id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17216v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17216v3 | Generating Images with Multimodal Language Models | 2023-05-26T19:22:03 | 2023-10-13T15:35:42 | Jing Yu Koh, Daniel Fried, Ruslan Salakhutdinov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | We propose a method to fuse frozen text-only large language models (LLMs)
with pre-trained image encoder and decoder models, by mapping between their
embedding spaces. Our model demonstrates a wide suite of multimodal
capabilities: image retrieval, novel image generation, and multimodal dialogue.
Ours is the first approach capable of conditioning on arbitrarily interleaved
image and text inputs to generate coherent image (and text) outputs. To achieve
strong performance on image generation, we propose an efficient mapping network
to ground the LLM to an off-the-shelf text-to-image generation model. This
mapping network translates hidden representations of text into the embedding
space of the visual models, enabling us to leverage the strong text
representations of the LLM for visual outputs. Our approach outperforms
baseline generation models on tasks with longer and more complex language. In
addition to novel image generation, our model is also capable of image
retrieval from a prespecified dataset, and decides whether to retrieve or
generate at inference time. This is done with a learnt decision module which
conditions on the hidden representations of the LLM. Our model exhibits a wider
range of capabilities compared to prior multimodal language models. It can
process image-and-text inputs, and produce retrieved images, generated images,
and generated text -- outperforming non-LLM based generation models across
several text-to-image tasks that measure context dependence. | [
-0.3946430385,
-0.6321438551,
0.5817181468,
0.0866975412,
-0.3863498867,
-0.085971944,
-0.5098334551,
-0.3276256025,
0.1654764116,
0.7134962082,
-0.4812568128,
-0.4023932815,
-0.6411733627,
0.081955947,
-0.3978575766,
0.7472329736,
0.0568834059,
-0.0427499451,
-0.4578561187,
0.0077210846,
-0.3401905894,
-0.2775733173,
-0.5132799149,
-0.2774609923,
0.4444233477,
0.1424314082,
0.8168828487,
0.5271709561,
0.4821805954,
0.4159002602,
0.3992139995,
0.3440158069,
-0.5791264772,
0.3256154954,
-0.0610915236,
-0.1187343448,
-0.221205622,
-0.1132768914,
0.6913062334,
0.4047800004,
0.1002430096,
-0.0638225973,
-0.2461490631,
0.3002288938,
-0.6096895337,
0.2417500615,
-0.9334734678,
0.0152986338,
-0.0543568693,
-0.539472878,
-0.8220388293,
-0.0709023476,
-0.0834067017,
-0.5499040484,
0.0706180185,
0.0684052631,
0.8638224602,
0.1101120412,
-0.7395502329,
-0.4256917834,
-0.8086951375,
0.8425524831,
-0.5625426173,
0.3684784174,
0.2814622521,
0.2871963084,
-0.0818064064,
-0.8932293653,
-0.7913025022,
-0.3047581017,
0.051795736,
0.3582214415,
-0.0635326281,
-0.070686847,
0.1253247112,
0.2540996969,
-0.3502322733,
-0.0419067778,
-0.2853701413,
-0.1343422383,
0.5560076237,
0.083681114,
0.5289399028,
-0.1624732614,
-0.4621637464,
-0.3371115923,
-0.6827891469,
-0.3876423538,
0.0766714364,
0.1645297855,
0.0003848184,
0.7756245732,
0.1647658646,
0.6505448818,
-0.136927709,
-0.452024579,
0.1429221183,
-0.4426391125,
-0.1073767394,
-0.1834205091,
1.0582506657,
0.5472055674,
0.1674941927,
-0.1009091362,
-0.4651462734,
0.2313039601,
0.0465486012,
-0.8601230383,
-0.1776763499,
-0.2094202936,
-0.439846009,
-0.2325592041,
-0.2986969352,
-0.7045580149,
-0.3380721509,
-0.0833784714,
0.4691303372,
-0.5010756254,
-0.4540727139,
-0.0809813216,
-0.0412989482,
0.1158197373,
0.3040703833,
-0.7055982947,
0.1921146363,
-0.0991878062,
0.6217086315,
0.006524846,
-0.2560218275,
-0.3754726946,
0.4734348953,
-0.5673837066,
0.7309051752,
-0.5948570967,
-0.2498536408,
0.3633390367,
-0.0673202574,
0.0742749721,
-0.3288940787,
0.1633305699,
-0.6590614915,
0.2350060642,
0.2620389462,
-0.3722437322,
-0.1776669472,
0.263012886,
-0.9462891817,
0.794619143,
-0.2058778852,
-0.6211721897,
0.2699199915,
-0.5706705451,
-0.468991667,
0.0685072988,
-0.3226239681,
-0.3895276487,
0.0093322638,
0.4001533389,
0.6933863163,
-0.6223265529,
0.4797720909,
-0.2562097907,
0.0877116919,
0.4621025026,
-0.5430129766,
0.2238156945,
0.3339765668,
-0.0991917923,
0.0862908885,
-0.5635774732,
0.0986463279,
0.4579334855,
-0.5940135717,
-0.2079808265,
0.1019711196,
0.4417631626,
0.3605329692,
0.2830379605,
-0.4788847864,
0.18300955,
-0.0848628283,
0.4668240249,
0.4645684958,
-0.1909754723,
0.6411139965,
-0.1550969779,
0.5525850058,
0.261297971,
-0.2406704873,
-1.0194667578,
-0.5114840865,
-0.9029691219,
-0.406917274,
0.1353996992,
0.3859412372,
-1.4126763344,
0.0585991219,
-0.6072342992,
-0.288300246,
-0.3947380483,
0.134198606,
0.5733681321,
0.3541424572,
0.2122911364,
-0.3885032237,
-0.3065952957,
-1.0225462914,
0.0921684206,
-0.0020828294,
0.1446300894,
0.3752364516,
0.6327610612,
-0.3217457533,
0.5508758426,
-0.4433221519,
-0.197266385,
-0.3432687819,
0.3003123403,
0.0441856124,
0.5467404127,
0.5899125338,
-0.9192858338,
-0.313934356,
0.1448413432,
-0.8115716577,
0.1831506789,
-0.3796139359,
-0.0295191985,
0.3559978306,
0.524690032,
-0.8302397132,
0.2835347056,
0.735871315,
-0.2175711989,
0.3289242685,
-0.2987268269,
0.3647524714,
-1.4116413593,
-0.0268281233,
-0.0332627185,
-0.4721271694,
-0.6127257347,
0.2877599895,
0.111982055,
-0.7314174771,
-0.4825134277,
0.6076444983,
-0.8647253513,
-0.0736925304,
-0.2225787193,
0.1297735125,
0.1834147125,
0.5295628905,
0.293199271,
0.5875899196,
0.869841814,
-0.4637944102,
0.3679951131,
0.1624147594,
-0.4665542245,
0.1393683404,
-0.3857032657,
0.204023391,
-0.2813424468,
0.398701787,
-1.0923732519,
-0.4118000567,
0.1283586174,
-0.2590097785,
0.5664117932,
0.034213908,
-0.6515430808,
-0.2660416365,
0.0143629359,
0.7768666744,
0.5628196001,
-0.4808111191,
0.8362790346,
0.2455664575,
-0.2317770869,
-0.3602029681,
-0.8678215742,
0.3510539234,
0.0635402128,
-0.7861686349,
0.4242282212,
-0.0498134419,
0.1732484251,
0.1933915615,
0.4012542963,
-0.2542403936,
-0.2125761658,
0.3138674796,
0.2381284386,
-0.3636623621,
0.2848339975,
0.1483893991,
0.0139723346,
-0.2090853602,
-0.218812421,
0.5352711678,
0.0159184225,
-0.5578582287,
-0.2739256918,
0.7666612267,
0.7725639343,
-0.4187816679,
0.6876748204,
0.6534420848,
-0.3885626793,
-0.0224386398,
-0.4762862623,
-0.136128515,
-0.4952269197,
0.584102273,
-0.4770031869,
-0.7693642974,
0.348805815,
-0.3239403069,
0.0256514326,
0.2677303553,
0.7347881794,
-0.0908838138,
1.1147834063,
0.7510895729,
0.3687446415,
0.4571324885,
-0.2274585515,
0.2896331549,
-0.5312763453,
-0.2331663668,
-0.1412393004,
-0.1427533329,
-0.4695447385,
-0.681992352,
0.3633905351,
-0.0060251714,
0.0694890097,
0.0501060002,
-0.2410104573,
0.4937459826,
0.4753516614,
0.1452880204,
0.0101050697,
0.2753325999,
-0.3327445984,
-0.0406711623,
-0.8081651926,
-0.5355612636,
1.1210309267,
0.0702474862,
0.8547509313,
0.0935245231,
0.6777632236,
0.0083978651,
0.4403239489,
-0.7831744552,
0.7011327744,
-0.2634267509,
-0.4514339864,
0.0057576904,
-0.3358009756,
-0.953694284,
0.2520079315,
-0.7001464963,
-0.3625019789,
-0.2464921623,
0.2419644445,
0.0184708256,
0.3677966595,
-0.7804443836,
0.6527107358,
-0.2948938608,
-0.468146503,
-0.1447641551,
-0.4693244994,
0.6011792421,
-0.1945402026,
0.2756491005,
0.0220792722,
0.0890736282,
0.4510566592,
0.0406379066,
0.8930703402,
-0.0037272458,
-0.1514276713,
0.2837889194,
0.30456236,
0.2506420612,
-0.1307548583,
-0.1013322324,
-0.0010390208,
-0.3122870326,
-0.2787058949,
-0.5467579961,
0.6964550614,
-0.6831214428,
-0.5596753955,
-0.1252419502,
-0.8507336974,
-0.0031823062,
0.4350530505,
0.3009737432,
0.7566191554,
-0.1972744465,
0.2347800732,
0.493460536,
-0.6421808004,
0.6504667997,
0.2102493942,
-0.573518157,
-0.6032543182,
0.8721929789,
-0.0583317764,
0.2955719829,
0.6169909239,
-0.12035539,
-0.3843028843,
-0.3632281125,
-0.4658735394,
0.2017365694,
-0.9850683212,
-0.4305343926,
-0.4516102672,
-0.153452158,
-0.5359208584,
-0.2174641639,
-0.4224691689,
-0.2458374053,
-0.3745219111,
0.2125287056,
0.2040378153,
0.6916065812,
0.1125819162,
0.392742008,
-0.855943203,
0.5637148619,
0.3705310524,
0.0512933023,
-0.0734529123,
-0.2674104273,
-0.3203485012,
-0.0384979136,
-0.4708819985,
-0.9086900353,
0.5851438642,
0.6007778645,
0.4285886586,
0.5169041753,
-0.0802340955,
0.5586466789,
-0.7905939221,
0.8167610765,
0.7383441329,
-0.8173335195,
0.5174849033,
-0.3500138521,
0.5723162293,
-0.1217107922,
0.2848673761,
-0.2073987424,
-0.4414779544,
-0.3500813842,
-0.8895447254,
0.4728892446,
0.2665753067,
0.4309560657,
-0.264485389,
0.1834950298,
0.0037694881,
0.2618599236,
-1.1666164398,
0.0645431578,
-0.4607760608,
-0.2645873427,
-0.2743702233,
-0.3870120645,
-0.2145080566,
-0.0315385275,
0.4227391779,
-0.3588959575,
0.5345348716,
-0.0099269934,
-0.3603788614,
-0.027131401,
0.1948901117,
0.6913917065,
0.5286690593,
0.2624124289,
0.4992766678,
-0.123357445,
-0.1291290671,
0.164814502,
-0.2188653499,
-0.0373529792,
0.0411668681,
0.5517930984,
1.1264529228,
0.1822102666,
-0.6821578145,
0.5769654512,
-0.0449203141,
-0.2984948158,
-0.3486071825,
-0.2438963056,
0.2849674523,
0.2464823872,
0.2839079797,
0.2400983274,
-0.0879780203,
-0.4872029722,
0.235063076,
0.5115290284,
-0.0828768015,
-0.3663169444,
0.6246525645,
0.1723295748,
-0.1645567268,
0.7971570492,
-0.0792716742,
-0.4033234119,
0.5461480021,
1.1099977493,
0.6835395098,
-0.1288508624,
0.3950407207,
0.3555596173,
0.4241452515,
0.1326255202,
0.3508920968,
-0.0218981896,
-1.0205070972,
-0.4540806115,
-0.587231338,
0.0292481948,
0.1555036455,
-0.5059438348,
0.2122420818,
-0.3022750318,
-0.4260785282,
-0.2024800032,
-0.5507994294,
-0.795547843,
0.3593887687,
0.5013474226,
0.5962367654,
-0.930332005,
0.9968873858,
0.8669314981,
-0.3955336511,
-0.6055857539,
-0.1506022662,
-0.3265230358,
-0.8933452964,
0.8331410289,
0.3788816929,
-0.3258876204,
0.0865218565,
-0.7248162031,
-0.7409077883,
1.1075607538,
0.7373957634,
-0.4687801301,
0.1793988198,
0.0484402813,
0.3426532149,
-0.8320347071,
0.3025624156,
-0.0660911128,
0.3440593481,
0.3321220279,
-0.6515330076,
0.1906739771,
-0.5516622663,
0.4557392895,
0.1969014108,
-0.3383843303,
0.8958747983,
-0.356122762,
-0.569720149,
0.2537199259,
0.6407356858,
0.2164523453,
0.0767443627,
0.4215598404,
0.6733581424,
0.4195073247,
0.0194240622,
1.0867882967,
-0.3547073305,
0.0653546005,
0.9761233926,
-0.3083656728,
0.9116744399,
0.721789062,
0.5246372819,
0.3179419935,
0.4822246432,
-0.0427217446,
0.9230101705,
-0.0254032593,
-0.3091152012,
-0.6104348898,
-0.3521280587,
-0.2780096829,
0.393768698,
0.4099441767,
-0.6800054312,
-0.3036047816,
0.3226002157,
-0.2007048577,
0.2172341943,
-0.1736763567,
0.6459840536,
0.0295630898,
-0.5902606249,
0.6412357092,
0.1622534394,
0.5436321497,
-0.5724501014,
-0.1205042377,
0.017620692,
-0.0190016795,
0.0376245491,
-0.7511745691,
0.0683744028,
-0.177454114,
-0.246176213,
-0.6137394905,
0.9397003055,
-0.8015812039,
-0.6884450912,
0.2882301807,
0.5044679046,
0.2244906873,
0.3320067823,
-0.4775006473,
0.2197767347,
-0.0621123128,
-0.3512460291,
0.240370661,
0.5841819644,
0.049666401,
0.6650736928,
0.6798318624,
-0.0561163276,
0.3654609323,
0.1142317131,
1.0425715446,
-0.5139725804,
-0.2611346543,
-0.6788190007,
0.6510908604,
0.132202521,
-0.1286001354,
0.3552978039,
0.3460292518,
0.5924031734,
-0.4917788208,
0.8189783096,
-0.0271796566,
-0.2996037304,
-0.969072938,
0.8114201427,
-0.9266932011,
-0.2287676185,
-0.2190803587,
-0.8336130977,
-0.3585901558,
0.4945925474,
-0.0845589042,
-0.0339307375,
0.7560886741,
0.9902120829,
-0.2700529695,
-0.3305465877,
0.6838588119,
0.0446024016,
0.2831438482,
0.5754882693,
1.0259311199,
-0.5465395451,
0.7032507062,
0.0521630086,
-0.1417197883,
0.1739337444,
-1.1398876905,
-0.9873811007,
-0.9384264946,
-0.2900384068,
-0.0651722327,
-0.2826120257,
0.5940987468,
0.9078550935,
-0.4140164852,
-0.2258818597,
0.0945192501,
-0.1530687362,
0.1010696888,
-0.1908752769,
-0.0137930289,
-0.2574741244,
-0.8225609064,
0.4733991027,
0.3855515122,
0.1882331669,
-0.4460222125,
-0.2486775666,
-0.2851922214,
0.2080479562,
0.8100401759,
-0.1123270541,
-0.7386776805,
-0.0470936038,
-0.1132103875,
-0.1260412335,
0.1092346087,
0.7887502909,
-0.536180377,
0.6454795599,
0.3420083225,
0.7289317846,
0.719238162,
-0.5507180691,
0.7410493493,
-0.8254096508,
0.4918197095,
0.138865605,
0.560071826,
0.5803623199,
-0.0520631932,
-0.128349483,
-0.0711787492,
-0.2949949205,
-0.6587295532,
0.7279530764,
-0.8662988544,
-0.2836139798,
1.1119052172,
-0.3360404968,
-0.3481312096,
0.3681500554,
-0.0775841624,
0.3409354687,
-0.3473751247,
0.5721145272,
0.5982051492,
0.2347150892,
-0.6209790707,
-0.2938973904,
0.0242752898,
0.2646327913,
-0.7907626033,
-0.2871088386,
0.8129911423,
-0.036621742,
0.5054273605,
0.7111872435,
-0.1702315509,
0.036417827,
0.1079256609,
0.4601522982,
-0.0748277754,
-0.575392127,
0.0521810353,
0.324457407,
-0.0238495097,
-0.1887426227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17211v1 | Coping with low data availability for social media crisis message categorisation | 2023-05-26T19:08:24 | 2023-05-26T19:08:24 | Congcong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | During crisis situations, social media allows people to quickly share
information, including messages requesting help. This can be valuable to
emergency responders, who need to categorise and prioritise these messages
based on the type of assistance being requested. However, the high volume of
messages makes it difficult to filter and prioritise them without the use of
computational techniques. Fully supervised filtering techniques for crisis
message categorisation typically require a large amount of annotated training
data, but this can be difficult to obtain during an ongoing crisis and is
expensive in terms of time and labour to create.
This thesis focuses on addressing the challenge of low data availability when
categorising crisis messages for emergency response. It first presents domain
adaptation as a solution for this problem, which involves learning a
categorisation model from annotated data from past crisis events (source
domain) and adapting it to categorise messages from an ongoing crisis event
(target domain). In many-to-many adaptation, where the model is trained on
multiple past events and adapted to multiple ongoing events, a multi-task
learning approach is proposed using pre-trained language models. This approach
outperforms baselines and an ensemble approach further improves performance... | [
-0.3472138643,
-0.6026560664,
0.3270992637,
0.8832004666,
-0.2249423862,
0.558709383,
-0.3016855121,
-0.5830391049,
0.3042596877,
0.4345768094,
-0.6688858271,
-0.3184717596,
-0.7714669108,
0.301120162,
-0.3732165694,
1.0359398127,
-0.0977680683,
-0.2477890551,
-0.0427560955,
-0.2711216807,
-0.396450907,
-0.8598521352,
-1.09020257,
-0.084861733,
0.4323833883,
0.8570033908,
0.48360309,
0.1111835316,
0.8390427232,
0.3060414493,
0.2174386382,
0.2172801793,
-1.0981388092,
0.0163329858,
-0.2469750196,
-0.1171288565,
-0.2989295125,
-0.3900347352,
0.3283450902,
0.2403624952,
-0.3129264116,
0.221970588,
0.3126965463,
0.5932452679,
-0.843123734,
0.1086681634,
-0.7537178397,
-0.0503660552,
0.1479646266,
-0.4180841446,
-0.269045949,
-0.168195039,
0.3501423597,
-0.9638434649,
0.3229337335,
0.241094172,
0.4427613318,
0.2720363438,
-0.3360194862,
-0.5686551332,
-1.0333504677,
0.7111125588,
-0.1364698112,
0.1480616778,
0.7923305035,
0.2763460577,
-0.192468226,
-0.6230718493,
-0.3493484855,
0.611278832,
0.126662001,
0.1761588007,
-0.2727567255,
-0.0974206924,
-0.2071397007,
-0.0119980937,
-0.4398956597,
0.242042914,
-0.2861728966,
-0.23379457,
0.7944736481,
0.27526775,
0.0870830044,
-0.3704297245,
-0.4360761344,
-0.0618623756,
-0.312133044,
-0.0953707173,
0.0778266639,
0.5748474002,
-0.3455183208,
0.2150531113,
-0.3056710362,
0.2239329219,
0.1629700214,
-0.2959287763,
0.1805275679,
-0.3230506182,
-0.4384121001,
0.179618597,
0.5779716969,
0.372838378,
0.1012616009,
0.3529052138,
-0.1094599441,
-0.2016934305,
0.6527088284,
-0.6714589,
-0.158619374,
0.0376476124,
-0.6919493675,
-0.0091946507,
-0.2685436308,
-0.9583443403,
-0.8591614962,
0.0268886462,
0.7014187574,
-0.0979973972,
-0.3346288204,
0.2208621949,
0.2262016982,
-0.4645940959,
0.6127665043,
-0.6970029473,
0.3530135751,
0.3374628723,
1.0514758825,
0.1155887991,
0.0038808878,
-0.3513198495,
0.057384368,
-0.013884359,
0.7918095589,
-0.4621330798,
-0.2948296964,
0.342831701,
0.5543736815,
-0.2410957217,
-0.3772693872,
0.8510243893,
-0.6081086993,
-0.2383429706,
-0.2357637435,
-0.1731177866,
-0.2718299329,
0.102610521,
-0.5440302491,
0.8313644528,
0.1696531475,
-0.7901310921,
0.3646171093,
-0.4821389914,
-0.6694464684,
0.039990183,
0.1209162325,
-0.6481393576,
0.1262811869,
0.3479290009,
0.9669944644,
-0.3577640355,
-0.0120114936,
-0.6351812482,
-0.2940259278,
-0.0934111848,
-0.1749212146,
0.2858684659,
0.3255934119,
-0.0003402908,
-0.0069669317,
-0.7170292735,
-0.2707755566,
0.4329867959,
-0.4044215083,
-0.6331429482,
0.4638554454,
0.5013592839,
0.4223342538,
-0.0337545387,
-0.2060632706,
-0.017073011,
0.0312217139,
0.5245344043,
0.6293756366,
0.4576046169,
0.410992831,
-0.5925492048,
0.3054065704,
0.5015220642,
0.3141691983,
-0.013245509,
-0.4471383393,
-0.6454696655,
-0.0565052107,
-0.2191680968,
0.8387132883,
-1.270468235,
0.1736883372,
-0.2735885978,
-0.3599544168,
-0.5559172034,
0.3190757036,
-0.0152962683,
0.113346085,
0.5356432199,
-0.3474549353,
-0.7664777637,
-0.8347601295,
0.1958091408,
-0.3282082677,
0.0689574629,
0.403508842,
0.4159873426,
-0.2217019945,
0.5157012343,
-0.4565033019,
-0.5049046278,
-0.5259626508,
0.2350646257,
-0.0564176925,
0.320723176,
0.3594822884,
-1.0852075815,
-0.3617326617,
0.0352324992,
-0.5500099659,
0.2311642021,
-0.6127029061,
-0.0674680173,
-0.0703326613,
0.0854229629,
-0.219023332,
0.5093786716,
0.3611063361,
0.1233006045,
-0.0544574261,
-0.2162352055,
0.3630232811,
-1.2271319628,
-0.3150589168,
0.2746566534,
-0.3417932391,
-0.9622119069,
-0.7020604014,
-0.0030497715,
-0.2070523202,
-0.5664168596,
0.3557164669,
-0.5985150933,
0.0411727168,
-0.3971931934,
0.2091868818,
-0.40294379,
0.3531437516,
0.1611455083,
0.3730230629,
0.7316840291,
-0.7269613147,
0.2952925861,
0.5024422407,
-0.1972906739,
0.6397112012,
-0.2047118843,
0.1286761016,
-0.5044837594,
0.2058458924,
-1.0185744762,
-0.6242799163,
0.445933789,
-0.2544218302,
0.2055894434,
-0.3177309334,
-0.3347238004,
-0.6005088091,
-0.0443500876,
0.2534232438,
0.1722168475,
-0.5448153615,
0.413812995,
0.6443825364,
-0.3712624609,
-0.418197453,
-0.4038698077,
0.0997748375,
-0.3447422385,
-0.2568339705,
0.1313673705,
0.0904339254,
0.0477529578,
0.1030738056,
-0.2750995457,
-0.5015875101,
0.3801534474,
0.5270816684,
0.0719519258,
-0.0919699073,
0.3441288471,
0.0003963142,
0.1646135151,
-0.2118073106,
-0.0000443638,
0.3590395451,
0.1735834479,
-0.1649232656,
-0.4428519905,
0.7120792866,
0.4465884566,
0.2179410309,
1.1325137615,
0.4472417533,
-0.8123977184,
-0.3347129822,
-0.431923449,
-0.1620908827,
-0.4688845277,
0.2874889672,
0.1056418568,
-0.933945775,
0.4259403348,
-0.1353782862,
-0.0510123819,
0.1316073984,
0.558770895,
-0.0723453164,
0.7471811175,
0.8308658004,
-0.412763387,
0.6361626387,
0.0670059621,
0.3926653564,
-0.1244338527,
0.1462733746,
-0.4250243902,
-0.1325123161,
-0.5225918293,
-0.3610595763,
0.391007632,
0.276385963,
-0.0334580839,
0.2834700942,
-0.5318039656,
0.2182646096,
0.0857502371,
0.4355609715,
0.1525850445,
0.1538197547,
0.7523066401,
0.2396073937,
-0.9301749468,
-0.5115517974,
0.8413287401,
0.3180490732,
0.7752385139,
-0.0011928936,
0.5952186584,
0.4207530022,
0.7505781651,
-0.5328856111,
0.3918260932,
-0.1433142871,
-0.7957540154,
-0.2386772931,
-0.3843044043,
-0.9754382968,
0.1942976117,
-0.6604317427,
-0.6638754606,
0.345105499,
0.0316472463,
-0.7340788245,
0.1132313386,
-0.8102616072,
0.684250176,
-0.0639040694,
-0.0666271821,
-0.3028095663,
-0.7364352345,
0.2266694605,
-0.6812756658,
0.5754439235,
-0.2471897006,
0.1253353804,
0.8079212308,
-0.0639491677,
1.2420035601,
-0.0204004683,
0.285037607,
0.6092502475,
-0.3838487864,
0.6053590775,
0.1381434351,
0.0442037843,
-0.1909697056,
0.1630300432,
-0.6587269902,
-0.3591516316,
0.4928736389,
-0.912836194,
-0.3859300613,
-0.072409302,
-0.3099515736,
-0.3301269114,
-0.007360741,
0.2864126563,
0.3632280827,
-0.0800092295,
0.2068174034,
0.3665348887,
-0.4142632782,
0.718282342,
0.54409343,
0.1521636993,
-0.4128858447,
0.9350312948,
0.2955856025,
0.0873927101,
0.3745545149,
-0.1846624464,
-0.0383314937,
-0.5691511035,
-0.1307594329,
-0.0053028339,
-0.8140258789,
-0.4123750329,
-0.8040990829,
-0.3159724474,
-0.3530340195,
-0.1609903127,
-0.227703318,
-0.1995888799,
-0.7325464487,
-0.0909112915,
0.6067699194,
0.7901607752,
-0.1596313715,
0.713445127,
-1.0109444857,
0.4329711795,
-0.0635709763,
0.3063359857,
0.1802888364,
-0.2692095339,
-0.4958527088,
-0.1754501909,
-0.4536372721,
-1.0388913155,
0.1632979065,
0.5273455977,
0.2168041319,
0.3449374735,
0.6858349442,
0.8392230868,
-0.4952177107,
0.4637262821,
0.2769989073,
-0.6981230974,
0.6026394963,
-0.2707466483,
-0.2951467335,
0.7840721011,
0.9933817387,
-0.7477692366,
-0.2026641667,
-0.448854804,
-0.8849241734,
0.7087485194,
0.3096038103,
0.3308415711,
-0.1774371564,
0.3872157335,
-0.1203482971,
0.2146483064,
-0.3734346628,
-0.3553562462,
-0.3493392169,
-0.2396732867,
-0.2001925707,
-0.2789550424,
0.0514752977,
-0.125122413,
0.6431960464,
-0.0725974292,
0.3774246573,
0.1571843773,
-0.1137967929,
-0.3860451877,
0.4572534561,
0.6696895957,
0.5704520345,
-0.0115002766,
0.0325820521,
0.2786383331,
-0.7071431279,
0.4594826102,
0.0640449971,
0.2972396016,
-0.10334903,
0.417250216,
0.8570408821,
0.3862124383,
-0.527202487,
0.6297439337,
-0.0638209209,
-0.1690232158,
-0.2084656358,
-0.0538767315,
-0.0409256294,
0.3602057695,
0.708750248,
-0.0601418614,
-0.0014925799,
-0.5993899703,
0.3659734428,
0.0192684885,
-0.0853029266,
-0.4025621414,
0.3933342099,
0.2937066555,
-0.3533346057,
0.2352882177,
-0.2577291727,
-0.3554395735,
0.3891146183,
0.6079890132,
0.8375049233,
-0.7160291076,
0.5707862973,
0.1871919483,
0.4585035741,
-0.4794078171,
0.472623378,
0.1966567934,
-0.8419526815,
-0.3394142985,
-0.4913510382,
-0.474432379,
0.438829273,
-0.8654336929,
0.0346550457,
-0.7265928984,
-0.5540201664,
0.0235974211,
-0.1873771548,
-0.9932289124,
0.3536221385,
-0.0290756188,
0.6703306437,
-1.3073146343,
0.6349779367,
0.9056866169,
-0.0337522253,
-0.6087121367,
-0.060677588,
0.1295450181,
-0.662425518,
0.2977931798,
0.1929600537,
0.4110034108,
-0.0685073957,
-0.4687849283,
-0.9990912676,
0.6882534027,
0.0105265416,
-0.7977976799,
0.0826073736,
0.123105146,
0.8534330726,
-0.5277652144,
-0.2336425483,
0.4637829959,
0.2754285038,
0.1120242625,
-0.9546177387,
-0.0325638354,
-0.0280785393,
-0.2317978293,
0.2668348849,
-0.6777613163,
0.3193154335,
-0.0549037978,
-0.5222969651,
-0.2657212019,
0.5427322984,
-0.236262545,
0.7365633845,
0.5226264,
0.1823526919,
0.7425298095,
0.0290265791,
0.833407104,
0.0395289995,
0.5702255368,
1.1513453722,
-0.5136578083,
0.9232563376,
0.1140409037,
0.0186785962,
0.0280566085,
1.043648243,
0.1913847774,
0.6519782543,
0.0259071011,
-0.4594389498,
-0.4916342199,
-0.3365620971,
0.0323585346,
0.1719172448,
0.5531346798,
-0.2931849062,
-0.4004132152,
0.5583896637,
-0.302287221,
-0.2654493153,
-0.6027364731,
0.8671302795,
0.2021826804,
-0.1327966005,
0.6518817544,
-0.1370036453,
0.2497333437,
-0.0321884044,
0.2499488145,
0.0086225234,
0.179094553,
-0.4317037463,
-0.651516974,
0.5241135359,
-0.0342238732,
-0.3819329143,
-0.1074085459,
1.0560933352,
-0.3203437626,
-0.5439994335,
0.4811242521,
0.7552191615,
0.084784098,
-0.0223943107,
-0.7620162964,
0.242871359,
-0.306473881,
-0.3430353403,
0.3719082475,
0.4339798391,
-0.2602519989,
0.8687348366,
0.3384999037,
0.0028278937,
-0.0848675445,
-0.0183441509,
0.9512333274,
-0.427131325,
-0.5723061562,
-0.7028048635,
0.2428100556,
-0.0140560549,
-0.1747242361,
0.5615753531,
0.2591500878,
0.6238235831,
0.0465488695,
0.8807391524,
0.0090429131,
0.7044558525,
-0.1434303373,
0.4706385136,
-0.6146416068,
0.0140641928,
-0.4991604686,
-0.6911063194,
-0.2673428953,
0.5020134449,
-0.3469214737,
-0.3484835923,
0.4445974529,
0.5423142314,
-0.1960864067,
0.3183546066,
0.1956671029,
0.0542060919,
0.0786807388,
0.764487803,
1.0773009062,
-0.2201573849,
0.5474205017,
-0.1858956665,
-0.2049895078,
-0.4177019298,
-0.7818321586,
-1.1515856981,
-0.8655498028,
-0.2779197693,
-0.2393839061,
0.0608685054,
1.1729114056,
0.8958251476,
-0.8720489144,
0.1150356084,
0.3545025885,
0.3557296991,
-0.1338866204,
-0.1992243379,
0.1965588331,
-0.1307567209,
-0.1149344891,
0.4097148776,
0.4095508754,
0.2045981139,
0.228380084,
0.3425055742,
-0.1377430111,
0.0995907038,
0.7965638638,
0.3069139421,
-0.2329993993,
-0.5534459352,
-0.239445731,
-0.0430253074,
0.2660760283,
0.8247201443,
-0.3986765444,
-0.0053444132,
0.2066564858,
1.215231657,
0.306265831,
0.2533787787,
-0.0091136238,
-0.8466926813,
0.0101257432,
0.0553830974,
0.1022091135,
0.5914621949,
-0.7559223771,
0.5170897245,
0.2691796422,
-0.5757299066,
-0.8872610331,
-0.1013123021,
-0.8536069989,
-0.2049295604,
1.0853639841,
-0.0904963762,
-0.0123729305,
-0.6582887173,
-0.1054028049,
0.2026000172,
-0.5947281122,
0.8834034204,
0.9093348384,
0.0282547381,
-0.398430407,
-0.8109408617,
0.4515037239,
0.1242628247,
-1.08504498,
0.1377839595,
0.2091525793,
0.3648847044,
0.2749709189,
0.8027001619,
0.6133395433,
0.1937722266,
-0.4618096948,
-0.270472914,
0.4244444668,
-0.5570086837,
-0.4142968655,
0.4588007033,
-0.4119131267,
-0.2396587729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17202v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17202v1 | BIG-C: a Multimodal Multi-Purpose Dataset for Bemba | 2023-05-26T18:49:55 | 2023-05-26T18:49:55 | Claytone Sikasote, Eunice Mukonde, Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present BIG-C (Bemba Image Grounded Conversations), a large multimodal
dataset for Bemba. While Bemba is the most populous language of Zambia, it
exhibits a dearth of resources which render the development of language
technologies or language processing research almost impossible. The dataset is
comprised of multi-turn dialogues between Bemba speakers based on images,
transcribed and translated into English. There are more than 92,000
utterances/sentences, amounting to more than 180 hours of audio data with
corresponding transcriptions and English translations. We also provide
baselines on speech recognition (ASR), machine translation (MT) and speech
translation (ST) tasks, and sketch out other potential future multimodal uses
of our dataset. We hope that by making the dataset available to the research
community, this work will foster research and encourage collaboration across
the language, speech, and vision communities especially for languages outside
the "traditionally" used high-resourced ones. All data and code are publicly
available: https://github.com/csikasote/bigc. | [
-0.5783637166,
-0.8450930715,
0.3915369511,
0.8410828114,
-0.4374361038,
0.0952733606,
-0.9178029299,
-0.5073968768,
0.5626790524,
0.4477639794,
-0.5632972121,
-0.6055439115,
-0.7804295421,
0.0348273441,
-0.4140152037,
0.4427630901,
0.2981776297,
0.1358644515,
0.1462603062,
-0.420007199,
-0.5645506382,
-0.5196951032,
-0.4779963791,
0.0311861336,
0.7441982627,
0.842900455,
0.9684696198,
0.1734567285,
0.2044151127,
0.2651037574,
-0.0211858619,
0.185845241,
-0.5933890939,
-0.0373642631,
-0.0925848261,
-0.0673600733,
-0.0409680344,
-0.163522929,
0.6308431029,
1.0211759806,
-0.1717597693,
0.1017279848,
-0.0893827006,
0.8029009104,
-0.9350172281,
0.6349909902,
-0.4379426837,
-0.1888395101,
-0.3151355982,
0.1033140346,
-0.526255846,
-0.5365939736,
-0.0706434324,
-0.4246976376,
-0.2814742625,
-0.0886106864,
0.8654283881,
0.2505428195,
-0.7477116585,
-0.6056594253,
-0.6198545694,
0.7285066843,
-0.3017647266,
0.5272994637,
0.6287173629,
0.5783572793,
-0.1913603097,
-0.5345879793,
-1.0506623983,
-0.1126511917,
0.1373076737,
0.2441932559,
-0.1526720077,
-0.1185401604,
0.2183616459,
0.2937508225,
-0.3239537776,
0.2232490927,
-0.6331672668,
-0.2159472555,
0.6423783302,
0.0195399951,
0.2739934623,
-0.3926532865,
-0.0779511034,
-0.1103164703,
-0.8408985138,
0.1057635173,
0.296472609,
0.4007205665,
-0.2174966335,
0.7865399122,
-0.1207873225,
0.8681595325,
-0.2038298398,
-0.1626235545,
0.518497467,
-0.6888290048,
-0.2401326001,
0.2908730507,
1.0995668173,
0.6126567125,
0.331063807,
0.1385309994,
0.3239501119,
-0.1539861709,
0.1472135931,
-0.875171721,
-0.187097162,
0.0776329488,
-0.63699615,
0.066601105,
0.0490379743,
-1.1005977392,
-0.2998866737,
-0.659889698,
0.0239823535,
-0.6901366711,
-0.3535043001,
-0.0821671709,
0.2248912156,
0.3709839582,
0.3711152077,
-1.0051985979,
-0.0492307097,
0.1520738751,
0.8386160731,
0.3181417584,
-0.3786072731,
-0.2223820537,
0.2461205423,
-0.6611253023,
0.4620366991,
-0.857444644,
-0.6035767198,
0.1236478165,
0.332776159,
-0.0452139899,
-0.606359899,
0.563113153,
-0.1907845438,
-0.1031851247,
-0.5985018611,
0.0953896269,
-0.2333714962,
0.1248819008,
-0.8283430934,
0.7676459551,
0.1451264471,
-0.303407222,
0.5292458534,
-0.6408862472,
-0.8360233307,
-0.0943639576,
-0.3729722202,
-0.267803967,
-0.0812380612,
0.4477095306,
0.590498805,
-0.6509671211,
0.5143852234,
-0.3637737632,
-0.1727278829,
0.5546607971,
-0.1918898076,
0.7553087473,
0.4880750477,
-0.2523851395,
-0.0665242821,
-1.0840258598,
-0.0168095473,
-0.0715172514,
-0.4310531318,
-0.0820706934,
0.0349048376,
0.5049257874,
0.4782182574,
0.2788511515,
-0.921559453,
0.0530256405,
0.1074969172,
0.7186667919,
0.4530595243,
-0.3738001287,
0.1220890358,
0.149287641,
0.2399258912,
0.4593446255,
0.2616906464,
-0.4874703288,
-0.4007739723,
-0.6177778244,
-0.6573008299,
0.3904207647,
0.3191168606,
-0.8417096734,
0.7021346092,
-0.4489426613,
-0.5576242208,
-0.5981611013,
0.1166482121,
0.2121912986,
0.3585427999,
0.3986566365,
-0.209467113,
-0.7480050921,
-1.4140762091,
0.7899218202,
-0.040253453,
0.0101309353,
0.5290958881,
0.3380696177,
-0.4957152009,
0.8235381246,
-0.5961028934,
-0.478854537,
-0.258405745,
-0.0577714555,
0.2571794093,
0.4833516777,
0.8463971019,
-0.9907947183,
-0.4685877562,
0.0966038182,
-0.9983702898,
0.1254068911,
-0.0794164389,
-0.0967333764,
0.0680313185,
0.749689877,
-0.5208730102,
0.2451464683,
0.868822813,
0.0171098374,
0.2011828274,
-0.0169175882,
0.611233294,
-1.3268682957,
0.3753268719,
-0.2263657749,
0.1408529431,
-0.3569965363,
-0.2596004009,
0.2182413638,
-0.6185076237,
-0.2359323204,
-0.0644913614,
-0.464777112,
-0.2164305001,
-0.0138379792,
0.0948739797,
-0.1470802277,
0.4727609158,
0.013774409,
0.8823466301,
0.9723899364,
-0.5802493095,
0.7108151913,
0.7541878819,
-0.6913745999,
0.8624489307,
-0.5167191029,
0.1344965994,
-0.0267656296,
0.2743718028,
-0.9987555742,
-0.6622323394,
0.1637607813,
-0.4310878515,
0.4173717201,
-0.1973266304,
-0.7872489095,
-0.4673319161,
-0.1741504222,
0.1780865192,
0.0185658112,
-0.7402207851,
0.4617622197,
0.7982465029,
-0.6438879967,
-0.6572700143,
-0.9748362899,
0.7603366971,
0.2378090769,
-0.9014303684,
-0.109028168,
-0.0497965775,
0.2343480885,
-0.1280644238,
0.2991115153,
-0.4012699425,
-0.1156871989,
0.496433109,
0.1968333423,
-0.3565773964,
-0.0109741753,
0.1684515923,
0.0835952163,
-0.0664856806,
-0.0667864829,
0.6725047827,
0.0615033209,
-0.3077725172,
-0.1584563553,
0.7149880528,
0.8889082074,
-0.1025161892,
1.0819603205,
0.4812082052,
-0.4094375074,
0.4130598009,
-0.5720537901,
0.5963183641,
-0.4050701559,
0.3186228275,
-0.4220771492,
-0.9750263691,
0.579023838,
-0.0687414631,
-0.1003876477,
-0.0559417121,
0.9358021617,
-0.1248264536,
0.5936651826,
0.3554174602,
-0.3097516,
0.3805259466,
-0.091157414,
0.4345018566,
-0.7557427287,
-0.6340793967,
-0.5930396318,
-0.4810826182,
-0.2901784182,
-0.3495495915,
0.1623781323,
-0.1009239182,
0.2294334024,
0.4594618082,
-0.1853129864,
0.456998378,
0.3930374682,
0.2371527702,
-0.0706455335,
-0.2947616279,
0.1044012234,
-0.1587315649,
-0.3910644948,
-0.4622658491,
1.2156111002,
0.0173147451,
0.8458015919,
0.4330866635,
0.1912308335,
-0.069323808,
0.0072944956,
-0.8298271894,
0.5903761983,
-0.225083679,
-0.5392606854,
-0.3959124684,
-0.3375436068,
-1.1810264587,
0.1187084913,
-0.2295417041,
-0.4349828064,
0.4528088272,
0.1915847063,
-0.1569519937,
0.0713652596,
-0.9162192941,
0.7545589209,
-0.0782344565,
-0.1348768771,
-0.3670822382,
-0.9275096655,
0.3873907626,
-0.3563328087,
0.2769825459,
0.0534926541,
0.2991613448,
0.4994468093,
-0.3072231114,
0.6115583777,
-0.2271545082,
-0.0815348327,
0.4426776469,
-0.3560345769,
0.0582824834,
0.0806029215,
-0.1178065464,
0.2741186321,
-0.1090212017,
-0.6364806294,
-0.3321324289,
0.718411088,
-0.7344492078,
-0.0450684652,
-0.0954241529,
-0.3556487262,
-0.2690804601,
0.1606481969,
0.1824533343,
0.6021376848,
-0.5250272155,
0.9579009414,
0.4748990536,
-0.6817526817,
0.3943635225,
0.3824401796,
-0.2323265821,
-0.5921192765,
0.9334890246,
0.3442831933,
0.1288978308,
0.1139915213,
-0.0595384017,
-0.2831627727,
-0.5867626071,
-0.6179149151,
0.0546732768,
-0.7783388495,
-0.2052675933,
-0.7696740031,
-0.0798127502,
-0.6180904508,
-0.2349480391,
-0.4021158516,
-0.2606820464,
-0.1499067098,
-0.2132039815,
0.1029810756,
0.5710096359,
-0.3719148636,
0.4502446055,
-0.6368447542,
0.4671121538,
0.4119440615,
0.2609470189,
-0.1795659363,
-0.1386318356,
-0.4501216114,
0.2472771555,
-0.2004074901,
-0.5961812139,
0.3134070337,
0.375220418,
0.4537964463,
0.412458092,
-0.134574607,
0.8127718568,
-0.454631865,
0.8969936371,
0.689727664,
-0.9294980764,
0.7140385509,
-0.2794610262,
0.3303634822,
0.9002963901,
0.4597188234,
-0.609855175,
-0.2135861814,
-0.2581729591,
-0.8567420244,
0.8166852593,
0.2480963618,
0.1753023714,
-0.1867898703,
-0.2079096138,
0.1301102489,
0.5702030659,
-0.4400445223,
-0.1228706092,
-0.7399168015,
-0.2331898808,
-0.3056165874,
-0.4213518202,
-0.1114246771,
-0.1549090892,
0.2956675887,
-0.3779757023,
0.3217191994,
-0.0578031614,
-0.4904814363,
-0.1229345575,
0.4607875049,
0.5795212388,
0.8537317514,
-0.1072368696,
-0.010549983,
-0.0153284939,
-0.7633937001,
-0.0579775199,
0.0939111337,
0.0291422345,
0.0111701814,
0.2010496557,
0.8244270682,
0.6256037951,
-0.7985907197,
0.6058353186,
-0.0543965809,
-0.2609984577,
-0.4960672855,
-0.2339165062,
0.2269077599,
0.0499506779,
0.4152268469,
0.0526490919,
0.0828071386,
-0.9416401982,
0.0835987926,
0.1124706417,
-0.3197571635,
-0.2295235693,
0.3290753067,
0.4648966789,
0.21277906,
0.8396556973,
0.2000264823,
-0.3720784783,
0.5364409089,
0.290677011,
0.2570716143,
-0.1120501757,
0.2515421808,
0.5751307607,
0.450127691,
0.1004935429,
0.4096820951,
-0.0056356564,
-0.6800024509,
-0.5578080416,
-0.6107751727,
-0.5626314282,
0.2324513495,
-0.8685395718,
0.3691097796,
-0.6480981112,
-0.0646522641,
0.3238149881,
-0.3208829761,
-0.5961175561,
0.1066813469,
0.4139334857,
0.8414050937,
-0.8277668357,
1.0536576509,
0.4804361463,
-0.5169035792,
-0.6815520525,
-0.3671560287,
-0.0013617015,
-0.7276186943,
1.0052928925,
0.2954013348,
-0.0746793374,
-0.0976237059,
-1.0550103188,
-0.7018405199,
1.1002334356,
0.7323255539,
-0.7715342641,
0.3276460767,
0.1549787372,
0.408310622,
-0.3176107407,
-0.0431371033,
0.4951041937,
0.8515077829,
0.4392032623,
-1.0910612345,
-0.2635888755,
-0.2696092427,
-0.1187434345,
0.234665513,
-1.1048015356,
0.5301033854,
-0.1724784374,
-0.2316933274,
0.0025395756,
0.7276188135,
0.0560617335,
0.241830647,
0.5466202497,
0.3496802151,
0.8468149304,
-0.2846947312,
0.7588437796,
-0.0808024853,
0.1905602962,
0.95200634,
-0.6080030799,
0.549489975,
0.3874411285,
-0.1416518539,
0.2400355339,
0.5320143104,
-0.206866771,
0.553927362,
0.1251667589,
-0.2764047384,
-0.3232484162,
-0.2754779458,
-0.3630303741,
0.7316766381,
0.7594320178,
-0.0999269336,
0.0490521677,
0.4396182001,
0.1646709293,
0.1509474665,
-0.2610116005,
0.5077903867,
-0.0079090577,
-0.5548551679,
0.3888683319,
-0.3016999662,
0.6803526878,
-0.8099006414,
0.0093188919,
0.0108477864,
0.0227441899,
-0.2505086958,
-1.077472806,
0.3976349235,
-0.1105041504,
-0.2160717398,
-0.136518538,
0.443230927,
-0.6563150883,
-0.3722345531,
0.399135977,
0.151912868,
0.2326488197,
0.1454369575,
-0.4947838187,
0.4034530222,
0.0866119489,
0.1117792055,
0.3349938095,
0.6900972724,
0.0317237563,
0.7549690008,
0.727819562,
0.0756225735,
0.2965379059,
0.3102975786,
1.1897443533,
-0.7828373313,
-0.3641364872,
-0.612218976,
0.1866621971,
-0.3233199418,
-0.4099750519,
0.4179528058,
0.8068526387,
0.6892880201,
-0.1249622777,
0.9142113924,
-0.5936155319,
0.2134161144,
-0.8233683109,
0.6276650429,
-0.2179561257,
-0.3399796784,
-0.4851101339,
-0.8926140666,
-0.1500993222,
0.7941438556,
0.1103405729,
-0.2267332524,
0.7138426304,
0.8288202286,
-0.1522209793,
0.3820053041,
0.6371263862,
0.3146016598,
0.4083376229,
0.586727798,
0.9602477551,
-0.2743840814,
0.8722582459,
-0.0759811848,
-0.3035986722,
-0.2288106084,
-0.7058414817,
-0.9042848349,
-0.8970487714,
-0.1483853608,
-0.294215709,
-0.0414820388,
1.0364595652,
0.7264723182,
-0.9712817669,
-0.1858836263,
0.6332518458,
-0.293418169,
0.1036571413,
-0.1043633446,
0.2728752792,
-0.1032288671,
-0.7397708297,
0.6193168163,
0.5813772082,
-0.1558506489,
-0.2307770401,
-0.0249564741,
-0.6851066351,
-0.3767852187,
1.0774718523,
0.3934569061,
-0.4122982919,
-0.5094534755,
0.0053979233,
-0.0512906834,
0.1380810887,
1.0564922094,
-0.4445892274,
0.5713445544,
-0.0442377776,
0.7227420807,
0.6109411716,
-0.3367288709,
0.7109795809,
-0.8896492124,
0.6015037298,
-0.0681510121,
0.6512701511,
0.5792133808,
-0.1238023415,
0.7130470276,
0.1354125142,
-0.4322818518,
-0.7113529444,
0.176625222,
-1.512997508,
-0.1005235985,
1.1016845703,
-0.3464961648,
-0.1215341315,
-0.4773778021,
-0.5831286907,
0.2741364241,
-0.6250826716,
0.5183256269,
1.1304358244,
0.2956561446,
-0.4064354599,
-0.4213670194,
-0.107135281,
0.0128414044,
-0.9404127598,
0.3166865408,
1.0036456585,
-0.0681483373,
0.5268576145,
0.6662877798,
-0.3354452848,
0.3707352877,
-0.1372049153,
0.0814796239,
-0.1044462249,
-0.3196649253,
-0.1229535118,
0.1227468327,
-0.1452434361,
-0.2709057629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.19280v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.19280v1 | Large language models improve Alzheimer's disease diagnosis using multi-modality data | 2023-05-26T18:42:19 | 2023-05-26T18:42:19 | Yingjie Feng, Jun Wang, Xianfeng Gu, Xiaoyin Xu, Min Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | In diagnosing challenging conditions such as Alzheimer's disease (AD),
imaging is an important reference. Non-imaging patient data such as patient
information, genetic data, medication information, cognitive and memory tests
also play a very important role in diagnosis. Effect. However, limited by the
ability of artificial intelligence models to mine such information, most of the
existing models only use multi-modal image data, and cannot make full use of
non-image data. We use a currently very popular pre-trained large language
model (LLM) to enhance the model's ability to utilize non-image data, and
achieved SOTA results on the ADNI dataset. | [
-0.2513502538,
-0.8601625562,
0.8409154415,
-0.1688066423,
-0.2850558758,
-0.4482741952,
-0.2796905041,
-0.8712381721,
0.4098542035,
0.5847438574,
-0.3748378456,
-0.4884305,
-0.8403705359,
0.0053398921,
-0.1984671354,
0.8943303823,
-0.0236303713,
0.8379516602,
-0.1979437619,
-0.2865198553,
-0.2657824457,
-0.3346042931,
-1.326159358,
-0.4228206575,
0.3787147105,
0.3949064314,
0.7795262337,
0.551812768,
0.5775093436,
0.2755042315,
-0.0963926017,
0.2393496633,
-0.184100166,
0.0392635763,
0.131366387,
-0.3936066926,
-0.9112740159,
-0.0305078551,
0.5133903623,
0.7744832039,
0.1172691509,
-0.0033695714,
-0.3772188425,
0.4534832239,
-0.1635199189,
0.3566973805,
-0.1291072518,
0.0498632155,
-0.2537035346,
-0.163994059,
-0.3076406121,
-0.1758260429,
0.1763634235,
-0.778486371,
-0.0390738212,
0.0756839514,
0.8541246653,
0.1705702543,
-0.7027221918,
-0.4029482603,
-0.8708049059,
0.694154501,
-0.7621186376,
0.3918865323,
0.7150272727,
0.1429537535,
-0.3386782706,
-0.3677191734,
-0.3634403348,
-0.6630362868,
0.2253359854,
-0.1078684777,
-0.1176538914,
0.1585274488,
0.2361059189,
0.4578525424,
-0.6076208353,
0.3538925946,
-0.5281817913,
-0.3619244397,
0.5617054105,
0.2654971778,
0.6992515922,
-0.0094395196,
-0.3663876057,
0.0773450136,
-0.6614028811,
-0.3914063275,
-0.0591315664,
0.19120498,
0.0878497884,
0.6041318178,
-0.0498669632,
0.8214809895,
-0.160028398,
-0.3251078427,
0.4434739649,
-0.2412658185,
-0.1762283444,
0.2808406651,
0.6101280451,
0.3404149115,
-0.0607531928,
0.0873899534,
-0.171998471,
0.2543378472,
-0.3990049064,
-0.7830512524,
-0.2826597095,
0.148300156,
-0.7359178066,
0.2204849571,
-0.3872802258,
-0.513745904,
-0.5676524639,
-0.2737956941,
0.5211288333,
-0.687261939,
-0.4190251827,
0.2418129146,
0.0291807037,
-0.1064865738,
0.3075572848,
-0.5550337434,
0.1269928664,
0.1409516931,
0.5879741907,
0.0092576742,
-0.1205189675,
-0.720728457,
0.2480863184,
-0.4320839345,
0.9468190074,
-0.6605327129,
-0.117399253,
-0.4476984441,
-0.0999548063,
-0.2093545794,
-0.7033473849,
0.3225788176,
-0.5599535704,
0.0862880051,
-0.1782233268,
-0.434935689,
-0.4330711067,
0.0492962226,
-1.1648826599,
0.7935557365,
0.1408652812,
-0.3295751512,
0.5671040416,
-0.7636600137,
-0.6308432221,
0.0943794176,
-0.2052513361,
-0.4562384784,
0.3565761149,
0.2368391007,
0.4154129922,
-0.5506653786,
0.530335784,
-0.2157231718,
-0.0190774128,
0.0542531125,
-0.3443253636,
0.380399406,
0.2660298944,
0.0892782211,
0.155309841,
-0.6730417609,
-0.2395783961,
0.3001849651,
-0.5555930734,
-0.5745067,
-0.0563373081,
-0.0558657609,
0.3008399904,
0.4946694076,
-0.5921658874,
0.3865043223,
-0.1594623178,
0.3058569133,
0.4544222951,
-0.1133703366,
0.1776019931,
-0.4919880033,
0.572437644,
0.5254218578,
0.1798639148,
-0.2535513937,
-0.8472108245,
-0.5387278795,
-0.4828484356,
0.3885527849,
0.6191677451,
-0.6036890149,
0.1908425242,
-0.3196485043,
-0.2373973876,
-0.6545620561,
0.1036347821,
0.3301391304,
0.4213562012,
0.3646295071,
-0.4448382854,
-0.5501570106,
-0.8119972348,
0.1666318625,
0.1436298341,
0.0577005446,
0.7164599895,
0.183961153,
-0.6929374337,
0.236163646,
-0.5060144663,
-0.7928857803,
-0.4601482451,
0.3426749408,
0.0521707349,
0.2987219691,
0.3519144952,
-0.6382048726,
-0.0821411163,
0.1112487391,
-0.8343327045,
0.1032671481,
-0.049353525,
0.1180528626,
0.2450073808,
0.7571768165,
-0.6695036888,
0.5715022087,
0.7719465494,
-0.610963285,
0.2255363017,
-0.6320789456,
0.211903438,
-1.1685950756,
-0.0985515416,
0.1767041534,
-0.3981445134,
-0.3627197444,
-0.2474844903,
-0.1783325821,
-0.3800448775,
-0.0884747729,
0.392326951,
-0.5896290541,
-0.1263716966,
-0.2380372584,
-0.0864002109,
0.116767481,
-0.0278354902,
0.2047617286,
0.6720125079,
1.044570446,
-0.8110540509,
0.3216636479,
0.1072663963,
-0.4762205184,
0.2160145938,
-0.548129797,
-0.082194075,
-0.3066597879,
0.2600283027,
-1.0037600994,
-0.168836683,
-0.0950809121,
-0.2836117744,
0.485981375,
0.1668041497,
-0.5454731584,
-0.107930176,
-0.1091103181,
0.8031341434,
0.0950793102,
-0.317579478,
1.0350338221,
0.598359406,
-0.2078652978,
-0.1533124298,
-0.8632778525,
0.2387879342,
-0.1622535437,
-0.6772928834,
0.3184189796,
-0.1856989712,
0.0738437176,
0.0976868421,
0.2126128972,
-0.3214533329,
0.069967635,
0.0120974332,
0.4125998914,
-0.6400715113,
0.4994993508,
-0.3303003609,
-0.2595286965,
-0.1910693347,
0.1386717558,
0.8554027081,
0.0125941997,
-0.3216673136,
-0.6144108176,
0.6773484349,
0.9107621908,
-0.2657071352,
0.7142625451,
0.2441719919,
-0.4311797619,
0.1868624538,
-0.3078461885,
-0.2401343435,
-0.3747602105,
0.6140591502,
-0.2455625534,
-0.6302632093,
0.6100324988,
-0.4072103798,
-0.3468824029,
0.3265035152,
0.4123856425,
0.1685111225,
1.5247887373,
0.8022694588,
-0.273547858,
0.5545423627,
-0.1711960733,
0.3446926475,
-1.108356595,
-0.2052625716,
-0.0543445386,
-0.1193509549,
-0.1987916231,
-0.3421245515,
0.4924751222,
-0.2232708931,
0.0112641538,
-0.1128400564,
-0.2171967477,
0.229690671,
0.2563970089,
0.5093488693,
0.2924095094,
-0.1167799234,
-0.0400786437,
-0.0234742109,
-0.6700310111,
-0.4674654603,
1.4065649509,
0.306877166,
0.8223183751,
0.1422294825,
0.2555544376,
0.1902899444,
0.2448040843,
-1.1750822067,
0.5818402767,
-0.6147460938,
-0.6382800341,
-0.1760948002,
-0.4696102738,
-1.3176859617,
-0.1813711524,
-0.1378412396,
-0.3987858891,
0.113574259,
0.1455513984,
-0.5916725993,
0.3113610744,
-0.738795042,
0.7956912518,
-0.5294693112,
0.2874975502,
-0.2868672609,
-0.4144159257,
0.4389181733,
-0.1383299083,
0.4138166606,
-0.2032400966,
-0.0846851841,
1.0219768286,
-0.1288814098,
0.7072802782,
-0.0405802876,
-0.0601355992,
-0.1002126038,
0.1160986051,
0.1624791324,
-0.101614438,
-0.1123662442,
0.1761054248,
-0.234220311,
-0.2253938019,
-0.4110768437,
0.8168050647,
-0.8611869216,
-0.4023662806,
-0.4770205617,
-0.8180177808,
-0.3599704206,
0.1940254569,
0.1154171303,
0.7255074382,
-0.0466712862,
0.0547138043,
0.9683958292,
-0.2405140996,
0.2234134525,
0.5290748477,
-0.1576832384,
-0.056716051,
0.8042176962,
0.2848340869,
0.2248536199,
-0.0208053794,
0.4039533138,
-0.1208875105,
-0.6307801604,
-0.3978125751,
0.3939759433,
-0.7482787371,
-0.2800112367,
-0.5356773138,
-0.2627735734,
-0.4087321162,
0.3026950955,
-0.3351823688,
-0.248806417,
-0.5517693758,
-0.0137647865,
0.786055088,
0.9191839695,
-0.0904569551,
0.3831356168,
-0.7817493677,
0.6769792438,
0.112268731,
0.3226879537,
0.0615153722,
-0.4758877754,
-0.2318787128,
0.023123797,
0.173770383,
-0.8630375862,
0.3585747182,
0.6723759174,
0.6522935033,
0.6370600462,
-0.2568972111,
0.8452596068,
-0.3338564336,
0.6084800959,
0.1981946379,
-0.6635254025,
0.6601592302,
-0.1682345569,
0.310092777,
0.3784513474,
0.5164581537,
-0.3240194917,
-0.0186959002,
-0.5050189495,
-1.0641268492,
0.7830430269,
-0.4201094806,
-0.0319039412,
-0.0181695595,
0.4219124615,
0.0413605869,
-0.2268126011,
-0.7215857506,
-0.142739445,
0.1371302605,
-0.3770653605,
-0.3478867412,
-0.3810353577,
-0.152525574,
-0.5036625266,
0.5602967739,
0.0365202054,
0.4597397745,
0.2646578252,
-0.194495976,
-0.3380811214,
0.0291790254,
0.6397845149,
0.6110544801,
0.11431548,
0.2399701625,
0.2403041869,
-0.7422424555,
-0.016821472,
0.0007185655,
-0.0038746283,
-0.1546034515,
0.3687764704,
0.7685540915,
-0.0242455769,
-0.8903084397,
0.6396380663,
-0.2557604313,
-0.0220694374,
-0.371881634,
-0.0257509649,
0.1221552566,
0.2702043355,
0.2537245452,
0.3538582027,
0.2114333361,
-0.7119246125,
0.3167647421,
0.6155432463,
-0.3269976377,
-0.3093155622,
0.4353116155,
-0.1029378474,
-0.21458821,
0.9219938517,
0.0306112617,
-0.2602422237,
0.6599906683,
0.7502605915,
0.2122835964,
-0.4650289416,
0.0328060575,
0.0411026776,
0.2279840112,
-0.3834637403,
0.708335638,
0.3359647393,
-0.815964818,
-0.6552876234,
-0.3142758906,
0.1022247747,
0.7780917287,
-0.7018378973,
0.3209377229,
-0.6264594793,
-0.42774719,
0.1805886775,
-0.066921331,
-0.5615327358,
0.4861934781,
0.3511609733,
0.767526865,
-1.2278453112,
1.0104846954,
0.9737799168,
-0.4374336302,
-0.7426949143,
-0.0794450343,
-0.3490072489,
-0.9898478389,
0.8638558984,
0.198673591,
-0.1445138454,
-0.0199733917,
-0.5282005072,
-1.2015125751,
0.9697221518,
0.5896324515,
-0.2844614685,
0.0979399681,
-0.3054136038,
0.5035082102,
-0.719638586,
0.1926504374,
0.3988059759,
0.6241674423,
0.3060269356,
-1.0938558578,
0.1906093955,
-0.2196826786,
-0.1341628283,
0.3746542335,
-0.3401227593,
1.3005943298,
-0.364572525,
-0.1386896372,
-0.1420029849,
0.5194265246,
0.2686519623,
0.375712961,
0.4150341749,
0.9366355538,
0.9397158027,
0.2348579764,
1.1559528112,
-0.3960585892,
-0.1166990846,
0.6894317865,
-0.2547109127,
0.8729689121,
0.2138962597,
0.4466302395,
0.4315300882,
0.6912984848,
0.1463693529,
0.3422896862,
-0.0657015964,
-0.2620255351,
-0.6105268002,
-0.4701184928,
-0.3779457808,
0.7861500382,
0.8638157248,
-0.4713760018,
-0.3312878013,
0.1771921366,
0.166604802,
-0.2005616277,
-0.4679806828,
0.8872916102,
-0.0614255331,
-0.2277812362,
0.5831876993,
0.1519986838,
0.6538447738,
-0.657440424,
-0.246883586,
0.0456691869,
0.1638292074,
-0.1814935654,
-0.437628746,
0.3604233563,
-0.3286454976,
-0.3382062316,
0.1696226895,
0.5860137939,
-0.381824255,
-0.7607557774,
0.5051103234,
0.4846436679,
0.5220843554,
0.0394750684,
-0.572157681,
0.0659243762,
-0.3409872055,
-0.1261785626,
0.3466373384,
0.4911787212,
-0.5807096958,
0.7392985225,
0.5897029042,
0.5521420836,
-0.0794069022,
-0.0246773176,
1.0638797283,
-0.7096825838,
-0.1537037343,
-0.8381147385,
0.0562624969,
0.0646700636,
-0.3584816158,
0.4681877792,
0.5929011106,
0.2865529954,
0.1436822861,
0.6744500399,
0.1424220204,
0.3194487989,
-0.6261824965,
0.6098092198,
-0.8149091005,
0.0468236618,
0.1609630734,
-0.4533942342,
-0.4889198244,
0.7633169293,
-0.3821053207,
0.2772350311,
0.7609220147,
0.7505375147,
-0.3150074184,
-0.1153922752,
0.3549871147,
0.479095459,
0.200787276,
0.9314563274,
0.7051562071,
-0.4641272724,
0.3696869016,
0.2986564636,
-0.5941289663,
-0.4295562506,
-0.8552158475,
-0.897159338,
-0.6514161229,
-0.3017994165,
-0.1154934466,
-0.1954445094,
0.8393944502,
0.9158665538,
-0.7021979094,
-0.0183379482,
0.335719794,
-0.1259500384,
-0.2000142932,
-0.0983495116,
0.5377486348,
0.137966156,
-0.44622612,
0.7656724453,
0.2708703876,
0.2817762196,
-0.3390420079,
0.1285897046,
-0.3618114591,
0.0342023373,
0.6516832113,
0.1815343797,
-0.4886748791,
-0.0139817521,
-0.1402834058,
-0.116580449,
0.284183383,
0.696927011,
-0.721447587,
0.3362494707,
0.3128312528,
0.4684681594,
0.2455322444,
-0.148388043,
0.6036247015,
-0.0601446293,
0.2758523226,
0.4706608355,
0.5578522682,
0.4106699228,
-0.9088075757,
-0.1787288487,
-0.0211303998,
-0.4593357146,
-0.4325411916,
0.4802320898,
-1.0047103167,
-0.424228549,
1.2219715118,
-0.0347185507,
-0.5266472101,
-0.5948643088,
-0.309709847,
0.1883013844,
-0.5236173868,
0.7590434551,
0.4731476307,
-0.6520656347,
-0.1819494069,
-0.7389469743,
0.4176637828,
0.4175657034,
-0.686060369,
-0.1511993408,
0.6925893426,
0.3927320242,
-0.0811572224,
0.8772999644,
-0.3483265936,
0.3005462289,
-0.3192555904,
0.0359262489,
-0.2810827792,
-0.5118473172,
-0.4293317497,
-0.0063595665,
0.384666115,
-0.1890269518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17197v1 | Entailment as Robust Self-Learner | 2023-05-26T18:41:23 | 2023-05-26T18:41:23 | Jiaxin Ge, Hongyin Luo, Yoon Kim, James Glass | cs.CL | cs.CL | Entailment has been recognized as an important metric for evaluating natural
language understanding (NLU) models, and recent studies have found that
entailment pretraining benefits weakly supervised fine-tuning. In this work, we
design a prompting strategy that formulates a number of different NLU tasks as
contextual entailment. This approach improves the zero-shot adaptation of
pretrained entailment models. Secondly, we notice that self-training
entailment-based models with unlabeled data can significantly improve the
adaptation performance on downstream tasks. To achieve more stable improvement,
we propose the Simple Pseudo-Label Editing (SimPLE) algorithm for better
pseudo-labeling quality in self-training. We also found that both pretrained
entailment-based models and the self-trained models are robust against
adversarial evaluation data. Experiments on binary and multi-class
classification tasks show that SimPLE leads to more robust self-training
results, indicating that the self-trained entailment models are more efficient
and trustworthy than large language models on language understanding tasks. | [
-0.1218562052,
-1.0086917877,
0.4962993264,
0.1508672833,
-0.2193471938,
-0.3545747101,
-0.3156759143,
-0.2109368742,
-0.1240099519,
0.4616489708,
-0.5499904752,
-0.4197701216,
-0.6674545407,
0.4341410398,
-0.3067343533,
1.150562644,
-0.030413257,
-0.2325313389,
-0.3073720932,
-0.0249871407,
-0.7305575013,
-0.2567884028,
-0.6276584268,
-0.328455776,
0.232384786,
0.3253292441,
0.5346979499,
0.7727435827,
0.1155213863,
0.3363758326,
0.2451244593,
0.0583512858,
-0.5860416293,
0.2799633443,
-0.3459770679,
-0.6550023556,
-0.3400838375,
-0.006625514,
0.3357849717,
0.5237935781,
-0.1191610619,
0.2317607105,
0.4717598855,
0.5836251974,
-0.8553971648,
0.0381577611,
-0.6665300727,
-0.2390678078,
0.00461976,
-0.3195407391,
-0.524109304,
-0.0174519941,
0.3552342057,
-1.0878334045,
0.2638314962,
0.0336579122,
0.8432354927,
0.8325209618,
0.007500439,
-0.4115762413,
-0.2917457819,
0.6660292745,
-0.7570004463,
0.5102800727,
0.7462863326,
0.0113157062,
-0.1786610335,
-0.6830133796,
-0.3605895936,
-0.2126368135,
-0.2826659083,
0.5023849607,
-0.2865651548,
0.1638439894,
-0.0066204867,
0.2304115444,
-0.6675351262,
0.1896669418,
-0.0068041417,
-0.1245839521,
0.2624302804,
-0.1239163578,
0.2271623313,
-0.1042947099,
-0.2860569358,
0.0588083677,
-0.6116104722,
0.1964009702,
0.3433489501,
0.2568544447,
-0.1415373534,
0.4434651136,
-0.6035766602,
1.0641288757,
0.5781177282,
-0.123424612,
-0.0749436915,
-0.4092463255,
-0.4786890745,
0.2334858477,
0.721155107,
-0.0063124979,
0.2672388554,
-0.4973435104,
0.1030383408,
0.0793720856,
0.4803059995,
-0.9007188678,
-0.5118643641,
0.2887444794,
-0.3350865841,
-0.2589104474,
-0.2340416312,
-0.383970201,
-0.0537575521,
-0.668135643,
1.0285840034,
-0.6850251555,
0.0922960714,
0.5277014971,
-0.0070840539,
0.3034134507,
0.5185001493,
-1.0077360868,
0.2501274347,
0.5677596331,
0.6138712764,
-0.0829783753,
-0.4338837266,
-0.5604417324,
0.2752034366,
-0.2968911827,
0.6806641817,
-0.4690907896,
-0.1387589574,
-0.2666187882,
0.1065836996,
-0.3351367116,
-0.4137344956,
0.4308768213,
-0.3258434236,
0.3445010781,
-0.0279026404,
-0.6025952101,
-0.2086608261,
0.5245590806,
-0.0794556886,
0.9311342835,
-0.1055794582,
-0.7674131989,
0.479272753,
-0.7432592511,
-0.4934597611,
-0.0105100963,
0.1571900398,
-0.362534821,
0.0322546177,
0.6948162317,
0.5088937283,
0.1232937872,
0.2466648966,
-0.254014343,
-0.2325938493,
-0.0324750841,
-0.3719260097,
0.7904282212,
0.0598977469,
-0.2663178742,
0.3224265575,
-0.5605469942,
-0.1796254218,
0.0681752488,
-0.1436022669,
-0.558731854,
-0.2022653073,
-0.6707552671,
-0.1680102646,
0.3031389415,
-0.2685275078,
0.1229499802,
-0.7478324771,
0.13274014,
0.779843092,
0.1102457345,
0.8245519996,
-0.2030106187,
0.3345630765,
-0.0152602773,
0.0915538445,
-0.3326616287,
-0.2331624627,
-1.1035957336,
-0.2851372063,
0.5106281042,
0.6043648124,
-0.9574818611,
0.6195272803,
-0.0079327803,
-0.3211318254,
-0.685236752,
0.5293594599,
0.4838386178,
0.838512361,
0.5995497704,
-0.0037035237,
-0.2994555235,
-0.7010436058,
-0.5140337944,
-0.0486322343,
-0.0593741611,
-0.2279206216,
0.5205097198,
-0.2191741019,
1.0156663656,
-0.466252476,
-0.3210126162,
-0.1231414378,
0.4738942981,
0.0997680351,
0.5561978817,
0.4495944083,
-0.3705794811,
-0.5450700521,
-0.26972574,
-0.8893309236,
-0.0683003291,
-0.3314417601,
-0.500546813,
-0.0888033509,
0.5324423909,
-0.2689898312,
0.4340230227,
0.1309762001,
-0.0467732251,
0.3453218639,
-0.4938336015,
-0.0161150489,
-0.8853337765,
-0.3711731732,
0.1265431494,
-0.3103840649,
-0.8192142844,
0.0468075983,
0.1996715367,
0.1110727042,
-0.3890289366,
0.4015820622,
-0.5484695435,
0.559951365,
-0.3134452701,
-0.0798593685,
0.0879316553,
0.3375686109,
0.3231036365,
0.6507048011,
1.1392140388,
-0.9813244939,
-0.0407453254,
0.4197731912,
-0.0408535004,
0.620675683,
-0.6566926837,
0.4661613703,
-0.4062757492,
0.1553978175,
-0.7834938765,
-0.250469476,
0.3357726336,
-0.3946936429,
0.5238023996,
-0.1748691797,
-0.2874336541,
0.015563719,
-0.1614725143,
0.0450559184,
0.4214525223,
-0.847147882,
0.5131986737,
0.0242662001,
0.06411542,
-0.4299313426,
-0.5075221062,
-0.0245206617,
-0.439040482,
-0.2791126966,
0.2391579598,
-0.0395697951,
0.0738382563,
-0.0654708967,
-0.1256742179,
-0.1086935103,
0.3560127914,
0.1491708606,
0.0454455465,
-0.1835191101,
0.2492898405,
0.1816467643,
-0.1714048237,
-0.0004083747,
-0.2711348236,
0.0462127775,
-0.2668325007,
-0.2690489292,
-0.5203196406,
0.0192694981,
-0.132111609,
-0.2946429849,
0.7878541946,
0.6178281307,
-0.3791694343,
-0.4162039161,
-0.3341030478,
-0.6469967961,
-0.5336641669,
0.1422259659,
-0.4990556836,
-1.0118438005,
0.0079322429,
-0.1687963456,
-0.0121046277,
0.2782402933,
0.4955732822,
-0.4367825091,
0.6102334857,
0.7852987647,
0.0680338517,
0.1577239782,
-0.0784743577,
0.327568233,
-0.5517652631,
0.0326800831,
-0.4297253191,
-0.0716437548,
-0.3573405147,
-0.1982224137,
0.0963347405,
0.4716721773,
-0.0053576333,
0.5464055538,
-0.6882324219,
0.4582431614,
0.3679997921,
0.2213145047,
0.1263354719,
-0.1224915311,
0.3295017183,
-0.1717010736,
-0.7874405384,
-0.4831445217,
0.9574485421,
0.3639323413,
1.0471266508,
0.1863956004,
0.9125149846,
-0.009153882,
0.2949939966,
-0.8965377212,
0.2190559655,
-0.040944729,
-0.5375989079,
-0.5146538019,
-0.1955065727,
-0.9968918562,
0.1844108254,
-0.3071758747,
-0.733828187,
0.3052442074,
0.4221840799,
-0.4971048236,
-0.1759595275,
-0.8392432332,
0.9931566119,
-0.2678691745,
-0.230780527,
0.092169106,
-0.5774026513,
0.2689707279,
-0.332873702,
0.1391912699,
-0.0456165411,
0.0033446541,
0.7824503779,
-0.1610065699,
0.9541037083,
-0.0648156777,
0.0715404078,
0.3503361344,
0.2394763082,
0.3361769319,
0.1669084728,
-0.1026828289,
-0.1113002673,
-0.0183740053,
-0.2978878617,
-0.9032153487,
0.4255334735,
-0.611623168,
-0.8580092788,
-0.2871879339,
-0.4345295727,
-0.3102354109,
0.1411450803,
0.49309811,
0.4667789638,
-0.0451431014,
0.3880036175,
0.8156237006,
-0.1011963487,
0.4680149257,
0.5557604432,
0.2146239281,
0.0172875114,
0.9867438674,
0.0313893519,
0.3759215772,
0.4174336195,
0.4762151837,
-0.6505939364,
-0.5886114836,
-0.539639771,
-0.0058242292,
-0.7251026034,
-0.3025439382,
-0.7370550632,
0.0049322252,
-0.5621289015,
-0.3622888923,
-0.3797277808,
-0.0803885087,
-0.6200509071,
-0.0957673565,
0.5075595975,
0.6407797933,
0.0104126558,
0.6122868657,
-0.4177253246,
0.4758635163,
0.5555732846,
0.1116583422,
-0.2508605719,
-1.0979132652,
-0.1676158011,
-0.0327571779,
-0.3976216912,
-0.9413924217,
0.2850993872,
0.6349651814,
0.7580150962,
0.3619737625,
0.6100511551,
0.9484243393,
-0.4667548239,
0.4790462255,
0.1381136179,
-1.1109864712,
0.9375910163,
-0.2367032319,
0.5764135718,
0.8811972141,
0.6962663531,
0.0485575609,
-0.4937514663,
-0.4735082984,
-0.5290924907,
0.6951182485,
0.2627210021,
0.2396071106,
0.0075049959,
0.4360780716,
0.2804580927,
-0.1544921249,
-0.8315716982,
-0.2967036366,
-0.6958553791,
-0.3554777205,
-0.0710256174,
-0.0251550507,
-0.1186836585,
-0.5009877682,
0.6895036697,
-0.5100956559,
0.0354711749,
0.367436856,
-0.5431365371,
0.3085667789,
0.6016505957,
0.2516958714,
0.6662384272,
-0.274836719,
0.3258598745,
0.691375196,
-0.2226034403,
0.2468128353,
-0.0631531253,
-0.2207724601,
-0.1471433043,
0.3878510296,
0.896153748,
0.3275311291,
-0.0466468744,
0.4425131083,
-0.0862253606,
-0.3954398334,
0.247893557,
0.2497938126,
0.0152701419,
-0.2894005179,
0.0959246382,
-0.0223150086,
0.4174627662,
-0.4812039435,
0.2416384816,
0.204278335,
-0.4943336248,
-0.1717294902,
0.5322668552,
-0.0130796945,
-0.108400248,
0.0796736702,
-0.3398765326,
-0.3970143795,
0.2310121357,
0.8972189426,
0.732604444,
-0.22317563,
0.2269099653,
0.5321023464,
0.4301092327,
-0.2180487067,
-0.1464411914,
-0.3506554067,
-0.6547869444,
-0.5555661321,
-0.7547922134,
-0.3994545937,
0.1035677269,
-0.8365672827,
0.0729919747,
-0.4364359081,
0.0818643644,
0.0896228328,
-0.4589455128,
-0.5647267699,
0.5180850029,
-0.2182745934,
0.6002495885,
-0.7538347244,
0.9285335541,
0.7125270963,
-0.1604621559,
-0.7615163922,
0.2241569459,
-0.113243334,
-0.5212783217,
0.4301458001,
0.2609519362,
-0.311688453,
0.2040823549,
-0.6036354899,
-0.7030249834,
0.648419559,
0.3929639757,
-0.4009849131,
0.2378143966,
-0.1880951226,
0.4392049909,
-0.1257216334,
0.20054093,
0.7012528181,
0.3109160662,
0.0264752749,
-0.7449015975,
0.1832773983,
0.0670371577,
-0.2695010602,
-0.0646116659,
-0.2143566757,
0.354501605,
-0.0718339011,
-0.3156935573,
-0.2126614153,
0.9228435755,
0.1105271727,
0.1200356185,
0.6003754735,
0.5311076641,
0.6047363281,
-0.1757003069,
0.8276680112,
-0.0583756454,
0.2714954019,
1.4326491356,
0.0510078855,
0.8218579888,
0.291472137,
-0.0840265751,
0.2872926891,
0.7110819817,
0.2312817425,
0.7364821434,
-0.0234997962,
0.0188600104,
-0.5343851447,
-0.015029219,
-0.3872096837,
0.706361711,
0.3178883493,
0.0464661829,
-0.4133240283,
0.0132514024,
0.0185000096,
0.232521683,
-0.2699168622,
1.0974445343,
0.1403849125,
-0.8609750271,
0.7031431198,
-0.1366155446,
0.9125570059,
-0.5722819567,
0.1058125347,
0.0859149694,
0.0346018299,
-0.2811763585,
-0.7892608643,
0.4132119119,
-0.0374114737,
0.0685451105,
-0.4079450667,
0.9605739713,
-0.4443837106,
-0.435644269,
0.2634034753,
0.4418299198,
0.1054083183,
-0.1397259235,
-0.9419713616,
-0.3911021948,
-0.0947692767,
-0.0917963535,
0.402977407,
0.494171828,
0.1204211116,
0.4797383547,
0.8137971163,
-0.3322021365,
0.1079490483,
0.2738884389,
0.6023843884,
-0.4072868824,
-0.6284097433,
-1.0014064312,
0.4790920019,
0.0897867978,
-0.2247603238,
1.1215600967,
0.3098007441,
0.79316324,
-0.198170051,
0.4645192623,
0.2762772143,
0.2838328183,
-0.6395394206,
0.763166666,
-0.5408706665,
-0.2624642551,
-0.0922597498,
-0.6661524773,
-0.2115027457,
0.7751417756,
-0.518207252,
-0.1175919846,
0.5715563297,
0.7627249956,
-0.1070211083,
0.0799703449,
0.569747746,
-0.0350538082,
0.0480161682,
0.2219532877,
0.8026769161,
-0.2881211638,
0.2406472266,
-0.3786679506,
-0.2546856999,
0.0731291696,
-0.9603130817,
-1.1862056255,
-0.3770980835,
-0.5636146069,
-0.1492661387,
0.1292499006,
0.6009400487,
1.0037742853,
-0.95398736,
0.013636278,
-0.183657676,
-0.1529559791,
-0.0526244976,
-0.1908250898,
0.3727006316,
-0.8055093288,
-0.5135573149,
0.7044949532,
0.4323585927,
0.1645529568,
0.1169469282,
-0.2068213224,
-0.2477212995,
0.1052908525,
0.4410559237,
0.2248240411,
-0.8402275443,
-0.2051568627,
-0.053617321,
0.0409985669,
0.015986776,
0.3285622299,
-0.6523609757,
0.8878416419,
0.2739289701,
0.9104557037,
0.5902028084,
0.2790869772,
0.4485467076,
-0.7534452081,
0.2251098901,
-0.0993212163,
0.212985754,
0.3974938989,
-0.5889530182,
0.4281935096,
-0.1761402786,
-0.4701676667,
-0.5692566037,
0.0198919959,
-0.798699677,
-0.3739559352,
0.9335184097,
-0.2948603034,
-0.3844817877,
-0.5130309463,
-0.160911873,
0.3934745789,
-0.2256642729,
0.476236701,
0.558358252,
-0.3105484545,
-0.2985748947,
-0.5488922,
0.6735861301,
0.7471567988,
-1.1119580269,
-0.1915795356,
0.0345260799,
0.40885216,
-0.0151052019,
0.4883975387,
0.2622140348,
0.2908347547,
-0.0993007049,
-0.1761278212,
-0.1780643612,
-0.3754011691,
-0.4860164523,
-0.1238918453,
0.066306062,
-0.4762676358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17182v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17182v2 | On the Copying Problem of Unsupervised NMT: A Training Schedule with a Language Discriminator Loss | 2023-05-26T18:14:23 | 2023-06-04T09:41:35 | Yihong Liu, Alexandra Chronopoulou, Hinrich Schütze, Alexander Fraser | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although unsupervised neural machine translation (UNMT) has achieved success
in many language pairs, the copying problem, i.e., directly copying some parts
of the input sentence as the translation, is common among distant language
pairs, especially when low-resource languages are involved. We find this issue
is closely related to an unexpected copying behavior during online
back-translation (BT). In this work, we propose a simple but effective training
schedule that incorporates a language discriminator loss. The loss imposes
constraints on the intermediate translation so that the translation is in the
desired language. By conducting extensive experiments on different language
pairs, including similar and distant, high and low-resource languages, we find
that our method alleviates the copying problem, thus improving the translation
performance on low-resource languages. | [
-0.0410761572,
-0.2712706625,
0.4778857827,
0.4027284682,
-0.6420827508,
0.4084635675,
-0.2606099546,
-0.0123961391,
0.1786621958,
0.6307521462,
-0.5961123705,
0.0505504012,
-0.5967699289,
0.1457549632,
-0.5197776556,
1.1285558939,
-0.3653070927,
0.2299964428,
0.1257807165,
-0.2452432811,
-0.454477191,
-0.5899656415,
-0.8390610218,
-0.5764921308,
0.2022511661,
0.0915136263,
0.3750024438,
0.8631107807,
0.4557992518,
0.2560423613,
-0.1631659865,
0.3295529485,
-0.4025330245,
0.0063510118,
-0.2957223058,
-0.4462301433,
0.0584262945,
-0.3244772851,
0.8699899316,
1.1585440636,
-0.2353162318,
-0.1259626299,
0.2076700032,
0.7681719065,
-0.3682718873,
-0.0300474074,
-0.6840346456,
0.4422113001,
-0.1398374736,
-0.419146508,
-0.5208112597,
-0.3063266575,
-0.1342198849,
-0.6505788565,
0.2779953182,
-0.2349235117,
0.4880426228,
0.4483056664,
-0.6325747967,
0.0411380306,
-0.7439473867,
0.7240417004,
-0.3235028982,
0.3441749811,
0.3035909235,
0.087221168,
-0.1670993865,
-0.3306069076,
-0.4427376688,
0.0520942807,
-0.0443180911,
0.1755754948,
-0.2723450661,
-0.2068540305,
0.0510798469,
0.0923957452,
-0.5045622587,
0.0546980016,
-0.4710277319,
-0.1596542448,
0.0691879764,
0.0397729054,
0.2213811129,
0.0271912348,
-0.4360860884,
0.0681328997,
-0.6791213155,
-0.3253263831,
0.2138896286,
0.3206504881,
-0.0435211398,
0.5453613997,
-0.1769731194,
0.4539090693,
0.0125231668,
0.3784454465,
0.2352417856,
-0.4183914363,
0.0876158252,
0.2186950594,
0.6448165774,
0.6917266846,
0.3002334833,
-0.5689627528,
-0.5504977107,
-0.1373020113,
0.1863492131,
-0.8068262339,
-0.3051891625,
-0.4632232487,
-0.4838189781,
-0.2162781209,
-0.2669937611,
-0.6054922938,
-0.0398577079,
-0.3853608072,
0.4754061699,
-0.4689279497,
-0.1584142894,
-0.1347993016,
-0.1683065295,
-0.1016782597,
0.0692285448,
-0.7469828129,
0.2797335088,
0.3524931967,
1.2132874727,
-0.733171165,
-0.5145855546,
-0.6750811934,
0.2640948892,
-0.3052545786,
0.5259966254,
0.0718075261,
-0.289069891,
-0.1568181664,
0.0350701287,
-0.3607034981,
-0.372525245,
-0.1674498767,
-0.618635118,
0.2482832223,
-0.3866456151,
-0.372269243,
-0.1532523185,
0.0359943323,
-0.5024504662,
0.7953432798,
0.3478415608,
-0.6356595159,
0.1435963213,
-0.5280252099,
-0.7530556321,
0.0506772287,
0.1724040061,
-0.4414437413,
0.2327132374,
0.0864111334,
0.4657119215,
-0.191717729,
-0.0110945376,
0.1863766909,
-0.6267306805,
0.469453603,
-0.4427479804,
1.0049214363,
0.3686068654,
-0.6938942671,
-0.2284359187,
-0.6211191416,
-0.0339978673,
0.3893694282,
-0.6648485065,
-0.4488773644,
-0.1786540002,
0.1735163778,
0.3605322242,
0.1322591752,
-0.6699786782,
0.4545594752,
-0.1762154996,
0.6001793742,
0.7036511302,
0.1525487453,
0.738007009,
-0.3012878299,
0.4057391584,
0.0564754568,
0.0461789332,
0.347245872,
-0.1309828311,
-0.8325130343,
-0.0904496759,
0.1310406923,
0.5253030658,
-1.1580278873,
-0.0133123184,
-0.3629034758,
0.0313026458,
-0.5125380754,
0.4304183125,
1.0414239168,
0.1908779144,
0.5526503921,
-0.4951273799,
-0.7351045609,
-0.7857849598,
0.0187876411,
0.3225823939,
0.2516632974,
-0.3200165331,
0.2731671929,
-0.0496594906,
0.5269718766,
-0.3153705895,
-0.5665227175,
-0.681106627,
0.2786934078,
0.0605590791,
0.5583124757,
0.5617374182,
-0.5911275148,
-0.6712942123,
0.285487771,
-0.7004520893,
-0.138542518,
-0.375995487,
-0.092883803,
0.7182417512,
0.6406802535,
-0.547380507,
0.3394741714,
0.691606462,
-0.2330042422,
0.096968092,
-0.4896564782,
0.1093555316,
-1.2038645744,
0.0705016255,
-0.5003820658,
-0.1866238713,
-0.3613699377,
-0.0960423723,
-0.0785261691,
0.1248797327,
-0.7099425793,
0.0779902861,
-0.5738168955,
-0.3231386542,
-0.463273108,
-0.2530806959,
-0.2295946181,
0.7511564493,
-0.0852838457,
0.8885205984,
0.0478802845,
-0.6112468839,
0.1154261455,
0.1570884734,
-0.1520876735,
0.6977647543,
-0.3986329436,
0.4361145794,
-0.0198686589,
0.1322350949,
-0.4981931448,
0.2230824381,
0.2257903963,
-0.3451521099,
0.5293226838,
-0.348808527,
-0.5085909963,
0.0228559952,
-0.0759012625,
0.3808462322,
0.561324656,
-0.6892639995,
0.1048000082,
0.141577214,
0.2357671261,
-0.5509053469,
-1.077244997,
0.0440959074,
-0.195143193,
-0.0765523314,
0.3786363006,
-0.0191099141,
0.1596459299,
0.2731600404,
-0.0888340697,
-0.3245913386,
0.3280542195,
0.0194523465,
-0.0074996161,
-0.1178925261,
-0.2493400127,
0.1121795699,
-0.0814589411,
0.0793143436,
-0.5591695905,
0.7203313708,
0.0422473513,
-0.2920414209,
-0.4561841488,
0.6890229583,
0.4389320016,
-0.1871291697,
0.6576752663,
0.6889654398,
-0.1647626311,
-0.5197323561,
-0.1873694509,
-0.1948247403,
-0.4035931528,
0.6311916709,
-0.4584657252,
-0.5974885821,
0.4042924047,
0.1303852499,
-0.1274507791,
0.3268760145,
0.45654881,
-0.1945067197,
1.0810307264,
0.5600891113,
-0.0093874373,
0.653922081,
-0.3503463566,
-0.3162151575,
-0.8648942709,
-0.1915869266,
-0.1644880474,
-0.5521726608,
-0.5349106193,
-0.2320515662,
-0.0107302619,
0.0982827321,
-0.4234730303,
0.7156783342,
-0.7185410857,
0.7843231559,
0.9849033952,
0.1411378682,
0.3447471857,
0.2634480596,
-0.3911328316,
-0.2839224339,
-0.7224366069,
-0.0808275118,
1.0146635771,
-0.2391776294,
0.4849055707,
0.2896272838,
0.9153782725,
0.177899152,
0.0407141373,
-0.3591849208,
0.5912362933,
-0.5748851895,
-0.3672297001,
-0.0890675187,
-0.9227449894,
-1.009698391,
0.3034752905,
0.1015489548,
-0.6737347245,
-0.0738384351,
0.047012642,
0.0275946502,
0.7087204456,
-0.4906527698,
0.8958120346,
-0.357588917,
-0.0653891042,
-0.1220452935,
-0.8532792926,
0.1693178415,
-0.389361769,
-0.1205086783,
0.1926751584,
0.2037002295,
0.7576339245,
-0.4739046395,
0.6768410802,
-0.2087713033,
0.5542780161,
0.0304543395,
0.5171387196,
0.4106940329,
-0.445294857,
0.2516938448,
-0.0273714159,
-0.083247833,
-0.3202248514,
-0.6809844971,
0.5074740648,
-0.9075505733,
-0.1802710295,
-0.5284123421,
-0.4715034664,
0.0779250935,
0.3817972243,
0.6677076221,
0.0272186771,
0.0048078173,
0.3105438054,
0.5807400346,
0.0300380774,
0.7150586843,
0.6379184127,
-0.2637614906,
-0.4587056041,
1.29829216,
0.2458910495,
0.5183698535,
0.5844174027,
0.3371964395,
-0.0965355188,
-0.8796012402,
-0.6948486567,
0.1104012355,
-0.7555046678,
-0.1539657265,
-0.6130020618,
-0.2083396912,
0.0538651906,
-0.2634360492,
-0.7456254363,
-0.6766098738,
-0.2265318632,
0.19907552,
0.336438328,
0.702912271,
-0.1693481207,
0.7205981016,
-0.8066837192,
0.1457572281,
0.0103859697,
0.1358239949,
-0.2052949071,
-0.9603563547,
-0.320815444,
-0.060263522,
-0.2409229726,
-0.6230026484,
0.4964976907,
0.16282098,
0.5773667097,
-0.0449448302,
0.1426803917,
0.368398875,
-0.314973712,
0.2892133296,
0.2644199729,
-0.7846359015,
0.2045797408,
-0.2615184486,
0.4583719969,
0.7121151686,
0.1910409778,
-0.6245207787,
-0.3309788108,
-0.2043688744,
-0.6741372943,
0.9425966144,
0.4912889302,
0.0129110105,
-0.0024088393,
0.049814228,
0.081997484,
0.1433338076,
-0.7510256767,
-0.3173820078,
-0.3836536705,
-0.0104971668,
-0.1077399999,
-0.0113855917,
0.2618447542,
-0.3003869057,
0.6745058298,
0.0036822837,
0.4104490578,
-0.0019275368,
-0.4346582592,
-0.2956851721,
0.2124331445,
0.5803900957,
0.2585116327,
-0.4444178343,
0.2504080832,
0.3071318269,
-0.5653599501,
0.2633194625,
0.1471436918,
-0.705177784,
0.1937641203,
0.0993105397,
0.7385159731,
0.3772347569,
-0.1328089237,
0.5630359054,
0.0289023276,
-0.2605500519,
-0.215043813,
-0.5521791577,
-0.0098638507,
0.1846749783,
0.1581476629,
0.2981810868,
-0.0325247981,
-0.3819341362,
0.3127654791,
0.1697971374,
-0.4931654334,
-0.3866102397,
0.699798584,
0.1472309232,
-0.3574663103,
1.0336511135,
-0.6159927249,
-1.1612763405,
0.3854136765,
0.7865754962,
0.9815571308,
-0.3143103123,
0.1301818788,
0.0497420989,
0.4926969707,
-0.4270108938,
0.2439220548,
0.0218166187,
-0.5807371736,
-0.4418887198,
-0.4270974696,
-0.2445916086,
-0.0514621437,
-0.6804130077,
0.0578355268,
-0.3252988458,
0.1715692133,
-0.2347567528,
-0.2312995642,
-0.7563315034,
-0.1325458139,
-0.0268308967,
0.1266658306,
-0.5150260925,
1.1285536289,
0.7522128224,
-0.6048438549,
-0.568502605,
-0.2660999298,
0.0139220878,
-0.744122684,
0.8981685042,
-0.0165387187,
-0.1313085705,
0.1889241189,
0.1429527998,
-0.7706620097,
0.8556318283,
0.7892749906,
-0.3955433667,
-0.1414323002,
0.372254312,
0.4159812033,
-0.0717925578,
-0.2091052085,
0.5619250536,
0.1655429453,
0.0760586932,
-1.0124405622,
0.3319986463,
-0.1552928239,
-0.025640348,
0.7280093431,
-0.5571878552,
1.0109330416,
-0.1339077204,
-0.2610575855,
-0.1109403968,
0.3814531565,
-0.3253127038,
0.1969065368,
0.3571801782,
0.5588166118,
0.3226450682,
-0.0596149899,
0.994664371,
-0.0038995997,
0.3530774713,
1.3394382,
-0.02354699,
0.8066484332,
0.7262003422,
-0.1331285834,
-0.1335527897,
0.4000847042,
-0.0792821795,
1.0458889008,
0.2828606963,
-0.1920737475,
-0.2744113803,
-0.1777448803,
-0.3721698225,
0.6126239896,
-0.2727437019,
-0.4601083994,
-0.3263540268,
0.3525307775,
0.2135243863,
0.2274206877,
-0.2699104548,
0.6757234931,
0.1873336583,
-0.6502191424,
0.6511809826,
-0.0659525394,
0.7479369044,
-0.4096055627,
-0.0103330752,
-0.5970417857,
0.6563835144,
0.092570059,
-0.6304025054,
0.7814459205,
-0.2013700902,
-0.1039105356,
-0.6730924845,
0.1548645645,
-0.5473094583,
-0.1684787869,
0.4793834388,
0.5749251842,
0.3948494196,
-0.3850055337,
-0.5647284985,
-0.1110255048,
0.2889896929,
-0.3167746961,
0.6787233353,
0.5209482908,
-0.1956560314,
0.5700707436,
0.6894806623,
0.1833268851,
0.308601141,
-0.1039224416,
0.718136549,
-0.7170145512,
-0.418187201,
-0.8306095004,
0.0061644404,
0.0523272566,
-0.5132917762,
0.7677989602,
0.6930786967,
0.9726225734,
-0.2452683598,
0.6272291541,
0.1588029414,
0.3698796332,
-0.6274080276,
1.0777382851,
-0.4442504346,
0.061267823,
-0.1238551214,
-1.2267554998,
-0.2513690889,
0.5458019376,
0.3035266101,
-0.3486949801,
1.2239720821,
0.372787714,
-0.0507570989,
-0.4040801823,
0.3787944019,
-0.2125654072,
0.0892836824,
0.96110183,
0.8601202369,
-0.2607200444,
1.0851408243,
-0.8253891468,
0.1037533656,
-0.2096511424,
-0.910433352,
-1.1085127592,
-0.6083338261,
-0.390974015,
-0.3822316527,
0.3520595431,
1.2165712118,
0.4181780815,
-0.6587437391,
-0.2589069605,
-0.2292540073,
0.0544484816,
-0.4995740652,
-0.1303421557,
0.476479739,
-0.0586234294,
-0.5284500122,
0.5550602674,
-0.0035461555,
0.3246637583,
-0.006106067,
-0.0006987205,
-0.3326110542,
-0.3387876451,
0.492202878,
0.3352111876,
-0.3820636868,
-0.2932899892,
-0.0220338292,
-0.3559983373,
0.0621129386,
0.9292174578,
-0.3443465233,
0.5853993893,
0.2234821767,
1.1046248674,
0.7732245326,
-0.3461169004,
0.6605195999,
-1.1045912504,
0.156705752,
0.1975533962,
0.4523602426,
0.4675071537,
-0.1704897732,
0.5143938065,
0.7066437602,
-0.3978352547,
-0.8053863049,
0.0136841005,
-1.1646906137,
-0.3056341708,
1.1459319592,
-0.0714101866,
0.0107475594,
-0.2791495025,
-0.1052481458,
0.6573310494,
-0.3481818736,
0.6337886453,
0.5299794078,
0.2479159236,
-0.1631588191,
-0.6994575262,
0.4384749532,
0.4690432847,
-0.4125334918,
-0.1030862182,
0.0407340713,
0.3634869158,
-0.0424920768,
0.4424977303,
0.1887416989,
0.3415034711,
-0.0524459817,
0.2558853924,
-0.5741732717,
-0.0140245073,
-0.3639095426,
-0.2970967293,
-0.0865664184,
-0.7660973072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17179v1 | Tokenization Impacts Multilingual Language Modeling: Assessing Vocabulary Allocation and Overlap Across Languages | 2023-05-26T18:06:49 | 2023-05-26T18:06:49 | Tomasz Limisiewicz, Jiří Balhar, David Mareček | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual language models have recently gained attention as a promising
solution for representing multiple languages in a single model. In this paper,
we propose new criteria to evaluate the quality of lexical representation and
vocabulary overlap observed in sub-word tokenizers. Our findings show that the
overlap of vocabulary across languages can be actually detrimental to certain
downstream tasks (POS, dependency tree labeling). In contrast, NER and
sentence-level tasks (cross-lingual retrieval, NLI) benefit from sharing
vocabulary. We also observe that the coverage of the language-specific tokens
in the multilingual vocabulary significantly impacts the word-level tasks. Our
study offers a deeper understanding of the role of tokenizers in multilingual
language models and guidelines for future model developers to choose the most
suitable tokenizer for their specific application before undertaking costly
model pre-training | [
-0.4221555293,
-0.384550482,
0.0106868586,
0.381878823,
-0.1938474178,
0.1365419626,
0.0085493354,
-0.7315596938,
0.3750720322,
0.0769079104,
0.0865286812,
0.0065163192,
-0.7398058772,
-0.0345457233,
-0.2052015066,
0.9440218806,
-0.1673271656,
0.3788361847,
-0.4951013029,
-0.1135241613,
-0.7836561203,
-1.1415762901,
-0.587423861,
-0.3353162408,
0.7455658317,
-0.137009427,
0.7345389128,
0.4020850956,
0.4572377205,
0.4212201536,
-0.4978071749,
-0.1119607985,
-0.219016552,
-0.1017915383,
-0.130403921,
-0.3957846165,
-0.4414229095,
-0.0374337211,
0.6958568096,
1.0110858679,
0.0875824615,
0.1000441909,
-0.0037603891,
0.0790484771,
-0.8669930696,
0.0445532314,
-0.5145452023,
-0.0366217494,
-0.3827899992,
-0.0857648328,
-0.241808027,
0.2520678341,
0.0538125411,
-0.5265900493,
-0.0281341765,
-0.0007029104,
0.6816349626,
-0.1109119132,
-0.4378288686,
-0.1425650269,
-0.4177047908,
0.968052268,
-0.6864760518,
0.6190155149,
0.339479804,
-0.1010313854,
0.1826403141,
-0.5646252632,
-0.3771491647,
-0.0615530051,
-0.3681104481,
0.0206554439,
-0.1677517295,
0.234052971,
-0.0168318078,
0.4270047545,
-0.1362579167,
0.4185266197,
-0.5605633855,
-0.4681142569,
0.1740161777,
0.0968737081,
0.6024947762,
-0.2421569079,
-0.3873092234,
0.2619841695,
-0.3870838284,
0.0775557086,
0.6701660156,
0.5833317041,
0.1992847025,
0.7074179649,
0.2004968971,
0.6693321466,
-0.389157027,
0.1133459285,
0.295938462,
-1.0341591835,
0.0563737601,
0.1114022508,
0.4462248385,
0.2142411917,
0.2847067118,
-0.2078732848,
-0.370148629,
-0.0529817827,
0.041527655,
-0.6276685596,
0.2701279819,
0.3055450618,
-0.4843998849,
0.0010128961,
0.2565667629,
-0.4189472198,
-0.10460563,
-0.1791668236,
0.2313797176,
-0.2003335953,
-0.604321301,
0.2691073716,
-0.3637008667,
0.0152679617,
-0.1072056368,
-0.9219326973,
0.3642491102,
0.9319355488,
1.0185008049,
-0.2774930298,
-0.7724067569,
-0.6169654131,
0.0176394489,
-0.4510298669,
0.5716326237,
-0.5814617872,
-0.4930811822,
0.0693737566,
-0.0398246199,
-0.2836005986,
-0.4452757537,
0.1886574179,
-0.5841001272,
0.1257202923,
-0.2824089229,
-0.6440923214,
-0.0163056999,
0.2389595062,
-0.8643416166,
1.0759863853,
0.0227623787,
-0.8533592224,
0.6144584417,
-0.5810685754,
-0.4219349027,
0.2051164508,
0.0894556493,
-0.0596742295,
0.3296811283,
0.135579139,
0.2790888548,
0.0967440307,
0.4412884116,
-0.1231866777,
-0.2768341005,
0.2948146164,
-0.342939198,
0.4416981637,
0.0602633804,
-0.0348352231,
0.5411848426,
-0.2975461781,
-0.0160466526,
-0.3347224593,
-0.299441427,
-0.7255827188,
-0.1937452406,
0.7072976232,
0.4768670797,
0.473084867,
-0.641035676,
-0.0639611185,
-0.5061757565,
0.3664248884,
0.6202845573,
-0.1234580129,
0.4605671465,
-0.2535005212,
0.7620087266,
0.4363949001,
0.254756093,
-0.233391732,
-0.5407235622,
-0.6734703183,
-0.3210341632,
0.8317989111,
0.3406300545,
-0.498026818,
0.1649401486,
-0.3424844742,
-0.3015720248,
-0.5127180219,
-0.1273736656,
0.5276183486,
-0.1398024261,
0.254160285,
-0.5182442665,
-0.7210224271,
-0.8157787323,
-0.2861717641,
-0.0977244377,
0.3064175248,
0.0554678962,
0.7631033659,
-0.0691804364,
0.9543097615,
0.039155066,
-0.3816702068,
-0.5704417825,
0.0513198823,
-0.0549937189,
0.665487051,
0.6491554379,
-0.8384912014,
-0.4548001587,
0.231663093,
-0.1373296827,
-0.0916554332,
0.0229576118,
0.1525862664,
0.2130909413,
0.6987807751,
-0.4813959897,
0.4257526398,
0.7482306957,
-0.4742509425,
0.6745508909,
-0.2724196017,
0.1509992182,
-0.9140946865,
0.3867646456,
-0.3816761076,
0.0246678945,
-0.9163479805,
0.1802817881,
-0.2348962426,
0.057748545,
-0.7416654229,
1.0781215429,
-0.4404997826,
-0.3505853117,
-0.198457256,
0.2070968598,
-0.0046916222,
-0.0162870213,
-0.0115046203,
0.9767376781,
0.5233848691,
-0.3295190334,
-0.0374753177,
0.1058351174,
-0.4146694243,
0.1964610815,
-0.8146723509,
-0.1768076867,
-0.0770773739,
0.0676422417,
-0.8984693885,
0.0550607406,
0.0769860148,
-0.4343042076,
0.2078409195,
-0.1582510322,
-0.5397889018,
-0.0453529358,
-0.1933850944,
0.8666466475,
-0.1895406097,
-0.3236175179,
0.6295030117,
0.6822417378,
0.0272583142,
-0.8088949919,
-0.8107421398,
0.2195168138,
-0.0807298571,
-0.363786459,
0.4370931387,
0.1345797181,
-0.2602665722,
0.1615478396,
-0.119111903,
-0.0630585998,
0.2975993454,
0.1122417077,
0.1843966395,
-0.1082390398,
0.2974093258,
-0.1672200263,
-0.2887203097,
-0.2502522469,
-0.5153083205,
0.9192873836,
-0.1156728119,
-0.5487512946,
-0.2589861453,
0.4852983654,
0.3515142798,
-0.7458621264,
1.1169962883,
0.7351965904,
-0.4361634552,
0.5037437677,
-0.5701690316,
0.1134274602,
-0.4061442614,
0.6770319939,
-0.741481781,
-0.9967440367,
0.8870277405,
0.1757714003,
-0.0799076334,
0.4077474475,
0.4916738868,
0.5460857153,
1.017839551,
0.6045823693,
-0.4125730395,
0.7477172613,
-0.0760496929,
0.2301652879,
-0.8335679173,
-0.1859143078,
-0.4773091376,
-0.1286433041,
-0.5387873054,
-0.6204286814,
0.0464504696,
0.3656644225,
0.3300553262,
0.2729387879,
-0.1362734735,
0.598231554,
0.4239639342,
-0.5896826982,
0.1065800115,
-0.0710755289,
-0.3549332619,
-0.0544416979,
-0.8546572328,
-0.4766166508,
0.7446316481,
0.3956689835,
0.1051591039,
0.0704807416,
0.5932489634,
0.0368857272,
0.1799193919,
-0.8112442493,
0.2285877913,
-0.2009467036,
-0.8016757369,
-0.3946956694,
-0.3851930201,
-1.1677758694,
0.7729151845,
0.0830986798,
-0.8849880099,
0.2357960641,
-0.0940186679,
-0.0880464315,
0.3889707029,
-0.665784061,
1.1693257093,
-0.2125554979,
0.0617914461,
-0.3738890588,
-0.3171270788,
-0.0031009319,
-0.1962028593,
0.6317126751,
-0.0439834744,
-0.4071864486,
0.7464097738,
-0.3906359971,
0.7614670992,
-0.2507098019,
-0.1370530874,
0.1646070629,
-0.1485743821,
0.1278183609,
-0.225012973,
-0.228925392,
0.6044044495,
0.431078285,
-0.722640574,
-0.3707822561,
0.44496122,
-0.4873589277,
-0.4109308124,
-0.4570683837,
-0.4804467857,
-0.1350884438,
0.4181746542,
0.1983463019,
0.5094569325,
-0.3504366279,
-0.0667016879,
-0.0950687677,
-0.3617232442,
0.4146055579,
0.1809066236,
-0.5992077589,
-0.3497186303,
1.2020936012,
0.2594849765,
0.4925045073,
0.368514508,
0.2826128602,
-0.1910234094,
-0.6595864892,
-0.3068521023,
0.1090180129,
-0.8523057699,
0.1136832833,
-0.6310785413,
-0.1459743828,
-0.4056541026,
0.1365586966,
-0.3155677021,
-0.5546953082,
-0.2753567994,
-0.0986785293,
-0.0761800408,
0.6971301436,
-0.1986943632,
0.3495646119,
-0.8888760805,
-0.2704828084,
-0.155502364,
0.4510089755,
0.2144260108,
-0.2277368009,
-0.5850102901,
-0.1324701011,
0.2830213904,
-0.4480296969,
0.1425264031,
0.2288307846,
0.8282595277,
0.2074093223,
-0.4090287089,
0.8760599494,
-0.5880713463,
0.8958705664,
0.25521487,
-1.3646786213,
-0.0329305753,
-0.0652696565,
0.5470055938,
0.3985719085,
0.1933880001,
-1.216658473,
-0.4963113666,
-0.1845316887,
-1.1135064363,
0.6306291223,
0.1059075072,
0.5113282204,
-0.3174183369,
0.1558500379,
0.0550413169,
0.2177639753,
-0.7035594583,
-0.1716762334,
-0.1578190625,
0.0355780162,
-0.1990790665,
-0.4033887684,
0.3309925199,
-0.1613653451,
0.5214895606,
-0.1318467855,
-0.030099649,
-0.1848267615,
-0.2400839478,
0.039006684,
0.4558549523,
0.5028778315,
0.585744381,
0.2150491029,
0.1444910616,
0.2000931501,
-0.4272885025,
-0.0471885428,
0.0993021205,
0.0087961005,
0.2288388163,
0.5956306458,
0.7915801406,
0.4998169839,
-0.7269861698,
0.5610342622,
0.0365805812,
0.0409354307,
0.1182653606,
-0.3017221689,
0.0490250029,
-0.1074784175,
0.0479431301,
0.1217214987,
0.2088772207,
-0.4082159996,
0.1450210959,
0.5379129052,
-0.4694049954,
-0.3876204193,
0.4571976066,
0.0753226057,
-0.0641170591,
0.3355700374,
-0.1356221139,
-0.9364092946,
0.5923245549,
0.4212409258,
0.4976999462,
-0.3007557392,
0.0894450471,
0.249513939,
0.3687206507,
0.0482496507,
0.2994793355,
0.1477822512,
-0.8173640966,
-0.5340793729,
-0.6112616658,
-0.1490536332,
-0.13825351,
-0.5986407399,
0.1371738762,
0.0945983827,
-0.4175429344,
0.0727027804,
-0.1844685972,
-0.4336979985,
-0.0345063582,
0.177370742,
0.8304103017,
-0.6777430773,
0.8145334125,
0.6857410669,
-0.4290431142,
-0.4769814312,
-0.1136611626,
-0.1944229603,
-0.5212827921,
0.8520179987,
0.4781207442,
-0.0684117302,
-0.0598679185,
0.2613061965,
-1.0617315769,
0.458386004,
0.087805666,
-0.2878263593,
-0.1364612281,
0.5984998941,
0.7005420923,
-0.2321728766,
0.3159054816,
0.3500158489,
0.4796463847,
-0.1055693105,
-1.2833616734,
-0.1040192917,
-0.3478473425,
0.3579446673,
0.5881524086,
-0.3519280255,
1.0082691908,
-0.0379848145,
-0.4728876948,
0.3577434719,
0.4877942204,
-0.0316661596,
-0.1098897681,
0.6642768979,
0.2722946107,
0.519562304,
0.0191837084,
1.1192984581,
-0.5854610205,
0.3122684062,
1.0849131346,
-0.1654926389,
0.9562446475,
0.8821922541,
-0.0823370069,
0.079033196,
0.6837676167,
-0.0526958369,
0.1605750024,
0.4794507623,
-0.1166421175,
-0.0782275349,
-0.6719371676,
-0.3291359842,
0.5379507542,
0.2600368559,
-0.0212278683,
-0.12898013,
0.3174506724,
-0.1737740338,
-0.0648839995,
-0.3085356355,
0.5343874097,
-0.1501537412,
-0.645406127,
0.2728661299,
0.2521533072,
0.8645361662,
-0.431235671,
0.2636838853,
-0.1671852618,
0.144920215,
-0.254449904,
-0.4543079138,
0.5532108545,
-0.1262159795,
0.1107710972,
-0.3307015896,
0.5944993496,
-0.6558598876,
-0.4261467457,
0.6224716902,
0.914255023,
0.1618368328,
0.0099584358,
-0.6611584425,
0.137685746,
-0.6154686809,
-0.2021835893,
0.3831754327,
0.2129968405,
-0.2838680148,
0.4496067166,
0.6550757289,
0.2107486278,
0.3004207611,
0.5311893225,
0.6884720922,
-0.3576439619,
-0.5970885158,
-0.7947669029,
0.4584297836,
0.1282114983,
-0.4613016844,
0.9353452325,
0.9360809922,
1.2010067701,
0.0636737198,
0.4663517475,
-0.0997503027,
0.1704781353,
-0.3376317918,
0.6557657719,
-0.8425360322,
0.2161667645,
-0.2608241737,
-0.5948665738,
-0.5170763135,
0.1699821353,
-0.3804789484,
0.2393422723,
0.5056620836,
0.6630631089,
0.0270408709,
-0.3219911158,
0.3642402887,
-0.2284433246,
0.2033184469,
-0.0412257686,
1.0577887297,
-0.3805585206,
0.3904919922,
-0.1339972764,
0.1081233993,
0.08341977,
-0.6295896769,
-0.8941091299,
-0.7114382982,
-0.1375615746,
-0.0730664805,
-0.1264432371,
0.8238717318,
0.6992365122,
-1.0398644209,
-0.5817626715,
-0.1039075032,
0.338699013,
-0.3422075808,
-0.2345826328,
0.2518023849,
-0.8038861156,
-0.9017162919,
0.0960904732,
0.3338911533,
0.0794594586,
-0.4124802053,
-0.0310213305,
-0.4230161309,
0.036242146,
0.5950324535,
-0.1599945724,
-0.9753465652,
-0.0985148773,
0.1400325596,
-0.0848158523,
0.1206037328,
1.1881729364,
-0.4902240038,
0.6257358193,
0.4343447387,
0.4673844278,
0.168302089,
-0.3473686576,
0.6346337795,
-0.9289203882,
0.4496980011,
-0.0265305806,
0.531667769,
0.4124832451,
-0.1590160578,
0.3100559711,
0.1325904727,
-0.077477403,
-0.9845221639,
0.2172991335,
-0.4170850217,
-0.5752916336,
0.9924330711,
-0.2610162199,
-0.0036107483,
-0.3887239993,
-0.2276527435,
0.2022513151,
-0.1197942868,
0.472074151,
1.0916110277,
0.1447490305,
-0.1117078066,
-0.4630487263,
0.3044849932,
0.530109942,
-0.676132381,
0.0560267083,
0.1235973462,
-0.051003512,
0.3997209072,
0.4954582453,
-0.2674815953,
0.041917976,
0.0701102242,
0.0954197571,
-0.0302143842,
-0.1300326437,
-0.4788128436,
-0.005843984,
0.1908050925,
-0.1918989271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18357v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18357v1 | DeepSI: Interactive Deep Learning for Semantic Interaction | 2023-05-26T18:05:57 | 2023-05-26T18:05:57 | Yali Bian, Chris North | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | In this paper, we design novel interactive deep learning methods to improve
semantic interactions in visual analytics applications. The ability of semantic
interaction to infer analysts' precise intents during sensemaking is dependent
on the quality of the underlying data representation. We propose the
$\text{DeepSI}_{\text{finetune}}$ framework that integrates deep learning into
the human-in-the-loop interactive sensemaking pipeline, with two important
properties. First, deep learning extracts meaningful representations from raw
data, which improves semantic interaction inference. Second, semantic
interactions are exploited to fine-tune the deep learning representations,
which then further improves semantic interaction inference. This feedback loop
between human interaction and deep learning enables efficient learning of user-
and task-specific representations. To evaluate the advantage of embedding the
deep learning within the semantic interaction loop, we compare
$\text{DeepSI}_{\text{finetune}}$ against a state-of-the-art but more basic use
of deep learning as only a feature extractor pre-processed outside of the
interactive loop. Results of two complementary studies, a human-centered
qualitative case study and an algorithm-centered simulation-based quantitative
experiment, show that $\text{DeepSI}_{\text{finetune}}$ more accurately
captures users' complex mental models with fewer interactions. | [
-0.5569386482,
-0.736803472,
0.7650374174,
-0.0910286084,
-0.1939006746,
-0.0358981639,
-0.4942376018,
-0.6070433855,
0.2301465124,
0.1914774477,
-0.8331975937,
-0.6830688119,
-0.2862539589,
-0.2178244889,
0.0149321295,
0.5921145678,
0.0375905223,
0.4162002504,
-0.3735160828,
-0.1427882612,
-0.6197628975,
-0.2662338316,
-0.6474781036,
-0.338373065,
0.6793667674,
0.6544528008,
0.5977780819,
0.1789910346,
0.6990919113,
0.4350131452,
0.3253461421,
0.4401161373,
-0.6263027191,
0.3329686821,
-0.2114499956,
-0.3933529854,
-0.475982666,
0.198972255,
0.2908981144,
0.9795166254,
0.0290998407,
-0.0652573109,
0.3133856654,
0.4629426301,
-0.6755982637,
0.4015460312,
-0.1294098496,
0.18396312,
-0.0828368962,
-0.0559520274,
-0.2752135396,
0.1289110035,
0.439248383,
-0.9290116429,
-0.2559056878,
-0.1023819074,
0.8114204407,
0.621637404,
-0.453663826,
-0.0289779101,
-0.8158880472,
0.871481359,
-0.830866158,
0.5546526909,
0.0989804193,
0.6089447141,
-0.0909141004,
-0.8939090967,
-0.6070110798,
-0.2185946405,
-0.0759058222,
0.3081327379,
-0.1106695384,
0.3138358891,
0.404304564,
0.0163770579,
-0.1582681388,
0.4990751743,
-0.1044506356,
0.0873084515,
0.8532524705,
0.6502688527,
0.1271569133,
0.0422299653,
-0.2629729509,
-0.2943991721,
-0.2212781459,
0.2707310915,
0.0874850377,
0.1704339832,
-0.1790040135,
0.4751857221,
-0.606705904,
0.4215318263,
0.1278802156,
0.3919147849,
0.2583088875,
-0.4339291155,
-0.6427397728,
0.0163775273,
0.7200509906,
0.6142169237,
0.3903722167,
-0.1834756732,
0.1491498202,
0.1735269576,
0.1654781848,
-1.1282559633,
-0.3469001055,
0.0825322866,
-0.3058894873,
-0.2238228172,
0.4262597263,
-0.5271373987,
-0.6632945538,
-1.1677668095,
0.2570067644,
-0.4985984266,
-0.4736507833,
0.1347566396,
-0.0833953694,
0.461310178,
0.612826407,
-0.6552670598,
0.344070673,
0.9472665787,
0.2742137313,
-0.3596652746,
-0.4197825193,
-0.8933635354,
0.2243873924,
-0.328530252,
0.5967294574,
-0.6698870659,
-0.0537591614,
-0.2839494348,
-0.0249010529,
-0.0178329125,
-0.3360308707,
0.0661327839,
-0.4588742256,
-0.1675980091,
-0.3041394353,
-0.9216225147,
-0.2359919101,
0.0939857513,
-0.508887589,
0.2965788543,
-0.3297178745,
-0.3631230891,
1.0223118067,
-0.8511294723,
-0.1703135967,
0.3160396218,
-0.5018639565,
-0.2976373136,
0.0547038876,
0.0755582228,
0.8880888224,
0.072228834,
0.3137879074,
-1.0010522604,
-0.3408184052,
0.5558484197,
-0.514835,
0.2981582582,
0.4072059691,
-0.3739593327,
0.5670918822,
-0.7855545282,
0.1557624787,
-0.1028879136,
0.0494200252,
-0.3802450001,
-0.0558844656,
-0.0780319348,
-0.0779366121,
0.0288839564,
-0.5652819872,
-0.0612123311,
-0.4567525685,
0.2820926309,
0.5031901598,
-0.0166969504,
0.7796657681,
0.4717989862,
0.230225265,
0.2670839429,
0.0419756174,
-0.0439409986,
-0.1995964646,
-0.8637158871,
-0.1835077107,
0.5116348267,
0.4194399118,
-0.550871551,
0.2782516479,
-0.4065691233,
-0.2016279995,
-0.5869638324,
0.2983694375,
0.2969497144,
0.2458572984,
0.1368381083,
-0.1828522682,
-0.4886014163,
-0.663295269,
-0.2123269886,
0.3940912485,
-0.2098096758,
0.3735869527,
0.2574851215,
-0.3822771311,
1.3517621756,
-0.4296756983,
-0.3731617332,
-0.2025852203,
0.3458171487,
-0.0933799595,
0.6151747108,
0.5717116594,
-0.908182323,
-0.2697843909,
0.2800751925,
-1.1388249397,
0.3814253211,
-0.1721141189,
-0.1385270804,
0.0070092431,
0.6288752556,
-0.4144025743,
0.7964398861,
0.0398251377,
-0.5326217413,
0.0464538597,
-0.065554969,
0.21300596,
-0.8380829096,
0.0347247422,
0.0458726473,
-0.1164894775,
-0.6529709101,
-0.1770131886,
-0.1825357825,
-0.4116430879,
-0.5274428129,
0.4337343574,
-0.331220597,
-0.1586271822,
-0.1089041233,
0.0958361179,
0.2763511837,
0.7384941578,
0.09261778,
0.5734171271,
0.4067608416,
-0.682435751,
0.513153851,
0.2486868054,
-0.5412077308,
0.8095145822,
-0.6363773346,
-0.0301158559,
-0.1229947656,
-0.1059525013,
-0.832828939,
-0.5888759494,
0.3584238589,
-0.5422918797,
0.3427269161,
-0.1884334385,
-0.2359468192,
0.1303341687,
-0.2033471465,
0.1931547225,
0.2168011069,
-0.592684865,
0.8369223475,
0.3176852763,
0.1865092814,
-0.1908074617,
-1.091332674,
0.1307177544,
-0.3563162982,
-0.9151251912,
0.0723704398,
-0.0132144764,
-0.4600220919,
0.1809375137,
0.0261099171,
-0.0827296823,
0.2925826907,
0.3990777433,
0.1449220181,
-0.4159338772,
0.0858330056,
0.2340154797,
-0.5114640594,
0.1731413901,
0.0989622623,
0.1814548522,
-0.5018280745,
-0.804023385,
-1.1017146111,
0.5098467469,
0.4772309661,
-0.3542561233,
0.3849030137,
0.8385083079,
-0.2467585057,
0.1979126632,
-0.5302506089,
-0.3014384806,
-0.5273227692,
0.2617608607,
-0.7057603598,
-0.9683110714,
0.4370580912,
-0.4295845628,
-0.0288932715,
0.3779467642,
0.0874066725,
-0.5884414315,
1.6287013292,
0.5600267053,
0.1651396304,
0.5324646831,
-0.6963467598,
0.1426933259,
-0.7495929003,
-0.385951519,
-0.0573401526,
-0.6750700474,
-0.3810212612,
-0.0022049572,
0.1936705112,
0.376067549,
-0.4723110497,
0.0284290481,
-0.2748759687,
0.3173628151,
0.5484488606,
0.3153289258,
0.1384885013,
0.1392919868,
0.2374771833,
-0.3892843723,
-0.683932364,
-0.2390054166,
0.4667154551,
0.4749191105,
1.1869498491,
-0.0225257128,
0.7907813191,
0.1576631069,
-0.0689462274,
-1.0188077688,
0.5063351393,
-0.044103656,
0.1125530079,
-0.5319591761,
-0.3830643296,
-1.0460224152,
-0.0251447093,
-0.4664515555,
-0.655279994,
0.7322143912,
0.1929174215,
-0.6657132506,
0.0842550248,
-1.2049645185,
1.1666039228,
-0.3024680912,
-0.4677101076,
-0.6428819895,
-0.5259037018,
-0.0482501574,
0.7257719636,
-0.1922450662,
-0.2626469433,
0.1093027666,
0.6601933241,
-0.4136348665,
1.4071627855,
-0.3955483735,
0.1562821865,
0.2526631951,
0.2919853926,
0.384283036,
0.406375587,
0.0622339398,
0.1177085489,
-0.1190834716,
-0.137496233,
-0.8362199068,
0.8150551319,
-0.5674903393,
-0.4007834196,
-0.1845102161,
-0.3177704513,
-0.2274814248,
0.2089751512,
-0.0954235569,
0.6205250621,
-0.2648295462,
0.5227231979,
0.5571838021,
0.2097605914,
0.4473257661,
0.242010057,
0.1805245876,
-0.4049410224,
1.2184627056,
0.0477604568,
-0.0480294265,
0.0237425119,
0.0982483551,
0.0037048957,
-0.294840306,
-0.5256328583,
-0.2355274558,
-0.6381286979,
-0.1914690137,
-0.3847964406,
-0.1224398017,
-0.171035558,
-0.3159248233,
-0.1538022757,
-0.0296938904,
-0.739854157,
-0.090039894,
0.6056495309,
0.3696954846,
-0.138102293,
0.189325735,
-0.63614887,
0.112026453,
0.6735963225,
0.6792777777,
0.1213696897,
0.2374006361,
-0.2202472985,
0.4126852155,
0.0715808645,
-0.5188639164,
0.0099852057,
0.1473148316,
0.5697106123,
0.7077839971,
0.0034543504,
0.9627706409,
0.0577790327,
0.5148053169,
0.3778459728,
-0.8105329871,
0.5167779922,
-0.1694179922,
0.386669606,
0.9405126572,
0.1158562526,
-0.38492167,
-0.1120931804,
-0.5074030757,
-0.5934802294,
0.7407943606,
0.0187086966,
0.1385999769,
0.096079044,
0.1230555922,
-0.0053317025,
0.1015635729,
-0.0613745786,
0.1718698591,
-0.1615632921,
-0.401751399,
0.2005298585,
-0.247404024,
-0.0259683132,
-0.5595113039,
0.2697691321,
-0.4611454308,
-0.1649269909,
0.3251693845,
-0.1941104829,
0.1703253388,
-0.0640830323,
0.0466170236,
0.74306494,
0.0333661251,
-0.0813760087,
0.5832404494,
-0.0779137015,
-0.4636410177,
0.119425483,
0.0378137752,
-0.3144794405,
0.396086961,
1.3873535395,
0.583627224,
-0.7783430815,
0.5378110409,
-0.1118246913,
-0.0742384419,
-0.5079337358,
0.4154022038,
-0.0739679039,
0.825042069,
0.1001423076,
0.0915651545,
0.6146308184,
-0.4215590656,
0.2494859546,
0.5996899605,
-0.7722986937,
-0.1228946671,
0.5849870443,
0.5971797705,
-0.1635272205,
0.6821867824,
-0.1528311074,
-0.0221168082,
0.6415131688,
-0.260004431,
0.9163327217,
0.1090519577,
0.0895082131,
0.1203454137,
-0.4545315802,
0.7197098136,
0.2923390567,
-0.516215086,
-0.5657730103,
-0.7906196713,
-0.3646104336,
-0.402125001,
-0.1587338299,
-0.7360337973,
0.4200772345,
-0.2066161782,
-0.1136822626,
0.3231140971,
0.1556820869,
-1.0539444685,
0.1444133371,
0.4000298083,
0.7437241673,
-0.5170116425,
0.6301606894,
0.4910766482,
-0.4915418327,
-0.693969965,
-0.4275121689,
-0.1241208017,
-0.4398424923,
0.6276304126,
0.2261736691,
-0.4095133841,
0.1139168441,
-0.8509740829,
-0.5623621345,
1.1337326765,
0.3428679705,
-0.5409301519,
0.2722983062,
0.2042172551,
0.4164035618,
-0.5737734437,
0.1910114586,
0.8379966617,
0.6949389577,
0.0926849544,
-0.3873847723,
-0.0339303091,
-0.2599684,
-0.0136777963,
0.053067483,
-0.3916203082,
0.0592149831,
-0.2825965583,
-0.2428165078,
0.0451634824,
1.2002173662,
-0.0537404306,
0.7767524123,
0.5827586055,
0.5988080502,
0.6741946936,
-0.16313079,
0.7821111083,
0.217259571,
0.1202427596,
1.2728177309,
-0.3087305427,
0.7295386791,
0.4863059819,
0.2005635649,
0.4677864611,
0.5981401205,
-0.301843971,
0.4976254702,
-0.1404248476,
-0.0692417994,
-0.6751343012,
-0.2183706909,
-0.1451342404,
0.4683163762,
0.5144686699,
0.1639669687,
-0.1739108413,
0.426173538,
0.0062780408,
0.1410848796,
-0.2301193625,
1.3607134819,
0.1721462458,
-0.3922905028,
0.167369917,
-0.4113954008,
0.5876992941,
-0.5023761392,
-0.4087581635,
-0.1032732055,
0.3007394969,
-0.4450862408,
-1.1958812475,
0.2369919866,
-0.3116697371,
-0.1186387464,
0.0552215725,
0.7924879789,
-0.4830581546,
-0.3103289008,
0.3799517453,
0.2246022224,
0.0350310393,
-0.0099340063,
-0.5925598741,
0.329303354,
-0.2648368776,
-0.3327047527,
0.3893779814,
0.5628194213,
0.0034718877,
0.5518440008,
0.7334069014,
-0.5726612806,
-0.1105521619,
0.5047143698,
0.9365515709,
-0.6507011056,
-0.5521295071,
-0.7620959878,
0.7351569533,
-0.6915279031,
-0.3270435631,
0.5791602731,
0.2920130789,
0.787317276,
0.0143661825,
0.49530375,
0.0144623304,
0.0589046031,
-0.6518028378,
0.6698310971,
-0.5183647871,
0.1441299468,
-0.1059259921,
-0.6160871983,
-0.2433398217,
0.3378068805,
-0.4228089452,
-0.0049661756,
0.2853356004,
0.5237424374,
-0.614861846,
0.1062081754,
0.3247567713,
0.1651872844,
0.3105300963,
0.4416558743,
0.8160145283,
-0.1315942258,
0.4415881038,
-0.4904232919,
-0.3323688209,
-0.2556144893,
-0.6959813833,
-0.9445426464,
-0.4147646725,
-0.4457525611,
-0.2140924186,
-0.1439545155,
0.8969277143,
1.0260090828,
-0.8911402225,
-0.1312526017,
-0.1792218238,
-0.0261478014,
-0.3542713523,
-0.2632164955,
0.2721887827,
-0.559576869,
-0.8353435397,
0.5330287218,
0.2091280073,
-0.0122912899,
-0.3427484632,
-0.4553275406,
0.2076291144,
-0.3539215028,
0.7074258924,
0.2622301877,
-0.655960083,
-0.2886587679,
0.0681766868,
0.0224724375,
-0.1251139939,
0.860609293,
-1.0327861309,
0.4277071953,
0.6411308646,
0.9424148202,
0.8818348646,
-0.2341153324,
0.61210531,
-0.403532356,
0.2932340503,
0.1342924684,
0.3001793623,
0.1040274352,
-0.5238689184,
0.5408404469,
0.031202428,
-0.1901218891,
-0.5945051312,
0.3158604503,
-1.1967259645,
-0.3347646892,
0.7603239417,
-0.0595967919,
-0.2516055107,
0.0908831358,
-0.3555560708,
0.1815074384,
-0.478204608,
0.2965369523,
0.2776471376,
-0.350553602,
-0.0515267476,
-0.4187365472,
0.5338196158,
0.6146301627,
-0.7359283566,
-0.0834574252,
0.5047590137,
0.0315781124,
-0.019535806,
-0.1100157499,
0.2947545648,
0.4496693611,
-0.2372841835,
0.0055565755,
-0.4599248767,
-0.4543284178,
-0.3451203108,
-0.1347290128,
-0.146007821,
-0.3599960506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17174v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17174v1 | From Dogwhistles to Bullhorns: Unveiling Coded Rhetoric with Language Models | 2023-05-26T18:00:57 | 2023-05-26T18:00:57 | Julia Mendelsohn, Ronan Le Bras, Yejin Choi, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Dogwhistles are coded expressions that simultaneously convey one meaning to a
broad audience and a second one, often hateful or provocative, to a narrow
in-group; they are deployed to evade both political repercussions and
algorithmic content moderation. For example, in the sentence 'we need to end
the cosmopolitan experiment,' the word 'cosmopolitan' likely means 'worldly' to
many, but secretly means 'Jewish' to a select few. We present the first
large-scale computational investigation of dogwhistles. We develop a typology
of dogwhistles, curate the largest-to-date glossary of over 300 dogwhistles
with rich contextual information and examples, and analyze their usage in
historical U.S. politicians' speeches. We then assess whether a large language
model (GPT-3) can identify dogwhistles and their meanings, and find that
GPT-3's performance varies widely across types of dogwhistles and targeted
groups. Finally, we show that harmful content containing dogwhistles avoids
toxicity detection, highlighting online risks of such coded language. This work
sheds light on the theoretical and applied importance of dogwhistles in both
NLP and computational social science, and provides resources for future
research in modeling dogwhistles and mitigating their online harms. | [
-0.4448580444,
-0.9989700913,
0.341466248,
0.1285229474,
-0.3619837165,
0.2312409878,
-0.4322857857,
-0.4768582582,
0.098463878,
0.5223770738,
-0.414789021,
-0.5039110184,
-0.8950137496,
-0.1995755583,
-0.6452490687,
1.316572547,
0.3595531583,
-0.1225211471,
0.1129773781,
-0.0819656551,
-0.0169171914,
-0.333040446,
-0.1833719164,
-0.4123854041,
0.6857793331,
0.0243518818,
1.1305823326,
0.7572128773,
0.6319323182,
0.2465094626,
-0.088928096,
-0.3246529996,
-0.4990332425,
0.2546579242,
-0.5213274956,
-0.3729329705,
0.057986699,
0.359845072,
0.1165526807,
0.8707839847,
-0.2766371071,
0.1752835214,
-0.0308113229,
0.3454478085,
-0.3799062669,
0.3403098285,
-1.0411008596,
-0.0986453667,
-0.5957958698,
-0.186386615,
-0.32447806,
-0.5709661841,
0.1314888299,
-0.4552207589,
0.0558710806,
0.1480374187,
0.8312208652,
0.1223241314,
-0.2086963356,
-0.5828337669,
-0.4427056015,
0.6777775288,
-0.5195231438,
0.0034656751,
0.4007865489,
0.1711927205,
-0.3303339183,
-0.9424606562,
-0.5300356746,
-0.2406360805,
-0.0963459909,
0.0673650876,
-0.7208359241,
0.106943503,
0.178543359,
0.1658324152,
-0.727401197,
-0.0098751755,
-0.5509465337,
-0.2451431006,
0.6447947621,
0.1684056222,
0.3109824657,
-0.3696382642,
-0.047143124,
-0.0619692318,
-0.5205457211,
-0.2523476779,
0.3560536504,
0.34668383,
-0.0018036764,
0.5411210656,
0.1878082752,
0.5157799125,
-0.1410013139,
0.1023299769,
-0.1187023446,
-0.0212952346,
0.0165454336,
-0.1501979381,
0.76854527,
0.2755940557,
0.5779839754,
-0.2145059556,
0.150009051,
0.7732515335,
0.3200491369,
-0.7412474751,
-0.4047006071,
0.2484058589,
-0.7541719079,
-0.5346126556,
-0.2105469257,
-0.934872508,
-0.6778233051,
0.0559255444,
0.1231339723,
-0.3565783799,
-0.4647425413,
0.3292467594,
-0.5198609233,
0.3269874454,
-0.1793081164,
-0.7063714862,
0.4790040553,
0.9512677193,
0.5479784608,
-0.1574969143,
-0.3792195022,
-0.2813446224,
0.0256609544,
-0.402877003,
0.5687720776,
-1.0155465603,
-0.4664191604,
0.2092792988,
-0.1982678175,
0.3308956325,
-0.5368152261,
0.5882349014,
-0.6339758039,
0.2581350505,
-0.0095693273,
-0.601965487,
-0.1789223403,
0.0660872832,
-0.5440628529,
0.8434729576,
-0.2162700742,
-0.8975650072,
-0.0108606415,
-0.6925806403,
-0.6023261547,
0.2354668975,
-0.166978538,
-0.1394818872,
0.4405332506,
-0.3423344195,
0.3502355218,
-0.4271778464,
0.4647272229,
-0.3644782305,
-0.268211633,
0.1887677908,
-0.2240941077,
0.8816165924,
0.2375489473,
-0.4354759455,
0.3354644179,
-0.6787791848,
0.0937459543,
0.3801642656,
0.0934035257,
-0.6513531208,
0.2882311344,
0.1454013735,
0.1864036173,
0.0632763728,
-0.496753633,
0.1052147821,
-0.2134870142,
0.6799303293,
0.7610599995,
-0.1464729458,
-0.0324139073,
-0.4106456637,
0.453255564,
-0.5200754404,
0.2840260267,
0.0196143482,
-0.8199729323,
-0.2788975537,
0.0306428447,
0.0314102098,
0.4069187343,
-0.6115381718,
0.1585977226,
-0.287030071,
-0.7981066108,
-0.2313864231,
-0.4778854251,
0.3234778643,
-0.0454755761,
0.1847516894,
0.0219139401,
-0.4900290668,
-0.9920917153,
-0.6615361571,
-0.4451742768,
-0.0818181932,
-0.095119223,
0.5775756836,
-0.084511444,
0.7415956855,
-0.5915463567,
0.1913100481,
-0.0794123933,
0.7347968221,
-0.0082822992,
0.0045429352,
0.1520671248,
-0.6337122917,
-0.3666558564,
-0.0819350332,
-0.3640092611,
-0.2859214246,
-0.0015423001,
-0.1855217665,
-0.4411966801,
0.321680814,
-0.6297748685,
0.3091709912,
0.8037235737,
-0.2831405997,
0.8009068966,
0.2042225748,
-0.032001134,
-0.8882843256,
0.0286593828,
-0.0635028407,
0.074659951,
-0.720600307,
0.5223478675,
-0.0773117468,
-0.1923217773,
-0.377610594,
0.3816590011,
-0.2365281433,
0.2021855712,
-0.4190825224,
0.3277238905,
-0.1730594337,
0.2675819397,
0.0588868074,
0.5361640453,
0.3994653523,
-0.2902109027,
0.5561616421,
0.0965392143,
-0.0617433377,
0.5410471559,
-0.4358925819,
0.1512683779,
-0.2198299766,
0.3316088021,
-0.7721551657,
-0.2992566526,
0.257329464,
-0.5033863187,
0.1300214976,
-0.0582022481,
-0.4280777872,
-0.5115156174,
-0.4862679541,
0.386002779,
0.5549512506,
-0.3687664866,
0.2002015114,
0.6547086239,
-0.1623656005,
-0.1807267219,
-0.6446940303,
0.42232126,
-0.4613569379,
-0.5368587375,
0.5442661643,
-0.0049631875,
-0.6323872805,
-0.0246217828,
0.0870655254,
-0.0942066908,
-0.098106049,
0.2937332392,
0.1317119747,
0.0251467135,
0.3700236976,
-0.2408851981,
0.0079485457,
0.3672843575,
-0.4110923409,
0.5979034901,
-0.3607274294,
-0.2447465956,
-0.1362406611,
0.6814719439,
0.6456970572,
-0.2674108148,
0.5313577652,
0.5896112919,
-0.4443251193,
-0.1422623694,
-0.5066959858,
-0.2621139884,
-0.4719876647,
0.5360803604,
-0.2029476315,
-0.8326455951,
0.4697289765,
-0.191247955,
0.0206697304,
0.4328724444,
0.4783887565,
0.1063249186,
0.7958962321,
0.4088493586,
-0.1431895494,
0.1458616406,
0.2180156559,
0.2303209901,
-0.4997321367,
-0.1953660697,
-0.9015206695,
0.1030635908,
-0.910731554,
-0.4987273812,
0.2020254433,
-0.2834897041,
-0.2922547758,
0.3250233233,
-0.6181498766,
0.4478286505,
0.284607321,
-0.2390446365,
0.0607994944,
0.1223639175,
-0.1273046583,
-0.3276567459,
-0.4155659974,
-0.5435521007,
0.8196001649,
0.3461060524,
0.9336789846,
0.0528865308,
0.3054667711,
0.4869590402,
0.4710851014,
-0.916328311,
0.7279945612,
-0.1008252129,
-0.8193884492,
-0.1439443678,
-0.2700180113,
-1.1747373343,
0.2535546422,
0.0534453578,
-0.8092618585,
-0.3042710423,
-0.0376305394,
0.0122257136,
0.4728187025,
-0.1789979339,
0.722271204,
-0.2814128995,
-0.5323643684,
-0.4753925204,
-0.6807401776,
0.349173516,
0.030806426,
0.6666271687,
-0.1454204619,
-0.1854101866,
0.635933876,
-0.1680172533,
0.8930602074,
0.1845005751,
-0.3219706416,
0.2362852991,
0.30881688,
0.7209111452,
-0.6088851094,
-0.0937035829,
0.3848771453,
0.090943262,
-0.5478002429,
-0.3184345365,
0.4923644066,
-0.207277,
-0.610822916,
-0.2968302071,
-0.4734868407,
-0.0847537294,
0.0885818824,
0.1948139668,
0.5505340695,
-0.230529353,
0.2426339537,
0.596685648,
-0.4368906021,
0.4253422618,
0.4037662148,
-0.4669875205,
-0.2433635294,
1.1239744425,
-0.1949493438,
0.3649531901,
0.0023577455,
0.4851095378,
-0.3270384371,
-0.5862439871,
-0.159743309,
0.3141926825,
-0.7637107372,
-0.0115056979,
-0.4109103382,
-0.1334294528,
0.0979535356,
-0.1333078593,
-0.3196310997,
-0.21326527,
-0.0099456338,
0.091806367,
0.3151584268,
1.0988197327,
-0.1392287016,
0.1880736798,
-0.6007787585,
0.0427083112,
0.1616342813,
0.527015686,
-0.1445220858,
-0.3272193074,
0.0729318187,
-0.282905221,
-0.1822451055,
-1.4981746674,
0.2138446718,
-0.057178773,
0.4450945854,
0.3401978314,
0.2459179461,
0.4555489421,
-0.6415338516,
0.9301094413,
0.2349645942,
-1.0145027637,
0.5209576488,
-0.854575932,
0.1033577994,
0.2081585675,
0.5386582613,
-0.9182015657,
-0.8551936746,
-0.5982542038,
-0.703420639,
0.1570540965,
0.1493093967,
0.5499591231,
-0.5172625184,
0.041988261,
0.2843457758,
0.276055038,
-0.654523015,
-0.2984515131,
-0.2933391333,
-0.200590834,
0.4080442488,
-0.2141564339,
-0.3328962326,
-0.1228477508,
0.6317721605,
-0.0949953645,
0.0312125813,
-0.2352858186,
-0.0317498706,
-0.0788037106,
0.5617696047,
0.6105379462,
0.6322386861,
-0.0580871589,
0.4669877887,
-0.2032522857,
-0.6544704437,
0.0125807701,
0.0662710369,
-0.0515435822,
-0.0393960215,
0.4574692547,
0.352058351,
0.1373920143,
-0.7213823199,
0.4740100801,
0.1620680541,
-0.138665244,
-0.0821439922,
-0.4203670323,
0.2610660493,
0.1399440616,
0.4957494438,
-0.1333692968,
0.3018216491,
-0.7729151249,
0.3348144591,
0.7733025551,
-0.2812519968,
-0.2794792652,
0.6199712753,
0.1374844164,
-0.3052892983,
0.1721556336,
-0.4254689813,
-0.8008906245,
0.3887145817,
0.6877986789,
0.72549963,
-0.1320100278,
0.4913884401,
0.2237563282,
0.5201699138,
0.2683993876,
-0.0106605543,
0.1560610235,
-0.4437882602,
-0.269605428,
-0.6017237306,
-0.312813431,
0.4977739155,
-0.7057621479,
-0.1027493328,
-0.3398455977,
-0.3053835928,
0.2882687151,
-0.0188025571,
-0.1761103719,
-0.1989352554,
0.3611302376,
0.7792807817,
-0.9376776218,
0.6752428412,
0.5548240542,
-0.276242584,
-0.569632411,
0.4497932792,
0.2634452581,
-0.6725820303,
0.3977690339,
0.0326205567,
-0.3370628357,
0.0885483474,
-0.8078320026,
-0.7039916515,
0.4632562399,
0.0039030383,
-0.3563112915,
0.0515373498,
0.1210108027,
0.4871456027,
-0.0342437215,
0.1476769149,
0.7237355709,
0.5814124942,
0.139210254,
-0.9756341577,
0.3597382605,
-0.33582744,
0.0190864056,
0.2814790905,
-0.5902341008,
0.8438890576,
0.0757526681,
-0.2972931862,
-0.0430348143,
0.4007338583,
0.105207935,
-0.0316670947,
0.1697016209,
0.0246811882,
0.7547304034,
-0.0868735835,
1.0126852989,
-0.3153239787,
0.2424686849,
0.9491737485,
-0.2229864448,
0.6948179007,
0.3048825562,
-0.4595934153,
0.4429184198,
0.4070982933,
-0.023677811,
0.346855402,
0.9577692747,
-0.3779218793,
-0.0064276913,
-0.3269073367,
-0.3983894587,
0.5529565215,
0.6340169907,
-0.1942934394,
-0.4308766425,
0.2194624096,
0.4702633619,
0.4170099795,
-0.277869463,
0.4802990556,
0.0243808813,
-0.7377749681,
0.5942726731,
0.1707277596,
0.8666884899,
-0.8199396133,
0.0295061208,
-0.0890263319,
-0.0658679008,
-0.0600573048,
-0.8897840381,
0.5550086498,
0.0579384603,
0.0516105928,
0.0228403602,
0.8264789581,
-0.3705979586,
-0.2227630168,
0.5300343037,
0.3051666021,
0.3321890533,
-0.1913716048,
-0.7055795789,
0.494941175,
-0.0796517134,
-0.1821961105,
0.1423268467,
0.2175188959,
-0.1304023266,
0.6545962691,
0.5281294584,
0.2626528442,
0.1645865142,
0.1066500768,
0.8920015693,
-0.5454744697,
-0.287383765,
-0.9806286693,
0.2856319249,
-0.1668998897,
0.0115508633,
0.7550733089,
0.4894822836,
0.6776827574,
0.1182949916,
1.0131140947,
-0.1853675246,
0.2964244187,
-0.2173675001,
0.8355611563,
-0.3649443686,
0.1133504435,
-0.2565250695,
-0.3975888491,
-0.3138724864,
0.5486742258,
-0.453928113,
-0.1688960493,
0.8520324826,
0.853088975,
0.0887556821,
0.4338179231,
0.3772552013,
0.3252578974,
0.2876036465,
0.2875887752,
1.0652111769,
0.0056740353,
0.9025979042,
-0.1710071564,
-0.2791703343,
-0.0159275103,
-0.8326380253,
-0.8234981298,
-0.6035291553,
-0.3269073367,
-0.57011199,
0.2333041877,
0.8722376227,
0.5310527086,
-0.4732267857,
-0.2951393425,
-0.0479339175,
-0.0652800128,
-0.0114233326,
-0.2484043837,
0.2966693938,
-0.185659796,
-0.4632756412,
0.109264411,
0.3052923679,
-0.2842262089,
-0.3899132311,
0.0685077235,
0.0127766998,
0.5994535685,
0.7324637771,
0.2259287089,
-1.0634403229,
-0.4120384753,
-0.226239115,
-0.215202108,
-0.1900018603,
0.8617071509,
-0.4726687968,
0.3466628492,
0.1560872793,
0.4259363413,
0.2505963147,
-0.0486037843,
0.2673909664,
-0.5316411853,
0.1281552613,
0.4200919271,
0.0452400222,
0.1980736703,
-0.0402620099,
0.3891681433,
0.4035660625,
-0.2782190442,
-0.6536765695,
0.6737645864,
-0.5748037696,
-0.6911729574,
1.247171998,
-0.0137204137,
-0.1788652241,
-0.2922865152,
-0.1885190755,
0.2080941051,
-0.1660693139,
0.7930679321,
0.9387835264,
0.143294394,
-0.0682517365,
-0.8912347555,
0.6910941005,
0.1905987561,
-0.9618036151,
0.3263097405,
0.6579653621,
0.3426581323,
0.1675315052,
0.6412295699,
-0.2078095526,
0.1156992391,
0.3760525882,
0.129472062,
0.1631076932,
-0.0870158076,
-0.1346343011,
0.4783698916,
-0.1175719872,
-0.0919386297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17131v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17131v1 | RAMP: Retrieval and Attribute-Marking Enhanced Prompting for Attribute-Controlled Translation | 2023-05-26T17:56:53 | 2023-05-26T17:56:53 | Gabriele Sarti, Phu Mon Htut, Xing Niu, Benjamin Hsu, Anna Currey, Georgiana Dinu, Maria Nadejde | cs.CL | cs.CL | Attribute-controlled translation (ACT) is a subtask of machine translation
that involves controlling stylistic or linguistic attributes (like formality
and gender) of translation outputs. While ACT has garnered attention in recent
years due to its usefulness in real-world applications, progress in the task is
currently limited by dataset availability, since most prior approaches rely on
supervised methods. To address this limitation, we propose Retrieval and
Attribute-Marking enhanced Prompting (RAMP), which leverages large multilingual
language models to perform ACT in few-shot and zero-shot settings. RAMP
improves generation accuracy over the standard prompting approach by (1)
incorporating a semantic similarity retrieval component for selecting similar
in-context examples, and (2) marking in-context examples with attribute
annotations. Our comprehensive experiments show that RAMP is a viable approach
in both zero-shot and few-shot settings. | [
-0.1691762507,
-0.9318862557,
0.2451057434,
0.3615987003,
-0.0054254928,
0.0181353278,
-0.0074324496,
-0.1381193101,
-0.050351128,
0.4561699629,
-1.0353933573,
-0.3363592029,
-0.4663007557,
0.3088478148,
-0.7964996099,
0.9990234971,
-0.2779341042,
0.0835793316,
0.0318416134,
-0.2114614993,
-0.7619357109,
-0.1588491946,
-0.7980914116,
-0.4420753717,
0.6390317082,
0.3949207962,
0.6208363175,
0.454782486,
0.8080165982,
0.1669589579,
0.1960410029,
0.285415411,
-0.4830991924,
0.3451885581,
0.0659254119,
-0.3147799671,
-0.5689103007,
0.1122431904,
0.8621576428,
0.3950756788,
0.1983981878,
0.0623289496,
-0.2902017832,
0.3902686238,
-0.5106748939,
-0.1210538074,
-0.6068038344,
0.0583625697,
-0.0934198424,
-0.3141195178,
-0.6163756251,
-0.2374060452,
-0.3144946992,
-0.569513917,
0.1341608167,
0.3405502439,
0.7700137496,
0.1989672035,
-0.5857649446,
-0.0664231405,
-0.5634504557,
0.9762679935,
-0.5367845893,
0.4925694168,
0.6103858948,
0.2724179327,
-0.3062614501,
-0.7241279483,
-0.7842790484,
-0.5192537308,
-0.3482066989,
0.0105832871,
0.1253482848,
-0.0604982227,
0.4641135037,
0.2992340326,
-0.5239947438,
0.2531517446,
-0.3589200974,
-0.3692268729,
0.5639362931,
0.1666820049,
0.6850193739,
-0.3292693198,
-0.5711744428,
-0.2834851742,
-1.2473794222,
0.0735272393,
0.1550264508,
0.7149062157,
0.0306690838,
0.6642808914,
-0.3587145209,
0.7889015079,
0.0870639458,
0.0731325522,
0.315421313,
-0.290438354,
-0.035733588,
-0.1293258071,
0.8594620228,
0.0866106674,
-0.0134506198,
-0.0323962457,
-0.5212259889,
-0.526455164,
0.1002389789,
-0.668043375,
0.2656023502,
0.2711062729,
-0.0322964713,
-0.2263752818,
0.0127861686,
-0.4668558538,
-0.317147553,
-0.2784804702,
0.7223315239,
-0.5856031775,
-0.1823872328,
-0.353097111,
-0.0649679154,
0.8164710999,
0.4839363694,
-0.8363819122,
0.1389916241,
0.7182824612,
1.0189630985,
-0.6477178335,
-0.5247494578,
-1.3649665117,
0.1743775457,
-0.4623172879,
0.5402014852,
-0.7815213203,
-0.3589729667,
0.2165183574,
-0.011846046,
-0.0656688288,
-0.2696067989,
0.3731868863,
-0.6820724607,
0.1321174502,
-0.2364801764,
-0.251586318,
-0.0700322688,
0.3561915159,
-0.6614368558,
1.4727108479,
0.3659647405,
0.015719654,
0.6661620736,
-0.8336651325,
-0.8659138083,
0.2969346046,
-0.3246741295,
-0.1650606543,
0.0373935401,
0.2866825759,
0.408742398,
-0.0616597719,
-0.0278580766,
0.3789680898,
-0.3136222064,
0.1779967546,
-0.1995208412,
0.5516453981,
0.2182283551,
-0.1809279323,
0.3505727351,
-0.404428035,
0.0211144947,
-0.258248508,
-0.3164375722,
-0.1827854961,
-0.389601469,
0.0705038607,
0.6221165061,
0.055748459,
-0.4742339849,
0.413836509,
-0.0318903811,
0.0085976683,
0.6653684378,
0.0126533974,
0.5019364953,
-0.2504023314,
0.7082279921,
0.043279659,
-0.0367069356,
-0.2229062021,
-0.5859401226,
-0.5814006329,
-0.3767736852,
0.0872723684,
0.5701596737,
-1.0695006847,
0.0521218181,
-0.3795250654,
-0.1356914341,
-0.8655520678,
0.4307467639,
0.5169259906,
0.6941339374,
0.5510720611,
-0.248715356,
0.0670123547,
-0.6143583655,
-0.3031080961,
-0.0444225855,
-0.2209843099,
0.304653585,
0.6526129842,
0.1580767035,
0.7628164887,
-0.5131966472,
-0.8271310329,
-0.7408927679,
0.7352294922,
0.055187583,
0.6550778151,
0.5020782948,
-1.0100573301,
-0.6678621769,
0.1198627129,
-0.3589071929,
-0.4629013836,
-0.3868246377,
-0.3935022652,
-0.1310441494,
0.6194311976,
-0.631065309,
0.3839434683,
0.2530675828,
-0.2309861183,
0.2760054767,
-0.138402462,
0.7686061859,
-0.9354866147,
0.2504990399,
-0.2649110258,
-0.4159968495,
-0.9434284568,
0.4252928793,
0.2223933339,
-0.1292369068,
-0.9638128877,
0.8949979544,
-0.290974468,
0.1681241691,
-0.321860522,
0.2350597531,
0.0156921335,
0.4597038031,
0.1983332336,
1.1440135241,
0.4361820519,
-0.8582808971,
0.3183735013,
0.7307846546,
-0.0251819137,
1.0238878727,
-0.4165106118,
0.3513579369,
-0.2310640812,
0.1135162115,
-0.7732180357,
-0.4645105004,
0.0342627876,
-0.5040866137,
0.635674417,
-0.0257856492,
-0.3926252425,
-0.2207662612,
-0.4639792442,
0.3400434852,
0.6197186112,
-0.2054003775,
0.5027692318,
-0.138029173,
-0.1116953865,
-0.5560669303,
-0.8982861638,
-0.0173268076,
0.0040168683,
-0.1030289978,
0.1005745754,
-0.0483868755,
0.0413174294,
-0.2647903264,
0.1432781368,
-0.2776974738,
-0.0083787469,
-0.0056943623,
0.169092834,
-0.0503170639,
0.2272473723,
0.1781474948,
-0.1053163335,
-0.3685033023,
0.1168829575,
0.4972053766,
0.1478117853,
-0.4759782255,
-0.4234091938,
0.6992506385,
0.4608585835,
-0.6301419735,
0.7487824559,
0.8930447698,
-0.2779306471,
-0.234825477,
-0.3277207017,
-0.418551445,
-0.4540545344,
0.3931736946,
-0.6369074583,
-0.7731403708,
0.3255295157,
-0.0620576739,
0.1725825965,
0.488201946,
0.5369090438,
-0.1230928674,
1.163844943,
0.5958465338,
-0.0311243664,
0.675822258,
-0.1958469152,
0.2199351192,
-1.1995457411,
-0.166964829,
-0.5472844243,
-0.7205432057,
-0.3756152391,
-0.4375723898,
0.485827744,
-0.1079763472,
-0.1581023633,
0.6998450756,
-0.1963101774,
0.2457656264,
0.7110348344,
-0.0177480578,
0.4211122692,
-0.0075087985,
-0.0126026357,
-0.1781567186,
-0.3420509398,
-0.1939895749,
0.7682381272,
-0.1335691512,
0.7357776761,
0.2354931235,
0.4628711641,
0.5313611627,
0.4020526409,
-0.9739835858,
0.6772677302,
-0.0717802271,
-0.8482871652,
-0.4263768494,
-0.4233244956,
-0.8676653504,
-0.0063397451,
-0.2471390218,
-0.8047373295,
0.050314799,
0.1646219194,
-0.3391854763,
0.0589011647,
-0.3692216873,
0.753539741,
-0.3301537931,
-0.3341448009,
-0.2442235202,
-0.6469372511,
0.0971954986,
-0.2366278917,
-0.0139263021,
-0.1430162638,
-0.1352746189,
0.5047036409,
-0.3139074445,
0.4874922931,
-0.0367271677,
0.032596916,
0.1867375672,
0.5744051933,
0.8101023436,
-0.5412423015,
-0.2814899385,
-0.3475726843,
-0.2406205833,
-0.2184684426,
-0.8558390737,
0.7400414944,
-0.3487465084,
-0.5149641037,
-0.2582659125,
-0.8831325173,
-0.3203950524,
0.5555635095,
0.1378765255,
0.453115344,
0.0583394803,
0.3248709142,
0.4821154475,
-0.2515379488,
0.2398503721,
0.8082633018,
-0.274171114,
-0.0575183183,
0.9280557036,
0.0632314608,
0.6066628098,
0.647892952,
0.0979568437,
-0.3322551847,
-0.4416700006,
-0.6484367847,
0.0639529377,
-0.6516031027,
-0.3765109777,
-0.4201220572,
-0.0824349225,
-0.4399886727,
-0.3423940241,
-0.0988128409,
-0.5840940475,
0.0447641276,
-0.3937481046,
0.7383832335,
0.7764589787,
-0.034185186,
0.5193497539,
-0.6030033231,
0.6173115969,
0.164448306,
0.2850168049,
-0.2298493385,
-0.6957089305,
0.0008341667,
-0.0513487756,
-0.3576450646,
-0.8998345137,
0.3159776628,
0.6333055496,
0.3868026733,
0.2380913496,
0.1703983992,
0.7778785229,
-0.6384875178,
1.1428211927,
0.1419265568,
-0.7239255905,
0.9494531155,
-0.313660413,
0.3572717011,
0.7102052569,
0.5937744379,
-0.7418530583,
-0.6297399998,
-0.1827598065,
-0.9446557164,
0.8739323616,
0.438282311,
0.5420997739,
-0.1787730455,
0.2420700192,
0.1707404405,
0.3540845513,
-0.7674390674,
-0.1109803841,
0.1551234126,
-0.3310964406,
0.4113892615,
0.1283300519,
-0.1139512509,
-0.1897790134,
0.8253871202,
-0.2223297656,
0.0323176943,
0.2094143927,
-0.4951036572,
-0.3225857019,
0.4715735018,
0.5076010227,
0.3532623053,
-0.0293105524,
0.0663604438,
0.3106581867,
-0.6109515429,
0.3163233399,
-0.2389512509,
-0.8300025463,
-0.1697652191,
0.3951585293,
0.9001651406,
0.0951910689,
-0.4502380192,
0.7084786296,
0.3286975622,
0.127181232,
0.2197547704,
0.0478202477,
-0.6861860156,
-0.1673866212,
0.4742029309,
-0.3467091322,
0.0661218762,
-0.5448022485,
0.4580293298,
0.4448954463,
-0.8993294835,
-0.2538126111,
0.8692559004,
0.2910058498,
-0.4236393273,
0.9666993022,
-0.314296186,
-0.427452296,
0.1782070398,
0.6354835629,
1.1067010164,
-0.2858065069,
0.3684163392,
0.5378765464,
0.4617643952,
0.021186579,
0.422814548,
-0.1177299023,
-0.3481107056,
-0.4936379194,
-0.5314390063,
-0.3124863505,
0.1279637367,
-0.6023768187,
0.4294858277,
-0.1423450112,
-0.0853545666,
-0.6403471828,
-0.2764976323,
-0.6614754796,
0.2842694521,
-0.0460646823,
0.9782901406,
-1.004971385,
0.5440124273,
0.6530603766,
-0.8983072042,
-0.857175827,
-0.1770734489,
0.1096160859,
-0.8445444107,
0.8331429362,
0.079204306,
-0.2383759916,
0.2754954696,
-0.6070099473,
-0.5367096663,
1.1331712008,
0.1438948065,
0.1476044506,
0.1673392653,
0.456518501,
0.4318076074,
-0.3010120988,
0.3160542846,
0.5974200368,
0.6592270732,
0.3997264206,
-0.966359973,
0.2452425808,
-0.153805241,
-0.1510149837,
0.2158692181,
-0.5268654823,
0.5587978363,
-0.059427429,
-0.1677459925,
0.1404380351,
0.7762309909,
0.0036406473,
-0.0787188858,
0.3466984332,
0.241087839,
0.4805730283,
-0.3379069865,
1.1844084263,
-0.1496748179,
0.0244924556,
1.0691025257,
-0.3597218394,
1.1870741844,
0.7014319897,
0.0281039141,
0.5149143934,
0.2934416533,
0.1770349145,
0.5487383008,
-0.1383461058,
-0.2698922157,
-0.3765605092,
-0.7170599699,
-0.0381856747,
0.3570224047,
0.2222511172,
-0.31696105,
-0.135906145,
0.0572960079,
0.0636104196,
-0.0529847257,
-0.3951575458,
0.803783834,
0.2702085674,
-0.9684641361,
0.2625436485,
-0.2913919389,
0.2350628674,
-1.0596247911,
-0.4058257043,
-0.3510542214,
-0.2201836407,
-0.2617811561,
-0.9959245324,
0.0637531057,
0.1752328277,
0.2025912255,
-0.7817985415,
0.5973857045,
-0.779355526,
-0.5634550452,
-0.1280659139,
0.5670029521,
0.223028779,
0.1752480417,
-0.5125851035,
-0.1426504999,
-0.3481267393,
-0.4048067331,
0.1618051082,
0.3100219965,
-0.4409913421,
0.8694815636,
0.5602618456,
0.3072364032,
0.265086323,
0.4432899654,
0.5304727554,
-0.495698154,
-0.2878403664,
-0.5362951756,
0.7464097738,
-0.1344457567,
-0.3803139329,
0.7417217493,
0.4269282818,
0.6017531157,
-0.2468047142,
0.5730966926,
-0.5382675529,
0.2343309671,
-0.5328387618,
0.7167511582,
-0.6691548824,
-0.0138763245,
-0.3120496273,
-0.7120901942,
-0.5181065798,
0.459025532,
-0.4133496881,
0.1228337064,
0.7700198293,
1.1420100927,
-0.182674244,
-0.6737334132,
0.4590577483,
0.0171943065,
0.4476784766,
0.4539063573,
0.6906164289,
-0.5052806735,
0.5883701444,
0.1504835486,
-0.2282116711,
-0.0944344029,
-1.0233683586,
-0.7151317596,
-0.7609035373,
-0.4784624279,
-0.1921423525,
-0.3985660672,
1.158428669,
0.6271970272,
-1.0925452709,
-0.1291971356,
0.1350208968,
0.2712839246,
-0.6568603516,
-0.1854070127,
0.3257715702,
-0.5631863475,
-0.8528549671,
0.521037221,
0.3669356108,
0.0617691725,
-0.2100462914,
-0.2898857594,
-0.4999894202,
0.1559352577,
0.5313251019,
0.2967250645,
-0.5831429958,
-0.48869434,
0.1919715554,
-0.1424957067,
0.0039515467,
1.0076384544,
-0.6480095387,
0.6876121759,
0.909475863,
0.566950202,
0.2288126945,
0.1774479002,
1.0291568041,
-1.2334079742,
0.179363355,
0.2170323133,
0.1039436385,
0.5307819247,
-0.3258941472,
0.490855217,
0.0145031195,
-0.1641241014,
-0.7656727433,
0.6756805182,
-0.7244027853,
0.3199060857,
1.3301573992,
-0.1748415679,
-0.1879517287,
0.0611303113,
-0.5006686449,
0.1582804024,
-0.4568658471,
0.5244882107,
0.679466784,
-0.1689122021,
-0.2973567843,
-0.7113179564,
0.8505805731,
0.4021566808,
-0.6436902285,
-0.0675336421,
0.4522736669,
-0.1761959195,
-0.0371414535,
0.7213305831,
-0.1490610093,
0.5122725964,
-0.4384463727,
-0.1971050501,
-0.1238389909,
-0.3928540349,
-0.2459943891,
-0.1851772666,
0.2496979833,
0.042406667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17127v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17127v1 | Characterizing and Measuring Linguistic Dataset Drift | 2023-05-26T17:50:51 | 2023-05-26T17:50:51 | Tyler A. Chang, Kishaloy Halder, Neha Anna John, Yogarshi Vyas, Yassine Benajiba, Miguel Ballesteros, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | NLP models often degrade in performance when real world data distributions
differ markedly from training data. However, existing dataset drift metrics in
NLP have generally not considered specific dimensions of linguistic drift that
affect model performance, and they have not been validated in their ability to
predict model performance at the individual example level, where such metrics
are often used in practice. In this paper, we propose three dimensions of
linguistic dataset drift: vocabulary, structural, and semantic drift. These
dimensions correspond to content word frequency divergences, syntactic
divergences, and meaning changes not captured by word frequencies (e.g. lexical
semantic change). We propose interpretable metrics for all three drift
dimensions, and we modify past performance prediction methods to predict model
performance at both the example and dataset level for English sentiment
classification and natural language inference. We find that our drift metrics
are more effective than previous metrics at predicting out-of-domain model
accuracies (mean 16.8% root mean square error decrease), particularly when
compared to popular fine-tuned embedding distances (mean 47.7% error decrease).
Fine-tuned embedding distances are much more effective at ranking individual
examples by expected performance, but decomposing into vocabulary, structural,
and semantic drift produces the best example rankings of all considered
model-agnostic drift metrics (mean 6.7% ROC AUC increase). | [
-0.6175979972,
-0.6746433973,
0.1886996329,
0.1511380821,
-0.2901660204,
0.1358180046,
-0.2763608992,
-0.1548678875,
0.2413599193,
0.3295440078,
-0.623088479,
-0.7783672214,
-0.5580194592,
-0.0362500958,
-0.7291904688,
1.1461045742,
0.0999764577,
-0.0490888618,
-0.4005357325,
-0.4540590346,
-0.4840371311,
-0.3922143877,
-0.2643619478,
-0.4076031446,
0.3614586294,
-0.0667178333,
0.8771877885,
0.7873533368,
0.5250385404,
0.1432981491,
-0.3916044235,
-0.0086811157,
-0.2923157513,
0.0400100686,
-0.3395210207,
-0.7361665368,
-0.395542115,
0.1337141395,
0.6432406902,
0.7118519545,
-0.3574968874,
0.2780728936,
-0.1723464429,
0.7167137265,
-0.5760688782,
0.1148743406,
-0.6040530205,
0.0381251946,
-0.5149043798,
-0.0794102401,
-0.2029494047,
-0.4362312853,
0.2324307859,
-0.570638001,
0.4715457857,
0.015760731,
0.7480883002,
0.4193522334,
-0.1462034583,
-0.4971445203,
-0.5072126389,
0.8288587332,
-1.0812298059,
0.4066636264,
0.2483650893,
-0.0530889891,
0.3230127394,
-0.3323196471,
-0.6053106189,
-0.1129913554,
0.2307415903,
0.1627303064,
0.0372701623,
-0.3777948022,
0.1098602265,
0.4140894115,
-0.4557973146,
0.3634339273,
-0.0940175578,
0.0469256192,
0.809335351,
0.5028197169,
0.2616327107,
-0.0493774116,
-0.2645958662,
-0.2717474103,
-0.6325818896,
-0.1514389366,
0.3994711936,
0.5858337283,
-0.4474571049,
0.2610866725,
0.0622432269,
0.43723014,
-0.2285246253,
-0.2700585127,
0.6525259614,
-0.2878717482,
0.2032843083,
-0.0872325748,
0.637753129,
0.6920383573,
0.0628683046,
-0.0078312671,
-0.1423932761,
0.2519639432,
0.2760729194,
-0.3931339979,
-0.4097925127,
0.1522915065,
-0.5404643416,
-0.2984794676,
-0.2000067234,
-1.0298963785,
-0.4855017364,
-0.2481116205,
0.114253439,
-0.6310189366,
-0.7776575089,
0.2521099448,
-0.3647590578,
0.1341450512,
0.0542060658,
-0.7671783566,
0.357180357,
1.0174205303,
1.1970152855,
-0.6417257786,
-0.3329291344,
0.277523458,
-0.3667612672,
-0.5503162742,
0.747700274,
-0.4442938566,
-0.0969486162,
0.3238133788,
-0.2199814916,
-0.2943996191,
-0.5503355265,
0.5413379073,
-0.3845865726,
0.2696955204,
-0.0877047554,
-0.7978329659,
-0.3840871751,
0.1291296184,
-0.7368972898,
1.0313351154,
0.0714169592,
-0.9307512641,
0.6501319408,
-0.8677089214,
-0.2513819635,
0.0276473351,
0.2945810258,
-0.3479872942,
0.4070763886,
0.0427975394,
0.5380194187,
-0.0834212005,
0.0507202037,
-0.5701811314,
-0.0626031235,
0.1378745288,
-0.1974122077,
0.5914224982,
0.1471953541,
-0.0702623948,
-0.3999487758,
-0.8798874617,
0.0654282048,
-0.110298939,
-0.2275719345,
-0.56717664,
0.4687949717,
0.0298650321,
0.3157830536,
-0.2001047581,
-0.5654208064,
-0.045290336,
-0.7688177824,
0.3610240519,
0.4667669535,
0.0235118661,
0.5077111721,
-0.1814899743,
0.569342792,
0.4268527031,
-0.179184854,
0.1643132269,
-0.5566817522,
-0.6788586974,
-0.12646918,
0.473797977,
0.406139642,
-0.4776168764,
0.4763350189,
-0.7415758371,
-0.3874765337,
-0.7358586192,
0.1066191569,
0.0223207101,
0.4952152967,
0.48764503,
-0.2616077065,
-0.0123272073,
-0.7258934379,
-0.4383859634,
-0.173219502,
-0.2009357363,
-0.0371390842,
0.4827326536,
-0.0147260642,
0.9445464015,
-0.2068878859,
-0.2139476687,
-0.3803545535,
0.2088925391,
0.1555492729,
0.2043282539,
0.4579313695,
-0.4530003965,
-0.1574060619,
0.0075260946,
-0.5729786158,
-0.0566353127,
0.0101769203,
0.1000217795,
0.3589898348,
0.1467234492,
-0.4282596409,
0.2590840161,
0.6272037625,
-0.4703149498,
0.2758605182,
0.3399000466,
-0.4960125983,
-0.9877796173,
-0.2241280675,
0.3509668708,
-0.0309337657,
-0.5971139669,
-0.0641909465,
-0.0462736487,
0.2547720373,
-0.5126997828,
0.4774709046,
-0.047460556,
-0.0497600548,
0.0503291711,
0.5711666346,
0.0707926825,
0.0585036762,
0.0241510309,
0.3276645541,
0.530384779,
-0.8321060538,
0.458786726,
0.4186340868,
-0.6649383903,
0.7134922743,
-0.4488738477,
0.0585511364,
-0.2262132168,
0.1134278849,
-0.6499592066,
0.0652347058,
-0.2633914649,
-0.4738971591,
0.3365903795,
-0.0024227235,
-0.301631093,
-0.2110442072,
-0.3031216562,
0.0149319647,
0.2993856072,
-0.3950167,
0.4155486226,
0.3838869929,
-0.113005504,
-0.4613057375,
-1.0220264196,
-0.0238080043,
-0.6170672774,
-0.631084919,
0.3237658739,
0.2197226733,
-0.4524280429,
0.0584318265,
-0.1038394719,
0.1813111156,
0.2832997739,
0.0419052243,
-0.0161338914,
-0.3563834429,
0.5697619319,
-0.1834812611,
0.061357636,
0.4399725199,
-0.3601786494,
0.5193967223,
-0.1768183857,
-0.0621831268,
-0.4281166494,
0.1371504664,
0.4611788094,
-0.1835282594,
0.9684969783,
0.6588907838,
-0.1229326129,
-0.6245205998,
-0.2961605787,
0.0726163462,
-0.3818894327,
0.5162816048,
-0.1967095882,
-0.5068539977,
0.7546444535,
0.0626443401,
0.1942787617,
0.6125522852,
0.7619794011,
-0.2088904232,
1.1072854996,
0.5661903024,
-0.0605149567,
0.2170608789,
-0.5187123418,
0.2825352252,
-0.9021078944,
-0.2874931097,
-0.4517808259,
-0.5691567659,
-0.881444037,
-0.2914634347,
0.0557594933,
-0.1075767875,
-0.0073416168,
0.0504244417,
-0.133392036,
0.2916838825,
0.3955942094,
-0.1259206533,
-0.0323149338,
-0.0088781733,
-0.2277813852,
-0.0572995059,
-0.6888442636,
-0.4899470806,
0.927323401,
0.6608241796,
0.7362890244,
0.1289905161,
0.4222085178,
0.246198386,
0.1611817777,
-0.7800274491,
0.2425450683,
-0.4023303092,
-0.6441159844,
-0.2534012794,
-0.4345796108,
-0.4111432433,
0.1779033393,
0.041819036,
-0.5058321953,
0.1626582295,
0.0086141359,
-0.2191850543,
0.3840916157,
-0.4009197354,
0.8246186376,
0.0806040317,
0.0651117936,
-0.1743557453,
-0.4443755448,
0.2068604529,
-0.0497699119,
0.2983954847,
-0.785238862,
-0.3160791397,
0.892840445,
-0.2661131918,
0.6020417213,
-0.3508168459,
-0.2821820378,
0.1569584906,
0.2804691494,
0.0587523244,
0.1005200669,
-0.3308354616,
0.4560522735,
0.2404784411,
-0.2392526567,
-0.5680930018,
0.7324224114,
-0.7223557234,
0.0347865,
-0.059537597,
-0.3978676498,
-0.5552302003,
-0.2471883148,
0.5846238136,
0.4952740073,
-0.0605417341,
0.2993434072,
0.5297957063,
-0.0387534127,
0.7431491017,
0.4932352901,
-0.1740932018,
-0.0921291485,
0.9961667061,
0.2027269602,
0.3516780138,
0.3088623583,
0.397839576,
-0.6949224472,
-0.8007172942,
-0.2033136636,
0.0286559109,
-0.6911464334,
-0.3209072351,
-0.4601433277,
0.1328620166,
-0.0807293579,
0.0916633606,
-0.6433969736,
-0.6165431738,
-0.2948435545,
-0.2465352714,
0.4712201059,
0.6278886199,
0.0229922514,
0.3963522911,
-0.4520086944,
-0.0185122211,
-0.2691562176,
0.6711411476,
-0.1372372955,
-0.8459840417,
-0.509411633,
0.1526793242,
-0.2924186885,
-0.7269202471,
0.6458768249,
0.7795410156,
0.3849394321,
0.3768838942,
-0.1567494869,
0.2583643198,
-0.1875922829,
1.2742033005,
0.0349223539,
-1.0159816742,
0.7098488808,
-0.4702150822,
0.5719587207,
0.5858024955,
0.4481405914,
-0.5652267337,
-0.622040987,
-0.5241132379,
-0.7008507848,
0.6645475626,
-0.2720348537,
0.3735756874,
-0.1830597818,
0.2880068421,
0.104751192,
0.0835743621,
-0.5984833837,
-0.3876451552,
-0.3789486289,
-0.2786240578,
-0.3532285988,
-0.0125123272,
0.0311103407,
-0.1646836102,
0.6314798594,
-0.3206048608,
0.1580501646,
-0.3080678284,
-0.1765844822,
0.0989440233,
-0.1068896651,
0.5384078026,
0.8224981427,
-0.0429763049,
0.0467651412,
0.2883105278,
-0.7235714793,
0.0825698078,
-0.327958405,
-0.1677431017,
0.3160021007,
0.5984964967,
0.8247953653,
-0.0176990181,
-0.2150740474,
0.5772807002,
0.0375425592,
-0.2721437812,
-0.1603398919,
0.0063310768,
0.1598160267,
-0.2331831008,
0.0607477278,
0.2201049477,
0.0958582461,
-0.2216356993,
0.173665002,
0.1075259596,
-0.5964943171,
-0.6515384912,
0.3753726482,
0.1611754596,
-0.1156114861,
0.8344099522,
-0.1672549993,
-0.3785503209,
0.4743076861,
0.3671318889,
0.9668188095,
-0.2906735241,
0.5371156335,
0.21257855,
0.2662712336,
-0.1336356699,
0.0916817337,
0.4403800666,
-1.0070098639,
-0.4394415021,
-0.956330359,
-0.0393246673,
0.2201381475,
-0.99839288,
0.1649965942,
-0.4546239078,
-0.2801912725,
0.2446961105,
-0.1003283933,
-0.6886069179,
0.1791526079,
0.4398645163,
1.036236167,
-0.92918396,
0.4592743814,
0.7397395968,
-0.1076700985,
-0.3369643986,
0.0513641387,
0.4661594331,
-0.5412180424,
0.4869118631,
0.151048705,
-0.0253257118,
-0.2505094409,
-0.3916072845,
-0.9910840392,
0.7044467926,
0.0300754365,
-0.1928757876,
0.0692867786,
0.2415733635,
0.823241353,
-0.530299902,
0.2074849904,
1.061552763,
0.0469252691,
-0.2263644636,
-0.6777307391,
-0.2458649129,
-0.0928888395,
0.391317755,
0.3363152444,
-0.5342413783,
0.6644051075,
0.0910107791,
-0.4670955837,
-0.3255232871,
0.4377086759,
-0.2914829254,
0.2214183211,
0.3531891704,
0.982159555,
0.6353045106,
-0.4028921723,
1.0351318121,
-0.3311285973,
0.4761272669,
0.9133713245,
-0.3524462879,
1.2620806694,
0.1181775555,
-0.3138288558,
0.639279902,
0.4952572882,
-0.067952387,
0.7433490157,
0.276093334,
-0.1203076914,
-0.044697687,
-0.0655961484,
-0.207989946,
0.8910351396,
0.8168660402,
-0.2585509717,
-0.2901100814,
0.2182785422,
0.1756398529,
0.0804265663,
-0.3847565353,
0.9511528611,
-0.0488422848,
-0.3794539869,
0.674764812,
-0.1397920847,
0.6950170398,
-0.2568916678,
0.2611441016,
-0.5067737103,
0.3791573048,
-0.247298792,
-0.8493951559,
0.595412612,
-0.2294685394,
-0.1751627326,
-0.1860368252,
0.1570795029,
-0.1958514005,
-0.5278813243,
0.205969125,
0.487963587,
0.0863440782,
0.1707158387,
-0.8182303309,
0.1752404273,
-0.2211533785,
-0.2763271332,
0.2878271043,
0.3632745743,
0.3225036263,
0.8822909594,
0.1897860914,
0.3000900447,
0.3729800582,
0.3218027949,
0.4878028631,
-0.493906796,
-0.4919164777,
-0.8496528268,
0.4548270702,
-0.0180975851,
-0.7918395996,
0.7725586891,
0.4728998244,
0.860941112,
0.0208772197,
0.6736358404,
0.0033808758,
1.0378395319,
-0.729120791,
0.5154626369,
-0.3865544796,
0.3233298957,
-0.0440908335,
-1.0629411936,
-0.185109973,
0.5318000317,
-0.1944885403,
0.0548332669,
0.6782217026,
0.5717582703,
0.2879852057,
0.2085417658,
0.2135718316,
0.339002192,
0.2930097878,
0.0936462581,
1.0454109907,
-0.2974532545,
0.0338320956,
-0.432703644,
0.0392130539,
-0.0778529793,
-0.8909294605,
-0.8253855705,
-0.6030469537,
-0.7007324696,
-0.1752936691,
-0.0752722248,
0.5602264404,
0.7758280039,
-0.8591109514,
-0.1040199623,
-0.064195089,
-0.0871182084,
-0.4170011878,
-0.3210761845,
0.1430517584,
-0.6760385036,
-0.3980687857,
0.3885631263,
0.0760146007,
-0.1866565794,
-0.5222939253,
0.3497825265,
-0.0780605674,
0.0627200603,
0.6097013354,
-0.0454842672,
-0.9615541101,
-0.1826923043,
-0.0999526232,
0.1780486256,
-0.0505679511,
0.5241131186,
-0.578007102,
0.2627880871,
0.4324119091,
0.253942281,
0.2355139554,
0.1065012217,
0.6225488782,
-1.1316016912,
-0.1140021384,
0.5037007332,
0.068895027,
0.485825181,
-0.0661186576,
0.3582911491,
0.1034475118,
-0.43878901,
-0.787528038,
-0.0138006937,
-0.4846057892,
0.0205149297,
1.0784348249,
-0.0683024302,
-0.1245060116,
-0.1401991993,
0.6931475997,
-0.3324308693,
-0.1885080338,
0.5619371533,
0.9903970957,
-0.1322972327,
-0.1173538715,
-0.8949214816,
0.9421188831,
0.3099888265,
-0.5533260107,
0.4363021851,
0.4636044502,
0.3109516799,
0.5915061235,
-0.0684650391,
-0.2901137173,
-0.1654747427,
0.1289263368,
-0.0409262329,
0.2952253819,
-0.3360700011,
-0.6853696108,
0.0695107803,
-0.0207335968,
-0.0521878675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17126v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17126v2 | Large Language Models as Tool Makers | 2023-05-26T17:50:11 | 2024-03-11T01:15:09 | Tianle Cai, Xuezhi Wang, Tengyu Ma, Xinyun Chen, Denny Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | Recent research has highlighted the potential of large language models (LLMs)
to improve their problem-solving capabilities with the aid of suitable external
tools. In our work, we further advance this concept by introducing a
closed-loop framework, referred to as LLMs A s Tool Makers (LATM), where LLMs
create their own reusable tools for problem-solving. Our approach consists of
two phases: 1) tool making: an LLM acts as the tool maker that crafts tools for
a set of tasks. 2) tool using: another LLM acts as the tool user, which applies
the tool built by the tool maker for problem-solving. On the problem-solving
server side, tool-making enables continual tool generation and caching as new
requests emerge. This framework enables subsequent requests to access cached
tools via their corresponding APIs, enhancing the efficiency of task
resolution. Recognizing that tool-making requires more sophisticated
capabilities, we assign this task to a powerful, albeit resource-intensive,
model. Conversely, the simpler tool-using phase is delegated to a lightweight
model. This strategic division of labor allows the once-off cost of tool-making
to be spread over multiple instances of tool-using, significantly reducing
average costs while maintaining strong performance. Furthermore, our method
offers a functional cache through the caching and reuse of tools, which stores
the functionality of a class of requests instead of the natural language
responses from LLMs, thus extending the applicability of the conventional cache
mechanism. We evaluate our approach across various complex reasoning tasks,
including Big-Bench tasks. With GPT-4 as the tool maker and GPT-3.5 as the tool
user, LATM demonstrates performance equivalent to using GPT-4 for both roles,
but with a significantly reduced inference cost. | [
-0.3268466592,
-0.7552170157,
0.7614378333,
0.0622825623,
-0.2147434652,
0.1435597986,
-0.4618098736,
-0.5482598543,
0.1048010737,
0.6579567194,
-0.3741685748,
-0.1431895345,
-0.2307839394,
-0.0070319804,
-0.5676596165,
0.6917113662,
-0.2219242603,
-0.0255678222,
-0.171017319,
0.1010583937,
-0.4911225736,
-0.5264917016,
-0.9659103155,
-0.5351692438,
0.7388202548,
0.3419341147,
0.7761724591,
0.6437355876,
0.3657615483,
0.3173675239,
0.0356106199,
-0.0108668962,
-0.555015564,
0.2836754024,
-0.4100827575,
-0.6858244538,
-0.5442995429,
-0.148391664,
0.2985545993,
0.7045099139,
-0.3091265857,
0.1371535063,
-0.0646480322,
0.3221599758,
-0.4771328568,
0.0548665002,
-0.9014149308,
-0.1112370118,
-0.3270041645,
-0.1580881029,
-0.4144300222,
-0.1554654688,
0.0552022159,
-0.4701399505,
0.344374299,
-0.0586248301,
0.467294395,
0.366427958,
-0.102031216,
-0.348528415,
-0.746925354,
0.869822681,
-1.0685590506,
0.3405828774,
0.2928415537,
0.3559882939,
-0.4381005466,
-0.7002629042,
-0.5770747066,
-0.1155989692,
0.2325976789,
-0.1255259514,
0.0841536373,
-0.2323089093,
0.3796518743,
0.2561563849,
-0.3028915524,
0.4030309618,
-0.4128268957,
-0.1480286866,
0.5673373938,
0.2610301673,
0.092700161,
0.1904869974,
-0.0328295566,
0.2699034214,
-0.9692655206,
-0.3442932367,
0.1971787959,
0.4821413457,
0.056409169,
0.6010103822,
0.1011288017,
0.5902867317,
-0.1762472242,
-0.4651962519,
0.0096133882,
-0.2419992685,
-0.4000165462,
-0.0160501357,
0.5707703233,
0.2145894915,
0.2616186738,
-0.2366931289,
-0.5004672408,
-0.1690818965,
0.285990268,
-0.749735415,
-0.1305066347,
0.1930729896,
-0.1223033369,
-0.1034865826,
-0.2757928371,
-0.337363869,
-0.5829457045,
-0.464651823,
0.3057700098,
0.0056134276,
-0.3884120584,
0.2965126932,
0.0338505432,
0.1725792289,
0.6492986083,
-0.5524566174,
0.3847982883,
0.6975573301,
1.0514198542,
-0.127213344,
-0.0862540975,
-0.6461918354,
0.4356894493,
-0.4715634286,
0.623295188,
-0.4367785752,
-0.6509488225,
0.055854883,
0.163722083,
0.409183532,
-0.7199857831,
0.2952339351,
-0.5368732214,
0.0885149613,
-0.5583362579,
-0.3080359697,
-0.0903916731,
0.2532072067,
-0.8544914722,
1.1133437157,
-0.0080270376,
-0.5179273486,
0.2669111788,
-0.5573983788,
-0.482826978,
0.0954874605,
-0.1243833899,
-0.2582372129,
0.2753631473,
0.0865694284,
0.5799543858,
-0.8763141632,
0.272983849,
-0.5375897288,
-0.4325281084,
0.0868614763,
-0.1207365319,
0.4286845624,
0.1360799074,
-0.4576494098,
0.2149546593,
-0.4470826089,
-0.0910114348,
0.3741042316,
-0.4193453193,
-0.1227740496,
0.2035981417,
-0.0131831653,
0.2167447656,
0.1707843393,
-0.4379529953,
0.3253317475,
-0.5001555681,
0.6364688277,
1.0017595291,
-0.2098644078,
0.2691755295,
-0.1946997344,
0.4953048527,
-0.1381866634,
-0.154308036,
-0.1873932034,
-0.2400695831,
-0.9698782563,
-0.1177863777,
0.1230112091,
0.3630337417,
-0.7164860964,
0.0877672732,
-0.0902102068,
-0.5089617372,
-0.3455375731,
0.3203266859,
0.3355393708,
0.1658492237,
0.1018142477,
-0.5305086374,
-0.367431879,
-0.8493148685,
-0.1001489908,
-0.0385199785,
0.0048090215,
0.1918337792,
0.5071313381,
-0.0531774759,
0.9009289742,
-0.4779946208,
-0.0106709283,
-0.3850643337,
-0.0015146029,
0.4209595025,
0.447432369,
0.3759729862,
-0.5826116204,
-0.4186767936,
0.0920779556,
-0.6757270098,
-0.3485883176,
-0.0860406086,
-0.0273088794,
0.4926296473,
0.6479128599,
-0.7735760808,
0.284689039,
0.1939661354,
-0.0037756197,
0.9155567288,
-0.1182556078,
-0.2457270324,
-1.0294859409,
0.2139077783,
-0.2129087001,
-0.3310453296,
-0.4439200163,
0.1849951446,
-0.2378318906,
-0.2339146584,
-0.4710127711,
0.792368412,
-0.6516491175,
-0.4014846683,
-0.4394774139,
0.2634623349,
0.009273706,
0.2706906796,
-0.2168533504,
0.9433451891,
0.3881135285,
-0.4450221658,
0.5095110536,
-0.2209184468,
-0.216643095,
0.3863926232,
-0.938995719,
0.3678719401,
0.1497537196,
0.329364419,
-0.5945270658,
-0.1603235602,
0.1838783175,
0.0954516828,
0.3317828476,
-0.1921428144,
-1.1651132107,
-0.5563861728,
-0.13872464,
0.3011868894,
0.330205977,
-0.3859671354,
0.6330705881,
0.3145842254,
-0.4054811597,
-0.3647387028,
-0.7608536482,
0.1767019033,
-0.1076262072,
-0.5929383039,
0.2557196319,
-0.2064286321,
-0.3259394169,
0.1176920384,
-0.4481932223,
-0.0177812856,
0.1949901581,
0.1954529881,
0.0679290593,
-0.3120320141,
0.425481379,
-0.2264822423,
-0.2299143076,
0.086931102,
-0.3288875818,
0.7840676308,
-0.0838809609,
-0.8188607097,
-0.2166657746,
0.4479553103,
0.781847775,
-0.4644340277,
0.7822363973,
0.6661836505,
-0.329382658,
-0.3277329206,
-0.9758957028,
-0.2573132515,
-0.4971624315,
0.2197657079,
-0.5472689271,
-1.0327255726,
0.7539093494,
-0.125968039,
0.4555742145,
0.0769294947,
0.916664958,
0.2506885529,
0.9748548269,
0.5957496166,
-0.1077686846,
0.3449565172,
-0.2076185495,
0.4477987885,
-0.7268615365,
0.1355190873,
-0.5055061579,
-0.2760227025,
-0.2425967753,
-0.7718747258,
0.1317468435,
0.2810364962,
-0.4380764663,
0.1756240427,
-0.3699245155,
0.6361254454,
0.4938730896,
-0.0908428431,
0.3179198802,
-0.3006982207,
-0.1276344806,
0.2017744333,
-0.7287017107,
-0.6274555326,
1.0394985676,
0.2508321404,
0.8761560321,
0.1497364491,
0.6581471562,
0.0350985378,
0.4169342816,
-0.868815124,
0.8640369177,
0.0620797537,
-0.5227332711,
-0.121031262,
-0.2502456903,
-0.7723543644,
0.3331893086,
0.1051798686,
-0.8072270155,
-0.2975707948,
0.100093998,
-0.1352639347,
0.6443368793,
-0.827403903,
0.7509456873,
-0.2585648894,
-0.7394177914,
-0.4092654586,
-0.3824620545,
0.2948714495,
-0.2949405015,
0.2444758713,
-0.1258166879,
-0.039089907,
0.5292173624,
-0.389518559,
1.0664188862,
-0.194854036,
-0.4173298776,
0.3022561669,
0.3151875138,
0.7890948057,
-0.0398314372,
-0.2991767228,
-0.2838616371,
-0.0722587109,
-0.4537086785,
-0.6646767259,
0.9399122,
-0.5441753268,
-1.2051631212,
-0.2728129625,
-0.7479394078,
-0.1077078134,
0.4772590697,
-0.4529874921,
0.6050518155,
0.0210502911,
0.2992944121,
0.4562380314,
-0.3180890679,
0.401268512,
0.5662984848,
-0.42609483,
0.1444085389,
0.6437107325,
0.1541725248,
0.501765132,
0.1606677324,
0.2808728814,
0.0017568308,
-0.6654203534,
-0.1955094635,
0.4847679138,
-0.8744694591,
-0.0854738429,
-0.4950034022,
-0.0854473934,
-0.0288865026,
-0.4811130762,
-0.4081552923,
-0.276759088,
-0.223957181,
0.0517482534,
0.2745146751,
0.6407163739,
0.0560824387,
0.300507009,
-0.6208068132,
0.1329887807,
0.2144833654,
0.3877726793,
0.3058546782,
-0.0339480378,
-0.3423659205,
-0.0770660043,
-0.3284824789,
-0.5935263634,
0.1762362421,
-0.0820970982,
0.5812097192,
0.1720398962,
-0.0552751385,
0.7779521942,
-0.6101409197,
0.9140966535,
0.1144065931,
-0.9257398844,
0.2999798656,
-0.4646266103,
0.6116722226,
0.1907053739,
0.1195062697,
-0.4855089486,
-0.6138828397,
-0.345295608,
-0.9703074694,
0.6790634394,
-0.0086995643,
0.0819159448,
0.0295312479,
0.3840544224,
0.1519230008,
0.272223413,
-0.6853189468,
0.0918561667,
0.0669955984,
0.0753159449,
-0.0744877458,
-0.1600224674,
-0.2258548141,
-0.0260725785,
0.7854263186,
-0.2829410732,
0.1780968606,
-0.0765712485,
-0.134084478,
-0.2723912001,
0.4377195239,
0.410594523,
1.0250396729,
0.0097630313,
0.3045286834,
0.2698625624,
-0.0871749893,
-0.054331176,
0.0019393025,
0.1226081401,
-0.1844932735,
0.29131639,
0.5979876518,
0.4562177658,
-0.9477223158,
0.1467918903,
0.232044965,
0.0208766442,
-0.2641658485,
0.144427821,
0.7141856551,
0.5321885347,
0.1481758654,
-0.2503378689,
-0.1104208604,
-0.6392056942,
0.0796238035,
0.4010463953,
-0.1013749614,
-0.2851310968,
0.4616378546,
0.2192186266,
-0.3894881308,
0.4588463902,
-0.1849736869,
-0.5922189355,
0.502458334,
0.8126125336,
0.7456643581,
-0.0910674408,
-0.0295053255,
0.1325391233,
0.2713752389,
-0.3100607395,
0.2673432529,
0.0239541922,
-0.5753864646,
-0.7335950136,
-0.5812506676,
-0.3402516544,
0.2071551383,
-0.4971815646,
0.223083213,
-0.5631891489,
-0.1905681193,
0.0400676504,
-0.00938279,
-0.7930660248,
-0.1087457016,
-0.2075229287,
0.9017663598,
-0.3322250545,
0.7383614779,
0.6183450222,
-0.3913063407,
-0.8520647287,
-0.1032784805,
0.3660387099,
-0.7343283892,
0.6628755927,
0.2395156473,
-0.393311739,
-0.0554007255,
-0.4892902076,
-0.8073270917,
1.1137549877,
0.4201743901,
-0.6736894846,
-0.0232003126,
-0.0779958814,
0.4789071083,
-0.2597120404,
-0.0732585564,
0.4797765315,
0.4235155582,
0.2733817101,
-1.3165920973,
0.3346243501,
-0.1668688357,
0.0060908748,
0.5660146475,
-0.4762770832,
0.9037173986,
-0.318499893,
-0.3642714322,
0.1351057142,
0.26093328,
0.3317551017,
0.0363949612,
0.4679318964,
0.6306108236,
0.5413348079,
-0.0008767337,
0.9935389757,
-0.052220948,
0.2117218375,
1.3073564768,
-0.6285187602,
0.8661743402,
0.6343514919,
-0.1829293221,
0.3153671622,
0.3370631337,
0.0491913706,
0.1929059029,
0.4474581778,
-0.2950510681,
-0.3876921535,
-0.2263901383,
-0.3882466257,
0.2805357873,
0.3219884932,
-0.2128012329,
-0.3721520901,
-0.1842921674,
0.3574263155,
-0.1053757444,
-0.2812806964,
0.5689890385,
0.3309697807,
-0.5062354207,
0.4540361762,
0.1510468125,
0.3542332947,
-0.6686722636,
0.1303157657,
0.197065264,
0.3689615428,
-0.0384693108,
-0.8688604832,
0.3229018748,
0.0247396734,
-0.165979594,
-0.317048192,
0.7168081999,
-0.2877234519,
-0.4646289051,
0.3380039334,
0.7768881917,
0.0693624243,
0.0160617772,
-0.7223815918,
0.3527172506,
-0.2238996774,
-0.2804308534,
0.3867083192,
0.5411605239,
-0.1975164711,
0.9798416495,
0.9205529094,
0.1797628105,
-0.125533551,
0.4249034524,
1.0910696983,
-0.6592850685,
-0.4382509589,
-0.8044788241,
0.4218184054,
-0.0212180503,
0.0300415363,
0.6731629968,
0.4586341679,
0.8602401614,
-0.0263837222,
0.7973150611,
-0.1977372468,
0.371170789,
-0.4833115637,
0.4250318408,
-0.794418335,
0.5096517801,
-0.2245120853,
-0.9758111238,
-0.3330006897,
0.4769233763,
-0.4487656951,
0.035725303,
0.6289468408,
0.9511131644,
-0.1901196688,
-0.034187872,
0.1617518663,
0.2957340479,
0.7738431692,
0.516241312,
0.6232241392,
0.0888511017,
0.4166612625,
0.0285599623,
-0.0469386503,
-0.2966790497,
-0.978433609,
-1.0492274761,
-0.41810444,
-0.0459850878,
-0.1536560506,
-0.0275406484,
0.9101800323,
0.698273778,
-0.5495001674,
-0.492429316,
0.0142282965,
0.1898987889,
-0.1035353765,
-0.2298993319,
0.1271439642,
-0.419011116,
-0.4735508561,
0.2637105882,
0.532184422,
-0.2075742632,
-0.6788662672,
0.0416953713,
-0.2073299885,
0.101772666,
0.7423077822,
0.1890290976,
-1.0653774738,
-0.4527258873,
-0.1333373338,
0.1005139723,
-0.0961224958,
1.0875941515,
-0.6484397054,
0.6731266379,
0.3143604398,
0.867529273,
0.7941219211,
-0.4443196058,
0.8447626829,
-0.5962256193,
0.1732342392,
0.1724374592,
0.4872604609,
0.5462187529,
0.0098286616,
0.5819560289,
0.051106669,
-0.5504876375,
-1.0529386997,
0.5698118806,
-0.9504480958,
-0.3746209443,
1.0120756626,
-0.0602948442,
-0.1515937746,
-0.2519669533,
-0.4000200629,
0.1523327976,
-0.459349364,
0.6588162184,
0.7545081377,
0.037005879,
-0.3283570409,
-0.8399834037,
0.1407440305,
0.2108217925,
-0.8624549508,
0.2906918824,
0.4252857566,
0.3893594146,
0.2333312035,
0.6495878696,
-0.0522736982,
0.0701221749,
-0.0683342367,
-0.0223764032,
-0.2218537629,
-0.2239292115,
0.2543385923,
0.1231257096,
0.3123550117,
0.4543513358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17118v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17118v2 | Scissorhands: Exploiting the Persistence of Importance Hypothesis for LLM KV Cache Compression at Test Time | 2023-05-26T17:39:58 | 2023-08-28T22:48:46 | Zichang Liu, Aditya Desai, Fangshuo Liao, Weitao Wang, Victor Xie, Zhaozhuo Xu, Anastasios Kyrillidis, Anshumali Shrivastava | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models(LLMs) have sparked a new wave of exciting AI
applications. Hosting these models at scale requires significant memory
resources. One crucial memory bottleneck for the deployment stems from the
context window. It is commonly recognized that model weights are memory hungry;
however, the size of key-value embedding stored during the generation process
(KV cache) can easily surpass the model size. The enormous size of the KV cache
puts constraints on the inference batch size, which is crucial for high
throughput inference workload. Inspired by an interesting observation of the
attention scores, we hypothesize the persistence of importance: only pivotal
tokens, which had a substantial influence at one step, will significantly
influence future generations. Based on our empirical verification and
theoretical analysis around this hypothesis, we propose Scissorhands, a system
that maintains the memory usage of the KV cache at a fixed budget without
finetuning the model. In essence, Scissorhands manages the KV cache by storing
the pivotal tokens with a higher probability. We validate that Scissorhands
reduces the inference memory usage of the KV cache by up to 5X without
compromising model quality. We further demonstrate that Scissorhands can be
combined with 4-bit quantization, traditionally used to compress model weights,
to achieve up to 20X compression. | [
-0.0740336552,
-0.2780078351,
0.6407883763,
0.4038010538,
-0.2159948349,
0.0285110157,
-0.2079154849,
-0.1407264471,
0.4263352454,
0.3169538081,
-0.165877685,
-0.2815754414,
-0.6004052162,
-0.3302133679,
-0.481851697,
0.7779931426,
0.0591132678,
0.1925695688,
-0.4543818235,
-0.1388115436,
-0.4527645409,
-0.4498094618,
-0.2824756205,
-0.0328696854,
0.436994195,
0.3014869094,
0.4330492616,
1.0130558014,
0.5459615588,
0.2005230486,
-0.2548469603,
-0.2352664322,
-0.8098461032,
0.6957373619,
-0.1473987252,
-0.7615984082,
-0.3178623021,
-0.0288857091,
0.7246447206,
0.4101516902,
-0.2015005648,
0.0628064647,
-0.0709582269,
0.2949885726,
-1.0692209005,
-0.113312304,
-0.7169551253,
0.0990934893,
-0.092385456,
-0.1818954498,
-0.7716615796,
-0.2379438579,
0.030669855,
-0.2707672417,
0.2202536911,
-0.061685916,
0.9020781517,
0.4549064338,
-0.0584340207,
0.1978936195,
-0.7902081013,
1.0959247351,
-0.4837184548,
0.359867692,
0.1018237993,
0.0033550905,
-0.2030284107,
-0.7425594926,
-0.2088571936,
-0.0481790565,
0.2528920174,
0.0238377936,
-0.2183118314,
0.1477300972,
0.3474541306,
0.3277944326,
-0.2205904573,
0.3408557475,
-0.5225018263,
-0.2789069712,
0.3114506304,
0.2946294844,
0.1959951073,
0.0372453928,
-0.5791501999,
-0.2325367033,
-1.1425275803,
-0.0625261068,
-0.1935806572,
-0.0763261244,
0.1289300174,
0.4118846953,
0.122726284,
0.1646725386,
-0.0260926131,
-0.2604257166,
-0.0758891553,
-0.0822677165,
-0.2251802385,
0.4399311244,
0.5364205241,
0.2767923474,
-0.0528624989,
-0.1321320981,
0.0903357789,
0.1686606556,
0.4455161691,
-1.3215910196,
-0.2891998291,
0.3758530319,
-0.435284853,
-0.2267925888,
-0.1844831109,
-0.8206356168,
-0.2231186181,
0.1817589253,
0.2825322151,
-0.3853363693,
0.0657145306,
-0.1565845758,
-0.2697172165,
0.0940297991,
0.408180356,
-1.0009264946,
0.0223679617,
0.685411036,
1.035230279,
-0.4732472897,
-0.0840676278,
-0.6326810122,
0.2332973331,
-0.518972218,
0.5990282893,
-0.5435052514,
-0.642129004,
-0.1852134764,
-0.2656619847,
0.2345470339,
-0.409291327,
0.361451894,
-0.4823582172,
-0.1372975558,
-0.3589767814,
-0.483206898,
0.1635737866,
0.0469577797,
-0.5926507711,
0.9919030666,
0.060432326,
-0.6095383763,
0.5296863317,
-0.3789432347,
-0.3058452904,
0.1112331077,
-0.41032359,
-0.4661936164,
0.6678641438,
0.1555564702,
0.661930263,
-0.4191009998,
0.3565060794,
-0.4582884312,
-0.4981063604,
0.1648133844,
-0.4870403111,
0.5161398053,
0.0452516228,
-0.3434207141,
-0.0168961901,
-0.4058172703,
0.0103644654,
-0.0213172976,
-0.4291608036,
-0.5522885919,
0.0948015973,
-0.2481005341,
0.1913091689,
0.3330174983,
-0.5711109638,
0.3785400391,
-0.2495746613,
0.7158899903,
0.9254617095,
0.1851008981,
0.4308945239,
0.0989606231,
0.6321123242,
0.1957588792,
0.2452334315,
-0.3827987015,
-0.3164586127,
-0.9255537391,
-0.3784174323,
0.4742554426,
0.0731584579,
-0.2307483405,
0.1214537844,
-0.6800906062,
-0.4351408482,
-0.5367598534,
-0.1324726045,
0.2479375452,
0.1811450571,
0.2531264126,
-0.4265280068,
-0.5324798226,
-1.2533211708,
0.0923561305,
-0.3122359216,
-0.0778142139,
0.2514722943,
0.3754259944,
-0.1471276879,
1.0879541636,
-0.5351274014,
0.1482703537,
0.036922209,
0.1267243773,
0.1335443109,
0.5882959962,
0.4468854368,
-0.6884371042,
-0.0707639307,
-0.2882408798,
-0.4958014786,
-0.0663630962,
-0.165855363,
-0.0444417521,
0.1098992974,
0.455527246,
-0.8572463989,
0.4872449934,
0.6387062073,
-0.1947391927,
0.601016283,
-0.2781443298,
0.0738722906,
-0.8904640675,
-0.0283679739,
-0.2639964223,
-0.0443329811,
-0.5657659173,
0.0208574142,
0.3670276701,
-0.0956943408,
-0.6015407443,
0.4440638423,
-0.4647600949,
-0.2187358141,
-0.1678736061,
0.018851554,
0.1263839751,
0.2541242838,
-0.2510735095,
1.1492242813,
0.419734925,
-0.5486437678,
-0.2983581722,
-0.0363034531,
-0.1008395329,
0.269215852,
-0.5369230509,
0.0396014526,
0.0094270986,
0.0714036971,
-0.9655032158,
0.0493551195,
-0.3490153253,
-0.322454989,
0.4104479253,
-0.0702807233,
-0.4261427224,
-0.0838458166,
-0.5623784661,
0.2639147937,
0.786477387,
-0.6451812387,
0.8876262903,
0.5912463069,
-0.0072209472,
-0.6775158048,
-0.6542649269,
0.2229536176,
-0.5728714466,
-0.4284372628,
0.4400428236,
0.0115858009,
-0.3938657939,
-0.0125476709,
-0.4599021673,
0.1404331177,
0.3006889224,
0.6629225612,
0.3552342355,
-0.3095217645,
0.4303174913,
0.3162106276,
-0.1919729859,
0.2210423648,
-0.4608229399,
0.5108098388,
0.0447974205,
-0.1547654718,
0.004915446,
0.2201348543,
0.9569202662,
0.0783635676,
0.7163391113,
0.4221195281,
-0.215416342,
-0.2350914925,
-0.7081701159,
-0.4006004333,
-0.4701056182,
0.4996476471,
-0.0656065345,
-1.1231201887,
0.4587304592,
-0.4121886492,
0.1049508005,
0.5639160872,
0.6251539588,
-0.0212350134,
0.9174380302,
0.5978924632,
-0.545222044,
0.3098322451,
-0.3051104844,
0.1973581761,
-0.9471063614,
0.0504576489,
-0.4403971136,
-0.4305328429,
-0.4154955447,
-0.6509636045,
0.4878704548,
0.260915488,
-0.2564734817,
0.0296131354,
-0.5535395145,
0.555532217,
0.3485695124,
-0.0379907973,
0.0469530597,
-0.0211945958,
-0.0164853148,
-0.2750045061,
-0.8986999393,
-0.3386607766,
1.1426603794,
0.4441629946,
0.8235482574,
0.0594048053,
0.701533258,
0.2080905288,
0.347301662,
-0.6707518101,
0.6794545054,
0.1516826451,
-0.4090982974,
-0.2321346253,
-0.1955164075,
-0.9403674006,
0.3801781237,
0.0053109424,
-1.0556583405,
0.3183026016,
0.2595904171,
-0.4787073731,
0.1262759417,
-0.5213328004,
0.4352916479,
-0.1995815337,
-0.8317506313,
-0.6848466396,
-0.5355167985,
0.4026600122,
0.0146148149,
-0.0684414878,
-0.0344411507,
-0.2461858392,
1.161298275,
-0.4189981818,
0.8979402781,
-0.0571942441,
0.0834332332,
0.060252618,
0.305883348,
0.7189790606,
0.0442942455,
0.1018321961,
0.2699048221,
-0.0888826475,
-0.2785325348,
-0.6966533065,
1.0000590086,
-0.6462951303,
-0.9844901562,
-0.3644832373,
-0.6291354299,
0.0641700104,
-0.0155307632,
-0.0161355287,
0.3059582114,
-0.1019601673,
0.5193554163,
1.0272237062,
0.0601109266,
0.5515797138,
0.1055323184,
-0.1285810918,
-0.2133693695,
0.8526588082,
0.1431287229,
0.4371049106,
0.2345885187,
0.41834566,
0.1395844966,
-0.6462400556,
-0.2097809911,
0.1491730362,
-0.7655853629,
-0.2455691993,
-0.7730440497,
-0.0915466696,
-0.2249189764,
-0.4782600701,
-0.6744014621,
-0.4978227317,
-0.3481314182,
-0.0832793266,
0.6281498075,
0.4970298409,
-0.1157434136,
0.3077526093,
-0.6933874488,
-0.0872756094,
0.1493684202,
-0.0114848558,
0.1989057809,
-0.3488815427,
-0.5263986588,
-0.3381291628,
-0.2873392105,
-0.7217773199,
0.5514116883,
0.1282982677,
0.3977954984,
0.8164628744,
-0.1610739231,
0.802891016,
-0.4583530724,
1.0434499979,
0.1131018847,
-0.9068073034,
0.4218658507,
-0.1252440959,
0.3561982512,
0.5741219521,
0.4825496972,
-0.4029075801,
-0.3677432239,
-0.862842381,
-1.2015552521,
0.4776104391,
-0.0160078499,
0.1241266429,
-0.0354843736,
0.3487229347,
-0.0581111461,
0.2160581797,
-0.3221339583,
-0.0697930083,
0.1143185124,
0.0361952484,
0.13932693,
-0.6209051013,
-0.0491391532,
-0.2788960338,
0.5084471107,
0.1094979718,
0.3998997808,
0.0134328138,
-0.0086574107,
0.0808894858,
0.1802502722,
0.6339932084,
0.6434751153,
-0.1827247739,
0.363106668,
0.3525478542,
-0.9724239111,
0.2781336606,
-0.3554976285,
-0.2022758275,
0.0133631704,
0.2307415307,
0.6395402551,
0.7489104867,
-0.8235687613,
0.3237260878,
-0.0501597002,
0.0137404203,
-0.2016551793,
0.3255712986,
0.1424594969,
0.2537391782,
0.3864922822,
-0.1649380028,
-0.0676865727,
-0.4093437791,
0.2769473791,
0.3500912189,
-0.4489920735,
-0.0834806189,
0.6554530263,
-0.0231240001,
-0.1858174205,
0.6435269713,
0.0933552161,
-0.745424211,
0.537977457,
0.4431444108,
0.8148756623,
-0.4910628796,
-0.2619029582,
0.293884933,
0.1874895543,
-0.3700498044,
0.0198797528,
-0.1688527912,
-0.4213488996,
-0.4527771771,
-0.6057392955,
-0.3331516683,
0.0433470048,
-0.638702929,
0.1135698706,
-0.5959832072,
-0.0977093726,
-0.2594914734,
-0.2873295248,
-0.422033757,
-0.091264613,
-0.2473209053,
0.8472873569,
-0.8003601432,
1.0418276787,
-0.1554596871,
-0.1096192151,
-0.7147523165,
-0.0702197179,
-0.0153752221,
-0.7258290648,
1.1479498148,
0.1480243802,
0.0439340062,
-0.0277225897,
-0.447470665,
-1.3528238535,
1.2357646227,
0.2880616486,
-0.6636455059,
-0.0055238823,
-0.3278705776,
0.3583889902,
-0.4037866592,
0.1384674758,
0.6881357431,
0.2886143327,
0.1354090571,
-0.4544886351,
0.1549511552,
-0.1746586263,
0.2193022221,
0.5103955865,
-0.5155481696,
1.0697175264,
-0.2576344907,
-0.2411749959,
-0.1892089099,
0.8175116777,
0.5410209894,
-0.198470816,
0.3035868704,
0.720689714,
0.6155163646,
-0.0247154403,
0.9667256474,
-0.4626971483,
0.3319930732,
1.020083189,
-0.2416266799,
1.0076421499,
0.9224131107,
-0.1903164089,
0.349349767,
0.459954679,
-0.0181899462,
0.5518018007,
0.3327906132,
-0.2081485838,
-0.2449881285,
-0.1683730632,
-0.3283318877,
0.3937917352,
0.6240751743,
-0.6569806933,
-0.1848242134,
0.0872161239,
0.3232612312,
-0.4705750346,
-0.1913031638,
0.3766913116,
0.1305201948,
-0.5762469769,
0.5167947412,
-0.1708519906,
0.5159191489,
-0.5892924666,
-0.1570516974,
-0.0854708329,
0.3014290929,
0.1651637852,
-0.4104534686,
0.0108150421,
-0.2181349546,
-0.2698899508,
-0.3118224442,
0.6802134514,
-0.2585043013,
-0.3037853837,
0.160128504,
0.0471470244,
0.3175522983,
0.2675424218,
-0.1902081966,
0.5058018565,
-0.1611072272,
-0.5095529556,
0.6570913792,
0.2785198689,
-0.1276262701,
0.7331637144,
0.5012218356,
0.4197587967,
-0.0579171106,
-0.2924641967,
1.1321203709,
-0.4608269334,
-0.560869813,
-1.2740988731,
0.3723590076,
-0.0913455188,
-0.2778695226,
1.2035497427,
0.6222851872,
0.2818926275,
0.1385839134,
0.5648171902,
0.1538452059,
-0.0549934469,
-0.5761213899,
0.781956315,
-0.3303222954,
0.1946797669,
-0.1609268486,
-0.5851741433,
-0.2715180218,
0.4618737698,
-0.350628525,
-0.1083068103,
0.7774508595,
0.6571840644,
0.0333543271,
0.0350168608,
0.3452609181,
0.3377698362,
0.4843382537,
0.6476970315,
0.4997193813,
-0.2211461663,
0.2834117711,
-0.0370752886,
-0.1830418706,
-0.55360502,
-1.0186697245,
-0.7063318491,
-0.636228621,
-0.3064928651,
-0.4316730499,
0.0823544189,
0.8059242964,
0.8366551399,
-0.4438113868,
-0.0721987113,
-0.0060671461,
-0.0681602731,
-0.0430852883,
-0.2098817527,
0.6749995351,
-0.1631044894,
-0.3534234166,
0.3649543226,
0.7792127728,
0.0464343615,
-0.8445187211,
0.0634294972,
-0.0516678765,
0.0368703827,
0.5916716456,
0.2564439476,
-0.7469258308,
-0.3855203688,
0.0217959043,
0.0155781386,
0.2047307938,
1.1060214043,
-1.0753289461,
0.4280883968,
0.4380143881,
0.8120464087,
0.7768480778,
-0.2334593236,
0.6871708035,
-0.6009409428,
0.339277178,
0.3625387549,
0.5576179624,
0.0822536796,
-0.6747573018,
0.3702948391,
0.1023926884,
-0.6135547161,
-1.0626380444,
-0.0582101271,
-0.7949058414,
-0.3755529821,
0.9765162468,
-0.290866822,
-0.5948646665,
0.0842615217,
0.1638836861,
-0.0287780762,
-0.586388886,
1.0161970854,
0.6691194177,
-0.0633071586,
-0.2807552218,
-0.5618383884,
0.319765538,
0.6009194255,
-0.5563414693,
0.3379997611,
0.3331782818,
-0.0329264514,
0.4482047856,
0.3950751126,
0.0014927395,
0.3033733964,
0.2132769227,
0.216699034,
0.146728754,
-0.5118508935,
-0.5142434835,
0.4274627566,
-0.0600166209,
-0.1552086174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17116v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17116v2 | Improving accuracy of GPT-3/4 results on biomedical data using a retrieval-augmented language model | 2023-05-26T17:33:05 | 2023-05-30T15:37:45 | David Soong, Sriram Sridhar, Han Si, Jan-Samuel Wagner, Ana Caroline Costa Sá, Christina Y Yu, Kubra Karagoz, Meijian Guan, Hisham Hamadeh, Brandon W Higgs | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have made significant advancements in natural
language processing (NLP). Broad corpora capture diverse patterns but can
introduce irrelevance, while focused corpora enhance reliability by reducing
misleading information. Training LLMs on focused corpora poses computational
challenges. An alternative approach is to use a retrieval-augmentation (RetA)
method tested in a specific domain.
