811450854,
0.3627690673,
0.5142289996,
0.4800226688,
-0.5570082068,
-0.5365819931,
0.6690507531,
-0.7706726193,
-0.1248281375,
-0.1717797071,
-0.3166247308,
-0.0554488599,
0.8338521719,
-0.6066662669,
-0.0220078994,
0.8785768747,
0.1493499726,
0.5749272704,
-0.6180602908,
0.431946069,
-1.0127099752,
-0.1734241396,
-0.4234532118,
-0.4142933488,
-0.5771121383,
0.4505905509,
0.2662847936,
-0.1090357006,
-0.6808900833,
0.5075913072,
-0.9002989531,
-0.0694099963,
-0.2766640484,
0.2496630251,
-0.1966704577,
0.4439345896,
0.0641223341,
0.5982505083,
0.5134599209,
-0.5498925447,
0.2974809408,
0.2151104957,
-0.622156322,
0.3636686504,
-0.3506629765,
0.12737602,
-0.0799848735,
-0.2839361429,
-0.9097812176,
-0.2122578621,
-0.0396033786,
-0.1821818352,
0.672981739,
-0.2749810219,
-0.4789344072,
-0.2163559496,
0.185282439,
0.4579963088,
0.2862699032,
-0.5570110679,
0.4820123315,
0.0490478426,
-0.3961827159,
-0.4422572851,
-0.5704538822,
-0.0673442259,
-0.2904923558,
-0.5617123246,
0.1434303224,
-0.0452903844,
0.0614013746,
-0.3890784681,
0.2456800044,
0.0019012081,
-0.0487679169,
-0.0825602785,
0.2038596123,
-0.2853004336,
-0.0154489055,
0.1433022916,
-0.2007339299,
0.0348378234,
-0.2238435,
0.6423127651,
-0.0996284932,
-0.4623464942,
-0.3532647192,
0.3505691886,
0.6608664989,
-0.6358036399,
0.7958186269,
0.8901211619,
0.0159183703,
-0.0729995146,
-0.507932961,
-0.1752359718,
-0.4320884943,
0.6192343235,
-0.7496835589,
-0.696777761,
0.6196736097,
-0.17655918,
0.2490488589,
0.2088114619,
0.8643497825,
0.2323977351,
1.3275103569,
0.5107063055,
0.0271400474,
0.4757814109,
-0.2444555461,
0.0002167151,
-0.6335622072,
-0.0142864222,
-0.3382736444,
-0.2642520368,
-0.6425668001,
-0.4753412604,
0.1616156697,
0.3529542983,
0.0128017822,
0.3529854119,
-0.1362370104,
0.5313935876,
0.5463030338,
0.0812812373,
0.3560546637,
0.1132823676,
-0.4762364626,
0.1247182488,
-0.6935018301,
-0.5430741906,
0.868745327,
0.1716686338,
0.9010894299,
0.1895308495,
0.5536525249,
-0.3298047483,
0.460840553,
-0.5675084591,
0.3205834329,
-0.4831492901,
-0.5247755051,
-0.1103874445,
-0.4876754582,
-0.7979575396,
0.529219687,
-0.3180030584,
-0.3656208217,
-0.2235801816,
0.210499227,
-0.3188148439,
0.1754416972,
-1.1073122025,
1.0374896526,
-0.7196285129,
-0.2179490924,
-0.4872050583,
-0.6312744617,
0.4490523934,
-0.458550185,
0.4590945542,
-0.0468142629,
0.1905195862,
0.3980170786,
-0.1600335091,
0.6311730146,
0.0142132984,
-0.423212111,
-0.230338037,
-0.0163699817,
0.3951230347,
0.0021779633,
-0.0558991469,
0.2560960948,
0.1219711974,
-0.3507009745,
-0.5276354551,
0.7551957965,
-0.9113314748,
-0.7972710729,
0.003805652,
-0.6857788563,
-0.1470650882,
0.479090333,
0.4841485023,
0.3904687464,
-0.011706938,
0.0703415647,
0.4392067492,
-0.1670342386,
0.3193669021,
0.6441960931,
-0.5726711154,
-0.167997852,
0.894739747,
0.3981308043,
0.8055557609,
0.4842090905,
0.0823434144,
-0.4403703809,
-0.7562991381,
-0.8586812019,
0.4478089213,
-0.714230299,
0.0083597507,
-0.3589581549,
-0.0584711395,
-0.2584839463,
-0.1743108481,
-0.4510372579,
-0.0132287582,
-0.0347320139,
-0.17538324,
-0.1029598489,
0.8880797625,
0.0298568066,
0.4911251366,
-1.2437916994,
0.3714355528,
0.3155082166,
0.1501639783,
0.0317268372,
-0.7440016866,
-0.5983018279,
0.2621949911,
-0.1124709249,
-0.7430258393,
0.4160552621,
0.2649802566,
0.8205922842,
0.3643263876,
-0.3408458233,
0.7318313718,
-0.8713023067,
0.206846714,
0.1191142127,
-0.8224816918,
0.0423064195,
-0.3555331528,
0.6001218557,
0.3670712411,
0.5915855765,
-0.4460806251,
-0.4766693115,
-0.0875343904,
-0.5560258627,
0.8483267426,
0.0107219433,
0.3915989101,
-0.0165292304,
0.373901099,
0.2715558708,
0.3155832291,
-0.7797845602,
-0.0270697083,
-0.061331369,
-0.0631585345,
-0.5222184062,
-0.0674749017,
-0.1124105528,
-0.1340028644,
0.3340999186,
-0.1229853705,
0.2234650105,
-0.2130105793,
-0.4629816413,
0.2641333342,
0.3972373307,
0.7344224453,
0.6733782887,
0.0520845391,
0.149482429,
0.2912661731,
-0.3177087307,
0.4164889753,
0.3681986034,
0.180408448,
-0.250687778,
0.5937666297,
1.1053832769,
0.2817851305,
-0.2855507433,
0.4098564684,
-0.1046004146,
-0.133720383,
0.1046724916,
0.0656844601,
0.2758798301,
0.261018455,
0.0771237686,
-0.2875204384,
-0.1917541623,
-0.472314477,
-0.0448847152,
0.3425577283,
-0.4037966728,
-0.5281897187,
0.6081166267,
0.0595730841,
0.0262421332,
0.5705496669,
-0.3869121075,
-0.5522424579,
0.3275611401,
0.6862640381,
0.2474865913,
-0.5659759045,
-0.1732400805,
0.3507273197,
0.4300383031,
-0.3259057105,
0.1230381876,
0.1680656672,
-0.6286149621,
-1.0403496027,
-0.6489902735,
-0.0713589191,
0.0398991257,
-0.6610925794,
0.3530382812,
-0.1200047061,
0.0265079942,
0.0619453639,
-0.3318809569,
-0.9037219286,
0.1536556631,
0.3898449838,
0.7368707061,
-0.7649509907,
0.962874949,
0.5447884798,
-0.3489502668,
-1.1985559464,
-0.4216290712,
-0.0164951663,
-0.9846545458,
0.7019432783,
0.416610539,
-0.0073485416,
0.3690485358,
-0.2960474491,
-0.6867519617,
0.6329944134,
0.9639785886,
-0.8967730999,
-0.2357751429,
0.3352143168,
0.3130276799,
-0.3374709189,
0.2926608622,
0.4933269918,
0.4323321879,
-0.1139008477,
-1.3200764656,
-0.0263898801,
-0.1449264586,
-0.2128268182,
0.2185914516,
-0.5280020237,
0.9553437233,
-0.3732848167,
-0.0524552353,
0.0241576564,
0.5487319231,
-0.0108125275,
-0.3938538134,
0.3411354423,
0.3880089223,
0.7471593022,
-0.0071791289,
1.3837653399,
-0.5139852762,
0.2277501822,
1.1488307714,
-0.0197772216,
0.8731589317,
0.2278709859,
0.0933188573,
0.1450758725,
0.3904503286,
0.2011393607,
0.6184524894,
0.0911214352,
-0.228332147,
-0.4699505866,
0.1523701847,
-0.6222283244,
0.559763968,
0.3533454537,
-0.4913654029,
-0.2429309338,
0.491709888,
0.1580254883,
-0.2148031145,
-0.6983941793,
0.7813482881,
0.4141989648,
-0.8726825714,
0.9929387569,
-0.084576413,
0.6291482449,
-0.8518960476,
-0.0911737382,
-0.0732350945,
0.3782496452,
-0.0148411142,
-0.8096486926,
0.1501413584,
-0.1853689998,
-0.1628744751,
-0.3061123192,
0.2030197084,
-0.7781305909,
-0.5571174026,
0.5608577132,
0.6236348748,
0.4752225578,
-0.0727080479,
-0.639347434,
0.0326468199,
0.2010393292,
-0.1212953553,
0.5261209011,
0.6233031154,
-0.1726366431,
0.6206200719,
0.6693663597,
0.3809732795,
0.5393738747,
0.2272911221,
0.6255086064,
-0.3871226609,
-0.4029503465,
-0.949270308,
0.2712771893,
0.3491269648,
-0.1013782322,
0.9225380421,
0.2809625864,
1.2058461905,
-0.3783522844,
0.5381425023,
0.2335182428,
0.1782225072,
-0.9499039054,
0.773750186,
-0.4571530521,
0.0706891865,
-0.0044927672,
-0.9545483589,
-0.2374044657,
0.5849579573,
-0.5692301393,
0.1874140501,
0.7568154335,
0.8467376232,
-0.3972178698,
-0.2768560946,
0.6536519527,
0.2928842902,
0.2915763855,
0.6452637315,
0.5535209179,
-0.1054652408,
0.8841462135,
0.0331240594,
-0.2032744437,
0.1371897906,
-0.691655457,
-1.0962722301,
-0.3246699572,
0.0806560516,
-0.0546101816,
0.0176720433,
0.9538945556,
0.8769881129,
-0.7313449979,
-0.4071975946,
0.1541642547,
-0.0877792463,
-0.3400938213,
-0.0364870802,
0.2791236639,
-0.7717489004,
-0.9338725209,
0.4571848512,
0.0073066601,
0.201047644,
-0.3279980719,
-0.1899465024,
-0.2875447869,
-0.1724428833,
0.6623389125,
0.0150931943,
-0.6364175081,
-0.1050528586,
-0.1113549471,
-0.352692157,
0.0731581897,
0.597276628,
-0.2183007002,
0.4393130541,
0.4789291918,
0.648924768,
0.5062879324,
-0.1832827032,
0.8964409828,
-0.6638314128,
0.2616591752,
-0.4238354862,
0.4375796616,
0.4704596996,
-0.0681298226,
0.2438600808,
-0.2448747456,
-0.5877462029,
-0.3684792519,
-0.0985268876,
-0.6836305857,
-0.0481543168,
1.222384572,
-0.5833772421,
-0.2225724608,
0.0387454629,
-0.5418739915,
0.4378969073,
-0.0619419292,
0.4250160158,
0.8723341823,
0.3258170485,
-0.3808400929,
-0.9353774786,
0.4564412236,
0.4368396401,
-0.6999568939,
0.1164591014,
0.1890435815,
0.1998108625,
0.122777693,
0.442029655,
-0.089375034,
0.3114726543,
-0.3414340019,
0.0482177287,
-0.0821210295,
-0.2115038931,
-0.4177910686,
0.1138691008,
0.4696364999,
-0.0138357021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15080v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15080v2 | Visually-Situated Natural Language Understanding with Contrastive Reading Model and Frozen Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:59:13 | 2023-10-26T12:51:07 | Geewook Kim, Hodong Lee, Daehee Kim, Haeji Jung, Sanghee Park, Yoonsik Kim, Sangdoo Yun, Taeho Kil, Bado Lee, Seunghyun Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have stimulated a surge of
research aimed at extending their applications to the visual domain. While
these models exhibit promise in generating abstract image captions and
facilitating natural conversations, their performance on text-rich images still
requires improvement. In this paper, we introduce Contrastive Reading Model
(Cream), a novel neural architecture designed to enhance the language-image
understanding capability of LLMs by capturing intricate details that are often
overlooked in existing methods. Cream combines vision and auxiliary encoders,
fortified by a contrastive feature alignment technique, to achieve a more
effective comprehension of language information in visually situated contexts
within the images. Our approach bridges the gap between vision and language
understanding, paving the way for the development of more sophisticated
Document Intelligence Assistants. Through rigorous evaluations across diverse
visually-situated language understanding tasks that demand reasoning
capabilities, we demonstrate the compelling performance of Cream, positioning
it as a prominent model in the field of visual document understanding. We
provide our codebase and newly-generated datasets at
https://github.com/naver-ai/cream . | [
-0.2336630821,
-0.9843037128,
0.500749588,
-0.1397872418,
-0.4318181276,
0.080638364,
-0.2658130825,
-0.9250119925,
-0.0018977631,
0.809784174,
-0.4512068331,
-0.706358552,
-0.681016922,
-0.0243818033,
-0.417980969,
0.5820832253,
0.0602487214,
0.0207999684,
-0.5233595371,
-0.3304105699,
-0.4145100415,
-0.0170162097,
-0.6574047208,
-0.3280096054,
0.3923992515,
0.3697540462,
1.002223134,
0.8959246278,
0.7005250454,
0.547955215,
-0.1442324519,
0.3255364299,
-0.359523356,
0.1180012003,
-0.0980205163,
-0.7257471085,
-0.2212021202,
-0.1939163506,
0.3713644445,
0.7786488533,
0.1425644755,
-0.2259357274,
0.1194529235,
0.7035044432,
-0.5223227143,
0.3371782005,
-0.5516293049,
0.011129708,
-0.0173605233,
0.1170491949,
-0.3982630372,
0.0916241705,
0.3393265307,
-0.8523395658,
0.5603853464,
0.188331753,
0.945969522,
0.2827479839,
-0.4918884933,
-0.3882928789,
-0.3423382342,
0.4645281732,
-0.3263431489,
0.458581835,
0.4195880592,
0.429646194,
0.3491622806,
-0.8403670788,
-0.889706552,
-0.1382980645,
-0.3235082924,
0.1886898726,
-0.1689569503,
-0.2845891714,
-0.2914651334,
0.4445431828,
-0.4101121724,
0.17537193,
-0.2826596797,
-0.0381570309,
0.1221516803,
0.1719735712,
0.5642495751,
-0.1135448441,
-0.3441055119,
-0.0476239696,
-0.2062302083,
-0.162770927,
-0.0945077091,
0.2035698444,
-0.5877825022,
0.4194195271,
0.0011527439,
1.0349495411,
-0.1007929146,
0.0924113765,
0.1972972304,
-0.204582721,
-0.4669756889,
-0.2005099803,
0.5535933971,
0.4463622868,
0.2473838776,
-0.2458570451,
-0.2773956358,
0.2436667234,
0.286593169,
-0.6412198544,
-0.4138592184,
0.1739973575,
-0.2878887653,
-0.4740687013,
0.0181464534,
-0.6897494793,
-0.8139832616,
-0.6609332561,
0.017465096,
-0.6710218787,
-0.1868903041,
0.121054709,
-0.0594223253,
0.4112465084,
0.5904237032,
-1.094676137,
0.5367575288,
0.7024900913,
0.8624172211,
-0.2406123132,
-0.1626765877,
-0.6885815263,
0.2366583496,
-0.4164463282,
0.9907082915,
-0.6758217216,
-0.000716141,
0.1936203688,
-0.080840528,
-0.1233040169,
-0.5838773847,
0.3834358156,
-1.0141717196,
0.1921070814,
0.1153525859,
-0.3031336963,
-0.4175382555,
0.7013469338,
-0.7890995741,
0.5112218857,
-0.032970883,
-0.7115429044,
0.033245977,
-0.5708608627,
-0.5529133677,
0.0612880625,
-0.1722313762,
-0.3222866654,
0.1160155982,
0.5507085919,
0.3229153752,
-0.2260878384,
0.036358092,
-0.1661839485,
-0.2034525871,
0.5985193849,
-0.3441156447,
0.5721019506,
0.332067132,
-0.1552565843,
0.2931675613,
-0.5690649748,
-0.3053459227,
0.2737004161,
0.0098125935,
-0.2497040331,
-0.3797465265,
0.3072748482,
-0.0615226179,
0.2406560928,
-0.2383396775,
-0.2531056404,
-0.4052069783,
0.383374691,
0.5013270378,
-0.4340859354,
0.919968605,
-0.0738145038,
0.45315063,
0.3467722535,
-0.0529600792,
-0.5915400982,
-0.1819920689,
-0.8777421713,
-0.3372699618,
0.2040289193,
0.6259881854,
-1.0116113424,
0.1231195778,
-0.2027108967,
-0.1299272925,
-0.5252966285,
0.2539947033,
0.6941920519,
1.0635288954,
0.4107322097,
-0.1157270893,
0.0710180625,
-0.9560059905,
-0.1259743571,
0.3074881732,
-0.0171546973,
0.5103290081,
0.3768264949,
-0.3428812027,
0.5174199343,
-0.5507734418,
-0.4646939337,
-0.3067193031,
0.0045420295,
0.4068864584,
0.4249854088,
0.3543473482,
-1.069893837,
-0.4733426571,
0.4256138504,
-0.8769137263,
-0.0474296585,
0.1431759894,
-0.4081019163,
0.2311932743,
0.7277014852,
-0.6335297823,
0.2956997454,
0.6141956449,
-0.4912829995,
0.211600095,
-0.1968939006,
0.3562043309,
-1.0466920137,
0.0854317024,
0.3711716831,
-0.3007003069,
-0.6655395627,
0.3852746785,
0.2688056231,
-0.2083030194,
-0.4600662291,
0.7266750932,
-0.8597647548,
-0.1712384224,
-0.2189599574,
0.6191292405,
0.4691147506,
0.3434849381,
0.2211022526,
0.5502482057,
0.7084557414,
-0.4211494327,
0.2575110197,
0.5660285354,
-0.3911631703,
0.8592281342,
-0.516561985,
0.22126849,
-0.179880634,
-0.0751320198,
-1.1307457685,
-0.4264353514,
0.4029630423,
-0.347835362,
0.7104750276,
-0.2275725007,
-0.3171994686,
0.1060293391,
0.0108024003,
0.3817151785,
0.3891797066,
-0.7610013485,
1.0680252314,
0.4224953651,
-0.1905576438,
-0.6362944245,
-1.0355541706,
0.2657370567,
-0.1024530455,
-0.9313618541,
0.4830123782,
0.3581117094,
-0.5132526159,
0.1485976875,
-0.0199573841,
-0.1091072261,
-0.2065417916,
0.0753360316,
0.4357233047,
-0.4269339442,
0.2748869658,
-0.31883955,
-0.2748030126,
-0.1873517632,
-0.3120793104,
0.4129734933,
-0.2834282517,
-0.2089108229,
-0.395413518,
0.193005845,
0.4821897447,
-0.5796123743,
0.7003747225,
0.5240719914,
-0.2438171655,
-0.1517146528,
-0.5158563852,
-0.0512577184,
-0.5226335526,
0.3400071263,
-0.4787141085,
-0.7177682519,
0.5837461948,
0.0408445299,
-0.1526177824,
0.265665561,
0.13686198,
-0.4434563518,
0.5105885863,
0.5943130851,
0.1473884284,
0.7132813931,
-0.2195895463,
-0.0701067299,
-0.7476002574,
-0.2853964865,
-0.3818994462,
-0.4378545582,
-0.213507995,
-0.7996872663,
0.1411985457,
-0.0227469653,
-0.0203717332,
-0.1459052414,
-0.3640299439,
0.8572292924,
0.4688059986,
0.5045329332,
0.3946199119,
0.1597800851,
-0.3228292167,
0.0040651276,
-0.4838424027,
-0.4952657521,
0.4482816458,
0.2142686546,
0.7164500952,
0.1835102737,
0.1944267899,
0.0686554313,
0.4570973814,
-0.8053258061,
0.509518683,
-0.4685654044,
-0.1495799422,
-0.1931323856,
-0.2385726422,
-1.0093848705,
0.4867573082,
-0.3665849566,
-0.5944933891,
0.0190639775,
0.2371413261,
0.1331314594,
0.2834975719,
-0.9391257763,
1.1138010025,
-0.3900482357,
-0.8313815594,
-0.1649583876,
-0.754602313,
0.4541660249,
0.3878671527,
0.3263125718,
0.1968907118,
-0.4377414286,
0.1880933791,
-0.3139497042,
1.0532002449,
0.1332813799,
-0.0046556033,
0.0671179593,
0.3526691198,
0.3065871298,
-0.1895306855,
-0.2277590781,
0.095975168,
-0.4745400846,
-0.5753163695,
-0.8548039198,
0.6448480487,
-0.5657764673,
-0.5558379889,
-0.3319625556,
-0.6758118868,
-0.189403832,
0.3553690016,
-0.0137191014,
0.7440419197,
-0.2662024796,
0.093501173,
0.7644225955,
-0.2778913677,
0.3161675036,
0.4701874256,
-0.2567087114,
-0.5053964853,
0.6121510863,
-0.4156828523,
0.2549433708,
0.7665402889,
0.0980660319,
-0.5914865136,
-0.8829261065,
-0.4121370316,
0.356328696,
-1.0907454491,
-0.0451575816,
-0.7029615045,
0.0251374431,
-0.2716600299,
-0.4586597085,
-0.0196277257,
0.0210953671,
-0.4884257317,
-0.0371608697,
0.3712416589,
0.7899079919,
0.2994089425,
0.3620353937,
-0.7575857639,
0.7590351701,
0.2225579172,
0.5640488267,
-0.1342364252,
-0.6462533474,
-0.1323263943,
-0.2308713496,
-0.0924000069,
-0.7909144759,
0.669110775,
0.0612099245,
0.4555377662,
0.5042853355,
-0.148538664,
0.5961304903,
-0.3054271042,
0.348218292,
0.22730425,
-0.7525226474,
0.3794948757,
-0.4745877683,
0.8478718996,
0.559138,
0.0988582596,
-0.5136615634,
-0.299385637,
-0.2835715413,
-0.6856572032,
0.5747651458,
0.079797104,
0.2013400346,
0.0449414141,
0.1917054951,
0.0336447358,
0.0186255034,
-0.6751032472,
0.2100249082,
-0.1153991669,
-0.5414393544,
-0.2762003541,
-0.0821318924,
-0.1458464712,
-0.0780608505,
0.3478323519,
-0.3914686441,
-0.0235306211,
0.1327163726,
-0.4642880261,
0.1596451104,
0.0717631578,
0.4158874154,
0.4980209172,
0.080123432,
0.5634993315,
-0.0390049219,
-0.5644712448,
-0.3933615983,
0.2504236698,
-0.0205737669,
-0.4015828371,
0.6792731881,
0.7271945477,
0.4265556335,
-0.591432929,
0.2679323554,
-0.2617419958,
-0.0355377942,
-0.0678050816,
0.0968583822,
0.506511271,
0.275711894,
-0.0870411918,
0.3590216935,
0.1311450154,
-0.5744911432,
0.2060434371,
0.4153798223,
-0.6293833256,
0.0307394005,
0.5113577247,
0.4847326875,
-0.4148160517,
0.9679666758,
0.1842836142,
-0.3944780827,
0.8230914474,
0.611566782,
0.595559895,
0.1422791183,
0.1825839132,
0.0634074435,
0.2309725881,
0.2943069339,
0.0922397897,
-0.1878331453,
-1.0665854216,
-0.0000562212,
-0.5217396021,
-0.3315936327,
-0.1372610629,
-0.2928674221,
0.1470474005,
-0.3210316896,
0.2536771595,
0.1415762752,
-0.2129040807,
-0.786911428,
0.3735137284,
0.1575981081,
0.9846335649,
-0.5878739953,
0.5907364488,
0.5113849044,
-0.3610580564,
-0.3214686811,
0.0698866174,
0.1172584966,
-0.9661989808,
0.4880822599,
0.6190109849,
-0.4244461358,
-0.1619519591,
-0.5664402843,
-0.5147491693,
1.0791064501,
0.5331640244,
-0.5855544806,
0.4520581067,
0.0172545612,
0.7220272422,
-0.5570781827,
0.3133232892,
0.5216260552,
0.3249482512,
0.548138082,
-0.2745854855,
0.0186303258,
-0.6486065984,
-0.1845450848,
0.0348508954,
-0.4162268639,
0.5746895075,
-0.4962599576,
-0.2527759373,
0.1550801992,
0.7035912275,
0.2357817441,
0.5286356807,
0.5267412663,
0.6065014005,
0.7923266292,
-0.1135110483,
1.5046788454,
-0.1935655922,
-0.3579326272,
1.3631463051,
-0.1937256902,
0.8921766281,
0.3960387707,
0.176865235,
0.4548940659,
0.5664255619,
0.1790360957,
0.4115563929,
0.0572001487,
-0.406296134,
-0.2503926456,
-0.2414256334,
-0.0234760921,
0.4911710322,
0.478739202,
-0.545353055,
0.0250031203,
-0.2819868028,
-0.3857068121,
0.6482702494,
-0.3370778859,
0.9584254026,
0.1485861838,
-0.6012222171,
0.439410001,
-0.1358814687,
0.5763273835,
-0.4393984079,
-0.2245824337,
-0.2586551905,
0.2792658806,
-0.1150581166,
-1.141876936,
0.325353533,
-0.0221815687,
-0.0629768819,
-0.1658242643,
0.8427273631,
-0.4226745665,
-0.6755359769,
0.3415535688,
0.4496156573,
-0.056363523,
0.1034575403,
-0.7984910607,
0.2582917511,
-0.3512630761,
-0.0917023644,
0.1910013855,
0.684468627,
0.1084026769,
0.6527418494,
0.6277238727,
-0.275549978,
-0.3372421265,
0.4216755033,
0.8396881223,
-0.6690541506,
-0.7986312509,
-0.8183779716,
0.6149126887,
-0.3608622551,
-0.2063650042,
0.333201766,
0.4350551963,
0.3629442453,
-0.2268284857,
0.3850672841,
0.3473389149,
0.0116654765,
-0.8425084352,
0.8114489913,
-0.4954360723,
0.2849622369,
-0.1517864615,
-0.6591935158,
-0.7172667384,
0.5867519379,
-0.5998327136,
0.0060278266,
0.6270475984,
0.9311314225,
-0.4427362382,
0.0406670049,
0.4469318986,
0.3834032416,
0.0879990309,
0.251802057,
0.7993381619,
-0.2009253949,
0.5228723288,
-0.0429587625,
-0.294505924,
-0.0086234733,
-0.987349987,
-1.0248377323,
-0.4741787314,
-0.207474649,
-0.2860139012,
0.0907572284,
0.42384848,
0.7090399861,
-0.6816260219,
-0.0739353225,
-0.3567612469,
0.3379125595,
-0.0347385667,
-0.2222284675,
0.4310456216,
-0.3705975413,
-0.8479132652,
0.1645840406,
0.6054890752,
0.2271692902,
-0.0090950103,
-0.016992595,
-0.2244039774,
-0.0338236429,
0.5000053048,
0.1273592412,
-0.716368854,
0.1502728611,
0.059615247,
-0.3144081831,
0.3227472901,
0.5668916106,
-0.7342233062,
0.6241160631,
0.5411962271,
0.9036468267,
0.7180053592,
0.0461416952,
0.578350544,
-0.455521822,
0.2521913648,
0.0819327831,
0.5973807573,
0.7669169903,
-0.5668690801,
0.5060686469,
0.0344038457,
-0.0803922638,
-0.2519858181,
0.3828506172,
-1.151932478,
-0.5531705022,
0.8363798857,
0.031059565,
-0.7170211077,
-0.1395326108,
-0.5127618909,
0.1652857363,
-0.2359478176,
0.7893871665,
0.3930305243,
-0.0235125385,
-0.8370108008,
-0.3374056518,
0.2195752412,
0.2818316519,
-1.1253026724,
0.0829632059,
0.747420609,
0.1068990827,
0.1552594751,
0.5478520393,
-0.2561233342,
0.2321522683,
0.2484596521,
-0.2469346076,
-0.2514583766,
-0.3146998882,
-0.450003475,
0.3213014007,
-0.1831970215,
-0.2035248727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15077v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15077v2 | Contrastive Learning of Sentence Embeddings from Scratch | 2023-05-24T11:56:21 | 2023-10-24T09:56:46 | Junlei Zhang, Zhenzhong Lan, Junxian He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Contrastive learning has been the dominant approach to train state-of-the-art
sentence embeddings. Previous studies have typically learned sentence
embeddings either through the use of human-annotated natural language inference
(NLI) data or via large-scale unlabeled sentences in an unsupervised manner.
However, even in the case of unlabeled data, their acquisition presents
challenges in certain domains due to various reasons. To address these issues,
we present SynCSE, a contrastive learning framework that trains sentence
embeddings with synthesized data. Specifically, we explore utilizing large
language models to synthesize the required data samples for contrastive
learning, including (1) producing positive and negative annotations given
unlabeled sentences (SynCSE-partial), and (2) generating sentences along with
their corresponding annotations from scratch (SynCSE-scratch). Experimental
results on sentence similarity and reranking tasks indicate that both
SynCSE-partial and SynCSE-scratch greatly outperform unsupervised baselines,
and SynCSE-partial even achieves comparable performance to the supervised
models in most settings. | [
-0.2217845619,
-0.7673722506,
0.5086861849,
0.2113382369,
-0.4454928935,
0.0312296171,
-0.1555271596,
-0.4248313606,
0.5974345803,
0.3040824234,
-0.8133782744,
-0.4134964347,
-0.2570467889,
0.2794807255,
-0.4820843041,
1.0499193668,
-0.0991782174,
0.1548262686,
-0.431897372,
-0.1683925092,
-0.3608171344,
-0.2886960506,
-0.162949577,
-0.4034169018,
0.2510811687,
0.3232616186,
0.4667330086,
0.6039033532,
0.1285941005,
0.2901381552,
0.0058095972,
0.1788057089,
-0.4731161892,
0.4931323528,
-0.3266245425,
-0.2827079594,
0.2375975996,
0.2539581358,
0.2446411252,
1.0044147968,
-0.0758426413,
-0.1712747663,
0.1267508119,
0.6061169505,
-0.8159406185,
0.0004126659,
-0.6314758658,
0.2581750453,
-0.0220158976,
0.2485738993,
-0.554638505,
-0.1972221583,
0.2835335135,
-0.8840293288,
0.2815652192,
0.1304550022,
0.8703644276,
0.1089762226,
-0.2582372129,
-0.3710756302,
-0.1338670999,
0.8488599062,
-0.3962805271,
0.4732218087,
0.2079259753,
-0.1374835819,
-0.0442554727,
-0.8948418498,
-0.3762114346,
-0.1950535774,
-0.1995921582,
0.3390719295,
0.1460296512,
-0.3017405272,
0.1578203589,
0.402710259,
-0.3058660328,
0.2192460895,
0.0596431829,
-0.1279954016,
0.3871165812,
0.1233878285,
0.301412493,
-0.3933648467,
-0.6980389953,
-0.1906933486,
-0.5445926189,
-0.4055446386,
0.0472606085,
0.3629311919,
-0.1185586452,
0.4159030616,
-0.1711072773,
0.3914110959,
0.1424669325,
0.4749428332,
0.5604731441,
-0.4884502888,
-0.3112166524,
-0.0437554643,
0.7279490232,
0.363992393,
0.1340799034,
-0.4991598725,
-0.4364758432,
0.2599142492,
0.2313268036,
-0.836014092,
-0.6180563569,
0.18000938,
-0.204420805,
-0.4215107858,
0.1493140906,
-0.9862609506,
-0.5870617628,
-0.3958668709,
0.4753623903,
-0.4294567406,
0.350589186,
-0.0687520355,
-0.2303286046,
0.0623694882,
0.3147490621,
-0.7427328229,
0.3973945081,
0.5270094275,
0.7641456127,
-0.1501284689,
-0.4126031995,
-0.7950552702,
-0.2085982561,
-0.4342910945,
0.5639670491,
-0.4333144128,
-0.2369920611,
0.3088879883,
-0.1238248721,
-0.1594763398,
-0.6615226865,
0.57372576,
-0.3103400767,
0.4419569671,
-0.1892451495,
-1.0001989603,
0.2527983189,
0.0215179697,
-0.6646377444,
0.8233450651,
0.1216928586,
-1.1791408062,
0.3553678989,
-0.2562136948,
-0.7349531651,
-0.2128216922,
-0.0196972303,
-0.7051973343,
0.2296399325,
0.3743236065,
0.5755935311,
-0.0935610309,
0.2054488957,
-0.2976467609,
-0.4143400788,
0.2457080781,
0.0251684375,
0.7202095985,
0.3752902746,
-0.1816078573,
-0.0771785975,
-0.7045952678,
-0.2284508348,
0.2557070851,
-0.1082239971,
-0.646140039,
-0.0163944345,
0.2734521031,
0.1303600222,
0.0319200307,
-0.9679635167,
-0.0562681779,
-0.4498747289,
0.5552712083,
0.6124957204,
0.2356596589,
0.4351830781,
-0.3940424323,
0.1124205813,
0.3477129638,
-0.3667750061,
-0.7811912298,
-0.0862832814,
-0.8818414211,
-0.2851184309,
0.4217398465,
0.5686739087,
-0.9009917378,
0.6299927831,
-0.1022202894,
-0.0661916807,
-0.9571934342,
0.2972262204,
0.536719501,
0.4944131076,
0.5674448013,
-0.1338334233,
-0.8318105936,
-0.9442743659,
-0.2069920897,
0.4018487334,
-0.0587723441,
0.0687607899,
0.7372407913,
-0.1312893033,
0.7105920911,
-0.6840969324,
-0.2339438796,
-0.1625854075,
0.254986763,
-0.1289760619,
0.6490322351,
0.0693369284,
-0.7389591336,
-0.393527329,
-0.2528777421,
-0.8110535145,
-0.1860193014,
-0.4915768802,
-0.1138875037,
0.0026242626,
1.0148053169,
-0.4996065199,
0.1073245555,
0.4465737045,
-0.152468726,
0.2963193953,
-0.2518370748,
0.0267850868,
-1.6888171434,
0.1318657398,
0.1845640689,
-0.5476467609,
-0.5072185397,
0.1514409781,
0.1422335058,
-0.0830835402,
-0.311157763,
0.3690629005,
-0.5959047079,
0.0596462078,
-0.0880521163,
0.6225719452,
0.0639853403,
0.2660817206,
0.1403981298,
0.6884016395,
0.2673107386,
-0.1532085687,
0.012772806,
0.5797907114,
-0.636210382,
0.4750810266,
-0.6702631712,
0.1213983223,
-0.1562717408,
0.2614689469,
-1.001204133,
-0.279047519,
-0.0613763556,
-0.1498212665,
0.1524015814,
0.2160910517,
-0.3321870267,
-0.0501041934,
-0.5528047681,
0.0887637064,
0.6027723551,
-0.8669574261,
0.1645080298,
0.2917488515,
-0.0412172265,
-0.4763308465,
-0.8616390824,
-0.052889172,
-0.0393366702,
-0.217403993,
0.4956637919,
0.0342993177,
-0.2350610793,
-0.0044494993,
0.0214173775,
0.0614920817,
0.3168301284,
0.5081665516,
0.144929871,
-0.068058461,
0.1447501332,
0.0675737783,
-0.0719425902,
0.0030468181,
-0.024659371,
0.420868516,
0.3301979005,
-0.1689230502,
-0.4026320279,
0.3235829175,
0.2169613242,
-0.2016412318,
0.8137382269,
0.2460452765,
-0.2574309111,
-0.6464170814,
-0.3744306564,
-0.2591038346,
-0.3894679248,
0.2792631984,
-0.2441417128,
-0.9209741354,
0.380482465,
-0.3203149736,
0.1488177925,
0.0981207117,
0.1166841239,
-0.2699266076,
0.4992909729,
0.3481272459,
-0.1552852392,
0.697363615,
0.0066253417,
-0.1039557159,
-0.8517734408,
-0.0537241697,
-0.4731098413,
-0.3185389638,
-0.5907648802,
-0.4062692821,
-0.2374434173,
0.242144376,
-0.3180853128,
0.3353267312,
-0.0003208147,
0.8158270121,
0.5911978483,
0.4476478994,
-0.0095535712,
-0.0015295509,
-0.4685899913,
-0.1605960578,
-0.3024436235,
-0.1856907457,
0.9168046117,
-0.1002312154,
0.5481176376,
-0.2970035076,
1.2279258966,
0.279502809,
-0.0017029516,
-0.3807947934,
0.4213761687,
-0.4758365154,
-0.0569804497,
0.2090913951,
-0.5509221554,
-0.9389557242,
0.5357924104,
-0.5727243423,
-0.5793389678,
0.0588049367,
0.0394076109,
-0.1227493137,
0.1522082835,
-0.8920946717,
0.8996094465,
0.3097098768,
-0.5764706731,
-0.0631147996,
-1.0093868971,
0.2914893329,
-0.162900731,
0.0352803729,
0.2893227339,
0.1533532292,
0.5427873731,
-0.1657028198,
0.9670547247,
0.0207464024,
0.1854486167,
-0.0064140828,
0.3905448616,
0.4739023149,
-0.0251966529,
-0.1817908287,
-0.3653155267,
-0.4731741846,
-0.4568796158,
-0.5305430293,
0.9750837088,
-0.6650467515,
-0.323356986,
-0.2921296358,
-0.463416934,
-0.3241432309,
0.0757606998,
0.1323740333,
0.2986488938,
-0.6363370419,
0.1238241941,
0.5203403234,
-0.2807593048,
0.5474200249,
0.2100474387,
-0.1322971135,
-0.7772862315,
0.694118619,
-0.4154797792,
0.3804166913,
0.6035413742,
-0.065115571,
-0.1568560004,
-0.2881710827,
-0.0450525172,
0.2889238894,
-0.7087342739,
-0.0063567357,
-0.498298943,
-0.1070261374,
-0.0928278342,
-0.5772750974,
-0.386015147,
-0.4645704627,
-0.396243453,
-0.3809343576,
-0.0664877519,
0.7020404339,
0.0480158888,
0.01757502,
-0.662808001,
0.407899946,
-0.0159115233,
0.003066818,
-0.2073084265,
-0.3442006111,
-0.2282589525,
0.0883976966,
-0.245043233,
-0.6525568962,
0.344324708,
0.1709546298,
0.3765639365,
0.1950714588,
0.301636517,
0.621479094,
-0.6073126793,
0.8194083571,
0.2338467985,
-1.0443499088,
0.6252611279,
0.0153737217,
0.3673368394,
0.8576902747,
0.3376896083,
-0.5530264974,
-0.4570558369,
-0.6734220386,
-0.9683076143,
0.6477971673,
0.2760830522,
0.3335175514,
-0.338671416,
0.3924058974,
0.3141423762,
0.263577193,
-0.6698135734,
-0.0030462709,
-0.1708625406,
-0.4773184359,
-0.3924845159,
-0.0367564932,
0.1009384096,
0.0934097916,
0.5135849118,
0.0944897309,
0.0238133259,
0.2956779003,
-0.5639852881,
0.0554204397,
0.3247743845,
0.3333783448,
0.1575203538,
-0.2373317182,
0.3909532726,
-0.0151600344,
-0.1586802006,
0.0030409645,
0.1710326225,
-0.3462745547,
-0.0839999169,
0.5289111733,
0.8518077135,
0.3549470007,
-0.7845856547,
0.7126187086,
0.2780643404,
-0.0808546767,
0.1091295704,
-0.2271527946,
0.2544122934,
0.2443449795,
-0.2748574615,
0.0954058766,
-0.046502918,
-0.5564448833,
0.654086709,
0.2106411904,
-0.3834087551,
-0.4134162664,
0.6782594323,
0.4157660007,
-0.0253266972,
1.0328626633,
-0.0722466558,
-0.5030221939,
0.2797449231,
0.7859615088,
0.9008893967,
-0.2092346996,
0.4658921063,
0.3856759965,
0.0446574129,
-0.2170111984,
0.1376646608,
-0.1373285651,
-0.8303770423,
-0.2520472109,
-0.4582301378,
-0.3253623247,
-0.0604583584,
-0.8989047408,
0.0228164122,
-0.4153654575,
0.30068928,
0.1720967591,
-0.1151789874,
-0.4301992655,
0.2135024816,
0.1519832462,
0.6709840894,
-1.345502615,
0.7163931727,
0.71893996,
-0.6791360378,
-0.1738509387,
0.233885631,
-0.1014729664,
-0.630413413,
0.6708991528,
0.4457937777,
0.2031623572,
0.0046201842,
-0.5091795325,
-0.2006017715,
0.8705894351,
0.4534390271,
-0.5308816433,
0.1599419862,
-0.16099374,
0.5424015522,
-0.5676701665,
0.1134365425,
0.3250697553,
-0.1171922833,
0.0117060011,
-0.467500329,
0.1867761016,
-0.2657004893,
-0.0730551928,
0.3354843259,
-0.4347278774,
0.9821892977,
-0.2586163282,
-0.1901350617,
0.261962086,
0.633362174,
0.1421248615,
0.0905910954,
0.3576811254,
0.991409421,
0.7087978125,
-0.0485090353,
1.0665491819,
-0.0707882121,
0.3543157876,
1.4999042749,
-0.7012521625,
1.2673133612,
0.6269381642,
0.1512103677,
0.7080827355,
0.459043473,
-0.1217152923,
0.7207050323,
0.3203938901,
-0.1254588366,
-0.5051910281,
-0.1698235422,
0.1501833051,
0.1028269678,
0.0494354442,
-0.59182024,
-0.4105189443,
0.2636743188,
0.1449182034,
0.628467977,
0.0693949759,
0.883461535,
0.1401345134,
-0.574919939,
0.3190390468,
-0.2611391544,
0.4365597963,
-0.4173812568,
-0.2559393942,
-0.5566518903,
0.4440315962,
-0.023455346,
-0.7455689311,
0.0217425879,
-0.100311026,
-0.1218813956,
-0.3323717117,
0.2871649861,
-0.604991734,
-0.195156157,
0.3267238736,
0.4405562878,
-0.1395705491,
0.2551375926,
-0.551476419,
-0.0597067811,
0.1364312172,
-0.1468662024,
0.6584425569,
0.3159824908,
0.2041624188,
0.5876100063,
0.4396651387,
-0.0741601139,
-0.1515045762,
0.0760090128,
0.9355034828,
-0.6987016797,
-0.6289368868,
-0.6908981204,
0.6076197028,
-0.3023576438,
-0.2792633474,
0.8331755996,
0.775256753,
0.9432337284,
-0.1482459307,
0.6204776168,
0.1848432869,
0.6957606673,
-0.89167732,
0.319714874,
-0.5593902469,
0.2620984018,
-0.3612744808,
-0.8439541459,
-0.3431573212,
0.8249827623,
0.0172581952,
-0.0339853168,
1.031017065,
0.611787796,
-0.2835481763,
0.3615350723,
0.1337450743,
0.2957642376,
0.0536420085,
0.5867430568,
0.7660108209,
-0.5719611645,
-0.030488627,
-0.4250491261,
0.21254237,
0.013443293,
-0.8626797795,
-0.90843606,
-0.6110426784,
-0.5384916067,
-0.2579145432,
0.2963066399,
1.2466881275,
0.4702502191,
-1.022793293,
-0.1333671957,
-0.4779476821,
-0.1241067499,
-0.1056048498,
-0.1492254734,
0.5653728843,
-0.6778575182,
-0.6775979996,
0.6454532146,
-0.0817083195,
0.114002794,
0.2478023469,
0.2663820982,
-0.4762739837,
0.1063454673,
0.3419709802,
-0.0005199295,
-0.5085663199,
-0.2286573946,
-0.2995350957,
-0.2569649816,
0.0174977574,
0.9302206039,
-0.8651383519,
0.5308066607,
0.4745824039,
0.8689327836,
0.4878984094,
0.3917033672,
0.4960718155,
-1.0905036926,
0.2463589162,
-0.0146791497,
0.5994006395,
0.4713279009,
0.0512733273,
0.4420319498,
0.3111468256,
-0.3927984834,
-0.6628075838,
0.1811675429,
-0.8983374238,
-0.6584269404,
0.9615387917,
-0.4506100714,
-0.0664435774,
0.0938472226,
-0.1302783638,
0.1868840009,
-0.2549116313,
0.6075043678,
0.5186290741,
0.2143770903,
-0.1055326834,
-0.2162575573,
0.3977796435,
0.5940625072,
-0.9106066823,
0.3322773278,
0.862146318,
0.2846226692,
0.1718570739,
0.0512448512,
0.1448323131,
0.1434794515,
0.3905823529,
0.0791979209,
-0.1350109875,
-0.1613190621,
-0.450098455,
0.313452065,
-0.2346842289,
-0.3373565078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15076v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15076v2 | Meta-Learning Online Adaptation of Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:56:20 | 2023-10-20T22:49:24 | Nathan Hu, Eric Mitchell, Christopher D. Manning, Chelsea Finn | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models encode impressively broad world knowledge in their
parameters. However, the knowledge in static language models falls out of date,
limiting the model's effective "shelf life." While online fine-tuning can
reduce this degradation, we find that naively fine-tuning on a stream of
documents leads to a low level of information uptake. We hypothesize that
online fine-tuning does not sufficiently attend to important information. That
is, the gradient signal from important tokens representing factual information
is drowned out by the gradient from inherently noisy tokens, suggesting that a
dynamic, context-aware learning rate may be beneficial. We therefore propose
learning which tokens to upweight. We meta-train a small, autoregressive model
to reweight the language modeling loss for each token during online
fine-tuning, with the objective of maximizing the out-of-date base
question-answering model's ability to answer questions about a document after a
single weighted gradient step. We call this approach Context-aware Meta-learned
Loss Scaling (CaMeLS). Across three different distributions of documents, our
experiments find that CaMeLS provides substantially improved information uptake
on streams of thousands of documents compared with standard fine-tuning and
baseline heuristics for reweighting token losses. | [
-0.4653899968,
-0.6286569834,
0.3420436978,
0.0330401137,
-0.3037261963,
-0.0717357025,
-0.3238523304,
-0.4764256179,
0.1306169927,
0.2349338084,
-0.5323888659,
-0.1865940243,
-0.5331882834,
0.0177927054,
-0.2272046208,
1.3303024769,
0.0741576478,
-0.0017920079,
-0.2027109563,
-0.4156949818,
-0.5966527462,
-0.110150516,
-0.7683323622,
-0.2123703212,
0.6675775647,
0.3383496106,
0.5138404369,
0.8674547076,
0.3393786848,
0.2108823061,
-0.1404152513,
0.1532336771,
-0.5783323646,
0.0045366543,
-0.3211841881,
-0.514210701,
-0.3010655046,
-0.0907491967,
0.6033633947,
0.78879565,
-0.4129375219,
0.4627993107,
0.1129108742,
0.6431491375,
-0.9512225389,
0.200543195,
-0.8710565567,
-0.1192170605,
-0.0283586644,
-0.4553852975,
-0.3631206155,
-0.1619186997,
0.2385780513,
-0.9371236563,
0.2336944789,
0.0556161366,
0.6653150916,
0.4706408083,
-0.431261152,
-0.4007052183,
-0.6960368752,
0.6100569963,
-0.4741940498,
0.3354842961,
0.5940365791,
0.3951325417,
0.001906421,
-0.7017139196,
-0.3754616678,
0.121880427,
-0.1132190451,
-0.012692404,
-0.1402570605,
0.0203579701,
0.051828295,
0.2882507741,
-0.1827788204,
-0.1723318398,
-0.3104926944,
-0.2014364451,
0.2280538231,
0.0649203062,
0.2504486442,
-0.0131971231,
-0.2190346569,
-0.0298174564,
-0.6214509606,
0.1051607206,
0.2324781418,
0.3555475175,
0.0918123201,
0.079302758,
-0.1460836381,
0.8614759445,
0.335452199,
-0.0852103755,
0.1767059714,
-0.4133190513,
-0.1681912094,
-0.0371614918,
0.3061309755,
0.3101585805,
0.1645495594,
-0.1408566982,
-0.065487355,
-0.4872198105,
0.2267649323,
-0.8746786714,
0.0073664309,
-0.0218915492,
-0.536283195,
-0.2164312005,
0.0349334665,
-0.4898069203,
-0.2798236907,
-0.3754316866,
0.7457644343,
-0.2320801467,
-0.1263489723,
0.2633063495,
-0.2840842009,
0.1429961026,
0.5117853284,
-1.0588748455,
0.3210152984,
0.4415819645,
0.8724808097,
0.135814026,
-0.2306139618,
-0.8986846209,
0.2635448575,
-0.1783692986,
0.6805253625,
-0.4912764132,
-0.1550676078,
-0.0276510417,
0.1835242212,
-0.2016010433,
-0.4775422513,
0.6403971314,
-0.6761683822,
0.3341045678,
-0.533403635,
-0.4215790629,
-0.1478576064,
0.254851371,
-0.5873647928,
1.010371685,
0.0810191333,
-1.0714714527,
0.5722662807,
-0.5120096803,
-0.4853212535,
-0.2006633133,
0.2121822387,
-0.2871574759,
0.2450630814,
0.2598482966,
0.472237587,
-0.2080729753,
0.1550009698,
-0.2752316594,
-0.5762409568,
-0.0713367984,
-0.2926313877,
0.7182685137,
0.2595578134,
-0.3495151997,
-0.1932673007,
-0.8695222139,
-0.1505161822,
-0.0507101826,
-0.8915220499,
-0.5468371511,
0.3113114536,
-0.0590124205,
0.1762505472,
0.0658895522,
-0.5880334377,
0.2419732064,
-0.455023706,
0.6221324801,
0.6556742787,
-0.0782948062,
0.4104314446,
-0.5424264669,
0.1938376874,
-0.1586702764,
0.0859458148,
-0.2888500094,
-0.3718976676,
-0.9469194412,
-0.2385404259,
0.4805570245,
0.3921180665,
-0.4808295071,
0.3746501803,
-0.4408941269,
-0.372446537,
-0.6654660106,
0.2455511093,
0.1429033577,
0.6019525528,
0.684515059,
-0.2191231847,
-0.3687769771,
-0.5650499463,
-0.6300680637,
-0.0910416022,
-0.242974937,
0.4135553539,
0.3445445299,
-0.3893590868,
0.9255172014,
-0.3799962997,
-0.4686714709,
-0.025259627,
0.502504766,
-0.2170716375,
0.2388145775,
0.4167967141,
-0.6651319265,
-0.5275803208,
-0.1096075252,
-0.2132874131,
-0.2047086358,
-0.1381112486,
0.1740309745,
0.0844300166,
0.6055635214,
-0.4666220546,
0.180966571,
0.5437249541,
-0.2460058182,
0.0068730158,
-0.5594539642,
-0.0448420458,
-1.0844322443,
0.2589844763,
-0.2944134474,
-0.5342988372,
-0.4958890378,
-0.1003033668,
0.2139791697,
-0.1337781698,
-0.4282338321,
0.8031830192,
-0.4889517426,
-0.2576366961,
-0.3639110327,
0.2568825185,
0.1229163706,
0.4995937943,
-0.0133395735,
0.5469990969,
0.3483318388,
-0.8621948957,
-0.0120909819,
0.0677195713,
-0.4237605631,
0.3580182493,
-0.4114681482,
-0.0793014616,
-0.3628708124,
0.5589778423,
-0.8855054379,
-0.0525329821,
0.2555187345,
-0.3391954899,
0.5264407992,
-0.0495095514,
-0.2377324104,
-0.0956666172,
-0.3706593215,
0.3863866925,
0.2311113477,
-0.5657321811,
0.8327522874,
0.1664919257,
0.0088320505,
-0.76126647,
-0.753739655,
-0.0549106635,
-0.0096721062,
-0.2750945985,
0.4961746037,
-0.0941925794,
0.0951002315,
0.1768697947,
-0.1263495088,
0.1105666757,
0.3369296491,
-0.0725683123,
-0.3731554449,
-0.1121141985,
0.541577518,
-0.0143786501,
-0.2281224132,
0.0043665441,
-0.6902747154,
0.3643442392,
-0.1692142934,
-0.241779685,
-0.3577247262,
0.0598271079,
0.7108212709,
-0.2107270211,
1.151301384,
0.8525378108,
-0.3592846096,
-0.1599633694,
-0.4694438875,
-0.106577158,
-0.4394135177,
0.3105966747,
-0.2440050542,
-0.5839313865,
0.5653204322,
-0.1400285959,
0.1049593911,
0.7327293754,
0.5290825963,
-0.3558516204,
0.9324014783,
0.9652445912,
-0.0784616917,
0.8143857121,
-0.1238479465,
-0.0644885153,
-0.7837826014,
-0.1754575074,
-0.5697731376,
-0.3856694698,
-0.6191275716,
-0.4607023895,
0.2230701596,
0.1224482581,
-0.3136816025,
0.1785332412,
-0.2612733543,
0.5025032163,
0.5712378025,
0.2642740905,
0.3864801228,
-0.0167008284,
-0.1512684226,
0.2419117242,
-0.9263914824,
-0.0516469106,
1.1676864624,
0.3785457909,
0.826782465,
0.1012306958,
0.1582896113,
0.3607276976,
0.4498645663,
-0.4925087094,
0.1587290764,
-0.0299437419,
-0.8672822118,
-0.5006136298,
-0.5434369445,
-0.8149536848,
0.1428873688,
-0.2641752064,
-0.3224997818,
0.2688081563,
0.4195652008,
-0.3277022839,
0.4406130612,
-0.4914485216,
0.8494442105,
-0.2479997873,
-0.2797620296,
-0.4587804675,
-0.9281970859,
0.0002093963,
-0.3612721264,
0.4821919799,
-0.0036459812,
-0.2536518574,
0.6885432005,
-0.3788461685,
1.0550855398,
-0.2039192468,
0.019967176,
0.3176537454,
0.1036959663,
0.6348327994,
-0.0897501484,
-0.0439999141,
0.051059965,
0.0529486611,
-0.5430019498,
-0.6326669455,
0.4347962141,
-0.8938323259,
-0.5169097185,
-0.2710033953,
-0.2506102622,
-0.0926374197,
0.1611539125,
0.3820606172,
0.5609040856,
-0.1328281462,
0.4635980129,
0.7014845014,
-0.3157206178,
0.463383615,
0.8002638817,
0.0173923913,
-0.4327121973,
1.0397502184,
0.1918546855,
0.4823583364,
0.7090821862,
0.5775749087,
-0.2295044214,
-0.3003476858,
-0.6863318682,
0.1659661233,
-1.0422383547,
-0.1909494549,
-0.78377527,
0.0445265546,
-0.1782577485,
-0.1564628482,
-0.1557558179,
-0.4540869594,
-0.5612035394,
-0.0463357121,
0.2117496133,
0.5438416004,
-0.1669145525,
0.3500979245,
-0.8283284903,
-0.0106842797,
0.5511634946,
0.3669398725,
0.0623482838,
-0.9646146297,
-0.5171756148,
0.1221947074,
-0.2161217183,
-0.667873621,
-0.0164992418,
0.8492543101,
0.6088177562,
0.5789045691,
-0.0146962935,
0.6013646722,
-0.5304729939,
0.490246743,
-0.0199951846,
-0.9825508595,
0.3982664049,
-0.5716600418,
0.4766753912,
0.8331879377,
0.5505585074,
-0.8227629066,
-0.1421579421,
-0.4747499228,
-0.5532529354,
0.6530691385,
-0.1250640452,
0.4358395338,
-0.0156338513,
0.6189867854,
0.059427686,
0.3700003028,
-0.8887658119,
-0.1153023019,
-0.4001993835,
-0.2608393133,
-0.1779672801,
-0.1620299518,
0.0725554004,
-0.4415438175,
0.5935512781,
-0.4800632298,
0.1119415984,
0.0134096602,
-0.3836172223,
-0.39900738,
0.1148095131,
0.7370622754,
0.6157509089,
-0.3982880414,
0.0785049349,
0.5610150099,
-0.367841363,
0.1313590258,
-0.1555839032,
-0.197397545,
-0.2445676774,
0.4946333468,
0.883431673,
0.5865771174,
-0.5420333147,
0.6684974432,
-0.2692108154,
-0.1364580244,
0.0803750306,
0.0971538126,
0.1666330248,
-0.1244177148,
0.3971375823,
0.2934283614,
-0.0487005487,
-0.8895943165,
0.1684525609,
0.4312291443,
-0.5026844144,
-0.3125437796,
0.6074149609,
0.5107532144,
-0.2058206797,
0.3247368038,
-0.0655879527,
-0.522323966,
0.3913995922,
0.5621799827,
0.6977784038,
-0.1923843175,
0.1397084147,
0.408944279,
0.265604347,
-0.2847713828,
-0.1303907484,
-0.4135149121,
-0.5354855657,
-0.3007213771,
-0.813419342,
-0.2904545367,
-0.0471683554,
-0.5118502975,
0.4709429145,
-0.3338771164,
-0.1801445633,
-0.2788439691,
0.0681835711,
-0.6933686733,
0.3864466548,
