id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.00013v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.00013v2 | Machine Learning Approach for Cancer Entities Association and Classification | 2023-05-30T07:36:12 | 2023-06-24T07:12:20 | G. Jeyakodi, Arkadeep Pal, Debapratim Gupta, K. Sarukeswari, V. Amouda | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | According to the World Health Organization (WHO), cancer is the second
leading cause of death globally. Scientific research on different types of
cancers grows at an ever-increasing rate, publishing large volumes of research
articles every year. The insight information and the knowledge of the drug,
diagnostics, risk, symptoms, treatments, etc., related to genes are significant
factors that help explore and advance the cancer research progression. Manual
screening of such a large volume of articles is very laborious and
time-consuming to formulate any hypothesis. The study uses the two most
non-trivial NLP, Natural Language Processing functions, Entity Recognition, and
text classification to discover knowledge from biomedical literature. Named
Entity Recognition (NER) recognizes and extracts the predefined entities
related to cancer from unstructured text with the support of a user-friendly
interface and built-in dictionaries. Text classification helps to explore the
insights into the text and simplifies data categorization, querying, and
article screening. Machine learning classifiers are also used to build the
classification model and Structured Query Languages (SQL) is used to identify
the hidden relations that may lead to significant predictions. | [
-0.0264799576,
-0.8182534575,
0.5301926732,
-0.1584447771,
-0.0431104042,
-0.0010749695,
0.2073319554,
-0.4827136099,
0.0886607766,
0.8254178166,
-0.508356452,
-0.6424741745,
-0.8558017612,
0.2873533368,
-0.3928044736,
0.9363278151,
0.3441690803,
0.4249125123,
-0.3023980856,
-0.1490039676,
-0.2646678984,
-0.3164511025,
-1.2698909044,
-0.3693260252,
0.7014308572,
0.291963011,
0.3102209568,
0.6743445992,
0.9169985056,
0.3253799975,
-0.1012458429,
0.2613012195,
-0.3294539154,
0.3569849432,
-0.1343715042,
-0.5941399336,
0.0592569523,
-0.1202209815,
0.0619945116,
0.8064554334,
0.0257259402,
-0.1244420484,
0.2030719668,
0.9434273839,
-0.3581169844,
0.2143314332,
-0.6509249806,
0.3941094875,
-0.2172169536,
-0.2733692229,
-0.2370053977,
-0.606695354,
0.237965703,
-0.567447722,
0.1862434596,
0.0040089544,
0.6536313891,
0.4116155505,
-0.823222816,
-0.9067635536,
-0.5466209054,
0.7255724669,
-0.4743843377,
0.1674843729,
0.3314955831,
0.4005303383,
-0.5797784925,
-0.7529204488,
-0.3190146983,
-0.2390215397,
-0.17873393,
-0.0082171876,
-0.0648099631,
0.3082945049,
0.2510170341,
0.3231472969,
-0.6084728241,
0.3042768836,
-0.4131689072,
-0.3585093915,
0.8019831777,
0.2417251915,
0.6063263416,
-0.3720328808,
-0.3032224476,
0.0357306786,
-0.6124432087,
0.0170438271,
0.0675739348,
0.2601289451,
0.3543587327,
0.5264720917,
-0.2411408871,
0.7204521894,
0.0229704734,
-0.3394177258,
0.105396226,
-0.3693433404,
-0.3609280586,
0.3204590678,
1.0404478312,
0.2925879657,
-0.1490558535,
0.0623790249,
0.466324836,
-0.0012451125,
0.1953035891,
-0.9573692083,
-0.1856374145,
0.387598604,
-0.7172136903,
-0.3306742907,
-0.1448126435,
-1.007856369,
-0.53525877,
0.0727058873,
0.2274026275,
-0.5325485468,
0.0980649441,
-0.1138927117,
0.0573101975,
0.0030022289,
0.2523682117,
-0.5603376627,
0.4011032283,
0.6652104855,
0.9442106485,
-0.1370958686,
0.3036618829,
-0.4784590602,
0.1156977415,
-0.1873123795,
0.7992423773,
-0.587115109,
-0.4344770312,
-0.3142403662,
0.1948784739,
-0.2604769766,
-0.4198925793,
0.8396615982,
-0.4499504864,
0.6472916007,
-0.1313744485,
-0.8515431285,
-0.7219574451,
0.1180754006,
-0.8599928617,
0.7856112719,
0.2016092688,
-1.0148276091,
0.6141914725,
-0.8696657419,
-0.3839650452,
0.2007561475,
-0.1092433408,
-0.9082354307,
-0.0769094303,
0.1308028847,
0.7198578715,
-0.3353899419,
0.2727946043,
-0.3251958191,
-0.0873109996,
0.0634431094,
0.2060090005,
0.8271923065,
0.5488123298,
-0.268252939,
-0.0377852879,
-0.6985089779,
0.0904653892,
0.0353800468,
-0.2174877822,
-0.5401722789,
0.2444061488,
-0.0215061586,
0.3507295549,
-0.1069538966,
-0.5188636184,
0.2089218348,
-0.5354679823,
0.2915425003,
0.2255423516,
0.5644042492,
0.1590636373,
-0.1961665303,
0.3332433105,
0.2175513804,
-0.0397986919,
0.0578949526,
-0.9047210217,
-0.3835258186,
-0.0626939014,
0.6596983671,
0.9310404658,
-0.6832689047,
0.4710031748,
0.2650996745,
-0.6639709473,
-0.3992275894,
0.0705611333,
0.5072340965,
0.7469194531,
0.3377015293,
-0.3167412579,
-0.9800789952,
-0.8053889275,
-0.2527578771,
-0.1047969759,
-0.045753479,
0.3939816654,
0.4885481894,
-0.3794561327,
0.6369560361,
-0.5917944908,
-0.6759082675,
-0.1557939947,
0.0837280974,
0.2168344259,
0.4493029714,
0.1616136879,
-1.0765068531,
-0.5271333456,
0.2916357517,
-0.9781775475,
-0.1620004922,
0.0352724604,
-0.1268057376,
0.153030619,
0.5019892454,
-0.1772101671,
0.6198869944,
0.2716439366,
-0.2270505577,
-0.0323761553,
-0.1298327446,
0.3316759169,
-1.1758010387,
0.0662822947,
0.2910778821,
-0.1206454337,
-0.6579176188,
-0.4094438851,
-0.2163518369,
-0.0821415707,
-0.0594885908,
0.3737524152,
-0.461966902,
-0.1056674495,
-0.4368580878,
-0.3197516203,
0.0151049672,
0.0654990897,
0.099381417,
0.359190464,
0.4719852209,
-0.9288524389,
0.3290254474,
0.22408548,
-0.3493314981,
0.2796866298,
-0.5697888732,
-0.1562105268,
-0.2825059891,
0.1620046794,
-0.7261125445,
-0.2257313728,
0.3920794725,
-0.6929784417,
0.3857738674,
-0.1822676361,
-0.2717531621,
-0.5587075353,
0.0619108975,
-0.3129143119,
0.4296186864,
0.0500162952,
0.5335041881,
0.8137003183,
-0.2449424267,
-0.5697156191,
-0.7457811832,
-0.1491618305,
-0.3388506174,
-0.4712384939,
0.3265790045,
0.1631902754,
-0.2375116199,
0.0993247256,
0.2122029811,
-0.3600874841,
0.23088938,
0.4661290646,
-0.0064081042,
-0.164992854,
0.3770931661,
0.2175866812,
-0.2597257197,
-0.0697265491,
-0.1172547117,
0.2017089278,
0.2463267446,
-0.2424274385,
-0.5737274885,
0.538020432,
0.4205735028,
0.0389860757,
0.8328868747,
0.65252918,
-0.6496795416,
0.1431715786,
-0.3159797192,
-0.1186714694,
-0.3275501132,
0.4649962187,
-0.123195909,
-0.6967971325,
0.3327173889,
-0.3162418306,
-0.1388127059,
0.7620381117,
0.8458506465,
-0.0229558423,
0.9508575797,
0.7935600877,
-0.1157731563,
0.1497909576,
-0.1345205605,
0.2240687758,
-0.5398378968,
-0.6774112582,
-0.7995309234,
-0.1976449937,
-0.7600106597,
-0.5001609325,
0.5238348246,
0.0202024393,
0.0088856965,
0.4871195555,
-0.9825239778,
0.1843206733,
0.4227633774,
0.2455900311,
0.4040666819,
0.0389852263,
-0.219624728,
-0.0606632046,
-0.6343184114,
-0.5619647503,
1.3949157,
0.2061548829,
0.4632195234,
0.0483352318,
0.7317677736,
0.37531811,
0.1152951717,
-0.7978870869,
0.3405670524,
-0.1854667217,
-0.71046561,
-0.3994008303,
-0.5696855783,
-1.3529999256,
0.0178204663,
-0.3523299992,
-0.6453220844,
0.1938075274,
-0.1222299859,
-0.2795242667,
0.3386726081,
-0.5547856688,
0.752517581,
-0.2828436792,
-0.0878531113,
0.1588193476,
-0.7566981912,
0.3110041916,
-0.1914422959,
0.3465970755,
0.0389537252,
-0.1195375174,
1.0728706121,
-0.3097350597,
0.4799664617,
-0.1695889086,
0.3896853924,
0.3412799239,
-0.0912251472,
0.2600858808,
0.1887694299,
-0.3002925813,
0.0476734526,
0.0231884755,
-0.3403446376,
-0.3910604715,
0.5722050667,
-0.5567786098,
-0.0585346371,
-0.5590165854,
-0.2660290897,
-0.0594715104,
0.2182010263,
0.4998298585,
0.1173613667,
-0.2034723908,
0.1964531541,
0.9716305733,
-0.2764866054,
0.2712810636,
0.3733374178,
-0.2548995614,
-0.2050586641,
0.7290062308,
0.1506441534,
-0.2281477153,
0.7699756622,
0.3335615098,
-0.2928145528,
-0.781162262,
-0.2146007121,
-0.1166176125,
-0.3315438926,
-0.3891882002,
-1.312718153,
-0.1674506664,
-0.4952286184,
0.1788431704,
0.0147892321,
-0.1203061566,
-0.5744598508,
-0.1648062617,
0.5989923477,
0.6219553351,
-0.087251842,
0.0686912239,
-0.8233832717,
0.2613044679,
0.1710006595,
0.0322067738,
-0.2457187474,
-0.171305865,
-0.1733764708,
-0.1227687746,
-0.4060581326,
-1.2390220165,
0.6315084696,
0.5532627702,
0.786370635,
0.4917877018,
-0.2174619287,
0.3368679285,
-0.2259151936,
0.3908936083,
0.2593071759,
-0.4911712706,
0.9194515347,
-0.204284057,
-0.1867650002,
0.6249810457,
1.0182507038,
-0.5697066784,
0.0127844801,
-0.7303540707,
-0.6313247085,
0.6331762075,
0.3339979351,
-0.4291449785,
0.082381703,
0.2797277272,
0.3155584037,
0.1508834362,
-0.4938232303,
-0.3795608878,
-0.0391776673,
-0.3946768641,
0.0466024354,
-0.2830381691,
-0.106252186,
-0.058335036,
0.886785686,
-0.2791919112,
0.4967921674,
0.3690089285,
-0.0445234105,
-0.1048790514,
0.2795128226,
0.333170712,
0.2010557801,
-0.2429418266,
-0.2487811744,
0.1565432847,
-0.5722279549,
0.0440236777,
0.0464563407,
-0.1927332729,
0.0944031179,
0.3716401756,
0.497203052,
-0.1511909813,
-0.4726391435,
0.2646499574,
-0.0345516205,
-0.268132627,
-0.2558941841,
0.1893689483,
0.1408654302,
0.0511894375,
0.5013715625,
0.1593186259,
0.7383603454,
-0.6304671168,
0.4929775,
0.4378544092,
-0.8861379623,
0.2124953121,
0.3184189796,
0.033758264,
-0.2392846793,
0.5302245021,
-0.100415796,
-0.5419533253,
0.9744997621,
0.3866808116,
0.4965231717,
-0.3271656036,
0.219962582,
0.7232362628,
0.1486615688,
-0.0485895127,
0.2216805816,
0.3788264394,
-0.4471541047,
-0.3336780369,
-0.6979855895,
-0.4525795281,
0.3077081144,
-0.5364987254,
0.3582914472,
-0.3879759014,
-0.1377450973,
0.4535235167,
0.4743263721,
-0.3405462801,
0.5257790685,
0.0686544552,
0.5498290062,
-0.8628489375,
0.7897034883,
0.7310618162,
-0.3848783672,
-0.673915863,
-0.3801255226,
0.3902851045,
-0.5419412851,
0.7676337361,
0.3633336127,
0.4265755713,
-0.274230957,
-0.2680522501,
-1.0713802576,
1.0709799528,
-0.1470884681,
-0.6870703697,
-0.2526296675,
-0.188836053,
0.5910944939,
-0.596439302,
0.3971942365,
0.1890396178,
0.49822703,
0.3705205321,
-0.8054370284,
-0.04054543,
-0.1341801137,
0.1546736062,
0.4639298618,
-0.1814073026,
0.7687045336,
-0.3166497052,
-0.158273533,
-0.0550877824,
0.5533385277,
0.2199308276,
0.8898629546,
0.2543085217,
0.7229208946,
1.0779465437,
-0.1204160601,
0.7895003557,
-0.0798275769,
0.4850688875,
0.6641762257,
-0.2492417246,
0.3660374582,
0.1580104381,
-0.5188205838,
0.7417434454,
0.9036818147,
-0.2448720038,
0.5105835199,
0.2974827588,
-0.1185814887,
-0.0231138654,
0.0737942979,
-0.4615206718,
0.4377944767,
0.9020211101,
-0.8650737405,
-0.1560299546,
0.4314463139,
0.0497687683,
0.108567372,
-0.4979036748,
1.067174077,
0.1807950288,
-0.5057594776,
0.1562260091,
0.0950507373,
0.6008691788,
-0.538510859,
-0.1827388555,
0.2384232581,
0.1481894404,
-0.540689826,
-0.6234474778,
0.7350355983,
-0.2025191784,
-0.4718828499,
0.3587689698,
1.1870232821,
-0.2060720325,
-0.7826485634,
0.2071905732,
0.5196228623,
0.4660196006,
0.0276847556,
-1.1935600042,
-0.2489692867,
0.0604432598,
-0.2623226941,
0.4378874898,
0.4214302301,
-0.1995981485,
0.8569753766,
0.7937471867,
0.0244690459,
-0.2165679336,
-0.4667929709,
0.6073763967,
-0.7163063884,
-0.4081776142,
-0.8318730593,
-0.0105831819,
-0.3454430401,
-0.1563500762,
0.7348006964,
0.6521760225,
0.4894032478,
0.1568501294,
0.669172883,
-0.2288388461,
1.0936951637,
-0.7158648968,
0.8656392694,
-0.4460290074,
0.0723996162,
-0.2811479568,
-0.5697675347,
-0.5881211758,
0.5938305855,
-0.3683313131,
0.2191384435,
0.8927198648,
0.6871206164,
0.2810109258,
0.0880393684,
0.1657519042,
0.2060512304,
-0.0045946948,
0.7577973008,
0.1622776091,
-0.6888207793,
0.4082100391,
-0.2269541025,
-0.1946868002,
-0.5805444121,
-0.7051076293,
-0.6917496324,
-0.7151317596,
-0.5476635695,
-0.5648103356,
0.1429714113,
0.6865584254,
0.9951195717,
-0.9826055765,
0.0475870334,
-0.2693295181,
0.4913981259,
-0.2519154251,
-0.2629116476,
0.551076889,
-0.0686295107,
-0.6017856598,
0.282376796,
0.334798485,
-0.1417842656,
-0.0293975342,
0.1833326519,
-0.5624853969,
-0.2016600966,
0.5567623973,
0.519836843,
-0.4349494278,
0.4138881266,
-0.1904991269,
-0.3926257491,
0.0751500428,
0.7122400403,
-1.1660660505,
0.3625775576,
0.5063883066,
0.7130763531,
0.3401856124,
-0.2886827886,
0.379426837,
-0.231701389,
-0.1730097234,
0.4620947242,
0.2308058888,
0.3437619805,
-1.102098465,
0.7834089398,
0.3770379424,
-0.8170771599,
-0.633580029,
0.228610605,
-1.1736656427,
-0.4761967957,
0.8877181411,
-0.0907537416,
-0.7262999415,
-0.6784848571,
-0.166091159,
0.4893426895,
-0.481788367,
0.627006948,
0.3004726171,
-0.6620545387,
-0.3281233311,
-0.5530130863,
0.7201494575,
0.0585158505,
-1.1318930387,
-0.6269713044,
0.2272165716,
0.4141535461,
0.178349629,
0.6709160209,
-0.3771248758,
0.1166063622,
-0.1656132936,
0.0364507772,
-0.0598686263,
-0.0367648154,
-0.0943360776,
0.5592739582,
-0.3017222285,
-0.0755672529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18787v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18787v2 | Universality and Limitations of Prompt Tuning | 2023-05-30T06:47:07 | 2023-11-16T08:26:59 | Yihan Wang, Jatin Chauhan, Wei Wang, Cho-Jui Hsieh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Despite the demonstrated empirical efficacy of prompt tuning to adapt a
pretrained language model for a new task, the theoretical underpinnings of the
difference between "tuning parameters before the input" against "the tuning of
model weights" are limited. We thus take one of the first steps to understand
the role of soft-prompt tuning for transformer-based architectures. By
considering a general purpose architecture, we analyze prompt tuning from the
lens of both: universal approximation and limitations with finite-depth
fixed-weight pretrained transformers for continuous-valued functions. Our
universality result guarantees the existence of a strong transformer with a
prompt to approximate any sequence-to-sequence function in the set of Lipschitz
functions. The limitations of prompt tuning for limited-depth transformers are
first proved by constructing a set of datasets, that cannot be memorized by a
prompt of any length for a given single encoder layer. We also provide a lower
bound on the required number of tunable prompt parameters and compare the
result with the number of parameters required for a low-rank update (based on
LoRA) for a single-layer setting. We finally extend our analysis to multi-layer
settings by providing sufficient conditions under which the transformer can at
best learn datasets from invertible functions only. Our theoretical claims are
also corroborated by empirical results. | [
-0.5924079418,
-0.5744277239,
0.573164463,
0.4023214877,
-0.1087697893,
-0.4325843751,
-0.3214854002,
-0.0076243286,
-0.2716040909,
0.4627754688,
-0.7576383352,
-0.2895341516,
-0.3673563302,
0.3991300464,
-0.2553996742,
1.1821715832,
0.2243635803,
-0.1145660952,
-0.0021486648,
-0.3582907617,
-0.7959784269,
-0.1017447039,
-0.527261734,
-0.078691408,
0.6466802359,
0.7156481147,
0.8682410121,
0.4995473325,
0.343209058,
0.3160341978,
-0.1678796113,
-0.1435715705,
-0.1052874103,
0.2531735599,
0.002045044,
-0.6467146873,
-0.2292339504,
-0.0187764242,
0.8845527172,
0.8580530882,
0.0439900979,
0.1432093382,
0.2414476275,
0.6510049105,
-0.4239139259,
-0.1767566204,
-0.7091565728,
0.1911058128,
-0.1125462726,
-0.2397818267,
-0.4525332451,
-0.2433175594,
0.1869333684,
-0.8090866804,
0.6209285259,
0.0100271655,
0.6712456942,
0.671411097,
-0.4235526621,
-0.329151988,
-0.8514559865,
0.7469376326,
-0.2959691882,
0.317232281,
0.0825812742,
0.4046196938,
-0.0562121831,
-0.603954494,
-0.2912656069,
-0.4701363742,
-0.1905988902,
0.0922816843,
-0.1535848528,
0.3018026054,
0.8442556858,
0.3507785201,
-0.4805859923,
0.2355084568,
-0.235819459,
-0.1796274781,
0.1480895877,
0.1720240861,
0.3206161261,
-0.1927613914,
-0.3774660826,
-0.173123762,
-0.7111863494,
0.5501199365,
0.4442663491,
0.5299870968,
-0.143810451,
0.1130708978,
-0.0035456393,
0.6006171703,
0.3288674653,
0.2613011301,
-0.0867187679,
-0.1832142174,
-0.0639391765,
0.0561718158,
0.5929328799,
0.1795172095,
0.5481407046,
-0.23942478,
-0.2191302031,
-0.0705111548,
0.4214867055,
-0.6442119479,
0.3127337098,
0.1082295105,
-0.106006518,
0.0890068859,
0.2089546025,
-0.6708068848,
-0.2601142228,
-0.405300796,
0.4532802403,
-0.2143096924,
-0.0821903646,
0.1549807638,
-0.1875898093,
0.6926490664,
-0.0217842665,
-1.0211724043,
0.4086928964,
0.5404429436,
0.6689466238,
-0.0334659293,
-0.5546916723,
-0.5763118267,
-0.2841281295,
-0.2005497366,
0.8903034329,
-0.5008779764,
-0.5751169324,
0.0532591492,
0.238017112,
-0.2220221907,
-0.4427800179,
1.0086899996,
-0.4888225794,
0.1088376865,
-0.5592315197,
-0.1831679642,
0.2828216553,
-0.3577878773,
-0.8000406027,
0.6508088112,
0.3147304058,
-0.4415811002,
0.5438145995,
-0.6298760176,
-0.7157745957,
-0.0520025976,
0.0733421519,
-0.258670032,
0.5177036524,
0.3119456172,
0.2950696647,
-0.4859321415,
0.3950523734,
0.0620617084,
-0.6386845112,
0.1902171075,
-0.7009117007,
0.8059165478,
0.2361222655,
-0.2503932118,
0.2524760664,
-0.8094853759,
-0.1790988892,
-0.0634790733,
-0.2110419124,
0.0451913178,
-0.1390142143,
-0.1335080117,
-0.0488265082,
0.032506451,
-0.5048500299,
0.3805001676,
-0.4855582118,
0.6427798271,
0.8185759783,
-0.1918799728,
0.7656223178,
-0.2154193968,
0.8420718312,
-0.1100787222,
0.5117428303,
-0.8126965165,
-0.3848363757,
-0.7056965828,
-0.0556507558,
0.426232487,
0.7981849313,
-0.2513376772,
0.5958240032,
-0.1358620971,
-0.3023937941,
-0.7616714835,
-0.0849160105,
0.2152386606,
0.7699656487,
0.5399619937,
-0.0015495414,
-0.4287251532,
-0.9736472964,
-0.3707049191,
0.2753995955,
-0.4105900228,
0.3616440892,
0.1137653291,
0.1357402056,
1.0280618668,
-0.153189078,
-0.2011906207,
-0.143417567,
-0.1577618569,
0.8575225472,
0.5345054865,
0.4680514038,
-0.6561685205,
-0.4186911881,
-0.1765201837,
-0.6664225459,
-0.3269989789,
-0.2953041494,
0.183833316,
-0.2333534658,
0.5044560432,
-1.0048714876,
0.2208733708,
0.2021275014,
-0.367660135,
0.4766869545,
-0.3949824572,
0.059581995,
-0.7289041281,
0.0134734325,
0.0792743638,
0.0648249909,
-0.7110049725,
-0.0091456408,
0.2141500562,
-0.5616850257,
-0.4450251758,
0.7014250755,
-0.3971870542,
0.0317820422,
-0.0616659373,
0.0340537988,
0.0889456198,
0.5655285716,
-0.2971305847,
0.8966974616,
0.9434099793,
-0.9226129651,
0.2530715764,
0.4591230452,
-0.3097345531,
0.8058604002,
-1.247271657,
0.0935108736,
-0.3787048161,
0.1329633594,
-1.0019441843,
0.0333860815,
0.2048249394,
-0.3104545176,
0.3047870398,
-0.1720307469,
-0.1261033714,
-0.4510801136,
-0.1557224393,
0.3317865729,
0.7020922899,
-0.7427029014,
0.7190263867,
-0.3112631738,
-0.0202604588,
-0.5530727506,
-0.4457216561,
-0.193568185,
-0.2149700224,
-0.6127321124,
0.371955812,
-0.4243175387,
0.0069734096,
-0.2806974053,
-0.3839285076,
0.221342802,
0.2249231935,
0.294041276,
0.0554257296,
-0.4471717477,
0.0579260178,
0.3448528945,
-0.5703769922,
0.0440244861,
-0.3778497279,
0.3062660098,
-0.2908361852,
-0.3672697246,
-0.3514596224,
0.450629741,
0.5779114366,
-0.1081191301,
0.3652557731,
0.5991939306,
0.0299558844,
-0.2653827369,
-0.4344108701,
-0.1081054285,
-0.6461760998,
0.1097761989,
-0.5961287022,
-0.7918012738,
0.7498568892,
0.0187417306,
0.037371017,
0.5908267498,
0.1739667207,
0.0111126369,
1.1403459311,
0.6008848548,
-0.0706225783,
0.4111197889,
0.1076346487,
-0.0722087473,
-0.8133503199,
-0.1325630099,
-1.0240967274,
-0.5335892439,
-0.7571763396,
0.3698461056,
0.5618457198,
0.0688650608,
-0.508110106,
0.2792551517,
-0.7289605141,
0.7966052294,
0.7161810398,
-0.0754263699,
0.0873476863,
-0.0526799448,
-0.2010929286,
0.1137277037,
-0.7849527001,
-0.2979290187,
0.8182237744,
0.1785429865,
0.7588438392,
-0.2214585096,
0.0381640457,
0.2896615267,
-0.1191487834,
-0.7393780947,
0.498375237,
-0.1368359923,
-0.5105399489,
-0.4855357409,
-0.293546021,
-1.2192215919,
0.0307183191,
0.0873217061,
-0.4030034244,
0.2416198403,
0.246935904,
-0.5088000298,
0.1088017449,
-0.8748221993,
0.8299122453,
-0.234089762,
0.0125896409,
0.2662497163,
-0.9303716421,
-0.0921453312,
0.2124390751,
-0.010800832,
0.0235468801,
-0.0855310112,
0.4009554088,
-0.0921652392,
0.7971494198,
-0.5254616737,
-0.2318075895,
0.1293409169,
-0.1113632843,
0.3962123394,
0.2691036165,
-0.1198213696,
0.0488529764,
-0.1572657228,
-0.5277324915,
-0.7915520072,
0.4633899033,
-0.8552050591,
-0.8657736778,
-0.1137596443,
-0.4056736529,
-0.4408480525,
0.2705165148,
0.7504318357,
0.9474269152,
-0.2304044217,
0.2608648837,
0.9393313527,
-0.277325511,
0.6323315501,
0.544685185,
0.2010694444,
-0.2222407311,
0.6909074187,
-0.0955040604,
0.0541246012,
0.4479506314,
0.4134073257,
-0.3151469231,
-0.4335377216,
-0.5981887579,
0.0189492274,
-0.6598379016,
-0.1450561583,
-0.3589519858,
-0.0601920746,
-0.2174655199,
-0.3578412533,
-0.1682875156,
-0.2704409957,
-0.5056686401,
0.0214494355,
0.3230410516,
0.6123305559,
0.0822401345,
0.5486533046,
-0.7804713249,
0.5028858781,
0.4539158046,
0.6976421475,
-0.1193650961,
-0.832886517,
-0.1052135229,
-0.2307950854,
-0.0679568797,
-0.5592819452,
-0.1421376318,
0.5153539777,
0.7857245803,
0.5332514048,
-0.0262104087,
0.2981536686,
-0.7980301976,
0.8142963052,
-0.0212870054,
-1.0334336758,
0.7654809952,
-0.4089983404,
0.8164588213,
0.6893229485,
0.4467208683,
-0.500777781,
-0.1378422976,
-0.4197376966,
-0.6864394546,
0.7275834084,
-0.1680994928,
0.6240051389,
0.1198756024,
0.6611552238,
0.5345066786,
0.1267985255,
-0.4048883915,
-0.4362921715,
-0.5562353134,
-0.2131127119,
-0.1232087538,
-0.1538306326,
0.0182028599,
-0.3807368279,
0.254198283,
-0.3371553719,
0.3476563692,
0.2452078313,
-0.3110873103,
-0.1299432665,
0.5946959853,
0.7053341866,
0.6541799307,
0.0249578506,
-0.0580026992,
0.2699564099,
-0.3742406666,
0.3248313963,
0.1337936074,
-0.5102159381,
-0.1386980265,
0.3462198377,
1.3160192966,
0.5652073622,
-0.374201268,
0.4511357248,
-0.2068891376,
-0.179900825,
-0.0768385828,
0.4758195579,
-0.3823936582,
0.0885961205,
0.5947060585,
0.4195132256,
-0.11017178,
-0.150510326,
0.1830750406,
0.5268917084,
-0.5760963559,
-0.738090694,
0.7811199427,
0.2643580139,
-0.6018191576,
0.7279090881,
-0.0071252296,
-0.1464923769,
0.6789200902,
0.6105030775,
1.0000286102,
-0.5173686743,
0.3432480097,
0.3674303889,
0.4899817407,
0.0149442395,
0.057567317,
-0.380112797,
-0.7511154413,
-0.3375079036,
-0.6393088698,
-0.4179320037,
-0.024198262,
-0.8961146474,
0.236262247,
-0.6402363777,
-0.1137674078,
-0.1223174557,
-0.2033516914,
-0.9292738438,
0.1261645406,
-0.1353102326,
1.0883170366,
-0.6679502726,
0.3962927759,
0.3994200826,
-0.2744269967,
-0.6558368206,
-0.0586767569,
-0.3135431111,
-0.863655746,
0.2625770271,
0.2903128564,
-0.0600177608,
0.3242740929,
-0.6639603376,
-0.6982070804,
0.8637646437,
0.6542487144,
-0.510420382,
-0.3945893645,
0.2276152968,
0.4176834524,
-0.1006038263,
0.392723918,
0.7907626629,
0.8204253316,
-0.095856376,
-0.8216614127,
0.0898329169,
-0.2846246958,
-0.0320456624,
0.1430943012,
-0.6373965144,
0.850810945,
-0.2571187317,
-0.4281800985,
0.1921421289,
0.5697293878,
-0.2583520412,
0.0354950614,
0.6632088423,
0.2614759803,
0.6345384717,
-0.2335517406,
1.1448323727,
-0.3701458871,
0.1012420058,
0.5902394652,
-0.1135887802,
0.0220621135,
0.1962504685,
-0.2301875502,
0.4005379677,
0.3917554319,
-0.2781310081,
0.3836500347,
-0.0215030927,
-0.0375540406,
-0.045666717,
-0.2198888212,
-0.5072439909,
0.2391461134,
0.1852677315,
0.0093312962,
-0.194811359,
0.3256607354,
-0.3044646084,
-0.1432883143,
-0.5710594058,
0.6951143146,
0.1136178076,
-0.96720469,
0.6332121491,
-0.3516642749,
0.7510976195,
-0.915055871,
0.2676856518,
-0.4093649089,
-0.1841826439,
-0.0727249011,
-0.6201783419,
0.1214312091,
-0.1891288608,
-0.3106203973,
-0.4216158092,
0.7314176559,
-0.0204298571,
-0.310125947,
0.0780607983,
0.48255229,
-0.408780843,
-0.2057487518,
-0.5170862079,
-0.0498779379,
-0.2930033505,
-0.5856554508,
0.1523769498,
0.5770768523,
0.4536601603,
0.5384787917,
0.4703787565,
0.0981406122,
0.003570948,
0.3363969922,
0.670381248,
-0.9674757123,
-0.5934575796,
-0.7461003661,
0.641972959,
0.4419561923,
-0.736918509,
0.6401578188,
0.047987733,
0.625718832,
-0.2747988999,
0.6683419347,
0.1719613373,
0.1810669899,
-0.809830606,
0.32466802,
-0.4661543071,
0.1449574828,
-0.1303638667,
-1.2425165176,
-0.2462362349,
0.2200171798,
-0.0175767746,
0.2073162347,
0.8322915435,
0.8658013344,
-0.1678890139,
0.3672230542,
0.4309758246,
0.1046148539,
0.0119038671,
0.4697870016,
0.9283201694,
-0.3027795553,
0.6096205115,
0.131479755,
-0.2012403607,
0.0810086057,
-0.8007139564,
-0.8371244073,
-0.6937194467,
0.0985524133,
-0.1366758347,
-0.2160862237,
0.8087182045,
0.6161147356,
-0.9722189903,
0.0367047265,
-0.1669031382,
0.2737384439,
-0.3713026941,
-0.2019668221,
0.2057641745,
-0.5918689966,
-0.5570244789,
0.698142767,
0.1546944529,
-0.0485212617,
-0.2699506581,
0.0066560684,
0.4415296614,
0.2067096531,
0.4569182098,
0.6531853676,
-0.5487907529,
-0.3509198725,
0.4031484127,
0.0822785869,
0.4255981445,
1.3268921375,
-0.8574451208,
0.1168565154,
0.2261947244,
0.5216203928,
0.2245482355,
-0.110996455,
0.5148163438,
-0.9734287858,
0.2409541458,
0.1125354171,
0.2565010488,
0.2157444805,
-0.3763804436,
0.1115610376,
0.0567250662,
-0.681753099,
-0.5486719012,
0.5532957911,
-0.9192696214,
-0.1079802364,
0.8535797596,
0.2426047772,
-0.1892330199,
-0.0906810388,
-0.2821348011,
0.1494397819,
-0.4629977942,
0.5088908076,
0.3922249675,
0.063625671,
-0.0907481685,
-0.4119226336,
0.6609296203,
0.3928059042,
-0.4763757288,
-0.0254541878,
0.2169954777,
0.1001521945,
0.0322842933,
0.4704169333,
0.2597423196,
0.3889970481,
-0.0899259746,
-0.3072387874,
-0.2608852088,
-0.7573781013,
-0.8447391391,
0.384347409,
-0.0235869754,
0.0814855322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18786v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18786v2 | Scalable Performance Analysis for Vision-Language Models | 2023-05-30T06:40:08 | 2023-05-31T17:55:44 | Santiago Castro, Oana Ignat, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Joint vision-language models have shown great performance over a diverse set
of tasks. However, little is known about their limitations, as the high
dimensional space learned by these models makes it difficult to identify
semantic errors. Recent work has addressed this problem by designing highly
controlled probing task benchmarks. Our paper introduces a more scalable
solution that relies on already annotated benchmarks. Our method consists of
extracting a large set of diverse features from a vision-language benchmark and
measuring their correlation with the output of the target model. We confirm
previous findings that CLIP behaves like a bag of words model and performs
better with nouns and verbs; we also uncover novel insights such as CLIP
getting confused by concrete words. Our framework is available at
https://github.com/MichiganNLP/Scalable-VLM-Probing and can be used with other
multimodal models and benchmarks. | [
-0.5048096776,
-1.0279473066,
0.4811514318,
0.3403383195,
-0.0739303008,
0.0522340201,
-0.2055699974,
-0.5679555535,
0.2347058952,
0.6869753599,
-0.451826185,
-0.2465296835,
-0.7822482586,
-0.1721937507,
-0.6384174824,
0.533898294,
-0.1299014688,
0.1028104946,
-0.5340589285,
-0.6720182896,
-0.490347445,
-0.5422794819,
-0.2241733223,
0.0622481182,
0.4179089367,
0.176445663,
0.4365391731,
0.7034537196,
0.9252147675,
0.3339597583,
-0.2217247933,
0.3129856586,
-0.5016633868,
0.140850395,
-0.2794088423,
-0.262558192,
-0.5608819723,
0.0056566861,
1.0646964312,
0.8140825033,
0.0743527487,
0.4816460609,
0.0450026281,
0.3689929843,
-1.0587089062,
0.1558903009,
-0.6677100658,
-0.1169467643,
-0.5312309861,
0.0215480383,
-0.2880764902,
0.1174006388,
0.1315906048,
-0.4578701556,
0.2545629442,
-0.0007307947,
1.2068655491,
0.3935934901,
-0.232798472,
0.2079115808,
-0.6588727832,
0.899543047,
-0.4547538459,
0.5486331582,
0.0513150096,
0.5769066811,
0.1922205091,
-0.8066523671,
-0.485907793,
-0.1446051598,
0.084808439,
-0.0259177461,
-0.1437181234,
-0.150801152,
0.4709835351,
0.3217743039,
-0.243398115,
-0.0533443317,
-0.19418253,
-0.3236770928,
0.5261241794,
0.5323441625,
0.1866737902,
0.0143826129,
-0.4685815275,
-0.6021850705,
-0.441506207,
0.3391014636,
0.0502636023,
0.2457087636,
0.0655194446,
0.775531888,
-0.2801994681,
0.9612037539,
-0.3206170499,
-0.095641315,
0.2593491971,
-0.58115381,
-0.1540067941,
-0.6332529783,
0.5152063966,
0.4870658517,
0.1307521164,
-0.013846959,
-0.3861613274,
0.1614346355,
0.3914919496,
-0.8474739194,
-0.3539805412,
0.0003309778,
-0.1048488617,
-0.0000351164,
-0.1805791706,
-0.8851274252,
-0.2074710876,
-0.1877878904,
0.7120046616,
-0.3022122681,
-0.2382404506,
0.084146902,
-0.2239490449,
0.2191187888,
0.1891063154,
-0.7950502634,
0.5311908722,
0.6562687755,
0.9358810186,
-0.5234644413,
-0.6174357533,
-1.0315792561,
0.0324851051,
-0.3934316635,
0.7787846923,
-0.656210959,
-0.2936813831,
0.0701772273,
-0.130716145,
-0.3045336902,
-0.6887258291,
0.1718648076,
-0.3216712475,
-0.3294682801,
-0.564761579,
-0.6884610057,
-0.1640557498,
0.5896021724,
-0.8043612242,
1.2359904051,
0.1295163333,
-0.7884961963,
0.6001850367,
-0.5134612322,
-0.0876469091,
0.2193717957,
-0.3639241755,
-0.4425720572,
0.3254239261,
0.4575705826,
0.5011305809,
-0.0597768277,
0.1547067016,
-0.4678514898,
-0.3031228781,
0.1906520426,
-0.1227317527,
0.5105355382,
-0.130242005,
-0.2066143304,
0.4847794771,
-1.0605764389,
0.3101531863,
-0.0223163497,
-0.2078066915,
-0.3500689566,
0.2593323886,
0.3653676212,
-0.1472376436,
0.2407547086,
-0.5613484979,
-0.0136793777,
-0.0464958474,
0.0309883691,
0.3705877662,
-0.2735766768,
0.1649234891,
-0.0674235523,
0.5175500512,
-0.0320026912,
0.2799459696,
-0.1557453722,
-0.3131569624,
-0.853117466,
-0.6270545721,
0.0508280993,
0.3755221665,
-0.7923393846,
-0.1630721092,
-0.2085319161,
-0.5243736506,
-0.3184475601,
0.098848559,
0.4966824055,
0.4395202696,
0.3846647143,
-0.6661416888,
-0.3126229048,
-1.0050325394,
-0.4174579084,
-0.1550369561,
-0.056449227,
0.6242043972,
0.5125346184,
-0.0919151083,
0.9259294271,
-0.617982924,
-0.2636276782,
-0.1801476181,
0.1671896279,
0.0019448344,
0.3041341901,
0.7467293739,
-0.8599946499,
-0.304654628,
-0.0232543889,
-0.4656145573,
-0.216425553,
0.1435200423,
0.005602215,
-0.189120084,
0.5719519258,
-0.3166185915,
0.249026224,
0.8167254925,
-0.4618896842,
0.7106152773,
-0.210343197,
-0.0014105563,
-0.7571772337,
0.197463721,
0.0496151932,
-0.2436823696,
-0.492636919,
0.4742424488,
0.374068737,
0.0376436487,
-0.5736746788,
0.4830796421,
-0.4135583341,
-0.5964793563,
-0.3035139441,
0.0287927054,
0.0535056517,
0.4177662134,
0.1112230271,
0.964027822,
0.804109633,
-0.7442457676,
0.3245490193,
0.1033040881,
-0.4436687529,
0.6119647622,
-0.8385245204,
-0.2741760314,
0.0436259396,
-0.2787918746,
-1.0600398779,
-0.3308606744,
-0.0620032921,
-0.2748626173,
0.2754340768,
-0.1127504483,
-0.3774625659,
-0.0793785825,
-0.1933087558,
0.5600815415,
0.2078479081,
-0.5335592628,
0.7155373096,
0.6394315958,
0.1095537022,
-0.4989248514,
-0.2593511343,
0.0260806549,
-0.1095960587,
-0.5519067645,
0.220195502,
0.1510081291,
-0.2961316705,
-0.0992208868,
0.0259115715,
-0.4336743951,
0.2449679077,
0.3005466163,
0.3199283779,
-0.3196355999,
0.071098201,
-0.2507752478,
0.085135743,
0.0670125335,
-0.0009282422,
0.5116917491,
-0.5668267608,
-0.357657522,
0.0228294786,
0.3886320293,
0.9371364117,
-0.7752293348,
0.5321006179,
0.8565521836,
-0.1645434797,
-0.1333199143,
-0.6649540663,
-0.0412019938,
-0.4416449666,
0.7064073086,
-0.5464708805,
-0.9826007485,
0.6213334203,
0.0105746593,
-0.0163748432,
0.3649721444,
0.5430759788,
-0.0690075979,
0.8654612303,
1.1535867453,
0.1267257929,
0.549246192,
-0.2865415514,
-0.0783557743,
-0.8643425107,
-0.1474231631,
-0.4327289462,
-0.1949110478,
-0.4932075143,
-0.7595216632,
0.5183426142,
0.1096153259,
0.2818622887,
0.4696544111,
-0.1648151577,
0.3437486887,
0.4605368078,
-0.3315484822,
0.0139186466,
-0.1440428942,
-0.2571214139,
-0.2032434791,
-0.5911952257,
-0.2137069255,
0.8645298481,
0.3437825143,
0.6659408808,
0.0662835985,
0.2995824814,
-0.2131189555,
0.0211534947,
-0.7082025409,
0.632856071,
-0.2858192623,
-0.6007146835,
-0.4654670656,
-0.2511011958,
-0.5780835748,
0.8138105273,
-0.2036379576,
-1.0080183744,
0.1162022948,
0.2321556658,
-0.2353356332,
0.3652918637,
-0.5116807818,
0.9579733014,
-0.1873796433,
-0.4952803254,
-0.1308346391,
-0.3368600309,
0.3229959011,
0.0214061271,
-0.0650360957,
-0.286341548,
-0.1888043135,
0.7956492901,
-0.3284569085,
0.7876726389,
-0.0080315899,
0.0784553364,
0.1543901414,
0.0761084482,
0.2962113321,
-0.1231478378,
0.4091676474,
0.2605134547,
0.4317840934,
-0.5376471877,
-0.4746878743,
0.526447773,
-0.2843993604,
-0.3395746052,
-0.1784349829,
-0.7906461358,
-0.5610694289,
0.2253843844,
0.1624798924,
0.6440628767,
0.0187673252,
0.2895126641,
0.558727622,
0.0258901343,
0.614438653,
0.5405912399,
-0.4870662987,
-0.0155324675,
0.9537784457,
0.1892988086,
0.3167084455,
0.3812115192,
0.1446377784,
-0.1180440784,
-0.8240513206,
-0.5087375641,
0.1180926338,
-0.4641409516,
0.2106236368,
-0.6833297014,
-0.0503646024,
-0.2000658661,
0.1711930335,
-0.9984648228,
-0.1449521482,
0.0158103649,
0.1891274601,
0.1851040125,
0.5589132309,
0.0968735293,
0.1395141929,
-0.9125202894,
0.271974653,
0.3809776604,
0.5306179523,
-0.089240998,
-0.2151143253,
-0.3074401021,
-0.419852823,
-0.0602435917,
-0.5847525597,
0.3796990812,
0.2797326446,
0.6418058872,
0.2987722456,
-0.1215798855,
0.8937597871,
-0.4826661646,
0.9005223513,
0.0570324063,
-1.0264252424,
0.4551858306,
-0.2687229812,
0.5325804353,
0.5103279352,
0.2394781262,
-0.3314763606,
-0.5501896739,
-0.2934882045,
-0.9275573492,
0.3859030306,
0.0940870717,
0.0357021727,
-0.0436413959,
0.0063534952,
-0.0891913772,
0.0680316538,
-0.341899544,
-0.0532669686,
0.1189437956,
0.1833853424,
-0.2047534883,
-0.6061073542,
-0.1877453774,
-0.2944734991,
0.1418585032,
-0.3680252135,
0.0051500723,
0.0878077522,
-0.2295868993,
0.1858927906,
-0.1377994865,
0.6906452179,
1.0141785145,
-0.206926778,
0.1632450372,
0.2321932316,
-0.6948074698,
-0.201979965,
-0.1834083796,
-0.0510412529,
0.267935425,
0.6604574919,
0.852801919,
0.4220776856,
-1.1122946739,
0.7967669964,
-0.1411508024,
-0.1228083372,
-0.0967585966,
0.0295165069,
-0.040893048,
0.4628775716,
0.0647521839,
0.0523266979,
0.1841658801,
-0.3293426037,
0.3995681405,
0.5292670131,
-0.6329863071,
-0.243406117,
0.6748194695,
0.1426852643,
-0.1397624314,
0.4307713509,
0.0466670804,
-0.7119231224,
0.5809801221,
0.1403123289,
0.6321191788,
0.0973516032,
0.0797312632,
0.3748294711,
0.2339768112,
-0.0513017923,
0.3241434097,
-0.4186300039,
-0.7353402972,
-0.709149003,
-0.535615027,
-0.5752691627,
-0.0165634528,
-1.0204154253,
0.0026028268,
-0.350684464,
-0.1982561052,
0.1145437658,
-0.0857359916,
-0.6544778943,
0.1490522772,
0.0409710631,
0.8838548064,
-0.8510685563,
0.9481483698,
0.6416842937,
-0.2050176412,
-0.7251796126,
-0.1586391479,
-0.0709711313,
-0.7225561738,
0.8769078255,
0.135148406,
-0.4112014771,
-0.4415702522,
-0.2843142748,
-1.1842086315,
0.7594816089,
0.2624288499,
-0.6459809542,
0.1484134644,
-0.0412699319,
0.5045397878,
-0.206285432,
0.1479762495,
0.4750900567,
0.121453099,
0.2041552067,
-1.2282757759,
-0.330547452,
-0.121752657,
0.2195008844,
0.3843969107,
-0.5734699965,
1.1988279819,
-0.0379973277,
-0.2073349953,
0.0223876815,
0.7018265128,
-0.0827573538,
0.3113943338,
0.522551477,
0.6210871935,
0.6531057954,
-0.0405625962,
1.1603914499,
-0.1939523667,
0.5635769367,
1.2757556438,
-0.2529796064,
1.329194665,
0.8448094726,
-0.1906895936,
-0.0354633145,
0.2544053197,
-0.1199480146,
0.4112349451,
0.1841073185,
-0.03984081,
-0.5566076636,
-0.1134539545,
-0.02574859,
0.8314082623,
0.2581137121,
-0.106976755,
-0.2941101789,
0.1442986727,
-0.3423326612,
0.1114809066,
-0.2752788961,
0.5484853387,
-0.3163061142,
-0.5597506762,
0.4645881355,
-0.245174706,
0.6096172333,
-0.5110784769,
-0.0258331429,
-0.1005661786,
0.424795717,
0.2239216417,
-0.7023628354,
0.4942083359,
-0.0646892637,
-0.0972510949,
-0.106412299,
0.5001190901,
-0.3234997094,
-0.6610921621,
0.432536006,
0.4856080413,
0.1461790651,
-0.0814756379,
-0.2957274318,
0.5891599059,
-0.2714996636,
-0.087319091,
0.3657693863,
0.0637773499,
-0.1540184021,
0.7645723224,
0.3338728845,
0.2623064816,
0.533785224,
-0.025657922,
0.7692174315,
-0.4997865856,
-0.2432628125,
-0.859026432,
0.4366293848,
-0.4012472928,
-0.6472021937,
0.8366314769,
0.5343686342,
1.1815526485,
-0.0755705759,
0.2406083792,
0.067365393,
0.5502705574,
-0.5830230117,
0.5960087776,
-0.7009218931,
0.0328121074,
-0.3166630268,
-0.9579566717,
-0.3204774857,
0.3770162165,
-0.0351307467,
-0.3397696614,
0.6684664488,
0.7767030597,
-0.082328245,
-0.349868536,
0.7304224968,
0.0551203489,
0.5232645273,
0.4616604745,
0.7251034975,
-0.3800255954,
0.4789849222,
-0.4046723545,
-0.2006580085,
-0.4557289183,
-0.8505390882,
-0.9108144045,
-0.7830781341,
-0.5134878755,
-0.0173432734,
-0.1006542593,
0.2262584418,
0.9920533299,
-0.6402240992,
-0.3623840213,
0.2344762236,
-0.1674674898,
-0.5502301455,
-0.1508674622,
0.2614598274,
-0.4563374519,
-0.7978513837,
0.4016370773,
0.4327342212,
-0.156209141,
-0.4546529651,
0.1964984983,
0.0571882948,
0.1414094269,
0.6955280304,
0.2389318943,
-0.8479340672,
-0.4911540449,
0.0098062372,
-0.0969900936,
-0.1208683401,
1.0304894447,
-0.639308393,
0.8210093975,
0.4875577092,
1.0719672441,
0.8106682897,
-0.333810091,
0.4964007437,
-0.6958177686,
0.0795801282,
0.1988274753,
0.4411379099,
0.2383673042,
-0.006244482,
0.3809474707,
0.2377998084,
-0.201123625,
-0.8374258876,
0.2859558761,
-1.2960004807,
-0.2053561509,
0.9485451579,
-0.3570314348,
-0.5069894195,
0.3042300045,
-0.0959198773,
-0.153166756,
0.2488256693,
0.5507127643,
0.893430233,
-0.1020158604,
-0.2803318799,
-0.5960031152,
0.2952281833,
0.6714767218,
-0.5176606774,
0.1113545746,
0.5268095136,
0.2498185635,
0.2803941965,
0.3003707528,
-0.2034418136,
0.4034034908,
0.3809387684,
-0.165378511,
-0.2566823363,
-0.5830580592,
-0.2744933367,
0.5379817486,
0.1220192686,
-0.7849327326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18760v1 | Shuo Wen Jie Zi: Rethinking Dictionaries and Glyphs for Chinese Language Pre-training | 2023-05-30T05:48:36 | 2023-05-30T05:48:36 | Yuxuan Wang, Jianghui Wang, Dongyan Zhao, Zilong Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce CDBERT, a new learning paradigm that enhances the semantics
understanding ability of the Chinese PLMs with dictionary knowledge and
structure of Chinese characters. We name the two core modules of CDBERT as
Shuowen and Jiezi, where Shuowen refers to the process of retrieving the most
appropriate meaning from Chinese dictionaries and Jiezi refers to the process
of enhancing characters' glyph representations with structure understanding. To
facilitate dictionary understanding, we propose three pre-training tasks, i.e.,
Masked Entry Modeling, Contrastive Learning for Synonym and Antonym, and
Example Learning. We evaluate our method on both modern Chinese understanding
benchmark CLUE and ancient Chinese benchmark CCLUE. Moreover, we propose a new
polysemy discrimination task PolyMRC based on the collected dictionary of
ancient Chinese. Our paradigm demonstrates consistent improvements on previous
Chinese PLMs across all tasks. Moreover, our approach yields significant
boosting on few-shot setting of ancient Chinese understanding. | [
-0.1405658424,
-0.3271778524,
0.4395620227,
-0.0375241749,
-0.572766602,
0.1961136162,
-0.3109412491,
-0.2804819047,
0.1318834275,
0.1893040985,
-0.5670338869,
-0.5684496164,
-0.6635013819,
0.079894796,
-0.3471388519,
1.0129284859,
-0.0440003648,
0.2672052085,
0.0449643694,
-0.1166518852,
-0.0522605069,
-0.5349205732,
-0.5397768617,
-0.2843350768,
0.7857476473,
0.2187185436,
0.813777566,
0.5269321799,
0.3297380209,
0.3415702283,
-0.13070333,
0.0291376151,
-0.414391309,
-0.3672932386,
0.0131467786,
-0.7907405496,
-0.5244097114,
0.1865187138,
0.5034260154,
0.7739172578,
-0.2242441624,
-0.2638772428,
0.3358031809,
0.8098255396,
-0.7544603348,
0.0495572686,
-0.7462917566,
0.0402664058,
-0.4285847545,
0.0858517662,
-0.1411234885,
-0.0227472149,
0.4032877088,
-0.9161111712,
0.3250234425,
-0.3292471766,
0.89753443,
0.0828062743,
-0.3202597201,
-0.6046831608,
-0.0903411433,
0.8647726178,
-0.683544755,
0.5682824254,
0.1220308542,
0.3094540536,
-0.1223831177,
-1.1412085295,
-0.7556679845,
-0.271630913,
-0.0512748994,
0.3982784152,
0.5142429471,
0.3423417807,
0.179538995,
0.6264252663,
-0.4964791536,
-0.1459850073,
-0.4016396403,
-0.1479929537,
0.6860597134,
-0.0795881674,
0.5599862933,
-0.0728704035,
-0.7299488783,
-0.1731679887,
-0.5600603819,
0.1497918218,
0.1804247051,
-0.0924196094,
-0.2059160471,
-0.2434542775,
-0.048169829,
0.787375927,
-0.1112534702,
-0.3513052762,
0.6865931153,
-0.6419678926,
-0.1798765659,
0.1218334436,
0.6311035752,
-0.0805228576,
0.4596193135,
-0.2486780137,
-0.1804855913,
0.0563372597,
0.2296256572,
-0.5417436957,
-0.8162285089,
0.1202224419,
-0.6963796616,
-0.2342149168,
0.4773398936,
-0.3614979088,
-0.4676830769,
-0.5272533298,
0.3422410488,
-0.7007920742,
-0.2858216166,
0.1425440758,
-0.3301539421,
0.1865412444,
0.478114754,
-0.9599857926,
0.0268962346,
0.5971800089,
0.6967941523,
-0.0662817657,
-0.5280131102,
-0.2943242788,
0.1587306261,
-0.3736722171,
0.386197269,
-0.2394604534,
-0.4315631688,
0.0759004131,
-0.0188534427,
0.0996722057,
-0.4286583364,
0.5444421768,
-0.4931435287,
0.0693459213,
-0.3103109002,
-0.3454394341,
-0.396407336,
0.2251242995,
-0.6018212438,
0.5766080618,
0.1433109492,
-0.9277535677,
0.4362440407,
-0.3856184185,
-0.6250719428,
0.2301896065,
-0.2569451034,
-0.065366596,
0.1434897333,
0.1583851278,
0.2487999052,
-0.0803403407,
-0.0087248832,
-0.0276468042,
-0.3085444868,
0.1319886744,
-0.1199505776,
1.2084326744,
0.4406234324,
-0.1772032678,
0.1717738062,
-0.896335721,
0.2163503319,
0.0598192476,
-0.2862436771,
-0.5732694864,
0.3817933202,
-0.170742929,
0.3706505001,
0.5701539516,
-0.3665593863,
0.0391731188,
-0.5925437808,
0.5717022419,
0.6768743992,
-0.6800612211,
0.3438266516,
-0.1148995683,
0.1732690781,
0.368979156,
0.3053223193,
-0.2023400813,
-0.0577672645,
-0.8355048299,
-0.2622999549,
0.4209254086,
0.5579980612,
-1.3527485132,
0.2725347877,
-0.2375396043,
-0.3408034742,
-0.5634901524,
0.6949868202,
0.3128719032,
0.305939585,
0.3604771793,
-0.5432789922,
-0.308853358,
-0.5345064402,
-0.0763120651,
-0.3917705119,
-0.3610964715,
-0.1180492938,
0.2819300294,
-0.2603326738,
0.5957926512,
-0.3447100222,
-0.4122793674,
-0.5145879984,
0.3604777157,
0.2220108509,
0.0386077017,
0.6597695351,
-0.9934746027,
-0.6502318978,
-0.1269473881,
-0.4852228761,
-0.1361593157,
-0.1840047836,
-0.0333844908,
0.0721183121,
0.4921725988,
0.0797603205,
0.2101739645,
0.4819202721,
0.0871269256,
0.4902373552,
-0.3491463959,
-0.0251731742,
-0.9770123959,
-0.3287157118,
-0.1907789856,
0.1225976124,
-0.8554716706,
0.1663664281,
0.4270864725,
0.2691679895,
-0.6780776978,
0.1788136512,
-0.8332340717,
0.2638600767,
-0.7406620383,
0.7724897265,
-0.0372186303,
0.3792268932,
0.264955461,
0.5508936644,
0.8047206998,
-0.8257701993,
0.6129074097,
0.1385429502,
-0.5013406277,
0.289388746,
-0.6377310753,
0.1775000393,
-0.2724292874,
0.0470177159,
-1.0498982668,
0.2618061602,
0.3943217397,
-0.4795199335,
0.320168376,
0.1310749948,
-0.4539241493,
-0.3669624031,
-0.6656103134,
0.4619059563,
0.5177679062,
-0.8047633171,
0.3550918996,
0.1959653199,
0.2045966685,
-0.587456286,
-0.526583612,
-0.0660147816,
-0.1367012709,
-0.7640060782,
0.6329865456,
-0.0034368597,
-0.1406423897,
-0.4353964925,
-0.0981503874,
-0.2827701867,
0.3930073678,
-0.133960098,
0.3868792653,
-0.0923140571,
0.1724646837,
-0.2980486453,
-0.1023857668,
0.0524159968,
-0.3141216338,
0.4500125349,
0.168226704,
0.0719625205,
-0.3048846722,
-0.2297951877,
0.1690815389,
-0.4514678121,
0.5086380243,
0.8529263735,
-0.1891433746,
-0.2246342301,
-0.1635435671,
0.0410740227,
-0.5254924297,
0.395627737,
-0.5892153978,
-0.4530127048,
0.2142668664,
-0.1841105074,
0.2360951155,
0.0991098359,
0.509493351,
-0.1691190451,
0.6888840795,
0.6277056932,
-0.3854023516,
0.8104203939,
-0.044700399,
0.2514857948,
-0.7781695724,
0.0956068039,
-0.2227368206,
-0.3895298541,
-0.5753296018,
-0.44490242,
0.3441462517,
0.3752879798,
0.2746400237,
0.323384136,
-0.2974804342,
0.2289716303,
0.6339927912,
0.1932695359,
0.0175406113,
-0.0698924512,
-0.106366016,
0.1137270853,
-0.6135911942,
-0.3342364728,
1.1368365288,
0.2056448013,
0.9084895849,
-0.0103980592,
0.8480618,
-0.0586146489,
0.039099142,
-0.6205591559,
0.4438063502,
-0.4909874201,
-0.4251295924,
-0.3733895719,
-0.1675581634,
-0.9368872643,
0.3552036285,
-0.1035649851,
-0.608856082,
-0.0713135898,
0.1348564029,
-0.3752418458,
0.0577814616,
-0.7057875991,
0.8156262636,
-0.667075038,
-0.2679290771,
-0.5054395199,
-0.8432793617,
0.3924462497,
0.1491673291,
0.367618233,
0.2597821653,
0.0152752502,
0.6464090347,
-0.3150019646,
0.5813652277,
-0.1073818877,
-0.4330105782,
0.5472450852,
-0.1881060302,
0.1288073212,
0.0898154974,
-0.1312391162,
0.5584911108,
0.4311659336,
-0.464569062,
-0.789963305,
0.3579178154,
-0.8170005679,
-0.7448053956,
-0.5482830405,
-0.4058102965,
0.2012272775,
0.0464423969,
0.3647736609,
0.202578485,
-0.1314661056,
-0.0222732462,
0.4805003405,
-0.3693021536,
0.149845317,
0.4911449552,
-0.062152788,
-0.3445025682,
1.0360033512,
0.2345355898,
0.4768492579,
0.5367071033,
0.0994130149,
-0.2192272246,
-0.5267542601,
-0.1837379187,
0.2306564897,
-0.7219688296,
0.399212271,
-0.1346762776,
-0.5240308046,
-0.5117698908,
-0.0980282649,
-0.0149657633,
0.0278599299,
-0.181493327,
0.276684463,
-0.2688253224,
0.5588020086,
-0.2250225395,
0.4675245583,
-0.7211424112,
0.7073626518,
0.2346700579,
0.1560787857,
-0.028998863,
-0.499792546,
-0.5129629374,
0.2868209183,
-0.5457674265,
-0.8902132511,
0.1765621752,
0.2650902867,
0.8002154827,
0.8961815238,
0.1257393509,
0.4957654178,
-0.7476918697,
0.9039847255,
0.4307892919,
-1.1719359159,
0.6433465481,
0.2131362408,
0.1497914493,
0.380243212,
0.4411301315,
-0.8180704713,
-0.0586245842,
-0.4302091002,
-0.7243971825,
0.8190916181,
0.0978606716,
0.0646184385,
-0.10991548,
0.4479947388,
0.2921218276,
0.4245780706,
-0.8241341114,
-0.4585342109,
-0.4957481325,
-0.3952099383,
-0.2074337602,
-0.5352424979,
0.0693824813,
-0.5309064984,
0.483674705,
-0.1273703575,
0.0930597931,
0.1952537,
-0.5015996099,
0.3533381522,
0.2527010143,
0.2197390497,
0.7388406992,
0.1566607356,
0.3035515249,
0.3925856948,
-0.6054019332,
-0.1450912505,
-0.1783011109,
-0.0151680056,
0.064501211,
0.4083763957,
0.7005935311,
0.0719207898,
-0.6065510511,
0.4632801116,
0.1185831055,
-0.4084290564,
-0.518610239,
0.347887814,
-0.0478184447,
0.0376749113,
0.0394684337,
-0.829760015,
0.2527731955,
-0.7207196951,
0.0418953486,
0.6141942143,
-0.2330697328,
-0.4195567667,
0.6046312451,
0.3580729961,
-0.0102500077,
0.6676574349,
-0.2074112147,
-0.976330936,
0.4056852162,
0.2958870828,
0.6147391796,
-0.3266762793,
0.2573538125,
0.3549253643,
0.337028116,
0.063378714,
0.3313164413,
-0.485637784,
-0.8989193439,
0.0648287609,
-0.448273629,
-0.1757676303,
0.1751018614,
-0.3575444221,
0.7373129725,
-0.5734544992,
0.1879095137,
-0.0492976457,
0.1998451203,
-0.3908432722,
0.4277218878,
0.6432400942,
0.8091398478,
-0.3383571804,
1.3457620144,
0.8111990094,
-0.4773221612,
-0.6335477829,
0.3475310802,
-0.0332553759,
-0.7986304164,
0.9651862979,
0.1388003975,
-0.0711418763,
-0.0263818465,
-0.5938339829,
-0.835211277,
1.1862380505,
0.0795794278,
-0.6869126558,
-0.1924773604,
0.2003899962,
0.4735741317,
0.0159988496,
0.5192173123,
0.5895986557,
0.307305187,
-0.0947507843,
-0.6913042068,
-0.3104564548,
-0.2031507045,
0.1495656967,
-0.0091319606,
-0.7229908705,
1.2255346775,
-0.1274892539,
-0.6711682081,
0.2009314597,
0.9479759336,
0.0215566233,
0.2512209713,
0.8341298699,
0.2865512967,
0.8037208319,
-0.1541434675,
0.7956492305,
-0.5438828468,
0.1188397408,
0.8595932126,
-0.1972874403,
0.4216301143,
0.4919836521,
-0.3297083378,
0.7139107585,
0.6810978651,
0.0602055751,
0.610057056,
0.6485412717,
-0.2668479085,
-0.5018647313,
0.2687905729,
-0.4125401676,
0.243145287,
0.3615412414,
-0.2458942831,
-0.4274765253,
-0.0334232599,
-0.2245945632,
0.21584557,
-0.2478902787,
0.5732374191,
0.4278985858,
-0.2514997721,
0.8407546878,
0.055900339,
0.9394635558,
-0.8365943432,
0.0732208118,
0.1000191793,
0.3557273149,
-0.2392794639,
-0.6087269187,
-0.1350386292,
-0.3904980719,
0.0929326862,
-0.1085585654,
0.6937872767,
-0.600153029,
-0.3640468717,
0.6224527955,
0.2481384873,
0.2993911505,
-0.0093895979,
-0.9124624729,
-0.1208924055,
0.0266324803,
-0.0538811609,
0.2503106296,
0.8006852865,
0.0624984279,
0.4689227939,
0.3556636572,
0.1051997319,
0.1007367373,
0.1835384071,
0.7272373438,
-0.5521506071,
-0.706386745,
-0.8680316806,
0.4149070978,
0.0818051621,
-0.2470069975,
0.6530537009,
0.1133957431,
1.2381830215,
-0.0981619135,
0.8951082826,
-0.0430180989,
0.4245799482,
-0.7281188965,
0.9685785174,
-0.9503711462,
0.0541121922,
-0.4749014676,
-0.6225217581,
-0.0682651475,
0.8388044238,
-0.3451777995,
-0.0325457081,
0.8683193326,
0.5013712645,
0.2217155397,
0.0532516688,
0.4952687323,
0.2091533989,
0.2007531971,
1.0080434084,
0.9285479188,
-0.5093345046,
0.5681651831,
-0.2993763685,
-0.3352558017,
0.0263207331,
-0.4608991742,
-1.1849470139,
-0.7246341109,
-0.3129293919,
-0.044944413,
0.2281001508,
0.817766428,
0.3864213228,
-0.8265144229,
-0.3507714868,
-0.129077673,
0.3471960723,
-0.3461362123,
-0.1167948544,
0.4323299527,
-0.9296748042,
-0.9803474545,
0.1847994477,
0.0502220504,
-0.0615498461,
-0.0790467188,
-0.2539332509,
-0.2345590293,
-0.2165382057,
0.6344467998,
0.1185621917,
-0.9052695632,
-0.311311692,
-0.0801030397,
-0.2681359649,
0.1468079388,
0.8939511776,
-0.9162070155,
0.5601593852,
0.5405134559,
0.4770795703,
-0.1312568188,
-0.119450748,
0.4930043519,
-0.3585694432,
0.3246970177,
-0.3758387864,
0.4867263734,
0.1104130968,
-0.1567374766,
0.4146993756,
0.4194214046,
-0.1380658746,
-0.3451810777,
0.3732362092,
-0.8596838713,
-0.610912323,
0.9654818773,
-0.4582868218,
-0.3644466102,
-0.1420646161,
-0.5085943937,
0.6347644329,
0.2719153166,
1.0450694561,
0.9297556877,
0.2936584949,
-0.1773612648,
-0.4154262543,
0.6023975015,
0.634535253,
-0.5686431527,
0.0100138709,
0.1861367375,
0.1991228461,
0.3470994234,
0.4362671971,
-0.2275545001,
0.4318297207,
-0.1413603723,
0.3285602629,
0.0618341602,
-0.4660067558,
0.0073335627,
-0.2133429348,
0.1239502579,
-0.6195673347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18756v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18756v1 | VSTAR: A Video-grounded Dialogue Dataset for Situated Semantic Understanding with Scene and Topic Transitions | 2023-05-30T05:40:37 | 2023-05-30T05:40:37 | Yuxuan Wang, Zilong Zheng, Xueliang Zhao, Jinpeng Li, Yueqian Wang, Dongyan Zhao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Video-grounded dialogue understanding is a challenging problem that requires
machine to perceive, parse and reason over situated semantics extracted from
weakly aligned video and dialogues. Most existing benchmarks treat both
modalities the same as a frame-independent visual understanding task, while
neglecting the intrinsic attributes in multimodal dialogues, such as scene and
topic transitions. In this paper, we present Video-grounded Scene&Topic AwaRe
dialogue (VSTAR) dataset, a large scale video-grounded dialogue understanding
dataset based on 395 TV series. Based on VSTAR, we propose two benchmarks for
video-grounded dialogue understanding: scene segmentation and topic
segmentation, and one benchmark for video-grounded dialogue generation.
Comprehensive experiments are performed on these benchmarks to demonstrate the
importance of multimodal information and segments in video-grounded dialogue
understanding and generation. | [
-0.6816541553,
-0.7449964881,
0.647490561,
0.183504954,
-0.4108075798,
0.025868142,
-0.1671803147,
0.1205955744,
-0.1862912625,
0.4985345304,
-0.8847975731,
-0.5115252733,
-0.5263853669,
-0.1324299723,
-0.2424179763,
0.9015188217,
0.1551416069,
0.2567617297,
-0.4134532213,
-0.5228567719,
-1.00753057,
-0.3917671144,
0.0415551551,
0.0998461545,
0.2190765142,
0.7490795255,
0.5117204189,
0.7132534981,
0.3071454465,
0.4104273617,
-0.1099574938,
-0.0344134904,
-0.5317850113,
0.2768587768,
-0.147861436,
-0.0715419278,
0.0104860747,
-0.2505972683,
0.7846948504,
0.5690701604,
0.1155396923,
0.1984960437,
-0.4345873296,
0.3988434374,
-0.737424314,
0.0197336674,
-0.4976255596,
0.2738962471,
0.218634069,
-0.2311570644,
-0.3113028109,
-0.1015958488,
-0.0659095421,
-0.5211604834,
0.6837553382,
-0.1367734075,
0.9758548737,
0.7017381787,
-0.6629167199,
0.1765210629,
-0.6434417963,
0.5577946305,
-0.0702651441,
0.6575881839,
0.2107803822,
0.6529522538,
0.0384212546,
-0.7964609265,
-0.5159834027,
0.0338179134,
0.0315286852,
0.0367839485,
-0.0335145853,
0.1627194732,
0.5032743812,
0.4431172907,
-0.4140283167,
-0.2772562802,
-0.1524032354,
-0.1852941364,
0.0471339524,
0.3014420569,
0.2479810864,
-1.0704512596,
-0.4476341307,
-0.3088076413,
-0.3463623524,
0.2319077402,
-0.0553885661,
-0.0299807396,
0.0043876604,
0.4540785253,
-0.4264280796,
0.5154711008,
0.0288412739,
-0.1812970191,
0.1903098226,
-0.9269885421,
-0.6058635712,
0.3040508926,
0.3790644407,
0.6156345606,
0.0335457511,
0.3154410124,
0.4287559092,
0.2447306067,
0.4273432791,
-0.997841835,
-0.2602801025,
0.2431289703,
-0.3749872148,
-0.1005825624,
-0.008805912,
-0.7408502102,
-0.4604319632,
-0.499289304,
0.2003765255,
-0.4308002889,
-0.4737479687,
-0.0324755721,
-0.2595813572,
0.5906829238,
0.6539359689,
-0.5257152915,
0.228622213,
0.7901978493,
0.5200260282,
0.5056211352,
-0.184787035,
-0.9275138974,
-0.1070759073,
-0.2004110813,
0.8509585857,
-0.4540701807,
-0.2027652413,
-0.1898983717,
0.1797411442,
-0.099886477,
-0.0997918472,
0.5372518897,
-0.3350341022,
0.2565730512,
-0.6579861045,
-0.1117353812,
-0.4585045278,
0.3777454197,
-0.4224027097,
0.9176275134,
-0.2962492108,
-0.8350356221,
1.0316386223,
-0.1379686296,
-0.1523765475,
-0.3036932647,
-0.5689075589,
-0.2220717818,
0.1132834852,
0.5983211398,
0.3225671947,
-0.2252239138,
0.9330131412,
-0.164655596,
-0.1657048911,
0.1265594363,
-0.6782763004,
0.0812140927,
0.3434005678,
-0.401568979,
0.4737462997,
-0.7690799832,
0.1023379788,
-0.2773543894,
0.4915053546,
-0.2053828686,
0.1681622267,
0.1292851418,
0.4941293001,
-0.1349019259,
-0.3291202486,
-0.1728650928,
0.1476466805,
0.4300273955,
0.7396206856,
0.2382598668,
0.1027476415,
0.2665771246,
0.3047328293,
0.2072748393,
-0.0733552575,
-0.647346437,
-0.2469505072,
-0.7886460423,
-0.4680657089,
-0.057946559,
0.2034688443,
-0.6862570643,
0.2815154195,
-0.3968955278,
-0.2085841149,
-0.2199370861,
-0.1633244753,
0.4429504573,
0.7694079876,
0.1858674288,
-0.2609578073,
-0.5367782712,
-0.8691107631,
0.1538171917,
-0.0868565366,
0.0063780905,
0.7061722279,
0.3213817179,
-0.070759505,
1.067868948,
-0.5177180171,
0.107806243,
-0.1693774611,
0.4085808694,
0.2115743905,
0.2430793196,
0.2660835683,
-1.2841514349,
-0.3336538374,
-0.0357675664,
-0.9955689311,
0.2041766644,
-0.2237173766,
-0.1549377292,
-0.6411296129,
0.7507081032,
-0.2598326802,
0.3868910968,
0.2511497438,
-0.8804183006,
0.2310721427,
-0.0789147243,
0.7803475261,
-1.1865823269,
-0.0405393951,
-0.1092834994,
-0.4620286226,
-0.4410020411,
-0.3689594567,
-0.1563041657,
-0.5753731132,
-0.5950684547,
0.0762103051,
-0.1746139526,
-0.5506997108,
-0.0413561165,
0.257832855,
0.1284008026,
0.6441989541,
0.6263949871,
1.2171610594,
0.519872427,
-0.3832476139,
0.2157853395,
0.8261116147,
-0.538214922,
0.8861344457,
-0.5977869034,
0.0146086281,
-0.4838672578,
0.1448364407,
-1.334408164,
-0.4543839395,
0.0524941385,
-0.2388843298,
-0.1320286542,
-0.4501227438,
-0.1374815851,
0.2285125256,
-0.187407136,
0.6306378841,
0.0880888402,
-0.4683727026,
0.4275771677,
0.2073962688,
-0.2532507479,
-0.7593863606,
0.0647914782,
0.1299366504,
-0.5855258703,
-0.7387461662,
-0.0127716959,
0.1387393475,
-0.133759439,
0.2465436459,
-0.2863402069,
-0.1827355623,
-0.1774472445,
0.7033047676,
-0.1974552125,
-0.6213085651,
0.1701410562,
-0.0633587316,
-0.4593347609,
-0.1384886503,
0.1579672098,
0.4502032697,
-0.3526567221,
-0.3282438219,
-0.2820810974,
0.4330774248,
0.8117957115,
-0.2643188536,
0.5557749271,
0.6887871623,
-0.0332740583,
0.1246959046,
-0.4687407315,
-0.1838897914,
-0.4014277756,
0.5404724479,
-0.5441493392,
-0.9464313388,
0.3260215223,
-0.5480918288,
-0.1453245282,
0.4179347456,
0.5104866624,
-0.0663767755,
0.6425392628,
0.4905691147,
0.252453208,
0.6544215083,
-0.1095824242,
0.0518710129,
-0.6733447909,
-0.1127826497,
-0.4993875027,
-0.0754791871,
-0.3973013163,
-0.7510282397,
0.3976890147,
0.1172439456,
-0.398460865,
0.5442017913,
-0.2656878233,
0.5373907089,
0.3024786711,
-0.0333656222,
0.1857270747,
0.0179093014,
0.221035257,
-0.5376361012,
-0.5935118794,
-0.3242734969,
0.7760689259,
0.3680184782,
0.3168994486,
0.1920328587,
0.0564531274,
0.59115237,
-0.1173363924,
-0.6561183333,
0.583368957,
0.070065327,
-0.4497468174,
-0.1627534032,
-0.2554253936,
-0.4665699005,
0.5517178178,
-0.1142414287,
-0.7166223526,
0.3705416024,
-0.1834141016,
-0.2824318111,
-0.0883646831,
-0.645829916,
1.1922858953,
-0.0369985253,
-0.6707139015,
-0.4588741064,
-0.8996138573,
0.3806710243,
0.3143722117,
0.1795720309,
-0.1563963294,
0.5961853862,
0.5776751041,
-0.5598080158,
0.6094477773,
-0.273853153,
0.344945997,
0.4044767618,
-0.2256535292,
0.0132398456,
0.6090850234,
0.2802909911,
-0.0818104818,
-0.076189898,
-0.1687562019,
-0.5740395784,
0.3254974782,
-0.7057866454,
-0.3810053766,
-0.4615547359,
-0.1390921026,
-0.3151639104,
0.1151331961,
0.1360274404,
0.8547708392,
-0.4253784716,
0.6560277343,
0.9794783592,
-0.3353588581,
0.1895595789,
0.2041210383,
0.045769617,
-0.9001534581,
0.8939337134,
-0.5343908072,
0.1958397031,
0.2762207091,
-0.1752837449,
-0.3422375917,
-0.1488705128,
-0.6801795959,
-0.1711495519,
-1.1520792246,
-0.1494250447,
-0.6808196902,
-0.1709707528,
0.0925967917,
-0.2158531398,
-0.6389306188,
-0.1450425535,
0.0066587329,
-0.5662485957,
0.4894494116,
0.4302531779,
-0.1245180145,
0.458642751,
-0.6580602527,
0.9577937126,
0.6165837646,
0.2011259049,
-0.455073595,
-0.3587056398,
-0.0635124147,
-0.2005466372,
-0.0756689906,
-0.582238853,
0.0379546992,
0.1109029129,
0.3824881613,
0.6427887082,
-0.0894406363,
1.0085915327,
-0.6033242345,
0.9143218994,
0.2657098472,
-0.9755010009,
0.6382386684,
-0.4876120389,
0.075230144,
1.024009943,
0.0330511443,
-0.6234263778,
0.1951739788,
-0.6170544624,
-0.7040641904,
0.7390944362,
0.4556283951,
0.0065238457,
0.1865827292,
-0.1882688999,
0.2241463214,
0.6910569668,
-0.4490966499,
-0.1205884218,
-0.6937347054,
0.2539390028,
-0.3188890517,
-0.2698242366,
-0.2851976156,
-0.4086750448,
-0.0510667451,
-0.1247515455,
0.4187150002,
0.2403647751,
-0.2007444054,
0.0500161536,
0.3329804838,
0.7525810599,
0.461176008,
-0.4697975218,
0.0871190056,
-0.0659826621,
-0.3320701122,
0.3524796963,
-0.1206697747,
0.4046486616,
0.0971721634,
0.3765735626,
1.1772292852,
0.5726260543,
-0.6862835288,
0.4202642441,
-0.3821459115,
-0.1636424512,
-0.1293789744,
0.0105870841,
-0.1945785731,
0.1962287873,
-0.0096672988,
0.2099261433,
0.2708989084,
-0.561788559,
0.6685937047,
0.0965501368,
-0.4835451841,
-0.0665334091,
0.5567650795,
0.3209850788,
0.0412433669,
0.8494547009,
0.1731781363,
-0.5275222659,
0.7280642986,
-0.009827856,
1.0184701681,
0.2855351865,
0.6045994759,
0.4737198353,
0.0025864716,
0.1798779219,
0.1699821949,
-0.9582893252,
-0.7029023767,
-0.5202847123,
-0.4301330149,
-0.5867326856,
0.0404550396,
-0.7919762135,
0.265902251,
-0.444349438,
-0.0810323432,
-0.0812139958,
-0.2161923051,
-0.6583496928,
0.5099834204,
0.0856694579,
0.5994090438,
-1.1690695286,
0.4603085816,
0.4862582386,
-0.2107288837,
-0.6401453614,
-0.0703992322,
-0.0849912167,
-0.3947550356,
0.7620322704,
0.4062773883,
-0.4076582491,
-0.2700014114,
-0.323831439,
-0.6292436123,
0.8358056545,
0.1921187639,
-0.1209455207,
0.3343448341,
0.186063543,
0.4076279104,
-0.1644178778,
0.4107200205,
0.3708545268,
0.4187922776,
0.5394468307,
-0.707921505,
-0.3086473942,
-0.4620766938,
-0.2704538405,
0.4097100198,
-0.573841691,
0.6337729096,
0.1400696933,
-0.0242955778,
-0.1770696491,
0.6494874358,
0.1733543873,
0.7154439092,
0.4754077494,
0.3606118262,
0.2587594986,
-0.2404853106,
0.4621678293,
0.0097667826,
0.220268473,
1.1563025713,
-0.0607161932,
0.4964529276,
0.5253211856,
0.1619946063,
0.4244102538,
0.7268558145,
0.2377598286,
0.7499799728,
-0.181662336,
-0.2306019664,
-0.8877589107,
-0.2831667364,
-0.6238572001,
0.7890046239,
0.5607877374,
-0.2642574012,
-0.525801599,
0.0905925706,
-0.3050894737,
0.2141017467,
0.0145366481,
1.1970887184,
-0.1179177389,
-0.4757013321,
0.5610436797,
-0.1967366189,
-0.1369639635,
-0.7884993553,
-0.3140017688,
-0.201740697,
-0.146928072,
0.0022337299,
-0.8041262031,
0.1437875181,
0.2835118771,
-0.1682222635,
-0.4900639951,
0.4601480663,
-0.0155856088,
-0.1857284456,
-0.2067471296,
0.3553663194,
0.07846573,
0.0177701283,
-0.4091571271,
0.3285339177,
0.1190293431,
-0.2349957228,
0.2362478375,
0.7952461839,
-0.0798610225,
0.4042266309,
0.4763757288,
-0.5498960614,
-0.1781129986,
-0.0570227392,
1.0708886385,
-0.9262594581,
-0.6323466897,
-0.4945639074,
0.8574206233,
-0.3101547956,
-0.5082446337,
0.7667978406,
0.3089128435,
0.4394610822,
-0.1385891289,
0.4739387929,
-0.2241794467,
-0.0557495952,
-0.7427219748,
0.2751388848,
-0.4637170732,
-0.1564341038,
-0.6791622639,
-0.9872248769,
0.1319982857,
0.6804652214,
-0.4915293753,
-0.1484189481,
0.6160131097,
0.4398615658,
-0.3853086233,
0.1846236438,
0.359744072,
-0.0503067188,
0.3672179282,
0.3227039576,
1.0561673641,
-0.3715794981,
0.2282913178,
-0.0643545017,
-0.0541749299,
-0.2152556181,
-1.0515195131,
-0.8873474002,
-0.7415923476,
-0.3153391778,
-0.163119927,
0.1181169525,
0.7296740413,
1.0099349022,
-0.7025020123,
-0.0958440304,
-0.4895735085,
0.1937710494,
-0.2035556585,
-0.2240393907,
0.3142257929,
0.0519108288,
-0.5642880797,
0.6860294938,
0.4617153406,
-0.639238894,
-0.1173427105,
0.0947672129,
-0.0054896958,
-0.1633668393,
0.5350604057,
0.4216829836,
-0.5394453406,
-0.5706924796,
-0.0139872432,
0.2238709182,
0.415032953,
1.2090086937,
-0.963584125,
0.7734313607,
0.5104070902,
0.5666840076,
0.6598142982,
0.6527298689,
0.8636003137,
-0.6560509801,
0.6428132057,
-0.0686834231,
0.1882450581,
0.3638865948,
-0.3053172529,
0.3726333082,
0.3954619467,
-0.3596300185,
-0.8289861679,
0.4714318812,
-1.1271733046,
-0.061968755,
0.895745039,
0.1202916279,
0.1550402492,
-0.2255815119,
-0.6385065913,
0.1252399683,
-0.4369727671,
0.2400843352,
0.6575962901,
-0.0248662829,
-0.4999186099,
-0.6294962764,
0.6058447361,
0.5838999152,
-0.6455595493,
0.3140335381,
0.8348414302,
0.1006940007,
0.0653439611,
0.460770607,
0.3313290179,
0.5324094892,
0.3720782697,
-0.3846877515,
-0.1201755404,
-0.8812012672,
-0.1657464653,
0.3486690521,
-0.1434129328,
-0.4577224553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18752v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18752v1 | GPT4Tools: Teaching Large Language Model to Use Tools via Self-instruction | 2023-05-30T05:27:21 | 2023-05-30T05:27:21 | Rui Yang, Lin Song, Yanwei Li, Sijie Zhao, Yixiao Ge, Xiu Li, Ying Shan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | This paper aims to efficiently enable Large Language Models (LLMs) to use
multimodal tools. Advanced proprietary LLMs, such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, have
shown great potential for tool usage through sophisticated prompt engineering.