To evaluate LLM performance, OpenAI's GPT-3, GPT-4, Bing's Prometheus, and a
custom RetA model were compared using 19 questions on diffuse large B-cell
lymphoma (DLBCL) disease. Eight independent reviewers assessed responses based
on accuracy, relevance, and readability (rated 1-3).
The RetA model performed best in accuracy (12/19 3-point scores, total=47)
and relevance (13/19, 50), followed by GPT-4 (8/19, 43; 11/19, 49). GPT-4
received the highest readability scores (17/19, 55), followed by GPT-3 (15/19,
53) and the RetA model (11/19, 47). Prometheus underperformed in accuracy (34),
relevance (32), and readability (38).
Both GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 had more hallucinations in all 19 responses compared
to the RetA model and Prometheus. Hallucinations were mostly associated with
non-existent references or fabricated efficacy data.
These findings suggest that RetA models, supplemented with domain-specific
corpora, may outperform general-purpose LLMs in accuracy and relevance within
specific domains. However, this evaluation was limited to specific questions
and metrics and may not capture challenges in semantic search and other NLP
tasks. Further research will explore different LLM architectures, RetA
methodologies, and evaluation methods to assess strengths and limitations more
comprehensively. | [
0.071617648,
-0.8856706023,
0.9877926707,
0.0413522981,
-0.1182785332,
0.0369113386,
-0.2176869363,
-0.7532761693,
0.3022408187,
0.4846610427,
-0.0827658474,
-0.7366253734,
-0.6474343538,
0.4890584946,
-0.4036220908,
0.895614922,
-0.1062729061,
0.2824907005,
0.1270996332,
-0.1238643005,
-0.3603835702,
-0.5686284304,
-0.693144083,
-0.4720050693,
0.7387123108,
0.0547040254,
0.9334400296,
0.4063096941,
0.8482818604,
0.1885483712,
-0.2931831181,
0.2460295409,
-0.4701725245,
0.1197765321,
-0.2250016779,
-0.4046066403,
-0.6181539893,
0.1446124911,
0.597204864,
0.8223720193,
-0.1452657729,
-0.2476977259,
-0.001440009,
0.5759757757,
-0.3228284419,
-0.0451251566,
-0.4796593487,
0.148669377,
-0.1755346656,
-0.3686988354,
-0.4575127363,
-0.5958583355,
0.4131652713,
-0.658074677,
0.3488598466,
0.1019925177,
0.8085564375,
0.1255870461,
-0.3108914793,
-0.3288220167,
-0.4106701016,
0.5837940574,
-0.8945484757,
0.569570303,
0.5051986575,
-0.0181080867,
-0.3368990421,
-0.8395096064,
-0.2142948061,
-0.6324825287,
-0.089477472,
0.1932708919,
-0.2570409179,
0.1261074692,
0.2687207758,
0.3513036072,
-0.9096867442,
0.1942840815,
-0.5477386117,
-0.3520091474,
0.2875172496,
0.2034436166,
0.2094142288,
-0.130432874,
-0.2387277335,
0.1853893548,
-0.9290745258,
-0.4427004158,
0.0602392443,
0.3356028795,
0.3029349744,
0.827381134,
-0.0458502769,
0.7184281945,
0.1850267798,
-0.0868867263,
0.4950548708,
-0.5161823034,
-0.2125648856,
-0.1044515669,
0.5871698856,
0.3784603477,
-0.0897369236,
-0.3181245625,
-0.1134905443,
-0.1079096198,
0.4414872527,
-0.840344727,
-0.099969618,
0.4219645858,
-0.5871093869,
-0.0233095717,
-0.3470881879,
-0.5345430374,
-0.3803038299,
-0.1915655136,
0.5262140632,
-0.6859182715,
-0.0630981475,
0.2137053311,
0.0060180696,
0.1707254648,
0.4105816185,
-0.6714401841,
0.326770246,
0.529388845,
1.1692013741,
-0.6121471524,
-0.2860483527,
-0.5292189121,
0.1232929826,
-0.3647457063,
0.801479578,
-0.6309363842,
-0.3952912986,
-0.035006471,
0.0208993163,
-0.1337322146,
-0.6372497678,
0.5781373978,
-0.5253107548,
0.2867714763,
-0.3489234746,
-0.7876625657,
-0.1445622742,
0.1069490463,
-0.7852801085,
0.6487656832,
0.2161241919,
-0.7633669972,
0.3756731451,
-0.6801883578,
-0.1635449678,
0.140876472,
-0.2037217319,
-0.2183041722,
0.1557451487,
0.1831350178,
0.3649695218,
-0.1556970775,
0.2326387763,
-0.2014808655,
-0.7042269707,
0.0988264605,
-0.2361063957,
0.3483923376,
0.1970523596,
-0.3431234062,
0.1131551713,
-0.3606111109,
0.069304727,
-0.0347984768,
-0.3907563388,
-0.1545493007,
-0.2926895618,
-0.2560634911,
-0.0499633513,
0.299041599,
-0.6581377387,
0.19434084,
-0.6861850619,
0.0582251474,
0.4331844747,
-0.0150273396,
0.1271555424,
-0.3617761731,
0.4432848692,
0.0431592725,
0.0964120254,
0.3160741925,
-0.8764409423,
-0.0911933407,
-0.2519216239,
0.2578099072,
0.495867759,
-0.7174171209,
0.1363785863,
-0.3229331374,
-0.4784940779,
-0.5696223378,
-0.1036255509,
0.3245354295,
0.5076479912,
0.6648789644,
-0.3616622984,
-0.4234725237,
-0.9805597663,
-0.2584393024,
-0.0695079342,
-0.1465487927,
0.303237915,
0.5560643077,
-0.5749657154,
0.5902591348,
-0.59586972,
-0.2860991955,
-0.2413864732,
0.1729256809,
0.4625549912,
0.2140140831,
0.1062798351,
-0.7074525356,
-0.3502448797,
0.3279226422,
-0.748131156,
-0.2252864093,
0.3722195923,
0.1635067016,
0.2833679616,
0.0035201549,
-0.7537967563,
0.5241522789,
0.4332979023,
-0.292473793,
0.6521449685,
-0.4470049441,
0.4631665051,
-0.7360106707,
0.2654035985,
-0.0656884834,
-0.2156261206,
-0.7885975838,
-0.0885885209,
0.086433731,
0.1873214096,
-0.2026226819,
0.49475348,
-0.2543570697,
-0.2840380967,
-0.5096619129,
0.4251774251,
0.005492229,
0.1921882033,
0.16164051,
0.9713205695,
0.1272719353,
-0.4308970273,
0.2676850855,
0.2764252126,
-0.2780754864,
0.1659139693,
-0.7614338994,
0.1992582232,
-0.0101190759,
0.3389652967,
-0.6627957225,
-0.2396220416,
0.140820086,
-0.4651807547,
0.2726440728,
0.1735730767,
-0.4449168444,
-0.2686198652,
-0.2620390356,
0.3862886131,
0.3961534798,
-0.2914560437,
0.479791075,
0.1736903042,
-0.2652065158,
-0.7179698944,
-0.7201462388,
0.1019124985,
-0.1195503324,
-0.5326853991,
0.7086376548,
-0.0621119253,
-0.057013981,
-0.0692376047,
-0.1602491587,
-0.0777681693,
-0.1936293393,
-0.1347935498,
0.2647190392,
-0.0642727688,
0.1346078962,
-0.3310090899,
0.1935566664,
-0.1136860847,
0.0304676387,
0.406701684,
-0.2286156267,
-0.4275557697,
-0.3128242791,
0.2606965601,
0.3069691062,
0.0322731026,
0.5556163788,
0.5897002816,
-0.5294152498,
0.3719609678,
-0.6602085233,
-0.2842338085,
-0.347748071,
0.523614943,
-0.3839326799,
-1.0363105536,
0.655452013,
0.1949556023,
0.0336451754,
0.4029055238,
0.7440380454,
0.1324909329,
0.8787583113,
0.4202155471,
0.1241525486,
0.343735069,
-0.0565922968,
0.2906529903,
-1.013192296,
-0.2075956911,
-0.4407126009,
-0.0686066672,
-0.737831533,
-0.5993152857,
0.5271715522,
-0.3719005585,
-0.1896706372,
0.1649646461,
-0.5611165166,
0.2132773101,
0.3393123746,
0.4997958541,
0.4236104786,
-0.0011774972,
0.0356571004,
-0.1782101393,
-0.4607686698,
-0.539776206,
1.4797270298,
0.5889271498,
0.6961443424,
0.4304234684,
0.6351169944,
0.2437240481,
0.5620247722,
-0.6694207788,
0.36840114,
-0.2035182118,
-0.7442402244,
-0.2725249827,
-0.6299429536,
-1.1966218948,
0.3122926652,
0.1280927509,
-0.7967373133,
0.1664848626,
-0.0920790061,
-0.527172029,
0.2132336944,
-0.6569510102,
0.630027473,
-0.1718069315,
-0.4734940827,
-0.0219034757,
-0.5555123687,
0.5006625652,
-0.4063300788,
-0.0063959844,
0.115047209,
-0.4190862179,
0.6536923051,
-0.2098629326,
0.587905407,
-0.0678970814,
-0.3761630654,
0.064534314,
-0.0639632866,
0.5398901701,
-0.1111764237,
-0.270966202,
0.1114896834,
0.2191880196,
-0.3658340275,
-0.6809664965,
0.7785090804,
-0.6197026372,
-0.6151816249,
-0.4686333835,
-0.4953941703,
-0.2845208943,
0.0910333097,
0.3365109861,
0.4323768616,
-0.0931036174,
0.2006999701,
0.7273804545,
-0.4685434103,
-0.1428328604,
0.5599547029,
-0.4746499956,
-0.4297843575,
0.6396631598,
0.0983254984,
0.3949117362,
0.3511793315,
0.2067920119,
-0.5447964668,
-0.9034538865,
-0.0555202402,
0.3903534114,
-0.6733846068,
-0.2136346251,
-0.7127182484,
-0.2105227858,
-0.426848799,
0.1936596781,
-0.1403919905,
-0.1500007361,
-0.1494507641,
-0.1893603057,
0.3203158081,
0.8188232183,
-0.1313779205,
0.0276869442,
-0.591887176,
0.3065230846,
-0.2253035903,
0.371924907,
-0.4075370431,
-0.956322968,
-0.2973695993,
0.1709874272,
-0.2586023808,
-1.1309747696,
0.6427034736,
0.1057542711,
0.4619384408,
-0.1331565529,
-0.4624726474,
0.6660515666,
-0.4003170133,
0.69203794,
0.0240005143,
-0.5611705184,
0.5033173561,
-0.490293473,
0.2679792643,
0.3973477781,
0.4189882576,
-0.2635611296,
-0.4644253552,
-0.624714911,
-0.7883881927,
0.4333690405,
0.5210515261,
-0.3042253554,
-0.1528445184,
0.6973214149,
0.0700854585,
0.0704544112,
-0.7577151656,
-0.153813526,
-0.0344903059,
-0.0992927924,
-0.119070977,
-0.2424472123,
-0.0875208303,
-0.2780249119,
0.6519396901,
-0.2334285975,
0.6395531893,
0.6706261635,
0.0209095869,
-0.0715147406,
0.1855318248,
0.6894384027,
0.8997530341,
-0.6829996705,
0.0809609294,
0.4333626032,
-0.9338474274,
0.0215850249,
0.2160941511,
0.0057412679,
0.13964127,
0.5039372444,
0.4200266302,
0.1495814174,
-0.6739698052,
0.4473383427,
-0.0733516887,
-0.2157727033,
-0.1666089743,
-0.2454295754,
-0.0765505508,
0.2188016027,
0.3888457716,
-0.1972460598,
0.4289918244,
-0.3988706768,
0.2534857988,
0.3442994654,
-0.2186574638,
-0.2454102635,
0.4213594794,
-0.0868897587,
-0.023046026,
0.53076756,
-0.0260247104,
-0.2626834512,
0.385128051,
0.7825565338,
0.6199764609,
-0.2500321865,
0.0234421846,
0.4484909773,
0.3894619644,
-0.1805323809,
0.4715682268,
0.6107831597,
-0.6506707072,
-0.680485189,
-0.4971702397,
-0.6113598347,
0.434807241,
-0.4793143868,
-0.0374256596,
-0.2205686569,
-0.4067785442,
0.0011890287,
0.3463316262,
-0.4446258545,
0.2562998831,
-0.1183568314,
0.856774509,
-0.4175409675,
0.8629851341,
0.643719852,
-0.533878088,
-0.658049643,
0.0422991067,
-0.2215559036,
-0.5054998994,
0.6637241244,
0.2098371387,
-0.1258024424,
-0.0166622866,
-0.5314186215,
-1.1744285822,
1.2424623966,
0.218813017,
-0.5846911669,
-0.1078514531,
-0.1269651204,
0.8466804624,
-0.3616304994,
0.3615825772,
0.8247582912,
0.5393810272,
0.0125062764,
-1.1409029961,
0.1207704544,
0.0779990628,
-0.138208285,
0.1456171423,
-0.2573701441,
0.5724663734,
-0.2913828492,
-0.003927249,
0.3103083074,
0.6557574868,
0.5965824723,
0.519061625,
0.0731611922,
0.4538719058,
1.1367379427,
-0.0690937713,
1.1434233189,
-0.2118817568,
0.2833782136,
0.8631896973,
-0.523237884,
0.8814806342,
0.3772414625,
-0.28526178,
0.2346186042,
0.5812038779,
0.0926200002,
0.4016113281,
0.2776644528,
-0.2596706152,
0.0112394113,
-0.0587760434,
-0.5610836148,
0.0896880478,
0.5356495976,
-0.4431952834,
0.0364924259,
-0.0464209802,
0.1625950485,
-0.1319865286,
-0.06893529,
0.4885685742,
0.1530029327,
-0.5218777061,
0.7477429509,
-0.03013332,
0.613370955,
-0.6264548898,
-0.078330338,
-0.4120107591,
0.1045222431,
-0.2839265168,
-0.8184090853,
0.4853307307,
0.157667771,
-0.1212728098,
0.2892667353,
0.6271107793,
-0.291837424,
-0.3550905287,
0.3987484276,
0.6014001369,
0.5743591785,
-0.0194953717,
-0.582185626,
0.2529921532,
0.0948954299,
-0.2219213843,
0.3185608089,
0.1749852151,
-0.0641581416,
0.8341472745,
0.5269201994,
0.3640262187,
-0.1264372915,
0.1729034781,
0.7550621629,
-0.8590244055,
0.2070054859,
-0.7201813459,
-0.1845946461,
-0.0843023732,
-0.1878662854,
0.6328041553,
0.6441757679,
0.4175632894,
0.1060790643,
0.5612484217,
0.0439857282,
0.7583559752,
-0.6441287994,
0.4739252031,
-0.5154681802,
0.3561241031,
-0.3055756986,
-0.8895183206,
-0.5617088675,
0.5069753528,
-0.5845504403,
0.483116895,
1.0694018602,
0.8267677426,
0.0418837965,
0.0706551075,
0.5211371183,
0.5838963985,
0.4883283079,
0.6299706101,
0.6754654646,
-0.4367720783,
0.2972689867,
-0.026232494,
-0.311478734,
-0.1471621394,
-0.6211906075,
-0.5954978466,
-0.3536917269,
-0.2331396937,
-0.4970084429,
0.4288327396,
0.8526588678,
0.4584027827,
-0.5869922042,
0.029594576,
0.2010536492,
-0.0272837654,
-0.2338573784,
-0.1334099919,
0.6715112329,
-0.3362518251,
-0.5822998285,
0.7793248296,
0.2771751285,
0.064134106,
-0.076845251,
0.0047427136,
-0.2905246913,
-0.0544877462,
0.7068530321,
0.0181339979,
-0.9611846209,
-0.2984496653,
0.0621406697,
-0.2833892703,
0.0348085612,
0.4217709005,
-0.7307133079,
0.2137210965,
0.3360973597,
0.6794804931,
0.3854171038,
0.2722803354,
0.6644840837,
-0.2664329708,
-0.3748231828,
0.4653336704,
0.3364584744,
0.4574500918,
-0.5411092639,
0.7853699923,
0.2653398514,
-0.9533807039,
-0.722032547,
0.0368140526,
-0.900821805,
-0.1617583334,
1.3535428047,
-0.097584717,
-0.1065758169,
-0.4473407865,
-0.3585062623,
0.0370053984,
-0.310441047,
0.6721965671,
0.5276438594,
-0.3818486929,
0.0549393669,
-1.0121109486,
0.5479707122,
0.5521370173,
-0.7452394962,
0.0130159743,
0.6811995506,
0.287645489,
0.1028843597,
0.8736885786,
-0.3498933017,
0.4102852345,
-0.433811605,
-0.0484685972,
0.1568914503,
-0.1689796448,
-0.4508902133,
0.1345546395,
0.1316944808,
0.1928433627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17104v1 | PromptNER: Prompt Locating and Typing for Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-26T17:16:11 | 2023-05-26T17:16:11 | Yongliang Shen, Zeqi Tan, Shuhui Wu, Wenqi Zhang, Rongsheng Zhang, Yadong Xi, Weiming Lu, Yueting Zhuang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt learning is a new paradigm for utilizing pre-trained language models
and has achieved great success in many tasks. To adopt prompt learning in the
NER task, two kinds of methods have been explored from a pair of symmetric
perspectives, populating the template by enumerating spans to predict their
entity types or constructing type-specific prompts to locate entities. However,
these methods not only require a multi-round prompting manner with a high time
overhead and computational cost, but also require elaborate prompt templates,
that are difficult to apply in practical scenarios. In this paper, we unify
entity locating and entity typing into prompt learning, and design a dual-slot
multi-prompt template with the position slot and type slot to prompt locating
and typing respectively. Multiple prompts can be input to the model
simultaneously, and then the model extracts all entities by parallel
predictions on the slots. To assign labels for the slots during training, we
design a dynamic template filling mechanism that uses the extended bipartite
graph matching between prompts and the ground-truth entities. We conduct
experiments in various settings, including resource-rich flat and nested NER
datasets and low-resource in-domain and cross-domain datasets. Experimental
results show that the proposed model achieves a significant performance
improvement, especially in the cross-domain few-shot setting, which outperforms
the state-of-the-art model by +7.7% on average. | [
-0.5660719275,
-0.7701961994,
0.5761184096,
0.0801496655,
-0.1622006744,
0.2285719216,
-0.204038322,
-0.2754569948,
0.2289250195,
0.066298902,
-0.3162190914,
-0.2774273157,
-0.4651590586,
0.3511503041,
0.0566268004,
0.6484388709,
-0.0446932353,
0.1681738794,
-0.1792387366,
-0.039285671,
-0.9322826862,
-0.4814224839,
-1.0572507381,
0.1410600096,
0.8114806414,
0.606680572,
0.2718690336,
0.4178009927,
0.1456607431,
0.406549871,
-0.2085529268,
0.1228441,
0.0186213069,
0.605561316,
-0.2441108078,
-0.4239973724,
-0.1525834054,
-0.0671138614,
0.7310608029,
0.4221329391,
-0.1347805262,
-0.1002594531,
-0.0551325865,
0.12938945,
-0.3694460094,
0.1737482101,
-0.5309965014,
0.0872829035,
-0.3348249495,
-0.1288176924,
-0.4319356382,
-0.348151058,
0.4468902946,
-0.682826221,
0.5407062769,
0.3980333805,
0.6433253288,
0.1534633189,
-0.6984747052,
-0.4540560842,
-0.3743126392,
0.5543818474,
-0.1658530682,
0.6295186877,
-0.0732386932,
0.5641035438,
-0.0617631264,
-0.5965919495,
-0.6829017401,
-0.1876346618,
-0.0722428709,
-0.0927438661,
-0.0069448622,
-0.1408862621,
0.5263352394,
-0.0030859404,
-0.6045965552,
0.4305342138,
-0.1691330224,
-0.144124642,
0.0096245203,
0.1854590625,
0.5230695605,
-0.2079328597,
-0.5322572589,
-0.1110991463,
-0.6071277857,
0.3294032514,
0.2551116645,
0.6855094433,
-0.10345193,
0.3870333731,
0.135622859,
0.9218696356,
0.4643191695,
-0.2416671515,
0.2226112783,
-0.1130390763,
0.0752183273,
0.2055087537,
0.5175082088,
0.1664276421,
-0.0550343581,
-0.1958345175,
-0.3885757923,
-0.0255871378,
0.2357086539,
-0.672506392,
-0.2444060147,
-0.2144857645,
-0.3307544589,
-0.1867042333,
-0.3148857951,
-0.9185017943,
-0.58567065,
-0.5338910818,
0.3413218856,
-0.5157618523,
-0.1455169618,
-0.1047048867,
-0.2867230475,
0.0706110746,
0.6110638976,
-0.7652807236,
0.1258980483,
0.409342587,
0.7165772915,
-0.1448902935,
-0.2432567626,
-1.0355873108,
-0.0795773119,
0.023942532,
1.1022591591,
-0.7752562761,
-0.3243774176,
0.0010174224,
-0.1550758034,
-0.370583266,
-0.3658302128,
0.250187248,
-0.8358056545,
0.4771752954,
-0.4015383124,
-0.6087809801,
-0.246916905,
0.2084969729,
-0.8453299403,
1.0020492077,
0.0951296836,
-0.8793947101,
0.5179822445,
-0.5206926465,
-0.4143835604,
0.3931750655,
-0.4308668077,
-0.2105654329,
0.1070044488,
0.1909527928,
0.301264137,
-0.4588404596,
0.4942232966,
-0.1497427374,
-0.3163772225,
0.2962549031,
-0.188478604,
0.4677303433,
-0.2112772614,
-0.2747636139,
0.0157162882,
-0.8091062903,
-0.2644317746,
0.1133754328,
-0.287314415,
-0.3928746581,
-0.323204875,
-0.1234953403,
0.5020517707,
-0.1115141213,
-0.4052093029,
0.289803952,
-0.1699627936,
0.2178414464,
0.625467062,
0.1418891847,
0.7714472413,
-0.0055524409,
0.8116279244,
0.0588550866,
-0.1667755246,
-0.3882323503,
-0.2873317599,
-0.5870593786,
-0.3731591702,
0.3880532086,
0.6661266088,
-0.9518033862,
0.2920598984,
0.012422232,
-0.2965770662,
-0.2886798084,
-0.3585785627,
0.4272212684,
1.2426409721,
0.6184077263,
-0.0246565398,
-0.5131977201,
-0.6816413403,
-0.0553604439,
0.0705469698,
0.163836211,
0.457981199,
0.3296376765,
0.2020708174,
0.8087254167,
-0.3402832747,
-0.1907058954,
-0.3758800626,
0.0621542707,
0.1882236749,
0.4358167946,
0.5198531747,
-0.8598606586,
-0.7405784726,
-0.6149328947,
-0.6056514978,
0.0831878856,
-0.0432181656,
0.1034297198,
0.018318424,
0.4700918794,
-0.6861609817,
0.3931200504,
-0.0689444318,
-0.2446807176,
0.6744025946,
0.0001266135,
-0.0306005906,
-1.1416478157,
0.0036322065,
0.2487473786,
-0.0050812257,
-0.6817727685,
-0.224995479,
0.1883334368,
-0.4125280082,
-0.3704863787,
0.8788984418,
-0.9273914099,
0.0460541435,
-0.2299890518,
0.122344695,
0.0908164755,
0.3039778769,
0.2764119506,
1.0269873142,
0.9164997339,
-0.8508622646,
0.1902035028,
0.5473176837,
-0.2522763908,
0.9535779953,
-0.7333468795,
0.2803199887,
-0.6637622714,
0.4134059548,
-0.8287994862,
-0.0110468771,
0.3760363162,
-0.3419535458,
0.8774086833,
-0.5649596453,
-0.4464048147,
-0.34326455,
0.1461867243,
0.3357350826,
0.3704594374,
-0.6969403625,
0.7174947858,
0.3781949878,
-0.4837984145,
-0.7285993099,
-0.0590085164,
-0.0691008493,
-0.2641494274,
-0.4507210851,
0.4991549253,
0.0917477235,
0.145623669,
-0.009409613,
-0.3286058605,
0.1713900566,
0.08250992,
0.2553928494,
0.5169766545,
-0.3188638091,
0.464245677,
0.0714559779,
-0.5692021847,
-0.2060682476,
-0.5144869089,
0.7022617459,
-0.0256846435,
-0.1846855283,
-0.5331932306,
0.5068384409,
0.1528131813,
-0.5724084973,
0.7648822069,
0.467164278,
-0.5543033481,
-0.1686769575,
-0.5573188663,
-0.1628103256,
-0.5139420033,
0.1774473786,
-0.7200341225,
-0.9380406141,
0.2403616309,
-0.1533411741,
0.0336556323,
0.1580129564,
0.1453001797,
-0.0894176289,
0.8440003395,
0.6668643951,
0.2448603362,
0.6003639102,
-0.1162706017,
0.4144049287,
-0.9312456846,
-0.5650632381,
-0.6996182203,
-0.3029232025,
-0.1682684422,
-0.4237310886,
0.4433327913,
0.28014189,
-0.3012059927,
0.3723421991,
-0.5222678781,
0.3730820715,
0.8083934784,
-0.1805706173,
-0.1595877409,
0.0021277058,
-0.8689230084,
-0.247259602,
-0.6470030546,
-0.536474824,
0.5242272019,
0.062283162,
0.4686976373,
0.0269062594,
0.8757374883,
-0.1492499858,
-0.0335630774,
-0.6415447593,
0.5489302278,
0.0389676429,
-0.3553647697,
-0.3050521612,
-0.3141618967,
-0.8202404976,
0.2186074853,
-0.2208570093,
-0.712094605,
0.3838273585,
0.3368836343,
-0.6329545379,
0.3567056656,
-0.5401071906,
0.8290864825,
-0.2880939543,
-0.0906503946,
0.2120446414,
-0.6799997687,
-0.1608910412,
0.1489850283,
-0.0237606205,
-0.0822102949,
-0.0342505127,
0.6029872298,
-0.0602333844,
0.6705260277,
-0.6612773538,
0.1899156719,
0.0764998794,
0.0896380842,
0.7292221189,
0.5132305622,
-0.1165947169,
-0.3278525472,
-0.5914600492,
-0.0840943381,
-0.5891308784,
0.4501178265,
-0.5211517215,
-0.504833281,
-0.6252992749,
-0.2562769055,
-0.1279564947,
0.4037364125,
0.5441813469,
1.0291321278,
-0.1316980422,
-0.1552633345,
1.0674601793,
-0.4301707447,
0.4880078435,
0.5864380002,
0.0630831495,
-0.5307351351,
0.7461991906,
0.0332175456,
-0.3241550326,
0.7866244912,
-0.1326857656,
-0.7392506599,
-0.4613769054,
-0.6866939068,
0.2674454451,
-0.5522885919,
-0.3681354523,
-1.1594465971,
-0.0322123282,
-0.483853817,
-0.2901669741,
-0.1724496186,
-0.2855807841,
-0.6306145191,
-0.2162949294,
0.238200739,
0.2745648026,
0.0710713118,
0.4113317132,
-0.6490806341,
0.3894291222,
0.3569456637,
0.2622136474,
0.1842433363,
-0.3649778366,
0.2539598346,
-0.2951502204,
0.0831838474,
-1.1226657629,
0.2965145707,
0.0502038114,
0.7621126771,
0.1995136589,
-0.0532290004,
0.5229296684,
-0.8051151633,
0.4432191551,
0.4859424531,
-0.5751044154,
0.5721286535,
-0.0529167317,
0.0885290727,
0.6801573038,
0.5546373129,
-0.8288004994,
0.1184979975,
-0.4054630101,
-0.8398554921,
0.7887611389,
-0.3688388169,
-0.0837237164,
-0.2525956333,
0.3161704242,
0.3320389688,
0.2727318704,
-0.3268890977,
-0.4830496907,
-0.1581741571,
-0.1235255599,
-0.0094477488,
-0.4174194932,
0.2092107683,
-0.1001416743,
0.6353566647,
-0.0792754069,
0.5384150743,
-0.0512383208,
-0.3517711759,
0.1877355129,
0.4069927037,
0.3049880266,
0.35424155,
0.1099295542,
0.3240224421,
0.0182688944,
-0.1067425087,
0.315643996,
0.5739833117,
-0.5644264221,
0.2406277061,
-0.0832996592,
1.2209670544,
0.4583827853,
-0.2413356453,
0.5513318777,
-0.35593611,
0.1995154917,
-0.5525456667,
0.0854691714,
0.1722212136,
0.3002138436,
0.2643487453,
0.2338674664,
0.0602339283,
-0.0579871014,
0.2806998491,
0.3384336233,
-0.432795018,
-0.4619989395,
0.7890191078,
0.2573117018,
-0.6388725638,
1.0735509396,
-0.6826011539,
-0.7592920661,
0.47124964,
0.8662826419,
0.7452072501,
-0.3199184239,
0.5082292557,
0.6275710464,
-0.1316082478,
0.0322559923,
0.5136662722,
-0.0690157115,
-0.549477458,
-0.0417013802,
-0.4821176827,
-0.1806360185,
-0.0898197293,
-0.5796031356,
0.5517785549,
-0.3150787354,
-0.2905740142,
0.310320586,
0.0385503806,
-1.1689659357,
0.0160326604,
0.28956002,
1.0452436209,
-0.5813115239,
0.524322331,
1.116484642,
-0.498482883,
-0.8813709021,
-0.1836510152,
0.2153040618,
-0.6341070533,
0.567802608,
0.6224476695,
0.2104170024,
0.2410963476,
-0.1449645609,
-1.1418699026,
1.0029853582,
0.0927081406,
-0.6540434361,
-0.6458990574,
-0.4266838133,
0.1232487261,
-0.3962983787,
0.5412657261,
-0.0524326898,
0.3509554863,
0.0737950355,
-0.777539432,
0.221022144,
-0.2623032331,
0.0909818336,
0.4594840705,
-0.5549519658,
1.0167453289,
-0.3344436586,
-0.533506453,
-0.1652025282,
0.6811822653,
0.6131640077,
0.2590463758,
0.7147330046,
0.4969020784,
1.1415743828,
0.14302589,
0.6182695627,
-0.1279246956,
-0.0280450899,
1.3635505438,
-0.6708676219,
0.3216938078,
0.3133923113,
0.1797751933,
0.697470665,
0.4920561612,
-0.1446538419,
0.6953666806,
0.2088429779,
-0.3993348479,
-0.1814806312,
-0.3175382316,
-0.4154855907,
0.115397431,
0.3879112303,
-0.1679237485,
-0.4211297631,
0.2144555002,
0.0052287658,
-0.1960924268,
-0.0241656285,
0.6984576583,
0.0901322961,
-0.7894868255,
0.0319383666,
0.1024247035,
0.6796684861,
-0.3217992783,
-0.2097089142,
-0.0391560085,
-0.1071464717,
0.2229364961,
-0.4611946642,
-0.2316203117,
-0.0240207538,
-0.2236499637,
-0.287139982,
0.9836200476,
-0.3552423716,
-0.1572574526,
0.1558042318,
0.6177170277,
0.0290178545,
0.0126441726,
-0.6698735356,
-0.3144767582,
-0.296882242,
-0.0944201201,
0.3637017906,
0.644832015,
-0.0496055223,
0.4762147963,
0.6760237813,
-0.1083737761,
0.2521497905,
0.158951804,
0.7878257632,
-0.7099288702,
-0.8558431268,
-0.5559556484,
0.4760648012,
-0.2041392326,
-0.4426085949,
0.5561372042,
0.6852158904,
0.5772545934,
-0.0615068451,
0.7707874775,
-0.2128820717,
0.7863115072,
-0.4237852395,
0.2033732682,
-0.2107181996,
-0.0173758864,
-0.062317729,
-0.8784892559,
-0.1090559587,
0.5412099957,
-0.1528481096,
0.0007400779,
0.634031117,
0.6949582696,
-0.1490315944,
0.0209623668,
-0.1005254835,
-0.2531329989,
0.2578436136,
0.5349810123,
1.1947445869,
-0.0597609617,
0.1825427115,
-0.2929792702,
-0.149986878,
-0.2776358724,
-0.7967346907,
-0.9647749066,
-0.6278423071,
-0.4237731695,
-0.167772755,
-0.0470225252,
1.1113405228,
0.6196725368,
-0.6517886519,
0.2717067897,
-0.0161029175,
0.3139412701,
-0.0476658903,
-0.2132163942,
0.4517442286,
-0.5450453162,
-0.6025725603,
0.71389395,
0.2062954754,
0.3474199772,
0.2407413125,
0.0941784829,
-0.1872079074,
-0.3319585919,
0.2955846488,
0.3545161188,
-0.5139843822,
-0.2009136975,
0.5961087346,
-0.169636935,
0.0597891696,
0.993938148,
-1.065251112,
0.4223276377,
0.5054063201,
0.6199232936,
0.2143717706,
-0.1132501438,
0.4544742703,
-0.8108836412,
-0.0615047626,
0.3445331454,
0.4871984124,
0.4205182195,
-0.4511725307,
0.1390838623,
0.2137196809,
-0.38056916,
-0.8648558259,
0.2566912174,
-0.8326282501,
0.0811955556,
0.8479922414,
-0.0196039826,
0.0079677831,
-0.3410311341,
-0.1624237299,
0.5587019324,
-0.6345585585,
0.4249253571,
0.2891254723,
-0.1330041587,
-0.3455724716,
-0.2980169058,
0.4123517275,
0.0802238211,
-0.3978612423,
-0.3586862683,
0.6363334656,
0.4886034429,
0.092454344,
0.8476885557,
0.1405094415,
0.3065262735,
-0.0691421703,
0.172877863,
-0.3366649151,
-0.7570061684,
-0.5066776872,
0.3465393186,
-0.1721287668,
-0.2614224553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17100v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17100v2 | BiomedGPT: A Unified and Generalist Biomedical Generative Pre-trained Transformer for Vision, Language, and Multimodal Tasks | 2023-05-26T17:14:43 | 2024-01-09T20:14:33 | Kai Zhang, Jun Yu, Eashan Adhikarla, Rong Zhou, Zhiling Yan, Yixin Liu, Zhengliang Liu, Lifang He, Brian Davison, Xiang Li, Hui Ren, Sunyang Fu, James Zou, Wei Liu, Jing Huang, Chen Chen, Yuyin Zhou, Tianming Liu, Xun Chen, Yong Chen, Quanzheng Li, Hongfang Liu, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Conventional task- and modality-specific artificial intelligence (AI) models
are inflexible in real-world deployment and maintenance for biomedicine. At the
same time, the growing availability of biomedical data, coupled with the
advancements in modern multi-modal multi-task AI techniques, has paved the way
for the emergence of generalist biomedical AI solutions. These solutions hold
the potential to interpret different medical modalities and produce expressive
outputs such as free-text reports or disease diagnosis. Here, we propose
BiomedGPT, the first open-source and generalist visual language AI for diverse
biomedical tasks. BiomedGPT achieved 16 state-of-the-art results across five
clinically significant tasks on 26 datasets. Notably, it outperformed OpenAI's
GPT-4 with vision (GPT-4V) in radiology human evaluation and surpassed Google's
Med-PaLM M (12B) in breast cancer diagnosis and medical visual question
answering. Moreover, BiomedGPT facilitates zero-shot transfer learning, greatly
enhancing its utility as a biomedical assistant, similar to ChatGPT. Our method
demonstrates effective training with diverse datasets can lead to more
practical biomedical AI. | [
-0.1985620856,
-0.7029257417,
0.8314853907,
0.0374408849,
-0.444519192,
-0.017901808,
0.0013276372,
-0.4270477295,
0.2469014376,
0.0962469056,
-0.5629127622,
-0.6349989772,
-0.7492294312,
0.0548773147,
-0.1460852176,
1.2582887411,
-0.0897392854,
0.2988958061,
-0.1946499646,
-0.3383246064,
-0.4372386336,
-0.2130443603,
-0.4209742844,
-0.3336972296,
0.8415802717,
-0.0765683204,
0.6946175098,
0.4557068944,
0.8031076193,
0.2596411705,
0.6463195682,
0.003021223,
-0.0084020849,
-0.2024819255,
-0.3525152504,
-0.252175808,
-0.4521888196,
-0.0362058356,
0.218421191,
0.67877841,
0.1680169404,
0.166992262,
-0.1036499813,
0.4524309933,
-0.372581929,
0.4016211927,
-0.2649040222,
0.1876331121,
-0.023018904,
-0.2640617788,
-0.1677196473,
-0.1748770773,
0.1042432785,
-0.7493057847,
0.2580746114,
-0.3543204665,
0.6919159293,
0.6434411407,
-0.4088518023,
0.1257515103,
-0.5091635585,
0.557149291,
-0.0838609859,
0.4628694952,
-0.1341606975,
0.6177289486,
0.0608302653,
-1.0664997101,
-0.2760605514,
-0.1629567444,
-0.0097189806,
0.5956578851,
-0.4795129001,
0.3128704727,
-0.0387858041,
0.0806826353,
-1.1571912766,
-0.1016606092,
-0.441606462,
-0.1915885508,
0.1855602413,
0.003509792,
0.8659669757,
0.1688564569,
-0.2950749397,
0.0014627546,
-0.5564740896,
-0.2825710773,
-0.4930467904,
-0.0600847118,
-0.1545239538,
0.4561826289,
-0.2161332369,
0.6654086709,
-0.2852558196,
0.0732669756,
0.3830398321,
-0.5785534382,
-0.4887168407,
-0.1737364978,
1.025536418,
0.0540640689,
0.1832073927,
-0.3795247376,
0.3842982054,
0.4639148116,
0.5690196157,
-0.8317200541,
-0.5343190432,
0.1827246547,
-0.4448694885,
-0.2527344823,
-0.1848973185,
-0.5688792467,
-0.156681627,
-0.1868158579,
0.6742587686,
-0.5698219538,
0.0073469453,
0.2758337259,
0.0301062651,
0.0722579211,
0.4854070246,
-0.756123364,
-0.1786261648,
0.2648372948,
0.7719855309,
0.0323405117,
-0.2285038531,
-0.4124036133,
0.3330796361,
-0.096998252,
0.8859610558,
-0.4871448576,
-0.2600777745,
-0.4956282377,
0.0060583856,
-0.3493663371,
-0.2814582884,
0.3815998137,
-0.0165462624,
0.3970790207,
0.0263422523,
0.2131510675,
-0.3044651151,
0.1731785983,
-0.3547340035,
0.1747845858,
0.319545269,
-0.5394269824,
0.3987011015,
-1.1322655678,
-0.4510546625,
0.6237940192,
-0.7516553402,
-0.4212554991,
-0.0974497423,
0.4590630531,
0.5705423355,
-0.4266304672,
0.280326128,
-0.1821594387,
-0.3521812856,
-0.0694027916,
-0.5046082735,
0.6541597843,
-0.011311478,
-0.5182107091,
0.5915724039,
-0.63294065,
0.2354687899,
0.2170408219,
-0.3228593767,
-0.0115574207,
-0.1568131298,
0.126989156,
0.1366331577,
-0.1054674387,
-0.7005041838,
0.418775022,
-0.3657102287,
0.6867350936,
0.4713749588,
-0.2822633386,
0.164371714,
-0.3435086608,
0.5966132879,
-0.0654170886,
0.2976474762,
-0.0590842925,
-1.0346599817,
-0.3292346299,
-0.8257936835,
0.0916528329,
1.0518434048,
-0.9259073734,
0.1867218763,
-0.5441860557,
-0.4436553419,
-0.8442620635,
-0.0347769596,
0.3375860453,
0.5649995804,
0.7625181675,
-0.2341039926,
-0.0964702368,
-1.0567891598,
-0.1230634972,
-0.0212748498,
-0.4444288611,
0.2829453051,
0.4129525721,
-0.9852824807,
0.6720721722,
-0.3079630733,
-0.4455762804,
-0.1423765123,
0.4382160604,
0.2531595528,
0.5095650554,
0.6342318058,
-0.8810031414,
-0.2247970104,
0.5616425872,
-0.9390357137,
-0.0478353016,
-0.0992208496,
0.0389893651,
-0.1459784955,
0.0594235472,
-0.7481934428,
0.598510325,
0.6354176402,
-0.3041571081,
0.3182127774,
-0.4631877244,
0.4098026156,
-1.0799440145,
0.4457312524,
-0.0137158884,
-0.2826367021,
-0.521363318,
-0.0384695679,
0.1199028268,
-0.4227162004,
-0.1173327714,
0.569221735,
-0.060482502,
0.130512014,
0.0988042131,
-0.4707266688,
-0.3069793582,
0.4485262632,
-0.0723170117,
0.6528165936,
0.6995082498,
-0.2745731771,
0.5556595922,
0.3901111484,
-0.0503034741,
0.4484264851,
-0.8114106059,
0.2311801612,
-0.4343265593,
0.118950747,
-0.8860861659,
-0.4462268054,
0.6598683596,
-0.4558235109,
0.2179324627,
-0.0660723522,
-0.0308193006,
-0.5569989085,
0.0004166875,
0.6191314459,
0.6002655029,
-0.320627749,
0.7129233479,
-0.1041625738,
-0.3266695738,
-0.4637508988,
-0.8192420006,
-0.0038522661,
0.0773468018,
-0.6058183908,
0.3146277964,
-0.2573121786,
0.1940211207,
0.0916325301,
-0.0235122107,
-0.1312606037,
-0.1195596457,
0.4056712985,
0.449996382,
-0.1485097706,
0.171006307,
0.1749370247,
-0.2756523788,
-0.1706836075,
-0.4408308268,
0.255078733,
-0.4144673645,
-0.8927131891,
-0.2910972834,
0.4501206577,
0.6915928125,
-0.4167714715,
0.0461533256,
0.9714684486,
-0.0691215321,
0.3441466093,
-0.2548992336,
0.0995034352,
-0.4064437747,
0.704066813,
-0.226331979,
-0.9504227638,
0.1648063958,
-0.2030320019,
-0.1430449337,
0.4382315874,
0.6879002452,
-0.0611250997,
1.0958502293,
0.5300486684,
-0.0651664585,
0.1225949153,
-0.0040601697,
0.3042213023,
-0.3132065833,
-0.2451823354,
-0.0271190852,
-0.3838264346,
-0.5079365373,
-0.5190241933,
0.9061641097,
-0.2021723688,
-0.4212670028,
-0.0211777389,
-0.922744751,
0.2813067734,
0.5168379545,
0.5633885264,
0.0644790456,
0.1091318429,
-0.0731014758,
0.2392762899,
-0.7729305029,
-0.1290090829,
1.1455354691,
0.0786504224,
0.5923598409,
0.0015462956,
0.6026983857,
0.2659712732,
0.7358480692,
-0.7289792895,
0.2747879922,
-0.3265986741,
-0.3580037653,
-0.2641145885,
-0.3907616735,
-1.0536385775,
0.165846929,
-0.2831507623,
-0.494504869,
0.0335369818,
0.2526555657,
-0.4416952431,
0.2119375169,
-0.6216403246,
1.2906887531,
-0.3566289544,
-0.2164778262,
-0.064402543,
-0.9064238667,
0.1872871518,
-0.1620211005,
0.1396002769,
-0.0071589062,
-0.0002441313,
0.262839973,
0.1737226099,
0.8640973568,
-0.0876505449,
0.427672416,
-0.1397990286,
-0.0303148329,
-0.0150495889,
-0.0437896363,
0.6971150041,
0.3430444896,
0.0340487808,
-0.5949713588,
-0.4636808038,
0.4254902303,
-0.6735022664,
-0.3224870265,
-0.2319481671,
-0.5851125121,
-0.3466496468,
0.3528541028,
0.498503536,
0.3981200755,
-0.3716696203,
0.1921790242,
0.4593761861,
-0.5138440728,
0.093639262,
0.1095917299,
-0.0270096101,
-0.4135527909,
0.9663819671,
-0.3531908989,
-0.0185690839,
0.5077009797,
0.1781442016,
0.0911508128,
-0.5542149544,
-0.9270113111,
0.0795641243,
-0.4402858317,
-0.3419816196,
-0.6868799329,
-0.2381982058,
-0.270596981,
-0.3672219515,
-0.0764759779,
0.0313209854,
-0.1530039907,
0.2545742691,
0.1696568877,
0.7218052149,
-0.0321678147,
0.155879572,
-1.0058854818,
0.6394675374,
0.6991624236,
0.3399138451,
-0.6321205497,
0.0253145043,
0.102276206,
0.1096862629,
-0.1813706607,
-0.8945865035,
0.3607763052,
0.3934634626,
0.6297225356,
0.4007271528,
-0.6940645576,
0.2514103055,
-0.6097759604,
0.617972374,
0.6561054587,
-0.5043580532,
0.6577358842,
-0.558719635,
0.5510497093,
0.3339212537,
0.5915099978,
-0.4472545981,
-0.0485636853,
-0.3484509885,
-0.5220697522,
0.1126641259,
-0.0586906038,
-0.0882486552,
-0.0148491738,
0.1415623128,
0.2476471215,
0.1342293322,
-0.6536647081,
0.0850889161,
-0.6403352618,
-0.6895204782,
-0.134052828,
0.2657147944,
-0.2980886698,
-0.5007727742,
0.2088846415,
-0.6674528122,
0.7610570788,
0.3817786574,
-0.1457648575,
0.3158791065,
0.6472421885,
0.5553104281,
0.4848234951,
-0.0331884809,
0.0235566385,
-0.1060280278,
-0.7763011456,
0.1892977506,
0.3607511818,
-0.0772489011,
-0.1599374712,
0.4180466831,
0.7909597158,
0.1373255104,
-0.7437343597,
0.6251192093,
0.0487160496,
-0.4843305349,
0.2081398219,
-0.016656274,
-0.028321702,
0.3303925991,
0.1000469178,
0.4709410071,
0.3895615041,
-0.4748203754,
0.2157323062,
0.5172846317,
-0.5667642951,
-0.4125061631,
1.1862676144,
0.207204923,
0.1742216051,
0.67665416,
0.054351896,
-0.2776690125,
0.2611657977,
0.4929976463,
0.9122577906,
-0.3280105293,
0.3973793089,
-0.0030980285,
0.2034489214,
0.1895752698,
0.3779854774,
-0.0773147866,
-0.7540343404,
-0.6588187814,
-0.6690706611,
-0.213185668,
0.1002264619,
-0.14481318,
-0.0851110294,
-0.4069928825,
-0.1390088201,
0.3283328116,
-0.5905601382,
-0.851834774,
0.2899223864,
0.068809405,
0.3812957704,
-0.7683980465,
0.9428541064,
1.0256911516,
-0.840094924,
-0.4450632632,
-0.3856527805,
-0.0853203014,
-1.2507665157,
0.7971090078,
0.0622176155,
-0.0094475839,
0.0677706227,
-0.7051215768,
-0.3738258779,
1.0723437071,
0.5589001179,
-0.303735882,
-0.2855947018,
0.3199257851,
0.5644122362,
-0.153655678,
0.3051080108,
0.3103807867,
0.5493426919,
0.0519953743,
-1.2113474607,
0.0304865707,
-0.5001034737,
-0.2628175318,
0.2007516176,
-0.3949334621,
0.8436120749,
-0.329883188,
-0.1431943625,
0.0320543125,
0.0471824519,
-0.0808137059,
0.2817600369,
0.119301483,
0.6565794349,
0.580819726,
-0.1893723309,
1.2500810623,
-0.0600196086,
-0.0255922358,
0.3629790843,
0.0514494553,
0.2414172292,
0.2141120434,
-0.3059493005,
0.3203313649,
0.1831659824,
-0.2367007136,
0.464535743,
0.0812450275,
-0.5671189427,
-0.3043363988,
0.1209593117,
-0.5426318049,
0.4353472292,
0.1837169379,
-0.4011847377,
-0.3627803326,
0.4388328493,
-0.3664825857,
-0.3058753908,
-0.4756124318,
0.7376599908,
-0.042835243,
-0.1005636975,
0.3313797116,
-0.3701808453,
0.7029997706,
-0.8045141697,
-0.3253362477,
0.0355397165,
0.1706790626,
-0.1190118492,
-0.64904809,
0.3278383613,
-0.4223813117,
-0.1022576988,
-0.1665140539,
0.8699585795,
-0.3730871975,
-0.5057405829,
0.1143472418,
0.7235805392,
0.3181172311,
-0.3817975819,
-0.6053474545,
-0.2587837875,
0.0976926833,
0.1258507222,
0.4666619301,
0.2511783838,
-0.0557664968,
0.6978193521,
0.5536743999,
0.0723227337,
-0.1677351296,
-0.2060820013,
0.8441408873,
-0.6002996564,
-0.2055659443,
-0.6670997143,
0.3388455808,
0.1801640093,
-0.2125401795,
0.1267802119,
0.359585613,
0.6046606302,
-0.3779718876,
1.1486018896,
0.0233234949,
0.2737273872,
-0.3704491258,
0.9717769027,
-0.5959788561,
-0.4787895679,
-0.0165438037,
-0.6527975798,
-0.7335649729,
0.6793198586,
-0.204575181,
0.276866436,
0.7389006615,
0.4507416189,
-0.3051359057,
-0.1129293516,
0.7031571269,
-0.0614688583,
0.3037023842,
0.8886327744,
0.3903827071,
-0.1938308179,
0.4362291098,
0.2564413249,
-0.5761646628,
-0.1062893048,
-0.4491440356,
-0.7343084812,
-0.4524459243,
-0.1143692955,
0.0770719871,
0.2929388285,
0.7258563638,
0.8114691377,
-0.6351632476,
0.4008107185,
-0.1143509895,
-0.4899929166,
-0.1902810186,
-0.0960940197,
0.4603091776,
-0.3289152682,
-0.4654241204,
0.7054242492,
0.7781397104,
0.1219207793,
0.0061381087,
0.0931069031,
0.1407733709,
-0.3147372603,
0.7212249637,
0.6200444698,
-0.6467561722,
-0.4101436138,
-0.0700001717,
-0.1431264579,
0.2291666865,
0.7496919036,
-1.044265151,
0.5491713285,
0.3165287077,
0.9956476688,
0.2780686915,
-0.1249046847,
0.5208209753,
-0.387318939,
0.2839861214,
0.4152547419,
0.2354237735,
0.1324329078,
-0.2616519332,
0.6075553894,
0.5940608978,
-0.6430672407,
-0.1674530804,
0.2339806706,
-1.3502812386,
-0.2856912911,
0.7827656269,
-0.0478220731,
-0.2155205309,
-0.1402673423,
-0.3940523863,
0.2948202491,
-0.028300453,
0.5411015153,
0.0794981793,
-0.6309310794,
-0.1527735144,
-0.6781359911,
0.4816492498,
0.3993935287,
-1.2049010992,
-0.5301742554,
0.5968173146,
0.4043206275,
0.1619221866,
0.9704751372,
-0.2013761997,
0.4397589564,
-0.149568066,
0.4010448158,
-0.3437671661,
-0.4090990722,
-0.1460971236,
0.1975671947,
-0.3880267441,
-0.4684613347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17080v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17080v1 | Expand, Rerank, and Retrieve: Query Reranking for Open-Domain Question Answering | 2023-05-26T16:41:03 | 2023-05-26T16:41:03 | Yung-Sung Chuang, Wei Fang, Shang-Wen Li, Wen-tau Yih, James Glass | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose EAR, a query Expansion And Reranking approach for improving
passage retrieval, with the application to open-domain question answering. EAR
first applies a query expansion model to generate a diverse set of queries, and
then uses a query reranker to select the ones that could lead to better
retrieval results. Motivated by the observation that the best query expansion
often is not picked by greedy decoding, EAR trains its reranker to predict the
rank orders of the gold passages when issuing the expanded queries to a given
retriever. By connecting better the query expansion model and retriever, EAR
significantly enhances a traditional sparse retrieval method, BM25.
Empirically, EAR improves top-5/20 accuracy by 3-8 and 5-10 points in in-domain
and out-of-domain settings, respectively, when compared to a vanilla query
expansion model, GAR, and a dense retrieval model, DPR. | [
-0.4349165261,
-1.0630776882,
0.6624996662,
0.1881015152,
-0.0954213813,
0.0874176845,
-0.3698238134,
-0.7343038321,
0.211601153,
0.5398337245,
-0.5067412257,
-0.5689272285,
-0.711322546,
0.1590723991,
-0.264364332,
0.5162447691,
0.4169611931,
-0.1035844535,
-0.3391698301,
-0.22950688,
-0.6129528284,
-0.3043448925,
-0.8760891557,
0.0591504388,
0.5421406031,
0.5724110007,
0.6608114839,
0.6171390414,
0.8586621284,
0.3188266158,
-0.3992001414,
0.2749885619,
-0.5950773954,
0.1249648258,
-0.0526018552,
-0.6431530118,
-0.570052743,
-0.0372432917,
0.3458057046,
1.1217452288,
-0.5236638188,
0.0743919685,
-0.2369999141,
0.5886567831,
-0.5875520706,
-0.1316360533,
-0.7640149593,
-0.2603265047,
-0.0918129534,
-0.6966059208,
-0.541406095,
-0.6277284026,
0.5585697293,
-1.0228313208,
0.2040955275,
0.4340665638,
0.5904873013,
0.2012762427,
-0.4374287426,
-0.3049207032,
-0.4186535776,
1.1714842319,
-0.5103766322,
0.8892487884,
0.4245220125,
0.3655033708,
0.213831991,
-1.0710804462,
-0.1091209874,
0.1764993966,
0.116695784,
0.1994677931,
-0.2539079487,
-0.0303126872,
0.0536625907,
0.5894552469,
-0.5012062788,
-0.2816881835,
-0.6195101738,
0.0328010395,
0.6572189927,
0.0357161611,
0.4171515703,
0.4126257002,
-0.1505561918,
-0.2579930425,
-0.7444012165,
0.0743289739,
0.106710054,
0.3153049946,
0.611559093,
0.5174366832,
-0.4380083084,
1.0973265171,
0.4182203412,
0.0973021686,
0.2324106544,
-0.1195300221,
-0.0988535509,
0.3103021383,
0.1272800863,
0.5668953061,
0.0628846362,
-0.6690303087,
0.0977919698,
-0.5017647743,
0.5125796199,
-0.7736591101,
-0.1172368601,
0.4123983383,
-0.6832231879,
-0.2624993324,
0.1669083387,
-0.7172322869,
0.087759167,
-0.2317715734,
0.6478337646,
-0.59088099,
-0.4426602423,
0.4806243181,
-0.283839643,
0.4187183976,
0.3207850456,
-0.9593991637,
0.6436482668,
0.8694762588,
0.5810835361,
-0.056875065,
-0.2996553481,
-0.8587591052,
0.1638575643,
-0.6884886622,
0.8348201513,
-0.9640216231,
-0.5497661233,
0.0347916,
0.2054353952,
-0.1745302081,
-1.0631899834,
0.7564682961,
-1.1499270201,
0.1626185775,
-0.2959409952,
-0.604562223,
-0.2764379382,
-0.0683278069,
-0.6946660876,
0.8206096292,
0.1609632075,
-0.5251643062,
0.4190208316,
-0.8421741724,
-0.1717380881,
0.0717582405,
0.4428823292,
-0.093929857,
0.368317157,
0.5119889379,
-0.2409077883,
0.0272343177,
-0.292568475,
-0.267128855,
-0.6124352217,
0.1840554625,
0.0520526133,
0.8304009438,
0.1928258687,
0.0857403949,
0.0170123596,
-0.4399522841,
0.5920799971,
-0.0452435426,
-0.4071500897,
-0.8236928582,
-0.0484075136,
-0.3537071943,
-0.3024408817,
0.0997312963,
-0.9790329933,
0.2326169163,
-0.6125950217,
0.5212990642,
0.3943238258,
0.3697758615,
0.6626044512,
-0.2003441751,
0.3355128765,
-0.1138707772,
0.1503635347,
0.0617152005,
-0.5962145329,
-0.5388787985,
-0.0961696804,
0.7848975658,
0.6754947901,
-0.277919054,
0.1857751757,
-0.3280428648,
-0.3058187962,
-1.1425577402,
-0.065065071,
0.2180471122,
0.3692459762,
0.6570807695,
-0.2239224017,
-0.4462806582,
-0.5469247699,
-0.537728548,
-0.1373784095,
-0.0615938269,
0.5441532135,
0.097900033,
-0.0724450871,
0.7210226059,
-0.858940959,
-0.2725631893,
-0.0180611871,
0.1091359705,
0.1445869803,
0.4816462696,
0.2909063399,
-1.0217131376,
-0.4357919395,
-0.1481232643,
-0.6964552999,
0.02889755,
0.4889863729,
-0.6484845281,
-0.2695663869,
0.644077301,
-0.5684859753,
0.2533791959,
0.1682128608,
-0.2046851069,
0.2367684543,
-0.0044506467,
0.3768891096,
-0.7804734111,
-0.033678893,
-0.3835393786,
-0.1271790117,
-0.5268117189,
0.4948269725,
0.1846603006,
-0.2845053375,
-0.3563318551,
0.3399234116,
-0.5309152007,
-0.050009124,
-0.1558310539,
0.2483299524,
0.0626060739,
0.2282053679,
0.2263389528,
1.0228993893,
0.5620535016,
-0.6017876863,
0.0196207929,
0.6761537194,
-0.28482458,
0.5456190109,
-0.8561987877,
0.2153678536,
0.0285842996,
-0.1177809834,
-0.9344823956,
-0.059718471,
-0.3028540015,
-0.7454434037,
0.3002248108,
-0.3169419765,
-0.1010548696,
-0.2602915466,
-0.2723341882,
0.6220133901,
0.4606956542,
-0.8329888582,
0.2936600149,
0.2940166295,
-0.4323851764,
-0.6396176815,
-0.4407506287,
-0.1413704604,
-0.300645411,
-0.9011327028,
0.6096779704,
-0.3164599836,
-0.4622471929,
0.358466655,
-0.3330527246,
-0.2835329473,
-0.0981728509,
-0.2968436778,
-0.0276339203,
-0.6107266545,
-0.0567845702,
0.1300234497,
-0.016756162,
0.2026580721,
-0.3553975523,
0.2698797286,
-0.269043684,
-0.2087939382,
-0.208235994,
0.6877291799,
0.4960180819,
-0.6950862408,
0.4805486202,
0.2033615708,
-0.0532115586,
-0.0288552754,
-0.5167595148,
-0.5250731707,
-0.5309566259,
0.1462266445,
-0.5877601504,
-0.918351531,
0.4017264843,
-0.150292322,
0.1639603227,
0.42232728,
0.2648133039,
-0.1287711114,
1.3573322296,
0.7987625003,
0.2548319995,
0.4216296971,
-0.3770353198,
0.1191059798,
-1.4880702496,
-0.1154888645,
-0.3617485762,
-0.2589585483,
-0.6249548793,
-0.2326043397,
0.2909165025,
0.2683801949,
0.0825129822,
0.1787205338,
-0.5899482965,
0.5474930406,
0.9570496678,
0.4396526217,
0.4032220542,
0.1622336656,
-0.0381019749,
-0.0032225514,
-0.6003996134,
-0.0590659007,
1.6312203407,
0.0594000481,
0.6833022833,
0.5633774996,
0.8657662868,
0.1264413893,
0.2060636282,
-0.6296685934,
0.331792891,
0.012689082,
-0.7930185199,
-0.6746404767,
-0.3153685033,
-1.275791049,
0.5272823572,
0.0839677826,
-0.6363243461,
0.6179004908,
-0.1790522039,
-0.5955219865,
0.1376459152,
-0.6260326505,
0.70278579,
0.0156653784,
-0.3869779408,
-0.1973451078,
-0.4532132745,
0.2995918691,
0.1382012069,
-0.0718561932,
0.2614581883,
-0.1808817685,
0.9184216857,
-0.4475233555,
0.2327522933,
-0.189860329,
0.0984781459,
0.5362897515,
0.0433033295,
0.3829964697,
0.2457140386,
-0.3899139762,
0.0508411527,
0.1128632426,
-0.5139059424,
-0.8429126143,
0.6867950559,
-0.8167377114,
-0.7719888091,
-0.1977776289,
-0.4430657625,
-0.4179798365,
0.3545585573,
0.1082558483,
0.7427987456,
-0.162584424,
0.6438649893,
1.1055048704,
-0.223368004,
-0.003235182,
0.8223126531,
-0.0331875682,
-0.6268976927,
0.8604829907,
0.1291912794,
0.2512941062,
0.5042288303,
0.0548283383,
-0.6561623812,
-0.7271472216,
-0.4344938397,
0.4281107485,
-0.5394753218,
-0.1608507931,
-0.7574138641,
-0.1141731963,
-0.6438624859,
-0.0499684177,
0.0746250376,
-0.5177127719,
0.0930291861,
-0.3059338629,
0.4374201894,
0.2825666368,
-0.1746293604,
0.5071665049,
-0.5006181598,
0.2930820882,
0.488011837,
0.6896743178,
-0.0764186531,
-0.4813112617,
-0.1104809865,
-0.0232311375,
-0.4275201261,
-0.8024039865,
0.4088713825,
0.2196778655,
0.8860882521,
0.3144751787,
0.2903470099,
1.0749695301,
-0.7053248286,
0.5147503614,
-0.1595874727,
-0.4989426136,
0.6106775999,
-0.2539339662,
0.0754515752,
0.8128806949,
0.2019569427,
-0.3700274825,
-0.6248978376,
-0.7925305963,
-0.9992951155,
0.7784192562,
0.143956542,
-0.0553592779,
-0.2089924812,
0.3840960562,
-0.0205763485,
0.2460594922,
-0.0910496935,
-0.2002082765,
-0.1783248186,
-0.1126176193,
-0.0541349985,
-0.4050368071,
-0.1690503955,
-0.2789289057,
0.5923942327,
0.0518394373,
0.6638171673,
0.5462177992,
-0.2646705806,
-0.4988859892,
0.2253700495,
0.3894580603,
0.8998357654,
-0.9470734596,
-0.1324280351,
0.1367430389,
-0.5785298944,
-0.2038349956,
0.0108820898,
-0.1077295393,
-0.0745943114,
0.3667327166,
0.4819329977,
0.1029263064,
-0.5986307859,
0.3846850693,
-0.1754414886,
-0.4756839275,
-0.2496944964,
-0.0298933946,
0.0592458323,
0.2362163812,
0.641153276,
-0.1746910661,
0.630966723,
-0.7105076313,
0.5551533699,
0.4368411005,
-0.5060980916,
-0.0096882656,
1.0061968565,
0.297688216,
-0.3249230385,
0.9526637793,
0.205545336,
-0.3027178645,
0.5362099409,
0.695024848,
0.6683210135,
-0.2223972827,
-0.1426098347,
0.5168267488,
0.4354073107,
0.1467331052,
0.6249564886,
-0.1307004541,
-0.3001118302,
-0.5728441477,
-0.5225687027,
-0.545301497,
0.0418880805,
-1.142470479,
-0.1713309288,
-0.0471412316,
-0.1114487201,
-0.0056189829,
0.4102461338,
-0.3934572637,
0.430121541,
-0.3890096545,
1.3595021963,
-0.3435383737,
0.5230249166,
0.7103855014,
-0.5437005162,
-0.5717244744,
0.2943412662,
-0.3816534281,
-0.7654776573,
0.6077717543,
-0.033425469,
-0.0586390421,
0.5320781469,
-0.4776277542,
-1.1494605541,
1.2183020115,
-0.0951537937,
-0.2450079322,
0.1380205899,
-0.1437008679,
0.3722737432,
-0.2929754257,
0.4722990096,
0.2579630315,
0.379544735,
-0.0746981129,
-0.7019787431,
-0.0265612192,
-0.154306069,
-0.2637787461,
0.3077820539,
-0.5445249081,
0.6682241559,
-0.3457772732,
-0.0750865042,
0.3604134023,
0.8647504449,
0.2383794039,
0.5169035196,
0.6045486927,
0.682051897,
0.8949406147,
-0.2397670448,
1.1070379019,
-0.4703748822,
0.0943067968,
0.788292706,
-0.1164364964,
1.2766708136,
0.4480834007,
-0.0046222038,
0.6467528939,
0.9110846519,
0.3460813761,
0.9587567449,
-0.0893926695,
-0.1131040379,
-0.389261961,
0.1511930227,
-0.6233683825,
0.1839969754,
0.3853011429,
-0.2062338442,
-0.1129876524,
-0.0247189663,
-0.2477920204,
-0.0659522116,
-0.4039446712,
0.9607627392,
-0.0104505317,
-0.9255657196,
0.6442986727,
0.022561064,
0.3271454573,
-0.4026274979,
-0.1196872592,
-0.5129077435,
0.2250495404,
-0.0932865217,
-0.727933228,
0.2742185891,
-0.3990308046,
-0.223695606,
-0.0952961296,
0.5647590756,
-0.5772063136,
-0.4936891794,
0.2935702205,
0.6643898487,
0.3236480355,
-0.2481867075,
-0.5484083891,
-0.0024626523,
-0.2123093009,
-0.2800187171,
0.2838118076,
0.7510688305,
-0.1699997932,
0.6458931565,
0.9122629762,
0.0131734293,
0.5091583729,
-0.0409968086,
0.7139721513,
-0.6923653483,
-0.4619021714,
-0.2635230422,
0.0513745099,
-0.3748164475,
-0.0390246101,
0.7591669559,
0.9125062227,
0.9055498242,
0.0414903797,
0.5939019918,
0.0245885532,
1.0725874901,
-0.3298374116,
0.4847891033,
-0.9924595356,
0.1587455124,
-0.0947017223,
-0.9229031801,
-0.3025909662,
0.5768144131,
-0.48549667,
-0.1462750286,
0.7390831709,
0.8585502505,
-0.4123752415,
-0.0114703337,
0.3255610466,
0.021176165,
0.0432874151,
0.4593367279,
0.7923721075,
-0.4847501814,
0.9455669522,
-0.2823614478,
-0.2848896682,
-0.6002135277,
-0.1486954689,
-0.4036543965,
-0.2233102471,
-0.3712955415,
-0.3357276022,
0.3453278542,
0.2757704556,
0.9176443219,
-0.6941717863,
-0.2348677665,
0.115867503,
0.2069010437,
-0.9326766133,
-0.3132159114,
0.4190205932,
-0.6384683251,
-0.9744753242,
0.7198833227,
-0.0023139413,
-0.5317352414,
0.2453442067,
-0.1274620891,
-0.2223562896,
0.5002400279,
0.756863296,
0.3183755875,
-0.7213080525,
-0.2927359641,
0.662113905,
0.2064433992,
0.1025246009,
0.7577735186,
-0.7301977277,
0.4579532743,
0.3485524952,
0.6646744609,
0.3810708821,
0.5470573902,
0.5682125092,
-0.5841195583,
-0.3228845894,
0.0755767077,
0.0140697807,
-0.0385201201,
-0.2486010045,
0.8616056442,
0.1090926975,
-0.6681703925,
-1.1277065277,
0.0647184402,
-1.133734107,
-0.3885082603,
1.0277255774,
0.1099269539,
-0.445402652,
-0.1005089507,
-0.243520841,
-0.0389999375,
-0.4386284351,
0.6309684515,
0.4103812575,
-0.2687724233,
-0.2232757956,
-0.7070210576,
0.3911994994,
0.400606364,
-0.4226553142,
0.078711383,
0.2520314455,
0.563447237,
0.2369517982,
0.7570284009,
-0.5114930272,
0.4278553128,
0.0077460906,
-0.3140377104,
-0.036824733,
-0.3234158158,
0.0965259895,
0.5525864363,
0.3065653443,
-0.5864182115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17077v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17077v1 | Learning and Leveraging Verifiers to Improve Planning Capabilities of Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-05-26T16:36:55 | 2023-05-26T16:36:55 | Daman Arora, Subbarao Kambhampati | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | There have been wide spread claims in the literature about the emergent
reasoning capabilities of Pretrained Large Language Models. However, recent
studies, have found that their ability to plan remains questionable. Through
our experiments using GPT-2, we empirically demonstrate that the performance of
a finetuned baseline remains poor because it violates pre-conditions of actions
in the plans that it generates. To improve the planning capabilities of a
finetuned LLM, we train a verifier, which can classify actions as being valid
or invalid in a particular state. By randomly sampling actions from the same
dataset, we generate examples of invalid actions which are then used to train a
verifier which can check for action applicability. In the presence of diverse
sampling from a generator and a verifier which can prune invalid trajectories,
we show significant gains in the success rate on the Blocksworld domain.
Additionally, we show that finetuning the GPT-2 generator itself to create the
verifier generalizes better than finetuning the base GPT-2. Lastly, we
investigate the role of the sampling temperature which can be used to control
the exploration-exploitation tradeoff. | [
-0.3904069364,
-0.8456728458,
0.719548285,
-0.1071592569,
-0.1277543008,
-0.0303697009,
-0.2749866545,
-0.238054648,
-0.0990915447,
0.5110886097,
-0.3866976202,
-0.0699866265,
-0.5614249706,
-0.2031679302,
-0.2842968106,
1.0505914688,
-0.144787997,
-0.186245352,
-0.0498823822,
0.1914871037,
-0.5230559111,
-0.5786553025,
-0.7795038223,
-0.6455581188,
0.2595955133,
0.5601225495,
0.7141759992,
0.5511862636,
0.1754817814,
0.3530632555,
0.0421606489,
0.2857257724,
-0.7442697287,
0.0170908794,
-0.4018420875,
-0.4302109182,
-0.1177203804,
-0.0394695401,
0.3689999282,
0.3763431311,
-0.2569705248,
0.0177805498,
0.2011405677,
0.2488285154,
-0.7242949605,
0.1553464532,
-0.7733351588,
-0.0843472332,
-0.1671264768,
-0.2750642598,
-0.2524690926,
-0.311185509,
0.2888555527,
-0.4269949496,
0.2543187737,
-0.1606056839,
1.030333519,
0.3582042158,
-0.236142844,
-0.0785797834,
-1.1235593557,
0.6295025945,
-0.4485814273,
0.2053410262,
0.5695582032,
0.5191472769,
-0.1551996917,
-1.0480328798,
-0.6909248233,
-0.165985316,
-0.1419952661,
0.0814196169,
-0.1617232114,
0.076836057,
0.5374754667,
0.3047706485,
-0.5091019869,
0.3371214867,
-0.4641188681,
-0.4259054363,
0.5170040131,
-0.0748969316,
0.0073258067,
-0.0541181155,
-0.4318787754,
-0.2842125297,
-0.889918983,
0.3643961549,
0.3424726129,
0.0911859646,
0.1520597488,
0.6362782121,
-0.3568315506,
0.6881546974,
-0.0150328521,
0.1906338036,
0.0170470681,
-0.3690624833,
-0.5677918196,
-0.3060279489,
0.413646549,
0.1094615534,
0.3994329274,
-0.0612745583,
-0.4836662114,
-0.0737642497,
0.3668471873,
-0.8100987077,
-0.5419282913,
0.2638766766,
0.0106673511,
-0.0756564215,
-0.1987702399,
-0.3804135621,
-0.218796432,
-0.5032812357,
0.5887147188,
-0.5245413184,
-0.2813814878,
0.1554629505,
-0.1566109955,
0.3362183273,
0.2961348295,
-0.8410348892,
0.3035223186,
0.6944462657,
0.4699862897,
0.3011999726,
-0.602101624,
-0.5922313929,
0.0899213701,
-0.3184244335,
0.9975557327,
-0.2332000136,
-0.3398109078,
0.1385400444,
-0.2314505428,
-0.0460135229,
-0.5332787633,
0.5704316497,
-0.5330092907,
0.1141105816,
-0.4547398984,
-0.3793670237,
-0.1580905914,
0.6667090058,
-0.534229219,
0.833748281,
0.1950585842,
-0.3717935979,
0.7198935747,
-0.3896845877,
-0.4778088927,
0.0995905995,
-0.3986762464,
-0.3966896236,
0.1172497272,
0.2001993209,
0.6511244178,
-0.1273009777,
0.1126188412,
0.0184450746,
-0.3727194667,
0.2238153666,
-0.4559438527,
0.5515070558,
0.342925638,
-0.2691414654,
0.0795520544,
-0.5803426504,
0.4255663753,
0.1186987758,
-0.6042171121,
-0.2292410433,
0.262372613,
-0.1052361131,
0.3094591796,
-0.0464884937,
-0.2272545844,
0.2063212693,
-0.3282248378,
0.5255002975,
0.7092975974,
0.1314475387,
0.3015234172,
-0.450062722,
0.4370622337,
-0.3167831004,
-0.0599040128,
0.0411011204,
-0.1183906868,
-0.7631824613,
-0.1290120482,
0.2126420736,
0.7351388931,
-0.989423275,
0.2595131993,
-0.3996292651,
-0.5522982478,
-0.0610978156,
0.1242359951,
0.5407628417,
0.2234056443,
0.4086216688,
-0.0745518953,
-0.5305950642,
-0.6323642135,
-0.2433540076,
-0.2023238242,
-0.0695681572,
0.1741876453,
0.296572119,
-0.077405192,
1.0342283249,
-0.3152450323,
0.0777788311,
-0.5199950337,
0.0099257352,
0.1277402639,
0.625400722,
0.487965256,
-0.729044795,
-0.2238480598,
0.0760216266,
-0.4758499563,
0.1254766434,
-0.2650142312,
-0.074714981,
-0.0538956858,
0.5617542267,
-0.5605722666,
0.3315773904,
0.4220838547,
-0.3214117289,
0.6227460504,
-0.3825238943,
0.026984226,
-0.7333233953,
-0.1441072375,
-0.1364906132,
-0.357237637,
-0.8690160513,
0.1009400338,
0.0286138114,
-0.0269366931,
-0.5011870265,
0.3953712583,
-0.3358168006,
0.1668998003,
-0.36683622,
-0.1030640528,
-0.2059780806,
0.3238197863,
0.1792763621,
0.7985474467,
0.4787803292,
-1.0129650831,
-0.0024300003,
0.1687857211,
-0.3488250375,
0.386287123,
-0.6393548846,
0.1264723092,
0.0286184736,
0.1266111135,
-0.9193355441,
-0.3221561313,
0.0217892397,
-0.2590630651,
0.6118222475,
-0.4076861441,
-0.32334584,
-0.462004602,
0.0550536774,
0.0601194724,
0.6216068268,
-0.5774627328,
0.5518571138,
0.2903906405,
-0.1769291461,
-0.6097020507,
-0.8249731064,
-0.1836084723,
-0.3072600961,
-0.4889243841,
0.1305200607,
0.1674399674,
-0.1509020329,
-0.255237937,
-0.2223937213,
-0.1170088723,
0.2404838651,
0.2203805596,
0.0069375858,
0.0998998582,
-0.119694382,
-0.0046632965,
-0.4019722342,
0.181681633,
-0.4666418731,
0.8432157636,
0.0297595598,
-0.4700862169,
-0.1580924094,
-0.0962548926,
0.2729117274,
-0.2480305582,
0.3790272772,
0.4284842312,
-0.3985522687,
-0.2202671915,
-0.7442720532,
-0.1499254256,
-0.5042065978,
0.428879112,
-0.5645127296,
-0.9634506702,
0.4976612031,
-0.3598775566,
0.2305020541,
0.3367667794,
0.3607931137,
0.0163770318,
0.6612935662,
0.6077138186,
-0.0272717662,
0.3527992964,
-0.5331350565,
0.1461515576,
-0.6012495756,
0.064387612,
-0.5018533468,
-0.3132370412,
-0.6477863789,
-0.509526372,
0.1348179132,
0.3049469292,
-0.3533968031,
0.3056451976,
-0.1900152862,
0.8598816395,
0.5632886291,
-0.0143490322,
-0.0630702153,
0.1895043403,
-0.1546792388,
0.0708959624,
-0.7216414809,
-0.7288635969,
1.0324552059,
0.2726103067,
0.5663954616,
0.060868077,
0.8854813576,
-0.196568042,
0.3194400072,
-0.5500590801,
0.3950067461,
-0.0032528078,
-0.7432075739,
-0.5517345667,
-0.3399162292,
-0.743588388,
0.3160574734,
-0.1597129554,
-0.9265648127,
0.2759703398,
0.6177865863,
-0.5699417591,
0.2829900682,
-0.8920906186,
0.8688899279,
-0.4157592952,
-0.5457749963,
-0.3305094838,
-0.284635365,
0.3012599945,
-0.0373437814,
0.014235924,
-0.0060957707,
0.3496923745,
0.3609474301,
-0.5733203888,
0.7843639255,
-0.6225057244,
-0.0432145111,
0.3799861372,
0.2020638734,
0.9300915599,
0.1603085697,
-0.0167108346,
-0.1044033691,
-0.2522034049,
-0.4575341046,
-0.3876796961,
0.5859606266,
-0.7395672202,
-0.70206213,
-0.1852426827,
-0.1826893538,
-0.421710521,
0.3098165095,
0.585627377,
0.195416376,
-0.4084436297,
0.0739842281,
0.625158906,
0.0206810646,
0.3751088977,
0.4043269455,
-0.1381601244,
-0.2632751465,
0.8869068623,
0.3302757144,
0.5702019334,
0.2032965124,
0.160351038,
-0.1858248115,
-1.1010881662,
-0.1475508064,
-0.1373310834,
-0.6807557344,
-0.1518321037,
-0.3573109508,
-0.4005040824,
-0.1346615255,
-0.2532735169,
-0.3190920949,
-0.3433246613,
0.2991039753,
-0.3981090486,
0.1240662411,
0.6134225726,
-0.3949591219,
0.6088911891,
-0.3663125932,
0.0171151273,
0.5342220664,
0.1593301296,
-0.39322263,
-0.4073455632,
-0.1923309267,
0.0762905255,
-0.2327002734,
-0.3941244185,
0.1570113003,
0.055107981,
0.8241704702,
0.4029737711,
-0.1320637017,
0.9345291257,
-0.5628693104,
0.6949652433,
-0.1818222553,
-0.7907021642,
0.6745727062,
-0.2314935029,
0.2964477241,
0.7142801285,
0.3775101304,
-0.2530462146,
-0.4276268184,
-0.7368861437,
-0.923697412,
0.5731139183,
0.3609357178,
0.226048544,
0.1959687173,
0.4291054308,
0.0513508767,
-0.0569209196,
-0.7657555938,
-0.1176538244,
-0.3367087841,
0.4443809092,
-0.3784534931,
-0.5084941387,
-0.207075581,
-0.1280152649,
0.753185153,
-0.1233393103,
0.0620324872,
0.1017677784,
-0.2744243741,
0.1367586404,
0.3553152084,
0.5491853952,
0.7138387561,
-0.0569869801,
0.2194523513,
0.4116475284,
-0.6662424803,
0.2276839614,
0.555237174,
-0.3970207572,
-0.3633648753,
0.3864846826,
0.7171297669,
0.0794640929,
-0.417797178,
0.2049647421,
-0.167891264,
-0.3792616725,
-0.346377641,
0.3084548116,
-0.164723292,
0.3265603185,
0.0535704046,
0.2957146466,
0.0662603825,
-0.2219079584,
0.1064775512,
0.2921729684,
-0.2632361054,
-0.2014376819,
0.2783243954,
0.0416733995,
-0.1810874492,
0.6186937094,
-0.4016748667,
-0.5663434863,
0.40594244,
0.625361979,
0.6177662611,
-0.3395782709,
0.0462829918,
0.4188775122,
0.630065918,
-0.1782387048,
0.5347949862,
-0.2443310171,
-1.0302703381,
-0.6177837849,
-0.3386761248,
-0.2842311859,
0.4301849902,
-0.4215541184,
0.1169196144,
-0.6879190207,
-0.1286238283,
-0.274078697,
0.1421244591,
-1.1420613527,
0.2178426683,
0.0480232239,
0.8511073589,
-0.8009904027,
0.7519720197,
0.7278155088,
-0.3003854454,
-1.1649475098,
0.1017630696,
0.1408293992,
-0.8839566708,
0.4378264248,
0.152404353,
-0.0898728818,
0.1506326944,
-0.4522908926,
-1.0175175667,
1.1920073032,
0.2455055118,
-0.7244743109,
0.1840043664,
0.1176930591,
0.3460257351,
0.1150069609,
0.1727656126,
0.7767466903,
0.4972532988,
0.1026663706,
-0.9224637747,
-0.0860733166,
-0.0792667344,
-0.0856509581,
0.1434610635,
-0.2681315243,
0.6758480668,
-0.3315684199,
-0.3997991979,
-0.0013803305,
0.7160987258,
0.4140252769,
0.1371944547,
0.6621991396,
0.7223560214,
1.0838067532,
-0.3443533182,
1.2632186413,
-0.0512411781,
0.2363466322,
1.2069206238,
-0.3737440109,
0.9127960205,
0.3794781566,
-0.1501556486,
0.3281677067,
0.5171852708,
0.2097531855,
0.7072258592,
0.4835163057,
-0.1912249923,
-0.477542609,
0.3464535177,
-0.2580385208,
0.5769588351,
0.5668851733,
-0.0016808884,
-0.4185290635,
0.0437458307,
0.195190981,
0.0601088665,
-0.2624883652,
0.618193984,
-0.1874485314,
-0.7881644964,
0.6119733453,
-0.1342483312,
0.4952198863,
-0.5984634757,
0.1926528811,
-0.0134025477,
0.4653060734,
-0.1436502784,
-0.8288555145,
0.2558794618,
0.0098177837,
0.0170507245,
-0.3362401724,
0.8248075843,
-0.1996008903,
-0.1229148805,
0.003060767,
0.6977427006,
0.088517122,
-0.03653742,
-0.3522234261,
-0.1143864617,
0.0352984741,
-0.4192049205,
0.1149314418,
0.6631657481,
-0.0647131354,
0.5951583982,
0.7220821977,
0.1824328154,
-0.0846983045,
0.0437229089,
1.0271860361,
-0.4672012031,
-0.4758209884,
-0.8589348197,
0.6244948506,
-0.2468542755,
-0.4077073932,
0.6952439547,
0.6487188339,
1.250254035,
0.0569308214,
0.9908484817,
-0.1607699245,
0.3737038076,
-0.8939540982,
0.5824214816,
0.0126526309,
0.3592498899,
0.1810425073,
-0.809600234,
-0.1699390411,
0.7865150571,
-0.6564097404,
0.1158748716,
0.5154289603,
0.7502788901,
-0.2115980089,
-0.2277897745,
0.3279787302,
0.1709284782,
0.7403160334,
0.6234689951,
1.0616483688,
-0.1508111656,
0.3845927715,
-0.3498601913,
-0.2432397604,
0.01175554,
-0.9266875386,
-0.9279667735,
-0.3746553659,
-0.1210788041,
-0.3260779381,
0.1223454252,
0.7681130767,
0.8590556979,
-0.6928216219,
-0.1435770839,
-0.3709034622,
0.0031861372,
-0.3273982406,
-0.1460655481,
0.1490468234,
-0.6416492462,
-0.5024532676,
0.5239631534,
-0.0711387768,
0.2943812609,
-0.2382419109,
-0.3561313748,
0.0001432495,
-0.071470134,
0.4620868266,
0.7144033909,
-0.4720073342,
-0.4057618082,
-0.3568844199,
0.0876583904,
-0.2889825106,
0.9386603236,
-0.926112473,
0.2170420289,
0.3721324503,
0.6521733403,
0.5448453426,
-0.1634039879,
0.6923283935,
-0.8175231814,
0.0811148658,
0.2215148658,
0.6283237338,
0.1060447246,
-0.241490379,
0.4977059364,
-0.13279441,
-0.8192453384,
-0.5888934135,
0.3019697368,
-0.5925175548,
-0.0524126366,
1.2189408541,
-0.1844774783,
0.001630892,
-0.0706097484,
-0.2312880605,
0.0803660229,
-0.0343560576,
0.6832281351,
0.7285033464,
-0.1056336537,
0.0415151231,
-0.7115576267,
0.8192119598,
0.3506972492,
-0.897126019,
0.2218132615,
0.6248047352,
0.390350908,
0.2659933865,
0.8291170001,
0.1878203154,
0.3805113435,
-0.0526082069,
-0.2597056925,
-0.2568816841,
-0.3209021986,
-0.3451181054,
0.0720495135,
0.3753872216,
-0.0458879881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17075v1 | CREST: A Joint Framework for Rationalization and Counterfactual Text Generation | 2023-05-26T16:34:58 | 2023-05-26T16:34:58 | Marcos Treviso, Alexis Ross, Nuno M. Guerreiro, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL | Selective rationales and counterfactual examples have emerged as two
effective, complementary classes of interpretability methods for analyzing and
training NLP models. However, prior work has not explored how these methods can
be integrated to combine their complementary advantages. We overcome this
limitation by introducing CREST (ContRastive Edits with Sparse
raTionalization), a joint framework for selective rationalization and
counterfactual text generation, and show that this framework leads to
improvements in counterfactual quality, model robustness, and interpretability.
First, CREST generates valid counterfactuals that are more natural than those
produced by previous methods, and subsequently can be used for data
augmentation at scale, reducing the need for human-generated examples. Second,
we introduce a new loss function that leverages CREST counterfactuals to
regularize selective rationales and show that this regularization improves both
model robustness and rationale quality, compared to methods that do not
leverage CREST counterfactuals. Our results demonstrate that CREST successfully
bridges the gap between selective rationales and counterfactual examples,
addressing the limitations of existing methods and providing a more
comprehensive view of a model's predictions. | [
-0.5607128739,
-0.7711117268,
0.354614079,
0.1774973571,
-0.3355582952,
-0.1465583891,
0.0052928571,
-0.3357793987,
0.2290718853,
0.495088011,
-0.9352967739,
-0.2363011986,
-0.4737811685,
0.0905579701,
-0.3354106247,
1.1011478901,
-0.1387204379,
0.294075191,
-0.169326365,
-0.5316886306,
-0.4709725976,
-0.5867453218,
-0.6923962235,
-0.3687676489,
0.5272639394,
0.1099347547,
1.0437293053,
0.8498081565,
0.3016036749,
0.2438654155,
0.1668469012,
0.2732775211,
-0.6386377811,
0.1388786137,
-0.5907244086,
-0.3981933594,
-0.4282273352,
0.2851988971,
0.4175412953,
0.800406456,
0.1548179537,
-0.1054242626,
0.0681783035,
0.6485629082,
-0.6138749719,
0.330247283,
-0.8450921178,
-0.1227845773,
0.0777594298,
-0.4537824392,
-0.5454128385,
-0.1351945996,
0.3549491167,
-1.0413832664,
0.3339439631,
0.1496099383,
0.9292018414,
0.3943844736,
-0.3369357288,
-0.3993535042,
-0.4542390108,
1.2081227303,
-0.718008101,
0.2881574631,
0.3500752747,
0.1730358154,
-0.0737013221,
-1.0593811274,
-0.6445314884,
0.1612590104,
-0.265429318,
0.3351929784,
-0.5619233847,
0.2350422591,
0.281773299,
0.2497133464,
-0.507011354,
-0.0340501666,
-0.0221778937,
-0.3965186775,
0.5806786418,
0.1103982329,
0.7383092046,
-0.1287925541,
-0.3439260721,
-0.322640568,
-0.7205044627,
0.143599838,
0.185403958,
0.6005237699,
0.0928632468,
0.5474871397,
-0.1830769181,
0.513241291,
0.0816597119,
-0.1294721067,
-0.0051294309,
-0.3756400943,
-0.3626363575,
0.1530241072,
0.4395529032,
0.8897603154,
0.1932798177,
-0.056358017,
-0.1262453645,
0.5537228584,
0.1448332518,
-1.0032339096,
-0.0953425542,
0.3288156986,
-0.6618555188,
-0.351400584,
-0.2807973027,
-0.6656160951,
-0.1714562029,
-0.5645924211,
0.2112903744,
-0.4741114676,
-0.1044970974,
0.0888600498,
-0.4335480928,
0.2730038762,
0.2527864575,
-0.9790765047,
0.247807622,
0.7455302477,
0.6175379753,
-0.1376436055,
-0.2331334651,
-0.6188836694,
-0.0950054675,
-0.6176882982,
0.7909020782,
-0.6214878559,
-0.2207046002,
0.1984043568,
-0.1512827724,
-0.4066892266,
-0.4216580689,
0.6600443125,
-0.7607612014,
0.2203008384,
-0.4732636213,
-0.5757474899,
-0.4253823161,
0.2113828808,
-0.7133991718,
0.5487477183,
0.2225124538,
-0.9043838382,
0.5460560322,
-0.282553345,
-0.3773086071,
-0.0169455763,
-0.2235834599,
-0.3468164206,
0.0790412873,
0.2972981632,
-0.0612615347,
-0.1926105917,
0.3933645189,
-0.3731883466,
-0.1177959219,
0.2543108761,
-0.56011343,
1.0699970722,
0.1459747553,
-0.1689565033,
0.3030312359,
-0.6117963195,
0.1217162833,
-0.2005329877,
-0.089136906,
-0.3861179948,
-0.1066390425,
0.1724235862,
0.2738003731,
0.0170137882,
-0.4247900248,
-0.122713834,
-0.5781933665,
0.2906979322,
0.4054506719,
0.2517632544,
0.505933404,
-0.720451355,
0.5900184512,
-0.1438339502,
0.1720587909,
-0.4037300944,
-0.4767420888,
-0.6831089854,
-0.5965347886,
0.2886665463,
0.5970389247,
-1.0434083939,
0.1230761781,
0.0853813887,
-0.2683014572,
-0.3524475694,
0.0301308166,
0.5013213158,
1.2137309313,
0.7309991717,
-0.0017109957,
-0.9846525192,
-0.8979373574,
-0.5450084209,
-0.2011208981,
-0.0132314516,
0.0914104804,
0.3333179653,
-0.3782936931,
1.2775691748,
-0.2999666631,
-0.2634114027,
-0.4394493103,
0.5200182796,
0.0242298841,
0.7127976418,
0.6798727512,
-1.1448283195,
-0.448266983,
-0.3555089533,
-0.7079790831,
-0.2373563349,
-0.4754803777,
-0.1241085902,
0.1906694919,
0.5941613317,
-0.5106711984,
0.6454284191,
0.4255100787,
-0.2455296218,
0.4919858575,
0.0089752674,
0.1045171693,
-0.737272501,
0.0097817341,
0.052388981,
0.0162812918,
-0.9325282574,
0.1659449488,
-0.0611287281,
0.1617340147,
-0.4986365736,
0.7476583123,
0.1768629551,
0.1610123068,
-0.1370426863,
0.238166675,
0.4376544356,
0.4958658814,
0.2088839412,
0.6299932003,
0.2628078163,
-0.4328441322,
-0.0083194543,
0.4691580236,
-0.0217426233,
0.6925871968,
-0.8474341035,
-0.4573839307,
-0.3505571485,
0.4644946754,
-0.9701564312,
-0.3373363912,
0.1413648874,
-0.3593805432,
0.1526145786,
-0.2657978535,
-0.0737183243,
0.1882181764,
-0.6449130177,
0.3371762633,
0.6385386586,
-0.6275616288,
0.816085875,
0.239898324,
-0.3787475526,
-0.8211521506,
-0.9483709335,
-0.050057821,
-0.199933663,
-0.662896812,
0.5727971792,
-0.2582170665,
-0.5661413074,
0.0192825925,
-0.2804869115,
-0.2831392884,
-0.0364449136,
0.1173715889,
0.6832411885,
-0.4285844266,
0.0796509832,
0.5247656107,
-0.1622108966,
0.0263663344,
0.0106395902,
0.2996692359,
-0.1461161673,
-0.1887571514,
-0.505599618,
0.2405709028,
0.3078858256,
-0.2180350274,
0.5877129436,
0.3728777766,
-0.3106607497,
-0.5082831383,
-0.3449494541,
-0.1901578009,
-0.4523507357,
0.2184654027,
-0.2032631636,
-0.6563397646,
0.7643765211,
-0.0722470582,
0.319263339,
0.8717775941,
0.2536429167,
-0.0090490738,
1.2944215536,
0.4605486393,
0.6363070607,
0.4090057313,
-0.2489899993,
0.0339487121,
-0.7469619513,
-0.1116766781,
-0.3960388303,
0.1026698425,
-0.5228281021,
-0.2204834223,
-0.0333890095,
0.4072359502,
-0.2282262743,
0.1063116342,
-0.3848382235,
0.5088580251,
0.2394807488,
-0.0290246718,
0.2841679454,
0.0354599804,
-0.238776356,
-0.5767679811,
-0.8929311037,
-0.6510299444,
0.858458221,
0.4221469164,
0.3866564333,
-0.0671913475,
0.4121952057,
0.0974235982,
0.9770072103,
-0.849715054,
0.3793510795,
-0.5843662024,
-0.6344822049,
-0.3719726801,
-0.3822548091,
-0.7948868871,
0.5434263349,
-0.4620111287,
-0.3218981028,
0.493737936,
0.4324380755,
-0.4086332321,
0.0920991004,
-0.5697121024,
1.0503185987,
0.0909729749,
-0.3345086873,
-0.1216839626,
-0.4297586083,
0.4446817636,
-0.2380761206,
0.4264696538,
0.0935113505,
-0.1462699324,
0.7729007006,
-0.5802623034,
0.8832674026,
-0.1159504354,
0.1008633003,
0.4449610114,
0.2080164403,
0.2953837514,
0.192249164,
-0.2211771309,
-0.0521136932,
-0.0452611335,
-0.3446253836,
-0.9272512197,
0.6643856168,
-0.5514007807,
-0.372204572,
-0.2736693621,
-0.9787003994,
-0.4530647397,
0.5077598691,
0.2990652323,
0.8206879497,
-0.2491760254,
0.222603783,
0.6980816722,
-0.32776016,
0.4557685256,
0.3654691875,
-0.1648851484,
-0.6906711459,
0.8547540903,
0.2116994262,
0.2255847901,
0.1544170231,
0.3756311834,
-0.6778632402,
-0.730017662,
-0.3423558176,
0.145421207,
-1.0805702209,
-0.0458285846,
-0.5240591168,
-0.207739383,
-0.273402065,
-0.5873842835,
-0.2352886796,
-0.7323948145,
-0.3671186566,
0.055909086,
0.060547106,
0.4971240461,
-0.1896774918,
0.4325581193,
-0.591738224,
0.5163092017,
0.4571918547,
0.1332370937,
0.0611829385,
-0.6416775584,
0.1536992937,
0.259907186,
-0.0161766354,
-0.4392541647,
0.6403234005,
0.0427996442,
0.6404471993,
0.3143357038,
0.5738729835,
0.8638074398,
-0.3612169921,
0.6145131588,
0.3731350899,
-1.0518444777,
0.2936733961,
-0.3814604282,
0.1255185902,
0.9063280225,
0.5651596785,
-0.2168605775,
-0.4296299517,
-0.7353440523,
-0.9570407867,
0.5847222805,
0.0594439693,
0.0404419266,
-0.0909334943,
0.2124762386,
0.0336033441,
0.148229599,
-0.6265111566,
-0.0830486268,
-0.8325770497,
-0.4026153684,
0.1239904165,
-0.2572622895,
-0.3244884908,
0.074215129,
0.7089419961,
-0.1842943579,
-0.5186501741,
0.4798637927,
-0.3209042251,
-0.2177786976,
0.1116598397,
0.7249131799,
0.8365414143,
-0.425413847,
0.1425053626,
0.2126962692,
-0.3255149424,
-0.2829167247,
0.0923282728,
-0.4854576588,
0.1461109966,
0.8630503416,
0.553706646,
0.2881316841,
-0.6752585769,
0.5037309527,
-0.1257133037,
-0.3508119881,
0.0232903231,
0.003697067,
-0.1755513847,
0.02152008,
0.4395627677,
0.5292630196,
0.1231242493,
-0.5003399849,
0.5195060372,
0.4387948513,
-0.498290658,
-0.0754710212,
0.6640985012,
0.1645134985,
-0.0597997345,
0.5285217166,
-0.2035452127,
-0.4775165617,
0.6567990184,
0.5716739297,
0.8537102342,
-0.066025503,
0.3158815801,
0.5456764102,
0.1447120458,
-0.1653970778,
0.0560614876,
0.1494234502,
-0.7933829427,
-0.6876245737,
-0.3853901029,
-0.6090191603,
0.1593105793,
-0.819804132,
0.0720475838,
-0.5799790621,
-0.1335871071,
0.3288176954,
-0.1118192151,
-0.2658114433,
0.4076525569,
-0.3236279488,
1.0017067194,
-0.9700443149,
0.4701456726,
0.3859322071,
-0.6677789688,
-0.7659663558,
0.0250199344,
-0.0253868233,
-0.6553680897,
0.9035408497,
0.1706176847,
-0.3261524737,
-0.3948756754,
-0.4842550755,
-0.6008538008,
0.9747408628,
0.4107119143,
-0.3332561553,
0.0169060584,
0.0944303125,
0.7659640908,
-0.7154094577,
0.201194495,
0.4367554188,
0.4883324504,
0.4510933757,
-0.5384607315,
0.2366823554,
0.0015040826,
0.1087413728,
-0.453222841,
-0.2987167537,
0.958091557,
0.0141761331,
-0.4127125144,
0.0728255436,
0.5063639283,
0.3612808287,
0.5477882624,
0.548545301,
0.3634366989,
0.590416193,
0.0205015186,
1.1561603546,
-0.4949306846,
0.1714579314,
1.2249107361,
-0.2082658112,
0.7333879471,
0.4066563845,
0.1724499464,
0.5282269716,
0.4435691237,
0.0893425196,
0.5340362787,
-0.0341861434,
-0.0743649825,
-0.3932900429,
-0.5400522947,
-0.0636888221,
0.1605859697,
0.3573943377,
-0.2799938917,
-0.452252984,
-0.1697252989,
0.2483493835,
0.4317305684,
-0.5427728295,
0.3556558192,
0.135572046,
-0.8601881862,
0.7279250026,
-0.0851420239,
0.5390403867,
-0.6185449958,
-0.2790289521,
-0.2375627458,
0.1666747481,
-0.5102174282,
-0.502441287,
0.7104449272,
-0.1969728917,
-0.3259423971,
-0.4846892953,
0.6876755953,
-0.3549993634,
-0.2753202915,
0.1002708822,
0.3137432635,
-0.2989171743,
0.2444611937,
-0.8550224304,
0.2527402043,
0.0863526016,
-0.2949236333,
0.2064171284,
0.2698771656,
-0.1284309775,
0.5450208187,
0.8834469318,
-0.015848672,
-0.3399383426,
0.3673757315,
0.9171081185,
-0.3046206236,
-0.4888846278,
-0.785877049,
0.5357420444,
-0.1713203341,
-0.376563251,
0.9375721216,
0.4612164497,
0.709219873,
0.0327503271,
0.7575768828,
0.3376220763,
0.6108791232,
-0.4189040959,
0.5280259848,
-0.3619405925,
0.3896256089,
-0.2272300869,
-0.714413166,
-0.716481626,
0.6735213995,
-0.4461263418,
-0.1293085963,
0.7245306969,
0.8702682257,
0.0741059557,
0.1732474864,
0.1674013287,
0.0924242064,
0.4030106962,
0.0224040728,
0.769831121,
-0.4381338656,
0.616679728,
-0.1438280344,
-0.3437955976,
-0.0284618698,
-0.964702785,
-1.1134860516,
-0.3580167294,
-0.4609807134,
-0.3896884024,
-0.1064068079,
0.850548625,
0.6429747343,
-0.9368560314,
0.0882132426,
-0.3809083104,
0.308945775,
-0.1632768512,
-0.2542587519,
0.4346714914,
-0.6717580557,
-0.615350008,
0.386847645,
0.2503265738,
0.2576031983,
-0.0350923575,
-0.2238622904,
-0.0016260671,
0.8145087957,
0.6518409848,
0.5303813815,
-0.6690551043,
-0.1386942863,
-0.1032840982,
-0.0266752578,
-0.1686307192,
0.8324015141,
-0.7435764074,
0.5296952724,
0.5759709477,
0.6578159332,
0.292296797,
0.235021919,
0.6696274877,
-0.399495095,
0.1205442846,
0.3627759814,
0.3190083802,
0.2471402586,
0.0629760474,
0.3584559262,
0.1191768199,
-0.1783060431,
-1.1250817776,
0.5049344301,
-1.0580298901,
-0.6047350764,
0.8499340415,
-0.3166389465,
-0.068504408,
-0.4417549372,
-0.2310879827,
0.254214108,
-0.2253911346,
0.4675995409,
0.5425006747,
-0.4136137664,
0.0513307154,
-0.3141602278,
0.9375460148,
0.6275871992,
-0.6653942466,
0.1969645023,
0.4712094069,
0.0356189795,
0.4061977565,
0.4922920465,
-0.1137738675,
0.4697401524,
0.4932060242,
-0.3122942448,
-0.2238461226,
-0.1532032937,
-0.4428721666,
0.1607122123,
0.0248836726,
0.3297995627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17073v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17073v1 | NeuroX Library for Neuron Analysis of Deep NLP Models | 2023-05-26T16:32:56 | 2023-05-26T16:32:56 | Fahim Dalvi, Hassan Sajjad, Nadir Durrani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neuron analysis provides insights into how knowledge is structured in
representations and discovers the role of neurons in the network. In addition
to developing an understanding of our models, neuron analysis enables various
applications such as debiasing, domain adaptation and architectural search. We
present NeuroX, a comprehensive open-source toolkit to conduct neuron analysis
of natural language processing models. It implements various interpretation
methods under a unified API, and provides a framework for data processing and
evaluation, thus making it easier for researchers and practitioners to perform
neuron analysis. The Python toolkit is available at
https://www.github.com/fdalvi/NeuroX. Demo Video available at
https://youtu.be/mLhs2YMx4u8. | [
-0.3373223841,
-0.7554901838,
0.2618759573,
0.3298521042,
0.1474721283,
-0.096493274,
-0.1323924363,
-0.5197268724,
0.2008044273,
0.4639369249,
-0.5712623596,
-0.6084656715,
-0.2776677907,
-0.0369634852,
-0.5366817117,
0.6769633889,
0.2700460851,
0.2326269001,
-0.3433458209,
-0.1630751938,
-0.2952341437,
-0.4035057425,
-0.9729148746,
-0.874132514,
0.542118907,
0.2074240595,
0.795894742,
0.0588344857,
0.3774785399,
0.2953543961,
-0.4998227954,
-0.2879424989,
0.1488209367,
0.1338375062,
-0.4511321783,
-0.254186213,
-0.7744784355,
-0.0512062535,
0.3780200481,
1.0204429626,
-0.3175008595,
0.1021895409,
0.0210303012,
0.5177323222,
-0.6529446244,
0.0617990121,
-0.2615634799,
0.3368606567,
-0.0418392643,
-0.1065016761,
-0.2220459431,
-0.4663476646,
0.3525371253,
-0.3420504332,
0.1288899928,
-0.2311064452,
0.4886368811,
0.2811493874,
-0.3027815521,
-0.0605365112,
-0.3343159258,
0.5330275893,
-1.2287322283,
0.1855725795,
0.2931953967,
0.3605675101,
-0.3445519805,
-0.9272504449,
-0.6178996563,
-0.1794674098,
-0.0601825044,
-0.1512843817,
-0.5543270111,
0.3566930294,
0.2947792709,
0.4401242137,
-0.8833940029,
0.3507628739,
-0.1538099647,
-0.3134509325,
0.5408596396,
0.2720747888,
0.7009509206,
-0.1940809637,
-0.0868168324,
-0.0219203308,
-0.2965625823,
-0.1843707114,
0.6121308208,
0.0316388607,
-0.0787339285,
0.5121327043,
-0.2890083492,
0.8663135767,
-0.4439385533,
0.5119188428,
0.4321033359,
-0.046117343,
-0.27279526,
0.2692800164,
0.9200163484,
0.4560848176,
0.1585827321,
-0.245518595,
-0.2655601799,
-0.0833237395,
0.3305656612,
-0.9412754774,
-0.5464658141,
0.3786178231,
-0.8562405109,
-0.3121829927,
-0.4364432096,
-0.9301077724,
-0.6362810731,
-0.5786354542,
0.2741976082,
-0.3586619496,
-0.7178115249,
0.5096263289,
-0.5490160584,
0.1955371648,
0.0525518581,
-0.8957640529,
0.8824111223,
0.4410348237,
0.9765615463,
-0.1744025797,
-0.2307934612,
-0.4221401215,
-0.4673748612,
-0.2276137173,
0.7337114811,
-0.4473071694,
0.0794732496,
-0.095692344,
0.0743442476,
0.154745549,
-0.4825159013,
0.3887756765,
-0.6417910457,
-0.2917815149,
0.1207613871,
-0.4261755943,
-0.4956864715,
0.1947384626,
-0.9947033525,
1.0084964037,
0.0380367115,
-0.6594896913,
0.1777942181,
-0.9368534684,
-0.2367090434,
0.0278199781,
0.0439646244,
0.040070422,
0.3682330251,
0.2908076942,
0.4938362539,
-0.3839082122,
0.4046837389,
-0.5589316487,
-0.0786421895,
0.3824306428,
-0.2931312919,
1.1440227032,
0.2767265737,
-0.1556407362,
0.5045421124,
-1.0880383253,
0.1923445314,
-0.0881280527,
0.0621203221,
-0.5472211838,
0.2054485679,
0.4079526365,
0.0848486722,
-0.0078609642,
-0.5998613834,
0.3019116521,
-0.9246767163,
0.9534894228,
0.6178897619,
-0.1291747391,
0.5982902646,
0.6018266678,
0.6205945015,
-0.3481779993,
0.1947313249,
0.1146207675,
-0.6365712285,
-0.2599118054,
0.4154058993,
0.5523400307,
0.2562193573,
-0.4795953035,
0.3616858423,
0.0975391194,
-0.4908744097,
-0.2117100954,
-0.0374080688,
-0.0234772954,
0.2981179655,
0.4736808836,
-0.4121480882,
-0.4873322546,
-0.9572687149,
-0.1622355878,
0.377196461,
-0.136811927,
-0.0345651656,
0.7920178771,
-0.3831951916,
0.9361081719,
-0.5727139711,
0.0030727475,
-0.2680576444,
0.4006467462,
0.6738446951,
0.4938535392,
0.6147039533,
-0.5882121921,
-0.2657534182,
0.3296647668,
-0.5927728415,
-0.229023084,
0.0511775315,
-0.0513419621,
-0.1485273391,
0.5905560851,
-0.5841835737,
0.6292557716,
0.6573267579,
-0.4340275228,
0.6052430272,
-0.1615167707,
-0.3656691313,
-0.8760730624,
0.4931391776,
-0.2088429481,
0.0692525804,
-0.457059294,
-0.0885400027,
-0.0676971599,
-0.3245743811,
-0.1975253075,
0.653732419,
-0.3208754063,
-0.1959660947,
-0.4696305096,
-0.0282969605,
0.0816818923,
0.1951964945,
0.1533150971,
0.5269671679,
0.8262512684,
-0.3989577889,
0.4705732167,
0.2727025151,
-0.4930599332,
0.0005769426,
-1.0047981739,
0.4092538655,
0.1577706486,
-0.2631926835,
-0.7140054107,
-0.2416405827,
0.2597286105,
-0.6694312096,
0.1430441141,
-0.3049094975,
-0.5634508133,
-0.0904180482,
-0.0296591334,
0.3920114338,
0.0259810183,
-0.6851349473,
0.5656147599,
0.5639927983,
-0.1139900312,
-0.7682160139,
-0.7886241674,
0.3677015901,
0.1810975224,
-0.5428705215,
0.4267514646,
-0.0149172051,
-0.3086919188,
0.357994169,
-0.2140861452,
-0.536177516,
0.1221472919,
0.2293973565,
0.0235948395,
-0.2917826474,
0.2653906047,
0.0301542338,
-0.4161323905,
0.426520735,
-0.4155587554,
0.6961107254,
-0.0845432803,
0.0928347185,
-0.4064892828,
0.4068643153,
0.3605004549,
-0.2578058541,
0.3299299777,
0.5284796953,
-0.4811801016,
-0.6435670853,
-0.0786729082,
-0.3465204537,
-0.474594146,
0.2514969409,
-0.0256324485,
-0.5870466232,
0.3309444785,
-0.0301106013,
-0.313282609,
0.3545078337,
0.2936046422,
0.2556204498,
1.0966867208,
0.7478846908,
-0.22013776,
0.1856566221,
-0.2560171485,
0.2402389646,
-0.7296437025,
-0.0959743336,
-0.5809536576,
-0.533395648,
-0.1137288362,
0.0011719975,
-0.1982746273,
-0.0101153981,
-0.1205581501,
0.4721668363,
-0.9782853127,
0.6473406553,
0.6287807226,
-0.2107053101,
0.090925701,
0.2592279613,
-0.1288891286,
-0.0807319805,
-0.6583698988,
-0.3954743743,
1.0715340376,
0.3428177834,
0.993032217,
-0.2047363967,
0.3848872483,
0.2479044795,
0.0094114505,
-1.1517314911,
0.6046563983,
0.0898997933,
-0.5859610438,
0.0758106783,
-0.3111848831,
-1.0651344061,
-0.0339387394,
-0.1830071956,
-0.9783367515,
0.6205633283,
-0.1030298993,
-0.5400422812,
0.3526293635,
-0.6670588851,
1.289475441,
-0.1192953289,
-0.2051740438,
-0.4549431205,
-0.4672754407,
0.2053208798,
0.4387327731,
-0.277430445,
0.0907319933,
0.0993532166,
0.7783457041,
-0.1789009273,
0.890380621,
-0.1027220115,
0.1003982872,
0.3023370206,
0.1616867334,
-0.068091467,
0.3311505914,
-0.232450977,
0.6525645852,
0.1513253748,
0.0117421011,
-0.734621048,
0.8782454729,
-0.6951395869,
-0.0063931006,
-0.658397615,
-0.7438437343,
0.2061582953,
0.4016063511,
-0.1057244241,
0.4858562946,
-0.0565547347,
0.2931630611,
0.5161226392,
-0.3532482982,
0.7404317856,
0.2710894346,
-0.466378808,
-0.4963839352,
0.6619340777,
0.1146951392,
-0.2184321433,
0.248992607,
0.1935838461,
-0.1971925944,
-1.0343403816,
0.0622119121,
-0.1293476671,
-0.7504255772,
-0.027011361,
-0.5393027663,
-0.1920461059,
-0.2717790306,
0.2530700564,
-0.2153957337,
-0.5246350169,
-0.1672512144,
-0.0912329257,
0.2816798389,
0.8339272141,
-0.3889950812,
0.5379295349,
-0.5817844272,
0.4335620105,
0.3533683419,
0.5905438662,
-0.0103549818,
0.2578843236,
-0.1251534969,
-0.2575733364,
-0.3898721635,
-1.1139812469,
0.7430954576,
0.0328188725,
0.6301652193,
0.2080469131,
-0.2490041256,
0.3219851851,
-0.303314805,
0.650169611,
0.2344513088,
-0.9864445329,
0.7239248753,
0.0536809154,
0.1972247064,
0.374948889,
0.3191752732,
-0.4988984168,
0.4799706638,
-0.553345263,
-1.0621131659,
0.8321672678,
0.2784965038,
-0.086660713,
0.0945811719,
0.5494206548,
0.0949445516,
0.1094027534,
-0.7473247051,
-0.1543961614,
-0.215569824,
-0.0397616029,
-0.0698692128,
-0.0534806922,
-0.2873131931,
-0.4903332889,
0.3683686554,
-0.4784040153,
0.2719961703,
0.2639200687,
-0.2839104235,
0.1189765632,
0.1535778642,
0.0693394244,
0.6209654808,
-0.5286899805,
0.1245787069,
0.0978717133,
-0.6475616097,
-0.1937529445,
0.2097366005,
-0.0432752259,
0.0939024687,
0.2797994912,
0.470458895,
0.0059603485,
-0.7016173601,
0.4003548026,
-0.3270922005,
-0.162027061,
-0.400156796,
0.0482145809,
0.2483815104,
0.4540415108,
0.0958853513,
0.4420334399,
0.7106541395,
-0.3136537075,
0.2421604693,
0.2961712778,
-0.6407130957,
-0.4330209196,
0.5375356674,
-0.0483693928,
-0.5077892542,
1.0263249874,
-0.1592986435,
-0.163769111,
0.8441565037,
0.4452538788,
1.3887968063,
0.014666819,
0.2855679691,
0.4514178634,
0.4004034996,
0.1750768721,
0.402605176,
-0.1151813418,
-0.6617731452,
-0.9366368651,
-0.6395521164,
-0.3309628665,
0.3578622639,
-0.6616811752,
0.1406977326,
-0.4873976409,
-0.3311216235,
0.3103711009,
-0.245247215,
-0.3386473656,
0.0935500041,
0.317963779,
1.2635682821,
-0.5488185883,
1.1078854799,
0.697765708,
-0.3815222383,
-0.443164289,
-0.2551035881,
0.0258973092,
-0.3237827718,
1.0148849487,
0.3936637044,
-0.1196864322,
-0.0425257012,
-1.0371325016,
-0.6388962269,
0.7902105451,
0.5115641356,
-0.402761817,
-0.0245959889,
0.0268367212,
0.5867945552,
-0.1632702053,
0.5535899997,
0.6000732183,
0.3841280937,
-0.4023614824,
-0.5607610941,
0.0603417754,
-0.7073014975,
-0.2489090562,
0.1624483168,
0.2658254206,
1.1088302135,
0.1124804914,
-0.0344431028,
-0.0557699539,
0.416542232,
-0.28429842,
0.3292926848,
0.3201657534,
0.692756772,
0.5176385641,
0.0265250392,
1.00626719,
-0.1375441849,
0.4178681672,
1.2798489332,
0.0328825042,
0.6949355006,
0.6315052509,
-0.0135788312,
0.6078037024,
0.4500202239,
-0.136992231,
0.2588292956,
0.2528656125,
0.1050069928,
-0.3070448339,
0.2282759398,
-0.363592118,
0.2557088137,
0.5708112717,
-0.1885495037,
-0.5174700022,
-0.2237402201,
-0.2692672312,
0.0134779019,
-0.3267753124,
0.5407012105,
0.3414420485,
-0.3052814603,
0.397395134,
-0.3595687449,
0.5260217786,
-0.7603606582,
-0.5249745846,
0.0783598721,
0.4512539506,
-0.5692309141,
-1.1494274139,
0.6621564031,
-0.4106378257,
-0.2536771894,
-0.0365518443,
0.9133888483,
0.2421301752,
-0.0080056414,
0.9480250478,
0.11897894,
0.0483505428,
-0.5183262229,
-0.9135015607,
-0.1662362069,
-0.2967840433,
-0.4888724983,
0.3327989578,
0.0062029609,
0.1568998694,
0.7158548236,
0.8342708349,
0.0601772368,
0.060113918,
0.2009446323,
0.8126351237,
-0.9486594796,
-0.0622156523,
-0.8932244778,
0.7502318025,
-0.6070145965,
-0.7246262431,
0.675774157,
0.5213515162,
0.5993024111,
-0.2048551291,
0.6858308911,
-0.4921748042,
-0.003801995,
-0.3533081412,
0.9664691091,
-0.6519472599,
0.0406396054,
-0.1313973516,
-0.9219281673,
-0.7505038977,
0.6619417667,
-0.295614779,
-0.5751097798,
0.8078368902,
0.9993078113,
-0.2830413878,
0.2905057669,
0.1433824599,
0.231078133,
0.2118557543,
0.4081936777,
1.1224733591,
-0.3957273066,
0.423212707,
-0.3868791461,
-0.0514578335,
0.0249437932,
-0.9848781228,
-1.110891223,
-0.3042637408,
-0.3428758085,
-0.4078020453,
-0.1532732099,
0.6716385484,
0.7654983401,
-0.9441506267,
-0.4367063344,
-0.5721027255,
0.3206225932,
-0.5819287896,
-0.2484537214,
0.4585241973,
-0.7129222751,
-0.7241850495,
0.7767165303,
0.2465010881,
-0.5447745919,
-0.2530760169,
-0.0006858269,
-0.4226222336,
-0.2636083663,
0.5263857245,
0.3215745389,
-0.3196837902,
0.0815702006,
0.1313879788,
0.1616272479,
0.0300308149,
0.8457375169,
-0.7703099847,
0.6896327734,
1.0186306238,
0.6368641257,
0.407387346,
-0.810023725,
0.7672525644,
-0.464106828,
0.2047001123,
0.5635153055,
0.3971115649,
0.1232111827,
-0.1115803346,
0.6206121445,
0.13851358,
-0.7516475916,
-0.7878915668,
-0.0363370627,
-1.225866437,
-0.6110137701,
1.0202567577,
0.1675589234,
-0.5220566988,
-0.3201037347,
-0.5390542746,
0.0564675406,
-0.222178027,
0.2474339157,
0.5367447734,
-0.0048841974,
-0.1802323759,
-1.1050174236,
0.4646323621,
0.2419338971,
-0.6355862617,
0.0622451864,
0.2356555313,
0.3071812987,
0.4024323821,
0.185103029,
-0.1750804931,
0.2662921548,
0.2001172751,
0.6729674339,
0.0671280324,
-0.1862950921,
-0.7743311524,
0.3884380162,
-0.2184708267,
-0.0535562485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18354v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18354v2 | LLMs and the Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus: Successes, Failures, and the Importance of Object-based Representations | 2023-05-26T16:32:17 | 2024-02-14T21:15:31 | Yudong Xu, Wenhao Li, Pashootan Vaezipoor, Scott Sanner, Elias B. Khalil | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Can a Large Language Model (LLM) solve simple abstract reasoning problems? We
explore this broad question through a systematic analysis of GPT on the
Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC), a representative benchmark of abstract
reasoning ability from limited examples in which solutions require some "core
knowledge" of concepts such as objects, goal states, counting, and basic
geometry. GPT-4 solves only 13/50 of the most straightforward ARC tasks when
using textual encodings for their two-dimensional input-output grids. Our
failure analysis reveals that GPT-4's capacity to identify objects and reason
about them is significantly influenced by the sequential nature of the text
that represents an object within a text encoding of a task. To test this
hypothesis, we design a new benchmark, the 1D-ARC, which consists of
one-dimensional (array-like) tasks that are more conducive to GPT-based
reasoning, and where it indeed performs better than on the (2D) ARC. To
alleviate this issue, we propose an object-based representation that is
obtained through an external tool, resulting in nearly doubling the performance
on solved ARC tasks and near-perfect scores on the easier 1D-ARC. Although the
state-of-the-art GPT-4 is unable to "reason" perfectly within non-language
domains such as the 1D-ARC or a simple ARC subset, our study reveals that the
use of object-based representations can significantly improve its reasoning
ability. Visualizations, GPT logs, and data are available at
https://khalil-research.github.io/LLM4ARC. | [
-0.4445866942,
-0.6727077961,
1.1491600275,
-0.0159381907,
-0.1361646056,
0.2273935527,
-0.0658327714,
-0.6786527038,
-0.2540154755,
0.2159456611,
-0.2820031941,
-0.7313190699,
-0.7066954374,
0.460550338,
-0.6409977078,
0.5996256471,
-0.298179239,
-0.1561299264,
-0.5954332352,
0.0758667216,
-0.2944680452,
-0.7613034844,
-0.5665461421,
-0.5455691218,
0.5073375106,
0.3476116955,
0.5186178684,
0.8598788977,
0.7328040004,
0.265922457,
-0.0116139753,
0.0265531745,
-0.3015622795,
-0.1222856343,
-0.2883605659,
-0.4980622232,
-0.3894261122,
-0.1647249162,
0.5146843195,
0.8604009151,
0.0618589707,
-0.135014385,
-0.1725444049,
0.6593141556,
-0.4561350644,
0.5032776594,
-0.5334863663,
0.0203380827,
-0.3560215533,
0.0482166335,
-0.4583156109,
-0.0764899999,
-0.04664829,
-0.6788901687,
-0.0258788113,
0.1618544906,
0.7721804976,
0.3975239992,
-0.2040539831,
-0.3175451159,
-0.6708920598,
0.9176530838,
-0.4889008403,
0.2310396433,
0.3638797402,
0.1995142549,
-0.0655418634,
-0.6797564626,
-0.3967266381,
-0.1688170284,
-0.1511321217,
0.0080503216,
-0.269549787,
0.1034490168,
0.4221317768,
0.2551766634,
-0.4864096045,
0.0437737294,
-0.4051380455,
-0.2960804403,
0.504822433,
0.1623969376,
0.366486907,
-0.0715875849,
-0.3301425874,
0.028480133,
-1.0744627714,
-0.1399485618,
0.2183267623,
-0.1071026251,
0.1827734262,
0.6657876372,
-0.1650728136,
0.5401409268,
-0.1612411886,
0.0824398771,
0.1070781499,
-0.2861931622,
0.1362069845,
0.0761002675,
0.5338652134,
0.0559407808,
0.3312736154,
-0.1780078709,
-0.3761428893,
0.3917898536,
0.1554290354,
-0.7311686873,
-0.3636008799,
0.3353385031,
-0.2211869061,
0.3013603091,
-0.0491715856,
-0.1406352222,
-0.1657036841,
-0.6401588321,
0.1325458884,
-0.6850165129,
-0.3096755445,
0.312800765,
0.0925324038,
0.3117823005,
0.49021101,
-0.9482739568,
0.6083731055,
0.8835843205,
0.8230486512,
-0.6005180478,
-0.3397507668,
-0.1719720662,
0.2007767409,
-0.5651979446,
1.3326280117,
-0.6378965378,
-0.344727844,
-0.2745494545,
-0.38096717,
0.0945368484,
-0.6771866679,
0.4759143293,
-0.2367787659,
-0.2621093392,
-0.5128324032,
-0.7362574935,
-0.2818764448,
0.4796664417,
-0.720082581,
0.9111890197,
0.0191714894,
-0.7215493321,
-0.0063153775,
-0.5742703676,
-0.2519279122,
-0.1104072705,
-0.5628983378,
-0.2186328918,
0.0820877254,
0.2369204015,
0.4218060374,
-0.3194512129,
-0.1495164633,
-0.1357151866,
-0.6424231529,
0.0073150084,
-0.1389170289,
0.3353411257,
0.0284303818,
-0.1682513803,
0.0225044675,
-0.4304676056,
-0.0164990742,
0.319699347,
-0.3303316534,
-0.0756872371,
0.2221555114,
-0.3830232322,
0.0483918935,
0.4350636899,
-0.4919701517,
0.2048844844,
-0.3085699975,
0.3125807345,
0.6359106898,
-0.1369754076,
0.3971759677,
-0.1854122132,
0.3665860593,
0.1993989348,
-0.3372488618,
-0.3347943127,
-0.6440327764,
-0.6248327494,
-0.0995234698,
0.0182170458,
0.3776988685,
-0.5640277267,
-0.0385612547,
-0.1417425573,
-0.3485699594,
-0.1356529295,
0.0203632936,
0.4030418396,
0.43185094,
0.4669148028,
-0.2208311707,
-0.5214596391,
-0.8897216916,
-0.2059969604,
-0.407209605,
0.0653095171,
0.1047024652,
0.5952564478,
-0.2144247741,
1.1370617151,
-0.4042854309,
-0.0819193274,
-0.288064152,
0.2067818046,
0.2115544826,
0.2036833018,
0.397375077,
-0.5567862391,
-0.2048885524,
0.3218814433,
-1.0893911123,
-0.1312393844,
0.1600758284,
0.0291868839,
0.1875825077,
0.5349572301,
-0.7729827762,
0.4716908634,
0.2555466592,
-0.2944940925,
0.9211747646,
-0.3049391806,
-0.0351253822,
-0.3478589058,
0.0956835672,
-0.0951074362,
-0.163729012,
-0.4301965535,
-0.0043594255,
-0.0040263562,
-0.0872185528,
-0.595759809,
0.5786203742,
-0.6169704199,
-0.4330415428,
-0.4482066333,
0.2719374001,
-0.1020758972,
0.70346874,
0.3108384311,
0.7008789778,
0.7102093101,
-0.6367957592,
0.3262946308,
0.0991031229,
-0.3339785933,
0.4601711631,
-0.8705891371,
0.4270585775,
-0.3240716755,
0.2512849569,
-0.712356329,
-0.1025228202,
0.2681261897,
-0.1176248565,
0.0277913623,
0.0361780114,
-0.5614057779,
-0.2124770731,
-0.1017978862,
0.7148999572,
0.3453209698,
-0.3131712675,
0.6670006514,
0.1945229024,
-0.2362160832,
-0.6440112591,
-0.6912528276,
0.1121101901,
0.0724236146,
-0.5220031738,
0.3934891522,
0.0076369373,
-0.3412600458,
0.2827813327,
-0.4169976413,
0.1780589372,
-0.0255888514,
0.127218172,
0.1403118372,
-0.2453943491,
0.0661154464,
0.0711535364,
-0.5400643349,
0.252076149,
-0.2203747034,
0.4558734,
-0.5867785811,
-1.0283435583,
-0.3723232746,
0.3921760619,
0.4535336494,
-0.0908352509,
0.2361756265,
0.1535401046,
-0.4717364013,
-0.0972264856,
-0.310723722,
-0.2868053317,
-0.3781238198,
0.5466184616,
-0.7701727748,
-0.6551125646,
0.5347343683,
-0.2409261465,
0.0627248213,
0.4367524087,
0.6092166305,
-0.0080457395,
0.9482152462,
0.1449283957,
-0.050556533,
0.1800648123,
-0.5076363683,
0.1332465857,
-0.8407304287,
-0.2240496278,
-0.4241439104,
-0.3183494508,
-0.1172260046,
-0.5806489587,
0.1645868421,
0.2550699413,
-0.6065517068,
0.2887286544,
-0.6429437995,
0.6808792353,
0.2723395824,
0.0223969556,
0.7955861688,
-0.1569629312,
-0.1406433135,
0.1001705453,
-0.5175965428,
-0.877168417,
1.1330333948,
0.4386442304,
0.7613232136,
0.0351278111,
0.7291149497,
0.1023129597,
0.4371475279,
-0.6811634302,
0.8188510537,
-0.0856886059,
-0.4405145347,
-0.1862338185,
-0.306268096,
-0.8987800479,
0.4604037702,
0.2242506444,
-0.7900866866,
0.0024038828,
0.1041059271,
0.0655395314,
0.3210277855,
-0.7871536016,
0.8503291607,
-0.3604106605,
-0.2088171691,
-0.2382335812,
-0.2241828442,
0.3222805858,
0.0313712247,
0.2200378031,
-0.5242438316,
-0.2906297147,
0.514251709,
-0.3500162661,
0.7707290649,
-0.0112178335,
-0.132675916,
0.5345497727,
0.1476643234,
0.7723551393,
0.0830815658,
-0.1475728154,
0.4397703707,
-0.1416136622,
-0.5141254067,
-0.7461758852,
0.6464149356,
-0.8305184245,
-0.914195478,
-0.5150868893,
-0.4381694496,
-0.0884016901,
0.2142594606,
0.1457255185,
0.3245075941,
-0.1099832505,
0.0024156941,
0.5758048892,
0.1393855512,
0.3356721103,
0.0813423246,
-0.5244581699,
0.2697611451,
0.8546785712,
-0.0488827825,
0.275475949,
0.3681891859,
0.0862653181,
-0.4593790174,
-0.9705174565,
-0.5259919167,
0.2691272795,
-1.154853344,
-0.078686133,
-0.4908897281,
-0.2264636159,
0.2774413228,
0.0627142191,
-0.4371962249,
-0.3854456246,
-0.2740001976,
-0.2069673091,
0.3227317631,
1.007712841,
0.0721176714,
-0.1102443263,
-0.2906811237,
0.3843572736,
0.2488648891,
0.3619591892,
-0.04235816,
-0.1807079911,
-0.0775854886,
-0.0776150301,
-0.2798390687,
-0.6217911839,
-0.1280599833,
-0.0797306523,
0.5904426575,
0.2439264953,
-0.2255227417,
0.3980642557,
-0.6921600103,
0.7028942704,
0.1221115515,
-0.9314651489,
0.3951060772,
-0.3862393796,
0.3832917213,
0.2567767799,
0.2463917583,
-0.3367714882,
-0.608920455,
-0.3469210863,
-0.7096461058,
0.6860722303,
0.4150315225,
-0.0844132304,
-0.1095118299,
0.338684082,
0.1456469595,
-0.1037147641,
-0.7100117803,
-0.3705738187,
-0.3518456221,
-0.209328115,
0.296769768,
-0.0217213705,
0.1157023758,
-0.1522698551,
0.3897427917,
-0.1149984226,
0.5699020624,
0.1814034283,
-0.2016715109,
0.3134011924,
0.1083847061,
0.596553266,
0.8938171268,
0.000226038,
0.3568017185,
0.1057697684,
-0.4139151573,
0.2166898549,
0.0374444127,
0.0527756065,
0.0856371969,
0.4671285748,
0.6297299266,
0.3346054554,
-0.7792841792,
0.2212413847,
0.1401325613,
-0.3244164288,
-0.3748510182,
0.0758912712,
0.326726377,
0.0220265966,
0.5842971206,
0.0576746427,
0.1036699265,
-0.4469021261,
0.1138832867,
0.3882330954,
-0.0266367588,
-0.353525579,
0.6691459417,
0.1568403244,
-0.1970660686,
0.4742316902,
-0.2743118703,
-0.3251261711,
0.7542000413,
0.5171203017,
0.5804201365,
0.1117063537,
0.0121577168,
0.3350478709,
0.1482684165,
-0.4434961081,
0.0583014488,
0.03205036,
-0.8442060947,
-0.7518225908,
-0.3726636171,
-0.7810541987,
-0.2117676586,
-0.1598515362,
0.1395624429,
-0.5908993483,
0.1283908188,
-0.1322117895,
-0.1821074635,
-0.6313632727,
-0.0158911627,
0.2438098341,
0.6902645826,
-0.5645014048,
0.7258448005,
0.8575925827,
-0.5506938696,
-0.7878767252,
-0.3547881246,
0.0422718562,
-0.7956863642,
0.80366081,
0.1570274532,
-0.4378256798,
0.0350613669,
-0.3959848285,
-1.094278574,
1.0778765678,
0.7402951717,
-0.6177408695,
-0.0243476015,
0.3382998705,
0.4190386534,
-0.4579382241,
0.3839893043,
0.7849490643,
0.7007251978,
0.0880657062,
-0.793074131,
0.065275535,
-0.1634409279,
-0.0070963255,
0.206648916,
-0.2356540263,
0.9510186911,
-0.2865011096,
-0.5172281861,
0.0620276667,
0.7130426764,
0.5585168004,
0.2907063365,
0.1762409359,
0.7668715715,
0.7243762612,
-0.4606723487,
1.4147783518,
-0.0919490829,
0.33333233,
0.9312384129,
-0.24317123,
0.7583760619,
0.5364644527,
-0.3922413588,
0.8899261355,
0.5175504684,
0.2524220645,
0.2786801755,
0.3785299063,
-0.314101398,
-0.2018004507,
0.3255292773,
-0.3546571434,
0.3315899372,
0.533787787,
0.06730818,
-0.4038825035,
-0.0159950815,
-0.2056075186,
0.2396856546,
-0.4485539198,
0.6552842855,
0.3211630583,
-0.4710764587,
0.6084056497,
-0.098481901,
0.4604534507,
-0.3374983072,
-0.2097543031,
-0.2602659762,
0.1967258006,
-0.3858307004,
-0.8800230026,
0.5259498358,
-0.0978104249,
-0.1402611136,
-0.2610864341,
0.6899646521,
-0.1910098642,
-0.5664853454,
0.1373814344,
0.7753482461,
0.5544658899,
-0.2235589623,
-0.55488801,
0.4768853784,
-0.2935695648,
-0.3337671459,
0.2351129353,
0.6382933855,
-0.1966590881,
0.950733602,
0.3636566699,
0.0800163597,
-0.1401199549,
0.0248340741,
0.8028686643,
-0.7881788611,
-0.1212174967,
-0.9348064661,
0.4815160036,
-0.039255444,
-0.0147452643,
0.4310795665,
0.643745482,
0.8755059242,
-0.1059384644,
0.9057609439,
-0.0404805243,
0.5232205987,
-0.6291083097,
0.3216350377,
-0.278983891,
0.6409597397,
-0.1965245605,
-1.04322505,
-0.4616742134,
0.7514539361,
-0.6126964688,
0.0928344503,
1.2194421291,
0.5465698242,
-0.1021490172,
0.0044720066,
0.3547492623,
0.0898704827,
0.3953716755,
0.8208408952,
1.0220347643,
-0.266816467,
0.8493714929,
0.0230745506,
0.03663202,
-0.0231064055,
-0.896514535,
-0.7507709861,
-0.5387836695,
-0.4510566592,
0.0401308388,
0.0368610434,
0.5287640691,
0.4823200703,
-0.654794991,
-0.1781144887,
-0.5360213518,
0.4401259422,
-0.3568196297,
-0.1430751383,
0.5907108188,
-0.4619266093,
-0.9082057476,
0.22707057,
0.546674788,
-0.0876472667,
-0.272726655,
-0.3457795084,
0.0602503233,
-0.1980272532,
0.7171631455,
0.4290243387,
-1.0678850412,
-0.5274668932,
0.0226402022,
-0.1014390662,
0.2565984428,
1.0125118494,
-0.9873877764,
0.1851262897,
0.1718908995,
0.8338724971,
0.756275177,
0.0675715208,
0.4782018065,
-0.511323154,
0.11878445,
0.4309158027,
0.6729813218,
0.37790519,
-0.0717672482,
0.5859507918,
0.2299476266,
-0.4798035026,
-0.4208822846,
0.4955489635,
-0.993488729,
-0.4597291648,
1.1739481688,
-0.1678528935,
-0.252432704,
-0.5730105042,
-0.4247009754,
-0.2307378799,
-0.4968692362,
0.639420867,
0.9486550093,
-0.6978750229,
-0.4623152316,
-0.3927821815,
0.4278976321,
0.3496671319,
-1.0715121031,
0.0556621961,
0.5046183467,
0.1437536627,
0.3481147587,
0.7674210668,
-0.3136493266,
0.4284857512,
0.0469969437,
0.0310347192,
-0.2656644583,
-0.1373900026,
0.0841919258,
0.2493449897,
0.3063791096,
-0.0479903743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17072v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17072v1 | Stereotypes and Smut: The (Mis)representation of Non-cisgender Identities by Text-to-Image Models | 2023-05-26T16:28:49 | 2023-05-26T16:28:49 | Eddie L. Ungless, Björn Ross, Anne Lauscher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Cutting-edge image generation has been praised for producing high-quality
images, suggesting a ubiquitous future in a variety of applications. However,
initial studies have pointed to the potential for harm due to predictive bias,
reflecting and potentially reinforcing cultural stereotypes. In this work, we
are the first to investigate how multimodal models handle diverse gender
identities. Concretely, we conduct a thorough analysis in which we compare the
output of three image generation models for prompts containing cisgender vs.
non-cisgender identity terms. Our findings demonstrate that certain
non-cisgender identities are consistently (mis)represented as less human, more
stereotyped and more sexualised. We complement our experimental analysis with
(a)~a survey among non-cisgender individuals and (b) a series of interviews, to
establish which harms affected individuals anticipate, and how they would like
to be represented. We find respondents are particularly concerned about
misrepresentation, and the potential to drive harmful behaviours and beliefs.
Simple heuristics to limit offensive content are widely rejected, and instead
respondents call for community involvement, curated training data and the
ability to customise. These improvements could pave the way for a future where
change is led by the affected community, and technology is used to positively
``[portray] queerness in ways that we haven't even thought of'' rather than
reproducing stale, offensive stereotypes. | [
-0.4260455072,
-0.2402692139,
0.2244899124,
0.1380031556,
-0.0780118033,
-0.0512061194,
0.2025727183,
-0.6098431945,
0.3149953783,
0.3066709042,
-0.6557891369,
-0.1928230524,
-0.7833538651,
0.4430141747,
-0.358378619,
0.737067461,
0.4275244474,
0.256398052,
-0.2972705066,
-0.2310298383,
-0.9334483743,
-0.5769471526,
0.1155590788,
0.27166906,
0.6119029522,
0.3198067844,
0.8343337774,
0.3159659207,
0.4478442371,
0.2499518245,
0.0274090003,
0.1980414093,
-0.748955369,
0.3939557374,
-0.357314229,
-0.3892665803,
-0.0126948077,
0.374045223,
0.3659569025,
0.7355629802,
0.4601092041,
0.4079484344,
-0.0941410959,
0.3270866573,
-0.6852403879,
-0.4129155576,
-0.4652945399,
0.1521365047,
-0.3867924511,
0.0105622811,
-0.5149541497,
-0.4113737345,
-0.2409876585,
-0.3515824974,
0.4149643779,
0.1574336886,
0.687830925,
-0.0321569815,
-1.0274740458,
-0.4317712486,
-1.1092722416,
0.8734539747,
-0.2416612357,
0.5019717813,
-0.0955786929,
0.4120114446,
-0.007346489,
-0.392491281,
-0.1839807034,
-0.0961103812,
-0.3507984579,
0.1582383662,
-0.2153798789,
-0.3287407756,
0.4177984297,
0.2095228583,
-0.6179680228,
-0.20544222,
-0.9968262911,
-0.2960303426,
0.9525410533,
0.2456218153,
0.4942290783,
-0.2878684998,
-0.5247561336,
0.108887054,
-0.6385874748,
-0.2676576972,
0.7639398575,
0.3398954272,
0.1191701069,
0.6665412188,
0.5010493994,
0.0418967009,
0.2299235165,
-0.189280197,
0.3562925756,
-0.0434988849,
-0.1394684762,
0.0100880265,
0.7074335217,
0.7823530436,
0.2498212159,
0.0255430136,
-0.1306542158,
0.4538266063,
0.3305900097,
-0.6218622327,
-0.0831705257,
-0.0911094323,
-0.6385046244,
-0.3104194701,
0.0228380822,
-0.9090117812,
-0.8944544196,
0.0718084499,
0.391752094,
-0.5836398602,
-0.5157163739,
-0.0841861367,
-0.7111287713,
-0.0153032793,
0.502399385,
-0.6999076009,
0.1229679212,
0.0970061123,
0.5233547091,
0.1190969497,
0.1838991344,
-0.0542384237,
0.1136622056,
-0.5747545958,
0.5413179994,
-0.6046264172,
-0.7436993122,
-0.2521525919,
0.1517767608,
0.0282194316,
-0.4486819804,
0.2702816427,
0.0053471876,
0.2953954041,
-0.5302239656,
-0.1015360728,
-0.0332748555,
-0.0858764797,
-0.8027940989,
0.7744646072,
-0.0619850457,
-0.8106889129,
0.4082667828,
-0.5741998553,
-0.2012347579,
0.0615492389,
-0.3836114407,
-0.2013032138,
0.3227072954,
0.1062487215,
0.3770781755,
-0.1613777131,
0.1269613653,
-0.4903911352,
-0.2378339916,
0.2340029478,
-0.4326300323,
0.840090096,
0.3567555249,
-0.2049505115,
0.0264342744,
-0.1925608367,
-0.5262825489,
0.2121076286,
0.4459452033,
-0.5255565047,
-0.3959498405,
0.3062866926,
0.5339176059,
-0.0481875278,
-0.7958649993,
-0.1988054961,
0.1625848562,
0.2317730188,
0.9282028675,
-0.2179552168,
0.48444736,
-0.5908849835,
0.6579748392,
0.4349496067,
0.5207535028,
-0.1675378978,
-0.7363843322,
-0.1550849676,
-0.3973100185,
0.1887679249,
0.3852166533,
-0.7692766786,
-0.3872518241,
-0.1249580532,
-0.5238103867,
-0.4449535608,
0.018449802,
0.3315945864,
0.2103090137,
0.0731571242,
-0.4750204086,
-0.6157726049,
-1.3191148043,
-0.5206919909,
-0.3590509295,
0.0159329362,
0.5535241961,
0.597990036,
-0.3194915652,
0.7259837389,
-0.3312185109,
-0.2991124988,
0.0772102103,
0.4309507906,
-0.1677295864,
0.4870733917,
1.036649704,
-1.0941692591,
-0.3387868404,
-0.3989940286,
-0.5879068375,
0.0099204006,
-0.2367715836,
-0.2231908292,
-0.2189664692,
0.2669771016,
-0.3840153813,
0.5017786026,
0.4100045562,
-0.3259558678,
0.7581467628,
0.1247757301,
0.4108323455,
-0.7989678979,
-0.0527577996,
0.3173772395,
-0.2840262353,
-0.6698344946,
-0.1188928708,
0.1415023804,
-0.488058418,
-0.6190019846,
0.569639504,
-0.6160163283,
-0.1197055057,
0.2197117805,
-0.2435566038,
0.1179336682,
-0.0097756721,
0.1045932472,
0.6121951938,
0.5290452242,
-0.5178149939,
0.1642791182,
0.2487010062,
-0.0483555533,
0.9973484874,
-0.3326951265,
0.1927854866,
-0.9277591109,
0.1994014233,
-1.2321532965,
-0.3006802201,
0.3818048239,
-0.6739547253,
0.0748474002,
-0.0914296657,
-0.4104447961,
-0.5374666452,
-0.2812030017,
0.811380744,
0.4187957644,
-0.3888541162,
0.7730771899,
0.394824177,
0.0413456634,
-0.603826344,
-0.7902157903,
0.2142429054,
-0.5992383361,
-0.7299655676,
0.1101130992,
-0.1674687266,
-0.3599944413,
-0.1855311245,
0.0185070802,
-0.1983020604,
-0.1157228947,
0.5263558626,
0.2914457619,
-0.1076421514,
0.4434372485,
0.0798567384,
0.0763914213,
-0.1171266586,
0.2010369897,
0.0938798189,
0.1022495031,
-0.2893454432,
-0.2174672335,
1.1081185341,
0.6166674495,
-0.1624331325,
0.7058172226,
0.7643969655,
-0.3909161985,
0.3016136289,
-0.4481032789,
-0.1094330028,
-0.4249170721,
0.134758845,
-0.2610324919,
-0.7563222647,
0.360486865,
-0.2537536621,
0.3661014736,
0.5569764376,
0.4047932327,
-0.5677432418,
1.1008880138,
0.8702946901,
0.4944892824,
0.357335031,
0.2329350114,
0.1113580242,
-0.4519767463,
-0.2544648349,
-0.4170061052,
-0.4839422405,
-0.8506311774,
-0.5137622356,
0.4127151072,
-0.3234773278,
-0.223371774,
0.1155927107,
-0.5007536411,
0.297762543,
0.3563791513,
-0.0145707652,
0.0654264241,
-0.2526477873,
0.0790084377,
-0.5272260308,
-0.4592669308,
-0.6434580088,
1.0284911394,
0.4453120828,
1.1042511463,
0.4621450901,
0.6571184993,
0.6552115679,
0.7655875683,
-0.365617007,
0.3312064111,
-0.3431715071,
-1.4519834518,
0.2039014846,
-0.3964867294,
-0.7437560558,
0.2727237642,
-0.3717024624,
-0.6789684892,
0.908872962,
0.3897445202,
-0.2994195521,
0.4107448161,
-0.7758905888,
0.5038366318,
-0.2629583776,
-0.3111335933,
0.2206920534,
-0.8395575881,
0.9838501215,
-0.0050180545,
0.6835374832,
-0.1000441685,
0.1248072907,
0.6193601489,
0.0570838377,
1.1502871513,
-0.3084827065,
-0.0270871762,
-0.0597507544,
0.2551479936,
-0.1547702253,
-0.055459898,
-0.2070040405,
0.2582110167,
0.3564921916,
-0.4500392675,
-0.364444375,
0.3683780134,
-0.9228165746,
-0.4594839215,
-0.3476520777,
-0.6096157432,
-0.0082427813,
-0.0545313358,
0.3058263063,
0.4602706432,
-0.4022583365,
-0.0924160928,
0.7670600414,
-0.7455224991,
0.0957930237,
-0.1972706467,
-0.4763500094,
-0.4837659895,
0.6249881387,
0.1055620834,
0.4702732563,
-0.0850147679,
0.0779277831,
-0.3019270003,
0.3342288136,
-0.5360547304,
0.3213953972,
-0.8459516168,
-0.1008336097,
-0.6261085868,
0.0057401783,
-0.8620559573,
-0.0454018191,
-0.4431214035,
-0.3489536643,
-0.2558283508,
0.0341857672,
0.0588631853,
0.9485949874,
-0.4041966796,
0.448970288,
-0.6202181578,
0.5570189953,
0.4062257707,
0.0751344711,
-0.3798317015,
-0.1820227206,
0.2381094843,
0.0494294465,
-0.3161469102,
-1.3406294584,
0.2260872871,
0.1044934019,
0.3896450102,
0.5138088465,
0.2764519155,
0.6752932668,
-0.2947565615,
0.7504591942,
0.5072225332,
-0.6577593088,
0.3451371193,
-0.1662545204,
0.1514292657,
0.3315507174,
0.5113181472,
-1.0124194622,
-0.3429143131,
-0.5992796421,
-0.4915419817,
0.3570822179,
0.312289238,
0.7740138173,
-0.1429280341,
0.1485846639,
0.7119836807,
0.3544645309,
-1.0697616339,
-0.6547781825,
-0.7538635731,
-0.1095944569,
-0.0344143026,
-0.4590196013,
-0.0836773887,
-0.2295996696,
0.4530857503,
0.0434313342,
0.8414857984,
-0.0068831607,
-0.3561128378,
-0.1387778372,
0.2347520292,
0.5088997483,
0.2078309357,
-0.0790729374,
0.3072095215,
-0.2032655329,
-0.3879571259,
0.4172969759,
-0.426319927,
-0.0982833356,
0.5429973006,
0.1212488189,
0.759097755,
-0.2330440134,
-0.3695127666,
0.6780138612,
-0.3896214962,
-0.4567121863,
-0.1964664757,
-0.2179047316,
-0.0289405212,
0.1342385262,
0.3224925399,
0.4716469944,
0.1524217725,
-0.8351992965,
0.0055393456,
0.486646235,
-0.6536239982,
-0.2136159688,
0.6992799044,
0.2806800604,
-0.215375483,
0.3371957541,
-0.160367921,
-0.3236662745,
0.5400885344,
0.5697473288,
0.5892628431,
-0.548820138,
0.6216598749,
0.5124672651,
0.7973454595,
0.3636550605,
0.2232718319,
0.3787412345,
-0.8352520466,
0.1812876016,
-0.2868328691,
-0.0570641533,
-0.0763660818,
-0.5549628139,
0.2604097128,
-0.6110895276,
-0.5462879539,
0.0014198287,
-0.5815392733,
-0.7571647763,
0.4293823242,
0.68028754,
0.6954056025,
-1.557559967,
0.2962899804,
0.6743876338,
-0.3186035752,
-0.3280529082,
0.0197352767,
0.412374109,
-0.2601517141,
0.6828245521,
0.4622490406,
-0.0725009218,
-0.349683404,
-0.5964243412,
-0.8165716529,
0.746195972,
0.5855270624,
-0.5362016559,
-0.0134138362,
0.4479382038,
0.3515170813,
-0.4314719737,
0.4728159606,
0.0751442164,
0.4499142468,
0.3750034571,
-0.6805725098,
-0.0181185864,
-0.3738076985,
0.3652767837,
0.1312725544,
-0.4398425221,
1.1975449324,
-0.2445140183,
-0.6437700987,
0.0419007428,
0.5499928594,
0.0266432241,
0.1697593778,
0.7322241068,
-0.0386671126,
0.7815265059,
-0.0101017347,
0.9260279536,
0.3722901642,
0.0819546431,
0.8431698084,
-0.0157329384,
0.1072670296,
0.6229403019,
0.0248031728,
0.3527295887,
0.6894600391,
0.0319517665,
0.4872067571,
0.1063994169,
-0.1148682013,
-0.398498565,
-0.393317312,
-0.3534073532,
0.3832125664,
0.3563257754,
-0.6226677299,
-0.3318950236,
0.4537101686,
-0.3352857828,
0.0960612297,
-0.1439263821,
0.5365021229,
0.1335578263,
0.212218523,
0.159116134,
0.1156109497,
0.9519894123,
-0.2794320285,
0.0592888668,
-0.1916262954,
-0.1457003951,
-0.27257967,
-0.4571081996,
0.3955048621,
-0.2706723809,
-0.2890266478,
-0.377304256,
1.0436154604,
-0.2649627924,
-1.0158835649,
0.187480554,
0.656447649,
0.3125856519,
0.2542838156,
-0.659643054,
-0.16995202,
0.018028954,
0.5107799768,
0.2086218297,
0.3306649029,
-0.4324862659,
0.5048396587,
0.3235501647,
-0.1397221684,
0.3844661415,
-0.0516488366,
0.5021318197,
-0.6171863675,
-0.395396173,
-0.6791479588,
0.7599505186,
-0.0818276852,
-0.300899148,
0.5475977063,
0.3451245129,
0.6123501062,
-0.1959336847,
0.7641948462,
-0.1124992743,
0.3196323812,
0.1036048606,
0.6849108338,
-0.7379216552,
-0.0296627823,
-0.6857128739,
-0.6279935837,
-0.2906797528,
0.3542261124,
-0.3617163002,
0.1583334357,
0.4531981945,
0.9111885428,
-0.2536340356,
0.2712495625,
0.5538046956,
0.0116573349,
0.2327257842,
0.2594563663,
1.261544466,
-0.5049881339,
0.2909085155,
-0.2688689232,
-0.162373662,
-0.0883657485,
-0.6120383739,
-0.9176989198,
-0.7108843327,
-0.3988391757,
-0.0600080565,
0.0764377415,
0.7340195179,
0.706848681,
-0.3697712123,
-0.2127185911,
0.6851647496,
0.0704746321,
-0.1081073582,
-0.1736760885,
-0.2494251132,
0.0725734979,
-0.6353157163,
-0.3607951105,
0.2239853293,
0.1249613538,
-0.5416142941,
0.0163650829,
-0.0832619295,
0.2236831486,
0.6945725083,
-0.25867486,
-0.6178091764,
-0.3003493845,
-0.077247113,
-0.3124185503,
0.213627398,
0.8068602085,
-0.5521091819,
0.3209631443,
0.2328054905,
0.1732677072,
0.1674238443,
-0.1004481539,
0.7648190856,
-0.8819294572,
0.0253450871,
0.2859396338,
0.3005278409,
0.509822011,
-0.8005126715,
0.1249068305,
0.4571369588,
0.0402024873,
-0.8265006542,
0.477047652,
-0.3804240227,
-0.488060683,
0.9993390441,
-0.0341965966,
-0.3373402655,
-0.2211922556,
-0.425165087,
0.0891032815,
-0.2585159838,
0.6967027187,
0.545499444,
-0.0617411956,
-0.4945152998,
-0.6335630417,
0.3045862615,
0.2996421754,
-0.5878582001,
0.0032580774,
0.8422290683,
0.5795878768,
0.2526190579,
0.4032495916,
-0.4706590176,
0.4129940867,
0.0316026621,
0.1708194911,
0.2069656998,
-0.3351200521,
-0.0295683127,
0.1245053858,
-0.2585119307,
-0.1842473894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17066v1 | Mindstorms in Natural Language-Based Societies of Mind | 2023-05-26T16:21:25 | 2023-05-26T16:21:25 | Mingchen Zhuge, Haozhe Liu, Francesco Faccio, Dylan R. Ashley, Róbert Csordás, Anand Gopalakrishnan, Abdullah Hamdi, Hasan Abed Al Kader Hammoud, Vincent Herrmann, Kazuki Irie, Louis Kirsch, Bing Li, Guohao Li, Shuming Liu, Jinjie Mai, Piotr Piękos, Aditya Ramesh, Imanol Schlag, Weimin Shi, Aleksandar Stanić, Wenyi Wang, Yuhui Wang, Mengmeng Xu, Deng-Ping Fan, Bernard Ghanem, Jürgen Schmidhuber | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MA, 68T07, I.2.6; I.2.11 | Both Minsky's "society of mind" and Schmidhuber's "learning to think" inspire
diverse societies of large multimodal neural networks (NNs) that solve problems
by interviewing each other in a "mindstorm." Recent implementations of NN-based
societies of minds consist of large language models (LLMs) and other NN-based
experts communicating through a natural language interface. In doing so, they
overcome the limitations of single LLMs, improving multimodal zero-shot
reasoning. In these natural language-based societies of mind (NLSOMs), new
agents -- all communicating through the same universal symbolic language -- are
easily added in a modular fashion. To demonstrate the power of NLSOMs, we
assemble and experiment with several of them (having up to 129 members),
leveraging mindstorms in them to solve some practical AI tasks: visual question
answering, image captioning, text-to-image synthesis, 3D generation, egocentric
retrieval, embodied AI, and general language-based task solving. We view this
as a starting point towards much larger NLSOMs with billions of agents-some of
which may be humans. And with this emergence of great societies of
heterogeneous minds, many new research questions have suddenly become paramount
to the future of artificial intelligence. What should be the social structure
of an NLSOM? What would be the (dis)advantages of having a monarchical rather
than a democratic structure? How can principles of NN economies be used to
maximize the total reward of a reinforcement learning NLSOM? In this work, we
identify, discuss, and try to answer some of these questions. | [
-0.648009479,
-0.6238532066,
0.6544629931,
0.2337296754,
-0.0900434554,
0.4922776818,
-0.3003787398,
-0.4678149819,
0.5701417327,
0.316077143,
-0.704134047,
-0.0991576761,
-0.4352932274,
0.2788458169,
-0.1793889105,
0.9998824,
0.2963344753,
-0.136282593,
-0.3918386102,
-0.0363701992,
0.0237217676,
-0.5559951067,
-0.7329999208,
-0.4488942623,
0.5410271287,
0.0802797079,
0.6197996736,
0.237987414,
0.354431361,
0.4446437359,
-0.1356901377,
0.3032628596,
-0.3558834195,
0.242414847,
-0.2255020738,
-0.5845672488,
0.0022692855,
0.1134980321,
0.4213189483,
0.6205326319,
-0.084273465,
0.0657814145,
-0.0314117111,
0.7219849229,
-0.2445463389,
0.4207576215,
-0.5624385476,
0.4261802137,
0.1730468571,
-0.1680450141,
-0.2151045799,
-0.4500386715,
0.3190403581,
-0.4625952542,
-0.1057059318,
0.2810769975,
0.3497726321,
0.3766563237,
-0.2789885402,
-0.2073698789,
-0.514102757,
0.9511114359,
-0.3962858915,
0.1185533702,
0.1760982424,
0.2874444127,
-0.3889107406,
-0.4973091781,
-0.8099334836,
-0.2999079227,
0.2503523827,
0.2845479846,
-0.3232335448,
0.0348175839,
0.1689340025,
-0.0105584776,
-0.4540036619,
-0.1430603266,
-0.4650071561,
-0.1795654744,
0.7657005787,
0.2097263932,
0.3238646686,
-0.1566532105,
-0.237332508,
0.0212871749,
-0.2000278831,
-0.2036223859,
0.1013994291,
0.3087295294,
-0.0748477206,
0.4872856736,
-0.2778843641,
0.6356496215,
0.1525610089,
-0.083328411,
-0.0379312448,
-0.4122785628,
-0.2777444124,
0.0482289456,
0.5854210258,
0.3210564852,
0.5553289056,
-0.5767216682,
-0.3278315365,
0.3508746326,
0.4040163755,
-0.550419271,
-0.1521831155,
0.1771695018,
-0.3687774539,
-0.4015493393,
-0.301424861,
-0.3857357502,
-0.5160195827,
-0.5960806012,
0.4690407515,
-0.2399365008,
-0.355959028,
0.0007541646,
-0.5325850844,
0.2934674919,
0.4197157621,
-0.6952044964,
0.5270208716,
0.5994289517,
0.7411965728,
-0.1346757412,
-0.3278861642,
0.1682106704,
-0.0813854039,
-0.4407400489,
0.8457856178,
-0.1488900036,
-0.1950981021,
-0.1875588298,
-0.4222870171,
0.0498359837,
-0.3784153759,
-0.2764016092,
-0.4446925521,
0.2439104915,
-0.3810267448,
-0.5092735887,
0.0450606272,
0.7178744078,
-0.6571992636,
0.4150440395,
-0.2551300526,
-0.4644465744,
0.0953920931,
-1.0565627813,
-0.5527895689,
0.2525632977,
-0.5088827014,
0.3689588904,
0.1264412254,
-0.0831825212,
0.5681632757,
-0.2893603444,
0.3934113085,
0.0123532768,
-0.1373995095,
0.4758908153,
-0.4135641158,
1.02511549,
0.0667679086,
-0.3781812191,
0.3391007781,
-0.4059827328,
0.2890530825,
0.3359639645,
-0.015615304,
-0.1514477134,
0.0396266915,
-0.1920992434,
0.2921376526,
0.2079994082,
-0.5925460458,
0.154536128,
-0.4281309247,
0.8084791303,
0.9648190141,
0.0586636029,
0.6299655437,
-0.6835183501,
0.3552378714,
-0.0974114314,
0.3048680425,
0.2843679488,
-0.6740526557,
-0.584896028,
-0.1127638593,
-0.1226864979,
0.3671633303,
-1.2152091265,
0.1411786973,
-0.0501602963,
-0.5982044339,
-0.20474796,
-0.2951253653,
0.3017756641,
0.2857877016,
0.1734815836,
-0.3740170002,
-0.6143789887,
-0.8641733527,
-0.0560056306,
-0.2092100978,
0.2098187208,
0.3557581007,
0.8644740582,
-0.1130331829,
1.0580866337,
-0.2010455728,
-0.0736834407,
-0.5321376324,
0.1232187599,
0.0232392978,
0.1992830932,
0.1432807297,
-0.9382959008,
-0.1931783259,
-0.1559219956,
-0.8019906282,
0.4940113723,
0.0031467825,
-0.0871869624,
0.3456160724,
0.384139806,
-0.6859602332,
0.1582883298,
0.5225971341,
-0.055018805,
0.9250875711,
-0.1625585109,
-0.1680740714,
-0.9971182346,
-0.2046628147,
-0.1329980195,
-0.0095875012,
-0.7170494199,
0.2041400373,
-0.3065494299,
-0.1480269432,
-0.5029245019,
0.7676458955,
-0.2894390821,
-0.2691995203,
-0.2628222704,
0.5605044961,
-0.3762621284,
0.8016576171,
-0.0419004597,
0.6309221983,
0.4662323296,
-0.8077744246,
0.5957694054,
0.2757052481,
-0.4651738703,
0.6966519952,
-0.5500685573,
0.2257847786,
-0.4569748938,
0.4983437955,
-0.5482670665,
-0.3276780844,
0.0384832844,
-0.4341120422,
-0.3647938967,
0.4597866535,
-0.368055135,
-0.4324327111,
-0.0997988135,
0.1994254589,
0.3823392689,
-0.3949583173,
0.5849663019,
0.7428981066,
0.0305880588,
-0.657867074,
-0.7060434222,
0.4626668394,
0.0917089954,
-0.4606261849,
0.3309785128,
-0.3076452315,
-0.6265938282,
0.2614203393,
-0.1404537112,
-0.1766107529,
0.2973390818,
0.2856472135,
0.3307058215,
0.0231386162,
0.3113896549,
-0.1683153212,
-0.0405326635,
0.0847736821,
-0.7054250836,
0.6679874659,
-0.5730589032,
-0.0283506941,
-0.1902768016,
0.283449471,
0.4737833142,
-0.3767533302,
0.6415412426,
0.1257766485,
-0.6040167809,
-0.2725372314,
-0.4260178804,
-0.2630113363,
-0.4448748231,
0.5605069399,
-0.017691223,
-1.0163321495,
0.2640079856,
-0.0644367784,
0.37411654,
0.2584271133,
0.6626483798,
-0.2600663602,
0.6826521754,
0.6122865081,
-0.1764427722,
0.3087154627,
-0.2381370068,
0.1210677028,
-0.6986751556,
-0.3465651572,
-0.2392690927,
-0.6420408487,
-0.3449163437,
-0.6015539765,
0.3081685007,
-0.4900034964,
-0.2703690529,
0.4190695584,
-0.4881667793,
0.7617979646,
0.5574216247,
-0.0846604705,
0.1228574142,
-0.1528797746,
-0.1914610863,
0.276188314,
-0.8142980337,
-0.5407444835,
1.1321629286,
-0.1645552069,
0.4671537578,
0.1190372705,
0.9960933924,
0.3255877197,
0.5127820969,
-0.9035093188,
0.9731857777,
0.0001260572,
-0.7735311985,
-0.5863649845,
-0.4546161294,
-0.9229742289,
0.2880651951,
-0.3563061953,
-0.6194146276,
0.0088948123,
-0.0670820698,
-0.4884864092,
0.3670204878,
-0.2426683903,
0.5157564878,
-0.3433166444,
-0.0303152204,
-0.5150468349,
-0.7846261859,
0.2017564625,
0.3218143582,
0.2268126905,
0.0014083203,
0.1145352349,
0.8056147695,
0.2989534736,
0.8647953868,
-0.0399173535,
-0.0348147601,
0.3082602322,
-0.0906071961,
0.1318710297,
-0.1917332113,
-0.0321703702,
-0.0192539115,
-0.2527218461,
-0.2375520021,
-0.7148661017,
0.5352963805,
-0.9044237733,
-0.5559931993,
-0.3232090473,
-0.8176516891,
-0.1274687648,
0.1874730736,
-0.0759864077,
0.6584058404,
-0.5794277191,
0.2992419302,
0.8614221215,
0.0047296607,
0.4803345799,
0.1005532146,
-0.3918343782,
-0.3675885797,
0.9519941807,
0.1388560236,
0.4857155979,
0.3328434527,
-0.0442989431,
-0.2437558323,
-0.3518362641,
-0.2525295317,
-0.0101307742,
-0.6944445372,
0.0267644729,
-0.7030581832,
-0.2729570866,
-0.32094419,
-0.2729486227,
-0.2106155157,
-0.6211177707,
0.053613767,
-0.0744892731,
-0.0473191589,
0.855764091,
-0.2299900651,
0.0529774837,
-0.3131412268,
0.2684753537,
0.7366682291,
0.0797700062,
0.3030881882,
0.0439281724,
-0.1773881912,
0.1639908552,
-0.2273331732,
-0.8862504363,
0.2153294832,
0.0039753877,
0.7332095504,
0.3257159591,
0.0611086823,
0.4955362976,
-0.4973365963,
0.5396643877,
0.2385418117,
-0.6609668136,
0.231500119,
-0.0649843141,
0.2008607537,
0.4376294613,
0.3474013507,
-0.9191963673,
-0.5638154745,
-0.7283909321,
-0.7163857222,
0.3472568989,
0.1742633134,
0.2608579993,
-0.3328389823,
0.2423032224,
-0.1503253132,
0.5014945865,
-0.8256670237,
-0.2256773859,
-0.2024921328,
-0.209021464,
-0.1017495468,
0.3890638351,
-0.4438724816,
-0.1449618638,
0.535296917,
-0.3171979487,
0.5245712996,
0.3736193478,
-0.1957395226,
-0.0573879443,
0.3226130903,
0.6099983454,
0.4312368035,
0.1773272455,
0.2753942013,
0.102565214,
-0.1492810845,
0.3814260662,
-0.2832326591,
-0.0919907838,
-0.4059877992,
0.141582787,
0.981808424,
0.1729629934,
-0.824336648,
0.0772257671,
-0.2351457626,
-0.5812853575,
-0.5439879298,
0.371696502,
0.2679920197,
0.7254135609,
0.6212701797,
0.4523071647,
-0.0798985139,
-1.0257167816,
0.198794663,
0.7736342549,
-0.4734954536,
-0.2203111053,
0.2992585003,
0.3033306599,
-0.7659566402,
0.6279569864,
-0.6134046316,
-0.8906257153,
0.9997553229,
0.6311166286,
0.8805420995,
0.2221243083,
0.5670473576,
0.0218280759,
0.675598681,
-0.207238391,
0.2776093781,
-0.1753083616,
-1.2273186445,
-0.3840102851,
-0.4390366077,
-0.6841862202,
-0.0700376406,
-0.302513361,
-0.5062633753,
-0.8186580539,
-0.2670099735,
0.0134118376,
0.3044593632,
-0.6653490663,
0.1161048859,
0.4376578629,
0.8320587277,
-0.5742339492,
0.4285416603,
0.8200766444,
-0.1593851894,
-0.6011398435,
0.0244857203,
0.0856257826,
-0.6557440162,
0.6706553102,
0.409300983,
-0.1892598867,
0.3815817833,
-0.9658910036,
-0.8998506665,
1.0941808224,
0.0246757828,
-0.2204091847,
-0.281042248,
-0.220381394,
0.5375862718,
-0.4804761708,
0.001297197,
0.24353306,
0.5975353122,
-0.127914086,
-0.7476596832,
-0.0785696432,
-0.376542002,
-0.2197162956,
0.181422919,
-0.6051075459,
0.9448428154,
-0.4479124546,
-0.2610099614,
0.1641578823,
0.8600683212,
0.4909941554,
0.1428665966,
0.5540771484,
0.3475593626,
0.988797605,
-0.0594247058,
1.0295777321,
-0.1529442668,
0.1207773462,
0.7078359723,
-0.5169615149,
0.5532251596,
0.4269177914,
-0.1781976223,
0.5223988891,
0.1600673795,
0.0452407412,
0.3806732893,
0.4864303172,
-0.2671638429,
-0.201328218,
-0.0771989003,
-0.0091752298,
0.3587551415,
0.2658673227,
0.2901394367,
-0.1316032559,
0.1445028335,
-0.3827992678,
0.0928060934,
-0.3844549954,
0.667318821,
0.1040948555,
-0.5747846365,
-0.0086918389,
-0.1412560493,
0.9060102701,
-0.4798263311,
0.1384925395,
-0.0822871774,
-0.0225751698,
0.1454837769,
-0.6123155951,
0.2171079069,
-0.1462355405,
-0.0695823282,
-0.3791972101,
0.6780464649,
-0.3394874334,
-0.3418550193,
0.1301686913,
0.6845929623,
0.2777046561,
-0.0436784513,
-0.6890336275,
-0.4340180159,
-0.1619164199,
-0.1226766631,
0.5360676646,
0.4171062112,
-0.0637038499,
1.0318592787,
0.6625699997,
0.0570859872,
-0.0388235264,
-0.2751091123,
0.6860511303,
-0.7877496481,
-0.6111683846,
-0.7094703317,
0.2366562784,
-0.3395242989,
-0.191643849,
0.6351018548,
0.1334569752,
0.8221063614,
0.0422356538,
0.8906263113,
-0.3816961348,
-0.1364104003,
-0.1941862702,
0.9590381384,
-0.5622053146,
-0.5418634415,
-0.2257558107,
-0.7407779694,
-0.16065678,
0.9262346625,
-0.10832192,
-0.0954702422,
0.6246443987,
0.5021798015,
0.5128712654,
0.5112717152,
0.3574780524,
0.2837300599,
0.1787651926,
0.5406098366,
0.9901750684,
0.1462835073,
0.3321525753,
-0.2116189599,
-0.2281476408,
0.0484909527,
-0.655490756,
-0.8630516529,
-0.7248561382,
-0.1050863266,
-0.0458139516,
0.2392874062,
1.3767232895,
0.4697861373,
-0.4032332599,
-0.490304172,
-0.1253898144,
0.2934893072,
-0.3192189336,
-0.1783509254,
-0.1144157723,
-0.3406209648,
-0.627078414,
0.4750596285,
0.5495936871,
0.0452474728,
-0.6814228296,
-0.0710955188,
-0.2557295561,
0.4168165922,
0.8490610719,
0.2265360951,
-0.6527311206,
-0.1614533961,
0.2548389733,
-0.1568365693,
-0.3371328413,
0.6261496544,
-0.9588468075,
0.1680147052,
0.100919418,
0.7111514807,
0.002812237,
-0.4445668459,
0.31354177,
-0.4436821938,
0.289685905,
0.6167782545,
0.1368774921,
0.0848776549,
0.044731129,
0.3487552702,
0.1931157112,
-0.5295345783,
-0.7174586058,
0.3910971284,
-0.6733348966,
-0.3960519731,
0.6708774567,
0.2549433112,
-0.5409842134,
-0.3644498289,
-0.1975149959,
0.2137624919,
-0.2802735865,
1.0053846836,
0.7416241169,
-0.2221123427,
-0.0967979729,
-0.4895674884,
0.3716224134,
0.5053175092,
-1.0275971889,
-0.1086468175,
0.3913874328,
-0.1621870846,
0.486159116,
0.9848580956,
0.217356801,
0.2125557512,
-0.1336136907,
0.2475646883,
-0.1088401005,
-0.676678896,
0.0088378703,
0.1100365743,
-0.3021471798,
0.1811377406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17055v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17055v1 | Counterfactuals of Counterfactuals: a back-translation-inspired approach to analyse counterfactual editors | 2023-05-26T16:04:28 | 2023-05-26T16:04:28 | Giorgos Filandrianos, Edmund Dervakos, Orfeas Menis-Mastromichalakis, Chrysoula Zerva, Giorgos Stamou | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the wake of responsible AI, interpretability methods, which attempt to
provide an explanation for the predictions of neural models have seen rapid
progress. In this work, we are concerned with explanations that are applicable
to natural language processing (NLP) models and tasks, and we focus
specifically on the analysis of counterfactual, contrastive explanations. We
note that while there have been several explainers proposed to produce
counterfactual explanations, their behaviour can vary significantly and the
lack of a universal ground truth for the counterfactual edits imposes an
insuperable barrier on their evaluation. We propose a new back
translation-inspired evaluation methodology that utilises earlier outputs of
the explainer as ground truth proxies to investigate the consistency of
explainers. We show that by iteratively feeding the counterfactual to the
explainer we can obtain valuable insights into the behaviour of both the
predictor and the explainer models, and infer patterns that would be otherwise
obscured. Using this methodology, we conduct a thorough analysis and propose a
novel metric to evaluate the consistency of counterfactual generation
approaches with different characteristics across available performance
indicators. | [
-0.35129565,
-0.8665457964,
0.6898280382,
0.2051635832,
-0.1962093562,
-0.2005740404,
0.1294976175,
-0.3778600991,
0.0055584675,
0.3279153109,
-0.8981910348,
-0.1121161804,
-0.6598000526,
0.1044703946,
-0.5519294143,
1.1705139875,
-0.1880957484,
0.0774990842,
-0.4768104553,
-0.3590468764,
-0.7076197863,
-0.3551602364,
-0.5700678825,
-0.8057695031,
0.3589200974,
0.1283165067,
1.0021073818,
0.5546498895,
0.1505796611,
0.3183375299,
0.0838332027,
-0.0227722079,
-0.4226033092,
-0.0804106221,
-0.8674635887,
-0.3207613528,
-0.2565190792,
0.276722908,
0.3335199058,
0.6090034842,
-0.0037928219,
0.1114479154,
0.0187418908,
0.5506423116,
-0.5247766972,
-0.0155664645,
-0.6656581759,
0.2274501622,
0.1652081013,
-0.2512661517,
-0.3270204067,
-0.2369205952,
0.130977124,
-0.6702225208,
0.4988760948,
-0.0891130567,
0.607268393,
0.3358998299,
-0.0990387201,
-0.3976991177,
-0.6597542167,
0.8066998124,
-0.7663680315,
0.47997877,
0.0396446884,
0.1467441618,
-0.1213058829,
-0.6480918527,
-1.056972146,
-0.0515652522,
-0.3849469423,
0.3297245204,
-0.6278440356,
-0.3279626966,
0.0056345239,
0.2629179955,
-0.8379581571,
0.1778704226,
0.2026359737,
-0.1099613085,
0.5909330249,
0.3052399457,
0.3840400279,
0.0125092994,
-0.3298376799,
0.188394174,
-0.7971315384,
-0.0949213728,
0.0883075371,
-0.0896208361,
-0.1128572822,
0.4308003485,
-0.222007513,
0.4008252621,
0.343133837,
0.3963605464,
-0.0739602298,
-0.5092630982,
-0.2096623927,
0.1058326736,
0.6175929904,
0.5933817029,
0.2112797201,
-0.3886995614,
-0.0071584783,
0.4103672504,
0.569796741,
-0.8027037978,
-0.1504747868,
0.2690731287,
-0.6531737447,
-0.3989251554,
-0.2510381341,
-0.852641046,
-0.2857546508,
-0.3095697761,
0.6536082029,
-0.2356410474,
-0.170549944,
-0.1247577071,
-0.1939428449,
0.2383950353,
0.2802181542,
-0.7694766521,
0.3108037114,
0.7350257039,
0.7540424466,
-0.0942272246,
-0.380050987,
-0.5459470749,
-0.1017876863,
-0.6704553366,
0.7359685898,
-0.5627164841,
-0.3926123977,
-0.1633594036,
0.0966566652,
-0.2501021326,
-0.3867964745,
0.2189300358,
-0.3822779655,
0.4004640877,
-0.4047592282,
-0.4900270998,
-0.5428032875,
0.356739074,
-0.4483292997,
0.7515946627,
-0.1296271682,
-0.5519455671,
0.3704443872,
-0.7681878805,
-0.2474293858,
-0.0821601003,
-0.2733243406,
-0.423961699,
0.3556811512,
0.2494366914,
0.1240416989,
-0.2528389394,
0.6896139979,
-0.1004023924,
-0.4914928675,
0.3184453547,
-0.705739677,
1.0205711126,
0.1076279357,
-0.5671739578,
0.2792853415,
-0.6827025414,
-0.2905145884,
0.2810513377,
0.1620968431,
-0.1581559628,
0.1537804306,
-0.214274928,
0.2907685935,
0.1245309934,
-0.6587508321,
-0.1944669336,
-0.3896525502,
0.3863151073,
0.6276125312,
-0.0106063467,
0.1044595316,
-0.333720386,
0.4861576855,
0.0670469105,
0.1214390993,
-0.371745944,
-0.4314979613,
-0.392534107,
0.0963990465,
-0.0904701576,
0.6052099466,
-0.6934112906,
0.1253639013,
-0.1270343959,
-0.6368131638,
-0.3334155679,
0.0227111783,
0.8314517736,
1.0405330658,
0.5208884478,
-0.2725247443,
-0.7290392518,
-0.8695351481,
-0.7866473198,
-0.2866976261,
0.1362898797,
0.182413578,
0.7895917296,
-0.2779507041,
0.9370123744,
-0.2228438556,
0.2402995974,
-0.0777719393,
0.5270272493,
0.3771718144,
0.7536554933,
0.7047025561,
-0.8982538581,
-0.2472705543,
-0.1789103299,
-1.0109367371,
-0.3015164435,
-0.4572193325,
0.0438275114,
0.2365124375,
0.8325396776,
-0.7713487744,
0.6347065568,
0.5523697734,
-0.4666152596,
0.7665520906,
-0.1126967669,
0.0855338946,
-0.5055041313,
0.2914690077,
-0.2005479485,
-0.0969323814,
-0.6434137821,
0.221784994,
-0.3531086147,
0.1179045439,
-0.3622938693,
0.6793227792,
0.0465798452,
-0.0793836787,
-0.0393933393,
0.2828296423,
0.2824014723,
0.4377433658,
0.0709853768,
0.6167730093,
0.2219058275,
-0.346254915,
0.402195096,
0.416476965,
-0.0227276888,
0.8843434453,
-0.9386572242,
0.2164415419,
-0.1817735285,
0.3971512914,
-1.4400256872,
0.2627269924,
0.5562927127,
-0.4997418225,
0.0043221624,
-0.2384561151,
-0.2093423754,
-0.1151609272,
-0.1643288732,
0.1593198776,
0.2138908356,
-0.7118019462,
0.7710136771,
-0.4294416904,
-0.1814783663,
-0.6872178316,
-0.7583533525,
0.3614863157,
-0.2992090881,
-0.2914471626,
0.4111783206,
-0.4197027683,
-0.5601916909,
0.2362719178,
-0.4963364005,
0.0825028419,
0.3453420103,
0.2603455186,
0.1761322767,
-0.5239102244,
0.0000477162,
0.1130368188,
-0.2349413633,
0.3575837612,
-0.3038401604,
0.2002007961,
-0.0647043288,
-0.1588127613,
-0.3902464509,
0.3634234667,
0.269829303,
-0.0491431132,
0.9706150293,
0.6555392146,
-0.1847328097,
0.1575522274,
-0.3547444642,
-0.007874514,
-0.379958719,
0.3619093597,
-0.6412777305,
-0.1847386807,
0.6283317208,
0.0353861228,
0.1347877085,
0.8100475073,
0.4326434135,
-0.0083678588,
1.0939928293,
0.48104316,
0.3879944086,
0.3556666374,
-0.1027853712,
0.0781505778,
-0.4160019457,
-0.2924396694,
-0.532848835,
0.0586164743,
-0.6642737985,
0.1181879044,
-0.164143011,
0.0746872276,
-0.1887746304,
0.1310250014,
-0.118393898,
0.5303292871,
0.2433297932,
-0.042422656,
0.2708727419,
-0.4617242217,
0.0156105487,
-0.0812819749,
-0.7345471978,
-0.5507847667,
0.6751307845,
0.1652106643,
0.1795942634,
0.198021099,
0.3657641113,
0.3910649121,
0.7266550064,
-0.5912327766,
0.3652115166,
-0.4819800556,
-0.6627393365,
-0.281286031,
-0.194961518,
-0.7104308009,
0.4908382595,
-0.4455524385,
-0.7640940547,
0.4079882503,
0.4042179883,
-0.1683302224,
0.0231458563,
-0.617271781,
1.3620785475,
-0.1305739433,
-0.4422186911,
-0.4234439433,
-0.6528649926,
0.1887784749,
-0.1175086722,
0.1640286446,
0.3773459792,
0.2224435955,
0.6920816302,
-0.3987387121,
0.9647083879,
-0.3142862022,
-0.3157346249,
-0.053606078,
0.2677689195,
0.4268585742,
0.1581272483,
-0.1883192062,
0.444847554,
-0.06498155,
-0.3865085542,
-0.9592862129,
0.5510778427,
-0.52049613,
-0.7743757963,
-0.0964513868,
-0.5800261497,
-0.1217520162,
0.3541054428,
0.352571249,
0.6114601493,
-0.6802645922,
0.1326654553,
0.5479787588,
-0.4494194984,
0.5721780062,
0.8047246933,
-0.0849485546,
-0.1652279198,
0.828207612,
0.1144457459,
-0.0678044409,
0.4570997655,
0.5108115673,
-0.4003486931,
-0.7661365867,
-0.7673361897,
-0.105113633,
-0.6410173178,
0.2567013502,
-0.4021125436,
0.1394614875,
-0.283898741,
-0.3496464193,
-0.329151541,
-0.3336974978,
-0.1942550838,
-0.0804486126,
0.0181084685,
0.8992083073,
-0.3117807508,
0.4777661562,
-0.3920000196,
0.7897823453,
0.3340114951,
0.3352628052,
0.1273314059,
-0.6046245098,
-0.3131505847,
0.1846118271,
-0.2181455791,
-0.9258815646,
0.3792326152,
0.1919910908,
0.6616540551,
0.3238003552,
-0.0853619874,
0.7385464907,
-0.5822571516,
0.8459035754,
0.0233750269,
-1.2888042927,
0.4917876422,
-0.1648907214,
0.2394027859,
0.3153119683,
0.4098570943,
-0.5054340363,
-0.3700980246,
-0.8365030885,
-0.6945558786,
0.6256920099,
0.1625924259,
0.0193983186,
0.0609923787,
0.2956692874,
0.5807231665,
0.2831777334,
-0.5560424328,
-0.135720253,
-0.9228782654,
-0.2060133964,
-0.5626891851,
-0.2165983319,
-0.2446255535,
0.2348607332,
0.5799591541,
-0.0392485224,
-0.1555466205,
0.4061457515,
-0.494125843,
-0.3107410669,
0.3808360696,
0.7296461463,
1.0756473541,
-0.2197360098,
0.1633349061,
0.0128580891,
-0.2544359565,
-0.1309044063,
0.3211372793,
-0.3682107031,
0.2249114066,
0.5965175033,
0.6199250817,
-0.0461413637,
-0.5250056982,
0.3408692181,
0.0365872979,
0.0120461257,
-0.3313062489,
-0.1205116734,
-0.1490027905,
0.3757016063,
0.3218407929,
0.20421049,
0.162948817,
-0.8185002804,
0.290463835,
0.406878978,
-0.5174798965,
-0.5785387158,
0.7020310163,
0.0477775373,
-0.5102083087,
0.5054044127,
-0.053143125,
-0.5494652987,
0.6684397459,
0.6804252267,
0.961283803,
-0.2563527524,
0.22363922,
0.0952112153,
0.3837207556,
0.1826416403,
0.2723456323,
0.0335383192,
-0.9516959786,
-0.6587102413,
-0.0735400692,
-0.536847651,
0.3833939731,
-0.7514999509,
-0.3287392259,
-0.2521927953,
0.3672868609,
0.4073016346,
-0.1026104316,
-0.5846967697,
0.6512284875,
-0.1388036907,
0.7091338634,
-1.1381442547,
0.4112073183,
0.584880054,
-0.5498313904,
-0.1289045811,
0.276899457,
0.1174826771,
-0.8585016727,
0.7220238447,
0.1363526434,
-0.3517882526,
-0.3316946924,
-0.6141425371,
-0.299374491,
0.5790467858,
0.3833530843,
-0.5726454258,
0.1171019673,
-0.0262852944,
0.9134172201,
-0.3694887757,
0.2673595846,
0.5964041948,
0.5710055232,
-0.3326369822,
-0.7135787606,
0.4175133705,
-0.3756765425,
-0.2355353236,
-0.2300594747,
-0.2851911485,
0.5192559361,
-0.1878982931,
-0.0045564971,
0.2644300759,
0.536698103,
0.0429387353,
0.8460180163,
0.5476219654,
0.5612491965,
0.1816654205,
0.0791798532,
0.923374474,
-0.1110533774,
0.1379725039,
1.34063375,
0.0655964613,
0.5163761377,
0.65438658,
0.0138010895,
0.8375278115,
0.1903437376,
-0.197920993,
0.3777778745,
0.0832127109,
0.3544648886,
-0.1903792173,
-0.3467412293,
0.0268689226,
0.7558265924,
0.2119284868,
-0.3730508089,
-0.1874206662,
-0.2630012929,
0.0516242273,
0.4673797786,
-0.3465131223,
0.6699904799,
-0.0374083184,
-0.69612813,
0.5853831172,
-0.2793575525,
0.2847985923,
-0.1350675672,
-0.4694253802,
-0.4144592285,
0.1836018115,
-0.2068307847,
-0.8210523129,
0.7524921894,
0.0747883841,
-0.2912724018,
-0.5516024232,
0.3011441529,
-0.1529234052,
-0.0683101043,
0.1584101021,
0.6002141833,
0.1474346071,
-0.0316145718,
-0.7268205285,
-0.2246898711,
-0.175503552,
-0.2293447703,
-0.0523846075,
0.5724036694,
-0.1861450821,
0.4359642267,
0.4063958526,
-0.0837294832,
-0.3660347164,
0.0902670771,
0.4604377747,
-0.8130497932,
-0.615784049,
-1.0850628614,
0.5239458084,
0.2020426542,
-0.5238140225,
0.8592908978,
0.3831006885,
0.8235951066,
-0.0102091571,
0.6159755588,
0.1030034497,
0.4484284818,
-0.5470865369,
0.4872380495,
-0.6117834449,
0.2425376475,
-0.4206253886,
-0.6893034577,
0.090543516,
0.3262551129,
-0.441380173,
-0.1732201427,
0.455976963,
0.5265914798,
-0.0099984901,
0.2292164266,
0.2302884459,
0.7100924253,
0.164146021,
0.1839708537,
0.9472895265,
-0.4766847193,
0.5632614493,
-0.0058376105,
0.0864902586,
-0.2162885964,
-1.1833231449,
-0.6991710067,
-0.2481562942,
-0.3978836834,
-0.2030003071,
0.4293867946,
0.3750947416,
0.3856431246,
-1.0505058765,
0.1208414882,
-0.5123772621,
0.4478096366,
-0.6776843667,
-0.237259984,
0.231031552,
0.010727969,
-0.5703245401,
0.5520231128,
0.0356708504,
-0.1321372092,
-0.2085503638,
-0.0644364506,
-0.1262423545,
0.4453823268,
0.6297975779,
0.3616009057,
-0.9607883096,
-0.3941482604,
-0.2102129161,
0.4499051571,
-0.056938827,
0.7792496681,
-0.9417964816,
0.518017292,
0.5072526932,
0.4198402166,
0.2989288568,
0.0666035116,
0.881752193,
-0.7499693036,
-0.0183505993,
-0.0000329758,
0.2391815484,
0.3152392209,
-0.2961119413,
0.5676936507,
0.3572757542,
-0.0578909479,
-0.8374717236,
0.436234504,
-0.5422139168,
-0.6850122809,
0.5780169368,
-0.4906577468,
0.2571475506,
-0.3139941394,
0.107818149,
0.5313843489,
-0.0882708505,
0.9662117362,
0.5176038742,
-0.3212680817,
-0.2176042944,
-0.3654962182,
0.305280745,
0.7109568119,
-0.5899744034,
0.1474782676,
0.403644979,
0.17927517,
0.4302062094,
0.2566720247,
-0.0722085312,
0.4171410799,
0.3841681778,
-0.2176824659,
-0.0878182724,
-0.239005208,
-0.5700044632,
-0.103710942,
-0.3376960158,
-0.0592106245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17050v1 | Exploiting Abstract Meaning Representation for Open-Domain Question Answering | 2023-05-26T16:00:16 | 2023-05-26T16:00:16 | Cunxiang Wang, Zhikun Xu, Qipeng Guo, Xiangkun Hu, Xuefeng Bai, Zheng Zhang, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Open-Domain Question Answering (ODQA) task involves retrieving and
subsequently generating answers from fine-grained relevant passages within a
database. Current systems leverage Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) to model
the relationship between questions and passages. However, the diversity in
surface form expressions can hinder the model's ability to capture accurate
correlations, especially within complex contexts. Therefore, we utilize
Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) graphs to assist the model in
understanding complex semantic information. We introduce a method known as
Graph-as-Token (GST) to incorporate AMRs into PLMs. Results from Natural
Questions (NQ) and TriviaQA (TQ) demonstrate that our GST method can
significantly improve performance, resulting in up to 2.44/3.17 Exact Match
score improvements on NQ/TQ respectively. Furthermore, our method enhances
robustness and outperforms alternative Graph Neural Network (GNN) methods for
integrating AMRs. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to employ
semantic graphs in ODQA. | [
-0.5300378203,
-1.1682629585,
0.6223591566,
-0.3440859616,
-0.3485541642,
0.4148275256,
0.0846788064,
-0.5726756454,
0.1896468848,
0.4458609521,
-0.4594298303,
-0.6867421865,
-0.570330143,
0.0586988367,
-0.0977992043,
0.7528088093,
-0.5575580597,
0.0465939045,
-0.3282051086,
-0.3209396005,
-0.1944828033,
-0.6059349179,
-0.7497642636,
-0.2354273945,
0.4859542251,
-0.0678979754,
0.6781468987,
0.4934100509,
0.2373438179,
0.1818237007,
-0.0596470982,
0.3523329496,
-0.3639099002,
0.057374347,
-0.1645026356,
-0.2812466919,
-0.5665979981,
-0.0360838659,
0.4737248123,
1.2247059345,
0.065673843,
0.2323959917,
-0.1349688172,
0.398932755,
-0.6410210729,
0.5566715002,
-0.4159423113,
0.047355596,
-0.1392010003,
-0.2790695429,
-0.2263503224,
-0.4874848425,
0.0637542531,
-0.8405502439,
-0.1651041061,
0.1675429791,
0.9435791969,
0.1052991748,
-0.6839953661,
-0.3760820329,
-0.5290548205,
0.5015578866,
-0.4801594317,
0.2005292326,
0.0806940198,
0.5836583376,
-0.1510654837,
-1.0166989565,
-0.6788515449,
0.2010884583,
-0.1663333774,
0.1092283055,
-0.2832291722,
0.2401560396,
0.1250942647,
0.5044718981,
-0.3840430677,
-0.378013283,
-0.4563780129,
-0.2205679268,
0.4287554026,
0.3949291408,
0.6144034863,
-0.1061837226,
-0.2875547111,
-0.0495262593,
-0.6226173639,
0.2998214066,
0.2024911195,
0.5774300694,
0.1605234146,
0.9607300758,
-0.256134361,
0.962982595,
-0.2957363129,
0.3948943317,
0.2432950139,
-0.4614517093,
-0.0223022047,
0.0002311684,
0.5738002062,
0.121658355,
0.4347951412,
-0.3590971529,
-0.0179319046,
0.0823127478,
0.105094038,
-0.7307130098,
-0.1397340447,
0.1797463298,
-0.2745411098,
0.2364106476,
0.4150857031,
-0.4481140375,
-0.0367510319,
-0.391880393,
0.5655761361,
-0.5735980272,
-0.2260476351,
0.5741150975,
-0.3529818952,
0.2593981028,
0.5124978423,
-0.499314338,
0.7228978872,
0.4873354733,
0.8138160706,
-0.0829379261,
0.0598392487,
-0.8700210452,
0.2590446174,
-0.136278525,
0.5931614637,
-0.7101223469,
-0.2494073808,
-0.0676417053,
-0.0990897194,
-0.4590390325,
-0.372985065,
0.349621594,
-1.1438906193,
0.15135324,
-0.240246743,
-0.5115264654,
-0.3945338726,
0.4185873866,
-0.6566922665,
1.0198639631,
0.2418958396,
-0.8363929391,
-0.0184377469,
-1.125844717,
-0.2549466491,
-0.0235665906,
-0.2893879712,
0.0566514619,
-0.0539763011,
0.381156832,
0.1406193078,
-0.0295942314,
-0.2507831454,
-0.1972771138,
-0.2560181618,
0.3283417821,
-0.0088554043,
0.7470923662,
0.0812817961,
-0.055576738,
0.155256629,
-0.4857183397,
0.5586512089,
0.1860256046,
-0.3387023807,
-0.6698208451,
-0.1253881007,
-0.333106637,
0.2983567417,
0.1137771308,
-1.0120282173,
0.0751628056,
-0.5843111277,
0.6929653883,
0.5773308277,
0.3027985692,
0.2610928416,
-0.1668619961,
0.6746734977,
0.1439926773,
-0.3417952359,
0.0583592504,
-0.8176783323,
-0.3378321528,
-0.1768226922,
0.5018817782,
0.4800220728,
-0.8349710703,
0.163139239,
-0.4368336797,
-0.1008368954,
-0.7811558843,
-0.2899642587,
0.3729303181,
0.5480054021,
0.6988631487,
-0.5213674307,
-0.3054299951,
-0.3738859296,
-0.4608176053,
-0.1780375391,
-0.1527076364,
0.5646194816,
0.7152391076,
0.0978236347,
1.3708422184,
-1.0892812014,
-0.1482918859,
0.0637227222,
0.2712832391,
-0.0226652548,
0.1441758573,
0.280403018,
-0.7952263355,
-0.5167506337,
-0.0353907011,
-0.6887862086,
0.0850920603,
0.6772554517,
-0.4057608545,
-0.0415450893,
0.6066954136,
-0.8130202293,
0.6142276525,
0.1589032561,
-0.6705365181,
0.4601031244,
-0.0682190731,
0.2980558276,
-0.7365556955,
0.2061144859,
-0.4381710589,
-0.2499742508,
-0.5209779143,
0.1776798069,
-0.1549124569,
-0.3382406235,
-0.4320145249,
0.8587600589,
-0.3229618371,
-0.2152851671,
0.0703887939,
0.4868232608,
0.3633462191,
0.4777665436,
-0.0885116458,
0.8107774854,
0.3077602386,
-0.5469620228,
0.1730913669,
0.5881761909,
-0.3005801141,
0.1764259338,
-0.8961707354,
0.320071578,
-0.5348521471,
0.2810931504,
-1.2899707556,
-0.1832960248,
0.5173665881,
-0.6312338114,
0.0642421544,
-0.1340799779,
-0.5973600149,
-0.3285128772,
-0.1740996689,
0.7232252359,
0.4113352299,
-0.5128564239,
0.8142406344,
0.3698470592,
-0.1055094078,
-0.5101627707,
-0.4872421324,
-0.2548308074,
0.055600848,
-0.9711546898,
0.4771757424,
0.2368969023,
-0.1706298441,
0.4107763171,
-0.2647574544,
-0.0707434043,
0.0058188634,
-0.013865361,
-0.0227012839,
-0.5661044121,
0.1239519119,
0.0738580301,
-0.2923232019,
0.2403540164,
-0.5170795918,
0.6883606315,
-0.1300983578,
-0.4852030575,
0.0913556367,
0.5073873997,
0.4069905579,
-0.7094339728,
0.7804083824,
0.3085527122,
-0.3943472803,
-0.1122868657,
0.1708645672,
-0.1459163725,
-0.411668092,
0.1489937156,
-0.6080707908,
-1.0682426691,
0.6685826778,
-0.0341017731,
-0.0033015269,
0.3384711742,
0.2214483023,
-0.0278183185,
1.2040476799,
0.0785972923,
0.4660052657,
0.0832769796,
-0.2002035677,
0.4208972156,
-0.8900443912,
-0.3386285603,
-0.425999552,
-0.0972813219,
-0.1719080806,
-0.8208445907,
0.5329443216,
0.2020049989,
-0.5084750652,
-0.1335485578,
-0.3757133484,
0.2715193927,
0.607550025,
0.2586763203,
0.5197392106,
0.038573727,
-0.2487556189,
0.1719311774,
-0.4392414093,
-0.6196803451,
0.9125673175,
0.2451421022,
0.8539945483,
0.3060630858,
0.4437849522,
-0.0699594766,
0.0743900016,
-0.6741839051,
0.6322644949,
-0.2262241393,
-0.5635480285,
-0.4575739801,
-0.5420392752,
-0.9595493078,
0.4205180407,
0.0350251347,
-0.6989159584,
-0.211332351,
-0.0089179846,
-0.4294090569,
0.3171394467,
-0.5255308747,
1.0568892956,
-0.0134774856,
0.0816552192,
0.2645019591,
-0.6152438521,
0.1815111786,
0.2847513556,
0.073113203,
-0.1621522903,
-0.23108913,
0.732911706,
-0.5809323788,
0.7745105624,
-0.4350003302,
0.0556110032,
0.5948314071,
-0.1797429323,
0.2929373384,
-0.1927246153,
-0.1151054651,
-0.0193628408,
0.1778447032,
-0.5907379389,
-1.0118720531,
0.3731710613,
-0.9229878187,
-0.5215049982,
-0.336084038,
-0.4711171389,
-0.4282531738,
0.2592741251,
0.0326310769,
0.6398587823,
-0.111194104,
-0.1446646452,
0.6012177467,
-0.153995648,
-0.0299458057,
0.2395846993,
-0.315005213,
-0.3938449323,
0.5687942505,
0.2760186791,
0.5366877913,
0.3559557796,
0.1731954515,
-0.6720042229,
-0.4817178845,
-0.6501940489,
0.2664804757,
-1.0953308344,
-0.2000245452,
-1.007810235,
-0.3795627654,
-0.2833324969,
0.0970691219,
0.2545949221,
-0.6465375423,
-0.0364076644,
-0.2174542099,
0.667930007,
0.5979949832,
0.4975080192,
0.1896827817,
-0.6773771644,
0.4613496065,
0.4021755755,
0.530454278,
0.0694336593,
-0.2961091697,
0.0240348019,
0.3524986804,
-0.2040281147,
-0.8112744093,
-0.0537108667,
0.4611638784,
0.6049500108,
-0.0742152482,
0.4467071891,
0.8225082159,
-0.5567746162,
0.8137508035,
-0.0951440409,
-0.9242735505,
0.3318709135,
-0.3473867178,
0.3660110831,
0.5989838243,
0.518822372,
-0.3239414692,
-0.4938628078,
-0.3679056168,
-0.8864443302,
0.8092884421,
0.3299847245,
0.3141763508,
-0.2439142466,
0.4264789224,
-0.0571712926,
0.4523955286,
-0.5273349285,
-0.4573898017,
-0.4931596816,
-0.4591151178,
0.1547238976,
0.0735700801,
-0.1574378908,
-0.1369554698,
0.3909490705,
-0.2926309407,
0.5145250559,
0.1885437816,
-0.0347397253,
-0.0958560556,
0.2161854357,
0.1021781862,
0.5799848437,
-0.3100533187,
0.3658533394,
-0.0718774274,
-0.481216222,
-0.0133456001,
0.3003806472,
-0.0439628512,
0.087873511,
0.1525531262,
0.7386907339,
0.0213730354,
-0.8055618405,
0.5864984393,
-0.0605957024,
-0.2442058325,
-0.1336641461,
0.0585475639,
0.2531437576,
-0.1759207547,
0.3450446725,
-0.1449991614,
0.1838846058,
-0.7364061475,
0.3025194407,
0.5098004341,
-0.6628177762,
-0.2079374641,
0.780087173,
-0.011248447,
-0.1014710441,
0.6439523101,
-0.1600249559,
-0.6243537664,
0.5210062265,
0.6185142398,
0.5319112539,
-0.0765710995,
0.2152838409,
0.3234915137,
-0.1391178668,
0.3557708263,
0.733279407,
0.0199831482,
-0.7440901399,
-0.5111460686,
-0.7141862512,
-0.3199542463,
-0.2141753286,
-0.7158488631,
0.1341421753,
-0.3461801708,
0.0123860408,
0.2100077569,
-0.0797328502,
-0.4335429668,
0.3221845925,
-0.1113234535,
1.0625532866,
-0.704444766,
0.4829169512,
1.1996189356,
-0.6768675447,
-0.9526785016,
-0.0562499613,
-0.3887538314,
-0.8469099998,
0.8234353662,
0.2842629552,
-0.2228809595,
0.3831756711,
-0.2904228866,
-0.7939327359,
1.1162594557,
0.2577368021,
0.3800069988,
-0.1924906075,
0.5041570067,
0.499352634,
-0.6530691981,
0.2667935193,
0.3795877099,
0.3351450264,
0.5627759695,
-0.6027359962,
0.3479695022,
-0.3618032634,
-0.2515059114,
0.6609383821,
0.0140321525,
1.0948913097,
-0.0948024094,
-0.5258347988,
0.0777321979,
0.5476864576,
0.3425219655,
0.3560836911,
0.516525805,
0.2968364656,
0.8771413565,
-0.1830795705,
0.9702091813,
-0.2513341308,
0.1814498901,
1.0404138565,
-0.0360907055,
0.8396956325,
0.4903479218,
-0.1064691693,
0.760553956,
0.5736245513,
0.5645010471,
0.5512760282,
0.5603739619,
-0.3860574365,
-0.3293087482,
-0.0932977125,
-0.3768513203,
0.2784634829,
0.4210380614,
-0.2022463083,
-0.7494063377,
0.0284883324,
0.0503776558,
0.3138124347,
-0.430251807,
0.7497826219,
0.2187752575,
-0.5966804624,
0.6569247842,
0.1020788327,
0.0936943814,
-0.7368121147,
-0.3089945018,
0.1759446263,
-0.0085491696,
-0.2263662368,
-1.0530449152,
0.3593402803,
-0.1594351232,
-0.076306954,
-0.0047858614,
0.5901446939,
-0.5394404531,
-0.2241450995,
0.4030836821,
0.8140440583,
0.0327558629,
-0.1759406626,
-0.568797946,
-0.172674939,
-0.3605089188,
0.025561763,
0.1482098401,
0.764691174,
-0.2584082782,
0.3520362079,
0.4693663418,
-0.2179269195,
0.2156820893,
-0.1135973707,
1.1807414293,
-0.5506788492,
-0.6872931123,
-0.6081345677,
0.661888063,
-0.1395787597,
-0.2230743021,
0.6887159944,
0.4784604311,
0.7418459058,
-0.0513795502,
0.9426011443,
-0.1884569824,
0.612606585,
-0.6721852422,
0.4147382677,
-0.5652319789,
0.0670075864,
-0.2558571398,
-0.7357413173,
-0.4493950009,
0.4582141042,
-0.7015510798,
-0.0602912642,
0.6573146582,
0.5582947731,
-0.3329913616,
0.1632217914,
0.0082866764,
0.0218654033,
0.3284316361,
0.569709003,
0.9986123443,
-0.5260818601,
0.66471982,
0.2241881341,
-0.1958682239,
0.0839775056,
-0.5627421737,
-0.9390289187,
-0.4891023338,
-0.4047143459,
-0.6457167268,
0.1125195622,
0.8127256036,
0.3557765186,
-0.7523081303,
-0.0272883791,
-0.0613510758,
0.07032419,
-0.187367335,
-0.2038214803,
0.7171577215,
-0.4437768161,
-0.493357271,
0.0490456261,
0.1180974543,
0.1511445045,
0.036283914,
-0.1447508633,
-0.2218092531,
0.2328363508,
0.6844263673,
0.3007709384,
-0.5889064074,
-0.661518693,
0.2256895602,
0.0633479282,
0.2630864084,
0.78616786,
-0.7796798348,
0.5266135335,
0.4924294055,
0.7838734388,
0.521124661,
0.5440297127,
0.6978166699,
-0.7498087883,
-0.3862869143,
0.4074465036,
0.0654241219,
0.1843487173,
0.0337615125,
0.4888678491,
0.0613132492,
-0.0704068244,
-0.7434746027,
0.4968747795,
-0.9723778367,
-0.3208220303,
1.0273435116,
-0.466303736,
-0.4361155033,
-0.7919017076,
-0.3075900674,
0.1476385742,
-0.2488926649,
0.3344468474,
0.5007505417,
-0.3575362563,
0.1693566442,
-0.5140696168,
0.4446230829,
-0.0042993533,
-0.7614979744,
0.0006080994,
0.27465114,
0.2043552697,
0.3122146726,
1.017844677,
-0.439347297,
0.1759067476,
-0.1279396862,
-0.1953221262,
-0.3856999874,
0.0799314752,
-0.0128872236,
0.5621026158,
0.1794466525,
-0.5378149152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17041v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17041v1 | RFiD: Towards Rational Fusion-in-Decoder for Open-Domain Question Answering | 2023-05-26T15:51:25 | 2023-05-26T15:51:25 | Cunxiang Wang, Haofei Yu, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Open-Domain Question Answering (ODQA) systems necessitate a reader model
capable of generating answers by simultaneously referring to multiple passages.