-0.0491486937,
1.0378066301,
-0.9261775613,
0.6448361874,
0.5318316817,
-0.452844888,
-0.3507439196,
0.3193953633,
-0.2635562122,
-0.751493454,
0.6746778488,
0.2207745463,
-0.2649618685,
0.3453764021,
-0.0702484176,
-1.2241641283,
1.1234797239,
0.4744756222,
-0.2877551913,
-0.204351902,
-0.0326745734,
0.6698598266,
-0.3416196704,
0.4283149838,
0.2207860798,
0.4179840088,
0.0846671239,
-0.835940063,
-0.0829699486,
0.1600752473,
-0.2933854759,
0.2616719306,
-0.8402837515,
0.9282548428,
-0.1912298799,
-0.3939282596,
-0.3020336032,
0.4113559127,
-0.5757653713,
0.1430970132,
0.5844054818,
0.5988346338,
0.9562080503,
0.157722488,
0.9248742461,
-0.41341874,
0.4198757708,
1.0607310534,
0.1016820818,
0.9648863077,
0.2025319934,
0.204153657,
0.7498751283,
0.8246108294,
0.2580598891,
0.7916973829,
0.2073281556,
-0.1450774521,
-0.3749155104,
-0.0466917194,
-0.3535417914,
0.3071600497,
0.3087034822,
-0.3657124043,
-0.4019119442,
0.2826381326,
-0.2252778113,
-0.1837383807,
-0.4633537233,
0.9170404077,
-0.03452003,
-0.6843731403,
0.7404031754,
0.2495246977,
0.4711292684,
-0.5016123056,
0.3696253002,
-0.3005654812,
0.2650385499,
0.0078149391,
-0.2590057254,
0.4174271822,
-0.2227453738,
-0.2938142717,
-0.3111777902,
0.7841063142,
-0.4489146471,
-0.4668740034,
0.424412936,
0.609244287,
-0.0544808395,
-0.0521632619,
-0.6858435869,
-0.2262847424,
-0.3420628309,
-0.3347797692,
0.4475584328,
0.5086370111,
0.0925071239,
0.9940937161,
0.5660246611,
0.073655583,
-0.0201541204,
-0.1715344936,
0.9334534407,
-0.4844608605,
-0.5978566408,
-0.7772839665,
0.3093428314,
0.1168297529,
-0.3403817415,
0.6210581064,
0.361723721,
0.9963276386,
0.0991911888,
0.6904070973,
0.1304915547,
0.4991269708,
-0.433938235,
0.7328731418,
-1.0562608242,
0.1297673434,
-0.0669976398,
-0.7698483467,
-0.2319569588,
0.39317137,
-0.1741703749,
-0.0306425225,
0.6320530176,
0.5609152913,
-0.2193997502,
-0.2048692107,
0.2477297187,
-0.0946646705,
0.1000112444,
0.3506128788,
0.557423234,
-0.5973562002,
0.7645412683,
0.1758074462,
-0.1059884727,
-0.6205246449,
-1.1861138344,
-0.9938010573,
-0.5342584252,
-0.1373951733,
-0.0971027985,
0.1374275237,
0.8931850791,
0.8338651657,
-0.6978514791,
0.0725143477,
-0.2041217536,
0.0981933549,
-0.305549562,
-0.0941618234,
0.3819604218,
-0.6039649248,
-0.3261936903,
0.1336858869,
0.1145293638,
0.0731716678,
-0.2623342276,
-0.0172132123,
-0.3268669844,
0.3753553033,
0.4030736685,
0.4076452553,
-0.5355713964,
-0.4938525558,
0.0067415424,
-0.1807420254,
0.1227624416,
1.027289629,
-0.7810360193,
0.630232513,
0.6261453032,
0.9627271295,
0.5740292668,
0.2079538107,
0.5764088631,
-0.7735254765,
0.0297700744,
-0.0655707344,
0.1682703346,
0.3653695881,
-0.2599904537,
0.2143184394,
0.4668766856,
-0.5359408259,
-0.601857543,
-0.0934390426,
-0.3358925581,
-0.5691947341,
1.0061010122,
-0.0640038997,
-0.220980987,
-0.3110450208,
-0.1102678776,
0.3704611063,
-0.0868867338,
0.8881424069,
0.7728686929,
0.1940823942,
-0.0252021067,
-0.5730526447,
0.8067573905,
0.462664634,
-0.6844834685,
0.4043211043,
0.1829269528,
0.519163847,
0.1369698942,
0.7040034533,
0.4649516344,
0.1698872447,
-0.185855478,
-0.1555984467,
-0.035780739,
-0.5393740535,
-0.5005107522,
0.0473056473,
0.0816497728,
-0.1294212937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15075v1 | HuatuoGPT, towards Taming Language Model to Be a Doctor | 2023-05-24T11:56:01 | 2023-05-24T11:56:01 | Hongbo Zhang, Junying Chen, Feng Jiang, Fei Yu, Zhihong Chen, Jianquan Li, Guiming Chen, Xiangbo Wu, Zhiyi Zhang, Qingying Xiao, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we present HuatuoGPT, a large language model (LLM) for medical
consultation. The core recipe of HuatuoGPT is to leverage both
\textit{distilled data from ChatGPT} and \textit{real-world data from doctors}
in the supervised fine-tuned stage. The responses of ChatGPT are usually
detailed, well-presented and informative while it cannot perform like a doctor
in many aspects, e.g. for integrative diagnosis. We argue that real-world data
from doctors would be complementary to distilled data in the sense the former
could tame a distilled language model to perform like doctors. To better
leverage the strengths of both data, we train a reward model to align the
language model with the merits that both data bring, following an RLAIF
(reinforced learning from AI feedback) fashion. To evaluate and benchmark the
models, we propose a comprehensive evaluation scheme (including automatic and
manual metrics). Experimental results demonstrate that HuatuoGPT achieves
state-of-the-art results in performing medical consultation among open-source
LLMs in GPT-4 evaluation, human evaluation, and medical benchmark datasets. It
is worth noting that by using additional real-world data and RLAIF, the
distilled language model (i.e., HuatuoGPT) outperforms its teacher model
ChatGPT in most cases. Our code, data, and models are publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/FreedomIntelligence/HuatuoGPT}. The online demo is
available at \url{https://www.HuatuoGPT.cn/}. | [
-0.0358291529,
-0.7835495472,
0.472168535,
-0.0079862559,
-0.5496795774,
0.1383386403,
-0.2708189785,
-0.7362016439,
0.1019505709,
0.5472218394,
-0.3228902221,
-0.2594187558,
-0.6628954411,
-0.115099825,
-0.4298409522,
0.9720853567,
0.177584067,
0.6470697522,
-0.1949090511,
-0.1017545536,
-0.4738610983,
-0.7338677049,
-0.9666637182,
-0.9269031286,
0.2155571282,
0.340883702,
0.8024131656,
0.6332073808,
0.3141371012,
0.148628667,
-0.0426267534,
0.0618498139,
-0.4285741746,
0.2447165549,
-0.013011598,
-0.4486090839,
-0.3841020167,
0.1387330294,
0.437476486,
0.702829659,
-0.6020050645,
-0.0439267084,
0.3556869328,
0.6403861642,
0.0623470657,
0.2806997001,
-0.3585518301,
0.0612157546,
-0.0226525161,
-0.0591125935,
-0.2242116928,
-0.5363036394,
0.3306540251,
-0.261654079,
-0.0525519922,
0.1090219319,
0.9987100959,
0.5430626869,
-0.3642715514,
-0.2625864744,
-0.7483649254,
0.5386325717,
-0.7344739437,
0.4244380593,
0.4802307189,
0.6154856086,
-0.2419039756,
-0.7633696198,
-0.3115825057,
-0.7137898803,
0.2299811393,
0.2481603622,
-0.0123843942,
0.151948303,
0.1508700401,
0.7810701728,
-0.333989501,
0.1880537719,
-0.2779221237,
-0.2508986294,
0.3989205062,
0.1454353034,
0.3853032291,
-0.0352436863,
-0.4144935608,
-0.0461648405,
-0.9064511657,
-0.0401767939,
0.2457548827,
0.0699524432,
-0.2674784362,
0.5720046163,
-0.2310519964,
0.8032333255,
0.0285630692,
-0.2304767668,
-0.1874236315,
-0.0529362373,
-0.2375859022,
0.1282994747,
1.0202969313,
0.2337398082,
0.6351193786,
-0.1037208289,
-0.0687564686,
-0.2031330913,
0.5756269693,
-0.8419238329,
-0.5574091673,
0.3678553402,
-0.3321858048,
-0.6834843755,
-0.2266158611,
-0.8842397332,
-0.685649395,
-0.2618158162,
0.112698108,
-0.5563357472,
-0.2311528772,
0.1731841862,
0.2753361762,
0.1047549024,
0.216895774,
-0.8941840529,
0.4106596708,
0.7712840438,
0.7606884837,
-0.0147237424,
-0.2255475074,
-0.4092662036,
-0.1880793869,
-0.175771445,
0.7977304459,
-0.4111433029,
-0.5720945597,
-0.0450291149,
-0.0675229281,
0.2525045276,
-0.7989344597,
0.6517617702,
-0.077348955,
0.451926589,
-0.0533057153,
-0.588163197,
-0.1276146472,
0.5116268992,
-0.7016456723,
1.1240566969,
0.455208987,
-0.7118878365,
0.4196330607,
-0.414676398,
-0.3448327184,
0.4318265915,
-0.307567209,
-0.5313302875,
-0.1797636449,
0.3135607243,
0.2630149722,
-0.7238283157,
0.7415442467,
-0.209868148,
-0.1848702431,
0.1234850958,
-0.4937666953,
0.9090870619,
0.1452539712,
-0.2888809741,
0.0790361613,
-0.5971863866,
0.0701121837,
0.2395644188,
-0.6295534372,
-0.357827723,
0.0212798044,
-0.0000943336,
0.0850010291,
0.1497883052,
-0.4912714064,
0.4857509732,
-0.616761148,
0.5031453967,
0.4974296987,
-0.094962433,
0.0550501719,
-0.5936804414,
0.8560729027,
-0.0748528987,
0.2278069407,
0.2836443782,
-0.7149674296,
-0.5043448806,
-0.3662347794,
0.6100283861,
0.5914433599,
-0.8644121289,
0.1419777572,
-0.5317575336,
-0.7015519738,
-1.0326966047,
-0.1079196483,
0.2935194075,
1.0122619867,
0.2348323017,
-0.3416361511,
-0.3982148767,
-0.8824918866,
-0.3380319774,
-0.4558130205,
-0.1600807309,
0.4727289677,
0.0091073941,
-0.2273744345,
0.6836300492,
-0.2468928695,
-0.2718958855,
-0.3105783761,
0.0098540615,
0.2427352071,
0.3901997805,
0.4809114635,
-0.6815840006,
-0.4545393884,
0.0056505967,
-0.5288348198,
-0.4103282392,
0.0596022047,
0.0764557496,
0.0375947952,
0.2882352769,
-0.2935377061,
0.1881982684,
0.9239370823,
-0.2267985493,
0.7361220717,
-0.2806089222,
0.2324777842,
-1.411043644,
0.1664309204,
-0.2209204137,
-0.7280449867,
-0.5945920944,
0.1717618406,
0.0288096648,
-0.198700726,
-0.4485315681,
0.7141308784,
-0.1841951162,
0.4205379188,
-0.3245281875,
-0.2149795741,
-0.268071413,
0.1062859893,
0.1243375316,
0.7611365318,
0.628100574,
-0.4919501841,
0.817013979,
0.193640098,
-0.415574789,
0.676240623,
-0.9509119391,
0.1154598221,
0.2714712024,
0.1287568063,
-0.6984086633,
-0.4752533436,
0.4288798273,
-0.2935171723,
0.2245544493,
-0.5606694221,
-0.5132088661,
-0.4050742984,
-0.1213611439,
0.4606646597,
0.6746273041,
-0.5599051118,
0.3817872405,
0.5478615761,
-0.3341752887,
-0.4758505821,
-0.605671227,
0.2377140373,
-0.3052202165,
-0.2210697085,
0.1603405774,
0.0032317971,
-0.079010427,
-0.061898306,
0.1312265247,
-0.2905170918,
0.080925867,
0.5712398887,
0.4370869994,
0.0229624789,
0.1723203957,
-0.1507183164,
-0.2183120102,
0.0098090228,
-0.1901412308,
0.9482604265,
-0.0639987737,
-0.6678580046,
-0.3716816306,
0.1015859693,
0.5643601418,
0.009058347,
0.3642641604,
0.3067484796,
-0.4360921681,
0.0202753879,
-0.525218606,
-0.2823272645,
-0.4459193945,
0.2515793145,
-0.1548217684,
-0.7170792818,
0.2923360467,
-0.2957579494,
0.0644181296,
0.2212807238,
0.9161276221,
0.0280847456,
0.7778900266,
0.5882312059,
-0.4038700461,
0.4067644477,
0.1470768601,
0.2022058964,
-0.6275222898,
-0.1969531626,
-0.3033793271,
-0.0925901681,
-0.8029803038,
-0.1677009314,
0.4790660739,
-0.1157743856,
0.0648306236,
0.1506914198,
-0.8588526249,
0.2800641656,
0.6894094348,
0.3216555119,
0.2735930681,
-0.1044814736,
-0.3955235183,
-0.0980743691,
-0.8251780868,
-0.5107584,
1.2802350521,
0.4073370099,
0.9809801579,
-0.175037846,
0.8261800408,
-0.0094047124,
0.4030558169,
-1.2030571699,
0.387490958,
0.0608204342,
-0.3318659365,
-0.1279146969,
-0.4531266987,
-1.1513073444,
0.1072752178,
-0.1367963701,
-0.4995301366,
-0.3054019511,
0.2774676979,
-0.4386518896,
0.260869354,
-0.6366215944,
0.5632911921,
-0.3091971874,
-0.2712414265,
-0.1230025664,
-0.5581004024,
0.39548105,
-0.1201853231,
0.1542124003,
-0.0937659889,
0.3158829212,
0.5624523163,
-0.438079834,
0.7865636945,
0.0179242268,
-0.1304449588,
0.0004417915,
0.1890843511,
0.1775986999,
0.2417780161,
-0.0752889141,
0.2387917042,
0.4628793895,
-0.3933131397,
-0.2775955796,
0.6870219707,
-0.6820925474,
-0.7085826993,
-0.5214177966,
-0.6618846059,
-0.3916656375,
0.1637751311,
0.2537950575,
0.5409356356,
-0.4070810974,
-0.0194600448,
0.3003255129,
-0.2989379764,
0.0005942319,
0.4057771862,
-0.3480812311,
-0.2139409631,
0.6514341831,
-0.052305501,
0.3368944526,
0.0544910468,
0.6084889174,
-0.4813435078,
-0.3540155292,
-0.4977247715,
0.3299081922,
-0.4602939785,
-0.1273490041,
-0.4124951065,
-0.535443902,
-0.458981365,
0.1248349994,
-0.3808959424,
-0.2876487672,
-0.0512764901,
0.1836962104,
0.4371833801,
0.8006504774,
0.0005890707,
0.227424413,
-0.7371678352,
0.4770519137,
0.3586151898,
0.4522819519,
-0.1871101409,
-0.5091637969,
-0.2031913847,
0.4296236932,
-0.3886754513,
-0.8876007199,
0.5895674229,
0.0177866165,
0.5734046102,
0.3552190661,
0.0743974075,
0.6936346889,
-0.6102712154,
0.8531648517,
0.0654451177,
-0.6366309524,
0.4429711998,
-0.1091732606,
0.4356739223,
0.5346888304,
0.3447545469,
-0.9555263519,
-0.7054155469,
-0.6769220233,
-0.6986210346,
0.4619893432,
-0.1399322152,
0.0719924048,
0.184391886,
0.5035046935,
0.1291042119,
0.2489205301,
-0.8258422613,
-0.0371208303,
-0.171958819,
-0.4541988969,
0.0621658191,
-0.3463231921,
-0.5016495585,
-0.4532153308,
0.5269530416,
-0.0236173291,
0.2599059939,
0.2965528071,
0.1124165431,
0.131986022,
0.4262106121,
0.3510938287,
0.528845191,
0.0155681316,
0.2624724507,
-0.0005333217,
-0.9474127889,
0.1031332687,
0.221860826,
0.0586376935,
0.0954712555,
0.3806613088,
0.4671234488,
0.1081136242,
-0.8541814089,
0.4809236526,
-0.037157543,
-0.2298153937,
-0.1462893039,
0.0771045238,
0.0771002844,
0.2195111513,
-0.0172097292,
-0.4241657853,
0.1056793928,
-0.5218169689,
0.1844757348,
0.4514304101,
-0.6275318265,
-0.2597034872,
0.9901630878,
0.0401175246,
-0.6263446808,
0.8110240698,
0.189203009,
-0.7671040893,
0.4266784191,
0.4360476136,
0.6356633902,
-0.5297241211,
0.2965925634,
0.1803996712,
0.1228607595,
-0.440854609,
0.3426900208,
0.1069382727,
-0.560539782,
-0.2329791486,
-0.4821999371,
-0.8163340092,
0.315758884,
-0.7197564244,
0.4326035082,
-0.4040498137,
-0.1221932396,
-0.087973468,
0.0059867338,
-0.5204775333,
0.1612244844,
-0.0741011575,
0.5512290597,
-0.5248356462,
1.3047851324,
0.7614752054,
-0.3297911882,
-0.9841775894,
0.0637029633,
0.0452486686,
-1.288669467,
0.1502998322,
0.0223990623,
0.0134589281,
0.0723441839,
-0.585221231,
-0.2136644125,
0.9272059202,
0.5860885978,
-0.6843373775,
-0.0574181788,
0.4469899535,
0.7502677441,
-0.1497056335,
0.1698220521,
0.640545845,
0.1669910848,
-0.0072593796,
-1.3898841143,
0.1126255766,
-0.0474680364,
-0.309125036,
0.172949031,
-0.4268888235,
0.671775043,
-0.1919708848,
-0.2097435147,
0.0376195684,
-0.1398263276,
0.3212321699,
-0.1108060107,
0.5153087974,
0.4495440125,
0.8113014102,
-0.178782776,
1.4227366447,
-0.6639277339,
0.5005632043,
1.2196931839,
-0.1371877193,
0.7279115915,
0.809912622,
-0.0903954878,
0.1553969979,
0.6982417107,
-0.0971524268,
0.489199549,
0.1354350001,
-0.2297970653,
-0.128484115,
-0.2696988583,
-0.3997372091,
0.4259548485,
0.1458577216,
-0.226184994,
-0.3052846193,
-0.0896046162,
0.0510287471,
0.0349033475,
0.1218110546,
0.8907441497,
0.3424428701,
-0.7269181609,
0.9401828647,
-0.1938333362,
0.4042854905,
-0.6044620872,
-0.1843935549,
-0.0866519138,
-0.0029960664,
-0.1022403985,
-0.868560195,
0.2739004195,
-0.1906263083,
0.3265576065,
-0.289673388,
0.6306328773,
-0.7043080926,
-0.3943658769,
0.0541960858,
0.6173610687,
0.3351887763,
-0.1754764467,
-0.7095543742,
-0.3088559508,
0.0131581258,
-0.0514512546,
0.2890848517,
0.3022278547,
-0.0403482728,
1.007178545,
0.6255887747,
0.6313270926,
-0.1892054677,
0.2742027938,
0.9415044785,
-0.5021223426,
-0.5001570582,
-1.1295382977,
0.1631952524,
0.0607784428,
-0.2069231421,
0.3179534376,
0.5095528364,
0.3872752786,
0.0633816868,
0.6394620538,
0.1118335575,
0.749343574,
-0.4873192608,
0.9701858163,
-0.6314100027,
0.1158686727,
-0.0146000599,
-0.4807012081,
-0.2480918169,
0.4227329195,
-0.1958388239,
-0.1220739335,
0.6503382325,
0.6253394485,
-0.1342875957,
-0.1207703948,
0.6030464768,
0.1378970295,
0.5092185736,
0.5878299475,
0.9934024811,
-0.1179328412,
0.3789304197,
-0.3531164527,
-0.3202109039,
-0.3669099212,
-0.6760238409,
-0.8231497407,
-0.5568023324,
-0.1724666208,
-0.3514121175,
-0.1051084176,
0.9150677919,
0.788315773,
-0.5687586069,
-0.2393502444,
-0.017386416,
-0.013622663,
-0.3659143746,
-0.2170525342,
0.3125098944,
-0.0149914511,
-0.9008159041,
0.2989076674,
0.2124655396,
0.4367018342,
-0.3608682454,
0.1496134698,
0.1943309903,
-0.0252068564,
0.3712807596,
0.1840573102,
-0.7895743847,
-0.2489279211,
-0.102319777,
-0.2426293939,
0.357817024,
0.7409265041,
-0.8150926828,
0.6791794896,
-0.0218744054,
0.72353971,
0.4735511541,
0.1531280279,
0.835075438,
-0.401168704,
0.5243620872,
0.4688152671,
0.4382418692,
0.4240486622,
-0.637650907,
0.5841997862,
-0.0548498333,
-0.675980866,
-0.8675522208,
0.2944983244,
-0.9595953822,
-0.0989766642,
1.3219451904,
-0.1236877441,
-0.0287814382,
-0.3181592524,
-0.5724901557,
0.3379865289,
-0.3680289388,
1.2676428556,
0.9122256637,
-0.1016671658,
-0.2372164875,
-0.9763944745,
0.7277436256,
0.5066325068,
-0.9109752774,
0.0042966958,
0.3237117529,
0.7060201168,
-0.3071295917,
0.8650866151,
-0.3757895827,
0.1812841445,
-0.1724401414,
0.2116298378,
-0.1684916168,
0.066833891,
-0.5355941057,
-0.0332071595,
0.4676263928,
-0.2671819925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15074v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15074v3 | Have LLMs Advanced Enough? A Challenging Problem Solving Benchmark For Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:55:59 | 2023-10-23T11:55:58 | Daman Arora, Himanshu Gaurav Singh, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The performance of large language models (LLMs) on existing reasoning
benchmarks has significantly improved over the past years. In response, we
present JEEBench, a considerably more challenging benchmark dataset for
evaluating the problem solving abilities of LLMs. We curate 515 challenging
pre-engineering mathematics, physics and chemistry problems from the highly
competitive IIT JEE-Advanced exam. Long-horizon reasoning on top of deep
in-domain knowledge is essential for solving problems in this benchmark. Our
evaluation on various open-source and proprietary models reveals that the
highest performance, even after using techniques like self-consistency,
self-refinement and chain-of-thought prompting, is less than 40%. The typical
failure modes of GPT-4, the best model, are errors in algebraic manipulation,
difficulty in grounding abstract concepts into mathematical equations
accurately and failure in retrieving relevant domain-specific concepts. We also
observe that by mere prompting, GPT-4 is unable to assess risk introduced by
negative marking for incorrect answers. For this, we develop a post-hoc
confidence-thresholding method over self-consistency, which enables effective
response selection. We hope that our challenging benchmark will guide future
re-search in problem-solving using LLMs. | [
-0.4291180074,
-0.7733775973,
0.9668214917,
0.2592745423,
0.0274667628,
0.1616479754,
-0.3987681866,
-0.3853551149,
-0.3281482756,
0.3194872141,
-0.60782969,
-0.3554531038,
-0.7396785021,
0.1980166584,
-0.1635981649,
0.597725153,
-0.4051168263,
0.1281303614,
-0.4785919785,
-0.0304969437,
-0.6865453124,
-0.3804033697,
-0.3482468426,
-0.4258517623,
0.3183546364,
0.356836319,
0.2968914211,
0.1418159455,
0.8700686097,
0.3506201804,
-0.1890395582,
0.1746345311,
-0.47412166,
0.4596844614,
-0.7075378299,
-0.1921996325,
-0.477527678,
0.1079948172,
0.3792948127,
1.0083731413,
-0.1136295795,
0.2018813044,
0.0693581328,
0.7834855318,
-0.4714159071,
0.3076410592,
-0.715944469,
-0.2752296329,
-0.2286501229,
0.0012400758,
-0.4131086171,
-0.2147740424,
0.1802138984,
-0.5226457715,
-0.1016800627,
0.072161369,
0.8298454285,
0.3370873034,
-0.3165410757,
-0.4193983078,
-0.6455378532,
0.7561547756,
-0.5471460223,
0.3963477612,
0.1004343778,
0.40551126,
-0.399551779,
-0.5667591095,
-0.1507181376,
-0.3848155141,
0.4599884748,
0.2343168259,
-0.0236568563,
-0.0673618987,
0.3769224882,
0.1778341383,
-0.7725716829,
-0.0317102559,
-0.5013592839,
-0.2362480015,
0.4611651599,
0.2252252698,
-0.0358048007,
-0.1143839508,
-0.2968954146,
-0.2285967469,
-0.6455069184,
-0.2443155497,
0.2261275649,
0.1599069536,
0.3187545836,
0.5504854321,
-0.1335598826,
0.432092458,
-0.1619052142,
0.2301951945,
0.3308740258,
-0.0534572303,
-0.0159574375,
-0.2194242328,
0.4310801625,
0.2136994004,
0.7125595808,
0.065630272,
-0.2939695418,
-0.0458841771,
0.2215067148,
-0.6597152352,
-0.3644182384,
0.1698309332,
-0.0024724223,
0.193558678,
-0.2012572438,
-0.5446659327,
-0.3566883504,
-0.3308168352,
0.5483865142,
-0.2757077217,
-0.2505390942,
0.2284842581,
0.1318744123,
0.2883074284,
0.458673209,
-0.4850632548,
0.3685932457,
0.7307454944,
0.6636304259,
-0.3918023407,
-0.2747807205,
-0.2200978249,
-0.0479144305,
-0.5812911987,
0.794072628,
-0.4165287614,
-0.4661897421,
-0.2699585259,
-0.0706475824,
0.1290890723,
-0.8753448725,
0.4847199023,
-0.5275235772,
-0.1623614728,
-0.4184660316,
-0.9248673916,
0.0718013793,
0.5215619802,
-0.4104297757,
0.9701563716,
0.2608573437,
-0.4685572386,
-0.0279695727,
-0.5188510418,
-0.2160048038,
0.0777576342,
-0.3120082915,
-0.313505739,
0.3483148217,
0.0713515952,
0.3630144596,
-0.6337755322,
0.5177030563,
-0.5260905623,
-0.2864581943,
0.0803893954,
-0.3852242827,
0.5043373704,
0.1305096149,
-0.2292182446,
-0.0936413258,
-0.7376831174,
0.4605877697,
0.5311484337,
0.0315008014,
-0.219618246,
-0.1537874937,
-0.37729913,
0.3380056024,
0.4416409433,
-0.4886734784,
0.1874411404,
-0.2405202687,
0.2893318236,
1.1671280861,
-0.0404364169,
0.0279629529,
0.1213409305,
0.4329351187,
-0.0219181441,
0.0002491769,
0.0246183742,
-0.5015660524,
-0.6402627826,
0.2530029714,
0.2767064273,
0.7064061165,
-0.5540317893,
0.0704066902,
-0.3351980448,
-0.630341053,
-0.3097770214,
0.2617370188,
0.5711452365,
0.6201277375,
0.5388795137,
-0.0865021199,
-0.2865706682,
-1.23525846,
-0.4737115502,
-0.0062896609,
0.0112994034,
0.3767367005,
0.7625285387,
-0.1438545138,
0.5513606668,
-0.5557051301,
0.0918216184,
-0.0950901061,
0.0923810378,
0.37095806,
0.4038291276,
0.0724410713,
-0.5316351056,
-0.5629927516,
0.103570126,
-1.0623825788,
-0.4210898876,
0.2932978272,
-0.0140529387,
0.166543439,
0.7358967662,
-0.5161975622,
0.0304185841,
0.5493243337,
-0.1040574387,
0.7458596826,
-0.3023822606,
0.1369307488,
-0.7198443413,
0.1089265198,
0.139310196,
-0.1151618287,
-0.2945556641,
0.1813249439,
0.3116420209,
-0.2501455247,
-0.2956909835,
0.640304327,
-0.6496884823,
-0.1111667827,
-0.3632243872,
0.3370929956,
-0.2547037005,
0.3498784006,
-0.2205883861,
0.9866457582,
0.5427459478,
-0.369527787,
0.5501047969,
0.1357371509,
-0.4457951784,
0.683352828,
-0.7492815852,
0.3464199603,
-0.0526141487,
0.0178728327,
-0.7921820283,
-0.2917737961,
-0.1348528862,
-0.2671548128,
0.5645878315,
0.0668406039,
-0.4066672325,
-0.713939786,
-0.0620604306,
0.4967199564,
0.5861796141,
-0.3716922998,
0.4504523575,
0.0664075688,
-0.5573153496,
-0.3835178912,
-0.5515314937,
0.0829279274,
-0.0277827494,
-0.7319667935,
0.1559492201,
-0.3502450883,
-0.2882488668,
0.1105047315,
-0.5668783188,
0.1299304962,
0.04685992,
-0.0825924352,
0.2510903478,
-0.1941384077,
0.1028997004,
-0.2220129073,
-0.5421069264,
0.300337851,
-0.224880904,
0.449758023,
-0.6277596354,
-0.6412269473,
-0.2232490331,
0.4644777477,
0.3931470215,
-0.1217426956,
0.3726704121,
0.020200761,
-0.3798781931,
-0.1927405745,
-0.6648429632,
-0.1202483401,
-0.5315731764,
0.7648902535,
-0.8056239486,
-0.9194023609,
0.578342855,
-0.3834922612,
-0.1094716191,
0.5713951588,
0.5632758141,
-0.1501161754,
0.8990222216,
0.337507993,
0.0074862549,
-0.0983474925,
0.0285033286,
0.2833055556,
-0.7282484174,
-0.1800978184,
-0.3504419029,
-0.0437113009,
-0.5931699276,
-0.3252666891,
0.6277787685,
0.0351836793,
-0.5648040175,
0.3176802993,
-0.4286157191,
0.7214763165,
0.3536172509,
0.008014665,
0.1903330833,
-0.2218534946,
-0.0961785167,
-0.2245933414,
-0.3255300522,
-0.3450181484,
1.043682456,
0.2789196074,
0.8576051593,
0.0332657918,
0.5928740501,
0.0251607429,
0.3415775895,
-0.4121497571,
0.779669106,
0.0482766926,
-0.8966779113,
-0.2318264097,
-0.617842555,
-0.7602181435,
0.1844335496,
0.3142172396,
-0.805403173,
-0.2336413264,
0.12207257,
0.0252046287,
0.1305880398,
-0.6656639576,
0.8409307599,
-0.293348372,
-0.5263085961,
-0.1372620463,
-0.7322977185,
0.2939559221,
-0.251506269,
0.2471182495,
-0.4264530241,
-0.0224323105,
0.4567810595,
-0.2125898749,
0.345187664,
-0.1871611178,
-0.2450836748,
0.4317286909,
0.3282754123,
0.7780649662,
-0.1414178312,
-0.2364034504,
-0.1250914484,
-0.1881304085,
-0.6959246397,
-0.6768265367,
0.9084557891,
-0.6319930553,
-1.0861144066,
-0.530429244,
-0.3140776753,
-0.7212995887,
0.2181871831,
0.2690363526,
0.3056563437,
-0.0620897599,
0.0991473421,
0.8151572347,
-0.1395130157,
0.1135304794,
0.3815082312,
-0.1517808139,
-0.3029492199,
1.0266427994,
0.3520540893,
0.5134884119,
-0.0550976507,
0.0665825978,
-0.2554792464,
-0.7703099251,
-0.3565532267,
0.2047747076,
-1.2075889111,
-0.2670633197,
-0.4566688538,
-0.5769760609,
-0.0982064977,
-0.1323449612,
-0.782612741,
-0.1081930697,
0.2146933228,
-0.0373010598,
-0.0473372228,
0.6971800923,
-0.0026454302,
-0.2165903449,
-0.6285219789,
0.1439529359,
0.2553566396,
0.6085899472,
-0.1333482713,
-0.4512595236,
-0.119184345,
-0.3599666059,
-0.356454134,
-0.8486865163,
-0.1298395246,
-0.1228808984,
0.6523307562,
-0.2228243947,
-0.0015913409,
0.4827088416,
-0.5288173556,
0.6527988315,
0.0259185545,
-0.9707217813,
0.5552598834,
-0.4803282619,
0.3270960152,
0.6212131381,
0.3656884134,
-0.2019965947,
-0.283007592,
-0.6144682169,
-1.044388175,
0.2512859404,
0.3027659655,
-0.0485854372,
-0.0260518938,
0.5163200498,
0.0538472384,
0.1262749434,
-0.7759441733,
-0.2366457283,
0.0513535514,
-0.203397423,
-0.0466089547,
-0.1811133325,
0.1068104431,
-0.2806601822,
0.9512007236,
-0.0702526718,
0.1156587526,
0.239470154,
-0.191092059,
-0.0918770656,
0.4503126144,
0.5976620913,
0.6786592007,
-0.1915822029,
0.0240293052,
0.4640663266,
-0.2087269723,
0.3216400743,
0.1814907789,
0.2515220642,
-0.4764904678,
0.2960138619,
0.4684458375,
0.0612972938,
-0.8648967743,
0.5556026697,
0.2379439473,
-0.4042539001,
-0.3126120865,
0.1095199734,
0.225843668,
0.2410795391,
0.3873894811,
-0.0875819921,
0.1984600276,
-0.428732425,
0.1355158538,
0.35834077,
-0.2441045642,
-0.0466620252,
0.5365585685,
0.0988977998,
-0.0977245793,
0.6933487654,
-0.3922865987,
-0.6544619203,
0.6929993629,
0.6370431781,
0.7411583066,
-0.2538415194,
-0.1704713851,
0.450081557,
0.3246914446,
-0.2968077362,
0.2784639001,
0.3464602828,
-0.4929526448,
-0.5933452249,
-0.3773088753,
-0.6927419305,
0.2915082276,
-0.5662481189,
0.1463502198,
-0.5342388153,
-0.0183632523,
-0.1019713432,
0.1078157052,
-0.6852451563,
0.2348019928,
0.0775055513,
0.9391171932,
-0.5724355578,
0.4025561512,
0.6376569867,
0.0342373885,
-0.7237867117,
-0.1236269623,
0.0868106186,
-0.8196873069,
0.4261240363,
0.2224826366,
-0.248123914,
-0.0139444647,
-0.6266900301,
-0.9617567062,
0.801356554,
0.4301571846,
-0.8588525653,
0.0201809071,
-0.0461610742,
0.4537942111,
-0.075228408,
0.2420276701,
0.7313128114,
0.6651411653,
-0.0292709619,
-1.1524482965,
0.0764252245,
-0.4137905538,
-0.0894130319,
0.3788566291,
-0.8502196074,
0.9256121516,
-0.2174573988,
0.0874375477,
0.1299790442,
0.703769505,
0.4614355564,
0.3788305521,
0.3470621705,
0.5218141675,
0.750843823,
-0.1962349862,
0.8944240212,
-0.0370929353,
0.5566381812,
1.1265902519,
-0.6349374056,
0.7900285721,
0.3739288151,
-0.3332838118,
0.351233691,
0.6051297188,
-0.1370992512,
0.3962582648,
0.6691064239,
-0.0883853137,
-0.7536194324,
0.3451891541,
-0.6224240661,
0.2177168131,
0.4543170035,
0.2107780576,
-0.4123115242,
0.1248894855,
-0.1736875772,
0.2749938965,
-0.2759124339,
0.4227851331,
0.3241690993,
-0.6977968812,
0.6145999432,
-0.210613057,
0.2860748768,
-0.4682764709,
0.2062962502,
-0.0990745276,
0.3779062033,
0.122261323,
-1.0808260441,
0.1781925261,
-0.078276962,
-0.06352669,
-0.0376334637,
0.7270883918,
-0.1417749524,
-0.4216511548,
0.4781331122,
0.8583064675,
0.2817548513,
-0.1723433286,
-0.6787732244,
0.13601695,
-0.178833425,
-0.623259306,
0.2052605599,
0.5065059066,
-0.0964362621,
1.0426968336,
0.1888395846,
-0.1143841147,
-0.0150924409,
0.0338340066,
0.8635745645,
-0.8679765463,
-0.1788184643,
-0.8185468912,
0.3765704334,
-0.1950317472,
-0.2598375082,
0.6304590106,
0.5927359462,
0.8827640414,
-0.0102624325,
0.7870766521,
0.2153453231,
0.6192817092,
-0.5483577847,
0.1991052479,
-0.7602059841,
0.3508115113,
-0.399065733,
-0.9928444624,
-0.2097920328,
0.4376086593,
-0.4495591521,
0.3571094871,
0.953943193,
0.5673466325,
-0.0380926169,
-0.0695589483,
0.4310589731,
0.4135269225,
0.4323916137,
1.0092955828,
0.9326898456,
-0.3373150229,
0.6147587299,
0.0460834764,
-0.1714336425,
-0.2365945429,
-0.870213747,
-0.8883321285,
-0.4830129743,
-0.3265322149,
-0.471311748,
0.4045598209,
1.0577710867,
0.3686208725,
-0.8549832702,
0.0647504106,
-0.2659796476,
-0.1519665867,
-0.0545372739,
-0.1551466137,
0.3401755095,
-0.4465340376,
-0.6051806808,
0.60067451,
0.3158006966,
0.181944862,
-0.1905235201,
-0.0121284472,
0.2302390784,
0.2134613246,
0.4246251881,
0.1720237285,
-0.5778250098,
-0.4735158384,
0.1660120487,
-0.227607429,
0.1283097267,
0.6478022933,
-0.4591900706,
0.3303509951,
0.2693791687,
0.8631096482,
0.6311253905,
-0.089403145,
0.4335134327,
-0.3642412424,
-0.1272164881,
0.4203525782,
0.4420848489,
0.3695064485,
-0.0056629824,
0.6659902334,
0.2963830531,
-0.8391522765,
-0.8378477693,
0.3173011243,
-0.9375477433,
-0.4635579586,
1.0682817698,
-0.1091592535,
-0.1822969466,
-0.0145464484,
-0.030869998,
-0.0692455396,
-0.1936658621,
0.5871927738,
1.2248190641,
-0.273565352,
-0.1828725934,
-0.8898494244,
0.2069946527,
0.8118380904,
-0.8054413199,
0.2509670854,
0.3779253066,
0.4337896407,
0.0830603018,
0.5263788104,
-0.1159318388,
0.2575148344,
0.0990650356,
-0.1407250166,
-0.0789660811,
-0.5862733722,
-0.0551819392,
0.2636792064,
0.3159794509,
0.2894089222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15070v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15070v3 | Annotation Imputation to Individualize Predictions: Initial Studies on Distribution Dynamics and Model Predictions | 2023-05-24T11:54:46 | 2023-10-05T07:10:25 | London Lowmanstone, Ruyuan Wan, Risako Owan, Jaehyung Kim, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Annotating data via crowdsourcing is time-consuming and expensive. Due to
these costs, dataset creators often have each annotator label only a small
subset of the data. This leads to sparse datasets with examples that are marked
by few annotators. The downside of this process is that if an annotator doesn't
get to label a particular example, their perspective on it is missed. This is
especially concerning for subjective NLP datasets where there is no single
correct label: people may have different valid opinions. Thus, we propose using
imputation methods to generate the opinions of all annotators for all examples,
creating a dataset that does not leave out any annotator's view. We then train
and prompt models, using data from the imputed dataset, to make predictions
about the distribution of responses and individual annotations.
In our analysis of the results, we found that the choice of imputation method
significantly impacts soft label changes and distribution. While the imputation
introduces noise in the prediction of the original dataset, it has shown
potential in enhancing shots for prompts, particularly for low-response-rate
annotators. We have made all of our code and data publicly available. | [
-0.6090130806,
-0.2874620557,
0.2800376713,
0.1847318113,
-0.3558442593,
-0.2099266052,
-0.2204991281,
-0.6345384717,
0.3315652013,
0.4542443454,
-0.6183219552,
-0.31227687,
-0.4919324517,
0.2405960709,
-0.1507904232,
1.4270086288,
0.2638511956,
-0.1509576738,
-0.4248426855,
-0.4207523763,
-0.4559484124,
-0.7239422202,
-0.3539919555,
-0.4397857785,
0.6436669827,
0.5094949603,
0.8268533945,
0.5774331093,
0.5204927921,
0.2233185917,
-0.3679567873,
-0.0461642258,
-0.3898957074,
0.2928718925,
-0.0448638536,
-0.1503718048,
0.1814693809,
0.1385134906,
0.3396750689,
0.9814012051,
0.2028868794,
0.4739477336,
0.2326796651,
0.4066429436,
-0.499794662,
0.2342670262,
-0.6209830046,
0.3577905893,
-0.2867708504,
-0.2194130123,
-0.4095448554,
-0.4587212503,
0.4612203836,
-0.5220315456,
0.521217823,
0.0591075309,
0.4648808241,
0.5840076804,
0.1039011851,
-0.2048127651,
-0.9560527802,
0.4188730419,
-0.8670429587,
-0.3320965767,
0.4345577359,
0.1379038692,
0.0291032866,
-0.5610988736,
-0.4850621521,
-0.3410590589,
-0.2266443968,
0.194050923,
0.2170117497,
0.0463864915,
0.4665456116,
0.1495031118,
-0.2307470888,
0.1362575144,
-0.39499861,
0.0629337654,
0.8912066817,
0.0395280048,
-0.0322496034,
-0.2344447225,
-0.4881472588,
-0.0319119953,
-0.5172943473,
0.0914493874,
0.7788835168,
0.5688050985,
0.0937660262,
0.7036317587,
-0.2614684403,
0.6179636717,
0.1462434828,
0.0786771029,
0.6298072934,
-0.0771038532,
-0.0283037387,
0.272331059,
0.8813425303,
0.2730121017,
0.2721003592,
-0.2220947444,
-0.0938704461,
-0.3645305932,
0.0013044281,
-0.661900878,
-0.4617236853,
0.4507493675,
-0.4750185311,
-0.4240288734,
0.0416815653,
-0.9650654197,
-0.9395159483,
-0.4318321943,
0.4054125249,
-0.1785770059,
-0.3185616136,
-0.1499738395,
-0.208193928,
-0.5192475319,
0.5896412134,
-0.8400384188,
0.124146007,
0.4619124532,
0.7743237615,
0.2116773576,
-0.2361388952,
-0.3662366271,
-0.0500687025,
-0.235509336,
1.0720245838,
-0.6495288014,
-0.3138644993,
-0.0994394198,
-0.1730652452,
0.3217143416,
-0.6252493262,
0.2533234358,
-0.0154404398,
0.058052931,
-0.4534315467,
-0.6612709165,
-0.3569432795,
0.0119193746,
-0.7120161653,
0.8070255518,
0.0568448231,
-0.9854628444,
0.6089461446,
-0.7164561749,
-0.0671825707,
0.4645319581,
0.0004625967,
-0.38192752,
0.1921544671,
0.2824926376,
0.5705356002,
-0.0408887044,
0.4115417302,
-0.8001966476,
-0.3735131025,
0.6198784113,
-0.3088651299,
0.7542883754,
0.1773092151,
-0.1639635712,
0.1307884455,
-0.6811295152,
-0.252635628,
-0.1436217278,
0.0893305391,
-0.2960518897,
0.2269644439,
0.1988624185,
0.3429925144,
-0.1269651055,
-0.6176933646,
0.380949825,
-0.6308220625,
0.1508268863,
1.199911356,
0.4160023034,
0.4928996563,
-0.2885996103,
0.55938977,
0.3019307256,
0.3113045096,
-0.2146731019,
-0.7075445056,
-0.5846806765,
-0.2206816971,
0.4910564125,
0.2904761732,
-0.4495686889,
0.0986928046,
-0.064429529,
-0.575335741,
-0.7776063681,
0.1123731211,
-0.02682372,
0.7935938239,
0.3829450309,
-0.0409805402,
-0.4213447869,
-1.0349315405,
-0.1353478581,
-0.3540884852,
-0.1791172624,
0.0949538425,
0.613986969,
0.2879767716,
1.3386001587,
-0.484821111,
-0.2527919412,
0.0157627128,
0.3638129234,
0.1234917715,
0.4572797418,
0.407638371,
-0.7717501521,
-0.1902742535,
-0.3341977,
-0.6957906485,
-0.1209767312,
-0.2925508618,
0.1516997069,
-0.1760598272,
0.0629438236,
-0.1515466422,
0.6574548483,
0.1026756987,
0.0090181204,
0.4346302748,
-0.096404694,
-0.1719581783,
-0.7709115744,
-0.0405982919,
0.3972500563,
-0.0702970326,
-0.4758137167,
-0.2646380663,
-0.4135080576,
-0.3398482502,
-0.4715648592,
0.6757622957,
-0.2470856756,
0.1046407521,
-0.1834630966,
-0.1509539932,
-0.3432803452,
0.4685744643,
0.3002485335,
0.6068689823,
0.3024146557,
-0.513794601,
0.249565348,
0.5109519362,
-0.3179626465,
0.2702322006,
-0.7986078262,
0.2700083256,
-0.6578459144,
0.3460991979,
-1.1816264391,
-0.3931991458,
0.7638795376,
-0.4176626205,
0.0439548604,
-0.4869735539,
-0.6247595549,
-0.4402630031,
-0.2890368402,
0.0170815941,
0.2716255486,
-0.5552847385,
0.3407723606,
0.5007506013,
-0.3482465744,
-0.5946449041,
-0.8132802248,
0.0718650073,
-0.461135149,
-0.2792761028,
0.0202385522,
-0.4093914628,
-0.2889070213,
0.1520197093,
0.3053453565,
-0.0999888256,
0.1036714315,
0.6594510078,
0.0820704103,
0.186921373,
0.6295671463,
-0.1536763161,
-0.3183666468,
0.0480395891,
-0.0257646423,
0.0754019469,
0.1174220741,
-0.3501353562,
-0.3882403672,
0.4386080503,
-0.0422604419,
-0.2418811619,
0.7980914712,
0.3816329539,
-0.440261066,
-0.1955744922,
-0.5050929785,
-0.1890421659,
-0.4271009266,
0.0321929529,
-0.1903574169,
-0.4273092151,
0.5177898407,
-0.0096916407,
0.273447752,
0.2355160415,
0.5971387625,
-0.2269784659,
0.9812742472,
0.5232066512,
0.0489001945,
0.3970104754,
-0.2166800946,
0.1868081093,
-0.6477764845,
-0.1318552792,
-0.5494710207,
-0.7114950418,
-0.6229141951,
-0.1287709475,
0.3761363029,
-0.2119130045,
-0.0834805965,
-0.0939598903,
-1.0850208998,
0.376178354,
0.8572285771,
0.3103550375,
0.1800107956,
0.0774873272,
0.381657511,
-0.2885229886,
-0.6722199321,
-0.600523293,
1.1144104004,
0.2699722052,
0.5373600125,
-0.312202543,
0.8124145865,
0.220861122,
0.9112585783,
-0.6994680166,
0.4394569099,
0.1529250294,
-0.7999408841,
-0.1193806976,
-0.3111663759,
-0.6148363352,
0.1008550897,
-0.2443642765,
-0.8400899172,
0.684094727,
0.251008749,
-0.6042925715,
0.2731850743,
-0.7619426847,
0.5875054598,
0.2584207356,
-0.2990660965,
0.253046155,
-0.9185814261,
0.3517870009,
-0.1382635236,
0.0805173442,
-0.5495787859,
-0.0009887858,
0.8885974884,
-0.7267670035,
1.0694916248,
-0.6104961038,
0.3794038892,
0.6527388692,
-0.1880964786,
0.4428198636,
0.1972341835,
-0.3430533409,
0.1490565538,
-0.1758819968,
-0.1902838051,
-0.4888368547,
0.4603115916,
-0.6716635823,
-0.3483748436,
-0.5441219211,
-0.5136402249,
-0.3309094608,
-0.4567449987,
0.4747077227,
0.5025997758,
0.3888674974,
0.0947643295,
0.420165956,
-0.1335532814,
0.6289829612,
0.2495130599,
0.1314040273,
-0.5951418877,
0.6878896356,
0.7426538467,
-0.07822413,
0.0357492603,
0.3651143312,
-0.2923716009,
-0.5257650614,
-0.2832573056,
0.0777292028,
-0.7325798869,
-0.5219275355,
-0.7188027501,
0.1022123769,
-0.3026830256,
-0.1045598686,
-0.1279660016,
-0.5549157262,
-0.4576027691,
-0.4649167061,
0.7580267787,
0.768676281,
-0.3544500172,
0.5026934147,
-0.3801208436,
0.0554335117,
0.1140731499,
0.3201403916,
0.1065972075,
-0.3251928985,
-0.2300039977,
0.1875011474,
-0.1239022017,
-1.0213603973,
0.446411103,
0.0501468182,
0.2253020406,
0.2400012314,
0.4070696831,
0.925507009,
-0.2476333231,
0.8039289713,
0.0953886881,
-0.7641671896,
0.6595339775,
-0.1802480519,
0.0453884788,
0.7832413316,
0.3527347744,
-0.5093551874,
-0.5811806321,
-0.7919398546,
-1.0900222063,
0.9559545517,
0.0043515246,
0.2213529497,
-0.0440846756,
0.5463407636,
0.6580204368,
0.4072676301,
-0.7036973834,
-0.521520257,
-0.3224684894,
-0.4046811759,
-0.10305354,
-0.4776295125,
0.082679227,
-0.3091189563,
0.6107264161,
-0.1966201663,
0.1884942651,
0.3023867011,
0.119634144,
-0.2109342366,
-0.0703095123,
0.2744615376,
0.7429084778,
-0.3888965249,
-0.0149266636,
0.0082207387,
-0.2303542644,
0.2446108013,
0.4218608439,
-0.6159222722,
0.339548707,
0.1811190248,
0.7475888729,
-0.0148288542,
-0.5262326002,
0.4411592782,
0.1664460152,
0.1163577065,
-0.571493566,
-0.2434902936,
-0.1300448179,
0.1872496158,
0.5720732212,
0.4466747642,
0.3514915109,
-0.1579189003,
0.0823654681,
0.1347615868,
-0.5290235281,
-0.4912159443,
0.956840694,
0.0833653361,
-0.1241758987,
0.4002068639,
-0.1513593942,
-0.0745602623,
0.583432734,
0.1460669786,
0.9216421843,
-0.183371529,
0.5410766006,
0.5166800618,
0.2883431017,
-0.1085177884,
-0.1286530346,
0.0365357585,
-0.454788655,
-0.5733474493,
-0.4604574144,
-0.6794098616,
0.2016854435,
-0.5102790594,
0.3637134731,
-0.5217410922,
-0.3342471421,
0.2690972686,
-0.0176830683,
-0.86636132,
0.3168815672,
0.4981934428,
0.7074156404,
-1.0088046789,
0.3043572009,
0.6964957118,
-0.9515093565,
-0.6419229507,
0.0277974382,
-0.0057661985,
-0.3319683075,
0.6386538148,
0.2440987527,
0.3725323677,
-0.1216551811,
-1.0105326176,
-0.741296947,
0.5843727589,
0.521679461,
-0.3954086602,
0.172882691,
0.0749433041,
0.5330197811,
-0.2645196915,
0.5994440317,
-0.0619915463,
0.5117983818,
0.0970271304,
-0.5205497146,
-0.0891104117,
-0.1834543496,
0.0179947149,
-0.1223744005,
-0.5964264274,
0.7761662602,
-0.2848467529,
-0.0666906834,
-0.0250047483,
0.9474389553,
0.1520143002,
0.5420420766,
0.5440536737,
0.2126575112,
0.9847263098,
0.0197347514,
1.1178747416,
0.0459019728,
0.4669632316,
1.4602997303,
-0.4290357828,
0.6473724842,
0.3083004355,
-0.1862850934,
0.1755590439,
0.9841517806,
-0.1141747311,
0.4409973919,
0.1767272055,
-0.3535117805,
0.0031488708,
-0.4294966459,
-0.2909641266,
0.1587005109,
0.2306749821,
-0.2439357936,
-0.1694627702,
0.3858633935,
0.0752913058,
-0.1766281873,
-0.1938913912,
0.8316034675,
-0.1450388581,
-0.3452834487,
0.2658515573,
-0.3938532174,
0.5952427983,
-0.4365615249,
-0.0219556112,
-0.4182005823,
-0.0436008275,
-0.3135183156,
-0.8896549344,
0.3121894598,
-0.1207605079,
-0.1113560721,
-0.4060041904,
0.7503654361,
-0.4793522358,
-0.5962689519,
-0.06985908,
0.4357441068,
0.3614020348,
-0.2441982329,
-0.647495687,
-0.3078795969,
0.0292764306,
-0.5699726343,
0.2405802011,
0.4636672139,
0.1852544099,
0.7521990538,
0.6583018899,
0.1648079604,
-0.0882439315,
0.0274832379,
0.9082472324,
-0.4993885458,
-0.2975145876,
-0.8260432482,
0.6601319909,
-0.1863234639,
-0.4636205435,
0.6312837601,
0.4362193346,
0.6222834587,
-0.2607754767,
0.9901455045,
0.0861410052,
0.7787442207,
-0.0545248203,
0.4352708757,
-0.3347720206,
0.1453426927,
-0.3660744727,
-0.8199349642,
-0.3267244101,
0.3590247035,
-0.4726677239,
-0.0385513306,
0.2511801124,
0.640134573,
0.1138984635,
0.1882034689,
0.067967847,
0.2219447643,
0.2054595351,
0.1655951887,
0.9097736478,
-0.1496544331,
0.338952601,
-0.9472050071,
-0.1390845329,
-0.4390127361,
-0.8819879889,
-0.6496143937,
-0.6514050364,
-0.7959785461,
-0.3341813385,
-0.1568004489,
1.2737636566,
0.8137726188,
-0.8443906903,
0.0759277344,
0.2085419446,
0.0509154797,
-0.3855091333,
-0.3019049466,
0.2517520785,
-0.3650819063,
-0.8219125271,
-0.0304143578,
0.298781544,
0.2020023912,
-0.3265494406,
0.4467294514,
0.0078944704,
-0.0883216709,
0.292024523,
0.2067424953,
-0.4885349572,
-0.3887215257,
-0.442753911,
0.4241241217,
0.3082781732,
0.6684334874,
-1.3002669811,
0.6863890886,
0.4595381916,
0.2656531334,
0.3379507065,
0.3220512271,
0.3944135308,
-0.9297078848,
0.5841876268,
0.6331682205,
0.1851605326,
0.591514647,
-0.6653045416,
0.7663905025,
0.2871521413,
-0.5919608474,
-1.0266557932,
-0.0926309675,
-0.7450349927,
-0.1738484651,
1.0288491249,
-0.0838804394,
-0.308467567,
-0.2681438029,
-0.2577031553,
0.0188369863,
-0.6356726885,
0.6983410716,
0.777946651,
-0.2285030782,
-0.072260268,
-0.8124949932,
0.4956717491,
0.12231341,
-0.6511355639,
0.3676263988,
0.4984247684,
0.2643245459,
0.2256625146,
0.7096623182,
0.3052735925,
-0.2749276161,
0.0433335975,
0.2950659394,
-0.2609879375,
-0.1601032913,
-0.355779767,
0.3437190652,
-0.0007768043,
-0.3522118628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15068v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15068v2 | ToMChallenges: A Principle-Guided Dataset and Diverse Evaluation Tasks for Exploring Theory of Mind | 2023-05-24T11:54:07 | 2023-10-23T22:16:15 | Xiaomeng Ma, Lingyu Gao, Qihui Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Theory of Mind (ToM), the capacity to comprehend the mental states of
distinct individuals, is essential for numerous practical applications. With
the development of large language models (LLMs), there is a heated debate about
whether they are able to perform ToM tasks. Previous studies have used
different tasks and prompts to test the ToM on LLMs and the results are
inconsistent: some studies asserted these models are capable of exhibiting ToM,
while others suggest the opposite. In this study, We present ToMChallenges, a
dataset for comprehensively evaluating the Theory of Mind based on the
Sally-Anne and Smarties tests with a diverse set of tasks. In addition, we also
propose an auto-grader to streamline the answer evaluation process. We tested
three models: davinci, turbo, and gpt-4. Our evaluation results and error
analyses show that LLMs have inconsistent behaviors across prompts and tasks.