Nevertheless, these models typically rely on prohibitive computational costs
and publicly inaccessible data. To address these challenges, we propose the
GPT4Tools based on self-instruct to enable open-source LLMs, such as LLaMA and
OPT, to use tools. It generates an instruction-following dataset by prompting
an advanced teacher with various multi-modal contexts. By using the Low-Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) optimization, our approach facilitates the open-source LLMs
to solve a range of visual problems, including visual comprehension and image
generation. Moreover, we provide a benchmark to evaluate the ability of LLMs to
use tools, which is performed in both zero-shot and fine-tuning ways. Extensive
experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our method on various language
models, which not only significantly improves the accuracy of invoking seen
tools, but also enables the zero-shot capacity for unseen tools. The code and
demo are available at https://github.com/StevenGrove/GPT4Tools. | [
-0.236211583,
-0.8069717288,
0.6800733209,
0.2858873606,
-0.2058440447,
0.0835148916,
-0.3643854558,
-0.0589481294,
-0.2564682066,
0.54313308,
-0.486559391,
-0.7113264799,
-0.3551326394,
0.0502540506,
-0.2181995809,
0.882355094,
-0.1653943211,
-0.0376273245,
-0.0729261562,
-0.0336962864,
-0.618375361,
-0.3187839687,
-0.3966962397,
0.2084002793,
0.371751219,
0.6254124045,
0.6262822747,
0.5189202428,
0.2480976284,
0.3616440594,
0.5349472761,
-0.1082783714,
-0.5120954514,
0.0040154457,
-0.1816062033,
-0.3906973004,
-0.3166259527,
0.1431986839,
0.6185746193,
0.3269872665,
-0.2291937172,
0.210131377,
0.195440039,
0.1947692782,
-0.4664392769,
0.374091506,
-0.6584054828,
-0.0174799822,
-0.1420985907,
-0.3333837986,
-0.4653355181,
-0.373947084,
-0.0673001632,
-0.6899232864,
-0.0051823081,
-0.1922941059,
0.285132587,
0.5755684972,
-0.3802320361,
-0.2854617536,
-0.3158708811,
0.8484406471,
-0.7691147327,
0.4586430192,
0.379142195,
0.5253415108,
-0.1533023715,
-0.7529315948,
-0.4295673072,
-0.3083539307,
0.2233454287,
0.1426212192,
-0.0242029242,
0.1020774841,
0.3290362656,
0.235205248,
-0.4721785784,
0.314263761,
-0.3652687669,
-0.2315426469,
0.1842084378,
0.0172682144,
0.3345355392,
-0.0734423324,
-0.3476245403,
-0.0788277164,
-0.8031330109,
-0.2799477577,
0.216194272,
0.2882669568,
-0.3173493147,
0.5343095064,
0.1498786211,
0.7029089332,
-0.0254529789,
-0.3935308456,
0.3453052938,
-0.3219019473,
-0.2868236303,
-0.2315461636,
0.7903505564,
0.1654544175,
0.2333532125,
-0.0593774617,
-0.1591845155,
-0.2056587785,
0.0182840023,
-0.9596436024,
-0.2718992829,
-0.0554451682,
0.0498564951,
-0.1569228768,
-0.6146762967,
-0.9169810414,
-0.2279942632,
-0.2763013244,
0.9453989863,
-0.2220344841,
0.0442104712,
0.1415722519,
0.1836279035,
0.3193113208,
0.5857974887,
-0.9126832485,
0.0959651917,
0.2546969652,
1.0372754335,
-0.0803489983,
-0.4326708317,
-0.8736314774,
0.3508666158,
-0.3047719598,
0.5053307414,
-0.6177834272,
-0.4831568897,
-0.2204055488,
0.098522678,
0.0230698325,
-0.0769398436,
0.0970486477,
-0.2482668608,
0.5731877089,
-0.0338843167,
-0.3085810244,
-0.2022067159,
0.1530627906,
-0.5048320889,
1.0055232048,
0.254986614,
-0.550601244,
-0.0527598262,
-0.9519874454,
-0.2399455607,
0.1785496175,
-0.5630198121,
-0.2954200506,
-0.0596822724,
0.5824164748,
0.5395910144,
-0.2185105383,
0.149301976,
-0.2886500955,
-0.2368580401,
-0.3174360693,
-0.6709930897,
0.631922543,
-0.0111568021,
-0.6462882757,
0.4940635562,
-0.3539637625,
0.0047868048,
0.3147934973,
-0.3374884725,
-0.0592512041,
-0.3228171468,
-0.2633956671,
0.1569403559,
0.2655400336,
-0.5054172277,
0.6137607098,
-0.281773895,
0.6067093015,
1.0861368179,
-0.1132018864,
0.4154420793,
0.2901535332,
0.8522425294,
-0.2393257916,
0.2437854409,
-0.4889024794,
-0.4879870117,
-0.7490118146,
-0.3790661395,
0.1207902357,
0.4063637853,
-1.1323696375,
-0.0458239689,
-0.119143419,
-0.3205900788,
-0.4870175421,
0.4246941507,
0.3138394356,
0.4949397743,
0.3786170185,
-0.2207295597,
-0.0952062085,
-0.8499252796,
0.0528987646,
0.182996884,
0.0303419363,
0.2151316702,
0.4382874966,
-0.2134772241,
0.7705967426,
-0.4217379391,
-0.2964458764,
-0.2850518823,
0.165054068,
0.2591232061,
0.3551803231,
0.7283026576,
-0.2080354244,
-0.5661007166,
-0.0062962458,
-0.6954639554,
-0.1535439938,
0.0205857977,
-0.1341997683,
0.206281513,
0.5885592699,
-0.2669999003,
0.1848536432,
0.957447648,
-0.0836542398,
0.5893173218,
-0.3804944456,
-0.0616058744,
-0.9559420347,
-0.2573137283,
0.0189080741,
-0.4416728914,
-0.3135160506,
0.0143035017,
0.1295393258,
-0.4735301435,
-0.5848484635,
0.6470342875,
-0.7892466187,
-0.2884584367,
-0.2153887749,
0.0651092678,
-0.1330945343,
0.6275119781,
-0.1474282444,
1.3162889481,
0.7931331396,
-0.1686838418,
0.3200666904,
0.1458998024,
-0.3432984054,
0.2560539246,
-0.5359573364,
0.4593867958,
0.0502524413,
0.096097976,
-0.6724607944,
-0.340454638,
0.396697402,
0.0389099866,
0.3095666766,
-0.5611222982,
-0.6448745728,
-0.2560220361,
-0.4812552333,
0.1194407418,
0.6022503376,
-0.907869339,
0.7279382348,
0.3131024539,
-0.3024809659,
-0.651879549,
-0.4479707778,
0.1766288429,
-0.2078360468,
-0.3779005408,
-0.1078038439,
-0.4282488525,
0.2542102039,
-0.0045152395,
-0.0115088746,
-0.0048387069,
0.0405947752,
0.1486811638,
0.2530507743,
-0.2149268091,
0.2824222147,
0.0956806764,
-0.071118407,
0.0004577455,
-0.2255208343,
0.4865453839,
-0.5484563708,
-0.7243055701,
-0.385086447,
0.1161138564,
0.4857387245,
-0.5238144398,
0.3154003918,
0.8206967115,
0.0489999615,
-0.4563631117,
-0.5409793854,
-0.2626904249,
-0.6521632075,
0.6217677593,
-0.3959977627,
-1.1302515268,
0.0802165568,
-0.1934391111,
0.2415731102,
0.030651981,
0.8379042149,
0.1670522094,
0.9434007406,
0.6953853965,
-0.1004946232,
0.6243679523,
-0.2652031779,
0.0112831751,
-0.6104499698,
0.0857428461,
-0.1403381228,
0.0417569354,
-0.2854298651,
-0.9706560373,
0.6458186507,
-0.1052091941,
-0.2097532302,
0.1217850819,
-0.6025878191,
0.8696450591,
0.7601733208,
-0.0980396196,
0.230074212,
0.0967750996,
-0.0557963997,
0.0727247596,
-0.7850555182,
-0.4631912112,
1.1739993095,
0.4603655636,
1.152936697,
0.094923608,
0.8124369383,
0.0913899615,
0.3745229542,
-0.9540449381,
0.6606114507,
0.0181092527,
-0.3808549643,
-0.4274944961,
-0.3536426723,
-0.7952594161,
0.3730308414,
0.1536394954,
-0.5677384734,
-0.0989769846,
0.2830430865,
-0.2969530225,
0.1730071306,
-1.1241745949,
1.216830492,
-0.7095609903,
-0.5731759071,
-0.1274438351,
-0.4602130949,
0.3708333969,
-0.2275766134,
0.486528486,
-0.1544755548,
-0.1477188617,
0.5168240666,
-0.1958362162,
1.1999843121,
-0.346983999,
-0.4137368798,
0.3763816953,
0.2677270174,
0.5174719691,
-0.1508058757,
0.0567936935,
-0.0829520226,
0.0316782333,
-0.279052943,
-0.6995558739,
1.0070953369,
-0.8029694557,
-0.9099761248,
-0.1745839417,
-0.7609012723,
-0.285017252,
0.317514509,
-0.3867795169,
0.7044782639,
0.1798989773,
0.1461762339,
0.2509733438,
-0.4963398874,
0.5830562115,
0.3655991554,
-0.3956398964,
-0.3193912506,
1.0743314028,
0.1182703599,
0.4531932771,
-0.0771765858,
0.4018092155,
-0.3272614479,
-0.5864921808,
-0.802652657,
0.3081336021,
-1.1272251606,
-0.2178994566,
-0.3422776461,
0.1986789405,
-0.3007668257,
-0.2707153857,
-0.3383641243,
-0.2424526513,
-0.2890880406,
0.0201926604,
0.4386282563,
0.8261630535,
-0.0353761017,
0.5087536573,
-0.7301668525,
0.1641846001,
0.6763935089,
0.4194225073,
-0.089346081,
-0.5092376471,
-0.2301686108,
-0.1558870524,
-0.3472964466,
-0.8046276569,
0.3279682398,
0.3719188273,
0.7152549624,
0.1657708138,
-0.0475295447,
0.6034504175,
-0.6727351546,
0.6625262499,
0.1359841079,
-1.1255170107,
0.5740302801,
-0.5205807686,
0.5409927368,
0.3302111924,
0.5119082928,
-0.2389345616,
-0.1903578043,
-0.1457815021,
-0.5409384966,
0.7911251783,
0.0925303325,
0.2924496531,
0.0445252061,
0.1430135518,
0.1981108636,
0.1152548045,
-1.0448535681,
0.1709220856,
-0.6916168928,
-0.475248307,
-0.1612449586,
-0.1572501659,
-0.1502578557,
-0.1352992654,
0.5910813808,
-0.7037165761,
0.1812931746,
-0.1145504862,
-0.2269680351,
0.0895270854,
0.4031454027,
0.4038429558,
0.7346725464,
0.0263711326,
0.2333742231,
0.3571978509,
-0.3673113585,
0.0552271418,
-0.0410540365,
0.2392449528,
-0.3081277907,
0.2853924036,
0.8061969876,
0.5562421083,
-0.7478591204,
0.6747989058,
0.1302820593,
-0.000273898,
-0.1875038892,
0.1144520119,
0.2672168612,
0.3095730841,
0.0345458016,
-0.4897145331,
0.0266330838,
-0.5623457432,
-0.0454456098,
0.4559758604,
-0.1697558612,
-0.4403160214,
0.6204719543,
0.448887974,
-0.0338346176,
0.4494275749,
-0.2639749944,
-0.4267197847,
0.246299386,
0.7019831538,
0.5256697536,
-0.3940937221,
0.2604118884,
0.2186043411,
0.422603786,
0.0716171637,
0.1984778345,
-0.0106080789,
-0.4635219574,
-0.7920894027,
-0.4681233466,
-0.4959814548,
0.1675763875,
-0.1795762926,
0.4030535221,
-0.4560981393,
0.1084935665,
-0.0610647462,
-0.385530889,
-0.6666728854,
-0.2755001485,
-0.0231610313,
0.6034268141,
-0.5865997076,
1.1227804422,
0.4539235532,
-0.5064835548,
-0.8984334469,
-0.1979021132,
0.2602153122,
-1.1193585396,
0.5979581475,
0.2008658946,
-0.4107964635,
0.5243717432,
-0.8798846006,
-0.8055093884,
1.0310026407,
0.7530806065,
-0.5985463262,
-0.2362633646,
-0.0801023394,
0.2370339781,
-0.1799547076,
0.2600603104,
0.1824868172,
0.47307989,
0.3054490983,
-1.1170532703,
-0.0519129969,
0.1201398969,
-0.3854974806,
0.1117942333,
-0.4353893101,
0.7502030134,
-0.3588551879,
-0.1122511327,
-0.1419453621,
0.351005882,
0.0586425066,
-0.0772041827,
0.549261868,
0.4149534106,
0.282935977,
0.2456120998,
1.0024027824,
-0.1560998708,
0.343203038,
1.3802757263,
-0.1455390751,
0.7836205363,
0.3081687689,
-0.0660638735,
0.3858247697,
0.328669399,
-0.1463592947,
0.40016976,
0.0102680456,
-0.1461830884,
-0.3446267843,
0.1092348471,
-0.3182692528,
0.5913977623,
0.4321219027,
-0.1341367513,
-0.5539187193,
0.2737268806,
0.0662920028,
-0.2299967706,
-0.3404161632,
0.5939438939,
0.0875264034,
-0.255421102,
0.7245761752,
-0.211998269,
0.6390291452,
-0.6651830077,
-0.222456038,
-0.0130891865,
-0.0041179694,
-0.0497547761,
-0.9578428268,
-0.0055305026,
-0.0078816367,
0.3850657046,
-0.1705289334,
0.6090645194,
-0.4497181773,
-0.4924018979,
0.1584451199,
0.718780458,
0.3632551134,
0.0140164811,
-0.747395277,
0.1661743969,
0.0967318714,
-0.275842309,
0.408505708,
0.4713569283,
-0.1140069887,
0.8507890701,
0.6268417835,
-0.1894872934,
0.191772446,
0.3451083004,
1.0458425283,
-0.5572755337,
-0.3064559996,
-0.6819933057,
0.3580848575,
0.1437871009,
0.0054934854,
1.0574210882,
0.3915573955,
0.8613858819,
-0.2343575358,
0.7799686193,
0.1582621634,
0.2866165638,
-0.6070488095,
0.4331068993,
-0.5282429457,
0.1526078284,
-0.3291651905,
-0.9165187478,
-0.2660034895,
0.5585851073,
-0.5643398762,
0.1726061851,
0.5578459501,
0.7515045404,
-0.3822568357,
-0.2618173659,
0.5017815828,
0.2976386547,
0.4797374308,
0.3749536276,
0.7909663916,
0.1619522274,
0.7403945923,
-0.2557887435,
-0.3906334043,
-0.0948762223,
-0.9832790494,
-1.2396985292,
-0.350422442,
-0.2845539153,
0.2333244681,
0.1237557977,
0.942525804,
0.8308933973,
-0.343634814,
-0.2712227702,
0.0979694426,
-0.1467177421,
0.279202342,
-0.1437761784,
0.4424639642,
-0.5591135621,
-0.8767761588,
0.7849786282,
0.3801056743,
0.2205143273,
-0.6719329357,
0.0138179827,
-0.0070365579,
-0.1450239718,
0.8697974086,
0.1740263551,
-0.8462162018,
-0.5863966942,
-0.0728696212,
0.2240663916,
0.1709000915,
0.5441933274,
-0.8176078796,
0.6603044271,
0.0982982144,
0.7908508778,
0.5631279349,
-0.0814039409,
0.5418473482,
-0.69255656,
0.2313216329,
0.1630869359,
0.3432795405,
0.4971375465,
-0.1157721058,
0.5896986723,
-0.0616191104,
-0.6471748948,
-0.7268139124,
0.2269833535,
-0.9107931852,
-0.2369641066,
1.1209404469,
-0.1943167299,
-0.1843188256,
-0.0570741929,
-0.5732931495,
0.0413570814,
-0.4616284668,
0.5698741674,
0.3365864456,
-0.0940363482,
-0.6985898018,
-0.9589372873,
0.1475268006,
0.0853076652,
-1.0877468586,
0.0290916245,
0.6477487087,
0.5125514269,
-0.1487339288,
0.5703777075,
-0.0677649751,
0.1301362365,
-0.0943896919,
0.3970781863,
-0.4308231771,
-0.1926280111,
-0.4154588878,
0.0389997773,
0.3116334677,
-0.1664788425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18747v1 | Adapting Multi-Lingual ASR Models for Handling Multiple Talkers | 2023-05-30T05:05:52 | 2023-05-30T05:05:52 | Chenda Li, Yao Qian, Zhuo Chen, Naoyuki Kanda, Dongmei Wang, Takuya Yoshioka, Yanmin Qian, Michael Zeng | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | State-of-the-art large-scale universal speech models (USMs) show a decent
automatic speech recognition (ASR) performance across multiple domains and
languages. However, it remains a challenge for these models to recognize
overlapped speech, which is often seen in meeting conversations. We propose an
approach to adapt USMs for multi-talker ASR. We first develop an enhanced
version of serialized output training to jointly perform multi-talker ASR and
utterance timestamp prediction. That is, we predict the ASR hypotheses for all
speakers, count the speakers, and estimate the utterance timestamps at the same
time. We further introduce a lightweight adapter module to maintain the
multilingual property of the USMs even when we perform the adaptation with only
a single language. Experimental results obtained using the AMI and AliMeeting
corpora show that our proposed approach effectively transfers the USMs to a
strong multilingual multi-talker ASR model with timestamp prediction
capability. | [
-0.2260040194,
-0.2223938704,
0.1723769158,
0.3353218138,
-0.3643280268,
0.3010406792,
-0.25746122,
-0.8798062205,
0.0073535889,
0.347972244,
-0.199512139,
-0.1927144378,
-0.7558184862,
0.0706504434,
-0.0414831229,
0.6372181177,
0.1257993579,
0.2857114077,
0.0480648652,
-0.4761503637,
-0.6005877852,
-0.9069848657,
-0.6906805634,
-0.406820029,
0.0941782966,
0.4356695414,
0.4421236217,
0.3168883622,
0.1548039317,
0.3623828292,
-0.0449396409,
0.158006072,
0.0041244021,
0.1004723758,
-0.0602616519,
-0.1145222336,
-0.6259503961,
-0.4207086265,
0.8649057746,
0.8539499044,
-0.44368276,
-0.1102191806,
0.1089328527,
0.0406861231,
-0.2586681545,
-0.0454775207,
-0.7489514947,
0.100239858,
-0.0759302527,
-0.4493555427,
-0.5612710118,
0.1608843803,
0.1159798503,
-0.2910435796,
0.1190990657,
-0.0682708919,
0.3443330526,
0.1154243723,
-0.5432428122,
-0.0758907199,
-1.0993205309,
0.6261646152,
-0.7761865258,
0.7370079756,
0.0282906927,
0.5213144422,
-0.0468877442,
-0.3661161661,
-0.5193272829,
0.0287732985,
-0.1177087277,
-0.0369849876,
-0.3697814345,
-0.1094345301,
0.1248248518,
0.1467340142,
-0.8149270415,
0.332839191,
-0.417313695,
-0.3928817809,
0.5707303882,
0.2292466909,
0.2678214014,
0.1245975271,
-0.5632185936,
-0.03926019,
-0.1124733537,
0.0704700351,
0.014125362,
0.5317507982,
-0.097273007,
0.1361757219,
-0.2000436783,
0.8182651997,
-0.0184934828,
-0.0799055398,
0.1783128232,
-0.3716243804,
0.1047011763,
0.1572864354,
0.8707190752,
0.2551602721,
0.2810126543,
-0.2549543083,
0.21815449,
0.0067362869,
0.0764723048,
-0.9157621264,
-0.0916696414,
0.0457012318,
-0.1814045608,
0.3675026298,
-0.0463998728,
-0.8725179434,
-0.2112111002,
-0.290568471,
0.5634995103,
-0.3678263128,
-0.3943174779,
0.3133790493,
-0.0948721766,
0.044610139,
0.2048704326,
-1.0175734758,
0.7261561751,
0.3373123109,
0.8014032245,
-0.1694979668,
-0.7546390891,
-0.8001779318,
0.50548172,
-0.0372396447,
0.9107401967,
-0.6084165573,
-0.5615722537,
-0.3419570625,
0.0200772416,
-0.4233919084,
-0.4192281067,
0.2738929391,
-0.4770109653,
0.0056407079,
0.1880925745,
-0.381185621,
0.0013668976,
0.0672647506,
-0.3488432765,
0.5445138812,
-0.2169499099,
-0.5255590677,
0.276229471,
-0.7837666869,
-0.5806159377,
0.1018845662,
-0.0145423068,
-0.2438947409,
0.0681101605,
0.4639121294,
0.5476657152,
0.0764505416,
0.3280453086,
-0.0894657522,
-0.2832271457,
0.3422689736,
-0.5514015555,
0.7730169892,
0.2027706951,
-0.0258203167,
0.2433564365,
-1.0268932581,
-0.0353227034,
-0.2237821668,
-0.354358077,
-0.2683824599,
0.1335667074,
0.361263454,
0.4114058316,
0.0995715559,
-0.6057909727,
0.1017700508,
-0.0963118523,
0.4416089356,
0.5821415782,
-0.0861866251,
0.4331999421,
-0.2454401255,
0.4133218229,
0.3145476878,
0.0372988917,
-0.3478331268,
-0.1875371337,
-0.7565049529,
-0.2898488641,
0.2270136625,
0.5522653461,
-0.4859713018,
0.360820204,
-0.6655931473,
-0.4965637624,
-0.4207117856,
-0.0265013054,
0.3509156704,
0.1009595022,
0.3939449787,
-0.5202340484,
-0.7210784554,
-0.4535260797,
-0.4925421476,
-0.2442861646,
-0.337187618,
0.2488935888,
0.1626516134,
-0.3057718277,
0.7095858455,
-0.2993194163,
-0.348521322,
-0.1268933862,
0.3179798424,
-0.040563032,
0.4423006475,
0.1869268566,
-0.7742468119,
-0.6347005963,
0.0838448256,
-0.3157356977,
0.0165379699,
-0.0957523063,
0.2371853739,
0.3439126015,
0.5376278162,
-0.1705875993,
0.2002262771,
0.7666362524,
-0.5083904862,
0.4170743227,
-0.1949413866,
0.3036790788,
-1.454564929,
-0.1829581708,
-0.3287616968,
-0.3504036665,
-0.9428630471,
-0.3038175702,
-0.0636350438,
-0.3289014101,
-0.2377810329,
0.8021773696,
-0.6291387081,
-0.4479233921,
-0.280100584,
-0.0200327411,
0.0307231639,
0.4430568814,
0.3495220542,
0.6887507439,
0.7447760105,
-0.7513061762,
0.2154321373,
0.3126555979,
-0.0852415487,
0.770568192,
-0.512503922,
0.4242534339,
0.0503287651,
0.4103848338,
-0.9422815442,
-0.1568839699,
-0.0461699069,
-0.6705924273,
0.5284344554,
-0.329484731,
-0.2205203623,
-0.2396705896,
-0.0249943323,
0.3329932988,
0.0440992676,
-0.8903633952,
1.0699511766,
0.5194118619,
-0.6478180885,
-0.4421898127,
-0.4927281141,
0.333594054,
-0.2355883718,
-0.6362694502,
0.1976569146,
-0.4569998384,
0.1254315376,
-0.3849185407,
-0.1342379302,
-0.3636085391,
-0.0805745125,
0.2772334814,
0.1659483463,
-0.2236330509,
0.0107885282,
-0.2983938754,
-0.2464054972,
-0.304415375,
-0.2877530456,
0.6018579602,
-0.1234565973,
-0.3785901964,
-0.3865404427,
0.5819246173,
0.5238378644,
-0.2293094248,
0.4823266268,
0.9404281974,
-0.5160323381,
0.0727772191,
-0.6751285195,
-0.1253299415,
-0.4065803587,
0.5830423236,
-0.7554511428,
-0.9924170375,
0.5662280321,
0.0169481318,
-0.0218476355,
0.1229122281,
0.3454113603,
0.2637422979,
0.9327291846,
0.7667309642,
-0.3468102515,
0.4905957878,
0.2117299139,
0.0593733415,
-0.8989049196,
-0.1744701266,
-0.6551042199,
-0.1028789654,
-0.4159638882,
-0.678212285,
0.3087412715,
-0.0184157118,
0.1154794395,
0.4100607932,
-0.1469262987,
0.4377776682,
0.2818478942,
-0.2495695651,
0.631152451,
0.140942961,
0.2128455192,
-0.0755449831,
-0.7067513466,
-0.326453954,
0.6978525519,
0.1609182209,
0.7283927202,
0.2930481434,
0.3165275753,
-0.0473783836,
0.0828942582,
-0.5968749523,
0.3355090916,
-0.436649859,
-0.5378904343,
-0.2853884697,
-0.6386454105,
-0.8034958243,
0.6306667328,
0.0737026036,
-1.1578429937,
0.1522102207,
0.2314770222,
-0.2883541584,
0.2408542037,
-0.6031296253,
0.8849366903,
-0.3003877997,
0.0911243409,
-0.2525147498,
-0.8174435496,
-0.0199139044,
-0.0706677139,
0.3978793025,
-0.2464576513,
0.1467694193,
0.8728134036,
0.0758800954,
0.7825844288,
-0.1996487975,
0.2275431752,
0.0621456169,
-0.1725703329,
0.1353084296,
-0.0377238765,
-0.1268820465,
0.5462657213,
0.2175023705,
-0.3002976477,
-0.2461481094,
0.597315371,
-0.7985748053,
-0.1772309989,
-0.5349939466,
-0.8001431227,
-0.5879849195,
0.0788844302,
0.2477477193,
0.8662738204,
-0.6341222525,
-0.1516662389,
0.0314595848,
-0.0525915734,
0.5630255342,
1.1966502666,
-0.1029889435,
-0.3381574154,
0.9082024693,
0.1032915637,
0.33620134,
0.4876151383,
0.3082425892,
-0.4297405183,
-0.5749339461,
-0.688344121,
0.0610151291,
-0.6429101229,
-0.113752611,
-1.0279947519,
-0.3217839003,
-0.6217918992,
-0.1096605361,
-0.345271647,
-0.6292372942,
-0.371838063,
0.2566017509,
0.4278931618,
0.6949765086,
-0.3290682733,
0.5077242851,
-1.040114522,
0.4020051956,
0.4603351653,
0.6080867052,
-0.1235547438,
-1.1730639935,
-0.1518793553,
-0.0523210354,
-0.2684772313,
-0.4922869205,
0.4291572869,
0.7873927951,
0.5000272393,
0.2674749494,
-0.1002353653,
1.0041341782,
-0.9539092779,
0.4171003401,
0.260776341,
-0.9532963634,
0.1978637278,
-0.1646543443,
0.6906748414,
0.3694449067,
0.3742313087,
-0.9687204361,
-0.3382118046,
-0.4126831293,
-0.7387295961,
0.891946137,
-0.2691050172,
0.223280102,
0.3490837216,
-0.0959717482,
0.2271694243,
-0.0584033243,
-0.5488291979,
-0.0981431976,
-0.2017160207,
-0.0116181523,
-0.5459213853,
-0.2867434025,
0.0937253684,
-0.09953437,
0.5078728795,
-0.232128635,
0.0945516303,
-0.1673703343,
-0.3084301353,
-0.2142200619,
0.8725497127,
0.5548906326,
0.7691423297,
-0.2831683755,
0.3122482002,
0.271399349,
-0.3034368753,
0.1962837279,
0.7949041724,
0.3672669828,
0.1999994218,
0.0712651461,
0.9303811193,
0.4364001453,
-0.503077805,
0.222293362,
-0.3293045461,
0.0935051218,
-0.3061881065,
-0.2067160606,
0.2187089175,
0.3674316704,
0.4169004858,
0.3856834173,
0.3200760186,
-0.5245139003,
0.3691034019,
0.3536103964,
-0.390663743,
-0.6838021874,
0.7736360431,
0.2893632948,
-0.5415732861,
0.1131321341,
-0.1722985059,
-0.8332425356,
0.2376165986,
0.8729265332,
0.5946958661,
-1.0238229036,
-0.1627335697,
0.3934841752,
0.040224269,
-0.0476291366,
0.1039470956,
-0.0795453191,
-0.9470456839,
-0.4453692734,
-0.697712183,
-0.5706585646,
-0.0081397761,
-0.7407750487,
0.135489881,
-0.0531565435,
0.0139083993,
0.3159239888,
-0.1388941705,
-0.4843626022,
-0.0580948144,
0.4858578444,
0.4911274612,
-0.9879379869,
0.8442345858,
0.6860132813,
-0.0287172608,
-0.5364578962,
-0.0676284134,
0.1356518418,
-0.5663089752,
0.0397902392,
0.2685072124,
-0.2967707515,
0.092114538,
0.0549791716,
-0.8207773566,
0.8499304056,
0.28362602,
-0.6552183628,
0.2952741385,
0.1170385927,
0.4718026519,
-0.3924100995,
0.0930499285,
0.4470846355,
0.0210013054,
0.2895101905,
-1.3807113171,
-0.2042200118,
-0.2323969752,
-0.0126974918,
0.2996720374,
-0.6350318193,
0.6102090478,
-0.3449787796,
-0.1112556383,
-0.0094085298,
0.65728122,
0.3966089189,
0.3930211663,
0.7531896234,
0.1086003035,
0.6037617922,
0.2611534595,
0.6998829246,
-0.0401751697,
0.0275043398,
1.5391032696,
-0.5352173448,
1.1594969034,
0.3229894936,
-0.2294496596,
0.233755365,
0.2800534368,
0.1309310198,
0.2903875411,
-0.0171574634,
-0.3807817101,
-0.1062046587,
-0.2974776328,
-0.344350785,
0.9398864508,
0.410785228,
0.2109044045,
0.0650021434,
0.1343302131,
-0.0719268471,
-0.0026192253,
-0.2530271113,
0.9206429124,
0.1018728241,
-0.4623799622,
0.4603226185,
-0.0059360838,
0.8507226706,
-0.4702936113,
0.0346517302,
0.0917992443,
0.3905584216,
-0.1204450279,
-0.2917565703,
0.4231069684,
0.06171849,
-0.3587376177,
-0.1452854276,
0.8666428328,
-0.9795184731,
-0.6279299855,
0.6334810853,
0.4365763366,
0.4304026067,
-0.0264093596,
-0.4440028071,
0.2850939035,
-0.1280866712,
0.0739110708,
0.4934726059,
0.1682049334,
0.0191155896,
0.4576984048,
0.3925723135,
0.0930141211,
0.3496131301,
0.5389063954,
0.6711388826,
-0.4374825656,
-0.6996465325,
-0.6855494976,
0.4483485818,
0.0155692818,
-0.0162508208,
0.5716062188,
0.5517359972,
0.7790881991,
0.09519355,
0.7117410898,
0.1572333425,
0.8624836802,
-0.3185918927,
0.6169641614,
-0.44521451,
0.1960123926,
-0.3191585839,
-0.7058147192,
-0.2931891382,
0.5999968052,
0.0657730252,
0.0178153273,
0.3458292186,
0.5373818278,
-0.3087102175,
0.2100881636,
0.570407629,
0.2325677574,
0.3253620267,
0.6406513453,
0.8239714503,
-0.6064724922,
0.9517089725,
-0.228349179,
-0.1765351892,
-0.2076134682,
-0.8565564156,
-0.812877655,
-0.6282439828,
-0.3648476005,
0.0918934941,
0.0300531778,
0.8114245534,
0.936372757,
-0.9805278182,
-0.5921272039,
0.5484772325,
-0.3244725168,
-0.200875327,
-0.1564413309,
0.1645135581,
-0.0115552889,
-0.7887812257,
0.7634717822,
0.3504558206,
0.1347714216,
0.3358944058,
-0.2345580757,
-0.2474855632,
-0.0431705154,
0.5491961241,
0.3081496358,
-0.5028232336,
-0.301125735,
-0.1084198281,
0.2926110327,
0.2639837265,
0.7534183264,
-0.3733409643,
0.819539845,
-0.0338835344,
0.5502374768,
0.5954924226,
0.061618574,
0.7563835382,
-1.1188194752,
0.4106255174,
0.1701863259,
0.4873306751,
0.7635666132,
-0.0175542217,
0.2447725236,
-0.1090362594,
-0.6792693138,
-0.8315332532,
0.2200754732,
-0.9291517138,
-0.1262518466,
0.98065418,
-0.1685862988,
0.4393244088,
-0.5288071632,
-0.0092087854,
0.4766539037,
-0.4391244054,
0.5970721245,
0.6951346397,
-0.1989821643,
-0.2994609773,
-0.4834193289,
0.120672971,
0.2540474832,
-0.8960567713,
0.2478592545,
0.4847553074,
0.4676300883,
0.4490349591,
1.0560292006,
-0.0011158641,
0.1980859041,
0.0681078807,
0.2505365014,
0.0932525918,
-0.4821424186,
-0.901355505,
-0.215854764,
0.3696335852,
-0.3809086382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18742v1 | Graph Reasoning for Question Answering with Triplet Retrieval | 2023-05-30T04:46:28 | 2023-05-30T04:46:28 | Shiyang Li, Yifan Gao, Haoming Jiang, Qingyu Yin, Zheng Li, Xifeng Yan, Chao Zhang, Bing Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Answering complex questions often requires reasoning over knowledge graphs
(KGs). State-of-the-art methods often utilize entities in questions to retrieve
local subgraphs, which are then fed into KG encoder, e.g. graph neural networks
(GNNs), to model their local structures and integrated into language models for
question answering. However, this paradigm constrains retrieved knowledge in
local subgraphs and discards more diverse triplets buried in KGs that are
disconnected but useful for question answering. In this paper, we propose a
simple yet effective method to first retrieve the most relevant triplets from
KGs and then rerank them, which are then concatenated with questions to be fed
into language models. Extensive results on both CommonsenseQA and OpenbookQA
datasets show that our method can outperform state-of-the-art up to 4.6%
absolute accuracy. | [
-0.3662335277,
-0.9257953167,
0.6912961602,
-0.1475677937,
-0.1447595805,
0.3903361857,
0.1453949064,
-0.4029801786,
0.0973556116,
0.5258772373,
-0.1471160799,
-0.5766978264,
-0.5736983418,
0.2224084735,
-0.1481354535,
0.7045331001,
-0.4307760894,
-0.0570879579,
-0.5479841232,
-0.1828151792,
-0.3406754732,
-0.5391511917,
-0.7558692694,
-0.5767807961,
0.7932935357,
0.4796414971,
0.8262144327,
0.3312562406,
0.2135034502,
0.2367319763,
-0.2782886624,
0.6129383445,
-0.5272189379,
0.1742728949,
-0.003196049,
-0.4315291345,
-0.1642436981,
-0.207742691,
0.5735710859,
1.0534853935,
0.1718479097,
0.1470223665,
-0.0163640417,
0.686131835,
-0.4842611849,
0.3714804053,
-0.4295201898,
0.0825754851,
0.0856481269,
-0.0614431426,
-0.4447664618,
-1.0095455647,
0.1751313061,
-0.7275128961,
0.1266947836,
0.0771898627,
0.6318975091,
0.0927117765,
-0.7357666492,
-0.2028767765,
-0.4979012012,
0.3598041832,
-0.4228981435,
0.5529859066,
0.4591055214,
0.4870322049,
-0.2215498537,
-0.831327796,
-0.5983473063,
-0.1387539953,
-0.3623878062,
0.0471903346,
-0.3059587181,
0.0431477688,
0.330335021,
0.327162534,
-0.528136909,
-0.1811830699,
-0.425565064,
-0.2265936583,
0.4528648853,
0.0226498842,
0.4038527012,
-0.3465356529,
-0.1127008647,
0.0710744038,
-0.6811675429,
0.111904338,
0.5378816724,
0.2848651409,
0.5486778021,
0.6502331495,
-0.5624392629,
0.9726964235,
0.0140199224,
0.0638612956,
0.3394008577,
-0.2867509127,
-0.0238380674,
-0.175270319,
0.5596463084,
0.2917708158,
0.5975079536,
-0.5059021711,
0.1488945186,
-0.2320908904,
0.0180962961,
-0.621447742,
-0.5130958557,
0.3462138176,
-0.1361943483,
-0.0904468,
-0.2942478657,
-0.5565160513,
-0.2886548936,
-0.2241424322,
0.5699384212,
-0.3803536594,
-0.4390105307,
0.205606699,
-0.3740193844,
0.1063812599,
0.2628067136,
-0.7202053666,
0.1851496547,
0.5429484248,
0.5054578781,
0.1478278041,
-0.2488175929,
-0.5111355186,
0.1926662624,
-0.3238987923,
0.7359064817,
-0.5294293165,
-0.0740784556,
-0.0902010277,
0.0178138074,
-0.232380718,
-0.5936688185,
0.3407672048,
-0.9583167434,
0.0270697735,
-0.48619771,
-0.7099962831,
-0.4729144871,
0.679777801,
-0.6831955314,
0.9755443931,
0.2829874456,
-0.8166066408,
0.0922659487,
-0.448639065,
-0.4772788882,
-0.0185449775,
-0.0134955207,
-0.190685764,
-0.372885406,
0.8054000139,
0.3967304528,
-0.2367420048,
0.2878457308,
-0.4101166129,
-0.1965340823,
-0.0225470476,
-0.1387502104,
0.7249745727,
0.0613971874,
0.1515389085,
-0.1321723908,
-0.3826763332,
0.4084855616,
0.1725218296,
-0.3389563262,
-0.2524961829,
-0.1643185318,
-0.7993778586,
-0.0671860948,
0.045538187,
-0.8674988747,
0.4044765532,
-0.3388499916,
0.5120058656,
0.329063803,
0.2588382959,
0.2319548875,
-0.2314313054,
0.4132704139,
-0.018370185,
0.0231515728,
0.3816564083,
-0.8853387833,
-0.5406085253,
0.099708721,
0.3321154714,
0.5543330312,
-1.2788846493,
-0.0998325944,
-0.4825259745,
-0.6845968366,
-0.4452941716,
-0.0577392466,
0.4798078835,
0.798902452,
0.6302073598,
0.0861855894,
-0.3070918918,
-1.1162122488,
-0.3888196349,
-0.1939732283,
0.0744812861,
0.365277499,
0.5392645001,
0.1109765172,
1.217607379,
-0.9453037977,
0.2586620152,
-0.3900592327,
0.2290527821,
0.1553402245,
0.4031117558,
0.3205042183,
-0.9803458452,
-0.562645793,
-0.1174655259,
-0.8668909073,
0.1241639182,
0.4921140075,
-0.2198052257,
-0.1160839424,
0.5677042007,
-0.6552894711,
0.417681396,
0.2753302157,
-0.0443329625,
0.3945566416,
0.0427963361,
0.1251405478,
-0.9672859311,
0.005485293,
-0.2894944847,
-0.4792897105,
-0.6924855709,
0.1340706348,
-0.076555118,
-0.1712929904,
-0.2983182073,
0.459269613,
-0.4109589756,
-0.1903515905,
0.1625510007,
0.2988504767,
0.2804548442,
0.6503766775,
-0.1448952109,
0.579161942,
0.2903831005,
-0.4431478083,
0.9143161178,
0.420335412,
-0.3633585572,
0.2732774019,
-0.7182917595,
0.5157244802,
-0.4164039195,
0.5112566352,
-1.1154209375,
-0.1082113609,
0.2832968235,
-0.5957257748,
0.2972120345,
-0.6930247545,
-0.6237002611,
-0.7842948437,
0.0654286146,
0.6931185722,
0.2200869024,
-0.7293211222,
0.7282165885,
0.4184575081,
-0.1071929708,
-0.7264419794,
-0.4926059544,
-0.1922428757,
0.178081125,
-0.9075649977,
0.0293331947,
0.0213454831,
0.0694443136,
0.3439538181,
-0.1730442494,
-0.1040002108,
0.0654179901,
-0.2061171085,
-0.0841790438,
-0.279050231,
0.1986099929,
0.0144967809,
-0.417337209,
-0.0776543394,
-0.7232953906,
0.5377460122,
-0.3748808801,
-0.4937515259,
-0.1772521287,
0.565948844,
0.602263689,
-0.2939847112,
0.544265151,
0.3240690529,
-0.576967299,
0.1543179452,
-0.4335280359,
0.0033417118,
-0.4139648676,
0.4353867471,
-0.527672112,
-1.0743147135,
0.5157857537,
-0.1474599689,
-0.1642480195,
0.2242471725,
0.3100364506,
-0.1001711488,
1.3344243765,
0.0016805237,
0.0959887281,
-0.0628984421,
-0.4183264077,
0.5231941342,
-0.9922213554,
-0.4351059198,
-0.4065930843,
-0.3228997588,
-0.4567150176,
-0.2956367731,
0.451967448,
0.3323833942,
-0.4744755626,
0.1792007387,
-0.5379337668,
0.8583452106,
0.8414034247,
0.2447454035,
0.3213857114,
-0.1425912976,
-0.3881653845,
0.3679189086,
-0.8370554447,
-0.2586589754,
0.9434761405,
-0.0218511429,
0.5469225049,
0.4414178431,
0.615005672,
-0.1718737185,
0.4206131995,
-0.6005711555,
0.5992332101,
-0.1782916784,
-0.7851819396,
-0.5290424824,
-0.7632499337,
-0.9920687675,
0.4026363194,
0.016337201,
-0.9522145987,
0.0683785379,
0.1232710853,
-0.4626249969,
0.6403827071,
-0.8288423419,
0.9423524737,
0.2068196833,
-0.0203828141,
0.2818387151,
-0.640717268,
0.3543183804,
0.242274493,
-0.0737804696,
-0.02779123,
0.4637767673,
0.6685121655,
-0.4384523928,
0.6627362967,
-0.3275983334,
0.0840151832,
0.4852995276,
0.179350704,
0.6322824955,
0.0708754808,
-0.1024321839,
-0.0811680555,
0.1694340408,
-0.4738223851,
-1.0244184732,
0.6396479607,
-0.9141235352,
-0.8250903487,
-0.0547939725,
-0.5757123828,
-0.6031380296,
0.3855767846,
0.2092873305,
0.7810639143,
0.3022568822,
0.225590378,
0.6228212714,
0.0055177151,
0.0133882388,
0.0216382761,
-0.4515292943,
-0.7155855894,
0.9671577811,
0.494335264,
0.5784016848,
0.4742786586,
0.33867836,
-0.565285027,
-0.5920417309,
-0.5611637235,
0.1449776739,
-1.1062128544,
-0.3758465052,
-0.8934913278,
-0.3914226592,
-0.6168992519,
-0.0840976983,
-0.1613185257,
-0.6969237328,
0.140670225,
-0.3734183908,
0.3079721332,
0.6531333923,
0.0764166713,
-0.0128378915,
-0.8166254759,
0.6440650225,
0.8817028403,
0.4084606171,
0.1089010909,
-0.0635389611,
0.0307942629,
0.1177041009,
-0.1146284789,
-1.0693029165,
-0.0620380044,
-0.1996692717,
0.703215301,
-0.1055061594,
0.191565007,
0.676446557,
-0.2655501068,
0.5996886492,
-0.1122284159,
-0.7619143128,
0.5256823301,
-0.3779925406,
0.1754028946,
0.5925444961,
0.5231820941,
-0.6560245156,
-0.3228213191,
-0.6033909321,
-0.8877174258,
0.631864965,
0.3459343314,
-0.137524873,
-0.2146990299,
0.613632977,
-0.2047447264,
0.1754986048,
-0.5452513695,
-0.3211546242,
-0.2771840394,
-0.2987924814,
0.2092588544,
-0.1603991389,
-0.2121929973,
-0.5161107779,
0.7014312744,
-0.4034890831,
0.2089369595,
0.3256267309,
-0.1044326499,
0.0439974293,
0.0679637641,
0.0945220068,
0.5767136216,
-0.2394649386,
0.3865079582,
0.3966594934,
-0.2631634474,
0.090499647,
0.1663373858,
-0.3777603507,
-0.2185295522,
0.3905457854,
0.4516588449,
0.0801616758,
-0.0686789826,
0.4557023346,
-0.0724349394,
-0.1731851399,
-0.0270557217,
-0.1061491296,
0.5414730906,
0.2205658108,
0.2120199353,
-0.0355677418,
-0.143821314,
-0.4726406932,
0.1643606424,
0.2624016106,
-0.3219354451,
0.0812994763,
0.3938871622,
0.1608864814,
-0.2283378541,
1.0284963846,
-0.3280729949,
-1.0099656582,
0.7859594226,
0.7208549976,
0.5837450624,
0.0955759138,
0.2444521487,
0.6632935405,
0.3397849202,
0.0641259626,
0.4954244792,
0.1055862829,
-1.0897469521,
-0.3910298645,
-0.320048362,
-0.5002301335,
-0.130922392,
-0.5337962508,
-0.1609273404,
-0.3644093871,
0.0689419806,
0.07013309,
0.046410054,
-0.5107288957,
0.2122723311,
0.2327292264,
0.832411468,
-0.6692506671,
0.6192799807,
0.609559834,
-0.6628954411,
-1.1413427591,
-0.1256180257,
-0.2084351778,
-0.9058129191,
0.7491630316,
0.1897229105,
-0.2295821011,
0.4691483676,
-0.6707596779,
-1.1977434158,
1.1186468601,
0.4053704143,
0.0284695011,
0.0069775162,
0.2286691219,
0.2120884806,
-0.221814394,
0.3767951131,
0.5441635847,
0.572009325,
0.4779270589,
-0.6753911376,
0.1654122025,
-0.2483320087,
-0.1956998408,
0.4476033449,
-0.5180770159,
0.8460322618,
-0.3080776632,
-0.2114409357,
-0.2023391277,
0.6912524104,
0.3500186503,
0.2182113826,
0.6589335203,
0.7279223204,
1.2288179398,
-0.2539942265,
1.1108700037,
0.0888813734,
0.3882779479,
1.091242075,
-0.2157778889,
0.5885087848,
0.1554589123,
-0.0628960431,
0.6056577563,
0.7200452685,
0.2609484494,
0.342407465,
0.3749314249,
-0.1228402033,
-0.7656252384,
-0.1259063482,
-0.3726364374,
0.240194276,
0.139506802,
0.0998829454,
-0.4557160735,
-0.1902301311,
0.2966938019,
-0.0948523432,
-0.225883022,
0.5946574211,
-0.0728549287,
-0.9129202962,
0.5980551839,
-0.2801161408,
-0.0264734812,
-0.4411355555,
-0.1117270365,
-0.4064848721,
-0.0409632809,
-0.2452365011,
-1.166002512,
0.2589278817,
-0.1946902424,
-0.2238849849,
-0.0716574565,
0.7402539849,
-0.5083023906,
-0.5827235579,
0.2425850034,
0.6200555563,
0.0155726112,
-0.0918647051,
-0.3885042369,
-0.5476431847,
-0.0198499486,
-0.1486701518,
-0.0127400868,
0.5208799243,
-0.1352500618,
0.8934671879,
0.884000361,
-0.2594803274,
0.0111019053,
0.2862280905,
1.1119799614,
-0.4633421898,
-0.4645215571,
-0.603767395,
0.2334505171,
-0.285382241,
-0.2285532057,
0.6211388111,
0.6196379662,
0.7183911204,
0.3184839189,
0.7366515398,
0.0367358662,
0.5478820801,
-0.5938789248,
0.5490286946,
-0.4463815987,
-0.0420028158,
-0.243647024,
-0.6173432469,
-0.6644971967,
0.4046426415,
-0.6153764725,
0.0324170142,
0.8097028136,
0.7513321042,
-0.0149753504,
0.4355813265,
0.1286042333,
0.220867455,
0.5016745925,
0.8803611398,
1.1245758533,
-0.2744720876,
0.8411152363,
-0.2292768061,
-0.0447586738,
-0.0031801832,
-0.7083950639,
-0.6875811219,
-0.3764205575,
-0.2932407558,
-0.4510890841,
-0.0086750677,
0.6816117167,
0.5137904286,
-0.606223762,
0.402556628,
0.0953802168,
0.7415199876,
-0.2452070266,
-0.163743481,
0.69037503,
-0.1278100014,
-0.4830821157,
0.3315755427,
0.0305490736,
-0.1436734498,
-0.0297573972,
0.1498155445,
-0.4532030821,
-0.1427256912,
0.5270285606,
0.307669431,
-0.5070573688,
-0.9403597713,
0.0175936557,
0.0238345489,
0.1605969071,
0.7316327095,
-0.9393200874,
0.4376824796,
0.8659499288,
0.6769501567,
0.6786715388,
0.1261869222,
0.4873365164,
-0.8658168316,
-0.4639608562,
0.4987755716,
0.4941465557,
0.4981286824,
-0.2812202275,
0.6357216835,
0.3786041141,
-0.4871389568,
-0.5727647543,
0.5270456672,
-0.7198207378,
-0.1975679398,
1.2675522566,
-0.2647998631,
-0.1631971747,
-0.6239016652,
-0.0984276533,
0.415977478,
0.0624062568,
0.205122456,
0.6449561119,
-0.3374996185,
-0.0059680119,
-0.4385070801,
0.227477625,
0.2084158361,
-0.6815698743,
0.1658922434,
0.3117561936,
0.3584810495,
0.3637081981,
0.8437855244,
-0.0155847734,
0.0611461997,
0.0766208097,
-0.2176940292,
-0.4009465575,
-0.3068067729,
0.2251042277,
0.5990862846,
-0.1094287559,
-0.1657455266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18741v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18741v1 | Grokking of Hierarchical Structure in Vanilla Transformers | 2023-05-30T04:34:13 | 2023-05-30T04:34:13 | Shikhar Murty, Pratyusha Sharma, Jacob Andreas, Christopher D. Manning | cs.CL | cs.CL | For humans, language production and comprehension is sensitive to the
hierarchical structure of sentences. In natural language processing, past work
has questioned how effectively neural sequence models like transformers capture
this hierarchical structure when generalizing to structurally novel inputs. We
show that transformer language models can learn to generalize hierarchically
after training for extremely long periods -- far beyond the point when
in-domain accuracy has saturated. We call this phenomenon \emph{structural
grokking}. On multiple datasets, structural grokking exhibits inverted U-shaped
scaling in model depth: intermediate-depth models generalize better than both
very deep and very shallow transformers. When analyzing the relationship
between model-internal properties and grokking, we find that optimal depth for
grokking can be identified using the tree-structuredness metric of
\citet{murty2023projections}. Overall, our work provides strong evidence that,
with extended training, vanilla transformers discover and use hierarchical
structure. | [
-0.1437913477,
-0.9133975506,
0.4310171604,
0.1361799091,
-0.0461807325,
0.2088847011,
-0.0561330095,
-0.6766104102,
-0.0506856665,
0.35738042,
-0.5187528729,
-0.393375963,
-0.6240078807,
-0.1690222323,
-0.4950783551,
1.1115785837,
0.2607870102,
-0.279294908,
-0.051519651,
0.0772331581,
-0.3552196324,
-0.6266822815,
-0.5311721563,
-0.7391136885,
0.3878816962,
0.4127651751,
1.1179711819,
0.8826729059,
0.4016831815,
0.3857115209,
-0.3349578679,
-0.2830588818,
-0.4788500667,
0.2355333567,
-0.0698702931,
-0.596214354,
-0.440608114,
-0.3268668354,
0.5805372596,
0.982609868,
-0.222321257,
0.1468646228,
0.1915091574,
0.8663498759,
-0.1368221641,
0.4505999982,
-0.7677906752,
0.1555018276,
-0.2054419965,
-0.2631731629,
-0.5703294873,
0.0351217799,
0.314371109,
-0.5032436252,
0.8129652143,
-0.0719711259,
1.0024533272,
0.0525638349,
-0.4909339845,
-0.0991040617,
-0.9367650747,
0.5479624867,
-0.5824831128,
0.485560149,
0.5246207714,
0.5280553699,
-0.1498131007,
-0.9989269972,
-0.0559842326,
-0.4184596837,
-0.6268789768,
0.0832540914,
-0.0477843396,
0.4850785136,
0.3623863757,
0.6991535425,
-0.5491328835,
0.0084126368,
-0.3776681721,
-0.0961981863,
0.1916172951,
0.3184553683,
0.4720716774,
-0.391929239,
-0.1183881611,
-0.3163152039,
-0.2393038869,
0.4048945904,
0.7408425212,
0.4514974058,
-0.0321595185,
0.536861062,
-0.3524830341,
0.430567503,
0.3966338336,
-0.0583155788,
0.252335757,
-0.0504923873,
-0.4025369287,
-0.1896945685,
0.3398140371,
0.2444514632,
0.4217480123,
-0.5222088099,
-0.2570461333,
0.1377989501,
0.6693797112,
-0.5517974496,
-0.6045845151,
0.1594970077,
-0.537923336,
-0.3654460311,
0.2898019254,
-0.5390887856,
-0.0384071097,
-0.2259158492,
0.1785936803,
-0.2938021123,
-0.2825268805,
0.3224658966,
-0.333481133,
0.2977876365,
-0.1161053479,
-1.5478255749,
0.7599957585,
0.7006784678,
0.899641633,
0.0587154552,
-0.4141428769,
-0.1634229273,
0.247021839,
-0.3913038969,
0.7728940248,
-0.5869809985,
-0.1806098521,
-0.0227522478,
0.2385349423,
0.0045963293,
-0.6656913757,
0.5159673095,
-0.4388464093,
0.110764496,
0.147915557,
-0.2900210917,
-0.0552908964,
0.1826065332,
-0.5512843728,
1.2193017006,
0.3291251659,
-0.8365338445,
0.6056893468,
-0.397136271,
-0.5641550422,
0.1081626192,
-0.2170233428,
-0.4505585432,
0.6404571533,
0.3299761415,
0.5420417786,
0.0249666143,
0.3752358556,
-0.0568714403,
-0.1611250937,
-0.275287807,
-0.1192108691,
0.4931139648,
-0.0978445038,
-0.2787803411,
0.2198063433,
-0.679984808,
0.0326689407,
0.26576671,
-0.546107769,
-0.4743541479,
-0.0146780591,
-0.0508735962,
0.0196800008,
-0.2708100379,
-0.4214246869,
0.4792036712,
-0.6577224135,
0.4292238355,
0.5889576674,
-0.0245895926,
0.9676673412,
-0.2275474966,
0.5248468518,
-0.1253845692,
0.1162883267,
-0.2983806133,
-0.4080637395,
-0.584967196,
-0.1533734947,
0.047109846,
0.2946357429,
-0.3924993575,
0.4164575934,
-0.352853924,
-0.4338116944,
-0.1705440283,
-0.2756816447,
0.1440217346,
0.6637818813,
0.452473402,
-0.2184333652,
-0.4291441739,
-1.2490193844,
-0.4008950293,
-0.2391655594,
-0.431958884,
0.0960474685,
0.3920331597,
-0.4064384401,
0.8416381478,
-0.6159414053,
-0.1581633687,
-0.3559376001,
0.5018516183,
0.4570216537,
0.3059509397,
0.6095434427,
-0.6514716744,
-0.6098383665,
0.4033039808,
-0.4396370947,
0.0133928247,
-0.1975591779,
-0.0582341179,
0.1083446667,
0.5569500327,
-0.9030057788,
0.2691656649,
0.477281332,
-0.2694676816,
0.7126476765,
-0.2632618546,
-0.070412308,
-0.9772130251,
-0.0645597801,
-0.2533521354,
-0.3341997862,
-0.8843946457,
0.1712666899,
0.2118181139,
0.1139931902,
-0.159156099,
0.2071000636,
-0.595688045,
-0.1793082356,
-0.0401664823,
-0.3805671334,
-0.1792622209,
0.6830536127,
-0.0149080651,
0.2922520936,
0.5021960139,
-0.5491146445,
0.2614281774,
0.0932457447,
-0.4625382125,
0.4414402843,
-0.8793978691,
0.0890530571,
-0.1735957414,
0.2730303407,
-1.2026232481,
-0.6306031942,
-0.0386376642,
-0.5409702063,
0.3074756563,
-0.5660370588,
-0.5491824746,
-0.3670107126,
-0.1008282676,
0.3804089725,
0.6406125426,
-0.5326749086,
0.8436736465,
0.17202802,
-0.2786794901,
-0.5557737947,
-0.7251774073,
-0.056678284,
-0.281596303,
-1.0208355188,
0.4958229661,
0.1643677056,
-0.1666217446,
0.082004495,
-0.530000031,
-0.2092111409,
0.0437632389,
0.3705377579,
-0.0951032713,
-0.3688999414,
0.2394500077,
0.1897271276,
-0.2982168496,
0.2164803892,
-0.2907611132,
0.692871511,
-0.2326470166,
-0.1449730545,
-0.2444001287,
0.1721579432,
0.7743401527,
0.1859361529,
0.540879488,
0.2231848538,
-0.3834130466,
-0.3188995421,
-0.2994980812,
-0.3769534826,
-0.5358988047,
0.6868295074,
-0.5807637572,
-0.7617884874,
0.7576822639,
0.091092743,
0.0005729193,
0.5651552677,
0.4377444386,
-0.2359407842,
1.1375256777,
0.9165319204,
-0.1276363879,
0.3248379827,
-0.2093180418,
0.1077494845,
-0.5169833899,
-0.2543455362,
-0.5727530122,
-0.4940129817,
-0.4143181145,
0.0977231413,
0.001868718,
-0.019960802,
-0.0850380287,
0.3977358937,
-0.3165555596,
0.8201208711,
0.3733679652,
-0.1248857304,
0.4492984712,
0.4272898734,
-0.2742495239,
-0.0034423182,
-0.5483848453,
-0.2534473836,
0.5260925889,
0.7473871708,
0.9883112311,
-0.2559799254,
0.3175903857,
0.0924902484,
-0.033838518,
-1.0512022972,
0.1990441531,
-0.0698805302,
-0.7014844418,
-0.5734555125,
-0.461068958,
-1.0168144703,
0.2699005902,
0.0862292796,
-0.6719596982,
0.090794608,
0.2738658488,
-0.1380404383,
0.413797617,
-0.7770453095,
0.7556120157,
0.0784808248,
0.3061057627,
-0.0150431925,
-0.844132185,
0.2057379335,
0.210530594,
0.005571655,
0.227217719,
0.3145574927,
0.4303616285,
-0.1328517795,
0.9423463345,
-0.1013836414,
-0.2827335596,
-0.0357982889,
0.4536946118,
0.5584568381,
0.1257404983,
0.4649409652,
0.0286177564,
-0.2648909688,
-0.5348092318,
-0.8801444769,
0.3843213916,
-0.8169565797,
-0.5144809484,
-0.2530792952,
-0.7767079473,
-0.3226020932,
0.1456736177,
0.561228931,
0.5160270333,
-0.2074591964,
0.6159350276,
0.4797174931,
0.1596350372,
0.2388428152,
0.1772560626,
-0.1986592561,
-0.1240663081,
0.4074429572,
0.1725028604,
0.5716214776,
0.5626139641,
0.3780907094,
-0.1434114575,
-0.5985319614,
-0.1110082492,
0.1186290532,
-0.7110514641,
0.0628637895,
-0.9828954339,
-0.4484393895,
-0.3159358501,
-0.2772542834,
-0.4084741473,
-0.6392877698,
0.295966506,
-0.6555989385,
-0.0838240013,
1.0678983927,
0.0851527527,
0.5678169727,
-0.7749096155,
0.6504122615,
0.6932477355,
0.5007895231,
0.1705342233,
-0.816239953,
-0.3163033128,
0.0177534074,
-0.0810574815,
-0.3622789085,
0.2614721656,
0.2549928129,
0.5362645388,
0.4137949944,
-0.3682726622,
0.6814714074,
-0.7050766945,
0.6013737917,
0.0408836715,
-0.6878374219,
0.2733516693,
-0.6327494383,
0.6237270236,
0.2997857928,
0.2305194885,
-0.8992397785,
-0.5449755788,
-0.6122031212,
-1.1314007044,
0.7482407689,
0.2913849354,
0.5175804496,
0.0857082978,
0.4252815843,
0.3895153105,
0.0393658318,
-0.9070963264,
-0.14567101,
-0.2631448209,
0.061572317,
-0.212095201,
-0.4398679137,
-0.111342378,
-0.4718744755,
0.2117522806,
-0.1286558658,
0.1942835897,
0.0094170636,
-0.3026400805,
-0.3731747568,
0.208138749,
0.3406797945,
0.6053658128,
-0.4510582685,
0.3776394129,
0.0083118267,
-0.6741738915,
0.1555914581,
-0.3616011441,
0.102754198,
-0.1391829252,
0.8509230018,
0.6903479695,
0.4005828202,
-0.0124604087,
0.1371307224,
-0.0721042007,
-0.4655416608,
-0.0406142771,
0.0224846266,
0.2653892636,
0.2880677879,
0.5750975013,
0.0987843573,
0.0643517971,
-0.668227613,
0.2351904362,
0.2135482728,
-0.395282954,
-0.7444354296,
0.352203697,
-0.0016312816,
-0.1976683587,
0.9250278473,
0.2525440454,
-0.3525081873,
0.7306294441,
0.8305742145,
1.1813410521,
-0.2695338428,
0.4937163591,
0.2385315597,
0.5606001616,
-0.2906177938,
-0.1986271292,
-0.1055099666,
-0.6346808076,
-0.4374035597,
-0.5386952162,
-0.2112565637,
0.2193816006,
-0.6917416453,
0.1116247252,
-0.4311639965,
0.0612847172,
-0.1544042826,
-0.4183429182,
-0.3743358552,
0.2183082551,
-0.0969126597,
0.7362982035,
-1.1047594547,
0.6535575986,
0.6493465304,
-0.0212531984,
-0.6262516379,
0.1931612641,
-0.1437887102,
-0.6283937097,
0.779035151,
0.3944615126,
-0.1847299039,
-0.019692855,
-0.6616726518,
-0.7255406976,
0.963950336,
0.3915474415,
-0.282752037,
-0.6520730257,
0.3828248978,
0.8418285847,
-0.3748910427,
0.0870497301,
0.6671782732,
0.3106834888,
0.1143167689,
-0.6827516556,
-0.2348276824,
-0.3737052679,
-0.0398907214,
0.3932899535,
-0.2414708883,
1.0159362555,
0.0150724025,
-0.5393471122,
-0.0568416491,
0.4712373912,
-0.1676618159,
-0.0507547744,
0.5990821123,
0.7642357349,
0.5296829343,
-0.0489082001,
1.1665747166,
0.0418309011,
0.331514746,
1.1711126566,
0.3116784394,
0.378954649,
0.2374751568,
-0.0872168541,
0.6614322662,
0.5403214693,
0.1135818958,
0.5891975164,
0.0565294549,
0.436740309,
-0.1640137881,
0.0807290226,
-0.5162674189,
0.2266706228,
0.2534497976,
-0.1386975497,
-0.2258908153,
-0.2864398062,
-0.110251002,
-0.1243273243,
-0.1061248034,
0.6869086027,
0.041925516,
-0.2296325862,
0.5486811399,
-0.2045867741,
0.5154684782,
-0.9089209437,
0.1537903398,
-0.4374656081,
0.0079453578,
-0.333335489,
-0.6834707856,
0.508554697,
-0.4758274555,
-0.4916427135,
-0.3153537214,
0.7250636816,
-0.3189861476,
-0.3590290248,
0.5808261633,
0.3132935166,
-0.2281069607,
-0.3903413713,
-0.273841083,
-0.5047976375,
-0.3835885227,
-0.5924755931,
0.3232603073,
0.6243636608,
-0.0332151093,
0.6074471474,
0.58758986,
-0.0474637337,
0.2798866928,
0.3011857271,
0.8292441964,
-0.7575083375,
-0.8458153605,
-0.8909612298,
0.8171750307,
-0.0332804061,
-0.2510683835,
0.7208142877,
0.3980079293,
1.1703346968,
-0.4333180189,
0.5016391873,
0.0280422419,
0.0875489414,
-0.4980706871,
0.4838075042,
-0.4222578704,
-0.0907332525,
-0.538402915,
-1.3295104504,
-0.5219025612,
0.3564071059,
-0.1980607361,
-0.0432605296,
0.9786806107,
0.5561089516,
-0.5109985471,
-0.1737675965,
0.5968463421,
0.5391104221,
0.4236320257,
0.2308147997,
1.0566493273,
-0.1432341039,
0.5658573508,
-0.3381659091,
-0.1788087338,
-0.1686550975,
-0.5857255459,
-1.2093317509,
-0.7189564705,
0.2120055854,
0.0567336939,
-0.1358176619,
0.4862145185,
0.7915403247,
-0.7443772554,
-0.38844347,
-0.3565734327,
-0.0162867401,
-0.3689647019,
-0.2999319732,
0.2416397184,
-0.5977081656,
-0.519805491,
0.3339191675,
0.3671633303,
0.2245113552,
0.0089110313,
0.094048351,
0.1119960994,
0.03056564,
0.6201646328,
0.1042014882,
-0.5013774633,
-0.5765314698,
0.2278793901,
-0.1147580296,
0.3689736426,
1.1314834356,
-0.522793293,
0.3147868812,
0.8974853754,
0.5784268379,
0.4281752706,
0.2312061191,
0.6377051473,
-1.0028370619,
0.2567078173,
0.0752396956,
0.2874885798,
0.1454996318,
-0.4643187523,
0.5300381184,
0.1577579975,
-0.6797507405,
-0.6508900523,
0.4585610032,
-0.5007926226,
-0.2808779776,
0.8808859587,
0.2200406045,
-0.1141474247,
-0.2457721233,
-0.4801608622,
0.0453239381,
-0.3423819542,
1.0353850126,
0.8581842184,
0.0117736896,
0.0252157561,
-0.446375221,
0.5510969162,
0.4287039936,
-0.5509519577,
0.2537309825,
0.0912136659,
0.1499546319,
0.298705101,
0.3274839222,
-0.151948005,
0.0740805492,
0.0818223357,
-0.1599569321,
0.0604609549,
-0.8760353923,
-0.3352790475,
0.3671146333,
0.0429830588,
0.0848385766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18736v1 | LonXplain: Lonesomeness as a Consequence of Mental Disturbance in Reddit Posts | 2023-05-30T04:21:24 | 2023-05-30T04:21:24 | Muskan Garg, Chandni Saxena, Debabrata Samanta, Bonnie J. Dorr | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Social media is a potential source of information that infers latent mental
states through Natural Language Processing (NLP). While narrating real-life
experiences, social media users convey their feeling of loneliness or isolated
lifestyle, impacting their mental well-being. Existing literature on
psychological theories points to loneliness as the major consequence of
interpersonal risk factors, propounding the need to investigate loneliness as a
major aspect of mental disturbance. We formulate lonesomeness detection in
social media posts as an explainable binary classification problem, discovering
the users at-risk, suggesting the need of resilience for early control. To the
best of our knowledge, there is no existing explainable dataset, i.e., one with
human-readable, annotated text spans, to facilitate further research and
development in loneliness detection causing mental disturbance. In this work,
three experts: a senior clinical psychologist, a rehabilitation counselor, and
a social NLP researcher define annotation schemes and perplexity guidelines to
mark the presence or absence of lonesomeness, along with the marking of
text-spans in original posts as explanation, in 3,521 Reddit posts. We expect
the public release of our dataset, LonXplain, and traditional classifiers as
baselines via GitHub. | [
-0.5806740522,
-0.8368391395,
0.6188947558,
0.76437819,
-0.5558610559,
-0.1170331016,
-0.2017196268,
-0.7277561426,
1.2425922155,
0.4967072308,
-0.8444736004,
-0.5348687172,
-0.676138401,
0.1912307143,
-0.5421566963,
1.0670640469,
0.0157134831,
-0.4004840851,
-0.3396626413,
-0.3244960606,
-0.2326216698,
-0.5346967578,
-0.447211206,
-0.2136442363,
1.048053503,
0.185239464,
0.4725573957,
0.0691694468,
0.9072059393,
0.2925108373,
-0.007090996,
-0.1462960243,
-0.6535410285,
0.0788164809,
-0.1415136307,
-0.0651019439,
-0.5386894941,
-0.1814127266,
0.2826309204,
0.7680990696,
0.0456353836,
0.4525748789,
0.0921597257,
0.6490811706,
-0.6082572341,
-0.2391787022,
-0.3642694652,
0.3369029462,
-0.31066975,
-0.1699799001,
0.2015491724,
-0.8418977857,
-0.1045217663,
-0.4380073249,
0.2798493505,
-0.352540493,
0.4199079573,
0.6779466867,
-0.4539467096,
-0.0202346928,
-0.5734405518,
0.4750035107,
-0.4631301463,
-0.1735055447,
0.7091159821,
0.2647812963,
-0.0510348231,
-0.3921073079,
-0.6329254508,
0.427631408,
-0.2720242739,
-0.0580737814,
-0.0907944292,
-0.0617345683,
0.293875128,
0.3569642305,
-0.3504753709,
-0.0805840716,
-0.630122602,
-0.0815331936,
1.0198707581,
-0.0663016811,
0.4175662696,
-0.5184602141,
-0.1827610433,
0.6155920625,
-0.1517240852,
0.0311198737,
0.4681359529,
0.1294972897,
-0.4748196006,
0.7194653153,
0.0602629557,
0.2179882675,
-0.1307150722,
-0.0649384931,
0.1277101338,
-0.2331508249,
0.271974057,
0.4151373506,
0.7456960678,
0.8383074403,
0.2166343182,
0.0389762521,
-0.0587718859,
0.3503063917,
0.5098029971,
-0.5052630901,
-0.3502778709,
0.291926831,
-0.5562749505,
-0.5065625906,
0.0610440485,
-0.6162478924,
-0.8404047489,
-0.0156478062,
0.1555730253,
-0.2273102105,
-0.5247647166,
0.0442140177,
-0.2381424159,
-0.2655084133,
0.3670428097,
-0.8080925941,
0.3393032551,
0.5230201483,
1.0322483778,
-0.474984169,
-0.2135086805,
-0.1552675068,
-0.4251862168,
0.1147927567,
0.9588158727,
0.0862357467,
-0.1125722453,
-0.0688601211,
0.3406946063,
0.1103888601,
-0.1000826731,
0.6672352552,
-0.2988584042,
0.087088488,
-0.3336062133,
0.0662119985,
-0.1556197852,
0.0317210481,
-0.726510644,
0.6427676678,
0.108900629,
-1.059599638,
-0.0016926653,
-0.7364314198,
-0.4735932648,
0.2732910514,
0.1086034849,
-0.322674185,
0.2815598845,
-0.143904835,
0.4591229856,
0.1445403546,
-0.1324535906,
-0.6895219684,
-0.4036150873,
0.2917383611,
-0.1505636573,
0.9267294407,
-0.1140084863,
-0.1846025437,
0.0662370473,
-0.7061668634,
0.1371693164,
0.1405443549,
-0.3191630542,
-0.7147704363,
0.1446805,
0.0315682702,
0.1934183687,
0.2261024863,
-0.5971900225,
-0.3386593759,
-0.1410035938,
0.2973018587,
0.7185509801,
0.2391029149,
-0.0015824307,
-0.1870699674,
0.4934476912,
-0.2195954025,
0.2266688794,
0.5370141864,
-0.4222484231,
-0.2094771117,
-0.1621178389,
-0.0241405126,
0.4609088004,
-0.6271066666,
0.5391438603,
-0.0506074987,
-0.0991869792,
-0.3922483027,
0.3297307193,
0.1983859092,
0.1949029863,
0.3358635306,
-0.437273711,
-0.8516594172,
-0.7398298383,
-0.060433168,
0.0172914919,
0.1828819662,
-0.073262997,
0.4536764622,
-0.6665030718,
0.6965165138,
-0.3495356739,
-0.3872090876,
-0.1664639264,
0.1242402717,
0.117090255,
0.2982721329,
0.3964380324,
-0.9664062858,
-0.4872048497,
-0.0856713727,
-1.2945716381,
-0.4385052323,
0.2747513652,
-0.1255156249,
0.1265233606,
0.5841014981,
-0.7165519595,
0.6072291136,
0.6681406498,
-0.3890045583,
0.7148355246,
0.1651195586,
-0.1710591912,
-0.7202652693,
-0.1296682805,
0.0696783885,
-0.1197133437,
-0.4197689593,
-0.1730096936,
-0.5169501305,
-0.0668440983,
-0.141162008,
0.0264232364,
-0.174239248,
-0.0725911483,
-0.3975327313,
0.559114933,
-0.2070629299,
0.15448834,
-0.4127479792,
0.1828619391,
0.3235620856,
-0.1539851576,
0.6909934282,
0.1514928043,
-0.0574399903,
0.608109653,
-0.6478080153,
-0.1230579317,
-0.415230751,
0.2877798378,
-0.9199807644,
-0.6983757615,
0.2780513763,
-0.6327326894,
-0.4005603492,
0.1488932222,
-0.3171992302,
-0.5444819331,
-0.5256733298,
0.5698640943,
-0.0187084451,
-0.3813963532,
0.3429207206,
0.5175583363,
-0.3956468403,
-0.3850683868,
-0.5734497309,
-0.0083179846,
-0.4557144344,
-0.6465557218,
0.3832322955,
-0.0007436238,
-0.7171635032,
0.1975296289,
-0.0885624811,
-0.13885656,
0.3090131581,
0.7826737165,
0.0917880163,
-0.0980941281,
0.3491467237,
-0.147668764,
-0.1864603609,
0.6182695627,
0.2093540728,
0.4973467886,
-0.2101480961,
-0.1942369193,
-0.5365598798,
0.5152161121,
0.3503050804,
0.2516679764,
0.709006846,
0.6950822473,
-0.4867565632,
-0.319552809,
-0.4309122264,
-0.2717671692,
-0.4256644845,
-0.1984757036,
0.0761455595,
-0.8808007836,
0.5767237544,
0.1005800664,
-0.2167468816,
0.1404567808,
0.0768340975,
-0.5781049728,
0.574973464,
0.9389056563,
0.0419510193,
0.3403125405,
0.2612982094,
0.3661092222,
-0.3301080167,
0.1422591507,
-0.0133918421,
-0.4957641959,
-1.0249760151,
-0.0649826676,
0.2754801214,
-0.0736266896,
0.0110937338,
0.2399139106,
-0.61127913,
0.6709447503,
0.3617575169,
0.4664554894,
0.3854234815,
0.0895354971,
0.2679391801,
-0.2792087197,
-0.3483250439,
-0.4684634805,
0.6468858123,
0.1641537398,
0.6320891976,
0.4318639338,
0.9623980522,
0.81795609,
0.2194577008,
-0.6241908669,
0.6567903161,
-0.1985622942,
-0.4759034812,
-0.3312588632,
-0.3925586641,
-0.8585122228,
-0.1646255106,
-0.4372466207,
-1.1768498421,
0.1465065628,
0.1137089133,
-0.765506804,
0.0459285118,
-0.6783303022,
0.6156621575,
-0.298104465,
-0.4445594251,
-0.1640942246,
-1.0238587856,
0.9029416442,
-0.4148701429,
0.1516291946,
-0.313675195,
0.3762175739,
0.5653338432,
-0.5629009604,
1.0869123936,
-0.1047509685,
-0.0390520245,
0.2476878166,
-0.2255332768,
0.2499943078,
0.0332212262,
0.1070149541,
-0.0305778943,
0.2771068811,
-0.5087826252,
-0.424785465,
0.8887442946,
-0.8408988714,
-0.4144377708,
-0.2992097139,
-0.2107540518,
0.1130251288,
0.225998193,
0.2906056941,
0.0574957207,
-0.0457070731,
0.4073356986,
0.6062694788,
-0.3816935122,
0.3630354404,
-0.0059658978,
-0.7414712906,
-0.3694806695,
0.9221793413,
0.08108785,
0.156089887,
-0.0831288323,
0.0191926211,
0.0544783883,
-0.1414977908,
0.3591785133,
0.6407843828,
-0.6312060952,
0.2542192638,
-0.7067648768,
-0.3118525743,
-0.4442748129,
-0.3081386089,
-0.3112682998,
-0.6714858413,
-0.1305454522,
-0.2815626562,
0.4970680475,
1.0310755968,
-0.5476076603,
0.3767377734,
-0.4278919399,
0.6127243042,
0.5604134202,
0.5759519935,
-0.1694689095,
0.0911169201,
-0.2268157005,
-0.2231446356,
-0.143560946,
-0.6290584207,
0.0372394361,
-0.0414594077,
0.2498833537,
0.6631048322,
0.5773069859,
0.4703094065,
0.298345387,
0.467101723,
0.3258066177,
-0.4894005656,
0.6149760485,
-0.5550046563,
0.0580653287,
0.6931610107,
0.6796452403,
-0.6607518792,
-0.0907737464,
-0.4693303108,
-0.9451282024,
0.5381745696,
0.363038063,
0.0300934222,
0.0431034751,
0.2150199562,
-0.0339254998,
0.0746462494,
-1.1678581238,
-0.381544143,
-0.4479791522,
0.1848073304,
0.029182015,
-0.500926137,
-0.3534351587,
-0.2263324857,
0.4768289924,
-0.0258030985,
0.5078073144,
0.202663064,
0.1256628484,
-0.4910356104,
-0.1267748028,
0.4967065752,
0.6106596589,
-0.7207385302,
0.5888342857,
-0.0153050842,
-0.4633750916,
-0.039978452,
0.3538557887,
0.0865674466,
0.1897279769,
0.5550507307,
0.3110862374,
0.1263223886,
-0.4942965508,
0.6067374945,
-0.3617683053,
-0.1004495695,
-0.9707147479,
0.2011424452,
0.3408558071,
0.275267899,
0.3505844474,
0.0881410539,
-0.2594695687,
-0.5834637284,
0.1495246142,
0.3255029023,
-0.560816288,
-0.6482306123,
0.4261579514,
0.1294939071,
-0.6934962869,
0.2188879699,
-0.3633918166,
-0.4281818867,
0.3722162247,
0.270036608,
0.8406338692,
0.0785028934,
0.4780265987,
0.1764781624,
0.3408056498,
0.0494347736,
0.3068492115,
-0.287194699,
-0.7192739844,
0.0007565458,
-0.5927840471,
-0.1209502965,
0.2016809136,
-0.60631603,
0.2494564801,
-0.6307054758,
-0.5406975746,
0.2156417668,
-0.1700520217,
-0.022374412,
-0.0793235004,
0.195093289,
0.3891872764,
-0.7991473675,
0.3544687629,
0.8045521975,
-0.2390313745,
-0.1915443987,
0.3533029258,
0.5418800116,
-0.2898872793,
0.5314007998,
0.4062115252,
-0.3531054258,
-0.157236442,
-0.7656961083,
-0.7566314936,
0.9118683338,
0.0203744024,
0.059757676,
0.1777843684,
0.3357935846,
0.8058212996,
-0.2241037786,
-0.293522954,
0.3893279731,
0.423653245,
-0.2037885934,
-0.6550347805,
0.1466953009,
-0.5507465005,
-0.0559946634,
0.170096755,
-0.6262604594,
0.6423009038,
-0.2201943696,
-0.5095534921,
-0.1028352603,
0.1828014702,
0.2346843183,
0.7115726471,
0.45274207,
0.4849966466,
0.4891973734,
0.0709271356,
0.718814671,
-0.0003554788,
0.1675677896,
1.1881625652,
-0.1715397835,
0.6633543372,
0.5058862567,
-0.1457855403,
0.558167994,
0.4499465823,
0.3019851148,
0.3621278107,
0.0515587255,
-0.7294977903,
-0.1507598758,
-0.4827187359,
-0.3339996934,
0.485052079,
0.3682341874,
-0.5996061563,
-0.4119896591,
0.2059236914,
0.0805481821,
0.1675982177,
-0.083306402,
0.5630742311,
0.4062028229,
-0.462538451,
0.6267226338,
-0.2507267296,
0.6498356462,
-0.4666808248,
0.1664832532,
-0.3491329551,
0.4218783975,
-0.7233466506,
-0.6251939535,
0.7852966189,
-0.07696639,
-0.3268924654,
-0.2365256846,
1.1496067047,
-0.0040513296,
-0.4809523523,
0.7677731514,
0.515873611,
0.4122409821,
-0.3438234925,
-0.4957410693,
0.018804932,
0.0491111763,
0.1443114281,
0.3524645269,
0.8127166033,
-0.136763677,
0.7111154795,
0.5769209266,
0.200302586,
-0.1826003939,
-0.1446077526,
0.9380248189,
-0.8754948974,
-0.237294212,
-0.7826846838,
0.3953302801,
-0.2954414785,
-0.3272990882,
0.8423328996,
0.1159319803,
0.282651335,
0.1783480346,
0.8517747521,
-0.4397322536,
0.5689879656,
-0.0201097783,
0.9950477481,
-0.5499434471,
0.5169224143,
-0.4874828458,
-0.7149052024,
-0.4378353655,
0.3621292412,
-0.5777522326,
-0.3598392606,
0.6854695082,
0.773780942,
-0.0046719699,
0.1651904881,
0.1415819675,
0.2825025022,
-0.2878097594,
0.1836860329,
0.8769968748,
-0.1946107596,
0.3838772178,
-0.6453968287,
-0.0850964785,
-0.506624341,
-0.6664230227,
-1.1683431864,
-0.5201442242,
-0.343401581,
-0.5857566595,
0.1956521422,
1.0558080673,
0.1562319696,
-0.5121391416,
-0.0782360137,
-0.2459199876,
0.802796185,
-0.0880543441,
-0.3476058543,
0.233632043,
-0.0676938891,
0.0820869356,
-0.1505811512,
0.2909277081,
0.068127647,
-0.509967804,
0.3307313025,
-0.4478580058,
-0.3293385506,
0.9468746781,
0.4113713205,
-0.4358766079,
-0.1846232563,
-0.334264338,
-0.1131282598,
-0.0363581255,
0.4190075397,
-0.2776409686,
0.2060552835,
0.2874772847,
0.2054983526,
0.2163683027,
0.5250654817,
0.206389904,
-0.7681127191,
-0.0570846014,
0.1092534587,
0.0376896374,
0.4278563261,
-0.5982069373,
0.6424458623,
0.7327700257,
-0.6499260068,
-0.8117577434,
0.0507818796,
-1.0151902437,
-0.1421414167,
0.9168854952,
-0.1305492818,
-0.439453274,
-0.4805466533,
-0.167052716,
-0.0189588554,
-0.4324786961,
1.4563834667,
0.5798335075,
-0.1795554906,
-0.4024474323,
-0.7540892363,
0.4738811553,
-0.0338629335,
-0.7945290208,
-0.0832804441,
0.4009820521,
-0.0225748755,
0.476728946,
0.6175422072,
0.2835545838,
0.3211015463,
-0.0164297335,
0.011761657,
0.3439579904,
0.192985937,
-0.0511643291,
0.3934002817,
-0.4482825398,
0.0076418845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18727v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18727v1 | An Annotated Dataset for Explainable Interpersonal Risk Factors of Mental Disturbance in Social Media Posts | 2023-05-30T04:08:40 | 2023-05-30T04:08:40 | Muskan Garg, Amirmohammad Shahbandegan, Amrit Chadha, Vijay Mago | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | With a surge in identifying suicidal risk and its severity in social media
posts, we argue that a more consequential and explainable research is required
for optimal impact on clinical psychology practice and personalized mental
healthcare. The success of computational intelligence techniques for inferring
mental illness from social media resources, points to natural language
processing as a lens for determining Interpersonal Risk Factors (IRF) in human
writings. Motivated with limited availability of datasets for social NLP
research community, we construct and release a new annotated dataset with
human-labelled explanations and classification of IRF affecting mental
disturbance on social media: (i) Thwarted Belongingness (TBe), and (ii)
Perceived Burdensomeness (PBu). We establish baseline models on our dataset
facilitating future research directions to develop real-time personalized AI
models by detecting patterns of TBe and PBu in emotional spectrum of user's
historical social media profile. | [
-0.514816761,
-0.8204988837,
0.586299777,
0.5809437633,
0.0756601319,
0.0832267851,
-0.2126145959,
-0.5481380224,
0.3532067537,
0.2473792881,
-1.0065455437,
-0.4684427679,
-0.9003683925,
0.096724391,
-0.3612531126,
0.8995804191,
0.1216257364,
-0.1253059059,
-0.2025284469,
0.0581857413,
-0.437522471,
-0.6573939919,
-0.7624712586,
-0.1641328037,
0.8824533224,
0.3239180446,
0.6487978697,
-0.0280388743,
0.9476222992,
0.211266458,
0.1863989383,
-0.0686035007,
-0.4539516866,
-0.1550833732,
-0.263615042,
-0.0628049672,
-0.2402595133,
-0.0019780654,
0.0837401077,
0.8207386136,
-0.0175767932,
0.5016451478,
0.2541389167,
0.5601434112,
-0.4553223252,
0.0479238331,
-0.3209537268,
0.1232631356,
-0.2911502123,
-0.4541383684,
-0.2582665086,
-0.527314961,
0.0023289991,
-0.517714262,
0.3423468471,
-0.2975712121,
0.6576985717,
0.3773286641,
-0.5253219604,
-0.2319984287,
-1.1035447121,
0.2821846306,
-0.3275738657,
-0.0308633726,
0.801476717,
0.3692302406,
-0.0859186575,
-0.2601594925,
-0.5042260289,
0.0484458655,
-0.3336142898,
-0.2263168395,
-0.2334186584,
0.0818287209,
0.3766130209,
0.1085592285,
-0.4935936332,
0.0070813471,
-0.5203335881,
-0.1571693271,
1.1580150127,
0.3034656644,
0.6071557999,
-0.0162117723,
0.166214779,
0.2303436249,
-0.4154980481,
0.3169723451,
0.4018923342,
0.284224391,
-0.3514090478,
0.6532386541,
0.030841127,
0.3345738649,
-0.0281360764,
0.0311089251,
-0.1484580338,
-0.1876140535,
0.1904247701,
0.1236542314,
0.7828320861,
0.9447452426,
0.4442246258,
-0.1474929005,
0.3192996383,
0.1760330945,
0.5636243224,
-0.6128104925,
-0.2895646095,
0.1282351613,
-0.5101678967,
-0.2173776776,
0.1348926127,
-0.5258873105,
-0.7517650127,
-0.3409134448,
0.1692610085,
-0.6298199892,
-0.326533854,
-0.1388035864,
-0.0516204201,
-0.3509964347,
0.1668083817,
-0.6845315695,
0.3600251675,
0.5264975429,
0.8744587898,
0.1141537428,
-0.0140541233,
-0.0409094654,
0.0275005754,
-0.1841318756,
0.8306006789,
-0.3288197815,
-0.1909666657,
0.2439998686,
0.0414302759,
0.0393298417,
-0.1577672809,
0.5930079222,
-0.1561863273,
0.0008213716,
-0.6879650354,
-0.3410559595,
-0.4107511938,
-0.0949470922,
-0.5789951086,
0.6508966088,
0.293754369,
-0.9539525509,
0.3691288531,
-0.652890861,
-0.5574221611,
0.4149441719,
0.1576231122,
-0.1836956441,
0.2009209245,
0.1498076171,
0.7761698365,
-0.2661441267,
0.4382808506,
-0.906637609,
-0.3889448941,
0.4082125723,
-0.1623987705,
0.922090292,
0.0529361591,
0.1157490015,
0.1114792079,
-0.6423041821,
-0.1873271465,
0.1647160202,
-0.0359736532,
-0.6250516176,
0.2960882485,
0.2707581222,
0.1972374916,
-0.0103753563,
-0.4601128697,
-0.3531053364,
-0.007120491,
0.521058321,
0.6170672774,
0.5394097567,
-0.0139392428,
-0.5032796264,
0.4916851819,
-0.1632431597,
0.4273622334,
0.388284415,
-0.3686788678,
-0.009442443,
-0.2281592786,
-0.2901156545,
0.6157757044,
-0.4601910412,
0.4992367327,
-0.0642669201,
-0.4485372305,
-0.4916121662,
-0.0978939459,
0.1653706133,
0.5903600454,
0.3868273795,
0.1293822527,
-0.7029438615,
-1.0553128719,
-0.4339709282,
-0.1983987689,
0.020535158,
0.081831336,
0.186248526,
-0.5111103654,
0.8907680511,
-0.3716627359,
-0.2981364429,
-0.1682987362,
0.3236607313,
-0.0227014367,
0.2279371768,
0.5998649001,
-0.6138480306,
-0.6227653623,
-0.1702335924,
-0.9791142344,
-0.5877524018,
-0.2104080766,
-0.2145629972,
-0.3632888496,
0.5311058164,
-0.4367611706,
0.6771640778,
0.2628797591,
-0.3394366205,
0.3700284958,
0.1060285866,
0.1767562479,
-0.8061924577,
0.0244119316,
0.6448581219,
0.0481815785,
-0.6924610138,
-0.3186563849,
-0.2895456851,
-0.1184653789,
0.0337577425,
0.1781197786,
0.0750018656,
0.2643717527,
-0.0865294561,
0.0832002088,
-0.2234335095,
0.2034910023,
-0.5048569441,
0.3148017824,
0.3046832979,
-0.3164676428,
0.0696778595,
0.3318784535,
-0.0592158027,
0.616191566,
-0.5771248341,
-0.256013006,
-0.7056266665,
0.0300977081,
-0.9510197639,
-0.5145884752,
0.2900406718,
-0.5736466646,
-0.1252094358,
0.1837977767,
-0.3377676308,
-0.4222140014,
-0.2069610506,
0.2061704546,
0.0466126502,
-0.1612539589,
0.1706869602,
0.6342409253,
-0.4811148345,
-0.1028863043,
-0.4141805172,
0.303943038,
-0.474257499,
-0.4735990763,
0.5440445542,
-0.1599124968,
-0.6611844897,
0.1581298858,
0.3883554935,
-0.0748965219,
0.3417237401,
0.8657122254,
0.2548054755,
0.1408672184,
0.462620765,
0.0879170671,
-0.1478966624,
0.6002501845,
0.5624755621,
0.4028859437,
-0.0635889918,
-0.1082556918,
-0.7513290048,
0.7130472064,
0.1871238053,
0.0467986353,
0.837798059,
0.5473045707,
-0.9252889752,
0.011001369,
-0.3432591558,
-0.1162681058,
-0.3602341413,
0.1827894598,
0.0514644273,
-0.7760239244,
0.6401216984,
0.1317143887,
-0.0938318223,
0.4151003063,
0.4613785744,
-0.4741955101,
1.0165433884,
0.6794885397,
-0.1154312789,
0.4030092657,
0.0676456094,
0.6174938679,
-0.4163674414,
-0.1694202274,
-0.26757285,
-0.1823191941,
-0.6130989194,
0.0257668979,
0.4183187485,
0.0756557509,
-0.4024093151,
0.0983973369,
-0.6576940417,
0.1174521819,
0.4194552004,
0.3513676524,
0.3091880679,
-0.0432228893,
0.2980822921,
-0.3677048385,
-0.3063796461,
-0.6596825123,
0.6930817366,
0.4314384162,
0.6292529106,
0.1377668977,
0.4777975976,
0.7842146158,
0.7403082252,
-0.4538636208,
0.329531312,
-0.0104764309,
-0.8650022149,
-0.221325621,
-0.1321224868,
-0.5428664088,
-0.2850552499,
-0.4678034484,
-1.098567605,
0.081488058,
0.2777824402,
-0.7727611065,
-0.1480967999,
-0.6074305773,
0.4709033072,
-0.1692279875,
-0.0678802729,
-0.3183275759,
-0.7859500051,
0.6737071872,
-0.2035937905,
0.3301461041,
-0.5488315821,
0.4499261677,
0.7234963179,
-0.5677703619,
0.9055164456,
-0.096212849,
0.396035105,
0.2626466751,
-0.1527960896,
0.0820323303,
0.2729862332,
-0.1276319027,
0.0893527269,
0.2635494769,
-0.1606505066,
-0.5209196806,
0.5248842835,
-0.7998716831,
-0.2371391207,
-0.2691162825,
-0.4882265031,
-0.2921289206,
0.0403356366,
0.380297333,
0.1731483042,
-0.2022975832,
0.0951143354,
0.3664547801,
-0.3943454623,
0.3705111444,
0.3051939309,
-0.093033351,
-0.3712304235,
0.7864062786,
0.3870717585,
-0.1790468395,
0.1805060208,
0.1815799475,
0.050486017,
-0.3483369052,
0.2849483788,
0.3564147949,
-0.7061172724,
-0.0808110163,
-0.5309776664,
-0.3192226291,
-0.4704579413,
-0.4026172757,
-0.0599189289,
0.0509137847,
-0.4849611223,
-0.3327041566,
0.6986017227,
0.8921236992,
-0.3317331374,
0.6511654854,
-0.6633660793,
0.3549213707,
0.026642384,
0.4476620555,
0.1684844643,
0.0019994006,
-0.2816742063,
0.0238969978,
-0.0378959998,
-1.112191081,
0.198551476,
0.1920641363,
0.3970606923,
0.6205872297,
0.5231912136,
0.7830141783,
-0.1362764388,
0.2536370158,
0.0929108039,
-0.5682162642,
0.6014419794,
-0.5593507886,
-0.1137605831,
0.9954090714,
1.0645631552,
-0.977052629,
-0.0511837862,
-0.5573217869,
-0.6790047288,
0.5006152987,
0.0658506602,
-0.0361515917,
-0.2077316344,
0.7367941737,
0.0562604666,
-0.2106909007,
-0.7057548761,
-0.151001513,
0.0678256229,
-0.3732364774,
-0.2186769545,
-0.445151329,
-0.2030087709,
-0.4733481109,
0.7360963821,
-0.076499626,
0.4072248042,
0.3606543541,
0.0017677835,
-0.5987628698,
-0.4680331349,
0.2437308282,
0.5778032541,
-0.5216069221,
0.2451310307,
-0.2045991868,
-0.3212572336,
-0.0153931137,
0.42663607,
-0.0996576846,
-0.2375587523,
0.7641711235,
0.5232766867,
-0.1737062335,
-0.629640162,
0.4601238668,
-0.3519386947,
-0.1682353467,
-0.8126809001,
0.0220160745,
0.2454614043,
0.203720063,
0.2882974148,
-0.0476429835,
0.129319042,
-0.4887967706,
0.2021978199,
0.3985558748,
-0.6710627079,
-0.5734587312,
0.6290209293,
-0.0360296294,
-0.7415364385,
0.4597843885,
-0.1754852533,
-0.1630547643,
0.2831946611,
0.1640919149,
0.7196735144,
0.006930592,
0.5971056223,
0.4297715724,
0.5174691081,
0.1819380075,
0.4624496996,
0.1325567514,
-0.5840315819,
-0.1331958473,
-0.5075079799,
-0.1954676062,
0.4611099958,
-0.6973673105,
0.325987488,
-0.8041203618,
-0.5375493765,
0.3928017318,
-0.1510719806,
-0.4945785701,
0.2778666914,
0.3492508233,
0.5763854384,
-1.1660555601,
0.2720072567,
0.4715518355,
-0.3744528294,
-0.5659721494,
0.3255768418,
0.2890459895,
-0.4047999978,
0.1627969593,
0.2504976988,
0.1252554804,
-0.298879683,
-0.656548202,
-0.9662667513,
0.687046349,
0.3302131593,
-0.2468713671,
-0.0794726163,
0.5105928183,
0.8301352859,
-0.2989379764,
-0.0010763941,
0.3216198981,
0.4253175557,
-0.2269829065,
-0.2292861193,
0.2559592426,
-0.602651,
0.1889423877,
0.0301696733,
-0.3735662103,
0.448546648,
-0.293749243,
-0.2787374556,
-0.384709537,
0.4415569901,
-0.0022079805,
0.5325027108,
0.2668608725,
0.4213554859,
0.5854284167,
0.0804852396,
0.9394937754,
-0.1043481901,
0.1034687087,
1.1027001143,
-0.1500101238,
0.5574252605,
0.1652883738,
-0.2524656355,
0.3068450093,
1.0202205181,
0.0790987611,
0.3651815355,
0.1806717515,
-0.4077780247,
-0.0936448798,
-0.3770607114,
0.0239903461,
0.23377195,
0.7690079808,
-0.5531651378,
-0.2603752017,
0.3875356615,
0.1374416649,
0.1964892596,
-0.0062271277,
0.6615864635,
0.1217461601,
-0.6002426744,
0.194325909,
0.0088101979,
0.3641492128,
-0.266136229,
0.0374278575,
0.1307032704,
0.1385695338,
-0.3928685188,
-0.7908625603,
0.9823465347,
-0.204266265,
-0.2739276588,
-0.2537567914,
1.0445936918,
-0.1570905745,
-0.8014501929,
0.4726660252,
0.3478612006,
-0.0218211152,
-0.4319910705,
-0.5758759975,
-0.196519956,
-0.1785935163,
-0.1929781139,
0.3404377699,
0.4356893003,
-0.4241212606,
0.6398984194,
0.5321118832,
-0.0075037158,
-0.1361408383,
0.0473324768,
0.6856431961,
-0.778835535,
-0.1613616347,
-0.8690546155,
0.445802927,
-0.2093495876,
-0.5087738037,
0.451559484,
-0.0341097228,
0.2975628972,
0.1875877231,
0.9755445123,
-0.3858872056,
0.7317280769,
0.1213370711,
0.9427556396,
-0.2931046188,
0.0075433264,
-0.2658676505,
-0.3825305998,
-0.5183449984,
0.4539617002,
-0.4651290178,
-0.185636282,
0.3199226856,
0.651047051,
0.3781991899,
0.0695274323,
-0.0816376582,
0.1729736179,
0.292548269,
0.2969781756,
0.6681970358,
-0.2231567204,
0.0331096649,
-0.907448113,
-0.2917303741,
-0.4311755896,
-0.8498083353,
-1.1735770702,
-1.0254576206,
-0.500035584,
-0.2533857822,
0.1263813376,
0.9499710202,
0.3414741158,
-0.4021241367,
0.0984693393,
-0.178269282,
0.2569847703,
-0.1038057059,
-0.3154826164,
0.0379946977,
0.0046225754,
-0.0705937296,
-0.2733792365,
0.3012554348,
-0.0242699329,
-0.2618527412,
0.2081314325,
-0.5533149242,
0.0394477881,
0.7744128704,
0.1850827783,
-0.4188250601,
-0.2506176829,
-0.2137295306,
-0.047629144,
-0.1536711156,
0.4906170964,
-0.3055687547,
0.0464918651,
0.4241732955,
0.3083488643,
-0.0448566116,
0.1920221299,
0.4702338874,
-0.5537097454,
-0.2897803187,
0.2183914185,
0.2128021717,
0.3777038753,
-1.1777629852,
0.5746805072,
0.2909733355,
-0.4043629467,
-0.7182036042,
-0.0622940138,
-0.8463213444,
-0.2751253843,
0.7330434322,
-0.0853626132,
-0.083763741,
-0.2106880248,
-0.2108751386,
0.5433854461,
-0.3632115424,
1.269718647,
0.7895773649,
-0.5303968191,
-0.2985910177,
-0.8091344237,
0.6257804632,
-0.0793155357,
-0.8959899545,
0.1584204882,
0.3432471156,
0.035486877,
0.0494449548,
0.7107242942,
0.0576282032,
0.1045754179,
-0.2170403749,
0.0826291963,
0.0532099679,
-0.1070526168,
-0.0039578793,
0.3020053804,
-0.1768109649,
0.3478299081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18725v1 | AdapterEM: Pre-trained Language Model Adaptation for Generalized Entity Matching using Adapter-tuning | 2023-05-30T04:03:23 | 2023-05-30T04:03:23 | John Bosco Mugeni, Steven Lynden, Toshiyuki Amagasa, Akiyoshi Matono | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB | Entity Matching (EM) involves identifying different data representations
referring to the same entity from multiple data sources and is typically
formulated as a binary classification problem. It is a challenging problem in
data integration due to the heterogeneity of data representations.
State-of-the-art solutions have adopted NLP techniques based on pre-trained
language models (PrLMs) via the fine-tuning paradigm, however, sequential
fine-tuning of overparameterized PrLMs can lead to catastrophic forgetting,
especially in low-resource scenarios. In this study, we propose a
parameter-efficient paradigm for fine-tuning PrLMs based on adapters, small
neural networks encapsulated between layers of a PrLM, by optimizing only the
adapter and classifier weights while the PrLMs parameters are frozen.
Adapter-based methods have been successfully applied to multilingual speech
problems achieving promising results, however, the effectiveness of these
methods when applied to EM is not yet well understood, particularly for
generalized EM with heterogeneous data. Furthermore, we explore using (i)
pre-trained adapters and (ii) invertible adapters to capture token-level
language representations and demonstrate their benefits for transfer learning
on the generalized EM benchmark. Our results show that our solution achieves
comparable or superior performance to full-scale PrLM fine-tuning and
prompt-tuning baselines while utilizing a significantly smaller computational
footprint $\approx 13\%$ of the PrLM parameters. | [
-0.6172770858,
-0.5662753582,
0.4203410447,
0.1142362356,
-0.3563732505,
-0.3196646273,
-0.5915609598,
-0.2321414351,
0.0883951485,
0.461086899,
-0.3885693848,
-0.4077729285,
-0.3326742649,
0.0802069455,
0.0207863245,
0.755880475,
-0.1647377312,
-0.0723962784,
-0.0665566772,
-0.4207601249,
-0.6526528001,
-0.3360138834,
-0.9540786743,
-0.0957560241,
0.4294622838,
0.5092619658,
0.3966463208,
0.6481928825,
0.3323228061,
0.3028600812,
0.1938801408,
0.3373501301,
-0.3734767437,
-0.0090560867,
-0.5242043138,
-0.5833038092,
-0.3487066627,
-0.1750585735,
0.7234800458,
0.5679970384,
-0.3838320673,
0.5239617229,
0.1717648506,
0.440020293,
-0.6466410756,
0.0784912184,
-1.112070322,
0.0065591638,
-0.1385994852,
-0.3497410119,
-0.4052720368,
-0.2446894944,
0.0201728623,
-0.7683278918,
0.2629475892,
0.4334123731,
0.8979668617,
0.35437271,
0.0703937784,
-0.2750097513,
-0.8912263513,
0.7048875093,
-0.8227411509,
0.3737996817,
0.2128151804,
0.2930048406,
-0.1944432259,
-0.7662896514,
-0.6258847713,
0.0262825768,
-0.1151730567,
-0.06377545,
-0.2161906511,
0.0881670788,
0.1081056595,
0.0962026641,
-0.6330018044,
0.3673214614,
-0.0331381112,
-0.161692217,
0.2352903336,
0.0930828303,
0.3252776265,
0.4890197814,
-0.0693261027,
0.0140604842,
-0.5865104795,
-0.3391144872,
0.2842164636,
0.6972882152,
0.096278742,
0.2304914743,
0.2235558629,
0.9664869905,
0.2893074453,
0.0667666197,
0.2077810168,
-0.4374565184,
-0.245457828,
0.1613953859,
0.5082541704,
0.1632038355,
0.5261793137,
-0.2497548014,
-0.1777258068,
-0.0751123428,
0.2860203385,
-0.8263328075,
-0.3316797912,
-0.2596263885,
-0.4662266076,
0.1386713535,
-0.2169834077,
-0.6601800919,
0.1310104877,
-0.565777123,
0.663343668,
-0.3209865689,
-0.2281055599,
0.1857587397,
0.2546384931,
0.2605194449,
0.1831673682,
-0.9737799764,
0.4364945292,
0.3867111802,
0.9839937687,
-0.010751754,
-0.2747199237,
-0.6286654472,
0.1369704455,
-0.2039624006,
0.7242558599,
-0.6711584926,
-0.2356592715,
-0.0465398468,
0.148360014,
-0.626958549,
-0.7582129836,
0.6951031685,
-0.5599306226,
0.1584891379,
0.0773864239,
-0.5825148225,
-0.1043298542,
0.1570855528,
-0.4303297698,
0.7385146022,
0.0056604389,
-0.5104755759,
0.4455516636,
-0.6149835587,
-0.4301615655,
-0.0855590701,
-0.0596255027,
-0.6014187336,
0.2656338215,
0.29228881,
0.3603245616,
-0.3393642306,
-0.0526954047,
-0.4248671234,
-0.556641221,
-0.2823969424,
-0.2014477551,
0.2582767904,
0.149801001,
-0.0119896717,
0.1986769438,
-0.8327909112,
0.1431093067,
0.1138854995,
-0.3928968608,
-0.541012466,
-0.0183438119,
0.0812835023,
0.3389258385,
-0.0410241522,
-0.1965121627,
0.0693752766,
-0.5014409423,
0.5056017041,
0.6696090102,
-0.0826172903,
0.7516647577,
-0.316172123,
0.3567397594,
0.2997927964,
-0.0514720045,
-0.1266887039,
-0.2585990131,
-0.7383125424,
-0.2337484062,
0.5253425241,
0.4774289131,
-0.7304618359,
0.6037498713,
-0.3721582294,
-0.4759044945,
-1.0030179024,
0.1656300724,
0.1143094823,
0.8536500931,
0.7066730857,
-0.138938874,
-0.5757938623,
-0.9335163832,
-0.6258450747,
0.0624503493,
-0.3069350719,
0.490062356,
0.2617562711,
-0.2135706991,
0.7374053001,
-0.1519465595,
-0.6354022622,
0.043728292,
-0.1658408791,
0.3518274724,
0.7182762027,
0.7722164989,
-0.6352723837,
-0.5398184657,
0.1473333538,
-0.3617606163,
0.0466370508,
-0.077497825,
-0.0165406335,
-0.1521219164,
0.5798549652,
-0.1916350275,
-0.0250955205,
0.6295940876,
-0.2590470314,
0.2921675146,
-0.5976402164,
-0.0270573329,
-1.0864999294,
0.1154458597,
0.1029215157,
-0.3321312964,
-0.7041708827,
-0.2515069544,
0.2310258895,
-0.2029108554,
-0.4809021056,
0.5572285056,
-0.5683134198,
0.100870043,
-0.294716537,
0.1905123144,
-0.1164497286,
0.5090817809,
-0.0877426267,
0.7825177312,
0.8079376817,
-0.9264143109,
0.1084929258,
0.1207858771,
-0.1120551229,
0.656483531,
-0.5189121962,
0.490802139,
-0.3322688341,
0.0759502426,
-0.4697166979,
0.2085476965,
0.3191209435,
0.0164490044,
0.5433524251,
-0.4344660938,
-0.2811237574,
-0.1085491329,
-0.1315549463,
0.4715988338,
0.4078010321,
-0.6204848289,
1.0893112421,
0.1975385994,
-0.1097393334,
-0.325853914,
-0.5399426818,
-0.1095153093,
-0.4336241782,
-0.3897178471,
0.5468868017,
-0.0807080418,
0.2238838524,
0.1748920381,
-0.190010041,
-0.0095957899,
0.1289656609,
-0.0476515703,
0.1209642738,
-0.6664676666,
0.1677683592,
0.1565163285,
-0.171858117,
-0.3212963939,
-0.7415791154,
0.5498300195,
-0.164812699,
-0.4154661596,
-0.3186039925,
0.1509086788,
0.3737475574,
-0.2307078242,
0.9962729216,
0.6359802485,
-0.4897897542,
-0.2058345824,
-0.4483348131,
-0.1455064267,
-0.4535829425,
0.5532345772,
-0.6595192552,
-0.7390326858,
0.5749157071,
-0.3153322339,
0.1157804877,
0.2742791474,
0.3970239162,
0.1368494481,
0.856228888,
0.5301061273,
-0.38386935,
0.7104995251,
0.2580624521,
0.0955461562,
-0.883534193,
0.0729605705,
-0.7918764949,
-0.5673083663,
-0.5583073497,
-0.3930521607,
-0.1271865368,
0.1952781975,
-0.3544200361,
0.3947034776,
-0.4744496644,
0.537745297,
0.3763267994,
0.0665685833,
0.0957689881,
-0.1575707346,
0.0998515636,
-0.1171370074,
-0.8005361557,
-0.461699605,
1.0334361792,
0.2204352021,
0.6815060377,
0.0329435728,
0.5923639536,
-0.0559963286,
0.440048784,
-0.5687259436,
0.3690710664,
-0.3938026428,
-0.2867811322,
-0.1585103571,
-0.5160493255,
-0.8918665648,
0.4144718051,
-0.3794005811,
-0.715898037,
0.4559279084,
0.4987297654,
-0.1839138269,
0.3101782799,
-0.9363039136,
0.8124693632,
-0.0331255198,
-0.1132286862,
-0.1624675095,
-0.4390126467,
-0.085592337,
-0.331818223,
0.1773544252,
-0.2206774503,
-0.0899996832,
0.7279363871,
0.0509467609,
0.3144060671,
-0.5289254785,
0.1555647105,
-0.0874392018,
-0.098884128,
0.6689445376,
0.2606484294,
-0.3146116138,
0.1459126472,
-0.1060085818,
-0.511708498,
-0.5867804885,
0.9353201985,
-0.605019629,
-0.5333123803,
0.1097150594,
-0.3035501242,
-0.3960160017,
0.3889272511,
0.2366087288,
0.2280977964,
-0.2208506465,
0.1333574653,
0.8097977638,
-0.1247746274,
0.4338549674,
0.6645284295,
-0.0391286127,
-0.1530819386,
0.9997586608,
0.0351076461,
0.0938850567,
0.3925683796,
0.0203887969,
-0.1742446125,
-0.8468647003,
-0.5598478913,
0.215336591,
-0.4396928549,
-0.3256467283,
-0.4488194883,
0.0649896264,
-0.1262813658,
-0.010773886,
-0.4887556732,
0.0504486188,
-0.6791132092,
0.1806119531,
0.0236907098,
-0.0439462811,
0.1607827395,
0.2259399444,
-0.720641315,
0.4377350807,
0.2697423398,
0.6033463478,
-0.1850083172,
-0.8545633554,
-0.2748118639,
-0.0266843941,
0.1843052208,
-0.6972908974,
0.0649725348,
0.9078426361,
0.6085443497,
0.2520537972,
-0.0258219801,
0.8634121418,
-0.7931949496,
0.244997561,
-0.0246198457,
-0.8261120319,
0.6369377971,
0.0719665512,
0.2071491629,
0.8095356822,
0.2350146472,
-0.3258441985,
-0.06858816,
-0.3358681202,
-0.8485680223,
0.8591473103,
0.0622211397,
0.3374085724,
0.1131483093,
0.6841483712,
-0.0029240462,
0.0551828481,
-0.3529754281,
-0.4650655091,
-0.2257067412,
-0.4867138565,
-0.3149235547,
0.0207219552,
-0.0155765945,
-0.2414099425,
0.718490541,
-0.3833487034,
0.2141783237,
0.036871355,
-0.4997981489,
-0.10160207,
0.2777181864,
0.6511620283,
0.5173024535,
-0.1312991977,
0.1565717757,
0.5997081399,
-0.4837143123,
0.1847480834,
0.2944886684,
-0.1718821526,
0.2227394432,
0.1404478103,
1.090157032,
0.339590162,
-0.3408649266,
0.1969738603,
-0.3671568334,
-0.1470247656,
-0.0549869835,
0.260350436,
0.2720970809,
0.1131635457,
0.1539297998,
0.4357257485,
-0.0638531595,
-0.4175358117,
0.1596235335,
0.3761599064,
-0.4255185127,
-0.5848487616,
0.6243234277,
0.1278562993,
-0.6356713176,
0.5369984508,
0.1219881028,
-0.0422874056,
0.2564383149,
0.9578566551,
0.7480365634,
-0.5393704176,
-0.2224709839,
0.327167064,
0.2267165929,
-0.146630913,
0.0488226786,
0.0933533981,
-0.9475259185,
-0.3791522086,
-0.7157199383,
-0.0302160997,
0.0544350669,
-0.7692632675,
0.4364071786,
-0.4210609198,
-0.1398360431,
0.0760593563,
-0.3371096551,
-1.1637032032,
0.1312098056,
0.0538489372,
1.0483107567,
-0.7810414433,
1.0313488245,
1.0649654865,
-0.1874523759,
-0.8186221123,
0.0104942741,
-0.4767806232,
-0.7795672417,
0.1121204048,
-0.0776605457,
0.0148457596,
0.5339264274,
-0.0214381255,
-0.6864883304,
0.8848896027,
0.8619273305,
-0.9413421154,
-0.2261451632,
-0.138226226,
0.4776311815,
-0.530171752,
0.2208801061,
0.8078103662,
0.5125502944,
-0.3632028103,
-0.9995975494,
0.0927961692,
-0.0650430992,
0.2681041062,
0.3177557886,
-0.2882269323,
0.5643627048,
0.1273740977,
-0.1847662777,
-0.2717607915,
0.6535957456,
0.0826402307,
0.1890491545,
0.7828675508,
0.4244975448,
0.7443426251,
-0.087235637,
0.4932826459,
-0.3587304354,
0.4941521883,
1.2353183031,
-0.227792263,
0.7688354254,
0.5624811649,
-0.0920355394,
0.3316020072,
0.355173111,
0.1300160736,
0.6367122531,
0.335229516,
-0.1138565317,
-0.2020934522,
0.140495941,
-0.3918175697,
0.2155985236,
0.4439166188,
-0.3700760007,
-0.2858863771,
0.3368710577,
-0.2636186182,
0.1978410929,
-0.5649253726,
1.1159771681,
0.1545969844,
-0.3402709365,
0.4835407436,
-0.0505556017,
0.7643265724,
-0.5464803576,
0.0450948663,
-0.1045870706,
0.2847780287,
-0.1296070814,
-0.3351531625,
0.3674889505,
-0.3606697321,
-0.3251404166,
-0.066037342,
0.9379398227,
-0.5712623,
-0.2115408033,
0.3552993536,
0.339890033,
-0.1477233917,
-0.1928023994,
-0.7309241891,
-0.17689237,
-0.1555507034,
-0.259837985,
0.5401853919,
0.4050661027,
0.1564197987,
0.5745335221,
0.5413513184,
0.2451610863,
0.0498649664,
0.2011675984,
0.7901951075,
-0.5557517409,
-0.4774377346,
-0.9015390277,
0.2625706792,
0.1284647286,
-0.2645314038,
0.4189810753,
0.4640645981,
0.8898503184,
-0.2100824416,
0.5852574706,
0.140700236,
0.394906342,
-0.6290565133,
0.5841565132,
-0.4077395797,
0.252497077,
-0.1210928112,
-1.2213408947,
-0.3175616264,
0.4944864213,
-0.2002229393,
0.0566157363,
0.2414329648,
0.7246046066,
-0.477440089,
-0.1910921484,
0.430511862,
-0.0315147154,
0.280354172,
0.5267748833,
0.4920828044,
-0.4128341377,
0.5262268782,
0.064058207,
-0.1247520819,
-0.4564449787,
-0.6889032722,
-0.7533168197,
-0.4470060468,
-0.3258361816,
-0.1363339871,
0.2534838021,
0.950386405,
0.7880218029,
-1.0037423372,
0.2938016355,
-0.1338090003,
0.0202154964,
-0.2983218729,
-0.1465498805,
0.4503115714,
-0.4233796597,
-0.738088727,
0.4096818566,
0.3099460006,
0.0076951804,
0.1764369309,
-0.0818850845,
-0.0159119535,
0.1188043579,
0.2681215703,
0.3367603123,
-0.5163347125,
-0.485465467,
-0.1650731862,
0.2260606289,
0.1037614346,
0.8341854811,
-0.7386148572,
0.5198097825,
0.0937826037,
0.7797748446,
0.4726746976,
-0.0294564646,
0.6088573933,
-0.8637004495,
0.4014082253,
0.47176373,
0.5145567656,
0.2316296101,
-0.1268723607,
0.0625806898,
-0.0769578516,
-0.5471417308,
-0.8560631275,
0.2640799582,
-0.6792331934,
-0.0995909497,
0.6598043442,
-0.3199463785,
-0.0449147932,
-0.2513420582,
-0.2280737758,
0.3584669232,
-0.1722876877,
0.4573558271,
0.2984717786,
0.1204213202,
-0.2768136561,
-0.2935082912,
0.4822584093,
0.4418489933,
-0.7309489846,
-0.1584916264,
-0.0767498687,
0.4744600654,
0.0303654186,
0.5418472886,
0.188213408,
-0.0103219328,
-0.1999328882,
-0.0524865799,
-0.1238898188,
-0.0653748363,
-0.4698066115,
0.0986599401,
0.3265045285,
-0.4204220772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18703v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18703v7 | Domain Specialization as the Key to Make Large Language Models Disruptive: A Comprehensive Survey | 2023-05-30T03:00:30 | 2024-03-29T14:05:07 | Chen Ling, Xujiang Zhao, Jiaying Lu, Chengyuan Deng, Can Zheng, Junxiang Wang, Tanmoy Chowdhury, Yun Li, Hejie Cui, Xuchao Zhang, Tianjiao Zhao, Amit Panalkar, Dhagash Mehta, Stefano Pasquali, Wei Cheng, Haoyu Wang, Yanchi Liu, Zhengzhang Chen, Haifeng Chen, Chris White, Quanquan Gu, Jian Pei, Carl Yang, Liang Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of natural
language processing (NLP), providing a highly useful, task-agnostic foundation
for a wide range of applications. However, directly applying LLMs to solve
sophisticated problems in specific domains meets many hurdles, caused by the
heterogeneity of domain data, the sophistication of domain knowledge, the
uniqueness of domain objectives, and the diversity of the constraints (e.g.,
various social norms, cultural conformity, religious beliefs, and ethical
standards in the domain applications). Domain specification techniques are key
to make large language models disruptive in many applications. Specifically, to
solve these hurdles, there has been a notable increase in research and
practices conducted in recent years on the domain specialization of LLMs. This
emerging field of study, with its substantial potential for impact,
necessitates a comprehensive and systematic review to better summarize and
guide ongoing work in this area. In this article, we present a comprehensive
survey on domain specification techniques for large language models, an
emerging direction critical for large language model applications. First, we
propose a systematic taxonomy that categorizes the LLM domain-specialization
techniques based on the accessibility to LLMs and summarizes the framework for
all the subcategories as well as their relations and differences to each other.