Although representative models like Fusion-in-Decoder (FiD) have been proposed
to address this challenge, these systems can inadvertently rely on spurious
features instead of genuine causal relationships between the question and the
passages to generate answers. To counter this problem, we introduce the
Rational Fusion-in-Decoder (RFiD) model. Our model leverages the encoders of
FiD to differentiate between causal relationships and spurious features,
subsequently guiding the decoder to generate answers informed by this
discernment. Experimental results on two ODQA datasets, Natural Questions (NQ)
and TriviaQA (TQ), demonstrate that our model surpasses previous methods,
achieving improvements of up to 1.5 and 0.7 in Exact Match scores on NQ, and
exhibits an enhanced ability to identify causal relationships. | [
-0.5986676216,
-0.8143498302,
0.4805240035,
-0.3089468777,
-0.2323516905,
-0.1529567391,
0.3791899979,
-0.7400974035,
-0.0483634472,
0.7085217834,
-0.7020286322,
-0.0422728397,
-0.0394836888,
0.4074823558,
-0.3214360774,
0.9621425271,
-0.2090173364,
0.1574746221,
-0.527094245,
-0.4094591737,
-0.5517951846,
-0.4826241732,
-0.439062506,
-0.2939899266,
0.5462139845,
0.2919093668,
0.6892670393,
0.5145040154,
0.7444569468,
0.0738685802,
0.2395002544,
0.3246274292,
-0.4194743633,
0.2943705022,
-0.4398609698,
-0.1775890291,
-0.1891007274,
-0.0904764086,
0.4939199388,
0.8836997747,
0.2071172148,
0.2806522846,
-0.1540455967,
0.4045481384,
-0.5687310696,
-0.2910938859,
-0.4172443748,
-0.3734758794,
-0.1323303133,
-0.5448154807,
-0.5879606009,
-0.6548745632,
0.0804550052,
-0.717738688,
0.2601695657,
0.2554943562,
0.9792250395,
0.3839473128,
-0.5429868698,
-0.3318975866,
-1.2460839748,
0.436532408,
-0.2701992393,
0.2631961405,
0.3704946041,
0.3838420808,
-0.231665194,
-0.3842229545,
-0.906101644,
0.1722606421,
-0.0874452144,
-0.034915518,
-0.0350424312,
0.0088422913,
0.4058322608,
0.1608719528,
-0.7233395576,
-0.538062036,
-0.1265550703,
0.2428178042,
0.7477446795,
0.4984098673,
0.4353946447,
-0.1789258271,
-0.5527676344,
0.0022037823,
-0.6799113154,
-0.0008566733,
0.0978316441,
0.1007192805,
0.385882169,
0.9122903347,
-0.2030233145,
0.9085974693,
0.2771820426,
-0.0686604828,
-0.1640769839,
-0.6774036884,
-0.1739917397,
-0.0084803142,
0.1669234931,
0.0985287204,
0.1227731034,
-0.3619304299,
-0.3022731543,
0.0784379765,
-0.0009452198,
-0.553094089,
-0.0329022333,
0.6602922082,
-0.5082641244,
0.1352928281,
0.5046544075,
-0.473590225,
-0.3688060045,
-0.2020273954,
0.8597797751,
-0.7520783544,
-0.3950486779,
0.5472493768,
-0.5827887058,
0.7020938993,
0.2377605438,
-0.4866785109,
0.3036067784,
0.6258889437,
0.4876659513,
0.1966873407,
-0.0908370093,
-0.6016253233,
0.4181176424,
-0.1649565101,
1.0688112974,
-0.6733528376,
-0.4002687037,
-0.0724434704,
-0.2862766087,
-0.3672351241,
-0.4978244901,
0.6806973815,
-1.1436645985,
0.2062376142,
-0.5811212659,
-0.5235699415,
-0.1326028854,
0.2643570304,
-0.8002296686,
0.841578424,
0.2228792906,
-1.1060212851,
0.2892502248,
-0.8353555202,
-0.1729373336,
0.2402449697,
-0.0017223171,
0.0407474935,
0.0625498518,
0.0790704116,
0.0303527694,
-0.5777748823,
0.3231096268,
-0.5066838861,
-0.3143250644,
0.7446566224,
-0.3121007979,
0.9220501184,
0.1540670395,
0.1450359225,
0.1322060227,
-0.800162077,
-0.2030744702,
0.2268084288,
-0.0727465972,
-0.8405056596,
0.0476855971,
-0.1687112153,
0.388227731,
-0.1408762336,
-0.9614411592,
0.0902138799,
-0.4568905234,
0.0822243616,
0.4693913758,
0.6220242381,
0.5890614986,
-1.0361143351,
0.339296937,
0.1090796962,
0.1966872513,
-0.2736431658,
-0.4461658597,
-0.7021317482,
-0.3606065214,
0.4281816185,
0.4488608837,
-1.3423194885,
0.2912313938,
-0.3417609036,
-0.2536083162,
-0.6567018032,
-0.4024426639,
0.2138952166,
0.7127609253,
0.2728752494,
-0.1426797062,
-0.0865916163,
-0.5409634709,
-0.3357315361,
-0.0273926109,
-0.1337474436,
0.3469648957,
0.826132834,
0.1818990856,
1.349925518,
-0.5893542767,
-0.2788367867,
-0.0438266248,
0.0451171249,
0.1518326104,
0.4597905576,
0.3706083,
-1.0050648451,
-0.292126894,
-0.1273341477,
-0.6091722846,
0.2282522023,
-0.232646361,
-0.5529562831,
0.2294535488,
0.2513802052,
-0.9738429189,
0.4723178148,
-0.3075536788,
-0.7749987245,
0.2513066828,
-0.1143773198,
0.1943139285,
-0.9064227939,
0.5018947721,
-0.21212551,
0.3552246094,
-0.8149097562,
0.1786480248,
0.1568664312,
-0.0459212288,
-0.218923673,
0.7009627819,
-0.1866706759,
0.0312436074,
0.1742396951,
0.1093299314,
0.2955940664,
0.3801904321,
0.0465032533,
0.3791486323,
-0.0143365478,
-0.5013411641,
0.2158786207,
0.4702377319,
-0.267498374,
0.6183690429,
-0.7900272608,
0.0937187076,
-0.6212127805,
0.2661169767,
-1.3003883362,
-0.7096073627,
0.5008675456,
-0.6143772602,
0.133616358,
0.0819301233,
-0.7159915566,
-0.4503734112,
-0.3039587438,
0.7976543307,
0.2948366404,
-0.8864341974,
0.9031614661,
0.2274627835,
0.1417504549,
-0.493720293,
-0.1900249571,
-0.7278655767,
-0.1033691019,
-1.100548625,
0.2805540562,
-0.1298454553,
-0.3284723461,
0.3912349939,
-0.1713367701,
-0.3098356426,
0.1105568856,
0.184871316,
0.5297154188,
-0.2762391567,
0.4936138093,
0.1022134349,
-0.0211350825,
0.2886767983,
-0.2975359559,
0.4243742526,
0.5398875475,
-0.2942588627,
-0.0349198841,
0.9708273411,
0.6815052629,
-0.7540943027,
0.8728350401,
0.1449793726,
-0.7091622949,
-0.3263094127,
-0.2124592513,
-0.3112788796,
-0.431545049,
-0.1603900194,
-0.6606205106,
-0.7800441384,
0.6344298124,
0.1404439956,
0.0874050334,
0.4765814245,
0.105875589,
-0.2043488473,
1.2339200974,
0.3855099976,
0.407437861,
0.1487286836,
-0.0832879618,
0.3306760192,
-0.797282517,
-0.6356709599,
-0.846483469,
0.0681729019,
0.0457901508,
-0.4381627738,
0.5141788125,
0.248903349,
-0.4484832287,
-0.2664543688,
-0.4503430128,
0.5885910988,
0.6196936369,
0.1202576756,
0.3612620533,
-0.157238096,
-0.059807267,
0.359688729,
-0.8560643792,
-0.2817822695,
0.9405850172,
0.239379853,
0.8607799411,
0.4925523698,
0.5626531839,
-0.0934938341,
0.2545179725,
-0.4432733357,
0.359954834,
0.2924026549,
-1.0152623653,
-0.3583653867,
-0.203345269,
-0.7697131038,
0.2403794676,
-0.526353538,
-0.2923747599,
0.5835909843,
-0.0604868643,
-0.7555468082,
0.1435063779,
-0.5384602547,
0.8066806793,
-0.0566169173,
-0.3804629147,
0.155458048,
-0.5009664893,
0.8200098872,
-0.0273754522,
-0.1443132758,
-0.0330852866,
0.0164680872,
0.6419999599,
-0.3444759548,
0.5206973553,
-0.0885488912,
-0.0073778331,
0.3787637055,
0.0581060238,
0.2278789282,
0.2397900671,
-0.1721518785,
-0.1431639344,
0.3738479912,
-0.4355880022,
-0.7570029497,
0.6549534798,
-0.7627399564,
-0.5070644617,
-0.7339124084,
-0.5995442867,
-0.164198041,
0.2208142579,
0.1695397645,
0.9666870832,
-0.2905153632,
-0.2183265686,
1.1029046774,
-0.1741974205,
0.4980582595,
0.4518259764,
0.0043539978,
-0.3911527693,
0.8560300469,
0.0894813687,
0.3186773956,
0.4321466386,
-0.095546402,
-0.5433627963,
-0.2859006524,
-0.6141316891,
0.6892909408,
-0.7475192547,
-0.5760273933,
-0.8307654262,
-0.292680949,
-0.3576969504,
-0.1424091458,
0.3479579389,
-0.2672896087,
-0.3950795829,
0.26985237,
0.4712947607,
0.7010308504,
0.2274016142,
-0.2641336918,
-0.8550617099,
0.6758828163,
0.3709130585,
0.5918464661,
0.1034723222,
-0.4225627184,
0.0376493745,
0.1627030969,
-0.1915767342,
-0.9475875497,
0.2198348641,
0.174950093,
0.4830326736,
0.2738493681,
0.9967145324,
0.5132775307,
-0.2506645322,
0.5639759898,
-0.2307051569,
-0.764572978,
0.4088081717,
-0.5121750236,
0.3467564881,
0.3443667591,
0.9345574379,
-0.2608950734,
-0.1706496924,
-0.5065620542,
-0.4066208005,
0.9252283573,
-0.0665788949,
-0.1875929683,
-0.308172375,
0.272911489,
0.1865604967,
-0.1991115808,
-0.243611753,
-0.0850205794,
-0.1357977539,
-0.299885571,
0.2335145622,
-0.3833111525,
-0.3147602081,
-0.1105026752,
0.4055747688,
-0.0187399741,
0.5366783738,
0.6299164295,
-0.0420328937,
-0.2926523685,
0.1376186609,
0.6538710594,
0.3524123728,
-0.5936345458,
-0.0706193522,
-0.432115972,
-0.3172367811,
0.0165794119,
0.1910264343,
-0.3969293237,
0.021141002,
0.284301728,
0.3276983798,
-0.2217079848,
-0.6925560832,
0.4400416017,
-0.2796911597,
-0.3149822652,
-0.3083925545,
0.080910489,
-0.1970122606,
0.1481416821,
0.5321454406,
0.3540952802,
0.2418542653,
-0.5470116735,
0.2857757211,
0.5534918308,
-0.2848972976,
-0.1209857762,
0.6033656597,
0.5064690709,
-0.2909141183,
0.5624805093,
-0.0598341525,
-0.329393357,
0.6070333123,
0.6317715049,
0.8010296226,
-0.1873665601,
0.3328335583,
0.5423148274,
0.2123252004,
0.1660778672,
0.7804179788,
-0.1426147521,
-0.9074214101,
-0.1675137877,
-0.4208351374,
-0.3810628951,
-0.2812378705,
-0.8860685825,
0.14820759,
-0.3441328108,
0.0613882728,
0.2001339942,
-0.0224578585,
-0.451000154,
0.0488847271,
-0.3034452498,
1.1644370556,
-0.5895007253,
1.1331613064,
0.4255089164,
-0.6992550492,
-0.7245625854,
0.1070763618,
-0.3718212843,
-0.0556102842,
0.5572987795,
-0.0142751848,
-0.0930527747,
0.2732433677,
-0.3357236385,
-0.9468661547,
1.0445297956,
0.018074438,
0.1585074514,
0.1580686569,
0.3017766178,
0.2999377847,
-0.5140045285,
0.3420621157,
0.6167286038,
0.2898673713,
0.3768835366,
-0.5859461427,
0.2629978359,
-0.300224036,
-0.22694619,
0.6180872321,
-0.1163857579,
0.9850533605,
-0.3748792112,
-0.7883602977,
0.3780360818,
0.4229782522,
0.0441603921,
0.5086343288,
0.2123977542,
0.1301571131,
0.7454299927,
-0.2715921104,
1.3250721693,
-0.1794662774,
0.0380571894,
1.0563153028,
-0.5718072057,
1.0259917974,
0.4604002535,
0.3967515528,
0.2198500037,
0.4583312869,
0.373586297,
0.6417579651,
0.0256779063,
-0.5859874487,
-0.4325397909,
-0.5057316422,
-0.3266012371,
0.2560839355,
0.4171657562,
-0.0658913627,
-0.3695538938,
0.1837915033,
-0.4821606278,
0.269271642,
-0.2658833861,
0.746941328,
-0.2595811188,
-0.7480831742,
0.7839999795,
0.0680929646,
0.4005024135,
-0.5937665105,
-0.3926628232,
-0.4249969423,
0.1631230265,
-0.0342946798,
-0.7721713781,
0.4483890533,
-0.1998420656,
-0.5647701621,
0.0865505338,
0.7544891238,
-0.6307098866,
-0.1842712313,
0.0931551531,
0.4441771805,
-0.4699204862,
0.1477813125,
-0.2644454539,
0.1491784155,
-0.1929910034,
0.3291998506,
0.1825959235,
0.4474315047,
-0.2256060392,
0.6330987215,
0.6959869862,
-0.5108850002,
-0.0328959674,
-0.4138929546,
1.0503957272,
-0.8063552976,
-0.2870053947,
-0.2903830707,
0.602206111,
-0.1436243653,
-0.5167184472,
0.7704396844,
0.1534415334,
0.9604401588,
-0.3084178865,
0.5670168996,
-0.0295438636,
0.8030154109,
-0.4727436304,
0.7279590964,
-0.3819057941,
0.2514917552,
0.00465512,
-0.8124783635,
-0.5491065979,
0.3086261749,
-0.1828898489,
-0.3255837262,
0.7128312588,
0.8467009068,
0.0481269881,
0.4621757865,
0.2292530686,
-0.0387074016,
0.1731882393,
0.8298607469,
1.097461462,
-0.6059424877,
0.4721499681,
-0.0673925057,
-0.1630513966,
-0.2622354925,
-0.2571250498,
-1.1369156837,
-0.8121199608,
-0.2824459672,
-0.5349199772,
-0.1066694409,
0.838943243,
0.1921283007,
-0.6339786649,
0.0035472556,
0.2747462094,
0.5698661804,
-0.1538086534,
-0.2214154154,
0.2434362322,
0.0089880629,
-0.3287441134,
0.0187704246,
0.321074456,
0.1607292891,
-0.0921144858,
0.0005207172,
-0.3771549165,
0.8343868852,
0.4979363978,
0.5328733921,
-0.6765986681,
-0.607747972,
0.4151422679,
-0.2558968961,
-0.3020990789,
0.9288951755,
-0.9340132475,
0.3681339025,
0.7717065215,
0.700304687,
-0.1607445925,
0.2599095106,
0.6299717426,
-0.208874166,
-0.2200325131,
0.4635725319,
-0.0883375332,
-0.0669774488,
-0.2655684054,
0.3173435926,
0.1851277202,
-0.3740692139,
-1.0370638371,
0.3379298449,
-1.0648565292,
-0.3512527943,
0.9873126149,
-0.054004889,
-0.486112982,
-0.8421518803,
-0.2901183367,
-0.1916564852,
-0.1109666973,
0.4611631036,
0.3393869102,
-0.1735666394,
0.017806882,
-0.0267077554,
0.5960384011,
0.0951786414,
-0.6513217092,
0.0003782696,
0.6543398499,
0.1218545362,
0.0957218185,
0.7086656094,
-0.1709133834,
0.6971374154,
0.4059751332,
-0.064832747,
-0.1985853016,
-0.4952974021,
-0.4412229061,
0.5378714204,
0.1059193239,
-0.368973583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17040v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17040v1 | A Mechanism for Sample-Efficient In-Context Learning for Sparse Retrieval Tasks | 2023-05-26T15:49:43 | 2023-05-26T15:49:43 | Jacob Abernethy, Alekh Agarwal, Teodor V. Marinov, Manfred K. Warmuth | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We study the phenomenon of \textit{in-context learning} (ICL) exhibited by
large language models, where they can adapt to a new learning task, given a
handful of labeled examples, without any explicit parameter optimization. Our
goal is to explain how a pre-trained transformer model is able to perform ICL
under reasonable assumptions on the pre-training process and the downstream
tasks. We posit a mechanism whereby a transformer can achieve the following:
(a) receive an i.i.d. sequence of examples which have been converted into a
prompt using potentially-ambiguous delimiters, (b) correctly segment the prompt
into examples and labels, (c) infer from the data a \textit{sparse linear
regressor} hypothesis, and finally (d) apply this hypothesis on the given test
example and return a predicted label. We establish that this entire procedure
is implementable using the transformer mechanism, and we give sample complexity
guarantees for this learning framework. Our empirical findings validate the
challenge of segmentation, and we show a correspondence between our posited
mechanisms and observed attention maps for step (c). | [
-0.373108089,
-0.4976833165,
0.6823093891,
0.1184959635,
-0.2902913094,
-0.1623577476,
-0.2334306985,
-0.1638840437,
-0.1410172433,
0.2934012413,
-0.7601975203,
-0.0951237828,
-0.4741561413,
0.2604780793,
-0.7361803055,
1.2068805695,
-0.0228427052,
0.0728345066,
-0.3021979928,
-0.0453457721,
-0.4781423509,
-0.3372804821,
-0.4011757374,
-0.2707183063,
0.5312254429,
0.6165969372,
0.1524760127,
0.5944963098,
0.2549951971,
0.3595884442,
0.0483937301,
-0.1534317583,
-0.8162577152,
0.2214803398,
-0.0806857795,
-0.7519609928,
0.2805053592,
0.1518829912,
0.8201336265,
1.0106703043,
0.0596861169,
0.1580265611,
0.5882175565,
0.2738983631,
-0.6418855786,
-0.0678111389,
-0.9713717103,
-0.0348500647,
-0.0706487149,
-0.2306510359,
-0.7636551857,
-0.1528187394,
0.2888795733,
-0.5727599859,
0.6119100451,
0.0784248859,
0.8690164089,
0.5317410231,
-0.225704819,
-0.4196562469,
-0.7254221439,
0.936265111,
-0.1205463484,
0.4760169685,
0.3116502762,
0.432731241,
-0.0088677248,
-1.0708223581,
-0.5041800737,
-0.3409307003,
-0.4986030161,
-0.0655525252,
-0.0174999591,
0.0446391776,
0.6242064834,
0.2872430384,
-0.360465765,
-0.0769974813,
-0.3653512001,
-0.0259365533,
0.0669951588,
0.0205159318,
0.0881127641,
0.0773454756,
-0.4942571521,
-0.2739177346,
-0.6592530608,
0.0954935327,
0.0450401232,
0.4041546583,
-0.0765939057,
0.2852171063,
-0.0331543237,
0.6994839311,
0.4566833973,
-0.004214643,
0.1363035589,
-0.2392815202,
-0.0589067154,
0.0886565074,
0.3772767186,
-0.2471415848,
-0.0378541946,
-0.3351954222,
-0.6336092949,
-0.2603544891,
0.3884649575,
-0.8909134269,
-0.1946921349,
0.0180517379,
-0.3923187256,
0.132514894,
0.1277336925,
-0.602368772,
0.13088952,
-0.3573833108,
0.77101475,
-0.4857156277,
0.2370049059,
-0.1852719337,
-0.0556724183,
0.2647514641,
0.2336088866,
-0.8333292603,
0.6070051193,
0.5313976407,
0.8152829409,
-0.2833630443,
-0.2890268564,
-0.8845273256,
-0.210826695,
-0.059047021,
0.7902433872,
-0.5302599072,
-0.2179850787,
-0.0466299579,
0.0924980938,
-0.4200811684,
-0.6769365072,
0.4784657061,
-0.6085794568,
0.1711678505,
-0.2871418595,
-0.558417201,
-0.2019326538,
0.1197483465,
-0.7966650128,
0.9676995873,
0.3832651973,
-0.5356736779,
0.5453286171,
-0.6996449232,
-0.3362696469,
0.2647117674,
-0.0460572578,
-0.3413971364,
0.1376211196,
-0.0022738795,
0.4362836778,
-0.202178061,
0.1531620175,
-0.1903349459,
-0.8163462877,
0.4083853066,
-0.5498885512,
0.6762541533,
0.2457523495,
-0.4563010335,
0.1680697352,
-0.5561388135,
-0.251590997,
-0.0356960967,
-0.3781571984,
-0.4325608611,
0.0868065804,
0.2797364593,
0.2323168814,
0.0099545419,
-0.5379973054,
0.1832394153,
-0.4551985562,
0.3235634863,
0.5827067494,
0.0173395444,
0.6630213261,
-0.1535694599,
0.4043030441,
0.0047517833,
0.1876043081,
-0.5041493773,
0.1189382151,
-0.9034981728,
-0.4198880494,
0.4060242772,
0.3307685852,
-0.7050182819,
0.3536961973,
-0.3518742025,
-0.1606904566,
-0.5346977711,
0.0412631929,
0.3674054742,
0.7422938347,
0.5600333214,
0.0499539562,
-0.324908942,
-0.8634240627,
0.0221536849,
0.2540995181,
-0.2148520052,
0.3623793125,
0.5439343452,
-0.0314492583,
1.0157933235,
-0.5001899004,
-0.2496064007,
-0.393035531,
0.1824678779,
0.3355674446,
0.5548658967,
0.4817436337,
-1.202981472,
-0.5574886799,
-0.2498505414,
-0.3601180315,
-0.1158904433,
-0.2398038954,
0.0631435364,
-0.1238621995,
0.9767792225,
-0.3929481804,
0.3631396294,
0.0276847109,
0.0145750577,
0.139614284,
-0.2407835424,
-0.1208051443,
-0.9670804739,
-0.0351314172,
0.1153998971,
-0.153832078,
-0.7282888889,
0.0765858144,
0.3202552199,
0.0021081038,
-0.4549492896,
0.4502710104,
-0.3937316835,
0.0764504522,
-0.3419760764,
0.0515676737,
-0.2506310642,
0.5945214033,
-0.1219055653,
0.823617816,
0.4467039704,
-0.6939985752,
-0.3018009067,
0.1808279455,
-0.4599209726,
0.4722186327,
-0.6749230623,
0.045523636,
-0.5236374736,
0.2674618065,
-1.3375099897,
-0.1368276179,
0.2130315602,
-0.0894508585,
0.5113083124,
-0.1648671925,
-0.4411450326,
-0.2360883057,
0.0436864756,
0.6924711466,
0.5496860147,
-0.9366301894,
0.5590312481,
0.1427997053,
0.1739245951,
-0.5622763038,
-0.2915204465,
-0.3440136909,
-0.4296337366,
-0.0534035787,
0.5001751781,
-0.3097885847,
-0.0834406614,
0.0392376147,
-0.0595427454,
-0.229242608,
0.3284151554,
0.1203928515,
0.1602206081,
-0.1370517313,
0.2137465179,
0.0970391557,
-0.0629403591,
0.0051186257,
-0.389118284,
0.5043919086,
0.0892218649,
-0.4772515297,
-0.1732009053,
0.3555117846,
0.4025353193,
-0.1325073391,
0.4899261594,
0.415540725,
-0.3796612322,
-0.630726397,
-0.4825412035,
-0.5710992217,
-0.4830256104,
0.4323130846,
-0.5221936703,
-0.9199696183,
0.3695769012,
-0.2404301465,
-0.1502293348,
0.2307791114,
0.2894902825,
-0.0304775368,
1.0131140947,
0.7776972651,
-0.0257212371,
0.5442736149,
-0.3426026106,
0.3301096857,
-0.7193222642,
-0.0663175732,
-0.7419353127,
-0.4919076562,
-0.365557611,
-0.3541039526,
0.6499657631,
0.1759906858,
-0.1188616902,
0.267206043,
-0.3974752724,
0.6171942353,
0.6812173724,
0.2062142938,
-0.0274168141,
-0.0901249945,
-0.3108412623,
0.0189555641,
-0.864859581,
-0.1029561311,
0.7159543037,
0.0107258027,
0.7967636585,
-0.2232545614,
0.6118628383,
0.0457516871,
0.6948207617,
-0.9081429839,
0.4982413352,
-0.1091221124,
-0.4065286815,
-0.390699774,
-0.1802171618,
-1.0581127405,
0.3848642409,
-0.1351136118,
-0.8090754151,
0.3701504767,
0.1153014451,
-0.2500178814,
-0.0152251553,
-0.6416247487,
0.8626958132,
0.0077427863,
-0.3299431503,
-0.1250392795,
-0.8196161389,
0.2131950855,
-0.3666979074,
-0.0681631491,
0.2394094914,
0.0245705638,
0.4348488748,
-0.2936004996,
0.8683614731,
-0.3764854968,
0.2776345313,
0.1584574729,
-0.0414332449,
0.4364790022,
-0.1616616845,
0.0628843904,
-0.2629355192,
-0.1886751354,
-0.3166342974,
-0.8551757932,
0.3917683065,
-0.6096174121,
-0.5646591783,
-0.2576627135,
-0.8206039071,
-0.089268662,
0.0668635443,
0.5407461524,
0.5643084049,
-0.02782798,
0.5486472845,
0.8529363275,
0.0635767132,
0.6307629347,
0.4608923197,
0.2423037142,
0.0519697256,
0.7514588833,
0.2122017145,
0.2281432152,
0.868119359,
0.1015969813,
-0.5192698836,
-0.5764097571,
-0.2686497867,
0.2284886986,
-0.8664526939,
-0.2148685008,
-0.6493605971,
-0.2818919122,
-0.0101450495,
-0.2335063964,
-0.0699536875,
0.0737714246,
-0.3393315375,
-0.0510825254,
-0.0455665961,
0.6677145362,
0.2072716653,
0.3485058248,
-0.6088197827,
0.1059792414,
0.4092593789,
0.1324098557,
0.1693751663,
-0.6766424179,
-0.3714751303,
-0.1065241396,
-0.1452370435,
-0.6921480894,
0.2938583195,
0.2176837176,
0.7333780527,
0.3626773059,
0.1358725876,
0.7291517258,
-0.744384408,
0.572488308,
-0.2728642523,
-1.078589797,
0.4021748006,
0.0351547301,
0.2271382511,
0.7076612711,
0.7779352069,
-0.3139235973,
-0.3440634906,
-0.4767128527,
-0.8207438588,
0.7814164758,
-0.0989915282,
0.1762521118,
-0.1723383665,
0.5337849259,
0.213321805,
-0.0224109553,
-0.8689056635,
-0.113647677,
-0.1066593826,
-0.3916807473,
-0.1621299088,
-0.3813569248,
-0.0354785323,
-0.0910773352,
0.561547637,
-0.5166903138,
0.000090353,
0.4138819575,
-0.5659697056,
0.0345403291,
0.2095938474,
0.5935562849,
0.5796966553,
-0.097380653,
0.2212990671,
0.2035432607,
-0.384878844,
0.2661798,
0.323551625,
-0.5743341446,
-0.1436176449,
0.2594358921,
0.8249357939,
0.6348176599,
-0.7203278542,
0.7284296751,
-0.2078713328,
-0.2388540357,
-0.2058882117,
-0.0084570004,
-0.4206435978,
0.3372072875,
0.7962422371,
0.0288373251,
0.5160202384,
-0.1027002037,
0.5156248808,
0.5708245635,
-0.7924144268,
-0.3795443177,
0.800483644,
-0.2926194966,
-0.2786086202,
0.7460967302,
-0.3431097269,
-0.3424539268,
0.3614730537,
0.9219512939,
0.8812283278,
-0.3179433644,
0.0984380096,
0.4076783657,
0.1662661135,
-0.1976250261,
-0.1369732916,
-0.503842175,
-0.6278004646,
-0.5707994103,
-0.6541577578,
-0.0866616592,
0.2176750749,
-0.7358165383,
0.2429169565,
-0.0439370796,
0.3356519938,
-0.1210689843,
-0.4238834977,
-0.7069627047,
0.1054680422,
0.0221548881,
1.0230019093,
-0.896097064,
0.9197357297,
0.432438612,
-0.2966567576,
-0.8632972836,
0.4452103674,
-0.408510834,
-0.6729955077,
1.0754703283,
0.3638542593,
-0.1021981537,
0.0447142683,
-0.7345820069,
-1.0351848602,
0.8773134947,
0.469404608,
-0.4271992445,
-0.0352452993,
-0.010652774,
0.3406495452,
-0.346992135,
0.3094961047,
0.40688923,
0.2094297856,
0.1557646543,
-0.6097880006,
0.19715029,
-0.1841465384,
0.0945637748,
0.1930575222,
-0.4274436831,
1.0484498739,
-0.1356599927,
-0.3717412055,
0.1764854193,
0.7668963671,
0.1373864412,
0.1138339415,
1.0545269251,
0.3743932545,
0.6310872436,
-0.0880799517,
1.1429238319,
-0.3074720502,
0.3972500861,
1.0151542425,
-0.2466898561,
0.6610378623,
0.6321958303,
-0.0427500084,
0.431396842,
0.4933151901,
0.0213620681,
0.7943783998,
0.2879159153,
-0.3668179512,
-0.2674468458,
-0.281832099,
0.1512542218,
0.5128076077,
0.4399293065,
-0.2801774144,
-0.4183853269,
0.3406536579,
-0.2840247154,
0.1144829541,
-0.3726256788,
0.8185147643,
-0.0692783073,
-0.9638204575,
0.6375208497,
-0.3476401865,
0.5062827468,
-0.6679259539,
-0.3984899223,
-0.0891847387,
0.1762657762,
0.1610390693,
-0.4418563843,
0.1877517998,
-0.3986282349,
-0.3558919728,
-0.3254225552,
0.6736122966,
-0.6154139638,
-0.3319427669,
0.1681429744,
0.3709543943,
0.1613568068,
-0.0689443797,
-0.4689235985,
-0.0735128969,
-0.0815991387,
-0.0586166084,
0.5187728405,
0.4982331395,
-0.1077411175,
0.4569404423,
0.34461689,
-0.2339838892,
0.1145452186,
0.0900555998,
0.8557514548,
-0.2713638842,
-0.5685587525,
-0.748714149,
0.4987702668,
0.0020135567,
-0.0825970396,
0.6483083367,
0.7151033878,
1.1922956705,
-0.2067661434,
0.6454899907,
0.0789332911,
0.6210099459,
-0.5293287635,
0.4418202639,
-0.6073858738,
0.0618564039,
-0.1015838012,
-0.8978593349,
-0.2751578093,
0.6354566813,
-0.2392451167,
-0.0186547879,
0.8368199468,
0.8853731155,
-0.4079163074,
-0.106552884,
0.3175117671,
0.1448468268,
0.1023791954,
0.5436444283,
0.760992527,
-0.3696297109,
0.6849845052,
-0.3842852712,
-0.2053266019,
-0.1708268076,
-0.6040842533,
-0.8484674096,
-1.1645834446,
0.0334026664,
-0.245406419,
-0.2175732106,
0.9956852794,
0.9926332831,
-0.6876865029,
-0.2988339663,
-0.0744081289,
0.2026815116,
-0.3136345148,
-0.2256018072,
0.3129257858,
-0.8936335444,
-1.0287448168,
0.4950387478,
0.1745400876,
-0.0153871775,
-0.0287162419,
0.1366186589,
0.0467687771,
-0.2726547122,
0.5728847384,
0.1889337003,
-0.6259232163,
-0.4494389594,
0.1001219302,
0.0246037338,
0.2075411975,
1.1985404491,
-0.9662179351,
0.2665965855,
0.2831311524,
0.9796499014,
0.6375590563,
-0.0872887373,
0.3302104473,
-0.8629969358,
0.2061584294,
0.2864043713,
0.5105950236,
0.2520721555,
-0.4304452538,
0.3391923904,
0.2474536449,
-0.5091750622,
-0.8732910752,
0.2241843641,
-0.8882645965,
-0.3513945937,
0.8876953125,
-0.0561963096,
-0.4467364252,
-0.1934679002,
-0.1272704154,
0.2022963911,
-0.1505312622,
0.7667931914,
0.386397332,
0.001074301,
-0.2430061251,
-0.3761724532,
0.562250495,
0.3179813027,
-0.5582104325,
-0.1222464964,
0.3044133782,
0.3171216547,
0.2596068084,
0.6020687222,
0.1434029341,
0.2063626647,
-0.1756937802,
-0.1847332269,
0.339885056,
-0.4673967659,
-0.4914488792,
0.5094035864,
-0.0723960847,
-0.1560030282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17026v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17026v3 | How Powerful are Decoder-Only Transformer Neural Models? | 2023-05-26T15:35:43 | 2024-02-02T18:04:58 | Jesse Roberts | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this article we prove that the general transformer neural model
undergirding modern large language models (LLMs) is Turing complete under
reasonable assumptions. This is the first work to directly address the Turing
completeness of the underlying technology employed in GPT-x as past work has
focused on the more expressive, full auto-encoder transformer architecture.
From this theoretical analysis, we show that the sparsity/compressibility of
the word embedding is an important consideration for Turing completeness to
hold. We also show that Transformers are are a variant of B machines studied by
Hao Wang. | [
-0.2756176591,
-0.6090680957,
0.7637857199,
-0.1021000668,
-0.1247002706,
-0.0206312798,
-0.2458486557,
-0.4313957095,
0.3183246851,
0.47270751,
-0.3156906664,
0.0816418603,
-1.0728974342,
0.1918736547,
-0.9750572443,
0.6804966331,
-0.0549635552,
0.0540950745,
-0.0553907454,
0.1962466389,
-0.24098894,
-0.447581619,
-0.5085183382,
-0.7146044374,
0.2551025152,
-0.1886906624,
1.0637352467,
0.690389812,
0.4371502995,
0.3916331232,
-0.2808412015,
-0.3598665297,
-0.320789516,
0.274512589,
-0.1162808388,
-0.643674016,
-0.4937599897,
-0.2509521842,
0.6325371265,
0.7309608459,
0.0950691178,
-0.2335765958,
0.1006923616,
0.2332224101,
-0.1375165433,
0.135313645,
-0.697601974,
0.3024755418,
0.1024352536,
0.0848718882,
-0.6242055297,
-0.2160415202,
0.115761213,
-0.3459001184,
0.4971800447,
0.0640185922,
0.8686422706,
0.3931282163,
-0.642880857,
-0.1937466711,
-1.0377895832,
0.6555161476,
-0.5286501646,
0.5991919041,
0.0946949273,
0.3168886602,
0.0560721196,
-0.9862368107,
-0.5446966887,
-0.4892053306,
-0.3826707304,
0.1033032611,
-0.5855039954,
0.4374808371,
0.5242566466,
0.864518106,
-0.6544322968,
-0.0524984039,
-0.3297706246,
-0.029707497,
0.0555147901,
0.0443771407,
0.457082957,
-0.232744202,
-0.2682746649,
0.1317280084,
-0.679741323,
-0.2821200788,
0.110975042,
-0.2564174831,
-0.0247780588,
0.8516808152,
0.2264471948,
0.6220730543,
-0.0577555783,
0.2475866675,
-0.0862017572,
-0.3343277276,
-0.5401084423,
-0.2700012028,
0.9062308669,
-0.285802573,
0.5365447998,
-0.9236553311,
-0.2979928553,
0.1286452115,
0.6823319793,
-0.6104043722,
-0.0943486318,
0.1483029425,
-0.3749043345,
-0.0274641402,
0.1654321849,
-0.2658461034,
-0.1875679344,
-0.3950040042,
0.6374945045,
-0.2051211447,
-0.5996562839,
0.3424390554,
-0.1754908711,
0.5277513266,
-0.0231697597,
-1.0624465942,
0.5168505907,
0.8160028458,
0.9120079279,
0.0311807524,
-0.2285488248,
-0.0163162723,
-0.0079366695,
-0.335254997,
0.6353285313,
-0.399458617,
-0.4899177849,
-0.006996111,
0.3295170069,
-0.2974716723,
-0.3885500133,
0.7444627285,
-0.7460637689,
-0.1048606113,
-0.184200719,
-0.7236028314,
-0.2602762878,
0.1544067413,
-0.8746125102,
0.5555554032,
0.3378014565,
-0.4923118353,
0.2141368091,
-0.6178948879,
-0.5741622448,
0.0322421901,
-0.0961452201,
-0.3895890117,
0.546092093,
-0.0622799546,
0.3772286773,
-0.2547073364,
0.4036097229,
-0.0190620441,
-0.6462066174,
0.6121812463,
-0.6879003644,
0.5526359081,
-0.0632647797,
-0.711879909,
0.194960013,
-0.4835729897,
-0.1118601114,
0.2690498829,
-0.1590221822,
0.2168295532,
-0.0698586777,
-0.1204311624,
0.1909654438,
0.069309637,
-0.7309503555,
0.2627379596,
-0.3537418842,
0.7414556146,
0.6058657765,
-0.4979539514,
0.6326814294,
-0.3225827217,
0.6058626175,
-0.3459098637,
0.0642605349,
-0.2974734306,
-0.5844342709,
-1.121419549,
-0.479465723,
0.4651920795,
0.6368819475,
-0.4253308475,
0.7025643587,
-0.5173770189,
-0.3244464397,
-0.597466886,
-0.1584842354,
0.182995826,
0.1358097196,
0.347491622,
0.1508966833,
-0.7343971729,
-0.9840472341,
0.0680522099,
0.2895831764,
-0.3639541864,
0.0822754875,
0.519415319,
-0.425137043,
0.6376860738,
-0.3248013258,
0.0553570762,
-0.5237339139,
-0.246851638,
0.3513789475,
0.2605845034,
0.1653273255,
-0.6140464544,
-0.2837982774,
-0.0362461619,
-1.0511257648,
0.1966985464,
0.0631896481,
0.2219310999,
0.0513253435,
0.3189129233,
-1.3121619225,
0.6068376303,
0.5277011991,
-0.0427590385,
0.0877506956,
-0.5288519263,
0.0315835103,
-0.877229929,
0.059681844,
-0.0776313022,
-0.4526830018,
-0.8050882816,
0.0702985227,
0.0634319931,
-0.3717752695,
-0.1932987273,
0.4452504814,
-0.4493239224,
-0.1188008562,
-0.5914696455,
-0.030520631,
-0.1433228403,
0.4104401171,
0.2430312932,
0.6250849366,
0.7527467012,
-0.535531044,
0.2521953583,
0.3224638104,
-0.2586555183,
0.1521613896,
-1.265699029,
0.086945653,
-0.1731261313,
0.1893163174,
-1.1043930054,
-0.161096096,
0.0543974563,
-0.3544741869,
0.4942038655,
-0.1546984911,
-0.3584828079,
-0.5310171247,
0.0420159735,
0.2352472991,
0.9833683372,
-0.5311244726,
0.6892949343,
0.2732406557,
0.030499747,
-0.308675319,
-0.9716100693,
0.2160956562,
0.3011062443,
-0.8749262094,
0.5421723723,
0.046623379,
-0.0360807665,
0.0043754769,
0.0674637407,
-0.0551149584,
-0.0206590518,
0.3175989687,
0.1705328822,
-0.3697718978,
-0.1358293146,
-0.0949384943,
-0.4095077217,
0.1021251604,
-0.0955011249,
0.7964619994,
-0.0758250281,
-0.4431226552,
-0.4824160039,
0.4862372875,
0.6702567339,
0.1519615352,
0.5056795478,
0.4987453818,
-0.3481417298,
0.074353002,
-0.5110964179,
-0.1469739527,
-0.5000805855,
0.4615691602,
-0.3618282974,
-1.0034511089,
0.4418270588,
0.2591876984,
-0.1896764338,
0.5301718712,
0.4617808461,
0.2399293631,
1.2389304638,
0.8547465205,
-0.0657336265,
0.1537653357,
-0.4665397406,
0.413769275,
-0.8044521213,
-0.1179271638,
-0.5133978724,
-0.2212574184,
-0.6665687561,
-0.0836066008,
0.001393132,
-0.2095999718,
-0.4822126925,
0.4358269572,
-0.7132658362,
0.6498994827,
0.652287662,
-0.0349906608,
0.2305929661,
-0.0853976905,
0.2193685174,
0.2560640872,
-0.4742811322,
-0.46912992,
0.8924945593,
0.5047629476,
0.7605845928,
0.0091471355,
0.4117162228,
0.0799174458,
0.1446166784,
-1.0984659195,
0.3837666214,
-0.2041372061,
-0.7299492359,
-0.0411007293,
-0.2627954781,
-1.1888920069,
0.2051723003,
-0.1062284261,
-0.5010975599,
-0.2050275207,
-0.244588539,
-0.2103564292,
0.622438848,
-0.5099791288,
0.6881406307,
-0.0383177027,
0.171186924,
0.0440303832,
-0.4973939359,
0.5541911721,
0.0807355046,
-0.0381608121,
0.375592351,
-0.1271951497,
0.4776151478,
-0.4454151988,
0.6718472838,
-0.069857575,
-0.055635307,
0.1518000215,
0.0103273029,
0.3814561963,
-0.2280117273,
0.1280355453,
0.2623957098,
-0.3379609883,
-0.330218643,
-0.619278729,
0.5424953699,
-0.911808908,
-0.802714169,
-0.3182430267,
-0.4558039606,
0.0447873436,
0.1462023109,
0.6101605892,
0.3785191178,
-0.0882988423,
0.2884724438,
0.9617904425,
0.0430527553,
0.524100244,
0.03411844,
-0.2216998935,
-0.558852911,
0.5925216079,
0.264454037,
0.1258250475,
0.3502158225,
0.0158630535,
-0.3051750958,
-0.5463225245,
-0.5940454006,
0.3561805785,
-0.7506182194,
-0.1067565084,
-0.7984166145,
-0.7754984498,
-0.2332624197,
-0.2749411464,
-0.2954566479,
-0.3742733002,
-0.0628538132,
-0.2814474404,
0.0205744337,
1.5041730404,
0.1569219679,
0.5995588899,
-0.8773291707,
0.663276732,
0.5360367894,
0.3866291046,
0.1873120368,
-0.5415490866,
-0.2457816601,
0.0905999094,
-0.4725200236,
-0.7166742682,
0.2726056874,
-0.0824580789,
0.7583882809,
0.0966156945,
-0.4045037329,
0.0723797977,
-0.599367559,
0.9678598046,
0.2301839888,
-1.0897084475,
0.1258998662,
-0.2366583794,
0.3134683371,
-0.1721875072,
0.478490144,
-0.3055140078,
-0.2928433418,
-0.825530231,
-0.7342551351,
0.4132011533,
0.1971048862,
0.5071824789,
-0.1444952935,
0.3457130194,
0.2294261307,
0.0019466676,
-0.9801318645,
-0.3698073924,
-0.418219775,
-0.1889101416,
-0.0372236185,
-0.616212666,
0.1463999599,
-0.1407743543,
0.6245079637,
0.2285164893,
0.6697349548,
0.1364073455,
-0.2848305702,
-0.0043957708,
0.400539726,
0.556712985,
0.5370170474,
-0.0019496825,
0.1412137747,
0.0092736352,
-0.5012780428,
0.5129065514,
-0.0146931009,
-0.2958919704,
0.1876840591,
0.3587045074,
0.9942069054,
0.3859018981,
-0.1415563822,
0.7116820812,
-0.2411476225,
-0.4444874823,
-0.2551336586,
0.1003672108,
0.1073273867,
0.2805471718,
0.4227285087,
0.2528083324,
0.0154882474,
-0.2544815838,
0.3189321756,
0.5782143474,
-0.4451280236,
-0.5750977993,
0.7062332034,
-0.0301216729,
-0.3657672703,
0.723354876,
-0.0598226041,
-0.7035526037,
0.5308035612,
0.9175097942,
1.2027618885,
-0.1406013519,
-0.0632521063,
0.2027677149,
0.4419441521,
-0.4039105177,
0.0759115294,
-0.0290259141,
-0.5996046066,
-0.872918129,
-0.4517248571,
-0.604352355,
0.0736878738,
-0.5717235804,
0.2091173381,
-0.266291678,
-0.2979421616,
-0.1676029712,
-0.2556402087,
-0.5423296094,
0.2985350192,
0.2459436059,
0.8938018084,
-0.5958282948,
0.992235899,
0.2850437164,
-0.3792451024,
-0.589697957,
-0.10385371,
-0.6067362428,
-0.868932724,
0.6410553455,
0.1974616796,
-0.1147651523,
0.0278621539,
-0.3804708719,
-0.89348948,
0.9564502239,
0.7051233649,
-0.4646888077,
-0.304535538,
0.4162979424,
0.4010836184,
-0.010623645,
0.5664600134,
0.5545703769,
0.5976638198,
0.1979304403,
-0.9644312263,
0.1526153088,
-0.1673201174,
0.0973099172,
0.4352814257,
-0.3825433254,
0.9049469829,
-0.0443820208,
-0.1732058972,
0.316190213,
0.7073389292,
-0.3096517622,
-0.2446608841,
0.1107722521,
0.807035625,
0.6126064062,
-0.3007445335,
1.3423221111,
-0.3498448431,
0.3837247193,
0.6168204546,
0.0100847967,
0.5541529655,
0.0304168873,
-0.3142844141,
0.1688849777,
0.2316382676,
-0.1530741006,
0.3396102488,
0.2971197069,
-0.2075863481,
-0.3336336315,
0.1379211247,
-0.527603209,
0.3982334435,
0.1378439963,
-0.5968513489,
-0.0435208753,
0.0415796265,
0.1110681593,
-0.2527413964,
-0.4436021447,
0.7574681044,
0.2738522589,
-0.5730432868,
0.8182920218,
-0.2568491697,
1.0249820948,
-0.7756573558,
0.2500590086,
-0.0914478898,
0.2161618471,
-0.1884603947,
-0.8379276395,
0.7556465864,
-0.2049043775,
-0.4595937133,
-0.0973346382,
0.9434546828,
-0.3195495605,
-0.4555693567,
0.4497534633,
0.5329989195,
0.0926997289,
-0.2741171718,
-0.2177260071,
0.0738260448,
-0.0557580777,
-0.4490834475,
0.2640964687,
0.1603047252,
0.4829616547,
0.5925741196,
0.2506850064,
0.1541761905,
0.1755089015,
-0.1286856085,
0.7450454235,
-0.8745162487,
0.1418820918,
-1.1739648581,
0.5414800644,
0.1482067406,
0.1601896435,
0.6630458832,
0.5636532307,
0.5851126313,
-0.3022939563,
1.127483964,
0.1551748514,
0.2466060221,
-0.513735652,
0.7570400834,
-0.3161586523,
-0.1237045154,
0.1132417992,
-1.0766667128,
-0.4746918082,
0.59182024,
-0.2353278548,
0.2000958771,
0.8217641711,
0.6451023221,
-0.2313673198,
0.3367618918,
0.8929226398,
0.1658993959,
0.3252193034,
0.5744532347,
0.9254832268,
-0.8727370501,
0.696367979,
-0.0358987562,
-0.1685569882,
0.3196590841,
-0.7984986901,
-0.8114444613,
-0.4073801637,
-0.1895403713,
-0.3089194,
-0.2051686794,
0.6015173197,
0.680049181,
-0.6155673265,
-0.19897452,
-0.3189892471,
0.1696965843,
0.0515101627,
-0.1758848429,
0.2904833555,
-0.5539003015,
-0.7426074743,
0.3232850134,
0.2694645524,
0.3709701896,
-0.3098645806,
-0.0100104446,
0.375964582,
0.320500493,
0.5868877172,
0.0283285659,
-0.6175892949,
-0.2911055684,
0.4011563659,
-0.0717391297,
0.3613276482,
0.9229714274,
-0.7955087423,
-0.0312727205,
0.514580071,
0.6997007132,
0.47874704,
-0.4095975161,
0.613358736,
-0.2648631632,
-0.0402279198,
0.1232860237,
0.9262168407,
0.3980252743,
-0.2337537259,
0.4093200266,
0.0872278288,
-0.9339062572,
-0.4713642895,
0.2819624245,
-1.0327349901,
-0.1164191514,
1.3125023842,
-0.2394873053,
-0.4514772296,
-0.1022215858,
-0.3240569234,
0.4056167305,
-0.002044433,
0.4093788564,
0.569344461,
0.080097802,
-0.2396923006,
-0.4021532536,
0.2472113669,
0.1629675925,
-0.4086627662,
0.1072533429,
0.0265142713,
0.2383799404,
0.2915408909,
0.4322513044,
-0.0820681155,
0.0610524602,
0.2252431661,
0.0311781168,
-0.1576783657,
-0.2268812358,
-0.4653262198,
0.2801819444,
0.2102320343,
-0.0078112273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17020v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17020v3 | Diable: Efficient Dialogue State Tracking as Operations on Tables | 2023-05-26T15:26:12 | 2023-11-01T20:36:38 | Pietro Lesci, Yoshinari Fujinuma, Momchil Hardalov, Chao Shang, Yassine Benajiba, Lluis Marquez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Sequence-to-sequence state-of-the-art systems for dialogue state tracking
(DST) use the full dialogue history as input, represent the current state as a
list with all the slots, and generate the entire state from scratch at each
dialogue turn. This approach is inefficient, especially when the number of
slots is large and the conversation is long. We propose Diable, a new task
formalisation that simplifies the design and implementation of efficient DST
systems and allows one to easily plug and play large language models. We
represent the dialogue state as a table and formalise DST as a table
manipulation task. At each turn, the system updates the previous state by
generating table operations based on the dialogue context. Extensive
experimentation on the MultiWoz datasets demonstrates that Diable (i)
outperforms strong efficient DST baselines, (ii) is 2.4x more time efficient
than current state-of-the-art methods while retaining competitive Joint Goal
Accuracy, and (iii) is robust to noisy data annotations due to the table
operations approach. | [
-0.1931531131,
-0.669495523,
0.7357807159,
0.1202052236,
-0.4550374746,
0.1727110744,
-0.0315336324,
-0.1478749812,
0.3865160346,
0.6069044471,
-0.7328564525,
-0.5197946429,
-0.5063342452,
0.0323490426,
-0.6600584388,
1.1578807831,
0.0899344832,
-0.2017629296,
0.0989744142,
0.0354815573,
-0.3436062634,
-0.5161780715,
-0.3839408755,
-0.1109127104,
0.271566242,
0.3334068358,
0.5272228718,
0.3810631633,
0.6429826021,
0.3825702369,
0.0470958427,
0.2157554328,
-0.5308899879,
0.5970403552,
0.086752452,
-0.4217500985,
-0.8425258994,
-0.3551522791,
0.4801447988,
0.5842810869,
-0.5120439529,
0.1443481147,
0.0532069728,
0.6384081841,
-0.5912345052,
0.6972311735,
-0.4713907242,
-0.1803000569,
-0.3775088787,
-0.0825572759,
-0.3121668696,
-0.5454915762,
0.2381348163,
-0.5522504449,
-0.1815682203,
-0.2555190325,
0.2795614004,
0.4727312028,
-0.4205916524,
-0.3724783063,
-1.1494637728,
0.5475719571,
-0.8685405254,
0.5998097658,
0.0616904497,
0.3346598744,
-0.3317041397,
-0.8858119249,
-0.7501696944,
-0.2746851444,
-0.1081400216,
0.1969335824,
-0.1903356016,
0.2697568536,
0.5873809457,
0.2154873312,
-0.3484688699,
-0.3267062008,
0.0027062853,
-0.1150303036,
0.4078544676,
0.511482954,
0.1630980223,
-0.0123056658,
-0.3737247884,
0.2348265201,
-0.5024366379,
-0.1696748286,
0.0473539196,
0.4064022601,
-0.1365544498,
0.5100480914,
-0.5290666223,
1.0908336639,
-0.1082602292,
-0.3376971185,
-0.2554475069,
-0.6127246022,
-0.0881197006,
0.0718721822,
0.8457759619,
0.3958322108,
-0.1680653095,
-0.1693433225,
-0.3020077646,
0.2925195098,
0.2357177883,
-0.7127940655,
-0.4139658213,
-0.022850737,
0.1281956285,
-0.0464499705,
-0.1741844714,
-0.9136010408,
-0.1745700687,
-0.2990183532,
0.405560106,
-0.3293839991,
-0.0240680724,
0.1705174446,
0.3105886877,
0.0278407987,
0.7923429012,
-0.9731155634,
0.5342288017,
0.7730854154,
0.9410432577,
-0.0210039038,
0.2610433698,
-0.4644308984,
0.319329232,
-0.560731411,
0.7139906883,
-0.3925016522,
-0.3919571936,
-0.2826467454,
-0.2127546519,
-0.1020672917,
-0.1476080716,
0.4855193496,
-0.5370123982,
0.2699787021,
-0.2871281505,
-0.4911280274,
-0.002817516,
0.2293892205,
-0.7446955442,
0.7948178649,
0.1337676346,
-0.5381932855,
0.499078393,
-0.874511838,
-0.4471730292,
0.0391173176,
-0.1906793118,
-0.4083803892,
-0.0906469673,
0.1799115688,
0.082722865,
-0.2032263875,
0.2666537762,
-0.0335116759,
-0.5622805953,
0.1016025096,
-0.3896587491,
0.4815461636,
0.2780521512,
-0.374833256,
-0.1114304438,
-0.7534125447,
-0.1384039521,
-0.1518834382,
-0.5979129672,
-0.2618019581,
0.309869647,
-0.2673158944,
0.0767234862,
0.1361933947,
-0.7953901291,
0.5378593802,
-0.3206371665,
0.6037735939,
0.3265624046,
0.1277372986,
0.3619346023,
-0.1007354707,
0.3635366857,
-0.0308312569,
0.0044265264,
-0.311571449,
-0.2731171846,
-0.6493698955,
-0.4527541101,
0.3813447058,
0.6913009286,
-0.6753884554,
0.4700881243,
-0.2713927627,
-0.3270207644,
-0.3174315393,
-0.3095852435,
0.307313472,
0.4584121704,
0.2107286602,
-0.3926717043,
-0.4623835087,
-0.729411304,
0.0238322429,
-0.2177236378,
0.1204638779,
-0.0211145338,
0.3006277382,
0.1830207855,
1.0469613075,
-0.7077252269,
-0.2300918698,
-0.3836619258,
0.1345527023,
0.2124183774,
0.4304968715,
0.1338909417,
-0.5447648168,
-0.6287374496,
-0.1514296383,
-0.6274223924,
-0.0577032529,
-0.235235095,
-0.1346450746,
0.3739332259,
0.3738668859,
-0.7885035872,
0.7302806377,
0.2141792029,
-0.1508886814,
0.282137692,
0.1857197136,
0.5244212747,
-1.2260826826,
0.0517539419,
-0.4042092264,
-0.4498636723,
-0.9233959913,
-0.4762860835,
0.051008191,
-0.229522109,
-0.3850819767,
0.0461582094,
-0.411298722,
-0.1790368259,
-0.0988922268,
0.3118899763,
0.028214423,
0.6256154776,
-0.0649775639,
0.8633872867,
0.324667275,
-0.6834164262,
0.6526443362,
0.7001734376,
-0.6708824039,
0.8192947507,
-0.345190227,
0.2948542535,
0.0260316618,
0.6116811037,
-1.1377586126,
0.1971694231,
0.3333819807,
-0.2949953377,
0.3962861598,
-0.4126124084,
-0.276835084,
-0.2560876906,
-0.0499351323,
0.1097286642,
0.3162426353,
-0.259172678,
0.2975051105,
0.5579319596,
-0.179742977,
-0.6443600655,
-0.4345689714,
0.4031820297,
-0.3061561286,
-0.3909499347,
0.4238915443,
0.2541129589,
-0.2555933595,
-0.2536736429,
-0.6889031529,
0.0100604454,
0.0935972854,
-0.2123750299,
0.217118755,
0.1215287894,
-0.1484317929,
-0.2053909898,
-0.3399171531,
-0.1541772634,
-0.3935936391,
0.7504521012,
0.1266289502,
-0.3832885921,
-0.9957761168,
0.4570530355,
0.8166022897,
-0.2029431909,
0.3180975914,
0.3504302204,
-0.3982995749,
-0.13590312,
-0.3455934823,
-0.3407347798,
-0.4455842674,
0.4664470851,
-0.6726683378,
-0.5314247012,
0.4149628282,
-0.1388880759,
0.7031149864,
0.1524877697,
0.3854809999,
-0.3622788489,
1.2155692577,
0.6215363741,
0.0300247949,
0.6067312956,
-0.1656470597,
0.5372769833,
-0.8511397243,
-0.202701062,
-0.6623264551,
-0.341099143,
-0.4406274855,
-0.3669164181,
0.6331721544,
0.0375300124,
-0.0482354909,
0.7500111461,
-0.2681354582,
0.0760706142,
0.6196008921,
0.0409490131,
0.6417981982,
-0.2878766656,
0.1193133369,
-0.0834784955,
-0.6042287946,
-0.5095178485,
0.9962264895,
-0.1727253199,
1.3855273724,
0.3674354553,
0.98214221,
0.4159576297,
-0.1986288577,
-0.7205837369,
0.8047632575,
-0.1788821518,
-0.3560373783,
-0.5317118764,
-0.4611159861,
-0.8439660668,
0.110651046,
-0.0588049777,
-1.048677206,
-0.1472280771,
0.2536967993,
-0.6411710978,
0.3640395403,
-0.5401240587,
0.730525732,
0.050356131,
-0.3846075237,
-0.3568826318,
-0.6098951101,
0.3775278926,
-0.0712016672,
-0.2160117775,
-0.392052263,
0.1118316054,
0.8912792802,
-0.583304882,
0.8425250649,
-0.3044103384,
-0.2234730273,
0.3708815873,
0.4744104147,
0.7662509084,
0.141761139,
0.1031786799,
-0.1647506952,
0.4305786788,
-0.0430294126,
-0.7878328562,
0.5400063396,
-0.1629897058,
-0.5318390131,
-0.5384702682,
-0.6213033199,
-0.2864637375,
0.0064214771,
-0.1511715204,
0.9028860331,
-0.3654307723,
-0.1292982996,
0.480368197,
-0.1410184652,
0.5522326231,
0.7805902958,
-0.0531374179,
-0.1605984867,
0.7023040652,
0.1231365129,
0.2894819677,
0.7186492085,
-0.1373264045,
-0.6251271963,
-0.3739235699,
-0.7979025841,
-0.0724833086,
-0.3272178769,
-0.3386933506,
-0.7646362185,
-0.049277395,
-0.3950151503,
0.1001217216,
-0.5094815493,
-0.8472633958,
0.2337580025,
0.1060089543,
0.3870663643,
0.8670346737,
-0.1193358973,
0.3463084698,
-0.7609769106,
0.5954532027,
0.5072045922,
0.6441056728,
-0.5122173429,
-0.2374143153,
-0.2782858312,
0.0779357702,
-0.4041017294,
-1.0395976305,
0.0217940193,
0.1914798468,
0.5460880995,
0.129280895,
0.227589488,
0.8558186889,
-0.5982869864,
0.8420843482,
0.2324646562,
-1.0376247168,
0.6391255856,
-0.2864832282,
0.4040854275,
0.5872728825,
0.0481156819,
-0.8472990394,
-0.5110945702,
-0.2980877757,
-0.6818623543,
1.1837437153,
0.0675592497,
-0.0472291969,
-0.0374706201,
0.0161062628,
0.0167892873,
0.3401317298,
-0.2607282698,
-0.0213786848,
0.1082042307,
-0.1364414692,
0.0327916406,
-0.1772337258,
-0.2442921847,
-0.0577900037,
0.6194709539,
-0.0462195389,
0.4785684645,
0.0915878043,
-0.3591344357,
0.0919087604,
0.5276627541,
0.6187961102,
0.6944884062,
-0.3566830456,
-0.0870231837,
0.1433167756,
-0.4537487626,
0.1645802408,
0.066262275,
-0.5265805721,
0.110299103,
-0.0515052825,
0.8081953526,
0.3496698141,
-0.3586954772,
0.3445550799,
-0.2110043764,
-0.2205664366,
-0.1359647214,
-0.0008915272,
-0.0210781954,
0.3729874492,
-0.1935433298,
0.0017558937,
0.4690802693,
-0.4738248885,
0.526694715,
0.3916429877,
-0.4087008238,
-0.2557770014,
0.6262928843,
0.4427533746,
-0.5027672648,
0.6659325957,
-0.224560976,
-0.500974834,
0.1679328084,
0.5163586736,
0.7250525355,
-0.2957870662,
0.4004238248,
0.3258651197,
0.1884684265,
-0.0900643021,
0.5505791306,
-0.4525901973,
-0.5534685254,
-0.6807829142,
-0.7652172446,
-0.777966857,
0.1560023874,
-0.6870732903,
0.254915446,
-0.0213850196,
-0.3563815057,
-0.0506541692,
-0.035852287,
-0.4637606442,
-0.117109552,
0.2599482536,
0.7155932784,
-0.6616798043,
0.7774249315,
0.3725276291,
-0.1152710244,
-0.4770614803,
-0.1004814655,
0.225829795,
-0.6467023492,
0.1323000938,
-0.1002276167,
-0.2620391548,
0.1678223908,
-0.0736542791,
-1.0422340631,
0.818241477,
0.2406736761,
-0.9721515775,
-0.2066001296,
0.2555123568,
0.2974852622,
0.0827511847,
0.3046110868,
1.2689135075,
0.3777829707,
0.0623116195,
-1.158107996,
-0.1140284687,
0.0714175776,
-0.2672528625,
0.8579608798,
-0.5966430306,
0.3992068172,
-0.2793475986,
-0.4758712351,
-0.0053541367,
0.4349801838,
-0.1848873794,
0.1748472303,
0.7738839984,
0.8215506673,
0.5722862482,
-0.6609002352,
0.447522521,
-0.3673196435,
0.2268081456,
1.1953817606,
-0.6016148925,
0.3905579448,
0.2577597499,
-0.462259382,
0.5090342164,
0.3310241997,
0.2025386244,
0.8217899203,
0.4219350219,
-0.5346602201,
-0.0948674828,
0.167117402,
-0.0212320779,
0.8106842041,
0.5815727115,
0.2834239304,
-0.5751116872,
-0.0329023562,
0.184908554,
-0.0322366729,
0.0045381305,
1.3584055901,
-0.0368288904,
-0.849824965,
0.4536264837,
-0.1993274391,
0.3633942902,
-0.8294994831,
-0.2065455168,
-0.3285085261,
0.118925713,
-0.0235211253,
-0.6275678277,
0.3967716992,
0.1314491481,
0.3046233952,
-0.3259013295,
0.1916919947,
-0.6837286353,
-0.1854381561,
-0.0993787497,
0.7245516181,
0.2162216902,
0.1320733577,
-0.5972499847,
0.0433521457,
0.1806966513,
-0.2887127995,
0.0585044585,
0.20278503,
-0.2957473099,
0.507057786,
0.3314038515,
0.1016829163,
0.0042110658,
0.3329765499,
0.7511898875,
-0.7541370392,
-0.8347329497,
-0.7749871016,
0.466645062,
-0.0647058487,
-0.140560478,
0.4152104557,
0.7368878126,
0.6578961611,
0.3658017218,
0.8231921792,
-0.4928998649,
0.6923406124,
-0.5237565041,
0.4427711666,
-0.3025611639,
0.4809276164,
-0.4723331034,
-1.0923544168,
-0.0465937927,
0.4654370844,
-0.210813567,
-0.3703222871,
0.7743855715,
0.8195194006,
0.0545331612,
0.3440398574,
0.3392807245,
0.1236175522,
0.6174936891,
0.6923314929,
1.0097994804,
-0.2087004334,
0.5816516876,
-0.5127741694,
-0.4366123676,
0.0637770966,
-0.5481867194,
-0.4138213098,
-0.8610321283,
-0.314532876,
-0.1529514194,
0.2028778344,
0.8485609293,
0.7969601154,
-0.7661684155,
-0.4451802969,
0.0544017889,
-0.192490831,
-0.5171396732,
-0.163025409,
0.3975068033,
-0.6052307487,
-0.9974483252,
0.7425162792,
0.4636259377,
-0.0066074682,
-0.01598051,
0.3517422676,
-0.1796848774,
0.091756098,
0.675596714,
0.1220001355,
-0.4292038679,
-0.2218518555,
-0.1674321294,
-0.1447042525,
0.1110986695,
1.0017043352,
-0.6729469895,
0.587289691,
0.4123952985,
0.3284438848,
1.0969130993,
0.1711380333,
0.683709383,
-0.6241905093,
-0.0814287364,
0.450155288,
0.2883709967,
0.2386532277,
-0.1338737011,
0.5220866203,
0.1884612441,
-0.5623461008,
-0.7983169556,
0.5164999366,
-1.1364513636,
0.1309555322,
0.6583619714,
-0.0992527828,
0.0735293925,
-0.3619526029,
-0.1334625483,
0.4366825521,
-0.5751854181,
0.9513784647,
0.4910212159,
-0.5227983594,
0.0474682376,
-0.5827465057,
0.908953011,
0.2307769507,
-0.9097146392,
0.3969660401,
0.5328081846,
0.0866245776,
0.0927562416,
1.1408213377,
-0.2980999351,
0.1245005801,
0.0380699076,
-0.0775408074,
0.1618013978,
-0.5887289643,
-0.013358186,
-0.2191124707,
-0.2770237327,
-0.49183321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17019v1 | Commonsense Knowledge Graph Completion Via Contrastive Pretraining and Node Clustering | 2023-05-26T15:24:32 | 2023-05-26T15:24:32 | Siwei Wu, Xiangqing Shen, Rui Xia | cs.CL | cs.CL | The nodes in the commonsense knowledge graph (CSKG) are normally represented
by free-form short text (e.g., word or phrase). Different nodes may represent
the same concept. This leads to the problems of edge sparsity and node
redundancy, which challenges CSKG representation and completion. On the one
hand, edge sparsity limits the performance of graph representation learning; On
the other hand, node redundancy makes different nodes corresponding to the same
concept have inconsistent relations with other nodes. To address the two
problems, we propose a new CSKG completion framework based on Contrastive
Pretraining and Node Clustering (CPNC). Contrastive Pretraining constructs
positive and negative head-tail node pairs on CSKG and utilizes contrastive
learning to obtain better semantic node representation. Node Clustering
aggregates nodes with the same concept into a latent concept, assisting the
task of CSKG completion. We evaluate our CPNC approach on two CSKG completion
benchmarks (CN-100K and ATOMIC), where CPNC outperforms the state-of-the-art
methods. Extensive experiments demonstrate that both Contrastive Pretraining
and Node Clustering can significantly improve the performance of CSKG
completion. The source code of CPNC is publicly available on
\url{https://github.com/NUSTM/CPNC}. | [
-0.5527213812,
-0.1514264494,
0.4448568523,
-0.1301965863,
-0.6171886921,
0.401684463,
-0.3135499656,
-0.415551722,
0.5867704153,
0.3112968206,
-0.4431703687,
-0.6225986481,
-0.711743772,
0.1068937257,
-0.1195921451,
0.8641294241,
0.1137437448,
-0.063768968,
-0.5009896159,
-0.2912565768,
-0.319167316,
-0.057422787,
-0.6968848109,
-0.605379045,
0.6231454015,
0.3926199377,
0.6859921813,
0.6640917063,
0.2094256878,
0.3758539557,
-0.2547452152,
0.1355688572,
-0.8527978659,
-0.2569865584,
-0.2200440764,
0.0549627207,
-0.2118893415,
0.010141884,
0.6338255405,
1.0342577696,
0.1399032474,
-0.3908165991,
0.5946472883,
0.8001663089,
-0.6638121009,
0.0190598536,
-0.6492392421,
0.0798994899,
0.02032982,
0.0565379634,
0.076716885,
-0.3822135329,
0.2915008068,
-1.2748954296,
0.3677625656,
-0.065765053,
0.7825055718,
0.2709074318,
-0.3928995728,
0.0166521948,
-0.0245013852,
0.6296266317,
-0.4688968956,
0.5023889542,
0.4722782373,
0.2115154266,
0.1354866326,
-0.9167985916,
-0.6367420554,
-0.249268055,
-0.6961354017,
0.4144971669,
0.1176194027,
0.3218055964,
0.1386610568,
0.4508134425,
-0.6104815602,
0.0749581978,
-0.4891112149,
-0.4190405309,
0.1494887024,
-0.0806539729,
-0.0907690153,
-0.2540320158,
-0.544182837,
-0.1749434769,
-0.6489849091,
-0.1716328561,
0.3010599613,
0.4107763469,
-0.119495593,
0.1774649173,
-0.6127772927,
0.8661181927,
0.0491174869,
0.0812284425,
0.5633453131,
-0.3674916625,
0.088817656,
0.021774929,
0.6585124135,
0.5886843801,
0.0985066891,
-0.4115947783,
0.0956506878,
0.0320232362,
0.2273718566,
-0.5330707431,
-0.4822530448,
0.0868783295,
-0.4007543027,
-0.3034465313,
0.0223093517,
-0.5480551124,
-0.5370246768,
-0.5832013488,
0.1734779626,
-0.4223096371,
-0.5983601213,
-0.1847374886,
-0.3420442641,
0.0759419277,
0.3419086933,
-0.3645499051,
0.5559912324,
0.7379834056,
0.9047945738,
-0.5248170495,
-0.4186422229,
-0.3282191157,
0.0675361156,
-0.2081665695,
0.714761138,
-0.4036048651,
-0.4482055306,
-0.2762931585,
0.0153296459,
-0.0191061776,
-0.6350269914,
0.2060256004,
-0.5758325458,
-0.2304778397,
-0.6468432546,
-0.5980488658,
-0.0119756395,
0.6678285599,
-0.7669377327,
1.0198068619,
0.3347808123,
-1.2339142561,
0.2466649115,
-0.2877279818,
-0.33311674,
0.4170196354,
-0.2192131132,
-0.2117702365,
-0.2235126495,
-0.214476794,
0.5656443834,
0.1278391182,
-0.0333371349,
-0.4530552328,
-0.499584049,
-0.0558995828,
0.2848369479,
0.465266645,
0.2244657725,
0.0086473152,
-0.0060084243,
-0.8394089937,
0.0968480706,
-0.0221259221,
-0.0761918649,
-0.5151900053,
-0.0943412185,
-0.1139302775,
0.2655992806,
0.4656092525,
-0.5080128908,
-0.2996488214,
-0.4014266431,
0.4057180285,
0.6885165572,
-0.1118853837,
0.5160691738,
-0.2608830929,
0.2015283704,
0.1727759838,
-0.1692513674,
0.1656183451,
-0.1834797263,
-0.6635459065,
0.0940221176,
0.274446696,
0.4602206349,
-0.9341595173,
0.3948777318,
-0.3085852265,
-0.5069279075,
0.0374274589,
0.1076094508,
0.7081093788,
0.9827671647,
0.6265771389,
-0.364831388,
-0.5340028405,
-0.5912246704,
-0.0035482398,
0.1511565298,
0.0797218829,
0.4720996022,
0.317366004,
-0.103368707,
0.9327368736,
-0.7535566092,
-0.2934398353,
-0.1162289456,
0.153664425,
0.1597867459,
0.742041111,
0.3474709392,
-0.8790822029,
-0.737772584,
0.3438389301,
-0.2683987319,
0.0242554769,
0.4252604842,
-0.0692439377,
-0.2458074242,
0.7714866996,
-0.1095956713,
0.3956071734,
0.5329341888,
-0.1371492147,
0.7915383577,
-0.0986386091,
0.2269100547,
-0.9742746949,
0.1847240627,
-0.3298031092,
-0.4820728898,
-0.49338305,
-0.1615403593,
0.0158150475,
-0.2973633409,
-0.5094678998,
0.6554692388,
-0.2638613284,
0.0240262821,
-0.2924504578,
0.6200030446,
0.0118981116,
0.6780102849,
0.135724321,
0.4289969802,
0.4083162844,
-0.8091608882,
0.3240320385,
0.011830369,
-0.0586433895,
0.6878112555,
-0.8262262344,
-0.0281535964,
-0.153774038,
0.1642105877,
-1.0724966526,
-0.2486128807,
0.1662652493,
-0.4385112822,
0.2818353772,
-0.3310932219,
-0.2050757408,
-0.3968064487,
-0.1791783571,
0.6843048334,
0.3912242651,
-0.6142704487,
0.4047700465,
-0.0173098333,
-0.0047217733,
-1.0004359484,
-0.506344378,
-0.3182552159,
0.0103434902,
-0.3304712772,
0.6397383213,
0.0555199198,
0.2253487259,
0.4354388714,
-0.2104090601,
-0.191180557,
0.0111878701,
0.1543779075,
0.0043082447,
0.0502547659,
0.2291350663,
-0.0098779611,
-0.4659869671,
-0.3181824684,
-0.4871560037,
0.5512173176,
-0.102203317,
-0.377260834,
-0.2126471847,
0.3203133941,
-0.0322742723,
-0.0956686586,
0.4145908952,
0.5564548373,
-0.3665046394,
-0.089175716,
-0.5838543177,
-0.2330048084,
-0.5037772655,
0.4469524324,
0.0893587023,
-1.303082943,
0.6285015941,
-0.3810810149,
-0.320396632,
0.442317009,
-0.2533671856,
-0.3239667118,
0.4768179357,
0.4461924434,
0.1499112546,
0.5605731606,
-0.4726073444,
-0.1626855135,
-0.8141388893,
-0.1572269052,
-0.5097798705,
-0.3982025683,
-0.489531517,
-0.2768987119,
0.2858442962,
0.5231400132,
-0.2074204534,
0.375448823,
-0.7253727317,
0.9269250631,
0.4238539934,
0.3417811096,
0.2923398316,
0.0318818614,
-0.588583529,
-0.1154857948,
-0.7531913519,
-0.1000492647,
0.8403269649,
-0.2909500003,
0.1801310033,
-0.271766156,
1.0336366892,
0.187301293,
0.2735018432,
-0.5353224277,
0.4597870409,
-0.5427185297,
-0.0580712967,
-0.2510238886,
-0.64012748,
-1.0866544247,
0.2152845263,
-0.409142524,
-0.6050392389,
0.0993894711,
0.6715713143,
-0.1978963912,
0.192914784,
-0.6207642555,
1.0788435936,
0.1130675003,
-0.3167136014,
-0.5895035863,
-0.8092654347,
0.2822478712,
0.2585222721,
0.0196826532,
0.1460009813,
0.1000571549,
0.869566381,
-0.848606348,
0.9304097891,
-0.406289041,
0.4562117457,
0.3370812535,
-0.1883253306,
0.5627310872,
-0.0664411485,
0.2596102059,
0.1234690025,
-0.1553228498,
-0.6406998038,
-0.6777181625,
0.7570723295,
-0.8380084634,
-0.2028068006,
-0.1930818856,
-0.0514753237,
-0.1904137433,
0.7458357811,
0.452187866,
0.3680188954,
-0.4054654241,
0.0164576862,
0.8163872361,
-0.0844432265,
0.2913028598,
-0.036279615,
0.1051435843,
-0.8523170352,
1.2317848206,
0.1176569313,
0.4211826921,
0.453956455,
0.2355084121,
-0.3942133784,
-0.7147397995,
0.1712444127,
0.3760213554,
-0.8731691241,
-0.4404535294,
-0.7672681212,
-0.2685758471,
-0.5120651722,
-0.4560915828,
-0.4276103675,
-0.5082726479,
-0.3136311173,
-0.0709842667,
0.2716668248,
0.7593779564,
-0.2665732205,
0.6557879448,
-0.6484676003,
0.2600495517,
0.7059439421,
0.7193976045,
0.3752816021,
0.1063799039,
-0.3376609385,
-0.1910236925,
-0.3640733659,
-0.7039256692,
-0.1889262199,
-0.0993700251,
0.5913140178,
0.5863152146,
0.1463541687,
0.618213892,
-0.3119390011,
0.5644618273,
0.8408197165,
-0.7429156899,
0.3046065867,
-0.3984051943,
0.3219542205,
1.0439772606,
0.4469064474,
-0.8282781839,
-0.1944032162,
-0.7336294055,
-0.8514178395,
0.5191139579,
-0.0268481951,
-0.2720571458,
-0.2054648846,
0.2217727751,
0.0155912191,
0.095276542,
-0.6487537026,
-0.0957578719,
-0.8743445873,
-0.0938166156,
-0.0270026997,
-0.0777855888,
-0.1689134389,
0.0023455655,
0.6925044656,
-0.2852230072,
0.0187672246,
0.1872065961,
-0.1867949069,
0.4003238082,
0.1437847614,
0.2195805162,
0.5927744508,
0.0433125496,
0.2861031294,
0.3394841254,
-0.4822366536,
-0.2434445471,
0.2039293796,
-0.046542298,
-0.2005880028,
0.4282316864,
0.4461512864,
0.3194283843,
-0.3686446249,
0.8420060277,
0.150672093,
-0.3348125219,
-0.2111939788,
0.0172870271,
0.4197372794,
-0.0345652625,
0.17312482,
0.1959834397,
0.017724691,
0.1543609351,
0.1451558471,
0.322552681,
-0.4639795423,
0.0803336799,
0.2487441152,
0.3416115046,
0.1365578473,
0.6202898622,
-0.656997323,
-0.7653545737,
0.7331970334,
0.3505021036,
0.4547469914,
0.0315787345,
0.3306694627,
0.6955450773,
-0.1327489167,
-0.1623103172,
0.1427249461,
-0.4942821264,
-0.8346276283,
-0.5489326715,
-0.4129213691,
-0.2977124751,
-0.0759436861,
-0.4340335727,
0.140567556,
-0.5961702466,
0.089733161,
-0.5273606181,
0.3464439809,
-0.7644455433,
0.4027036726,
-0.1901593059,
0.7710946202,
-0.7672569156,
0.5450925231,
0.5256885886,
-0.1294901967,
-0.8539682627,
-0.520596385,
-0.1615399271,
-0.6212300062,
0.4810994267,
0.08128912,
-0.2521044016,
-0.0197501387,
-0.4998351336,
-0.7990853786,
1.3536162376,
-0.0246632416,
-0.5122583508,
0.123266533,
0.2088828087,
0.3277257085,
-0.3182481527,
-0.0743079707,
0.2254541069,
0.5539881587,
0.5610850453,
-0.6301888824,
0.2168168426,
-0.1862196922,
0.0430824123,
0.0729241073,
-0.6179178357,
0.6741471887,
-0.0099827703,
-0.2109397501,
-0.0245919432,
0.6643711329,
0.4707942307,
0.4141688943,
0.776640594,
1.0408171415,
0.9794121385,
-0.1397192329,
0.5651835203,
-0.3215998411,
0.2736633122,
1.3064011335,
0.1299489141,
0.5808266401,
0.178564474,
-0.1757695228,
0.423045665,
0.5537286401,
0.2575328946,
0.6260181665,
0.2065324336,
-0.230514124,
-0.3213799298,
-0.1217160895,
-0.7560468316,
-0.080060482,
0.3131235838,
-0.1344863772,
-0.4249534607,
-0.2666944563,
0.0051506101,
0.2320257425,
-0.5589984059,
0.8102963567,
0.0654132366,
-0.6196455359,
0.4531658292,
-0.3455243409,
0.8351528645,
-0.7397242188,
-0.0667417273,
-0.2993173599,
-0.1351599693,
-0.4927289784,
-0.4695896208,
0.3451063633,
-0.4906029701,
-0.1106188521,
-0.1604773849,
1.0531722307,
-0.5319406986,
-0.1529643536,
0.4113043845,
0.3050095737,
0.1212497056,
0.0614406466,
-0.5286291838,
-0.1974792331,
-0.2070336342,
0.3220593929,
0.2721897662,
0.4614248872,
0.2005919367,
0.2108983696,
0.4445931613,
0.1344132572,
-0.0281252172,
-0.1056166813,
1.1603726149,
-0.4709202051,
-0.8122407198,
-0.3856149018,
0.4116000533,
-0.5141019225,
-0.2171920389,
0.3328859806,
0.5287246704,
1.2435575724,
0.1842589378,
0.7434154153,
-0.0937513784,
0.609474957,
-0.4883374274,
0.8471007943,
-0.5211507678,
-0.0866524056,
-0.6233299971,
-0.8727638721,
-0.1989419162,
0.5637432337,
-0.2636441886,
0.1126835793,
0.9891613126,
0.9267383218,
-0.3412813842,
-0.1150657609,
0.3076690435,
0.0189846251,
-0.142869547,
0.6769692302,
0.8471598625,
-0.0218207706,
0.8059801459,
-0.2900433838,
-0.2913525701,
0.0841776133,
-1.1595009565,
-0.7934952378,
-0.6816353798,
-0.4196210504,
-0.5075371861,
-0.038525939,
0.7731468678,
0.8336613774,
-0.5943428874,
0.0999498516,
-0.365252912,
0.5831295848,
-0.3104387224,
-0.2413782626,
0.599180758,
-0.5019060969,
-0.1626143306,
0.0906373858,
-0.0724174753,
0.1019114256,
0.1167061552,
-0.5109906793,
0.0385546386,
-0.5445415378,
0.3476584852,
0.5146322846,
-0.3837210536,
-0.2248819321,
-0.3562470973,
0.1136855111,
0.163851887,
1.1853147745,
-1.1031777859,
0.3004820049,
0.5664389729,
0.7768794298,
0.6297228932,
-0.057145603,
0.00332805,
-0.9917466044,
0.0258202795,
0.2073776871,
0.3324864507,
0.4471149147,
-0.215877831,
0.3371116221,
0.6770261526,
-0.2491669655,
-0.2893792689,
0.4997690022,
-1.1851747036,
-0.4577053189,
0.8976644278,
-0.2984434366,
-0.1161940843,
-0.3546546698,
0.0636891574,
0.4393722713,
-0.3232352138,
0.4563876987,
0.6107064486,
-0.0165787619,
-0.0525994301,
0.1589563191,
0.6730175018,
0.2593977451,
-0.4368560612,
0.0712063238,
0.5234240294,
0.4736707211,
0.3541362882,
1.0331155062,
-0.1386096478,
0.3791331947,
0.061064411,
-0.1730939001,
-0.4003040195,
-0.1921805441,
0.0172115061,
0.3296537399,
-0.1008887291,
0.09986756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17013v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17013v1 | D-CALM: A Dynamic Clustering-based Active Learning Approach for Mitigating Bias | 2023-05-26T15:17:43 | 2023-05-26T15:17:43 | Sabit Hassan, Malihe Alikhani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite recent advancements, NLP models continue to be vulnerable to bias.
This bias often originates from the uneven distribution of real-world data and
can propagate through the annotation process. Escalated integration of these
models in our lives calls for methods to mitigate bias without overbearing
annotation costs. While active learning (AL) has shown promise in training
models with a small amount of annotated data, AL's reliance on the model's
behavior for selective sampling can lead to an accumulation of unwanted bias
rather than bias mitigation. However, infusing clustering with AL can overcome
the bias issue of both AL and traditional annotation methods while exploiting
AL's annotation efficiency. In this paper, we propose a novel adaptive
clustering-based active learning algorithm, D-CALM, that dynamically adjusts
clustering and annotation efforts in response to an estimated classifier
error-rate. Experiments on eight datasets for a diverse set of text
classification tasks, including emotion, hatespeech, dialog act, and book type
detection, demonstrate that our proposed algorithm significantly outperforms
baseline AL approaches with both pretrained transformers and traditional
Support Vector Machines. D-CALM showcases robustness against different measures
of information gain and, as evident from our analysis of label and error
distribution, can significantly reduce unwanted model bias. | [
-0.1316165477,
-1.1246579885,
0.2411099821,
0.2549316585,
-0.3258160353,
0.2645418942,
-0.4193206429,
-0.2930825055,
0.1086589023,
-0.2184576988,
-0.5616574883,
-0.4229491055,
-0.3793221414,
-0.1259997338,
-0.195159629,
0.7787363529,
-0.254900068,
-0.0605209209,
0.0436123386,
-0.2244094908,
-0.352255702,
-0.3738772273,
-0.8081063032,
-0.0684346035,
0.7197158337,
0.2123871297,
0.6361425519,
0.595769465,
0.4990576208,
0.2259103954,
-0.5545503497,
0.0562438592,
-0.3334772885,
0.5777790546,
0.0726166293,
-0.5748502016,
-0.6636990309,
0.1915342659,
0.9256935716,
0.4192592502,
-0.3608036935,
-0.1158237457,
-0.1527300477,
0.5531498194,
-0.9260767698,
0.0998710468,
-0.9107458591,
0.4354170859,
-0.0799579546,
0.0906128585,
-0.3698303699,
-0.3394027054,
0.0741233006,
-0.7002339959,
0.1874398738,
-0.0640618354,
0.6168987751,
0.9490672946,
-0.3530981839,
-0.3527397215,
-0.781289041,
1.0752937794,
-0.6212272048,
-0.0636600927,
0.3234749734,
0.1852798462,
-0.1201808453,
-0.4466695189,
-0.799867332,
0.2345522791,
0.1288704872,
0.4590521157,
-0.1900943816,
-0.0802352652,
0.302885294,
0.405728817,
0.1260123253,
0.3900723457,
-0.0215942189,
0.1186140552,
0.5608536005,
-0.2016372681,
0.2169430852,
0.3175329566,
-0.4712052047,
-0.2269200832,
-0.1667745858,
0.0756582245,
0.2118557543,
0.4153806567,
0.0784185529,
0.1000229493,
0.1279819012,
0.5544328094,
0.4523148239,
-0.249227494,
0.4734502137,
0.2678797841,
-0.1553462148,
0.5434352756,
0.3846943974,
0.2095652819,
-0.166296795,
-0.0536658205,
-0.2610410452,
0.3909347355,
0.4630196095,
-0.5443977714,
-0.2012354583,
0.3903183639,
-0.3108705282,
-0.8352071643,
-0.1463805139,
-1.0697994232,
-0.6408422589,
-0.1300256848,
0.497415781,
0.0158136245,
-0.4916611612,
-0.0845878571,
0.2021402419,
-0.2389589399,
0.5065185428,
-0.6469687223,
0.3335645497,
0.1935895085,
0.9856241941,
-0.7783593535,
0.064241156,
-0.3757255673,
0.1808741987,
-0.24465774,
0.827031374,
-0.5652225018,
-0.0894980654,
0.204343304,
-0.0950774997,
-0.1187684387,
-0.5138508081,
0.8981087208,
-0.4348573685,
0.0373401828,
-0.1674020439,
-0.2555858493,
-0.3837250769,
0.4049890637,
-0.8046537042,
1.378911972,
-0.1077040583,
-0.9955275655,
0.7277669311,
-0.6371312141,
-0.4795209765,
-0.2414962202,
-0.0553213879,
-0.9331624508,
0.0613585152,
0.3056184947,
0.4345968664,
0.2963113487,
0.3040302694,
-0.5936875343,
-0.6276412606,
0.4475148618,
-0.3993943632,
0.5082603693,
0.1347343773,
-0.8658959866,
0.3890098631,
-0.867595315,
-0.1949488968,
0.0623394772,
-0.4841230214,
-0.5327866673,
0.2873074412,
-0.312324971,
0.3161937892,
-0.0817167088,
-0.4369640648,
0.3006651402,
-0.2016026378,
0.1200813577,
0.8866918683,
0.1442395002,
0.7130261064,
-0.2020362169,
0.4577874839,
0.4507809877,
0.0804923624,
-0.189954102,
-0.2815770507,
-1.0478372574,
-0.8686521649,
0.326128751,
0.6965067387,
-0.6438453794,
0.638630867,
0.1912767291,
-0.6190776825,
-0.5217736959,
0.0798138902,
0.0063544591,
0.5171786547,
0.5441229343,
-0.1470162719,
-0.1642068923,
-0.4740559757,
-0.3370864987,
-0.0826481134,
0.264732033,
0.1798499376,
0.0250265766,
-0.2385697663,
0.7796345949,
-0.53728652,
-0.4079229832,
-0.0753183812,
0.2734428942,
0.0113836154,
0.459068507,
0.68469733,
-0.7856809497,
-0.592700243,
-0.3742752075,
-0.5699591637,
-0.3489795327,
-0.2751608789,
-0.361286819,
0.0991687998,
0.4738552868,
-0.4175641239,
0.670504272,
0.3114503622,
-0.2778213918,
0.0820651129,
0.1108313724,
-0.1819766462,
-0.7389541268,
0.0428539217,
0.0822125152,
0.0515731424,
-0.5668057799,
-0.3161720932,
0.1176677942,
-0.0711798668,
-0.2171130627,
0.6055861115,
-0.4968695045,
0.3751777709,
-0.6386902928,
0.1628677398,
-0.1157323197,
0.5648050904,
0.1557144672,
0.3472250402,
0.9139912128,
-0.7552310228,
0.1942755282,
0.1884936988,
-0.0584647506,
0.3997766078,
-0.1436533928,
0.0792745203,
-0.2389682978,
0.6069402099,
-0.7921504974,
-0.0008596834,
0.2910173535,
0.0157812815,
0.5351279974,
-0.0962986276,
-0.1676424593,
-0.2965899408,
-0.2637122571,
0.3627000451,
0.5547253489,
-0.6749303937,
0.6724019647,
0.5598959327,
-0.3044315875,
-0.7122097015,
-0.5727080107,
-0.25343889,
-0.4905881882,
-0.0540644825,
0.3998996913,
-0.0518321618,
-0.4054464102,
0.005543631,
-0.4711382091,
-0.3299485743,
0.3394865394,
0.1843177825,
0.0550593697,
0.2626731694,
0.4572774768,
0.3782462478,
-0.1530507207,
-0.0458800457,
-0.096844539,
0.0434061736,
0.3102649748,
-0.4131941199,
-0.4836587012,
0.1498539746,
0.5356585383,
-0.22504206,
0.8325172663,
0.9212245941,
-0.5714316964,
-0.7552267909,
-0.5242779255,
-0.4564869702,
-0.5016164184,
0.2465117574,
0.2030448467,
-0.6855129004,
0.5109816194,
-0.2655364573,
0.5345888734,
0.2380999178,
0.8123518229,
0.0120592592,
1.030066967,
0.621083498,
0.0581218153,
1.0045772791,
0.1297380775,
0.6204132438,
-0.3058157265,
-0.1544709951,
-0.3592883348,
-0.8538589478,
-0.2030809671,
-0.6904711127,
0.1328856349,
0.1640277952,
-0.0224882122,
-0.5431983471,
-0.6695426702,
0.0532229431,
0.4808751345,
0.3169747293,
0.0763031989,
0.1299456954,
-0.0724098235,
-0.1598326862,
-0.9020195603,
-0.1898167878,
0.662501812,
0.4801232517,
0.8595745564,
0.150389716,
0.2773832083,
0.3829179406,
0.5619475245,
-1.0480841398,
0.4503781199,
0.1040080413,
-0.6663507819,
-0.0558078177,
-0.529446125,
-0.7154243588,
0.1669558287,
-0.563883543,
-0.1782721728,
0.5390007496,
0.5158594847,
-0.4637104869,
0.5868914127,
-0.5623739362,
0.4837106466,
-0.3203110695,
-0.7899497151,
-0.1547129005,
-0.3867102265,
0.2045256346,
-0.5202363133,
0.2998618186,
-0.4163807034,
-0.1349011511,
0.9781433344,
0.1547836363,
1.1142976284,
-0.6442550421,
0.0965809301,
0.574754715,
0.0287134647,
0.4260707498,
-0.0077666235,
-0.3852418959,
-0.251321435,
-0.6043395996,
-0.5955520868,
-0.5789535046,
0.7063404322,
-0.585582912,
-0.1430703253,
-0.7965580821,
-0.6295650005,
-0.2828483582,
0.1055696905,
-0.3282354772,
0.1185357943,
-0.0087204725,
-0.0182183869,
0.8927229643,
-0.2974745929,
0.7474883795,
0.7041877508,
0.1372883916,
-0.2819355726,
0.6221298575,
0.1243716329,
0.0666432157,
-0.1155841723,
0.2918162644,
-0.1030880362,
-0.565640986,
-0.1093769073,
0.0640921444,
-0.7390184999,
-0.4041411877,
-0.9260172248,
0.2014916241,
-0.0725833774,
-0.4316779077,
-0.3311324418,
-0.5272192955,
-0.2450066656,
-0.4387225211,
0.6778532863,
0.5160018802,
0.1190824136,
0.538954854,
-0.4653302133,
0.1215820834,
0.4147233963,
0.4626435935,
0.2828512192,
-0.5448995829,
-0.3355933726,
-0.105761148,
-0.3415658176,
-0.8684366941,
0.3156959414,
0.4147575498,
0.8375557661,
0.4352227747,
0.5456315279,
0.5001989007,
-0.2664613426,
0.5864233375,
-0.0122824917,
-0.6872476339,
0.6496434212,
-0.4004125893,
0.3054184914,
0.7761512995,
0.3987886608,
-0.02546506,
-0.333083123,
-0.7569607496,
-1.1796323061,
0.6431150436,
0.0942207053,
-0.0614324436,
-0.0717918426,
0.6948503852,
-0.1181812286,
0.3206769526,
-0.9511098266,
-0.0985099897,
-0.163488254,
-0.5167216063,
0.2297129333,
-0.2937610447,
-0.3110676706,
-0.2545184195,
1.0254046917,
-0.1922280192,
0.2102522999,
0.1634218544,
-0.0346439704,
-0.3166441023,
0.0681563541,
0.2188794762,
0.2044056505,
-0.2814530432,
0.2551552355,
0.335570544,
-0.8560090065,
0.2140144408,
0.149831906,
-0.4601139426,
-0.0012443558,
0.0539178215,
0.7866905928,
0.2540535629,
-0.6361836195,
0.492969811,
-0.1580801606,
0.0182922594,
-0.1789533943,
0.2448642999,
-0.3865805864,
0.0344329253,
0.5128798485,
0.2650131285,
-0.1567796022,
-0.3967763186,
0.2617396414,
0.075920321,
-1.027130127,
-0.3032616079,
0.609565258,
0.5473673344,
0.021878399,
0.4339772165,
-0.177252695,
-0.7150456905,
0.3891040683,
0.5983490944,
0.8590199947,
-0.530749917,
-0.0882160291,
0.5244829059,
0.1612162143,
-0.3414820731,
0.3371197879,
0.1508627087,
-0.7410926223,
-0.2867520154,
-0.8034991026,
-0.499453336,
-0.2904899716,
-0.7881807685,
0.4109392166,
-0.5816280842,
-0.3621259928,
-0.4166297317,
0.1039326638,
-0.1739508212,
0.4594568014,
0.0135389743,
0.8803699017,
-1.2019199133,
0.7803301811,
1.0866287947,
-0.0108262384,
-0.4316534996,
0.1834400445,
0.119591713,
-0.3607841432,
0.0213501118,
0.257250607,
0.0770658255,
0.1275341809,
-0.4359939694,
-0.6344916224,
1.066160202,
0.0449202359,
-0.3892073929,
0.4234766066,
-0.6673184037,
0.4961467087,
-0.2534817159,
-0.0310103167,
0.3309928775,
0.5732799172,
0.0855600089,
-0.4436061084,
0.03749438,
-0.4746042788,
-0.6680633426,
0.1801004261,
-0.6962969303,
0.5715641379,
0.0456436425,
-0.0371866375,
-0.5293405056,
0.7210541368,
0.3470321894,
0.5052884817,
1.0130273104,
0.5734468699,
1.0894825459,
-0.2220933586,
0.461240381,
-0.2281145006,
0.1051023901,
0.8160045147,
-0.5593215823,
0.7325212359,
0.4073476791,
0.0518979728,
0.3420220315,
0.6252290606,
-0.0999316275,
0.5832446218,
0.201709196,
-0.7544836998,
-0.0989738181,
-0.1408585012,
0.0288984198,
0.3542358875,
0.6084689498,
-0.1768872887,
0.0722657144,
0.0401494391,
0.4135532677,
0.2536646426,
-0.3963608146,
0.8490477204,
0.0310911871,
-0.723326087,
0.2607316971,
-0.1421027184,
0.8538172245,
-0.6064597964,
0.036217358,
-0.0621002391,
0.5346559882,
-0.2588067055,
-0.255753845,
0.1877588332,
0.0239466205,
-0.2923453748,
-0.3795666397,
0.9069549441,
-0.4933066666,
-0.7880282402,
0.2158108503,
0.3449566066,
-0.1591687053,
0.032587368,
-0.8281579614,
0.2701326311,
-0.0011070037,
-0.371991992,
0.3870509267,
0.5184246898,
-0.2181926519,
0.5024162531,
0.6168494821,
-0.0073046535,
0.1671323627,
-0.0113317883,
1.1559067965,
-0.4226185381,
-0.6462025046,
-0.5326425433,
0.5727971792,
-0.2862640619,
-0.0912550017,
0.6950500607,
0.2171196043,
0.1881763637,
0.3778283298,
0.8547554612,
-0.0260348674,
0.8261501789,
-0.2333132476,
0.8185883164,
-0.5484255552,
0.2325667292,
-0.3515165448,
-1.0358874798,
-0.634160161,
1.1004052162,
-0.225080058,
0.1180389002,
0.5965262651,
0.4618414342,
-0.1745237261,
-0.0632754415,
-0.1365222633,
0.5380718708,
0.358173281,
-0.2105993479,
0.6284855008,
-0.1248046607,
0.3916649818,
-0.4377526939,
-0.7870275974,
-0.1758362651,
-1.1648007631,
-0.9703825712,
-0.1215607971,
-0.6829841137,
-0.316437006,
0.0027773308,
0.5649453998,
0.561116755,
-0.7093979716,
0.3112247288,
0.1222348809,
-0.0053253141,
-0.6298351288,
-0.1901095808,
0.5684119463,
-0.5021377802,
-0.7622910738,
0.4993880093,
0.1749681383,
0.1945064962,
-0.159610495,
0.34703058,
-0.4567779601,
0.2675574124,
0.2885904908,
0.0789057016,
-0.2887203097,
0.0590149611,
-0.0724242628,
0.0502551682,
0.0810418576,
0.7253262401,
-0.8079325557,
0.4992648959,
0.2746920884,
0.5550280213,
0.3814378977,
0.1452338696,
0.5040661097,
-0.7465350628,
0.82142061,
0.4971881211,
0.0450556725,
0.330027163,
-0.4603215456,
0.3967794776,
0.2495514154,
-0.6475141644,
-1.238155961,
0.0610937178,
-1.2625000477,
-0.3532826304,
1.0246475935,
-0.3404632211,
-0.2765983045,
-0.3789691925,
-0.3233862221,
0.5144805908,
-0.5240285993,
1.3430585861,
0.4125295877,
0.0212595183,
-0.0700183511,
-0.5190612674,
0.7504039407,
0.713850975,
-0.7148171663,
0.21314089,
0.3757323623,
-0.2288404852,
0.0303718317,
0.3994964957,
0.0326994918,
0.0491121598,
-0.0155950831,
0.23243016,
0.1867610067,
-0.2772289515,
-0.4919835925,
0.1042869315,
0.0782885775,
0.0896695107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17008v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17008v2 | NormBank: A Knowledge Bank of Situational Social Norms | 2023-05-26T15:09:11 | 2023-07-24T19:18:25 | Caleb Ziems, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Yi-Chia Wang, Alon Halevy, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present NormBank, a knowledge bank of 155k situational norms. This
resource is designed to ground flexible normative reasoning for interactive,
assistive, and collaborative AI systems. Unlike prior commonsense resources,
NormBank grounds each inference within a multivalent sociocultural frame, which
includes the setting (e.g., restaurant), the agents' contingent roles (waiter,
customer), their attributes (age, gender), and other physical, social, and
cultural constraints (e.g., the temperature or the country of operation). In
total, NormBank contains 63k unique constraints from a taxonomy that we
introduce and iteratively refine here. Constraints then apply in different
combinations to frame social norms. Under these manipulations, norms are
non-monotonic - one can cancel an inference by updating its frame even
slightly. Still, we find evidence that neural models can help reliably extend
the scope and coverage of NormBank. We further demonstrate the utility of this
resource with a series of transfer experiments. | [
-0.2510641813,
-0.6623304486,
0.3995051384,
0.2135381848,
0.2157869488,
-0.2659475207,
-0.2408949733,
-0.4265437126,
0.0087042116,
0.4710526466,
-0.259934634,
-0.3339545131,
-0.2936959863,
-0.022284152,
-0.0396543294,
1.1175746918,
0.1251662225,
-0.168467775,
-0.4962669611,
-0.2913608849,
-0.2782238722,
-0.5030050874,
-0.7140692472,
-0.2021483332,
0.3414019346,
0.7074115276,
0.9142599106,
0.4013168514,
0.1499614865,
0.4389309883,
-0.0068536513,
0.1787910759,
-0.0655031353,
0.1330609918,
-0.0526238158,
-0.1133764684,
-0.6708265543,
0.1678328961,
0.2943071127,
0.7345234156,
-0.1134021804,
0.3419459164,
0.0802712813,
0.475733906,
-0.499891758,
0.5061631799,
-0.1199949905,
-0.0260017514,
0.326562494,
0.4018782079,
-0.1689417064,
-0.4295064807,
0.1661809683,
-0.8790290356,
-0.0204124916,
-0.041363012,
0.7135311961,
0.4716442823,
-0.6723598242,
-0.0200890414,
-0.7336411476,
0.5267775059,
-0.4203139246,
0.3756097257,
0.7691753507,
0.2580684423,
0.2031462342,
-0.7427440882,
-0.5230993032,
-0.2399452478,
-0.2697137296,
-0.1251428425,
-0.185745731,
0.1318765432,
0.2176832706,
-0.1268512011,
-0.1175265238,
-0.1243054792,
-0.5647258759,
-0.2547071874,
0.6827698946,
0.1040923819,
0.0818825439,
-0.5253956318,
-0.3705147505,
0.0597248264,
-0.0953267142,
0.4465898871,
0.1921983808,
0.16853185,
-0.2398218662,
0.2681481242,
-0.0733259991,
0.834810257,
0.0782114118,
-0.124111861,
0.0737935752,
-0.4793914258,
-0.0863336995,
-0.1089091375,
0.3588352501,
0.6293228269,
0.3023385406,
0.0145954601,
-0.2950260639,
-0.4376153648,
0.4195635319,
-0.4296072125,
-0.0231335722,
0.1386757046,
-0.5588776469,
-0.483756125,
-0.1852759272,
-0.5550771356,
-0.4959871471,
-0.4613831937,
0.1061912328,
-0.6680334806,
-0.3045862019,
-0.2636860609,
-0.3249430954,
0.3834500909,
0.3505092263,
-0.7450194955,
0.2864797711,
0.6132612228,
0.8176257014,
0.2162257135,
-0.0494086407,
-0.0763261467,
0.2144160718,
0.0161640644,
0.5847643018,
-0.5316573977,
-0.2763573527,
0.0165756568,
-0.171560958,
0.0877134055,
-0.3689836264,
0.4426805079,
-0.5280783176,
-0.3823407888,
-0.1533525139,
-0.5835262537,
-0.1738493294,
0.63447541,
-0.8264187574,
0.5738762021,
0.294678092,
-0.3441978693,
0.4983209074,
-0.8474811316,
-0.4385904074,
0.2104404271,
-0.0578199178,
-0.1479936093,
-0.2030017376,
0.1034361497,
0.3863038123,
-0.0234466456,
0.7549976707,
-0.5630634427,
-0.1546847075,
0.3157656789,
-0.4242317975,
0.9803851843,
0.5588551164,
-0.0202122629,
0.1804563552,
-0.748901844,
-0.3235148787,
-0.0057823164,
-0.291656971,
-0.6048358679,
-0.1562777609,
0.2486744076,
0.0198864937,
0.5479122996,
-0.3051710427,
0.1286457479,
0.3554277718,
0.7829232216,
0.990504384,
-0.0738500059,
0.6495847702,
-0.5387893915,
0.22859855,
-0.1055631861,
0.5115821362,
0.1118616611,
-0.4343252778,
-0.2731339633,
-0.5271611214,
0.0861223638,
0.5932163596,
-0.3392650187,
0.2847232819,
0.0538296998,
-0.2871677577,
-0.2143803686,
0.1445320398,
0.0083894571,
0.7175560594,
0.2888454199,
-0.0626809523,
-0.698816061,
-0.9786345363,
0.0176114701,
-0.4021435976,
0.0412215069,
0.6678272486,
0.1701078713,
-0.1988149434,
1.059081316,
-0.0874174312,
-0.2638457119,
-0.2434698194,
-0.0614825226,
0.3149383068,
0.5429566503,
0.5890259147,
-1.1121047735,
-0.1067901552,
-0.3189167082,
-0.955188632,
0.0792849809,
-0.3676180542,
0.1542844474,
0.1887956411,
0.9183719158,
-0.3969576657,
0.4043342769,
0.460611552,
-0.8571917415,
0.4259000123,
-0.4017672241,
0.1274260581,
-1.0335856676,
0.015342202,
0.1286584884,
-0.2615860403,
-0.5273429751,
-0.2773483098,
0.0517617352,
-0.2825967073,
0.1000852138,
0.7774524689,
-0.0228094738,
-0.0722825229,
0.2190051377,
0.0113123404,
0.0578025542,
0.536901474,
0.004628941,
0.5971396565,
0.3669651449,
-0.4999098182,
0.510699451,
0.5110128522,
-0.4506743252,
1.1307308674,
-0.7679098248,
-0.1915061176,
-0.0968673453,
0.3740677238,
-0.9897366166,
-0.2339578122,
0.0841435269,
-0.3341444433,
-0.0282256473,
-0.3619886637,
-0.2637850046,
-0.0906896666,
0.1219981015,
0.5377976298,
0.4432076514,
-0.3993116617,
0.6427711248,
0.5952788591,
-0.1303666532,
-0.5397233963,
-0.4802515805,
0.1742488742,
-0.3492619991,
-0.731487453,
0.1141733229,
0.1326946616,
-0.821888566,
0.3887731433,
-0.2465001643,
-0.3543120325,
0.3879612386,
0.5513154268,
0.3494563401,
-0.0837700143,
0.3526873589,
-0.141266048,
0.0186416581,
-0.0082867146,
-0.6838843822,
0.083565481,
-0.6889309287,
-0.2633780539,
-0.2233612984,
0.3425920606,
0.4855066836,
-0.0756585374,
0.8808711171,
0.6528353095,
-0.5290299058,
0.2134455144,
-0.512473762,
-0.0327490233,
-0.5143711567,
0.0260446053,
-0.1943120658,
-1.0279253721,
0.694503665,
0.1366399229,
0.3087360263,
0.2542587817,
0.2818306386,
-0.2278396189,
0.5421254635,
0.6143734455,
0.0185403861,
0.7128690481,
-0.1170383766,
0.2042594403,
-0.6212127209,
-0.2694934607,
-0.237108767,
-0.5239932537,
-0.5501122475,
-0.2708650231,
0.6586455107,
0.0108146127,
-0.4872517288,
0.2348623872,
-0.120759435,
0.4240865707,
0.6946899295,
0.1609908938,
0.1744732708,
-0.5082553029,
-0.0440288335,
0.4424209893,
-0.8030255437,
-0.7398157716,
1.0755603313,
0.0828542039,
0.5400536656,
0.3221644759,
0.6932148933,
0.8764219284,
0.5471771955,
-0.5136553049,
0.4485509992,
0.0503223166,
-1.0140397549,
-0.6207351089,
-0.4042186141,
-0.8149895072,
-0.2383897454,
-0.2095102817,
-0.8407023549,
0.3811061978,
0.2645736337,
-0.9269651175,
0.3383584023,
-0.9341718554,
1.1002709866,
-0.0451080389,
-0.5043931603,
-0.3647176921,
-0.6815880537,
0.2806090415,
0.2141356319,
0.5512779355,
-0.1646206677,
0.0472702309,
0.527230382,
-0.4137851596,
1.3082839251,
-0.4191691875,
0.0757522061,
0.4117536247,
0.1002205089,
0.2261752933,
0.6590552926,
-0.2176960111,
0.1087894067,
0.3987766504,
-0.6978674531,
-0.5060464144,
0.5443274975,
-0.961981535,
-0.5325537324,
-0.1263114512,
-0.9863295555,
-0.3682777584,
0.1771479249,
-0.3739233613,
0.4296065271,
-0.4435057342,
0.3963398337,
0.5659961104,
-0.1304174066,
0.2832852006,
0.198582381,
0.1733022779,
-0.0570003502,
0.5384682417,
0.1822009534,
-0.0171204638,
-0.0536046959,
0.2003936023,
-0.2897622883,
-0.156923607,
-0.2580262721,
-0.2486710101,
-0.8146733642,
-0.2086011469,
-0.5413960814,
-0.0763515383,
-0.9045329094,
-0.5940372944,
-0.2010221779,
-0.7468448877,
0.1067584082,
-0.3851215839,
0.7993828654,
0.6361623406,
-0.936340034,
-0.0566344447,
-0.9052640796,
0.3782632947,
0.7481657863,
0.4252551198,
-0.1727961302,
-0.5453798175,
-0.1605759859,
-0.2027914524,
0.266405642,
-0.8935590982,
0.0648394749,
0.1635937691,
0.6602445245,
0.6441911459,
0.4076399207,
0.3840174377,
-0.1704867929,
0.5696015358,
-0.0934960842,
-0.7791956067,
0.1736748368,
-0.350288868,
0.0141000384,
0.633166194,
0.3621909916,
-0.8856449723,
-0.1853413582,
-1.0112020969,
-0.9836606383,
0.4886734188,
-0.0540886521,
0.3631738126,
-0.0621298961,
0.5921829343,
-0.0377436727,
0.0672700629,
-0.4783793688,
0.0048853415,
-0.6778345704,
-0.2641468644,
-0.1193039492,
-0.2777764499,
-0.4062259793,
-0.4707567394,
0.396677196,
-0.2642259002,
0.0176663883,
0.2904348075,
-0.0792437121,
0.1292019933,
0.1276898831,
0.5175535679,
0.5866447687,
-0.2705085278,
0.415889442,
0.3274932802,
-0.1104999408,
0.0830433741,
0.3349385262,
-0.2616767883,
-0.438246578,
0.3711412847,
0.5964345336,
0.3402251899,
-0.7337349653,
0.300249964,
-0.2091584057,
-0.1079583392,
-0.7603094578,
0.0267213397,
0.1802878827,
0.8607469201,
0.0981726125,
0.3267562687,
0.0011035397,
-0.5126169324,
0.7119392157,
0.1751939356,
-0.5676787496,
-0.0217748508,
0.3631268144,
0.2576684356,
-0.3673967123,
0.9553535581,
-0.2583629489,
-0.2333553731,
0.8011481762,
0.2450520992,
0.5259290934,
-0.0700187534,
0.5223451853,
0.5051679015,
0.3718996346,
0.2419008315,
0.192891404,
-0.5899705887,
-1.204447031,
-0.0988134444,
-0.6691607833,
-0.4685890973,
-0.1016270071,
-0.75844872,
-0.1058484465,
-0.8403141499,
-0.1682621688,
0.1634629369,
-0.2770038545,
-0.812708497,
-0.155008778,
0.3027204573,
0.9377320409,
-0.8357130289,
0.743552804,
0.8520219326,
-0.5073414445,
-0.7807372212,
-0.2957248092,
0.3428922892,
-1.0892096758,
0.561340034,
-0.1079034656,
0.0736247748,
-0.2248171568,
-0.7919606566,
-0.6629695296,
0.8863192797,
0.049682159,
-0.1571366638,
-0.0514681488,
-0.1978560388,
0.4668954313,
-0.2778094113,
-0.1200789213,
0.7578231096,
1.0744814873,
-0.0018548633,
-0.6665155292,
0.1501156241,
-0.5500469208,
-0.2785025537,
-0.2647657692,
-0.653963089,
0.7097628713,
-0.4044110477,
0.4149499536,
-0.2446312755,
0.7310580611,
0.116308488,
0.398029238,
0.8858060837,
0.4651329219,
0.9262031913,
0.1225094497,
0.8485230207,
-0.3072449565,
0.021118192,
0.8469390869,
-0.2365424931,
0.2196940929,
0.6100088358,
0.1545926034,
0.500898838,
0.8420988321,
0.0415733792,
0.1861476898,
0.1414515823,
-0.1558867246,
-0.633820653,
-0.4957892895,
0.1672395468,
0.5859437585,
0.5372244716,
0.0070492593,
-0.2676735818,
-0.0404063687,
0.1071718559,
0.1812093705,
-0.3343752623,
0.7844384909,
0.0836061686,
-0.7648648024,
0.3487406671,
0.0867391676,
0.22717309,
-0.380851388,
-0.1292088032,
-0.4987530112,
0.0359500051,
-0.1306760758,
-0.8132949471,
0.5953383446,
0.0032921922,
-0.024131801,
-0.7354504466,
0.7926152945,
-0.0906879529,
-0.1709455848,
-0.0006639732,
0.6098456383,
-0.1136582494,
0.2297222018,
-0.6926171184,
-0.3909459412,
-0.3243030906,
-0.3334284723,
0.2302448153,
0.9111611247,
-0.4247895777,
0.4976685047,
0.4753469527,
-0.2476784438,
-0.1865809709,
-0.0911783874,
0.6491347551,
-0.5787412524,
-0.5545335412,
-0.5441907048,
0.2174169868,
-0.2925818563,
-0.3721057177,
0.4642494619,
0.0898736119,
0.753890574,
0.2396560162,
0.8593575358,
-0.4946231246,
-0.211497739,
-0.3250567317,
0.6598262191,
-0.5391665101,
0.0075320802,
-0.0059152809,
-0.4217411876,
-0.2634104192,
0.9117400646,
-0.4709462821,
-0.060525801,
0.0413752198,
0.4589731395,
-0.0539029017,
0.0539438538,
0.3501490057,
0.0653111041,
0.1110140905,
0.4262197018,
0.8067685962,
0.2910099924,
0.6686103344,
-0.129611671,
-0.3959632516,
-0.3021348119,
-0.8556469083,
-0.6530329585,
-0.9272403121,
-0.0287041888,
-0.4596137702,
-0.0234635882,
1.2974727154,
0.9032232761,
-0.6653369665,
-0.3269534707,
0.2704661191,
0.5620244145,
-0.5593751669,
-0.1548171639,
0.1040191278,
-0.5136312842,
-0.4185212255,
0.2035414577,
0.2300026417,
-0.1094903573,
-0.1829406172,
-0.1438206285,
-0.3309271932,
0.2734753191,
0.3096542954,
0.4454595149,
-0.1492538452,
-0.7665652633,
0.1225008443,
-0.1953284591,
-0.1379956305,
0.9727566242,
-0.4947814047,
0.1607211679,
0.4301497936,
0.7252177596,
0.3379761577,
-0.2043775022,
0.640345335,
-0.8888180256,
0.440079689,
0.3135739565,
0.5196560025,
0.0876335278,
-0.4383941591,
0.4520931542,
0.394019872,
-0.3772360384,
-0.5185267925,
0.4437734187,
-0.7731713653,
-0.5743301511,
1.0319850445,
-0.2435550541,
-0.3853363097,
-0.5831070542,
0.1200196221,
0.3887932003,
-0.53586936,
1.1046642065,
0.6923976541,
-0.1607985944,
-0.2841562033,
-0.521175921,
0.6616798043,
0.4081139863,
-0.6137200594,
0.0696801916,
0.7711917162,
0.1926472336,
0.3290961981,
0.769503057,
0.0921633691,
0.2956878245,
0.1114743724,
0.0588260852,
-0.4039932191,
-0.3892326951,
0.0098020863,
0.2516727149,
-0.0006243195,
0.2141178399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17006v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17006v1 | Zero-shot Visual Question Answering with Language Model Feedback | 2023-05-26T15:04:20 | 2023-05-26T15:04:20 | Yifan Du, Junyi Li, Tianyi Tang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a novel language model guided captioning approach,
LAMOC, for knowledge-based visual question answering (VQA). Our approach
employs the generated captions by a captioning model as the context of an
answer prediction model, which is a Pre-trained Language model (PLM). As the
major contribution, we leverage the guidance and feedback of the prediction
model to improve the capability of the captioning model. In this way, the
captioning model can become aware of the task goal and information need from
the PLM. To develop our approach, we design two specific training stages, where
the first stage adapts the captioning model to the prediction model (selecting
more suitable caption propositions for training) and the second stage tunes the
captioning model according to the task goal (learning from feedback of the
PLM). Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed
approach on the knowledge-based VQA task. Specifically, on the challenging
A-OKVQA dataset, LAMOC outperforms several competitive zero-shot methods and
even achieves comparable results to a fine-tuned VLP model. Our code is
publicly available at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/LAMOC. | [
-0.2339062691,
-0.7767152786,
0.5972427726,
-0.1066506207,
-0.5799010992,
-0.0065086964,
0.1695510596,
-0.2788718343,
0.0604296103,
1.0626516342,
-0.7332968712,
-0.5099301338,
-0.2038568556,
-0.0804392621,
-0.2455102503,
0.8618086576,
-0.2827770114,
0.4735378027,
-0.6094397306,
-0.2607239783,
-0.8723422885,
-0.4273509979,
-0.5155096054,
0.0347083546,
0.5739885569,
0.5776927471,
0.2286513895,
0.5913248062,
0.435284853,
0.1853061169,
0.1210367233,
0.0678996295,
-0.6266337633,
0.0047829188,
-0.064322263,
-0.7820757627,
-0.1889925897,
-0.1657934338,
0.4938854277,
0.3823491335,
-0.2473466545,
0.4687894583,
-0.475073576,
0.5101642609,
-0.5686903596,
0.1837842315,
-0.8448860645,
0.1351691335,
0.234840259,
-0.4922684431,
-0.5237612128,
-0.0306470096,
0.1405823231,
-0.8187556267,
0.1171155646,
0.2691144049,
0.9879492521,
0.5947662592,
-0.1352107376,
0.1002468169,
-0.5858759284,
0.7354662418,
-0.6865625978,
0.1318961978,
0.0415523164,
0.7935937643,
0.346996665,
-0.6395715475,
-0.890019834,
-0.2383284271,
0.3010379076,
0.355361253,
0.2126593888,
0.1264624149,
0.1264417619,
0.2588208914,
-0.5074497461,
-0.1813199669,
-0.7005224824,
-0.1429337412,
0.4264425933,
0.1826278865,
0.3200391829,
-0.1787010431,
-0.7761153579,
0.0412974507,
-0.7442786098,
0.3916151524,
-0.0920647457,
0.2380340397,
-0.0236714277,
0.6857267618,
-0.7078422308,
0.983780086,
-0.0839736685,
0.162710458,
0.0266931783,
-0.2160822898,
-0.3422418237,
-0.1242247671,
0.5431809425,
0.6189493537,
0.4383230805,
-0.0250773579,
-0.0171602964,
-0.302502811,
0.4959654808,
-0.7506014705,
-0.0448196903,
0.116898492,
-0.14321585,
-0.4020560086,
0.0927440897,
-0.5958089232,
-0.3534291089,
-0.3539367914,
0.8704579473,
-0.1363803893,
0.2768431306,
0.1942119002,
-0.0665898621,
0.8091481328,
0.8942582607,
-0.3933501244,
0.0821224079,
0.2521848083,
0.6421253681,
-0.065634802,
-0.3290715218,
-1.1714370251,
0.1215403602,
-0.2704767287,
0.7354576588,
-0.3408014774,
0.0134868938,
0.0335125364,
-0.0044080503,
-0.018717574,
-0.3362491727,
0.1495639384,
-0.8326202035,
0.4099336565,
-0.4195612669,
-0.4563647807,
-0.4731953442,
0.4034733474,
-0.595756948,
0.4661082327,
0.1723954827,
-0.6002908349,
0.1377972662,
-0.5910148025,
0.1075257957,
0.4568960965,
-0.1749550402,
-0.2627517879,
-0.0154001387,
0.5596037507,
0.253988862,
-0.2030261755,
0.056283433,
-0.3826992512,
-0.3622393608,
0.1644819677,
-0.0664265305,
0.6174753904,
0.0542275161,
-0.3284423053,
0.4063758552,
-0.5610038638,
0.2857804596,
0.1562947631,
0.0733205378,
0.1123546883,
-0.3333036005,
-0.296867907,
0.225583151,
0.1465091109,
-0.6773708463,
0.1778934449,
-0.1911759824,
0.2825301886,
0.53899014,
0.2451559156,
0.430195123,
-0.2090404928,
0.850980103,
-0.057351172,
0.5147512555,
-0.3436797559,
-0.4477318823,
-0.8613681197,
-0.0516712442,
0.3561691344,
0.7989596725,
-1.4482197762,
-0.4948650599,
0.0155984331,
-0.2720820606,
-0.6688441634,
0.29077968,
0.6179934144,
0.8229839802,
0.4510712326,
-0.7427644134,
-0.3892386258,
-0.5782060027,
0.261538595,
-0.5144364238,
0.1088290438,
0.5887249112,
0.3824209571,
0.2379736155,
0.6984218359,
-0.631046176,
-0.3361426294,
-0.3428667188,
0.1233834326,
-0.0895284787,
0.0480297208,
0.6267650723,
-0.7727780938,
-0.4780679345,
-0.0851124078,
-0.8313652277,
-0.0827378631,
-0.1122144908,
-0.2701691687,
0.0421279594,
0.5081351399,
-0.334956646,
0.4737905562,
0.2736734748,
-0.1028116122,
0.8045471907,
0.0935480893,
0.1578798443,
-0.6988757849,
0.0751326531,
-0.3360258043,
-0.3009545803,
-0.7801362872,
0.4321915507,
-0.0339440107,
-0.1929950416,
-1.053109169,
0.8051877618,
-0.2727671862,
0.1961045861,
-0.2728597224,
0.1177071482,
0.1036310866,
0.8930715322,
0.4561312795,
0.5871642232,
0.7041119337,
-0.2695104778,
0.6021296382,
0.348964721,
-0.2254452705,
0.6123492122,
-0.9309702516,
0.0042106588,
-0.5016597509,
-0.1606776416,
-1.1439709663,
-0.1135229617,
0.2849616408,
-0.7397524714,
0.1475790143,
-0.0847291201,
-0.0378258154,
-0.6242169142,
-0.279887259,
0.4186378419,
0.1903168708,
-0.2309914082,
0.3539041281,
0.0820537508,
-0.2898604274,
-0.9048889875,
-0.6398997307,
0.024047222,
0.1372369379,
-0.3614218831,
-0.1381005496,
-0.4486578703,
0.0818057209,
-0.0959712043,
-0.1122463048,
-0.393011719,
-0.1956233233,
0.2515844405,
0.5629324317,
-0.2755019963,
-0.0702329949,
-0.3545956314,
0.0983391479,
-0.0226363875,
-0.2896551192,
0.3769102097,
-0.238880083,
-0.236741066,
-0.4900273979,
0.2030988634,
0.656175673,
-0.5754884481,
0.547734201,
0.5336920619,
0.0131036257,
-0.3409979939,
-0.4842871428,
-0.1442045569,
-0.3954684734,
0.2340894192,
-0.0914475694,
-1.1379777193,
0.5430722833,
0.3717146218,
-0.1301923692,
-0.0700756162,
0.5508753657,
-0.4441458881,
0.5501225591,
1.0566635132,
0.1174702942,
0.5904366374,
-0.4134328961,
0.0719138607,
-0.5396159291,
-0.1898547709,
-0.0481574535,
0.0299407877,
-0.0200831722,
-0.5833924413,
0.3675657213,
0.3725775182,
-0.2840880752,
0.2737633288,
-0.378378123,
0.391978085,
0.9156745076,
0.1302106231,
0.0832686797,
0.0673922375,
-0.1088732481,
0.1881113052,
-0.9238590002,
-0.0726560354,
1.174559474,
0.0495778322,
0.5595867634,
-0.2241649479,
0.5285226107,
0.1034961939,
0.3376263082,
-0.73134619,
0.6417623758,
0.0369621664,
-0.5960157514,
-0.6878581643,
-0.4213392138,
-0.4312311709,
-0.0112020755,
-0.0866049379,
-0.6824046969,
0.1361105293,
0.2240423262,
-0.5768954754,
0.2405463159,
-0.467505604,
1.1004803181,
-0.4094229937,
-0.5415940881,
0.2656511366,
-0.9117082953,
0.4322671294,
0.2472635061,
-0.0712737888,
0.1512446553,
0.1437372714,
0.4584892094,
-0.598254621,
0.925973773,
-0.3992432058,
0.1251173168,
0.8933896422,
0.0289031081,
0.0667153448,
0.0633143708,
0.0515089668,
-0.0764183179,
0.2838647366,
-0.5510334373,
-0.7830550671,
0.2948321402,
-0.6874301434,
-0.7675142884,
-0.1592753381,
-0.6969276667,
-0.2539761961,
0.2849062383,
-0.0119778533,
0.5089419484,
0.1725860238,
0.2723552585,
0.6318543553,
-0.3837710619,
0.4172763228,
0.9399171472,
-0.4327208698,
-0.7642118931,
0.9571354389,
-0.0418775193,
0.5390700102,
0.830907464,
-0.0980320275,
-0.2009438276,
-0.6380547881,
-0.9850606918,
0.3706351519,
-0.6330090761,
-0.349462837,
-0.1674105972,
-0.4411596954,
-0.2172318399,
-0.1671956033,
-0.1838223487,
-0.3172982633,
-0.1621567905,
-0.164330259,
0.2729150653,
0.5195319057,
0.3284451962,
0.4922667444,
-0.7026056647,
0.4612631798,
0.8100450039,
0.4372972846,
-0.0549485497,
-0.6111571789,
-0.1629355848,
0.0949586779,
-0.2830815613,
-0.9766051173,
0.4214763641,
0.1500719786,
0.4131233394,
0.2673558891,
0.1821222305,
0.6417355537,
-0.47645697,
1.1500407457,
0.2997618616,
-0.8054858446,
0.6311654449,
-0.4917223454,
0.7004750967,
0.7140660286,
0.1833581924,
-0.5086695552,
-0.3579673767,
-0.2328504175,
-0.6020076275,
0.6036854982,
0.0682945251,
0.1205659136,
0.4036422968,
0.6410446167,
-0.0075678555,
0.8250158429,
-1.0033255816,
-0.1689257622,
-0.4951356351,
0.1028753743,
0.1967084259,
-0.219338581,
-0.1680425406,
-0.3412051499,
0.4959175885,
-0.4344915152,
0.1925022602,
0.3823747337,
-0.2148914635,
-0.3943824172,
0.058481928,
0.7943453193,
0.8015042543,
-0.3011817634,
-0.1059104875,
0.2042189986,
-0.272103548,
-0.0907690004,
-0.2038094699,
-0.7132133245,
0.0821330994,
0.3398346901,
1.1663166285,
-0.146817252,
-0.9560893178,
0.8114657402,
-0.1337897032,
-0.4207290709,
-0.0770510957,
0.0755863413,
-0.2063272446,
0.220621556,
0.3516446054,
-0.1184631735,
-0.0055331877,
-0.5936282277,
0.3313098252,
0.4084834456,
-0.9619163871,
-0.1577884555,
0.9873412251,
0.1362165511,
-0.1639118344,
0.2335160226,
-0.0972685963,
-0.6437741518,
0.7752677798,
0.1340392083,
0.57936728,
-0.1332579404,
0.9415096641,
0.4646496773,
0.2982543707,
0.2771989405,
0.687464118,
-0.2486123741,
-0.5215041637,
-0.6468973756,
-0.6760118604,
-0.6398619413,
0.196498543,
-0.7460218668,
0.2613806427,
-0.4836753309,
0.2382169664,
-0.2334976494,
0.0110636577,
-0.5806697011,
0.4942092597,
0.4176636636,
0.771679759,
-0.5819197893,
0.8125964999,
0.7385522723,
-0.9421192408,
-0.8214583397,
-0.3107991219,
-0.0188997518,
-1.0034396648,
0.5892032385,
0.0716838017,
0.0182883646,
-0.0727768242,
-1.0174285173,
-0.8655179739,
1.2570698261,
0.4570852816,
-0.4475803673,
0.0429004841,
0.3382338583,
0.7557890415,
-0.5473912954,
0.2390130311,
-0.1206285357,
0.2395261526,
0.6435027719,
-0.9001213312,
-0.1846985668,
-0.3354997635,
0.073230572,
-0.3057085276,
-0.6694149375,
0.549354732,
-0.5600994229,
-0.1690739989,
0.4612340629,
0.7616860867,
0.1015636474,
0.4212203026,
0.3269772828,
0.4672550857,
0.4106669426,
0.1014711186,
1.1122765541,
-0.2842108905,
0.1668531299,
1.5276540518,
-0.1802407801,
1.1528526545,
0.7142187357,
0.1916565597,
0.6081193089,
0.3786399066,
-0.1091680974,
0.7336613536,
0.2236488312,
-0.0234033,
-0.4077611864,
-0.4034985602,
-0.0688379779,
0.3799542487,
-0.2234845012,
-0.1772345752,
-0.2041875571,
0.0694927052,
-0.3192461729,
0.1135415211,
-0.6636683941,
0.7892936468,
-0.0144994771,
-0.7574691176,
0.7809109688,
-0.4366571903,
0.1408675164,
-0.6213118434,
-0.21976915,
-0.2677805722,
-0.2224060595,
0.0877265111,
-0.8735437989,
0.0232471339,
-0.0531268157,
-0.2609682977,
-0.2115958035,
0.4287818074,
-0.7966249585,
-0.5191776752,
0.0731283948,
0.8183579445,
-0.0237101372,
-0.186343357,
-0.4812498987,
-0.1975899637,
0.2577260435,
0.0755540058,
-0.1006315127,
0.2155358791,
-0.0867320299,
0.8372513056,
0.4363766909,
0.0469214804,
0.2999664247,
0.2294899523,
0.6795545816,
-0.5020657778,
-0.2237012237,
-0.3073129058,
0.7745599747,
0.0177637134,
-0.2655460238,
0.539490521,
0.123781167,
0.9508081079,
-0.5325367451,
0.5862694979,
0.1840722859,
0.2566858232,
-0.4129478931,
0.6133015156,
-0.7623946667,
0.133745417,
-0.1444862336,
-0.7746631503,
-0.5869734287,
0.0132241854,
-0.4640004933,
-0.3151808381,
0.5954255462,
0.9338256121,
0.3515681326,
-0.2890323102,
0.5243878961,
0.210764423,
-0.0364946574,
0.6750168204,
0.7821747661,
-0.4441957474,
0.80616045,
-0.4321071208,
0.0235088654,
-0.1947694719,
-0.7174939513,
-0.8035108447,
-0.6131649017,
-0.4704791009,
0.0614842623,
0.2667406797,
0.184654668,
0.8301800489,
-0.9661322832,
-0.2210668325,
-0.066002436,
0.1399526,
-0.3093565404,
-0.2941229045,
0.0768286064,
-0.1564270258,
-0.4304707348,
0.0210018512,
0.4287552536,
-0.1568801701,
-0.1651941389,
-0.107395947,
-0.1842350662,
0.3228280246,
0.6688463092,
0.5752845407,
-0.8638545871,
-0.5460678935,
0.3983733654,
0.0991995782,
0.1143540218,
0.5012127757,
-0.8305296302,
1.0044058561,
0.5378655195,
0.6544488072,
0.651653111,
0.1892503947,
0.7167096734,
-0.6576886773,
-0.1214198843,
0.1534654647,
0.1431454122,
0.3467145264,
-0.2964457273,
0.4371165633,
0.2258209735,
-0.2273465991,
-0.7663491964,
0.2467994541,
-1.4538139105,
-0.2132385075,
0.9813630581,
-0.1585882157,
-0.5663778186,
0.2823616862,
-0.5680384636,
0.0902281031,
-0.115220435,
0.7192132473,
0.5058301687,
0.0124184722,
-0.8890146613,
-0.7256772518,
0.2502961457,
0.5948213339,
-0.7480003834,
-0.1106605828,
0.5497213006,
0.2864505053,
0.0775350034,
0.5910716653,
-0.1006482989,
0.8017823696,
-0.2277241051,
0.5173189044,
-0.4821230173,
-0.5263742208,
-0.3675698638,
0.4529235363,
0.0754180104,
-0.3951477408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17002v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17002v1 | An Empirical Comparison of LM-based Question and Answer Generation Methods | 2023-05-26T14:59:53 | 2023-05-26T14:59:53 | Asahi Ushio, Fernando Alva-Manchego, Jose Camacho-Collados | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question and answer generation (QAG) consists of generating a set of
question-answer pairs given a context (e.g. a paragraph). This task has a
variety of applications, such as data augmentation for question answering (QA)
models, information retrieval and education. In this paper, we establish
baselines with three different QAG methodologies that leverage
sequence-to-sequence language model (LM) fine-tuning. Experiments show that an
end-to-end QAG model, which is computationally light at both training and
inference times, is generally robust and outperforms other more convoluted
approaches. However, there are differences depending on the underlying
generative LM. Finally, our analysis shows that QA models fine-tuned solely on
generated question-answer pairs can be competitive when compared to supervised
QA models trained on human-labeled data. | [
-0.5890081525,
-1.1692965031,
0.5290667415,
-0.3689628839,
-0.1249815524,
0.087950334,
-0.0088849114,
-0.4963576794,
-0.388386637,
0.3117201924,
-0.4074282646,
-0.1587577164,
-0.0258763414,
0.1840808988,
-0.3475023508,
0.9660773277,
0.3058421612,
0.0897203758,
-0.6069981456,
-0.1006962806,
-0.6057840586,
-0.368347317,
-0.5725905895,
-0.3592777252,
0.5059258342,
0.3922072947,
0.9656512141,
0.539466083,
0.3894226551,
0.1837685853,
-0.1328524947,
0.4078346491,
-0.4956631958,
0.1947306395,
-0.2372622639,
-0.5408610702,
-0.1492122114,
-0.1275817454,
0.5587540865,
0.8169152141,
-0.0480993129,
0.6353861094,
0.2248842716,
0.5985915661,
-0.7037411332,
-0.2966100872,
-0.7548589706,
-0.2121270448,
0.2302392721,
-0.388093859,
-0.3904967308,
-0.7954079509,
0.1620468199,
-0.4313991368,
0.3141849637,
0.1914922744,
0.8737617135,
0.2205587178,
-0.3120459318,
-0.4040551484,
-0.6823414564,
0.6057103276,
-0.9925196171,
0.196316123,
0.2387074083,
0.2473626435,
-0.2034550756,
-0.6809725165,
-0.5534952879,
0.0719602481,
-0.0631326139,
0.0533679202,
0.1646680236,
0.1183465719,
0.3512108326,
0.4939066172,
-0.826158464,
0.2400701493,
-0.327897042,
0.2937834263,
0.6656143665,
0.2385378033,
0.1747996807,
-0.1951577067,
-0.2174758166,
-0.1276704818,
-0.9010292888,
0.4337084293,
0.3014844656,
0.319899708,
0.2487321645,
0.6384310126,
-0.4743787944,
1.0867204666,
0.321174711,
-0.091276288,
-0.078611359,
-0.4333271384,
-0.4168309569,
-0.3477884531,
0.5341379642,
0.5596159101,
0.2628895342,
-0.4345651865,
-0.1061707512,
-0.089625746,
0.0549604408,
-0.8648400307,
-0.094958365,
0.4881657064,
-0.3637780249,
-0.2018969804,
-0.0719479024,
-0.5404762626,
-0.1611597538,
-0.403105408,
0.7764216661,
-0.2826125622,
0.0690397397,
0.0876479372,
-0.0995156616,
0.9187906981,
0.1609369367,
-0.6501917243,
-0.0821427107,
0.654515028,
0.5507727861,
-0.1296836287,
0.0554641671,
-0.6277750731,
-0.1339963078,
-0.6386233568,
0.7856423259,
-0.4246433079,
-0.4088704586,
0.3086507618,
-0.2254449874,
0.0893471017,
-0.800042212,
0.3752484918,
-0.8730758429,
0.6483901739,
-0.4553435147,
-0.9031348825,
0.0082609244,
0.0872905701,
-0.4137929678,
1.0402148962,
0.1264497191,
-0.5930412412,
0.4337271154,
-0.0672132894,
-0.2822345495,
0.2227794528,
-0.153331995,
-0.4091183543,
0.0835877433,
0.1609527171,
0.5455938578,
-0.5975810289,
0.3538759053,
-0.1878109425,
-0.4298217297,
0.3641330302,
-0.2880803347,
0.5096850395,
0.4462123513,
0.1227632612,
-0.0001301496,
-0.9286209345,
0.5618698597,
0.1764922589,
-0.684833765,
-0.2063822001,
0.1494177282,
-0.3095745146,
0.3835110664,
0.2699987888,
-0.3197914958,
-0.0491837971,
-0.4409278631,
0.4977199137,
0.4041262269,
0.2711462379,
0.2798034549,
-0.6862542033,
0.4952611029,
-0.2489748597,
-0.116455853,
-0.5123570561,
-0.3669292033,
-0.7507225275,
0.2605159879,
0.4288738668,
0.6580217481,
-0.8942689896,
0.3755016029,
-0.1088874862,
-0.4625757635,
-0.7538151145,
0.1183880568,
0.6144305468,
0.726739049,
0.4032018185,
-0.1851109713,
-0.2740758657,
-0.6995547414,
-0.312689364,
-0.3168250024,
-0.0896587968,
0.3785503805,
0.0193103738,
0.3853645325,
0.9509468079,
-0.397529304,
0.524045229,
-0.1518270522,
0.0705306754,
0.0861558542,
0.4469441772,
0.4825323522,
-0.6620479226,
-0.4846427441,
-0.1314708441,
-0.7970644236,
-0.1735879332,
-0.1186630651,
-0.0562506504,
0.0504318923,
0.4536101222,
-0.3313977122,
0.267462939,
0.2241469622,
-0.3482735157,
0.3981619775,
-0.0177953318,
0.2653190494,
-1.2850823402,
0.1874295026,
-0.1989018917,
-0.2998909056,
-1.0491921902,
0.5249122381,
0.1238865331,
-0.1455607712,
-0.4800685048,
0.5361940265,
-0.3582529724,
-0.1243010238,
-0.2177744508,
0.1813359708,
0.2496063411,
0.5659022927,
-0.164407298,
1.1031558514,
0.1950931549,
-0.7049438953,
0.1516688615,
0.3955939412,
-0.3905453682,
0.3768721223,
-1.0757335424,
0.3813531101,
-0.2820158601,
-0.2322354466,
-1.2702801228,
-0.1727058887,
-0.2077011615,
-0.5597958565,
0.2433554828,
0.0797852427,
-0.5173529387,
-0.1890225112,
-0.3861864805,
0.5722814798,
0.917783916,
-0.5424293876,
-0.1848132461,
-0.0296633989,
-0.3333755434,
-0.3359270394,
-0.4040271342,
-0.1391553134,
-0.4035772979,
-0.6196264625,
0.159743011,
-0.2268668562,
-0.2883199155,
-0.2764114141,
0.0666086152,
-0.0491901524,
0.153283,
-0.0777665079,
0.119219102,
-0.5149008036,
0.3855178654,
0.149655655,
0.3890193105,
-0.089013733,
0.0005518198,
0.589689672,
0.0345469862,
-0.2181301564,
-0.1087172627,
0.5495125651,
0.2031048983,
-0.5038273335,
0.6626945138,
0.1450979263,
-0.1912850738,
-0.0790632516,
-0.5507240891,
-0.2015327513,
-0.4463163912,
0.0695910379,
-0.2656952739,
-0.9983941913,
0.4832449853,
-0.0148117552,
0.2942432463,
0.3078457117,
0.5771067142,
-0.1569967419,
1.1748996973,
0.5015003681,
0.2362695485,
0.4856033325,
-0.0156201972,
0.0101266513,
-0.7280136943,
-0.1307685226,
-0.6919571161,
-0.1977213621,
-0.5210306048,
-0.2978975475,
0.3748170435,
0.775447607,
-0.2612218261,
0.1277128309,
-0.4179751277,
0.40999493,
0.6959996819,
-0.0038065996,
0.3272477686,
-0.1033246443,
0.2129352391,
0.3268434703,
-1.0412105322,
-0.6790318489,
1.2702775002,
0.1856639236,
0.5635610223,
0.0719174817,
0.6325198412,
0.1066268831,
-0.0772233158,
-0.4593958557,
0.444178611,
0.0942489952,
-0.4441184103,
-0.4860700369,
-0.1615273803,
-0.9526097775,
0.2774497271,
-0.3472698629,
-0.5538914204,
0.2834058404,
0.2089184672,
-0.6712909341,
-0.0319778845,
-0.7239649296,
0.6257781386,
-0.0160186253,
-0.6459169388,
0.1369915605,
-0.8390744328,
0.2865858972,
-0.0204063598,
-0.1265666485,
-0.0675859451,
0.2831110656,
0.4944547415,
-0.3844493926,
0.5501446128,
-0.0532473922,
-0.416431278,
0.7287686467,
-0.1942609102,
0.4728367925,
0.1374561787,
-0.125972867,
-0.4008627236,
0.124132894,
-0.5775321126,
-0.5754725933,
0.4519797862,
-0.6612457037,
-0.6722124219,
0.1145487055,
-0.7356107831,
-0.488366574,
0.0620550811,
0.396093905,
0.6490605474,
-0.1654351354,
0.123255223,
0.8804665208,
-0.519803524,
0.491890192,
0.4314850867,
-0.1467756778,
-0.1971075684,
0.6526788473,
0.0858720839,
0.7608044147,
0.4359541237,
-0.0426603779,
-0.3544207215,
-0.5835466981,
-0.6374239922,
0.0175028089,
-0.5615316033,
-0.3697753549,
-0.3530206382,
-0.370141983,
-0.507915616,
-0.1629431099,
0.1550298631,
-0.4962562919,
-0.2282336056,
-0.1063639,
0.2989811301,
0.4139096141,
0.2423683852,
0.206670329,
-0.5982751846,
0.5272735357,
0.7458069324,
0.0767835006,
-0.0742482543,
-0.5866361856,
-0.1936535537,
0.2538707852,
-0.3920702934,
-0.995131433,
0.0127263358,
0.523522377,
0.2933984399,
0.210605979,
0.0287016816,
0.7682795525,
-0.5159654617,
0.9921473265,
-0.1259047389,
-0.5754384398,
0.6750641465,
-0.3740183115,
0.4616351128,
0.4867534339,
0.1046317369,
-0.3384324014,
-0.4182972312,
-0.4813211262,
-0.7945824265,
0.2154048234,
0.0339295268,
0.2073297501,
-0.2171940356,
0.6961093545,
0.2999818623,
0.4268092811,
-0.3132993281,
-0.0761899948,
0.0374096781,
-0.1150901392,
-0.1563699245,
-0.1898378283,
-0.0111354217,
0.0130118364,
0.4112269282,
-0.3486044109,
0.0624560229,
0.3214693964,
-0.1305392236,
-0.2173240483,
0.5805248618,
0.5451305509,
0.8211565018,
-0.1972923279,
-0.0227300711,
0.2870245874,
0.1208271459,
0.2011427581,
0.0967092514,
-0.6570931077,
-0.0352405757,
0.3935317993,
0.8448109627,
-0.2560512424,
-0.9016669393,
0.157983318,
0.1835901141,
-0.2019436359,
0.2332240641,
0.3357163966,
0.0056239902,
0.368026644,
0.3259464204,
-0.56875664,
0.2855247557,
-0.6916804314,
0.1307374537,
0.7026021481,
-0.0839295164,
-0.1771828532,
0.7752721906,
0.0907334015,
-0.3595306873,
0.189789474,
-0.1631046832,
0.0563557483,
0.7248746753,
0.6447922587,
0.5965873003,
-0.1596954614,
0.2797948122,
0.3130119741,
-0.0701027811,
0.082984224,
0.660078764,
-0.1996443868,
-0.6473819017,
-0.4245278537,
-0.6088042855,
-0.3215859234,
0.2776112556,
-0.9551134109,
-0.0903841704,
-0.2341279835,
0.0121281333,
-0.0557629913,
0.0608609244,
-0.7176292539,
0.5891608596,
-0.125117451,
0.7306160331,
-0.6113279462,
0.5774050951,
0.9736835957,
-0.402453512,
-0.8010761738,
0.1782600284,
-0.5971845984,
-0.7328725457,
0.2055132687,
-0.0249332059,
0.0751979873,
0.2731006444,
-0.6039792895,
-0.6415506601,
1.2624912262,
0.2375947982,
-0.4857780933,
-0.2455228865,
0.4295109212,
0.7342470288,
-0.1833658814,
0.0086927637,
0.652980268,
-0.0857213065,
-0.1156731248,
-0.7502937317,
-0.088722907,
-0.2023338079,
0.2226903141,
0.2721212208,
-0.7504320145,
0.7543311715,
-0.2400809526,
-0.3962791562,
0.5192126632,
0.8143758774,
0.4336490333,
0.35873124,
0.1940353513,
0.4790101349,
0.5696154833,
-0.0628690794,
0.8177827597,
-0.5986936092,
0.2473391742,
0.980394721,
-0.2041668445,
0.884100914,
0.4633191228,
-0.203660965,
0.2040895671,
0.8222116828,
0.1675881147,
0.578633666,
0.2812329829,
-0.1023918465,
-0.2776995003,
-0.2239959836,
-0.5728464127,
0.1025436148,
0.1695658267,
-0.1904824674,
-0.226750493,
-0.1976196468,
-0.1374394149,
0.3304356039,
-0.5226799846,
1.1011788845,
-0.0114137493,
-1.1303347349,
0.9469771981,
0.0368123241,
0.4063382745,
-0.1479575783,
0.0664187521,
-0.578306675,
-0.2971194386,
-0.0581833422,
-0.8752319813,
0.0090255272,
0.206413269,
-0.2405173182,
0.1098891348,
0.9040725231,
-0.760078907,
-0.3021712005,
-0.3107113838,
0.9440740347,
-0.1239554062,
0.2611068785,
-0.5137146711,
-0.5074076056,
-0.2196449488,
-0.2255476415,
0.247225076,
0.330403477,
-0.0251915827,
0.5686994791,
0.532256484,
-0.1383631378,
0.4717927575,
-0.0977132171,
0.6722062826,
-0.5003484488,
-0.2832992971,
-0.6470778584,
0.5288066268,
0.073854059,
-0.4301810861,
0.6754745841,
0.54962641,
0.80632025,
-0.006844616,
0.8478057981,
0.0154934693,
0.7611330748,
-0.7761232853,
0.2017835677,
-0.5883632302,
0.0911237374,
-0.1717839688,
-0.8653035164,
-0.0275323335,
0.1873788238,
-0.0674425513,
0.1804242283,
0.233317256,
0.7652688026,
0.1884533614,
-0.2893408239,
0.4255849421,
-0.2475626469,
0.1721791774,
0.7319194078,
1.0430021286,
-0.5179846883,
0.2443727404,
0.0607431866,
0.1021593213,
-0.1430784464,
-0.5623216033,
-0.9669276476,
-0.470572114,
-0.1990539432,
-0.2356718779,
0.296574384,
0.6472472548,
0.3763801455,
-0.7839145064,
-0.1264819652,
-0.1693249941,
0.0047165398,
-0.0829164535,
-0.186252445,
0.2736940086,
-0.7610120177,
-0.7200943232,
0.2766185105,
0.0168256517,
0.1181179285,
-0.2587620318,
-0.0028592434,
-0.1123114973,
0.5459612012,
0.5771719217,
0.4712086022,
-0.6481789351,
-0.4100578427,
0.2807907462,
-0.1062333807,
0.187060684,
0.5885122418,
-0.8872820735,
0.3320488334,
0.7866930366,
0.8385350704,
-0.0280445684,
0.6406515241,
0.7398931384,
-0.8874176145,
-0.1492517591,
-0.0240866449,
0.0363647565,
0.3228081763,
-0.1883260757,
0.4840464592,
-0.2817822993,
-0.8315259814,
-1.000617981,
0.4651817083,
-0.5731476545,
-0.4451248646,
1.2753927708,
-0.0372965895,
0.301004976,
-0.0325891376,
-0.2037080526,
0.3620295227,
-0.0550585948,
0.6900958419,
0.5456197858,
-0.1885133535,
-0.1233589128,
-0.5946624875,
0.8277992606,
0.7300117016,
-1.0548114777,
-0.1492052972,
0.4482637644,
0.1351181269,
0.0110855028,
0.3529007137,
0.2004634142,
0.465436846,
-0.3825544119,
-0.075905785,
0.0100944191,
-0.1654284745,
-0.481949091,
0.468858093,
0.5252575874,
-0.2796983719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16986v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16986v3 | NavGPT: Explicit Reasoning in Vision-and-Language Navigation with Large Language Models | 2023-05-26T14:41:06 | 2023-10-19T17:59:43 | Gengze Zhou, Yicong Hong, Qi Wu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO | Trained with an unprecedented scale of data, large language models (LLMs)
like ChatGPT and GPT-4 exhibit the emergence of significant reasoning abilities
from model scaling. Such a trend underscored the potential of training LLMs
with unlimited language data, advancing the development of a universal embodied
agent. In this work, we introduce the NavGPT, a purely LLM-based
instruction-following navigation agent, to reveal the reasoning capability of
GPT models in complex embodied scenes by performing zero-shot sequential action
prediction for vision-and-language navigation (VLN). At each step, NavGPT takes
the textual descriptions of visual observations, navigation history, and future
explorable directions as inputs to reason the agent's current status, and makes
the decision to approach the target. Through comprehensive experiments, we
demonstrate NavGPT can explicitly perform high-level planning for navigation,
including decomposing instruction into sub-goal, integrating commonsense
knowledge relevant to navigation task resolution, identifying landmarks from
observed scenes, tracking navigation progress, and adapting to exceptions with
plan adjustment. Furthermore, we show that LLMs is capable of generating
high-quality navigational instructions from observations and actions along a
path, as well as drawing accurate top-down metric trajectory given the agent's
navigation history. Despite the performance of using NavGPT to zero-shot R2R
tasks still falling short of trained models, we suggest adapting multi-modality
inputs for LLMs to use as visual navigation agents and applying the explicit
reasoning of LLMs to benefit learning-based models. | [
-0.1999710947,
-0.7044656873,
1.0665912628,
-0.0456816219,
-0.1077364013,
-0.0974803939,
-0.1050800756,
-0.1722521484,
-0.1009620279,
0.7597859502,
-0.6084707975,
-0.6079270244,
-0.2988450825,
-0.3994706273,
-0.1280623674,
0.79330194,
-0.1014123112,
-0.0528195798,
0.0556024462,
-0.0170946456,
-0.7373231053,
-0.5892961025,
-0.5970976353,
-0.4084575176,
0.680758059,
0.3787026703,
0.869661212,
0.5079676509,
0.1661453098,
0.2417695373,
0.2857898474,
0.2599119246,
-0.3388275802,
0.2243143469,
-0.5419431925,
-0.406104207,
-0.5857215524,
-0.3700348139,
0.5277248621,
0.3677607179,
-0.0716564357,
-0.2362916321,
-0.233497113,
0.4815556109,
-0.5324674845,
0.495226413,
-0.2860341966,
0.1089831889,
0.2351027429,
-0.303141892,
-0.4924783111,
0.0543619692,
0.1777859479,
-0.7761199474,
-0.0450510234,
0.0848890021,
0.5762580633,
0.5233703256,
-0.6015079618,
-0.1771452874,
-0.7732355595,
0.6380101442,
-0.314124167,
0.5833300352,
0.089482896,
0.4083636403,
-0.1485677212,
-0.6250541806,
-0.3782593012,
-0.5007092953,
0.0940763652,
0.3953798413,
-0.0845316201,
0.2832662165,
0.251445502,
-0.2372968644,
-0.9543557167,
0.0439605005,
-0.241926387,
-0.0930382535,
0.4887117147,
0.1124986783,
0.3690839708,
0.0274953265,
-0.7078989744,
-0.0927613601,
-0.8678802848,
-0.0673657134,
-0.2596565187,
0.229052335,
-0.0014230114,
0.7280567288,
-0.3788621724,
0.797908783,
-0.2022822201,
0.0634151921,
-0.2063475549,
-0.116283074,
-0.2598564923,
0.1179531142,
0.535318017,
0.4738461375,
0.541057229,
-0.2741526663,
-0.3922550976,
-0.0248096362,
0.3375415802,
-0.6090166569,
-0.2127095312,
0.0076345047,
0.0562934764,
0.1751756966,
-0.2545664012,
-0.4855153859,
-0.339073956,
-0.4405864775,
0.5787178874,
-0.4404144287,
-0.2207054049,
0.4033842981,
0.0874111801,
0.9229910374,
0.7986983657,
-0.5487125516,
-0.0641690716,
0.6542613506,
0.7060782313,
0.0217704084,
-0.4787659347,
-0.6116722226,
0.3428474665,
-0.5305062532,
0.8867540956,
-0.6563603878,
-0.4547286034,
-0.033521276,
0.0291041378,
-0.2026429623,
0.0745218173,
0.4808359444,
-0.5577844381,
-0.1395348459,
-0.3474546075,
-0.3196124732,
-0.6433483362,
0.5794692636,
-0.3251021206,
0.6762803793,
-0.0455582216,
-0.1201894879,
0.316167593,
-0.7453222275,
-0.4769905508,
0.3403054774,
-0.3260336518,
0.1332837343,
-0.1217871085,
0.4143326581,
0.5769453645,
-0.1752885133,
0.1712916791,
0.0984069854,
-0.5217148066,
-0.162316218,
-0.636256814,
0.3261558115,
-0.141413644,
-0.5711500645,
0.1233646125,
-0.3620858788,
-0.0201757308,
0.2879579663,
-0.3748278618,
-0.0697342157,
0.1650999635,
-0.3364787996,
0.1427396536,
0.2688306868,
-0.2141283751,
0.6859788299,
-0.1628869027,
0.0580797903,
0.6759685278,
0.1037359387,
0.6814744473,
-0.0271599926,
0.7054868937,
-0.3589630723,
0.2542420328,
-0.4265471399,
-0.792662859,
-1.0534969568,
0.0616655387,
-0.161723718,
0.7987954021,
-1.2666074038,
-0.0960905924,
-0.5268007517,
-0.2903236449,
0.1257063597,
-0.2877285182,
0.5484326482,
0.32270509,
0.4356595278,
-0.1271336824,
-0.1871014237,
-0.4460081458,
-0.005431327,
-0.3513779342,
-0.0050437404,
0.3154979944,
0.590495348,
-0.1622449309,
0.5591911674,
-0.4360430837,
-0.0449530184,
-0.4600772858,
0.1071269363,
-0.1061149165,
0.3269949257,
0.3161610365,
-0.8201897144,
-0.25945732,
0.2910723388,
-0.9377593994,
0.0895853862,
-0.5248714685,
-0.4244565964,
-0.0159913413,
0.5976524353,
-0.6437439919,
0.6799542904,
0.2664930224,
-0.4771351516,
0.3729878366,
-0.3831098378,
0.073349297,
-0.5806049705,
-0.2419610471,
0.0792164579,
-0.2390843928,
-0.773458004,
0.3170539141,
-0.0293837786,
0.0264399126,
-0.4365990758,
0.8031715155,
-0.6600747108,
-0.3334764838,
-0.362026602,
0.1492865533,
-0.0747383013,
0.9731822014,
0.6266123652,
0.6669163108,
0.7357659936,
-0.5781242251,
0.5588434339,
0.2100283504,
-0.0491873659,
0.5453647375,
-0.6352744699,
0.0945136547,
-0.1738805324,
0.2442999035,
-0.827675879,
-0.2496575415,
0.3692418635,
-0.4155183434,
0.3448166251,
-0.6855567694,
-0.3211224973,
0.0028617298,
0.2776411176,
0.2972137332,
0.5137463808,
-0.4842062294,
0.9991210699,
-0.107787773,
-0.1871752888,
-0.5139160156,
-0.6623401642,
0.312361151,
0.1572342515,
-0.5433558226,
-0.1744870245,
-0.0493336432,
-0.0053517846,
-0.1730834097,
-0.1191487238,
-0.0205705296,
-0.2172257006,
0.4307574332,
0.5265617967,
-0.3220634162,
0.1537888646,
-0.1326387376,
-0.2093470395,
-0.0040721926,
-0.5836905241,
0.3701850474,
-0.4601642489,
-0.7587090135,
0.0050591454,
0.1344231665,
0.6290448904,
-0.4426316917,
0.2776203752,
0.4272340834,
0.1110680476,
-0.2269399166,
-0.3328381777,
0.0318369083,
-0.4122829735,
0.454366982,
-0.5142536759,
-0.5710533261,
0.1581297964,
-0.1899677813,
0.1869687289,
0.090746671,
0.4828923643,
0.2064572126,
0.8987825513,
0.3885933161,
0.2805720866,
0.4030334353,
-0.490201056,
0.0516163297,
-0.7989311814,
-0.5029155612,
0.1186710149,
-0.2539310157,
-0.43244192,
-1.0214245319,
0.587872684,
-0.261549741,
-0.5770472884,
0.0917048082,
-0.4422284365,
0.7255125642,
0.6495711803,
0.0478601344,
0.2734756172,
-0.0830163211,
-0.2818574905,
0.3119267225,
-0.777048111,
-0.4234513938,
0.8575035334,
0.0560883917,
0.8576505184,
0.0444463529,
0.4542170167,
0.0850906447,
0.1140339524,
-1.086400032,
0.9383686781,
0.2170007676,
-0.5270807147,
-0.3843605518,
-0.1967634261,
-0.7069121599,
0.5976769328,
-0.0947933644,
-0.5300590396,
0.2463934869,
-0.1140922159,
-0.2450668812,
0.3895618916,
-0.5813472867,
0.8722186089,
-0.6629320383,
-0.5347660184,
0.1144661233,
-0.8088564277,
0.2694739699,
0.2638112903,
-0.0837963596,
0.0212264694,
-0.344624579,
0.1998465955,
-0.188544333,
0.8775392175,
-0.3218016028,
-0.1616124511,
0.4043827951,
0.480001986,
0.5486631393,
-0.176637888,
0.3032476902,
0.132306993,
-0.4647337198,
-0.3975280523,
-0.7634727955,
0.5892793536,
-0.4607307613,
-0.6117932796,
-0.5902209878,
-0.4578872621,
-0.1976468265,
0.1981679648,
0.0340076722,
0.555308938,
-0.1190475076,
-0.0492192432,
0.7829681635,
-0.3372942507,
0.3549956381,
0.7444320321,
-0.2659933865,
-0.0219569542,
1.0418188572,
0.0102204923,
0.3113369048,
0.7491385341,
0.0049731028,
-0.4136909246,
-0.6138840914,
-0.8745293617,
0.1451955736,
-0.8176748753,
-0.0165820159,
-0.297852993,
-0.2872827649,
0.2145091295,
-0.5323236585,
-0.4495746195,
-0.331774801,
0.0904518068,
-0.1531149149,
0.0111964652,
0.915306747,
-0.0822061375,
0.2278772146,
-0.5780647397,
0.3057724833,
0.5897049308,
0.0474243723,
-0.0722550601,
-0.5074288845,
0.0058871862,
0.1037823334,
-0.1596811265,
-0.7183318138,
0.2936282158,
0.0160682723,
0.5796992183,
0.201474309,
-0.1416508257,
0.5509823561,
-0.5605332255,
0.8904669881,
0.1024033651,
-0.5114402771,
0.6726382375,
-0.5407847166,
0.6305747032,
-0.042523507,
0.2578964531,
-0.4538024664,
-0.1426522434,
-0.31134969,
-0.6011949778,
0.5355284214,
0.2607169747,
-0.1121995971,
0.2251724601,
0.4584161341,
-0.2644597888,
-0.1027819961,
-0.6960344315,
0.0073194141,
-0.4406967461,
0.1579904556,
-0.1246050894,
-0.0823045522,
0.1912218332,
-0.1259815395,
0.5618359447,
-0.3984127045,
0.2760296464,
0.3083100915,
-0.20547539,
0.2919981182,
0.3553327024,
0.7054597139,
0.46957165,
-0.0073592188,
0.0395737067,
0.1139100492,
-0.3927835822,
0.3016474545,
-0.0834178627,
-0.2432971746,
-0.1379180104,
0.5042710304,
0.9340549707,
0.3112287819,
-0.6830638051,
0.7218338847,
-0.041811049,
-0.3073653281,
-0.2349652797,
0.2240639627,
0.0577662177,
0.6462433338,
0.1226102337,
0.1109997034,
0.1035251319,
-0.4599826336,
-0.0774196312,
0.306142956,
-0.5993072987,
-0.2889061868,
0.6560062766,
0.1158280373,
0.0259960238,
0.5825815201,
-0.2352740914,
-0.563283205,
0.4935852885,
0.0137402676,
0.8769927621,
-0.3469087481,
0.3699512482,
0.3489310145,
0.5193406343,
-0.2788098454,
0.218869105,
-0.2990372479,
-0.6641643643,
-0.6854531765,
-0.4873788059,
-0.5256912708,
-0.2135473043,
-0.4155641198,
-0.0517010652,
-0.4125742018,
0.1738337278,
-0.4081866145,
-0.3768583536,
-0.7024450302,
0.3393396437,
0.4073700607,
0.5935801864,
-0.435177356,
0.7608184218,
0.8062878251,
-0.7230690122,
-0.7788220644,
0.0488114208,
0.0701480359,
-1.2572580576,
0.7731426954,
-0.0259591993,
-0.5216736197,
-0.0572952963,
-0.6437726617,
-0.6885176301,
1.0632046461,
0.4510222375,
-0.5941161513,
-0.4347137213,
0.0870839432,
0.2964431643,
-0.171065852,
0.1707161069,
0.4604187906,
0.5732765794,
0.8533933759,
-0.817111969,
0.073021926,
0.0439770557,
-0.0286739971,
0.2362306565,
-0.561555028,
0.6364793181,
-0.6796244979,
-0.1556601673,
0.2140981853,
0.3489697874,
0.1709699184,
0.21512492,
0.2354775071,
0.4495000243,
0.4305642247,
-0.144461453,
1.267734766,
0.0429703407,
0.094785355,
1.1788488626,
-0.2366795391,
0.7333544493,
0.116964072,
0.3120599985,
0.5502360463,
0.290718466,
0.1005696058,
0.6356603503,
-0.0397541597,
-0.3785519898,
-0.6254885197,
0.1143589765,
-0.1438330263,
0.7558841705,
0.4825415909,
-0.1124223843,
-0.335205555,
0.0723551363,
0.0478540175,
-0.323592782,
-0.636633873,
0.827147305,
0.0065627969,
-0.8007224202,
0.6997995377,
-0.28269732,
0.2072466761,
-0.6601631045,
-0.3860138059,
-0.262299329,
0.0756279156,
0.0069596027,
-1.0602611303,
-0.1726389676,
-0.059893921,
0.2823877633,
-0.2806928456,
0.7655496001,
-0.3837828934,
-0.3342256248,
0.1779149175,
0.8323299885,
0.3747915626,
-0.4652642012,
-0.5047209263,
-0.0640806705,
0.1367248446,
-0.4272711575,
0.1551850587,
0.6717305779,
-0.1237331405,
0.9924519658,
0.3742848039,
0.1190827787,
0.1256023496,
0.0173905324,
0.738476336,
-0.9179716706,
-0.3532000482,
-0.6404880285,
0.6378850341,
0.1850053072,
0.0715463907,
0.4676925838,
0.3252192438,
0.6566745043,
-0.0065299515,
0.9469561577,
0.277575314,
-0.0878756791,
-0.8515732288,
0.3971900344,
-0.6306157708,
0.1303087622,
0.1496534199,
-0.7764343023,
-0.2233102769,
0.8619220853,
-0.6110867262,
0.2444453984,
0.5594389439,
0.8323863745,
-0.1713501215,
-0.1581542939,
0.769559443,
0.1785281152,
0.4306030273,
0.9645041227,
0.9750289321,
-0.2049945593,
0.6871452332,
0.2179873735,
-0.1608775556,
-0.3342573941,
-0.7240232825,
-0.7813467979,
-0.3909442723,
-0.247010842,
0.055280447,
0.3081022501,
0.5105288625,
0.7564002872,
-0.193396166,
-0.0499918237,
-0.3594690859,
0.1156455353,
-0.0826059803,
-0.1663970202,
0.1396357864,
-0.0864513442,
-0.545727849,
0.834066093,
0.6416646242,
0.2090982795,
-0.4296425283,
-0.4487123489,
-0.0394843481,
0.10063719,
0.9244099855,
0.5843585134,
-0.863859117,
-0.3228134513,
-0.0397317186,
0.0679460913,
0.0381622538,
0.7074502707,
-0.8162242174,
0.6570133567,
0.12171828,
0.4149456024,
0.8269206285,
-0.1078247577,
0.6545327306,
-0.5190215111,
0.0413564555,
0.3020839989,
0.4585499763,
0.2984244823,
-0.2116775513,
0.7114225626,
0.0341536552,
-0.7078928947,
-0.2364120483,
0.384221077,
-1.2401390076,
-0.2920954823,
1.5419480801,
-0.1575333327,
-0.2770955563,
-0.1607686132,
-0.683578074,
-0.0089412779,
-0.4807848036,
0.0501335599,
0.3884539604,
-0.289958179,
-0.530534327,
-0.9570192099,
0.1876719892,
-0.0136126261,
-0.6351470947,
-0.0092398906,
0.7662360668,
0.1126759723,
-0.0225800909,
0.6057166457,
0.1289542168,
0.4616048634,
0.15994744,
0.1703115106,
-0.2397232056,
-0.5720421076,
-0.065556407,
0.0612084903,
0.0367673673,
-0.2497940958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16982v1 | TranSFormer: Slow-Fast Transformer for Machine Translation | 2023-05-26T14:37:38 | 2023-05-26T14:37:38 | Bei Li, Yi Jing, Xu Tan, Zhen Xing, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Learning multiscale Transformer models has been evidenced as a viable
approach to augmenting machine translation systems. Prior research has
primarily focused on treating subwords as basic units in developing such
systems. However, the incorporation of fine-grained character-level features
into multiscale Transformer has not yet been explored. In this work, we present
a \textbf{S}low-\textbf{F}ast two-stream learning model, referred to as
Tran\textbf{SF}ormer, which utilizes a ``slow'' branch to deal with subword
sequences and a ``fast'' branch to deal with longer character sequences. This
model is efficient since the fast branch is very lightweight by reducing the
model width, and yet provides useful fine-grained features for the slow branch.
Our TranSFormer shows consistent BLEU improvements (larger than 1 BLEU point)
on several machine translation benchmarks. | [
-0.2387161851,
-0.6737448573,
0.3334925473,
0.1852353662,
-0.4526481926,
0.0384785458,
-0.3990314901,
-0.2729910314,
-0.0628562793,
0.4791462123,
-0.4626653492,
-0.057349287,
-1.0385383368,
0.2081999779,
-0.5436865687,
0.9664977789,
-0.1051266044,
-0.0349695198,
0.7583821416,
-0.243114695,
-0.1815120727,
-0.224654898,
-0.9051030278,
-0.5028505921,
0.6003684402,
0.542345345,
0.8199846745,
0.840470016,
0.6756054163,
0.3483006358,
-0.2658964992,
-0.0456046611,
-0.4834945202,
0.2897855937,
-0.000721443,
-0.5299252868,
-0.4801594913,
-0.400364399,
0.7202709317,
0.5341613889,
0.0994261801,
0.2818577588,
0.0419366807,
0.6658972502,
-0.2562751174,
0.129044503,
-0.662509799,
0.0069497423,
-0.3934882879,
0.1251237541,
-0.6081361771,
-0.1208785623,
0.1451879293,
-0.1865818501,
0.6937929988,
0.1004191265,
0.931217432,
0.4699699581,
-0.8011068106,
-0.2296994179,
-0.8630588055,
0.8334329128,
-0.3739007711,
0.9219322801,
-0.1725593507,
0.670630753,
0.3025422692,
-0.860656321,
-0.3708002865,
0.0293918122,
-0.3602682054,
-0.0541935042,
-0.255571425,
-0.1293138713,
0.2425877154,
0.4564657211,
-0.519498229,
0.206126079,
-0.3094852865,
-0.1261921525,
0.519325316,
0.1663394123,
-0.0935190246,
-0.1865583211,
-0.5816429853,
-0.3483782411,
-0.427331984,
0.1906962097,
-0.0302805826,
0.479111284,
-0.2673396766,
0.5878880024,
0.0638247207,
0.2134437263,
0.3522869945,
-0.1335230321,
0.3251340091,
-0.4936437607,
-0.1916569024,
-0.1004937813,
0.8527953029,
-0.0677706972,
0.045444712,
-0.0176917203,
-0.5434505343,
-0.1315796375,
0.1329249442,
-1.3712569475,
-0.2660350204,
-0.0301304888,
-0.7969868779,
0.0451982468,
-0.0984563679,
-0.5224481821,
-0.3782596886,
-0.0328035206,
0.1564273983,
-0.6582058072,
-0.0740019754,
-0.2974412143,
-0.1517883092,
0.18736884,
0.4239448905,
-0.853387177,
0.1983528882,
0.1578150392,
0.9649572968,
-0.1053620055,
-0.4374994934,
-0.5667456985,
-0.0678589791,
-0.2722339928,
0.8725437522,
-0.339122206,
-0.5264088511,
-0.2587884068,
0.372305125,
-0.0528662428,
-0.3342087269,
0.5536808372,
-0.2969576716,
-0.1710236222,
-0.0315360092,
-0.0540994965,
-0.3673625588,
-0.1016817093,
-0.6492266059,
1.0433282852,
0.3597058356,
-0.4437283874,
0.2486111522,
-0.572765708,
-0.759031415,
0.1200678945,
0.1467950344,
-0.6041528583,
0.4116759002,
0.1723463237,
0.5027632117,
-0.5088124871,
-0.0529943295,
0.0061578555,
-0.5178533196,
0.1056173071,
-0.7320239544,
0.3491405845,
0.3553485274,
-0.1962224692,
0.188234657,
-0.5079662204,
-0.4011495709,
0.2052238286,
-0.5882611871,
-0.1127792597,
-0.1494676769,
0.5645080209,
0.1748558134,
0.1101567745,
-0.6414474845,
0.4207095504,
-0.2877625525,
0.5588289499,
0.2955730259,
-0.3137669563,
0.8578990698,
-0.0854164138,
0.3682739139,
0.2457295209,
0.1394177824,
-0.4507722259,
-0.3552443981,
-0.9891735911,
-0.5662033558,
0.4567010403,
0.5278095007,
-1.1836475134,
0.1603716165,
-0.5549260378,
-0.6429392695,
-0.7026946545,
0.2015406638,
0.4295281768,
0.1089921072,
0.8418277502,
-0.2187666893,
-0.0403003506,
-0.7774068713,
-0.3558662236,
0.269811213,
-0.3584951758,
0.1038978919,
0.4175581038,
-0.6223781705,
0.4094242752,
-0.5707121491,
-0.3553683758,
-0.6593410969,
0.3761546314,
0.041836407,
0.3452002406,
0.5515304208,
-0.7821722031,
-0.7622137666,
0.1937988102,
-0.1508375853,
-0.0097940667,
0.0460162535,
0.127683416,
0.1241559982,
0.491659373,
-0.5932908058,
0.3237867355,
0.548560679,
-0.4136485159,
0.0902464762,
-0.1905609071,
0.1381252259,
-1.1425079107,
-0.1153720021,
0.1932440996,
-0.4457014501,
-0.7777506709,
0.0321453698,
0.6401616335,
-0.3193032742,
-0.8341335654,
0.5424404144,
-0.1890413016,
0.1205361038,
-0.4715272486,
0.0227495879,
0.0009938498,
0.4653319716,
0.0862432942,
0.7131162286,
0.303865999,
-0.3453092873,
0.022113543,
0.1940172464,
0.0565417446,
0.5831496119,
-0.5931673646,
0.1197481453,
-0.1987808198,
0.5089249015,
-0.7131522298,
-0.0305212941,
-0.0005654129,
-0.1833068281,
0.5302436948,
-0.2449411899,
-0.5118992925,
-0.5261927247,
-0.2268710881,
0.5663685203,
0.5534476042,
-0.4372852743,
0.8484945893,
-0.0226472579,
-0.3350131214,
-0.2237184644,
-0.9005945921,
-0.3148505092,
-0.0395779274,
-0.4749166965,
0.5170682073,
0.2613922656,
0.3204092383,
-0.171912536,
-0.1491622627,
-0.2502250373,
-0.018018797,
0.0939361081,
-0.0684073493,
-0.3983815014,
0.040506646,
0.3811699152,
-0.3065847754,
-0.4681343436,
-0.2476405501,
0.4788469374,
-0.282815069,
0.0999139696,
-0.2948873937,
0.3519014418,
0.6851816773,
-0.4490843713,
0.5262033343,
0.9536330104,
-0.2711807191,
-0.2879427075,
-0.2677293122,
-0.3434696496,
-0.4619391859,
0.5262628794,
-0.6918529868,
-1.1770724058,
0.359097302,
-0.3165206909,
0.0636171699,
0.7595333457,
0.4761020839,
-0.1293789446,
0.9278625846,
0.8884395957,
0.1548441797,
0.5969811082,
-0.4334747791,
0.479393959,
-0.7478920817,
-0.0706242099,
-0.7574805021,
-0.5978645682,
-0.8665566444,
-0.8276970387,
0.2371252179,
0.3086099327,
-0.2299345285,
0.9324095845,
-0.1749649048,
0.2344152927,
0.2299472839,
-0.032612253,
0.1632452458,
-0.4195715487,
-0.00165439,
0.1569585353,
-0.8002447486,
-0.25341326,
0.7992177606,
0.6721631289,
1.0449919701,
0.1002797037,
0.477915436,
0.1818298101,
0.4096943438,
-1.0756267309,
0.2138492018,
-0.8878461123,
-0.4479387105,
-0.4811824262,
-0.5464575887,
-0.8421783447,
0.5434365273,
-0.3640066087,
-0.3475802541,
0.2003249824,
0.156742245,
-0.4609896541,
0.2765371203,
-0.7097861767,
0.9129375219,
-0.2308991104,
0.1951206177,
-0.0312389638,
-0.8431768417,
0.313079983,
-0.3475731313,
0.1227129772,
-0.024877049,
0.1566418707,
0.3834673464,
-0.4397505224,
0.3074288964,
-0.062238533,
0.0383258834,
0.1806862056,
0.1229615733,
0.5286069512,
0.003501598,
0.2199423313,
0.3322698474,
-0.2755454481,
-0.3530413806,
-0.4878344238,
0.5648068786,
-0.5409623981,
-0.1402653605,
-0.1535658687,
-0.7778275609,
0.204538703,
0.3481370807,
0.2452822924,
0.4301561117,
0.1749596894,
0.540538311,
0.753924191,
-0.0132948523,
0.6442185044,
0.401869148,
-0.2536105216,
-0.2802711129,
0.9481063485,
0.2536543012,
0.3096951246,
0.6015010476,
0.3328126669,
-0.3442803621,
-0.2877978981,
-0.7446133494,
0.2348883152,
-0.5362254977,
-0.5211642981,
-0.7997470498,
-0.3940021992,
-0.2605727911,
-0.2168696821,
-0.7303399444,
-0.5180794597,
0.1751998663,
0.1413966566,
0.2611657381,
0.7355591059,
0.5590137839,
1.0254539251,
-1.1588822603,
0.7139611244,
0.2087771893,
0.1215468496,
-0.0550791994,
-0.78612113,
-0.5547397733,
-0.1418607384,
-0.6646791697,
-0.6483504772,
0.2674987316,
0.207901895,
0.1195828915,
0.2964215279,
-0.1940913498,
0.5948024392,
-0.9155602455,
0.7496976852,
0.1841928065,
-1.1007210016,
0.2414921075,
0.0021310803,
0.7895880938,
0.5095360279,
0.4181602895,
-0.5540963411,
-0.5699723959,
-0.3455388248,
-0.8298073411,
0.7162960172,
0.2210226953,
0.0298196729,
0.1682485491,
0.1111747622,
0.4786913991,
0.2028784454,
-0.6956267357,
-0.3653583229,
-0.3687245548,
-0.1720650196,
-0.2893919647,
-0.1571587622,
0.6031999588,
-0.1020195037,
0.6140010953,
-0.3322351575,
0.2852036059,
-0.1236523092,
-0.4735253751,
-0.1940545142,
0.450873524,
0.4817370772,
-0.0703164786,
-0.0443977788,
0.4059633315,
0.3973976076,
-0.5890245438,
0.1961470693,
0.4170507789,
-0.3463942111,
0.0988195166,
0.2379645258,
0.9387558103,
0.4026328921,
-0.0713796467,
0.4477636814,
-0.0932165384,
-0.1350987852,
0.3918203712,
-0.2618959248,
0.1463385969,
0.5417015553,
0.3265698254,
0.6459151506,
0.1082484797,
-0.5371712446,
0.2014748454,
0.1271337718,
-0.5617331862,
-0.3481962383,
0.8013034463,
0.4369592369,
-0.6188764572,
0.7271023989,
-0.0907323733,
-0.7221498489,
0.1058187187,
0.4312072396,
1.0041978359,
-0.5107007027,
-0.0699108168,
0.0887730792,
0.5607617497,
-0.2317714095,
0.1497202218,
-0.0941407457,
-0.3851658404,
-0.4723706245,
-0.9095987678,
-0.0277717244,
-0.1084869877,
-0.3596642613,
0.5193713307,
-0.0451679453,
-0.2830320299,
0.0399927944,
-0.1561914086,
-0.8582929373,
0.2236550152,
0.2138709277,
1.1005285978,
-1.0890312195,
1.4044536352,
0.4024674594,
-0.3488150537,
-0.7219327688,
0.2357370704,
-0.2185223848,
-0.3635849357,
0.6004551649,
0.4360074401,
-0.2397249639,
0.1363812983,
0.0524987429,
-0.8104562163,
1.1705956459,
0.2184255719,
-0.8386532664,
-0.1708599329,
0.2575536668,
0.4249952137,
-0.3134907186,
0.4113183618,
0.4708152711,
0.5540928841,
0.0522051416,
-0.8540407419,
0.0556458719,
0.1350011975,
0.5275971293,
0.7673392892,
-0.950873673,
1.0588060617,
0.0012133897,
-0.0587919839,
0.0681136027,
0.880186677,
-0.2482815385,
0.0492540412,
0.6446719766,
0.532499969,
0.3654366732,
-0.3220132291,
0.957151413,
-0.102251105,
0.5812741518,
1.0097210407,
-0.0735519156,
0.8428171873,
0.4854606092,
0.0884175599,
0.4028423727,
0.3775498569,
0.0682593957,
0.5946592093,
0.0797832087,
0.231807068,
-0.2068083733,
0.0035402982,
-0.1208833382,
0.3224325478,
0.317842871,
-0.4282973111,
-0.3514751792,
0.2740491331,
-0.0435430296,
-0.1539264768,
-0.3861527741,
0.4879499376,
0.3267886043,
-0.3833511174,
0.3812626898,
0.5759430528,
0.7466028333,
-0.6695848703,
0.0168173574,
-0.4146719575,
0.3275089562,
-0.0268793385,
-0.6300652027,
0.4334006011,
0.1251131147,
-0.318721652,
-0.5762493014,
0.6979610324,
-0.7434568405,
-0.6536964774,
0.3422674239,
0.4598942101,
0.034262225,
-0.0634736717,
-0.692571044,
0.0023903777,
-0.3151778877,
-0.4034848213,
0.0562394001,
0.6558859944,
-0.3521136642,
0.498383522,
0.2897726595,
-0.0137124937,
0.229696244,
0.2584651113,
0.6389812827,
-0.6025836468,
-0.2107987404,
-0.7841478586,
0.7398386002,
0.2755764723,
-0.2363147885,
0.7017062306,
0.6009452343,
0.8414090872,
-0.2267707139,
0.5179851651,
-0.0977364704,
0.2724789977,
-0.371267885,
0.8481601477,
-0.535099864,
-0.2359496057,
0.1199534163,
-1.3343794346,
-0.230624795,
0.3496240377,
0.1208321229,
-0.1490642279,
1.2700812817,
0.3957762718,
-0.4489709735,
-0.1146331131,
0.3727296889,
0.2039687932,
0.1883362085,
0.4620675445,
0.499278903,
-0.8567110896,
0.6630488038,
-0.4085425138,
-0.1254536211,
-0.4388822615,
-0.5688926578,
-1.0148963928,
-0.4402527213,
-0.1009263918,
-0.0935125276,
-0.2386271209,
0.9580417275,
0.623247683,
-0.8497138023,
-0.3550519347,
0.2058810294,
0.0888018534,
-0.5161835551,
-0.1765764356,
0.1781240702,
-0.311476469,
-0.8048456907,
0.5981119871,
0.3101085424,
0.1892137676,
-0.0938421711,
-0.1659923047,
-0.1625923216,
0.2186180353,
0.7066379786,
-0.234614864,
-0.7205184698,
-0.3844508827,
0.1537400931,
-0.3309880197,
0.1288603842,
1.0760234594,
-0.4305558503,
0.1993794292,
0.5345657468,
0.7276659012,
0.9316426516,
0.0482984222,
0.3266197145,
-0.7840961218,
0.1654745638,
0.1511564255,
0.4331386089,
0.2562831044,
-0.2686844468,
0.3518652916,
0.1917972714,
-0.4491032362,
-0.401086092,
0.3608110547,
-0.8866815567,
-0.1900546849,
0.9007733464,
-0.2405235916,
-0.2477387339,
0.2175089866,
-0.2615972757,
0.6150614023,
-0.5527216792,
0.2918254435,
0.3516541719,
0.0063934987,
-0.100954555,
-0.2962451577,
0.2628208399,
0.1991737634,
-0.5213116407,
0.055307813,
0.0971428603,
0.1276941895,
0.3073156774,
0.2384850979,
0.0327266678,
0.148171559,
-0.0421730801,
0.0313017704,
0.0492061786,
-0.8260649443,
-0.5070129037,
0.1878584921,
0.1043534353,
0.0713964924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16967v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16967v3 | Evaluating Open-Domain Dialogues in Latent Space with Next Sentence Prediction and Mutual Information | 2023-05-26T14:21:54 | 2023-06-10T13:23:41 | Kun Zhao, Bohao Yang, Chenghua Lin, Wenge Rong, Aline Villavicencio, Xiaohui Cui | cs.CL | cs.CL | The long-standing one-to-many issue of the open-domain dialogues poses
significant challenges for automatic evaluation methods, i.e., there may be
multiple suitable responses which differ in semantics for a given
conversational context. To tackle this challenge, we propose a novel
learning-based automatic evaluation metric (CMN), which can robustly evaluate
open-domain dialogues by augmenting Conditional Variational Autoencoders
(CVAEs) with a Next Sentence Prediction (NSP) objective and employing Mutual
Information (MI) to model the semantic similarity of text in the latent space.
Experimental results on two open-domain dialogue datasets demonstrate the
superiority of our method compared with a wide range of baselines, especially
in handling responses which are distant to the golden reference responses in
semantics. | [
-0.3829284906,
-0.4794690013,
0.3976238668,
0.091764167,
-0.2404643297,
-0.0158619676,
-0.4412042499,
-0.128714487,
0.1780890822,
0.3013897538,
-0.8782660365,
-0.5920186043,
-0.5141653419,
-0.0723249316,
-0.0215525366,
0.9513155222,
-0.0427468531,
0.176771611,
-0.6388694048,
-0.4763761461,
-0.51663661,
-0.5643743873,
-0.3716939986,
0.072681725,
0.3860471845,
0.3002655208,
0.6750016212,
0.1225672364,
0.5219293833,
0.3884815574,
0.2382101864,
0.3205138445,
-0.3410547674,
0.0266571045,
-0.2425743192,
-0.4008316398,
-0.1990823895,
0.1558840573,
0.598737359,
0.9753798842,
-0.0011115838,
-0.0946745574,
0.046649009,
0.550139606,
-0.5959143639,
0.3844437599,
-0.7503855824,
0.3683045208,
0.2713318765,
-0.2627797127,
-0.1672975719,
-0.1853049248,
0.6560693979,
-0.596286118,
-0.0849016681,
-0.0587257259,
0.954578042,
0.2825880647,
-0.1322394162,
-0.2213903219,
-0.466178,
0.852524817,
-0.7194948792,
0.2778450251,
0.4905532002,
0.493861407,
0.0354955904,
-0.6655672789,
-0.6233530641,
-0.3938730955,
-0.172096163,
0.5032820106,
-0.1766518801,
-0.1964330524,
-0.2633704841,
0.4065770805,
-0.515435338,
0.0197161026,
-0.1307617873,
-0.1815693229,
0.2778177559,
0.3693192601,
0.2361057699,
-0.1971741915,
-0.3917351067,
-0.0747532174,
-0.0712836161,
-0.2205036432,
0.3419603705,
0.2722324431,
-0.2588604689,
0.5042039156,
-0.2001344413,
0.6430208087,
-0.0457496047,
0.453646034,
0.5351462364,
-0.4962886572,
-0.26132375,
-0.4318417609,
1.060656786,
0.7071587443,
0.1467573941,
-0.2953845561,
-0.056157317,
0.2607801557,
0.2603960633,
-0.7647798657,
-0.1773483455,
-0.0923802108,
-0.6184821725,
-0.2283429801,
0.265291512,
-0.6869410872,
0.0730911791,
-0.3567471206,
0.3862890601,
-0.4891353548,
-0.0035782955,
0.0534036122,
0.0949047878,
0.1371064037,
0.3636930287,
-0.5885757804,
0.5753316879,
0.6783925295,
0.8415783644,
-0.3827892244,
-0.3320323527,
-0.7343992591,
-0.3805542886,
-0.2949584723,
0.6724008918,
-0.8179048896,
-0.3633118868,
0.1078255773,
-0.043841403,
-0.2643581033,
-0.578907609,
0.4025231004,
-0.5145821571,
0.7721170783,
0.0773016587,
-0.5712838173,
0.0989774615,
0.346226275,
-0.5920701623,
0.6898183823,
0.5276752114,
-0.9389642477,
0.3160312772,
-0.6688608527,
-0.139219448,
0.0512269884,
-0.4736518264,
-0.3583383262,
-0.0051217545,
0.1244253293,
0.3801341951,
-0.3914810121,
0.1639525741,
-0.4871135652,
-0.099945046,
0.4402110875,
-0.7417808175,
0.3066599369,
0.2403173447,
-0.1328431368,
0.0652486235,
-0.6753802299,
0.1294350326,
-0.1060245782,
0.0616722219,
-0.4764106274,
-0.1969025582,
-0.3869376779,
0.3633226454,
0.2828850746,
-0.7024205327,
-0.0326053016,
-0.7230572701,
0.2429876179,
0.5822100639,
0.2306089848,
0.5260901451,
-0.3437544405,
0.4807515442,
0.16886428,
0.1973542273,
-0.2272126675,
-0.4400854409,
-0.7141488194,
0.1348677576,
0.3307853341,
0.5559670329,
-0.8646295667,
0.7077012658,
-0.3961494267,
-0.1884925365,
-0.4550561607,
-0.0051910309,
0.6919115782,
0.3975326717,
0.251939714,
-0.9448924065,
-0.4603130817,
-0.79016155,
-0.277085036,
-0.485035181,
-0.1274609417,
0.9017781615,
0.4178875983,
-0.2702615559,
1.0053888559,
-0.5425382853,
-0.3994167149,
0.1348267794,
0.3367213905,
-0.0404468291,
0.2547384501,
0.4901019335,
-0.8148203492,
-0.5790416002,
-0.058009807,
-0.6736516953,
-0.161457479,
-0.129078567,
-0.2601838708,
-0.0537786633,
0.4551555514,
-0.3836824298,
0.4245044887,
0.4145842493,
-0.3066097796,
0.4626014531,
0.0359571576,
0.364607513,
-1.1124788523,
-0.2344687879,
-0.073058188,
-0.0590230189,
-0.1333770305,
-0.2162209749,
-0.2147734463,
0.0145141669,
-0.4770120978,
0.6920791268,
-0.262169987,
-0.210623309,
-0.1354341954,
0.4420973659,
-0.1606058925,
0.6740543246,
0.1276592761,
0.873437047,
0.249339819,
-0.5802164078,
0.2846187651,
0.6569653153,
-0.523312211,
0.5467681885,
-0.3810052276,
0.1846223027,
0.0750628114,
0.4065076411,
-0.7545847297,
-0.0652139187,
0.1293218285,
-1.0181491375,
0.0200736541,
-0.0192795172,
-0.1505743116,
-0.3953076303,
-0.278447181,
0.4037725627,
0.1656273007,
-0.5464130044,
0.420995146,
0.3198770881,
-0.4431936443,
-0.8584218621,
-0.4568087757,
0.1303624511,
0.1335268319,
-0.633716166,
0.229864046,
-0.4070085883,
-0.2419082075,
0.1913408488,
-0.1301923245,
-0.2804578543,
0.0438170917,
0.3339931369,
0.3451136649,
-0.3562364578,
0.1657565981,
0.1585876644,
-0.0987473354,
0.1457676142,
-0.9024494886,
0.3902405798,
-0.464694798,
-0.3190194964,
-0.1973141581,
0.3539429605,
0.2114121616,
-0.2811736166,
0.6730030775,
0.5346750617,
-0.3497409225,
-0.1149471998,
-0.1537443846,
-0.0544014722,
-0.415029496,
0.5653629899,
-0.4414563179,
-1.1549334526,
0.1775386482,
-0.1114602238,
-0.0377217643,
0.6499696374,
0.7345097065,
0.1009423882,
0.6071738601,
0.7081115246,
-0.0327899344,
0.4435558021,
-0.2885750532,
0.1661955565,
-0.7333886623,
-0.3652046025,
-0.4443004429,
0.2732553482,
-0.3025972247,
-0.8225585818,
0.2455616146,
-0.1197184324,
-0.0528617725,
0.4835296273,
-0.0858766437,
0.4294183254,
0.2039084733,
0.0097765299,
-0.1038665175,
-0.094178699,
-0.6738287807,
-0.3729278445,
-0.6173269153,
-0.4052192867,
1.00674963,
0.2461419702,
0.4771060944,
0.0509389602,
0.5355755091,
0.3834241927,
0.3910692334,
-0.7531250119,
0.5128499866,
-0.3067171574,
0.0164061747,
-0.3339061141,
-0.8084844351,
-0.7030982375,
0.2904820442,
-0.1804179251,
-0.8150206804,
-0.0277182851,
-0.2944212556,
-0.3401853442,
0.2065049112,
-0.2871593535,
0.7044177651,
-0.0943333507,
-0.3044767976,
-0.1390177161,
-0.9773883224,
0.0534256473,
-0.1024229005,
0.0991015062,
-0.070553124,
-0.0750130266,
0.7990790009,
-0.7023291588,
0.7722491622,
-0.2184532583,
-0.030150732,
0.5558152199,
-0.0204850975,
-0.0733024031,
0.2159729451,
0.0092808064,
0.1020469069,
-0.1911695302,
-0.2123860717,
-1.0384646654,
0.7693737745,
-0.8893703222,
-0.1812175512,
-0.1860218644,
-0.2532272637,
-0.5925116539,
-0.1355391592,
0.1812738478,
0.3630329669,
-0.777258575,
0.1267240793,
0.4420898557,
-0.5286639929,
0.3664470613,
0.6757832766,
0.0690472797,
-0.7607896328,
0.7823584676,
-0.5083495975,
0.3528049886,
0.8627309799,
0.2032189518,
-0.3434400558,
-0.1240419745,
-0.5020107031,
-0.0304904804,
-0.826674819,
-0.3915739954,
-1.1038509607,
-0.3575730324,
-0.3015134633,
0.110181272,
-0.3201916814,
-0.6013007164,
-0.2090985477,
-0.0817327648,
-0.0424862877,
0.363147378,
-0.1705644876,
0.1672089994,
-0.9450380206,
0.0870813057,
0.403580904,
0.5267472863,
-0.0935377479,
-0.7370178103,
-0.4225793183,
-0.0530085228,
-0.1642836928,
-0.4992136955,
0.4250566363,
0.497846663,
0.5619702339,
0.3069228828,
0.1083821803,
0.3309625983,
-0.6447327733,
1.066885829,
0.4703012407,
-0.8498516679,
0.5152702332,
-0.1359874606,
0.2883415818,
0.8985310197,
0.4798388481,
-0.5212934017,
-0.385494262,
-0.5904079676,
-0.7541153431,
0.4189191759,
0.4483310282,
0.4818454981,
-0.2290626615,
0.2426107824,
0.3802874088,
0.3164558113,
-0.6454307437,
-0.2727202177,
-0.1837730557,
-0.3015171289,
-0.184089005,
0.0540679768,
-0.0015615778,
-0.0263555646,
0.5904151797,
-0.3365242779,
0.6971680522,
0.2108537257,
-0.1314050257,
-0.1414697766,
0.320397377,
0.3543905318,
0.3282361627,
-0.1679530442,
-0.3418703973,
0.2629461586,
-0.2987885773,
-0.0745951459,
0.2207730561,
0.3321441412,
0.126368314,
0.3927744627,
0.9456582069,
0.1824011058,
-0.5789792538,
1.1168366671,
-0.6234272718,
-0.2323045284,
-0.4404165447,
-0.1134105995,
-0.3129656315,
0.1198447198,
0.0341873989,
0.2749798298,
0.2739552259,
-0.5572052002,
0.7258495688,
0.3273870647,
-1.0113363266,
-0.2174555361,
0.4816118181,
0.1673008054,
-0.332541436,
0.4408586323,
-0.181511417,
-0.7819984555,
0.5599812269,
0.2390513122,
1.1224079132,
-0.1674862504,
0.2517944872,
0.3167248368,
-0.0012182912,
0.4673530161,
0.0641311258,
-0.3825251162,
-0.6836646199,
-0.4343105853,
-0.8083609343,
-0.6579909921,
0.1302664578,
-0.7026484609,
0.1027750149,
-0.3115299642,
0.0019257652,
0.0160333961,
0.0331803523,
-0.6636173129,
0.5547312498,
0.1381639838,
0.8436440229,
-0.7224995494,
0.6879244447,
0.5105823278,
-0.4766191542,
-0.4969125092,
0.3459039629,
-0.1591015309,
-0.4727694392,
0.6089921594,
0.3915771246,
-0.313151747,
-0.6877962351,
-0.4540697038,
-0.4944512844,
0.8397790194,
0.0483592339,
-0.5804559588,
0.1089891121,
0.0265044011,
0.6448952556,
-0.9177660942,
0.7173841,
0.3420516849,
0.1425981224,
-0.1012470201,
-1.0761653185,
-0.2850016356,
-0.7012898326,
-0.0377042554,
0.1589761674,
-0.7890565991,
0.6619635224,
-0.1653758138,
-0.0188390631,
0.4692234397,
1.1145426035,
-0.2809280157,
0.5532560945,
0.7209253311,
0.5125982165,
0.5463370085,
0.1974887103,
0.8751763701,
-0.3701569736,
0.3345853388,
1.5364750624,
-0.1355220377,
0.8302664757,
-0.0352099724,
-0.1075287163,
0.840086937,
0.5720509291,
0.0470240042,
0.6953210831,
0.492156595,
-0.4629517794,
-0.0084073357,
0.118834056,
-0.2309891433,
0.4556081295,
0.6069339514,
-0.3438710272,
-0.0290257409,
0.0782791227,
-0.2313063443,
0.4421507716,
0.042656254,
1.081723094,
0.284932673,
-0.8398068547,
0.378495276,
0.2097983658,
0.694244802,
-0.5025302768,
-0.1250006557,
-0.1379283071,
0.0588446558,
0.0159330163,
-0.5513028502,
0.3406768739,
-0.0282490719,
-0.1101386324,
0.1609570235,
0.689119637,
-0.5187003016,
-0.054473415,
0.7165729403,
0.5776469111,
0.2932484746,
0.0571286865,
-0.9191168547,
-0.291589886,
-0.1724150479,
0.1871561259,
0.2663413286,
0.6625827551,
-0.0446561053,
0.5935174227,
0.3640841544,
-0.2225625217,
-0.1054179594,
0.3818820417,
1.0387413502,
-0.548905015,
-0.6969859004,
-0.4857640564,
0.0659464076,
-0.2035408616,
-0.4832519591,
0.4931383431,
0.7240917683,
0.9789796472,
0.1211249009,
1.0322356224,
0.1775348932,
0.6322334409,
-0.525025785,
0.4127589166,
-0.4691033065,
0.3964169621,
-0.5213276744,
-0.9938718081,
-0.0924732983,
0.6905584931,
-0.3233884871,
0.1526187509,
1.018430829,
0.5225325823,
-0.2036353201,
0.2287974507,
0.5163378119,
0.1421190351,
0.0461120494,
0.7453753948,
1.0399622917,
-0.4392292202,
0.6507076621,
-0.1135238707,
-0.4209424555,
-0.0189154372,
-0.6663289666,
-0.9664170146,
-0.8530923128,
-0.4070645869,
-0.5930550694,
0.3020790517,
0.9648919702,
0.6075495481,
-0.6731656194,
-0.1028705314,
-0.0310488306,
-0.238192305,
0.1351376325,
-0.2416891456,
0.3017949164,
-0.4986489713,
-0.6205509901,
0.4980315268,
0.6461758614,
-0.1242039502,
-0.248012349,
-0.3357146978,
0.0711850151,
0.4115534425,
0.5490490198,
0.0486897118,
-0.4803881645,
-0.1143129468,
-0.1923028082,
-0.2286364287,
0.1312534958,
0.9062324762,
-0.9778289199,
0.4642890096,
0.0951917097,
0.9212400317,
0.4270351827,
-0.111955367,
0.8656233549,
-0.803201437,
0.0585054941,
0.5400794744,
0.2633446157,
0.5076298118,
-0.2165937424,
0.5171684027,
0.2895216644,
-0.4257737398,
-0.3785339296,
0.3696930707,
-0.8535704017,
-0.2643663883,
1.0213817358,
-0.7773252726,
-0.2512131631,
-0.0058912244,
0.0829617605,
0.1674926728,
-0.3497684896,
0.4518490732,
0.6151385903,
0.2145146281,
0.0583628751,
-0.3433770537,
0.3062865436,
0.7692478895,
-1.0253406763,
-0.1847701073,
0.5567983389,
0.164917767,
0.0764910877,
0.7201457024,
-0.325081259,
0.3301098943,
0.0139517654,
-0.4210326374,
0.3269417882,
-0.5218133926,
-0.3747354448,
-0.0654743239,
-0.2373811901,
-0.3434491158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16960v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16960v3 | Training Socially Aligned Language Models on Simulated Social Interactions | 2023-05-26T14:17:36 | 2023-10-28T09:02:39 | Ruibo Liu, Ruixin Yang, Chenyan Jia, Ge Zhang, Denny Zhou, Andrew M. Dai, Diyi Yang, Soroush Vosoughi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC | Social alignment in AI systems aims to ensure that these models behave
according to established societal values. However, unlike humans, who derive
consensus on value judgments through social interaction, current language
models (LMs) are trained to rigidly replicate their training corpus in
isolation, leading to subpar generalization in unfamiliar scenarios and
vulnerability to adversarial attacks. This work presents a novel training
paradigm that permits LMs to learn from simulated social interactions. In
comparison to existing methodologies, our approach is considerably more
scalable and efficient, demonstrating superior performance in alignment
benchmarks and human evaluations. This paradigm shift in the training of LMs
brings us a step closer to developing AI systems that can robustly and
accurately reflect societal norms and values. | [
0.0577138849,
-0.7421338558,
0.4433764219,
-0.1053502336,
0.0261397939,
0.5154613256,
-0.3357090354,
-0.531871736,
0.3691265881,
0.1197137386,
-0.4089654386,
-0.3664378524,
-0.5552292466,
-0.2013224512,
-0.2801904678,
0.9351962209,
0.2883756459,
0.3187766671,
-0.3124878705,
-0.3730294108,
0.03020823,
-0.7828277349,
-0.7167623043,
-0.5507333875,
0.4219302833,
0.0916840658,
1.1025644541,
0.5626365542,
0.353995055,
0.4158352613,
0.1447044164,
0.1049024239,
-0.8480433822,
-0.175412491,
-0.1832003742,
-0.1592487544,
-0.4507429004,
0.1918036491,
0.7418008447,
0.7467910647,
-0.1927218884,
0.2564997077,
0.2316459566,
0.6637612581,
-0.5114361048,
0.2275270671,
-0.9093418717,
-0.1402219087,
0.0578499921,
0.1994582862,
-0.4159223437,
-0.6927497983,
0.0030648252,
-0.5465566516,
-0.0693875924,
-0.0721555054,
1.0555176735,
0.1054764986,
-0.2062217891,
0.0680416971,
-0.7175777555,
0.6660478711,
-0.5968828797,
0.3634666502,
0.0245531015,
0.4164584577,
-0.1416767836,
-0.486313194,
-0.6695668697,
-0.0494672023,
0.1371504366,
-0.1724766493,
0.0944477022,
0.1007287577,
-0.0272044688,
-0.1088975519,
-0.3099084198,
0.0973622799,
-0.5092840791,
0.0219526868,
0.9381967187,
0.2087109685,
0.3579242229,
0.0692052841,
-0.2803416848,
-0.2592560053,
-0.6590435505,
0.322435379,
0.4434693456,
0.5119025111,
-0.4809740782,
0.3103652894,
-0.0329428464,
0.3825267553,
0.2705879509,
-0.0554306582,
0.325568825,
-0.1766189784,
-0.1094611511,
0.1470639408,
0.794424355,
0.4631394744,
0.717140615,
-0.1943369657,
-0.1508910656,
0.5572431087,
0.5362389684,
-0.3395698965,
0.0410229489,
-0.0910228863,
-0.4854157567,
-0.8968804479,
-0.0835543945,
-0.5681286454,
-0.4884637892,
-0.605245471,
0.275585413,
-0.3924607337,
-0.4502911866,
0.0304655302,
0.0198457669,
0.5702876449,
0.3311077952,
-1.1058608294,
0.5090972781,
0.9768738151,
0.8073190451,
-0.1073518172,
-0.3225154877,
-0.3823884726,
0.3617762327,
-0.3948964179,
0.5488349199,
-0.8051481247,
-0.2889043093,
0.2353797257,
-0.0991783589,
-0.0780447498,
-0.2502530217,
0.1377630383,
-0.597648859,
-0.2985316217,
-0.1475079954,
-0.5856902599,
0.2893826962,
0.4117072821,
-0.2927468121,
0.9659953713,
-0.0033758995,
-0.643299818,
0.3386068344,
-0.5439699292,
-0.269335717,
0.1858723313,
-0.5022728443,
-0.4154907465,
-0.0848489106,
-0.0498261675,
0.4555597007,
0.0123594254,
0.4442941546,
-0.9882614613,
-0.5051597953,
0.2716228962,
-0.2792191505,
0.6984378695,
0.2089349329,
-0.3042140603,
0.4725941718,
-0.6419075727,
0.1112312376,
0.2669272721,
-0.095527418,
-0.5553420782,
0.0594454519,
-0.1305868477,
0.1082318276,
0.3544149101,
-0.5540763736,
0.1918066591,
-0.5372418761,
0.4482808709,
1.1280903816,
-0.3010626733,
0.8989824057,
-0.4226331413,
0.3673484921,
-0.3044948876,
0.3339662552,
0.505828917,
-0.227267012,
-0.5356250405,
-0.1977275908,
0.1881259531,
0.5205507278,
-0.516525209,
0.3351425529,
-0.5926432014,
-0.7355754375,
-0.798826158,
0.1737609655,
0.4450939298,
0.1925166696,
-0.0385783948,
-0.082875587,
-0.5922077298,
-0.7449103594,
-0.4826953411,
-0.3950616121,
0.1038005129,
0.2425465882,
0.3130867779,
-0.3002550006,
0.9555459619,
-0.114316076,
0.146809414,
-0.4740331769,
-0.0019164768,
-0.1499999017,
0.5640646815,
0.4337998927,
-0.7576838136,
-0.5811805725,
0.1303018332,
-0.9132550359,
0.0865458101,
-0.0194802713,
-0.1984465569,
0.3307438493,
0.8046643138,
-0.2423847616,
0.3710165918,
0.6772614717,
0.0335014462,
0.2954173684,
-0.1268325895,
0.0804430544,
-1.2967157364,
-0.0369609781,
0.0545659997,
-0.3182586133,
-0.6820882559,
-0.0673168078,
0.0357673317,
-0.2055025399,
-0.4331960082,
0.699059546,
-0.5562013984,
-0.1974986494,
-0.0332489051,
0.2514950633,
-0.2891007066,
0.4048991203,
0.1452285051,
0.6338391304,
0.3739155531,
-0.4901947379,
0.1671088189,
0.092626676,
-0.2074354142,
0.7375754118,
-0.8542724252,
0.3767153621,
-0.3787884116,
0.115775004,
-0.8442720771,
-0.3423719108,
0.0504806824,
-0.5878947973,
0.2131265104,
-0.150546506,
-0.2323832512,
0.0397328958,
-0.350625217,
0.3687474132,
0.6928573847,
-0.4510338604,
0.6747718453,
0.9375808239,
0.04048815,
-0.6582743526,
-0.2037640959,
-0.063401781,
-0.2593770623,
-0.7404209375,
0.0896454006,
0.1784625202,
-0.5200833082,
-0.1600812972,
0.3342466354,
0.128296718,
0.2881664038,
0.3800997734,
0.3272994757,
-0.0254587531,
-0.0286199041,
0.0819779485,
-0.0045801504,
-0.0295021851,
-0.160267666,
0.7123761177,
-0.4577905834,
-0.5309384465,
-0.5018752813,
0.2707854807,
0.6149802804,
-0.1462995708,
1.0391522646,
0.359742105,
-0.5979585648,
0.1471561044,
-0.3836648464,
-0.1016254798,
-0.5963093638,
0.5030149817,
-0.1916205883,
-0.8913334012,
0.3934593499,
-0.1496007442,
0.2214215845,
-0.0152567495,
0.414100498,
-0.1443182826,
1.3220500946,
0.8194855452,
-0.417070061,
0.5836261511,
0.2025165707,
0.2875673175,
-0.5959540606,
-0.2443916202,
-0.405456394,
-0.4510329664,
-0.5555970669,
-0.2904005349,
0.384192884,
0.0516959615,
-0.4505369961,
0.2584806979,
-0.3037885129,
0.5316236019,
0.4373807609,
0.0555148348,
-0.1555567086,
-0.0065034037,
-0.077477783,
0.0304558091,
-0.6805008054,
-0.9022132158,
0.9810363054,
0.4627330601,
0.9201155305,
0.0954620168,
0.9957847595,
0.2839090526,
0.7543218136,
-0.5273299217,
0.6722967029,
0.1079225615,
-0.4230827093,
-0.5449199677,
-0.2126216739,
-0.9731833935,
0.0671700686,
-0.4597884715,
-0.846896112,
-0.022542255,
0.2609471679,
-0.3214790821,
0.2919973135,
-0.5842447281,
0.9370008707,
-0.0840963572,
-0.3724078238,
-0.3363024294,
-0.9065757394,
0.0944940969,
0.2279534042,
0.52065593,
-0.1091887504,
0.2271080762,
0.4014769793,
-0.0912817493,
1.2844543457,
-0.150197506,
-0.0688780397,
0.052594237,
-0.0104737449,
0.4912549853,
0.0097619006,
-0.0650805235,
0.2787124515,
0.1632613242,
-0.5531536937,
-0.4803009927,
0.5572292805,
-1.1356170177,
-0.6026438475,
-0.4680488706,
-0.5995217562,
-0.1792279184,
0.0114422012,
-0.1345744282,
0.1488354802,
-0.823664248,
0.1556628197,
0.5789481997,
-0.0927807614,
0.1174353361,
0.3235384524,
-0.0962585658,
-0.4534296095,
0.7267360091,
-0.1161620393,
0.6574696302,
0.1921354681,
-0.0739843398,
-0.286490351,
-0.0642278641,
-0.3767959177,
0.1554459631,
-0.5987169147,
-0.0071796621,
-0.666904211,
-0.4437060952,
-0.9293487072,
-0.6190282702,
-0.4250565171,
-0.251876682,
-0.0435936451,
-0.2171318233,
0.1031023636,
0.8363568783,
-0.1747258902,
0.282112807,
-0.9407516718,
-0.0547329038,
0.1667395234,
0.2426257879,
-0.0371186137,
-0.3053462803,
-0.2349171937,
0.3764836192,
-0.1208653972,
-0.858071208,
0.224726364,
0.2050878406,
0.6349260807,
0.5098544955,
0.0821681321,
0.8095616698,
-0.7581133842,
0.5787108541,
0.0997510478,
-0.9427112341,
0.3890571892,
-0.4106571376,
0.0515016094,
0.755366087,
0.3920341432,
-0.8633265495,
-0.3976271749,
-0.7395666242,
-0.601254344,
0.5671527982,
-0.1120955497,
0.4982620478,
-0.1250102222,
0.6719783545,
-0.1567093879,
0.138409242,
-0.8482761979,
-0.0430265851,
-0.0422938503,
-0.7414469123,
-0.2339212149,
-0.0942643359,
-0.2475659102,
-0.2780956328,
0.7313098311,
-0.2015674263,
0.0003559754,
-0.1711852401,
-0.1172186434,
-0.1866469085,
0.1122760177,
0.3696717024,
0.4506435394,
0.0381860547,
0.1963458806,
0.3105905056,
-0.1412713528,
0.3386009634,
-0.2540393472,
-0.194173187,
-0.3752624094,
0.0521367639,
0.6530385613,
0.3063302338,
-0.5575525165,
0.5921772718,
-0.2071698457,
-0.0841802955,
-0.5569908619,
0.1923529506,
0.3542732894,
0.4285431504,
-0.1623275876,
0.0768522844,
-0.16304259,
-0.7195025086,
0.2456494272,
0.9282596111,
-0.6232128143,
-0.495618701,
0.5831642151,
0.3210198283,
-0.7335690856,
0.3367495835,
-0.1920592189,
-0.5371989012,
0.4680944383,
0.5582026839,
0.7029289603,
-0.3520374298,
0.3484492898,
0.2209341377,
0.3811249137,
-0.123506248,
0.1593051106,
-0.009204777,
-1.1392040253,
-0.0957744271,
-0.7573173046,
-0.548760891,
-0.1125099361,
-0.8161682487,
0.4209812582,
-0.6234026551,
0.0317001529,
-0.0405575559,
-0.2145818621,
-0.3278643191,
-0.0509354696,
0.282366097,
0.5575564504,
-1.1933010817,
1.0599783659,
0.8705140352,
-0.1283484697,
-0.8758493066,
-0.138073504,
0.1111596748,
-0.9997947216,
0.5207089782,
0.1932266057,
-0.3473088145,
-0.0527437739,
-0.7892962694,
-0.9768288136,
0.8801738024,
0.5191701055,
-0.3130188584,
0.0070888577,
0.3783385754,
0.784003973,
-0.5566337705,
-0.0260563046,
0.4205993414,
0.0863096714,
-0.1409882009,
-0.8340776563,
0.0092126885,
-0.4830893874,
0.2174397111,
0.1074986234,
-0.8994785547,
0.4975046515,
-0.0527151451,
-0.2551517189,
0.0502265282,
0.8393408656,
0.3694001138,
0.3044350743,
0.5459615588,
0.3430187106,
0.7786685824,
0.108266145,
0.7799879313,
-0.4845895767,
0.1627297252,
1.0470728874,
-0.7854631543,
0.8051521778,
0.3926295638,
0.0162068885,
0.5767915249,
0.7016233802,
0.393032521,
0.3965462744,
0.1926855296,
-0.216510728,
-0.3761076033,
-0.0529053472,
-0.2801733315,
0.4311925173,
0.3181702197,
-0.0517986119,
0.0799955577,
-0.3509497344,
0.0106479265,
0.6304160357,
-0.2700246274,
0.9838784933,
0.0902146697,
-0.5626645684,
0.5063161254,
-0.1788516939,
0.7228721976,
-0.6399601102,
0.0080980519,
0.056869369,
0.4199936688,
0.0016894055,
-0.3778023422,
0.4106045067,
-0.1348928958,
-0.0541975871,
-0.3056783378,
0.6596772075,
-0.4698157609,
-0.4271171093,
0.4136588275,
0.2387663573,
0.0655151829,
0.3477330506,
-0.7570309043,
0.0454299077,
-0.1931346953,
0.1134534255,
0.7082150578,
0.4900610447,
-0.2453622371,
0.6961845756,
0.6313918233,
0.0261172168,
-0.0210431069,
0.1385266334,
0.8139595389,
-0.3664134443,
-0.5578070283,
-1.008523941,
0.2678715289,
-0.5001040697,
-0.0528624319,
0.5200496912,
0.322286427,
1.006583333,
0.2131361514,
0.7996551991,
0.1707312018,
0.3695463836,
-0.2731133699,
0.8451758623,
-0.3541904092,
0.1626688987,
-0.5144019127,
-0.6301653385,
-0.0201882496,
0.7760444283,
-0.3438380361,
-0.0067092651,
0.148293063,
0.8340943456,
0.0110552022,
0.0099467374,
0.4030593634,
-0.0306358226,
0.3184148073,
0.2885116339,
0.9932317138,
-0.1245363802,
0.2517915964,
-0.0309658647,
-0.4295679331,
0.0641183779,
-0.7709109783,
-0.9825963378,
-0.524186492,
-0.1412544847,
-0.4621630907,
0.4492254555,
1.4423387051,
0.6855724454,
-0.6762018204,
-0.5663593411,
0.0891657025,
-0.0702002868,
-0.2225593925,
-0.2357154638,
0.0387313105,
-0.5196918845,
-0.7718025446,
0.1631035954,
0.3469239473,
0.1362302601,
-0.3536002338,
-0.4406736493,
-0.2678812444,
0.4064278901,
0.3578749001,
0.2483103573,
-0.4880632162,
-0.6978498101,
0.0094555411,
-0.3407012224,
0.0894781426,
0.4822427928,
-0.5741383433,
0.0207011495,
0.2216382772,
0.8170607686,
0.0561439097,
0.1724737883,
0.8382890821,
-0.7335984707,
0.3996656537,
0.0715508983,
0.334625423,
0.4190865159,
-0.5064922571,
0.2872465253,
0.104816258,
-0.5705798864,
-0.9540260434,
0.4491623342,
-0.7828121781,
-0.1263893843,
1.3109703064,
-0.1608529985,
-0.486254245,
-0.106804803,
-0.1099647805,
0.5137500167,
-0.4428065121,
1.1703249216,
0.4788263738,
0.1444295198,
0.1343062818,
-0.0221653339,
0.6327983737,
0.5039466619,
-0.7663840055,
0.0828806907,
0.3898513913,
0.340811342,
0.1182650477,
0.8402577639,
-0.2467142045,
0.1178814173,
-0.2418528646,
0.2325172126,
0.3952269852,
-0.0962746367,
-0.4538924396,
0.0662958026,
0.1037288979,
0.0323483571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16958v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16958v2 | MixCE: Training Autoregressive Language Models by Mixing Forward and Reverse Cross-Entropies | 2023-05-26T14:14:51 | 2024-05-26T20:24:55 | Shiyue Zhang, Shijie Wu, Ozan Irsoy, Steven Lu, Mohit Bansal, Mark Dredze, David Rosenberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Autoregressive language models are trained by minimizing the cross-entropy of
the model distribution Q relative to the data distribution P -- that is,
minimizing the forward cross-entropy, which is equivalent to maximum likelihood
estimation (MLE). We have observed that models trained in this way may
"over-generalize", in the sense that they produce non-human-like text.