Performing the ToM tasks robustly remains a challenge for the LLMs. In
addition, our paper wants to raise awareness in evaluating the ToM in LLMs and
we want to invite more discussion on how to design the prompts and tasks for
ToM tasks that can better assess the LLMs' ability. | [
-0.5361973643,
-0.9274041653,
0.9026326537,
-0.038778875,
-0.296762675,
0.0057768719,
-0.5811879635,
-0.2626737058,
0.2638453841,
0.2021794766,
-0.8167614341,
-0.1251035035,
-0.6731026769,
0.1985578835,
-0.2173512429,
0.8759357333,
-0.0941173658,
0.2854297161,
-0.1610917002,
0.0870407298,
-0.6409831047,
-0.3692386448,
-0.6604783535,
-0.2664259672,
0.4842403531,
0.1032419801,
0.3072570562,
0.5260343552,
0.8466618657,
0.2935526967,
-0.0411812626,
0.3153655529,
-0.3384553492,
0.336476028,
-0.4349510968,
-0.5427383184,
-0.5442008972,
0.0694041699,
0.3959583044,
0.6675906777,
-0.2023376524,
0.1813041568,
0.4352933764,
0.3921254873,
-0.527007401,
0.2331857234,
-0.5068104267,
0.0143152829,
-0.0467436239,
-0.2916835248,
-0.1797332764,
-0.3761940002,
0.4797842205,
-0.5123966932,
0.2205195725,
0.1865332723,
0.5741687417,
0.2778221667,
-0.554440856,
-0.4331690073,
-0.5590404868,
1.0597789288,
-0.3731299341,
0.2483317703,
0.3147048056,
0.443318814,
-0.1226608083,
-0.2479313761,
-0.9111113548,
-0.1732845306,
0.0806106403,
0.1120602861,
-0.1234830245,
0.2696245313,
0.3014363348,
0.7173142433,
-0.6931655407,
-0.2952794135,
0.0409698896,
0.0718054175,
0.7041519284,
0.552606523,
0.1191932037,
-0.3558598757,
-0.412351191,
-0.3397972286,
-0.1709007472,
-0.0969771743,
0.158342734,
0.2523342073,
-0.0395074822,
0.5454237461,
-0.1109464765,
0.773612082,
0.2312718332,
-0.1791653633,
-0.0026932231,
-0.181139335,
-0.4082749486,
-0.5801129341,
0.6617659926,
0.4041804075,
0.5520657301,
-0.074859947,
-0.2328905016,
0.1419366598,
0.5390582681,
-0.4534018636,
-0.3122652173,
0.3138191998,
-0.2691680789,
0.0443652049,
-0.1488439888,
-0.8505233526,
-0.6724372506,
-0.4841330945,
0.5494169593,
-0.5945675969,
-0.38276425,
0.4004408717,
-0.1886542141,
0.0413470864,
0.5249464512,
-0.6961943507,
0.4153472185,
0.4541772604,
0.3925953209,
-0.3626705408,
-0.4212122858,
0.1788819283,
0.1474557072,
-0.2923026681,
0.7658732533,
-0.5251938701,
-0.3897987008,
-0.1707125306,
-0.1158497408,
-0.2778211236,
-0.2807666063,
0.3328314126,
-0.3033973873,
0.5600064993,
-0.9881845713,
-0.9309231639,
-0.5305461287,
0.5079526305,
-0.3058215678,
0.5533931851,
-0.0093654785,
-0.5131895542,
0.3048952818,
-0.8782103062,
-0.2526314259,
0.2298207134,
-0.6215364337,
0.3303138316,
0.1766255051,
0.0831186399,
0.7768297791,
-0.8041098118,
0.650741756,
-0.3757074475,
-0.2516893744,
0.3470897079,
-0.3625549376,
0.9910902381,
0.2527934015,
-0.4321215153,
0.0613738224,
-0.5863515735,
0.258313477,
0.481293112,
-0.0024018632,
-0.5339531302,
0.0510550812,
-0.08144667,
-0.0315386169,
0.1824979186,
-0.4460082352,
0.2401609421,
0.0003836878,
0.292226851,
0.9399287105,
0.0136370501,
0.0637017712,
-0.659539938,
0.8014494181,
-0.1040147394,
0.0531934164,
-0.2435373366,
-0.452827692,
-0.8393381238,
-0.4421941638,
-0.1389136165,
0.514164269,
-0.6838063598,
0.7948080897,
-0.4753695726,
-0.5347349644,
-0.2188238204,
-0.0110177426,
0.6269137859,
0.3255308867,
0.3231872022,
-0.4372853339,
-0.2940655053,
-1.0512117147,
-0.4401727319,
-0.2008063793,
-0.0774508417,
0.3078131974,
0.5261546969,
0.0548364669,
0.856647253,
-0.7648320198,
-0.0784208179,
-0.2323012054,
0.0644796714,
-0.1117019951,
0.5323376656,
0.4598584771,
-0.4166204333,
0.209395498,
-0.4495194256,
-0.7418882251,
0.1725066751,
0.1891321093,
-0.0239601787,
-0.1310330033,
-0.0355942622,
-0.7319839597,
0.071998775,
0.3094354868,
-0.3574869335,
0.2853673697,
0.1274315864,
0.3745641112,
-1.1041346788,
-0.0939699858,
0.3568646908,
-0.0519177504,
-0.3887351751,
0.416872412,
-0.0670866221,
0.3613022268,
-0.0553834252,
0.6130047441,
-0.2255266309,
0.0566429421,
-0.1770003587,
0.0833316222,
0.0035248038,
0.7323342562,
-0.1758242697,
0.7822542191,
0.457954824,
-0.8424896598,
0.558103323,
0.0892336294,
-0.312795341,
0.8259758353,
-0.4055844545,
0.4140387774,
-0.156804949,
0.2071591765,
-1.3672692776,
-0.378382951,
0.2189542204,
-0.0891566426,
0.1128178015,
0.3396804035,
-0.579447329,
-0.5851897001,
-0.2359988242,
0.437961638,
0.5863407254,
-0.4017133415,
0.6731538773,
0.5899451375,
-0.0746034235,
-0.1405829936,
-0.744294107,
-0.039548438,
-0.5441074967,
-0.3739985824,
0.0921057314,
-0.4599164724,
-0.6011379957,
-0.154040128,
-0.06655211,
-0.2711420953,
0.0230994243,
0.0816048533,
0.1431227028,
0.0152182812,
0.2849560082,
-0.2014817297,
0.2244438678,
0.3235883713,
-0.3250264823,
0.5436046124,
-0.2938044667,
-0.4118875265,
-0.3604474664,
0.0107536968,
0.519949913,
-0.1695611328,
0.1172667369,
0.1131618619,
-0.4799533784,
-0.4150573611,
-0.7587182522,
-0.4402524829,
-0.4553044736,
0.4160750508,
-0.4696126282,
-0.9382924438,
0.4085398018,
0.1132261157,
0.1247771755,
0.3010472059,
0.6013483405,
-0.2891876101,
0.8731502295,
0.7159749866,
0.0745353177,
0.2898389697,
-0.2045909911,
0.1912859529,
-0.7484722733,
0.0020962486,
-0.2302836478,
-0.3503063619,
-0.4282243848,
-0.3773690462,
0.2654642761,
-0.3115471005,
-0.1388008296,
0.2920814157,
-0.5084038973,
0.4778043628,
0.339353621,
0.1617483348,
0.304089278,
-0.0178130791,
-0.1380726397,
-0.0799041167,
-0.616892755,
-0.7075408101,
1.1667616367,
0.2334529012,
0.6036477685,
0.2155921459,
0.4055528939,
0.28407529,
0.0814845636,
-0.9557017684,
1.1027510166,
-0.0574140511,
-1.024966836,
-0.3431285918,
-0.1548312455,
-0.7802975178,
0.2823174,
0.1571116298,
-0.6975418925,
0.0804244056,
0.1574884206,
-0.5479341745,
0.2141973972,
-0.6372400522,
0.4846792519,
-0.1367748231,
-0.2104993314,
-0.5792856812,
-0.4640186131,
0.6915531158,
-0.116202198,
-0.0518224835,
-0.1154022291,
0.1434475929,
0.9913925529,
0.0015844459,
0.690482378,
-0.0833232626,
-0.5227952003,
0.3988157809,
0.1987877786,
0.0543667376,
-0.2595578134,
0.0760565475,
-0.1387469918,
0.2091975957,
-0.263856858,
-0.8685976863,
0.4790285528,
-0.4786329567,
-0.8718798161,
-0.517889142,
-0.8887899518,
-0.5309938192,
0.1476819515,
-0.0051382012,
0.3200857341,
-0.1057544947,
-0.0788519382,
0.8884692192,
0.098606281,
0.3160799146,
0.5356461406,
-0.3879541457,
-0.2499929368,
0.7627117038,
0.3120425344,
0.0021006088,
0.1055514216,
0.1084568128,
-0.2555121481,
-0.4355331659,
-0.2154937685,
0.0811813548,
-0.8470463157,
0.1038163006,
-0.5147159696,
0.1168498695,
-0.2550496757,
0.0960253179,
-0.2529754043,
-0.3768187761,
0.147077322,
-0.1771658212,
0.3519782126,
1.000377655,
0.3098924756,
0.2207733542,
-0.3526703417,
0.2379187495,
0.6533727646,
0.4077808261,
0.206374824,
-0.3921252191,
-0.1429022104,
0.1116156951,
-0.3700316846,
-0.8485004306,
-0.0770499334,
-0.3570002615,
0.5169914365,
0.4122571349,
-0.0536597818,
1.0307940245,
-0.2913398743,
0.8314584494,
-0.1278070956,
-1.1608918905,
0.4441224933,
-0.7787821889,
-0.0421311222,
0.5181622505,
0.1886380464,
-0.2722121179,
-0.3526139557,
-0.7337961197,
-0.3998986781,
0.497517854,
0.0943993703,
0.0218125228,
-0.2045207173,
0.467015326,
0.0729659647,
0.3568220735,
-0.4401886463,
-0.0891109109,
0.1387799233,
-0.5531495214,
-0.2789428532,
-0.2422230393,
-0.4642008543,
-0.3436116576,
0.444067508,
-0.176686123,
0.4695018232,
0.2724385858,
0.0069257924,
-0.33154881,
0.2626363337,
0.5516451597,
0.8469955921,
-0.1878335327,
0.1267158985,
0.2344699204,
-0.5068073273,
0.2388112247,
-0.05711817,
0.1070267931,
-0.3604736626,
0.4341927171,
0.5656710863,
-0.1207567453,
-0.8704915643,
0.4091870189,
-0.1399875134,
-0.1456027031,
-0.4255155027,
0.5365226269,
-0.2105689645,
0.3612499237,
0.4346255362,
-0.0867517665,
0.1707065552,
-0.4602590799,
0.0660614222,
0.5269830227,
-0.1186161563,
-0.3881388903,
0.3541865051,
0.1487880051,
-0.2096958905,
0.2793437243,
-0.3242969811,
-0.3432773352,
0.6746838689,
0.2294628918,
1.1062530279,
-0.3693007827,
-0.2919133008,
-0.0322856903,
0.4628257751,
-0.2610936165,
0.9167701006,
-0.0009720349,
-0.8958390951,
-0.3704023659,
-0.2916496992,
-0.4367416799,
0.3369609118,
-0.8991265297,
-0.0134144602,
-0.5661722422,
-0.5126104951,
-0.2655174434,
0.1449920088,
-0.8725755215,
0.5758102536,
0.0296650883,
0.6789844632,
-0.5901167393,
0.8076140881,
1.0867815018,
-0.0747187957,
-0.8833776116,
0.4513476789,
0.2564743459,
-0.8270310163,
0.5318543911,
0.0401348472,
-0.2941906452,
0.2728119493,
-0.4793895483,
-0.8870361447,
1.1253769398,
0.373013109,
-0.521887064,
-0.108384937,
-0.2394395918,
0.5435165167,
-0.393763423,
0.3391062319,
0.4560186267,
0.5600248575,
-0.2352993786,
-0.961755991,
0.1054956913,
-0.2369630784,
0.0794695318,
-0.0975176916,
-0.8690250516,
0.9239885807,
0.0469317101,
-0.1297919452,
0.1068627164,
0.6303184628,
0.4871018529,
0.108178474,
0.7472943664,
0.5958068967,
0.9772714972,
-0.0497006327,
1.1800529957,
-0.3410302997,
0.4084832966,
0.917294383,
-0.5294536948,
0.4970572889,
0.4432182014,
-0.418374449,
0.2207889557,
0.498523891,
-0.0391856879,
0.308044821,
0.4901693463,
0.0395374298,
-0.3360711336,
-0.1830198765,
-0.0990806669,
0.559034586,
0.3559994102,
-0.1081354171,
0.0050975895,
0.15503259,
0.0536669306,
0.1218335181,
-0.155677408,
0.3377406895,
-0.0574927442,
-0.7749439478,
0.4388138652,
-0.0281784218,
0.7577775121,
-0.5329880118,
0.1671855301,
-0.1070465222,
0.3031792343,
0.2774243355,
-0.8679032326,
0.1072315276,
0.1991291046,
-0.1662979424,
-0.2906517684,
0.4488939047,
-0.2647666633,
-0.4531702697,
0.2832151949,
0.8478426933,
0.202235058,
0.0968766436,
-0.5643677115,
0.0686948076,
-0.001963035,
-0.6206227541,
0.1095684469,
0.4753625393,
0.0393788442,
0.9287267327,
0.1991675943,
0.0066811456,
-0.0606213249,
-0.0933423564,
0.5926687121,
-0.9875090718,
-0.5369596481,
-1.0073857307,
0.2774914801,
0.1676377356,
-0.5997958183,
1.1705073118,
0.2283412814,
0.8656870127,
0.0783797055,
0.9073325396,
-0.0020868671,
0.6239978671,
-0.5429364443,
0.4919900596,
-0.6552509069,
0.2626627684,
-0.5474521518,
-0.8464244604,
-0.0292662494,
0.7759971023,
-0.4282722473,
0.4917505383,
0.9653005004,
0.460357219,
0.135376811,
0.5999403596,
0.2069147229,
0.2202613801,
0.3562441468,
0.7440871596,
0.9956544042,
-0.1726316214,
-0.0272461046,
-0.2589758337,
-0.2110236585,
0.0987171531,
-0.7002841234,
-1.1564562321,
-0.8247677088,
-0.3342368603,
-0.0604554527,
0.2438049912,
1.3506753445,
0.6872920394,
-0.5763052702,
-0.5592082143,
-0.1962919831,
-0.2412920296,
-0.3017038107,
-0.2436238229,
0.2404405922,
-0.2922270298,
-0.846750617,
0.483546108,
0.2068218291,
0.2212400436,
-0.5357706547,
0.2555858195,
0.0842885822,
0.2780248523,
0.4431752861,
-0.2831917405,
-0.991677165,
-0.4128223658,
0.0463082753,
-0.1781372428,
-0.1651954055,
0.9271627665,
-0.6999492049,
0.2953167856,
0.3804297149,
0.7556340694,
-0.1574791968,
-0.1179978028,
0.6525637507,
-0.2488199323,
-0.0702632964,
0.3963975012,
0.4525804818,
0.2002526671,
-0.3439666629,
0.4054972827,
0.282117635,
-0.3648660481,
-0.8306769729,
0.2967025042,
-0.9810407162,
-0.5456675291,
1.0269885063,
-0.1244489402,
-0.1628603488,
-0.030575892,
-0.0513962023,
0.1904284358,
-0.2129025161,
1.0342071056,
1.3392890692,
-0.3272149265,
-0.0900888592,
-0.6553745866,
0.3805671036,
0.9664280415,
-0.6149833798,
0.185171783,
0.5389298201,
0.2241073549,
0.3152163029,
0.6456282139,
0.1537858844,
-0.0734466463,
-0.3559344709,
0.2036057413,
0.0677503496,
-0.4385378361,
-0.599249959,
0.1691677719,
-0.0547759496,
-0.1683186591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15067v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15067v3 | Not All Metrics Are Guilty: Improving NLG Evaluation by Diversifying References | 2023-05-24T11:53:29 | 2024-05-25T03:39:55 | Tianyi Tang, Hongyuan Lu, Yuchen Eleanor Jiang, Haoyang Huang, Dongdong Zhang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Tom Kocmi, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most research about natural language generation (NLG) relies on evaluation
benchmarks with limited references for a sample, which may result in poor
correlations with human judgements. The underlying reason is that one semantic
meaning can actually be expressed in different forms, and the evaluation with a
single or few references may not accurately reflect the quality of the model's
hypotheses. To address this issue, this paper presents a simple and effective
method, named Div-Ref, to enhance existing evaluation benchmarks by enriching
the number of references. We leverage large language models (LLMs) to diversify
the expression of a single reference into multiple high-quality ones to cover
the semantic space of the reference sentence as much as possible. We conduct
comprehensive experiments to empirically demonstrate that diversifying the
expression of reference can significantly enhance the correlation between
automatic evaluation and human evaluation. This idea is compatible with recent
LLM-based evaluation which can similarly derive advantages from incorporating
multiple references. We strongly encourage future generation benchmarks to
include more references, even if they are generated by LLMs, which is once for
all. We release all the code and data at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/Div-Ref to
facilitate research. | [
-0.4586623609,
-0.3228944838,
0.3455736637,
0.4028250277,
-0.4454807937,
0.1842309237,
-0.3933878839,
-0.3881014287,
-0.124777399,
0.0810647532,
-0.5232083797,
-0.4732177258,
-0.5701171756,
0.3728049695,
-0.4589045048,
1.1876450777,
0.3245565891,
0.1793852746,
-0.5552331209,
-0.3920192719,
-0.4533195496,
-0.0220073815,
-0.2831003964,
-0.4486170113,
0.5477505922,
0.2322127074,
0.7064442039,
0.5074306726,
0.9064492583,
0.2863427401,
-0.0862399936,
0.390922755,
-0.6592559814,
-0.0422362797,
-0.3457872868,
-0.3998728693,
-0.316328764,
0.0479433015,
0.7354646325,
0.8883443475,
-0.2424280792,
0.3168101907,
0.0293054525,
0.9200274348,
-0.8693199158,
-0.025068149,
-0.7934546471,
-0.1070764437,
-0.206163168,
-0.0322183222,
-0.3357667327,
-0.5769905448,
0.3773112595,
-0.5799784064,
0.2949708998,
0.0466365144,
0.7966763973,
0.7296884656,
-0.3348625898,
-0.1170237586,
-0.7307127118,
1.1834189892,
-0.8968117833,
0.2525541186,
0.1040950418,
0.3622174561,
-0.0163567048,
-0.7123697996,
-0.5066933632,
-0.3256318569,
-0.1698722839,
0.2030947059,
-0.4808589816,
-0.281234175,
0.1988277882,
0.5492529869,
-0.4006319642,
-0.0401360095,
-0.355554074,
-0.1097653657,
0.8308364749,
0.2681056261,
0.1222648323,
-0.2623243928,
-0.4773944318,
-0.2466452271,
-0.6287240982,
-0.2032459527,
0.5056537986,
0.3671407104,
0.120841682,
0.3121721745,
-0.2549534142,
0.7694478035,
-0.0150871379,
-0.162673831,
0.6121152639,
-0.8176823258,
-0.065531224,
-0.0895411298,
0.9374672771,
0.6136527658,
0.2813006938,
-0.4570735395,
0.1642779708,
0.304867506,
0.6285491586,
-0.8166393042,
-0.0462488346,
-0.1494213492,
-0.3682633042,
-0.3062714338,
0.3510332406,
-0.9447330236,
-0.4250692427,
-0.3419876397,
0.1628922522,
-0.3267943561,
-0.1752524674,
0.4858626127,
-0.3855618834,
0.1556755304,
0.2367970496,
-0.5815033317,
0.473382771,
0.6089346409,
0.4823818207,
-0.3238388002,
-0.3220733106,
-0.8340233564,
-0.0576086454,
-0.2052260637,
0.7489743829,
-0.5410636663,
-0.4257642627,
0.1162479892,
-0.3900172114,
0.4850199223,
-0.8526659012,
0.8696796894,
-0.3117240667,
0.4243947864,
-0.4357199371,
-0.3338585794,
0.0618371964,
0.1035544723,
-0.7787806392,
1.2488086224,
0.1009464562,
-0.8315322995,
0.7773523927,
-0.5061976314,
-0.4764070511,
0.2315301746,
-0.2427176535,
-0.6005898714,
0.4000855684,
0.2737526,
0.2411420494,
-0.8000757694,
0.4140953124,
-0.3598431647,
-0.1779815108,
0.1891059875,
-0.227480948,
0.4213200212,
0.226469487,
-0.1610714495,
-0.1607028991,
-1.0068395138,
0.0545841865,
-0.0090522207,
-0.4279639423,
-0.5478199124,
-0.0002657495,
-0.2698216736,
0.033202745,
0.1875135154,
-0.4669682384,
0.0602135025,
-0.3825030029,
-0.016026739,
0.3867538571,
-0.1253102124,
0.5868185759,
-0.4332945347,
0.4484375119,
0.0024057776,
0.0168876722,
0.0350021198,
-0.4315090775,
-0.8153832555,
-0.1314188242,
0.4347155988,
0.1085345373,
-0.5830598474,
0.7497985959,
-0.5309070349,
-0.5063050389,
-0.7961589694,
0.5252835751,
0.2653717697,
0.4706344604,
0.4378609359,
-0.6237776279,
-0.6229627728,
-0.9338650703,
-0.4050756395,
-0.280921042,
-0.2497766763,
0.2449735403,
0.2601739764,
-0.2857395113,
1.2628031969,
-0.5602562428,
-0.1627759039,
-0.073591955,
0.3343835771,
0.2337051034,
0.0651428401,
0.6303227544,
-0.5682220459,
-0.5054920316,
-0.1439137757,
-0.5782104731,
-0.4349199533,
-0.2205737382,
-0.2749408185,
-0.582285881,
0.3231666088,
-0.2650253773,
0.2237721682,
0.4328170121,
-0.1714936495,
0.4947294295,
-0.0909726396,
-0.1896193922,
-0.8232600093,
-0.0211063959,
0.2576533556,
-0.2737541199,
-0.3945887089,
-0.0088842018,
0.0932525173,
0.3855597973,
-0.250619173,
0.4290246367,
-0.3814802766,
0.1583589315,
-0.3094121516,
0.4782855511,
0.3602392673,
0.0743759945,
-0.4700881541,
0.6112049222,
0.5291959643,
-0.5209672451,
0.4635828733,
0.2361803055,
-0.6222465634,
0.5170155764,
-0.7791877389,
0.0328173712,
-0.3695528507,
0.3032110929,
-0.9083037972,
0.0828259811,
-0.1469415277,
-0.271193862,
0.2469146401,
0.1293856353,
-0.6406847835,
-0.3801457882,
-0.4550299346,
0.2704142332,
0.5813600421,
-0.7216553688,
0.3321144879,
0.3973940313,
-0.000136648,
-0.8382291198,
-0.8295502067,
0.0045228414,
-0.5321053863,
-0.6510115862,
0.5956414938,
-0.2384702116,
-0.4267966449,
-0.0410729609,
-0.3161272109,
0.2038478255,
0.0176998656,
-0.1282360703,
0.2725119889,
-0.1677826643,
0.4897094667,
-0.2416778505,
-0.119359687,
0.0109352944,
-0.2558066249,
0.3147162795,
-0.4731807709,
-0.3657364547,
0.0126146106,
0.1579728276,
0.3471865058,
-0.4207755625,
0.4035666883,
0.8876788616,
-0.1430641562,
-0.5709004998,
-0.739897728,
-0.0577852577,
-0.4770188034,
0.3495871127,
0.0055044689,
-0.777694881,
0.2944637537,
-0.363232851,
0.0911415443,
0.4285194278,
0.5481315255,
0.1252825558,
0.5290668607,
0.6132644415,
-0.124644503,
0.399826467,
-0.0973567665,
0.4647883773,
-0.9403558373,
-0.0211930294,
-0.4754102826,
-0.4159446657,
-0.7036004066,
-0.7368060946,
0.1650145203,
0.4112092853,
0.1837988198,
0.3260365427,
-0.6755766869,
0.5763899088,
0.2719271183,
-0.2158513814,
0.4613072574,
-0.0318049602,
-0.2090864182,
-0.1664450467,
-0.6288622022,
-0.5780363083,
1.2749757767,
0.4053228498,
1.0062112808,
0.311645627,
0.9483627081,
0.087939322,
0.6092103124,
-0.7482216954,
0.4210888445,
-0.4133941531,
-0.5384440422,
-0.1949200928,
-0.6298174858,
-1.0237238407,
0.3806248903,
-0.1857647598,
-0.640527606,
0.1703723222,
-0.1414328218,
-0.5810160637,
-0.1389027983,
-0.6289263368,
0.5744851828,
-0.2248020172,
-0.7217221856,
-0.2337099463,
-0.3582488894,
0.3522400558,
-0.1772112399,
0.2669279575,
-0.3442823291,
-0.0103378585,
0.6477352381,
-0.489512831,
0.6511788964,
0.1462211311,
-0.1690627635,
0.6021354795,
-0.3066544533,
0.4567164183,
0.3550052345,
-0.2192742229,
0.0290514342,
-0.3833962083,
-0.1751198769,
-0.7468626499,
0.8271512985,
-0.6860533357,
-0.452794522,
-0.3214528859,
-0.5217229128,
-0.3763043582,
-0.0253226813,
-0.0313767418,
0.1987663358,
-0.3492244184,
0.5343097448,
0.4440789521,
-0.3211683929,
0.4464209378,
0.4828707278,
-0.1791111678,
-0.4451949,
0.6921437383,
-0.323320955,
0.2835065722,
0.2756253183,
0.6555107236,
-0.4833851457,
-0.4647190571,
-0.2806623578,
0.3310946226,
-0.8024340868,
-0.3902763426,
-0.4667654634,
0.1774997711,
-0.3626450896,
0.1539042145,
-0.4293515086,
-0.3682455122,
0.0055987737,
-0.1892865449,
0.3908118606,
0.6320829988,
-0.1420314461,
0.2964267433,
-0.745400846,
0.3443244398,
0.6049202681,
0.532833457,
0.0405783802,
-0.485645622,
-0.1904919893,
-0.1347468942,
-0.426115185,
-0.5613713264,
0.2391605377,
0.1759797931,
0.8709700108,
0.3587709367,
0.0475986712,
0.9371368289,
-0.7730552554,
0.6640725136,
0.5878597498,
-0.8795341849,
0.3981586993,
-0.2609087527,
0.6233372092,
1.0531811714,
0.1927274168,
-0.4876413345,
-0.3246626854,
-0.5441623926,
-1.0679951906,
0.4524167478,
0.2655005753,
0.2091115713,
-0.1230104938,
0.0541236103,
0.2907242477,
0.2625810504,
-0.9944607019,
-0.2871757448,
-0.1223583668,
-0.1002411991,
-0.0173341949,
0.0060911099,
-0.3163281083,
-0.2840332985,
0.464542836,
-0.1215057969,
-0.1604798138,
0.0136024607,
0.0101800403,
-0.0230324678,
0.3273124099,
0.2407614738,
0.7357198,
-0.1638458073,
0.1376333535,
0.3682940006,
-0.2379709184,
-0.0309147164,
0.0964600891,
0.1378779709,
0.4019491673,
0.4129705429,
0.6565395594,
0.088746503,
-0.6376127601,
0.5700930357,
-0.2643744946,
-0.1258274913,
-0.1421179175,
0.0392809436,
0.2814462185,
-0.0170045886,
0.3499239683,
0.0710508823,
0.1848205328,
-0.4583340883,
0.4385977983,
0.3878766596,
-0.249334842,
-0.0234665982,
0.5101338625,
0.4831159115,
-0.131404236,
0.5026640892,
-0.4578714669,
-0.0952018946,
0.4587855041,
0.3772570789,
1.0660867691,
0.0544196405,
0.186028704,
0.6494506598,
0.32932657,
-0.1709546894,
-0.0885202661,
-0.0288597457,
-0.7795911431,
-0.6774209738,
-0.9868682623,
-0.1956351548,
0.1990040094,
-0.6998999715,
0.4819447696,
-0.2763495147,
-0.3148113787,
0.2233747989,
-0.1163981333,
-1.0877223015,
0.2162436247,
0.4361583591,
0.6490851045,
-0.7024003267,
0.7195325494,
0.5363430977,
-0.4835697711,
-0.4626246095,
0.2471715361,
-0.1060554013,
-0.5124925971,
0.8061224818,
0.1525970697,
-0.2760202885,
-0.3328563273,
-0.2798298895,
-0.9743320346,
0.9954819679,
0.2087785453,
-0.784681499,
0.0788823888,
0.2672327757,
0.8471180201,
-0.3885427415,
0.3552674055,
0.6809711456,
0.5545334816,
-0.0694151372,
-0.938605845,
-0.0016431523,
-0.2923390865,
0.1503286064,
0.1598076671,
-0.6136152744,
0.4043862522,
-0.2379117906,
-0.3787866533,
-0.1143321097,
0.5285685658,
0.2622482777,
0.0463123322,
0.7038143277,
0.7445542216,
0.8165847659,
-0.1503539979,
1.1631879807,
-0.2252201587,
0.4241302311,
1.3675700426,
-0.3090307713,
0.6456030607,
0.6581493616,
-0.4718669951,
0.6129291654,
0.0995075703,
-0.3867205381,
0.710943222,
0.7801424265,
-0.4162932038,
-0.2267400026,
-0.2586596012,
-0.1697636545,
0.5817732811,
0.1576268226,
-0.3376691341,
-0.5795083046,
-0.3528382778,
-0.3022605777,
0.435134083,
0.1419308782,
0.7866860628,
0.1611698419,
-0.7825564146,
0.5346646905,
-0.0223631151,
0.9573140144,
-0.7171120644,
0.1183849499,
-0.1035497263,
0.2216558605,
-0.2407266349,
-0.5066245794,
0.3965349793,
0.2400175333,
-0.1062591225,
-0.3685216308,
0.5987347364,
-0.3169348538,
-0.639215529,
0.5948803425,
0.6119930148,
0.0022663479,
0.2910473347,
-0.5274948478,
-0.0224809516,
0.0668656304,
0.0245054401,
0.1629453301,
0.626082778,
0.1278112084,
0.4508445263,
0.6728678346,
0.059060961,
0.1222050861,
0.6545186043,
0.9083955288,
-0.5484365821,
-0.2087144107,
-1.1040689945,
0.8554974794,
-0.4828646183,
-0.5742078424,
0.8242135644,
0.6043354273,
1.0870550871,
0.0916447863,
1.0032758713,
0.0865678638,
0.4051732719,
-0.166724503,
0.4196263552,
-0.5755901337,
0.4145608842,
-0.5427199006,
-1.0598375797,
-0.3738587201,
0.7476649284,
-0.4141937792,
0.0646791086,
0.8133196235,
0.6109659076,
-0.0536385849,
-0.142625019,
0.2801086903,
-0.1415935606,
0.4024937153,
0.4467266202,
1.1609185934,
-0.5526377559,
0.8078320026,
-0.2042890638,
-0.2182790488,
-0.1074338257,
-1.2567975521,
-0.8385915756,
-0.2435353845,
-0.6106901765,
-0.1014956608,
-0.3202424645,
0.6035118103,
0.6985476017,
-0.5308517814,
-0.2886939347,
-0.1988772154,
-0.1168261841,
-0.1861332506,
-0.2043261528,
-0.0309818909,
-0.6233730316,
-0.9335499406,
0.4953812957,
0.384495914,
-0.2770425081,
-0.4625195265,
-0.0785798803,
-0.1461415291,
0.0800291672,
0.5110046268,
-0.2339356989,
-0.7345369458,
-0.3144600391,
-0.141667217,
-0.0981578156,
0.1919862777,
0.8113712072,
-0.8054352999,
0.6677750945,
0.6711199284,
0.9166480899,
0.4476893842,
0.1422782987,
0.7558882236,
-1.0314483643,
-0.0030173343,
0.4083104432,
0.4539188445,
0.6485110521,
-0.1391529292,
0.7437215447,
-0.0408517607,
-0.4227418303,
-0.749407053,
0.3244532943,
-0.993152976,
-0.1983573288,
1.31336689,
0.0090076746,
0.1372903883,
0.169244051,
0.0705111846,
0.1235512123,
-0.343144536,
1.0566660166,
1.0283721685,
-0.0236869901,
0.2767367661,
-0.5380405188,
0.4681393206,
0.7590200901,
-0.9278487563,
0.1349070519,
0.4291703701,
0.222576201,
0.6684858203,
0.2518296838,
-0.3334720731,
0.2414432913,
0.0824501961,
0.085492067,
0.2499679625,
-0.1150697172,
-0.2964672744,
-0.1302462816,
0.1322738975,
-0.2038189322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15066v2 | GPT4Graph: Can Large Language Models Understand Graph Structured Data ? An Empirical Evaluation and Benchmarking | 2023-05-24T11:53:19 | 2023-07-11T15:08:00 | Jiayan Guo, Lun Du, Hengyu Liu, Mengyu Zhou, Xinyi He, Shi Han | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models~(LLM) like ChatGPT have become indispensable to
artificial general intelligence~(AGI), demonstrating excellent performance in
various natural language processing tasks. In the real world, graph data is
ubiquitous and an essential part of AGI and prevails in domains like social
network analysis, bioinformatics and recommender systems. The training corpus
of large language models often includes some algorithmic components, which
allows them to achieve certain effects on some graph data-related problems.
However, there is still little research on their performance on a broader range
of graph-structured data. In this study, we conduct an extensive investigation
to assess the proficiency of LLMs in comprehending graph data, employing a
diverse range of structural and semantic-related tasks. Our analysis
encompasses 10 distinct tasks that evaluate the LLMs' capabilities in graph
understanding. Through our study, we not only uncover the current limitations
of language models in comprehending graph structures and performing associated
reasoning tasks but also emphasize the necessity for further advancements and
novel approaches to enhance their graph processing capabilities. Our findings
contribute valuable insights towards bridging the gap between language models
and graph understanding, paving the way for more effective graph mining and
knowledge extraction. | [
-0.1993819177,
-1.1713963747,
0.8141250014,
0.0067590936,
-0.0437759683,
0.390071243,
-0.227842778,
-0.660025835,
-0.3599443734,
0.3560042679,
-0.3808674514,
-0.9477559328,
-0.7612503767,
0.1825669557,
-0.4267304242,
0.8344923854,
-0.2303823531,
0.0424938239,
-0.2022444904,
-0.0552680828,
-0.3418157995,
-0.5914508104,
-0.6886059642,
-0.5487203002,
0.3088537157,
0.0049541849,
0.6433876753,
0.628857255,
0.2771550715,
0.3614428341,
-0.2217751741,
0.2061087042,
-0.9580154419,
-0.1369174719,
0.0421841033,
-0.3303011358,
-0.5866584182,
0.0865455046,
1.0093274117,
1.0881489515,
0.1662970334,
-0.0222552139,
0.2268279493,
0.5097789764,
-0.0899082348,
0.9389150739,
-0.8009339571,
-0.0735461637,
-0.1590037048,
0.1075912416,
-0.5918412805,
-0.187740922,
-0.0222768467,
-0.6101918817,
0.2156663239,
0.2479498535,
0.9257380366,
-0.0412944853,
-0.6749054193,
-0.3034507632,
-0.5592571497,
0.3879294693,
-0.5619494319,
0.6000213027,
0.3266715705,
0.3661569357,
-0.3913336098,
-1.0643687248,
-0.5032449961,
-0.2183167338,
-0.1383037269,
-0.0353794023,
-0.3477213979,
0.2451485991,
0.4044030905,
0.4341721833,
-0.7083643675,
0.3212554455,
-0.285019815,
-0.3484288454,
0.4701891541,
0.1169523001,
0.512337923,
-0.2305704355,
-0.0171571467,
-0.1065653339,
-0.8339918852,
-0.0032009217,
0.5039226413,
0.3997014165,
-0.1515572816,
0.5670949817,
-0.3976313174,
0.8939658999,
-0.5327289104,
0.0705716535,
0.4057177305,
-0.5777090192,
-0.2493465394,
-0.3760727942,
0.8334619403,
0.1158747748,
0.8223784566,
-0.5877569318,
-0.0191682931,
0.0446522124,
-0.0970407575,
-0.8275179267,
-0.4936472774,
-0.0096733393,
-0.2129839212,
0.0130469622,
-0.1905459315,
-0.4053576291,
-0.2627924979,
-0.1938202083,
-0.0324806198,
-0.6199953556,
-0.1392451376,
0.1202829257,
-0.1614748985,
0.3805132806,
0.1706764549,
-0.7949807644,
0.4324587584,
0.987038672,
1.037037611,
-0.1006824896,
-0.371833384,
-0.3407011032,
0.1427365988,
-0.2927934229,
0.8308107853,
-0.7488188148,
-0.3632138669,
-0.1124630645,
0.0887790248,
-0.646186471,
-0.3171862066,
0.5856178403,
-0.719337821,
-0.1498880237,
-0.1732327938,
-0.8149210811,
-0.3765530884,
0.5223942995,
-0.626940608,
0.8457205892,
0.2406256348,
-0.812941432,
0.2300671786,
-0.4484066367,
-0.4172416031,
0.2260162681,
-0.3093140125,
-0.2823985517,
-0.2018176615,
0.4023082256,
0.5759077668,
-0.1124109924,
0.3338045776,
-0.6138307452,
-0.349863261,
0.1961359978,
-0.3872513473,
0.5350150466,
0.0496049188,
0.0315309577,
0.1777945608,
-0.6280838847,
0.2465366423,
0.3216036856,
-0.2256187648,
0.0442788973,
0.0669440851,
-0.1941774189,
0.0653955489,
0.1505246162,
-0.4559033811,
0.2556610405,
-0.4359018207,
0.9758901,
0.756426394,
-0.0738943219,
0.1328500509,
0.0583819374,
0.422544241,
-0.4488939941,
-0.1946844906,
-0.1384154856,
-0.5514364243,
-0.3209606409,
-0.2709191144,
0.4147899151,
0.4782622457,
-0.6323591471,
0.0213307925,
-0.7494419217,
-0.346578896,
-0.2311000973,
0.2548207641,
0.3363899589,
0.6112469435,
0.2005388886,
-0.1754196882,
-0.3181443512,
-0.7718042731,
-0.0735795051,
-0.2493474185,
-0.1158718914,
0.7534883618,
0.5381768346,
-0.44865188,
0.7614279985,
-0.5539403558,
0.055846218,
-0.5414829254,
0.0543990396,
0.3474754095,
-0.048121281,
0.465631187,
-0.4549521208,
-0.4021298289,
0.164374128,
-0.9410927296,
-0.1542245448,
0.4088544846,
-0.0547389761,
-0.1089487672,
0.6474624872,
-0.6155732274,
0.1921091676,
0.7584311366,
-0.368427068,
0.484790206,
-0.2329093516,
0.0105447602,
-0.6052910686,
0.0923411772,
-0.0774917752,
-0.5143212676,
-0.6945381165,
0.0415189825,
-0.0777807981,
-0.1517920792,
-0.0258277096,
0.4819121957,
-0.5738551021,
-0.4685297608,
-0.1397499442,
0.4666355848,
-0.0439881124,
0.4630146027,
-0.1193865091,
0.8037790656,
0.58294487,
-0.3519197404,
0.296194315,
0.4145059586,
-0.4090652168,
0.1047212854,
-0.9223819971,
0.4740096033,
-0.0595051236,
0.3757182062,
-1.4880895615,
-0.3729654551,
0.2459443659,
-0.4089231491,
0.2759482861,
-0.4448535442,
-0.7251679897,
-0.4014529884,
0.1129084602,
0.3278909922,
0.3162899315,
-0.3064664602,
0.4990510345,
0.5597528815,
-0.250426501,
-0.3197390735,
-0.2490261346,
0.2545813918,
-0.1063761935,
-0.9073093534,
0.131677717,
0.0435745604,
-0.2453690767,
0.0411411859,
0.0387086459,
-0.0581281185,
0.1666960716,
0.2884503603,
0.1533678472,
-0.1782471538,
0.0915701166,
-0.3734336495,
-0.1988413632,
0.127147615,
-0.2586655915,
0.9307194948,
-0.3547377884,
-0.4593233466,
-0.1539027393,
-0.1092252433,
0.2699229717,
-0.281257391,
0.6030596495,
0.5378817916,
-0.1652123928,
-0.0762908682,
-0.237353757,
0.1563163251,
-0.4273741543,
0.6955584288,
-0.5405260324,
-1.1341838837,
0.7007707953,
-0.3134464622,
-0.1784226298,
0.4970622063,
0.4924977422,
0.0967586711,
1.2016553879,
0.4085441232,
-0.5478754044,
0.3138471842,
-0.4541391432,
0.355904907,
-0.7412638664,
-0.1310549825,
-0.6047028303,
-0.076725252,
-0.6830614209,
-0.3615255356,
0.23858051,
-0.0553454719,
-0.2975234985,
0.0178458281,
-0.2230850309,
0.5007067323,
0.0353038348,
0.1252992451,
0.4300440252,
-0.0180892348,
-0.0293340795,
0.3991581202,
-0.5493658185,
-0.578129828,
1.1319023371,
0.4703636467,
0.4759472013,
-0.151942566,
0.2461879551,
0.1663520932,
0.2497544289,
-0.7621102929,
0.6487796307,
-0.1005121842,
-0.2245648652,
-0.4487111866,
-0.6323880553,
-1.2087503672,
0.2908815444,
0.0868610516,
-0.9460471869,
-0.3665808737,
0.041321598,
0.2721946836,
0.2023880482,
-0.8538973927,
1.1265026331,
-0.0740448534,
-0.0417726003,
-0.2091155946,
-0.4772842228,
0.3406248391,
0.0595876351,
0.5353884697,
-0.3886341453,
0.2463975698,
0.7071934342,
-0.1851041764,
0.8136504292,
-0.1839893758,
-0.0076024444,
0.1861083359,
-0.0030287439,
0.7344337702,
-0.0657440051,
-0.2243574709,
0.4515159726,
-0.1336355507,
-0.4228476882,
-0.5567569733,
0.5579090714,
-0.8463366628,
-0.5638907552,
-0.0930588096,
-0.7572301626,
-0.4375155866,
0.2918665707,
0.0304406583,
0.4843466282,
-0.3220896721,
0.0530353263,
0.3583191335,
0.0592905954,
0.1386193186,
0.2412643731,
-0.2973653078,
-0.1408072561,
0.6779718399,
0.1286891103,
0.2893983126,
0.082472153,
0.0269228537,
-0.4367730618,
-1.1378842592,
-0.3603267074,
0.5160189867,
-0.9217124581,
0.1535504013,
-0.8077664971,
-0.3610832691,
-0.462307632,
0.2817351818,
0.0539839007,
-0.1912726909,
0.0514611676,
-0.4050489366,
0.3186657429,
1.0053111315,
0.4732437432,
0.3982523382,
-0.6153150201,
0.2283047289,
0.100466527,
0.4814325869,
-0.040265277,
-0.4264285862,
-0.142620638,
0.0387635306,
0.0258151218,
-0.808547914,
0.2774817646,
0.2467220575,
0.8319985867,
0.3216802776,
-0.3878071606,
0.6493294835,
-0.7000491619,
0.5790194273,
-0.4247677624,
-0.9167336822,
0.1841522753,
-0.5885208249,
0.0795207322,
0.3162189722,
0.3516182005,
-0.4682767987,
-0.3330254257,
-0.5312789679,
-0.8464871049,
0.5362923741,
0.3457737863,
0.1188159958,
0.0563559197,
0.5357179046,
-0.1079251543,
0.1953811347,
-0.8007667661,
0.1026390344,
-0.1102801114,
-0.1711523235,
-0.4455417693,
-0.1831348836,
-0.0056676795,
-0.1649321169,
0.3792076111,
-0.4015108943,
0.2051196992,
-0.17135337,
-0.2884598374,
0.2429101318,
0.2373751849,
0.1331689209,
0.9600812197,
-0.0779395998,
0.2068641037,
0.2972098887,
-0.421607554,
-0.1949177831,
0.2727566659,
0.1582002789,
-0.3140071034,
0.8370821476,
0.9154444337,
0.1735380739,
-0.643974483,
0.3524370492,
-0.0564602166,
-0.1278460771,
-0.1150953397,
0.1234564111,
0.2696226537,
0.1349183023,
0.0992193595,
-0.5474594235,
0.1987794489,
-0.6641309857,
0.1396153122,
0.6397140622,
-0.1231987327,
-0.5218280554,
0.5004286766,
-0.1509223133,
-0.0812153444,
1.0011143684,
-0.1835096031,
-0.6594644785,
0.5403396487,
0.6813521385,
0.4699783623,
0.0740431473,
0.1022734046,
0.2084380388,
0.2045514137,
0.1431394666,
0.0164448377,
0.06196668,
-1.0484850407,
-0.701248765,
-0.4757922292,
-0.4259211719,
0.0637681261,
-0.2440540344,
-0.0758474693,
-0.2319366932,
-0.0453949757,
0.2390128821,
0.0748269036,
-0.8372703195,
0.0551255345,
0.0275352653,
0.6632547379,
-1.0125871897,
0.818772614,
0.4403502345,
-0.1312151104,
-1.0356528759,
-0.2282873839,
-0.030729752,
-1.3112344742,
0.6793020368,
0.2558963895,
-0.1650477052,
0.1916585267,
-0.5591979027,
-0.652156055,
0.9281516075,
0.4052841961,
-0.2917694449,
-0.2282486856,
0.375010103,
0.7356289029,
-0.2827710509,
0.4733056128,
0.8586315513,
0.5687003136,
0.2568907738,
-0.8620126843,
0.0162984915,
-0.4217004478,
-0.137326315,
0.142948553,
-0.4678111374,
0.9169043303,
0.0876098573,
-0.3983311057,
-0.2465231866,
0.4862592518,
0.2454727888,
0.3443311453,
0.5227991343,
0.4150192142,
1.0405670404,
-0.240737021,
1.3915394545,
-0.4825422466,
0.3442985713,
0.8889751434,
-0.4741018414,
0.603734076,
-0.0926433131,
-0.4666834176,
0.5414149165,
0.8129454851,
0.006568525,
0.12040364,
0.3216143847,
0.0243328307,
-0.241173774,
-0.0264716744,
-0.1760564446,
0.6308496594,
0.5107885599,
-0.2019947022,
-0.3390720189,
-0.2674658597,
0.1533441991,
-0.071853213,
-0.2700105906,
0.851811707,
0.0636794344,
-0.4530225098,
0.5286592841,
-0.0611712746,
0.0516302772,
-0.7414997816,
-0.0689327717,
0.0112541895,
0.0863730013,
-0.1248147562,
-0.9223744273,
0.2544617653,
0.0007590434,
0.1220556423,
-0.042495992,
0.8334674835,
-0.1044895798,
-0.3557152152,
0.4471330941,
0.6850563884,
0.3629630804,
-0.1268997788,
-0.5402722955,
0.2491111904,
-0.0370990001,
-0.2220560014,
0.2888971269,
0.6457585692,
-0.1525929421,
0.8444888592,
0.6390489936,
0.1529427618,
-0.0608003475,
0.3365713954,
1.0568603277,
-0.564718008,
-0.4941738546,
-1.0610889196,
0.0464725085,
-0.2210132331,
0.1711055785,
1.0648657084,
0.6606263518,
0.7831431031,
0.3116742074,
0.9079016447,
0.2049482018,
0.3654649556,
-0.6900097132,
0.447560221,
-0.0024876399,
0.1034160405,
-0.3763158023,
-0.7436623573,
-0.237722978,
0.44941172,
-0.855066061,
0.2769264281,
0.5939669013,
0.6315072775,
0.0202237926,
0.1229869947,
0.1638365388,
0.4695757627,
0.6508535147,
0.5668919683,
0.7949452996,
-0.0203016698,
0.6256175041,
0.3211664855,
-0.0863704756,
0.1254621744,
-0.736397922,
-1.1076477766,
-0.3994083405,
-0.0432977453,
-0.2094139457,
0.1003659442,
0.3340331316,
0.6010817885,
-0.6066731811,
-0.1607739031,
-0.2327477783,
0.2871286273,
0.0580316857,
-0.1939564049,
0.6996974945,
-0.3086702526,
-0.819447875,
0.5375266075,
0.291570574,
0.0724054575,
0.0112292897,
-0.0039639492,
0.0146346157,
-0.1145565286,
0.6473578811,
0.1694085002,
-0.4875754714,
-0.5759046674,
-0.0432505868,
0.0608808361,
0.294876039,
0.8312458992,
-0.685739994,
0.2888824642,
0.6181907654,
0.6021986604,
0.7934661508,
0.2298801243,
0.4830721915,
-0.5905947089,
0.0193523988,
-0.1559377909,
0.6640436649,
0.4393431544,
-0.2268442065,
0.6788116097,
0.3291999698,
-0.7671018839,
-0.7955226302,
0.3002686203,
-0.925814569,
-0.2233478725,
1.1231149435,
-0.3472040594,
-0.1965297461,
-0.382263869,
-0.1750756651,
0.4157465994,
-0.087495029,
0.4840777218,
0.8353539109,
-0.3501978517,
-0.0929916948,
-0.8818639517,
0.1965549439,
-0.1222791374,
-0.9737731218,
0.3447378576,
0.6548436284,
0.4403190017,
-0.2686139345,
0.8872567415,
-0.038573388,
-0.2531992495,
-0.0155762956,
-0.3132210672,
-0.3520292342,
-0.1469209492,
-0.1948254555,
0.3854833245,
0.2329511344,
0.1693027169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15065v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15065v2 | Inference-Time Policy Adapters (IPA): Tailoring Extreme-Scale LMs without Fine-tuning | 2023-05-24T11:52:55 | 2023-12-06T09:00:19 | Ximing Lu, Faeze Brahman, Peter West, Jaehun Jang, Khyathi Chandu, Abhilasha Ravichander, Lianhui Qin, Prithviraj Ammanabrolu, Liwei Jiang, Sahana Ramnath, Nouha Dziri, Jillian Fisher, Bill Yuchen Lin, Skyler Hallinan, Xiang Ren, Sean Welleck, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | While extreme-scale language models have demonstrated exceptional performance
on a variety of language tasks, the degree of control over these language
models through pure prompting can often be limited. Directly fine-tuning such
language models can be effective for tailoring them, but it can be either
extremely costly (e.g., GPT-3) or not even feasible for the broader community
(e.g., GPT-4).
We propose Inference-time Policy Adapters (IPA), which efficiently tailors a
language model such as GPT-3 without fine-tuning it. IPA guides a large base
model during decoding time through a lightweight policy adapter trained to
optimize an arbitrary user objective with reinforcement learning.