Second, we present an extensive taxonomy of critical application domains that
can benefit dramatically from specialized LLMs, discussing their practical
significance and open challenges. Last, we offer our insights into the current
research status and future trends in this area. | [
-0.6561066508,
-0.9617239833,
0.3571514487,
0.4060303271,
-0.1380159855,
0.4110442698,
-0.5394466519,
-0.802739799,
-0.0601105653,
0.7787187696,
-0.3296724558,
-0.504352212,
-0.7632365227,
0.14585419,
-0.4625422359,
0.6410319209,
-0.0669087544,
-0.2735503912,
-0.3941522241,
0.0137901604,
-0.3803036511,
-0.8448112607,
-0.2921724916,
-0.19084993,
0.3766793013,
0.1588862091,
0.5478290915,
0.5762290955,
0.7044090629,
0.2833846807,
-0.4812200367,
0.1816993058,
-0.3326010108,
0.2972154319,
-0.2880133986,
-0.1447736025,
-0.662219286,
-0.0575572401,
0.8986234069,
1.2089072466,
0.0064931549,
0.0858575627,
0.2239071131,
0.297239244,
-0.4864987731,
0.1279903352,
-0.9060900211,
-0.0983099192,
-0.5914528966,
-0.2137132883,
-0.3470186293,
-0.0553540103,
0.2937461436,
-0.1623077095,
0.1426859796,
-0.1647364348,
0.5916495919,
0.0190715343,
-0.5679614544,
-0.1305135638,
-1.0460994244,
1.0417709351,
-0.7812261581,
0.5404770374,
0.2438932955,
-0.0120330732,
-0.0320121087,
-0.5301108956,
-0.2466230839,
-0.1831027567,
0.2312907428,
-0.3748323023,
-0.0789402649,
0.1507000625,
0.2906753421,
0.4193279147,
-0.4764029682,
0.5824143291,
-0.0683135614,
-0.0602786057,
0.5469981432,
0.5158398747,
0.2667514086,
0.2056376934,
-0.1172017679,
0.4973726869,
-0.9800601006,
-0.141952917,
0.1648881882,
0.3582791686,
0.1715089083,
0.5359372497,
-0.3683505356,
0.8370569944,
-0.2615395784,
-0.1343080848,
0.1744747311,
-0.3923726678,
-0.1411854625,
-0.5488956571,
0.5809748173,
0.0849602297,
0.3087148368,
-0.2394417375,
-0.2816342115,
-0.1373941302,
0.3802628517,
-0.5941596627,
0.3969042599,
0.2739195526,
-0.3282999396,
-0.0146304416,
-0.3445984423,
-0.6605093479,
-0.2262485176,
-0.4489232898,
-0.1576189846,
-0.1905139685,
-0.3404091597,
0.3722060919,
0.1932590902,
0.3364302516,
0.423543483,
-1.0813392401,
0.4677648544,
1.0808207989,
0.7736530304,
-0.6050632,
-0.2518749833,
0.0557083152,
0.1427109689,
-0.1921411753,
0.6994755268,
-0.8030267358,
-0.5350448489,
0.4600831866,
-0.1067346856,
-0.0268864539,
-0.8410790563,
0.7169898152,
-0.8960133195,
-0.3503547907,
-0.0677777678,
-0.6431185007,
-0.3106552064,
0.4144205749,
-0.568272531,
0.6769214272,
-0.0437745713,
-0.5327467322,
0.0919117108,
-0.4516226053,
-0.7069113255,
0.3781689405,
0.0377663262,
-0.3060916364,
0.1116421744,
-0.2009463161,
0.5740433931,
-0.6073983908,
0.3079276085,
-0.3773339987,
0.0822853521,
0.3170600533,
-0.2723962367,
0.667853117,
0.1194286123,
-0.2497143298,
0.1192573234,
-0.6427562833,
0.1207324341,
0.0253331233,
-0.2385791987,
-0.5835010409,
0.0624657013,
0.1503307223,
0.3021492064,
0.3202039599,
-0.1474203765,
0.2041099668,
-0.4271413088,
0.4711951911,
0.6186727285,
0.0869738534,
0.4162670672,
-0.0767358243,
0.6861407757,
-0.1000769362,
0.5172362924,
0.0697659627,
-0.5098836422,
-0.5050116777,
-0.2702928782,
0.3076158464,
0.3028360009,
-0.271445632,
0.7382341623,
-0.1373306662,
-0.5725505948,
-0.1062169746,
0.1871832609,
0.2009119987,
0.1639626175,
0.2443705499,
-0.464553386,
-0.6431089044,
-1.0200581551,
-0.266292572,
0.1177242324,
0.1505304426,
0.3303039074,
0.5586900115,
-0.4977208376,
0.9796586633,
-0.5713019967,
-0.3941872418,
-0.3298891485,
-0.2665251195,
0.1179049015,
0.2770080566,
0.4668593407,
-0.9045920968,
-0.6390815377,
0.0298438687,
-0.4819457829,
-0.1278637052,
0.1938064843,
0.1297500283,
0.2004060298,
0.4404557347,
-0.6681476831,
0.153812781,
0.570423305,
-0.0905448049,
0.8760114908,
0.1625397205,
-0.2016295046,
-0.5964150429,
0.2181430757,
0.0591121837,
-0.0432149954,
-0.9387051463,
0.4119176567,
-0.0605617501,
0.2853220701,
-0.2170537859,
0.539188385,
-0.4954152405,
0.0679403692,
-0.2779078484,
0.00267472,
-0.1760698706,
-0.0453751236,
0.237173155,
0.4345532358,
0.6633375883,
-0.861551702,
0.3269019425,
0.3655484021,
-0.4628058374,
0.0155511564,
-0.7037313581,
-0.0211300626,
0.3249058425,
0.1264161766,
-0.6060779095,
-0.184130922,
-0.0396055356,
-0.2002709359,
0.3845211267,
-0.1468701065,
-0.531847775,
-0.2745626569,
-0.2069301456,
0.5547821522,
0.4655224085,
-0.2454517484,
0.4551207423,
0.8262092471,
-0.5494422913,
-0.6911178827,
-0.5459358692,
0.280433476,
-0.2464994341,
-0.5802815557,
0.4183835387,
-0.2003579736,
-0.5130749941,
-0.2601242661,
0.1139563024,
-0.1698000282,
0.3540104032,
0.1181360409,
0.3881536126,
-0.170642361,
-0.035376247,
-0.1168892533,
0.0289616026,
0.1507692039,
-0.2195252031,
0.6735233665,
0.0809411034,
-0.3184768856,
-0.0227021538,
0.5434749722,
0.5887778401,
-0.4670244455,
0.6648157835,
0.2118640244,
-0.2781051397,
-0.4730847478,
-0.6631326079,
0.0076886192,
-0.4500216842,
0.6115148067,
-0.3421365321,
-1.323143363,
0.6030089259,
-0.331510514,
0.2270215452,
0.3277447224,
0.8638877869,
0.426201582,
0.9101664424,
0.993553102,
-0.0166741908,
0.461360991,
-0.1319760829,
0.4502435327,
-0.9457117319,
-0.1624572128,
-0.7236510515,
0.1333053112,
-0.4442342818,
-0.7016139627,
0.3216928244,
-0.1335982531,
0.1303040981,
-0.0174561199,
-0.2217279673,
0.2995644808,
0.1108689308,
-0.5387392044,
0.4597893059,
0.0679262504,
-0.0108068427,
-0.2231802791,
-0.3948052824,
-0.6692228913,
1.1249662638,
0.5263983607,
0.8159090281,
0.1441091895,
0.3400608003,
0.2179219127,
0.1383175403,
-1.0618737936,
0.7036705017,
-0.2570793927,
-0.7503926754,
-0.3295062482,
-0.2851520479,
-0.8716465235,
0.2949355245,
0.000536075,
-0.6620939374,
0.1650605351,
-0.0758295506,
-0.0174176469,
0.3104349077,
-0.2805953622,
0.5748112202,
0.0113400975,
-0.3657259941,
-0.3147354722,
-0.5735750198,
0.5663672686,
-0.415065378,
0.321004957,
-0.1185425073,
-0.3103770912,
0.546795845,
-0.0255990122,
1.0834810734,
0.1579826027,
-0.5561439395,
0.2058630884,
0.1468585581,
0.444984585,
-0.1041121408,
-0.0362096317,
0.4279476702,
-0.255382061,
-0.1301466078,
-0.2915441394,
0.7412733436,
-0.6143228412,
-0.8209233284,
-0.3188279271,
-0.4711758196,
-0.7544306517,
0.1901917607,
-0.0678265244,
0.2536720932,
-0.504112184,
0.0571701117,
0.9631721377,
-0.1240925863,
0.2485921979,
0.6868417263,
-0.3132725656,
-0.0504428633,
0.8209774494,
0.2472650409,
0.4920600057,
0.3290664554,
-0.1868697405,
-0.2920212746,
-1.1672781706,
0.1510529667,
0.4578938782,
-0.7402256131,
-0.0236063264,
-0.8897899985,
-0.4828392863,
-0.6101078987,
-0.0466144308,
-0.3441915214,
-0.3932392597,
-0.2764269412,
0.0173833761,
-0.1146971211,
0.8255237937,
0.2435290962,
0.0363024548,
-0.9397630095,
0.1970779151,
0.1998554021,
0.6044377685,
0.1797406673,
-0.6372273564,
-0.410379231,
-0.2460843325,
-0.2007026225,
-0.3470636904,
0.3872594833,
0.1191390902,
0.7113700509,
0.4831335247,
0.1010555327,
0.3611167073,
-0.7177467346,
0.8354418874,
-0.0305564553,
-0.8814435601,
0.1467701197,
-0.3190515637,
-0.0108520789,
0.1291059852,
0.6092943549,
-0.8806454539,
-0.5090672374,
-0.6066154838,
-1.1422040462,
0.5508031249,
-0.1149853244,
0.4322603643,
0.0851718262,
0.3275193572,
0.3942996562,
0.2548161745,
-0.5400418639,
-0.3013784289,
0.4279467463,
0.2600358725,
-0.1291734874,
-0.5831810236,
-0.249023363,
-0.2905874252,
0.6612474918,
-0.1678205132,
-0.0693667755,
-0.1648074239,
-0.1878181845,
0.1032434404,
0.4942602217,
0.5885898471,
0.870366931,
-0.0125011224,
0.1469472647,
0.0054589431,
-0.501234591,
0.0542599559,
-0.1890756786,
-0.2866403162,
-0.007798499,
0.5076112747,
0.4658187628,
-0.0668915361,
-0.715079546,
0.3107506931,
0.1432393342,
-0.2259009033,
-0.2989153862,
0.0345137455,
0.1166535094,
0.1130016744,
0.2311807275,
0.0466522016,
0.2029241472,
-0.5056577325,
-0.0287120752,
0.6935542822,
-0.1882524937,
-0.470498383,
0.2392459661,
0.3525725603,
-0.1068978831,
0.270378381,
0.0485329144,
-0.6036172509,
0.4860061407,
0.5935941935,
1.0076403618,
-0.3487633765,
0.1110254452,
0.0398143604,
0.3861632049,
-0.0032861577,
0.0202136002,
0.1836576611,
-0.8618518114,
-0.5809600353,
-0.765583396,
-0.5733875632,
0.2739230692,
-0.4007113278,
0.1381296515,
-0.6359938979,
-0.2186334878,
0.1478390843,
-0.0448517129,
-0.2866901159,
-0.047698725,
0.2865861654,
1.0781954527,
-0.5580833554,
0.7389287949,
0.6755381823,
-0.0450921245,
-0.2494175434,
0.1371758878,
0.009247791,
-0.519436419,
0.6746360064,
-0.164706111,
-0.0891684368,
-0.0500955582,
-0.5143448114,
-0.7768572569,
0.5161585212,
0.1079778299,
-0.5961372256,
-0.0807534307,
0.4304561317,
0.6354931593,
-0.5178151727,
0.0086156065,
0.8817151189,
0.5155405998,
-0.065147154,
-1.0123070478,
0.1365961879,
-0.07606031,
0.282312572,
0.127381593,
-0.732496798,
0.7203592658,
-0.0824164972,
-0.1119218394,
0.0448927432,
0.3495998383,
-0.0450557172,
-0.1623644829,
0.3548417091,
0.1362588257,
0.4629925489,
0.066078335,
0.851616323,
-0.2606136501,
0.3820280135,
0.8705843687,
-0.7037394047,
0.9055675864,
0.3929372132,
-0.4006852806,
0.1289311498,
0.5291141272,
0.0386025421,
0.1300870925,
0.3710249364,
-0.5239720941,
-0.472930491,
-0.4061047137,
-0.3932770491,
0.3836010695,
0.9026620984,
-0.2453936785,
-0.1750038415,
-0.0612582751,
-0.1412470192,
0.0680714473,
-0.227511704,
0.7583072782,
0.21575661,
-0.5057809949,
0.6362460256,
0.3225885928,
0.7773353457,
-0.8845364451,
0.1527781785,
-0.0004886819,
0.0922111422,
-0.2993300259,
-0.8736556768,
0.4399758577,
-0.0455653854,
-0.4202152193,
-0.44658795,
0.7387288213,
-0.2563188076,
0.0291364975,
0.5360000134,
0.6343098283,
-0.1846509576,
-0.2326929271,
-0.5874746442,
0.3902481496,
-0.2426495701,
-0.3381323814,
0.6032222509,
0.3317779005,
-0.2296395898,
0.8175489306,
0.5041069388,
0.1973090023,
0.0953809097,
0.3064326048,
1.1097370386,
-0.7551860213,
-0.2491676509,
-0.8074294925,
0.2304131836,
0.1006510109,
-0.2151908427,
0.7568633556,
0.5593700409,
0.6567191482,
-0.1419963092,
1.0314381123,
-0.0324868001,
0.5483165979,
-0.3675538599,
0.4427264929,
-0.4533389807,
0.4776009917,
-0.1824111789,
-0.9258926511,
-0.7199835777,
0.1007063165,
-0.4267790616,
0.1808980405,
0.7234072685,
0.6259923577,
-0.0009364398,
-0.0763310865,
0.4881232977,
0.4791207016,
0.5345615149,
0.2356550694,
1.006844759,
0.1737231016,
0.3492701948,
-0.0393820032,
-0.310308069,
-0.5370808244,
-0.5992093682,
-0.8393051028,
-0.697994411,
-0.4360962808,
-0.1837020516,
-0.1058105603,
0.7818484306,
0.6303129196,
-0.7618007064,
-0.5278201699,
0.2339687496,
0.3960067332,
-0.1464312375,
-0.257032454,
0.0514247604,
-0.4962235093,
-0.8893264532,
0.2432600558,
0.6220571995,
-0.0570593067,
-0.4130377173,
0.1553717107,
-0.2300833017,
0.1012212113,
1.0140594244,
0.3622747064,
-0.7889474034,
-0.1071053669,
-0.0219623893,
-0.2501446307,
-0.1127451509,
1.0534141064,
-0.3288404942,
0.1244882643,
0.4973262846,
0.6583347917,
-0.0172432438,
-0.3269841671,
0.5738671422,
-0.6477540731,
-0.0259304047,
0.5632978082,
0.2773343921,
0.1486159712,
-0.2456047684,
0.3755777478,
0.40500319,
-0.5916925073,
-0.9392077923,
0.5108054876,
-1.0805616379,
-0.3236231804,
1.3679385185,
-0.0534070805,
-0.1088936925,
-0.6435545087,
-0.028380543,
-0.1886968613,
-0.0869335681,
0.6660622954,
0.8414940238,
-0.0472972207,
-0.0453460738,
-0.6184553504,
0.6174070239,
0.2222460508,
-0.7287498116,
0.6729791164,
0.3776501417,
0.4221268296,
0.1412329376,
0.5547159314,
-0.3743142188,
-0.0333535634,
-0.3135603368,
0.1659617722,
0.1521179676,
-0.2925506234,
-0.5293648839,
0.3994666636,
0.5333676934,
0.4959072173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18679v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18679v2 | KEYword based Sampling (KEYS) for Large Language Models | 2023-05-30T01:35:04 | 2023-06-02T02:35:03 | Jyothir S V, Zuhaib Akhtar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Question answering (Q/A) can be formulated as a generative task (Mitra, 2017)
where the task is to generate an answer given the question and the passage
(knowledge, if available). Recent advances in QA task is focused a lot on
language model advancements and less on other areas such as sampling(Krishna et
al., 2021), (Nakano et al., 2021). Keywords play very important role for humans
in language generation. (Humans formulate keywords and use grammar to connect
those keywords and work). In the research community, very little focus is on
how humans generate answers to a question and how this behavior can be
incorporated in a language model. In this paper, we want to explore these two
areas combined, i.e., how sampling can be to used generate answers which are
close to human-like behavior and factually correct. Hence, the type of decoding
algorithm we think should be used for Q/A tasks should also depend on the
keywords. These keywords can be obtained from the question, passage or internet
results. We use knowledge distillation techniques to extract keywords and
sample using these extracted keywords on top of vanilla decoding algorithms
when formulating the answer to generate a human-like answer. In this paper, we
show that our decoding method outperforms most commonly used decoding methods
for Q/A task | [
-0.1884533316,
-0.7443964481,
0.616453886,
-0.0150139015,
-0.4672005773,
0.326684773,
-0.0070953895,
-0.2708046436,
0.0134081049,
0.4428529441,
-0.5566358566,
-0.5261330009,
-0.3112723231,
0.2550203502,
-0.36015746,
0.7257661819,
0.4543617666,
-0.0196970217,
-0.3267463148,
0.0504065193,
-0.305880785,
-0.740947783,
-0.5996026397,
-0.0712332055,
0.208446905,
0.2507970035,
0.5279524326,
0.4405176938,
0.3405273259,
0.2392992079,
-0.3096332252,
0.0510276109,
-0.4778667092,
0.3417695165,
-0.1481882483,
-0.8457592726,
-0.2332666516,
0.1152546927,
0.0601334833,
0.4777249098,
-0.3248994946,
0.3171625733,
-0.0594464354,
0.6028587818,
-0.6194140315,
0.2416772693,
-1.0892000198,
-0.1749756187,
-0.2491094172,
-0.1620725989,
-0.2469345927,
-0.3810254037,
0.0505205132,
-0.6274648905,
0.7439956665,
-0.0996833816,
0.703168869,
0.121623002,
-0.1540295631,
-0.8739753962,
-0.5370182395,
0.6998522282,
-0.9888763428,
0.1680211574,
0.5781029463,
0.3639012873,
-0.0789921582,
-0.7319984436,
-1.0208837986,
-0.0666187182,
0.0631710961,
0.0964965075,
0.3272799551,
0.2637892067,
0.2867964506,
0.4741353393,
-0.274870187,
-0.3349111378,
-0.5865917802,
-0.0938896909,
0.5998866558,
0.1417600513,
0.3356517553,
-0.3568846881,
0.1087484881,
-0.5241985917,
-0.6816183329,
0.4205864966,
0.3080042005,
0.3535229862,
0.2022604048,
0.3762917221,
-0.4593779445,
0.8935875297,
0.1855153143,
-0.2311887145,
0.1471665502,
-0.4474483132,
-0.131741181,
-0.2384650707,
0.572904408,
0.3582820594,
0.3332359791,
-0.2384702563,
-0.0222933386,
-0.1297109723,
0.3203089535,
-0.8103656769,
-0.3867622018,
0.3712654114,
-0.5255585909,
-0.5233942866,
-0.0242533293,
-0.9717000127,
-0.265837878,
0.0442610234,
0.3221365511,
-0.2391319722,
-0.3420493603,
0.2108716667,
-0.3731653988,
0.4897345901,
0.161953792,
-0.8102641702,
0.27292642,
0.4984279871,
0.5504244566,
0.1204096973,
0.2320242077,
-0.4155707955,
-0.2291680872,
-0.3172906637,
0.5355374813,
-0.5029928684,
-0.6455945969,
0.1681890786,
-0.271963954,
0.0278224684,
-0.7388174534,
0.3265572488,
-1.1018342972,
0.1589989513,
-0.5691335797,
-0.6355523467,
-0.4068481922,
0.4803365171,
-0.8204160929,
0.7694064379,
0.105442591,
-0.7544499636,
0.2818910778,
-0.578994751,
-0.2313497961,
0.2478562444,
-0.3106760085,
-0.3686653376,
0.2189474553,
0.4750730395,
0.253229022,
-0.2577050924,
0.0034145911,
-0.2987223268,
-0.3156213462,
0.7901374102,
-0.1484132558,
0.8375059962,
0.5464932919,
-0.1405789405,
-0.3065197766,
-0.734811604,
0.3150771558,
0.1384430677,
-0.4245427549,
-0.4101637304,
0.091100499,
0.049797684,
0.3181085587,
0.1476387233,
-0.8359045386,
0.08913403,
-0.4690634012,
0.5800762773,
0.2787320316,
0.4335811734,
0.1637663841,
-0.3121900558,
0.8033689857,
0.039744556,
-0.2759028375,
-0.1296613961,
-0.4540040195,
-0.301692456,
-0.1969017088,
0.6248142719,
0.5527226329,
-0.9802690744,
0.2845500708,
-0.2738621533,
-0.3914029896,
-0.9129821658,
0.310901612,
0.4003077745,
0.3439831436,
0.1638620943,
-0.0077513107,
-0.4049265683,
-0.5717836618,
-0.2568629384,
-0.3460523784,
-0.1769013405,
0.2350594103,
0.2079920918,
0.3040805459,
1.1989194155,
-0.8017711043,
-0.0797245502,
-0.4274322093,
0.2030416876,
0.2736208737,
0.1624542773,
0.4887266457,
-1.0336214304,
-0.4696954787,
-0.4993766844,
-0.5478235483,
0.0642149746,
0.0409392901,
-0.058315251,
-0.1565599293,
0.7307446003,
-0.5276606083,
0.284411937,
0.4179148972,
-0.1339650154,
0.1277718544,
-0.1080405936,
0.3132844567,
-1.4881384373,
0.3079701066,
-0.3535847068,
-0.1110711768,
-0.4798859656,
0.3999821842,
0.096183151,
-0.2820812464,
-0.5144332647,
0.4207603335,
-0.5232744813,
0.2462135255,
-0.5434243679,
-0.0038479089,
0.0783482864,
0.4189564884,
0.1645716429,
0.9636568427,
0.3196427226,
-0.5777524114,
0.3476458788,
0.3236794472,
-0.2882407308,
0.2981878221,
-0.8321939111,
0.5106087923,
-0.3124107122,
0.1568214446,
-1.3207137585,
0.0700529963,
-0.1081700251,
-0.7326305509,
0.1216315478,
-0.1144314706,
-0.7531332374,
-0.4048467278,
-0.2950383127,
0.6040663719,
0.9030843377,
-0.2275029272,
0.2541253567,
0.4681592882,
-0.2551855445,
-0.3112657368,
-0.3400533199,
-0.1701039076,
-0.1624793708,
-0.2481996864,
0.047458075,
-0.0126055153,
-0.2376216054,
0.2239167243,
-0.1750775874,
-0.2707206607,
0.1866639405,
0.049246043,
0.0110432757,
0.005142943,
0.2628067136,
-0.0205439515,
0.1982783824,
0.1680447012,
-0.0976795107,
0.5717368722,
0.3215916455,
-0.2321103215,
-0.1645099968,
0.388681531,
0.769074142,
-0.5256358981,
0.5800350904,
0.2215463966,
-0.2430505902,
-0.1355902851,
-0.4694356322,
-0.5164667368,
-0.4519619644,
0.3946765661,
-0.548648417,
-0.9059188962,
0.6682786942,
0.0894478485,
0.1862003356,
0.268132329,
0.4049503505,
-0.3929692507,
0.9387503862,
0.409942627,
-0.2092404664,
0.1973551661,
-0.3443345129,
0.379704833,
-0.7738253474,
0.0686713681,
-0.7961153388,
-0.3396928012,
-0.6286182404,
-0.5566173196,
0.4670372903,
0.2608900964,
0.5541950464,
0.0725749433,
-0.4024851918,
0.22186701,
0.8425433636,
0.1896669716,
0.140404135,
0.0153628066,
-0.1832936555,
0.0288508125,
-0.553348124,
-0.207333222,
1.5886375904,
0.083016634,
0.7141822577,
-0.139191702,
0.8365690708,
0.2482976317,
0.0335364453,
-0.5982543826,
0.5030100942,
-0.0228215177,
-1.0691951513,
-0.445934236,
-0.1783675849,
-0.9906813502,
0.2480462641,
-0.1352564245,
-0.5755013227,
-0.0366786942,
0.2376621515,
-0.5986326337,
0.0499482714,
-0.374004811,
0.6916692257,
0.0705416352,
0.0617256165,
-0.2771697938,
-0.7457870245,
0.2316719592,
0.108305715,
0.2316238433,
0.0803842396,
0.2638224363,
0.8690539598,
-0.3227909207,
0.8107290268,
-0.394449681,
-0.0544338487,
0.8065648675,
-0.0951002017,
0.3831219375,
0.1090352535,
-0.0394991711,
-0.3200734854,
0.399012506,
-0.488684535,
-0.8667209148,
0.2970062494,
-0.6410509348,
-0.6819364429,
-0.3370603919,
-0.62940979,
-0.4479489625,
-0.1288696527,
0.3369388282,
0.4933309555,
-0.0777217597,
0.3421656489,
1.1185982227,
-0.2190900445,
0.3751803339,
0.682533443,
-0.1384355873,
-0.4691410363,
0.7501676679,
-0.0627905577,
0.2085819691,
0.7856832743,
0.1339498609,
-0.752833128,
-0.7071749568,
-0.5165483356,
0.2848502994,
-0.478453666,
-0.1990526319,
-0.6858751178,
-0.3502117097,
-0.7993700504,
0.2099984288,
-0.0459080264,
-0.271690011,
0.0101771001,
-0.3038176596,
0.4689347446,
0.3283075094,
0.1769568026,
0.2247918397,
-1.2876278162,
0.7539821267,
0.8033216596,
-0.1114319637,
-0.0065783849,
-0.2875021994,
-0.1630371064,
0.2924390435,
-0.2208427489,
-1.3522675037,
0.3047142327,
0.1357097626,
0.6580857635,
0.2209441662,
0.2938176394,
0.595723331,
-0.2965059876,
0.994953692,
-0.3113527596,
-0.7755312324,
0.5471431613,
-0.1946975887,
0.608297646,
1.1093245745,
0.1980314553,
-0.7637248635,
-0.6909613013,
-0.7808380723,
-0.8991957307,
0.5087934136,
0.3845311701,
0.3480965793,
-0.1822200269,
0.4958985448,
-0.0718074813,
0.635112226,
-0.5031396747,
-0.1098360047,
-0.0266367719,
-0.4768521488,
-0.0360161066,
-0.3221407533,
0.1440260261,
-0.0025241554,
0.593609035,
-0.0322413854,
0.1175098643,
0.153438583,
-0.2094827145,
0.0136734899,
0.4498313367,
0.5679054856,
0.4489762485,
-0.4382316172,
0.0524104349,
-0.1033206657,
-0.771140039,
0.0657162368,
-0.0307657942,
-0.5667177439,
0.0717328638,
0.1346488297,
0.4107952416,
-0.1565853357,
-0.9687390327,
0.5230637789,
-0.1873684227,
-0.1689088196,
0.0083348406,
0.1287768781,
0.3557924926,
-0.0302680936,
0.6110167503,
-0.3624198139,
0.4588598609,
-0.6353456378,
0.3198584616,
0.5465326905,
-0.1944279373,
-0.312512666,
0.5952970386,
0.4200672507,
-0.2647761703,
0.9047255516,
-0.5085329413,
-0.7322332859,
0.6757754683,
0.4259039164,
0.8754815459,
-0.0650973246,
0.2491108775,
0.5430478454,
0.1006387174,
0.1580676287,
0.7580020428,
-0.4621036649,
-0.7878659964,
-0.4824611843,
-0.9016897678,
-0.1895245612,
0.568236351,
-0.8070706129,
-0.2477308214,
-0.081925936,
0.0508433506,
-0.4198129177,
0.2110916674,
-0.5386126637,
0.5436776876,
-0.0135220289,
1.0104179382,
-0.9879012108,
0.8387494087,
0.9815786481,
-0.3604927063,
-1.1006462574,
0.3009130955,
-0.2525931299,
-0.6436347365,
0.6322879195,
-0.1116053909,
0.1801094115,
0.1815249324,
-0.4884866774,
-0.8459720612,
0.8918802738,
-0.2132326066,
-0.4459407628,
-0.3401480317,
0.2374560088,
0.7196901441,
-0.0014127,
-0.1603998095,
0.4509185851,
0.1018212512,
0.4541080594,
-0.7791869044,
0.032972917,
-0.4878251255,
0.3175367117,
0.0241095591,
-0.0547117628,
0.645907104,
-0.0133124907,
-0.2622732818,
0.224320218,
0.8464360833,
0.6366255283,
0.2414227575,
0.6269513965,
0.7649668455,
0.5388979912,
0.2099954933,
0.9326992631,
-0.5371092558,
0.3088560104,
1.0072677135,
-0.1270537972,
0.9307151437,
0.5495298505,
-0.4699805677,
0.214455694,
0.5299149752,
0.3233015835,
0.9833909273,
0.4839522243,
-0.2754625976,
-0.1846491247,
0.3076511919,
-0.2675289512,
0.5912156701,
0.4222801626,
-0.2796956897,
-0.4877165854,
0.0430005975,
-0.0583589375,
0.3875016868,
-0.1645627916,
1.0402208567,
-0.044529289,
-0.9542248249,
0.3199598789,
0.0429568514,
0.6098138094,
-0.4960593581,
-0.2668579221,
-0.1911174655,
-0.0480068289,
0.2538395822,
-0.7140678763,
0.1632210612,
-0.0500400402,
-0.2480246276,
-0.1555826813,
0.554817915,
-0.7415280938,
-0.5420080423,
-0.4094518423,
0.6928470731,
0.1313474029,
-0.3678708971,
-0.4600072205,
-0.2901116908,
0.04478129,
-0.002698909,
0.1321932971,
0.384223938,
0.0911017582,
0.3399413526,
0.6393718719,
0.3750499487,
0.4052238464,
-0.1876729727,
0.6143950224,
-0.5495582223,
-0.8320839405,
-0.5752654076,
0.378667146,
-0.1375639588,
-0.1787845045,
0.6180081964,
0.5191533566,
0.7528401613,
-0.3745140731,
0.9950962067,
-0.3397488892,
0.9727249146,
-0.6119840741,
0.7603949904,
-0.3077246547,
-0.0576613247,
-0.0641877726,
-0.7309318185,
0.2066565901,
0.5420324206,
-0.1584529877,
-0.0278433077,
0.5159255862,
0.7968886495,
0.1956625432,
-0.1881454736,
0.349707365,
-0.0802821591,
0.4386200011,
0.4933801293,
0.6378381252,
-0.5010641217,
0.4553617239,
-0.2609440982,
-0.0266608745,
-0.2584514916,
-0.5848291516,
-0.74507761,
-0.9708510041,
-0.2228568196,
-0.3894616663,
0.0347261503,
0.6902318597,
0.66144979,
-0.9455394745,
-0.2415440828,
-0.1893044561,
0.0247675329,
-0.4455454051,
-0.2624431252,
0.248471275,
-0.5995356441,
-0.9115839601,
0.0287874229,
-0.1885254979,
-0.0800539553,
-0.1326042116,
0.2332472205,
-0.1808465272,
0.1870299429,
0.3704032004,
0.2302504033,
-0.5822870135,
-0.0942055136,
0.518588841,
-0.2586952746,
-0.0471432805,
1.1126371622,
-0.932944715,
0.5910306573,
0.9020920992,
0.8144901991,
0.4947624803,
0.3454358876,
0.6622402668,
-0.7926998734,
-0.0651900992,
0.4341521263,
-0.0635276511,
0.2981240451,
-0.2730010748,
0.1556441486,
0.2546471953,
-0.1495460272,
-0.6379365325,
0.3313516676,
-1.009021163,
-0.4566125572,
1.1577692032,
-0.2056992799,
-0.4284699559,
-0.2207465172,
-0.3221740723,
0.3423282504,
-0.2364632189,
1.2145901918,
0.7891484499,
0.1564123929,
-0.2615808547,
-0.2085586041,
0.7590919733,
0.1464762837,
-0.7719863057,
-0.1051302478,
0.318487078,
0.6080486178,
0.3177652955,
0.8811547756,
-0.2797265947,
0.4960482717,
-0.1194295138,
0.1065352261,
-0.0451901704,
0.053415712,
-0.136329174,
0.5238390565,
0.4443953037,
-0.8020687699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18675v1 | History Repeats: Overcoming Catastrophic Forgetting For Event-Centric Temporal Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-05-30T01:21:36 | 2023-05-30T01:21:36 | Mehrnoosh Mirtaheri, Mohammad Rostami, Aram Galstyan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.6; I.2.7 | Temporal knowledge graph (TKG) completion models typically rely on having
access to the entire graph during training. However, in real-world scenarios,
TKG data is often received incrementally as events unfold, leading to a dynamic
non-stationary data distribution over time. While one could incorporate
fine-tuning to existing methods to allow them to adapt to evolving TKG data,
this can lead to forgetting previously learned patterns. Alternatively,
retraining the model with the entire updated TKG can mitigate forgetting but is
computationally burdensome. To address these challenges, we propose a general
continual training framework that is applicable to any TKG completion method,
and leverages two key ideas: (i) a temporal regularization that encourages
repurposing of less important model parameters for learning new knowledge, and
(ii) a clustering-based experience replay that reinforces the past knowledge by
selectively preserving only a small portion of the past data. Our experimental
results on widely used event-centric TKG datasets demonstrate the effectiveness
of our proposed continual training framework in adapting to new events while
reducing catastrophic forgetting. Further, we perform ablation studies to show
the effectiveness of each component of our proposed framework. Finally, we
investigate the relation between the memory dedicated to experience replay and
the benefit gained from our clustering-based sampling strategy. | [
0.0285089724,
-0.6377140284,
0.5495397449,
-0.0026191275,
-0.4540684521,
0.6677139401,
-0.0249512866,
-0.1100555286,
0.2196800411,
0.3871608377,
-0.6794556975,
-0.7540356517,
-0.3178502619,
-0.3103601635,
-0.2241571695,
0.9400283098,
-0.3904626966,
-0.3250279427,
-0.2017602473,
-0.3590092957,
-0.68199718,
-0.4476925731,
-1.332212925,
-0.9374145269,
0.6796833873,
0.4426261783,
0.0282735247,
0.6796136498,
-0.1441589594,
0.0238377675,
0.0333619006,
0.1775816828,
-0.8560786843,
0.119391337,
-0.1726247519,
-0.4275665879,
-0.31622383,
-0.2338110954,
0.9093860984,
1.0232101679,
-0.4381428957,
-0.0869603977,
0.058074519,
0.7452085018,
-0.5602668524,
0.1037218124,
-0.5451982021,
0.5771208405,
0.1084748581,
-0.4510163963,
-0.4814976454,
-0.4707068503,
0.1850902438,
-0.7777466774,
0.4512465596,
0.0366339162,
0.5297235847,
0.2104304433,
-0.350643605,
0.010180857,
-0.8998042941,
0.6727156639,
-0.4497893155,
0.5431607366,
0.3724628985,
0.2971923947,
-0.2092974186,
-0.7576161623,
-0.2222517133,
-0.2452468574,
0.0506310463,
0.3731631637,
0.0789642334,
0.0122243529,
0.2788333297,
0.138791725,
-0.6765667796,
-0.0011959908,
-0.158644259,
-0.1723050922,
0.1837439537,
0.4426040351,
-0.0413352959,
0.3207332194,
-0.3361635506,
0.0259289462,
-0.7012250423,
0.0025257079,
-0.04017663,
-0.0534247719,
0.0764371604,
0.201032266,
-0.3051295877,
0.5296704173,
0.1481871307,
-0.2734362483,
0.3073823154,
-0.2680515051,
0.0079665445,
0.0681827068,
0.2023907304,
0.410038203,
0.1829961687,
-0.9116389751,
0.2946237922,
-0.1731000394,
0.6471606493,
-0.342910707,
-0.3491097689,
0.0599136613,
-0.3000460267,
-0.1888906658,
-0.2085489631,
-0.5553253889,
-0.2635092437,
-0.4537276924,
0.3011200428,
-0.7767719626,
-0.263145268,
-0.05106223,
-0.5317409635,
-0.0756377578,
0.3277283609,
-0.566123724,
0.12042927,
0.6293883324,
0.9309489727,
-0.2398438007,
-0.4774749279,
-0.3064542115,
0.771510303,
-0.5152366757,
0.4957086742,
-0.3417646885,
-0.5458631516,
-0.1858902723,
0.0374128036,
-0.2160354555,
-0.4941980541,
-0.026552083,
-0.6585922241,
-0.0990720987,
-0.3561530113,
-0.7777328491,
-0.3258441687,
0.6888698339,
-0.3376821578,
0.8659551144,
0.2465497553,
-0.4382457733,
0.9337064028,
-0.2191908956,
-0.2981493175,
0.0565324947,
-0.0211702865,
-0.904596746,
0.0815625265,
-0.1190297306,
0.1518389136,
0.245079875,
0.2945069373,
-0.7951390147,
-0.3249994814,
-0.2815203071,
-0.0491976514,
0.1660099328,
-0.1280194372,
-0.2287027836,
-0.0517224409,
-0.7989323735,
-0.1379554421,
0.1092825159,
-0.3637130857,
-0.2603672445,
0.161451593,
-0.3727589846,
0.0295491032,
0.2417871803,
-0.5481520295,
0.4344604611,
-0.0796658024,
0.4736157358,
0.7317547798,
0.7664091587,
0.4683027267,
-0.8415230513,
0.3067034781,
0.291446358,
0.2011570781,
-0.3932948112,
-0.0629545897,
-0.7931086421,
0.2275707722,
-0.0864389613,
0.502009213,
-0.8205869794,
0.1627127379,
-0.4885231256,
-0.626263082,
0.384871006,
0.1267107725,
0.2018734962,
0.9537941217,
0.4658150971,
-0.3964477479,
-0.6688570976,
-0.5468479991,
0.095927,
-0.4214124382,
-0.1342687905,
0.5385629535,
0.3227017224,
-0.1721629798,
1.058427453,
-0.2483890057,
-0.3329891264,
-0.0100890324,
0.360838443,
0.0549994633,
0.6191293597,
0.6255888939,
-0.4521802962,
-0.1678537726,
0.2606133819,
-0.952989459,
0.2390027046,
-0.4010102153,
0.0293690953,
0.5076345801,
0.5654375553,
-0.2251257747,
0.6445048451,
-0.0265960414,
-0.3467289507,
0.4667368829,
-0.2842139304,
0.3148627877,
-0.7364193201,
0.2178429067,
-0.6371588111,
-0.2809083462,
-0.3335399628,
-0.4999918342,
0.182181716,
-0.0733150542,
-0.0974309221,
0.732172966,
0.0177735593,
0.2503889203,
-0.2497502714,
-0.2059841156,
-0.1694680154,
0.7258133292,
0.015109214,
0.159857288,
0.2420727164,
-0.7934343219,
0.2449983209,
0.0597037897,
0.0808788389,
0.6471366286,
-0.3544902205,
0.4097316861,
-0.3390115499,
0.4259285629,
-0.9253004193,
-0.1968433708,
0.2914094031,
-0.4557941556,
0.6853412986,
-0.5522400737,
-0.3754684031,
-0.5102668405,
-0.0211644918,
0.3692160547,
0.6452205181,
-0.5285896063,
1.0285032988,
-0.0201690048,
-0.0170231946,
-0.5817946196,
-0.3705275059,
0.1906797439,
-0.3608993292,
-0.2278394848,
0.1753570884,
-0.0570624545,
0.3687993288,
0.1929043233,
-0.6272144914,
0.1496295482,
0.1704297215,
0.3064691722,
-0.0244653095,
0.0841660723,
0.4630975127,
0.0168742742,
-0.3280996978,
-0.2314641923,
-1.1983984709,
0.5966853499,
0.3049287498,
-0.3418700695,
-0.1788526177,
0.2734015584,
0.4109666348,
0.380385071,
0.7716722488,
0.6395757198,
-0.5299564004,
-0.1203330457,
-0.9895534515,
-0.0915826559,
-0.3404680789,
0.4101281166,
0.0760025904,
-1.197835803,
0.7998925447,
-0.1818705052,
0.3476232588,
0.2024303824,
0.2610944211,
-0.4938524067,
0.4523775876,
0.6050822735,
-0.3601798415,
0.699126482,
-0.1840168387,
-0.0531461276,
-0.54439044,
-0.5267648697,
-0.0143379765,
-0.5121577978,
0.0316814743,
0.0866564959,
0.4215570986,
0.5209088326,
-0.6257372499,
-0.0220766254,
-0.1012436822,
0.377296418,
0.3839350939,
0.5493583083,
0.2829783857,
0.1750649661,
0.0292439032,
0.0513434149,
-1.1041119099,
-0.030858269,
1.3317499161,
0.0093066031,
0.4114644527,
-0.3013583422,
0.8814088702,
0.3934906423,
0.5251443982,
-0.2911797166,
0.1936179996,
-0.0408682972,
-0.193325758,
-0.3156143427,
-0.7029417157,
-1.0322198868,
-0.4193719625,
0.0939630121,
-0.8634825945,
0.0576882325,
0.6674548388,
-0.2839170694,
0.7059288025,
-0.4377601147,
0.8000728488,
0.1489916295,
-0.1585099697,
-0.585803926,
-0.3944195509,
0.0610447526,
-0.2231137305,
-0.1184058487,
0.0892568976,
-0.0438272953,
0.7784080505,
-0.189346388,
1.1766576767,
-0.4189780354,
0.6038299799,
0.3343412876,
0.1394382268,
0.6727709174,
0.1072642282,
0.2991227806,
0.1306147426,
-0.2309519053,
-0.7682148218,
-0.6324398518,
0.5485252142,
-0.7180461287,
-0.3063022494,
0.0118753966,
-0.5697261691,
-0.2773664594,
0.2039086223,
0.2969895005,
0.3731140792,
-0.3444299102,
0.2264824361,
0.8895606995,
-0.0838647112,
0.467038542,
0.5122466683,
-0.0768909231,
-0.6918177605,
1.0156861544,
0.4982094467,
0.2826843858,
0.1299304515,
-0.0466947258,
0.0213398021,
-0.776902616,
-0.1488351822,
0.3474516273,
-0.6454712152,
-0.2096295357,
-1.0318778753,
-0.1232038364,
-0.2553455532,
-0.3794640005,
-0.2598011494,
-0.4540695548,
-0.2355433106,
-0.1886461228,
0.5603922606,
0.5229995847,
-0.2543401718,
0.4009144008,
-0.7454702854,
0.1682697088,
0.3157655895,
0.6213723421,
0.4704380929,
-0.3871830702,
-0.3791083097,
-0.1751436889,
-0.3881027997,
-0.4738685191,
0.0740331188,
0.2502765059,
0.6787549853,
0.2517662346,
-0.1827155203,
0.6148024201,
-0.5815865993,
0.7435517311,
0.2266497314,
-0.339972347,
0.5553414822,
-0.5981621742,
0.4650467038,
0.5770964026,
0.3769560754,
-0.9560605884,
-0.4450974166,
-0.9575806856,
-1.1195186377,
0.5502333045,
-0.1696828306,
-0.3089117408,
-0.1042231992,
0.9241732359,
0.0645171553,
0.3016448617,
-0.3463194966,
-0.1932010204,
-0.405741483,
-0.0254492369,
-0.0959477425,
-0.2978416979,
-0.2381313294,
0.1287558228,
0.7565252781,
-0.0465598889,
0.0280102808,
0.0357552096,
-0.1378104687,
-0.0800003707,
-0.0276601892,
0.3023964167,
0.80103302,
-0.2493281662,
-0.3187499344,
0.5858926773,
-0.6024280787,
0.2243451178,
-0.2235933244,
-0.3364650905,
-0.1390904337,
0.5214611888,
0.4948382974,
0.3949911892,
-0.195661813,
-0.034015473,
0.1730356961,
-0.2216484994,
-0.8057062626,
0.2872135043,
0.0218335483,
0.2554705441,
0.6315168738,
0.155739367,
-0.3227047026,
-0.2322033644,
0.4427820146,
-0.0490002967,
-0.5027776957,
-0.0970418751,
0.4957197905,
-0.33211115,
-0.1423771232,
0.9282258749,
-0.2490843982,
-0.4685304761,
0.6699342132,
0.3261906505,
0.7508385777,
-0.130646497,
-0.0679189414,
0.7804056406,
0.1363780797,
-0.4058841467,
0.1471446902,
-0.255543679,
-0.3986345828,
-0.2917350233,
-0.4763371944,
-0.3411820233,
0.0568694025,
-0.568025291,
-0.0714456737,
-0.8268740177,
-0.1519480497,
-0.6738075614,
-0.0901027471,
-0.7244523764,
0.1361974478,
0.0644956678,
0.8744707704,
-0.856013298,
0.7050062418,
0.3361920118,
-0.1933178604,
-0.5038864613,
-0.3054691851,
0.1693019867,
-0.5985893607,
0.1818944514,
-0.1913682073,
0.2708720565,
0.1003165692,
-0.3984948695,
-0.9266744256,
1.5956249237,
-0.0437945575,
-0.5032451153,
-0.191081062,
-0.0036649017,
0.3816508651,
-0.3249240816,
-0.2561431229,
0.8278902173,
0.3432243764,
0.5182445049,
-0.7194634676,
-0.1834283024,
0.0254296623,
-0.1582946628,
0.4689828157,
-0.5430621505,
0.3053769767,
-0.1897306889,
-0.2337839454,
0.1384558827,
0.5818418264,
0.5600345135,
0.7715147138,
0.3943558335,
1.1436654329,
0.9225129485,
-0.3424380124,
0.861592114,
-0.0397357084,
0.2818142772,
1.3765169382,
0.1410978734,
0.268180877,
0.2333063632,
-0.1014441103,
0.294262737,
0.7807352543,
-0.0403290428,
0.5346942544,
-0.18985264,
-0.2156979442,
-0.4481391907,
-0.0903070197,
-0.5568218827,
-0.2848806083,
0.4108069241,
-0.155089885,
-0.5962836742,
0.3645335436,
0.1227030903,
-0.3760899305,
-0.6547808051,
0.8787593246,
0.1741401851,
-0.4631374478,
0.32756266,
-0.6537709832,
0.1787609309,
-0.9755135179,
-0.0000738669,
-0.5210881829,
0.1625933647,
-0.0793819129,
-0.4530524313,
0.5075733662,
-0.47471416,
-0.5731958747,
-0.1507618278,
0.2885943055,
-0.4289204478,
-0.2610274553,
0.2670300305,
0.1492565274,
-0.1798342615,
0.2138208896,
-0.2827526629,
-0.0292737987,
-0.0465062112,
-0.1614607722,
0.3297765553,
0.5752637386,
-0.2034065127,
0.9197913408,
0.3400855362,
0.0272699799,
0.0536542349,
0.1266178042,
0.7553526759,
-0.8820411563,
-0.767356813,
-0.6663787365,
0.3897404671,
-0.0095236227,
-0.0842629373,
0.4715780616,
0.5230123401,
0.9917861223,
0.2008985132,
0.8471460342,
0.1702624112,
0.5781982541,
-0.5260497928,
0.7781502604,
-0.4625945091,
0.0220950954,
-0.0646826178,
-0.6351867914,
-0.3578841984,
0.0582721904,
-0.3446225822,
0.0968789905,
0.5730037689,
0.2509448528,
0.0323783867,
0.027000837,
0.2109821588,
0.3174402118,
0.5029815435,
1.0688652992,
0.7808606029,
-0.1216228157,
0.6336025596,
-0.190848738,
-0.345359534,
0.0148335025,
-0.8811534047,
-0.9166305065,
-0.5283335447,
-0.4025476873,
-0.5555764437,
0.3470496535,
0.7719284892,
0.5288845897,
-0.6678789854,
0.095096454,
-0.1238142997,
0.0882561877,
-0.288180232,
-0.1273138225,
0.4517056346,
-0.6442787647,
-0.0150362728,
0.2733683884,
0.5220593214,
0.308152318,
0.2085316777,
0.0427872017,
0.1850246489,
-0.4868091643,
0.3169669211,
0.8035820723,
-0.3453216553,
-0.74511379,
-0.1107342765,
0.3775589168,
0.2293016315,
1.0773557425,
-1.2227687836,
0.5973232388,
0.1140328869,
0.7716026902,
1.0625739098,
-0.3192826509,
0.5941618681,
-0.7487064004,
0.1115870625,
0.3104528785,
0.324973762,
0.1756287068,
-0.2961754203,
0.6265253425,
0.6903358698,
-0.4958195984,
-0.5779346824,
0.2278596014,
-0.9006109834,
-0.2423141748,
0.6398134232,
-0.2398432344,
-0.1575401276,
-0.61167413,
0.2072625756,
0.5274261832,
-0.2015232146,
1.2203733921,
0.8533968925,
-0.1735158712,
-0.2441712916,
-0.2626763284,
0.3114790022,
0.1498223245,
-0.3470821679,
0.1270906627,
0.4330752492,
0.6560200453,
-0.0038440635,
0.778068006,
-0.195963338,
0.6140037775,
0.0855250061,
-0.1747236103,
-0.4432590306,
-0.6841102242,
-0.3040518761,
0.3660534322,
-0.1803931445,
0.2171348482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18657v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18657v2 | Representation Of Lexical Stylistic Features In Language Models' Embedding Space | 2023-05-29T23:44:26 | 2023-05-31T22:50:25 | Qing Lyu, Marianna Apidianaki, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | The representation space of pretrained Language Models (LMs) encodes rich
information about words and their relationships (e.g., similarity, hypernymy,
polysemy) as well as abstract semantic notions (e.g., intensity). In this
paper, we demonstrate that lexical stylistic notions such as complexity,
formality, and figurativeness, can also be identified in this space. We show
that it is possible to derive a vector representation for each of these
stylistic notions from only a small number of seed pairs. Using these vectors,
we can characterize new texts in terms of these dimensions by performing simple
calculations in the corresponding embedding space. We conduct experiments on
five datasets and find that static embeddings encode these features more
accurately at the level of words and phrases, whereas contextualized LMs
perform better on sentences. The lower performance of contextualized
representations at the word level is partially attributable to the anisotropy
of their vector space, which can be corrected to some extent using techniques
like standardization. | [
-0.4132576883,
-0.7583110929,
0.7142565846,
0.3268881738,
-0.3602413237,
0.0296119787,
-0.5239223838,
-0.1907294542,
0.6180464625,
0.3878791928,
-0.3604617119,
-0.7793968916,
-0.5577408671,
0.0721747726,
-0.5077880621,
0.6002888083,
-0.3505473733,
0.0529642738,
-0.5657585263,
-0.3464060128,
-0.4339782298,
-0.8359696269,
0.034479741,
0.0499653853,
0.4269708395,
-0.093706511,
0.9360681176,
0.9656410813,
0.4520986974,
0.353587091,
-0.2020709366,
-0.1149641573,
-0.3589701355,
0.4170870781,
0.1591754705,
-0.4195931256,
-0.0269267522,
0.0792540982,
0.8343450427,
0.9450497031,
0.1475129724,
-0.1847876757,
0.2832895517,
0.4347820282,
-0.4999297261,
0.2606986165,
-0.4373189509,
0.1780961901,
-0.2437649965,
-0.4726575911,
-0.2226441503,
-0.4121452272,
0.3254052401,
-0.6832730174,
0.1023940742,
0.1502937227,
0.8384222984,
0.1809465736,
-0.3749902546,
-0.3954080641,
-0.8195205927,
0.8295134902,
-0.5080341697,
0.4380652905,
0.2070074975,
0.1011705697,
-0.0256945677,
-0.5654168129,
-0.316534549,
-0.5532334447,
-0.4472281039,
-0.2008101791,
-0.1512094438,
0.1078478992,
0.3919677138,
0.2243427634,
-0.4345966876,
-0.0180542227,
-0.0491417423,
-0.1585649401,
0.5017425418,
0.0087028826,
0.3356657624,
-0.2613509297,
-0.4664314389,
-0.2290390879,
-0.7356266379,
-0.1586975008,
0.1222900003,
0.2267125249,
-0.1039111838,
0.5299711823,
0.1184879616,
0.4964352846,
-0.3539946675,
-0.004048394,
0.4058923721,
-0.4251952767,
-0.0255952142,
-0.0082307048,
0.6197578311,
0.0097619956,
0.4476387203,
-0.2343496829,
-0.2973871231,
0.0373932682,
0.2639268637,
-0.5485584736,
0.0547521748,
-0.0057936925,
-0.488761425,
-0.2256511003,
0.2024958134,
-0.2320054621,
-0.3354924917,
-0.4232858717,
0.2864920795,
-0.6647183299,
-0.0061558993,
0.050180532,
-0.2936147153,
0.2219779938,
0.3191657662,
-0.7681421638,
0.355550766,
0.5841911435,
0.9253613949,
0.1163138524,
-0.2496254146,
0.0580079481,
-0.0085907523,
-0.6297386289,
0.4829921126,
-0.8523264527,
-0.2172113955,
0.3041328788,
-0.1999878138,
-0.002863413,
-0.375103116,
0.2296147496,
-0.305337131,
-0.0756488889,
-0.4704592526,
-0.7497914433,
-0.1540376246,
0.0726552457,
-0.6402968168,
0.9261829853,
-0.0118078114,
-0.8384050727,
0.3067410588,
-0.3039998114,
-0.1984672248,
0.1342554241,
-0.5177191496,
-0.0264370255,
0.5981606245,
-0.0117075825,
0.7400555611,
-0.0712487698,
-0.052625481,
-0.3623904586,
-0.4687415659,
0.5689846873,
-0.1038419455,
0.2370576859,
0.2929070592,
-0.1573335379,
0.1333696097,
-0.868250668,
-0.0156540163,
0.2790813148,
-0.0974026546,
-0.9952327609,
0.1470439136,
0.2600989044,
0.1396724433,
0.2868997753,
-0.5321137309,
0.0818773583,
-0.3385190666,
0.487957567,
0.4679035842,
-0.0978028178,
0.5914545655,
-0.2449729443,
0.4249192178,
0.0480390377,
-0.490013361,
-0.1599401534,
-0.2413784266,
-0.7085357308,
-0.3154042959,
0.3727609515,
0.2613447309,
-0.5262409449,
0.6909322739,
-0.3597249687,
-0.3784883022,
-0.1920181215,
0.1534803361,
0.3766014576,
-0.0627195835,
0.1564835012,
-0.393198669,
-0.3733921051,
-0.9384896159,
-0.2158880085,
0.1086178347,
-0.1386886239,
0.3528577387,
0.4757097065,
-0.0765106231,
0.9376008511,
-0.4483682215,
-0.1491833627,
-0.2151065916,
0.3183313608,
-0.1170241609,
0.4660049677,
0.903978169,
-0.4860477746,
-0.2773353755,
-0.1586936414,
-0.7087971568,
-0.2091905326,
-0.0308362395,
-0.0807730928,
-0.038750805,
0.8769960999,
-0.2537100315,
0.3199113011,
0.4465781748,
-0.4200483561,
0.2464069724,
-0.275331527,
-0.0678565726,
-0.9195300937,
-0.1302652061,
0.0744624212,
-0.1853448004,
-0.706566751,
0.1325114369,
0.056359075,
-0.2002838254,
-0.2692189217,
0.4715767801,
-0.50602144,
-0.1227427721,
-0.0585235842,
0.3684539795,
0.0590614565,
0.5976936221,
0.3626146317,
0.3897213638,
0.4343386292,
-0.4241366088,
0.0666396692,
0.0061539975,
-0.4949261546,
0.3052068055,
-0.7268110514,
0.0833383501,
-0.4838598669,
0.225769043,
-1.0588723421,
-0.1091506481,
-0.2584341764,
-0.2092722207,
0.3798214197,
-0.0336865149,
-0.5570586324,
0.141479522,
-0.4555996954,
0.7565820217,
0.4242397547,
-0.1691591591,
0.3725760877,
0.2589313686,
-0.1765152365,
-0.3567320406,
-0.6112303138,
-0.2649792731,
-0.266402036,
-0.565207243,
0.5698668361,
0.3567332923,
-0.3703204989,
0.3251330554,
0.2620007396,
0.06355156,
0.0600830242,
0.1875524819,
0.0178937986,
-0.2888362408,
0.4216280878,
-0.0563785322,
0.1751763523,
-0.0568296351,
-0.3042341173,
0.9185829759,
-0.1409044117,
-0.3167259693,
-0.1653140932,
0.4650538266,
0.6198161244,
-0.2580450773,
0.7928647399,
0.6087572575,
-0.6447033882,
-0.1994316876,
-0.3074183464,
0.0333189368,
-0.421941489,
0.5660856366,
-0.4035769701,
-0.9973490834,
0.6417120695,
0.0992457941,
-0.1367634833,
0.4968634844,
0.506568253,
-0.1864965856,
0.9906030297,
0.7614442706,
0.1190925613,
0.6714532375,
-0.2275118828,
-0.0104863141,
-0.8323006034,
-0.4033027887,
-0.6398509741,
-0.527895987,
-1.0042709112,
-0.6385607123,
0.4236272275,
0.0757629871,
-0.4259675443,
0.3868864775,
-0.1318021566,
0.3533679843,
0.5408874154,
-0.1570606977,
-0.0921978429,
0.2057017535,
-0.5282580256,
-0.4742417932,
-0.5327519178,
-0.7314798832,
0.9634612203,
0.7407764196,
0.9035487771,
0.2536014915,
0.8742604852,
0.0755650923,
-0.1714643091,
-0.9882146716,
0.3752322793,
-0.3969335556,
-0.2420775741,
-0.176279366,
-0.3782658279,
-0.7551247478,
0.0653916001,
-0.5891755223,
-0.8580968976,
0.4868906438,
0.0822233632,
-0.2730866969,
0.0682836473,
-0.4471481442,
0.704372704,
-0.0670473352,
-0.1688795239,
-0.2392026931,
-0.3268850148,
-0.0219365824,
0.0181627106,
0.2386899292,
-0.0454423539,
-0.1238217354,
0.9500894547,
-0.6549428105,
0.7464143634,
-0.077051267,
0.0003094255,
0.0741620362,
0.3568859696,
0.3025014699,
-0.1775179505,
0.3663007319,
0.1544222087,
0.1857767999,
-0.3277823031,
-0.9460987449,
0.7816563249,
-0.8142108321,
-0.4156864285,
-0.4880607426,
-0.6113669276,
-0.3802868426,
-0.0306575615,
0.2029885948,
0.9293439984,
-0.4879022539,
0.5567976832,
0.5196348429,
-0.4926733673,
0.2150019705,
-0.1737722754,
-0.3819075823,
-0.1117679849,
0.7966226339,
0.3391115963,
0.2790793478,
0.5609736443,
0.212852791,
-0.4585123956,
-0.4661135972,
-0.0926772729,
0.3088892698,
-0.9301157594,
0.2155151665,
-0.571157515,
-0.3114542663,
-0.3072630465,
-0.3177649379,
-0.3132472932,
-0.8225288987,
-0.0551428124,
0.0322810784,
0.2937800884,
1.2341800928,
0.2508013844,
0.3009735644,
-0.6798676252,
-0.2478769869,
0.1198360994,
0.2071162015,
0.0602288805,
-0.5823209882,
-0.2863185108,
-0.2486908287,
-0.1833828837,
-0.9012774825,
0.5154217482,
0.1877803653,
0.4260947704,
0.6033701301,
-0.3966169655,
0.4807289243,
-0.7126834989,
0.7448542118,
-0.0090727322,
-1.0029518604,
0.3329035044,
-0.3312389851,
0.2164400965,
0.3235064447,
0.6321194172,
-0.6977229118,
-0.3911734819,
-0.5294460654,
-0.7550444007,
0.3367510438,
0.3104817271,
0.511919558,
-0.07636071,
0.3722886741,
-0.171843186,
0.2363428921,
-0.5311156511,
-0.3239172101,
-0.4302702248,
-0.4259293675,
-0.2763903439,
-0.5649347901,
-0.1175881177,
-0.2020714581,
0.1157128215,
0.1069837585,
0.6343517303,
0.0312871635,
-0.2405845821,
0.336622715,
0.3881982565,
0.6709897518,
0.4036666155,
-0.1792943031,
0.4645374119,
-0.0093653807,
-0.3451702297,
0.1869609952,
-0.0710626617,
0.0477592088,
0.2355595082,
0.9229110479,
1.0141614676,
0.5702822208,
-0.3913806081,
0.5528291464,
0.0718372092,
0.024610823,
-0.228837207,
-0.0900683627,
0.0129160434,
0.019943513,
0.0927690193,
-0.089479357,
0.1254839897,
-0.8217446208,
-0.0171809122,
0.4472647011,
-0.4622199535,
-0.3141848445,
0.4551897347,
-0.0381859727,
0.0302883163,
0.2685744464,
-0.1680330634,
-0.6004790664,
0.5136191845,
0.6285156012,
0.9290668964,
0.2025316209,
0.0726250857,
0.3729477823,
0.0815174133,
0.1369545162,
0.1839960366,
-0.0248229597,
-1.0449069738,
-0.0791640431,
-1.0171639919,
-0.2245896906,
0.0049388944,
-0.5794072747,
0.2986313701,
-0.8230854273,
0.0128269177,
0.0771268159,
-0.3577319086,
-0.8381745219,
0.0204170309,
0.3812554479,
0.7286468148,
-0.9520756006,
0.6848307252,
0.803455174,
-0.3157407045,
-0.9557108879,
0.0326700732,
0.1932385415,
-0.7349087596,
0.8580619693,
0.1741717309,
-0.0300607365,
-0.1492026001,
-0.3772380352,
-1.1326833963,
0.9086502194,
0.2555292547,
-0.6899471283,
-0.0557203442,
0.281288445,
0.7530386448,
-0.6552267671,
0.1516470909,
0.3853458166,
0.193303898,
0.1768028885,
-0.6146392226,
0.1103011742,
-0.3244872391,
0.6544576883,
0.0019500423,
-0.2258914411,
0.9177846313,
0.2390487343,
-0.4699631631,
0.0336530246,
0.6981217265,
0.0241743587,
-0.4461990595,
0.3630877435,
0.562335968,
0.6678339243,
-0.4110338688,
1.2378168106,
-0.5131065845,
0.3183356225,
0.5465516448,
0.2238291502,
0.8057212234,
0.3214838505,
-0.0106621282,
0.7264487147,
0.4859682918,
0.2186495811,
0.5747421384,
0.4491558671,
-0.1376863569,
-0.1294809729,
-0.2643298805,
-0.3505843282,
0.6205834746,
0.4880969226,
-0.6923568249,
-0.0166339409,
0.0210344065,
0.2441219836,
0.3055999577,
-0.279476285,
0.7111973763,
0.2175234258,
-0.3134072423,
0.7552035451,
0.2558541894,
0.6728498936,
-0.745288074,
0.0055941776,
-0.0675760433,
-0.0282806046,
-0.0907103866,
-0.6292954683,
0.2512203157,
-0.2085479349,
0.0036699574,
-0.3304635882,
0.6369888783,
-0.6322499514,
-0.5392209888,
0.290327549,
0.489816606,
0.1098801941,
0.2268271297,
-0.2578175068,
0.3478022814,
-0.5218423605,
-0.1869321615,
0.1749227941,
0.6848235726,
-0.2022574842,
0.3234640062,
0.2647797465,
0.3695364296,
0.1396460831,
0.4059826434,
0.8372715712,
-0.7880388498,
-0.5514499545,
-0.9285714626,
0.1546707302,
0.0679279119,
-0.3219178021,
0.7114396691,
0.1449035853,
0.8822737932,
-0.1398445815,
0.7368667722,
-0.0200878978,
0.0319603905,
-0.8270845413,
0.6863731742,
-0.5491482615,
0.2491876483,
-0.5226784945,
-1.0830895901,
-0.4646018744,
0.9859334826,
-0.3797429502,
0.2137701064,
0.9064791203,
0.691470325,
-0.050208427,
-0.1485200971,
0.4577269852,
0.3456627429,
0.035487853,
0.2864842713,
0.9220640659,
0.0033561154,
-0.160791561,
-0.2652891576,
-0.2353939563,
-0.059073437,
-0.7216767073,
-0.9225701094,
-0.919143796,
-0.1122369394,
-0.334356308,
-0.2751373649,
1.3361492157,
0.4546414018,
-0.6780555248,
-0.2304426432,
0.0945937485,
-0.0666527748,
-0.0347824991,
-0.1483958215,
0.5567368269,
-0.6000567675,
-0.7297950983,
0.1727266312,
0.3026430905,
0.1366638839,
-0.6607914567,
-0.0449714512,
0.0597078986,
0.3175941408,
0.6334643364,
-0.1316391379,
-0.6104662418,
-0.7219896913,
0.0610516407,
-0.2053498328,
0.0364838727,
1.1853582859,
-0.4610856175,
0.4545405209,
0.7317013741,
0.5380471349,
0.219180584,
-0.2478350401,
0.6425104737,
-1.1970691681,
0.4631423056,
0.2254357189,
0.7874321938,
0.405772835,
-0.0090229865,
0.1115251929,
0.3849506676,
-0.078179583,
-0.5657739639,
0.3891989589,
-0.7747163773,
-0.2454746664,
1.3290973902,
-0.2070543468,
-0.2794807553,
-0.0150225619,
0.008147629,
0.0361878574,
-0.0465955734,
0.3775895238,
0.9720665216,
0.0919814184,
0.0980553776,
-0.3083743453,
0.709718883,
0.2996159196,
-0.3282641768,
-0.0632011667,
0.432926625,
0.2608464658,
0.4657157362,
0.4049592316,
-0.3407543004,
-0.0442622341,
-0.0825585723,
-0.0347491875,
-0.0117982617,
-0.5143521428,
-0.5203953981,
0.194732815,
0.3452765644,
-0.0552537069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18654v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18654v3 | Faith and Fate: Limits of Transformers on Compositionality | 2023-05-29T23:24:14 | 2023-10-31T16:35:07 | Nouha Dziri, Ximing Lu, Melanie Sclar, Xiang Lorraine Li, Liwei Jiang, Bill Yuchen Lin, Peter West, Chandra Bhagavatula, Ronan Le Bras, Jena D. Hwang, Soumya Sanyal, Sean Welleck, Xiang Ren, Allyson Ettinger, Zaid Harchaoui, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Transformer large language models (LLMs) have sparked admiration for their
exceptional performance on tasks that demand intricate multi-step reasoning.
Yet, these models simultaneously show failures on surprisingly trivial
problems. This begs the question: Are these errors incidental, or do they
signal more substantial limitations? In an attempt to demystify transformer
LLMs, we investigate the limits of these models across three representative
compositional tasks -- multi-digit multiplication, logic grid puzzles, and a
classic dynamic programming problem. These tasks require breaking problems down
into sub-steps and synthesizing these steps into a precise answer. We formulate
compositional tasks as computation graphs to systematically quantify the level
of complexity, and break down reasoning steps into intermediate sub-procedures.
Our empirical findings suggest that transformer LLMs solve compositional tasks
by reducing multi-step compositional reasoning into linearized subgraph
matching, without necessarily developing systematic problem-solving skills. To
round off our empirical study, we provide theoretical arguments on abstract
multi-step reasoning problems that highlight how autoregressive generations'
performance can rapidly decay with\,increased\,task\,complexity. | [
-0.2656310797,
-0.470602572,
0.9291599393,
0.4931260645,
0.1077361032,
0.5271703601,
0.1597338766,
-0.3554138541,
-0.2836365998,
0.6023136377,
-0.9684627056,
0.0735562816,
-0.9393666983,
0.2530171871,
-0.591768086,
0.9110690355,
-0.391117543,
-0.1073909029,
-0.4595006704,
-0.1310459375,
-0.4425101578,
-0.1660000384,
-0.51121521,
-0.4405513108,
0.4803958237,
0.3862227499,
0.8492144942,
0.6334351301,
0.6036173701,
0.3306594789,
0.0028240415,
-0.022274578,
-0.5669460297,
0.6817491651,
0.1043366194,
-0.7834802866,
0.0068508391,
0.0867405534,
0.5391144753,
0.81934762,
0.2250284702,
0.0181866996,
-0.0144532742,
0.3919035494,
-0.3345159292,
0.2432064414,
-0.5468332767,
0.2037550658,
-0.0938055143,
-0.2752191126,
-0.4809949696,
-0.3386622667,
-0.2069034725,
-0.3971386254,
0.1486380994,
-0.1808615476,
0.533790648,
0.7141329646,
-0.7746391892,
-0.3474557996,
-1.1275275946,
1.1763179302,
-0.09967269,
0.3626678884,
0.1044617221,
0.2447740883,
-0.2708703279,
-0.710847199,
-0.5577815771,
0.0638197809,
-0.0808393508,
0.1599761844,
-0.25532794,
0.0006415824,
0.7668117285,
0.5145058036,
-0.4364673495,
-0.134235695,
-0.3458341956,
-0.1798093319,
0.4384010136,
0.7188725471,
0.4389105737,
0.0768872201,
-0.1946218163,
-0.3413483202,
-0.6470018029,
0.1031753942,
0.4660689831,
-0.1573617607,
-0.0187478699,
0.738089025,
0.1156219989,
0.4111810923,
0.0012688087,
-0.383795023,
-0.3447565138,
-0.3669761419,
0.0305224452,
-0.2724420428,
0.6013050675,
0.1306087226,
0.1906968355,
-0.062126182,
-0.0333618335,
0.3158932924,
0.3600616455,
-0.7529470325,
-0.1054892838,
0.136027202,
-0.3675413728,
-0.2864110768,
-0.1128067449,
-0.3687870502,
-0.2642864585,
-0.2940601707,
0.3343121707,
-0.4537724853,
0.1393937767,
-0.0562529452,
-0.1347287744,
0.4167369604,
0.2542284131,
-0.8025497198,
0.0304052662,
0.809355855,
0.5653735399,
-0.1217885315,
-0.5384021997,
-0.3222413361,
-0.0324297175,
-0.1686950177,
0.4873334169,
-0.6617090106,
-0.6886242628,
-0.2560809851,
0.1632246375,
-0.4226050377,
-0.2698089182,
0.6467632651,
-0.5486691594,
-0.1074797437,
-0.6743406057,
-0.4834530056,
-0.0959293842,
-0.1473660618,
-0.7161605358,
0.733381331,
0.2382334918,
-0.5123807788,
0.4224339128,
-0.4872086346,
-0.8578432798,
0.0249175318,
-0.2725426555,
-0.1180500463,
0.5440392494,
-0.3464769721,
0.2557936013,
-0.4548148215,
0.2569276392,
-0.1616091728,
-0.4678397775,
0.1829816103,
-0.788844645,
0.9326017499,
0.2412482351,
-0.5248118043,
-0.1261820346,
-0.6662436128,
-0.1221932396,
0.2670118809,
-0.2785214484,
0.0403012484,
0.4567165971,
-0.3614294231,
0.3600985706,
0.2875218391,
-0.4681478739,
0.1002829298,
-0.1972973198,
0.4991074502,
0.5860849023,
-0.2556920648,
0.4155030549,
-0.4242191315,
0.8142488599,
0.0400516279,
0.5681981444,
-0.500420332,
-0.7033286095,
-1.1859593391,
0.2509673536,
-0.142691806,
0.5665697455,
-0.7740560174,
0.2176709324,
-0.4098348022,
-0.4937824607,
-0.2785077393,
0.0165802632,
0.1526468396,
0.431248188,
0.5211573243,
-0.1841256768,
-0.3264318407,
-1.0402840376,
-0.2280201912,
-0.0769030601,
-0.0651125088,
0.0987886861,
0.6508619785,
-0.1780712903,
0.9577696919,
-0.4988478124,
-0.0885177925,
-0.1992564648,
0.3077221811,
0.228032589,
0.4171534479,
0.3616056144,
-0.8710065484,
-0.4526450336,
-0.0906759053,
-0.7967251539,
-0.1942241192,
-0.3725216091,
0.1941382587,
0.0160579309,
0.359310478,
-0.7675560117,
0.4777632356,
0.8623283505,
-0.4372732341,
0.5357505679,
0.0362628624,
-0.0232991427,
-0.8482584357,
-0.2077379227,
-0.2074252069,
0.0027165671,
-0.5605764389,
0.2257889956,
-0.01599635,
-0.0061062709,
-0.1890360862,
0.1561278403,
-0.262683183,
-0.0002973568,
-0.4285845459,
-0.400836885,
0.1631244868,
0.0854579359,
-0.0220165998,
0.8246286511,
0.5372141004,
-0.5236876011,
0.2857284248,
0.1603928804,
0.0078219902,
0.6861701608,
-0.6861394644,
-0.1506484002,
-0.1263350993,
0.3805079162,
-0.7985278368,
-0.283700943,
-0.0191738531,
-0.0973606482,
0.0980434045,
-0.0738224164,
-0.4581489861,
-0.4936229289,
0.0173764378,
0.5836194158,
0.596842587,
-0.2751440406,
1.2108849287,
-0.2601641119,
0.0147927878,
-0.51741153,
-0.7274726033,
0.158954978,
-0.0208374765,
-0.6817699075,
0.3760386109,
-0.2660915852,
-0.4555432796,
0.017292019,
-0.3739561737,
0.1354327798,
0.219590798,
0.4224939346,
-0.0130815618,
-0.0758338496,
-0.0961913243,
0.4527556896,
-0.2928906381,
0.4417797029,
-0.1126440242,
0.5557922721,
-0.1423195302,
-0.8328226805,
-0.0816671401,
0.5916677713,
1.0723518133,
-0.2179840803,
0.9230298996,
0.5276802182,
-0.1561082006,
-0.0215517115,
-0.6564513445,
-0.0745852441,
-0.4900175631,
0.0083248904,
-0.5285163522,
-0.9051056504,
0.7715667486,
0.0433984138,
0.1234117746,
0.7854712009,
0.3650490046,
-0.0695255175,
0.9897284508,
0.435764581,
0.1911454052,
0.0269210078,
-0.2086249143,
0.4046188891,
-0.6000754237,
-0.4346267283,
-0.465187043,
-0.4146190882,
-0.6583546996,
-0.63005054,
0.5833844543,
-0.2243167311,
-0.2494728267,
0.3746064007,
-0.2990022004,
0.8058000803,
0.4247056544,
-0.1479013413,
0.5701394677,
-0.2735656798,
-0.0593200698,
-0.2414970547,
-0.552962184,
-0.3262549639,
0.9739006758,
0.3955663443,
0.8673940301,
0.1093890816,
0.5430423617,
0.0687050745,
0.3653224111,
-0.9460048676,
0.4805083871,
-0.165803805,
-0.7098573446,
-0.2326815277,
-0.5900713801,
-0.8021780252,
0.1568753719,
0.0299672373,
-0.3731894791,
0.2202531546,
-0.1351368725,
-0.1543772221,
0.3393460512,
-0.3538093865,
0.6310347915,
-0.3284613192,
-0.1597684473,
-0.1901653409,
-0.866022408,
0.4908375144,
-0.2581900954,
0.1595439166,
0.1694639176,
0.1754954606,
0.4064138234,
-0.4010637403,
0.8687050343,
0.0779011622,
-0.4192970097,
0.371845901,
0.4348855615,
0.633977294,
-0.1896802485,
0.1856511086,
-0.1151741073,
0.0591498315,
-0.3504824638,
-0.6061143279,
0.7112805843,
-0.4647337794,
-0.7453579903,
-0.5270751119,
-0.7684775591,
-0.2923948169,
0.1943763345,
0.4067786634,
0.3044326603,
0.0900763795,
0.4852522314,
0.9744713902,
-0.1534874439,
0.6309688687,
0.3410385847,
0.0248974245,
-0.2335280329,
0.6654985547,
0.1195962355,
0.5434159636,
0.265973866,
0.1947333217,
-0.3452736735,
-0.27490592,
-0.2761241794,
0.1288712472,
-1.0960159302,
-0.0161099229,
-0.8408354521,
-0.2012012899,
0.0609629788,
-0.142788291,
-0.407867372,
-0.1890997887,
-0.4608377516,
0.0961465389,
-0.0281918887,
0.7169377804,
0.2861176133,
0.1644434631,
-0.9219684601,
0.2916806638,
0.7121574879,
0.2357289195,
0.1049097627,
-0.5306518674,
-0.0445198081,
-0.0862351879,
-0.7292375565,
-0.8519775867,
-0.1829696447,
-0.0152837411,
0.2912304997,
0.4427203834,
0.0059900265,
0.7153024077,
-0.5544871688,
0.6510126591,
0.2063316554,
-1.1860349178,
0.2633982003,
-0.4870908856,
0.2968522012,
0.4743585885,
0.6226978898,
-0.4533934295,
-0.6175294518,
-0.6704516411,
-0.6151028872,
0.339473933,
0.4663543701,
0.5389611721,
0.018937964,
0.3094498813,
0.0869320258,
0.0022512572,
-0.7757883668,
-0.4654301703,
-0.2862018049,
-0.1945772767,
0.0238186959,
-0.246097669,
-0.2119844258,
-0.5023294091,
0.3652476966,
-0.3092601001,
0.2355740517,
0.0850620046,
-0.1112103537,
-0.4528033137,
0.2257461548,
1.0201585293,
0.694047153,
0.533536911,
0.1905612051,
0.1810499281,
-0.3131178319,
0.503415823,
-0.032410264,
-0.2121443897,
-0.3589134812,
0.6075965166,
0.7953956723,
0.2611639798,
-0.4876388311,
0.423335731,
-0.0015562846,
-0.2894766927,
-0.5039795041,
0.2093427032,
0.2469377518,
0.4033642411,
0.7140359282,
0.2748350799,
0.0438966155,
-0.6687048078,
0.0294243656,
0.4814063311,
-0.2838163674,
-0.3581723869,
1.0434360504,
-0.1104018912,
-0.2796260118,
0.5272866488,
-0.1126518622,
-0.7072035074,
0.6404379606,
0.4778702557,
0.9563410282,
-0.2584872842,
0.2734271884,
-0.0314314701,
0.5094438195,
-0.2970918119,
0.1817356348,
0.0670965239,
-0.8008800745,
-1.001142621,
-0.8325198293,
-0.5592191815,
0.1235076264,
-0.4154268801,
-0.1105031446,
-0.144251734,
-0.2036424428,
-0.2943220437,
-0.3560587466,
-0.5081000328,
0.256272018,
-0.0647180453,
0.5692862272,
-1.0293562412,
0.2944377363,
0.2522593439,
-0.304536283,
-0.7988352776,
0.1837421358,
-0.1968361884,
-0.637904346,
0.8593545556,
0.1169639081,
-0.1941139251,
0.0416301899,
-0.4244465232,
-0.8322835565,
1.0073628426,
0.4189425707,
-0.4268763065,
-0.0947250947,
0.5194407105,
0.689652741,
-0.0061762263,
0.2071690112,
0.6728776097,
1.0049827099,
0.2462215126,
-0.960146606,
0.2440773398,
0.0651283562,
-0.1436111182,
0.4402039945,
-0.8382687569,
1.0112097263,
-0.0532555468,
-0.1861279011,
0.0963689089,
0.447391808,
-0.0518624224,
0.2662161887,
0.48701033,
0.7340396643,
0.1365170032,
-0.5555086136,
1.2301181555,
-0.3043965697,
0.2822341025,
0.645729661,
-0.2896052301,
0.1887512505,
0.584354043,
-0.5620735884,
0.5058906674,
0.2597614825,
-0.195310086,
-0.1047803685,
0.0716619939,
-0.4266673923,
-0.6377493143,
-0.1772224456,
-0.017580932,
0.7429874539,
0.2265431434,
-0.4091582894,
-0.1222318485,
0.0162292514,
0.0178971291,
-0.0780542493,
0.1533714235,
0.4236266315,
0.2467073053,
-0.83965379,
0.3037870228,
-0.0895905122,
0.2943214774,
-0.4943929911,
0.0002029138,
-0.2380911112,
-0.1293451041,
-0.238662377,
-0.7828439474,
0.5763918757,
-0.2859250307,
-0.1826656014,
-0.5703322887,
0.6813278794,
-0.1009921804,
-0.6613101363,
0.2134275436,
0.5465295911,
-0.2127186656,
-0.1376752257,
-0.338729471,
0.3345433474,
-0.1126983687,
-0.2967284322,
0.1714107692,
0.4012599885,
-0.0896791816,
1.003947854,
0.4389165044,
-0.1221348718,
0.1554378271,
-0.027085552,
0.7602260113,
-0.5630107522,
-0.1339308172,
-1.08510077,
0.4103773534,
0.2429437786,
-0.0223060921,
0.7375446558,
0.5261776447,
0.6678029299,
-0.2211797684,
0.6174638867,
-0.0729852691,
-0.0784050301,
-0.5537012815,
0.3965940177,
-0.60289675,
0.1369627267,
-0.0915576741,
-1.3229392767,
-0.2833683491,
0.3723152578,
-0.2223637551,
0.1881603599,
0.9805240035,
0.3398178816,
-0.0816904083,
0.1972347945,
0.3523887694,
0.0417154618,
0.3809818923,
0.6422147751,
1.176633954,
-0.4059364498,
0.6159294248,
-0.2893377244,
0.071260035,
-0.0798718557,
-0.7319195867,
-0.6990618706,
-0.5327744484,
-0.2188704759,
-0.1889495105,
-0.6129323244,
0.5180956125,
0.2700193524,
-0.6472005844,
-0.0891812444,
-0.3948718607,
0.3103659153,
-0.1711249352,
-0.2958367765,
-0.0463628098,
-0.2555607259,
-0.8061911464,
0.6264010072,
0.3305594325,
0.4346198142,
-0.5098035932,
-0.0234475452,
0.5829167366,
0.2077512294,
0.7865253687,
0.2009794116,
-0.8129293919,
-0.4715813696,
0.2648579776,
0.2261705697,
-0.0269450285,
1.1865139008,
-0.4193635881,
0.1734502316,
0.5771673918,
0.4535013139,
0.4443513453,
0.016796058,
0.4490301311,
-0.48497504,
-0.2635074258,
0.3988316655,
0.4222346842,
-0.0413939543,
-0.202109322,
0.3276968896,
0.5065653324,
-0.5782709122,
-0.7291830182,
0.758564055,
-0.8088473082,
-0.1881737262,
0.9236034751,
0.0501037091,
0.0879505947,
-0.2174551785,
0.2348732352,
0.102367945,
0.0694424957,
0.5881282687,
0.9035829902,
-0.3135479093,
-0.2572191358,
-0.4157574177,
0.3778131604,
0.5000901222,
-0.5499784946,
-0.0330716558,
0.4518927932,
0.2695046961,
0.4381239712,
0.3315294087,
-0.1188227832,
0.0944121405,
0.1569997221,
-0.4635877907,
0.0328624956,
-0.6667922735,
-0.0850150585,
0.3931249678,
0.1794393808,
0.4353353977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18641v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18641v1 | Enhanced Chart Understanding in Vision and Language Task via Cross-modal Pre-training on Plot Table Pairs | 2023-05-29T22:29:03 | 2023-05-29T22:29:03 | Mingyang Zhou, Yi R. Fung, Long Chen, Christopher Thomas, Heng Ji, Shih-Fu Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Building cross-model intelligence that can understand charts and communicate
the salient information hidden behind them is an appealing challenge in the
vision and language(V+L) community. The capability to uncover the underlined
table data of chart figures is a critical key to automatic chart understanding.
We introduce ChartT5, a V+L model that learns how to interpret table
information from chart images via cross-modal pre-training on plot table pairs.
Specifically, we propose two novel pre-training objectives: Masked Header
Prediction (MHP) and Masked Value Prediction (MVP) to facilitate the model with
different skills to interpret the table information. We have conducted
extensive experiments on chart question answering and chart summarization to
verify the effectiveness of the proposed pre-training strategies. In
particular, on the ChartQA benchmark, our ChartT5 outperforms the
state-of-the-art non-pretraining methods by over 8% performance gains. | [
-0.4134254754,
-0.3884304464,
0.5007858276,
-0.2001603395,
-0.8853240609,
0.3770169914,
0.1903083324,
-0.7703553438,
0.1802509725,
0.6868946552,
-0.6447203159,
-0.6482423544,
-0.8029534221,
-0.353976965,
-0.2432032079,
0.809574604,
-0.0735935792,
0.3132867217,
-0.1086525097,
0.017111076,
-0.8076603413,
-0.4404264092,
-0.3095740676,
-0.1571575552,
0.5971493721,
0.6332683563,
0.6538168788,
0.5260139108,
0.5631241202,
0.1973782182,
0.7260350585,
0.1568755805,
-0.6134174466,
0.0053897328,
0.1792849898,
-0.5705695152,
-0.6945992112,
0.0767937452,
0.2276888639,
0.7118084431,
0.5052246451,
0.2477942556,
0.0138949454,
0.7629846334,
-0.7102097273,
0.9647228122,
-0.5551285148,
0.2249631286,
-0.3635672927,
-0.3240830004,
-0.4967158735,
0.0484853536,
0.1624810249,
-0.8819846511,
0.0129633043,
0.1724904478,
0.9295578003,
0.3834694028,
-0.5450348854,
0.0673402771,
-0.4552306533,
0.4995259941,
-0.2247831374,
0.9194005132,
0.5215629339,
0.7237363458,
0.3554681838,
-1.1323758364,
-0.5662705898,
-0.148502171,
-0.3124671578,
0.4717636704,
-0.2064398974,
0.0197613761,
0.153712675,
0.0932436809,
-0.4670471549,
0.0102729509,
-0.5475022793,
-0.1438203305,
0.6016991735,
0.0320749432,
0.3097187877,
-0.0561967194,
-0.5065513849,
-0.2123154551,
-0.5765565634,
0.3218994439,
-0.1502858698,
0.1398068666,
-0.204096511,
0.2558815777,
-0.1558020115,
0.6163089275,
0.1167344525,
0.0908585861,
0.4261425436,
-0.4655196369,
-0.3125339448,
-0.0883035585,
0.3284541368,
0.3726644218,
0.6197709441,
-0.1623515934,
-0.2837995589,
0.0520047434,
0.4008903503,
-0.4594844282,
-0.5824458599,
-0.2351635695,
-0.4553092122,
-0.2135103494,
0.0720024854,
-0.2741572559,
-0.4645960331,
-0.5758087039,
0.7737135291,
-0.413561672,
-0.0519890301,
-0.0062114345,
-0.216222927,
0.2310564965,
0.6559833288,
-0.7623489499,
0.1325460523,
0.4443246126,
0.3638830483,
-0.0445041023,
-0.463768959,
-0.7569016218,
0.4865175188,
-0.456602931,
0.9152451158,
-0.6364427805,
-0.0696688741,
-0.4444460571,
-0.0949300453,
-0.2582909167,
-0.2211121172,
0.390729785,
-0.6172099113,
0.0735359341,
-0.4062964916,
-0.3491264284,
-0.5081419349,
0.1874068379,
-0.8186295629,
0.6374107003,
0.1567378193,
-0.6915556788,
0.964040041,
-0.7420110703,
-0.3507143557,
0.370518893,
-0.5890650749,
-0.48434484,
-0.0639904514,
0.7412624359,
0.6259096861,
-0.1291261315,
-0.1700676233,
-0.0641470775,
-0.17975761,
0.0459911935,
-0.166921258,
0.1784947067,
-0.0753064007,
-0.5615725517,
0.6690315604,
-0.5268006921,
0.1456603408,
0.197170645,
0.1713065803,
-0.117165342,
-0.1443448961,
0.2709380388,
0.0761983693,
0.0860146731,
-0.0190759413,
-0.1210903972,
-0.1915691048,
0.165994525,
0.603890419,
-0.1605621874,
0.050112728,
-0.2084125578,
0.6850935817,
0.3519968688,
0.2341422439,
-0.2417101711,
-0.5180695653,
-0.6784089208,
-0.2905943394,
0.2563272417,
0.4872661829,
-1.0821031332,
0.1862297058,
-0.5239561796,
-0.6228791475,
-0.2074948996,
0.0297514573,
0.5765758157,
0.7322992086,
0.5815908313,
-0.891284883,
-0.5834400058,
-0.7880310416,
-0.1992067546,
0.2080290318,
-0.0056478032,
0.2089543045,
0.458989799,
-0.0710441098,
0.7801536918,
-0.4186956882,
-0.3896495104,
-0.891315937,
0.2977771461,
-0.0772156492,
0.2684816122,
0.7278653383,
-1.0295141935,
-0.7965957522,
0.0178508516,
-0.5082662702,
0.0749176145,
-0.0325575992,
-0.1086544469,
-0.099891603,
0.6265522838,
-0.2398733348,
0.8736419082,
0.3454278111,
-0.5906818509,
0.3794505298,
-0.1569287479,
0.2403368801,
-0.7195525765,
-0.0267758183,
-0.2283826917,
-0.5011985898,
-0.701123476,
-0.1463196725,
0.1443521976,
-0.2077345103,
-0.366217643,
0.3600227237,
-0.7586138844,
-0.3842100203,
-0.2778987288,
0.0735066235,
0.0133866565,
0.5420709252,
0.4204246998,
0.6009136438,
0.6091356277,
-0.2681046128,
0.2345299125,
0.2735553384,
-0.5236509442,
0.5512391925,
-0.3645344079,
0.2438410074,
-0.2624717355,
0.1915355176,
-1.0976970196,
0.0210524537,
0.4358707964,
-0.3634434044,
0.4388456345,
-0.1111741588,
-0.0849231109,
-0.3395847082,
-0.1951134652,
0.5200402737,
0.3993472457,
-0.3172603846,
0.7377318144,
0.5219849944,
0.2241335213,
-0.7770671844,
-0.6860743761,
0.0152902706,
-0.0405682363,
-0.4989446104,
0.187604174,
0.211914584,
0.044346869,
-0.1226556525,
-0.3372951746,
-0.2189510018,
-0.1149919555,
0.3789735138,
0.1267870367,
-0.2913189232,
0.0242455322,
-0.3838599324,
-0.6447672844,
-0.0344138071,
-0.2712568641,
0.6500797272,
-0.0626167208,
-0.5521082282,
-0.5268782973,
0.0871347785,
0.5601598024,
-0.7153475285,
0.4105923474,
0.8976644278,
-0.1332097948,
0.0422421917,
-0.3841474354,
-0.3029091954,
-0.4556718767,
0.6564224362,
-0.6911610961,
-0.3186638355,
0.4209498763,
0.2695903182,
-0.0935082585,
0.3551341295,
0.3817038238,
-0.338354528,
0.8023452163,
0.8610383272,
0.1148367971,
0.6388987899,
-0.3579294682,
0.2332003564,
-0.2378593832,
-0.3253470659,
-0.0047128703,
-0.7024999857,
-0.0380046703,
-0.6766157746,
0.6328206062,
-0.1038746461,
-0.0395861305,
0.141910702,
-0.2613787055,
0.6116181016,
0.7775152326,
0.5273259878,
0.3064028919,
-0.2223491073,
0.0292285811,
-0.3170222044,
-0.7005437016,
-0.0875631124,
1.2762172222,
0.2578737438,
0.6801675558,
-0.4839423299,
0.3364346623,
0.1692572385,
0.2301454991,
-0.6106312275,
0.4247636795,
-0.1096122488,
-0.4570746422,
-0.4829790294,
-0.1376153231,
-0.9484403133,
0.2716725171,
-0.3739206791,
-0.5152932405,
0.1091014892,
0.3796246946,
-0.140852645,
0.2937726676,
-0.9577009678,
1.4799017906,
-0.7624118924,
-0.0102222273,
-0.439769268,
-1.0200033188,
0.1530407667,
-0.0851368085,
0.2342591733,
-0.0048522372,
-0.0530328006,
0.6810290813,
-0.1877931505,
0.9530732632,
-0.1689301282,
0.2553728819,
-0.0577376634,
-0.0534884818,
0.3429382145,
-0.2744258046,
0.498344928,
0.1417930126,
0.0376581438,
-0.5896320343,
-0.7523012161,
-0.0605023876,
-0.7354592085,
-0.4291789234,
-0.2051483244,
-0.7833244205,
-0.3192531466,
0.259236306,
0.2578840554,
0.4073397517,
0.1801681221,
0.2261174768,
0.238877371,
0.0210825391,
0.0862817839,
0.2070027143,
-0.2315991372,
-0.3486843407,
0.6630736589,
0.212484628,
0.4113770127,
0.6582073569,
-0.0249261986,
-0.2135306448,
-0.7244048715,
-0.3172439635,
-0.0157450289,
-1.1000909805,
0.076354906,
-0.3962965906,
-0.1620090753,
-0.2473858595,
-0.1745102406,
-0.2791810632,
-0.3803322315,
-0.0027821911,
-0.176565975,
0.2768799365,
0.7755381465,
-0.0189789329,
0.3503188491,
-0.7526972294,
0.498028487,
0.4820003808,
0.2096780092,
-0.0582121275,
-0.3228552639,
-0.4159198999,
-0.0559708998,
-0.2130206525,
-1.1012089252,
0.3978408277,
0.0188946128,
0.6489416957,
0.484188199,
-0.0757042915,
0.8219695091,
-0.2938789725,
0.3249171972,
0.3237651885,
-1.0540318489,
0.4171257317,
-0.1748803407,
0.4630525112,
0.4210045934,
0.5490284562,
-0.4216320813,
-0.2520313561,
-0.5102806687,
-0.7377430797,
0.6904929876,
0.1399929523,
-0.273614049,
0.7695468664,
0.0950082988,
0.3449920118,
0.4588860571,
-1.0683609247,
-0.0999293998,
-0.7445082664,
-0.2736379206,
-0.4518336356,
-0.019912092,
-0.0418176576,
-0.7644559145,
0.1828860193,
-0.3292605579,
0.0454204679,
-0.0420787595,
-0.3898608387,
-0.0938283056,
-0.1014759466,
0.4880267382,
1.2165868282,
-0.0425905064,
0.3153131902,
0.2884745598,
-0.860159874,
-0.4081302285,
0.0639104098,
0.1648308188,
-0.2377013862,
0.7630819082,
1.0788787603,
0.4403172433,
-0.6115558147,
0.4814103842,
-0.0676494315,
-0.0893362015,
-0.0757123381,
-0.0502515584,
0.1002839878,
0.4012835622,
0.4458422661,
-0.1389448792,
-0.0423676632,
-0.7225114107,
0.4139673114,
0.4094350934,
-0.6532539129,
-0.3013456762,
0.7844669223,
0.0526289195,
0.1119707078,
0.3772629499,
0.1955213249,
-0.8954875469,
0.6230325699,
0.0602315664,
0.6385393739,
0.0490636379,
0.2032944858,
-0.0772081688,
0.5077106357,
0.820191443,
0.6721342802,
-0.4117553532,
-0.7280169129,
-0.2771376967,
-0.0877324492,
-0.533667028,
0.157319203,
-0.2639190853,
0.3415235579,
-0.3351611793,
0.1245426536,
0.1732909679,
0.0208938774,
-0.9073420167,
0.4879250824,
0.2451254874,
0.4848113358,
-0.8678215146,
0.9948398471,
0.5141618848,
-0.892264545,
-1.0596520901,
0.0167388543,
-0.2607838213,
-1.3226208687,
1.1322805882,
0.2202759832,
-0.0947141349,
0.0319195874,
-0.5022383332,
-0.7282903194,
1.1240460873,
0.4740835428,
-0.3814915717,
-0.087533325,
0.4569173753,
0.3397051692,
-0.4849125445,
0.5926584005,
0.4681047499,
0.7667865157,
0.1835472733,
-1.2164626122,
0.042622257,
-0.0668610632,
-0.4214617312,
0.0816078112,
-0.3695611954,
0.9415073395,
-0.3128284812,
-0.0827501342,
-0.6666289568,
0.5764913559,
-0.1021932885,
0.5913859606,
0.7816386223,
0.2933919728,
0.5486482382,
-0.066953294,
0.7503157854,
-0.3708257377,
-0.0217586625,
1.1575944424,
-0.0621574707,
0.6864641905,
0.3820256889,
0.2358914167,
0.4251470566,
0.7290241718,
0.0912165418,
0.6263279319,
-0.1942433119,
0.2910866141,
-0.6735660434,
0.2033077776,
-0.6084772944,
0.5510385633,
0.2516210973,
-0.4283623397,
-0.3426819444,
0.069318153,
-0.3264473081,
0.0467008725,
-0.456859827,
0.6378865242,
0.0866138786,
-0.211359784,
0.6093279123,
-0.4886047244,
0.1169885173,
-0.636081934,
-0.0026711614,
0.0291238017,
0.179971233,
-0.1982169449,
-0.8439381719,
0.0834590048,
-0.4181168675,
0.0712589398,
-0.5229543447,
0.5806244612,
-0.2967873216,
-0.4013257027,
0.2213895619,
0.7996637821,
0.0659063011,
-0.202329725,
-0.6951649785,
-0.0779333189,
-0.0603584051,
-0.0336869694,
0.1435220093,
0.480659306,
-0.255835712,
0.7550363541,
0.4176790714,
-0.146864593,
0.0833820477,
0.1731410474,
0.949678719,
-0.6027335525,
-0.8861252069,
-0.4933897257,
0.6227740645,
-0.0127608031,
-0.1484370828,
0.563793838,
0.5750522017,
0.9125246406,
-0.4262872934,
0.6108213663,
0.3813049793,
0.4684982598,
-0.744202733,
1.0830830336,
-0.654666841,
-0.1290806681,
-0.3915403485,
-0.7308043242,
-0.3712894619,
0.4162192345,
-0.8915616274,
0.0563418157,
0.9653199911,
0.3849107623,
-0.3391350806,
-0.074238278,
0.5430731177,
0.0571616851,
0.2146005332,
0.8245238066,
0.7161014676,
-0.1765784174,
0.7665957808,
-0.3866097927,
-0.0902423039,
-0.1011376977,
-0.6319282651,
-1.1545269489,
-0.8354500532,
-0.0692821145,
0.2196934372,
0.1399765164,
0.5654613376,
1.005645752,
-0.7387599945,
-0.3606882095,
0.0404615477,
0.0299415588,
-0.2982549965,
-0.0877840072,
0.6373113394,
-0.2306057811,
-0.4387803376,
0.2812256217,
0.3389629722,
0.2374504656,
-0.2067181617,
-0.1337311566,
-0.0352894999,
-0.1657767445,
0.4400978684,
0.150739342,
-0.4885290861,
-0.4112957716,
-0.1752759069,
0.1365180314,
0.5291795731,
0.8961134553,
-0.9405197501,
0.6462806463,
0.5380501151,
0.5247178674,
0.9260184169,
0.0062170643,
0.7354797721,
-0.472286284,
0.4458899796,
0.3008829057,
0.3257133961,
0.0410634242,
-0.1938368529,
0.5468915701,
0.273989141,
-0.055651363,
-0.6404634118,
0.4329036176,
-1.0435519218,
-0.209126547,
0.2853302658,
-0.0391112007,
-0.1870319396,
-0.300136745,
-0.4590053856,
0.4066051841,
-0.0083923545,
0.8033658862,
0.3526503742,
-0.2904433012,
-0.6218329668,
-0.6049582958,
0.7085992098,
0.5072359443,
-1.0378235579,
-0.2126479447,
0.409416914,
-0.0338980854,
0.0098067084,
0.6928533912,
0.1453830749,
0.6800557971,
0.04759432,
0.0380652323,
-0.2469560653,
-0.4139066339,
0.1950622946,
0.2863180935,
0.1449392587,
-0.4207023978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18638v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18638v1 | Short Answer Grading Using One-shot Prompting and Text Similarity Scoring Model | 2023-05-29T22:05:29 | 2023-05-29T22:05:29 | Su-Youn Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | In this study, we developed an automated short answer grading (ASAG) model
that provided both analytic scores and final holistic scores. Short answer
items typically consist of multiple sub-questions, and providing an analytic
score and the text span relevant to each sub-question can increase the
interpretability of the automated scores. Furthermore, they can be used to
generate actionable feedback for students. Despite these advantages, most
studies have focused on predicting only holistic scores due to the difficulty
in constructing dataset with manual annotations. To address this difficulty, we
used large language model (LLM)-based one-shot prompting and a text similarity
scoring model with domain adaptation using small manually annotated dataset.