Moreover, we believe that reverse cross-entropy, i.e., the cross-entropy of P
relative to Q, is a better reflection of how a human would evaluate text
generated by a model. Hence, we propose learning with MixCE, an objective that
mixes the forward and reverse cross-entropies. We evaluate models trained with
this objective on synthetic data settings (where P is known) and real data, and
show that the resulting models yield better generated text without complex
decoding strategies. Our code and models are publicly available at
https://github.com/bloomberg/mixce-acl2023 | [
-0.3178836107,
-0.5406912565,
0.333719939,
0.2064970732,
-0.1162826121,
0.1034865454,
-0.3538642526,
-0.5084003806,
0.3220803142,
0.4166016877,
-0.565942049,
-0.4912929535,
-0.4710263312,
0.0134950411,
-0.7400534749,
1.0771491528,
-0.1766715646,
0.177136004,
0.1303034127,
0.0138313444,
0.0014676128,
-0.5320967436,
-0.6495733857,
-0.3033299744,
0.3977387846,
0.4149730504,
0.8638497591,
0.4602274299,
0.0995590016,
0.2304363996,
0.3963578939,
0.0047567249,
-0.4287596345,
0.4356715977,
-0.3162677288,
-0.0961341187,
-0.2770950794,
0.2771894932,
0.4675166309,
0.6994808912,
-0.2340542674,
0.0193158258,
0.0114617608,
0.5977393389,
-1.0412347317,
-0.1654552817,
-0.5033577681,
0.0294725746,
0.178756848,
-0.1086290181,
-0.2991272807,
-0.3088184297,
0.0682963207,
-0.3624805808,
0.3397003412,
0.1454408914,
0.682385087,
-0.0499978662,
-0.4640105367,
-0.2272760123,
-1.0089622736,
0.866527319,
-0.8678658605,
0.998960793,
0.4139897227,
0.2548926771,
0.0776076689,
-0.5755116343,
-0.8194676042,
-0.1975376308,
0.2085226625,
0.3574020863,
-0.0216225199,
-0.1346704215,
-0.0710804686,
0.4489800334,
-0.96410954,
-0.0784509629,
-0.1826745868,
-0.1512275934,
0.9740447998,
0.3032039106,
0.47384426,
0.5162187219,
-0.2089178115,
-0.401478529,
-0.4536223412,
-0.3199290037,
0.6160848141,
0.1427929997,
-0.2408749461,
0.5995780826,
-0.1917608678,
0.7034563422,
0.2510918081,
0.2739968002,
0.2927752137,
-0.4424265921,
-0.5573404431,
-0.1410936266,
0.9480425119,
-0.0825748146,
0.1625495851,
-0.5689105392,
-0.4277916551,
-0.0091718473,
0.132471323,
-0.6102203131,
-0.4335744083,
0.1479605585,
-0.5217790604,
-0.330727607,
-0.0503396727,
-0.7623944283,
-0.0432381332,
-0.5034760237,
0.4152513146,
-0.3156195283,
-0.3248778582,
0.0803007185,
-0.1736739725,
0.2425977737,
0.1678494811,
-1.1179823875,
0.7339881063,
0.3926109374,
0.5462424159,
-0.1649067551,
-0.6203473806,
-0.3398906291,
0.115441069,
-0.3578935266,
0.5841130614,
-0.6651224494,
-0.3520361781,
-0.2464758605,
-0.2215092182,
-0.2552492321,
-0.455142349,
0.3007233441,
-0.4141606987,
0.5413900614,
-0.0438455902,
-0.589389801,
-0.0187241994,
0.1608117521,
-0.5733672976,
0.9879494309,
-0.0080708358,
-1.1038986444,
0.6101767421,
-0.2516146004,
-0.5180145502,
-0.5149502158,
-0.1869891435,
-0.3906778097,
-0.0176252462,
0.3014499843,
0.2795605361,
-0.3290090859,
0.2394467145,
-0.4611392319,
0.0938194543,
0.0344773456,
-0.4881851673,
0.8200003505,
0.4628838301,
-0.4205675423,
0.1936427355,
-0.9301587343,
-0.0150163379,
0.1838784367,
-0.2290805876,
-0.6306893229,
0.0207372848,
0.3098361194,
0.3003430963,
0.1701991707,
-0.5955360532,
0.0642404929,
-0.561609745,
0.1010131761,
0.2293005437,
-0.0807575434,
0.6698487997,
-0.2625931501,
0.5114659667,
0.170682162,
0.045410946,
0.0890835077,
-0.4683859944,
-0.835259378,
-0.1319628507,
0.2859995663,
0.9272272587,
-0.6094954014,
0.4778564572,
0.1679445654,
-0.5844527483,
-0.5312101245,
0.3567944467,
0.2262973487,
0.3771818876,
0.541687727,
-0.2678881586,
-0.9419023991,
-0.9925809503,
-0.5035856962,
-0.1371157914,
-0.0550480857,
0.0342607982,
0.5351310968,
-0.5302708149,
0.8964399695,
-0.2456651777,
0.3321860433,
-0.4241095781,
0.3816849291,
-0.1350230128,
0.6227370501,
0.2979635596,
-0.7370075583,
-0.6410064101,
-0.0882959515,
-0.5732405186,
-0.1582786441,
-0.1683477312,
-0.2369493246,
0.2070287466,
0.65139395,
-0.3762062788,
0.4068228006,
0.8318039179,
-0.3821428716,
0.3391077816,
-0.1825152189,
0.1050020382,
-1.2502319813,
0.1727493703,
0.153884396,
-0.5819891095,
-0.6481704712,
-0.1572168916,
0.0773236528,
-0.3106306493,
-0.1572326422,
0.6989066005,
-0.5712064505,
-0.0991501734,
-0.3331923783,
-0.0159802027,
0.0928237066,
0.1852618456,
0.5643923879,
0.7488828301,
0.5952489376,
-0.730974257,
0.3411570489,
-0.1840688288,
0.0043238704,
0.239492476,
-0.5135284066,
0.0962995291,
-0.2452205271,
0.1628996432,
-0.9209504128,
-0.0280451998,
0.2877590358,
-0.5176523924,
0.6721595526,
0.2102995664,
-0.2635363042,
-0.1541317105,
-0.0779766813,
0.6261696815,
0.5595946312,
-0.5120321512,
0.6468907595,
0.5214060545,
-0.0638501346,
-0.5724889636,
-1.0193380117,
0.0255849604,
-0.0376812033,
-0.5596215129,
0.2359032184,
-0.029161023,
-0.4164240062,
0.0063284482,
0.0969154909,
-0.3152567446,
-0.1808316112,
-0.1773843318,
-0.0395380221,
-0.2260617763,
-0.0438729636,
0.0951012447,
-0.0522824377,
-0.0015362463,
-0.5196472406,
0.3948842585,
0.0823576674,
-0.3392444849,
-0.2060052752,
0.5797762871,
0.2443771958,
0.05702978,
0.8807359934,
0.5041460395,
-0.4518405199,
-0.3502769768,
-0.5310721993,
-0.3408530354,
-0.4077741802,
0.2948207259,
-0.2314264029,
-0.445625633,
0.6128931046,
0.4058872759,
0.2638947368,
0.4958157837,
0.8241941929,
0.0324997716,
1.0808392763,
0.6198060513,
-0.3658649027,
0.484885335,
-0.137393415,
0.1317066401,
-0.4929370582,
-0.1020172462,
-0.5024431944,
-0.1805440933,
-0.5664156675,
-0.2469550222,
-0.1909355521,
-0.1059521511,
-0.2788703144,
0.4483120441,
-0.1058188751,
0.470604986,
0.5271116495,
0.0497007035,
0.1846565306,
-0.1435534656,
-0.3004839718,
-0.0997565314,
-1.0101218224,
-0.216138199,
1.1584097147,
0.5193935633,
1.3824725151,
-0.2643927932,
1.221167922,
0.2513310313,
0.3671895266,
-0.4947334826,
0.2625267804,
-0.1194180474,
-0.6470019817,
-0.1998816282,
-0.7527307868,
-0.8769745231,
0.2465361208,
-0.2467162311,
-0.4429061413,
0.5167208314,
0.4018761516,
-0.0210241564,
0.4375918806,
-0.6453483701,
0.9829157591,
-0.3018021882,
-0.3128140867,
-0.1068327129,
-0.5813859105,
0.503462553,
0.1574700922,
0.3959970772,
0.3418631852,
-0.1860274076,
0.6692734957,
-0.4156228304,
0.9756318331,
-0.0343461558,
-0.2689513564,
0.301297605,
0.3378048539,
0.6026074886,
0.0413695127,
0.2532654107,
-0.0114134876,
-0.3635634184,
-0.4856755137,
-0.4541839957,
0.6550551653,
-0.933514595,
-0.0682116821,
-0.3203377128,
-0.4327242672,
-0.3889195621,
0.0375387669,
0.6426201463,
0.1697223186,
-0.486402601,
-0.2151744217,
0.7408049107,
-0.26657933,
0.3052000403,
0.4347997904,
-0.1760865301,
-0.7726666927,
0.8796320558,
-0.1309756488,
0.415843606,
0.4388840199,
0.1181871444,
-0.3660831153,
-0.2918493748,
-0.3840512335,
0.1322638541,
-0.7170010805,
0.0192430019,
-0.838855803,
-0.3129469156,
-0.6297047734,
-0.1506418139,
-0.7750352621,
-0.5518006682,
-0.3906447887,
0.1287109256,
-0.0987441242,
0.6877736449,
-0.3023806512,
0.2483897507,
-0.9052250385,
0.3957419693,
0.494959861,
0.2831614316,
-0.0700154155,
-0.7396834493,
-0.4115923345,
0.2914862633,
-0.1441582143,
-1.0849457979,
0.8016015887,
0.2944035828,
0.7730582356,
0.1116428226,
-0.1403723508,
0.3891868591,
-0.3546763062,
0.3671176732,
0.2307820767,
-1.131200552,
0.4995040298,
-0.2095528245,
0.2947975695,
0.7270380855,
0.4817010164,
-0.6515594721,
-0.8953019977,
-0.8062475324,
-0.981941998,
0.3414716423,
0.4535332322,
-0.0130870836,
-0.0515313894,
0.1500204653,
0.3333798647,
0.2671205103,
-0.9971247315,
-0.2357124686,
-0.4169680476,
-0.664581418,
-0.1626262963,
-0.173231259,
0.2499066144,
-0.1560064852,
0.9928874373,
0.1673951298,
0.2352571636,
0.3803753853,
-0.3391542733,
-0.3491765559,
0.3226239979,
0.6814764142,
0.3614570498,
-0.2898331881,
0.0377208777,
0.1929784864,
-0.5625398755,
0.0848337114,
-0.0282727536,
-0.3558543026,
0.043097008,
0.3399519324,
0.8600565791,
0.0463489257,
-0.5326506495,
0.3301919103,
-0.2793709636,
-0.393440038,
-0.249481976,
0.1190650165,
0.0589868352,
0.406835407,
0.2402640879,
0.1114157289,
0.4978135228,
-0.6244472861,
0.3163051307,
0.4591296613,
-0.1994524151,
-0.3768309355,
0.8184542656,
0.1913314313,
-0.0767938271,
0.4618147612,
-0.1301717311,
-0.4952429533,
0.5328268409,
0.7643747926,
1.3428959846,
-0.3218795061,
-0.0159168821,
0.3159555793,
0.6009405255,
-0.1812900901,
0.6237272024,
-0.1355701983,
-0.9101092219,
-0.4488127232,
-0.5486220121,
-0.6198379397,
0.0939312205,
-0.6122686863,
0.2610028982,
-0.3749948144,
-0.100296773,
-0.2132847607,
-0.2655828595,
-0.6426107287,
0.5606048107,
0.4270621836,
0.9204163551,
-1.3842589855,
0.9529931545,
0.7415385842,
-0.3321459591,
-0.5556653142,
0.3143071532,
-0.3646605611,
-0.6017630696,
0.8509955406,
-0.1781140119,
-0.1749667525,
0.0719421059,
-0.612847805,
-0.8771981597,
0.5886111856,
0.1707666516,
-0.7650431991,
-0.0141419386,
0.0047909473,
0.4945211112,
-0.6446687579,
0.2601271272,
0.3766582906,
0.3329872489,
-0.0868806839,
-0.9567136168,
-0.1613625884,
-0.3052870333,
-0.1286791265,
0.339840591,
-0.4020270705,
0.8558442593,
-0.0872618034,
-0.2063692361,
-0.4303312898,
0.8241477609,
0.1365417093,
0.5124217272,
0.4511030614,
0.8127299547,
0.3370228708,
0.3052172363,
0.8861919045,
-0.3387825489,
0.3936443627,
1.4062439203,
-0.361299932,
0.830139935,
0.4958729446,
-0.1360609233,
0.5062612891,
0.5734357834,
0.3400970697,
0.6629368663,
-0.1155851483,
-0.0635013729,
-0.3843884766,
0.5998809338,
-0.3596425354,
0.2296874225,
0.3723134696,
-0.6996361613,
-0.4336479902,
0.1060401276,
-0.3037129939,
0.0394936465,
-0.160172835,
0.8619451523,
0.1227953658,
-0.3809909523,
0.6793146729,
0.1729898304,
0.5815240741,
-0.4287474751,
0.2312025577,
-0.3056780398,
0.1059341356,
-0.1257067174,
-0.5474215746,
0.6283424497,
-0.0597297028,
-0.2494181246,
-0.0134711349,
0.8014985919,
-1.0532282591,
-0.6307893991,
0.3036314547,
0.469709605,
0.0655022264,
0.0877689272,
-0.9034080505,
-0.2789567709,
0.0253342129,
-0.5160472393,
0.2596766055,
0.51521945,
-0.0337524712,
0.6575782895,
0.4658721089,
0.3644021153,
0.2523805797,
0.0667875484,
0.7536148429,
-0.9384359717,
-0.7415879965,
-1.0382354259,
0.2484687418,
-0.0470856689,
-0.1415241212,
0.8148423433,
0.8343245983,
0.9668109417,
-0.0117820306,
1.0670922995,
0.1391643137,
0.6166821718,
-0.5899201632,
0.4699403942,
-0.6283278465,
0.0213537533,
-0.1328315139,
-1.0551755428,
-0.126247108,
0.7716265917,
-0.4008351266,
0.2705181539,
0.5236313939,
0.5565852523,
-0.5351887941,
0.0876727775,
0.2530757189,
-0.0287548006,
-0.048654113,
0.5341895819,
0.7694596052,
-0.5197892785,
0.3413195312,
-0.4652797282,
-0.0935831666,
-0.1896858066,
-0.7807319164,
-0.9544056654,
-0.318400979,
-0.4192138314,
-0.4049000144,
0.2149255276,
1.0596859455,
0.7074599862,
-1.1383154392,
-0.6003700495,
-0.5315083265,
-0.1764548719,
0.064260602,
-0.1926999539,
0.0566109084,
-0.4542194307,
-0.6001614332,
0.4050168097,
0.1502977163,
0.5145052671,
-0.4462847412,
-0.2592616975,
-0.2717310488,
0.3380849659,
0.2990880013,
0.4951479435,
-0.1934398115,
0.2442419678,
-0.0440761521,
-0.4086095989,
-0.0553401597,
1.1165539026,
-0.758911252,
0.4245497584,
0.9783785939,
0.5418208838,
0.7256876826,
-0.0125482883,
1.0730243921,
-0.7147197127,
0.4148077667,
0.3602573574,
0.3805778623,
0.2993697524,
-0.3189892471,
0.166697517,
0.2837415934,
-0.6163839698,
-0.5441278815,
0.3233279288,
-0.4362716973,
-0.440815568,
1.1169201136,
0.0468756147,
-0.3859681487,
-0.2262476534,
-0.010886441,
0.4568521976,
-0.449118197,
0.6093756557,
0.4479968846,
-0.0261597,
-0.1635122448,
-0.4207037687,
0.4666720033,
0.5007098913,
-0.8097258806,
0.1946029663,
0.5040126443,
0.3744216859,
-0.1978845,
0.5918926597,
0.1043836325,
0.1463546604,
0.2837241888,
0.3318941593,
0.2179295123,
-0.3718393743,
-0.2718275785,
-0.2139580995,
0.0015696186,
-0.0725701079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16957v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16957v1 | DisfluencyFixer: A tool to enhance Language Learning through Speech To Speech Disfluency Correction | 2023-05-26T14:13:38 | 2023-05-26T14:13:38 | Vineet Bhat, Preethi Jyothi, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Conversational speech often consists of deviations from the speech plan,
producing disfluent utterances that affect downstream NLP tasks. Removing these
disfluencies is necessary to create fluent and coherent speech. This paper
presents DisfluencyFixer, a tool that performs speech-to-speech disfluency
correction in English and Hindi using a pipeline of Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR), Disfluency Correction (DC) and Text-To-Speech (TTS) models.
Our proposed system removes disfluencies from input speech and returns fluent
speech as output along with its transcript, disfluency type and total
disfluency count in source utterance, providing a one-stop destination for
language learners to improve the fluency of their speech. We evaluate the
performance of our tool subjectively and receive scores of 4.26, 4.29 and 4.42
out of 5 in ASR performance, DC performance and ease-of-use of the system. Our
tool can be accessed openly at the following link. | [
-0.2588022947,
-0.8858961463,
-0.1522177905,
0.3750419021,
-0.2240852714,
0.7641981244,
0.0819786191,
-0.3102550507,
0.1892358363,
0.0666804388,
-0.4708562195,
-0.0820678324,
-0.7936098576,
0.1450687796,
-0.7824249864,
0.7379380465,
0.2626099885,
0.1937186271,
0.1338244081,
0.0899606422,
-0.8244140148,
-0.2256239057,
-0.9502930641,
-0.5195176601,
0.3352575898,
0.483350426,
0.7126309276,
0.4745281339,
0.268678993,
0.5416598916,
-0.2809943259,
-0.1247994006,
-0.4576579034,
0.1613955647,
-0.475895226,
-0.22770226,
-0.2111938894,
-0.5399611592,
0.7357881665,
0.6595356464,
-0.6463637948,
-0.4509929717,
0.213953808,
0.7493312955,
-0.4496484697,
-0.048560258,
-0.7707864046,
-0.0056151599,
-0.3347965181,
0.3721873462,
-0.1008264348,
-0.4263692498,
0.0209634472,
-0.3036543429,
0.1197690815,
-0.3277039826,
0.7471081614,
0.7187553048,
-0.3321145773,
-0.3230383098,
-0.9316490889,
0.5325259566,
-0.6015087366,
0.5918322206,
0.3148960769,
0.5881766677,
0.0283347964,
-0.6376870275,
-0.9122071862,
0.0768389851,
-0.2400829196,
0.2026684731,
-0.32395643,
0.1313141137,
0.1357025206,
0.7094673514,
-0.66367805,
0.2623433173,
-0.2625815272,
-0.4537141323,
0.5649901032,
-0.1503669471,
0.6230857372,
-0.0624811687,
-0.0296696797,
-0.2928718925,
-0.204308033,
-0.1867055297,
0.2333821952,
0.3272778988,
-0.0888885483,
0.3317224383,
-0.1285562664,
0.5466657877,
0.0790131316,
-0.5574015975,
0.1648234874,
0.1337796599,
-0.2934814394,
0.5147368908,
0.4534654915,
-0.0734580532,
-0.0459582694,
-0.3260180354,
-0.2890996039,
0.261606276,
-0.0167027116,
-0.550357163,
-0.3128816783,
0.0023585949,
0.2353152782,
-0.1032306924,
0.0613669008,
-0.7973496318,
-0.3336307108,
-0.403642267,
0.4805103242,
-0.6528121233,
-0.5227069855,
0.0723274723,
-0.3459610343,
0.0159874205,
0.263286531,
-0.7674688697,
0.4346806705,
0.3815568388,
0.8362159133,
-0.3307067752,
-0.206467241,
-0.6753306389,
0.1061009243,
-0.0740039125,
0.6091275215,
-0.2746011317,
-0.5168527365,
0.0230547693,
-0.2036452591,
-0.0810557157,
-0.6221678853,
0.6272687912,
-0.3227516413,
0.042958919,
0.0204622895,
-0.4611877799,
-0.0322825536,
-0.1415611953,
-0.7594846487,
0.9756838083,
0.2358517796,
-0.4824316502,
0.4509824514,
-0.4912840128,
-0.7066546082,
0.4924997687,
-0.0057909419,
-0.4332917333,
-0.1150736958,
0.1594453603,
0.0294212084,
0.1998728812,
0.3184375167,
0.2736328244,
-0.3865489662,
0.0265904386,
-0.7217556238,
0.8776922226,
0.2637063265,
-0.526019454,
0.1147170886,
-1.2024832964,
-0.1647754908,
0.078736417,
-0.5187299848,
-0.2619009018,
0.0987672955,
0.2991942167,
0.3221783638,
-0.1003456265,
-0.6053631306,
-0.170899123,
-0.9057747722,
0.4647331536,
0.574329555,
-0.3342951238,
0.2901037633,
-0.1397843063,
0.2038200945,
0.302819252,
-0.1643994898,
0.0889307112,
-0.2297190577,
-1.0280613899,
-0.4136002064,
0.257758677,
0.7360545993,
-1.0723739862,
0.4887107611,
-0.1677220911,
-0.6270275712,
-0.6370142102,
0.1736017466,
0.7270696759,
0.8119651079,
0.5047925711,
-0.1732853651,
-0.6477817297,
-0.5471251011,
-0.2019065619,
-0.2974546254,
-0.1157298759,
-0.4592487514,
0.2048690766,
-0.2047047317,
0.9624780416,
-0.3239091039,
-0.609855175,
-0.2097045481,
0.0634166375,
-0.3505746424,
0.5378803015,
0.33220011,
-0.7154534459,
-0.6470900178,
-0.0279786084,
-0.1173683107,
-0.2459617704,
0.1353531331,
0.3623312116,
0.744089365,
0.6285073161,
-0.169880718,
0.4280552268,
0.737665236,
-0.3900862634,
0.4276269376,
-0.0496974736,
0.1950698197,
-1.1506950855,
0.2251942605,
-0.1525669992,
-0.5434477925,
-0.7154609561,
-0.1007034779,
-0.1505488306,
-0.1689956784,
-0.4428709745,
0.3139772117,
-0.0596489087,
0.2829304934,
-0.2138634175,
0.5057718158,
-0.0005844827,
0.1606261432,
-0.0625612065,
0.9965160489,
0.4271570742,
-0.4699426591,
0.287073046,
0.5346493721,
-0.0959166065,
0.5593451858,
-0.5895569921,
0.2512365878,
-0.0834186748,
-0.0823956057,
-1.3647093773,
-0.3194374442,
0.2743108571,
-0.4004338682,
0.4418809712,
-0.1062327847,
-0.2465937436,
-0.2413740009,
-0.0486511514,
0.0095686521,
0.4003449082,
-0.6926926374,
0.3350674212,
0.5171342492,
-0.525924027,
-0.6438269019,
-0.8545248508,
0.1372506618,
0.0663610846,
-0.3573852479,
0.6067262888,
-0.1303711832,
-0.2907803357,
-0.33016029,
-0.2325212806,
-0.4459787905,
-0.1436009109,
0.3039397895,
0.1539276838,
0.1020040587,
0.2709863186,
0.4034101069,
-0.0126514668,
-0.1695462614,
0.3195733726,
0.6825937033,
-0.0660007372,
-0.5265066624,
-0.5449653268,
0.404925406,
0.4376862645,
-0.0840903148,
0.4452619255,
0.5121608973,
-0.5153679252,
-0.0558291711,
-0.7165222168,
-0.1502080858,
-0.5229672194,
0.5799949765,
-0.3944500089,
-0.8937813044,
0.2729547322,
0.001573946,
0.0511338077,
0.3954608738,
0.2472741604,
0.210818395,
1.094389677,
0.5439853072,
-0.3012776673,
0.6467605233,
0.1788363308,
0.3846258223,
-0.1897170544,
-0.256062299,
-0.6052898169,
-0.0742677301,
-0.1945897639,
-0.1858799756,
0.0198081024,
0.2477163672,
0.0779012591,
0.2782118022,
-0.6920129061,
0.4574384391,
0.2782415152,
0.0259400159,
0.4841668308,
0.065765135,
-0.0648753718,
-0.328849256,
-0.3337629139,
-0.4369215965,
0.2434277683,
0.2774315476,
0.4178363383,
0.3916770518,
0.451310128,
0.1704826206,
-0.010981462,
-0.9687820077,
0.3841567338,
-0.3610797822,
-0.3079682887,
-0.5214413404,
-0.3908877671,
-0.6443403363,
-0.0160401929,
-0.1283348352,
-0.5880846381,
0.1526468098,
0.3959237337,
-0.1157682762,
0.3463338912,
-0.8561557531,
0.4737281203,
0.1438794136,
-0.2914064825,
-0.3433819413,
-0.5593290925,
0.2797664106,
-0.1806673408,
-0.0434885174,
0.119972907,
0.3140268922,
0.4905053973,
-0.512638092,
0.7314667106,
-0.4365795553,
-0.1787809283,
-0.0122253234,
0.0946682692,
0.2798425257,
0.0641031042,
-0.1485430747,
0.3195640147,
0.0043129763,
-0.027663555,
-0.5835523009,
0.5469042659,
-0.6453550458,
-0.5936498642,
-0.3990516365,
-0.4683545828,
-0.2678737938,
0.3014340997,
-0.0237330534,
0.4124889374,
-0.4360467494,
-0.1088572592,
0.6892572045,
-0.1474741399,
0.7391925454,
0.7367606759,
-0.3532967567,
-0.3843891025,
1.0139898062,
0.0910396129,
0.2376408279,
0.403065294,
0.0928829089,
-0.5477722883,
-0.5704542398,
-0.4423869848,
0.177855894,
-0.7570810914,
-0.2228971869,
-0.4246774316,
-0.5986714363,
-0.5895681977,
-0.0593277961,
-0.3440139592,
-0.5757065415,
-0.0220395736,
0.0580486692,
0.3805259168,
0.6169607043,
-0.1921603233,
0.4913793504,
-0.5031174421,
0.3852229416,
0.589623332,
0.4623050988,
-0.4360476434,
-0.6589772105,
0.0544238836,
0.3344560564,
-0.6174356341,
-0.5961316228,
0.537709415,
0.589327991,
0.1807570308,
0.4356216192,
-0.063842237,
1.2005844116,
-0.6922350526,
0.6416890025,
0.4597886503,
-1.4349315166,
0.7819469571,
0.2579604387,
0.2843181491,
0.480445385,
0.1979944408,
-0.6844246387,
-0.6979647279,
-0.1305742264,
-0.9270907044,
0.8568683863,
0.1653882563,
-0.0649498925,
-0.0015641209,
0.3378789723,
0.0305708256,
0.0111266077,
-0.3865398169,
-0.3576289415,
-0.6404546499,
-0.1837900281,
-0.2638128102,
-0.1903982162,
-0.0739036351,
-0.3880647719,
0.9491012096,
0.0859002918,
-0.1071551889,
0.3855554163,
-0.3619379401,
-0.2008470744,
0.4806878567,
0.6089416742,
0.524230063,
-0.0367182344,
-0.0173613448,
0.3860358,
-0.9024250507,
0.224288255,
0.3996911943,
0.1344294548,
0.314616859,
-0.169451952,
0.6350153089,
-0.0671904758,
-0.7783845663,
0.4989751875,
-0.2853071988,
-0.2289147228,
-0.3702112138,
0.1245380864,
0.0560585819,
-0.1004045978,
0.2801111341,
0.3752592504,
0.3869066536,
-0.321160078,
0.3813904226,
0.2275439054,
-0.7012462616,
-0.1130243167,
0.741897583,
0.2584487498,
-0.7877003551,
0.5444010496,
-0.2158157527,
-0.4268375933,
0.039762862,
0.8320342898,
0.6460067034,
-0.989287138,
0.3173590004,
0.2313313782,
-0.021945538,
0.0937320814,
0.1452650279,
0.1001185104,
-0.5960183144,
-0.5718701482,
-0.6222004294,
-0.3862466216,
0.3115390837,
-0.6029239893,
0.4295478463,
-0.3020111918,
0.1824198365,
0.2472681403,
-0.2345910221,
-0.2058869451,
0.338478446,
0.0845779702,
0.6830739379,
-0.7441507578,
0.9567565918,
0.6718646288,
-0.4986118674,
-0.9034820199,
0.0979502946,
0.3458334804,
-0.6558541656,
0.5052528381,
0.0048019453,
-0.6516123414,
0.3014276326,
0.0901560336,
-0.542235136,
0.7221326828,
0.8495615721,
-1.0147130489,
0.1664377749,
0.6060040593,
0.516067028,
0.4264833927,
0.2110164911,
0.7457922697,
0.1483903378,
0.3026137054,
-1.1524027586,
-0.0164047442,
-0.3262603879,
0.0914823413,
0.2642391026,
-0.3240415454,
0.3377338648,
0.3482085168,
-0.4696828127,
-0.1842473745,
0.3826465607,
0.1997200102,
0.2722064257,
0.8007782102,
0.6572428942,
0.6085019112,
-0.2136752754,
0.4092636108,
-0.189713195,
0.0399359949,
0.9579355121,
-0.2279282659,
0.936511457,
0.7446600795,
-0.2859649658,
0.4944276214,
0.0500093065,
0.3807688355,
0.4506962001,
0.248338908,
-0.5887596607,
0.2263298631,
-0.0486159809,
-0.1338050216,
0.6872369647,
0.3983481824,
0.2070222348,
-0.309659183,
0.2845275104,
0.0944720507,
0.508367002,
-0.1515733451,
1.060801506,
-0.1897105277,
-0.6172949076,
0.7360625863,
-0.0921305194,
0.825514555,
-0.6732202172,
-0.355373174,
-0.269671768,
0.5402452946,
-0.379862994,
-0.5204751492,
1.0087120533,
-0.0587424748,
-0.1774846464,
-0.1740158647,
0.8079518676,
-0.6044018269,
-0.2819568515,
0.353518784,
0.200758189,
0.0456004106,
-0.2167724073,
-0.835552752,
0.1684860587,
0.0178310461,
0.3182722032,
0.183374241,
0.2190295607,
0.2701719403,
0.6284653544,
0.3840096295,
0.1610371321,
-0.0242381953,
0.4946665764,
0.9522051811,
-0.1171426848,
-0.3617692888,
-0.7978524566,
0.7706672549,
-0.355753392,
-0.2739380002,
0.6253731251,
0.7108538151,
1.0053986311,
-0.0320798084,
0.7756890655,
-0.2587097883,
0.9497230053,
-0.2287511826,
0.8921775818,
-0.5075421929,
0.320903331,
-0.6150584221,
-0.6084654927,
-0.4435689449,
0.8069067597,
0.0619076304,
-0.2312878519,
0.6044242382,
1.1417819262,
-0.0246218294,
-0.0322468467,
0.6907716393,
0.1721175015,
0.3809772134,
0.0915448293,
0.698264122,
-0.589230299,
0.7507609129,
-0.4274629354,
-0.3731728196,
-0.0779177174,
-0.4758274853,
-0.6468176842,
-0.8157193065,
-0.5016975999,
-0.1311675459,
0.36323753,
0.7889918685,
0.4324588478,
-1.0284030437,
-0.2926096022,
-0.6245337725,
0.1052204594,
-0.3660176396,
-0.3179982603,
0.1232320964,
-0.5821990371,
-1.1266673803,
0.5575972795,
0.3745187521,
0.0912918448,
-0.1910559982,
-0.066749461,
-0.1961520463,
-0.0060371831,
0.7104651928,
0.3188304305,
-0.7430077791,
-0.2923226357,
-0.2899391949,
-0.0629689693,
0.1264866889,
0.6485868096,
-0.7079339623,
0.6510944963,
0.2654907703,
0.5418159366,
0.0658763498,
-0.2091585994,
0.4632987082,
-1.1281714439,
0.3015851974,
0.2002477497,
0.3524316251,
0.4417745471,
-0.3090301752,
0.1484199911,
0.196308881,
-0.6425388455,
-0.9493088126,
0.1305911094,
-0.9002125859,
-0.2353095561,
0.7787287831,
-0.0911220014,
0.2065856159,
-0.5801481605,
-0.7253715992,
0.7742879987,
-0.4598425329,
1.0976696014,
0.5465316176,
0.2104910761,
-0.3460731208,
-0.0991355032,
0.7348498702,
0.5777819753,
-0.7305110693,
0.0302807111,
0.3583915234,
0.3532214761,
0.3545028269,
0.3454262018,
-0.2833975554,
0.1465812176,
0.0999627933,
0.1582500041,
0.0441238172,
-0.0547447689,
-0.7101106048,
-0.0960794836,
0.0644506738,
-0.2006567121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16954v1 | Compositional Generalization without Trees using Multiset Tagging and Latent Permutations | 2023-05-26T14:09:35 | 2023-05-26T14:09:35 | Matthias Lindemann, Alexander Koller, Ivan Titov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Seq2seq models have been shown to struggle with compositional generalization
in semantic parsing, i.e. generalizing to unseen compositions of phenomena that
the model handles correctly in isolation.
We phrase semantic parsing as a two-step process: we first tag each input
token with a multiset of output tokens. Then we arrange the tokens into an
output sequence using a new way of parameterizing and predicting permutations.
We formulate predicting a permutation as solving a regularized linear program
and we backpropagate through the solver. In contrast to prior work, our
approach does not place a priori restrictions on possible permutations, making
it very expressive.
Our model outperforms pretrained seq2seq models and prior work on realistic
semantic parsing tasks that require generalization to longer examples. We also
outperform non-tree-based models on structural generalization on the COGS
benchmark. For the first time, we show that a model without an inductive bias
provided by trees achieves high accuracy on generalization to deeper recursion. | [
0.0141190765,
-0.6174007654,
0.6638936996,
0.1639445573,
-0.3451812565,
0.1185223609,
0.0205328427,
-0.2874460518,
0.0406204872,
0.5799921155,
-0.8082110882,
-0.7454090118,
-0.5464813113,
-0.1389524341,
-0.3506934941,
0.9015117288,
0.1842863858,
0.2381976247,
-0.2792689502,
-0.2059096992,
-0.4247997701,
-0.3616316617,
-0.2739213407,
-0.4998025298,
0.5753139853,
0.2910176814,
0.4843787551,
0.6800498962,
0.4372277856,
0.2457783222,
-0.1677128226,
-0.0483330749,
-0.4105266333,
0.2925725281,
-0.2695210576,
-0.5532106161,
-0.1414738148,
0.0726914331,
0.6735935211,
1.2031782866,
0.0086223492,
0.0404771231,
-0.0461456664,
0.4013978839,
-0.5079908967,
0.0681794509,
-1.0537620783,
0.2938923538,
-0.122677654,
-0.0905108303,
-0.42945081,
-0.0277245678,
-0.0377200469,
-0.67530936,
0.4322305322,
-0.2868184149,
0.4991364181,
0.3561859727,
-0.5027121305,
-0.0688337684,
-0.7260293961,
0.9556909204,
-0.6400147676,
0.4693704545,
0.2769363523,
0.2667325139,
-0.3165613413,
-0.9976047277,
-0.311129868,
-0.0527120344,
-0.105957523,
0.2151501924,
0.1242841035,
0.2409847677,
0.3968481123,
0.4547193944,
-0.7211004496,
-0.0682537183,
-0.0360125042,
-0.0658433661,
0.3504038751,
0.2929495275,
0.2806641757,
-0.1060256734,
-0.4906529188,
-0.155160442,
-0.5760596395,
0.2142393291,
0.2044581324,
0.1922935545,
0.1601105332,
0.7655009627,
-0.2694085538,
0.6629326344,
0.0016303704,
0.0709113851,
0.2099744081,
-0.7024673223,
-0.2276093662,
-0.3122851849,
0.4044932127,
0.0378459059,
-0.0337489508,
-0.4774585068,
-0.2556475699,
0.4925529659,
0.0386807136,
-0.7192820907,
-0.5984231234,
0.18193762,
-0.4396317601,
-0.2789642811,
-0.0017789897,
-0.4970060289,
-0.2650165856,
-0.446587652,
0.270139426,
-0.3078268468,
-0.0624711365,
0.073052749,
-0.2049946189,
0.4117416739,
0.2266136259,
-0.8568670154,
0.5676437616,
0.9667169452,
0.6052143574,
-0.0927373916,
-0.3224710822,
-0.6311612725,
0.4347243309,
-0.377401799,
0.6917681694,
-1.0216526985,
-0.2177687287,
-0.4442929327,
-0.0213576723,
-0.1151523292,
-0.4805990458,
0.440641582,
-0.4997633994,
0.1126507446,
-0.249806419,
-0.80344522,
-0.3039936125,
0.1515352875,
-0.5218364,
0.8740733266,
0.0827403516,
-0.7117859125,
0.2986509204,
-0.6033559442,
-0.4046615064,
0.0134940036,
-0.4621912837,
-0.2113896161,
0.4519541562,
0.1238359287,
0.165088594,
-0.0882027224,
0.4870560765,
-0.4494533837,
-0.1961283833,
-0.0424916968,
0.0035963668,
0.8096414804,
0.2047288716,
-0.2001416534,
0.3809239864,
-0.6505441666,
0.3481341004,
0.2238099873,
-0.3051788211,
-0.2691656649,
0.2271490842,
-0.3493727744,
0.2748043835,
0.2077956051,
-0.6113529801,
0.1491113305,
-0.8288248181,
0.412907809,
0.7127901316,
-0.0474605002,
0.5886773467,
-0.2318488061,
0.2564734519,
0.2256781459,
-0.1105440184,
-0.510976553,
-0.4774038196,
-0.7337667346,
-0.031515643,
0.4350385368,
0.4090878665,
-0.4890863597,
0.6203727722,
-0.1866797656,
-0.4266358912,
0.0082337018,
0.0511694849,
0.4570094943,
0.4386317134,
0.3804837465,
-0.493295908,
-0.642752707,
-0.7517161965,
-0.3380346894,
0.1020044163,
-0.0933235064,
0.0214271154,
0.4344554842,
-0.2346275598,
0.9139774442,
-0.5827937126,
-0.0338560976,
-0.0539224371,
0.2795552909,
0.2424482703,
0.8460682631,
0.086788781,
-0.7207453847,
-0.2858456671,
-0.0985935852,
-0.6302790046,
0.0257910807,
0.179307878,
-0.2020704448,
-0.0337363034,
0.5390266776,
-0.3967599571,
0.4091718197,
0.5213132501,
-0.4608152509,
0.1851491928,
0.1474528164,
-0.5771021247,
-1.1329001188,
0.0514094494,
-0.4618922174,
-0.3353812397,
-0.5778897405,
0.283958286,
-0.2937760353,
-0.2902509868,
-0.0451994762,
0.3494157195,
-0.2170367837,
-0.4311903417,
-0.1281372011,
-0.4514275491,
0.3245416284,
0.5393971205,
0.119047977,
0.4054580629,
0.4160536826,
-0.4784331918,
0.2395244092,
0.0973182395,
-0.0226096231,
0.1178567335,
-0.8409401774,
0.1875763237,
-0.3530097902,
0.4680893719,
-1.2037035227,
-0.0728702322,
0.3248986602,
-0.4766373634,
0.0267913956,
-0.2524113655,
-0.317037493,
-0.1198100075,
-0.3140687644,
0.5748152733,
0.3182677925,
-0.3791435361,
0.7048956156,
0.1808714122,
0.0807700381,
-0.3622878492,
-0.7533265948,
-0.1544833481,
-0.0403654501,
-0.7747431993,
0.6962563396,
-0.161596626,
0.0120184626,
0.0965209007,
-0.4522994161,
-0.2167825103,
0.3697383404,
0.2136095464,
-0.0957516208,
-0.377943486,
0.3701521754,
-0.0028600367,
-0.2774504721,
-0.1161561087,
-0.6352444291,
0.8447462916,
-0.1597337574,
-0.5132129192,
-0.4283525646,
0.7013499141,
0.1782141328,
-0.6585307121,
0.4688389599,
0.5971096754,
-0.6017300487,
-0.0048182574,
-0.3413127363,
-0.268148452,
-0.3926418126,
0.2934033871,
-0.6557036638,
-0.9413028359,
0.459300369,
-0.1616704315,
0.1275562197,
0.5118482113,
0.3323895037,
-0.2178633064,
1.0975724459,
0.3935621977,
0.4372446835,
0.5112845898,
-0.3542800546,
0.1662695855,
-0.7042211294,
-0.3260289133,
-0.4927084744,
-0.4319581091,
-0.616243422,
-0.5048028827,
0.2007654756,
0.2762129009,
-0.2583609521,
0.1550184786,
-0.4308275878,
0.8738231063,
0.8125582337,
-0.0131777888,
0.4228510559,
0.2614757419,
-0.4169359207,
0.0555054843,
-0.5796968341,
-0.3993852735,
1.0935850143,
0.208943516,
0.6314148903,
0.0549244285,
1.0845934153,
0.1220496744,
0.0083363606,
-0.9229018092,
0.4702940881,
-0.5497542024,
-0.2563742697,
-0.4844950736,
-0.3897688389,
-1.227955699,
0.4877484143,
-0.0471033081,
-0.6935571432,
0.2413421571,
0.0371514708,
-0.2880322039,
0.0417008512,
-0.7172627449,
1.0078239441,
-0.0250709616,
-0.2504881322,
-0.0782983452,
-0.945618093,
0.3342215121,
0.1669432968,
-0.1216910034,
-0.296984911,
-0.0388574339,
0.7073168755,
-0.6620938182,
0.7593701482,
-0.2582743168,
0.2862709165,
0.3214872181,
0.2081915289,
0.6151086092,
-0.2157966793,
0.1623548269,
-0.0506006069,
0.2237251699,
-0.6425351501,
-0.6695176363,
0.5480191112,
-0.7906924486,
-0.5242932439,
-0.3120980263,
-0.4818638861,
-0.348785758,
0.2670449317,
0.160066247,
0.3599923849,
-0.1182003394,
0.1689967662,
0.4848040044,
0.0811139494,
0.4798001051,
0.1699915528,
-0.2898915708,
-0.4774324894,
0.8261509538,
0.0809657425,
0.0536833927,
0.3809379041,
0.5127321482,
-0.4150615036,
-0.4992233515,
-0.1240390241,
0.1305945963,
-0.7789453864,
-0.1618184745,
-0.9291831851,
-0.1968429834,
-0.5915849805,
0.1750971377,
-0.261698395,
-0.6271700859,
-0.2258404195,
-0.0802521929,
-0.2551022172,
0.8421372771,
0.2006962299,
0.3711431026,
-0.6362164021,
0.4186914861,
0.6224606037,
0.3441448212,
-0.0560757332,
-0.3381016552,
0.1084733233,
-0.0033228185,
-0.4762413204,
-0.8295788765,
0.0280838553,
0.2303291112,
0.4550002217,
0.1680101752,
-0.1738806069,
0.8160778284,
-0.4528452754,
0.6255871654,
0.2917440236,
-1.0747231245,
0.4566641152,
-0.3930363953,
0.2369172871,
0.5941013694,
0.0127940122,
-0.5709603429,
-0.1031461731,
-0.670399785,
-0.7492626309,
0.7058522701,
0.1684021801,
0.1689784229,
0.053346172,
0.1597213298,
0.1302971542,
0.1658921093,
-0.9172243476,
0.1566245705,
-0.4442526102,
-0.2861685455,
-0.0686337277,
-0.568506062,
-0.1138467938,
-0.4597148895,
0.5258719921,
-0.0767663643,
0.1252888292,
0.1369393319,
-0.1722947359,
-0.0444579795,
0.1986627132,
0.383220464,
0.6178096533,
0.0092423577,
0.5911943913,
-0.123757109,
0.0973424986,
0.1923217773,
0.0145470677,
-0.2682910264,
-0.1198737547,
0.3833233416,
0.5881760716,
0.0765847862,
-0.4388783574,
0.6302360296,
0.1460391283,
-0.1023131013,
-0.2574755549,
0.06047111,
0.3199775815,
0.3997556865,
0.0027889616,
0.0682343245,
0.4126905203,
-0.3529188335,
0.1661444008,
0.448417455,
-0.083854042,
-0.4798745811,
0.5812245607,
0.0953878909,
0.0481024496,
0.6099644899,
-0.2527338564,
-0.2900533378,
0.7228939533,
0.8446958661,
0.9476481676,
-0.2709445059,
0.0475918837,
0.2873328626,
0.1501810849,
0.0533543713,
0.384629786,
-0.2498462051,
-0.9049236774,
-0.5117962956,
-0.8451997638,
-0.2113319337,
0.1842808276,
-0.4341709912,
0.083569698,
-0.6610605717,
0.0914036855,
0.2197691798,
-0.1034961268,
-0.5529184937,
0.2477975041,
0.1396437138,
0.6170223355,
-1.0418503284,
0.8728291988,
0.8779360056,
-0.2897520065,
-0.8131937981,
0.1347918361,
-0.4447267354,
-0.6256635785,
0.4978097975,
0.4749623537,
0.0722506642,
0.1026692614,
-0.7249758244,
-1.0571341515,
0.9274649024,
0.4619829357,
-0.2940168381,
-0.1742965877,
0.1403071731,
0.4368130267,
-0.4417064488,
-0.1276006103,
0.5291694999,
0.4100063145,
0.6688408256,
-0.3217653036,
-0.0652915239,
-0.2409500182,
0.3972082734,
0.1853972673,
-0.3701192439,
1.2597023249,
0.1199860647,
-0.3949097693,
0.1355183572,
0.5638526678,
-0.0239335112,
0.5398393869,
0.3539682627,
1.0813336372,
0.8828190565,
0.046213232,
0.9005374908,
-0.0668212324,
0.3155475557,
1.8470323086,
-0.2664798796,
0.5625761151,
0.5298376679,
-0.3588010371,
0.5129581094,
0.6073567867,
0.0913914442,
0.4131828249,
0.3189598918,
-0.4225678146,
-0.606158793,
-0.3550030291,
-0.4014982879,
0.724740386,
0.2565225363,
-0.5409842134,
-0.5755209327,
-0.3788675666,
-0.1193913221,
0.3139103353,
-0.1712223142,
1.036352396,
-0.162033394,
-0.7373196483,
0.4251936376,
0.404216826,
0.2757765353,
-0.5310040116,
-0.1629288644,
-0.1124116555,
-0.0151893944,
-0.391055882,
-0.4911577106,
0.7917171121,
-0.3487479091,
-0.3383467197,
-0.0660889372,
0.8060151935,
-0.4576658905,
-0.7183264494,
0.2238372862,
0.6198387146,
0.0959364772,
-0.2279477715,
-0.4100881219,
-0.2295184284,
-0.1266115159,
-0.010410496,
0.0446137413,
0.2874698639,
-0.2755507827,
0.1011347622,
0.7297124267,
-0.4568772018,
0.4324628711,
-0.0126829464,
1.1286761761,
-0.8233045936,
-0.4428902566,
-0.9926974773,
0.3232161701,
0.1995690316,
0.0457979962,
0.4182903469,
0.7768832445,
1.0047795773,
-0.0625310913,
0.5375833511,
0.1976866573,
0.4373610318,
-0.5603685975,
0.0278731994,
-0.4650582969,
0.0467069745,
-0.0435467847,
-1.0276793242,
-0.680742383,
0.510679841,
-0.4139006436,
-0.0973900706,
0.7014531493,
0.7940753698,
-0.0845023543,
0.149112314,
0.4402537644,
0.1369531304,
0.2360325307,
0.6978907585,
0.9764482975,
-0.184365958,
0.2741068006,
-0.2680404782,
-0.0167638175,
0.1045697629,
-0.7111738324,
-0.7790407538,
-0.4606323838,
-0.0173506644,
-0.3505578935,
-0.1418918669,
0.9557375312,
0.6198174953,
-0.9186255336,
-0.1673731655,
-0.6174954176,
0.3399750292,
0.0503503978,
-0.2153392732,
0.0746919289,
-0.6531009078,
-0.5107427239,
0.4716832042,
0.2737552524,
0.1213725731,
-0.0029591699,
0.0167236887,
-0.2258549184,
0.066052258,
0.6138295531,
-0.030386813,
-0.8786579967,
-0.2311079055,
-0.2336206734,
0.0814203545,
0.4454305172,
0.9126472473,
-0.8264020085,
0.5027117729,
0.6464122534,
0.7903461456,
0.7028252482,
0.2001129836,
0.2102955431,
-0.8955134749,
0.1229073927,
0.4375792146,
0.2966255546,
0.1557385772,
-0.0582129434,
0.6412749887,
0.6541316509,
-0.1476842016,
-0.436085999,
0.8430557847,
-0.8990212083,
-0.3166577518,
0.866778791,
-0.2822418511,
-0.2769798934,
0.0082767438,
-0.0018617992,
0.3470597267,
-0.2024457008,
0.2683341205,
0.5529589653,
-0.2368608266,
0.0919372961,
0.2745000124,
0.1224295571,
0.6633155942,
-0.7358345389,
-0.0322205983,
0.7871685028,
0.491592586,
0.0854317993,
0.6738862991,
-0.2920843661,
0.0997527242,
0.0443276912,
-0.0025484234,
-0.084604077,
-0.4854599833,
-0.4999948144,
0.4827754796,
0.2287740409,
-0.3044137061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16947v1 | Sentence-Incremental Neural Coreference Resolution | 2023-05-26T14:00:25 | 2023-05-26T14:00:25 | Matt Grenander, Shay B. Cohen, Mark Steedman | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose a sentence-incremental neural coreference resolution system which
incrementally builds clusters after marking mention boundaries in a
shift-reduce method. The system is aimed at bridging two recent approaches at
coreference resolution: (1) state-of-the-art non-incremental models that incur
quadratic complexity in document length with high computational cost, and (2)
memory network-based models which operate incrementally but do not generalize
beyond pronouns. For comparison, we simulate an incremental setting by
constraining non-incremental systems to form partial coreference chains before
observing new sentences. In this setting, our system outperforms comparable
state-of-the-art methods by 2 F1 on OntoNotes and 7 F1 on the CODI-CRAC 2021
corpus. In a conventional coreference setup, our system achieves 76.3 F1 on
OntoNotes and 45.8 F1 on CODI-CRAC 2021, which is comparable to
state-of-the-art baselines. We also analyze variations of our system and show
that the degree of incrementality in the encoder has a surprisingly large
effect on the resulting performance. | [
-0.4031389058,
-0.6368397474,
0.4269926846,
0.3571120799,
-0.2483716756,
-0.061299555,
-0.774481535,
-0.6863068342,
0.347712636,
0.3242931366,
-0.3814578652,
-0.391171366,
-0.8852685094,
0.4232712388,
-0.5795246363,
0.8411260843,
0.2854727209,
-0.1660143435,
-0.4406454563,
-0.1584143639,
-0.6061172485,
-0.7116990089,
-0.519695878,
-0.4731202722,
0.3262549937,
0.6562664509,
0.6000176668,
0.764934659,
0.6670401096,
0.3135172427,
-0.5689365864,
0.173628673,
-0.0572316051,
0.1139687598,
-0.1806620657,
-0.3232190907,
-0.4571122825,
-0.2171040773,
0.7047140598,
0.7626993656,
0.0674467236,
0.166518569,
-0.075557135,
0.3758563101,
-0.6197654605,
0.076866217,
-0.8042136431,
-0.0091343587,
-0.2044863552,
-0.0145744989,
-0.4720501602,
-0.214872703,
0.2267220318,
-0.3356600404,
0.3406290114,
-0.1296233535,
0.8966796994,
0.0277369265,
-0.1748096794,
-0.5333084464,
-0.5582528114,
0.5078370571,
-0.8520659804,
-0.018595254,
0.2383580655,
-0.2752584517,
0.2848799825,
-0.6824472547,
-0.6903392076,
-0.452503413,
-0.1386325657,
-0.1362667382,
-0.2696356773,
0.0971180052,
0.4805625081,
0.3974954486,
-0.498736918,
0.1729044914,
-0.3579083979,
-0.2818336487,
0.3141063452,
0.1403817236,
-0.0158380941,
-0.2580849826,
-0.1841170192,
0.2824890018,
-0.638215065,
-0.0230684448,
-0.0686302185,
0.4622860253,
0.2913201749,
0.5327086449,
-0.1602745503,
0.5713348985,
0.8349558115,
-0.1012777761,
0.2040662169,
-0.5638076067,
-0.0613547228,
0.4435971081,
0.4827292562,
0.4128102064,
0.0664639324,
-0.2471792251,
0.1365715712,
0.3238812089,
0.3974970877,
-0.6730856895,
-0.1964180171,
-0.0130165983,
-0.3073278069,
0.0612954088,
-0.1921928525,
-0.4105393887,
-0.2866936326,
-0.5019899011,
0.27591905,
-0.8316572309,
0.1251916587,
-0.1099349111,
-0.075341858,
-0.0706358552,
0.3438172638,
-0.7255529165,
0.4110949337,
0.4773738682,
1.0069692135,
-0.1193750501,
-0.2993387282,
-0.2545377314,
-0.0048951148,
-0.3172474802,
1.0111135244,
-0.616155982,
-0.611261785,
-0.0958094597,
-0.2951999605,
-0.0931736454,
-0.9866926074,
0.6906988621,
-0.1872410029,
-0.1637251377,
-0.2873633802,
-0.7588607669,
-0.1111208722,
0.5502995253,
-0.399618119,
0.9984586835,
-0.2324491888,
-0.5050144196,
0.103020668,
-0.5616718531,
-0.5826985836,
0.0880033448,
0.0277673155,
-0.1046330482,
0.1168577597,
0.2601849139,
0.3428263068,
-0.3361834884,
0.2938925624,
0.1234493852,
-0.2950722575,
0.19425565,
0.0703540593,
0.3254773915,
-0.0833876655,
-0.3549135625,
0.4878537655,
-0.6046757102,
-0.1453864872,
-0.3488209546,
-0.1226874068,
-0.4063909054,
-0.2816469073,
-0.2860796154,
0.2689705193,
0.5606720448,
-0.7146472335,
0.1734870672,
-0.2338573933,
0.7496248484,
0.541637361,
0.0170932915,
0.8052815795,
-0.031173829,
0.0865975767,
0.466670543,
0.2311956733,
-0.3495434225,
-0.3953931332,
-1.183891654,
0.0060939658,
0.2507503629,
0.4234403372,
-0.4289931953,
0.6958973408,
-0.5127235651,
-0.5007672906,
-0.2096564025,
-0.2286707908,
0.4951075613,
0.7355465889,
0.7537064552,
-0.2623150349,
-0.5767659545,
-1.1682126522,
-0.0118810618,
-0.1262515187,
0.2655289769,
0.2496943176,
0.6468263268,
0.1801553965,
0.8278191686,
-0.2238255739,
-0.3101098835,
0.0758844689,
0.1877114922,
0.4330892563,
0.757860899,
0.2730014622,
-0.6388130784,
-0.2469558418,
-0.0418310203,
-0.575262785,
0.1321690083,
-0.0938120261,
0.0521555208,
0.0522093587,
0.5457507372,
-0.745331645,
0.513684094,
0.3464208841,
-0.4719555974,
0.7916051745,
-0.1783009619,
0.0716353953,
-0.9018951654,
0.1044295207,
0.0213599987,
-0.1233252585,
-0.422998935,
-0.1659641713,
0.1665213257,
0.0551553406,
0.0002138666,
0.060911797,
-0.5073318481,
0.0820476338,
-0.3705864549,
0.1830224991,
-0.0965235233,
0.4774335623,
0.2086796463,
0.7544521093,
0.2358328849,
-1.0381709337,
0.236323297,
0.5671434402,
-0.2508304417,
0.9651807547,
-0.5469295382,
0.177704528,
-0.076522626,
0.5430860519,
-0.7667620778,
0.294128716,
0.0198894776,
-0.5472826958,
0.0727342069,
0.1184337959,
-0.3679783046,
-0.325150907,
-0.0407350622,
0.4935961664,
0.2059989423,
-0.4826918244,
0.5571138263,
0.3678103685,
-0.3019826114,
-0.4917130768,
-0.8763652444,
0.6127111316,
0.0719540343,
-0.4683870673,
0.942547977,
-0.1169030666,
-0.0738931447,
0.1027204171,
-0.141640082,
0.0220523719,
-0.3337412477,
0.4925474226,
0.2046492845,
-0.1007600278,
0.5656783581,
0.25088498,
-0.142396301,
-0.0372934081,
-0.5279005766,
0.4600836039,
-0.5050008297,
0.1884808093,
-0.3430981636,
0.7397607565,
0.3501549363,
-0.2833170891,
0.559048593,
0.2958542407,
-0.5868443847,
-0.0093345884,
-0.6590572596,
-0.1941928118,
-0.3998299241,
0.2408037782,
-0.7042790651,
-1.2964824438,
0.5348348618,
-0.2315323055,
0.1017860696,
0.5171490312,
0.7170478106,
-0.0494654961,
0.2618933618,
0.3936386406,
0.2114707232,
0.3818112314,
-0.2394534349,
0.2625986338,
-1.1736872196,
-0.2094970196,
-0.8037275672,
-0.5531360507,
-0.0633146241,
-0.529635787,
0.1046410277,
0.2341030687,
-0.334898144,
0.792586267,
-0.7695678473,
0.3082169294,
0.6484530568,
0.2266287655,
0.4619788527,
-0.3347150385,
-0.2740531266,
-0.1958532631,
-0.6952043176,
-0.3278057575,
0.5380941033,
-0.0602012835,
0.1741794646,
0.0360802077,
0.4699185193,
0.5491438508,
0.5623930097,
-0.7557523847,
0.841768384,
-0.3482044339,
-0.4310279191,
-0.1201711074,
-0.3250851631,
-0.6096467376,
0.1792623699,
-0.1475023776,
-0.8511884809,
0.5789346099,
0.0568947978,
-0.4647429287,
0.391269654,
-0.3597040176,
0.4950308502,
0.3847818375,
-0.1977000982,
-0.3857150376,
-0.7353046536,
0.0459761359,
0.462616086,
-0.1147705391,
-0.3188225329,
-0.1983357519,
0.6908367276,
-0.4316765964,
0.9589016438,
0.0021227484,
0.122155197,
0.517889142,
0.1537374109,
0.3994804323,
-0.0366443209,
-0.2060427219,
0.3192270398,
-0.1348873228,
-0.2243289053,
-0.4849855602,
1.0249156952,
-0.5469628572,
-0.2252319008,
-0.3943433762,
-0.6772660613,
-0.057041917,
0.0458739623,
0.5473131537,
0.4502701163,
-0.2620843053,
0.0519311577,
0.5510067344,
0.3023632467,
0.8209042549,
0.2537839711,
0.0648957565,
-0.7832190394,
0.3015508652,
0.5119760036,
-0.1100287959,
0.4596127272,
-0.0309637785,
-0.3982693255,
-0.6505582333,
-0.2552061379,
0.3953990042,
-0.8756812215,
-0.5629766583,
-0.7008162141,
-0.1172126159,
-0.7468018532,
-0.1317064762,
-0.3228236437,
-0.6423549056,
-0.3671733737,
-0.298196584,
0.5046087503,
0.4682096243,
-0.23600775,
0.3811552823,
-0.896484375,
-0.0558035113,
-0.0404936858,
0.0649372265,
-0.0136178425,
-0.8636277318,
-0.495536387,
-0.2810696959,
-0.0984593555,
-0.6245546937,
0.1763523221,
0.39676103,
0.0730370581,
0.1457235366,
0.1535277069,
0.993052125,
-0.491089344,
0.9248858094,
0.2319797575,
-1.3994057178,
0.4865134656,
-0.1417619437,
0.6723440886,
0.8892648816,
0.0708990023,
-0.8909011483,
-0.155835852,
-0.6826322079,
-0.9138935208,
0.1963742077,
0.1104571,
0.120725356,
-0.4834299684,
1.0898649693,
0.0671903193,
0.2339696735,
-0.4100556374,
-0.1123336181,
0.1627334356,
0.0063133379,
-0.026002083,
-0.4062069058,
0.0324438363,
-0.322558403,
0.6615628004,
-0.2813443542,
0.4846304953,
0.6905741096,
-0.3750946522,
0.1644520909,
0.3544358909,
0.7397611737,
0.6125041842,
0.0750906467,
0.4865726829,
0.3427189887,
-0.522929132,
0.1153396368,
-0.2228107303,
-0.429056555,
0.2465785891,
0.4026143849,
0.692004621,
0.3177386224,
-0.3902254403,
0.1877259165,
0.2655153573,
-0.3056111038,
-0.5031756163,
-0.338473171,
0.2803229392,
0.2377770245,
0.281714052,
0.6515110135,
0.1905253679,
-0.291833967,
0.3276051283,
-0.0342406556,
-0.6818757057,
-0.4125221372,
0.0315781049,
0.3871459365,
-0.3228570819,
0.9273626804,
0.0202809051,
-0.5224981308,
0.5591537356,
0.617244482,
0.8512119651,
-0.2291773111,
0.1983957291,
0.9256292582,
0.3784635365,
-0.1884326935,
0.2027827054,
-0.3121955991,
-1.0637264252,
-0.5933762789,
-0.2861980498,
-0.5661634803,
-0.2640101314,
-0.9681700468,
-0.2377882153,
-0.7668257952,
-0.6819351315,
-0.0409248061,
-0.1935537606,
-0.3268023431,
0.212098524,
0.3015287519,
0.9337185025,
-0.3406341672,
0.8356682062,
0.8536695242,
-0.3236000836,
-0.3709281683,
-0.2503015399,
-0.2774251103,
-0.1674784571,
0.5167458057,
0.3615576327,
-0.2518366277,
0.1554346085,
-0.4423980713,
-0.7664551139,
1.1160663366,
0.4203255773,
-0.6598692536,
-0.2487838119,
-0.0729372501,
0.4445005059,
-0.5107577443,
0.1631905884,
0.7699745297,
0.6041549444,
-0.0583840981,
-1.2217808962,
0.2385430783,
-0.4115418196,
0.2644849718,
0.2551063001,
-0.6967054605,
0.9523043633,
-0.228615731,
-0.4333397746,
0.2140662223,
1.0521430969,
-0.0888755918,
-0.0159332287,
0.5465314388,
0.9669516087,
0.707077682,
-0.2051125467,
0.7661976814,
-0.2587600052,
0.3190667033,
1.6079939604,
-0.3078669906,
1.014332056,
0.7458800077,
-0.1318821609,
0.6082058549,
0.5435380936,
0.1642255187,
0.1620491743,
0.2983384728,
-0.4925348163,
-0.4586647749,
-0.60850811,
-0.1963927895,
0.1666577458,
0.5049645305,
-0.393732518,
-0.2312151343,
0.1655572802,
0.1121701747,
0.46262151,
-0.5090092421,
0.7996515036,
0.0767949298,
-0.8747726083,
0.3203857541,
0.0374832526,
0.9608736038,
-0.4865894914,
0.06286975,
-0.1218183115,
0.5312888026,
-0.2586151063,
-0.5575940609,
0.6072969437,
-0.0450679064,
-0.61872226,
-0.0691210106,
0.6860161424,
-0.5512920022,
-0.3466883004,
0.4098951519,
0.2631513476,
-0.1218980327,
-0.4334764183,
-0.5500243902,
-0.0025018004,
-0.2341592461,
0.1034874469,
0.2088583857,
0.2840631604,
0.0606662668,
0.3255641162,
0.4597983956,
-0.0958985612,
0.2972933352,
-0.1315574348,
0.848521471,
-0.9191032052,
-0.5131116509,
-0.7504833937,
0.189643681,
-0.2727310956,
-0.7241178751,
0.4897190928,
0.4620093703,
0.6974319816,
-0.0193115268,
0.6533223987,
-0.3628993034,
0.4281657338,
-0.3497233093,
0.0768076181,
-0.0519329756,
-0.0253797043,
0.0471349247,
-0.7928437591,
-0.6720787883,
0.6720930338,
-0.3913097978,
-0.3120892644,
1.0125724077,
0.6543526649,
0.3662014306,
0.2989840508,
0.1977209747,
0.225963071,
0.1445417851,
0.6619526148,
0.7628844976,
-0.4624911845,
0.5638158321,
-0.4264237881,
-0.1402645111,
-0.1465168744,
-0.8700706363,
-0.4501974583,
-0.7373514771,
-0.5839446187,
-0.6088091731,
0.1756409556,
1.0477050543,
0.7185003757,
-0.7906656861,
-0.3826307058,
-0.1173511147,
-0.2180656791,
-0.6389715075,
-0.1892153174,
0.2852980793,
-0.431342721,
-0.6776824594,
0.3855342567,
0.6115888357,
-0.4840104282,
-0.0800084099,
0.1940816194,
-0.7049286962,
0.0392451398,
0.7517101765,
0.1116820127,
-0.6707167625,
-0.4315105677,
-0.0125982203,
-0.2285456359,
0.5269877911,
1.3908919096,
-0.6928678751,
0.1634557396,
0.6121214032,
0.4654604495,
0.6139630675,
0.1096728146,
0.3276954293,
-0.6832125783,
0.1589734554,
0.6804543734,
0.3598370552,
0.2594960034,
-0.4239090979,
0.400865674,
0.251180917,
-0.4751600027,
-0.2362944633,
0.3134645224,
-1.200705409,
-0.1967217028,
0.7502515316,
-0.3622626066,
-0.2455411702,
-0.1651426703,
-0.2297415286,
0.0509918667,
-0.6987051964,
0.4348948598,
0.8243391514,
-0.4788252115,
-0.3891589046,
0.3119147718,
0.0834249556,
0.4036895931,
-0.6878699064,
0.1464026421,
0.6466217637,
0.1078406274,
0.9603585005,
0.6969144344,
-0.2985053658,
0.2616998553,
0.1987103969,
0.4555286467,
-0.0666954592,
-0.4008142352,
-0.3559870422,
0.5280468464,
-0.1648721993,
-0.0177453533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16944v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16944v3 | Learning to Imagine: Visually-Augmented Natural Language Generation | 2023-05-26T13:59:45 | 2023-06-15T06:25:34 | Tianyi Tang, Yushuo Chen, Yifan Du, Junyi Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | People often imagine relevant scenes to aid in the writing process. In this
work, we aim to utilize visual information for composition in the same manner
as humans. We propose a method, LIVE, that makes pre-trained language models
(PLMs) Learn to Imagine for Visuallyaugmented natural language gEneration.
First, we imagine the scene based on the text: we use a diffusion model to
synthesize high-quality images conditioned on the input texts. Second, we use
CLIP to determine whether the text can evoke the imagination in a posterior
way. Finally, our imagination is dynamic, and we conduct synthesis for each
sentence rather than generate only one image for an entire paragraph.
Technically, we propose a novel plug-and-play fusion layer to obtain
visually-augmented representations for each text. Our vision-text fusion layer
is compatible with Transformerbased architecture. We have conducted extensive
experiments on four generation tasks using BART and T5, and the automatic
results and human evaluation demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed
method. We will release the code, model, and data at the link:
https://github.com/RUCAIBox/LIVE. | [
-0.5888461471,
-0.900511682,
0.5650631189,
0.4467848539,
-0.3330833018,
0.4422217309,
-0.1279863566,
-0.6689473987,
0.2049219757,
0.7243015766,
-0.6539515257,
-0.4014101326,
-0.0740972459,
0.2788475156,
-0.1969709545,
0.5477461219,
-0.1012304798,
-0.2228248864,
-0.4446259737,
0.2086850703,
-0.5266627669,
-0.1789308786,
-0.4303157032,
-0.0024312255,
0.23182863,
0.32688272,
0.5128523707,
0.5369668603,
0.1440413743,
0.367387861,
0.2125718445,
0.5843030214,
-0.3305619061,
0.1442169994,
0.1261451989,
-0.3013311327,
-0.1389058381,
0.0996189192,
0.7224108577,
0.5637429357,
0.0352248438,
-0.1197610497,
0.0298725776,
0.4108353853,
-0.4485581815,
0.0754823238,
-0.4994978607,
0.3833850026,
0.1686248928,
-0.1942459494,
-0.4940065145,
-0.4652913213,
0.4660609663,
-0.9233558178,
0.250477463,
0.3946703672,
0.8684284091,
0.131352216,
-0.267385751,
-0.0777971372,
-0.7299664617,
0.4581752121,
-0.472491771,
0.29212448,
0.1561765075,
0.2990580797,
-0.0382298976,
-1.0927911997,
-0.9893359542,
-0.2565327883,
0.06169549,
0.348207891,
0.1085637733,
0.0240780599,
0.213101998,
0.6451846957,
-0.5403735042,
-0.2395853251,
-0.3396050334,
-0.0765742436,
0.4892782271,
0.0147412205,
0.88388592,
-0.2886192501,
-0.5279957056,
-0.3417138159,
-0.4482651353,
-0.2588780224,
0.170038566,
0.0538539216,
-0.2781877816,
0.608183682,
0.0468426421,
0.9733490348,
-0.1159567386,
-0.0381927043,
0.2456654459,
-0.3187726438,
-0.4408938885,
0.0471947417,
0.8617911339,
0.5053616762,
0.499584049,
-0.1807287782,
-0.1982295364,
0.3328349888,
0.5590663552,
-0.6005997062,
-0.4430803955,
-0.1982480586,
-0.1714836806,
-0.4959276617,
-0.0129509037,
-0.9899479151,
-0.4750931561,
-0.4847130477,
0.808899641,
-0.6125639081,
-0.1618977487,
0.0019073967,
-0.2203519493,
0.0360610075,
0.2018675357,
-0.8704962134,
0.3613315225,
0.1542160958,
0.4874728322,
-0.0646669343,
-0.5602691174,
-0.3587518632,
0.2959587872,
-0.3782031834,
1.1449538469,
-0.3566124141,
-0.3727754653,
0.2457514405,
-0.2912021279,
-0.0767951608,
-0.625873208,
0.3401897848,
-0.297062695,
0.7175825834,
0.0966450348,
-0.4942215979,
-0.1181917563,
0.1772038192,
-0.8617327213,
1.014349699,
0.1199387908,
-0.6780191064,
0.5766865015,
-0.7982487679,
-0.6278986931,
0.4357473254,
-0.1637197584,
-0.4072740078,
0.1747459322,
0.5283027291,
0.3523969948,
0.125350818,
0.047747571,
0.1406812668,
-0.1257499158,
0.3898794651,
-0.3220252991,
0.4205852151,
0.2512300611,
-0.2228536755,
0.2954636812,
-1.0414266586,
0.0427038372,
0.2839145958,
-0.2908568084,
-0.2475190014,
0.0773333758,
0.156843707,
0.1800864935,
0.0178911556,
-0.6758936644,
-0.1099143624,
-0.9048154354,
0.3672780395,
0.3020872176,
0.3142954707,
0.7989561558,
-0.3320199251,
0.6095690727,
-0.034722209,
-0.0549374074,
-0.5921307206,
-0.4485610127,
-1.0342257023,
-0.283878386,
0.0983824059,
0.538472712,
-1.2541185617,
0.2404779494,
-0.2846883237,
-0.1889463216,
-0.7496168017,
0.1214349866,
0.208971858,
0.6160343289,
0.4248979688,
-0.1768075526,
-0.769082129,
-0.8311092257,
-0.1931678206,
0.0713215321,
-0.1154058799,
0.0343432464,
0.2275653929,
-0.2102035135,
1.092800498,
-0.5209607482,
-0.2671776116,
-0.5177506208,
0.3579953909,
-0.384139061,
0.5618559122,
0.401622355,
-0.7823410034,
-0.4710043371,
-0.0100378972,
-0.8236842155,
-0.0585837103,
-0.2927716076,
-0.2694004476,
0.3619315028,
0.454657644,
-0.4893135726,
0.567541182,
0.5126875639,
-0.3386590779,
0.1527613252,
-0.5567982793,
0.1931436956,
-1.3436926603,
-0.0722773895,
0.1431361884,
-0.3875255585,
-0.6785940528,
0.1268738955,
0.0439079255,
-0.6005893946,
-0.5273807049,
0.5418459773,
-0.6646570563,
0.0172357969,
-0.305334866,
0.1758321971,
0.2395606488,
0.5330601335,
0.3769614398,
0.6222348213,
0.5758092403,
-0.5179622173,
0.2867637575,
0.2811224461,
-0.852365911,
0.3601574302,
-0.3853042424,
-0.0458299965,
-0.2938646972,
0.1317098439,
-0.9004819393,
-0.5943693519,
0.2599378824,
-0.2357778996,
0.2375772297,
0.4242578447,
-0.752524972,
-0.3356516361,
-0.0627740845,
0.2798952162,
0.7886765599,
-0.6970657706,
0.9410322905,
0.4980585575,
-0.1690484285,
0.086555995,
-0.8497388363,
0.3292696476,
-0.1684136242,
-0.7774761319,
0.557572782,
-0.1128773093,
-0.1944798976,
-0.0041696718,
0.4743794203,
0.0911157057,
-0.0463537388,
0.338563174,
0.4669906795,
0.0424232446,
-0.1017028317,
0.1527654827,
0.0756770149,
-0.0188904405,
-0.1969883144,
0.4310378432,
0.1385092884,
-0.1218269542,
-0.4051705897,
0.5121591687,
0.414729476,
-0.5408374667,
0.5782971978,
0.4737991691,
-0.461543411,
-0.6772750616,
-0.5328961611,
0.2462269813,
-0.4672963619,
0.0646631196,
-0.1733737588,
-0.7056829333,
0.3437775075,
-0.0647254735,
0.1285077333,
0.1056123674,
0.4941260517,
-0.3476625979,
0.928121686,
0.8218894601,
0.6516290307,
0.6710895896,
-0.1860875636,
0.2148035765,
-0.6000311375,
-0.4101487994,
0.2330112755,
-0.2635241449,
-0.1999526173,
-0.6611693501,
0.3825485408,
-0.0223469827,
0.0184231978,
0.22803545,
-0.5814602971,
0.6090695858,
0.7319328189,
0.3272671103,
0.1513223797,
0.3540200591,
-0.5030841231,
-0.1648819894,
-0.7161188722,
-0.5175133348,
0.6857450604,
0.1669103354,
0.5847593546,
-0.2984361947,
0.7928774357,
0.0653141141,
0.4533765018,
-0.4761951268,
0.8479372263,
0.0394737795,
-0.2299250662,
-0.0184497368,
-0.0959697068,
-0.7469350696,
0.1561796069,
-0.6736295223,
-0.4333628416,
-0.0182559453,
0.3578039706,
-0.3442799449,
0.1266280115,
-0.9767439365,
0.9773798585,
-0.3272653222,
-0.3829607368,
-0.0045659128,
-0.7537567616,
0.3780708313,
0.0507268347,
0.2134732902,
0.2786327004,
0.1183504313,
0.4824949503,
-0.407361269,
0.9435425997,
0.0538981594,
-0.1357020438,
0.6171471477,
0.1740493476,
0.1218145862,
-0.2007131875,
0.2274134606,
-0.3532961607,
-0.3590043783,
-0.1621389389,
-0.4484695792,
0.7004387379,
-0.5350397229,
-0.3149990439,
-0.207559973,
-0.5637164116,
-0.260464251,
0.172662586,
0.3835531175,
0.6222699285,
-0.5586633086,
-0.2325167805,
0.663618803,
-0.47276631,
0.6642993689,
0.0908827931,
-0.6992411613,
-0.9002958536,
1.1444630623,
-0.0139174415,
0.4149434865,
0.4869712293,
0.007160773,
-0.2195093036,
-0.2249388248,
-0.6591683626,
0.1470931619,
-0.7038702369,
0.0046979324,
-0.5974577069,
-0.1546316445,
-0.422009021,
-0.3323077559,
0.0328598358,
-0.0781319961,
-0.6649219394,
-0.2429887503,
0.1139434427,
0.6982434392,
0.0682623461,
0.2647126019,
-0.7168866396,
0.7122918367,
0.6814298034,
0.40908885,
-0.0234163329,
-0.2205135077,
-0.175376147,
0.1664028466,
-0.3288070261,
-0.6672541499,
0.9423604608,
0.3950245678,
0.5768945813,
0.2072952539,
-0.1301908791,
0.7038062215,
-0.7841608524,
0.834544003,
0.2377397716,
-0.7829589844,
0.8402242064,
-0.2354615778,
0.5696352124,
0.4362613261,
0.0692938417,
-0.3302095532,
-0.591440618,
-0.6162814498,
-0.6746947169,
0.410207957,
0.2289244682,
0.1475318223,
-0.2648884058,
0.0610205196,
0.1827977151,
0.0575572215,
-0.9322186708,
0.0811531916,
-0.5781972408,
-0.4557638466,
-0.0997223929,
-0.2496154457,
-0.005894925,
-0.3213390112,
0.28148669,
-0.0790405869,
0.3941747546,
0.2042717487,
-0.2931057811,
-0.2221471369,
-0.0120615298,
0.7913339734,
0.4243008196,
0.0588672236,
0.4173078835,
0.0476854108,
-0.3966953456,
-0.2286980897,
-0.0397982597,
-0.3121644258,
-0.0111521427,
0.4033053517,
1.2533205748,
0.5672437549,
-1.1718370914,
0.3459041417,
-0.1597241759,
-0.5029969811,
-0.4928037822,
0.1805618107,
0.2467242181,
0.0555302761,
0.2822350562,
0.2562919259,
-0.2752613425,
-0.7482495308,
0.027688466,
0.2366041243,
-0.2502133548,
-0.4291906357,
0.9100177884,
0.4586952925,
-0.7131723166,
0.5201138854,
-0.1108015403,
-0.5713456869,
0.3093396127,
0.9135844111,
0.935326755,
0.0514678806,
0.4061037004,
0.1325640231,
0.1161693111,
0.032006897,
0.4911930561,
-0.1711162478,
-0.7789090276,
-0.5183393359,
-0.9856008291,
-0.1855450571,
-0.0853715539,
-0.2163478136,
0.2257093638,
-0.45206514,
0.1850480139,
-0.1574726701,
-0.3136893511,
-0.6351979375,
0.4591032863,
0.7039511204,
0.7612389326,
-1.0267698765,
0.6593775749,
0.9595578313,
-0.5008746386,
-0.8004565239,
0.0424018763,
-0.517067194,
-0.6298565865,
0.4898902178,
0.3256983161,
0.0673504397,
0.5070673227,
-0.7372543812,
-0.5285638571,
1.0276162624,
0.3262353837,
-0.068210043,
-0.130009234,
0.2170565873,
0.7682807446,
-0.7378175259,
-0.2489817888,
0.1724981666,
0.2660768032,
0.2885604501,
-0.6777998209,
-0.3011510968,
-0.393374294,
0.217560187,
0.0034595719,
-0.0894263238,
0.5735007524,
-0.2181112468,
-0.7527416945,
0.1576710939,
0.8958641887,
0.2827180028,
0.1634855866,
0.4355366528,
0.8114168048,
0.4308008254,
0.1742758006,
1.1722860336,
-0.1698275954,
-0.148770541,
1.0268194675,
-0.2100308388,
0.860678792,
0.4465054274,
0.1092485338,
0.6806198955,
0.3593663871,
0.0371841155,
0.6787742972,
0.1101182997,
-0.7117632031,
-0.4048748612,
-0.1715911329,
0.1001081839,
0.2265385687,
0.2365468293,
-0.5542199016,
-0.0517284162,
0.5970517993,
-0.568418026,
0.7006368041,
-0.2260475457,
1.0516611338,
0.0008606627,
-0.8977706432,
0.3685266972,
-0.196757406,
0.5519754291,
-0.3553895652,
-0.3257900178,
-0.0367336273,
-0.0760106221,
0.0117407115,
-0.8942040205,
0.0574930087,
0.0001164713,
-0.123947233,
-0.674636364,
0.853202641,
-0.7691860199,
-0.8883646131,
-0.1609723121,
0.362991035,
-0.072950922,
0.1373928785,
-0.3059580326,
0.1496235281,
0.0781457052,
-0.0074478784,
0.2698527277,
0.5735875964,
0.0058848052,
0.6979456544,
0.5311188698,
0.1434846669,
0.3821612597,
0.2087623924,
0.8036735058,
-0.5193783045,
-0.7119688392,
-0.6281681657,
0.8349452019,
-0.2849663496,
-0.2466250062,
0.5563119054,
0.56049335,
0.7107218504,
-0.474955529,
0.74307096,
-0.0443352871,
0.644960463,
-0.5096971393,
0.8597550988,
-0.3607121706,
-0.0190367009,
-0.3673364222,
-0.9987036586,
-0.5417476892,
0.6227518916,
-0.0209301896,
-0.3477106988,
0.7447410822,
0.7706429362,
-0.056554731,
0.0781643018,
0.3968854547,
-0.0724364892,
0.1294050813,
0.2813499868,
0.9646564722,
-0.3689742684,
0.3621123135,
-0.3901104331,
-0.091983974,
0.1313228011,
-1.0058922768,
-1.0179218054,
-0.5815373063,
-0.3709035218,
0.0317601189,
-0.2026820928,
0.832123518,
0.4717799723,
-0.3491660058,
-0.0554257818,
-0.5802960992,
-0.2846986055,
0.015008512,
-0.2250552624,
0.0283223037,
-0.2426086217,
-0.7719043493,
0.6368826628,
0.4700075388,
0.5340231657,
-0.4932916462,
0.0536247715,
-0.3835171759,
0.0725409463,
0.7908439636,
0.247186318,
-0.6882005334,
-0.4125294983,
-0.1494938582,
-0.1627634317,
0.0721481219,
0.6330207586,
-1.3964757919,
0.7870981693,
0.5708422661,
0.5890006423,
0.390474081,
0.2281094939,
0.9531152248,
-0.7596353889,
0.247053951,
0.257843256,
0.1741328984,
0.5537176728,
-0.0144512728,
0.1311917901,
0.3722648919,
-0.3281490207,
-0.7638184428,
0.1291507632,
-1.2807358503,
-0.1829188019,
0.8289337754,
0.0663193017,
-0.4179337919,
0.1963393092,
-0.576939106,
0.2435379773,
0.0338574424,
0.6224522591,
0.3316338658,
0.084770523,
-0.6274695396,
-0.3217025697,
0.468790859,
0.1402364224,
-1.0812381506,
-0.1060313508,
0.7778221965,
0.1120819673,
0.1115588695,
0.3906640708,
0.1865729988,
0.2254173309,
0.2380630523,
0.3847571611,
-0.1500422359,
-0.2475927025,
-0.0809084699,
0.391054213,
-0.2139966786,
-0.1756468415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16938v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16938v2 | Few-shot Fine-tuning vs. In-context Learning: A Fair Comparison and Evaluation | 2023-05-26T13:55:17 | 2023-05-30T08:34:49 | Marius Mosbach, Tiago Pimentel, Shauli Ravfogel, Dietrich Klakow, Yanai Elazar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few-shot fine-tuning and in-context learning are two alternative strategies
for task adaptation of pre-trained language models. Recently, in-context
learning has gained popularity over fine-tuning due to its simplicity and
improved out-of-domain generalization, and because extensive evidence shows
that fine-tuned models pick up on spurious correlations. Unfortunately,
previous comparisons of the two approaches were done using models of different
sizes. This raises the question of whether the observed weaker out-of-domain
generalization of fine-tuned models is an inherent property of fine-tuning or a
limitation of the experimental setup. In this paper, we compare the
generalization of few-shot fine-tuning and in-context learning to challenge
datasets, while controlling for the models used, the number of examples, and
the number of parameters, ranging from 125M to 30B. Our results show that
fine-tuned language models can in fact generalize well out-of-domain. We find
that both approaches generalize similarly; they exhibit large variation and
depend on properties such as model size and the number of examples,
highlighting that robust task adaptation remains a challenge. | [
-0.3850255013,
-0.9234676361,
0.4266545475,
-0.1617313623,
-0.148656413,
-0.3353421688,
-0.7054514885,
-0.4715590179,
-0.6706966162,
0.305516988,
-0.5268514156,
-0.1648168415,
-0.5675005317,
0.1764059365,
-0.0742359534,
1.1381648779,
0.0884467885,
0.1531846076,
-0.3440483809,
-0.2346660644,
-0.6175308824,
-0.26358217,
-0.6451562047,
-0.4116598368,
0.2222063243,
0.6185567379,
0.4834232628,
0.3421404958,
0.677770555,
0.2382037938,
0.0996925756,
0.331364274,
-0.7806616426,
-0.2091039866,
-0.3010696173,
-0.4763189256,
-0.1341472268,
0.0313678309,
0.5035167933,
0.9060794711,
0.331101656,
0.2937043607,
0.4748060703,
0.6484663486,
-0.9837014079,
0.1108258143,
-0.9150987864,
-0.270052582,
-0.3028269708,
-0.1368672848,
-0.3902769983,
0.1188625693,
0.2322035134,
-0.7253572941,
0.2792723775,
0.0410954207,
0.7529193759,
0.4523557723,
-0.3730185032,
-0.200332433,
-0.8325831294,
1.0753389597,
-0.7471267581,
0.3442990184,
0.582305789,
0.4525410831,
-0.3455291986,
-0.3101880848,
-0.2586436272,
-0.2327248752,
0.04738288,
-0.0222720876,
-0.3128668666,
-0.0642062053,
0.3472483456,
0.0065206047,
-0.4755910933,
0.4252260923,
-0.0589858517,
0.0756775439,
0.3700339794,
0.0704549998,
-0.0754846334,
-0.0149943996,
-0.186697796,
-0.0270983484,
-0.8682076931,
0.227178216,
0.1515138149,
0.8938136101,
-0.3477104902,
0.2416231334,
-0.4982258677,
0.9312529564,
0.421938926,
-0.3462991118,
-0.1153552607,
-0.4530546069,
-0.426959604,
-0.415548712,
0.6077810526,
0.2849650681,
0.3861367404,
-0.3603117466,
-0.1061274633,
-0.1494714171,
0.0133599434,
-0.6977643371,
-0.0040152739,
-0.0462725274,
-0.5168090463,
0.0838484094,
-0.0556163006,
-0.3606039286,
-0.0998113602,
-0.2926936746,
0.6763228774,
-0.3282920718,
0.1823125184,
0.1007700786,
-0.0435280837,
0.2809315622,
0.4384704232,
-1.0400407314,
0.5408261418,
0.7772741914,
0.8405608535,
-0.4435251057,
-0.3623979688,
-0.7209658623,
-0.1300893724,
-0.4175717235,
0.7369292378,
-0.7297576666,
-0.2733873427,
-0.123187989,
-0.0186710171,
-0.1844341606,
-0.8511738181,
0.3119841814,
-0.4127153158,
-0.0107358955,
-0.3005253971,
-0.6293068528,
-0.0704734847,
-0.0433327742,
-0.2915792465,
0.8770056367,
0.3887084723,
-0.5825414062,
0.9522970319,
-0.5024388433,
-0.4089626372,
-0.0075851753,
-0.1189738214,
-0.46542117,
0.4058071077,
0.0801477209,
0.7029277682,
-0.3360999525,
-0.1160879284,
-0.6628394723,
-0.6111029387,
0.2221046537,
-0.2622211874,
0.5120349526,
0.2807808816,
-0.2216669172,
-0.1718156189,
-0.7440307736,
0.0485488549,
-0.0357582495,
-0.481795311,
-0.4430245757,
0.0134059349,
-0.0617848374,
0.2160080075,
-0.0049156332,
-0.4180209041,
0.0430241749,
-0.724732101,
0.4065667689,
0.3729692698,
0.0399661176,
0.9602406025,
-0.4605993629,
0.2565138936,
0.1890500039,
-0.0349631086,
-0.1031735316,
-0.238127768,
-0.5538591743,
-0.1485923678,
0.4453098774,
0.3743065298,
-0.5312163234,
0.1915873587,
-0.2934066951,
-0.289575398,
-0.3283720613,
0.5449727774,
0.5329812169,
0.622361064,
0.3973923028,
-0.4340607524,
-0.3053143322,
-0.665040493,
-0.5590147376,
0.1464167684,
-0.109479256,
0.6195673347,
0.7724446654,
0.0972841084,
1.053106904,
-0.1664191186,
-0.4884730577,
-0.3550358117,
-0.0912632421,
0.0147915492,
0.7035964131,
0.8154649138,
-0.4095089436,
-0.8221179843,
0.3633283973,
-0.4451262653,
0.2767527401,
-0.113206774,
0.130820483,
0.2247154266,
0.4090790153,
-0.2456271797,
0.4274329245,
0.4261239171,
0.1077700704,
0.1538468301,
-0.1917525232,
0.050892815,
-0.7777048945,
-0.0704712346,
0.0951595828,
-0.4473519623,
-0.7896404266,
0.136877045,
0.1794877797,
-0.0138016874,
-0.701838553,
0.6179309487,
-0.2568764389,
-0.0498975851,
-0.5639085174,
-0.0240601674,
-0.1909160316,
0.564874053,
-0.0355852209,
0.8502534032,
0.7658698559,
-0.8443907499,
-0.0761336237,
0.1929434538,
-0.6212004423,
0.3758559823,
-0.5010066628,
0.3337911665,
-0.0212977473,
0.2173945308,
-0.8026880026,
-0.4128739238,
0.0641095042,
-0.2026814669,
0.4136928916,
-0.4476779699,
-0.3536295295,
0.0023102469,
-0.2593137622,
0.3829376996,
0.4951947331,
-0.5749295354,
0.0393528305,
0.079837434,
0.1399063021,
-0.4083356261,
-0.7194553018,
-0.3420137465,
-0.5408995748,
-0.2657123506,
0.4464755356,
-0.1069782823,
-0.1730570793,
-0.348159641,
-0.2862918079,
-0.2487624139,
0.3465572894,
0.1489468366,
-0.263553381,
-0.3825614452,
0.1253019422,
0.1160446852,
0.005577907,
-0.4007917941,
-0.2065411508,
0.1656711549,
-0.2605425715,
-0.2417719364,
-0.3848980963,
0.3539651036,
0.2577085197,
0.0291326158,
0.6390792727,
0.2886855006,
-0.4558360577,
-0.3704087138,
-0.3508235216,
-0.4963594079,
-0.4643607438,
0.3519656062,
-0.583029449,
-1.0478671789,
0.4287447035,
-0.4196839333,
-0.1111203432,
0.2982366383,
0.5556188822,
-0.2742186785,
0.9954072237,
1.0643606186,
-0.1214822084,
0.6053218246,
-0.2273433954,
0.0747354925,
-0.6940891147,
0.366882205,
-0.7039991021,
-0.3686297536,
-0.7455886602,
0.0178044662,
0.3146401346,
0.2880343795,
-0.1683124006,
0.4212231934,
-0.1076179296,
0.7355310917,
0.5280437469,
0.3389013708,
0.1641088724,
-0.0548264198,
0.1256842911,
-0.0264268722,
-1.0977876186,
-0.4418171942,
1.3038609028,
0.1580075622,
0.7260048985,
0.1215632632,
0.5924124718,
-0.1675204933,
-0.0950253531,
-0.9266466498,
0.1013018265,
-0.5980830193,
-0.7069936395,
-0.5156220198,
-0.1960485876,
-1.0486998558,
0.2929282486,
-0.3664911687,
-0.7750013471,
0.4196553826,
0.4178437889,
-0.8230996132,
0.1047627628,
-0.9501388669,
1.0283048153,
0.0385973603,
-0.5343900919,
-0.176531598,
-0.7350233197,
0.1309717894,
-0.3326736987,
0.2291394025,
0.0002563568,
0.1896052808,
0.4836461842,
-0.2474299222,
1.228433609,
-0.0276973806,
0.1903272569,
0.2114480138,
0.0001636406,
0.496525377,
0.048660934,
0.0037073849,
-0.0891012624,
0.1222794279,
-0.5866519213,
-0.5636718273,
0.7134167552,
-0.7533278465,
-0.517428875,
-0.0058025215,
-0.5014519095,
-0.5960574746,
0.2715100944,
0.6310415268,
0.5870264173,
-0.3223116398,
0.4279552102,
0.516259253,
0.0007234688,
0.6837992072,
0.4762639999,
0.3301262558,
0.282464087,
0.7879197598,
0.1264719367,
0.4965357482,
0.5274531245,
0.2977919281,
0.0273254141,
-0.8083266616,
-0.2489525825,
0.0953504145,
-0.689955771,
-0.3269931972,
-0.2162258923,
0.2618298829,
-0.4407447875,
-0.258271277,
-0.4919208586,
-0.1375269741,
-0.5641961694,
0.3208845258,
0.2869185805,
0.5073561668,
0.1363281459,
0.659840405,
-0.4197899699,
0.2069425732,
0.4005460739,
0.4814202487,
-0.2652923763,
-0.9201699495,
-0.5887005329,
0.0612338744,
-0.4592931569,
-0.6028212905,
0.0781946555,
0.7255948186,
0.3687708378,
0.5468601584,
-0.061508771,
0.9764012694,
-0.6152890325,
0.6108462811,
-0.142798841,
-0.9185621738,
0.5067331195,
-0.3474468589,
0.6297038794,
0.9012918472,
0.3141668141,
-0.0997010469,
-0.2841422856,
-0.4957109094,
-0.2561009526,
0.8640182018,
-0.0905314013,
0.2591343522,
0.0630888566,
0.477290839,
0.5957688689,
0.0666780993,
-0.5050225258,
-0.0033581464,
-0.1050407961,
0.1109876335,
-0.3116945624,
0.0174892992,
-0.1397553384,
-0.3720765114,
0.3367493451,
-0.5565620661,
0.0050081857,
-0.2422730774,
-0.5271779299,
-0.3474340141,
0.4461137056,
0.7739793658,
0.6970416307,
-0.2375940233,
0.0614382848,
0.7409524322,
-0.1121215969,
-0.1206981614,
-0.3486625552,
-0.0124070123,
-0.2156606317,
0.5016057491,
1.1862461567,
0.5625655651,
-0.4038815796,
0.6608569622,
0.3394497335,
-0.2903740704,
0.2383357286,
0.2699494362,
-0.2656168938,
0.2727597952,
0.0184227452,
0.4011538625,
0.1407765001,
-0.5592861772,
-0.0194592513,
0.746243,
-0.2917685211,
-0.380312264,
0.4984208047,
0.0859428793,
-0.0809080377,
0.156006664,
-0.2116042525,
0.1271077096,
0.5139700174,
0.7527410984,
0.7939699292,
0.2596736848,
-0.0375146046,
0.19677791,
0.1155713573,
-0.3083811402,
-0.0525937341,
-0.2943956852,
-0.8329364657,
-0.4323983192,
-0.3134718239,
-0.392403543,
0.3403288722,
-0.5596618056,
0.3479433358,
-0.4940784276,
-0.3042972386,
-0.0733930692,
0.100707747,
-1.0204775333,
0.1414793432,
-0.1741688102,
0.7676363587,
-0.8691322803,
1.0805236101,
0.8678819537,
-0.1500100195,
-0.4072381258,
0.1600986123,
-0.0481336564,
-0.4608130157,
0.5987538099,
-0.0308519956,
-0.2520618737,
0.0671931207,
-0.7089304924,
-0.9062292576,
0.865565896,
0.559127152,
-0.5361194611,
0.1527441591,
-0.0756653771,
0.5719400048,
-0.5006761551,
0.0580649152,
0.791336,
0.2037461251,
-0.1873173565,
-1.2867114544,
-0.2821404338,
0.323390305,
0.1224424392,
-0.0671653599,
-0.6683152318,
0.7655735612,
-0.1974384636,
-0.3250645697,
-0.009923405,
0.5640093684,
-0.0807663724,
0.243951425,
0.4344445765,
0.1544264406,
0.4158655107,
0.0006010861,
1.0658940077,
-0.0635280013,
0.5268956423,
1.3027585745,
-0.1568246633,
0.9333208799,
0.5504562259,
-0.2779031992,
0.0039006069,
0.6538373232,
0.2582350671,
0.8686771989,
-0.0349348113,
0.0405065306,
-0.4417847395,
0.1949607432,
-0.1347139925,
0.6768606305,
0.3005061746,
0.1798743606,
-0.4717488885,
0.296191752,
-0.1113636866,
0.1465055794,
-0.3570784926,
0.9831048846,
0.1993309259,
-0.5624349117,
0.8215035796,
0.0367671326,
0.8588523269,
-0.4171664119,
0.3356252313,
-0.1747775972,
0.2484676391,
-0.1232152656,
-0.2843064368,
0.2183205932,
0.0585060567,
-0.2319796085,
-0.1291703582,
0.7717911005,
-0.2696034014,
-0.0481621735,
0.0121553242,
0.5529852509,
0.0166902114,
-0.1019716114,
-0.6771095991,
-0.1436049938,
-0.2788929045,
-0.1288830638,
0.7022636533,
0.2502703667,
-0.2238611281,
0.6311811805,
0.3661239445,
0.0024228208,
0.0731113404,
-0.1132437512,
0.6654691696,
-0.2839066982,
-0.354262203,
-0.8548215032,
0.1618352979,
0.4098629057,
-0.6491839886,
0.7293730974,
0.382602483,
1.2939991951,
-0.411233604,
0.7301305532,
0.2911430299,
0.4907743633,
-0.6279271841,
0.3207070827,
-0.8631736636,
0.0306711923,
-0.3787581623,
-0.6393456459,
-0.505918026,
0.685326159,
-0.5032176971,
0.2519077063,
0.7554340363,
0.7390282154,
-0.4978369772,
-0.337479651,
0.5568948388,
-0.0694452003,
-0.0683892742,
0.6754031777,
0.6045282483,
-0.3869366944,
0.2509385347,
-0.2601854801,
-0.2235696018,
-0.4418919086,
-0.8661173582,
-1.1120091677,
-0.5996795297,
-0.3312308788,
0.2269241512,
0.0770264417,
0.9031191468,
1.0521930456,
-1.1777852774,
-0.3378503919,
-0.1408938318,
0.0285221264,
-0.5086849928,
-0.0924424902,
0.0437544957,
-0.6922421455,
-0.8846573234,
0.6647359133,
0.2813549638,
0.1505465657,
0.1855016202,
-0.00534049,
0.1215388775,
0.0310742743,
0.688388288,
0.516232729,
-0.7849672437,
-0.53061831,
-0.079408139,
-0.1023332104,
0.0935930163,
0.7720400095,
-0.7699387074,
0.3716757596,
0.5444462299,
0.7144263387,
0.5420210361,
-0.1037353873,
0.3920759261,
-1.0231313705,
0.3832450807,
-0.1562446207,
0.131586656,
0.0931380466,
-0.1802488863,
0.251072526,
-0.0180944391,
-0.5323842168,
-0.8662320375,
0.3679319918,
-0.871095717,
-0.5343883634,
1.043371439,
-0.008323241,
0.0479288436,
-0.1859418005,
-0.0589640997,
0.2240443379,
-0.2731134593,
0.6609170437,
0.6629549265,
-0.412350744,
-0.0250153337,
-0.6951435208,
0.8961899281,
0.6400815845,
-0.7104594111,
0.0344618037,
0.1618127972,
0.378190428,
-0.2732726932,
0.4617604613,
0.2563076615,
0.4124477804,
-0.327881515,
-0.4740143716,
0.1138267294,
-0.4397012293,
-0.7430256009,
0.1389636248,
0.3295723796,
-0.222098276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16937v1 | Finspector: A Human-Centered Visual Inspection Tool for Exploring and Comparing Biases among Foundation Models | 2023-05-26T13:53:15 | 2023-05-26T13:53:15 | Bum Chul Kwon, Nandana Mihindukulasooriya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Pre-trained transformer-based language models are becoming increasingly
popular due to their exceptional performance on various benchmarks. However,
concerns persist regarding the presence of hidden biases within these models,
which can lead to discriminatory outcomes and reinforce harmful stereotypes. To
address this issue, we propose Finspector, a human-centered visual inspection
tool designed to detect biases in different categories through log-likelihood
scores generated by language models. The goal of the tool is to enable
researchers to easily identify potential biases using visual analytics,
ultimately contributing to a fairer and more just deployment of these models in
both academic and industrial settings. Finspector is available at
https://github.com/IBM/finspector. | [
-0.7562893033,
-0.4287831187,
0.2879180014,
0.1149960682,
-0.1602698416,
0.21326226,
-0.0313636996,
-0.4936217368,
0.0407040678,
0.7813747525,
-0.6089850664,
-0.4870556295,
-0.5386194587,
-0.1385208666,
-0.663707912,
0.9457925558,
-0.0501300618,
0.3119759858,
-0.4830096364,
0.1193105653,
-0.4268889725,
-0.0358087756,
-0.4428060353,
-0.4841150641,
-0.0429055318,
0.4448903501,
0.6085612178,
0.3708710074,
0.5531230569,
0.3392232358,
0.1905349195,
-0.1595799029,
-0.6032592654,
0.1085595712,
-0.4604377449,
-0.4481102228,
-0.3514093459,
0.3357014656,
0.4519805908,
0.8613764644,
0.2893962264,
0.5659364462,
0.1054274812,
0.7772365212,
-0.7701584697,
0.3256281018,
-0.3270822763,
0.2293344736,
-0.3613626957,
-0.0392615795,
-0.4025524259,
-0.5805159211,
0.2146418989,
-0.3434165418,
0.7355490327,
0.1051419824,
0.8846043944,
0.341172874,
-0.530356586,
0.1999032944,
-0.5275232792,
0.9759289622,
-0.3235515058,
0.9907810092,
0.1456248909,
0.6357468367,
0.0401780717,
-0.8152248263,
-0.511014998,
0.0991205499,
-0.4999147058,
-0.1706882864,
-0.3526066244,
0.2202921808,
0.1284909248,
0.283770889,
-0.7121194005,
-0.0420238376,
-0.5090051889,
-0.5972598195,
0.7004952431,
-0.07188797,
0.426443398,
-0.4091489911,
-0.2958488762,
-0.4700431228,
-0.6070198417,
0.3395955861,
0.4579648972,
0.0897586197,
0.0035305943,
0.4377698302,
-0.3388746083,
1.0065358877,
0.0484002605,
-0.0493327454,
0.2668143511,
-0.1501298845,
-0.4555475414,
0.0925707147,
0.6750343442,
0.5791939497,
0.4721021056,
0.0643355697,
-0.4708424211,
0.2782193124,
0.4689211547,
-0.7401311398,
-0.4768885672,
-0.0532488339,
-0.7331656218,
-0.7523699999,
0.3180546761,
-1.1405053139,
-0.5947825313,
-0.1676365435,
0.0062930151,
0.0535870083,
-0.4312361479,
0.1037700176,
-0.4548285306,
0.2428786755,
0.1965546161,
-0.7467742562,
0.4192556739,
0.7815287709,
0.3929964006,
-0.1652017832,
-0.2333894521,
-0.7262017131,
-0.3613040149,
-0.2567632496,
0.9176409245,
-0.5672703981,
-0.611212492,
-0.059575174,
-0.027067285,
0.0870108902,
-0.5643098354,
0.7676619291,
-0.2736442089,
0.3205350041,
-0.3321943283,
-0.3991210759,
-0.0414937437,
0.1672307551,
-0.837389648,
1.2146940231,
0.5465085506,
-0.9370613098,
0.7726697326,
-0.731992662,
-0.2450394183,
0.2315918952,
-0.9540930986,
-0.537504375,
-0.0956691802,
0.2078947723,
0.6663035154,
-0.4947349131,
0.6669005752,
-0.23462376,
-0.5172868371,
0.1308246255,
-0.3051616848,
0.9799074531,
-0.0314042345,
-0.8268446922,
0.4072262943,
-0.6682661176,
-0.1514565498,
-0.0412020758,
-0.1482416838,
-0.3563971817,
-0.1273825765,
0.5203370452,
0.0610003397,
-0.1161135659,
-0.7485477328,
0.0516116507,
-0.1983440667,
-0.0467047207,
0.9621235728,
-0.2217764109,
0.3929488957,
-0.0287232157,
0.797755301,
-0.2127261758,
0.4620687962,
0.0984492376,
-0.5695418119,
-0.8876125813,
-0.3429805338,
-0.056555815,
0.123553887,
-0.3553625941,
0.3155582845,
-0.3477248251,
-0.5760358572,
-0.6037407517,
0.1684745699,
0.5502591729,
0.9447702169,
0.169934541,
-0.4821668863,
-0.6079045534,
-1.4628112316,
-0.5737244487,
-0.2978191376,
-0.0436672531,
0.3184494972,
0.4424421191,
-0.3589513898,
1.4089686871,
-0.6687945127,
-0.1123935878,
-0.1193619892,
0.2238827795,
0.1941115111,
0.4175068438,
1.0517054796,
-1.1646178961,
-0.398235023,
0.0309680328,
-0.7954331636,
-0.3419785202,
0.1927014589,
-0.2399738431,
-0.2389053851,
0.5862979293,
-0.4154838026,
0.6229608655,
0.3178394735,
-0.872789979,
0.8821188211,
0.5695278049,
0.3134606779,
-0.3868274689,
0.5065740943,
0.2358055562,
-0.4056496322,
-0.6495752335,
-0.030265471,
0.2261396497,
-0.0820116401,
-0.3666610122,
0.6429792047,
-0.2268728912,
-0.3783121407,
0.1312913001,
-0.1029949188,
0.463665694,
0.0788968727,
0.043363668,
0.9249933362,
0.291682452,
-0.2542284429,
0.3416488171,
0.2484685034,
-0.6741089225,
0.7729628086,
-0.6251662374,
-0.0759936795,
-0.2130009681,
0.0548679493,
-0.9514511824,
-0.2767283916,
0.1659299582,
-0.2839686573,
0.2890028358,
-0.2840620875,
0.1209552139,
-0.5431694984,
-0.677149415,
0.2865132093,
0.343628943,
-0.8604571223,
0.7145441771,
0.4748612344,
-0.1714022607,
-1.0768381357,
-0.5380505323,
-0.2487322241,
-0.1171071455,
-0.7988008261,
0.1483484209,
-0.1168965772,
-0.6025300622,
-0.0232054628,
-0.2987888753,
-0.2159630805,
0.1733258814,
0.4555700719,
0.5844302177,
-0.3696755171,
-0.157082215,
0.2443201542,
0.0580693074,
0.214825362,
-0.0888144746,
0.358923465,
-0.5171165466,
-0.4154216051,
-0.1930657923,
-0.0429033227,
1.0173910856,
-0.3797732294,
0.0464637019,
0.6947413087,
-0.3766747117,
-0.1828426868,
-1.0867921114,
-0.2986297607,
-0.5530606508,
0.5008876324,
-0.2873051465,
-0.7969638705,
0.1768586636,
-0.0657271221,
-0.1679070741,
0.2533498406,
0.294136405,
0.0350356363,
0.8303638697,
0.9816288352,
-0.2841114104,
0.3691076934,
-0.3104637265,
0.3003858328,
-0.6217873693,
-0.517939806,
-0.5878479481,
-0.0962510705,
-0.0858681351,
-0.1665446907,
0.3094621897,
0.0667213723,
-0.1741911769,
0.0654996186,
-0.7864776254,
0.7661039829,
0.3815602064,
-0.19548361,
0.2053144127,
-0.2336909473,
-0.1459897608,
-0.2499608994,
-0.3971447051,
-0.729018569,
0.8939766884,
0.5011764169,
0.5790045857,
-0.1949511468,
0.5721570253,
0.5588161945,
0.8043010235,
-0.7248932123,
0.427714467,
-0.0699674115,
-0.814127624,
-0.4029698074,
-0.2040260285,
-0.5490454435,
0.4488880038,
-0.2296711653,
-0.683378756,
0.7209867239,
0.372071743,
-0.0043211016,
0.3872720897,
-0.6657610536,
1.4966709614,
-0.4310713112,
-0.3580446243,
0.0427387655,
-0.3481775522,
0.6749463677,
-0.1742037833,
0.3377526104,
-0.1326752007,
0.4692814648,
0.8194303513,
-0.4431975186,
0.9604341984,
-0.4394548237,
0.0662642941,
-0.0718656406,
0.2769064605,
0.2573233843,
-0.0404336788,
-0.0448068567,
0.0028870511,
-0.103366822,
-0.3522047997,
-0.5035354495,
0.5550626516,
-0.7065246105,
-0.3930125237,
-0.1996384114,
-0.1455333978,
-0.3560125828,
0.5271967053,
0.2179397196,
0.2021994144,
-0.7985132933,
0.0452938899,
0.5618730783,
-0.2709096074,
0.0478634648,
0.3573827446,
-0.3464926183,
0.31659922,
0.6564635634,
-0.4469944537,
-0.1139666438,
0.1944219172,
0.2032838315,
-0.0397102535,
-0.3524194658,
-0.4238215983,
0.1237761974,
-0.7633951902,
-0.2730539739,
-0.3775971234,
0.1092860103,
-0.3701645732,
-0.4118190706,
-0.6468840241,
-0.3093044758,
0.0737926438,
-0.4547427297,
0.0835323632,
1.0358331203,
0.1711173803,
0.1636193991,
-0.2292196751,
0.0930228233,
0.6470176578,
0.6353031397,
-0.1089049205,
-0.1001906693,
-0.033177238,
-0.2930670381,
-0.0499319322,
-0.6215051413,
0.352832377,
-0.1181251109,
0.7297199965,
0.8889253139,
-0.1520062536,
0.2834109366,
-0.2043974549,
0.6765415668,
0.3708762228,
-1.1332803965,
0.7246369123,
-0.2643894851,
-0.1026169658,
0.816926837,
0.5488273501,
-0.5328143239,
-0.3310216069,
-0.3850548267,
-0.429028064,
0.6416675448,
-0.1932802647,
-0.371552974,
0.1971412152,
0.1428499371,
0.4200834334,
0.334307164,
-0.513518095,
-0.1722252667,
-0.7198400497,
-0.1267638505,
-0.0733701885,
-0.282654047,
-0.0721540973,
-0.2043388337,
0.6146315932,
-0.2396576256,
-0.1402077824,
0.0651709139,
-0.3635721505,
-0.3110005558,
0.317776382,
0.3513193429,
0.7281628251,
-0.5528126955,
0.3989256918,
-0.1113207042,
-0.8196775317,
0.0308280829,
0.0247386135,
-0.2337273061,
0.231969893,
0.5995255113,
0.7571086287,
0.4790233672,
-0.9546232224,
1.0488108397,
-0.3050791323,
0.0971393362,
-0.1635890603,
0.0467504449,
-0.1968232542,
0.2287153453,
0.4615003765,
0.4183615148,
0.5419855714,
-0.3875302672,
0.3821659982,
0.299954772,
-0.6833658218,
-0.2672905624,
0.6708564162,
0.4989157319,
-0.1915297061,
0.742077589,
0.0658342317,
-0.7794857025,
0.519361496,
-0.0077819978,
0.7028048038,
-0.4504205287,
0.5519874096,
0.0755956024,
0.6174075603,
-0.1346053183,
0.0667175651,
-0.0638728589,
-1.0569903851,
-0.1166687906,
-0.5980821848,
-0.258535713,
0.1209449321,
-1.0244514942,
0.4049107134,
-0.494605571,
-0.2861444652,
0.3654617965,
-0.2570510507,
-1.1673855782,
0.3403106034,
0.0845178068,
0.9758144617,
-1.4284256697,
0.6336808801,
0.7254692912,
-0.4570897818,
-0.3601212204,
-0.2763023078,
0.3150692284,
-0.7489667535,
1.122059226,
0.171990335,
-0.5229533315,
-0.3820082545,
-0.4909667075,
-0.4550970793,
1.0764297247,
0.6395439506,
-0.5661609769,
0.0535429008,
0.1007870883,
0.2638970613,
-0.2309326231,
0.3209613264,
0.9175946712,
0.6910592318,
-0.7558954954,
-1.0574201345,
0.0955560282,
-0.5318066478,
-0.2413107008,
0.2157403529,
-0.389446944,
0.8427917957,
0.1352277547,
-0.0734436512,
-0.4931732416,
0.2792406678,
0.1801522523,
0.3283897936,
0.7895233035,
0.0408245102,
0.95975703,
-0.1465098113,
1.1922823191,
-0.2012289464,
0.4245115519,
0.8926507831,
-0.1378834397,
0.5276869535,
0.6578992605,
-0.1375119686,
0.630151093,
0.2736378312,
-0.2063996643,
0.3651944995,
0.1312466711,
-0.132658869,
-0.386403352,
-0.2509053051,
-0.3032199442,
0.6170653701,
0.2731122971,
-0.4303354323,
-0.0165047143,
-0.0017037754,
-0.0887762904,
0.2615787089,
-0.1672324389,
0.0473022833,
-0.1446383297,
-0.5202402472,
0.3721098602,
0.1515280902,
1.0192778111,
-0.4930329919,
-0.063370876,
-0.2920764089,
0.1724057496,
-0.4873800874,
-0.7067662477,
0.1494230181,
0.0412262715,
-0.2141581923,
-0.3792504072,
1.1497737169,
-0.0936927125,
-0.428742528,
0.5416994095,
0.6665788889,
0.0133480411,
-0.0333999656,
-0.6646173596,
0.5276151299,
0.0926847681,
-0.3782421052,
0.0102820564,
-0.1547676921,
-0.1995987445,
0.7436743975,
0.4510293603,
-0.0625816062,
-0.0385952555,
0.3927567303,
0.8871920109,
-0.4414809346,
-0.4098852873,
-0.6293556094,
0.4635413587,
-0.4436026216,
-0.3401570916,
0.6747829914,
0.899063468,
1.1195653677,
-0.4945393503,
0.9036727548,
0.3074948192,
0.4212189019,
-0.115987733,
1.0317337513,
-0.2813813388,
0.1166301444,
-0.5705530047,
-0.7774839997,
-0.2373864949,
1.0370948315,
-0.2463146001,
0.0097240601,
0.4200234115,
0.8072206378,
-0.544685185,
0.2265673876,
0.1297014654,
0.2400630862,
0.3119132817,
0.046197556,
0.8305780888,
-0.1420933157,
0.3426793516,
-0.296510607,
-0.6122970581,
-0.2856524885,
-0.7582758665,
-1.4211742878,
-0.4998142123,
-0.3582937121,
-0.0237965714,
0.1534008831,
0.6305190325,
0.945792377,
-0.9011740685,
-0.6751725078,
0.0166482013,
0.2439227849,
-0.026055634,
-0.2977025807,
0.282643944,
0.086074017,
-0.4980981946,
0.5776072741,
0.2048731297,
-0.1270972639,
-0.7937184572,
0.0270318482,
0.1695112437,
-0.1219657958,
0.569222331,
0.2664363086,
-0.493383348,
-0.3918426633,
-0.0466805883,
0.126400575,
-0.2130309939,
1.1569129229,
-0.9211703539,
0.5699472427,
0.5765958428,
0.5241156816,
0.8219510913,
-0.2824241221,
0.8136695027,
-0.9369786978,
0.0601626337,
0.1110297218,
0.61975348,
0.6086618304,
-0.4712761641,
0.7445542812,
0.2026971281,
-0.1467636973,
-1.1551710367,
0.2957030535,
-0.6869541407,
-0.3570982814,
0.4555467665,
0.2331776768,
-0.1627092808,
-0.2771800458,
-0.2053443044,
0.0733670294,
-0.2796894014,
0.7663078308,
0.5209833384,
-0.2429093719,
0.0405755304,
-0.5399085283,
0.7709841132,
0.3515999317,
-0.7628712654,
0.0457644202,
0.3825012147,
0.6464183927,
0.2547483742,
0.7596728206,
-0.1826628596,
0.4093213379,
-0.1092171445,
0.5357895494,
-0.1443689167,
-0.2580126822,
-0.2583656013,
-0.0414468758,
0.0756683126,
0.1890750527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16935v1 | Gender Lost In Translation: How Bridging The Gap Between Languages Affects Gender Bias in Zero-Shot Multilingual Translation | 2023-05-26T13:51:50 | 2023-05-26T13:51:50 | Lena Cabrera, Jan Niehues | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural machine translation (NMT) models often suffer from gender biases that
harm users and society at large. In this work, we explore how bridging the gap
between languages for which parallel data is not available affects gender bias
in multilingual NMT, specifically for zero-shot directions. We evaluate
translation between grammatical gender languages which requires preserving the
inherent gender information from the source in the target language. We study
the effect of encouraging language-agnostic hidden representations on models'
ability to preserve gender and compare pivot-based and zero-shot translation
regarding the influence of the bridge language (participating in all language
pairs during training) on gender preservation. We find that language-agnostic
representations mitigate zero-shot models' masculine bias, and with increased
levels of gender inflection in the bridge language, pivoting surpasses
zero-shot translation regarding fairer gender preservation for speaker-related
gender agreement. | [
-0.1964162141,
-0.47990188,
0.436842978,
0.2187400013,
0.0945705026,
0.2224636674,
-0.0264030248,
-0.287235707,
-0.0102796089,
0.3131925464,
-0.6719247103,
-0.1166526303,
-0.6854103804,
0.175091207,
-0.374573499,
0.8474969268,
-0.1091452911,
0.5635148287,
-0.194458738,
-0.2406354398,
-0.9191159606,
-0.6469743848,
-0.2842118442,
-0.6358602643,
0.3224184215,
0.2556403577,
0.7053800225,
0.6038497686,
0.2511945665,
0.2106616944,
-0.2069839835,
-0.2490033805,
-0.3360316455,
0.4278999865,
-0.433100611,
-0.6594982147,
-0.37880072,
-0.0018436064,
0.8828725219,
0.9908272624,
-0.1875319034,
0.1508543491,
-0.1352135092,
0.8128439784,
-0.5483922362,
0.0843587294,
-0.6831043363,
0.3207681179,
-0.3730044663,
-0.036548458,
-0.2005297393,
0.0201381352,
0.1386089325,
-0.0796724781,
0.5358715653,
0.0410632007,
0.7115418315,
0.1044862941,
-0.5182924271,
-0.0011140204,
-0.7620196342,
0.7842576504,
-0.6098430753,
0.4311285615,
0.3804513514,
0.2894165218,
-0.1443472207,
0.2612886429,
-0.4953566492,
-0.1453734636,
0.0363341756,
0.1446071565,
-0.2994196415,
-0.05931684,
0.1988060772,
0.2096823007,
-0.5719607472,
-0.1008389518,
-0.4986665845,
-0.0905442238,
0.4676442146,
-0.0813437626,
0.5113824606,
-0.1233720183,
-0.1693089306,
-0.1322012246,
-0.8777005672,
-0.2974317968,
0.8720220923,
0.5362452865,
-0.0422881767,
0.7145486474,
0.0589379221,
0.4682776332,
0.0400816016,
0.3924984932,
0.4176493287,
-0.1977374852,
-0.0119072506,
0.3277848363,
0.6591267586,
0.3648919761,
0.4118757546,
-0.3306619823,
0.0742033869,
0.078547217,
0.1313385367,
-0.4815753698,
0.3516515493,
-0.2621479332,
-0.3414708674,
0.0884330273,
0.0673987195,
-0.4058146477,
-0.3736107945,
-0.0497811325,
0.2018245757,
-0.242488876,
-0.5270886421,
0.4255967736,
-0.4731518626,
0.291883558,
0.205861792,
-1.0985114574,
0.1240717098,
0.4368372858,
0.8048684597,
0.2783167362,
-0.4184644222,
-0.2825624943,
0.3752796352,
-0.3929701149,
0.2865683138,
-0.4291890562,
-0.3408249319,
-0.1479794681,
0.1176941544,
-0.4078196585,
-0.3232964277,
0.2269695997,
-0.130618304,
0.509290576,
-0.5489522219,
-0.3209018111,
-0.2384041846,
0.2978871465,
-0.4675039649,
0.532115221,
-0.145496577,
-0.6050499082,
0.0742516741,
-0.6291872263,
-0.2941513658,
-0.2468783557,
-0.5026623607,
-0.4242543578,
0.4050910473,
0.1028708145,
0.2713483274,
-0.2390162796,
0.2204155475,
-0.2618169487,
-0.2765298188,
0.2925696671,
-0.6189312935,
0.8463457227,
-0.2221597731,
-0.4658916891,
-0.1325771511,
-0.0822213143,
-0.5281512737,
0.3205119967,
0.0634511113,
-0.4219014347,
-0.1851062477,
-0.1601350456,
0.3865288496,
-0.0511869527,
-0.9441751838,
0.22182253,
-0.4747275114,
0.3906866908,
0.5625905991,
-0.2841877937,
0.8568486571,
-0.0970098227,
0.5359473228,
0.3925806284,
-0.1176831052,
-0.2828171849,
-0.7887488604,
-0.633719027,
0.3949796259,
0.4441609979,
0.732313931,
-0.8313654065,
-0.2040693909,
-0.1817864031,
0.0026116348,
-0.8579211831,
-0.0649694875,
0.6881836653,
0.5185638666,
0.1514824331,
-0.4813385606,
-0.29710567,
-1.3146466017,
-0.4975072443,
-0.1628757864,
0.0401893668,
0.1119675338,
0.5213928819,
-0.1329760551,
0.7702978849,
-0.273367703,
-0.4047963917,
-0.3163551092,
0.2268714756,
0.1801975518,
0.5670431852,
0.9075550437,
-0.5886767507,
-0.4097597301,
0.2207527757,
-0.823225379,
-0.1263622195,
-0.2033771574,
-0.1705292314,
0.183763206,
0.2622404099,
-0.7242267132,
0.7113502622,
0.5391790271,
-0.472640872,
0.3501220345,
-0.2637165487,
0.2495134324,
-0.8559885621,
-0.0403999202,
-0.1311823577,
-0.2691442072,
-0.8688024282,
0.0666276664,
0.2257854193,
-0.1126582846,
-0.4782595932,
0.5667943358,
-0.7090506554,
-0.2384119183,
-0.280095011,
0.0092573147,
-0.0218269397,
0.290658474,
0.1133518666,
0.8057168126,
0.4331178665,
-0.1933044791,
-0.2074106485,
0.4512015581,
0.3617773056,
0.6121283174,
-0.4757202566,
0.2224280238,
-0.5058940649,
-0.0065539628,
-0.5150470138,
0.1665461361,
0.5961021781,
-0.8748063445,
0.6536648273,
-0.2792160213,
-0.3084280193,
-0.1443870366,
-0.3393446505,
0.5163482428,
0.0499716327,
0.0593389161,
0.233198747,
0.2119302452,
-0.082868427,
-0.9202866554,
-1.2265800238,
0.2969447076,
0.1079511866,
-0.3934798539,
0.200875327,
-0.0358647145,
-0.105004102,
0.0304727927,
-0.1567386687,
-0.0132399891,
0.0077166189,
0.2058382332,
0.0875643343,
-0.1408301741,
0.2187615037,
0.2852570713,
-0.163938567,
-0.0238684826,
-0.3924390078,
0.6780815125,
-0.4198975861,
-0.6808177233,
-0.1309639961,
0.9124589562,
0.542881906,
-0.1584172845,
1.0319979191,
0.4972150624,
-0.3103980422,
0.095857501,
-0.402330637,
-0.1563736647,
-0.3403054178,
0.3025653362,
-0.3286771774,
-1.0064527988,
0.5311519504,
0.3364113569,
0.0130076986,
0.5396945477,
0.5503957868,
-0.1489728391,
0.9260767698,
0.8770940304,
-0.1610724181,
0.4278055131,
-0.1229659244,
0.1754574478,
-0.8224837184,
-0.1436820626,
-0.5510174632,
-0.4640342593,
-0.5455793738,
-0.3544248343,
0.1029161811,
-0.0370370634,
-0.3911134005,
0.4829148054,
-0.2656326592,
0.5259546041,
0.775585413,
-0.1142751053,
0.2113073617,
0.1397271007,
-0.140364483,
-0.4145124555,
-0.9491198659,
-0.1397712529,
0.9691520929,
0.3876241148,
0.2303751856,
0.2720410526,
0.4518537223,
0.1521940529,
-0.0521047711,
-0.4869086146,
0.2896790206,
-0.2381620109,
-1.1058778763,
-0.0740019828,
-0.6036108732,
-0.7668740749,
0.3639833629,
-0.0652945936,
-0.4541170001,
0.4408387244,
-0.0869652182,
0.0248490274,
0.5506560802,
-0.5178131461,
0.8109493256,
-0.2562149465,
-0.4116471112,
-0.0922054797,
-0.8767271638,
0.476767391,
0.0701792613,
-0.0087427823,
-0.2753208876,
0.1225084886,
0.2087671906,
-0.1496978998,
0.7772476077,
-0.1327691823,
0.0661468208,
-0.2389644235,
0.237799257,
-0.1872268319,
-0.1575116962,
-0.2323602289,
0.7761095762,
-0.3820384145,
-0.5544553399,
-0.5002183318,
0.4127781689,
-0.7448790073,
-0.7476455569,
-0.8132845759,
-0.8473578095,
-0.0674120113,
0.3382501006,
0.2145000696,
-0.0067129596,
-0.0277987719,
0.1124921367,
0.7822318673,
-0.4659300148,
0.5747092962,
0.5587441921,
-0.2430266589,
-0.2368033379,
0.5555497408,
0.2322417051,
0.5109688044,
0.3954740763,
0.1353583187,
-0.191967994,
-0.3398350179,
-0.971714735,
0.4425314665,
-0.432521373,
-0.2411181331,
-0.4355855882,
-0.2567420602,
-0.3344302475,
-0.0572890155,
-0.6050918698,
-0.6484484076,
-0.0032522767,
-0.0546429865,
0.1341673583,
0.4752864242,
-0.0701425672,
0.5099850297,
-0.7524228692,
0.2657684982,
-0.0501945019,
0.2256570011,
-0.0896751657,
-0.481754005,
-0.154956013,
0.2322942466,
-0.1724801958,
-1.2110991478,
0.4882977009,
0.2178409696,
0.5972676873,
0.0883868858,
-0.1820975989,
0.5465942025,
-0.7491599321,
0.6429898739,
0.5873740911,
-1.1049916744,
0.4583500624,
-0.6860376,
0.8472961187,
0.4972218573,
0.1641229689,
-0.9562144279,
-0.4402986169,
-0.3425482512,
-0.7745475769,
0.8094857335,
0.6477802992,
0.4129113555,
0.0006435488,
0.501742363,
0.1800227612,
0.842223525,
-0.9252023697,
-0.5382495522,
-0.310852617,
0.0682101324,
0.1644977629,
-0.0896357223,
-0.0810732469,
-0.3973797858,
0.5014851689,
-0.0199066438,
0.4988651872,
0.1297166049,
-0.2419359833,
-0.2151204497,
0.4244354665,
0.7001583576,
0.1891566217,
-0.1211001799,
0.0237744506,
0.096003063,
-0.5730480552,
0.3671199679,
-0.0782319382,
-0.8485493064,
0.3201099932,
0.3112606704,
0.9624816179,
0.0859086812,
-0.1771265715,
0.5465108156,
-0.2149892747,
-0.2720585465,
0.0875452608,
-0.3557730615,
0.2386102229,
0.2138853818,
0.2577986419,
0.4606100321,
0.0223294944,
-0.7204700112,
-0.0033984957,
0.5799149275,
-0.3996357322,
-0.3473787606,
0.9116423726,
-0.0169361234,
-0.2439249307,
0.6579320431,
-0.2009549439,
-0.6627485752,
0.430565387,
0.5057839155,
1.2446584702,
-0.6401173472,
0.2260031551,
0.2471971959,
0.7717493176,
0.0193619076,
0.1525083482,
0.0203606784,
-0.7453296781,
-0.3170808256,
-0.3699814975,
-0.2987493277,
-0.509914279,
-0.5216915607,
0.1485450864,
-0.2429934293,
-0.3224734366,
-0.4181573391,
-0.2918814421,
-0.5879799724,
-0.3088244498,
0.439181,
0.5927484035,
-1.0099426508,
0.8453603983,
0.7176377773,
-0.6258827448,
-0.4867699146,
0.0013465562,
0.2225483656,
-0.6016490459,
0.4985251129,
0.1388137043,
-0.3280546963,
-0.217398569,
-0.2134040445,
-0.7058218718,
1.0358829498,
1.0957831144,
-0.6257132292,
0.0179554988,
0.8706626296,
0.3580979109,
-0.2752628624,
0.3399455547,
0.3423197567,
0.4220429063,
-0.0268868189,
-1.1611882448,
-0.280434072,
-0.2634494305,
0.104869768,
0.2724562883,
-0.4972086549,
1.1565107107,
0.124246195,
-0.165868625,
-0.2419913858,
0.3807058632,
0.1163842529,
0.3801308274,
0.1739099473,
0.4832358658,
0.3993860483,
-0.1447468847,
0.8150131702,
0.0000582051,
0.2174086273,
1.0463913679,
-0.2967038155,
0.6488906741,
0.5060425401,
0.1518185884,
0.2820730209,
0.1671453714,
0.1569734961,
0.2782314718,
-0.0276696049,
-0.2345061302,
-0.0075151967,
-0.2088758051,
-0.6340353489,
0.4716080427,
0.1650312543,
-0.3604744077,
-0.4035528004,
0.1409216076,
0.3248359859,
0.2748736143,
-0.2970724702,
0.3326307237,
0.347363919,
-0.3316342831,
0.3281746507,
0.1784520745,
0.5708879828,
-0.6162920594,
-0.0300086625,
-0.4848920107,
0.153722018,
-0.1240642741,
-0.6554749012,
0.6462484598,
-0.1062011421,
-0.6564277411,
-0.6223279834,
0.8378655314,
-0.875764966,
-0.5457305312,
0.5274199247,
0.979392767,
0.0396851227,
-0.237022236,
-0.8779293299,
-0.0712113157,
-0.0155396061,
0.0030749,
0.4308345616,
0.2203547657,
-0.3132104278,
0.6442219019,
0.5178675056,
0.2767265141,
0.2261270136,
0.273272723,
0.5887420774,
-0.8013450503,
-0.2940326035,
-1.0724201202,
0.5165574551,
-0.0980887786,
-0.1077473387,
1.0997706652,
0.4375697672,
0.7878446579,
-0.3444925249,
0.5766718388,
0.1920493394,
0.2686178088,
-0.1643027365,
1.2637622356,
-0.4305581748,
0.0826111212,
-0.3919374645,
-0.9456698298,
-0.6336661577,
0.3787519336,
-0.3428374231,
-0.1430018842,
0.5796111822,
0.588182807,
-0.0888040364,
-0.2123792022,
0.5062840581,
0.0029735828,
0.0614223033,
0.568610549,
0.8121181726,
-0.717533946,
0.2742182016,
-0.0510068759,
0.0452887304,
0.0819240957,
-0.9370088577,
-0.7766925693,
-0.3374961615,
-0.2823687196,
0.0991734043,
0.3104947805,
0.5468369126,
0.6954784393,
-0.5719994903,
-0.6168936491,
-0.1327296048,
0.2667024136,
-0.2081328183,
-0.1195917949,
0.0157609433,
-0.0650662556,
-0.6902537942,
0.4453209937,
0.4399589002,
0.0206966028,
-0.501858294,
-0.2077441812,
-0.4111379683,
-0.0728363395,
0.475722909,
0.3116695881,
-0.5540110469,
-0.1027593687,
0.3209653795,
0.1730211526,
0.0783588961,
0.7087839246,
-0.6641583443,
0.646032989,
0.5138787031,
0.6253200173,
0.3910474479,
-0.3378633261,
1.2514603138,
-1.0494199991,
0.3858184516,
0.1732333601,
0.3252895176,
0.5882952213,
-0.3039030433,
0.49224931,
0.6009046435,
-0.253960222,
-0.7996463776,
0.4403211176,
-0.6720145345,
-0.3619324565,
0.9096335769,
0.0190164987,
-0.1448515654,
-0.051102709,
-0.0922670513,
0.4648551643,
-0.3265661001,
0.4280304611,
0.8644195199,
0.0844479129,
-0.3745296001,
-1.1427254677,
0.1842385381,
0.6252970099,
-0.2279313505,
0.0013221821,
0.2989141941,
0.1235813051,
0.1368328184,
0.3783559799,
-0.2050533444,
0.1727043688,
-0.0828713104,
0.3372611403,
-0.0815196931,
-0.195657894,
-0.7803029418,
-0.0813356787,
-0.0984062925,
-0.3868205547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16934v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16934v2 | On Evaluating Adversarial Robustness of Large Vision-Language Models | 2023-05-26T13:49:44 | 2023-10-29T12:32:19 | Yunqing Zhao, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Xiao Yang, Chongxuan Li, Ngai-Man Cheung, Min Lin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG, cs.MM | Large vision-language models (VLMs) such as GPT-4 have achieved unprecedented
performance in response generation, especially with visual inputs, enabling
more creative and adaptable interaction than large language models such as
ChatGPT. Nonetheless, multimodal generation exacerbates safety concerns, since
adversaries may successfully evade the entire system by subtly manipulating the
most vulnerable modality (e.g., vision). To this end, we propose evaluating the
robustness of open-source large VLMs in the most realistic and high-risk
setting, where adversaries have only black-box system access and seek to
deceive the model into returning the targeted responses. In particular, we
first craft targeted adversarial examples against pretrained models such as
CLIP and BLIP, and then transfer these adversarial examples to other VLMs such
as MiniGPT-4, LLaVA, UniDiffuser, BLIP-2, and Img2Prompt. In addition, we
observe that black-box queries on these VLMs can further improve the
effectiveness of targeted evasion, resulting in a surprisingly high success
rate for generating targeted responses. Our findings provide a quantitative
understanding regarding the adversarial vulnerability of large VLMs and call
for a more thorough examination of their potential security flaws before
deployment in practice. Code is at https://github.com/yunqing-me/AttackVLM. | [
-0.4928056598,
-0.9220665097,
0.3820828199,
-0.0495867021,
-0.0749764889,
-0.0139124021,
-0.2002339214,
-0.4199459553,
-0.3197643757,
0.4755022824,
-0.2572642863,
-0.162350297,
-0.5928437114,
-0.1821789593,
-0.6139774323,
1.0329502821,
0.2688219547,
-0.1506772339,
0.1122063994,
-0.2584888935,
-0.3523098528,
-0.814468503,
-0.4993323684,
0.1941677183,
0.6038970947,
-0.4325052202,
1.0192710161,
0.3041062653,
0.728281498,
0.3413177729,
-0.0513420776,
-0.0111535517,
-0.6720064282,
0.0867494345,
-0.195215553,
-0.4200903475,
-0.4501211941,
-0.2535102367,
0.5605534315,
0.1905672699,
0.0436295718,
0.0741480663,
0.1839892566,
0.3620744944,
-0.9845355749,
-0.0481980965,
-1.0661854744,
0.0272405483,
-0.316270709,
0.036752902,
-0.6221428514,
-0.1979614943,
0.2057373524,
-0.5230817199,
0.1678143293,
-0.0090639452,
0.938975811,
0.3483026624,
-0.3906050622,
-0.1346130073,
-0.7743031383,
0.5801054835,
-0.621409297,
0.1902917922,
0.2519679368,
0.7021132708,
-0.1833069324,
-0.7233146429,
-0.4828770459,
-0.5289033055,
0.0977233425,
0.164887473,
-0.5951589346,
-0.0387064591,
0.4703998268,
0.2597008944,
-0.8919878006,
-0.0738891661,
-0.3656952679,
-0.3102838993,
0.4939828515,
0.1572359651,
0.2137333751,
0.1265006214,
-0.5227413774,
-0.3250213265,
-0.7223246098,
-0.0268969666,
0.5102027059,
0.1852352768,
0.1312960833,
0.7416948676,
0.149939388,
0.7879063487,
-0.245359689,
0.1095875055,
-0.0039669443,
-0.7505977154,
-0.4054053724,
-0.3694730997,
0.9263063073,
0.4227766693,
0.3082388937,
-0.1267180592,
-0.3878981471,
0.3677177131,
0.8836616874,
-0.7191322446,
-0.3873630464,
0.1509185433,
-0.2649107277,
-0.5320103168,
-0.0255626291,
-0.9905749559,
-0.4527178705,
0.1976539344,
0.7249165773,
-0.3869791627,
-0.1809218079,
-0.037554279,
-0.0126085682,
0.2585166097,
0.225069955,
-0.5379127264,
-0.060792055,
0.514287591,
0.7762607336,
-0.0433040522,
-0.3846482337,
-0.8894639015,
0.0018970192,
-0.4173663855,
0.353087455,
-0.1093504652,
-0.3213326037,
0.174587667,
-0.1236030236,
0.0265633948,
-0.3812308609,
0.3923301101,
-0.5359553099,
-0.096141018,
-0.148690924,
0.0478036366,
0.0553347841,
0.7149142027,
-0.7153206468,
0.5084956288,
0.176659286,
-0.8437085152,
0.3804295659,
-0.4984628558,
-0.2325476259,
0.0150349857,
-0.1494626552,
-0.7129545808,
0.1587581486,
0.2712817788,
0.3339236379,
-0.0190884378,
-0.0116310464,
-0.8455582261,
-0.0675339177,
0.4777286053,
-0.8356968164,
0.8344690204,
0.3336462677,
-0.432218641,
0.3915649951,
-0.6503620148,
0.11873772,
0.4607338905,
-0.212261498,
-0.4252919555,
-0.1157387197,
0.0344674513,
0.154258579,
0.0301123541,
-0.3596097231,
0.0856353715,
-0.401914537,
0.354319334,
0.9077749848,
-0.2569359243,
0.0325470157,
0.1085988507,
0.6257995367,
-0.1410814226,
0.6028853655,
-0.2936891913,
-0.3769079447,
-0.4613238275,
-0.2484006882,
0.1689023226,
0.4563338757,
-1.3879704475,
-0.0225270167,
-0.0220399797,
-0.4143178165,
-0.3489890993,
0.0602495819,
0.788707912,
0.3181834817,
0.221808359,
-0.1509360969,
-0.2034747899,
-0.8692939878,
-0.1811920851,
-0.2814073563,
0.0330439471,
0.2574897408,
0.6642065048,
-0.1851195991,
0.3661834598,
-0.4741425514,
0.1777229905,
0.028609857,
-0.2683388591,
-0.2852478921,
0.0969281793,
0.9511399269,
-0.9608104229,
-0.2302832901,
0.0607905164,
-0.8422382474,
0.2779784203,
0.1447539479,
-0.1401180923,
0.1840334684,
0.1866735369,
-0.561609149,
0.6272586584,
0.734184742,
-0.3868463635,
0.766402781,
-0.2932704091,
-0.0159951169,
-0.8772140145,
0.2910820544,
0.0521563143,
-0.1549809128,
-0.7333750129,
0.6346197724,
0.1470442414,
-0.3178614676,
-0.6901222467,
0.2881254554,
-0.3053443134,
-0.2754933536,
-0.1934291273,
0.0275524817,
-0.0617635697,
0.3316603899,
-0.3868609369,
0.8446329832,
0.5366874933,
-0.4657230675,
0.6115688682,
0.1552192867,
-0.4357821643,
0.616972506,
-0.7343446016,
0.1259557158,
-0.0415213183,
0.0889075249,
-0.7972313762,
-0.3292235732,
0.2834684551,
-0.4566321969,
0.4163610339,
-0.1272300631,
-0.261287868,
-0.5780786276,
-0.4124353528,
0.4139342606,
0.3426234126,
-0.504480958,
0.3125231862,
0.2027929872,
0.0224294383,
-0.8758402467,
-0.6893720627,
0.4068686366,
-0.2880360186,
-0.6536721587,
-0.2800090909,
-0.1828789562,
-0.3737078607,
-0.015372687,
0.0995054543,
0.2212163657,
0.4613105953,
0.1346264929,
0.3836830556,
-0.3118550181,
-0.3585688472,
-0.6249649525,
-0.0358950384,
0.0887839645,
-0.3672847152,
0.4431318045,
-0.4380809963,
-0.8165920377,
0.2258854806,
0.3251182139,
0.8950846195,
-0.6500945091,
0.6220174432,
0.8749229908,
-0.3349426091,
-0.1425529718,
-0.2190781385,
0.0128429336,
-0.4404378831,
0.5684674978,
-0.356559813,
-0.625777483,
0.4309080541,
0.4851709604,
0.1324389726,
0.2283379138,
0.7938004136,
0.3870358467,
1.157374382,
0.3906246126,
0.0168697387,
0.3622107208,
-0.2384947836,
0.2172981054,
-0.6762086153,
-0.1512434036,
-0.4269798994,
0.0433970653,
-0.4428482652,
-0.2590471506,
0.5164071918,
-0.2451601177,
-0.0808959231,
0.3657144606,
-0.4382422268,
0.1667939425,
0.5890014172,
-0.0010554001,
-0.0557592511,
0.0202341862,
-0.0349770933,
0.1798992157,
-0.5895755291,
-0.3277581036,
1.2773926258,
0.4402323365,
0.9585074782,
0.3960257471,
0.1618019342,
0.0551086217,
0.2741293609,
-0.5876386166,
0.4284541011,
-0.223606959,
-0.6416954398,
-0.3652547896,
-0.4636124969,
-0.9692611694,
0.5504254103,
-0.3502300084,
-0.6248494387,
0.0161889456,
0.4016745687,
-0.4749643803,
0.3800278306,
-0.7577528358,
0.90337497,
-0.5337510109,
-0.5292314291,
0.2159816176,
-0.5938861966,
0.6428934336,
-0.4393685162,
0.0860616416,
0.3127506971,
0.1385636628,
0.1051176563,
-0.2668890655,
0.5935034752,
-0.1926718205,
-0.2193952799,
0.1608353704,
0.2226891816,
0.4974040687,
0.0026588365,
0.1062895358,
0.044655554,
-0.1717743427,
-0.4956589043,
-0.6097177267,
0.750194788,
-0.4818703532,
-0.6300527453,
-0.3183850944,
-0.5022991896,
-0.1896588653,
0.2849490643,
0.5496096015,
0.5531918406,
-0.224819243,
0.4850638211,
0.7265959978,
-0.415042758,
0.395773977,
0.3178217411,
-0.2737598121,
-0.5727826953,
1.0768898726,
0.0840947926,
0.6791756153,
0.0727733523,
0.0009726831,
-0.281162113,
-1.0092610121,
-0.8733865023,
-0.2720814943,
-0.5208255649,
-0.2341989875,
-0.3881130815,
-0.224492833,
-0.3195535541,
-0.0302829947,
-0.3843518496,
0.0943644941,
0.1280271411,
0.0172516257,
-0.1649336517,
0.7032365799,
0.2159619182,
0.002547011,
-0.6450875998,
0.4083693922,
0.5964916945,
0.1701013446,
-0.039888341,
-0.2661827803,
-0.1868398041,
0.1421559751,
-0.3988225758,
-0.7600921988,
0.3477117121,
0.0013594875,
0.6604138613,
0.3764855862,
0.1640344709,
0.4732223749,
-0.4390186667,
1.0068793297,
0.1858703941,
-0.5827813745,
0.6133697629,
-0.4432645142,
0.2888265848,
0.2478933781,
0.1142506152,
0.1906289011,
-0.5903080702,
-0.5802688599,
-0.7761659622,
0.4113323689,
0.5755663514,
0.0551421233,
0.1682222337,
0.0639453977,
-0.1405955702,
0.3000521064,
-0.7965324521,
-0.1130401418,
-0.6431125402,
-0.0163674746,
-0.3044857085,
-0.2128833532,
-0.4710920453,
0.3962962627,
0.3777143657,
-0.2654992938,
0.1326797009,
0.0505218804,
0.0715098828,
-0.0284117758,
0.2204041034,
0.8748542666,
0.5274671912,
-0.1312270314,
0.4028184712,
0.1164165214,
-0.5887953639,
0.0542471297,
0.3017351031,
-0.3605390787,
-0.4013895094,
0.5913237929,
0.8882552385,
-0.0752511844,
-0.7591311932,
0.9118193388,
-0.3996434808,
-0.2042425573,
-0.0975355953,
0.0802365765,
-0.409971118,
0.3760680258,
0.1709255278,
0.3144817054,
0.0974369347,
-0.6297857761,
0.131283626,
0.9742980599,
-0.4135538638,
-0.3330717087,
0.8903747201,
-0.048309356,
-0.2138760984,
0.2732763588,
-0.0890703052,
-0.7381969094,
0.5828309655,
0.5753902793,
0.9281886816,
-0.2701691389,
0.0285255425,
0.0199334528,
0.8113827705,
0.0370864086,
-0.0771512315,
0.1875372678,
-0.3824793696,
-0.3630695939,
-0.511295855,
-0.2925229669,
0.4362704456,
-0.7283414602,
0.0294235852,
-0.5001664758,
-0.2950980365,
0.0194904581,
-0.4331965446,
-0.5807052851,
0.1062631458,
0.2916630805,
0.6482211947,
-0.647552669,
0.5894631743,
0.7795181274,
-0.3034044504,
-0.5247403979,
0.2216792256,
0.133644715,
-0.8868712187,
0.3294966221,
-0.0154863335,
-0.1900831163,
-0.4417457581,
-0.5421907902,
-0.5933731198,
0.8695659637,
0.683108747,
-0.3856460452,
-0.0989987925,
-0.0722942948,
0.60922575,
0.1630979776,
0.0619414672,
0.2176285088,
0.2749153972,
0.0692096204,
-1.0005239248,
0.0974933729,
-0.2485664487,
0.0977157801,
0.3018990755,
-0.7626620531,
0.8639740944,
-0.3382475674,
-0.1314553916,
0.0851409659,
0.3461064994,
0.1712268442,
0.4352276921,
0.5513466597,
0.5517077446,
0.4195487797,
-0.1424323916,
1.3267097473,
-0.109406203,
0.2223814428,
0.7173723578,
-0.0856315494,
0.747862637,
0.28127262,
-0.1279290617,
-0.2205809653,
0.1001649797,
-0.2291218787,
0.5390219688,
0.2132564783,
-0.1362523884,
-0.0905282199,
0.2345294654,
-0.4623869359,
0.4279064536,
0.2402199358,
-0.2304789126,
-0.1315333843,
0.4011678994,
-0.0459934212,
-0.0122954277,
-0.3353120387,
0.6064231396,
0.0120807877,
-0.6909121871,
0.9154089093,
-0.3375851512,
0.4303890169,
-0.743183434,
0.0781231076,
0.0173975639,
0.4996189177,
-0.0523868166,
-0.8887242675,
0.2539718151,
0.2550577521,
0.1218066886,
0.1734402329,
0.7248671651,
-0.1976596564,
-0.3449975252,
0.350911051,
0.1903099418,
-0.1951904446,
-0.2551924586,
-0.6889252663,
0.3394802809,
0.1670921743,
-0.3522518873,
0.6729399562,
0.3309929371,
0.0803651065,
0.8437601924,
0.732021749,
0.2589482963,
0.2287681848,
-0.1762516797,
0.9628702402,
-0.3116340637,
-0.2269787639,
-0.976405561,
0.5210978389,
-0.1112539247,
-0.269605279,
0.9597694278,
0.3308058679,
0.8301798105,
-0.0311916545,
0.9190310836,
0.1126420647,
-0.0774927437,
-0.5720535517,
0.6703412533,
-0.57982409,
0.2058734149,
-0.4539014101,
-0.8996988535,
-0.3169808686,
0.3139484823,
-0.1047026813,
-0.0860174149,
0.3522863686,
0.8348721862,
-0.1784209907,
-0.3264198899,
0.7808656096,
0.3526039124,
0.7063032389,
0.7407482266,
0.9995345473,
-0.3455370963,
1.2538787127,
-0.1189801395,
-0.3222842813,
-0.2960290611,
-0.7660155892,
-0.9783944488,
-0.4164788425,
0.0089474479,
-0.7850331068,
0.3295173645,
0.3166477382,
0.5783537626,
-0.6779013872,
0.3321444094,
0.2230883986,
-0.1415284425,
-0.0124870697,
-0.1350531578,
0.3811237216,
-0.0546361282,
-0.5477702022,
0.3711903989,
0.3358018696,
0.3243904114,
-0.7704390883,
0.0663964376,
0.3618761301,
-0.0736185089,
0.7889594436,
0.3289197683,
-0.8254195452,
-0.4456077218,
-0.04979752,
-0.2399528027,
-0.3521861434,
0.5558731556,
-0.3845080435,
0.711540401,
0.2604062855,
0.7936574817,
0.2715128958,
0.0379092731,
0.6613718271,
-0.501462996,
0.1294927448,
0.1964876503,
0.4538243413,
0.3394013643,
-0.3121220469,
0.3585784733,
0.0850374028,
-0.5573863387,
-1.1690006256,
0.4509616196,
-0.8908609748,
-0.3094570935,
1.2218937874,
-0.4529062808,
-0.2695346475,
-0.0105246045,
-0.3727069199,
-0.1424712241,
-0.0894826874,
0.7206281424,
0.7001065612,
0.2053947598,
-0.0587822236,
-0.8067002296,
0.3872230351,
0.1202602461,
-0.6427121162,
0.2507277131,
0.5005548,
-0.0069915075,
0.3952009976,
0.2572282553,
-0.1888336986,
0.3585063219,
0.3862724006,
-0.4207280278,
-0.4100497663,
-0.3509078026,
-0.397336185,
0.5902688503,
0.1680893451,
-0.3192273676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16932v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16932v1 | A Neural State-Space Model Approach to Efficient Speech Separation | 2023-05-26T13:47:11 | 2023-05-26T13:47:11 | Chen Chen, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Kai Li, Yuchen Hu, Pin-Jui Ku, Eng Siong Chng | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | In this work, we introduce S4M, a new efficient speech separation framework
based on neural state-space models (SSM). Motivated by linear time-invariant
systems for sequence modeling, our SSM-based approach can efficiently model
input signals into a format of linear ordinary differential equations (ODEs)
for representation learning. To extend the SSM technique into speech separation
tasks, we first decompose the input mixture into multi-scale representations
with different resolutions. This mechanism enables S4M to learn globally
coherent separation and reconstruction. The experimental results show that S4M
performs comparably to other separation backbones in terms of SI-SDRi, while
having a much lower model complexity with significantly fewer trainable
parameters. In addition, our S4M-tiny model (1.8M parameters) even surpasses
attention-based Sepformer (26.0M parameters) in noisy conditions with only 9.2
of multiply-accumulate operation (MACs). | [
-0.2345549613,
-0.367487222,
0.6231746078,
0.264249891,
-0.3109887242,
0.2221626341,
-0.1300495863,
-0.4120200276,
0.3228212893,
0.148852244,
-0.3561154604,
-0.2240329981,
-0.7635204196,
0.0396600515,
-0.3261726499,
0.661814034,
0.2193846703,
0.4899431467,
-0.1190661117,
-0.0471015908,
-0.110995844,
-0.3620977104,
-0.5667826533,
-0.3578131199,
0.5507856607,
0.0032644072,
-0.0046809665,
0.8471895456,
0.3452910781,
0.3832795918,
-0.6501523256,
0.0063633872,
-0.2198548317,
0.1565924287,
-0.1044773385,
-0.6561505198,
-0.1608446389,
0.2761525214,
1.1040388346,
0.6826264858,
-0.4777402878,
-0.0147470012,
-0.0500472933,
0.2150387764,
-0.3838292062,
0.4220854044,
-0.7140164971,
0.0852794647,
-0.0732943341,
0.0659690052,
-0.1759294719,
-0.3944698274,
0.0840893835,
-0.3320890069,
0.0072494014,
-0.4797672331,
0.8672434092,
0.3697294295,
-0.2535673082,
0.1176301986,
-0.9797834158,
0.9587129354,
-0.6092163324,
0.7413910627,
0.0626296103,
0.4286544919,
0.0343974568,
-0.8001204133,
-0.475910157,
0.3341565728,
0.4651117027,
0.0068716304,
-0.2311006337,
-0.0623301491,
0.256244272,
0.1520393789,
-0.1282793581,
0.1976381242,
-0.9025563002,
-0.389180094,
0.4028447568,
0.0672941282,
0.2277986407,
-0.3140530586,
-0.7199820876,
0.4244723916,
-0.6834192276,
0.1262675822,
0.0020467488,
0.4461289942,
-0.0537665077,
0.0339806564,
0.2076792866,
0.5462127924,
0.1520254612,
-0.423918426,
0.0706110969,
-0.2375856489,
-0.0719901323,
-0.0273009948,
0.6024614573,
-0.1107756346,
-0.4888072908,
-0.3303352892,
-0.3289258778,
0.4451595545,
0.3672029078,
-0.9105706811,
0.0378004238,
0.1544189602,
-0.5475360751,
-0.1343328953,
-0.4029391706,
-0.610485971,
-0.3380836546,
-0.602350533,
0.5148498416,
-0.5133953691,
-0.401524812,
-0.1603227109,
-0.001075309,
0.2796842754,
0.255777061,
-0.8301293254,
0.7239028215,
0.5224238038,
0.9434325099,
-0.5413501263,
0.1251567304,
-0.685855031,
-0.1254521459,
-0.415972352,
0.5423564315,
-0.2779144347,
-0.1585309058,
-0.5390978456,
-0.2557071745,
-0.2027542591,
-0.7243753672,
0.1078326479,
-0.7082611322,
-0.1088358536,
0.0254461188,
-0.786670506,
-0.3351086378,
-0.129112184,
-0.8340725303,
0.6280328035,
-0.007442933,
-0.0472520106,
0.1100264415,
-0.6621760726,
-0.1193144694,
0.1501166075,
-0.4460277855,
-0.2827151418,
0.0806766376,
0.1035665944,
0.4408582747,
-0.2366487682,
0.2017323524,
-0.3664027452,
-0.2312643826,
-0.0259489678,
-0.2797982693,
0.5474256277,
0.7340257764,
-0.1657144278,
0.1919853687,
-1.0839477777,
-0.0347855426,
-0.0658773333,
-0.6126865149,
-0.1421078593,
0.0491106175,
-0.2779562175,
0.4522469044,
0.3141990602,
-0.7862778306,
-0.3850694597,
-0.5944789052,
0.9250706434,
0.5400235057,
-0.1254621893,
0.9621165395,
-0.057038337,
0.4890799224,
0.3789902329,
-0.2523185909,
-0.104961589,
-0.2394951731,
-0.5797246695,
-0.7677543759,
0.4678606391,
0.2840182185,
-0.5284150839,
0.4730997384,
-0.3207420707,
-0.3053615987,
-0.3954153061,
0.0669100732,
0.2451526225,
0.4894383848,
0.3502593935,
-0.1850326806,
-0.5928928852,
-0.7453617454,
-0.1175677106,
0.190923959,
0.0424524546,
-0.057396058,
0.3350901306,
0.0242797323,
1.0135983229,
-0.1986307651,
-0.0236182213,
-0.4889377356,
-0.3147913516,
0.2175251395,
0.3845263422,
0.2690867186,
-0.6986038089,
-0.0116072008,
-0.3833461404,
-0.7200903296,
0.0347590521,
0.3626107574,
-0.0878815353,
-0.0243874304,
0.4620497525,
-0.7855834961,
0.6232684851,
0.4478153586,
-0.056463737,
0.1166676879,
0.1400719285,
-0.3125709593,
-1.3170194626,
-0.1452629566,
0.2791555524,
-0.3746979535,
-0.9503905177,
0.0403361097,
0.3981130421,
-0.4945571423,
-0.8009851575,
0.0945428535,
-0.5058553219,
-0.4326433241,
-0.3011759222,
0.3622231781,
0.1468260586,
0.6762632728,
0.077132754,
0.3002140224,
0.4185059071,
-0.5700311661,
0.0446257554,
-0.0471754335,
-0.2264772803,
0.3756788075,
-0.6091076136,
0.1582223177,
-0.0917410702,
0.3526788056,
-1.1552772522,
0.0400950983,
0.1951038688,
-0.1601600498,
0.4959905148,
-0.1627727598,
-0.1124870554,
0.0229676105,
0.045438759,
0.5693612099,
0.362011075,
-0.8102604747,
0.8982045054,
0.700412631,
-0.5117115378,
-0.1839734614,
-0.4791373014,
-0.2304572314,
-0.455435276,
-0.6502706409,
0.4867132306,
0.1185337827,
-0.0657630116,
-0.1536354423,
-0.6698881984,
-0.3773559034,
-0.0270735975,
0.2673257887,
0.3039347529,
-0.0353822708,
-0.0923540518,
0.0497119687,
-0.0529132299,
0.1235013679,
-0.3736219406,
0.4042031169,
-0.2895130217,
-0.0021198241,
-0.6039777994,
0.469765991,
0.4621993005,
-0.301115185,
0.418277055,
0.3016584814,
-0.783066988,
-0.2538111806,
-0.2680452168,
-0.3977896869,
-0.4288091362,
0.48837322,
-0.3791747093,
-0.9447758198,
0.5831877589,
-0.2860888243,
0.1514687091,
0.0975794122,
0.2398866266,
-0.158727929,
1.1020855904,
0.1881063432,
-0.2229791135,
0.6088330746,
-0.5267936587,
0.3612754941,
-0.8037279248,
-0.135069564,
-0.4949580133,
-0.5480248928,
-0.0151726557,
-0.7215932608,
0.2042069882,
0.3070304692,
-0.1661317348,
0.2055590302,
-0.3819260001,
0.4903540611,
0.2565107346,
0.151535213,
-0.1351752877,
0.1927241683,
-0.3654894233,
-0.3347263038,
-0.8639219999,
-0.3154920042,
0.5839595795,
0.5377156734,
0.660007,
0.0773928165,
0.8628292084,
-0.1011776552,
-0.0539273806,
-0.9593365192,
0.7590064406,
-0.354385674,
-0.3328437507,
-0.3526450992,
-0.6887155175,
-0.9321709871,
0.8343103528,
-0.0650187209,
-0.9725869298,
0.1957665086,
-0.1864663213,
-0.8075416088,
0.5161426067,
-0.6049695015,
0.283901602,
0.0170607418,
-0.1579766721,
-0.1545066833,
-0.8040127158,
0.3385339677,
-0.0236691162,
0.2797591686,
-0.3043980002,
0.1992008686,
0.8973859549,
-0.363140583,
0.7216714025,
-0.4864198565,
-0.0634930059,
0.1631779224,
0.0925281271,
0.1006878093,
-0.1747710258,
-0.0487535335,
0.5904309154,
0.0503235348,
0.0061881454,
-0.6633253694,
0.7303680182,
-0.9311722517,
-0.3082772493,
-0.2030164897,
-0.6651729941,
-0.0546221659,
0.2655834258,
0.0485558249,
0.7147957087,
0.2335196882,
0.3287140429,
0.4898130894,
0.0049137878,
0.6684041023,
0.5152329206,
-0.1803561002,
-0.7223221064,
0.894713223,
0.4507865608,
0.1533865929,
0.0860785246,
0.1765471101,
-0.7993324995,
-0.3814466894,
-0.1308806092,
0.2617974579,
-0.776329875,
-0.2132634073,
-0.3799898028,
-0.6649540067,
-0.3043510914,
0.5900840163,
-0.6642125845,
-0.6840183139,
-0.5128068328,
-0.2199645936,
-0.1147722527,
0.7343298793,
-0.192458719,
0.243613869,
-0.725420773,
0.7319401503,
0.2883039117,
0.2572077215,
-0.3801180124,
-0.6663287878,
-0.2872291505,
-0.1983194798,
-0.4083178639,
-0.8122030497,
0.5469864011,
0.3275314867,
0.6305240989,
0.4595844448,
-0.2678706944,
0.8144119978,
-0.670330584,
1.0138236284,
0.5182543397,
-1.0871244669,
0.5187491775,
-0.058074519,
0.2425511926,
-0.1285837889,
0.1532776952,
-0.2339707166,
-0.3699918389,
-0.4983324707,
-0.8283347487,
1.0867266655,
-0.0053420076,
-0.3508396447,
0.092573382,
0.5714911819,
-0.0510606058,
0.0643481463,
-0.5297979712,
-0.2142087221,
-0.0964956358,
-0.3029735982,
-0.103949517,
-0.1754020602,
-0.2453688085,
-0.2561399937,
0.3555986583,
0.0534188598,
0.4227251112,
-0.1266634762,
-0.043142844,
-0.0260391608,
0.2120770216,
0.6098639965,
0.4184716344,
0.2266296148,
0.381998837,
0.1424089074,
-0.2293465883,
0.5573355556,
0.2752438486,
-0.0285765883,
0.0092692161,
-0.2718454301,
0.8887021542,
0.5871429443,
0.0979118347,
0.5312316418,
-0.3435030282,
-0.5784177184,
-0.1327794641,
0.223418802,
0.4824031591,
0.5285147429,
0.2517424822,
0.5158598423,
0.1630864292,
0.2212775052,
0.2175625712,
0.112446405,
-0.2838305831,
-0.5256724954,
1.0034292936,
0.2733434439,
-0.3753500879,
0.2951898873,
0.1827565134,
-0.1755507886,
0.5346488953,
0.6341912746,
0.6437824965,
-0.5627831221,
-0.0514727868,
0.0393599011,
-0.143776834,
-0.1809603572,
0.6522611976,
-0.3072634637,
-0.9975141287,
-0.5137749314,
-0.7320514321,
-0.125167042,
0.4175629616,
-0.812631011,
-0.0721135363,
-0.8735486865,
-0.4187740088,
0.2498155385,
-0.1826751232,
-0.4808485806,
0.2113959789,
0.4828230739,
0.7865499854,
-0.5622027516,
0.8245475888,
0.4784599245,
-0.0346602015,
-1.2790660858,
-0.294651866,
0.2149448395,
-0.1792085469,
0.6985760927,
0.3839330971,
-0.5833266973,
-0.1822226644,
-0.6706046462,
-1.1785626411,
0.8321808577,
0.9038709998,
-0.6673045158,
0.1013149023,
-0.1397468299,
0.3268846571,
-0.4694056213,
-0.0385762788,
0.7693568468,
-0.0633740053,
-0.0201703738,
-0.4994891882,
-0.2698714435,
-0.4248158038,
0.4589378238,
0.1147172526,
-0.6663559079,
0.8674309254,
-0.0134859355,
-0.3651003242,
0.2530105114,
0.977619648,
0.7620140314,
0.260279268,
0.9265673161,
0.6122156978,
0.8644201756,
-0.2615235448,
0.3421566784,
-0.4701139629,
0.0942252427,
1.1226996183,
-0.4800107479,
0.9259641171,
0.7573467493,
-0.105561398,
0.4747286737,
0.50605762,
0.5254292488,
0.721673131,
0.4084034264,
-0.4713118672,
-0.2805167437,
0.3542776108,
-0.1157965958,
0.8179101944,
0.5744718313,
-0.2538641393,
-0.245334059,
0.1469613761,
-0.3261134923,
0.0308437552,
-0.3156905174,
0.8193098903,
0.3737099767,
-0.4424244463,
0.4186563194,
0.0292174891,
0.4670318961,
-0.6659604311,
-0.1266822219,
-0.036721915,
0.0956178829,
-0.2485234737,
-0.1122903675,
0.2415070236,
0.0788287371,
-0.384208113,
-0.3320463896,
0.8227469325,
-0.6873005033,
-0.1297647655,
0.389059335,
0.2884600461,
0.4763006866,
0.1821406037,
-0.3918808699,
0.2586342394,
-0.1791445464,
-0.2016364783,
0.1654014289,
0.2294512987,
0.0682215169,
0.514944613,
0.5986791849,
0.6092459559,
0.4771009088,
0.2334078699,
0.6630787253,
-0.6716989279,
-1.1659040451,
-0.6349102259,
0.275721252,
-0.051287543,
0.1271977872,
0.4198952913,
0.4444167614,
0.3757196367,
0.142339915,
0.8258476853,
0.2543979883,
0.9558164477,
-0.4047470093,
0.695412755,
-0.4671732783,
0.5418164134,
0.0098180529,
-0.7602567673,
-0.3368953764,
0.8701133132,
-0.1380546391,
0.1707761139,
0.3617874682,
0.7899106741,
0.0535370149,
0.4770051539,
0.5753837228,
0.1399941891,
0.4665447474,
0.3193022013,
1.2952866554,
-0.295932889,
0.5311619639,
-0.1628831029,
-0.0700386316,
0.2023501545,
-0.4803954065,
-0.2703917921,
-0.3635661304,
-0.2791910172,
-0.1732028723,
-0.3608605862,
0.8918796182,
1.3425593376,
-0.6055670977,
-0.245774731,
-0.0030464525,
-0.0035006488,
-0.2275458872,
-0.1923623681,
0.0640291199,
-0.4951188862,
-0.8989336491,
1.2128548622,
0.4803570807,
-0.2195115238,
-0.3434878588,
-0.3032464683,
0.1258640438,
0.1010515764,
0.4861432314,
0.1716274172,
-0.9109936357,
-0.2598592043,
-0.2549943328,
-0.2082775533,
0.327349931,
0.5979202986,
-0.4596627355,
0.601074338,
0.4131699204,
0.6678302884,
0.7090469599,
-0.1176209301,
0.542802453,
-0.9613835812,
0.1704894602,
0.184256494,
0.7183564305,
0.2900981605,
-0.1903976351,
0.2212104201,
0.3923245966,
-0.4923791885,
-0.5218362808,
0.1828609705,
-0.8904281855,
-0.1668383628,
1.0702410936,
-0.3176320791,
-0.5134202242,
0.0580564216,
0.0202276278,
0.5841746926,
-0.4808692634,
0.5495011806,
0.5775619745,
-0.3071034253,
-0.266821146,
-0.0429737307,
0.3799120784,
0.2906787694,
-0.645252645,
-0.4732401371,
0.5296596289,
0.8271570802,
0.3380446434,
0.6330866814,
-0.6509914398,
0.3314523995,
-0.0251216888,
0.2060979307,
0.0812413618,
-0.7062080503,
-1.0721684694,
0.4664840102,
-0.3948188126,
-0.790148735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16917v1 | Large Language Models Are Partially Primed in Pronoun Interpretation | 2023-05-26T13:30:48 | 2023-05-26T13:30:48 | Suet-Ying Lam, Qingcheng Zeng, Kexun Zhang, Chenyu You, Rob Voigt | cs.CL | cs.CL | While a large body of literature suggests that large language models (LLMs)
acquire rich linguistic representations, little is known about whether they
adapt to linguistic biases in a human-like way. The present study probes this
question by asking whether LLMs display human-like referential biases using
stimuli and procedures from real psycholinguistic experiments. Recent
psycholinguistic studies suggest that humans adapt their referential biases
with recent exposure to referential patterns; closely replicating three
relevant psycholinguistic experiments from Johnson & Arnold (2022) in an
in-context learning (ICL) framework, we found that InstructGPT adapts its
pronominal interpretations in response to the frequency of referential patterns
in the local discourse, though in a limited fashion: adaptation was only
observed relative to syntactic but not semantic biases. By contrast, FLAN-UL2
fails to generate meaningful patterns. Our results provide further evidence
that contemporary LLMs discourse representations are sensitive to syntactic
patterns in the local context but less so to semantic patterns. Our data and
code are available at \url{https://github.com/zkx06111/llm_priming}. | [
-0.0858571231,
-0.6126183271,
0.7210618854,
0.1310495436,
-0.2821124792,
-0.4274682999,
-0.4258951545,
-0.445264101,
-0.1742941588,
0.5855576992,
-0.3295558691,
-0.1855386049,
-0.2950204313,
0.241891697,
-0.0095756063,
1.0005255938,
0.1439829767,
0.3839693069,
0.022746237,
0.0713516846,
-0.4860171676,
-0.8780044913,
-0.3630577326,
-0.5883039236,
0.2021539807,
0.4058879614,
0.8036475778,
0.3934039772,
0.376644522,
0.1873354167,
-0.0959085375,
-0.2516495883,
-0.4157803357,
0.039301347,
-0.388925612,
-0.7884505391,
-0.2165314555,
0.0971225724,
0.8886581063,
0.9336248636,
0.034127418,
0.1268864572,
0.3443330824,
0.5214553475,
-0.5875536799,
0.2952972651,
-0.7270891666,
-0.0423505418,
-0.2734545767,
-0.1342099011,
-0.8261947036,
-0.0192995016,
0.3734683096,
-0.5335600972,
0.3788933456,
0.2064898014,
0.6371961832,
0.0491823703,
-0.4974686503,
-0.2537784278,
-0.6909272075,
0.6669695377,
-0.855155468,
0.4703434408,
0.3219098449,
0.0703625381,
-0.5647992492,
-0.4674742222,
-0.5646111965,
-0.4324513972,
-0.4107059538,
0.0220186282,
-0.0275535844,
0.0887227133,
0.4204484224,
0.0473330431,
-0.5653685331,
0.2015673071,
-0.170267567,
-0.0793449879,
0.4315622747,
-0.0186240673,
0.0663498044,
-0.2164905518,
-0.5389714241,
-0.040015474,
-0.8545125127,
0.0302421134,
0.3887250423,
0.4008505642,
-0.1585248411,
0.3720704317,
0.3406022191,
1.0261005163,
0.3486065269,
-0.1468435675,
0.1493315101,
-0.0874239877,
-0.3898276091,
0.214368239,
0.7854219079,
0.4219799936,
0.8100156784,
-0.1151659116,
0.0031883225,
-0.0969451889,
0.1611981392,
-0.5596935749,
-0.3171342015,
-0.3854778707,
-0.4054031968,
-0.0196540803,
0.3729500473,
-0.5504925251,
-0.6621064544,
-0.3468327224,
0.2200731188,
-0.3670513034,
-0.3267647326,
0.397444129,
0.0119711151,
0.434212774,
0.0309683476,
-0.9478340149,
0.3845515847,
0.5415385365,
0.6706722379,
-0.1196873263,
-0.2405170351,
-0.2963656485,
0.2256810665,
-0.4029090405,
0.8041368723,
-0.8851645589,
-0.3388616443,
0.0104251159,
0.2916265726,
-0.2307078242,
-1.1703755856,
0.6719328165,
-0.4042604566,
0.2265939265,
-0.5027140975,
-0.4785517454,
-0.2757746577,
-0.238597706,
-0.4725902081,
0.6594980359,
0.1552356482,
-0.7936240435,
0.4152895808,
-0.5089671612,
-0.2312703878,
-0.2199604213,
-0.2952902019,
-0.0857847258,
0.3412966132,
0.0156115899,
0.4906836748,
-0.3669869006,
0.3234766722,
-0.1422322839,
-0.6776589751,
0.7401397824,
-0.3028893769,
0.7363343239,
-0.1497731656,
-0.4224047959,
0.155951038,
-0.5317408442,
-0.3446542025,
0.2142615914,
-0.2301858366,
-0.4965055585,
0.0221056323,
-0.0161246452,
0.3293667436,
-0.2688760459,
-0.3496454954,
0.16191338,
-0.6238387227,
0.4674416184,
0.8906632662,
0.048828695,
0.6612630486,
-0.3783082366,
0.4998971224,
0.3401507139,
-0.2672672272,
-0.1015345007,
-0.3994956911,
-0.811101079,
-0.1704165936,
0.0629515946,
0.4344373345,
-0.2626104951,
0.3690526187,
-0.2974826097,
0.0638403967,
-0.2980965674,
-0.0043505821,
0.379589051,
0.3916708231,
0.0508315787,
-0.2816053033,
-0.6704220176,
-1.4727165699,
-0.4197584391,
-0.0909606814,
-0.412057966,
0.2214813232,
0.3604022861,
0.1346390694,
0.8755466938,
-0.1784409583,
-0.4168781638,
-0.1702052504,
-0.0546386354,
0.2875108421,
0.1725689322,
0.845079124,
-0.586042285,
-0.3811557591,
-0.2928915322,
-0.4981076717,
-0.1753055453,
-0.3053603172,
-0.1681953818,
-0.1628948599,
0.5311506391,
-0.5110051632,
0.0827533677,
0.4741928875,
-0.6952152848,
0.5575668812,
0.0501975566,
-0.3677800298,
-0.9660152793,
-0.0896564052,
0.2077819109,
-0.3845246136,
-0.5618723035,
-0.1394995004,
-0.1418025047,
0.2132956088,
-0.4360923171,
0.5821498632,
-0.5571432114,
-0.3952127993,
-0.1968852729,
0.1146609336,
-0.137326017,
0.4605553448,
0.2464815378,
0.9643346667,
0.4620919526,
-0.621802032,
-0.0182664581,
-0.0106066344,
-0.5033511519,
0.459545821,
-0.5374711156,
0.3839146793,
-0.4335425496,
0.5637362599,
-0.8668700457,
-0.3786942363,
0.4971948862,
0.0780287609,
0.2365960926,
-0.0733555108,
-0.5439732671,
0.0189193729,
-0.2346328944,
0.3997810185,
0.5771017075,
-0.3919557035,
0.2015538067,
0.2549196184,
0.0030886529,
-0.2174163461,
-0.6909986138,
-0.0816958994,
-0.3502780795,
-0.1535157263,
0.2333502322,
0.0420720465,
-0.7589346766,
-0.2445639223,
0.0138292415,
0.1649861187,
-0.0687611625,
0.362562865,
0.1169802547,
-0.3255122602,
0.0119705601,
-0.4207699001,
0.0592437275,
0.3363311589,
-0.3452126682,
0.5247291923,
-0.0676176772,
-0.2393198758,
-0.5227284431,
0.0722073093,
0.6476050615,
0.1030537486,
0.5788341165,
0.321904093,
-0.3043793738,
-0.237354219,
-0.3363540471,
-0.4907341301,
-0.4120336771,
0.4176438153,
-0.4452857077,
-0.762021184,
0.4439583123,
0.0382732116,
-0.2139953226,
0.2132463157,
0.7122852206,
-0.1616706699,
0.769240737,
0.2757134736,
0.1256717891,
0.605861187,
-0.0694400445,
0.1454485059,
-1.1532031298,
0.0983093753,
-0.2614687681,
-0.4666233659,
-0.610668242,
-0.5133293271,
0.2148168087,
0.085029982,
-0.437700659,
-0.0041099233,
-0.3894743025,
0.5023924112,
0.2917764187,
0.1209179461,
0.1579304039,
0.1000106633,
0.0229232311,
-0.5379754305,
-0.6308091283,
-0.6470789313,
0.984529078,
0.3124731481,
0.6193622947,
0.1602817476,
0.1336588562,
0.1791996956,
0.6187961102,
-0.5889840126,
0.6044396162,
-0.2065266371,
-0.6121828556,
0.0956522822,
-0.004786435,
-0.9868840575,
0.4246999323,
-0.0273435544,
-1.0549857616,
0.5755684972,
0.0391363055,
-0.2984931171,
0.2300786227,
-0.6933670044,
0.6723285317,
-0.1178407669,
-0.3446807861,
0.035230834,
-0.5014059544,
0.5509054065,
-0.171071887,
0.2726542056,
-0.2171158046,
0.0017879206,
0.818203032,
-0.0559671856,
1.2107023001,
-0.2326305658,
-0.3468228579,
0.3273982406,
0.34345752,
0.5725735426,
0.0508828983,
-0.3530452549,
0.0359632857,
-0.3519260585,
-0.3462349474,
-0.5747804642,
0.6842422485,
-0.7829403281,
-0.7199782729,
-0.5403782725,
-0.7178393006,
-0.3021222353,
-0.0377130471,
0.2571560144,
0.2316090763,
-0.1771707535,
0.1460072547,
0.530198276,
-0.2034613788,
0.2446851432,
0.5324774981,
-0.3131884634,
0.1332330257,
0.4849776924,
0.004738214,
0.4551230371,
0.3614329994,
0.343467325,
-0.098459132,
-0.4211381674,
-0.3507466912,
0.5676686764,
-0.6700707078,
0.1496715248,
-0.1591586918,
0.0123053901,
-0.1723239869,
-0.1614577919,
-0.0333797187,
-0.0977269709,
-0.3977218866,
-0.1843118817,
0.2583558559,
0.8819647431,
0.2026110888,
0.390753597,
-0.328974992,
0.1910439879,
0.2178741693,
0.0457190908,
-0.0512146689,
-1.0144491196,
0.0389698856,
0.1554077417,
0.0837906897,
-1.016207695,
0.0838783309,
0.4177624583,
0.4010592103,
0.5043055415,
-0.0535176247,
0.5368537903,
-0.4944423139,
0.8825457096,
-0.0650783107,
-0.708716929,
0.3752797842,
-0.6222072244,
0.5679728985,
0.4294366241,
0.3449721634,
-0.3291807771,
-0.3044510782,
-0.5387302637,
-0.5866664052,
0.7130985856,
-0.2341199368,
0.3424988389,
-0.1377342641,
0.8576579094,
0.3898834884,
-0.0529997833,
-0.7807193995,
-0.108992964,
0.010422308,
0.0524173565,
-0.1750081927,
-0.5772081614,
0.0195547659,
-0.1736822128,
0.3791757524,
-0.2548661828,
0.4826059639,
0.1969439983,
-0.2918324471,
-0.1020685658,
0.399512589,
0.7318267226,
0.8905233741,
-0.2815243006,
0.3691472113,
0.108542271,
-0.4792501628,
0.2169062197,
-0.1645147502,
-0.4244905412,
0.2881514132,
0.700974226,
0.9063669443,
0.6416227221,
-0.6100827456,
0.5033359528,
0.2326558083,
-0.0606465153,
-0.4695159793,
0.1140175238,
0.0342385545,
0.1793546975,
0.3180409074,
-0.0149142575,
-0.0407426096,
-0.9848594069,
-0.0476817489,
0.3091222644,
-0.432549715,
-0.803984642,
0.6380944848,
-0.0920086801,
-0.3308522701,
0.5663173199,
-0.3252807558,
-0.4354635179,
0.2319124788,
0.9905208349,
0.8465051651,
-0.1918374896,
-0.0485536829,
0.3813393414,
0.059896484,
-0.0383457392,
0.2788208723,
0.1714429855,
-1.0035578012,
-0.554476738,
-0.6256930828,
-0.0716072991,
0.4114604592,
-0.6988323331,
0.2373416275,
-0.4776184857,
-0.2812102735,
0.0296306424,
-0.5049431324,
-0.6839980483,
-0.0538745821,
0.3041368127,
0.6745533347,
-0.9776979089,
0.8951525092,
1.1489270926,
-0.1383220106,
-0.6559497118,
0.4334873557,
0.0076556928,
-0.65057832,
0.9369031191,
0.0742388964,
-0.0108565046,
-0.0393041819,
-0.4033098519,
-0.7611741424,
0.6492467523,
0.919890523,
-0.7054909468,
-0.1946765631,
0.3371331394,
0.4177447855,
-0.4693154395,
0.0964379385,
0.7615330219,
0.5262115598,
-0.3348114491,
-1.1795611382,
0.262665242,
0.0514344163,
0.0299009737,
0.0360696539,
-0.6132173538,
0.8193895817,
-0.2899021804,
-0.2074214965,
-0.2000353336,
0.4416684508,
0.1760390997,
-0.1053449884,
0.5671775937,
0.204035446,
0.5264348984,
0.0310765486,
1.0123672485,
-0.1458377242,
0.0675159767,
1.3150186539,
-0.5702860951,
0.7797444463,
0.5708100796,
-0.4490253031,
0.7937946916,
0.5829440355,
0.2136180699,
0.4555186331,
0.5335555077,
-0.2294117957,
-0.344091922,
-0.3848924339,
-0.1329767108,
0.6765640974,
0.4423520267,
-0.5605026484,
-0.1024961472,
0.174104467,
0.2158846408,
0.1876415908,
-0.190246895,
0.7105469108,
0.3374492526,
-0.6210318208,
0.6038696766,
-0.1706002802,
0.6814156175,
-0.4339067042,
-0.0938614979,
0.0127172144,
0.4636904299,
-0.1966301203,
-0.66711694,
0.0813167244,
-0.2142723203,
-0.2855360806,
-0.2919586897,
0.6824486256,
-0.16117993,
-0.5144923925,
0.287145257,
0.4624154866,
0.4097485542,
-0.0329129696,
-0.4812250137,
-0.0790917501,
0.0760498941,
-0.4113657773,
0.6062099338,
0.2937876284,
-0.4536753893,
0.4350956678,
0.5121512413,
0.1591089368,
0.0262467563,
0.3610156775,
0.5427482724,
-0.5812883973,
-0.2432504445,
-0.9256867766,
0.2664353251,
0.2852041423,
-0.3261193931,
0.6874421239,
0.4978869855,
1.0405673981,
-0.2285535485,
0.7074391842,
0.194005385,
0.2419890761,
-0.6181245446,
0.3087548912,
0.0052585695,
0.1638816297,
-0.0773185715,
-1.1361029148,
-0.2885894179,
0.9169501066,
-0.5996977091,
0.0043878267,
0.6309136748,
0.6629481912,
-0.1035969481,
-0.1363514215,
0.2477330714,
0.5521216393,
-0.0270859301,
0.5605826378,
0.9074095488,
-0.1598618776,
0.0958748609,
-0.1109458283,
-0.1168166921,
-0.352768153,
-0.6779136062,
-0.876190424,
-0.5873879194,
-0.1936140656,
-0.1557092667,
0.2761059701,
1.0840426683,
0.6727710962,
-0.811847508,
-0.2939432859,
-0.0850029141,
-0.2012994289,
-0.2235403657,
-0.2706785798,
0.4479208291,
-0.0043887179,
-0.7414446473,
0.4582607448,
0.062990278,
0.0631521493,
-0.3600204289,
0.0142705841,
-0.200358361,
-0.1676021069,
0.5822885633,
-0.0543156043,
-0.9684135318,
-0.6685628295,
0.1204036325,
0.0462308936,
0.2596055269,
1.1620938778,
-0.9546195865,
0.3168091476,
0.3152790368,
0.0528827272,
0.1149776652,
0.0413855202,
0.7662115097,
-0.7167434692,
0.613827467,
0.2954062819,
0.4516339302,
0.3859751225,
-0.3228801489,
0.3360053599,
0.2386499792,
-0.427301228,
-0.8116992712,
0.3941928744,
-0.7940084934,
-0.2975054979,
1.5565133095,
0.0226295553,
-0.0616922826,
-0.1314053982,
-0.3676905334,
0.0891018733,
-0.2275548428,
0.5210257173,
0.791000545,
-0.3696094751,
-0.0927202925,
-1.0226038694,
0.4736235142,
0.5165023804,
-0.2207012773,
0.3207044899,
0.440413475,
0.3478729725,
-0.0083487369,
0.5707591772,
0.0869794562,
0.1775218397,
-0.2615329325,
-0.0924909785,
0.2573445737,
-0.0177947655,
-0.4966560304,
-0.1062673256,
0.5928287506,
0.0552211292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18239v1 | A Study on Knowledge Distillation from Weak Teacher for Scaling Up Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-05-26T13:24:49 | 2023-05-26T13:24:49 | Hayeon Lee, Rui Hou, Jongpil Kim, Davis Liang, Sung Ju Hwang, Alexander Min | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Distillation from Weak Teacher (DWT) is a method of transferring knowledge
from a smaller, weaker teacher model to a larger student model to improve its
performance. Previous studies have shown that DWT can be effective in the
vision domain and natural language processing (NLP) pre-training stage.
Specifically, DWT shows promise in practical scenarios, such as enhancing new
generation or larger models using pre-trained yet older or smaller models and
lacking a resource budget. However, the optimal conditions for using DWT have
yet to be fully investigated in NLP pre-training. Therefore, this study
examines three key factors to optimize DWT, distinct from those used in the
vision domain or traditional knowledge distillation. These factors are: (i) the
impact of teacher model quality on DWT effectiveness, (ii) guidelines for
adjusting the weighting value for DWT loss, and (iii) the impact of parameter
remapping as a student model initialization technique for DWT. | [
-0.59757936,
-0.5178596377,
0.5117768049,
-0.1598108113,
-0.5586876273,
0.1506567895,
-0.2570779324,
-0.0785376281,
-0.212898612,
0.3447262049,
-0.0709073767,
-0.1044313014,
-1.2073754072,
0.048779998,
-0.6609820127,
1.1484525204,
-0.0779728815,
0.2668924034,
-0.1726132631,
0.0916204005,
-0.7393233776,
-0.4544362128,
-0.6715380549,
-0.7222365737,
0.4162436128,
0.6451346874,
0.8538069725,
0.3678664267,
0.6764426827,
0.2925306559,
-0.3374372125,
-0.1933186054,
-0.7706229687,
-0.0265778974,
-0.3347579837,
-0.6817023754,
-0.3935904503,
0.2106103301,
0.5519512892,
1.0534687042,
-0.332013607,
0.2974017262,
0.4952273965,
0.7944780588,
-0.6018685699,
-0.0397425331,
-0.8971061707,
-0.0712471679,
-0.1582430154,
0.1042917967,
-0.1144912839,
-0.3255878687,
0.7215671539,
-0.3961907625,
0.3966648281,
-0.1010998413,
0.9834521413,
0.439874053,
-0.6886830926,
-0.1899968386,
-0.7376512885,
0.9510676265,
-0.7811464071,
0.2852343917,
0.5446514487,
0.3177708685,
-0.1893830448,
-1.0477297306,
-0.8261094093,
0.0017564092,
-0.1594514996,
-0.04685729,
-0.0509507433,
0.1391390264,
0.2117696851,
0.7173382044,
0.142494455,
0.1207623705,
-0.628382206,
0.063120015,
0.2836223543,
0.0606100857,
0.1179432273,
-0.1481399089,
-0.3846414685,
-0.3275044858,
-0.2622371316,
-0.2572321892,
0.305203259,
0.5142830014,
0.025783129,
0.3748049438,
0.0027962928,
0.8860808015,
0.1436770707,
-0.7422301173,
-0.0908349827,
-0.349393487,
-0.040941827,
0.0872533619,
0.3659791946,
0.2551034987,
0.5061379671,
0.0045036813,
-0.3442267179,
-0.1936647445,
0.4443051517,
-0.9715696573,
-0.4220460951,
-0.276843518,
-0.5162167549,
-0.7060253024,
-0.2948997319,
-0.7210006118,
-0.266568929,
-0.6487135291,
0.5914763808,
-0.2726768255,
-0.7867312431,
-0.0478862114,
-0.5073338747,
0.0143267,
0.2594508827,
-1.1587167978,
0.4492239058,
0.2729889154,
0.7691968083,
-0.2104733139,
-0.4039047956,
0.1140756533,
0.0120946942,
-0.094515115,
0.2692000866,
-0.0874334648,
-0.4700086117,
-0.2296728492,
-0.4704537392,
0.0409499966,
-0.5482687354,
0.5226313472,
-0.404176414,
0.2008921653,
-0.1856015623,
-0.5945042372,
-0.0421891883,
0.1551989019,
-0.5245863795,
1.0241901875,
0.3726830184,
-1.0673015118,
0.8623957038,
-0.1937726438,
-0.519018054,
0.0592333078,
0.0379987545,
-0.2465982884,
0.4988904297,
0.2370222211,
0.4565008283,
-0.4485180676,
0.4984453917,
-0.0479151011,
-0.4478877187,
-0.1590644866,
-0.6995265484,
0.7644774914,
0.256803602,
-0.3483553529,
-0.4553141892,
-1.0368177891,
0.0557866506,
0.194332242,
-0.5580288768,
-0.7787561417,
-0.1370970756,
-0.1526297331,
-0.1155473962,
0.1734389514,
-0.317247957,
0.4109542966,
-0.4304238856,
0.300889194,
0.6922209859,
0.0338968001,
0.4761084318,
0.1190327927,
0.3336769342,
0.1491034776,
0.2524630129,
0.2742700875,
-0.284209758,
-0.9586158991,
-0.091321364,
0.4547612071,
0.0608861707,
-1.1125459671,
-0.1179834679,
-0.3032079041,
-0.623219192,
-0.6438847184,
0.2968730927,
0.2667132318,
1.0630443096,
0.5146219134,
-0.0919516906,
-0.5010342598,
-0.66364187,
-0.1704549342,
-0.300994128,
0.0020093475,
-0.2206501365,
0.4504492879,
0.0276549421,
1.0882074833,
-0.8510403037,
-0.4905140698,
-0.495138675,
0.0915094241,
0.4314290285,
0.3132054508,
0.8004956841,
-0.9648527503,
-0.6784554124,
-0.3308695853,
-0.4973499477,
0.090079695,
0.3692441881,
-0.0724742413,
-0.1075448915,
0.3260090053,
-0.2859305739,
0.5778401494,
0.7993622422,
-0.2546337247,
0.4316271842,
-0.3697149754,
0.2307405025,
-1.1584361792,
-0.1664575636,
-0.2130406201,
-0.1374966949,
-0.7591837645,
-0.1235751212,
-0.1236611456,
-0.2323945016,
-0.5147470832,
0.2366116345,
-0.4403741658,
0.4451967478,
-0.7061625123,
0.4117638767,
0.1965847909,
0.3396696746,
-0.0258169957,
0.4739134312,
0.6766802669,
-0.7797760963,
0.4374730587,
0.0200153049,
-0.4038117826,
0.6972250342,
-0.9181858897,
-0.0171412118,
-0.088091664,
-0.2232938409,
-1.0082983971,
0.3455234766,
-0.2049358636,
-0.1795964241,
0.7315608263,
-0.425822407,
-0.3997680843,
-0.5738286972,
0.1752831936,
0.2204010636,
0.7267014384,
-0.6019902229,
0.5271546841,
0.2878416479,
0.149841547,
-0.5806134939,
-0.841445148,
0.0900811553,
-0.3876541555,
-0.33237198,
0.423604846,
0.3951539695,
-0.3376281857,
0.1299287975,
-0.3539930284,
-0.3520623147,
0.2192780972,
-0.0825295597,
0.1595903635,
-0.0017515619,
0.0497909375,
0.0312870815,
-0.1553287804,
-0.0629319698,
-0.38671121,
0.3300101757,
0.0276642758,
-0.1751988977,
-0.4409572482,
-0.0941867307,
0.5184644461,
0.158155784,
1.1217089891,
0.6897795796,
-0.129114449,
-0.2918906808,
-0.5110635757,
-0.5215597749,
-0.491309911,
0.4535084963,
-0.5556566715,
-0.4694833159,
0.2925094068,
-0.3030424714,
-0.0251561888,
0.3960078359,
0.4306866527,
0.0405282937,
0.7917307615,
0.9639967084,
-0.1862498969,
0.6025018692,
-0.3001153469,
0.3635561764,
-0.6452251673,
-0.0457160994,
-0.4955751598,
-0.4838109016,
-0.3940265477,
-0.2811529934,
0.2282546014,
0.5469126105,
0.0791928843,
0.351711452,
-0.6307435036,
0.4056616426,
0.6932080388,
-0.0242608394,
0.4296263754,
-0.0093015051,
-0.267480731,
-0.062664941,
-0.8855373859,
-0.4440483451,
1.4002591372,
0.4125357568,
0.9493716359,
0.2232137322,
0.9119061232,
-0.0927382708,
0.2724634707,
-0.6347180009,
0.3966455162,
-0.2638824284,
-0.8323861361,
-0.6875052452,
-0.5919600725,
-0.783728838,
0.6374078393,
-0.2428490967,
-0.3134740293,
-0.0177496728,
0.3278901875,
0.0365107022,
0.4426485002,
-1.1547744274,
0.7731235623,
-0.2395386696,
-0.0825062171,
-0.2780965567,
-0.4584185481,
0.279214561,
-0.2792170048,
0.1342447102,
-0.0854249522,
0.2397859693,
0.7789229751,
-0.8171585798,
0.7628065944,
-0.6968319416,
-0.2040989846,
0.4494413137,
-0.1599543989,
0.4035882354,
-0.0655543953,
0.0622235797,
0.3414127231,
0.1119046658,
-0.431401521,
-0.7538989186,
0.4350087345,
-1.0565235615,
-0.9532034397,
-0.2505585253,
-0.1600615531,
-0.3105656505,
0.3569141924,
0.299790293,
0.3897178471,
0.1449803859,
0.2970273197,
0.5860287547,
0.1342862397,
0.4740200937,
0.6095647216,
-0.3219434917,
-0.2353313118,
0.7031080127,
0.4878481328,
0.5920196772,
0.2376483679,
0.5926986337,
-0.2376665473,
-1.0386664867,
-0.3112604916,
-0.1800155938,
-0.8745650053,
-0.2526142895,
-0.1847617775,
-0.0491316952,
-0.5724797249,
0.085085772,
-0.709847033,
-0.345176518,
-0.4374703765,
-0.1790528744,
0.4687466025,
0.6389205456,
0.1619544923,
0.4639053643,
-0.4823056161,
0.3839423954,
0.4614545107,
0.391464293,
0.3495398462,
-0.9326089025,
-0.4695645273,
0.1056144238,
-0.2218874097,
-0.7709256411,
0.1500823349,
0.3169507384,
0.739541769,
0.4648178518,
0.3167722523,
1.0522645712,
-0.3969989717,
0.7558178902,
0.4754030704,
-1.0008106232,
0.836745739,
0.073669225,
0.4604099989,
0.8883995414,
0.5515643954,
-0.2052926421,
-0.511808455,
-0.4419668913,
-1.054035902,
0.5565707684,
0.1748512238,
0.3735582829,
0.2205023319,
0.6505052447,
0.084982343,
0.2757725716,
-0.6415162086,
-0.5819194913,
-0.3899136484,
-0.1976271719,
-0.205863595,
-0.3929994404,
-0.0591787547,
-0.6512543559,
0.5444752574,
0.0757305622,
-0.463887006,
0.0233772863,
-0.2057442367,
0.2455701828,
0.0003247833,
0.1848758608,
0.8306455016,
-0.0843519717,
0.5396280885,
0.4991604984,
-1.1475422382,
0.3465036452,
-0.2618017793,
0.0250500254,
-0.0933619216,
0.5208609104,
0.8608437181,
0.3316380084,
-0.1716914624,
0.5459192395,
-0.1731386036,
-0.2676196694,
-0.0358924344,
0.1812584549,
-0.1331589371,
-0.014161936,
0.5865646005,
-0.1344092637,
-0.0459322631,
-0.3799952865,
0.0881128609,
-0.1845577806,
-0.2232714295,
-0.0987908393,
0.5875540972,
0.3728049994,
0.1351515651,
1.0169196129,
0.026297776,
-0.3917409778,
0.1691065729,
0.5155472755,
0.5392801166,
-0.2595398128,
0.0293039083,
0.3506022692,
0.2509866953,
-0.1641648561,
-0.1058166474,
-0.1403133273,
-0.8687828183,
-0.3259857297,
-0.9635139704,
-0.197406888,
-0.1688578576,
-0.9385546446,
0.586815238,
-0.2978733182,
-0.6244747639,
-0.0237487908,
0.2939631343,
-0.9269296527,
0.3268036246,
-0.0377073251,
0.5529454947,
-0.7490668893,
1.1449644566,
0.5869036913,
-0.5803607106,
-1.3527876139,
0.024552362,
-0.1157679483,
-0.889075458,
1.1631823778,
-0.455946207,
-0.0378467627,
0.2426110208,
-0.1085498855,
-1.0320330858,
1.0943260193,
0.4807068706,
-0.8314960003,
-0.0709949359,
0.1885284185,
0.6312380433,
0.0892643481,
0.1039936543,
0.6657016873,
0.3178168833,
0.5357615352,
-1.1741812229,
0.0279259831,
0.1831317693,
0.3016869128,
0.2602469027,
-0.3999482095,
0.9087230563,
-0.2833586335,
-0.1099641845,
-0.5543556213,
0.6551281214,
-0.1430725157,
0.0369600803,
0.7124081254,
0.8132249713,
0.67163831,
-0.1389773786,
0.7334452271,
-0.2388489693,
0.3565057218,
1.0052803755,
-0.0073746312,
0.7436323166,
0.9800651073,
-0.5294246078,
0.4467816949,
0.3096112013,
-0.0254584663,
0.7545051575,
0.4794872105,
-0.0916920155,
0.2293013036,
0.1828668714,
-0.4610320926,
0.6678583026,
-0.0746834502,
-0.2645267248,
-0.1621087939,
0.5679136515,
0.1497920305,
0.0270628091,
-0.5717333555,
0.8818203211,
0.1751879901,
-0.6913198233,
0.8355752826,
-0.117128022,
0.6797358394,
-0.4823277593,
0.1610564739,
-0.2203186005,
0.4930939376,
-0.1188662946,
-0.6481381059,
0.4136266112,
0.0175337624,
-0.2388793081,
-0.5263134241,
0.9408224225,
-0.4312058985,
-0.3844589293,
0.223551929,
0.4578107595,
0.3031116724,
-0.0434212759,
-0.4695360661,
0.0619100332,
-0.0721744671,
-0.5595421791,
0.5377947688,
0.6794630885,
0.4423552155,
0.5115149021,
0.3070169091,
0.3801212311,
-0.0156279858,
0.638763845,
1.0554839373,
-0.3399997354,
-0.1926661581,
-1.0038855076,
0.5418774486,
-0.0232368447,
-0.3309808373,
1.2960250378,
0.1390090883,
0.8539098501,
0.0453932844,
0.4765072763,
-0.1166539267,
0.3385495245,
-0.3246623278,
0.8882120252,
-0.583055079,
0.1031983495,
-0.5911207795,
-1.037263155,
0.1500792205,
0.5242500305,
-0.1959985197,
0.1058320329,
0.6167524457,
0.2518189251,
0.3084413707,
-0.1434742808,
0.5820804238,
-0.0404763259,
0.3420593143,
0.2364538163,
0.6977676749,
-0.4761879444,
0.7021459341,
-0.4071876705,
-0.3331858218,
-0.0100077568,
-0.8297153711,
-1.0529203415,
-0.6660975218,
-0.473495841,
-0.1780251861,
-0.2319440842,
0.3407460153,
0.883820951,
-0.3505999148,
-0.0813104138,
-0.3350714743,
0.2265432179,
-0.1773261875,
-0.2402380407,
0.2907565832,
-0.5422258973,
-0.8666374683,
0.0159183331,
-0.1798674315,
0.5605900884,
-0.5886796713,
0.2039663345,
-0.0264428686,
-0.1601001173,
0.5595015883,
-0.3154072464,
-0.3601637185,
-0.3346295953,
-0.4020356834,
-0.002512228,
-0.4483428895,
0.8470229506,
-0.7086412311,
0.4892450273,
0.2979433537,
0.1889900118,
0.721347332,
-0.2337986976,
0.6576256156,
-1.0180339813,
0.5671305656,
0.2437032014,
0.1817174405,
0.1418839991,
-0.0955490842,
0.3559053838,
0.4545063078,
-0.4540553391,
-1.0455118418,
-0.0363197923,
-0.4952799976,
-0.4297718704,
0.9192757607,
-0.2383326888,
-0.0453983769,
-0.1051846519,
-0.1483552456,
0.3845696151,
0.0719362795,
0.8345758319,
0.8877301216,
0.1107342094,
-0.1541588157,
-0.3751033545,
0.6178503036,
0.2256855816,
-0.2662556171,
0.039907299,
-0.0585032776,
0.4665710926,
0.0982056782,
0.5846166611,
-0.0639747605,
-0.513697803,
0.6118102074,
0.0192700792,
-0.177141428,
-0.3189067841,
0.108233422,
0.3686573803,
0.3644056916,
-0.2123349607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16897v1 | Inter-connection: Effective Connection between Pre-trained Encoder and Decoder for Speech Translation | 2023-05-26T13:01:29 | 2023-05-26T13:01:29 | Yuta Nishikawa, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In end-to-end speech translation, speech and text pre-trained models improve
translation quality. Recently proposed models simply connect the pre-trained
models of speech and text as encoder and decoder. Therefore, only the
information from the final layer of encoders is input to the decoder. Since it
is clear that the speech pre-trained model outputs different information from
each layer, the simple connection method cannot fully utilize the information
that the speech pre-trained model has. In this study, we propose an
inter-connection mechanism that aggregates the information from each layer of
the speech pre-trained model by weighted sums and inputs into the decoder. This
mechanism increased BLEU by approximately 2 points in en-de, en-ja, and en-zh
by increasing parameters by 2K when the speech pre-trained model was frozen.