On five challenging text generation tasks, such as toxicity reduction and
lexically constrained generation, IPA consistently brings significant
improvements over off-the-shelf language models. It outperforms competitive
baseline methods, sometimes even including expensive fine-tuning. In
particular, tailoring GPT-2 with IPA can outperform GPT-3, while tailoring
GPT-3 with IPA brings a major performance boost over GPT-3 (and sometimes even
over GPT-4). Our promising results highlight the potential of IPA as a
lightweight alternative to tailoring extreme-scale language models. | [
-0.1578915715,
-0.6303172112,
0.6868385673,
0.5683435202,
0.0398568101,
-0.1123403534,
-0.3098429143,
-0.3564958274,
-0.1119991541,
0.4675919116,
-0.4615312815,
-0.0688666403,
-0.242468223,
0.0554236583,
0.1842067689,
1.132573843,
-0.0512507595,
-0.2947433293,
0.5525822043,
-0.0482540242,
-0.2487749159,
-0.0061464738,
-1.0389469862,
-0.4658245444,
0.3484094143,
0.3131399453,
0.8928835988,
0.7725068927,
-0.1090441942,
0.2244328409,
-0.1476466358,
0.2384534776,
-0.2902123332,
-0.1495050341,
-0.6724154353,
-0.516946435,
-0.5771904588,
-0.1416792572,
0.6682219505,
0.4560445547,
-0.2609522641,
-0.024759382,
0.0843713805,
0.633262217,
-0.9069555998,
0.0437408946,
-0.9010846019,
-0.0234603379,
0.2105693072,
-0.0539049916,
-0.6314590573,
-0.1790326685,
0.0676106513,
-0.7802743912,
-0.0124907382,
0.3420739472,
0.952929616,
0.294112891,
-0.204381898,
-0.1298909187,
-0.9881772399,
0.8895487785,
-0.9565098882,
0.1218899116,
0.1924677193,
0.3753026426,
-0.2570581138,
-0.6469691992,
-0.8304697275,
-0.1246573254,
0.1815285087,
0.097911939,
-0.3991623521,
0.5523763895,
0.1869619489,
0.1123003736,
-0.4619423747,
0.5486801863,
0.0980831385,
-0.0338262543,
0.3847745359,
0.2414381802,
0.147383213,
0.130169183,
-0.1163836271,
-0.1459167004,
-0.7059130669,
0.0335529,
0.3666143417,
0.3465235233,
-0.0069296276,
0.3353859782,
-0.1559976786,
0.7429612875,
0.0333125293,
-0.1545799375,
0.0233345665,
-0.0993635803,
-0.2723736167,
0.0148293218,
0.9063460827,
0.3518114388,
0.2615087032,
-0.0427692123,
-0.5021619797,
0.0182319302,
0.0373663083,
-0.8872042894,
-0.1386360973,
0.1517480016,
-0.3847774267,
-0.2382564098,
-0.5467083454,
-0.6727608442,
-0.3108100891,
-0.0235364363,
0.4811223447,
-0.3384701014,
-0.2046799213,
0.2334501743,
-0.3476731181,
0.2637046576,
0.1872391552,
-1.1806526184,
0.2509855032,
0.3986703157,
1.0871239901,
-0.0988551229,
-0.3766737282,
-0.4533751607,
0.5269806981,
-0.4027115405,
0.7238864899,
-0.7667242885,
-0.3680410385,
-0.1024921909,
0.0247613899,
-0.1235274374,
-0.4642977118,
0.50233531,
-0.4716870785,
-0.0842236206,
0.107305631,
-0.4695949852,
0.2738374472,
0.2684564292,
-0.4716484845,
0.9314396977,
0.3203055263,
-0.3230094016,
0.4819308519,
-0.979796946,
-0.3900304735,
-0.083377406,
0.1354798824,
-0.3999885619,
0.0724326372,
0.7061366439,
0.5420885682,
-0.2797526419,
0.1842131317,
-0.622463882,
-0.3383916318,
-0.0025400149,
-0.5498252511,
0.5946418643,
0.4263698459,
-0.4291269779,
0.1085126922,
-0.8049725294,
0.1354873776,
0.0816955566,
-0.4762699902,
-0.4553431869,
0.2092055529,
0.197642073,
0.1621516794,
0.1636240631,
-0.5873618722,
0.3648687303,
-0.3469928801,
0.8304864764,
1.0217012167,
0.0166199822,
0.6127471924,
-0.3512501419,
0.5718325377,
-0.3314759731,
0.2990700901,
-0.0581352748,
-0.2343131155,
-0.5960886478,
-0.4016742706,
0.0298845824,
0.668256104,
-0.9323925972,
0.3927401304,
-0.4076063633,
-0.6172366738,
-0.6929681301,
0.0788340718,
0.4814775288,
0.3598362505,
0.3880274296,
0.1575377584,
-0.2463398427,
-0.9536873102,
-0.9354857206,
-0.5282587409,
-0.3049198091,
0.6250604987,
0.2355127037,
-0.1490956396,
0.9254487157,
-0.510369122,
-0.1263469905,
-0.4870893359,
0.1016957387,
0.2029001117,
0.2813228667,
0.6293115616,
-0.602419138,
-0.6677114964,
0.0541284829,
-0.2511513233,
-0.4426988959,
-0.3668785095,
0.3340370059,
0.2368832976,
0.5268198252,
-0.0575651675,
-0.0174315013,
0.7349807024,
-0.4980721176,
0.5876364708,
-0.5450845957,
-0.2253682464,
-0.8738502264,
-0.097537294,
-0.0389235541,
-0.3355652094,
-0.5821538568,
-0.062984556,
0.246517241,
0.0192951802,
-0.4984157383,
1.0561381578,
-0.1989732385,
0.0978869647,
-0.295358628,
-0.1590333581,
0.0871717036,
0.5300870538,
0.1460584849,
0.9998633862,
0.2789400816,
-0.7643666863,
-0.2421918511,
-0.1394215375,
-0.2808665037,
0.4546357691,
-0.8443436623,
-0.0051085544,
-0.0430186316,
0.6193459034,
-0.6495496035,
-0.1293865293,
-0.0266816951,
-0.0059219655,
0.0181949735,
-0.295276314,
-0.2229686826,
-0.1384969801,
-0.4053158462,
0.1892608106,
0.6897265315,
-0.7334961295,
0.85182482,
0.2263730913,
-0.1780979335,
-0.553222537,
-0.6287866831,
0.0207642987,
-0.2681418955,
-0.111262165,
0.2870432436,
-0.0767226666,
-0.1614799351,
0.1255203784,
0.0573981851,
-0.028357638,
0.0074067321,
0.0774418041,
0.1977258921,
-0.2473643422,
-0.1076542586,
0.5480364561,
-0.0072899358,
-0.236874029,
-0.6573633552,
0.1867946386,
-0.3255913258,
-0.0234893784,
-0.3660345972,
0.1390310973,
0.6559424996,
-0.0639726073,
0.9067595005,
0.493318975,
-0.1289330125,
-0.5117137432,
-0.5659524798,
0.0976554677,
-0.5468690395,
0.3979685307,
-0.4592778385,
-0.9866014123,
0.229153648,
-0.340975374,
0.41444695,
0.1710767895,
0.5487580895,
0.1310116798,
1.2531206608,
0.4871511459,
-0.2664507031,
0.9903689027,
0.122907117,
0.1294144392,
-0.893484652,
0.1542233825,
-0.4775141478,
-0.2793825567,
-0.5893450379,
-0.1379760653,
0.3787818551,
0.0075643533,
-0.614327848,
0.2119105458,
-0.4093816876,
0.7218248844,
0.3623650968,
0.1924682111,
0.1377327144,
-0.1145109683,
0.086101599,
0.122101739,
-0.741030097,
-0.529170692,
1.0354787111,
0.2957002223,
0.9948399067,
0.1119535118,
0.3834955096,
0.3927297592,
0.3692015111,
-0.6803119779,
0.3673520684,
-0.3075525761,
-0.5279381275,
-0.4368085861,
-0.5109241605,
-0.6872285008,
0.3416317105,
-0.1209437102,
-0.8447765112,
0.3396528959,
0.657793045,
-0.4717139006,
0.5198155642,
-0.9607689381,
0.6678558588,
0.0114759505,
-0.3808247447,
-0.1532472223,
-0.4323474467,
0.0599713847,
-0.0899583921,
0.3508976996,
-0.3675231636,
-0.6096730828,
0.5071700215,
-0.4336243272,
0.9096073508,
-0.506470263,
-0.0534881875,
0.1973980367,
0.1510048062,
0.962613523,
0.0301402193,
-0.2592714727,
-0.1983599067,
-0.01877225,
-0.6477401853,
-0.7705862522,
0.8391522765,
-0.9155123234,
-0.3658840656,
-0.1020647138,
-0.7973410487,
-0.3220018446,
0.4085030854,
0.1447400749,
0.1788110137,
-0.2541780174,
-0.1812419444,
0.6661623716,
-0.3444282115,
0.6214389205,
0.8694270849,
-0.1238132566,
-0.1624033898,
1.1778452396,
-0.1062259823,
0.6307643056,
0.7507262826,
0.5937368274,
-0.2808467448,
-0.6004721522,
-0.4804800451,
-0.0303096939,
-0.2926125824,
0.0500554629,
-0.7583983541,
0.1529194713,
-0.3331533372,
-0.4551106393,
-0.5719642639,
-0.6669954658,
-0.0770265535,
0.1017698497,
0.3818042576,
0.5469070077,
-0.2086862475,
0.8077991009,
-0.6080688834,
0.380381912,
0.2945731878,
0.3482134044,
-0.0508154109,
-0.6342073679,
-0.0261332989,
-0.1872678399,
-0.1667076051,
-0.4433895648,
0.1477515996,
0.7983250618,
0.0485583842,
0.5412308574,
0.2970357835,
0.6524043679,
-0.9574728608,
0.9090800881,
-0.0599626042,
-1.0055238008,
0.4426933229,
-0.4021965861,
0.4760890007,
0.5159884691,
0.1392936558,
-0.5547007918,
-0.4111394584,
-0.3476089239,
-1.0203425884,
0.7039901018,
-0.0339235924,
0.2800886035,
-0.0914166868,
0.4998803437,
0.0603443272,
-0.1778532267,
-0.5835760832,
-0.0792169645,
-0.2489842027,
-0.0680430979,
-0.1763889939,
-0.1437937915,
0.1191143543,
0.0099726832,
0.961935401,
-0.4127153158,
0.0083994288,
0.039930474,
0.0262768697,
0.0987899005,
0.766248703,
0.446773231,
0.5527021885,
-0.2116194665,
0.021832535,
0.4017727971,
-0.3742220104,
0.365096271,
0.1261360943,
-0.3160216212,
-0.1825868636,
0.3744246066,
1.1892504692,
0.2267120779,
-0.8371821642,
0.436160773,
-0.1807902455,
-0.1224219128,
-0.1292191595,
0.5271667838,
-0.0475372411,
0.3002589643,
0.0936317742,
-0.0614685677,
0.0796872303,
-0.329942435,
-0.2372148782,
0.3435138464,
-0.5485946536,
-0.3111843765,
0.8803297281,
0.126839444,
-0.3634089828,
0.4388340116,
-0.0802820176,
-0.2159468979,
0.3333167136,
0.957762301,
0.8017853498,
-0.4543321729,
0.1210606322,
0.1288185269,
0.4467945099,
-0.3154397309,
0.2108308971,
-0.0323927365,
-0.823325634,
-0.5834292769,
-0.556848228,
-0.5029328465,
0.2949057519,
-0.7301893234,
0.0055450546,
-0.6809352636,
0.0025542111,
-0.0527463779,
-0.4086740911,
-0.5925219655,
0.0538083687,
-0.2519601583,
1.3103642464,
-1.1233912706,
0.804890871,
0.7897775769,
-0.0594340265,
-0.9254989028,
0.0562650822,
-0.0420889594,
-1.1345959902,
-0.1621580422,
-0.1920568049,
-0.1120779738,
0.1497617215,
-0.5392364264,
-0.2868487835,
1.0157258511,
0.561086297,
-0.8411645889,
-0.5415400267,
-0.0619472265,
0.4879978299,
-0.1626834422,
0.3856734037,
0.959174633,
0.4195716083,
-0.231996417,
-0.9857088923,
0.1943198144,
-0.0327755362,
0.4157809913,
0.413628757,
-0.7400384545,
0.5405394435,
-0.2450800389,
0.1426723599,
-0.0139021333,
0.5878705382,
0.3168195784,
0.0310461447,
0.8499137163,
0.3202878535,
0.5512851477,
0.2928761542,
1.2077876329,
-0.268894434,
0.1707672924,
1.3890672922,
-0.2992631793,
0.8307240605,
0.6483830214,
-0.3233621418,
0.4202028811,
0.5284056067,
0.322969228,
0.5569500327,
-0.0077771358,
-0.4437564313,
-0.3678654432,
-0.3275112212,
-0.2109080851,
0.0414320491,
0.6974769235,
-0.3231832683,
-0.2705463469,
0.0963329077,
0.3014472723,
-0.0985359922,
-0.4368789196,
0.8459956646,
0.1342492551,
-0.7859350443,
0.4539152384,
0.0827682242,
0.5863068104,
-0.8799993992,
-0.1222779974,
-0.1199787259,
0.5699613094,
-0.0697896257,
-0.6858701706,
-0.0068857661,
0.0101144565,
-0.2670216262,
-0.3134903312,
0.5408425331,
-0.3019206524,
-0.2635348141,
0.3378166556,
0.1763099432,
0.0665411353,
-0.1413523704,
-0.7572348714,
-0.0266054478,
0.0729740635,
-0.5203961134,
0.4537636638,
0.52981776,
-0.1571870595,
0.7753916979,
0.5490204096,
0.4603545368,
-0.0525275432,
-0.1057035029,
0.9285433292,
-0.3977364898,
-0.7260735035,
-0.9620267153,
0.1412398368,
0.1732725054,
-0.3392635286,
0.3512332141,
0.3698832989,
0.7577931285,
0.0649137944,
1.1994658709,
-0.2291089445,
0.3066128492,
-0.5150692463,
0.627063036,
-0.6654384732,
0.3641465008,
-0.2517066598,
-0.9022783041,
-0.1128223389,
0.1894961149,
-0.3104871511,
-0.2245270908,
0.4431532621,
0.8727687597,
-0.1797885895,
-0.0675652847,
0.2229757905,
0.2550725937,
0.8141503334,
0.6270164847,
0.5964900851,
0.0478499047,
0.875677526,
-0.0285426266,
-0.6618635654,
-0.180805847,
-1.1063789129,
-0.9145604968,
-0.2729358673,
0.1074909493,
-0.4662559628,
0.4139449298,
1.0275409222,
0.5659021139,
-0.696841836,
0.0433216169,
-0.2188811898,
-0.0204753596,
-0.5201016068,
-0.2415224016,
0.4550508857,
-0.4714890718,
-0.8113886118,
0.6014869809,
0.18563959,
-0.0894218087,
0.0588626154,
-0.2421736717,
0.2381297648,
0.3018799424,
0.4936091006,
0.69660604,
-0.617485404,
-0.3174943626,
-0.3343338966,
0.0770989284,
-0.1776918769,
1.0419454575,
-0.6654275656,
0.5918162465,
0.2336494178,
0.8293562531,
0.4356478155,
-0.3710374534,
0.8293655515,
-0.5536237955,
0.2094992399,
0.2358138859,
0.2790721655,
0.001642959,
-0.2349913716,
0.3965070248,
-0.1993624717,
-0.7493790388,
-0.8555410504,
0.4484815896,
-0.483263582,
-0.3400469124,
1.1744155884,
-0.3806158602,
-0.2657212913,
-0.308065176,
-0.2445358783,
0.0855911076,
-0.8278928995,
0.550183475,
0.440669328,
-0.4053412974,
-0.0228817035,
-0.5082222223,
0.5508864522,
0.4337885082,
-0.7268599272,
0.2397980988,
0.1230498552,
0.4015534222,
-0.1678227633,
0.8053928018,
0.0520851687,
0.0419464633,
0.0123162521,
-0.082387872,
-0.1233085468,
-0.2505169213,
-0.3513115942,
-0.1732716262,
0.4164996743,
-0.0085809287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15064v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15064v3 | AutoPlan: Automatic Planning of Interactive Decision-Making Tasks With Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:52:23 | 2023-10-26T16:44:39 | Siqi Ouyang, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent large language models (LLMs) are promising for making decisions in
grounded environments. However, LLMs frequently fail in complex decision-making
tasks due to the misalignment between the pre-trained knowledge in LLMs and the
actual rules in the environment. Existing methods require either costly
gradient computation or lengthy in-context demonstrations. In this paper, we
propose AutoPlan, an approach to guide LLM-based agents to accomplish
interactive decision-making tasks. AutoPlan augments the LLM prompt with a
task-solving plan and optimizes it through iterative experience collection and
reflection. Our experiments show that AutoPlan, though using no in-context
demonstrations, achieves success rates on par with the baselines using
human-written demonstrations on ALFWorld and even outperforms them by 8% on
HotpotQA. The code is available at https://github.com/owaski/AutoPlan. | [
-0.5319519639,
-0.633485496,
0.863840282,
0.536139071,
0.1481245905,
0.1318282336,
-0.2521618605,
-0.049847845,
0.1998275518,
0.4316889644,
-0.8176935911,
-0.6253537536,
-0.2184551656,
-0.1950768232,
0.0028230823,
0.4360065162,
-0.4374207854,
-0.4169593751,
-0.2613691688,
0.0906678215,
-0.3229773939,
-0.0454400703,
-0.6940778494,
-0.5198268294,
0.4153701365,
0.7139680982,
0.7710769773,
0.5177164078,
0.0911723077,
0.4331468046,
0.06988208,
0.6453940868,
-0.0577096753,
0.2985878289,
-0.3195643127,
-0.2254808396,
-0.4201129675,
0.0379153565,
0.1789967865,
0.6469277143,
-0.2403812408,
-0.0717028379,
-0.1675853431,
0.4089934826,
-0.6256657243,
0.5538903475,
-0.2303016186,
0.3151755929,
0.4033447206,
-0.1857959479,
-0.3226290047,
-0.115455091,
0.1178901792,
-0.8991137147,
-0.1545969397,
0.4035336375,
0.2881797254,
0.5884230733,
-0.2654439509,
-0.4980516136,
-0.9969356656,
0.6918970942,
-0.6782974601,
-0.0057968651,
0.3769179881,
0.5795096159,
-0.530503273,
-0.6246111989,
-0.618299067,
-0.3643830419,
-0.2518352568,
0.2009311169,
-0.0390908085,
0.3256298304,
0.5166627169,
0.0348385498,
-0.3436592519,
0.3111362755,
-0.0275561772,
0.0320362523,
0.7742282748,
0.4024483263,
0.0978547558,
-0.2029558569,
-0.3608043492,
-0.2910033464,
-0.5499133468,
0.2848765254,
0.0963157192,
0.1992285252,
-0.0313646495,
0.584869802,
-0.5065028667,
0.72140342,
0.2088066339,
-0.1587601304,
-0.0762314647,
-0.0648907796,
-0.4614163041,
-0.1237125769,
0.6416144967,
0.1786714941,
0.1473175883,
0.186890617,
-0.3816793859,
-0.3747251332,
0.0990144685,
-0.5841709971,
-0.3688395023,
0.4258161187,
-0.2747582793,
-0.120785743,
-0.3532123268,
-0.6415599585,
-0.3382079601,
-0.7617219687,
0.6304244995,
-0.1942064166,
-0.0541976131,
0.1447426826,
0.045317065,
0.0934023112,
0.8819608688,
-0.5620185137,
0.3231379092,
0.3641103804,
0.5129329562,
-0.0507816374,
-0.5341786742,
-0.6141268611,
0.3166027069,
-0.3101762235,
0.9698345065,
-0.2916179597,
-0.3809415102,
0.146974802,
-0.15829961,
-0.1635683924,
-0.3834452629,
0.3996804357,
-0.2411438227,
0.2920738757,
-0.4057947993,
-0.6348947287,
-0.2715811729,
0.3275981545,
-0.6624888182,
0.7283555269,
0.0402790643,
-0.2079972327,
0.5762937665,
-0.9936881065,
-0.4499900639,
0.2531060278,
-0.4057384729,
0.0029034584,
-0.2993898094,
0.4046027958,
0.6598191857,
-0.1213578805,
0.3451197147,
-0.0030669514,
-0.2243994921,
-0.072407864,
-0.0557984523,
0.7002616525,
0.3111790717,
-0.8351067305,
0.3913453221,
-0.4993119836,
0.0143961199,
0.078197822,
-0.3909746706,
-0.0716975927,
0.2712389827,
-0.0404141396,
0.6589564085,
0.1581415832,
-0.2483293712,
0.6921272278,
-0.2364230603,
0.153054148,
0.6594583988,
-0.2067162842,
0.6030955315,
-0.5671664476,
0.7400328517,
-0.4388048351,
0.2850034833,
-0.244267866,
-0.3779591024,
-0.864151597,
-0.3196229339,
-0.0991468877,
0.5249439478,
-0.9381808639,
0.5184447169,
0.1008641198,
-0.3825064301,
-0.0512313619,
0.1811255217,
0.2380972058,
0.2903606296,
0.3889930248,
0.1194311008,
-0.3093748391,
-0.8422193527,
-0.098138392,
-0.2893348932,
0.1264256835,
0.3300772309,
0.5574387312,
-0.3051876426,
1.102660656,
-0.4230459929,
-0.6995311975,
-0.4538368583,
0.5211109519,
-0.0597098917,
0.3236721754,
0.4698114991,
-0.6915715337,
-0.5240966678,
-0.0842325836,
-0.644556284,
-0.432000488,
-0.4857694507,
-0.1455187052,
0.1357607096,
0.6632335782,
-0.9387664795,
0.4440040588,
0.3190303445,
-0.4018722773,
0.3315986991,
-0.5105589628,
-0.0611075349,
-0.6737414598,
-0.0218975153,
-0.2400406301,
-0.3052011132,
-0.49038589,
-0.0320973992,
-0.1021471173,
0.0545135885,
-0.3389784992,
0.937051475,
-0.6019206643,
-0.2597619295,
-0.4545084536,
0.1095224395,
0.0513269939,
0.8851279616,
0.3493480682,
0.5366064906,
0.2793028951,
-0.5284435153,
0.4807191193,
0.6039757133,
-0.3176296651,
0.3633542359,
-0.3135600686,
-0.0998584479,
-0.1552125663,
0.5509800911,
-0.9223920107,
-0.4594055116,
0.2441961169,
0.0075167292,
0.1803562641,
-0.0118346307,
-0.4768627584,
-0.3413956165,
-0.205861941,
0.2610473335,
0.4992739558,
-0.716719985,
1.2315075397,
0.2786711454,
-0.3535538912,
-0.4328644276,
-0.3842759728,
0.2103331983,
-0.189379856,
-0.3688654602,
0.3861139715,
-0.3582991064,
-0.5684928894,
-0.1863534302,
0.271654278,
0.2317988575,
-0.0193709824,
0.5285309553,
-0.1830943525,
0.3040291369,
-0.0186515674,
0.1281366646,
-0.0434255749,
0.2281861752,
-0.1255071908,
0.5000607967,
-0.0616744235,
-0.6493236423,
-0.3092930615,
0.4973354936,
0.7841210961,
-0.1845776588,
0.270862639,
0.0870492831,
-0.2356956005,
-0.7485502958,
-0.5824602246,
0.2372671515,
-0.5339765549,
-0.0155201815,
-0.3408299983,
-0.3241679966,
0.3621122241,
-0.4702274799,
0.6107563376,
0.1361278892,
0.6085361242,
-0.2930844426,
1.2081543207,
0.6384291649,
0.053325627,
0.3787952662,
-0.3869401813,
0.1013333946,
-0.3344262242,
-0.3941607177,
-0.1931830049,
-0.347232312,
-0.2009992898,
-0.614734292,
0.3945684731,
-0.2735027075,
-0.4103054106,
0.1674640179,
-0.1227978468,
0.4013401866,
0.6078349352,
-0.2283057272,
0.3601201475,
-0.2037048638,
-0.3103582263,
0.1650963426,
-0.8997452259,
-0.4938227534,
0.5495257378,
0.1690371782,
0.6422168016,
-0.1347921491,
0.7120562792,
0.46244964,
0.37547791,
-0.7476404905,
0.718551755,
0.3234933019,
-0.1291217506,
-0.6002066135,
-0.0894896686,
-0.6202049851,
0.2025540173,
-0.1673049331,
-0.2234928757,
0.4193283617,
0.3088595569,
-0.5004248619,
0.0548659004,
-0.4618245363,
0.6752666235,
-0.6029566526,
-0.2701544166,
-0.2448883802,
-0.4407387972,
0.0098114219,
-0.0513864569,
0.4219523072,
-0.1109122857,
-0.05774533,
0.4659416974,
-0.5487986207,
0.8123825192,
-0.5900829434,
-0.202136904,
0.20490098,
0.2538281083,
0.9698604941,
-0.3366922438,
-0.1013915315,
-0.4975996315,
-0.4344653487,
-0.237781018,
-0.6768192649,
0.4809128344,
-0.4139909446,
-0.458126694,
-0.2260498852,
-0.7525939941,
-0.2635477185,
-0.0281318221,
0.1727151275,
0.3860368431,
-0.3097894788,
-0.3544254005,
0.4684375823,
-0.4710196853,
0.8123835921,
0.7708162069,
-0.4969203472,
-0.0941432938,
0.4964480102,
0.0761048421,
0.1763804853,
0.0850393623,
0.0631131306,
-0.1978887171,
-0.5945365429,
-0.5602346659,
0.0730765387,
-0.9722582698,
-0.0727502927,
-0.6619492769,
0.000239239,
-0.036906343,
-0.5622878671,
-0.3055379987,
-0.4539391994,
0.1317912191,
-0.1760640591,
0.274679929,
0.98418957,
-0.3068355918,
0.3713796437,
-0.211829558,
0.2592218518,
0.5824133158,
-0.1079825535,
-0.1231615692,
-0.2346764356,
-0.1332303286,
-0.1060030237,
-0.0828912333,
-0.4863513112,
0.6863656044,
0.1844682097,
0.7280712724,
0.4072007835,
0.3300009072,
0.5813506246,
-0.4170057178,
0.5225971937,
-0.2876112163,
-0.7522697449,
0.6569048166,
-0.4977429211,
0.5392405391,
0.7083387375,
0.412746191,
-0.2430396527,
-0.6472215652,
-0.5485815406,
-1.0458676815,
0.6707183123,
0.2491578162,
-0.1912252307,
0.1420733482,
0.0378026552,
0.144050777,
0.3021763265,
-0.5031772852,
-0.1317410767,
-0.025110295,
-0.1411688626,
-0.0476440862,
-0.1218900606,
-0.2594921887,
-0.4841822088,
0.6367756128,
-0.4408634007,
0.2477361262,
0.2191911191,
-0.3963261843,
-0.2669990361,
-0.057780575,
0.5175260305,
0.7258883715,
-0.0536395051,
-0.0174077414,
0.2829419672,
0.0570406541,
0.1071793213,
0.3493252993,
-0.1152935401,
-0.181753993,
0.4096854627,
0.6686107516,
0.1997560412,
-0.9257136583,
0.608071208,
-0.1949834228,
-0.3130397499,
-0.7555735707,
0.141313538,
0.1194514185,
0.5380920768,
0.3577157557,
-0.2055310011,
0.1581718475,
-0.413736403,
0.0617174841,
0.1978822201,
-0.057172589,
0.1667753011,
0.4684374928,
0.318964988,
-0.3855691552,
0.4809086621,
-0.370677948,
-0.6240624189,
0.9083781242,
0.2058017999,
0.8693958521,
-0.2212941945,
0.4215046465,
0.1490047425,
0.179192543,
-0.1509033144,
0.3529393971,
-0.4657470882,
-0.5246235728,
-0.5967413187,
-0.5041600466,
-0.8137796521,
-0.0493214317,
-0.1744979322,
0.2373643965,
-0.6379826665,
0.2835162878,
-0.2272427082,
0.0056750346,
-0.7526726127,
0.3182707131,
0.2709989548,
1.0574988127,
-0.9102377295,
0.5007862449,
0.8162882328,
-0.1831703037,
-0.881413877,
0.0093849199,
-0.0503961518,
-0.5776003599,
0.7974143624,
0.216786921,
-0.3802084327,
-0.0576887131,
-0.5601944327,
-0.7284719944,
1.2603137493,
0.1710102558,
-0.4731415808,
-0.1808539033,
0.1287052929,
0.3712661266,
-0.632569313,
0.4931748211,
0.4480597377,
0.9317227006,
0.0167039093,
-0.9947619438,
0.0019904252,
-0.3341703713,
-0.230803296,
0.0430166051,
-0.71407938,
0.71943748,
-0.1631726325,
0.0261763539,
0.0350494161,
0.5596086979,
0.2104870975,
0.370585233,
0.9225395918,
0.4294671714,
0.6430212259,
0.1411196589,
0.7713266015,
-0.2044401467,
0.023682138,
1.0039185286,
-0.5248094797,
0.6062893867,
0.1537744254,
0.1417331845,
0.5674287081,
0.6240228415,
0.0973187387,
0.5529505014,
0.0948175117,
-0.3853147924,
-0.5599976778,
0.0029462841,
0.2507146001,
0.5939418077,
0.4966751337,
-0.1520804316,
-0.4630895555,
0.4643208385,
-0.0664839521,
0.227202788,
-0.3053863943,
0.7944076657,
-0.0717367604,
-1.0045311451,
0.3784334362,
-0.1428369284,
0.319983542,
-0.4500014186,
-0.3824034333,
-0.2651185691,
0.0726887584,
-0.2193138152,
-0.6835140586,
0.1022317484,
-0.2702997923,
0.1005130783,
-0.818572402,
0.6997206211,
-0.4483064115,
-0.1390392333,
0.5281742811,
0.7012793422,
0.0939821005,
-0.1567423642,
-0.6184844971,
-0.3028429151,
-0.1650789976,
-0.5207967162,
0.1774147302,
0.3447856605,
-0.3500576615,
0.9941223264,
0.4041958153,
-0.14014709,
-0.1913053095,
-0.0879042223,
0.9288316965,
-0.7058676481,
-0.670709312,
-0.4940801561,
0.4222422242,
-0.2131232619,
-0.0234447103,
0.5043996572,
0.4386959374,
0.6506839991,
0.0361800492,
0.8852372169,
-0.1251849681,
0.399343133,
-0.6804170609,
0.5455784798,
-0.4753615558,
0.3474746943,
-0.0294635426,
-0.9082826376,
-0.123018302,
0.7403624654,
-0.4086279273,
0.0879068375,
0.5754355788,
0.6479277015,
-0.1518180072,
-0.1877692193,
0.2023394406,
0.1120856777,
0.4391035736,
0.6842505336,
1.1456624269,
0.3033931255,
0.3059402704,
-0.4421952069,
-0.3609707355,
-0.2782725096,
-1.1242538691,
-0.9697369337,
-0.5515732169,
-0.2286954522,
0.2474223375,
0.0046838755,
1.4572227001,
0.6971372366,
-0.4201513231,
-0.4120194316,
-0.317111969,
-0.0292171743,
-0.1490267515,
-0.161982134,
0.2506377697,
-0.4809522033,
-0.6738603711,
0.8934969902,
0.1826430261,
0.0108526507,
-0.4764049351,
-0.2585131228,
-0.2062970102,
0.1441982388,
0.6031597257,
0.5925363302,
-0.6174061894,
0.0318032801,
-0.1608014554,
-0.1394229382,
-0.122487016,
0.9624882936,
-1.1094123125,
0.2689326108,
0.3627594411,
0.5043183565,
0.6960145235,
-0.0101540955,
0.9760150313,
-0.4633763731,
0.16487661,
0.3854811788,
0.3499629498,
0.2246960849,
-0.3384692371,
0.452709049,
-0.3283137083,
-0.7655345798,
-0.3338561654,
0.3223406374,
-0.8620179892,
-0.4929078221,
1.2975423336,
-0.1069847718,
-0.0802427754,
-0.3490847051,
-0.6828379631,
-0.1332524121,
-0.3569268584,
0.8289332986,
0.4225200713,
-0.4362823665,
-0.0177288856,
-0.6181020141,
0.8660863042,
0.54201895,
-0.9739705324,
0.3509372771,
0.8116894364,
-0.164677605,
0.0543344431,
0.7953699827,
0.4881061316,
0.277210474,
-0.3860387504,
0.2501917481,
-0.3482494652,
-0.6422344446,
-0.2759612203,
0.0933461636,
0.321243763,
0.2244867682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15062v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15062v2 | Lawyer LLaMA Technical Report | 2023-05-24T11:52:07 | 2023-10-14T02:14:51 | Quzhe Huang, Mingxu Tao, Chen Zhang, Zhenwei An, Cong Jiang, Zhibin Chen, Zirui Wu, Yansong Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs), like LLaMA, have exhibited remarkable
performance across various tasks. Nevertheless, when deployed to specific
domains such as law or medicine, the models still confront the challenge of a
deficiency in domain-specific knowledge and an inadequate capability to
leverage that knowledge to resolve domain-related problems. In this paper, we
propose a new framework to adapt LLMs to specific domains and build Lawyer
LLaMA, a legal domain LLM, based on this framework. Specifically, we inject
domain knowledge during the continual training stage and teach the model to
learn professional skills using properly designed supervised fine-tuning tasks.
Moreover, to alleviate the hallucination problem during the model's generation,
we add a retrieval module and extract relevant legal articles before the model
answers any queries. When learning domain-specific skills, we find that
experts' experience is much more useful than experiences distilled from
ChatGPT, where hundreds of expert-written data outperform tens of thousands of
ChatGPT-generated ones. We will release our model and data. | [
-0.1130925938,
-0.6935199499,
0.5995715857,
0.1052141637,
-0.4264537096,
0.1478883773,
-0.238151446,
-0.5549521446,
0.0897808075,
0.9533810019,
-0.2545800805,
-0.6609845757,
-0.7573572993,
-0.0385803841,
-0.3459061086,
0.981539607,
0.0771085992,
0.0031403636,
-0.0835085139,
-0.1543378979,
-0.8044164181,
-0.6244218349,
-0.7129667401,
-0.382794559,
0.196418345,
0.3293471336,
0.5422679186,
0.5337170362,
0.3501085937,
0.2036426961,
-0.0489039384,
0.1904818565,
-0.5459571481,
-0.0736704245,
-0.4613344073,
-0.6303437352,
-0.7177376747,
-0.1918875873,
0.256138593,
0.6787593365,
-0.5493573546,
-0.0157634038,
-0.2940761745,
0.4822705984,
-0.2628730834,
0.2082817703,
-1.1234544516,
0.157752201,
-0.0395191982,
-0.3846725523,
-0.3624391258,
-0.053208515,
0.0493902415,
-0.8249557018,
0.1554230005,
0.0904466063,
0.7786802053,
0.5747157335,
-0.6407393813,
-0.3547210991,
-0.489410162,
0.4922112823,
-0.8829705119,
0.2020576447,
0.392919451,
0.6196117401,
-0.3726510108,
-0.6587537527,
-0.5827940702,
-0.3973282874,
0.2543768585,
-0.1688330472,
-0.0588387325,
-0.1021767706,
0.0277088229,
0.0286708977,
-0.3120263517,
0.335955143,
-0.1985409558,
0.1052841246,
0.8155975342,
0.2630831599,
0.1576482803,
0.2886857092,
-0.0003931512,
0.386906594,
-1.0720239878,
-0.2650881112,
0.3221782744,
0.4363565445,
0.0599507466,
0.6303368807,
-0.0669332221,
0.6278137565,
0.1002918482,
-0.5590248704,
0.0846668929,
0.2516528368,
-0.265000701,
0.0057701375,
0.3836494982,
0.0922683179,
0.6606680155,
-0.1188969836,
-0.4405027926,
-0.281507194,
0.6553121805,
-0.6023356318,
-0.1295914799,
0.0324308053,
-0.4347710013,
-0.34730196,
-0.3103958368,
-0.3462102413,
-0.772683382,
-0.5159597993,
0.4647299945,
-0.3519419432,
-0.2480531931,
0.5700778961,
0.3636843264,
0.0689972118,
0.4565257728,
-0.8231396079,
0.4019461274,
0.7996130586,
0.5716712475,
-0.1962738335,
-0.1118390858,
-0.6510486007,
0.2212819606,
-0.2414079458,
0.7051513791,
-0.7597311735,
-0.2762042284,
0.3780395985,
0.0503734052,
0.0400860831,
-0.8270444274,
0.1331768483,
-0.8612576127,
-0.3260848522,
0.1037860215,
-0.6294922233,
-0.3453800082,
0.246060282,
-0.318708688,
0.5167801976,
0.2459180206,
-0.4540552795,
0.443130523,
-0.5870247483,
-0.5761849284,
0.3220590353,
-0.3584011793,
-0.421449393,
-0.0270849392,
0.1993738711,
0.8119251132,
-0.3180745542,
0.7332655787,
-0.0278409496,
-0.380625397,
0.1017189622,
0.2026650161,
0.7341111898,
0.066153571,
-0.2490399331,
-0.0057946625,
-0.9602018595,
-0.4547158182,
0.385260582,
-0.5065802932,
-0.1637787074,
0.164981842,
-0.2172239125,
0.084453091,
0.098870635,
-0.1933171451,
0.3656620383,
-0.2746362984,
0.4291743338,
0.7067196965,
0.2067122906,
0.117711626,
-0.295366019,
0.7271078229,
0.104205817,
-0.2064994574,
0.1068522334,
-0.555960536,
-0.8619241118,
-0.282825619,
0.1637291163,
0.5319681168,
-0.5714375973,
0.3809615672,
-0.4160189629,
-0.4130110741,
-0.634044826,
0.5161409974,
0.2169758528,
0.4144100845,
0.3746289909,
-0.4702650309,
-0.4545138478,
-0.8342649341,
-0.2208427042,
-0.0514513254,
0.1125782132,
0.514097333,
0.6499176025,
-0.5631563067,
0.7120263577,
-0.4166682363,
-0.5401789546,
-0.3134128451,
-0.1622576267,
0.3392964005,
0.1966273189,
0.5939716697,
-0.5974075794,
-0.4585103095,
0.3491800725,
-0.882178843,
-0.1240514442,
-0.2342648059,
-0.0405057073,
-0.077417478,
0.4571219683,
-0.6559966207,
0.2313313931,
0.0893128738,
-0.3503291905,
0.7800096869,
-0.240644902,
-0.2636498511,
-0.9513070583,
-0.0495238043,
0.0008974247,
-0.4510081112,
-0.657687366,
0.2198935151,
-0.1182631329,
-0.0794626027,
-0.5210191607,
0.616174221,
-0.2788960338,
-0.164034158,
-0.491150707,
0.1550707817,
-0.2616513371,
0.5480175614,
0.1483067423,
0.8935912251,
0.5403593779,
-0.8802798986,
0.2903788686,
0.4780719876,
-0.5067284703,
0.6628436446,
-0.5640609264,
0.2911066413,
0.006099978,
-0.0261672903,
-0.2123340964,
-0.3207114935,
0.0682297423,
-0.0160645712,
0.3959619403,
-0.3874992728,
-0.5767130852,
-0.2060132921,
0.2644137144,
0.1017915532,
0.4738098085,
-0.6183294058,
0.7189079523,
0.7429509759,
-0.2174872011,
-0.7065668702,
-0.4462280869,
0.2482769191,
-0.3001327515,
-0.4645934105,
0.341122061,
0.065841794,
-0.3310860693,
-0.0044074864,
0.1293874383,
-0.243822217,
0.2029813081,
0.341627866,
-0.1311511546,
-0.4223728478,
0.3587270379,
0.1494491547,
0.0509121567,
0.1702070087,
-0.2190998942,
0.4985374212,
0.0562997498,
-0.466614902,
-0.3265293539,
0.1787601113,
0.4045995474,
-0.292545259,
0.6440857053,
0.0229280274,
-0.3149622679,
-0.6404446959,
-0.752746284,
0.0652173758,
-0.5234515667,
0.6516984701,
-0.6378139853,
-1.2091585398,
0.4305554926,
-0.3222254217,
0.1053580865,
0.3376999497,
0.8217374682,
0.2183251083,
0.4880681634,
1.1113126278,
-0.2223313153,
0.2995757759,
-0.1848138571,
0.4304206073,
-0.6161747575,
-0.3729385734,
-0.2470375746,
0.1156879514,
-0.0997511372,
-0.3903027773,
0.0843727291,
0.0262482185,
-0.5658300519,
0.5494751334,
-0.3767127991,
0.4664711356,
0.3446971178,
0.2090913802,
0.5104157925,
0.1699318439,
-0.1236713678,
0.1670412272,
-0.6318517327,
-0.8060575128,
1.2716866732,
0.478982389,
0.5251990557,
0.1933289915,
0.6042692065,
0.389970988,
0.3481306136,
-0.823540926,
0.6686894298,
-0.1620106101,
-0.3925440609,
-0.0759741142,
-0.2052719295,
-0.7942867875,
0.1524066031,
-0.0625060201,
-0.6257461905,
0.0069181533,
-0.0987707749,
-0.4248725474,
0.3832982481,
-0.2255089581,
0.4879205525,
-0.1510475129,
-0.2495880127,
-0.4450114965,
-0.3065570593,
0.4378918409,
-0.6303594112,
0.3062905967,
-0.3603586853,
-0.1871147603,
0.6212255955,
-0.4446711242,
1.139565587,
-0.2099096775,
-0.4438129365,
0.4571698904,
0.3776682317,
0.5304029584,
0.179212302,
-0.2412469685,
-0.0992917269,
-0.2276421636,
-0.2807735801,
-0.4717961252,
0.4893592,
-0.8208254576,
-1.0814722776,
-0.0863936767,
-0.7223966718,
-0.4457296729,
0.0397488885,
-0.3010050356,
-0.1142123118,
-0.1395838112,
-0.0750613362,
0.6164571643,
-0.3147675693,
0.0763270929,
0.9338593483,
-0.1248957142,
-0.1004865393,
0.8674467206,
0.0644591898,
-0.1167348325,
0.1640565246,
-0.0717765912,
-0.0368384495,
-0.8372880816,
-0.2405175567,
0.5123669505,
-0.9763424397,
-0.48555246,
-0.6929920912,
-0.3482076824,
-0.140824452,
-0.2435876131,
-0.2934581041,
-0.2293200642,
-0.4820385873,
-0.0558617078,
0.6725590229,
0.9243639112,
0.3510468006,
0.5272213817,
-0.6998802423,
0.2114391774,
0.3999358416,
0.3368861675,
-0.0004992292,
-1.1462067366,
-0.2591730952,
-0.2996638417,
-0.3407334685,
-0.508161664,
0.5426004529,
0.3910400867,
0.7036811709,
0.4032302499,
-0.1924120486,
0.6619668007,
-0.8488510847,
0.6917683482,
0.0316640995,
-0.8570051193,
0.5920562744,
-0.4861627817,
-0.2384005636,
0.3830329478,
0.4556759596,
-0.2578406334,
-0.4050073624,
-0.3648849428,
-0.6036062241,
0.3450553715,
-0.121980086,
0.7185508013,
0.0432484895,
0.9894468188,
0.4246627092,
0.3268995285,
-0.8163798451,
0.2033462375,
0.0926885009,
-0.2048354149,
0.122212477,
-0.2765982449,
-0.2605811357,
-0.3554138541,
0.7599007487,
-0.261256963,
0.2492849827,
-0.1169229448,
-0.3648575842,
0.0109258452,
0.1280098706,
0.5963438749,
0.9269044399,
0.056030497,
0.0970766172,
0.4146538675,
-0.4398315847,
0.2784404755,
-0.2146856934,
0.2067361027,
-0.2462792397,
0.4717888236,
0.592690587,
0.0679289773,
-1.0797049999,
0.6481746435,
0.3418929577,
-0.5232564807,
-0.3142610192,
0.4455243945,
0.3017380834,
0.5760487914,
0.3826419413,
-0.2601694763,
-0.1777582914,
-0.4759905636,
0.3612213731,
0.2168652415,
-0.1036075801,
-0.1568493843,
0.8215444684,
0.1451285481,
-0.4018696249,
0.335591048,
-0.1524288207,
-0.5120918155,
0.5621712208,
0.796818614,
0.4729903936,
-0.0256778505,
0.0864381716,
0.1042378992,
0.0984237492,
-0.3786760271,
0.2606956959,
0.2380129844,
-0.6374040246,
-0.5065662265,
-0.4761667252,
-0.3594022095,
0.1885525882,
-0.2410875261,
0.1968462467,
-0.7366287708,
-0.1401264518,
-0.1564774066,
0.0996904299,
-0.8022070527,
0.2105526477,
-0.2319512516,
0.9386364222,
-0.5922000408,
1.1446588039,
0.5012643933,
-0.5707627535,
-0.533886373,
-0.2183759212,
-0.0627930909,
-1.1421823502,
1.0367878675,
-0.0356153771,
-0.0948980153,
-0.0047963341,
-0.7256358862,
-0.4721498191,
1.2054724693,
0.6324970722,
-0.8561571836,
0.1357769519,
0.3697356582,
0.7140453458,
-0.9508758187,
-0.3117169142,
0.609916985,
0.0126603646,
-0.1297768056,
-0.9561906457,
0.2502113283,
-0.1989691854,
0.0571498647,
-0.4107939899,
-0.5435239673,
0.6635460854,
-0.3923866451,
0.0592672452,
-0.0562186427,
0.6474164128,
0.2957340181,
0.0128072314,
0.2558457553,
0.5122385025,
1.0390335321,
0.3780349195,
0.9369626641,
-0.4016283453,
0.0939927548,
1.3058798313,
-0.6057657003,
1.0261303186,
0.463555187,
-0.0658092946,
0.4662159979,
0.4938334823,
-0.3077359498,
0.5197365284,
0.5688632131,
-0.4441632032,
-0.5559879541,
-0.2878473401,
-0.2606575787,
0.3765246272,
0.3900145888,
-0.424821198,
0.0837392807,
0.0689438805,
-0.0187309328,
0.2675415576,
-0.309176892,
0.6982443929,
0.5062913895,
-0.3044803143,
0.60114187,
0.2229391187,
0.6080304384,
-0.2692216635,
-0.1124191284,
-0.2968945801,
0.1565157473,
-0.1916475445,
-0.6652074456,
0.2052077949,
0.2858214378,
0.0974313393,
0.0746609718,
0.6939620376,
-0.1747427285,
-0.4376350343,
0.4438207448,
0.5641132593,
0.3624143898,
-0.0981647447,
-0.5738080144,
-0.1255594343,
-0.2563203573,
-0.2191587985,
0.3884632289,
0.6838353276,
-0.0826781318,
1.0448986292,
0.4552140832,
0.2249185443,
0.0529916435,
0.3417418599,
1.1727435589,
-0.5300660133,
-0.1631984413,
-0.5358219147,
0.4144087136,
0.0230929907,
-0.2668667138,
0.305321157,
0.3665645421,
0.7625911832,
-0.2192256302,
0.7922227383,
0.2611060143,
0.3111224473,
-0.5997310877,
0.915261209,
-0.6688399911,
0.6067759395,
0.156866923,
-0.8812068701,
-0.5499100685,
0.79493922,
-0.3757662475,
-0.014161828,
0.3900470436,
0.9284926653,
-0.2881521285,
-0.2882378697,
0.7529933453,
0.174345687,
0.4920927286,
0.5551069379,
0.6474267244,
-0.3219462931,
0.4261550307,
0.0421162695,
0.1037557796,
-0.4145650864,
-0.8348495364,
-1.391477108,
-0.3513571024,
-0.4614323378,
-0.0735354051,
0.3212999105,
0.9312095046,
0.8008435369,
-0.707475245,
-0.2652345896,
-0.0441286713,
-0.1431551576,
0.0494052023,
-0.1290525794,
0.3726070821,
-0.5907809734,
-0.2996762693,
0.6053696871,
0.1401741654,
-0.0289037563,
-0.0661772117,
-0.2829676867,
-0.0429041125,
0.1697277427,
0.7799881697,
0.1196021065,
-0.8048946857,
-0.4131425023,
-0.2379895747,
-0.1134726182,
0.2510590553,
0.853107512,
-0.5672269464,
0.1829693764,
-0.2380426079,
1.0571585894,
0.4755080938,
-0.3680700064,
0.6628224254,
-0.6478008032,
0.1779096723,
0.2652101815,
0.5419352055,
0.2371279001,
-0.5623209476,
0.6997638941,
0.1291874796,
-0.4056043923,
-0.6631205678,
0.1146630198,
-0.8429032564,
-0.4363382757,
1.2290561199,
-0.3435992002,
0.0051232693,
-0.368414104,
-0.2697319984,
0.278585583,
-0.2238574326,
1.0365575552,
0.5281618237,
0.1541443169,
-0.1539072245,
-1.0395621061,
0.3492686749,
0.3559065759,
-0.8088884354,
-0.03032979,
0.1880507916,
0.7234825492,
-0.2034932226,
0.7874339223,
-0.0961480588,
0.1455792636,
0.0173326004,
0.1425764263,
-0.3604970574,
-0.426630646,
-0.2726996541,
0.2492556125,
0.4282972515,
0.3405152857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15060v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15060v4 | Who Wrote this Code? Watermarking for Code Generation | 2023-05-24T11:49:52 | 2024-07-03T15:09:52 | Taehyun Lee, Seokhee Hong, Jaewoo Ahn, Ilgee Hong, Hwaran Lee, Sangdoo Yun, Jamin Shin, Gunhee Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Since the remarkable generation performance of large language models raised
ethical and legal concerns, approaches to detect machine-generated text by
embedding watermarks are being developed. However, we discover that the
existing works fail to function appropriately in code generation tasks due to
the task's nature of having low entropy. Extending a logit-modifying watermark
method, we propose Selective WatErmarking via Entropy Thresholding (SWEET),
which enhances detection ability and mitigates code quality degeneration by
removing low-entropy segments at generating and detecting watermarks. Our
experiments show that SWEET significantly improves code quality preservation
while outperforming all baselines, including post-hoc detection methods, in
detecting machine-generated code text. Our code is available in
https://github.com/hongcheki/sweet-watermark. | [
-0.1521994025,
-0.5855557323,
0.171113506,
0.1902671307,
-0.5031687021,
0.047611136,
-0.0412048027,
-0.5170689225,
0.2839742303,
0.7261018157,
-0.1709067971,
-0.438919723,
-0.4886456728,
0.1011033803,
-0.3106574118,
1.1643278599,
0.08100456,
-0.1517670155,
-0.1699110568,
0.1128999367,
-0.7046621442,
-0.5456296206,
-0.4345541298,
-0.0817277804,
0.078321442,
0.3818600476,
0.5322460532,
0.7819063067,
0.6214413643,
0.1982775778,
-0.0490902662,
0.1809184104,
-0.4708696902,
0.441629082,
0.222295627,
-0.7311981916,
-0.2798148096,
-0.2583078146,
0.3732111454,
-0.078084901,
0.402813673,
0.1764240414,
0.0166463181,
0.7894425392,
-1.1523503065,
0.0827153176,
-1.0816458464,
0.1714984626,
-0.3029382825,
-0.5896303654,
-0.4903962314,
-0.3814158738,
-0.7424297333,
-0.149431318,
0.0265795644,
0.1043938175,
0.9795420766,
0.6880811453,
-0.1201295927,
-0.3957771063,
-0.550532341,
1.0046720505,
-0.7454568148,
0.1212945729,
0.8326194882,
-0.2304737717,
-0.0171442349,
-0.6595784426,
-0.2918508053,
-0.1445854753,
0.1980988085,
-0.0175520554,
-0.3731799126,
-0.321469754,
0.2776698172,
0.3805487752,
-0.5761855245,
-0.184668079,
-0.3910743892,
-0.3625076711,
0.6749356389,
0.2317980975,
0.5372649431,
-0.1361855716,
-0.197572425,
0.1982379556,
-0.66773206,
0.1327972263,
0.4907910228,
0.1747825146,
0.0539190099,
0.3022626936,
0.1307468563,
0.5345765352,
-0.1817952543,
0.0635563359,
0.1781346649,
-0.098599501,
-0.2155750394,
0.2514181137,
0.6310857534,
0.4554107189,
0.3575487435,
0.0248661563,
-0.5158940554,
0.1510099024,
0.1163787767,
-1.053385973,
-0.5580943227,
0.0210023429,
-0.7187033296,
-0.6245855689,
0.3123981357,
-0.2871657908,
-0.5507026911,
0.0552949235,
0.129824087,
-0.3315015137,
-0.3461374044,
0.0430659689,
-0.5495220423,
0.061845161,
-0.1148822531,
-0.7634170651,
-0.0335501693,
0.6213796139,
0.4886668921,
0.092638351,
-0.1943173409,
-0.7714897394,
0.2372142673,
-0.5901142955,
0.6933585405,
-0.7816432118,
-0.2989939749,
-0.2017833143,
-0.2104284167,
0.2887955606,
-0.7358855605,
0.2574703991,
-0.8666461706,
-0.0535378009,
-0.229310751,
-0.5602852106,
0.4233857989,
-0.0552965552,
-0.7039356232,
0.9425111413,
0.1851915419,
-1.0135396719,
0.8370986581,
-0.5946281552,
-0.4850823581,
0.4130124748,
-0.16167216,
-0.7407922745,
0.2458250523,
-0.0198368914,
0.1542771459,
-0.1670160741,
0.1991062909,
-0.071655646,
-0.4101679623,
0.4723492265,
-0.2813482583,
0.7669604421,
0.5881665945,
-0.4875772297,
0.1256839335,
-0.7172428966,
0.3138538301,
0.4329641461,
-0.6086515784,
-0.6995332837,
-0.169657886,
0.1059948429,
-0.0308184493,
0.4188983142,
-0.2564654052,
-0.0138803245,
-0.1104126498,
0.4570274055,
0.8998287916,
0.2521946728,
0.2460816205,
-0.2820739448,
0.6831101179,
0.1261920482,
0.2177388817,
-0.2678243816,
-0.6797599792,
-0.4592222571,
-0.3185097873,
0.6908237338,
0.6473107934,
-0.626858294,
0.6898592114,
0.132709831,
-0.2406187207,
-0.4791163802,
0.672611773,
0.5618939996,
0.0495668538,
0.2330986857,
-0.3511607349,
-0.5606445074,
-0.7075363994,
-0.4768767655,
-0.2948775291,
-0.0235397518,
0.144401595,
0.5471524596,
-0.3730675578,
0.9373560548,
-0.7508768439,
0.1731839478,
-0.0188810378,
-0.0170052182,
-0.0792281181,
0.9964267612,
0.7558148503,
-0.7933590412,
-0.5102921128,
-0.1316068619,
-0.5819746256,
-0.3582604825,
0.0507482626,
-0.4465494752,
0.2247796804,
0.5442717671,
-0.2243483067,
0.6183611155,
0.4573846161,
-0.6316512227,
0.6296724677,
0.0202609953,
0.5119880438,
-1.0395317078,
0.2994325459,
-0.3188872933,
-0.1307587475,
-0.3732916713,
0.3881604075,
0.2997455597,
-0.3352993429,
-0.3262548149,
0.4676034153,
-0.3480211198,
0.3837680817,
-0.6752089858,
-0.4944541454,
0.1870788187,
0.2001078427,
-0.2925049961,
0.739605844,
0.6949326396,
-0.5435490012,
0.0644844472,
0.0533243716,
-0.2951599658,
0.7060608864,
-0.6326866746,
0.392344147,
-0.0718795657,
-0.1675599515,
-0.7665039897,
-0.1039164811,
0.2851375639,
-0.556895256,
0.205281198,
-0.531724751,
-0.6513034105,
-0.1125222743,
-0.3844704926,
0.4471550584,
0.8256517649,
-0.1562106609,
-0.1759735942,
0.3839155436,
0.0314374194,
-0.1974552572,
-1.1825019121,
0.2886763513,
-0.3914050758,
-0.6034882069,
0.4216940999,
-0.1889965683,
-0.5312443972,
0.2059990317,
-0.4479118288,
-0.3730736077,
0.3531883955,
0.2006047815,
-0.0424886197,
-0.3047615886,
-0.0189560149,
0.2365574241,
-0.3485787511,
-0.0273296852,
-0.3710647225,
0.5383623838,
0.0207129214,
-0.2296411097,
-0.485393554,
0.5012321472,
0.5123900771,
-0.5006487966,
0.4534059465,
0.5129083991,
-0.7069460154,
-0.5079065561,
-0.1702681035,
-0.2458869219,
-0.5206298232,
0.0005526393,
-0.3090594113,
-0.9028024077,
0.5278656483,
0.2162818313,
-0.0388565026,
0.3314162195,
0.2393271625,
0.2090842873,
0.7660898566,
0.8279697299,
-0.3135454357,
0.7153330445,
-0.0803835541,
0.2467078567,
-0.3420173526,
0.0139788771,
-0.8689081669,
-0.2192462087,
-0.5388692617,
-0.3312570453,
0.0542162508,
0.5900759101,
-0.3125702143,
0.4946865141,
-0.9606885314,
0.7547749281,
0.9169549942,
0.3170008361,
0.1174466908,
0.0164828096,
0.2305460423,
0.0440983288,
-0.4165627658,
-0.5256823897,
0.6304373145,
0.0565624237,
0.8662282825,
-0.2343863994,
1.2420372963,
0.903182745,
-0.1009319201,
-0.3048709631,
0.3819215596,
-0.0583619773,
-0.8654071689,
-0.1001307592,
-0.6479353905,
-1.0977419615,
-0.3661644161,
0.2542717755,
-0.5139613152,
-0.0000662139,
0.2648413777,
-0.2654762566,
0.3108454347,
-0.7482626438,
0.9763125777,
-0.2534989119,
-0.3427568376,
-0.2777953744,
-0.375231564,
0.2243835777,
-0.2364966422,
0.118407622,
-0.1006858796,
0.0129597876,
0.9814544916,
-0.6550323963,
0.6721084118,
-0.5950074792,
-0.3735121489,
0.7932545543,
0.6148170233,
0.506446898,
0.1553211212,
-0.1258603036,
-0.1379769593,
-0.109587647,
-0.7343503833,
-0.2857385874,
0.7154904008,
-0.1912186444,
-0.3952611685,
-0.0313711092,
-0.1952110529,
0.0411170647,
0.4240143299,
0.4121676981,
0.2663628757,
0.3188995123,
0.1563364267,
0.288115412,
-0.3444996476,
0.6088083386,
0.0656404048,
0.1059421152,
-0.7663229704,
1.2405440807,
-0.1869331747,
-0.110148713,
0.2887270153,
0.2569639981,
0.2450050414,
-0.6406695247,
-0.3389899731,
-0.2590628564,
-0.7469585538,
-0.6866083741,
-0.2468084097,
-0.258141309,
-0.3048057258,
-0.5813287497,
-0.32395643,
-0.2328384221,
-0.3511888981,
0.0385801345,
0.6322120428,
0.5993973017,
-0.0074727791,
0.2012105286,