The accuracy and quadratic weighted kappa of our model were 0.67 and 0.71 on a
subset of the publicly available ASAG dataset. The model achieved a substantial
improvement over the majority baseline. | [
-0.3429151177,
-1.2218805552,
0.6178605556,
-0.1143739522,
-0.3922982812,
-0.0888895094,
0.0079885032,
-0.5357294679,
0.2238826603,
0.4228720963,
-0.6466463208,
-0.8618881702,
-0.5025860667,
0.3579595983,
-0.2351240367,
1.2152382135,
0.0143511379,
0.1280005425,
-0.5118734241,
-0.3987728059,
-0.4683306217,
-0.3631530106,
-0.852868855,
-0.5594487786,
0.5526154041,
0.6963481307,
0.6384186149,
0.545047462,
0.8682441711,
0.209134981,
0.0828833804,
-0.1418351531,
-0.1014072001,
-0.2471419126,
-0.1509395242,
-0.3711791635,
-0.9667366147,
0.1830771267,
0.6175147295,
0.6948316693,
0.002652185,
0.8966168165,
0.2008068115,
0.5996616483,
-0.2993935645,
0.0342186317,
-0.2839115858,
-0.0918911248,
-0.149696365,
-0.1562980413,
-0.4705869257,
-0.6797271967,
0.4246255159,
-0.7173397541,
-0.0311023053,
0.1921532005,
0.6910849214,
0.3928232491,
-0.2438915968,
-0.4587514997,
-0.2243456393,
0.8241578937,
-0.7811846733,
-0.3881524801,
0.6551460028,
0.4678688049,
0.3686695397,
-0.4240057468,
-0.3753055334,
-0.2361138165,
-0.0464770086,
0.2680267692,
0.0461635441,
0.2951751053,
0.1530756801,
0.3973129988,
-0.6270014644,
0.2560800314,
-0.4196980298,
0.0359591022,
0.8598051667,
0.5203638673,
0.0779392049,
-0.4928895533,
-0.4828920066,
0.0481837094,
-0.5980705023,
0.4021438658,
0.3704164028,
0.5155252218,
0.0793586746,
0.5838792324,
-0.2469782084,
0.7821017504,
0.037756592,
-0.1310131699,
-0.0784039125,
-0.2255776376,
-0.2234849483,
0.1171640009,
0.5766819119,
0.6719216704,
0.4994135201,
0.2531372905,
0.0173503328,
-0.1060098857,
0.3104635477,
-0.6550071836,
-0.1467142552,
0.0838195011,
-0.5382063389,
-0.3664183021,
-0.0812282488,
-0.705544889,
-0.1621407866,
-0.5031637549,
0.9090388417,
-0.1943487525,
0.4965959787,
-0.0002755868,
0.1269727647,
0.3942855,
0.7975658178,
-0.2901378572,
0.463508755,
0.3318030834,
1.0254565477,
-0.5324215889,
-0.4470090866,
-0.411435008,
-0.2197177708,
-0.1982587874,
1.071410656,
-0.4337391555,
-0.4084767997,
-0.1415912509,
-0.2635352015,
0.0604684018,
-0.5371578336,
0.4656078219,
-0.5783968568,
0.4285666645,
-0.330168277,
-0.8573698401,
-0.4554059505,
0.5899342895,
-0.4816108346,
1.205193758,
0.2819538414,
-0.7745462656,
0.2407747507,
-0.8130193949,
-0.256111443,
0.4016262889,
0.3839837313,
-0.4020158052,
-0.1185323521,
0.2679850757,
0.4312064052,
-0.3712213039,
-0.0239968151,
-0.3042808771,
-0.6359210014,
0.0010032702,
-0.1352037489,
0.4271425009,
-0.1740626097,
0.0490725003,
0.0084302463,
-0.6864321828,
0.1981531531,
-0.110174112,
-0.4636338949,
-0.6009812355,
-0.3524584174,
-0.1581420451,
0.2788235843,
0.2667191327,
-0.4232926965,
0.4142178297,
-0.3013037443,
-0.3060762882,
0.9455607533,
0.4503140152,
0.51836133,
-0.6766885519,
0.9265445471,
-0.1125009656,
0.0776468813,
-0.2182309926,
-0.6356641054,
-0.63236624,
-0.1767965704,
0.5042488575,
0.6225563884,
-0.6476896405,
0.3736910522,
-0.3422042429,
-0.5282289982,
-0.9032830596,
0.3713688552,
0.5278652906,
0.8248484135,
0.4954817295,
-0.3368289173,
-0.1022737771,
-0.693007946,
-0.3539363444,
-0.3060116172,
-0.0616075248,
0.2989392281,
0.6060476899,
0.1761324555,
1.0283259153,
-0.7725637555,
-0.5272936821,
-0.2548021972,
0.4808700085,
0.0166415032,
0.1348574758,
0.4317879379,
-0.3075230718,
-0.8108140826,
-0.3563959002,
-0.6203511953,
-0.2595033348,
0.2056430429,
-0.0291697718,
0.0736569464,
0.1792118698,
-0.0864890888,
0.6648036242,
0.2352989614,
-0.1316210628,
0.7278657556,
0.1357312948,
0.4962240458,
-1.0572706461,
0.0388766751,
0.1993861347,
-0.4442235529,
-0.5263571739,
-0.0371773355,
-0.1120703146,
-0.0402934551,
-0.6702703238,
1.0650593042,
0.1379767358,
0.1283205599,
-0.6550419331,
0.0812669247,
0.0550458618,
0.6155514717,
0.0000298911,
0.8360111713,
0.4810604155,
-0.8610551357,
0.3461836874,
0.1991600394,
-0.2939627171,
0.6966098547,
-0.9809558392,
0.1222767234,
-0.2554640472,
0.3468878567,
-1.1086424589,
-0.3105819821,
-0.0614335686,
-0.5334481001,
-0.0939211473,
-0.1648481339,
-0.4320291877,
-0.2929121852,
-0.5300762057,
0.6024615765,
0.5643016696,
-0.4524131119,
0.2851986587,
0.0155460909,
-0.5591983199,
-0.1390835643,
-0.5142403245,
-0.4276165068,
-0.3433502614,
-0.442186892,
0.0565873198,
-0.2234674394,
-0.1817400903,
-0.1147309244,
0.1020163223,
-0.0503517091,
-0.1386125684,
0.2448153347,
0.4423277676,
-0.2744358778,
0.4910243154,
0.1253531426,
-0.0070677125,
0.162193045,
0.2510109842,
0.2356461287,
-0.2101850361,
-0.3779648542,
-0.5075462461,
0.5428828597,
0.5845431089,
-0.0962227061,
0.686466217,
0.1097251475,
-0.4850381613,
-0.1183594689,
-0.2610084414,
-0.3709141612,
-0.4146958292,
0.1273796856,
-0.2611163855,
-0.7802586555,
0.627240479,
-0.037483979,
0.1610870361,
0.4008370936,
0.4205793142,
-0.2451506406,
1.1765190363,
0.5185682178,
-0.0353125855,
0.3342697024,
-0.0936458483,
0.1591997743,
-0.6564842463,
-0.0792640671,
-0.5558422208,
-0.3185029626,
-0.2665757239,
-0.2005811483,
0.5946733952,
0.2302582115,
-0.0654213205,
0.1569922268,
-0.392781347,
0.6025901437,
0.4873944819,
0.3644662201,
0.2914963067,
-0.1560444385,
-0.1533877701,
0.0310475398,
-0.3329753876,
-0.9022502303,
1.0446971655,
0.4225805402,
0.8251596093,
-0.0487110578,
0.7126159072,
0.5995557904,
0.6293147802,
-1.1745946407,
0.5811040998,
-0.0680810139,
-0.579110384,
-0.5129400492,
-0.2323663086,
-0.4738481045,
0.0365947448,
-0.1656319648,
-0.6422526836,
-0.380348444,
0.0799091682,
-0.6353692412,
-0.2151920646,
-0.8255047798,
0.6720635295,
0.0105544068,
-0.2673152685,
0.0557866469,
-0.6230916381,
0.3123917282,
-0.2223033309,
0.199400574,
-0.3191809952,
0.2224440575,
1.1837882996,
-0.3888871074,
0.7682752013,
-0.1258223951,
0.1517120302,
0.7415332198,
0.0851296261,
0.187635079,
0.086589165,
-0.4939199388,
-0.0871862024,
0.1171894819,
-0.6194105148,
-0.7643498778,
0.487527132,
-0.5715466142,
-0.6719154119,
-0.568975687,
-0.5208813548,
-0.1243890375,
0.0551441908,
0.3256606758,
0.2957975268,
-0.0664963499,
-0.1214284003,
0.5326052308,
0.0393448062,
0.451587975,
0.4993786216,
-0.1905886084,
-0.1870502681,
0.3677340448,
0.0076409671,
0.3892202675,
0.2276126146,
0.4748973846,
-0.6738142967,
-0.1307968944,
-0.4348396957,
0.2569322586,
-1.0102205276,
-0.6240820885,
-0.3549065888,
-0.0325548947,
-0.5100598931,
-0.4217787087,
0.0421588607,
-0.421774596,
-0.4069921076,
-0.3099809289,
0.4745801091,
0.8327895999,
0.4082321525,
0.6153568029,
-0.9435593486,
0.2725031972,
0.4739391804,
0.3188244998,
0.1498522609,
-1.085093379,
-0.2868434787,
-0.0234040022,
-0.4717070758,
-0.9247654676,
0.0318541676,
0.4688096941,
0.1570533067,
0.174801141,
0.2499380261,
0.914617002,
-0.491374433,
1.0723731518,
0.1153538153,
-1.0393345356,
0.9125549793,
-0.1373647004,
0.7983797193,
0.9781578183,
0.6522502899,
-0.2449241281,
-0.3277561963,
-0.2878146768,
-0.5268588066,
0.6830824018,
-0.3087174296,
0.0552573688,
-0.0301964991,
0.5759552121,
0.3280973434,
0.0132888807,
-0.8619365692,
-0.2453680038,
0.0093961693,
-0.4228616059,
-0.1405537724,
0.0002945912,
0.1056706011,
-0.4738028646,
0.7672418952,
-0.4624543786,
-0.093616657,
0.1641208082,
-0.0950472057,
-0.1061250195,
0.5927422047,
0.4379411638,
0.5753370523,
-0.1727313995,
-0.0263827387,
0.5556702018,
-0.4591859877,
0.3050151169,
-0.2164237648,
-0.1971274167,
0.0138329025,
0.4659706056,
0.4046985507,
-0.1368300319,
-0.6689549088,
0.6526962519,
-0.0454716347,
-0.1232955903,
-0.0331623852,
-0.072660774,
-0.3176077008,
-0.1311979741,
0.5031270385,
-0.1993966699,
0.3840870261,
-0.5454999208,
0.1819934994,
0.1914989501,
-0.3822770715,
-0.2224291414,
0.2412454933,
0.08727438,
-0.4828034639,
0.4885478914,
-0.11237479,
-0.4500304759,
0.4899111092,
0.3301567137,
0.6560260057,
-0.3846449554,
0.4528797567,
0.676774621,
-0.0715933517,
-0.0885282531,
0.143754527,
-0.2312434018,
-0.1012864485,
-0.2122315168,
-1.0145270824,
-0.6428269744,
-0.1858402491,
-0.9968479872,
0.471221,
-0.5057761669,
-0.2052867562,
0.0698016658,
0.3491270542,
-0.5372790694,
0.7131739855,
-0.2349867821,
0.8856991529,
-1.256357193,
0.7941495776,
1.1903474331,
-0.4898616374,
-0.9105354548,
0.0163845085,
-0.0293071344,
-0.5115087628,
0.3638678789,
0.3188187778,
-0.187494874,
-0.010078107,
-0.35941872,
-0.4935179949,
1.0624778271,
-0.0959444493,
-0.1596637964,
-0.2890165746,
0.2873583138,
0.9626600742,
-0.3814757466,
0.4207549989,
0.5425884724,
0.2887307405,
0.2052322775,
-0.8258399963,
-0.0434098728,
-0.2124349624,
-0.1261940449,
0.1325735897,
-0.4267499149,
0.354691416,
-0.1796037704,
0.046226427,
0.0008081251,
0.5502302051,
0.4428889453,
0.6652183533,
0.2887159288,
0.6388075352,
0.5188252926,
-0.0640504584,
0.970174253,
0.0534510501,
0.4104108512,
1.1729575396,
-0.2587524652,
1.0283771753,
0.4081690907,
-0.0746882707,
0.5496909618,
0.7318092585,
0.264144212,
0.4939393103,
0.2985400856,
-0.2206742167,
-0.2785065174,
-0.2488866448,
-0.0268343203,
0.6875338554,
0.1493596882,
-0.1479083449,
-0.4051272571,
0.2538272142,
-0.2236629426,
0.1971724927,
-0.7063509226,
0.9773311019,
0.1693237722,
-1.0367634296,
0.2921226621,
0.0910556018,
0.7599332333,
-0.4835648835,
-0.1446747035,
-0.3156665564,
-0.0910904109,
-0.2465763539,
-0.9581958055,
0.3558858633,
0.2938540578,
-0.3660427034,
-0.1476905197,
0.5727763176,
-0.4068906307,
-0.5940698981,
-0.0318633467,
0.345418781,
0.1513563693,
0.0906654373,
-0.7411792278,
-0.3669573069,
-0.3919642568,
-0.084983632,
0.1668415219,
0.1760915369,
-0.1361860335,
0.6648016572,
0.2817215323,
-0.1172024161,
0.313603431,
0.0412234627,
0.4029233456,
-0.5718001723,
-0.6446922421,
-0.7135958672,
0.4364037216,
0.1901066899,
-0.3917103112,
0.8146879673,
0.3877094388,
0.6483339667,
-0.1000149548,
0.484411329,
0.3626900613,
1.0268523693,
-0.5042998791,
0.6349039674,
-0.6827580333,
0.2202997655,
-0.5340754986,
-0.8006412983,
-0.4080976844,
0.3838795424,
-0.4649704397,
0.1990045756,
0.8530091643,
0.4877889752,
0.135471791,
-0.0620817132,
0.3184501529,
-0.4741207957,
0.1128653064,
0.553584516,
0.6113578081,
-0.6979953051,
0.2818202674,
-0.1839028001,
-0.2912775874,
-0.305601269,
-0.6621928215,
-1.1457591057,
-0.5330499411,
-0.6805149317,
-0.2528540492,
-0.0738548711,
0.9332736135,
0.5618921518,
-0.768789649,
-0.0509562194,
0.2992838621,
0.0609653741,
-0.0468591601,
-0.3695407212,
0.5699232817,
-0.0251544379,
-0.6542230248,
-0.149905771,
0.3224750161,
0.4162774384,
0.0938876346,
-0.0805924535,
-0.316410929,
0.4717698693,
0.6128118038,
0.0629653186,
-0.8463331461,
-0.5677631497,
0.2023267001,
-0.2795669436,
0.1362692267,
0.5794782043,
-0.7048982978,
0.2913678288,
0.4976571798,
0.52514112,
0.0718209073,
0.6895184517,
0.1176828891,
-0.9748963714,
-0.1971289814,
0.4711719155,
0.0205495544,
0.3936491013,
-0.4832430184,
0.0520679243,
-0.1736634374,
-0.7341547608,
-0.5693736076,
0.1841928661,
-1.0745242834,
-0.1679324359,
0.987046957,
-0.3992865384,
-0.2206462473,
-0.0568700507,
-0.3381170034,
0.1613608599,
-0.2397839427,
0.9608023167,
1.0747927427,
-0.3759546578,
-0.4268120229,
0.0439658351,
0.458168298,
0.4610441625,
-1.2421072721,
-0.2729443312,
0.3313065469,
0.3280106783,
0.0994037464,
0.7649189234,
-0.0655592903,
0.6518146992,
-0.4233392775,
-0.1726193875,
0.1030343994,
-0.527752459,
-0.780365169,
0.3066084981,
0.2204344869,
-0.2729639709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18624v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18624v5 | W-procer: Weighted Prototypical Contrastive Learning for Medical Few-Shot Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-29T21:17:52 | 2023-08-01T00:04:32 | Mingchen Li, Yang Ye, Jeremy Yeung, Huixue Zhou, Huaiyuan Chu, Rui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Contrastive learning has become a popular solution for few-shot Name Entity
Recognization (NER). The conventional configuration strives to reduce the
distance between tokens with the same labels and increase the distance between
tokens with different labels. The effect of this setup may, however, in the
medical domain, there are a lot of entities annotated as OUTSIDE (O), and they
are undesirably pushed apart to other entities that are not labeled as OUTSIDE
(O) by the current contrastive learning method end up with a noisy prototype
for the semantic representation of the label, though there are many OUTSIDE (O)
labeled entities are relevant to the labeled entities. To address this
challenge, we propose a novel method named Weighted Prototypical Contrastive
Learning for Medical Few Shot Named Entity Recognization (W-PROCER). Our
approach primarily revolves around constructing the prototype-based contractive
loss and weighting network. These components play a crucial role in assisting
the model in differentiating the negative samples from OUTSIDE (O) tokens and
enhancing the discrimination ability of contrastive learning. Experimental
results show that our proposed W-PROCER framework significantly outperforms the
strong baselines on the three medical benchmark datasets. | [
-0.3642798066,
-0.3319916427,
0.3285759389,
-0.4933574796,
-0.4347758591,
-0.1008376926,
-0.1424482018,
-0.5527521968,
0.3942698836,
0.1803551316,
-0.4473520219,
-0.6564626694,
-0.6723544002,
0.1388731748,
-0.0826702937,
1.2063987255,
0.0833879337,
0.4914152026,
-0.0960047618,
-0.527549684,
-0.026472399,
-0.0185995996,
-1.0098241568,
-0.6284272671,
0.7199442387,
0.364956826,
0.3662640452,
0.3138836026,
0.6743928194,
0.3476199806,
0.0257846639,
0.0938103646,
-0.4219354093,
-0.172646746,
-0.0835468546,
-0.5596032143,
-0.2859521508,
-0.0629509315,
0.5573070049,
0.9208847284,
-0.165169701,
0.128390789,
0.0530194752,
0.5807572007,
-0.9518223405,
0.0765672922,
-0.36006549,
0.2167238444,
-0.4235067964,
0.047390949,
-0.2532952726,
-0.0615994185,
0.2718738914,
-0.9429843426,
0.3876137137,
0.0369030535,
1.0518676043,
-0.0674487054,
-0.3300773501,
0.0731766075,
-0.3882992566,
0.5168817639,
-0.5300062299,
0.4758720696,
0.2678366899,
0.3949227631,
-0.1306311041,
-1.0284918547,
-0.523840487,
-0.1158873141,
-0.0254690256,
0.440661788,
-0.3721705675,
0.3108623624,
-0.0976465642,
0.1167536974,
-0.3881962299,
0.4093785882,
-0.4391407073,
-0.3677245378,
0.1333743483,
0.1205278933,
-0.0232002158,
0.3919912279,
-0.4189810157,
0.1964830309,
-0.7419885993,
-0.2001562119,
0.1590276361,
0.313124001,
-0.1742399782,
0.4279990196,
-0.081384249,
0.7388072014,
0.247436747,
-0.4650419652,
0.5434884429,
0.1301025301,
-0.374147594,
0.0721631721,
0.6889516115,
0.4294835627,
0.1087682247,
-0.2378555387,
-0.0683139637,
-0.1727408469,
0.1825753599,
-1.0891144276,
-0.4893900752,
0.0477289781,
-0.8181029558,
-0.3359903395,
-0.03187038,
-0.4207365513,
-0.5376327634,
-0.0756743774,
0.5828275084,
-0.720646739,
-0.0248032007,
0.0908175334,
-0.0720715523,
-0.01737055,
0.2277701497,
-0.7127282619,
0.6696919799,
0.3651482165,
0.9274245501,
-0.0795054883,
0.0930889845,
-0.549438715,
0.154196173,
-0.2705070078,
0.8285560608,
-0.3184238672,
-0.4484165907,
-0.3022403717,
-0.0629071668,
0.1822824031,
-0.8038105369,
0.1969081461,
-0.4600445926,
0.1431269944,
-0.0476093888,
-0.6960859895,
-0.2620628774,
0.5038071275,
-0.6429768205,
0.4266215861,
0.1460419744,
-1.1552883387,
0.5600190759,
-0.072661303,
-0.3577434123,
0.3773452044,
-0.4734866917,
-0.918100059,
0.2591266334,
-0.088108331,
0.2477919906,
-0.229205057,
-0.1879135966,
-0.2377194613,
-0.4793326855,
0.0551722236,
0.1676988006,
0.5461344719,
-0.0711977109,
-0.267231226,
-0.036554426,
-1.0585277081,
-0.1186689362,
0.2800889909,
-0.1879847497,
-0.6610138416,
-0.2929954231,
-0.1095737666,
0.1408584416,
-0.1351566464,
-0.9589186907,
0.1147167459,
-0.5216722488,
-0.0277695861,
0.3632526696,
0.2138478905,
0.4449232817,
-0.5073083043,
0.5231665373,
0.256483525,
-0.0408469811,
0.2500644922,
-0.4171009064,
-0.693649292,
-0.8036523461,
0.4951634109,
0.4032449424,
-0.8160189986,
0.0289561246,
0.1031590775,
-0.5365495682,
-0.6207975745,
-0.016642483,
0.7843014002,
1.1451938152,
0.7298339605,
-0.4194237292,
-0.9395684004,
-1.0831561089,
0.0006217574,
-0.2475526929,
-0.3477516472,
0.3247291446,
0.5659828186,
-0.107832469,
0.7917969823,
-0.7320052981,
-0.9578951001,
-0.3226648569,
0.2562837899,
0.1837336421,
0.5332989097,
0.2596348822,
-0.6679673195,
-0.1955952495,
-0.224320665,
-0.3762078285,
-0.0462149046,
-0.1727054417,
-0.0363950394,
-0.3469416797,
0.5784293413,
-0.3916471303,
0.1186011657,
0.3916072547,
0.114606373,
0.6843851209,
-0.2086310089,
-0.3392925262,
-1.0070719719,
0.1843632311,
0.2550883591,
-0.244128406,
-0.4814699888,
-0.1369880885,
-0.0667170212,
0.2244387269,
-0.7118310928,
0.6869459152,
-0.3523616791,
0.0399429575,
-0.1562454551,
0.1458767503,
0.1211250499,
0.1675842404,
0.3149746954,
0.4593655765,
0.5855305195,
-0.7487034202,
0.0515642352,
0.1501949579,
-0.1938180923,
1.118180275,
-0.6136056185,
-0.1804385185,
-0.4222842157,
0.5894206166,
-0.702542603,
0.136546433,
0.2564303875,
-0.3627766073,
0.4199286401,
-0.2569045126,
-0.1854977608,
-0.1820026338,
-0.2654827237,
0.4965302348,
0.3887911141,
-0.2782841623,
0.3988690376,
0.205300808,
0.2353390306,
-0.4329028726,
-0.8450191617,
-0.1937607527,
-0.0607075579,
0.032606788,
1.0885350704,
0.270503521,
-0.1604696065,
0.0584890209,
-0.3945510685,
-0.163427785,
-0.2166076899,
0.3309898078,
0.241863057,
-0.2247619927,
0.4999014735,
-0.4202743471,
-0.4074059427,
-0.2778969705,
-0.5259336233,
0.2733997107,
0.0295896605,
-0.069876276,
-0.4854280353,
0.0762287676,
-0.0409036465,
-0.1269680262,
0.9621919394,
0.8914425373,
-0.7323433161,
0.0643304363,
-0.4503743947,
-0.3329406977,
-0.4089168906,
0.4607917666,
-0.5485706329,
-0.7594371438,
0.537445128,
-0.4245888293,
-0.008403142,
0.4246028364,
0.5051158071,
-0.5344899893,
0.5772812963,
0.5648043752,
0.3255775273,
0.4674485028,
-0.5358294845,
-0.2362994105,
-1.1039750576,
-0.6028203964,
-0.3289058208,
-0.7360937595,
-0.6520847678,
-0.137736991,
0.5817542672,
0.1467106342,
-0.2225518823,
0.3036622107,
-0.2673536837,
0.4020531774,
0.4251226187,
0.6343083382,
0.1465895474,
-0.3142786622,
-0.7641304135,
-0.3530096114,
-0.4262478054,
-0.1294686496,
0.9449060559,
0.1177672818,
0.7248752117,
0.20619376,
1.2954244614,
-0.0817638189,
0.6021788716,
-0.9269216657,
0.5695366263,
-0.5365313292,
-0.3881845176,
-0.0042038858,
-0.3366499245,
-1.288212657,
0.3686539531,
-0.5341195464,
-0.7266780734,
0.4022586942,
0.2199949026,
-0.6218777299,
0.3662686348,
-0.3106173277,
0.6117466092,
0.0818030536,
-0.388910234,
0.0282319114,
-0.814915657,
0.2600489259,
0.1721034348,
0.0298924092,
0.0220448058,
-0.5333374739,
0.7897517681,
-0.6763392687,
0.9466217756,
-0.4573294222,
0.1465999335,
0.1544608325,
0.2025115639,
0.3856491745,
-0.0071305209,
0.1821193248,
0.1562979519,
-0.4008361399,
-0.403619051,
-0.256169945,
0.2872208357,
-0.4496066272,
-0.0750591904,
-0.1421582252,
-0.0127051277,
-0.2879882455,
0.4172841012,
0.8062483072,
0.4954466522,
-0.4007054865,
0.1273051351,
0.7209228873,
-0.1689913124,
0.1908481866,
0.670360446,
0.2467142344,
-0.5305779576,
0.8773531318,
0.1800096333,
-0.1189403236,
0.6907026172,
0.3043256998,
-0.0725924745,
-0.8661642671,
-0.0416790433,
0.3205506802,
-0.4705659151,
-0.6829230189,
-0.6703596115,
0.075506486,
0.0646747872,
-0.2953955531,
-0.5575836897,
-0.164335534,
-0.3098016381,
-0.0537965037,
-0.0869816318,
0.1813952178,
0.0625932813,
0.5386455059,
-0.6184145808,
0.6385984421,
0.2328887731,
0.3359506428,
-0.2294600457,
-0.4453111589,
-0.140090555,
-0.4735256732,
-0.2376016229,
-1.0118646622,
0.1710845828,
0.5114132166,
0.5329390764,
0.7256157398,
0.1436943859,
0.6817853451,
-0.5639725327,
0.2973673046,
0.631054759,
-0.5794832706,
0.3616215587,
0.1882677078,
0.4192940593,
0.9267200828,
0.402451247,
-0.4134019613,
-0.2959800065,
-0.6968417764,
-0.8360067606,
0.2539374232,
0.0474526957,
-0.1718161553,
-0.3502539396,
0.245260641,
0.310451746,
0.0288042817,
-0.6008366942,
-0.2146509588,
0.1029914394,
-0.3329927027,
0.3037977517,
-0.0391720012,
-0.2495349944,
-0.014411401,
0.6673463583,
-0.2861100435,
0.2704786956,
0.3141051829,
-0.2728094459,
0.2465260327,
0.3032175303,
0.4876405895,
0.1726526916,
-0.2972486019,
0.3917726278,
0.3652167618,
-0.6495047212,
0.2700555027,
0.1404143274,
-0.0502231084,
0.0758279413,
0.6270440221,
0.6161355972,
0.4475522637,
-0.4308893383,
0.7326096296,
0.0891429856,
-0.4166662395,
-0.1623518467,
-0.2602891028,
0.0529044718,
0.3345133066,
0.1995034814,
0.1875548065,
0.4073138833,
-0.2150178999,
0.4725527167,
0.3810602129,
-0.5239921808,
-0.2804475725,
0.5476997495,
0.3573533595,
0.1776712537,
0.7325680256,
-0.4431214631,
-0.2156219482,
0.6621473432,
0.7842741609,
0.7576016784,
-0.0730699524,
0.2065891623,
0.6482665539,
0.0489223115,
-0.0057699927,
0.2630806565,
-0.0494903773,
-0.8162496686,
-0.0917151496,
-0.3641165495,
-0.2522360384,
0.1569981873,
-0.7173237801,
0.4326839149,
-0.720494628,
-0.6118260622,
0.3006818593,
0.0097064013,
-0.8827767372,
0.4927724004,
0.2605894208,
0.7090388536,
-0.7019745708,
0.7319980264,
0.9859752655,
-0.5370097756,
-0.2874310613,
0.0723625794,
0.3272351027,
-0.9191068411,
0.9392947555,
0.2929602861,
-0.3194065392,
0.0813329816,
-0.1723536104,
-0.3560735583,
1.1736695766,
0.3366523981,
-0.9904809594,
-0.0881042406,
-0.3518435955,
0.6419279575,
-0.4988195598,
0.3164702952,
0.3215383291,
0.1595767289,
0.260353148,
-0.6592029929,
0.1554890722,
0.1752439588,
-0.0742962807,
0.2778663635,
-0.6865752339,
0.7469697595,
-0.8489419222,
-0.2343465686,
0.045248948,
0.4408461452,
0.4373806715,
0.39839679,
0.5378866792,
0.7224511504,
0.5443094969,
-0.0247346293,
0.7150067687,
0.0202677622,
0.1860036403,
1.4019334316,
-0.2192180604,
0.740418911,
0.5380686522,
-0.3323586881,
0.7043936253,
0.4954708219,
-0.1831194162,
0.6697348952,
0.6310446262,
-0.4567285478,
-0.1630904824,
-0.2800174356,
-0.2313361764,
0.7554918528,
0.2834839225,
-0.526864171,
-0.3764557838,
0.2130825818,
0.2309499234,
-0.2049082816,
-0.3412010372,
1.0319280624,
0.1608880311,
0.0210821237,
0.3567252457,
0.1555240303,
0.7743656635,
-0.6312558651,
-0.0956794992,
-0.2717628777,
0.3439902365,
-0.452066958,
-0.3076214194,
0.0827275813,
-0.3025993407,
0.0941638947,
0.4336479306,
0.6226468086,
-0.361751318,
-0.3034737706,
0.1475604773,
0.4257132113,
0.1123455241,
0.1949261874,
-0.7928988934,
-0.2896569669,
-0.4678292871,
-0.1332398504,
0.4366213977,
0.2206051052,
-0.0449789837,
0.5949114561,
0.2089873105,
0.4048796892,
-0.4426558912,
0.4060323834,
0.7733507156,
-0.3504063487,
-0.558447063,
-0.7880607247,
0.3684546351,
0.0146531779,
-0.3339636028,
0.222868517,
0.6593567729,
0.9040111899,
-0.057190638,
0.2716567814,
0.0137376953,
0.2082927525,
-0.5180428028,
0.4426071346,
-0.5423002839,
-0.0076554595,
-0.1634184122,
-0.7639690042,
-0.6757030487,
0.5089896321,
0.1251844764,
0.1226406768,
0.7262400985,
0.5828475356,
0.0085250409,
-0.6382066607,
0.4500629008,
0.0778985545,
0.0200963262,
0.7375797629,
0.1396734416,
-0.4226083755,
0.6943263412,
-0.2368133217,
-0.2300818563,
-0.387200743,
-0.7422001958,
-0.6915512681,
-0.3497924805,
-0.7343766689,
-0.3165709674,
0.2579970658,
0.9351192713,
1.0506132841,
-0.9040565491,
0.368994832,
-0.2226311564,
-0.1860249639,
-0.6442860961,
-0.139389053,
0.5513302088,
-0.2189624608,
-0.4985147715,
0.1814870834,
0.3530117273,
0.3376843333,
-0.0004782381,
-0.1788275093,
-0.1333618164,
-0.1778563857,
0.3130221069,
0.4710291326,
-0.5122561455,
-0.0122507745,
-0.4701797664,
-0.2632330358,
0.0095709395,
0.9923898578,
-1.2671740055,
0.7749138474,
0.3545070589,
0.5002393723,
0.5233606696,
-0.0844525099,
0.145320043,
-1.3028632402,
0.286377579,
0.3413465023,
0.4307526052,
0.282697022,
-0.1555091292,
0.4378302395,
0.5060530901,
0.0860266164,
-0.3551697135,
0.3486974537,
-0.7337076664,
-0.2814842165,
0.8033634424,
-0.4081428051,
0.2075152397,
-0.150012359,
-0.2387996018,
0.494558841,
-0.2405456752,
0.6034955382,
0.3186312914,
-0.471854955,
-0.4231319129,
-0.2303986102,
0.4800435007,
0.3106601238,
-0.7831590176,
-0.5610533357,
0.3169409931,
0.4936969578,
-0.0192190781,
0.9244427085,
-0.3842255771,
0.2784210742,
0.2934226096,
0.3385048211,
-0.4487679005,
-0.2143912017,
-0.1748647988,
0.2435945719,
0.0710061714,
-0.8365778327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18623v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18623v1 | Alfred: A System for Prompted Weak Supervision | 2023-05-29T21:16:42 | 2023-05-29T21:16:42 | Peilin Yu, Stephen H. Bach | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Alfred is the first system for programmatic weak supervision (PWS) that
creates training data for machine learning by prompting. In contrast to typical
PWS systems where weak supervision sources are programs coded by experts,
Alfred enables users to encode their subject matter expertise via natural
language prompts for language and vision-language models. Alfred provides a
simple Python interface for the key steps of this emerging paradigm, with a
high-throughput backend for large-scale data labeling. Users can quickly
create, evaluate, and refine their prompt-based weak supervision sources; map
the results to weak labels; and resolve their disagreements with a label model.
Alfred enables a seamless local development experience backed by models served
from self-managed computing clusters. It automatically optimizes the execution
of prompts with optimized batching mechanisms. We find that this optimization
improves query throughput by 2.9x versus a naive approach. We present two
example use cases demonstrating Alfred on YouTube comment spam detection and
pet breeds classification. Alfred is open source, available at
https://github.com/BatsResearch/alfred. | [
-0.4141501486,
-0.4118796289,
0.3974613547,
0.2364017814,
0.0895883366,
-0.2124936283,
0.0392334647,
-0.4137715995,
0.354468286,
0.3722764254,
-0.41225034,
-0.5950055122,
-0.6841780543,
0.3681067526,
-0.2264209688,
1.4336944818,
0.1172543243,
-0.2471423745,
0.0387749337,
-0.1206863299,
-0.0300039146,
-0.2164893597,
-0.9307617545,
-0.3086772263,
0.8769856095,
0.6553325653,
0.9931011796,
0.4436134994,
0.3769595325,
0.3167380095,
0.0886557698,
0.1352812648,
-0.3494657278,
0.6072362065,
-0.2780019343,
-0.3241700828,
-0.4825752378,
-0.245832324,
0.1984285861,
0.9996622801,
0.1625080258,
0.1758183688,
0.1375069916,
0.7091718316,
-1.1305813789,
0.1126188785,
-0.3482930064,
0.1424202174,
-0.0916854367,
-0.0865046829,
-0.3719621897,
-0.1265729815,
0.4444519877,
-0.8866592646,
0.2682204247,
0.1839111745,
0.5196899176,
0.3248596191,
-0.2085995078,
-0.5477565527,
-0.487180829,
0.9772590399,
-0.4367505312,
0.0470921807,
0.8662968874,
0.297988832,
-0.0359960906,
-1.0779136419,
-0.3014653921,
-0.2647480965,
-0.0027276718,
0.0303785224,
-0.3757663369,
0.4750556052,
0.3643397391,
0.0608391985,
-0.3510116339,
0.0718909502,
-0.3556837738,
-0.3428930044,
0.4528414011,
0.2375292778,
0.1777527332,
-0.1323420405,
-0.0389082581,
-0.0915102586,
-0.4101534486,
0.0496836789,
0.3344136775,
0.6404207349,
0.0094905403,
0.5148268342,
-0.4696694016,
0.5769805312,
0.0577571653,
-0.0684755147,
0.0783710331,
0.2733759582,
-0.1445769072,
0.3147292435,
0.8563383222,
0.2217054814,
0.1875486523,
-0.1700160354,
-0.5629999042,
0.3230062425,
0.487786442,
-0.6514161825,
-0.5426858068,
0.3058556914,
-0.5199489594,
-0.3651918173,
-0.1662069261,
-0.3167650104,
-0.4178772569,
-0.1924234927,
0.5606570244,
-0.4303927124,
0.0448521934,
-0.0189432856,
-0.4582703412,
-0.2725309134,
0.6892784834,
-1.1476837397,
0.3310022354,
0.5495557785,
0.801289618,
-0.2389280498,
-0.3923299909,
-0.7808472514,
0.081117548,
-0.5979446173,
0.4320661426,
-0.2411255538,
-0.1194450781,
0.2627871335,
0.0240210779,
0.4649746716,
-0.7635564804,
0.4616918564,
-0.7284654379,
0.0364341252,
0.0741508529,
-0.4036316574,
0.0031383829,
0.0902614966,
-0.3924225867,
1.1490939856,
0.4528906643,
-0.9287495613,
0.4831451178,
-0.5269336104,
-0.5052085519,
0.4997722507,
-0.0617855489,
-0.2665359676,
-0.2755763531,
0.3909132481,
0.5874400139,
0.0096922843,
0.1328219771,
-0.419595927,
-0.4161267281,
-0.1448253095,
-0.0963770077,
0.7069008946,
0.3367771208,
-0.2212047279,
0.3192700446,
-0.749515295,
-0.014034004,
-0.0506315939,
-0.411567241,
-0.7781304717,
-0.1325028241,
-0.0497777425,
-0.3183266819,
0.2644931078,
-0.1916679293,
0.3482004106,
-0.4932988286,
0.2752491832,
0.6538498998,
-0.0917020515,
0.500334084,
-0.3138096929,
0.7003181577,
-0.3088645041,
0.1551392674,
-0.4137646556,
-0.6331911683,
-0.5038295984,
-0.3759020865,
0.1088413298,
0.7067515254,
-1.0311616659,
0.3370175958,
0.4225155413,
-0.2028984874,
-0.6999223232,
0.4192101657,
0.3961687982,
0.7801754475,
0.4132143557,
-0.2242663354,
-0.6542313695,
-0.9715378284,
0.0808755979,
-0.3243476748,
-0.4124616683,
0.326846987,
0.5533928275,
-0.5921866894,
0.9216020107,
-0.2994996011,
0.041101858,
-0.1334386021,
0.4649260342,
0.4967977107,
0.2909811139,
0.3021591306,
-0.4784097075,
-0.5488513112,
-0.2630908787,
-1.0872664452,
-0.4262185395,
0.195698902,
-0.0017993626,
0.1318370104,
0.3884738386,
-0.6640452743,
0.3194039464,
0.2256813794,
-0.0120274853,
0.9072373509,
-0.06568975,
-0.1142642945,
-0.8666172028,
0.1852451861,
-0.0068428097,
-0.1467597634,
-0.3371314108,
-0.1814548522,
0.0486678593,
-0.5205708146,
-0.3699569106,
0.3924154043,
-0.1164715365,
-0.1697178036,
-0.3316623271,
-0.1188220233,
-0.1614307165,
0.3087149858,
-0.0450916812,
0.879021883,
1.1463963985,
-1.0111522675,
0.6102381349,
0.5137585402,
-0.1127575561,
0.4271962345,
-0.9068158865,
0.2826682031,
-0.051373899,
0.0436190926,
-0.8185146451,
-0.5443834662,
0.5628167391,
-0.466027081,
0.0798878074,
-0.540350914,
-0.2131328583,
-0.4048621655,
-0.5125769973,
0.2507676184,
0.4701030254,
-0.8776904345,
0.224349767,
0.1064597815,
-0.2811900079,
-1.0906022787,
-0.2721930146,
0.2754002512,
-0.1120506898,
-0.5565854907,
0.1733128577,
0.3222874999,
-0.4629642963,
0.2185290456,
-0.1143799648,
0.021992851,
0.0732189491,
0.3522063196,
0.2346208543,
-0.2790483832,
0.267475307,
0.1932808161,
-0.2344243079,
0.0169438403,
-0.5061978698,
0.0379860811,
-0.0396683253,
0.0664738417,
-0.966471076,
0.5071150661,
0.6632244587,
0.1812392473,
0.5456026793,
0.1575142145,
-0.2083252966,
-0.9825143218,
0.2137869895,
-0.6101354957,
-0.6192523837,
0.1976191252,
-0.3119879961,
-0.8069967628,
0.1139400899,
-0.3603190184,
-0.0314334966,
0.274969548,
0.2651657164,
-0.3887169361,
1.2797130346,
0.6131359339,
-0.3598389328,
0.5340704322,
-0.2257395983,
-0.0220168065,
-0.4780077338,
0.2020485401,
-0.3779457808,
-0.1843648851,
-0.23145096,
0.2247535735,
0.4435340166,
0.5044777393,
-0.6231672764,
0.1407143772,
-0.8005572557,
0.1274013966,
1.0233912468,
-0.2493230402,
-0.0492966101,
0.0136079565,
0.0203677732,
0.0244207624,
-0.8787036538,
-0.7806453109,
1.3548291922,
0.3537320495,
1.3242871761,
-0.0661988556,
0.8139722943,
0.9331997037,
0.2782797217,
-1.1265064478,
0.537132144,
0.2078333497,
-0.3432569206,
-0.3200266361,
-0.4428195655,
-1.2426792383,
-0.0250384901,
-0.2852993608,
-0.5507280827,
-0.0057234005,
0.3961600065,
-0.5150757432,
-0.0389750041,
-0.9465745687,
0.7499854565,
0.0216738954,
-0.3595181704,
0.0166966189,
-0.7408257723,
0.1448144019,
0.2052999288,
-0.1547777802,
0.1770296842,
-0.1289370358,
1.0054569244,
-0.8347631693,
1.0282531977,
-0.2842768133,
-0.0777762011,
0.3474998772,
0.0770920068,
0.7570242882,
0.1761535853,
0.1922779977,
-0.1482526958,
-0.0914707482,
-0.1635040641,
-0.5807405114,
0.3559976518,
-0.8847401738,
-0.1785026193,
-0.6343810558,
-0.5800440311,
-0.1785969436,
0.2851918936,
0.1531812698,
0.4685860574,
0.3029088378,
-0.1119131222,
0.655823648,
-0.2958397865,
0.2153429985,
0.727417767,
-0.3231307566,
-0.4341443479,
0.82332021,
-0.0793631226,
-0.1394488364,
0.0641639903,
0.0976728424,
-0.0482641384,
-0.5847539902,
-0.3325055242,
0.1235850677,
-0.8244249225,
-0.3386414647,
-0.6152182221,
0.2388021052,
-0.6536352038,
-0.4259613454,
-0.2214907408,
-0.4350362122,
-0.3483919203,
0.1185695678,
0.3924649358,
0.8998519778,
-0.1493081152,
0.6654297709,
-0.5819844007,
0.5407723784,
0.6014271975,
0.2602638006,
-0.1370552778,
-0.2289182544,
-0.2553288639,
-0.4965291917,
-0.367623657,
-0.9049055576,
0.278598696,
0.2099467069,
0.2633532286,
0.8482499123,
0.4694646001,
0.0646389648,
-0.3284419775,
0.4994151294,
0.2027874142,
-0.6835126877,
1.0260953903,
-0.3888926506,
0.0692524761,
0.562681675,
0.7621530294,
-0.6010579467,
-0.6787619591,
-0.4229690731,
-1.147785306,
1.2213127613,
-0.1835758537,
-0.135515973,
-0.2553822696,
0.4542170167,
0.252061218,
0.2223644108,
-0.1065866873,
-0.3583462238,
-0.1124076396,
-0.3799898922,
0.0405987874,
-0.0999458879,
-0.2927150428,
-0.2804885209,
0.9079296589,
-0.3271485865,
0.1408206075,
0.2770946026,
-0.111635305,
-0.2496989965,
0.002688485,
-0.0309263282,
0.5917226076,
-0.4346039891,
0.3921810091,
-0.1191773266,
-0.5220612884,
-0.0603582188,
0.1479494423,
-0.4440717995,
0.0868334323,
0.5971223712,
0.7731440067,
-0.0243219528,
-0.7327713966,
0.2455784231,
0.0092297243,
-0.2790367603,
-0.2167168558,
0.3604110479,
-0.2599928379,
0.2485454828,
0.735538125,
0.2024616599,
0.3228589594,
-0.5109242797,
0.3940961063,
0.2100526989,
-0.2125324309,
-0.2195546627,
0.6626865268,
0.1918201447,
-0.4500965178,
0.6754463315,
-0.5061706901,
-0.4300032556,
0.5989173651,
0.6161316037,
0.5740947723,
-0.1458127201,
0.3699269295,
0.3023716807,
0.1579632908,
-0.2007644176,
0.2948315442,
-0.4902738035,
-0.7698054314,
-0.4866644144,
-0.4752842784,
-1.0226727724,
0.1097434387,
-0.6918564439,
0.1112401709,
-0.6533874869,
-0.3118561506,
0.2283101827,
-0.0851743445,
-0.2161704004,
0.1490903944,
0.1063022166,
0.7504684925,
-0.8999141455,
0.7032549977,
1.0848749876,
-0.2838698924,
-0.7316558957,
-0.2369449735,
-0.1124852449,
-0.7817587852,
0.8947899938,
0.2789375186,
-0.3555195928,
-0.032186199,
-0.9319601655,
-0.4061485529,
0.6090653539,
0.5501605272,
-0.397567153,
0.2442532927,
-0.2949179709,
0.2912053466,
-0.0381506495,
0.185847789,
0.2074759007,
0.1555308104,
0.0001626916,
-0.7304292321,
-0.1132276729,
-0.2288640738,
-0.2764296234,
0.2688206434,
0.0050740037,
0.8734641075,
-0.236632213,
-0.2319540977,
-0.1527769566,
0.726287961,
0.1889027506,
0.8033962846,
0.2835221887,
0.6903004646,
1.0960303545,
0.2059681416,
1.1050748825,
-0.2940124273,
0.2231048644,
1.0112843513,
-0.344678551,
0.5324990153,
0.4609235823,
-0.343255192,
0.365583092,
0.5123001933,
0.1641955376,
0.7333090901,
-0.032092344,
-0.6786587238,
-0.0262989756,
-0.2107200623,
-0.2916836143,
0.0195891242,
0.3982225657,
-0.3390105367,
-0.1998785585,
0.3111924231,
-0.0630396456,
-0.1002726108,
-0.7366925478,
0.7587717772,
0.1778145134,
-0.6997189522,
0.7126352191,
0.1229043975,
1.1419093609,
-0.8844595551,
-0.1642908603,
-0.1626020819,
0.3777894378,
-0.3888265193,
-0.6968111992,
0.2135107368,
0.0497568585,
-0.1973575652,
-0.2930047214,
0.9942762852,
-0.0894990116,
-0.0196582098,
0.2980587184,
0.2303132713,
0.4324378669,
-0.0909519643,
-0.6663154364,
-0.0731645599,
-0.4536349475,
-0.2121725231,
0.2197912782,
0.5966921449,
-0.0415258594,
0.7946822047,
0.523851037,
0.1123209596,
-0.1493928432,
0.087013118,
0.8157171607,
-0.4304190874,
-0.6478398442,
-0.5232474804,
-0.0409886092,
0.0935087204,
-0.5468954444,
1.0233696699,
0.3403867483,
0.6415948868,
-0.0545335189,
1.1123195887,
-0.2548385859,
0.488658458,
-0.1152277216,
0.6267433763,
-0.3430298269,
-0.0821805671,
-0.1595184654,
-0.712896347,
-0.3043246567,
0.7544431686,
-0.3719566464,
-0.0653023645,
0.467661947,
0.9337692261,
-0.1028866619,
0.0613156185,
0.0635042861,
-0.0811717734,
-0.0215326082,
0.4867506325,
1.1465454102,
-0.0256861113,
0.3265225291,
-0.23500745,
-0.3529459834,
-0.2921157181,
-0.4185415506,
-1.0139191151,
-0.2611935437,
-0.3265418708,
-0.5081006885,
0.3033895195,
0.9950493574,
0.8664304614,
-1.0196956396,
-0.024880033,
-0.304025799,
0.1793606877,
-0.5139451027,
-0.2572189867,
0.4938178062,
-0.9471837878,
-0.415907383,
0.7083037496,
0.122871086,
-0.1835320443,
-0.1426911801,
-0.4990440309,
0.3008642197,
-0.2814582586,
0.5036305785,
0.7138156295,
-0.1596699655,
-0.0538514815,
-0.4257397652,
-0.3004581928,
-0.0641921833,
0.6398188472,
-1.0015141964,
0.4751945734,
0.3442115188,
0.8285256624,
0.4665400982,
-0.0614631139,
0.3505461812,
-0.9041041136,
0.2661019564,
0.7525083423,
0.0546240658,
0.2605381012,
-0.3348444402,
0.3346501589,
0.2620212138,
-0.631882906,
-0.8825105429,
0.1295600235,
-0.7171552181,
-0.3629048765,
0.7885591984,
-0.0853177533,
-0.2663159072,
-0.5680071115,
-0.4400067925,
0.1541677713,
-0.8307850957,
0.9600853324,
0.379786253,
-0.2540504932,
-0.0012268154,
-0.838642776,
0.7017663121,
0.627753377,
-0.4005424678,
-0.1181095839,
0.4808077812,
0.0751553327,
0.1354678869,
0.8657088876,
0.4493730664,
0.3920788765,
0.1453521103,
0.1468856186,
-0.0648168027,
-0.6170104742,
-0.4165261984,
0.5835667253,
0.2016400844,
-0.4155616462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18602v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18602v1 | From `Snippet-lects' to Doculects and Dialects: Leveraging Neural Representations of Speech for Placing Audio Signals in a Language Landscape | 2023-05-29T20:37:06 | 2023-05-29T20:37:06 | Séverine Guillaume, Guillaume Wisniewski, Alexis Michaud | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | XLSR-53 a multilingual model of speech, builds a vector representation from
audio, which allows for a range of computational treatments. The experiments
reported here use this neural representation to estimate the degree of
closeness between audio files, ultimately aiming to extract relevant linguistic
properties. We use max-pooling to aggregate the neural representations from a
"snippet-lect" (the speech in a 5-second audio snippet) to a "doculect" (the
speech in a given resource), then to dialects and languages. We use data from
corpora of 11 dialects belonging to 5 less-studied languages. Similarity
measurements between the 11 corpora bring out greatest closeness between those
that are known to be dialects of the same language. The findings suggest that
(i) dialect/language can emerge among the various parameters characterizing
audio files and (ii) estimates of overall phonetic/phonological closeness can
be obtained for a little-resourced or fully unknown language. The findings help
shed light on the type of information captured by neural representations of
speech and how it can be extracted from these representations | [
-0.4978734255,
-0.4349964261,
0.5578379035,
-0.0436549634,
-0.0627190173,
-0.0512473807,
-0.6556837559,
-0.2950622737,
0.6651613712,
0.2915881276,
-0.3659481704,
-0.2489829063,
-0.5077618361,
0.043977011,
-0.6144465208,
0.6431485415,
0.8136487007,
0.0440064594,
-0.1022243649,
-0.2249507308,
-0.2229835093,
-0.907867074,
-0.4191937447,
-0.2746839523,
0.5737703443,
0.2303945124,
0.6241270304,
0.7653106451,
0.1185550168,
0.3889956176,
-0.4052295089,
-0.0541672558,
-0.1170714498,
0.2092346102,
0.1142549366,
-0.6825778484,
-0.1210490763,
-0.1364298165,
0.8177751303,
1.0748294592,
-0.281157136,
0.0168611333,
-0.0587287731,
0.3492972553,
-0.2549700141,
-0.00205277,
-0.6499116421,
0.297552675,
-0.4081994891,
-0.2615868151,
-0.2638736665,
-0.0641428679,
0.2545297444,
-0.2741838098,
0.117193222,
-0.1846657991,
0.8674613833,
0.1037295908,
-0.2990856767,
-0.1935903728,
-0.6169305444,
0.8380285501,
-0.6620013714,
0.6640020609,
0.3945944309,
0.3111186028,
0.1699250042,
-0.577991128,
-0.4951242507,
-0.3006466925,
0.0426631086,
-0.0045221644,
-0.1565142274,
-0.2476712316,
0.235905841,
0.2851166129,
-0.3303568363,
0.1167546362,
-0.4315258861,
-0.4203942716,
0.3822834194,
-0.0867715701,
0.263522923,
-0.3538005352,
-0.0402373224,
-0.191498965,
-0.6359886527,
-0.1254031062,
0.4477104843,
0.6678510308,
-0.1620315313,
0.5576585531,
0.3457603157,
0.648137033,
0.0364784114,
-0.0851246566,
0.4929422438,
-0.299297601,
-0.0096482392,
0.2714389563,
0.8287190795,
0.2266086042,
0.1737714708,
-0.0788158029,
-0.2817976475,
-0.259616226,
0.0925513059,
-0.2173484117,
-0.1762871742,
-0.1151752323,
-0.4338982105,
-0.1547311842,
-0.1273765117,
-0.710365057,
-0.3720283806,
-0.5342116952,
0.112336047,
-0.7154111862,
-0.510689497,
-0.4582989812,
-0.3936601877,
0.0688294545,
-0.0984571576,
-1.1002101898,
0.5930444598,
0.6248692274,
1.1311239004,
0.010604701,
-0.3254225254,
-0.5466437936,
0.2552207112,
-0.2806476951,
0.9083429575,
-0.5854971409,
-0.4831748605,
0.1185455024,
-0.2163727432,
0.1417140067,
-0.7430669069,
0.2543717921,
-0.3121240437,
-0.0950441957,
-0.2494350076,
-0.4689849615,
0.0340179242,
-0.1507846266,
-0.9873679876,
1.1890349388,
0.23994717,
-0.610438168,
0.0192348529,
-0.4998042583,
-0.3041745126,
-0.1379181445,
-0.5735260248,
0.0572709776,
0.2856951654,
-0.0366454609,
0.3862962127,
-0.0181748215,
-0.2971398234,
-0.0937314853,
-0.0776894391,
0.4777473211,
-0.3715186119,
0.7959762216,
0.3102890253,
-0.157464236,
-0.2523284554,
-0.5708475113,
-0.1101782024,
-0.0719416589,
-0.2756619453,
-0.5845981836,
-0.1686309576,
0.2693406343,
0.0608513989,
0.2319070697,
-0.5862396359,
0.029261047,
-0.5366423726,
0.7051410675,
0.6595939398,
-0.3786271811,
0.8374242187,
-0.2771818042,
0.370769918,
-0.0388426445,
-0.406586349,
-0.3263022304,
-0.3813741207,
-0.4549483657,
-0.2227285802,
0.644874692,
0.3210401833,
-0.1040197164,
0.3645851016,
-0.5355255008,
-0.3505282402,
-0.3902519941,
-0.0028481809,
0.1363077611,
0.4163398743,
0.1133115143,
-0.3434989452,
-0.579870224,
-0.8931925893,
0.1825533509,
-0.0256302636,
-0.3810670376,
0.3225433826,
0.0718588382,
0.0344355106,
0.8109356165,
-0.37604931,
-0.2243212909,
-0.3389790654,
0.0509211496,
0.3430433869,
0.1115538403,
0.994402349,
-0.6483319402,
-0.3245222569,
0.1760438979,
-0.4439258575,
-0.184770152,
0.1007996351,
0.1860218197,
0.0183314104,
0.9156933427,
-0.444566071,
-0.0073852949,
0.6603911519,
-0.0037884668,
0.7181031108,
-0.1637382358,
-0.0806482881,
-0.994762063,
-0.1889204532,
-0.1105840504,
-0.3318589032,
-0.7405647039,
-0.0236608591,
-0.1531016827,
-0.0387255177,
-0.2893945575,
0.2058238089,
-0.5059111118,
-0.4913187325,
-0.1111605018,
0.5954710841,
-0.1410468519,
0.3629644513,
0.2505748272,
0.8290002346,
0.8149785995,
-0.4031297565,
0.3729303777,
-0.0001373137,
-0.287488699,
0.5542490482,
-0.4166625738,
0.2435076535,
-0.0172813255,
-0.0145821441,
-0.8386079073,
-0.1079810709,
-0.2347140908,
-0.6562075019,
0.4438304901,
-0.1875140071,
-0.3667637408,
0.2210256159,
-0.0866993517,
0.5354118347,
0.3888036013,
-0.2424553037,
0.7781682611,
0.9511620402,
-0.6507256031,
-0.4220753908,
-1.1031911373,
0.1423619986,
-0.3711320758,
-0.5051417947,
0.2695934474,
0.2115353346,
-0.4628046453,
0.0828018636,
0.0107921772,
-0.342087239,
-0.3972272277,
0.279384613,
-0.0799685866,
-0.5621436238,
0.2582925558,
-0.1854193211,
0.1178073511,
0.1625119448,
-0.4691469967,
0.6630089283,
-0.1488632858,
-0.1724083126,
0.1500172168,
0.8795424104,
0.3789050579,
-0.1046801209,
0.309595108,
0.3574382961,
-0.1795035303,
-0.4035536945,
-0.2971460223,
-0.2390165776,
-0.4795130491,
0.525996089,
-0.4746836424,
-0.6427346468,
0.6043101549,
-0.1490837336,
-0.1755926907,
0.3320978582,
0.4123029709,
-0.4190795124,
0.5560357571,
0.6611871123,
-0.4064953923,
0.7214244604,
-0.5456833839,
-0.03294589,
-0.7689497471,
-0.1494594663,
-0.8145266175,
-0.0552416109,
-0.3875707388,
-0.5253559351,
0.4622001052,
-0.2282868624,
0.0366940983,
0.656803906,
-0.2382777929,
0.4931356609,
0.7796688676,
-0.0194200128,
-0.1667551845,
0.3913805485,
-0.7597682476,
-0.2964088321,
-0.9880983233,
-0.2969322503,
0.884321928,
0.2511105835,
0.1597383916,
0.2966069877,
0.8541395664,
0.3230123222,
-0.1188440993,
-0.9850611091,
0.4883198738,
-0.4916316271,
-0.2316672802,
-0.5036546588,
-0.2815520167,
-0.8962389231,
0.1590869725,
-0.0548337623,
-0.8786604404,
0.1565733552,
-0.1789202094,
-0.5212852955,
0.2822840512,
-0.4981206059,
0.4081606269,
-0.1469499916,
-0.0814310312,
-0.4053920507,
-0.6173942089,
-0.0968734026,
0.0826721638,
0.7887259722,
0.1395522952,
0.0553513728,
0.6036682725,
-0.4587160051,
0.5662969351,
-0.0184737481,
-0.2139955163,
0.1551048309,
0.3699228168,
-0.1194218248,
-0.3350054622,
-0.312612474,
0.4443262219,
0.1618783474,
-0.1941667199,
-0.656811595,
0.7852766514,
-0.8039132357,
-0.3075849414,
-0.4661289155,
-0.5147008896,
-0.2713962197,
0.2276768982,
0.2178646326,
0.9065223932,
-0.1425531805,
0.0363284089,
0.5128648281,
-0.1689448506,
0.6441737413,
0.0722920001,
-0.1577981114,
-0.3761239052,
0.9437910318,
0.2397131175,
0.2671787441,
0.4629671574,
0.2998594046,
-0.5002080202,
-0.5882300735,
-0.341430366,
0.3283171952,
-0.9187247753,
0.0103576751,
-0.2708796263,
-0.3161982894,
-0.4776830673,
0.0131908897,
-0.3439128101,
-0.6021464467,
-0.13247931,
-0.237655282,
0.2514828146,
0.8761914968,
-0.7422944307,
0.337318778,
-0.8424234986,
0.2041882277,
0.2913420498,
0.061498113,
-0.0900076181,
-0.7643229961,
-0.4800664783,
0.1017245501,
0.0987192541,
-1.0768741369,
0.5540091991,
0.7649860382,
0.6673602462,
0.4680231214,
-0.3883627653,
0.6219808459,
-0.822996974,
1.0832173824,
0.3188542128,
-0.931851387,
0.3569635451,
-0.3231495321,
0.2731849551,
0.3078118265,
0.2244196832,
-0.7618887424,
-0.6179645061,
-0.4749232531,
-0.8377500772,
0.4476810098,
0.2491752654,
0.3815283775,
-0.0516071618,
0.0884065554,
-0.0764035061,
0.0803552866,
-0.4471607804,
-0.5312882662,
-0.4587182999,
-0.0878008455,
-0.167461291,
-0.010975684,
-0.268800199,
-0.128085494,
0.1157152206,
0.0076238988,
0.7053948641,
0.1087734997,
-0.1353631318,
0.1590339988,
0.1194463894,
0.5205541253,
0.2911787927,
-0.1481764019,
0.6370730996,
0.1031735465,
-0.6397925615,
0.0140602812,
0.0463958532,
0.1925438046,
0.5316841602,
0.6637209654,
0.3221440315,
0.2239183784,
-0.4937430918,
0.5271838903,
0.0797982067,
-0.0382407047,
-0.6543433666,
-0.1190725192,
0.4729136229,
0.2195560336,
0.2558559477,
0.2455417216,
0.3659101129,
-0.6836043,
0.5583493114,
0.2452017665,
-0.4395661354,
-0.3440542817,
0.4527858198,
0.089081876,
-0.2897409499,
0.6308985949,
0.0775189027,
-0.3714229763,
0.7078732848,
0.2911648154,
0.6645975113,
-0.321074754,
0.0295366347,
0.4375611544,
-0.029309839,
0.2797536254,
0.1119040176,
-0.3845759034,
-0.7954693437,
-0.4781894088,
-0.6034716368,
-0.1579310447,
0.0928134769,
-0.6271021962,
0.054372251,
-0.2942429781,
-0.480140835,
0.5150552392,
-0.3926929832,
-0.6296811104,
-0.0854388028,
0.7326953411,
1.0947799683,
-0.8362218738,
1.0011285543,
0.4841715991,
-0.308172226,
-1.0467166901,
0.007037661,
0.230050981,
-0.4883447886,
0.8937151432,
-0.1000116169,
-0.4751308858,
-0.3760194778,
-0.4429236352,
-1.0000281334,
0.6767470837,
0.6931254864,
-0.7975705862,
0.1366082728,
0.4982016385,
0.5144458413,
-0.421246171,
0.5476528406,
0.6467046738,
0.2421865612,
-0.034412317,
-1.1836720705,
-0.2492211908,
-0.487534821,
-0.2091751397,
-0.1060836166,
-0.3557628989,
0.9982889891,
-0.0551915318,
-0.0145045826,
-0.0005366267,
0.6397148371,
0.1498875171,
-0.0615479462,
0.6628632545,
0.2848488688,
0.7586489916,
-0.1677056253,
0.9168946147,
-0.3557269871,
0.016762279,
1.2271718979,
0.0340024196,
0.8994755745,
0.6831952333,
-0.2144917995,
0.7099167109,
0.5538149476,
0.0824936926,
0.9071187973,
0.2369960845,
-0.4864233732,
-0.0213297792,
-0.3067831695,
-0.3060795665,
0.5309290886,
0.6937984228,
-0.3636314869,
-0.0873442963,
-0.1152317896,
-0.0798980519,
0.2626307905,
-0.3236910105,
0.7646645308,
0.4021226466,
-0.4786193073,
0.6075932384,
-0.214464277,
0.5938965082,
-0.8317955732,
-0.2034361064,
-0.2478482723,
-0.2518123388,
-0.2289486825,
-0.8094736934,
0.3521626592,
-0.1803208292,
-0.1123735756,
-0.2861441374,
0.5205155015,
-0.6260576844,
-0.2021015584,
0.6043030024,
0.341370225,
0.5144001245,
0.1862060726,
-0.3766610622,
-0.0228894465,
-0.1644002795,
-0.0328824371,
0.2066870779,
0.7389014959,
0.2417771518,
0.3333488405,
0.4045061469,
0.8209116459,
0.4145864844,
0.4533265829,
0.7987120152,
-0.6568591595,
-0.7461484075,
-0.6345009208,
0.2187522352,
-0.1388367414,
-0.0397467017,
0.6471108198,
0.4609122276,
0.8662000895,
-0.1579376608,
1.1292612553,
-0.2106821984,
0.4139662385,
-0.5617774725,
0.5087655783,
-0.5027161837,
0.1628687978,
-0.3916927278,
-0.7702543736,
-0.1413612366,
0.8429808617,
-0.0505854934,
-0.2433873117,
0.665702939,
0.9575581551,
-0.3340933919,
-0.0696809441,
0.510093987,
0.3462370634,
-0.0943220109,
0.2362385392,
0.9410808086,
-0.0043280525,
0.6080682278,
-0.3979895413,
-0.0412575305,
0.1716437489,
-0.8180724382,
-0.6099765897,
-0.8853113651,
0.0468499064,
-0.3005073071,
-0.1588330865,
0.9917914271,
0.9784424901,
-0.8231602907,
-0.708553195,
0.3284815252,
-0.052969221,
-0.4505208731,
-0.162738055,
0.4254906178,
-0.2821512222,
-0.7432544231,
0.7589099407,
0.0926461816,
-0.0420475006,
-0.4216362238,
-0.1156663373,
0.00506048,
0.13465029,
0.6634002328,
0.1927296072,
-0.4951577783,
-0.2410071045,
0.1535567343,
-0.0172612891,
0.3820457458,
0.9742337465,
-0.5882586837,
0.3185616136,
0.3988184035,
0.1932014972,
0.4672688842,
-0.466365099,
0.7923293114,
-1.1734981537,
0.4267624617,
0.1865573972,
0.5645619631,
0.4976051748,
-0.1401983947,
0.2044548392,
-0.0365889519,
-0.2578766942,
-0.6840199232,
0.3464611173,
-1.1158559322,
-0.2503359616,
1.2546197176,
-0.1365212351,
-0.3783458769,
-0.1680635214,
-0.2410213947,
0.2136164457,
-0.6212306619,
0.6546778679,
0.745360136,
-0.1066895127,
-0.2375457287,
-0.6321517825,
0.6864402294,
0.2038600296,
-0.1892576367,
0.0013577007,
0.5622843504,
0.4077842236,
0.7418480515,
0.5797682405,
-0.1204037815,
0.1549580097,
0.2788828611,
-0.1852633357,
-0.0427107066,
-0.3256166577,
-0.6201007366,
0.3532914519,
0.0975738615,
-0.1478520334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18599v1 | Improving Generalization for Multimodal Fake News Detection | 2023-05-29T20:32:22 | 2023-05-29T20:32:22 | Sahar Tahmasebi, Sherzod Hakimov, Ralph Ewerth, Eric Müller-Budack | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.MM | The increasing proliferation of misinformation and its alarming impact have
motivated both industry and academia to develop approaches for fake news
detection. However, state-of-the-art approaches are usually trained on datasets
of smaller size or with a limited set of specific topics. As a consequence,
these models lack generalization capabilities and are not applicable to
real-world data. In this paper, we propose three models that adopt and
fine-tune state-of-the-art multimodal transformers for multimodal fake news
detection. We conduct an in-depth analysis by manipulating the input data aimed
to explore models performance in realistic use cases on social media. Our study
across multiple models demonstrates that these systems suffer significant
performance drops against manipulated data. To reduce the bias and improve
model generalization, we suggest training data augmentation to conduct more
meaningful experiments for fake news detection on social media. The proposed
data augmentation techniques enable models to generalize better and yield
improved state-of-the-art results. | [
-0.4784383774,
-0.9880008698,
0.4621530473,
0.1612081975,
-0.3445591927,
0.1006079391,
-0.0660343915,
-0.5243729353,
0.3190190196,
0.1945070624,
-0.5009774566,
-0.2021737695,
-0.6529982686,
-0.0531106628,
-0.6086239815,
0.7944613099,
0.0997203216,
0.1438928694,
-0.2448915839,
-0.2664323747,
-0.3656142652,
-0.3195894063,
-0.2181900889,
0.0354330242,
0.4987246692,
0.3635484576,
0.7686821818,
0.3644782305,
0.2640324235,
0.3039635718,
0.2451097369,
0.7603659034,
-0.4075284004,
-0.2097053379,
-0.170404613,
-0.4194974303,
-0.334305793,
0.2117918879,
0.5679680705,
0.0999066308,
0.207903415,
0.1951136142,
-0.5242331028,
0.1568536162,
-0.6630212665,
0.0068025356,
-0.6704498529,
-0.1610937715,
-0.0016935628,
-0.259444952,
-0.4627114534,
-0.2582276464,
-0.1950327307,
-0.7048330307,
0.579747498,
0.0757690966,
0.832038939,
-0.0376475379,
-0.7838167548,
-0.0758958161,
-1.0813564062,
0.7329900265,
-0.6779358983,
0.6008544564,
0.1110890806,
0.5852555037,
0.0182856079,
-0.6814578176,
-0.9349470735,
-0.2585508227,
-0.1348809302,
-0.0362266116,
-0.4216162264,
-0.0310672764,
0.2696809173,
0.3498460054,
-0.5978204608,
-0.0391156189,
-0.5638625026,
-0.4588035643,
0.4897147417,
-0.1053729281,
0.40541327,
-0.208451122,
-0.3535580933,
-0.3535403311,
-0.1613897532,
-0.1060298011,
0.6494545341,
0.1891506612,
-0.1124963462,
0.3197595477,
-0.4467719793,
0.662173152,
0.1184825078,
-0.3004450798,
0.6144610643,
-0.6696343422,
-0.0731883347,
-0.3851438165,
0.3729064763,
0.6028079987,
0.233612895,
-0.0750927106,
-0.331110388,
0.5568417311,
0.6388930082,
-0.5751695037,
-0.1392185539,
0.052456215,
-0.606379807,
-0.4375356138,
0.2676285803,
-0.6855407357,
-0.2420711666,
-0.6260271668,
0.6799915433,
-0.4587492943,
-0.4997990429,
0.0767084956,
-0.5644158721,
-0.1166594103,
0.3827275038,
-0.4658952057,
-0.2053811699,
0.4053392708,
0.6117892265,
0.1132030189,
0.0658531636,
-0.5093634725,
0.1453331709,
-0.2938636541,
0.9274208546,
-0.8723098636,
0.1050794274,
0.0325282849,
0.1517483592,
-0.0647700951,
-0.4322618246,
0.7859557271,
-0.6325452924,
0.3287706077,
-0.0304357167,
-0.3594729304,
-0.3374690711,
0.4498540461,
-0.7870461941,
0.68937397,
0.0688521117,
-0.6369608045,
0.7377050519,
-0.6609490514,
-0.4562571645,
-0.2493105531,
0.2126796991,
-0.6565959454,
0.424205035,
0.7881982327,
0.4978407025,
0.3477533758,
0.2889138162,
-0.5692298412,
-0.4027476609,
0.0755089819,
-0.76930058,
0.2513087094,
0.2892035544,
0.0194960311,
0.2061589211,
-0.8325384855,
-0.2403408438,
-0.1570976228,
-0.2191592008,
-0.4846253097,
-0.1793428063,
0.3823016584,
0.2796664238,
-0.1140466556,
-0.6617062092,
0.2256138176,
-0.0266249869,
0.2822719812,
0.5891316533,
-0.0864017084,
0.5704647899,
-0.4770009518,
0.3126499355,
0.5391139388,
0.4110023081,
-0.3557187319,
-0.2724107504,
-0.7334218621,
-0.3532244265,
0.3638991117,
0.2456531674,
-1.2530531883,
-0.0535508431,
-0.4547588527,
-0.3781255186,
-0.6750730276,
0.1089073569,
-0.0284114163,
0.1871601194,
0.663105607,
0.064524956,
-0.6301583648,
-1.1955453157,
-0.8289566636,
0.2218300402,
-0.0893553197,
-0.1701960415,
0.4774987698,
-0.4798243344,
0.9519310594,
-0.103947185,
-0.2547785342,
-0.1605808884,
0.170748651,
0.0776826367,
0.3740497828,
0.6704596281,
-1.418743968,
-0.3968040347,
-0.10192734,
-0.5550103784,
0.1811090112,
-0.2851177454,
0.3439216316,
0.2016127259,
0.3756297231,
-0.6388084292,
0.5895394087,
0.5736875534,
-0.0921220928,
0.4823103845,
0.0273937546,
0.5347632766,
-1.0346113443,
-0.3515992761,
0.470163703,
-0.6174712777,
-1.060603857,
0.1027786359,
0.5824738145,
-0.1004383489,
-0.4413456321,
0.4200826287,
-0.3567529917,
0.1139114946,
-0.4149358869,
-0.1981427222,
0.1592371017,
0.1867414564,
-0.1646218151,
0.5092816353,
0.3126251101,
-0.5608066916,
0.7333352566,
-0.2753693759,
-0.2417446226,
0.5106666088,
-0.4502409399,
-0.1044587791,
-0.5168074965,
0.70288378,
-1.113458395,
-0.6744189858,
0.3606916666,
-0.6953161359,
0.1600290537,
-0.1485779881,
-0.9270412922,
-0.5236110687,
-0.4464219213,
0.3416572213,
0.1046660542,
-0.6895768642,
0.8988162279,
0.0478759818,
0.3751993775,
-0.3780784011,
-0.6290075779,
-0.0796588287,
-0.1720831245,
-0.980329752,
0.4703335762,
0.0688391998,
-0.097664088,
-0.0741467774,
-0.2799961269,
-0.1367073357,
-0.3613153994,
0.0115467487,
0.1121193841,
-0.1508983523,
0.5271184444,
0.3711742461,
0.0934288502,
-0.3168225288,
0.0435929373,
0.3868895173,
-0.0313183703,
-0.4055356383,
-0.8658991456,
0.1851392537,
0.8440780044,
-0.1033248752,
0.7713425159,
1.2679058313,
-0.5398077369,
-0.1777009964,
-1.0445187092,
-0.5195432305,
-0.4836369455,
0.336643666,
-0.1414364725,
-0.6077910066,
0.1497859359,
-0.1034328938,
-0.0481894277,
0.2968931794,
0.3349096477,
0.0907902494,
1.3318529129,
0.71516186,
-0.0477874167,
0.5373795629,
-0.1643006355,
0.4007912576,
-0.2575130165,
-0.185456261,
0.0306163765,
-0.4339534938,
-0.430003047,
-0.6483640671,
0.4948884547,
-0.2132440507,
0.5022963881,
0.3307139575,
-0.3759045303,
0.3853116333,
0.4308562279,
0.4165216684,
0.5115615726,
0.5126050711,
0.331371963,
0.0039102663,
-0.6349615455,
-0.3181628585,
1.0983020067,
0.5454068184,
0.7400594354,
0.0745513067,
-0.0586633384,
0.6612478495,
0.4186128974,
-0.3146174252,
0.140065819,
-0.1962309182,
-0.8643302917,
-0.0713385344,
-0.460354805,
-0.5603148341,
0.5963295102,
-0.3709445894,
-0.045781076,
0.3207095861,
0.2903102338,
-0.2322638482,
0.4092975557,
-0.9712000489,
0.4664053023,
-0.0139460415,
-0.0534846149,
-0.6311249733,
-0.3599559963,
0.7034514546,
-0.1237440482,
0.5409138203,
0.0221806783,
0.0527336076,
0.1829802245,
0.0355237797,
0.9984877706,
-0.2251105458,
0.0836460441,
-0.0629546344,
-0.33426705,
0.5672610998,
0.2533597648,
0.2741988897,
0.0367247127,
-0.3490647376,
-0.5022492409,
-0.4678550065,
0.7352728844,
-0.5790740252,
-0.2545338869,
-0.1707896441,
-0.9017196298,
-0.3517458439,
-0.1921758503,
0.2303445488,
0.5515261292,
-0.0538768508,
0.3012214899,
0.5523591042,
-0.2074621469,
0.4014495015,
0.5080648661,
-0.1621339172,
-0.2160397917,
1.0453757048,
0.2591336966,
0.0843896717,
0.095200628,
-0.0702171326,
-0.5296558142,
-0.2218581885,
-0.6031515598,
0.1552869827,
-0.5823431611,
-0.1141238138,
-0.8336039782,
-0.1368531883,
-0.9997153282,
0.1461936384,
-0.1952818036,
-0.4391172826,
-0.4117892087,
-0.1289890707,
0.3056586385,
0.442540139,
-0.2369254082,
0.5910180211,
-0.7711206079,
1.0023773909,
0.4204634428,
0.1669564247,
-0.1610306203,
-0.6983048916,
-0.222982496,
0.5340975523,
-0.4997397661,
-0.7012704015,
0.4275927246,
0.1338821203,
0.6728246808,
0.6493290663,
-0.0817394927,
0.7100405097,
-0.0513175093,
0.414849937,
0.2033403963,
-0.6328575015,
0.4897820354,
-0.5499753952,
0.118190363,
0.0789030865,
0.6466265917,
-0.4848024845,
-0.281852752,
-0.4696558416,
-0.515394628,
0.5846631527,
0.2379584014,
0.6102063656,
0.2107313871,
0.0530319288,
0.1824189574,
0.3406261206,
-1.0804671049,
-0.0525858812,
-0.4602675736,
-0.0256058946,
-0.0116033722,
-0.1560280472,
0.1252330244,
-0.4921967089,
0.63592875,
-0.036194928,
-0.0266945586,
-0.0180907939,
-0.5227401257,
-0.0402891412,
0.1474756151,
0.8532610536,
0.8228504658,
-0.031351205,
-0.0011748887,
0.0221392568,
-0.2785430849,
0.0966709182,
0.057923492,
-0.1825944632,
0.4571539462,
0.3683608174,
0.752725482,
-0.0482963659,
-0.4862292707,
0.687998116,
0.0800125226,
-0.2154246569,
-0.3599719703,
0.1124859899,
-0.121719189,
0.3354525566,
0.6548936963,
0.6432588696,
0.2881572843,
-0.810867548,
0.2032416314,
0.3645513654,
-0.319329381,
-0.4920519888,
0.5142672062,
0.2590694726,
-0.0312173162,
0.3128631413,
-0.0732372031,
-0.5665989518,
0.5342577696,
0.4692531228,
0.2909324467,
-0.3562864661,
0.4976902008,
0.0984365195,
0.6650742888,
-0.236781314,
-0.0225477517,
0.296186775,
-0.9119838476,
-0.5202225447,
-0.4648293853,
-0.008879045,
0.6155167222,
-0.3065800667,
0.4262348413,
-0.2619587183,
-0.4062601328,
0.0885654986,
-0.4320943952,
-0.5973632932,
0.2756074369,
0.2613694072,
0.7612460852,
-1.0936920643,
0.5886879563,
0.7400658131,
-0.2816265523,
-0.1874561459,
0.0897506028,
0.1737864465,
-0.4378843904,
0.4285400808,
0.4186609089,
0.2827242613,
-0.2434349358,
-0.7134138942,
-0.5922863483,
0.7649334669,
0.3583087623,
-0.6125272512,
-0.012325448,
0.3630063236,
0.4940541983,
-0.4442380071,
0.2771929801,
0.2865769565,
0.7826659083,
-0.2087237686,
-0.7344083786,
-0.2518407106,
-0.099854514,
0.1169673949,
0.0984464809,
-0.6532894969,
1.0135792494,
0.1338804662,
-0.1738359332,
-0.3678294122,
0.7329283953,
0.0625294223,
0.8594651818,
0.6382027268,
0.7646958232,
0.3534580171,
-0.0173984747,
0.9902976155,
0.1070251614,
0.3167124689,
0.6685277224,
0.0876359493,
0.3200432658,
0.3298702836,
0.1683090627,
0.4541533887,
0.5679286718,
-0.323548466,
0.4053747356,
0.0313832536,
-0.3365956545,
-0.6165917516,
-0.0712383017,
-0.3866605461,
0.4372108579,
0.4847475886,
-0.587357223,
-0.3982416391,
0.6531158686,
-0.0512669198,
0.1091642231,
-0.4682980776,
0.2010194063,
-0.3455206156,
-0.2356704623,
0.3815353513,
0.3186202049,
1.1035200357,
-0.3922512531,
-0.1192436591,
-0.1376793534,
0.2473955601,
-0.3002213538,
-0.1119679287,
0.3101859391,
-0.2203607708,
-0.4977866411,
-0.0653233603,
1.2591843605,
-0.4216868877,
-0.7312307954,
0.2167148292,
0.5236592889,
-0.1133727655,
-0.5657473803,
-0.3760452867,
0.2011401057,
0.0401396789,
-0.1368281692,
0.2023671418,
0.1500477493,
-0.2971265316,
0.7454032302,
1.1229264736,
-0.2305838764,
0.370862633,
0.063124828,
1.0753313303,
-0.2184581906,
-0.3648203909,
-0.6161540151,
0.4535416663,
-0.5964532495,
-0.2037954777,
0.8490772247,
0.5048128963,
1.0123534203,
-0.4439317584,
0.8386223912,
0.1380927414,
0.8279288411,
-0.3493017852,
0.679826498,
-0.8195924163,
0.1341817975,
-0.0947427452,
-0.990868926,
-0.2460887283,
0.2892814279,
-0.1354964525,
0.1911390126,
0.2782133222,
1.0150270462,
-0.7016556859,
0.0485011265,
0.5750299096,
0.2180556655,
0.2976878583,
-0.0488059856,
1.0363851786,
-0.6065636277,
0.6866710186,
-0.3639799356,
-0.1481697112,
-0.5926421881,
-0.5033745766,
-0.9683047533,
-0.4244221449,
-0.214917779,
-0.1061984077,
0.1673869789,
0.5257238746,
1.1678647995,
-0.6482648253,
0.4017544687,
0.2327373922,
0.042889528,
-0.1633046716,
-0.3414834142,
0.0021549719,
-0.3480110466,
-0.8226755857,
0.5975775719,
0.0090463338,
0.0384839475,
-0.2846059203,
0.2662483752,
-0.310881108,
0.3806891739,
0.853433013,
-0.0790601075,
-0.7685604095,
-0.4806295931,
0.0102772843,
0.1218919456,
-0.103389442,
0.8237270117,
-0.8895106316,
0.4676285386,
0.5100135207,
0.3495298624,
0.4541473985,
0.4448490143,
0.335811168,
-1.0481654406,
0.2485840619,
0.0372801349,
0.128912732,
0.275713414,
-0.315628618,
0.2586329579,
0.6289637089,
-0.2527322173,
-0.9189014435,
0.1830713004,
-0.6819050908,
-0.5106086731,
1.0417211056,
0.3586438,
0.0494739525,
-0.4480312765,
-0.1013616398,
0.2292683274,
-0.6587797999,
0.7619267702,
0.6617162824,
0.1042579561,
-0.209264949,
-0.7504208088,
0.2304640412,
0.2003082931,
-0.6946035624,
-0.3665961623,
0.8003330827,
0.4561805427,
0.3848020434,
0.2164808661,
0.0724365488,
0.471050024,
-0.0039647901,
0.0250686575,
-0.2578891814,
-0.6312553883,
-0.2375529408,
0.1466948241,
-0.8226433396,
-0.2884553671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18598v1 | A Method for Studying Semantic Construal in Grammatical Constructions with Interpretable Contextual Embedding Spaces | 2023-05-29T20:30:38 | 2023-05-29T20:30:38 | Gabriella Chronis, Kyle Mahowald, Katrin Erk | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study semantic construal in grammatical constructions using large language
models. First, we project contextual word embeddings into three interpretable
semantic spaces, each defined by a different set of psycholinguistic feature
norms. We validate these interpretable spaces and then use them to
automatically derive semantic characterizations of lexical items in two
grammatical constructions: nouns in subject or object position within the same
sentence, and the AANN construction (e.g., `a beautiful three days'). We show
that a word in subject position is interpreted as more agentive than the very
same word in object position, and that the nouns in the AANN construction are
interpreted as more measurement-like than when in the canonical alternation.
Our method can probe the distributional meaning of syntactic constructions at a
templatic level, abstracted away from specific lexemes. | [
-0.2696449757,
-1.3198900223,
0.6311607361,
0.1665421724,
-0.3629618585,
-0.4912884235,
-0.3756481111,
-0.3842054605,
0.3164498508,
0.3145153522,
-0.4303246439,
-0.4510829449,
-0.4225641489,
0.2137668282,
-0.3322467506,
0.5414784551,
-0.153050229,
0.1064117104,
-0.1250312328,
-0.233986035,
-0.4992330968,
-0.5588495731,
-0.1326788366,
0.1892157048,
0.3880016208,
0.0336571522,
1.0957473516,
0.8490513563,
0.4488652945,
0.3316109478,
-0.1605212837,
-0.0059074806,
0.1224689707,
0.2685935497,
-0.2510332167,
-0.4070783257,
-0.2134385705,
0.1873048097,
0.8049383759,
1.0995634794,
-0.0768803805,
-0.0192365162,
0.1491703391,
0.2374168634,
-0.7571191788,
0.5544614792,
-0.4887806475,
0.1922836751,
-0.2853099108,
-0.1197920069,
-0.4047738016,
-0.2447617352,
0.1253090501,
-0.5588138103,
0.17406708,
-0.0634521842,
0.7714878917,
0.0949418023,
-0.6747088432,
-0.376470536,
-0.3314638436,
0.6022304296,
-0.6126415133,
0.7778837681,
0.4146771431,
0.2095424235,
-0.2346402407,
-0.5349633694,
-0.8639900088,
-0.4437769055,
-0.4575464725,
-0.0621892437,
-0.1969680041,
0.1034990475,
0.0160163566,
0.2593538165,
-0.5432606936,
-0.1024375632,
-0.1480515599,
-0.0317114256,
0.6900503039,
0.0423266552,
0.4153409004,
-0.6058359146,
-0.2199200094,
-0.1587926149,
-0.5896567702,
-0.4167745709,
0.3571414948,
0.5377742648,
0.0094288858,
0.7689517736,
0.0305634383,
0.8308898807,
-0.3579190075,
0.1934402287,
0.2913183868,
-0.426392287,
-0.3235474825,
-0.0260722209,
0.4123378694,
0.4041027427,
0.2078071535,
-0.1007648185,
0.1869211048,
0.3212160468,
0.4112542868,
-0.4421938062,
-0.1498630047,
0.0033682229,
-0.4502561092,
-0.0970880836,
0.1426424533,
-0.1392153054,
-0.1406821012,
-0.4606927633,
0.076434426,
-0.6366139054,
-0.3289752603,
0.2729929388,
-0.1735142022,
0.4748306274,
0.1178024039,
-0.842617929,
0.3486740291,
0.9228321314,
0.7589589953,
-0.0425321907,
-0.5990574956,
-0.1160748601,
0.2538194656,
-0.4618600607,
0.6133137941,
-0.5616442561,
-0.1258379221,
0.4085772634,
0.2842516005,
-0.1893847436,
-0.356003046,
0.2734992504,
-0.4848002493,
0.0383195095,
0.1264598668,
-0.906869173,
-0.3941405416,
0.5816342235,
-0.6824411154,
0.4953731894,
0.0957912579,
-0.3791408837,
0.3167925775,
-0.607801199,
-0.4244056344,
0.0465345979,
-0.2423871905,
0.0156252272,
0.463509649,
-0.2384592742,
0.7805055976,
0.309779644,
0.1986947954,
-0.3155072629,
0.1869027317,
0.5925693512,
-0.0778979287,
0.6731898189,
0.2688843608,
-0.3536904156,
-0.173226431,
-0.7031546831,
0.091357626,
-0.0284137558,
-0.2321527451,
-0.626059413,
0.2325341254,
0.403018862,
0.0843943581,
0.0861181095,
-0.7470688224,
-0.0358954556,
-0.6285799742,
0.5322422981,
0.3393615186,
0.0262409449,
0.5436802506,
0.1560801268,
0.3084836006,
-0.080310978,
0.0150156282,
0.2540421486,
-0.1843264699,
-0.6679419875,
-0.0580254458,
0.0391979106,
0.2932101488,
-0.4382978082,
0.4986596107,
-0.1467918903,
-0.1141369939,
-0.0931216627,
0.0733897462,
0.5646643639,
-0.0382776968,
0.2079828531,
0.0436278433,
-0.5353162289,
-1.0894585848,
-0.1050504223,
-0.2747132182,
0.2750509381,
0.2082947046,
0.6320579648,
0.0025839058,
0.5599655509,
-0.6509717107,
-0.3071987629,
-0.2193221599,
-0.1874740869,
-0.0008742465,
0.4629502892,
0.6428054571,
-0.8277717829,
-0.2379689515,
-0.0172367245,
-0.771114409,
0.3126795888,
0.1142708734,
-0.2905983329,
0.2220033705,
0.8382303119,
-0.7063827515,
0.2693615854,
0.3395525515,
-0.9476134181,
0.2801623642,
0.0319249034,
-0.3785685003,
-1.0128662586,
-0.2705655992,
-0.3430871069,
-0.3044213355,
-0.6624404192,
0.7934505939,
0.071351707,
0.135524407,
-0.6989011765,
0.5659193397,
-0.4896943271,
-0.0363654494,
-0.2075080425,
0.3298895955,
0.1675338745,
0.4157471061,
0.1694367677,
0.1628597677,
0.0727207959,
-0.4179214835,
0.1675467044,
0.4136602283,
-0.4579868019,
0.6579546928,
-0.4020381272,
-0.1565633714,
-0.2613607347,
0.2980594933,
-1.0016418695,
-0.3778649271,
0.1838696599,
-0.3426591754,
-0.0883544758,
0.3149270415,
-0.5100264549,
0.103476122,
-0.0066157463,
0.5438121557,
-0.0560081154,
-0.2644867003,
0.3413798809,
0.1914597005,
0.0319403969,
-0.164221853,
-0.8492292762,
-0.1531147361,
-0.2962132692,
-0.5666747689,
0.2606787086,
0.2178147286,
-0.7920305133,
0.2768363655,
0.0993796214,
-0.1067399234,
0.4750235677,
0.251624912,
0.2819958627,
-0.3428061903,
0.3549769223,
-0.1280104369,
0.2574940026,
0.2176892012,
-0.3117754459,
0.5585276484,
-0.3172352314,
-0.215274021,
-0.2935032248,
0.6805872917,
0.3179663718,
-0.040416386,
0.7835956812,
0.3702270687,
-0.8189351559,
-0.1336273551,
-0.4302632809,
0.1438151002,
-0.3364641666,
0.3370564282,
-0.7110543847,
-0.8910531402,
0.4201978147,
0.6329057217,
-0.087897338,
0.6035903096,
0.4819208682,
-0.154619351,
0.7769249082,
0.5430784822,
0.4536410272,
0.4990607202,
-0.3047495782,
0.1543956101,
-0.8492463827,
-0.3663010001,
-0.3541051745,
-0.3017574549,
-0.6205192208,
-0.4094992876,
0.1982129067,
0.0237920545,
-0.4029563367,
0.5062865615,
-0.1929153204,
0.4693572819,
0.2070765048,
0.1684353799,
0.1385206282,
-0.3024854362,
-0.2034099847,
-0.1175285876,
-0.1615945399,
-0.5521644354,
0.7203446031,
0.2587910295,
0.3036718667,
0.5207208991,
0.4535443187,
-0.0652229264,
0.0674791932,
-1.0730513334,
0.3486115932,
-0.2837437987,
-0.6890919209,
-0.259260565,
0.0126649607,
-0.9571273923,
0.4416986108,
0.0047499621,
-0.7280089259,
0.4735979438,
-0.1018255427,
-0.3858062029,
-0.0446854122,
-0.6868736148,
1.0498762131,
-0.0469767153,
-0.1466752887,
-0.2827101648,
-0.4999646246,
0.1165969148,
0.4358578026,
0.2068151236,
-0.1278162897,
-0.3270986676,
0.379343152,
-0.6336481571,
0.8979465365,
-0.1572839767,
-0.2631519139,
0.1703969538,
0.5302399397,
0.2474922687,
0.0267107114,
-0.0541445166,
-0.0103632482,
0.2053742558,
-0.3806800544,
-0.9631000757,
0.3902288079,
-0.5983662605,
-0.3023272157,
-0.3320955336,
-0.7397170067,
-0.2709273994,
0.1106290072,
0.1086018682,
0.7168928981,
-0.5000345111,
0.2560902536,
0.0356563032,
0.2010547966,
0.4470179677,
0.3212914467,
0.0515016392,
0.0431695096,
0.4287766218,
0.096536696,
0.355196476,
0.650870502,
0.3078579903,
-0.4055544138,
-0.3811127245,
0.006195398,
0.1164309382,
-0.732442677,
-0.0539186969,
-0.7273735404,
-0.20992814,
-0.3622141182,
-0.4038912356,
-0.4117842317,
-0.7391725183,
-0.1236738116,
-0.3621391654,
0.38810426,
0.7661707401,
-0.0010653757,
0.3663893044,
-0.442527771,
-0.0288341884,
0.0777480453,
0.292306304,
-0.014185085,
-0.1741370261,
-0.0491414927,
-0.0258795861,
-0.103858754,
-0.7889384031,
0.40920344,
0.3133121431,
0.5253267288,
0.5111384392,
-0.354770124,
0.6870682836,
-0.6777189374,
0.8325490952,
0.0941318646,
-0.9975389838,
0.7564262748,
-0.4933024347,
0.1782710701,
0.4973591864,
0.1203422546,
-0.4630635679,
-0.5151513219,
-0.7213921547,
-0.749145329,
0.2435048074,
0.2241781056,
0.4445905983,
-0.6068689227,
0.5625013709,
0.0431652069,
0.101612322,
-0.7332009673,
-0.0461997986,
-0.2384632677,
-0.1374001354,
-0.4510938525,
-0.3502855003,
-0.159770295,
-0.0426736623,
0.2505756915,
-0.1208143458,
0.3495229185,
0.1938721091,
-0.4616756737,
0.4700801969,
0.3398409188,
0.4992545545,
0.66377455,
-0.1796449274,
0.658354342,
0.0328060649,
-0.4284170568,
0.1349313259,
0.0393459946,
0.1354160309,
0.2143232375,
0.7433846593,
0.7069983482,
0.5477308631,
-0.3026565909,
0.720531702,
0.142230764,
-0.085598655,
-0.7291362882,
-0.1939688623,
-0.1058565155,
0.4185833037,
-0.2647631466,
-0.4281707704,
0.4454685152,
-1.0882649422,
0.0607583933,
0.4764660597,
-0.5827078223,
-0.4181282818,
0.2272481322,
-0.2458258569,
-0.1312730014,
0.6171531081,
-0.3492667377,
-0.4571774006,
0.5676375628,
0.7863089442,
0.9063526392,
-0.086168386,
0.2311580479,
0.3255147338,
-0.0503214858,
-0.0309734084,
0.3992083669,
-0.1832682639,
-1.1269272566,
-0.1480222642,
-0.740309298,
-0.104020752,
-0.0755961537,
-0.8186824918,
0.1415698677,
-0.2680782676,
0.1227581799,
0.3518795669,
-0.2200367898,
-0.6792038679,
0.0114221852,
0.2236978859,
0.7019885182,
-0.9593996406,
0.4532934427,
1.0650573969,
-0.3391795158,
-0.8776984215,
-0.133965686,
0.1178581417,
-0.6637112498,
0.6310594678,
0.1147494018,
-0.0357831344,
-0.2022374123,
-0.5899066329,
-0.9174196124,
0.8798690438,
0.2749847472,
-0.2193785608,
-0.2033180594,
0.0564550571,
0.6688402891,
-0.3763585687,
-0.022558989,
0.8048921227,
0.3958462775,
-0.18229644,
-0.6141531467,
0.3572880328,
-0.3803929985,
0.0992062315,
0.2250717133,
-0.3691105545,
0.7438267469,
0.2005521059,
-0.4160984755,
0.2802687585,
0.5680408478,
0.0795095116,
-0.1737093776,
0.6456939578,
0.5197039843,
0.5774266124,
0.0483870283,
1.2966713905,
-0.0656920224,
0.277659893,
1.0351039171,
0.0877113566,
1.1249719858,
0.7935993075,
0.0603646152,
0.5954386592,
0.4230834842,
0.0575896911,
0.5678278804,
0.5886166096,
-0.1531765759,
-0.306521982,
-0.401622951,
-0.2119580805,
0.9791760445,
0.595164299,
-0.2535170317,
-0.211319685,
0.3825747669,
0.3172861338,
0.2785484493,
-0.1184675768,
0.7044116855,
0.3362959325,
-0.6156394482,
0.3223513365,
-0.0212566666,
0.1642272025,
-0.2565643191,
-0.0975848734,
-0.1796319187,
0.401073724,
-0.2088441253,
-0.7658955455,
0.7143859863,
-0.3095469475,
0.0822243392,
-0.4184954166,
0.426027149,
-0.2861498594,
-0.621707499,
0.3182632923,
0.6379389763,
0.2754176259,
0.1808055639,
-0.1387985945,
0.0220033862,
-0.568852365,
-0.1980389208,
-0.0047015534,
0.608895421,
-0.202244848,
0.237474665,
0.2495598197,
0.1963709295,
-0.0201930013,
0.3340632617,
0.5372017026,
-0.7901062369,
-0.7625193,
-1.023816824,
0.4263623059,
0.245223552,
-0.4833525121,
0.7263703346,
0.4645197988,
0.9768432379,
0.0877044648,
0.2903473675,
-0.3318993151,
0.0528916828,
-0.6558283567,
0.4721111953,
-0.5066420436,
-0.1798491627,
-0.3994363546,
-1.0330762863,
-0.8036926985,
1.043035984,
-0.2405127585,
-0.5289747715,
0.9389740229,
0.5185136199,
-0.1944200993,
0.110143438,
0.1602512002,
0.3690106273,
0.0032858632,
0.3071211576,
1.2926360369,
-0.3010853529,
0.1107611731,
-0.2765482962,
0.0463711694,
-0.0494190305,
-0.6506586075,
-0.7410102487,
-0.8393611312,
-0.2107865065,
-0.3350304961,
0.0650883168,
0.9579385519,
0.4825331867,
-0.5969124436,
-0.2872292101,
-0.3171999454,
0.0589748509,
-0.3568250537,
-0.2559025586,
0.7317759991,
-0.4074562192,
-0.6983117461,
0.3811460137,
-0.0203303117,
-0.0658834055,
-0.390170306,
0.3061957955,
-0.4684889615,
-0.2108194679,
0.9160642624,
-0.2822660208,
-0.8855179548,
-0.9110532403,
0.1407612413,
-0.131323725,
-0.1028262526,
0.6903654933,
-0.2252687961,
0.3369238675,
0.5811828375,
0.3719162941,
0.3438250124,
-0.1435761899,
0.6935067773,
-0.8103422523,
0.3438680172,
0.0807720646,
0.5319821835,
0.17901209,
-0.3782136142,
0.6662905216,
0.0799693838,
0.0476920269,
-0.6933115125,
0.3861345053,
-0.9475285411,
-0.4544992745,
1.3149261475,
-0.0509929359,
-0.2163862288,
-0.0390379205,
0.1677568853,
0.2807454169,
0.0777783617,
0.4325128198,
0.9551805854,
-0.2919616401,
0.1551843882,
-0.7892019153,
0.3451026082,
0.2594109476,
-0.6634330153,
-0.1742443442,
0.7664698362,
0.1975849718,
0.3361333311,
0.2572447956,
-0.3644923866,
0.2920572758,
0.0872092694,
-0.0821628943,
0.05522383,
-0.388798058,
-0.4643708169,
0.1842053533,
-0.0207448099,
-0.4804419577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18596v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18596v1 | Building Accurate Low Latency ASR for Streaming Voice Search | 2023-05-29T20:24:14 | 2023-05-29T20:24:14 | Abhinav Goyal, Nikesh Garera | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) plays a crucial role in voice-based
applications. For applications requiring real-time feedback like Voice Search,
streaming capability becomes vital. While LSTM/RNN and CTC based ASR systems
are commonly employed for low-latency streaming applications, they often
exhibit lower accuracy compared to state-of-the-art models due to a lack of
future audio frames. In this work, we focus on developing accurate LSTM,
attention, and CTC based streaming ASR models for large-scale Hinglish (a blend
of Hindi and English) Voice Search. We investigate various modifications in
vanilla LSTM training which enhance the system's accuracy while preserving its
streaming capabilities. We also address the critical requirement of
end-of-speech (EOS) detection in streaming applications. We present a simple
training and inference strategy for end-to-end CTC models that enables joint
ASR and EOS detection. The evaluation of our model on Flipkart's Voice Search,
which handles substantial traffic of approximately 6 million queries per day,
demonstrates significant performance gains over the vanilla LSTM-CTC model. Our
model achieves a word error rate (WER) of 3.69% without EOS and 4.78% with EOS
while also reducing the search latency by approximately ~1300 ms (equivalent to
46.64% reduction) when compared to an independent voice activity detection
(VAD) model. | [
-0.2878928781,
-0.6320006847,
0.0834352896,
-0.0157600287,
-0.2980694175,
0.2853417993,
-0.4425839484,
-0.5822056532,
0.4358297288,
0.5782450438,
-0.5348835588,
-0.3522460759,
-0.5321729779,
0.1567212194,
-0.4556533694,
0.3589202166,
0.3138029277,
-0.0679259822,
0.2900320888,
-0.3296941817,
-0.3269697726,
-0.558896184,
-1.1852681637,
-0.1832216531,
0.4198763371,
0.3388148844,
0.4947506785,
0.4753894806,
0.2440780997,
0.2131724954,
-0.7051219344,
0.2123861164,
-0.6408631802,
0.3998838365,
0.1668835282,
-0.3049074709,
-0.2173093855,
-0.2236887068,
0.5248227119,
0.3605215251,
-0.4601015449,
0.2337381989,
0.0162013415,
0.6586176753,
-0.7834945321,
0.1353877187,
-0.6517189741,
0.1006967351,
-0.2563159466,
-0.2604937553,
-0.39936167,
-0.2682806551,
0.3553290963,
-0.4131097198,
0.3222307563,
-0.1326389462,
0.8267104626,
0.4863836467,
-0.2535585165,
-0.2951017022,
-0.9191073775,
0.5574055314,
-1.0959684849,
0.8587519526,
0.5084629059,
0.5596418977,
0.0005580671,
-0.4802734554,
-0.5924466848,
-0.2143946141,
0.1686282307,
0.2849283218,
0.0060735364,
0.1830542833,
0.1035331041,
0.3184343278,
-0.7555085421,
0.2955532968,
-0.3219710886,
-0.2023872435,
0.4568487406,
-0.1107477918,
-0.021690825,
-0.1201536804,
-0.1072252393,
0.0710313469,
-0.5852098465,
0.2433778346,
0.4576351643,
0.652479291,
-0.1037501395,
0.5938295722,
-0.3659011424,
0.8026199341,
0.2148760408,
-0.0825655386,
0.1039168015,
-0.1900416911,
-0.0692513287,
0.4579515159,
0.5047212243,
0.0425870121,
0.2208571732,
0.1257187426,
-0.3803110421,
0.063824378,
0.2502369881,
-0.6972897053,
-0.0635998622,
0.3158932626,
-0.4924627542,
-0.163067773,
-0.220473215,
-0.24874942,
-0.1584965587,
-0.2937259376,
0.5208410621,
-0.2901181579,
-0.2820961475,
0.0909669921,
0.2285679579,
0.4677608609,
0.2856673002,
-0.5765679479,
0.3712992668,
0.3902255893,
0.9878998995,
-0.3679791391,
-0.0194804091,
-1.0504282713,
0.1282340139,
-0.0758961588,
0.7181081772,
-0.4482713044,
-0.4255082011,
0.0589406267,
-0.0721576065,
-0.1112850532,
-0.5608372092,
0.7499604821,
-0.7604107857,
0.0022568498,
0.2642667294,
-0.6684888005,
-0.1677832007,
0.1574893892,
-0.7867540717,
1.0691171885,
-0.2729187012,
-0.4304069579,
0.0818826482,
-0.8680070043,
-0.6301708221,
0.2008408159,
0.0673379228,
-0.4398829937,
0.0989760533,
0.2975093722,
0.4213877022,
-0.2794032395,
-0.0028471448,
-0.1425615549,
-0.8372806907,
0.1226061881,
-0.4738090932,
0.607927978,
0.4171113372,
-0.3688143492,
-0.0382817984,
-0.6621025205,
0.2574989498,
-0.066537194,
-0.5270256996,
-0.0577139817,
0.3440054059,
0.4186333716,
-0.016145803,
0.0214122757,
-0.64963907,
-0.3080323339,
-0.6058029532,
0.5792063475,
0.3886743486,
-0.246769622,
0.1874461323,
0.0450327061,
0.4149762094,
-0.0947253853,
0.0510945171,
-0.2006117105,
-0.4375012219,
-0.6301878095,
-0.1482806206,
0.2813214064,
0.4765254855,
-0.6206347942,
0.4942098856,
-0.6033280492,
-0.3174163103,
-0.7790555358,
0.0582196042,
0.3810471594,
0.3988353908,
0.3100270331,
-0.3111050725,
-0.6521310806,
-0.4985142052,
-0.3028348982,
-0.1217986047,
-0.1264794171,
0.3928253949,
-0.066727981,
-0.311540246,
0.9825553298,
-0.3950048983,
-0.5167438984,
-0.416411221,
0.0368412845,
0.3691029251,
0.0824757591,
0.1035225019,
-0.8911043406,
-0.8445736766,
0.0409928113,
-0.1661795974,
-0.3357607126,
0.1473328769,
0.4327710867,
0.3704979122,
0.4467533529,
-0.4165365696,
0.5478582382,
0.5441874862,
0.0112388926,
0.2505271137,
-0.056380555,
0.1471520066,
-0.9906409383,
0.1104608253,
0.0292554013,
-0.4366889298,
-0.8611040711,
-0.0302755516,
-0.261010766,
-0.3843358457,
-0.6518167853,
0.5021810532,
-0.413443625,
-0.1497378051,
-0.4612961113,
0.2995486557,
-0.1654297262,
0.3725798428,
0.3125308156,
0.8961152434,
0.3186675608,
-0.6498337984,
0.2733081579,
0.1593908072,
0.0392434373,
0.4335480332,
-0.7804919481,
0.2790035605,
0.1500763595,
0.2071499079,
-1.0584619045,
-0.0492305756,
-0.2092444748,
-0.8243957162,
0.3701915741,
-0.6355680823,
-0.5755459666,
-0.3158474267,
-0.1484135985,
0.2956946492,
0.7296627164,
-0.7738297582,
0.6712438464,
0.4624017477,
-0.2252811491,
-0.4325621128,
-0.4514540434,
0.1786404252,
-0.0118308971,
-0.7048447132,
0.246615082,
0.0753192827,
0.3375640512,
-0.3635216355,
-0.1468060464,
-0.2480718791,
-0.2860053778,
0.1752812266,
0.0062060934,
-0.3172435462,
-0.2650181055,
-0.2578590214,
-0.2136162519,
-0.3027895689,
-0.4402010441,
0.6434674263,
0.0456709377,
-0.451184839,
-0.4539791644,
0.383869648,
0.5716823936,
-0.3620751798,
0.4408106208,
0.8557186723,
-0.4924975634,
-0.1505486965,
-0.9344012737,
-0.1827136576,
-0.491076529,
0.2330485284,
-0.1217960566,
-0.9398601055,
0.6901340485,
0.2380451262,
-0.3775669038,
0.1102689281,
0.4307802916,
-0.3388216197,
0.8165497184,
0.4115480781,
-0.0213975441,
0.5377065539,
-0.2409645021,
0.4076904356,
-0.7912501097,
0.1021057144,
-0.5059725046,
-0.2095475346,
-0.7027126551,
-0.4327766001,
0.5419893861,
-0.2810317576,
-0.0375525616,
0.4275959134,
-0.5472634435,
0.4151672721,
0.5545123816,
0.2256384641,
0.3482216895,
0.2116090357,
0.1111654341,
-0.1496607661,
-0.6248003244,
-0.1176186204,
0.8309301734,
0.2433943599,
0.818865478,
0.2618205547,
0.4981734753,
0.4144467413,
-0.2764864564,
-0.7800900936,
0.3146837652,
-0.5472798944,
-0.4954368472,
-0.5790861845,
-0.3801366985,
-0.6768673658,
0.078635782,
0.2062926441,
-0.5127984285,
-0.0343206972,
0.2051293552,
-0.4315125644,
0.3453954458,
-0.5294628143,
0.4551320076,
-0.2664028704,
-0.503239274,
-0.2326022983,
-0.9109473825,
-0.0932546109,
0.1662153006,
-0.2024833262,
-0.0287670065,
0.1989703476,
0.6628544927,
-0.4609078169,
0.789090991,
-0.506942153,
0.1331033856,
0.550014019,
-0.1620220244,
0.7433341742,
-0.2634888589,
-0.0401817001,
0.2113047391,
0.0714301243,
-0.3099534214,
-0.3779504001,
0.5267726183,
-0.7265915871,
-0.1559342295,
-0.3319174945,
-0.0626065582,
-0.1614539325,
0.1418471485,
0.289234966,
0.2862261832,
-0.0574414171,
0.4455280602,
0.9440494776,
-0.0350378789,
0.4581703842,
0.6283460259,
-0.1255707741,
-0.2706004381,
0.744951427,
0.2469833642,
0.2884878516,
0.3859891593,
0.2270464003,
-0.6809526682,
-0.702691555,
-0.502219677,
0.1214695796,
-0.4802012444,
-0.0921243951,
-0.7108625174,
-0.6539076567,
-0.3745059073,
-0.0399367921,
-0.782733202,
-0.1028228104,
-0.4431159198,
0.1534296125,
0.5598788261,
0.2353410572,
0.0993919224,
0.7913977504,
-0.8442863226,
0.4105929434,
0.0931060463,
0.4819957912,
0.0209680647,
-1.0419584513,
-0.4797001481,
0.1558008343,
-0.017988978,
-0.6182495952,
0.5824157,
0.6349166632,
0.330540657,
0.3292540014,
0.0094310418,
0.8569535017,
-0.4087607563,
0.73638165,
0.0924028978,
-0.8000952601,
0.59262532,
-0.3166243434,
0.4545035958,
0.6413907409,
0.1132724509,
-0.7329390049,
-0.0765309408,
-0.1782354712,
-0.7850021124,
0.6116142273,
0.3309208751,
-0.0652328953,
0.3363371491,
0.2467064857,
-0.0179769993,
0.0404914133,
-0.4367089868,
-0.0204635803,
-0.1890992373,
-0.1870516986,
-0.0997804254,
-0.1548352838,
0.4340299666,
-0.1595661491,
0.6731345057,
-0.3051661849,
0.1102151573,
0.2032729834,
-0.3550905287,
-0.1319478899,
0.2694211304,
0.500623107,
0.085205093,
-0.4236137271,
-0.0754164159,
0.2291231006,
-0.7739320993,
0.2451354712,
0.157202974,
-0.1400227994,
0.2694047093,
0.0291575715,
0.7167742252,
0.358009696,
-0.8551214337,
0.5821792483,
-0.1184597164,
0.3809596896,
-0.8083367944,
-0.1031918302,
0.3352451622,
0.0263738967,
0.5233111382,
-0.0165049266,
0.2941918373,
-0.2625765204,
0.1502496898,
0.2950976491,
-0.4890423417,
-0.2151809037,
0.7491101027,
0.2522692382,
-0.4627203047,
0.6832689047,
-0.1287617981,
-0.689260006,
0.4271044135,
0.3588477373,
1.2489967346,
-0.6495363712,
-0.21393314,
0.2330800295,
0.1421399415,
-0.0713186562,
0.357725203,
-0.2206734866,
-0.4896022677,
-0.7089095712,
-0.7290983796,
-0.5210762024,
0.172183305,
-0.7011034489,
0.6090413928,
-0.014365498,
-0.186906755,
-0.2289428711,
-0.0919554979,
-0.6111590862,
0.2764464915,
0.3525735736,
0.7479138374,
-0.5004613996,
0.8580664396,
0.3713575006,
-0.1407854706,
-0.7324203849,
-0.0164650045,
0.0750510767,
-0.5462536216,
0.5157231092,
0.2038526386,
-0.6497543454,
-0.0044148904,
-0.3487551212,
-0.9979792237,
0.9975504279,
0.0343609825,
-0.8201941252,
-0.222511068,
0.2715267539,
0.8144433498,
-0.3059893548,
0.4503831565,
0.2686184645,
0.2139880806,
0.5134246945,
-1.137165308,
-0.4554844499,
-0.2209171355,
0.1397127807,
0.0459956713,
-0.647015214,
0.6055564284,
-0.1327949464,
-0.2129259259,
-0.1852757931,
0.4843404293,
0.288233012,
0.525775969,
0.5387362838,
0.4778267741,
0.2207597792,
0.0800538585,
0.5959800482,
-0.2760098875,
0.2823942006,
1.2382633686,
-0.5922288299,
1.3481446505,
0.4958352745,
-0.1128180027,
-0.1436470896,
0.7943740487,
0.2595686316,
0.6358732581,
0.1426706314,
-0.2619331479,
-0.119899191,
-0.1045504436,
-0.1222961992,
0.6092993617,
0.3981475234,
-0.0181196071,
0.1319140047,
-0.0985025764,
-0.204770267,
-0.0084613385,
-0.3165840507,
0.8696544766,
0.0888445526,
-0.27717489,
0.9309501052,
-0.201748684,
1.0373591185,
-0.5608709455,
0.1151358262,
-0.151159659,
0.2964229286,
-0.3377494514,
-0.4741729498,
0.4580814242,
0.2468376309,
-0.1874374002,
0.0712847263,
0.723706007,
-0.5401835442,
-0.3402691483,
0.5863870978,
0.410549283,
0.1719142199,
-0.2152619213,
-0.3705830276,
0.3211464584,
-0.016084576,
-0.1545547843,
0.1041682437,
0.0047309515,
0.1389572769,
0.7768104076,
0.9083922505,
0.4783626497,
0.4212767482,
0.1996960193,
0.4970247447,
-0.4808325171,
-0.9282274246,
-0.4629128575,
0.3202369511,
-0.014996212,
0.0772559792,
0.3842146397,
0.7243102193,
0.9062905312,
-0.0350182131,
0.71942693,
0.1803358942,
0.9232487679,
-0.4116642773,
0.9364355206,
-0.5924710035,
0.3240225911,
0.0161662456,
-0.8193382025,
-0.1434154809,
0.5625668168,
0.0434626937,
0.059990745,
0.2782368958,
0.8114788532,
-0.3860943019,
0.2237171233,
0.6198078394,
0.2847847641,
0.4079098403,
0.3272310197,
0.7303088903,
-0.5942271948,
0.6501125693,
-0.0759419799,
0.038196288,
-0.6625477076,
-0.634358108,
-0.6241245866,
-0.6206630468,
-0.287676841,
-0.2901732326,
0.3436602056,
1.0458054543,
0.7706189156,
-0.899872303,
-0.4539529681,
0.3107099533,
-0.371440798,
-0.2387866229,
-0.2204578817,
0.3587938845,
0.0138654895,
-0.5549917817,
0.5484488606,
0.4325816035,
-0.0474288911,
-0.1855344772,
-0.3212270439,
-0.3369562924,
0.1140816063,
0.681055069,
0.4153529108,
-0.9303795695,
-0.353993237,
0.2709820569,
0.0205082539,
0.2952088118,
0.6686281562,
-0.7250766754,
0.6934372783,
0.3590075076,
0.679466486,
0.9918856621,
0.0265897624,
0.2717450857,
-0.7558451295,
-0.0628515109,
0.5301555395,
0.1388114393,
0.5377944112,
-0.3619954288,
0.5435292721,
0.072432138,
-0.5567857623,
-0.961403966,
0.0124576222,
-1.1177431345,
0.3166180253,
0.9566302299,
0.0154134184,
-0.1349436492,
-0.1980617642,
-0.0839964896,
0.4775738716,
-0.5380461812,
0.6637740731,
0.368293345,
-0.2871606946,
-0.2767834067,
-0.7640265822,
0.2750898004,
0.4011422396,
-0.4056912661,
0.1408762187,
0.2387409359,
0.3202344477,
-0.016229216,
0.5445322394,
0.0343580507,
0.3275942504,
-0.2805101275,
0.0931546018,
-0.0060750232,
-0.1098308116,
-0.5663616657,
-0.023121722,
-0.0104926489,
-0.2803778648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18585v1 | Exploiting Explainability to Design Adversarial Attacks and Evaluate Attack Resilience in Hate-Speech Detection Models | 2023-05-29T19:59:40 | 2023-05-29T19:59:40 | Pranath Reddy Kumbam, Sohaib Uddin Syed, Prashanth Thamminedi, Suhas Harish, Ian Perera, Bonnie J. Dorr | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of social media has given rise to numerous ethical challenges,
with hate speech among the most significant concerns. Researchers are
attempting to tackle this problem by leveraging hate-speech detection and
employing language models to automatically moderate content and promote civil
discourse. Unfortunately, recent studies have revealed that hate-speech
detection systems can be misled by adversarial attacks, raising concerns about
their resilience. While previous research has separately addressed the
robustness of these models under adversarial attacks and their
interpretability, there has been no comprehensive study exploring their
intersection. The novelty of our work lies in combining these two critical
aspects, leveraging interpretability to identify potential vulnerabilities and
enabling the design of targeted adversarial attacks. We present a comprehensive
and comparative analysis of adversarial robustness exhibited by various
hate-speech detection models. Our study evaluates the resilience of these
models against adversarial attacks using explainability techniques. To gain
insights into the models' decision-making processes, we employ the Local
Interpretable Model-agnostic Explanations (LIME) framework. Based on the
explainability results obtained by LIME, we devise and execute targeted attacks
on the text by leveraging the TextAttack tool. Our findings enhance the
understanding of the vulnerabilities and strengths exhibited by
state-of-the-art hate-speech detection models. This work underscores the
importance of incorporating explainability in the development and evaluation of
such models to enhance their resilience against adversarial attacks.