Furthermore, we investigated the contribution of each layer for each language
by visualizing layer weights and found that the contributions were different. | [
-0.4954487979,
-0.7014770508,
0.2982879877,
0.049487602,
-0.5997570753,
-0.1230207831,
-0.1923959255,
-0.5608199239,
0.1510958821,
0.3661703169,
-0.2117819786,
-0.0522171892,
-0.7213517427,
0.1043247432,
-0.5832175612,
0.8606952429,
0.2512570918,
0.2062336504,
-0.4000769556,
0.0437359139,
-0.2907367647,
-0.5469923615,
-0.6394774318,
-0.6175483465,
0.440779537,
0.1576565057,
0.6554554105,
0.5254855752,
0.5748841166,
0.4105454087,
-0.0411725268,
-0.1789129674,
-0.4832625091,
0.0566741899,
-0.1334285587,
-0.6345921755,
-0.5450561047,
-0.1482217163,
0.8437569141,
0.6804722548,
0.0072722221,
0.2743897438,
0.2665664554,
0.7442960143,
-0.5564853549,
-0.0655785799,
-0.5973969102,
-0.3145162463,
-0.4674058557,
-0.5200176239,
-0.4031464458,
-0.204354465,
0.1062250286,
-0.1969761848,
-0.0814476013,
-0.3286638856,
1.1570634842,
0.498408705,
-0.3926386535,
-0.169360429,
-0.7897441983,
0.2018438131,
-0.8659712076,
0.6146751642,
0.5482209325,
0.1070815101,
0.0834862441,
-0.6186591983,
-0.6416655183,
-0.1289769709,
-0.1407344341,
0.3164530993,
-0.1092098206,
0.1461824328,
0.0831756592,
0.1358355731,
-0.3860682249,
0.193264544,
-0.455344528,
-0.0796927139,
0.5276195407,
-0.2024877071,
0.5858129263,
0.1837212741,
-0.1125912443,
-0.10741321,
-0.5618633032,
0.286008209,
0.4413280189,
0.3490132689,
-0.4324688017,
0.6225554347,
0.0114990445,
1.1161899567,
0.2414819747,
-0.2317215204,
0.3893128932,
-0.4846916497,
-0.1608327925,
0.5687826276,
0.7146232128,
0.0386103652,
0.4041089118,
-0.1524416208,
-0.0345302187,
-0.1056391522,
0.0578255802,
-0.8990874887,
-0.1095206663,
0.1292267591,
-0.5151745677,
0.096924603,
0.1574493796,
-0.196168229,
0.3380482495,
-0.4064531922,
0.7697425485,
-0.4029833972,
-0.3695414364,
0.0734726042,
0.0604004376,
0.3441687524,
0.1342004389,
-0.9045966864,
0.5254496336,
0.0864281803,
0.882101953,
0.2294887304,
-0.4207024276,
-0.6981418133,
0.3651313186,
-0.2158486247,
0.6410279274,
-0.4742123783,
-0.0192582365,
-0.1517046094,
0.040177539,
-0.3003118634,
-0.3276562691,
0.3693386316,
-0.4989101589,
0.1650745571,
-0.2969411016,
-0.6848368645,
-0.1679855585,
-0.2097970247,
-0.5876948833,
0.5425459146,
-0.0680047125,
-0.8830583096,
0.0763052627,
-0.3440514505,
-0.6260547042,
0.2572051585,
-0.0783673823,
-0.2305117697,
0.1840230972,
0.3939200342,
0.4192176163,
-0.3454773724,
0.135651052,
-0.1104382277,
-0.3069401979,
0.5069465637,
-0.1508079618,
0.8955151439,
0.2850800455,
0.168039158,
-0.021466516,
-0.7153941989,
-0.1397854835,
0.0717777386,
-0.7035676241,
-0.4377318621,
-0.1183906123,
-0.1757481098,
0.3858284354,
0.3256358802,
-0.4192937016,
-0.2424524128,
-0.5578922033,
0.5933941603,
0.2651206553,
-0.1270593256,
0.5926222205,
-0.0798023716,
0.3255270422,
0.290930599,
-0.2682732046,
-0.3335763812,
-0.2800634801,
-0.7147920132,
0.1033109501,
0.6127027273,
0.8136499524,
-0.6612641811,
0.5723241568,
-0.3982786238,
-0.3579892516,
-0.8008537292,
-0.1738302112,
0.4884808958,
0.7732015848,
0.5035203099,
-0.3248072863,
-0.0958952084,
-0.6467231512,
-0.3407521546,
-0.0913823918,
-0.133774817,
-0.0896937251,
0.3446371555,
0.1954915971,
0.6678142548,
-0.1639628708,
-0.2446516156,
-0.2221168429,
-0.2306271791,
0.3451415896,
0.6913881898,
0.7894629836,
-0.5871448517,
-0.6281017065,
0.2242708355,
-0.553760469,
-0.175240472,
-0.0015490821,
-0.2861875892,
-0.2910927534,
0.738990128,
-0.4976738989,
0.3069838583,
0.7355508208,
-0.0981464833,
0.2530433834,
-0.374853462,
0.4122234285,
-1.127050519,
0.0388377681,
-0.1758022755,
-0.1807120889,
-1.0461544991,
-0.1745304912,
0.131805554,
-0.2367275506,
-0.4641104341,
0.2377350032,
-0.5217581391,
-0.1880121678,
-0.1233549193,
0.4754395783,
-0.0802035034,
0.415353328,
-0.243293643,
0.7683944106,
0.7756414413,
-0.6763785481,
0.3811617792,
0.2855718136,
-0.2893513441,
0.4182532132,
-0.9302372932,
0.2678773403,
-0.1897424906,
0.057254307,
-1.1095371246,
-0.1069784313,
0.0237715226,
-0.8185256124,
0.3927617073,
-0.2442182899,
-0.2222274095,
0.0971280187,
0.1762858927,
0.6802916527,
0.3630052805,
-0.3834061921,
0.6031720042,
0.4613583982,
-0.3868466914,
-0.3554833531,
-1.1489906311,
0.107672058,
-0.0541442297,
-0.9008728266,
0.5745153427,
0.0081431195,
0.0144320875,
0.1936111748,
0.0809500217,
-0.2303001136,
-0.1451842636,
-0.1224616989,
-0.1613189578,
-0.2848471701,
0.108504422,
0.4935300648,
-0.1146836281,
0.1133340895,
-0.359798789,
0.7138600349,
0.0987304226,
-0.3305061162,
-0.4915979207,
0.4631853998,
0.4283564389,
-0.5456195474,
1.1179554462,
0.4954299033,
-0.3224171102,
0.1266840547,
-0.4230906069,
-0.0671120733,
-0.4810708165,
0.4466300309,
-0.806522727,
-0.7918028831,
0.5705615878,
-0.0254844502,
-0.1408688426,
0.2200310528,
0.3194311559,
-0.1171215251,
0.9563574195,
0.5813771486,
0.0186696555,
0.6391656995,
0.0597500019,
0.2434017956,
-0.9148513079,
-0.2953632474,
-0.755186379,
-0.1136985421,
-0.3248052001,
-0.1795884967,
0.1746899486,
0.7670448422,
-0.1041955724,
0.3475490808,
-0.2340442389,
0.2766160667,
0.538713634,
0.2744907737,
0.1167582348,
0.2315027118,
-0.0756846443,
0.0713279247,
-0.8002399206,
-0.1156342253,
0.5901329517,
0.2444915026,
0.7041707635,
0.3426917493,
0.6429725885,
-0.0234136563,
-0.3963194191,
-0.5383610725,
0.5590859652,
-0.4460527897,
-0.0238177609,
-0.3903204203,
-0.6417620182,
-0.8929175735,
0.253334403,
-0.3966554105,
-0.5631474257,
0.3069573641,
0.4393001199,
0.0561996177,
0.0944762155,
-0.7604997158,
0.4320163429,
-0.3162868321,
-0.2959107757,
-0.3515988886,
-0.8786106706,
0.0594045371,
-0.0922006294,
0.0861486793,
0.1380964369,
0.2847215533,
0.8199723363,
-0.582501173,
0.3291366696,
0.0486695394,
-0.1820201427,
0.1726810783,
-0.0396314301,
0.4322655797,
-0.2298939377,
-0.0204316992,
0.4390595853,
-0.2465548515,
-0.4088407457,
-0.4929207265,
0.1851632148,
-0.9757865667,
-0.4619059265,
-0.0218834896,
-0.3207940161,
-0.0243745297,
0.2092736512,
0.6528436542,
0.7460941672,
0.0483540334,
0.3027305007,
0.5156162977,
-0.2829264998,
0.5706400871,
0.3889654577,
-0.0816897377,
-0.4939899147,
0.6310708523,
0.3378761709,
0.8144980073,
0.7929878831,
0.1881227791,
-0.188199386,
-0.649733305,
-0.4312099516,
0.3407086134,
-0.6317824721,
-0.1162663475,
-0.6942536235,
-0.6328734756,
-0.7233683467,
-0.1718692034,
-0.2932361662,
-0.1916032881,
-0.0658213049,
-0.1347829849,
0.244527936,
0.2375825047,
-0.1478911936,
0.7668905854,
-0.9487994909,
0.4232916832,
0.4948451817,
0.0884446651,
0.161150381,
-0.7837685943,
-0.7722876072,
0.2616028488,
0.3859896362,
-1.049189806,
0.3733002543,
0.4756968915,
0.5794298053,
0.4698334634,
-0.1284686178,
0.9278491139,
-0.5223183036,
0.5685711503,
0.460978508,
-1.4108196497,
0.6636323333,
-0.0869961753,
0.8269074559,
0.2810558379,
0.2121865451,
-0.2022790015,
-0.4251590669,
-0.074143894,
-0.8160616755,
0.9149737358,
0.460822463,
-0.0950461179,
0.2458483726,
0.3272520602,
-0.2240606844,
0.0990596265,
-0.6366709471,
-0.2138364166,
-0.4199208319,
-0.1019681767,
-0.0738218352,
-0.3395001888,
0.1086136624,
-0.3508788347,
0.4812736809,
0.111463815,
0.256593883,
0.1156465188,
-0.5472795963,
-0.177417323,
0.1230968162,
0.5045169592,
0.5628686547,
-0.1344750971,
0.3123424649,
0.2122699171,
-0.8059409261,
0.0778097585,
0.0426352657,
-0.2222185731,
-0.1343384981,
0.6718955636,
1.1668698788,
-0.0687412918,
0.0063525909,
0.3302416503,
-0.1218881309,
-0.2397185564,
0.0652192533,
-0.0085220616,
0.2854749858,
0.2077894211,
0.2147817165,
0.1953415275,
-0.1618787646,
-0.4884377122,
0.2681720555,
0.1656176895,
-0.2945506871,
-0.4885084331,
0.7063550949,
0.5182616115,
-0.483266294,
0.7425631285,
0.2243102938,
-0.3603757918,
0.4926201403,
0.9403809905,
0.6548336744,
-0.8197753429,
0.008730324,
0.4466443658,
0.5303257108,
0.0469369963,
0.1869821697,
-0.2077385783,
-0.9334773421,
-0.8682656884,
-0.7223827243,
0.103948012,
-0.0475085415,
-0.8152330518,
0.2455743998,
0.1760500073,
-0.1824644059,
-0.33043167,
-0.2312972695,
-0.7702680826,
0.3183824122,
0.0942579657,
0.4402531385,
-0.8604013324,
1.2167758942,
0.5873671174,
-0.5911176205,
-0.8702090383,
0.0498818345,
-0.4831880629,
-0.6217032075,
0.6834498644,
-0.0025159088,
-0.5457395315,
0.4451139271,
-0.3648642004,
-1.2171003819,
0.7738106251,
0.7414742708,
-0.8407251239,
0.0636560172,
0.3426987231,
0.2920126319,
-0.4072751701,
0.312199384,
0.140051797,
0.2250157744,
-0.093788974,
-1.0329155922,
0.0126002179,
-0.3478510678,
-0.0076923724,
0.3332136273,
-0.4145573974,
1.0272890329,
-0.1293059289,
-0.5430725813,
-0.3261779547,
0.7880957127,
-0.0794489235,
-0.1494083256,
0.5522717237,
0.5504387021,
0.3439558446,
0.0757293776,
0.633723557,
-0.454772681,
0.0624332353,
1.215852499,
0.0053933281,
0.8055585027,
0.3005875051,
-0.1768950373,
0.2681377232,
0.3463217616,
0.2856007516,
0.765190661,
0.0311518926,
-0.1965770423,
-0.1950546503,
-0.0794984624,
-0.6929946542,
0.3528058827,
0.5143390894,
-0.1492153406,
-0.0822523609,
0.275685966,
-0.0404861346,
-0.0195068866,
-0.3077892065,
0.9294636846,
0.2033565789,
-0.5181686282,
0.6798523068,
-0.2071751505,
0.3339163661,
-0.827847302,
0.0074995565,
-0.1284370869,
-0.0618931465,
-0.3978875577,
-0.6328251362,
0.1504743546,
-0.1496485919,
-0.0406161621,
0.0142125906,
0.7066295743,
-0.9832101464,
-0.313139081,
0.6738703251,
0.6458339095,
0.4047581553,
0.0576395318,
-0.5593252778,
0.0970348939,
-0.1206013113,
-0.211167872,
0.4310366511,
0.5493841171,
0.2405561507,
0.3755969703,
0.86975348,
0.3804724216,
0.3880878389,
0.5896367431,
0.7843694091,
-0.4620506465,
-0.6549186707,
-0.9488887191,
0.6919842958,
-0.0080190711,
-0.1464526206,
0.5739480853,
0.2857410908,
1.0924249887,
0.0174136423,
0.6029750109,
-0.0299125891,
0.1575679034,
-0.7368229032,
0.8144233227,
-0.4796229303,
0.0873307586,
-0.3602867424,
-1.1774882078,
-0.0301692709,
0.6140568852,
0.1255148351,
-0.1154089347,
0.7742199898,
0.7040635347,
-0.1026476026,
-0.4253762662,
0.5297733545,
0.2860595882,
0.2610361576,
0.3321709633,
0.5443119407,
-0.4383286238,
0.5645689964,
-0.1443407089,
-0.2827013433,
-0.0349229164,
-0.7538149953,
-0.9725170732,
-0.8782035708,
-0.3391983211,
-0.2211019546,
0.0964647457,
0.4670877457,
0.7407218218,
-0.4003230929,
-0.4920723736,
-0.1950230002,
-0.1883132309,
-0.3528884947,
-0.1176622063,
0.3442578912,
-0.2260797024,
-0.5081578493,
0.5105041265,
0.3410333395,
0.0532885455,
-0.0274561886,
-0.0859561339,
-0.3869891167,
0.2809649706,
0.6976258159,
0.04147017,
-0.5293464661,
-0.02855023,
-0.4076466858,
0.16161111,
0.0115927979,
0.8329091072,
-0.7228758931,
0.4524863958,
0.8936605453,
0.67677176,
0.805074811,
0.052243676,
0.7406999469,
-0.7230891585,
0.4796770811,
-0.1606000811,
0.3749274015,
0.2669506073,
-0.3318292499,
0.181256935,
-0.1907735616,
-0.5386789441,
-0.6295086741,
0.3907451332,
-0.7911248803,
-0.2878017426,
0.5201221108,
-0.2341790795,
-0.2446506172,
-0.0537838973,
0.047896333,
0.7342413068,
-0.2516986728,
0.3069561124,
0.5360420346,
-0.1159243584,
-0.5372385979,
-0.3758880198,
0.2936680615,
0.2714967728,
-0.8082327843,
-0.3228073418,
0.0971050337,
0.0328733772,
0.107289277,
0.7182546854,
-0.1171987355,
-0.1726442873,
0.1665383428,
-0.0405464172,
-0.1265143007,
-0.3690564036,
-0.3465937376,
0.0491972789,
-0.1529335678,
-0.38304618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16896v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16896v1 | MultiTool-CoT: GPT-3 Can Use Multiple External Tools with Chain of Thought Prompting | 2023-05-26T13:00:58 | 2023-05-26T13:00:58 | Tatsuro Inaba, Hirokazu Kiyomaru, Fei Cheng, Sadao Kurohashi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance on various
reasoning tasks. To further improve the performance, we propose MultiTool-CoT,
a novel framework that leverages chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting to
incorporate multiple external tools, such as a calculator and a knowledge
retriever, during the reasoning process. We apply MultiTool-CoT to the Task 2
dataset of NumGLUE, which requires both numerical reasoning and domain-specific
knowledge. The experiments show that our method significantly outperforms
strong baselines and achieves state-of-the-art performance. | [
-0.8383458257,
-0.9269945621,
0.8310795426,
0.1810536385,
-0.3999805748,
0.2751735449,
-0.2824318707,
-0.3906086981,
-0.1385031044,
0.5325995088,
-0.5844974518,
-0.4353075922,
-0.7048364282,
0.2012475878,
-0.1363852769,
0.9738411307,
-0.2183729857,
0.0996051133,
-0.0051085916,
-0.0525478683,
-0.7261700034,
-0.6649528146,
-0.6771500111,
-0.452172488,
0.6279009581,
0.4242564738,
0.7433546782,
-0.2076121718,
0.3197935522,
0.1834112108,
0.1585927606,
0.4916919172,
-0.2362632155,
0.2210847586,
-0.3159125447,
-0.5188062191,
-0.5187519193,
-0.1424852908,
0.1654044688,
0.1063655019,
-0.1503908336,
0.063832283,
0.1125326976,
0.739992559,
-0.7554630041,
0.0048199841,
-0.6779538393,
-0.041563049,
0.2329522818,
-0.2205288261,
-0.6356055737,
-0.6036154628,
0.13329418,
-0.5568758249,
0.1220450699,
-0.2362385094,
0.2629467845,
0.2313791364,
-0.5869071484,
-0.3426578939,
-0.5139781833,
0.5163318515,
-0.5770764351,
0.3792435229,
0.4792224467,
0.3949314654,
-0.1445105523,
-0.7208535075,
-0.5096389055,
-0.180156365,
-0.0105943894,
0.0700113103,
0.1640455723,
0.0104619702,
0.5411685109,
0.1818192303,
-0.4000186026,
-0.4077239037,
-0.3171181083,
-0.1653172225,
0.3381845653,
0.0448115505,
0.040334519,
0.1387784779,
-0.5356945992,
-0.1065500304,
-1.0085368156,
-0.3204750717,
0.0783951208,
0.2605990469,
-0.0198393874,
0.5995081067,
-0.0388785899,
0.7850503325,
-0.1793881059,
-0.13356933,
0.1460531503,
-0.5099214315,
-0.3563919961,
0.0070257792,
0.5970378518,
0.1510582864,
0.3383014202,
0.0192867927,
-0.2060668916,
-0.0105945431,
0.3310875893,
-0.6024174094,
-0.3733709157,
0.2613986433,
-0.0212224443,
-0.1550378948,
-0.1083117872,
-0.9657480717,
-0.4570349157,
-0.4553556144,
0.6044445038,
-0.5542057753,
-0.4149015844,
-0.135627687,
-0.3360539675,
0.1656326056,
0.5078209639,
-0.6852357984,
0.4520701468,
0.5933990479,
1.0697427988,
-0.0424384661,
-0.2793316841,
-0.6620372534,
0.2222808897,
-0.4464870095,
0.9858213663,
-0.5566962361,
-0.4224440753,
-0.2784716189,
-0.1313514858,
-0.0939670429,
-0.2629447877,
0.2023506463,
-0.5792690516,
0.1266610324,
-0.7267878652,
-0.3958640695,
-0.3532178104,
0.479742378,
-0.8480418921,
1.3468782902,
0.1856550127,
-0.6994875669,
0.4682081044,
-0.8812538981,
-0.2878630757,
-0.0880821869,
-0.4107636809,
-0.0861655101,
0.100099586,
0.6120247245,
0.2729021907,
-0.7661826015,
0.4445699453,
-0.3033135831,
-0.4245008826,
0.0494130142,
-0.5365817547,
0.6481046081,
0.1532778591,
-0.5424819589,
0.2188481688,
-0.3988899589,
0.2614204884,
0.0455742925,
-0.0968908295,
-0.2137191147,
-0.3542169034,
-0.2748269737,
0.6699852347,
-0.0018738249,
-0.2806125283,
0.6662842035,
-0.1135956496,
0.2171646208,
0.7784651518,
0.1053635702,
0.0992196128,
-0.236627236,
0.6748819351,
-0.0712869167,
-0.0389318317,
0.2204851359,
-0.9020542502,
-0.4398294687,
-0.026231112,
-0.0089471154,
0.5274775028,
-1.3308398724,
-0.0038205672,
0.1197934076,
-0.3673731089,
-0.1970047653,
0.1887935549,
0.5116176009,
0.2717016339,
0.5181381106,
0.0188871901,
-0.3462927341,
-0.5307409167,
-0.0966289639,
0.096651651,
0.0120701985,
0.1951582432,
0.5866459608,
0.0310332049,
0.7914206982,
-0.6856684089,
-0.1432491988,
-0.5059191585,
0.3558582962,
0.2209638804,
0.3438250721,
0.408758074,
-0.6857705712,
-0.4207600951,
0.0863818303,
-0.7154932022,
-0.0311040189,
0.085467115,
-0.3521428108,
0.1722794175,
0.5049936771,
-0.6286920309,
0.3121017516,
0.4933573008,
-0.3458615541,
0.9266716838,
-0.3009904921,
0.2413199395,
-1.1462535858,
0.0918013304,
-0.3324744999,
0.0510785989,
-0.6012659073,
-0.0619098134,
0.1305831075,
-0.0092281355,
-0.5588775277,
0.6359914541,
-0.4410013556,
-0.1828098595,
-0.4433954358,
0.401965946,
0.2857130766,
0.5532385707,
0.0902106389,
1.3601564169,
0.5288928151,
-0.7134929895,
0.5203640461,
0.2898710072,
-0.1831861287,
0.4478131533,
-0.3878497481,
0.5889527798,
0.1145890802,
0.4359140396,
-0.8802678585,
-0.1439202577,
0.0399084277,
-0.162067607,
0.0423676297,
-0.2664531469,
-0.7860961556,
-0.6498616934,
-0.5046456456,
0.5644590259,
0.1074962914,
-0.7130813003,
0.7852358818,
0.1385824382,
-0.201249063,
-0.6063114405,
-0.5681146979,
0.0788830072,
-0.2327641845,
-0.405169338,
0.1006704867,
0.062776342,
-0.0378058143,
-0.1763466597,
-0.142683655,
-0.2332566381,
-0.2191922218,
-0.0414670594,
0.427226752,
-0.1541128308,
0.525590539,
0.0138056446,
-0.2076627612,
0.2245411873,
-0.5678707957,
0.7150378227,
-0.2818944454,
-0.3718204796,
-0.0437084958,
0.2546432316,
0.5342938304,
-0.1931397617,
0.6457458735,
0.7531437278,
-0.3911019862,
-0.1505530179,
-0.8380010128,
-0.2689671516,
-0.4987766743,
0.109178938,
-0.8920286894,
-0.6808512211,
0.377774626,
-0.3999856114,
-0.0955703706,
0.3515357971,
0.7928812504,
0.5583093166,
1.136312604,
0.3755102754,
-0.0108716683,
0.2224162072,
-0.4333180487,
0.3485608399,
-1.3214249611,
-0.2639826834,
-0.2799227536,
0.030475365,
-0.428137213,
-0.5516360998,
0.5086714625,
0.2000525743,
-0.3330602348,
0.4404248297,
-0.6152203679,
0.6946699619,
0.7478286028,
0.22325553,
0.2913081348,
-0.2118673921,
-0.7529104352,
0.4999777377,
-0.8034955263,
-0.5684522986,
1.2696788311,
-0.237475276,
0.6974707246,
0.2625831068,
0.5705291629,
-0.0506592318,
0.4398336112,
-0.5718135834,
0.5573317409,
-0.010136121,
-0.7359386683,
-0.2409385741,
-0.3756691217,
-0.8192650676,
0.6251351833,
0.061253991,
-1.2457885742,
-0.0303251669,
0.0704060048,
-0.5701478124,
0.4962738156,
-0.9281932116,
0.7518398166,
-0.2595471144,
-0.5660308003,
-0.2781256139,
-0.5285850167,
0.5207431912,
-0.1637507975,
0.2382751107,
-0.2240383178,
0.0767228901,
0.6049752235,
-0.4167435467,
0.558146894,
-0.3321172297,
-0.2927922904,
0.7292423248,
0.3039592505,
0.7541646361,
0.3191922605,
-0.2022271156,
-0.2400799394,
0.2307749689,
-0.1423040479,
-0.8280913234,
0.8954610825,
-0.6342207789,
-0.6639983058,
-0.3257749379,
-0.6957786679,
-0.6698758006,
0.221322462,
0.1725610644,
0.6597592831,
0.1845864356,
-0.1063806489,
0.2783409357,
-0.1864024848,
0.3146077394,
0.1012162864,
-0.3165187538,
-0.6728498936,
0.7556124926,
0.0054821731,
0.593981266,
0.1451170892,
0.4599298835,
-0.6349329352,
-0.0434192717,
-0.4681170285,
0.0044634226,
-1.1414892673,
-0.4629202485,
-0.547989428,
-0.1275083274,
-0.2695752382,
-0.3243518472,
-0.2185521722,
-0.4827536941,
0.2021456659,
-0.3080904782,
0.7546688318,
1.0236586332,
-0.1008154526,
0.1507278979,
-0.8114241958,
0.6315075159,
0.5101716518,
0.5053358674,
0.2135975063,
0.060567569,
-0.1104082987,
0.0538565814,
-0.4738145471,
-0.8677837253,
0.1342690438,
-0.199997291,
0.4513909221,
0.1076416671,
0.0295820106,
0.7317240238,
-0.2052461803,
0.7668704391,
0.2391665429,
-0.9402219057,
0.7418208122,
-0.1883246452,
0.6469010711,
0.5808230042,
0.2101829201,
-0.2108914554,
-0.5315787792,
-0.501518786,
-0.8131978512,
0.6831641793,
0.4365856051,
-0.4199006855,
-0.2056404352,
0.1263474822,
0.2687973678,
0.2566370368,
-0.5741244555,
0.1425078958,
-0.0168141499,
0.035458643,
0.214975819,
0.0078815157,
-0.2916294932,
-0.21285972,
0.7532194853,
-0.5338445902,
0.5416224003,
0.3229884207,
-0.1793843657,
0.0617393777,
0.4211188555,
0.5455323458,
0.9640763402,
-0.0513888337,
0.4696787894,
0.7334079742,
-0.5860946774,
0.3356834948,
-0.1699188948,
0.2591803074,
-0.3484994173,
0.2725788355,
0.5391989946,
0.2674222887,
-0.381259352,
0.2543060184,
-0.0959370285,
-0.2728797495,
0.0086943759,
0.1355083436,
0.0595732257,
0.1948910952,
0.2707157433,
0.0825623348,
0.1532631367,
-0.4435220063,
0.3643929064,
0.163236782,
-0.2403608412,
-0.0797241703,
0.5355350971,
0.1274636984,
0.0244538262,
0.5624572039,
-0.2125378251,
-0.6465883851,
0.8001420498,
0.6958709955,
0.9323826432,
-0.0548098981,
0.1446259171,
0.3701982498,
0.242002964,
-0.3501697183,
0.7247478366,
-0.1106542423,
-0.7054576874,
-0.7746664882,
-0.1238462925,
-0.529933989,
0.1004411653,
-0.5620046854,
0.406206727,
-0.3739537001,
-0.3924761713,
-0.1223705783,
-0.0259293709,
-1.0054900646,
0.1431034356,
0.076408051,
0.9273606539,
-0.4615123272,
1.1254439354,
0.4123806357,
-0.4171061516,
-0.944421947,
-0.0687211528,
0.3316504657,
-0.8014742732,
0.4375759661,
0.4073123634,
-0.7357057333,
0.0009060894,
-0.1868101358,
-0.9941906929,
1.1883863211,
0.2698494494,
-0.4988302886,
0.0634538159,
-0.0863286778,
0.2926824987,
-0.3601690233,
0.5131246448,
0.7828122377,
0.6202813983,
0.2701910734,
-1.0606108904,
0.3823866546,
-0.0829593614,
-0.1940345019,
0.5800452232,
-0.52964288,
0.7753249407,
-0.5531932116,
0.0665952638,
-0.1554152071,
-0.0073424708,
0.6922029853,
0.2863897681,
0.337787658,
0.4024970829,
0.9522020817,
-0.1120830551,
1.1430674791,
-0.4916613996,
0.4044536948,
1.4171351194,
-0.4888967872,
0.7790499926,
0.3486423194,
-0.2746183276,
0.4904706776,
0.341419667,
0.0935198367,
0.533995688,
0.0838542804,
-0.4553215802,
-0.092839323,
0.2195601463,
-0.5420486331,
0.1251817048,
0.5836555362,
0.0143463397,
-0.2190770656,
0.1481043696,
-0.0812000111,
-0.482180357,
-0.2118192315,
0.9039134979,
0.2590821087,
-0.9216457009,
0.5697358847,
-0.3703964949,
0.2081611305,
-0.6083866358,
-0.244314611,
0.1685384214,
0.3064884841,
-0.0292966887,
-1.0806879997,
0.3419262469,
-0.1087211296,
0.2905466855,
-0.0282849614,
0.7384852171,
-0.2068689167,
-0.5691300631,
0.5873744488,
0.909401238,
-0.0648126081,
-0.4052822292,
-0.6050696969,
-0.0476602428,
-0.3173548281,
-0.3054103255,
0.1593222916,
0.841760695,
-0.2206373811,
0.8083162904,
0.7501171827,
-0.1795344502,
-0.0344821773,
0.6856703162,
1.2266479731,
-0.8886219263,
-0.3556837738,
-1.0485562086,
0.1970206946,
-0.14205724,
-0.3624072075,
0.6274390221,
0.5963042378,
0.5982373953,
0.010296138,
0.925624907,
-0.1081983373,
0.0846887752,
-0.8221011758,
0.1469128728,
-0.1631314456,
0.1826789826,
-0.4723963141,
-0.9911565781,
-0.357745856,
0.60962075,
-0.461894244,
0.1696570218,
1.4288363457,
0.6147861481,
0.1617142409,
0.4765706062,
0.2660737932,
-0.0169475265,
0.530400455,
0.7944406271,
0.8550695181,
-0.182046026,
0.5324211121,
-0.1309706569,
-0.1728439629,
0.1231389865,
-0.8036458492,
-1.0001398325,
-0.513138473,
0.0361779369,
-0.362362951,
0.1282304674,
1.2054508924,
0.6479104757,
-0.8260813951,
-0.1644373387,
-0.4775206745,
0.3056234717,
-0.48340711,
-0.2052409798,
0.4713619649,
-0.5651484132,
-0.1505259424,
0.4243002534,
0.358761847,
-0.0534341484,
-0.1668709368,
-0.0257818028,
-0.4899054766,
0.055043228,
1.0636744499,
-0.3260776997,
-0.9709666967,
-0.3226374388,
-0.1066193506,
0.234028548,
0.1221655756,
1.28548944,
-1.064391613,
0.4988546073,
0.4409332275,
0.2711656094,
0.7940350771,
0.0299080629,
0.9172085524,
-0.6793062687,
0.1536180079,
0.1227249131,
0.4911825061,
0.0533649214,
-0.5164245963,
0.8564751148,
-0.1449069381,
-0.5150187612,
-0.404235661,
0.2711285651,
-0.6403590441,
-0.4362033606,
1.2148305178,
-0.0296448488,
0.0809577629,
-0.3757580519,
-0.6874169707,
0.1245178878,
-0.5501921773,
0.725574255,
1.0551813841,
-0.4515324831,
-0.3578003645,
-0.8445276022,
0.5392026901,
0.0341235809,
-1.2007960081,
0.1603048146,
0.2508940101,
0.1760956049,
0.1544889957,
0.8388751149,
-0.1448661089,
0.3906606436,
0.2009131759,
-0.1899215281,
0.0424039736,
-0.6611050367,
0.0102251694,
0.2172679603,
0.0920376182,
0.2052208632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16895v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16895v1 | UMSE: Unified Multi-scenario Summarization Evaluation | 2023-05-26T12:54:44 | 2023-05-26T12:54:44 | Shen Gao, Zhitao Yao, Chongyang Tao, Xiuying Chen, Pengjie Ren, Zhaochun Ren, Zhumin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Summarization quality evaluation is a non-trivial task in text summarization.
Contemporary methods can be mainly categorized into two scenarios: (1)
reference-based: evaluating with human-labeled reference summary; (2)
reference-free: evaluating the summary consistency of the document. Recent
studies mainly focus on one of these scenarios and explore training neural
models built on PLMs to align with human criteria. However, the models from
different scenarios are optimized individually, which may result in sub-optimal
performance since they neglect the shared knowledge across different scenarios.
Besides, designing individual models for each scenario caused inconvenience to
the user. Inspired by this, we propose Unified Multi-scenario Summarization
Evaluation Model (UMSE). More specifically, we propose a perturbed prefix
tuning method to share cross-scenario knowledge between scenarios and use a
self-supervised training paradigm to optimize the model without extra human
labeling. Our UMSE is the first unified summarization evaluation framework
engaged with the ability to be used in three evaluation scenarios. Experimental
results across three typical scenarios on the benchmark dataset SummEval
indicate that our UMSE can achieve comparable performance with several existing
strong methods which are specifically designed for each scenario. | [
-0.4279831052,
-0.1451441199,
0.4829795361,
0.4600021541,
-0.6649457812,
0.1399413496,
-0.0161741674,
0.1370857954,
0.1940026283,
0.4259446859,
-0.6341159344,
-0.5509855747,
-0.2616811991,
0.3913571239,
-0.0740341395,
1.2294678688,
0.1245042607,
0.1085571721,
-0.3620414436,
-0.3241507113,
-0.6458421946,
-0.7885363698,
-0.419026196,
-0.3051270247,
0.2587522268,
0.510076046,
0.3982278109,
0.2340994179,
0.5535340905,
0.3804388642,
-0.1612999886,
0.2689407468,
-0.3089344501,
0.0349760875,
-0.3221790493,
-0.0065610935,
-0.8082037568,
-0.0115004405,
0.6466982365,
0.7309384942,
-0.2111411691,
0.286509186,
0.3918407857,
0.6042804122,
-0.7448420525,
-0.2630770206,
-0.3078784347,
0.0655127987,
0.2556238174,
-0.4391277134,
-0.2850159109,
0.0073959059,
0.1013636142,
-0.4802597761,
0.2052683234,
0.2062675655,
0.8391001821,
0.1050395444,
-0.5508539081,
0.271330744,
-0.3433263004,
0.7992151976,
-0.9877694249,
0.1484037638,
-0.0222469196,
0.2771064341,
-0.0809161663,
-0.6004958749,
-0.2612498701,
-0.0112857372,
-0.1045576856,
0.6925927997,
-0.0089302175,
0.1819406897,
-0.1245892569,
0.4288710058,
-0.4526898563,
0.1474957615,
-0.0775384754,
-0.3495327234,
0.7830248475,
0.6164602637,
0.1498232037,
-0.6018159986,
-0.8025352359,
0.0023693314,
-0.4638106823,
-0.0051736957,
0.3779987693,
0.2318193316,
-0.1985538006,
0.4329273701,
-0.3230063021,
0.4342652261,
-0.1426122636,
-0.1843697429,
0.2002030909,
-0.8006796241,
-0.3912994564,
-0.2079350799,
0.8530181646,
0.8816376925,
-0.0508780703,
-0.4098813534,
-0.1538355201,
-0.106227152,
0.3652351201,
-0.7001526356,
0.0169784483,
-0.0676239207,
-0.5154494643,
-0.2019287199,
0.4187562168,
-0.9900872111,
-0.1770696342,
-0.5704073906,
0.4710731506,
-0.4344630241,
-0.0892413035,
0.0839387104,
-0.3268208206,
-0.2053040117,
0.3316610456,
-0.8082137108,
0.3351903558,
0.4661281705,
0.6851992011,
-0.2520966232,
-0.7939792275,
-0.361625582,
0.1253573298,
-0.0524607822,
0.9994149208,
-0.1186514422,
-0.7569381595,
-0.5113604069,
-0.3018499017,
-0.3461052179,
-0.207002759,
0.7114982605,
-0.1539514661,
0.1291324049,
-0.1251959205,
-0.7672223449,
-0.1855484247,
-0.0742608979,
-0.4061824083,
0.7146986723,
0.0868562534,
-0.7375615835,
0.4864349365,
-1.0226525068,
-0.4204404652,
-0.1421267688,
0.1046096385,
-0.4627756476,
0.3064265549,
0.5095312595,
0.4364084005,
-0.2290481478,
0.4132971168,
-0.1133004576,
-0.4176854491,
0.0091351541,
-0.4559100568,
0.5298275352,
0.2618457377,
-0.0053674676,
0.5201765299,
-0.6617235541,
-0.0024960893,
-0.1824589372,
-0.2283892334,
-0.6718319654,
-0.2872673273,
-0.1010779366,
0.2779415548,
-0.0241211075,
-0.4086582065,
0.2497906089,
-0.3902100921,
0.1531614363,
0.7014249563,
0.5872644186,
0.4253971577,
-0.3954445124,
0.5003067851,
0.1936177611,
0.360539645,
-0.6837483048,
-0.4095329642,
-0.6844853759,
-0.1337201595,
0.7262919545,
0.3367046714,
-0.3822727501,
0.6961252689,
-0.3085716963,
-0.1335736364,
-0.5543134212,
0.1183592156,
0.5555431247,
0.5526170731,
0.4868533015,
-0.3299530447,
-0.8447304368,
-0.8806718588,
-0.4040426016,
0.2586770356,
-0.274156332,
-0.1411620229,
0.6104664207,
-0.0501620509,
1.0451003313,
-0.2524709105,
-0.4509062767,
-0.6091142297,
0.6210902333,
0.0945152938,
0.4756871164,
0.2476195991,
-0.6767780781,
-0.1756185442,
-0.4970389903,
-0.7556678057,
-0.0864452273,
-0.3470165431,
-0.0529485233,
0.247090131,
0.4910907745,
0.1234399229,
0.551659286,
0.5126676559,
-0.5812854171,
0.4594051242,
-0.6063818932,
0.5819734335,
-1.440392375,
0.099842459,
0.0820805356,
-0.0749818236,
-0.2367235273,
0.1258799285,
0.2078408897,
-0.081538476,
-0.2913647592,
0.5623965859,
-0.6308224797,
-0.1006711945,
-0.0482558496,
0.1848375946,
0.2910226882,
0.4972964227,
-0.2304003388,
0.7993026972,
0.2898201048,
-0.7913659215,
-0.0640036762,
0.313528657,
-0.2661287189,
0.7900448442,
-0.5520995855,
-0.0097188214,
-0.1500980407,
0.1240386367,
-0.8759121299,
-0.1116812155,
-0.2160881013,
-0.4195224345,
0.0911416039,
0.0175720323,
-0.4169147313,
-0.311390847,
-0.6381903887,
0.1261915416,
0.3184764683,
-0.6057112813,
0.6873704791,
0.3451554477,
-0.0904475302,
-0.2808017135,
-0.3803548813,
0.3445087671,
-0.3892363012,
-0.6194081903,
0.371041894,
-0.2361114323,
0.006074232,
-0.0564821437,
-0.4932776093,
0.0529086627,
0.3273780644,
0.4166001081,
0.3008697033,
-0.0734737143,
-0.1109928787,
0.3182734549,
-0.4600250423,
-0.3513456583,
0.1072877198,
0.2538499236,
-0.1252557933,
-0.3007442355,
-0.5265968442,
0.6135230064,
0.3508414626,
-0.2375176996,
0.2930632234,
0.2010720223,
-0.0692174658,
0.0254818574,
-0.6178457737,
-0.0018770759,
-0.4140929282,
0.2385089844,
-0.6818272471,
-0.7115085125,
0.5370548964,
-0.4027200639,
0.2764396966,
0.8244004846,
0.3181303442,
-0.3993211687,
0.9444535971,
0.6903813481,
-0.110680677,
0.048167821,
-0.201260522,
-0.0330978967,
-1.2014055252,
-0.3733474016,
-0.5443485379,
-0.1649942696,
-0.011180941,
0.1030470356,
0.6775123477,
0.3527338207,
-0.0933396444,
0.3064595163,
-0.1663901657,
0.6667430997,
0.4706124365,
-0.0897784084,
0.7477377057,
-0.0458625965,
-0.6336656213,
-0.1669546515,
-0.9401278496,
-0.603158474,
1.1881320477,
0.1179214194,
0.6856210232,
-0.1047427207,
0.8711493611,
0.5228632689,
0.4258489013,
-0.2893435359,
0.5426276326,
-0.1370449364,
-0.2008865774,
-0.5189256072,
-0.4956305921,
-1.2252042294,
0.7225031257,
-0.196348846,
-0.8140272498,
-0.1637539119,
-0.2149671465,
-0.7966910601,
0.2163851559,
-0.7077301145,
0.9655227065,
-0.130515337,
0.084822461,
-0.14684017,
-0.7870320082,
0.4427390993,
-0.0391530655,
0.2369776964,
-0.0046036108,
-0.0930808187,
0.8286687136,
-0.5065668225,
0.6323019266,
0.158957988,
0.1890400499,
0.1766895056,
-0.179018259,
-0.1520416439,
0.3540329337,
-0.1811417192,
0.3654038608,
-0.0972062573,
-0.2024109364,
-0.6106362939,
0.6337184906,
-0.6774406433,
-0.309284538,
-0.3763155639,
-0.4781059921,
-0.3451987803,
0.1230776235,
0.6088740826,
0.5520493388,
-0.4761831164,
-0.0752452537,
0.1221403703,
0.0150412172,
0.8219766021,
0.8065448999,
-0.09217868,
-0.6502186656,
0.696590662,
-0.0646339953,
-0.0899459794,
0.1962586343,
0.1435378045,
-0.3641392291,
-0.3667346537,
-0.6508796215,
-0.0215722062,
-0.4967541099,
-0.5194405913,
-0.5435779691,
-0.0601834506,
-0.4117950499,
-0.1950544566,
-0.4188556671,
-0.1512563378,
-0.2509775162,
-0.0190882422,
-0.2082382143,
0.5853900909,
-0.0823638812,
0.4996799231,
-1.1085538864,
0.6080992222,
0.0750239268,
0.6091156602,
-0.1291573495,
-0.6700199246,
-0.2360445559,
-0.0026290643,
-0.4659818709,
-0.982301414,
0.2126541883,
0.1403751373,
0.7793402076,
0.2457937151,
0.0560074039,
0.846026957,
-0.2708231509,
0.6817037463,
0.4246733487,
-1.1961562634,
0.5979288816,
-0.1145361662,
0.5834848881,
1.0926566124,
0.1304993927,
-0.3926754594,
-0.3231727183,
-0.8955597878,
-0.980084002,
0.5935716629,
0.2691696286,
-0.0634099618,
0.2785689533,
0.308652401,
0.3063084781,
0.2824979722,
-0.2234216481,
-0.4694476426,
-0.2037357241,
0.1431936473,
-0.258987993,
-0.3311853409,
0.1331132203,
-0.5238815546,
0.7465456128,
-0.0123086795,
-0.0656394809,
0.3386726975,
-0.3307312429,
0.0714902133,
0.5704560876,
0.441850096,
0.743532002,
-0.274009943,
-0.272251904,
0.368347764,
-0.062467061,
0.2053027153,
0.0357042253,
-0.1427418888,
0.274355799,
0.1821618527,
0.8290834427,
0.8000988364,
-0.3057318032,
0.6271103024,
-0.2691422403,
-0.2129659355,
-0.04165411,
0.0191953946,
-0.1141582727,
-0.0519727282,
0.3929018676,
0.3258495629,
0.4340819418,
-0.4021528959,
0.3599523008,
0.0194582026,
0.0004402349,
-0.3224997818,
0.5382056832,
0.4595163763,
-0.0410650969,
0.5892364383,
-0.4231433272,
-0.4245326221,
0.5836028457,
0.5054661036,
0.9266455173,
-0.6156176925,
0.2126593888,
0.4707789719,
0.2362918556,
0.0558195598,
0.3377276957,
0.1186807752,
-0.4606284201,
-0.6321308613,
-0.7212163806,
-0.6399047375,
0.196729213,
-0.7605711222,
0.2264339626,
0.0527857989,
-0.1524489224,
0.0968503729,
-0.0851514414,
-0.5252674818,
0.2853527069,
-0.194557175,
0.9210800529,
-0.7857992053,
0.5122867823,
0.9016022682,
-0.5602498055,
-0.7344891429,
-0.0923120975,
-0.0114619406,
-0.2479216158,
0.0875471681,
0.0624755174,
-0.0047872183,
-0.0093064718,
-0.0417811684,
-0.6679782271,
1.0787625313,
0.2247012407,
-0.5247921348,
0.0082944334,
-0.1734034568,
0.5467437506,
-0.4701350629,
0.3872376084,
0.6745398641,
0.5619105101,
0.0506986193,
-0.9957203269,
-0.0485832095,
-0.3241637647,
0.1446518451,
0.210891068,
-0.6358762383,
0.6168670654,
-0.6101731658,
-0.3673864901,
0.3240449131,
0.8047600389,
0.0038446782,
0.4107004106,
0.382814467,
0.6767661572,
0.5456741452,
-0.0580127165,
1.2295269966,
-0.1197946593,
0.4357858002,
1.5191508532,
-0.1525068134,
0.5009990931,
0.3249823153,
-0.1711165607,
0.2310091853,
0.4742709994,
-0.2380360961,
0.4898193777,
0.2611833215,
0.0214449298,
-0.2652673125,
0.0907115415,
-0.4363554716,
0.6229350567,
-0.0194672737,
-0.1045029238,
-0.8372553587,
0.0260581262,
-0.0649621189,
0.1043295786,
-0.4392342269,
1.0810397863,
0.0736172348,
-0.7959128022,
0.2722632289,
0.3691453934,
0.7366148233,
-0.641600728,
0.1410399228,
-0.6286457777,
-0.0565832891,
-0.1898559928,
-0.4533978105,
0.3744218349,
0.0117726913,
-0.1482271254,
-0.0116771739,
0.5186059475,
-0.2111996263,
-0.4353942871,
0.1640895903,
0.7185166478,
0.2236984819,
-0.2804258466,
-0.5939775109,
-0.2106343061,
-0.11343503,
-0.3444180787,
0.6980529428,
0.2285955697,
-0.0912658051,
0.4132121801,
0.6533915401,
-0.1532074362,
-0.2551189363,
0.6655203104,
0.7325834036,
-0.7717959285,
-0.8969803452,
-0.9706989527,
0.7683737278,
-0.3094160855,
-0.7675071359,
1.104390502,
0.8942976594,
0.40399611,
0.004374932,
0.7713267803,
0.4126268923,
0.4303323925,
-0.493039608,
0.757814467,
-0.6027618647,
0.2480442673,
-0.4999316037,
-0.8822580576,
-0.4135080874,
0.2586081028,
0.1209238842,
0.0345877595,
0.876054287,
0.1672000885,
-0.0793024451,
0.3925260305,
0.5842872262,
-0.078043133,
-0.1770958304,
0.3634986579,
0.6589968204,
-0.5621985197,
0.2637234628,
-0.3494799435,
-0.2959262729,
-0.1795922369,
-1.196295619,
-0.9858941436,
-0.6968856454,
-0.3106290996,
0.0210585799,
0.2278544158,
0.7302225232,
0.6695469618,
-0.714987278,
-0.1953546852,
0.195396468,
0.0518615842,
-0.2690173984,
-0.2192304134,
0.4009336829,
-0.6355624199,
-0.6103428602,
0.6558716893,
0.5371232033,
0.101550214,
-0.0584592149,
-0.0399948843,
0.0128896432,
0.0112440987,
0.5956810713,
0.0593797155,
-0.4123467207,
0.0629793555,
-0.3010010123,
-0.0508540459,
0.1702585071,
1.0189808607,
-0.7921475768,
0.3881387711,
0.110102497,
0.4825528264,
0.3372896612,
0.5110940337,
0.5525235534,
-0.8521053195,
-0.1071826741,
0.0567052215,
0.697009027,
0.1890468299,
-0.2935291231,
0.5910698175,
-0.0615635775,
-0.4154733419,
-0.4298948646,
-0.2097605318,
-0.9628305435,
-0.3432227969,
1.0465708971,
-0.235174641,
0.1833049059,
-0.1708766073,
-0.2826302648,
0.3559247851,
-0.6080822349,
0.9143183827,
0.5311439633,
-0.2560837865,
0.2943378091,
-0.2794130743,
0.2424851507,
0.7204036117,
-1.1216298342,
-0.3330717981,
0.4938639998,
0.3491975665,
0.0563963018,
0.5213639736,
-0.0789658353,
0.3253176212,
-0.1209752858,
0.1447114348,
-0.3827720582,
-0.5561665893,
-0.6847831011,
0.3865622282,
-0.3837302923,
-0.253840059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16894v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16894v1 | Robustness of Multi-Source MT to Transcription Errors | 2023-05-26T12:54:16 | 2023-05-26T12:54:16 | Dominik Macháček, Peter Polák, Ondřej Bojar, Raj Dabre | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic speech translation is sensitive to speech recognition errors, but
in a multilingual scenario, the same content may be available in various
languages via simultaneous interpreting, dubbing or subtitling. In this paper,
we hypothesize that leveraging multiple sources will improve translation
quality if the sources complement one another in terms of correct information
they contain. To this end, we first show that on a 10-hour ESIC corpus, the ASR
errors in the original English speech and its simultaneous interpreting into
German and Czech are mutually independent. We then use two sources, English and
German, in a multi-source setting for translation into Czech to establish its
robustness to ASR errors. Furthermore, we observe this robustness when
translating both noisy sources together in a simultaneous translation setting.
Our results show that multi-source neural machine translation has the potential
to be useful in a real-time simultaneous translation setting, thereby
motivating further investigation in this area. | [
0.0792221352,
-0.5768930912,
0.5862364769,
0.5263602138,
-0.4511503875,
0.300842464,
-0.5138869286,
-0.5341584086,
-0.0038626085,
0.2024943531,
-0.413697958,
-0.1773228645,
-0.9829862118,
0.596686244,
-0.5518200994,
0.7664852738,
-0.0880254135,
0.8200112581,
-0.0650355294,
-0.7258331776,
-0.5916731954,
-0.7701123953,
-0.5760754943,
0.0355228037,
0.5965331197,
0.2136557102,
0.700496912,
0.6103602052,
0.6273462772,
0.3730819821,
0.0871069282,
0.3337083757,
0.2096849233,
0.5770035386,
-0.0182490312,
-0.3881388605,
-0.2314792573,
-0.1746868342,
1.0513877869,
0.420522064,
-0.106140323,
0.172137931,
0.4590031803,
0.338282913,
-0.2494184971,
0.0763128772,
-0.621532917,
-0.2947440743,
-0.3041964471,
-0.3677033484,
-0.5139038563,
-0.2334368378,
-0.0023826547,
-0.4469227493,
0.1590012312,
-0.2416591346,
0.8239129186,
0.7255097628,
-0.5703994632,
-0.308850944,
-1.0042607784,
0.7866206765,
-0.6948080659,
0.6617247462,
0.2375567704,
0.4033261538,
0.0897310674,
-0.528557241,
-0.4489943981,
-0.0702472776,
-0.1411666572,
0.2130622715,
-0.1841252148,
-0.3788498938,
0.1110552102,
-0.1014062017,
-0.3718146086,
-0.1501136124,
-0.4404434562,
-0.5166893601,
0.2555015385,
-0.1875747591,
0.6807262897,
-0.1279538572,
-0.0751826242,
-0.1421300322,
-0.5502599478,
-0.129456073,
0.6150292158,
0.7815535665,
-0.0289025679,
0.6555749178,
0.3559552431,
0.7070804834,
-0.1787760109,
-0.1538866609,
0.4209679067,
-0.9424390197,
0.126303643,
0.2723597288,
0.9152157903,
0.0395273268,
-0.1195344478,
-0.2004366517,
0.0608679578,
0.069343172,
0.4734098613,
-0.3411126733,
0.1129507124,
0.3864633739,
-0.256057173,
0.0337429158,
0.1817722172,
-0.4429896176,
0.1357843429,
-0.5381664038,
0.4676986337,
-0.6203866601,
-0.1529597938,
-0.2954146266,
-0.1923660338,
-0.166824311,
0.3060725927,
-0.5345482826,
-0.0131113064,
0.2870171666,
0.9228748083,
-0.1609899104,
-0.7260339856,
-0.8747003675,
0.2712789476,
-0.2273675054,
1.0123665333,
-0.0394429527,
-0.1493494213,
-0.1453586668,
-0.0823030546,
-0.2454307526,
-0.367857486,
0.6268488169,
-0.3951560855,
0.2702130079,
-0.3091946244,
0.0617966503,
-0.0969333351,
-0.0835864246,
-0.8636234403,
0.6956176758,
-0.0731628537,
-0.7149922848,
0.3351289034,
-0.4876911938,
-0.8809558153,
-0.4084273279,
-0.0862306654,
-0.6247931123,
0.1120242402,
0.3296346068,
0.0751887485,
0.0384764485,
0.4221042991,
-0.1058962569,
-0.0073073721,
0.6171362996,
-0.7696173191,
1.0344899893,
0.2968925238,
-0.3175111711,
0.224798426,
-0.8556277752,
0.1099093929,
-0.0535115041,
-0.8254693151,
-0.3709740639,
0.2633778751,
0.2328487933,
0.5824398994,
-0.094672747,
-0.4731827974,
-0.3588428795,
-0.1560698897,
0.5836502314,
0.6632778645,
-0.1175068989,
0.352817893,
-0.1478331536,
0.2473672777,
0.2563497722,
-0.0121103609,
-0.00582192,
-0.583597064,
-0.3961634934,
-0.2128873467,
0.5614634156,
0.7730221152,
-0.9656620026,
0.3326517642,
-0.359837234,
-0.1537854224,
-0.9510458708,
0.2599216104,
0.5317534208,
0.5056310892,
0.5724034905,
-0.158844918,
-0.7471380234,
-0.7353602052,
-0.5584177375,
-0.0586927608,
-0.0875491053,
0.0397285633,
0.0128183896,
0.0183459539,
0.5987407565,
0.2013683915,
-0.2020299286,
-0.0918520018,
0.1592457443,
0.0389380679,
0.6512900591,
0.4715557992,
-0.8612404466,
-0.7810769677,
0.0035383054,
-0.7214853764,
-0.0819742158,
-0.1915273964,
-0.1176075861,
0.30975613,
0.2608412206,
-0.3406911194,
-0.0225034114,
0.9769525528,
-0.1845733076,
0.3784310818,
-0.4185568392,
0.4920645356,
-1.5321825743,
0.0838174894,
-0.172221899,
-0.2983920872,
-0.7154749632,
-0.017716147,
0.2602207363,
0.039335344,
-0.6023020148,
-0.1042662114,
-0.4872209132,
-0.3007541299,
-0.211294353,
0.2092589587,
0.0688999444,
0.1655882299,
-0.2261599153,
1.0243920088,
0.5268203616,
-0.5018311143,
0.1950015277,
0.2930784822,
-0.2516524196,
0.8055744171,
-0.5999289751,
0.2526536584,
-0.1414012611,
0.0636626333,
-0.9072830081,
-0.2841617167,
0.2450245917,
-1.0235463381,
0.6620697975,
-0.091260232,
-0.6549654603,
0.0614125505,
0.0203878246,
0.2921858132,
0.0184195582,
-0.4106900096,
0.6260772943,
0.3186744153,
-0.3639036715,
-0.9046903253,
-1.1679232121,
0.2952984571,
-0.0422569476,
-0.6402108073,
0.0116024883,
-0.137346983,
-0.2930229008,
0.3403781652,
-0.3397497535,
-0.1875634193,
0.0385178439,
0.085739553,
0.3942373991,
-0.2899755538,
-0.0443043709,
0.1641101241,
-0.1860033721,
-0.1344877332,
-0.5478403568,
0.2278869599,
0.0951273367,
-0.7299168706,
-0.5594181418,
0.8588290811,
0.8086553216,
-0.2883713543,
0.8217456341,
0.7377646565,
-0.3438076377,
0.1011205763,
-0.4944883883,
-0.0504201278,
-0.390008837,
0.2857821882,
-0.4468043447,
-0.7242025137,
0.7373080254,
0.4484823048,
-0.0110738073,
0.6916710734,
0.5367355943,
-0.2089604884,
1.1785584688,
0.3295795619,
-0.0215655062,
0.5858424306,
0.2170646489,
0.1437679529,
-0.7791069746,
-0.05687695,
-1.0723762512,
-0.0614946708,
-0.4879195094,
-0.2696421444,
0.43517977,
-0.1277967095,
0.1548270136,
0.6650845408,
-0.458429426,
0.2518095374,
1.0919458866,
0.2265413851,
0.45654127,
0.2358037382,
-0.2052315325,
-0.2354747504,
-0.7748561502,
-0.5111050606,
1.074160099,
0.093990624,
0.3077936769,
0.3216576874,
0.3745254874,
0.0267556608,
0.2715336382,
-0.5424970388,
-0.0774581656,
-0.3475788534,
-0.9568365812,
-0.4196203947,
-0.5677132607,
-0.7844676971,
0.374861747,
-0.37383762,
-0.3086461723,
0.1732214391,
0.2849573791,
-0.4062744677,
0.2589958012,
-0.9225849509,
0.7492291927,
-0.3438805938,
-0.1504007131,
-0.2028694153,
-1.0224618912,
0.0276903175,
-0.3023153245,
0.4440202415,
0.0189700723,
0.1544145197,
0.5368807912,
-0.0205169693,
0.4696092606,
0.0755599886,
0.1081630364,
0.3747021854,
-0.1056634486,
0.440359354,
-0.0509144478,
-0.0422728695,
0.6708545685,
-0.0427687131,
-0.4297457337,
-0.4839556813,
0.3916295469,
-0.9978207946,
-0.2841691077,
-0.4975155294,
-0.490689069,
-0.2176192552,
0.3589812219,
0.4862469733,
0.4725921154,
0.0913449526,
0.3187782466,
0.3345602751,
-0.1520006657,
0.3893785179,
0.5905426741,
0.4303605556,
-0.883433342,
0.8769565225,
0.4294903278,
0.5099782348,
0.3088947535,
0.0470555909,
-0.3508294225,
-0.80185467,
-0.9818984866,
0.0126021104,
-0.843690455,
-0.40600878,
-0.7120293975,
-0.1125857905,
-0.5448254943,
0.1248641089,
-0.5742892027,
-0.3759484291,
-0.3152121305,
-0.1309779137,
-0.0804637298,
0.3875545859,
-0.3255378306,
0.1976622492,
-1.3082917929,
0.3849633336,
0.2958791852,
0.2036417425,
-0.5115585923,
-0.6350352168,
-0.4245857596,
0.2724122703,
-0.0688436851,
-1.0385309458,
0.3729903996,
0.0740483329,
0.8228824735,
-0.1079423502,
-0.1276683658,
0.6065390706,
-0.8919249773,
0.6459992528,
0.3034797311,
-1.0492516756,
0.4930184484,
-0.3158560395,
0.3606046736,
0.6778502464,
0.0945706442,
-0.5156417489,
-0.8701992631,
-0.4262867868,
-0.7437688112,
0.8767232299,
0.2792893052,
0.02446739,
0.1180896759,
-0.0440361388,
0.0823671743,
0.1282740831,
-0.6380072236,
-0.3617276549,
-0.4498221278,
-0.2106485814,
-0.3708125651,
-0.1139578968,
-0.4299529791,
-0.03260573,
0.5988408327,
-0.0368658155,
0.3424350023,
0.4018054307,
-0.1743884832,
-0.5637634397,
0.4630002379,
0.9825451374,
0.640245676,
-0.1189870909,
0.4332152903,
0.2532193363,
-0.5783343315,
0.2837062776,
0.2780861855,
-0.2138004899,
0.4918757975,
0.329721719,
0.6328489184,
0.1520043463,
-0.3418227136,
0.3604609072,
-0.0792225227,
-0.0793570802,
-0.2508390248,
-0.4448129237,
0.1575926989,
0.2030882984,
0.4752974212,
0.9981186986,
-0.011234412,
-0.5081008077,
0.2419239879,
0.2755794227,
-0.1992446035,
-0.3893969655,
0.9282702208,
0.0471369773,
-0.3966491818,
0.5446667075,
0.1519476175,
-0.4191564023,
0.3623770475,
0.6489472389,
0.8892171979,
-0.7347840071,
-0.1345097125,
0.361667335,
0.5809938908,
-0.3574527204,
0.1536453515,
0.2288652807,
-0.7560549378,
-0.9854905009,
-0.2861595452,
-0.5822074413,
-0.3226805627,
-0.7471371293,
0.1825273037,
0.1498113722,
-0.3185065985,
0.0463617332,
-0.597832799,
-0.4316878915,
-0.0709115267,
-0.0573661402,
0.3517687023,
-0.8952685595,
1.1323530674,
0.7829352021,
-0.4436846375,
-0.8606747985,
0.031442076,
0.0902946964,
-0.5795538425,
0.4578398168,
-0.2376758307,
-0.3639939427,
-0.2687183917,
-0.3539920449,
-1.2379648685,
0.8656827211,
0.9357699752,
-0.3927082717,
0.1268122643,
0.0586084202,
0.6082463861,
0.0674042851,
-0.2707844973,
0.0816506892,
0.4759319127,
-0.0527609326,
-1.2388279438,
-0.0620305687,
-0.119638741,
-0.3384898603,
0.0914353579,
-0.5147171617,
0.7393279076,
-0.0718617886,
-0.4824634194,
-0.3425013721,
0.5004591346,
0.0196282752,
0.3035763204,
0.391464293,
0.2849430442,
0.5517452359,
-0.1872268617,
0.9601842761,
-0.4555955827,
0.0569048561,
1.3908424377,
0.0976483002,
1.0416309834,
0.711091876,
-0.2039050758,
0.1645627469,
0.2666769326,
0.1522601992,
0.6522601843,
-0.4656729698,
-0.2344615161,
-0.0585368462,
0.2154383808,
-0.2792514265,
0.4276172817,
0.2931481004,
-0.4558059573,
-0.1198367551,
0.260468483,
-0.1089709029,
0.1885604709,
0.1117252782,
0.7255234122,
0.1231502444,
-0.8741452098,
0.1995916665,
-0.0934255123,
0.4483443797,
-0.5514819622,
0.0655007064,
0.1497807354,
0.1384491175,
-0.1455897242,
-0.5310761333,
0.9680045247,
-0.0100062592,
-0.2203216851,
-0.4555850029,
0.6622046232,
-0.5335657001,
-0.4526135325,
0.3097057939,
0.7880666256,
0.0423799641,
-0.1499580443,
-0.4746856689,
0.2190132141,
0.0009533549,
0.0150157101,
0.2915079594,
0.3872356117,
0.3123362362,
0.3663024902,
0.8913904428,
0.3030568957,
0.4643649757,
0.0594645739,
0.6635177732,
-0.2984569967,
-0.3202735782,
-1.0142848492,
0.7401976585,
-0.0928128809,
0.0023545627,
1.1489673853,
0.4091719985,
0.9788948894,
-0.0422196575,
0.9807056189,
-0.0016150915,
0.627990365,
-0.4985470772,
0.6011135578,
-0.2825706899,
0.0952523425,
-0.2386929542,
-0.9198559523,
-0.7144823074,
0.5269184113,
0.1544993371,
-0.3979718983,
1.0008302927,
0.4369198084,
-0.0211677086,
-0.2106183618,
0.3466975987,
0.0496686772,
0.1288253963,
0.1037763655,
0.665961802,
-0.5266475677,
1.1477222443,
-0.2076192945,
0.0643712208,
0.0033149917,
-0.6118857265,
-0.403262049,
-0.7526538372,
-0.3077552021,
-0.8981074095,
0.0915808752,
0.8895674944,
0.7245923877,
-1.2137241364,
0.0453003831,
0.1752591878,
0.2826771438,
-0.7069568634,
-0.0807481706,
0.4454863071,
-0.5730878115,
-1.0276017189,
0.7677452564,
0.3864136338,
0.2050930858,
-0.0756127387,
-0.1021681204,
-0.0576772168,
-0.0736646652,
0.5206357837,
0.2004614174,
-0.6808401942,
-0.5252680182,
0.2642814517,
-0.3760290444,
0.3676797152,
0.9200353622,
-0.0111659495,
0.7409628034,
0.5620360374,
0.7418140769,
0.3018874526,
0.0651932731,
0.8231802583,
-0.8696380854,
0.0552781671,
0.2006757855,
0.5423033834,
0.5847686529,
-0.3033546209,
0.3234285414,
0.3086175025,
-0.6178218126,
-0.7741449475,
0.0546452589,
-1.1409204006,
-0.1426760107,
1.0995256901,
-0.4073497951,
-0.0480403677,
-0.4477780461,
-0.1920589656,
0.8041003942,
-0.3415826559,
0.7810266018,
1.1238533258,
-0.0592716075,
-0.0414399356,
-0.9476808906,
0.2645682991,
0.3382217884,
-0.5491147041,
-0.2217241973,
0.5414457321,
0.3905636668,
0.6644163132,
0.4519317746,
-0.3078195751,
0.2810253501,
0.3999270201,
-0.1870645732,
-0.0789686665,
-0.3031822741,
-0.6357325315,
0.1098035201,
0.2182787955,
-0.5472646952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16885v1 | Hierarchical Verbalizer for Few-Shot Hierarchical Text Classification | 2023-05-26T12:41:49 | 2023-05-26T12:41:49 | Ke Ji, Yixin Lian, Jingsheng Gao, Baoyuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Due to the complex label hierarchy and intensive labeling cost in practice,
the hierarchical text classification (HTC) suffers a poor performance
especially when low-resource or few-shot settings are considered. Recently,
there is a growing trend of applying prompts on pre-trained language models
(PLMs), which has exhibited effectiveness in the few-shot flat text
classification tasks. However, limited work has studied the paradigm of
prompt-based learning in the HTC problem when the training data is extremely
scarce. In this work, we define a path-based few-shot setting and establish a
strict path-based evaluation metric to further explore few-shot HTC tasks. To
address the issue, we propose the hierarchical verbalizer ("HierVerb"), a
multi-verbalizer framework treating HTC as a single- or multi-label
classification problem at multiple layers and learning vectors as verbalizers
constrained by hierarchical structure and hierarchical contrastive learning. In
this manner, HierVerb fuses label hierarchy knowledge into verbalizers and
remarkably outperforms those who inject hierarchy through graph encoders,
maximizing the benefits of PLMs. Extensive experiments on three popular HTC
datasets under the few-shot settings demonstrate that prompt with HierVerb
significantly boosts the HTC performance, meanwhile indicating an elegant way
to bridge the gap between the large pre-trained model and downstream
hierarchical classification tasks. Our code and few-shot dataset are publicly
available at https://github.com/1KE-JI/HierVerb. | [
-0.30499506,
-0.915551722,
0.462898165,
0.0759286284,
0.008735612,
0.2024585009,
-0.0906819701,
-0.162623778,
-0.0961621031,
0.0406224653,
-0.5667011142,
-0.7296746969,
-0.6889802217,
0.099354066,
0.2823264599,
1.1646674871,
0.1107338816,
-0.3063873947,
-0.0294527095,
-0.1577375978,
-0.6521692276,
-0.4404457808,
-0.5505854487,
-0.6018576622,
0.7433998585,
0.6242172718,
0.746240437,
0.5727228522,
0.5202130675,
0.2774064243,
-0.3214850724,
-0.0324930735,
-0.544056654,
0.0434724726,
0.2219845355,
-0.1562356353,
-0.4609111547,
0.0781060979,
0.776201427,
0.6769064665,
-0.0087778922,
0.2466263175,
0.2286334187,
0.2558549047,
-0.7556989789,
0.2200867534,
-0.2774200439,
0.1706805229,
-0.3806915879,
-0.4406389892,
-0.4968861043,
-0.3095861375,
0.1827510446,
-0.5915796757,
-0.108678177,
0.2585944235,
0.978985548,
0.4038651586,
-0.3568400145,
0.0375897959,
-0.630651772,
0.8717115521,
-0.4645255804,
0.2827001512,
0.3808128536,
0.539463222,
-0.0590007491,
-0.6810982227,
-0.1877294034,
-0.2561304569,
-0.2812943757,
0.3358399868,
-0.3309429586,
0.4394441247,
0.3644635081,
0.0225414112,
-0.558563292,
0.4499044418,
-0.0471453965,
-0.2719100416,
-0.1922018677,
0.3432581425,
0.2220838815,
-0.8128728271,
-0.4319349527,
0.0312845334,
-0.4276316464,
0.3098282516,
0.085031271,
0.5048867464,
-0.153298974,
0.3446501195,
-0.1338845938,
0.7031835318,
0.1826895773,
-0.4689570069,
0.2927073836,
-0.3699142337,
-0.0993910432,
0.232267797,
0.9532760382,
-0.0267773159,
-0.000532449,
0.109046869,
-0.1469134539,
-0.0537227951,
0.0745570883,
-1.2400478125,
-0.0305991583,
0.044560656,
-0.5375318527,
-0.1206360012,
-0.1422445029,
-0.6541639566,
-0.4184557498,
0.0604752116,
0.2922567427,
-0.4031407833,
0.1872416139,
-0.0670827925,
-0.2021856457,
0.2445017397,
0.2203915864,
-0.7114706039,
0.4177830815,
0.4751117229,
1.1434087753,
-0.0198426601,
-0.5969914198,
-0.9132473469,
0.0622961447,
-0.3516918719,
0.9549899101,
-0.5109151602,
-0.3391696811,
-0.1196516007,
-0.4214695394,
-0.1503197104,
-0.3504740298,
0.519962132,
-0.3755765557,
0.2589992285,
-0.0431138054,
-0.4119643271,
0.2282961607,
0.6024893522,
-0.3818728328,
1.190259099,
0.025160009,
-1.0433205366,
0.3366984725,
-0.5723550916,
-0.3678487241,
0.5434114933,
-0.3532489538,
-0.4384530187,
-0.2028719038,
0.2367964983,
0.3916774988,
-0.1607797891,
0.0655875504,
0.0345216691,
-0.5833147168,
-0.2431627512,
-0.3074625134,
0.6244120598,
-0.0437273979,
-0.1486275643,
0.297986418,
-0.6962214112,
0.0232444555,
-0.182691291,
-0.6457653642,
-0.4022928774,
-0.3655255437,
-0.000094031,
0.4512029588,
0.189097181,
-0.6544134021,
0.1700189412,
-0.5872762203,
0.0504771955,
0.6490055919,
0.3080377281,
0.5924390554,
-0.3328666389,
0.9166601896,
0.1362915784,
0.1618971825,
-0.3078801632,
-0.5956482291,
-0.4581313431,
-0.5319725871,
0.2030764371,
0.5940800905,
-0.8058936596,
0.4284105897,
-0.3809034824,
-0.4482956827,
-0.632007122,
0.1082118079,
0.5523731112,
0.7385669351,
0.4269169271,
-0.0523427837,
-0.3924416304,
-0.5995459557,
-0.1093153879,
-0.3028864563,
0.1899225712,
0.4673621058,
0.5304557085,
-0.3569298387,
1.1557048559,
-0.5364969969,
-0.7092725635,
-0.4789310992,
0.6019409299,
0.2704234719,
0.317689687,
0.3517294824,
-0.1593040824,
-0.4925777614,
-0.0493871048,
-0.6686078906,
-0.3002500534,
-0.1695883423,
-0.2421901822,
-0.2019042224,
0.4639772177,
-0.6470157504,
0.3193195462,
0.3530676365,
-0.081751138,
0.5351818204,
-0.1041942015,
0.057126753,
-0.9972184896,
-0.0987636819,
0.1797809601,
-0.1947278231,
-0.7293152809,
-0.2063770592,
-0.1436204314,
-0.0393204689,
-0.6892709136,
0.6234967113,
-0.248228848,
-0.0111379456,
-0.3481152654,
0.1712796837,
-0.1055506766,
0.672796309,
0.0341839455,
0.4185786545,
0.5913839936,
-0.4698043168,
0.1337783933,
0.5955212712,
-0.136990726,
0.6618655324,
-0.7224225998,
0.1037900746,
-0.2796114683,
0.5819355249,
-0.909244597,
-0.1507633328,
0.361084342,
-0.3565967381,
0.0594916977,
-0.4861794114,
-0.6656219363,
-0.4063143432,
-0.3993532956,
0.3837248981,
0.6757359505,
-0.660877645,
0.5193828344,
0.0191921834,
-0.1469117254,
-0.5764098763,
-0.5038057566,
0.0743999109,
-0.0252278056,
-0.4747059047,
0.3806964755,
-0.0331426486,
0.2821509838,
-0.2302852273,
-0.2653659582,
-0.0852997303,
-0.0285211653,
0.5704135895,
0.4029319584,
-0.2439640462,
0.1372596622,
0.0985350981,
-0.4082878828,
-0.1303349286,
-0.1887427568,
0.4114380479,
-0.3723154962,
0.0571663752,
-0.8051235676,
0.0566891804,
0.1983725727,
-0.2710599601,
0.6029294729,
0.7050204277,
-0.4264247715,
-0.1405362487,
-0.0941240788,
-0.0845431015,
-0.4669843614,
0.1901591122,
-0.7290867567,
-0.8304943442,
0.1494959146,
-0.3381750584,
-0.1188272685,
0.1792898923,
0.4442181289,
-0.1608367115,
1.0918569565,
0.5754865408,
-0.1225637645,
0.5912872553,
-0.3011738062,
0.0110841505,
-0.6045525074,
-0.1052843928,
-0.7372862101,
-0.1887831986,
-0.7356843948,
-0.0192321315,
0.6149032116,
0.0128690451,
-0.3596228957,
0.2677206397,
-0.3192960322,
0.6752519608,
0.6169065237,
0.132693395,
0.2919106185,
-0.1387797147,
-0.2597446442,
0.0092657181,
-1.0254700184,
-0.5921894312,
0.3411028385,
0.6557390094,
0.907063663,
-0.1642608494,
1.1815422773,
-0.1580735445,
0.1249209717,
-1.3124523163,
0.4867436886,
-0.1353885978,
-0.3300616443,
-0.2017875165,
-0.5719608068,
-0.9323377609,
0.3554469049,
-0.2181038409,
-0.5768023133,
0.2646669447,
0.1799374968,
-0.7075899839,
-0.1070328429,
-0.6157917976,
1.1623663902,
-0.008096219,
-0.3083607852,
0.1528128982,
-0.8685339689,
0.053144075,
0.089294523,
0.1403079629,
0.013348666,
-0.0175277367,
0.8965360522,
-0.3440870643,
1.0546174049,
-0.4600951374,
0.1428429186,
0.2584497333,
-0.004208873,
0.4433668256,
-0.2859046459,
0.2030895352,
0.0528343283,
-0.0499130264,
-0.4833016098,
-0.457770288,
0.3547461629,
-0.7170159221,
-0.3218977153,
-0.5840621591,
-0.4324950576,
-0.4395737648,
0.5071319342,
0.5781353116,
0.4852734208,
-0.3423892558,
0.0455466844,
0.2803299129,
-0.2724102736,
0.497638464,
0.2088669986,
0.0219306797,
-0.1285281181,
0.7867385745,
-0.0290345456,
0.0729834959,
0.3879443109,
0.7410419583,
-0.0727326199,
-0.4299265742,
-0.3043303192,
-0.0051049194,
-0.8491187692,
-0.3245407343,
-0.6162669063,
-0.4107995033,
-0.0867371708,
-0.2294362485,
-0.1880566627,
-0.1110411733,
-0.2758322954,
-0.1583375037,
0.059866894,
0.7090067863,
0.1758806556,
0.9868350029,
-0.7976787686,
0.6196647286,
0.2053452879,
0.2530169785,
-0.1509128213,
-0.6631433368,
-0.3560758531,
-0.3058579862,
-0.3011851907,
-0.645034492,
0.2223739177,
0.3713029325,
0.3919650018,
0.1909107715,
-0.0531593449,
0.823353231,
-0.6636639833,
0.6136679053,
0.4345414639,
-0.8644986153,
0.7574245334,
-0.2123428732,
0.8910441399,
0.7518664598,
0.588894546,
-0.5915464759,
-0.4960308671,
-0.2412229329,
-0.5938813686,
0.9389585853,
0.1840747893,
-0.0139408289,
0.0215206686,
-0.0311152022,
0.2128629982,
0.0423041545,
-0.6295253634,
-0.1699792147,
-0.3665549159,
-0.4393496215,
0.1386919767,
-0.0751962513,
0.1431188434,
-0.3229039013,
0.4484526813,
-0.2886219323,
-0.093206875,
-0.074874714,
-0.3651469946,
-0.0790971741,
0.7377209663,
-0.1525979191,
0.3321444988,
-0.4116196334,
0.3765986562,
-0.0754422471,
-0.4520990252,
0.4444342554,
0.1525902748,
-0.4095609188,
0.0443710871,
0.5525104403,
0.9101494551,
0.3334147036,
-0.2829897404,
0.7031621337,
0.0846953541,
-0.0670566335,
0.4315377772,
-0.1441230774,
-0.3154996336,
0.0358600914,
0.074709326,
0.2725557089,
0.2938962877,
-0.3765031099,
0.0665942729,
0.0606831424,
-0.4528951049,
-0.2773123682,
0.3400081396,
0.2147464752,
-0.1089553386,
0.649179697,
-0.5013136268,
-0.5479755402,
0.2577729225,
0.449596256,
0.9821277261,
-0.1710263491,
0.5183395147,
0.4324691892,
0.2859894335,
0.00250045,
-0.0139296483,
-0.2263954878,
-0.7285687327,
-0.2883518636,
-0.6080117822,
-0.3486857116,
-0.2445097268,
-0.473533988,
0.228284806,
-0.548483789,
-0.4946542382,
0.3858078122,
0.0425688997,
-0.6801877022,
-0.0398480184,
0.2137101144,
0.6646143198,
-0.7719917893,
0.8818386793,
0.7444750667,
-0.6416998506,
-0.4202824831,
0.2347415537,
0.0931142122,
-0.4326059818,
0.9011250734,
0.4255407453,
-0.5436486006,
0.2715444863,
-0.485152185,
-0.3947741985,
0.8473578095,
0.2262773812,
-0.4790017009,
-0.3276008666,
0.0924163982,
0.7128137946,
-0.1934666038,
0.3276447952,
0.6664747,
0.4931468368,
0.2384844422,
-0.9341673255,
-0.0782627091,
-0.07706137,
0.2916645706,
0.0981690511,
-0.333573848,
0.3557519615,
-0.3423812687,
-0.3998934627,
0.0915662125,
0.3871237934,
0.3153147995,
0.4040034711,
0.4280152023,
0.3376089036,
0.6760447621,
-0.0156473666,
1.0183035135,
0.0609827451,
0.3024733067,
1.2676562071,
-0.115606755,
0.8109616041,
0.3727272153,
0.0812611058,
0.6268301606,
0.7207195163,
0.0987033024,
0.5179751515,
0.1954233497,
-0.0712437928,
-0.2474190593,
-0.4978743494,
0.0743420944,
0.541680038,
0.0536618121,
0.1730197817,
-0.4406903386,
0.3083474636,
-0.0304565392,
-0.122374393,
-0.3602362573,
0.9775207043,
0.2007876635,
-0.3907244503,
0.7649419308,
0.1019073129,
0.9449937344,
-0.5534644127,
0.110571295,
-0.1236344203,
-0.0244711936,
-0.5022085905,
-0.6124795675,
-0.1099283174,
0.1435233355,
-0.0060511553,
-0.4336439967,
0.8741552234,
-0.3959299624,
-0.1389868706,
0.2670304179,
0.7775837779,
0.0566166565,
0.0346800387,
-0.7957351804,
-0.1361911446,
-0.6977239251,
-0.2615219951,
0.1092803553,
0.3023471534,
0.0692343861,
0.3734329045,
0.2079954445,
-0.0033365609,
0.2422966957,
0.5090712309,
0.5647798777,
-0.8300635815,
-0.7989854813,
-0.7538248301,
0.2815718651,
0.2362905294,
-0.4406095743,
0.8260506392,
0.511513412,
0.554435432,
0.1083596498,
0.5694441199,
0.1501169503,
0.1424535066,
-0.3653825819,
0.4492245317,
-0.2753576338,
0.1414172202,
-0.3962883651,
-0.7320221066,
-0.3281840086,
0.3939920962,
-0.320286572,
0.2366085351,
0.9833340645,
0.6637443304,
-0.0844091177,
-0.2242787778,
0.3512773216,
0.2898701727,
0.0830975994,
0.6223077178,
1.1775119305,
-0.4300151169,
0.7040938139,
-0.3321447372,
-0.5121576786,
-0.0865530819,
-0.622707665,
-0.9964274168,
-0.3895215392,
-0.479437232,
-0.272136122,
0.1373735964,
1.0586304665,
0.9295608997,
-0.4599119425,
-0.3758067489,
-0.0225871876,
0.2316720039,
-0.1473145038,
-0.2512530088,
0.284699589,
-0.6144441366,
-0.5831882358,
0.375169307,
0.4225302935,
0.1260471344,
0.1405138224,
-0.2443269938,
-0.0854358524,
-0.111776121,
0.8968101144,
0.114182815,
-0.3876200318,
-0.1682654172,
-0.0312731974,
-0.4560373724,
0.4511334002,
0.6993367076,
-0.9688584805,
0.3694940209,
0.6191083789,
0.6729999185,
0.5486212373,
0.1922630817,
0.0346078351,
-1.3266100883,
0.0561537929,
0.2928879261,
0.1849058867,
0.1922804862,
-0.2166970521,
0.1291434765,
0.0793809146,
-0.3678279519,
-0.5311816335,
0.1810403317,
-1.003905654,
-0.2542291582,
1.2388830185,
0.0270623695,
-0.2817060947,
-0.0077914805,
-0.3609407246,
0.1695674956,
-0.6086441278,
0.3646728992,
0.5749637485,
-0.2729488015,
-0.2321885079,
-0.4007714987,
0.5240322948,
0.1309696883,
-1.1634556055,
-0.1641456485,
0.7893394828,
-0.146318078,
0.1278645098,
0.9081614017,
0.0820181891,
0.2948537767,
0.0333171301,
-0.0591127686,
0.1015393734,
-0.7311846018,
-0.5916676521,
0.3296251297,
0.2957735062,
-0.4535159469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16867v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16867v1 | Playing repeated games with Large Language Models | 2023-05-26T12:17:59 | 2023-05-26T12:17:59 | Elif Akata, Lion Schulz, Julian Coda-Forno, Seong Joon Oh, Matthias Bethge, Eric Schulz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are transforming society and permeating into
diverse applications. As a result, LLMs will frequently interact with us and
other agents. It is, therefore, of great societal value to understand how LLMs
behave in interactive social settings. Here, we propose to use behavioral game
theory to study LLM's cooperation and coordination behavior. To do so, we let
different LLMs (GPT-3, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4) play finitely repeated games with
each other and with other, human-like strategies. Our results show that LLMs
generally perform well in such tasks and also uncover persistent behavioral
signatures. In a large set of two players-two strategies games, we find that
LLMs are particularly good at games where valuing their own self-interest pays
off, like the iterated Prisoner's Dilemma family. However, they behave
sub-optimally in games that require coordination. We, therefore, further focus
on two games from these distinct families. In the canonical iterated Prisoner's
Dilemma, we find that GPT-4 acts particularly unforgivingly, always defecting
after another agent has defected only once. In the Battle of the Sexes, we find
that GPT-4 cannot match the behavior of the simple convention to alternate
between options. We verify that these behavioral signatures are stable across
robustness checks. Finally, we show how GPT-4's behavior can be modified by
providing further information about the other player as well as by asking it to
predict the other player's actions before making a choice. These results enrich
our understanding of LLM's social behavior and pave the way for a behavioral
game theory for machines. | [
-0.1311691403,
-0.8991748095,
0.8735664487,
0.4322712123,
-0.039446786,
0.3677227795,
-0.2074539661,
-0.1845141798,
0.2263117582,
0.5529037714,
-0.560983181,
-0.4360520244,
-0.4475908279,
0.1302708834,
-0.0337590612,
0.8342258334,
-0.075347662,
0.214647755,
-0.0609546453,
-0.2633270323,
-0.5000527501,
-0.7457941771,
-0.870362699,
-1.0145735741,
0.6453443766,
0.1158369258,
0.8403283358,
0.6143590212,
0.4425655305,
0.5004517436,
-0.0249004979,
-0.0399540775,
-1.0296052694,
0.3748910427,
-0.3626179695,
-0.4696325958,
-0.1279168278,
0.0869524553,
0.6017401218,
0.5088510513,
-0.5564333797,
-0.3209808171,
-0.0292155221,
0.7163892388,
0.1153819934,
0.2684307694,
-0.4676288664,
0.0919384807,
-0.2949408591,
-0.0383604467,
-0.2940947711,
-0.2698041499,
0.0042281635,
-0.578079164,
-0.1060915291,
0.1535789669,
0.6421444416,
0.0267098714,
-0.4463428259,
-0.4072091579,
-0.9381889105,
0.5721495748,
-0.4748093784,
0.0167436488,
0.3508518934,
0.0754289255,
-0.9338371158,
-0.4169795513,
-0.6477673054,
-0.5099332333,
-0.0664546564,
0.1661868989,
-0.0882238522,
0.1241832748,
0.3373869956,
0.1275924444,
-0.426577419,
0.0471387841,
-0.318925947,
0.1170200408,
0.4282194376,
0.632166326,
0.3961410224,
0.1930125207,
-0.4435248673,
0.2158739567,
-0.5478513241,
0.3746559322,
0.5184937119,
0.049281016,
-0.2963991463,
0.5848070979,
0.252140969,
0.4146607518,
0.4016675055,
0.0110037057,
-0.0672023147,
-0.2681494951,
0.179433465,
-0.0645808131,
0.857629478,
0.5345197916,
0.4091685414,
-0.3870334029,
-0.2722429931,
0.3953516781,
0.2763594091,
-0.2540702522,
-0.2715400457,
0.1220855042,
-0.5439376831,
-0.4124459922,
-0.0789374337,
-0.7585360408,
-0.5261417031,
-0.2098134905,
0.484069556,
-0.4645633101,
-0.3068237007,
0.3321688175,
-0.3441504836,
0.4895276129,
0.087360844,
-1.0800508261,
0.7131569982,
0.8976801634,
0.929461956,
-0.4973141849,
-0.7222906351,
-0.6130712032,
0.5078968406,
-0.4715183973,
0.4559507072,
-0.6213579178,
-0.4682123065,
0.0068239071,
-0.0574570447,
-0.0409394801,
-0.4172791839,
-0.0811441243,
-0.4928029776,
-0.1776672155,
-0.5210413337,
-0.6092298627,
0.1346587092,
0.7462394834,
-0.8503670096,
0.7160724998,
-0.0757803246,
-0.4868100286,
0.1774202585,
-0.5649712682,
-0.4769017398,
0.002918995,
-0.2179997414,
-0.3292562664,
0.0250049252,
-0.4444020391,
0.1632844359,
-0.0671005994,
0.1060190946,
-0.7341052294,
-0.7268179655,
0.4145478606,
0.1570379138,
0.6455337405,
-0.0719226599,
-0.243318513,
0.1991337985,
-0.1858053058,
-0.336856842,
0.4235380292,
-0.6040942669,
-0.1285640001,
0.3753015399,
-0.6677947044,
0.178294301,
0.2106022686,
-0.3073464632,
0.544780314,
0.0562762879,
0.5844935179,
0.8170523047,
0.0779591948,
0.5221349597,
-0.8628113866,
0.4403826892,
-0.1385582238,
0.2138515413,
0.3459436297,
-0.4305101335,
-0.4542230368,
-0.1550811976,
-0.1529601216,
0.5564765334,
-0.8430185914,
0.0987512395,
-0.1144938692,
-0.2706080675,
0.1955700368,
0.0175775457,
0.1913703233,
-0.2106633484,
0.0670595989,
-0.2843396962,
-0.4597868919,
-0.2999249399,
-0.2408850938,
-0.3835852146,
0.3622088134,
0.3289530277,
0.4965904057,
-0.325995028,
0.6385287642,
-0.0808789209,
-0.1561411917,
-0.4178346395,
0.202118367,
0.1918738186,
0.3750809133,
0.36413908,
-0.3921405673,
-0.313134402,
-0.0098760147,
-0.7781272531,
0.1660021096,
-0.1275892556,
-0.234412387,
0.2772897184,
0.4904550016,
-0.6811723113,
0.0918442458,
0.6699607372,
-0.4774669409,
0.5025301576,
-0.2959410548,
0.198539868,
-0.5527642965,
-0.3694787621,
-0.2953980565,
-0.2652374804,
-0.7070066333,
0.266831845,
-0.4585168064,
0.2798234522,
-0.0186849851,
0.4028988183,
-0.3683642447,
-0.3638304472,
-0.1540789157,
0.2353795618,
-0.4594223499,
0.5029885173,
0.1130005568,
0.4310511053,
0.4609186351,
-0.6398034692,
0.6103391051,
-0.0236114021,
-0.17446661,
0.5030552149,
-0.7320330143,
0.3099832535,
-0.0369052291,
0.3267531991,
-0.9930692315,
-0.0511910804,
0.348715961,
-0.2838020623,
0.2576910555,
-0.0904505923,
-0.5866393447,
-0.2638260126,
-0.3829806149,
0.105919987,
0.411054194,
-0.3674133718,
0.8143219948,
0.3460780978,
-0.0932778195,
-0.4760718942,
-0.4227550924,
0.0360716358,
-0.2765508592,
-0.5967147946,
0.2127255648,
-0.2814053893,
-0.5948571563,
-0.1908506602,
-0.0237775203,
0.1000843421,
0.07904654,
0.3163981438,
0.1655067205,
0.0486001,
0.0077195354,
-0.4175036252,
0.0275114514,
0.0273294114,
-0.1571646631,
0.8929651976,
-0.2957768738,
-0.2219131738,
0.1128488481,
0.5093142986,
0.5716559291,
0.1120045409,
0.6386272311,
0.3868540525,
-0.1639923155,
0.2163868248,
-0.4767271876,
-0.1029262617,
-0.5267938972,
0.2623433769,
-0.453656137,
-1.1036242247,
1.0013734102,
-0.1027399227,
0.18560265,
-0.2489331067,
0.6068183184,
-0.2756401896,
0.9207013249,
0.4968223572,
-0.2433400601,
0.4993794262,
0.0908022672,
-0.1033688262,
-0.5387795568,
-0.1901349723,
-0.3026427925,
-0.5343363285,
-0.7458512783,
-0.343552798,
0.1327693015,
0.070953466,
-0.8241852522,
0.2559939325,
0.0148355691,
0.6673097014,
0.3609835207,
0.2940506041,
0.3030302227,
-0.1950143427,
-0.2553869784,
0.0426658578,
-0.5072413683,
-0.2948232591,
0.7158260345,
0.2367597669,
0.8052457571,
0.6615128517,
1.0083215237,
0.1332135797,
0.2023329437,
-0.5507848263,
0.639233768,
-0.1488807946,
-0.4764645994,
-0.564938426,
-0.5085965991,
-1.2912154198,
0.0653663203,
-0.1990758479,
-0.9224055409,
-0.095368512,
0.1192879304,
-0.3057948053,
0.2348006368,
-0.2166890502,
0.6360933781,
-0.2291475534,
-0.6346442699,
-0.313985914,
-0.4958600402,
0.5970474482,
0.1488870829,
0.2195961177,
0.0848721564,
-0.1297558546,
0.3688517213,
-0.0942192376,
0.7881212831,
0.0580674484,
-0.1763784736,
0.0168995149,
0.5220125318,
0.9030832648,
0.1399573088,
-0.1312869489,
0.1628479064,
0.1080418006,
-0.3492797911,
-0.4278018773,
0.8292215466,
-0.8711280823,
-0.8255442977,
-0.6344503164,
-0.4480644166,
-0.0032406098,
0.1369808763,
0.1154784709,
0.2094231844,
-0.3370372951,
0.2175092548,
0.6506817341,
-0.1144067049,
0.5058152676,
0.765188098,
-0.3348021507,
-0.2315403968,
0.7703334093,
-0.1607322246,
0.3921463192,
0.2347701788,
0.2190290987,
-0.1083880067,
-0.3724122047,
-0.0910264328,
0.3080591261,
-0.3912810981,
0.1707983464,
-0.3443948328,
0.2612352371,
0.0102517772,
-0.2789254785,
-0.1263194382,
0.1588794589,
0.0825760886,
-0.1111917496,
0.1994413584,
1.075512886,
-0.3546769023,
0.4079048932,
-0.600283742,
0.443223536,
0.5156205893,
0.4976830184,
-0.0979032665,
-0.2034011781,
0.2742425501,
-0.130767405,
-0.1788334101,
-1.1904038191,
0.0108001661,
-0.1620759964,
0.7078462243,
0.2280065417,
-0.2610545456,
0.5280280709,
-0.631413877,
0.929663837,
0.0801719725,
-0.9008662105,
-0.1799497753,
-0.8579341769,
-0.0119239325,
0.2349959165,
0.0724069402,
-0.7494512796,
-0.2550490201,
-0.4031220675,
-0.5228894949,
0.8799487352,
0.1057306677,
0.2096997797,
-0.2423526198,
0.45392555,
-0.1704879254,
0.1047222391,
-1.0981572866,
-0.4030453861,
-0.0785384998,
0.0355732627,
0.0480730683,
-0.2175932527,
-0.314837724,
0.0085174302,
0.4291270673,
0.159373641,
0.3454701006,
-0.2056698203,
0.2209902108,
-0.3425497413,
0.0178841334,
0.6276659369,
0.3924825191,
0.0169935115,
0.0889766589,
0.1572457701,
-0.2166496515,
0.5152136683,
-0.1531429291,
0.0390724428,
-0.2887963355,
0.2542442679,
0.4177196324,
0.4156528711,
-0.4452819824,
0.4682340622,
-0.256339699,
-0.3223056197,
-0.3265586793,
0.1010173187,
0.4021787047,
0.6967995763,
-0.1391470432,
-0.2742882371,
-0.007757741,
-1.0585445166,
0.249485895,
0.7474443913,
-0.1622239053,
-0.1671642363,
0.2016274035,
0.0661718249,
-0.6714886427,
0.477203697,
-0.6162267923,
-0.6785669327,
0.6371043324,
0.6638977528,
0.5054066777,
-0.1812992245,
0.3547960222,
0.209060505,
0.2920239866,
-0.5676453114,
0.4681541324,
0.0770526826,
-0.8904802799,
-0.2935368419,
-0.1229210943,
-0.3975790441,
0.227083683,
-0.4342643619,
0.1665025502,
-0.623249352,
-0.0690001473,
-0.2986158133,
0.1183936596,
-0.5432755947,
-0.6570565104,
-0.0341132246,
0.0898754522,
-0.5039311647,
0.5815967917,
0.6933848858,
-0.2748496532,
-0.6927496195,
-0.0171289742,
0.1223976389,
-0.797437489,
0.4926417172,
-0.1064167097,
-0.2041413337,
-0.049588412,
-0.9027106166,
-0.9116918445,
1.134876132,
0.0946515352,
-0.7202484608,
0.0302012376,
-0.0609976649,
0.3917293847,
-0.1392521262,
-0.0375759006,
0.9027310014,
0.6013086438,
0.1125421524,
-0.7437795997,
0.1592760235,
0.0280480795,
-0.0401678421,
0.3755336702,
-0.9826621413,
0.9694715738,
-0.4662479758,
-0.172736451,
0.4411337972,
0.3908387125,
0.7559909225,
0.1821174771,
0.6371979117,
0.2472582012,
0.6283019185,
-0.1399311721,
0.7395540476,
-0.0865452886,
0.3096505702,
1.0706101656,
-0.7931258082,
0.4423052073,
0.47305125,
-0.3219807148,
0.567945838,
0.334220916,
-0.1421504915,
0.2219141126,
0.6574375033,
-0.1011071876,
-0.4336913526,
0.3077824414,
-0.0443767123,
0.4856746495,
0.4730294347,
-0.0508750007,
-0.243409723,
-0.2202791721,
0.0302192606,
0.2312701046,
-0.1233408824,
0.946315527,
0.0166392047,
-0.6334473491,
0.060758803,
-0.0638164729,
0.7772875428,
-0.7881461382,
-0.15029037,
-0.3782921433,
0.19329606,
0.0941445827,
-0.7740811706,
-0.1051330566,
-0.2747487128,
-0.2663944066,
0.0948548913,
0.4403716922,
-0.5234330297,
0.0465390794,
0.4653391242,
0.3209792674,
0.2282279283,
0.3104773462,
-0.6297404766,
0.3765311241,
-0.1065944582,
-0.2119868845,
0.5529764891,
0.6059353948,
-0.0186339375,
0.8248432279,
0.4620331824,
0.1878338754,
0.0020185218,
-0.0860723704,
0.505219698,
-0.7418003082,
-0.4290612638,
-1.1559611559,
0.0813586786,
-0.1182061583,
-0.0528166145,
0.4740538001,
0.168528676,
0.5725566149,
-0.0153469145,
0.5418610573,
0.1049135178,
0.0465282053,
-0.6120846272,
0.3337973058,
-0.0337817147,
0.2615499198,
-0.2937976718,
-0.6319621205,
0.0763690323,
0.6986786723,
-0.1253311634,
0.1526621282,
0.5847054124,
0.6007955074,
0.2932993174,
-0.0052619027,
0.343200773,
0.2232693881,
0.5704920292,
0.7926549315,
1.1445218325,
0.0658474267,
0.674269557,
0.0414939113,
-0.166099444,
-0.0539634153,
-0.896587193,
-1.0082535744,
-0.3768871725,
-0.1121016741,
-0.5075960159,
0.2074854225,
1.2018235922,
0.3795003295,
-0.2698729932,
-0.5641084909,
-0.0802978426,
0.2891639769,
-0.5553902984,
-0.2045874745,
-0.1017211005,
-0.2951025069,
-0.5409539938,
0.2604786456,
0.204546839,
0.1917154193,
-0.1991958022,
-0.4139329493,
-0.2055945545,
0.2328007668,
0.5871575475,
0.5015915632,
-0.7604815364,
-0.3877012432,
0.0489889197,
-0.1317033023,
-0.1662158221,
1.1262996197,
-0.4087482095,
0.2349578291,
0.3682404757,
0.2355200797,
0.3545598686,
-0.0213120487,
0.7884693146,
-0.4163134992,
-0.0367873237,
0.1060580313,
0.5230409503,
0.1984855533,
-0.3685573339,
0.5052534342,
0.1154876277,
-0.8399496675,
-0.5322390795,
0.3789750934,
-0.7976224422,
-0.2094171941,
1.3455030918,
-0.1968685091,
-0.0347178504,
-0.3918372095,
-0.2948842645,
0.184506312,
-0.6482346058,
0.8727861643,
1.15817976,
-0.3676448464,
-0.1160205379,
-0.3993571699,
0.7550329566,
0.2946115732,
-0.4856610596,
0.2237389833,
0.510363996,
0.3220927417,
0.1524914205,
0.8414211869,
-0.0828780159,
0.3259503543,
-0.1423300356,
-0.2260893136,
-0.033209756,
-0.1274787039,
-0.4279282987,
-0.1519498974,
0.0692952052,
-0.0338813178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16863v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16863v2 | Controlling Learned Effects to Reduce Spurious Correlations in Text Classifiers | 2023-05-26T12:15:54 | 2023-06-21T07:06:15 | Parikshit Bansal, Amit Sharma | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | To address the problem of NLP classifiers learning spurious correlations
between training features and target labels, a common approach is to make the
model's predictions invariant to these features. However, this can be
counter-productive when the features have a non-zero causal effect on the
target label and thus are important for prediction. Therefore, using methods
from the causal inference literature, we propose an algorithm to regularize the
learnt effect of the features on the model's prediction to the estimated effect
of feature on label. This results in an automated augmentation method that
leverages the estimated effect of a feature to appropriately change the labels
for new augmented inputs. On toxicity and IMDB review datasets, the proposed
algorithm minimises spurious correlations and improves the minority group
(i.e., samples breaking spurious correlations) accuracy, while also improving
the total accuracy compared to standard training. | [
-0.3299054503,
-0.750708282,
0.228388682,
0.2202977687,
-0.2379236221,
-0.1624599993,
-0.0388926528,
-0.6314176917,
0.6674620509,
0.7140372396,
-0.4630213678,
-0.2408702672,
-0.9549705982,
0.0824180692,
-0.4035289586,
1.4704186916,
0.2306005955,
-0.1063788533,
-0.0547778979,
-0.1301008314,
-0.7239761949,
-0.5158922076,
-0.6235286593,
-0.3489304483,
0.8590477705,
0.3391206861,
0.9809115529,
0.6331167817,
0.6676310897,
0.0969283879,
-0.2598264813,
0.1560713798,
-0.6638516188,
-0.073502019,
-0.3177635372,
-0.5896729827,
-0.4213805795,
0.1299275309,
0.6434968114,
0.7450294495,
0.3230311573,
-0.0609615669,
0.2966410816,
0.5419937372,
-0.7948678136,
0.0655410886,
-0.5358405709,
0.089685142,
0.04814988,
-0.8600634933,
-0.5585804582,
-0.2328998446,
0.288985759,
-0.5620544553,
0.4509677589,
0.1095555201,
1.0098910332,
0.7067466974,
-0.324593246,
0.0931675956,
-0.8789803982,
0.926851511,
-0.6358135343,
0.2254442722,
0.5363073349,
-0.1521683186,
-0.342459172,
-0.5351775885,
-0.1781017333,
-0.1534816623,
-0.4622990191,
0.2013411075,
0.2151996791,
0.2692305744,
0.4644751549,
0.0599789061,
-0.2352058738,
0.3420438468,
-0.5110525489,
-0.3874352276,
0.8382200599,
0.0131402044,
0.292247057,
-0.0500992239,
-0.4559197724,
-0.046185676,
-0.5085458159,
0.0499324314,
0.1373797208,
0.3616594374,
0.1029322073,
0.5563549399,
0.0248671919,
0.6071625352,
0.0864494741,
-0.2016347051,
0.195704475,
-0.2001055777,
-0.1756096482,
0.4199047685,
0.6671027541,
0.5407447219,
0.0253595449,
-0.0252083056,
0.0041471715,
0.3484898806,
0.2062571198,
-0.5630393624,
-0.3366040587,
0.1453594267,
-0.2471846789,
-0.4659909308,
-0.0506275594,
-0.8790127635,
-0.4041570425,
-0.4109099805,
0.5504473448,
-0.2893267572,
0.1044972837,
-0.0553927869,
-0.3662129939,
-0.208148554,
0.3259981871,
-0.7057376504,
0.1400573999,
0.3371154666,
0.7490232587,
-0.2932255864,
-0.3208973706,
-0.6386119723,
0.3609106243,
-0.2527836859,
0.6466719508,
-0.669688642,
-0.4403708279,
-0.1214680001,
-0.0910593271,
-0.131291315,
-0.3647230566,
0.7571402192,
-0.5819244981,
0.2758879066,
-0.0401484556,
-0.6351600289,
-0.3175421953,
0.0582043827,
-0.9098599553,
0.9350693226,
-0.1496406496,
-0.9989093542,
0.7855184674,
-0.363367945,
-0.4471864998,
-0.2603161037,
0.2548053265,
-0.6779012084,
-0.0565189384,
0.4021179974,
0.2881305516,
0.0052066832,
0.6966848969,
-0.384634465,
-0.5640799999,
0.1894711852,
-0.4009760916,
0.786174655,
-0.0043756356,
-0.1724694371,
0.3543574512,
-0.8322973251,
-0.3942920864,
-0.3291878104,
-0.2516805232,
-0.7207574844,
0.1575502604,
0.0325705595,
0.2326787859,
-0.0005129246,
-0.1957212985,
0.1957561225,
-0.2662499547,
-0.2110459954,
0.6437147856,
0.6159595847,
0.542978704,
-0.5093421936,
0.1732010245,
0.2147857994,
0.4194018543,
-0.1190179586,
-0.7163006663,
-0.8043156266,
-0.3025219142,
0.423604846,
0.6183523536,
-0.6336340904,
0.7259005308,
-0.026952805,
-0.2493369728,
-0.1866096258,
0.4006906748,
0.4355001748,
0.6406578422,
0.6422666907,
-0.6030616164,
-0.5772925019,
-0.6111664772,
-0.5440211296,
-0.0123779448,
-0.1961399019,
0.1571755558,
0.3046064973,
-0.4082943797,
1.0155322552,
-0.5584460497,
-0.6849527955,
0.2279223949,
0.2651349902,
0.0254454594,
0.8366447687,
0.4601953924,
-0.7743602395,
-0.3394778371,
-0.2248404622,
-0.5344869494,
-0.2635267973,
-0.6318386197,
-0.1591118425,
-0.0609020814,
0.8286063075,
-0.0614776425,
0.4853194356,
0.1438891143,
-0.2654235661,
0.2652176321,
-0.2395670712,
0.0439474024,
-0.5593369007,
-0.0702738836,
0.2892666459,
0.144484058,
-0.6820063591,
-0.4364210665,
0.188708812,
0.1274170876,
-0.3271028101,
0.5272669792,
-0.1676282287,
0.4300515652,
-0.0996172652,
0.1296910942,
0.2442052066,
0.6211001277,
0.0849247351,
0.4206219912,
0.406448245,
-0.8857662082,
-0.2117385864,
0.1774968654,
0.094728902,
0.3905406892,
-0.3777417839,
-0.2120390087,
-0.3511103392,
0.1605047733,
-0.6767722368,
-0.3010967374,
0.1384580433,
-0.5646548867,
0.608974576,
0.0253168419,
-0.2581422627,
-0.0050350996,
-0.3354282379,
0.0667424724,
0.3072301745,
-0.613060832,
0.558978796,
0.3644076288,
0.1038491353,
-0.8902323842,
-0.6606504321,
-0.0499133393,
-0.3080091476,
-0.0956108645,
0.4159473479,
0.214377135,
0.0315620303,
0.0541980937,
0.0546011701,
-0.3222475648,
0.1936966032,
0.1478392482,
0.4623721242,
0.3089956939,
0.4167450666,
0.5457684398,
-0.1673987359,
0.0619434901,
-0.0913835093,
0.1804052442,
0.4280320406,
0.1349773556,
-0.4226434231,
0.0566990897,
0.4069083929,
-0.1824270338,
0.7286847234,
0.5579966903,
-0.1229488999,
-0.2966450155,
-0.4055472612,
-0.4665372968,
-0.447948277,
0.4499755204,
0.0039686807,
-0.7330447435,
0.4953148961,
-0.0892527401,
-0.1260303855,
0.6088749766,
0.1059812531,
-0.0642026663,
1.103255868,
0.9002030492,
-0.2906071246,
0.874558568,
-0.1508032829,
0.0479568876,
-0.815335989,
-0.2837393284,
-0.3166092634,
-0.2928314507,
-0.7390259504,
-0.3453867435,
0.415551424,
0.320199877,
0.019518042,
0.1870005876,
-0.5695317388,
0.3695608974,
0.6780068278,
0.56145823,
0.2604310513,
-0.0108665032,
-0.1502435505,
-0.1772182584,
-0.7830246091,
-0.0801786855,
1.2053828239,
0.1896699071,
0.8424538374,
-0.188502267,
0.5797386765,
0.4946453273,
0.5270174146,
-0.6672555804,
0.1454419792,
-0.1154336184,
-0.6875411272,
-0.256278038,
-0.353315562,
-0.747512877,
-0.0582020134,
-0.6668395996,
-0.5558473468,
0.6632300615,
0.3331132531,
-0.0974774063,
0.2032893747,
-0.8407095671,
0.5263275504,
-0.0629665479,
-0.7586550117,
-0.3094996512,
-0.7260711789,
0.6202933192,
-0.3730945587,
0.0415621325,
0.1214038506,
-0.0419495925,
0.8717508912,
-0.3183646798,
1.1255702972,
-0.2048492432,
0.1750628352,
0.4010943174,
-0.0497424453,
0.3594204187,
-0.0727106854,
-0.0046796356,
0.302107811,
-0.2288244367,
-0.507262826,
-0.6795665026,
0.5555470586,
-0.6807987094,
-0.5241982937,
-0.3305945992,
-0.7706961036,
-0.3206776977,
0.2185391784,
0.2787342668,
0.1879447997,
-0.0692540631,
-0.0128071764,
0.6415804029,
-0.3873705864,
0.4121187329,
0.2455405295,
-0.1538717002,
-0.5352606773,
0.8469430804,
0.2859000266,
0.404437989,
0.409935832,
0.3343828917,
-0.141210705,
-0.3864726424,
-0.0039563864,
0.1632163674,
-0.6288675666,
-0.1750261188,
-0.7275005579,
-0.2249221206,
-0.3237870634,
-0.3062058985,
0.0129438257,
-0.5011076331,
-0.5157594085,
-0.1550615132,
0.5901581049,
0.41637519,
-0.2385189235,
0.7208007574,
-0.9253085256,
0.0353748053,
0.3574367464,
0.498367548,
-0.0951532722,
-0.8258516788,
-0.4273878634,
-0.3035399616,
-0.3569761813,
-0.7411083579,
0.6797410846,
0.4090106189,
0.4335334003,
0.7511634827,
0.2254111171,
0.4925643802,
-0.3617944717,
0.4712747931,
0.2518184781,
-0.9307128191,
0.7461236715,
-0.16338557,
-0.0330989696,
0.4772232175,
0.6241724491,
-0.2891066968,
-0.6817067266,
-0.7096893191,
-0.7408323288,
0.6912894845,
0.2565115988,
-0.1044749171,
0.0645674765,
0.3845045865,
-0.0345816836,
0.0384961665,
-0.5953709483,
-0.4320974052,
-0.1695474982,
0.0140343914,
-0.2237366289,
-0.5612882972,
-0.0491678454,
-0.3459815085,
0.8102917075,
0.17365098,
-0.2037265301,
0.4650021195,
-0.1563794315,
-0.2068281323,
0.0712998733,
0.5330641866,
0.2295001596,
-0.6542631984,
0.199351266,
0.2137764841,
-0.7102360725,
-0.0218373779,
0.031319499,
-0.6473537683,
0.159242183,
0.3064758182,
0.7293382883,
0.1527618021,
-0.4420983493,
0.3227718472,
0.0175738018,
0.0339679532,
0.1075624526,
0.3755998611,
-0.4559420049,
-0.1487370729,
0.1780474484,
0.5720838308,
0.3778484762,
-0.1569513232,
0.6398946643,
0.3272300959,
-0.8495742083,
-0.0556985922,
0.7559101582,
0.1939578354,
-0.2420035154,
0.2130261958,
0.1642802507,
-0.5192368031,
0.7902756929,
0.5421203375,
0.7431317568,
-0.4890182316,
0.0322078466,
0.7809342146,
0.6110988855,
-0.0703807399,
-0.1702600867,
0.0741542429,
-0.8037750125,
-0.6186110377,
-0.3526452482,
-0.7351528406,
-0.1795223057,
-0.841868639,
0.5310962796,
-0.7253565192,
-0.2458991408,
0.132098794,
-0.2370419204,
-0.3061174154,
0.4844073653,
-0.1886098683,
0.466702491,
-1.3424965143,
0.9847750068,
0.2636846304,
-0.6227413416,
-0.701741457,
-0.0383446179,
0.0039767125,
-0.2576165795,
0.731637001,
0.148695305,
0.0870691389,
-0.0305603705,
-0.6135079265,
-0.9407268763,
0.5104052424,
-0.0537458658,
-0.5688541532,
0.2769199014,
-0.0436884388,
0.4966314137,
0.0805054456,
0.3242810071,
0.6609073281,
0.4238226116,
-0.1021113172,
-0.8441398144,
-0.031459339,
-0.2213154733,
-0.1462382227,
0.2703742683,
-0.3470054567,
0.5338979363,
-0.2818900645,
-0.0965019464,
-0.5016302466,
0.4350390434,
0.0279095806,
0.3244696259,
0.4367674589,
0.3251723349,
0.9171768427,
0.0678995103,
1.0374658108,
-0.3754264116,
0.4507385194,
1.2603977919,
-0.1247386038,
0.4744084179,
0.6085312366,
-0.2211033106,
0.4362621605,
0.5432198048,
-0.3220851719,
0.5532577634,
-0.11267481,
-0.2616974413,
0.0269542634,
-0.3458840549,
-0.1064819917,
0.2341402769,
0.7195905447,
-0.6280515194,
-0.1362902373,
0.1206536219,
-0.0463854149,
0.0458102114,
-0.3785595298,
0.7246210575,
0.0266090054,
-0.5404458642,
0.6550108194,
-0.1926252693,
0.9775264859,
-0.4571953118,
-0.2376523614,
-0.0862880498,
0.239882037,
-0.5573813915,
-0.3401756883,
0.5555973649,
-0.3110952079,
-0.4477499425,
0.1631257534,
0.7237099409,
-0.545175612,
-0.5152148604,
0.5661313534,
0.0587511212,
-0.0734131709,
0.1593743563,
-0.5400806069,
-0.2933966219,
0.1002277955,
0.0835284293,
0.2402798086,
0.2231722176,
-0.356703788,
0.4992796183,
0.8044392467,
0.2769490778,
0.190190509,
0.0866831765,
0.7625187039,
-0.5937127471,
-0.4923730493,
-0.6264187098,
0.4729075134,
-0.1883300394,
-0.2851019204,
0.7053475976,
0.4966282547,
0.7897897363,
-0.2163147479,
0.579017818,
0.2446080893,
0.5835691094,
-0.5295254588,
0.7716288567,
-0.3596165776,
0.529931128,
-0.4865540862,
-0.8249803782,
-1.0148444176,
0.3887804449,
-0.376793623,
-0.240582034,
0.8967629671,
0.9046397209,
0.1736828089,
-0.1466391385,
0.3928315938,
0.2909318507,
0.314958483,
0.1889865249,
0.4840258956,
-0.5246393681,
0.4218146801,
-0.8005290627,
-0.3598290086,
-0.2014352232,
-0.8999273181,
-1.0034735203,
-0.1915336847,
-0.5493083,
-0.4999384284,
-0.0306503046,
0.674683094,
0.3623189628,
-1.0071074963,
0.1150190756,
-0.215138033,
0.4875645041,
-0.4427681267,
-0.3348042071,
0.7305096388,
-0.6586130261,
-0.8129398823,
0.0265169591,
0.2525928915,
-0.0048944135,
0.0006304518,
0.1145355031,
-0.3785359263,
0.1243715361,
0.5300956964,
0.2301394939,
-0.4672427177,
-0.3139095008,
-0.1786385179,
0.0392245613,
0.1454476714,
0.803172946,
-0.8715266585,
0.7978817821,
0.4109891653,
0.4861005545,
0.4521479905,
-0.0505357757,
0.5485440493,
-0.7596714497,
0.5533341169,
0.2700508237,
0.2755437791,
0.1931543648,
-0.8227793574,
0.5022469759,
0.2612446547,
-0.5056394339,
-0.6794326901,
-0.0376927853,
-0.8992028832,
-0.2589957416,
0.7979037762,
-0.008593753,
-0.2334093601,
-0.4043067992,
-0.2481871247,
0.5522760153,
-0.3238014579,
0.9897896647,
0.2714045942,
-0.1796071827,
-0.0331989378,
-0.364944309,
0.8121811748,
0.7254266739,
-0.6164410114,
-0.2031958103,
0.6445642114,
0.1934996247,
0.3272294998,
0.1218660027,
-0.234340921,
0.2014689744,
0.060433723,
0.2629542649,
0.1966996342,
-0.5447565317,
-0.5757758617,
-0.154307425,
-0.0603069402,
-0.0145158395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16859v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16859v1 | Scientific Fact-Checking: A Survey of Resources and Approaches | 2023-05-26T12:12:15 | 2023-05-26T12:12:15 | Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of fact-checking deals with assessing the veracity of factual claims
based on credible evidence and background knowledge. In particular, scientific
fact-checking is the variation of the task concerned with verifying claims
rooted in scientific knowledge. This task has received significant attention
due to the growing importance of scientific and health discussions on online
platforms. Automated scientific fact-checking methods based on NLP can help
combat the spread of misinformation, assist researchers in knowledge discovery,
and help individuals understand new scientific breakthroughs. In this paper, we
present a comprehensive survey of existing research in this emerging field and
its related tasks. We provide a task description, discuss the construction
process of existing datasets, and analyze proposed models and approaches. Based
on our findings, we identify intriguing challenges and outline potential future
directions to advance the field. | [
-0.1043471768,
-0.7810598016,
0.7494005561,
0.2133848667,
0.0021385844,
0.2116204351,
0.0541763082,
-0.6159770489,
0.2346297055,
0.5209303498,
-0.3540700674,
-0.4980918765,
-0.9113097787,
0.665900588,
-0.4960958958,
1.0517103672,
-0.0770034492,
0.172411263,
-0.6213240623,
0.0097711142,
-0.1370647401,
-0.408033371,
-0.5487203002,
-0.2597869039,
0.5198355913,
0.341917336,
0.3815356195,
0.4122983217,
0.8620929122,
0.335347563,
-0.2120687962,
0.5305749774,
0.0087077282,
0.2159918696,
-0.318518877,
-0.5016964078,
-0.242339775,
0.1932141036,
0.4473386705,
0.5681133866,
-0.0997786149,
0.5135867,
-0.1637318283,
0.6523352861,
-0.7140089273,
0.2589226961,
-0.3980019987,
0.3805746138,
-0.2488308847,
-0.3187543154,
-0.0685886517,
-0.5469848514,
0.2160556018,
-0.2945405245,
0.5827533603,
0.31502828,
0.7762246728,
0.435474515,
-0.6141088605,
-0.6092861891,
-0.6032940149,
0.6131669283,
-0.801661551,
0.5001316071,
0.6446310282,
-0.0134063177,
-0.1794747263,
-0.6846231222,
-0.5639201999,
-0.4295918643,
-0.3388926685,
-0.043055445,
-0.2340617925,
-0.0985760391,
0.5896912217,
0.3105275631,
-0.5723742247,
-0.3511506319,
-0.6178096533,
-0.3624407351,
0.618258357,
-0.2374486178,
0.5832380652,
-0.5370252132,
-0.0660620779,
0.2610135078,
-0.6534085274,
-0.1568762511,
-0.0009887578,
-0.0116896126,
0.0342530236,
0.9257118702,
-0.4819746017,
0.605943799,
-0.0169256069,
-0.2318473458,
0.0384304896,
-1.1131699085,
-0.0274144746,
0.2804251015,
0.4956648946,
0.4996676743,
-0.692504108,
-0.0587549582,
0.1292140931,
0.1279919744,
0.0390346944,
-0.5622797012,
-0.1252086312,
0.3259170949,
-0.5015829802,
-0.2006980181,
-0.0920337662,
-0.8461000323,
-0.4679090679,
-0.1969902217,
0.1292802244,
-0.2807855308,
-0.147610873,
0.1339215934,
-0.2383125275,
-0.3821469247,
0.420375973,
-0.4235339463,
0.0560920127,
0.6095855832,
1.1531424522,
-0.2470773011,
0.0738323331,
-0.2070099413,
-0.1683427989,
-0.2430268824,
0.9539102912,
-0.0412991419,
-0.0741880387,
-0.2228387743,
0.0506455228,
-0.0176614393,
-0.2700566649,
0.7329627275,
-0.5453056693,
0.2068952918,
-0.804054141,
-0.5109091997,
-0.3631049693,
0.7959234715,
-0.7487630844,
0.8573681712,
-0.1934213638,
-1.128177762,
0.582709372,
-0.8643543124,
-0.3232043087,
0.1231657267,
0.0454070941,
-0.4728506804,
-0.0703163967,
0.2497674078,
0.2934040427,
-0.4102765322,
0.4405008554,
-0.1499001533,
0.210518375,
0.3897452652,
-0.0604474582,
0.894231081,
0.3750728071,
-0.4639963806,
-0.0716210753,
-0.8539628386,
-0.0306629781,
-0.2306920439,
-0.1063158587,
-0.4571394622,
0.2905168235,
-0.2301461697,
0.1850337684,
0.1283809841,
-0.8532086611,
0.2122871429,
-0.1822355837,
0.3506866395,
0.0379759893,
0.4365558326,
-0.0979435369,
-0.6424088478,
0.1174233928,
-0.1870002598,
0.3745338917,
-0.1001376659,
-0.7457780242,
-0.353898257,
-0.1802494377,
0.6719450355,
0.6679227948,
-0.6828872561,
0.7207742333,
0.1118500531,
-0.5699847341,
-0.4937730134,
-0.1006603763,
0.1694038212,
0.8750092983,
0.5855574608,
-0.3266805708,
-0.7546568513,
-0.493793726,
-0.2511339784,
-0.3008738756,
0.0591685027,
-0.0786878988,
0.7805221677,
-0.1929775625,
1.0743819475,
-0.5900397301,
-0.0354864486,
0.2295871228,
0.360642761,
0.0411519408,
0.4653422534,
0.465264827,
-0.8605175614,
-0.2601454258,
-0.0641431361,
-1.0411559343,
-0.2024637163,
0.0933828726,
0.4299394786,
0.0248898156,
0.3921501637,
-0.6238441467,
0.4479520917,
0.5245727301,
-0.5836737752,
0.7596499324,
-0.1799327433,
0.7386050224,
-0.4415950179,
0.2562826276,
0.0960178673,
-0.1402075589,
-0.5604689717,
-0.0568112098,
-0.034331616,
0.2000945061,
-0.3955180347,
0.2165041268,
-0.3844176233,
0.0921275839,
-0.4675112963,
-0.3270283937,
-0.0431279801,
-0.2675483823,
0.0545023717,
0.2645766735,
0.5389780402,
-0.6731892824,
0.6091017127,
0.472402662,
-0.5368795395,
0.5300647616,
-0.7192028165,
-0.2201340795,
-0.2037364542,
0.4807159305,
-0.650634706,
-0.2840292454,
0.3267264664,
-0.3898652196,
-0.1106066331,
-0.1809958071,
-0.6986454129,
-0.6204587221,
-0.0472348928,
0.0165108535,
0.2827172279,
-0.3528530002,
0.2673444152,
0.4268890917,
-0.5835156441,
-0.7442270517,
-0.3683825731,
0.2619709074,
0.1197814941,
-0.5060787797,
0.2603937089,
0.1555809975,
-0.820751369,
0.1999748051,
-0.4208938479,
-0.1552177668,
-0.1665052474,
0.1476415992,
0.2452630401,
-0.0267745182,
0.1099835634,
0.0083887521,
0.0400900319,
0.3148369789,
0.0237528272,
0.0320446379,
-0.0094858026,
-0.610096097,
-0.2312198132,
0.3781169355,
0.4345525503,
-0.1395208389,
0.5104867816,
0.5337762237,
-0.5165451169,
0.1346368641,
-0.7598304152,
-0.5031324625,
-0.4112059474,
0.3454363942,
0.3559968472,
-0.7464920878,
0.2999474406,
-0.3740783632,
0.2499937415,
0.5760034323,
0.4080757797,
-0.2724906802,
0.5783746839,
0.6381782889,
0.552545011,
-0.0960855931,
-0.032142926,
0.3978507519,
-0.3816596568,
-0.4428285658,
-0.8696035743,
0.0966718048,
-0.510070622,
-0.7035446763,
0.5556823611,
-0.4056455791,
-0.0369149037,
0.1411344558,
-0.6861582398,
0.2874543369,
0.395881772,
0.1619878411,
0.6657727361,
-0.2875670195,
0.2467485517,
0.0120161977,
-0.7490709424,
-0.4111925662,
0.9791004062,
0.425643295,
0.4331478477,
-0.283292979,
0.373061806,
0.6702103615,
0.3906366825,
-0.5935295224,
0.4143072367,
0.165777117,
-0.9365609288,
-0.4065429866,
-0.4824925959,
-0.6911290288,
0.0613145232,
-0.6893623471,
-0.2592706084,
0.2378671318,
0.3514231741,
-0.3921127617,
0.4606066644,
-0.3635289669,
0.3990835547,
-0.6977756619,
-0.1203414574,
-0.2502079606,
-0.7966271043,
0.6023159623,
-0.0801845416,
0.4781282842,
-0.2709161341,
0.3162267506,
0.8670398593,
-0.1762066782,
0.7488367558,
-0.0829945803,
-0.0676392391,
0.3119993508,
-0.1871361583,
0.3792571127,
0.3826954663,
-0.0347654447,
0.4416816235,
0.5321416259,
-0.2692384422,
-0.4648964405,
0.389952004,
-0.4360610247,
-0.4189396799,
-1.1125453711,
-0.3640415967,
-0.2747630477,
0.1823453158,
0.1531083435,
-0.0440952033,
-0.2389766723,
0.1358156055,
0.8187539577,
-0.0137282433,
0.1140455306,
0.8543384671,
0.0828891173,
-0.1396701336,
0.6926445961,
0.1551595777,
-0.2267743796,
0.3450613916,
0.3854863346,
-0.3938563764,
-0.8164426684,
-0.0942715257,
0.2236338854,
-0.423604995,
-0.2213864923,
-0.8289731741,
-0.1710238606,
-0.4765590131,
0.2723050714,
-0.4220897853,
-0.4141608179,
-0.0541066006,
-0.0416007675,
0.4947389662,
0.966845572,
-0.4190592766,
-0.2097877562,
-0.844132483,
0.7101127505,
0.3511029482,
0.3655858934,
-0.2513241172,
-0.0714341551,
-0.2326614112,
0.253349036,
-0.2172246724,
-0.87470752,
0.2792226374,
0.0211173911,
0.5023641586,
0.2748303115,
0.1898597777,
0.2514484823,
-0.5232688189,
0.9622628689,
0.309609592,
-0.564760685,
0.7420626879,
0.0604133718,
-0.3228490055,
0.5925127864,
0.8473752141,
-0.7660266757,
-0.2002632469,
-0.7368149757,
-0.7675893903,
0.279997319,
0.1392894983,
-0.6229199767,
0.1104970127,
0.3365642726,
0.2356644124,
0.2674099505,
-0.1950594038,
-0.3224247396,
-0.3990041316,
0.1010426879,
0.1093027145,
-0.019349847,
-0.727789104,
-0.2924423218,
0.6811207533,
-0.1508019567,
0.0045875935,
0.6387521029,
-0.0471205786,
-0.167493701,
0.4523357153,
0.6294211149,
0.6301265955,
-0.3106016815,
0.4429562986,
0.173981443,
-0.6642701626,
0.2577349544,
0.1062855199,
-0.6813068986,
0.2498005629,
0.2313748002,
0.3565123081,
0.0646010637,
-0.6389561892,
0.2177453935,
0.1004491225,
-0.3907151818,
-0.0068563004,
-0.0161778033,
-0.0491882637,
-0.1197818741,
0.6181949973,
0.5235227942,
0.3036561608,
-0.5956051946,
0.5245386958,
0.3774421811,
-0.0084397942,
-0.4352574646,
0.3544229269,
0.1339662671,
0.0753945708,
0.4921354949,
-0.1514469832,
-0.3453505039,
0.7818981409,
0.4025704861,
0.2316799015,
-0.1725383997,
0.4720920026,
0.6437526941,
0.3514043391,
-0.4631929994,
0.2306013554,
0.0610451512,
-0.5785915852,
-0.7704893947,
-0.493851006,
-0.9245221615,
0.253692925,
-0.3657825887,
0.0568767004,
-0.1432368308,
-0.3753614724,
0.3992793262,
0.1525010467,
-0.4512910545,
0.4446572959,
-0.1026650444,
0.8091196418,
-1.1072051525,
0.2689263821,
0.6474347711,
-0.1673635095,
-0.1741452515,
-0.1119673327,
0.4939092696,
-0.4661750197,
0.7616028786,
-0.2857373059,
0.0038947933,
-0.4601219594,
-0.9060356021,
-1.2853480577,
0.6767116785,
0.1808197796,
-0.457067579,
-0.1192465127,
-0.096719563,
0.5458551645,
0.0555284172,
0.285097599,
0.4713076651,
0.9287738204,
0.1640479267,
-0.8629278541,
0.1383885294,
-0.2558747828,
-0.5612313747,
-0.330435127,
-0.3705931902,
0.5651461482,
-0.3028762937,
-0.0512013137,
-0.2069277912,
0.7304635644,
0.5751814842,
0.7287427187,
0.5278803706,
0.3043647707,
0.9535381198,
-0.1550455838,
0.6098229885,
-0.5445920825,
0.4832335413,
0.7327677011,
-0.547506988,
0.3259649575,
0.4858599901,
-0.45074898,
0.3707185984,
0.6849139333,
-0.4727818966,
0.2094178498,
0.2240498662,
-0.1444589943,
0.039351698,
-0.4857230186,
-0.4898288548,
0.5016698837,
0.8548722267,
-0.1747320443,
-0.2739055753,
0.0846648961,
-0.0203171838,
-0.0647137836,
-0.2641819715,
0.5839830041,
-0.1051496491,
-0.7622461319,
0.1071429029,
0.0690824911,
0.8055177927,
-0.8121385574,
-0.4489960074,
0.3917298615,
-0.4376479089,
-0.5655474663,
-0.8349282146,
0.7060713172,
0.120937176,
-0.2737428248,
-0.2575408816,
1.0209259987,
-0.4845584035,
-0.171481356,
-0.2904230952,
0.7370782495,
0.0281090382,
0.0408004485,
-0.7210772038,
-0.0396870449,
-0.096684739,
-0.035614986,
0.0512929633,
0.1012154296,
-0.0088398596,
0.6513778567,
0.8564729095,
0.4998623729,
-0.117317602,
-0.3384889364,
0.2793525457,
-0.4301654696,
-0.4212367833,
-0.5369979143,
0.1044766605,
-0.2677017152,
-0.0363225415,
1.1067756414,
0.3846630454,
0.4701699913,
-0.3356351554,
1.1590313911,
-0.4948967099,
0.7558115721,
-0.3443134129,
1.074216485,
-0.1717705578,
-0.2691794932,
-0.0419376604,
-0.2970274091,
-0.5291751623,
0.5079696774,
-0.0699769855,
-0.1700293273,
0.9396286607,
0.3792794943,
0.1052375883,
0.3715294302,
-0.1553757787,
0.2608830929,
0.1326813251,
-0.1631669253,
0.7575517297,
-0.3360136747,
-0.1100103781,
-0.4273584485,
-0.4604019523,
-0.2722527087,
-1.2488375902,
-0.603423655,
-0.5173457265,
-0.8368045092,
-0.5351271033,
0.0577838905,
0.8765601516,
0.8213100433,
-1.2397214174,
0.2789789438,
-0.1899482012,
0.5199047923,
-0.6920205951,
-0.1308630407,
0.7434228659,
-0.1285944581,
-0.3015877008,
0.4489411116,
0.2777763605,
-0.0568565391,
-0.0641813651,
0.3565148413,
-0.4997186065,
0.0846172795,
0.5002242923,
0.8927596807,
-0.5054552555,
-0.0296017863,
0.172808677,
-0.0758816302,
-0.0895694345,
1.0495200157,
-0.4868404567,
0.4341695309,
0.7132998705,
0.6964660287,
0.2919818759,
-0.1395401508,
0.2428255826,
-0.6513414383,
-0.3565439284,
0.4823474884,
0.4797253311,
0.4885407686,
-0.52323246,
0.5649009943,
0.5357830524,
-0.7914006114,
-1.0182622671,
0.133932814,
-0.9539932013,
-0.0988414735,
0.7471343279,
0.055844143,
-0.3052556813,
-0.6413357854,
-0.0086960597,
0.3307619393,
-0.0456002355,
1.3480621576,
0.6528129578,
-0.3998218775,
0.1947484314,
-0.6250153184,
1.0162643194,
0.2652743161,
-1.0064181089,
0.0652207881,
0.1701579243,
0.4151848257,
0.6745308042,
0.5577505827,
-0.3316737711,
0.5764569044,
-0.0864225924,
0.2207449377,
-0.1179866716,
-0.2064707279,
0.0960083753,
0.3588545024,
-0.3626004755,
0.1566374302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16852v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16852v1 | Model-Based Simulation for Optimising Smart Reply | 2023-05-26T12:04:33 | 2023-05-26T12:04:33 | Benjamin Towle, Ke Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Smart Reply (SR) systems present a user with a set of replies, of which one
can be selected in place of having to type out a response. To perform well at
this task, a system should be able to effectively present the user with a
diverse set of options, to maximise the chance that at least one of them
conveys the user's desired response. This is a significant challenge, due to
the lack of datasets containing sets of responses to learn from. Resultantly,
previous work has focused largely on post-hoc diversification, rather than
explicitly learning to predict sets of responses. Motivated by this problem, we
present a novel method SimSR, that employs model-based simulation to discover
high-value response sets, through simulating possible user responses with a
learned world model. Unlike previous approaches, this allows our method to
directly optimise the end-goal of SR--maximising the relevance of at least one
of the predicted replies. Empirically on two public datasets, when compared to
SoTA baselines, our method achieves up to 21% and 18% improvement in ROUGE
score and Self-ROUGE score respectively. | [
-0.4540573359,
-0.6398994923,
0.1168415993,
0.1818985492,
-0.2038073093,
0.2500178814,
0.1457944512,
-0.1897787303,
0.5178261399,
0.5082437396,
-0.9793247581,
0.1437692791,
-0.0598886311,
0.098463513,
-0.096832335,
1.165122509,
0.4618828595,
0.2585723996,
-0.4400006831,
0.0117571382,
-0.4494567811,
-0.6227431893,
-0.5462837815,
-0.2224900424,
0.5430029631,
0.4618010223,
0.3103993535,
0.3453527093,
0.9844793081,
0.1904987544,
-0.0879801884,
0.3193418086,
-0.962200582,
0.1900574267,
-0.5719313025,
-0.4807633758,
-0.3706902862,
-0.1765592694,
0.3528612852,
0.101046212,
-0.2922778726,
0.6114176512,
-0.280397594,
0.3883807361,
-0.964281559,
-0.0129368575,
-0.540561676,
0.2076510787,
0.1588027924,
-0.5598504543,
-0.491127193,
-0.4137070477,
0.0361532643,
-0.5222129822,
-0.0093658911,
0.130737558,
0.7175680995,
0.16333206,
-0.3706751168,
0.0775756687,
-1.0623880625,
0.9839442372,
-0.7065137625,
0.2510905564,
-0.1838762909,
0.8708783984,
-0.1973774433,
-0.6619445682,
-0.4684877694,
0.0491143689,
0.0728478804,
0.6715351343,
0.2567271888,
-0.1233021915,
0.5070059896,
-0.0102402633,
-0.3761701286,
-0.3987053633,
-0.344843924,
-0.1918128282,
1.0492835045,
0.6083737612,
-0.1197774485,
-0.3015562296,
-0.5483704805,
-0.3419703543,
-0.2898702621,
0.2726887167,
0.5510458946,
0.6514178514,
-0.0496160351,
0.6025404334,
-0.2806400061,
0.7057601213,
-0.1058587283,
-0.3538343012,
0.136639908,
-0.3945499063,
-0.0009413846,
-0.3927046955,
0.633461535,
0.2707555592,
0.486761868,
0.0401472226,
-0.5838747621,
-0.1191808954,
0.2453551739,
-0.9500351548,
-0.1711118966,
0.1451105475,
-0.4615901709,
-0.2496840656,
0.20258829,
-0.8163853884,
-0.2497678697,
-0.3013248444,
0.6033365726,
-0.2354278713,
-0.3530597091,
0.3002189696,
-0.106874533,
0.0263360851,
0.3895754218,
-0.478256762,
0.707040906,
0.383061856,
0.3820973039,
0.0895117372,
0.0562401451,
-0.9484599233,
0.2063942403,
-0.0566725805,
1.1197463274,
-0.6907690167,
-0.4986663461,
-0.4487582743,
-0.485996455,
-0.1986024231,
-0.6522315741,
0.4507763684,
-0.7593208551,
0.025521487,
-0.5747749805,
-0.3458732069,
0.1700686365,
0.3744101524,
-0.7130388618,
1.0357099771,
0.0270139538,
-1.2152022123,
0.1136167794,
-0.9770299196,
-0.365292877,
-0.1254796684,
-0.0440828465,
-0.4257614911,
0.1238017827,
0.005442176,
0.3681870997,
-0.2763279676,
0.1566525698,
-0.5676383376,
-0.5786030293,
0.3402217627,
-0.1740785092,
0.4053989351,
0.4117124081,
0.1006127521,
0.3753670454,
-0.6336674094,
0.3790472746,
0.3112475276,
-0.2251342088,
-0.2862616479,
0.0252166204,
0.4447844923,
0.6563230753,
0.0084111569,
-0.6506341696,
0.1428039819,
-0.2092019022,
0.2146332264,
0.7655901313,
0.2190263867,
-0.0403919332,
-0.514160037,
0.6651673913,
0.3441583514,
0.4358961284,
-0.1514467001,
-0.3014110923,
-0.4376885891,
-0.4771267474,
0.7173960805,
0.8419328332,
-0.5948649645,
0.1478728503,
-0.5353193879,
-0.0891313255,
-0.4550455511,
-0.1835894883,
0.4270583093,
0.433742255,
0.428807199,
-0.2827318907,
-0.5961386561,
-1.0152121782,
-0.6559170485,
-0.2169726938,
0.2194012403,
0.5611016154,
0.6402311325,
-0.0718209893,
1.4335902929,
-0.8094922304,
0.1078499928,
-0.6201046109,
0.087338008,
-0.1817110479,
0.2235179991,
0.1666454077,
-1.2263499498,
-0.4496962726,
-0.2038258165,
-0.4960815012,
0.2105591893,
-0.1908621639,
0.0106282039,
-0.2303557247,
0.4332244992,
-0.5041781068,
0.6365778446,
0.0744825453,
0.1315953583,
0.6794764996,
-0.1707472056,
-0.0630889311,
-1.5129656792,
0.5277561545,
0.0061249789,
-0.423074156,
-0.5245289207,
0.0879224986,
0.1459328383,
-0.1696753502,
-0.5558047295,
0.9737217426,
-0.1134546176,
-0.3097827733,
-0.1372494698,
-0.1444400102,
-0.3657358587,
0.4408962727,
-0.1394326836,
0.8331544995,
0.1530965865,
-0.4615722597,
0.1939484775,
0.0458282679,
-0.0574581213,
0.3708689809,
-0.6371735334,
0.1117603406,
-0.5230202675,
0.4409381449,
-1.0053735971,
-0.7715408206,
0.0164062399,
-0.405774802,
0.0111028105,
0.1747798175,
-0.4872111678,
-0.7870987654,
-0.2660904825,
0.6142300367,
0.4470384419,
-0.272796154,
0.9663968682,
0.3533893228,
-0.053219825,
-0.6622196436,
-0.279012531,
-0.1448733062,
-0.1020886227,
-0.5614081621,
-0.0250311904,
-0.4949466288,
-0.2298317105,
-0.1999588907,
-0.1139452308,
0.1575716585,
0.169812873,
0.0362376347,
0.0925602019,
0.1820992529,
0.045860894,
-0.1927474588,
-0.1380348951,
0.0093988655,
0.005316583,
0.7169701457,
-0.2133316547,
-0.6105625033,
-0.5905231833,
0.4597163498,
0.5775150657,
-0.607666254,
0.7331786156,
0.2638029158,
-0.4248303771,
-0.4661773443,
-0.4473765492,
-0.8029811382,
-0.4896701872,
0.4815648496,
-0.6426492929,
-0.495059371,
0.8815723658,
-0.1167756543,
0.1595454961,
-0.0917875841,
0.2123420089,
0.1240958795,
1.4334993362,
0.7296305299,
0.0511634611,
0.3011763096,
-0.231134057,
0.7222782969,
-0.543913722,
-0.588984549,
-0.2833056748,
-0.3474105,
-0.2120587975,
-0.4466239214,
0.4193931222,
-0.0765847713,
-0.1774816215,
0.024390351,
-0.1369355917,
0.4096347988,
0.6344325542,
0.298930496,
0.1467615664,
0.0307243299,
-0.3183024228,
-0.0734586343,
-0.9532836676,
-0.2919788361,
0.992946744,
0.1472514123,
1.0433678627,
-0.0674963892,
0.9391904473,
0.2375238836,
0.6672292352,
-0.854952693,
1.1030137539,
0.1887790561,
-0.4183593392,
-0.1064492837,
-0.8583727479,
-0.5697107315,
0.1211337373,
-0.2980384231,
-0.4531903863,
-0.1708494276,
0.323282212,
-0.965754509,
0.331212014,
-0.4586404562,
0.4850469828,
-0.0815381706,
-0.4924122393,
-0.0257659107,
-1.0236514807,
0.3200113475,
-0.1681537032,
0.2094847709,
0.1803662628,
0.2451507896,
0.6992983222,
-0.2923295498,
0.5675473809,
-0.1103267744,
0.2322383374,
0.3853636384,
-0.0513213873,
0.5257514119,
0.1171153262,
-0.2192067504,
-0.6302257776,
-0.1248144433,
-0.5637315512,
-0.765286088,
0.4129130542,
-0.6421034336,
-0.6839368343,
-0.3630294204,
-0.885763824,
-0.3472899497,
0.1808892637,
0.0272953361,
0.5300043225,
-0.3219487667,
0.070364058,
0.8356417418,
-0.05277,
0.3136861026,
0.5752317309,
-0.2967075109,
-0.4551423192,
0.7118798494,
0.0498184562,
0.2305482328,
0.3279178739,
0.2733308673,
-0.4153394401,
-0.1680792421,
-0.2413282245,
0.2291811258,
-0.5268084407,
-0.4633012414,
-0.9609751701,
-0.5014401078,
-0.5404077172,
0.1283798367,
-0.3919727206,
-0.3339289129,
-0.0783433765,
-0.2137714326,
0.1464965492,
0.631100297,
-0.2507051229,
0.1322170645,
-0.6142696142,
0.2865139246,
0.4893882275,
0.3054015636,
-0.0280902311,
-0.3485798836,
-0.2997772694,
0.4833827913,
-0.3020987511,
-0.5875629783,
0.4471641481,
0.0124515984,
0.6142251492,
0.4122925103,
0.4418362379,
0.9213052988,
-0.3503828049,
0.4103171229,
0.0828273296,
-0.5609893203,
0.7143080235,
-0.4684042931,
0.2511307895,
0.6790882349,
0.2260327935,
-0.4439582229,
-0.0726859123,
-0.7414287329,
-0.7732180953,
0.6883692145,
-0.0598311163,
0.2956383526,
-0.1469525099,
0.3991941512,
-0.1060171053,
0.1763571948,
-0.5266355276,
0.0675981566,
0.0109602343,
-0.3132719696,
0.1596967727,
0.0586026721,
-0.2306104153,
0.0424197838,
0.5994529724,
-0.3592914343,
0.3690882921,
0.04590353,
0.1924538612,
-0.2688699067,
-0.0131209251,
0.573522985,
0.6968789101,
-0.4684799016,
-0.1299728155,
0.2155523002,
-0.5224783421,
-0.1756383926,
-0.0063580335,
-0.190430209,
-0.3073985279,
-0.0458383821,
0.6042687893,
0.1276613772,
-1.1302089691,
0.6124626994,
-0.2924416363,
-0.012318681,
0.0902250037,
0.253316313,
0.189506799,
0.116534926,
0.3690655529,
0.502068162,
0.2054073513,
-0.5010871291,
0.3592043817,
0.6817287207,
-0.4193564057,
-0.3650180995,
0.6882257462,
0.0870067477,
-0.6987500191,
0.5652290583,
-0.0736091882,
-0.6816798449,
0.7910140157,
0.8690874577,
0.5961810946,
-0.4757521749,
0.3193744421,
0.3885522187,
-0.1166908219,
-0.4451675117,
0.8904974461,
0.3546927869,
-0.4398667216,
-0.1966938674,
-0.5722277164,
-0.5548246503,
0.0857203081,
-1.105517149,
0.3603253067,
-0.531306982,
-0.5301240683,
-0.3086985946,
0.0485828966,
-0.7012532353,
0.5011621714,
-0.0624842234,
1.2479401827,
-0.9899980426,
0.4956648648,
0.9782063961,
-0.1393350661,
-0.9613782167,
0.3894062042,
-0.3979737461,
-0.4361509681,
0.7316398621,
0.3029947877,
-0.5503716469,
0.2259156704,
-0.646559,
-0.858884275,
0.8417286873,
0.4430554211,
-0.0869513527,
0.2012198418,
0.1896456331,
0.5844276547,
-0.3535583615,
0.7691781521,
-0.0660196468,
0.2329427302,
0.3988517225,
-0.8374013901,
-0.1979504973,
-0.558342576,
0.2270962596,
0.1953584999,
-1.1536974907,
0.9158786535,
-0.5855454803,
-0.21129103,
0.0704648793,
0.8316147923,
0.7120718956,
0.3211020529,
0.3484773934,
0.5510914326,
0.6559614539,
0.298529774,
0.9800752401,
-0.3928455114,
0.6215228438,
1.0703037977,
-0.7156578302,
1.1698633432,
0.6062618494,
0.245649606,
0.4686549902,
0.7531011105,
0.2339011431,
0.9394572973,
0.605062902,
-0.3986172676,
-0.5741149783,
-0.131783545,
-0.1789789349,
0.2051919103,
0.1090973541,
0.1873318106,
-0.2475572973,
0.0430364646,
-0.2448441535,
0.1224890128,
-0.3749712706,
0.6677033305,
-0.1233441532,
-0.7929893732,
0.293348372,
0.1700048596,
0.5545520186,
-0.7892591357,
-0.0017919927,
-0.5662342906,
0.5625202656,
0.0442849994,
-0.4362594187,
0.0572218224,
-0.1662921309,
-0.302811861,
-0.1186711714,
0.9189168811,
-0.1427018195,
-0.7974382043,
0.2576972544,
0.6029884219,
-0.0708414689,
0.3092018068,
-0.8211678863,
-0.4328392148,
-0.1636915058,
-0.5532577634,
0.365196079,
0.378585577,
-0.5073661804,
1.2619073391,
0.687282443,
-0.1242230535,
-0.0914762169,
-0.1452738345,
1.2116640806,
-0.5805029273,
-1.0021380186,
-0.6001280546,
0.4961479604,
-0.4804077744,
-0.1296838522,
0.7307174206,
1.0888012648,
0.7253860235,
-0.303611666,
0.9789012074,
0.302095741,
0.8487990499,
-0.1097681299,
0.450950563,
-0.6122528911,
0.2234033197,
-0.2323307842,
-0.8515303731,
-0.2720094621,
0.6588179469,
-0.4622721672,
0.3333238065,
0.2761848271,
1.1613724232,
-0.7531549335,
0.2660159767,
0.1845128983,
-0.1972225606,
0.1345613152,
0.4210700691,
0.9063988328,
-0.2827960849,
0.5003172755,
-0.0293048043,
-0.1867629886,
-0.6454668045,
-0.8454630375,
-1.0533145666,
-0.1053582728,
0.0113415616,
-0.4321213663,
0.4662853777,
1.1775279045,
0.9482851624,
-0.8952071071,
-0.34174335,
0.2174431235,
-0.2963326871,
-0.2273611873,
-0.2098837644,
0.1195379943,
-0.1052217558,
-0.2717110217,
0.0057459553,
0.2264078557,
0.0946671441,
-0.1512144357,
-0.1285132766,
-0.1794070601,
0.8624705076,
0.3704366982,
0.3386296034,
-0.2551808059,
-0.1176131889,
0.5563200712,
-0.2002748549,
-0.0306368582,
0.9097180963,
-1.1124329567,
0.1936803013,
0.5816571712,
0.6154563427,
0.5294071436,
0.5565491915,
0.429125458,
-0.5535691977,
-0.0144394273,
0.626367867,
-0.1148512363,
0.3145221472,
-0.366312623,
0.3517066836,
0.2406429946,
-0.2567943335,
-1.0429030657,
0.4283423424,
-0.8181551695,
-0.3067070246,
1.0820786953,
-0.1437286437,
-0.2501391172,
-0.1670119166,
-0.1940274537,
0.0208913255,
-0.4613455236,
0.9764336944,
0.1814058423,
-0.2789223194,
0.1036197618,
-0.57186836,
0.4088768363,
0.5845487714,
-1.1381183863,
0.1496428102,
0.2481376678,
0.6522220373,
0.0894921795,
0.7469741702,
0.1487666368,
0.2949503958,
-0.3146797419,
-0.0596126057,
-0.0441433825,
-0.704831779,
0.1465420127,
0.2728198469,
-0.5138090849,
0.0930267051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18350v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18350v1 | Towards Open-World Product Attribute Mining: A Lightly-Supervised Approach | 2023-05-26T11:51:31 | 2023-05-26T11:51:31 | Liyan Xu, Chenwei Zhang, Xian Li, Jingbo Shang, Jinho D. Choi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR | We present a new task setting for attribute mining on e-commerce products,
serving as a practical solution to extract open-world attributes without
extensive human intervention. Our supervision comes from a high-quality seed
attribute set bootstrapped from existing resources, and we aim to expand the
attribute vocabulary of existing seed types, and also to discover any new
attribute types automatically. A new dataset is created to support our setting,
and our approach Amacer is proposed specifically to tackle the limited
supervision. Especially, given that no direct supervision is available for
those unseen new attributes, our novel formulation exploits self-supervised
heuristic and unsupervised latent attributes, which attains implicit semantic
signals as additional supervision by leveraging product context. Experiments
suggest that our approach surpasses various baselines by 12 F1, expanding
attributes of existing types significantly by up to 12 times, and discovering
values from 39% new types. | [
-0.1421297789,
-0.7121382952,
0.2515347302,
0.4729843438,
0.1511510462,
-0.1997962296,
-0.2263285369,
-0.8242144585,
0.0329617634,
0.4899211824,
-1.122191906,
-0.9042901397,
-0.3635978401,
-0.3110435009,
-0.2578333914,
1.2184584141,
0.2151377052,
-0.6387457252,
-0.3532624245,
-0.0970744044,
0.1086979285,
-0.2453517765,
-0.5003908277,
-0.0073532299,
0.6494571567,
0.7427883148,
0.6470555663,
0.3266319335,
0.5569935441,
0.2557937801,
0.0054432857,
0.3256261647,
-0.4246871769,
0.1481869519,
-0.2485134155,
-0.387986958,
-0.8692438602,
0.3970420361,
-0.2192448378,
0.7850518227,
-0.0821433887,
0.8204888701,
0.313092798,
0.1645304263,
-1.1362993717,
0.3919337392,
-0.5010378957,
0.3166358471,
-0.1515828967,
-0.1119599193,
-0.4965303838,
0.144630909,
-0.0218383279,
-1.0732533932,
0.6345927119,
0.5041570067,
0.8842379451,
0.0583968721,
-0.3771555424,
-0.0141470712,
-0.969311595,
1.2332270145,
-0.3756723106,
0.2941765189,
0.6839969158,
0.2272235006,
-0.1359160393,
-0.8246243596,
-0.2074867636,
-0.0690785497,
-0.4251072705,
-0.0968835354,
-0.2668921649,
-0.1635129154,
0.364685446,
0.6704722047,
-0.0072708693,
0.2056154013,
-0.3617756665,
-0.1572512388,
0.7252004147,
0.1306569278,
0.0243078135,
-0.1268583387,
-0.5749979019,
-0.0015304262,
-0.8493052721,
0.4185563624,
0.332325846,
0.4052310586,
-0.0342317,
0.6869455576,
-0.7267205119,
0.3579710424,
0.0811666399,
-0.2289924175,
0.1220385954,
-0.3394024074,
-0.0922802761,
-0.0005346255,
0.6858358979,
0.3532207906,
-0.1923842877,
-0.4181089997,
-0.2475841343,
-0.4824899733,
0.1593645513,
-0.4750034213,
-0.5601798296,
0.0644002184,
-0.7813162208,
-0.602937758,
0.4273605347,
-0.6422914863,
-0.4292330742,
-0.0441106148,
0.6577265263,
-0.0847925767,
-0.2074912786,
-0.196070686,
-0.1399987042,
0.4252900481,
0.2159286588,
-0.7935239077,
0.5510108471,
0.8659710884,
0.8206443787,
-0.1128824204,
0.1094123796,
-0.5718224049,
0.4829361439,
-0.0992471203,
0.9129862785,
-0.3130329251,
-0.0609833226,
-0.2713145912,
0.4169041514,
0.7090170383,
-0.4109084904,
0.6717898846,
-0.5665791631,
-0.0084237093,
-0.1783408672,
-0.146898061,
-0.0516122505,
0.2555246651,
-1.0760262012,
0.9889895916,
0.1107779145,
-0.7233645916,
0.8567379713,
-0.6756937504,
-0.6477953792,
0.1393247992,
0.1874569505,
-0.5599281788,
0.465244472,
0.621414721,
0.6695326567,
-0.3458811045,
-0.3126022816,
-0.6406760216,
-0.1813212484,
0.1889325976,
-0.1156287044,
0.8349760175,
0.236049965,
-0.2166909128,
-0.2962268591,
-0.9244738221,
0.3109670579,
0.0765251592,
0.2602138519,
-0.6937569976,
0.1083414257,
0.2261693925,
0.2569389641,
0.4510090947,
-0.867131114,
0.3126074374,
-0.0813120157,
0.0735051706,
1.1281547546,
0.4216857553,
0.4917355776,
-0.0893792361,
0.3334206343,
-0.0737270042,
0.5413131118,
-0.0269034505,
-0.3979943395,
-0.9777622223,
-0.5134921074,
0.194378987,
0.1339888573,
-0.4166278839,
0.6654396057,
-0.1544612646,
-0.4734671414,
-0.5860196948,
0.3344176114,
0.2225737274,
0.1449726373,
0.3793449104,
-0.5214987993,
-0.3613704443,
-1.3794711828,
-0.3962560296,
0.17654787,
-0.4585975707,
0.4996553659,
0.2901392281,
0.0208235439,
1.1828277111,
-1.2750543356,
-0.9847339392,
-0.0655221418,
0.590339303,
0.5247234106,
0.5237131715,
0.2000424415,
-0.6362361312,
-0.4900140166,
0.1247520149,
-0.7621493936,
-0.191989243,
0.0635942444,
-0.0695481077,
-0.1972824335,
0.4049687684,
-0.3753965497,
0.5657071471,
0.1128516644,
-0.1960392743,
0.1105068997,
-0.0414025784,
0.1820625365,
-0.9137476683,
0.0392187051,
0.3780590892,
-0.0737966523,
-0.4243785441,
0.1560018659,
-0.0619154759,
-0.0425699577,
-0.6585682631,
0.4180140793,
-0.6780010462,
-0.0675009638,
-0.1758900583,
-0.5087579489,
0.040385168,
0.6067934036,
-0.0607824624,
0.4738318324,
0.4876977503,
-0.8556696177,
0.4275380075,
0.2443677783,
-0.4672606289,
1.0082942247,
-0.5424868464,
0.0028550795,
-0.1386927813,
-0.1079856157,
-0.5340101719,
-0.1966485977,
-0.0632216707,
-0.4491967857,
0.2500399053,
-0.1317284703,
-0.6340239048,
-0.2786898613,
-0.4210582376,
0.1469910741,
0.6977451444,
-0.9019396901,
0.5089190602,
0.0824547857,
-0.1331100315,
-0.3600566089,
-0.5419833064,
-0.1709598601,
-0.2521921694,
-0.6924834251,
0.587305665,
0.2160431743,
-0.250844568,
0.3376325965,
-0.3794034123,
-0.2398528308,
0.3273352981,
0.4282204211,
-0.0210357551,
0.0449334905,
0.0781414062,
-0.0230884217,
-0.23020491,
0.0076059746,
-0.3430648148,
-0.037632443,
0.1270096004,
-0.18818973,
-0.4826180935,
0.3932964504,
-0.3209175169,
-0.1904128939,
0.7455015779,
0.5765035748,
-0.559697926,
-0.8247162104,
-0.2183520645,
-0.2175740749,
-0.5814877748,
0.0952521861,
-0.304664433,
-0.5593451262,
0.3078666329,
-0.0288387835,
0.0622089617,
0.5631842613,
0.3567168415,
-0.3816861212,
1.3046367168,
1.1734149456,
0.0164094567,
0.2224948853,
-0.3372712135,
0.5395843983,
-0.840370357,
-0.5790691972,
-0.3182759583,
-0.725821197,
-0.6419579387,
-0.2672357857,
0.4383096993,
0.011310773,
-0.1967829466,
0.4801983535,
-0.5412821174,
0.4131850302,
1.1592801809,
0.6630411744,
0.531170845,
0.2154963166,
0.3618457019,
-0.1195774451,
-0.1736615449,
-0.0691289604,
1.4511129856,
0.1887083352,
1.277043581,
0.0186597873,
0.6121560335,
0.5642861128,
0.52172333,
-0.6147798896,
0.3903050125,
0.0053717378,
-0.8016963005,
0.1524808109,
-0.2318417728,
-0.691665113,
-0.348592937,
-0.34395504,
-0.9388679266,
0.2929442823,
0.3250546157,
-0.419582963,
0.2767637372,
-0.5437338352,
0.6572899222,
-0.5448091626,
-0.9049744606,
0.0373397209,
-0.4385122061,
0.3996410668,
0.1230068803,
0.1630832702,
-0.1299876422,
-0.1787786782,
0.7616912723,
-0.5134156346,
0.7752358913,
-0.3051593006,
-0.0812324807,
0.1467764378,
-0.0771850571,
0.363116473,
-0.0446154997,
0.4192039371,
-0.0010365853,
-0.2882380188,
-0.6215154529,
-0.7289828062,
0.9127320647,
-0.67292732,
-0.4621712863,
-0.6836957932,
-0.2245729864,
-0.4396078289,
0.0626382753,
0.136032775,
-0.3335529864,
-0.4790723026,
0.5776386857,
0.7021982074,
-0.2235754132,
0.2285058796,
0.5588692427,
0.1048461124,
-0.1247736886,
1.0666283369,
-0.1213553548,
0.1581452936,
0.3893460929,
0.102044411,
-0.0042505623,
-0.231989339,
0.2149216086,
-0.1235930845,
-0.5429810286,
-0.4759933949,
-0.6563720107,
-0.1502396315,
-0.4880314469,
0.0952523872,
-0.2365507632,
-0.6224555969,
-0.1728309393,
-0.3209548593,
0.7772498727,
0.77058357,
-0.2806177139,
0.6671795845,
-0.5958221555,
0.4100367129,
0.5533799529,
0.6825125813,
0.0850237235,
0.0101354737,
-0.4228658974,
0.045235917,
-0.6160188317,
-0.5549607873,
0.2363058925,
0.527962923,
0.5877433419,
0.8615894318,
0.3037326038,
0.5409333706,
-0.157048732,
0.7576603889,
0.0102970432,
-0.5743862391,
0.5901040435,
-0.1037751362,
-0.3114983141,
0.5737537146,
0.7157162428,
-0.3402028978,
-0.1097808555,
-0.9047618508,
-1.0810198784,
1.0543996096,
0.3429012299,
-0.0350122228,
0.1849214137,
0.060781382,
0.3062347174,
0.4146246314,
-0.9574138522,
-0.3425453603,
0.0384642184,
-0.1761108637,
-0.0461817943,
0.0097063668,
-0.0001177141,
-0.3079488277,
0.8891231418,
0.021807719,
0.1008207202,
-0.1822280437,
-0.3560942709,
0.0419287942,
0.1967425495,
-0.6359017491,
0.2003030479,
-0.4463984072,
0.202128768,
-0.1170518175,
-0.1570962816,
-0.0622491315,
0.1577594578,
-0.3227942884,
-0.5858473182,
0.3815393448,
0.4356332123,
0.2898918688,
-0.3099713027,
0.8646041155,
0.2018332779,
0.0206586458,
-0.353694737,
0.0003111003,
-0.2310985923,
0.1691364497,
0.4179467857,
-0.1586562395,
0.531855464,
-0.7393895984,
0.4595772326,
0.5634625554,
-0.5763926506,
-0.4945545197,
0.7215340137,
0.0440539829,
0.029061228,
0.7718629837,
-0.4117601812,
-0.1918255836,
0.4586983025,
0.5556606054,
0.9449307919,
-0.1038453355,
0.1626206636,
0.2281302512,
0.423943609,
0.0970659852,
0.1206847504,
-0.4516834021,
-0.5317746401,
-0.1421603858,
-0.8154649734,
-0.2444576621,
0.2013690323,
-0.7873613238,
0.5063650608,
-0.5146445036,
0.1692675501,
-0.0525747277,
-0.0210607424,
-0.9166026711,
0.4460647404,
-0.0335525684,
0.5742211342,
-1.1853673458,
0.3078852594,
0.3326562941,
-0.7151601911,
-0.3191883266,
-0.1716376841,
0.0395140387,
-0.8259804845,
0.6566258669,
0.4161990285,
0.1642291248,
-0.3054170609,
-0.9492509365,
-0.774743855,
1.3171471357,
-0.2594026029,
0.0737073496,
-0.1941649616,
0.2152487934,
0.3528740704,
-0.2620625496,
0.0901938602,
0.4518846571,
0.3684930205,
0.2309026867,
-0.3133459687,
-0.019760821,
-0.5057868958,
-0.1878549755,
0.1423011869,
-0.3927497566,
0.9966064692,
0.0694470406,
-0.3591318429,
0.1402618587,
0.9387089014,
-0.2435992062,
0.3328332603,
0.6562797427,
0.8869364262,
0.4452688694,
-0.071253553,
0.937269032,
-0.0805691257,
0.4776164591,
1.2366943359,
-0.2623732984,
0.7641133666,
0.2678094208,
-0.280888319,
0.6194102168,
0.6853809357,
-0.2464472204,
0.8341177702,
-0.0473645665,
-0.4604762495,
-0.459741652,
-0.582485199,
-0.0064485683,
0.3302957118,
0.2022279501,
-0.4749421477,
-0.2326025516,
-0.130688712,
-0.2065139115,
-0.0815122128,
-0.5479277968,
0.9248657823,
0.0874055326,
-0.3039244711,
-0.0788542554,
0.252825737,
0.7448753715,
-0.5696858764,
-0.2687158883,
0.0352209546,
0.4377566278,
-0.6601249576,
-0.5547197461,
-0.0230016131,
0.047976464,
-0.0016557272,
-0.4681222141,
0.8888080716,
-0.1737359166,
-0.9346157908,
0.1208940446,
0.5456285477,
-0.2610953748,
-0.3056444824,
-0.1249658316,
-0.7858154178,
-0.2238458246,
-0.4449884892,
0.2386606932,
0.4904370308,
-0.2683539987,
0.3962521553,
0.7487699389,
-0.0029375188,
-0.0355966426,
-0.4612666368,
0.8431055546,
-0.9308953881,
-0.5211343169,
-0.4651770592,
0.482640326,
-0.5961219668,
-0.1555602998,
0.9665614963,
0.883389473,
0.9588457942,
-0.004283817,
0.8851181269,
-0.4689797163,
0.5120743513,
-0.3425007463,
0.6551447511,
-0.7494236827,
0.1532198787,
-0.3287513852,
-1.0838701725,
-0.2237457186,
0.5013715625,
-0.0136206793,
-0.1184266955,
0.6611987352,
0.8552302122,
-0.6671929955,
0.1942979097,
-0.144406572,
0.2760000229,
0.2879285812,
0.5196195841,
0.6349315643,
-0.2108809948,
0.4228279591,
-0.7648508549,
-0.6764990091,
0.1746994108,
-1.1840956211,
-0.5333761573,
-0.3409549594,
-0.2074147016,
-0.2324881107,
-0.2402304262,
0.9717755318,
0.7102338076,
-0.8999538422,
0.0916385725,
0.0930919349,
0.0267225709,
-0.7218512297,
-0.2317306846,
0.3030885458,
-0.3104395866,
-0.6409566402,
0.2841747105,
0.1460258961,
-0.1956505775,
-0.3763083816,
0.3614974618,
-0.1108394116,
-0.2368918806,
0.537502408,
0.1928679049,
-0.2729225457,
-0.3326454461,
0.2049547732,
0.5456574559,
0.0740765631,
0.834869206,
-0.7763336301,
0.3049788773,
0.3048182726,
0.2615948915,
0.8213043809,
0.0821197927,
0.5876846313,
-1.4833579063,
0.3528140783,
0.1071248055,
0.1357651949,
0.2354030162,
-0.327291131,
0.4417895079,
0.0536156185,
-0.1912558526,
-0.5346464515,
0.4651920199,
-0.8599470258,
-0.1097743064,
0.8944343925,
-0.3163944185,
-0.6917690635,
0.0866405666,
0.079816021,
-0.219490543,
-0.2891250849,
0.6821808219,
0.3795672059,
-0.1017264053,
0.1071020067,
-0.1868324727,
0.4931519926,
-0.1589704156,
-0.7785483599,
0.1585226804,
0.5241057277,
0.1230211332,
0.1759268641,
0.3920938075,
-0.0379903242,
0.250046134,
-0.2123409808,
0.2248515189,
-0.243609935,
-0.5260971785,
0.1197799817,
0.3281524479,
0.2241515517,
-0.1190220639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16843v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16843v1 | Randomized Positional Encodings Boost Length Generalization of Transformers | 2023-05-26T11:47:52 | 2023-05-26T11:47:52 | Anian Ruoss, Grégoire Delétang, Tim Genewein, Jordi Grau-Moya, Róbert Csordás, Mehdi Bennani, Shane Legg, Joel Veness | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | Transformers have impressive generalization capabilities on tasks with a
fixed context length. However, they fail to generalize to sequences of
arbitrary length, even for seemingly simple tasks such as duplicating a string.
Moreover, simply training on longer sequences is inefficient due to the
quadratic computation complexity of the global attention mechanism. In this
work, we demonstrate that this failure mode is linked to positional encodings
being out-of-distribution for longer sequences (even for relative encodings)
and introduce a novel family of positional encodings that can overcome this
problem. Concretely, our randomized positional encoding scheme simulates the
positions of longer sequences and randomly selects an ordered subset to fit the
sequence's length. Our large-scale empirical evaluation of 6000 models across
15 algorithmic reasoning tasks shows that our method allows Transformers to
generalize to sequences of unseen length (increasing test accuracy by 12.0% on
average). | [
-0.2995306551,
-0.1781057864,
0.6626115441,
0.2672081888,
-0.3353936374,
0.000431665,
-0.5071310401,
-0.2701135278,
0.2099366337,
-0.004747516,
-0.5280035138,
-0.1875274926,
-0.8341784477,
0.1755547076,
-0.7155506015,
0.9482904077,
0.1240800247,
-0.1638555378,
0.1793775707,
-0.2176301628,
-0.3341259062,
-0.5514694452,
-0.3369930983,
-0.1051234081,
0.6406790018,
0.5143390894,
0.8930202723,
0.6712966561,
0.7706263065,
0.2207989842,
0.1182489023,
0.2013607472,
-0.6318640113,
0.1087126806,
-0.1043870747,
-0.6983627677,
0.2112615854,
-0.2143996358,
0.8949940801,
0.7546165586,
-0.2150020152,
0.2640819848,
-0.3582125604,
0.6659785509,
-0.6980914474,
-0.0898063108,
-0.5553184152,
0.371953845,
0.0228589382,
-0.4363898337,
-0.6462209225,
-0.2538115978,
0.2220839262,
-0.5118992925,
0.6201972961,
-0.0380597264,
0.5550469756,
0.5215002894,
-0.146415472,
-0.1122956872,
-1.2769552469,
0.9120660424,
-0.3280307949,
0.4565011561,
0.217140615,
0.392544806,
-0.1744447947,
-0.5027359128,
-0.4667369723,
-0.0928497091,
-0.1570916325,
0.121482946,
0.0114636868,
-0.0517417081,
0.6417918205,
0.2917098105,
-0.4778393805,
-0.0786945522,
-0.524284184,
0.2601397038,
0.638053596,
0.0005770203,
0.1132798493,
-0.1272874475,
-0.2844785154,
-0.5249471664,
-0.5313709378,
0.1728525162,
0.5864874125,
-0.2072698921,
-0.1712671518,
0.4928781092,
-0.0852426142,
0.6108189821,
0.598002553,
-0.0035684546,
0.1844310313,
-0.1065182686,
-0.0844918787,
0.1408109516,
0.701769352,
0.0484610163,
0.1704764664,
-0.3606584072,
-0.0456386469,
-0.1601656377,
0.5263491273,
-0.5273501873,
-0.084066242,
0.2144622654,
-0.3082195222,
-0.0706294551,
0.3243480623,
-0.4390449524,
-0.1377289295,
-0.1709736139,
0.2133305818,
-0.5202586055,
0.2674662769,
0.3004701734,
-0.4441525936,
0.3648415506,
-0.0580248162,
-1.3910968304,
-0.1438733488,
0.58826828,
0.6511740685,
-0.2388203144,
-0.3026317656,
-0.3422902524,
0.2740174532,
-0.3625339568,
0.634223938,
-0.6433395147,
-0.3497711718,
-0.1187416539,
-0.0167715866,
-0.1441562176,
-0.2978675067,
0.5646345019,
-0.7621144056,
0.22454907,
-0.0840190798,
-0.3197675347,
-0.0020329636,
-0.1764690876,
-0.4937264919,
0.7663640976,
0.2844468057,
-0.6746144295,
0.5654165149,
-0.42930457,
-0.7189859748,
-0.0815871283,
-0.3160344362,
-0.5002732873,
0.5438149571,
0.4115974903,
0.2986934781,
-0.23958911,
0.2057067603,
-0.280408591,
-0.9886612296,
0.2915370464,
-0.571836412,
0.4194195271,
0.1439561397,
-0.5850328207,
0.0923016518,
-0.5561262369,
-0.0553123429,
0.2650791109,
-0.2300771773,
-0.2475084811,
-0.0464588515,
-0.3552754819,
0.2523875833,
0.0942851231,
-0.3889797032,
0.3321636319,
-0.551343143,
0.6883812547,
0.6758320332,
-0.0159140769,
0.8674277663,
-0.2299180925,
0.598510921,
-0.0036103122,
0.3439258039,
-0.2051746696,
-0.4699088037,
-0.8131642342,
-0.1929552406,
0.2361821234,
0.4821726382,
-0.7981386185,
0.5113512874,
-0.7255498767,
-0.281840682,
-0.3444649577,
-0.0207345933,
0.3531771004,
0.1599865854,
0.434107542,
-0.537825048,
-0.4727500379,
-1.1344136,
-0.0216701385,
0.0720362961,
-0.5189515948,
0.0744171366,
0.3670634925,
-0.2971213162,
0.9646447897,
-0.4850362539,
0.0114877438,
-0.2849043906,
0.0704662204,
0.4855083823,
0.4145202935,
0.3742008507,
-0.6363558173,
-0.1805129498,
-0.1523447633,
-0.7218192816,
0.6038541794,
-0.357459873,
0.0144455312,
-0.0108317016,
0.1536161155,
-0.9716200233,
0.4121777713,
0.3801861703,
0.0906772837,
0.2840614617,
-0.4811611474,
-0.0275261961,
-0.9138923883,
-0.0886171162,
0.0717010424,
-0.0489145294,
-0.4851319194,
-0.1059223413,
0.0653004572,
-0.2499359399,
-0.3021837473,
0.053691905,
-0.5021490455,
-0.4938707948,
-0.1238697246,
-0.0002510343,
-0.1281783879,
0.9823397994,
0.1349929422,
0.7448920608,
0.1980094463,
-0.4681719542,
0.3603584766,
0.3319396973,
-0.3076140881,
0.4762327969,
-0.6783570051,
0.2449050993,
-0.4091716409,
0.552583456,
-0.80299896,
-0.5510057211,
0.2830910087,
-0.4123586714,
0.4735880792,
-0.1620617658,
-0.291772306,
-0.8029668927,
-0.2078227252,
0.819848597,
0.8519300818,
-0.73415941,
0.1647443175,
0.1575189531,
0.2205450088,
-0.8971958756,
-0.6020624638,
-0.2188579738,
-0.3651027679,
-0.6095988154,
0.333858788,
0.0056690229,
0.1837283075,
-0.3209836483,
-0.3644153476,
0.2013938129,
-0.1399015039,
0.2701710463,
-0.2031026334,
-0.0977549255,
0.189806208,
0.0829511881,
-0.0952467099,
0.1057214364,
-0.6255378127,
0.4829448164,
-0.066155009,
-0.6815959215,
-0.3943468332,
0.5389790535,
0.4338669777,
0.0022486518,
0.586127758,
0.593534112,
-0.1759275347,
-0.6413673162,
-0.4156405032,
-0.5562681556,
-0.52783674,
0.4006322622,
-0.1652548909,
-0.926822722,
0.377918154,
0.2782380283,
-0.1869822145,
0.2593483329,
0.2741091847,
-0.1517896801,
1.2379542589,
0.6788471341,
-0.0542337522,
0.5063410997,
-0.462525785,
0.58640939,
-0.560916543,
-0.0162710976,
-0.1030275971,
-0.7718769908,
-0.6360881925,
-0.6314026117,
0.3270829618,
-0.1096325666,
-0.1601779163,
0.4799353778,
-0.8154808283,
0.7828007936,
0.8977420926,
0.1939169765,
-0.0262770094,
0.2961241901,
0.0567768775,
0.018002769,
-0.8772405982,
-0.0958865955,
1.067378521,
0.340993762,
0.7279715538,
-0.1855129153,
0.7888041735,
0.4069230258,
0.1955286413,
-0.8353754878,
0.4159114957,
-0.0718440935,
-0.2586064339,
-0.6283888221,
-0.2964059114,
-0.9576945305,
-0.0999394208,
0.2464019805,
-0.5448823571,
0.5172011256,
0.1789460629,
-0.6356621385,
0.3098107278,
-0.6842649579,
0.5960434079,
-0.0783104673,
-0.1845249236,
-0.1350674927,
-0.908495307,
0.4164537489,
-0.0235268865,
-0.0686186627,
0.1868013293,
0.3047143221,
0.722697258,
-0.3384514749,
0.7183439136,
0.0679017529,
-0.0458626784,
0.328597188,
-0.3732584119,
0.6493617892,
0.4518810213,
0.3878352642,
0.1775346696,
-0.5096508861,
-0.6030396819,
-0.8862277865,
0.5847243667,
-0.7758119106,
-0.7634899616,
-0.40116629,
-0.6070652604,
-0.3776067793,
-0.0801282972,
0.7869367599,
0.3917455971,
0.170019716,
0.2929416299,
0.8212659955,
-0.1079286709,
0.5574336052,
-0.0344205797,
0.432577014,
-0.4608763754,
0.7807400227,
-0.0928144678,
0.1651152372,
0.6543861032,
-0.0943403468,
-0.4078484774,
-0.4753479958,
-0.3442096412,
0.1619558185,
-0.879032433,
0.0351425335,
-0.4812760353,
-0.3053117394,
-0.1114001945,
-0.3898168802,
-0.2712431252,
-0.612193048,
-0.0249455441,
-0.3062419295,
0.2148625553,
0.6856452227,
-0.1424786299,
0.2564189136,
-0.7789354324,
0.5438308716,
0.548261404,
0.3749091625,
0.1187955514,
-0.7762697935,
-0.412661761,
-0.0082238214,
-0.3008291721,
-0.6469029188,
0.325021714,
-0.1196349263,
0.4107071459,
0.4195374846,
-0.0512744822,
0.5533912778,
-0.705080092,
0.6071922183,
0.4210265279,
-0.568860352,
0.3422780037,
-0.4465517104,
0.5386229157,
0.3092703223,
0.4642468691,
-0.5368110538,
-0.3343109787,
-0.6726696491,
-0.9943440557,
0.7867017984,
0.4436853528,
0.1753740758,
-0.4181093574,
0.3060751557,
0.1401056349,
0.0008956319,
-0.2791615427,
-0.3041143417,
-0.2367716283,
-0.3648520112,
-0.387792021,
-0.3877786994,
-0.3323458433,
-0.133604899,
0.5381242633,
-0.1749324799,
0.8462811112,
0.3668516576,
-0.2457693368,
-0.045676522,
0.4227804244,
1.0429042578,
0.5955751538,
-0.2752859592,
0.0908843204,
0.1301542222,
-0.5850396156,
0.4890810549,
0.1266657263,
-0.3058899939,
0.0476195589,
0.152325049,
0.9041666985,
0.5806402564,
-0.4401165545,
0.5148787498,
-0.1238552257,
0.0090983883,
-0.6454626322,
-0.0557979606,
0.1458290368,
0.1356307715,
0.5298327208,
0.3285913765,
0.1424195468,
-0.1946577728,
0.3007369339,
0.3066974282,
-0.4751019478,
-0.5115113258,
0.7374548316,
0.1243069246,
-0.4270811379,
0.7784072161,
-0.2027439475,
-0.0457508601,
0.7865870595,
0.4301321507,
1.1284224987,
0.0594413318,
0.2855172753,
0.4145458341,
0.2035861313,
-0.536418438,
0.0631082729,
-0.2128920406,
-0.5901988745,
-0.5492146611,
-0.5755339265,
-0.4029402733,
0.0873010829,
-0.5311182141,
0.0537740141,
-0.5310453773,
-0.2137223035,
-0.4311183393,
-0.6352735162,
-0.7320407629,
-0.0095432913,
0.2980627418,
0.5748349428,
-0.4743285179,
0.6317776442,
0.5391467214,
-0.2203203589,
-0.839830339,
-0.0161220729,
-0.4870895743,
-0.7034774423,
0.678963542,
0.5593547225,
-0.0439521559,
-0.1403368413,
-0.4482989609,
-1.1784613132,
1.078273654,
0.3720627129,
-0.7061004043,
-0.434104383,
0.5277813077,
0.6845985651,
-0.230215013,
0.3018226326,
0.6409669518,
0.176799655,
0.051890973,
-0.5633296371,
-0.0196245741,
-0.1607506722,
0.3146953881,
0.3575891852,
-0.6963592172,
0.4351047873,
-0.480902791,
-0.162572369,
0.0502148047,
0.7793719769,
0.3210927546,
0.076976575,
0.2341340631,
0.7690471411,
0.4458496869,
-0.0375785045,
1.2772165537,
-0.4214210212,
0.4188812375,
1.0940442085,
-0.0627282262,
0.4851981401,
0.4534970522,
-0.0851225257,
0.4407260418,
0.4083605111,
-0.1754881889,
0.5421862006,
0.2043673247,
-0.1091778055,
-0.3363128603,
0.2631280124,
-0.354269743,
0.2037398517,
0.2598768473,
-0.7054969668,
-0.0202906281,
0.124462612,
-0.3781238496,
0.0047991164,
-0.1959338039,
0.2827022076,
0.2745404243,
-0.9273341894,
0.8708071113,
-0.1244154572,
0.7427540421,
-0.4944040179,
0.0255194791,
-0.287166357,
0.382714361,
0.0362884104,
-0.6139941812,
0.0365936011,
-0.4622507989,
-0.4829936028,
-0.451341778,
0.5237283111,
-0.1491202563,
-0.2844051719,
0.0500634424,
-0.0382169671,
-0.2099681944,
0.0585820712,
-0.2279328406,
-0.414211303,
-0.2348926216,
-0.4153312743,
0.4018486738,
0.2956663668,
-0.4131192267,
0.6918225288,
0.6698783636,
-0.4139176905,
0.4098205864,
0.0886035934,
0.5193138123,
-0.8098415136,
-0.7273002863,
-0.6310518384,
0.2655411661,
-0.0430071019,
-0.2702011764,
0.7071302533,
0.2596350908,
1.0875616074,
-0.7877755165,
0.6888445616,
0.2319810688,
0.0569673926,
-0.2664665878,
0.3156577945,
-0.2053631842,
0.1017487273,
0.1190713048,
-1.071586132,
-0.2785337567,
0.4654354453,
-0.625053823,
0.0657600239,
0.7739841342,
0.3911418617,
-0.2772184908,
-0.001154326,
0.3506798744,
-0.1112021282,
0.0750287399,
1.0517039299,
0.9253382683,
-0.4387924075,
0.8046891689,
-0.5668299198,
0.0991688743,
-0.3825218379,
-0.5651146173,
-0.9374529719,
-0.3912287056,
-0.0425909795,
-0.0254348721,
0.1788308024,
0.6787869334,
0.7891873121,
-0.8766487241,
0.0779902562,
-0.3423095345,
0.1459212601,
-0.5353724957,
-0.2300369292,
0.3441982269,
-0.2687829435,
-0.642439127,
0.4995496869,
0.5154385567,
0.0205137674,
-0.0591583997,
-0.0263006538,
0.0822347403,
0.0751373693,
0.4450675845,
0.7599295974,
-0.6823627353,
-0.7072890997,
0.1991355717,
-0.1120839193,
0.3346749246,
0.8777750134,
-0.7128184438,
0.0227112919,
0.7677130699,
0.4918483794,
0.3339649141,
0.2079549134,
0.6728765965,
-1.0275437832,
0.3349434733,
0.2932499051,
0.5153564215,
0.3131207526,
-0.5016008615,
0.5314723253,
0.3062462807,
-0.5853437781,
-0.6016353369,
0.5793330669,
-1.1651365757,
0.0151338698,
1.2516604662,
-0.0419237316,
-0.2991880774,
0.1590849012,
0.031688638,
0.1506242305,
-0.4752306342,
1.1391308308,
0.525474906,
-0.0115676066,
0.0053361724,
-0.1461630911,
0.7110434175,
0.5557667613,
-0.3347531557,
-0.2523314953,
0.293438375,
0.3346663117,
0.6637688279,
0.3530064821,
0.0953781009,
0.6235277653,
-0.1413006932,
-0.1141903251,
0.141747281,
-0.4861575961,
-0.5327084661,
0.4667040408,
-0.1062420458,
-0.0537770949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16834v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16834v1 | Free Lunch: Robust Cross-Lingual Transfer via Model Checkpoint Averaging | 2023-05-26T11:24:32 | 2023-05-26T11:24:32 | Fabian David Schmidt, Ivan Vulić, Goran Glavaš | cs.CL | cs.CL | Massively multilingual language models have displayed strong performance in
zero-shot (ZS-XLT) and few-shot (FS-XLT) cross-lingual transfer setups, where
models fine-tuned on task data in a source language are transferred without any
or with only a few annotated instances to the target language(s). However,
current work typically overestimates model performance as fine-tuned models are
frequently evaluated at model checkpoints that generalize best to validation
instances in the target languages. This effectively violates the main
assumptions of "true" ZS-XLT and FS-XLT. Such XLT setups require robust methods
that do not depend on labeled target language data for validation and model
selection. In this work, aiming to improve the robustness of "true" ZS-XLT and
FS-XLT, we propose a simple and effective method that averages different
checkpoints (i.e., model snapshots) during task fine-tuning. We conduct
exhaustive ZS-XLT and FS-XLT experiments across higher-level semantic tasks
(NLI, extractive QA) and lower-level token classification tasks (NER, POS). The
results indicate that averaging model checkpoints yields systematic and
consistent performance gains across diverse target languages in all tasks.
Importantly, it simultaneously substantially desensitizes XLT to varying
hyperparameter choices in the absence of target language validation. We also
show that checkpoint averaging benefits performance when further combined with
run averaging (i.e., averaging the parameters of models fine-tuned over
independent runs). | [
-0.2263090461,
-0.6191125512,
0.5222835541,
0.3107142746,
-0.2355336249,
-0.0685772151,
-0.1523112357,
-0.6036598682,
0.0695649311,
0.2520272434,
-0.3697131276,
-0.3155069649,
-0.6577797532,
0.0188533198,
-0.4362603128,
0.8803560138,
-0.1573568285,
0.1848228127,
0.1106749848,
-0.413943857,
-0.4022603333,
-0.2188508064,
-0.6597636342,
-0.1663590074,
0.5100904107,
0.1478672177,
0.6341545582,
0.639882803,
0.2731405199,
0.1914981455,
0.0083283996,
0.0226653758,
-0.3414562941,
-0.0116406055,
-0.5476709604,
-0.3420416713,
-0.4697909653,
-0.3125197887,
0.8860442638,
0.8289897442,
0.013527927,
0.1748879552,
0.210513413,
0.4938376248,
-0.8808647394,
0.2259660214,
-0.6327016354,
0.0573003553,
-0.1669983268,
0.1348087341,
-0.4700689316,
-0.0187144261,
-0.0473788045,
-0.8071764112,
-0.1666066498,
-0.0054275929,
0.8542804718,
-0.1003426611,
-0.3350680172,
0.1034184024,
-0.6552791595,
1.0505735874,
-0.7268702984,
0.5882186294,
0.243837133,
0.3063465059,
0.1010686383,
-0.2556625903,
-0.3371704817,
-0.0728176609,
0.1034751609,
0.1133317947,
-0.4631911218,
0.0455679744,
0.2545562088,
0.261600405,
-0.6329863071,
0.3585932851,
-0.1078453511,
-0.5168294907,
0.1884967685,
0.1888591647,
0.4983109236,
0.099420853,
-0.4600335956,
-0.2963353992,
-0.4950942099,
0.128780067,
-0.014543185,
0.8450916409,
-0.0835731998,
0.4566529095,
-0.6311306357,
0.7189981341,
-0.0689500496,
-0.0042429967,
0.1198585033,
-1.0087202787,
-0.2054922432,
-0.2705288231,
0.8913832307,
0.3826642334,
0.251464963,
-0.3980679214,
-0.4963899851,
-0.0597453937,
-0.1278970242,
-0.8644483685,
-0.0560674705,
0.1049052253,
-0.2704122663,
-0.1331688017,
-0.3439974785,
-0.743927598,
0.0819454715,
-0.2155466974,
0.6941843033,
-0.5671946406,
-0.2136943936,
-0.0894861296,
-0.0537683107,
0.1163563952,
0.3528849483,
-0.8378992081,
0.3899942636,
0.3696814477,
1.1415739059,
-0.308711946,
-0.6106792688,
-1.080144763,
0.3548364043,
-0.6903967261,
0.9495054483,
-0.423032254,
-0.0904520079,
0.0035362446,
0.1222307459,
-0.6904871464,
-0.4056846499,
0.2356274277,
-0.3354460001,
-0.0140586942,
-0.6776814461,
-0.3559542,
-0.1522551179,
0.3816034198,
-0.5093559027,
1.0252701044,
0.2810831368,
-0.6993511915,
0.4886597693,
-0.5961996317,
-0.4472953677,
-0.0146238348,
0.0951790586,
-0.1181987226,
-0.0546275489,
0.538906455,
0.3429754078,
-0.1635909677,
-0.0999780968,
-0.4407750368,
-0.3572319746,
-0.0826348737,
-0.1934848279,
1.0257663727,
0.2412104607,
-0.5210988522,
0.1592008471,
-0.7042684555,
0.2486473024,
-0.1028782204,
-0.3350949287,
-0.4219634235,
-0.2391242534,
0.1568164229,
0.4280362427,
0.0620999448,
-0.5649353862,
0.0994134247,
-0.1416909546,
0.0410406776,
0.5841802359,
-0.2576502562,
0.6182889938,
-0.5860028267,
0.5259523988,
0.2598582506,
-0.0769702047,
-0.407769084,
-0.2997341454,
-0.7252398729,
-0.5630023479,
0.4621985257,
0.9258909822,
-0.9488719702,
0.1203318909,
-0.5177045465,
-0.4989669919,
-0.2979689538,
0.36238271,
0.5789086819,
0.3224032521,
0.4548157752,
-0.5928092599,
-0.0778195336,
-0.9058558941,
-0.3706225455,
-0.2192929685,
-0.1627718508,
0.1475515813,
0.2054673135,
-0.0012228604,
0.6369373202,
-0.1159915477,
-0.3480196595,
-0.5587933064,
0.3710643947,
-0.0812415108,
0.6777513027,
0.9622043371,
-0.1040058583,
-0.6489848495,
0.3296051621,
-0.3740834296,
-0.1713769436,
-0.35026595,
-0.3371061385,
0.3075728416,
0.3418359458,
-0.5238866806,
0.0950700343,
0.4841191471,
-0.2712115347,
0.6095278263,
-0.1325326413,
0.3127355278,
-1.0159125328,
0.1844173372,
-0.0449655168,
-0.4541910291,
-0.5561850071,
0.1556890458,
0.2804107964,
0.050087139,
-0.6380685568,
0.6998390555,
-0.5173292756,
-0.2842378318,
-0.2747710049,
0.0099183647,
-0.0728372559,
0.570522368,
0.0342783444,
0.6528479457,
1.033767581,
-0.5257173181,
0.0239860844,
0.0511594415,
-0.4378890991,
0.7233868241,
-0.4026975632,
0.1476017088,
0.2251837105,
0.2390553802,
-0.8815864921,
0.0599606261,
0.253921777,
-0.1538394541,
0.3908234537,
-0.2935377955,
-0.5781884789,
0.2701617181,
-0.1409721524,
0.5116115212,
0.3197982907,
-0.2907160819,
0.6105776429,
0.0840683877,
-0.2908995748,
-0.4528953433,
-0.8265686035,
0.1857403666,
-0.1039782315,
-0.6389667392,
0.1159319356,
0.0235380158,
-0.1201858297,
-0.0665789545,
0.0411768593,
-0.3306249678,
0.0993824676,
-0.1643865556,
0.2120819688,
-0.5572995543,
-0.3667238057,
0.3939802945,
-0.1105111539,
-0.2091722339,
-0.5660123825,
0.1615299135,
-0.0077251834,
-0.4368777275,
-0.4261817038,
0.5140859485,
0.9569547772,
-0.1621251255,
0.7842624784,
0.6368145347,
-0.4201148748,
-0.0903616622,
-0.3100123107,
-0.0821409449,
-0.3194942772,
0.4915702939,
-0.3955942392,
-0.6154401302,
0.9558954835,
0.2868483365,
0.4645368457,
0.304921627,
0.4671748877,
0.4127814174,
1.1291241646,
0.7461755872,
-0.2940667868,
0.6480535269,
0.1712901443,
0.0326666869,
-0.642629087,
0.246831432,
-0.6294513941,
-0.1083365753,
-0.3954175711,
-0.5833076239,
0.0718213618,
-0.0209213477,
-0.0250706729,
0.5173668861,
0.120421797,
0.4882371724,
0.4556782544,
-0.0824177116,
0.2027680278,
0.08373335,
-0.6490683556,
0.0122466953,
-0.8502058387,
-0.1717800945,
0.8521900177,
0.2157752961,
0.505776763,
0.0876201913,
0.4265818894,
-0.0182229765,
0.0160403438,
-0.6508535743,
0.5711758137,
-0.286675036,
-0.5627766252,
-0.3913588822,
-0.5643581152,
-0.6944283843,
0.5689980388,
-0.0673172995,
-1.102206707,
0.2515497506,
0.1609854102,
-0.673884213,
0.4712293446,
-0.4967676997,
0.9416258335,
-0.1061461717,
-0.6378479004,
-0.1351293176,
-0.5608141422,
0.2925088704,
-0.2934093475,
0.408611685,
-0.2442726195,
0.0990732834,
0.7198731899,
-0.1503595859,
0.7738879919,
-0.1017086208,
-0.0268729609,
0.0744622722,
0.6076304317,
0.6196299791,
-0.3671432734,
-0.0310919881,
0.4231775105,
0.4091490805,
-0.7070607543,
-0.4948251545,
0.6093931794,
-0.5003764629,
-0.2921251655,
-0.305105865,
-0.9401007295,
-0.3336382806,
0.5706869364,
0.103966929,
0.4064714611,
0.0167263877,
0.06442184,
0.3760274649,
-0.203578949,
0.4491103888,
0.5787534118,
-0.2424135208,
-0.2862760723,
0.9604702592,
0.360688746,
0.7716539502,
0.5183684826,
0.119576931,
-0.1261816174,
-0.814648807,
-0.9679293036,
0.0168156102,
-0.8214830756,
-0.1099501103,
-0.7338098884,
0.0117215058,
-0.6623488069,
-0.2417819351,
-0.69062078,
-0.672655046,
0.0439269654,
-0.0478850603,
0.0117364908,
0.2832567692,
-0.3168506622,
0.1478785574,
-1.1170607805,
0.1166867018,
0.1918904334,
0.2039082646,
0.0013072734,
-0.6408140063,
-0.4465382397,
0.1672715247,
-0.1289825439,
-0.7189166546,
0.3664034009,
0.4255081415,
0.7510183454,
0.3985302746,
0.0954832733,
0.9206652045,
-0.2768933475,
0.8079974651,
0.0506239198,
-1.0707702637,
0.1743703783,
-0.5843925476,
0.5374931693,
0.6840437651,
0.1501451284,
-0.632663846,
-0.7957696915,
-0.1095987037,
-0.9643124938,
0.9201574922,
0.2960224152,
0.0186353009,
0.0471633673,
0.0256764349,
0.0376702882,
-0.2870056927,
-0.7984950542,
0.1134169325,
-0.1185818687,
-0.0509391911,
0.0868452117,
0.0337397531,
0.0251537375,
-0.1144078001,
0.7159660459,
-0.5091915727,
-0.0638431981,
-0.0308728646,
-0.4057495296,
-0.3508965671,
0.220985651,
0.5416500568,
0.7306333184,
-0.0150067685,
0.1905950457,
0.5121984482,
-0.3520371616,
0.0024238066,
0.1104798242,
-0.3388686478,
-0.0006407136,
0.4056692123,
0.6833217144,
0.698641479,
-0.6956838369,
0.4938209355,
0.0063200411,
-0.0464434177,
0.3096292317,
0.0653626248,
-0.0752462223,
0.270235002,
0.1581555903,
0.0183360707,
0.0479964614,
-0.4079584181,
0.3212639689,
0.4700091183,
-0.5053158402,
-0.5219674706,
0.555962503,
-0.0454112962,
0.2831287682,
0.6676884294,
-0.030925395,
-0.458856225,
0.4437141418,
0.5626943111,
1.0047426224,
-0.3146595657,
0.0995511711,
0.6174923182,
0.460018605,
-0.3293303251,
-0.0563868135,
-0.2903950512,
-0.7374522686,
-0.4112584889,
-0.6780731082,
-0.4019104242,
-0.0930915326,
-0.8010574579,
0.3333594203,
-0.1844251305,
0.1883910596,
-0.1617459357,
-0.1813270897,
-0.3593952656,
0.063590847,
0.104911305,
1.0700668097,
-1.1778094769,
1.016072154,
0.5292932987,
-0.2599838078,
-0.7555966973,
-0.1124998853,
0.0126294699,
-0.5631732345,
0.2860636711,
0.025966106,
-0.122492902,
-0.2905614674,
0.036243584,
-1.0520102978,
0.9723795056,
0.5866619349,
-0.6609087586,
-0.094907552,
0.2518381476,
0.2998639643,
-0.357326895,
0.2282834947,
0.5089251399,
0.3438930809,
0.3862053156,
-1.341982007,
0.2788945436,
-0.1815038323,
-0.0352831148,
0.1392386109,
-0.4450237155,
0.8428474665,
-0.3200318515,
-0.1857967377,
0.2077423036,
0.5267534256,
0.3154040277,
0.2564284503,
0.6510039568,
0.4339346588,
0.5104264617,
0.0961868316,
1.0683087111,
-0.475956887,
0.2643943131,
1.0133453608,
-0.3566922247,
0.8555000424,
0.4183604419,
0.0229363553,
0.1030689403,
0.7123386264,
0.1118971407,
0.6062881351,
-0.3222937584,
0.0528517812,
-0.5076297522,
0.0750070959,
-0.1755046695,
0.2914503813,
0.065696843,
-0.241287753,
-0.631682992,
0.0006411413,
0.3121917546,
-0.3759134412,
-0.2793215513,
0.6690497398,
-0.0539097227,
-0.8872630596,
0.5604999065,
0.003074172,
0.5296195149,
-0.735969007,
0.2827929258,
-0.3996539414,
0.1993577629,
0.0235964283,
-0.4273432791,
0.4801154435,
-0.0059940335,
-0.0180580243,
-0.3088440597,
0.4968494177,
-0.5604810119,
-0.7029806972,
0.4154974222,
0.5795280933,
0.195732072,
-0.067725569,
-0.6531198025,
-0.0291490871,
-0.0061039235,
-0.1584868282,
0.8011471033,
0.445104152,
-0.3491503298,
0.4791941941,
0.7201465964,
0.230098784,
0.3361051679,
-0.03490052,
0.7475433946,
-0.4917555153,
-0.6568393111,
-0.6020988822,
0.3841530979,
0.2573748827,
-0.2758071721,
0.8751900196,
0.6244184971,
0.8774670959,
0.1708026081,
0.6610666513,
0.020130299,
0.4328277707,
-0.6188846827,
0.7899086475,
-0.6670751572,
0.0868112296,
-0.5821093321,
-0.9064055085,
-0.3976486921,
0.4228342175,
-0.1603713185,
0.0192444213,
0.654014647,
0.7978715301,
-0.3386903107,
-0.3564456105,
0.7748898864,
0.1299932152,
0.3948205113,
0.7198417187,
0.5443524718,
-0.2404032648,
0.6552971005,
-0.4253158271,
-0.3653006256,
-0.0426530614,
-0.9270792603,
-0.6310617924,
-0.4099548161,
-0.6400463581,
-0.3098811805,
0.1664818078,
0.7664177418,
0.8711379766,
-1.0209568739,
-0.3659233749,
0.1425846964,
0.0734020025,
-0.7260797024,
-0.1460516006,
0.3164295256,
-0.6419363618,
-0.9180871844,
0.4576359987,
0.3872653842,
0.1438087821,
-0.1083092019,
0.0821271315,
-0.0281262323,
0.3617317975,
0.4874350727,
0.3864132762,
-0.4349046052,
-0.2893178761,
0.150901854,
-0.1251380593,
-0.0008597821,
0.7790303826,
-0.5806245208,
0.4728630185,
0.5198438764,
0.6339071393,
0.2468989491,
-0.2859255075,
0.6938691735,
-0.4453440011,
0.2731612921,
-0.0274209753,
0.5608199835,
0.3243803978,
-0.1714727283,
0.1835343391,
0.2003588676,
-0.1732967049,
-1.0948785543,
0.0578896441,
-1.0795098543,
-0.3272258043,
1.2849484682,
-0.5328608155,
-0.3491854966,
-0.2533915937,
0.1419226229,
0.091557771,
-0.1527839452,
0.7904211283,
0.7784428,
-0.1289031506,
-0.1601207703,
-0.5164743066,
0.0507477187,
0.6491242051,
-0.7098151445,
0.2814888954,
0.4385707974,
0.6317191124,
0.1820506901,
0.4411276579,
-0.3240523636,
0.5612812042,
0.2203330845,
-0.2778680623,
0.0321884304,
-0.2751836777,
-0.2974491417,
0.1896573901,
0.0580600165,
-0.4100188315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16833v1 | KNSE: A Knowledge-aware Natural Language Inference Framework for Dialogue Symptom Status Recognition | 2023-05-26T11:23:26 | 2023-05-26T11:23:26 | Wei Chen, Shiqi Wei, Zhongyu Wei, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Symptom diagnosis in medical conversations aims to correctly extract both
symptom entities and their status from the doctor-patient dialogue. In this
paper, we propose a novel framework called KNSE for symptom status recognition
(SSR), where the SSR is formulated as a natural language inference (NLI) task.