-0.9476391077,
0.3854956627,
0.1951828897,
0.5497424006,
-0.1628597379,
-0.3005018532,
-0.4901810884,
-0.0266258158,
-0.2887731194,
-0.6583664417,
0.1806273311,
-0.0034980057,
0.354637444,
0.4586710334,
0.3072020411,
0.612498343,
-0.3251055181,
1.044885993,
0.4664699733,
-1.2838203907,
0.9395731688,
-0.0206312276,
0.2930393219,
0.6510412693,
-0.168126449,
-0.0356820859,
-0.7786908746,
-0.4246766269,
-0.9517211318,
0.3640578091,
0.3908179998,
0.4573196173,
-0.0586673133,
0.1237913221,
0.3876792192,
0.2662055492,
-0.5675464869,
-0.1495563388,
-0.2845415175,
-0.0029543138,
0.4992594421,
-0.3704136908,
0.200893864,
-0.0513638146,
0.4984772503,
0.0509446524,
0.3583002985,
-0.0628265738,
-0.2227877378,
-0.4025796354,
0.2175396085,
0.5881230235,
0.5297700763,
-0.0344622843,
0.3406050503,
-0.3589344025,
-0.4723776877,
-0.0686979592,
-0.2058217973,
-0.4246300161,
-0.0909693763,
0.570713222,
0.8216859698,
-0.2959426045,
-0.6351470351,
0.3632846177,
0.0487342216,
-0.1505015641,
0.2318526655,
0.5899848342,
-0.2591662407,
0.0963552743,
0.5198956132,
0.4430715144,
0.0764673501,
-0.2957181334,
0.4787156582,
0.3651515841,
-0.2847235799,
-0.4293097854,
1.0387220383,
0.2308683544,
-0.3360758722,
0.4555447996,
-0.3572978079,
-0.5057193041,
0.6739301085,
0.7862682343,
1.1657571793,
-0.0662180558,
0.0140295932,
0.1638014913,
0.3861312866,
0.2419045419,
0.8729544282,
-0.4202862382,
-0.5768951178,
-0.219394803,
-0.6773081422,
0.0228301995,
0.0603698529,
-0.3249571621,
0.2512631416,
-0.4667666852,
-0.4363307059,
-0.1302776784,
-0.1610108167,
-0.4705374837,
0.1459335387,
0.4121555686,
0.6996868253,
-0.7904487848,
0.4650555253,
0.6714261174,
-0.3683196604,
-0.4096625447,
0.5339710712,
-0.2119527459,
-0.678730011,
0.4285551012,
0.058214765,
-0.1286256462,
0.0618057884,
-1.009540081,
-0.5357025862,
0.53283149,
0.5927983522,
-0.0224174261,
0.3636333644,
-0.0417360216,
0.2942962348,
0.0780440569,
-0.314209938,
0.2434572726,
0.6289254427,
-0.4029748142,
-0.7651041746,
0.390882194,
-0.7993791103,
0.0339672528,
0.2335282564,
-0.4950273037,
0.3220199049,
-0.2596705556,
-0.1259108186,
0.1629416198,
0.3651096821,
0.5254738331,
0.5407484174,
0.2336973399,
0.4785144925,
0.8238118291,
0.0244329032,
0.7734025717,
-0.7861278057,
0.0703803003,
0.5633461475,
-0.3317367136,
0.401094377,
0.5322512388,
-0.1343710274,
0.323410064,
0.5015807152,
-0.3912210166,
0.7071643472,
0.5927696824,
-0.1260285676,
-0.2194656134,
-0.2719737291,
-0.5962332487,
0.3070414066,
-0.0112478593,
-0.6018054485,
0.1785031855,
-0.0489978567,
0.1753195822,
0.0068411236,
-0.2780086398,
0.6211255789,
0.168786034,
-0.3994085491,
0.9946767688,
0.2411826253,
0.8554413915,
-0.2279443443,
0.0615668334,
-0.3205040991,
0.0569667779,
-0.438467145,
-0.7183610201,
0.3617957234,
0.3762491047,
-0.2907017469,
-0.3328336775,
0.9626494646,
-0.0971363038,
-0.2534030974,
-0.0017575225,
0.3063308597,
0.294172585,
-0.1000188738,
-0.7236011028,
0.4010124803,
0.0251854733,
-0.1624807715,
0.055438228,
0.6761733294,
-0.0192437153,
0.3093132377,
0.6211946011,
-0.0652018189,
0.0980623066,
0.1799540222,
0.7283008099,
-0.8830194473,
-0.8714439273,
-1.1983617544,
0.5828070045,
0.0783165172,
-0.4382133186,
0.7470870018,
1.1026524305,
0.7926545739,
-0.5802357197,
1.0790789127,
-0.3602632582,
-0.5794337988,
-0.5655633807,
0.9081862569,
-0.5965781808,
0.0001863652,
-0.7772789598,
-0.7704450488,
-0.7114626169,
0.1970648021,
0.0383480042,
0.2194273919,
0.6392470598,
0.9328813553,
0.0325276256,
-0.1866300255,
0.5103862882,
-0.3707360327,
0.3813487887,
0.4244504869,
1.0691033602,
-0.459474206,
0.5410258174,
-0.23624672,
-0.1751117855,
-0.1508970559,
-0.8089206219,
-0.8702721,
-0.7124085426,
-0.7273192406,
-0.5884289742,
0.0700033829,
0.853731811,
0.884680748,
-1.1477999687,
0.0456870869,
-0.4005134404,
0.3036429286,
-0.3176450133,
-0.2981695831,
0.4025788903,
-0.4724971056,
-0.4037874043,
0.2332408428,
0.2336603105,
0.2280973792,
0.1368253529,
-0.3406254053,
0.5437296033,
0.2005128264,
0.3554027677,
0.1099638194,
-0.3139300942,
0.0964095965,
0.0347718708,
-0.2857716382,
-0.0024462063,
1.2078690529,
-0.3664420843,
0.1294103563,
0.8598108292,
0.6432700157,
0.0741247088,
0.0331612229,
0.178716898,
-0.7120501995,
0.0240833275,
0.3385492265,
0.2705132365,
0.1612846255,
-0.596547544,
0.3292416632,
0.5715342164,
-0.5586451888,
-1.2319376469,
0.1284583211,
-0.5499256253,
-0.5130717158,
1.1364374161,
0.0839584619,
-0.2780896127,
-0.0279568695,
-0.2976839542,
-0.002327889,
-0.5884417892,
0.8663144112,
0.3944995105,
0.0631069764,
0.0357853137,
-0.2846316993,
0.6013245583,
0.1295670867,
-0.892824173,
0.1101815253,
0.4336502552,
0.3733363748,
0.1176187173,
0.6088020205,
-0.1925751716,
0.4215996861,
0.3793370724,
0.3893659115,
-0.0972070619,
-0.3724429011,
0.0263084527,
0.2129218876,
0.3840056062,
-0.497064054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15057v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15057v2 | Linear-Time Modeling of Linguistic Structure: An Order-Theoretic Perspective | 2023-05-24T11:47:35 | 2023-12-12T08:46:11 | Tianyu Liu, Afra Amini, Mrinmaya Sachan, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tasks that model the relation between pairs of tokens in a string are a vital
part of understanding natural language. Such tasks, in general, require
exhaustive pair-wise comparisons of tokens, thus having a quadratic runtime
complexity in the length of the string. We show that these exhaustive
comparisons can be avoided, and, moreover, the complexity of such tasks can be
reduced to linear by casting the relation between tokens as a partial order
over the string. Our method predicts real numbers for each token in a string in
parallel and sorts the tokens accordingly, resulting in total orders of the
tokens in the string. Each total order implies a set of arcs oriented from
smaller to greater tokens, sorted by their predicted numbers. The intersection
of total orders results in a partial order over the set of tokens in the
string, which is then decoded into a directed graph representing the desired
linguistic structure. Our experiments on dependency parsing and coreference
resolution show that our method achieves state-of-the-art or comparable
performance. Moreover, the linear complexity and parallelism of our method
double the speed of graph-based coreference resolution models, and bring a
10-times speed-up over graph-based dependency parsers. | [
-0.1079179049,
-1.0243477821,
0.5560112,
0.3063772023,
-0.4288925529,
0.2748102844,
-0.2362538129,
-0.8834403753,
0.2150934339,
0.33632496,
-0.1176648736,
-0.4437305331,
-0.6137802601,
0.0483806059,
-0.5394922495,
0.7955845594,
0.0657721236,
0.1075336486,
-0.0423137136,
-0.3293916285,
-0.1190553457,
-0.7057121992,
-0.5650179982,
-0.4714723825,
0.64187181,
0.0475634858,
0.94524014,
1.263023138,
0.3903897703,
0.4455057979,
-0.6260845065,
-0.0730248913,
-0.4411639869,
0.2760708332,
-0.2091779709,
-0.5751718879,
-0.4617505372,
0.1540511549,
0.446598202,
1.3630136251,
0.0242111497,
0.39019081,
-0.147781238,
0.4957605302,
-0.1742213815,
0.4622086585,
-0.5031043887,
0.0003050239,
-0.1898302436,
-0.179934442,
-0.4584612846,
-0.3005636632,
0.3417400718,
-0.2884149551,
0.2249413729,
0.5209210515,
0.9080016017,
-0.0535614528,
-0.3138467371,
-0.4293076694,
-0.9331493378,
0.5934519172,
-0.6140768528,
0.546092093,
0.2869760096,
0.0444532819,
-0.2419994771,
-0.7325896621,
-0.5284600258,
-0.2903957665,
-0.2622895539,
-0.2514879704,
0.1014819369,
0.5606004596,
0.407025367,
0.6330811381,
-0.6653447747,
0.1357406825,
-0.3304879963,
0.045652315,
0.26988253,
0.1782553792,
0.4273318946,
-0.4414183795,
-0.3243362904,
0.1641692966,
-0.4013594389,
0.2198934704,
0.1865466237,
0.4732345045,
0.0937673524,
0.7064911127,
-0.0094814384,
0.8298707008,
0.2593811452,
-0.2477401793,
0.1507802904,
-0.6534315944,
-0.3373310864,
0.072096318,
0.7136228681,
0.0126156705,
0.2270541787,
-0.2650292814,
-0.0459984541,
0.4874449074,
-0.0107123461,
-0.6040640473,
-0.2036097497,
0.3290740848,
-0.4258772433,
-0.2970727384,
-0.219441697,
-0.5762871504,
-0.0203758162,
-0.6765086651,
0.0897629634,
-0.4606140852,
-0.0247987341,
0.1819916517,
0.4374718666,
-0.0372757912,
0.1123695001,
-0.8270446062,
0.7959693074,
0.9366875291,
0.9090042114,
0.1158345789,
-0.1525451839,
-0.5523483753,
-0.0554019287,
-0.3675551116,
0.5250444412,
-0.8069764376,
-0.2108346969,
-0.2767196,
-0.442509681,
0.0519549251,
-0.2972619832,
0.7055473328,
-0.4711191356,
0.3012079298,
-0.2101622373,
-0.7230787277,
-0.2206896842,
0.0126154097,
-0.451620698,
1.1206395626,
-0.1013373509,
-0.8649277091,
0.0070913662,
-0.2993090451,
-0.6395255923,
0.0882865861,
-0.2302206308,
-0.1853867769,
0.3052302003,
0.1494013369,
0.3478240967,
-0.2877574563,
0.3621378243,
-0.3097945452,
-0.2096396685,
-0.2111204118,
0.0484674573,
0.9244536161,
0.1617071331,
-0.4111163318,
0.1942118257,
-0.8497076631,
0.2049141079,
0.0712991953,
-0.3084204793,
-0.7836952209,
0.3846904039,
-0.1517912149,
0.38641271,
0.0894095823,
-0.6616695523,
0.1679206342,
-1.0151071548,
0.6314837337,
0.8580191731,
-0.3367307782,
0.7213586569,
0.1757276505,
0.2587034702,
0.0059520286,
0.314396888,
-0.1203924417,
-0.5254500508,
-1.0438917875,
-0.0439407006,
0.3715217412,
0.4957284331,
-0.5539224148,
0.3705203533,
-0.424503386,
-0.3851204515,
-0.197684288,
-0.137648344,
0.8954301476,
0.5413643122,
0.2032952309,
-0.4188911021,
-0.6524514556,
-0.7398937941,
-0.2300747186,
-0.6400204897,
0.173052609,
0.3055361509,
0.2542464137,
0.2774493694,
0.8182410598,
-0.6251920462,
0.2823283672,
-0.087501891,
0.2826845348,
0.6392528415,
0.2933549583,
0.6633037329,
-0.6706853509,
-0.4175434709,
0.154416889,
-0.463214606,
-0.0837345421,
0.2717393637,
-0.1912965626,
-0.048000548,
0.2280329615,
-0.6749964952,
0.342187345,
0.3558844626,
-0.6585803032,
0.5872948766,
-0.158648327,
-0.3130590022,
-0.9441577196,
0.0331723318,
-0.2860646546,
-0.4840710759,
-1.0071672201,
0.0683864579,
-0.175804168,
-0.1735976636,
-0.0671021938,
0.3652004302,
-0.5088157058,
-0.4589426517,
-0.0595981441,
0.1119670942,
0.0869003832,
0.7509248853,
-0.1996014416,
0.4596956372,
0.2348354906,
-0.6209901571,
0.2203336656,
0.0767804012,
-0.4347569346,
0.4232181907,
-0.8583417535,
0.2618899345,
-0.2901515365,
-0.0511494875,
-1.0534703732,
0.2821010649,
0.320636481,
-0.436781317,
0.2357025445,
-0.2200811356,
-0.6960641146,
-0.3910475373,
0.2673599124,
0.7293990254,
0.2747042477,
-0.4078243077,
0.6327605247,
0.2712297142,
-0.3761116266,
-0.5903535485,
-0.2667773664,
0.0104707163,
0.1055341512,
-0.5881968141,
0.5818521976,
-0.1282710582,
-0.6559081078,
0.038821999,
-0.2503708005,
-0.0245373789,
0.0307549611,
0.2423592508,
0.1961430311,
-0.3628988564,
0.0277568996,
-0.1514298618,
0.0131203542,
-0.0077964449,
-0.7249442935,
0.6358667016,
-0.3065488935,
-0.0201625545,
-0.1534965187,
0.4917773306,
0.6782839894,
-0.3543142676,
0.5761534572,
0.0269157384,
-0.2978494465,
-0.1944769621,
-0.5401827097,
0.1403549761,
-0.453132391,
0.132852152,
-0.4807704091,
-0.6796678305,
0.6414782405,
0.2462177128,
0.3063474,
0.2075731158,
0.4406555295,
-0.0924203545,
0.9044159651,
0.5247930288,
-0.2130624652,
0.6912484169,
-0.1797627211,
0.4065784812,
-0.2363008112,
-0.0640380755,
-0.6945201159,
-0.3291258216,
-0.3701795936,
-0.3815637231,
0.0623050965,
0.2789343596,
-0.1635427475,
0.7037185431,
-0.3716610372,
0.6823062301,
0.3768028617,
0.000745247,
0.409930706,
0.143555671,
-0.6859482527,
0.0678320602,
-0.4690836072,
-0.1791962087,
0.5904650688,
0.2069927007,
0.375403285,
0.0399600714,
0.4412419498,
0.0599195622,
-0.1494881213,
-0.9656636715,
0.6440394521,
-0.4119116366,
-0.3972595632,
-0.2757509053,
-0.5712558031,
-0.9431708455,
0.5005315542,
0.2359835356,
-0.7149415016,
0.249938339,
0.1108157486,
-0.0844091699,
0.2912859619,
-0.816356957,
0.4336833358,
-0.3932558298,
-0.2007924169,
-0.2290753424,
-0.7793941498,
0.2734992802,
0.2877307534,
0.4088719487,
-0.2873475552,
0.255635649,
0.8188256621,
-0.7833099365,
0.7829294801,
0.0128184706,
0.0808829516,
0.1170345619,
0.4524546862,
0.5993093848,
-0.1717903018,
-0.0312043689,
0.0397000834,
-0.0030725277,
-0.6192964315,
-0.7916857004,
0.662537992,
-0.6431444883,
-0.4070829153,
-0.3893418908,
-0.5936951637,
-0.0557803288,
0.4024800956,
0.0692729279,
0.9761512876,
0.2035676241,
-0.4278834462,
0.3573920131,
0.0972525403,
0.4474570155,
0.2374211848,
-0.3644410968,
-0.5295481086,
0.6958281398,
0.5403561592,
0.2821825147,
0.5500873923,
0.2595468462,
-0.2513903975,
-0.6862053871,
-0.0594013073,
0.6006174684,
-0.6918483377,
0.0496899709,
-0.6190365553,
-0.0741653442,
-0.2691980898,
0.1273230612,
-0.4142692089,
-0.7420305014,
-0.0361950621,
-0.298215121,
0.2311710268,
1.071957469,
0.3758600652,
0.0988389477,
-0.4672080576,
0.2811042368,
0.0577675141,
0.5536344051,
0.1101968139,
-0.2985808849,
-0.2961322367,
-0.3247007728,
0.0762000754,
-0.6914803982,
0.3419984579,
0.130719915,
0.3912548721,
0.3675050437,
0.0495176986,
1.0631181002,
-0.946929574,
0.611269176,
0.2088061869,
-1.2632039785,
0.3080480397,
-0.3279789686,
0.1132029369,
0.2786051333,
0.1619829684,
-0.6236092448,
-0.315879643,
-0.5479347706,
-1.0482711792,
0.6904229522,
0.6276407838,
-0.1673737466,
-0.084663786,
0.7029548883,
-0.0936446115,
0.1198423877,
-0.5795927644,
-0.6066682339,
-0.1001794934,
-0.1051333994,
-0.2656176388,
-0.5946145654,
0.1396012455,
-0.4634671807,
0.2855928242,
0.1480365098,
0.4278424978,
0.1631513685,
-0.1975891739,
0.0257137939,
0.2502083778,
0.8089860678,
0.9053048491,
-0.2253210843,
0.5826630592,
-0.1474211663,
-0.3051263094,
0.2518459857,
-0.0024181623,
-0.0574188605,
0.3547667861,
0.5454052687,
0.8874059319,
0.6012197733,
-0.3370093405,
0.2211363316,
0.0850902274,
0.1447054446,
-0.0726891086,
-0.5834655762,
0.0029612377,
0.1661859602,
0.1212058142,
0.0858902037,
0.1611714661,
-0.4042136371,
0.2826811075,
0.0616413131,
-0.2876247764,
-0.796327889,
0.472551614,
0.1782541126,
-0.5487626791,
0.5137637854,
-0.0219638366,
-0.7661149502,
0.5681022406,
0.4698545933,
0.7981399894,
-0.3598143458,
0.0914026573,
0.3620347083,
0.0672326162,
-0.1142126173,
0.4550885558,
-0.1995400339,
-0.5177301168,
-0.7418384552,
-0.9173651934,
-0.1735734493,
-0.1535975188,
-0.6933550239,
0.1046124995,
-0.8082258105,
-0.2454859465,
0.4056077302,
-0.0186758917,
-0.4138791561,
-0.0611254871,
0.0562431812,
0.6563231349,
-0.5536651611,
0.8561633229,
0.4602454305,
-0.2080353945,
-0.7732025981,
-0.2437582165,
-0.1086512804,
-0.4871554971,
0.983335495,
0.1493987739,
-0.1804784983,
-0.0805437937,
-0.2307692021,
-1.1403799057,
0.6970201135,
0.4904400408,
-0.5701076388,
-0.6438522935,
0.1057801992,
0.777723372,
-0.2919704318,
0.2801766098,
0.3182321191,
0.0590533614,
0.0435405076,
-1.1592200994,
-0.014653651,
-0.3796432912,
0.4340396821,
0.5902308822,
-0.3111284673,
1.1335191727,
0.0400987677,
-0.5702052116,
0.062446285,
0.7438209653,
-0.1679248065,
0.0248422939,
0.8206378818,
0.5004520416,
0.7107734084,
0.0647318065,
1.0012007952,
-0.4815381765,
0.5941905379,
1.2761614323,
-0.2469045073,
0.8295046687,
0.5020496249,
-0.492036283,
0.5676947832,
0.5386811495,
0.3175235093,
0.1377872825,
0.4095804691,
-0.1377483308,
-0.1863722205,
-0.3521800339,
-0.0744228289,
0.2891558111,
0.3633365631,
-0.5878002644,
-0.3313107193,
-0.0886197984,
0.1236848608,
0.2994311154,
-0.2883036435,
0.5992215872,
0.2304155678,
-0.5044028759,
0.8705534935,
0.0184392128,
0.2577404082,
-0.3921945095,
0.0698796883,
-0.1594252437,
0.1922032833,
-0.015655404,
-0.5077922344,
0.313041985,
-0.072903201,
-0.4616624117,
-0.3902412653,
0.2524937391,
-0.4846924841,
-0.6467486024,
0.820035398,
0.2239221483,
0.0148197031,
0.3602957129,
-0.6674345136,
-0.1115967929,
-0.3665707111,
-0.3034898639,
0.017861411,
0.1109042615,
-0.0793791115,
0.4521655142,
0.5236791968,
0.0508635044,
0.3939936757,
0.0076438366,
0.8684069514,
-0.5784885287,
-0.6147243381,
-0.9771339893,
-0.0342418477,
-0.0193161462,
0.0494394079,
0.5596991777,
0.5770882964,
0.9247304797,
0.1898320168,
0.3482050896,
-0.1267634332,
0.5066986084,
-0.5244012475,
0.272844851,
-0.3273061514,
0.2937431335,
-0.4552482963,
-0.8843969107,
-0.5499367118,
0.3180223405,
-0.4880657494,
-0.2837097943,
0.7788054943,
0.6136752367,
-0.0979088768,
-0.0852594823,
0.3994655013,
0.5495694876,
0.2969069183,
0.5143219233,
0.5638318062,
-0.3420139849,
0.7668135762,
-0.6116330624,
-0.0537471958,
0.1581358761,
-0.4362262189,
-1.0415273905,
-0.6686781645,
0.0368378609,
-0.5994067192,
0.0716776848,
1.2156023979,
0.6733635068,
-0.8568263054,
-0.5371077061,
-0.2012530416,
0.2655798495,
-0.385576725,
-0.1917306334,
0.522294879,
-0.3836004734,
-0.9356858134,
0.3725185394,
0.4981820583,
-0.1013945267,
-0.0313664377,
0.1919938326,
-0.5434244275,
0.1457594931,
0.9892526269,
0.2260844111,
-1.3066564798,
-0.5237361193,
0.1625503153,
-0.2058165967,
0.3676190376,
1.0409604311,
-0.6422811151,
0.5370581746,
1.0320911407,
0.4334518313,
0.4363439977,
0.1041666716,
0.753390491,
-0.7188511491,
0.1472192556,
0.064986974,
0.5158677101,
-0.0439191535,
-0.364477694,
0.5117473602,
0.5571257472,
-0.2842214406,
-0.8449752331,
0.7422243357,
-1.139475584,
-0.2888649702,
0.8347740769,
-0.4104037583,
-0.4870222211,
-0.4401483834,
-0.2014009356,
0.2740067542,
-0.2968287766,
0.4578600228,
0.5542231202,
-0.0292098895,
-0.1265920848,
-0.0753685459,
0.3116045594,
0.503043592,
-0.345454216,
0.1818692386,
0.3062717617,
0.2445561737,
0.5268387794,
0.4742842019,
-0.1096495092,
-0.2755002379,
-0.2519211471,
-0.179200992,
-0.049114801,
-0.40764606,
-0.2629403472,
0.4581667185,
0.0565322302,
0.0131829511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15056v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15056v1 | Reasoning over Hierarchical Question Decomposition Tree for Explainable Question Answering | 2023-05-24T11:45:59 | 2023-05-24T11:45:59 | Jiajie Zhang, Shulin Cao, Tingjia Zhang, Xin Lv, Jiaxin Shi, Qi Tian, Juanzi Li, Lei Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Explainable question answering (XQA) aims to answer a given question and
provide an explanation why the answer is selected. Existing XQA methods focus
on reasoning on a single knowledge source, e.g., structured knowledge bases,
unstructured corpora, etc. However, integrating information from heterogeneous
knowledge sources is essential to answer complex questions. In this paper, we
propose to leverage question decomposing for heterogeneous knowledge
integration, by breaking down a complex question into simpler ones, and
selecting the appropriate knowledge source for each sub-question. To facilitate
reasoning, we propose a novel two-stage XQA framework, Reasoning over
Hierarchical Question Decomposition Tree (RoHT). First, we build the
Hierarchical Question Decomposition Tree (HQDT) to understand the semantics of
a complex question; then, we conduct probabilistic reasoning over HQDT from
root to leaves recursively, to aggregate heterogeneous knowledge at different
tree levels and search for a best solution considering the decomposing and
answering probabilities. The experiments on complex QA datasets KQA Pro and
Musique show that our framework outperforms SOTA methods significantly,
demonstrating the effectiveness of leveraging question decomposing for
knowledge integration and our RoHT framework. | [
-0.5710449815,
-0.9971777201,
0.6816673875,
-0.1350414157,
-0.0763709322,
0.3574837148,
0.1646475196,
-0.4471681118,
-0.2634716332,
0.2668940425,
-0.8677498698,
-0.4389830232,
0.023868192,
-0.4045793712,
-0.3952336907,
0.6883898973,
-0.1046897694,
-0.2585006058,
-0.4353941977,
-0.2367485315,
-0.3464161456,
-0.3061720133,
-0.679839313,
-0.3561728001,
0.3971653283,
0.7623200417,
0.9080791473,
0.5440062284,
0.0950117111,
0.1899047941,
-0.1883263737,
0.1322760433,
-0.2436386198,
0.1927545518,
-0.5032530427,
-0.6946630478,
-0.2341010123,
-0.2376575172,
0.5110414624,
0.8566808701,
-0.2046706378,
0.4425141811,
-0.1717017293,
0.0996870175,
-0.4708203673,
0.1233575493,
-0.4847455323,
0.2445567846,
0.0436040089,
-0.6746715903,
-0.1354467124,
-0.4587953389,
0.1084184572,
-0.5503037572,
0.0857825875,
0.029444309,
0.7517536879,
0.3062968254,
-0.3798547089,
-0.0845244676,
-0.7023732662,
0.5842604637,
-0.3353427947,
0.5205084085,
0.3862578869,
0.766338706,
0.0234140791,
-0.689185977,
-0.6945420504,
0.131335482,
-0.0325079337,
0.2776430547,
-0.2388629615,
-0.1270268708,
0.0079346113,
0.4663528502,
-0.6881707311,
-0.0988600627,
0.0155676426,
-0.145980373,
0.2832508981,
0.1906145513,
0.5812038779,
-0.4663980603,
-0.4495900571,
-0.0384458825,
-0.6400921941,
0.3845093846,
0.2321670204,
0.1853910238,
0.3516500294,
0.3969933689,
-0.0710356385,
0.2718469203,
0.0490415357,
-0.2444477081,
-0.1625547558,
-0.4288025498,
-0.2197586894,
-0.072548084,
0.1370945424,
0.0372173302,
-0.0120358067,
-0.2604584098,
-0.0051495065,
-0.0445575565,
-0.0075498479,
-0.5152904391,
-0.1841783822,
0.6714167595,
-0.4491167963,
-0.0484904461,
-0.360812515,
-0.4966551363,
0.0073380484,
0.0082094213,
0.5499104261,
-0.4392655492,
-0.5195109248,
0.1553153247,
-0.2004189342,
0.2942931652,
0.5083260536,
-0.5661454797,
0.361007005,
0.6718947291,
0.1191188395,
0.260817647,
-0.0621656664,
-0.6633443832,
0.1162571907,
-0.2382283807,
0.7693404555,
-0.4071924686,
-0.026387874,
0.0009877792,
-0.1764530838,
-0.0427022465,
-0.7000329494,
0.6073260307,
-0.924066484,
0.6388298869,
-0.2354291379,
-0.3318374157,
-0.3930462003,
0.5864129066,
-0.4098905325,
0.9320555925,
0.3803058267,
-1.0246521235,
0.3636630774,
-0.6523936391,
-0.2977398038,
0.1008968726,
-0.2373483032,
-0.3630734682,
-0.3125284612,
0.2950724959,
0.23034136,
-0.5349623561,
0.4001703858,
0.0280236248,
-0.1193618625,
-0.195446834,
-0.120456256,
1.0792623758,
0.3198298812,
-0.4499473274,
0.1192421615,
-0.6819175482,
0.4349854589,
0.0485844649,
-0.4522523582,
-0.3816177845,
0.0782865509,
-0.2357517481,
0.3369865119,
-0.1456098557,
-0.4469300807,
0.0506191254,
-0.2770415843,
0.422008425,
0.3456456959,
0.316632241,
0.4833748937,
-0.2345912009,
0.8756973743,
0.194068253,
0.1447306871,
0.0026971719,
-0.5509102345,
-0.3381052017,
-0.096955955,
0.3025968373,
0.6796267033,
-0.9119454622,
0.0376166105,
-0.0860391855,
-0.3207149804,
-0.5276289582,
-0.3210370839,
0.4079805315,
0.8164860606,
0.6313300729,
0.3506744206,
-0.6038357615,
-0.979855895,
-0.1403891593,
-0.4878692031,
-0.2060531527,
0.0941030532,
0.4825193286,
-0.1596439183,
1.1536874771,
-0.4646948874,
0.1269703954,
-0.4384571612,
0.3012388349,
-0.0944543034,
0.4813276529,
0.2798417807,
-1.0737199783,
-0.0621349104,
0.1749713421,
-0.6824204922,
-0.0301621668,
-0.3326148987,
-0.2842127681,
-0.1931925565,
0.3705946505,
-0.710046351,
0.3876932561,
0.1441949606,
-0.3839736283,
0.8596788645,
0.1514918357,
0.2800565362,
-0.8258812428,
0.0145069677,
-0.3536884487,
-0.4297823906,
-0.3119303882,
0.5273650885,
-0.0506738722,
0.0029617499,
-0.1164908633,
0.2788989544,
-0.3672741055,
-0.1555093825,
0.1830805242,
0.1798911542,
0.1535979509,
0.634196341,
0.2087667286,
0.5086925626,
0.4011722505,
-0.2448479533,
0.1420724392,
0.42789644,
-0.5839790702,
0.3957205117,
-0.6409452558,
-0.3462859392,
-0.2887212336,
0.3242689371,
-1.2147656679,
-0.0155318929,
0.3212397397,
-0.6209452748,
-0.09545625,
-0.1549925506,
-0.6047113538,
-0.2541076243,
-0.1994650662,
0.5519639254,
0.4203049541,
-0.7098284364,
0.6078919172,
0.1189983487,
-0.2470979393,
-0.5938366652,
-0.6845306158,
-0.2107353956,
-0.3920245767,
-0.9582813382,
0.4700931311,
-0.0202232078,
-0.4226726294,
0.4214304388,
-0.5321121216,
-0.3788860142,
0.0957539454,
0.1936440617,
-0.0589200892,
-0.5850973129,
0.208152771,
0.5204973817,
-0.2382740676,
0.3506560922,
-0.3740614653,
0.1876417547,
0.1531775147,
-0.460460335,
-0.4935568273,
0.84988904,
0.6587535739,
-0.3282365203,
0.5429007411,
0.3762618303,
-0.4401400685,
-0.3402553499,
-0.1871466637,
-0.1798303723,
-0.2887529731,
0.2189528346,
-0.7812108994,
-0.9860515594,
0.7670615911,
-0.1155569479,
0.2754820287,
0.2765008807,
0.6365376115,
-0.2936636806,
1.2301582098,
0.2429799139,
0.4834674001,
0.0715700313,
-0.4961463213,
0.3879950643,
-0.4256359339,
-0.4963731766,
-0.5707241893,
-0.1053850949,
-0.2093312442,
-0.6884532571,
0.3517944813,
0.1931844205,
-0.2896607816,
0.092732355,
-0.1703486443,
0.3073361814,
0.7163385153,
0.0622182637,
0.5999265313,
-0.2178407907,
-0.0228203386,
0.4455931187,
-1.0885853767,
-0.3188609779,
0.3469423652,
0.6628168225,
0.5281860828,
0.1627390683,
0.5715557337,
-0.1273375452,
-0.0518301912,
-0.7106814384,
0.3704467714,
0.4216535389,
-0.9344201088,
-0.6974472404,
-0.6325007677,
-0.7706620097,
0.4686864614,
-0.1261256635,
-0.609800458,
0.5110667348,
0.1235945597,
-0.6547334194,
0.4375486374,
-0.5173249245,
0.8337154984,
0.2717275918,
-0.1653970033,
-0.1250090748,
-1.0206873417,
0.6594339609,
0.2124925703,
0.4498601258,
0.1609791815,
0.2685020566,
0.6849395037,
-0.7578088641,
0.3586264849,
-0.3241412044,
-0.3676644862,
0.6263007522,
0.166963324,
0.2275691032,
0.3930578828,
0.0109086968,
-0.2868603468,
0.491474241,
-0.5528820753,
-0.9873255491,
0.4138496518,
-0.7360454798,
-0.7361751199,
0.0037408867,
-0.6701124907,
-0.4987387955,
-0.1487378031,
0.3339184523,
0.5949912071,
0.2310000211,
0.1460885704,
0.7890382409,
-0.0298070665,
-0.1293188632,
-0.0040949914,
-0.2569197118,
-0.1672053188,
0.5023129582,
0.2733588815,
0.392919004,
0.8005306721,
0.4821895361,
-0.5185423493,
-0.5381527543,
-0.4571167827,
-0.1165979356,
-0.7466248274,
-0.283069551,
-0.8540750146,
-0.0887968466,
-0.2038561106,
-0.0628711209,
-0.0410921946,
-0.792524159,
0.3181207776,
-0.3404459953,
-0.1158590391,
0.0184861906,
-0.1428796649,
0.0966849029,
-0.7799890041,
0.8700500131,
0.8898662329,
0.0333307423,
0.2193896621,
-0.445029676,
-0.1227731928,
0.0477771685,
0.1726678312,
-0.9408175945,
-0.2041393369,
0.0098918462,
0.7520784736,
0.2460053116,
0.3702889681,
0.7164344788,
-0.1222740933,
0.5183048844,
-0.0243858788,
-0.833684504,
0.5649145246,
-0.4892556071,
0.4873079062,
0.6383844018,
0.6622707844,
-0.2889578342,
-0.3520224988,
-0.7827013731,
-0.8371247649,
0.626154542,
0.2984494567,
-0.371539712,
0.1209318563,
0.2972391546,
0.2819075882,
-0.0469426066,
-0.4370760024,
-0.2427768111,
-0.1655249745,
0.2089581192,
0.4835922718,
-0.4265991449,
-0.2948243916,
-0.5181061625,
0.636252284,
-0.038954623,
-0.0177622195,
0.1808082014,
-0.1179471761,
-0.2540677488,
0.5390380621,
-0.1270410269,
0.6328029633,
-0.3074592352,
0.4525474906,
0.0009368592,
-0.0849619135,
0.1913888156,
-0.1442894936,
-0.2275469452,
-0.1991838217,
0.6676332951,
0.3426017761,
0.1580739915,
-0.7225742936,
0.2805077434,
-0.1918943822,
-0.6030620337,
0.1299875379,
0.0554692633,
0.5403365493,
0.4697102904,
0.399187237,
-0.0792185366,
0.4023559391,
-1.1336355209,
0.4171167016,
0.0721454397,
-0.1364015788,
-0.1814480722,
0.6328661442,
0.0280221067,
-0.0124868425,
0.6761811376,
-0.1719860137,
-0.7111214995,
0.5257632732,
0.5041361451,
0.4395646155,
-0.2019869536,
0.5324302316,
0.3542297781,
0.152000457,
0.2001113743,
0.6732664704,
-0.6684418917,
-0.7500266433,
-0.6915919781,
-0.3867220283,
-0.4609746635,
-0.0936593413,
-0.7280640602,
-0.2649409175,
-0.4108352959,
0.4041925073,
0.1818205863,
-0.0771213546,
-0.2862880528,
0.5711891651,
-0.1278788894,
1.2133432627,
-0.9212503433,
0.6008975506,
0.7735880017,
-0.634904623,
-1.2111006975,
0.1930121034,
-0.128635183,
-0.6932563186,
0.6621322632,
-0.2610425949,
-0.2333432585,
0.1332076043,
-0.5042109489,
-0.4474398196,
0.8618206978,
0.2589499354,
-0.0767076686,
-0.082547918,
0.1296046525,
0.3747661412,
-0.0821005777,
0.1258120686,
0.8223027587,
0.6951728463,
0.6597808599,
-0.5775262713,
0.1416780055,
-0.3486106396,
-0.3826708496,
0.2401313633,
-0.0796476454,
0.8266784549,
-0.3597400188,
-0.4962587059,
-0.0609923936,
0.6489315033,
0.3599751294,
0.5163919926,
0.8047906756,
0.6896860003,
0.7191214561,
0.0867130384,
0.7644537091,
0.1831442118,
0.2847364247,
1.3086631298,
0.1223940104,
0.7299966216,
0.4786011577,
-0.235908255,
0.9437707663,
0.8106911778,
0.8014289141,
0.5516461134,
0.4761868715,
-0.273496896,
-0.8616919518,
-0.0360479914,
-0.489918083,
0.615619421,
0.1062474474,
0.2508603036,
-0.7483291626,
0.0581569895,
-0.0004157152,
0.2269120067,
-0.1810911596,
0.5389255881,
-0.1910845488,
-0.7573486567,
0.6673842072,
-0.0555970259,
-0.0608775765,
-0.4802936316,
-0.1336863339,
-0.2799908519,
-0.1640146971,
-0.6037709117,
-1.1376068592,
0.559520185,
-0.2402900457,
-0.4794325829,
-0.2595006526,
0.5397749543,
-0.5078998208,
-0.0321415886,
0.1627395302,
1.0552129745,
0.0326191112,
-0.4036586285,
-0.5211509466,
-0.3509206772,
-0.0685127228,
-0.3130310774,
0.2146247029,
0.9350848794,
-0.4643040895,
0.9208032489,
0.6382035017,
-0.4223710895,
-0.161773771,
0.100320451,
0.990623951,
-0.6238388419,
-0.7620946169,
-0.3037311435,
0.8156850338,
0.2232776433,
0.039886225,
0.7882629037,
0.433768183,
0.5060973763,
0.1540273428,
0.7528508306,
-0.2481738776,
0.6505885124,
-0.2659176886,
0.3958953321,
-0.7901032567,
0.280589968,
-0.1640394926,
-0.7285428643,
-0.491672039,
0.569049716,
-0.2031314671,
-0.1389056593,
0.7915463448,
0.5494395494,
-0.1846423,
0.2079653591,
0.2948792875,
0.167062521,
0.2712754011,
0.6665162444,
1.1739227772,
-0.2424782068,
0.6918370128,
-0.2144932002,
-0.5119365454,
-0.120414421,
-0.5854705572,
-0.5012947917,
-0.7114080191,
-0.5299978852,
-0.1989311576,
0.0259738378,
0.5980553627,
0.7474306226,
-0.6715934277,
0.1653884351,
-0.0165904947,
0.6734076738,
-0.623902142,
-0.2810569406,
0.6424824595,
-0.0597153641,
-0.3089449704,
0.301330477,
0.3083574474,
-0.4934404194,
-0.378986001,
0.2377869636,
-0.3958891332,
0.0139747038,
0.7564485669,
0.427133888,
-0.4222503006,
-0.5227814317,
0.0252203625,
0.1740232557,
0.1897591501,
0.7593733072,
-1.034009099,
0.1368253529,
1.0364243984,
0.6348913908,
0.3451217711,
0.3205738366,
0.4377528131,
-0.5486863256,
-0.3793569207,
0.4798876643,
0.1005147398,
-0.1776658595,
-0.3137556314,
0.5648517609,
-0.0376181863,
-0.4024626017,
-0.7957339883,
0.3820732236,
-1.1632702351,
-0.6295547485,
0.804133594,
-0.219711259,
-0.1638034433,
-0.7296036482,
-0.3058157563,
0.0989197642,
-0.0006322001,
0.5037965178,
0.2652430236,
-0.4299656153,
-0.4838218689,
-0.4321103394,
0.3423212171,
0.4112883508,
-1.1395312548,
0.1125886217,
0.5068261623,
0.2706204057,
0.2870651186,
0.6839906573,
-0.3571354747,
0.6714828014,
0.2834297419,
-0.0675164238,
-0.0515851155,
-0.381890595,
0.1731096506,
0.9698614478,
-0.0058934735,
-0.2517972589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15054v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15054v2 | A Mechanistic Interpretation of Arithmetic Reasoning in Language Models using Causal Mediation Analysis | 2023-05-24T11:43:47 | 2023-10-20T12:13:27 | Alessandro Stolfo, Yonatan Belinkov, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Mathematical reasoning in large language models (LMs) has garnered
significant attention in recent work, but there is a limited understanding of
how these models process and store information related to arithmetic tasks
within their architecture. In order to improve our understanding of this aspect
of language models, we present a mechanistic interpretation of
Transformer-based LMs on arithmetic questions using a causal mediation analysis
framework. By intervening on the activations of specific model components and
measuring the resulting changes in predicted probabilities, we identify the
subset of parameters responsible for specific predictions. This provides
insights into how information related to arithmetic is processed by LMs. Our
experimental results indicate that LMs process the input by transmitting the
information relevant to the query from mid-sequence early layers to the final
token using the attention mechanism. Then, this information is processed by a
set of MLP modules, which generate result-related information that is
incorporated into the residual stream. To assess the specificity of the
observed activation dynamics, we compare the effects of different model
components on arithmetic queries with other tasks, including number retrieval
from prompts and factual knowledge questions. | [
-0.3630503416,
-1.1209133863,
0.6585600376,
0.2692493796,
-0.094647646,
-0.5753159523,
0.0655935332,
-0.3278039992,
0.3104774058,
0.3868826032,
-0.6351141334,
-0.0232171994,
-0.7201914787,
0.2804262638,
-0.3967471719,
0.4848899245,
0.0801490322,
0.2961440384,
-0.1839399785,
-0.0883287638,
-0.5227816105,
-0.5847011209,
-0.8316683173,
-0.438737154,
0.6750234365,
0.1717644781,
0.9047213197,
0.5155056119,
0.7248134017,
0.4461745918,
0.0768814087,
-0.2765476108,
-0.2809077203,
-0.0231945608,
-0.268850565,
-0.9626019001,
-0.4341460764,
-0.0372013673,
0.7434650064,
1.0830253363,
-0.0106267715,
0.4285267591,
-0.1094021425,
0.763668716,
-0.744720459,
0.4931893945,
-0.5559586287,
0.1384138316,
-0.0946139544,
-0.4697340429,
-0.8375692368,
-0.1461645514,
-0.2121933252,
-0.237056151,
0.1120212302,
-0.1351343691,
0.3074200153,
0.5710759163,
-0.5306072235,
-0.3574714363,
-0.8614928126,
0.4562779367,
-0.8747566342,
0.4142483175,
0.4786973894,
0.3260291815,
-0.1349527687,
-0.5882248282,
-0.643730402,
-0.2014169842,
-0.388893187,
0.0181909371,
-0.574449718,
0.0663574412,
0.6162478924,
0.1547177136,
-0.395072341,
-0.0147343101,
-0.4101226926,
-0.0892652124,
0.3522680104,
0.4224671125,
0.2489359528,
-0.1084167287,
0.1240788624,
0.1680502743,
-0.7556964755,
0.294557035,
0.2498211414,
0.0061124866,
0.0056471233,
0.8793536425,
-0.2959884703,
0.8104086518,
0.1831573844,
0.0674779564,
-0.1630187184,
-0.0306336656,
-0.5131292343,
0.2498605549,
0.70675385,
0.0062272153,
0.2743691802,
0.0157213565,
-0.2388881892,
0.1570775509,
0.1654814035,
-0.9556084275,
0.1611099243,
0.0947918072,
-0.4801297784,
-0.4530265331,
0.1846029609,
-0.1480242312,
0.0872638747,
-0.6899731755,
0.5361378193,
-0.1292021275,
-0.2964013517,
0.4388657212,
0.2507492006,
-0.0944338962,
0.0273513198,
-1.1194927692,
0.3275837898,
0.8814966083,
0.4559575021,
0.4065277576,
-0.112400353,
-0.795912981,
0.0860219002,
-0.3307509124,
0.4740849435,
-0.588478446,
-0.0076896143,
0.0425348207,
0.1584957838,
-0.3559051156,
-0.442894429,
0.6059737802,
-1.1381011009,
0.025747465,
-0.2889753878,
-0.6208056808,
-0.3180813491,
0.0388948172,
-1.1207216978,
0.5925568342,
-0.2717197239,
-0.6694748998,
0.1321389824,
-0.5069699287,
-0.2880468667,
-0.1457716823,
-0.2472952753,
-0.197869271,
0.5748147964,
-0.0407929644,
0.3883900344,
-0.5665094256,
0.6891484261,
-0.3875848949,
-0.2206604183,
0.8404300809,
-0.9145394564,
0.7523196936,
-0.0120687028,
-0.5432588458,
-0.0257326141,
-0.7785559893,
-0.3588402569,
-0.043705374,
-0.0915293023,
-0.1752404422,
0.3708474636,
-0.8643801808,
0.5266233683,
0.2086345255,
-0.2251940221,
0.0978537425,
-0.2574938238,
0.0742983595,
0.5597938895,
0.1395839304,
0.6239651442,
0.0271576531,
0.3598437309,
0.1168491691,
0.1738962829,
-0.2534545064,
-0.4743795097,
-0.9146918654,
0.2307445407,
0.007310634,
0.4285443425,
-0.7760859728,
0.1843711734,
-0.4029127359,
-0.1008198857,
-0.3915333152,
-0.1810942143,
0.1989374906,
0.7003641129,
0.3143162727,
0.2208011746,
-0.130092293,
-0.9663687348,
-0.2802215219,
-0.15359734,
-0.1157183722,
0.2258136421,
0.3191282749,
-0.0392737053,
0.8085998297,
-0.6448561549,
-0.1636599302,
-0.1259942502,
0.5618393421,
0.6637589931,
0.1981282532,
0.2241716236,
-0.7289284468,
-0.0838629976,
-0.1952122599,
-0.829272151,
-0.6130616665,
-0.3316266835,
-0.1819288582,
0.0686181784,
0.7963919044,
-0.8889556527,
0.5941263437,
0.3633826077,
-0.7238837481,
0.7822880149,
-0.0905622393,
0.3145316541,
-0.6118301749,
0.0075662523,
-0.0425904766,
0.0249762405,
-0.7929016948,
-0.1093496606,
0.1062318385,
0.0972185805,
-0.1998552084,
0.3390910625,
-0.3209815323,
-0.2049788833,
-0.2891876101,
-0.1280925423,
-0.0914153755,
0.6736965775,
-0.0577415302,
0.5956158638,
0.2558171749,
-0.587700963,
0.3135330975,
-0.2719035149,
-0.1224011928,
0.3115543127,
-0.815222621,
-0.2232708484,
-0.1734694988,
-0.0517156459,
-1.0523084402,
0.1109067351,
0.2576243877,
-0.6666995287,
0.3060393631,
-0.0966582224,
-0.7337579131,
-0.0134166107,
0.1433955282,
0.6352022886,
0.1668837667,
-0.2375645339,
0.8920273781,
0.2256415933,
-0.2801608443,
-0.3416819274,
-0.268391341,
-0.0820996463,
-0.0976781547,
-0.8236779571,
-0.1213298365,
0.3131377697,
-0.7374428511,
0.111110419,
-0.1071917638,
0.0736675113,
0.1663657278,
0.1229238212,
0.3117028475,
-0.5387918949,
0.2818754017,
0.2585437298,
-0.6099458337,
0.8869944811,
-0.1624967158,
0.4940166473,
0.0200045817,
-0.7348569632,
-0.4091148674,
0.1549102366,
0.5868812799,
-0.3210372627,
1.0747526884,
0.4188068509,
-0.3780371249,
0.1933479756,
-0.5066465735,
-0.443067193,
-0.4406114519,
0.1861163825,
-0.689486146,
-0.7369187474,
0.6463224292,
-0.0018024346,
-0.1973692328,
0.8222281337,
0.914031148,
0.081642203,
1.4809991121,
0.09122587,
-0.0606708303,
0.3370392025,
-0.1877559572,
0.2569600046,
-0.5405113697,
-0.224829331,
-0.572964251,
-0.4492837191,
-0.3145979345,
-0.7145690918,
0.4894710481,
0.1731079817,
-0.37360695,
-0.0353083685,
0.0428242013,
0.4219494164,
0.3894329667,
0.0567101315,
0.4437915981,
-0.209555909,
-0.0952801779,
-0.2011919171,
-0.5130683184,
-0.3918273449,
0.6603921652,
0.3310196996,
0.8252848387,
0.5140257478,
0.0432647727,
0.2293856144,
0.556137681,
-0.6071944237,
0.6077117324,
0.0514144674,
-0.6359838247,
-0.4244455695,
-0.6579546928,
-0.8269822001,
0.5470701456,
-0.1873101443,
-0.5515227318,
0.1274747103,
-0.1310338229,
0.0573753901,
0.2643262148,
-0.463983506,
0.8572039604,
-0.1837759465,
-0.4915573895,
-0.7562204003,
-0.5536347032,
0.5783923268,
-0.1588120908,
0.3223437965,
-0.0781830251,
0.1016749442,
0.4396367371,
-0.6046817899,
0.9998582006,
-0.0758606717,
-0.2637640834,
0.2118955255,
0.5146514177,
0.6121131182,
-0.1234261617,
-0.1735814214,
0.2879001498,
-0.3555998206,
-0.2258342355,
-1.0329581499,
0.5085689425,
-0.6305574775,
-0.9043213129,
-0.2446188778,
-0.5513079166,
-0.0682917684,
0.231005311,
-0.1005613729,
0.8690817356,
0.2367257774,
0.2273990363,
0.5696315765,
-0.0803120583,
0.3691197336,
0.8957827687,
-0.2372214943,
-0.0141622834,
0.6579985023,
0.233470425,
0.501081109,
0.9190577865,
0.2057189047,
-0.444748491,
-0.0851899981,
-0.4306220114,
0.4513200521,
-0.8542461991,
-0.103156887,
-0.5427957773,
-0.0388318934,
-0.0966322049,
0.1612897366,
-0.0130917458,
-0.672059536,
-0.3448937833,
-0.2678022385,
-0.0634509549,
0.5990226865,
0.0088342335,
0.1141770408,
-0.9297736287,
0.3238307834,
0.3046595454,
0.1355053633,
0.4093492925,
-0.7452245951,
-0.3538462818,
0.2581623197,
-0.1202980727,
-1.0766882896,
0.2775342762,
-0.0175369047,
0.3753610253,
0.7885479927,
-0.1777553707,
0.5566211343,
-0.7610886693,
0.3469882309,
0.2261041403,
-0.9431052208,
0.2035661936,
-0.2088668644,
0.2128545344,
0.0422737375,
0.3779505491,
-0.2863401175,
-0.5426719189,
-0.6483739614,
-0.4701856375,
0.6077334881,
0.1683572531,
0.1045632139,
-0.1085556448,
0.3838217854,
-0.2332189083,
0.0401369743,
-0.6325146556,
-0.3739666641,
0.3355677426,
-0.0701391473,
0.1038149744,
-0.5384941697,
0.075085558,
-0.1841981858,
0.5465414524,
0.0679969862,
0.1067879274,
-0.0696107671,
-0.3817081749,
-0.400932461,
0.1898299158,
0.8636820316,
0.7113215923,
0.0429490283,
0.4486939311,
0.0807333365,
-0.2959214747,
0.0597498156,
0.0021764238,
-0.0699028075,
0.106561698,
0.7563928366,
0.8684929013,
0.7657266259,
-0.3491730094,
0.3449070752,
-0.1594863981,
0.018584827,
-0.2276374549,
-0.051894594,
0.1430229843,
0.2852012813,
0.5660892725,
-0.0890201554,
0.4358765185,
-0.3279682994,
0.2501326501,
0.4299813509,
-0.3692536354,
-0.7212331891,
0.8269333243,
-0.0294342618,
-0.2655439079,
0.515722096,
-0.079629086,
-0.4796364605,
0.670743525,
0.5889457464,
0.7610899806,
-0.3955066204,
0.1377527118,
0.4078972638,
0.4857671261,
0.2483191937,
-0.0305431336,
-0.0641656294,
-0.795125246,
-1.0612510443,
-0.6804797053,
-0.1912819743,
-0.0967575461,
-0.7094764709,
0.3216050267,
0.1075361595,
-0.040377263,
0.3905167282,
-0.3819026649,
-0.4988566041,
0.2283700854,
0.1878762394,
0.7957975268,
-1.1111685038,
0.495929569,
0.4060943425,
-0.5834633112,
-1.1049005985,
-0.4033640027,
-0.046038609,
-1.1263903379,
0.986553371,
0.0185458474,
-0.1441610157,
0.0312263593,
-0.2571442723,
-0.8329332471,
0.8711156845,
0.4176365435,
-0.47450611,
0.170223549,
0.9037069082,
0.6204252839,
-0.2150791436,
0.5432254076,
0.65980196,
0.3292481601,
0.3504164517,
-0.7320368886,
0.2262123972,
-0.2743228376,
-0.4013753235,
0.639799118,
-0.1580535769,
1.0658951998,
-0.1944036931,
-0.0475866497,
-0.3782333434,
0.5597041845,
0.0640832633,
0.3932636082,
0.3659800589,
0.7171536684,
0.3234189749,
-0.1052513272,
1.217030406,
-0.4583462775,
0.4288409948,
0.7420704961,
0.0487712622,
0.7432914376,
0.4370062053,
-0.4552612603,
0.4415440857,
0.3617916107,
0.4519293606,
0.2223320752,
0.0953337625,
-0.5417044759,
-0.3019176126,
-0.0173225384,
-0.1266502291,
0.2261570543,
0.4773513973,
-0.4622279406,
-0.3606389463,
-0.3886252046,
0.0924575925,
-0.4737413228,
-0.5257342458,
0.8898347616,
0.2332129329,
-0.7760738134,
0.3162046969,
0.0559550114,
-0.2440391034,
-0.4550661445,
-0.2368809879,
-0.2229955494,
0.3248589337,
-0.2701689005,
-0.6581090689,
0.4108878374,
-0.1933291256,
-0.4576651752,
0.0864138976,
0.6927742362,
-0.4796344042,
-0.7965201735,
0.0364250019,
0.4947897196,
0.1314113438,
-0.3183569312,
-0.6282212734,
0.1311013848,
-0.0272111837,
-0.324798882,
0.2019157559,
0.9845810533,
-0.3398223519,
0.5642288923,
0.9616014361,
0.0397732779,
0.227438435,
0.6450858712,
0.8072139621,
-0.6630058885,
-0.3188023269,
-1.4323613644,
0.7007205486,
0.1924275309,
0.2466489226,
0.6147382259,
0.3643717766,
0.1902893782,
-0.0977767408,
0.2125302106,
0.2880014181,
0.0136818253,
-0.6675981283,
0.3916610181,
-0.3417317867,
0.5624623299,
-0.0523577891,
-0.9707722068,
-0.3306422532,
0.4766087234,
-0.6730781794,
-0.2540605962,
0.736731708,
0.6219601631,
-0.1047477573,
0.1964035332,
0.4412042201,
0.5179846883,
0.4547660649,
0.3332899213,
0.7793725133,
-0.272144556,
0.2328939885,
0.0061604679,
-0.4241669178,
-0.326587379,
-0.7360320687,
-0.6171773672,
-0.5313686132,
0.1275220215,
-0.2093053162,
-0.5946837664,
0.5872959495,
0.0766372085,
-0.7650675774,
-0.259101212,
-0.1507122964,
0.280900687,
0.0050306516,
-0.2892330289,
0.4714725912,
-0.5323622227,
-0.5560934544,
-0.1216845214,
0.5874255896,
-0.371355921,
-0.2982772291,
0.1568005532,
-0.0349919647,
0.2240198851,
0.8313887119,
-0.0237818994,
-0.5632211566,
-0.0570929088,
0.315990895,
-0.0378492996,
-0.2577490509,
1.1505163908,
-0.5802809,
0.4140297472,
0.3967446387,
0.594268322,
0.3932827115,
0.0134405866,
0.7254909873,
-0.3772225678,
0.2569330633,
0.0686880574,
0.7711122036,
-0.0122296838,
-0.2603860199,
0.4844653904,
0.159890309,
-0.4923222363,
-0.6521380544,
0.2051400095,
-0.4754701853,
-0.0224377718,
1.1317203045,
0.0684017614,
-0.0246888045,
0.0121490574,
-0.0530710816,
0.1490439922,
0.051825434,
0.8411860466,
0.833799243,
-0.16355744,
-0.1375540644,
-0.5637513399,
0.2086892873,
0.4877849221,
-0.5852462053,
-0.0589470603,
0.667770803,
-0.1297973543,
0.3489712179,
0.4484156668,
-0.1569713205,
0.4615590572,
-0.1428878903,
-0.1868735403,
0.1475590318,
-0.0291380659,
-0.2606401742,
0.0840503424,
-0.0528327152,
0.1009365842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15053v1 | Decomposing Complex Queries for Tip-of-the-tongue Retrieval | 2023-05-24T11:43:40 | 2023-05-24T11:43:40 | Kevin Lin, Kyle Lo, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | When re-finding items, users who forget or are uncertain about identifying
details often rely on creative strategies for expressing their information
needs -- complex queries that describe content elements (e.g., book characters
or events), information beyond the document text (e.g., descriptions of book
covers), or personal context (e.g., when they read a book). This retrieval
setting, called tip of the tongue (TOT), is especially challenging for models
heavily reliant on lexical and semantic overlap between query and document
text. In this work, we introduce a simple yet effective framework for handling
such complex queries by decomposing the query into individual clues, routing
those as sub-queries to specialized retrievers, and ensembling the results.