Ultimately, this work paves the way for creating more robust and reliable
hate-speech detection systems, fostering safer online environments and
promoting ethical discourse on social media platforms. | [
-0.3160744607,
-1.0024809837,
0.4193122685,
-0.0432305448,
-0.1664368212,
0.0277480129,
-0.208620742,
-0.4878071249,
0.0248205978,
0.271543175,
-0.4566204548,
-0.02417133,
-0.7318797708,
-0.0994354188,
-0.7361338139,
1.2414810658,
0.2626186311,
-0.0620536767,
0.0076432023,
-0.3846223652,
-0.266903162,
-0.4465828538,
-0.8721282482,
-0.0817736909,
0.486790359,
-0.1411866695,
1.1636222601,
0.6794717312,
0.2431437522,
0.2982972264,
-0.383487761,
-0.2367823124,
-0.806160748,
0.2748105526,
-0.4184682965,
-0.465941757,
-0.1570083052,
-0.0657810569,
0.3914555013,
0.3589725494,
0.0997467861,
0.016265519,
0.1458580047,
0.4118958414,
-0.4568335414,
-0.2555253804,
-1.0175609589,
-0.1148436517,
-0.031571202,
-0.1698412597,
-0.4719175696,
-0.3874753118,
0.1942915022,
-0.5257820487,
0.2290291786,
-0.1167433932,
0.5934178233,
0.1578574032,
-0.0350765176,
-0.5324326754,
-0.7628218532,
0.6452232599,
-0.641512394,
0.2432645857,
0.1544881612,
0.4948833287,
-0.134393543,
-0.7150849104,
-0.5754417777,
-0.2960258424,
0.0142756291,
0.097782895,
-0.8010274768,
-0.0577708855,
0.0789152607,
0.3958262205,
-0.7202878594,
0.1117554531,
-0.2950899005,
-0.1698688865,
0.5215034485,
-0.0485101789,
0.5614598393,
-0.1838726103,
-0.3905888796,
0.2860701084,
-0.3375505805,
-0.0466237217,
0.7821515203,
0.3214946687,
-0.0399063565,
0.2045500726,
0.0928077474,
0.4780192077,
-0.0939369723,
0.10408023,
-0.2533499002,
-0.1550701559,
-0.1566026062,
-0.0101275854,
0.6613612175,
0.2325302362,
0.538218677,
-0.5135450363,
0.1873481274,
0.386734426,
0.8553315401,
-0.7473927736,
-0.3817911148,
0.3750903904,
-0.687081337,
-0.911857605,
-0.3766496778,
-0.7744520903,
-0.890941143,
0.1004010215,
0.4094442427,
-0.5217205286,
-0.5096094608,
-0.0899089202,
-0.4270356894,
0.0054849973,
0.2714566886,
-0.6328289509,
0.1521173418,
0.6132416725,
0.8973778486,
-0.1937883943,
-0.1658769995,
-0.289919138,
-0.1377305537,
-0.1622914523,
0.4543689787,
-0.4121615589,
-0.2292544991,
-0.0369328745,
-0.1152637228,
-0.0098216506,
-0.273891449,
0.7404075265,
-0.6787234545,
0.0951736122,
-0.0068849721,
-0.3359282017,
-0.368639797,
0.2815837562,
-0.5756565332,
0.3987901509,
0.0752673969,
-0.9964475632,
0.0733405352,
-0.6401147842,
-0.4640972614,
0.0997317433,
-0.0483128987,
-0.4962493479,
0.2848504782,
0.0487513579,
0.2639660835,
-0.250485301,
0.2410295457,
-0.8360734582,
-0.1736251116,
0.591738224,
-0.8366428018,
1.183128953,
0.473487556,
-0.5364581943,
0.2279293686,
-0.7653170824,
-0.0491170548,
0.6077921987,
0.0442992225,
-0.2174806446,
0.1249258146,
0.1423379481,
0.0751386732,
0.0397739075,
-0.3457456529,
-0.4962366819,
-0.5610663891,
0.6669966578,
1.0167006254,
-0.2287482917,
0.3458221853,
-0.2306128293,
0.8750521541,
-0.3464114964,
0.3514823914,
0.0395263731,
-0.2888397574,
-0.2602085471,
-0.1842754185,
-0.0384301245,
0.5674943328,
-0.627161324,
-0.1275912076,
-0.0939711109,
-0.7654696703,
-0.5010764003,
-0.0465443842,
0.5544202328,
0.6726974249,
0.284599483,
0.0755012408,
-0.6602162719,
-1.0667998791,
-0.8014233708,
-0.4438248575,
0.2094065696,
0.2656787932,
0.4018695652,
0.0803146586,
0.8206586242,
-0.2862052321,
0.3667928278,
-0.455234617,
0.0238822773,
-0.2579562068,
0.1855539829,
0.835095346,
-1.2625812292,
-0.3138166666,
-0.1468460411,
-0.7565153241,
-0.11469993,
-0.0216891393,
-0.000758716,
-0.1489473879,
0.1346416175,
-0.1479552835,
0.5861888528,
0.4188644588,
-0.3617601693,
0.7659660578,
0.1625191271,
0.2658079267,
-0.9326329231,
-0.1092762798,
-0.1877225041,
-0.3205946386,
-1.1702708006,
0.3045510054,
-0.3067767918,
-0.2752704322,
-0.6623701453,
0.2955496311,
-0.0515584908,
-0.0430660732,
-0.5677830577,
0.1104697064,
0.0541796722,
0.2240579128,
-0.3965248764,
0.4573195577,
0.5340268612,
-0.4443081617,
0.3046694994,
-0.0678279102,
-0.1661899239,
0.8877868056,
-0.8239403367,
-0.1016558707,
-0.2034929395,
0.0996194109,
-0.9460732341,
-0.0905181989,
0.4439274371,
-0.9779894948,
-0.0072118626,
-0.4397938251,
-0.2649791837,
-0.0543920733,
-0.4162741899,
0.2161691189,
0.2538489699,
-0.6794883013,
0.731372118,
0.5579713583,
-0.1645810306,
-0.4872944355,
-0.6555259824,
0.1102721244,
-0.7814846039,
-0.809266448,
0.3132550716,
-0.2048098147,
-0.5245087147,
0.0409889482,
-0.046327956,
-0.2863837779,
0.7619377375,
0.4570318162,
0.0693896413,
-0.127964586,
-0.1165253669,
-0.2474352121,
0.0499041639,
0.3827420175,
-0.1512974501,
0.4138400853,
-0.2931518555,
0.0100834714,
-0.5058928132,
0.2416401953,
0.6608464122,
-0.0338634625,
1.0088436604,
0.8170927763,
-0.5504223704,
-0.1852561086,
-0.1826150119,
-0.0050072605,
-0.433881253,
0.3427750468,
-0.1906384975,
-0.856916666,
0.6721477509,
0.3047206402,
0.0780231208,
0.4846234918,
0.4652853012,
0.084747605,
1.1279016733,
0.4453270733,
-0.0370846242,
0.577534616,
0.1647161394,
0.2088652998,
-0.3967860937,
0.1639707685,
-0.4872753322,
0.1051567867,
-0.5508643985,
0.0948906466,
0.1104797274,
-0.0891350359,
-0.1973781139,
0.3677003086,
-0.5599465966,
0.4009313881,
0.1211246476,
0.0136149293,
0.0132448832,
0.1492876112,
0.2752546668,
-0.0591234639,
-0.4845824242,
-0.5558097363,
0.9162766933,
0.5844017863,
0.5171281099,
0.4748173356,
0.2543745935,
0.5652154088,
0.2403774858,
-0.5892435312,
0.2830791175,
-0.2292378247,
-0.7794563174,
-0.0566649027,
-0.4067376256,
-0.8496876955,
0.4547599256,
-0.2610425651,
-0.9564003348,
-0.0179204121,
0.3682574928,
-0.38196522,
0.4586005509,
-0.5830863714,
1.0667864084,
-0.3413731158,
-0.3083882332,
-0.3370076418,
-0.5017545819,
0.3843880892,
-0.0874314234,
0.593988955,
0.1580610424,
0.3305337131,
0.8127450347,
-0.2054155916,
0.816061914,
-0.1346734315,
-0.1281578541,
0.1230279133,
0.206917569,
0.3462087214,
-0.1283207238,
-0.2106547207,
0.0591953471,
-0.1776722521,
-0.317307353,
-0.8100503087,
0.7912716269,
-0.5131039023,
-0.6038612127,
-0.1611639857,
-0.5255075097,
0.0021327173,
0.2885169387,
0.1959942132,
0.4907316267,
-0.4288782477,
0.1707069874,
0.7310860753,
-0.3578327,
0.1700164229,
0.4034244418,
-0.3074910939,
-0.5490529537,
1.2519860268,
0.1275096536,
0.5145164728,
0.0665268078,
0.2994849682,
-0.1096851528,
-0.8122293949,
-0.4106993079,
-0.1177920923,
-0.7665997744,
0.212709561,
-0.6666389704,
-0.166221112,
-0.4860653877,
-0.4208454192,
-0.3110814691,
-0.5922557712,
-0.2512685657,
-0.0336438753,
0.2935319245,
0.8040884733,
-0.0686714351,
0.4804283977,
-0.1316671371,
0.5706523657,
0.2593904436,
0.0171331484,
0.1323300898,
-0.9596025944,
-0.2710499763,
0.12417835,
-0.28459993,
-1.3490124941,
0.2946406901,
-0.2049697489,
0.4652057588,
0.4386118054,
0.1620583236,
0.5769589543,
-0.3147747815,
0.6927682161,
-0.0553565212,
-0.8327714205,
0.7911965251,
-0.3445513546,
-0.1691335142,
0.4836378992,
0.3399719,
-0.18156524,
-0.6104056239,
-1.026184082,
-0.8845283985,
0.6897476912,
0.6392460465,
-0.1048389375,
0.1493812054,
0.2818762064,
0.0949504897,
0.0115241418,
-0.8302591443,
-0.6089783311,
-0.3887855113,
-0.1453838497,
0.0728692412,
-0.3003683984,
-0.264395684,
0.322777003,
0.7903639674,
0.1897150278,
0.0949911848,
-0.1627142429,
-0.3220704794,
0.3305037916,
0.500380218,
0.3838212192,
0.6796612144,
-0.1235576645,
0.1731796265,
0.005086829,
-0.4917216003,
-0.0033500278,
0.4830924273,
-0.3043273687,
-0.1604795307,
0.3810207546,
0.8389069438,
0.0514883772,
-0.5836597681,
0.4806065261,
-0.3289788067,
0.0816270486,
-0.4913564026,
0.1324589998,
-0.0210087188,
0.359587878,
0.2490741014,
0.0900280476,
0.3076746166,
-0.509454906,
-0.0413147882,
0.719568789,
-0.4291774631,
-0.3022302389,
0.9291518331,
-0.1607059091,
-0.3887251318,
0.0563227832,
-0.0710655302,
-0.8131139874,
0.794952333,
0.6531124711,
0.8825404048,
-0.1841803342,
0.4256718755,
-0.0640650243,
0.6520777345,
0.3789034486,
-0.0751768127,
-0.011261736,
-0.7218937874,
0.0569058992,
-0.4901923537,
-0.4210038781,
0.422118932,
-0.9297518134,
-0.1839331239,
-0.6802432537,
0.0337880775,
0.6319396496,
-0.2803143859,
-0.318138957,
0.4105167091,
0.1401522607,
0.6256198287,
-0.9272220731,
0.1797560602,
0.6130663753,
-0.362624824,
-0.4619725049,
0.0461497754,
0.3586461842,
-0.8614060283,
0.3080600202,
0.2708633244,
-0.3757953346,
-0.2638664842,
-0.5955321789,
-0.4525570869,
0.7356612086,
0.6142585278,
-0.0180808753,
0.2799292803,
-0.0252630897,
0.6945233941,
-0.260027945,
0.1675276905,
0.5586388111,
0.214293018,
-0.1401565224,
-0.5487502813,
0.2547142208,
-0.2802785039,
-0.0492726006,
-0.0892082304,
-0.3642518222,
0.5026391745,
-0.0476178378,
-0.3500029445,
-0.0515044071,
0.7138257027,
0.0291049276,
0.4720353186,
0.7202299237,
0.5557043552,
0.6423259974,
0.2330480665,
1.080722928,
-0.1228872761,
0.1107746959,
1.1010996103,
0.2934404016,
0.5422623754,
0.0954820588,
-0.1222014651,
0.3380880654,
0.3762995005,
0.1149144769,
0.335740298,
0.3170871437,
-0.3973065913,
-0.2014098018,
-0.2460336834,
-0.2852646708,
0.4222837389,
0.4535278976,
-0.6425076127,
-0.1708556712,
0.1928964257,
0.4526449442,
0.2827136517,
-0.3807864487,
0.5240907073,
-0.216884166,
-0.3182177246,
0.4725433588,
0.0189035907,
0.4943540096,
-0.4983838797,
0.2635291517,
0.2382428348,
0.2075684369,
-0.3385048509,
-0.79265517,
0.4781498313,
0.361718595,
-0.3961956501,
-0.1256152987,
0.9225312471,
-0.1029141024,
-0.1036657244,
0.3405487835,
0.0458659828,
0.2700627148,
-0.2952648401,
-0.9645069838,
0.2650565505,
0.2072025537,
-0.0348364003,
0.4165079296,
0.1663134843,
0.2517503202,
0.910600543,
0.7310274243,
0.1337362081,
-0.1416734904,
0.0313293189,
0.8416005969,
-0.4209524095,
-0.5254508257,
-1.193784833,
0.4447066784,
-0.1854576617,
-0.1703234017,
0.9157431722,
0.3506585658,
0.6275036931,
0.3263106048,
1.1778907776,
-0.1343068779,
0.6417172551,
-0.1802982688,
0.928486526,
-0.4895072877,
0.3346024454,
-0.4162715375,
-0.4149875641,
-0.2550720572,
0.5201237798,
-0.4432998896,
-0.0377833359,
0.3415160179,
0.7925562859,
0.0204969887,
0.3378995955,
0.1800486296,
0.6099321842,
0.5383423567,
0.1750135422,
0.8433112502,
-0.2719470859,
1.1646221876,
-0.1852754802,
-0.3299393952,
-0.0842383802,
-0.8214337826,
-0.8797644377,
-0.2848725915,
-0.2974767685,
-0.8561366796,
0.4270602465,
0.2514889538,
0.3222632706,
-0.6874842644,
0.1941531003,
-0.0890452415,
0.4821857214,
-0.1211245358,
-0.3393683434,
0.255743295,
0.0118499435,
-0.4275953472,
0.5478385687,
0.2417970598,
-0.0250653792,
-0.3341513872,
-0.0176103041,
-0.0227452088,
0.2879683673,
0.4867598116,
0.6698104143,
-0.8487159014,
-0.1270216405,
-0.3636135161,
0.2204297036,
-0.3098156154,
0.504239738,
-0.5484896898,
0.6302449703,
0.2477435917,
0.9473948479,
-0.0482693501,
0.0559852272,
0.5402069092,
-0.1662351638,
-0.1825355887,
0.0703290328,
0.366458118,
0.4789395928,
-0.4931997657,
0.3510882854,
0.1792601496,
-0.5883176923,
-1.1129405499,
0.5873687863,
-0.7684583068,
-0.4915835559,
1.0170332193,
-0.3470901549,
-0.1149511635,
-0.412682265,
-0.1010353938,
0.2832364738,
-0.1708824784,
0.7738934755,
0.6611917615,
0.1266925335,
0.0119624948,
-0.5225237608,
0.4588568807,
0.3191254139,
-0.6062551141,
0.3285716474,
0.4003539383,
0.3119942844,
0.1511724889,
0.4294270575,
-0.1032638773,
0.5201258659,
0.0576638654,
-0.4508295059,
-0.0304558352,
-0.1775753498,
-0.6684102416,
0.4856389165,
-0.1577665508,
-0.1021332443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18582v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18582v2 | Information Association for Language Model Updating by Mitigating LM-Logical Discrepancy | 2023-05-29T19:48:37 | 2024-02-09T06:37:51 | Pengfei Yu, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models~(LLMs) struggle with providing current information due
to the outdated pre-training data. Existing methods for updating LLMs, such as
knowledge editing and continual fine-tuning, have significant drawbacks in
generalizability of new information and the requirements on structured updating
corpus. We identify the core challenge behind these drawbacks: the LM-logical
discrepancy featuring the difference between language modeling probabilities
and logical probabilities. To evaluate and address the core challenge, we
propose a new task formulation of the information updating task that only
requires the provision of an unstructured updating corpus and evaluates the
performance of information updating on the generalizability to question-answer
pairs pertaining to the updating information. We further propose a novel and
effective pipeline approach for the task, highlighting a self-prompting-based
question-answer generation process and a associative distillation methods to
bridge the LM-logical discrepancy. We develop two datasets for evaluation, one
sourced from news articles published in March and April 2023, and the other
from the Natural Questions benchmark. Experimental results demonstrate the
superiority of our approach, significantly increasing the factual consistency
score (on a scale from 0 to 1) by up to 0.16. Furthermore, our method
effectively mitigates forgetting utilizing a compact replay buffer with only
2.3% of the training tokens. | [
0.1194205433,
-0.8717752695,
0.5629290342,
0.1171465442,
-0.0580583625,
0.1637313515,
-0.2996456623,
-0.2608859539,
0.095873937,
0.568385303,
-0.4320452511,
-0.4343066514,
-0.5533084869,
-0.1009575278,
-0.358974874,
0.8914532065,
-0.0470573194,
-0.1347084045,
-0.3637644053,
-0.193447426,
-0.9347936511,
-0.4861346781,
-0.7460079789,
-0.1495524347,
0.1950012147,
0.29728055,
0.5722916126,
0.6316378117,
0.508163631,
0.2793605626,
-0.1281649917,
0.3753893077,
-0.2471647114,
0.1831776798,
-0.3417660594,
-0.6297519803,
-0.3915035129,
-0.2731176317,
0.8328021169,
0.7614552975,
-0.3785809577,
0.2787013054,
0.0530199297,
1.0846401453,
-0.7752879858,
0.3157106936,
-1.0215539932,
-0.0688630044,
-0.2153853625,
-0.3116118908,
-0.3184161782,
-0.2053569108,
-0.121738933,
-0.475712508,
0.0834604949,
0.0384513475,
0.4808743,
0.5840636492,
-0.1110276207,
-0.4970775247,
-0.7414847016,
0.5456035137,
-0.7461443543,
0.1792266965,
0.3242808878,
0.0427149795,
-0.3434379995,
-0.3495296836,
-0.5807407498,
-0.2705590725,
0.1369423866,
0.0990848392,
-0.4802491963,
-0.1349798441,
0.2874357402,
0.2125605941,
-0.2811931372,
0.0302923415,
-0.3179732561,
-0.0831201524,
0.4882723689,
0.0277162902,
0.1141216084,
0.0065947152,
-0.2824892998,
-0.0395480543,
-0.8120558858,
-0.0533913672,
0.5127298236,
0.1191443652,
0.0771660879,
0.6307133436,
-0.3611697853,
0.6955637336,
0.0985518768,
0.1263073981,
0.3271706104,
-0.4782224298,
-0.120089218,
0.1661708802,
0.4718810916,
0.46388641,
0.3044472337,
0.07424891,
-0.22145091,
0.0422892682,
-0.0469445251,
-0.2460554987,
-0.2448029369,
0.407933414,
-0.0416918695,
-0.1010637954,
-0.0873399749,
-0.5568442345,
-0.551640451,
-0.3606211841,
0.4148744643,
-0.2533462644,
-0.2151165456,
0.4363540113,
0.1548565477,
-0.1859451532,
0.6330467463,
-0.8098780513,
0.0762576163,
0.3503297269,
0.428388387,
0.0105867283,
-0.0684854165,
-0.578073442,
0.2316065282,
-0.31627509,
0.831879735,
-0.343762368,
0.0952286273,
-0.2039676309,
-0.2698120475,
-0.1207654923,
-0.7322347164,
0.2791987956,
-0.5421692729,
0.2951519489,
-0.2940278947,
-0.7381526828,
0.1127121374,
0.4092368782,
-0.6042055488,
1.187146306,
0.100603424,
-1.035036087,
0.0296918135,
-0.48486045,
0.0304601956,
-0.1711736321,
-0.3248939216,
-0.2331304103,
-0.0412788875,
0.1192704439,
0.166644603,
-0.3027034998,
0.5985392332,
-0.2168252766,
-0.162591964,
0.3056876063,
-0.3668083847,
0.7094983459,
0.1184187531,
-0.1175039634,
0.223182708,
-0.8252099156,
-0.3255412281,
0.0338645615,
-0.472347945,
-0.3125804663,
0.141459927,
-0.6364601851,
0.1842916757,
0.6103314161,
-0.5406639576,
0.3462862074,
-0.1320363879,
0.1991031021,
0.9657840133,
0.1481377631,
0.2049487233,
-0.5139043927,
0.2082235664,
0.4387560189,
0.1648478359,
-0.2709206939,
-0.4820575714,
-0.9055427909,
-0.0370914377,
0.5876784325,
0.8450641036,
-0.5708058476,
0.5476852655,
-0.1868849397,
-0.316070348,
-0.7528469563,
0.4370337129,
0.2341388762,
0.8688641191,
0.5352193117,
-0.2491000295,
-0.7069399953,
-0.7546113133,
-0.2365095615,
-0.4523440003,
-0.0291303284,
-0.0910061449,
0.2042534202,
-0.1230564639,
1.0456370115,
-0.4663136601,
-0.4036208391,
-0.2254326195,
0.2333301902,
0.3796481788,
0.4007491767,
0.2149564028,
-0.5497095585,
-0.226036787,
-0.1576162279,
-0.7051436305,
-0.2797750235,
-0.2129844129,
0.1900354922,
0.3413999379,
0.5202551484,
-0.808603406,
0.2960962057,
0.4519850612,
-0.2568556368,
0.598459363,
-0.6308918595,
0.2554964125,
-0.9388382435,
0.0239585564,
-0.0688268319,
-0.074129343,
-0.6266587973,
-0.1109361798,
0.0336124822,
0.1208786294,
-0.4606982172,
0.6352035403,
-0.4635746777,
0.1170828193,
-0.2347578853,
0.3797826171,
-0.1215817854,
0.5290093422,
-0.1697462201,
0.3705277443,
0.6214872599,
-0.7102745175,
0.4792434871,
0.2176040709,
-0.2678072453,
0.3894095123,
-0.3726820648,
0.2090225518,
-0.5745064616,
0.2551271617,
-0.7982703447,
0.052768819,
0.3904733956,
-0.3369826674,
0.2444141507,
0.1418619007,
-0.6844834685,
-0.1117612571,
-0.2778155506,
0.1597107947,
0.3944960833,
-0.3434888721,
0.5891008973,
0.4324721694,
-0.2684141397,
-0.7036052346,
-0.4464272857,
0.1549481452,
-0.1376639307,
-0.736636281,
0.2168580592,
-0.2560639083,
-0.4642078876,
0.2150128782,
-0.4129182994,
0.0926264524,
0.1675300002,
-0.4689085186,
0.3612643778,
0.054789871,
0.358369112,
-0.2597989738,
-0.0647042617,
0.140149653,
-0.2750571966,
0.2762303054,
-0.0100385388,
-0.4871503413,
-0.2832321823,
0.1433192044,
0.12813209,
-0.2184446454,
0.5128543973,
0.3041076362,
-0.5113605261,
0.0192660633,
-0.8818845153,
-0.22980389,
-0.4051285982,
0.4318014681,
-0.2003119439,
-0.7365040183,
0.5813338161,
-0.0090611037,
0.1112220511,
0.3640090227,
0.554132998,
-0.2812460065,
0.9225437641,
0.4964762926,
-0.1749798506,
0.3504388034,
0.1373194158,
0.1488007903,
-0.7127714157,
-0.2644613683,
-0.4632746577,
-0.218766585,
-0.3842399716,
-0.5823718309,
0.2757247984,
0.2428411245,
-0.098292917,
0.1466156691,
-0.2038948685,
0.2953440249,
0.6495029926,
0.0456217676,
0.6557316184,
-0.1542742103,
-0.0109926285,
0.0443879813,
-0.8067225814,
-0.3780163229,
1.1948777437,
0.2398932874,
0.8239920735,
0.2986967266,
0.4992829859,
0.5954056978,
0.0987258032,
-0.2060797662,
0.5023595691,
-0.1349588186,
-0.5493791103,
-0.1867318898,
-0.5253738165,
-0.7716565728,
-0.0241440684,
-0.453738004,
-0.8729902506,
0.0798530355,
0.5943058133,
-0.1510999054,
0.3938008249,
-0.5338901877,
0.7935659885,
-0.1724443138,
-0.2379503399,
-0.200183481,
-0.7384155989,
0.2309396416,
-0.4223072529,
0.3453952372,
-0.1994642615,
0.0925475582,
0.4841912985,
-0.0738922507,
0.8441371918,
-0.3179741502,
-0.0799262971,
0.5256769061,
-0.1162273958,
0.7746975422,
-0.0288122911,
-0.1307628453,
-0.0814919025,
-0.0462659039,
-0.3924711347,
-0.983022213,
0.3765853047,
-0.4874937832,
-0.923527658,
-0.4143163562,
-0.6625809669,
-0.4423156083,
0.003616442,
-0.1047784239,
0.3151842654,
0.1145290732,
0.1248814464,
0.9675277472,
-0.1830590665,
0.1763090789,
0.6025795341,
-0.2300844789,
-0.0201803818,
0.7774279714,
0.0131758573,
0.3626125753,
0.6258832216,
0.3494113088,
-0.4547437429,
-0.7672433853,
-0.4270593524,
0.1786106229,
-0.779361248,
-0.1756064892,
-0.5183275938,
-0.153713882,
-0.4218871593,
0.4726478159,
-0.2627391219,
-0.5696284771,
-0.2597993314,
0.0984799862,
0.2457368374,
0.5635131001,
-0.1471232772,
0.0286727604,
-0.7192043066,
0.2336375713,
0.0495689549,
0.042814143,
-0.2304728031,
-0.6465840936,
-0.1677590013,
0.3064268529,
-0.3934190869,
-0.9174595475,
-0.0520879924,
0.1904355437,
0.5450750589,
0.0208786149,
0.1948665679,
0.6787074804,
-0.4102407396,
0.5031585693,
0.2223026007,
-0.816921711,
0.7932925224,
-0.2591285706,
0.4411628842,
0.5914400816,
0.1450279653,
-0.5455169082,
-0.6135280132,
-0.698967278,
-0.6588336825,
0.4246536195,
0.0975937024,
0.0637291446,
-0.1657038182,
0.2747653723,
-0.3124462068,
0.5102082491,
-0.6159848571,
-0.24577564,
0.0747228265,
-0.3759146631,
0.1505491734,
-0.1073562279,
-0.0974583998,
-0.1362935603,
0.813597858,
-0.2160114944,
0.0769466609,
0.2705039382,
-0.2212243974,
-0.0406357422,
0.5387855172,
0.5662811399,
0.6842030287,
-0.412153393,
0.0396611132,
0.3565194905,
-0.1858766377,
0.1346096545,
0.1201485395,
-0.2283261418,
-0.0007348996,
0.285082221,
0.8677933216,
0.3880659342,
-0.9079731107,
0.4316391051,
0.1069083959,
-0.2184092551,
-0.3283447921,
0.1636276692,
0.2581531405,
0.1031666696,
0.461612016,
0.2300967723,
-0.1143017858,
-0.7408646941,
0.0755683184,
0.2180835009,
-0.3107619584,
-0.1438869238,
0.4772299528,
-0.0812764764,
-0.0632902458,
0.5587645769,
-0.3539320827,
-0.1875302792,
0.3581757247,
0.4575472176,
0.4092601836,
-0.333073765,
0.0639890209,
0.1605813801,
0.3752666712,
-0.3073634207,
0.4143927097,
0.190569371,
-1.004458189,
-0.4738298655,
-0.4245960712,
-0.4993596077,
0.3490428329,
-0.3614627123,
0.4424118698,
-0.3968839347,
0.0277096089,
-0.3223141432,
-0.0386311375,
-0.4407552779,
0.2930181921,
0.0288119093,
1.0613752604,
-0.6477023363,
0.9519635439,
0.7089443207,
-0.2884925902,
-0.7146862745,
-0.2480280846,
0.0354586951,
-0.5407044291,
0.5110365152,
-0.1533818394,
0.0040941439,
0.0487439744,
-0.0470364764,
-0.8654402494,
1.0537325144,
0.6499057412,
-0.7551563382,
-0.2785383761,
0.3621647954,
0.4765432775,
-0.4743083119,
0.1669720411,
0.5500075817,
0.5744935274,
0.1770981997,
-0.5981408954,
-0.0656410828,
-0.2679911554,
-0.2053586841,
0.1545940489,
-0.3581562638,
0.8039446473,
-0.3695649505,
-0.2479301989,
-0.0993160829,
0.7581929564,
0.403457582,
0.1029442549,
0.6655414701,
0.7857960463,
1.0993887186,
-0.0291269124,
0.6038191319,
-0.4760895371,
0.3309277892,
1.6321946383,
-0.4380311668,
0.7877209187,
0.5571383238,
-0.0544690192,
0.3727503717,
0.5155650377,
-0.0135447662,
0.4514646828,
0.4674533904,
-0.4548182786,
-0.1418903768,
-0.0594846122,
-0.298850596,
0.4176860452,
0.2733386755,
-0.0568327345,
-0.4622497559,
-0.2412510216,
0.0563488379,
0.2924557328,
-0.3093233705,
0.5819675922,
-0.1308443099,
-0.8221877217,
0.2962913513,
0.0821018144,
0.4153866172,
-0.6688631773,
-0.0999242663,
-0.1822636276,
0.1736107767,
-0.0999991521,
-0.7440389991,
0.4927372634,
0.1723526567,
-0.2017044425,
-0.0575283952,
0.7454643846,
-0.6556976438,
-0.4478724301,
0.2816563547,
0.4962409437,
-0.1238123178,
-0.0622452423,
-0.9649615884,
0.1989681423,
0.0416529477,
0.0170568116,
0.292291224,
0.4265065193,
-0.1516937613,
0.7993552685,
0.6950479746,
0.3758458197,
0.0962048471,
0.1639026701,
0.7745912075,
-0.4356498122,
-0.3656965494,
-0.7692528367,
0.5868695974,
-0.1040792689,
-0.1964420676,
0.4895448387,
0.3451154232,
0.8768600821,
-0.0275509711,
0.7886564136,
-0.0588951893,
0.5767701864,
-0.8261406422,
0.2488011122,
-0.2728463709,
0.8151999116,
-0.1260125786,
-1.0196068287,
-0.2148959488,
0.3793332577,
-0.1749212146,
-0.1524660587,
0.8756168485,
0.8469239473,
0.0271448437,
0.0768835321,
0.1497237235,
0.4807592928,
0.126315549,
0.6774156094,
0.8161019087,
-0.3772099614,
0.2755602002,
-0.1447626799,
-0.3779463172,
0.0661207139,
-1.192663908,
-0.6575911045,
-0.5185474157,
-0.6969189644,
-0.3207681179,
0.3558130264,
0.9720776677,
0.2616102397,
-0.744423449,
-0.2732197642,
-0.1113506183,
0.1411750764,
-0.1349674463,
-0.1448786855,
0.2175001502,
-0.5903045535,
-0.4456279874,
0.3547185063,
0.2781216502,
-0.1952664852,
-0.2886967957,
0.1906041801,
-0.5455648303,
0.209027499,
0.2572590113,
0.3021202683,
-0.4257288575,
-0.5715922117,
-0.0262088291,
0.0896105766,
0.2616779804,
0.5718668699,
-0.6603683233,
0.4048175514,
0.3402856588,
0.8740044832,
0.3628104627,
0.002407291,
0.478045404,
-0.8364473581,
-0.0647754818,
-0.0191020481,
0.4189721048,
0.6263272762,
-0.304992497,
0.3384197354,
0.3038686812,
-0.469026804,
-0.6273149252,
0.3826122284,
-0.9551848769,
-0.0827510282,
0.9442111254,
-0.1676252782,
-0.2988411188,
-0.1986697763,
-0.0814695433,
0.2812820077,
-0.1392629743,
0.9710298777,
0.8322222829,
-0.0467732139,
-0.007755232,
-0.5538544655,
0.3563334048,
0.4667251408,
-0.9267921448,
0.3280265927,
0.4431918263,
0.3762548864,
0.158321768,
0.8620967269,
-0.0550860204,
0.2394398451,
-0.3795882165,
0.031287685,
-0.0292460695,
-0.3425407708,
-0.3213278949,
-0.1608497947,
0.0978720263,
0.0505098552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18576v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18576v1 | TreeMAN: Tree-enhanced Multimodal Attention Network for ICD Coding | 2023-05-29T19:37:26 | 2023-05-29T19:37:26 | Zichen Liu, Xuyuan Liu, Yanlong Wen, Guoqing Zhao, Fen Xia, Xiaojie Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | ICD coding is designed to assign the disease codes to electronic health
records (EHRs) upon discharge, which is crucial for billing and clinical
statistics. In an attempt to improve the effectiveness and efficiency of manual
coding, many methods have been proposed to automatically predict ICD codes from
clinical notes. However, most previous works ignore the decisive information
contained in structured medical data in EHRs, which is hard to be captured from
the noisy clinical notes. In this paper, we propose a Tree-enhanced Multimodal
Attention Network (TreeMAN) to fuse tabular features and textual features into
multimodal representations by enhancing the text representations with
tree-based features via the attention mechanism. Tree-based features are
constructed according to decision trees learned from structured multimodal
medical data, which capture the decisive information about ICD coding. We can
apply the same multi-label classifier from previous text models to the
multimodal representations to predict ICD codes. Experiments on two MIMIC
datasets show that our method outperforms prior state-of-the-art ICD coding
approaches. The code is available at https://github.com/liu-zichen/TreeMAN. | [
-0.2373989671,
-0.3654069901,
0.5913587809,
0.1112322286,
-0.4630497396,
0.0625186637,
-0.0392898694,
-0.4799828231,
0.4007866383,
0.3718650639,
-0.3278533518,
-0.7401845455,
-0.4095593989,
0.0762777328,
-0.125295043,
1.2077364922,
-0.0654333234,
0.0735753924,
-0.222031787,
-0.2189618498,
-0.3601411879,
-0.6615634561,
-0.3744240403,
-0.0579034239,
0.7934788465,
0.2805500627,
0.4073940516,
0.8046864867,
0.9908232689,
0.2102029026,
0.0111145377,
0.128619656,
0.1920628846,
0.1212493479,
0.3762114048,
-0.1884662956,
-0.8743575215,
-0.7121307254,
0.4850451052,
0.1309033781,
-0.1580915153,
0.2847625911,
0.1902244687,
0.5055377483,
-0.3952668607,
0.6545894146,
-0.4399777651,
0.377369225,
-0.1020539105,
-0.6772702336,
-0.579657197,
-0.2275769114,
-0.1143533736,
-0.4782385826,
0.1377224326,
0.0606684014,
0.5105051398,
0.3222345412,
-0.6439102888,
-0.0848425031,
-0.529974103,
0.3415527344,
-0.3480572999,
0.4372494519,
0.4603951871,
0.4467273951,
0.3560602367,
-0.7199158072,
-0.2446064651,
-0.1197072119,
-0.3215171695,
0.3385146558,
-0.1565793008,
0.3995138109,
0.2674103677,
0.2492907941,
-0.5775931478,
-0.357983619,
-0.2384853661,
-0.0367864445,
0.3041249812,
0.0362060443,
0.484723717,
-0.2933175862,
-0.2762902379,
-0.2849402726,
-0.2030034065,
0.0727515146,
-0.5007543564,
0.0565884262,
-0.3015107214,
0.4032335281,
-0.0675353333,
0.4076017737,
0.2008308172,
-0.5748375654,
0.7699236274,
-0.3615127206,
-0.4886818826,
0.6667255163,
0.6280819178,
0.5301668048,
0.0222824141,
-0.012357831,
-0.1186293811,
0.1920530647,
0.3336658776,
-0.6279886961,
-0.4797706604,
0.1787526459,
-0.8955894709,
-0.1267220974,
-0.1143687889,
-0.8065770864,
-0.1018795893,
-0.1994689256,
-0.1389078498,
-0.4859781861,
-0.1870826632,
-0.0836146697,
0.1088688076,
-0.3896624744,
0.3606584966,
-0.7320219874,
0.2394265383,
0.3294934034,
0.736544311,
0.2525595427,
-0.0200322475,
-0.6163601875,
0.5217205882,
-0.1930064857,
0.6872795224,
-0.6308239102,
-0.0121450266,
-0.2033462375,
0.0728619546,
-0.197587803,
-0.3812758923,
0.7155375481,
-0.3812077045,
-0.2650593519,
0.4511116445,
0.1026150361,
-0.2601287663,
0.4987034202,
-1.0113551617,
0.6439806819,
0.1596792489,
-0.9599459171,
0.3191229105,
-0.761075139,
-0.6219364405,
0.2528392375,
-0.2474126667,
-0.905349791,
-0.0103836963,
0.6122507453,
0.4672999978,
-0.2150022238,
0.5238385201,
-0.1975241452,
0.1884269863,
0.252030313,
-0.3623652756,
0.5263399482,
0.2715392709,
-0.0882081762,
0.352914691,
-0.7391706109,
0.2378174514,
-0.016400842,
-0.4572015405,
-0.3029171824,
-0.0513632149,
0.4382204413,
0.281463325,
-0.1844939142,
-0.4812814593,
0.0757629573,
-0.1832412332,
0.2888848782,
0.3828710318,
0.1198343411,
0.104193449,
-0.6480840445,
0.807795465,
0.2731282115,
0.249100849,
-0.7047178745,
-0.5319237113,
-0.1966620982,
-0.2927190959,
0.3264470398,
0.4707400203,
-0.6514282227,
0.3303536177,
-0.5208545923,
-0.1307342499,
-0.5887093544,
0.0919976458,
0.6925041676,
0.4691356421,
0.4538206458,
-0.6141498089,
-0.5900661945,
-0.7459384799,
0.1596584767,
-0.2689620852,
0.0354253277,
0.6552575231,
-0.0002930841,
-0.3590480983,
0.7171568871,
-0.2608886957,
-0.7490547895,
-0.4201535881,
-0.0193775818,
-0.0363777615,
0.6135264039,
0.3600561321,
-0.7813954949,
-0.6614475846,
0.6459704041,
-0.3283550739,
0.1173158959,
-0.2777253389,
0.4254601002,
-0.0419750214,
0.3499414027,
-0.4225289524,
0.2524545789,
0.556103766,
-0.0990357175,
0.0577658229,
-0.5144559145,
0.2501416802,
-1.2028874159,
0.17516689,
0.2081140876,
-0.2881162167,
-0.494699657,
-0.1371079087,
0.602617085,
-0.2299402207,
-0.2491990328,
0.0801231787,
-0.6748823524,
-0.0238789152,
0.2850083113,
-0.0962370485,
0.1147153825,
0.7051706314,
-0.159279108,
0.2362806499,
0.5392822027,
-0.2684969008,
0.4194477499,
0.276961416,
-0.2328175902,
0.5617223382,
-0.3412810564,
0.0439334139,
-0.3906529248,
0.4159317315,
-0.8116627336,
-0.3225926459,
0.2869651318,
-0.3195027709,
0.6107707024,
-0.3447467089,
-0.5612852573,
-0.5493063331,
-0.3077639937,
0.9071462154,
0.2955665886,
-0.3293310106,
0.6591818929,
0.4522950649,
-0.2838773727,
-0.1765269935,
-0.7607147098,
0.3004974127,
-0.1476686597,
-0.3430542052,
0.611539185,
-0.0472571142,
0.1410475373,
0.2652578056,
-0.0677635297,
-0.1231220514,
-0.0493953377,
0.4590589702,
0.1217004284,
-0.4258593619,
0.3752631843,
0.2222535312,
-0.3351898789,
0.1369522959,
-0.1941567212,
0.3722981215,
0.189474225,
-0.672088325,
-0.8772307038,
0.4956985414,
0.8487284184,
-0.8218998313,
-0.0866275057,
0.3343231976,
-0.5641109943,
0.0561185591,
-0.3042037785,
-0.18002069,
-0.3442938328,
0.7119557858,
-0.3237136304,
-0.6090322733,
0.1094402298,
-0.1129147708,
-0.282358706,
0.2403148562,
0.2553476393,
-0.1346528381,
1.6855722666,
0.5448424816,
-0.0821681693,
0.4732973278,
-0.0693308264,
0.0063892636,
-1.1885639429,
-0.6452442408,
-0.5620740056,
-0.3732920587,
-0.3705393374,
-0.3921147287,
0.6677567363,
-0.018715594,
-0.0242736749,
-0.0197462905,
-0.7921625972,
0.2821769714,
0.3109192848,
0.4030694664,
0.369259268,
0.2557839751,
-0.1813301444,
0.0292629693,
-1.0658802986,
-0.1236018911,
1.0673651695,
0.4410485327,
0.8508232832,
-0.04903185,
0.440972805,
0.1036928967,
0.5388317704,
-0.6350659728,
0.1907082051,
-0.1400082856,
-0.2602054477,
0.2244219035,
-0.1941169202,
-1.0278458595,
-0.0993111804,
-0.131092906,
-0.5545669198,
0.2347588241,
0.3261523843,
-0.5548160672,
0.2070604414,
-0.7606298923,
1.099241972,
-0.4327575862,
0.1197345033,
-0.3169395328,
-0.8262606859,
0.2469361424,
-0.0554040074,
0.2861250341,
0.1560709178,
0.111252144,
0.6857506633,
-0.2913797796,
0.9075371623,
0.1010411531,
0.1501053572,
0.09072873,
-0.0968713537,
0.4100427926,
0.2838302255,
0.5036308169,
-0.331448108,
0.1197774634,
-0.0527082235,
-0.4338361025,
0.551040709,
-0.5499805212,
-0.3144569397,
-0.4452881813,
-0.4664779007,
-0.0728288293,
0.1336342692,
-0.2744850516,
0.9890942574,
0.1122660115,
0.3353537917,
0.6073071361,
0.048800569,
0.6010343432,
-0.1041719913,
-0.2204358578,
-0.7624963522,
0.7364385724,
-0.0024580068,
0.0651738644,
0.7108625174,
0.0286618415,
-0.1505110711,
-0.4179556668,
-0.8229749799,
0.0092213033,
-0.6895625591,
-0.6945927143,
-1.0342819691,
-0.3501245379,
-0.2800650001,
-0.0457617417,
0.1836365759,
-0.0235577468,
-0.1605724841,
-0.1071920693,
0.5691885352,
0.5608876944,
0.2426377684,
0.2989017069,
-1.1731162071,
0.4790040851,
0.2223239094,
0.5178729296,
0.1540867239,
0.0684482902,
-0.3745253682,
-0.1155795529,
-0.2813261449,
-0.9760152102,
0.3498589396,
0.2678197324,
0.5396336317,
0.678314805,
0.0232035313,
0.7030518055,
-0.5509362817,
0.145275861,
0.6637231708,
-0.6987040639,
0.7483384013,
0.0022590859,
0.5731901526,
0.2769428194,
0.1637633294,
-0.7608074546,
-0.285741955,
-0.629085958,
-0.5463624597,
1.0676680803,
-0.0680945739,
-0.0954979733,
-0.0576656722,
0.0137334168,
-0.270267874,
0.0676940307,
-0.6919837594,
-0.2814717591,
-0.2987215519,
-0.7319393158,
-0.1018066481,
-0.4207856357,
-0.1478951126,
-0.1919275224,
0.0251510292,
-0.3216120899,
0.3688057363,
0.6616764665,
-0.1219191998,
-0.4348471165,
0.3568526208,
0.5454540849,
0.4687846601,
-0.1935350448,
0.5319387913,
-0.0425810628,
-0.6903577447,
0.1068651825,
0.3005312383,
0.0291206557,
0.1658549011,
0.3547823131,
0.8369888663,
0.1423825324,
-0.6823498607,
0.4827091992,
-0.1026925817,
-0.0637806728,
-0.0216322821,
-0.0938732624,
0.0868486464,
0.1939896047,
0.2621448636,
0.5557069778,
0.271656692,
-0.4320023656,
0.5536816716,
0.265563786,
-0.7530667186,
-0.3635734618,
0.6496242881,
0.3018552363,
-0.5851123333,
0.1887028515,
-0.0075261584,
-0.6560748816,
0.9997021556,
0.741969049,
0.7865698338,
-0.4892968833,
0.1787436604,
0.3134067357,
0.3596944213,
0.3589943051,
0.2862912714,
-0.3306373656,
-0.3018766046,
-0.593280077,
-0.2047098428,
0.05087718,
0.0982593596,
-0.618647933,
0.2980891168,
-0.7061943412,
-0.1813798249,
-0.1188742444,
-0.3190943003,
-0.4601301849,
0.5510675907,
0.1969510913,
0.5630711317,
-0.4281242192,
1.0052280426,
0.9272322059,
-0.2010069042,
-0.7308514714,
0.1202818677,
0.0074209245,
-0.4461062551,
0.5472262502,
0.5242992043,
0.0933730453,
0.1800706834,
0.2257751673,
-0.8499636054,
1.1124619246,
0.1511231214,
-0.8709145188,
-0.018710671,
-0.1223152801,
0.3177731931,
-0.6228523254,
0.5541148782,
0.1172492877,
0.2630336583,
0.0060564461,
-1.1660995483,
0.1722958833,
-0.5789874792,
0.0540384725,
0.3955779672,
-0.4188818336,
0.4677376449,
-0.4209988415,
-0.3208824992,
-0.573289454,
0.1087870374,
0.0097543849,
0.4484217465,
0.4444881976,
0.5841470957,
0.5733252764,
0.2564272583,
1.1083767414,
-0.6578421593,
0.2310706526,
0.9358436465,
-0.1045850441,
0.5602611303,
0.2551935911,
-0.1393676847,
0.4476845264,
0.5009826422,
0.128873378,
0.629997611,
-0.0193875916,
-0.2821173966,
-0.1233029664,
-0.3086940944,
-0.6668886542,
0.1530120671,
0.2286852151,
-0.6462512612,
-0.3309577703,
0.3541683853,
-0.1610444337,
-0.1609753966,
-0.5161751509,
1.1470150948,
-0.0423005782,
-0.5057576895,
0.4138640761,
0.1168898195,
0.2260431498,
-0.3466123044,
-0.3073768616,
0.0723887384,
0.2935809791,
-0.2840951085,
-0.4610238671,
0.1801479459,
-0.2259017229,
-0.2286917716,
-0.4444403946,
0.5999746323,
-0.5701829791,
-0.5748547912,
0.2743144035,
0.2078328282,
-0.1148992702,
0.0577964485,
-0.6802675724,
0.0003951277,
0.0575859584,
0.1711042672,
0.3160649538,
0.7299984694,
-0.1187912077,
0.6918200254,
0.6821683645,
-0.0045839548,
-0.1187080741,
0.2634352148,
1.0068590641,
-0.5011678934,
-0.8230119348,
-0.9162305593,
0.4948481917,
0.0412291139,
-0.3080698252,
0.312079072,
0.7116106153,
0.6889203191,
-0.0413223132,
0.6472027898,
0.0389577858,
0.3375135064,
-0.4238244593,
0.7140212059,
-0.4924706519,
0.0208597258,
-0.354002744,
-0.6613772511,
-0.7597276568,
0.4300622046,
0.2102892697,
0.0823205635,
1.0325442553,
0.5357619524,
-0.3758267462,
-0.3116974533,
0.1821079552,
0.0584980845,
0.1388624012,
0.8456809521,
0.4204232395,
-0.220527038,
0.8108304739,
-0.4649681151,
-0.2383083254,
-0.6636890769,
-0.6566744447,
-0.7988386154,
-0.620845437,
-0.5546419024,
-0.1885617077,
-0.0046518533,
0.9680631757,
0.8235337734,
-0.8334248662,
0.1151361316,
-0.1344384402,
0.1716442555,
-0.3523795605,
-0.078652449,
0.7328138351,
-0.287599504,
-0.3394222856,
-0.0769649297,
0.6517084241,
0.1681537628,
0.1794990301,
-0.1876780987,
0.0307391658,
-0.6198464036,
0.4199474454,
-0.1476703882,
-0.759390831,
0.0188414082,
0.0337626711,
-0.3425410688,
0.7265118361,
1.0655212402,
-0.8296843767,
0.6705468893,
0.1655547768,
0.6826890111,
0.4638291001,
0.1651383787,
-0.0203559957,
-0.5692825317,
0.0103694154,
0.5014368296,
0.285025686,
0.1879750192,
-0.3362550437,
-0.0581496097,
0.1361842155,
-0.2183303833,
-0.6967005134,
0.0613202378,
-1.1629477739,
-0.0118373279,
0.852501452,
-0.1337525398,
-0.3672867715,
-0.4921454489,
-0.694452703,
0.0887497663,
-0.5507230163,
0.7126487494,
0.1172674447,
-0.0811708868,
-0.8962221146,
-0.3865613639,
0.7009137273,
0.3150550723,
-0.8910707235,
0.1525208801,
0.456111908,
-0.208720386,
0.4459933639,
0.6988430619,
-0.0863427296,
0.546245873,
-0.2210087925,
0.304759562,
-0.1708730906,
-0.5826173425,
-0.4164226949,
0.4956803024,
0.1174436063,
-0.3362790346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18565v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18565v1 | PaLI-X: On Scaling up a Multilingual Vision and Language Model | 2023-05-29T18:58:38 | 2023-05-29T18:58:38 | Xi Chen, Josip Djolonga, Piotr Padlewski, Basil Mustafa, Soravit Changpinyo, Jialin Wu, Carlos Riquelme Ruiz, Sebastian Goodman, Xiao Wang, Yi Tay, Siamak Shakeri, Mostafa Dehghani, Daniel Salz, Mario Lucic, Michael Tschannen, Arsha Nagrani, Hexiang Hu, Mandar Joshi, Bo Pang, Ceslee Montgomery, Paulina Pietrzyk, Marvin Ritter, AJ Piergiovanni, Matthias Minderer, Filip Pavetic, Austin Waters, Gang Li, Ibrahim Alabdulmohsin, Lucas Beyer, Julien Amelot, Kenton Lee, Andreas Peter Steiner, Yang Li, Daniel Keysers, Anurag Arnab, Yuanzhong Xu, Keran Rong, Alexander Kolesnikov, Mojtaba Seyedhosseini, Anelia Angelova, Xiaohua Zhai, Neil Houlsby, Radu Soricut | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | We present the training recipe and results of scaling up PaLI-X, a
multilingual vision and language model, both in terms of size of the components
and the breadth of its training task mixture. Our model achieves new levels of
performance on a wide-range of varied and complex tasks, including multiple
image-based captioning and question-answering tasks, image-based document
understanding and few-shot (in-context) learning, as well as object detection,
video question answering, and video captioning. PaLI-X advances the
state-of-the-art on most vision-and-language benchmarks considered (25+ of
them). Finally, we observe emerging capabilities, such as complex counting and
multilingual object detection, tasks that are not explicitly in the training
mix. | [
-0.3052145243,
-0.2317431122,
0.2552806139,
0.2976977527,
-0.2296877056,
0.3220599592,
-0.0883619264,
-0.6342517138,
0.1645694971,
0.4305569828,
-0.4650132954,
-0.2549835443,
-0.8123867512,
0.0267874077,
-0.4622401297,
0.7579211593,
0.0562907904,
0.3318627775,
0.1256792694,
-0.5163987279,
-0.6516278386,
-0.4021067321,
-0.9498335123,
0.1478994936,
0.4876527488,
0.2968126833,
0.6570466161,
0.9932638407,
0.5779687762,
0.3490103483,
-0.010697782,
0.0261203554,
-0.3243126273,
0.0485227518,
-0.1554365903,
-0.9888369441,
-0.7425346375,
-0.2836459875,
1.360103488,
0.8271629214,
-0.1953393668,
0.3396825492,
-0.2913211286,
0.4694534838,
-0.6441509128,
0.2423948497,
-0.5471376181,
-0.0584884733,
-0.2376205474,
0.2377086282,
-0.3021695316,
0.1629809737,
0.1290520281,
-0.7661215067,
0.196825996,
0.3562511802,
0.6590697169,
0.0189706963,
-0.4896346331,
0.0813086554,
-0.2741578221,
0.9005514979,
-0.2882946134,
0.75968647,
0.0659827888,
0.6820696592,
0.4379681051,
-0.6628264785,
-0.604763031,
-0.1739941835,
0.123081252,
-0.2111778706,
-0.399248749,
-0.1186706573,
0.1891448796,
0.6833515167,
-0.6687631607,
0.006388973,
-0.4999718666,
0.04352846,
0.5188767314,
0.2453521341,
0.6699298024,
0.0366363302,
-0.2826661468,
-0.4622673094,
-0.8156539202,
-0.0318604782,
0.0871341974,
0.3342044055,
-0.266505301,
0.4859417379,
-0.4332848489,
1.1242954731,
-0.4630417824,
-0.2066649497,
0.2147226483,
-0.5671509504,
-0.3929333985,
0.0797510818,
0.3254178464,
0.5487487912,
0.1461813599,
0.0506921969,
0.0048071854,
0.0767778158,
0.1100191548,
-0.5593830347,
-0.0884900391,
-0.379009366,
-0.4700209796,
-0.3423310518,
-0.4230708778,
-0.8605934978,
-0.37491557,
-0.4303120375,
0.5120857358,
-0.2728044391,
-0.5860337019,
0.2719384134,
-0.0942366496,
0.2467099875,
0.615392983,
-0.9628978968,
0.6273884177,
0.4115729034,
1.0135928392,
-0.3183891177,
-0.6347958446,
-0.887465179,
0.124336265,
-0.5246266723,
0.5794968605,
-0.6299643517,
-0.1445802003,
-0.1562466025,
-0.0124070039,
0.0265075285,
-0.4300578237,
0.0781070143,
-0.37588799,
0.180312112,
-0.653904736,
-0.2107471526,
-0.2800608873,
0.6603928208,
-0.8703011274,
0.9566774964,
0.3312411308,
-0.5432177782,
0.6919795871,
-0.6173151731,
-0.4474900663,
0.1767196506,
-0.2087842375,
-0.036350362,
0.2963602543,
0.2484655976,
0.2078360617,
-0.5285720825,
-0.1682277024,
-0.2167935073,
-0.1085326523,
-0.0119068464,
-0.4363789856,
0.8847842813,
-0.0179224256,
-0.308531791,
0.3842010498,
-1.2609027624,
0.0468218476,
0.0567460693,
-0.5204262733,
-0.3795089424,
-0.2924262285,
0.2358562499,
0.4161087871,
0.1642139703,
-0.8264297247,
0.1748321801,
-0.3986436725,
0.3782008588,
0.4780982137,
-0.5294008851,
0.5642655492,
-0.0418846086,
0.703881681,
-0.0760350004,
0.1214110926,
-0.688488543,
-0.7317354679,
-0.9332475662,
-0.386529386,
0.0897955596,
0.5137530565,
-0.623113513,
-0.1878852397,
-0.5003615618,
-0.3316831291,
-0.6662493944,
0.2849622071,
0.6771277189,
0.5869585872,
0.3445890844,
-0.4876455069,
-0.5460785627,
-0.710151732,
0.075761117,
-0.2817234397,
0.2031270713,
0.0866449997,
0.3319493532,
0.0437791757,
0.4940899014,
-0.5974028707,
-0.2179808766,
-0.4968388081,
0.1013581604,
-0.3852969408,
0.3238030374,
0.4801724851,
-1.0632596016,
-0.7022320628,
0.5262801051,
-0.5672904849,
0.2646138072,
0.0799553618,
0.0731108114,
0.2246208191,
0.5393506885,
-0.4212086201,
0.3301138878,
0.5070478916,
-0.3664201498,
0.6063535213,
-0.3948616087,
0.3331917822,
-1.179620266,
-0.1130488291,
0.052934166,
-0.5116899014,
-0.6077203751,
0.6249468327,
0.3455893695,
-0.287235409,
-0.7445858717,
0.6749124527,
-0.4610459208,
-0.4787646532,
-0.3236778975,
-0.0305062104,
0.1171549186,
0.4733271301,
0.3710379601,
0.8708634973,
1.1665219069,
-0.1991242319,
0.6216259003,
0.0067882352,
-0.6360014081,
0.8240563869,
-0.5878489614,
-0.4403644502,
-0.0066004344,
-0.0774599165,
-1.2203521729,
-0.2476866245,
-0.1237553358,
-0.1396660209,
0.4312184751,
0.1154582575,
-0.7339413762,
-0.3595603108,
-0.1688816249,
0.7668742537,
0.2288070917,
-0.6215245724,
0.5459868908,
0.1828226298,
-0.1654058397,
-0.5620468259,
-0.7987128496,
0.4896774292,
-0.1265470982,
-0.5075163245,
0.1894166321,
0.2612970173,
-0.3138095438,
-0.0800652802,
0.042822551,
-0.2554188073,
-0.2183736563,
-0.0405332223,
0.184965685,
-0.4813884199,
0.0188331176,
0.1700740159,
-0.0301368106,
-0.0732514933,
-0.1674913764,
0.5635036826,
-0.4830100536,
-0.2828930318,
-0.2737229764,
0.6585604548,
0.8796424866,
-0.6144837141,
0.4036031961,
0.680172205,
-0.2881216407,
0.193367973,
-0.4811735749,
0.0908478349,
-0.4027795494,
0.9567149878,
-0.4761935771,
-0.8119894266,
0.4538581967,
-0.0233397372,
-0.1706758142,
0.2233788371,
0.7593889832,
0.1257042736,
1.4952162504,
1.1391891241,
-0.0326110274,
0.4095424116,
-0.2555426657,
-0.0072924295,
-0.8005055785,
-0.2925888598,
-0.0341122709,
-0.3022716045,
-0.4774005115,
-0.6002239585,
0.4012727439,
-0.1984184086,
-0.1382992566,
0.5435593724,
-0.2035124898,
0.5609409809,
0.8209801316,
-0.0165044982,
0.4729366601,
0.0382631682,
0.0710694939,
0.0366937146,
-0.9145652056,
0.0010005911,
1.4101135731,
0.2547456026,
0.6365029812,
0.2729021013,
0.2040537894,
0.1183575019,
0.1101757884,
-0.4906946421,
0.6462188959,
-0.3145674467,
-0.9295754433,
-0.313005954,
-0.1700963378,
-0.7012935877,
0.5057892799,
0.0354742222,
-0.7627882361,
0.3467646837,
0.0853672475,
-0.4670623243,
0.5947847366,
-0.7573415041,
0.9880238771,
-0.3890527487,
-0.1324984878,
-0.6484012008,
-0.9963360429,
0.4367735982,
-0.1906135529,
0.0548269786,
0.0818949714,
-0.3513794541,
0.5085732937,
-0.2236168683,
0.970780611,
0.1381393075,
-0.0936816931,
0.0109545402,
0.0641677231,
-0.1277415454,
0.0458134636,
0.1187544614,
0.0479225777,
0.1910020262,
-0.6025569439,
-0.6901853681,
0.5864289999,
-0.7874844074,
-0.4461784065,
-0.3854748607,
-1.1202330589,
-0.1244345382,
0.3721542656,
0.0840382501,
0.5827047825,
-0.0251089539,
0.1964146942,
0.677608788,
-0.1617355496,
0.3484137952,
0.4751332998,
-0.6939340234,
-0.6007147431,
1.2652008533,
0.216292277,
0.7112922668,
0.7061814666,
-0.0840945542,
-0.2736620903,
-0.1185433194,
-1.0535522699,
0.0393727273,
-0.8829416633,
-0.1028121933,
-0.3307406604,
0.122582987,
-0.3355602622,
-0.0697037131,
-0.493549943,
-0.5896772742,
0.0101826396,
0.0153806871,
-0.0433044434,
0.6409077048,
-0.053245794,
0.6968330741,
-0.5168276429,
0.2509120405,
0.5141782761,
0.3976275027,
0.0184320919,
-0.5156391859,
-0.4564374387,
-0.1154674739,
-0.1649736464,
-0.6847128272,
0.4830234945,
0.3489963412,
0.3402279615,
0.5887952447,
-0.748368144,
0.6684924364,
-0.6495652795,
0.6873849034,
0.5845922828,
-0.873259306,
0.6440176964,
-0.3125633299,
0.496465683,
0.2789850533,
0.3650912046,
-0.5159650445,
-0.1680712253,
-0.3683277071,
-0.5078223944,
0.6393035054,
0.0091270544,
0.2601380646,
0.1625501364,
0.356282115,
0.279484123,
0.3986073434,
-0.877681911,
-0.1235160157,
-0.2915871441,
0.0552989654,
-0.1076279208,
-0.2412748933,
-0.1540913433,
-0.7398434281,
0.3689854145,
-0.1210190654,
-0.0038297919,
-0.2939165533,
-0.2346306741,
-0.0218047202,
0.061256323,
0.8171759844,
0.7726121545,
-0.0755454302,
0.2481231242,
0.3642496467,
-0.5397680998,
0.3472137451,
0.0151873166,
0.0813450143,
-0.1923145056,
0.4985405803,
1.2508939505,
0.4412275553,
-1.0122021437,
0.3866393566,
0.0068758,
-0.1354157925,
0.3315565288,
0.1137136891,
-0.307395041,
0.3053504229,
0.207147032,
0.2621887326,
0.2409424633,
-0.8384990096,
-0.0171460994,
0.2826145887,
-0.3028842807,
-0.4451415241,
0.6554444432,
-0.0281219855,
-0.0949640721,
0.4458153248,
-0.4317352176,
-0.4738253653,
0.4835912883,
0.8934648037,
0.4787567556,
-0.204799667,
0.3707842231,
0.276953727,
0.5434620976,
-0.1383768469,
0.6730518341,
-0.4298413098,
-0.6492741108,
-0.5747449398,
-0.5052749515,
-0.5033881068,
-0.1508482397,
-0.8387786746,
0.2549038529,
-0.151834473,
0.1112719625,
0.0133313444,
-0.0225423649,
-0.5121754408,
0.6061097383,
0.4042852521,
1.1438462734,
-1.0342364311,
1.0816563368,
1.1372773647,
-0.5949112177,
-0.547285974,
-0.343919158,
-0.0887149125,
-1.1687191725,
0.9147940874,
0.2198843062,
-0.0131633682,
0.0836670175,
-0.1211146489,
-1.3151874542,
1.0763183832,
0.7576309443,
-0.5660763383,
-0.3126710355,
0.403357327,
0.5306075215,
-0.4465188682,
-0.097905986,
0.5801506042,
0.2250101268,
0.0709214732,
-1.0231862068,
-0.1136562377,
-0.4826613665,
0.1533994973,
0.1941870302,
-0.5734762549,
0.9925703406,
-0.2320600897,
0.2597378492,
0.1846979409,
0.7039315701,
0.1763800979,
0.1214527637,
0.6483690143,
0.9892600775,
0.6766215563,
-0.0353136845,
1.2736721039,
-0.1789773703,
-0.0959493071,
1.2616555691,
-0.3492817283,
1.0617949963,
0.4142908752,
-0.3898029029,
0.6075252295,
0.7277260423,
-0.0159819275,
0.6017059088,
-0.0411205254,
-0.5005667806,
-0.4816423059,
-0.1813511103,
-0.3697776496,
0.6127973795,
0.3501540124,
-0.2273786366,
-0.5586366057,
0.7266649604,
-0.3847723305,
-0.2146986574,
-0.770352006,
0.502771318,
-0.1472930014,
-0.5385502577,
0.3393907249,
-0.0168630295,
0.3908133507,
-0.5179460049,
0.0648819506,
0.0148749752,
0.3166551888,
0.1233115122,
-1.0828591585,
0.3561938107,
-0.1403052211,
-0.264537394,
-0.2166860104,
0.6920204759,
-0.4698612988,
-0.9474517703,
0.2581976652,
0.4734455645,
0.2178667337,
-0.3701033592,
-0.6289711595,
0.3037445843,
-0.1367090493,
0.1693642884,
0.4653499722,
0.4703974426,
-0.4715395272,
0.7793607116,
0.3321029544,
0.3375831246,
0.6864544749,
0.2527033389,
0.9062829018,
-0.2603128552,
-0.541981101,
-0.7654771805,
0.4584731758,
-0.314519614,
-0.503708601,
0.7608584166,
0.7254080772,
1.0988428593,
-0.010890008,
0.487903595,
0.0311205219,
0.1196268797,
-0.0068903281,
0.4801159799,
-0.9808263779,
-0.2109281272,
-0.0793015286,
-0.8858598471,
-0.7967848182,
0.3846438825,
-0.2979028821,
-0.108517617,
0.4141287208,
0.6343756318,
-0.2138564587,
-0.1066203639,
0.5964486003,
-0.1238385066,
0.1550672501,
0.3072083294,
0.427544713,
-0.4661506116,
0.7455175519,
-0.4064773917,
-0.5182062984,
0.0285106823,
-0.6415852904,
-0.7753149867,
-0.8308082819,
-0.408596307,
0.1569967866,
-0.005703426,
0.510161221,
1.1467007399,
-0.751694262,
-0.5647056699,
-0.4088205695,
-0.0347140394,
-0.5347021818,
-0.0857770965,
0.2520176768,
-0.5374388695,
-0.7522526979,
0.3321306109,
0.8404547572,
-0.102645807,
-0.6374323964,
-0.0951898396,
-0.384806484,
-0.0643992722,
1.0329662561,
0.4027638733,
-0.8140336871,
0.0968026817,
0.1853481084,
0.1773366332,
0.2374259531,
0.617169261,
-0.5992829204,
0.9533237219,
0.449159205,
0.6327010989,
0.6541286111,
-0.3460463583,
0.8469485044,
-0.9278876185,
0.2582220435,
-0.2738437355,
0.5198050737,
0.5148856044,
-0.012531992,
0.3912907839,
0.2206593603,
-0.2094095498,
-1.0977643728,
0.200793609,
-1.1499236822,
-0.0931420252,
0.891120851,
-0.2045046091,
-0.2298658639,
0.2974607646,
-0.4855923057,
0.1159256101,
0.1137805209,
0.5840476155,
0.7004944682,
0.0396761671,
-0.4834801555,
-0.5399549603,
0.1157525405,
0.6225152612,
-0.8846939802,
0.1359086633,
0.195518747,
0.2021687776,
0.4378583729,
0.3834642768,
-0.1193971857,
0.8543316126,
0.118094638,
0.0767611787,
0.2513994873,
-0.6034227014,
-0.3797301054,
0.3041054308,
0.0802600235,
-0.5245897174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.00008v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.00008v2 | Brainformers: Trading Simplicity for Efficiency | 2023-05-29T18:42:01 | 2024-04-25T05:46:01 | Yanqi Zhou, Nan Du, Yanping Huang, Daiyi Peng, Chang Lan, Da Huang, Siamak Shakeri, David So, Andrew Dai, Yifeng Lu, Zhifeng Chen, Quoc Le, Claire Cui, James Laudon, Jeff Dean | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Transformers are central to recent successes in natural language processing
and computer vision. Transformers have a mostly uniform backbone where layers
alternate between feed-forward and self-attention in order to build a deep
network. Here we investigate this design choice and find that more complex
blocks that have different permutations of layer primitives can be more
efficient. Using this insight, we develop a complex block, named Brainformer,
that consists of a diverse sets of layers such as sparsely gated feed-forward
layers, dense feed-forward layers, attention layers, and various forms of layer
normalization and activation functions. Brainformer consistently outperforms
the state-of-the-art dense and sparse Transformers, in terms of both quality
and efficiency. A Brainformer model with 8 billion activated parameters per
token demonstrates 2x faster training convergence and 5x faster step time
compared to its GLaM counterpart. In downstream task evaluation, Brainformer
also demonstrates a 3% higher SuperGLUE score with fine-tuning compared to GLaM
with a similar number of activated parameters. Finally, Brainformer largely
outperforms a Primer dense model derived with NAS with similar computation per
token on fewshot evaluations. | [
-0.4394575059,
-0.4734406471,
0.3495295346,
0.3851207197,
0.0024203924,
0.0083994316,
-0.4227075577,
-0.3359166384,
0.0914212912,
0.4726527333,
-0.3171587288,
-0.0465489291,
-0.8716314435,
-0.0718199015,
-0.5507348776,
0.9478425384,
0.2623188198,
-0.0437675156,
-0.0295037199,
0.0376531892,
-0.5113152266,
-0.1952345073,
-0.9770252109,
-0.7243350744,
0.5856136084,
0.3577655256,
0.9838122129,
0.6175639629,
0.5617286563,
0.4948076308,
0.0551324487,
-0.0929573327,
-0.5367048383,
0.0646746606,
-0.0581047609,
-0.4177339971,
-0.5151715279,
-0.2919981778,
0.1865198761,
0.7877899408,
-0.1706981361,
0.124636285,
0.2096440941,
0.8142077923,
-0.6193350554,
0.179386273,
-0.5727776885,
0.1514211893,
-0.119265534,
0.1571429521,
-0.4924593568,
-0.1823154539,
0.1841247231,
-0.5202133656,
0.3157453835,
-0.1051319614,
0.6929636598,
0.5506483316,
-0.0278041922,
-0.0135654612,
-0.7262182236,
0.6606084704,
-0.3255812824,
0.562094748,
-0.1341301203,
0.7176764011,
0.0136531414,
-1.262747407,
-0.5888085961,
0.1539209634,
-0.3504596353,
0.3158356547,
-0.6482899785,
0.172526598,
0.3122744858,
0.4428934753,
-0.4176467955,
0.2568160892,
-0.5006468892,
-0.2135530412,
0.4366032779,
0.1407970935,
0.1655132771,
-0.3073115349,
-0.2301271558,
-0.401897788,
-0.2091536224,
0.3583405018,
0.217728138,
-0.0322554894,
0.118009299,
0.4849986136,
-0.3290266097,
0.8887856007,
0.6452431679,
0.0265834052,
0.0101306811,
0.0867680088,
-0.6083415747,
0.0374361053,
0.6884333491,
0.3396131098,
0.4762652218,
-0.5785708427,
-0.3536808193,
0.171408087,
0.8712717295,
-1.0853075981,
-0.7259860039,
0.2132173181,
-0.6188313365,
-0.3204643726,
-0.0572767854,
-0.4019888341,
-0.1129527315,
-0.6775466204,
0.6810740232,
-0.5184838176,
0.2118662894,
0.3377750516,
-0.3770894706,
0.3592693806,
0.3453955054,
-1.1546752453,
0.6734433174,
0.6176434159,
0.6575061679,
-0.3539792299,
-0.0189108066,
-0.3087497652,
-0.121488601,
-0.1852381378,
1.0912239552,
-0.4160320163,
-0.0101220869,
-0.5578886271,
-0.0805603266,
0.0468696617,
-0.6581792235,
0.5343105793,
-0.695443511,
0.2358863205,
-0.1378577799,
-0.1925517768,
-0.4465907216,
-0.0588247366,
-0.9574038386,
0.7131250501,
0.2968271077,
-0.4841662347,
0.6440622211,
-0.6526044011,
-0.4864728749,
0.381029129,
-0.2389017195,
-0.293425113,
0.1975672245,
0.1420682818,
0.6562011242,
-0.1975483447,
0.2999737561,
0.1772452146,
-0.6758154035,
0.1472596079,
-0.5698934793,
0.5673368573,
-0.010301047,
-0.7372167706,
0.3009740114,
-0.9082225561,
0.178492263,
-0.0232986305,
-0.327016741,
-0.0456120633,
-0.0754725412,
0.4779139459,
0.31029737,
-0.1052485332,
-0.3810160756,
0.0225785132,
-0.4468704164,
0.6849272847,
0.6869729757,
-0.4485032558,
0.7546395063,
-0.3013732433,
0.2954895496,
0.0156608056,
0.3728420436,
0.0907564908,
-0.4316162467,
-1.0528926849,
-0.3073446453,
0.3695234358,
0.4755815268,
-0.3417420685,
0.6301800013,
-0.3408007622,
-0.7697914243,
-0.6252117753,
0.1181328669,
0.2174163163,
0.3805172145,
0.5401319265,
-0.5052333474,
-0.6048228741,
-1.4484895468,
-0.3213743567,
0.4886424243,
-0.223598823,
0.0460049659,
0.1172611043,
-0.2891085148,
0.8915656805,
-0.578481853,
-0.2708907723,
-0.2204248756,
-0.0711132884,
0.6285655499,
0.5624078512,
0.4979579747,
-0.6768743992,
-0.4397074282,
-0.016356064,
-0.5990041494,
0.2054834813,
-0.2120962441,
-0.1377613246,
-0.0731917843,
0.3623951375,
-0.755405426,
0.3195181191,
0.5605837107,
-0.0679894537,
0.299530983,
0.0441640951,
-0.1996921897,
-0.5378705859,
0.2853950262,
-0.2126393616,
-0.2136254311,
-0.7879021168,
-0.2851289511,
0.0455120802,
0.0242466256,
-0.3888517022,
0.2416186333,
-0.3315972686,
0.219198972,
-0.2391047925,
-0.0338847078,
0.0185871553,
0.8331818581,
-0.380112946,
0.7575052381,
0.627063632,
-0.6222819686,
0.2298507541,
0.1849413812,
-0.3285180628,
0.4634892941,
-1.2109767199,
0.3244873285,
-0.515786767,
0.0691192597,
-0.9533628225,
-0.2714048028,
0.0864226744,
-0.1119460091,
0.3919818699,
0.1605410874,
-0.2267220765,
-0.5491639376,
-0.2268330008,
0.36598593,
0.6162605882,
-0.4633333087,
0.9732739329,
0.3318939209,
0.0762402788,
-0.6973360181,
-0.9835888147,
0.1606871337,
0.1342224777,
-0.785492897,
0.8523463607,
-0.1050155014,
0.0801535696,
0.0591545627,
-0.3875873983,
0.0907714739,
-0.0224684328,
0.4391861856,
0.0101271383,
-0.3325155079,
-0.0969998538,
0.2182614058,
-0.3441235721,
0.1404445767,
-0.5887691975,
0.6833337545,
-0.2081959099,
-0.1203830168,
-0.3567092121,
0.3041869998,
0.6564911008,
-0.0125952223,
0.5744289756,
0.5935419798,
-0.341286391,
-0.2576464117,
-0.8725958467,
-0.2963390648,
-0.58309865,
0.3696643412,
-0.511177361,
-0.8867935538,
0.3824992478,
0.2043031603,
0.0556025319,
0.5611004829,
0.4491136372,
0.0064420705,
1.0288574696,
0.5728064179,
0.2110833377,
0.3835240602,
-0.4743065834,
0.3429300487,
-0.7726560831,
-0.4670582712,
-0.051427193,
-0.8880246282,
-0.4793807268,
-0.1840251535,
0.3456862271,
0.1047874093,
-0.3687808514,
0.6945649981,
-0.9694160819,
0.7281296849,
0.6094450951,
0.3744125664,
0.1313825101,
0.1115128174,
0.0120667499,
-0.04189099,
-0.9650889039,
-0.6465177536,
0.9408317804,
0.2059555948,
0.7687234282,
-0.0236520953,
0.249008283,
-0.0704681426,
0.2839303613,
-0.9776816368,
0.404379338,
-0.6275216341,
-0.3390626907,
-0.1629325002,
-0.0690817833,
-0.9396970272,
0.1590831429,
-0.2299399376,
-0.4209456742,
0.4587567747,
0.1657226235,
-0.6443864703,
0.2202966958,
-0.8532423377,
1.0269201994,
-0.1676421165,
-0.3658419847,
-0.2047108859,
-0.7549248934,
0.3557851315,
-0.0473934412,
-0.3670255542,
0.3250641227,
0.0971759483,
0.6771628261,
-0.0828770623,
0.6893663406,
0.0936463922,
0.3686969578,
0.0719391853,
-0.0267663654,
0.0966681838,
0.0082337186,
-0.0368532948,
0.1745919436,
-0.7132694125,
-0.4086105824,
-0.7779683471,
0.6433488131,
-0.9086619616,
-0.5828969479,
0.0957106352,
-0.4297566116,
0.1590067595,
0.5225455761,
0.3215932548,
0.8021726608,
-0.035155341,
0.6130558252,
0.6255887151,
0.1761861593,
0.6517572403,
-0.1616413444,
0.1579910517,
-0.4339581728,
0.5066092014,
0.3144873977,
0.2709199786,
0.489941597,
0.0463649742,
-0.1126101092,
-0.3741625845,
-0.3287257552,
-0.0461233966,
-0.86780864,
-0.4376854599,
-1.1405576468,
-0.6988137364,
-0.0535367355,
-0.2162732631,
-0.4683903456,
-0.3973630369,
-0.0314411744,
0.0399470069,
0.1434948891,
0.8449507356,
0.1961832643,
0.6206284761,
-0.3168946505,
0.4596939981,
1.0046439171,
0.7247558832,
0.2727230191,
-0.2377311736,
-0.2546758056,
-0.2910864353,
-0.5557827353,
-0.6223579645,
0.1264518499,
0.1161434501,
0.7186724544,
0.3154676855,
-0.4008345902,
0.8084738851,
-0.6092517972,
0.3899141252,
0.226578638,
-1.044662118,
0.1627216786,
-0.0000647967,
0.4483726323,
0.6914756894,
0.1738476157,
-0.3709101677,
-0.1208482608,
-0.6540536284,
-0.8748218417,
0.7011100054,
0.3586625755,
0.1639727354,
0.1882101893,
0.2909292281,
0.2526860535,
0.2000865787,
-0.5968534946,
-0.413193047,
-0.8077267408,
-0.1451462209,
0.1165356189,
0.0201698057,
0.0940470248,
-0.4804968834,
0.1675978601,
-0.2732897699,
0.4104001522,
0.4046343267,
-0.3378643692,
-0.0027356367,
0.2011735588,
0.4392846823,
0.5095503926,
0.0237660203,
0.4736827612,
0.3449109495,
-0.6550192237,
-0.0106854131,
-0.144174099,
-0.1851356477,
-0.1670037359,
0.1301546097,
1.118491888,
0.4972261786,
-0.3666695058,
0.4296371639,
-0.2815942466,
-0.2323237658,
-0.3003922403,
0.4098724723,
0.1664595604,
0.3004252613,
0.3779092133,
1.0971910954,
0.5498341918,
-0.1930554807,
0.3455994725,
0.3184681237,
-0.5788263083,
-0.3382557333,
0.730933249,
0.041844029,
-0.5574185252,
0.6610729694,
-0.0751967132,
-0.5936088562,
0.4955120981,
0.6203594804,
1.0181758404,
0.0576670729,
-0.0214713253,
0.1248763055,
0.3578425646,
-0.1809450388,
0.0294371229,
-0.0369860977,
-0.6454241872,
-0.8239816427,
-0.5525909066,
-0.2222301215,
0.0876377299,
-0.3981869817,
0.4623224735,
-0.6685744524,
-0.3286231756,
0.2979153991,
-0.3732848763,
-1.180787921,
0.3948068321,
0.1621067524,
0.9462544322,
-0.473829329,
0.5860617757,
0.8088327646,
-0.2001617551,
-0.9134841561,
-0.256554395,
-0.4375054836,
-0.6291024685,
0.8922053576,
0.5431808829,
-0.3574817777,
0.2516019046,
-0.3461820483,
-0.8035238981,
1.1764189005,
0.4555246532,
-0.6926887035,
-0.1797740012,
-0.1487136781,
0.4489202797,
-0.2154617906,
0.7646314502,
0.6609894633,
0.5426908731,
0.0446443297,
-0.5546819568,
0.2509457171,
-0.4164628088,
0.1831270009,
0.1035123244,
-0.6808355451,
0.8857923746,
0.1059288979,
-0.4225051105,
-0.4162375629,
0.6756988168,
-0.0219213516,
-0.2750187218,
0.6952980161,
0.5636797547,
0.4059506357,
-0.121435076,
0.9498190284,
-0.3297507763,
0.0470238477,
0.6351078153,
0.253603965,
0.6327033043,
0.3911606669,
-0.0816465691,
0.8564496636,
-0.0908284932,
-0.1063215584,
0.3763269484,
0.2629268169,
0.2575600743,
-0.357147485,
0.2540305257,
0.0143192094,
0.823990047,
0.0043871128,
-0.1473823041,
-0.1379030943,
-0.1503360122,
-0.0392177925,
0.0513341837,
-0.1481573135,
0.6775689125,
0.1278139055,
-0.8256923556,
0.5350043774,
-0.1585942507,
1.069899559,
-0.4244948626,
0.0764941052,
-0.064537406,
0.3609557152,
-0.4705358148,
-0.7760378122,
0.557541728,
-0.4011560082,
-0.4382613599,
-0.3397859931,
0.8807529211,
-0.1346949339,
-0.4448859096,
0.2920991182,
0.2338812202,
-0.2443516999,
-0.3127747774,
-0.5208153129,
-0.0438613817,
-0.4221452177,
-0.2946943045,
-0.0410167426,
0.2248263359,
0.2018095106,
0.5280844569,
0.6759232879,
-0.0649691299,
0.1536561698,
0.2483932823,
1.0797741413,
-0.8232939243,
-0.327572763,
-0.9287199378,
0.7664263248,
-0.5499480963,
-0.4749008119,
0.5471258163,
0.6310537457,
0.695821166,
-0.3818950653,
0.4634846151,
0.0671354383,
-0.0890331492,
-0.3950161934,
0.9521747828,
-0.2669230998,
-0.0786625519,
-0.1982844472,
-1.1858838797,
-0.523549974,
0.7514589429,
-0.047990445,
0.0582836121,
0.761539042,
0.6453235745,
-0.43084535,
0.167707637,
0.2296266258,
0.2183896005,
0.2055515051,
0.7193951011,
0.6238686442,
-0.8527670503,
0.52280128,
-0.4099904001,
-0.1968561262,
-0.0799306929,
-0.6526381373,
-0.9893384576,
-0.2404240668,
-0.1229262277,
-0.0331611559,
-0.1849178821,
0.7165278196,
1.2042286396,
-0.9599506259,
-0.3334565163,
-0.292412281,
-0.0761504471,
-0.4093609452,
-0.2578457594,
0.0410567112,
-0.5788103342,
-0.6742688417,
0.2323120385,
0.5806763172,
-0.1323309094,
-0.3334417641,
0.1445641965,
0.3502327502,
0.0299217366,
0.8870744109,
-0.2705947459,
-0.7177968025,
-0.3547591269,
0.497377485,
-0.3308754265,
0.1639090329,
0.791146934,
-1.2721791267,
0.1709464043,
0.6190007925,
0.7323009968,
0.6659679413,
-0.2234707773,
0.6240703464,
-0.4624050558,
-0.0272058547,
0.1731567532,
0.2664240599,
0.3982644379,
-0.3394800723,
0.2622700632,
-0.0198149625,
-0.6948035359,
-0.3155846,
0.0940613896,
-1.3865157366,
-0.1107189953,
0.6243752241,
0.5152729154,
-0.4578489959,
-0.160943836,
-0.4303682446,
0.2025508434,
-0.3799824417,
0.7481884956,
0.282437861,
-0.1567721069,
-0.1208741367,
-0.3858483732,
0.5685327649,
0.6000047922,
-0.5649736524,
-0.3266734779,
-0.0613592379,
0.3655282259,
0.5624281168,
0.3481757641,
-0.0879609138,
0.2646909356,
-0.0536975227,
0.1692151129,
-0.0728950948,
-0.4014474154,
-0.3240904212,
0.5751917958,
-0.2021347433,
0.0394945182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18554v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18554v2 | Forgotten Knowledge: Examining the Citational Amnesia in NLP | 2023-05-29T18:30:34 | 2023-07-31T17:38:03 | Janvijay Singh, Mukund Rungta, Diyi Yang, Saif M. Mohammad | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | Citing papers is the primary method through which modern scientific writing
discusses and builds on past work. Collectively, citing a diverse set of papers
(in time and area of study) is an indicator of how widely the community is
reading. Yet, there is little work looking at broad temporal patterns of
citation. This work systematically and empirically examines: How far back in
time do we tend to go to cite papers? How has that changed over time, and what
factors correlate with this citational attention/amnesia? We chose NLP as our
domain of interest and analyzed approximately 71.5K papers to show and quantify
several key trends in citation. Notably, around 62% of cited papers are from
the immediate five years prior to publication, whereas only about 17% are more
than ten years old. Furthermore, we show that the median age and age diversity
of cited papers were steadily increasing from 1990 to 2014, but since then, the
trend has reversed, and current NLP papers have an all-time low temporal
citation diversity. Finally, we show that unlike the 1990s, the highly cited
papers in the last decade were also papers with the least citation diversity,
likely contributing to the intense (and arguably harmful) recency focus. Code,
data, and a demo are available on the project homepage. | [
-0.2933386266,
-0.2269741595,
0.8312984109,
0.4911063015,
0.3012390733,
0.2063195109,
0.2105093896,
-0.6856131554,
0.3620679677,
0.1588238329,
-0.212090224,
-0.4123750925,
-0.7008444071,
0.2871148586,
-0.3617488146,
0.9971920252,
0.179852128,
-0.2367476076,
-0.2180835754,
-0.2240718901,
-0.3164162338,
-0.6351639032,
-0.4819267094,
-0.2814430296,
1.0596876144,
0.0075556538,
0.1426014602,
0.3713742197,
0.2942410111,
0.0901760682,
-0.5057025552,
0.0008107948,
-0.551748693,
0.1830992699,
-0.6897242665,
-0.4384225309,
-0.3353797495,
-0.2557525039,
0.6830562949,
1.1764566898,
0.2710591555,
0.1215877905,
0.0490578115,
1.1458290815,
-1.0744358301,
-0.0851525441,
-0.7566252947,
-0.0463036261,
-0.2731775939,
-0.6780281663,
-0.5699192286,
-0.4477990568,
0.2359012067,
-0.5688669682,
0.3578516841,
0.0804362595,
0.5112354755,
0.036265377,
-0.4231637716,
-0.3098961413,
-0.9232686758,
1.0569593906,
-0.1771738529,
0.2794753313,
0.5756264329,
-0.1083602607,
-0.0526349284,
-1.2293286324,
-0.261364311,
0.0531286262,
-0.0749879479,
0.0665983707,
-0.5564094782,
-0.5268085003,
0.4066762328,
0.0111930259,
-0.5751834512,
-0.5504321456,
-0.5793060064,
-0.0336250998,
0.2918385863,
-0.1959099919,
0.2082643509,
-0.1354602128,
-0.4419457316,
0.2694763243,
-0.7084074616,
-0.4219689369,
0.0746732727,
0.0254013445,
0.4684165716,
0.4761808515,
-0.0103783617,
0.495259136,
-0.1734491438,
0.1059525758,
0.2674621344,
-0.4523336291,
-0.0710705668,
0.0122443521,
0.3634514213,
0.1509401649,
0.420630008,
-0.5345680118,
0.2602727115,
-0.4455908239,
0.3549969196,
-0.3060441315,
-0.2370263636,
-0.1093969345,
-0.5066966414,
0.245858565,
-0.0779603943,
-0.7340292931,
-0.3726516962,
-0.0980150178,
0.1000213027,
-0.5516927242,
-0.2498706579,
-0.0492826998,
-0.5513859391,
-0.0129968608,
0.2737526298,
-0.8929955959,
0.0757847056,
0.6413145661,
1.1061866283,
-0.2463579774,
-0.4914223552,
0.1165536791,
0.4366789162,
-0.2198832035,
0.8008505702,
-0.6072250009,
-0.3471852541,
-0.1007856578,
-0.0821508095,
-0.5025163293,
-0.4687171578,
0.4532844722,
-0.7457814217,
0.1347502321,
-0.4062294066,
-0.2506919503,
-0.3510427773,
0.0794583112,
-0.6213307977,
0.9898177981,
0.2269686162,
-1.1513499022,
0.6051107645,
-0.5060744286,
-0.1036749631,
-0.0759711564,
0.0339349546,
0.0174599104,
-0.0047320947,
0.1074704677,
0.0695530698,
0.0591228567,
0.4341783822,
-0.3811157644,
-0.4255264699,
0.2204058021,
-0.3230451047,
1.2127887011,
0.3587915599,
-0.1694053859,
-0.3158980906,
-0.9487889409,
-0.150036037,
-0.0652585924,
-0.1198693439,
-0.9376971126,
-0.0280425977,
-0.0033939383,
0.0523077026,
0.1615113467,
-0.4737882316,
0.1406024098,
-0.117111057,
0.5243012309,
0.2406089604,
0.6246528625,
0.3356162906,
-0.6199402809,
0.3867884576,
-0.1852582991,
-0.1386706531,
-0.3623602688,
-0.5393789411,
-0.5312626958,
0.1147205532,
0.0895819813,
0.2908352613,
-0.2572139502,
0.1358423978,
-0.3139571846,
-0.2255814672,
-0.1510057449,
0.0893338099,
-0.087507017,
0.5262371302,
0.6238400936,
-0.0213151835,
-0.9222261906,
-0.834864974,
-0.5420574546,
-0.5783981085,
-0.2230162472,
0.3453038335,
0.7208602428,
-0.1157665104,
1.0538605452,
-0.41920802,
-0.1704214066,
0.1942828894,
0.4035052061,
0.0155706089,
0.5582771897,
0.8440375924,
-0.6962066293,
-0.1264661849,
-0.2810814381,
-0.701215148,
-0.0955830812,
-0.3018149734,
-0.0633505136,
0.292504102,
0.9398415089,
-0.1474495679,
0.3214790523,
0.298466295,
-0.4330489039,
0.3926718831,
0.0830840617,
-0.0856831372,
-0.5755570531,
0.965685904,
-0.348026067,
0.1558050215,
-0.1633558869,
-0.2606732249,
0.1557610482,
-0.0918706134,
-0.1466405839,
0.4489732087,
-0.6997597814,
0.0721487403,
-0.2558785677,
-0.0557789393,
0.1679358482,
0.2980982661,
0.0403419472,
0.5547418594,
0.0990580022,
-0.4312573969,
-0.3452423215,
-0.1401841044,
0.0049303402,
0.5398898125,
-0.5007587075,
0.3130701184,
-0.3096652031,
0.1807187796,
-1.0423614979,
0.3185034692,
0.0307796691,
-0.487087518,
0.3195283711,
-0.3787336349,
-0.2674586773,
-0.1754071563,
-0.0779783353,
0.4620339572,
-0.0321816169,
-0.3423822522,
0.698367238,
0.2249503881,
-0.6128417253,
-0.9699389935,
-0.5767967701,
0.3034371138,
-0.1417602748,
-0.4331845939,
0.3325830698,
-0.1255359501,
-0.5654380918,
0.0732195377,
-0.3242594302,
-0.2155789733,
0.1784524024,
0.3724676371,
-0.0766168162,
-0.2478180528,
0.3888746202,
-0.0341043882,
-0.1372197866,
0.0786007568,
-0.4442652464,
0.5897001624,
-0.3121030629,
-0.1465951502,
0.2933480144,
0.6439961791,
0.4742782414,
0.0353171565,
0.6853439212,
0.338803798,
-0.2949377298,
0.103324838,
-0.617690742,
0.1697130948,
-0.3219370842,
0.3049232662,
0.1023724452,
-0.6770464182,
0.4737842977,
0.0453300551,
0.2332234085,
0.5750948787,
0.0819306374,
-0.3390825689,
0.2369817793,
0.7030335069,
0.0419302024,
0.6523923278,
-0.095006302,
-0.1252257079,
-0.8279676437,
-0.4056789279,
-0.742613554,
-0.4660621285,
-0.2828287482,
-0.3231382072,
0.0217642915,
0.2958466709,
-0.275665462,
-0.0457037464,
-0.3414329588,
0.4124401212,
0.5294883847,
-0.1070375219,
0.6365517378,
-0.2222150564,
0.1402894408,
-0.3346015513,
-0.7109727859,
-0.507489562,
1.3072931767,
0.273788631,
0.449650377,
-0.0365301222,
0.8147549629,
0.47734043,
0.3957698047,
-0.688680172,
0.3360432684,
0.284049511,
-0.8411746621,
-0.2059100568,
-0.1259243637,
-1.3791593313,
0.1898715794,
0.03349296,
-0.6260703206,
0.8928879499,
0.0163496993,
-0.2670820653,
0.1584554315,
-0.5890674591,
0.4786760807,
0.0651728436,
-0.4038786888,
-0.0369141474,
-0.8204296827,
0.4081133604,
-0.078313224,
0.0507837273,
0.1144183651,
0.0528397635,
1.061190486,
0.0523897409,
0.8552030325,
-0.2211320102,
0.2760287225,
0.2286186963,
0.121830225,
0.2100758106,
0.1836100966,
0.1216249242,
0.0923624337,
0.082999073,
-0.6439438462,
-0.4001924694,
0.8784449697,
-0.3595760167,
-0.3894203603,
-0.9515318871,
-0.787751019,
-0.1977991909,
0.3870118856,
0.0063295504,
-0.0190760456,
-0.3453293145,
0.4364524186,
0.7982933521,
-0.0538378023,
0.7902200222,
0.6722493172,
-0.3245312274,
-0.3005492985,
0.6157160997,
0.3712101579,
0.0553215779,
0.5422549844,
-0.0786384717,
0.1102558449,
-0.7385959625,
0.1710781455,
0.5549608469,
-0.6120672822,
0.0319916792,
-1.1525348425,
-0.0450007766,
-0.4248655736,
-0.129323557,
-0.234796524,
-0.8103573322,
-0.5172733068,
-0.0346171968,
0.186378181,
0.5093274117,
-0.1496457011,
-0.0937610343,
-0.4379839897,
0.073111251,
0.3122832179,
0.2106695026,
0.3613103628,
-0.3335833251,
-0.1967358738,
-0.5188221335,
-0.226755619,
-0.9366306663,
0.4978192747,
0.2488638312,
0.6544619203,
0.3236495554,
-0.0507939644,
0.477956146,
-0.3142185807,
0.6636969447,
-0.1256236285,
-0.5234917402,
0.4965842068,
-0.4658998251,
0.4828901291,
0.8137715459,
0.7669445276,
-0.6316956878,
-0.2061680406,
-0.8981707096,
-1.4051167965,
0.2101362944,
-0.1472173035,
-0.2282731384,
-0.089164421,
0.2216570079,
0.1980861276,
-0.0525835156,
-0.6887548566,
-0.4863650799,
-0.2067744285,
0.2896154821,
0.0809405372,
-0.4910898805,
-0.4002354145,
-0.0440402292,
0.4126271904,
-0.0325584374,
0.2491417378,
0.5433367491,
-0.3889907897,
0.079105258,
0.3469256759,
0.8951712251,
1.5145173073,
-0.6312491298,
0.4045508504,
-0.2732352912,
-0.8483372927,
-0.2239017487,
0.0977801904,
-0.7183721662,
0.2211141586,
0.5774342418,
0.3667107522,
0.3685722351,
-0.3250518739,
0.0353048295,
0.1274356246,
-0.1655767113,
-0.700227499,
-0.1178788617,
0.3285053074,
0.19004336,
1.1267578602,
0.4686137736,
0.073633492,
-0.6181330085,
0.2601478696,
0.1630951166,
-0.4099752605,
-0.2302400023,
0.5333376527,
-0.0225751158,
0.0710494295,
0.2574225366,
0.2055884451,
-0.0517803393,
0.3752497733,
0.7629024982,
0.809874475,
0.1688074768,
0.0825946704,
0.6265221238,
0.5720197558,
-0.0971319973,
0.1857836992,
-0.0731742978,
-0.3038142025,
-0.2178097069,
-0.5392190814,
-0.0640351698,
0.2958949506,
-0.8018635511,
-0.3251699209,
-0.4139902294,
-0.3740409315,
0.102107875,
0.0564860031,
-0.5762739182,
0.0429090746,
-0.1162566245,
0.9212173223,
-1.0082848072,
0.5883832574,
0.4622755051,
-0.4033652544,
0.0926893726,
0.1293710172,
-0.0119269993,
-0.7273059487,
0.9755323529,
-0.2641670704,
-0.0888857991,
0.1881923527,
-0.6965501904,
-1.2848678827,
1.0682874918,
0.0167006105,
-0.5550436378,
-0.2010686398,
-0.5694483519,
0.6699388623,
-0.2143306881,
0.0888509154,
0.5997234583,
0.5051146746,
0.0487923026,
-0.4757244289,
-0.0737596676,
-0.430007726,
-0.0494303219,
0.2664432824,
-0.4020235538,
0.6171405911,
-0.4199269712,
-0.4516479373,
-0.0623174496,
0.9086393118,
0.4115753174,
0.9401129484,
0.030042354,
0.3537932932,
1.0357722044,
-0.0218194779,
0.664732635,
0.1742544919,
-0.0389454328,
1.2904119492,
-0.1389598548,
0.7605111599,
1.2172642946,
-0.3123628795,
0.6074820161,
0.1059253067,
0.0040894179,
0.4880501032,
-0.0818373412,
-0.0643078983,
0.1274626553,
-0.0815647617,
-0.7956116199,
-0.0821664408,
0.3894434273,
-0.9448548555,
-0.1488995105,
0.0079250578,
0.235782519,
0.1225641444,
-0.2114743292,
0.5916789174,
0.2562524974,
-0.6731268764,
0.5786013603,
-0.5123093128,
0.4948026836,
-0.7415974736,
0.0736082196,
-0.5440074801,
-0.0191137046,
-0.1828885227,
-0.7576636672,
0.5104315877,
-0.1099044457,
-0.8715608716,
-0.20660384,
0.6716631055,
-0.1406132877,
-0.2678865194,
0.2847786248,
0.5894297361,
0.1206134185,
0.0561902486,
-0.3400854468,
-0.0893737972,
0.0808566958,
-0.2852196097,
0.5308185816,
0.5811003447,
-0.1084101349,
0.7086225152,
0.4756258428,
0.3609400988,
0.2188012898,
0.0964862332,
0.515529871,
-0.9620910883,
-0.1164477542,
-0.6993252635,
0.1743843257,
-0.223159492,
-0.6907308698,
0.9303367734,
0.6776399612,
0.7778357863,
-0.0482719652,
0.8101127744,
-0.1991142184,
0.8010481596,
-0.3014521897,
0.8182620406,
-0.3405744433,
0.2023855597,
-0.4469814301,
-0.8188803196,
-0.6941349506,
0.3497837186,
-0.2836026847,
0.1573196948,
0.9896537662,
0.2352151275,
0.2368971407,
0.1149339676,
-0.0315200128,
0.1013816297,
0.1501312256,
0.4019086659,
0.8944385052,
-0.2603628933,
0.6278411746,
-0.1662018448,
-0.0816026628,
-0.3378801346,
-1.0932594538,
-0.4619755149,
-0.6215596199,
-0.3283212483,
-0.3884267807,
0.3384152949,
0.2931227088,
0.1767035723,
-0.8583232164,
0.1502875686,
0.0258752611,
0.3077012002,
-0.6172535419,
-0.2727690041,
0.5775206685,
-0.1738097668,
-0.5537157059,
0.4847538471,
0.4222105145,
0.0054461653,
0.0149335898,
0.3347692788,
-0.7546112537,
-0.1680672169,
0.4879365563,
0.8708113432,
-0.3731026947,
-0.1074443087,
0.3334631026,
-0.17565386,
0.171171084,
1.3487269878,
-0.8326556087,
0.5225043297,
0.7865375876,
0.2561616302,
0.7440428138,
0.0669365227,
0.5192357898,
-0.6803815365,
-0.0068055121,
0.82351017,
0.4132461846,
0.3423170149,
0.0620881803,
0.6708834767,
0.6421905756,
-0.8293038607,
-0.9675905704,
-0.0338722691,
-1.0691534281,
-0.586948216,
0.7222578526,
-0.09794195,
-0.1284254044,
-0.9303318858,
0.0348693505,
-0.0080189081,
-0.3914768994,
1.1050288677,
0.8133411407,
-0.3455934525,
-0.2479648143,
-0.4208536148,
0.4176993072,
0.5236912966,
-0.3824030757,
0.2811014652,
0.5681891441,
0.3572514057,
0.7172396779,
0.7166032195,
-0.3704673648,
0.3111647964,
0.3388116956,
-0.1368854344,
0.0352166332,
-0.6403557062,
-0.0808658004,
0.6483682394,
0.0532122031,
0.3535611331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.00007v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.00007v1 | Datasets for Portuguese Legal Semantic Textual Similarity: Comparing weak supervision and an annotation process approaches | 2023-05-29T18:27:10 | 2023-05-29T18:27:10 | Daniel da Silva Junior, Paulo Roberto dos S. Corval, Aline Paes, Daniel de Oliveira | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The Brazilian judiciary has a large workload, resulting in a long time to
finish legal proceedings. Brazilian National Council of Justice has established
in Resolution 469/2022 formal guidance for document and process digitalization
opening up the possibility of using automatic techniques to help with everyday
tasks in the legal field, particularly in a large number of texts yielded on
the routine of law procedures. Notably, Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques
allow for processing and extracting useful information from textual data,
potentially speeding up the process. However, datasets from the legal domain
required by several AI techniques are scarce and difficult to obtain as they
need labels from experts. To address this challenge, this article contributes
with four datasets from the legal domain, two with documents and metadata but
unlabeled, and another two labeled with a heuristic aiming at its use in
textual semantic similarity tasks. Also, to evaluate the effectiveness of the
proposed heuristic label process, this article presents a small ground truth
dataset generated from domain expert annotations. The analysis of ground truth
labels highlights that semantic analysis of domain text can be challenging even
for domain experts. Also, the comparison between ground truth and heuristic
labels shows that heuristic labels are useful. | [
-0.1984274387,
-0.5089347959,
0.4188885093,
0.020651117,
-0.4958843291,
-0.0536220968,
-0.4521885514,
-0.5629975796,
-0.0152524039,
0.9686430693,
-0.1940782815,
-0.8718986511,
-0.8359944224,
0.0990933105,
-0.5419623256,
1.2599908113,
-0.0879116207,
-0.002401324,
-0.27989465,
-0.2827929258,
-0.4083201587,
-0.3838252723,
-0.4805861115,
-0.39963606,
0.3956433833,
0.1756605208,
0.7454728484,
0.883141458,
0.7256138921,
0.3871760368,
-0.1409412324,
-0.0108459927,
-0.378715843,
0.0053421967,
-0.4793789387,
-0.4089897573,
-0.2838883102,
0.0498830676,
0.2232922018,
0.4856202602,
0.0279103983,
0.0587009676,
-0.1594002098,
0.5647832751,
-0.4944574833,
0.5580878258,
-0.6182344556,
0.1395575553,
-0.3594143391,
-0.295227766,
-0.1446888,
-0.4219657183,
0.2048949003,
-0.8543210626,
0.3433677256,
0.1264420152,
1.1268770695,
0.7933946252,
-0.3774539232,
-0.6084232926,
-0.5034083128,
0.5993614197,
-0.7496421933,
0.1525291353,
0.6374822259,
0.4119073451,
-0.147072345,
-0.5083019137,
-0.3376858234,
-0.3801564574,
-0.2710059881,
0.1159585938,
-0.2286101282,
0.0521383397,
0.4369409978,
-0.1503988206,
-0.4592645168,
0.2887791693,
-0.5734655857,
-0.4401834905,
0.8247990608,
0.0623058155,
-0.1109617874,
-0.0166045669,
-0.1404839158,
0.0330878012,
-0.6667681336,
-0.3104226291,
0.7161371112,
0.286010623,
0.1085733846,
0.4591834545,
-0.3992355466,
0.8488471508,
-0.2799761295,
-0.3548943996,
0.4425225854,
-0.2402769476,
-0.1484365165,
0.3667061329,
1.0592944622,
0.4133895636,
0.5607399344,
-0.267190963,
-0.4636612236,
0.0068258783,
0.4954289794,
-0.4349344373,
-0.2573977709,
0.1361958981,
-0.4383895099,
-0.1218962818,
0.2112757713,
-0.6147471666,
-0.4579007626,
-0.8101525903,
0.0942470208,
-0.5533204079,
0.2911814451,
-0.1278508753,
-0.2036511898,
0.2951749265,
0.5681638718,
-0.5082940459,
0.3795779645,
0.9907423854,
0.3037670851,
-0.1042660698,
0.0378880128,
-0.2926975787,
0.2124692649,
-0.2684870064,
0.8155617714,
-0.596788466,
-0.2182871401,
0.0541143194,
0.0390386432,
0.1073138937,
-0.6017077565,
1.1817424297,
-0.5435347557,
0.1078472808,
-0.3228597641,
-0.5716357231,
-0.3279282749,
0.3877513409,
-0.6409941912,
1.0318695307,
-0.0222161058,
-0.7414833307,
0.8830196857,
-0.3989380896,
-0.4923808277,
0.3313496709,
-0.4314507246,
-0.7789734602,
-0.2712475955,
0.0872122273,
0.4478601515,
-0.4584478736,
0.3037393987,
-0.1834305376,
-0.3813937604,
-0.0284964554,
-0.1170372218,
0.9696726799,
0.4059538245,
-0.418287158,
0.2551673353,
-0.7723580599,
-0.1738216728,
0.0614874773,
-0.384609431,
-0.6011003256,
-0.0739584714,
0.0181757603,
0.2809050083,
0.146804899,
-0.3187150955,
0.2481368035,
-0.2446804643,
0.2109192312,
0.5689626336,
0.0436963513,
0.1464901865,
-0.2063401043,
0.2579394877,
-0.0201159101,
-0.0926398411,
0.0013522059,
-0.5993968248,
-0.632109642,
-0.244283393,
0.8398509622,
0.7040854692,
-0.7210402489,
0.5996688604,
-0.58019346,
-0.4433149397,
-0.8256520629,
0.2950645983,
0.508015275,
0.461542964,
0.4160022438,
-0.2719277143,
-0.4988250732,
-1.0745691061,
-0.4333331287,
-0.1936394125,
-0.0374318957,
0.2684884369,
0.9758612514,
-0.1521604806,
0.9010576606,
-0.080701746,
-0.7483335137,
0.357298702,
0.5099567175,
0.2788550556,
0.2015057206,
0.8222497702,
-0.8827904463,
-0.2674235702,
0.1420085877,
-1.2329229116,
-0.3021655977,
-0.067610085,
0.1948597282,
0.3615095615,
0.4712901413,
-0.1318547577,
0.5644901991,
-0.2745330036,
-0.4903090298,
0.1637745798,
-0.4866842926,
0.4235686064,
-0.5489436984,
-0.0746007711,
0.1743222773,
-0.2546756864,
-0.3211931586,
0.1492816061,
-0.1059432179,
0.369156152,
-0.5594303012,
0.3239622116,
-0.5074545741,
-0.3242858052,
-0.2388840914,
0.2169775218,
-0.3267583847,
0.4614908993,
0.1490039527,
0.5254473686,
0.4528930485,
-0.4614171982,
0.7210656404,
0.3879292905,
-0.138502568,
0.9638562202,
-0.4537848532,
-0.01142566,
-0.2137752771,
0.0769685656,
-0.4361488223,
-0.0483767316,
0.463349402,
-0.204231739,
0.124167107,
-0.5044340491,
-0.8306184411,
-0.5034683347,
-0.2661773264,
0.1131791994,
0.4011363685,
-0.0203916784,
0.4138672352,
0.4764510989,
-0.2295121104,
-0.7562389374,
-0.5908362865,
0.5196989775,
-0.4536368847,
-0.3023241758,
0.2378446311,
0.4396058917,
-0.5000144839,
0.5332350135,
0.2866234481,
-0.2055781633,
0.1256679893,
0.448227942,
-0.0911762118,
-0.2457564026,
0.0441505201,
0.2160483599,
-0.2490312308,
0.2998273373,
-0.375220418,
-0.041438669,
-0.0493756235,
-0.2641197443,
-0.4315790236,
0.1957280487,
0.0642252862,
-0.1461758316,
0.4796464443,
0.4508205354,
-0.4375660419,
0.159321174,
-0.4132643342,
0.1383163631,
-0.3099267185,
-0.2922038138,
-0.5215675831,
-0.5244706869,
0.3857922852,
-0.1141758338,
0.0913681462,
0.7128250003,
0.9317531586,
-0.053911332,
0.2153573036,
0.4950490296,
-0.211720705,
0.220676586,
-0.2140183598,
-0.1981654465,
-0.0322835892,
-0.3213520944,
-1.0526241064,
-0.0515364893,
-0.7901214957,
-0.3444623947,
0.2806020975,
-0.2659053504,
0.0043488713,
0.7270823717,
-0.4949624538,
0.5012732148,
1.0210584402,
-0.1290003955,
0.5441752672,
-0.0211026147,
-0.1895596236,
0.0480332337,
-0.6043350101,
-0.8872674704,
1.0728988647,
-0.0130712176,
0.4534494877,
-0.0251190457,
0.811645627,
0.7020640373,
0.1192731261,
-0.6931890845,
0.5878983736,
-0.1195923463,
-0.4732975662,
-0.2816796005,
-0.3085144162,
-1.2018989325,
0.0699444488,
-0.7815137506,
-0.5545417666,
0.0836008117,
-0.2730059326,
-0.1293671578,
-0.1143727899,
-0.4266743958,
0.6911244392,
0.0637342483,
-0.548263073,
-0.132977128,
-1.0813521147,
-0.1251966357,
-0.2430004776,
0.2589127123,
-0.1788388491,
-0.065598987,
1.145812273,
-0.7243219614,
0.5961082578,
-0.0793770775,
-0.440676719,
0.753798306,
-0.2853838801,
0.3988983035,
-0.2404384613,
-0.1919240654,
0.1761146486,
0.0736531392,
-0.4757893384,
-0.424757719,
0.490575105,
-0.6924943328,
-0.3634451628,
-0.5087838173,
-0.1967220157,
0.0312385131,
0.4280315936,
0.2349665165,
-0.0035905058,
-0.1390964985,
-0.1462426484,
0.5412234068,
0.0708833858,
0.3788813055,
0.6155853868,
0.5111948848,
-0.2081573457,
0.9902520776,
0.3411298692,
-0.6315217614,
0.3814471066,
-0.1110153049,
-0.2833366096,
-0.6785453558,
-0.4735885561,
0.1256000698,
-0.694352746,
-0.3325905502,
-0.5491209626,
0.1273402274,
-0.4837888777,
-0.0694663599,
-0.0212436952,
-0.4882832766,
-0.0398073271,
-0.0904071182,
0.5101491213,
0.6664994359,
0.1445705146,
0.1382237375,
-0.7851068974,
0.478831917,
0.0928820446,
0.2367097884,
-0.6921651363,
-0.2923830748,
-0.0136096552,
-0.041590292,
-0.0571063645,
-0.8971612453,
0.1589155793,
-0.0347709097,
0.6773743629,
0.3831324875,
0.1393252015,
0.2909006774,
-0.5117830038,
0.3786192536,
-0.3745950162,
-0.6712713838,
0.6392640471,
-0.6008493304,
-0.3131665289,
0.8165181279,
0.600237608,
-0.0689069033,
-0.4630043507,
-0.7681528926,
-0.8701050282,
0.6772678494,
0.5943791866,
-0.2859097123,
0.3572259843,
0.5189868808,
0.3002414405,
0.3666118085,
-0.2528607845,
0.0031065275,
-0.0089888079,
-0.3231166899,
0.0654904842,
0.1495829821,
-0.3372807801,
-0.0153434351,
0.8538104296,
-0.2187132835,
0.1880486459,
-0.1066924781,
-0.206973061,
0.1547492296,
0.3580414355,
0.4466933608,
0.5583220124,
-0.0796038434,
0.1955545247,
0.1442408562,
-0.2334970087,
0.0322069339,
0.3005823195,
-0.363637656,
0.0762602538,
0.7766600847,
0.7692822814,
-0.1136453301,
-0.7467628717,
0.5580642223,
0.089952901,
-0.5257663727,
-0.3411299288,
0.0873131454,
-0.2390477806,
0.1754060686,
0.0825983733,
-0.1932534277,
0.4712270796,
-0.4986438751,
0.4251061082,
-0.0360049084,
-0.5655757189,
0.1163385808,
0.7843611836,
0.214137122,
-0.3333419263,
0.459520787,
-0.3400901556,
-0.3848057389,
0.7362972498,
-0.0594959892,
0.4689312279,
0.3152057528,
0.0416228957,
0.0954376459,
0.2389839888,
-0.3684244752,
0.0266582407,
-0.2198935151,
-0.3807248771,
-0.3326811492,
-0.2407796532,
-0.5301299095,
-0.2786224782,
-0.5581609607,
0.4432694018,
-0.2477123588,
-0.052745387,
0.0448871553,
0.150230065,
-0.7436184883,
0.4586137235,
-0.0255062934,
0.6030174494,
-0.9507132173,
0.7812871933,
0.7060980797,
-0.483648628,
-0.212727353,
-0.1879735589,
0.2627618015,
-0.6268863678,
0.598521769,
-0.1032573655,
0.0616495945,
-0.4727891982,
-0.4684281945,
0.0339766666,
0.8213028312,
0.3210802972,
-0.5674176216,
0.0491763279,
0.4725706875,
1.0548852682,
-0.0251566973,
0.2336688042,
0.9032295346,
0.7413836122,
0.205390051,
-0.7489210367,
0.1794636846,
-0.3773391843,
-0.3062875569,
0.1620296091,
-0.4074904025,
0.336445421,
-0.1768823266,
0.0950159431,
-0.177165851,
0.7127648592,
0.0432479084,
0.4853752255,
0.4543680251,
0.7874834538,
0.8259704709,
-0.3820579946,
0.7976818681,
-0.2463941276,
0.4326938093,
1.182525754,
-0.297352463,
0.3274590075,
0.2463321388,
-0.0571941063,
0.1646009088,
0.6739783883,
-0.522018671,
0.2995927334,
0.3586311936,
0.1003797501,
-0.2361148447,
-0.4221044183,
-0.2051246762,
0.5185569525,
0.4249326885,
-0.4500006437,
-0.3873802423,
-0.117765598,
0.0856615603,
0.4829116762,
-0.3052467704,
1.2026115656,
-0.1629011333,
-0.5686294436,
0.3099191189,
0.2986586988,
0.3923492134,
-0.0423609875,
-0.2161886841,
0.0377853103,
-0.0253563244,
-0.2586414814,
-1.1501442194,
0.4722553194,
0.3634338975,
0.2168469727,
-0.46421507,
0.8105467558,
-0.0657972321,
-0.3428951502,
0.3008648455,
0.431524992,
0.5723731518,
-0.0148758786,
-0.9714536071,
-0.2673976421,
-0.4530126154,
-0.106721133,
-0.0022204462,
0.9697241783,
-0.7280503511,
0.5139629841,
0.2046160996,
-0.0052932817,
0.0098160133,
0.1117410436,
0.8825921416,
-0.7800392509,
-0.4611764848,
-0.6059587598,
-0.0373218283,
-0.2730281353,
-0.3976924121,
0.4407560825,
0.7054466009,
0.8702641726,
0.1102340072,
0.7849295139,
-0.0734713525,
0.3917340934,
-0.7337975502,
0.5875964165,
-0.2121584266,
0.253745079,
-0.4128296375,
-0.8910335302,
-0.4011172652,
0.5227510333,
-0.3825028837,
-0.0769375935,
0.438637495,
0.6018953919,
-0.0191422813,
-0.0466050245,
0.2057784051,
0.1296879053,
0.1205729023,
0.6005507112,
0.5498789549,
-0.4704035223,
0.5425404906,
-0.0730761364,
0.0525821894,
-0.4007589817,
-0.8850255013,
-0.9811574221,
-0.540954113,
-0.5151724815,
-0.3497073352,
0.4958539903,
0.849796176,
0.4781877995,
-0.8772956729,
0.1484770477,
-0.0073614656,
0.2118789554,
-0.1685239971,
-0.1575190425,
0.4834305942,
-0.0019860908,
-0.6819300652,
0.0309710149,
0.0499736629,
0.0321489163,
0.2216566801,
0.064010188,
-0.1395557672,
-0.0379879884,
0.2886657119,
0.2787501216,
-0.5429441929,
-0.3649544418,
-0.6530786157,
-0.3953865767,
0.1933503598,
0.8909541965,
-0.8868144751,
0.0839014649,
0.6880950928,
0.7800444961,
0.4791939259,
0.0301583298,
0.1743863821,
-0.6621995568,
0.3459191024,
0.3582009971,
0.5211341977,
0.1110577732,
-0.1163335294,
1.1133692265,
0.3349064887,
-0.2449069023,
-0.3175635934,
-0.0395375825,
-1.2087204456,
-0.4108068645,
1.0587383509,
-0.3908399642,
-0.4307030439,
-0.5893180966,
-0.4839395583,
0.3312253356,
-0.6421994567,
0.7611693144,
0.6350520849,
0.1225526184,
0.2466065437,
-0.580925405,
0.4551506937,
0.0332830176,
-1.0001764297,
-0.1144839153,
0.619189322,
0.2143128663,
0.2792105377,
0.5744222999,
-0.1269776076,
0.1341055483,
0.0694391876,
0.0545760468,
-0.1204385161,
-0.2661694288,
-0.1276049912,
0.3937097788,
-0.3665015697,
0.2266880423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18294v1 | Transformer Language Models Handle Word Frequency in Prediction Head | 2023-05-29T17:59:15 | 2023-05-29T17:59:15 | Goro Kobayashi, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Sho Yokoi, Kentaro Inui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prediction head is a crucial component of Transformer language models.