For each mentioned symptom in a dialogue window, we first generate knowledge
about the symptom and hypothesis about status of the symptom, to form a
(premise, knowledge, hypothesis) triplet. The BERT model is then used to encode
the triplet, which is further processed by modules including utterance
aggregation, self-attention, cross-attention, and GRU to predict the symptom
status. Benefiting from the NLI formalization, the proposed framework can
encode more informative prior knowledge to better localize and track symptom
status, which can effectively improve the performance of symptom status
recognition. Preliminary experiments on Chinese medical dialogue datasets show
that KNSE outperforms previous competitive baselines and has advantages in
cross-disease and cross-symptom scenarios. | [
0.065263994,
-0.343174696,
0.796525836,
0.2850829661,
-0.2874466181,
-0.0874779671,
-0.0902850181,
-0.52178514,
0.5605529547,
0.4403900206,
-0.435470134,
-0.7240162492,
-0.6977189779,
0.1806834042,
-0.1860359907,
1.1188054085,
0.2224379182,
0.2605412304,
-0.1645426005,
0.1683805287,
-0.4464100897,
-0.2182232291,
-1.0226339102,
-0.101663515,
0.2921511829,
0.1949539781,
0.4068952501,
0.0741295293,
0.3568532169,
0.225526005,
0.0340686999,
-0.1161459982,
-0.1192583293,
0.6093636751,
0.3380375206,
-0.6288574338,
-0.3532720804,
-0.1838385016,
0.537240386,
0.7846146226,
-0.0045665246,
-0.1891366243,
0.1105147898,
0.5545536876,
-0.3914043605,
0.3962909877,
-0.0892852321,
0.3555538356,
0.0812399536,
0.4389244318,
-0.3134497106,
-0.4801287949,
0.5678975582,
-0.5189168453,
0.1643007845,
-0.3594498634,
1.1308914423,
0.3777049482,
-0.5367131233,
-0.1517107487,
-0.4074270129,
0.6394907832,
-1.1749943495,
0.8090386987,
0.5943787694,
0.6944198608,
0.0194395222,
-0.6199732423,
-0.506509006,
-0.3346893191,
-0.5575563908,
0.3837938905,
0.0802470595,
0.245752573,
0.0485386364,
0.2739171684,
-0.6742619872,
-0.1216099188,
-0.1256121248,
-0.5009288192,
0.2325008512,
0.0334977582,
0.3838141859,
-0.9214909673,
-0.1776251793,
0.4000158608,
-0.1732445359,
0.1118755564,
-0.386613667,
0.0986027569,
-0.5576171279,
0.1623654366,
-0.1192095205,
0.8543432355,
-0.2411979735,
-0.5281104445,
0.0818302035,
-0.2820321321,
-0.4284268916,
0.3830516636,
0.828068614,
0.4241831601,
-0.2592193484,
-0.3453215063,
0.0944814458,
0.3542343676,
0.1335380524,
-0.4138049781,
-0.5826419592,
0.4172692895,
-0.5975936055,
-0.209116891,
-0.0848159492,
-1.0195394754,
-0.6553492546,
-0.3635365963,
0.1055146903,
-0.5603457689,
-0.4520431459,
-0.1583914906,
-0.1720973402,
-0.0450293943,
0.3269780874,
-0.6746311784,
0.2367099822,
0.5679671764,
0.6626429558,
0.0450106971,
0.3796235919,
-0.5060819983,
0.2911422849,
-0.3208060265,
0.6145867705,
-0.436789602,
-0.3020493686,
-0.2556090355,
-0.1056865156,
-0.328797549,
-0.3622805476,
0.5496821404,
-0.0623961799,
0.2827015519,
-0.2691321075,
-0.6500589848,
0.0896405429,
0.2389095277,
-0.6596909165,
0.8626894355,
0.4079645574,
-0.6883317232,
0.6207746863,
-0.8718032241,
-0.5611226559,
0.1980306804,
-0.2346418649,
-0.1674344093,
-0.104418844,
0.2277061194,
0.5508428812,
-0.2592550516,
0.4839525223,
-0.2506819963,
0.2541043758,
-0.1556185931,
-0.3230736554,
0.6539123654,
0.3130405247,
0.0417104401,
-0.1468645483,
-0.6653054357,
-0.0205027536,
-0.1402069628,
-0.0447309203,
-0.6066769958,
0.1514497995,
-0.6960109472,
0.0643447563,
0.1972765476,
-0.8752596378,
0.0398426726,
-0.9121959209,
0.271302402,
0.4408828616,
0.3272218704,
0.3086737096,
0.0666520372,
0.4374584854,
0.1939263642,
0.3981821835,
0.0537711605,
-0.8536995649,
-0.7515617609,
-0.4935514331,
0.4018541574,
0.6994075775,
-0.6796832681,
0.3547425568,
-0.1272566915,
-0.0203400254,
-1.0342049599,
-0.0397770144,
0.6097784638,
0.8057934642,
0.0746243671,
0.3991034627,
-0.809075892,
-0.977976203,
-0.2121572196,
-0.1766970754,
-0.1705342084,
0.2901750505,
0.1776623726,
-0.1842174977,
0.9923512936,
-0.5076467991,
-0.3901539445,
-0.5639973283,
0.299695462,
0.3663880229,
0.1578596234,
0.4659370184,
-0.6878331304,
-0.6269689202,
0.4088778198,
-0.8681993484,
-0.2512499988,
-0.0361778252,
-0.1770946383,
0.4440874755,
0.3371674418,
-0.5781932473,
0.764521718,
0.5153372288,
-0.5491175652,
0.4396170676,
-0.0420193411,
0.2181638181,
-1.4668693542,
-0.0713491216,
0.0929561406,
-0.2457848787,
-0.5697777271,
-0.4227099419,
-0.0227572285,
-0.1208970845,
0.0414853394,
0.5513880253,
-0.0840289146,
-0.0480833128,
0.1428268403,
0.2899981737,
0.2737616897,
0.2602141201,
0.0002246919,
0.2664711177,
0.5738034248,
-0.7907416821,
0.1490186155,
0.1744963974,
-0.4538532794,
0.67985636,
-0.4034877419,
-0.4142363667,
-0.0356240869,
0.1423193067,
-1.0040252209,
-0.4019920528,
0.3714010119,
-0.7232471704,
0.2561586797,
-0.3497986495,
-0.2395648956,
-0.6525065303,
0.2722351253,
0.155086115,
0.4982718527,
-0.3066703677,
0.939550221,
0.3429862559,
-0.5294469595,
-0.3059609234,
-0.4085482061,
0.0019204459,
0.1028726548,
-0.4768961966,
0.0678933337,
0.156860888,
-0.1009936854,
0.0988695845,
-0.5113325715,
-0.331133604,
0.0583859943,
0.2857086658,
0.4474074244,
-0.2814283967,
0.2821729183,
0.4580831826,
-0.3740454912,
0.3222546875,
-0.039500691,
0.3281747997,
-0.0034812831,
-0.4251480699,
-0.892889142,
0.4808444083,
0.5929415226,
0.1166862696,
0.357144773,
0.3427729309,
-0.4813646972,
0.0706332922,
-0.4323910475,
-0.3029580116,
-0.347120434,
0.095090583,
-0.2986630201,
-0.8030580282,
0.6807974577,
-0.1209537983,
-0.020381568,
0.4099838138,
0.191209048,
-0.5877506733,
1.5015798807,
0.2242354155,
-0.3489868045,
-0.1069289073,
-0.0364271961,
0.74282974,
-0.6683626771,
-0.189773798,
-0.5615055561,
-0.2509123087,
-0.2261230797,
-0.1152347252,
0.8591962457,
0.1261920482,
0.0079573803,
0.0162507333,
-0.3907627463,
0.3034946024,
0.4420602322,
0.1222415939,
0.0394534022,
-0.4653978348,
-0.5404756665,
-0.5386988521,
-0.8525972962,
-0.2312108725,
0.6124750376,
0.2058983147,
0.2802426815,
0.2129147053,
0.8850063086,
0.4176663458,
0.3184422851,
-0.6448245049,
0.659380734,
-0.3915097713,
-0.3038734794,
-0.0801314637,
-0.6157294512,
-0.9509817362,
-0.1144673377,
-0.1342705339,
-0.9826205969,
0.0977564976,
0.2362296283,
-0.5665028691,
0.1648141891,
-1.0617456436,
1.1528325081,
-0.0990146771,
0.4546068609,
-0.1531989723,
-1.037369132,
0.4795109332,
0.1577834934,
0.3613818586,
-0.1459211707,
0.4375864267,
0.8367283344,
-0.479352504,
1.1986055374,
-0.6558838487,
-0.0444771089,
-0.0722263977,
0.1527875215,
0.2026743144,
0.4648203254,
0.0584407337,
0.1570157111,
0.3521964848,
-0.2375351936,
-1.1606066227,
0.5777648687,
-0.4444895983,
-0.3833220303,
-0.2353080958,
-0.4113258421,
-0.4969249368,
0.3373460174,
0.0990756005,
0.5023963451,
-0.077632226,
-0.2680547535,
0.5788015127,
-0.2940587103,
0.0787565336,
0.7994257212,
-0.2138848156,
-0.4472983181,
0.9341833591,
-0.258660078,
0.3078674972,
0.4338489175,
0.4762254059,
-0.2955680788,
-0.1227733642,
-0.3321554661,
0.2278242558,
-0.625022471,
-0.3807009757,
-0.8010035157,
-0.5609464645,
-0.7484960556,
-0.1084932983,
-0.2313013673,
-0.4148833454,
-0.1116791517,
-0.0569755472,
0.5518045425,
0.8093131781,
-0.115923211,
0.2145698667,
-0.9617897868,
0.8204371929,
0.1437717527,
0.6787523031,
-0.0976458862,
-0.2305592597,
-0.2387377322,
0.3669988513,
0.2845127285,
-0.8524330854,
0.4076901376,
0.1516184807,
0.7150440812,
0.8150197864,
0.51450634,
0.6827875972,
-0.2871878743,
0.976559639,
0.4139531851,
-0.7964322567,
0.9613779187,
0.0408381671,
0.2904866338,
0.5004869699,
0.3794064224,
-0.8187822104,
-1.0009721518,
-0.6303065419,
-0.6373315454,
0.6020466685,
0.1348140538,
-0.3979543447,
-0.3987829089,
0.1619979888,
0.1275253743,
-0.1876341999,
-0.5545881391,
-0.1833494455,
-0.1735686511,
-0.7015846372,
0.2549274266,
-0.348941505,
-0.2190869749,
-0.6714107394,
0.6932852864,
0.0694314837,
0.6821671128,
0.4446928203,
-0.0621957034,
0.2158159316,
0.2363691777,
0.4220069945,
0.1553533375,
-0.4524650574,
-0.1427527517,
0.0195995215,
-0.4071385562,
-0.2931613624,
0.2931427062,
0.0607607998,
0.3816876709,
0.3174555004,
1.014598608,
0.5732671022,
-0.5966433883,
0.577703476,
-0.0924489275,
-0.2998705506,
-0.0772775188,
0.0714203343,
0.0034496498,
0.2870029807,
0.1003072783,
0.140397951,
0.2324324101,
-0.0283906888,
0.2723996043,
0.4499909282,
-0.6110390425,
-0.2248646021,
0.3425794244,
0.3129290342,
-0.328568846,
0.543692708,
-0.3245173693,
-0.588829577,
0.571429491,
0.4375907481,
0.5339586139,
-0.4251698256,
0.431191951,
0.3288591504,
0.0504635386,
0.2864733934,
0.5676655769,
-0.1300593466,
-0.6734255552,
-0.6069452763,
-0.6962317824,
-0.3538855612,
0.1546952277,
-0.9690535665,
-0.0333880931,
-0.2693561316,
-0.3492146134,
0.2260885835,
-0.2624302208,
-0.305948168,
0.1610749513,
0.1399998218,
0.7613229752,
-0.878516078,
0.6800758243,
0.5398652554,
-0.132348001,
-0.7143980265,
-0.0611253045,
0.1527915001,
-0.7343212962,
0.6500296593,
0.1911568642,
0.2143612504,
0.0142066749,
-0.2221582383,
-0.8630238175,
0.7266232371,
0.323279351,
-0.2936859131,
-0.004686459,
0.0091248434,
0.3734209239,
-0.1998556256,
-0.0623711608,
0.7924167514,
0.6251759529,
-0.0368410908,
-1.1726509333,
-0.0986004174,
-0.4118175805,
-0.2611662745,
0.7273016572,
0.1883451343,
0.1830432713,
-0.3209269345,
-0.374042958,
0.1291369647,
0.4877744317,
0.2079571187,
0.3457967639,
0.6189364791,
0.892511487,
0.8808134794,
-0.1353721172,
1.2322707176,
-0.4639605582,
-0.1878346503,
1.054161191,
-0.3899324238,
0.6652812958,
0.1388920248,
-0.2692284584,
0.8643072248,
0.227083683,
0.3118007183,
0.5474629998,
-0.3782373667,
-0.5813782811,
-0.304549396,
-0.0384325571,
-0.3723923862,
0.2779864967,
0.7607752085,
-0.4740120173,
-0.6057863832,
0.3635240495,
0.0477655381,
-0.264895469,
-0.013829031,
1.1868890524,
0.0793263838,
-0.5343158245,
0.6552134752,
-0.4686296582,
0.116788663,
-0.9673608541,
-0.3083860576,
-0.0668427423,
-0.0549238846,
-0.0227219742,
-0.7005613446,
0.2296960354,
-0.1060493737,
-0.5465046167,
0.0875216499,
0.8444194198,
-0.4237262607,
-0.6766156554,
0.24893713,
0.2284347415,
0.5037680864,
0.0813516974,
-0.7326809764,
-0.2271772176,
0.1155749634,
0.1912950426,
0.4517920017,
0.6502154469,
0.019435212,
0.7146464586,
0.6147637367,
0.2416323274,
-0.1397051662,
0.55856359,
0.675814569,
-0.5549047589,
-0.7152954936,
-0.4808043838,
0.6024057865,
-0.5887708664,
-0.1111682206,
0.5709738731,
0.2327700555,
0.0870807171,
0.0268535912,
0.9740626812,
-0.1219376773,
1.090857029,
-0.3400958776,
0.9120354056,
-0.3866605461,
0.0911757201,
-0.346172899,
0.0363840722,
-0.370203495,
0.8488530517,
-0.3724558353,
-0.0988526866,
0.7367735505,
0.507098496,
0.1491011083,
0.4782285094,
0.1258285046,
0.6702858806,
0.1380071044,
0.7160052657,
0.3497976661,
-0.1173127517,
0.144921124,
-0.3683505058,
-0.2538444996,
-0.1679094583,
-0.8799684048,
-0.609095633,
-0.553658545,
-0.3041284084,
-0.2541194558,
0.2583993673,
0.7928649187,
0.8632627726,
-0.9807850122,
0.1163078025,
-0.0419966951,
0.2462861687,
-0.4780497551,
-0.3776819408,
0.3415975869,
-0.5251514912,
-0.0631438047,
0.6161617637,
0.3709014058,
0.0252646487,
0.127381742,
-0.0968766883,
-0.1570821404,
-0.4216993451,
0.8035174608,
0.24633196,
-1.0357011557,
-0.0393407904,
-0.2724817991,
0.03041628,
-0.0169395227,
0.8594217896,
-1.1014126539,
0.6003379226,
0.0630909428,
0.6805615425,
0.012041444,
-0.2446157187,
0.8849158883,
-0.8076515794,
-0.0640538633,
0.6030184031,
0.3344888389,
-0.0036913184,
-0.424310565,
0.0810532868,
0.3952616453,
-0.2670301497,
-0.8708194494,
0.4034147859,
-1.3049380779,
-0.4290763438,
0.8506447673,
-0.168642953,
-0.1213239208,
-0.8229939938,
-0.259411186,
0.2173755169,
-0.5032808185,
0.6908612251,
0.504180789,
-0.3038663864,
-0.2139125466,
-0.9471163154,
0.6797589064,
0.5404934287,
-0.6820480824,
0.1804199666,
0.3323251307,
0.1430389136,
-0.0260809176,
0.5898312926,
0.0725861788,
0.4582985044,
-0.2429409027,
-0.0074035362,
0.2715443969,
-0.1454759091,
0.2749732137,
-0.1600902975,
-0.3260805011,
-0.0241869055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16826v1 | Prompt- and Trait Relation-aware Cross-prompt Essay Trait Scoring | 2023-05-26T11:11:19 | 2023-05-26T11:11:19 | Heejin Do, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automated essay scoring (AES) aims to score essays written for a given
prompt, which defines the writing topic. Most existing AES systems assume to
grade essays of the same prompt as used in training and assign only a holistic
score. However, such settings conflict with real-education situations;
pre-graded essays for a particular prompt are lacking, and detailed trait
scores of sub-rubrics are required. Thus, predicting various trait scores of
unseen-prompt essays (called cross-prompt essay trait scoring) is a remaining
challenge of AES. In this paper, we propose a robust model: prompt- and trait
relation-aware cross-prompt essay trait scorer. We encode prompt-aware essay
representation by essay-prompt attention and utilizing the topic-coherence
feature extracted by the topic-modeling mechanism without access to labeled
data; therefore, our model considers the prompt adherence of an essay, even in
a cross-prompt setting. To facilitate multi-trait scoring, we design
trait-similarity loss that encapsulates the correlations of traits. Experiments
prove the efficacy of our model, showing state-of-the-art results for all
prompts and traits. Significant improvements in low-resource-prompt and
inferior traits further indicate our model's strength. | [
-0.5068378448,
-0.7177901268,
0.7096805573,
0.4949170947,
0.1954789311,
0.0285973921,
0.0494400263,
-0.6154872179,
0.4416997433,
0.1998816729,
-0.7981106043,
-0.4098529518,
-0.4323627353,
0.2633091509,
-0.0984976068,
0.9492777586,
-0.2548120618,
0.0116591183,
-0.5861492157,
-0.3137850761,
-0.5638611317,
-0.5231406093,
-0.7455350161,
-0.1384811848,
0.8694489598,
0.3810852766,
0.1313358396,
0.5445199609,
0.6628242731,
0.2129530013,
0.098709859,
-0.1190931424,
-0.2403728813,
0.2988486886,
-0.2340433896,
-0.4543759525,
-0.7132075429,
0.4565914869,
0.3846361637,
0.7331649661,
0.452239573,
0.3504915833,
0.521295011,
0.1419974267,
-0.5698176026,
0.154205665,
-0.3544258475,
0.2016342729,
-0.0338314325,
-0.1760712713,
-0.532456398,
-0.3181460202,
0.0677954182,
-0.6784809828,
0.3120447695,
0.1941969246,
0.752622962,
-0.0109770689,
-0.2619595826,
0.0241776425,
-0.3335803151,
0.9411652684,
0.0872683674,
0.1065893173,
0.5055860877,
0.2034039944,
0.2561402321,
-0.2654972374,
-0.123590894,
-0.1774748862,
-0.1472031921,
0.2569483519,
0.1806852669,
0.1653185487,
0.2648637593,
0.4159121513,
-0.541406095,
-0.040957626,
-0.0388538986,
-0.475795418,
0.4743784368,
0.557749629,
0.071259886,
-0.1010223478,
-0.4959059358,
0.0612480119,
-0.5416135192,
0.8322114348,
0.2428795695,
0.4648455381,
-0.1938844174,
0.458630383,
0.1061709374,
0.4152862132,
0.6432235241,
-0.118394047,
-0.1419003904,
-0.3159205317,
0.1449381858,
-0.1088457182,
0.6352890134,
0.4465357661,
0.0383305028,
-0.0441156588,
-0.0467106961,
0.3100179732,
0.1341387779,
-0.6433122754,
-0.1321546435,
-0.0666704029,
-0.789478004,
-0.3967758715,
-0.2122253329,
-0.9158529639,
-0.2710672915,
-0.2405716628,
0.516449213,
-0.4912805855,
0.2893661559,
-0.5364544392,
-0.1785022765,
0.4154643118,
0.3665830195,
-0.633179605,
0.3707918227,
0.4180738032,
0.8352459073,
-0.2547481656,
-0.5902606845,
-0.7979511619,
-0.0440932252,
-0.1594018787,
0.7272095084,
-1.05849123,
-0.443017453,
-0.2385646254,
-0.0903236344,
-0.2464293838,
0.095664449,
0.879668355,
-0.2792671621,
0.4112338126,
-0.7689424753,
-0.9688803554,
-0.0282950606,
0.3390858471,
-0.6540465951,
0.8981377482,
0.2175639272,
-0.8885315061,
0.2982550561,
-0.3793687522,
-0.282189101,
-0.0622506551,
-0.2366718054,
-0.5250636339,
-0.0286825895,
0.214276582,
0.489225179,
-0.2701549232,
0.0914052129,
-0.7110027075,
-0.4803413153,
0.2024195194,
-0.3397521079,
0.6241365671,
-0.1676951051,
-0.0239417423,
-0.0633778125,
-0.6225337982,
0.0416875407,
-0.2641169429,
-0.0850877762,
-0.5109782219,
-0.4306831658,
-0.0624118075,
0.1533756107,
0.3895266652,
-0.5775039196,
0.1498952508,
0.1194495186,
-0.2118177712,
0.7803231478,
0.1963356435,
0.4723718166,
-0.7683157921,
0.7779286504,
-0.2188639343,
0.3470545113,
-0.4972224534,
-0.7563682199,
-0.4774387777,
-0.6554591656,
0.0435467623,
0.6934201121,
-0.3567342162,
0.7871536613,
0.1804386228,
-0.5823522806,
-0.4457367063,
-0.2563797534,
0.5939356685,
0.8928003311,
0.6293871403,
-0.0855742767,
-0.251079917,
-0.4982960522,
-0.709131062,
-0.2075539827,
0.0701244324,
0.1925705224,
0.2463296205,
0.1391181499,
0.826546371,
-0.6764861941,
-0.3045623004,
-0.360077858,
0.4871476293,
-0.0646429658,
0.6481542587,
0.8143351078,
-0.3384160697,
-0.6640848517,
-0.4422876537,
-0.5490013957,
-0.3927027285,
-0.0429521203,
-0.0098051429,
-0.2917455733,
0.5530148149,
-0.4472970963,
0.6899459362,
0.3100937009,
-0.759209156,
0.8028265834,
0.1633199602,
0.5519550443,
-1.0215660334,
0.0777956471,
0.2724609375,
-0.0921265706,
-0.3155964315,
0.1389258355,
-0.0629617125,
-0.4083423615,
0.1243583187,
0.692997992,
-0.1122921556,
0.1996579915,
0.0405567959,
-0.5373279452,
0.6691051722,
0.7725738287,
0.103577666,
0.8087912202,
0.6594054103,
-0.542129457,
0.0663710758,
0.2771520317,
0.1550584435,
1.0916571617,
-0.6366689801,
0.0056733037,
0.0204749443,
0.1614590436,
-0.8393191099,
-0.0125136301,
0.1254997104,
-0.4489187598,
0.3874497116,
-0.0351809561,
0.4701783955,
0.0464140773,
-0.6858308911,
0.6534010172,
0.3301663101,
-0.3258008659,
0.905121088,
-0.0662541911,
-0.6504566669,
-0.3732504249,
-0.3404688239,
-0.2011826336,
-0.329692632,
-0.4305050969,
0.5820620656,
-0.2110269517,
-0.0638127998,
0.224100858,
0.0670362711,
-0.2179276049,
-0.0929055288,
0.2611103654,
0.4216481447,
-0.1811704487,
0.3708512783,
0.1977596581,
-0.1516469717,
0.1690414548,
-0.0890792161,
0.044068832,
0.1735473573,
-0.391544342,
-0.359321475,
1.20997262,
0.8537929058,
-0.4016864002,
0.7487871051,
0.4370811582,
-0.3635494709,
-0.3239859045,
-0.3753399849,
-0.3613432348,
-0.3929176331,
0.2166030556,
-0.6632711887,
-0.829621017,
0.7825117111,
0.0461046509,
0.0000021733,
0.4650975466,
0.035058327,
-0.4044257998,
0.8465462923,
1.0146926641,
-0.1223519593,
0.5091891289,
0.0303285439,
0.3215075433,
-0.7162102461,
-0.2325771749,
-0.8873088956,
-0.2248928994,
-0.315272063,
-0.2063448578,
0.4981615543,
-0.0250045955,
-0.3610636294,
0.1177805811,
-0.3474372625,
0.3885444701,
0.4814859927,
0.261636585,
-0.0051644603,
-0.1821870655,
-0.5291778445,
-0.355599314,
-0.511644423,
-0.3377952576,
1.0972747803,
0.3687031567,
0.7078686357,
-0.4051936865,
0.7372317314,
0.6092113256,
0.2045161426,
-0.5309044719,
0.5463909507,
-0.151575312,
-0.3111414611,
-0.449195236,
-0.483076781,
-0.2909557223,
-0.2259018719,
-0.3415207565,
-0.690559268,
0.4234777391,
0.1963734329,
-0.6661262512,
0.126278013,
-0.5364531279,
1.0257860422,
-0.072333537,
-0.7644994259,
-0.114960745,
-0.4353363216,
0.1767606139,
-0.0289959051,
-0.1910672635,
-0.1143257618,
0.1113136932,
0.8653657436,
-0.471272409,
0.8923636079,
-0.0685043335,
0.1770762801,
0.3578490615,
0.0332570709,
0.4724217355,
-0.0698037818,
-0.1950909048,
-0.0218141861,
-0.1173748001,
-0.4460830986,
-0.703340292,
0.6873375773,
-0.8065499067,
-0.4241890311,
-0.4883933067,
-0.2759152949,
-0.3435077369,
-0.0158084556,
0.6657382846,
0.6818184257,
-0.5331054926,
-0.3903307319,
0.9442731142,
-0.2037157118,
0.3664539754,
0.3817076385,
-0.0627796501,
-0.3575828671,
0.9118860364,
0.0922046676,
-0.0318164676,
0.5117549896,
0.1890148073,
-0.3862456381,
0.0086610634,
-0.1603180617,
0.0939020514,
-0.8336285353,
-0.3484186828,
-0.8836926818,
-0.2054294646,
-0.4729354978,
-0.6716108918,
-0.1188557521,
-0.3432574868,
-0.4053270817,
-0.2201188803,
0.5633373857,
0.4586403668,
0.0048553734,
0.0091472631,
-0.7633103728,
0.3813087642,
0.574913919,
0.5170875788,
-0.0348697156,
-0.6904298663,
0.0265378114,
-0.3906364441,
-0.2661834955,
-0.9651254416,
0.0046270164,
0.3576759696,
0.4702448547,
0.4860019982,
0.3206861019,
0.4504518211,
-0.0911262631,
0.6234801412,
0.1850379556,
-1.1331140995,
0.4719204605,
-0.1684167832,
0.2272493392,
0.9039028287,
0.5741081834,
-0.3515608311,
-0.623255372,
-0.1988008916,
-0.4746543169,
0.4712611735,
-0.0634811446,
-0.1079366878,
0.2065030783,
0.4220904708,
0.5365333557,
-0.0972765237,
-0.821354568,
-0.0939744115,
-0.4873698056,
-0.7088207006,
0.131344527,
-0.1642707288,
0.1247060299,
-0.5979011655,
0.6176728606,
-0.1823828816,
0.2631213069,
0.3288467824,
0.257273972,
-0.2623944283,
0.2989881337,
0.0683457926,
-0.1236217916,
-0.1243725717,
0.0353237614,
0.066727303,
-0.6385098696,
0.4655448198,
0.2898257673,
-0.3813908696,
-0.1375847906,
0.7428512573,
0.5587569475,
0.0788428634,
-0.2755994499,
0.7340903282,
-0.4220417738,
0.0672110766,
-0.0179834478,
0.1356937289,
-0.1706591696,
0.0111026959,
0.1665196419,
0.4416271448,
0.1593194753,
-0.6422799826,
0.2309843004,
0.2215248048,
-0.7161416411,
-0.3781014383,
0.5803529024,
0.6550729871,
-0.1945863068,
0.4615931213,
-0.4055897295,
-0.6308274269,
0.725734055,
0.2403921038,
1.1218466759,
-0.681432724,
0.2409863025,
0.5117012858,
0.1857850403,
0.2352101505,
0.6381867528,
-0.1937567741,
-0.4543909729,
-0.2822764218,
-0.8288265467,
-0.4930490255,
-0.0186376125,
-0.7332698703,
0.3613200784,
-0.4841257036,
-0.2735514641,
-0.1914533079,
0.1523561329,
-0.7486773133,
0.4369523525,
-0.2357866913,
1.0455684662,
-1.2824029922,
0.4465742707,
0.8993132114,
-0.3422319889,
-1.0192970037,
0.2609432936,
-0.2158075124,
-0.2843348086,
0.1142928079,
0.5086840391,
-0.2518998682,
-0.2715220451,
-0.0885325745,
-0.6795806289,
0.8964266777,
0.2139187753,
-0.5226536393,
-0.0792601779,
0.085949488,
0.4972557127,
-0.6490801573,
0.4701977968,
0.2168498635,
0.4947659969,
-0.193106845,
-0.6393848062,
0.1233674809,
-0.3949120343,
-0.4924715459,
-0.0696423277,
-0.757555604,
1.1819250584,
-0.14779149,
0.0517764725,
0.1244170889,
0.6135544777,
0.0717119873,
0.7630719543,
0.3160922527,
0.6744918823,
0.7474361062,
-0.0829409212,
0.6714222431,
-0.463011682,
-0.0403172821,
1.0133810043,
-0.523945868,
0.4177144468,
0.2829484344,
0.0491277538,
0.5850710869,
0.4255318642,
0.1890339851,
0.5131898522,
-0.2634568512,
-0.5012991428,
-0.5297977328,
-0.4557424486,
-0.3802720606,
0.7039109468,
0.246364668,
-0.4553268552,
0.1124172583,
-0.0495094545,
-0.2740064859,
0.4533199966,
-0.54286623,
0.6202286482,
0.1095213592,
-1.0663471222,
-0.0367570817,
-0.027826814,
0.344078213,
-0.6972411275,
-0.2884861827,
-0.3929830492,
0.0682852492,
0.0375779606,
-0.6394645572,
0.2652509511,
0.174296394,
-0.6251021028,
-0.146455273,
0.8604068756,
-0.5252894759,
-0.8084640503,
0.4824098647,
0.5378642678,
-0.4117466807,
0.1278684288,
-0.4942794144,
-0.0410806909,
-0.4463479221,
-0.1345299929,
0.3561703861,
0.6171033382,
-0.2251885384,
0.4828038514,
0.1473286897,
-0.1097308323,
-0.2432450503,
-0.1650574803,
0.7429696918,
-0.7711470723,
-1.0187118053,
-0.5205208659,
0.1796608418,
-0.1446002573,
-0.6092682481,
0.6196650267,
0.3044561446,
0.3765809834,
0.025485348,
0.98804003,
0.1818795651,
0.8643032312,
-0.263489902,
0.5517068505,
-0.3698845506,
0.0366352908,
-0.5511753559,
-0.8726085424,
0.1332819313,
0.3549427688,
-0.1592157632,
0.2083700895,
0.7909950614,
0.6245672703,
-0.0176437404,
0.2122794837,
0.2149955183,
-0.2921450138,
0.0276923366,
0.809902668,
0.9207670093,
-0.2273601741,
0.2789142728,
-0.1885694265,
-0.5199155807,
-0.1975339055,
-0.8615223169,
-1.1490527391,
-0.4840694368,
-0.3745092452,
-0.0393735506,
0.1979473978,
0.8034692407,
0.3846214116,
-0.7679504156,
0.1773001105,
0.0089988867,
0.2108594179,
-0.6357243061,
-0.2693585455,
0.3324497342,
-0.2647214234,
-0.1231573299,
0.1080463082,
0.5288863182,
0.0679115877,
-0.2772080898,
-0.1425990611,
0.0504207909,
0.5510694385,
0.2330259383,
0.3030219972,
-0.2423477173,
-0.6182636023,
0.2096014023,
-0.293541491,
-0.1642938405,
0.9974472523,
-0.6584718823,
0.0786319748,
0.4531756341,
0.4116368592,
-0.240604952,
0.1071948782,
0.6356779933,
-0.7012464404,
-0.0931891724,
0.5266155601,
0.5229017138,
0.3576383591,
-0.7597644925,
-0.0520428754,
0.4182606936,
-0.542886436,
-0.3575183153,
0.3627696037,
-0.8126620054,
-0.2677030563,
0.4198323488,
-0.8021135926,
-0.0262856111,
-0.4618699849,
-0.1575435251,
0.2490698844,
-0.4144776165,
1.0309225321,
0.6531027555,
-0.2165244818,
-0.2621579468,
0.4878700972,
0.6628614664,
0.6067972183,
-0.7530094981,
0.0914570615,
0.3865371644,
-0.0173913557,
0.1028982848,
0.5708788037,
0.1901496649,
0.5037514567,
0.2669577301,
-0.0736303926,
0.1098311692,
-0.6934543848,
-0.2033122927,
0.6812539697,
0.0509351157,
-0.1322224438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18226v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18226v2 | HowkGPT: Investigating the Detection of ChatGPT-generated University Student Homework through Context-Aware Perplexity Analysis | 2023-05-26T11:07:25 | 2023-06-07T11:43:44 | Christoforos Vasilatos, Manaar Alam, Talal Rahwan, Yasir Zaki, Michail Maniatakos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) in text generation tasks
proliferates, concerns arise over their potential to compromise academic
integrity. The education sector currently tussles with distinguishing
student-authored homework assignments from AI-generated ones. This paper
addresses the challenge by introducing HowkGPT, designed to identify homework
assignments generated by AI. HowkGPT is built upon a dataset of academic
assignments and accompanying metadata [17] and employs a pretrained LLM to
compute perplexity scores for student-authored and ChatGPT-generated responses.
These scores then assist in establishing a threshold for discerning the origin
of a submitted assignment. Given the specificity and contextual nature of
academic work, HowkGPT further refines its analysis by defining
category-specific thresholds derived from the metadata, enhancing the precision
of the detection. This study emphasizes the critical need for effective
strategies to uphold academic integrity amidst the growing influence of LLMs
and provides an approach to ensuring fair and accurate grading in educational
institutions. | [
-0.3556433916,
-0.8742328286,
0.5770853162,
0.0244776141,
0.1040254906,
0.3078457117,
0.1699639112,
-0.0120073985,
0.0040456974,
0.4854739606,
-0.5971948504,
-0.4175955057,
-0.6816728115,
0.1230353788,
-0.5245444179,
1.5043637753,
-0.0175965596,
-0.0870021731,
-0.6588944197,
0.0339228846,
-0.23418805,
-0.6974768639,
-0.2379812151,
-0.4564658701,
0.2327412963,
0.723216176,
0.2214012891,
0.4964526892,
0.9267241359,
0.3758480251,
0.0641269386,
-0.2564622164,
-0.6278701425,
0.0326530151,
0.0671670213,
-0.3262158036,
-0.3668147326,
-0.0843104273,
0.5969779491,
0.6585326791,
-0.2185659558,
0.5147397518,
0.210256353,
0.6428878307,
-0.4932985008,
0.0958104357,
-0.6320097446,
0.0191130675,
-0.5317754149,
-0.1396829337,
-0.0865155384,
-0.221965149,
0.0843739286,
-0.4915371835,
0.419149816,
-0.4519394934,
0.7065755725,
0.5298656821,
-0.4374844432,
-0.524469614,
-0.3360696435,
0.629586041,
-0.6705490351,
0.1794347316,
0.219746545,
0.3152193725,
-0.4821871519,
-1.0716432333,
-0.7421868443,
-0.1282188147,
-0.0684525371,
0.3532154262,
0.3054434657,
0.0296001807,
0.4277074039,
0.5954350233,
-0.5807836652,
-0.3451747,
-0.2346562147,
-0.2916015983,
0.4704360962,
0.1220273226,
0.62172997,
-0.6277896166,
-0.3865951896,
0.1711081415,
-0.7309750319,
0.2414920926,
0.7759892344,
-0.1538016796,
0.1847778559,
0.8038130403,
-0.3171230555,
0.2951998413,
-0.1143288463,
-0.240595445,
0.0913422033,
-0.2856348455,
-0.0316240154,
0.3170185387,
0.7451549172,
0.1258354187,
0.1610906571,
-0.0624757111,
-0.2819100022,
0.0844910964,
0.248358503,
-0.6146094203,
-0.4426523745,
-0.0202365834,
-0.1972963512,
-0.3860172331,
-0.0623026974,
-0.5030037165,
-0.2057341486,
-0.5798724294,
0.4267666638,
-0.2957086861,
-0.3451886475,
-0.113176696,
0.1228346229,
0.3048653007,
0.197552368,
-0.6764725447,
0.0137449838,
0.7315633893,
0.4705198109,
-0.1523270756,
-0.4895677865,
-0.0925520658,
0.2600318789,
-0.087647602,
0.9147311449,
-0.4972919822,
-0.3112710118,
-0.1758415848,
-0.1535883099,
-0.0015793225,
-0.3232687712,
0.6245926619,
-0.4563302398,
0.1218705922,
-0.3959951103,
-0.7138772607,
0.0262188129,
0.6211645007,
-0.2948716879,
1.3811109066,
0.2048216909,
-0.9749991894,
0.2997713983,
-0.9548211694,
-0.1470064819,
0.5207621455,
-0.1975314915,
-0.5759886503,
-0.1410679519,
-0.0043274951,
0.4622364342,
0.0631631836,
0.6395173073,
-0.0023089868,
-0.3956881464,
0.3950611055,
-0.3785279393,
0.7859098911,
0.0953866541,
-0.235467732,
-0.0750451908,
-0.8674733043,
-0.0733276978,
0.203686595,
-0.6732020378,
-0.4599784315,
-0.1448810399,
0.0769286081,
-0.007389491,
0.3945098519,
-0.657563746,
0.3560699224,
-0.0812059492,
0.2938922942,
0.7147366405,
0.0026532593,
-0.0722767562,
-0.2167879343,
0.6054466367,
-0.4205755889,
-0.1393323392,
0.0023453336,
-0.3841874003,
-0.7101050019,
-0.1875719577,
0.312933892,
0.6434005499,
-0.7367864251,
0.1418434381,
-0.3221845925,
-0.4952428043,
-0.3273508549,
0.1821560562,
0.3437424898,
0.7367759347,
0.2456406951,
-0.2392748743,
-0.3392648399,
-0.8128493428,
-0.3915370405,
-0.0860559419,
-0.2215765119,
0.327270627,
0.6868041158,
-0.1490359902,
1.0970396996,
-0.5209758282,
-0.2494007945,
0.0028385844,
0.5550830364,
-0.0395732671,
0.682931602,
0.2650917172,
-0.7868145704,
-0.666742444,
-0.2283624113,
-0.931299746,
-0.538171649,
-0.0576471798,
-0.1601237953,
-0.142680794,
0.8048840761,
-0.4038874805,
0.2981483042,
0.279725939,
-0.4777212739,
0.8691321015,
0.0631398484,
0.2376110256,
-1.1044492722,
0.1505818963,
-0.2738684714,
-0.2660740614,
-0.4148595035,
0.0863515958,
-0.1754716486,
-0.2063000351,
-0.1265689582,
0.0608628392,
-0.3429699838,
0.0968605131,
-0.2266748846,
0.0622903258,
-0.3939758837,
0.3801462352,
-0.336186111,
0.8641949892,
0.3058403134,
-0.0973469019,
0.2261545807,
0.4216249883,
-0.340896666,
0.8329803944,
-0.5122251511,
0.3572512567,
-0.1001593694,
0.2490009964,
-1.3146724701,
-0.4450320005,
0.2114913166,
-0.8208277822,
0.1385662854,
-0.4804680943,
-0.4990044832,
0.0055262856,
-0.1617015302,
0.7422222495,
0.2518707216,
-0.4960417747,
0.5617640615,
0.3216979504,
-0.3743721843,
-0.9859312177,
-0.3101623058,
0.1636997759,
-0.3040389419,
-0.5621133447,
0.2730790377,
-0.1209982708,
-0.1588598341,
0.0307860151,
-0.1132571101,
-0.1538909823,
0.3599613607,
0.4476687014,
0.2652100921,
-0.2932935059,
-0.0351971686,
0.2519753277,
-0.0344263427,
0.6057087779,
0.009089699,
0.4028906226,
0.0091685746,
-0.3771461844,
-0.1709069908,
0.3910344243,
0.674688518,
-0.1459559351,
0.4366285503,
0.638394773,
-0.1810605824,
-0.2615621984,
-0.6042584181,
-0.1847726852,
-0.5365216136,
0.3949157596,
-0.4355558157,
-0.7732555866,
0.4231217504,
-0.2810740173,
-0.0105500203,
0.2737058401,
0.5043204427,
-0.0355743393,
0.486857146,
0.6116317511,
-0.0924734026,
0.3433784544,
-0.1969065219,
0.5440836549,
-0.886593163,
-0.239203468,
-0.4834015071,
-0.0823981911,
-0.6675482988,
-0.0423496217,
0.3841553032,
0.210258916,
-0.115303129,
-0.0049457359,
-0.6805350184,
0.9707433581,
0.6581349969,
-0.0973488614,
0.41673401,
0.0447492003,
-0.0679550245,
0.0873255059,
-0.3411101103,
-0.9138863683,
1.4926954508,
0.0254988428,
0.1510806233,
0.2200377285,
0.7421036959,
0.4190246463,
0.7126677036,
-0.6367822289,
0.677090466,
0.064965494,
-0.6921371222,
-0.4808416069,
-0.4323439896,
-0.9357976317,
-0.0460611694,
-0.0499560311,
-0.9726422429,
-0.4542707801,
0.0467983857,
0.0805422589,
0.1803877503,
-0.5965014696,
1.0635412931,
0.232754305,
-0.4965274334,
0.1382791549,
-0.6195850968,
0.4701672196,
-0.2731415033,
-0.073761344,
-0.1727284789,
0.3682534695,
0.9437689185,
-0.4493836164,
0.6702527404,
-0.0669103414,
-0.1655248553,
0.6001736522,
0.2638807595,
0.4409577847,
0.3798478246,
0.1642431468,
0.2122643739,
0.0809017569,
-0.4697143137,
-0.3327687979,
0.8509150743,
-0.7559941411,
-0.8459614515,
-0.3065354824,
-1.0152775049,
-0.0795786977,
0.3031489551,
0.4090543985,
0.3605808318,
0.0340127349,
0.1656036824,
0.5685406327,
-0.0582904406,
0.4322396815,
0.4507571161,
0.1728786081,
0.1477510929,
1.4236147404,
0.31063959,
-0.0535474867,
0.2632159591,
0.132145524,
-0.304748863,
-0.7418627739,
-0.4369412959,
0.1006623209,
-0.979003489,
-0.0691516101,
-0.6200593114,
-0.2947603762,
-0.7059485316,
-0.3064945936,
-0.2639475465,
-0.3888688385,
-0.1236146316,
-0.0472202376,
0.0508429408,
0.7912951708,
0.1118827611,
0.4413821399,
-0.553816855,
0.013674981,
0.4214690328,
0.369130671,
-0.112353541,
-0.4250206947,
0.3267764151,
-0.3100169599,
-0.7460373044,
-0.586258173,
0.2398965508,
-0.2709252536,
0.5005018115,
0.1772535592,
0.1778736413,
0.1544645429,
-0.370523721,
0.7936265469,
-0.1380539089,
-1.0668188334,
0.1920721829,
-0.6418713331,
0.1120639741,
0.3612202704,
0.4764971733,
-0.5408707857,
-0.7417631745,
-0.6184286475,
-1.0754637718,
0.6429077387,
0.453125,
0.3150883019,
0.4166893661,
0.6218767166,
0.1705076545,
0.1061250865,
-1.2487375736,
-0.275339812,
-0.4334619045,
-0.6473298073,
0.2070705593,
-0.4287889898,
-0.0829616934,
-0.0211635195,
0.5700644851,
-0.0755077973,
-0.0042361859,
0.2851762176,
-0.1059800908,
0.2319238931,
0.390289098,
0.4803640544,
0.8658049107,
-0.0810022876,
0.0611550771,
0.0901594684,
-0.840207994,
0.1650947928,
0.0827280432,
-0.1306515336,
-0.1714328229,
0.3992570043,
0.0571754053,
-0.3698296547,
-0.7899497151,
0.5848338008,
-0.0231342837,
-0.2975068092,
-0.6352843642,
0.1424784064,
-0.0104982285,
0.0892819837,
0.5237717628,
-0.3430968523,
0.6294238567,
-0.1669893414,
0.2653549314,
0.4595413506,
-0.1283365041,
-0.1951887757,
0.4552867711,
0.0787379369,
-0.4181159735,
0.738312006,
-0.1344113797,
-0.7816064954,
0.9389625788,
0.5651410222,
0.6078001261,
-0.3570744097,
0.172258243,
0.2901962101,
0.0828046799,
0.2323191017,
0.089982897,
-0.1534577608,
-0.7075414062,
-0.2663293183,
-0.7235024571,
-0.3011738956,
0.5024312735,
-0.4819533825,
0.2506130338,
-0.3663362861,
0.1324111968,
0.1607177854,
-0.2448388487,
-0.1905590594,
0.2238625735,
-0.0145399608,
0.0239805523,
-0.8947416544,
0.7190064192,
0.9188779593,
0.0135404449,
-1.0712271929,
0.1335364133,
0.1834423542,
-0.5189439058,
0.7014989853,
0.326657325,
-0.0523852557,
0.3078560829,
-0.5196290612,
-0.821395874,
0.8155851364,
0.2042457014,
-0.3952122629,
0.1782204956,
0.5812394619,
0.351382345,
0.2106295675,
0.1410036087,
0.6113414168,
0.3298579454,
-0.0230540335,
-0.6446653008,
0.0477656983,
-0.3912174404,
-0.4828491807,
0.5526164174,
-0.3496743441,
0.7494853139,
0.1681824028,
-0.028601693,
-0.2321713865,
0.1937902421,
0.1724974811,
0.6242182851,
0.2587259114,
0.6500996947,
0.5884514451,
-0.2173734456,
0.8189262748,
-0.190081656,
0.4317676127,
1.0078929663,
0.0987636149,
0.3489208519,
0.8062598109,
-0.2415027767,
0.3296177089,
0.6140626669,
-0.3707484007,
0.2287409455,
0.6412917376,
-0.4552810788,
-0.1192753166,
-0.2453330159,
-0.3592752218,
0.6137085557,
0.1962730885,
-0.0546178371,
-0.2398664504,
-0.0372114815,
0.0099054072,
0.1993779987,
-0.3171501756,
0.829267621,
-0.1666061729,
-0.9323151112,
0.3104061186,
0.0214071441,
0.4631461501,
-0.3444919288,
-0.1824439913,
-0.3574178219,
0.1336451769,
-0.4334011376,
-0.7035262585,
0.2581658661,
0.0677246749,
-0.1398905665,
0.04605297,
0.572229445,
-0.4093428552,
-0.5885680318,
-0.1419735253,
0.450550586,
0.315326333,
0.0166244023,
-0.5874710083,
-0.3805099726,
0.0111760143,
-0.4248238206,
0.4476556182,
0.8009644747,
-0.1044349447,
0.6485846639,
0.7775854468,
-0.2323033512,
0.2128940076,
-0.2186293006,
0.6897589564,
-0.2024415284,
-0.323030591,
-0.9605455995,
0.3765999973,
-0.0179642662,
-0.4809868634,
0.7975593209,
0.5819978714,
1.0728551149,
-0.0054165032,
0.813513279,
-0.0711336285,
0.3413096368,
-0.3900212348,
0.9765461683,
-0.5089857578,
0.5680876374,
-0.6921332479,
-0.7970978022,
-0.2848602533,
0.5004079938,
-0.535763979,
-0.2272824496,
0.6203638911,
0.7800309658,
-0.1425242275,
-0.0808963701,
0.0824736953,
-0.1768840849,
0.4630803168,
0.4403677285,
1.1608775854,
-0.2034300119,
0.8110789061,
-0.2555069327,
-0.1847918034,
-0.052138716,
-0.8393344283,
-1.0713422298,
-0.4783768654,
-0.614808619,
-0.2868648469,
-0.2072529048,
0.6058642864,
0.2288356274,
-0.7610194683,
-0.2549832463,
-0.4326609373,
0.2563654482,
0.0911756903,
-0.3092192411,
0.6471843123,
-0.4700457454,
-0.6857014298,
0.0147213014,
-0.0969410911,
0.2270077318,
-0.044801224,
0.2412617803,
-0.1068212539,
0.1316419542,
0.3233225644,
-0.0241529327,
-0.5585133433,
-0.1240399703,
-0.2555722892,
-0.237865299,
0.1912900954,
1.0475751162,
-0.3512011766,
0.2659053802,
0.4473724365,
0.8812308908,
0.2319050431,
0.1924656779,
0.3396290243,
-0.8225448132,
-0.1069011837,
0.2606863081,
0.1357924342,
0.4315391779,
-0.7073082924,
0.4919686615,
0.5251111388,
-0.9406836629,
-1.0912245512,
-0.0978023708,
-0.7538285255,
-0.4864828885,
0.6659761071,
-0.4878045619,
-0.0933229774,
-0.4217274189,
-0.4348891079,
0.350006938,
-0.3050458133,
1.4985605478,
1.0097112656,
-0.0520511158,
0.0280623287,
-0.7038488984,
0.6862908006,
0.7042811513,
-0.8949452043,
0.1345154643,
0.22381863,
0.509506464,
0.2354011536,
0.4205505252,
-0.0269606765,
0.2725704312,
-0.1577416807,
0.1170183569,
-0.1895126551,
-0.1296484619,
0.2121833712,
0.6519201398,
-0.0288980659,
-0.1050665602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16820v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16820v2 | Domain Aligned Prefix Averaging for Domain Generalization in Abstractive Summarization | 2023-05-26T11:02:38 | 2023-05-29T06:19:48 | Pranav Ajit Nair, Sukomal Pal, Pradeepika Verma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Domain generalization is hitherto an underexplored area applied in
abstractive summarization. Moreover, most existing works on domain
generalization have sophisticated training algorithms. In this paper, we
propose a lightweight, weight averaging based, Domain Aligned Prefix Averaging
approach to domain generalization for abstractive summarization. Given a number
of source domains, our method first trains a prefix for each one of them. These
source prefixes generate summaries for a small number of target domain
documents. The similarity of the generated summaries to their corresponding
documents is used for calculating weights required to average source prefixes.
In DAPA, prefix tuning allows for lightweight finetuning, and weight averaging
allows for the computationally efficient addition of new source domains. When
evaluated on four diverse summarization domains, DAPA shows comparable or
better performance against the baselines, demonstrating the effectiveness of
its prefix averaging scheme. | [
-0.5160431862,
-0.3816815317,
0.3499256968,
0.2393916696,
-0.5865900517,
0.1742647588,
-0.2172717452,
-0.3836299777,
0.6976824999,
-0.1576193571,
-0.3786615133,
-0.4587742686,
-1.0232436657,
0.1056293845,
0.0057559307,
0.9331322312,
-0.1074320823,
-0.044521071,
-0.386420697,
-0.6084187031,
-0.8976641297,
-0.2432150692,
-0.5985183716,
-0.2347322106,
0.3040463626,
0.3946745694,
0.7292935848,
0.5805811882,
0.6890665293,
0.3227859437,
0.1757424921,
0.6510871649,
-0.3618432581,
-0.0682203099,
-0.1508797407,
0.2289723158,
-1.378816843,
-0.0042672222,
0.5812842846,
1.1406433582,
-0.2232585102,
0.2894409597,
0.0163500197,
0.712877512,
-0.7973092794,
-0.2190061957,
-0.4543169439,
-0.4134861827,
-0.0950881541,
-0.4499407113,
-0.0819331855,
-0.282433629,
0.0333594084,
-0.9751936197,
0.2537792325,
0.180668205,
0.7839421034,
0.1198351681,
-0.3980232477,
-0.2854766548,
-0.3179186881,
1.0917768478,
-0.692037344,
0.1266098917,
0.1676046401,
0.1172972322,
0.0955785364,
-0.7096682787,
-0.3145947158,
0.4424414933,
-0.1127175689,
0.1668229997,
-0.5101275444,
-0.1118932739,
-0.0502275936,
0.4639333487,
-0.756785512,
-0.1358855069,
-0.2126704752,
0.0098107634,
0.889126122,
0.1166314706,
0.2497343421,
0.3626544178,
-0.4140611291,
0.1102452055,
-0.4651719034,
-0.2906142175,
0.2873197198,
0.3479138315,
-0.1976934671,
0.3261176944,
-0.3942710161,
0.8153585792,
0.2844152749,
-0.0496442802,
0.3934096396,
-0.3953107893,
-0.2634605765,
0.3053553402,
0.5364812613,
0.8838486671,
0.4545384645,
-0.2643778324,
-0.2234911174,
-0.046009656,
0.5016055703,
-0.8568009734,
-0.2985853255,
0.1659633517,
-0.6580041647,
-0.0567100234,
-0.0598771088,
-0.6319751143,
-0.0818168744,
-0.2425402701,
0.4094060659,
-0.3585429788,
-0.2613279819,
-0.0021864963,
-0.5037052035,
0.2903552353,
0.4842084944,
-1.2463059425,
1.0053792,
0.5889006257,
0.9812507033,
-0.7309881449,
-0.3042069376,
-0.7954409719,
0.2597581744,
-0.3469844162,
0.951154232,
-0.3597417772,
-0.398986727,
-0.2463952452,
-0.3185802698,
-0.0084527051,
-0.5716506839,
0.4010848999,
-0.819742918,
-0.1959907711,
0.0693791509,
-0.702598393,
-0.1523330063,
0.0362762101,
-0.4418383837,
0.8677325249,
0.2257588953,
-0.6850081086,
0.5323572159,
-0.3679687977,
-0.4244907498,
-0.0410959907,
0.1289589256,
-0.5880345106,
0.3276261985,
0.4364359975,
0.4204980433,
-0.0066141295,
0.2940724492,
-0.151076287,
-0.417322129,
-0.0071014478,
-0.0546665229,
0.3766114712,
0.2145341933,
-0.0897535905,
0.0087133292,
-0.6237746477,
0.1685171127,
0.0547384396,
0.0990701094,
-1.0954595804,
-0.0472919308,
-0.0493750274,
-0.2866843939,
0.3289240599,
-0.2997103333,
0.4986442924,
-0.3452088237,
-0.452785641,
0.4608447552,
0.2515675426,
0.6765418053,
-0.3540461659,
0.2800547481,
0.0384267941,
-0.3534736931,
0.070163548,
-0.5244517922,
-0.3395172954,
-0.4821787179,
0.8530273438,
-0.012994227,
-0.4867332578,
0.4721751511,
-0.610835135,
-0.3944989741,
-0.1541353464,
0.2800043225,
0.4638779461,
0.2460225672,
0.7198560238,
-0.8162353635,
-0.2940651178,
-0.6849423051,
-0.5080839396,
0.3360284567,
-0.2585859001,
-0.1412557811,
0.3017871976,
0.0555753596,
1.0182919502,
-1.1370408535,
-0.4663887918,
-0.2192825675,
0.6414802074,
-0.0203085709,
0.6691786051,
0.7804246545,
-0.7168856263,
-0.5903988481,
-0.1643768698,
-0.584385097,
-0.4798791409,
-0.0625425279,
0.0048575853,
-0.0382700637,
0.2600315809,
-0.4580979049,
0.0742374957,
0.3822996616,
-0.3434748054,
0.267565459,
-0.2760424018,
0.0469319597,
-1.2143516541,
0.172296524,
0.123152487,
-0.4992619753,
-0.6288051605,
-0.1182489842,
0.1573558003,
-0.0155117987,
-0.0358818397,
0.7339535356,
-0.9878158569,
-0.2355890274,
-0.7844077349,
0.3366368413,
-0.0002382177,
0.6127918363,
0.1603902429,
0.8900592327,
0.6184390783,
-0.8563324809,
0.0269112159,
0.1922835559,
0.0681587234,
0.5917439461,
-0.6852695942,
-0.1350962222,
-0.1187872142,
0.198654741,
-0.7639100552,
-0.0812592283,
0.088070631,
-0.6539441943,
0.561303556,
0.0274372175,
0.2047540247,
0.3444358706,
-0.7139537334,
0.9957348108,
0.4583708942,
-0.378626287,
0.7654115558,
0.5971643925,
-0.5059095025,
-0.7123611569,
-0.2594532669,
0.1262536645,
-0.2231672257,
-0.3266827762,
0.9389921427,
0.0362443402,
-0.4176238179,
0.2424672246,
-0.5355359912,
-0.2402433157,
0.0941589922,
0.1475105882,
0.1056288704,
-0.2326714844,
-0.1332710236,
0.2794392109,
-0.24351722,
-0.1246107966,
-0.2746182382,
0.2663633823,
0.110565111,
-0.0477746911,
-0.092502594,
0.5698217154,
0.303278476,
-0.1129519492,
0.4273451567,
0.0690361857,
-0.3291933537,
-0.6273714304,
-0.2290265411,
0.0731165186,
-0.4606329203,
-0.0034322231,
-0.3672448695,
-0.4071514606,
0.5785111189,
-0.4219165742,
0.1624347568,
0.8408905268,
0.4716524482,
0.1209919006,
0.8015170097,
1.0370980501,
-0.1315197498,
0.2299628854,
-0.3189727664,
-0.0690509826,
-0.7693939209,
0.0599569045,
-0.2882638574,
-0.4966837168,
-0.2094244063,
-0.3464170396,
0.2126488835,
-0.0541347601,
0.2906440794,
0.4080950916,
-0.3571022153,
0.5684770942,
0.3169742525,
-0.2577210069,
0.5652146339,
-0.0201950017,
0.1769764721,
0.0880154967,
-0.5233082771,
-0.1893691123,
1.0721306801,
0.0356345363,
0.8100059628,
0.2885924578,
0.7680771351,
0.7914770246,
0.2211867124,
-0.9285855889,
0.3579710722,
-0.0920914114,
0.0385202728,
-0.233964771,
-0.4864045978,
-0.8211542368,
0.2633224428,
0.0610429086,
-0.197747618,
0.4477140903,
0.1122799814,
-0.2727966607,
-0.0396661721,
-0.3106820583,
0.5862885118,
0.2504079044,
0.0566845313,
-0.4098047614,
-0.5423223972,
0.4554495215,
-0.2104000151,
-0.0450860076,
-0.1582259685,
-0.4554309547,
0.9864344597,
-0.7138926983,
0.6059750319,
-0.2243334651,
-0.1818937659,
0.3405653834,
-0.1741421819,
0.2384356558,
0.000624435,
0.2011525035,
0.3759338856,
-0.4228330255,
-0.6056140065,
-0.7101809978,
0.6741273403,
-0.5592389107,
-0.3219015598,
-0.7888559103,
-0.4853913784,
-0.4295008779,
0.3237127662,
-0.0321370475,
0.7595069408,
-0.4114368558,
-0.311221689,
0.6588210464,
0.4889136553,
0.7587330341,
0.6541640759,
0.4995117188,
-0.613021493,
0.87661165,
0.071492821,
0.1017814055,
0.3941831887,
-0.0499394424,
-0.139486894,
-0.9811507463,
-0.7279940844,
0.2066243589,
-0.4990733266,
-0.7896499038,
-0.6522607207,
0.0321146399,
-0.3500856757,
-0.4322845042,
-0.2202816457,
-0.8822283745,
0.0019644094,
0.19801265,
0.3154076636,
0.5248517394,
0.3465372026,
0.4928569794,
-0.927287817,
0.6672636271,
0.3999843895,
0.6122863293,
-0.0215934515,
-0.6574311852,
-0.4681989253,
-0.3750393689,
-0.4325553775,
-0.7094833851,
0.2256440371,
0.599136591,
0.4355672598,
0.3379753828,
0.2982371449,
0.7525801659,
-0.6665155292,
0.8103177547,
0.2002717853,
-1.0004353523,
0.2392842919,
-0.2506773174,
0.4969237447,
0.8491772413,
0.5515370369,
-0.1422987729,
-0.3468593657,
-0.5606265068,
-0.7281564474,
0.6059663296,
0.1618488431,
0.1728403121,
0.1141591668,
0.3225899041,
0.2024839371,
0.0838945583,
-0.3715777695,
-0.489479214,
-0.0526583865,
-0.3381837606,
0.20223701,
-0.0809183419,
-0.2190663218,
-0.0903412253,
0.9374537468,
-0.6461923122,
0.1215764135,
0.1693622172,
-0.2617810369,
-0.2691754103,
-0.0008404228,
0.8095434308,
1.0467960835,
-0.2731584609,
0.2157128751,
0.338640213,
-0.8253808618,
0.176502496,
0.2621032,
0.041228395,
0.2565469742,
0.5072347522,
0.3861531019,
0.2841473818,
-0.5518997312,
0.7571132183,
-0.2478180379,
-0.380979985,
0.1682732701,
0.0496164598,
-0.1599301547,
-0.1012696102,
0.6041659713,
0.3544304371,
0.2908503711,
-0.2543127239,
0.2764673531,
0.5415780544,
-0.0245370027,
-0.3336544335,
0.6785774231,
0.4192661047,
0.2803432941,
0.0862188041,
-0.2539877594,
-0.1605903059,
0.5244598985,
0.4609565437,
1.3559762239,
-0.1589859426,
-0.2272460163,
0.2648682892,
-0.0367661826,
0.015909614,
0.2319473624,
-0.2534615397,
-0.5939669013,
-0.6564072371,
-0.7327682376,
-0.6537197232,
-0.4182052612,
-0.4725679159,
0.2928897738,
-0.2109093815,
-0.0177106112,
0.2553826272,
0.1389465928,
0.0524359979,
0.3795949221,
-0.0075993063,
1.0593732595,
-0.8990684748,
0.7498479486,
0.8002844453,
-0.1033352837,
-0.5307335854,
0.3791949749,
-0.1578935981,
-0.5084267259,
0.437124908,
-0.1229321882,
-0.4669406414,
-0.0134626273,
-0.0755243525,
-0.961796701,
1.0863385201,
-0.1314972788,
-0.099748984,
0.1649009585,
-0.2976326644,
0.343000114,
-0.6730807424,
0.1336006969,
0.3824185133,
0.2015355676,
0.0139240529,
-0.7435597181,
0.399640739,
-0.5753723383,
-0.0149592236,
0.5406813622,
-0.7405549884,
0.5421581268,
-0.11244791,
-0.2701468766,
-0.1239169091,
1.2936538458,
0.0067162062,
0.7581549883,
0.4124803245,
0.6281688213,
0.5735403895,
0.1127619743,
0.6873819232,
-0.2320045829,
0.1799442619,
1.138202548,
-0.2724550366,
0.4308177829,
0.331104815,
-0.0737642944,
0.4231378138,
0.4696630538,
-0.1481308043,
0.8014106154,
0.008232493,
-0.2749804258,
0.3020566702,
0.0058596446,
-0.4681185186,
0.5261608362,
0.1960356832,
-0.1084503159,
-0.4663681388,
-0.2470546961,
0.0480354652,
0.2133357823,
-0.7599625587,
1.1188424826,
0.1954938769,
-0.8653407097,
0.8580800891,
0.3898156881,
0.7052257061,
-0.9421800375,
-0.2079562396,
-0.3629575968,
-0.1022938043,
-0.4038775265,
-0.3119536638,
0.4501911998,
0.1738820225,
-0.3284352124,
-0.2550756037,
0.9125384688,
-0.5288382769,
-0.1806586236,
0.0195823126,
0.5958952904,
-0.0451693162,
0.0348811112,
-0.125927493,
-0.1254484206,
-0.4725318253,
-0.2962015569,
0.6616729498,
0.3488157392,
-0.3737657964,
0.2363262177,
0.2307587415,
0.1705894321,
-0.1025750712,
0.015431392,
1.1164265871,
-0.4406707287,
-0.5933899283,
-0.7282233238,
0.4180082083,
-0.2050873339,
-0.4354787171,
0.9160703421,
0.7511538863,
0.3711740077,
-0.148297444,
0.5719189644,
-0.192802608,
0.2079449594,
-0.5542028546,
0.5656469464,
-0.6606894135,
0.0303959996,
-0.2190417051,
-1.3723562956,
-0.5378834009,
-0.0251215715,
-0.0392791964,
0.1208646297,
0.6632940769,
0.4628775418,
-0.5426072478,
-0.1668574959,
0.1579459906,
-0.3907687664,
-0.1061620712,
0.2158750743,
0.1281279773,
-0.496630311,
0.1479168534,
-0.0843597949,
-0.5357992053,
-0.1850718558,
-1.0505852699,
-0.7211149335,
-0.3068314195,
-0.532615006,
-0.0007847893,
-0.0334480144,
0.9141913056,
0.5634889007,
-0.9405389428,
-0.1276510358,
0.1779649407,
0.1303790212,
-0.9318457842,
-0.2326783389,
0.7430889606,
-0.6964806914,
-1.0104496479,
0.5893075466,
0.0755419284,
-0.0654031262,
0.2418293059,
-0.0535575673,
0.0077481959,
0.3119112849,
0.4639061689,
0.2735944688,
-0.1247524098,
-0.0722046793,
-0.4744657874,
-0.0798233449,
0.0193356797,
1.0585243702,
-0.7684710622,
0.3430342078,
0.5015230775,
0.7753001451,
0.3039403856,
0.8030602336,
0.8056288362,
-1.3390835524,
-0.0989100561,
0.0925336108,
0.2350772917,
0.1547763944,
-0.2792382538,
0.5903642178,
0.1809027344,
-0.4536130428,
-0.5584432483,
-0.147844702,
-1.3836541176,
-0.3469187021,
0.6694110632,
0.1161427125,
0.0217932314,
-0.07344006,
0.1036268622,
0.1062047035,
-0.4985973239,
0.6711108685,
0.3149145246,
-0.3637624383,
0.3246307671,
-0.237478748,
0.8909680247,
0.3992542922,
-0.8078468442,
0.2991883457,
0.5130779147,
0.3077581525,
0.3196599782,
1.0032867193,
0.0794025213,
0.5582694411,
0.1427533478,
0.1379124969,
-0.1561489254,
-0.4671324492,
-0.6708926558,
0.3148676753,
0.0033937979,
-0.4236914515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16819v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16819v1 | With a Little Push, NLI Models can Robustly and Efficiently Predict Faithfulness | 2023-05-26T11:00:04 | 2023-05-26T11:00:04 | Julius Steen, Juri Opitz, Anette Frank, Katja Markert | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conditional language models still generate unfaithful output that is not
supported by their input. These unfaithful generations jeopardize trust in
real-world applications such as summarization or human-machine interaction,
motivating a need for automatic faithfulness metrics. To implement such
metrics, NLI models seem attractive, since they solve a strongly related task
that comes with a wealth of prior research and data. But recent research
suggests that NLI models require costly additional machinery to perform
reliably across datasets, e.g., by running inference on a cartesian product of
input and generated sentences, or supporting them with a
question-generation/answering step.
In this work we show that pure NLI models _can_ outperform more complex
metrics when combining task-adaptive data augmentation with robust inference
procedures. We propose: (1) Augmenting NLI training data to adapt NL inferences
to the specificities of faithfulness prediction in dialogue; (2) Making use of
both entailment and contradiction probabilities in NLI, and (3) Using
Monte-Carlo dropout during inference. Applied to the TRUE benchmark, which
combines faithfulness datasets across diverse domains and tasks, our approach
strongly improves a vanilla NLI model and significantly outperforms previous
work, while showing favourable computational cost. | [
-0.2066691369,
-0.5696091652,
0.5288307071,
0.0755696446,
-0.0121513112,
-0.1009886116,
-0.1424213201,
-0.6313333511,
-0.056777548,
0.601695776,
-0.8163389564,
-0.116338186,
-0.4031181931,
0.1138879955,
-0.3502693176,
0.9778677821,
0.134306699,
0.0819780231,
-0.4249461889,
-0.3428923786,
-0.4730989039,
-0.2498970926,
-0.3599268198,
-0.3021131456,
0.3747639656,
-0.0794978514,
1.1795954704,
0.6398535371,
0.4444534779,
0.3402246535,
0.1420841217,
0.5906286836,
-0.3717924654,
0.2985998094,
-0.2347973138,
-0.8905757666,
-0.5009806156,
0.2240292281,
0.4568662345,
1.0115696192,
-0.0014184585,
-0.1010962427,
0.347121954,
0.5005257726,
-0.5739216805,
-0.0036975213,
-0.9582796693,
-0.0558936633,
-0.030476924,
-0.0914798453,
-0.4421069324,
-0.329364866,
0.1418999732,
-0.8631225824,
0.314943105,
0.0012382971,
1.079204917,
0.5589223504,
-0.0949730054,
-0.2269400656,
-0.6827769876,
1.1919347048,
-1.1497933865,
0.5627119541,
0.4958484173,
0.0431605652,
-0.3969420791,
-0.5487576127,
-0.4723603129,
-0.3920686543,
-0.1933816522,
0.3130589128,
-0.285482347,
0.0251294654,
0.437163949,
0.3840242624,
-0.4147823751,
-0.184328869,
0.0437891893,
-0.1254058182,
0.5647298694,
0.2225695848,
0.2766081393,
0.0825385973,
0.0924220234,
-0.1782432646,
-0.4375983477,
-0.0437264852,
0.5190544724,
0.215780437,
-0.0166144855,
0.625533402,
-0.1706470996,
0.7476385236,
0.0513808206,
-0.0503318645,
0.1446095854,
-0.6807556152,
-0.1505416483,
-0.3428494334,
0.7162729502,
0.2069539279,
0.259698391,
-0.6052070856,
-0.1770667136,
0.393535018,
0.4351214767,
-0.5307411551,
-0.3155325055,
0.3897983134,
-0.1736258864,
-0.2678628862,
0.1275868714,
-0.5340512991,
-0.1028538346,
-0.5303977728,
0.3519135416,
-0.7282133102,
-0.0856888741,
0.0325660184,
-0.1650757641,
0.0807355642,
0.4373753071,
-0.474602282,
0.3042823374,
0.9324930906,
0.6853634715,
-0.178655237,
-0.2967240214,
-0.6594614387,
0.0615233481,
-0.4739286304,
0.3645569682,
-0.5640769601,
-0.171754837,
-0.022913808,
0.0790987462,
-0.1096743718,
-0.4862063527,
0.7923597097,
-0.4526815712,
0.2338325679,
-0.1699665487,
-0.6307540536,
0.0423876904,
0.2656595111,
-0.7598214746,
0.8557409048,
0.0121818725,
-0.9803146124,
0.5063067675,
-0.2572928369,
-0.2760412991,
-0.1931542903,
0.2573369741,
-0.6286498904,
0.4432161748,
0.2577605546,
0.1416280568,
-0.1989063621,
0.642534852,
-0.7121453285,
-0.3480356932,
0.5700674057,
-0.9801309109,
0.7380222082,
0.088112779,
-0.1568500102,
-0.2632153332,
-0.8724768162,
0.0815678984,
-0.0975955352,
-0.167877689,
-0.4506770074,
0.1388765723,
-0.1421451122,
-0.0839818344,
0.1268270165,
-0.6661765575,
-0.0680630282,
-0.8828763962,
0.1093731523,
0.4191859066,
-0.2470760196,
0.4972155094,
-0.4659397602,
0.1407079995,
0.0698427036,
0.2777227163,
-0.0298253968,
-0.6531240344,
-0.8967032433,
-0.1871870905,
0.4653920829,
0.594974041,
-0.7919430733,
0.4416556954,
-0.5739423633,
-0.3031215072,
-0.8394714594,
0.3369880915,
0.4762697518,
0.5812138915,
0.3061307073,
-0.3730049133,
-0.5763975978,
-0.8215755224,
-0.5977185965,
-0.3725073338,
-0.4559787512,
0.1215201765,
0.2789492011,
-0.1774934232,
1.1349133253,
0.0122486884,
-0.0755433962,
-0.1576961875,
0.393317908,
0.3909968734,
0.6297205687,
0.2557696402,
-0.8328828812,
-0.1558346897,
-0.0696216598,
-0.8186706305,
-0.1335641146,
-0.2656516135,
-0.236303106,
-0.0491989963,
0.0074477582,
-0.4662040472,
0.618262589,
0.5956586599,
-0.0602167696,
0.3075033128,
-0.1864925027,
0.0401691273,
-1.0304297209,
-0.0192153901,
0.1045709625,
-0.3400961757,
-0.7425230145,
0.1695256531,
-0.1155351847,
0.20019719,
-0.1071672142,
0.3405548632,
-0.2224823982,
-0.0234075151,
-0.2892155051,
-0.0195628908,
0.3895283043,
0.3777233958,
0.0732368603,
0.7680051327,
0.3604206443,
-0.4970052838,
0.0227784459,
0.4204595387,
0.0104341423,
0.3741339445,
-0.8765734434,
0.0269672293,
-0.0862243697,
0.1998809129,
-0.7721526623,
-0.370179981,
-0.0435298458,
-0.6121472716,
0.309114337,
-0.2294598669,
-0.3679489493,
-0.0253046881,
-0.2608146369,
0.2690595984,
0.5136399269,
-0.5318940282,
1.0592422485,
0.0570444763,
0.1354331076,
-0.6679645181,
-1.0346832275,
0.2437855601,
-0.0288897846,
-0.610737443,
0.2755486369,
-0.1097593233,
-0.2889031768,
0.0547078699,
-0.0962400436,
-0.202696681,
0.1626257449,
0.4614087343,
0.5073469281,
-0.2284646034,
-0.1908592135,
0.118606694,
-0.1169514284,
0.1603818238,
-0.4045475125,
0.0554345436,
-0.1696198136,
-0.6436833143,
-0.5915153027,
0.4621112347,
0.5568016171,
-0.1958836764,
0.8261548281,
0.5348396897,
-0.3965214491,
-0.0998240039,
-0.8507204652,
-0.2182330489,
-0.4904900193,
0.1744540185,
-0.3900699317,
-0.6422134638,
0.3828732669,
0.0570048057,
0.476760298,
0.2080908716,
0.047151465,
-0.230024606,
1.3559740782,
0.4837682545,
0.0433370657,
0.1574477404,
-0.0536074713,
0.2853203118,
-0.7111952305,
0.026027903,
-0.4138649404,
-0.0242668819,
-0.8699353337,
-0.341751188,
0.2128850967,
0.1972234547,
0.0394865535,
0.3814686537,
-0.1984859109,
0.1665440947,
0.641780138,
0.3439917266,
0.3833611608,
-0.0354250297,
0.1668296456,
-0.3665142357,
-0.7557479739,
-0.6246381402,
1.0867426395,
0.3616550267,
0.699659586,
0.1426914632,
0.4589598179,
0.1151844859,
0.5999573469,
-0.4758316278,
0.2861185074,
-0.2925809026,
-0.4233895838,
-0.1368516386,
-0.6150150895,
-0.5787222981,
-0.0220526773,
-0.359478265,
-0.4975854754,
0.5582433343,
0.4430767,
-0.2160325497,
0.3904173374,
-0.4775586426,
0.5577615499,
-0.0244868491,
-0.7281421423,
0.0064658416,
-0.6599979997,
0.4589764774,
-0.1737566292,
0.0905556455,
-0.0744837224,
-0.0340476744,
0.4247432947,
-0.5167196989,
0.8652234674,
-0.020723803,
0.0217277389,
0.15057455,
0.2589818835,
0.6370338202,
0.3998907208,
-0.4467248917,
0.1338560283,
-0.0502606221,
-0.5255280733,
-1.0943473577,
0.6460492015,
-0.5749319792,
-0.5838823915,
-0.1240822226,
-0.6670323014,
-0.7148966193,
-0.097385101,
0.3126740754,
0.5073400736,
-0.1933205724,
-0.0553100035,
0.9674735069,
-0.0572261885,
0.322673142,
0.2289575189,
0.2397556752,
-0.4349959195,
1.0235182047,
-0.3046970069,
0.4461917579,
0.2377718091,
0.095594272,
-0.328237474,
-0.4885862768,
-0.4500071704,
0.1091415733,
-0.5676296353,
-0.1814303994,
-0.8769126534,
-0.1899332106,
-0.1723230481,
-0.1009657606,
-0.5678088665,
-0.3306092024,
-0.199213922,
-0.0095029008,
0.2183887661,
0.3878195286,
-0.1043595895,
0.0097381463,
-0.7418709993,
0.3386955261,
0.6271956563,
0.2526433766,
-0.1114183664,
-0.6898528337,
0.1205686331,
0.5894708037,
-0.0682812408,
-0.6024705768,
0.426238358,
0.622115016,
0.2658184171,
0.3223057389,
0.2447762787,
0.9360885024,
-0.4622869492,
0.6596394777,
0.1720505208,
-0.9439017177,
0.4476539791,
-0.2944209576,
0.1191733032,
0.9165077209,
0.1787578762,
0.021337714,
-0.906826973,
-0.5411175489,
-0.5958119631,
0.4515283108,
0.5361338258,
0.4266685545,
0.0993975252,
0.4858134985,
0.1880716085,
0.1811701655,
-0.7854668498,
0.0137101086,
-0.488265425,
-0.4457920492,
0.0958236158,
-0.0172862485,
-0.181505844,
-0.2435179949,
0.8729169965,
-0.4268282354,
0.2432737797,
0.3441128731,
-0.0222007763,
-0.0095341764,
0.2626462579,
0.1616538763,
0.5830580592,
-0.147330001,
-0.0221641995,
0.4805343449,
-0.3676956594,
0.0207342897,
0.0847497806,
-0.2744557261,
0.3156924844,
0.5288348198,
0.8823918104,
-0.033213973,
-0.7068167925,
0.7449526191,
-0.2593404353,
-0.2182079852,
-0.1594891846,
0.1537243575,
-0.1252720803,
0.049050916,
0.2126302272,
0.4214473367,
0.2848647535,
-0.5746099949,
0.3179383874,
0.7563135624,
-0.8368752599,
-0.3654982448,
0.8080019951,
-0.163456738,
-0.0947937667,
0.5598598719,
-0.1775416583,
-0.3397891819,
0.3012780845,
0.3945367336,
0.7594584227,
-0.0619915798,
0.1624227166,
0.2827628851,
0.4057685435,
-0.1102473363,
0.1050224528,
0.0290173944,
-0.8310177326,
-0.7697343826,
-0.7595859766,
-0.4737316072,
0.0320671424,
-0.7841908932,
-0.0697937459,
-0.1714620292,
-0.1932375133,
0.0008866201,
-0.3050555289,
-0.6881945133,
0.592974484,
0.047455091,
0.6533204317,
-0.8947048187,
0.6561488509,
0.3204141259,
-0.1860706359,
-0.7251796722,
0.2113313824,
-0.2287413925,
-0.4433016181,
0.1656382829,
0.0785081908,
-0.2105414122,
-0.3437333107,
-0.5880525112,
-0.6529777646,
0.513591826,
0.601529181,
-0.6298362613,
-0.138346374,
0.3580281734,
0.6150774956,
-0.2197277993,
0.4214862883,
0.6277214885,
0.3810806572,
-0.0346145071,
-0.5780259371,
-0.0078664022,
-0.465577811,
0.1068304777,
0.0076485244,
-0.1555933505,
0.4145561457,
-0.0090803066,
-0.2062268257,
0.4844804108,
1.0180217028,
0.2329654098,
0.4606526196,
0.6920301914,
0.6163567305,
0.5304397941,
-0.4580507576,
1.0868115425,
-0.3538330197,
-0.0657519475,
1.155843854,
-0.1930122674,
0.7665797472,
0.4080926478,
-0.0482431725,
0.3922120333,
0.2571876943,
-0.1269156635,
0.3432440758,
-0.1675868928,
-0.2465241253,
-0.5020288229,
-0.4502368867,
0.0221883934,
0.3546152413,
0.2513263822,
-0.2055554092,
0.1776839942,
0.0170054268,
-0.0735139996,
0.3121014237,
0.1431774497,
0.8552986383,
-0.014422006,
-1.0391391516,
0.5108834505,
-0.1428963244,
0.712187767,
-0.6463219523,
-0.1864829063,
-0.2584396601,
0.051513698,
-0.302924633,
-0.4918066859,
0.6264170408,
-0.0357799865,
-0.1839065999,
-0.0242970362,
0.5742337108,
-0.384873271,
-0.7490692735,
0.2016149312,
0.5976015925,
-0.2531125546,
0.1372242719,
-0.7063238025,
-0.0570848621,
0.0330759101,
0.0045604995,
0.1948079765,
0.3420010507,
0.0652816072,
0.6825879812,
0.9957119226,
0.0552834794,
0.1163392514,
0.1977685988,
0.9367779493,
-0.1411972046,
-0.2469711304,
-0.6180766225,
0.597685039,
-0.3902316093,
-0.2099572122,
0.7910078168,
0.4465924799,
0.606712997,
0.1264181733,
0.7975372672,
0.1825894713,
0.628154695,
-0.4719186425,
0.4459063709,
-0.6209072471,
0.2052422911,
-0.4894173741,
-0.9793638587,
-0.253028661,
0.3037002683,
-0.1271345764,
0.0167801753,
0.3397219181,
0.9486666322,
-0.3089236915,
0.3144411147,
0.4095733762,
-0.0502962507,
0.0749538839,
0.4231566787,
0.956097424,
-0.673848033,
0.2879806161,
-0.4314672947,
-0.141020745,
0.3255823255,
-0.7723093033,
-0.8192775846,
-0.2916501164,
-0.5633506179,
-0.4531995952,
0.3855374157,
0.4986627698,
0.8041883707,
-1.0600192547,
0.1496529877,
-0.6285302639,
-0.1430727541,
-0.3824177682,
-0.2164944261,
0.1303706914,
-0.398363024,
-0.9348403215,
0.6770870686,
0.1686417907,
0.0587728024,
-0.2373324037,
0.0411165878,
0.1415520161,
0.5373886824,
0.0328465551,
0.1785654426,
-0.8941190243,
-0.1305838674,
0.0743134245,
0.1125463396,
0.0581383109,
0.6353362203,
-0.6490183473,
0.4043107033,
0.2349284291,
0.8766175508,
0.1635255069,
0.204731375,
0.9803314805,
-0.7587936521,
0.092805095,
0.3526825011,
0.3562516868,
0.5713883042,
-0.3373901546,
0.4730800986,
0.0142463306,
-0.3804554343,
-0.8964973092,
0.318300128,
-0.7323477268,
-0.0829634219,
0.718296051,
-0.4872066677,
-0.3853227496,
-0.4889959097,
0.1388806999,
0.3439166248,
-0.1031242236,
0.569019556,
0.388989687,
0.2183357477,
-0.0188825093,
-0.5491458178,
0.6214001775,
0.9125855565,
-0.632084012,
0.052482672,
0.2802098691,
0.0642650947,
0.327899158,
-0.1564899087,
-0.0265409127,
0.3318284154,
0.0879159123,
-0.2254508138,
-0.0540722162,
-0.1626995802,
-0.1981732994,
0.1111931354,
-0.0653388873,
0.0122540202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16816v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16816v1 | Songs Across Borders: Singable and Controllable Neural Lyric Translation | 2023-05-26T10:50:17 | 2023-05-26T10:50:17 | Longshen Ou, Xichu Ma, Min-Yen Kan, Ye Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 | The development of general-domain neural machine translation (NMT) methods
has advanced significantly in recent years, but the lack of naturalness and
musical constraints in the outputs makes them unable to produce singable lyric
translations. This paper bridges the singability quality gap by formalizing
lyric translation into a constrained translation problem, converting
theoretical guidance and practical techniques from translatology literature to
prompt-driven NMT approaches, exploring better adaptation methods, and
instantiating them to an English-Chinese lyric translation system. Our model
achieves 99.85%, 99.00%, and 95.52% on length accuracy, rhyme accuracy, and
word boundary recall. In our subjective evaluation, our model shows a 75%
relative enhancement on overall quality, compared against naive fine-tuning
(Code available at https://github.com/Sonata165/ControllableLyricTranslation). | [
-0.0988310128,
-0.0616744943,
0.4520258009,
0.7189993858,
-0.1178032234,
0.349393338,
-0.4963654578,
-0.5194278955,
0.2641974688,
0.4452598393,
-0.7321721315,
-0.543161869,
-0.5857001543,
-0.0394740328,
-0.3038567007,
0.875613153,
-0.3264827132,
-0.06729424,
0.3113843203,
-0.002974377,
-0.4402891695,
-0.1519230753,
-0.5339134932,
-0.1137669832,
0.4998340905,
0.2308418006,
0.7045662999,
0.4120462537,
0.4548523426,
0.1898026466,
-0.3775121868,
0.1718539745,
-0.1192051545,
0.1818028539,
-0.2832985222,
-0.4784204066,
-0.483371824,
0.2833922803,
0.6673690677,
0.555113554,
-0.0515673906,
0.047397498,
0.1570962816,
0.7493433952,
0.1452192962,
-0.1626074761,
-1.0880764723,
0.3626866937,
-0.2929656804,
-0.1093206778,
-0.0735425353,
-0.7527170777,
0.4179635346,
-0.8629592657,
-0.0074020498,
-0.0381810665,
1.1878335476,
0.4785881341,
-0.230730325,
-0.5959975719,
-0.7060952783,
0.660107553,
-0.6324328184,
0.2399646491,
0.2422026694,
0.4663501084,
-0.2020013481,
-0.7361057997,
-0.1161995679,
-0.2615701854,
-0.0166302901,
0.4136928916,
-0.2115186453,
0.0562401339,
0.2347911447,
0.3939825594,
-0.4936175644,
-0.3753336668,
-0.3806492686,
-0.3001753986,
0.5012748837,
-0.0884430856,
0.9614796638,
-0.4510333836,
-0.644744575,
0.3036072552,
-0.7047921419,
0.5090254545,
0.3287066221,
0.7557636499,
-0.1706968844,
0.4161434174,
-0.0136086829,
0.7254906893,
-0.0181330498,
0.0119937947,
-0.0558873713,
-0.3000177741,
0.0916186497,
0.0573267266,
0.6088821888,
0.3651614785,
0.1583057493,
-0.5484393835,
-0.5157003403,
-0.1970330179,
0.2690984607,
-0.4125654995,
-0.0821183771,
0.1866357327,
-0.4310869575,
0.137203142,
-0.0854755715,
-0.2719414532,
-0.2613589764,
-0.7325225472,
0.7579917312,
-0.7056569457,
-0.2850429714,
0.0147631112,
0.0035703341,
0.0801141411,
0.1347946674,
-0.7292209268,
-0.0660515055,
0.571131587,
1.4788310528,
-0.2978974879,
-0.4055820107,
-0.206087783,
-0.1510676295,
-0.5393666029,
0.4057541192,
0.1022285819,
0.0137918293,
-0.3017306924,
-0.0425632223,
-0.6673333049,
-0.4794959724,
0.5576957464,
-0.5234838724,
0.0375153944,
-0.5716433525,
-0.2975564301,
-0.33255741,
0.0068195034,
-0.6535186172,
0.2330714613,
0.3392730653,
-0.3633604944,
0.2276632786,
-0.5276812911,
-0.4788307846,
-0.2559938133,
0.3339573443,
-0.191781044,
0.3139255047,
0.0249158181,
0.1452478468,
-0.0793081746,
0.313691169,
0.2247708738,
-0.4066159725,
0.3785731196,
-0.1876988262,
1.0408756733,
0.5468763113,
-0.3486019075,
0.1677726358,
-0.6064230204,
0.277259469,
-0.0244781282,
-0.4507306516,
-0.2195950747,
-0.1252274662,
0.369020462,
0.5980780721,
0.1143180951,
-0.4041882753,
0.0283147171,
-0.6853951216,
0.8776287436,
0.3670349121,
-0.2880567312,
0.7173988819,
-0.4330600798,
0.7957035303,
-0.2621115446,
0.1742253155,
0.2046601772,
-0.4315197468,
-0.4187766612,
0.0420288928,
0.6218155026,
0.7271085382,
-0.7851048112,
0.4243577421,
-0.2555800378,
-0.4861011803,
-0.8008249402,
0.1968259066,
0.2433465421,
0.375579685,
0.4195156693,
-0.1786452234,
-0.4138271511,
-0.5797547698,
-0.4419039786,
0.073608309,
-0.1187701896,
0.1628861427,
0.1146528497,
0.1288147569,
0.7169454098,
-0.0347680114,
-0.6924945116,
-0.2350675166,
-0.1338828355,
0.5419658422,
0.7960830927,
0.5532658696,
-0.7491548061,
-0.7879418135,
0.1837342978,
-0.4873448014,
-0.4543373287,
-0.5595166087,
-0.5321214795,
-0.0779422224,
0.3771728277,
-0.4938683212,
0.1554341912,
0.8414013982,
-0.4745282531,
0.2065881193,
0.1027503237,
0.2666295767,
-1.1348519325,
0.1746050417,
-0.3786216378,
-0.2157248557,
-0.721603334,
0.1306297183,
0.2976104617,
0.0330117196,
-0.2780640721,
-0.0277286489,
-0.5463383198,
-0.1747065932,
-0.2549697459,
0.1836523861,
0.1235293373,
0.1757634282,
-0.0181914475,
0.8742691278,
0.382445395,
-0.4325280488,
0.3522543311,
0.4085741043,
-0.2643224895,
0.9339881539,
-0.6812874079,
-0.2283331454,
0.1705056578,
0.156706959,
-0.8734138012,
-0.1350786537,
0.3523011208,
-0.78329283,
0.3576290607,
-0.4382265806,
0.0138458787,
-0.0406908616,
0.3922027647,
0.2723874748,
0.6510284543,
-0.6070780754,
0.409404397,
0.0632228479,
-0.2667491734,
-0.2883349657,
-0.8010447621,
0.4938338101,
-0.3572389483,
-0.6138857007,
0.5866931081,
0.0169673469,
0.1080040336,
-0.0041981251,
-0.2302702665,
0.1061612219,
0.1996738762,
0.0411088467,
-0.0786378756,
-0.4731250405,
0.2733640671,
0.320063144,
-0.1906841248,
0.105667524,
-0.8958495259,
0.2487469912,
0.0993529186,
-0.0850690976,
-0.2994006276,
0.3678109944,
0.5707072616,
-0.4639037549,
0.2901624739,
0.4511145055,
-0.2729040086,
-0.6347550154,
0.1282591671,
0.2819829583,
-0.389508009,
0.0012426509,
-0.5983831882,
-0.6380668879,
0.9527930021,
-0.1733016968,
-0.0698860213,
0.4567719698,
0.0010584507,
-0.1670689136,
0.7368260622,
0.3898612559,
0.2498675436,
0.4390580356,
-0.2883149087,
-0.0197933502,
-1.0986380577,
-0.0527655445,
-0.4842951,
-0.6894768476,
-0.6493068933,
-0.2850631475,
0.4366780818,
0.3457414508,
0.0125811044,
0.7610884309,
-0.7049994469,
0.4255522192,
0.5614028573,
0.0824668258,
0.2004528195,
-0.3565547466,
-0.3939022422,
-0.4870366156,
-0.574773252,
-0.0909911394,
0.8142196536,
0.3511862159,
0.3775395155,
0.4875414968,
0.4394764304,
-0.0648585185,
0.2012624741,
-0.7913948298,
-0.0280139912,
-0.4206188619,
-0.8323789239,
-0.3527772427,
-0.5507426858,
-0.5577961206,
0.2009049207,
-0.0594468787,
-0.6786327362,
-0.0450026914,
-0.206441924,
-0.5433411002,
0.6027416587,
-0.4836565852,
0.7547230721,
-0.4449407458,
0.0052529569,
0.6186543703,
-0.8137814403,
0.4888524115,
-0.3666150272,
-0.0571881421,
-0.3488090932,
-0.2289102972,
0.3801380992,
-0.3573020399,
0.5136626363,
-0.2315705717,
-0.4085499644,
0.0752539933,
0.1702076495,
0.2612222433,
-0.115974158,
0.1503803134,
0.1275609732,
-0.118312411,
-0.5115796924,
-0.8257864714,
0.7302652001,
-0.6232376695,
-0.2248492539,
-0.0858818293,
-0.8290693164,
-0.2995029688,
0.3212252855,
0.8219505548,
0.2141376436,
0.2509769499,
-0.0886137933,
0.5641914606,
-0.5107041597,
0.3488447964,
0.1824695766,
-0.4097521305,
-0.8321874142,
1.0139594078,
0.6147567034,
0.7139446139,
0.2880960703,
0.2329014093,
-0.5653702617,
-0.6877920628,
-0.8268579841,
0.0595868304,
-0.5109972358,
-0.1393543929,
-0.4393404722,
-0.5190763474,
-0.3224929571,
-0.2300089002,
-0.55851686,
-0.5652367473,
-0.0708690062,
0.1776970029,
0.4569752514,
0.8407664299,
-0.445078671,
0.546628356,
-0.8589134216,
0.4162651896,
0.1465244442,
0.6288930178,
-0.0774155706,
-0.8860939741,
-0.361343503,
-0.1264480352,
0.0247649848,
-1.0557101965,
0.3461319208,
0.1467436254,
0.2728529871,
0.0004766241,
0.1993421912,
0.7202033997,
-0.5174703598,
0.6230342388,
0.1114709377,
-1.3196948767,
0.7576964498,
-0.6013215184,
0.2046456486,
0.610463798,
0.3383957148,
-0.8585771918,
-0.3814371526,
-0.20809111,
-1.1047145128,
0.5627492666,
0.3622612059,
0.2420635372,
0.6898522377,
0.3474330306,
0.0484881662,
0.09653157,
-0.6885089874,
-0.2337312698,
-0.4657847583,
-0.1417029202,
-0.3925566971,
0.4470049739,
0.1498610079,
-0.3353117406,
0.6447400451,
-0.1375990659,
-0.0228486713,
0.4963915646,
-0.1126780808,
-0.213278383,
0.2796591818,
0.723467648,
0.4850986004,
-0.1921926737,
-0.0313279703,
-0.0399178453,
-0.4751071036,
0.3961316347,
0.2032289505,
-0.8206533194,
0.1389734149,
0.1128800288,
0.7171287537,
-0.0312962569,
0.009002612,
0.4025757313,
-0.0854493603,
-0.1885718554,
-0.2801362574,
-0.0800330564,
0.2794008553,
0.2487327904,
0.0849264711,
0.5324794054,
0.1282867044,
-0.0432418026,
0.3464725614,
0.3683113158,
-1.1095546484,
-0.2846908569,
1.1808539629,
0.0731453747,
-0.1404989511,
0.2401305884,
-0.2521042526,
-0.8128095269,
0.5475586057,
0.5975520015,
1.1289705038,
-0.1654982716,
0.2620258331,
0.4641724527,
0.7293089032,
-0.0038249493,
0.281475246,
-0.0528678522,
-0.4627324343,
-0.6957728863,
-0.5248157978,
-0.3516249359,
0.0296064243,
-0.7105228305,
-0.2097759396,
-0.3949539661,
-0.2347136885,
-0.1723442972,
-0.0548545718,
-0.2349978983,
0.2055144012,
0.0364888832,
1.0506228209,
-0.9728298783,
0.6732392907,
0.5677652955,
-0.5228152871,
-1.2276762724,
0.237951979,
0.0547592044,
-0.3293369412,
0.3749471605,
0.0529106632,
0.0794729218,
0.3199060559,
-0.5793446302,
-0.9705808759,
0.9262754321,
0.2880207896,
-0.3271250427,
0.0800027922,
0.2985554934,
0.4701439738,
-0.1056073382,
-0.0181633793,
0.8822450042,
0.5890987515,
0.1962496936,
-1.0141359568,
0.017609708,
-0.3605985343,
0.1604838669,
-0.0164303202,
-0.7413144708,
1.0738402605,
0.0885406137,
-0.2831073403,
0.5375377536,
0.6156300306,
0.0833990872,
0.4157374501,
0.4236710072,
0.4548276663,
0.6979033351,
-0.5674304962,
0.6437276602,
-0.1162287742,
0.1849872917,
0.9660463929,
-0.133196637,
0.5621620417,
0.4289029241,
-0.1426255554,
0.1372988522,
0.7030918598,
0.2596298456,
0.4527966976,
0.675925374,
-0.243451342,
-0.349113822,
-0.3520970345,
-0.4889943898,
0.5727129579,
0.2554167509,
-0.5329225063,
0.0044352356,
0.033912573,
-0.1213611886,
0.5606513023,
-0.2631871104,
0.4673236609,
0.4446114898,
-0.7953234315,
0.6118053198,
-0.1841261238,
0.9714322686,
-0.5373238325,
0.1523282826,
-0.3252528608,
-0.1642600149,
-0.314227879,
-0.6435875893,
0.4678071439,
-0.0197142083,
-0.1949703395,
-0.5373468399,
0.5205885172,
-0.7098811865,
-0.3313542008,
0.514686048,
0.5969727635,
-0.0124227721,
-0.3250837326,
-0.7760242224,
-0.2739841342,
0.1952773184,
-0.0900129825,
-0.0162740741,
0.6713641286,
0.09903384,
0.4831249416,
0.66868186,
0.9846542478,
0.3922363818,
0.0661349744,
0.6284148097,
-0.8112945557,
-0.7848888636,
-0.3028495014,
0.6505387425,
0.1225476637,
-0.3995126188,
0.5686223507,
0.3024654686,
0.8720007539,
-0.1328595877,
0.9042468667,
-0.0068167746,
0.8131204844,
-0.9262878895,
1.4846186638,
-0.7416081429,
0.1630615145,
-0.3906082213,
-0.8360949159,
-0.5719385147,
0.4211635292,
-0.0833775774,
-0.0721888915,
0.5129405856,
0.6294770241,
-0.2464061677,
-0.2015848756,
0.4872162342,
-0.0954908356,
0.0405406766,
1.0980371237,
1.3606545925,
-0.7348595858,
0.5251219869,
-0.4376885295,
0.1149762943,
0.2774903178,
-0.7843708992,
-0.5354725718,
-0.6952501535,
-0.1736659259,
-0.5603687167,
-0.22777614,
0.9668251276,
0.7892827988,
-1.0669943094,
-0.0718694478,
-0.0685344413,
0.4257905483,
-0.4275403619,
-0.1891184747,
0.2872660756,
-0.5104961395,
-0.7625566721,
0.5017469525,
-0.0321075805,
0.4295280278,
-0.0743503273,
-0.3321382999,
0.2360993177,
0.0838737264,
0.267555207,
0.2666358054,
-0.8402872682,
-0.2186927944,
0.2595943213,
-0.3309308887,
0.0007336442,
0.7721743584,
0.0087912166,
0.3646669686,
0.6128588319,
0.7256255746,
-0.2584071755,
0.1991735101,
0.5449321866,
-0.7421579957,
-0.2972498834,
0.2483355403,
0.0245344415,
0.277605325,
-0.2258930057,
0.4045345783,
0.2984788418,
-0.5022309422,
-0.3690054715,
0.2106694877,
-1.0266830921,
-0.1655849516,
1.0896731615,
-0.4452600181,
-0.3170737624,
-0.0867296383,
-0.2973414063,
0.4346351326,
-0.0941576287,
0.4322756827,
0.6166959405,
0.216803357,
0.0454048812,
-0.9058989882,
0.8919698,
0.3814381659,
-0.4908446074,
-0.1427653879,
0.3667328358,
0.2325054854,
0.201047048,
0.4283577502,
-0.1968250573,
0.4315896332,
-0.0537819415,
0.2858482301,
0.0894919038,
-0.4819113314,
-0.7061196566,
0.1099364609,
0.2960937023,
-0.3027927279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16811v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16811v1 | Improved Visual Story Generation with Adaptive Context Modeling | 2023-05-26T10:43:42 | 2023-05-26T10:43:42 | Zhangyin Feng, Yuchen Ren, Xinmiao Yu, Xiaocheng Feng, Duyu Tang, Shuming Shi, Bing Qin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Diffusion models developed on top of powerful text-to-image generation models
like Stable Diffusion achieve remarkable success in visual story generation.
However, the best-performing approach considers historically generated results
as flattened memory cells, ignoring the fact that not all preceding images
contribute equally to the generation of the characters and scenes at the
current stage. To address this, we present a simple method that improves the
leading system with adaptive context modeling, which is not only incorporated
in the encoder but also adopted as additional guidance in the sampling stage to
boost the global consistency of the generated story. We evaluate our model on
PororoSV and FlintstonesSV datasets and show that our approach achieves
state-of-the-art FID scores on both story visualization and continuation
scenarios. We conduct detailed model analysis and show that our model excels at
generating semantically consistent images for stories. | [
-0.2896752954,
-0.6983267069,
0.4981107414,
0.3052478433,
-0.49560377,
-0.1766210496,
-0.2108978927,
-0.4299297333,
0.0768837631,
0.5200981498,
-0.4537142515,
-0.4894151986,
-0.6096307039,
0.0333440825,
-0.3504352272,
1.0691010952,
-0.3657887578,
-0.1979812235,
-0.4216261506,
-0.1996897906,
-0.8893040419,
0.1755757779,
-0.6393969655,
-0.1142206565,
0.3595837653,
0.5195545554,
0.6830800772,
0.6355400085,
0.2668378353,
0.1674962938,
-0.1537176669,
0.3781856,
-0.7357359529,
0.7075713277,
0.0177182853,
0.1102846116,
-0.2017478943,
-0.2689308524,
0.7045525312,
0.5742858052,
-0.2380036265,
-0.1695426852,
0.2386509478,
0.6613658071,
-0.4526243508,
-0.0428033136,
-0.4564600587,
0.0820365772,
0.2594938576,
-0.5403934121,
-0.4310263693,
-0.4799281955,
0.6562565565,
-0.7260576487,
0.622409761,
-0.2166461945,
0.6830718517,
0.0308359582,
-0.5029993057,
-0.4275248945,
-0.7340774536,
0.4056776464,
-0.4162641466,
0.0891412944,
-0.16452308,
0.3060028255,
-0.1331337392,
-0.8449288011,
-0.2450508773,
-0.2372555435,
0.1744942367,
0.3101176023,
0.0055046692,
-0.3754466176,
0.0889448747,
0.1889518648,
-0.3781040311,
-0.2619979382,
-0.4747330248,
0.0009766107,
0.7036967874,
0.3709528148,
0.2646475136,
-0.143287763,
-0.5999549627,
-0.2110452503,
-0.6600989103,
0.1279350966,
0.1276187152,
-0.1355586499,
-0.2939010262,
0.4296101034,
-0.2507349551,
0.7161554098,
0.1905329823,
-0.1740655303,
0.1488106549,
-0.3996199071,
-0.0192289017,
0.2143818885,
0.4324402213,
1.0940272808,
0.6348839402,
-0.093265146,
-0.1380044073,
0.0181644242,
0.5194125175,
-1.0187646151,
-0.2785608768,
-0.0324604362,
-0.6436325908,
-0.4589551985,
-0.109188363,
-0.8189919591,
-0.7358654141,
-0.077503942,
0.3835433722,
-0.6128969789,
-0.2100942135,
0.1016042903,
-0.6296738386,
0.0526417159,
0.7749372721,
-0.8243772388,
0.0591896251,
0.0862190202,
1.0663408041,
-0.5055416822,
-0.1025377065,
-0.4840825796,
0.3671942651,
-0.7066372633,
1.0556982756,
-0.3342827857,
-0.5181844831,
0.0456213132,
-0.1159965768,
0.2133812159,
-0.4842229784,
0.3805955946,
-0.1976033449,
0.1674072146,
-0.2439485341,
-0.5254131556,
-0.1181901246,
0.1205758974,
-0.422036916,
0.7365859151,
0.1737977713,
-0.8126155734,
0.6195034981,
-0.5236975551,
-0.4091909826,
-0.0101546394,
-0.0642862543,
-0.3179517388,
0.479934603,
0.2693186402,
0.4899829328,
0.1231102198,
0.5782613754,
-0.2179962099,
-0.442084372,
-0.0292918533,
-0.5737407207,
0.3094400764,
0.1780068874,
-0.2222029567,
0.3475233912,
-0.6753481627,
-0.2821643949,
0.2986172438,
-0.1867519915,
-0.2376996279,
0.3461683691,
0.2873566151,
-0.0036407146,
-0.1194188148,
-0.4767433405,
0.3082490563,
-0.0474931896,
0.2087089866,
0.7041767836,
0.427401185,
0.5797474384,
-0.3904349208,
0.4093849957,
0.265501678,
-0.1190000102,
-0.9115417004,
-0.826849401,
-0.6214523911,
0.0779365599,
0.0978566557,
0.2136853337,
-0.7961412668,
0.0051032738,
-0.5538796186,
-0.3595541716,
0.0792641565,
-0.1426625401,
0.0092422403,
1.0325989723,
0.3158785105,
-0.6445447206,
-0.2595430017,
-0.6607490778,
0.0653917119,
0.1116638184,
-0.2545906603,
0.4213220179,
0.2415640354,
-0.1150174886,
1.0574474335,
-0.4498184323,
-0.0313839465,
-0.1084511727,
0.1021986604,
-0.0069745095,
0.753085196,
0.6490048766,
-0.8605049849,
-0.6451046467,
0.0433600955,
-0.6429957151,
-0.1801053733,
-0.3311407268,
-0.1428737193,
0.2334168851,
0.3315391243,
-0.340577662,
0.8192277551,
0.4831168056,
-0.9364185929,
0.6442762613,
-0.5288402438,
0.4053638875,
-1.1197556257,
0.089093715,
0.0512449704,
-0.5166875124,
-0.7212302089,
-0.1996957511,
0.1170776263,
-0.1067840308,
-0.3987391889,
0.800072372,
-0.4000149965,
-0.1302868128,
-0.4098234475,
0.2181017846,
0.2835021615,
0.1832001507,
0.3532706797,
0.6562167406,
0.7215528488,
-0.4616987407,
0.3832481802,
0.2608016431,
-0.6200147867,
0.824161768,
-0.6902133226,
-0.1502333134,
-0.4676994085,
0.4231054783,
-1.1574376822,
-0.3814999163,
0.1191174537,
-0.2746740282,
0.3686926961,
-0.0387759879,
-0.2256722152,
-0.0434640422,
-0.2591290474,
0.1960637122,
0.7750434875,
-0.6233403683,
0.7043046355,
0.0472939052,
-0.3809210658,
-0.1226756647,
-0.5971283913,
0.1621385962,
-0.4974091649,
-1.0831477642,
0.828728199,
-0.3496312201,
0.0076454761,
0.1178240776,
-0.187608093,
-0.1139307618,
-0.21154809,
0.1200691387,
0.1134578735,
-0.4819623232,
-0.0719582886,
0.1949920207,
-0.0119655496,
-0.3633705974,
-0.068284288,
0.31401968,
0.3887045085,
0.077833645,
-0.3204477131,
0.4317270517,
0.6602044702,
-0.0036966172,
0.6564303637,
0.6443805099,
-0.2889933884,
-0.1453046948,
-0.2714559138,
0.1320694834,
-0.401769042,
0.1632597744,
-0.1655220687,
-0.5867293477,
0.8431017399,
-0.1117944941,
0.22968629,
0.3054399788,
0.494487524,
-0.0097720455,
1.1515147686,
0.7642431259,
0.5184969306,
0.7168619037,
-0.1700866073,
-0.1496248841,
-0.910723567,
-0.2433975339,
-0.02148767,
-0.2705987096,
-0.1431233883,
-0.3936964869,
0.4912338555,
0.5126285553,
-0.0062683667,
-0.119789958,
-0.3205156624,
0.50439924,
0.1683924794,
0.1766898632,
0.4272522628,
0.3465543985,
-0.2441916168,
0.0365183875,
-0.8395845294,
-0.5884969234,
0.9843136668,
0.2563320398,
0.7425460815,
-0.0176001918,
0.5766490102,
0.3222815692,
0.4765589237,
-0.3393691778,
0.2091639489,
-0.2765522301,
-0.1734687984,
-0.1432532519,
-0.2220787704,
-0.9726762176,
0.2577425241,
-0.3595665395,
-0.8406282067,
0.3980949223,
0.1318910122,
-0.4896236062,
-0.045717936,
-0.9224640727,
0.9516092539,
0.1858485192,
-0.5700165033,
-0.0940149575,
-0.4117576778,
0.3747337759,
-0.0513071641,
-0.1723984182,
0.0136376442,
-0.0499021448,
0.5576965213,
-0.4103199244,
0.5995080471,
-0.2712654471,
-0.1652111411,
0.4954965413,
0.1638953686,
0.4512726068,
0.2978334129,
-0.084048517,
-0.1056429595,
-0.119559139,
-0.5207475424,
-0.5116959214,
0.811229229,
-0.2952475548,
-0.3919283152,
-0.0049307649,
-0.9535215497,
0.0749713555,
0.1287500858,
0.4813581407,
0.800421536,
-0.3092192411,
0.4771485031,
0.7144421339,
-0.3658533394,
0.6651833057,
0.1340240985,
-0.2802277803,
-0.4126862586,
0.4275818765,
0.0819746107,
0.3473173082,
-0.1972454935,
0.1990665048,
-0.1231043786,
-0.5627925396,
-0.8045200706,
-0.2552890778,
-0.7843055129,
-0.3425345421,
-0.6298803687,
-0.0995843634,
-0.2451049984,
-0.5949745774,
-0.2895816267,
-0.0966910571,
-0.2633377016,
0.0321860984,
0.4370404482,
0.6694518328,
0.2487273067,
0.3002017438,
-0.7369915843,
0.498439759,
0.172793448,
0.4602282941,
0.1832819581,
-0.464809984,
-0.1325549036,
-0.0589827485,
-0.581256628,
-0.8720297217,
0.4617403448,
0.3265098929,
0.4357680976,
0.367642045,
-0.0943597257,
0.9439499974,
-0.8555685282,
0.9098257422,
0.2560925186,
-0.6744559407,
0.5917925835,
-0.5070834756,
0.5562531948,
0.094727397,
-0.0290931743,
-0.4850898385,
-0.2792767286,
-0.6919029951,
-0.7229834199,
0.4203396142,
0.4421674013,
0.3624026477,
0.0654980317,
0.486883074,
0.3352302313,
-0.0454017743,
-0.5091920495,
0.1138970703,
-0.3482261896,
-0.4806752801,
-0.2204101235,
-0.2192011029,
0.0749423876,
-0.2089570463,
0.2680798471,
-0.264375329,
0.0439673699,
0.5588667393,
0.0009568765,
-0.4843093753,
-0.3140807152,
0.7297506332,
0.8480049372,
-0.2091461718,
-0.1587675214,
0.0196106136,
-0.5340509415,
-0.0367208943,
-0.0801334083,
-0.4292815924,
0.106128335,
0.4243839383,
1.093247056,
0.2060835361,
-0.8382496834,
0.5913287401,
-0.2874029577,
-0.166931957,
0.0096789133,
0.4854981005,
0.009505976,
0.487357676,
0.6696199775,
0.4391821325,
-0.047156211,
-0.456966728,
0.5083523393,
0.2037340105,
-0.3448295593,
-0.0179314986,
0.6305055022,
0.1646061093,
-0.1200240999,
0.5261195898,
0.2061586976,
-0.1760738194,
0.9107041955,
0.8549127579,
0.6901720762,
-0.1916377693,
0.4193561673,
0.2996614277,
0.06127676,
-0.2908860743,
0.1820484251,
-0.1435672939,
-0.7444128394,
-0.1762525886,
-0.5938292146,
-0.1557260007,
-0.1056015864,
-0.5307769179,
0.4449770451,
-0.1310322583,
0.1326177865,
-0.2391276211,
-0.1888506263,
-0.4539602101,
0.3120453954,
0.3294495642,
1.1334102154,
-0.7473992705,
0.7860222459,
0.3675996363,
-0.0845220909,
-0.4385541677,
0.2320343554,
-0.4577067792,
-0.1991584897,
0.100362964,
0.5191833973,
0.2376483828,
0.2957686484,
-0.4402164221,
-0.9136795402,
1.4918364286,
0.2109094113,
-0.4198153913,
0.1362553239,
-0.5359153748,
0.7122532725,
-1.1358668804,
0.0017506734,
0.2678906322,
0.201830402,
0.4506295025,
-0.4240953922,
-0.1280320138,
-0.2733598948,
0.4543389678,
-0.2194061726,
-0.1737235039,
0.59828794,
-0.54602772,
-0.4534504712,
0.4875055552,
0.7256772518,
0.6273807883,
0.6252375841,
0.4688936472,
0.2844255269,
0.6126956344,
-0.0380693302,
1.3609101772,
-0.1591572315,
0.0802128166,
0.982390523,
-0.241414234,
0.5953299999,
0.3284912407,
0.4513288736,
0.6821652055,
0.8387436271,
-0.017616624,
0.9393721223,
-0.0843003318,
0.0837285221,
-0.0433422923,
-0.1290001571,
-0.3792975545,
0.1931646615,
0.1593000144,
-0.6021127701,
-0.3841809332,
0.2856067419,
-0.510168016,
0.1483929753,
-0.4645207226,
0.5745382309,
-0.2283004373,
-0.6778523922,
0.4865157008,
-0.0151379593,
0.6068165302,
-0.462729305,
-0.1988178343,
-0.5034993887,
-0.162347436,
0.0806025341,
-0.8363717198,
0.3367323875,
0.3132006526,
-0.3903829753,
-0.4575085342,
0.8450963497,
-0.707873106,
-0.486227572,
-0.04093327,
0.282386452,
-0.1121336967,
0.1936219782,
-0.4349304438,
0.1437497735,
-0.0929265246,
-0.3753351271,
0.0523434803,
0.5038679242,
-0.2382648885,
0.3724915385,
0.4540246725,
-0.1318688244,
0.3322201073,
0.1192535833,
0.5904443264,
-0.4986211061,
-0.8252155781,
-0.5490175486,
0.9162252545,
-0.2178836167,
-0.522836864,
0.5203588605,
0.4692179859,
0.5790666342,
-0.2818309665,
0.4082588851,
-0.0316180661,
0.000320602,
-0.7152888775,
0.7564503551,
-0.5348886251,
0.1061876193,
-0.3740343153,
-1.212256074,
-0.2937652767,
0.6402437091,
0.0400931798,
0.0070292479,
0.6564162374,
0.5670149922,
-0.3304171562,
0.0054896954,
0.2065945119,
0.1561382562,
0.2572860718,
0.4429488778,
0.8117073774,
-0.4747656286,
0.2451568693,
-0.0308653247,
-0.2054411769,
-0.1354810297,
-1.1487298012,
-0.630389452,
-0.5752609968,
-0.4044377804,
-0.3239994943,
0.0716089085,
0.1086029783,
0.8224357963,
-0.5011804104,
-0.0336832628,
-0.4455502331,
-0.0301391017,
-0.2203803807,
-0.2790093422,
0.1689236164,
-0.1442854106,
-0.7330036759,
0.3068881631,
0.4948676229,
0.2146105915,
-0.2429942936,
-0.3641380072,
0.1211650744,
0.3076928854,
0.6145025492,
-0.2304830551,
-0.5447357893,
-0.473544538,
-0.3020860851,
-0.1498636305,
0.3679583669,
0.750939548,
-1.0368857384,
0.6674226522,
0.621955812,
0.3157405257,
0.5805113316,
0.1380605847,
0.8277567029,
-0.8131940365,
0.0941250473,
-0.1091533825,
0.3905340433,
0.5395471454,
-0.4452866018,
0.4821770489,
0.2536669075,
-0.2715697885,
-0.6692163944,
0.230195716,
-1.0194352865,
-0.4093325734,
0.987030983,
-0.110490568,
-0.2374753803,
0.1219948679,
-0.4330382645,
0.2559607029,
-0.1786771268,
0.7801702023,
0.58653301,
-0.1473319232,
-0.2278107554,
-0.487398684,
0.3536450863,
0.106597513,
-0.5521692634,
0.0414614752,
0.8497018814,
0.5383353233,
0.161013335,
0.6448648572,
-0.1060918048,
0.511215806,
0.1583624631,
-0.248897627,
-0.0755307823,
-0.6666427255,
-0.3748379648,
0.2630251348,
-0.5071640611,
0.1209901124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16809v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16809v3 | GenQ: Automated Question Generation to Support Caregivers While Reading Stories with Children | 2023-05-26T10:42:21 | 2023-09-25T17:37:37 | Arun Balajiee Lekshmi Narayanan, Ligia E. Gomez, Martha Michelle Soto Fernandez, Tri Nguyen, Chris Blais, M. Adelaida Restrepo, Art Glenberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | When caregivers ask open--ended questions to motivate dialogue with children,
it facilitates the child's reading comprehension skills.Although there is scope
for use of technological tools, referred here as "intelligent tutoring
systems", to scaffold this process, it is currently unclear whether existing
intelligent systems that generate human--language like questions is beneficial.
Additionally, training data used in the development of these automated question
generation systems is typically sourced without attention to demographics, but
people with different cultural backgrounds may ask different questions. As a
part of a broader project to design an intelligent reading support app for
Latinx children, we crowdsourced questions from Latinx caregivers and
noncaregivers as well as caregivers and noncaregivers from other demographics.
We examine variations in question--asking within this dataset mediated by
individual, cultural, and contextual factors. We then design a system that
automatically extracts templates from this data to generate open--ended
questions that are representative of those asked by Latinx caregivers. | [
-0.4888151884,
-0.6769413352,
0.2467324883,
0.0729865357,
-0.1811783016,
0.1671374142,
0.2290327996,
-0.3240091801,
-0.0302072484,
0.448367238,
-1.0383368731,
-0.2734942734,
-0.0242734309,
0.4596354961,
-0.4164948761,
0.7260368466,
-0.1239539832,
-0.043962121,
-0.4526590109,
-0.0197809692,
-0.0443333313,
-0.1706134379,
-0.9559012055,
-0.0368127339,
0.5330763459,
0.9620988965,
0.6457806826,
0.5066173077,
0.1112974957,
0.1878219694,
0.1294440031,
0.3235344589,
-0.1982481629,
0.6197036505,
-0.0118389064,
-0.7473896742,
0.0720890611,
0.0963335112,
0.1483433098,
0.7289689779,
0.0743507817,
0.4947050214,
-0.1193990707,
0.771920085,
-0.3833809793,
-0.177207619,
-0.4013877809,
0.6227483153,
0.0348666236,
-0.2268711329,
-0.0275303796,
-0.985018909,
0.0403445587,
-0.6214018464,
0.6981804967,
0.204101786,
0.6399217844,
0.3712212443,
-0.5280134678,
-0.3278805315,
-0.7610494494,
0.403970331,
-0.4987576604,
0.0549408905,
0.7552165985,
0.1808568239,
-0.1752893478,
-0.532525003,
-0.6944676042,
0.0000692328,
-0.2296600789,
0.3769495785,
-0.0807744637,
-0.3227529228,
0.2299620211,
0.1725345105,
-0.9535335898,
-0.1447221488,
-0.6517866254,
0.1809853911,
0.6797114611,
0.2573993802,
0.6989573836,
-0.1167155132,
-0.1594335884,
-0.0456420891,
-0.6462270617,
0.5466596484,
0.6970661879,
-0.0319701359,
0.0690435544,
0.6664106846,
-0.364952594,
0.7668324113,
0.155414626,
0.0928740278,
0.0446412712,
-0.4815099239,
0.2491265684,
0.0131128784,
0.7071977854,
0.5797114968,
0.6687642932,
-0.1469454616,
0.0498254225,
-0.2404534966,
0.1286066324,
-0.5834758282,
0.1390520036,
0.5017408133,
-0.2767155766,
-0.1967108697,
0.0960281491,
-0.9353768826,
-0.3697459698,
-0.2798160017,
-0.1034708172,
-0.4278928041,
-0.0582957678,
0.016962206,
-0.3805317581,
0.3698676229,
0.1875620484,
-1.2192206383,
0.118187882,
0.1819589734,
0.3796958923,
0.0692433342,
0.0135980835,
-0.5597590208,
0.0471422523,
-0.0601392351,
1.0629972219,
-0.5177115202,
-0.8273704052,
0.0535160825,
0.1584503055,
-0.3648115396,
-0.539014101,
0.2829156518,
-0.4599711299,
0.7713000178,
-0.3103090525,
-0.2446156144,
0.0890559033,
0.3662414551,
-0.3261845708,
1.0815984011,
0.605244875,
-0.6775278449,
0.486551553,
-0.4609228969,
-0.3260100186,
0.5852844119,
-0.1391245723,
-0.2955313623,
-0.149105832,
0.7214527726,
0.0860602632,
-0.30609411,
-0.0022597359,
0.0345513597,
-0.188784793,
0.1679736078,
-0.3121890426,
1.0952789783,
0.3631762564,
-0.4500786066,
-0.0681958944,
-0.5503594875,
0.3220450878,
0.3889620602,
-0.119587183,
-0.3816106021,
0.0800979882,
-0.2606467903,
0.0993419364,
0.0489483774,
-0.8083153963,
0.4107322991,
-0.2109224647,
0.290173918,
0.1633981466,
0.1969466358,
0.2171915919,
-0.5320940614,
1.296884656,
-0.33678931,
0.5138673186,
-0.4126332402,
-0.5641546845,
-0.5233124495,
0.2311225384,
0.1155781597,
0.9081714153,
-1.0237920284,
0.3530356288,
0.1816499978,
-0.5563287139,
-0.5319741368,
0.2272143215,
0.2911833525,
0.7542222738,
0.2307004631,
0.0094331577,
-0.3537948728,
-0.5913296342,
0.2243210673,
-0.497416079,
-0.2688761055,
0.6713593602,
0.3616179824,
0.17547521,
1.1027061939,
-0.5402941704,
0.2584357858,
-0.1977135539,
0.1151450276,
-0.1087685451,
0.494158864,
0.5020496249,
-0.867775321,
-0.5660579205,
-0.0942327082,
-0.7205363512,
-0.3144634366,
-0.1477978528,
-0.2512207627,
-0.0718434602,
0.7944864631,
-0.5354477167,
0.4629492164,
0.3846505582,
-0.813721776,
0.649579227,
-0.1436028183,
0.2038864195,
-1.2625720501,
0.3382107317,
-0.3156586587,
0.0598997772,
-0.4703214169,
0.0197344068,
0.0429312438,
-0.205341503,
-0.4854165316,
0.6372676492,
-0.2495139241,
0.1215088367,
0.3904207349,
0.103108041,
0.2574446797,
0.0542129055,
-0.1508559883,
1.0883908272,
0.0359893516,
-0.4352873564,
0.693518579,
0.493293941,
-0.1234123781,
0.8210056424,
-0.9783651233,
0.2714810371,
-0.2906666398,
0.1344472319,
-0.9203880429,
-0.0844263807,
0.5090557933,
-0.656814456,
-0.171349138,
-0.1074685082,
-0.60882622,
-0.8643824458,
-0.1684148014,
0.5106732249,
0.2923088074,
-0.4862102568,
0.1909804344,
0.2387621552,
-0.903809011,
-0.3514794409,
-0.2412173897,
-0.1110393181,
-0.2433010936,
-0.7704533935,
0.0871226192,
-0.4269076288,
-0.3613480628,
0.1851747483,
0.262560457,
-0.0195985213,
0.0290328208,
-0.0296037178,
0.3570434451,
-0.4029544294,
0.3907618225,
0.6388013959,
0.0391382687,
0.1202140599,
-0.1913820505,
0.5959915519,
-0.0743852481,
-0.3565954566,
0.0687205866,
0.80131042,
0.4814683199,
-0.6562142968,
0.6110803485,
0.493532896,
-0.0177936312,
-0.3170473874,
-0.3559058905,
-0.0852590948,
-0.470964551,
-0.3625327051,
-0.1140879914,
-1.0922276974,
0.7948893905,
0.2561240494,
0.1969958395,
0.1652095914,
0.4700958133,
-0.4439396262,
1.2221029997,
0.3062846363,
0.2128337324,
0.392753154,
-0.0567491874,
-0.0915170461,
-0.529919982,
-0.5977882743,
-0.7026405931,
-0.3011241257,
-0.2422117144,
-0.2322217673,
0.2984472513,
-0.0797310621,
-0.394212395,
-0.0062389425,
-0.6053703427,
0.3514739871,
1.1349166632,
-0.0275953263,
0.3715589046,
0.0174369998,
-0.4048925042,
0.1864772737,
-0.7457453012,
-0.5904260278,
0.8919440508,
-0.0633845255,
0.6563709974,
-0.0439314693,
0.6679929495,
0.4116283953,
0.3234237134,
-0.6488039494,
0.320630759,
-0.0261146985,
-0.7693087459,
-0.6126425266,
-0.2412743866,
-1.4708180428,
0.0283827633,
-0.1746011227,
-0.651160717,
0.6101259589,
0.0306985918,
-0.9394379854,
0.1443589926,
-0.724919796,
0.7010079026,
-0.3796276152,
-0.0109748999,
0.3989676833,
-0.8113011122,
0.2000253052,
0.0958032608,
-0.187112838,
0.1110018343,
0.1887072623,
0.5766938329,
-0.5713940859,
0.5943891406,
-0.0760923102,
0.0363970026,
0.8215514421,
0.1318475455,
-0.0045561511,
0.2593668997,
-0.1064182147,
-0.527996242,
0.2789490223,
-0.3984591365,
-0.5142846107,
0.2665694058,
-0.8731653094,
-0.7574462891,
-0.2419961095,
-0.8345886469,
-0.30693084,
0.1304416806,
0.2610774636,
0.15204373,
-0.1122635826,
0.2507080734,
0.8945411444,
-0.5155599713,
0.3669797778,
0.565276444,
-0.2022078782,
-0.1036636606,
0.517762363,
-0.0716348588,
0.1019531116,
0.1488536894,
0.1734274179,
-0.2209445983,
-0.180006519,
-0.8654714227,
0.2860941291,
-0.1749685407,
-0.2035281062,
-0.6193293333,
-0.3715830743,
-0.5624238253,
-0.2441340089,
0.2227796465,
-0.397459805,
-0.668292582,
-0.4381438196,
0.3793924153,
0.5855727196,
0.1406539679,
0.1912457049,
-1.0270476341,
0.3564054668,
0.9613314271,
0.104934454,
-0.3494805694,
-0.2045141757,
0.0792043805,
0.0026637397,
-0.2844495475,
-0.8094001412,
0.5342419147,
0.0700327307,
0.47253564,
0.4697265625,
0.4085124433,
0.3169413507,
-0.5099186301,
0.9281824231,
-0.0274732243,
-0.4632758498,
0.7286612988,
-0.5547165871,
0.5299586654,
0.7595227361,
0.4935589135,
-0.8024693131,
-0.4084366858,
-0.5307464004,
-0.7459833026,
0.6451299191,
-0.0031225933,
0.3744068444,
-0.0744214728,
0.4708922505,
0.4727426171,
0.0704334453,
-0.2579373717,
-0.0667832047,
-0.5217255354,
-0.4359857738,
0.1250859797,
-0.1996981949,
-0.1281944364,
-0.3288207948,
0.2641830742,
-0.3453729451,
0.238872245,
0.3428015113,
0.2282420248,
-0.648740232,
0.2616354823,
0.5599205494,
0.5560127497,
-0.0116885705,
-0.1288453043,
-0.244685635,
-0.5250470638,
0.0883157328,
0.5649728179,
-0.833889842,
-0.1887095273,
0.2073207051,
0.5156238675,
-0.3604536355,
-0.9126248956,
0.1173031852,
-0.6678346395,
-0.5526688695,
-0.5137335062,
0.498480469,
0.2817941904,
0.3339000642,
0.4561297894,
-0.4428649545,
-0.2062227428,
-0.485119909,
0.2439328283,
0.3760379255,
-0.3979091346,
-0.0422212183,
0.6396350265,
0.251619935,
-0.6101890802,
1.1860804558,
-0.0252610184,
-0.4389160872,
1.0096160173,
0.5016702414,
0.5500543714,
-0.4908477664,
0.8750198483,
0.243678689,
0.4249634445,
0.375821054,
0.8317878246,
-0.1682076007,
-0.8839588165,
-0.0386458114,
-0.3608499467,
-0.7652435303,
0.0437095016,
-0.7737746835,
-0.0861936882,
-0.318416357,
-0.1488110423,
-0.4169762731,
-0.2624270618,
-0.8438302875,
0.5093359947,
0.1372758895,
0.778327167,
-0.7463914156,
0.3082306981,
0.8926362395,
-0.5436450243,
-0.7917964458,
0.0954456329,
-0.286760509,
-0.7822297812,
0.6053027511,
-0.125794068,
0.0375801325,
0.2353741825,
-0.7415975332,
-0.9068793058,
1.1686469316,
0.0582719818,
-0.1899544001,
-0.2265880257,
0.4682985842,
0.6192532182,
-0.3713643849,
0.3839647472,
0.3646278381,
0.4427248836,
0.0373840705,
-0.5345447063,
-0.2150512934,
-0.6983177066,
-0.3432863951,
-0.1568083167,
-0.6201400757,
0.6919558048,
-0.3413304389,
-0.1490306258,
0.1854053438,
0.5004684329,
0.3055218756,
0.4689809084,
0.5756081939,
0.276201427,
0.7760161161,
-0.0956072882,
1.214725852,
-0.4298693538,
-0.1533405185,
0.7320461869,
0.0147678815,
0.3438423276,
0.3642825484,
-0.1360105276,
0.5910916924,
0.8381415009,
-0.0144633222,
0.1286374778,
0.0714508146,
-0.5081474185,
-0.0605439991,
-0.5533241034,
-0.3798475564,
0.2723832726,
0.4087918997,
-0.44143641,
-0.0093889134,
0.0304551404,
0.0641917214,
0.1177792251,
-0.0764565766,
0.7876280546,
0.0737028793,
-1.2095997334,
0.3136557937,
-0.2060754001,
0.0451398231,
-0.612552762,
0.0147799524,
-0.6828477383,
-0.3718971908,
-0.012884004,
-0.8671033382,
0.0246827602,
0.2711708546,
-0.2435538173,
-0.2876605988,
0.4822373986,
-0.5751171708,
-0.7084377408,
-0.0957221314,
1.1848447323,
-0.0509306118,
0.284357667,
-0.8182945251,
-0.5707626939,
0.0585541353,
-0.3668862581,
0.1092584953,
0.4372179806,
-0.1984208226,
0.8813624382,
0.8592987061,
0.1403383315,
0.2704001963,
0.2816902697,
0.7253511548,
-0.5106769204,
-0.473748982,
-0.408855617,
0.6398895979,
0.0163058005,
-0.6953097582,
0.5774928331,
0.2053083181,
0.6366757154,
-0.0886006877,
0.9645477533,
-0.1685683578,
0.6709842086,
-0.1343405098,
0.6330717206,
-0.5819997191,
-0.1971271634,
-0.113204971,
-0.8568401933,
-0.2499607354,
0.4946369827,
-0.2440121025,
-0.0383559614,
0.7734045386,
0.6753287315,
0.2556130886,
0.3994712532,
0.1345162243,
-0.3295261562,
0.366572082,
0.2516011,
0.9392594695,
-0.0242758654,
0.6364656687,
-0.2828131914,
-0.1691378504,
-0.089217715,
-0.3889729083,
-0.9800555706,
-0.4072588086,
-0.1200386882,
-0.2628050745,
0.1660990864,
0.9837814569,
0.2248363495,
-0.862875998,
-0.0482219122,
0.0195263941,
0.2200811356,
-0.0550433323,
-0.2710842192,
0.4581206739,
-0.2900727987,
-0.8552021384,
0.2619118989,
-0.0191597547,
-0.0041887048,
-0.4269768894,
0.3433975875,
-0.0608524196,
0.1361620575,
0.3349285126,
0.6824167371,
-0.1284755766,
-0.262026608,
0.299672246,
-0.2325665206,
-0.0780877396,
0.8937495947,
-0.8061932325,
0.590043962,
0.5041773915,
0.7153249383,
0.1747187972,
0.5030654669,
0.619209826,
-0.3920018375,
-0.1301320046,
0.6914680004,
0.1527107507,
0.2897490561,
-0.6358268261,
0.5333923697,
0.3582948446,
-0.5412248969,
-0.2700522542,
0.2802226543,
-0.5821387172,
-0.1398650855,
1.2369338274,
-0.1454490125,
-0.2567270994,
-0.6152476668,
-0.5529376268,
0.2123667747,
-0.473598361,
0.8084706068,
0.4261164069,
-0.3456799984,
-0.5728779435,
-0.4375144839,
0.3248804212,
0.5802964568,
-0.9646295905,
-0.3815658689,
0.3244564235,
0.1716757268,
-0.2789325118,
0.5233860612,
-0.0826692879,
0.3892535865,
-0.0508957282,
0.0592396185,
-0.1622190922,
0.1428455859,
0.1532667577,
0.3041093647,
-0.2382287979,
0.0541941077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16806v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16806v4 | Do GPTs Produce Less Literal Translations? | 2023-05-26T10:38:31 | 2023-06-06T03:15:43 | Vikas Raunak, Arul Menezes, Matt Post, Hany Hassan Awadalla | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-3 have emerged as general-purpose
language models capable of addressing many natural language generation or
understanding tasks. On the task of Machine Translation (MT), multiple works
have investigated few-shot prompting mechanisms to elicit better translations
from LLMs. However, there has been relatively little investigation on how such
translations differ qualitatively from the translations generated by standard
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) models. In this work, we investigate these
differences in terms of the literalness of translations produced by the two
systems. Using literalness measures involving word alignment and monotonicity,
we find that translations out of English (E-X) from GPTs tend to be less
literal, while exhibiting similar or better scores on MT quality metrics. We
demonstrate that this finding is borne out in human evaluations as well. We
then show that these differences are especially pronounced when translating
sentences that contain idiomatic expressions. | [
-0.1828574687,
-0.6423098445,
0.9361120462,
0.0193207748,
-0.4662962556,
-0.0062049418,
-0.2897737026,
-0.5995046496,
0.0038336702,
-0.0468372814,
-0.5060679317,
-0.3109606206,
-0.7394833565,
0.6413212419,
-0.4572945535,
1.2077461481,
-0.3006991446,
0.1171113402,
0.1077812761,
0.0382380709,
-0.3054392636,
-0.4060347378,
-0.5047690272,
-0.5321570039,
0.8569415212,
-0.1529537141,
1.1253267527,
0.6706261039,
0.6276702881,
0.2355627865,
-0.3011934161,
-0.07511051,
-0.1153655499,
-0.1320903748,
0.0944365114,
-0.4131243229,
-0.1766904593,
0.2401314974,
0.792488277,
0.5413459539,
0.1726994962,
0.2652266622,
0.4002583027,
0.6090797782,
-0.1786107272,
0.4303562641,
-0.7813572884,
0.1372363567,
-0.0114428047,
-0.0705521926,
-0.4063022137,
-0.498926729,
0.2607450485,
-0.5623937249,
-0.0292562693,
-0.1429456025,
1.0744777918,
0.1648938209,
-0.5495038629,
-0.2546280324,
-0.5106124282,
0.7724753618,
-0.9716733098,
0.1077763438,
0.0367670842,
0.3672812879,
0.0297039952,
-0.4894186258,
-0.5995944738,
-0.6050966382,
-0.4077903628,
-0.0733733177,
-0.1511416435,
0.1868605167,
0.2783642709,
0.2699407339,
-0.6392114758,
0.1684404612,
-0.3460853696,
0.1205813661,
0.3028205335,
0.2806857824,
0.2893164456,
-0.5669721961,
-0.415648222,
-0.1103882343,
-0.9777676463,
-0.2280667126,
0.2850799859,
0.4097585976,
-0.249081403,
0.7226447463,
0.0182866119,
0.6787652373,
-0.4071724117,
-0.4628806114,
-0.0419538543,
-0.6531675458,
-0.3631387651,
-0.2520179749,
1.0200622082,
0.4154865742,
0.4179833233,
-0.3526298702,
-0.4180544615,
0.1924780309,
-0.1760111451,
-0.8703737259,
0.1655209661,
-0.2801349759,
-0.3553448915,
-0.3260923028,
0.0948455259,
0.0288168285,
-0.2569094002,
-0.5916115046,
0.4713438451,
-0.5733319521,
0.2163507491,
0.2446062118,
-0.1560242027,
0.5168257952,
0.4977530539,
-0.554433167,
0.298890233,
0.7627205849,
0.978561759,
-0.2883984447,
-0.3830683231,
-0.3687905073,
-0.1296419501,
-0.5802820921,
0.3297463655,
-0.2730395496,
-0.2581290007,
-0.1684994251,
-0.1872950941,
-0.0658925772,
-0.5693973303,
0.2837200165,
-0.4823256135,
0.2123813182,
-0.6173175573,
-0.3185581863,
-0.3843665719,
0.3332030475,
-0.2740679383,
0.5955207944,
-0.0571542829,
-0.5806203485,
0.6040924788,
-0.5660264492,
-0.4447854757,
0.0795825124,
-0.4721444845,
0.0431478173,
0.3823545873,
0.0682970732,
0.4357052147,
-0.7549940348,
0.164122209,
-0.0588384233,
-0.4503497779,
0.4940882623,
-0.7781717181,
0.4988041222,
0.274738133,
-0.4571198225,
-0.1616250575,
-0.4335665107,
0.166668728,
0.346311897,
-0.3356465995,
-0.1068202406,
-0.0500154644,
-0.024556838,
0.5023633838,
-0.0754228011,
-0.5277333856,
0.3579812944,
-0.2720169127,
0.7959638238,
0.6859967113,
0.0453560017,
0.3770686984,
-0.3104009926,
0.5632158518,
-0.060294386,
-0.0390340984,
-0.0856697634,
-0.7151817083,
-0.3414906859,
-0.437884897,
0.1732614338,
0.5778675675,
-0.7382507324,
0.0756106898,
-0.7473976016,
-0.1533630341,
-0.5473365188,
0.1034274176,
0.4472974837,
0.4360972345,
0.3010301888,
0.013695416,
0.019815702,
-1.0744324923,
-0.6316589713,
-0.2312519997,
-0.1530822814,
-0.0453101657,
0.5333167911,
0.0930679739,
0.6903544664,
-0.2445409745,
-0.2515285313,
-0.2191195041,
0.290043205,
0.3051475883,
0.1109325364,
0.6723052859,
-0.4783436656,
-0.8074212074,
0.3463861942,
-0.6746317744,
0.1285806894,
-0.2878586948,
0.2642193735,
0.1588736176,
0.1861893684,
-1.0530593395,
0.3751474321,
0.4114443362,
-0.0636780038,
0.4221677482,
-0.0492436327,
0.3925822377,
-1.0127409697,
-0.0485605225,
-0.1679990441,
-0.4468024671,
-0.3527095914,
0.190299049,
-0.0124079827,
-0.0083200661,
-0.6576990485,
0.5372961164,
-0.5650520325,
-0.2926986814,
0.0294276271,
0.5008351207,
0.2843651175,
0.2234550416,
-0.0959225073,
1.0464009047,
0.2105531693,
-0.4426450133,
0.1555695534,
0.2280594707,
-0.3114638925,
0.3052563667,
-0.8574160337,
0.191009149,
0.0230465475,
0.0950011536,
-0.9913495183,
-0.2548195422,
0.2385190725,
-0.4795671105,
0.2130222768,
-0.3939601183,
-1.0383813381,
-0.3845605254,
-0.2966062129,
0.1288540065,
1.006172657,
-0.4214267731,
-0.2270506322,
-0.1693353653,
-0.243220374,
-0.1367008686,
-1.1754603386,
0.1816721112,
-0.1740074903,
-0.6313124895,
0.0541464947,
0.2819270194,
-0.2883583605,
-0.0146417143,
-0.1122114882,
-0.1121047884,
0.0174627881,
-0.3094683588,
0.343642205,
-0.4785155356,
0.1114698574,
-0.0065326924,
0.130362168,
0.1377677768,
-0.3409373462,
0.1157736704,
-0.2537435889,
-0.4816671014,
-0.6010724306,
0.2793746591,
0.8008743525,
-0.0198237337,
1.0291291475,
0.5121259689,
-0.2780820429,
0.4327131212,
-0.3209589124,
-0.3913267553,
-0.4322063625,
0.1281630248,
-0.6622217298,
-0.8139531016,
0.4941950142,
0.4176693261,
0.027329389,
0.460390836,
0.4763633013,
0.0223799367,
1.4141774178,
-0.0050706244,
0.194428429,
0.280954212,
0.0436418205,
0.29427737,
-0.7884184122,
0.3289743066,
-0.4671339989,
-0.3887560666,
-0.8433929086,
-0.2880613506,
0.4791267216,
0.1308303326,
-0.2502019405,
0.4168927372,
-0.5967929363,
0.7151528001,
0.243115887,
-0.202323854,
0.5377560854,
0.1319710463,
-0.0621425956,
-0.4566171765,
-0.5537353754,
-0.9234184027,
0.8537957668,
0.3152245879,
0.4967404306,
0.2496922463,
0.6857485771,
-0.1038113236,
0.5655411482,
-0.943446517,
0.5086852908,
-0.1440493912,
-0.5852716565,
0.0167030338,
-0.6942560077,
-0.8920127749,
0.3096698225,
-0.1617343575,
-0.7378715277,
-0.2915200889,
-0.0722292513,
-0.2918209136,
0.3480299115,
-0.8008930683,
0.9541023374,
-0.2530908585,
-0.0369854495,
0.0934268981,
-0.6942691207,
0.4162628949,
-0.1333858669,
0.0704402402,
-0.1966492534,
-0.2663040161,
0.2409980595,
-0.4528365731,
0.5774003267,
-0.0757376105,
-0.2693170309,
0.437826544,
0.4424230456,
0.9062101245,
0.0111568347,
0.1023212671,
0.0177966412,
0.0351932347,
-0.4858663976,
-0.6997374892,
0.604978919,
-0.7455973625,
-0.6060991287,
-0.2455916554,
-0.6620426774,
-0.0125111109,
0.2923278511,
0.565208137,
0.1425524205,
-0.1574590951,
0.1036412865,
0.2418714762,
-0.2403670996,
0.3270011246,
0.2859347165,
-0.4004855454,
-0.1730644405,
0.4880572259,
0.502050221,
0.699002564,
0.4040739834,
0.1418193579,
-0.4563038349,
-0.4244942069,
-0.6304526925,
0.4609434009,
-0.8748414516,
-0.1511911154,
-0.3853560686,
0.1122200936,
-0.3672325015,
-0.3080272377,
-0.2654486895,
-0.5421331525,
0.0258978661,
-0.2367658764,
0.5018823147,
1.0166028738,
0.182685107,
0.4894493818,
-1.002900362,
0.3593094051,
0.3967237175,
-0.031389609,
-0.4588835239,
-0.8188214898,
-0.0121485461,
0.2052556574,
-0.214103207,
-0.9990263581,
0.3583910763,
0.0638367757,
0.0034028199,
0.2003421932,
-0.3707134128,
0.73049891,
-0.7221968174,
0.9361237288,
0.3679642379,
-1.0986273289,
0.2001465112,
-0.7578068376,
0.3998828232,
0.4619188011,
0.1658124328,
-0.5305168033,
-0.2904616296,
-0.4288939536,
-0.5487841964,
0.4351888895,
0.3848537505,
0.4654448926,
-0.4540850222,
0.4028521478,
0.1194839552,
0.3125028908,
-0.9190875888,
-0.142877996,
0.2088647932,
0.0580894984,
-0.2175357044,
0.2017067522,
-0.0852278173,
-0.1171306893,
0.3658617735,
-0.0862260237,
0.4135257602,
0.1073729768,
-0.2624700665,
-0.0039883526,
0.6366835237,
0.7060608864,
0.5087612867,
-0.0178811122,
0.1060614884,
0.2726961076,
-0.1122398376,
0.4715095162,
-0.0601366051,
-0.360036552,
0.4270611107,
0.1824633479,
0.9431659579,
0.1962243319,
-0.2738981545,
0.6671110988,
0.1302108616,
-0.10219419,
-0.0388438515,
-0.3247422576,
0.2060502023,
-0.0308244172,
0.0778615475,
0.1519074589,
0.1651993543,
-0.4344580173,
-0.1301378161,
0.4693776071,
-0.3666426837,
-0.5487928987,
0.7131553888,
-0.0477279946,
-0.0306469221,
0.6554177999,
-0.571946919,
-0.2639582753,
0.3554807305,
0.5436295271,
1.1405457258,
0.1993016601,
0.2119645923,
0.1424223334,
0.7480914593,
-0.1558574438,
-0.0471399352,
0.0607550181,
-0.3840608299,
-0.9240115285,
-0.3931102455,
-0.2687960267,
0.2060260326,
-0.6457310915,
0.3892496824,
-0.2302519977,
-0.3209370971,
-0.1225415766,
-0.3854789436,
-0.8766102791,
-0.0852825344,
0.2426780015,
0.6942199469,
-0.7925514579,
0.818748951,
0.8204554915,
-0.7365215421,
-1.1345897913,
0.0246870089,
0.0198775735,
-0.6624974012,
0.9060465693,
0.2808015347,
-0.0716533214,
0.1759921461,
-0.4547483921,
-0.5651679039,
0.88228935,
0.8700498939,
-0.2999789715,
-0.3066394329,
0.6710362434,
0.6199238896,
-0.0980416462,
0.1363825649,
0.4856853783,
0.7482615709,
-0.1893398464,
-1.1336416006,
0.1572346836,
0.2074152976,
0.1757046729,
0.4392084479,
-0.282145679,
0.9311854243,
-0.1969778836,
-0.5095834732,
0.1981604695,
0.3213767111,
0.1657473743,
-0.0437656306,
-0.1973019242,
0.3892032504,
0.3079487383,
-0.2988130152,
1.7385981083,
-0.0822087005,
0.3356486261,
0.9794158936,
-0.1681306064,
0.6175706387,
0.74007833,
-0.3616227806,
0.0652209669,
0.4926266372,
0.3050152957,
0.2288749665,
0.3062002659,
-0.2194871008,
-0.1402051002,
0.2079143375,
-0.3572932184,
0.056498412,
0.0478406884,
-0.653347671,
-0.2847207785,
-0.1138271987,
0.5727456808,
-0.0966158286,
-0.1577585191,
0.7228583694,
0.523249805,
-0.8114378452,
1.0378252268,
0.0788619444,
0.5113843083,
-0.5438381433,
0.0116529297,
-0.3528588712,
0.0359857567,
-0.0468421876,
-0.858623147,
0.3371480405,
0.2309265137,
-0.1831460446,
-0.3424212635,
0.3492306769,
-0.2429693192,
-0.1367448419,
0.2397302687,
0.8346901536,
0.4179538786,
-0.2866407335,
-0.7921042442,
-0.1421359777,
-0.1351509094,
-0.4128570557,
0.385784179,
0.6006774902,
-0.082824342,
0.4051108956,
0.530277729,
0.2273421884,
0.4980527759,
-0.1567833424,
0.3985350728,
-0.4606994092,
-0.1584269404,
-1.1773598194,
0.4149784148,
0.1882070452,
-0.2672694623,
0.7985572219,
0.4157966971,
0.7045262456,
-0.4456278384,
0.7909629941,
0.1348333955,
0.223140195,
-0.6634304523,
0.5457261801,
-0.4487377107,
0.2655462325,
-0.1901326478,
-1.3221633434,
-0.4489504993,
0.5535923243,
-0.4871979654,
0.0129206534,
0.9286163449,
0.6409433484,
-0.1905930042,
-0.3637772799,
0.6999936104,
0.2795014977,
0.2822089791,
0.4861133695,
0.9818608165,
-0.7754684687,
0.6239523888,
0.2652433813,
0.249303475,
0.1109217852,
-0.8938906789,
-0.6914573908,
-0.3168746233,
-0.3119211495,
-0.1915098131,
0.0652357489,
0.9355501533,
0.3819876909,
-0.4455417693,
-0.005521087,
-0.4613802433,
0.0376618914,
-0.1368310153,
-0.21474199,
0.1424291283,
-0.5781335831,
-0.7714854479,
0.3996829093,
0.3125469089,
0.3865705431,
-0.0976517349,
-0.1896784604,
0.0682293177,
0.3786637783,
0.6676535606,
0.0835116059,
-0.9532884955,
-0.5964565873,
0.278332293,
-0.6138608456,
0.3018094003,
0.6333372593,
-0.7240408063,
-0.0031603749,
0.7179940939,
0.5113307238,
0.3067091703,
-0.2998315692,
0.5110784173,
-0.8262681961,
0.1900720447,
0.1859464645,
0.3454793692,
0.4583047628,
-0.1003769115,
0.5347206593,
0.3080083132,
-0.4393341243,
-0.8278670907,
0.4709230959,
-0.5012326837,
-0.0014968714,
1.4593013525,
-0.3276204169,
-0.1113962829,
0.2687982023,
-0.1405466646,
0.1741559058,
-0.1666273773,
0.3651618063,
0.904768765,
-0.035772372,
0.051819399,
-0.8549116254,
0.4550524354,
0.5441552997,
-0.7243208289,
-0.0181518625,
0.4385915995,
0.3284650445,
0.0645638108,
0.35516271,
-0.4862833619,
0.2179104686,
-0.1958170533,
0.0293345302,
0.2909811437,
0.0271443762,
-0.3711430132,
-0.2280293703,
0.565084815,
-0.1126124784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16801v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16801v3 | Motion-Based Sign Language Video Summarization using Curvature and Torsion | 2023-05-26T10:30:23 | 2024-01-16T15:56:35 | Evangelos G. Sartinas, Emmanouil Z. Psarakis, Dimitrios I. Kosmopoulos | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, 68T45, 68U10, I.4.9; I.5.4; I.2.7 | An interesting problem in many video-based applications is the generation of
short synopses by selecting the most informative frames, a procedure which is
known as video summarization. For sign language videos the benefits of using
the $t$-parameterized counterpart of the curvature of the 2-D signer's wrist
trajectory to identify keyframes, have been recently reported in the
literature. In this paper we extend these ideas by modeling the 3-D hand motion
that is extracted from each frame of the video. To this end we propose a new
informative function based on the $t$-parameterized curvature and torsion of
the 3-D trajectory. The method to characterize video frames as keyframes
depends on whether the motion occurs in 2-D or 3-D space. Specifically, in the
case of 3-D motion we look for the maxima of the harmonic mean of the curvature
and torsion of the target's trajectory; in the planar motion case we seek for
the maxima of the trajectory's curvature. The proposed 3-D feature is
experimentally evaluated in applications of sign language videos on (1)
objective measures using ground-truth keyframe annotations, (2) human-based
evaluation of understanding, and (3) gloss classification and the results
obtained are promising. | [
-0.1436411142,
-0.6471991539,
0.6035407782,
-0.0407675542,
-0.6460644007,
-0.1286581606,
0.1707004458,
-0.1019763499,
0.7848952413,
0.6661692858,
-0.4847729504,
-0.8768704534,
-0.8544767499,
-0.1514750868,
-0.5181645751,
0.8167057633,
-0.2563572824,
0.0860566795,
0.3980323672,
-0.3111431599,
-0.3117815554,
-0.0955127999,
-0.376498878,
0.0533272997,
-0.2024287581,
0.5100750923,
1.0304890871,
0.654714644,
0.5666272044,
0.2725640237,
-0.1122123599,
-0.1158054322,
-0.105948329,
0.0884320736,
0.4546994269,
-0.3191183805,
-0.6015924215,
-0.0695976466,
0.8617616892,
0.7092300653,
0.0777020827,
0.2593318224,
-0.2572049797,
0.5733667016,
-0.3351909518,
0.1139473245,
0.2232248187,
0.3359006345,
-0.6766902804,
-0.2090022564,
0.3179349899,
-0.6337705851,
-0.219026044,
-0.5453001261,
0.4659195542,
-0.0137626911,
0.5230073929,
0.3066969216,
-0.3092756569,
-0.178805396,
-0.8097938895,
0.2776737213,
-0.8230708838,
0.8602954149,
0.3670798838,
0.6295006275,
0.06435626,
-0.1380737722,
-0.6283913255,
-0.1773041934,
0.2478604615,
0.0795870423,
0.222260505,
0.3285404146,
0.5277459025,
0.4367782474,
-0.8982543945,
0.0376060642,
-0.6025121808,
-0.3161705434,
0.6786780953,
0.4021817744,
0.5530214906,
-0.0871114954,
-0.0500708111,
-0.5000530481,
-0.4135283828,
0.1254256219,
0.5266211629,
0.0373688862,
-0.6880307198,
0.9256982207,
-0.0315764844,
1.004894495,
0.0118146073,
-0.5189546347,
0.1616401821,
-0.1561235934,
0.0914500058,
-0.1935438216,
0.7026607394,
0.8832681179,
0.2387213856,
-0.0600272156,
0.0024934381,
-0.2063884288,
-0.2857529223,
-0.8030213118,
-0.0180577859,
0.061758481,
-0.4940624237,
0.1052252799,
0.3785611987,
-0.9268947244,
-0.5051317811,
-0.1658873111,
0.0927119926,
-0.4230504632,
-0.2597262859,
0.2476235032,
-0.2916819453,
0.3190689981,
0.2153153121,
-1.0362948179,
0.4246852696,
0.5181456208,
1.2464005947,
-0.3315497637,
-0.0957293361,
-0.6678984165,
0.3535917103,
-0.1307678372,
0.3990111053,
-0.3910905123,
-0.4200666249,
-0.0368753299,
-0.3920671046,
0.2147576362,
-0.2330143601,
0.1792973578,
-0.3411149383,
0.1905816048,
0.2140645981,
-0.4177015722,
-0.2390649468,
0.077395536,
-0.81455338,
0.6531481743,
0.2887050509,
-0.3170161247,
0.5739607215,
-0.7847927809,
-0.6535686851,
0.1984703839,
-0.2203407884,
-0.5584021807,
0.1563774496,
0.051729124,
0.3599602878,
-0.0726501644,
0.0542616472,
-0.3925988376,
-0.3664741516,
0.1322244257,
-0.317560643,
0.5825587511,
0.1591866612,
-0.3699701726,
0.0395707041,
-0.6625327468,
-0.2771500349,
-0.3460232019,
0.187773779,
0.0123178661,
-0.2454914004,
-0.1245189458,
0.0879251733,
0.0627930984,
-0.4563883543,
-0.1479538381,
-0.5618514419,
0.2543053925,
0.2114825547,
0.2729557157,
0.2752120495,
0.0750747398,
0.9177991152,
-0.1399564594,
0.4910005033,
0.0763309821,
-0.6274155378,
-0.3266462982,
0.073827073,
-0.2499325424,
0.2642049789,
-0.7152643204,
0.092682749,
-0.2716452181,
-0.2631347775,
-0.1051184237,
0.2140312791,
0.4819366932,
0.3190521598,
0.1694286168,
-0.5301089883,
-0.1815783083,
-0.4970588386,
-0.2781596184,
-0.4275707304,
-0.2317472547,
0.0110478848,
0.1686123461,
0.6911680698,
0.7280925512,
-0.8327985406,
-0.4844081998,
-0.188452974,
0.1999742538,
0.3772001863,
0.0984780043,
0.712924242,
-0.9376285672,
-0.4747404158,
-0.1935055405,
-0.617483139,
-0.1541926116,
-0.233472541,
0.2203166187,
-0.0939536169,
0.5516161323,
-0.4705301523,
0.5982242823,
0.4632151127,
-0.5884815454,
0.4876468778,
-0.2397654802,
0.304667294,
-1.0730494261,
0.0463186689,
0.1111605689,
-0.166147247,
-0.6736831069,
-0.18761985,
-0.231046021,
-0.3966297209,
-0.4788196385,
0.5121873021,
-0.4384718239,
-0.6342932582,
-0.4256618619,
0.6558507085,
-0.366173327,
0.4696960449,
0.3060661554,
0.7837562561,
0.5667192936,
-0.6762904525,
0.5261978507,
0.4314802289,
0.0391543135,
0.8301206231,
-0.4268875718,
-0.2386605591,
-0.0369661115,
-0.2583611906,
-0.8646527529,
-0.538036406,
0.4170353711,
-0.6276922822,
0.1131848171,
-0.0297197197,
-0.1753015816,
-0.576654911,
-0.441652298,
0.3717592359,
0.281758219,
-0.2728455961,
0.642131269,
0.6864457726,
-0.0527595729,
-0.3260792494,
-0.5628313422,
0.130086422,
-0.5974302888,
-0.6127681732,
0.3623987436,
0.1047294289,
-0.1685816199,
-0.4005278647,
-0.3940427005,
-0.0543172136,
-0.1418974549,
0.4136759639,
0.1934129894,
-0.0138866156,
-0.3487919569,
0.0357104726,
-0.2512736917,
0.1293104291,
-0.1021753699,
0.3743825853,
-0.2118076682,
-0.351023078,
-0.6166272163,
0.3699863255,
0.8478320837,
0.1150211096,
0.1851713061,
0.6475405097,
-0.3207152188,
0.2486367971,
-0.4069152474,
-0.1778401285,
-0.4348373413,
0.4456483424,
-0.1837878525,
-0.9439841509,
0.5912031531,
0.1938159168,
-0.1316630542,
0.184847638,
0.4789684713,
-0.2636558115,
0.9543548822,
0.7705925107,
0.1083859801,
0.8761661649,
-0.2716789544,
0.1148598939,
-0.8040487766,
-0.3550986052,
-0.2002685815,
-0.2945695221,
-0.2801329494,
-0.2294179797,
0.8446313143,
0.2546169162,
-0.1574794203,
0.9333732724,
-0.0324102938,
0.3582322598,
0.3735458851,
0.1312112808,
0.1774771363,
-0.3337849379,
-0.0268869046,
-0.0720786005,
-0.1778380275,
-0.4303205311,
1.0056722164,
0.0946719944,
0.530652225,
0.4777474701,
0.4680557847,
0.4351037741,
0.0575824603,
-0.6790542006,
0.8832481503,
-0.1805564314,
-0.2594109476,
-0.5296601057,
-0.21704714,
-0.5991431475,
-0.0992237926,
-0.1124905944,
-0.838594377,
-0.2259862423,
0.4985735714,
-0.5206152201,
0.3856570125,
-0.407646656,
0.8206977248,
-0.6137111783,
-0.0704193339,
-0.1671172976,
-0.9518882632,
0.2949065566,
0.1054014862,
0.0267074127,
0.0644105971,
0.067391336,
0.9141988754,
-0.8384491205,
0.8881772161,
-0.5382878184,
-0.1700647622,
0.2852510512,
0.3279621005,
0.3252272606,
0.0233469885,
0.3420706987,
-0.0092923939,
-0.2310546935,
0.1775461733,
-0.9112256169,
0.2023610771,
-0.4021011591,
-0.8195930719,
-0.0361940861,
-0.3622440994,
-0.3955035508,
0.2784977853,
0.135595575,
0.3860893548,
-0.1760927737,
-0.1527928859,
0.2071399093,
0.1580028981,
0.7682679892,
0.4190802574,
-0.2700086236,
-0.5810242891,
0.7757418156,
-0.1726408899,
0.2543815672,
0.4468285739,
0.2712163925,
-0.4778073132,
-0.8012111187,
-0.4367049634,
0.4165714383,
-0.4423506558,
-0.158990413,
0.0475508608,
0.156447202,
-0.4048490226,
-0.294107765,
-0.0384815708,
-0.9071540833,
-0.1537135392,
-0.41962412,
0.4719399512,
0.3222085834,
-0.1366452128,
0.8372971416,
-0.7194337845,
0.5551730394,
0.0989700109,
0.4489983916,
-0.503677249,
-0.5470837951,
-0.2091600001,
-0.1250415146,
-0.537294805,
-0.9893030524,
0.3144616187,
0.254131645,
0.402467519,
0.8204792142,
-0.3060278296,
0.642911315,
-0.205191046,
1.120765686,
0.6884992123,
-1.0682448149,
0.5612245798,
-0.3912756741,
0.1369923204,
0.2699751556,
0.1686911136,
-0.7649257779,
-0.6029337645,
-0.5938001871,
-0.665700376,
0.8251402378,
0.374977082,
-0.0065844641,
0.2458121628,
0.4640504122,
0.1739419848,
0.0099187521,
-0.5031582117,
-0.2021587789,
-0.4941239357,
-0.2970077395,
0.1385885626,
0.2039784193,
0.0285656378,
0.1436215341,
0.4333474934,
-0.2628008723,
0.0475194044,
-0.2393568307,
-0.3873226345,
-0.0645111054,
-0.1736654341,
0.986756444,
0.3441183865,
-0.1672141254,
0.0936082006,
0.1632587016,
-0.9410967231,
0.1367608756,
-0.2597947419,
-0.371286273,
0.128050074,
0.3739563823,
1.0340931416,
0.0870989189,
-0.4504394531,
0.7712569833,
0.4899275601,
-0.1357411742,
-0.334703505,
0.2014544159,
-0.4236644804,
0.4200708866,
0.1718927324,
0.0098847793,
0.3750419915,
-0.0197559297,
0.3739531338,
0.329425633,
-0.3320946097,
-0.7692019343,
1.2033119202,
0.1373620182,
-0.8131144047,
0.3516283929,
0.0872970223,
-0.4172441363,
0.5771785378,
0.4196003079,
1.1804879904,
-0.2872717381,
0.5886958241,
0.5619388819,
-0.0681263879,
-0.0110277971,
0.4786882102,
-0.5596425533,
-0.4817442596,
-0.331625253,
-0.2858529389,
-0.535287261,
-0.1668631583,
-0.7003242373,
0.460154295,
-0.432298243,
-0.4454493523,
-0.0926370919,
-0.4370105267,
-0.2179371566,
0.2099238336,
0.339572072,
0.5618695617,
-1.0210676193,
0.4980846047,
0.1799340099,
-0.6037300229,
-0.3220555186,
0.1906194091,
0.2852125466,
-0.7664127946,
0.6914263368,
0.0081618112,
-0.6871648431,
-0.212762475,
-0.1525739729,
-0.9489076138,
1.180821538,
0.3803628385,
-0.1038068384,
-0.2375433594,
0.6843345761,
0.5311505795,
-0.2743550539,
0.1300289929,
0.5159208179,
0.4984833896,
0.3639560044,
-0.8422260284,
-0.0951689407,
-0.0982644334,
0.3969893157,
0.4312877059,
-0.7300770283,
0.1277316362,
-0.3533433378,
-0.2348077148,
0.0214690678,
0.9539607167,
0.1625004709,
0.1591114253,
0.3983757794,
0.3094367683,
0.3223868906,
-0.057457909,
0.7239540219,
-0.4686947167,
0.2301885486,
0.7796316147,
0.0729299411,
0.4698017836,
0.5982629657,
-0.3440911472,
0.125242129,
0.3485009372,
-0.0083832853,
0.4212939441,
0.090503484,
0.0301876329,
-0.0717678145,
0.4429341555,
0.1222894192,
0.5702146292,
0.5776028037,
-0.0584893674,
-0.6242948771,
0.5975230932,
0.085045211,
0.2223262042,
-0.3779701293,
0.5067661405,
0.0244907159,
-0.5025357008,
0.2337248474,
-0.0471090786,
0.2641678452,
-0.5070442557,
-0.106141068,
-0.3944389522,
-0.1410254985,
-0.135107547,
-1.1568539143,
0.7351049781,
0.08413627,
0.2352649719,
-0.3082674742,
-0.0648064986,
-0.3862226009,
-0.1999132186,
-0.0017279645,
-0.1252013743,
0.5000980496,
0.2825239003,
-0.3563473225,
0.0755597726,
-0.0916955024,
0.015003236,
-0.3073526621,
0.0820073187,
-0.3966387808,
0.6116167903,
0.0868866891,
0.1552414298,
0.0584874041,
0.2192089409,
0.4026166797,
-0.6920235753,
-0.6496136189,
-0.8036842346,
0.3518900275,
-0.2140204906,
-0.6277887821,
0.8087199926,
0.7334524989,
0.580835104,
-0.1232592314,
0.4048216343,
-0.242510125,
0.2472016066,
-1.0195034742,
0.363871485,
-0.3401601911,
0.2226504683,
-0.5082628727,
-1.0165011883,
-0.9555233121,
0.5090997815,
-0.3365804255,
0.2017101943,
0.7275600433,
0.7846439481,
0.0762040168,
0.1615445912,
0.365177393,
0.0092863077,
0.3694102168,
0.5593841076,
0.2004561126,
-0.5554570556,
0.6379539371,
0.0059744068,
-0.3881143332,
-0.4184134305,
-0.7410663962,
-0.8799257874,
-1.019446969,
-0.6217306852,
-0.3258328736,
-0.1797399223,
0.4815151095,
0.5928245783,
-0.7965273261,
-0.5306976438,
-0.1412686408,
-0.0542472489,
-0.4341272712,
-0.1700911224,
0.7461023927,
0.2307908386,
-0.7226244807,
0.3329097629,
0.4974105358,
0.5197029114,
-0.2217151523,
-0.2960379422,
0.4372138083,
-0.3710775375,
0.263823241,
0.8385820985,
-0.5898458958,
-0.5352283716,
0.0727075711,
0.4095303118,
0.1170764044,
1.0898164511,
-0.3177849054,
0.5051261783,
0.3548486233,
-0.0685834438,
1.1806702614,
0.1098610163,
0.7096930146,
-0.704949379,
0.1887289733,
0.1423713267,
0.2753760219,
0.2809353471,
-0.3165548146,
0.4111945033,
0.2668195665,
0.1256557852,
-0.398948282,
0.4611291289,
-1.2087651491,
0.286262989,
0.8921221495,
0.198329851,
-0.2442760617,
-0.0883168951,
-0.0514207035,
0.3039756417,
-0.0804449096,
0.7820412517,
0.5229993463,
-0.530118525,
-0.3653667569,
-0.1747356504,
0.5974932909,
-0.0016197308,
-0.6074745059,
0.1617745608,
0.6897234917,
0.2022322267,
0.1983206123,
0.5787059069,
-0.4967824817,
0.4074332714,
-0.0880853236,
-0.0480427481,
-0.4454944432,
-0.4874083102,
-0.3547239304,
0.1979373097,
-0.2580472529,
-0.3898096085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16799v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16799v1 | To Revise or Not to Revise: Learning to Detect Improvable Claims for Argumentative Writing Support | 2023-05-26T10:19:54 | 2023-05-26T10:19:54 | Gabriella Skitalinskaya, Henning Wachsmuth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Optimizing the phrasing of argumentative text is crucial in higher education
and professional development. However, assessing whether and how the different
claims in a text should be revised is a hard task, especially for novice
writers. In this work, we explore the main challenges to identifying
argumentative claims in need of specific revisions. By learning from
collaborative editing behaviors in online debates, we seek to capture implicit
revision patterns in order to develop approaches aimed at guiding writers in
how to further improve their arguments. We systematically compare the ability
of common word embedding models to capture the differences between different
versions of the same text, and we analyze their impact on various types of
writing issues. To deal with the noisy nature of revision-based corpora, we
propose a new sampling strategy based on revision distance. Opposed to
approaches from prior work, such sampling can be done without employing
additional annotations and judgments. Moreover, we provide evidence that using
contextual information and domain knowledge can further improve prediction
results. How useful a certain type of context is, depends on the issue the
claim is suffering from, though. | [
-0.3301656246,
-0.6778467298,
0.8270144463,
-0.1738545895,
-0.0008353185,
0.0212365054,
-0.2332313061,
-0.3125186265,
0.1642322391,
0.3841411471,
-0.5104934573,
-0.2567724884,
-0.4820002615,
0.523924768,
0.0093716895,
1.0053254366,
-0.4461273551,
0.192764625,
-0.4818738699,
-0.3495005667,
-0.7683324218,
-0.290495187,
-0.6047753096,
-0.151781112,
0.5395318866,
0.4507623911,
0.1506427974,
0.3327234685,
0.2240854204,
0.3929315209,
-0.1835832894,
0.1963444948,
-0.3276276588,
0.3959822357,
-0.2738394141,
-0.5327618718,
-0.1385202259,
-0.060624063,
0.4950560331,
0.7808936834,
-0.0961644873,
-0.1372462511,
-0.0034574231,
0.6914548278,
-0.5734848976,
-0.1167591214,
-0.9704487324,
0.1309158951,
-0.2129725516,
-0.131981045,
-0.4845348597,
-0.5043302178,
0.3445582688,
-0.8203059435,
0.634560585,
0.0630184337,
0.8122242689,
0.1689142287,
-0.204286173,
-0.5867109299,
-0.5518706441,
0.5622424483,
-0.6930988431,
0.1310872883,
0.2681418955,
0.0831493214,
-0.2886541486,
-1.0786360502,
-0.6552851796,
-0.0378270447,
-0.1392902285,
0.1711250991,
-0.3460613191,
0.135861218,
0.2448898107,
0.3297337592,
-0.1583426297,
-0.185790047,
-0.4833395481,
-0.3300100863,
0.5389053822,
-0.2136757374,
-0.0190279465,
-0.071511142,
-0.2229716778,
-0.2232278436,
-0.5651172996,
0.0173286535,
0.8026364446,
0.1621183604,
0.3072629869,
0.2982888222,
-0.0993452221,
0.6720279455,
0.6023448706,
0.2099640816,
0.043903701,
-0.1648663729,
-0.1881231666,
0.1805193275,
0.3142623901,
0.4089789987,
-0.1213794127,
0.0421752781,
-0.0568332113,
-0.1998935044,
0.468262285,
-0.4415675402,
-0.3175896108,
0.319666177,
-0.3709145188,
-0.1102780849,
0.0817904398,
-0.9408628345,
-0.6624753475,
-0.4314470887,
0.2883690298,
-0.2500566244,
-0.1039525792,
0.0014840638,
-0.5062087774,
-0.2408598661,
0.7434384227,
-0.5677896738,
0.204815045,
0.625176847,
0.6934555769,
0.0304125324,
-0.1540285349,
-0.3380113244,
0.0824007466,
-0.4923187494,
1.2854788303,
-0.6448385715,
-0.3919771612,
0.4141350389,
0.0980891809,
-0.1314790696,
-0.7614604235,
0.8934460282,
-0.2919325829,
0.533082664,
-0.5222941041,
-0.9710432291,
-0.3123094141,
0.4416539669,
-0.8999089003,
0.8069581985,
0.2321259379,
-0.7934110165,
0.6287229061,
-0.4443741739,
-0.0437161364,
0.0410769135,
0.0078309001,
-0.6559814811,
0.2148890197,
0.0118943974,
0.3211400211,
0.353725493,
0.0737000033,
-0.2237319946,
-0.1131693646,
0.0648783892,
-0.0947570652,
0.345279187,
0.1666541249,
-0.2881591618,
0.3654646277,
-0.7356489897,
-0.1462482363,
-0.1674999595,
-0.4353453517,
-0.5341341496,
0.3778088689,
-0.1781036556,
-0.1936934292,
-0.0014416287,
-0.6300429106,
0.4629024565,
-0.3690810204,
0.418821156,
0.9367271662,
0.3488526344,
0.1886583567,
-0.7144863009,
0.324269712,
-0.0827896222,
-0.1507239491,
-0.371052295,
-0.6114487052,
-0.735804081,
-0.0874818414,
0.3312559426,
0.2145881057,
-0.7469286323,
-0.0955370292,
-0.0046946825,
-0.3112327754,
-0.7002612948,
0.2559642792,
0.2536613345,
0.5399680138,
0.6901279092,
-0.0623188876,
-0.8832089901,
-0.5942069888,
-0.8058741093,
-0.3081101775,
0.1129163206,
0.1479857266,
0.3332057297,
-0.1076575071,
0.9255842566,
-0.3435530066,
-0.3958615959,
-0.4017271101,
0.391749233,
-0.3294961154,
0.2735972106,
0.3501750827,
-0.7173478603,
-0.6164468527,
-0.102901347,
-0.4475745261,
-0.4941722751,
-0.6420716047,
0.0634485483,
0.2803680003,
0.9335554838,
-0.1623875797,
0.2735529542,
0.2807719111,
-0.3890807927,
0.3721453249,
-0.2292471677,
0.0123993866,
-1.05367589,
-0.2552495599,
0.1775559038,
-0.2893996835,
-0.4707804322,
0.0643176064,
-0.1950763166,
0.3174757957,
-0.0919077694,
0.2635729313,
-0.4559304714,
0.6821798682,
-0.0834196955,
0.2363868952,
0.0908525661,
0.2525610924,
0.0875361711,
0.3988724649,
-0.1275239885,
-0.3306123614,
0.0708179027,
0.0842565969,
-0.2836810946,
0.9005204439,
-0.4924043119,
0.3440509439,
-0.3585104942,
0.5599043369,
-1.1529773474,
-0.1923282444,
0.1395502836,
-0.2429964542,
0.2826138437,
-0.3175150156,
0.0926892832,
0.085294351,
-0.5284076333,
0.0870979205,
-0.0333836824,
-0.6214658618,
0.5854298472,
0.2114665508,
-0.3500816524,
-0.5396374464,
-0.2956519723,
0.1264916956,
-0.3518282771,
-0.2694520652,
0.7958287001,
-0.0346909091,
-0.7266719937,
0.0613584556,
0.1267036498,
0.0526018813,
-0.218724668,
0.2579835951,
-0.0258687213,
-0.0448400527,
0.1100649759,
0.0451216549,
0.0933912843,
0.071859546,
-0.123853676,
0.1437928379,
0.186535731,
-0.2582051456,
-0.183381781,
0.6670560241,
0.287114501,
0.2458542585,
0.3079252541,
0.1420284361,
-0.4105851948,
-0.4805840254,
-1.0404740572,
0.0966701135,
-0.4473223984,
0.1555468738,
-0.1612948924,
-0.7238454223,
0.2607889473,
-0.517604053,
0.4193583429,
0.4703094661,
0.3551057279,
-0.1667529047,
0.6093360782,
0.6411315799,
0.2817574739,
0.5077079535,
-0.1317976564,
0.1782935709,
-0.7928988338,
-0.1662175506,
-0.5481731296,
-0.2413500249,
-0.5928602815,
-0.3875083923,
0.1461938769,
0.1012776941,
0.1709764898,
0.2821969688,
-0.6494626403,
0.3364023864,
0.2879855037,
0.0349467136,
0.4429799318,
0.1122242808,
-0.2904549837,
-0.4576331973,
-0.5188308954,
-0.6215988994,
0.7930731773,
0.2518528402,
0.1480556428,
0.1606590599,
0.642308414,
0.3988204598,
0.8353426456,
-0.9140816331,
0.379370898,
0.2232840955,
-0.462757349,
0.0512165204,
-0.2825969756,
-0.9153798819,
0.4791463017,
-0.22129412,
-0.3268007934,
0.3632990718,
0.2918168902,
-0.3011684716,
0.5516469479,
-0.8568252921,
0.789685607,
0.4202978313,
-0.579005599,
-0.2704590559,
-0.3148564398,
-0.0875017047,
0.0387827829,
0.2064377815,
0.327224046,
0.1784556061,
0.6184219718,
-0.7000916004,
0.9172952175,
-0.2971214652,
-0.0278947391,
0.7208476067,
0.1004962698,
0.3867657483,
-0.16919671,
-0.1737947017,
-0.1936252415,
0.2848782539,
-0.1674765795,
-0.4279588759,
0.4876131117,
-0.4533487856,
-0.8341316581,
-0.6265002489,
-0.122559391,
-0.3027723432,
-0.0699819103,
0.4298326373,
0.1514083743,
-0.6110751033,
0.1949445307,
0.5087551475,
0.0058171605,
0.6981300116,
0.3976234198,
0.2980670631,
-0.6658388376,
0.6758248806,
0.4275026917,
0.0784428865,
0.1190678328,
0.4372138381,
-0.3107095361,
-0.6403768659,
-0.4267175496,
0.1063774601,
-0.8553361893,
-0.2976720333,
-0.5015152097,
0.4660689533,
-0.4415615201,
-0.5967295766,
-0.0779926404,
-0.3593671024,
0.0138917193,
-0.1961515397,
0.333019197,
0.9986730218,
-0.2086405605,
0.0336666964,
-0.3936701417,
-0.1304077804,
0.3862486184,
0.1343097091,
0.0189827457,
-0.4142525494,
0.086774081,
-0.1382378787,
-0.7716252804,
-1.0537962914,
0.3197023273,
0.1512710899,
0.3851641119,
0.1907920092,
0.183234036,
0.9088312387,
-0.6392126679,
0.9986472726,
-0.0613204539,
-0.9395831823,
0.5688607693,
-0.1223049685,
-0.0715050995,
0.7957722545,
0.4775822163,
-0.7843104005,
-0.1790295541,
-0.7547557354,
-0.8611846566,
0.1924547106,
-0.0581068024,
0.2155001611,
-0.0483097881,
0.6158013344,
0.1343680322,
0.1270661056,
-0.773950398,
0.2862429619,
-0.3820647299,
-0.245739609,
0.3328228593,
-0.0631922334,
-0.3522740006,
-0.2605085969,
0.6215618849,
-0.3420594037,
0.0017622767,
0.907715559,
-0.0050325287,
-0.2772177756,
0.3761023581,
0.8155118227,
0.5644698143,
0.0153153352,
0.0904960036,
0.4767405391,
-0.5873172879,
-0.0440961272,
0.0017240683,
-0.2788853943,
0.5522068143,
0.5057242513,
0.4450401068,
0.1763699651,
-0.4848817289,
0.5758546591,
-0.0902041718,
-0.2817688584,
-0.5713252425,
-0.154692784,
-0.1142349169,
0.1415639073,
0.1123772785,
0.2412517667,
-0.0191580392,
-0.6759951115,
0.1416984051,
0.1860561967,
-0.5580568314,
-0.3543327749,
0.3667240441,
0.1837257594,
-0.4132070839,
0.1627517492,
-0.1697436869,
-0.4652563035,
0.4957425296,
0.3997095525,
0.7764572501,
-0.2063095272,
0.1603833139,
0.5347189307,
-0.1296661496,
-0.2534149885,
0.0069608358,
-0.0942761004,
-0.5555637479,
-0.2737128437,
-0.1443780661,
-0.6810826063,
0.2049776912,
-0.5366978049,
0.3895996511,
-0.8074624538,
-0.0444103591,
0.1050066203,
0.0895111859,
-0.2203546017,
-0.0438975804,
-0.1875160187,
0.7302532792,
-0.5476629734,
0.4247512817,
0.8941241503,
-0.3923832774,
-0.5712880492,
0.3393674791,
0.2515369654,
-0.1570794433,
0.2936096489,
-0.0041682366,
-0.1212679446,
-0.2689157724,
-0.8774947524,
-0.243036285,
0.8015950918,
0.2246252,
-0.5428737998,
0.0293521713,
-0.1806303859,
0.6609301567,
-0.2817362249,
0.1624626964,
-0.0538196079,
0.4585538208,
-0.007459831,
-0.5910497308,
0.069098562,
-0.0974396318,
-0.1145538166,
-0.0417816639,
-0.6726399064,
0.7947927117,
-0.2964648306,
-0.101830624,
0.1307158023,
0.6889262199,
0.0434378199,
0.5655412078,
0.5595015287,
0.6558874249,
0.9256825447,
-0.0911658928,
0.8971316218,
0.0554175638,
0.2222749293,
1.3259196281,
-0.2756889462,
1.1442067623,
0.5427019596,
0.0384938754,
0.9835827947,
0.5475068688,
-0.1077390388,
0.4101162255,
0.3523517251,
-0.6181721687,
-0.1620724797,
-0.2401049137,
-0.3159566224,
0.1102049276,
0.4547271729,
-0.3215487599,
-0.2204874903,
-0.249741599,
0.5716826916,
0.6579917669,
-0.1236486137,
1.0067685843,
-0.0296311546,
-1.3718459606,
0.3210681677,
0.192423746,
0.5342613459,
-0.4118869305,
-0.5732873678,
-0.2134388089,
0.3128044307,
-0.5009971857,
-0.5575767756,
0.48862046,
0.1000856087,
-0.1560658664,
-0.4013669193,
0.6112119555,
-0.433221817,
-0.2056754977,
0.0991294608,
0.2752838433,
-0.2367382944,
0.1228461042,
-0.5148291588,
0.0042671906,
0.0090354327,
-0.1741444618,
0.2139612138,
0.6189055443,
-0.0468593463,
0.1599165201,
0.6639249921,
0.2850484252,
-0.0411188714,
0.1363789886,
0.7630785108,
-0.2649999559,
-0.1918147802,
-0.6759298444,
0.6141530275,
-0.4559098482,
-0.5928652287,
0.6594946384,
0.3606083095,
1.2184998989,
0.0815051645,
0.8903987408,
0.0686274469,
0.7191813588,
-0.4416994154,
0.3285179138,
-0.3456073105,
0.1023063362,
-0.5029919744,
-0.6024361253,
-0.2355601937,
0.9263005257,
-0.3913497627,
-0.2447922826,
0.8330457211,
0.6713856459,
0.1890249401,
0.2395259738,
0.1038866118,
0.1589841992,
0.4219980836,
0.3367450535,
0.7534775138,
-0.6306266189,
0.4636932015,
-0.2093633711,
-0.0219872184,
-0.1044413745,
-1.1878069639,
-0.6922929883,
-0.8013390899,
-0.7868759632,
-0.7692411542,
0.0629339889,
1.0848556757,
0.4214138389,
-0.8382383585,
0.0219875164,
-0.3510676026,
0.1814333797,
-0.4758345485,
-0.1847033203,
0.1327488422,
-0.4845576584,
-0.6834177971,
0.4245865345,
-0.1823571622,
-0.0969492346,
-0.087019071,
0.1690336466,
-0.3363434672,
0.4319531322,
0.3949809074,
0.5154547691,
-0.6647416353,
-0.4954026341,
-0.2522834241,
0.2419188768,
0.2958702147,
1.2783193588,
-0.7354162931,
0.8047485352,
0.6369408369,
0.5794988275,
0.2273647785,
0.1100240052,
0.5760704279,
-0.7078347206,
-0.1218150556,
0.3013950288,
0.5804410577,
0.6734121442,
-0.2998594046,
0.4666340351,
0.7217333317,
-0.4827983379,
-0.8594780564,
0.039399486,
-0.6705080867,
-0.4949760437,
1.1006541252,
-0.5904488564,
0.116245769,
-0.5552864671,
-0.6260559559,
0.1665889174,
-0.2051276118,
1.093614459,
1.1725575924,
-0.0968931764,
0.0122152818,
-0.500597775,
0.9226132035,
0.5339339375,
-0.6016744971,
0.1756495833,
0.6117582917,
0.3819398582,
0.425404042,
0.5098914504,
-0.1049914137,
0.0261852667,
0.1067321151,
-0.2587911785,
0.2084428072,
-0.1265002638,
-0.4172558784,
0.5718743801,
0.0968102515,
0.2108228803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16798v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16798v1 | Schema-Guided User Satisfaction Modeling for Task-Oriented Dialogues | 2023-05-26T10:19:30 | 2023-05-26T10:19:30 | Yue Feng, Yunlong Jiao, Animesh Prasad, Nikolaos Aletras, Emine Yilmaz, Gabriella Kazai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | User Satisfaction Modeling (USM) is one of the popular choices for
task-oriented dialogue systems evaluation, where user satisfaction typically
depends on whether the user's task goals were fulfilled by the system.
Task-oriented dialogue systems use task schema, which is a set of task
attributes, to encode the user's task goals. Existing studies on USM neglect
explicitly modeling the user's task goals fulfillment using the task schema. In
this paper, we propose SG-USM, a novel schema-guided user satisfaction modeling
framework. It explicitly models the degree to which the user's preferences
regarding the task attributes are fulfilled by the system for predicting the
user's satisfaction level. SG-USM employs a pre-trained language model for
encoding dialogue context and task attributes. Further, it employs a
fulfillment representation layer for learning how many task attributes have
been fulfilled in the dialogue, an importance predictor component for
calculating the importance of task attributes. Finally, it predicts the user
satisfaction based on task attribute fulfillment and task attribute importance.