This approach allows us to take advantage of off-the-shelf retrievers (e.g.,
CLIP for retrieving images of book covers) or incorporate retriever-specific
logic (e.g., date constraints). We show that our framework incorportating query
decompositions into retrievers can improve gold book recall up to 7% relative
again for Recall@5 on a new collection of 14,441 real-world query-book pairs
from an online community for resolving TOT inquiries. | [
-0.3186273277,
-0.7524447441,
0.4710137248,
0.0632902086,
-0.206674844,
0.0742888227,
-0.0027943994,
-0.2261475176,
0.3412507176,
0.8002176881,
-0.6975853443,
-0.6330285072,
-0.3688048124,
-0.1100926921,
-0.5548695326,
0.8910905719,
0.2982930839,
-0.5722588897,
-0.1000721604,
-0.0837633014,
-0.3466354311,
-0.3979948759,
-0.4514840543,
-0.1538029015,
0.4381361902,
0.5113318563,
0.4195140004,
0.6791795492,
0.3141926527,
0.2032432705,
-0.2800438702,
0.3572623432,
-0.7978625894,
0.3048527539,
-0.4935047626,
-0.9418607354,
-0.2083465159,
-0.3449934125,
0.1372315586,
0.6891418695,
-0.0907078683,
-0.0567467958,
-0.2542439103,
0.7117044926,
-0.8790405989,
0.2155817598,
-0.6954159737,
-0.0682236999,
-0.3669134974,
-0.7502147555,
-0.4833083451,
-0.3009596169,
0.4126895964,
-0.7453420162,
0.4806509912,
-0.1508941203,
0.7652006149,
0.2108471692,
-0.548388958,
-0.5436601639,
-0.7072416544,
0.4798758924,
-0.2891149819,
0.4594117403,
0.5924961567,
0.346351862,
-0.2332558483,
-0.7551039457,
-0.4645787477,
0.1046835259,
-0.2303265333,
0.1808165461,
-0.0267113969,
-0.1346052736,
0.0439614244,
0.2604226172,
-0.3635773063,
-0.373824507,
0.0689013153,
-0.026354393,
0.4145807624,
-0.070756197,
0.4425262213,
-0.322404027,
-0.3852414787,
-0.1989061683,
-0.7898892164,
0.2289107293,
0.2346179485,
0.3818031549,
0.5808410645,
0.5720736384,
-0.2489472181,
0.5542624593,
0.4152294993,
-0.121686615,
-0.0932878256,
-0.4923730493,
0.235631004,
0.1191504672,
0.1399649084,
0.4245408475,
0.2601092458,
-0.4120408297,
-0.2931256294,
-0.3596051931,
0.1195426732,
-0.5948814154,
-0.4539175928,
0.1735813022,
-0.284198463,
0.0692354813,
-0.0095460303,
-0.4927877486,
-0.3996010125,
0.0090466086,
0.5459759831,
-0.5428248644,
-0.513556838,
0.3151902258,
-0.5348546505,
0.3698305488,
0.2370989919,
-0.7967880368,
0.6352963448,
0.7008014321,
0.4746756852,
0.1677759439,
-0.0192211475,
-0.730283916,
0.45167768,
-0.2019137293,
0.9363433719,
-0.49391222,
-0.4253383577,
0.0609545708,
0.0644534156,
0.0895041451,
-0.6596061587,
0.6843745708,
-0.8621594906,
-0.0680289865,
-0.7452400923,
-0.6312555671,
-0.0831094533,
0.7330717444,
-1.0344278812,
1.0988367796,
0.008568258,
-0.7887871861,
0.1953151077,
-0.4390019476,
-0.4513977766,
0.1262305975,
-0.2094187587,
-0.1152163744,
-0.0127967615,
0.5299059749,
0.1305694431,
-0.4783222675,
0.1164017692,
0.1568757147,
-0.3417093456,
0.0319015086,
-0.0658730417,
0.6516088247,
-0.1371528655,
-0.3019111156,
-0.2919481099,
-0.5672274828,
-0.0332145095,
0.1928825825,
-0.4599083662,
-1.0807378292,
-0.0457941927,
0.1169689894,
-0.2218673825,
0.2172622681,
-0.4930579662,
0.3786405921,
-0.4059338868,
0.3157752454,
0.2017372102,
0.2250297219,
0.4485274255,
-0.2449903935,
0.3084146082,
0.0845248029,
-0.0100159394,
-0.4266770184,
-0.1350974143,
-0.6264261007,
-0.122303687,
0.3160257339,
0.5734371543,
-0.9882927537,
0.4213392735,
-0.3205412626,
-0.5623900294,
-0.3373898268,
-0.2321797758,
0.6659970284,
0.6512101293,
0.2852502763,
-0.0323723219,
0.1033864841,
-0.7824429274,
-0.7020691633,
-0.0696357638,
-0.139921844,
0.4851399958,
0.2976420522,
0.1851829886,
1.2576571703,
-0.6934213042,
-0.3892026842,
-0.0688059554,
0.1923642904,
-0.1522633582,
0.4143348336,
0.6092645526,
-1.3987634182,
-0.3756837249,
0.0941004232,
-0.2310752124,
0.1625011116,
0.0272359233,
-0.4540495276,
-0.0286336746,
0.6177428961,
-0.7581888437,
0.4396261871,
-0.363450557,
-0.615706265,
0.5864243507,
-0.0377331264,
0.3346287608,
-0.8177979589,
0.0803266615,
-0.123421438,
-0.1822080761,
-0.4065494835,
0.0407237522,
0.3316276371,
0.0792413801,
-0.1433747858,
0.7590361238,
-0.7072415948,
0.2282313555,
0.1691843718,
0.2617364228,
0.2032108009,
0.3098453581,
0.034884911,
0.6339164376,
0.3068408072,
-0.7458341718,
0.2292376757,
0.5133244395,
-0.1793306768,
0.7984108925,
-0.4188943207,
0.1027010828,
-0.2692579627,
0.2183982879,
-1.2130752802,
-0.2021135986,
0.1084462404,
-0.4467378259,
0.5200864077,
-0.5529527664,
-0.5850581527,
0.0270771161,
-0.5977877975,
0.5446001887,
0.1113672107,
-0.756362617,
0.8712478876,
0.3708781898,
-0.3893939555,
-0.9692974687,
-0.7190980315,
0.1414440125,
-0.1499279886,
-0.516151607,
0.9266958833,
0.102557309,
-0.0484032556,
0.4255179465,
-0.5327286124,
-0.2126008123,
-0.2367209196,
-0.3835818768,
-0.2406391352,
-0.0828979984,
0.5515792966,
0.1921653748,
-0.1651656479,
-0.1670089364,
-0.3972783685,
0.5418246388,
-0.1587544382,
-0.4968818724,
0.127370283,
0.5392782092,
0.4683779776,
-0.5122491717,
0.2378289402,
0.4918795526,
-0.5413556695,
-0.2509915233,
-0.8339318633,
-0.3177102208,
-0.4667364955,
0.5226435661,
-0.8990340829,
-0.4476651847,
0.850584805,
-0.2553328574,
-0.1196709797,
0.3417709768,
0.2249618024,
-0.0746240467,
0.5114001632,
0.6807565093,
0.3100785911,
0.4912431836,
-0.2991509438,
0.0788271353,
-0.7032248974,
-0.5438385606,
-0.4160130918,
-0.2282752246,
-0.2720434368,
-0.3416541219,
0.4258876145,
0.0172198452,
0.1178013831,
0.2739956081,
-0.5475097299,
0.9584137797,
0.8259002566,
0.5368288755,
0.6062797904,
0.0625201464,
-0.0700677335,
0.0029371285,
-0.8512142897,
-0.2396050245,
0.9587951899,
-0.1215559393,
0.8606435061,
0.3619276583,
0.7406733632,
0.1426134706,
-0.1964909583,
-0.9945626855,
0.5150606632,
-0.3597604632,
-0.744353056,
-0.428088367,
-0.3088547289,
-1.0370922089,
0.2128494084,
0.1059358492,
-0.6559095383,
0.370095849,
-0.0096403342,
-0.3320455849,
0.1995728314,
-0.7167439461,
0.7936316133,
-0.3834601045,
-0.3082500696,
0.1833665371,
-0.8601372838,
0.0693453699,
0.0974654779,
-0.1440602094,
0.1214372665,
-0.4190850258,
0.755110383,
-0.4739916325,
0.7379277349,
-0.0992394462,
-0.0282269381,
0.3658533096,
0.529912293,
0.518322289,
-0.00047043,
-0.0947761536,
-0.7249684334,
0.5386845469,
-0.3813765347,
-0.9062289596,
0.5449102521,
-0.4902310073,
-0.5621887445,
-0.3506169617,
-0.5296635032,
-0.2686832547,
0.4040544033,
0.3389901519,
0.8040739894,
-0.0691917837,
0.1434015334,
1.0370615721,
-0.0061956104,
0.1607590467,
0.4537385106,
0.1745944917,
-0.0481034555,
0.9419743419,
0.4072157145,
0.1357509643,
0.820456624,
0.145480752,
-0.6510059237,
-0.442238152,
-0.193755582,
0.5260075331,
-1.0278351307,
-0.0920636058,
-0.6490948796,
0.1300363988,
-0.3333280385,
0.0200483352,
-0.4587829709,
-0.4850170016,
-0.2812511325,
-0.1260987967,
0.6001678705,
0.470964849,
0.3656544387,
0.2392967492,
-0.8261313438,
0.2224678099,
0.1546837389,
0.4232150018,
-0.0232168213,
-0.292768091,
0.1358477771,
-0.4723035097,
0.0352850147,
-0.9413291216,
0.3781481385,
0.3855928481,
0.5654328465,
0.1138969362,
0.8379528522,
0.8010559678,
-0.2440235019,
0.4375337362,
-0.1038612723,
-0.7029061913,
0.6938080192,
-0.4947075844,
0.4065475166,
0.7426767945,
0.7763723731,
-0.5740358829,
-0.0583832748,
-0.6095855236,
-1.3255457878,
0.6634399295,
0.1618818641,
-0.1456177533,
0.0035391685,
0.7104818225,
0.2852275074,
0.2341185361,
-0.4424007237,
-0.1082454473,
0.0339980721,
-0.3033308685,
0.2973218262,
-0.5191397071,
-0.4096717834,
-0.0325011015,
0.2843068838,
-0.1375750005,
0.118255198,
0.3664198816,
-0.380445987,
0.3253144324,
0.3398381472,
-0.0790373161,
0.561008215,
-0.4589180052,
0.3360267282,
-0.3393310606,
-0.5015741587,
-0.2000772655,
0.1365772784,
-0.2707846165,
-0.0433951542,
0.3441490233,
0.2189217061,
0.3305791616,
-0.830116868,
0.4219581485,
-0.1754484326,
-0.0143759958,
-0.1845450848,
-0.2632828057,
0.3571461141,
0.2744475901,
0.5221648812,
-0.3307902217,
0.5396140218,
-0.7494656444,
0.5434539914,
0.2892421186,
-0.224948138,
-0.1251191646,
0.0755635649,
0.3574624062,
-0.2912550271,
0.7141953111,
-0.2760663629,
-0.755310297,
0.5178148746,
0.5827940106,
0.6044495106,
0.1648006737,
-0.0101829013,
0.0555824079,
0.2449762672,
-0.1358868182,
0.4077311754,
-0.3296818733,
-0.4789588451,
0.0140494015,
-0.2731086016,
-0.2859047055,
-0.1405385584,
-0.7129545808,
0.2086663544,
-0.0516953506,
-0.1947384477,
-0.1035660878,
-0.0066938875,
-0.496517092,
0.1174200997,
-0.2652939856,
1.1179972887,
-0.6063038111,
0.4116816223,
0.6966645122,
-0.7200846076,
-0.7682004571,
0.2123720497,
0.0897954926,
-0.4674014747,
0.5002745986,
-0.1187333763,
-0.3871005476,
0.2172078639,
-0.1956092715,
-0.8414866328,
0.949629724,
0.3130032122,
-0.3546513319,
-0.4834276438,
-0.0142326225,
0.309317112,
0.0262361504,
0.5243088007,
0.9785952568,
0.3870426714,
0.5568528771,
-1.0167686939,
0.195808351,
-0.2708380818,
-0.3466401994,
0.2583594322,
-0.5621978641,
0.9273781776,
0.0009136624,
-0.3521233797,
0.0877484754,
0.0587101392,
-0.0034999677,
0.4752100706,
0.4808337688,
0.3928657174,
0.9769456387,
-0.3409669995,
0.9678694606,
0.0216308031,
0.3867117465,
1.0015313625,
0.1350398213,
0.8807587028,
0.576523304,
0.0560687557,
-0.0055565792,
0.7958650589,
0.3605479598,
0.7323521376,
0.0549060479,
-0.2109354883,
-0.3585159183,
-0.1948262602,
-0.4155546129,
0.2409823835,
0.7405447364,
0.1125586107,
-0.5946148038,
-0.0303625669,
0.0421041101,
0.2109262794,
-0.223665148,
0.8220117688,
-0.0864481404,
-0.6995947957,
0.6195582747,
-0.2584823966,
0.7566267848,
-0.4458135962,
0.0295203235,
-0.4007706642,
0.474902004,
-0.3009640872,
-1.0306367874,
0.2508155107,
-0.2837454677,
-0.3487717211,
0.0378071107,
0.9726269245,
-0.618991375,
-0.2508961856,
0.3120530844,
0.5546281934,
0.1959980577,
-0.4788435102,
-0.6160289645,
-0.111380145,
-0.1567040831,
-0.4368893802,
0.1511754245,
1.069598794,
-0.2595497072,
0.8241028786,
0.371851325,
-0.2197078764,
0.1893163919,
0.0681571215,
0.9604958892,
-0.8774467111,
-0.6757333875,
-0.4929907322,
0.3286597133,
0.0507364981,
-0.2436101735,
0.5105463266,
0.5247965455,
0.8423851132,
-0.1735438406,
0.6394636035,
-0.0311577749,
0.579408288,
-0.4577876627,
0.8271135092,
-0.9578593373,
0.3439230025,
-0.1856585741,
-0.6390514374,
-0.3534160256,
0.3031655252,
-0.2163965404,
0.0498603471,
0.497202307,
0.8229059577,
-0.2910952866,
-0.2143094689,
-0.0614680089,
0.028351767,
0.6460593939,
0.4781573415,
0.6311160326,
-0.3692912757,
1.0074851513,
-0.1255664229,
-0.3349225521,
-0.6443688273,
-0.7393685579,
-0.7003888488,
-0.6996557117,
-0.3101226985,
-0.1765322536,
0.2479691952,
0.7589933276,
0.5170699954,
-0.356997788,
-0.2034280896,
0.1643226296,
0.1415693015,
-0.2804520428,
-0.2019249052,
0.6819260716,
-0.3781227171,
-0.706505537,
0.0425319374,
0.2039443105,
-0.15613015,
0.1736267656,
0.2490206361,
-0.5915325284,
0.0922553688,
0.7462109327,
0.5337771177,
-0.8304122686,
-0.0625542253,
0.504255414,
0.064953275,
-0.0095856059,
0.8147777915,
-0.7942824364,
0.7266033888,
0.5750062466,
1.0165891647,
1.0249029398,
0.2475763708,
0.5016790628,
-0.9864789844,
-0.136586383,
0.6655245423,
-0.099044919,
0.2038802803,
-0.5476716161,
0.6329030395,
0.1766852289,
-0.1881049275,
-0.8893675208,
0.3734912574,
-1.382956028,
-0.366134882,
0.8844295144,
-0.0283473451,
-0.3737800717,
-0.2306294888,
-0.3846485019,
0.1751293987,
-0.3850035071,
0.7790598869,
0.6737976074,
-0.26037848,
-0.1977509409,
-0.1336039752,
0.4304697812,
0.4096647799,
-0.5341354609,
0.1991643459,
0.2796711624,
0.4987188578,
0.3925814927,
0.6824442744,
-0.3198807836,
0.3465205431,
0.1304395199,
-0.0706973001,
-0.1711874753,
-0.3567775786,
0.3538573384,
0.3416806161,
-0.0040033823,
-0.3585896194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15051v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15051v2 | A Monte Carlo Language Model Pipeline for Zero-Shot Sociopolitical Event Extraction | 2023-05-24T11:41:33 | 2024-06-02T19:17:34 | Erica Cai, Brendan O'Connor | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current social science efforts automatically populate event databases of "who
did what to whom?" tuples, by applying event extraction (EE) to text such as
news. The event databases are used to analyze sociopolitical dynamics between
actor pairs (dyads) in, e.g., international relations. While most EE methods
heavily rely on rules or supervised learning, \emph{zero-shot} event extraction
could potentially allow researchers to flexibly specify arbitrary event classes
for new research questions. Unfortunately, we find that current zero-shot EE
methods, as well as a naive zero-shot approach of simple generative language
model (LM) prompting, perform poorly for dyadic event extraction; most suffer
from word sense ambiguity, modality sensitivity, and computational
inefficiency. We address these challenges with a new fine-grained, multi-stage
instruction-following generative LM pipeline, proposing a Monte Carlo approach
to deal with, and even take advantage of, nondeterminism of generative outputs.
Our pipeline includes explicit stages of linguistic analysis (synonym
generation, contextual disambiguation, argument realization, event modality),
\textit{improving control and interpretability} compared to purely neural
methods. This method outperforms other zero-shot EE approaches, and outperforms
naive applications of generative LMs by at least 17 F1 percent points. The
pipeline's filtering mechanism greatly improves computational efficiency,
allowing it to perform as few as 12% of queries that a previous zero-shot
method uses. Finally, we demonstrate our pipeline's application to dyadic
international relations analysis. | [
-0.2026405483,
-0.9373123646,
0.7196053863,
0.0737788975,
-0.303263694,
0.4384891689,
-0.3095186055,
-0.0883524641,
0.1714638621,
0.3254817128,
-0.4070541263,
-0.6665580869,
-0.7088168859,
-0.2364833206,
-0.5681023002,
1.1346875429,
0.0946742818,
-0.2516518831,
0.07249479,
0.2628718317,
0.2139239907,
-0.3920769989,
-0.6658906937,
-0.2622259855,
0.8133463264,
0.6875793934,
0.3471198082,
0.4836869538,
0.2185160965,
0.1313307136,
0.0262772739,
-0.1640745848,
-0.6686197519,
0.3782287538,
-0.1082381457,
-0.2096009851,
-0.3535956144,
0.0292757768,
0.6480397582,
0.5649520159,
-0.2568091452,
0.1885621399,
-0.1235486567,
0.5591123104,
-0.9909301996,
0.3943856061,
-0.9839578271,
0.1909481883,
-0.4804261923,
-0.340247333,
-0.2742544413,
0.0541589372,
-0.1966310441,
-0.2448037714,
0.2568910718,
-0.2444805503,
0.5810508132,
-0.2567452192,
-0.3851289451,
0.0356176533,
-0.8988149762,
0.8064280152,
-0.544239819,
0.0778648853,
0.1913708746,
0.0873322561,
-0.4640929401,
-0.5854472518,
-0.9187669158,
-0.226112023,
0.5004683137,
0.4464424849,
-0.1050952747,
0.2075026631,
0.2548621893,
0.1463954002,
-0.4997569919,
0.0734915808,
-0.4717591107,
0.1234670207,
0.7704758048,
-0.0140515184,
0.1902362257,
-0.4709299803,
-0.1703440994,
-0.0029557815,
-0.7415792346,
-0.125286147,
0.4651610553,
0.3784435391,
-0.1013638079,
0.6757247448,
-0.5237467289,
0.510733366,
-0.0026730523,
0.0237432439,
-0.2606755197,
-0.062260475,
-0.0872730836,
0.2368023992,
1.082049489,
0.2661099434,
0.2703787088,
-0.2464155555,
0.0744640827,
0.1223523095,
-0.0066377614,
-0.9757881165,
-0.2527472675,
0.3294928372,
-0.0584077388,
-0.7222447991,
-0.2438915223,
-1.1857329607,
-0.2962909639,
0.0036043017,
0.1863953918,
-0.3953933716,
-0.3151559234,
-0.0520933717,
-0.1185903996,
0.3586219549,
0.2130322903,
-0.6590953469,
0.0732998028,
0.8785638213,
0.9725781083,
-0.0050009713,
0.010266358,
-0.9752725363,
0.151395902,
-0.411991626,
0.6908201575,
-0.8345068097,
-0.4589373767,
-0.0625057593,
-0.2928120792,
0.0048644147,
0.0132633774,
0.3109511137,
-0.5639047027,
0.2423178554,
0.0120595209,
-0.6852135062,
0.1080406606,
0.1877873987,
-0.3001862466,
0.7599275112,
-0.1607954651,
-0.6592561603,
0.3110185564,
-0.6843357086,
-0.3274080455,
0.2921989262,
-0.6259182692,
-0.2702192068,
0.2922332883,
0.2059527487,
0.5789783597,
-0.3423463404,
0.5340203643,
-0.6213725209,
-0.4202973247,
0.1076771095,
-0.4241100252,
0.827680409,
0.2659623325,
-0.2871167064,
-0.1125484034,
-0.9364575744,
-0.1875611395,
0.1263726354,
0.1111614481,
-0.1246014163,
0.2896229923,
-0.2613245249,
0.3660835922,
-0.0378760807,
-0.8194302917,
0.2954350412,
-0.4985620379,
0.3056866527,
0.5839785933,
0.4378602207,
0.6196573973,
-0.030718619,
0.6412448883,
0.2216068208,
-0.2196266502,
-0.1702502221,
-0.5038353205,
-0.5763041973,
-0.4195295572,
0.3389059305,
0.7258933783,
-1.1518508196,
0.2153645158,
-0.1568749994,
-0.5409845114,
-0.2922711968,
-0.2360827774,
0.2816533148,
0.425660491,
0.0348478407,
-0.2370186448,
-0.5241833329,
-0.4659978151,
-0.2680492699,
-0.5632833838,
-0.1082947031,
-0.1913615167,
0.3260973096,
0.2581939995,
0.9821451306,
-0.4204158485,
0.0792427287,
-0.4693843722,
0.6367545724,
0.1448290944,
0.2233669907,
0.3384709954,
-0.4031825066,
-0.4816610217,
0.1102883145,
-0.7638711929,
-0.0916553661,
-0.1646036059,
-0.149957791,
0.2104712427,
0.4490185082,
-0.4133142233,
0.5867732167,
0.3699772656,
0.085197337,
0.3545284271,
0.0744591653,
0.1205459088,
-1.1721183062,
0.012840596,
0.18824552,
-0.0324855074,
-0.8547328711,
0.0259701237,
-0.1470818967,
-0.2071379125,
-0.5750189424,
0.5288962126,
-0.4375396073,
-0.0755035281,
-0.1702536047,
0.5711522698,
-0.1502853334,
0.475905925,
0.2124921679,
0.3690085709,
0.634418726,
-0.4383360744,
0.3513183296,
-0.146525979,
-0.3620578647,
0.5377706885,
-0.380000025,
0.219967261,
-0.5053902268,
0.0481152646,
-0.7808730602,
-0.0811802745,
0.4994330704,
-0.5101225376,
0.3658699691,
-0.5361772776,
-0.3031922281,
0.0323813297,
-0.4200614989,
0.022572659,
0.6080132127,
-0.0543558449,
0.1881896406,
0.5101433396,
-0.200587526,
-0.6858872771,
-0.3129362762,
0.2421728969,
-0.1767943799,
-0.1562370658,
0.1249147728,
0.2757827938,
-0.3370960951,
-0.0487621464,
0.0338067934,
-0.1647730321,
0.0886403248,
0.1479055434,
0.3866427243,
-0.0417406261,
0.0224753171,
0.2769057751,
-0.0984535888,
0.0229929965,
-0.1710770428,
0.361635983,
0.1516036391,
-0.3968837857,
-0.2956921756,
0.5228657126,
0.4685097635,
-0.1441518366,
0.9828957915,
0.6612867713,
-0.3336507082,
-0.1420128196,
-0.3056144416,
-0.2564751506,
-0.3250772655,
0.5410759449,
-0.2197102159,
-0.8294439912,
0.5254269242,
-0.0323422775,
0.0693926811,
0.3337609172,
0.6274039745,
-0.1679409891,
1.0574059486,
0.2658389807,
-0.1217984855,
0.6911844611,
-0.2946026921,
0.5150835514,
-0.8617036939,
-0.0072185649,
-0.4358849823,
-0.2753758132,
-0.6722835898,
-0.5768279433,
0.4662913382,
0.2359930873,
-0.0893115476,
0.1356971115,
-0.2138542235,
0.4721297324,
0.3373443782,
-0.273457557,
0.2852093279,
0.2691500485,
-0.0597356297,
-0.1270800233,
-0.842572391,
-0.5390352011,
0.9377804399,
0.0186497085,
0.6206647158,
-0.1020381898,
1.0728569031,
0.0168616846,
0.4830462635,
-0.7428446412,
0.7361064553,
-0.1028148681,
-0.5315444469,
-0.315934211,
-0.5593633056,
-1.000110507,
0.29349491,
-0.3052552938,
-1.1927105188,
0.4255078435,
-0.0343633182,
-0.4639655054,
0.6091226339,
-0.2297340035,
0.8497818112,
0.2022052258,
-0.5081208348,
-0.1205771416,
-0.487377286,
0.464872539,
0.0851019695,
0.3478318155,
-0.4533079267,
0.1995416135,
0.4766674936,
-0.0442368835,
0.76878649,
-0.165379867,
-0.0092791691,
0.4497094154,
0.3470582068,
0.4445130527,
0.2399319708,
-0.324228406,
0.282301724,
0.2481749207,
-0.4200508893,
-0.5294678211,
0.7508756518,
-0.6280078292,
-0.4212842286,
-0.6192359328,
-0.486218363,
-0.0321412496,
-0.2441525906,
0.2813726962,
0.4657121003,
-0.5293082595,
0.1856288016,
0.3587346673,
-0.1327476799,
0.5645289421,
0.628374517,
-0.3147898614,
-0.1272535622,
1.1995819807,
0.2864916623,
0.2046136409,
0.4306070209,
0.0113671487,
0.014167225,
-0.4034231007,
-0.6601834893,
-0.0212857705,
-0.288515687,
-0.2908839285,
-0.7656545043,
-0.5217756629,
-0.3284437358,
-0.0748382807,
-0.3527781665,
-0.6977291107,
-0.4048634768,
-0.053023193,
0.2850286663,
0.3560790718,
-0.323771596,
0.2974898219,
-0.9102926254,
0.2532708049,
0.0944342315,
-0.0461252928,
-0.1009326875,
-0.4292145669,
-0.1263952404,
0.1384937167,
-0.6045486927,
-1.3785271645,
0.631604135,
0.4198655188,
0.2380189896,
0.3768717051,
0.3567444682,
0.7787751555,
-0.5941468477,
0.9397088885,
0.1073248684,
-1.010345459,
0.69094491,
-0.4449054003,
0.110786438,
0.3561506271,
0.3227389455,
-0.7853605151,
-0.7171165943,
-0.8481884003,
-0.8097482324,
0.7139098048,
0.3543742299,
0.1262086928,
-0.6098963022,
0.6709916592,
-0.2555051744,
0.4166965783,
-0.4729532003,
-0.1598254293,
0.2547919452,
-0.167564109,
-0.0080834916,
-0.2376705706,
-0.0355026275,
-0.0526989438,
0.636334002,
-0.1519085318,
0.1975666434,
0.1964538544,
-0.0256963316,
-0.334207654,
0.4823235273,
0.3840199411,
0.4631833732,
-0.2180668265,
0.1180900261,
0.128201142,
-0.1276090145,
0.090118669,
0.2096673846,
-0.3125319481,
-0.0495620109,
0.3242941201,
0.6705749631,
0.2183385342,
-0.5593259931,
0.4931414425,
-0.1158202961,
-0.2017496973,
-0.3054735959,
0.0947350785,
-0.2189390063,
0.3801919818,
0.2572598755,
-0.301623702,
0.3238094449,
-0.9079877734,
0.3646929562,
0.5491394401,
-0.4732775688,
-0.4502171278,
0.4709501266,
0.139770329,
-0.2396010011,
0.4877890646,
-0.8169864416,
-0.4113610983,
0.5755750537,
0.3253000379,
0.8564353585,
-0.1409791112,
0.8017814159,
0.3915564716,
0.1893771589,
0.1062508374,
0.3559370041,
-0.0152245676,
-0.8403066993,
-0.8618139625,
-0.6656270027,
-0.5342327356,
0.157414481,
-0.7945619822,
0.2858508825,
-0.3245773613,
0.0564473383,
0.00230436,
0.1797326207,
-0.431055814,
-0.2000897527,
0.4401634037,
0.3485535979,
-0.8544253707,
1.0374795198,
0.4757725894,
-0.3072166741,
-0.3619371355,
0.0366552286,
0.148795411,
-0.582113862,
0.6147418618,
-0.1843476146,
0.0143584553,
0.0309406687,
-0.5776823759,
-0.6277987957,
0.7111238241,
0.4740280807,
-0.9134414196,
-0.0239153728,
-0.016354559,
0.4589492679,
-0.4058963656,
0.2686202228,
0.5767790675,
0.1478046775,
0.4587209821,
-0.4299971461,
-0.1571285874,
0.0215933491,
0.1365447938,
0.3669848144,
-0.3905525208,
0.67614007,
-0.1328109205,
-0.3847908676,
-0.0635510385,
0.828032732,
0.3100482523,
0.6039102674,
0.2810512483,
0.260069102,
0.4968966544,
0.0394833125,
1.0140616894,
-0.4995193779,
0.5232328773,
1.2427676916,
-0.6556519866,
0.8998637795,
0.4509243667,
-0.083747156,
0.5817871094,
0.3431628048,
0.4413077533,
0.4524738193,
0.4144233763,
-0.5860399604,
-0.2941925228,
0.0096154325,
-0.0121710058,
0.5937619209,
0.5990642309,
-0.0252434984,
-0.4930486679,
-0.1597907394,
0.1721257269,
-0.0591289066,
-0.1055452079,
0.790379107,
0.2076160759,
-0.5167255402,
0.1628889441,
0.0892076343,
0.173670277,
-0.3553094864,
-0.2086456269,
-0.1795751005,
-0.0226743985,
0.0835530236,
-0.7282721996,
0.3972631395,
0.2594399154,
0.100513503,
0.0859232917,
0.666772902,
-0.7922151685,
-0.716437757,
0.2352609485,
0.7722216249,
0.3132095635,
-0.1749802977,
-0.6500293016,
0.1182802394,
-0.1112736985,
-0.2849797308,
0.4676258862,
0.7593534589,
-0.1049540117,
0.2737098634,
0.6443198919,
0.5099778175,
-0.0390905552,
0.1705988348,
0.648547411,
-0.5645944476,
0.0427405871,
-1.1186782122,
0.5338445902,
-0.4951443672,
0.0122279581,
0.5648427606,
0.2260847986,
0.63245368,
0.2987702191,
0.7452248931,
-0.2913658917,
0.3045633137,
-0.2251187712,
0.5107235312,
-0.4067853689,
0.2711958885,
-0.3225106001,
-0.8499479294,
-0.4067669809,
0.8367612958,
-0.4147624075,
-0.2015145719,
0.4735645056,
0.8128527999,
0.1078129932,
-0.0445603281,
0.5897058845,
0.2586791813,
0.4942392111,
0.4687052965,
0.8975710273,
-0.4152881503,
0.3512288332,
-0.4098772705,
-0.3459830582,
-0.2297285944,
-1.2370625734,
-0.8188747168,
-0.5464713573,
-0.6787104011,
-0.2107002139,
0.3222070634,
1.0504719019,
0.6826393604,
-0.7478781343,
-0.3295382261,
-0.105926536,
0.3457742929,
-0.1292590946,
-0.2737566829,
-0.0436801277,
-0.48126176,
-0.8940932751,
0.4159646332,
0.6315316558,
-0.3647461832,
-0.2583874464,
0.333350867,
-0.3305535913,
0.3976336718,
0.7211737633,
0.3631123602,
-0.5359082818,
-0.542557478,
-0.186725527,
0.1607683599,
-0.1240926012,
0.652163744,
-0.6351595521,
0.5526939034,
0.494769454,
0.2815822363,
0.6788395047,
-0.3396549225,
0.6820402741,
-1.0082136393,
0.4278812408,
0.3051252663,
0.3132190704,
0.1182673648,
-0.3179197311,
0.4031023979,
0.1851788461,
-0.5927526355,
-1.0101397038,
0.403518796,
-0.7896850109,
-0.0177520961,
1.090354085,
-0.1299046874,
-0.3517810702,
-0.0018248203,
-0.0748483017,
0.525287807,
-0.5777536035,
0.9668941498,
0.6535705924,
-0.0414968692,
-0.4674717188,
-0.6259122491,
0.3139604032,
0.2013096213,
-0.6521862745,
-0.0606297702,
0.4280956388,
0.0767652467,
0.0052344589,
0.7254596353,
-0.1466800123,
0.0189884752,
-0.1778207421,
0.1506184191,
0.3234853446,
-0.4204126298,
-0.3782820702,
0.2857278585,
-0.1378874928,
-0.1678761393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15048v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15048v1 | Ranger: A Toolkit for Effect-Size Based Multi-Task Evaluation | 2023-05-24T11:38:39 | 2023-05-24T11:38:39 | Mete Sertkan, Sophia Althammer, Sebastian Hofstätter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | In this paper, we introduce Ranger - a toolkit to facilitate the easy use of
effect-size-based meta-analysis for multi-task evaluation in NLP and IR. We
observed that our communities often face the challenge of aggregating results
over incomparable metrics and scenarios, which makes conclusions and take-away
messages less reliable. With Ranger, we aim to address this issue by providing
a task-agnostic toolkit that combines the effect of a treatment on multiple
tasks into one statistical evaluation, allowing for comparison of metrics and
computation of an overall summary effect. Our toolkit produces
publication-ready forest plots that enable clear communication of evaluation
results over multiple tasks. Our goal with the ready-to-use Ranger toolkit is
to promote robust, effect-size-based evaluation and improve evaluation
standards in the community. We provide two case studies for common IR and NLP
settings to highlight Ranger's benefits. | [
-0.4612519145,
-0.6153650284,
0.3116905391,
0.7478618026,
-0.2749132514,
0.1748061776,
-0.2245206684,
-0.3757952452,
0.9249463677,
0.5734787583,
-0.647330761,
-0.1344195604,
-1.1939760447,
0.1994493753,
-0.3860310614,
1.0779213905,
0.0171437934,
-0.0852593929,
-0.0183307789,
-0.5035780072,
-0.7403563857,
-0.1255751401,
-0.632457912,
-0.3765126765,
1.0329333544,
0.6601843238,
0.5909135938,
0.1162940785,
1.3527323008,
0.1922154874,
0.1524257362,
0.1383566707,
-0.3118316829,
0.2482220829,
-0.0415254608,
0.021597717,
-0.7403864861,
0.1099454314,
0.7603436708,
0.4775617719,
-0.4558790326,
0.7665034533,
0.0720163584,
0.5737344623,
-0.8759093881,
0.044614099,
-0.4973041415,
0.109768562,
-0.0703134537,
-0.3219219148,
-0.350473702,
-0.0277132615,
0.0197136309,
-0.7428313494,
0.1624813527,
0.1203493774,
0.2792001963,
0.3705749512,
-0.429128468,
-0.0514786094,
-0.4666284621,
0.959980309,
-0.5133908391,
-0.0515164658,
0.1408107728,
0.6290150881,
0.1860422641,
-0.7786114812,
-0.4822039902,
0.2715066373,
-0.5288376212,
0.1935695559,
-0.3204475343,
0.3656274378,
0.5535363555,
0.0038122565,
-0.4169094861,
-0.1110035032,
-0.1205815971,
-0.1770840585,
0.3792975247,
0.2711559236,
0.2588498592,
-0.6836488247,
-0.0736431479,
-0.3006485701,
-0.2595911622,
-0.3083379865,
0.140876174,
0.388892889,
0.1669280827,
0.6794460416,
-0.0161805693,
0.5243917704,
-0.1654457003,
-0.2440703213,
0.2212974876,
-0.5561982989,
-0.4002487361,
-0.3550608754,
0.953803122,
0.6514153481,
-0.4112698138,
-0.2184993774,
-0.2517839372,
0.1241775751,
0.1430320889,
-0.9892082214,
-0.0146853523,
0.1622463167,
-0.8414649963,
-0.1903789788,
-0.0708275288,
-1.3065036535,
-0.3570308387,
-0.2226459682,
0.6386240125,
0.0690020397,
-0.7127825618,
0.1413259953,
-0.7788453102,
-0.024863828,
0.4491769373,
-0.6125065088,
0.6463694572,
0.5576210022,
1.062022686,
-0.2819243073,
-0.4744433463,
-1.0207306147,
-0.0457966886,
0.0376164876,
0.5435346961,
-0.6298866868,
-0.7954465151,
-0.3648162484,
0.0036739854,
-0.3978262246,
-0.3162328005,
0.5275568962,
-0.1162679866,
0.206416741,
-0.4182858169,
0.1464912146,
-0.0178806279,
0.1376049966,
-0.9182417393,
1.2173908949,
0.4097077847,
-0.9441508055,
0.5936189294,
-1.4083838463,
-0.6342242956,
-0.138773188,
0.2081985921,
-0.3842033744,
0.0212471113,
0.1382254362,
0.4925768375,
-0.4542152882,
0.4373900592,
-0.144663021,
0.0933818817,
-0.1111508012,
-0.3584226072,
0.7609353662,
0.1758409441,
-0.294849664,
0.500304997,
-0.2514351606,
0.2758237123,
-0.2418435365,
0.0556042604,
-0.2126134634,
-0.1618744582,
0.4621047676,
0.436901927,
-0.0199047234,
-0.8595619798,
0.0529807135,
0.14648965,
0.3219361007,
0.3455025852,
0.1149342209,
0.2699299753,
-0.4597111046,
0.8606773615,
-0.6584407091,
0.6689299941,
-0.231775552,
-0.4373378456,
-0.2213655114,
-0.5202419162,
0.5211789012,
0.2978990376,
-0.7964701653,
0.3110082746,
-0.3679212928,
-0.613583684,
-0.3680314422,
0.1029231474,
0.3330657482,
0.4131810069,
0.4519355595,
-0.7767072916,
-0.6030631661,
-0.8752438426,
-0.294927001,
0.1861523241,
-0.1470257491,
0.2937494814,
0.7926647663,
-0.3587494195,
1.1644290686,
-0.7527087331,
-0.7205112576,
-0.4426477551,
0.4707458317,
-0.0425990894,
0.2744618654,
0.9028689861,
-0.4420732558,
-0.603127718,
-0.2604158521,
-0.2878288627,
-0.226226896,
0.0974157751,
-0.2098789662,
-0.1837465316,
0.0083430968,
-0.7662933469,
0.3282859027,
0.5060070753,
-0.3509944081,
0.5612174869,
-0.3158079386,
0.4364158511,
-0.6906645298,
0.4981379807,
0.051990021,
-0.2001874447,
-0.2873609662,
0.1254228801,
-0.1147131622,
-0.2297398001,
-0.0533069111,
0.6594324112,
-0.256824404,
-0.4353945851,
-0.099207297,
0.0938862041,
0.2039696574,
0.3643237948,
-0.0811354816,
0.5016881824,
0.3833695352,
-0.1023684964,
0.1192076504,
-0.0083007785,
-0.1016550139,
0.5650933385,
-0.6876997352,
-0.0967621505,
-0.0579703227,
0.6133925319,
-0.8725935817,
-0.5411829948,
0.2481168807,
-0.318756789,
0.1610821337,
-0.0380912125,
-0.7742546201,
-0.426204145,
-0.7452341914,
0.0630194098,
0.4051956534,
-0.2771756947,
1.0317376852,
0.4117963314,
-0.1832940727,
-0.9058399796,
-0.5960092545,
0.246430546,
-0.4334600866,
-0.536732614,
0.1448855847,
-0.1070119888,
-0.3235977888,
0.1594881713,
-0.1535196453,
-0.1877532899,
0.0755010843,
0.2884362936,
-0.1334202141,
0.0386390872,
0.127420783,
0.1086886153,
-0.1882946044,
0.1509860754,
0.4235054553,
0.1621170491,
0.1174507812,
-0.3787381649,
0.0924680755,
0.5358495116,
0.7057019472,
-0.5656881928,
0.5408570766,
0.4721961617,
-0.0908308402,
-0.3759281933,
-0.3044611514,
-0.4095880091,
-0.3690547049,
0.2663403451,
-0.0025997011,
-0.4810868502,
0.4270543158,
-0.3413286507,
0.5694912672,
0.8876266479,
-0.1737501919,
0.0097041856,
0.9607082605,
0.565925777,
0.1640142053,
0.7036599517,
-0.4311344028,
-0.0161407571,
-1.2351800203,
-0.0581386052,
-0.5809934139,
-0.7346670628,
0.2280368358,
-0.8086475134,
0.4579816461,
-0.1016258746,
-0.0239736084,
0.3177739382,
-0.9074577093,
0.3569193482,
0.3629945517,
-0.0208173357,
0.2556782961,
-0.1848080456,
0.4588797092,
-0.0037061786,
-0.8304810524,
-0.3688601255,
1.4420696497,
0.1121705472,
0.5242502689,
0.226427719,
0.6095554233,
0.6304550171,
0.9708519578,
-0.9531698823,
0.5479604602,
-0.3434564173,
-0.744781673,
-0.8223164678,
-0.4107818305,
-1.1419667006,
0.5990001559,
-0.3803775907,
-0.5546514392,
-0.1106658578,
-0.0184152722,
-0.1595445573,
0.1809572279,
-1.1202110052,
0.99087286,
-0.2790769935,
0.1492102742,
-0.5938386321,
-0.7259469032,
0.4392154813,
-0.4072436094,
0.3892088532,
-0.2530306578,
-0.0118094422,
1.1392221451,
-0.3946499825,
0.9116148353,
-0.545656383,
0.4356123209,
0.3236043453,
-0.0815813839,
0.3145442307,
-0.062982142,
-0.0939548686,
0.1256714314,
0.2524353564,
-0.1359688193,
-0.968934834,
0.5535340905,
-0.6114063859,
-0.4117209017,
-0.4849271476,
-0.4688999355,
0.1305305958,
0.2951774299,
-0.1854125708,
0.5636969805,
-0.317006588,
0.3275728822,
0.270188421,
-0.1678410769,
0.4963353574,
0.7965587378,
-0.7669285536,
-0.4656507373,
0.80555439,
0.5975650549,
0.3205444515,
0.3430325687,
0.4289693534,
-0.1022062004,
-0.1052689999,
-0.27765432,
0.0552280359,
-0.6506590247,
-0.4556353688,
-0.6946405172,
0.1417094618,
-0.0090067713,
-0.0737443715,
-0.0362348743,
-0.695294857,
0.3098348975,
-0.0228053872,
0.6107721329,
0.796903789,
-0.204094395,
1.0240668058,
-0.4928213656,
0.5218788385,
0.3814424276,
0.6293702722,
0.1033790037,
0.0281872321,
-0.0622908287,
-0.0028619024,
-0.4887760282,
-0.6203165054,
0.2370104343,
0.3612616956,
0.6591233015,
-0.1291817278,
0.0406944752,
0.3011761606,
-0.2420124114,
0.5134803057,
0.6659020782,
-0.8485658765,
0.6828058958,
-0.2630676031,
0.3705546558,
0.4758532941,
-0.2178685367,
-0.8633413315,
-0.1820956171,
-0.800711453,
-0.7246075869,
1.0116981268,
0.3079528809,
-0.2752093077,
0.0499332435,
-0.1038996354,
0.2731167376,
0.2035141438,
-0.4071501791,
-0.198252961,
-0.3696215153,
0.044235792,
-0.3657729924,
-0.1098145992,
-0.5422587395,
-0.1140228659,
0.4241552949,
-0.2973301113,
0.1968191862,
0.0893238112,
-0.0861928239,
-0.339071691,
0.3190119565,
0.2386633605,
0.8490222692,
-0.462502569,
0.1467481703,
0.3774877787,
-0.6180869937,
-0.2215378582,
0.0948382393,
0.2246099561,
0.3801745474,
0.7676807642,
0.4656367898,
0.2390506715,
-0.3864652514,
0.6626504064,
-0.1962646395,
-0.3538774252,
0.3401557207,
-0.0735987127,
-0.1405907571,
-0.2816678584,
0.3175905943,
0.6501535177,
0.3590765595,
-0.353482455,
0.1781022102,
0.5550957918,
-0.2206522226,
-0.1442745477,
0.2551232874,
0.6555722356,
-0.4889446795,
0.1230352446,
0.1417116672,
-0.309685111,
1.1370881796,
0.1255966425,
0.9467887282,
-0.2798496783,
0.6858804822,
0.4168429673,
0.6795384884,
-0.2529510558,
0.2664937973,
0.0675050914,
-0.2088846117,
-0.7526593804,
-0.4627790749,
-0.5621328354,
-0.2534040809,
-0.6530591846,
0.126004383,
-0.3775335252,
-0.4123250246,
0.3316551745,
0.0678376108,
-0.7923640609,
0.2007449269,
-0.9101439714,
0.806874454,
-0.8855153322,
0.6460177898,
0.4569667876,
-0.221225813,
-0.7250617743,
-0.1022886932,
0.0337483287,
-0.6650229096,
0.5939487219,
0.2766795158,
-0.5982480645,
-0.3091093302,
-0.2383389622,
-0.8704992533,
1.2963687181,
0.2729680538,
-0.4130226672,
0.4928049445,
-0.1815398335,
0.648753047,
-0.2882488072,
0.6415805221,
0.5072393417,
0.8811879158,
0.1002956033,
-1.3286203146,
-0.1074667722,
0.0753483027,
-0.5123358965,
0.7776204944,
-0.7170618773,
0.486415118,
-0.0920021236,
-0.1662338674,
-0.4226008356,
-0.1202997938,
-0.231808722,
0.4663339555,
0.8144441247,
0.2521372736,
0.7101357579,
-0.0526145026,
1.0787624121,
-0.3069455624,
0.5428085923,
1.149802804,
-0.2362989038,
0.7553111315,
0.5436625481,
-0.2991585135,
0.0395606533,
0.2758125365,
0.2623360753,
0.4354574084,
0.294578135,
-0.089694716,
0.0107260374,
-0.4181667864,
-0.3368750811,
0.2140063047,
0.3838224113,
-0.2165617049,
-0.5058572292,
0.2499498427,
-0.1428878158,
-0.2160017043,
-0.2449121624,
0.4695980251,
0.049023848,
-0.6535507441,
-0.1172578409,
-0.006204559,
0.7289117575,
-1.1460194588,
-0.1559656411,
0.1231122464,
0.0623197183,
-0.5435635448,
-1.2297917604,
0.7698610425,
0.0485885516,
-0.2985344231,
-0.6735030413,
0.9434212446,
-0.0893511847,
-0.4638278782,
0.5346348882,
0.5874166489,
0.0118193394,
-0.1329399198,
-0.6315799952,
-0.0325012878,
-0.2512164414,
-0.1481883824,
0.210207507,
0.4398159385,
0.0138795981,
0.6911903024,
0.4017154574,
0.0102727041,
-0.3447488546,
0.3194006085,
0.7290835381,
-0.3059111834,
-0.0308221821,
-0.5793675184,
0.446201086,
-0.4567628503,
-0.5578203797,
0.927945435,
0.6855296493,
0.1334896237,
-0.0019418539,
1.0258876085,
-0.6690365672,
0.6507686377,
-0.0234647244,
0.4455215931,
-0.5960572362,
0.1867228001,
-0.5428757071,
-1.0400308371,
-0.4525192082,
0.2472413033,
-0.3129452467,
0.0709790513,
0.9797331095,
0.338885814,
-0.0998390988,
-0.1203235015,
0.0952686071,
-0.1786192656,
0.4207363129,
0.1356977224,
0.4911282063,
-0.0789181739,
0.6501484513,
0.0573529638,
-0.5006680489,
-0.1085510999,
-0.9165017605,
-0.8477220535,
-0.3942394555,
-0.2034683228,
-0.0111004254,
-0.1956351995,
0.7564693689,
0.6523692608,
-0.2529226542,
-0.3050096035,
0.3746410906,
0.4949047565,
-0.5657106638,
-0.2243984193,
0.5211402178,
-0.049032744,
-0.1894252598,
-0.150594309,
0.4985264838,
-0.4423100054,
-0.3801852167,
-0.0579448044,
-0.0363700576,
-0.175480321,
0.8558686376,
0.1394172013,
-0.7402809858,
-0.4407727122,
0.130717501,
0.0811123177,
-0.0732093304,
1.0520695448,
-0.7133826613,
0.7214441299,
0.3863008022,
0.3742625713,
0.5086001158,
-0.314312607,
0.5734202266,
-0.9041743279,
-0.2471085042,
0.0884676278,
0.2741541862,
0.2553514838,
-0.1283260286,
1.0229480267,
-0.0690173209,
-0.5767737627,
-0.8157224655,
0.0417995453,
-1.0193758011,
-0.3638180792,
1.0580390692,
0.0865000263,
0.1923174411,
0.0337722227,
-0.7740158439,
0.0350200348,
-0.600449264,
0.6125294566,
1.0278029442,
-0.1025183797,
-0.0768938363,
-0.6409352422,
0.5401183367,
0.2281449288,
-1.1111351252,
0.3209594786,
0.3714587688,
0.2525303066,
0.3561166525,
0.8002126217,
0.3167956173,
0.143403545,
0.1363517046,
0.1811778694,
0.1881670803,
-0.443813026,
-0.0579264127,
0.0485301912,
0.0451235473,
-0.0243176688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15047v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15047v3 | Ghostbuster: Detecting Text Ghostwritten by Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:37:10 | 2024-04-05T23:57:35 | Vivek Verma, Eve Fleisig, Nicholas Tomlin, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce Ghostbuster, a state-of-the-art system for detecting
AI-generated text. Our method works by passing documents through a series of
weaker language models, running a structured search over possible combinations
of their features, and then training a classifier on the selected features to
predict whether documents are AI-generated. Crucially, Ghostbuster does not
require access to token probabilities from the target model, making it useful
for detecting text generated by black-box models or unknown model versions. In
conjunction with our model, we release three new datasets of human- and
AI-generated text as detection benchmarks in the domains of student essays,
creative writing, and news articles. We compare Ghostbuster to a variety of
existing detectors, including DetectGPT and GPTZero, as well as a new RoBERTa
baseline. Ghostbuster achieves 99.0 F1 when evaluated across domains, which is
5.9 F1 higher than the best preexisting model. It also outperforms all previous
approaches in generalization across writing domains (+7.5 F1), prompting
strategies (+2.1 F1), and language models (+4.4 F1). We also analyze the
robustness of our system to a variety of perturbations and paraphrasing attacks
and evaluate its performance on documents written by non-native English
speakers. | [
-0.2257471383,
-0.8610577583,
0.7354261279,
-0.0961105078,
-0.1800659597,
0.2677084506,
-0.1968667358,
-0.6208715439,
0.2846026421,
0.6751015186,
-0.1932475567,
-0.4637358785,
-0.8468160629,
0.1651120037,
-0.850084126,
1.3693383932,
0.0955941901,
-0.0580178648,
-0.2551430464,
0.1500851363,
-0.3188195229,
-0.6087112427,
-0.6961424351,
-0.3122794628,
0.488619417,
0.0958387479,
0.4850576222,
0.5639936328,
0.3117768168,
0.2741715014,
0.0614761263,
0.1942683607,
-0.3780057728,
0.231483981,
-0.2249370217,
-0.2372657657,
-0.3998298645,
0.0126319965,
0.6345751286,
0.25517869,
0.2436870933,
0.1360350996,
-0.0052574626,
0.3725481927,
-0.6670966744,
-0.12250074,
-0.770247817,
-0.3684104681,
-0.268936336,
-0.1728340089,
-0.6161729097,
-0.3052588403,
-0.0811429173,
-0.1509338915,
0.727624774,
0.120470807,
0.9206913114,
0.1551490873,
-0.1466918588,
-0.4654312134,
-0.7035984993,
0.6472652555,
-0.4197182655,
0.238326177,
0.4084886014,
0.2992818654,
-0.1167685911,
-0.8403149247,
-0.9662626386,
-0.5151785016,
0.0084943231,
0.1080714837,
-0.3496780097,
-0.1229231283,
0.0493613109,
0.3723301888,
-0.882024169,
0.0891379416,
-0.2268366963,
-0.4018199444,
0.7356260419,
0.0230697189,
0.3240042925,
-0.1358175725,
0.0098678507,
-0.1806221306,
-0.2701868415,
-0.3970115185,
0.7742925286,
-0.1628922671,
0.2759211361,
0.4042316079,
0.0174944792,
0.6597887874,
-0.0508545265,
-0.0172432214,
-0.2145215571,
-0.1590502858,
0.1300620288,
0.127234146,
0.8389831781,
0.2895685732,
0.4165507555,
-0.3253104091,
-0.6669402122,
0.3758843839,
0.2427550852,
-0.7379118204,
-0.5654402971,
0.0493503772,
-0.5593636632,
-0.4719938934,
0.2041460574,
-0.6071304679,
-0.728504777,
-0.0344870016,
0.4459518194,
-0.5048507452,
-0.3044361174,
0.0796737,
-0.3526137471,
0.0781932846,
0.3294250965,
-0.7669337988,
0.3083538115,
0.8149599433,
0.8158330917,
-0.4872896969,
-0.4360946417,
-0.7393338084,
0.143945545,
-0.4139836729,
1.2105383873,
-0.4851643443,
-0.2494955361,
-0.1025546566,
-0.1729268581,
0.1255333573,
-0.4877267182,
0.642804265,
-0.1846193522,
0.4378680587,
0.4178782403,
-0.7155607343,
-0.0943948105,
0.1541172862,
-0.6983910799,
1.1420595646,
0.0569358394,
-0.650814116,
0.4712083638,
-0.3640450537,
-0.5471046567,
0.2182296515,
-0.1134903878,
-0.7441576123,
0.3135457337,
0.1427433193,
0.7464191914,
-0.1501358598,
0.4192119241,
0.0350322537,
-0.6486093402,
0.2904107571,
-0.6061227918,
0.515981853,
0.0306296293,
-0.4529865384,
0.0986668468,
-1.0228735209,
-0.2560842037,
0.4030833542,
-0.2396377325,
-0.4897044897,
0.0302660055,
0.6979355216,
-0.1447416544,
0.364674747,
-0.5627448559,
0.0713003203,
0.0579872653,
0.3276628554,
0.6704393029,
0.0862083063,
0.0556395762,
-0.4200515747,
0.5809094906,
-0.2962884009,
-0.2848767936,
-0.747451365,
-0.6424995065,
-0.7294455171,
-0.503272593,
0.3046393096,
0.6027299166,
-0.515712738,
0.9633285999,
-0.0250827596,
-0.5863065124,
-0.4338864982,
-0.1521096677,
0.4842118919,
0.3248246312,
0.3377594352,
-0.1666427553,
-0.3741230369,
-0.8492552042,
-0.4476777017,
-0.3549349606,
-0.2935322821,
-0.2258971184,
0.7450501323,
-0.2378085107,
0.7663193941,
-0.4798117876,
-0.3675924242,
-0.4409349263,
0.4625167847,
-0.2570003569,
0.6375904679,
0.6249986887,
-0.6977449656,
-0.4685987532,
-0.0586124361,
-0.7496794462,
-0.2704218328,
-0.4342365861,
0.2538285851,
0.5585013628,
0.5506403446,
-0.6619593501,
0.6155973077,
0.3682581782,
-0.3581814766,
0.3729985356,
-0.2188775092,
-0.0098845214,
-1.2751541138,
0.1895241141,
0.0746055171,
-0.3875038624,
-0.5879175663,
-0.0214024968,
0.1504942626,
-0.2977991998,
0.0982637033,
0.6933883429,
-0.480586499,
0.2221684009,
-0.7954343557,
0.1900461167,
0.0906835347,
0.2731255591,
0.1547373235,
0.729719162,
0.2764742076,
-0.2699217498,
0.248645857,
0.0134320166,
-0.2354235202,
0.7617626786,
-0.5411519408,
0.5467880964,
-0.3046376407,
0.4611940086,
-1.1275361776,
-0.1614448726,
0.1992848814,
-0.8281945586,
0.2688701451,
0.0024685564,
-0.7834160328,
-0.2758324146,
-0.2182009667,
-0.1235737428,
0.5298395157,
-0.4426785111,
0.8544092178,
0.3116345704,
-0.0529304706,
-0.2927053571,
-0.5555772781,
0.6279942989,
-0.0318132788,
-0.5142602921,
0.1539122015,
-0.073742412,
-0.1824982613,
0.1580469161,
-0.0806777477,
-0.1169966608,
0.2702327967,
0.1972299963,
0.1387793422,
-0.1994390637,
-0.1326960027,
0.1175005883,
-0.2816206813,
0.0373443738,
-0.6678863764,
0.6647365689,
0.1256590337,
-0.1708162725,
-0.5152685046,
0.3919153512,
0.5307311416,
-0.4313412011,
0.6790181994,
0.8101331592,
-0.7059028149,
-0.4681529105,
-0.7906226516,
-0.3194395304,
-0.4499283731,
0.3585627377,
-0.2654933333,
-0.6694277525,
0.3612420857,
0.4785880148,
-0.1923649311,
0.3871877491,
0.5711179376,
0.3092432022,
1.0767900944,
0.9888038635,
-0.2650088966,
0.4840804338,
0.0529888719,
0.3891539872,
-0.224584192,
-0.1170637831,
-0.6643038392,
-0.0284743365,
-0.4809142053,
-0.0505330637,
-0.0956136435,
-0.1702642888,
0.4422548711,
0.5752089024,
-0.8201234341,
0.7678016424,
0.813331306,
-0.2102728337,
0.4964190722,
-0.2466816008,
0.2056907564,
0.091850996,
-0.1878002733,
-0.9673331976,
1.2938899994,
0.200919643,
0.5524557233,
-0.2768209279,
0.8300750256,
0.5728573799,
0.5430911183,
-0.5839021206,
0.6693736911,
-0.0452374704,
-0.6881699562,
-0.0760565475,
-0.1650656313,
-0.8753191233,
0.1163827032,
-0.3234750926,
-0.7065244913,
-0.2405133098,
0.0659841597,
-0.053646557,
0.412840873,
-0.7130156755,
0.850222826,
-0.2438447773,
-0.3391340673,
-0.2097827047,
-0.2998536229,
0.208411634,
-0.437530309,
-0.285289824,
-0.0418402553,
-0.0832102224,
0.7096913457,
-0.0473952331,
0.5190877318,
-0.0631462038,
-0.2016964406,
0.3654928505,
0.2191869318,
0.5717314482,
0.1266016364,
-0.0177719649,
0.3212245107,
-0.1352566779,
-0.3983647227,
-0.4808154106,
0.4847242534,
-0.3567341864,
-0.4451214671,
-0.7319974303,
-0.6451429129,
0.1571782827,
0.6248691678,
0.5555206537,
0.1803563684,
-0.466822654,
0.1743791252,
0.6400518417,
-0.1565510184,
0.4074768424,
0.6731615067,
-0.2697939873,
-0.2257866263,
1.2669909,
-0.0395694636,
-0.1587644219,
0.4454050958,
0.1359700412,
0.018687766,
-1.0270775557,
-0.5198493004,
0.1856652051,
-0.551371634,
-0.0517892726,
-0.950591445,
-0.2679097354,
-0.5073809028,
-0.2640428841,
-0.20277825,
-0.2846799791,
-0.3097635806,
-0.0166480001,
0.165847823,
0.8808305264,
0.2011060715,
0.3379140794,
-0.5788895488,
0.3879457116,
0.0061023273,
0.1128005087,
-0.1650942862,
-0.4539145827,
-0.3156906068,
-0.4782526195,
-0.462328732,
-0.6982965469,
0.5082990527,
-0.0716456696,
0.4826100469,
0.4684665203,
0.0075713596,
0.1524699926,
-0.5810788274,
0.8019540906,
-0.2107471228,
-0.9884889722,
0.3796055913,
-0.5841563344,
0.0773859918,
0.596790731,
0.2852377892,
-0.5047590733,
-1.007042408,
-0.7020493746,
-0.453884542,
0.4196171761,
0.3129910231,
0.2776396871,
0.0563756824,
0.3567055464,
0.2060617656,
0.4602254033,
-0.7345712781,
0.0752920061,
-0.2008554339,
-0.5554121137,
-0.257748425,
-0.0956088752,
0.2691845894,
0.0952607766,
0.4807174206,
-0.1945088804,
0.2091535032,
0.050622236,
-0.1540023386,
-0.1406764388,
-0.1904693097,
0.7129587531,
0.6218370795,
-0.2069885731,
0.0823140964,
-0.1637046635,
-0.7810126543,
-0.099799335,
0.4947811365,
-0.370606035,
0.22088404,
0.5940180421,
0.38185063,
-0.3039970696,
-0.949593842,
0.5607689023,
-0.1884228587,
-0.155325681,
-0.6177284718,
0.2196022272,
-0.2015856206,
0.0420658216,
0.7251704335,
0.1168169752,
0.2268071771,
-0.3203561008,
0.3633098006,
0.501372695,
-0.2649965584,
-0.5421274304,
0.9838196039,
0.0551720373,
-0.6433030963,
0.2831624746,
-0.2856391072,
-0.6654596925,
0.6607871652,
0.6083812118,
1.2870395184,
-0.2530214489,
0.1029221565,
-0.0337694027,
0.6716480255,
-0.2382117063,
0.018434165,
-0.0574545227,
-0.6751207113,
0.054167591,
-0.397544235,
-0.6247165799,
0.6384538412,
-0.3089786768,
0.5602486134,
-0.7373487949,
0.0839177519,
0.17268911,
0.0095260674,
-0.2910703123,
0.0308727343,
0.1932071149,
0.6196776628,
-0.8728346825,
0.7903966308,
0.7854133844,
-0.5303433537,
-0.2717172801,
0.6842386127,
0.0875052512,
-0.5358090997,
0.2652696669,
0.5901343822,
-0.3129757345,
0.1739214063,
-0.6904159188,
-0.5578668714,
0.7584600449,
0.2389827371,
-0.200203374,
-0.0310888682,
-0.1513505876,
0.823153615,
-0.2553651631,
0.1279779375,
0.5077716708,
0.4021987915,
-0.4476211667,
-0.651186645,
-0.0163987651,
-0.3285005391,
-0.1543364674,
0.2650316954,
-0.6329166889,
0.9064784646,
0.1929496527,
-0.1647426188,
0.4244570434,
0.8324055672,
0.1944240779,
0.6678624153,
0.2706044614,
0.5141429305,
0.8674795628,
-0.0005916494,
1.0011628866,
-0.3775143623,
-0.0074596237,
0.7202569842,
-0.4237645268,
0.6306115985,
0.1831334531,
0.2621082067,
0.5573602915,
0.4117696583,
-0.4861386418,
0.1402436197,
0.3256583512,
-0.2579118311,
-0.0815083683,
-0.0970306918,
-0.0818721652,
0.3888742626,
0.1813372076,
-0.3439409733,
0.0541251525,
0.1528396606,
0.299998641,
0.6132333279,
-0.0571005158,
0.693572402,
-0.1099929065,
-0.8959214687,
0.4675510526,
0.3285818398,
0.844342351,
-0.5072365403,
-0.1181964874,
-0.3851336539,
0.6166108251,
-0.0948692262,
-0.6354545951,
0.0811736882,
0.2935090065,
-0.1705894917,
-0.2257592231,
0.9426301718,
-0.4638568759,
-0.6358587742,
0.2596258521,
0.3086778224,
0.2611728013,
-0.2849627435,
-0.356128633,
0.1037872285,
-0.2983927727,
-0.2137105018,
0.2049518228,
0.5852723122,
-0.2046942264,
0.5138267279,
0.6519761086,
0.0168728381,
-0.0511943176,
-0.2192508131,
0.6207159162,
-0.5596826077,
-0.7063079476,
-0.7881996632,
0.2625567019,
-0.2337199599,
-0.4361409247,
1.0391994715,
0.9395236373,
0.9621387124,
-0.0968592986,
1.1196798086,
0.1837690622,
0.6986872554,
-0.4523885548,
1.0784609318,
-0.461682409,
0.1059038565,
-0.5150954723,
-1.2299383879,
-0.4040350914,
0.6931009889,
-0.1596342772,
0.0355083756,
0.8789812326,
0.8541471958,
-0.1102829725,
-0.0640615597,
0.2683133781,
-0.3258605003,
0.4785101116,
0.3031565845,
1.0022314787,
-0.3943576813,
0.8150100708,
0.0893267319,
-0.234763965,
-0.199764967,
-0.8048768044,
-1.4676305056,
-0.7123935223,
-0.330055356,
-0.5556737781,
0.1723302305,
0.4966776073,
0.5609528422,
-0.8848560452,
-0.2163108885,
-0.1836982667,
0.1343685687,
-0.1610897928,
-0.2483491153,
0.2983473241,
-0.1107428372,
-1.045634985,
0.4677413702,
0.1844873726,
0.0692379177,
-0.6311172247,
0.1306869686,
-0.0932232067,
0.389783591,
0.2447496653,
0.1388807446,
-0.5433691144,
-0.3889395595,
-0.1360950023,
-0.2666354179,
-0.1904540658,
0.9816292524,
-0.7099252343,
0.1638956219,
0.6180337667,
0.8255492449,
0.5433411598,
0.0039736009,
0.4587894082,
-0.5665447712,
0.3145777285,
0.3897742629,
0.1518334597,
0.5758095384,
-0.4951096475,
0.3410340846,
0.5876278281,
-0.6286258101,
-1.1312321424,
0.123096697,
-0.5307695866,
-0.4962050915,
0.8740724921,
0.1339136809,
-0.1779925376,
-0.2884701788,
-0.2881704271,
0.1197234765,
-0.5810374618,
0.9734751582,
0.6876672506,
0.1132097244,
-0.1495486796,
-0.4265280664,
0.453016758,
0.3094614744,
-0.8555989265,
-0.0886007547,
0.7868734002,
0.2394817919,
0.4582737982,
0.7041231394,
0.1873501241,
0.3680405617,
0.1068048999,
0.2864533365,
-0.2359649092,
-0.625634253,
-0.4471244216,
0.247491166,
-0.1869968772,
-0.070240356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15045v1 | SETI: Systematicity Evaluation of Textual Inference | 2023-05-24T11:35:31 | 2023-05-24T11:35:31 | Xiyan Fu, Anette Frank | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose SETI (Systematicity Evaluation of Textual Inference), a novel and
comprehensive benchmark designed for evaluating pre-trained language models
(PLMs) for their systematicity capabilities in the domain of textual inference.