Despite its direct impact on prediction, this component has often been
overlooked in analyzing Transformers. In this study, we investigate the inner
workings of the prediction head, specifically focusing on bias parameters. Our
experiments with BERT and GPT-2 models reveal that the biases in their word
prediction heads play a significant role in the models' ability to reflect word
frequency in a corpus, aligning with the logit adjustment method commonly used
in long-tailed learning. We also quantify the effect of controlling the biases
in practical auto-regressive text generation scenarios; under a particular
setting, more diverse text can be generated without compromising text quality. | [
-0.6142006516,
-0.5956074595,
0.3238359392,
0.2036734223,
-0.228386566,
-0.3138386011,
-0.2646141052,
-0.6605352759,
-0.0291332398,
0.6614869237,
-0.8284749985,
0.1165140346,
-0.8402332664,
-0.0216919407,
-0.6075559258,
1.2646682262,
0.2327997833,
0.0209607352,
0.1387465,
0.1376161426,
-0.9738042355,
-0.5046823621,
-0.4318106472,
-0.8213397264,
0.6032550335,
0.1106363982,
1.1314146519,
0.5779991746,
0.4742464423,
0.1812552214,
0.0188676436,
-0.5112842917,
-0.4503872395,
0.498742342,
-0.3073091507,
-0.5721362829,
-0.2363545299,
-0.1539051682,
0.6780270934,
0.5352000594,
-0.0038441436,
-0.0263892803,
0.3482763469,
0.6517600417,
-0.194646284,
0.4630304873,
-1.0389404297,
-0.2080031782,
-0.3751558065,
-0.0581113026,
-0.511446178,
-0.0248141065,
0.5521757603,
-0.0946004763,
0.5665653348,
0.222135365,
1.0472238064,
0.5145190954,
-0.4259774387,
-0.2205453813,
-0.8938866258,
0.8886530399,
-0.3829269707,
0.6526268125,
0.4138204753,
0.1523758024,
-0.1174416095,
-0.5306890011,
-0.5862723589,
0.1295127869,
-0.2664012611,
0.1839349866,
-0.3444982171,
0.1167146787,
0.268658042,
0.1831780523,
-0.3299311996,
-0.0380364954,
-0.4122224748,
-0.0953516141,
0.4689073563,
-0.007690744,
0.0522033162,
-0.2770318985,
-0.0287074856,
-0.389618516,
-0.5549076796,
-0.0629991293,
0.484577477,
0.32452932,
0.1734847873,
0.4822411537,
0.2125622928,
0.6067509055,
0.4065671265,
0.0159581397,
0.1454795748,
0.066574268,
-0.2101448178,
-0.0435127728,
0.6478588581,
0.4040155411,
0.5965019464,
-0.2398569733,
-0.3439725339,
0.1386930346,
0.7380880117,
-0.569416523,
-0.0924532637,
0.0756987259,
-0.3189754188,
-0.4113920033,
0.1178869531,
-0.9553376436,
-0.1643834114,
-0.3552298248,
0.568413198,
-0.3918673396,
-0.3168714941,
-0.0923625529,
-0.3093001246,
0.1532547027,
-0.0319018662,
-1.1323310137,
0.20356372,
0.610028863,
0.5019513369,
-0.4613320529,
-0.3015029728,
-0.069705762,
0.1578252167,
-0.244626075,
0.8397149444,
-0.4955192208,
-0.6043878794,
0.1825289279,
0.1529856473,
-0.2175260335,
-0.3822518885,
0.556856513,
-0.6838329434,
0.4284353852,
-0.5129138827,
-0.3060798049,
-0.2019455284,
-0.3271999955,
-0.9333919287,
1.0596064329,
0.4247572124,
-1.0759510994,
0.8592036963,
-0.4682364464,
-0.5456641912,
-0.1238106713,
-0.2262064964,
-0.6353318095,
0.3861375153,
0.1785628647,
0.3630352914,
-0.1386232674,
0.4059986174,
0.0689887926,
-0.3390198052,
0.2164358646,
-0.5577929616,
0.4326900244,
0.0160707682,
-0.6587764621,
0.0180838946,
-0.3640679121,
-0.3113689721,
0.0241720378,
0.0444898158,
-0.3161357641,
0.3312787712,
0.2340735644,
0.2821582556,
-0.1993659884,
-0.388143599,
0.0802085176,
-0.3879721463,
0.2819987833,
0.7384214401,
-0.0663760081,
0.4158081412,
-0.3689355254,
0.5440785289,
0.0044945059,
-0.0414688773,
-0.1019392386,
-0.7440654039,
-0.8387874365,
0.1753623784,
0.3377172947,
0.3252015114,
-0.5026319623,
0.2969338596,
-0.2416097969,
-0.4989953339,
-0.4226956069,
-0.1527605951,
0.0765915811,
0.5290221572,
0.2608149648,
-0.1834855378,
-0.5374522805,
-1.0204093456,
-0.5877518058,
-0.1198991835,
-0.2595202327,
0.1586363018,
0.4192005396,
-0.4241507351,
1.3763307333,
-0.4781643748,
-0.4205168784,
-0.4288873076,
0.5048856139,
0.2848771214,
0.2397687584,
0.7291449308,
-0.8103765249,
-0.4722186923,
-0.4207431376,
-0.2606565356,
-0.3094106019,
-0.0928004757,
-0.1426342577,
0.3523787856,
0.303303659,
-0.6933861971,
0.469841361,
0.7800334692,
-0.449654758,
0.5984228849,
0.1689109951,
-0.2772158384,
-0.777131021,
-0.0851202384,
0.3645178676,
-0.2145358473,
-0.6848799586,
-0.1228933185,
0.2322457284,
0.1333774775,
-0.0859926045,
0.3976365626,
-0.1761095673,
-0.0034038648,
-0.6669083238,
-0.209729135,
-0.0168810822,
0.3037463725,
0.2865719199,
1.2290617228,
0.4120956659,
-0.6635911465,
-0.0600964129,
0.1858450472,
-0.331294775,
0.4061470926,
-0.8428836465,
-0.0202882085,
-0.4516380727,
0.3863039315,
-0.8605994582,
-0.1677159518,
-0.199241668,
-0.3969508708,
0.6899170876,
0.0764066502,
-0.3985114098,
-0.6961926818,
0.0540944897,
0.1227591783,
0.7031259537,
-0.209396556,
0.5604875088,
0.5871139169,
-0.1704025567,
-0.5995875001,
-0.7979370952,
-0.3552942276,
-0.2330699265,
-0.3368994594,
0.553847909,
0.1730294377,
-0.2872230709,
-0.2594642937,
-0.1350794733,
0.0561968461,
-0.1878692806,
0.3701906502,
0.2652064264,
0.0452224575,
0.2852783203,
0.1980424374,
-0.1896874309,
0.4327375293,
-0.4172860682,
0.8891707659,
0.0759182796,
-0.015756024,
-0.0209817998,
0.0051879217,
0.4921525121,
-0.1294172257,
0.6534884572,
0.7486458421,
-0.3592504263,
-0.2031193823,
-0.6777351499,
-0.4627656341,
-0.4929295778,
0.5841978788,
-0.3689656556,
-0.6555894017,
0.3172041178,
0.4302905798,
0.0815509334,
1.038351059,
0.9357298017,
-0.073955439,
1.1157147884,
0.8937876225,
-0.3326742053,
0.5485317707,
0.0045781066,
0.1149884537,
-0.7829678059,
0.0405877717,
-0.4815699458,
-0.2306439281,
-0.7966594696,
-0.3801022172,
0.4041319489,
-0.1799278706,
-0.0863996223,
0.5679721832,
-0.6160665751,
0.1422764659,
0.7644788027,
-0.0807923004,
0.0313085094,
0.0163905565,
-0.013661786,
-0.303604275,
-0.3362091482,
-0.2455844581,
1.1310204268,
0.7570970058,
0.7077645659,
-0.4741276205,
0.1878150254,
0.3085212409,
0.4098534584,
-0.7143300772,
0.0380277336,
-0.1776050478,
-1.0740265846,
-0.4765503705,
0.0634557679,
-0.8261794448,
0.3475148082,
-0.0174091607,
-0.6689706445,
0.2094981223,
0.1728114039,
-0.1698285937,
0.3012924194,
-0.2907327414,
0.4446665645,
0.0700232983,
-0.0581780858,
-0.3575627804,
-0.519369185,
0.1736474484,
-0.4175797403,
0.1965302676,
-0.1824197471,
0.2985374928,
0.8455427885,
0.1286105663,
0.6779208779,
-0.1518283933,
-0.5063707232,
0.3876166642,
0.1767602861,
0.5668538213,
-0.0435554385,
-0.4029885232,
0.4425452948,
-0.0699335486,
-0.0419207551,
-0.1591970623,
0.3993720412,
-0.7683113217,
-0.7032909393,
-0.4957922399,
-0.7818794847,
-0.3961570561,
0.2474075854,
0.7685425282,
0.2135736495,
-0.0641906112,
0.1426129788,
0.6670484543,
-0.2071709186,
0.6337223053,
0.1503764242,
-0.4168067575,
-0.0910134912,
0.5235267878,
0.3479478955,
0.4323150814,
0.2142463773,
0.3361566067,
-0.2611042857,
-0.1336630583,
-0.410918653,
0.1764209121,
-0.5510756969,
-0.1552295238,
-0.7984576821,
-0.3236697614,
-0.4335540235,
0.0690235943,
-0.201292634,
-0.3247700036,
-0.0810558125,
-0.2481302768,
0.4741609693,
0.8863779902,
0.340580821,
0.9272481799,
-0.3817432523,
0.2693319619,
0.3356926143,
0.6165014505,
-0.072888501,
-0.7687129974,
-0.1888484508,
0.0484439805,
-0.5574723482,
-0.9099240899,
0.5216315985,
0.1704504341,
0.2675042152,
0.2941136658,
-0.2538261414,
0.2874517441,
-0.9088483453,
0.9278594255,
0.0846991763,
-0.9941927195,
0.4541315734,
-0.6008512974,
0.4753658772,
0.2458917201,
0.13769719,
-0.7102379799,
-0.7558506727,
-0.5450390577,
-0.6783970594,
0.795679152,
0.1172635853,
0.5340037942,
-0.1066414118,
0.2045974135,
0.5633887053,
0.3784510493,
-0.7817842364,
-0.4518346786,
-0.5898591876,
-0.1221345663,
-0.0304152369,
-0.6252040267,
0.2716335654,
-0.3420463204,
0.6271880269,
-0.1064720005,
0.6664990783,
-0.0262454525,
-0.0772148967,
-0.6632745266,
0.1093196347,
0.6008119583,
0.8062067628,
-0.3506988883,
-0.2167121023,
0.2415923029,
-0.6741900444,
-0.3640240729,
-0.1403855234,
-0.3450538218,
0.5180678964,
0.2054305375,
1.0333672762,
0.0597698465,
-0.281073451,
0.5290657282,
0.1111301109,
-0.2806894481,
-0.6433461905,
0.0583883338,
-0.1277567595,
0.0226745922,
0.7401262522,
0.0673511028,
0.0528441593,
-0.3600935638,
0.5712516308,
0.5743650198,
-0.6287861466,
-0.6081700325,
1.0997033119,
0.0414354391,
-0.175591439,
0.5206536651,
0.2409718484,
-0.9118506908,
0.4906195104,
0.7148644924,
0.9897978306,
-0.4080283046,
-0.0373953879,
0.3094719648,
0.4072613716,
-0.1355750859,
0.2178505808,
0.5453975201,
-0.7812743783,
-0.5232657194,
-0.8125222921,
-0.2338097245,
0.1998081952,
-0.7269490361,
0.5783980489,
-0.1103549823,
-0.6520311236,
0.0178483333,
-0.2417093217,
-0.9706708193,
0.5771626234,
0.4088003337,
0.7885759473,
-0.8211189508,
1.1582736969,
0.2513895035,
-0.3667569757,
-0.6979358196,
0.3484716117,
-0.1611106843,
-1.0125277042,
0.8726477623,
0.2470982075,
0.030017646,
-0.059553951,
-0.2980807424,
-1.1344513893,
0.7600086927,
0.058858227,
-0.678470552,
-0.4946832955,
0.4920791984,
0.5176724792,
-0.1397148371,
0.480160594,
0.7945783734,
0.7128757238,
-0.333421886,
-1.290892601,
-0.1858235747,
0.2882567048,
0.1865331978,
0.4181393683,
-0.6164500713,
1.1173402071,
0.1556506157,
-0.0353039429,
-0.4467438459,
0.9697676897,
-0.3031949103,
-0.2353849113,
0.6712906957,
0.2988232076,
0.3897013366,
-0.3278569579,
1.1107192039,
-0.7882419825,
0.5855571032,
0.7285943031,
-0.0867574662,
0.609149754,
0.6284403205,
-0.3593971431,
0.7228714824,
0.345233798,
-0.3064245284,
0.5356328487,
0.0995269865,
0.2026713639,
0.1356241107,
0.0168501493,
-0.4297136664,
0.5950291753,
0.5247579813,
-0.6005493999,
0.0209399071,
-0.013101819,
0.1079916283,
-0.1529027224,
-0.2551009059,
0.5922809243,
0.1432957649,
-0.9362079501,
0.3374269605,
0.0842691511,
0.9919388294,
-0.5428788662,
0.3378584087,
0.0671618432,
0.3740570545,
-0.0088705923,
-0.7212117314,
0.6094061136,
-0.3565292954,
-0.4934360385,
-0.2997346222,
0.8664355874,
-0.4917529225,
-0.6469475031,
0.3332263827,
0.2867736816,
-0.3859024942,
-0.4237174094,
-0.5130237937,
0.0729641989,
-0.1162376925,
-0.5800764561,
0.3088609278,
0.2553153038,
0.0072274068,
0.5218316317,
0.1282055378,
0.2009737641,
0.0256808419,
0.1053959876,
0.5523673892,
-0.5794201493,
-0.3894926012,
-0.885596931,
0.2641531229,
0.2570236325,
-0.335945636,
0.5949856639,
0.2587533295,
0.8039383292,
-0.3699649572,
0.9424741864,
-0.0492153987,
0.831970036,
-0.1788639575,
0.978862226,
-0.2354200333,
-0.2510228753,
-0.4567547143,
-1.2770963907,
-0.0021508429,
0.5861409307,
-0.2932748199,
0.1185920388,
0.8245928288,
0.3794049919,
0.1607522368,
0.2867713571,
0.2270204425,
0.096486181,
0.2533928156,
0.1429745108,
0.2475990951,
-0.5231510401,
0.3981077075,
-0.5876796842,
0.0311358571,
-0.1313457489,
-0.9057123661,
-0.8392379284,
-0.667711556,
-0.0066601145,
-0.433015883,
-0.0371561497,
0.7508622408,
0.580516696,
-1.0458257198,
-0.3767211139,
-0.1205716059,
-0.1558128744,
-0.3527511358,
-0.2926460505,
0.3790302277,
-0.577062428,
-0.9427143335,
-0.0683539584,
-0.1088156626,
-0.0834876373,
-0.4653762281,
0.3097046018,
0.3049150407,
0.2628598511,
0.5784453154,
-0.2181104422,
-0.8439902067,
-0.5142371058,
0.0664989948,
-0.2004739791,
0.164141655,
0.8776414394,
-0.9962075949,
0.1686027795,
0.2514607608,
0.3589789271,
0.3380847871,
0.0421208777,
1.0975267887,
-0.7445462942,
0.1699704677,
0.097191982,
0.3806225657,
-0.0338870436,
-0.4933438599,
0.3245292306,
0.1682379544,
-0.6809113026,
-0.6776715517,
0.2516727746,
-0.4676069915,
-0.2247526944,
1.400847435,
0.5043957829,
-0.0779191554,
0.0356520228,
-0.1883236468,
0.4661696851,
-0.240361318,
0.845620513,
1.0987349749,
0.1263638586,
-0.1892835498,
-0.9466522932,
0.7757578492,
0.5970678926,
-0.1148624048,
0.2723364532,
0.1632657349,
0.2114649415,
0.1042160839,
0.1390827596,
-0.0410119779,
-0.0041444888,
-0.1894915253,
0.2229385823,
0.3380718231,
-0.3887386024,
-0.1532191485,
-0.1282821894,
0.121364519,
0.1731984615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18290v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18290v2 | Direct Preference Optimization: Your Language Model is Secretly a Reward Model | 2023-05-29T17:57:46 | 2023-12-13T18:48:48 | Rafael Rafailov, Archit Sharma, Eric Mitchell, Stefano Ermon, Christopher D. Manning, Chelsea Finn | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | While large-scale unsupervised language models (LMs) learn broad world
knowledge and some reasoning skills, achieving precise control of their
behavior is difficult due to the completely unsupervised nature of their
training. Existing methods for gaining such steerability collect human labels
of the relative quality of model generations and fine-tune the unsupervised LM
to align with these preferences, often with reinforcement learning from human
feedback (RLHF). However, RLHF is a complex and often unstable procedure, first
fitting a reward model that reflects the human preferences, and then
fine-tuning the large unsupervised LM using reinforcement learning to maximize
this estimated reward without drifting too far from the original model. In this
paper we introduce a new parameterization of the reward model in RLHF that
enables extraction of the corresponding optimal policy in closed form, allowing
us to solve the standard RLHF problem with only a simple classification loss.
The resulting algorithm, which we call Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), is
stable, performant, and computationally lightweight, eliminating the need for
sampling from the LM during fine-tuning or performing significant
hyperparameter tuning. Our experiments show that DPO can fine-tune LMs to align
with human preferences as well as or better than existing methods. Notably,
fine-tuning with DPO exceeds PPO-based RLHF in ability to control sentiment of
generations, and matches or improves response quality in summarization and
single-turn dialogue while being substantially simpler to implement and train. | [
-0.4833066463,
-0.5205571651,
0.6157631874,
0.1721430272,
-0.3085091114,
0.0390523933,
-0.6679211259,
-0.0355461314,
-0.0585649647,
0.6889148951,
-0.851100564,
-0.3035444617,
-0.5023496747,
-0.1363376826,
0.3832239509,
0.8178833723,
0.0670886934,
-0.0579124391,
-0.1682307422,
0.0673824623,
-0.1121572405,
-0.5477131009,
-0.6541843414,
-0.7240476012,
0.7202315331,
0.6364976168,
0.8343731165,
0.9030814171,
0.2086150348,
0.2147206068,
-0.2034527063,
0.352222383,
-0.620265007,
0.1022390425,
-0.2115785331,
-0.284734726,
-0.3211664855,
0.1304809153,
0.4252997041,
0.8245977759,
-0.318623513,
-0.0885386243,
0.0907596424,
1.1223130226,
-0.7876726985,
0.240237847,
-0.5255827904,
0.0882974267,
0.2129245996,
-0.4775521457,
-0.4141834676,
-0.5714842677,
0.3138020039,
-0.5493815541,
-0.1347644478,
0.0054689497,
0.8204897046,
0.5299121737,
-0.2995186448,
-0.0325862095,
-0.9604125023,
1.0141361952,
-0.5318657756,
0.3396968246,
0.4171005487,
0.143966943,
-0.3144395053,
-0.1161523759,
-0.2480166256,
-0.4625151157,
0.0827521458,
-0.0449930727,
0.0199562628,
0.3806277812,
0.0181527603,
0.3304277062,
-0.2028002739,
0.4180398285,
0.0110523384,
-0.1520027518,
0.6393036842,
-0.0120939035,
-0.0142907603,
-0.0513650626,
-0.3112380803,
-0.4077720642,
-0.7617986202,
0.5010088086,
0.6360526681,
0.3568355441,
0.2323459387,
0.3255822659,
-0.5584215522,
0.6986506581,
0.3158626258,
-0.2802282572,
0.0274287835,
0.210282892,
-0.0167015288,
-0.0146814985,
0.8273037672,
0.3955350518,
0.4514111876,
-0.1428304464,
-0.3620463312,
0.0163309295,
0.1008220837,
-0.7744961977,
-0.0999471545,
0.3268502951,
-0.4338469207,
-0.6893324256,
-0.0442387648,
-0.6562918425,
-0.4300203919,
-0.6571372151,
0.0800485238,
-0.059128046,
-0.399258703,
0.3559366763,
0.1262175739,
0.0314043574,
0.2453836203,
-1.22105968,
0.2323633432,
0.8712946773,
0.4409823716,
-0.4572534561,
-0.1983046532,
-0.7243078351,
-0.0724014863,
-0.4107105732,
0.5845056176,
-0.5817869306,
-0.4489687085,
0.1292445064,
-0.101731576,
0.1119803041,
-0.642098546,
0.7608991265,
-0.5659513474,
0.1904072016,
-0.1564757824,
-0.386631012,
-0.0732106045,
0.201549083,
-0.4939086139,
0.7842644453,
-0.1188424304,
-0.6313317418,
0.3963994086,
-0.4900700152,
-0.2112612277,
-0.3063973486,
-0.0268884078,
-0.3232227564,
0.1935022026,
0.2496812493,
0.4784126282,
-0.1423398852,
0.6582918763,
-0.3503633142,
-0.3493674695,
0.0537396856,
-0.2021988481,
0.3372935653,
0.1963031143,
-0.2927969396,
0.552456975,
-0.6054555178,
0.045888193,
0.1509038806,
-0.6664413214,
-0.513391614,
0.4000414908,
-0.2826420665,
0.1525134742,
0.4039656818,
-0.529296875,
0.3343023658,
-0.7480918169,
0.3940213621,
1.1442422867,
-0.159897238,
0.8699727654,
-0.0276215188,
0.4956154227,
-0.0929084197,
0.4316569269,
0.290117234,
-0.0245924424,
-0.7225086093,
-0.1201222315,
0.2543688416,
0.3731395304,
-0.3667694628,
0.7840291858,
-0.0439703986,
-0.2524151504,
-0.4086369872,
0.1272827387,
0.319344759,
0.4393138289,
0.089565143,
-0.0233721845,
-0.331399858,
-1.16071558,
-0.1089242324,
-0.0929714739,
0.0709617734,
0.4589516819,
-0.0811339244,
-0.2018064708,
0.9218386412,
-0.8330858946,
-0.0267212931,
-0.3477546275,
-0.0280662887,
0.3669109941,
0.3289420605,
0.1413574219,
-0.7776325941,
-0.4354940057,
0.0371983238,
-0.3053206801,
-0.0647425801,
0.2508134842,
-0.294411391,
0.2126460522,
0.1276996434,
-0.2987187207,
-0.087661095,
0.5033888817,
-0.1295984983,
0.3283849359,
-0.4963991642,
-0.177831322,
-0.5376750827,
0.0683838129,
-0.0478578694,
-0.2255551517,
-0.3079779446,
-0.0852922052,
0.0992520303,
-0.1755208671,
-0.2886386514,
0.5515944362,
-0.310970068,
0.2149027586,
-0.4872450233,
-0.0265284814,
-0.1602008194,
0.9435925484,
0.3768796623,
0.4493204653,
0.6086380482,
-0.8394802809,
0.4426455796,
-0.0097923288,
-0.1028029248,
0.165961653,
-0.6842635274,
0.2277477533,
-0.4670318365,
0.0596843548,
-0.6795910001,
-0.0465200469,
0.2571961582,
-0.12262398,
0.44466573,
-0.0903583691,
-0.1389187425,
-0.1654229611,
-0.5008071661,
0.0385746844,
0.5636282563,
-0.687808156,
0.2236553431,
0.4552795887,
-0.0725995451,
-0.754105866,
0.0698774308,
-0.3637003303,
-0.2100122571,
-0.2986270785,
0.2817952335,
-0.1885384172,
-0.1308965385,
-0.2687534988,
-0.2725733221,
0.1680481136,
0.1470763534,
0.2593208253,
0.2724941671,
0.188863188,
0.0192343201,
0.162418291,
-0.4446711838,
-0.0440193042,
-0.2398006767,
0.6554038525,
-0.0672822297,
-0.0370325558,
-0.3305660486,
0.2510050833,
0.4950592518,
-0.3246931434,
0.3405436575,
0.1539226323,
0.1317911595,
-0.474221766,
-0.4256368279,
-0.4380840957,
-0.4931181967,
0.3846471012,
-0.4193928242,
-0.8643575311,
0.0101864357,
-0.3053367138,
-0.0087707089,
0.1425201595,
0.4450175464,
0.2244847119,
1.4425173998,
0.7462638617,
-0.3832081258,
0.6659399867,
-0.0645944178,
-0.0839605257,
-0.5458321571,
-0.2163265347,
-0.4806261063,
-0.2981657684,
-0.7161502838,
-0.0594137907,
0.2428919673,
0.1438756734,
-0.3419018686,
-0.0152410697,
-0.7765519023,
0.557731092,
0.8166819811,
0.2505930662,
0.3892948627,
0.0483801588,
-0.1661176533,
-0.1252246797,
-0.6121200919,
-0.4389956295,
0.9022860527,
0.5176717043,
1.0370371342,
-0.2831425667,
0.8076553345,
0.1634609699,
-0.090214096,
-0.9815594554,
0.4496521354,
-0.2846980095,
-0.1248806193,
-0.5146611929,
-0.5235899687,
-0.8562402129,
0.2861516476,
-0.1232299134,
-0.5830142498,
0.3067244887,
0.4284312725,
-0.2489638627,
0.0515574031,
-0.5721492171,
0.7779142261,
-0.3681982458,
-0.4295808673,
-0.3267530203,
-0.6231577992,
0.2656161785,
0.3131347299,
0.0217137598,
-0.4618362188,
-0.0717282966,
0.6006035805,
-0.1890922338,
0.6147834063,
-0.3684868217,
-0.2295855582,
-0.1770362109,
0.1929459572,
0.7395098805,
0.0858493224,
-0.0549445078,
-0.2036945671,
-0.0554901063,
-0.2988581061,
-0.6632010937,
0.9317372441,
-1.1483705044,
-0.7275424004,
-0.3578436673,
-0.2572812438,
-0.4878405631,
0.0950787812,
0.0857073143,
0.2729082406,
-0.3095118999,
0.0355298482,
0.9284939766,
-0.2436505705,
0.3697917461,
0.5976383686,
-0.3182517588,
-0.3743752539,
0.8475319743,
-0.3829596341,
0.2851675451,
0.7533089519,
0.7443847656,
-0.5221019983,
-0.4468948841,
-0.4752934873,
0.3512032628,
-0.5499027967,
0.0536231995,
-0.3852342069,
0.0762065947,
-0.070396468,
-0.0286110751,
-0.6694535017,
-0.3022884727,
-0.2474002838,
-0.0774263665,
0.1931565106,
0.574308455,
-0.0233302601,
0.1154680252,
-0.4349497855,
0.213909328,
0.4781508744,
0.5729382634,
-0.1379761398,
-0.3012063503,
-0.0110293897,
0.1307877749,
-0.1832250506,
-0.5762584209,
0.3307576478,
-0.0341375209,
0.5791150928,
0.5423790812,
0.2810675204,
0.3343382478,
-0.4214976132,
0.3442471921,
0.1807819754,
-0.7442277074,
0.7614668608,
-0.3623426259,
0.1581965238,
0.6227155328,
0.4267027676,
-0.4847857058,
0.085937649,
-0.3700197935,
-0.7777770162,
0.8675256371,
-0.363679111,
0.1483969986,
0.1927957088,
0.3987023532,
0.149347648,
0.2966462374,
-0.5413511992,
-0.2803510427,
-0.1821515411,
0.0877929702,
-0.2002555132,
-0.4944433868,
-0.2470746487,
-0.2727001607,
0.7488214374,
-0.2395570874,
-0.1077652648,
-0.0005347942,
0.2663525045,
-0.322942555,
0.357865274,
0.6159357429,
0.6407829523,
-0.5777798891,
0.1097651795,
-0.4833445251,
-0.1058848724,
0.3261215985,
-0.0818547308,
-0.3242157996,
-0.2458724976,
-0.2605063021,
1.1732965708,
0.1353655159,
-0.6870266795,
0.509272337,
-0.0496202521,
-0.1904618889,
-0.1472378224,
0.2853933275,
0.0242665615,
-0.0014139017,
0.1754342914,
-0.0475791395,
0.0383490138,
-0.4285535216,
-0.0120723136,
0.5579003096,
-0.6899250746,
-0.173015371,
0.5012162328,
0.5168831348,
-0.3182145357,
0.3015138805,
-0.1085103601,
-0.3927460313,
0.364168644,
0.3514464796,
0.9174745679,
-0.1363121271,
0.5383381844,
0.3383647799,
0.0447474606,
-0.4138461947,
-0.0327718183,
-0.200832054,
-0.9117800593,
-0.4751778543,
-0.797793448,
-0.6263126135,
0.1639930755,
-0.721667707,
0.1007873192,
-0.5796687603,
0.0425865576,
-0.1432286203,
0.1272885054,
-0.3731101751,
0.1945029646,
0.0707120672,
0.5343043804,
-0.615659833,
0.8905189037,
0.7382972836,
-0.1913698912,
-0.8139804006,
-0.128809005,
-0.2981032431,
-0.9882487059,
0.7097686529,
-0.1678729355,
-0.2704100013,
0.0823569745,
-0.4731993377,
-0.6810734868,
0.6913952231,
0.5266301036,
-0.7352766991,
-0.053647995,
-0.0038087624,
0.3569245934,
-0.3136864603,
0.0468603112,
0.6882664561,
0.4945712388,
0.1760648787,
-0.8398920894,
0.05928047,
0.1096243039,
0.2045267671,
0.4141956568,
-0.7731383443,
0.5091934204,
-0.1804117262,
-0.0156105263,
-0.242836073,
0.3201858997,
0.2444668114,
-0.1078992337,
0.7396315932,
0.3422047496,
0.5877887011,
-0.0823767707,
1.0673943758,
-0.2328905761,
0.4162401557,
0.8654076457,
-0.248068735,
0.8367187977,
0.6683786511,
-0.1843745559,
0.2339933664,
0.8226296306,
0.3228575289,
0.8619299531,
0.4246454835,
-0.1838570386,
-0.4939605594,
-0.1740852147,
-0.0976404697,
0.3558073044,
-0.1294589341,
-0.2201718837,
-0.155001536,
0.0419895314,
0.1183973476,
0.4759791791,
-0.3735760748,
0.9967304468,
-0.1143314987,
-1.0719161034,
0.8170098066,
0.1474006325,
0.9184837341,
-0.7268543839,
0.1867803484,
-0.4059403837,
0.4241330624,
-0.0873693079,
-0.4872163236,
0.0076999152,
-0.3448233902,
-0.3486075699,
-0.418621242,
0.6431100965,
-0.5197558403,
-0.1986247897,
0.4223310351,
0.4191245437,
-0.1487276852,
-0.3646389842,
-0.5875275731,
0.0863756686,
0.2737860084,
-0.4687895179,
0.5175165534,
0.1785402,
0.1546753347,
0.8215613365,
0.6166971326,
0.3864097595,
-0.3418120444,
0.1826845556,
0.8782301545,
-0.6623471379,
-0.5683633089,
-0.8481448889,
0.2022528201,
-0.0076000313,
-0.3262815773,
0.400370419,
0.3847955465,
0.7258205414,
-0.2774685025,
0.7059197426,
0.3221780956,
0.5844984651,
-0.4778944552,
0.4614214599,
-0.6235663891,
0.1307132542,
-0.1813117266,
-0.9958689809,
-0.1438012868,
0.5441195965,
-0.3361034393,
-0.2451646179,
0.4905510545,
0.8099713922,
0.0200197306,
-0.2519435287,
0.4292807281,
-0.1898803115,
0.1653821766,
0.5988047719,
0.8895338178,
0.1775158197,
0.4345526993,
-0.5785250664,
-0.4075097442,
-0.1967454702,
-0.9220411181,
-0.7674837708,
-0.3639582992,
-0.3265264034,
-0.120920375,
0.1734577864,
1.0812041759,
0.9083073735,
-0.73376894,
-0.4416766465,
-0.1716847122,
0.438831687,
-0.2184974402,
-0.2566694915,
0.3216645718,
-0.4633541703,
-1.0213890076,
0.4200337231,
0.3791736066,
-0.1573423594,
-0.4126897454,
-0.4478248358,
0.0636406317,
-0.0864793658,
0.5345990062,
0.3753400147,
-0.7671169043,
-0.220794633,
0.0649098903,
-0.1059872732,
0.1264052093,
0.9588370323,
-0.5179186463,
0.5807005763,
0.5095404387,
0.6281327605,
0.5206547976,
0.1672488153,
0.8423411846,
-0.6566631794,
0.3200944662,
0.3372468054,
0.1262216121,
0.2328889072,
-0.4258926809,
0.2609474361,
0.0369006395,
-0.7879678607,
-0.6814092994,
0.542278111,
-1.0608003139,
-0.4049800634,
1.2985358238,
0.081275627,
-0.212589711,
0.1711039841,
-0.482886076,
0.0619509444,
-0.8666166663,
0.7324718237,
0.4229242206,
-0.2608717382,
-0.2664847672,
-0.2387179881,
1.0466308594,
0.5696915388,
-0.5755255222,
0.2353913635,
0.4998570085,
0.3251998127,
-0.1394118965,
0.6929221153,
0.0893446952,
-0.0546107627,
-0.4527567029,
0.1570528746,
-0.345392555,
-0.288841784,
-0.4605078101,
0.2105884552,
0.5991188884,
-0.447052449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18287v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18287v2 | LaFTer: Label-Free Tuning of Zero-shot Classifier using Language and Unlabeled Image Collections | 2023-05-29T17:56:35 | 2023-10-23T12:32:47 | M. Jehanzeb Mirza, Leonid Karlinsky, Wei Lin, Mateusz Kozinski, Horst Possegger, Rogerio Feris, Horst Bischof | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recently, large-scale pre-trained Vision and Language (VL) models have set a
new state-of-the-art (SOTA) in zero-shot visual classification enabling
open-vocabulary recognition of potentially unlimited set of categories defined
as simple language prompts. However, despite these great advances, the
performance of these zeroshot classifiers still falls short of the results of
dedicated (closed category set) classifiers trained with supervised fine
tuning. In this paper we show, for the first time, how to reduce this gap
without any labels and without any paired VL data, using an unlabeled image
collection and a set of texts auto-generated using a Large Language Model (LLM)
describing the categories of interest and effectively substituting labeled
visual instances of those categories. Using our label-free approach, we are
able to attain significant performance improvements over the zero-shot
performance of the base VL model and other contemporary methods and baselines
on a wide variety of datasets, demonstrating absolute improvement of up to
11.7% (3.8% on average) in the label-free setting. Moreover, despite our
approach being label-free, we observe 1.3% average gains over leading few-shot
prompting baselines that do use 5-shot supervision. | [
-0.49105528,
-0.4521510005,
0.1911174208,
-0.4615907967,
-0.5039855838,
0.1312743574,
-0.3055327237,
-0.6909987926,
0.0265668482,
0.568578124,
-0.3021610081,
-0.5468053222,
-0.5447410345,
-0.2221778929,
-0.2299099714,
1.1999989748,
-0.138928473,
-0.2775036097,
-0.0773975626,
-0.3965552449,
-0.3564997017,
-0.2128945589,
-0.5753941536,
-0.4443491399,
0.6844418645,
0.4215246737,
0.4166123569,
0.8215717673,
0.4183951318,
0.1139080301,
-0.0432403386,
0.140491873,
-0.625271976,
-0.0585302748,
-0.0641316697,
-0.5595761538,
-0.2189754248,
-0.0650211796,
0.6698422432,
0.4031045437,
0.2116443962,
0.380676955,
0.0501900464,
0.6264767647,
-1.06022048,
0.266739428,
-0.7855821848,
0.2002349794,
-0.5951849222,
-0.5020352602,
-0.6137083173,
0.136544019,
-0.2684042156,
-0.7125285864,
0.5078787208,
-0.1750161797,
1.2967174053,
0.5863837004,
-0.0514338501,
0.1690319031,
-0.6629673839,
0.7756354809,
-0.2122152001,
0.4457647502,
0.282515049,
0.3778323531,
-0.0157584269,
-0.4460508227,
-0.4157053232,
0.0102354279,
0.0703008696,
0.2033563256,
-0.4171146154,
0.0667126477,
0.348608613,
0.2469859868,
-0.4544203579,
0.5198706985,
-0.6308346987,
-0.1365345418,
0.4807528853,
-0.2348074317,
-0.1078858078,
0.4010649621,
-0.2264739573,
-0.2949374616,
-0.7938612103,
0.3324549198,
-0.1773763448,
0.5264543891,
-0.0422565714,
0.7714213133,
-0.3143059611,
1.1255069971,
0.0479274057,
-0.0423331112,
0.29521209,
0.0880833343,
-0.488402456,
0.1164591685,
0.7985882163,
0.6181361675,
0.728502214,
-0.1419993341,
-0.2113705724,
0.5219578743,
-0.1308685392,
-0.7664115429,
-0.1940181404,
-0.0554013886,
-0.0034266345,
-0.2774515748,
-0.2860304713,
-0.4092877209,
-0.3357200623,
-0.1239045337,
0.4970039725,
0.0586948656,
0.2450969815,
0.2009369582,
0.0173520111,
0.4788422287,
0.4175697863,
-0.6621672511,
-0.1486754566,
0.1598414034,
0.8488231301,
0.0783292055,
0.0333174579,
-0.9250848889,
0.2288152725,
-0.6558761597,
1.1369694471,
-0.2711432576,
-0.3248744011,
-0.0910542831,
-0.0989122689,
0.2548762262,
-0.5177170038,
0.2356663048,
-0.469183892,
0.1202505305,
0.1430300474,
-0.597730577,
0.0997982249,
0.1157260314,
-0.4316591918,
0.9329538345,
-0.0626979768,
-0.5116379261,
0.7364051938,
-0.5429959893,
-0.1187210232,
0.5389291048,
-0.181553185,
-0.476615876,
0.139913857,
0.3069640994,
0.5694882274,
-0.0840267166,
0.174828887,
-0.4142440557,
-0.6670175791,
0.0232003238,
-0.2524178922,
0.6383814216,
0.1330652982,
-0.1869003177,
0.1164243892,
-0.9391195774,
0.3863604367,
0.0466988645,
-0.1917879432,
-0.4834425747,
-0.4176793098,
-0.0147525705,
0.1950692683,
0.0560495257,
-0.6986473203,
0.303692311,
-0.4741497934,
-0.2519970238,
0.6485746503,
-0.2597368658,
0.4724914432,
-0.0159257948,
0.3541217446,
-0.030900158,
0.0774681121,
-0.2743636072,
-0.4457593262,
-1.2309070826,
-0.504701376,
0.5459412932,
0.6387327909,
-1.1076266766,
0.4084942639,
-0.1160522327,
-0.3627588451,
-0.7425755262,
0.2177368551,
0.7087036371,
0.6242915988,
0.4284870028,
-0.4770665169,
-0.345567286,
-0.8655329347,
-0.2260975391,
0.081616044,
-0.3115029335,
0.1459712982,
0.2447374761,
0.0746015236,
1.0075242519,
-0.7513204217,
-0.5446637273,
-0.0100779552,
0.1197564229,
0.1758392453,
0.2094467133,
0.5767473578,
-0.2596862614,
-0.6636996865,
0.1166031063,
-0.9361832738,
-0.3252634108,
0.1508591771,
-0.0403900407,
0.6099787354,
0.5859803557,
-0.1255494654,
0.7046529055,
0.2003338039,
-0.3460097909,
0.0331172273,
-0.1382805705,
-0.4365118444,
-0.6140074134,
-0.0606301613,
0.382067591,
-0.2142186761,
-0.8777052164,
0.1963044256,
0.1943189502,
0.000578349,
-0.8497954607,
0.8454211354,
-0.4062476754,
0.1937081367,
-0.4613499641,
0.0880823284,
-0.1962910891,
0.4176024497,
0.4253798425,
0.4842990637,
1.0014220476,
-0.5795691013,
-0.0765902847,
0.121746704,
-0.4683443904,
0.729696691,
-0.4481222332,
-0.0090949759,
-0.5312520266,
0.0779332593,
-0.5745766163,
-0.0947849825,
0.4633524716,
-0.3323356807,
0.6554902196,
0.0936001316,
-0.3432972133,
-0.4086895585,
-0.3115430772,
0.3296538591,
0.5373454094,
-0.5768752098,
-0.1624850035,
0.1729154885,
0.3596250713,
-0.6484818459,
-0.669474721,
-0.0544190221,
-0.0572522655,
-0.0159841031,
-0.1085396707,
-0.104168579,
0.0867788792,
-0.0032328591,
-0.2407104075,
-0.2484083474,
-0.1482755095,
0.126017198,
0.3884006143,
-0.151105389,
0.4609938562,
-0.3203117847,
-0.3600740433,
-0.7494558096,
-0.207676366,
0.171882391,
-0.3046573102,
0.0067901588,
-0.2582457662,
-0.0057536168,
0.0870221481,
-0.3616728485,
0.7438080311,
0.7383998632,
-0.2032253295,
-0.248987332,
-0.3850000799,
0.1039305851,
-0.4659545124,
0.0243891478,
-0.2575345039,
-1.4504426718,
0.120546028,
0.1494408995,
-0.0778536797,
0.3041186929,
0.3065685332,
-0.2481213063,
0.4098793566,
0.9897168279,
0.1316641867,
0.4943712652,
-0.2434950173,
0.3063668311,
-0.5024254322,
-0.2015627027,
-0.3070436418,
-0.3656324446,
-0.7602763176,
-0.5296698809,
0.5125196576,
0.3615741134,
-0.1737684906,
0.2387725562,
-0.6669171453,
1.0906399488,
0.6679397225,
0.0335534774,
0.3136090934,
0.2902440429,
0.1074609086,
0.0151942736,
-0.636482656,
-0.1375510991,
1.1373195648,
-0.0249994025,
0.7209632397,
-0.3526556492,
0.9817246199,
0.0385959819,
0.2590554357,
-1.1286627054,
0.6068361998,
-0.474671036,
-0.4260777533,
-0.3310528696,
-0.3492353559,
-1.0732774734,
0.2771238089,
-0.310303539,
-0.8798294067,
0.0607140027,
0.3985224664,
-0.4185860157,
0.4287911654,
-0.5658742785,
0.6933956146,
-0.2024392039,
-0.5053040981,
0.4072786272,
-0.630177021,
0.5287035704,
-0.4453211129,
-0.0562353581,
-0.3870039284,
-0.0572588854,
0.4270827174,
-0.2397090346,
0.8814224005,
-0.3189595342,
-0.1010070145,
0.3545697629,
-0.1132020429,
-0.0937820673,
-0.5185235143,
0.4412896931,
0.3751186132,
0.0609410107,
-0.5534564257,
-0.4404763877,
0.5264160037,
-0.5333504081,
-0.3689168692,
-0.5172104239,
-0.5126494765,
-0.3473841846,
0.4565382898,
0.422704041,
0.265632391,
0.117773369,
0.3898109794,
0.7427560687,
-0.3931941986,
0.6793828607,
0.6530840993,
-0.2850252986,
-0.3124391139,
0.9202637076,
0.3137506843,
0.1447960436,
0.5452584624,
0.0618253313,
-0.3814612925,
-0.2762200236,
-0.4387769103,
0.1615393758,
-0.5754627585,
-0.6830852628,
-0.2670053542,
-0.2690775096,
-0.2001989782,
-0.4494667649,
-0.4152873158,
-0.5360360742,
-0.396145612,
0.003250913,
0.5013303161,
0.3633811474,
0.0139305769,
0.5658088923,
-0.7337098122,
0.5062118173,
0.1921269745,
0.7759743929,
-0.2039439678,
-0.4366369843,
-0.3145995438,
-0.2022894025,
-0.2459975481,
-0.3608882725,
0.4115726054,
0.6581940055,
0.3758914173,
0.3723216355,
0.1523033679,
0.8449231982,
-0.4328073561,
0.6086964011,
0.5213344693,
-0.7769846916,
0.6981402636,
-0.3577311337,
0.7748314142,
0.3715464771,
0.2242900282,
-0.3324348927,
-0.3911541998,
-0.4435007572,
-0.8384981155,
0.7806056738,
0.0430884734,
-0.274151355,
0.2339641303,
0.147964105,
0.0207700953,
0.2735167146,
-0.957870841,
-0.1796059161,
-0.2703166902,
-0.077395916,
-0.4068345428,
0.0660849139,
0.0844151378,
-0.5717183948,
0.5980349183,
-0.3674621582,
-0.0421028137,
-0.0964501649,
-0.0552108549,
-0.3397554457,
0.4596158862,
0.5432879329,
0.1173592284,
-0.3249805868,
0.0935991034,
-0.0464056171,
0.0112250187,
0.3915160894,
-0.1271396577,
-0.8160218596,
-0.0445874184,
0.1363682002,
1.2436341047,
0.135512799,
-0.6799092889,
0.3000200689,
0.2537862957,
-0.4417749941,
0.1050982326,
0.1657832414,
-0.2774159908,
0.1432218999,
-0.0696724877,
0.0544301532,
-0.210113734,
-0.2350064814,
0.2783481181,
0.6070333123,
-0.5875675678,
-0.0231363159,
0.6198750734,
-0.2184686363,
-0.090015918,
0.3544961214,
-0.2737154365,
0.1194752306,
0.2291539758,
0.5674238801,
0.8514759541,
-0.1721182168,
0.5541140437,
0.3508963883,
0.2636074126,
-0.1325873137,
0.184812203,
-0.2212875187,
-0.953481853,
-0.2915652692,
-0.9323982596,
-0.2823558748,
0.4845141768,
-0.7067818046,
0.3169458807,
-0.4304068685,
0.017192198,
0.1629368365,
-0.277828902,
-0.6572568417,
0.3254799247,
0.3271211982,
0.7644315362,
-0.7996504903,
1.0459692478,
0.6851252317,
-0.4108169377,
-0.7079342008,
-0.1947884262,
-0.1246499121,
-0.8921024799,
0.4219742417,
0.3985362351,
-0.3566299081,
0.140935868,
-0.6790754795,
-0.5770719051,
0.6912724376,
0.3560746908,
-0.7622708082,
0.2526564598,
0.2236727923,
0.8350533843,
-0.0125545245,
-0.0677021593,
0.4472408593,
0.3528872728,
0.6776407957,
-1.0964053869,
-0.3939660788,
-0.2874237299,
0.0416869558,
0.6504543424,
-0.7154975533,
0.4292622805,
-0.0303332526,
-0.2448046952,
0.0047247661,
0.2394272536,
0.075923644,
0.6110185981,
0.2770926356,
0.8219242692,
0.6644871831,
-0.1975221038,
0.7191070914,
-0.0471041538,
0.3569353521,
1.1609624624,
-0.5308561921,
1.0389664173,
0.5259870887,
0.034354873,
-0.0305986367,
0.4765412807,
-0.3997898996,
0.7754018307,
0.2328149378,
-0.4513320029,
-0.4586343169,
-0.44402197,
-0.2371396124,
0.7689177394,
0.2743085921,
-0.0600927547,
-0.6373104453,
0.1995828897,
-0.2190059721,
-0.0454070866,
-0.7345309854,
0.7502212524,
0.0470220856,
-0.5238535404,
1.2952691317,
-0.2883651853,
0.9552474022,
-0.4648673534,
0.1784180254,
-0.1162595823,
0.3660493791,
-0.2085546553,
-0.874365747,
0.2531478703,
0.3309337795,
-0.0028145823,
-0.3541980386,
0.9323163629,
-0.5898714066,
-0.666144371,
0.1639250964,
0.6483490467,
0.4292746186,
0.115756698,
-0.2611699104,
-0.2040466964,
0.0537835583,
0.1569276601,
0.4653191566,
0.1926691532,
-0.3303346038,
0.4562213719,
0.5345798731,
0.196860075,
0.029764507,
0.0624076948,
0.7188319564,
-0.697502315,
-0.0933909267,
-0.6555490494,
0.3329650164,
0.1177275926,
-0.0629472733,
0.3673358262,
0.5446760058,
1.3275382519,
-0.4781080484,
0.6501384377,
0.193074584,
0.46801278,
-0.5672209859,
0.7973791957,
-0.9688469768,
-0.1370707899,
-0.0934441462,
-0.6134745479,
-1.0706553459,
0.6195665598,
0.010259741,
-0.2646890581,
0.3868712187,
0.8672064543,
-0.0920811966,
-0.4004850984,
0.7805489898,
-0.0369938836,
0.1214989573,
0.5754401088,
0.5421071053,
-0.2672357857,
0.5582780838,
-0.267521143,
-0.3904595971,
0.0422738642,
-0.9710328579,
-1.0163557529,
-0.2560150027,
-0.4670508504,
0.0368415229,
0.127915293,
0.4979107678,
0.4178462625,
-0.9262589216,
-0.2255287319,
0.0158767458,
-0.2381242812,
-0.0272357613,
-0.2099656463,
0.0703819096,
-0.2033394426,
-0.5136768222,
0.4547859132,
0.6345596313,
0.3202410042,
0.1404857337,
0.104471229,
0.0121917594,
-0.0238213819,
0.8461369872,
0.8385811448,
-0.8072165251,
-0.2702231407,
0.0161509793,
0.3136691153,
0.3549858332,
0.4743182361,
-1.1118112803,
0.7704392672,
0.0938419923,
0.2431135029,
0.6545041203,
-0.2103516608,
0.0891416073,
-1.1860826015,
0.4862478971,
0.0460912399,
0.0875152349,
0.2694071531,
-0.0052962592,
0.5822145939,
0.2204040736,
-0.3552304804,
-0.9858387709,
0.3320177495,
-1.1607395411,
-0.0904012248,
0.7440834045,
-0.0419732966,
-0.2605686486,
0.2081958801,
-0.1632919014,
0.5644301772,
-0.32990098,
0.747600615,
0.4241224527,
-0.3217622042,
-0.5540423989,
-0.4079098105,
0.2378073037,
0.0774458423,
-0.7393878698,
-0.1271203011,
0.704346776,
0.1352588832,
0.1999498904,
0.9953015447,
0.1742940843,
0.1438181251,
-0.1883987188,
0.2525804341,
-0.1813274622,
-0.4831851423,
-0.4912888706,
0.2866874337,
0.1394867599,
-0.4905614555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18283v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18283v1 | CommonAccent: Exploring Large Acoustic Pretrained Models for Accent Classification Based on Common Voice | 2023-05-29T17:53:35 | 2023-05-29T17:53:35 | Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Sara Ahmed, Danielius Visockas, Cem Subakan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS | Despite the recent advancements in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), the
recognition of accented speech still remains a dominant problem. In order to
create more inclusive ASR systems, research has shown that the integration of
accent information, as part of a larger ASR framework, can lead to the
mitigation of accented speech errors. We address multilingual accent
classification through the ECAPA-TDNN and Wav2Vec 2.0/XLSR architectures which
have been proven to perform well on a variety of speech-related downstream
tasks. We introduce a simple-to-follow recipe aligned to the SpeechBrain
toolkit for accent classification based on Common Voice 7.0 (English) and
Common Voice 11.0 (Italian, German, and Spanish). Furthermore, we establish new
state-of-the-art for English accent classification with as high as 95%
accuracy. We also study the internal categorization of the Wav2Vev 2.0
embeddings through t-SNE, noting that there is a level of clustering based on
phonological similarity. (Our recipe is open-source in the SpeechBrain toolkit,
see: https://github.com/speechbrain/speechbrain/tree/develop/recipes) | [
-0.455802083,
-0.4812804461,
0.2255667001,
0.2308418751,
0.012377643,
0.120492816,
-0.6936954856,
-0.5290227532,
0.3022850454,
0.4057051539,
-0.215167284,
-0.6630647182,
-0.3945103586,
0.005509418,
-0.241427958,
0.4271912277,
0.1618913114,
0.4071353376,
-0.028431803,
-0.4506530762,
-0.358101964,
-0.990917623,
-0.7836285233,
-0.2083800286,
0.5248914361,
0.8412129879,
-0.0060772467,
0.1433127373,
-0.0469957367,
0.3845637739,
-0.3159544766,
0.1933777034,
-0.1700030863,
0.0793743506,
0.1752578318,
-0.3631338477,
-0.5586202145,
-0.254065156,
0.4169044197,
0.8920307159,
-0.3907406628,
0.0594106391,
0.1751375496,
0.1430870742,
-0.5575158596,
0.2279643416,
-0.5824078321,
-0.0485075712,
-0.403034538,
0.1385779381,
-0.2080086321,
-0.4962313473,
0.1472711414,
-0.4742099047,
0.3274919391,
-0.1005151421,
0.1546047032,
0.2848554552,
-0.6194933653,
-0.1876142919,
-0.8468734026,
0.9927222133,
-0.5563489199,
0.4703516364,
0.0007834493,
0.4890636802,
-0.0433369391,
-0.7754971981,
-0.8494875431,
-0.0810370147,
0.2511377335,
0.1167598292,
-0.2496612072,
0.5029901862,
-0.0181436148,
0.4714046121,
-0.6691510081,
0.5302177072,
-0.185159564,
-0.2352538109,
0.5571345091,
-0.1981693953,
0.344265908,
0.3462720513,
0.0314302966,
-0.197005108,
-0.6179808378,
0.2635623515,
0.0630855188,
0.6432235837,
-0.0606621765,
0.2098094076,
-0.1383031756,
0.2532114685,
0.0827677771,
0.1831164509,
0.4933501482,
0.0740423575,
0.1734946072,
0.7458823323,
0.5475049615,
0.198159799,
0.4637242556,
0.1751036346,
-0.1391278654,
0.1376815438,
0.0631545112,
-0.5764413476,
0.1084834039,
0.2933986187,
-0.0879022554,
-0.1253784448,
-0.0060580615,
-0.4258338213,
-0.097928986,
-0.4888999164,
0.4855540991,
0.2138412446,
-0.5513566136,
-0.0143455826,
-0.1235904843,
0.1380617768,
0.4646270573,
-0.7742719054,
0.6307454705,
0.803679049,
0.7137806416,
-0.3093139231,
-0.2303621769,
-0.4379769862,
-0.2147767246,
-0.2104207575,
0.6042692661,
-0.2736068964,
-0.3982926905,
0.3390725553,
0.2000485063,
-0.0369674042,
-0.6025379896,
0.4705705643,
-0.2571159303,
-0.0707796514,
-0.1090119854,
-0.2582047284,
-0.4850292802,
0.1419524997,
-0.8500418067,
0.792026937,
-0.2912023962,
-0.3258004189,
0.2122252882,
-0.5783404112,
-0.5419870615,
-0.1621123999,
-0.2639771998,
-0.3510251343,
0.2093614489,
0.0165867172,
0.2991812825,
-0.2155309021,
0.0349257663,
-0.246992901,
-0.4672072232,
0.0029805931,
-0.6213733554,
0.9128371477,
0.263124764,
-0.4176670313,
-0.054862503,
-1.0378644466,
0.0956705362,
-0.2405967116,
-0.0831937119,
-0.2614515722,
-0.3485810459,
0.3358141482,
-0.1128599644,
0.25271824,
-0.7392888665,
-0.0215036888,
-0.1548263729,
0.3440346122,
0.2372202575,
-0.0098554082,
0.3808550537,
0.0229177363,
0.1247434914,
0.0272251889,
-0.0192925278,
-0.0158991907,
-0.4388007522,
-0.7893001437,
-0.0689399317,
0.1948590577,
0.7983264923,
-0.1616324782,
0.552976191,
-0.1394912004,
-0.6591748595,
-0.2945252657,
-0.2155078799,
0.4875169396,
0.3140255213,
0.5394455791,
-0.5170689821,
-0.4693988264,
-0.5398539305,
0.0712645501,
-0.0857808068,
-0.2773448527,
0.462905407,
-0.1425689459,
-0.0830244645,
0.5572692156,
-0.2284269333,
-0.366001308,
-0.248356685,
0.4424205422,
0.2731806338,
0.6850432158,
0.4042304754,
-0.8549801111,
-0.5444200039,
0.2939604521,
-0.2586959302,
-0.3123294413,
0.3945761919,
0.4415818453,
0.0473018065,
0.5637264252,
-0.4876668751,
0.4597635269,
0.3719092906,
0.1930510849,
0.4976021051,
-0.1138597578,
0.3525576293,
-0.9711458683,
0.0028712216,
-0.1310851127,
-0.0375917293,
-0.961155355,
-0.4827793837,
-0.1462228298,
-0.2013568431,
-0.5663283467,
0.386482358,
-0.3918452859,
-0.3466136158,
-0.0745540708,
-0.2099144459,
0.0268948898,
0.6647425294,
0.3389681578,
0.7606773376,
0.4216658473,
-0.49582991,
0.4789685011,
0.2496183664,
-0.2103125304,
0.5837529898,
-0.6616927385,
0.7295004725,
0.1419458985,
0.2484648973,
-0.7454835773,
-0.1217593476,
-0.3638472557,
-0.5820037127,
0.7386681437,
-0.3767978847,
-0.0730691999,
-0.2969862819,
0.0602709241,
0.6691203713,
0.3982693553,
-0.8271195292,
0.8755148053,
0.5485053658,
-0.6819720864,
-0.7303475738,
-0.6862862706,
0.0192561336,
-0.17053096,
-0.5486518145,
0.4027605057,
0.1070698425,
-0.214857623,
-0.295244813,
-0.1029057354,
-0.5941058397,
-0.1160832122,
0.2107274681,
-0.1563072801,
-0.6037943959,
0.1447579116,
0.0859094039,
0.0443310514,
-0.2881605923,
-0.3490212262,
0.410957545,
-0.2992747128,
-0.3808885813,
-0.3797748387,
0.6818273067,
0.6521689892,
-0.5291025043,
0.2308723629,
0.6569731236,
-0.3390383422,
-0.3054274321,
-0.9824112654,
-0.0668960437,
-0.4519350231,
0.6201072335,
-0.2293872237,
-0.9046480656,
0.6697288156,
-0.1336752027,
0.0086365892,
0.1908798069,
0.3172678351,
0.0519268587,
0.9391923547,
0.4990993738,
0.0010517952,
0.5318335295,
-0.155143857,
-0.0861512423,
-0.4700711668,
-0.0978491455,
-0.7793419957,
-0.0061498154,
-0.5729751587,
-0.341945231,
0.4352182746,
-0.3589503467,
-0.3604580462,
0.2472020239,
-0.5007286072,
0.6013094783,
0.5770733356,
-0.1549319178,
0.0837440342,
-0.1107942536,
-0.182215929,
0.2170785069,
-0.5657328367,
-0.3098948896,
1.0897121429,
0.2714571357,
0.4796794653,
0.0716378987,
0.683127284,
0.1561457515,
-0.0366701335,
-0.7655014396,
0.2705873251,
-0.7249900103,
-0.4483492076,
-0.405946523,
-0.3052333593,
-0.759331286,
0.0953017995,
-0.1660699248,
-0.740726769,
0.5593355298,
0.2571286857,
-0.5860754848,
0.2103331685,
-0.9221194386,
0.8318814039,
-0.5110659599,
-0.2483691871,
-0.5640530586,
-0.6505865455,
-0.068239443,
-0.149993971,
0.0734391287,
0.1661291122,
0.3819978535,
0.7014877796,
-0.3799723983,
0.6683007479,
-0.498275131,
0.3515307307,
0.4727789462,
-0.3692766726,
0.1469688416,
-0.3048940301,
-0.2369755059,
0.8016102314,
0.1335067004,
-0.2675542831,
-0.5455260873,
0.5939434767,
-0.8956193924,
-0.3339129984,
-0.3053493202,
0.0680458918,
-0.3376929462,
0.1961105913,
0.2821894288,
0.8900054097,
-0.6163833141,
0.3146431744,
0.7589924932,
-0.2376583368,
0.2975636125,
0.5891931653,
0.3154932261,
-0.5980683565,
0.7439844012,
0.4232467115,
-0.0089079728,
0.3259679377,
0.0607699566,
-0.3130023181,
-0.7610731125,
-0.2186596096,
-0.1566679031,
-0.6406539083,
-0.0089148181,
-0.4183152914,
-0.3009225428,
-0.5730572343,
-0.0268576574,
-0.6643738151,
-0.5742461085,
-0.2071941048,
0.0070631737,
0.0586658269,
0.9923680425,
-0.2856995761,
0.5765179396,
-0.810002625,
-0.1379008442,
0.7725652456,
0.156117171,
0.0901356265,
-0.3828905225,
-0.4892987013,
-0.1027915776,
-0.1140119731,
-0.6868235469,
0.3638370335,
0.5044163465,
0.7423328161,
0.6049838066,
0.0650804713,
0.4750959575,
-0.7099924088,
0.7599723339,
0.3070799112,
-0.9230749607,
0.2261803895,
0.0038303675,
0.1131708324,
0.8775371313,
0.3246977627,
-0.6382041574,
-0.0622667596,
-0.3541122079,
-1.031124115,
0.4704404473,
-0.137542069,
0.0255893096,
0.0720964447,
0.0622707456,
0.1405820251,
0.2986277342,
-0.3618603349,
-0.0423739552,
-0.4142403305,
-0.5623980761,
-0.2175629586,
-0.1225063428,
0.0571447015,
-0.2402291894,
0.4774575233,
-0.1152052879,
0.1371652335,
0.164133057,
-0.4577935636,
0.0086558079,
0.4552841783,
0.536182344,
0.138774097,
-0.4654377401,
0.3287231028,
0.6497553587,
-0.7363638282,
0.2093174458,
0.2849327624,
0.3452270329,
0.0569868498,
0.2777707875,
0.6233403087,
0.4428493083,
-0.2403683066,
0.768443644,
-0.3750682771,
-0.0174188782,
-1.1242887974,
0.0672184899,
-0.1480825245,
0.1754894108,
0.5221125484,
0.0381693505,
0.3171394765,
-0.4125470221,
0.2150527835,
0.2099960893,
-0.5114489794,
-0.622672081,
0.140210107,
0.6905860901,
-0.4586999714,
0.4567735493,
-0.2314293981,
-0.9841387272,
0.6835646033,
0.2889178991,
1.1335471869,
-0.8323376775,
-0.4483492076,
0.574341476,
-0.0895654634,
-0.1815355867,
0.0914098322,
-0.2897383273,
-0.8282172084,
-0.2706626654,
-0.3649208248,
-0.664930284,
0.037350975,
-0.8131596446,
0.5286181569,
-0.4043868184,
-0.1165232286,
-0.0163350366,
0.0933587924,
-0.8366867304,
0.2456593513,
0.7175734639,
0.7649587393,
-1.0701819658,
0.674705565,
0.7711241245,
-0.2068553716,
-0.9263352156,
-0.1263410747,
0.4160929024,
-0.5919295549,
0.3372107744,
0.6096121073,
-0.3587124646,
0.0069095227,
-0.4669008851,
-0.7434483767,
0.9564580917,
-0.0441539064,
-0.7779325843,
-0.0338958055,
0.196321547,
0.4994260967,
-0.5003160238,
0.6530611515,
0.6311792135,
0.3251680136,
0.2646104097,
-1.4445515871,
-0.4906108677,
-0.3413891792,
-0.3363147378,
-0.2590486705,
-0.5952373743,
0.7349439859,
0.0058850348,
-0.2023827732,
-0.1026483253,
0.407528609,
0.1588332653,
0.8099660277,
0.8925523758,
0.5072398782,
0.9903818965,
-0.148688525,
0.2461486459,
-0.2239623368,
-0.179516688,
1.1791270971,
-0.4653965235,
1.1148321629,
0.0076985378,
-0.1917045265,
0.5809305906,
0.5192754269,
0.140151307,
0.3218002915,
0.0939198807,
-0.5468370318,
-0.1450134963,
-0.1743341386,
-0.3257037103,
0.8825819492,
0.5890533924,
0.1840158701,
0.2576741874,
0.029190965,
-0.033707656,
-0.0753103197,
-0.6146730781,
1.0356650352,
0.4099468887,
-0.379420042,
0.4093803763,
-0.5785781145,
0.7925199866,
-0.3973277509,
-0.2529443204,
-0.1618714333,
0.1185757592,
-0.3211425245,
-0.468844831,
0.0648509562,
0.0782325864,
-0.0853250846,
0.163288936,
0.5724586844,
-0.7027670145,
-0.1451532841,
0.3377058208,
0.2093176097,
0.2384733558,
-0.145862475,
-0.1945228279,
0.094081156,
-0.2129487991,
0.0990441069,
-0.0276453067,
0.6093104482,
-0.0862928331,
0.2221717238,
0.5806102753,
0.4164974988,
-0.0443716012,
0.4450041354,
0.5908326507,
-0.7294011712,
-0.9711848497,
-0.0888402462,
0.5322588682,
-0.189714551,
-0.1435546279,
0.3622506857,
0.4061684608,
0.667873323,
0.1672960371,
0.695913136,
0.4327015281,
0.9294365644,
-0.292514652,
0.8061916232,
-0.6395252943,
0.247325927,
-0.1633889973,
-1.1259052753,
-0.3190323412,
0.4308989942,
-0.2288623899,
0.0057897675,
0.4135236144,
0.8677470684,
-0.1523121446,
0.0539429896,
0.2891071141,
0.1788163185,
0.2166135311,
0.3337995112,
0.855096519,
0.1275136024,
0.5780419111,
0.007094102,
-0.4221730232,
-0.4496178031,
-0.6055243611,
-0.4649009109,
-0.5258062482,
-0.1634180397,
-0.1192260981,
0.1025236547,
1.3938889503,
0.9617580771,
-1.2255131006,
-0.3786586225,
-0.0600578338,
-0.0121694254,
-0.1042512804,
-0.1620087624,
0.3041559458,
-0.1231448352,
-0.7281274199,
0.5570767522,
0.077336967,
0.2921860218,
0.0677262023,
-0.0612749644,
0.3619979918,
0.1077830493,
0.3145855367,
0.7234530449,
-0.497448802,
-0.2838080525,
-0.0929953232,
0.090368934,
0.2457984537,
0.6666001081,
-0.3933285475,
0.5548508167,
0.2376237661,
0.4585383832,
0.6166264415,
-0.0586027689,
0.7425011396,
-0.865382731,
0.3923322856,
0.5442073345,
0.3297207952,
0.5873291492,
-0.1095363945,
0.1114266217,
-0.1251635551,
-0.7986161113,
-0.8562377691,
0.1231108233,
-1.1519978046,
0.0821098462,
0.9940171838,
-0.186493665,
-0.3556295931,
-0.5397743583,
-0.0382142588,
0.641731143,
-0.5317794085,
0.545108974,
0.3059508801,
-0.0105488924,
-0.216861546,
-0.1755291671,
0.5490370989,
0.4388009906,
-0.4505524039,
-0.0097884079,
0.4109729528,
0.2575847805,
0.565389514,
0.4705209732,
0.03065845,
0.4605038464,
0.1673013568,
0.6806055903,
-0.1422546506,
-0.4007525742,
-0.7844923735,
-0.049189873,
0.3256304562,
-0.2620325983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18281v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18281v1 | HyperConformer: Multi-head HyperMixer for Efficient Speech Recognition | 2023-05-29T17:53:04 | 2023-05-29T17:53:04 | Florian Mai, Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Titouan Parcollet, Petr Motlicek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS | State-of-the-art ASR systems have achieved promising results by modeling
local and global interactions separately. While the former can be computed
efficiently, global interactions are usually modeled via attention mechanisms,
which are expensive for long input sequences. Here, we address this by
extending HyperMixer, an efficient alternative to attention exhibiting linear
complexity, to the Conformer architecture for speech recognition, leading to
HyperConformer. In particular, multi-head HyperConformer achieves comparable or
higher recognition performance while being more efficient than Conformer in
terms of inference speed, memory, parameter count, and available training data.
HyperConformer achieves a word error rate of 2.9% on Librispeech test-clean
with less than 8M neural parameters and a peak memory during training of 5.7GB,
hence trainable with accessible hardware. Encoder speed is between 38% on
mid-length speech and 56% on long speech faster than an equivalent Conformer.