Experimental results on benchmark datasets (i.e. MWOZ, SGD, ReDial, and JDDC)
show that SG-USM consistently outperforms competitive existing methods. Our
extensive analysis demonstrates that SG-USM can improve the interpretability of
user satisfaction modeling, has good scalability as it can effectively deal
with unseen tasks and can also effectively work in low-resource settings by
leveraging unlabeled data. | [
-0.1960720718,
-0.3911091089,
0.6008067131,
0.1746394187,
-0.2446276098,
0.0092203347,
-0.2393291295,
-0.0904462263,
0.1486860514,
0.9134325385,
-0.705440104,
-0.6824094653,
-0.4495494366,
0.0063724834,
-0.1286370307,
0.7483872175,
0.1550855488,
0.2833919227,
-0.8121888638,
0.2021276504,
-0.249551028,
-0.5507990122,
-0.2566092312,
-0.4649882615,
0.3754312992,
0.5896107554,
0.6130965352,
0.2982604206,
0.606695354,
0.2568162978,
-0.109827362,
-0.0675125271,
-0.4769506752,
0.3874539137,
-0.170624882,
-0.4583891928,
-0.5657165051,
0.3759758472,
0.2292073667,
1.1117693186,
-0.5299859643,
0.4019430876,
0.5054417849,
0.4223673344,
-0.4700004458,
0.5092104077,
-0.3078805208,
0.0145036383,
-0.025484642,
-0.0967694148,
-0.4811203182,
-0.2374019623,
0.1746028066,
-0.5752972364,
-0.0426049419,
-0.0814262182,
0.8028056622,
0.5074161291,
-0.5999538302,
-0.1829899698,
-0.7602975368,
1.027197361,
-0.8183382154,
0.3355976045,
0.3928743303,
0.2166809142,
-0.3861782253,
-0.4638275206,
-0.5625151992,
-0.3623649478,
-0.2963487208,
0.2522359192,
0.0859242752,
0.3193335533,
0.3386190534,
0.5905670524,
-0.6010818481,
-0.0428678766,
-0.1485522091,
-0.040207468,
0.5905718803,
0.613132,
0.298373729,
-0.5535894632,
-0.6702855825,
0.383864671,
-0.4197808504,
0.5876821876,
0.1458755136,
0.3794748783,
0.403246969,
0.5166141987,
-0.8247491717,
0.7850385308,
0.0251132287,
-0.4326537848,
0.1212431118,
-0.2650695741,
-0.3171176612,
-0.5358063579,
0.7603783607,
0.5489135981,
-0.2347226292,
-0.2247810662,
-0.1195093021,
0.4383151233,
0.4034079015,
-0.719609201,
0.1735492498,
0.2134962082,
-0.8593224287,
-0.1921426207,
-0.2251621336,
-0.3279186487,
-0.3856734931,
-0.6113032103,
0.243910253,
-0.294962585,
-0.1371370405,
0.2022011429,
0.3508552313,
-0.1992188245,
0.4583446681,
-0.9383140802,
0.5152711272,
0.5912488103,
0.5679649711,
-0.502394855,
-0.1267639399,
-0.4937866926,
0.0613522157,
0.0190374181,
0.5363736749,
-0.6785888672,
-0.5790834427,
-0.1693597287,
-0.2096027136,
-0.1401241571,
-0.3103706539,
0.7406770587,
-0.236163184,
0.1588218957,
-0.4358003438,
-0.6508392692,
-0.1992809474,
0.147467345,
-0.190498203,
1.0372947454,
0.4113802314,
-0.3386530578,
0.4113373756,
-0.7892772555,
-0.207354933,
0.4574725628,
-0.0666477308,
0.0799375325,
0.2077912092,
-0.1392064691,
0.7558822632,
-0.7078727484,
0.4751835167,
-0.1946720183,
-0.6651158929,
-0.0202070214,
0.0381252319,
0.6711297035,
0.6418008208,
-0.0455539003,
0.1201764569,
-0.4901688695,
0.0860630572,
-0.1950221956,
-0.1704728752,
-0.2654415965,
-0.0367247649,
-0.161277771,
0.5841962695,
0.5465724468,
-0.8271359205,
0.2956694663,
-0.1505378932,
0.3142156005,
0.4639751911,
-0.180697009,
0.7001678944,
0.1627071053,
0.6564093232,
0.0201623049,
0.3912810385,
-0.0739465877,
-0.3294976056,
-0.6211516261,
-0.2112762034,
0.178540051,
0.6051881909,
-0.2694176435,
0.5525373816,
-0.3440358937,
-0.5812140703,
-0.121027194,
0.1711701602,
0.2466899008,
0.6400157213,
0.1063290685,
-0.7129544616,
-0.1396250427,
-0.8232451677,
-0.3828478456,
-0.2609339058,
-0.3243605196,
0.7476505041,
0.0943619534,
-0.4353013933,
1.08535254,
-0.8206624389,
-0.6839603782,
-0.5336609483,
0.3877490163,
0.2446569204,
0.3050085604,
0.1962780356,
-0.5288567543,
-0.605643034,
-0.1378421485,
-0.8788754344,
-0.2900339663,
-0.1581321061,
-0.0478986092,
-0.0642618313,
0.0833875015,
-0.819744885,
0.7214286923,
0.2297405154,
-0.2604053915,
0.4926944971,
0.0485169552,
0.3965061307,
-1.1038515568,
-0.0241791066,
0.0335596241,
-0.0484993979,
-0.6901659369,
-0.1883487999,
-0.1290476024,
-0.3299169242,
-0.2491951883,
0.3625173867,
-0.3445895612,
-0.4110116661,
-0.1067847833,
0.0856288821,
-0.059723869,
1.0012034178,
-0.042333141,
0.5086978078,
0.4454656243,
-0.4213850796,
0.3762455285,
0.5902100801,
-0.196973443,
1.0049811602,
-0.5130041242,
-0.1192755699,
0.0787948295,
0.2483154386,
-1.2011958361,
-0.1992221475,
0.2284014523,
-0.2964534461,
0.1278359741,
-0.151056394,
-0.2014938295,
-0.4604565799,
0.0452445969,
0.1655061096,
0.2964317799,
-0.26576069,
0.9576580524,
0.4355688393,
-0.5762495399,
-0.5021321774,
-0.1680271477,
-0.0012209911,
-0.1325669587,
-0.6728543639,
0.420411557,
-0.067996569,
0.1471176893,
-0.2185571045,
-0.3251159489,
-0.0035577286,
0.062198218,
0.8462058306,
0.4426760375,
0.2635736167,
-0.1804671884,
-0.198631838,
-0.3591990173,
0.0177564565,
-0.1558629721,
0.3953941762,
-0.2963885963,
-0.4163597524,
-0.7709019184,
0.6684259176,
0.3515820503,
-0.2002117783,
0.3598398268,
0.5097644329,
-0.3225591183,
0.1269200444,
-0.4093246162,
-0.3077506721,
-0.4346389174,
0.3420887291,
-0.3627669811,
-1.0135146379,
0.5659813881,
-0.5182110071,
0.0529787429,
0.1626851112,
0.1668255627,
-0.3745194077,
1.5435602665,
0.4356250465,
-0.1167295948,
0.5543973446,
-0.2263327092,
0.2249790281,
-0.7701835632,
-0.271114409,
-0.5185528398,
-0.3821102083,
-0.1649109721,
-0.2017175853,
0.2845433354,
0.2618915141,
-0.1926034093,
0.4755280912,
-0.5468668342,
0.0938631445,
0.5387009382,
-0.173608467,
0.267539382,
0.0835539624,
-0.2468683571,
-0.3700995743,
-0.3537683487,
-0.6536902785,
0.9931566715,
0.0946325362,
0.864998877,
-0.1442732513,
0.8149340153,
0.5520918965,
0.2159088999,
-0.7241043448,
0.8354198337,
-0.1652836651,
-0.1473784149,
-0.4938413203,
-0.6402710676,
-0.6840770245,
0.1855440736,
-0.0532165654,
-1.3216303587,
-0.1003248394,
0.1851297319,
-0.3892530203,
-0.1868572235,
-0.5278927088,
1.0818017721,
-0.1852042079,
-0.1874723285,
-0.3028032184,
-0.6941649914,
0.1251566857,
0.5846287012,
-0.1262497902,
-0.3395805955,
0.3237632513,
0.6759953499,
-0.5645654798,
0.7371208072,
-0.4160944819,
0.1007829532,
0.1305777133,
-0.001319601,
0.7821888328,
-0.0295487512,
-0.0688883662,
0.311948359,
0.0284905266,
-0.4151659012,
-0.9741357565,
0.8968378901,
-0.4643473923,
-0.8950811625,
-0.4947763383,
-0.7072418928,
-0.5476076603,
0.2612649202,
0.0838222876,
0.2527391315,
-0.2312943637,
0.026883712,
0.3781242967,
0.0922389552,
0.0361485779,
0.479664892,
-0.2487069666,
0.0685832947,
0.8869353533,
0.1047148034,
0.2768007517,
0.029179588,
-0.2374413162,
-0.5213839412,
-0.3815402389,
-0.596054256,
0.0541341119,
-0.5683035254,
-0.2235679477,
-0.6469420195,
-0.2648702562,
-0.0889293924,
-0.000060814,
-0.318916291,
-0.6065562963,
-0.359457463,
-0.0548329689,
-0.054448463,
0.7727625966,
0.3044451475,
0.5426489115,
-0.5658626556,
0.2458449155,
0.3397990167,
0.5999116898,
-0.3737156093,
-0.4222466052,
-0.3914721012,
0.2491526306,
-0.5821398497,
-0.8477025628,
0.2479677349,
-0.0977963954,
0.7811401486,
0.5130451322,
0.1035021096,
0.4396090806,
-0.1948577911,
1.1073701382,
0.1906249076,
-0.934559226,
0.4227088988,
-0.420458883,
0.1040464118,
0.4983523786,
0.2166280597,
-0.8280407786,
-0.3259027004,
-0.5217130184,
-0.7647770643,
1.0966775417,
0.138915509,
0.0775723755,
0.2353655994,
0.5274975896,
0.1386063695,
0.4846152067,
-0.4918812215,
-0.6353681684,
-0.2670582235,
-0.2674111426,
-0.037905857,
-0.4486678839,
0.1956533939,
0.0501979329,
0.6439000964,
-0.1913437545,
0.2653015852,
-0.2565777302,
-0.1210945174,
-0.1018943563,
0.5088169575,
0.1638012528,
0.5625860691,
-0.1906730682,
-0.2524056733,
0.0215588193,
-0.2231695205,
0.1649867594,
0.2695221305,
-0.3127580881,
-0.1236026064,
-0.5499593019,
0.6773673892,
0.1395700723,
-0.4284304678,
0.6753979325,
-0.1637016386,
0.0089648394,
0.1273522824,
0.3841678798,
0.3212151825,
0.1321287602,
0.4945770502,
0.2870230079,
0.6761356592,
-0.1897825748,
-0.0256509483,
0.6428483725,
-0.7134954929,
-0.248440817,
0.6330882907,
0.290276289,
-0.2396413088,
0.2589616477,
-0.2583758831,
-0.4280373454,
-0.0083051603,
0.5009591579,
0.453920573,
-0.6440831423,
0.6742743254,
0.2427774221,
-0.1427410394,
-0.0764695629,
0.6909384727,
-0.3880736828,
-0.3144975007,
-0.1441362947,
-0.803704381,
-0.3662142456,
0.0176633056,
-0.9801833034,
-0.0545135103,
-0.1450764686,
-0.354671061,
-0.169332698,
0.0488707982,
-0.7544844747,
0.5959685445,
-0.2404034734,
0.5328329206,
-0.7494518161,
0.3583716452,
0.5919873714,
-0.4650920331,
-0.8432246447,
-0.214647457,
0.1502431184,
-0.3776552081,
0.5515335798,
0.040388234,
-0.2674240172,
-0.0089270175,
-0.2641744018,
-0.8493583202,
1.2747410536,
0.5857256055,
-0.3097965717,
0.1094114855,
0.6312812567,
0.6175426841,
-0.703494668,
0.2648097277,
0.4256758392,
0.0890582502,
0.2702761292,
-0.7023609877,
0.0769661292,
-0.369248122,
0.3660046458,
0.1672109962,
-0.5726472735,
0.6116603017,
-0.2168396711,
-0.1355433017,
0.1735782623,
0.7521958947,
0.0301495623,
0.279399395,
0.7808666825,
0.4553202093,
0.7301312089,
-0.2880992293,
0.5815680027,
-0.2244069874,
0.4429869652,
1.0207673311,
-0.5068886876,
0.7971349955,
0.4240006506,
-0.2919301093,
0.7031926513,
0.7089384198,
0.3909122348,
0.4286650717,
0.1316669285,
-0.2838596404,
-0.6814398766,
-0.6024908423,
-0.2530405819,
0.6740614772,
0.5218126774,
-0.3887193799,
0.002032368,
-0.0540762991,
-0.327906698,
0.0202784706,
-0.185940966,
0.8478249311,
0.0229091253,
-0.8610767722,
0.3748452961,
-0.1076792032,
0.2896031141,
-0.4426620305,
0.0533870719,
-0.2317237258,
-0.0292560589,
-0.3821336627,
-0.5915258527,
-0.0467266887,
-0.1575647146,
-0.3446706533,
-0.4641469419,
0.8302398324,
-0.5947903991,
-0.4224488735,
0.1480670869,
0.4953570068,
0.2685421705,
-0.1838836372,
-0.6368271708,
-0.2866812646,
0.1742176861,
-0.4316287935,
0.3794472218,
-0.0370887667,
-0.1098361835,
0.8155016899,
0.7159538865,
-0.1287279278,
-0.5914486647,
0.2866160274,
0.7722534537,
-0.7260510921,
-0.8249229789,
-0.3564731181,
0.5296081305,
-0.2545586228,
-0.0579675846,
0.7827911377,
0.5406352878,
0.5590054989,
0.0534498282,
0.877828002,
0.2041328251,
0.8368880749,
0.017025467,
0.5702630877,
-0.6848596931,
0.5285026431,
-0.589787364,
-0.947065115,
-0.1004393101,
0.4598517716,
-0.3046774566,
0.1771795899,
0.3225240409,
0.6989322305,
-0.0476349369,
0.4840244949,
0.4447687566,
0.0105804838,
-0.1367886066,
0.6954499483,
1.0271369219,
-0.1761708558,
0.6233842373,
-0.032424476,
-0.3503901064,
-0.4080762267,
-0.5507305861,
-0.7143543959,
-0.7638019919,
-0.0664559752,
-0.1792246401,
-0.195001483,
0.7544324398,
0.767208755,
-0.6569154859,
-0.2110051066,
0.1101857275,
-0.0722853541,
-0.3995528221,
-0.214580074,
0.0615829453,
-0.3668627739,
-0.6279053092,
0.0626640171,
0.6974071264,
-0.286413759,
-0.3028847873,
-0.4661274552,
0.1878677905,
0.0289199539,
0.2446502298,
-0.0088543091,
-1.1184089184,
-0.2333897799,
0.4576005936,
-0.4673597515,
-0.1107804552,
0.8043629527,
-0.5682439208,
0.5145279765,
0.253218174,
0.2631291449,
0.6605110765,
0.259308815,
0.7309178114,
-0.6699491143,
-0.3281035423,
-0.0508905724,
0.4709346592,
0.3423080742,
-0.7772151828,
0.5171124935,
-0.0199480355,
-0.6965053082,
-0.6755079627,
0.4491505325,
-1.090241909,
0.1846751571,
1.0308306217,
-0.677143693,
0.1930784434,
-0.3554001153,
-0.4893687069,
0.2319060564,
-0.5772727132,
0.8773152828,
0.6838374734,
-0.5180922151,
0.1334535927,
-0.0720103234,
0.9167144299,
0.7128852606,
-0.787686348,
0.3000505567,
0.6922305822,
0.1656974703,
0.3104951978,
0.7639439702,
0.2371082455,
0.4810007513,
-0.2937427163,
0.000134802,
-0.1746702939,
-0.2101876736,
0.1580261737,
0.1863110811,
-0.0504223593,
-0.041951742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16797v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16797v2 | Calibration of Transformer-based Models for Identifying Stress and Depression in Social Media | 2023-05-26T10:19:04 | 2023-07-05T21:45:29 | Loukas Ilias, Spiros Mouzakitis, Dimitris Askounis | cs.CL | cs.CL | In today's fast-paced world, the rates of stress and depression present a
surge. Social media provide assistance for the early detection of mental health
conditions. Existing methods mainly introduce feature extraction approaches and
train shallow machine learning classifiers. Other researches use deep neural
networks or transformers. Despite the fact that transformer-based models
achieve noticeable improvements, they cannot often capture rich factual
knowledge. Although there have been proposed a number of studies aiming to
enhance the pretrained transformer-based models with extra information or
additional modalities, no prior work has exploited these modifications for
detecting stress and depression through social media. In addition, although the
reliability of a machine learning model's confidence in its predictions is
critical for high-risk applications, there is no prior work taken into
consideration the model calibration. To resolve the above issues, we present
the first study in the task of depression and stress detection in social media,
which injects extra linguistic information in transformer-based models, namely
BERT and MentalBERT. Specifically, the proposed approach employs a Multimodal
Adaptation Gate for creating the combined embeddings, which are given as input
to a BERT (or MentalBERT) model. For taking into account the model calibration,
we apply label smoothing. We test our proposed approaches in three publicly
available datasets and demonstrate that the integration of linguistic features
into transformer-based models presents a surge in the performance. Also, the
usage of label smoothing contributes to both the improvement of the model's
performance and the calibration of the model. We finally perform a linguistic
analysis of the posts and show differences in language between stressful and
non-stressful texts, as well as depressive and non-depressive posts. | [
-0.6145328879,
-0.9179855585,
0.5719173551,
0.4180877805,
-0.2160313129,
-0.0483582504,
-0.4084481597,
-0.3745954037,
0.2935162187,
0.0711545944,
-0.8119004965,
-0.425211221,
-0.9633260965,
0.144877851,
-0.2263504714,
1.0807961226,
-0.0103054959,
0.1743651927,
-0.051125776,
0.1962479353,
-0.2763222456,
-0.3445801735,
-0.5968773365,
-0.4324145615,
0.6278250217,
0.0553369001,
0.8534321189,
-0.1416043043,
0.6764053702,
0.2274193466,
-0.2725906372,
0.0802420899,
-0.6932672262,
0.0343091674,
-0.1538662612,
-0.2304248661,
-0.2003181875,
-0.2066774219,
0.1723898649,
0.2754664421,
0.2659234107,
0.2987467349,
0.2666493952,
0.3151077628,
-0.7358918786,
0.2245962024,
-0.5007828474,
0.1164033934,
0.1707159579,
-0.2277975529,
-0.358078897,
-0.6695752144,
0.0342749842,
-0.4285571277,
0.3469196558,
-0.556125164,
0.9254155159,
0.7791799903,
-0.6213915944,
-0.2710939944,
-1.2250066996,
0.6255327463,
-0.6851553321,
0.3903891742,
0.3825320899,
0.4648909569,
0.0945430472,
-0.4428924322,
-0.4590311348,
0.1897813678,
-0.1998873949,
0.193199411,
-0.1719021797,
-0.2089442313,
0.2907774746,
0.2642634511,
-0.3624163866,
0.0528479554,
-0.3781594038,
-0.2428107262,
0.5776035786,
-0.1571402997,
0.2063230723,
-0.4953339994,
-0.2064012438,
-0.3640903831,
-0.0853671432,
0.15576002,
0.0641451329,
0.3411203921,
-0.181818381,
0.4555620849,
0.2636519969,
0.2000615895,
0.1517991126,
-0.1554346979,
0.3543388546,
0.0234436989,
-0.1795323938,
0.0050960323,
0.7340914607,
0.6633556485,
0.2858827412,
0.1391004473,
-0.2542513311,
0.4252031446,
0.5450602174,
-0.7973726988,
-0.4395991564,
-0.0046041766,
-0.4547882974,
-0.2374151349,
-0.2024913877,
-0.9663355947,
-0.8434535265,
-0.2754650712,
0.5509940386,
-0.5041728616,
-0.3945336342,
-0.0652843118,
-0.0040819626,
0.1191647053,
0.1997124851,
-0.3943678439,
0.1527177989,
0.5537984967,
0.8026297092,
0.2022987753,
0.2728806734,
-0.1725949496,
-0.2856328487,
-0.1298860461,
0.8341341019,
-0.349177897,
-0.3192411959,
0.2334837168,
0.3857112527,
-0.0530773588,
-0.2437616587,
1.1569699049,
-0.4404969513,
-0.1237847507,
-0.3199786246,
-0.3727398217,
-0.1415804029,
0.1022011861,
-0.9559203386,
1.2425667048,
0.1803759336,
-0.8032357693,
0.1704361886,
-0.448970437,
-0.5516079068,
-0.0872856453,
0.2721453011,
-0.5367047191,
0.3492530882,
0.5070802569,
0.6777918935,
-0.3035338521,
0.408339709,
-0.6678546667,
-0.4029517174,
0.4990709424,
-0.4176622629,
0.5021488667,
0.2578307986,
-0.1208296418,
-0.0634328499,
-0.744499445,
-0.1144141927,
-0.0106419064,
-0.075818181,
-0.5511812568,
0.1648004651,
0.4877555966,
0.5010079741,
-0.1561075598,
-0.6105390191,
-0.390593648,
-0.0672386512,
0.433339119,
0.6258943677,
0.0976229608,
0.0885451958,
-0.1972611398,
0.4027435482,
0.164756909,
0.2802042663,
0.00394003,
-0.4246719182,
-0.5030728579,
-0.4340859652,
0.1574730426,
0.6738633513,
-0.7066926956,
0.7196021676,
-0.2979780436,
-0.8887284994,
-0.7324891686,
-0.0210061129,
0.054013107,
0.419131875,
0.6409051418,
-0.2052518129,
-0.5632532239,
-0.7189573646,
-0.3978486955,
0.2352449,
-0.2431464493,
0.3408598006,
0.1938584596,
-0.5333783031,
0.7178531885,
-0.5885753632,
-0.3246273696,
-0.0138315372,
0.4925936759,
0.2713720202,
0.2405325323,
0.4370225966,
-0.9286344647,
-0.4461430311,
-0.3204967678,
-0.610298872,
-0.2497518957,
-0.2201569229,
-0.0681472048,
-0.1692870706,
0.1390760243,
-0.6237525344,
0.4428627193,
0.5965208411,
-0.0840203464,
0.3726532757,
-0.0240544807,
0.0645986646,
-1.0735503435,
-0.0894406438,
0.6698552966,
-0.3706703484,
-0.8240970373,
-0.5371206999,
0.213192597,
-0.3596866429,
-0.3588701487,
0.251167655,
-0.0750780478,
0.2037865669,
-0.3900663853,
0.1617789567,
0.1486344934,
0.2096484751,
-0.2456144542,
0.2053825557,
0.6195932031,
-0.4249051809,
0.253862083,
0.2521369159,
-0.3680927753,
0.5830315948,
-0.5929142833,
-0.0638269633,
-0.4896753728,
0.5197618008,
-1.2470600605,
-0.2326799631,
0.1950103045,
-0.3182588518,
0.2169186622,
0.2815546095,
-0.5046958327,
-0.7202553153,
-0.1427077055,
0.4066691697,
0.4891456366,
-0.3230881691,
0.7390376329,
0.3742022812,
-0.1620025337,
-0.1516247094,
-0.6269826889,
-0.1625545472,
-0.2566875219,
-0.4554643929,
0.6437119842,
0.101146102,
0.1355358064,
0.1622760892,
-0.1474414915,
-0.2995029688,
0.0546489954,
0.5153458714,
0.2633106411,
-0.1002677903,
0.5156232715,
0.0396406539,
-0.0475685671,
0.0484283902,
0.3226757348,
0.4708629251,
0.0079017542,
-0.0695484728,
-0.7576451302,
0.2254806608,
0.5363423824,
-0.1631712019,
0.8779290318,
1.16079247,
-0.7503732443,
0.0161581319,
-0.8298428655,
-0.4410481751,
-0.4337210655,
0.1449144185,
-0.2182321399,
-0.7193241119,
0.4533753693,
-0.485668093,
-0.3919600248,
0.4794717133,
0.6097313762,
-0.203322947,
0.9739519358,
0.879344821,
-0.1128780693,
0.6180061102,
0.0458634272,
0.6314817667,
-0.6043453217,
0.1609797776,
-0.3198076487,
-0.531248033,
-0.5956755877,
-0.4534092247,
0.4421693683,
-0.0168364514,
-0.1873390675,
0.5536683798,
-0.5695998669,
0.0685976669,
0.2818682194,
0.6078534126,
0.081959419,
-0.2364700735,
0.2425106019,
-0.29923141,
-0.2577220201,
-0.4797318578,
0.6911023855,
0.4631320536,
1.1013925076,
-0.3090615571,
0.2650027573,
0.3790676892,
0.6177503467,
-0.7252737284,
0.1782408208,
-0.2011306882,
-0.7129324079,
-0.0736279935,
-0.4432718158,
-0.5186886787,
-0.1127875522,
-0.3837019503,
-0.7507415414,
0.4954486191,
0.1077058613,
-0.6788441539,
0.0444339514,
-0.8198019266,
0.9178988338,
-0.3828268647,
0.0208742358,
-0.2000153661,
-0.7243455648,
0.3690928817,
-0.4789181054,
0.4404452443,
-0.3774537146,
0.5503929853,
0.5327137113,
0.1532411128,
1.1551600695,
-0.1844628602,
-0.1743111908,
0.1130378917,
-0.2182449847,
0.4360171854,
-0.0358874314,
-0.1858599484,
-0.1549859643,
0.3386051655,
-0.0874443874,
-0.7532603145,
0.5713851452,
-0.9998198748,
-0.2270519435,
-0.0284937788,
-0.7305229902,
-0.2449003309,
0.1104849949,
0.1435139924,
0.2312436253,
-0.2269525826,
0.2950344384,
0.3999087811,
-0.5603764653,
0.2717258632,
0.1827254295,
-0.1350698769,
-0.4453594685,
0.6426891088,
0.0918772817,
-0.0264455117,
0.308986485,
0.1938655972,
-0.3103865087,
0.4819273055,
0.3538856208,
0.4737325013,
-0.8700274229,
-0.3360043168,
-0.6905473471,
-0.3939827681,
-0.5972397923,
-0.0661258623,
-0.5650753379,
-0.3435023129,
-0.4337147474,
-0.2551032007,
0.4452016354,
0.3718999326,
-0.182543844,
0.4849659801,
-0.8289758563,
0.5787286162,
0.0272859354,
0.4328954518,
-0.1462343335,
-0.211768508,
-0.2634650469,
0.2327269614,
-0.6659868956,
-1.2039217949,
0.2314337194,
0.4132490754,
0.2111017406,
0.5205093026,
0.471847862,
0.7370817661,
-0.2121222764,
0.2952718735,
0.1667204052,
-0.856377542,
0.6192960739,
0.1261947006,
0.0486763977,
0.5324578285,
1.0034993887,
-0.8254535794,
-0.1860719025,
-0.3817414343,
-0.7016009092,
0.5080745816,
0.1470282972,
0.3981436789,
0.0107007902,
0.4022408724,
-0.0085410038,
-0.1055625826,
-0.8402441144,
-0.1094008386,
-0.6336077452,
-0.3702836335,
-0.3329432011,
-0.3224703968,
-0.1099454612,
-0.4381470978,
0.6831037998,
0.0296052508,
0.510825634,
0.1631892622,
-0.3157527447,
-0.2726484835,
0.1615210176,
0.1712824255,
0.182856366,
-0.3680280447,
0.3594869673,
-0.0266403724,
-0.1365071386,
0.1801987886,
0.51496315,
-0.1706220955,
0.2608554065,
0.0826249421,
1.0890231133,
0.4400683641,
-0.4568270147,
0.5330911279,
-0.1051750183,
-0.0950343236,
-0.2893152833,
-0.1734628975,
0.1052251756,
0.5966498852,
0.1749946177,
0.0836342201,
0.0399463549,
-0.343614608,
0.3570232689,
0.311663121,
-0.815764308,
-0.6319679618,
0.6188576221,
0.0559149981,
-0.5457953811,
0.2980629802,
-0.0082151107,
-0.6251314878,
0.4046140313,
0.6596217752,
0.8810063601,
-0.6015664935,
0.619756937,
0.3602403998,
0.3865202963,
-0.2008094639,
0.3917433918,
0.0850272477,
-0.8969219327,
-0.3806491494,
-0.7422905564,
-0.1892036051,
0.3199697435,
-0.8526452184,
0.4582298994,
-0.1195285544,
-0.9341598749,
0.1191534325,
-0.2621649504,
-0.9358956814,
0.4287228882,
0.4566317201,
0.7627906203,
-1.3680909872,
0.6127571464,
0.6512048244,
-0.0822517052,
-0.6206778884,
0.1618972123,
0.0716051981,
-0.3409782648,
0.3948952854,
0.6439464092,
0.0598328486,
0.1701594293,
-0.106230706,
-0.8358792663,
0.8931548595,
0.3808082938,
-0.1849246323,
-0.1295265853,
0.4048279524,
0.8237455487,
-0.0818208754,
0.4254010916,
0.3665750921,
0.5849891901,
0.05052156,
-0.6179673672,
0.2138800025,
-0.3968273997,
0.2629050314,
0.105855912,
-0.3080817461,
0.618499577,
0.2459996939,
-0.4524993598,
-0.4896464944,
0.4498202503,
-0.217450127,
0.1036392301,
0.6270390153,
0.587608397,
0.6595342755,
-0.126036495,
0.8855974078,
-0.5181101561,
0.8781648278,
0.8882418275,
-0.3143607378,
0.6729771495,
0.3025152981,
0.038582515,
0.4542398751,
0.7888665199,
-0.2847573757,
0.6141726971,
0.0061453185,
-0.2471723258,
-0.3143883944,
-0.386995554,
-0.207469523,
0.1172773317,
0.5733711123,
-0.6978188753,
-0.5406832695,
0.4697305858,
-0.0318871997,
-0.2509963214,
0.0450445712,
0.4497422278,
0.3672856092,
-0.4948472977,
0.6033527255,
-0.0796743706,
0.478944093,
-0.1223094314,
0.3890439868,
0.1036455706,
0.5477516651,
-0.180613935,
-0.4952913523,
0.6470006108,
0.0640356839,
-0.0834327489,
-0.3749855757,
1.1837049723,
-0.2567732334,
-1.071421504,
0.7523212433,
0.5689927936,
-0.0951383635,
-0.345155865,
-0.4947630763,
0.1097003967,
-0.5083758235,
-0.443628937,
-0.0325240679,
0.4960692227,
0.2632237375,
0.4984538257,
0.3231615126,
-0.1413220167,
0.0822910666,
0.2789245546,
0.9324762225,
-0.4442513585,
-0.1025338769,
-0.9119951725,
0.576469183,
-0.0240936484,
-0.1433242559,
0.4828881025,
0.1011825874,
0.5311149359,
-0.1751051843,
0.7324025035,
-0.1593662351,
0.5059862733,
0.0194556769,
0.6231884956,
-0.6493642926,
-0.1906472147,
-0.7130257487,
-0.8288900852,
-0.5533691049,
0.6685784459,
-0.6262270212,
-0.1722986996,
0.6696833372,
1.0036236048,
-0.2463808507,
0.200908944,
0.0760143995,
0.314483732,
0.4146939218,
0.5306118131,
0.6832344532,
-0.5395612121,
0.4705785215,
-0.6584473252,
-0.4275531471,
-0.3048469424,
-0.8383313417,
-0.9421907663,
-0.6997784972,
-0.2814674079,
-0.2450469285,
-0.1909094006,
0.7517223358,
0.4125544131,
-0.6613221765,
0.1860675216,
0.2756208479,
0.0707511902,
-0.4766009748,
-0.2450522333,
0.2860457599,
-0.180141598,
-0.3267296553,
0.0485501662,
0.0245218165,
-0.0325531662,
-0.0617236421,
0.4097472429,
-0.194225356,
0.2278314382,
0.6538302898,
-0.1239778474,
-0.5128720999,
-0.3572633266,
0.0582788512,
-0.2007630318,
0.1996306926,
0.6019552946,
-0.5473140478,
0.217480123,
0.4507036805,
0.8227659464,
0.6092612743,
0.217328921,
0.2900847197,
-0.6017961502,
-0.0968306065,
0.0272831712,
0.2774824202,
0.5443807244,
-0.5632642508,
0.2406568676,
0.1047708839,
-0.6217991114,
-0.7583510876,
0.1416470259,
-0.7594627738,
-0.1145874783,
0.8588625789,
-0.1319807917,
-0.1573625803,
0.0768882111,
-0.2200018913,
0.968859911,
-0.1687011272,
1.3191803694,
0.9241774082,
0.0528487787,
-0.3365125358,
-0.6099655628,
0.3297550082,
0.2588962018,
-0.7469774485,
-0.0608508699,
0.1466056108,
0.0031062039,
0.483535856,
0.3305912614,
0.1110058054,
0.0113996174,
-0.4669646919,
0.1350540668,
0.4440146387,
-0.1364219636,
-0.1919558495,
0.1092729568,
-0.4739379883,
0.1729738116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16784v1 | Incorporating Distributions of Discourse Structure for Long Document Abstractive Summarization | 2023-05-26T09:51:47 | 2023-05-26T09:51:47 | Dongqi Pu, Yifan Wang, Vera Demberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | For text summarization, the role of discourse structure is pivotal in
discerning the core content of a text. Regrettably, prior studies on
incorporating Rhetorical Structure Theory (RST) into transformer-based
summarization models only consider the nuclearity annotation, thereby
overlooking the variety of discourse relation types. This paper introduces the
'RSTformer', a novel summarization model that comprehensively incorporates both
the types and uncertainty of rhetorical relations. Our RST-attention mechanism,
rooted in document-level rhetorical structure, is an extension of the recently
devised Longformer framework. Through rigorous evaluation, the model proposed
herein exhibits significant superiority over state-of-the-art models, as
evidenced by its notable performance on several automatic metrics and human
evaluation. | [
-0.4018553793,
-0.4199284017,
0.4659086168,
0.2512266636,
-0.4085844159,
0.0419881344,
-0.0162846521,
-0.1663016379,
0.2026871443,
0.3762750924,
-0.1584168971,
-0.2753446698,
-0.9834099412,
0.1765809953,
-0.5167242289,
1.3239078522,
0.0957347527,
-0.3808226883,
0.0292675942,
-0.1365874559,
0.0650090799,
-0.5339137912,
-0.2831519246,
-0.6223878264,
0.8732923865,
0.0761157721,
0.8025290966,
0.6863170862,
0.6773098707,
0.3049457073,
-0.4919598997,
-0.3647623658,
-0.5701985955,
0.3904099762,
-0.5068362951,
-0.5521751046,
-0.4069381654,
-0.3301742077,
0.8889710903,
0.7342961431,
-0.0621245839,
0.1216397211,
0.2083021402,
0.8117451668,
-0.6020972729,
0.1740893573,
-0.092638582,
0.0793161094,
-0.1714776456,
-0.3329605162,
-0.7119070888,
-0.3778344691,
0.3127692938,
-0.1446442455,
0.3362676203,
0.0943819806,
0.601629734,
0.1064316109,
-0.8456351757,
-0.2699671388,
-0.8834579587,
0.6455316544,
-0.5129702091,
0.3049986064,
0.0110425204,
0.3068163991,
0.0073328838,
-0.6873957515,
0.0094985943,
-0.1359448582,
-0.5071036816,
0.317907989,
-0.3221195936,
0.4372027218,
0.0346228629,
0.7377305627,
-0.6335631013,
-0.216797173,
-0.6061440706,
0.1541527957,
0.2664006352,
-0.024307169,
0.0584832877,
-0.6285097599,
-0.6177150607,
0.1240064725,
-0.3783369064,
-0.0925884992,
0.328168869,
0.3171718717,
-0.3170220554,
0.8553775549,
-0.0923994184,
0.4495075047,
0.2995345891,
-0.0786123872,
-0.337348938,
-0.1165442318,
-0.1447770745,
0.0985830054,
0.828312695,
0.3139694333,
0.1234039441,
-0.0252494868,
-0.2161336094,
-0.0431019701,
0.2001302689,
-1.0064058304,
-0.3039016426,
0.2807684541,
-0.7478419542,
-0.5972543955,
0.124951005,
-0.6389217973,
-0.0848833099,
0.0031490661,
-0.18184641,
-0.5598658323,
-0.4253396094,
-0.0115229366,
-0.443210125,
0.2241142243,
-0.0613181368,
-0.8721736073,
0.7158225179,
0.908922255,
1.1001260281,
-0.4339977205,
-0.0752161592,
-0.2297063172,
0.5105943084,
-0.1028518975,
1.4184646606,
-0.6661508083,
-0.5926891565,
-0.1607854664,
-0.2423479706,
-0.1841466725,
-0.033913251,
0.797829926,
-0.4891659915,
0.6791740656,
-0.0953051001,
-0.6737390161,
-0.353233546,
0.2612384856,
-0.7545952201,
0.9652309418,
0.5188057423,
-1.1844204664,
-0.0629177243,
-0.6826431155,
-0.6811189055,
0.0350029469,
-0.1338447332,
-0.5115876198,
0.3787671328,
0.0364565924,
0.4168478549,
-0.2182959169,
0.4119955599,
0.0089108171,
-0.410906136,
0.4254088998,
-0.2158183157,
0.5444016457,
0.1882662624,
-0.1161141619,
0.3899235725,
-0.7295627594,
-0.2611956596,
-0.1247809231,
-0.1808443964,
-0.3196941316,
0.0547532924,
0.3463020623,
0.189551428,
-0.1810402274,
0.0198167618,
-0.1857907623,
-0.816198349,
0.581359446,
0.4512945712,
0.4662536085,
0.9067907929,
-0.4648026526,
0.911265552,
-0.2515737712,
-0.2447775453,
-0.5926728249,
-0.1390119195,
-0.494094342,
-0.3977352679,
0.4276394546,
0.515835464,
-0.1662816107,
0.460079819,
-0.4828646481,
-0.4826876819,
0.1297959685,
-0.569434762,
0.6864501238,
0.3335708678,
0.0050133658,
-0.1171755642,
-0.5172668695,
-1.0027133226,
-0.3188171089,
-0.1678044647,
-0.0720950738,
-0.3288131356,
0.5167644024,
0.4457890093,
0.7772222757,
-0.7630783916,
-0.2062776238,
-0.8484746814,
0.5694221258,
0.0579225644,
0.203977704,
0.7288029194,
-0.6575699449,
-0.3239918649,
-0.1376207918,
-0.3773695529,
0.1890598983,
-0.1410814673,
-0.0549391955,
0.0069377562,
0.3897435665,
-0.926068604,
0.3696905673,
0.1380528659,
-0.0988108441,
0.3999833167,
-0.0330521129,
0.1425407082,
-1.4815765619,
0.1924386322,
0.0255985372,
-0.2859432995,
-0.5286819935,
0.1954453588,
0.1390807927,
-0.3695148528,
-0.210081622,
0.3002072275,
-0.5518846512,
-0.2133598477,
-0.4157221317,
0.1493797004,
0.1816209108,
0.4739968777,
0.0725510716,
0.582978189,
0.0901836827,
-0.3655802906,
-0.2514702976,
0.2274281383,
0.0711292103,
1.0434356928,
-1.0681573153,
-0.2744650245,
-0.6190247536,
0.6826356053,
-1.414970994,
-0.4981364608,
0.2768087685,
-0.5208560228,
0.3341489732,
-0.5047045946,
-0.1090775728,
-0.2535629272,
-0.5786014199,
0.5097871423,
0.2881434858,
0.2079028189,
1.0431705713,
0.2879723012,
-0.5780206323,
-0.6646696925,
-0.6308244467,
0.1205019951,
-0.3290886581,
-0.496381402,
0.5266408324,
0.3124054968,
-0.389944911,
-0.049446363,
-0.1852964312,
0.0468253456,
-0.0791808367,
0.3847594857,
0.113167651,
-0.4323287308,
0.0610319711,
0.3669841588,
-0.4073392451,
0.2284515202,
-0.0012389268,
0.3913035393,
0.2120353729,
-0.1226259172,
-0.4854176342,
0.6865000129,
0.5783168077,
-0.5714485645,
0.4641845524,
0.2797608972,
-0.2768059373,
-0.1933923662,
-0.4150041044,
-0.2467854023,
-0.3944355249,
0.6155029535,
-0.2285462916,
-0.8689000607,
0.6160072684,
0.0823923275,
0.1042603031,
0.6650748849,
0.2205290347,
-0.0338630974,
0.7806975245,
0.7024251223,
0.0087092454,
0.4126256108,
0.0158553179,
0.3111567497,
-0.7626524568,
0.0727238581,
-0.7012090683,
-0.2204030603,
-0.3760326207,
-0.3917264938,
0.3021883965,
-0.2144110948,
-0.1117309481,
0.2425308377,
-0.7794086933,
0.6937805414,
0.0285273083,
-0.2822315097,
0.362350136,
-0.1093914732,
0.365570575,
-0.1107816771,
-0.4864611626,
-0.581771791,
0.6892277598,
0.4985423088,
0.6161530614,
0.1579038501,
0.8568786383,
0.1137469187,
0.4837172925,
-1.0090078115,
0.4325282872,
0.0666712895,
-0.5342813134,
-0.2071363181,
-0.3033913076,
-0.7926160693,
0.7038778663,
0.0914366394,
-0.4337400198,
0.1560145915,
0.0203821771,
-0.5318023562,
-0.0159982685,
-0.468995899,
0.5188999176,
0.1565490365,
0.0890136808,
-0.1662501395,
-0.8342869878,
0.7245186567,
0.3652807474,
0.3518607318,
-0.1398835629,
-0.0729625672,
0.7933499813,
-0.0538876913,
0.7487347722,
0.1433575004,
-0.0927711278,
0.1608593613,
0.2834341228,
0.6593720913,
0.1159201488,
0.0115638338,
-0.4378303587,
-0.0602320544,
-0.1959721595,
-0.7859336734,
0.3549498022,
-0.4561714232,
-0.4135099351,
-0.9377376437,
-0.6444357038,
0.1544981599,
0.4582893848,
0.4099870324,
0.5951253176,
-0.581720531,
0.2111595571,
0.8552086949,
0.312204361,
0.2427107245,
0.1827836335,
-0.2101633549,
-0.756198287,
0.4027495086,
0.1383518875,
0.2658667862,
0.7999426126,
0.2790422142,
-0.2461519688,
-0.6445028186,
0.0303594396,
0.4280316234,
-0.875484705,
-0.2562453747,
-1.0240736008,
-0.4689060748,
-0.4344920516,
-0.4980744421,
-0.2926773727,
-0.8268056512,
-0.2345379442,
-0.5024396777,
0.237156719,
0.985135138,
0.2683639526,
0.6112329364,
-0.4664339423,
0.4588585198,
0.0075566224,
0.2259472609,
0.1231014282,
-0.7831648588,
0.0584274903,
-0.3458732367,
-0.462828517,
-0.9519447684,
0.2979337275,
0.2198137045,
0.3464857638,
0.4237854183,
0.1658670604,
0.4462404847,
-0.4096468687,
0.6690613031,
0.2811873853,
-0.8324402571,
0.4507838488,
-0.8195941448,
0.6356224418,
0.5209581852,
0.2975896895,
-0.5814779401,
-0.7471221685,
-0.5054562688,
-0.9956303835,
0.4989054501,
0.3757096529,
0.1027710959,
-0.1373301297,
0.2667064965,
0.0242462736,
-0.0999988168,
-0.8275009394,
-0.1675904095,
-0.1819470823,
-0.3505189419,
0.0742686316,
-0.789991498,
-0.3070249557,
0.1439800709,
0.4601724148,
0.0340261981,
0.2151473761,
0.1559908539,
-0.2578508556,
-0.0111433081,
0.780700624,
1.0792921782,
0.9021921754,
-0.3647151887,
0.572527647,
-0.1459769309,
-0.3436493576,
0.2151762694,
0.3144487441,
-0.1893827617,
0.1706595123,
0.4699097872,
0.4068713188,
1.028847456,
-0.014881487,
0.5183362961,
-0.064959541,
-0.3410282135,
-0.3973077536,
-0.179554686,
0.3645109832,
0.1767320633,
0.5448949933,
0.2328910381,
0.4517510831,
-0.238091588,
0.4350914955,
0.1553948075,
-0.4480831623,
-0.5057321191,
0.7398923635,
0.1936531514,
-0.3849324584,
-0.0412112251,
-0.0439732447,
-0.4944805503,
0.462230742,
0.7194060683,
0.8983849287,
-0.4358829856,
0.4812810421,
0.3304976225,
0.220430389,
-0.3571746945,
0.1292187124,
-0.1159724146,
-0.0363527797,
-0.6214647293,
-0.340447247,
-0.4875599146,
-0.3800533116,
-0.931948185,
0.2131907344,
-0.329962194,
-0.1997499317,
0.2758570611,
-0.5446400642,
0.1252522022,
-0.0640856028,
-0.0564253442,
0.6468690634,
-0.6199670434,
0.2908382714,
0.2373222113,
-0.298114717,
-0.3327656686,
-0.0470245518,
-0.0400028825,
-0.2156628221,
0.4457677901,
0.1873265207,
-0.5284131169,
-0.1083163247,
-0.0396134146,
-1.1932901144,
0.9520995021,
0.3334335089,
-0.3215874732,
-0.376085639,
0.1556487232,
0.5175954103,
-0.3301132023,
0.4117271304,
0.2205909044,
0.3407755494,
0.2344200313,
-0.5010907054,
0.2093669921,
-0.0598951466,
0.2199944258,
0.6733965874,
-0.5680515766,
0.7191813588,
-0.089809835,
-0.4829469323,
-0.1221070215,
1.0922048092,
0.2256636024,
0.0544348992,
0.1203431934,
0.2124256194,
0.4683450758,
0.0425000712,
0.8051741719,
-0.5342893004,
0.4042744935,
1.4527301788,
-0.145834133,
0.8418136835,
0.3836595714,
-0.2386599481,
0.5586284399,
0.1824648082,
0.190268293,
0.3563981652,
0.2078365386,
-0.0711985826,
0.1032921895,
0.049835898,
-0.4932817817,
0.4335857034,
0.3060796559,
-0.7094644308,
-0.6467584968,
-0.1209240258,
0.2262644619,
0.3659316003,
-0.1165075377,
0.7965046763,
0.4088157713,
-0.7498018742,
0.4574349821,
0.1432821602,
0.6137684584,
-0.6374605298,
0.1366309673,
0.0041636648,
0.0574754141,
-0.2523456216,
-0.8242562413,
0.7454856038,
-0.2318609655,
-0.4074901342,
-0.3374536335,
0.8814198375,
-0.3984708786,
-0.7510483265,
0.0064868047,
0.1892893761,
-0.2347677648,
-0.12791951,
-0.2936863601,
0.0580811091,
-0.3465389609,
-0.492954433,
0.3032808304,
0.4575842321,
0.0711080357,
0.4593432248,
0.2166594118,
-0.254780978,
-0.4022969604,
-0.0064050485,
0.8943800926,
-0.7712523341,
-0.9839120507,
-0.9704521894,
0.5759911537,
-0.2468252331,
-0.4012440443,
0.6633430123,
0.8291251659,
0.1143297404,
0.0386020131,
0.8249557614,
0.116128087,
0.6411904693,
-0.0883327276,
0.9790503383,
0.1626523584,
-0.2089008391,
-0.3206116557,
-1.0647666454,
-0.519944489,
0.5648132563,
-0.4645148814,
-0.1856430322,
0.9765843153,
0.4328867197,
-0.2744802237,
0.2842829525,
0.0774344876,
-0.0591691397,
0.2341573238,
0.3406244516,
0.6611950994,
-0.4492797852,
0.6374402642,
-0.2523110509,
-0.1772353053,
-0.098740913,
-0.863119185,
-1.2779313326,
-0.7765910625,
-0.2299201936,
-0.2535353005,
0.1220472753,
0.8180257082,
0.4451669157,
-0.6735235453,
-0.3752241135,
0.0320029408,
0.1806460321,
-0.0283826869,
-0.2569492757,
0.6019772887,
-0.1291911155,
-0.3135811687,
0.0913401544,
0.6651187539,
0.2852423787,
-0.1920901686,
0.4582394958,
-0.0052694436,
0.3831863701,
0.7855868936,
0.1353503466,
-0.6226249933,
-0.2892456651,
-0.1130171865,
-0.1205437705,
0.2557086051,
1.0418753624,
-0.2309627831,
-0.1232385263,
0.4835283458,
0.1942723393,
0.4576480389,
0.3784535527,
0.7982109785,
-0.6890926957,
0.2996668518,
0.5224482417,
0.254760325,
0.295052588,
-0.4834269881,
0.283844769,
-0.2260932326,
-0.5269719362,
-1.0611200333,
0.4437518716,
-1.165247798,
-0.1459835619,
1.0046573877,
0.0826568156,
-0.5144004822,
-0.1910903305,
-0.3385010958,
0.206548959,
-0.5439450741,
0.811390996,
0.7714723349,
-0.0053068115,
-0.6241297126,
-0.0491252877,
0.5087313652,
0.1471282989,
-0.742179811,
0.4096692801,
0.4086761177,
0.3380601406,
0.2113195211,
0.7149859667,
-0.258513242,
0.2202717811,
-0.1780586541,
-0.1801837534,
-0.0140066156,
-0.0618883632,
-0.2962338626,
0.8613700867,
0.0030863697,
0.3180770874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16768v1 | Towards a Common Understanding of Contributing Factors for Cross-Lingual Transfer in Multilingual Language Models: A Review | 2023-05-26T09:31:12 | 2023-05-26T09:31:12 | Fred Philippy, Siwen Guo, Shohreh Haddadan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, pre-trained Multilingual Language Models (MLLMs) have shown
a strong ability to transfer knowledge across different languages. However,
given that the aspiration for such an ability has not been explicitly
incorporated in the design of the majority of MLLMs, it is challenging to
obtain a unique and straightforward explanation for its emergence. In this
review paper, we survey literature that investigates different factors
contributing to the capacity of MLLMs to perform zero-shot cross-lingual
transfer and subsequently outline and discuss these factors in detail. To
enhance the structure of this review and to facilitate consolidation with
future studies, we identify five categories of such factors. In addition to
providing a summary of empirical evidence from past studies, we identify
consensuses among studies with consistent findings and resolve conflicts among
contradictory ones. Our work contextualizes and unifies existing research
streams which aim at explaining the cross-lingual potential of MLLMs. This
review provides, first, an aligned reference point for future research and,
second, guidance for a better-informed and more efficient way of leveraging the
cross-lingual capacity of MLLMs. | [
-0.5603358746,
-0.3302717507,
0.3330907822,
0.2592434883,
0.017232826,
0.0556451231,
-0.1151591316,
-0.826572597,
0.0137061616,
0.3204116225,
-0.2691016793,
0.0948842689,
-0.7578879595,
0.293490082,
-0.4520354867,
0.8905590773,
-0.3475542963,
0.0527518876,
-0.0387487225,
-0.3906477094,
-0.5461139083,
-0.9429976344,
-0.2461669445,
-0.4804896116,
0.871845305,
0.287596941,
0.3144329786,
0.0061260588,
0.1874965131,
0.109452948,
0.2558337152,
-0.2638781071,
-0.6134341955,
-0.1807885468,
-0.264226526,
-0.4504405856,
-0.3119106889,
-0.0619029403,
0.8630359769,
1.0050164461,
0.2100107223,
0.1016306728,
0.2687139809,
0.5428283215,
-0.7439848185,
-0.3067161441,
-0.5498231649,
0.2572298944,
-0.2726435065,
-0.1829426736,
-0.4669182897,
0.0229883417,
0.3196614087,
-0.596167028,
-0.0415139087,
-0.1133506671,
0.6821196675,
-0.3227101266,
-0.8294401169,
-0.2158507705,
-0.9327008128,
0.9591687918,
-0.6067298055,
0.6857805848,
0.1411269456,
0.1230290905,
0.4246029258,
-0.3694256246,
-0.3861376345,
-0.1678407937,
-0.3020383418,
-0.2160751224,
-0.1056333706,
-0.2472267747,
0.1306458563,
0.1142774448,
-0.6769145131,
0.1808774471,
-0.5816096663,
-0.2042843699,
0.5386639833,
0.0522605516,
0.5743727684,
0.2244615704,
-0.5688917637,
0.1448143423,
-0.9441877007,
0.3060502708,
0.1171904877,
0.4193980992,
-0.2032724768,
0.4592800438,
-0.0004223717,
0.7906603217,
-0.1779466122,
0.0432814956,
0.1957918108,
-1.0145951509,
-0.0932737663,
0.1888852715,
0.6444644332,
0.2440270782,
0.658896029,
-0.2045031935,
-0.0084584076,
-0.403708905,
0.1464270651,
-0.7981801033,
0.2701197863,
-0.185766235,
-0.318223536,
0.0543030128,
0.0878206491,
-0.4824706316,
0.0921768025,
-0.3742254376,
0.3557283282,
-0.1749759316,
-0.7010254264,
0.0218628999,
-0.1267885268,
0.4038251042,
0.2181871384,
-0.9645827413,
0.217430383,
0.3938471973,
0.7117941976,
-0.512121141,
-0.8627512455,
-0.1645300537,
0.2056382895,
-0.5342210531,
0.6510674357,
-0.3082424998,
-0.227607131,
0.4150156677,
0.2775926292,
-0.5135000348,
-0.0177197754,
0.0950608626,
-0.3370768428,
0.4483086765,
-0.6997942924,
-0.319922775,
-0.5902525783,
0.3275896907,
-0.4573084116,
0.7203329802,
0.0372193344,
-0.7243308425,
0.4850833416,
-0.4457754195,
-0.7923263311,
-0.0947241411,
-0.056861978,
0.0559767522,
0.2323526591,
0.1275748461,
0.4998105168,
-0.1978173107,
0.1232350841,
-0.4371191859,
-0.2079406232,
0.3428235948,
-0.4587728083,
1.2085268497,
0.0463246554,
-0.2367248684,
0.1054292843,
-0.4662106633,
-0.0045360457,
-0.0198024437,
-0.1729336679,
-0.5330558419,
-0.559268117,
0.2087488323,
0.5704346895,
0.1272883713,
-0.3422348797,
-0.0457353666,
-0.1029532105,
0.043426536,
0.2702477574,
-0.1199597567,
0.8152140379,
-0.3363180459,
0.7113173604,
-0.0026107971,
0.2436070442,
-0.1047856957,
-0.2218552381,
-0.5930524468,
0.1324507147,
0.4399847388,
0.581348598,
-0.7626060247,
-0.2976792753,
-0.0863205492,
-0.4362572432,
-0.7071794868,
0.3716908097,
0.448333323,
0.2411803305,
0.2905088067,
-0.4949130118,
-0.4896958768,
-0.7939882278,
-0.2597819567,
-0.0664602369,
0.4247408211,
0.3121017516,
0.2139539272,
0.0653344467,
0.6545200944,
0.1741615534,
-0.2758018672,
-0.5702217817,
0.0372628719,
-0.0077846511,
0.3924898803,
1.1465044022,
-0.6335764527,
-0.9784101248,
0.4847216904,
-0.8211484551,
-0.3392431736,
-0.287248373,
0.0318404362,
0.5190308094,
0.5726257563,
-0.5884600878,
0.3602215946,
0.856349647,
-0.3821154535,
0.6818135381,
-0.1548314393,
0.2809917033,
-0.6887141466,
0.41038692,
-0.3060790002,
-0.0906285793,
-1.1903533936,
0.0052551529,
0.0690605268,
0.121300973,
-0.9010181427,
0.892526567,
-0.8042102456,
-0.2455468178,
-0.1750315875,
0.240602389,
-0.0102542024,
0.5374003649,
-0.0874286294,
0.4186680913,
0.7071720362,
-0.700599432,
0.1438360959,
-0.0466247164,
-0.0705476031,
0.6721923351,
-0.6198575497,
-0.085428521,
0.1194188446,
0.0292400196,
-0.8503625989,
0.4401428998,
0.4944811761,
-0.3137592077,
0.5759516358,
-0.2692439258,
-0.0564415976,
-0.0179105774,
-0.004945226,
0.5393975973,
0.167362541,
-0.0219822004,
0.3753860593,
0.2050620019,
-0.3953452408,
-0.6884712577,
-0.7950984836,
0.1525818855,
-0.2211461961,
-0.3685394526,
0.2223386168,
-0.0788740963,
-0.2284314334,
0.1980415434,
0.1291458756,
0.0769890994,
0.2054197341,
-0.0759101361,
0.3315959573,
-0.5058650374,
0.0353396647,
-0.1189640835,
-0.1703034937,
-0.099694401,
-0.2973822057,
0.2737546563,
0.0784170255,
-0.5444069505,
-0.1256972402,
0.5807752013,
0.7003878951,
-0.2011116296,
0.7630079389,
0.8789517879,
-0.0395071134,
-0.0148236016,
-0.4130446017,
-0.0153784137,
-0.2526311576,
0.365947932,
-0.6561099291,
-0.8884589076,
0.6237154603,
0.2749875784,
0.2101658732,
0.4666572511,
0.7401778102,
0.2342942953,
0.6294562817,
0.9542030096,
-0.1708157212,
0.5126675367,
0.198660627,
0.2556477189,
-0.8023958206,
-0.0822034404,
-0.509472549,
-0.0363768861,
-0.5050575137,
-0.3653562665,
-0.0294166766,
0.290825963,
0.0648583993,
0.2761599123,
0.1676274389,
0.0251091123,
0.2820924222,
-0.735275805,
0.2920820117,
0.0844060704,
-0.4580092728,
0.0881646723,
-1.1332080364,
-0.142151475,
1.0787727833,
0.2792764008,
0.6052120328,
0.2578389347,
0.2899243832,
-0.0161045305,
0.3160989285,
-0.4216477573,
0.2778991461,
-0.1385930032,
-1.0704957247,
-0.5451375246,
-0.1786692739,
-1.1416356564,
0.6449298859,
-0.298045963,
-0.6295580268,
0.3496980369,
-0.2669484019,
-0.1120632514,
0.2010602504,
-0.5446245074,
0.8727450371,
-0.4869859815,
-0.4835784435,
-0.0744623467,
-0.5487191677,
0.3820710778,
-0.39046368,
0.3726526201,
-0.1320327222,
0.0988350064,
0.4802515805,
0.1298895031,
0.9084547758,
-0.2153545022,
-0.4568473697,
0.2582914233,
0.160047695,
0.0368284918,
-0.4013256431,
0.1162016615,
0.6186415553,
0.3184288442,
-0.5131818056,
-0.5375275016,
0.4725874066,
-0.5964334011,
-0.4798161685,
-0.3180701733,
-0.5805690885,
-0.3525468111,
0.3454241753,
0.0579949468,
0.2599865198,
-0.2542006671,
0.4202347696,
0.2873944938,
-0.098216936,
0.7034534216,
0.8022567034,
-0.8369450569,
-0.0387615301,
0.9117687941,
0.600467205,
0.4830823243,
0.427308023,
-0.0788179114,
-0.2987981439,
-0.6572862864,
-0.7984926105,
0.2493176609,
-0.5298326612,
0.2901657522,
-0.4263785481,
-0.3377247751,
-0.7869626284,
-0.2303548008,
-0.2798379064,
-0.4444032907,
-0.3947991431,
0.0270566791,
-0.0261770282,
0.7052006721,
-0.3716925979,
-0.0330592617,
-1.025701046,
0.0719781741,
0.2727616727,
0.2125309557,
0.3832032084,
-0.7302758098,
-0.5378146172,
0.0784945041,
0.1912864894,
-0.8168562055,
0.4139096141,
0.2235827297,
1.2232815027,
0.2798644006,
0.0328158624,
0.7649925351,
-0.3972683549,
0.7524463534,
0.2407913953,
-0.7668977976,
-0.0128558772,
-0.0196522195,
0.1542835385,
0.2340870649,
0.8823039532,
-0.7356888056,
-0.1744894683,
-0.35692361,
-0.6752445102,
0.5982907414,
0.077486679,
0.0909461826,
0.7184368968,
-0.1418468207,
0.3574567139,
0.0539268628,
-0.9077249169,
-0.1052457169,
-0.0740040615,
0.2682572305,
-0.4835845232,
-0.3192358911,
-0.0904290676,
-0.191978991,
0.5994638205,
-0.1931122839,
-0.1482987553,
0.1832963973,
-0.5857030749,
-0.1413547099,
0.4420655668,
0.9253125787,
0.7622765899,
-0.0012070969,
0.2240139246,
0.2823396921,
-0.1886156946,
0.1843662113,
0.0502010621,
-0.2859525383,
-0.0015680466,
0.7308699489,
1.0482783318,
0.4070198536,
-0.167294085,
0.3517261744,
0.0656721741,
-0.3861603141,
0.0095908614,
-0.2386607677,
-0.0842852369,
0.0724203363,
0.2593125999,
-0.1161301583,
-0.1148544997,
-0.7656362653,
0.2099553198,
0.5441080928,
-0.5548054576,
-0.6830211282,
0.1413781494,
0.2795054913,
-0.1491209418,
0.3458478153,
0.0362255536,
-0.5772156715,
0.154939279,
0.6993456483,
0.6767496467,
-0.3931429386,
0.1582697183,
0.2388846576,
0.4911941886,
0.2002968937,
-0.0926314071,
-0.2953762412,
-0.9597949982,
-0.5708269477,
-0.5683769584,
-0.1965286434,
-0.0478271134,
-0.6277096272,
0.158752054,
0.0469584689,
0.0629313812,
-0.1115500703,
0.0671068653,
-0.7775612473,
-0.1966018975,
0.3217617571,
0.7100168467,
-1.0044629574,
0.975528121,
0.5905148387,
-0.5294226408,
-0.6930162907,
-0.3060978055,
-0.0196918286,
-0.8835268021,
0.6623877287,
-0.2821553051,
-0.1017877311,
-0.0997897238,
0.1499867737,
-0.8880139589,
0.6626246572,
0.2017297149,
-0.4772557616,
-0.152317673,
0.4126864374,
0.5172788501,
-0.7160819769,
0.1665199399,
0.4408169389,
0.6264054179,
0.2426025122,
-1.3996832371,
0.0935000554,
-0.1739743799,
-0.1082859635,
-0.1023868397,
-0.2405941337,
0.8772156239,
-0.3730760217,
-0.2737632096,
-0.2187750489,
0.1671101898,
0.144239381,
0.4703084528,
0.2185768634,
0.1834494621,
0.2092598826,
0.2290498912,
0.9991437197,
-0.3664153814,
0.1142543405,
0.940179944,
-0.6151709557,
0.9785663486,
0.8948261142,
-0.2454708815,
0.4838660657,
0.4310901761,
0.0940411538,
0.4282621145,
-0.1096486524,
0.00559679,
-0.2255943269,
-0.2792277038,
-0.5854680538,
0.560927093,
0.2182812095,
-0.3767331243,
-0.2469008714,
0.2827319503,
-0.2085275203,
-0.4313645363,
-0.3602261245,
0.7275979519,
0.200348556,
-0.7642746568,
0.6779040098,
-0.4261652827,
0.5994026065,
-0.676528275,
-0.0296157766,
-0.1651098877,
-0.0303100534,
-0.1669836342,
-0.8569969535,
0.4881100059,
-0.1481507421,
-0.1139206961,
-0.8177440763,
1.1353924274,
-0.6918469667,
-0.3336787224,
0.6573416591,
1.2692354918,
0.2892823517,
0.1269508004,
-0.6282452345,
0.0480307043,
0.1844836175,
-0.1704254746,
0.778670311,
0.7319154739,
-0.0616659895,
0.408303827,
0.8511241078,
0.4156231284,
0.3322620094,
0.1400920302,
0.3765619993,
-0.6785040498,
-0.2176399678,
-0.6280184984,
0.5820323229,
0.2908082604,
-0.2658642232,
1.1334797144,
0.2106954753,
1.1109418869,
-0.203577742,
0.7791622877,
0.0243624337,
0.2526870072,
-0.4756126404,
0.9389070868,
-0.8428848386,
0.0000096318,
-0.0458390936,
-0.7936193943,
-0.2818862498,
0.4369041324,
-0.1322810799,
0.0791433379,
0.7078562379,
0.5076577663,
0.157735914,
-0.2775844634,
0.797783196,
0.1201364249,
0.1957505047,
0.5951300263,
0.8996248245,
-0.3004727662,
0.6609729528,
-0.0570552982,
0.1629617661,
-0.4865854681,
-0.9581481218,
-0.8124946952,
-0.694627583,
-0.2989352643,
0.0699000284,
-0.0886889473,
0.4095033109,
0.8513439894,
-0.8280032873,
-0.558617413,
0.1557626873,
0.4096578956,
-0.1689753532,
-0.1931200325,
0.1312326789,
-0.4600846171,
-0.4237753153,
0.1123973653,
0.2909517288,
0.3430420756,
-0.6498992443,
-0.2232123315,
-0.5337661505,
-0.0004396781,
0.9522972703,
0.6506574154,
-0.8140899539,
-0.1423258483,
0.1299390197,
-0.1916046292,
-0.2369858921,
1.0899509192,
-0.5824086666,
0.1908760816,
0.5544531941,
0.5810418725,
0.3565717638,
-0.6968015432,
0.7760320902,
-0.5975068808,
-0.0289915837,
-0.0511392839,
0.392344445,
0.4159959853,
0.0413414836,
0.4274530411,
0.4981978834,
-0.3054037988,
-0.9208256006,
0.048222255,
-0.6600435376,
-0.4781984389,
1.3519806862,
-0.2841020226,
0.0177759454,
-0.4342992008,
0.0283411033,
0.2074780166,
0.1518663168,
0.3315019906,
0.9917598963,
-0.2722581327,
-0.5897105336,
-0.6042754054,
0.3059280515,
0.4433551133,
-0.7380723357,
0.2484288216,
0.2158372551,
0.4444268942,
0.3141001165,
0.7141379714,
-0.0321212746,
0.2054483294,
0.2259838134,
-0.0227984823,
0.0690622404,
-0.5350209475,
-0.5601604581,
0.4234251082,
0.0943690836,
0.1143888757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.01761v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.01761v1 | Distinguishing Human Generated Text From ChatGPT Generated Text Using Machine Learning | 2023-05-26T09:27:43 | 2023-05-26T09:27:43 | Niful Islam, Debopom Sutradhar, Humaira Noor, Jarin Tasnim Raya, Monowara Tabassum Maisha, Dewan Md Farid | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | ChatGPT is a conversational artificial intelligence that is a member of the
generative pre-trained transformer of the large language model family. This
text generative model was fine-tuned by both supervised learning and
reinforcement learning so that it can produce text documents that seem to be
written by natural intelligence. Although there are numerous advantages of this
generative model, it comes with some reasonable concerns as well. This paper
presents a machine learning-based solution that can identify the ChatGPT
delivered text from the human written text along with the comparative analysis
of a total of 11 machine learning and deep learning algorithms in the
classification process. We have tested the proposed model on a Kaggle dataset
consisting of 10,000 texts out of which 5,204 texts were written by humans and
collected from news and social media. On the corpus generated by GPT-3.5, the
proposed algorithm presents an accuracy of 77%. | [
-0.2544353902,
-1.1035642624,
0.3402535319,
-0.000097692,
-0.1895353645,
0.6158764958,
-0.2880355716,
-0.5029597878,
-0.1612519026,
0.552777648,
-0.6521862745,
-0.4739863276,
-0.799584806,
0.21819821,
-0.5080010295,
1.2268629074,
0.1549663693,
-0.1944176853,
0.0754580349,
0.4266602397,
-0.3876618147,
-0.6431797743,
-0.7397825718,
-0.5293889642,
0.2310811579,
0.1833513826,
0.6967716813,
0.2627665401,
0.5646613836,
0.3618268669,
-0.0328905247,
0.2817476988,
-0.5373101234,
-0.2263400406,
0.0996111855,
-0.2705587149,
-0.0507529937,
0.1686408669,
0.369947046,
0.0466759205,
-0.0372210592,
0.0121728899,
0.3850592673,
0.6467744708,
-0.2690785229,
0.3158794641,
-0.8710696697,
0.3309330046,
-0.1259123981,
-0.2713688016,
-0.7214755416,
-0.5471814871,
0.1533184648,
-0.477306217,
0.6093418598,
0.0535209142,
1.0703462362,
0.1663455069,
-0.50115484,
-0.8119468689,
-0.7886891961,
0.5818226933,
-0.5928035975,
0.257999599,
0.2683964968,
0.4070265591,
-0.4593223631,
-0.6621205211,
-0.9727011323,
-0.4452365637,
-0.3345107734,
0.2461968362,
-0.1188123301,
-0.0287120715,
0.0355100296,
0.2920370102,
-0.9593650699,
0.0575512014,
-0.4254039824,
-0.4016847312,
0.6431588531,
-0.0615509972,
0.6012104154,
-0.4284801483,
-0.3827406764,
-0.1555361003,
-0.4493597746,
-0.2038073391,
0.5194541812,
0.1352702081,
0.047467228,
0.5023774505,
-0.2543226182,
0.4500906467,
-0.0018471533,
-0.0693175197,
0.3406656384,
-0.0243384894,
-0.3789983988,
0.1681127101,
1.4134910107,
0.2928846776,
0.6765553951,
-0.1981919855,
-0.024960909,
0.2084533125,
0.3991845846,
-0.8028743267,
-0.4687390029,
-0.2172777504,
-0.5411479473,
-0.6348053217,
0.1330564916,
-0.5891125202,
-0.6674982309,
-0.1517692357,
0.2560163438,
-0.5426854491,
-0.1846390665,
0.0002431464,
-0.1184867695,
0.3190696239,
0.2701138258,
-1.0537889004,
0.0481630117,
0.8544436097,
0.8147554994,
-0.2198058963,
-0.1283533275,
-0.2535942495,
-0.0442742631,
-0.3442023396,
1.0644078255,
-0.4379006326,
-0.2675358951,
-0.0420601815,
-0.1217069328,
-0.2719704211,
-0.5090347528,
0.8616514802,
-0.7352970839,
0.6976479888,
0.1442693472,
-0.7927466035,
-0.2472236603,
0.2853292823,
-0.6514328122,
0.8607783318,
0.1249447241,
-0.8806293011,
0.6349182129,
-0.7504110932,
-0.5380041599,
0.4606446028,
-0.1491043568,
-0.9344198108,
-0.2148623317,
0.3460896611,
0.6224917769,
-0.1696718037,
0.3931818306,
-0.0147906952,
-0.2926970422,
0.5602338314,
-0.8760333061,
0.6375027299,
0.462612927,
-0.387360394,
0.1744236201,
-0.6783477068,
0.1397103071,
0.2509649396,
-0.5467264652,
0.1865270734,
0.1111871749,
0.2055929154,
0.1512549371,
0.0011884585,
-0.5565901399,
0.2303104848,
-0.3011788428,
0.7172924876,
0.5537955761,
0.1857199073,
0.2558798492,
-0.317096591,
0.3784334958,
-0.0983545855,
0.0379615799,
-0.2346111089,
-0.8921163678,
-0.6446132064,
-0.2550367117,
0.4781075716,
0.9709299207,
-0.6365231872,
0.6198994517,
-0.3913072944,
-0.6435815692,
-0.4924075603,
0.0346899256,
0.3853046298,
0.3747771084,
0.1254962534,
-0.1258167326,
-0.3379470408,
-0.7606304884,
-0.3133094013,
-0.3333771825,
-0.3440350294,
0.2757005394,
0.2952834964,
-0.4414171576,
0.8510516286,
-0.5316241384,
-0.2099406868,
-0.2707483768,
0.595333457,
-0.0465699211,
0.3190417588,
0.2795905471,
-0.9944706559,
-0.7968213558,
0.3355097175,
-0.7849136591,
-0.1446325034,
-0.3790477514,
-0.0356571674,
0.2832597196,
0.5438254476,
-0.6922538877,
0.5251855254,
0.3701115847,
-0.2889088094,
0.5362510085,
-0.2255609632,
0.3323990703,
-1.1230281591,
-0.1210349053,
0.0021169267,
-0.3172930479,
-0.6202310324,
-0.3602887094,
0.0650540888,
-0.3909821212,
-0.1592010111,
0.3808225393,
-0.1605809927,
0.2135807425,
-0.3488147855,
0.1375006735,
-0.104417935,
0.5806768537,
0.2142204791,
0.8671467304,
-0.0023052085,
-0.4052564502,
0.5304718018,
0.3450624943,
-0.4328303635,
0.3615605533,
-0.5531314611,
0.4645423889,
-0.073097311,
0.3051772416,
-1.0566990376,
-0.3244674802,
0.6682080626,
-0.8759491444,
-0.1009528935,
-0.1914754808,
-0.7141301632,
-0.3984183371,
0.1757420152,
-0.0996053144,
0.7868649364,
-0.3879036307,
0.4316931963,
0.3215542734,
-0.4166341722,
-0.0385326929,
-0.3451349735,
0.278065443,
-0.2210251689,
-0.5926885605,
0.2432529777,
0.0332858413,
0.2152922004,
-0.0210461076,
0.4417016208,
-0.2359527946,
0.0337548815,
0.2930755317,
0.2349564433,
-0.2212044001,
0.2867718637,
-0.1046483591,
-0.3302928209,
0.0191342253,
-0.1809129715,
0.7660307884,
-0.1106378809,
-0.3712210953,
-0.6223801374,
0.332157135,
0.4045208097,
-0.2591164708,
0.5766772032,
1.0041214228,
-0.0696697608,
-0.1055092588,
-0.3218649328,
-0.0992225856,
-0.5035447478,
0.3805437386,
-0.151678592,
-0.6507828236,
0.1460080296,
-0.0736355186,
-0.1705211252,
0.5402495861,
0.7245528698,
-0.0757801533,
1.1898933649,
0.4916861057,
-0.34534356,
0.6562455893,
0.1815738827,
0.38724792,
-0.2251887918,
-0.1753415465,
-0.5267643929,
-0.211308971,
-0.9760985374,
-0.0308524519,
-0.082935974,
-0.1454819739,
-0.3001028895,
0.3365162313,
-0.8636533618,
0.5332142711,
0.9555882215,
0.2261863351,
0.3511320055,
0.0696456209,
0.1012615487,
0.3024688065,
-0.5033380985,
-1.0207047462,
1.0525269508,
0.1948651075,
0.3073438704,
-0.0836619586,
0.5551636815,
0.7351439595,
0.6422006488,
-0.6557046771,
0.5628308058,
-0.1260575652,
-0.4935657084,
-0.1122781485,
-0.6210368276,
-1.2256712914,
0.035482686,
-0.5711967945,
-0.7911981344,
-0.4855424464,
-0.0472477376,
-0.056724254,
0.1862539351,
-1.24497509,
1.0246703625,
-0.2016157508,
0.2781160176,
-0.0968989655,
-0.5280323029,
0.0316738859,
-0.1263623238,
-0.09790162,
-0.147655189,
0.3681402206,
0.7734413743,
-0.094084613,
0.8515020013,
0.1201156452,
-0.0165321026,
0.4930685461,
-0.1352001131,
0.5768623948,
-0.0375274122,
0.1724222004,
0.0494114608,
-0.3030544519,
-0.3582079709,
-0.5089168549,
0.2778080106,
-0.8879550099,
-0.2571492791,
-0.3112820685,
-0.3168971241,
-0.0526817851,
0.4404969513,
0.6403122544,
0.1976847053,
-0.4190203846,
0.0798442587,
0.5263210535,
-0.3736607432,
0.5076748133,
0.3627786934,
-0.2361389548,
-0.3646134138,
1.0915359259,
-0.2787402868,
-0.0337985866,
0.5599370599,
0.2563984394,
-0.1372001618,
-0.5547655821,
-0.705042243,
-0.12483114,
-0.4582886994,
-0.0083602499,
-0.5670869946,
-0.6977767944,
-0.2452781498,
-0.1230603755,
-0.0645043701,
0.1616978496,
-0.3595210314,
0.0318854339,
0.177303493,
0.8276007175,
0.5676441789,
0.606595993,
-0.9744858742,
0.3475747705,
0.4480882883,
0.165951401,
-0.2660131156,
-0.1867537946,
0.1153105944,
0.2831195593,
-0.6269136667,
-0.9163597226,
0.6041020155,
0.1243882403,
0.3531614542,
0.4837815166,
-0.0132385846,
0.1325702071,
-0.5543176532,
0.712883234,
0.2139483839,
-0.7449662685,
0.5195429325,
-0.5075491071,
0.2047601342,
0.1643554717,
0.2343073785,
-0.7963504195,
-0.4728304148,
-0.8905225992,
-0.4433633387,
0.4497782886,
0.5818287134,
0.3851386905,
-0.1740153879,
0.1629562825,
0.188778922,
0.2405154854,
-0.8576523662,
0.2464246005,
-0.1733387709,
-0.472669065,
-0.0905813202,
-0.0776322857,
0.3062191606,
0.2564604282,
0.6224253178,
-0.1304256767,
0.4345264435,
-0.1673642397,
-0.3002466261,
0.2923783958,
0.4490426779,
0.5290865302,
0.2653319836,
-0.0144629739,
-0.1187085658,
-0.0405918472,
-0.8457936049,
0.0577071942,
0.1358768791,
-0.4305288196,
0.0256819781,
0.4977738857,
0.8097299933,
-0.2132762074,
-0.7247083783,
0.5801925063,
-0.2834204137,
-0.4024315774,
-0.3278202713,
0.3236469328,
-0.0425643697,
0.2881338894,
0.4818593562,
0.2379953265,
0.1171074584,
-0.3294200599,
0.2700242698,
0.4520461261,
-0.5254728794,
-0.1802289188,
0.4965264797,
0.2910155356,
-0.7870149016,
0.9819436669,
-0.5303352475,
-0.8211131096,
0.5363494754,
0.4592339396,
1.0652884245,
0.0278925952,
0.6863662004,
0.0994946286,
0.1780988872,
0.2104908824,
-0.1480766684,
-0.0115233446,
-0.9202788472,
-0.4126011729,
-0.4538514018,
-0.3350633681,
0.309243232,
-0.2911579609,
0.3288902938,
-0.3144378066,
-0.0989678651,
0.3427439034,
0.1608401537,
-0.5912742615,
0.2088610232,
0.3479829133,
0.3833650947,
-1.0727369785,
0.698574543,
0.416973263,
-0.3054989576,
-0.6233514547,
0.3723317385,
-0.0605128109,
-0.8428169489,
0.6478792429,
0.4368259311,
0.008196068,
0.214513585,
-0.5493602157,
-0.3360517919,
0.7163391113,
0.2988660336,
-0.3671882749,
0.1965111196,
0.41988042,
0.6548168659,
-0.1568721384,
0.3174395859,
0.2917711139,
0.2621565759,
0.187848717,
-1.0440199375,
-0.09708637,
-0.3851275146,
-0.0555408746,
0.3826913536,
-0.3942879438,
0.5052552819,
0.0759964883,
-0.5030165315,
-0.040761102,
0.6815571785,
0.0474536046,
0.246694833,
0.3312094808,
0.3401073813,
1.0040813684,
-0.1413098872,
0.8383828998,
0.0987840742,
0.5355225801,
0.7483665347,
-0.0420426987,
0.8253248334,
-0.0842441544,
-0.2922984958,
0.551089704,
0.6239593625,
-0.1955996007,
0.519952774,
0.232551977,
-0.5639628172,
-0.0353681222,
0.2074118555,
-0.1598691344,
0.5446190834,
0.2920324504,
-0.5019805431,
-0.16710338,
0.1521832198,
0.1273102313,
0.0735969841,
-0.1235015392,
1.3759276867,
-0.2655097246,
-0.8789181709,
0.3907296062,
0.0008492494,
0.5937644243,
-0.3005090356,
0.0164753534,
0.06191599,
0.4432609081,
-0.07702481,
-0.8154127002,
0.300290525,
-0.014037976,
-0.2223633975,
-0.2367248684,
1.1659582853,
-0.3294980228,
-0.6401848793,
-0.2286192179,
0.414702177,
0.1354255825,
-0.4042785764,
-0.881148994,
-0.2843734622,
0.1093921885,
-0.2351855636,
0.2736721337,
0.6960516572,
-0.120853737,
0.7652752399,
0.8942982554,
-0.223620832,
0.1230824888,
-0.0403719693,
0.7145161629,
-0.5817315578,
-0.7643728852,
-1.1028901339,
0.1791223288,
-0.4914392233,
-0.2746222019,
0.6278529167,
0.5916531086,
0.589206636,
-0.2366115898,
1.2297673225,
-0.0996146947,
0.6922331452,
-0.5658782721,
0.9526367188,
0.2026337832,
0.1562730074,
-0.3496967256,
-0.6781733036,
-0.2738335431,
0.6306910515,
-0.5308061838,
0.0914494693,
0.5222774148,
0.7742442489,
-0.0683530346,
0.3851387799,
0.0828227922,
-0.2727195024,
0.4797478616,
0.6837019324,
0.9764718413,
-0.2681652308,
0.9091499448,
0.1176082641,
-0.2833935916,
-0.36211586,
-0.9829084873,
-1.1401393414,
-0.7100589275,
-0.3731437624,
-0.2169079036,
0.0630790889,
0.5900130272,
0.7577197552,
-0.6683008075,
0.2597743571,
-0.5341190696,
0.0618700609,
-0.1983009726,
-0.2706966698,
0.5285035968,
-0.4508405626,
-0.6665896773,
-0.0658092797,
0.0995647311,
0.1717838347,
-0.0482001118,
-0.0140030244,
0.1091793254,
0.006447983,
0.5974527001,
0.2238854468,
-0.4048347175,
-0.4631094038,
-0.0378591865,
-0.3441578746,
0.2627112865,
0.6490702629,
-0.9172512889,
0.2340785563,
0.5165851712,
0.7071731687,
0.5622127652,
0.0633176416,
0.5431688428,
-0.7423142791,
-0.0272974689,
0.2739100158,
-0.0512961186,
0.4130642712,
-0.4618882835,
0.2955527604,
0.2330153584,
-0.8453581333,
-0.2628032565,
0.2664580643,
-0.8778042793,
-0.2341486961,
1.1049792767,
-0.0808580369,
-0.1785774976,
-0.2316063344,
-0.756931603,
0.4131454825,
-0.3989781439,
1.0501862764,
0.6851814389,
0.0603943579,
-0.3887172639,
-0.8106976151,
0.5761319399,
-0.0889071822,
-1.1144757271,
-0.0453445166,
0.3537345827,
0.1458590627,
0.1696318388,
0.6381782293,
0.0729147792,
0.0722733662,
-0.0228790902,
0.0442830101,
0.1209165081,
0.0259471685,
0.2727753222,
0.3810673952,
-0.249633804,
-0.3612372577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16765v1 | Backpack Language Models | 2023-05-26T09:26:23 | 2023-05-26T09:26:23 | John Hewitt, John Thickstun, Christopher D. Manning, Percy Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Backpacks: a new neural architecture that marries strong modeling
performance with an interface for interpretability and control. Backpacks learn
multiple non-contextual sense vectors for each word in a vocabulary, and
represent a word in a sequence as a context-dependent, non-negative linear
combination of sense vectors in this sequence. We find that, after training,
sense vectors specialize, each encoding a different aspect of a word. We can
interpret a sense vector by inspecting its (non-contextual, linear) projection
onto the output space, and intervene on these interpretable hooks to change the
model's behavior in predictable ways. We train a 170M-parameter Backpack
language model on OpenWebText, matching the loss of a GPT-2 small
(124Mparameter) Transformer. On lexical similarity evaluations, we find that
Backpack sense vectors outperform even a 6B-parameter Transformer LM's word
embeddings. Finally, we present simple algorithms that intervene on sense
vectors to perform controllable text generation and debiasing. For example, we
can edit the sense vocabulary to tend more towards a topic, or localize a
source of gender bias to a sense vector and globally suppress that sense. | [
-0.2912897468,
-0.4977257252,
0.0888784602,
0.6105986238,
-0.2624894381,
0.002064965,
-0.2638165057,
-0.4082072973,
0.040902894,
0.0944919735,
-0.2491754144,
-0.2862175107,
-0.6446980238,
-0.1651862264,
-0.5606011152,
0.9779670238,
-0.3359976411,
-0.0247832257,
-0.0541528054,
-0.4250932634,
-0.7144991159,
-0.6286402941,
-0.5325201154,
-0.560528338,
0.7387849092,
-0.200948894,
0.5528897643,
0.3991589546,
0.0927064419,
0.2416009158,
-0.3896522522,
-0.1646716446,
-0.4533447027,
0.0368397012,
-0.4389943182,
-0.3581674099,
-0.2891814709,
0.0100295926,
0.4987413287,
0.4629855454,
-0.1730788052,
-0.0395588279,
0.3683069944,
0.1372523606,
-0.6627358198,
0.1099245697,
-0.5534670353,
-0.2262028903,
0.0471281484,
-0.1556075811,
-0.5302461982,
0.1381721497,
0.2024742663,
-0.4816935062,
0.1140924767,
0.218787089,
0.8834186196,
0.1486576945,
-0.3949043155,
-0.2953542471,
-0.7051841021,
1.1536561251,
-0.3021152318,
0.5296922922,
0.3697313666,
0.2498347312,
-0.263069123,
-0.6291411519,
-0.7946648002,
0.1539385766,
-0.1627616137,
-0.0086088805,
-0.2577911615,
0.0434166491,
-0.4040504396,
0.1166082695,
-0.5083750486,
0.0798601732,
-0.371295929,
-0.0543098152,
0.5111223459,
-0.1159703657,
0.4871355593,
-0.2727556229,
-0.6958984137,
-0.2723687887,
-0.734592855,
0.0882949233,
0.3457777202,
0.2808969915,
-0.2801899314,
0.4052681923,
0.0920451134,
0.882090807,
-0.1045276523,
0.0275143888,
0.1655107737,
0.0615742467,
-0.3928840756,
-0.1615705937,
0.5507420301,
0.2768035233,
0.2313418239,
-0.2731520534,
-0.6418458223,
0.0140934922,
0.5530144572,
-0.7738648057,
-0.2115078717,
0.1478401572,
-0.764550209,
-0.6740552187,
-0.4601207972,
-0.6069203615,
-0.4752020836,
-0.5582308173,
0.7234641314,
-0.4713401198,
-0.3993728161,
0.2492955774,
-0.4464828968,
0.5604871511,
0.2219816595,
-1.1764478683,
0.5342401862,
0.5539432168,
0.9981433749,
-0.3188119233,
-0.3278648853,
-0.2956159115,
0.0469592288,
-0.300951153,
0.9220474362,
-0.6961938739,
-0.3040283322,
0.1017760485,
0.0357911475,
-0.1400761455,
-0.3512377441,
0.3753788173,
-0.6236186028,
0.0588163175,
-0.1602391452,
-0.3383023143,
-0.2794623673,
0.3304566145,
-0.3392755985,
0.9135488868,
0.1860282868,
-0.5643804669,
0.2051258832,
-0.4377436042,
-0.3230057955,
0.1298111975,
-0.3076041639,
0.1066462994,
0.4288051426,
0.0122824907,
0.2866285443,
-0.0776188895,
0.3369030654,
-0.1779038161,
-0.3598287106,
0.1809060574,
-0.406552732,
0.7216531634,
-0.1631097645,
-0.0549938008,
0.3471800089,
-0.7228399515,
-0.0681261867,
-0.0872407481,
-0.614030838,
-0.6864129901,
0.335477978,
0.5305540562,
0.2421683967,
0.1340500414,
-0.503602922,
0.2225976288,
-0.398407042,
0.6295853853,
0.9666053653,
-0.3565757871,
0.7663623095,
-0.1520410329,
0.5534490943,
-0.0297930539,
0.0847854465,
-0.2932421565,
-0.4648565352,
-0.7225862145,
-0.2350025624,
0.2130514383,
0.5224261284,
-0.7966428399,
0.2981618345,
-0.0953297839,
-0.4282435179,
-0.0708832219,
0.1240897253,
0.3361949921,
0.6030728817,
0.5118286014,
-0.1337183714,
-0.3576002121,
-0.834369719,
-0.4998046756,
-0.2588759661,
-0.3400632441,
0.2256687135,
0.5190563202,
-0.2116724998,
0.753823936,
-0.4221203625,
-0.2482069135,
-0.4665590525,
0.3120380938,
-0.1137403175,
0.6493726373,
0.6404752731,
-0.7997044325,
0.1000564247,
-0.0596763529,
-0.5670294166,
-0.10959097,
0.0095569259,
-0.2784491181,
0.180382818,
0.4935539961,
-0.7098594308,
0.5221781135,
0.7062689066,
-0.6127737164,
0.4124022722,
-0.2780320346,
-0.5429635644,
-0.8810907006,
0.0330407731,
-0.0714155287,
0.0984085947,
-0.6080034375,
0.1027121246,
0.3582253456,
0.0776403621,
-0.5067375898,
1.1142814159,
-0.323766619,
-0.1522544175,
-0.4522101283,
0.1145568043,
0.3088291883,
0.6397947669,
0.0408100821,
0.4818284512,
0.4436798096,
-0.7681666613,
0.326580286,
0.5057358742,
-0.5746694803,
0.5647531748,
-0.9807144403,
-0.1029021516,
-0.5713736415,
0.4115398228,
-1.2250032425,
-0.0501885749,
0.0194805469,
-0.3302925825,
0.5020197034,
0.0173790269,
-0.2851850092,
-0.2063785195,
-0.1247621253,
0.5330815911,
0.3957971334,
-0.8169917464,
0.8103542924,
0.2959576845,
-0.0676033944,
-0.6599074006,
-0.8754807711,
-0.1197466478,
-0.0005485351,
-0.0420461856,
0.3963502944,
-0.0881390348,
-0.1813783199,
-0.0266813859,
-0.1928140074,
-0.1272405833,
0.1342051476,
0.2996836901,
0.3589804471,
0.0575893335,
0.7442691326,
0.3058488071,
-0.0230053496,
-0.1350748539,
-0.8562465906,
0.648663342,
-0.1950958222,
0.0716108754,
0.0247855205,
0.1301258653,
0.3124412,
-0.4328013957,
0.9161458015,
0.4395785332,
-0.4958141744,
-0.3293929994,
-0.074095577,
-0.1354914904,
-0.539040029,
0.1778777391,
-0.628454864,
-0.591633141,
0.4267560542,
0.1701309234,
0.104352437,
0.0936834887,
0.4199978113,
-0.1065227687,
0.8745548725,
0.8396887183,
-0.0497761667,
0.5342146754,
-0.0911725387,
0.4081127048,
-0.9414745569,
-0.3536373377,
-0.4588089883,
-1.0278329849,
-0.6102536917,
-0.5107454658,
-0.0803669989,
0.5173155665,
-0.2840725183,
0.4654988945,
-0.6520130634,
0.5950413346,
0.4871982336,
-0.1396541893,
-0.0055718869,
-0.0142426481,
-0.4007451534,
0.1532715261,
-0.733956337,
-0.5338314772,
0.9449853301,
0.3644310832,
1.0186738968,
0.049043674,
0.3379654586,
0.0907855257,
0.5104290247,
-0.9917185903,
0.4391886294,
-0.125731647,
-0.5015437603,
-0.0021265035,
-0.0064180437,
-0.8511913419,
0.4588271976,
-0.0535450168,
-1.0304909945,
0.5346081257,
0.2149953842,
-0.1858945638,
0.2055488378,
-0.7694177628,
0.8615108728,
-0.245945707,
-0.3783291578,
-0.0377328582,
-0.4917272627,
0.2498352081,
0.1946801096,
0.1115437672,
0.0189953502,
-0.3436843753,
0.5802636743,
0.1355154961,
0.9320075512,
-0.1806859672,
-0.270141542,
0.1119781062,
0.2478132397,
0.1671948433,
-0.1092902049,
-0.0736228526,
0.5106705427,
0.1270064861,
-0.5253606439,
-0.6573138237,
0.9508295655,
-0.783611834,
-0.2469969243,
-0.3013899028,
-0.7450525165,
0.0627148077,
0.4073192775,
0.2684834898,
0.8615085483,
-0.2550637126,
0.0846077576,
0.5534345508,
-0.763260901,
0.6125670075,
0.4260624349,
-0.5735495687,
-0.0675232783,
1.0903918743,
0.1349515468,
0.0971390381,
0.8603172898,
0.3650608063,
-0.4719115496,
-0.3731333315,
-0.6779509187,
-0.0539556779,
-0.7073698044,
-0.1563927531,
-0.7984062433,
-0.0294505432,
-0.1754976064,
-0.1715216041,
-0.1898873597,
-0.6641218066,
-0.1691511869,
-0.2206002623,
0.2095199227,
0.9708353877,
0.1220960021,
0.7483471632,
-0.3309601545,
0.3283242881,
0.2559469342,
0.5778458714,
-0.0538282581,
-0.5020508766,
-0.187017411,
-0.2186493576,
-0.5064241886,
-0.8499592543,
0.613792181,
0.1507795453,
0.2067616731,
0.4584691525,
-0.1120440215,
0.3828029633,
-0.5853722095,
0.7246053815,
-0.0219308417,
-1.0808932781,
0.4632751942,
-0.3721897602,
0.4516746402,
-0.0329156071,
0.187717244,
-0.4636567831,
-0.3941232562,
-0.4814099967,
-0.7002741694,
0.6229956746,
0.0235884748,
0.4597057104,
-0.071867153,
0.2669877112,
0.0494951382,
0.50574857,
-0.5174283385,
-0.0431987122,
-0.5515954494,
-0.4596307576,
-0.2450282872,
-0.372838378,
-0.0251535494,
-0.3213637769,
0.5217080116,
-0.3009004891,
0.3280532658,
-0.1010953188,
-0.0461884439,
0.1292577237,
0.2648920417,
0.9035798311,
0.627166152,
-0.0483323336,
0.5386798382,
-0.0212448258,
-0.2881526053,
0.0254296754,
-0.0032244087,
-0.4073712826,
0.10293255,
0.2200759053,
0.9449239373,
0.5473308563,
-0.6960225105,
0.5315449834,
-0.3266253471,
-0.0190589856,
-0.297496587,
-0.0928146169,
0.148425743,
0.1145285591,
0.1024467722,
0.3195773661,
-0.0561731048,
-0.2246385664,
-0.021203164,
0.5648502111,
-0.3428404629,
-0.6758244038,
0.7157260776,
0.2426314801,
-0.3210158646,
0.346949935,
-0.0775280222,
-0.4899891913,
0.3927651644,
0.6817092896,
0.827501297,
-0.5705467463,
0.1821348816,
0.4103550911,
0.6121588945,
-0.0991443843,
0.3491584063,
-0.2823675871,
-0.9334094524,
-0.253865093,
-1.1062614918,
-0.073896639,
0.4391512871,
-0.5568566918,
0.3508363366,
-0.4684627652,
0.342774868,
-0.1346881092,
-0.4485856891,
-0.7395043969,
0.2463831156,
-0.1690616906,
1.2854635715,
-0.7333396077,
1.0032048225,
0.7103108168,
-0.1898311675,
-0.7110436559,
-0.1485099494,
-0.0885607675,
-0.7877987027,
0.8781276345,
0.4190841019,
0.0043393043,
-0.0645127073,
-0.5261359811,
-0.6920897365,
0.8492732644,
0.1157428026,
-0.5338507891,
-0.2217264622,
-0.3052326441,
0.603212893,
-0.2784247398,
0.3348327577,
0.6770800352,
0.3889714181,
-0.1096752509,
-0.6914743781,
-0.1091909111,
-0.1886432767,
0.3717048764,
0.2407048792,
-0.4129468501,
1.0233615637,
0.1155977026,
-0.2908395231,
0.0831456557,
0.5970172882,
0.0109057827,
0.1026727036,
0.3893295825,
0.4774398208,
0.7085157037,
0.04864005,
1.3970586061,
-0.3173008859,
0.0832040608,
1.3391920328,
-0.1447459757,
1.1961612701,
0.7474297285,
0.2898930609,
0.5994326472,
0.3311386704,
0.37133044,
0.5804903507,
0.4045620859,
-0.571382463,
-0.0719500482,
-0.1203305498,
0.0481542945,
0.7219641805,
0.524818182,
-0.4145553112,
-0.2623187602,
0.349103719,
-0.3760182858,
0.0228454228,
-0.1138186008,
0.6450117826,
0.185849458,
-0.6865203381,
0.829238534,
0.2745523155,
0.6314908266,
-0.6121245027,
-0.0109512461,
-0.1370500177,
0.6197631955,
0.0385552421,
-0.4992927015,
0.4510222375,
-0.0763595104,
-0.2330421209,
-0.6280441284,
1.1411408186,
-0.5905352235,
-0.4375295937,
0.4662631154,
0.3904723525,
0.0712081045,
-0.0723443925,
-0.3618030846,
0.4254608154,
-0.4722692668,
-0.525754869,
0.3502161801,
0.1454951018,
-0.2033064216,
0.8492639065,
0.3393765986,
0.0971081257,
0.1276504397,
-0.1218261719,
0.8577340841,
-0.4528905451,
-0.4707450867,
-0.6909129024,
0.2722637057,
0.0752168521,
-0.3726705611,
0.4504455626,
0.2283301055,
0.9415082932,
-0.2440971136,
0.9460217953,
-0.1385667026,
0.1986690909,
-0.1919706017,
0.8630061746,
-0.5031622052,
0.0160133764,
0.2188540548,
-0.7877335548,
-0.1185121685,
0.9016517401,
-0.2963550985,
-0.1016135141,
0.4172432125,
0.7727711201,
-0.203333199,
0.0983827114,
0.3206635118,
0.2716054618,
0.5805731416,
0.3859470189,
0.8008573651,
-0.6000385284,
0.4893937707,
0.0415293537,
-0.3570207357,
-0.0517417565,
-0.9743920565,
-0.992955029,
-0.5792723298,
0.0528213941,
-0.2391889989,
-0.099586077,
0.6269573569,
0.7959610224,
-0.6934539676,
-0.226725176,
-0.5457766056,
0.3829693198,
-0.3581709564,
-0.2708049715,
0.0369144939,
-0.5404520035,
-0.8323703408,
0.6279087067,
0.3535429835,
0.126942724,
-0.5797683597,
-0.2502669692,
0.0074268845,
0.3390290439,
0.9570375085,
0.2532553375,
-0.752764523,
-0.3752070367,
-0.0599725582,
-0.0165845845,
-0.2206540853,
0.9605849981,
-1.1041311026,
0.6147814393,
0.7843610048,
0.789501965,
0.2760467231,
-0.3188599944,
0.8083097935,
-1.030470252,
0.4348376393,
-0.051696375,
0.2756740749,
0.3575389087,
0.0487391837,
0.0748323128,
0.0664856136,
-0.4686207771,
-0.7990905643,
0.4276652932,
-0.8548418283,
-0.4179325402,
1.1222894192,
-0.1791148335,
-0.4588339627,
0.0058187474,
-0.3364188671,
0.1663575321,
-0.1086056679,
0.8041641712,
0.813855052,
0.1795761138,
-0.3538430035,
-0.6666485667,
0.5071918964,
0.3935629725,
-0.5786239505,
0.0005635362,
0.294391036,
0.3501622975,
0.2111122459,
0.5132616758,
0.0943852514,
-0.0675529912,
-0.0582485348,
0.1268241107,
0.0926126838,
-0.5216404796,
-0.5896744728,
-0.0129630454,
-0.08683303,
-0.4983358085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16756v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16756v2 | Leveraging Domain Knowledge for Inclusive and Bias-aware Humanitarian Response Entry Classification | 2023-05-26T09:15:05 | 2023-05-30T13:16:33 | Nicolò Tamagnone, Selim Fekih, Ximena Contla, Nayid Orozco, Navid Rekabsaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Accurate and rapid situation analysis during humanitarian crises is critical
to delivering humanitarian aid efficiently and is fundamental to humanitarian
imperatives and the Leave No One Behind (LNOB) principle. This data analysis
can highly benefit from language processing systems, e.g., by classifying the
text data according to a humanitarian ontology. However, approaching this by
simply fine-tuning a generic large language model (LLM) involves considerable
practical and ethical issues, particularly the lack of effectiveness on
data-sparse and complex subdomains, and the encoding of societal biases and
unwanted associations. In this work, we aim to provide an effective and
ethically-aware system for humanitarian data analysis. We approach this by (1)
introducing a novel architecture adjusted to the humanitarian analysis
framework, (2) creating and releasing a novel humanitarian-specific LLM called
HumBert, and (3) proposing a systematic way to measure and mitigate biases. Our
experiments' results show the better performance of our approach on zero-shot
and full-training settings in comparison with strong baseline models, while
also revealing the existence of biases in the resulting LLMs. Utilizing a
targeted counterfactual data augmentation approach, we significantly reduce
these biases without compromising performance. | [
-0.5841372609,
-0.6483751535,
0.3812918365,
-0.0248624068,
0.0424959138,
0.1934065372,
-0.1843400002,
-0.5061101913,
-0.2760022283,
0.5694907904,
-0.4924101233,
-0.6213520765,
-0.6966249943,
0.0982182473,
-0.2628521025,
1.3114446402,
0.0900360718,
0.0343936086,
-0.0598006621,
-0.6860582829,
-0.2160332501,
-0.8314998746,
-0.2534543872,
-0.2247882932,
0.5536419153,
0.61835742,
0.7662326694,
0.4727070034,
0.4201081991,
0.216963768,
0.0521211214,
-0.037819203,
-0.6071387529,
-0.1335127205,
-0.5108818412,
-0.067028299,
-0.6118873358,
0.0975804627,
0.2503966391,
0.541336596,
-0.274025321,
0.5922221541,
0.2361342907,
0.382781744,
-0.6882941723,
-0.0375063084,
-0.4169763029,
0.1512726545,
-0.1942336559,
-0.3242868185,
-0.137258932,
-0.2154208124,
0.4926840365,
-0.6256418824,
0.5830604434,
0.1427669376,
0.2575645447,
0.2319514155,
-0.2721576393,
-0.1337975115,
-0.4565973878,
1.0201736689,
-0.4440521598,
0.4201729596,
0.3260434866,
0.2302302718,
-0.0256231818,
-0.5097278357,
-0.5175734758,
0.3395386338,
0.2640507817,
0.0121980067,
0.0355344117,
0.081761755,
0.1360105872,
0.0668309927,
-0.6871438026,
0.1517356336,
-0.0916797146,
-0.2812368572,
0.5679889917,
0.2122692615,
0.249054864,
-0.3726892173,
-0.4754898846,
0.2060038,
-0.5880638957,
0.150121972,
0.0586662851,
0.5040110946,
-0.4294494987,
0.4198569953,
-0.318898499,
0.5691366792,
0.0335301645,
-0.049618084,
0.1711909622,
-0.063086912,
-0.2989816964,
0.0698919296,
0.4003219604,
0.4871712327,
0.3198056519,
-0.1268528551,
-0.2468571663,
0.120642148,
0.5507060885,
-0.7812957764,
0.0420894213,
0.314045459,
-0.5429842472,
-0.7053242326,
-0.1409026831,
-0.9427442551,
-0.646084547,
-0.2152065337,
0.1590733677,
-0.0145414714,
0.037778154,
0.1176037043,
0.1905453652,
0.261379689,
0.4079073668,
-0.4872230291,
0.4074097276,
0.5894780755,
0.6750164032,
0.0652525499,
0.116571337,
-0.9434140921,
0.0747919753,
0.2617106736,
0.6469996572,
-0.6006084681,
-0.5406003594,
0.3717807829,
-0.1086626351,
0.4030126333,
-0.3999728262,
0.8102971315,
-0.8123853207,
0.0441478491,
-0.4283979535,
-0.2189536542,
-0.3455166519,
0.5932298899,
-0.3992065191,
0.9611805081,
0.3053909838,
-1.0007470846,
0.4863885939,
-0.6476052403,
-0.3046846986,
0.0286089703,
-0.3297796547,
-0.4404467642,
0.0629095137,
0.41027987,
0.4952282608,
-0.6118228436,
0.5388263464,
-0.3946221769,
-0.1737345904,
0.1533229053,
-0.2390999347,
0.8155418634,
0.056481082,
-0.452891916,
0.1690360606,
-0.6473311782,
-0.1573036462,
0.1132955849,
-0.4569655955,
-0.2675417662,
-0.0242746901,
0.4202975929,
0.387969017,
0.05461777,
-0.6367613673,
0.2541461885,
-0.3177352548,
-0.0613695346,
1.0568578243,
-0.2692006826,
0.5950633287,
-0.4281798303,
0.5847555995,
-0.0525831468,
0.4944601357,
0.2404262424,
-0.5894896388,
-0.6359683275,
-0.3360909522,
0.2411162555,
0.74009341,
-0.7179151177,
0.4658472538,
-0.3333243132,
0.1336648464,
-0.4831808209,
0.0442253835,
0.2125912607,
1.0161632299,
0.6150299907,
-0.3633261025,
-0.7564030886,
-0.6723985076,
-0.3644851148,
-0.1529103965,
-0.1439112723,
0.3836355507,
0.5133413076,
-0.3991392851,
1.0553649664,
-0.3823626041,
-0.402474612,
-0.4658905268,
-0.0617936626,
0.0862671286,
0.4208829403,
0.5103361607,
-0.807217598,
-0.067233108,
0.0640527382,
-1.0030937195,
-0.2707417011,
0.0559077747,
-0.263217479,
-0.0221660398,
0.0708754882,
-0.1852511466,
0.7388030887,
0.2674693465,
-0.3477709293,
0.2434062362,
0.2211816758,
0.2315094322,
-0.694245398,
0.2225760221,
0.0730599612,
-0.2791204453,
-0.896916151,
0.1022434384,
0.0251859836,
-0.0955231786,
-0.5095882416,
0.8417853713,
-0.0832620636,
0.0733283982,
-0.1960254163,
0.0889085382,
-0.1520426124,
0.3678734601,
0.0765049383,
0.350697726,
0.5374783278,
-0.4613319337,
0.1717965454,
0.6162875891,
-0.2233816832,
0.6993653178,
-0.525534153,
0.1425209343,
-0.3108554482,
0.4091743529,
-0.539951086,
-0.324403137,
0.5936191082,
-0.3053618968,
0.0890476555,
-0.3304597735,
-0.2068330348,
-0.2064988911,
-0.5158560276,
0.8467091918,
0.6481765509,
-0.658778429,
0.7098872662,
0.61081779,
-0.3378706276,
-0.906101346,
-0.4463042021,
-0.0113151269,
-0.4704794288,
-0.4514729679,
-0.0003299357,
0.0141414702,
-0.2441470027,
-0.2709617615,
-0.2351016849,
-0.0979834348,
0.1253256798,
0.3428207636,
0.4060148001,
0.1605877876,
0.034651909,
0.0538881049,
-0.1475748569,
0.0329412073,
-0.3170655668,
0.3051512241,
0.1249695122,
-0.1477388144,
-0.3744964302,
0.5892003775,
0.4359408021,
-0.1142513677,
0.7520490289,
0.4655415416,
-0.3812211752,
-0.1768493801,
-0.5395283699,
-0.0280364323,
-0.449944973,
0.1778015196,
-0.0643069372,
-0.8803572655,
0.6332243681,
-0.0443624817,
0.374406606,
0.1092629433,
0.5356965661,
-0.0099476203,
0.7982125878,
0.7125607133,
-0.384850055,
0.1765733361,
-0.222038269,
0.2275032848,
-0.9228545427,
-0.2854379714,
-0.5958774686,
-0.2399458885,
-0.2837193012,
-0.5964285731,
0.6999965906,
-0.3097857535,
-0.4791987836,
-0.3829538822,
-0.3713463247,
0.1573908478,
0.0743861794,
0.1197882295,
0.3170774877,
0.0299292468,
0.2329659015,
-0.0430646352,
-0.9693837166,
-0.6092001796,
1.2167420387,
0.478107065,
0.9311419725,
0.0926145911,
0.6502383351,
0.6760981083,
0.9357373714,
-0.8038718104,
0.519950211,
0.0810468495,
-0.6175730824,
-0.1085071713,
-0.4177699983,
-0.7985439301,
0.331111908,
-0.1715779155,
-0.5427085161,
0.4254778028,
0.151029706,
-0.4640765488,
0.1006073728,
-0.1205221564,
0.4326211214,
-0.0214756466,
-0.2773186266,
-0.0892444476,
-0.8283398151,
0.1834415346,
-0.1580750197,
0.716334343,
-0.0675878376,
-0.17171745,
0.5820707679,
-0.2392483056,
1.1309629679,
-0.3188098967,
-0.4112020433,
0.2509400249,
0.1084598005,
0.4722329676,
0.3498240709,
-0.2130297571,
0.5354827642,
-0.6244815588,
-0.515100956,
-0.5647283792,
0.6223835349,
-0.6855596304,
-0.5704748631,
-0.3975159228,
-0.7364262342,
-0.4415996075,
0.0128337517,
0.2173481137,
0.6127977371,
-0.5295501947,
-0.1269491762,
0.7536058426,
-0.3412133455,
0.0553943664,
0.5380505919,
-0.0158731677,
-0.1880249232,
0.6280432343,
0.2526689768,
-0.103959322,
0.0378357954,
0.1767350435,
-0.3284931481,
-0.457644403,
-0.6199652553,
-0.0442847013,
-0.6455043554,
-0.4794760048,
-0.7502925396,
-0.0243959613,
-0.4550950527,
-0.5390916467,
-0.1292287707,
-0.2907814682,
-0.1659364849,
-0.0645042881,
0.1993785501,
0.4430128634,
-0.0821096674,
0.1001361459,
-0.9915960431,
0.6133362651,
0.0466655381,
0.3110058904,
0.0750895515,
-0.8720775247,
-0.2083943784,
0.0631743744,
-0.1764984578,
-0.6655490398,
0.0954321995,
0.2276866287,
0.6279169917,
0.3813906312,
0.3244362772,
0.4513968527,
-0.688380599,
0.5678138137,
0.0919717848,
-0.9520017505,
0.7268750668,
-0.4672250152,
0.1428930014,
0.4595904648,
0.299511075,
-0.4548860192,
-0.2802668512,
-0.6632213593,
-0.7957847714,
0.7872697115,
0.3069613874,
-0.0080266576,
0.0905726999,
0.2702753544,
0.25124529,
0.2816584706,
-0.4716887772,
-0.0980035663,
-0.3446315229,
-0.3563892841,
0.1382660121,
-0.1444963813,
-0.7187017202,
-0.2225370705,
0.4647874534,
-0.2870990634,
-0.1998874694,
0.2632940114,
-0.3111870587,
-0.0768745542,
0.4309830666,
0.25409922,
0.4085945189,
0.0124176005,
0.0576673709,
0.4584300518,
-0.5003526807,
0.3843585849,
-0.0388380364,
-0.1562473327,
-0.2593675554,
0.4727953076,
0.0453029238,
0.1144773886,
-0.9206694365,
0.5855984092,
-0.0572820082,
-0.0157049,
0.1269664168,
0.0180735271,
-0.5649627447,
0.3999136984,
0.2736441493,
0.0965671837,
0.6560348868,
-0.4727430344,
0.264500916,
0.3225080669,
-0.1314989626,
-0.4326099455,
0.3223710656,
0.6611366272,
-0.0400793701,
0.4471638799,
-0.0062139551,
-0.4658512771,
0.3485171497,
0.3412653208,
0.858003974,
-0.6275408268,
0.4050659239,
0.2031269073,
0.3074437082,
0.1144631207,
0.478100121,
-0.2343622148,
-0.893404901,
-0.2163224518,
-0.6489590406,
-0.1293969303,
0.060919527,
-1.031144619,
-0.194699645,
-0.6480136514,
-0.2119888812,
-0.2883468866,
-0.3630104661,
-0.9566490054,
0.3022640944,
0.0766264051,
0.8358624578,
-0.8383574486,
0.4400016963,
0.693872571,
0.0966621265,
-0.2446860075,
0.133864522,
0.2610041499,
-0.823135376,
0.6944095492,
0.1148372889,
-0.3392965496,
-0.2325882465,
-0.5250878334,
-0.560069859,
0.5467173457,
0.2321322858,
-0.4703334272,
0.0954871029,
0.1968035698,
0.3908759654,
-0.41071859,
-0.2716799676,
0.8231861591,
0.5302786231,
-0.2614324093,
-0.8301848173,
0.2334787697,
-0.1004225016,
0.1223334968,
0.1378097981,
-0.4586266577,
0.31062904,
-0.3249466121,
-0.1732411087,
-0.1285305619,
0.4774730802,
0.179378137,
0.4531358182,
0.4394584596,
0.4682622254,
0.712311089,
0.0182468109,
1.0988798141,
0.076399371,
0.502774477,
0.958130002,
-0.6005144715,
0.3399736285,
0.3982689083,
0.0047499589,
0.3779204786,
0.3776750565,
0.318392396,
0.6170727015,
0.2926624417,
-0.5639086366,
-0.2520990074,
-0.5032215118,
-0.356654495,
0.549399972,
0.519929409,
-0.1501961052,
-0.4691331089,
0.3005190492,
-0.0508326143,
-0.0639296696,
-0.5122488141,
0.651022017,
-0.0535101742,
-0.0856866315,
0.566072464,
0.0097604068,
0.5612415075,
-0.1818214208,
-0.0591275357,
-0.0596989654,
-0.0653477386,
-0.4163871706,
-0.7166142464,
0.3258517385,
0.440417707,
-0.3184868991,
-0.0616189614,
0.6933782697,
-0.0461567678,
-0.3683991134,
0.2778577507,
0.6757420301,
-0.2185319066,
0.171441406,
-0.6522598267,
0.356128037,
-0.2212192267,
-0.3624648452,
0.3624078929,
0.4321870506,
-0.2567697763,
0.7539971471,
0.6190053225,
-0.0728151128,
-0.2506524324,
0.3914774954,
1.1232436895,
-0.6913059354,
-0.6276328564,
-0.7251657844,
0.7430437207,
-0.1396494955,
-0.2890738547,
0.6557343602,
0.3596437871,
0.5807091594,
-0.0091462703,
1.2049217224,
-0.1068986952,
0.3463038504,
-0.3375018537,
0.4434779286,
-0.4138124287,
0.3629398048,
-0.2504034638,
-0.7122470737,
-0.4372587204,
0.6057621241,
-0.1734256297,
0.0488334149,
0.0674009994,
0.4813410044,
-0.2049364001,
-0.1200540736,
0.219686985,
0.1293412447,
0.4287692904,
0.2872013748,
0.8733804226,
-0.2165732384,
0.2474239618,
0.1930317134,
-0.6629935503,
-0.2762840986,
-0.6638754606,
-1.0088605881,
-0.1809256077,
-0.0170563515,
-0.3151936233,
0.197115764,
0.8700919151,
0.7135254741,
-0.7810762525,
-0.0773967057,
0.2245791405,
0.0354471765,
0.1244595647,
-0.1790686101,
0.1495499164,
-0.1092381701,
-0.4567932189,
0.247506842,
0.5056195855,
-0.1824416965,
-0.2506355643,
-0.1327185035,
0.0591108128,
0.3334037364,
0.8132912517,
0.3526510298,
-0.696421504,
-0.5591458678,
-0.1568106115,
0.0973868296,
0.0254075397,
1.101600647,
-0.9572505951,
0.4348607957,
0.2334788293,
0.9722143412,
-0.2132980824,
0.1635874063,
0.5025219321,
-0.9213469625,
0.3577498496,
0.6013171077,
0.1940715611,
0.3347067237,
-0.647937119,
0.5615392327,
0.0290100109,
-0.5648014545,
-0.9226077795,
0.3105362952,
-0.9125077128,
-0.1116121188,
1.0376707315,
-0.0891243815,
0.0148398215,
-0.7574323416,
-0.2934323251,
0.2112335414,
-0.5064935088,
1.1588490009,
0.489277333,
-0.2998377681,
0.1481418014,
-0.5168902278,
0.4633882344,
0.3047324121,
-0.9757506251,
0.1179751307,
0.5545012951,
0.3374803364,
-0.0778240785,
0.74365592,
-0.1337431371,
0.4359026551,
-0.4610382318,
0.1239917353,
0.2694720924,
-0.5690444112,
-0.4113142788,
0.2217365652,
-0.3039385676,
0.0158545151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16755v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16755v2 | Can large language models generate salient negative statements? | 2023-05-26T09:13:59 | 2023-09-21T13:36:03 | Hiba Arnaout, Simon Razniewski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We examine the ability of large language models (LLMs) to generate salient
(interesting) negative statements about real-world entities; an emerging
research topic of the last few years. We probe the LLMs using zero- and k-shot
unconstrained probes, and compare with traditional methods for negation
generation, i.e., pattern-based textual extractions and knowledge-graph-based
inferences, as well as crowdsourced gold statements. We measure the correctness
and salience of the generated lists about subjects from different domains. Our
evaluation shows that guided probes do in fact improve the quality of generated
negatives, compared to the zero-shot variant. Nevertheless, using both prompts,
LLMs still struggle with the notion of factuality of negatives, frequently
generating many ambiguous statements, or statements with negative keywords but
a positive meaning. | [
-0.4755537212,
-1.0152108669,
0.7670292854,
-0.1762863994,
-0.2942162752,
-0.3400601149,
-0.4301488698,
-0.6680224538,
0.4210473299,
0.6075028181,
-0.4953198433,
-0.6541077495,
-0.6004276276,
0.1975448281,
-0.6179166436,
1.0175080299,
0.5384417772,
-0.0524369739,
-0.161877498,
0.1448454857,
-0.4720655382,
-0.6310261488,
-0.4716573954,
-0.2945721149,
0.9522436857,
0.5167057514,
0.7056533694,
0.3274995983,
0.3378967941,
0.1382349432,
-0.0383280739,
-0.0099406252,
-0.5129498243,
0.5284414291,
-0.3919114769,
-0.5137701035,
-0.0834560171,
0.1143592745,
0.4421153963,
0.8233596683,
0.2777558267,
0.312793076,
-0.2423799038,
0.3268539906,
-0.646192193,
-0.0340699591,
-0.7553042173,
-0.0635701865,
-0.3123492897,
-0.0820224732,
-0.538202107,
-0.3557813168,
0.2319640666,
-0.1482556015,
0.2703177333,
-0.0325134769,
1.2401872873,
0.2383723259,
-0.6221446991,
-0.5205344558,
-0.721344769,
0.966560781,
-1.0357651711,
0.2857951522,
0.3038446605,
0.2628277242,
-0.1583485752,
-0.2108677924,
-0.6638452411,
-0.5948782563,
-0.0718884543,
-0.0697272718,
-0.15626432,
-0.0499117412,
0.4610758722,
0.0279206932,
-0.3502140939,
0.3512708843,
-0.2535519302,
-0.1584224254,
0.8839742541,
0.0745526999,
0.1340598166,
-0.514775753,
0.1560079604,
0.2325956225,
-1.1656355858,
-0.3998810351,
0.5118592978,
0.5511471033,
0.0185699333,
0.7972206473,
-0.2600460947,
0.9124736786,
0.0158374775,
-0.1982266456,
-0.1305418462,
-0.0323014371,
-0.1271090209,
0.1905226707,
0.5787332058,
0.4866127372,
0.2950586081,
-0.3601101041,
-0.1896526068,
0.4050604701,
-0.0718925446,
-0.8624209762,
-0.1604109704,
0.241315946,
-0.1613221616,
-0.2358063161,
0.0118265226,
-0.7185639739,
-0.6625667214,
-0.351633966,
0.270454973,
-0.1294472665,
-0.1159442216,
0.1210757792,
-0.1081664562,
0.2085239142,
0.468403548,
-0.5204316974,
0.0694164485,
0.6280235648,
0.5447100401,
0.099745661,
0.0267772526,
-0.910875082,
0.1491230726,
-0.5936415195,
0.7507073879,
-0.7226745486,
-0.4233454168,
-0.0476152077,
-0.187548995,
0.4644694328,
-0.625009954,
0.4033949077,
-0.6226170659,
0.3585626781,
-0.6267889738,
-0.5039008856,
-0.3168595135,
0.5754985809,
-0.4194834232,
0.5273020267,
-0.1374582946,
-0.3078146577,
0.4325217009,
-0.506760478,
-0.4476460516,
0.1550844908,
-0.4755042493,
-0.3025540709,
0.3081106544,
-0.1338914931,
0.6352243423,
-0.5773640275,
0.6373654008,
-0.403239876,
-0.3674253821,
0.6087366343,
-0.3664568365,
0.4642674625,
0.0469991677,
-0.6708701849,
-0.0964253172,
-0.6965191364,
-0.2173165828,
0.1272751093,
-0.1528755426,
-0.4498997629,
0.0037756525,
-0.4774877429,
0.4476073384,
0.0584495105,
-0.704518199,
0.1563159972,
-0.355568409,
0.2312506437,
0.5654704571,
0.3372732103,
0.0821334049,
-0.0567507483,
0.4989162982,
0.0975052789,
-0.2088680714,
-0.2940223515,
-0.5133250952,
-0.9437729716,
-0.0636850744,
0.2173304856,
0.2334989309,
-0.4284458756,
0.1986688673,
0.0394828655,
-0.528234601,
-0.3685687482,
-0.1720414162,
0.4910973907,
0.8431372643,
0.1923637837,
0.0361023583,
-0.4453969002,
-0.9279218316,
-0.3496188521,
-0.0912620947,
0.2413177639,
0.6298330426,
0.5432403684,
-0.2902415097,
0.6579960585,
-0.6245331168,
0.1524372995,
0.1875778586,
0.2941586077,
0.297423929,
0.0968088061,
0.6182501316,
-0.9053869843,
-0.3978930712,
-0.307861954,
-0.6956621408,
-0.3358702958,
-0.0597356409,
0.0701724514,
0.2493250817,
0.3590140939,
-0.890725553,
0.1154842377,
0.6056228876,
-0.5716884136,
0.8218762875,
0.2811203599,
0.1326393932,
-0.8808709383,
0.0866624117,
0.2870510817,
-0.1580125391,
-0.5808866024,
0.1267926097,
-0.0803314671,
-0.2079595029,
-0.452732116,
0.7097523808,
-0.5844044685,
-0.1021315306,
-0.3159629405,
0.4244759679,
0.1159222052,
0.1252637804,
-0.042478051,
0.5204831362,
0.5528231859,
-0.9406291246,
0.4444339573,
0.0182996392,
-0.25200665,
0.2833233178,
-0.5260007977,
-0.1825131476,
-0.3799338639,
0.1813439578,
-0.9559889436,
-0.5526373386,
0.2574521005,
-0.4110608697,
0.2557557225,
-0.1456523687,
-0.4507930279,
-0.402934581,
-0.2549667656,
0.3231107891,
0.6953125596,
-0.4155226052,
-0.0534867793,
0.1949045658,
-0.2727852762,
-0.6077436805,
-0.9382121563,
0.5022738576,
-0.2876604497,
-0.342607528,
-0.0444863662,
0.1399241686,
-0.7832260728,
0.0114157367,
0.3026816845,
0.3806666434,
0.1660258025,
0.3940659463,
0.3373964131,
-0.2703427374,
0.540636301,
-0.240600571,
-0.0681682974,
0.2242821306,
-0.1948148608,
0.5510387421,
-0.0625099167,
-0.7451950908,
-0.3444909751,
0.2932084203,
0.5073925853,
-0.2106410712,
0.7153149843,
0.2244218737,
-0.2586904466,
-0.0159455314,
-0.804159224,
-0.4143692851,
-0.3930127621,
0.2962044179,
-0.0274330433,
-1.1500647068,
0.3949278295,
-0.0929664895,
-0.0249207038,
0.6599667072,
0.5140908957,
0.0943523422,
1.1173012257,
0.4217717946,
0.3203938603,
0.2512466311,
-0.0800067484,
0.562848866,
-0.51658535,
-0.0865570456,
-0.623421073,
-0.1330795437,
-0.7250227928,
-0.2834053934,
0.4475432932,
0.2060598135,
-0.2482854575,
-0.1944215894,
-0.4904244244,
0.55203408,
0.4983456135,
-0.3007980883,
0.1112729907,
-0.2283018976,
0.1710311025,
-0.1960928291,
-0.3425423801,
-0.8588340282,
1.0060971975,
0.141155839,
0.7147421837,
0.317495048,
0.7334389687,
0.2861335874,
0.7543360591,
-1.0105754137,
0.6466728449,
-0.0892786533,
-0.6860146523,
-0.2614919543,
-0.3711017668,
-0.6029723287,
0.1707986742,
-0.3453341722,
-0.7337577343,
0.1662181467,
0.3600776196,
-0.5090329051,
0.2857944965,
-0.765950799,
0.5607538819,
-0.4208682775,
-0.4739196002,
0.04739419,
-0.4780919254,
0.6772863865,
-0.2246476412,
0.012737033,
-0.2617360055,
-0.0404893458,
0.42198807,
-0.135235548,
1.0685306787,
-0.4216677547,
-0.655783236,
0.6173359752,
0.2708587646,
0.712220788,
0.1289984435,
-0.5376029611,
0.1691151708,
-0.5006031394,
-0.4176189303,
-0.4546504915,
0.7686418891,
-0.5299895406,
-0.9612355828,
-0.1153029278,
-0.4413283169,
-0.1854669303,
0.421669811,
0.1744448543,
0.5659947991,
-0.2301549613,
0.0436914787,
0.5829899311,
-0.6711149216,
0.2653914094,
0.7823608518,
-0.2334259003,
0.1576272845,
1.0835829973,
0.3846197128,
0.362650007,
0.3649896681,
0.1127659157,
-0.3137054741,
-0.6056861281,
-0.3329198062,
0.5691444278,
-0.6357752681,
-0.3307851553,
-0.5769324303,
-0.0366464779,
-0.548784554,
-0.216700539,
-0.2080175728,
-0.5181850195,
-0.3163837492,
-0.1413557082,
0.2967839837,
0.8761015534,
-0.0768261775,
0.0315327793,
-0.8243774176,
0.2229528278,
0.4589960873,
0.0081272833,
-0.0172647107,
-0.3115752935,
-0.2217998356,
0.306016624,
-0.2038006634,
-0.8968323469,
0.4479255378,
-0.1171371639,
0.1472077668,
0.5875117779,
0.2124640644,
0.5528439283,
-0.3901531696,
1.3315740824,
0.1956278533,
-0.7925165892,
0.4402101338,
-0.6995719671,
0.3176137209,
0.0950672328,
0.400834322,
-0.7383440733,
-0.6926234365,
-0.6248787045,
-0.6781956553,
0.4715279937,
-0.2204754204,
0.3932512105,
-0.5200530887,
0.6259230971,
0.3652257323,
0.5542243719,
-0.6470587254,
-0.2681565881,
-0.0402306691,
0.1325868666,
-0.2226659805,
-0.5427803993,
-0.1578226835,
0.1984303743,
0.8775972724,
-0.1604948342,
0.1206579134,
0.1321777403,
0.054010611,
-0.3981668651,
0.5772764683,
0.8301909566,
0.7145008445,
-0.1133133471,
0.5347015262,
-0.0204277113,
0.1219804659,
0.1148198396,
-0.0646967068,
-0.5038917065,
0.2102477401,
0.3395270109,
0.6220260859,
-0.0494720191,
-0.9539417624,
0.5431195498,
0.1064738035,
-0.189793393,
-0.0992592797,
0.0293722898,
0.1884997487,
0.3295641243,
0.3087428808,
-0.2471095622,
0.0411396511,
-0.5866187811,
-0.1021644473,
0.740967989,
-0.177565828,
-0.525832653,
0.5671744943,
0.2621529698,
-0.201887235,
0.5707820058,
-0.4894731343,
-0.4678767622,
0.5261150002,
0.5854613781,
0.7042998672,
0.0710099339,
0.4652455747,
0.2862853706,
0.1676600873,
0.1471106708,
0.139624238,
-0.0001712134,
-0.7227372527,
-0.6986538768,
-0.4894253016,
-0.5488926172,
0.495038718,
-0.4842157364,
0.3167913258,
-0.2748442292,
-0.3098617494,
0.0755281299,
0.0115199815,
-0.3909601271,
0.3401354253,
0.5178634524,
0.4543501139,
-0.7715770006,
0.3757563531,
0.6874681711,
-0.4017232656,
-0.6728904843,
0.1380811036,
-0.0055175154,
-0.591135025,
1.0128437281,
0.1601471007,
-0.2767327726,
-0.2175649405,
-1.022793293,
-0.9960147142,
0.7483888268,
0.7029883265,
-0.7010992765,
-0.071888119,
0.0765783191,
0.5714702606,
-0.0751816705,
-0.0340417475,
0.0373130813,
0.620842278,
-0.0213046633,
-0.676368773,
0.3078231514,
-0.0024379455,
-0.3200446665,
0.5215082169,
-0.882077992,
1.2951465845,
-0.449283123,
-0.3653615713,
-0.0762302279,
0.4387280047,
0.3512900472,
0.2023606598,
0.1444335133,
0.4291871786,
0.816382885,
-0.0165882278,
1.1183040142,
-0.3510974646,
0.2680619359,
1.1832401752,
-0.4963422418,
0.4418906868,
0.5948722363,
0.3698745668,
0.4970353246,
0.5554891229,
-0.2802097201,
0.2780323327,
0.29400599,
-0.3033645153,
-0.4764516652,
-0.5878676772,
-0.4259901047,
0.2958358228,
0.594778955,
-0.4558792412,
-0.4692030251,
-0.2497862577,
0.1159109026,
-0.011231387,
-0.1742717475,
0.5360384583,
0.2260531783,
-0.9279198647,
0.7370512486,
0.3120088577,
0.7921347618,
-0.4344191849,
-0.2860957384,
-0.0222393721,
0.0257978309,
-0.3483515382,
-0.5930597186,
0.1262036115,
0.270829618,
-0.1741079241,
-0.1686015427,
0.9398888946,
-0.3964709342,
-0.1554343402,
0.0413399003,
0.7344202995,
0.3949862719,
0.0026661421,
-0.4819544852,
-0.1672317535,
0.0085262163,
-0.3456694782,
0.2190709114,
0.5485202074,
-0.1566828787,
0.5122342706,
0.5443618894,
0.2554942667,
0.0761707202,
0.2880001962,
0.7748851776,
-0.8814997673,
-0.3010142148,
-1.0146973133,
0.2713949978,
-0.0668820292,
-0.0958589688,
1.2315458059,
0.3807759285,
0.83965832,
0.0831421316,
1.0432137251,
0.0765758902,
0.6172220111,
-0.4154909551,
0.3533506989,
-0.4870835245,
0.2899054885,
-0.3796818852,
-0.8052610755,
-0.5323498249,
0.3426781595,
-0.7858956456,
0.0521959811,
0.2753483057,
0.9556549788,
0.105910562,
-0.1032735705,
0.5126290321,
0.506313026,
0.5711643696,
0.3372940719,
1.1989587545,
-0.1959103644,
0.2918428779,
-0.0132478727,
0.1497291625,
-0.4552652538,
-0.8693900704,
-0.8837654591,
-0.2124256343,
-0.4246824086,
-0.363137126,
0.0408212915,
0.7332125902,
0.4813432693,
-0.6829867959,
0.0435508713,
-0.1391242445,
0.1592992842,
0.3516483605,
-0.3596106172,
0.3297096491,
-0.1711481065,
-0.6780445576,
0.2024620324,
0.3869076073,
0.3288364708,
-0.5463254452,
-0.08834178,
-0.2568711638,
0.2275034636,
0.7636487484,
0.290405035,
-0.72660923,
-0.5285859108,
-0.0768279359,
-0.1310759932,
-0.3079512715,
0.6144598126,
-0.7601191998,
0.1537181884,
0.1653120071,
0.4777524471,
0.257989198,
-0.0232234504,
0.4641785324,
-0.7077018619,
0.163026154,
0.4913361371,
0.1791388392,
0.5406327844,
-0.5164778233,
0.2515617013,
0.1831549853,
-0.4376203418,
-1.1201335192,
0.519352138,
-0.2709238827,
-0.3725865781,
1.5360200405,
0.0762773007,
-0.2425097674,
0.0689446703,
-0.1121438667,
0.2006783932,
-0.4537192881,
0.916308105,
0.7703266144,
-0.4186472893,
0.146600917,
-0.4791028798,
0.2240082771,
0.5940098166,
-0.7225491405,
0.1338604987,
1.0169746876,
0.2198412865,
0.5174586773,
0.4595376253,
-0.0624590404,
0.0957251415,
-0.0803916007,
0.0164036341,
-0.0051547838,
-0.2633493841,
-0.2573410273,
0.1616364568,
0.3126448989,
0.1235430241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16750v1 | Automating the Analysis of Institutional Design in International Agreements | 2023-05-26T08:57:11 | 2023-05-26T08:57:11 | Anna Wróblewska, Bartosz Pieliński, Karolina Seweryn, Sylwia Sysko-Romańczuk, Karol Saputa, Aleksandra Wichrowska, Hanna Schreiber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This paper explores the automatic knowledge extraction of formal
institutional design - norms, rules, and actors - from international
agreements. The focus was to analyze the relationship between the visibility
and centrality of actors in the formal institutional design in regulating
critical aspects of cultural heritage relations. The developed tool utilizes
techniques such as collecting legal documents, annotating them with
Institutional Grammar, and using graph analysis to explore the formal
institutional design. The system was tested against the 2003 UNESCO Convention
for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage. | [
-0.7576104999,
-0.6984852552,
0.2955268919,
0.0977533907,
-0.3625447154,
0.1004990488,
0.0070763775,
-0.9180938005,
0.0789044648,
0.762799859,
-0.2051589638,
-0.4091070592,
-0.592721343,
0.3660993874,
-0.1441415995,
0.6260815263,
-0.8235853314,
-0.1581392735,
-0.1688568592,
-0.2227834016,
-0.300193578,
0.0166691616,
-0.4990813434,
-0.1852939129,
-0.0313697793,
0.3806477189,
0.3488995433,
0.66692698,
0.89286834,
0.427752167,
0.0977948979,
0.1535553932,
-0.3527457416,
-0.1864043623,
-0.2229491025,
0.1317645907,
-0.4570475519,
0.4511185586,
0.6964461207,
0.1061335206,
0.5549733043,
0.6365045905,
0.1663958281,
0.4942615926,
-0.4697104692,
1.113576889,
-0.2530470192,
0.0614344105,
0.0619825348,
-0.4748283327,
-0.116989933,
-0.3909932375,
0.2010564655,
-0.7760244608,
-0.3897797167,
0.2657659054,
1.0642111301,
0.0907317922,
-0.6027116179,
-0.5167781711,
-0.5885404944,
0.4116231799,
-0.3865457773,
0.1992447376,
0.4831641316,
0.1855978966,
-0.1740812212,
-0.8699259758,
-0.5418532491,
-0.2978741229,
-0.6653389335,
0.0646538511,
-0.0888706446,
0.0693164542,
0.3272469044,
0.5876199603,
-0.4541987479,
-0.1223637983,
-0.8289237618,
-0.2128715664,
0.8668380976,
-0.1061621904,
0.9162632823,
-0.3723934889,
-0.3295428157,
0.1621768475,
-0.626373589,
0.1771586537,
0.2753593624,
-0.0400838442,
-0.1332876235,
0.287225455,
-0.4495946765,
0.1924269199,
-0.0388733968,
-0.0353213772,
0.0215313789,
-0.406973958,
-0.2023799866,
-0.1189448982,
0.8962621689,
0.4406983256,
0.590583086,
-0.3968013525,
-0.2796820402,
-0.0570543222,
0.2161024362,
-0.5797724128,
-0.0503876247,
-0.0731753781,
-0.6749809384,
-0.4167005122,
0.4952945411,
-0.3576239049,
0.2108789086,
-0.9042485356,
0.3467459977,
-0.0294341557,
-0.4070157409,
-0.3824104667,
-0.499767065,
0.5156106949,
0.0468994677,
-0.5327515006,
0.3877205551,
0.6503062248,
0.7076838613,
-0.0678381771,
0.0054274667,
-0.0837819055,
0.3417695463,
-0.407333374,
0.5746027231,
-0.2416280508,
-0.6827260852,
0.0372529812,
0.4875860512,
0.2670418322,
-0.1893294305,
0.4449642897,
-0.7800557613,
-0.1007040814,
-0.1460348666,
-0.3732245564,
-0.4375190437,
0.3965150118,
-0.9823321104,
0.5034430027,
0.311922282,
-0.3292424977,
0.8008628488,
-0.9369750023,
-0.2833259106,
0.2801775038,
-0.5704445243,
-0.2878391147,
-0.0855095237,
-0.0465731025,
0.0650690421,
-0.1831558049,
0.4021703601,
-0.2762166858,
-0.333723098,
0.0171030201,
0.228299439,
0.9842324257,
0.4686863124,
-0.5642033815,
0.1869710982,
-0.7721809149,
-0.1920307577,
-0.0174962971,
-0.534337163,
-0.3802811205,
-0.0922710374,
-0.0882648751,
0.490203619,
0.2175327986,
-0.3708437085,
0.4046301544,
-0.0689230338,
0.197557494,
0.8495788574,
0.3920786977,
0.7877656221,
-0.2938713431,
0.3002283871,
-0.4339605272,
0.3280538321,
0.2813092172,
-0.1693075448,
-0.6432957053,
-0.2147444189,
0.0490728579,
0.3506095409,
-0.4636085629,
0.2870883644,
-0.3449598849,
-0.1606814563,
-0.3583238423,
0.0386496261,
0.4698497951,
0.1234552041,
-0.1600789726,
-0.6530144215,
-0.8199871778,
-0.9819915891,
-0.2690399587,
-0.4507570267,
0.2409878522,
0.3407789767,
0.7965311408,
-0.2626418471,
1.0452368259,
0.0780465901,
-0.5469380021,
0.0895483568,
0.4051977992,
0.0490962081,
0.6953785419,
0.8502936363,
-0.6785013676,
-0.542977035,
0.3632139564,
-1.1186295748,
-0.0384720452,
0.1350135654,
-0.5021874905,
0.1201216727,
0.576013267,
-0.0764013603,
0.7839692235,
-0.162454918,
-0.4433407187,
0.6266335249,
0.1107880473,
0.5572344065,
-0.5283560753,
0.2260260582,
-0.2694254816,
0.0477606691,
-0.3897251785,
0.4049126208,
0.0788953081,
0.0046268557,
-0.315890938,
0.8456439376,
-0.6843568087,
0.0770042688,
0.0113335429,
0.3160464168,
0.1313620955,
0.4569179714,
0.1539224535,
0.4793370962,
0.3303227127,
-0.7176511288,
0.0822037756,
0.677554667,
-0.3556568623,
0.9325214624,
-0.2795217931,
0.2240052521,
-0.1055743694,
0.0926828012,
-0.6634198427,
-0.2393595725,
0.4651747346,
-0.1720946282,
0.445456326,
-0.7314515114,
-0.3269625902,
-0.3103192747,
-0.2187490016,
0.3738951087,
0.2109891623,
-0.2684345841,
0.8494641185,
0.8842560053,
0.0417191088,
-0.5632718205,
-0.4235116541,
0.1964672506,
-0.1782164574,
-0.9642847776,
-0.0951655284,
-0.1430395395,
-1.0539278984,
0.1243060976,
0.0641149431,
-0.1991544366,
0.3034019768,
0.509980917,
0.052923739,
-0.2091885805,
-0.4355559945,
-0.0146044074,
-0.2919580936,
0.5025935769,
-0.3300875127,
-0.0001401504,
-0.2975127697,
-0.2326005846,
-0.9400163293,
0.3887122273,
0.8734057546,
-0.3511694372,
0.3320475221,
0.4017651677,
-0.3311862648,
0.0290295929,
-0.4275845885,
0.005013274,
-0.4788739979,
-0.1297007352,
-0.641623497,
-0.1919561923,
0.6822028756,
-0.1385186017,
0.5146403313,
0.7723810077,
0.4855023921,
0.1781272739,
0.590803504,
0.5713653564,
-0.0362065323,
0.5142614245,
-0.8528830409,
-0.0657138899,
-0.8019654155,
-0.3806550503,
-0.5842078328,
-0.4615244865,
-0.6231672764,
0.2089132667,
0.329824537,
-0.2580572963,
0.0105893426,
0.3176091909,
-0.3384734392,
0.4505693913,
0.4640603364,
-0.0984125733,
0.5932806134,
-0.3408251703,
-0.0805462226,
0.3174546063,
-0.102567561,
-0.9247125983,
0.73873806,
0.2188395709,
0.6310533881,
0.1600338817,
0.7854320407,
0.6377035379,
0.5670130849,
-0.6440901756,
0.2715851963,
0.2599140108,
-0.5494289398,
-0.3610278666,
-0.1559576392,
-0.4597655535,
0.1201695353,
-0.1335399151,
-0.7345361114,
1.0129598379,
-0.1705195457,
-0.1174107641,
0.4594828188,
-0.2746938169,
0.5883012414,
0.0314524882,
-0.0942585468,
-0.1136344448,
-0.4705806077,
0.5096901655,
-0.1864940673,
0.688354075,
-0.0586183108,
0.549977541,
0.9674347043,
-0.0726655647,
0.5043472648,
0.0651595071,
-0.1938297302,
0.5601996183,
0.5906409621,
0.8392510414,
0.1963880956,
-0.1864976138,
0.1007168218,
0.2442362905,
-0.0139333224,
-0.3152154088,
0.6138446927,
-1.0739789009,
-0.3736448884,
-0.0931625515,
-0.4153119624,
0.3510846198,
0.3404158354,
0.0841388106,
0.3987333477,
-0.704002142,
0.1198932454,
0.3390440047,
0.3533224165,
0.4038667083,
0.7010219097,
0.1172089204,
-0.2998004258,
0.6840130687,
0.5762680173,
0.0386875831,
0.055479154,
0.0688844994,
-0.1080417931,
-0.6463025212,
-0.2381467223,
0.0067660636,
-0.882668972,
-0.0649647936,
-0.4697875679,
-0.2243881524,
-0.7297927737,
-0.4095453024,
0.3028757572,
-0.5744864941,
-0.2833886743,
-0.2524844408,
-0.0055892509,
1.1098465919,
-0.5284212232,
0.0433743298,
-0.4542580843,
0.4216450751,
0.2889388204,
0.2394672334,
-0.5424966812,
-0.2943099141,
-0.1645220518,
-0.3953133821,
-0.1567846835,
-0.7213103175,
0.1197467893,
0.2007331252,
0.8095030189,
0.9514518976,
0.2388232052,
0.4477780759,
-0.3938979506,
0.4329936504,
-0.3394048512,
-0.759160161,
0.4428084195,
-0.2846738994,
-0.1856484562,
0.5879952312,
0.221124202,
-0.5282736421,
-0.9229832888,
-0.9779909849,
-0.8027650118,
0.5547841191,
0.1600899547,
-0.1926058531,
-0.0197241064,
0.4887490869,
0.0144785941,
-0.2042562068,
-0.6099183559,
0.0922468081,
0.1855549812,
0.0790482089,
0.4451125264,
-0.404073745,
-0.6710709333,
0.0136170266,
0.9258221388,
-0.0258905832,
-0.1349498034,
0.3256453574,
-0.6451126337,
-0.3491240144,
0.201760307,
0.2924769819,
1.339056015,
0.0769441873,
0.2744891047,
0.1055788547,
-0.3135909438,
-0.0714636222,
-0.1098620445,
-0.2367214561,
-0.2327768058,
0.5255583525,
0.3316309452,
0.0939452723,
-0.0531905219,
0.1449553668,
-0.3875672817,
-0.359262675,
-0.5625923276,
-0.0096881632,
-0.5733678937,
0.5361472368,
0.1836870015,
-0.2937499285,
0.2117846608,
-0.68004179,
0.8216385841,
0.5179517865,
-0.5049108267,
-0.2649280429,
0.4350523949,
0.2795047462,
-0.5480944514,
0.669329524,
-0.0895719826,
-0.2373087406,
0.6552116275,
0.1393078417,
0.8197869062,
0.1780365556,
0.1863483787,
0.5747576952,
0.6019197106,
0.4416579008,
0.2154289931,
-0.3476631641,
-0.3571457863,
-0.0294968169,
-0.6788790822,
-0.2376223505,
-0.2698692679,
-0.6521924734,
0.2653493881,
-0.4404047728,
-0.062897943,
-0.2709322274,
0.4129250646,
-0.8670984507,
-0.0274701938,
0.0036749523,
0.6941986084,
-0.9163060784,
0.4562776983,
0.1270722896,
-0.868450582,
-0.5865710378,
-0.463026315,
0.3293489516,
-0.8079360723,
0.8414373398,
-0.347396642,
-0.0335961431,
-0.1204552129,
-0.5857192874,
-0.9318270087,
1.1442761421,
-0.0472413525,
-0.4380811155,
0.1003584787,
0.1388363242,
0.2426685691,
-0.4683086872,
0.0289601367,
1.0047756433,
0.9697728753,
-0.101290971,
-1.0904948711,
0.2464247793,
-0.5349364877,
-0.548691988,
0.235303089,
-0.3431527913,
0.5047411323,
0.1217086092,
-0.451407671,
-0.1025726944,
0.6922535896,
-0.0218631122,
0.1114382595,
0.6007969379,
0.18989411,
0.5652529597,
-0.2756791711,
0.7047085762,
-0.5865297914,
0.3623231947,
0.5548756719,
0.2371379882,
0.1632632464,
0.4082753956,
0.0857534036,
0.6508217454,
0.8417362571,
-0.1523818821,
0.3350814879,
0.2364803553,
0.0097335465,
0.1964955181,
-0.0769605413,
-0.2533739805,
0.5899929404,
0.4248999655,
-0.4096727967,
-0.1612665653,
-0.3971455097,
0.156740889,
-0.317021817,
-0.2920123339,
1.2913469076,
0.110296905,
-0.5416445136,
0.1248549893,
-0.303512305,
-0.1837834567,
-0.4526161253,
-0.255296737,
-0.1091054752,
-0.0529032089,
-0.2456733137,
-0.6298045516,
0.4177679121,
-0.4073828161,
0.0528939851,
-0.2143271714,
0.5751517415,
-0.2674423754,
-0.2933612168,
0.273925066,
0.2828873098,
0.2378530204,
0.2893539071,
-0.6275448799,
0.031385351,
-0.6023450494,
-0.1522797942,
-0.0391250253,
0.7741969228,
-0.6008274555,
0.2108322829,
0.5987371206,
0.0882182643,
-0.2110869735,
0.0231508985,
0.7029702067,
-0.3046954572,
-0.5428723097,
-0.7363880873,
0.5849664807,
-0.3361139596,
-0.0153787201,
0.4993565679,
0.3911383748,
0.7984543443,
0.0717808977,
0.6800389886,
-0.2888577878,
-0.5444222093,
-0.3791962266,
1.1148374081,
-0.3315389454,
-0.0775759816,
-0.5379071832,
-0.6067683697,
-0.3983541429,
0.474270761,
-0.2023943663,
-0.5215767026,
0.5607718229,
0.5552082658,
-0.1220947281,
-0.1063217521,
0.0613907762,
0.2234151959,
0.5997694135,
-0.187754944,
0.7400362492,
-0.0507227592,
0.4700649381,
-0.3528140485,
-0.5368731618,
-0.194059819,
-0.7242723703,
-0.8345556855,
-0.7369890809,
-0.1682399958,
-0.2763112485,
-0.1880585253,
0.7556848526,
0.5860085487,
-0.8361910582,
-0.5759695768,
0.3638317287,
0.4446259439,
-0.2292307615,
-0.2285314649,
0.7331923246,
-0.4214390516,
-0.5377673507,
0.2220571488,
0.4249204695,
0.0026844363,
-0.6176248789,
-0.1621250957,
-0.1506362557,
0.1557560563,
0.4968512654,
0.5836449862,
-0.6394744515,
-0.6278063059,
-0.5643820763,
0.0714339465,
-0.0352284685,
1.20639956,
-0.2853622437,
0.6866366267,
0.8958531022,
-0.0298704896,
0.1875677258,
-0.2538414598,
0.7744808793,
-0.5539826155,
0.151081875,
-0.0514293574,
0.7206194997,
-0.2055253237,
-0.5720482469,
0.7413796186,
0.1325243562,
-0.6880327463,
-0.5287488103,
0.1508063227,
-0.6957399845,
-0.0902112499,
0.8438631892,
-0.1942757368,
-0.6427931786,
-0.6960263848,
-0.3346299529,
0.3959124982,
-0.0913790539,
1.1778421402,
0.6264415383,
-0.2318837345,
0.3355064988,
-0.3841434121,
0.9008108377,
-0.7797181606,
-0.788005054,
-0.1965669841,
0.4954136312,
0.4621543884,
0.3589699268,
0.8748093247,
-0.5669485927,
0.3976426721,
-0.2854215205,
0.0986779183,
-0.0068701538,
-0.4122273028,
0.2232861817,
0.263727814,
-0.1165860221,
0.0462409928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16742v1 | Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning without Introducing New Latency | 2023-05-26T08:44:42 | 2023-05-26T08:44:42 | Baohao Liao, Yan Meng, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) of pre-trained language models has
recently demonstrated remarkable achievements, effectively matching the
performance of full fine-tuning while utilizing significantly fewer trainable
parameters, and consequently addressing the storage and communication
constraints. Nonetheless, various PEFT methods are limited by their inherent
characteristics. In the case of sparse fine-tuning, which involves modifying
only a small subset of the existing parameters, the selection of fine-tuned
parameters is task- and domain-specific, making it unsuitable for federated
learning. On the other hand, PEFT methods with adding new parameters typically
introduce additional inference latency. In this paper, we demonstrate the
feasibility of generating a sparse mask in a task-agnostic manner, wherein all
downstream tasks share a common mask. Our approach, which relies solely on the
magnitude information of pre-trained parameters, surpasses existing
methodologies by a significant margin when evaluated on the GLUE benchmark.
Additionally, we introduce a novel adapter technique that directly applies the
adapter to pre-trained parameters instead of the hidden representation, thereby
achieving identical inference speed to that of full fine-tuning. Through
extensive experiments, our proposed method attains a new state-of-the-art
outcome in terms of both performance and storage efficiency, storing only 0.03%
parameters of full fine-tuning. | [
-0.6055775881,
-0.8364988565,
0.4670489728,
0.1887667179,
-0.4967778027,
-0.1089542359,
-0.583782196,
-0.3456203341,
0.2620250285,
0.4054029882,
-0.7059839964,
-0.1924212277,
-0.4931533039,
-0.1563843191,
0.1072473302,
0.9400760531,
0.0154541405,
-0.457152009,
-0.0692817643,
-0.1221420988,
-0.1287429184,
-0.2009654492,
-0.6150679588,
-0.0089196544,
0.482717514,
0.3830137849,
0.4718307555,
0.7900284529,
0.1320030838,
0.2974834442,
0.1402172595,
0.4773034155,
-0.4366629422,
-0.0057492484,
-0.0715779066,
-0.2051321566,
-0.5488911867,
0.1430970877,
0.8889510632,
1.0469542742,
-0.0665254816,
0.3612824976,
0.405816853,
0.6589040756,
-1.1059188843,
0.1448802203,
-1.0126745701,
-0.0837531537,
-0.2242011875,
-0.2171353549,
-0.3500570059,
-0.0352207497,
-0.0534287989,
-0.9466183782,
0.5414028168,
-0.1379280388,
0.9674479961,
0.6812517643,
0.0531347394,
0.3440710902,
-0.7026702166,
0.8343501687,
-0.5395045877,
0.5961569548,
0.4320986569,
0.3277558088,
-0.0980737582,
-0.7001698017,
-0.4211813807,
0.094162181,
-0.1848529279,
-0.1729699522,
-0.0783277825,
0.3126807213,
0.1711487174,
0.2135595977,
-0.4235527217,
0.0353394076,
0.0219016671,
-0.3244571984,
0.5128496885,
-0.1836375594,
-0.392808795,
0.4908043742,
-0.1102015153,
0.0475364886,
-0.6372128129,
0.0158349089,
0.4594978094,
0.4874289632,
0.1665851027,
0.0059014377,
-0.6809367537,
0.9086193442,
0.6292434335,
0.0092127286,
0.130472526,
-0.3259512186,
-0.2220998555,
-0.31895715,
0.6272762418,
-0.1231409162,
0.0418319292,
-0.4333483577,
-0.1413488388,
-0.047741048,
0.1330017,
-1.1150841713,
-0.5388717055,
-0.1179394796,
-0.2995635271,
-0.0420471057,
-0.0662674159,
-0.5650250316,
-0.0077580418,
-0.2346611768,
0.6263408661,
-0.0339745022,
-0.1196516827,
0.1751621813,
0.3473769426,
-0.021643389,
0.5097134709,
-1.0055664778,
0.605459094,
0.574405551,
0.6272405386,
-0.3002169728,
-0.3439672887,
-1.1642743349,
-0.0022065355,
-0.2548115253,
0.8709074259,
-0.6178287864,
0.165062964,
-0.4188702703,
0.2805754542,
-0.2438631505,
-0.5658712387,
0.3574058712,
-0.3771419227,
-0.111726813,
0.0313597284,
-0.3317134082,
0.0040450282,
-0.1153578535,
-0.4696514606,
0.8778882623,
0.1508477032,
-0.2811901569,
0.5162363052,
-0.5034705997,
-0.5046121478,
0.110865809,
-0.1431856006,
-0.7382524014,
0.1790661961,
0.388052702,
0.707113564,
-0.1832896173,
0.3161893189,
-0.5332373977,
-0.7663667798,
-0.1638723612,
-0.5957818627,
0.362904191,
0.1727515161,
-0.5236366987,
-0.1160619333,
-0.9088280797,
0.1332430243,
-0.2057868987,
-0.4269717634,
-0.1707103252,
0.0436749756,
-0.122651808,
0.0876251906,
0.4938442111,
-0.6112783551,
0.0459518172,
-0.5320338607,
0.3538197875,
0.7601237297,
-0.0932352394,
0.5121108294,
-0.20958893,
0.2159250081,
-0.1806326807,
0.231096983,
-0.1973334849,
-0.2156605572,
-0.7907710075,
-0.5121958852,
0.3871452212,
0.1854311824,
-0.3347146511,
0.5161530972,
-0.0752781704,
-0.5794764757,
-0.4580387175,
0.3554599881,
0.4563745856,
0.5289744139,
0.2785587311,
-0.1096778065,
-0.3387150764,
-0.8454751372,
-0.4213514924,
0.1301795244,
-0.1749139726,
0.7192515135,
-0.0031763362,
0.0507500917,
0.5876037478,
-0.7658040524,
-0.1315058768,
0.3728500903,
-0.0028209272,
0.3713748455,
0.8561213017,
0.6191385388,
-0.5768761635,
-0.6864022017,
0.040705964,
-0.0982865691,
-0.3158683479,
-0.1355458945,
-0.2902060747,
0.2342993319,
0.4903353453,
-0.3081339896,
0.2487130165,
0.6013961434,
-0.3882133663,
0.2507349253,
-0.4679648876,
0.0787467435,
-0.7253895998,
0.1436827034,
-0.1021083817,
-0.3098532856,
-0.4929792285,
-0.0557969883,
0.1907548159,
-0.1101636812,
-0.2628010213,
0.6085532904,
-0.5070353746,
0.2471762002,
-0.2699370682,
-0.3196701407,
0.1534916759,
0.9210239649,
0.0317490213,
0.8631266952,
0.7171349525,
-0.6503779888,
-0.1941572577,
-0.0687027574,
0.0989686698,
0.3476326168,
-0.6446131468,
0.2249055803,
0.1095721573,
-0.1123759076,
-0.8261189461,
-0.0791155249,
0.3161281645,
-0.1972881556,
0.4911195934,
-0.4433196485,
-0.4372527003,
0.0401835106,
-0.1496637166,
0.4000718892,
0.6044353843,
-0.5427561402,
0.4990169406,
0.3454817235,
-0.1603627354,
-0.4659894109,
-0.1689617932,
-0.3056411147,
-0.3316622376,
-0.3585266471,
0.5969229341,
-0.3888600171,
0.4645991623,
-0.2496293485,
-0.5866068006,
-0.4759863913,
0.3093603551,
0.2598367333,
0.0070114224,
-0.3958937228,
-0.0835689902,
0.5526413321,
-0.2193268538,
-0.3114351034,
-0.5777401328,
0.2848999202,
-0.2013307363,
-0.3088386357,
-0.3621252775,
0.4113040566,
0.3666328788,
-0.3360351026,
0.760684371,
0.7227715254,
-0.5186277032,
-0.3192293942,
-0.8243626952,
-0.2933496833,
-0.580706954,
0.1737279743,
-0.3774977922,
-1.2269399166,
0.4871384501,
-0.3415219188,
0.0031709638,
0.1027468443,
0.1913007945,
0.0005063782,
0.8753963113,
0.8106719255,
0.3345279098,
0.580878675,
0.0900259241,
0.0502076373,
-0.6058357954,
0.0882457271,
-0.5267611146,
-0.279307574,
-0.5658180714,
-0.4875063002,
0.3399696648,
0.3538946509,
-0.4558893442,
0.47273314,
-0.5665258765,
0.6653904319,
0.5129524469,
0.3191936016,
0.149719134,
0.1843820363,
0.1068975553,
0.014056351,
-0.718403101,
-0.1955874413,
1.017162323,
0.0292906929,
0.6373153329,
-0.2381688654,
0.6540470719,
-0.0715556145,
-0.2396745831,
-0.2948512733,
0.5636511445,
-0.4934647381,
-0.1750872433,
-0.4319059849,
-0.3763960302,
-0.9151693583,
0.2824723125,
-0.3355168998,
-0.8905662894,
0.4689930677,
0.5735872388,
-0.6166823506,
0.1706272364,
-0.8371964097,
0.8612151742,
0.1692148447,
-0.744086206,
-0.1397881061,
-0.5826380253,
-0.1556692421,
-0.57747823,
-0.2311662138,
-0.4255748689,
-0.1755726635,
0.7317943573,
-0.4618007541,
0.8333157897,
-0.5112315416,
0.1127879173,
0.021938907,
-0.0271213297,
0.6439470649,
0.2824726403,
-0.093242906,
0.2710550129,
0.0794515535,
-0.6032113433,
-0.7288886309,
0.8425668478,
-0.5996642709,
-0.6032710671,
0.0719315708,
-0.7233713865,
-0.4378426075,
0.4036863446,
0.0229470879,
0.2646476924,
0.1010835767,
0.1554766744,
0.7695299387,
-0.1408910304,
0.4348865151,
0.8926430941,
0.4389253557,
-0.2252086103,
1.068063736,
0.1578585654,
0.2098671049,
0.5206542611,
0.2617333531,
-0.0743548051,
-0.7382298112,
-0.217520684,
0.3301092982,
-0.2145619988,
-0.2842730582,
-0.6015346646,
-0.1019230038,
-0.3011792302,
-0.3826189637,
-0.7954474092,
-0.3897710145,
-0.3779297471,
0.4988391399,
0.4439739883,
0.0699252039,
-0.153261885,
0.5108829737,
-0.6325543523,
0.3493888378,
0.4489269555,
0.9735944867,
-0.2539514005,
-0.4255923331,
-0.3769059479,
0.065940246,
-0.1428954005,
-0.4295996726,
-0.02311996,
0.8476725817,
0.6266454458,
0.3849448264,
0.3288622499,
1.1099439859,
-0.6455850005,
0.4336525202,
-0.203669399,
-0.9976785183,
0.5832424164,
-0.3254781961,
0.145376429,
0.6805620193,
0.0431300364,
0.2085491568,
-0.3388933837,
-0.6231749058,
-0.7496420145,
0.8370816112,
0.0944938213,
0.2197373062,
0.2324869186,
0.550111115,
0.4558739662,
0.2552447021,
-0.2788439095,
-0.2548944056,
-0.0909422636,
0.2087441087,
-0.2141444683,
-0.0955271199,
0.152803272,
-0.6297724247,
0.6038038135,
-0.4975790381,
0.2438933998,
-0.0456327908,
-0.0611991324,
-0.4035363495,
0.0135153392,
0.3996213377,
0.6371970177,
-0.2393184155,
0.1984183192,
0.2816069126,
-0.5580359697,
0.1094444171,
0.6601547599,
-0.1706951708,
0.0609687716,
-0.0094425008,
0.9322953224,
0.3304042816,
-0.5371983647,
0.5764347315,
0.0106321378,
-0.4113077521,
-0.0147474101,
0.3767845333,
-0.1010368615,
0.4449748993,
0.1803080887,
0.4971280992,
0.0526071526,
0.1302754134,
0.4882910848,
0.5813652873,
-0.2482232749,
-0.4077833891,
0.8821080923,
0.0924580246,
-0.0446376465,
0.1438015401,
-0.1702143103,
0.0749312118,
0.2100070119,
0.4836829305,
0.7474794984,
-0.325773567,
0.1558998823,
0.2777661979,
0.1719986051,
0.1590874642,
0.1624359936,
-0.6353273988,
-0.5503373146,
-0.7365532517,
-0.973197341,
-0.0515575223,
0.2897058725,
-0.5408523083,
0.2017653435,
-0.5065826178,
0.2078753859,
0.0776436478,
0.1702547371,
-0.6231107116,
0.0878736079,
-0.0518699475,
0.8197937608,
-0.9258691072,
0.9657403231,
0.6963492036,
0.0270501561,
-0.837795794,
0.1266405135,
-0.5945281386,
-0.7395542264,
0.172504589,
-0.0094512971,
-0.0238520466,
0.1357954293,
-0.3267844021,
-0.87869066,
0.8629589677,
1.0340826511,
-0.5986121297,
0.0396158695,
0.0389053635,
0.3761484921,
-0.1755272895,
-0.0201118272,
0.5549516678,
0.2897133827,
0.0801800564,
-1.0688453913,
0.3179525137,
-0.4442941248,
0.0242773872,
0.4089139104,
-0.6384059191,
0.9091141224,
0.0801342577,
-0.219098419,
-0.0332161412,
0.5460214019,
0.0422631316,
0.133833304,
0.7103027701,
0.3315667212,
0.735765636,
-0.0595879778,
0.5282942057,
-0.4412532747,
0.3975862265,
1.1784157753,
0.0343768001,
0.6508741975,
0.5565735102,
-0.1789228767,
0.0376743041,
0.4721684158,
0.0572340526,
0.7561638951,
0.0567903332,
-0.3524008691,
-0.7078030705,
-0.0385288522,
-0.222657308,
0.3407076001,
0.2100229412,
-0.1573136151,
-0.3823176026,
-0.0778851137,
-0.0179419983,
0.1396790296,
-0.2771959901,
0.7813600302,
-0.1812930256,
-0.6616976857,
1.044762969,
-0.2318969369,
0.7093154788,
-0.5512336493,
-0.2357176393,
-0.0322980545,
0.212411657,
-0.1279549301,
-0.3757436275,
0.5345153809,
-0.2235388458,
-0.2447032481,
-0.2572387159,
0.7542923093,
-0.5665840507,
-0.2862462699,
-0.0609658845,
0.4024044275,
0.0288294796,
-0.4356623292,
-0.5546377897,
0.0144064492,
-0.182307899,
-0.2718434632,
0.5988618135,
0.3603153825,
0.1409871727,
0.3722597063,
0.6989837885,
0.2265521437,
0.0593589768,
-0.3579684794,
1.0345383883,
-0.0710920393,
-0.5203402042,
-0.642100215,
0.3666809201,
0.0875853524,
-0.2540035248,
0.4219471216,
0.4477602243,
0.9122909904,
-0.1654931158,
0.4997746944,
0.079684183,
0.4517733455,
-0.4036311805,
0.9297129512,
-0.621994555,
0.1989493072,
-0.5517296791,
-0.8759388328,
-0.3891978562,
0.7470296025,
-0.0911927745,
-0.0329333842,
0.412891686,
0.948824048,
-0.4883322716,
-0.2603977323,
0.5088502169,
0.0160776302,
-0.0144043732,
0.7219437361,
0.1265599728,
-0.499889195,
0.5640322566,
-0.4897615016,
-0.3087907135,
-0.0364297293,
-1.0670336485,
-0.9238562584,
-0.8580586314,
-0.580863893,
-0.0379146524,
0.3557462692,
0.5786194205,
1.219158411,
-0.7755149603,
0.2033555657,
-0.3076230884,
-0.17898269,
-0.4825074673,
-0.1452966183,
0.4592015743,
-0.3726902902,
-0.7205697894,
0.3446452022,
0.2561703026,
-0.1754069775,
0.1631201655,
-0.2255022377,
0.0699830279,
0.0455921814,
0.4357419014,
0.3980451524,
-0.6755428314,
-0.4982019663,
0.020318076,
0.5314004421,
0.0888302624,
0.4851138592,
-1.0147600174,
0.4475711584,
0.2461725324,
0.918128252,
0.5881862044,
-0.3075621724,
0.5449680686,
-1.0565801859,
0.3395847082,
0.1216059178,
0.3000015616,
0.0521646068,
-0.488052845,
0.2293458283,
0.276902765,
-0.5794500709,
-0.9137017131,
0.2147681713,
-1.0177556276,
-0.1400317997,
0.6627708077,
-0.4259466529,
-0.0296600722,
0.0255719237,
-0.031537544,
0.4719030559,
-0.2991439104,
0.6749446392,
0.1199068278,
-0.1971314847,
-0.3211193383,
-0.2223944366,
0.5877500176,
0.5242986083,
-0.6879627705,
0.1978083104,
0.2199878693,
0.4351450205,
-0.1327520013,
0.6530817151,
0.1870429069,
0.2700248361,
-0.0156046106,
-0.425340116,
-0.3448941708,
-0.3823376596,
-0.1758909076,
0.2392672747,
0.0308812317,
-0.3795010448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16740v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16740v1 | Conjunct Resolution in the Face of Verbal Omissions | 2023-05-26T08:44:02 | 2023-05-26T08:44:02 | Royi Rassin, Yoav Goldberg, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Verbal omissions are complex syntactic phenomena in VP coordination
structures. They occur when verbs and (some of) their arguments are omitted
from subsequent clauses after being explicitly stated in an initial clause.
Recovering these omitted elements is necessary for accurate interpretation of
the sentence, and while humans easily and intuitively fill in the missing
information, state-of-the-art models continue to struggle with this task.
Previous work is limited to small-scale datasets, synthetic data creation
methods, and to resolution methods in the dependency-graph level. In this work
we propose a conjunct resolution task that operates directly on the text and
makes use of a split-and-rephrase paradigm in order to recover the missing
elements in the coordination structure. To this end, we first formulate a
pragmatic framework of verbal omissions which describes the different types of
omissions, and develop an automatic scalable collection method. Based on this
method, we curate a large dataset, containing over 10K examples of
naturally-occurring verbal omissions with crowd-sourced annotations of the
resolved conjuncts. We train various neural baselines for this task, and show
that while our best method obtains decent performance, it leaves ample space
for improvement. We propose our dataset, metrics and models as a starting point
for future research on this topic. | [
-0.4392297864,
-1.0731822252,
0.4999034703,
0.1608559042,
-0.2217280716,
-0.08592318,
-0.4009075463,
-0.4944692254,
0.4417541623,
0.412322551,
-0.6647287607,
-0.148723945,
-0.6066218615,
0.2881839275,
-0.2592467666,
0.6612557769,
-0.1153173074,
-0.0470173992,
-0.3459072709,
-0.1203503013,
-0.6815305352,
-0.4324577749,
-0.5711559057,
-0.402546078,
0.4901670218,
0.9835340977,
0.3360745907,
0.6042909026,
0.2508716881,
0.4087973237,
-0.1947190464,
0.5230752826,
-0.3069253266,
0.0480386578,
-0.380232513,
-0.1000330076,
-0.3269025087,
0.3872302771,
0.7391092181,
1.1142864227,
-0.3518674672,
-0.0284112375,
0.2227013707,
0.7704669237,
-0.6878753901,
0.4073039889,
-0.5115206242,
0.0799543858,
-0.1143243313,
-0.0147761256,
-0.4797095656,
-0.2354246229,
0.3594413996,
-0.6482274532,
0.2471378297,
-0.0292479601,
1.1877046824,
0.2608913779,
-0.369685024,
-0.2312593311,
-0.7522328496,
0.397898525,
-0.3755422235,
0.0970356464,
0.4891275465,
0.3069931567,
-0.4971348047,
-0.7691919804,
-0.7044545412,
-0.2668150067,
-0.3635599911,
0.3251374066,
-0.2222069502,
0.0672427937,
0.259120971,
0.2873316705,
-0.2888765335,
0.0139445588,
-0.4952912629,
-0.2087014169,
0.1983799338,
0.296277523,
0.1188756377,
-0.423841089,
-0.1493321061,
0.35623613,
-0.5457371473,
-0.1117272303,
0.2027762383,
0.3891375065,
-0.0728094056,
0.8285062313,
-0.2508555949,
0.8507726789,
0.5485956073,
0.4895734787,
0.2391010672,
-0.6674374342,
-0.3183461428,
-0.0530107021,
0.6951300502,
0.1086807624,
0.3478530049,
-0.0699199513,
0.3194529116,
0.0143339746,
0.3606964648,
-0.2045570016,
-0.2813664973,
0.2243629843,
-0.2594933808,
0.015890589,
-0.2587173879,
-0.6166818738,
-0.4858689904,
-0.8138942719,
0.2340637147,
-0.4792037308,
-0.1463027745,
-0.029260397,
-0.299139142,
0.0822283775,
0.5334864855,
-0.624103725,
0.5548967719,
0.5995358825,
0.5963352323,
0.2945848107,
-0.4285416901,
-1.1174077988,
-0.1668674201,
-0.4110000432,
0.6932654381,
-0.3031042218,
-0.0273887143,
-0.0717172921,
0.210426569,
-0.2375733107,
-0.6821175814,
0.825902462,
-0.0524245501,
0.4407789707,
-0.3029292226,
-0.6316759586,
-0.4130516052,
0.4445509613,
-0.7410669327,
0.628056407,
-0.0215596091,
-0.528565526,
0.2281308174,
-0.0722448006,
-0.3023046851,
0.2507132888,
-0.2840337455,
-0.2559113204,
0.0198935959,
-0.0419852361,
0.3766694367,
-0.4223148823,
0.1195913851,
-0.0043500634,
0.0141554046,
-0.2053323835,
0.041907087,
0.7070928216,
-0.2976293266,
-0.1890785843,
0.1884885877,
-1.3130005598,
-0.1115579605,
-0.1105063856,
-0.4570057392,
-0.6399394274,
0.2332431823,
-0.0616256371,
0.3672685027,
0.092274338,
-0.8848097324,
-0.2175089121,
-0.7061339617,
0.4284599423,
0.755877018,
0.0589697994,
0.6880869269,
0.0444321595,
0.1242221445,
0.23037678,
0.1940048188,
0.0678789094,
-0.2642219067,
-0.9081663489,
-0.2860246003,
0.1169877499,
0.3964135945,
-0.9977007508,
0.5344456434,
-0.133371681,
-0.5458759665,
-0.3091778457,
-0.1835535467,
0.4755427241,
0.7806449533,
0.2748262584,
-0.1522261202,
-0.7459853888,
-0.9852260351,
-0.3158191741,
0.0334606692,
0.1796096861,
0.027824806,
0.5793148279,
0.3224129677,
1.133920908,
-0.3084434569,
-0.7332257628,
-0.1353354752,
0.0690475255,
0.1893846393,
0.5828310251,
0.1248967573,
-0.9277804494,
-0.1518166959,
0.0512430444,
-0.8716655374,
0.0737661496,
-0.064227283,
-0.0048239129,
0.255956322,
0.6785958409,
-0.7565073371,
0.4454133511,
0.5073245168,
-0.4991299212,
0.9756697416,
-0.3888662755,
-0.4068036675,
-0.9127218127,
0.1096731499,
0.0885576531,
-0.377702266,
-0.5170756578,
-0.2399089783,
-0.0244548582,
0.0785911083,
-0.437943548,
0.3051252067,
-0.6728309989,
0.1991060078,
-0.1196312159,
0.5568647981,
0.1078110561,
0.7475721836,
0.1064962223,
0.1024599746,
0.3049609661,
-0.762963295,
0.6232510209,
0.3107018173,
-0.0909834728,
0.7822287083,
-0.6348635554,
-0.1268602163,
-0.5104215741,
0.2532099783,
-1.1704956293,
-0.2558853924,
0.9195759296,
-0.227627635,
0.1543290913,
-0.1453316063,
-0.4158989489,
-0.1454024613,
0.0269130804,
0.0929102302,
-0.1551362723,
-0.418314904,
0.8839511871,
0.57065171,
-0.0720000565,
-0.4245229065,
-0.5845189095,
0.0967317447,
0.1618241668,
-0.2635701001,
0.3008878827,
0.0535973422,
-0.3120953441,
0.147495687,
-0.2042665184,
0.0391983651,
-0.1621748954,
0.4707289934,
0.1183515862,
0.0522612184,
0.395394057,
-0.3864068687,
-0.2438438684,
0.1654636115,
0.0962632298,
0.5227547288,
-0.2126383185,
-0.0504438505,
-0.3029163182,
0.6029300094,
0.4202721417,
-0.3541165292,
0.7122305632,
0.1713065356,
-0.6846207976,
-0.2055305243,
-0.5072935224,
0.0734553114,
-0.4183370471,
0.1711919159,
-0.3504938483,
-0.6691994071,
0.5529520512,
0.0440118946,
0.0662155598,
0.2978182137,
0.3615272641,
-0.0624555424,
0.2840388417,
0.528470099,
0.2054033279,
0.6945269108,
-0.0526748896,
0.0448571108,
-0.9395080805,
-0.3695155978,
-0.8228880167,
-0.2001341432,
-0.6458784342,
-0.1984596252,
-0.0112037165,
-0.11580237,
-0.2295613289,
0.491292417,
-0.378798455,
0.4169015884,
0.7076534033,
0.2870033085,
0.2211966366,
-0.1230406687,
-0.2961778939,
-0.2176017314,
-0.6055829525,
-0.1534399539,
0.4820644557,
-0.0460045449,
0.0958297998,
0.0222107284,
0.5752440095,
0.0167137869,
0.1655641645,
-0.9284507036,
0.7040675879,
-0.1848738343,
-0.1415351182,
-0.3016201556,
-0.6704471707,
-1.2482435703,
0.4931408465,
-0.0205887146,
-0.7723590136,
0.6378409863,
-0.0717306286,
-0.1884294003,
-0.1492907107,
-0.8448830247,
1.1419702768,
0.3880967796,
-0.4414629936,
-0.15719302,
-0.6830067039,
0.3550492227,
0.2282824069,
0.0748313591,
-0.0963323191,
0.074427098,
0.5939583182,
-0.6661862135,
0.9058739543,
-0.0466885976,
-0.0283592828,
0.3741613328,
0.1742951423,
0.664593935,
-0.4974503219,
0.1635311097,
-0.0601488613,
-0.4482289553,
-0.1888152659,
-0.4095749557,
0.6385351419,
-0.3710234165,
-0.3189241588,
-0.4734757841,
-0.2559151351,
-0.1243866012,
0.2586143613,
0.2053160667,
0.3662101924,
-0.3376727402,
-0.0894940495,
0.2596966326,
0.0120075243,
0.6108820438,
0.596581161,
0.1128398404,
-0.4258717,
0.7041466832,
0.6245239377,
0.0437328108,
0.1344639957,
0.1312076598,
-0.2872549593,
-0.0979139432,
-0.2378909439,
0.5832832456,
-0.7029876709,
-0.0999915078,
-0.343067348,
-0.1467940807,
-0.1452270895,
0.2602964938,
-0.3140799701,
-0.4652594924,
-0.5361037254,
-0.2249035984,
0.2280497104,
0.4314154685,
-0.1828720272,
0.0498470142,
-0.808947742,
0.5387862325,
0.0969322622,
0.3084449172,
0.0773219839,
-0.1573878974,
-0.1485829502,
-0.0185218807,
-0.2745945156,
-0.7941268682,
0.282311976,
0.3263662755,
0.443369776,
-0.0964756086,
0.1006344929,
1.0043715239,
-0.6288848519,
0.6074985266,
0.2875488997,
-1.0103788376,
0.5848764777,
-0.2931267321,
0.2286409289,
0.2715120614,
0.0786969289,
-0.7301838398,
-0.5166183114,
-0.8535175323,
-1.0344697237,
0.7872359157,
0.3368066549,
-0.4578722119,
-0.3244942725,
0.5566558838,
-0.2036082745,
0.0768834576,
-0.5036391616,
-0.1425284743,
0.3634409904,
0.0016405713,
-0.2367495894,
0.059821181,
-0.0534029007,
-0.1315220892,
0.4721131027,
-0.0027185564,
-0.2261113673,
0.5188440681,
-0.0701292232,
-0.2524003983,
0.1163036004,
0.3126727045,
0.5888915062,
0.0447938181,
0.2112786472,
-0.2378409952,
-0.508420229,
0.038385272,
0.1933792233,
0.1292857081,
0.3209802806,
0.0606028028,
0.1049629077,
0.3753215373,
-0.6472857594,
0.4260743558,
0.0029297895,
0.0201927163,
-0.6915792227,
-0.3778809309,
0.0906021819,
0.2324983776,
0.1476254612,
0.6328148246,
0.0897000059,
-0.7082918882,
0.375382483,
0.1376250982,
-0.3891416192,
-0.2080825418,
0.4265905023,
0.1000664607,
-0.1779580116,
0.8507040143,
-0.0323272385,
-0.3058979213,
0.739819169,
-0.0045520822,
0.7649576068,
-0.0046872878,
0.36692065,
0.4636498094,
0.4303826094,
-0.1793570518,
0.3014319837,
0.1092832088,
-0.8324486613,
-0.6127017736,
-0.1447999328,
-0.2455366403,
0.0118012726,
-0.622872591,
0.2043575346,
-0.635350585,
-0.1199970394,
0.3634355664,
0.0706659332,
-0.5525024533,
0.0789943561,
0.0164816603,
0.7632824779,
-0.7514698505,
0.5305950046,
0.6169512272,
-0.8521519899,
-0.8516135812,
-0.2466851324,
0.141915381,
-0.2590107322,
0.4715327322,
-0.1047229916,
-0.2329979688,
-0.0828307867,
-0.5507493615,
-0.5090274215,
0.397106111,
0.4917414486,
-0.5196956992,
0.0524216704,
0.0373057164,
0.6627517343,
-0.0952936038,
-0.1423828751,
0.6856271625,
0.4801602364,
-0.0959615186,
-1.0702476501,
0.3563949764,
-0.0741690397,
-0.2462732494,
0.41038239,
-0.7345858812,
1.1932431459,
0.0811031386,
-0.3289424479,
0.1655804813,
0.5340973735,
0.0008353207,
0.0923791677,
0.3567145765,
0.5557083488,
0.6497833729,
-0.1663086712,
0.7386233211,
0.5289821625,
0.381573081,
1.5687755346,
-0.2656737566,
0.8576078415,
0.7488695383,
0.2581290305,
0.1357755363,
0.500526011,
0.1830158979,
0.3042329252,
0.325321883,
-0.1065924615,
-0.3289433718,
-0.2357228994,
0.0721071586,
0.6416321397,
0.5420455337,
-0.2588661313,
-0.6895589828,
0.0531768799,
0.1223108619,
0.4190929234,
-0.4752759039,
0.8281723857,
0.0084337695,
-0.929312706,
0.7170279622,
-0.0608023554,
0.071072422,
-0.3844178915,
-0.4911708534,
-0.3381503522,
0.537227869,
-0.3251875043,
-0.7182323337,
0.4791626036,
-0.2845728695,
-0.2948133945,
-0.193760857,
0.6195460558,
-0.641663909,
-0.1464894116,
0.4515279531,
0.6328850985,
0.1515026242,
-0.3438275456,
-0.4451831281,
-0.1986020207,
-0.235876292,
0.0181528311,
0.0796279311,
0.962323308,
-0.0567710102,
0.5192406178,
0.4512773752,
0.2936454713,
0.199897185,
0.1196579337,
0.9184992313,
-0.5106183887,
-0.2783998549,
-0.8055146337,
0.4548501968,
-0.1669506282,
-0.3914386928,
0.7850784063,
0.4694695771,
0.7183682919,
-0.048259642,
0.4080476165,
-0.2754354179,
0.6410441995,
-0.2897424996,
0.2478199005,
-0.473521024,
-0.0665048435,
-0.4111096561,
-0.4354914427,
-0.4125349522,
0.4544242918,
-0.3623301983,
-0.3548372984,
0.7269070745,
0.5769177675,
-0.024236653,
0.067700617,
0.1127137616,
0.497734338,
0.2594649792,
0.6628369689,
0.9009478092,
-0.6347885728,
0.5671275854,
-0.1607143134,
-0.1547059417,
-0.324675262,
-0.7410705686,
-0.3017036915,
-0.8575320244,
-0.5637523532,
-0.5137661695,
-0.0655249134,
0.8813943863,
0.3920430839,
-0.4372417629,
-0.1222812161,
-0.4249022603,
0.4638456702,
-0.7456205487,
-0.2686253786,
0.4236643016,
-0.4719956815,
-0.7754501104,
0.3701454699,
0.1049636677,
-0.2346422374,
0.0443342775,
0.1225280464,
-0.6901573539,
-0.2181896567,
0.7818210125,
0.4083135724,
-0.4890498221,
-0.5004448891,
-0.3693655431,
0.0008164179,
0.2047598809,
0.7103905082,
-0.9135649204,
0.5634052753,
0.5900247693,
0.186554715,
0.2601153553,
0.10609404,
0.5892802477,
-1.1162279844,
0.342504859,
0.3722837269,
0.5393947959,
0.111358881,
-0.1420557201,
0.4012278616,
0.4541776478,
-0.2919614017,
-0.3752069771,
0.2733305395,
-1.1736485958,
-0.2333156168,
0.8664446473,
-0.1668992937,
-0.5642946959,
-0.4731782377,
-0.4784350395,
0.3064424694,
-0.3139549196,
0.655790329,
1.1927950382,
-0.0408501923,
-0.3079242706,
-0.3254916072,
0.347823292,
0.2450513393,
-0.759172976,
0.5107295513,
1.1592149734,
0.2264208049,
0.4527062178,
0.5670250654,
-0.1195587516,
0.5755005479,
0.1773770601,
0.0435854606,
0.0590753742,
-0.456009537,
-0.2816296518,
0.5440852642,
-0.420538187,
-0.7476562262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18212v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18212v1 | Multimodal Recommendation Dialog with Subjective Preference: A New Challenge and Benchmark | 2023-05-26T08:43:46 | 2023-05-26T08:43:46 | Yuxing Long, Binyuan Hui, Caixia Yuan1, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li, Xiaojie Wang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM | Existing multimodal task-oriented dialog data fails to demonstrate the
diverse expressions of user subjective preferences and recommendation acts in
the real-life shopping scenario. This paper introduces a new dataset SURE
(Multimodal Recommendation Dialog with SUbjective PREference), which contains
12K shopping dialogs in complex store scenes. The data is built in two phases
with human annotations to ensure quality and diversity. SURE is well-annotated
with subjective preferences and recommendation acts proposed by sales experts.
A comprehensive analysis is given to reveal the distinguishing features of
SURE. Three benchmark tasks are then proposed on the data to evaluate the
capability of multimodal recommendation agents. Based on the SURE, we propose a
baseline model, powered by a state-of-the-art multimodal model, for these
tasks. | [
-0.4799319506,
-0.4680936635,
0.442776531,
0.0674137995,
-0.1786498129,
-0.149264887,
-0.0961507857,
-0.6626716852,
0.1092194095,
0.3244234025,
-0.9955250621,
-0.3655031025,
0.0112364544,
0.1822839677,
0.1758310497,
1.063313961,
0.063957639,
0.1740189642,
-0.540797472,
-0.4742054641,
-1.0188530684,
-0.5113965273,
-0.3031620085,
-0.2705791593,
0.3737059534,
0.6693546772,
0.8935992122,
-0.0436668992,
0.3105468154,
0.3874416947,
0.3177289963,
0.5793861747,
-0.1657816321,
0.4486982524,
0.0517141223,
-0.5004532337,
-0.6891399622,
0.0517502651,
0.1065363213,
0.3025753498,
-0.0020158961,
0.1602156311,
-0.2354512662,
0.5088940263,
-0.5515583754,
0.2698881924,
-0.1301188618,
0.0709170178,
0.1548092216,
0.0726421997,
-0.2604579926,
-0.2446374893,
0.6539089084,
-0.8643046618,
0.1649402529,
0.1894159019,
0.7890430689,
-0.0593422838,
-0.855869472,
-0.2841074467,
-0.8276743889,
0.871322453,
-0.5152741075,
0.5768698454,
0.5219084024,
0.5324388742,
0.1571246982,
-0.3375888765,
-0.4806727469,
-0.5359919071,
0.0274789389,
0.0037909185,
-0.1300077289,
-0.1897957027,
0.0604787953,
0.1845694184,
-0.3289112151,
-0.6627813578,
-0.0427899063,
-0.3599776924,
0.370585382,
0.2903836668,
0.0403077453,
-0.2514177859,
-0.6920015812,
-0.1468366981,
-0.0647586882,
0.3227009177,
0.2939978838,
0.162749812,
-0.169463113,
0.4313206077,
-0.6245405078,
0.7844022512,
0.0959919915,
-0.4819534421,
0.7283716202,
-0.9494018555,
0.0211796891,
-0.2197790444,
0.5714693069,
1.201723814,
0.4522446096,
-0.0517746694,
-0.1520809233,
-0.0778985992,
0.214917168,
-0.2958022058,
-0.0478441305,
0.1986387968,
-0.4986250699,
0.0199327357,
0.0303189773,
-0.6863515973,
-0.2257234156,
-0.5823182464,
0.4673978984,
-0.4200183153,
-0.2551230788,
0.2121640742,
-0.1074994579,
-0.4686732888,
0.6155766845,
-0.304549396,
0.0361541994,
0.2323751748,
0.4690777361,
0.0960281119,
-0.2502254844,
-0.1620980352,
0.1191774607,
0.0567017011,
1.0639339685,
-0.7476313114,
-0.3129585683,
-0.0194137134,
0.2408489138,
0.152462393,
-0.5341259837,
0.8214771152,
-0.2664021552,
0.2120466828,
-0.6106595397,
-0.3275666535,
-0.3444252908,
0.8621227741,
-0.5315294266,
0.648252368,
0.2159197628,
-0.4469784498,
0.755585134,
-0.4141358733,
-0.3037577569,
0.2010464668,
0.108431749,
-0.2820004523,
-0.1673856527,
0.1244575009,
0.4770813286,
-0.2302496284,
0.3760580122,
-0.7110887766,
-0.2541113794,
0.6866317987,
-0.5353010893,
0.2951367497,
0.4134745002,
-0.2688187659,
0.1035237759,
-0.8108023405,
-0.1063856333,
-0.1788661927,
-0.1725387424,
-0.2349526286,
-0.137473315,
0.3449917436,
0.3531900346,
0.5993900299,
-0.5519908667,
0.4752756655,
0.3067033887,
0.1522968858,
0.7094404697,
-0.0519144349,
0.324864924,
-0.5536751747,
0.6094306111,
0.2266300023,
0.5725525022,
-0.1964056343,
-0.5645579696,
-0.7395536304,
-0.2950280309,
0.1066305265,
0.3614555299,
-0.7935445905,
0.1527951807,
0.0219120532,
-0.2663661838,
-0.0670080408,
-0.0451860167,
0.3773920536,
0.2239273787,
0.071104832,
-0.464515239,
-0.5085604787,
-1.245949626,
0.0266001653,
-0.1327907294,
0.2435848117,
0.858117342,
0.0557281524,
-0.5236632824,
1.1101722717,
-0.6384229064,
-0.5321279168,
-0.0991608873,
0.1391090602,
0.2559032738,
0.2876665294,
0.6327534914,
-0.800704062,
-0.2805568576,
-0.1782619953,
-0.5943306088,
0.1606100947,
-0.1520887762,
-0.0813930631,
-0.3463126123,
0.0194076523,
-0.5916752815,
-0.0029399826,
0.3807036877,
-0.5166226029,
0.7596143484,
-0.6333203912,
0.6709173918,
-1.1485177279,
-0.4000037909,
0.5494217873,
-0.2057144344,
-0.7162964344,
-0.3188537061,
0.0389966331,
-0.0231158547,
-0.5164347291,
0.3898156285,
-0.1677953601,
0.0634282753,
-0.0772068799,
-0.2816322744,
0.0366358049,
0.6101914048,
0.0121344114,
0.6080403328,
0.5322772861,
-0.6900951862,
0.5774917006,
0.5337737799,
-0.4467908144,
1.0783569813,
-0.4241052568,
0.0221368037,
-0.1999700963,
0.6059714556,
-1.1588640213,
-0.3173583746,
0.3140487969,
0.0181421861,
-0.3188968897,
-0.0428553149,
-0.4426690638,
-0.1969017833,
-0.3263430893,
0.7569705844,
-0.1094683632,
-0.1525290459,
0.6394780874,
0.1509820521,
-0.0091540096,
-0.3442006707,
-0.2489706725,
0.0902220756,
-0.1348172724,
-0.6449090242,
-0.0285954978,
-0.5809516907,
-0.1722148955,
-0.3789399266,
-0.0362706184,
0.0097142803,
-0.0155185862,
0.4674730897,
0.4981821477,
-0.0014381838,
0.0704948753,
-0.3865717351,
-0.4216168523,
-0.2279718071,
-0.149995476,
0.4141388237,
-0.4679818153,
-0.3812630773,
-0.6481317282,
0.3811606467,
0.7232448459,
-0.0270436127,
0.2003081739,
0.9015573859,
-0.0959010124,
0.2579213083,
-0.8104534745,
-0.0874563977,
-0.4957249463,
0.2333813906,
-0.6679601669,
-0.7324925661,
0.0507406592,
0.0087576918,
0.0277603343,
0.1005765647,
0.6519061923,
-0.0953146592,
1.1377668381,
0.4736483991,
0.1158713847,
0.3803912401,
-0.0618582144,
0.4420422912,
-0.3744564354,
-0.5963760614,
-0.4432162642,
-0.4031520784,
-0.3316631913,
-0.2684490383,
0.5628044605,
-0.09513212,
-0.0159301329,
0.4968649745,
-0.2653835416,
0.1677664071,
0.7842127681,
0.4628120661,
0.2636900842,
-0.0773884952,
-0.0654511303,
-0.0584394,
-0.2265251428,
-0.436612159,
0.9608122706,
0.145457685,
0.6320294738,
0.2603513896,
0.0088877641,
0.7045770884,
-0.1024950296,
-0.6989620924,
0.6377307773,
0.0216607787,
-0.853444159,
0.1451405138,
-0.2081117928,
-0.6782999635,
0.0564239882,
-0.5012164712,
-0.719499588,
0.6208412051,
0.2495273352,
-0.538644731,
-0.076087907,
-0.9063572288,
0.7793825865,
-0.3778882325,
-0.489538312,
-0.2620730102,
-0.4472993016,
0.1097342372,
0.2058439851,
0.4393191338,
-0.6292425394,
0.1843695492,
0.576143086,
0.0130144637,
0.4940903783,
-0.3117166758,
0.0874381736,
0.1865235418,
0.1638487279,
0.427033186,
0.1234728917,
0.0666488335,
0.0410534069,
0.1452186853,
-0.302438885,
-0.2793141901,
0.5227130651,
-0.6908303499,
-0.2166141868,
-0.2965092063,
-0.6621130705,
-0.8941977024,
0.1184942871,
-0.0563937239,
0.7900856137,
-0.0314807929,
0.4264245927,
0.1339865327,
0.1431572139,
0.2455233783,
0.3423059583,
0.0940314978,
-0.470058918,
1.1698473692,
-0.1993989944,
-0.0673926696,
0.193306759,
0.234552145,
-0.5330637097,
-0.3366837502,
-0.4052993655,
-0.1489927471,
-0.8640241623,
-0.1104695871,
-0.8739920855,
0.5763148069,
-0.3435608745,
-0.0244530179,
-0.1643085033,
-0.2912733257,
-0.0462653972,
-0.0423511304,
0.2724213004,
0.8824074268,
0.1384384632,
0.0972178951,
-0.7815341353,
0.4796453118,
0.9021336436,
0.4583454728,
0.0024949752,
0.0898433551,
-0.4511832297,
0.2296558022,
-0.3263745308,
-0.3965138793,
0.1764781475,
-0.0711519793,
0.5896641612,
0.8807610869,
0.1088457778,
0.4917776883,
-0.1583193094,
0.9612781405,
0.4238141477,
-0.4968144894,
0.0422978774,
-0.6676592231,
0.3452434838,
0.9127124548,
0.4139510095,
-0.5702850223,
0.1827403456,
-0.2967755795,
-0.7581023574,
0.7897150517,
0.1735100597,
0.0443497524,
-0.1133886054,
-0.0865809619,
0.6450011134,
0.6684424281,
-0.5138806701,
-0.235943526,
-0.3889994025,
-0.0327026471,
-0.4535127282,
-0.4649551511,
-0.0518201441,
-0.2149517238,
0.3478957117,
-0.2655329406,
0.3019378781,
0.0048381332,
-0.1011596918,
0.1504549682,
0.5116499662,
0.6688579917,
0.8301933408,
-0.7756686211,
-0.1508494914,
-0.0145483669,
-0.2070443034,
0.3719410598,
-0.325365603,
0.1281330585,
-0.194702968,
0.05493512,
0.7643806338,
0.3381800354,
-0.898614347,
0.564139843,
-0.2975010574,
-0.3687057793,
-0.1786315143,
-0.0649722442,
-0.1488933265,
0.3518645465,
0.2448537499,
0.5898052454,
0.4713165164,
-0.836006701,
0.231735602,
0.2600778341,
-0.5175039172,
-0.2739966512,
0.3930556476,
0.4557395875,
-0.2233375758,
0.392233789,
-0.1081972718,
-0.4114663303,
0.2433436215,
0.2922077179,
0.9194077253,
0.2911907136,
0.4595292807,
0.2099006176,
-0.0720054358,
-0.1955701411,
0.1178004146,
-0.542206049,
-0.8992407918,
0.2351412326,
-0.3972774148,
-0.713768065,
-0.2492003739,
-0.6342957616,
0.1695770472,
-0.3514056504,
-0.5999534726,
-0.0346485674,
-0.059328299,
-0.8509354591,
0.5521919727,
0.0780616477,
0.2572254837,
-0.623093307,
0.5446751118,
0.57217592,
-0.2035992891,
-0.332764715,
-0.1491872817,
0.1697258949,
-0.521140635,
0.5491009355,
0.1817491204,
-0.3191586733,
-0.7913362384,
-0.1948464811,
-0.4746519923,
0.8140833974,
0.1156877205,
-0.6507396698,
0.0843642578,
0.1049766093,
0.3880202472,
-0.6465073824,
0.7438191175,
0.3205731511,
0.8284569383,
0.0364428386,
-0.7342351079,
-0.2506051362,
-0.5061666965,
-0.1532678902,
-0.151766941,
-0.8695801497,
1.0181047916,
0.2619813681,
0.2960646152,
0.2085116506,
0.1665920615,
0.0471508689,
0.6863422394,
1.0508904457,
0.3951960504,
0.3703607321,
-0.0560097359,
1.0155175924,
-0.2113142759,
0.2399525046,
1.0257151127,
-0.6761842966,
0.6619268656,
0.0776306614,
-0.1597166806,
0.4999728203,
0.6386733651,
-0.0931457132,
0.5533650517,
-0.2793556452,
-0.3287342787,
-0.6828820705,
-0.4666361213,
-0.3672413528,
0.4644084275,
-0.1292244345,
0.1282207966,
-0.2044266313,
0.2790884972,
-0.3848479092,
-0.2853539586,
-0.0097720977,
0.8650099039,
-0.5149385333,
-0.6646856666,
0.4780519009,
-0.0811067596,
0.9423851371,
-0.7397274375,
-0.0265211537,
-0.0471276566,
0.2928965092,
-0.2468304187,
-0.5416725278,
-0.5390213728,
-0.2214564979,
-0.4163105488,
-0.3178988099,
0.700279057,
-0.1827921569,
-0.4455052912,
0.0953295007,
0.3742641509,
-0.0043576928,
-0.1587128192,
-0.7863192558,
-0.2310420126,
0.2115462273,
-0.0784082115,
0.2732685804,
0.1736464202,
-0.2318703085,
0.8991074562,
0.7270741463,
-0.4544668496,
-0.0777491257,
0.2802056968,
0.4927161336,
-0.6400632858,
-0.4923511446,
-0.2503170967,
0.4600562155,
-0.1374373138,
-0.6690990925,
0.9334636927,
0.4283497632,
0.7218615413,
-0.2270734757,
0.5464535952,
0.2445870042,
0.3110284805,
-0.1240840107,
0.2547724843,
-0.7298667431,
0.058921881,
-0.4468022883,
-1.0082185268,
0.1263903826,
0.500612855,
-0.1499109119,
0.4279212654,
0.5949640274,
0.658608377,
-0.2179097086,
0.3590134084,
0.3603808284,
-0.0168054737,
0.1618810892,
0.4395987988,
0.9036129117,
-0.2277607322,
0.5066846609,
-0.3846201301,
-0.0651997402,
-0.4836617112,
-0.6637678146,
-0.662450552,
-0.789955318,
-0.3467440307,
-0.3686940074,
-0.0749276578,
1.4333369732,
1.1311887503,
-0.8091965914,
-0.4476023316,
0.3138459027,
-0.2291049659,
-0.5056809187,
-0.2074631304,
-0.0525324941,
-0.0425655618,
-0.6306645274,
0.4595156908,
0.4249690175,
0.0117042586,
-0.2302036434,
-0.1850970536,
-0.2967422009,
0.0638981462,
0.6535047293,
-0.2455724925,
-0.5421491265,
-0.2224547118,
-0.0226964969,
0.165694505,
0.1510808766,
0.9743482471,
-0.6614858508,
0.8545508981,
0.2968330681,
0.1544227302,
0.508202374,
-0.1572924405,
0.6941810846,
-0.505153358,
0.3055534065,
0.1011322141,
0.4904228151,
0.101150468,
-0.1838851422,
0.2103726715,
0.2741045654,
-0.3679619431,
-0.4661951959,
0.3783192337,
-1.3427927494,
-0.3182178736,
1.020406723,
-0.2503952384,
-0.0980346128,
-0.6176778078,
-0.7218657732,
-0.2567747831,
-0.9389356375,
0.5604961514,
0.9224590063,
-0.0344224423,
-0.0425547659,
-0.3103455901,
0.1251434684,
0.4371006489,
-0.5512722731,
-0.0402061306,
0.8745399714,
0.1555266082,
0.2222436816,
0.6332114935,
0.3854203224,
0.5159055591,
-0.0488921218,
-0.1435512006,
-0.2912953794,
-0.4847950041,
0.189946264,
0.6951506734,
0.0938373655,
-0.2510536611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16739v1 | AlignScore: Evaluating Factual Consistency with a Unified Alignment Function | 2023-05-26T08:41:59 | 2023-05-26T08:41:59 | Yuheng Zha, Yichi Yang, Ruichen Li, Zhiting Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many text generation applications require the generated text to be factually
consistent with input information. Automatic evaluation of factual consistency
is challenging. Previous work has developed various metrics that often depend
on specific functions, such as natural language inference (NLI) or question
answering (QA), trained on limited data. Those metrics thus can hardly assess
diverse factual inconsistencies (e.g., contradictions, hallucinations) that
occur in varying inputs/outputs (e.g., sentences, documents) from different
tasks. In this paper, we propose AlignScore, a new holistic metric that applies
to a variety of factual inconsistency scenarios as above. AlignScore is based
on a general function of information alignment between two arbitrary text
pieces. Crucially, we develop a unified training framework of the alignment
function by integrating a large diversity of data sources, resulting in 4.7M
training examples from 7 well-established tasks (NLI, QA, paraphrasing, fact
verification, information retrieval, semantic similarity, and summarization).
We conduct extensive experiments on large-scale benchmarks including 22
evaluation datasets, where 19 of the datasets were never seen in the alignment
training. AlignScore achieves substantial improvement over a wide range of
previous metrics. Moreover, AlignScore (355M parameters) matches or even
outperforms metrics based on ChatGPT and GPT-4 that are orders of magnitude
larger. | [
-0.0759204701,
-0.5509749651,
0.7206280231,
0.2620568275,
-0.0750870034,
0.0888114572,
-0.2029869556,
-0.3135358393,
-0.0556426421,
0.2021337599,
-0.4463265538,
-0.5866491199,
-0.5173289776,
0.0958617032,
-0.4083045423,
1.2315411568,
-0.376747787,
0.026646331,
-0.6714393497,
-0.7037664652,
-0.6864919662,
-0.0994978622,
-0.0845378786,
-0.2368198782,
0.3463563025,
0.4494441748,
0.765788734,
0.61676687,
0.8872259259,
0.2891094685,
0.4608511925,
0.3986132443,
-0.3454349041,
0.1895173192,
-0.4189694822,
-0.1417638808,
-0.2317343354,
0.0417969264,
0.821395278,
0.5554294586,
-0.2548250854,
0.4663985968,
0.2696208358,
0.578905642,
-0.9315520525,
0.0587604158,
-0.6042636633,
-0.0274724457,
0.0322267748,
-0.0781697109,
-0.2099512666,
-0.8548832536,
0.0789490491,
-0.8676256537,
0.1585877985,
0.1648630202,
1.118875742,
0.45461905,
-0.5137162805,
-0.4369012117,
-0.860044837,
0.7824098468,
-0.812708497,
0.4368387163,
0.0951723009,
0.3176802993,
-0.034910161,
-0.5500365496,
-0.8207110763,
-0.0829551443,
-0.2132983953,
0.4687119126,
-0.1253460646,
-0.2515732944,
0.2000143677,
0.301638633,
-0.8005750179,
-0.1104825884,
0.1590678543,
-0.3329841793,
0.6739675403,
0.208084926,
0.206382826,
-0.0655699223,
-0.497417748,
-0.2667864859,
-0.2053697258,
0.107301645,
0.3872903883,
0.1133225039,
-0.0085983081,
0.7123473883,
-0.3092892766,
0.5553851128,
0.351141125,
-0.4132162333,
0.1699275076,
-0.6672363281,
-0.3996028602,
0.2393589914,
0.831974566,
0.4221526384,
-0.2086982131,
-0.2801150382,
-0.0481017157,
0.286896199,
0.4087051749,
-0.5184987783,
-0.2074758261,
0.1544225812,
-0.011531014,
-0.0760302171,
0.4728329182,
-0.6594119072,
-0.4308561683,
-0.6247847676,
0.7467750311,
-0.6347414851,
0.1432738155,
0.0811270699,
-0.0220336337,
0.4769191742,
0.4489278197,
-0.6766992211,
0.3058405817,
0.8996391296,
0.596550405,
-0.2921248078,
-0.3233779669,
-0.7760125995,
0.0081943749,
-0.1567953527,
0.9370190501,
-0.3441823423,
0.0782708749,
-0.0739989206,
-0.0931867585,
-0.3074680567,
-0.4089369476,
0.9873301983,
-0.2438188493,
0.4528425932,
-0.2913881838,
-0.7972045541,
-0.0950437263,
0.520986259,
-0.5986660719,
1.21299541,
0.2074143589,
-0.9028549194,
0.6357983947,
-0.3525935411,
-0.416955322,
0.0888538286,
-0.1913369894,
-0.8367981315,
-0.0824007615,
0.0236746278,
0.0851958171,
-0.4092835486,
0.5286740065,
-0.2289596945,
-0.3515226245,
0.1223038882,
-0.4020404518,
0.6567702293,
-0.0747183636,
-0.4856303632,
0.0129662398,
-0.8814094663,
0.2735936046,
-0.2426550388,
-0.3183779418,
-0.3648961186,
-0.1110250205,
-0.1887217313,
0.0133788055,
0.4292016327,
-0.8366636634,
-0.0549961664,
-0.2289151996,
-0.2192814052,
0.280477196,
0.0296494551,
0.4488232136,
-0.4690828025,
0.2781666517,
0.1218420193,
0.0759035796,
-0.034975905,
-0.4412247837,
-0.6492226124,
-0.235272482,
0.5517664552,
0.7007362843,
-0.2104128599,
0.961587429,
-0.4761292338,
-0.5326063633,
-0.7469251752,
0.3037960529,
0.3934002221,
0.8662563562,
0.3459370136,
-0.2748635411,
-0.8172715306,
-0.8091751933,
-0.546684742,
-0.3130892515,
-0.0935409516,
-0.2270251662,
0.346736908,
-0.1657478213,
1.2214436531,
-0.2699409723,
-0.2707013488,
0.1997401416,
0.5070556402,
-0.0811564997,
0.3939005136,
0.1633244157,
-0.7000308037,
-0.5558784604,
0.2048858702,
-0.8186451793,
-0.143945381,
-0.311355412,
-0.2369326502,
0.1516628861,
0.0953966975,
-0.5262550712,
0.3454965651,
0.5996628404,
-0.2973318994,
0.6014364958,
-0.2490039617,
0.4685953856,
-1.0359169245,
0.3758144379,
0.1968682706,
-0.2340005636,
-0.2575417161,
-0.1425191164,
0.3436892033,
0.2816903293,
-0.0206160024,
0.4106018841,
-0.332824409,
-0.0209632888,
0.1298986673,
0.586120069,
0.4062645733,
0.2437791079,
-0.4578730464,
0.5987830162,
0.1774867177,
-0.3478875756,
0.3937436342,
0.5621027946,
-0.4382701218,
1.149471879,
-0.4072799087,
-0.0464684777,
-0.1229159385,
0.0783114731,
-1.2589249611,
-0.3506618142,
0.1141728386,
-0.4312312007,
0.0530097075,
0.192718789,
-0.4087536037,
-0.2263184786,
-0.2483031899,
0.1557648778,
0.449085176,
-0.6037245393,
0.5795504451,
0.2622536123,
0.0342063792,
-0.6727914214,
-0.2797181308,
-0.0208960939,
-0.2016043067,
-0.6811950803,
0.2631391883,
-0.14395383,
-0.2360216528,
0.0831381157,
-0.5089070201,
-0.2779430747,
-0.0169885643,
0.1797272861,
0.4023524523,
-0.4409423172,
0.1250196695,
0.059110444,
0.1995906532,
-0.0436898954,
-0.328887552,
-0.0158237349,
-0.2572342455,
-0.5512228608,
-0.508906126,
0.1513402611,
0.4762588739,
-0.3856524825,
0.5636758804,
0.6334313154,
-0.2205194384,
0.1489185691,
-0.7701839805,
0.2030500025,
-0.3707920611,
0.2013745904,
0.0518735051,
-0.7210453749,
0.3561756015,
0.0191387441,
0.3928664029,
0.7522307038,
0.2279437333,
-0.2129920423,
1.0594938993,
0.4577172697,
0.2221542448,
0.0449362621,
0.3453083038,
0.3201994896,
-0.6938940287,
-0.4641857445,
-0.5768463612,
-0.2744334936,
-0.3946510553,
-0.1151492,
0.1494134963,
0.2056845725,
-0.242635712,
0.46050331,
-0.3872897327,
0.5264078975,
0.2519681454,
-0.1437159926,
0.4928106964,
-0.0848603472,
-0.176934436,
-0.1146457419,
-0.5065442324,
-0.6069050431,
0.9739826322,
0.0099593047,
0.626136601,
-0.0440088771,
0.5618501902,
0.2798472643,
0.5923827291,
-0.7320805192,
0.2390718907,
-0.2089182138,
-0.2895196974,
-0.3578950763,
-0.5139865875,
-0.7803168893,
0.0662994087,
-0.5192997456,
-0.5253139734,
-0.0602454059,
0.3213528395,
-0.3211669028,
0.1351551265,
-0.7139543891,
0.9593157172,
-0.3293904662,
-0.2461155504,
0.2801340222,
-0.8188925385,
0.4691381752,
-0.2058146596,
-0.0166180115,
-0.1984220892,
0.322881043,
0.7066718936,
-0.1688466817,
0.4942608774,
0.0708091632,
-0.20413737,
0.2904926836,
-0.0708371624,
0.3271678388,
0.1336105019,
-0.0606938265,
0.0902138203,
0.3062943518,
-0.242028892,
-0.8675966263,
0.5724608898,
-0.5246045589,
-0.360253036,
-0.4474032819,
-0.6484704018,
-0.508857131,
0.234010309,
0.4051531851,
0.2929434776,
-0.7481933236,
0.3553610742,
0.6952826977,
0.3051711619,
0.1631714553,
0.5046739578,
0.1936183125,
-0.4476878643,
0.712849319,
-0.184929952,
0.0771948621,
0.5646244287,
0.2137349099,
-0.5335595012,
-0.0614507422,
-0.3977676928,
0.047531575,
-0.5080688596,
-0.6457853317,
-0.5748760104,
-0.2771652341,
-0.4044496119,
0.0442396589,
-0.2530705929,
-0.4303676486,
0.012160643,
0.0522471406,
0.0436048768,
0.5437138677,
0.0118530355,
0.2778725028,
-0.858548224,
0.2902256548,
0.2311512977,
0.4200738966,
-0.3600431681,
-0.5544418693,
-0.3150689006,
0.2289899886,
-0.5544867516,
-0.6807461977,
-0.0817621201,
0.3156428933,
0.566080451,
0.4021899998,
0.1524377018,
0.677093327,
-0.509745419,
0.5234053731,
0.486549437,
-1.1310987473,
0.3231024444,
-0.0343188234,
0.4021887779,
1.0056295395,
0.2309170067,
-0.630843997,
-0.6177252531,
-0.7613320947,
-0.4587978125,
0.3661727309,
0.3697746992,
-0.307787478,
0.1936130822,
0.2917280197,
0.3206041455,
0.2139670253,
-0.3725534976,
0.0166106876,
-0.3622236252,
-0.9422363639,
0.0001533406,
0.1655237228,
-0.5078009963,
-0.1708304435,
0.5964618921,
-0.3229201436,
0.0474632084,
0.30705145,
-0.1965973228,
-0.1782351285,
0.4786753356,
0.501837194,
0.7106167078,
-0.1048245132,
0.1936448365,
0.2627199888,
-0.627766192,
0.3272114694,
0.2412459552,
-0.158162564,
0.1425151378,
0.3138113022,
0.6119941473,
0.3834303916,
-0.6209763885,
0.7043591142,
-0.1465860903,
-0.303276509,
-0.1503994763,
0.2193324119,
-0.0362231024,
0.0843698531,
0.124540478,
0.2546675503,
0.1095215008,
-0.380273819,
0.4935345948,
0.5224934816,
-0.590854466,
-0.4019062221,
0.6539025307,
-0.0822448432,
-0.105964683,
0.4926459491,
-0.277300328,
-0.2951090336,
0.5669804811,
0.5675756931,
0.8918860555,
-0.2741802931,
0.5509110689,
0.4835612774,
0.3269248903,
-0.292891115,
0.1121082753,
0.0377136692,
-0.7984760404,
-0.3823507428,
-0.7146697044,
-0.6344547868,
-0.0622102506,
-0.7917528152,
0.1839019954,
-0.3924963772,
-0.0291909892,
0.1498216838,
0.1249584928,
-0.6433744431,
0.5310516953,
-0.0334774293,
0.6013529301,
-0.8921447396,
0.5225943923,
0.8734276295,
-0.2534056306,
-0.8383410573,
0.336620152,
0.1490643322,
-0.5684421062,
0.2378280312,
0.1275646389,
-0.1878765076,
-0.2546590269,
-0.5851815343,
-0.8933619261,
1.1560662985,
0.5734866858,
-0.4661941826,
0.0478947274,
0.1976573169,
0.588968873,
-0.536166966,
0.0305851176,
0.7556129098,
0.6613203287,
0.047816094,
-0.7080039382,
0.1097996384,
-0.1210379153,
-0.1910133809,
0.3311438859,
-0.52866745,
0.3487191498,
-0.043108575,
-0.3968041837,
0.25261724,
0.7281857133,
0.2600291669,
0.5077897906,
0.4803601503,
0.7457361221,
1.1870210171,
-0.3028198779,
0.7312281132,
-0.2129140645,
0.548088491,
1.3819321394,
-0.6388972402,
0.736225009,
0.4277454317,
0.0842277929,
0.6262428164,
0.1694389433,
-0.2882350981,
0.2797598839,
-0.1917940676,
-0.2594245076,
-0.1029224098,
0.0208114628,
-0.0567836203,
0.5048043728,
-0.0136314072,
0.2509782314,
-0.4531574547,
-0.2414286286,
-0.0018508817,
0.4463071227,
0.104275316,
0.7848867178,
-0.3115698099,
-0.9667912722,
0.2748341858,
-0.0888306722,
0.2493343949,
-0.7290272713,
-0.1270453185,
-0.1952503324,
0.1803946942,
-0.3842197359,
-0.9497782588,
0.4703767598,
-0.0574117973,
-0.1415670663,
0.1196077764,
0.5445064902,
-0.5768549442,
-0.3307313621,
-0.0050529186,
0.1763785034,
-0.3213597834,
0.0518434681,
-0.5045154691,
-0.1721426696,
0.018864803,
0.2500686049,
0.1591382623,
0.7112974524,
0.1218665838,
0.1355046779,
0.5910357833,
-0.2134153694,
-0.0375602134,
-0.2056459785,
0.4487776458,
-0.5111882091,
-0.4306417406,
-0.545463562,
0.6002929211,
-0.4133257866,
-0.7592164874,
1.0050902367,
0.7741995454,
0.6762761474,
0.2039804757,
0.7293889523,
-0.1121126264,
0.5699422359,
-0.4449702501,
0.5400385857,
-0.5361101031,
-0.0311624631,
-0.3087176085,
-1.2525871992,
-0.3087457716,
0.3664946854,
-0.0778826177,
-0.300557673,
0.9543128014,
0.3887608945,
-0.2570520937,
0.2661170363,
0.2491300553,
0.0742025077,
0.0706653148,
0.2427705377,
0.6877190471,
-0.7183923721,
0.6060734391,
-0.0412876531,
-0.2446866632,
-0.1069492251,
-0.9090693593,
-0.4076239169,
-0.5832443237,
-0.599925518,
-0.4470050335,
0.0090554291,
0.5938980579,
0.4536930025,
-1.0842227936,
-0.0526827089,
-0.1621676236,
0.1134182066,
-0.3437625766,
-0.2307340205,
0.2887302637,
-0.4759744704,
-0.4866113365,
0.1360488087,
0.5948272347,
-0.1590897292,
-0.0027931142,
0.0013980956,
-0.2931510806,
0.3634480834,
0.3814025223,
0.5807878971,
-0.4466070831,
-0.560562253,
0.1641500294,
-0.4175284207,
0.476983726,
0.7202658057,
-0.5248152018,
0.4007721245,
0.3178261817,
0.9970274568,
0.1895559132,
0.461209327,
0.5109854937,
-0.8867639899,
-0.2660630643,
0.220571816,
0.2496484667,
0.6261101961,
-0.4414458573,
0.3569540381,
0.1058894768,
-0.7517328858,
-0.5668526888,
0.0549177416,
-1.1759771109,
0.3017106056,
0.8159350753,
-0.1193816513,
-0.221529007,
0.0271373987,
-0.1385458708,
0.4601874053,
-0.1223154366,
0.9286533594,
0.7448472381,
-0.1012714729,
0.3054926395,
-0.2321266681,
0.4864324927,
0.6805476546,
-1.1521209478,
-0.0417145975,
0.5877533555,
0.3641093671,
0.3507691026,
0.2933550477,
-0.1864491701,
0.2805778384,
-0.0747914985,
0.0272241216,
0.5046995878,
-0.3173119128,
-0.2860344648,
0.0328311361,
-0.3158958256,
-0.0769015327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16734v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16734v1 | AMPERE: AMR-Aware Prefix for Generation-Based Event Argument Extraction Model | 2023-05-26T08:38:25 | 2023-05-26T08:38:25 | I-Hung Hsu, Zhiyu Xie, Kuan-Hao Huang, Prem Natarajan, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Event argument extraction (EAE) identifies event arguments and their specific
roles for a given event. Recent advancement in generation-based EAE models has
shown great performance and generalizability over classification-based models.
However, existing generation-based EAE models mostly focus on problem
re-formulation and prompt design, without incorporating additional information
that has been shown to be effective for classification-based models, such as
the abstract meaning representation (AMR) of the input passages. Incorporating
such information into generation-based models is challenging due to the
heterogeneous nature of the natural language form prevalently used in
generation-based models and the structured form of AMRs. In this work, we study
strategies to incorporate AMR into generation-based EAE models. We propose
AMPERE, which generates AMR-aware prefixes for every layer of the generation
model. Thus, the prefix introduces AMR information to the generation-based EAE
model and then improves the generation. We also introduce an adjusted copy
mechanism to AMPERE to help overcome potential noises brought by the AMR graph.
Comprehensive experiments and analyses on ACE2005 and ERE datasets show that
AMPERE can get 4% - 10% absolute F1 score improvements with reduced training
data and it is in general powerful across different training sizes. | [
-0.6229005456,
-0.9292994738,
0.4552677572,
0.1693244874,
-0.3394852281,
-0.137660414,
-0.0523925647,
-0.79157269,
0.21922867,
0.1606294811,
-0.4279202521,
-0.1956966668,
-0.4347387254,
0.1823235899,
-0.4818114042,
0.7350124121,
-0.2188980877,
-0.0163786896,
-0.1762353331,
-0.1361602992,
-0.4412531853,
-0.6459096074,
-1.2479532957,
-0.4162332714,
0.3726299405,
0.1803192198,
0.4050679207,
0.8213382959,
0.3247359693,
0.2480397373,
0.0061434135,
0.1488538533,
-0.0075015952,
0.2559920847,
-0.186825484,
-0.1261375099,
-0.7825577855,
0.0114626428,
0.5219344497,
0.2860459983,
-0.1562379152,
-0.1724771559,
-0.2927201986,
0.0665780306,
-0.5861946344,
-0.0667163134,
-0.8175550103,
0.0449816585,
-0.1009944379,
-0.3508032262,
-0.667807579,
-0.0248537175,
-0.0226129461,
-0.5790735483,
0.3190844953,
0.3256432414,
1.1443191767,
-0.2813751996,
-0.2733557522,
-0.2868621945,
-0.8480706215,
0.839653492,
-0.732001543,
0.5254471302,
-0.0680300146,
0.0777416825,
0.1162351444,
-0.8358857632,
-0.7952654958,
0.0649272949,
0.0322218016,
-0.0342960842,
-0.5272313952,
0.208524242,
0.0970296562,
0.4766942263,
-0.0720153525,
0.1704466343,
-0.1082027331,
-0.2493766844,
0.8219016194,
0.1485979557,
0.2474156469,
-0.2397589535,
-0.3750601411,
-0.0215243287,
-0.6857685447,
-0.2364425063,
0.4103619158,
0.2903157175,
-0.1182551533,
0.4214762449,
-0.0237106383,
0.5818107128,
0.3490955234,
0.3908695877,
0.1009785607,
-0.3059009016,
-0.1592685878,
0.1290038526,
0.7536235452,
-0.0770779774,
0.2410247326,
-0.3214706481,
-0.2915682793,
-0.0880037844,
0.304461062,
-0.9463739395,
-0.2613963783,
0.1434714943,
-0.269585222,
-0.4789246023,
0.0764144361,
-1.000826478,
-0.3504795134,
-0.4295883477,
0.4555636346,
-0.4231771231,
0.0439475775,
-0.0881522149,
-0.1435901374,
0.4888721406,
0.4441893399,
-0.6722163558,
0.4158257544,
0.3789402544,
0.6792898774,
-0.1273467988,
-0.0090678828,
-0.947753489,
0.3043461442,
0.1135667786,
1.1374599934,
-0.7810150385,
-0.6676306129,
-0.2248301655,
-0.1140216812,
-0.2872105837,
-0.3614029884,
0.7032803297,
-0.6441432238,
0.3769958019,
-0.0385881849,
-0.8698360324,
-0.2394533753,
0.171647355,
-0.5990720987,
0.5532574058,
-0.4573884606,
-0.3760918975,
0.3995164037,
-1.0663381815,
-0.6505852938,
0.0047134818,
-0.2797280848,
-0.6175058484,
0.2465286851,
0.5756995082,
0.2241815776,
-0.1310890019,
-0.0488622487,
-0.0756600499,
0.1017251834,
0.161286518,
-0.6910446286,
0.3579435647,
0.0914035887,
-0.3320793211,
0.1577242762,
-0.7706092,
0.0389565006,
-0.0070918552,
-0.251486361,
-0.2186412066,
0.3394289315,
0.0173674487,
0.1624671072,
-0.0031365834,
-0.6122226119,
0.1676092893,
-0.5680205226,
0.114614211,
0.7737712264,
0.6510401964,
0.3379272521,
-0.179931432,
0.4913308322,
0.1908015162,
-0.0661624894,
-0.2860020399,
-0.5296834707,
-0.8591774106,
-0.2767365575,
0.5126364231,
0.6218444109,
-0.3894740343,
0.2963686585,
-0.0568509698,
-0.1329146773,
-0.6243558526,
0.1253426373,
0.2047911584,
0.3325782716,
0.6522486806,
-0.2193205357,
-0.8255383372,
-0.8826733232,
-0.1745936424,
-0.4030317664,
0.1085867435,
0.4588969052,
0.2880781591,
0.0124821402,
0.8286928535,
-0.528960526,
-0.1874049455,
-0.3811582923,
0.4330475032,
-0.144422099,
0.4578196406,
0.2296661139,
-0.8660721779,
-0.1656010449,
0.2749935687,
-0.6429492235,
-0.4294962883,
-0.2749473155,
-0.1716376543,
0.074506171,
0.3945078254,
-0.6448996067,
0.519015491,
0.1099971384,
-0.6974064708,
0.6556212902,
0.0464509204,
0.3901646137,
-1.3304861784,
-0.0433016084,
0.0749766156,
-0.1152306423,
-0.6553246379,
0.0246822294,
-0.1329169422,
-0.0745836794,
-0.447396636,
0.8098537922,
-0.4105041623,
0.3026694655,
-0.3872845173,
0.1026398763,
0.4017884731,
0.2546935976,
0.1803856492,
0.7012251019,
0.4178974926,
-0.6774284244,
0.1898547262,
0.4035796523,
0.184826687,
0.6886850595,
-0.6860806346,
0.1720443517,
-0.1259747148,
-0.2197112292,
-0.4355816543,
-0.1340820789,
0.0235079788,
-0.3151317239,
0.6428136826,
-0.1012473032,
-0.1343926787,
-0.0482961908,
-0.0224524569,
0.3283783793,
0.4130530655,
-0.5760794282,
0.9171453118,
0.3903813362,
-0.2034233809,
-0.1988321245,
-0.3613506258,
0.2245691717,
-0.3791941106,
-0.6032806635,
0.6195773482,
0.1061098203,
-0.3734785914,
0.1509324312,
-0.117421858,
-0.0309343375,
-0.0918401778,
0.1087415963,
0.1713902652,
-0.4954248667,
0.2921623886,
0.0222979579,
-0.1467122734,
0.0870359614,
-0.0992861539,
0.3626023531,
-0.033231128,
-0.4582588077,
-0.3034477234,
0.6755383015,
0.5983254313,
-0.3931585252,
0.751124382,
0.2475919724,
-0.4885214567,
-0.3732219338,
-0.6292542815,
-0.4890590012,
-0.4283208251,
0.361448735,
-0.4043620527,
-0.4444600642,
0.589964807,
-0.0474189557,
0.421092391,
0.4673727751,
0.3883244991,
-0.0655641034,
1.1273174286,
0.2031050622,
0.0016386977,
0.53539294,
-0.2521190643,
0.2720974982,
-0.9080871344,
-0.2798811197,
-0.4418666661,
-0.3492360115,
0.1568169296,
-0.4570748806,
0.0898065418,
0.085867472,
-0.0013295427,
0.2849651575,
-0.1369930804,
0.4494961798,
0.0929252878,
-0.1218434721,
0.4335552156,
0.1033964455,
0.0552827716,
0.0286046173,
-0.6420323849,
-0.6005554199,
0.5269613266,
0.3026492,
0.4931381345,
0.1417587847,
0.7116158605,
0.5871454477,
0.5068327785,
-0.7641755939,
0.6772964001,
-0.0202981494,
-0.7347371578,
-0.0650101081,
-0.4006391764,
-0.8915004134,
0.4964234531,
-0.2855805457,
-0.9700756669,
0.4953025877,
0.2487450987,
-0.0217793807,
0.6279358864,
-0.6144703627,
0.803465724,
0.0224025864,
-0.4641059935,
-0.1578094959,
-0.0372251868,
0.0881556496,
0.0395397954,
0.2337211818,
0.0082203066,
0.0845188946,
0.7658045292,
-0.5102694035,
0.5975996256,
-0.1849921346,
0.0472393595,
0.5887237787,
-0.0792491511,
0.9873228073,
0.0957154259,
-0.4080656469,
-0.0675216615,
-0.6190372109,
-0.2821240127,
-0.6408270597,
0.6818418503,
-0.5485644341,
-0.780313015,
-0.0132633103,
-0.3379444778,
-0.278316021,
-0.159374103,
0.3899308145,
0.8462874293,
-0.2457598001,
0.1127955094,
0.5570325851,
0.0707597584,
0.6269186735,
0.5173335671,
-0.0030146998,
-0.428739965,
0.7224422097,
-0.1027571708,
0.0319082737,
0.2701211274,
-0.1015961543,
-0.3167794943,
-0.5408005118,
-0.6390024424,
0.1913587004,
-0.8158640862,
-0.3620198667,
-1.0023808479,
-0.1956879795,
0.1139461249,
-0.587067306,
-0.2951005399,
-0.5902747512,
-0.293302387,
-0.4711012244,
0.5065674782,
0.3141795397,
0.140862897,
0.3845604658,
-0.6499838829,
0.201458782,
0.2477578819,
0.2758406103,
0.2250356078,
-0.3479129672,
-0.0736863986,
-0.0771918446,
-0.6402952075,
-1.2019252777,
0.189998135,
0.5679064393,
0.6504147053,
0.2810012102,
0.0043655806,
0.8779517412,
-0.44063586,
0.7325224876,
0.1551425606,
-1.1369203329,
0.7267315388,
0.00332006,
0.132696256,
0.47090137,
-0.1228878275,
-0.0678957105,
-0.6123294234,
-0.9662948847,
-1.0418510437,
0.5660793185,
0.594897449,
0.2162778676,
-0.3062024713,
0.2808375657,
-0.0424021445,
0.078638196,
-0.8895658255,
-0.2134144157,
-0.0127330031,
-0.2358032465,
0.4001235068,
0.0482639335,
0.2400510013,
-0.0872258991,
1.0974611044,
0.2216743082,
0.3048889339,
0.3424393237,
-0.0737711415,
-0.3648689687,
0.5969737768,
0.2490102202,
0.1896756887,
0.1352463365,
0.1898793578,
0.5912012458,
-0.468266964,
0.2666441798,
0.3022360206,
-0.3937346339,
0.2928601503,
0.478077203,
1.0127030611,
0.2337212712,
-0.4179736674,
0.3152388632,
0.0651009753,
-0.1994327158,
-0.1233055815,
0.1378454268,
-0.1375318021,
0.0894535184,
0.2640165687,
0.1309721023,
0.2859602273,
-0.3053774834,
0.5660831332,
0.4901200533,
-0.5423830152,
-0.5498825908,
0.9341598749,
0.51301682,
-0.2122307569,
0.3770193458,
-0.1675193161,
-0.3134357035,
0.5764141679,
0.710975945,
1.0599687099,
-0.3055539727,
0.0043766252,
0.3791623414,
0.1838548928,
0.4289971888,
0.3579426706,
0.0525931045,
-0.6802136898,
-0.6052222252,
-0.9324168563,
-0.1919572204,
0.2926095128,
-0.4243811965,
0.4364623427,
-0.2301993817,
-0.2549633384,
0.3111014962,
-0.0694566071,
-0.6062093377,
0.1674303561,
0.2427048534,
1.0744906664,
-0.9080492258,
0.5557330251,
1.0909811258,
-0.3650800288,
-0.9458042979,
-0.0398845114,
-0.2263245583,
-0.1550740898,
0.2359111756,
-0.0076652365,
-0.0079820305,
0.2802030146,
-0.0118888998,
-0.4274424016,
0.9538057446,
0.1615849286,
-0.2613166571,
0.0424366146,
-0.2225591689,
0.3320039213,
-0.7775532603,
-0.0358897634,
0.0926559716,
0.6988337636,
0.3860553801,
-0.5453723073,
0.1976346374,
-0.358899951,
-0.1959531456,
0.7583341599,
-0.1588252336,
0.5090921521,
-0.2788350582,
-0.4350001514,
-0.1150135323,
0.8044211268,
0.3527726233,
0.6499925852,
0.3882576525,
0.5787120461,
0.6318760514,
-0.1474548876,
1.1108967066,
-0.0849339664,
0.0989662185,
0.8828674555,
-0.2927391529,
0.7534976602,
0.6424408555,
0.0274957549,
0.7254888415,
0.0321314149,
0.0176119208,
0.395142585,
-0.0163892098,
-0.7790317535,
-0.4237285256,
-0.0284015555,
-0.1901821643,
0.3162841797,
0.4050822556,
-0.6122450829,
-0.4106613696,
0.0180344097,
0.1518216282,
-0.0198480766,
-0.4050383866,
1.089201808,
0.1227367148,
-0.5327637792,
0.1917366683,
0.1288377792,
0.1727101952,
-0.6929304004,
-0.2407281399,
-0.0770801827,
0.0743912011,
-0.1359199286,
-0.3445407748,
0.3972624242,
0.195934996,
-0.4426399171,
0.2095102817,
0.9172021151,
-0.3819874227,
-0.6163010597,
0.1018161029,
0.6491728425,
-0.0886377916,
0.238689065,
-0.503590703,
0.1219165698,
0.0542229712,
-0.6296548843,
0.1271802336,
0.4526396096,
-0.1999685913,
0.4506411552,
0.6348010302,
0.3140380085,
0.0406616442,
-0.0018261509,
0.6732082963,
-0.5541905165,
-0.4857907891,
-1.0906187296,
0.7899105549,
-0.5387791395,
-0.2019139677,
0.6607471108,
0.4835426211,
0.2717658579,
-0.093201898,
0.8588960767,
-0.2614215314,
-0.1391262561,
-0.5701910853,
0.331178993,
-0.3159271479,
0.5808883905,
-0.189702332,
-0.9086302519,
-0.2962301672,
0.5412664413,
-0.4812431335,
-0.0256672204,
0.3997820616,
0.6569553018,
-0.3965476155,
0.4319349527,
0.242920801,
0.1548352987,
0.5476204753,
0.3804186881,
0.6445929408,
-0.5356904268,
0.3874613047,
0.0693334639,
-0.0968407616,
-0.2343402803,
-1.0047094822,
-0.5709350109,
-0.4343962073,
-0.8990294337,
-0.0085579632,
0.2363132238,
0.8272079229,
0.843290031,
-1.1276437044,
0.0570548959,
-0.3700832725,
0.0644495711,
-0.2499569505,
-0.2931492031,
0.287479043,
-0.4945830107,
-0.6285941005,
0.5596562624,
0.1791059673,
0.345805198,
0.3137218058,
-0.1690505892,
-0.3669542074,
0.7184630036,
0.5996932983,
0.3875047266,
-0.5344082713,
-0.5634330511,
-0.287602514,
0.4036621749,
-0.0528312773,
0.8015080094,
-0.7988145947,
0.341021806,
0.2376266271,
0.412799269,
0.2657037377,
0.3146853447,
0.9554181695,
-1.2009445429,
-0.0127210002,
0.180128023,
0.7714589834,
0.2787902653,
-0.3554158807,
0.3775526285,
0.2482275814,
-0.3647504747,
-0.8468987942,
0.4110713899,
-0.8840259314,
-0.240517512,
1.0369882584,
-0.0461332947,
0.0736927614,
-0.2446930408,
-0.3552705944,
0.2474246919,
-0.4036676884,
0.6743014455,
0.7107168436,
-0.2949605584,
-0.2550750375,
-0.368129611,
0.2857037485,
0.2205881923,
-0.9013904333,
0.2013424486,
0.659840703,
-0.1511044949,
0.2867751122,
0.2826003432,
-0.3632824421,
0.29946661,
0.0177462995,
0.201876387,
-0.327380091,
-0.2537858486,
-0.1740160286,
0.6251571774,
0.1094809994,
-0.1300410777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16731v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16731v4 | Automatic Emotion Experiencer Recognition | 2023-05-26T08:33:28 | 2023-07-27T15:09:38 | Maximilian Wegge, Roman Klinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | The most prominent subtask in emotion analysis is emotion classification; to
assign a category to a textual unit, for instance a social media post. Many
research questions from the social sciences do, however, not only require the
detection of the emotion of an author of a post but to understand who is
ascribed an emotion in text. This task is tackled by emotion role labeling
which aims at extracting who is described in text to experience an emotion,
why, and towards whom. This could, however, be considered overly sophisticated
if the main question to answer is who feels which emotion. A targeted approach
for such setup is to classify emotion experiencer mentions (aka "emoters")
regarding the emotion they presumably perceive. This task is similar to named
entity recognition of person names with the difference that not every mentioned
entity name is an emoter. While, very recently, data with emoter annotations
has been made available, no experiments have yet been performed to detect such
mentions. With this paper, we provide baseline experiments to understand how
challenging the task is. We further evaluate the impact on experiencer-specific
emotion categorization and appraisal detection in a pipeline, when gold
mentions are not available. We show that experiencer detection in text is a
challenging task, with a precision of .82 and a recall of .56 (F1 =.66). These
results motivate future work of jointly modeling emoter spans and
emotion/appraisal predictions. | [
-0.441883117,
-0.6567621231,
0.3618647158,
-0.0183307175,
-0.1300434023,
0.1416298151,
-0.0351725146,
-0.8736065626,
0.4530754983,
0.2666286528,
-0.386587292,
-0.283839196,
-0.8652516007,
0.3268136382,
-0.1712061167,
1.194444418,
-0.3508003652,
-0.5806615353,
-0.090319775,
-0.0812289193,
-0.2022573501,
-0.9218610525,
-0.759178102,
-0.3713738322,
0.8483263254,
0.2995127141,
0.2984303534,
0.125217706,
0.5745995045,
0.3551515937,
-0.2247010022,
-0.0327858441,
-0.1742582321,
0.1916137785,
0.0912776738,
-0.4279960096,
-0.3198848069,
0.0567051955,
0.1088811085,
0.1068043932,
-0.0587418377,
0.0458342098,
-0.0174510647,
0.6069367528,
-0.8612235785,
0.3369779289,
-0.4440804422,
0.6605629325,
-0.1595491767,
-0.4047886431,
-0.213297382,
-0.3124764264,
0.4593869448,
-0.3704091907,
0.2527819276,
0.3066506982,
0.6333847046,
0.2764772773,
-0.574332118,
-0.5755812526,
-0.5810195804,
0.6615244746,
-0.1195765212,
0.3042162359,
0.3261241913,
0.1392834634,
0.308901608,
-0.4995876253,
-0.6534312963,
-0.0701444894,
-0.3970932961,
0.1575204879,
-0.571901381,
0.2927080393,
0.1964566112,
0.4556739628,
-0.2476598471,
-0.1090105101,
-0.3260640204,
-0.0027277665,
0.5893527865,
0.2908475399,
0.3900493085,
-0.3252775371,
-0.2645736039,
0.1610406041,
-0.1905540824,
0.3557220101,
0.4102112651,
-0.0980211496,
0.018780699,
0.642088294,
0.0900358409,
0.4443171322,
0.2014432698,
0.2933887839,
0.4337969124,
0.1591491997,
-0.1358230412,
0.3455826938,
0.7121457458,
0.2747308612,
0.4625997245,
-0.1023245677,
-0.1756922454,
0.2753536701,
0.4920732975,
-0.6424039602,
-0.3811932802,
0.270986408,
-0.435590148,
-0.2836436331,
-0.0295807496,
-0.8106766343,
-0.8611471057,
-0.073654227,
0.7767773867,
-0.2263172865,
-0.3184089363,
-0.2099379003,
-0.3486976027,
0.0616041832,
0.5044345856,
-1.0178991556,
0.3694498539,
0.576851666,
0.6161106825,
-0.2289411724,
-0.0657806173,
-0.1267697662,
-0.2029447407,
-0.1993799508,
1.0178552866,
-0.6563093662,
-0.1826407015,
-0.0386379436,
0.262062937,
-0.3792623878,
-0.4030769169,
0.484331727,
-0.4309821129,
-0.1574296802,
-0.2877638936,
-0.7261570692,
-0.1426110864,
0.4771313667,
-0.7734633088,
0.9125920534,
-0.027575057,
-1.0118508339,
0.50804919,
-0.7126855254,
-0.086963065,
0.0017711446,
-0.001126776,
-0.2437409014,
0.2522931099,
0.0793418139,
0.6082980037,
-0.0371718891,
-0.303366065,
-0.1109280959,
-0.3143755496,
0.6585665345,
0.0903585479,
-0.0059250356,
0.1282709092,
-0.3550801575,
0.0563432835,
-0.4682955146,
-0.3163893819,
-0.2350381613,
-0.2105911672,
-0.7716606259,
0.0466396771,
0.2532916963,
0.2626676261,
0.1651049405,
-0.7092585564,
0.0180657282,
-0.1292413622,
0.090382643,
0.7642710805,
0.1220806837,
0.2882987261,
-0.0022998597,
0.7225533724,
0.0212257709,
0.0112340264,
-0.2462248504,
-0.3061566949,
-0.7981891036,
-0.1369940937,
0.3099947274,
0.6778547168,
-0.3934215605,
0.4664973319,
0.0452306308,
-0.463773936,
-0.5680394173,
0.0403772742,
0.5190246701,
0.3259648979,
0.2911091745,
-0.0761261731,
-0.6777266264,
-0.7702995539,
-0.7757204175,
-0.4099081755,
0.0373149253,
0.3559558392,
0.6069950461,
0.0550458319,
0.7849426866,
-0.4960352182,
-0.6925297379,
-0.1811985224,
0.5056350231,
-0.4446325302,
0.3252879083,
0.2653450072,
-1.0175822973,
-0.4584017396,
0.187178418,
-0.9736677408,
-0.2160608619,
0.1010267064,
0.13630867,
0.3314838707,
0.5089366436,
-0.322171092,
0.6495580673,
0.3588538468,
-0.5180777907,
0.0207441021,
-0.1369804889,
0.4679161608,
-0.6167823672,
0.0924143717,
0.2825876176,
0.1828595847,
-0.621707201,
-0.4818745553,
0.0366613902,
0.1830218434,
-0.3310036063,
0.7044929862,
-0.4951483905,
-0.0197725743,
-0.2299862057,
-0.1458286643,
-0.2840138078,
0.4108494222,
0.3390327692,
0.2665557265,
0.1698828042,
-0.4108924568,
0.2959213257,
0.2015132457,
-0.2698337138,
0.8536692858,
-0.5373262167,
0.2814581692,
-0.316943258,
0.0615195595,
-1.3611038923,
-0.3460291028,
0.3307363689,
-0.4773174524,
0.2441164106,
-0.2166569531,
-0.4762490988,
-0.4206450582,
-0.1967642307,
0.2488813251,
0.6178843379,
-0.3339723647,
0.7792500257,
0.52888906,
-0.205399707,
-0.4877059162,
-0.6915781498,
0.037936125,
-0.6492251158,
-0.2458649427,
0.2479332387,
0.1777526438,
-0.2744896114,
0.0497363955,
-0.1180611625,
-0.1118583903,
-0.0396504477,
0.544023633,
-0.1869143099,
0.4095664322,
0.3829900622,
0.0963101834,
-0.3181967735,
0.1764232218,
0.5245150924,
-0.0337872654,
-0.1231901497,
-0.2084486037,
-0.5769304037,
0.3372887969,
0.3036114573,
-0.2285379916,
0.7545938492,
0.7749292254,
-0.6539842486,
0.0727476478,
-0.7900470495,
0.0810269117,
-0.4279425144,
0.2209333479,
-0.442522347,
-0.9178805947,
0.7612777352,
0.012477505,
-0.1492761225,
0.3858411312,
0.2821983993,
-0.0565715618,
1.1669014692,
0.7418859005,
0.1706804186,
0.6321834922,
0.0311349053,
0.141324237,
-0.9711366296,
-0.4721696675,
-0.4907948077,
-0.6194508076,
-0.4914420247,
-0.0984332263,
0.3795232475,
-0.1098414063,
0.0209571905,
0.1287855655,
-0.5414220691,
0.2584795058,
0.0502432026,
0.1827253401,
0.0997730866,
-0.1174112186,
0.2822373807,
-0.5149128437,
-0.2528166473,
-0.6556568742,
0.6193695068,
0.3467630446,
0.8231191039,
-0.0812073275,
0.8921293616,
0.5942668319,
0.6403797865,
-1.0825204849,
0.3157985806,
-0.0035888553,
-0.6603932381,
-0.121542424,
-0.0572352186,
-0.9959642887,
0.1650861204,
-0.1326699108,
-1.0823837519,
0.4298794866,
0.3344614804,
-0.3820761144,
0.1138480157,
-0.7821353078,
1.0718048811,
0.0488104485,
-0.0613009371,
0.115653418,
-0.7409410477,
0.110962674,
-0.2607948482,
0.3174833953,
-0.1011355892,
-0.2585560381,
1.1346541643,
-0.2880313993,
0.8196892738,
-0.4499717057,
-0.0539572835,
0.4275122881,
0.1463751495,
0.3983491659,
-0.4428611696,
-0.1995678246,
-0.1706951559,
-0.263350904,
0.0477479361,
-0.680028975,
0.5131498575,
-0.6210798621,
-0.1688087881,
-0.565367341,
-0.1995571703,
-0.0139910011,
-0.3914553225,
0.2216366976,
-0.1416121274,
-0.3869535029,
0.1156734154,
0.5742172599,
-0.2651385069,
0.3278084099,
0.3373655379,
0.1195683554,
-0.3851465881,
0.6998868585,
0.3395060003,
-0.1352266073,
0.3469525874,
0.0542579107,
-0.2566573024,
-0.1318506896,
-0.2871502042,
-0.0455020852,
-0.6978080869,
-0.1011584327,
-1.2139800787,
0.1063063219,
0.0207687877,
-0.2908628881,
-0.2930009067,
-0.2478484064,
-0.3665404618,
-0.4385857582,
0.8922707438,
0.8367478848,
-0.148912847,
0.3975066543,
-0.6722477078,
0.1597636044,
0.5127087831,
0.1614249498,
0.1075441912,
-0.439091444,
-0.1703170389,
-0.4184884429,
-0.2751340568,
-1.062087059,
0.5648582578,
0.308690846,
0.4386042058,
0.5056554079,
0.3081938326,
0.7130299807,
-0.4894545674,
0.8330350518,
0.0220378283,
-1.1907778978,
0.7463979125,
0.0915924758,
-0.3845517039,
0.3318933845,
0.5563277006,
-0.7685562372,
-0.344450593,
-0.705411315,
-1.046192646,
0.795584023,
0.3479667604,
0.2969826162,
-0.2322740555,
0.466448456,
0.1027316302,
0.3309695125,
-0.5667226911,
-0.2660454214,
0.1243155971,
-0.3072336614,
-0.1647222638,
-0.4077353477,
0.1176339313,
-0.1473444253,
0.1773009151,
0.0625135526,
0.5366882682,
0.4795010686,
-0.2869565785,
-0.3586449623,
0.4096082747,
0.0437305309,
0.193464756,
-0.3366593122,
0.2322153598,
0.314794898,
-0.2832864523,
0.2425348312,
0.2097921968,
0.4543008208,
0.0096611306,
0.2931739688,
0.7386075258,
0.4042515457,
-0.4809348881,
0.5910336375,
-0.0437534302,
-0.0238633733,
-0.5057923794,
-0.0506095029,
-0.0549207814,
0.4903535545,
0.745054841,
-0.1566993892,
0.3758288026,
-0.6239438057,
0.1835370064,
0.1938473731,
-0.9254590273,
-0.6041126847,
0.5759227276,
0.1721580178,
-0.3342932463,
0.1849558204,
-0.1488604695,
-0.9716296196,
0.831223011,
0.3403351605,
1.003480196,
-0.5338164568,
0.0072470172,
0.0707501769,
0.185167104,
-0.0051655676,
0.6151781082,
-0.0407658368,
-0.68314749,
0.0811668113,
-0.5604118109,
-0.6657769084,
-0.3332381248,
-0.7964137197,
0.2321000397,
-0.2933017612,
-0.3317688107,
0.3401278257,
-0.0804295316,
-0.6488710642,
0.5898362994,
0.2443825155,
0.4689788818,
-1.2094004154,
0.3159700334,
1.0385422707,
-0.2371251285,
-0.6332637072,
-0.2058062553,
0.1890469044,
-0.3742137849,
0.9423976541,
0.4528443217,
0.0174774099,
0.0081600193,
-0.3887897134,
-0.3397494555,
1.0041052103,
-0.0713154152,
-0.0534357056,
0.0942777023,
-0.2855962515,
1.0484719276,
-0.5311095715,
0.6240302324,
0.2784694135,
0.381169647,
0.0850618854,
-1.002450943,
0.0472956188,
-0.5373730659,
-0.0800938681,
0.4411708415,
-0.7262507677,
1.0536087751,
-0.0937151611,
0.0415157676,
-0.1080840752,
0.6051480174,
0.3278072476,
0.7337759733,
0.767034471,
0.3110253513,
0.6380403638,
-0.0488866791,
0.9928116202,
0.0730846375,
0.4426673353,
0.5179731846,
-0.3624896705,
0.9384570122,
0.6022392511,
-0.1910730749,
0.7006254792,
0.8775089979,
0.11324884,
0.4122098982,
0.3721710145,
-0.3757661879,
-0.2912849486,
-0.2500560582,
-0.381983608,
0.5002177954,
0.6779161096,
-0.7546110153,
0.148518905,
0.3057441413,
0.025249768,
-0.2461305708,
-0.3840181828,
0.8568383455,
0.1179151312,
-0.375634551,
0.041895207,
-0.243477121,
0.9493284822,
-0.4040587842,
-0.1977312714,
0.0174245145,
0.3662815094,
-0.4614313543,
-0.7444573641,
0.3855537474,
0.3583915234,
-0.0439762995,
-0.0962419286,
0.9987514019,
-0.2620609701,
-0.3431575894,
0.4512340426,
0.5034343004,
0.5085868239,
-0.2328949273,
-0.3916954696,
-0.0030432199,
-0.3626506627,
-0.7234244943,
0.3240509629,
0.8938580751,
0.0576045886,
0.4962021708,
0.2275510728,
-0.4227482975,
0.0577839129,
-0.2589834929,
0.6113139391,
-0.9161227345,
-0.5905437469,
-0.9224759936,
0.6698327661,
-0.0104880519,
-0.3472001851,
0.6197103858,
0.3689672053,
0.4399015009,
-0.2418793291,
0.8457401991,
-0.3291177452,
0.4987108409,
-0.1759457588,
0.7750871778,
-0.9568532109,
-0.0091419294,
-1.0290865898,
-0.6053671241,
-0.3296752274,
0.7279171944,
-0.3670851588,
0.1879855692,
0.631698072,
0.386544764,
0.0451019853,
0.1072580442,
0.1967546344,
-0.1421639919,
0.0105657885,
0.6466992497,
1.1673777103,
-0.5951675177,
0.5811749697,
-0.212634474,
-0.181448102,
-0.2745050788,
-0.931863308,
-1.0327237844,
-0.4712153971,
-0.624802351,
-0.2765929699,
0.1668051481,
1.1091617346,
0.2008246481,
-0.7659029961,
-0.0945372134,
0.183131367,
0.0511964969,
-0.0816319659,
-0.2433989346,
0.3884879649,
-0.0823573843,
-0.8669325113,
-0.2298100293,
0.1058254391,
0.1137434021,
0.3178177476,
-0.0656272918,
0.0038448735,
-0.0052882819,
0.5734681487,
0.3114144802,
-0.727383554,
-0.5014836192,
-0.0521522984,
0.0375275835,
-0.1030827314,
0.7245785594,
-0.7491089106,
0.5272197127,
0.4788965881,
0.4304311872,
0.4762313068,
-0.0152377784,
0.2666917145,
-0.7624041438,
-0.1592277884,
0.0677022859,
0.2531761229,
0.3663116693,
-0.5922985673,
0.583376646,
0.2149585336,
-0.6393625736,
-0.8113696575,
-0.1087981686,
-0.9003638029,
0.2134743929,
0.9979497194,
-0.4354455471,
-0.1455446333,
-0.2014605701,
-0.5060884356,
0.4656043351,
-0.4942449331,
0.9422807693,
0.8547132015,
-0.652649343,
-0.5788151622,
-0.4006264806,
0.6517270207,
0.3001992702,
-0.8106755018,
0.0907395408,
0.3654361367,
0.2318092734,
0.2641049027,
0.7336137295,
0.0275026709,
0.1069867015,
-0.0773611292,
0.4245904088,
0.1684671342,
-0.1181915253,
-0.4878813922,
0.3670826554,
-0.1712606847,
-0.2173977494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16726v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16726v1 | RankCSE: Unsupervised Sentence Representations Learning via Learning to Rank | 2023-05-26T08:27:07 | 2023-05-26T08:27:07 | Jiduan Liu, Jiahao Liu, Qifan Wang, Jingang Wang, Wei Wu, Yunsen Xian, Dongyan Zhao, Kai Chen, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Unsupervised sentence representation learning is one of the fundamental
problems in natural language processing with various downstream applications.