Specifically, SETI offers three different NLI tasks and corresponding datasets
to evaluate various types of systematicity in reasoning processes. In order to
solve these tasks, models are required to perform compositional inference based
on known primitive constituents. We conduct experiments of SETI on six widely
used PLMs. Results show that various PLMs are able to solve unseen
compositional inferences when having encountered the knowledge of how to
combine primitives, with good performance. However, they are considerably
limited when this knowledge is unknown to the model (40-100% points decrease).
Furthermore, we find that PLMs can improve drastically once exposed to crucial
compositional knowledge in minimalistic shots. These findings position SETI as
the first benchmark for measuring the future progress of PLMs in achieving
systematicity generalization in the textual inference. | [
-0.2031431049,
-0.4990798533,
0.4103066921,
0.4867973328,
-0.109273009,
-0.1458489448,
-0.7325712442,
-0.222448647,
0.0308644734,
0.4757045507,
-0.7052833438,
-0.6785683632,
-0.3511601388,
0.2719520628,
-0.4785476327,
0.7292358875,
-0.034581773,
0.2008778453,
-0.0881921053,
-0.2734982371,
-0.4383144081,
-0.1380784959,
-0.258918941,
-0.3273648918,
0.5658736229,
0.231647715,
0.4558391273,
0.4690270722,
0.9011802077,
0.3341611624,
0.0568563379,
0.0465498157,
-0.4953320026,
0.1799768955,
-0.2986862659,
-0.7475462556,
-0.0776424557,
0.3594352305,
1.0292831659,
1.2575947046,
0.1945157498,
0.2262114137,
-0.1638470441,
0.5761259198,
-1.01851511,
-0.1122924462,
-0.5084397197,
0.2030832767,
-0.1742405444,
-0.0969126597,
-0.7482275963,
-0.4776630104,
0.3294121623,
-0.8759034872,
0.154306367,
-0.0928729475,
0.7618725896,
0.4798656702,
-0.2607730925,
-0.2007522285,
-0.8052890897,
1.2899192572,
-0.9330435991,
0.1987419873,
0.3050951064,
0.3101603985,
-0.0381235182,
-1.1686457396,
-0.5615323782,
-0.3192786276,
-0.2365757674,
0.4880679846,
0.2968088388,
-0.0324341767,
0.5449274182,
0.5397512317,
-0.5014486313,
-0.138586536,
-0.0829562768,
0.2558973134,
0.556702435,
-0.0135338772,
0.4807420969,
-0.0048352699,
-0.105542928,
0.0837381482,
-0.428784281,
-0.0738595203,
0.322524935,
0.0760356709,
-0.0834474191,
0.5470123887,
-0.3545077443,
0.761274159,
-0.2528784275,
-0.081709139,
0.2706569433,
-0.8833037019,
-0.1975959837,
-0.346603632,
0.9745523334,
0.0964518785,
0.4780784547,
-0.2349602729,
-0.3073537052,
0.1173901781,
0.1751832515,
-0.6053546071,
-0.0942622796,
0.287771523,
-0.6277902126,
-0.3717330694,
0.2561360896,
-0.2231163681,
-0.1278505772,
-0.4819217622,
0.2786160111,
-0.7311115861,
-0.276488781,
0.1095922366,
-0.5084226727,
0.4259170592,
0.1229434088,
-0.6710040569,
0.3746492267,
1.0816117525,
0.7172263265,
-0.2175414711,
-0.387711823,
-0.1250126362,
0.2507780194,
-0.6525748968,
0.836137414,
-0.8540347219,
-0.4094630778,
0.0486066677,
-0.3034234047,
-0.3208061159,
-0.6517592072,
0.9977794886,
-0.1209505945,
0.2915349305,
-0.2566142976,
-0.7445581555,
0.1367660761,
0.345136553,
-0.788149178,
0.9755353332,
-0.2094023973,
-1.1712474823,
0.6481417418,
-0.6604653597,
-0.422209084,
0.1798092872,
-0.0117043378,
-0.0785249546,
0.2684831917,
0.0340887271,
0.0644924268,
-0.2238326967,
0.6153936386,
-0.5112026334,
-0.6458951235,
0.4929365814,
-0.294349879,
0.7241809368,
-0.0466450676,
-0.2060988992,
0.3808904886,
-0.7635585666,
0.3909958005,
-0.3286228478,
0.0332397185,
-0.6831808686,
0.1454315335,
-0.0638969317,
0.0828363523,
0.3369202614,
-0.4584595859,
-0.0014291449,
-0.5663561821,
0.1627241671,
0.6012289524,
0.0098919626,
0.4500834346,
-0.4712464809,
0.0087984595,
-0.1281251907,
0.2204730511,
-0.1581178159,
-0.3030846119,
-0.9780545235,
-0.5025460124,
0.6696404219,
0.5314102769,
-0.6480085254,
0.7103970647,
-0.6348445415,
-0.527923882,
-0.4286204278,
-0.2000973374,
0.6054985523,
0.307965219,
-0.0675837323,
-0.2846145034,
-0.7059136033,
-1.1971127987,
-0.4466735423,
-0.124772355,
-0.36919716,
0.0503329895,
0.7347683907,
0.0374900289,
1.1023212671,
-0.2134228051,
-0.0477552041,
-0.1458288431,
0.3805424571,
0.3489142656,
0.4739954174,
0.1228647381,
-0.5151792765,
-0.3491677344,
0.0277494434,
-1.3362293243,
-0.3058596551,
0.0370451659,
-0.2951385379,
-0.347042352,
0.281406939,
-0.4367557466,
0.3495861292,
0.2869954109,
-0.1686272025,
0.5773862004,
-0.0808485374,
0.1360644102,
-0.9636804461,
0.4089634717,
0.0661446825,
0.0052216421,
-0.8052150607,
0.1573957205,
0.0401678011,
-0.079438962,
-0.1975130141,
0.5655623078,
-0.4496332407,
-0.212710917,
-0.0784777403,
0.209498316,
-0.1548966914,
0.3317576349,
0.2589381337,
0.9211501479,
0.4385343492,
-0.5190055966,
-0.1219421551,
0.2222590148,
-0.3427478373,
0.5680437088,
-0.8568291664,
-0.0696072951,
0.0467189662,
0.2625308335,
-0.4926391542,
-0.0097594652,
-0.0229112916,
-0.2875410914,
0.0672697052,
0.2401082814,
-0.4079101086,
-0.1581648439,
-0.5759319663,
0.4555029571,
0.3883185983,
-0.2903393209,
0.7512069941,
0.0325179845,
0.0281379968,
-0.9511308074,
-0.5271897912,
-0.0007275766,
0.0460822284,
-0.7371182442,
0.0886483267,
-0.3312016428,
-0.646291256,
-0.2371963561,
-0.2418861091,
-0.2534553111,
0.0075973575,
0.3137463629,
0.0148708075,
-0.3931865394,
0.0935742259,
0.1047050282,
-0.1079187617,
0.1417632699,
-0.3248760998,
0.303824991,
-0.1636532545,
-0.3373451829,
-0.6252884865,
0.3579891622,
0.1511409283,
-0.4471153319,
0.6415294409,
0.3195698261,
-0.4795596004,
-0.3651290536,
-0.7736214995,
-0.1808870286,
-0.4059886634,
0.1386454999,
-0.6801223755,
-0.4692583382,
0.6022439003,
-0.1697331965,
0.2549216151,
0.3728875518,
0.2000996172,
-0.0419078507,
0.5820211172,
0.3649374545,
0.097724691,
0.4452100098,
-0.4517205954,
0.1255932897,
-0.6382551193,
-0.0273336861,
-0.7592708468,
-0.2927595675,
-0.4078170657,
-0.4209308326,
0.0782995746,
0.1415771246,
-0.1061196774,
-0.0161660369,
-0.1159911603,
0.7456154823,
0.718026638,
0.2853078544,
0.7149042487,
-0.3243550956,
0.02630651,
-0.1274906993,
-0.483784616,
-0.8295148611,
1.3528695107,
0.2906239927,
0.4996447563,
-0.0647923872,
0.8206933737,
0.2762845159,
0.7146280408,
-0.7214957476,
0.791225493,
-0.2919057608,
-0.5221397877,
-0.404374361,
-0.4471636117,
-0.5430396795,
0.2120663077,
-0.0319019631,
-0.3114994168,
0.1715263426,
-0.2709743977,
0.1073989421,
-0.0187246632,
-0.7391104698,
0.8627647161,
0.1146250814,
-0.2989468575,
-0.1575482041,
-0.675455153,
0.8268512487,
-0.1125551239,
0.0337020047,
-0.1759578288,
-0.4011950195,
1.0014845133,
-0.3960126936,
0.8688836694,
-0.0331226364,
-0.0251390189,
0.2522337437,
-0.213845402,
0.153566882,
0.4236130714,
-0.2842032015,
0.2984740436,
0.0666345432,
-0.5553774238,
-0.8367868066,
0.743563652,
-0.585281074,
-0.3454351723,
-0.2876076102,
-0.5142779946,
-0.3507993221,
0.4646470249,
0.261757046,
0.473020792,
-0.7470074296,
-0.0650980026,
0.9712942243,
0.2327614874,
0.6687525511,
0.5328682065,
-0.0525662154,
-0.3612419963,
0.8089286089,
-0.2402598411,
0.2371941358,
0.4257832468,
0.0429264382,
-0.0224090517,
-0.8643673062,
-0.1669422984,
0.4956185222,
-0.7786851525,
0.1146213189,
-0.5314756036,
-0.2574005425,
-0.0892784894,
0.116312325,
-0.3811474741,
-0.4766768515,
-0.1142032072,
0.0854216814,
-0.4591556787,
0.7251757383,
0.3297466934,
0.238914147,
-0.5289560556,
0.202344805,
0.1149592176,
0.619787097,
-0.4989248216,
-0.5816611648,
0.0097503224,
-0.1128949448,
0.1186111644,
-0.6333633661,
0.048763372,
0.441937089,
0.6217894554,
0.6123144031,
0.0289931167,
0.5303972363,
-0.5172433853,
0.5184355974,
-0.0457793921,
-1.0892183781,
0.6610971689,
-0.4721283615,
0.4562850893,
0.9554286599,
0.3415591717,
-0.4599734247,
-0.6186634898,
-0.5137506723,
-0.3504897058,
0.4544489384,
0.4160555005,
-0.1877283603,
-0.0695582181,
0.2356583327,
0.2827210426,
0.1895391345,
-0.7182532549,
-0.1300450116,
0.1296839267,
-0.6239578128,
0.1482721567,
-0.3627485931,
-0.4383867383,
-0.0645971075,
0.8351259828,
-0.2481016368,
-0.0745536834,
0.1521740705,
-0.3566045463,
0.1214875504,
0.3678037524,
0.509085834,
1.2906649113,
-0.1616626382,
-0.0978179127,
0.170113638,
-0.4039109647,
-0.1364334077,
0.0363548957,
-0.531670928,
0.2681120932,
0.9488967061,
0.6785422564,
0.4407703876,
-0.9389237165,
0.6308422685,
-0.3875463903,
-0.1533782929,
-0.6130953431,
-0.0370583311,
-0.2425379306,
-0.0789343938,
0.2096755952,
-0.0113549139,
0.3667250276,
-0.4229589999,
0.1043773964,
0.5719535947,
-0.481793344,
-0.3212704062,
0.083676286,
0.3466749787,
-0.0601876937,
0.428594321,
0.0831516385,
-0.012104935,
0.4693602026,
0.3582646549,
0.8718668222,
-0.3335544467,
0.2196541578,
0.4189008474,
0.4898191392,
-0.2160590142,
0.3453566134,
-0.0316581354,
-0.8158943653,
-0.5531625748,
-0.5321052074,
-0.5011066794,
-0.0449009165,
-0.6116138101,
0.2207065076,
-0.5738119483,
0.0527695902,
0.2177914083,
-0.1373216659,
-0.2563031614,
0.2016633302,
-0.1934610605,
1.1844249964,
-0.9629331231,
0.5458524823,
0.5318204165,
-0.5012293458,
-0.5535749793,
0.1340422183,
-0.4301654398,
-0.2394908369,
0.6791589856,
0.3792749345,
0.0457553007,
-0.1571705192,
-0.7181580067,
-0.5527343154,
0.8597031832,
0.1447885036,
-0.4990206063,
-0.0053087948,
0.0919519439,
0.6963149905,
-0.4582185149,
0.8285967708,
0.8965039253,
0.7402627468,
-0.2185880095,
-0.8873077631,
-0.0940891802,
-0.4961071908,
0.30691576,
0.253580153,
-0.2650380731,
0.4644209445,
0.1847413182,
-0.4425143898,
0.291467905,
0.8820025325,
0.1829052866,
0.5636585355,
0.3605684936,
0.7266300321,
0.777451396,
-0.3871331215,
1.0923810005,
-0.2819400132,
-0.0067819324,
1.2227783203,
-0.5386195183,
0.897506237,
0.4898445904,
-0.1322367191,
0.5199586153,
0.3744377196,
0.2458611429,
0.3600450456,
0.355832696,
-0.7822541595,
-0.1057138443,
-0.2940682769,
-0.3473582566,
0.0591235943,
0.2467987239,
-0.3360084891,
0.1336563677,
0.0529989488,
-0.2334041446,
0.4206515849,
-0.1549427062,
1.0406614542,
-0.0685474351,
-0.9835740924,
0.4790437818,
-0.1025710702,
0.735458374,
-0.8879435658,
0.0568977892,
-0.4543173015,
0.2343853116,
-0.2215137035,
-0.5159114003,
0.3662053049,
-0.1585073322,
-0.4574581385,
0.0807735771,
0.7488324046,
-0.4114108682,
-0.7021505237,
0.1504312754,
0.5803304315,
0.012517604,
-0.0462493449,
-0.3889442682,
-0.1184607595,
-0.1388109326,
-0.2360904217,
-0.0313195325,
0.5035880208,
-0.2354883999,
0.8014392257,
0.615696013,
0.0625337362,
0.1705833077,
0.5490579605,
0.826911211,
-0.7999495268,
-0.2123360187,
-0.5325439572,
0.4355954528,
-0.6105999947,
-0.3587276042,
0.6802555323,
0.7339206338,
0.735220015,
-0.3251046538,
0.9512786865,
0.1465138495,
0.5009325147,
-0.5507178307,
0.521297276,
0.0277045649,
0.3161036074,
-0.0723939985,
-1.0847371817,
-0.3330192864,
0.2779122889,
-0.5182667971,
0.1463727504,
1.3977185488,
0.6796646118,
-0.1384683102,
0.4147561789,
0.197733283,
-0.0408646055,
-0.0833661631,
0.2126476318,
0.9295392036,
-0.458089143,
0.2842051387,
-0.3679341376,
-0.4862084091,
0.5302942395,
-0.5848095417,
-1.17730546,
-0.2894013822,
-0.3597251773,
0.0274036191,
0.3239943981,
0.4320368767,
0.5931876302,
-0.9350419641,
-0.4320963025,
-0.24029544,
0.089357473,
-0.3207265437,
-0.1904836446,
0.1008997113,
-0.6175054908,
-0.9351375103,
0.593990922,
0.3790894151,
-0.3704471588,
-0.2066217661,
0.0185966622,
-0.5021209717,
0.2477187067,
0.2096267492,
0.1376801282,
-0.7951019406,
-0.0781771764,
-0.1926304102,
-0.0771621689,
-0.0977566093,
1.41753757,
-0.5070815086,
0.265850544,
0.6138445735,
0.5252054334,
0.2095887214,
-0.0001835254,
0.6959820986,
-0.937779665,
0.380185008,
0.4167330265,
0.4468061924,
0.3036888242,
0.1893803328,
0.9618058801,
0.2353891581,
-0.3294257522,
-0.8090668917,
0.3219685256,
-0.9663843513,
-0.1208794862,
0.8128294349,
-0.413808316,
-0.4426348209,
-0.03811571,
0.1273823231,
0.1823033392,
-0.038954366,
0.3350869119,
0.7286049724,
0.4548867643,
-0.1025105044,
-0.494645983,
0.3124015033,
0.7812423706,
-1.2141296864,
-0.0294394456,
0.516690433,
0.2368067205,
0.207496047,
0.63859272,
-0.1090162992,
0.1077974513,
0.057315778,
0.2195759863,
0.1256896406,
-0.207114324,
-0.3748116195,
0.1208378002,
0.0166626945,
0.0211485494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15044v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15044v1 | Is Summary Useful or Not? An Extrinsic Human Evaluation of Text Summaries on Downstream Tasks | 2023-05-24T11:34:39 | 2023-05-24T11:34:39 | Xiao Pu, Mingqi Gao, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Research on automated text summarization relies heavily on human and
automatic evaluation. While recent work on human evaluation mainly adopted
intrinsic evaluation methods, judging the generic quality of text summaries,
e.g. informativeness and coherence, our work focuses on evaluating the
usefulness of text summaries with extrinsic methods. We carefully design three
different downstream tasks for extrinsic human evaluation of summaries, i.e.,
question answering, text classification and text similarity assessment. We
carry out experiments using system rankings and user behavior data to evaluate
the performance of different summarization models. We find summaries are
particularly useful in tasks that rely on an overall judgment of the text,
while being less effective for question answering tasks. The results show that
summaries generated by fine-tuned models lead to higher consistency in
usefulness across all three tasks, as rankings of fine-tuned summarization
systems are close across downstream tasks according to the proposed extrinsic
metrics. Summaries generated by models in the zero-shot setting, however, are
found to be biased towards the text classification and similarity assessment
tasks, due to its general and less detailed summary style. We further evaluate
the correlation of 14 intrinsic automatic metrics with human criteria and show
that intrinsic automatic metrics perform well in evaluating the usefulness of
summaries in the question-answering task, but are less effective in the other
two tasks. This highlights the limitations of relying solely on intrinsic
automatic metrics in evaluating the performance and usefulness of summaries. | [
-0.3085848987,
-0.4880374372,
0.2933636904,
-0.0795228779,
-0.4983084798,
-0.0097397529,
-0.2146753222,
-0.6770058274,
0.4158030748,
0.0927365646,
-0.1719842553,
-0.170302555,
-0.4223247468,
0.4397066534,
-0.8447510004,
1.4639577866,
-0.0023867982,
-0.3706028163,
-0.2953374684,
-0.2754409611,
-0.4045640528,
-0.4807031453,
-0.6178237796,
-0.2706599236,
0.5676498413,
0.2649845481,
0.5669230819,
0.5116558075,
0.8399897218,
0.2338986695,
-0.1237767115,
-0.0617602952,
-0.4759751558,
0.3420042694,
-0.1455895752,
-0.4042453766,
-0.4682090878,
0.0659483597,
0.4882040918,
0.6597621441,
0.1425509453,
0.5445460677,
0.4340744317,
0.8046751618,
-0.4785561562,
0.1292917281,
-0.2341500074,
0.0591215864,
0.1499246657,
-0.4151355028,
-0.0548434332,
-0.4521527886,
0.4911187589,
-0.3653653562,
0.3762268424,
-0.0317106284,
0.7956289053,
0.3967413008,
-0.4402578175,
-0.5813714862,
-0.6274734735,
0.5876677632,
-0.8641180992,
-0.1714047045,
0.2468947172,
0.4040121138,
0.469131887,
-0.4779281914,
-0.3366601169,
-0.3300279677,
-0.3111462593,
0.4758678377,
-0.2875715196,
0.0358147621,
0.169932127,
0.4697577953,
-0.6338397861,
-0.0242638178,
-0.3615356386,
-0.1174882352,
0.6706264019,
0.3969202936,
0.4217653573,
-0.4004224837,
-0.1874332875,
-0.1471287757,
-0.4148537219,
0.5552015901,
0.5147792697,
0.2803047597,
-0.1459230036,
0.6651299,
-0.5229606032,
0.6435653567,
-0.261865437,
-0.1538750976,
-0.0697079673,
-0.8028486371,
-0.0758699402,
-0.2285446376,
0.5809156895,
0.936512351,
0.3458313644,
-0.4337958395,
-0.1627519876,
-0.0347137228,
0.376224786,
-0.6338623762,
-0.304954946,
0.3060176969,
-0.6296687126,
-0.2770311832,
0.2555982769,
-0.3236305118,
-0.0313603915,
-0.4661282599,
0.4191562533,
-0.282197535,
0.0393990204,
-0.3293030262,
-0.7970627546,
0.0801488683,
0.5024145842,
-0.8406171799,
0.3621022999,
0.5890397429,
0.9812163711,
-0.382014662,
-0.3487739563,
-0.3532262444,
0.0849165395,
-0.1896193624,
1.1726187468,
-0.196373105,
-0.2290316224,
-0.439322114,
-0.0815406218,
-0.1538352221,
-0.6029294133,
0.6516951919,
-0.384742707,
0.1533826888,
-0.3767204881,
-0.4156005383,
-0.5254771113,
0.1588196009,
-0.6881463528,
0.8246597052,
0.0878888369,
-0.7667609453,
0.6454386115,
-0.5565872192,
-0.6906535029,
-0.0729098096,
0.143929705,
-0.2752486467,
0.3013262153,
-0.1116317138,
0.5616649389,
-0.0277095754,
0.1983469576,
-0.0607965291,
-0.6732422709,
0.190462932,
-0.1701172441,
0.5251665115,
-0.0020113501,
-0.2918986976,
0.1769832671,
-0.360167861,
0.0819335282,
-0.4198089242,
-0.2696504891,
-0.5029941201,
0.1513721645,
-0.0827704445,
0.1877436489,
0.1002761647,
-0.2151319683,
-0.1444239467,
-0.3445486724,
0.2992414832,
0.3828881979,
0.1767363548,
0.5003558397,
-0.8277493119,
0.5390974879,
-0.413005203,
-0.1337963492,
-0.4974845052,
-0.5264119506,
-0.5613449812,
-0.3148356378,
0.2252902091,
0.6177007556,
-0.6155155897,
0.5042261481,
-0.2984043956,
-0.7620874047,
0.1271335781,
-0.1123432592,
0.5774720311,
0.617120266,
0.1523037702,
-0.3331554234,
-0.3766773939,
-0.9239849448,
-0.8230315447,
-0.4395797551,
-0.1287468821,
0.1329074353,
0.7964693904,
0.32659024,
0.9630685449,
-0.4167045057,
-0.2511583269,
-0.3784932196,
0.5410361886,
0.1671575457,
0.0373735093,
0.6084999442,
-0.666554749,
-0.5401955247,
-0.1387069672,
-0.9931801558,
-0.2676543593,
-0.134769842,
0.071629487,
0.2335935384,
0.1525972933,
-0.3244839609,
0.4249966443,
0.2116735429,
-0.4907694757,
0.6552502513,
-0.4213271141,
0.3393464386,
-0.6766886115,
0.5410678387,
0.0061451681,
-0.5545652509,
-0.5725107789,
0.2697730064,
0.1015891656,
0.0156529658,
-0.0817376524,
0.5553531647,
-0.3112799823,
-0.1345965862,
-0.5312402248,
0.2216219604,
-0.0054548536,
0.5151487589,
0.079556264,
0.5690231323,
-0.0290846899,
-0.8444532752,
0.2123016119,
0.118864961,
-0.2759668827,
0.6110597253,
-0.7761055231,
-0.2709724307,
-0.1771450043,
0.2030196637,
-1.0944045782,
-0.3307934999,
0.1181252971,
-0.6786646843,
0.0708765239,
0.3237307072,
-0.3648092449,
-0.1365885437,
-0.8651504517,
0.166487813,
0.4476807117,
0.0018441026,
0.3446141779,
0.4465131462,
-0.7139935493,
-0.2444889545,
-0.6507226825,
0.2366286665,
-0.2867600024,
-0.3461755514,
0.2203497142,
0.138894245,
-0.3126783967,
0.1541904062,
-0.1466737837,
-0.1438460201,
0.2430338413,
0.1076092795,
0.2727952003,
0.2569627464,
0.0690051466,
0.427003026,
-0.2887409329,
-0.0013165324,
-0.0038264294,
-0.1626888663,
0.0361196212,
-0.0866262913,
-0.4968670607,
0.6360773444,
0.3232691586,
0.0377377383,
0.341596365,
0.3179505169,
-0.3069948554,
0.1155721918,
-0.1640493274,
-0.1912384331,
-0.2825328708,
0.4363396168,
-0.0629774109,
-0.8676800728,
0.5022048354,
0.601960063,
0.3878811896,
0.7110664248,
0.4923686385,
-0.3797243237,
0.8812952042,
0.6698175073,
0.1545511633,
0.2266440988,
-0.1364487857,
0.1818647832,
-0.765712142,
0.0318654627,
-0.6896870136,
-0.5224586129,
-0.4068900645,
0.1104175001,
0.6089202762,
0.0580269359,
0.0541747659,
0.6209663749,
-0.4718610942,
0.341994673,
0.4871126413,
-0.0884059593,
0.7566438913,
-0.0905652866,
0.3039568067,
0.0143839875,
-0.4896672368,
-0.8165192008,
0.8773530722,
0.0895566195,
0.5082390904,
0.2233707309,
0.4857687056,
0.6858046055,
0.55169034,
-0.8833591342,
0.3497520387,
-0.2858582139,
-0.5336176157,
-0.6137516499,
-0.5884695053,
-0.7017474771,
0.3250588477,
0.0136060296,
-0.7158438563,
-0.1519095004,
0.3261101544,
-0.6934639215,
0.018374376,
-1.0423437357,
0.4716534615,
-0.1334820241,
0.0966864079,
-0.2319621444,
-0.6739637256,
0.3085750639,
-0.1530009955,
0.0499831177,
-0.1157177314,
-0.4778254032,
1.1041162014,
-0.3883674145,
0.702483654,
-0.0752774999,
-0.1215679049,
0.3402679861,
-0.0467537083,
0.1628372818,
0.003932178,
-0.1311220825,
0.0613671578,
0.4667578638,
-0.266022414,
-0.944462657,
0.4262140989,
-0.4768462777,
-0.3580358624,
-0.421695292,
-0.2466641814,
0.0696179792,
0.3301992416,
0.5222649574,
0.807433188,
-0.0834095553,
0.0461627096,
0.0015717944,
0.0430064574,
0.6390802264,
0.3556625545,
0.0301896203,
-0.4049506187,
1.0473569632,
0.3415504694,
0.2130560577,
0.7171434164,
0.1816200018,
-0.4390395582,
-0.4776663184,
-0.5714845657,
0.0153575912,
-0.5591754913,
-0.2702340186,
-0.8668984175,
0.0190452319,
-0.1305127144,
-0.2161101997,
0.1780861765,
-0.9487704039,
-0.193253547,
0.1030617803,
-0.003606224,
0.8641189337,
0.0691250116,
0.0550953038,
-0.8817559481,
0.6274539828,
0.2737472951,
0.1968486905,
0.2912692428,
-0.6663346291,
-0.4936483502,
-0.0162161998,
-0.2654937804,
-0.7949385047,
0.3087000549,
0.3345362544,
0.4707627296,
0.3744063079,
0.3024444282,
0.3024794161,
-0.1631811857,
0.8043109775,
0.1394679099,
-0.9039020538,
0.2708835006,
-0.5313940644,
0.5178854465,
0.938190341,
0.3554660678,
-0.5187493563,
-0.7176412344,
-0.2705153823,
-0.9916229844,
0.669239819,
0.5855821967,
0.12192671,
0.1743875593,
0.3524812758,
0.4959206581,
0.3773473799,
-0.4019184709,
-0.235866785,
-0.0401489101,
-0.1067823693,
-0.133440569,
-0.2368643135,
0.1672204584,
-0.1229881421,
0.5665203333,
-0.207314685,
0.3584032357,
0.3493329585,
-0.216673553,
0.2455497831,
0.3011024594,
0.5322456956,
0.6968554854,
-0.3573055863,
0.1070813388,
0.2977616787,
-0.5654563308,
0.2447853833,
0.0302745234,
-0.3964310288,
0.0658217072,
0.6373473406,
0.351985395,
0.3193049133,
-0.826133132,
0.5065695643,
-0.4409809411,
0.0103296256,
-0.3308271766,
0.2718675137,
-0.22508578,
0.009079136,
0.5333251953,
0.318985343,
0.6550169587,
-0.6020847559,
-0.0245787408,
0.4123223722,
-0.5637927055,
-0.5954310894,
0.4942844808,
0.4602852762,
-0.2146931738,
0.2356701195,
-0.387614131,
-0.4540523291,
0.6598232388,
0.0066500688,
1.0537412167,
0.2188698351,
0.1988192499,
0.4149088562,
0.2621470392,
0.1051578894,
0.2511788309,
-0.6159112453,
-0.1589802206,
-0.6590038538,
-0.3890410066,
-0.682821095,
-0.5022226572,
-0.7081866264,
0.2729009986,
0.0022216507,
-0.2970018089,
0.129117161,
-0.0862217546,
-0.1980183423,
0.28783077,
-0.3148063123,
0.8732808828,
-0.6134471893,
-0.0203465149,
0.8409302831,
-0.3510238826,
-0.5078314543,
0.0666262135,
-0.1109750122,
-0.0369543098,
0.4607362151,
0.2960246801,
-0.2710317075,
-0.2299654782,
-0.1571354866,
-0.5914001465,
1.1192615032,
0.2508659959,
-0.0250915512,
-0.3533621728,
-0.1524365395,
0.7826614976,
-0.0900270715,
0.934507668,
0.2787279487,
0.2397296876,
-0.2574461401,
-1.11941576,
0.0866165608,
-0.6343263984,
-0.2147693634,
0.1943006963,
-0.7612909675,
0.5593534708,
-0.3628873527,
-0.5006229281,
0.3952257335,
0.4411368668,
-0.1367789358,
0.4254881442,
0.5195418,
0.3488685489,
0.6145727038,
-0.081788905,
1.4195816517,
-0.1191397384,
0.4291470349,
1.1437437534,
-0.0914932564,
0.8840416074,
0.1143686324,
-0.1819657087,
0.3934038877,
0.3759989738,
0.3382762671,
0.3047792017,
0.0673959255,
0.0438404605,
-0.001279044,
-0.0230845641,
-0.1789729744,
0.4948212206,
-0.1834697872,
-0.3737922311,
-0.5891191959,
-0.1983549893,
0.0008985878,
-0.1014875397,
-0.1230836585,
0.9731721878,
0.0399355702,
-1.0867967606,
0.2402191162,
0.0730287358,
0.5470013022,
-0.4123420119,
-0.0077659586,
-0.0637091771,
-0.0167075805,
-0.3977532387,
-0.7941210866,
0.7459685802,
0.4724276066,
-0.4131026864,
-0.2657759786,
0.7104769349,
0.057862334,
-0.1479746401,
0.0942957178,
0.6406638026,
0.2699103355,
-0.425579071,
-0.1035066992,
-0.5310667753,
-0.1584658772,
-0.2233354449,
0.1629689634,
0.1233485192,
-0.1294245124,
0.6819104552,
0.5152394772,
0.1096581146,
-0.3792951405,
0.0711930767,
0.6865938902,
-0.9773288369,
-0.9044046402,
-0.8915910125,
0.4393306077,
-0.1079918742,
-0.4446782172,
1.0481946468,
0.7760716677,
0.5579766631,
0.0235585328,
1.068915844,
-0.1527119875,
0.8694286346,
-0.3168262839,
0.9039387107,
-0.4278184175,
0.0973674059,
-0.496571213,
-0.9698625803,
-0.1548604816,
0.2325559556,
-0.2684234083,
0.2173384428,
0.8272988796,
0.2567088902,
0.12565355,
0.4557597041,
0.2793678939,
-0.2078374326,
0.0617325082,
0.4126294255,
1.1070436239,
-0.2637859285,
0.5832111239,
-0.172398895,
-0.6836017966,
-0.2365625054,
-0.8280504346,
-0.9734833837,
-0.6890369058,
-0.2623530328,
0.1529521942,
-0.0413281433,
0.6504881978,
0.6554803252,
-0.7381061912,
-0.2595116496,
0.0394853763,
-0.0077045802,
-0.3239392042,
-0.3058267534,
0.2956061959,
-0.283082813,
-0.6318119764,
-0.2515700758,
0.5994620919,
-0.0191866308,
-0.2454642951,
0.2583462,
0.1549120843,
-0.1659332961,
0.8514353037,
0.1728640348,
-0.3257302642,
-0.1236126348,
0.3122102618,
0.0109630655,
-0.3597556651,
1.1249675751,
-0.8326562047,
0.3465940952,
0.8925566673,
0.384459585,
0.0305208396,
0.4144069552,
0.5537824631,
-0.3579310477,
-0.3610919416,
0.2582833767,
0.2172516584,
0.2991322577,
-0.3844237626,
0.4058684707,
-0.0588723905,
-0.5320702791,
-0.5302177668,
-0.0789442509,
-0.8599111438,
0.0215649381,
0.97828722,
-0.4059182405,
-0.1252236664,
-0.5201203823,
-0.3195834458,
0.210511893,
-0.523116231,
0.7855631113,
0.6573367119,
-0.7269971967,
0.0948217064,
-0.384019196,
0.3794340491,
0.3588583469,
-1.0965000391,
-0.058320038,
0.2517215014,
-0.0807363763,
0.1742548048,
0.5590354204,
-0.0438820124,
0.3962829113,
-0.3355483115,
-0.4017644227,
-0.0906083882,
-0.2029102594,
-0.4745460153,
0.1793381423,
-0.0706547871,
0.1688039601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15041v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15041v1 | Generating Faithful Synthetic Data with Large Language Models: A Case Study in Computational Social Science | 2023-05-24T11:27:59 | 2023-05-24T11:27:59 | Veniamin Veselovsky, Manoel Horta Ribeiro, Akhil Arora, Martin Josifoski, Ashton Anderson, Robert West | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have democratized synthetic data generation,
which in turn has the potential to simplify and broaden a wide gamut of NLP
tasks. Here, we tackle a pervasive problem in synthetic data generation: its
generative distribution often differs from the distribution of real-world data
researchers care about (in other words, it is unfaithful). In a case study on
sarcasm detection, we study three strategies to increase the faithfulness of
synthetic data: grounding, filtering, and taxonomy-based generation. We
evaluate these strategies using the performance of classifiers trained with
generated synthetic data on real-world data. While all three strategies improve
the performance of classifiers, we find that grounding works best for the task
at hand. As synthetic data generation plays an ever-increasing role in NLP
research, we expect this work to be a stepping stone in improving its utility.