(The HyperConformer recipe is publicly available in:
https://github.com/speechbrain/speechbrain/tree/develop/recipes/LibriSpeech/ASR/transformer/) | [
-0.3863253295,
-0.1727935225,
0.4317576289,
0.2716401517,
-0.1000377983,
-0.2038519531,
-0.4539583027,
-0.4632718563,
0.1076051295,
0.1075010002,
-0.2846375108,
0.1055940241,
-0.8953213096,
-0.0282708816,
-0.4221589267,
0.6810794473,
0.1200349182,
0.0042835874,
-0.3029216528,
-0.319065243,
-0.1390878409,
-0.8014703989,
-0.6680244803,
-0.4547917247,
0.6041927338,
0.2779610455,
0.5959939361,
0.9790676832,
0.6320213079,
0.4370405972,
-0.3511481583,
-0.2620844543,
-0.4063869417,
0.1726686209,
0.08926972,
-0.0739993602,
-0.4181675017,
-0.2619816363,
0.8828300238,
0.5840596557,
-0.2431589067,
0.3439998329,
0.2200538814,
0.6626775861,
-0.918569088,
0.4108970463,
-0.4760642052,
-0.2353621721,
-0.319750905,
0.1637785435,
-0.1013981104,
-0.2246636897,
0.3609181345,
-0.5139694214,
0.2751520276,
-0.2061147541,
0.5499256253,
0.4301976264,
0.0668712258,
-0.0867323503,
-1.1714115143,
0.7418634295,
-0.4155083895,
1.2367346287,
0.0554064065,
0.6260790825,
0.1282787919,
-0.9147142172,
-0.8568193913,
0.0155821312,
-0.0586230084,
0.2143041939,
-0.6236892939,
0.1712728441,
0.5747341514,
0.3953406513,
-0.6904372573,
-0.2650260329,
-0.3518327773,
-0.2448016852,
0.2236501724,
-0.113959983,
-0.222719714,
0.246438235,
-0.1700329632,
-0.1628559381,
-0.2605729699,
0.2820325196,
0.0265413206,
0.1083493605,
-0.087800689,
0.2001026422,
-0.1511788368,
0.8901114464,
0.4881234169,
-0.2385632545,
0.2575076818,
-0.1445796788,
-0.2318516225,
0.3008956909,
0.6220567822,
0.132398665,
0.2022007257,
-0.1441147923,
-0.2361349761,
0.2629847527,
0.2282465845,
-0.9040551782,
-0.1829376668,
0.3025521338,
-0.2847530246,
0.3592262566,
0.1143555418,
-0.722871244,
-0.2740603685,
-0.5920026302,
0.4159295857,
-0.1604770273,
0.0087341461,
0.1470621228,
-0.4203573763,
0.4758444726,
0.2199053764,
-0.6332137585,
0.6573324203,
0.6435707211,
0.9585473537,
-0.2926109135,
-0.1726274192,
-0.8284366131,
0.3889437318,
0.2016466111,
0.7664934993,
-0.6407359242,
-0.324586004,
-0.4546823502,
-0.1364476234,
-0.2605404556,
-0.8551014662,
0.5881435275,
-0.3657610118,
-0.1291121542,
-0.0684127808,
-0.4231143892,
-0.1314761788,
-0.1430695057,
-0.8378579617,
0.587405622,
-0.1774220318,
-0.5102706552,
-0.0120970095,
-0.5759925246,
-0.4273543954,
0.1582562625,
-0.1204589978,
-0.6330048442,
0.0623362735,
0.1209559068,
0.4251497686,
-0.4041697085,
0.0185408741,
-0.207481727,
-0.5265451074,
0.1540157199,
-0.4808010161,
0.3227061927,
0.0526896156,
-0.499455303,
0.1899106205,
-1.1601624489,
-0.1977247,
-0.1105178818,
-0.6604221463,
-0.1093750075,
-0.1177224368,
0.5642807484,
0.2867434919,
0.0261718798,
-0.9006569982,
-0.4096293747,
-0.3289168775,
0.4874927402,
0.4288684726,
-0.1235996932,
0.4173981249,
-0.3738264441,
0.2456883937,
0.2766027749,
0.2735902667,
0.0043572648,
-0.4961896241,
-1.0110627413,
-0.5358938575,
0.3153245151,
0.5029640794,
-0.1563513428,
0.5364586115,
-0.3783406019,
-0.6631996036,
-0.7249269485,
0.1726341546,
0.7632965446,
0.393458128,
0.3603942692,
-0.3020584285,
-0.7749750018,
-0.7458029389,
-0.0815000385,
0.0000346076,
-0.1755967587,
0.1292095333,
0.1315020621,
-0.288428694,
0.8387625217,
-0.4560643435,
-0.3211043775,
-0.267262131,
-0.1988609582,
0.2697327435,
0.6484719515,
0.2335853577,
-0.9142090082,
-0.4271255434,
0.0421516784,
-0.2417381555,
0.2699564397,
0.101704672,
0.0633673891,
-0.0494287647,
0.5735600591,
-0.67048949,
0.434196651,
0.5600099564,
0.2802607417,
0.3427608311,
-0.0386413373,
-0.2634132504,
-0.7648018003,
0.2905631065,
0.290176779,
-0.2278019935,
-1.0123598576,
-0.2639072537,
0.25859043,
-0.3600590825,
-0.5388258696,
0.3281570375,
-0.5746923685,
0.0185548402,
-0.3492995799,
-0.0284235533,
-0.1519335508,
0.7821906209,
0.1201137453,
0.8224226236,
0.6973792315,
-0.8497444391,
0.4150512218,
0.2413433194,
-0.1156829074,
0.5275879502,
-1.0586144924,
0.3654280603,
-0.4519463181,
0.2532588243,
-0.8535804152,
-0.1762643754,
-0.0474179126,
-0.5346226692,
0.2949936986,
0.0148653714,
-0.0499771312,
-0.5039477944,
-0.2900221348,
0.4227427542,
0.4643138349,
-0.552256465,
0.8685282469,
0.5341542959,
-0.1505932063,
-0.3816505969,
-0.4707775414,
-0.2406162769,
-0.0724662691,
-0.0967967883,
0.2353966832,
-0.330739975,
0.0886425152,
-0.3198485374,
-0.4865317345,
-0.0846983939,
-0.3518027961,
0.5082677603,
-0.0179355387,
-0.3242680132,
-0.0545478538,
-0.238279283,
-0.2297118753,
-0.0509904325,
-0.46446383,
0.4081692994,
-0.0652995706,
-0.0820271224,
-0.7774453163,
0.4730381072,
1.1108465195,
-0.6390538812,
0.3608382642,
0.6256869435,
-0.7458336949,
0.3031259179,
-0.7345814109,
0.0507415645,
-0.4714339674,
0.3963404298,
-0.5689535141,
-0.7652091384,
0.3398557007,
0.1394949406,
0.0777974203,
0.1315814704,
0.6960803866,
0.1496922821,
0.9877874851,
0.5972984433,
-0.2774915695,
0.5650577545,
-0.1242793649,
0.1330890656,
-1.1312893629,
-0.1703286767,
-0.5303956866,
-0.2487159222,
-0.4925513864,
-0.3684624135,
0.6114512086,
-0.3413469195,
-0.3020479679,
0.5206304789,
-0.3888939023,
0.478066057,
0.8518883586,
0.1978337169,
0.1907807887,
-0.2548548579,
0.1669047624,
0.2024978548,
-0.6550278068,
-0.1982071251,
0.8724253774,
0.2993336618,
0.9169915318,
0.1465879977,
0.4896945059,
-0.1848725528,
-0.076867722,
-1.152721405,
0.409368664,
-0.20141536,
-0.3020368516,
-0.3567512929,
-0.2170570642,
-0.8561400175,
0.1786051542,
-0.2731576562,
-0.5893808603,
0.7095372677,
0.5297126174,
-0.8377658129,
0.0714331418,
-0.5855411291,
0.6045991182,
0.1851413995,
-0.1606214792,
-0.0948801041,
-0.7306715846,
-0.0174825471,
-0.3307221234,
-0.0260645989,
0.2491284311,
0.1487599611,
0.9959415197,
0.0292640962,
0.5395300388,
-0.2862705886,
0.2752149701,
0.0373786576,
-0.2864165902,
0.2145049721,
-0.1243992448,
-0.0403907523,
0.1494602114,
-0.2414849401,
-0.0414588712,
-0.7282259464,
0.6252898574,
-0.8433704972,
-0.5510492921,
-0.3449595273,
-0.8289294839,
-0.4135685265,
0.2327525616,
0.1310535669,
0.8492739797,
-0.1036921963,
0.3262163401,
0.8590202928,
0.1929143667,
0.3532085419,
0.401178062,
0.3634350896,
-0.7092558742,
0.9886230826,
0.2286103666,
0.2569791675,
0.5258863568,
0.2886284888,
-0.1897556484,
-0.3934823573,
-0.1547914296,
0.3494446874,
-0.366651237,
-0.344260931,
-1.0008372068,
-0.4867644906,
-0.5630244613,
0.0710302219,
-0.4713765085,
-0.3745409846,
0.061751999,
0.1400787532,
0.2177256346,
0.520933032,
-0.1731826514,
0.7939192057,
-0.6728482246,
0.6274145246,
0.7419956326,
0.4396919012,
0.0825800076,
-0.5387814641,
-0.4445308745,
-0.213369146,
-0.3808019757,
-0.5208855271,
0.1330075562,
0.5335488915,
0.5966789126,
0.6830250025,
-0.1587028503,
0.9784618616,
-0.900618732,
0.1133009717,
0.2353636026,
-1.0811347961,
0.3432105482,
0.1686054319,
0.717089057,
0.3284416795,
0.605766058,
-0.6687363386,
-0.5076202154,
-0.3171269894,
-0.643784821,
0.6472455263,
0.1634594053,
-0.1533244252,
0.2903051674,
0.3368768692,
-0.2192780524,
0.0568926781,
-0.250652492,
-0.3111216128,
-0.2298832834,
-0.3386985958,
-0.4312404692,
-0.1942605823,
-0.0645219758,
-0.5939055681,
0.5791428685,
0.0091578597,
0.5296673179,
0.4139674306,
-0.2526730895,
-0.2797860205,
0.2643308938,
0.591642797,
0.4717286527,
-0.3250746131,
0.3202969134,
0.2003218532,
-0.7841833234,
0.1744462103,
0.5943967104,
0.1174667701,
0.1167595312,
0.1339121312,
0.9975067973,
0.3307004571,
-0.5543417335,
0.5443809032,
-0.2765220404,
-0.1503941268,
-0.2540727258,
-0.0191112813,
0.2081700563,
0.4034388065,
0.2001085728,
0.2367255837,
0.5875447989,
-0.2001118362,
0.4423716068,
0.2596760094,
-0.707736671,
-0.340949893,
0.8592224121,
0.2179738581,
-0.291141808,
0.3513230979,
0.1333194673,
-0.5655625463,
0.2823812366,
0.7448837757,
0.8795241117,
-0.7906801701,
-0.498010993,
0.3532845378,
0.081599161,
0.011693594,
0.0938403904,
-0.3830502629,
-0.6275252104,
-0.2730060816,
-0.6834338903,
-0.7931646109,
0.2233336717,
-0.8536317945,
0.2125325948,
-0.5710591078,
-0.2096034586,
0.7111853957,
-0.4690612257,
-0.482537806,
0.123462759,
0.5863206983,
0.7868047357,
-0.4037210345,
0.8090110421,
0.8857033849,
0.0809262469,
-0.3782174587,
0.1790285856,
0.1809503883,
-0.5133543015,
0.3804027736,
0.5130946636,
-0.6251644492,
0.1729427874,
-0.0895955265,
-1.014529705,
0.8377329707,
0.3714337647,
-1.0627090931,
-0.0638176277,
-0.0139687359,
0.2495160401,
-0.0371346809,
0.1762546152,
0.8687871695,
0.326019913,
0.1558914483,
-1.1774076223,
-0.0670302436,
-0.2575068176,
0.3013500869,
0.1624067426,
-0.6250188947,
0.5555797815,
-0.2276842594,
-0.2662038803,
-0.1987443268,
0.9825455546,
0.2611357272,
0.1234370098,
0.823354423,
0.39444682,
0.5518628955,
0.0557734631,
0.6296595931,
-0.4804171622,
0.2191381007,
0.945905447,
-0.3648017645,
0.9372276068,
0.3427362442,
-0.0882792622,
0.3211124241,
-0.0522837006,
0.2272769064,
0.4037269652,
0.1932855248,
-0.4422137737,
-0.1882586628,
0.0458118767,
-0.0903689563,
0.7690474391,
0.185572356,
0.0921557397,
-0.0913048014,
0.3813058436,
0.0202651564,
-0.0318753943,
-0.5364156961,
0.938038528,
-0.0446520001,
-0.3116153777,
0.6829117537,
-0.2175454646,
0.8259668946,
-0.7051081657,
-0.0835637599,
0.0886597261,
0.7633382678,
-0.0971981734,
-0.5359915495,
0.4003020227,
0.0641107559,
-0.4904932082,
0.0361123234,
0.6388456225,
-0.5851120949,
-0.4726086259,
0.263440758,
0.400541842,
0.0069933087,
-0.453268379,
-0.4954336286,
0.2540851831,
-0.4354989827,
-0.1452140361,
0.062249653,
0.1334354579,
0.1011865884,
0.5514238477,
0.6391311288,
0.0429864228,
0.1863086224,
0.2362303734,
0.9817939997,
-0.6301025748,
-0.5521777272,
-0.7267395854,
0.1193301305,
0.0188715663,
-0.0351498537,
0.5526461601,
0.8590344191,
0.8611662388,
-0.1751002669,
0.6876795888,
0.1952894479,
0.7504127622,
-0.0677210689,
0.7034050226,
-0.1680106819,
-0.5116168261,
-0.2263828665,
-0.7235853076,
-0.5821571946,
0.6098925471,
0.0285376608,
-0.0713006929,
0.5223114491,
0.886453867,
-0.3985539377,
-0.008211527,
0.5228738189,
0.1913106292,
0.2285742164,
0.6939067245,
0.4964418411,
-0.4221025109,
0.7155865431,
-0.3591240942,
-0.5898560286,
0.0995390564,
-0.2918516695,
-0.7162848115,
-0.6943498254,
-0.3422826529,
-0.0830882043,
0.2980329096,
1.152566433,
1.0168946981,
-1.1041170359,
-0.6988196969,
0.2429933399,
-0.2700224519,
-0.5763247013,
-0.1925573498,
0.1252809167,
-0.1718167514,
-0.9634771943,
0.2482312024,
0.4181106389,
0.0186496172,
-0.0727847368,
-0.0545536429,
-0.0658426136,
0.2366765738,
0.8241835237,
0.3847509325,
-0.3995634317,
-0.1394272149,
-0.0567443706,
0.0866691098,
0.2693754733,
0.9442168474,
-0.818685174,
0.4254546762,
0.265732497,
0.7950252891,
0.5660111308,
-0.0053128866,
0.5359383225,
-0.4319597483,
0.0898382664,
0.0991609469,
0.4494967163,
0.2982529998,
-0.3778294325,
-0.0445360057,
0.3267145157,
-0.6761201024,
-0.5916268229,
0.186799407,
-1.3263084888,
0.3834873736,
1.0926805735,
-0.0098441672,
-0.5194069743,
-0.1436529309,
-0.2804274559,
0.5258058906,
-0.5514979362,
0.2723579407,
0.3339262307,
-0.4297901392,
-0.3013504148,
-0.3969299495,
0.4465646446,
-0.0699023232,
-0.5615298152,
0.3620201647,
0.2980632782,
0.371295929,
0.4686720669,
0.488929987,
-0.2013290077,
0.6340720057,
-0.2292114943,
0.4192406833,
0.021735644,
-0.5736904144,
-0.7809647918,
0.1028791219,
-0.0969165936,
-0.5243536234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18513v1 | SlimFit: Memory-Efficient Fine-Tuning of Transformer-based Models Using Training Dynamics | 2023-05-29T17:50:52 | 2023-05-29T17:50:52 | Arash Ardakani, Altan Haan, Shangyin Tan, Doru Thom Popovici, Alvin Cheung, Costin Iancu, Koushik Sen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based models, such as BERT and ViT, have achieved
state-of-the-art results across different natural language processing (NLP) and
computer vision (CV) tasks. However, these models are extremely memory
intensive during their fine-tuning process, making them difficult to deploy on
GPUs with limited memory resources. To address this issue, we introduce a new
tool called SlimFit that reduces the memory requirements of these models by
dynamically analyzing their training dynamics and freezing less-contributory
layers during fine-tuning. The layers to freeze are chosen using a runtime
inter-layer scheduling algorithm. SlimFit adopts quantization and pruning for
particular layers to balance the load of dynamic activations and to minimize
the memory footprint of static activations, where static activations refer to
those that cannot be discarded regardless of freezing. This allows SlimFit to
freeze up to 95% of layers and reduce the overall on-device GPU memory usage of
transformer-based models such as ViT and BERT by an average of 2.2x, across
different NLP and CV benchmarks/datasets such as GLUE, SQuAD 2.0, CIFAR-10,
CIFAR-100 and ImageNet with an average degradation of 0.2% in accuracy. For
such NLP and CV tasks, SlimFit can reduce up to 3.1x the total on-device memory
usage with an accuracy degradation of only up to 0.4%. As a result, while
fine-tuning of ViT on ImageNet and BERT on SQuAD 2.0 with a batch size of 128
requires 3 and 2 32GB GPUs respectively, SlimFit enables their fine-tuning on a
single 32GB GPU without any significant accuracy degradation. | [
-0.7170394063,
-0.8209939003,
0.2193764448,
-0.0413212702,
-0.228342995,
0.1661916375,
-0.3901751935,
-0.1183765978,
0.0803577229,
0.3273452222,
-0.9211560488,
0.1272060126,
-0.2508752942,
-0.4775307477,
-0.1983017623,
1.1584912539,
-0.0555831566,
-0.2174649537,
-0.3355452716,
-0.1851528138,
-0.6151998043,
-0.0169848632,
-0.6526553631,
-0.4079120457,
0.1813521385,
0.3972842097,
1.0513557196,
0.716558814,
0.7136818767,
0.323310107,
-0.2750732899,
0.1375416517,
-0.7910161018,
0.1909807175,
-0.0903984681,
-0.330935806,
-0.364759475,
-0.0708497465,
0.3669132292,
0.1104201674,
-0.3931306303,
0.5561499596,
-0.0244654305,
0.6158385277,
-0.860141933,
0.1792543381,
-0.7436572313,
0.0933918133,
-0.0135517577,
-0.0541640483,
-0.1536142081,
-0.021575151,
0.1681275666,
-0.6712428331,
0.5864794254,
-0.2003657818,
1.1611833572,
1.0043983459,
0.1163399071,
0.3371478915,
-0.8313302994,
0.8312081695,
-0.7194500566,
0.5693694949,
0.1252700239,
0.2656628191,
0.2091547251,
-0.7480813265,
-0.3652201891,
0.0812937915,
-0.0739861578,
0.3973288238,
-0.1646301001,
0.0235303044,
0.6277971864,
0.3442035019,
-0.6442677379,
0.0777494237,
-0.5054350495,
-0.2074935734,
0.3465772271,
0.3055050969,
0.1900052875,
0.1312381923,
-0.2052739859,
-0.1433018595,
-0.286116749,
-0.1748429388,
0.1723879278,
0.2147915363,
-0.190295592,
0.2746540606,
-0.0226164591,
0.4238921106,
0.2757875621,
-0.3069319427,
0.2308271974,
0.1608846933,
-0.6494522095,
-0.1036143899,
0.6229628325,
0.304023236,
0.2557338774,
-0.1675933748,
-0.3765106499,
0.0645816773,
0.5795602202,
-1.34961164,
-0.9545564055,
0.1515694857,
-0.3411651552,
-0.0921297818,
-0.3349079192,
-0.7903146148,
-0.2036429644,
-0.1312095374,
0.4652340114,
-0.8372427225,
-0.0723880902,
0.0604093969,
-0.1952761114,
0.3394853175,
0.457683742,
-1.0176438093,
0.4931027889,
0.5455073714,
0.8824816942,
-0.3147644401,
0.0019206845,
-0.5249096751,
0.1726750731,
0.1326580197,
0.5905359983,
-0.4003406763,
-0.1882410049,
-0.2867037356,
-0.1036821082,
-0.4015192688,
-0.7456995845,
0.5247575641,
-0.2625725269,
0.004522094,
0.0223426372,
-0.5193013549,
-0.0872879997,
0.2648251057,
-0.7739323378,
1.0932010412,
-0.0526789986,
-0.7746909261,
0.2584910095,
-0.5261359811,
-0.3345457911,
0.2271684706,
0.2651029825,
-0.8544120193,
0.4206993878,
0.4033461809,
0.7521835566,
-0.3001796007,
0.0798962712,
-0.0686043575,
-0.5036568642,
-0.207538411,
-0.3062615693,
0.3878890276,
0.4095345736,
-0.242450133,
0.0203857478,
-0.6054867506,
0.2098699212,
0.3846128881,
-0.082394138,
-0.2162924558,
0.0446854793,
0.1715298295,
0.0386822671,
0.2266858071,
-0.4864095151,
0.3038364947,
-0.2392596006,
0.6780629754,
0.5681157708,
-0.304063648,
0.2420348674,
-0.1127578467,
0.5806629658,
-0.0556259453,
0.4339060485,
-0.5002486706,
-0.595927,
-0.9426680803,
-0.5111888051,
0.2327831835,
0.7712470889,
-0.6893909574,
0.171076715,
-0.326417774,
-0.4785820246,
-0.3277328908,
0.1875050664,
0.2116024792,
0.3712065816,
0.5787119269,
-0.263723284,
-0.100587301,
-1.1030108929,
-0.0194130577,
-0.0914405212,
-0.1023858562,
0.2700043321,
0.5512741804,
0.0069080521,
0.8601613045,
-0.8587608933,
-0.3970601857,
-0.0957264677,
-0.1206005812,
0.1802184433,
0.6139736176,
0.7987561226,
-0.7382309437,
-0.4112844169,
-0.045872163,
-0.1075648442,
0.1256688982,
-0.3607873619,
0.2401254177,
-0.2607858777,
0.3723056018,
-0.980121851,
0.4354531765,
0.6163467765,
-0.1892656833,
0.514295876,
-0.3134256303,
-0.2132913023,
-0.7601785064,
0.1946212798,
0.1023148745,
-0.4888990223,
-0.5833183527,
0.1925199032,
0.2600924671,
-0.2151561528,
-0.4054543078,
0.3943333328,
-0.1761673838,
0.4931229949,
-0.0512062944,
-0.3023894727,
-0.0077335229,
0.6654419899,
-0.1801267564,
0.9547885656,
0.4674102664,
-0.3790440261,
0.2468912303,
0.2739697993,
-0.2123065442,
0.4067441821,
-0.515558362,
0.0441455506,
-0.0956769809,
-0.0674637854,
-0.6414364576,
-0.105003655,
0.0280699395,
0.0005614076,
0.6338425279,
-0.2744955719,
-0.6819631457,
-0.413629353,
-0.284463495,
0.3897453249,
0.8818773031,
-0.5274703503,
0.8487622142,
0.4771083593,
0.2166779339,
-0.324249655,
-0.6651661992,
-0.2265791148,
-0.37050578,
-0.5060297847,
0.4217359722,
-0.3582325876,
0.0901673213,
0.0232060775,
-0.5073206425,
-0.4065868556,
0.1768790036,
0.3142890036,
0.3485270441,
-0.2775893509,
-0.1917164028,
0.1020096689,
-0.1117369384,
-0.1650497764,
-0.2873925865,
0.5622267723,
-0.3493493497,
-0.072914131,
-0.5064013004,
-0.1116175875,
0.6642713547,
-0.390517205,
0.9088359475,
1.1825618744,
-0.3467968106,
-0.5275483131,
-0.789357245,
-0.2904260159,
-0.6081814766,
0.3232119381,
-0.3342799842,
-0.8261850476,
0.8119833469,
-0.2851940095,
0.2279490978,
0.5469551682,
0.7360892296,
-0.1033138335,
0.8445415497,
0.714879632,
-0.0968632326,
0.7086295485,
-0.6424015164,
0.2615397573,
-0.6901082397,
-0.2730373442,
-0.1816105992,
-0.6893503666,
-0.439740926,
-0.5439094305,
0.3647817075,
-0.0597832538,
-0.3487002254,
0.4566191435,
-0.8607697487,
0.7709887028,
0.2141562104,
0.1316444725,
-0.2491585612,
-0.1194511279,
-0.2377145588,
-0.0937151983,
-0.942850709,
0.0766621754,
0.5103856325,
0.3916441798,
0.9180290103,
-0.2655968368,
0.3571670055,
-0.0522026382,
0.1055807695,
-0.8539603353,
0.597887814,
-0.434330821,
-0.589269042,
-0.1227959245,
-0.5079584718,
-0.4501774907,
0.1118985489,
-0.1026488543,
-0.9823989272,
0.0352178887,
0.5055137873,
-0.6337959766,
0.8732404709,
-0.8603889942,
0.9027653933,
-0.001362925,
-0.5429115295,
-0.34233284,
-0.466440469,
0.4710846245,
-0.2533742189,
-0.4266833365,
-0.4187089503,
0.1029993668,
0.7068400979,
-0.5880091786,
0.6048329473,
-0.1598916054,
0.0892884806,
0.3015508354,
0.2331944704,
0.5752333403,
0.0639031902,
-0.0733306259,
0.2740591764,
0.2236810327,
-0.2510943711,
-0.5475741029,
0.8024325371,
-0.7298290133,
-0.3739321232,
-0.1108013019,
-1.0540188551,
-0.2803596854,
0.0815483108,
0.1012051851,
0.2099432498,
-0.1104081422,
0.2486241162,
1.0956968069,
-0.4331644177,
0.4286295474,
0.2462443858,
0.1638616323,
-0.147372067,
1.027430892,
0.0543009788,
0.2169191688,
0.3509433568,
0.1547208577,
0.2728112638,
-0.6541247964,
-0.3115440905,
0.1822939217,
-0.2723705471,
-0.6975564361,
-0.5536143184,
-0.485075146,
0.0511905923,
-0.1619650722,
-1.0030725002,
-0.684686482,
-0.2963596582,
0.2171559185,
0.6795102954,
0.1724685431,
0.1071024388,
0.874279201,
-0.6062731147,
0.5246880651,
0.1781092733,
0.6600666642,
-0.2565968633,
-0.5303276777,
-0.5905958414,
-0.1809925586,
-0.5771859288,
-0.4508227408,
0.5775422454,
0.5572804809,
0.3374597132,
0.5218074918,
-0.1702273339,
1.2817655802,
-0.7237795591,
0.7262733579,
0.2147636712,
-0.9306202531,
0.5917046666,
-0.3067638576,
0.6745785475,
0.5918053389,
0.0166197959,
0.0935904384,
-0.4563376009,
-0.7866048217,
-0.9158079028,
0.8384122252,
0.3277483881,
0.1945152581,
0.5295718312,
0.6246938109,
-0.0524981879,
0.0381367579,
0.0224741194,
-0.3488358259,
-0.3360264897,
-0.0603620745,
0.1659193337,
-0.0634778216,
0.0387421213,
-0.6342356205,
0.7062883973,
-0.3290740848,
0.3661100566,
-0.1777150929,
0.0389086753,
-0.1713325828,
-0.1820866913,
0.3531548381,
0.4839654863,
-0.5304742455,
-0.0942033827,
0.5584759116,
-1.0272886753,
-0.2813362479,
0.1451011896,
-0.4200208783,
-0.042031575,
-0.1040390283,
1.0958865881,
0.2157435268,
-0.8110280037,
0.2367384583,
-0.2514891326,
-0.1231971905,
-0.0877894536,
0.4895330966,
-0.0897512734,
0.2857357562,
-0.0809258968,
0.6135407686,
-0.0960733518,
-0.1673201174,
0.3843780458,
0.7750754952,
-0.3477188349,
-0.4579793811,
1.0992959738,
-0.0958741158,
0.0605915599,
1.0861349106,
0.0243074484,
-0.4699609876,
0.4985259473,
0.4328242242,
1.0306288004,
-0.4524512887,
0.1914813519,
0.4768106341,
0.4765759408,
-0.2647399604,
0.1858671904,
-0.0448400974,
-0.7804196477,
-0.5877289772,
-0.9020312428,
-0.253063798,
0.2933186293,
-0.6977338195,
0.395233959,
-0.7601074576,
-0.4059624374,
0.0812550113,
0.1251473129,
-1.2216045856,
0.2408895493,
0.5042912364,
1.1258028746,
-0.7330298424,
1.2261506319,
0.5631484985,
0.1138100699,
-0.863502264,
-0.0884221494,
0.0457675233,
-0.6678189635,
0.2295803577,
0.096056737,
0.0033829543,
0.0193542689,
-0.4532666802,
-0.7706450224,
1.0898513794,
0.9926291704,
-0.5786833763,
-0.0860948488,
-0.0858823508,
0.4487041831,
0.0186956748,
0.5024576783,
0.7345866561,
0.5727724433,
0.31583184,
-1.2160856724,
-0.0655901283,
-0.2998491824,
-0.1346734315,
0.4492475986,
-1.0174291134,
0.8759862781,
-0.4158729613,
-0.2160282433,
0.0474508703,
0.612308979,
-0.1063207686,
-0.0135915894,
0.6112715006,
0.851328969,
0.7462155819,
-0.3243428171,
0.8560284376,
-0.5471965075,
0.6635971069,
0.8326397538,
-0.0879466012,
0.6068627834,
0.4426046312,
0.090899691,
0.2309385389,
0.3548771143,
-0.5923080444,
0.6191638112,
0.0033734853,
0.1714255214,
-0.525143683,
-0.0174693372,
0.013405934,
0.3751917183,
0.4786774516,
-0.025753621,
-0.2285473943,
0.1056046858,
0.1200624183,
-0.5622756481,
-0.4247674346,
0.5854958296,
0.0395460688,
-0.2772778273,
0.6259030104,
0.0289042797,
0.5591336489,
-0.8426674604,
0.2290890068,
-0.0923760906,
0.6038030386,
-0.2868107855,
-0.5875616074,
0.3562779427,
-0.1052614003,
-0.0902264714,
-0.5009740591,
0.7882728577,
-0.1745938063,
-0.5498794913,
-0.0554029681,
0.5224914551,
-0.0194991231,
-0.0275841858,
-1.0390181541,
0.2707047164,
0.0172980763,
-0.7305185795,
0.3531811237,
0.2587109506,
0.1970745474,
1.0137722492,
0.5949342847,
0.1558423638,
0.2012323588,
-0.1761559397,
1.23485744,
-0.3424598277,
-0.5111769438,
-0.8124541044,
0.5159362555,
0.0584933311,
-0.2340917289,
0.6312813163,
0.9194359183,
0.6063605547,
-0.1114774793,
0.4132056236,
-0.2191881686,
-0.1148988008,
-0.4540187716,
0.8202419281,
-0.6276922226,
0.246744737,
-0.1686817557,
-1.0151027441,
-0.3656278253,
0.6808086038,
-0.0904766694,
-0.135737583,
0.5278883576,
0.6450788379,
-0.7602410913,
0.1881425232,
0.4207338095,
0.3817159534,
0.3084073961,
0.4523516297,
0.4115105867,
-0.4612904191,
0.415758729,
-0.5306822658,
-0.0015895242,
0.1426812857,
-0.6887614131,
-0.9988749027,
-0.4865918756,
-0.7538361549,
-0.1534153521,
-0.0894787908,
0.6669613719,
1.0499994755,
-0.861241281,
0.0261320658,
0.2703378797,
-0.2441897541,
-0.4902477562,
-0.2225373685,
0.4995260537,
-0.354801625,
-0.6257112622,
0.3144450784,
0.3137725592,
-0.2501739562,
-0.3423483074,
0.0687023327,
0.3024181724,
0.2928988039,
0.4945544302,
0.1965887845,
-0.3577860892,
-0.3110269606,
-0.1184290722,
0.4348647594,
0.2901861072,
1.0609960556,
-1.2963974476,
0.2791524529,
0.4465048909,
0.497059226,
0.9440513253,
-0.14745453,
0.2612243593,
-0.7869943976,
0.4248776734,
0.3417243659,
0.3341912925,
0.1340928823,
-0.2871913314,
0.3984697163,
0.1065752506,
-0.6373767257,
-0.8850237727,
0.0074593676,
-1.27402246,
-0.228681162,
0.7325449586,
-0.0314611569,
-0.2084583789,
0.2976163924,
0.0491887219,
0.0930522904,
-0.3525809646,
0.7075074315,
0.1941242218,
-0.1777847707,
-0.4495179355,
-1.1400556564,
0.7071347833,
0.2864348292,
-0.5152966976,
0.1364742368,
0.2156423032,
0.3704886436,
0.1989929378,
-0.0007056312,
0.3009508848,
-0.0373497754,
-0.1770678908,
-0.1593354493,
-0.2098938525,
-0.3360269666,
-0.0086918948,
0.2813108265,
-0.6964905858,
-0.047942277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18278v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18278v1 | Mathematical Structure of Syntactic Merge | 2023-05-29T17:50:32 | 2023-05-29T17:50:32 | Matilde Marcolli, Noam Chomsky, Robert Berwick | cs.CL | cs.CL, math.QA, math.RA, 68Q70, 16T05 | The syntactic Merge operation of the Minimalist Program in linguistics can be
described mathematically in terms of Hopf algebras, with a formalism similar to
the one arising in the physics of renormalization. This mathematical
formulation of Merge has good descriptive power, as phenomena empirically
observed in linguistics can be justified from simple mathematical arguments. It
also provides a possible mathematical model for externalization and for the
role of syntactic parameters. | [
-0.4840511382,
-0.9302690625,
0.5684344769,
0.1987624615,
0.0568478443,
0.1212588996,
-0.2384871989,
-0.4078711569,
0.5828694701,
0.3456547856,
-0.5545657873,
-0.0151444385,
-0.6466526389,
0.0577403083,
-0.6356200576,
1.0166493654,
-0.1649436802,
-0.013338157,
-0.0932048112,
-0.093318142,
-0.1241778731,
-0.4138459861,
-0.5836543441,
-0.3425803185,
0.3828219175,
0.1143186018,
1.2990026474,
0.5564689636,
1.035077095,
0.5170140266,
-0.1886003017,
-0.3418237269,
-0.2417781204,
0.1605405062,
0.1951081157,
-0.7971445322,
-0.0292710289,
-0.0932170749,
1.2153896093,
1.5779929161,
-0.4145511687,
-0.0707570463,
-0.0311318152,
0.8117248416,
-0.1550999135,
0.1515104622,
-0.0239901543,
0.1423767507,
-0.1168955788,
-0.1890000254,
0.0056322571,
-0.9187993407,
0.0703660175,
-0.2812244594,
-0.0545819774,
-0.2871846855,
0.779373765,
0.0902772844,
-0.3750418723,
-0.0497207046,
-1.1448800564,
0.6885918379,
-0.5454582572,
0.673566401,
0.0535011962,
0.5380806923,
-0.3824698925,
-0.4699826837,
-0.5022920966,
0.1239272729,
-0.4857514799,
-0.0535302795,
-0.3386135995,
0.4262696505,
0.4521666467,
0.683180809,
-0.7380678058,
-0.276735872,
-0.7892038822,
-0.1250495762,
0.507979393,
0.2526260018,
0.6601190567,
0.0187746994,
-0.3636333346,
0.1908586025,
-0.4266989529,
-0.0253489763,
0.6361005902,
0.3990790844,
-0.3385342956,
0.6104429364,
-0.1776799113,
0.8266381025,
-0.146928966,
-0.2678723633,
0.0509824082,
-0.724250257,
-0.4994855523,
-0.2086410075,
0.8881604671,
-0.0361495912,
0.0305491276,
-0.3103326559,
-0.1106264964,
0.085949637,
-0.0001961637,
-0.59072119,
-0.2378103733,
-0.1085204706,
-0.5041413903,
-0.629104197,
-0.0693854019,
-0.410888195,
0.1881118268,
-0.3862805963,
0.1049600914,
-0.6243357062,
-0.330619514,
-0.1544106305,
-0.1577041149,
0.1636499614,
0.0351121835,
-0.9838179946,
0.9403149486,
0.7256430984,
0.7477936745,
0.1005387232,
-0.4639058709,
-0.2322112918,
-0.0840220824,
-0.392575562,
0.6730041504,
-0.6249433756,
-0.4462847114,
-0.007759992,
-0.313616395,
-0.0765455142,
-0.2865665853,
0.2746559978,
-0.731377244,
0.5465216637,
0.0036128613,
-0.535349369,
-0.5299733877,
0.0967042297,
-0.8204994798,
0.921679616,
0.4369747341,
-0.4648524821,
0.4844096303,
-0.7270851731,
-0.3728510439,
0.3352312446,
-0.095412761,
0.0310953278,
0.4523864388,
-0.4956539571,
-0.3510808349,
-0.3244421184,
0.1642054766,
-0.0840515494,
-0.0395001285,
0.3708307743,
-0.0406145118,
1.1083828211,
0.3697449863,
0.2435317934,
0.3466930091,
-0.591021657,
0.1727139205,
-0.0764647275,
-0.211278066,
-0.6250635386,
-0.347201705,
-0.0633643568,
0.0974698067,
0.2403541356,
-0.0888493434,
0.6838372946,
-0.876685679,
0.0046754307,
0.273235023,
0.2323220372,
1.0988178253,
-0.1685436815,
0.806968689,
-0.1869401485,
0.04183276,
0.0155521724,
-0.4872204661,
-0.5687921643,
-0.2804987133,
0.594326973,
0.3154283762,
-0.4491779208,
0.336115092,
-0.177896902,
-0.1442520916,
-0.2462010682,
0.2898315787,
0.3187987506,
0.2405087948,
-0.1534190029,
0.0323972851,
-0.888738513,
-1.1389160156,
-0.3104861379,
-0.4178587198,
0.1808045059,
-0.1230182275,
0.2985889912,
-0.0389102921,
0.9282591939,
-0.3500078022,
-0.1910331696,
-0.3144961894,
0.2870616615,
0.6301096082,
0.3661440611,
0.3611420691,
-0.6876012087,
-0.5053340197,
0.0277125929,
-0.7682985067,
0.0429373756,
0.0181347076,
-0.2198889554,
-0.1428382099,
0.5947210193,
-0.7348474264,
0.3063770533,
0.2385649383,
-0.2498372495,
0.2257491499,
0.0067489697,
0.1590076536,
-1.0908180475,
-0.0699530765,
-0.3376066983,
-0.2741847932,
-0.8465878367,
0.6770302653,
-0.4411390722,
-0.4118189216,
-0.4755293429,
0.2917491496,
-0.6689400077,
-0.1096513495,
-0.1621723026,
0.1937073618,
-0.5688992143,
0.1197507754,
-0.1848366261,
0.3931190968,
0.8587788343,
-0.6528050303,
0.5214724541,
0.2363571674,
0.2425611913,
0.2377535403,
-0.3275451362,
-0.5094996095,
-0.236114502,
0.1674189717,
-1.0534342527,
-0.3988390565,
0.0704303384,
-0.4706849158,
0.2606338263,
-0.3659398556,
-0.6084107161,
-0.274906069,
-0.3273125589,
0.9205973148,
0.6429497004,
-0.138203159,
0.6893880367,
0.2436048388,
-0.1253531724,
-0.370051682,
-0.5535364747,
-0.2302861512,
-0.2769382,
-0.9380497932,
0.1200571805,
0.1060417295,
-0.5806537867,
0.4414145052,
0.1977474093,
-0.0286013149,
-0.2271857411,
0.2103867829,
0.6533361077,
-0.4944523871,
-0.0647102296,
0.0547653995,
-0.129998669,
0.1380192786,
-0.2408077866,
0.5605481863,
-0.1313862205,
-0.1389736086,
-0.2608135045,
0.461125344,
0.5865994692,
0.2235312909,
0.7957707644,
0.287432313,
-0.6312609911,
-0.0612377226,
-0.1944744289,
-0.2396506518,
-0.4154561758,
-0.2956038415,
-0.4216957092,
-0.8072937727,
0.7707513571,
-0.1186369658,
-0.126249209,
0.7079246044,
0.6994220018,
-0.0424324535,
0.6432181597,
0.9579358697,
0.2235366255,
0.5445637703,
-0.3275219202,
0.3916676939,
-0.6037173867,
-0.342952013,
-0.4287674427,
-0.5683513284,
-0.6709549427,
-0.2376105785,
0.2594896853,
0.5486208797,
0.0416765325,
0.665266335,
-0.2216330916,
0.7847731709,
0.2834108174,
-0.8092212081,
0.2373445332,
0.2165700942,
-0.343310535,
-0.3870052397,
-0.685654223,
-0.1745484471,
0.6717012525,
0.2941742241,
1.1012430191,
0.4587985575,
1.3667633533,
0.0435048118,
-0.0362160653,
-1.1434648037,
0.6144627333,
0.1479949355,
-0.3505495787,
-0.2321550548,
-0.4175598323,
-0.8741630912,
0.1814607531,
-0.3460635841,
-1.0711280107,
0.4578807354,
-0.0998812765,
-0.3262397349,
0.0037972701,
-0.7156628966,
0.8322324753,
0.1139592752,
0.0098397406,
-0.3931320012,
-0.5992339253,
0.8842716813,
0.0517682768,
0.3076835871,
0.2350281924,
-0.0357431062,
0.9205431342,
-0.7156849504,
0.5014195442,
0.1941867322,
-0.1223917753,
0.3856593668,
0.8139749765,
0.2981225252,
-0.2004478276,
0.4208672047,
0.1698210239,
0.4375318289,
0.0435918681,
-0.9254798889,
0.810348928,
-0.5739797354,
-0.2395294309,
-0.5490709543,
-0.6442328691,
-0.2264789641,
0.5487313271,
0.3605404198,
0.4911295772,
-0.2578508556,
-0.0763024613,
0.2459895462,
0.1350167096,
0.5009650588,
0.445315212,
-0.9729070067,
-0.2630182803,
0.7980044484,
0.0026292307,
0.1491992772,
0.5699262023,
0.2291046828,
-0.4216956794,
-0.1632022262,
0.0889912024,
0.5273923874,
-0.8862027526,
-0.2092907131,
-0.461761713,
-0.5938822627,
-0.2363051623,
-0.3789626956,
-0.3136472106,
-0.9767174125,
0.2120835781,
0.1791963577,
0.1506928205,
0.817076385,
-0.356431067,
0.7137123942,
-0.9753486514,
0.3676890135,
-0.1996691823,
0.4654333293,
-0.32194224,
-0.3995400965,
-0.4062386751,
-0.2323893756,
-0.1277401447,
-0.930991888,
0.2327104658,
0.17025204,
0.4989550114,
0.4915859699,
-0.3848005831,
0.8093422651,
-0.4265993834,
0.560918808,
0.794570148,
-0.9896159768,
0.4706224203,
-0.4390493929,
0.2877095044,
0.4028132558,
0.5509706736,
-0.5136526227,
-0.7152582407,
-1.1117696762,
-0.6338528395,
0.6749327779,
0.4219571352,
-0.1777023226,
-0.0142783048,
0.0927216485,
-0.0626980215,
0.1967199296,
-0.4721152782,
-0.4520233274,
0.4451321959,
-0.218752265,
0.3113296926,
-0.2245733291,
-0.7753275037,
-0.0767909735,
0.2364532351,
0.3219984472,
0.3808363676,
-0.4045574367,
-0.0076515642,
-0.4924305081,
0.3649294674,
0.6548677683,
0.6913215518,
-0.0347668789,
0.2510654926,
-0.2041693926,
-0.1924107671,
0.0739854127,
-0.155796513,
-0.0519401282,
0.1015067995,
0.7999555469,
0.3945292532,
0.293427825,
-0.3467563689,
0.2392647862,
0.0932781845,
-0.2639417946,
-0.1445634216,
-0.0462685302,
-0.130636543,
0.3143247664,
0.1703126878,
0.4264045358,
0.6892493963,
-0.9272736311,
0.4041796327,
0.738057375,
0.0754874423,
-0.6578941345,
0.4945284724,
-0.1219036505,
-0.341602236,
0.4549892843,
0.0049387845,
-0.6893296242,
0.3774413764,
0.8217827082,
1.0691472292,
-0.0928107947,
0.101253733,
0.5341143012,
0.3246603608,
0.0475123934,
0.2887259424,
-0.1219810545,
-0.5550118089,
-0.6120483279,
-0.871086061,
-0.246994257,
-0.29156515,
-0.5911563039,
0.5485386252,
-0.4883241355,
-0.4007571042,
0.5420131087,
-0.3279802799,
-0.4400067925,
-0.1573648304,
0.3043936789,
0.6344510913,
-0.9100188613,
0.6469647884,
0.7746091485,
-0.6591136456,
-1.2061420679,
-0.22106646,
0.261431843,
-0.8304795027,
1.3210349083,
-0.5141379237,
-0.2805213034,
-0.5003298521,
-0.2958371043,
-1.2849112749,
0.5173736215,
0.5667828321,
-0.2637512088,
-0.4209516346,
-0.1005755439,
0.7563255429,
-0.4280960262,
0.0978409871,
0.7129038572,
0.5304240584,
0.4600794911,
-1.2002818584,
0.1765980422,
-0.1561003178,
0.1559439301,
0.9355868101,
-0.2834244072,
0.8838353753,
-0.2702765763,
-0.6402041316,
-0.0918237641,
0.4945168495,
-0.4204345942,
-0.3998462856,
0.1066916883,
0.5649061203,
0.3886162937,
-0.3887244761,
1.0886819363,
-0.6430780888,
0.6928707957,
0.5097283721,
0.3027337193,
0.5141065717,
0.5641227961,
-0.6187438369,
0.5371156931,
0.2348109335,
0.1584772468,
0.3693730533,
-0.0519721247,
-0.112688385,
-0.0164016224,
-0.0533283055,
-0.4314139187,
0.4553275704,
0.2497862279,
-0.1539313644,
-0.6321949959,
-0.1783388853,
-0.1931536496,
-0.020661734,
-0.1790594012,
1.0784854889,
0.1195760444,
-0.509150207,
0.8048245311,
-0.0328493118,
0.2177401036,
-0.8260251284,
-0.2678673863,
-0.1078722849,
0.0189429503,
-0.7318470478,
-0.9931628108,
1.0603255033,
-0.5026677251,
-0.09817487,
-0.0397034213,
0.5902065635,
-0.7960505486,
-0.4748686254,
0.1835533679,
0.3988015652,
0.1794540435,
0.8504655957,
-0.4859355092,
0.2442213744,
-0.3300607204,
0.320124954,
0.1573813558,
0.3921786249,
-0.1107508093,
0.4878903627,
0.6467376351,
0.5830943584,
0.2592279911,
0.1054062247,
0.7649600506,
-0.7922750711,
-0.9566221237,
-1.0097270012,
0.0376033336,
0.2843696475,
0.078123346,
0.6947166324,
0.6539640427,
0.566367507,
-0.2393436432,
0.5365485549,
-0.2986097634,
0.0549569093,
-0.5006620288,
0.4318346679,
-0.4976865053,
0.1076516435,
-0.3885852993,
-1.3839195967,
-0.4364220798,
0.3267395496,
-0.2785553932,
-0.065229632,
1.1888204813,
0.359354645,
-0.1848536283,
-0.3348667324,
0.5083983541,
0.0028619193,
0.0150937624,
0.434327364,
0.7191447616,
-0.3376613557,
0.2767045498,
-0.0762386322,
-0.1696029902,
-0.2332535982,
-0.39462924,
-0.5666941404,
-0.7152734995,
-0.3303900063,
-0.4527898431,
-0.4483550191,
0.9580523372,
0.3818946481,
-0.6360555887,
-0.5692533255,
-0.2774012387,
0.3699769676,
-0.2767313719,
-0.3247573674,
0.3160709143,
-0.6672973037,
-0.8988800049,
0.3130712807,
0.5926292539,
0.0598859787,
-0.2467197925,
0.0402358025,
-0.0048953597,
0.4088807404,
0.5115069151,
0.7117769122,
-0.7162804008,
0.083602652,
-0.0962458253,
-0.0939643458,
-0.1430975497,
1.2022953033,
-0.5461932421,
0.5634638667,
0.7104064226,
0.4842882752,
0.1249307543,
0.0534215942,
0.7658115029,
-0.5988225937,
0.5073207021,
0.1172959283,
0.4234322608,
-0.0089888796,
-0.2766119838,
0.4130735993,
0.3664267659,
0.0291470606,
-0.9869895577,
0.5944145322,
-1.1989780664,
0.137338981,
0.9466568828,
0.4931686819,
-0.1154903844,
0.3646836579,
0.1635590792,
0.214877978,
-0.2084198594,
0.2032803893,
0.9318595529,
-0.4980550408,
-0.2558186054,
-0.126844734,
0.8860647082,
0.0774422735,
-0.6682783365,
-0.1220873892,
0.5226231813,
0.2234391123,
0.6158916354,
0.6604443789,
-0.4119756222,
0.311588943,
0.4967349768,
-0.214860782,
0.0478764176,
-0.3477223516,
-0.5880976319,
0.2744741142,
0.2885817289,
-0.0286068209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18265v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18265v1 | Check-COVID: Fact-Checking COVID-19 News Claims with Scientific Evidence | 2023-05-29T17:39:22 | 2023-05-29T17:39:22 | Gengyu Wang, Kate Harwood, Lawrence Chillrud, Amith Ananthram, Melanie Subbiah, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | We present a new fact-checking benchmark, Check-COVID, that requires systems
to verify claims about COVID-19 from news using evidence from scientific
articles. This approach to fact-checking is particularly challenging as it
requires checking internet text written in everyday language against evidence
from journal articles written in formal academic language. Check-COVID contains
1, 504 expert-annotated news claims about the coronavirus paired with
sentence-level evidence from scientific journal articles and veracity labels.
It includes both extracted (journalist-written) and composed
(annotator-written) claims. Experiments using both a fact-checking specific
system and GPT-3.5, which respectively achieve F1 scores of 76.99 and 69.90 on
this task, reveal the difficulty of automatically fact-checking both claim
types and the importance of in-domain data for good performance. Our data and
models are released publicly at https://github.com/posuer/Check-COVID. | [
-0.2225687355,
-0.7833447456,
0.4102152884,
0.3228613436,
-0.2846386135,
0.1175371185,
0.0480941385,
-0.858232975,
0.181875661,
0.2063767165,
-0.1496529728,
-0.5040185452,
-0.468570739,
0.2351246029,
-0.6803828478,
1.2808853388,
-0.1413229555,
-0.0103518376,
-0.7287134528,
0.1509608179,
0.2570100725,
-0.5998661518,
-0.5989574194,
-0.4937533736,
0.4922676384,
0.5685943961,
0.5851556659,
0.1730766445,
0.8278554678,
0.1196106896,
0.1404778212,
0.2647791803,
-0.3391699195,
-0.1098752245,
-0.2273605913,
-0.1318856031,
-0.6125817895,
0.4570977688,
0.0035027869,
-0.0525928736,
0.0543571599,
0.5753415227,
-0.4619601071,
0.2808465958,
-0.7171262503,
-0.0787782818,
-0.2711445391,
0.1015233621,
-0.3007480204,
0.0077727046,
-0.4110788107,
-0.4767937064,
0.2481289208,
-0.5567701459,
0.513094008,
0.1765143871,
1.2037178278,
0.1816759557,
-0.5336832404,
-0.192536667,
-0.5165622234,
0.3631238639,
-0.3471524119,
0.2531435192,
0.5105420947,
0.2711286545,
0.0947167426,
-0.7101336718,
-0.594399035,
-0.4246826172,
-0.0213512555,
0.2336373031,
-0.5363978744,
-0.3443473577,
0.2782907784,
0.5696601272,
-0.8450631499,
-0.1723182648,
-0.4584006965,
-0.5018451214,
0.9583880901,
-0.3400467038,
0.2996523082,
-0.0285598189,
-0.4689927697,
-0.12565355,
-0.8855475783,
0.2026078999,
0.0383414552,
-0.2232315987,
-0.305818826,
0.5487222672,
-0.4344910383,
0.3487281203,
0.2435474843,
-0.1577235162,
0.0882231221,
-0.5887551308,
-0.4324151278,
0.403588742,
0.7538813353,
0.619756043,
-0.4549302161,
-0.2688879967,
0.0728865936,
0.4603004754,
0.0897922292,
-0.8544277549,
-0.5856524706,
0.0473751351,
-0.1699105799,
-0.4800620079,
0.0399033241,
-0.8278879523,
-0.5665774941,
0.1534146816,
0.6343484521,
-0.2172762305,
-0.0880874842,
0.2613369226,
-0.5584000945,
0.0374056771,
0.6522842646,
-0.0460645221,
0.405033201,
0.5098534226,
0.7094793916,
-0.1959192306,
0.0926849321,
-0.7792773843,
-0.2893615067,
-0.318192482,
1.0007758141,
-0.4874426723,
0.0342562944,
-0.2871890366,
-0.235820815,
0.2373241186,
-0.465346843,
0.9232422113,
-0.4627648592,
0.4189929664,
-0.7399708033,
-0.3155914545,
-0.283762008,
0.3722631335,
-0.6555541158,
1.1194850206,
-0.1223943233,
-0.8699373603,
0.6743033528,
-0.6789383888,
-0.4962976575,
0.1255502701,
-0.0752898082,
-0.7532944083,
-0.1108293906,
0.3592690229,
0.1527314335,
-0.5548468828,
0.3497436345,
-0.2968783081,
-0.0961817354,
0.1757798493,
-0.1039241105,
0.755509913,
0.2984411418,
-0.6811372638,
-0.0654761791,
-0.9274711013,
-0.3309116364,
-0.0264297798,
-0.2114874274,
-0.3546052277,
0.1623500586,
-0.0030383787,
0.2302145511,
0.4244810939,
-1.1078804731,
0.2644067407,
0.1623841226,
0.2407108545,
-0.0390089899,
0.1428591311,
-0.1018702909,
-0.5892714262,
0.2838950455,
0.216127798,
0.4234303832,
0.1597370505,
-0.5277012587,
-0.5684388876,
-0.4662038386,
0.1342709512,
0.7328948379,
-0.5460828543,
0.3797507584,
0.1917999387,
-0.8507282734,
-0.1977044642,
-0.2905525863,
0.236081928,
0.6676384211,
0.5989462137,
-0.3071676493,
-0.8582223058,
-0.5831090212,
-0.466045171,
-0.2617513537,
0.329537034,
-0.0833583996,
0.7632538676,
-0.0566406064,
0.8692229986,
-0.5192701817,
0.0664186627,
0.3651024997,
0.5101807117,
0.05451978,
0.2912519276,
0.4439035654,
-0.7211143374,
-0.2908322811,
0.1745860726,
-0.7543090582,
-0.0756401047,
0.0202941056,
0.3403617144,
-0.1290139556,
0.6162540317,
-0.4673164189,
0.4816597104,
0.460657239,
-0.7520940304,
0.7432791591,
-0.244831115,
0.3817618191,
-0.6393947601,
0.2062850744,
0.3130135536,
-0.4521814883,
-0.5458425283,
0.1240912825,
0.0802239254,
-0.1248556525,
-0.3071366251,
0.2266182154,
-0.0762764364,
0.2764825523,
-0.2725768983,
-0.1127745658,
0.3144895732,
-0.2022653073,
-0.194088757,
0.7699179649,
0.4706690013,
-0.5870454311,
0.6876122355,
0.1584460288,
-0.5140621066,
0.6148123741,
-0.7999444008,
-0.0771814734,
0.0253576096,
0.542118609,
-0.6005313396,
-0.2975443304,
0.1685048044,
-0.3235203326,
-0.2649737,
0.2521388233,
-0.320318222,
-0.569139123,
-0.2615816295,
0.3222704828,
0.2264620662,
-0.6648972631,
0.2178573757,
0.4835575819,
-0.0172790568,
-0.5253947973,
-0.4261538386,
0.3524424136,
0.0564056709,
-0.5651439428,
0.6246961355,
-0.039257966,
-0.6121785641,
0.2513665855,
-0.418412894,
-0.3852483034,
0.1966482699,
0.311696738,
0.1149095818,
-0.3069495559,
-0.0956026167,
-0.0700984001,
0.323520273,
0.1616910547,
0.0461235344,
0.2042662948,
-0.3471907973,
-0.3549589515,
-0.4156236649,
0.3070919812,
0.8719621897,
-0.348508507,
0.2736819386,
0.5872761607,
-0.5524667501,
0.3298774958,
-0.776339829,
-0.1413760185,
-0.3484547734,
0.1324243098,
-0.1467661113,
-0.7889739871,
0.3319054246,
-0.060245838,
-0.0793856084,
0.9468930364,
0.2652111351,
0.2050342858,
0.5468382239,
0.5079222322,
-0.1504387259,
0.0291442238,
0.0954313427,
0.2871208489,
-0.1405429095,
-0.4606178999,
-0.8367361426,
0.2225077897,
-0.3676095903,
-0.3681405783,
0.4160600305,
-0.0125684887,
-0.2725540102,
0.307300657,
-0.3556469381,
0.365613848,
0.6001730561,
0.2982548177,
0.5979657769,
-0.1485688835,
0.1115785465,
0.3766842782,
-0.6018897295,
-0.2183920741,
0.7983268499,
0.2136292458,
0.6828878522,
-0.0428684428,
0.7067654133,
0.7275948524,
0.4157538414,
-0.3223488927,
0.3636744916,
-0.3184318244,
-0.7400277257,
-0.0645088628,
-0.1491948217,
-0.6626439095,
-0.1276816875,
-0.4801930785,
-0.3547876477,
0.4413064718,
0.0790025964,
-0.642641902,
0.124050431,
-0.6182104349,
0.4536024034,
-0.4213466346,
-0.415460676,
-0.6028733253,
-0.2974612117,
0.4915797412,
0.0177639574,
0.1744723916,
-0.2608417273,
0.1890827268,
0.7930666804,
-0.5624964237,
0.7673219442,
-0.0667258278,
0.0142160067,
0.3054255545,
-0.312205255,
0.6777876616,
0.3986347616,
-0.1403748095,
0.1702296436,
0.2995612919,
-0.4395143986,
0.0072404589,
0.4648489356,
-1.0727961063,
-0.5008580685,
-1.2312716246,
-0.3520188332,
0.1234048977,
0.1980589181,
0.3296630681,
0.5230942965,
-0.6851788759,
0.2683137059,
0.605566442,
-0.1716641486,
0.2323995978,
0.9366820455,
-0.204449743,
-0.5105566978,
0.7030112743,
-0.0120375101,
-0.2462779433,
0.6685526967,
0.4699570239,
0.0023082586,
-0.4429205954,
-0.2089921981,
0.0370324068,
-0.1465070248,
-0.3132204413,
-0.5247247815,
-0.242339924,
-0.4786452353,
0.1054735854,
-0.4033481479,
-0.2050067633,
-0.1321794689,
0.009713348,
0.7004799843,
0.9968292117,
-0.2366380692,
-0.0866358802,
-0.4070851207,
0.7317138314,
0.4301220775,
0.2462282032,
-0.860948801,
-0.19696711,
-0.409450233,
0.1236612573,
-0.4089875221,
-0.5698809624,
0.1575767249,
0.2515862584,
0.3540256023,
0.4142041802,
0.4040062129,
0.667147994,
-0.3729936779,
1.174485445,
0.2931962907,
-0.9003516436,
0.4572192132,
-0.1592462659,
0.058442425,
0.5446515083,
0.5862270594,
-0.4473735392,
-0.3984644115,
-0.7593967915,
-0.481469661,
0.2326717526,
-0.0712896958,
-0.661250174,
-0.0459084101,
0.2934030294,
0.333894819,
0.0913790837,
-0.2583371103,
-0.1781460196,
-0.5018910766,
0.1550701112,
-0.1460073441,
-0.3797631264,
-0.6097381115,
-0.3483557105,
0.8105982542,
0.133651942,
0.2389825433,
0.8053869009,
-0.1657285094,
-0.3722496331,
0.3852848411,
1.0251231194,
0.6907173991,
-0.3555387259,
0.6644977331,
-0.046817828,
-0.8404089212,
0.2807783186,
0.2977872193,
-0.4221815467,
0.1609774232,
0.0987037718,
0.5891584158,
0.0590142235,
-0.5704032779,
0.6241205931,
-0.2370162755,
-0.399679482,
-0.2608245313,
0.0320236012,
-0.2984531522,
0.2794956863,
0.5033605099,
0.650452435,
0.1435509175,
-0.5318740606,
0.4705701768,
0.3836249411,
-0.0131021021,
-0.6689888239,
0.6938403845,
0.2510205507,
0.0431809202,
0.2132143378,
-0.2407549173,
-0.3851136267,
0.5829629302,
0.4934577048,
0.6849153042,
-0.2880211473,
0.5853382945,
0.3389379978,
0.44800964,
-0.5806154013,
0.4099682868,
0.2959708571,
-0.3996355534,
-0.620917201,
-0.1730413735,
-0.9029709101,
0.5709829926,
-0.7506492138,
0.2643360794,
-0.3145400286,
-0.2232249826,
0.3047482371,
0.3760931492,
-0.6853591204,
0.4273486435,
0.0770668387,
1.2501292229,
-1.1685454845,
0.7353870273,
0.6962707043,
-0.3019472063,
-0.2308990359,
-0.0612193905,
0.1004121006,
-0.4552565515,
0.4256291687,
0.0802682266,
-0.0942719802,
-0.4532325566,
-0.8863275051,
-0.9813557863,
1.0130428076,
0.5334684849,
-0.572471559,
0.2467120737,
-0.1447417736,
0.5427780747,
-0.3089223504,
0.1500180066,
0.3569186628,
0.5272259116,
-0.130879581,
-0.9626945853,
0.0625948831,
-0.4558538795,
-0.9335073829,
-0.1809862703,
-0.9314861894,
0.7843993306,
-0.1107873619,
0.0645415187,
-0.2198861241,
0.8212291002,
0.1051047221,
1.0812009573,
0.404066056,
0.9374589324,
1.2022176981,
-0.0529052056,
0.9065152407,
-0.4498052299,
0.218123883,
1.0903544426,
-0.3410769701,
0.838131845,
0.3955692649,
-0.1590770632,
0.6957238913,
0.583455503,
-0.278398186,
0.3663874865,
-0.0418250747,
-0.4405676126,
-0.1725860834,
-0.4255869985,
-0.5509144068,
0.4284899235,
0.2543365955,
-0.025896078,
-0.2277485728,
-0.0373510085,
0.352021426,
-0.1820688993,
-0.2542904317,
0.5460146666,
-0.300360173,
-0.9931548834,
0.3687559962,
0.0577649511,
0.4949832261,
-0.294978708,
0.1839728653,
0.0709035918,
0.064274855,
-0.3442229331,
-0.4116338491,
0.3241067529,
0.3724468648,
-0.4398174286,
0.0989739969,
0.8908548355,
-0.5536758304,
-0.3170335591,
-0.2119808048,
0.4669090211,
0.1379827261,
-0.3340488076,
-0.3153562248,
-0.0048263585,
-0.3548255563,
-0.0588643216,
0.1616570204,
0.091507718,
-0.221329242,
0.2976722419,
0.5511677265,
0.1054677218,
-0.1029629037,
-0.2431892455,
0.6857822537,
-0.4847459197,
-0.2678700984,
-0.833245337,
-0.0021556825,
-0.3694065213,
-0.3038595915,
0.9201229215,
1.0293382406,
0.6365171671,
-0.1783411503,
1.0420114994,
-0.306633383,
0.2705557048,
-0.0125010777,
0.8137603998,
-0.2046342343,
-0.4343176186,
0.0368009061,
-0.0753985718,
-0.4455983043,
0.3734407425,
-0.4880181253,
-0.5369217396,
1.0336997509,
0.5835974216,
0.1204064041,
0.2439813018,
0.1361601502,
0.2609163225,
0.4673179686,
0.2518380284,
0.6118814945,
-0.5253174305,
0.3216591775,
-0.3723945916,
-0.4716671407,
-0.5984759927,
-1.247995615,
-0.7885400057,
-0.3924522996,
-0.9746779203,
-0.6755782366,
0.2536474466,
0.9817982316,
0.6527264118,
-1.1365039349,
0.0183482487,
-0.2603195608,
0.1646089107,
-0.7379396558,
-0.1295634955,
0.575938344,
-0.0866834298,
-0.1460102051,
0.5267820358,
0.3713405132,
-0.2728743851,
-0.0909543708,
0.0319294855,
-0.3799446225,
0.1982286423,
0.5979585648,
0.518066287,
-0.5246201158,
-0.499262929,
-0.0190392863,
-0.3722766936,
0.0549502112,
0.9349036813,
-0.6604595184,
0.427968055,
0.714328289,
0.5499296784,
0.6560922265,
-0.1000276804,
0.4378704131,
-0.6887732744,
-0.1245164648,
-0.0345155336,
0.390416652,
0.3603207767,
-0.4612174034,
0.3537910283,
0.5833469033,
-0.739033103,
-0.8733146787,
0.0221552439,
-1.1374666691,
0.09469001,
0.8952416182,
-0.162833482,
-0.4181189537,
-0.3406489491,
-0.0551192649,
0.3345226645,
-0.4939523935,
1.1760325432,
0.6123416424,
-0.0710974187,
-0.0149922287,
-0.160876289,
0.9075801969,
0.1224350557,
-0.943749249,
-0.18919155,
0.1915288866,
0.2856962979,
0.3186282218,
0.407641083,
0.0235767905,
0.9709307551,
0.087088868,
0.2394585609,
-0.3888157308,
-0.3081597686,
-0.127483055,
0.5057963729,
-0.0258724764,
-0.1691654325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18248v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18248v3 | Do Language Models Know When They're Hallucinating References? | 2023-05-29T17:12:03 | 2024-03-20T13:12:48 | Ayush Agrawal, Mirac Suzgun, Lester Mackey, Adam Tauman Kalai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | State-of-the-art language models (LMs) are notoriously susceptible to
generating hallucinated information. Such inaccurate outputs not only undermine
the reliability of these models but also limit their use and raise serious
concerns about misinformation and propaganda. In this work, we focus on
hallucinated book and article references and present them as the "model
organism" of language model hallucination research, due to their frequent and
easy-to-discern nature. We posit that if a language model cites a particular
reference in its output, then it should ideally possess sufficient information
about its authors and content, among other relevant details. Using this basic
insight, we illustrate that one can identify hallucinated references without
ever consulting any external resources, by asking a set of direct or indirect
queries to the language model about the references. These queries can be
considered as "consistency checks." Our findings highlight that while LMs,
including GPT-4, often produce inconsistent author lists for hallucinated
references, they also often accurately recall the authors of real references.
In this sense, the LM can be said to "know" when it is hallucinating
references. Furthermore, these findings show how hallucinated references can be
dissected to shed light on their nature. Replication code and results can be
found at https://github.com/microsoft/hallucinated-references. | [
-0.2223814875,
-0.4349734783,
0.7369015217,
-0.0162835363,
-0.0182833616,
-0.3112578094,
-0.0251329187,
-0.8254745603,
-0.0149563095,
0.7700917125,
-0.4336475432,
-0.0911945403,
-0.4066845477,
0.3076047897,
-0.6520077586,
0.8430582285,
0.1408054978,
0.034117084,
-0.2858933806,
-0.2126008123,
-0.2871725559,
-0.7572607994,
-0.0792478323,
-0.5212442875,
0.4591008127,
-0.1589548439,
1.0390627384,
0.6862788796,
0.3848165572,
0.2681561112,
-0.0471608341,
0.2713810205,
-0.6270604134,
0.3720394969,
-0.4080895483,
-0.3447148204,
-0.0839456245,
-0.0556909777,
0.4252527058,
0.7923811674,
-0.0901580825,
-0.1480492502,
0.163245514,
0.6422348022,
-0.5511654019,
-0.0257033519,
-1.0501465797,
0.0798109174,
0.0404093973,
-0.420985043,
-0.8517781496,
-0.4973964691,
-0.1570978016,
-0.1712952405,
0.4540587962,
0.0329797007,
1.1213835478,
0.3644314706,
-0.2606914937,
-0.6231967807,
-0.9523800015,
0.4129500389,
-0.4556641877,
0.6642567515,
0.755523622,
0.0540340692,
-0.1889191419,
-0.3871120512,
-0.4711305797,
-0.5873753428,
-0.437089026,
-0.380705893,
-0.0223758742,
-0.1627738327,
0.3461586237,
0.2467423975,
-0.648413837,
-0.350610733,
-0.5122173429,
-0.3645419478,
0.2898808122,
-0.3512454331,
0.4982357025,
-0.1197049618,
-0.2663142681,
0.239468798,
-0.8370200992,
-0.7767806649,
0.3294859231,
0.2506805658,
0.3007979691,
0.6087332368,
0.2715081275,
0.566424489,
0.1221451536,
0.1240222305,
0.1212833822,
-0.2566883266,
-0.1996869594,
0.3007028103,
0.5746597648,
-0.0967522636,
0.5389788151,
-0.9804084897,
-0.4641598165,
-0.0140305459,
0.6347354054,
-0.5516532063,
-0.5823108554,
0.3059588969,
-0.2803870142,
-0.0559014194,
0.1733107865,
-0.3861022294,
-0.5843128562,
-0.2810353339,
0.7645375133,
-0.5196477771,
-0.4466591775,
-0.0462062098,
-0.0446358211,
-0.1312577575,
0.1005202606,
-0.8525738716,
0.3041513264,
0.5842119455,
0.7263117433,
-0.1474370509,
-0.5083836913,
-0.6352565289,
0.2698088586,
-0.5341821909,
0.8970289826,
-0.4871308804,
-0.251044035,
0.1796156466,
0.2182629257,
0.0162059125,
-0.9475593567,
0.1518711001,
-0.4671525061,
-0.1102265716,
-0.6179155111,
-0.6120800972,
0.0318458378,
-0.0726749524,
-0.969131887,
0.7431710958,
-0.1073573902,
-0.7472452521,
0.0943393111,
0.2057196349,
-0.1508651227,
-0.0303697586,
-0.4450761974,
-0.3112286627,
0.2954368591,
-0.2945210934,
0.2217236012,
0.0554467142,
0.3842580616,
-0.2337052226,
-0.3601951599,
0.3783540726,
0.0368016697,
0.8013510704,
0.2990499735,
-0.3303577602,
0.0205589291,
-0.7979146242,
-0.1764883846,
0.1248338372,
-0.0275488533,
-0.5210688114,
0.1696230173,
-0.2326582819,
0.0522671416,
0.0649775043,
-0.1509325951,
0.1550408602,
0.1189166382,
-0.013497781,
0.6506075263,
-0.0210437719,
0.2201671302,
-0.4867294133,
0.0959865674,
0.1176343709,
-0.2108194977,
-0.200588271,
-0.2843591273,
-0.8078764677,
0.2959364951,
0.0098626707,
0.1623550504,
-0.6009801626,
0.4196061194,
0.0351122245,
-0.545402348,
-0.2988158762,
0.1659479141,
0.35410285,
0.4468307495,
0.2943910658,
0.1109372154,
-0.6326699257,
-0.7732551694,
-0.4073550701,
-0.4910930693,
0.1071048006,
0.1990433037,
0.5993948579,
-0.2262618393,
0.6314762235,
-0.0779578909,
-0.1802261472,
0.003100133,
0.1830086708,
-0.1114372686,
0.3540025651,
0.4617004395,
-0.6825169921,
-0.1057556048,
-0.0842249542,
-1.1757982969,
-0.1813055873,
-0.3505769968,
-0.2549729049,
0.1934124082,
0.6856820583,
-0.5709903836,
0.0927689523,
0.5368639827,
-0.5015995502,
0.8021276593,
-0.3378807008,
-0.1326035708,
-0.5405295491,
0.2487661391,
-0.2555274963,
-0.2276360393,
-0.5872161984,
0.0440915525,
0.2327225655,
0.2911702991,
0.0663086772,
0.344204396,
-0.792450428,
-0.1719932854,
-0.3398937285,
0.205889672,
-0.1090069562,
0.2153754532,
0.2755672634,
0.6458232403,
0.3454789519,
-0.7200479507,
-0.0783473477,
0.0323717743,
-0.4069347084,
0.389367491,
-0.4346945882,
0.5372162461,
-0.22652179,
-0.1506112069,
-0.7096931338,
-0.1454961002,
0.2580784857,
-0.2846477032,
0.1798549443,
-0.0352308452,
-0.5540779829,
0.104530707,
0.1844463646,
0.1079658046,
0.2000755072,
-0.5396580696,
0.4515942633,
0.6192983985,
0.076462172,
-0.5770553946,
-0.5529174209,
-0.1088095978,
0.2710869014,
-0.2160272151,
0.2320986241,
-0.2805525959,
-0.5304879546,
0.2288565189,
-0.3762316108,
-0.2054915875,
-0.0052680313,
0.4560918212,
0.1103219464,
-0.2031338662,
0.4336004853,
-0.3924434185,
0.1454646736,
0.1151989624,
-0.0891332179,
0.5861671567,
-0.0508569777,
-0.4487119019,
-0.224444896,
0.2495950907,
0.4991499186,
-0.0105394023,
0.7019554973,
0.2518954575,
-0.8158724904,
-0.1988611519,
-0.845089972,
-0.5929909945,
-0.3609227538,
0.3447546065,
-0.484128952,
-0.4314141572,
0.6128160954,
0.3699993789,
-0.2426423579,
0.4319732487,
0.4343808889,
0.2981288433,
0.7586635947,
0.7260831594,
-0.0928854421,
0.0533593595,
0.1723909527,
0.125004977,
-0.4822015166,
-0.5059409142,
-0.9513403177,
0.0331447124,
-0.4315654337,
-0.2361411601,
-0.0860016942,
0.2065659761,
-0.2167671621,
0.4240348339,
-0.6110975146,
0.6830826998,
0.3190058768,
0.112446405,
0.5982019305,
0.0827671885,
-0.3177255392,
-0.0330754109,
-0.3967101574,
-0.8314086795,
0.6052522063,
0.292091459,
0.9014049172,
0.0306892954,
0.6241587996,
0.324827522,
0.3886536062,
-0.4805813432,
0.4682888687,
0.4501470625,
-0.8551527262,
-0.1539206207,
-0.3871540129,
-0.8392224312,
0.2859100699,
0.0861108899,
-0.9777585268,
0.6705333591,
0.1680156142,
-0.1664455533,
0.4208460152,
-0.3794778585,
0.6380722523,
-0.200583443,
-0.4814231694,
-0.0181817263,
-0.3391303122,
0.4730780125,
-0.2017177343,
0.1419394165,
-0.0206986126,
0.2658647299,
0.4952435791,
-0.3713110983,
0.7476424575,
0.0946244001,
-0.4148072004,
0.1978095621,
0.7457242012,
0.6455305219,
-0.1335696131,
-0.2390377969,
0.2168837339,
0.1080958098,
-0.1286939383,
-0.3694682121,
0.8853902221,
-0.743914783,
-0.5897520185,
-0.7147817016,
-0.4451773763,
-0.1052977517,
0.1410794705,
0.2542622089,
0.1589691788,
-0.1576184481,
0.1315012425,
0.6968782544,
-0.0348606929,
0.190173924,
0.4478609264,
-0.4806640446,
0.063597396,
0.8867888451,
0.2164866775,
0.3594813645,
0.1151525602,
-0.2097672224,
-0.1639343202,
-0.4019525945,
-0.2587149143,
0.7100186348,
-0.8531457186,
-0.073173672,
-0.8316486478,
-0.4390715659,
-0.3181990981,
0.2486211807,
-0.4853788316,
0.0062816553,
-0.2282779068,
-0.0990582407,
0.0193428937,
1.1900064945,
-0.0893479809,
-0.242618084,
-0.6383019686,
0.3567632735,
0.2220897228,
0.3207032382,
0.1661043614,
-0.3391876817,
-0.211115554,
-0.0143400757,
-0.1884635091,
-1.3948266506,
0.3579108119,
0.1381893605,
0.7134064436,
0.6040621996,
0.1034052521,
0.4590650797,
-0.6365376115,
0.6302340627,
-0.206472069,
-0.7654109597,
0.2646405101,
-0.0302271023,
0.051230479,
0.4265509248,
0.6860383749,
-0.5525976419,
-0.653362751,
-0.4544348419,
-0.4013746083,
0.6252397299,
0.2026682198,
0.0924883261,
-0.3730906844,
0.3462719917,
0.3405620754,
0.2851604223,
-1.0940519571,
-0.1780545861,
-0.2532142699,
0.230798468,
0.1728869528,
-0.6453976631,
-0.1248602122,
-0.0208148416,
0.6359046698,
0.1613857001,
0.2494144887,
0.304746747,
-0.5312530994,
-0.4386926889,
-0.0692886114,
0.69048208,
1.0519311428,
-0.4816947877,
0.727628231,
-0.3922107518,
-0.4541046619,
0.105442822,
-0.2805425823,
-0.2012160271,
0.4871219695,
0.2640052736,
0.5886540413,
0.1300365925,
-0.7375584245,
0.150369674,
0.217014268,
-0.0291382112,
-0.4808167815,
0.0650728717,
0.1351284534,
0.232275486,
0.4940332472,
0.1114303842,
0.0075725527,
-0.8694579601,
0.4453300238,
0.4386958182,
-0.5336021781,
-0.5699326396,
0.7456347346,
-0.1724527478,
-0.4597297609,
0.7404353619,
-0.2293426841,
-0.4271951914,
0.3742226362,
0.8513922691,
0.950699985,
-0.5347688198,
0.2446072698,
0.3592670262,
0.6136466861,
-0.3962102234,
0.1893282086,
0.092903398,
-0.8928174376,
-0.0359966978,
-0.5811003447,
-0.2463104874,
0.6313297749,
-0.6269347668,
0.091693677,
-0.2378946096,
0.0187934935,
-0.0201557837,
-0.4512276947,
-0.3999892473,
0.0271698926,
0.221365124,
0.5323156118,
-0.8371621966,
0.9616181254,
0.1910214871,
-0.6726896167,
-0.397678107,
0.2698396444,
0.0250613727,
-0.6176023483,
0.7246103287,
0.1833638102,
-0.2610144019,
-0.0231600683,
-0.4535064101,
-0.6617413759,
0.4715097845,
0.5421108603,
-0.6404322982,
-0.2344790548,
0.0757183358,
0.3935744762,
-0.2683015168,
0.2671072483,
0.3693873584,
0.4838214219,
0.083984077,
-0.8475345969,
0.3746092916,
-0.3110280335,
-0.1943363696,
-0.0008186902,
-0.193132326,
0.7828776836,
-0.5668109059,
-0.3565497696,
0.1936960816,
0.685985744,
0.2619692683,
0.0353494436,
0.4117273688,
0.2115672231,
1.099250555,
-0.0372518748,
1.0101509094,
-0.5238336325,
0.2354975492,
1.2980748415,
-0.3804955184,
0.8402139544,
0.6585608125,
0.0780424923,
0.3724775314,
0.4184917212,
-0.2673873007,
0.5236046314,
0.1754994243,
0.0231929459,
-0.35659042,
-0.021020893,
-0.5621874928,
-0.0404532664,
0.2097596526,
-0.6488047242,
-0.1102865338,
-0.1288628131,
0.0778869689,
0.1287803054,
0.2150064707,
0.6759831309,
0.1352708489,
-0.877735734,
0.9377824664,
-0.4490031302,
0.0789924264,
-0.4229865372,
-0.1109349355,
-0.3631311953,
0.2737484872,
-0.2219015658,
-0.2699856758,
0.4046278894,
-0.1834845245,
-0.3631435931,
0.0762430653,
0.5829290152,
-0.58281672,
-0.2622972429,
0.445638895,
0.6281368732,
0.5679593086,
-0.4452526271,
-0.2903446257,
0.4224592149,
0.0893847719,
-0.0999265537,
0.3413147032,
0.5870143771,
0.0441144668,
0.6813235879,
0.1984286308,
0.3754101396,
0.0271320622,
0.1682520658,
0.5439945459,
-0.6447737813,
0.0752296671,
-0.9389989972,
0.2247098088,
-0.0973225757,
-0.1025002003,
0.7579939961,
0.684314549,
0.9020066261,
-0.2799318135,
0.7354323864,
0.2879615724,
0.3798619509,
-0.4682920277,
1.057092309,
-0.5415933728,
0.526257813,
-0.2286933362,
-0.9699008465,
-0.1362304688,
0.9207022786,
-0.0804560408,
0.2625597119,
1.0395568609,
1.0362896919,
-0.0900952592,
0.008116615,
0.460193634,
0.5714678764,
0.0690948069,
0.1400647908,
0.8107917309,
-0.3122448921,
0.6342548728,
-0.3610465229,
0.1706254929,
-0.4605839252,
-0.7822003365,
-0.9159830213,
-0.9733354449,
-0.5494198799,
-0.7795495391,
0.4612074494,
0.7212427258,
0.4822520614,
-0.9193549156,
-0.3487107754,
-0.1452326328,
0.2637659013,
-0.2562851012,
-0.1660680622,
0.4199650586,
-0.6190965772,
-0.6377950311,
0.1643630266,
0.2699759603,
0.221120283,
-0.4962260127,
-0.0956801325,
-0.1559279114,
0.1710773259,
0.2192344964,
0.2910525203,
-0.9557201862,
-0.3084002435,
0.1165030375,
-0.4791832566,
0.0198203623,
0.8499934673,
-0.7178100944,
0.5364549756,
0.3838143647,
0.2492352724,
0.0520095825,
-0.1753899604,
0.4911822379,
-0.3586182594,
0.1515827924,
0.2850499749,
0.4407065511,
0.4072123468,
-0.448438853,
0.4321278632,
0.3206964433,
-0.6752576232,
-1.1986342669,
0.1654596329,
-0.6201394796,
-0.4952596426,
1.1477918625,
0.0427286066,
-0.2575536668,
-0.2468673736,
-0.1085020602,
0.1894759387,
0.1132416874,
1.3306866884,
0.9448900819,
0.1519166976,
-0.2243579775,
-0.7011365294,
0.8960673809,
0.2171787024,
-0.4860090911,
0.4043301642,
0.5956681371,
0.1805230975,
0.4823031127,
0.4873689711,
-0.2096892595,
0.0760559142,
0.2133877873,
0.1160525531,
0.1354213059,
-0.5467197895,
0.1474682242,
0.1929171532,
0.2288727015,
0.2500846982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18201v1 | A Critical Evaluation of Evaluations for Long-form Question Answering | 2023-05-29T16:54:24 | 2023-05-29T16:54:24 | Fangyuan Xu, Yixiao Song, Mohit Iyyer, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long-form question answering (LFQA) enables answering a wide range of
questions, but its flexibility poses enormous challenges for evaluation. We
perform the first targeted study of the evaluation of long-form answers,
covering both human and automatic evaluation practices. We hire domain experts
in seven areas to provide preference judgments over pairs of answers, along
with free-form justifications for their choices. We present a careful analysis
of experts' evaluation, which focuses on new aspects such as the
comprehensiveness of the answer. Next, we examine automatic text generation
metrics, finding that no existing metrics are predictive of human preference
judgments. However, some metrics correlate with fine-grained aspects of answers
(e.g., coherence). We encourage future work to move away from a single "overall
score" of the answer and adopt a multi-faceted evaluation, targeting aspects
such as factuality and completeness. We publicly release all of our annotations
and code to spur future work into LFQA evaluation. | [
-0.6529577374,
-0.8832295537,
0.6844760776,
0.2978498638,
-0.1357167959,
0.2354519665,
-0.3117830455,
-0.714617312,
0.0012003726,
0.3489635885,
-0.6702213287,
-0.0668120384,
-0.4796886444,
0.341834873,
-0.3015939891,
1.0828282833,
-0.2106864154,
-0.1036809534,
-0.6580399871,
-0.3020262122,
-0.4335732758,
-0.391418159,
-0.6587209702,
-0.2735785842,
0.6373976469,
0.3838664591,
0.9328917265,
0.1258572191,
0.5489756465,
0.1919721067,
-0.1250910908,
-0.0125959208,
-0.6104139686,
0.0629227534,
-0.1390557736,
-0.1635874659,
-0.4851426184,
0.0049061514,
0.6399864554,
1.0273920298,
0.175223425,
0.5815573931,
0.0504731797,
1.0726572275,
-0.4787658155,
-0.2182112783,
-0.2261960506,
-0.0457373857,
-0.1613275707,
0.0728718787,
-0.2976333797,
-0.5337539911,
0.4068060517,
-0.3791923523,
0.056153059,
-0.0115074906,
0.4947744906,
0.2795083821,
-0.6278681159,
-0.3044887483,
-0.7292048335,
0.6848211288,
-0.3355102539,
0.4697751403,
0.236503467,
0.6231127381,
-0.0845516324,
-0.6273580194,
-0.3218143284,
-0.2865983844,
0.1518767029,
0.1697222143,
-0.106385842,
0.2586133182,
0.0894408748,
0.5057353377,
-0.6300116777,
-0.0286634099,
-0.6473172307,
-0.2044069022,
1.0955364704,
0.1025803462,
0.0562028103,
-0.1536117494,
-0.3815432191,
0.1654516459,
-0.3237716556,
0.5521277189,
0.2528440356,
-0.086012505,
0.4268931448,
0.5627354383,
-0.5742520094,
0.6113204956,
0.20060274,
0.1506039798,
0.044651676,
-0.1510088146,
-0.3662392199,
-0.274571687,
0.797583878,
0.6520465612,
0.3320811391,
-0.3773587644,
-0.1799561679,
-0.311925739,
0.3609083593,
-0.6442312598,
0.2658346593,
0.527148366,
-0.4960912168,
-0.2861221433,
-0.0127615994,
-0.6986736655,
-0.3307744563,
-0.1521418393,
0.6788868904,
-0.1554576457,
-0.070884712,
0.3232916296,
-0.1997514069,
0.3937274516,
0.3911705911,
-0.4580836892,
0.5605534911,
0.7604112625,
0.2180331945,
-0.6447979808,
-0.3785608709,
-0.5819664001,
-0.4247822762,
-0.2786254883,
0.8475610614,
-0.3047831655,
-0.4425264895,
-0.0472116992,
-0.0133539559,
0.1419604421,
-0.6494848132,
0.9919977188,
-0.7390161157,
0.3921764195,
-0.3418777287,
-0.3876814246,
-0.1838309765,
0.1624991447,
-0.8947729468,
1.186183095,
0.4655058682,
-0.5441270471,
0.4525477588,
-0.8008132577,
-0.3201096952,
0.0076804394,
-0.0405547693,
-0.3572345376,
0.1153794155,
0.2162628025,
0.3504729271,
-0.5728154182,
0.2254387289,
-0.0818755105,
-0.351380676,
0.4829034209,
-0.4683074355,
0.6074772477,
0.153885603,
-0.5630648136,
0.172163859,
-0.5918625593,
0.3814189732,
-0.129809007,
-0.2058438957,
-0.031912107,
-0.2379862368,
-0.0124146473,
0.1566543281,
0.0662493035,
-0.5726518035,
-0.0788531676,
-0.3582129776,
0.301315099,
0.7465500236,
0.2772201896,
0.3891149163,
-0.5949984789,
0.9874087572,
-0.3587110341,
0.469992578,
0.3318131566,
-0.5895514488,
-0.7150703073,
0.1471108496,
0.2548986077,
0.3898566067,
-0.5304813981,
0.1666810513,
-0.2598925829,
-0.630346179,
-0.4295836091,
0.3657213151,
0.4255953431,
0.3234906197,
0.2990912795,
-0.4866208434,
-0.0693221837,
-1.2023195028,
-0.4250455797,
-0.1103365943,
0.1033331826,
0.4295431674,
0.611425519,
0.0075474926,
1.1406867504,
-0.5306275487,
0.2044978142,
-0.0914839506,
0.0432725586,
0.0684068277,
0.0284791999,
0.6060959697,
-0.7306631207,
-0.4071775973,
-0.4949893653,
-0.3111762702,
-0.0037131011,
0.001516538,
-0.4277176261,
0.1277586967,
0.1772449017,
-0.6802209616,
0.3082064986,
0.2594285309,
-0.3288202286,
0.8455376029,
0.3514135182,
0.3910741806,
-0.4988220632,
0.2124631852,
-0.1516148001,
-0.2779999077,
-0.4722969234,
0.2233683914,
-0.0872202441,
-0.1959277242,
-0.3529099822,
0.6225981116,
-0.27278018,
0.0252495613,
0.0951806307,
0.1628079116,
0.2625294328,
0.1609931737,
-0.1554362029,
0.775302887,
-0.0484356359,
-0.3633662164,
0.551861465,
0.098817192,
-0.5591430664,
0.352751106,
-0.8262969255,
0.6808807254,
-0.3563725352,
0.3840123117,
-1.2064447403,
-0.3327198625,
-0.0267440435,
-0.7377968431,
0.0335809067,
0.3184206188,
-0.0302701984,
-0.5711032748,
-0.5671218038,
0.6181644201,
0.2734590173,
-0.1773216426,
0.3091256618,
0.1025465056,
-0.2975751758,
-0.7921866775,
-0.3140651286,
0.0365021229,
-0.1612340361,
-0.7299816012,
0.0131167723,
-0.586212337,
-0.4103108048,
-0.2089259923,
-0.3705052435,
-0.3350245059,
0.4282057583,
0.1864993125,
-0.1477641761,
-0.3095359206,
0.1654239744,
0.1753451824,
0.1224496961,
0.5631244183,
0.1121889353,
0.1957235634,
-0.2353202254,
-0.2709897161,
-0.1394990385,
0.8563548326,
0.6804141998,
-0.5592967868,
0.1559087187,
0.4466812313,
-0.4773108065,
-0.1430303752,
-0.6302743554,
0.1030049101,
-0.4043174088,
0.5710911155,
-0.2446968704,
-0.9943557978,
0.1112775281,
0.1470759064,
0.262986511,
0.9549731612,
0.3678578734,
-0.1958948523,
0.8144763708,
0.6415116191,
0.1670144498,
-0.1019555181,
-0.0890662,
0.0648687109,
-0.5281026959,
-0.2577390075,
-0.5288605094,
-0.1920980513,
-0.1787019223,
-0.4977330565,
0.4974030852,
0.2130530775,
-0.2271445245,
-0.1785623282,
-0.6431803703,
0.4157474339,
0.1923102438,
0.2530079186,
0.1209718361,
-0.3843643963,
0.2279862612,
0.1189432368,
-0.1373516172,
-0.5886577964,
1.0349305868,
0.7311968207,
0.4327230453,
0.2436866611,
0.8383692503,
0.4482904077,
0.4654934406,
-1.1724556684,
0.5340428948,
0.0136165451,
-0.7371644378,
-0.8883924484,
-0.2113060206,
-0.8705912828,
-0.0866247267,
-0.291089505,
-0.3691833317,
-0.1923210621,
-0.2729676366,
-0.8217694163,
-0.3298934996,
-0.5479105711,
0.7699080706,
-0.4498841166,
-0.3483603597,
-0.107536912,
-0.7360681891,
0.3882475793,
-0.144037053,
0.0538882986,
0.026574228,
-0.106013909,
1.1110512018,
0.0466352366,
0.5478506088,
-0.2695360482,
-0.2323653996,
0.4324853122,
0.0028603524,
-0.1668142229,
0.4111657739,
-0.4310898781,
-0.3280816078,
0.4508797228,
-0.3705380857,
-0.9814305305,
0.3484391272,
-0.8246585131,
-0.8086909652,
-0.4054612219,
-0.1626981497,
-0.5072204471,
0.2565828264,
0.0035859314,
0.3139408231,
-0.7708711624,
0.2242387086,
0.6226795316,
-0.2030835152,
0.0724288076,
-0.0123978546,
-0.438698709,
-0.7631402612,
0.3671823442,
0.0132662803,
0.3580399454,
0.3459450305,
0.3872735202,
-0.4475684166,
-0.5319402814,
-0.8631951213,
0.1158364192,
-0.7881539464,
-0.1237668172,
-0.4495822489,
-0.3527468145,
-0.2136001885,
-0.1532457024,
-0.0022101442,
-0.7409944534,
-0.1218060777,
-0.1222283393,
0.1385206729,
0.830362618,
0.3652653098,
-0.0469651893,
-0.898639679,
0.4499638677,
0.831486702,
0.4092366397,
-0.0647321641,
-0.3164901137,
-0.1777208894,
0.0241348632,
-0.3573179841,
-0.7775862813,
-0.3046449721,
0.496856004,
0.5501748919,
0.1278889924,
0.2529358566,
0.5071975589,
-0.443557471,
1.1708315611,
0.0823445469,
-0.9139288068,
0.4434229434,
-0.1422226131,
0.3522235751,
1.0588204861,
0.6344107985,
-0.4350094795,
-0.1701707095,
-0.3325967193,
-0.7595573068,
0.1942800432,
0.0559261218,
0.1664734185,
-0.0925277844,
0.6702917814,
0.5300891995,
0.2558011711,
-0.4656285942,
-0.1427833289,
-0.1703385562,
-0.044370953,
-0.2542906702,
-0.4243789017,
-0.3268124163,
-0.3174425066,
0.2675874829,
-0.1960767061,
0.4925750196,
0.5355160832,
-0.2204936892,
-0.2649702132,
0.6371607184,
0.7909945846,
1.1109484434,
-0.3323385715,
-0.1381151974,
0.3390968144,
-0.453328073,
0.0943348408,
0.21344392,
0.0132934032,
0.0003099282,
0.4246385992,
0.4463514984,
-0.0962875932,
-0.579398036,
0.746222496,
-0.2068199068,
-0.468945086,
-0.5984356999,
-0.0848830417,
-0.070478037,
-0.0059028408,
0.561897099,
-0.1244984344,
0.510283649,
-0.7653754354,
0.2438254356,
0.4265683293,
-0.6877437234,
-0.2334854454,
0.4657138288,
0.4054395854,
-0.3371091485,
0.3887251914,
0.0543027259,
-0.7800449729,
0.6557825804,
0.3072255254,
1.0767134428,
-0.1559836119,
0.3789839745,
0.1947857291,
0.3454952538,
0.3030912578,
0.51255548,
-0.3227007985,
-0.246688813,
-0.452703476,
-0.6761965156,
-0.6750754118,
0.101627849,
-0.8154452443,
0.0637600347,
-0.527102828,
-0.3374023139,
0.0716613084,
0.4629242718,
-0.7710955739,
0.764395535,
0.074540332,
1.2139818668,
-0.5514751673,
0.2775166631,
0.7357453704,
-0.2923175991,
-0.5590668917,
0.1348396242,
-0.2497039884,
-0.5045757294,
0.7133541107,
0.3967954218,
-0.4367539585,
-0.4110313356,
-0.4790037572,
-0.5217782855,
1.0574833155,
0.1603763402,
-0.1759221703,
-0.2289581299,
0.4185225964,
0.5614737272,
-0.1850461215,
0.6727603078,
0.5926308036,
0.503031075,
-0.2955460548,
-1.3684104681,
0.1297421157,
-0.2577558458,
-0.4062976241,
0.224997893,
-0.926155448,
0.3116193712,
-0.1964249611,
-0.1095969304,
0.2151171267,
0.7623382807,
-0.0958553404,
0.4549397826,
0.8963052034,
0.1091915518,
0.7627854943,
0.1910984069,
0.6502709985,
-0.1193205342,
0.2402252108,
0.8704351783,
-0.161074087,
1.0177352428,
0.4819375575,
-0.3098758161,
0.3805802763,
0.6048005223,
0.5325957537,
0.2381039709,
0.7210547328,
-0.2694254816,
-0.3869648576,
0.0219792575,
-0.3218658268,
0.6999033689,
0.1054599658,
-0.262503475,
-0.1348264813,
-0.1698874533,
-0.0554863997,
0.0925634131,
-0.2435553521,
0.5704491735,
0.1798326075,
-1.0328478813,
0.837025106,
-0.0451077633,
0.4299045205,
-0.437867105,
0.0357804224,
-0.1252319068,
-0.0952474922,
-0.4077068865,
-1.1485430002,
0.3030821383,
0.1125610396,
-0.3071301281,
-0.2069433033,
0.5603579283,
-0.0261138044,
-0.2938455939,
0.2741478086,
0.5921054482,
0.1616113186,
-0.1751316637,
-0.6389585137,
-0.2796919644,
-0.0334553085,
-0.4724421501,
0.1550502777,
0.330686599,
-0.177997604,
0.4578736722,
0.428519696,
-0.3625768125,
-0.0437505506,
0.148631081,
0.916682899,
-0.7190199494,
-0.0746147484,
-0.4691869318,
0.6479567289,
-0.1234390289,
-0.7291574478,
0.3399023116,
0.7247599363,
0.526689887,
0.0148616424,
0.7908645868,
0.1184488386,
0.5490433574,
-0.4250752032,
0.8543319702,
-0.5908802748,
-0.1782988757,
-0.433501333,
-0.9824739099,
-0.2294029444,
0.1721217185,
-0.1940358877,
0.0553543642,
0.8087913394,
0.2526896894,
0.1238307431,
0.0702932104,
0.3015584946,
-0.1426192075,
0.2766883075,
0.8716005683,
1.1458301544,
-0.4535268247,
0.6545794606,
-0.4385340512,
-0.5335116386,
0.0149036804,
-0.7940425873,
-0.9070624113,
-0.6585513353,
-0.0672496781,
-0.3800735176,
0.083729662,
0.9178202748,
0.2924674451,
-0.4775206745,
-0.238314867,
0.6491757631,
-0.1007427126,
-0.1000378355,
-0.2221639454,
0.5273489952,
-0.0259242915,
-0.3498950899,
0.2978534102,
0.0966887325,
-0.3279522359,
-0.4439684749,
0.133797124,
0.1398932785,
0.2396958917,
0.9465266466,
0.19913432,
-0.6904354692,
-0.7209738493,
0.6443625093,
-0.009532541,
0.1018121839,
0.5500558019,
-0.6271968484,
0.3574741781,
0.4839795232,
0.9689822793,
0.286293447,
0.2292738259,
0.6215877533,
-0.1727350205,
-0.5134965777,
0.5501571298,
-0.0657361671,
0.1814835817,
-0.4545208514,
0.3484782577,
-0.1857317835,
-0.9391909838,
-0.8577240705,
0.162002936,
-1.305606246,
0.1270932108,
1.1859438419,
-0.0628154352,
-0.2383214235,
-0.2711925507,
-0.4337161481,
-0.0334746614,
-0.2830998003,
0.5183581114,
0.9690585732,
-0.4780062139,
-0.0927457958,
-0.8215759993,
0.6313425303,
0.6351060271,
-0.7798424959,
0.0237518642,
0.4824292958,
0.4841173589,
0.1092518941,
0.8919230103,
-0.0174179375,
0.6951111555,
-0.5407267213,
-0.1024815217,
0.1986752003,
-0.3613314033,
-0.5248057246,
0.2158456147,
0.7120150924,
0.1019002199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18200v1 | Contextual Knowledge Learning For Dialogue Generation | 2023-05-29T16:54:10 | 2023-05-29T16:54:10 | Wen Zheng, Natasa Milic-Frayling, Ke Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Incorporating conversational context and knowledge into dialogue generation
models has been essential for improving the quality of the generated responses.