Recently, contrastive learning has been widely adopted which derives
high-quality sentence representations by pulling similar semantics closer and
pushing dissimilar ones away. However, these methods fail to capture the
fine-grained ranking information among the sentences, where each sentence is
only treated as either positive or negative. In many real-world scenarios, one
needs to distinguish and rank the sentences based on their similarities to a
query sentence, e.g., very relevant, moderate relevant, less relevant,
irrelevant, etc. In this paper, we propose a novel approach, RankCSE, for
unsupervised sentence representation learning, which incorporates ranking
consistency and ranking distillation with contrastive learning into a unified
framework. In particular, we learn semantically discriminative sentence
representations by simultaneously ensuring ranking consistency between two
representations with different dropout masks, and distilling listwise ranking
knowledge from the teacher. An extensive set of experiments are conducted on
both semantic textual similarity (STS) and transfer (TR) tasks. Experimental
results demonstrate the superior performance of our approach over several
state-of-the-art baselines. | [
-0.1512913555,
-0.2361197025,
0.5919899344,
0.0571060926,
-0.3370504677,
0.3251394629,
-0.28666085,
-0.0457773209,
0.3005307019,
0.4709535837,
-0.276165992,
-0.7316736579,
-0.9189341664,
-0.0052123996,
-0.4857019484,
1.0197464228,
0.2132812887,
0.1153742895,
-0.4110033512,
-0.1573588252,
-0.5168691278,
-0.5588151217,
-0.3650233746,
-0.1810489148,
0.3587917387,
0.4517871737,
0.2809611857,
0.0652857423,
0.5195807219,
0.3117522299,
-0.0323728956,
0.2060898095,
-0.7736420035,
0.4193795621,
-0.4077633023,
-0.2496349066,
0.4165670872,
0.237037316,
0.5777562261,
1.0627193451,
-0.1451431811,
-0.1526882797,
0.4808100164,
0.6775742173,
-0.636347115,
0.201126352,
-0.9440667629,
-0.0743273944,
0.0219357032,
-0.1271833032,
-0.6465001106,
-0.3438676596,
0.0159853436,
-0.62656039,
-0.0595356748,
-0.1560657024,
0.782053113,
0.2765060365,
-0.7879061699,
-0.1283240616,
-0.3083080649,
0.6787611246,
-0.4435120523,
0.1171000898,
0.1878330112,
0.3281742632,
-0.2280465513,
-0.738941133,
-0.2306528538,
-0.2827337682,
-0.2715762556,
0.4711703956,
0.034385059,
-0.1353996545,
-0.0154044898,
0.4228518903,
-0.4817126691,
0.1679322869,
-0.0076114242,
-0.0029607054,
0.3594929874,
-0.1900650263,
0.0735683143,
-0.2514935136,
-0.6746598482,
-0.3364557326,
-0.4197636545,
0.3160521686,
0.0995716378,
0.4098848403,
0.2067473233,
0.3160802722,
-0.2372619957,
0.2836776972,
0.1001478136,
0.333334744,
0.1327742487,
-0.0572844073,
-0.1271894872,
0.1107963175,
0.768464148,
0.3498693109,
0.0699445084,
-0.4801867008,
0.0132580753,
0.1935140193,
0.391820997,
-0.8665786982,
-0.4297167063,
-0.1667146087,
-0.3939777911,
-0.6031597257,
0.6702799797,
-0.7892247438,
-0.3115739822,
-0.3112527132,
0.5617603064,
-0.2367379069,
0.1901489645,
-0.0406238623,
-0.0450359806,
-0.0140839685,
0.0314214565,
-1.0093231201,
0.4792248309,
0.3640565872,
0.4506999552,
-0.6282116175,
-0.1484793127,
-0.8764888644,
0.2189198732,
-0.2607141137,
0.7354069948,
-0.6590040922,
-0.174741134,
0.0258674119,
0.182805106,
-0.2859371305,
-0.541211307,
0.6397522688,
-0.5223037004,
0.2707122266,
-0.1282304823,
-0.798713088,
-0.1093668863,
0.0230216961,
-0.4122414589,
1.0566927195,
0.0368182883,
-0.7196264267,
0.3480179012,
-0.2955724299,
-0.3822533786,
0.0220726039,
-0.2115217447,
-0.5173205733,
0.2676108778,
0.3020957112,
0.6667003632,
0.038406413,
0.2429775447,
-0.010584712,
-0.7052356005,
0.0575949736,
-0.248241365,
0.7180933952,
0.0503151529,
-0.2646849453,
-0.0446641035,
-0.7135234475,
-0.002725071,
0.1169617921,
-0.0958968922,
-0.6693159938,
-0.1763671488,
-0.0269036889,
0.0678893849,
0.167088151,
-0.6104633808,
0.286398679,
-0.2918580472,
0.5510975718,
0.5596085787,
0.2478907555,
0.5641415715,
0.0258360524,
0.0551637895,
0.3349435031,
-0.3124385774,
-0.0218250211,
-0.1149939224,
-0.6997979879,
-0.0541302264,
0.4800449312,
0.499772042,
-0.6287871599,
0.6893872023,
-0.251354754,
-0.1606161743,
-0.4688691199,
0.0335051566,
0.2121389806,
0.2437006831,
0.6202529073,
-0.2259628028,
-0.4121885598,
-0.5633051991,
-0.2202358842,
0.0031339678,
-0.073012121,
-0.1422896087,
0.3719358444,
-0.0453474335,
0.7471474409,
-0.7533992529,
-0.6395797133,
-0.289737463,
0.3732904494,
-0.0814276934,
0.5666718483,
0.3556566238,
-0.986278832,
-0.4609659016,
-0.1186799631,
-0.6736735106,
-0.0757932365,
-0.1297471672,
-0.2427560836,
0.0226421747,
0.8722455502,
-0.2708560824,
0.2455652207,
0.4033358991,
-0.2077760547,
0.0864637569,
-0.4289501011,
0.4312596619,
-1.4093135595,
-0.059792161,
-0.0397830084,
-0.3885710537,
-0.2022634745,
-0.0682241172,
-0.0311174672,
-0.3117056191,
-0.2463715076,
0.0806108341,
-0.3823629022,
-0.1153890416,
-0.010995294,
0.4566957653,
0.156026423,
0.6768220067,
-0.049756784,
0.6191333532,
0.6311545372,
-0.3723230362,
0.1214586198,
0.3266469538,
-0.108166039,
0.5403203964,
-0.3984589279,
-0.2547417879,
-0.1655481905,
0.1592490077,
-1.2916778326,
0.1994760484,
-0.2402564734,
-0.4244148433,
0.3070200682,
-0.0578631274,
-0.2536176443,
-0.0350230969,
-0.5229198337,
0.1360428035,
0.5873066783,
-0.6869831085,
0.0587459616,
0.2781003118,
-0.0156243937,
-0.5020353794,
-0.6602141261,
0.0451352634,
-0.2285126746,
-0.0382341854,
0.7682850361,
0.1722201705,
0.0374272615,
-0.017133709,
-0.2231675237,
-0.1439105719,
0.1305404902,
0.1917413771,
0.1574813724,
0.03391001,
0.2953284681,
0.2424316406,
-0.3847898245,
-0.1006522849,
-0.4085759223,
0.164950043,
0.1037986651,
-0.2935495377,
-0.5009149313,
0.4879911542,
0.4788604379,
-0.2305057496,
0.6773675084,
0.5128154159,
-0.2632972896,
-0.1467632949,
-0.32219854,
-0.313826561,
-0.3693182468,
0.2170491815,
-0.2644223571,
-0.9335514307,
0.3249595761,
-0.2959218621,
-0.1372458041,
0.3523263037,
0.0130766658,
-0.3791458607,
0.9888731837,
0.7536213398,
-0.0743624717,
0.4633437097,
-0.205482915,
0.3237572312,
-0.5970080495,
-0.2698085606,
-0.6332817078,
-0.1682726443,
-0.9566509128,
-0.2704764009,
0.142652005,
0.4532935321,
-0.2921884358,
0.5117593408,
-0.6631432772,
0.646964252,
0.3256248236,
0.0560618155,
0.4946675599,
0.3359545767,
-0.3767629862,
-0.2941908836,
-0.3741443157,
-0.432561636,
0.8316230178,
-0.1527374685,
0.5041244626,
0.0693001673,
1.1203023195,
0.6151148081,
-0.1843182147,
-0.5548553467,
0.5166354775,
-0.9815630317,
0.3702116311,
-0.2078671455,
-0.5052384734,
-1.0568640232,
0.6109676957,
-0.38177827,
-0.7529271245,
0.1627565771,
-0.3782528043,
-0.0101515818,
0.1245416924,
-0.6532253623,
1.1021842957,
0.0720613971,
-0.1624560654,
-0.1060045883,
-0.9165333509,
-0.091969721,
0.3932713568,
-0.1012605205,
0.0572806038,
0.1221622378,
0.6623340249,
-0.2677150667,
0.5807492733,
-0.1255667359,
0.301797986,
-0.0271080006,
0.0313645378,
0.3682867587,
0.2232353836,
-0.0051142522,
0.0121623073,
0.0579050034,
-0.6081798673,
-0.781933248,
1.0408370495,
-0.7131099701,
-0.2740392685,
-0.5666529536,
-0.2199360877,
-0.360363394,
0.2149782628,
0.2820844054,
0.3590480387,
-0.4298621118,
0.3060030043,
0.7917502522,
0.2136239409,
0.4213497639,
0.2190876901,
0.0178922657,
-0.3442933559,
0.9318658113,
-0.0267617591,
0.2327776551,
0.9188119769,
-0.0222708695,
-0.5384366512,
-0.6125785112,
-0.1056564748,
0.0126611115,
-0.7181782722,
-0.1523086727,
-0.6178428531,
-0.3688017726,
-0.4578955472,
-0.3379106224,
-0.1861666739,
-0.4186206162,
-0.3265278339,
-0.1583910137,
0.1827889383,
0.7478277087,
0.0964196026,
-0.0684293881,
-0.4850063026,
0.3427288532,
0.5017252564,
0.1514897197,
-0.1746290922,
-0.3683878183,
0.1226490065,
-0.0749144927,
-0.3885392249,
-0.6651005149,
0.1582679451,
0.1746418327,
0.7748989463,
0.1368931979,
0.4920235276,
0.4802308083,
-0.2161710113,
0.8715522289,
0.3484025002,
-0.8900904655,
0.6343900561,
0.0085935928,
0.3050025702,
1.2070403099,
0.4486035407,
-0.485242933,
-0.6717792153,
-0.4738953412,
-0.9832361937,
0.3621822298,
0.4258031249,
0.0521090068,
-0.2644934058,
0.3277257085,
0.279035598,
0.1141566709,
-0.8629626632,
-0.1938878,
-0.399813503,
-0.4242471755,
-0.1637034714,
-0.0923304781,
0.3399140537,
-0.0756462738,
0.6830368042,
-0.1808275431,
-0.0132556912,
0.161620155,
-0.4828909636,
0.4277608991,
0.6075939536,
0.0629177168,
0.315938741,
-0.303663969,
0.5765033364,
0.0520299599,
-0.397892803,
0.1642294377,
0.2390241176,
-0.067845352,
-0.0868479759,
0.1948021948,
0.4825232923,
0.7049639821,
-0.4874639511,
0.8368477821,
-0.0623427592,
-0.0136380224,
0.0386309549,
-0.2116031796,
0.16690588,
0.020564178,
0.4040993154,
0.0588287413,
0.3320637643,
-0.5531053543,
0.4865106642,
0.2994475365,
-0.8648113608,
0.2391917706,
0.5868080258,
0.3847850859,
0.2201817483,
0.6473238468,
-0.4226339161,
-0.4858306348,
0.5230765343,
0.439019382,
0.5638416409,
-0.0223893132,
0.6482985616,
0.3957425058,
-0.2042948604,
-0.1577173173,
-0.2735293806,
-0.2829264104,
-0.3992436528,
-0.2287731767,
-0.5309554338,
-0.2029067129,
-0.1717518121,
-0.970798552,
0.2252867818,
-0.0438345075,
0.3688188791,
-0.0080119492,
0.3062050939,
-0.1844859123,
-0.0178234875,
0.0696340576,
0.4662378132,
-0.9461131096,
0.6963428259,
0.7725746036,
-0.8325014114,
-0.5278701782,
0.2785709202,
-0.3064092696,
-0.4685292542,
0.6872662902,
0.4724508226,
-0.2007238269,
0.196891278,
-0.1944359988,
-0.5557229519,
1.2489336729,
0.5515105128,
-0.4509640634,
0.1312512159,
0.1096295863,
0.5600677133,
-0.6575180888,
0.3498885036,
0.3700389266,
0.0551617518,
0.4168230295,
-0.5589455366,
0.1395267695,
-0.0762571096,
0.3881531358,
0.191975072,
-0.5189728141,
0.5309455395,
-0.1143016294,
-0.2335778475,
0.0876518711,
0.5553454757,
0.1376747787,
0.160875544,
0.2530181706,
0.6779398918,
0.75919801,
-0.1917234361,
0.6016775966,
-0.0208229236,
0.6410844922,
0.9831736684,
-0.4214229882,
1.0860356092,
0.383610189,
-0.0421812013,
0.8661087751,
0.5235310197,
0.0341807827,
0.8759355545,
0.2197506726,
-0.1221620068,
-0.4905964732,
-0.1409710348,
-0.3120465577,
0.5099776387,
-0.1062909141,
-0.3657643795,
-0.6507601142,
0.1784190238,
-0.128263697,
0.9833120108,
-0.2599179745,
0.9901918769,
0.012351349,
-0.6096904278,
0.5916563869,
-0.3305959702,
0.6914591789,
-0.5220496058,
-0.4865595102,
-0.1628861278,
0.1035532132,
-0.2209456265,
-0.7463845611,
0.0587188788,
-0.3409779966,
-0.3984186649,
-0.4694919884,
0.50413239,
-0.7631943226,
-0.3816360831,
0.5217590332,
0.3321207464,
0.2642269433,
-0.0677084103,
-0.5331217051,
-0.2214798182,
-0.0601164103,
0.1544344872,
0.7429088354,
0.4489292204,
-0.1164381653,
0.3510376513,
0.3888834417,
-0.1082113534,
-0.2444175631,
0.426600486,
0.8456636071,
-0.6118908525,
-0.8336941004,
-0.4770863652,
0.4321047068,
-0.5243675113,
-0.0330687761,
0.4781537354,
0.5430159569,
0.8224115372,
0.1404126436,
0.4846051931,
0.1510154456,
0.5231466889,
-0.6831635237,
0.6999377012,
-0.4376552701,
0.3884251416,
-0.1387828588,
-1.1717467308,
-0.3630689681,
0.699326992,
-0.1853247732,
-0.1462871283,
1.1333110332,
0.5096553564,
-0.0428208373,
-0.0921493098,
0.5133160353,
0.1872587055,
0.1405916959,
0.8775476217,
0.4601874948,
-0.6960828304,
0.6356710196,
-0.0923135728,
-0.1968542486,
-0.1658288687,
-0.8567864895,
-0.7992954254,
-0.8609938025,
-0.5175694823,
0.0140038272,
0.4453256428,
0.8104548454,
0.7227497101,
-0.954192996,
0.0027426267,
-0.3835102022,
0.2669365108,
-0.5859389305,
-0.2670407891,
0.6507735848,
-0.6069708467,
-0.5641120672,
0.3184064031,
0.2957472205,
-0.1737470925,
-0.0832962915,
0.1643377542,
-0.4117539823,
-0.1714271754,
0.7051110268,
0.0012523541,
-0.5500800014,
-0.343219012,
-0.3914200664,
-0.3653967083,
0.1224614754,
0.9444307685,
-1.024757266,
0.2276198864,
0.3545986414,
0.7958912849,
0.5640072823,
0.17153956,
0.1201188266,
-0.9235045314,
0.0514155701,
0.1687922627,
0.2827853262,
0.4026390314,
-0.4036909938,
0.2380657792,
0.3446534872,
-0.5281054378,
-0.4814620614,
0.2553489506,
-1.4329353571,
-0.499666065,
0.9130143523,
-0.3796708286,
0.2878798842,
-0.1182769388,
-0.1710128188,
0.1697160304,
-0.5463369489,
0.8022406101,
0.5709537268,
-0.0548198409,
-0.2334170341,
-0.2554559708,
0.3348044753,
0.367418021,
-0.8958642483,
0.0884950757,
0.3620289862,
0.2988504767,
0.1072115675,
0.226153791,
-0.2907691598,
0.063281931,
-0.1363047957,
-0.124865137,
-0.0564184487,
-0.1650209278,
-0.3448195755,
0.580298543,
-0.0558164231,
-0.3914255202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16724v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16724v2 | Code-Switched Text Synthesis in Unseen Language Pairs | 2023-05-26T08:22:35 | 2023-07-07T07:51:38 | I-Hung Hsu, Avik Ray, Shubham Garg, Nanyun Peng, Jing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing efforts on text synthesis for code-switching mostly require training
on code-switched texts in the target language pairs, limiting the deployment of
the models to cases lacking code-switched data. In this work, we study the
problem of synthesizing code-switched texts for language pairs absent from the
training data. We introduce GLOSS, a model built on top of a pre-trained
multilingual machine translation model (PMMTM) with an additional
code-switching module. This module, either an adapter or extra prefixes, learns
code-switching patterns from code-switched data during training, while the
primary component of GLOSS, i.e., the PMMTM, is frozen. The design of only
adjusting the code-switching module prevents our model from overfitting to the
constrained training data for code-switching. Hence, GLOSS exhibits the ability
to generalize and synthesize code-switched texts across a broader spectrum of
language pairs. Additionally, we develop a self-training algorithm on target
language pairs further to enhance the reliability of GLOSS. Automatic
evaluations on four language pairs show that GLOSS achieves at least 55%
relative BLEU and METEOR scores improvements compared to strong baselines.
Human evaluations on two language pairs further validate the success of GLOSS. | [
-0.3230982125,
-0.4745101333,
0.548186481,
0.4339685738,
-0.2069612294,
0.5876428485,
-0.3813855648,
-0.4123052359,
0.3270657361,
0.6315620542,
-0.4236577451,
-0.5580043197,
-0.3926784694,
0.0624073185,
-0.4997834861,
1.2838110924,
-0.2259345502,
-0.115613617,
-0.0362209603,
-0.1288239509,
-0.2211827636,
-0.7370043993,
-0.1278192252,
-0.2060610503,
0.2447153777,
0.5117849708,
0.9137149453,
0.3015118539,
0.2958491445,
0.2469440252,
0.3057139218,
0.2307001501,
-0.3729103506,
0.0349902958,
0.0364166163,
-0.4330407679,
-0.63969028,
0.112379089,
0.6248238087,
0.7246774435,
0.1510940194,
-0.1189808026,
0.0678336844,
0.7510015368,
-0.5323389173,
0.1014447659,
-0.8679756522,
0.0592637509,
-0.3127934337,
-0.2819920778,
-0.5648610592,
-0.0563800856,
-0.2299665064,
-0.5114845037,
0.3779183626,
-0.105424054,
0.8783419132,
-0.0041592061,
-0.4417739511,
-0.2503333688,
-0.8719690442,
0.6476655602,
-0.6462407112,
0.6372350454,
0.4820577502,
-0.0246916842,
0.0219688509,
-0.6924473643,
-0.393732816,
-0.3976474404,
-0.0996069461,
0.59284693,
0.0416636541,
-0.0559113398,
-0.1676634401,
0.2724921107,
-0.4655957818,
-0.1004373655,
-0.367814064,
-0.1904630661,
0.6220389009,
0.1170569509,
0.3876743913,
-0.078033261,
-0.4655927718,
-0.0592336655,
-0.5694741011,
-0.3320688903,
0.3568792045,
0.3532559872,
-0.2755251229,
0.4981422722,
0.0080954358,
0.6355790496,
0.0753734186,
0.1584845334,
0.3840426505,
-0.5291059613,
-0.2865603864,
-0.1734321266,
0.8438509703,
0.3133177459,
0.0916688517,
-0.4870609939,
-0.4504956305,
-0.0141968131,
0.1564887464,
-0.6931638718,
-0.5769463181,
0.0161956884,
-0.3446440697,
-0.191335544,
0.0374782346,
-0.5247865319,
0.0110849421,
-0.3137480319,
0.4482546747,
-0.422434777,
-0.3469671607,
0.0526529029,
-0.1372780651,
-0.1831336021,
0.1279321313,
-0.9276249409,
0.6443362236,
0.2665045857,
0.8831567764,
-0.4632098675,
-0.5967312455,
-0.56628865,
0.2260674387,
-0.5511642694,
0.3760338128,
-0.4789994955,
-0.4857880771,
-0.0509720668,
-0.1320465654,
-0.215230763,
-0.4750216007,
0.0504056364,
-0.5751587152,
0.4319298565,
0.2560999095,
-0.4795305133,
0.1288821399,
-0.0553742088,
-0.610937953,
1.0660011768,
0.165237084,
-0.585300386,
0.1014323905,
-0.5189473033,
-0.517698586,
0.0683040768,
-0.1436969787,
-0.521435678,
0.394902885,
0.0983933359,
0.1762306243,
-0.1165333316,
0.1999837458,
-0.0270299315,
-0.3062629402,
0.5242084265,
-0.3556581736,
0.4097983539,
0.0560429059,
-0.3142250478,
-0.01002221,
-0.7571833134,
0.3524219096,
-0.0222133715,
-0.5144543648,
-0.4604417086,
-0.2305647135,
0.4920603335,
0.2219320536,
0.3542323709,
-0.1835902482,
0.276355803,
-0.3987989128,
0.2560074925,
0.5392910242,
-0.1799018085,
0.49100703,
-0.1951282173,
0.6515843272,
-0.1064146757,
0.1301165521,
0.0045466041,
-0.7278280258,
-1.0544315577,
0.0424782112,
0.605917573,
0.4803363383,
-1.1476390362,
0.1840481013,
-0.072919637,
-0.1728699505,
-0.4434702992,
0.2646017373,
0.827773571,
-0.0973491669,
0.584800601,
-0.5275066495,
-0.4152374268,
-0.8112886548,
-0.39963305,
-0.1552019715,
0.1040200293,
0.125660345,
0.3957081437,
-0.3162354231,
0.8672574759,
-0.6249901652,
-0.149725318,
-0.2626655102,
0.0564886741,
0.1927101165,
0.6041461229,
0.4534161091,
-0.873011291,
-0.7249541283,
0.1397976875,
-0.3599298298,
-0.3509336114,
-0.3979780376,
-0.2098781615,
0.4970304072,
0.8830720186,
-0.2371064872,
0.1926389337,
1.0572148561,
-0.2117811143,
0.7816691995,
-0.4207556546,
0.1861917078,
-0.9048424363,
0.30180493,
-0.4094255865,
-0.273401469,
-0.855668366,
0.1350371242,
0.2435058355,
-0.0390344746,
-0.5011357069,
0.815980494,
-0.9142237306,
-0.1050097868,
-0.3193259835,
0.0638106614,
0.0379183292,
0.6708150506,
0.1400049776,
0.7040359378,
0.4971922636,
-0.5425391793,
-0.2021083087,
0.1989278644,
-0.1333088577,
0.2035101652,
-0.4207498133,
0.5262444019,
0.3919070661,
-0.2234841734,
-0.7650268674,
-0.0914352387,
0.3734256327,
-0.3870325387,
0.4944469929,
-0.5721110106,
-0.4408643246,
-0.1336071938,
0.0640206859,
0.5746563673,
0.5445398688,
-0.3588334918,
0.2309939563,
0.4458575249,
-0.1189767942,
-0.1500006765,
-1.0058552027,
0.4908413291,
0.1351251453,
-0.1651501358,
0.4658065736,
-0.5449883342,
-0.0939621702,
-0.0077441861,
-0.3556984365,
-0.4937860668,
-0.0815585107,
0.3111793697,
0.3279574215,
-0.0769875869,
0.1317987591,
0.1789130569,
-0.3084349632,
-0.1229113266,
-0.499055326,
0.5695194602,
-0.1620357633,
-0.1993588358,
0.1550103128,
0.3056775033,
0.4286331534,
-0.3688788414,
0.6186962128,
0.4168026447,
-0.082755737,
-0.3452119231,
-0.1690249741,
0.0006589342,
-0.548304975,
0.2538136244,
-0.6954136491,
-0.7243221998,
0.4184648991,
0.0467035212,
-0.0675817505,
0.1352918446,
0.5108562708,
0.1659713835,
0.8525183201,
0.8396426439,
0.2151242644,
0.5271760225,
-0.0380249321,
-0.1734962314,
-0.5136788487,
0.0614998154,
-0.1092397347,
-0.0543529578,
-0.5912466049,
-0.6654076576,
0.5546756387,
0.1683745235,
0.1685173959,
0.475137949,
-0.4410689175,
0.7612251043,
0.5743346214,
0.2647388875,
0.3972643316,
0.1029818878,
-0.2818318605,
-0.0871586204,
-0.7152446508,
-0.1697896123,
1.301672101,
-0.0854990482,
0.4713989496,
-0.0207320806,
0.9612720609,
0.1501518041,
0.2511651814,
-0.5430837274,
0.6969712377,
-0.4440632164,
-0.5592185259,
0.0419768095,
-0.7652228475,
-0.9988084435,
0.3145911694,
-0.2167768031,
-0.0984025374,
-0.2078429312,
0.0748478472,
0.1889834404,
0.1786295772,
-0.7826387882,
0.7828894854,
-0.4612608552,
-0.2495636046,
-0.1729130596,
-0.7755753994,
0.4047433436,
-0.4009592235,
0.3166037202,
0.0748551264,
-0.1351576298,
0.6083163023,
-0.2319302112,
0.7690161467,
0.2843005359,
-0.3036993444,
0.024326684,
0.4773572087,
0.05684999,
0.097304225,
0.0016090279,
0.3696996868,
-0.4813160002,
-0.4691193998,
-0.3876496553,
0.7185762525,
-0.5817884803,
-0.6167681813,
-0.3242206573,
-0.5990006328,
-0.3691038787,
0.679025948,
0.2202601731,
0.6301919222,
-0.4037552476,
-0.3473595083,
0.3445510268,
-0.3042473793,
0.5451605916,
0.8816068172,
-0.6532798409,
-0.6759423018,
1.0343028307,
-0.0819638744,
0.8690977097,
0.6563667059,
0.0703102052,
0.1342305839,
-0.6697415113,
-0.6553961635,
0.2208111435,
-0.6141092777,
-0.0024176294,
-0.5244933963,
-0.3234142363,
-0.0463609695,
-0.2877650857,
-0.5993781686,
-0.6686720252,
-0.0728001222,
0.2837924063,
0.1964101195,
0.7716397047,
-0.1262205094,
0.0864217654,
-1.0270330906,
0.5410103202,
0.1920819879,
0.3973633945,
-0.4432536662,
-0.3802598119,
-0.6175996065,
0.1367938221,
-0.0630908087,
-0.9765805006,
0.5475571156,
0.2288408428,
0.2560139298,
-0.05755556,
-0.0095833289,
0.440610528,
-0.7039620876,
0.4819335938,
0.3055452108,
-1.253203392,
0.4887251556,
-0.3431687951,
0.653400898,
0.5525468588,
0.0791814476,
-0.6499943733,
-0.8900439739,
-0.5020407438,
-0.6860115528,
0.8387175798,
0.7847802043,
0.0771924183,
0.0994080752,
0.1517765969,
0.2972876728,
0.354051888,
-0.8757181764,
-0.601043582,
-0.2631153762,
-0.0703777075,
-0.3740244508,
0.1893784553,
-0.0925824195,
-0.1234109402,
0.5202745795,
-0.2250708193,
0.1487902552,
0.0209349357,
-0.3230168819,
-0.1620937586,
0.2641066909,
0.5198082328,
0.516566515,
-0.163774997,
0.3703120649,
-0.1447221339,
-0.5849156976,
0.0697364956,
0.067542918,
-0.3034481406,
0.3889656067,
0.1689976901,
0.7857259512,
0.4832401872,
-0.4160681367,
0.3897476196,
0.0331864469,
-0.0234540217,
0.1139750034,
0.0489954837,
0.2185984403,
-0.1689737886,
0.0540850535,
0.6412912011,
-0.1049680188,
-0.626596272,
0.2940654755,
0.2883748114,
-0.3288033307,
-0.5611025095,
0.7645512223,
0.418094933,
-0.4006121755,
0.4004915655,
-0.3650586307,
-0.6927427053,
0.6057905555,
0.6695777774,
0.9666492343,
-0.3289918303,
0.3930021524,
-0.0304832458,
0.4834403694,
0.1221279576,
0.1364417821,
-0.1189214513,
-0.8146668077,
0.0105046947,
-0.4803955555,
-0.498416245,
-0.052884426,
-0.5340039134,
0.4307383299,
-0.2878928483,
-0.0182051994,
-0.2537867725,
-0.260631144,
-0.5739138126,
0.1941680163,
0.1060067192,
0.4912796021,
-0.8290506005,
1.1285251379,
0.7853834629,
-0.4104293287,
-0.3387830257,
0.3465745151,
-0.2269331217,
-0.8594040275,
0.4367509484,
0.1179163456,
-0.1471998692,
0.1400680393,
-0.3385649621,
-0.724386096,
0.5220239162,
0.3770793676,
-0.4696004093,
0.2223574817,
0.3028308749,
0.6820787191,
-0.1371269226,
0.2579648197,
0.3812071085,
0.3641475439,
-0.240643397,
-1.273537159,
-0.0059919083,
-0.4196337163,
-0.1976618767,
0.520267725,
-0.7998392582,
0.8610154986,
-0.2027932107,
-0.4891653657,
0.1346979588,
0.3871696591,
0.0375949033,
0.3387075067,
0.3248727918,
0.2098148614,
0.3882645667,
0.177917704,
0.8787760139,
-0.3973073959,
0.3418321908,
1.2620164156,
-0.3298188746,
0.7737870216,
0.4094525278,
-0.139191106,
0.4316006601,
0.1709056646,
0.0374316759,
0.5824448466,
-0.1072115377,
-0.2616987824,
-0.4528691471,
0.3667258918,
-0.505539,
0.3375146389,
0.3581189513,
-0.240577668,
-0.0431330204,
0.0367405675,
0.181529209,
0.0990008637,
-0.1647504717,
0.5381473303,
0.2651473582,
-0.751486659,
1.0232031345,
0.2321410775,
0.5971438885,
-0.6750441194,
0.1797932684,
-0.5516309738,
0.1922179908,
-0.1422854215,
-0.7520655394,
0.1487348527,
-0.1246609464,
-0.244741261,
-0.6097573042,
0.5108001232,
-1.0200641155,
-0.5486304164,
0.3924581707,
0.7094115019,
0.2365801781,
0.0029655814,
-0.8376390934,
0.0180673748,
0.1598422378,
-0.0115163149,
0.4985629022,
0.2470007092,
-0.0509274267,
0.4844266474,
0.6964190602,
0.1127962694,
0.2737694383,
0.2087229937,
0.8720024824,
-0.7536067367,
-0.4977033734,
-0.6497381926,
0.2082869411,
0.1873172075,
-0.4449262619,
1.002394557,
0.8099881411,
0.7574067712,
-0.4189014435,
0.8648553491,
-0.0289826617,
-0.0422712378,
-1.0960421562,
0.9149214029,
-0.5855427384,
0.2832202017,
-0.3119878769,
-0.9314848781,
-0.4313720167,
0.1076261625,
0.1522485167,
0.0433694087,
0.9995049238,
0.8309450746,
-0.27411443,
-0.2805506885,
0.4925851822,
0.3394018114,
0.2194517702,
0.8693306446,
0.7279286385,
-0.7697610259,
0.7080314159,
-0.1064982414,
-0.2500988543,
-0.1746007353,
-0.7863267064,
-1.1374801397,
-0.7014547586,
-0.5605313182,
-0.4189434648,
0.3317986429,
0.5185332298,
0.7303206921,
-0.8102987409,
-0.5591211915,
-0.3820725679,
0.262371093,
-0.2445237637,
-0.2226245105,
0.200890407,
-0.4084122777,
-0.8269629478,
0.8458275795,
0.4427783489,
0.292909652,
-0.0324620157,
-0.2785333693,
0.0351164825,
0.1216015816,
0.3317412734,
0.3047623336,
-0.38742733,
-0.002162159,
0.052846089,
-0.3132571578,
0.2177272588,
1.017416954,
-0.7580757141,
0.5787526369,
0.3418584168,
0.3968157768,
0.7285398245,
-0.1902956218,
0.7918642163,
-1.1260962486,
0.2528657019,
-0.0790310502,
0.1780366898,
0.3236881495,
0.0590472557,
0.414611429,
0.3510860503,
-0.457668364,
-0.7936074734,
0.4213647842,
-0.9827200174,
-0.4580404162,
1.3531993628,
0.0694800615,
-0.0068942476,
-0.2681155205,
-0.1887289435,
0.1018239334,
-0.1792572439,
0.7224889398,
0.531742394,
0.0584526397,
0.00243823,
-0.340996176,
0.6781057715,
0.6861790419,
-1.0051168203,
0.009398466,
0.3755613565,
0.2334387898,
0.1292954981,
0.7695513964,
0.0350570865,
0.3390107751,
0.1159006357,
0.2644830644,
-0.0179521646,
-0.478641361,
-0.2774972618,
0.0132378638,
-0.1055293679,
-0.2447740883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16718v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16718v2 | People and Places of Historical Europe: Bootstrapping Annotation Pipeline and a New Corpus of Named Entities in Late Medieval Texts | 2023-05-26T08:05:01 | 2023-06-06T20:42:10 | Vít Novotný, Kristýna Luger, Michal Štefánik, Tereza Vrabcová, Aleš Horák | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7; I.7.0 | Although pre-trained named entity recognition (NER) models are highly
accurate on modern corpora, they underperform on historical texts due to
differences in language OCR errors. In this work, we develop a new NER corpus
of 3.6M sentences from late medieval charters written mainly in Czech, Latin,
and German.
We show that we can start with a list of known historical figures and
locations and an unannotated corpus of historical texts, and use information
retrieval techniques to automatically bootstrap a NER-annotated corpus. Using
our corpus, we train a NER model that achieves entity-level Precision of
72.81-93.98% with 58.14-81.77% Recall on a manually-annotated test dataset.
Furthermore, we show that using a weighted loss function helps to combat class
imbalance in token classification tasks. To make it easy for others to
reproduce and build upon our work, we publicly release our corpus, models, and
experimental code. | [
-0.5604165792,
-0.2852127254,
0.6086621284,
-0.3667848706,
-0.0782782063,
0.105280444,
-0.2485581636,
-0.8819494247,
0.4372991025,
0.4210313559,
-0.1460905969,
-0.5637857318,
-0.4342373013,
0.2070001811,
-0.464957267,
0.7239019871,
-0.4279116094,
0.390440315,
-0.0491840504,
-0.1567642689,
-0.0873601884,
-1.1571041346,
-0.4424353838,
0.0508064702,
0.4223001599,
0.3889863789,
0.3078761101,
0.6420881748,
0.5994347334,
0.3099531233,
-0.1329093575,
0.2094910741,
-0.3870735765,
0.0652772412,
-0.3043494225,
-0.3398083746,
-0.3348810673,
-0.201502353,
0.6875371933,
0.5335335135,
0.1858391613,
0.4589965045,
0.0216790959,
0.3000696003,
-0.6333355904,
0.1370434612,
-0.4934702814,
0.0109145893,
-0.4276097715,
-0.6415919065,
-0.4629347324,
-0.2955189943,
0.2431612909,
-0.7688125968,
0.6924219131,
0.3590689898,
0.953494966,
0.0844927877,
-0.2871543169,
-0.1735836267,
-0.7246559262,
0.9297971725,
-0.3196561038,
0.1966108829,
0.5221324563,
0.3081248403,
-0.1836677343,
-0.8322734833,
-0.2889710069,
0.151615411,
-0.2236391306,
-0.248037383,
-0.2046557069,
-0.3524530232,
0.1505246311,
0.075043872,
-0.2458136827,
0.2054872215,
-0.6903407574,
-0.4721649587,
0.4895429611,
0.1849956959,
0.1017886624,
0.0054027527,
-0.4955593646,
-0.1805074811,
-0.7376170754,
-0.1110835448,
0.6711056828,
0.482634455,
0.1222728342,
0.4311655164,
-0.0268797297,
0.5922646523,
0.1375787705,
-0.1851190031,
0.3672876656,
-0.1189491451,
0.1542895734,
0.3587850034,
0.179440096,
0.5416220427,
0.4858725965,
-0.3827990592,
-0.1077541262,
-0.0836388171,
0.2758716047,
-0.7478731871,
-0.3842994273,
-0.2986957431,
-0.6141500473,
-0.1032193825,
0.3243325949,
-0.6090211272,
-0.3955464959,
-0.3783043325,
0.1102609932,
-0.2964147627,
0.03418855,
-0.0641822591,
-0.2612273693,
0.2394658923,
0.805780828,
-0.9961745143,
0.4719214439,
0.5813453794,
0.7202012539,
-0.3331131339,
-0.4598725438,
-0.6503084898,
0.1203366145,
-0.1275070459,
0.869687736,
-0.3751195669,
-0.1527281404,
0.0979351178,
0.5870108604,
0.3216927946,
-0.3836170137,
0.7761042118,
-0.653300643,
0.2402579188,
-0.2082618922,
-0.605247736,
-0.3488743305,
0.1106445268,
-0.8818904757,
1.028283,
0.1081286222,
-0.9234144688,
0.5101711154,
-0.1915475875,
-0.2702113092,
0.3873849213,
-0.3108433187,
-0.1497150958,
0.091375038,
0.1183158606,
0.5340850353,
-0.147998631,
0.067032516,
-0.1265336424,
-0.5427954197,
0.0141469762,
-0.1199198291,
0.5792309642,
-0.1020868719,
-0.5039146543,
-0.2433080375,
-0.7858096957,
-0.0802909434,
-0.0165154841,
-0.4690138102,
-0.6715422869,
0.2168522328,
0.8213341236,
0.1845513433,
0.3307768703,
-0.6788301468,
0.3853225112,
-0.2495446354,
0.3964317143,
0.4895522594,
0.0408544056,
0.4537505209,
-0.3140521646,
0.5636276603,
-0.0221593939,
-0.312481612,
-0.1541686803,
-0.473128438,
-0.5711671114,
-0.2441122234,
0.7616647482,
0.5252439976,
-0.5232796669,
0.389793843,
-0.4368532002,
-0.4795506001,
-0.5986011624,
-0.367070049,
-0.1192244291,
0.6791445017,
0.5003261566,
-0.0725573823,
-0.9473572373,
-0.9322577715,
0.0824194998,
-0.5464354753,
-0.3099195659,
0.0272140168,
0.7660947442,
0.1318998188,
0.9142916799,
-0.11162588,
-0.2268989086,
0.2080922425,
0.1122791916,
-0.3622698188,
0.5351042747,
0.561557591,
-1.0787725449,
-0.1439664811,
0.0799134299,
-0.1908508837,
0.2823205292,
0.0321861245,
-0.2343748659,
0.5274368525,
0.4948230386,
0.081720598,
0.5851764083,
0.2162519991,
-0.5023770332,
0.2535024881,
-0.1298552752,
0.4174312949,
-1.0868206024,
0.277309984,
-0.3085421026,
-0.6010856032,
-0.1864100695,
-0.4272929132,
0.2439162731,
0.2501520216,
-0.7783824801,
0.8846762776,
-0.4749772251,
0.0918233469,
-0.0614765473,
0.3103284836,
-0.3079259396,
0.1740546525,
0.5022515655,
0.4470856488,
0.1402169317,
-0.3451944292,
0.0066702901,
0.2980592549,
-0.4896186292,
0.756885767,
-0.0680630803,
-0.1386720687,
-0.0516081639,
0.1139149591,
-0.7148174047,
-0.3968524635,
-0.1176099777,
-0.5456190705,
0.2381975204,
-0.4329904616,
-0.7529035807,
-0.1289445758,
-0.0502389073,
0.4202237725,
0.4212593138,
-0.6964070797,
0.5428158641,
0.702878356,
-0.232365042,
-0.5625336766,
-0.8059995174,
0.0768564492,
-0.4711749852,
-0.4685886204,
0.5437994003,
0.0579520576,
-0.3038183451,
0.02490847,
0.0924093127,
-0.4577917457,
0.2443652004,
0.4404447377,
0.5542818904,
-0.1172709092,
0.363551259,
-0.4387233555,
-0.1526331156,
-0.203681156,
-0.4952106774,
0.3874880075,
-0.25869295,
-0.3273322582,
-0.3883553445,
0.2715869844,
0.3536053002,
-0.0651304573,
0.7337468863,
0.4494016469,
-0.7391226888,
0.0502208248,
-0.7072396278,
-0.269559443,
-0.3050256073,
0.2851808369,
-0.1553929299,
-1.1127531528,
0.6726546288,
-0.1704984307,
0.2119415849,
0.869557023,
0.6607492566,
-0.0857158154,
0.3427029848,
0.5835027695,
-0.0232924093,
0.2300626189,
0.0096706292,
0.0536325015,
-0.2921444476,
-0.251069963,
-0.658151269,
-0.7293570042,
-0.9650309086,
-0.2998119593,
-0.0065613766,
0.0844828784,
-0.1067535356,
0.5029895306,
-0.3492986858,
0.5963343382,
0.5976875424,
-0.3628866971,
0.4970593452,
0.2317292988,
0.0845074952,
-0.3216586113,
-0.4692074955,
-1.1998502016,
1.007573843,
0.2593432367,
0.6114966273,
-0.0901613832,
0.9992183447,
0.3134543896,
0.197557956,
-0.5544139147,
0.1162246391,
0.0048998431,
-0.8316055536,
-0.2114171088,
-0.0824078918,
-0.9415493011,
-0.1882209182,
-0.1494196653,
-0.793479383,
0.687759161,
0.1205400005,
-0.6227818727,
0.6377090216,
-0.48608917,
0.7832765579,
-0.0553155132,
-0.0491169989,
0.3363645375,
-0.9505464435,
-0.258464843,
-0.1865619123,
0.1297959387,
0.0970161632,
-0.31880638,
0.8896309137,
-0.1615552008,
0.6291335225,
-0.0450045466,
0.1637153327,
0.2218825817,
0.065412432,
0.5597392917,
-0.3404616714,
-0.1084788218,
0.41862306,
0.3584106565,
-0.5695474148,
-0.2319859862,
0.6470279694,
-0.6284253001,
0.0329129249,
-0.4260127544,
-0.1640926003,
0.3272827566,
0.0522072688,
0.4182319343,
0.4250093102,
-0.3611985743,
0.4618997872,
0.2725802064,
0.2955023646,
0.6913320422,
0.6478016376,
0.0823956728,
-0.5277408361,
0.6503525376,
0.5974763632,
-0.0419157371,
0.5610893965,
-0.545924902,
0.0051049599,
-0.5435019732,
-0.5071070194,
-0.0733171478,
-0.6771789789,
-0.2166753262,
-0.3835109174,
0.0965386629,
-0.1398088634,
-0.652489543,
-0.3079623282,
-0.8344800472,
-0.6270580888,
-0.2498968989,
0.2450172752,
0.6522294879,
0.0534616709,
0.3320832849,
-0.3533475101,
-0.2631531358,
-0.2745552063,
-0.0564144216,
-0.1313760728,
-0.282592237,
-0.4078989923,
-0.5112099051,
-0.1221458763,
-0.7955613136,
0.5710797906,
-0.2280569971,
0.321782589,
0.2368307859,
0.1998045146,
0.7147022486,
-0.9784514308,
0.6236692071,
0.0321168117,
-0.5853808522,
0.1282986999,
0.0362771899,
-0.0454200767,
0.8937903643,
0.4282621145,
-0.4635709822,
-0.2028967738,
-0.8352172971,
-1.1499350071,
0.5592643619,
0.0479593128,
-0.2867454588,
-0.2493993342,
0.42723611,
0.2403455079,
0.0210548099,
-0.6158140302,
-0.3211672306,
0.2856588066,
-0.21370323,
-0.0490597673,
-0.2707283497,
0.0964692608,
-0.0172147229,
0.8292801976,
0.045443736,
-0.0957779214,
0.4478316605,
-0.3613225222,
-0.2293678671,
0.4197585285,
0.3712639213,
1.0035446882,
-0.1845319271,
0.4531801343,
0.6169321537,
-0.6148590446,
0.2278286517,
0.4061022997,
-0.3863201737,
0.342106998,
0.5570671558,
0.6112254262,
0.4821377099,
-0.593509376,
0.4995719492,
-0.1652132571,
0.0264970995,
-0.9947139025,
-0.3220431209,
0.0312021393,
0.6059772372,
0.7977643013,
0.1543360949,
-0.0087165711,
-0.2302471548,
0.1657881141,
0.0775175467,
-0.4175855815,
-0.2229478657,
0.5305603147,
0.079968676,
-0.4703010619,
0.451097101,
-0.3885406852,
-0.4063010216,
0.3131021857,
0.2728015482,
0.6672779322,
-0.1496729255,
0.0069332724,
0.5818267465,
0.499270767,
-0.2159072459,
0.2201509774,
0.0816070512,
-0.2644993365,
-0.3271303773,
-0.9539033175,
-0.3104562461,
-0.0687013268,
-0.6664481759,
0.810602963,
-0.1649233103,
-0.3676387072,
0.0858363509,
0.1779782176,
-0.9272703528,
-0.0487133749,
0.3001405001,
0.8690955043,
-0.711643815,
0.6344743371,
0.7824971676,
-0.2038529515,
-0.3836787939,
-0.1078477055,
-0.0470120087,
-0.3496178091,
1.032042861,
0.0658422485,
-0.1489384472,
0.1346344203,
-0.4501016736,
-0.9026752114,
1.2561947107,
0.424616158,
-1.063482523,
-0.4064873457,
-0.3850772977,
0.5123420358,
-0.6208156943,
0.0836986005,
0.134979561,
0.4552664459,
-0.0987520441,
-0.8603844047,
-0.2092324942,
-0.120550178,
-0.168895945,
0.5455695391,
-0.1085620597,
0.8620510697,
-0.024484897,
-0.4477909803,
0.5057500005,
0.7292087078,
0.1119487733,
0.2014079988,
0.3851587772,
0.5060361028,
1.0471715927,
-0.2845932543,
1.0759629011,
-0.311507076,
0.321701169,
1.4458850622,
-0.1304548532,
1.191417098,
0.5821664333,
-0.0633120686,
0.5968422294,
0.937146306,
-0.2609333098,
0.2700093389,
0.270781368,
-0.325009346,
-0.2067456692,
-0.129101634,
-0.3428927362,
0.2721080184,
-0.1267860085,
-0.6510752439,
-0.2568698525,
0.0344810486,
0.3687459528,
-0.1438399702,
-0.4215522707,
0.6336169243,
-0.3071088791,
-0.3966061473,
0.2747842968,
0.0305155795,
0.3841147423,
-0.3071513474,
-0.1012740508,
0.3317531943,
0.2479843348,
-0.1895762384,
-0.3035386503,
-0.0145542454,
0.180367142,
-0.4420123994,
-0.1398559213,
0.510743022,
-0.5724989176,
-0.7623838782,
0.3039536476,
0.4153509438,
0.5950955153,
0.0881778523,
0.1320816875,
-0.2254169136,
-0.2233111709,
-0.0272410531,
0.18273592,
0.6655778289,
-0.3949316442,
-0.1895232201,
0.3381219208,
0.1937668324,
0.0035656155,
-0.1244442314,
0.5483765602,
-0.9117839932,
-0.5375585556,
-0.9912552238,
0.4515519738,
-0.0284950994,
-0.3515168428,
0.7422347665,
0.9442698956,
1.279178977,
-0.0886474103,
0.571203649,
0.1469431818,
0.8422396779,
-0.2615061402,
0.7253242135,
-0.3742542863,
-0.2727064192,
-0.2158731967,
-0.8349280357,
-0.3591471016,
0.5934408903,
-0.4054770172,
-0.3407744169,
0.7522990108,
0.3772449791,
0.023437487,
-0.0497134961,
0.2163523436,
0.1172295734,
-0.0690855384,
0.3095588982,
1.0156041384,
-0.2765361667,
0.3554465175,
-0.140320763,
-0.0131947706,
-0.3563979566,
-0.9505426884,
-0.7142270207,
-1.0628193617,
-0.2749491632,
-0.2824682295,
0.0746460259,
1.0622515678,
0.7741081119,
-1.1247284412,
-0.1719102263,
0.3073351383,
-0.1869966239,
0.2707701921,
-0.1525370926,
0.5947104096,
-0.1294603944,
-0.8323447704,
0.2435814887,
0.2632185221,
0.3887552619,
-0.4100483954,
-0.1461941004,
-0.2709566951,
-0.4186006486,
0.2862834334,
0.228057012,
-0.8650677204,
-0.3047606349,
-0.0601833947,
-0.0040602214,
0.1949086636,
0.8103311658,
-0.9347297549,
0.4093641639,
0.3429530859,
0.6515133977,
0.6414399743,
0.2330430001,
0.1444826871,
-0.5706810355,
0.1557939351,
0.5654799342,
0.718341291,
0.7084990144,
-0.3168836534,
0.5828829408,
0.3435517251,
-0.6087819934,
-0.7543732524,
-0.3419299722,
-0.7859457731,
-0.2335765511,
0.6501162052,
-0.2303218693,
-0.4812375605,
-0.2997255921,
-0.3130237758,
0.2257866114,
-0.3477586508,
0.7640733123,
1.156283617,
0.1294243336,
0.4530860186,
-0.9236341715,
0.3696116507,
-0.046753265,
-0.6953505874,
-0.1229181662,
0.8169826269,
0.2078689635,
0.5367543697,
0.4020517468,
-0.2189871371,
0.1655782759,
-0.3007998765,
0.504362464,
0.0880742818,
-0.5487444997,
-0.2599490583,
0.5727881789,
-0.0942816362,
-0.0869591311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16701v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16701v1 | PIP: Parse-Instructed Prefix for Syntactically Controlled Paraphrase Generation | 2023-05-26T07:42:38 | 2023-05-26T07:42:38 | Yixin Wan, Kuan-Hao Huang, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Syntactically controlled paraphrase generation requires language models to
generate paraphrases for sentences according to specific syntactic structures.
Existing fine-tuning methods for this task are costly as all the parameters of
the model need to be updated during the training process. Inspired by recent
studies on parameter-efficient learning, we propose Parse-Instructed Prefix
(PIP), a novel adaptation of prefix-tuning to tune large pre-trained language
models on syntactically controlled paraphrase generation task in a low-data
setting with significantly less training cost. We introduce two methods to
instruct a model's encoder prefix to capture syntax-related knowledge: direct
initiation (PIP-Direct) and indirect optimization (PIP-Indirect). In contrast
to traditional fine-tuning methods for this task, PIP is a compute-efficient
alternative with 10 times less learnable parameters. Compared to existing
prefix-tuning methods, PIP excels at capturing syntax control information,
achieving significantly higher performance at the same level of learnable
parameter count. | [
-0.0057146563,
-0.7842264175,
0.3434608877,
0.4340647459,
-0.6332061887,
-0.3734103739,
-0.063206315,
0.2634007931,
0.1169013828,
0.6374084353,
-0.5792030692,
-0.3342475593,
-0.5898330808,
0.2304068804,
-0.2661859989,
0.8443388939,
0.1758489758,
0.0783783346,
0.0078672031,
0.151476115,
-0.3160630167,
-0.3411611915,
-0.7650490403,
-0.0204155855,
0.6970672011,
0.4080503285,
0.6627725363,
1.0928465128,
0.430745542,
0.1700853854,
-0.0645313188,
0.3348560631,
-0.1759337485,
0.2620961964,
-0.3261544108,
-0.4943331182,
-0.3972251117,
-0.2878973782,
0.7024961114,
0.8968473077,
-0.0370451584,
0.1295353919,
0.1459848732,
0.6353892088,
-1.0340490341,
0.3559245169,
-0.9285488725,
-0.1297207326,
-0.264462173,
-0.6376614571,
-0.5657850504,
-0.3698768318,
-0.3397628665,
-0.7086278796,
0.040794149,
0.1321183145,
0.6487087011,
0.592527926,
-0.3848884404,
-0.2165573686,
-0.2587800324,
0.5930883288,
-0.6698105335,
0.3338261247,
0.4644624889,
0.197611019,
-0.1394709349,
-1.060608387,
-0.3422523439,
-0.1613709927,
-0.1258264929,
-0.0812499672,
-0.0733852237,
0.3851309717,
0.4309014678,
-0.1383027583,
-0.3116795421,
0.0784744918,
-0.239331007,
-0.0638313219,
0.1860449016,
0.1725623906,
0.1949861199,
-0.3161831796,
-0.190217495,
-0.0545547158,
-0.9088626504,
0.1734678447,
0.2845354676,
0.4617420137,
0.1817741543,
0.4767902195,
-0.5931167006,
0.7596732974,
0.3691065907,
-0.0585433543,
-0.1904370785,
-0.262301296,
-0.3952318132,
0.2258381695,
0.6073020101,
0.1688222885,
0.1943732798,
-0.2078384459,
-0.1741959304,
-0.1090441793,
0.2101185024,
-0.9261546731,
-0.4900640845,
-0.1555434167,
-0.0230128188,
-0.2699823081,
-0.1117049828,
-0.6997311711,
-0.0876332819,
-0.4667166471,
0.3690646589,
-0.6839597225,
0.2169644386,
0.1555777937,
-0.3997859061,
0.4897602797,
0.3084612191,
-1.025808692,
0.3492070436,
0.8019241095,
0.586687088,
0.1926634163,
-0.713421464,
-1.2528011799,
0.5149491429,
-0.4971090555,
0.5111212134,
-0.8316913843,
-0.0348125845,
-0.1165733859,
0.0042031184,
-0.2555489242,
-0.2909161747,
0.46223557,
-0.4984984398,
0.0118336789,
-0.2524425089,
-0.5600529313,
0.1397971213,
-0.1016566679,
-0.1978343576,
0.7603843212,
0.1208897308,
-0.8647663593,
0.5459775329,
-0.4887799621,
-0.4550540149,
0.2727879286,
0.0886392519,
-0.177469939,
0.1052772552,
0.5836210847,
0.4685259163,
-0.2520704269,
0.4977705181,
0.0422459505,
-0.2195074409,
-0.2215465903,
-0.3212543428,
0.6706423759,
0.1336684674,
-0.303668946,
0.248351112,
-0.4982534945,
0.0845283642,
-0.0617431104,
-0.1121247485,
-0.5555369258,
-0.115454942,
-0.5359031558,
-0.0802477524,
0.1991915256,
-0.1599547565,
0.1371511072,
-0.553919673,
0.4844133258,
0.4962938726,
0.4347378314,
0.6041215062,
-0.1293535531,
0.5689101815,
-0.167128101,
0.2738807797,
-0.3513248265,
-0.259784013,
-1.0148534775,
-0.2519780695,
0.4746773839,
0.2822516561,
-0.9917493463,
0.5021013618,
-0.3835258782,
-0.4244041145,
-0.5554289222,
0.2541223466,
0.6623197198,
0.6187344193,
0.5665556192,
-0.002839305,
-0.1989804804,
-0.759431839,
-0.6173246503,
-0.0002220817,
0.0210050829,
0.2104631811,
0.3282493055,
0.3289864659,
0.7128576636,
-0.3729126751,
-0.0465645343,
-0.518016696,
0.2271080613,
-0.0212825555,
0.6811510921,
0.3817176223,
-0.6779919863,
-0.7742571235,
-0.2207434773,
-0.2752562463,
-0.48285079,
-0.2495220006,
-0.3367835283,
-0.163250193,
0.659152627,
-0.6963807344,
0.0518988967,
0.1124485135,
-0.28633973,
0.4344351888,
-0.4445367455,
-0.0716023371,
-1.0521684885,
0.1070872545,
-0.3479210436,
-0.168159321,
-0.4811991155,
0.4458321929,
0.645404458,
-0.4053183496,
-0.6426187754,
0.464910388,
-0.6650422215,
0.383113265,
-0.118271172,
-0.2378772199,
0.0682513639,
0.724399507,
0.1259149909,
0.9328256249,
0.7414879799,
-0.8741495609,
0.2404762506,
0.3589860201,
-0.1533775628,
0.2157790363,
-0.6262620091,
0.1844534427,
-0.102123484,
-0.0490050949,
-0.4106535316,
-0.5267950892,
0.2673411667,
-0.2039989978,
0.2881868184,
-0.4748576581,
-0.5445039272,
0.1388800889,
-0.2901105583,
0.2440236658,
0.7956939936,
-0.5934500098,
0.1774945259,
0.0197648089,
-0.4161362946,
-0.3425533175,
-0.3926230371,
0.1424469203,
-0.4177107513,
-0.0944381356,
0.302803874,
0.3081150353,
0.1156521738,
-0.3074287176,
-0.0539477244,
-0.1688734144,
0.0031700956,
-0.0898968726,
-0.3072995543,
-0.0323942304,
0.130292654,
0.8141074181,
-0.0625365004,
0.1203444526,
-0.3096897304,
0.6289767623,
0.4239805341,
-0.2949447334,
-0.6261606812,
0.4150111377,
0.5620556474,
-0.618927598,
0.5783022642,
0.1506224573,
-0.0460732691,
-0.607363224,
-0.2702117562,
-0.3232877254,
-0.5070504546,
0.1762363762,
-0.6076906323,
-0.2380976826,
0.0244713854,
-0.3672739863,
-0.1561114937,
0.1615255922,
0.1975235194,
0.1791023165,
0.7503972054,
0.4820598066,
0.1160762161,
0.4547377527,
0.0965155587,
0.0584456921,
-0.5664148927,
-0.1883322001,
-0.494163543,
-0.2395460606,
-0.209504962,
-0.3263664544,
0.3973257542,
0.5066183805,
-0.4800263345,
0.6083552837,
-0.4063511789,
0.6378873587,
1.0055756569,
0.2693581283,
0.0363988988,
-0.1383274049,
0.0210136287,
-0.0996159017,
-0.8539225459,
-0.2073164135,
0.9488077164,
-0.0073728501,
0.7271558046,
-0.0602813438,
0.7604304552,
0.0218010731,
-0.4432758987,
-0.6130450368,
0.6682626009,
-0.1881883591,
0.0598656647,
-0.2549164891,
-0.2588670552,
-0.8497846127,
-0.0946256369,
0.0544947311,
-0.3376552761,
0.0998284817,
0.3313873112,
-0.3910962939,
0.0241301674,
-0.7061766386,
0.9712087512,
-0.141097486,
-0.4798313379,
-0.151792556,
-0.8015039563,
0.1142996103,
-0.2370002121,
-0.3622959554,
0.0280315559,
-0.4318530262,
0.6430397034,
-0.601108551,
0.8540179729,
-0.5708562136,
0.2638304234,
0.1157708466,
0.3842455745,
0.8889034986,
-0.0158765744,
-0.2447900176,
-0.4630896747,
-0.0621268302,
-0.4341359437,
-0.7940073013,
0.4678799808,
-0.2593040168,
-0.7155485749,
-0.0615944937,
-0.4649745524,
-0.1944804937,
0.2180562317,
0.3135298789,
0.5751584768,
0.20491907,
0.2967438102,
0.4486844242,
-0.2553143799,
0.4428380132,
0.3399121165,
0.2586932778,
-0.5690888762,
0.6322852373,
-0.1283935457,
0.3676377237,
0.7961477637,
0.3272410035,
-0.2758104801,
-0.6206448674,
-0.3871346116,
0.2376152277,
-0.658483088,
-0.4979305267,
-0.6929553151,
-0.1358818114,
-0.482952863,
-0.3446420729,
-0.1809974164,
-0.461777389,
-0.2361945212,
0.147604987,
0.4757752419,
0.0934231356,
0.2433752865,
0.8053401709,
-0.6796908975,
0.3549905419,
0.3041191399,
0.0430777892,
-0.5046334267,
-0.6564900279,
0.0045514191,
-0.0087894313,
-0.2356626391,
-0.8966403008,
0.7284173965,
0.7709122896,
0.1857842207,
0.2718059123,
0.6476367712,
0.9804391861,
-0.7760672569,
0.7960101366,
0.1025969312,
-1.1417617798,
1.0019351244,
-0.3021674156,
0.4324526191,
0.6819224954,
0.4858736992,
-0.135175094,
-0.5960698128,
-0.5400884151,
-0.7463293672,
0.7747377157,
0.1486162096,
0.4329883158,
-0.218308568,
0.5441458821,
0.4864539206,
0.2412932962,
-0.5960077047,
0.0982198417,
-0.0297131781,
-0.0830674469,
0.058810126,
-0.314782083,
0.0061517823,
-0.5397134423,
0.6318246722,
-0.2983416319,
0.052681718,
0.0607107766,
-0.2632414699,
0.1711340547,
0.3256940544,
0.3437487483,
0.5564933419,
-0.1177006438,
0.304875344,
0.2228424698,
-0.1231628507,
-0.014571473,
-0.0355098546,
-0.3559896946,
0.1928768605,
0.3043146729,
1.1533010006,
0.4088190496,
-0.475974679,
0.6002525687,
0.2672668397,
-0.3098037243,
-0.021497177,
0.3752917051,
-0.0484812446,
0.0228717662,
-0.1298653036,
-0.0382243022,
0.1053568423,
-0.1278571934,
0.181912899,
0.2271262109,
-0.0079216762,
-0.2746842802,
0.8247533441,
0.3699264228,
-0.3506099582,
0.6604626179,
-0.3466166556,
-0.3614896834,
0.4633781314,
0.7571858168,
1.0448268652,
-0.1157850623,
0.0991452783,
0.3403938115,
0.1209044233,
-0.001386473,
0.2062301636,
-0.5610963702,
-0.2427274287,
-0.4675415456,
-0.8165453672,
-0.6050118804,
-0.0352945998,
-0.7329943776,
0.666574955,
-0.5019398928,
0.2173772305,
0.0562243834,
-0.4277797639,
-0.3937825561,
-0.0041711596,
-0.214002952,
1.1598238945,
-0.6928620338,
1.2500181198,
0.5905287266,
-0.4074480534,
-0.9425078034,
0.1992178112,
-0.5213174224,
-0.781083703,
0.9569035172,
0.0643443838,
-0.0089880591,
0.5293068886,
-0.3898136914,
-0.4600443542,
0.8778114915,
0.8803389668,
-0.3862572014,
-0.5003066659,
0.2291316092,
0.2752447426,
-0.0721239373,
0.2236496061,
0.5873618722,
0.2992711067,
-0.0785600096,
-0.9980688095,
0.0999874845,
-0.2282294631,
0.04396284,
0.530757308,
-0.4362278879,
0.702701211,
0.0702132061,
-0.1719900668,
0.0265630074,
0.4561634362,
-0.1807792634,
0.0038519644,
0.3180410862,
0.4258691072,
0.5729355216,
0.0963262171,
1.049272418,
-0.7620395422,
-0.0142209502,
1.134034276,
-0.0610958077,
0.9141944051,
0.7523576617,
0.0244523212,
0.0776371434,
0.4991709292,
0.2135954946,
0.9975284934,
0.103935577,
-0.3893243968,
-0.3848117888,
-0.1775866151,
-0.1912040859,
0.4642048776,
0.3110361993,
-0.5372551084,
-0.4419722259,
0.0490163155,
-0.1172006205,
0.1063539907,
-0.4373700619,
1.185639739,
-0.0007855265,
-0.979191184,
0.9838550687,
0.0261896383,
0.3925173581,
-1.0268855095,
-0.0175427925,
-0.4834263325,
0.0088575585,
0.1193761081,
-0.3112755716,
0.3665160835,
0.229206115,
0.1654779017,
-0.5698307753,
0.4952152967,
-0.527079165,
-0.351893574,
0.0750801861,
0.5005975366,
0.2482924014,
-0.3418548107,
-0.581935823,
-0.3896572292,
0.0617467985,
-0.0870311186,
0.3407043517,
0.55772686,
0.0984705761,
0.6305137277,
0.4164248705,
0.4244709313,
0.4114583135,
0.0270232484,
0.9155358672,
-0.6227921247,
-0.6553199291,
-0.8941599727,
0.3408302367,
0.0275920797,
-0.3959570527,
0.6113743782,
0.5025107265,
0.6576296687,
-0.4354249835,
0.6176403165,
-0.07920596,
0.2549313307,
-0.8287371993,
0.5805045962,
-0.4693025947,
0.1101826653,
-0.0328833647,
-1.0350168943,
-0.3850897849,
0.173090905,
-0.2762661576,
-0.48524189,
0.8629052043,
1.0089639425,
-0.3825444281,
-0.1946035475,
0.3653060496,
-0.3295014799,
0.0392319299,
0.5661514997,
0.5631250143,
-0.1565617025,
0.3846447468,
-0.6285113096,
-0.2023314387,
0.1309672594,
-0.908985436,
-0.8491288424,
-0.4090349078,
-0.4512710571,
0.0540862754,
0.5128229856,
1.0300337076,
0.5417640805,
-0.72209692,
-0.0076232045,
-0.8086664081,
-0.2207409739,
-0.3445701897,
-0.1513820142,
0.5873275399,
-1.169746995,
-1.1122852564,
0.660104692,
0.1089479849,
-0.2789280415,
0.348715961,
-0.0586001053,
0.0081674308,
0.0340783112,
0.2315402031,
0.1445581019,
-0.717043519,
-0.0807978511,
-0.2133610547,
-0.1377604008,
0.0075374222,
0.9170154929,
-0.6119478345,
0.4363775849,
0.5615512133,
0.9252766967,
0.2752406597,
0.2714441419,
0.8120545149,
-1.0829753876,
0.3114146292,
0.3237199485,
0.2730764747,
0.0294017438,
-0.2362818271,
0.2472253293,
0.226649642,
-0.3439136744,
-0.7542387247,
0.1535602212,
-0.9132748246,
-0.2659654617,
1.2992540598,
-0.283002764,
-0.1622022539,
0.1381856948,
-0.3642867208,
0.413292706,
-0.3882802725,
0.3169879019,
0.0756458566,
-0.0362489857,
-0.3270916641,
-0.2075533122,
0.8295314908,
0.8224335313,
-0.7310389876,
0.349386096,
0.2307398766,
0.1467889845,
-0.4174714684,
0.2644347847,
0.1247240752,
0.3165415227,
0.3355074525,
-0.0720796883,
-0.4591030478,
-0.3780127168,
-0.360901922,
0.3332998157,
0.3789794445,
-0.4863314331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16697v1 | DKAF: KB Arbitration for Learning Task-Oriented Dialog Systems with Dialog-KB Inconsistencies | 2023-05-26T07:36:23 | 2023-05-26T07:36:23 | Vishal Vivek Saley, Rocktim Jyoti Das, Dinesh Raghu, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Task-oriented dialog (TOD) agents often ground their responses on external
knowledge bases (KBs). These KBs can be dynamic and may be updated frequently.
Existing approaches for learning TOD agents assume the KB snapshot contemporary
to each individual dialog is available during training. However, in real-world
scenarios, only the latest KB snapshot is available during training and as a
result, the train dialogs may contain facts conflicting with the latest KB.
These dialog-KB inconsistencies in the training data may potentially confuse
the TOD agent learning algorithm.
In this work, we define the novel problem of learning a TOD agent with
dialog-KB inconsistencies in the training data. We propose a Dialog-KB
Arbitration Framework (DKAF) which reduces the dialog-KB inconsistencies by
predicting the contemporary KB snapshot for each train dialog. These predicted
KB snapshots are then used for training downstream TOD agents. As there are no
existing datasets with dialog-KB inconsistencies, we systematically introduce
inconsistencies in two publicly available dialog datasets. We show that TOD
agents trained with DKAF perform better than existing baselines on both these
datasets | [
-0.2043425143,
-0.7202258706,
0.6612492204,
-0.0521385372,
-0.0755920932,
0.3996288478,
0.1342445016,
-0.4885771275,
0.0141880373,
0.3819206953,
-0.6968598366,
-0.2120390534,
-0.8045020103,
0.0661242679,
0.2601650059,
0.7520754337,
-0.1521163136,
0.3121563196,
-0.462323308,
-0.1511742175,
-0.7903024554,
-0.5084884763,
-0.8521981239,
-0.4624752998,
0.1969888061,
0.4103803635,
0.5308475494,
0.2956919372,
0.2852880955,
0.3576949239,
0.170654878,
0.4340164661,
-0.088314712,
0.4092206955,
0.0882369578,
-0.5022001863,
-0.5351364613,
-0.2811987102,
0.3738309145,
0.5390267372,
-0.0311262272,
-0.2415336072,
-0.2531353831,
0.9482179284,
-0.3492586315,
0.6835356951,
-0.6680753827,
0.4071796238,
0.104081355,
-0.456518352,
-0.6483747363,
-0.0932591036,
0.4575562477,
-0.6058061123,
0.0586283207,
-0.1428998709,
0.9043233395,
0.467746973,
-0.6961633563,
-0.4836479425,
-0.7469252348,
0.5081302524,
-0.5875006318,
0.4417935312,
0.554869175,
0.6622944474,
-0.6066024899,
-0.4329451919,
-0.4365823865,
-0.4445043206,
-0.1322352886,
0.1357406825,
-0.1135160252,
0.2844800055,
0.2460795343,
-0.1377336532,
-0.3636101484,
-0.1572378576,
-0.048225712,
-0.363191992,
0.3796772957,
0.4037070274,
-0.1419937313,
-0.1293875575,
-0.4203042984,
-0.071377255,
-0.6943197846,
0.3377870917,
0.3590970635,
0.3843175471,
-0.0173269939,
0.0080510341,
-0.4982149005,
0.6498193741,
0.8016552925,
-0.4017567337,
0.346345365,
0.2000304759,
-0.3150283694,
0.2021066993,
0.42160815,
0.2344421893,
-0.2446669936,
-0.6073901653,
-0.2681882083,
-0.4207610488,
0.3869762421,
-0.4666843116,
-0.1125996336,
0.6092146039,
-0.2077388614,
-0.297911793,
-0.2785382271,
-0.8991799355,
-0.6413681507,
-0.5979132056,
0.6732680798,
-0.2128126472,
-0.3576672673,
-0.5006173253,
-0.0073591047,
0.0192008428,
0.7337099314,
-0.4006816447,
0.0553193241,
0.3644402027,
0.4204630852,
0.2365952432,
-0.2150708288,
-0.7103838921,
0.046849452,
-0.3257102966,
0.8662142158,
-0.5233040452,
-0.2749174237,
0.1441105455,
-0.0756167024,
-0.2352940887,
-0.8125253916,
0.0361280106,
-0.9149225354,
0.0849692449,
-0.5050309896,
-0.5291293859,
-0.3605510294,
0.5965521932,
-0.546623826,
0.9209455848,
0.3269661963,
-0.6521230936,
0.7177692652,
-0.6877839565,
-0.194386825,
-0.0887167975,
-0.3245735168,
-0.3668676615,
-0.0643214062,
0.0876253992,
0.5278938413,
-0.1476917863,
0.5811396837,
-0.3088369071,
-0.1077182442,
0.1572440118,
-0.3314400315,
0.7901327014,
0.2194104493,
-0.3890299201,
0.0582882203,
-0.7206990123,
-0.1612617373,
-0.0283093732,
-0.3304952085,
-0.0789785087,
-0.0478135236,
-0.4247762561,
0.3926261365,
0.1999505609,
-0.6449390054,
0.3225649893,
-0.0620009378,
0.0449909754,
1.0076584816,
0.1476166695,
0.3068443537,
-0.7451366782,
0.5037776232,
0.7091452479,
0.1658599973,
0.0703924894,
-0.2184976786,
-0.8633036613,
-0.3826240897,
0.178571865,
0.3749658167,
-1.336823225,
0.2750027776,
-0.4220007658,
-0.3915786147,
-0.2614940703,
-0.0277196895,
0.2132487893,
0.7588367462,
0.0115139885,
0.0124117285,
-0.6345100999,
-0.7053101063,
-0.0221278295,
-0.4626443386,
0.5600708723,
0.5192168355,
0.3184811473,
0.002514194,
1.2448487282,
0.0153523004,
-0.4109663069,
-0.2507815361,
0.3670251667,
-0.1532989591,
0.5445929766,
0.6045392752,
-0.7725851536,
-0.8612830639,
0.0475958772,
-0.7847918868,
0.3100837767,
-0.2761827111,
-0.1789039373,
0.5656929612,
0.4946449399,
-0.8072338104,
0.4240796566,
0.2038348913,
-0.3437000811,
0.5874066353,
-0.0057223346,
0.3077634871,
-0.9145894051,
-0.2056281269,
-0.3243381381,
-0.6088857055,
-0.6844553351,
-0.3916425705,
-0.2088620514,
0.1136242822,
-0.4562909901,
0.6343053579,
-0.2733871341,
0.0610273778,
-0.2460585833,
-0.0508570597,
-0.1830832362,
1.2127562761,
0.1365925819,
0.7803100944,
0.6550371647,
-0.7960547209,
0.3533861041,
0.4648439586,
-0.195362106,
0.6559779048,
-0.0207125302,
0.4385105371,
-0.3698213398,
0.4813989997,
-0.8553391099,
-0.2795970142,
0.5834764242,
-0.456148535,
0.5621415973,
-0.5291671753,
-0.4920634627,
0.0969800875,
0.0200826917,
0.1625567526,
0.3917885423,
-0.7131658792,
1.1690382957,
0.4759868085,
0.0684142411,
-0.8865792751,
-0.1002847552,
-0.2418249547,
-0.1774693429,
-0.3530184627,
-0.2676959932,
0.0249263402,
-0.0867565274,
0.1379092485,
-0.5958440304,
-0.408870399,
0.0917315632,
0.4809361398,
0.0562678538,
0.0940069333,
0.362533927,
0.0181381498,
0.0104919514,
0.1199572161,
-0.1823072582,
0.4445364177,
-0.0051027234,
-0.3659839034,
-0.3530450165,
0.2359913886,
0.8794915676,
0.3402041793,
0.5969792008,
0.5270329714,
-0.2703798413,
-0.0250092987,
-0.7516376376,
0.0406824388,
-0.4691853821,
0.4010068178,
-0.690072298,
-0.6365000606,
0.6188465953,
-0.2859225571,
0.1400019079,
0.2449703962,
0.4992275536,
-0.3409202695,
1.090262413,
0.6295180321,
0.0080416631,
0.7299920917,
-0.3061326444,
0.0928774923,
-0.8133020997,
-0.3857309222,
-0.3056648076,
-0.1812519878,
-0.2788853943,
-0.1957116276,
0.4552392066,
-0.1099535748,
-0.3188266456,
0.1794244349,
0.041227743,
0.1349099576,
0.4266198277,
0.2694779336,
0.3196023405,
0.1393985748,
-0.3415323794,
0.1256954819,
-0.8736518025,
-0.4075838625,
1.0897796154,
0.3557905257,
0.3890770376,
0.2523743212,
0.5598623753,
0.6830761433,
0.4062124193,
-0.8224785924,
0.5544207096,
0.3561691642,
-0.7557338476,
-0.1428478658,
-0.6258128285,
-0.9844876528,
0.2254518718,
-0.0364451483,
-0.9174131155,
0.325212419,
0.4042334259,
-0.174830243,
0.3868549764,
-0.8066230416,
0.7986305952,
0.0643600151,
-0.1283830255,
-0.2492069602,
-0.5944445729,
0.1567974538,
0.0655946359,
-0.1162768006,
-0.3698827922,
0.3331629634,
0.7282244563,
-0.580440104,
1.1025822163,
-0.8884426951,
-0.0740282312,
0.4924834967,
0.2178991884,
0.9306547642,
0.0062916172,
0.112177752,
0.0230604336,
0.1244964451,
-0.4939275086,
-0.7102384567,
0.2400085777,
-0.9823970199,
-0.7886573672,
-0.5411349535,
-0.7138594389,
-1.0142326355,
-0.0978826806,
0.1196705103,
0.7757020593,
0.2644536197,
-0.0611407645,
0.4610876143,
0.2783894241,
0.3960977197,
0.8134773374,
0.2360576987,
-0.3539281189,
0.8348933458,
0.0865689367,
0.3539391458,
0.473780036,
-0.0651081353,
-0.2826709151,
-0.7380535007,
-0.5471069217,
-0.0556823239,
-1.0278580189,
-0.6291791201,
-0.7629802823,
-0.0705651194,
-0.2878708243,
0.2248163521,
-0.2789568007,
-0.2645667493,
-0.0105582839,
0.0837792903,
0.6177738309,
0.7024333477,
-0.0846559256,
0.4323185682,
-1.2155706882,
-0.0586561263,
0.3883977234,
0.4435066283,
0.3186716139,
-0.6204420328,
-0.4429160655,
0.2769684196,
-0.3686388135,
-0.7659364939,
0.0155774737,
-0.0499147959,
0.708806932,
0.1510098875,
0.2570743859,
0.9200718403,
-0.4133237898,
0.5875092149,
0.1845157892,
-0.8118509054,
0.2546275258,
-0.4181264043,
0.1373712122,
0.7857094407,
0.3136856258,
-0.5484486222,
-0.4590344727,
-0.7821378112,
-0.5832090378,
1.14281106,
0.0249801986,
-0.275360167,
0.0207228195,
0.1527394056,
0.5142925978,
0.4466612935,
-0.4460921586,
-0.1589110345,
-0.0497691631,
-0.5747126341,
0.4783920348,
0.0278845467,
-0.2802874446,
0.0752307922,
0.962598145,
-0.2055004239,
0.6875779629,
0.4512159526,
-0.4463230073,
-0.3131682277,
0.0887197554,
0.4160797298,
0.7452362776,
-0.3542993069,
-0.1644428223,
0.1676901877,
-0.6625196338,
0.4435442984,
-0.1062213629,
0.1676386893,
0.1163470745,
0.2099377215,
0.9171125293,
-0.0910493582,
-1.026242733,
0.5156697035,
-0.1166810095,
-0.3281401992,
-0.4814227819,
-0.2003778815,
-0.3318422139,
0.6670336723,
0.2436652035,
0.4851557612,
-0.0345871747,
-0.506557107,
0.0130798565,
0.4107948542,
-0.5121837258,
-0.2342860401,
0.0384308174,
0.5577353239,
-0.2224299312,
0.4701717496,
-0.6608532071,
-0.6661908031,
0.6369143128,
-0.0320647806,
0.9972982407,
0.2235884815,
0.2996356785,
0.084076196,
0.0003958167,
0.1276382208,
0.083765544,
-0.4902878702,
-0.9421756268,
-0.3151858151,
-0.242390126,
-0.7404091954,
0.3523965776,
-0.530510366,
-0.0956278518,
-0.5302539468,
-0.4141019881,
-0.536352098,
0.2094233632,
-0.9962559342,
0.0363536924,
-0.1397261769,
0.6367989182,
-0.6815842986,
0.7885121107,
0.8971392512,
-0.2777865827,
-0.8259318471,
0.1960984915,
-0.0777379572,
-0.6431958675,
1.1419391632,
-0.0917544514,
-0.045851104,
-0.1758493334,
-0.131930396,
-0.9132760167,
1.0837626457,
0.3447824419,
-0.3149671555,
-0.0144570237,
0.1644662023,
0.2789409459,
-0.2943322361,
0.2542689443,
0.4528639317,
0.3365649581,
0.0910360515,
-1.1304323673,
0.0345129147,
-0.1620345861,
-0.3293654621,
0.2282041907,
-0.9741140008,
0.4164174497,
0.1563078463,
-0.2029656619,
0.0780492499,
0.5302405953,
0.0821177512,
0.370695889,
0.8217749596,
0.5032224059,
0.72580266,
-0.3473447263,
0.5422824621,
-0.1068355292,
0.2870930135,
1.3333284855,
-0.4328323305,
0.5096516609,
0.5292367339,
-0.2512606084,
0.390509814,
0.702344954,
0.2242438644,
0.7394561172,
-0.2898845971,
-0.3984085619,
-0.3369974792,
0.0830833837,
-0.0599541143,
0.563331604,
0.2611207068,
0.2058739662,
-0.5154197812,
0.2813481092,
-0.0424948856,
-0.3711651266,
-0.1442420483,
1.2480294704,
-0.4372413456,
-0.831885457,
0.5529080629,
-0.4361014366,
0.3290345669,
-0.6042712331,
-0.272125572,
-0.1416098475,
0.2988574207,
-0.0409080461,
-0.241848439,
0.2581471205,
-0.0759427249,
-0.1218423322,
-0.1554099321,
0.509878099,
-0.3843899965,
0.089066945,
0.1156759262,
0.5261543393,
0.1075437143,
0.1030313522,
-0.7053155899,
-0.1016741395,
0.0905008912,
-0.093996942,
0.6401819587,
0.6738926768,
0.256336242,
0.7306004167,
0.3490357101,
-0.1320344955,
0.1320927888,
-0.2396367639,
0.8353608251,
-0.3315418959,
-0.4945183694,
-0.2235832661,
0.6939249039,
-0.0627793297,
-0.2432292849,
0.2894600928,
0.087117061,
0.722909987,
-0.174286887,
0.8148105145,
-0.3072470427,
0.5947189331,
-0.7581095695,
0.3845158517,
-0.4597328901,
0.1211146712,
0.2508575916,
-0.4611246586,
0.2977685332,
0.4754762352,
-0.2426951975,
0.1751799434,
0.8289836645,
0.6868390441,
0.1890704483,
0.1472230852,
0.4529612958,
0.3824679554,
0.5598583817,
0.5140838027,
0.8888155222,
-0.5036455989,
0.7045721412,
-0.3397974074,
0.0179883167,
-0.4156708419,
-0.7454558015,
-1.0523055792,
-0.7691726685,
-0.5872969627,
-0.3312264681,
0.3186143041,
1.4594124556,
1.0075039864,
-0.7728644013,
0.0149072846,
-0.30780527,
0.1602114588,
-0.416916132,
-0.2960194945,
0.2291242331,
-0.7965730429,
-0.768989265,
0.3672297597,
0.1033957675,
0.2361167967,
-0.1133534908,
-0.0706226602,
-0.1500128508,
0.0270761475,
0.4160761535,
0.3452610075,
-0.6960704923,
-0.5308205485,
-0.345633626,
-0.0517626517,
0.4703568816,
0.8636184931,
-0.9421949983,
0.5982655883,
0.2538159192,
1.0219874382,
0.356261313,
-0.354064256,
0.5345022678,
-0.9908265471,
0.375253588,
0.3693519235,
0.4271502197,
0.2089378536,
-0.7585064173,
0.2702935934,
0.2505093515,
-0.4782776237,
-0.823392272,
0.2699850798,
-1.1736721992,
-0.059751559,
0.7710627913,
-0.4900915623,
-0.1111147627,
-0.6443035007,
-0.2980194092,
0.2518157065,
-0.7901916504,
0.9874083996,
1.043191433,
-0.3435380161,
0.1095412895,
-0.5567200184,
0.8360946774,
0.3916408122,
-0.8845005631,
0.2919401228,
0.4168507159,
0.3174259067,
0.1965565383,
0.7400984764,
0.0229124781,
0.5804729462,
0.3590879142,
-0.3002371788,
-0.3856269121,
-0.5079974532,
-0.1383670866,
0.087725684,
0.1712209731,
-0.3451778591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16675v1 | Multiview Identifiers Enhanced Generative Retrieval | 2023-05-26T06:50:21 | 2023-05-26T06:50:21 | Yongqi Li, Nan Yang, Liang Wang, Furu Wei, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Instead of simply matching a query to pre-existing passages, generative
retrieval generates identifier strings of passages as the retrieval target. At
a cost, the identifier must be distinctive enough to represent a passage.
Current approaches use either a numeric ID or a text piece (such as a title or
substrings) as the identifier. However, these identifiers cannot cover a
passage's content well. As such, we are motivated to propose a new type of
identifier, synthetic identifiers, that are generated based on the content of a
passage and could integrate contextualized information that text pieces lack.
Furthermore, we simultaneously consider multiview identifiers, including
synthetic identifiers, titles, and substrings. These views of identifiers
complement each other and facilitate the holistic ranking of passages from
multiple perspectives. We conduct a series of experiments on three public
datasets, and the results indicate that our proposed approach performs the best
in generative retrieval, demonstrating its effectiveness and robustness. | [
-0.5882165432,
-0.6241841912,
0.8892541528,
0.2659811676,
-0.5651482344,
0.3886077404,
0.2508891225,
-0.241765663,
0.4329608083,
0.5039432645,
-0.2944671512,
-0.3640988171,
-0.4682971239,
0.3260217309,
-0.6201658845,
1.031021595,
0.3020216227,
-0.1135765165,
-0.4091336131,
-0.3022766113,
-0.101760149,
-0.6818837523,
-0.0970001742,
-0.0701175258,
0.8011874557,
0.0956195742,
0.4577974379,
0.7126532793,
0.752458334,
0.3406332135,
-0.1628931165,
0.5145674348,
0.049739752,
0.0754697695,
-0.0665131211,
-0.2618999481,
-0.3259297013,
0.2031778395,
0.8028214574,
0.7839738131,
0.0079976348,
-0.0129883625,
0.0873613656,
0.905695796,
-0.8018090725,
0.2369532436,
-0.62735039,
0.2989402115,
-0.4614593387,
-0.5572437644,
-0.5278404355,
-0.9477666616,
0.5336552858,
-0.9204544425,
0.4205327034,
0.0499467216,
0.5810313821,
0.0210122298,
-0.8127169013,
-0.0490204096,
-0.6693738699,
0.5194781423,
-0.2540991604,
0.3320624232,
-0.0433827676,
0.332814306,
0.1156847328,
-0.6977749467,
-0.4501511753,
-0.0115114888,
-0.2958663702,
0.399818629,
0.3994201124,
0.0034499397,
0.1763440967,
0.6742703319,
-0.5784341097,
-0.5966751575,
-0.5384156108,
-0.3298848867,
0.7496392727,
0.1793460697,
0.16574049,
-0.5053624511,
-0.5314067006,
-0.3504483104,
-0.6887896061,
-0.1799049377,
0.4017659128,
0.2790867984,
0.1057712808,
0.6441941261,
-0.2948217988,
0.7944740057,
0.2061864734,
-0.1744397581,
0.5906686783,
-0.7688269019,
-0.0924585983,
0.1936548054,
0.5650035143,
0.4948094487,
0.1874008477,
-0.1075136662,
0.1255943924,
-0.2890692949,
0.3845357597,
-0.7275010943,
-0.337269932,
0.0183661319,
-0.7147468925,
-0.2693744302,
0.4248609841,
-0.8559099436,
-0.6397322416,
-0.5064708591,
0.390172869,
-0.5111477375,
-0.293587923,
-0.3097620904,
-0.5820271969,
0.4289788902,
0.6659485102,
-0.7848830223,
-0.0352278352,
0.5915876031,
0.9005914927,
-0.4877697825,
-0.1206050962,
-0.447054565,
0.3061082661,
-0.466688782,
0.9197970629,
-0.9363871217,
-0.6576282978,
-0.0804857314,
0.086022459,
0.0202465318,
-0.6806818247,
0.1707796752,
-0.631724298,
0.2880008221,
-0.3608586192,
-0.502396524,
-0.2241695523,
0.1457411051,
-0.9882996678,
0.7196956277,
-0.050069686,
-0.6820662618,
0.3535815775,
-0.5776033998,
-0.5371955037,
0.1818174571,
-0.3213150799,
-0.2961264253,
0.5308188796,
0.1080937684,
-0.0848737136,
-0.0356524736,
0.2501215935,
-0.1134445295,
-0.1167712063,
0.1196735278,
-0.5835011005,
0.3642677963,
0.213180095,
0.424159199,
0.1185363233,
-0.6904101968,
0.2312228829,
-0.1600378305,
-0.6572674513,
-0.7733469009,
-0.004937314,
0.3490054011,
-0.0387091897,
0.207182169,
-0.592376411,
0.4050137103,
-0.3887943625,
0.0210698321,
0.5480487347,
0.2883731723,
0.5948345661,
-0.2959696651,
0.3955334723,
0.1501941383,
0.1570446789,
-0.4431078136,
-0.7119885683,
-0.4777007699,
-0.21466811,
0.5911613703,
0.4310196936,
-0.7767856717,
0.0961669236,
-0.3149796128,
-0.4075349867,
-0.4760192931,
-0.001809705,
0.5520341396,
0.0701623335,
0.6952357888,
-0.4675926268,
-0.634201467,
-1.0675227642,
-0.5570890307,
0.0466314815,
-0.1922474802,
0.4513719082,
0.4306158125,
0.3616539836,
0.745947659,
-0.7216553688,
-0.4158814847,
-0.0832973644,
0.2551569343,
0.0456063934,
0.4588179886,
0.4983044565,
-1.3895479441,
-0.6451585293,
0.0433954187,
-0.6750878692,
0.3045651615,
-0.2770621479,
-0.4009413123,
-0.2967307866,
0.5333418846,
-0.3384681642,
0.4218466282,
0.1837256551,
-0.2254333347,
0.2690678239,
-0.3532647789,
0.2536494136,
-1.2948923111,
-0.0955249518,
0.0417939201,
0.1511662155,
-0.334887892,
-0.1403428465,
0.309764415,
0.0121866902,
-0.5394770503,
0.5386235714,
-0.5047309399,
0.0063178879,
0.047580678,
0.2771902084,
0.442358464,
0.4092996418,
0.3138135374,
0.7373746037,
0.1059370786,
-0.5638157725,
0.4104385078,
0.4106171429,
-0.4048917592,
1.0032268763,
-0.5313691497,
0.1021761224,
-0.6575012207,
0.5076762438,
-0.8957707882,
-0.5740323067,
-0.0939249843,
-0.3450523615,
0.1969715357,
-0.185657382,
-0.3274614811,
-0.0210522041,
-0.4646861553,
0.7763643265,
-0.0621784255,
-0.6307703257,
0.7095060349,
0.2840628028,
-0.0734746456,
-0.3470583558,
-0.4498125911,
0.105448164,
-0.2998137176,
-0.3721075356,
1.1596602201,
-0.1259978861,
0.0281562563,
-0.0796823949,
-0.2526010275,
-0.0661595389,
-0.1425165683,
0.0372345746,
0.2641070783,
-0.1413244903,
0.1701266468,
0.3365912735,
-0.2445439696,
-0.234662801,
-0.109565787,
0.2629269958,
-0.0414302498,
-0.5009788871,
-0.43250525,
1.0431983471,
0.7504179478,
-0.7305604219,
0.4997336864,
0.3810602427,
-0.3435629308,
0.1765495539,
-0.3732714057,
-0.0067500211,
-0.4540010691,
0.1700854003,
-0.5798496008,
-0.3748107255,
0.3444437087,
-0.078039147,
-0.0446730219,
0.2779513299,
0.2742708623,
-0.0832922533,
1.1507763863,
0.4397454858,
0.3527758718,
0.6013262272,
-0.2683542967,
0.2113314718,
-1.362909317,
-0.8785355091,
-0.419356972,
-0.3276475668,
-0.7821640372,
-0.3706778884,
0.78810817,
0.0027496677,
0.1698097438,
0.371314317,
-0.7765986919,
0.6666935682,
0.8890869617,
0.2378036827,
0.6011688709,
-0.1116026044,
-0.4915625751,
0.0184764005,
-0.1625514328,
-0.467123419,
1.1928374767,
-0.2764168978,
0.8324027658,
0.7114556432,
0.8092172742,
0.3511733115,
0.4660247862,
-0.526327312,
0.2411674708,
-0.1234739944,
-0.9290357828,
-0.0695215836,
-0.2181618065,
-0.950466454,
0.7266001105,
-0.1675194949,
-0.6623511314,
0.495993793,
-0.0142301079,
-0.6858337522,
-0.1635702401,
-0.9116992354,
0.8780311346,
-0.4164125025,
-0.2509559393,
-0.0657903478,
-0.5664901137,
0.1283636838,
-0.2155620605,
-0.0576242618,
0.0328600667,
0.0495758876,
0.3986013532,
-0.2349875718,
0.5296564698,
-0.0463428497,
0.1442047954,
0.1878894866,
-0.1010279432,
0.0747338012,
0.3207292259,
-0.0209978018,
-0.2988100946,
0.2966123223,
-0.287376374,
-0.7902530432,
0.7385206223,
-0.3485324979,
-0.7580108047,
-0.6267351508,
-0.1793184578,
-0.073096551,
0.1820762157,
0.3839358091,
0.7257743478,
-0.0280464794,
0.6903731823,
0.7014827728,
-0.4276607335,
0.5053935647,
0.2882859409,
-0.0657595769,
-0.6082287431,
0.8971508145,
0.1332407892,
0.2004142404,
0.7174764872,
0.0430877097,
-0.7117069364,
-0.3911173642,
-0.4887318313,
-0.0774686337,
-0.5186060667,
-0.3937259316,
-0.4743722677,
-0.5305640101,
-0.2266123593,
0.1936838478,
-0.3129279912,
-0.261138171,
-0.0430997126,
-0.2923821807,
0.236358732,
0.4850717783,
-0.0068947515,
-0.0803825259,
-1.0713756084,
0.5370239019,
0.4458861947,
0.4698255956,
0.1350155771,
0.0183921028,
-0.0182566084,
-0.1750734001,
-0.7520106435,
-1.1758031845,
0.2865553796,
0.495355159,
0.8374431133,
0.4602917135,
0.4239029884,
0.7048272491,
-0.5146767497,
0.5000450611,
0.0897329748,
-0.7674666047,
0.8266234398,
-0.2009112835,
0.2837943137,
0.5425736904,
0.4372287989,
-0.4305455089,
-0.231188491,
-0.2158048004,
-0.8269669414,
0.3809400797,
0.4668117464,
0.4075621068,
-0.1854505241,
0.1966664642,
0.3172014356,
0.2772081494,
-0.7218275666,
-0.2198042274,
-0.403593272,
-0.3137296438,
0.208998695,
-0.087122649,
-0.2051478028,
-0.3276360631,
0.0855902582,
-0.3418855667,
0.36393255,
0.5661321878,
-0.0142915882,
0.4340234697,
0.2413068712,
0.4768374264,
0.5743895769,
-0.4560578465,
0.2446469963,
-0.2921044528,
-0.5911362171,
0.1943345666,
0.1239423826,
-0.3265106082,
0.0760084167,
0.293889612,
0.4953989089,
-0.2190802693,
-0.3981310427,
0.4943323433,
-0.0772601143,
0.0066967332,
-0.7208608389,
-0.0146089094,
-0.1983680278,
0.3536948264,
0.5760182142,
0.0693593249,
0.5446028709,
-0.662304461,
0.2305771858,
0.4893808663,
-0.3036353588,
-0.2929039598,
0.7186633348,
0.5084460974,
-0.4051854908,
0.6526132822,
-0.064666301,
-0.2943882942,
0.5548595786,
0.3613359928,
0.7669600248,
-0.0933085233,
0.3714237213,
0.3191535175,
0.0351849459,
0.1234475374,
0.2381643802,
-0.4520073831,
-0.740150094,
-0.4269932806,
-0.7797615528,
-0.2997414768,
0.1096168607,
-0.810310483,
-0.0985494405,
-0.2755204141,
-0.2974976301,
0.3435721695,
-0.2664359808,
-0.5869476199,
0.1686756462,
0.3248269558,
0.9114868045,
-0.6645473242,
0.8941898346,
0.8150137067,
-0.7377359867,
-0.2103297114,
0.2406739295,
0.1075905189,
-0.1145521104,
0.2790781558,
0.2830753326,
0.0054530841,
0.0419975296,
-0.097492896,
-1.0982702971,
1.0333482027,
-0.0985142067,
-0.3136166036,
-0.2686278522,
0.1425008476,
0.6712284088,
-0.4454631209,
0.2995369434,
0.350160867,
0.6145732999,
0.2741150856,
-0.8447496891,
-0.0124999583,
-0.5113886595,
0.3531243205,
0.2006154358,
-0.580783546,
0.690177381,
-0.3462019563,
-0.3390877843,
0.4276070297,
0.4483421743,
0.4077578485,
0.5100491047,
0.2487591505,
0.3757176399,
0.6417117119,
-0.4857264757,
1.2796930075,
-0.2551881969,
0.1905177832,
0.8621017933,
0.1001583338,
0.7780895829,
0.7298504114,
-0.0816705972,
0.5186244249,
0.7700548768,
0.037644688,
1.1771302223,
0.1142260879,
-0.39150846,
-0.3218498528,
-0.2244515717,
-0.5893413424,
0.4276679158,
0.4195876122,
-0.5350500345,
-0.1047804058,
0.092987977,
-0.268764019,
0.1546673179,
0.1557040513,
0.998457849,
0.0902634487,
-0.8671407104,
0.3709896505,
-0.0068378574,
0.4306598604,
-0.3169161081,
-0.3401917815,
-0.5208413601,
0.2216488123,
-0.2437092811,
-0.7354810238,
0.4684110284,
-0.409204632,
-0.0863020644,
-0.4208892286,
0.1141046956,
-0.3861045241,
-0.5671220422,
0.0954676419,
0.6191795468,
-0.2222599983,
-0.2807593346,
-0.2307537794,
-0.2197475135,
-0.1155173331,
-0.1313847601,
0.2771320343,
0.650585413,
-0.0647139028,
0.348475486,
0.7967463732,
-0.2185480148,
0.0850137994,
0.176903829,
0.7881039977,
-0.8885538578,
-0.3284609616,
-0.6983113885,
0.5047184825,
-0.4746795595,
-0.5369030237,
0.7800158262,
0.9972655177,
0.9293788075,
-0.1380664259,
0.902895689,
0.0749014765,
0.3849981725,
-0.5253161788,
0.5675436854,
-0.9434479475,
0.2328469753,
-0.4512647092,
-1.1509977579,
-0.4484324157,
0.6749557853,
-0.0024598148,
-0.0974814668,
0.7107458711,
0.6869116426,
-0.2695964575,
-0.1191116944,
0.0623532385,
-0.3461292982,
0.3223166168,
0.3312886357,
1.1345905066,
-0.3995541632,
0.7189499736,
-0.1765292585,
-0.0054703294,
-0.3753679097,
-0.6759762168,
-0.6113558412,
-0.8762552142,
-0.3169770539,
-0.3306744695,
-0.0005650849,
0.5507609844,
0.9131640792,
-0.8906870484,
0.1797895283,
-0.0577878915,
0.3269744217,
-0.202614367,
-0.2807675302,
0.4814079106,
-0.0053742155,
-0.938853085,
0.3460960686,
0.496270895,
0.2504374385,
-0.3186133206,
0.1311257482,
-0.1534954607,
0.2952266037,
0.7789247632,
-0.000480601,
-0.9325236082,
-0.4316213429,
0.2739848793,
-0.0257587731,
0.2819575965,
0.9029334784,
-0.8857299685,
0.6168887019,
0.7345570922,
0.3365208805,
0.6188836098,
0.6372713447,
0.5115286112,
-0.7726138234,
-0.0438299254,
0.1721897721,
0.123690255,
0.3501929939,
-0.1618388593,
0.3885248601,
0.4220228195,
0.0121047944,
-0.5929275155,
0.4140693843,
-1.0468968153,
-0.1583533436,
0.8815318942,
0.0613281876,
-0.0106748976,
-0.1884643435,
-0.3133040071,
-0.0665766001,
-0.466675967,
1.0290004015,
0.6021774411,
-0.3661587238,
-0.1402915716,
-0.2751135826,
0.5508713722,
0.0530928224,
-1.0497118235,
-0.4043530822,
0.5576013923,
0.1526266187,
0.6797189116,
0.4352739751,
-0.5954720974,
0.05951038,
-0.0451243818,
-0.3533414006,
0.2707555592,
-0.7774605155,
0.2389021814,
0.2903914154,
-0.309391588,
-0.4769749343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16664v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16664v1 | Score-balanced Loss for Multi-aspect Pronunciation Assessment | 2023-05-26T06:21:37 | 2023-05-26T06:21:37 | Heejin Do, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | With rapid technological growth, automatic pronunciation assessment has
transitioned toward systems that evaluate pronunciation in various aspects,
such as fluency and stress. However, despite the highly imbalanced score labels
within each aspect, existing studies have rarely tackled the data imbalance
problem. In this paper, we suggest a novel loss function, score-balanced loss,
to address the problem caused by uneven data, such as bias toward the majority
scores. As a re-weighting approach, we assign higher costs when the predicted
score is of the minority class, thus, guiding the model to gain positive
feedback for sparse score prediction. Specifically, we design two weighting
factors by leveraging the concept of an effective number of samples and using
the ranks of scores. We evaluate our method on the speechocean762 dataset,
which has noticeably imbalanced scores for several aspects. Improved results
particularly on such uneven aspects prove the effectiveness of our method. | [
-0.4830848277,
-0.5619831681,
0.0100894552,
0.5016767979,
-0.2686929703,
0.2668881118,
-0.248800382,
-0.1884416789,
0.6438430548,
0.2067983001,
-0.4252474904,
-0.3066665828,
-0.5051699877,
-0.0456266031,
-0.1098707765,
0.9116965532,
0.184520185,
0.327400893,
-0.0241410621,
-0.6552097797,
-0.9717197418,
-0.6294057369,
-0.5751651525,
-0.5393865108,
0.6790550947,
0.7351175547,
0.6418225765,
0.5875934958,
0.3711134493,
0.1814026386,
-0.2853691876,
-0.0323176831,
-0.5038388371,
-0.0081925588,
0.2565404177,
-0.3207679689,
-0.7249285579,
0.1716356575,
0.9149375558,
1.1360361576,
-0.6536126137,
0.2394656688,
0.2786957026,
0.4358253777,
-0.7865164876,
-0.2556194961,
-0.5963177085,
0.1649559289,
-0.0949894786,
-0.2381268591,
-0.3060869575,
-0.1437220424,
0.2501924634,
-0.5747479796,
0.1899897158,
-0.0531207621,
0.4088425338,
0.225353688,
-0.4325006306,
0.0310781188,
-0.481072247,
1.0910174847,
-0.4811011553,
0.3587003946,
0.128393501,
-0.0503855199,
0.1013429165,
0.2183292657,
-0.4412430823,
-0.1859786808,
0.5041288137,
0.370429039,
-0.0197378304,
0.1590196788,
-0.051050771,
0.4548757076,
-0.2107893974,
0.2084361166,
-0.5045875907,
-0.6092550159,
0.6409723163,
0.0441646874,
0.1393828094,
-0.1255485862,
-0.1371933669,
-0.2457559854,
-0.3333280087,
0.0726691037,
0.7872219086,
0.8106662035,
0.0063650208,
0.5269745588,
-0.1501894444,
0.5344094038,
0.2783736885,
-0.2351364046,
0.6160172224,
-0.1867752075,
-0.131892398,
0.6958755255,
0.2747489512,
0.7853646874,
-0.0580565147,
0.125279963,
-0.171015799,
-0.118723616,
0.2549407482,
-0.5212873816,
-0.0767818093,
0.0711162463,
-0.494146198,
-0.3431135416,
0.0435616635,
-0.8202499151,
-0.6933556199,
-0.4985900819,
0.7490760088,
-0.2326751053,
-0.3900821209,
-0.1427930743,
-0.2400891632,
0.0864284262,
0.471439451,
-0.7102285624,
0.4987231791,
0.5311835408,
0.9767311811,
-0.288664192,
-0.1284296662,
-0.7344529033,
-0.513294518,
-0.408095777,
0.5755636096,
-0.5758430958,
-0.7395480871,
-0.190608725,
-0.1334935874,
-0.0416241325,
-0.8255717754,
0.7436528206,
0.1715696901,
0.1856684536,
-0.3343220949,
-0.4875154495,
-0.3388244808,
0.1774526983,
-0.791710794,
0.9043229222,
0.1354496777,
-0.6114631295,
0.5834937096,
-0.0834630653,
-0.7775986195,
-0.0157870557,
0.087264955,
-0.5896430016,
0.318618685,
0.0391183905,
-0.1688035578,
-0.0153467264,
-0.0436823629,
-0.4966761768,
-0.5717754364,
0.1739715189,
-0.6811368465,
0.6111034155,
0.0302451253,
-0.326390326,
-0.2065245211,
-0.709025681,
0.3611926436,
-0.5568449497,
-0.6224765778,
-0.4973179102,
0.0218948592,
0.1734688133,
-0.277882725,
-0.1145370677,
-0.6870850325,
0.1199900359,
-0.3584712148,
0.221104607,
0.6341514587,
-0.096574001,
0.5100588202,
-0.5379633307,
0.5594049096,
-0.0773142353,
0.3787653148,
0.2284476161,
-0.5080493689,
-0.7628111839,
-0.3145875037,
0.6274154782,
0.6423393488,
-0.1292929649,
0.5387691855,
-0.1040001884,
-0.4603122771,
-1.2824783325,
0.0779369473,
0.2383685112,
0.6083294749,
0.6427323818,
-0.7819795012,
-0.4037651122,
-0.8017337322,
-0.2754635811,
-0.1593972892,
0.0983137041,
0.2991895378,
-0.0634018704,
-0.0524813645,
0.392264694,
-0.1868257821,
-0.5266933441,
-0.1356054991,
0.2788270712,
0.1089197248,
0.6938528419,
0.2680255771,
-0.719192028,
-0.0184439141,
-0.2182658613,
0.0403360128,
-0.3054826558,
0.0668161139,
0.0280569401,
0.0302148424,
0.0128899766,
-0.232631892,
0.3154150248,
0.5232483149,
-0.141764611,
0.4226642251,
0.1442934424,
0.505823493,
-0.646607697,
-0.279935509,
0.0446143039,
0.1105468273,
-0.3505242169,
-0.3067941666,
-0.1325889975,
0.0392714404,
-0.2897251546,
0.4371764362,
-0.1979450434,
-0.0453403406,
-0.3425408006,
-0.0617594942,
0.1708853692,
0.4757767618,
-0.3772607446,
0.4397709072,
0.3861215115,
-0.4921496212,
0.2358653396,
-0.2219887674,
-0.1021395922,
0.9101490378,
-0.5987942219,
0.0126201771,
-0.1638481915,
0.2264775038,
-1.0843200684,
-0.0292568691,
0.0428205431,
-0.5669831038,
0.4596947134,
-0.3066108823,
0.1933622658,
-0.2357476354,
-0.6469689012,
0.6218378544,
0.3007382452,
-0.1920149475,
0.6183003187,
0.6768703461,
-0.331174165,
-0.7096211314,
-0.7189692855,
-0.0639552698,
-0.5285208225,
-0.3940418661,
0.5543804169,
-0.2327888459,
-0.2858534753,
-0.0044199233,
-0.5247124434,
-0.0791345462,
0.1711631715,
0.2362431437,
0.0456477106,
-0.2350386828,
0.4489713013,
0.2413093299,
0.0206753816,
-0.2243591249,
-0.2301339805,
0.2693309784,
0.0374563672,
-0.2308604419,
-0.3871857822,
0.5568469167,
0.7342767119,
-0.080636397,
0.3781897724,
0.5229836702,
-0.4516194165,
-0.2849490345,
-0.667779386,
-0.009594853,
-0.3713375926,
0.6115688682,
-0.2188316584,
-0.6070820689,
0.7404905558,
0.1419311464,
0.1370396763,
0.6556113362,
0.5591810346,
-0.1287470311,
1.0592509508,
0.4029662311,
-0.5015208721,
0.4586951733,
-0.0568690486,
0.0460451059,
-0.861222744,
-0.1657339185,
-0.5531187057,
-0.6466730833,
-0.6187194586,
-0.1736662537,
0.5208534598,
0.0391770266,
0.0336634777,
-0.273283124,
-0.6570715904,
0.3130087852,
0.8707880378,
0.3239454031,
0.0014734651,
0.0260394104,
-0.0541064404,
-0.0715369359,
-0.4957347512,
0.0043071704,
1.1506844759,
0.2456929535,
0.7752777338,
0.3397814035,
0.8674803376,
0.7480998635,
0.3839259446,
-1.2449010611,
0.1105385423,
-0.4871732593,
-0.3164363205,
-0.6403503418,
-0.7002151012,
-0.6056246161,
0.468696475,
-0.2068831027,
-0.2677313983,
0.1869982928,
0.4677952826,
-0.629652679,
-0.0920820609,
-0.8724563122,
0.6851680875,
-0.2798160911,
-0.2161711156,
-0.3965903819,
-0.3224092424,
0.366402179,
-0.0453123301,
0.3430416882,
-0.3576118946,
0.3111857772,
1.0450935364,
-0.8094739914,
0.6654133201,
-0.5619982481,
0.0420702733,
0.4742019773,
-0.0576956607,
-0.1302587986,
-0.0156115396,
-0.5215515494,
0.1133051738,
0.0225719884,
-0.3727419972,
-0.7237193584,
0.9182406664,
-0.9121323228,
-0.3351434171,
-0.4062483609,
-0.204281196,
-0.1031833738,
0.016428791,
0.4275797904,
0.7566697598,
-0.0827802643,
0.1442808807,
0.3857052326,
-0.0250950586,
0.140251413,
0.4304305911,
0.4343542755,
-0.9532186985,
1.0708446503,
0.6764543056,
0.2771905959,
0.1311807334,
0.5859671831,
-0.326459825,
-0.3221986592,
-0.3755428791,
-0.1180926859,
-0.6804172993,
-0.2430498153,
-0.0528639629,
0.0096505154,
-0.4632132947,
0.1381089538,
-0.382569164,
-0.4421983957,
-0.0693141595,
-0.3822335899,
0.0517108664,
0.3255718648,
-0.140164569,
0.399409771,
-0.3621175289,
0.1450745016,
0.3268246353,
0.4035939276,
0.215624094,
-0.9445297718,
-0.1208577827,
0.1179194897,
-0.4732243419,
-0.7824719548,
0.0730981082,
0.634752512,
0.7576155663,
0.25206545,
0.2756604552,
0.8847715855,
-0.2913631797,
0.490825206,
0.1563682109,
-1.1995328665,
0.1773151457,
0.1534650922,
0.4631907344,
0.8009712696,
-0.1975320429,
-0.8164172769,
-0.3143374026,
-0.6032822728,
-1.0712153912,
0.5080949068,
0.1087963134,
0.2451049238,
0.0388799086,
0.3322342932,
0.1657532752,
0.1549200267,
-0.497108072,
-0.2956818342,
-0.6128534675,
-0.6043519378,
-0.0495336987,
-0.2470502406,
-0.1180021018,
-0.4010434449,
0.7370814681,
-0.0395396091,
-0.0292817894,
0.3438811302,
-0.0246221721,
-0.271762073,
0.5362585783,
0.6969586015,
0.2603854835,
-0.2275407612,
0.2339590639,
0.3135988116,
-0.7879876494,
0.2723658383,
0.2100326717,
-0.1982137859,
-0.0584684685,
0.6590835452,
0.6972386837,
0.2911756337,
-0.3794227242,
0.5181018114,
0.0514077432,
-0.3676409721,
-0.1005122885,
-0.012876017,
-0.3351317048,
-0.0769980922,
0.5567605495,
0.2839299142,
0.3758164644,
-0.5543549657,
0.3834462464,
0.1608105749,
-0.8602110744,
-0.2106472254,
0.3229754269,
0.6069155931,
-0.1626813859,
0.7558281422,
-0.2716377974,
-0.662473917,
0.8697405457,
0.0986113399,
0.8503159285,
-0.7707840204,
0.2294765115,
0.2739923,
0.5199654698,
-0.2309249789,
0.5223247409,
0.0452667251,
-0.5800076723,
-0.2080580741,
-0.5821709037,
-0.5745159984,
-0.050074473,
-0.9009433985,
0.24979195,
-0.3341831863,
-0.5892773867,
0.2184188664,
0.1126383692,
-0.4963487685,
0.4014578164,
0.3513960838,
0.4037363231,
-0.7924979329,
0.2844752967,
0.5110597014,
-0.3402117193,
-0.7168956399,
0.0267210957,
0.315959394,
-0.7470552325,
0.2202626467,
0.4793488085,
-0.3357285559,
-0.2410221249,
-0.1386614889,
-0.9050228596,
0.6864081621,
0.4780727029,
-0.6485235095,
0.3441907465,
-0.0522380322,
0.32285887,
-0.256859988,
0.385595113,
0.3879310191,
0.4838720858,
0.1058228686,
-1.207126379,
-0.2632411122,
-0.1626867354,
-0.3584528863,
0.1868947893,
-0.7917543054,
1.1551383734,
-0.2239830047,
-0.131029129,
-0.0534735732,
0.6095751524,
-0.0125220995,
0.7295767069,
0.8896125555,
0.5825858712,
1.1723585129,
0.0475206599,
0.5230112672,
-0.0307886824,
0.3447120786,
1.1013075113,
-0.2528251112,
0.7577560544,
0.3138301373,
-0.1402033865,
0.2276865393,
0.7999860048,
0.0579794794,
0.5162894726,
0.7557954788,
-0.3109176457,
-0.3137435615,
-0.376667738,
-0.197344929,
0.6806672812,
0.305696696,
0.0076121218,
0.1315516531,
0.1581038684,
-0.0398234464,
-0.0865909606,
-0.6818395853,
0.5321073532,
-0.0372116864,
-0.6872386932,
0.5299594998,
0.0623595044,
0.574909091,
-0.2158347815,
-0.2240217626,
-0.5528325438,
0.1789996326,
-0.3428126574,
-0.526986897,
0.0166711845,
-0.4291727543,
-0.4546914697,
0.2472700626,
0.0714623407,
-0.8036350012,
-0.6633844972,
0.3599019945,
0.11995323,
-0.0108590964,
-0.1627810299,
-0.5459033847,
0.3653176725,
-0.0422238,
0.1447552592,
-0.0033996932,
0.3473448753,
-0.2654469609,
0.4709684551,
0.1133773476,
0.1236935705,
0.2175954729,
0.6521781087,
0.4310939014,
-0.5402874947,
-0.6124127507,
-0.5374183655,
0.3186315894,
0.0295296945,
-0.6765757799,
0.4920163155,
0.4073793888,
0.5928321481,
0.3811720014,
0.9417819977,
0.2579710186,
0.8453997374,
-0.3612582684,
0.4592567086,
-0.7253335118,
0.1793806255,
-0.4849894047,
-0.8042177558,
-0.3599162698,
0.3682431877,
0.1853002459,
0.2007521242,
0.3364881277,
0.5664017797,
0.0580201559,
-0.1114737466,
0.1971483082,
0.0079159308,
0.2272871435,
0.3371012807,
0.4623618722,
-0.4862172604,
0.5498030782,
-0.2100800127,
-0.4800097942,
-0.435616076,
-0.4316510558,
-0.4108689129,
-0.3703524768,
-0.6081151366,
-0.2145582736,
0.1550556868,
0.765696466,
0.848102212,
-0.7388986349,
-0.2362568676,
0.4862345159,
0.2935175598,
-0.6243451238,
-0.2493503839,
0.3435790837,
0.0270821564,
-0.5654502511,
0.3830822408,
0.0106128613,
-0.0570029169,
-0.1948824227,
-0.1246676221,
0.2339679897,
-0.0390034541,
0.4865303338,
0.2593236566,
-0.8455221653,
-0.5053077936,
-0.013428851,
0.2120423466,
-0.1410618573,
0.7148638368,
-0.4601142406,
0.7422715425,
0.3044850528,
0.5496322513,
-0.2138936371,
0.4357159138,
0.709695816,
-0.9348176718,
-0.0370260477,
0.2677692771,
0.3311118186,
0.6034187675,
-0.4011563361,
0.1462876648,
0.4427202046,
-0.2829571366,
-0.7140654922,
-0.2275945991,
-1.2298303843,
-0.0189474896,
0.8645715714,
0.2513101399,
-0.0075773532,
0.0135370065,
-0.2096499503,
0.232700035,
-0.843506217,
0.8895443082,
0.8362511396,
-0.2045617551,
-0.0993604735,
-0.1250442117,
0.4129135609,
0.7937284112,
-0.2958548963,
0.0924960747,
0.602694869,
0.1223863587,
0.3120591342,
0.4717175961,
0.1792841256,
0.3137865365,
-0.0861103609,
0.338922888,
0.3230988085,
-0.4450807869,
-0.5906826854,
0.2177007794,
0.1020411476,
-0.6377307773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16663v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16663v2 | GDA: Generative Data Augmentation Techniques for Relation Extraction Tasks | 2023-05-26T06:21:01 | 2023-06-15T02:43:12 | Xuming Hu, Aiwei Liu, Zeqi Tan, Xin Zhang, Chenwei Zhang, Irwin King, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T01, I.2.7 | Relation extraction (RE) tasks show promising performance in extracting
relations from two entities mentioned in sentences, given sufficient
annotations available during training. Such annotations would be
labor-intensive to obtain in practice. Existing work adopts data augmentation
techniques to generate pseudo-annotated sentences beyond limited annotations.
These techniques neither preserve the semantic consistency of the original
sentences when rule-based augmentations are adopted, nor preserve the syntax
structure of sentences when expressing relations using seq2seq models,
resulting in less diverse augmentations. In this work, we propose a dedicated
augmentation technique for relational texts, named GDA, which uses two
complementary modules to preserve both semantic consistency and syntax
structures. We adopt a generative formulation and design a multi-tasking
solution to achieve synergies. Furthermore, GDA adopts entity hints as the
prior knowledge of the generative model to augment diverse sentences.
Experimental results in three datasets under a low-resource setting showed that
GDA could bring {\em 2.0\%} F1 improvements compared with no augmentation
technique. Source code and data are available. | [
-0.1961887032,
-0.9491306543,
0.5866274238,
0.1050238758,
-0.5464703441,
-0.1648362577,
-0.1097070724,
-0.6715198159,
0.4898369014,
0.3106850386,
-0.7278835773,
-0.3437860012,
-0.369117409,
0.2372683138,
-0.1430827379,
0.9725646377,
-0.0594318062,
-0.0771506652,
-0.7779099941,
-0.2815588117,
-0.4494405985,
-0.4939581156,
-0.1077836454,
-0.2551951408,
0.3120147586,
0.3731893599,
0.8367701173,
0.6462917924,
0.396209836,
0.226632297,
-0.0132448403,
0.7067995667,
-0.2310576886,
0.5258671641,
-0.2511588037,
-0.4262916744,
-0.5293965936,
-0.0393665135,
0.4736641049,
0.7144983411,
-0.0674598813,
0.0887680799,
-0.1598965377,
0.5091770887,
-0.9256299138,
0.5289373994,
-0.4101403356,
-0.1769071817,
-0.2806983292,
-0.1819217652,
-0.1682632267,
-0.1500453949,
-0.0119281178,
-0.9687372446,
0.1596506685,
-0.0714763328,
1.07414639,
0.2517426908,
-0.2933547795,
-0.2960163355,
-0.6728422642,
0.5079990029,
-0.33050102,
0.444812417,
0.3342773914,
0.0335292853,
-0.0116025778,
-0.8307580948,
-0.7034342289,
-0.1852113605,
-0.4789317846,
0.0688759461,
-0.1273222268,
0.0066754799,
0.5107814074,
0.685158968,
-0.2830634415,
-0.0830088109,
-0.1237023324,
0.093292281,
0.5739247203,
0.1998469383,
0.4936197698,
-0.4167020321,
-0.3709750175,
-0.0120607978,
-0.8571147323,
-0.2646339536,
0.3993606567,
0.0609896146,
0.0467280969,
0.8218961358,
-0.3276646435,
0.5821041465,
-0.1047168002,
0.1050080061,
0.5911185741,
-1.0028624535,
-0.261074841,
-0.3998320699,
0.9536770582,
0.333940953,
0.2743103504,
-0.636085391,
0.0117619941,
0.5014306903,
0.2492826581,
-0.7048718929,
-0.516708076,
0.0181304403,
-0.5032918453,
-0.1961088628,
0.034142606,
-0.8386641145,
-0.0607088543,
-0.4278979897,
0.2207485139,
-0.658134222,
-0.3896329999,
-0.3554939628,
-0.1600230932,
0.0932272226,
0.0909275785,
-1.0992053747,
0.3533232212,
0.5906957984,
0.8012145162,
-0.0538498908,
-0.0543481149,
-0.6274163127,
0.2928139865,
-0.1385756731,
0.6503264904,
-0.7721093893,
-0.5491935015,
-0.1133958846,
0.034338396,
0.0067345188,
-0.5414238572,
0.7180811763,
-0.6411267519,
0.3199920654,
-0.4012440145,
-0.6432552934,
-0.0033874901,
-0.0087564709,
-0.9231854677,
1.0375937223,
0.391258359,
-0.8037429452,
0.4091200531,
-0.5164663792,
-0.7102196813,
0.0559373945,
-0.4364411533,
-0.5292943716,
0.0117875244,
0.7381281853,
0.1923522949,
-0.3571947515,
0.1780305058,
-0.2012818009,
-0.2718761265,
-0.0704873204,
0.0584585331,
0.7855579257,
0.1284626275,
-0.0613837689,
0.0996579975,
-0.7317104936,
0.0056140544,
-0.0112499148,
-0.1157575548,
-0.6996712089,
-0.133982107,
-0.0170051828,
0.270113498,
0.1399581432,
-0.5038360357,
0.5374593735,
-0.6616591215,
0.1780313402,
0.2884761989,
0.3193757832,
0.7788254619,
-0.2481277585,
0.6218116283,
0.2623711228,
-0.085438557,
-0.3732213676,
-0.6144714355,
-0.5031297803,
-0.2449228913,
0.5294452906,
0.5253964663,
-1.4242604971,
0.6253228188,
-0.5376490951,
-0.2149801701,
-0.7655833364,
0.5104244947,
0.4777022004,
0.4740418792,
0.7038196921,
-0.459505707,
-0.7923215032,
-0.9692682624,
-0.0403085612,
-0.0642005205,
-0.0138749452,
0.0952554122,
0.3196893036,
-0.2452118546,
1.1834017038,
-0.5955730677,
-0.5473378897,
-0.096639514,
0.1412780732,
-0.0205428675,
0.4398346543,
0.5293143988,
-0.9495633841,
-0.2345487326,
-0.1541284472,
-1.1129920483,
0.0420395955,
-0.1195995286,
-0.1846043169,
0.0520793647,
0.4139926136,
-1.0563995838,
0.2109773606,
0.2424732,
-0.084388338,
0.4717057943,
-0.1645517647,
-0.0736494064,
-1.1953192949,
-0.0368899181,
0.1554971933,
-0.226486966,
-0.6376996636,
0.2008635253,
0.239348188,
0.1855351031,
0.0539848544,
0.2635534704,
-0.9640370011,
-0.1069964617,
-0.1841720045,
0.0631260797,
0.0845591947,
0.3342660666,
0.005006949,
0.9983035922,
0.558280468,
-0.5354373455,
0.557854116,
0.6005650163,
-0.1933850497,
0.6611299515,
-0.4514188468,
0.334390074,
-0.3193016648,
0.117749989,
-0.5911673903,
-0.0452354997,
0.7504302859,
-0.2776235044,
0.2516695261,
-0.1559221745,
-0.5103779435,
-0.0672985241,
-0.4179572463,
0.2066033036,
0.3964957297,
-0.5782590508,
0.756257534,
0.4600301981,
-0.2249213457,
-0.6588971615,
-0.4829677939,
0.1956801116,
-0.1362070739,
-0.6371174455,
0.7182625532,
0.2109805048,
-0.2520541549,
0.5736144781,
-0.0820209756,
-0.1475968212,
-0.0466198623,
0.4042370021,
0.5767000914,
-0.1175521389,
0.4830183089,
0.1066849306,
-0.0945240781,
0.1894012839,
-0.0951936394,
0.215364337,
0.4480519891,
0.0431956127,
-0.2584979236,
0.4278967679,
0.1078127027,
-0.3630010188,
0.7723793387,
0.6501515508,
-0.4736472964,
-0.0297834836,
-0.3629054129,
-0.0800914988,
-0.4065093994,
0.294960022,
-0.7441846728,
-0.6532891393,
0.3474505246,
0.0129528726,
-0.1974554211,
0.5641704202,
0.2482176721,
0.0279377867,
0.5014038086,
0.6686674953,
-0.1617385298,
0.5582616329,
-0.3688963354,
0.1206142381,
-1.1747331619,
-0.2855872512,
-0.3617031872,
-0.1117558926,
-0.3685208261,
-0.4370601773,
0.1529176831,
0.2486320138,
0.4339662194,
0.4991892874,
-0.4128825963,
0.3067591786,
0.4282309115,
0.3333099782,
0.4624437988,
0.1311587393,
0.2504175007,
-0.2152006328,
-0.4291040301,
-0.2202059031,
1.2774832249,
-0.0434167385,
0.628321588,
0.2750554979,
0.8019179106,
0.1078848913,
0.410717994,
-0.7345330715,
0.3801777661,
-0.0681956261,
-0.2979983985,
-0.2617368996,
-0.7090122104,
-0.8643485308,
0.1085359752,
-0.5017192364,
-0.7440952063,
0.4359576702,
0.1004609913,
-0.2391913831,
-0.1779408902,
-0.8464691043,
0.7087345719,
0.0782650113,
-0.4173768163,
0.0238228105,
-0.6771161556,
0.5181004405,
-0.0243185293,
-0.003797444,
0.166208446,
-0.1339112222,
0.6598258018,
-0.4493168294,
0.3249323964,
-0.3129668236,
-0.0709192008,
0.2501114011,
-0.3520916998,
0.7908414602,
0.1602796763,
0.0339814834,
-0.2953010499,
-0.2400047332,
-0.0956801698,
-0.9552694559,
0.6443046927,
-0.3960747719,
-0.4045366347,
-0.1715808064,
-0.7281537652,
-0.4407888353,
0.0456452593,
0.1259927452,
0.2754388452,
-0.0767021626,
-0.03064516,
0.3466145098,
0.1602671444,
0.3308265805,
-0.1013029441,
-0.0468145274,
-0.5674232841,
0.8497493863,
0.1300792694,
0.1765485853,
0.3124407828,
-0.405202657,
-0.7353997827,
-0.3483288884,
-0.4971305728,
0.2079627663,
-0.5891097784,
-0.3689078391,
-0.7445251346,
0.0169445146,
-0.5088351965,
0.5046671629,
0.0510599017,
-0.6626743078,
-0.3357622325,
-0.2160519511,
0.4234277606,
0.4718983173,
0.0378839634,
0.0728118569,
-0.7686531544,
0.8577885032,
0.3532060981,
0.0201826394,
-0.1917516589,
0.1380140185,
-0.2031827718,
0.0056719589,
-0.1418047398,
-1.1528174877,
0.2116137594,
0.4574641287,
0.4407143891,
0.0898003429,
0.0348128639,
0.7876834273,
-0.2556771636,
0.5717456341,
0.2042479068,
-0.7914654613,
0.593524754,
-0.0445924848,
-0.0925960988,
0.495783329,
0.2929390669,
-0.0725289732,
-0.1333779544,
-0.8978911042,
-1.0106043816,
0.584860146,
0.444709301,
0.1817155331,
-0.0212272462,
0.5930354595,
-0.0737926289,
0.3311268091,
-0.3616683781,
-0.5432233214,
-0.0973445624,
-0.3144365847,
-0.0704414621,
-0.4481209517,
-0.0781927258,
-0.197776705,
0.5168119073,
-0.042692773,
0.2036344111,
0.3351451159,
-0.3648145199,
-0.094894357,
0.3834896088,
0.1060430259,
0.7367292047,
-0.1269739121,
0.0982906148,
0.0521726944,
-0.511691153,
0.2752129734,
0.6828827262,
-0.4852345884,
0.2431454808,
0.2754541039,
0.6375868917,
0.1063190177,
-0.1454218924,
0.4460273385,
0.1100088358,
-0.044520013,
0.0970070437,
0.1502804011,
0.2611194253,
0.1508304924,
0.2154850066,
-0.1668584645,
0.287137419,
-0.7356249094,
0.4588234425,
0.5312515497,
0.0039518671,
-0.1979888678,
0.7449150681,
0.1225450635,
-0.0124061117,
0.6366827488,
-0.6645678282,
-0.1448057443,
0.331566602,
0.6183028221,
0.6694920659,
-0.023995297,
0.2300679833,
0.2432040274,
0.0863128379,
-0.0891548246,
0.3258635402,
-0.2204045802,
-0.8010529876,
-0.7613164783,
-0.4125241637,
-0.4366569817,
-0.004434499,
-0.81477952,
0.1403363049,
-0.0967670754,
-0.1693927944,
0.290547967,
0.0897861645,
-0.559284389,
0.243123278,
-0.1881425679,
0.5416966677,
-0.7312936783,
1.1165139675,
0.9209122062,
-0.8992741704,
-0.7888131738,
-0.0261339769,
-0.3369219303,
-0.3214409351,
0.5194286704,
0.0249322839,
0.1585404128,
0.0645080954,
-0.1367777884,
-0.4260118604,
1.1011875868,
0.6413080096,
-0.5426241755,
-0.4242627621,
-0.0762122795,
0.4560514688,
-0.3994689584,
0.2295575738,
0.6986022592,
0.3323228955,
0.0672948956,
-0.672616601,
0.3554102182,
-0.5860793591,
0.104317151,
0.3850669265,
-0.0384484977,
0.7705820799,
-0.1108057201,
-0.5314670205,
0.2840541005,
0.905179143,
0.0785225779,
0.1192506924,
0.5280416608,
0.932721138,
0.8473700285,
-0.2580494583,
1.0734623671,
-0.051431071,
0.4295117259,
1.3047165871,
-0.3167511523,
0.4076650143,
0.5098487139,
-0.2086621523,
0.6443575621,
0.2003060281,
-0.1157755256,
0.6113564968,
-0.1512802988,
-0.3354445398,
-0.1066047177,
-0.3639266491,
-0.5107007623,
0.1670325994,
0.3311797976,
-0.4001704752,
-0.1633106321,
-0.2100137621,
0.0546467938,
0.2618539035,
-0.0716335922,
0.8402231932,
0.1694725305,
-0.5881115198,
0.2492413372,
-0.141355291,
0.6483560205,
-0.3251147866,
-0.3630838096,
-0.060703665,
0.0216886755,
-0.3125393689,
-0.6711097956,
0.4285977185,
-0.1291640699,
-0.3785914183,
0.0198170319,
0.9705805182,
-0.7152531743,
-0.2450033277,
0.2276082188,
0.7704083323,
-0.3159024417,
-0.0902934,
-0.3869079947,
-0.0643880516,
-0.1722195148,
-0.0098685054,
0.1811370403,
0.4790731072,
0.0506035574,
0.2417554706,
0.7099879384,
0.3710793257,
-0.2466537803,
0.1523696929,
1.2069453001,
-0.563873291,
-0.4274664521,
-0.8609954715,
0.3703554571,
-0.4741684496,
-0.202063635,
0.7628727555,
0.5169354677,
0.6887065172,
-0.1151513308,
0.7355374098,
-0.3209439516,
0.3573023379,
-0.8110917211,
0.2324243784,
-0.2374089509,
0.1070735231,
-0.5162048936,
-1.2070057392,
-0.219847858,
0.4944947362,
-0.2914971113,
0.0069981455,
0.8166466355,
0.7595291138,
-0.080378972,
0.1250300705,
-0.1070250869,
-0.0550598279,
0.3152985275,
0.6020882726,
0.7481900454,
-0.5905835629,
0.4768680632,
-0.3882588446,
0.0554648563,
0.2749173045,
-0.5516194105,
-0.6852718592,
-0.596154809,
-0.3270365596,
-0.1909461617,
0.3334414065,
0.75854671,
0.5409951806,
-0.5460906029,
0.2828274965,
-0.1606046706,
0.0906659514,
-0.3036030233,
-0.2589526772,
0.4986103475,
-0.5435245037,
-0.7605447769,
0.5434554219,
0.1733468026,
-0.1287976354,
-0.0466293283,
-0.1067102775,
-0.4229948223,
-0.5443650484,
0.3615493476,
0.1514566839,
-0.3622026742,
-0.2529007792,
-0.1531917155,
0.0153640034,
0.143937394,
0.603590548,
-0.9583300352,
0.4799022079,
0.3661136329,
0.7319216132,
0.469145298,
0.6480492353,
0.6759647131,
-1.1488482952,
0.2001491338,
0.0747062936,
0.3237098157,
0.4640212953,
-0.4876700938,
0.8271989822,
0.43909958,
-0.2591411471,
-0.5878269672,
0.2324722856,
-0.9007419348,
0.0315555409,
1.0732648373,
-0.3071053624,
-0.015474584,
-0.1774940193,
-0.2206538767,
0.4040521979,
-0.3550820053,
0.4796026945,
0.5363436341,
-0.1346455067,
-0.3210561275,
-0.2481737882,
0.6762018204,
0.3979851305,
-1.204349637,
0.0541931093,
0.7491453886,
0.0585745983,
0.4328601658,
0.7662755847,
-0.0533052422,
0.3533308804,
-0.0779149905,
-0.1082389504,
-0.4038130939,
-0.3267372251,
-0.1473468542,
0.2685065269,
-0.1161431149,
-0.4478429258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16653v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16653v1 | AdaPlanner: Adaptive Planning from Feedback with Language Models | 2023-05-26T05:52:27 | 2023-05-26T05:52:27 | Haotian Sun, Yuchen Zhuang, Lingkai Kong, Bo Dai, Chao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated the potential in
acting as autonomous agents for sequential decision-making tasks. However, most
existing methods either take actions greedily without planning or rely on
static plans that are not adaptable to environmental feedback. Consequently,
the sequential decision-making performance of LLM agents degenerates with
problem complexity and plan horizons increase. We propose a closed-loop
approach, AdaPlanner, which allows the LLM agent to refine its self-generated
plan adaptively in response to environmental feedback. In AdaPlanner, the LLM
agent adaptively refines its plan from feedback with both in-plan and
out-of-plan refinement strategies. To mitigate hallucination, we develop a
code-style LLM prompt structure that facilitates plan generation across a
variety of tasks, environments, and agent capabilities. Furthermore, we propose
a skill discovery mechanism that leverages successful plans as few-shot
exemplars, enabling the agent to plan and refine with fewer task
demonstrations. Our experiments in the ALFWorld and MiniWoB++ environments
demonstrate that AdaPlanner outperforms state-of-the-art baselines by 3.73% and
4.11% while utilizing 2x and 600x fewer samples, respectively. | [
-0.3313036859,
-0.8137804866,
0.784632206,
0.3921922147,
0.1777747869,
-0.107844539,
-0.2889688015,
-0.0980488509,
0.3600943685,
0.4542390704,
-1.0220944881,
-0.3714540005,
-0.0709829181,
0.1701809913,
0.1157080531,
0.6857643127,
-0.1942460835,
-0.2259957641,
-0.0421684235,
-0.0865635648,
-0.7369816303,
-0.1827910095,
-1.0527113676,
-0.3985404074,
0.575769484,
0.7818359137,
0.5956796408,
0.4170758426,
0.2042841613,
0.3811640143,
-0.0887423977,
0.3729610145,
-0.4896767437,
0.3638041914,
-0.2389310598,
-0.2308987528,
-0.6697121859,
-0.506388247,
0.4772278666,
0.5081523657,
-0.3358445764,
0.0134373615,
-0.0720048398,
0.693476975,
-0.4923335314,
0.466622293,
-0.7288463116,
0.0820130482,
0.4572854936,
-0.287252605,
-0.3521832526,
-0.139895454,
-0.0374087095,
-0.6744871736,
0.2096640468,
-0.1101226285,
-0.0875022337,
0.6202497482,
0.1519851536,
-0.5788618326,
-1.0791311264,
0.5396745801,
-0.61093539,
-0.0780854598,
0.1045562029,
0.184541434,
-0.5759548545,
-0.4346549809,
-0.6798964739,
-0.1874650717,
0.0774448439,
0.19366166,
-0.0579003766,
0.0560518764,
0.2868672013,
-0.1298199892,
-0.6861045957,
0.3912861049,
-0.264401108,
0.0068212855,
0.8251357675,
0.3510317206,
-0.009143698,
0.1598998606,
-0.2270781547,
-0.086134702,
-0.5973786116,
0.1199894994,
0.1745712906,
0.469507128,
0.0707126707,
0.3750635982,
-0.3709950745,
0.5230606794,
0.0180273261,
-0.1812295169,
-0.042681478,
-0.1928406358,
-0.2066946626,
0.0807387754,
0.4116738737,
0.1882779449,
0.0894469768,
0.1073953062,
-0.6001109481,
0.0108728753,
0.2588748634,
-0.6426894665,
-0.5992197394,
0.4055116177,
-0.2330394238,
-0.0913393423,
-0.4137988985,
-0.7565063238,
-0.4594834745,
-0.3169431388,
0.3960852921,
-0.2606570423,
-0.0524228215,
0.0248077083,
0.0329073854,
-0.0167321954,
0.7102026343,
-0.6528977156,
0.4479916394,
0.456651628,
0.7743823528,
0.026674863,
-0.5765085816,
-0.6036613584,
0.1326617748,
-0.5155866146,
1.1532629728,
-0.3955048025,
-0.6786233187,
-0.0694227293,
-0.0453293435,
-0.0632473901,
-0.5165213943,
0.3223777711,
-0.5243425965,
0.0343313143,
-0.2783901989,
-0.3278786242,
-0.2484748363,
0.0799377859,
-0.692276299,
0.6453866959,
-0.0799446255,
-0.200419873,
0.440964371,
-1.0477108955,
-0.3748163581,
0.0851574317,
-0.1775391251,
-0.3359968662,
-0.1181770936,
0.3622507751,
0.1674675047,
0.2646078169,
-0.0717356578,
-0.1846042275,
-0.3737072051,
-0.0079537379,
-0.0906117037,
0.4326284826,
0.0928776339,
-0.4108123481,
0.7060801983,
-0.7372395992,
0.0545133092,
0.2155716121,
-0.3512925208,
0.004669833,
0.3325234652,
-0.2982459962,
0.2778903842,
0.0550128631,
-0.2061920464,
0.5055345297,
-0.3748479486,
0.2234081179,
1.1379435062,
0.0947693884,
0.5896530747,
-0.791626215,
0.724663198,
-0.4215303063,
-0.1211001053,
-0.5599006414,
-0.2648853362,
-0.9628763199,
-0.163347736,
-0.3367024362,
0.5090819001,
-0.6820569634,
0.3972793221,
-0.268319726,
-0.2666647434,
-0.2268018872,
0.3315032125,
0.202251032,
0.1738793552,
0.3777555823,
-0.2315237373,
-0.491351068,
-0.3950493038,
0.1323818564,
-0.3427850604,
0.142786622,
0.2604026794,
0.5670776963,
-0.2129267454,
0.8466494679,
-0.5793107152,
-0.4814904928,
-0.4745610356,
0.1156074256,
0.1611592919,
0.2495245188,
0.2944335639,
-0.4633478522,
-0.3225059807,
-0.2110854089,
-0.473534584,
-0.207331121,
-0.5441741347,
0.1055237502,
0.4536950886,
0.5325398445,
-0.6482165456,
0.3473379016,
0.3723829687,
-0.3170240521,
0.6805564165,
-0.5329743624,
-0.479075104,
-0.5949026346,
-0.0781152546,
-0.4397389293,
-0.1884061992,
-0.5215904117,
0.1356741935,
-0.2772119045,
-0.1194405109,
-0.1144429296,
0.8043533564,
-0.6001627445,
-0.1520359218,
-0.7942388654,
-0.0275163446,
-0.2606649399,
0.6597953439,
0.2961480618,
0.8859867454,
0.4155730903,
-0.8313313127,
0.4743055105,
0.5205604434,
-0.0994876325,
0.0559808947,
-0.5153451562,
0.5571690202,
-0.3294231892,
0.6057932973,
-0.8044314384,
-0.11740762,
0.254796356,
-0.1218202412,
0.0574837551,
-0.0657643154,
-0.1792830974,
-0.4239973128,
-0.5236614347,
0.0743923262,
0.4387501478,
-0.6178928614,
0.874080956,
0.1243296787,
-0.7693061233,
-0.1188626587,
-0.4425340295,
0.0677642822,
0.0120417075,
-0.5085753202,
0.1818096042,
-0.525849998,
-0.4718858302,
0.0590056814,
-0.2135309726,
0.192879051,
-0.0079775956,
0.5155814886,
0.146147266,
-0.1223480627,
0.0270954147,
-0.2312596589,
-0.1884102821,
0.1154838055,
-0.3869967759,
0.6232005358,
0.0626498014,
-0.3492251933,
-0.1033144519,
0.3895539343,
0.6025189161,
-0.1218306869,
0.4303138256,
0.0515980311,
-0.1908843368,
-0.8712430596,
-0.3581662178,
-0.2090079188,
-0.499251157,
0.2626247704,
-0.5457236171,
-0.4824480712,
0.4855971336,
-0.1394041628,
0.505433321,
0.0106751518,
0.7831197977,
0.1389046907,
0.9113936424,
0.87891078,
0.1718624532,
0.3908540606,
-0.2720559239,
0.091532059,
-0.635848403,
-0.1625395268,
-0.1410729289,
-0.3750502169,
-0.3793790638,
-0.6290928125,
0.2784078717,
-0.3457478583,
-0.2855471969,
0.1218509227,
-0.2158963978,
0.5030702353,
0.5953638554,
-0.0399347171,
0.3524817228,
-0.2896604538,
-0.0523141772,
0.2850960791,
-0.800786078,
-0.6467807889,
0.8251734376,
0.1896108836,
0.8723890781,
0.0771138445,
0.7533127069,
0.1761363149,
0.2961553633,
-0.807261467,
0.7171363235,
0.164432928,
-0.1974861175,
-0.6468006968,
-0.2440004498,
-0.8016328216,
0.3513109684,
-0.0628315508,
-0.6018463969,
0.3798603415,
0.1801762432,
-0.7189500332,
0.0862837657,
-0.6720711589,
0.5333061814,
-0.3574246764,
-0.3335531354,
-0.4154452085,
-0.3100919724,
0.0766088441,
-0.397962302,
0.4121290147,
-0.2839474082,
-0.1225827932,
0.4116366208,
-0.4886131287,
0.7610316277,
-0.3407121897,
-0.056982778,
0.2547974288,
0.3992764354,
0.9851482511,
-0.0298766196,
-0.2617073357,
-0.5563822985,
-0.3254253864,
-0.2459663749,
-0.4195106626,
0.7626743317,
-0.5311784148,
-0.7863021493,
-0.3617777526,
-0.910811305,
-0.1800785065,
0.2250925153,
-0.0994713455,
0.2917311192,
-0.3404178321,
-0.3528689444,
0.2604454756,
-0.4733965397,
0.8466259837,
0.8905755877,
-0.4634051025,
-0.1066744551,
0.6218722463,
0.0214219894,
0.252725631,
0.1085650697,
0.1029573008,
-0.1494487971,
-0.7843956947,
-0.1281137168,
0.0997704491,
-0.8329684138,
-0.137168467,
-0.5088868737,
-0.1560433805,
-0.3196264207,
-0.3905665278,
-0.2350331992,
-0.3153537214,
-0.0152019672,
-0.1356926113,
0.2666172683,
0.9227836132,
-0.2937517762,
0.1337008923,
-0.4257855415,
0.2906154394,
0.3998265862,
0.0843331665,
0.0456008241,
-0.3257599771,
0.016200969,
-0.072814092,
-0.2609247565,
-0.4607568085,
0.684464097,
0.2405197769,
0.4755078852,
0.2342139035,
0.2504459918,
0.8027091026,
-0.724965632,
0.5303837657,
-0.3160928488,
-0.4624701738,
0.7651227713,
-0.1502572149,
0.6608849168,
0.4845613837,
0.1365490407,
-0.2012044191,
-0.5365376472,
-0.5443980098,
-0.8940530419,
0.6551389098,
0.1150546297,
0.0744959936,
0.2208549827,
0.0946659744,
0.1627494991,
-0.0242214035,
-0.6580225825,
0.0399774015,
-0.0705722049,
0.1633307338,
-0.1296572238,
-0.2762777805,
-0.207512632,
-0.0880370215,
0.593488574,
-0.392729193,
0.2471803576,
0.4022296667,
-0.0973220468,
-0.4482101202,
0.3614091575,
0.7724969387,
0.9250769615,
-0.219090566,
0.0797148943,
0.4491682053,
-0.2803817093,
0.2208649367,
0.3316083848,
-0.2969604731,
-0.0629812926,
0.5515771508,
0.6748458743,
0.1217008904,
-0.9272259474,
0.0861877352,
-0.2111250162,
-0.125502184,
-0.6249907017,
0.2591036856,
-0.0604943186,
0.4791967571,
0.2728048861,
0.2260516733,
-0.0427592695,
-0.5628175139,
0.2356038541,
0.1420709342,
-0.2094272822,
-0.3089816868,
0.5282605886,
0.3820916712,
-0.4217203259,
0.4295045733,
-0.5514124036,
-0.3808416426,
0.6764093041,
0.6351351142,
0.933860302,
-0.2660508454,
0.2070299089,
0.2582035959,
0.3130325675,
-0.0066641401,
0.5316953659,
0.0522363186,
-0.8503359556,
-0.4404021502,
-0.488805145,
-0.3845128417,
0.1686330736,
-0.1921253353,
0.2510263026,
-0.7728871703,
0.1748761684,
-0.1465146095,
0.0411178134,
-0.5134617686,
-0.0145346476,
0.1288547367,
0.9480338097,
-0.5807794929,
0.6746632457,
0.9995805025,
-0.3166184425,
-0.8110494018,
0.2810657322,
0.455684036,
-0.9528654218,
0.571289897,
0.1589306742,
-0.3777271807,
0.0843341127,
-0.1885126978,
-0.8625516891,
1.2423914671,
0.1020596251,
-0.697145462,
-0.1324469447,
-0.4453755915,
0.4218978882,
-0.4240098596,
0.1305881292,
0.5602956414,
0.4351572692,
0.3778885305,
-0.9031427503,
0.2066538781,
-0.1690643132,
0.0213987213,
0.0800772682,
-0.559894681,
0.7038821578,
-0.785228312,
-0.3103200197,
0.3303771317,
0.5699241161,
0.4694963694,
0.2718274891,
0.6242798567,
0.5272818208,
0.8596601486,
0.3174231946,
0.9068540931,
-0.185054034,
-0.0416637324,
1.3606600761,
-0.6353176832,
0.8163803816,
0.1200960353,
-0.0171959773,
0.6163950562,
0.3911519349,
0.0865297467,
0.775311172,
0.042034898,
-0.3900074959,
-0.0434365757,
-0.0060872873,
0.0088012945,
0.379696101,
0.3056875467,
0.0997784957,
-0.2715986371,
0.1382087916,
-0.0063308454,
0.2071157545,
-0.508759141,
1.0418982506,
0.0270161629,
-0.8729251623,
0.3208465576,
-0.1674458236,
0.4380454421,
-0.3977825046,
-0.2422646731,
-0.3316515684,
0.5267020464,
-0.2547507286,
-0.6445609927,
0.3372380137,
-0.1299234331,
-0.118297115,
-0.4331540763,
0.7226333022,
-0.3732764125,
-0.3409872353,
0.267119199,
0.4844004214,
-0.2477160543,
-0.0242364667,
-0.4988098741,
0.1177489832,
-0.096489802,
-0.1547406614,
-0.0568644218,
0.3600381017,
0.0223482847,
0.9978607297,
0.6779076457,
0.4281706512,
-0.0110230464,
0.0125472285,
0.9241004586,
-0.7269982696,
-0.755394578,
-0.6928560734,
0.3231651187,
0.0707225278,
0.0100655118,
0.5529500246,
0.4750695527,
0.8162012696,
-0.1052993387,
0.8239685893,
0.1514590681,
0.4575150907,
-0.7908147573,
0.2516802251,
-0.1754652262,
0.7262297273,
0.0298534986,
-0.9119138122,
-0.0934823975,
0.7014466524,
-0.4925525486,
0.041515328,
0.7009302378,
0.9630343318,
0.2541948557,
-0.1779085845,
0.0507912561,
0.3973408937,
0.507014513,
0.6517105103,
1.0090839863,
0.3162018657,
0.4020151794,
-0.1170281544,
-0.3654809892,
-0.1790833324,
-0.7193675041,
-0.7835904956,
-0.3599091172,
-0.2006522715,
0.0929666311,
0.1423266828,
1.2089487314,
0.5889500976,
-0.7833454609,
-0.4717511237,
-0.4246613979,
0.3066143095,
-0.2799125016,
-0.2033460885,
0.1730176657,
-0.7292699814,
-0.4345907569,
0.8788609505,
0.4245858788,
0.0118534537,
-0.2508005202,
-0.351983726,
0.0086598592,
0.1220528558,
0.5750118494,
0.5427581668,
-0.7547502518,
-0.1858884543,
-0.1613166481,
0.1744801253,
-0.0082227523,
0.8837150931,
-0.9301304817,
0.5334092975,
0.2421256453,
0.3290578127,
0.4370924532,
0.0634487122,
0.7912043333,
-0.6987947226,
0.4245448411,
0.5231052041,
0.2932329774,
0.1079973802,
-0.2202551812,
0.4759221673,
-0.133734405,
-0.7782443762,
-0.5626153946,
0.2766841352,
-0.7630950212,
-0.6415375471,
1.2177318335,
0.1644143015,
-0.0020068053,
-0.1076056212,
-0.5538005233,
-0.3146011531,
-0.5424585938,
0.9556062222,
0.3528311849,
-0.6750332713,
-0.3472461104,
-0.4411101937,
0.6096145511,
0.1029461697,
-0.8552876711,
0.2823929787,
0.773683846,
0.1131632701,
0.234390527,
1.1301833391,
0.3266393244,
0.362796396,
0.0827512294,
0.0179144293,
-0.164835915,
-0.5987188816,
-0.468269825,
-0.1310219616,
0.5710069537,
0.0618788041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16651v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16651v1 | TADA: Task-Agnostic Dialect Adapters for English | 2023-05-26T05:45:03 | 2023-05-26T05:45:03 | Will Held, Caleb Ziems, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models, the dominant starting point for Natural Language
Processing (NLP) applications, fail at a higher rate for speakers of English
dialects other than Standard American English (SAE). Prior work addresses this
using task-specific data or synthetic data augmentation, both of which require
intervention for each dialect and task pair. This poses a scalability issue
that prevents the broad adoption of robust dialectal English NLP. We introduce
a simple yet effective method for task-agnostic dialect adaptation by aligning
non-SAE dialects using adapters and composing them with task-specific adapters
from SAE. Task-Agnostic Dialect Adapters (TADA) improve dialectal robustness on
4 dialectal variants of the GLUE benchmark without task-specific supervision. | [
-0.3983189166,
-0.6466706991,
0.4420786202,
0.377476722,
0.0178152528,
-0.1413450688,
-0.2782568932,
-0.4413965642,
0.5408277512,
0.4067525566,
-0.4832035601,
0.0023748404,
-0.5651250482,
0.2392528504,
-0.0697346106,
0.6452354789,
0.2662908137,
-0.2171322256,
-0.1467197388,
-0.3757386208,
-0.8477780223,
-0.3901766241,
-0.9314628839,
0.0121131837,
0.1946451515,
0.475253731,
0.6734654307,
0.5323140025,
0.2622236907,
0.3393883407,
0.0688037723,
0.2141857892,
-0.1281782687,
0.3441348374,
-0.6813727021,
-0.7038639784,
-0.7244085073,
-0.206961289,
0.4289593995,
0.7180863619,
-0.2281268835,
-0.0896232948,
0.0779138207,
0.7765668035,
-0.5871196985,
0.0444786958,
-1.2672708035,
-0.2090342343,
-0.2134874463,
0.1515597105,
-0.4706260264,
0.0346376263,
0.1018392891,
-0.7515518069,
0.32918185,
0.2493093163,
0.6680102348,
0.1286886483,
-0.4348665178,
-0.1438448131,
-0.6081233025,
0.8483971357,
-0.9096000195,
0.5175057054,
0.2128979862,
0.3765044808,
-0.326962024,
-0.3493116498,
-0.736987412,
-0.0234924424,
0.0963620469,
0.0285701975,
-0.1917965114,
0.1487918496,
0.0087629082,
0.347224772,
-0.5241434574,
0.0975101441,
-0.040054135,
0.0093346853,
0.4114340246,
-0.00824669,
0.3206164241,
-0.1261820048,
-0.0647756904,
0.1962172091,
-0.5748574734,
-0.0939341635,
0.1584444195,
0.8632923961,
-0.0001111409,
0.3483129442,
-0.0518669225,
0.8529015183,
0.5822773576,
-0.0328722745,
0.1397286355,
-0.3129914701,
-0.1776040643,
-0.1812675148,
0.5411817431,
0.2713671923,
0.1914658993,
-0.3314593732,
-0.2485901266,
-0.1112077832,
0.5522152781,
-0.4187972546,
-0.1045363396,
0.3873021305,
0.0447630472,
0.0928769931,
-0.3357759714,
-0.775993228,
-0.2916881442,
-0.2256059349,
0.5948407054,
-0.4444520772,
-0.0930979252,
0.0384314694,
-0.0162098296,
0.2989097238,
0.1777566969,
-1.4385659695,
0.4954057932,
0.6640464664,
0.8668361902,
-0.3833962083,
-0.4727236629,
-0.4177153707,
0.2467062622,
-0.5414664149,
0.7600338459,
-0.4272218645,
-0.2254142016,
0.0140897864,
0.5235285759,
-0.4136134982,
-0.709464848,
0.6867963672,
-0.3534244895,
0.3517936766,
-0.3173286319,
-0.469183892,
-0.139722243,
0.3265998065,
-0.6439003348,
0.8891791701,
0.2903018296,
-0.3654959202,
0.4949055016,
-0.7044315934,
-0.6914196014,
-0.1931460947,
0.2990355492,
-0.2296321243,
0.3920936584,
0.5165398121,
0.4731780887,
-0.1531013995,
0.4305849075,
-0.3217601478,
-0.184213981,
-0.2373941988,
-0.3178096116,
0.7694886923,
-0.0509878844,
-0.295966953,
-0.0135727003,
-0.6936116219,
-0.1282868087,
0.070197776,
-0.0062603275,
-0.4699314237,
0.1148994863,
0.108035624,
0.1222976819,
0.3160769641,
-0.5098125935,
0.1620351225,
-0.6194840074,
0.3319097757,
0.7947049141,
-0.2123404294,
0.5205600262,
-0.5185770392,
0.3655029237,
-0.0159848053,
-0.0952766538,
-0.0828388855,
-0.5157101154,
-0.9482412934,
-0.3154099286,
0.2210905403,
0.6940520406,
-0.9093475342,
0.7587981224,
-0.4113587737,
-0.5749331713,
-0.4654704332,
0.261364758,
0.0970710069,
0.594035089,
0.384429127,
-0.3398528695,
-0.7121841311,
-1.1084802151,
-0.4367429018,
-0.3681191504,
-0.293887943,
0.0823038295,
0.145835489,
-0.1207255423,
0.912307024,
-0.216261521,
-0.2660533786,
-0.3429774642,
-0.0498595536,
0.3461140394,
0.3852275312,
0.9012241364,
-0.4781138599,
-0.7886609435,
0.1916153878,
-0.4081638157,
-0.2989669442,
-0.23826693,
0.023042446,
0.398573488,
0.1589325815,
-0.3702443838,
-0.1649175733,
0.7664811015,
-0.384170264,
0.5153331161,
-0.1640098393,
0.2687552869,
-1.4707528353,
-0.0364211909,
0.1819754094,
-0.4489099979,
-0.9644172192,
0.1278208345,
0.0652222335,
-0.0244702343,
-0.086521104,
0.6831431389,
-0.2098326683,
0.1264310926,
-0.3164369166,
0.0988575295,
0.2549783885,
0.279224962,
0.2048088759,
1.0908093452,
0.5907275677,
-0.3357413411,
0.0996807292,
0.2338613421,
0.1655614227,
0.8570582867,
-0.6169926524,
0.1104362682,
0.1030620337,
-0.1336932182,
-0.8804920912,
-0.2131042033,
-0.2032991797,
-0.1753939837,
0.35553056,
-0.0412316956,
0.1536207646,
-0.0810989141,
-0.4812103808,
0.0856096596,
0.4149208069,
-0.6430250406,
0.8177944422,
0.4409630597,
-0.5879650116,
-0.5129132271,
-0.6533247232,
0.3444459438,
-0.3195606768,
-0.525724411,
0.170964852,
0.0249892827,
-0.224946931,
-0.160177201,
-0.3206931651,
-0.4319606125,
-0.0126622804,
0.0043199509,
0.2259269655,
-0.5055623055,
-0.1949657649,
0.0117798299,
0.0675872341,
-0.0268502552,
-0.2815515101,
0.1771490425,
-0.0387153178,
-0.3615052104,
-0.1218933314,
0.4393784404,
0.7743000984,
0.235190019,
0.8290894628,
0.3123800755,
-0.3214663267,
-0.5379661918,
-0.7377924323,
-0.0389067568,
-0.5450360179,
0.4162508845,
-0.3980735838,
-0.7787691951,
0.4635537565,
0.0665879026,
0.2511463463,
0.45890221,
0.3037567139,
0.0355008841,
0.5542061925,
0.7524058819,
-0.4559438229,
0.3786171079,
0.3961128592,
0.4617164135,
-0.6315897107,
0.3363857865,
-0.6152540445,
-0.1918125153,
-0.386133343,
-0.5018220544,
0.307921499,
-0.1765772551,
-0.0104678096,
0.7805703282,
-0.3864118755,
0.4079863727,
0.4556573331,
-0.0858969539,
0.1887944341,
-0.1545149535,
0.3232005239,
-0.2848339975,
-0.7087379098,
-0.3166683018,
1.1674283743,
0.1555230469,
0.3976798952,
0.2891831398,
0.4313573539,
0.469417423,
-0.0715079457,
-0.809005022,
0.587027669,
-0.5064429045,
-0.6571680903,
-0.322445333,
-0.0584256798,
-0.8004421592,
0.1529732049,
-0.2844757736,
-0.7573951483,
0.4855012894,
0.3497600257,
-0.0789447054,
0.2740237117,
-0.9678053856,
0.8345882893,
0.1355323046,
-0.2413461506,
-0.1181700453,
-0.3162296414,
0.1898889244,
-0.5593059063,
0.4806327224,
0.043656081,
-0.2335113585,
0.4361975193,
-0.378556788,
0.7478473783,
-0.3563446105,
-0.0342670456,
0.1317611039,
0.057025414,
0.7540338039,
-0.1606672853,
-0.3844293058,
0.1046732143,
0.0478960983,
-0.7077894211,
-0.7340766788,
0.6320480108,
-0.4423824847,
-0.9394307137,
-0.2556103766,
-0.780559063,
-0.8983360529,
0.0772890225,
-0.0952256843,
0.2641758919,
-0.2503857017,
0.0843083411,
0.4102957845,
0.3036079407,
0.4144877195,
0.670627892,
0.0173430685,
-0.3611645103,
0.9643658996,
-0.0296031497,
0.5285812616,
0.2238045633,
-0.0090904627,
-0.2615836561,
-0.890801549,
-0.5810890198,
-0.005369443,
-0.5387721062,
0.0964197516,
-0.30029127,
0.010745598,
-0.4736870229,
-0.6279479861,
-0.5149858594,
-0.683473587,
0.1159425378,
0.0810457245,
0.2425619215,
0.5794968605,
0.0595473945,
0.2247714251,
-0.5918765068,
0.4393359423,
0.6339434385,
0.1787121445,
-0.2830230892,
-0.8399270177,
-0.2138062716,
-0.0592752025,
-0.0824816152,
-0.8093830943,
0.2329223156,
0.6547332406,
0.467893362,
0.1758673787,
0.0805226862,
0.7317458987,
-0.7690962553,
1.0942442417,
0.035434626,
-1.1208117008,
0.4744636416,
-0.4758414626,
0.2792518735,
0.7024719119,
0.2522850931,
-0.2986166179,
-0.4526325762,
-0.2290947884,
-0.9136148691,
0.5612745881,
-0.0509347729,
0.2781439722,
-0.1262929738,
0.364852488,
0.195871532,
0.1088256463,
-0.724335134,
-0.0672228783,
-0.2586854398,
-0.324701637,
-0.2638958097,
-0.1335587204,
-0.0164194144,
-0.1901155114,
1.0512449741,
-0.5070667267,
0.0073699406,
0.1317877322,
-0.0070854942,
-0.0682063028,
0.5521903634,
0.0444047935,
0.4607836604,
-0.0599437729,
0.0768196583,
0.4601505995,
-0.5919470191,
0.3998844326,
0.069734171,
-0.3057208657,
0.1968848258,
0.4811786413,
0.6393665075,
0.1129357368,
-0.6213483214,
0.3540395796,
0.2011871785,
-0.0982697532,
0.1085115522,
0.1561158746,
0.2044017762,
0.1257961094,
0.1899214387,
0.2269284874,
0.2034108937,
-0.630758822,
0.2775551677,
0.7805915475,
-0.2770817578,
-0.4789017141,
0.6905566454,
0.3641031981,
-0.3416882157,
-0.1454100311,
-0.2533864081,
-0.1935708374,
0.5057145953,
0.9332316518,
1.0976378918,
-0.5559255481,
0.0296731759,
0.2688247859,
0.4092265069,
-0.0873847604,
0.2378697544,
0.2258183211,
-0.8026467562,
-0.6316741705,
-0.5694605112,
-0.6009942889,
-0.0061459849,
-0.6757172942,
0.2938937545,
-0.3987901509,
-0.1297264397,
0.027490722,
-0.295825839,
-0.3199334443,
0.2484136969,
-0.1143841669,
1.0267704725,
-1.1567989588,
0.9567608833,
0.9399747849,
0.309476167,
-0.6359048486,
0.4528413713,
0.0058440762,
-0.7348040342,
-0.1532395333,
-0.165073514,
-0.0889773741,
-0.1605710089,
0.0491863154,
-0.6254298687,
0.7711238265,
0.5793817043,
-0.5603390932,
-0.0577441491,
0.3247182667,
0.5081188679,
-0.1728936434,
0.0005022666,
0.6242752075,
0.4755384922,
-0.0170381684,
-1.2057628632,
0.1750854254,
-0.2172060162,
0.0519361086,
0.1593976915,
-0.5022091866,
0.592023313,
0.1975836605,
0.1578415781,
-0.0007023349,
0.4933229685,
-0.0419744514,
0.245978415,
0.7981328368,
0.524361968,
0.6651965976,
-0.1364150792,
0.4995309412,
-0.3734309673,
0.0009625084,
1.1804138422,
-0.4789708853,
1.0540326834,
0.6234759688,
-0.6243516207,
0.5030052662,
0.0952015519,
0.2803905606,
0.3111953139,
-0.4046613872,
-0.4755139053,
-0.2482965589,
-0.0230291709,
-0.1180840433,
0.5212463737,
0.4049504995,
0.0963048115,
-0.1498319805,
-0.1247580573,
-0.0128819784,
0.4478277862,
-0.3126401007,
0.7270748615,
-0.1791784465,
-0.7546839118,
0.8495503068,
-0.2487019002,
0.8350418806,
-0.8405163288,
0.2258500457,
-0.0913012177,
-0.000227513,
-0.1982814819,
-0.481148392,
0.887126863,
-0.0758222118,
-0.327932924,
0.0691833198,
0.7005006075,
-0.2530445755,
-0.3864679337,
0.2639815509,
0.6074389219,
-0.2940441668,
-0.1055868044,
-0.5112974644,
-0.1982404441,
0.1166888401,
-0.3305261433,
0.5760940313,
0.4992394745,
0.0496328622,
0.5765823126,
0.4030414224,
0.2362587899,
-0.0589358322,
-0.4684573114,
0.7923333645,
-0.5738437772,
-0.3282759488,
-0.6312550306,
0.5348366499,
-0.0266260728,
-0.0702510029,
1.0221384764,
0.4560672641,
0.4460240901,
-0.1658557206,
0.8913213611,
-0.320428431,
0.5795736313,
-0.4646232128,
0.47785905,
-0.6868205667,
0.2311284244,
-0.1807870269,
-1.0253925323,
-0.1907722056,
0.2907506526,
-0.1227541789,
-0.2651293278,
0.6634048223,
0.7443648577,
-0.2930638492,
0.1000755504,
0.4407869577,
0.3658704758,
0.1728408039,
0.4904188812,
0.1479942948,
-0.2167734504,
0.1869460791,
-0.2998768091,
-0.1337800175,
0.1142768189,
-1.0757457018,
-0.8688043952,
-0.6652220488,
-0.1060219258,
-0.3153456151,
0.3364720047,
0.8098421097,
0.7952073812,
-1.3918287754,
-0.1457852721,
-0.2351183891,
0.0076673697,
-0.4189352691,
-0.2777493298,
0.1496147066,
-0.7183917165,
-1.0646517277,
0.9474728107,
0.3636576831,
-0.1481784582,
-0.106993638,
0.1375404745,
-0.0511931814,
0.5074827075,
0.4861246347,
0.5332045555,
-0.7370761037,
-0.5740453601,
-0.1201430708,
0.2597005963,
0.1810330302,
0.5059373975,
-0.8034140468,
0.6244573593,
0.2126275897,
0.8277035952,
-0.1103862524,
-0.0451940075,
0.8816214204,
-0.9199830294,
0.4836649299,
0.0531867258,
0.5691142678,
0.3014891744,
-0.1768290401,
0.4533459842,
0.3906415999,
-0.6319149137,
-0.7786627412,
0.199585408,
-1.1186676025,
-0.1552104652,
0.859148562,
-0.3884426653,
-0.1225343123,
-0.4989698529,
-0.2314734459,
-0.2407758534,
-0.2923494875,
0.7166193128,
0.7188424468,
-0.0134705277,
0.1160188094,
-0.5987500548,
0.3894603848,
0.715213716,
-0.8470184207,
0.1518548429,
0.3567934334,
0.2874446809,
0.2217640877,
0.5618646145,
0.3706577718,
0.0819276795,
0.2294641435,
-0.1229911372,
0.0995398834,
-0.2103970647,
-0.485648483,
0.1881592721,
0.5084968805,
-0.0698905513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16648v1 | Dramatic Conversation Disentanglement | 2023-05-26T05:39:49 | 2023-05-26T05:39:49 | Kent K. Chang, Danica Chen, David Bamman | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a new dataset for studying conversation disentanglement in movies
and TV series. While previous work has focused on conversation disentanglement
in IRC chatroom dialogues, movies and TV shows provide a space for studying
complex pragmatic patterns of floor and topic change in face-to-face
multi-party interactions. In this work, we draw on theoretical research in
sociolinguistics, sociology, and film studies to operationalize a
conversational thread (including the notion of a floor change) in dramatic
texts, and use that definition to annotate a dataset of 10,033 dialogue turns
(comprising 2,209 threads) from 831 movies. We compare the performance of
several disentanglement models on this dramatic dataset, and apply the
best-performing model to disentangle 808 movies. We see that, contrary to
expectation, average thread lengths do not decrease significantly over the past
40 years, and characters portrayed by actors who are women, while
underrepresented, initiate more new conversational threads relative to their
speaking time. | [
-0.3117001951,
-1.0117738247,
0.2761096656,
0.0466478318,
-0.2011636347,
0.5487741232,
0.0836331323,
0.020791024,
0.3407424688,
0.564735949,
-0.7063935399,
-0.190512687,
-0.8368622661,
-0.2001179755,
-0.6980522871,
0.864669621,
-0.0050306479,
0.183956489,
0.0807353482,
-0.2341427058,
-0.7296330333,
-0.3138506711,
-0.258792609,
-0.2217427343,
0.7683148384,
0.2847689092,
0.8633899093,
0.6034157276,
0.7492492199,
0.3883065283,
-0.1276731938,
0.3490753174,
-0.7280719876,
0.2453629673,
-0.1516752392,
-0.3329943419,
0.0342952646,
0.1578511447,
0.5720272064,
1.024856925,
-0.5195686817,
0.1494555175,
-0.018680796,
0.9432705641,
-0.2688557506,
0.2612812519,
-0.339037627,
0.3422113657,
-0.3810656965,
-0.2655932009,
-0.3143495619,
-0.2849298418,
0.172363013,
-0.1956601888,
0.2710838616,
-0.0237856675,
0.8999304771,
0.3515124619,
-0.7044480443,
-0.0456014015,
-1.3437321186,
0.43238464,
-0.5612373948,
0.2155229896,
0.423873961,
0.4933654368,
-0.1576423943,
-0.6552451253,
-0.5111528039,
-0.1481799185,
-0.002725299,
-0.2100023031,
-0.2832115293,
-0.1163157821,
0.3849555552,
0.6149892807,
-0.354125917,
-0.1543666571,
-0.3634633124,
0.2308187932,
0.4982384741,
0.6438724399,
0.2512105107,
-0.1666917354,
-0.084929198,
-0.1053787097,
-0.2030635625,
-0.1805152148,
0.4252176285,
-0.2154322565,
-0.1578371972,
0.5342347622,
-0.1792676598,
0.2012833655,
0.2729807496,
-0.1272477806,
-0.0841178671,
-0.2736116648,
0.0080534304,
0.0221899226,
0.5191839337,
0.8524773717,
0.2157085091,
0.2069943547,
0.3239849508,
0.1813019216,
0.0672119632,
-0.640709579,
-0.6270592809,
-0.0699665621,
-0.3405025303,
-0.4928718805,
-0.0659124479,
-0.7490408421,
-1.1370464563,
-0.4422411323,
0.1175445542,
-0.3668017685,
-0.4523905516,
-0.0488171019,
-0.4463570714,
0.2389815301,
0.4135376215,
-0.6358733177,
0.2188803852,
0.4573686421,
0.7777439952,
0.066244483,
-0.2076213807,
-0.1203523204,
0.0533306375,
-0.8544005156,
0.4592079818,
-0.4362331629,
-0.072152026,
-0.0219679028,
0.0719929934,
-0.071252048,
-0.3634526432,
-0.0238731131,
-0.2296442389,
0.3328216076,
-0.0379897505,
-0.3416029811,
-0.035282433,
0.3467358053,
-0.815092802,
0.3759830296,
-0.1942814589,
-0.8237683177,
0.2151189297,
-0.3761515021,
-0.2715096474,
-0.2939677536,
-0.3606647253,
-0.2262318432,
0.1142341644,
0.0267253555,
-0.0175943989,
-0.2832270265,
0.6274982691,
-0.1277665645,
-0.4668456912,
0.8182100058,
-0.7811901569,
0.2375550717,
0.1752028167,
-0.1935793757,
-0.3464430869,
-0.4772230089,
-0.5242242813,
-0.0424746163,
0.0090270527,
-0.2277294248,
0.3895504773,
-0.4934548438,
0.1340909749,
-0.0509978421,
-0.2901514769,
-0.1034486666,
-0.2070703059,
0.6206324697,
0.6124481559,
0.3734888732,
0.3080739677,
-0.6064653397,
0.2558532357,
0.6518852711,
0.0499270484,
-0.2923831344,
-0.2694561183,
-1.0685853958,
-0.0865354761,
0.2418964356,
0.4704270065,
-0.8539708257,
-0.0854913667,
0.1264419109,
-0.4276661873,
-0.2250967175,
-0.3929768205,
0.1966121942,
0.1709819585,
0.0341792218,
-0.3135504127,
-0.4177292585,
-0.5837950706,
-0.4373420179,
-0.2342900336,
-0.1263673604,
0.3372869492,
-0.0421853624,
0.0930765867,
0.8420610428,
-0.8227950931,
-0.2805741131,
-0.3141850829,
0.6339625716,
0.3848687112,
0.4454838336,
0.2618979514,
-0.7480118871,
-0.6153879762,
-0.2288637459,
-0.8648678064,
0.3130350113,
-0.2814368904,
-0.1609226465,
0.0272091329,
0.8003479242,
-0.3520950675,
0.6056880355,
0.5267882347,
-0.4700419605,
0.4119628966,
-0.0928135961,
0.5699076653,
-0.9848418236,
-0.4774681628,
0.0746991932,
0.0426072218,
-0.8696583509,
-0.5498747826,
-0.5300050378,
-0.2010271251,
-0.5708634257,
0.0779603794,
-0.4432184994,
0.1364237368,
0.0582904369,
0.2611373365,
0.1150823236,
0.8877120614,
-0.0735936016,
0.2780927122,
0.514251411,
-0.4311562479,
0.3557092547,
0.4889706671,
-0.5729867816,
0.3510979116,
-0.282607764,
0.3554486334,
-0.5295286179,
0.4201380908,
-1.5683950186,
-0.3648823202,
0.07177113,
-0.2109529674,
0.0027248017,
-0.271954596,
-0.147749871,
-0.0442425646,
-0.1967931837,
0.2729783952,
0.4485767186,
-0.0498125255,
0.3937926292,
0.6092472672,
-0.3076434433,
-0.3364085257,
-0.7065877914,
0.1914086193,
-0.685578227,
-0.6066455841,
0.2370782048,
-0.1943392009,
-0.5892803073,
-0.4392478764,
-0.0721083134,
-0.7513420582,
-0.2168373019,
0.2268388122,
0.0817433819,
-0.0768042505,
-0.0262242742,
0.0952124447,
0.1089772359,
-0.1232594922,
0.5381121635,
0.6664643288,
0.2912091911,
-0.3213033378,
-0.5346314311,
0.6919921041,
0.8733400106,
-0.0465898588,
0.719494164,
0.5789326429,
-0.2564745545,
0.2581290603,
-0.4693954289,
-0.1691096425,
-0.4704741836,
0.4832415581,
-0.2157978266,
-0.8593862057,
0.8712255359,
-0.2805373371,
0.1036494076,
-0.0832560807,
0.2466055602,
-0.3405626118,
1.2670207024,
0.4866503775,
0.2353703976,
0.9507340789,
-0.0786601305,
0.5765702128,
-0.7103641033,
-0.0353079699,
-0.0919042975,
-0.7452536821,
-0.5941938758,
-0.6096782684,
0.3728554547,
0.1748934388,
-0.1436074823,
0.2013685852,
-0.1042761654,
0.8272356987,
-0.1001011357,
0.1548332423,
0.4313625991,
-0.2548082769,
0.0974611789,
-0.4904054701,
-0.4663197398,
-0.2774965167,
0.6123330593,
0.5905275345,
0.8879927397,
0.5956537127,
0.1569190472,
0.49863711,
-0.0316880271,
-0.3757089376,
0.7688424587,
-0.389434576,
-0.6309657693,
-0.5233070254,
-0.4719007015,
-0.9748012424,
0.1514985561,
0.0880931988,
-0.6376573443,
0.5375717282,
-0.1201376766,
-0.1800746769,
0.295017153,
-0.5158532858,
0.7313088179,
0.2200099677,
-0.2877219617,
-0.4977183342,
-0.5600572228,
0.6939349771,
0.1337991506,
0.0017692178,
-0.597319603,
0.7491016984,
0.7872837186,
-0.3248012066,
0.9787512422,
-0.0783219635,
-0.0485605448,
0.5265885592,
0.4837807119,
0.3556597829,
0.2275109887,
0.2934371829,
0.3766817749,
0.0095614484,
0.0634351,
-0.3685688972,
0.3088967204,
-0.5591765046,
-0.4981574118,
-0.4005410671,
-0.5590467453,
0.0044857659,
-0.3398523927,
0.2606706321,
0.9142541885,
-0.5271991491,
0.2578231096,
0.7375636697,
-0.1903541088,
0.6921837926,
0.7367824912,
-0.2113851756,
-0.3070349991,
0.7914894819,
0.305280894,
0.2369183451,
0.2972646952,
0.1485170573,
-0.1708532125,
-0.1083822474,
-0.2081710398,
0.2454058677,
-0.4888674915,
-0.0047261282,
-0.3241998851,
-0.3873851299,
-0.169794336,
0.1810119748,
-0.4038969278,
-0.4695033431,
-0.1489365697,
-0.1630593985,
0.3776174486,
0.5606338978,
0.1621458977,
0.2151516974,
-0.7034073472,
0.1938858032,
0.5381969213,
0.1594668627,
-0.1194459721,
-0.7810930014,
-0.4810147583,
0.0052471813,
-0.566762805,
-1.0030395985,
0.5503990054,
0.3576906025,
0.2439042628,
0.5026293993,
0.5683338642,
0.8252170086,
-0.663857162,
0.9770095944,
0.4418722391,
-0.710380137,
0.3115048409,
-0.6535620093,
0.4376510382,
0.3790636957,
0.1817105412,
-1.0793925524,
-0.6273977757,
-0.7061257362,
-0.5981126428,
0.7180801034,
0.2290400267,
0.314308852,
-0.1007394344,
-0.1994075775,
-0.0103032822,
0.666701138,
-0.2191626281,
-0.3987596631,
0.1553301513,
0.05528678,
-0.034792766,
-0.1106823757,
-0.6882563233,
-0.2816079855,
-0.1389681399,
-0.0589255691,
0.3984129429,
0.1066370234,
-0.0199968535,
-0.1850717962,
0.0740075931,
0.4657428265,
0.8578190804,
-0.2741045654,
0.3410899639,
0.0814300328,
-0.4075854123,
0.0355929807,
-0.0949044675,
0.5866298079,
0.3483306468,
0.1631244868,
1.0693922043,
0.1190019995,
-0.4435795248,
0.2540627122,
-0.2944264412,
-0.2684674859,
-0.3161692619,
-0.0161855053,
-0.0307545345,
0.449603796,
0.2238563597,
0.2321178913,
0.1700821966,
-0.9255707264,
0.5541527271,
-0.2647742331,
-0.5124359727,
-0.2050128728,
0.2731892765,
0.4669003487,
-0.5525836349,
0.5784569383,
-0.0219464302,
-0.2180039883,
0.5122105479,
-0.1043289304,
0.8638421893,
-0.3771082163,
0.6519104242,
0.1777765006,
-0.1027192324,
-0.028615525,
-0.3351508677,
0.037540637,
-0.888884306,
-0.3597205877,
-0.0883492008,
-0.6840028167,
0.1879973412,
-0.6560766101,
0.1979121715,
-0.3631448746,
-0.1255281866,
0.1603371948,
-0.2020163387,
-0.0724551529,
-0.3077979386,
0.3399072886,
0.3871749043,
-1.0426158905,
0.7473115325,
0.3466955125,
-0.3615958989,
-0.5292776823,
0.1628797799,
0.1615572274,
-0.1081083864,
0.2635754347,
0.0428681001,
0.158338055,
-0.1506420076,
-0.4029501379,
-0.7267592549,
1.1163864136,
0.3812283576,
-0.6857933402,
-0.1850062311,
0.5485317111,
0.5389603972,
-0.3225169778,
0.4358155131,
1.0159170628,
0.0909757838,
0.3418462276,
-0.9341961145,
-0.450724721,
-0.038939409,
-0.1513246149,
0.5543153286,
-1.0396902561,
0.9087021947,
0.0249439199,
-0.4169929028,
-0.0840478018,
0.4442854226,
0.4017755985,
0.606572926,
0.7391685843,
-0.0578853488,
0.5137779713,
-0.4151047766,
0.3150133789,
-0.0646535233,
0.3056399226,
1.0755659342,
-0.4830397069,
0.485660404,
0.457060039,
-0.2534389794,
0.6529685259,
0.5420542955,
0.4383287728,
0.5485118628,
0.2446104586,
-0.1675689518,
-0.2886406481,
-0.071746394,
-0.1526576728,
0.5323935747,
0.423790127,
-0.1841708124,
-0.2859301567,
0.0868846104,
0.2123720348,
0.1887646168,
0.282830596,
1.0100294352,
0.1756418645,
-0.6458811164,
0.4761841297,
-0.2944134772,
0.0928513482,
-0.6790909171,
-0.4471881688,
-0.8254211545,
0.2281857878,
0.0718479753,
-0.8109764457,
0.3674502075,
-0.0925664976,
-0.1939246207,
-0.060894683,
0.3246189356,
-0.8730905056,
-0.1570413709,
-0.0919620693,
0.2547924221,
0.5183037519,
0.1578903198,
-0.750158608,
0.1314866543,
0.3321443796,
-0.1548398137,
0.4327079058,
0.9347345233,
-0.0860828832,
0.467685014,
0.3457859755,
-0.2415234149,
0.1868055016,
0.2081399709,
0.8057823777,
-0.7925086617,
-0.6616490483,
-0.5355027914,
1.0195640326,
-0.2096571475,
-0.501953721,
0.5706501007,
0.066799283,
0.2958219349,
-0.1386117786,
0.1471084803,
-0.2463559806,
0.4511074722,
-0.5087456107,
0.5890215039,
-0.0532105453,
0.4963882864,
-0.4953457713,
-0.8935136199,
0.2359185666,
0.5010674,
-0.0807580724,
-0.3129270375,
0.9228564501,
0.8713313937,
0.3603504002,
0.097919479,
0.5801945329,
0.2481668741,
0.5555053949,
0.4250842035,
1.3055955172,
-0.5230779648,
0.4862021804,
0.0896339566,
-0.2092549801,
-0.3381582499,
-0.7607395053,
-0.7993737459,
-0.8099368215,
-0.9247452617,
-0.0567877665,
0.0707130358,
0.3570541143,
0.6865054369,
-0.3160621524,
-0.4685655832,
-0.2244151831,
0.2351985574,
-0.5785069466,
-0.274030596,
-0.056289386,
0.0747951865,
-1.0171817541,
0.6638439894,
0.0820634067,
-0.1034745947,
-0.4957179427,
0.1100875735,
-0.4047838748,
0.6374502182,
0.3350645006,
0.1386600584,
-0.2935167253,
-0.1834168285,
-0.4335181713,
0.0215078574,
0.2041437775,
0.8409726024,
-0.4398400784,
0.3690375686,
0.7156785131,
-0.1000926942,
0.5315486193,
0.1215614751,
0.7383403778,
-1.0345087051,
0.4021627307,
0.0093893958,
0.0911433995,
0.1768580675,
-0.31445086,
0.4719939232,
0.3113044202,
-0.7150744796,
-1.184340477,
0.3464892209,
-0.9119261503,
-0.2190415412,
0.7732716799,
-0.0190852862,
0.0007908117,
-0.1226584986,
-0.3432310224,
0.2438196838,
-0.4731485844,
0.7901061177,
0.9406535625,
-0.5011160374,
-0.4042520523,
-0.429677844,
0.6239680648,
0.2039182484,
-0.4434909523,
0.4998820424,
0.5351835489,
-0.0125789559,
0.5080375075,
0.3986594975,
-0.2787000835,
-0.1275006086,
0.0907852873,
-0.2754069269,
0.1904722601,
-0.7202556133,
-0.1327795386,
0.0109428614,
-0.1127529293,
-0.4810832143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16646v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16646v2 | Language Models Can Improve Event Prediction by Few-Shot Abductive Reasoning | 2023-05-26T05:32:29 | 2023-10-08T03:27:20 | Xiaoming Shi, Siqiao Xue, Kangrui Wang, Fan Zhou, James Y. Zhang, Jun Zhou, Chenhao Tan, Hongyuan Mei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models have shown astonishing performance on a wide range of
reasoning tasks. In this paper, we investigate whether they could reason about
real-world events and help improve the prediction performance of event sequence
models. We design LAMP, a framework that integrates a large language model in
event prediction. Particularly, the language model performs abductive reasoning
to assist an event sequence model: the event model proposes predictions on
future events given the past; instructed by a few expert-annotated
demonstrations, the language model learns to suggest possible causes for each
proposal; a search module finds out the previous events that match the causes;
a scoring function learns to examine whether the retrieved events could
actually cause the proposal. Through extensive experiments on several
challenging real-world datasets, we demonstrate that our framework -- thanks to
the reasoning capabilities of large language models -- could significantly
outperform the state-of-the-art event sequence models. | [
-0.2237431556,
-0.7001526952,
0.8346745968,
-0.0909033939,
-0.0938903391,
-0.3000513911,
-0.3049644828,
-0.9332789779,
-0.0643863231,
0.2563342154,
-0.5903514028,
-0.330581218,
-0.2876029611,
0.1224371716,
-0.8139711022,
0.5696977973,
0.3042727113,
-0.1800991148,
0.1730082035,
0.2142053843,
-0.3167953491,
-0.3649890721,
-0.613915801,
-0.4718922377,
0.6263778806,
0.6236932874,
0.7767730355,
0.5793975592,
0.689299345,
0.2065797746,
0.1519138366,
0.2097632438,
-0.5199368596,
0.1146069318,
-0.3656514585,
-0.5129267573,
-0.1617521644,
-0.2690793872,
0.3337034583,
0.6138878465,
-0.200393945,
-0.1149984375,
-0.4592264891,
0.4570528269,
-0.5695199966,
0.0155817736,
-0.7531985641,
0.0194104239,
-0.1493157446,
-0.2243632078,
-0.8768081069,
-0.3183364868,
0.08083722,
-0.428526938,
0.1501745284,
0.2734500766,
0.7331379652,
-0.0938420743,
0.0251064114,
0.0520241633,
-0.8476979733,
0.7059080005,
-0.7964413166,
0.4284773171,
0.3387470543,
0.3767284453,
-0.2863433361,
-0.5821480155,
-0.9029091001,
-0.1696064025,
-0.036058493,
-0.280957371,
-0.0002823799,
0.1599557102,
0.463924557,
-0.2225649804,
-0.9519813657,
0.325938642,
-0.206139043,
0.2571108341,
0.7427908182,
0.3878904581,
0.4806948006,
-0.344211489,
-0.0266784988,
0.1548153758,
-1.0705159903,
-0.2068585604,
0.1818509996,
0.316755563,
-0.0880595297,
0.4539242089,
-0.3495331705,
0.6984688044,
-0.177480191,
0.059995804,
-0.2472025901,
0.1456010789,
-0.2144591063,
0.1129962504,
0.2996915281,
0.517721653,
0.6180405617,
-0.3914917707,
0.116609022,
0.3317053616,
-0.0754200965,
-1.0640497208,
-0.6176909804,
0.5240507126,
-0.5807366371,
-0.2456142753,
0.2038099468,
-0.6990298033,
-0.5656471848,
-0.2824168205,
0.1497634202,
-0.5778343678,
-0.482781738,
0.4811349511,
-0.2582838833,
0.2422302663,
0.6312100291,
-0.6440785527,
-0.0537106022,
1.0682173967,
0.6585125923,
-0.2486575693,
-0.3846079111,
-0.8465561271,
0.0506831631,
-0.4898312986,
0.8548742533,
-0.8462838531,
-0.1385701746,
0.2206515521,
-0.1679187864,
0.2840883732,
-0.3372836709,
0.4008617699,
-0.7069329619,
0.10845045,
-0.0407123081,
-0.7030848861,
-0.1046049818,
-0.0563762002,
-0.6184950471,
0.6623289585,
-0.4207542539,
-0.5393477082,
0.4885434806,
-0.4962295592,
-0.5892149806,
0.2068244368,
-0.2598719895,
-0.2417345196,
0.278499037,
0.121298559,
0.4685905576,
-0.198193863,
0.5248952508,
-0.487827301,
-0.3515947461,
0.5261163116,
-0.2068970948,
0.4244056344,
0.1619947404,
-0.2451057881,
0.0787583217,
-1.1153736115,
0.0086823395,
0.0476858504,
-0.1252965182,
-0.1771959215,
0.3740004003,
0.3311011791,
0.2233180255,
-0.2790178657,
-0.5308096409,
0.4932195544,
-0.8561947346,
0.1873859018,
0.6397404671,
-0.0038636443,
0.6240386367,
-0.0728285834,
0.5524526834,
-0.1972698867,
-0.1209900603,
-0.6591505408,
-0.6450207829,
-0.5793043971,
0.0018686313,
-0.0515131429,
0.5488221645,
-0.785962522,
0.1767935604,
-0.2256150544,
-0.3631308377,
-0.0498422459,
-0.1928783506,
0.328147769,
0.3758664727,
0.1401606947,
0.1964947432,
-1.0895599127,
-0.4177309573,
-0.5184472203,
-0.5216638446,
0.0481814221,
-0.0786821768,
0.4744817019,
0.0095414845,
0.9618777633,
-0.5663955808,
0.1193777472,
-0.5876931548,
0.394251585,
0.3549553752,
0.3530345857,
0.4995909035,
-0.7568003535,
-0.0524846651,
0.2415753901,
-0.7270545363,
-0.1168355718,
-0.194802925,
-0.1095208004,
0.4068657756,
0.2024152726,
-0.6353855729,
0.790812552,
0.2343902141,
-0.5396798253,
0.8686134219,
0.1248975992,
0.1529623121,
-0.6622270942,
-0.0544790886,
-0.2427900136,
-0.2262113392,
-0.617182374,
0.1340394318,
0.1657599211,
-0.2978526652,
-0.4691442549,
0.7709078193,
-0.1599872559,
-0.0597136803,
-0.6777626276,
0.198759228,
0.0926512852,
0.0170834623,
0.6304186583,
0.4534142315,
0.6015337706,
-0.8282745481,
0.5319840312,
0.3634266257,
-0.9711755514,
0.2114270926,
-0.4099821448,
-0.1169087663,
-0.2373719066,
-0.0229758639,
-1.0199979544,
-0.4444361031,
-0.3279204965,
-0.5926341414,
0.0368775278,
-0.061337024,
-0.4356211722,
-0.491556555,
0.059016481,
0.240181163,
0.3470537663,
-0.8460552692,
0.5999076962,
-0.077669844,
-0.1057212874,
-0.561602056,
-0.9781609178,
0.2067004889,
-0.0863998979,
-0.7666271329,
0.1866790205,
0.0843612477,
-0.5768286586,
-0.0190802738,
0.1572057009,
0.023002604,
0.0653441399,
0.3018904328,
0.3413451612,
-0.3876136243,
0.6408765912,
-0.4319490194,
-0.4062940478,
-0.1079692766,
-0.4660815299,
0.4479318857,
0.0532200933,
-0.6349995732,
-0.6337189078,
0.4153191149,
0.3802453578,
-0.1133713648,
0.8884333968,
0.1763235182,
-0.5456227064,
-0.4747212827,
-0.7429704666,
-0.5172279477,
-0.3956900239,
0.5460861921,
-0.4410825372,
-0.6047230959,
0.6130743623,
-0.0306721684,
0.018607961,
0.0479114838,
0.4637482464,
-0.06567128,
1.195769906,
0.5164230466,
-0.0519562885,
0.632813096,
-0.1948354244,
0.5360555649,
-0.2880711555,
-0.0229138434,
-0.4548669755,
-0.3495787084,
-0.0112904878,
-0.4736302197,
0.1409415752,
0.0224676076,
-0.1261361986,
0.3701189756,
-0.1415911615,
0.8139909506,
0.2171752155,
-0.1572583318,
0.5333139896,
-0.2453321218,
0.1574566215,
0.1154397428,
-0.779081583,
-0.6187523603,
0.7721375227,
0.0425241664,
1.174857378,
0.1425507814,
0.5555346012,
0.1439774334,
0.2639244795,
-0.5654514432,
0.4811736345,
0.2262388915,
-0.7596513629,
-0.4270402491,
-0.310803473,
-0.8380093575,
0.317548126,
-0.0834556967,
-1.0193016529,
0.5463353992,
0.1295304745,
-0.465820998,
0.3672382236,
-0.4476896226,
0.7920603156,
-0.3052224815,
-0.3887889385,
-0.5344645977,
-0.2640357614,
0.3747627139,
0.2938053012,
0.5967327356,
-0.3746773303,
0.2364806384,
0.5901422501,
-0.3654750884,
0.9157482982,
0.1283904761,
-0.0500522032,
0.3781217337,
0.583140552,
0.8677013516,
0.1863912344,
-0.6486927271,
-0.3546886146,
-0.0960001275,
-0.0904553458,
-0.5866855383,
0.7097659111,
-0.4098640978,
-0.52334553,
0.0022497796,
-0.2108159214,
-0.0696054697,
-0.238045916,
0.3842327595,
0.7806784511,
-0.2883688509,
0.0274493359,
0.5722341537,
-0.1093325317,
0.8434401155,
0.7377277613,
-0.7463209629,
0.0441471748,
0.4557138979,
-0.1489295512,
0.1897903383,
0.5230924487,
0.2120191306,
-0.0807367116,
-0.392801553,
-0.4991218746,
-0.0508019328,
-0.8551210165,
-0.5499871969,
-0.6352298856,
0.2022499889,
-0.3480869234,
-0.5317543149,
-0.3086304665,
-0.8436284661,
-0.1157297269,
-0.7263348103,
0.6177304387,
0.6296139359,
-0.0948287398,
0.428620398,
-0.7013300657,
0.3791361451,
-0.0599736422,
0.5038983822,
0.3190217018,
-0.5495855808,
-0.1453012526,
-0.4639385343,
-0.0804303661,
-1.175814867,
0.5709291697,
0.4574646354,
0.409471482,
0.8003008962,
0.2140231431,
0.756765902,
-0.6842038035,
0.606475234,
0.3596143425,
-0.8178089857,
1.0807921886,
-0.2630300224,
0.2219940424,
0.1437287182,
0.2481263727,
-0.6222457886,
-0.3936661482,
-0.7181372046,
-0.5360424519,
0.9498399496,
-0.0303558875,
-0.1032767743,
-0.2885598838,
0.4088895917,
0.3136323392,
-0.0673741475,
-0.8916241527,
-0.0574529208,
0.3094160259,
-0.0608990416,
0.1308095753,
-0.3096422553,
0.1950059533,
-0.2551164031,
0.6647940278,
-0.0772554278,
-0.1567492783,
0.0231599286,
-0.1327575594,
-0.6199556589,
0.1871077418,
0.3306868672,
1.175100565,
0.0239949692,
0.2262156457,
0.2741355896,
0.1491355002,
-0.0329857282,
-0.0072334325,
-0.0674547851,
0.0772031322,
0.7023869157,
0.6362906098,
0.5177920461,
-1.1156647205,
0.4426487088,
0.0778539628,
0.1922195256,
-0.3040597737,
0.082661666,
0.0965261832,
0.3407995105,
0.5519551039,
-0.2267811596,
0.2522839606,
-0.7909626961,
0.5026726127,
0.2119969726,
0.0848207474,
-0.4515622854,
0.670596242,
0.4227852225,
-0.3602871895,
0.5296772718,
-0.2454041094,
-0.6558427811,
0.8392418623,
0.6934674382,
0.476321876,
-0.3686513007,
0.1551528573,
0.6214894056,
0.225974068,
-0.2257073671,
0.5516465306,
0.3204545081,
-0.819789052,
-0.9146458507,
-0.7632244229,
-0.3251359165,
-0.0175934639,
-0.1503670961,
0.5403075814,
-0.2121456712,
0.0692072958,
0.0620989241,
-0.2956048846,
-0.6088395119,
-0.0024856741,
0.4925991893,
1.0434629917,
-1.0088882446,
0.8129118085,
0.5540917516,
-0.5910890102,
-0.4388926625,
-0.2527486682,
0.0077888384,
-0.6258206964,
0.9598533511,
0.3511398435,
-0.0901449248,
-0.2404473573,
-0.4480378032,
-1.1301726103,
0.3772344291,
0.3701734245,
-0.9158605933,
-0.1244832054,
-0.1331504434,
0.3027225435,
-0.4294304848,
0.11937996,
0.5288711786,
0.4959141314,
0.287460655,
-0.9330385923,
-0.1132224053,
0.1593054235,
-0.0143464971,
0.4211009443,
0.0625964329,
0.5531526208,
-0.7792335749,
-0.4408708215,
0.4396860898,
0.9296188951,
0.2131008804,
0.6086537838,
-0.0116526959,
0.4175477922,
0.8389825225,
-0.2207375914,
1.2966800928,
-0.0365411639,
0.1738991588,
1.1549766064,
-0.5873688459,
1.1354511976,
0.0937158391,
-0.2096489519,
0.7943681479,
0.1834074259,
0.4170934558,
0.5193727016,
0.1456543803,
-0.16579099,
-0.794844389,
0.243488431,
-0.3281981647,
0.5053092241,
0.5971406698,
-0.2246806771,
-0.3471343219,
0.5999826789,
-0.2044138014,
0.2846047878,
-0.3574512005,
0.749771595,
0.0681719482,
-0.7420657277,
0.3576605618,
0.0783695877,
0.3569926918,
-0.3213668764,
-0.2254340947,
-0.0472623222,
0.5766465664,
-0.3763681352,
-0.6706770062,
0.3978620172,
-0.0971852764,
-0.099799186,
0.0858531296,
0.9128085971,
-0.3236915767,
-0.516469717,
0.2454176098,
0.5195217729,
0.0762016699,
-0.1947942674,
-0.1612753421,
0.4037178755,
-0.3103349805,
-0.2329813093,
0.1835608035,
0.6966980696,
-0.0833321735,
0.9480315447,
0.4443683326,
0.1883227825,
0.0375225917,
0.2484538853,
0.5190235376,
-0.8886198401,
-0.6195672154,
-1.1436446905,
0.3574717641,
-0.2021835893,
-0.0145745734,
0.2765173912,
0.6447762251,
0.6289734244,
-0.2154716849,
0.727568686,
-0.050501775,
0.6328280568,
-0.4764086306,
0.2497548461,
-0.2598176897,
0.2067348957,
0.0092505505,
-0.4808440804,
-0.4961737692,
0.9455472827,
-0.6267679334,
-0.2675559819,
0.4898175299,
0.7283842564,
0.114446871,
0.4664332867,
0.6043625474,
0.2208543122,
0.4609712362,
0.5910662413,
1.2559216022,
-0.0107473563,
0.5075462461,
-0.0811625868,
-0.1519296169,
-0.8723607659,
-1.1770117283,
-0.7675350308,
-0.6431066394,
-0.3918005228,
-0.0439046733,
0.3403087556,
0.9954763651,
0.7855188847,
-1.1446670294,
-0.1516077965,
-0.2420929968,
0.3131787777,
-0.2825428545,
-0.2820497453,
0.2867308557,
-0.5549800396,
-0.553108871,
0.4782732725,
0.431622684,
-0.3064624071,
0.0681311935,
0.1051710695,
-0.2967886031,
0.1450115889,
0.8624312282,
0.3464027941,
-0.9659053087,
-0.673853159,
-0.339730233,
0.1347660422,
-0.1965770125,
0.8098413348,
-1.0894664526,
0.1886568218,
0.6185896993,
0.5285746455,
0.2443921715,
-0.0471746325,
0.7439050078,
-0.7298540473,
0.3678766787,
0.3451271057,
0.680198729,
0.136640504,
-0.4836296737,
0.739014864,
0.0479285568,
-0.4130449593,
-0.9351882935,
0.6209130883,
-0.6574989557,
-0.5973592997,
1.1844549179,
0.1339540482,
-0.0535182245,
-0.1593414694,
-0.2553830147,
-0.1080218777,
-0.2079875767,
0.9400817156,
0.8115137219,
-0.6072720289,
-0.4994434714,
-0.3787609041,
0.6643550396,
0.3804720342,
-0.7334436178,
0.6213383675,
0.7981845737,
-0.1058194414,
0.1247037724,
0.4068233967,
0.0495874323,
0.7947998047,
-0.2269972414,
0.0204741526,
0.0492985062,
-0.6656408906,
-0.1827461571,
0.33400172,
0.3411061764,
0.1803227216
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.