We conclude this paper with some recommendations on how to generate
high(er)-fidelity synthetic data for specific tasks. | [
-0.2491804808,
-0.8398033977,
0.693371892,
0.2882411182,
-0.2373363376,
0.2061283588,
-0.3350204825,
-0.3804078102,
0.2824280262,
0.6028392911,
-0.3851160407,
-0.5344045162,
-0.332600534,
0.2031870633,
-0.637845397,
1.0558860302,
0.3342192471,
0.1401800066,
-0.2825786769,
0.0090752421,
0.0041589355,
-0.9095390439,
-0.7372810245,
-0.4289040267,
0.4977958798,
0.3133749962,
0.8072066903,
0.6529236436,
0.4829817414,
0.2251184285,
-0.0271597542,
0.5005505085,
-0.620706439,
0.5825285316,
-0.2570329309,
-0.657005012,
-0.2780447602,
-0.0542498939,
0.7269976735,
0.5564464331,
-0.0899666622,
0.1690812856,
-0.2034454048,
0.6784148812,
-0.4238878191,
0.0327181295,
-0.9250059128,
0.1865471601,
-0.3036355972,
-0.3176155984,
-0.4418975115,
-0.4707312286,
-0.3029183447,
-0.4316443503,
0.6838893294,
0.1435305625,
0.6015282869,
0.2066442817,
-0.0727190226,
0.024322819,
-0.8965764642,
0.8724102974,
-0.8380859494,
0.1638066024,
0.2594831586,
0.3662027419,
-0.5069630146,
-0.8116791844,
-0.6914619207,
-0.3467409313,
0.2356548607,
0.0333634391,
0.0581045859,
-0.0585549138,
0.5939762592,
0.3930903077,
-0.3568859994,
-0.2309437841,
-0.2245810777,
-0.1517948061,
0.8476025462,
0.0249488801,
0.238737911,
-0.3534048796,
0.0899704471,
-0.2699031234,
-0.9013513327,
-0.3971467614,
0.7506996989,
0.4588668048,
0.3187482655,
0.89350003,
-0.3922852576,
0.3980144262,
-0.1162055284,
0.0068360539,
0.2115225643,
-0.3824092746,
-0.0397790149,
-0.0652152672,
0.6434785128,
0.1787388325,
0.6161313653,
-0.2324253023,
-0.4674622715,
0.3801515996,
0.4162158072,
-0.4723533988,
-0.2351598591,
0.052172292,
-0.0857060775,
-0.6665997505,
0.0934367925,
-0.5145714283,
-0.3322378695,
-0.662466228,
-0.0716083795,
-0.4190478027,
-0.2087955028,
0.1091771722,
-0.348053813,
0.2160888463,
0.2038585246,
-0.6047487259,
0.333195895,
0.8492810726,
0.7377570868,
-0.0799618661,
-0.0239186026,
-0.5544137359,
0.1485214978,
-0.3929654956,
0.6864364147,
-0.3617940545,
-0.1654777974,
0.061275769,
-0.2022290677,
0.3131920099,
-0.7671895027,
0.6366713047,
-0.3974836469,
-0.0783676133,
-0.3143880665,
-0.3820810914,
0.2574798763,
0.3091051579,
-0.5660611987,
1.2889658213,
0.1332069486,
-0.9156859517,
0.2461755574,
-0.3978194892,
-0.5797461271,
0.1213765219,
-0.2844743729,
-0.2386854291,
0.4099454284,
0.02918512,
0.4032258093,
-0.4339615703,
0.7896169424,
-0.3836148679,
-0.3578185737,
0.5497899652,
-0.5700895786,
0.6443953514,
0.2136211544,
-0.2991860211,
-0.2489745617,
-0.7938785553,
0.0814683288,
0.1908543557,
-0.1705721915,
-0.3112125397,
0.1948274672,
0.3126884103,
0.1434977502,
-0.1703247577,
-0.4814968705,
0.0951935947,
-0.5849481821,
0.3067455888,
0.8258453012,
-0.0406199768,
0.2411286384,
-0.5833855867,
0.4173792899,
-0.0373789817,
-0.0135833956,
0.1220382005,
-0.4874496758,
-0.8315296173,
-0.2233937532,
0.4464570582,
0.4352398217,
-0.9524629712,
0.5871305466,
-0.3497187197,
-0.4416145086,
-0.4843597412,
0.0052823168,
0.2056314647,
0.3707801998,
0.3139796257,
-0.0178552438,
-0.6840437055,
-0.9237290621,
-0.6056210399,
-0.125446409,
-0.1688089967,
0.3646212816,
0.4447168112,
-0.3494491279,
1.1895468235,
-0.6337567568,
0.0863005668,
-0.1804913431,
0.1680949181,
0.0074955523,
0.5143096447,
0.5050632954,
-0.8007265925,
-0.350625664,
-0.252183497,
-0.8315213323,
-0.2756173313,
-0.0357765667,
-0.2476541251,
0.2473089248,
0.5096256733,
-0.797495842,
0.1158279553,
0.2323596627,
0.0737911984,
0.5852699876,
0.0422031023,
-0.0467529111,
-1.2213448286,
0.0483147465,
0.1004729047,
-0.5595641136,
-0.7193003297,
0.2752537429,
-0.2384325117,
-0.0368187539,
-0.4494049251,
0.5519121289,
-0.1693522632,
0.0153834792,
-0.0329283029,
0.046672605,
-0.167170018,
-0.0498037115,
-0.0675005913,
0.5200352073,
0.3888239264,
-0.5011319518,
0.5756030083,
-0.0438028499,
-0.1311322004,
0.3898518384,
-0.6891995668,
0.2819781601,
-0.2648168206,
0.6448796988,
-0.8149411082,
-0.7578700185,
0.0850971043,
-0.5809396505,
0.0600833893,
-0.1728106886,
-0.9125325084,
-0.2029715776,
-0.5616636276,
0.4274941385,
0.7858806252,
-0.6513307095,
0.475217402,
0.3500844538,
0.0122322561,
-0.5476326346,
-0.7849318981,
0.2345717847,
-0.4111275077,
-0.7623369098,
0.5168702602,
0.1224169135,
-0.5128806233,
-0.1344804615,
-0.0366236605,
0.2084837705,
-0.0172361266,
0.1673281342,
0.0472473167,
-0.0992967486,
0.1924757808,
0.1160533056,
0.0914112702,
0.3581240475,
-0.2009226084,
0.7306291461,
0.2403388619,
-0.2970694005,
-0.1724674553,
0.228277415,
0.542134285,
0.3010213673,
0.7561384439,
0.6542109847,
-0.51693964,
-0.7785055637,
-0.6932379603,
-0.4157448709,
-0.4958894849,
0.0245172139,
-0.2022901326,
-0.5128123164,
0.4872696698,
-0.1585168391,
0.0367799103,
0.2707247138,
0.3681107461,
-0.0895948336,
1.2836399078,
0.3914366663,
-0.0262164026,
0.4282001257,
-0.2109714448,
0.5151873827,
-0.6282106638,
-0.1041128486,
-0.6096369624,
-0.0951042995,
-0.7260888219,
-0.5169945359,
0.3581800461,
-0.0741753876,
-0.1256265044,
-0.0701897889,
-0.4088730216,
0.4371579885,
0.6092814207,
0.1453962326,
0.1853291243,
0.4757242203,
0.1279308945,
-0.0477316156,
-0.5528218746,
-0.6421285868,
1.1869963408,
0.1788347512,
0.7906393409,
-0.0454789959,
0.8603183031,
0.2770084143,
0.3230561018,
-0.749881506,
0.7134003043,
-0.3656129837,
-0.3484016359,
-0.0141459014,
-0.7038840652,
-0.5760668516,
0.0455116667,
-0.308526516,
-0.0522586666,
-0.263043344,
0.2904727161,
0.0967433825,
0.1390821934,
-0.4818012118,
0.2861170769,
0.0000640947,
-0.3359128833,
-0.0662432164,
-0.6083554029,
0.5045745373,
-0.1981290281,
0.1277057976,
-0.0926519036,
0.3471954763,
0.5144676566,
-0.2540040612,
0.8392211199,
-0.2213552594,
-0.0763026997,
0.3400895596,
0.048401583,
0.7339624166,
0.3604276776,
-0.2296930254,
-0.0271545537,
-0.2137611508,
-0.4051256776,
-0.6569029689,
0.7953352332,
-0.5836957097,
-0.7333903909,
-0.3577247262,
-0.6714686155,
-0.3326829374,
-0.1119623706,
0.319416672,
0.1553257555,
-0.2637705505,
0.4304727614,
0.7348762155,
-0.2079218179,
0.049578242,
0.1320670396,
-0.060224928,
-0.2853206992,
0.8935009241,
0.2222143561,
0.3291448653,
0.0163529702,
0.146127522,
-0.3166023493,
-0.2902017236,
-0.3558442295,
0.4193966985,
-0.7673518658,
-0.2896183431,
-0.7444203496,
-0.4488039315,
-0.7516432405,
-0.2868440747,
-0.2502573729,
-0.8019686341,
-0.3974616826,
-0.1798187047,
0.4373196959,
0.4690766633,
-0.067221351,
0.1941487044,
-0.5516107082,
0.6111312509,
0.0288413614,
-0.1240733489,
-0.2878116071,
-0.542026639,
0.2181723714,
0.4521023929,
-0.1795942932,
-0.6849934459,
0.5438732505,
0.1011893302,
0.3604654372,
0.0109279417,
0.2527276874,
0.5718855858,
-0.4286561012,
0.8539890051,
-0.0836188793,
-0.770542562,
0.4888928831,
-0.575617671,
-0.0137920761,
0.4516354799,
0.2728148699,
-0.4830915034,
-0.7480527759,
-0.9341309667,
-1.0220439434,
0.4838655591,
0.3122086823,
0.7065144777,
-0.2108022571,
0.6949378848,
-0.0297503509,
0.2918005586,
-0.8817522526,
-0.0579648875,
-0.1357818842,
-0.5205851197,
-0.0459348224,
-0.0522754267,
-0.4086385071,
-0.2332920134,
0.7635509968,
-0.3160562515,
0.0482943952,
0.1141849458,
0.0262716189,
-0.0586870424,
0.1722421795,
0.2821109593,
0.4037849307,
0.096735619,
0.4398393035,
0.0167120807,
-0.4647525251,
0.0886816606,
-0.2995916307,
-0.4623529613,
0.1066807136,
0.1839774549,
0.3520751595,
-0.3273740113,
-0.7436554432,
0.3974214196,
0.2726955116,
-0.1158515513,
-0.4900419712,
0.4596718252,
0.0523793399,
-0.0560856462,
0.3289255202,
0.0984353274,
0.1947537512,
-0.7733187675,
0.1599625796,
0.6106262207,
0.2344095409,
-0.4472950101,
0.2186603248,
-0.0071984683,
-0.3291590214,
0.8251557946,
-0.3141661584,
-0.6533372402,
0.7387831807,
0.9729312062,
0.754235208,
-0.1618176401,
0.5364704132,
0.2852876782,
0.2211959809,
-0.5829796195,
0.4549455345,
0.0730485395,
-0.808932066,
-0.3713357449,
-0.7533284426,
-0.3031510115,
0.3444364667,
-0.4092102051,
0.4866065383,
-0.4306182265,
-0.32984519,
0.0767195523,
-0.202846244,
-0.4265346527,
0.272638768,
0.0046719215,
0.6456131339,
-1.1727448702,
0.5915784836,
0.5845315456,
-0.1013627499,
-0.6195263267,
0.1431312412,
-0.1576202363,
-0.5361737609,
0.7026034594,
0.1104351953,
-0.2171587497,
0.0343936943,
-0.9839402437,
-0.7092235684,
0.763530314,
0.6370300651,
-0.3624416888,
-0.1337660998,
0.4191807806,
0.9547235966,
-0.2613177299,
-0.1568547487,
0.5161008239,
0.5554378033,
0.151561588,
-0.4014776945,
0.1490350515,
-0.207623288,
0.1700803638,
0.1347535402,
-0.4260405898,
0.8386198282,
0.1120740771,
-0.3297420144,
-0.0660726652,
0.380094707,
0.6639882922,
0.4175530672,
0.3490661085,
0.6137781739,
0.689915061,
-0.2372741997,
1.0094647408,
-0.0700136349,
0.1937245429,
0.8425751328,
-0.5475221276,
0.5872171521,
0.6403785944,
-0.0591845997,
0.2264561206,
0.5214287639,
-0.1266658157,
0.1915817708,
0.6339256763,
-0.3944854438,
-0.2133778334,
-0.4340327978,
-0.2232524455,
0.2596412003,
0.3541965187,
-0.4886321127,
0.0307075027,
-0.0782122836,
0.0111155612,
0.1326290965,
-0.0172665063,
0.5857764482,
0.095938839,
-0.8071784377,
0.5685318708,
0.1463842839,
0.5919001698,
-0.2792874575,
-0.2442237884,
-0.3383410573,
0.0500941426,
-0.4356298447,
-0.6150708795,
0.4571068585,
0.1031015143,
-0.2022861093,
-0.2345156521,
0.8414512277,
-0.3389782906,
-0.4763017595,
0.1148277596,
0.5344194174,
0.2784757316,
-0.2086006552,
-0.511231482,
-0.0548886806,
-0.0799512938,
-0.3701926768,
0.2280467302,
0.4575853348,
-0.3084903061,
0.6891901493,
1.1557120085,
0.4629042745,
0.2033983022,
0.330381453,
1.0244859457,
-0.7027573586,
-0.3379455805,
-0.7993335724,
0.2631924152,
-0.3340498507,
-0.076998204,
0.8154608607,
0.5379446745,
0.8797776699,
-0.1527111083,
0.8794364929,
-0.0392751992,
0.3965622485,
-0.5780584812,
0.4171945751,
-0.3444381952,
0.2692040801,
-0.1399958134,
-1.3637703657,
-0.5177306533,
0.6574184299,
-0.0061719883,
0.0887886807,
0.5458737016,
0.9292051196,
-0.2851164639,
0.0289959311,
0.1703812033,
0.1914060265,
0.5647062659,
-0.0471211746,
1.0780347586,
-0.3295601308,
0.0398712903,
-0.2011897564,
0.0928369164,
-0.097326681,
-0.8314187527,
-0.7085325122,
-0.3251523674,
-0.2003409415,
-0.5147747993,
0.0296376348,
0.9738229513,
0.6293528676,
-0.5627517104,
-0.0303598531,
-0.5933895707,
-0.0352692641,
0.1465526223,
-0.3691621125,
-0.0057071075,
-0.5817338228,
-0.7818306684,
0.4943029881,
-0.0200977102,
0.1483464241,
-0.4260882735,
0.2280658334,
0.153778106,
0.4712537229,
0.6598047018,
0.0034701887,
-0.7221018076,
-0.4148588479,
0.2121028155,
-0.1658805758,
-0.1977111548,
0.9903069735,
-0.8177061081,
0.1169040874,
0.6918477416,
0.6677200198,
0.3257916272,
0.3095732927,
0.5903468132,
-1.1186039448,
0.0327513963,
0.5468096137,
0.2373726815,
0.6240805984,
-0.5758634806,
0.7317724228,
0.4024045765,
-0.6147187948,
-1.4881958961,
0.2887731493,
-0.8069242835,
-0.2522429228,
1.603746295,
0.1557517499,
-0.1318929791,
-0.142007336,
-0.1502086669,
0.3422179222,
-0.3028191924,
1.016297102,
0.6723449826,
-0.0151154799,
0.4099313915,
-0.5719565749,
0.7133390307,
0.4937717915,
-0.9366115332,
0.2851305008,
0.734978199,
0.2882084846,
0.3825699389,
0.5587596297,
-0.1341519356,
0.0588046089,
-0.0901615098,
-0.144503668,
0.2563691139,
-0.5802028775,
-0.1174526289,
0.0930510536,
-0.0449194834,
0.531385839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15040v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15040v2 | Active Learning for Natural Language Generation | 2023-05-24T11:27:53 | 2023-10-17T14:37:10 | Yotam Perlitz, Ariel Gera, Michal Shmueli-Scheuer, Dafna Sheinwald, Noam Slonim, Liat Ein-Dor | cs.CL | cs.CL | The field of Natural Language Generation (NLG) suffers from a severe shortage
of labeled data due to the extremely expensive and time-consuming process
involved in manual annotation. A natural approach for coping with this problem
is active learning (AL), a well-known machine learning technique for improving
annotation efficiency by selectively choosing the most informative examples to
label. However, while AL has been well-researched in the context of text
classification, its application to NLG remains largely unexplored. In this
paper, we present a first systematic study of active learning for NLG,
considering a diverse set of tasks and multiple leading selection strategies,
and harnessing a strong instruction-tuned model. Our results indicate that the
performance of existing AL strategies is inconsistent, surpassing the baseline
of random example selection in some cases but not in others. We highlight some
notable differences between the classification and generation scenarios, and
analyze the selection behaviors of existing AL strategies. Our findings
motivate exploring novel approaches for applying AL to generation tasks. | [
-0.0298339967,
-1.3658850193,
0.2039995193,
0.1232896894,
-0.4218925834,
-0.0359718613,
-0.523834765,
-0.5361828208,
-0.1518032104,
0.385351032,
-0.4689618647,
-0.5768455863,
-0.3274828494,
0.348320812,
-0.2592710853,
1.1432746649,
-0.1084374413,
-0.4484080672,
0.2722987533,
-0.1966150999,
-0.4940873682,
-0.1807779372,
-1.0546212196,
-0.1115417108,
0.5241356492,
0.2991943657,
0.7254548073,
0.8209721446,
0.27031973,
0.236190632,
-0.1934667826,
0.6404178739,
-0.2033934742,
0.6440737844,
0.1945114136,
-0.3896385431,
-0.0876910761,
0.3540710807,
0.6924889088,
0.7994650602,
-0.154059127,
0.1165002733,
-0.1546302736,
0.5782149434,
-0.7540211678,
0.0901993737,
-0.9810623527,
0.4162347019,
-0.238313362,
-0.0694284737,
-0.5167192221,
-0.3748328686,
0.2647277415,
-0.6800327897,
0.6270759702,
0.2546897233,
0.6786441207,
0.4766468406,
-0.5036758184,
-0.8927328587,
-0.9109003544,
0.8450208306,
-0.5739185214,
0.1337614208,
0.580219388,
0.157942012,
0.0568595827,
-0.8719066978,
-0.4621512592,
-0.2767156959,
0.1592206657,
0.189721182,
-0.3345418274,
0.1732749939,
0.2636823356,
0.4878990948,
-0.3125255108,
0.2279480547,
-0.3219526112,
-0.0244029984,
0.7000886202,
-0.3831153512,
0.2006350905,
-0.3043355942,
-0.3658103943,
-0.1051722243,
-0.5446082354,
-0.0024934951,
0.5459570289,
0.6948479414,
0.3753477335,
0.5177244544,
0.115275912,
1.0424060822,
0.0940374956,
0.0375423208,
0.1421491951,
-0.3054835796,
-0.358140111,
0.4501178563,
0.7897929549,
-0.2192747742,
0.0461086966,
-0.2822719216,
-0.2857141197,
-0.0379149839,
0.5347644091,
-0.3568051755,
-0.3141727746,
0.008966581,
-0.3102539778,
-0.4776318967,
0.1726464182,
-0.4066580236,
-0.0174123514,
-0.1406801939,
0.3215075731,
-0.251552552,
-0.1843351126,
-0.1523963064,
0.0987398624,
0.0220304243,
0.0999263376,
-0.9565086365,
0.0424517877,
0.362926662,
0.5851371288,
-0.493119061,
-0.0340770185,
-0.786234796,
0.1339426339,
-0.4312869906,
0.7366085052,
-0.3984638751,
-0.097602196,
0.2842147946,
-0.1686688364,
-0.0245628599,
-0.5668521523,
0.7623935342,
-0.5040904284,
0.3434675038,
0.0968743488,
-0.2711807191,
-0.39474684,
0.0358206332,
-0.8575707674,
1.3716187477,
-0.0527932718,
-0.558375299,
0.8658424616,
-0.682078898,
-0.7779393792,
0.1594994515,
-0.0937263146,
-0.8862151504,
0.130663693,
-0.0327410661,
0.6655215621,
0.0770440623,
0.1741264164,
0.2643194497,
-0.0467636101,
0.0963008106,
-0.4334447682,
0.6452895403,
0.3497882783,
-0.6637330055,
0.1614333391,
-0.8632887602,
0.0777261406,
0.1012036502,
-0.7393832803,
-0.315553993,
0.1805330962,
-0.1868477911,
0.0548691787,
-0.1108080521,
-0.2712551057,
0.3882050812,
-0.2421600968,
0.1084552705,
0.52431494,
0.3482864797,
0.5440482497,
-0.0930235088,
0.5323083997,
-0.407263428,
-0.1693150401,
-0.1155231595,
-0.5728638172,
-0.8446468711,
-0.2012332231,
0.5657818317,
0.4739716053,
-0.8898317814,
0.6129999757,
0.2777641714,
-0.4177758694,
-0.7013158202,
0.6056715846,
0.4303402305,
0.144346267,
0.508400619,
0.0982713699,
-0.5717895031,
-0.8211359382,
-0.3058778346,
-0.3353761137,
0.1850079894,
0.2865412533,
-0.0427828953,
-0.0962457135,
0.7478991151,
-0.3334945142,
-0.1799671799,
-0.6270561218,
0.6553197503,
-0.09895695,
0.1471527666,
0.4854091406,
-0.7804560065,
-0.5493474007,
0.0383839905,
-0.7669280171,
-0.2915742099,
-0.4331811368,
-0.2561607361,
0.2341047376,
0.5479958057,
-0.3567218781,
0.2920338511,
0.5413511992,
-0.1431795359,
-0.010763051,
-0.0510827154,
-0.3028790951,
-0.7079503536,
0.0380139798,
0.0942631438,
-0.1008961275,
-0.8399655223,
-0.1739826202,
0.0241128914,
-0.0579219759,
-0.4544484615,
0.4678104818,
-0.8282767534,
0.269587338,
-0.5832908154,
-0.0382809304,
-0.4438601732,
0.4935518205,
0.0596211478,
0.4389928281,
0.6374032497,
-0.9478604794,
0.2293754965,
0.2882864177,
-0.1591189653,
-0.3519647717,
-0.2942281663,
0.2331416458,
-0.1838887483,
0.0393891558,
-0.6644340754,
-0.1169696748,
0.1846022755,
-0.2217230946,
0.5351173282,
-0.0440149643,
-0.5135752559,
-0.0804390237,
0.1317365021,
0.0512254089,
0.6534929872,
-0.5222092271,
0.5209233761,
0.2067082375,
-0.1240049452,
-0.3621310592,
-0.4353891909,
-0.0832807869,
-0.1810521334,
-0.0651909411,
0.1525832564,
0.2451860309,
-0.393237561,
0.0443213843,
-0.3367856443,
0.2337446958,
0.4656823575,
0.0751652867,
-0.1069409475,
-0.1126766056,
0.2681472301,
0.2296429724,
0.0249204785,
-0.0250588432,
0.0549974218,
0.1140852645,
0.1817830801,
-0.3708123863,
-0.152284801,
0.2329678386,
0.1028715447,
-0.5345587134,
0.6928918362,
0.7367598414,
-0.3294202983,
-1.0182646513,
-0.2079939246,
-0.1293196678,
-0.4084050357,
0.2753821015,
0.3122102916,
-0.5193756223,
-0.0528868884,
-0.2228261083,
0.9204234481,
0.4072137177,
0.379881084,
0.0968396589,
1.1748255491,
0.6518527865,
0.5723844171,
0.8494355679,
-0.2067713737,
0.4073691666,
-0.4024516642,
-0.1577170342,
-0.3366122544,
-0.4713365138,
-0.3494495153,
-0.3624583781,
0.0378047712,
0.4890318215,
0.2427526414,
0.1044783592,
-0.5624931455,
0.1615808755,
0.6294386387,
-0.0767870992,
0.1673924476,
0.1814867854,
-0.0456599891,
0.1502107978,
-1.0827203989,
-0.7981086969,
0.9431006312,
0.1313324273,
0.399389267,
0.2196525335,
0.7152394652,
0.3423666656,
0.5887186527,
-0.905489862,
0.679925561,
-0.2104935944,
-0.7159617543,
-0.379653424,
-0.5596920848,
-1.4343185425,
-0.0263955146,
-0.6810398698,
0.0448634475,
-0.3829709589,
0.3199587166,
-0.3976098895,
0.3072988093,
-0.8230181336,
0.5960063338,
-0.5925132632,
-0.4973561466,
0.2282518148,
-0.5689733028,
0.1989701539,
-0.1870889664,
0.0652102754,
-0.0202829745,
0.0770503879,
1.0422992706,
0.1624308378,
0.8108435869,
-0.3465120494,
-0.1165771112,
0.7586350441,
-0.0887097418,
0.5020608902,
-0.0022666929,
-0.2586762607,
-0.3896278143,
-1.0582997799,
-0.3430499434,
-0.4869878888,
0.3731052876,
-0.5960840583,
-0.3805835843,
-0.4518322647,
-0.3485493958,
-0.2523870766,
0.2271645367,
0.0725379661,
0.2438323349,
-0.1338229179,
0.4121658802,
0.905387044,
-0.2564800084,
0.7684924006,
0.3361955285,
0.0086078644,
-0.2995789349,
0.7740796208,
0.1388630569,
0.3407917321,
0.1404048055,
0.2687751949,
-0.0728678554,
-0.9161149263,
-0.5136842132,
0.1377931684,
-0.4985598922,
-0.3878311515,
-0.7054970264,
-0.1766163558,
-0.1733835489,
-0.1080085263,
-0.2344560474,
-0.4456846118,
-0.5270909667,
-0.5346148014,
0.2718966305,
0.8133963346,
0.2161131799,
0.2923712134,
-0.5374205112,
0.5936374068,
0.7360469699,
0.0846985057,
0.0335536078,
-0.1117866635,
-0.2591282129,
-0.0257299338,
-0.5702955723,
-0.9724208713,
0.2136421949,
0.6437613964,
1.1362490654,
0.5645974278,
0.3066428602,
0.2948066294,
-0.403647691,
0.82349509,
0.0272504948,
-0.4848810732,
0.9494273067,
-0.2551544309,
0.3052853346,
0.7140914202,
0.431540817,
-0.1691404134,
-0.6233938932,
-0.9044387937,
-1.3011236191,
0.756875515,
0.4858043492,
0.090521656,
-0.4641765654,
0.3814467192,
0.4861485958,
0.1304500848,
-0.9316757917,
-0.4096060097,
-0.1461037248,
-0.1429385543,
0.0478774533,
0.1598173827,
-0.0267601926,
0.1190361306,
1.0185996294,
-0.196271196,
0.1099712923,
0.0536576658,
-0.214129284,
-0.369930476,
0.2244549543,
0.3407218456,
0.3734242618,
0.0030062138,
0.2318563461,
0.1312642246,
-0.5069451332,
-0.1511856318,
0.0809448212,
-0.4997965395,
0.2331331074,
0.5703682303,
1.2879629135,
0.2916827798,
-0.664454639,
0.2357156426,
0.0125697469,
-0.4396280944,
-0.1073189229,
0.5923413634,
-0.2943117023,
-0.1674949825,
0.9932544231,
0.1585941464,
-0.2289536744,
-0.8593013883,
0.1512201577,
0.3850082457,
-0.5605707765,
-0.2357136011,
0.6091046333,
0.430078119,
-0.6004965305,
0.6683964729,
-0.5792380571,
-0.5125174522,
0.3843458891,
0.5690163374,
0.8677920699,
-0.0593119226,
0.0884533599,
0.4288861454,
0.2781508863,
-0.3114111722,
0.1739331633,
-0.1932703704,
-0.5816566944,
-0.4720000625,
-0.7325863838,
-0.3645846546,
0.1181353629,
-0.6488121748,
0.3485079408,
-0.4532024264,
-0.2639165521,
-0.1221953109,
0.2869048417,
-0.4189414382,
0.2073820382,
0.3852300346,
0.5964009762,
-1.108341217,
0.4709036648,
1.2629617453,
-0.148489818,
-0.6554843783,
0.0921242684,
-0.3829443753,
-0.3618249595,
0.2957372069,
0.2451887876,
0.1528691947,
0.2544969618,
-0.5716840029,
-0.331957221,
0.997903049,
-0.0365922265,
-0.0648241937,
-0.1833724976,
-0.386846751,
0.5511398315,
-0.1463666409,
-0.2510671318,
0.0962586254,
0.4261148274,
0.0653578565,
-0.6066996455,
-0.1804885119,
-0.3092772961,
-0.40786165,
0.5928542018,
-0.5662379861,
0.4454343021,
-0.1517226398,
-0.5011019111,
-0.1913125068,
1.0338064432,
0.5530065298,
0.4362422824,
0.7930325866,
0.3571180403,
0.8518416882,
0.0005613852,
0.6358758211,
0.008164064,
-0.0567645617,
0.4922293127,
-0.2449472994,
0.6977877617,
0.3015974462,
0.0232135672,
0.237750262,
0.5538213253,
-0.1648793817,
0.6033514738,
0.1442231685,
-0.5583335161,
-0.3832674325,
0.0030456379,
-0.0002058474,
0.557307899,
0.2149663568,
-0.5774951577,
-0.1428277791,
0.1827591062,
0.0842530429,
0.3042693734,
-0.4094240963,
1.0932924747,
-0.2446011603,
-1.0089050531,
0.3744724393,
-0.0224685632,
0.6517102718,
-0.8029720187,
-0.365858674,
0.0770934746,
-0.1753869206,
-0.2419057786,
-0.5297130346,
0.0414728895,
0.3430011272,
0.0145292636,
-0.881475091,
0.7090520263,
-0.3932465017,
-0.4906212986,
-0.071281001,
0.5661021471,
0.0179318972,
0.3112923205,
-0.5168263912,
-0.1693337709,
0.3991929889,
-0.5261320472,
0.1794329584,
0.7824507952,
-0.2143601179,
0.3461645544,
0.9480950832,
0.2355559617,
0.5030882955,
-0.1586067528,
0.6290890574,
-0.5882695317,
-0.3286759555,
-0.5160216093,
0.5190808773,
-0.0426184423,
-0.5561658144,
0.9410923719,
0.6302849054,
0.5389794707,
0.2951037288,
1.0221133232,
-0.2803443074,
0.5310788751,
-0.6990086436,
0.4418067932,
-0.1779244095,
0.2682811618,
-0.0341080502,
-1.2120219469,
-0.442071557,
0.8538423181,
-0.0307738259,
-0.0269298907,
0.7552668452,
0.1918497086,
-0.0940543488,
0.0428594053,
-0.0172745381,
0.001206993,
0.2006546408,
0.0520372093,
0.7000316381,
-0.2057261318,
0.718788445,
-0.326051563,
-0.2990935743,
-0.0120820682,
-0.8852450252,
-1.0878266096,
-0.4459419549,
-0.5305708647,
-0.0214706268,
0.0787417293,
0.9846371412,
0.5344711542,
-0.5742307305,
0.1489908546,
-0.4334004223,
-0.097119607,
-0.5662922263,
-0.1186675504,
0.3419730663,
-0.4423173964,
-0.7462837696,
0.7011902928,
-0.2266031951,
0.0646172464,
-0.1040287167,
0.1634808481,
-0.654014647,
-0.1578218341,
0.5536241531,
0.5214402676,
-0.5230597854,
0.0442293435,
0.0768746659,
-0.0679463372,
-0.0854097083,
0.8070632219,
-0.9148219228,
0.304587245,
0.3629768491,
0.7985034585,
0.465444386,
0.2404815853,
0.456397295,
-1.147069335,
0.0121799847,
0.6265979409,
-0.1660265177,
0.3634009957,
-0.103503637,
0.5256037116,
-0.0431576632,
-0.5204675198,
-0.9205767512,
0.2141851783,
-1.0226355791,
-0.3586258292,
1.657438159,
0.1096927002,
-0.1465285569,
-0.3102059066,
-0.3584751487,
0.7247875333,
-0.4059607685,
0.7884914279,
0.4585726559,
-0.3367293775,
-0.057807155,
-0.9027924538,
0.6722489595,
0.469103992,
-0.6975884438,
0.192629084,
0.4852089584,
-0.2976278663,
0.2002889812,
0.0548230894,
0.3833916187,
0.2378028035,
-0.2885228992,
0.1707707494,
-0.2802878916,
-0.3427821994,
-0.1535865664,
0.4217876792,
0.3045906723,
-0.1018777415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15038v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15038v2 | Is GPT-4 a Good Data Analyst? | 2023-05-24T11:26:59 | 2023-10-23T02:10:58 | Liying Cheng, Xingxuan Li, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated their powerful capabilities
in plenty of domains and tasks, including context understanding, code
generation, language generation, data storytelling, etc., many data analysts
may raise concerns if their jobs will be replaced by artificial intelligence
(AI). This controversial topic has drawn great attention in public. However, we
are still at a stage of divergent opinions without any definitive conclusion.
Motivated by this, we raise the research question of "is GPT-4 a good data
analyst?" in this work and aim to answer it by conducting head-to-head
comparative studies. In detail, we regard GPT-4 as a data analyst to perform
end-to-end data analysis with databases from a wide range of domains. We
propose a framework to tackle the problems by carefully designing the prompts
for GPT-4 to conduct experiments. We also design several task-specific
evaluation metrics to systematically compare the performance between several
professional human data analysts and GPT-4. Experimental results show that
GPT-4 can achieve comparable performance to humans. We also provide in-depth
discussions about our results to shed light on further studies before reaching
the conclusion that GPT-4 can replace data analysts. | [
-0.4271844029,
-0.7525317073,
0.8225345612,
-0.1085254624,
-0.2175713032,
0.4832041562,
-0.2467418462,
-0.6461683512,
-0.0963111892,
0.0900650248,
-0.3522259295,
-0.5447558165,
-0.533371985,
0.4815426767,
-0.7749334574,
1.0631343126,
-0.0823159963,
-0.0107431123,
-0.2208621204,
0.0717155486,
-0.6686754227,
-0.8358572721,
-0.8753953576,
-0.2405797988,
0.5273728967,
0.2544698119,
0.7599396706,
0.3975019157,
0.5800260901,
0.3629740775,
0.3206660151,
-0.08817745,
-0.7112783194,
0.0240237359,
-0.2713074684,
-0.5576422215,
-0.694856286,
0.4114661813,
0.2997269034,
0.6662765145,
0.1035921946,
-0.0314708836,
0.0359077491,
0.8649939299,
0.1215709597,
0.42615363,
-0.4390623868,
-0.0836901888,
-0.6087062955,
-0.0925009474,
-0.081637755,
-0.4409162998,
0.1158732623,
-0.5419290662,
0.3351219296,
0.1671280265,
0.6892612576,
0.3196807504,
-0.4935420752,
-0.0647336021,
-0.8376113772,
0.974757731,
-0.7584008574,
0.4318111837,
0.5092602968,
0.5165321827,
-0.0758735389,
-0.5483917594,
-0.4879510403,
-0.1005143225,
0.1626790613,
0.148174122,
-0.2588769794,
-0.1959192008,
0.2636111975,
0.3408894241,
-0.7580806017,
0.1018140689,
-0.4441497922,
-0.0991003513,
0.6446300149,
0.2741329074,
0.1816141754,
0.2084321976,
-0.1082853377,
0.4239740372,
-0.6723880768,
-0.36431095,
0.6249377728,
0.2052205652,
0.0603861697,
0.2650035322,
-0.29652372,
0.6966324449,
0.0093237963,
0.0208724625,
0.4150992036,
-0.4548460841,
-0.0304610971,
-0.1942305565,
0.6298123002,
0.4519037008,
0.6439587474,
-0.6699774265,
-0.2624533474,
0.3442131877,
0.7219389081,
-0.6320741773,
-0.3727170825,
0.428851068,
-0.3179033101,
-0.0966606811,
-0.2546337247,
-0.784909308,
-0.186846301,
-0.5782052875,
0.0641232878,
-0.3177765012,
-0.3313286006,
0.0276783872,
0.2109148204,
0.2745547891,
0.3104046583,
-0.7419427633,
0.6136371493,
0.8077940345,
0.7838186026,
-0.823448658,
-0.3071515262,
-0.2566496134,
0.0191766564,
-0.6763470173,
1.011964798,
-0.5458884239,
-0.5063188076,
-0.3488334119,
-0.3567271531,
-0.0195284989,
-0.6181322932,
0.7533941269,
-0.5894246697,
0.0735005885,
-0.5171218514,
-0.6850100756,
-0.1706798971,
0.4970407784,
-0.6958225369,
0.7587346435,
0.2560981512,
-0.8508246541,
0.5376724005,
-0.6386157274,
-0.2604122758,
0.1784166098,
-0.4852696657,
-0.4661056995,
-0.3530298769,
0.1907794774,
0.4080772102,
-0.5132001042,
0.3102533221,
-0.2343914807,
-0.5865452886,
0.3179846406,
-0.2385958731,
0.3097486496,
0.3629820645,
-0.4675215781,
-0.0857126787,
-0.4119761288,
0.1152205616,
0.0337741673,
-0.1643972099,
0.0450011194,
0.0424269736,
-0.2548409998,
-0.0198113434,
-0.0626179576,
-0.4839353561,
0.3018810749,
-0.2412528694,
0.3314810693,
0.5983499885,
0.0043405611,
0.3733766079,
-0.420342356,
0.7616509199,
-0.1540139467,
-0.0477292053,
0.4368895292,
-0.7205976844,
-0.2366634756,
-0.1733003259,
0.2545781136,
0.4316620827,
-0.9128354788,
0.054571759,
-0.1687707752,
-0.3985796869,
-0.2413930744,
0.1528242379,
0.0965330303,
0.6102441549,
0.3113815486,
-0.1949670166,
-0.6208542585,
-0.9425183535,
-0.5170419812,
-0.1102891043,
0.0807202309,
0.0999967083,
0.3974300027,
-0.3446610868,
1.2395833731,
-0.3151664734,
-0.1138557866,
-0.6137593389,
-0.0227018818,
0.6342616677,
0.1789536774,
0.723793447,
-0.6935542822,
-0.4828789234,
-0.0627804324,
-0.9835475087,
-0.0626150742,
0.2194412351,
-0.1064116955,
0.0719053224,
0.0620123409,
-0.8668077588,
0.3231689632,
0.2743058205,
-0.2621467412,
0.6427793503,
-0.0274771824,
0.3573376834,
-0.6512284875,
0.265443325,
0.1070753783,
-0.232685104,
-1.0656261444,
-0.2217438519,
-0.151274845,
-0.2248501331,
-0.1151314899,
0.434002161,
-0.2708946168,
-0.4926590621,
-0.3468395174,
-0.0689079165,
-0.284879148,
0.28541857,
-0.1699564159,
0.9873605967,
0.7810842991,
-0.4813345969,
0.4655352831,
0.4103318155,
-0.5074745417,
0.6904435158,
-0.4982199371,
0.519302547,
0.1476526707,
0.3069328368,
-0.8251323104,
-0.3238996863,
0.3111326098,
-0.4304105639,
0.2755982876,
-0.0530382954,
-0.5289924145,
-0.6794658303,
-0.28689605,
0.2828341424,
0.4120565951,
-0.3395290375,
0.306728065,
0.3924498558,
-0.6626726985,
-0.3461357951,
-0.6530657411,
0.4369805157,
-0.5894789696,
-0.6281246543,
0.3358811438,
-0.1403072774,
-0.4721258581,
-0.1243764684,
-0.170867458,
-0.3072933555,
-0.0212163962,
-0.1012718529,
0.3359963596,
-0.0948682204,
-0.2401627302,
-0.4877707064,
-0.4958026707,
0.2715204358,
0.0516014732,
0.0780622289,
-0.292185694,
-0.395331651,
-0.403385669,
0.2046821266,
0.3235099018,
-0.1882915944,
-0.0519737154,
0.3496346176,
-0.1735319197,
0.0614494532,
-0.4591221213,
-0.0588211343,
-0.4527181089,
0.3300139606,
-0.5763844252,
-0.4198043048,
0.4327563643,
-0.0142478142,
0.0711861625,
0.2549284697,
0.5413446426,
-0.0492686555,
1.1984754801,
0.4462852478,
-0.6331688166,
0.1452762485,
-0.4935934842,
0.5354890227,
-0.4211213291,
0.0726172775,
-0.3936391771,
-0.2692958117,
-0.2508489788,
-0.0652277693,
0.2842721641,
-0.1680881977,
-0.4199842215,
-0.000212863,
-0.3821590841,
0.4825408459,
0.2724916339,
-0.1875594258,
0.2997671366,
-0.2315665781,
0.648612082,
-0.0001130223,
-0.4171687365,
-0.6783848405,
1.1775372028,
0.3704612851,
0.7417478561,
0.1188396439,
0.5267422199,
0.3676371276,
0.3908124268,
-0.5296317339,
0.5272658467,
0.1104133427,
-0.6139687896,
-0.2063760608,
-0.5904282331,
-0.9497738481,
0.1411859542,
0.1122122705,
-0.8300175667,
-0.1045089439,
0.0201521162,
-0.2318143696,
0.1598426998,
-0.7883878946,
0.9851035476,
-0.5297088027,
-0.3476980925,
-0.0435713641,
-0.5021651983,
0.2797288299,
-0.4245355129,
0.4428389966,
-0.3338693678,
-0.0412519798,
0.7685024142,
-0.2748519182,
0.5536594987,
-0.5874636769,
-0.0355159491,
0.3871956468,
0.0996053591,
0.4567761123,
-0.0835068226,
-0.5041211843,
0.2825815976,
-0.1084324121,
-0.3640072942,
-0.6152202487,
0.7047954798,
-0.7497785687,
-0.6553174257,
-0.3979053497,
-0.5881257057,
-0.5815821886,
0.172504887,
0.0624454543,
0.2774139047,
-0.0776944458,
-0.1780911535,
0.1120628864,
0.1037376747,
0.1916348785,
0.2011457682,
-0.1015388966,
0.067665115,
1.0413577557,
0.1980666816,
-0.0578404739,
-0.0936169773,
-0.0188200772,
-0.3739200532,
-0.8638600707,
-0.8102873564,
0.1886405796,
-0.4491594136,
-0.2240395844,
-0.4480894804,
0.1036015078,
-0.0380278267,
-0.0850718692,
-0.3039869964,
-0.0586982295,
-0.0792209879,
-0.3472491801,
0.5106037259,
0.906178534,
0.3015028536,
0.1295746416,
-0.3731766939,
0.3184454441,
0.1764779091,
0.4999852777,
-0.2283165753,
-0.2096983939,
-0.2678423524,
-0.0657463074,
-0.3688245714,
-0.7686641216,
0.4305229187,
0.0126800919,
0.8468376994,
0.1604907215,
-0.2594072521,
0.3480314314,
-0.378346175,
0.8500937819,
-0.2155538052,
-0.7537300587,
0.0495730229,
-0.7123759389,
0.1750940233,
0.5289215446,
0.5411734581,
-0.2515303195,
-0.509986937,
-0.4900787473,
-0.6859174371,
0.8499593139,
0.5343635082,
-0.1473124772,
0.2650378644,
0.5242081285,
0.4465867281,
0.4155907333,
-0.5503501296,
-0.1613300592,
-0.3935568631,
-0.1963940263,
-0.2405942976,
0.1029301956,
0.1180679351,
-0.175942719,
0.5186210275,
-0.2077946216,
0.47595945,
-0.4007888734,
0.3103247285,
0.039899081,
0.2040756494,
-0.1010924578,
1.1833781004,
-0.3250931203,
0.1223378181,
0.2603959143,
-0.4416899383,
0.1504185349,
0.2646860778,
0.1713079661,
-0.2074722499,
0.3891512454,
0.4477764666,
-0.0318668745,
-0.5105427504,
0.6243132353,
-0.0775198489,
-0.331975311,
-0.060334947,
0.0780618712,
0.3260506094,
0.1128097326,
0.5126357079,
-0.3244839907,
0.4157869816,
-0.7425055504,
0.2610196769,
0.1941781193,
0.1931525916,
-0.5153324008,
0.8235485554,
0.4096088111,
-0.101383239,
0.7697497606,
-0.2152902782,
-0.5973495245,
0.6630006433,
0.411441803,
0.4440095425,
-0.285933733,
0.0132646039,
-0.0544625409,
-0.0059132874,
-0.1024611592,
0.5969285965,
0.2285188437,
-0.6998937726,
-0.6415287852,
-0.2602968216,
-0.7128694057,
0.066321902,
-0.379633069,
0.1171992794,
-0.040124435,
-0.2622932494,
0.2069695592,
0.1643118262,
-0.8634148836,
0.3752914965,
-0.1190374494,
0.5334023237,
-0.6002123356,
0.9521780014,
0.434422791,
-0.3021320999,
-0.5852578282,
0.0390372649,
0.1732803583,
-0.5373045206,
0.7485947013,
0.2873916924,
-0.0485213436,
0.001994598,
-0.5066182017,
-0.9347424507,
1.0157088041,
0.4688548148,
-0.5194309354,
-0.1169714481,
0.2601372302,
0.6943828464,
-0.2166607678,
0.3791249692,
0.9549111724,
0.7287355661,
-0.1099888161,
-0.8204270005,
-0.23525922,
-0.1796544045,
-0.2783488929,
0.2705118358,
-0.496240139,
0.9581902027,
-0.1297816187,
-0.2045801729,
0.1044900194,
0.44025895,
-0.0664260536,
0.569829464,
0.5016152263,
0.3111946881,
0.7090212107,
-0.0262707677,
1.2929233313,
-0.4470625818,
0.3484944105,
0.9001890421,
-0.6909524798,
0.4326730371,
0.0839011893,
-0.6225650311,
0.3690336347,
0.8973969221,
-0.0541243628,
0.557053864,
0.1796652675,
-0.0284077488,
-0.0314686969,
0.6024338603,
-0.1992605776,
0.2265225202,
0.3281612992,
0.0936722308,
-0.2769009471,
-0.0916843042,
-0.2355365455,
-0.1903232634,
-0.2262343466,
0.488412261,
0.1370683908,
-0.5212304592,
0.4467737079,
-0.0150028719,
0.2752403319,
-0.4672015607,
-0.057778012,
-0.3598978221,
0.1121889353,
-0.3800986111,
-0.9833419919,
0.5598805547,
0.4088704288,
0.1317897588,
-0.1169337407,
0.6651843786,
-0.0747802407,
-0.0035595989,
0.1454276741,
0.8931837678,
0.7349645495,
-0.2792271972,
-0.7663719058,
0.18689017,
0.0738539696,
-0.3445669413,
0.1812256426,
0.2849604785,
-0.1205980182,
0.7574202418,
0.4534082115,
0.0637046844,
-0.3363316059,
0.1642401367,
0.8677878976,
-0.8754294515,
-0.4643988609,
-0.7949426174,
0.2081720978,
-0.0619846359,
-0.0970524326,
0.8799760938,
0.8817204237,
0.5350496173,
0.213790372,
1.0794507265,
0.0399842151,
1.0910503864,
-0.4144274592,
0.231798768,
-0.1835076362,
0.2816306949,
-0.4868865013,
-1.3206499815,
-0.2475094795,
0.5018473864,
-0.7367008924,
0.5217025876,
0.7679030895,
0.6006266475,
-0.274220258,
0.3856064379,
0.3189124465,
0.3843168318,
0.6727337837,
0.4231376648,
0.9005438685,
0.170189783,
0.5339362621,
0.1709953994,
-0.3129604757,
0.0243635792,
-0.5547620058,
-0.8018315434,
-0.3224504292,
-0.0351361372,
0.1634290814,
0.3227367699,
0.4091620445,
0.6596633792,
-0.5178095698,
-0.2079920918,
-0.1662089825,
-0.2108647823,
-0.0705077201,
-0.1526077688,
0.4385711551,
-0.1744257063,
-0.7985473871,
0.6442755461,
0.1554554552,
-0.1804252416,
-0.2589327097,
-0.1633978486,
0.1742739677,
-0.1680083871,
0.3482461274,
0.1501255035,
-0.3547118306,
-0.4237215221,
-0.3045131862,
-0.0264141411,
0.2131766081,
0.8599206209,
-0.7934399843,
0.3065266311,
0.141299054,
0.9399024844,
0.7677972913,
0.3106878996,
0.6955819726,
-0.4274764359,
-0.3368093669,
0.2994630933,
0.4265769422,
0.5090659261,
-0.5225518942,
1.0331765413,
0.1928698421,
-0.9782522321,
-0.5227451324,
-0.0159440637,
-0.8289121389,
-0.1815470755,
1.2934321165,
0.1484370381,
0.0181380901,
-0.5239691734,
-0.4888437986,
-0.0291275848,
-0.5812322497,
0.7950699925,
0.6917546988,
-0.9317009449,
0.261305362,
-1.0825624466,
0.4945214391,
0.3211806715,
-1.2538816929,
0.0998231843,
0.4944023192,
0.4158453941,
-0.2693528235,
0.9411418438,
0.0322570093,
0.1109640971,
-0.1011087969,
-0.0876230001,
0.0617239662,
-0.1200925186,
0.0272476617,
-0.1321528703,
0.3557245731,
-0.0014996629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15035v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15035v2 | Self-ICL: Zero-Shot In-Context Learning with Self-Generated Demonstrations | 2023-05-24T11:22:34 | 2023-10-23T14:50:57 | Wei-Lin Chen, Cheng-Kuang Wu, Yun-Nung Chen, Hsin-Hsi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited striking in-context learning
(ICL) ability to adapt to target tasks with a few input-output demonstrations.
For better ICL, different methods are proposed to select representative
demonstrations from existing training corpora. However, such settings are not
aligned with real-world practices, as end-users usually query LMs without
access to demonstration pools. In this work, we introduce Self-ICL -- a simple
framework which bootstraps LMs' intrinsic capabilities to perform zero-shot
ICL. Given a test input, Self-ICL first prompts the model to generate
pseudo-inputs. Next, the model predicts pseudo-labels for the pseudo-inputs via
zero-shot prompting. Finally, we perform ICL for the test input with the
pseudo-input-label pairs as demonstrations. Evaluation on 23 BIG-Bench Hard
tasks shows Self-ICL outperforms zero-shot baselines on both average accuracy
and head-to-head comparison. Moreover, with zero-shot chain-of-thought,
Self-ICL achieves results comparable to using real demonstrations.
Additionally, we conduct a range of analyses to validate Self-ICL's
effectiveness and provide insights for its behaviors under different settings. | [
-0.2870844901,
-0.8722757101,
0.5867118835,
0.2007605582,
-0.1487306654,
0.131853655,
-0.1973647177,
-0.2729878426,
-0.1426321715,
0.1945166588,
-0.6598704457,
-0.6465254426,
-0.1104454324,
0.1407183409,
-0.661960423,
1.2340849638,
-0.0957252309,
-0.1323869079,
-0.2573377788,
-0.1071209162,
-0.4904409051,
-0.4579468966,
-0.2355258018,
-0.3408350945,
0.4127212167,
0.8487680554,
0.0108251115,
0.5752706528,
-0.1212143302,
0.1593219191,
0.4584755898,
-0.2267121971,
-0.5537351966,
0.2887125313,
-0.3371303976,
-0.2212377042,
0.060260959,
0.0464565419,
0.8292872906,
0.534717083,
-0.0008128869,
0.4328641295,
0.3202416599,
0.265255332,
-0.802942872,
-0.0572178364,
-0.6922413707,
0.1788152307,
-0.1134911403,
-0.0500394516,
-0.5097645521,
0.2999137044,
-0.0224343594,
-0.2624027431,
-0.011418812,
-0.0761878639,
0.4053081274,
0.2756140232,
-0.3480798006,
-0.316492945,
-0.8008043766,
0.7327708006,
-0.732508719,
0.3441251218,
0.2622882426,
0.415571481,
-0.0194905866,
-0.7401999831,
-0.5580510497,
-0.530483067,
-0.1316188723,
0.115705274,
0.0127668027,
-0.1121945232,
0.3029521406,
0.1235574633,
-0.5444590449,
0.410692811,
-0.2957516313,
-0.0555591658,
0.3912748396,
0.1341408044,
0.2113641948,
0.0102568865,
-0.6535972357,
0.1163125709,
-0.9890134335,
0.1492132992,
-0.2078758925,
0.40802598,
-0.1409451067,
0.4926353991,
-0.4617627859,
0.7997540832,
0.5321660638,
-0.1400745213,
0.0927551463,
-0.0158757586,
-0.4263294041,
0.2663477957,
0.8506079912,
-0.0882445201,
-0.1674409509,
-0.2231990248,
-0.3460346758,
-0.4306620657,
0.050838694,
-0.827090621,
-0.0086634103,
0.2768027186,
-0.184751153,
-0.27654773,
-0.4052813053,
-0.4761310816,
-0.0786510557,
-0.3810446262,
0.9822674394,
-0.3870255947,
0.0271971524,
-0.1574275643,
0.2766269147,
0.2805740833,
0.1519909203,
-0.7086626887,
0.3359458447,
0.3058824539,
0.9672446251,
-0.3689055741,
-0.6108926535,
-0.8177980781,
0.300422132,
-0.4418437481,
0.7152163386,
-0.1091777086,
-0.190627411,
0.0652813241,
-0.2357512116,
-0.0422301404,
-0.5200712085,
-0.1656461656,
-0.3251130283,
0.2491601259,
-0.0400834642,
-0.8026667237,
0.2414708883,
0.4835369289,
-0.0618105456,
0.9926702976,
0.0426159836,
-0.3996455967,
0.3909284472,
-0.9097108245,
-0.5435504913,
0.3724280894,
-0.5436633825,
-0.1766485572,
-0.0571212173,
-0.0163645037,
0.8908572197,
-0.0065122186,
0.2609479725,
-0.4631487429,
-0.5693662167,
0.1960533261,
-0.4156010747,
0.6480710506,
0.2164004743,
-0.9746745825,
0.1957976967,
-0.826235652,
0.0118372599,
0.1095866859,
-0.0817090124,
-0.1166513786,
-0.1356694996,
-0.2810806632,
0.6561945677,
0.1706436723,
-0.4911315143,
0.2437896132,
-0.4674871564,
0.1945881099,
0.6424773932,
-0.0359709673,
0.3799631894,
-0.0725070387,
0.5302765369,
-0.0231899377,
0.1104299277,
-0.3853624165,
0.2053567767,
-0.7335395217,
-0.4145478606,
0.1785659939,
0.4007247984,
-0.8582016826,
0.2740036845,
0.1002354175,
-0.3762657642,
-0.3415534794,
0.4362901747,
0.7446891665,
0.8708767891,
0.5036674142,
-0.1069080234,
-0.1250040531,
-0.9649868608,
0.0560786724,
-0.2050883025,
-0.1055805609,
0.1922861636,
0.5730871558,
0.1437640488,
1.0086843967,
-0.3338969946,
-0.4678945243,
-0.2484941185,
0.4197151959,
-0.0000489094,
0.2970712185,
0.5535209775,
-0.2127895206,
-0.7163027525,
-0.1883233786,
-0.8595157862,
-0.2469121069,
-0.3604845107,
0.1186645031,
0.2556974292,
0.7850899696,
-0.1571009159,
0.4815223217,
0.4222307205,
-0.1887367219,
0.843668282,
-0.4327679574,
-0.2034003437,
-0.8014987707,
0.0523482971,
0.0854751393,
-0.3986144066,
-0.6707769632,
0.0848064199,
0.3160988092,
-0.0558281764,
-0.7713662982,
0.7298229337,
-0.5542547703,
-0.3134534955,
-0.5437698364,
0.094548136,
-0.2665179968,
0.5706576705,
0.199761793,
0.9357129931,
0.8241413832,
-0.7739472389,
-0.0121733528,
-0.0726309195,
-0.4112957716,
0.5574526787,
-0.4704881907,
0.1711150408,
-0.0591642112,
0.2938017547,
-1.0529180765,
-0.0902988687,
0.4028410614,
-0.014593197,
0.4493497908,
-0.1663426161,
-0.3929550648,
-0.162534833,
-0.1828923821,
0.3805913925,
0.4597925842,
-0.8252594471,
0.2521832287,
0.028298866,
0.2229872346,
-0.7366275787,
-0.712993443,
0.164173767,
-0.2098878175,
0.0562020577,
0.3634382784,
-0.5962486267,
-0.0293316245,
-0.2482102662,
0.2416914552,
0.0396529436,
0.1627307236,
0.3172177672,
0.0743291602,
-0.1864268184,
0.3017238975,
0.0503955148,
0.1624090075,
-0.0351357833,
-0.3730709255,
0.4483403265,
-0.3687109649,
-0.6560205221,
-0.615038693,
0.2269542962,
0.4794675708,
-0.0129615013,
0.5545092225,
0.342625916,
-0.1458052397,
-0.53061378,
-0.4568842053,
-0.1891659796,
-0.4732845724,
0.2146353871,
-0.4537672698,
-0.825861752,
0.2063711286,
-0.1188602075,
0.1770155132,
0.1154500395,
0.7288892865,
-0.4648107588,
0.8385556936,
0.6113208532,
-0.1085509732,
0.4668060243,
-0.3882971704,
0.1191254482,
-0.7723054886,
-0.0273193512,
-0.0153923659,
-0.3443342149,
-0.0394702218,
-0.3313125968,
0.3235491812,
0.1476194412,
-0.4381040335,
0.3618880808,
-0.3196494579,
0.5576772094,
0.5925853848,
0.0208089836,
0.074303098,
-0.1246912405,
-0.4887328446,
0.0438512862,
-0.7533516288,
-0.3525810242,
0.8280857801,
0.2507064342,
0.7648327351,
-0.1000248864,
0.9723145962,
0.4449310005,
0.6376391053,
-0.7444299459,
0.5464658737,
0.1871433258,
-0.6322957277,
-0.5072555542,
-0.0718633235,
-0.6615024209,
0.1609898657,
-0.0287686456,
-0.7914748788,
0.080199331,
0.5449312329,
-0.5288300514,
0.2153179049,
-0.5400218964,
0.9821555614,
-0.6551132798,
-0.613904357,
-0.0707828179,
-0.7057938576,
0.3488377929,
-0.0525106825,
0.2786735594,
0.0640763938,
-0.0092250295,
0.2626492381,
-0.1354362518,
1.2893939018,
-0.2382126898,
-0.2182842195,
0.3959182501,
0.5683320761,
0.2464196384,
-0.1616451591,
0.0227769483,
-0.037674997,
0.0309986323,
-0.2638036907,
-0.7203453779,
0.8789767027,
-0.5759265423,
-0.6034514904,
-0.3462347984,
-0.3388233483,
-0.301477313,
0.1093078926,
0.2511162758,
0.7845065594,
-0.2654097974,
0.1773194373,
0.3642235994,
-0.2004897892,
0.7127609253,
0.8561407924,
-0.3773891926,
-0.1230032742,
0.9643102884,
0.3471722603,
0.5235348344,
0.2958079875,
0.2617664635,
-0.4083811939,
-0.5014258027,
-0.8417854309,
0.0865410641,
-0.8035778999,
-0.3626874089,
-0.5174386501,
-0.1904755682,
-0.4104971886,
-0.2960391641,
-0.376976788,
-0.2393184304,
-0.3640215397,
-0.042882476,
-0.2000100911,
0.7588838339,
-0.257014364,
0.2827919722,
-0.2927215695,
0.1236680895,
0.5264285803,
0.3497846723,
0.093998909,
-0.8228958249,
-0.3410374522,
-0.0013409242,
-0.3711411357,
-0.8594663143,
0.3728768229,
0.3806840479,
0.5037263632,
0.588218987,
0.1806027293,
0.8542411327,
-0.8044320941,
0.8706079125,
0.2532286346,
-1.0461857319,
0.5794882774,
-0.2415281534,
0.4487085044,
0.5819012523,
0.5446631908,
-0.4820811152,
-0.393438518,
-0.5502746701,
-0.5555661917,
0.7268925905,
0.0214073565,
0.1074830368,
-0.2106812596,
0.5116918683,
0.0972920358,
0.0460625514,
-1.1420761347,
-0.3767468631,
-0.3081306517,
-0.3245810866,
0.0068032146,
-0.239869073,
-0.0375789888,
-0.3073882461,
0.7232647538,
-0.6117342114,
0.0992202759,
0.3591526151,
-0.5265081525,
-0.0709424317,
0.2530657947,
0.7409574389,
0.7463778853,
-0.0841655657,
0.3548356593,
0.5103718638,
0.2518773973,
0.2596052289,
-0.2293747514,
-0.3313713372,
-0.2565536201,
0.2860153317,
0.7262955308,
0.5650696754,
-0.8659825325,
0.7295598388,
0.0232503284,
-0.297719568,
-0.4612629712,
0.0164536405,
-0.0621399172,
0.2447253615,
0.3908952475,
-0.4930106997,
0.2722112238,
-0.7909417152,
0.4600439966,
0.5548315048,
-0.7601808906,
-0.4095098674,
0.438169688,
-0.1398208588,
-0.4594929814,
0.3267611563,
-0.4656940699,
-0.3590460718,
0.4344326258,
1.1034748554,
0.8209129572,
-0.206574589,
0.5143238902,
0.3219819367,
0.0156051377,
0.1942296773,
-0.1294173151,
-0.5117495656,
-0.5242901444,
-0.5636353493,
-0.4061529338,
-0.3635858297,
0.4274420738,
-0.4970336258,
0.407740891,
-0.6123678088,
0.3954807222,
-0.1435021311,
-0.1937857866,
-0.6001019478,
0.294715941,
0.3983490765,
0.8253096938,
-0.7812050581,
1.0293805599,
0.4571603537,
-0.3406180441,
-0.654902637,
0.2052671462,
0.0284580979,
-0.8421730995,
0.9305160046,
0.2687203288,
-0.2818519771,
0.16253829,
-0.8593575954,
-0.8018140793,
1.1966238022,
0.4262892008,
-0.5554029346,
0.2068755627,
0.0830626264,
0.6637371778,
-0.743421495,
0.3915203512,
0.1060309559,
-0.0016223068,
0.1750859916,
-0.7519361377,
-0.0129361963,
0.266335994,
-0.323880136,
-0.2487554997,
-0.8223022819,
0.4095550478,
-0.0988181382,
-0.2317535728,
-0.1025620773,
0.8710028529,
0.3207114935,
0.4229740798,
0.7708067894,
0.1353026628,
0.3112252057,
0.4753929079,
0.9847651124,
-0.4269550145,
0.2563149035,
1.5222814083,
-0.6366003752,
1.0331050158,
0.3781198561,
0.1519884914,
0.7230300903,
0.4709592164,
0.1858110726,
0.5482459664,
0.2092798352,
-0.4355548024,
-0.4779153466,
-0.1163832322,
0.0816727132,
0.5867070556,
0.3544664383,
-0.1764097661,
-0.4567121267,
0.3469627202,
-0.2359465957,
0.0658635497,
-0.1726201028,
0.9205693603,
0.0144963078,
-0.6888846159,
0.5448998213,
-0.166225791,
0.5832747817,
-0.5458563566,
-0.2177527249,
-0.1386904418,
0.014552135,
0.1644583941,
-0.7706559896,
0.1259575039,
0.0304060187,
0.0154670915,
-0.4085874557,
0.8501932025,
-0.5684782267,
-0.311490953,
0.429323107,
0.4701399207,
0.3712919354,
0.0440154932,
-0.8706513047,
-0.3407981098,
-0.2054437995,
-0.0536422394,
0.7656904459,
0.2780022621,
0.0012054387,
0.8177586198,
0.3658137619,
-0.2218509167,
-0.0312908925,
0.0271271598,
0.7513471246,
-0.5695135593,
-0.2081904411,
-0.9814212918,
0.3929121494,
-0.0078373104,
-0.3279540241,
0.6903172135,
0.5893149376,
1.0480210781,
-0.1524603963,
0.7835550308,
-0.0795160234,
0.5233444571,
-0.4976494312,
0.5362706184,
-0.6543329954,
0.0702683777,
-0.0783049986,
-0.4425650835,
-0.2883272767,
0.6156042218,
-0.2695697248,
-0.0582184345,
0.5859212875,
0.6729550362,
-0.2864577174,
-0.463939786,
0.8928321004,
0.2693327069,
0.3169485033,
0.345821023,
1.0291012526,
-0.1805211455,
0.4441052079,
-0.6109030843,
-0.2422799915,
-0.1966956854,
-1.0990129709,
-1.0700604916,
-0.6375083327,
-0.3978116214,
-0.0761138424,
0.0202568546,
1.3130155802,
1.0274038315,
-0.7387765646,
-0.5466580987,
0.0794610977,
-0.0509044975,
-0.2697635889,
-0.217576161,
0.3241916001,
-0.7600775361,
-0.5056901574,
0.861970067,
0.5346652269,
0.0351435244,
-0.607360661,
-0.0641569048,
-0.2856190205,
-0.0780224055,
0.7398233414,
0.6765434146,
-0.7335503697,
-0.4399616122,
-0.0642113164,
-0.0197409913,
0.0850800201,
0.8451476097,
-1.1555008888,
0.4650205076,
-0.0740864426,
0.5934975743,
0.6105735302,
-0.1371916682,
0.4366881847,
-1.048843503,
-0.0678031743,
0.1128437743,
0.1901192814,
0.2292174697,
-0.3914260566,
0.2204130292,
0.009681195,
-0.6018999219,
-0.7026991844,
0.1956878006,
-0.5680084825,
-0.4766400158,
1.0795664787,
-0.2099010348,
-0.3165114522,
-0.0937247053,
-0.1695221812,
0.1235112473,
-0.0872930586,
1.0491198301,
0.4681390524,
-0.3647750914,
-0.2528253496,
-0.5210926533,
0.417144984,
0.5051855445,
-0.6809217334,
0.0936861932,
0.4392780066,
0.5788426399,
0.0166818425,
0.6988656521,
0.1883805245,
0.210739404,
-0.6237985492,
0.1929415762,
-0.0803195164,
-0.6112453341,
-0.6396677494,
0.2127721012,
0.2650624514,
-0.106442228
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.