The context, comprising utterances from previous dialogue exchanges, is used as
a source of content for response generation and as a means of selecting
external knowledge. However, to avoid introducing irrelevant content, it is key
to enable fine-grained scoring of context and knowledge. In this paper, we
present a novel approach to context and knowledge weighting as an integral part
of model training. We guide the model training through a Contextual Knowledge
Learning (CKL) process which involves Latent Vectors for context and knowledge,
respectively. CKL Latent Vectors capture the relationship between context,
knowledge, and responses through weak supervision and enable differential
weighting of context utterances and knowledge sentences during the training
process. Experiments with two standard datasets and human evaluation
demonstrate that CKL leads to a significant improvement compared with the
performance of six strong baseline models and shows robustness with regard to
reduced sizes of training sets. | [
-0.2891108692,
-0.5520202518,
0.363319546,
-0.1047998294,
-0.2649469972,
-0.1136135459,
0.0135788554,
-0.1507168263,
-0.4035369158,
0.5173531771,
-0.4249464869,
-0.3121809959,
-0.327952534,
-0.3847509921,
-0.0127290692,
1.0687732697,
0.220618844,
0.6267367601,
-0.618678093,
-0.2422953248,
-0.8701271415,
-0.5421392918,
-0.7014506459,
-0.4910354614,
0.4508129358,
0.3132992089,
0.1752614677,
-0.0110393781,
0.0839978307,
0.2174190879,
-0.0809864998,
0.1639294475,
-0.8047665358,
0.3181916773,
-0.1745087951,
-0.5466672182,
-0.3245426714,
0.0134735713,
0.3649311364,
0.8789120317,
-0.0296474807,
-0.0043660505,
0.4206140041,
0.3308902979,
-0.5901370645,
0.1938367337,
-0.8780117631,
0.1607351899,
0.2703643441,
-0.5501906872,
-0.4800799787,
-0.043310184,
0.4905278087,
-0.6121920347,
0.2785530686,
0.0442381352,
0.390691936,
0.2120664418,
-0.6017964482,
-0.3476293981,
-0.575601697,
0.9296606779,
-0.7703987956,
0.3650038838,
0.3890927732,
0.3923698366,
-0.0088146692,
-0.589763701,
-0.4400492013,
0.0945050567,
-0.1833273172,
0.2219086587,
0.1853031814,
0.0324540921,
0.3148771226,
0.096349664,
-0.0338847861,
-0.1989708096,
-0.4535318911,
-0.2775633931,
0.4871582389,
0.3198843896,
0.0440205671,
-0.4347603619,
-0.5533943176,
-0.146847561,
-0.8079682589,
0.377628684,
0.2433939874,
0.4796729088,
-0.3282321692,
0.3057705462,
-0.2829990089,
0.7858963013,
0.1793415099,
-0.3826331496,
-0.0599998385,
-0.4462392628,
-0.1259618998,
0.1346463114,
0.5393682122,
0.5632192492,
-0.0802693442,
-0.1116286367,
-0.1699445993,
-0.3557395339,
0.4045093358,
-0.8314875364,
-0.2537289262,
-0.2227761596,
-0.3841410279,
-0.6437860727,
-0.1368181705,
-0.4512889683,
-0.2345390022,
-0.597114563,
0.3866853416,
-0.5072128177,
-0.1529351771,
-0.4499227107,
-0.1822976321,
0.5710533261,
0.6954934597,
-0.8776420951,
0.2081676275,
0.2779644728,
0.5419757962,
0.0168684106,
0.368039459,
-0.7801455855,
0.3274013102,
-0.3062803447,
0.5019029379,
-0.5087110996,
-0.5734666586,
-0.0585382581,
-0.2412403375,
-0.0417413004,
-0.4117076695,
0.345363915,
-0.721085906,
0.5087710619,
-0.3824595213,
-0.5331525207,
-0.2456981242,
0.2687673271,
-0.2062785178,
0.7872989774,
0.4721553624,
-0.9247176051,
0.6199504733,
-0.3119643927,
-0.4572060108,
0.2149742246,
-0.4076664746,
-0.2446781397,
0.1626103967,
0.2522203922,
0.7919670939,
-0.0945045725,
0.4296568036,
-0.354393512,
-0.0256689116,
0.0891720951,
-0.4188774526,
0.531401813,
0.1687016785,
-0.172031045,
-0.0550096966,
-0.5906923413,
0.0928464755,
0.014539876,
-0.5118303895,
-0.5513292551,
0.0586361699,
-0.0876249745,
0.3572181761,
-0.0128620053,
-0.3583897054,
0.0637614653,
-0.5866345167,
0.3644517064,
0.6375927925,
0.3189703822,
0.5865027308,
-0.339120388,
0.1618085206,
0.4103476405,
-0.1571641564,
-0.1524192542,
-0.3356139958,
-0.7161285281,
0.2980457544,
0.2462043911,
0.4605220556,
-1.1859717369,
0.344774574,
-0.155024156,
-0.2706156969,
-0.0086269425,
0.4389811754,
0.5018741488,
1.1050443649,
0.4369014502,
-0.3112906814,
-0.5036407113,
-0.5454203486,
-0.0523982309,
-0.2705514729,
-0.359026283,
0.7572178245,
0.3169911802,
0.1164015681,
1.3036795855,
-0.6559601426,
-0.2514395714,
-0.5079206228,
0.2718696296,
-0.2590390742,
0.6819323301,
0.4612382054,
-0.9732507467,
-0.3865945339,
-0.0739139915,
-0.9381203055,
0.0865758583,
0.0669564977,
-0.0879048109,
0.0296443012,
0.6726995707,
-0.193531245,
0.280421406,
0.3299437761,
-0.1663617492,
0.3259450495,
-0.022532424,
-0.0214041397,
-1.5270944834,
0.0210063197,
-0.2208711803,
-0.5335787535,
-0.7058771849,
-0.4703008533,
-0.1901954561,
-0.1952667981,
-0.646455586,
0.5989066958,
-0.1020540372,
0.0709642246,
0.0301708337,
0.1484894156,
0.1997333765,
0.7797421217,
0.2756894231,
0.6178478003,
0.2882915139,
-0.7201814651,
0.3564244509,
0.4115408361,
-0.5569590926,
0.8127399683,
-0.5599080324,
0.0923062712,
-0.0630268455,
0.3098580837,
-1.0168510675,
-0.1634075642,
0.1115768552,
-0.4035064876,
0.4070514739,
-0.1759476364,
0.0197817739,
-0.095006153,
0.0798985809,
0.545548439,
0.4803905189,
-0.4116036296,
0.7085251808,
0.3502641022,
-0.3016187251,
-0.4109216332,
-0.3522621393,
-0.3923963606,
-0.3705899119,
-0.5329144597,
0.1639941633,
-0.0750967711,
-0.1393505037,
-0.1745202392,
-0.1707401872,
-0.0236025415,
0.1712805331,
0.1430622935,
-0.0582159087,
-0.2105088383,
0.3326085508,
0.1395984143,
0.0905643702,
0.0915854126,
-0.4847457409,
0.4868552685,
0.3291845918,
-0.2271007299,
-0.3404142857,
0.1961470693,
0.2286211401,
0.0163037106,
0.8126084208,
0.7008126974,
-0.2092184722,
-0.2762070298,
-0.4386641979,
-0.4937621653,
-0.4187400639,
0.3050438464,
-0.3194940686,
-0.833363235,
0.3943164349,
-0.2809186876,
-0.0409957692,
0.2517689466,
0.5612254143,
-0.1901003271,
1.2245771885,
0.6401215196,
-0.0992153436,
0.6407846212,
-0.2418458313,
0.2590892017,
-1.0285077095,
-0.3457571566,
-0.1924123466,
-0.0640632659,
-0.0338970385,
-0.6894360185,
0.4926193655,
0.4999500215,
-0.0592513606,
0.0708594099,
-0.1145164818,
0.1721289605,
0.5021322966,
0.2490237951,
0.2944276631,
-0.0607078336,
-0.4984754622,
-0.0052998695,
-0.9993588328,
-0.4733866155,
1.1987261772,
0.1633976847,
0.6829065084,
0.0301561486,
0.4787168205,
0.3910388947,
0.3141040504,
-0.759974122,
0.3463566005,
0.2713123262,
-0.362641573,
-0.3983524144,
-0.730170548,
-0.5187647939,
0.2240761518,
-0.2768386602,
-0.662604332,
-0.1001202762,
0.2201536894,
-0.6734862328,
0.1098004729,
-0.7782953382,
0.745886147,
-0.126069203,
-0.4443107545,
-0.2000985593,
-0.7466759682,
0.4244028628,
0.0330172479,
0.0079806782,
0.0235020984,
0.5062884688,
0.947019279,
-0.536988318,
1.0795068741,
-0.6488582492,
-0.2836693227,
0.3573137224,
-0.1788538247,
0.2562298179,
0.5402881503,
0.2248423845,
-0.1411230862,
-0.0160031021,
-0.35207811,
-0.7498147488,
0.3790534437,
-0.8333123922,
-0.5647503138,
0.034464322,
-0.6302992702,
-0.5872551203,
0.0980123281,
0.2280437201,
0.9039390087,
-0.3660560548,
0.447298944,
0.9911513925,
-0.4332740307,
0.0122666946,
0.5750560164,
0.2054249793,
-0.1950345188,
0.8100553751,
-0.0302301552,
0.4930444658,
0.6464170218,
0.0829574689,
-0.2175644636,
-0.3363209069,
-0.2014846057,
-0.3758411705,
-0.6495108008,
-0.4370047748,
-0.7319800854,
-0.3402057886,
-0.6383789182,
-0.13971214,
-0.1523011178,
-0.291797936,
-0.2241430283,
-0.0109997857,
-0.0964623764,
0.7707802653,
0.245649159,
0.472935915,
-0.5781106949,
0.2113547027,
0.9714302421,
0.0379437022,
0.2977485955,
-0.3921675086,
-0.3739043772,
0.3776569068,
-0.7549737096,
-0.5786117315,
0.2517333925,
0.2222969532,
0.5974814892,
0.6802703738,
0.2720035911,
0.43926844,
-0.4720821083,
0.9821707606,
0.2733821571,
-0.8119007349,
0.8083871007,
-0.4235661328,
0.5642494559,
0.4615415037,
0.2761500478,
-0.4968686998,
-0.3732990623,
-0.5831091404,
-0.7080665231,
0.9509411454,
0.2004508823,
0.3539943993,
0.2134663314,
0.1785140485,
-0.0105683245,
0.2505504787,
-0.5651614666,
0.1664510965,
-0.4146685302,
-0.2620278895,
-0.0297644865,
-0.3219475746,
-0.5005128384,
-0.3007549047,
0.7963932157,
-0.5691782236,
0.2319014519,
0.1427981853,
-0.4139048755,
-0.0824759305,
0.1316610128,
0.6541160941,
0.4993019402,
-0.1855545789,
-0.1026006192,
0.5448493361,
-0.1177462786,
-0.1422757804,
-0.2460572273,
0.0734718964,
-0.3349044621,
0.5481144786,
0.9534115791,
0.7584935427,
-0.4970427155,
0.7767996788,
-0.3236148655,
-0.2945444286,
-0.2229635417,
0.2264955938,
0.0976656973,
0.3639579713,
0.4119826257,
0.1231938824,
-0.0000391822,
-0.2515133619,
0.3569971919,
0.4843039513,
-0.5853766203,
-0.2999446392,
0.5453211069,
0.5106651783,
0.2303874493,
0.5399928093,
-0.0837132558,
-0.6213704348,
0.2372500598,
0.3137120008,
0.3916985989,
-0.2368235141,
0.1548731625,
0.3932823241,
-0.4098210931,
0.2475026846,
-0.1184899881,
-0.7554244995,
-1.0274722576,
-0.1738027185,
-0.9721918702,
-0.3189544082,
0.1770725995,
-0.7821879983,
0.2826920748,
-0.345631361,
0.0292082764,
-0.2097430825,
0.0966226384,
-0.8791301847,
0.2646362484,
0.2208716422,
0.624566555,
-0.8365536928,
0.8117818832,
0.4431313574,
-0.3224968016,
-1.1238771677,
0.0242000744,
-0.0825017914,
-0.77285707,
1.0477064848,
0.2101635784,
0.1525259018,
0.0192492586,
-0.5848413706,
-0.6975278854,
1.2540323734,
0.1840581894,
-0.2066170275,
-0.361097306,
0.0818668678,
0.3374122083,
-0.6464368701,
0.2884449363,
0.2179701477,
0.0189266205,
0.4587773383,
-0.666503787,
-0.0726059228,
-0.1356234699,
0.2430501282,
-0.1726018488,
-0.4854757786,
0.6519306302,
0.0834837705,
-0.1989800483,
0.0540701412,
0.7296708822,
0.0722348988,
0.1344494075,
0.5543549657,
0.4582660496,
0.5725976229,
-0.1981537342,
0.6702815294,
-0.516889751,
0.1614917964,
1.201813221,
-0.2399016619,
0.6740535498,
0.3374046087,
0.1315985769,
0.6251049638,
0.3729574084,
0.2357527465,
0.6650568843,
0.0600583069,
-0.4221706092,
-0.4653437734,
-0.3576741219,
-0.3116027415,
0.6212159395,
0.4795092344,
-0.3607535064,
-0.3471754491,
0.3044137061,
-0.2162552178,
-0.0446015522,
-0.2437759191,
1.2946749926,
0.2955662608,
-0.7527829409,
0.5498262644,
-0.2756741345,
0.4892320335,
-0.7103544474,
-0.2078915685,
-0.1281969249,
0.0924763307,
-0.0984692201,
-0.3852624297,
0.1780770272,
-0.1554615796,
-0.4074259698,
-0.4311409593,
0.7842122912,
-0.5766509771,
-0.2701629102,
0.2124588192,
0.5584949255,
-0.2052074969,
0.1789041162,
-0.4033497572,
-0.5234776139,
-0.0677577779,
-0.2285678089,
0.3961122632,
0.5021961927,
-0.0607754551,
0.5139594078,
0.5721145272,
-0.1863887012,
-0.2430834174,
0.2068934143,
1.1582944393,
-0.3227454126,
-0.5864787698,
-0.2973577976,
0.6063392162,
-0.3133770823,
-0.112428613,
0.655934155,
0.341686964,
0.9501647949,
0.0414379798,
0.9637587667,
-0.188282162,
0.4584336877,
-0.7790344357,
0.7532292604,
-0.4901676476,
0.1664810479,
-0.4004686475,
-0.7083311081,
0.0829929784,
0.5819995403,
-0.6656075716,
0.1198301315,
0.3612000048,
0.620965898,
-0.0322366618,
-0.0011206472,
0.5757838488,
0.0661042929,
0.3987598121,
0.6986560225,
0.8531731367,
-0.3603730798,
0.4046944082,
-0.0299931318,
-0.0667502061,
-0.1414117217,
-0.6890063882,
-1.2050395012,
-0.7588997483,
0.0916771293,
-0.172148183,
-0.1297645271,
0.6812143922,
1.1469918489,
-0.8280362487,
-0.0511755496,
-0.1283672303,
0.1909747571,
-0.0052005844,
-0.32887128,
-0.0991832465,
-0.6916039586,
-0.4311745167,
0.4745844007,
-0.051317025,
0.0627329051,
-0.2774069309,
-0.3588561416,
-0.1436483562,
-0.0947223082,
0.7288017273,
-0.0830668211,
-0.506619215,
-0.3800813556,
-0.4712426662,
-0.0314508155,
-0.0539432429,
1.0349855423,
-1.1083723307,
0.402218163,
0.4831133485,
0.4721385241,
0.51347965,
0.2272518277,
1.1799961329,
-1.3648091555,
0.2118679583,
0.2411985248,
0.185968399,
0.6310451627,
-0.3339530528,
0.2135261297,
0.3426050246,
-0.3762802184,
-0.6234935522,
0.3800688386,
-0.7643031478,
-0.2340212017,
0.9000097513,
-0.31232813,
0.0150254657,
-0.1566841006,
-0.3002132773,
0.4705390632,
-0.4333838224,
0.6125948429,
0.6519283056,
0.0988435224,
-0.1084926501,
-0.5120766163,
0.8844202757,
0.5543821454,
-0.5625831485,
-0.0416655019,
0.3772524595,
0.3302375972,
0.2353583276,
0.5630124807,
0.2496223152,
0.0263611916,
-0.1243472174,
-0.2272038758,
0.2482896894,
-0.2439826578,
-0.0160961971,
0.2727528811,
-9.975e-7,
0.3452711403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18189v1 | Marked Personas: Using Natural Language Prompts to Measure Stereotypes in Language Models | 2023-05-29T16:29:22 | 2023-05-29T16:29:22 | Myra Cheng, Esin Durmus, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | To recognize and mitigate harms from large language models (LLMs), we need to
understand the prevalence and nuances of stereotypes in LLM outputs. Toward
this end, we present Marked Personas, a prompt-based method to measure
stereotypes in LLMs for intersectional demographic groups without any lexicon
or data labeling. Grounded in the sociolinguistic concept of markedness (which
characterizes explicitly linguistically marked categories versus unmarked
defaults), our proposed method is twofold: 1) prompting an LLM to generate
personas, i.e., natural language descriptions, of the target demographic group
alongside personas of unmarked, default groups; 2) identifying the words that
significantly distinguish personas of the target group from corresponding
unmarked ones. We find that the portrayals generated by GPT-3.5 and GPT-4
contain higher rates of racial stereotypes than human-written portrayals using
the same prompts. The words distinguishing personas of marked (non-white,
non-male) groups reflect patterns of othering and exoticizing these
demographics. An intersectional lens further reveals tropes that dominate
portrayals of marginalized groups, such as tropicalism and the
hypersexualization of minoritized women. These representational harms have
concerning implications for downstream applications like story generation. | [
-0.580914855,
-0.6060060859,
0.671742022,
0.4466004074,
-0.1963103861,
0.1893330961,
-0.0867524073,
-0.4058319926,
0.5268045068,
0.8455018401,
-0.5207877159,
-0.6618546247,
-0.482496202,
0.3259894848,
-0.1768432856,
0.9598391056,
0.295291394,
-0.0275750738,
-0.2688827813,
0.0379888266,
-0.5499073863,
-0.6445858479,
-0.5629760623,
0.0407264791,
0.8154655099,
0.2453055382,
0.5730804205,
0.7675602436,
0.2951646447,
0.2787435055,
-0.004125949,
0.0656561628,
-0.4865316153,
0.2234902084,
0.0058986912,
-0.2034515589,
-0.1036619619,
0.415833801,
0.4188711047,
1.1855658293,
0.5809788704,
0.116147384,
0.126469925,
0.3215321898,
-0.5341925621,
0.1222054586,
-0.3115038872,
-0.0041576312,
-0.5773428082,
-0.2766381204,
-0.4525462389,
-0.7536673546,
-0.1013301238,
-0.3046510518,
0.2389770299,
0.3401134312,
0.6422595382,
0.0217767768,
-0.8514264822,
-0.2121397257,
-0.7849263549,
0.8076556921,
-0.6721056104,
0.0671951547,
0.5312489271,
0.2849473357,
-0.1643414348,
-0.1532981992,
-0.3944666386,
-0.4511984885,
-0.5115285516,
0.0628983751,
-0.0248997137,
0.1399190873,
0.5973117948,
0.2420617342,
-0.7372995019,
0.3980931938,
-0.3106272221,
-0.3683929741,
0.5423800349,
0.4178622663,
0.6389279366,
-0.511392951,
-0.3403098583,
0.3255811632,
-0.8546329737,
-0.0386122428,
0.6986579299,
0.6116450429,
-0.0568610206,
0.6591978073,
0.0133866956,
0.7645972967,
0.059027005,
-0.1911375821,
0.1460728794,
-0.2007476538,
0.2080814838,
-0.0318704173,
0.753213346,
0.6485335231,
0.5872118473,
-0.1208649501,
-0.3043994606,
0.2674365044,
-0.1792741269,
-0.6130731702,
-0.3024297953,
-0.1145244688,
-0.1900466532,
-0.2639782727,
-0.2204028219,
-1.1042746305,
-1.0110030174,
-0.2970226407,
-0.0085176015,
-0.3212786615,
-0.1553080976,
-0.1189286113,
-0.2253766507,
0.2068348676,
0.3791390359,
-1.2707009315,
0.3177435696,
0.6255198121,
0.6877216101,
-0.1572654396,
0.196421057,
-0.4710787535,
0.0492646024,
-0.2472656518,
0.8244635463,
-0.6909303665,
-0.3864543438,
0.2548297644,
-0.3279508948,
-0.1833803356,
-0.5849120617,
0.4154540598,
-0.1292711496,
0.2677902579,
-0.5418732762,
-0.5532339811,
-0.0754880235,
0.2550739944,
-0.4881148636,
1.1689352989,
0.0934558585,
-0.5923317671,
0.6394099593,
-0.2684271932,
-0.1621334106,
0.4761393368,
-0.3829862475,
-0.0740276203,
-0.0704027265,
0.2189847231,
0.5425581932,
-0.09048336,
0.2910639048,
-0.2742755413,
-0.2381311506,
0.2002128959,
-0.1096859425,
0.8475992084,
-0.1839113683,
-0.3664129972,
0.2222496867,
-0.695782125,
-0.3818576336,
0.0735316053,
-0.113074027,
-0.8144669533,
-0.0944843069,
0.1332638115,
0.2023382038,
0.2248422652,
-0.6298180819,
0.0981350243,
-0.2354793102,
-0.0702476948,
0.8879090548,
0.2060654163,
0.1858694851,
-0.4454418123,
0.670610249,
-0.0704308078,
0.0085391141,
-0.1110144034,
-0.7744094133,
-0.7589094043,
-0.6558521986,
-0.0525796339,
0.4792650044,
-0.6575638652,
0.7067583203,
-0.1618640721,
-0.5484979153,
-0.1741949916,
-0.0139522664,
0.4623527229,
0.5644099712,
0.0627007186,
-0.2874505818,
-0.5856971145,
-1.1149175167,
-0.4509967864,
-0.3813506961,
-0.3144385219,
0.3070311844,
0.4432502985,
0.0714690387,
1.0482404232,
-0.4547991157,
-0.2068857253,
-0.3163792789,
0.4186401963,
-0.0293070618,
0.2952219248,
0.727380991,
-0.5256209373,
-0.4792537689,
-0.4042687118,
-0.6611210108,
-0.7674091458,
0.0220817775,
0.0737154931,
-0.2144538611,
0.3844045699,
-0.2956117988,
0.2648285031,
0.2751824558,
-0.6907618046,
0.7798343301,
0.1575243771,
0.1806192547,
-0.6374440789,
-0.008712288,
0.4852280915,
-0.1749382615,
-0.7898126841,
-0.180085212,
-0.3380707204,
-0.1813551188,
-0.3678461313,
0.8053682446,
-0.4711975157,
-0.1065215096,
0.0517309681,
0.252910614,
0.0328221321,
0.3477481902,
0.1741250306,
0.7289132476,
0.2878279984,
-0.5518626571,
0.2427387238,
0.2694540322,
-0.2817403078,
0.8614916205,
-0.4036678374,
0.2523336112,
-0.4778494835,
0.1781148314,
-1.1079913378,
-0.3160526752,
0.5958752632,
-0.2671064436,
-0.276823014,
-0.2722379863,
-0.592787981,
-0.2646357715,
-0.1665119082,
0.5522384644,
0.5126155615,
-0.352656275,
0.3467762768,
0.3579779863,
-0.3075628281,
0.0279774982,
-0.2846807539,
0.1841564178,
-0.741045475,
-0.5588943362,
-0.3133782446,
-0.0723650828,
-0.6043806672,
-0.4752036035,
0.3307238221,
-0.037591666,
0.0213531051,
0.3692960739,
0.3684510887,
-0.1121301651,
0.0065574832,
-0.3122170269,
-0.0188434087,
0.2119339257,
0.0335960835,
0.5987724662,
0.112467207,
-0.1985403299,
-0.0430082157,
0.546843946,
0.3794194162,
-0.3892518282,
0.6347599626,
0.3281367123,
-0.4753155708,
0.1567253768,
-0.5636122823,
-0.1832057685,
-0.4540291727,
-0.0348559245,
-0.1039590687,
-0.9350169301,
0.6716083288,
0.0845775306,
-0.0033963046,
0.2061131597,
0.2760266364,
0.0719868094,
1.1053631306,
0.4824030399,
0.0572710484,
0.3299459219,
0.4571574926,
0.4329035878,
-0.5824756026,
-0.2150232643,
-0.7355936766,
-0.20057486,
-0.6284381151,
-0.4590200186,
0.4690174162,
-0.3349074125,
-0.223353222,
0.2872130573,
-0.3882841468,
0.5275541544,
0.596745193,
-0.1690182686,
0.3199307323,
-0.2093217969,
-0.0865198746,
-0.7658180594,
-0.1574361175,
-1.0293998718,
0.8309374452,
0.2834512889,
0.3875589073,
0.034165442,
0.7385448813,
0.4324598014,
0.480435133,
-0.602838099,
0.9433788657,
-0.0454200767,
-0.7678112984,
-0.1049877554,
-0.503148675,
-0.9077966809,
0.1135668829,
-0.0863672048,
-1.3483268023,
0.4287823737,
0.2106623054,
-0.3347122669,
0.242674306,
-0.3245529234,
0.9014015794,
-0.2740677595,
-0.1189963222,
0.3605479598,
-0.5048725605,
0.6825515628,
-0.1697137058,
0.3034713864,
-0.5924697518,
0.0210728571,
0.9713098407,
-0.2853656709,
1.1540856361,
-0.3164166808,
-0.1604785621,
0.0395582877,
0.2464960217,
0.3166869283,
-0.235837549,
-0.087471582,
-0.0775757954,
-0.1620708555,
-0.4063977599,
-0.5308305621,
0.4596608877,
-0.3986544311,
-0.5100731254,
-0.4087730646,
-0.6622997522,
-0.3674162924,
0.1835550964,
0.2292273492,
0.5569838881,
-0.2758910656,
-0.4974472821,
0.5366368294,
-0.4979065061,
0.0419239998,
0.5637221932,
-0.5429414511,
-0.055540178,
1.0189421177,
-0.0279195551,
0.3856625259,
0.162793532,
0.1627456695,
-0.2654999793,
-0.4684370756,
-0.2972837985,
0.3995293081,
-0.7036123276,
0.215539366,
-0.6548926234,
0.1672519594,
-0.590359807,
-0.2205559909,
-0.0346753523,
-0.106017895,
-0.1225443631,
-0.1332594156,
0.3173755407,
0.9189401865,
-0.0667461827,
0.3880240023,
-0.5008689761,
0.3790653646,
0.2978630662,
0.0121914521,
-0.3538824916,
-0.4003764689,
0.1629579663,
-0.0590255409,
0.1290545762,
-1.0857796669,
0.448484838,
-0.1654758453,
0.2661284208,
0.6094426513,
0.3550070226,
0.4514548779,
-0.2847144902,
0.8010758162,
0.1938498169,
-0.6968706846,
0.5673118234,
-0.8681495786,
0.048672244,
0.6220856905,
0.3862966001,
-1.0583312511,
-0.9881731272,
-0.2842832208,
-0.857866168,
0.3498614132,
0.1093172655,
0.3158047795,
-0.5066065192,
0.0066062389,
0.1637948453,
0.2161895484,
-0.8802780509,
-0.4483388364,
0.0555326566,
-0.2589233518,
0.0128761204,
-0.4667286575,
-0.1390142292,
-0.0687698647,
0.473549515,
-0.0814527199,
0.042534139,
-0.1066622809,
-0.0293950196,
0.0319320001,
0.2863915563,
0.4074720442,
0.5492768288,
-0.2238286138,
0.3195832074,
-0.408752352,
-0.3340445459,
0.3776589036,
0.2027792931,
-0.5840219855,
0.1936233193,
0.3317394257,
0.7930703759,
0.3805165589,
-0.5847712755,
0.5043026209,
0.0440678932,
0.1028200611,
-0.35100016,
-0.1159332246,
-0.1296631098,
-0.1350217015,
0.252592057,
-0.2361715734,
0.171307832,
-0.5109124184,
-0.0266053341,
0.4055642188,
-0.5454012752,
-0.233505547,
0.5543931723,
0.4415659606,
-0.258571744,
0.5096921921,
-0.3073766232,
-0.4545717537,
0.6077497602,
0.3228133023,
0.7433953285,
-0.2356406003,
0.5219948292,
0.39320153,
0.5174492002,
0.3351114094,
-0.0276636183,
0.3704220355,
-0.8210310936,
-0.0615307912,
-0.5879986882,
-0.3857563138,
0.2097254246,
-0.6520959139,
0.2422175854,
-0.6406969428,
0.0061533642,
0.2485125065,
-0.3155820668,
-0.4782098532,
0.2137021422,
0.4453287125,
0.6439660788,
-1.4214589596,
0.1277472079,
0.5703322291,
-0.3965384364,
-0.7098654509,
0.0892613456,
0.4714447558,
-0.7013677359,
0.6490355134,
0.511480391,
0.1962226927,
0.098646,
-0.3989239931,
-0.6009018421,
0.4135398865,
0.3563582599,
-0.2976695299,
0.0966179296,
0.6091900468,
0.5753433108,
-0.3582774401,
0.3066785932,
0.8006547093,
0.8363381624,
0.0124812042,
-0.8218613863,
0.1555950791,
-0.2111399323,
-0.0093358429,
0.3356345594,
-0.1750146449,
0.5812706947,
-0.0499875695,
-0.362611562,
0.1613889039,
0.4370242059,
0.4722785354,
0.2186195999,
0.6907234192,
0.2399335951,
0.7815347314,
-0.2258759588,
0.928573668,
0.1586396098,
-0.0742538869,
0.8964725733,
-0.5021938682,
0.0967793018,
0.527392149,
-0.21525684,
0.346488595,
0.7226244211,
-0.093509078,
0.1236975715,
0.4724535048,
-0.7089710832,
-0.4438737035,
-0.7162516117,
-0.1128228828,
0.440587163,
0.3051332831,
-0.303586483,
-0.3122624457,
0.2207786739,
0.3233624399,
0.557104826,
-0.2505399883,
0.6965497732,
0.1638271064,
-0.6070734859,
0.2564385235,
-0.115659155,
0.6748916507,
-0.4267163873,
0.0073780217,
-0.4944706559,
-0.2665712237,
-0.0975826234,
-0.6897104979,
0.1406770349,
0.1051923633,
-0.1874342859,
-0.4140005112,
0.6856139898,
-0.5620603561,
-0.7865895629,
0.2205989212,
0.5503405929,
0.6076901555,
-0.0663263053,
-0.2349260598,
-0.1234250665,
-0.063393198,
0.0758532882,
0.3477066755,
0.3387856781,
-0.3835302591,
0.6771637201,
0.392095089,
0.1993826628,
0.3032818139,
0.3683622181,
0.4069746733,
-0.5417340994,
-0.593772471,
-0.7519489527,
0.4946352243,
-0.1673441976,
-0.350572288,
1.0604934692,
0.5976752043,
0.411447674,
-0.0378586128,
0.7734353542,
-0.0484540164,
0.7779394388,
-0.3205381036,
0.3854100406,
-0.0489129536,
0.3301592767,
-0.4528580606,
-0.8617976308,
-0.4085313678,
0.2870003283,
-0.9035410881,
0.2257745564,
0.315854609,
0.8924931884,
0.1149870753,
-0.044817932,
0.3888894618,
0.0310672317,
0.3307655156,
0.3359226286,
1.010597229,
0.1507115364,
0.2536627352,
-0.1491572261,
-0.3795256615,
-0.01491425,
-0.6850267649,
-1.1057546139,
-0.501465261,
-0.577242136,
-0.1879000515,
0.0151622407,
0.6499339342,
0.3864628971,
-0.6207081676,
-0.2530713975,
0.2317199707,
0.0767630041,
0.0616809651,
-0.3173065186,
-0.0290307831,
-0.0959816501,
-0.8442123532,
0.18325378,
0.2833558619,
0.1432752907,
-0.5633707643,
0.0448467433,
-0.0370854363,
0.070183441,
0.3589500487,
0.2800761163,
-0.6492717266,
-0.5696695447,
-0.2883975804,
-0.2589894533,
-0.0073801978,
0.9799063802,
-0.6095612049,
0.2513220608,
0.2699255049,
0.0828894377,
-0.1898391247,
0.0766521618,
0.7933881283,
-1.1192158461,
0.2355068326,
0.5998293161,
0.4211740196,
0.7572341561,
-0.4986850619,
0.2821148634,
0.3786458671,
-0.3558970094,
-0.7079726458,
0.4961311221,
-0.7716635466,
0.1659520715,
1.359672308,
-0.2232591659,
0.1098697856,
-0.6096529961,
-0.2943794429,
0.0219825543,
-0.310369283,
0.6830960512,
0.5961969495,
0.0122587336,
-0.2800029218,
-0.7559102178,
0.5614830852,
0.345587641,
-0.9334962964,
0.2045125365,
1.0141795874,
0.2124464065,
0.0954937562,
0.7860962152,
-0.0828944817,
-0.0718235523,
-0.2857718468,
0.1097974405,
0.260415554,
0.0025613753,
-0.0539882816,
-0.1588529944,
0.0607072525,
-0.0834486932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18185v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18185v2 | Syntax and Semantics Meet in the "Middle": Probing the Syntax-Semantics Interface of LMs Through Agentivity | 2023-05-29T16:24:01 | 2023-07-10T13:10:40 | Lindia Tjuatja, Emmy Liu, Lori Levin, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in large language models have prompted researchers to examine
their abilities across a variety of linguistic tasks, but little has been done
to investigate how models handle the interactions in meaning across words and
larger syntactic forms -- i.e. phenomena at the intersection of syntax and
semantics. We present the semantic notion of agentivity as a case study for
probing such interactions. We created a novel evaluation dataset by utilitizing
the unique linguistic properties of a subset of optionally transitive English
verbs. This dataset was used to prompt varying sizes of three model classes to
see if they are sensitive to agentivity at the lexical level, and if they can
appropriately employ these word-level priors given a specific syntactic
context. Overall, GPT-3 text-davinci-003 performs extremely well across all
experiments, outperforming all other models tested by far. In fact, the results
are even better correlated with human judgements than both syntactic and
semantic corpus statistics. This suggests that LMs may potentially serve as
more useful tools for linguistic annotation, theory testing, and discovery than
select corpora for certain tasks. Code is available at
https://github.com/lindiatjuatja/lm_sem | [
-0.3668580353,
-1.0796978474,
1.0535589457,
-0.1659435928,
-0.1931017488,
-0.0189629346,
-0.3243613541,
-0.3500504792,
0.2292169929,
0.3326151967,
-0.5461972356,
-0.3570778072,
-0.5279861093,
0.1127440482,
-0.5818662047,
0.6653782725,
0.0221616812,
0.0865779296,
-0.275270313,
-0.3241348863,
-0.1880972534,
-0.8501692414,
-0.5031602979,
-0.2005131096,
0.8250750303,
0.1188438907,
1.2766582966,
0.5534868836,
0.5850149393,
0.360563308,
0.1177517548,
0.0957069919,
-0.1135980263,
0.4551768899,
-0.3696374893,
-0.3528789282,
-0.6411093473,
0.2276066095,
0.8000636101,
0.8661603332,
0.0616831742,
0.0634215549,
-0.1747321337,
0.5670067072,
-0.6094780564,
0.1068613306,
-0.6215125918,
-0.2576643825,
-0.2089920044,
-0.3509222269,
-0.4176490605,
0.0959890783,
0.1216350347,
-0.3169369102,
0.1587525755,
0.0573932752,
0.9201905727,
0.3602087498,
-0.6643022895,
-0.3869719505,
-0.7100617886,
0.4098501503,
-0.3560822308,
0.5541459918,
0.3133075237,
0.3278280795,
-0.185724318,
-0.7687597871,
-0.950422287,
-0.6226384044,
-0.2389013618,
0.0746306628,
-0.2338716686,
0.0969923362,
-0.095158577,
0.1683312654,
-0.5471203923,
0.0081452653,
0.0143153686,
0.0149510708,
0.5142102242,
0.1904065907,
0.6197339296,
-0.0719681978,
-0.2973406911,
-0.0661929771,
-0.6842163801,
-0.0823287442,
0.3269677758,
0.5588522553,
0.2855814695,
0.7715273499,
0.2136523277,
0.7386125326,
-0.3827632666,
0.5345971584,
-0.0509412885,
-0.5427815914,
-0.122039184,
-0.1475884616,
0.6620352268,
0.4029736221,
0.1775075495,
-0.2192548215,
-0.3853417337,
0.445928067,
0.3111284673,
-0.4963328838,
-0.0556337833,
0.3245800436,
-0.1695284545,
-0.078121677,
-0.0473823473,
-0.1331640184,
-0.2571099102,
-0.5726907253,
0.4934388399,
-0.2870449126,
-0.5726285577,
0.1388519704,
0.0452489331,
0.4620048702,
0.1843861341,
-0.830955565,
0.6553784609,
0.9643776417,
0.6987655759,
-0.2237630039,
-0.6372830272,
-0.6217613816,
0.086414814,
-0.4759712517,
0.6993844509,
-0.6714811325,
-0.1352019906,
-0.11635416,
0.1909457892,
-0.2169169337,
-0.3482482433,
0.4587459862,
-0.5397698283,
0.1002514362,
-0.1999336332,
-0.7636390924,
0.0473010875,
0.1424609721,
-0.8716821074,
1.0852810144,
0.0641581044,
-0.3120179772,
0.3935840428,
-0.5906069875,
-0.1471052766,
0.116901435,
-0.4839682281,
-0.1129239053,
0.1556102037,
-0.5219131112,
0.7420005798,
-0.0260804016,
0.3778555095,
-0.2392500192,
-0.3144720197,
0.7495404482,
-0.1741156429,
0.1548736244,
0.1246376559,
-0.3296771944,
0.0853982046,
-0.7660203576,
-0.1395089477,
0.3247115314,
0.1026988328,
-0.6582698822,
0.2245499939,
-0.0780047402,
0.4008985162,
0.1994470954,
-0.2617599666,
0.1222955361,
-0.3136382997,
0.3724196255,
0.8084488511,
-0.1485514939,
0.7202194333,
-0.1616676748,
0.4444962144,
-0.1198019683,
0.0054880599,
0.1446761489,
-0.2703899443,
-0.9412427545,
-0.1385308802,
0.0632889122,
0.1747404039,
-0.7058441639,
0.3926826417,
-0.2676987946,
-0.3537519276,
-0.4291338027,
-0.0771885291,
0.3087099493,
-0.0165556427,
0.1529711634,
-0.0346306674,
-0.131569013,
-1.0017211437,
-0.464908421,
-0.2455900162,
0.2176919878,
0.2023391128,
0.5045586228,
-0.2225976139,
0.961694479,
-0.2983575463,
-0.0513351299,
-0.2966197133,
-0.2915933132,
0.229480505,
0.0861341283,
0.701197505,
-0.6197518706,
-0.1595476568,
0.107860893,
-0.5353243947,
-0.1800688207,
0.077812165,
-0.3635460436,
0.1517874002,
0.5397168994,
-0.8197496533,
0.062606737,
0.4582770169,
-0.8121834993,
0.2038292587,
-0.1245051846,
-0.1298976243,
-0.8624336123,
-0.0452540554,
-0.1686271876,
-0.3215669096,
-1.0281220675,
0.3004248738,
-0.0486111343,
0.2277172059,
-0.4997678697,
0.7953593731,
-0.7019372582,
-0.2809941769,
-0.4736179709,
0.5760007501,
0.065464966,
0.2276145518,
0.0438199826,
0.7743623257,
0.3931369781,
-0.6045630574,
0.3071407974,
-0.1081488878,
0.1713138521,
0.228417322,
-0.5294291377,
0.2292795777,
-0.2896986306,
-0.1124461815,
-1.0187780857,
-0.1383131295,
0.3269464672,
-0.5349830389,
0.1800798178,
0.0058634579,
-0.6281118393,
0.1138750762,
-0.1228315979,
0.3332214952,
0.1668161005,
-0.2081639469,
0.8103612065,
0.4342189729,
-0.1161580384,
-0.3081139624,
-0.4531042874,
0.1220487878,
-0.1713738739,
-0.4594046772,
-0.1389915496,
0.0288325064,
-0.7237532139,
0.047520142,
-0.1933361441,
0.1291645467,
0.3910921216,
0.188583985,
0.4700155854,
-0.0443318896,
0.4101400375,
-0.0838836953,
-0.1241078973,
0.2550816238,
-0.0630799308,
0.6373742819,
-0.4576044679,
-0.4630744755,
0.1417264938,
0.1820643246,
0.4333697259,
-0.2383256108,
0.6701700687,
0.3702374995,
-0.4488690197,
-0.3633857667,
-0.2855451107,
-0.1064158976,
-0.4541017711,
0.3104263246,
-0.791549027,
-0.6530629396,
0.460274756,
0.2956361175,
-0.2018979788,
0.5329361558,
0.8318593502,
0.1937840581,
0.7564028502,
0.3038602769,
0.2765302956,
0.4726855457,
-0.2297445983,
0.1958726943,
-0.4789197147,
0.0277994424,
-0.5095019937,
0.0082523832,
-0.7106127143,
-0.4538296759,
0.2104371339,
-0.2134139538,
0.0246677604,
0.4375282228,
-0.3352974951,
0.4224685729,
0.281529814,
0.0339688472,
0.3727724254,
-0.2887040079,
-0.1259550899,
0.1547648013,
-0.4155367911,
-0.969999969,
0.9330605268,
0.310390383,
0.452034384,
0.490303427,
0.5149453878,
0.3589451313,
0.1999972463,
-0.766219914,
0.9275317192,
0.0291660614,
-0.5718322992,
-0.3016796112,
-0.138839826,
-1.2738909721,
0.543064177,
-0.1871670783,
-0.4874284565,
0.0901886895,
-0.1685046256,
-0.1956232935,
-0.0050236047,
-0.9072954655,
0.9115933776,
-0.2868041396,
-0.7595085502,
-0.0796300992,
-0.7417101264,
-0.0962072685,
0.1455715597,
0.4371595979,
-0.4591039419,
-0.5564897656,
0.3759109974,
-0.4834961295,
0.6209810972,
-0.0154919922,
-0.3637533784,
0.1269791722,
0.4497492909,
0.3090956211,
-0.1417535692,
0.0860479921,
-0.1838496476,
0.2434273064,
-0.5119857788,
-0.8456432819,
0.8095079064,
-0.8742030859,
-0.5575992465,
-0.8097718954,
-0.3327927887,
-0.2060836554,
0.2639711499,
-0.2409013361,
0.5038480759,
-0.3708470166,
-0.2363636792,
0.2949867547,
0.2066898942,
0.5193569064,
0.7634445429,
-0.4869482815,
0.1271090806,
0.8543518782,
0.0489556044,
0.6109340787,
0.337338537,
0.078523986,
-0.3237691522,
-0.4023021162,
-0.3302458227,
0.2623459697,
-0.878180325,
0.1873318553,
-0.7139478326,
-0.2476142347,
-0.0102495635,
-0.012913472,
-0.3493845463,
-0.530957222,
-0.1394242346,
-0.2877568901,
0.2503108978,
0.8215551972,
0.3309251368,
0.1559280455,
-0.706314981,
0.0726797655,
0.0877493843,
0.2021715939,
-0.2270560563,
-0.2258607,
-0.1626597047,
-0.1365486234,
0.1005553976,
-1.0139476061,
0.1363741308,
0.3058857024,
0.6578474045,
0.1511754096,
-0.0438060574,
0.0723419562,
-0.4719623625,
0.8430897593,
-0.2870670557,
-0.9670462608,
0.401688695,
-0.5448280573,
0.1218512878,
0.5343697071,
0.3264594078,
-0.4529930055,
-0.7800500989,
-0.645359695,
-0.8288413882,
0.4015690088,
0.4517344236,
0.1613679677,
-0.3868084848,
0.4470710456,
0.1801076084,
0.2083950937,
-0.8575781584,
-0.3314940035,
0.2575928867,
-0.1408172846,
-0.378809154,
-0.1006264314,
-0.1208871156,
-0.0666089207,
0.4834762812,
-0.1258115768,
0.100242652,
0.3977307081,
-0.3917154372,
0.1272373646,
0.4009977579,
0.451069802,
0.8336911798,
-0.1974501163,
0.5971781611,
-0.223081708,
-0.5083218217,
0.3157243133,
0.258972019,
0.0147885112,
0.2669716179,
0.5478753448,
0.6483192444,
-0.0048619248,
-0.5905973911,
0.7503176332,
-0.1964500993,
0.0757762045,
-0.4975103736,
0.0595284589,
-0.1171828732,
0.2669655681,
0.2591888905,
-0.2117694616,
0.3775889874,
-0.9648967981,
0.1534650773,
0.463142246,
-0.2634161115,
-0.4452693164,
0.4998800755,
0.1767953932,
-0.2603015602,
-0.0239376351,
-0.3850134015,
-0.6167798042,
0.5235080123,
0.0996174961,
0.9341321588,
-0.0612085648,
-0.0925476104,
-0.1141940057,
0.3877407908,
0.2179532945,
0.257848829,
-0.1544928402,
-0.9242978692,
-0.369759351,
-0.3620609343,
-0.5130666494,
-0.3089717925,
-0.4502063096,
0.3899868131,
0.0163659006,
-0.2931810915,
0.1714432836,
0.0549136326,
-0.6264614463,
0.1034948081,
0.1389549077,
0.4819741845,
-0.8739124537,
0.7725786567,
1.0347657204,
-0.4698081911,
-0.6293796897,
-0.0048240642,
-0.0625172853,
-0.8057945967,
0.5402690172,
0.0749644414,
-0.412471652,
-0.1171579286,
-0.2972219586,
-0.6240925789,
1.1212755442,
0.1876690835,
-0.5361979008,
-0.0836718157,
0.3423027992,
0.7558618784,
-0.281093955,
0.5316988826,
0.934574604,
0.37186566,
-0.2441450506,
-0.812646389,
0.3378093243,
-0.4621170759,
-0.1571884453,
0.4333457649,
-0.7804263234,
0.7936626673,
0.1088664681,
-0.3893439472,
0.0613237545,
0.5169511437,
0.0886149555,
0.5106185079,
0.5756299496,
0.3411238492,
0.5775794983,
-0.2846292257,
1.0242749453,
-0.5009521246,
0.2837304175,
0.9174181819,
-0.5586728454,
0.7555630803,
0.7544801235,
-0.2769035101,
0.3176679909,
0.6764284968,
0.3980448842,
0.3204579949,
0.4318851531,
-0.4953405261,
-0.1875418276,
-0.0895132422,
-0.3771348298,
0.5128079653,
0.3658695221,
-0.1458874792,
-0.0597027205,
-0.025218036,
0.1845576614,
0.279586792,
-0.2083283067,
0.8831715584,
0.0921884254,
-0.6583165526,
0.303732574,
-0.3299573064,
0.1156792417,
-0.5588139892,
-0.0506531559,
-0.2344197631,
0.3300823867,
-0.0468482971,
-0.9183646441,
0.1806689501,
-0.3844743073,
0.0513744317,
-0.1910123825,
0.8030253053,
-0.4637595713,
-0.3259216249,
0.7592877746,
1.0572913885,
0.3452009857,
0.0671009645,
-0.2403755784,
0.2673400044,
-0.6887813807,
-0.3715352714,
0.28836447,
0.7546454072,
0.0866054073,
0.5214805603,
0.5014945269,
0.1826831549,
-0.0078702709,
0.3431807756,
1.0804293156,
-0.8203458786,
-0.1812299639,
-1.1681205034,
0.292386502,
0.0744655728,
-0.1305907518,
0.8479585648,
0.5761501193,
0.7433255315,
0.1740123779,
0.5136709213,
0.0443243198,
0.3504426181,
-0.66415447,
0.4705862403,
-0.6390824318,
0.3577874601,
-0.3466064036,
-0.9831306338,
-0.1805634052,
0.2551374733,
-0.2307112664,
0.0771081969,
0.8792419434,
0.7192704082,
0.0469046682,
-0.1308940649,
0.5282188654,
0.3020914793,
0.2502681017,
0.3606666028,
1.4089133739,
-0.2360976487,
0.1684372574,
0.1326757818,
-0.3035317659,
-0.0654532909,
-0.778456986,
-0.8983717561,
-0.8004103303,
0.0051477631,
-0.6333534122,
0.330071032,
1.1463466883,
0.1893563718,
-0.2113628089,
-0.2920494974,
-0.107744202,
0.0008258553,
0.0209749993,
-0.2206220031,
0.3395530283,
-0.4250202775,
-0.7847832441,
0.2911844254,
0.2411721498,
0.0144210812,
-0.4700746238,
-0.0928119346,
-0.3702441156,
0.2670009434,
0.715475142,
-0.1712719649,
-0.6531008482,
-0.4902813137,
0.3049744368,
-0.2903964221,
-0.2428309023,
0.8609252572,
-0.4488613904,
0.3445286155,
0.3167605996,
0.5867027044,
0.2626989484,
-0.1956555247,
0.6419630647,
-0.4626588523,
0.1943918169,
0.1820099503,
0.5173912048,
0.2141053528,
-0.2230361849,
0.7365424037,
0.2398289442,
-0.7051008344,
-0.8459162116,
0.2778175771,
-1.0675110817,
-0.3796491325,
1.3800721169,
0.244129315,
-0.380099982,
0.039929945,
-0.2117350847,
0.1352691352,
-0.1931355149,
0.2894600332,
1.106139183,
-0.0374072865,
-0.0758379921,
-0.8349226117,
0.4548104107,
0.60372293,
-0.5574183464,
-0.0889068246,
0.6679298878,
0.0671628416,
0.0391488262,
0.8321174383,
0.1884800792,
0.3005588353,
-0.1708872169,
0.0798205137,
0.1257503033,
-0.3064340055,
-0.4406603575,
-0.2233266085,
0.4777716398,
-0.2418271601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18176v1 | Perceived Trustworthiness of Natural Language Generators | 2023-05-29T16:09:58 | 2023-05-29T16:09:58 | Beatriz Cabrero-Daniel, Andrea Sanagustín Cabrero | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Natural Language Generation tools, such as chatbots that can generate
human-like conversational text, are becoming more common both for personal and
professional use. However, there are concerns about their trustworthiness and
ethical implications. The paper addresses the problem of understanding how
different users (e.g., linguists, engineers) perceive and adopt these tools and
their perception of machine-generated text quality. It also discusses the
perceived advantages and limitations of Natural Language Generation tools, as
well as users' beliefs on governance strategies. The main findings of this
study include the impact of users' field and level of expertise on the
perceived trust and adoption of Natural Language Generation tools, the users'
assessment of the accuracy, fluency, and potential biases of machine-generated
text in comparison to human-written text, and an analysis of the advantages and
ethical risks associated with these tools as identified by the participants.
Moreover, this paper discusses the potential implications of these findings for
enhancing the AI development process. The paper sheds light on how different
user characteristics shape their beliefs on the quality and overall
trustworthiness of machine-generated text. Furthermore, it examines the
benefits and risks of these tools from the perspectives of different users. | [
-0.5732386708,
-0.5915359855,
0.4715747535,
-0.0111717433,
-0.1028066352,
0.3949617147,
-0.005499376,
-0.7869786024,
-0.2749772668,
0.4787597656,
-0.2094086707,
-0.0912314132,
-0.5603303313,
0.5988181829,
-0.3539855778,
1.0138968229,
0.0879818499,
-0.2969048023,
-0.2917919159,
0.2435393631,
-0.3642721772,
-0.6281346083,
-0.7956652641,
-0.4402882457,
0.303152144,
0.1609212756,
1.3270591497,
0.383086741,
0.355733037,
0.3232682943,
0.0331824608,
-0.0827131346,
-0.3457040787,
0.3208681047,
-0.1146128848,
-0.4651152194,
-0.1169607118,
0.3183858395,
0.2312820554,
0.2696875632,
-0.0348966122,
0.3325967789,
0.3295535445,
0.6077038646,
-0.3852442503,
-0.0589238666,
-0.6482579112,
0.1717246771,
-0.1112935171,
-0.2897093594,
-0.3182708621,
-0.6591976285,
0.4527472556,
-0.7922326326,
0.2099475712,
0.2080522031,
0.8786144853,
0.248683989,
-0.4399448633,
-0.789565444,
-0.7503967881,
0.7341833115,
-0.7289315462,
0.1413092464,
0.5318343043,
0.3463515341,
-0.3217138052,
-0.6174806356,
-0.8545850515,
-0.244307667,
-0.3069612086,
0.1711939275,
-0.0653243959,
0.1477075666,
0.4405907691,
0.5136018991,
-0.3775289059,
0.3220395148,
-0.3450020552,
-0.427013725,
0.8113779426,
0.020852793,
0.6556842327,
-0.6287544966,
-0.1338897496,
-0.1330536902,
-0.6268525124,
0.1333732754,
1.2835681438,
-0.019001456,
-0.0429405496,
0.5589604974,
0.0183619373,
0.399466157,
-0.095553264,
-0.0103277387,
0.2224790156,
-0.5092563629,
-0.3939734995,
0.1113328114,
1.0548801422,
0.2889499962,
1.0055766106,
-0.0065420773,
-0.0780908167,
0.0208595116,
0.714471519,
-0.5638361573,
-0.1082024574,
0.2983345985,
-0.5345224738,
-0.8590134382,
0.4073056579,
-0.6788198948,
-0.4703396261,
-0.4085862339,
0.2618400455,
-0.4957309067,
-0.2454521209,
-0.3151427209,
-0.3695622087,
0.0723464116,
0.2098857015,
-0.7948636413,
0.053204976,
0.4781845808,
0.4689289927,
-0.0658057034,
-0.1060932875,
-0.2670006156,
-0.0186453704,
-0.1894142181,
0.403297931,
-0.2369127274,
-0.9701794982,
0.0727445334,
-0.5703580976,
0.164285332,
-0.3531526923,
0.5490620136,
-0.0997470841,
0.7095047235,
-0.1799977869,
-0.2629375756,
0.1158604249,
0.0852283165,
-0.539429307,
1.0550743341,
0.0148178758,
-0.826135993,
0.7239857316,
-0.7379101515,
-0.668261528,
0.2246904075,
-0.432253927,
-0.2976112068,
0.1374771148,
0.0632137582,
0.451140672,
-0.1765285581,
0.4227237403,
0.1260424852,
0.0702740178,
0.6880635023,
-0.656770587,
1.0410945415,
0.6516427994,
-0.4548560977,
-0.1548074782,
-0.587521255,
0.2056687474,
-0.1975214034,
-0.3884445727,
-0.1089863628,
-0.0044674128,
0.1756410599,
0.3309279382,
0.2139729112,
-0.3648580909,
-0.4874147475,
-0.5668724775,
0.4657828808,
0.9154161215,
0.3228189349,
0.3806402087,
-0.4558376074,
0.577259481,
-0.1251467466,
0.2701857388,
-0.1018456295,
-0.8440791965,
-0.4515790939,
0.1472924948,
0.3114540875,
0.3376303017,
-0.5506334305,
0.6903430223,
0.0118918074,
-0.6768246293,
-0.7986530662,
0.3151019514,
0.4764799476,
0.5409830809,
-0.0330089331,
-0.1524261087,
-0.4664053917,
-1.1222425699,
-0.501178503,
-0.5149173141,
-0.3452227414,
0.5588100553,
0.5126468539,
-0.3339784741,
1.2146886587,
-0.1655928195,
0.214068383,
-0.1412857175,
0.6127557158,
-0.3916505277,
0.5952835679,
0.4554275274,
-1.0040954351,
-0.6348111629,
0.1272210181,
-0.7435655594,
-0.0258230045,
-0.342163384,
0.0006798675,
0.4446279109,
0.0425489955,
-0.6843804121,
0.5108810067,
0.6465093493,
-0.2936050296,
0.6780366302,
-0.1304958463,
0.3403266072,
-1.6099894047,
0.3169671893,
0.052080743,
-0.2567531765,
-0.7303043604,
0.1959841847,
-0.4035060704,
-0.1507315636,
-0.3872542083,
0.3978130817,
-0.2216265798,
-0.0713022724,
-0.0989632905,
0.2735120952,
0.0897724405,
-0.1433372498,
-0.2495665103,
1.2231775522,
0.3188016117,
-0.6505669951,
-0.0718539506,
0.4040136933,
-0.3578160703,
0.6431413293,
-0.8764991164,
0.2562071383,
0.1449202299,
-0.0625500828,
-0.6206132174,
-0.3717631996,
0.1967488825,
-1.0635198355,
0.041049026,
0.4156398177,
-0.7527626157,
-0.1675373763,
-0.211877808,
-0.1929060072,
0.8462489247,
-0.1389042586,
0.258949846,
0.5016887188,
-0.1089596078,
-0.497977227,
-0.9099887609,
0.4174257219,
-0.2386637777,
-0.7044311166,
0.1642267257,
-0.0744671151,
-0.6487065554,
-0.0322745778,
0.0674871355,
-0.00332886,
0.457138747,
0.5767198205,
-0.0053571914,
-0.0248135515,
0.059274897,
0.1089080051,
-0.1514936835,
0.2915143967,
0.1829354465,
0.3101427853,
-0.12051218,
-0.0768497735,
-0.510925293,
0.1974084973,
0.3250940442,
-0.1755633801,
0.6766451597,
0.6359136701,
-0.2913815379,
0.0702776313,
-0.5913270116,
-0.2511946261,
-0.53403157,
-0.1515481472,
0.2000926286,
-0.9976773858,
0.3863663375,
-0.0055586207,
0.26578632,
0.6239095926,
0.579680264,
-0.4364559054,
1.0467283726,
0.6602438092,
0.0879465789,
0.1778769791,
0.2836225927,
0.4320123196,
-0.5411798954,
-0.1094661132,
-0.9515495896,
-0.259676367,
-0.9515340924,
0.0294278152,
0.1237931848,
-0.0876318663,
-0.1707801521,
0.2737314701,
-0.6654107571,
0.2109444588,
0.8171319962,
-0.3338281214,
0.3892372251,
-0.0158669781,
-0.0634330511,
-0.0799949542,
-0.3777911365,
-1.3026248217,
0.9680780172,
0.2369328737,
0.4614265859,
-0.0609198026,
0.8946150541,
0.6943070889,
0.094072029,
-0.4156801105,
0.316267401,
0.2194029242,
-1.0342544317,
-0.4447270334,
-0.4448894858,
-0.8690066338,
-0.2847308218,
-0.5620618463,
-0.8109345436,
-0.1571978778,
0.3059527874,
-0.3268550932,
0.1167263016,
-1.0150483847,
0.6050140262,
-0.3014768362,
-0.0904936939,
-0.2027114481,
-0.8732105494,
0.125072971,
-0.2023159713,
0.1174304187,
0.0701276585,
0.1888636053,
0.6823936701,
-0.1297486126,
0.7118637562,
0.0147214746,
0.0231457185,
0.7274919748,
0.1104472429,
0.3018038869,
0.311350286,
-0.3486732841,
0.2475034744,
-0.125252068,
-0.0179680474,
-0.4464015663,
0.6533908844,
-0.9826403856,
-0.7864030004,
-0.3567346036,
-0.4494083524,
-0.1344016343,
0.5879464746,
0.5403901935,
0.1913669258,
-0.4341740608,
0.2923724055,
0.4732636213,
-0.584215045,
0.2992126048,
-0.2432738245,
-0.0371140055,
-0.2601708174,
0.652605176,
-0.085522905,
0.4512293041,
-0.0273481719,
0.3784084916,
-0.0343400687,
-0.4449853003,
-0.4955099523,
-0.170868367,
-0.3023953736,
0.0103126345,
-0.4504356682,
-0.3401850462,
-0.23296763,
-0.4680006206,
-0.0019380791,
-0.4396725893,
-0.5734344721,
-0.3486845493,
0.4042625129,
0.7812748551,
0.2338885069,
0.4494162202,
-0.6242241263,
0.2511439919,
0.2376134545,
0.1765231639,
-0.3665218651,
-0.0549550839,
-0.0313299112,
0.2913050652,
-0.486661464,
-0.5913176537,
0.2523292005,
-0.2204219103,
0.5628461838,
0.2821243703,
0.0111033469,
0.2694390714,
-0.1883712858,
1.2093276978,
0.1187983006,
-0.9776436687,
0.5128047466,
-0.3654708564,
0.1035111621,
0.7881762981,
0.4169622064,
-0.392242372,
-0.8108320236,
-0.9120670557,
-0.3683383167,
0.3972572088,
0.9579372406,
0.4220190346,
0.1125870049,
0.1409964412,
0.4640417099,
0.4367414713,
-0.5694476366,
-0.2129929215,
-0.5376461744,
-0.1766014546,
-0.0451576561,
-0.1268172115,
-0.0039353045,
0.2114442885,
0.5424593687,
0.0318215601,
0.2182863355,
0.2085922956,
0.1169880331,
-0.2260734886,
0.6821585894,
0.5485860705,
0.7728311419,
-0.0677660629,
-0.0596740395,
-0.1687062681,
-0.5549109578,
-0.1235530972,
-0.1212874725,
-0.4148968458,
-0.0760102645,
0.1355496943,
0.5021486878,
-0.0203146636,
-0.596432507,
0.1727727056,
0.0029261601,
-0.580515027,
-0.2996361852,
0.2774327099,
0.1980608553,
-0.2809972465,
0.2890764475,
0.6079410911,
0.1893025488,
-0.5594342351,
0.1509127468,
0.4465101957,
-0.4063669741,
-0.4241524935,
0.7971735001,
0.6220828295,
-0.8730229139,
0.5153201818,
-0.038797196,
-0.2573188543,
0.4245249331,
0.2584653497,
1.0056272745,
0.1002967432,
0.5151895881,
0.2082533389,
0.542311132,
0.1663829535,
0.1228337064,
0.1310129911,
-0.7999876738,
-0.0957659855,
-0.3319458961,
-0.5400639772,
0.0439203158,
-0.4892286956,
0.1133312657,
-0.5581748486,
-0.7102596164,
-0.2027149945,
0.0214856323,
-0.7334985733,
0.1509405077,
-0.0944120362,
0.6719504595,
-0.3396649957,
0.4984084666,
0.6457971931,
-0.4957364202,
-0.6563139558,
0.169432506,
-0.0150422724,
-0.715407908,
0.2718384564,
0.1249274462,
-0.1385716647,
-0.0638578981,
-0.4096032083,
-0.27078861,
1.0853539705,
0.2418352664,
-0.2345398068,
-0.0658053309,
0.4602868259,
0.8062556386,
-0.0849139392,
-0.0542685799,
0.2289543152,
0.5117262602,
-0.3771378398,
-1.122081399,
0.0019462825,
-0.1035912335,
0.0392212942,
0.1645528078,
-0.321485877,
0.5521634817,
-0.0605552569,
-0.4118914306,
-0.0635085702,
0.2746912539,
0.1661802679,
0.288890928,
0.2737655342,
0.1144590601,
0.7170798779,
0.1591333449,
1.1977027655,
-0.5308282971,
-0.0736851171,
0.5851219296,
-0.0133599062,
0.5367941856,
0.7114714384,
0.1208003983,
0.6133437157,
0.1023310125,
0.1050079688,
0.0121672703,
-0.01728791,
0.0335858576,
-0.0707997978,
-0.2439334691,
-0.3641949594,
0.4030015767,
0.2111363411,
-0.7111726403,
0.1239728853,
-0.3530882299,
0.1724302173,
0.5943153501,
0.1507822871,
0.719170928,
0.2709803581,
-0.7588153481,
-0.0726597384,
-0.0606972054,
0.6672875881,
-0.3350818157,
-0.005284809,
0.3174881935,
-0.3074764013,
-0.3710983396,
-1.1092866659,
0.3046373725,
0.4561678171,
0.0733785778,
-0.6074978113,
0.8735598922,
0.2434763312,
-0.4466767013,
-0.2969982028,
0.8469931483,
-0.0807320774,
0.0231368653,
-0.7354825735,
-0.2332030982,
0.079600133,
-0.2382187992,
0.1908496916,
0.3171875179,
0.1193285659,
0.7623460293,
0.8217960596,
0.0154463556,
-0.0749105439,
-0.1707932055,
0.4053227007,
-0.438206315,
-0.4212549329,
-0.8985421658,
0.6784984469,
-0.4017945826,
-0.8104423881,
1.0148057938,
0.4776276946,
0.8614631891,
0.0481198654,
1.1767246723,
-0.2385699004,
0.3610768616,
-0.3791866004,
1.1943323612,
-0.1225925758,
-0.0550272204,
-0.5088231564,
-0.6483709216,
-0.1714347154,
0.5205563307,
-0.0052356701,
0.3205808997,
0.5004379153,
0.549459815,
0.2677827775,
0.3011341989,
0.1475073844,
-0.1499533355,
0.6004056334,
-0.0144774029,
0.8776038289,
-0.2546249032,
0.6447188854,
-0.2363858372,
0.2029905915,
0.0971650779,
-0.9904587269,
-1.080542326,
-0.5601883531,
-0.0871896893,
-0.0943410993,
-0.2710575163,
0.8121114373,
0.3415587246,
-0.6434721351,
-0.2974864841,
-0.3593488932,
0.0971421674,
0.1563312113,
-0.3390880227,
-0.1533177048,
-0.1215814203,
-0.676306963,
-0.0516004972,
0.1092367694,
0.194971323,
-0.5459919572,
-0.3890284896,
0.0589267276,
0.1987436414,
0.5404213667,
0.2632094026,
-0.7415876389,
-0.5406490564,
0.0472309142,
-0.3023768663,
-0.0370933525,
0.7808719873,
-0.7122192979,
0.5475167036,
0.5291018486,
0.5446204543,
-0.1443609595,
0.2328597605,
1.1544998884,
-0.5056300163,
-0.2278242111,
0.22492598,
0.0095841074,
0.4550103843,
-0.609701395,
0.5377438664,
-0.0735478625,
-0.8109846115,
-0.8535447717,
0.2450437844,
-0.6378210187,
0.116897136,
1.0287166834,
0.2952870131,
0.1222023368,
-0.3498372138,
-0.6039128304,
0.3084056973,
-0.7774045467,
1.0369012356,
0.6060537696,
-0.0864369571,
0.143339321,
-0.7794777155,
0.9064005613,
0.0706103891,
-0.9859216213,
-0.03658548,
0.3771762848,
0.1050477028,
0.3140513301,
0.3893533945,
-0.1022648886,
0.2446146756,
0.0438971184,
-0.0229782537,
-0.3138056695,
0.0058318414,
0.1432173401,
-0.0483203419,
0.3935601115,
0.2596134543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18170v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18170v2 | Leveraging Training Data in Few-Shot Prompting for Numerical Reasoning | 2023-05-29T16:01:40 | 2023-06-09T05:00:30 | Zhanming Jie, Wei Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting with large language models has proven
effective in numerous natural language processing tasks, but designing prompts
that generalize well to diverse problem types can be challenging, especially in
the context of math word problem (MWP) solving. Additionally, it is common to
have a large amount of training data that have a better diversity coverage but
CoT annotations are not available, which limits the use of supervised learning
techniques. To address these issues, we investigate two approaches to leverage
the training data in a few-shot prompting scenario: dynamic program prompting
and program distillation. Our approach is largely inspired by Gao et al.,
(2022), where they proposed to replace the CoT with the programs as the
intermediate reasoning step. Such a prompting strategy allows us to accurately
verify the answer correctness through program execution in MWP solving. Our
dynamic program prompting involves annotating the training data by sampling
correct programs from a large language model, while program distillation
involves adapting a smaller model to the program-annotated training data. Our
experiments on three standard MWP datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of
these approaches, yielding significant improvements over previous baselines for
prompting and fine-tuning. Our results suggest that leveraging a large amount
of training data can improve the generalization ability of prompts and boost
the performance of fine-tuned small models in MWP solving. | [
-0.7277458906,
-1.021953702,
0.718400836,
0.2924930453,
-0.3522907495,
0.2407245636,
-0.2773354948,
-0.0541973226,
-0.2120725513,
0.2681028843,
-0.8304854035,
-0.3538957536,
-0.6236214638,
0.3195468187,
-0.0513677038,
0.9855486155,
-0.2024800777,
0.0028347904,
-0.0479997844,
-0.0861154944,
-0.8017163277,
-0.4916911423,
-0.6380959749,
-0.4671680629,
0.6918293238,
0.5071538687,
0.6055945158,
0.3533205986,
0.3962211311,
0.3114700615,
-0.0769733191,
0.5348011255,
-0.4990986586,
-0.0286569633,
-0.0361452587,
-0.6894794703,
0.0373280346,
0.0169856362,
0.456494689,
0.8766929507,
-0.0453827269,
0.2177065164,
0.1818903983,
0.8517796993,
-0.7623638511,
0.2563848197,
-0.8354918957,
0.3247168064,
0.000604936,
-0.3177660406,
-0.4423576891,
-0.4479663372,
0.1987972409,
-0.5775148273,
0.069285281,
-0.0522964299,
0.3802872002,
0.476464361,
-0.2342496663,
-0.3813499808,
-0.7654554248,
0.8113433719,
-0.5237594843,
-0.1708217561,
0.5855510235,
0.3010322154,
-0.4534992278,
-0.4248667955,
-0.6593270302,
-0.0925840139,
0.1679984331,
-0.0752694905,
-0.3423751593,
0.1636552364,
0.9734817743,
0.0703920797,
-0.2736435831,
-0.0706115514,
-0.3817943335,
0.0401834287,
0.4603866935,
0.2785857022,
0.0883875266,
0.1095722094,
-0.2112238407,
-0.2653935552,
-0.5712412,
0.144122839,
0.3263981342,
0.6548780203,
-0.2244590968,
0.5292441845,
-0.1053859666,
0.9787350297,
0.0725241378,
0.0192686338,
0.0800954923,
-0.1515816003,
-0.1854827702,
0.1522715092,
0.624301672,
-0.018034732,
0.7155876756,
0.3552308381,
-0.1316932887,
0.1961708814,
0.0999922305,
-0.6082734466,
-0.330650866,
0.0818706155,
0.003138138,
-0.4146675169,
-0.098433122,
-0.8737635016,
-0.360458523,
-0.6991318464,
0.287266016,
-0.3811549544,
0.0355396681,
0.0831474438,
-0.3585166037,
-0.2214457691,
0.2781614661,
-1.0547616482,
0.0799047649,
0.7132306099,
0.9736804962,
0.0695108324,
-0.1277469844,
-0.9112973213,
-0.1509454101,
-0.4997083247,
0.7677957416,
-0.7950440645,
-0.5009946823,
0.0029906367,
-0.5218117237,
0.014011492,
-0.6103153825,
0.1160677373,
-0.3051840067,
-0.1257546395,
-0.6858400106,
-0.2333688736,
0.0878740028,
0.5935686231,
-0.5962953568,
1.2269054651,
0.0916728005,
-0.8510335088,
0.3460018933,
-0.5405640006,
0.008933207,
-0.0072376905,
-0.5595403314,
-0.2099746913,
0.3654986918,
0.5606968999,
0.1408006102,
-0.1000415385,
0.2511389256,
-0.4240653813,
-0.3806879818,
0.2361963391,
-0.7460327148,
0.5322773457,
0.1831777841,
-0.1520461589,
-0.2975974381,
-0.7810521722,
0.2236840576,
0.0235127658,
-0.1865072101,
-0.4293120503,
-0.2299039662,
-0.6570328474,
0.2168686986,
-0.1447629929,
-0.2935961187,
0.7708278894,
-0.4238201082,
0.0501273088,
0.7769761682,
0.2939215302,
0.3884785771,
-0.1887008101,
0.8182423711,
0.0784934089,
-0.144863084,
-0.266777128,
-0.6288811564,
-0.3954416215,
-0.178727299,
0.2106185257,
0.5851585865,
-1.3335208893,
-0.0412431397,
0.087298207,
-0.1820223033,
-0.2327397913,
0.1476312578,
0.3253965676,
0.7615866065,
0.4231184125,
0.236666441,
-0.4908440113,
-0.3463742435,
-0.3068339825,
-0.1729301065,
-0.0206702575,
0.1748210043,
0.4401128888,
0.1443552375,
1.236954093,
-0.9548498988,
-0.0921238884,
-0.3023349643,
0.835940361,
0.4502566457,
0.4198056757,
0.5364642143,
-0.4457564056,
-0.6274145842,
-0.2267082334,
-0.7080262303,
-0.2926154733,
-0.2896059752,
-0.1819418669,
-0.190589726,
0.38937518,
-0.2871807814,
0.7017591596,
0.4139403105,
0.077603735,
0.7246294022,
-0.222494781,
0.0675516501,
-0.6152805686,
0.0032893047,
-0.0651094541,
-0.0423231795,
-0.4710006416,
-0.2594754398,
-0.2784199119,
-0.3308455348,
-0.5793752074,
0.3750246465,
-0.4045853019,
0.2577197254,
-0.4825925529,
0.1304819882,
-0.0721831694,
0.5258159637,
0.0041518975,
0.8463910222,
0.5271016359,
-0.7283625007,
0.5780017376,
0.1963995546,
-0.2339762151,
0.3875049055,
-0.6435024738,
0.4157907963,
-0.4392323196,
0.4658991694,
-1.0445804596,
0.0693886206,
0.0804095939,
-0.291880548,
0.0670944229,
-0.5000880361,
-0.5003737211,
-0.7014242411,
-0.4249017835,
0.5955162048,
0.4201792181,
-0.7008492351,
0.2561690509,
-0.1379808038,
-0.1574543118,
-0.6132089496,
-0.7388256788,
-0.1909079701,
-0.1880240738,
-0.2359059602,
0.1176597029,
0.0230252184,
-0.2964965999,
-0.2305971682,
-0.1523369104,
-0.1036219597,
-0.1073474661,
0.0767876059,
0.577409029,
0.0294359252,
0.2824594676,
0.2302667946,
-0.5142781734,
0.1570542306,
-0.3701067567,
0.6656984091,
-0.0598821528,
-0.3792330325,
-0.3184443414,
0.2372273952,
0.1705253422,
-0.1172059178,
0.6571458578,
0.4797823727,
-0.4423875511,
-0.4042104185,
-0.2599049509,
-0.4263333976,
-0.5399938226,
-0.1100347862,
-0.5367977023,
-0.6399597526,
0.3435917199,
-0.5169622302,
0.2210137397,
0.0126912119,
0.5508110523,
-0.08444269,
1.3838124275,
0.4303259552,
-0.1279880255,
0.6744455695,
-0.6005764604,
0.2448278368,
-0.7007396221,
-0.0919208303,
-0.5365561247,
-0.580918014,
-0.3193761706,
-0.4285906851,
0.6087450981,
0.1544640809,
0.0008444137,
0.1413095593,
-0.6676231027,
0.8602846861,
0.2791721821,
0.1079834178,
0.1497469097,
0.1661876887,
-0.6823738217,
-0.1387061626,
-0.8223780394,
-0.4207318127,
0.8290754557,
0.0427590534,
0.9500700831,
-0.2505374551,
0.8486427069,
-0.0213182513,
0.020535836,
-1.0322362185,
0.5241817832,
-0.1327791512,
-0.4847851992,
-0.3262959123,
-0.5267379284,
-0.9487358928,
0.2373893857,
-0.3948505223,
-0.9023976922,
0.1475633681,
0.5118646622,
-0.8097733259,
0.2060331851,
-0.5603871942,
0.4898865521,
-0.1474182755,
-0.3408936262,
-0.2295647115,
-0.4075256884,
0.2881259024,
-0.0670052245,
0.1864045709,
-0.2205678225,
0.1393517852,
0.4229619801,
-0.8526828885,
0.9152661562,
-0.3747371435,
-0.1118015945,
0.7341963053,
0.1706321985,
0.8137164116,
0.06125113,
-0.1461921185,
-0.2036090642,
0.1483956575,
-0.3286806643,
-0.996131897,
0.5679312348,
-0.4718528688,
-0.4421210885,
-0.5866526365,
-0.4433171451,
-0.5717968941,
-0.0030126034,
0.3789194524,
0.6037929654,
0.3025080562,
-0.0688244477,
0.6172719598,
-0.0448852852,
0.5364821553,
0.0423590206,
-0.2264420986,
-0.3173216879,
0.7812834978,
0.1641254276,
0.3502086699,
0.1254741848,
0.6304558516,
-0.2615692019,
-0.2495614439,
-0.5016554594,
0.1212339327,
-0.7242593765,
-0.2576276064,
-0.3248315454,
0.0362062789,
-0.0248140916,
-0.3668710291,
-0.1847002208,
-0.3387363255,
-0.3479000926,
-0.0797097012,
0.6400282383,
0.4837619662,
0.0760980546,
0.3776893616,
-0.9972224832,
0.5429700613,
0.3933564126,
0.1969914734,
0.2340633571,
-0.3235461414,
-0.0274497047,
0.3613464534,
-0.3772402704,
-0.7954192758,
0.2259882092,
0.0366072208,
0.3545060754,
0.3403424621,
0.2862070799,
1.1585072279,
-0.5653748512,
0.8241524696,
0.4344668388,
-0.8788734674,
0.8396524191,
-0.1764142513,
0.7995118499,
1.0653882027,
0.5372904539,
-0.3718932271,
-0.2075529844,
-0.3920405507,
-0.5090391636,
0.6924334764,
0.0515937172,
0.2341028601,
-0.2230147272,
0.3524534106,
0.0644435212,
0.1656152904,
-0.1287650615,
0.0199482013,
0.1226416156,
-0.353517592,
0.4610137343,
0.1893037111,
-0.1258154213,
-0.4460116923,
0.3818936348,
-0.5680555105,
0.0618395321,
0.0606515594,
0.1199856102,
0.0216003247,
0.1273520887,
0.3879488409,
0.6888267398,
0.2045898885,
0.2514832616,
0.6196103692,
-0.5546252728,
0.1814872622,
-0.4065032899,
0.0192053933,
0.104803808,
0.3463479578,
0.7505434752,
0.2030560821,
-0.6421246529,
0.3690860569,
0.0450051352,
-0.2513265312,
0.0099481847,
0.2277782708,
-0.2375866473,
0.0719148815,
0.3793571889,
-0.0091342703,
0.0238081608,
-0.6124029756,
0.0516297854,
0.3648201525,
-0.2454522699,
-0.1661381125,
0.3495638669,
0.0975034609,
-0.1526745558,
0.997961998,
-0.1663565636,
-0.5788329244,
0.64528054,
0.5605232716,
0.6308364868,
0.2426625788,
0.216444999,
0.5587581396,
-0.1425527334,
-0.3307638764,
0.478561759,
-0.366165787,
-0.5592355728,
-0.5567970872,
-0.2259933054,
-0.5551239848,
-0.0457567424,
-0.6686685085,
0.677421689,
-0.8420509696,
-0.4784519076,
0.1090610623,
-0.0199466441,
-0.7007548213,
0.1011380404,
0.4260755479,
0.901822269,
-0.8653941751,
0.7116595507,
0.5550996065,
-0.3778072596,
-1.1236572266,
-0.0950726047,
0.3333032131,
-0.8357910514,
0.6446173787,
0.0994197652,
-0.3910803497,
-0.0742844343,
-0.8588024378,
-0.4978969991,
0.7971326113,
0.3091159165,
-0.8807079196,
-0.0368795469,
0.1786682159,
0.4745925665,
-0.2234230489,
0.1338281035,
0.7060552239,
0.421977073,
0.7284359932,
-0.6720633507,
-0.1122198924,
-0.0205684938,
0.0664768443,
0.4082868695,
-0.3101295829,
0.6695229411,
-0.5296762586,
-0.0071762726,
-0.2014627755,
0.4824191034,
0.883210659,
0.555351913,
0.6096200943,
0.3041368723,
0.9986363649,
-0.114763096,
0.7999563217,
-0.013285459,
0.2706348002,
1.1610072851,
-0.2652486265,
0.7972465754,
0.6748242974,
-0.4946257174,
0.5339382291,
0.4141723812,
-0.0034060301,
0.4619763792,
0.3977092803,
-0.4764390886,
-0.1325326413,
-0.0016954676,
-0.3089240491,
0.2909444571,
0.3692071438,
-0.0209283866,
-0.4492813349,
0.1635272056,
0.0407530852,
0.0715885311,
-0.2740291357,
0.7800389528,
0.4387981296,
-0.8261522651,
0.858127892,
-0.2729673684,
0.534286499,
-0.7138158083,
-0.3191811442,
-0.0276795272,
0.0678329542,
-0.3366773129,
-0.7793974876,
0.3563573956,
0.4869103134,
-0.0811604336,
-0.2017353177,
0.4673696756,
-0.4629240334,
-0.6227327585,
-0.2783867121,
0.2958268821,
0.19302921,
-0.1484405249,
-0.7230405211,
0.19689928,
-0.1715065241,
0.1400555372,
0.2054683119,
0.7572062016,
-0.2506724298,
0.6513046026,
0.9209671617,
0.2120530754,
0.0216217358,
0.4795863032,
1.1088527441,
-0.5134798288,
-0.5544372797,
-1.2658243179,
0.377220422,
-0.0014145559,
-0.3909594715,
0.4842275977,
0.2808172107,
0.4269039333,
-0.0792289451,
0.786008358,
0.1464003175,
0.093438521,
-0.5974349976,
0.0694135502,
-0.1263158023,
0.3889932334,
-0.3937202096,
-0.8744303584,
-0.3415749967,
0.6986011863,
-0.5071045756,
0.0200855732,
0.8164528012,
0.5006476641,
0.083203122,
0.2100598514,
0.1075417474,
-0.2534113526,
0.4121310413,
0.7097913623,
0.9028675556,
-0.0722551048,
0.4119740427,
-0.216042459,
-0.4754928052,
-0.1735311896,
-1.1800220013,
-1.0032128096,
-0.2206335664,
-0.395100981,
-0.2486987859,
-0.2481772155,
1.4818493128,
0.4821266532,
-0.7626781464,
0.1560511291,
-0.3583149314,
0.1109552979,
-0.2914471626,
-0.1678612083,
0.0367774442,
-0.614643991,
-0.628942728,
0.2780788839,
0.2197407931,
0.3388711512,
-0.1529040039,
0.2343439758,
-0.0260276627,
0.2387268394,
0.7191593647,
0.319439441,
-0.415386945,
-0.1201678738,
-0.016832009,
0.0706346557,
-0.0855495334,
1.2133966684,
-1.1926100254,
0.6966739893,
0.7860956192,
0.6094714999,
0.6712654233,
0.3337757885,
0.6452434063,
-0.952142477,
0.4187043309,
0.2949979603,
0.1089610457,
0.0321217701,
-0.3635225892,
0.3583160937,
0.1544499993,
-0.1813041568,
-0.8324187994,
0.2172961533,
-0.734750092,
-0.2088469714,
1.0188237429,
-0.1190488413,
-0.1157008484,
-0.1068788394,
-0.6413549781,
0.0706793889,
-0.360239327,
0.7697000504,
1.0396776199,
-0.376362592,
-0.0868354589,
-0.4255344868,
0.4659329355,
0.2617601156,
-0.6986433268,
0.1229729205,
0.3219750524,
-0.0991277695,
-0.029297417,
0.5612823963,
0.003636613,
0.1934826225,
0.1712927371,
-0.5703362226,
-0.2615526617,
-0.4938754737,
-0.4960183203,
-0.020466011,
0.0332381539,
-0.355341047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18169v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18169v3 | LM-CPPF: Paraphrasing-Guided Data Augmentation for Contrastive Prompt-Based Few-Shot Fine-Tuning | 2023-05-29T15:59:51 | 2023-07-05T09:15:55 | Amirhossein Abaskohi, Sascha Rothe, Yadollah Yaghoobzadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, there has been significant progress in developing
pre-trained language models for NLP. However, these models often struggle when
fine-tuned on small datasets. To address this issue, researchers have proposed
various adaptation approaches. Prompt-based tuning is arguably the most common
way, especially for larger models. Previous research shows that adding
contrastive learning to prompt-based fine-tuning is effective as it helps the
model generate embeddings that are more distinguishable between classes, and it
can also be more sample-efficient as the model learns from positive and
negative examples simultaneously. One of the most important components of
contrastive learning is data augmentation, but unlike computer vision,
effective data augmentation for NLP is still challenging. This paper proposes
LM-CPPF, Contrastive Paraphrasing-guided Prompt-based Fine-tuning of Language
Models, which leverages prompt-based few-shot paraphrasing using generative
language models, especially large language models such as GPT-3 and OPT-175B,
for data augmentation. Our experiments on multiple text classification
benchmarks show that this augmentation method outperforms other methods, such
as easy data augmentation, back translation, and multiple templates. | [
-0.4609302878,
-0.6158949733,
0.4566332102,
0.2819296122,
-0.4593063891,
-0.2126951814,
-0.2159548402,
-0.1222625077,
-0.4830619097,
0.5659332275,
-0.6128379107,
-0.4796708524,
-0.4117625952,
0.5238192081,
-0.1639537215,
1.0239465237,
0.2304925919,
0.1855216622,
0.0284330212,
-0.1597266495,
-0.4858896434,
-0.3693014383,
-0.7328194976,
-0.2820829749,
0.5361363888,
0.5753856897,
0.8851406574,
0.6467417479,
0.4701015651,
0.2251451761,
-0.1862951368,
0.4363080263,
-0.484354645,
-0.1277298331,
-0.3934660554,
-0.3796037436,
-0.1620338261,
-0.3407357335,
0.6565791965,
0.8394620419,
0.0296070948,
-0.3883558512,
0.6827824116,
0.7029221654,
-0.6100777388,
0.1531821638,
-0.7353722453,
-0.0190005451,
-0.0074209422,
-0.5399334431,
-0.2712789178,
-0.2305227667,
0.0390015207,
-0.7430655956,
0.5007711649,
0.3423122168,
0.6288259029,
0.2969077826,
-0.0991683826,
-0.2450100332,
-0.2874684632,
1.0732718706,
-0.8668291569,
0.1174770594,
0.4773246944,
0.1197033077,
-0.0963466987,
-0.6586303711,
-0.5332917571,
-0.2941273451,
-0.2336868942,
-0.0116998293,
0.0131578101,
0.3019129932,
0.4072013199,
0.4479546547,
-0.5225317478,
0.4092185497,
-0.1162936985,
-0.0838541985,
0.1469534934,
0.3248857558,
0.1842261553,
-0.2572821677,
-0.3049164414,
-0.0206181109,
-0.6896457672,
-0.2836675346,
0.2939264774,
0.7581239343,
-0.2480231375,
0.5219710469,
-0.4980412722,
1.2226206064,
0.1145539656,
-0.0971788466,
0.0916670337,
-0.5556704402,
-0.234543696,
-0.0845467597,
0.7045864463,
0.7270337343,
0.2331293225,
0.0241764318,
-0.192362994,
-0.1455007344,
-0.2726581395,
-0.8245804906,
-0.5521172285,
-0.0103136636,
-0.4872356951,
-0.3434484005,
-0.1967684925,
-1.0221756697,
-0.6332196593,
-0.506370306,
0.3316588402,
-0.6385992169,
0.2210226357,
0.2661005557,
-0.1079956442,
0.3842785954,
0.5194399953,
-1.0570935011,
0.2063338459,
0.7927613258,
0.9331318736,
-0.433172971,
-0.430193305,
-0.6753108501,
-0.0851119459,
-0.3740788698,
0.8881066442,
-0.7773315907,
-0.4878730774,
0.0660362169,
0.0401793532,
-0.045221433,
-0.6869681478,
0.8825240135,
-0.1450156868,
0.5479859114,
-0.3323917091,
-0.6840788126,
0.016400408,
0.3588762581,
-0.3526474237,
0.9484461546,
0.1916348636,
-0.7956793308,
0.1985083371,
-0.3206546903,
-0.1485825181,
0.163988173,
-0.0939135253,
-0.4019424617,
0.1110361665,
0.7338341475,
0.6441880465,
-0.4691011608,
0.1157145798,
-0.2911546826,
-0.4263237119,
0.0220451858,
-0.5113140941,
0.613275528,
0.1873786896,
0.1103666723,
0.1388565302,
-0.9460133314,
-0.1558555961,
-0.0689907372,
-0.3231954575,
-0.1957493126,
-0.1852247119,
0.0502549261,
0.2683721781,
0.0897754133,
-0.2601284981,
0.0993021503,
-0.7182461619,
0.0965509787,
0.6022151113,
0.3037803173,
0.632510066,
-0.6299386621,
0.4773477018,
-0.0488770008,
-0.0655551478,
-0.7245886922,
-0.3857626319,
-0.7219102979,
-0.1140380427,
0.2916727662,
0.6596964598,
-1.0906206369,
0.4900069833,
-0.099321112,
-0.3617556095,
-0.4738223851,
0.4053052962,
0.2574307919,
1.1838717461,
0.7773456573,
0.1667901427,
-0.3631669283,
-0.8205385804,
-0.3038624227,
0.1264395863,
-0.4510649443,
0.2420642674,
0.0006745722,
0.201238662,
0.5671756268,
-0.5776312351,
-0.2432584167,
-0.3585041165,
0.0976593122,
0.4070986509,
0.6960405707,
0.5203220248,
-0.6280158162,
-0.65934062,
-0.1529778987,
-0.4396417439,
-0.3871716261,
-0.4206777215,
0.0186002459,
-0.2531749308,
0.5556918979,
-0.2591496706,
-0.1607099921,
0.4001803398,
-0.1594429314,
0.4803818464,
-0.2832925022,
0.2429504395,
-0.9805012941,
-0.1561852843,
0.061240714,
-0.2707477212,
-0.6690379381,
0.0401835442,
0.213308543,
-0.2925721407,
-0.6187813282,
0.5604516268,
-0.2631371319,
0.2770508528,
-0.6200648546,
0.217989862,
0.0845671818,
0.5304472446,
0.2016747892,
0.6770099998,
0.900916636,
-0.9390922189,
0.2084025443,
0.2319626212,
-0.4025718868,
0.783449173,
-0.5552716255,
0.0674984306,
-0.2416705042,
0.1563901305,
-0.9068869352,
-0.0850642547,
0.5018540025,
-0.1308586746,
0.1863118261,
-0.124499388,
-0.5354602337,
0.0731549039,
-0.3993015885,
0.2118942142,
0.5412886143,
-0.8558546901,
0.2655357718,
-0.2795198858,
-0.5114949942,
-0.3609995246,
-0.5374891758,
0.0906053483,
-0.3608830571,
-0.1666317582,
0.7092178464,
-0.1929869801,
0.0268213805,
-0.3708692789,
0.1069820076,
0.112000145,
-0.0450426489,
-0.1789459437,
0.226544559,
-0.2137206048,
0.1560515016,
0.0632301867,
-0.1904878914,
-0.3457838297,
0.0201622192,
0.5792588592,
0.1193220094,
-0.207874909,
-0.4266809523,
0.2554963529,
0.0607242063,
0.0397839397,
0.5769792199,
0.6570020318,
-0.2992371023,
-0.2019607723,
-0.3184553087,
-0.282982558,
-0.4953831434,
0.3243144751,
-0.3126504123,
-0.7628312707,
0.2186120003,
-0.304907769,
0.0136210099,
0.4435885251,
0.4603827894,
-0.1392251402,
1.0591065884,
0.5757626295,
-0.0105057592,
0.6985920668,
0.1060740203,
-0.1635203958,
-0.6546099782,
0.0296663269,
-0.7537184954,
-0.242419824,
-0.6280124187,
-0.4802393913,
0.0837748349,
0.4570058286,
-0.067784518,
0.1856903285,
-0.4983680546,
0.5426971912,
0.4011358619,
0.3804758489,
0.2035819441,
0.0039524785,
-0.05074016,
-0.2356204391,
-0.7938703895,
-0.3651309013,
0.905123055,
0.1316526085,
0.692262888,
-0.2038942426,
0.5711998343,
0.0739280358,
-0.059988752,
-0.6505477428,
0.5263016224,
-0.4113427401,
-0.0693435743,
-0.0599164031,
-0.2126322538,
-0.6485348344,
0.2936422825,
-0.4189919829,
-0.4466768801,
0.4932973683,
0.464238286,
-0.5124893188,
0.0070244372,
-0.523845315,
0.7390756607,
-0.0014705161,
-0.4183713198,
-0.0883696973,
-0.6449750066,
0.196091935,
-0.2026331425,
-0.0351163819,
-0.1961460114,
-0.2602166533,
0.5998936892,
-0.4600529671,
0.8597322702,
-0.3172436953,
-0.0106297843,
0.0393042304,
-0.1818248481,
0.8181411028,
0.0196627006,
-0.3520638049,
-0.1800571233,
-0.1241769418,
-0.5838568211,
-0.6616463065,
0.7728753686,
-0.2493144125,
-0.493999213,
-0.1550003886,
-0.5007666349,
-0.5363123417,
0.0637233332,
0.356262356,
0.3020426333,
-0.0000473319,
0.391746372,
0.6289991736,
-0.5858464837,
0.536126256,
0.5459125042,
-0.1681054831,
-0.3932752311,
1.0649996996,
-0.4245516956,
0.2450377643,
0.7611789107,
0.4365021288,
-0.2731813192,
-0.785546124,
-0.2323214263,
0.1019725949,
-0.7875647545,
-0.3365860283,
-0.6230916381,
0.0990125835,
-0.280341953,
-0.5212814808,
-0.0152456211,
-0.4727712274,
-0.7419239879,
0.0312969796,
0.3248859048,
-0.0538886301,
0.0013961071,
0.7665447593,
-0.7482096553,
0.7453180552,
0.2859839499,
0.0378287025,
-0.2882490754,
-0.7858630419,
0.0327438079,
-0.0711004511,
-0.3051324487,
-0.7914344072,
0.4949951172,
0.5223494768,
0.3994954526,
0.3182854652,
0.1533564925,
0.7490250468,
-0.4057427049,
0.947745204,
0.2718270719,
-0.7407846451,
0.607580483,
-0.4029245079,
0.6014544368,
0.7827814221,
0.3044541776,
-0.3229633272,
-0.1882717758,
-0.372307837,
-0.7045605183,
0.6448694468,
-0.0442882366,
0.2618442774,
-0.1043845266,
0.3357309699,
0.3231344521,
0.1638281345,
-0.6961786747,
-0.1707189083,
-0.1810892224,
-0.41231668,
-0.3710142076,
-0.2250919938,
0.0775641426,
-0.2402779311,
0.5841116309,
-0.4337936044,
-0.0908785388,
0.0235483684,
-0.1006321013,
0.1443508416,
0.5584471822,
0.5782952905,
0.5245795846,
-0.1479422748,
0.1533852816,
0.5175068974,
0.0040131565,
-0.0973857045,
0.4021652341,
-0.2088376135,
0.105698742,
0.3222366273,
0.9999614358,
0.4592138827,
-0.6107689142,
0.4341934919,
0.2862788439,
-0.0389455482,
0.3812530339,
0.126952216,
-0.134178564,
0.06787166,
0.2504507601,
0.0664994195,
0.2330621034,
-0.1828609109,
0.1860637367,
0.2138997167,
-0.3405771255,
-0.0118205501,
0.4515743256,
0.2229294181,
-0.2280626297,
0.4332088828,
-0.014303416,
-0.2681132555,
0.3982275426,
0.721014142,
0.6728618145,
-0.3198156357,
0.1312992871,
0.4628435671,
0.134054482,
-0.3029142916,
0.2649384737,
-0.2820426226,
-0.6040638089,
-0.2704732716,
-0.7226725817,
-0.517814219,
0.2615690231,
-0.5565874577,
0.6810916066,
-0.4604635239,
0.2775031328,
0.017227428,
-0.2004633993,
-0.7515863776,
0.4004836679,
-0.0987595171,
0.9116346836,
-0.8391644359,
0.8396407962,
0.3909851909,
-0.194552049,
-0.415148139,
0.1769337952,
-0.234400332,
-0.8881676197,
0.3177009821,
0.13896662,
0.1221578419,
0.3085496128,
-0.4490469396,
-0.3205153048,
0.8742896318,
0.4043594599,
-0.9886168242,
-0.1520982832,
0.1006173566,
0.5460252166,
-0.3176607788,
-0.0617353395,
0.4867836535,
0.3684951961,
0.0171476472,
-0.6254021525,
-0.0210426897,
0.1931213737,
0.0687136948,
-0.0470932685,
-0.2699763477,
0.7067806721,
-0.1189190447,
-0.0100023141,
0.2143064141,
0.5649964809,
0.3843494654,
0.2139591724,
0.5091274977,
0.3508240581,
0.5160392523,
0.0028872692,
1.0594944954,
-0.4681565464,
0.241302222,
1.3984758854,
-0.0555189177,
0.7990071774,
0.533516407,
-0.1952205747,
0.1217485517,
0.6394615173,
-0.2636357248,
0.8844975829,
0.0664961189,
-0.4016309977,
-0.2476950437,
-0.3224917948,
-0.3391313553,
0.1049011424,
0.5160417557,
-0.7734565735,
-0.5142725706,
0.2493596077,
-0.18922019,
0.1725086421,
-0.5885174274,
0.9465519786,
0.2609011829,
-0.7320406437,
0.7381079197,
0.1763732135,
0.9075236917,
-0.5031574965,
-0.1856607348,
-0.1969566643,
0.0069454992,
-0.254322648,
-0.7372354269,
0.0680079013,
0.0414884798,
0.0111768423,
-0.3900382817,
0.8424382806,
-0.5857809186,
-0.4397010505,
-0.0016758939,
0.4553905129,
-0.0610937662,
-0.1791677475,
-1.0972266197,
-0.0959892496,
0.1737094671,
0.0210639965,
0.3884210587,
0.2063196301,
0.3896044195,
0.4991936088,
0.5736637712,
0.1493096203,
-0.1720893383,
0.3107733428,
0.8759692311,
-0.5856981874,
-0.649990499,
-1.0668113232,
0.3655888438,
-0.0078475475,
-0.3222333193,
0.708678782,
0.4868088961,
0.6196844578,
-0.1821874231,
0.691937983,
0.3669557571,
0.7445674539,
-0.9355426431,
0.2112407088,
-0.3275040984,
0.3723759651,
-0.3973785043,
-1.0843052864,
-0.5088536143,
0.4423774183,
-0.1937109083,
0.0329997726,
0.6471315026,
1.0792851448,
-0.2016410232,
-0.0604442954,
0.603623271,
-0.0566751882,
0.0796895102,
0.475667417,
0.7109928727,
-0.3687824607,
0.6469919682,
-0.5570607781,
-0.0907088369,
-0.1936741918,
-1.0982838869,
-0.8033329844,
-0.4115351439,
-0.5301760435,
-0.0395513959,
0.1625429392,
0.833252728,
0.4082363546,
-0.9938852787,
0.2802075446,
-0.5720761418,
-0.0207306966,
-0.2148540616,
-0.2413412482,
0.4538168907,
-0.6205332279,
-0.9984890819,
0.6767057776,
0.2781649232,
0.2440737635,
0.0688153133,
-0.1278688163,
0.0011321157,
-0.0729302838,
0.4289186001,
0.3605613708,
-0.6704000831,
-0.0789028481,
-0.2271661013,
-0.0988485441,
0.1437449753,
0.8412970304,
-0.8640886545,
0.533416152,
0.5403903127,
0.79098773,
0.2051434666,
0.3205477297,
0.7155347466,
-0.9842927456,
0.1841801256,
0.2536393404,
0.4280792475,
0.6437956691,
-0.2349698842,
0.1645708084,
0.109221369,
-0.5401436687,
-0.7777827978,
0.1969940066,
-1.0008413792,
-0.361813575,
1.2303594351,
-0.124670662,
0.325712204,
-0.2005771101,
-0.7152478099,
0.088725321,
-0.2597942054,
0.5688968301,
0.6205290556,
-0.3165893555,
-0.5980083942,
-0.3102878034,
0.8775434494,
0.6635549068,
-0.8841682076,
0.1350052953,
0.4957457781,
0.1057311967,
-0.1522412002,
0.4887764156,
0.080490388,
0.2681387067,
-0.0614522696,
-0.4331833124,
-0.0847697034,
-0.0538287908,
-0.8501734138,
0.3749562502,
0.2693277597,
-0.2503474057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18156v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18156v1 | Exploring Effectiveness of GPT-3 in Grammatical Error Correction: A Study on Performance and Controllability in Prompt-Based Methods | 2023-05-29T15:31:29 | 2023-05-29T15:31:29 | Mengsay Loem, Masahiro Kaneko, Sho Takase, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large-scale pre-trained language models such as GPT-3 have shown remarkable
performance across various natural language processing tasks. However, applying
prompt-based methods with GPT-3 for Grammatical Error Correction (GEC) tasks
and their controllability remains underexplored. Controllability in GEC is
crucial for real-world applications, particularly in educational settings,
where the ability to tailor feedback according to learner levels and specific
error types can significantly enhance the learning process. This paper
investigates the performance and controllability of prompt-based methods with
GPT-3 for GEC tasks using zero-shot and few-shot setting. We explore the impact
of task instructions and examples on GPT-3's output, focusing on controlling
aspects such as minimal edits, fluency edits, and learner levels. Our findings
demonstrate that GPT-3 could effectively perform GEC tasks, outperforming
existing supervised and unsupervised approaches. We also showed that GPT-3
could achieve controllability when appropriate task instructions and examples
are given. | [
0.0309514645,
-1.2402188778,
0.7097155452,
0.2927327454,
0.0942531899,
-0.11125388,
-0.2745606899,
-0.2079213411,
-0.1391307116,
-0.1458580792,
-0.4078505337,
-0.6611857414,
-0.7397786379,
0.4102018476,
-0.0818605945,
0.9773281217,
-0.5098779202,
0.1409641355,
0.2332925498,
0.1099523455,
-0.7966327667,
-0.6891784668,
-0.8644220829,
-0.0748998672,
0.6522763968,
0.6759113073,
0.7956255078,
0.621720016,
0.4942288995,
0.2743266225,
-0.1265551001,
-0.1123721153,
-0.3799791038,
0.0411606282,
-0.1272816211,
-0.3993178606,
-0.6763738394,
0.1716803163,
0.7691756487,
0.3415265977,
-0.240752548,
-0.3367863595,
0.5673311353,
0.3831614256,
-0.8485321403,
0.3387416899,
-0.1641313136,
0.0280952714,
-0.4526423812,
-0.0033373872,
-0.4343858957,
-0.5010417104,
-0.3129180372,
-0.8678860664,
0.4389472604,
-0.2417623401,
0.6441609263,
0.1757237464,
-0.0378598385,
-0.3160406053,
-0.7358208299,
0.4942169189,
-0.8143826723,
-0.0252024569,
0.6178973913,
0.2741115391,
-0.1363071352,
-0.3080844879,
-0.5697287321,
-0.2118721306,
-0.0899714008,
0.3773201406,
-0.2016100734,
0.4048246443,
0.6451396346,
0.0744662136,
-0.6621480584,
0.2675634623,
-0.0374427289,
-0.2635960877,
0.0266516339,
-0.1252624243,
0.3361578286,
-0.1328311116,
0.1760383993,
0.1760789305,
-0.5088543296,
0.0901178569,
0.3772328198,
0.5815401673,
0.0661054254,
0.7767688632,
-0.4270976782,
0.876716733,
0.1272831112,
-0.1350366622,
-0.0722610652,
-0.2278821021,
-0.2660979927,
-0.1817756146,
0.5905014277,
0.3156476319,
0.1383993477,
-0.0503794067,
-0.3174991012,
0.2294243574,
0.0524795353,
-0.4224869013,
-0.0615259558,
-0.1707683951,
-0.0523732007,
-0.0228385963,
-0.0117161404,
-0.4676215649,
-0.1871542782,
-0.3491880894,
0.8724435568,
-0.4629781246,
0.114401482,
0.0510162301,
0.1249874309,
0.0824951082,
0.7096092105,
-0.9867730737,
0.534745872,
0.5366965532,
1.1755738258,
-0.2137095779,
-0.5855122805,
-0.9479702115,
0.0358944423,
-0.4009886086,
0.3566141427,
-0.3044457734,
-0.4107001424,
0.1269274354,
-0.0081125619,
-0.6084958911,
-0.2585847378,
0.3444421291,
-0.4403910935,
0.349555254,
-0.2688551843,
-0.5854556561,
-0.0603479967,
0.2901670039,
-0.7196560502,
0.933934927,
0.1907749176,
-0.5498791337,
0.277238518,
-0.753251791,
-0.4693636,
0.0462603681,
0.0066694338,
-0.2183284461,
-0.0600860566,
0.2800244987,
0.6049972773,
0.2067587078,
0.0929920897,
0.0777430385,
-0.8046218157,
-0.0881896913,
-0.5205890536,
0.4808824658,
-0.142921105,
-0.9244651794,
0.180067867,
-0.6078935266,
-0.0972544923,
-0.0185246877,
-0.1906922013,
0.0206986144,
-0.2942887843,
-0.3348896801,
0.1102320552,
-0.0923129618,
-0.5174642801,
0.2956448197,
0.1196727902,
0.212660417,
0.5856614709,
0.0474498346,
0.5234732628,
-0.2616244853,
0.9121358395,
-0.3996809125,
0.2425766587,
0.0616624989,
-0.4663716555,
-0.6785427332,
-0.0839428604,
0.1411333978,
0.9829154015,
-1.1843780279,
0.0162319988,
0.1829248518,
-0.5173304081,
-0.2598749697,
0.2313411087,
0.6728707552,
0.8131747246,
0.5853569508,
0.1631878316,
0.0292663462,
-0.6073254347,
-0.5094817877,
-0.1813003868,
-0.0413017236,
-0.0231319144,
0.4053651094,
0.1132174581,
0.8327709436,
-0.4999476373,
-0.2680025399,
-0.3965096772,
0.4440323114,
0.2782131433,
0.6987160444,
0.2910363078,
-0.2182120383,
-0.4881823063,
-0.0149182258,
-0.4710867703,
-0.3772362173,
-0.0790753216,
-0.0302353296,
0.5433775187,
0.2576594651,
-0.579863131,
0.491959393,
0.3272815943,
-0.3353361189,
0.7072868943,
-0.2946932316,
0.4299043119,
-0.5447263122,
0.0008942379,
0.0437546112,
-0.3137313724,
-0.7182250619,
-0.1843099147,
0.3491015136,
-0.0018981734,
-0.6101561785,
0.2198389173,
-0.2647877634,
0.2400503755,
-0.1322547197,
0.094330512,
-0.2504083812,
0.5956308246,
-0.0558579303,
1.0755163431,
0.4776696265,
-0.5430275202,
0.3208333254,
0.0573770627,
0.1158712953,
0.7881448865,
-0.5883563161,
0.2731055319,
-0.0995987281,
-0.0115790442,
-0.7378851771,
-0.4801166654,
0.6054429412,
-0.4476331472,
0.4329278171,
-0.1180501208,
-0.6065191627,
-0.2539095879,
-0.2015761137,
0.0547064319,
0.3609042764,
-0.3073072433,
0.3468747735,
-0.3961278498,
-0.5742809176,
-0.4494171143,
-0.624556601,
-0.1554901153,
0.0675718859,
-0.1387853771,
0.0702813119,
-0.0196738131,
-0.0898797065,
-0.14736332,
-0.1637500674,
0.0787303969,
0.0162171274,
0.173544541,
0.4030627012,
0.1046773717,
0.0036966619,
-0.0649001524,
-0.1226357818,
-0.244143188,
0.0085793156,
0.1765171736,
-0.3813738525,
-0.5418133736,
-0.6361125708,
0.318947494,
0.1848371625,
0.207225129,
0.4651614428,
0.3256292045,
-0.3259035647,
0.0078928685,
-0.6336863041,
0.061393626,
-0.3922611773,
0.1409424096,
-0.251732111,
-1.1017268896,
0.3929403722,
0.3620943129,
-0.2215676457,
0.4651919305,
0.2084251791,
-0.1550153643,
0.8706666231,
0.4339568317,
-0.0493849702,
0.5380918384,
0.0780590102,
-0.0523166843,
-0.4033102095,
-0.0715841502,
-0.7217479944,
-0.201107949,
-0.4559296668,
-0.3249053359,
0.2144653201,
0.4444362819,
-0.4223034978,
0.3351828754,
-0.2046073824,
0.7143485546,
0.8499006629,
0.1386610717,
0.4194756746,
-0.2687422931,
-0.1345024407,
-0.1738811284,
-0.7074109912,
-0.4857441485,
0.5783417225,
0.1112494469,
0.6975533366,
0.1200137809,
0.5397834778,
0.1897207052,
0.2493606508,
-0.7670739293,
0.4673281014,
-0.0366079807,
-0.42369169,
-0.5111783743,
-0.3743619919,
-0.3942441046,
0.1551729292,
0.0395805053,
-0.6734753847,
-0.122435987,
0.5034232736,
-0.5970356464,
0.332834065,
-1.0763696432,
1.0343306065,
0.0076405127,
-0.7014552951,
0.3153645396,
-0.8529613018,
-0.0062390189,
0.0116738332,
-0.0076875766,
0.0762486458,
-0.0941720083,
0.6016182303,
-0.4186546504,
0.911077857,
-0.6128687859,
-0.1938513517,
0.2723518908,
0.2312111706,
0.8958453536,
-0.0756596625,
0.1016039327,
-0.0360795595,
-0.2814462781,
-0.5056830645,
-0.7504717112,
0.6167848706,
-0.7277551293,
-0.6155741215,
-0.546482861,
-0.378341049,
-0.4477526844,
0.3814354241,
0.4340221584,
0.391574651,
-0.1411484331,
-0.1250516027,
0.3798173964,
0.1357631534,
0.8737722635,
0.5080602169,
-0.0927342623,
-0.4498045444,
0.7205087543,
0.5119639039,
0.3575516939,
0.3030615747,
-0.0849063918,
-0.1661896557,
-0.6799946427,
-0.4655534029,
0.1551516503,
-0.5846381783,
-0.2366014123,
-0.3974376619,
0.0576949455,
-0.3559074402,
-0.4904440939,
-0.1428551227,
-0.4709189236,
-0.547292769,
-0.3951956928,
0.2950900495,
0.9068202972,
-0.2580687106,
1.0127229691,
-0.5800631046,
0.2597573698,
0.4180380106,
0.6546042562,
-0.546903789,
-0.210211724,
-0.1685576886,
-0.1570981741,
-0.2036828697,
-1.0398982763,
0.071970202,
0.0124341091,
0.2384854406,
0.0262575187,
-0.4836399555,
0.693154037,
-0.530376792,
1.0221421719,
0.0053651775,
-1.3420956135,
0.8116036654,
-0.8059839606,
0.6018039584,
0.5857560039,
0.2719116807,
-0.5868076086,
-0.3709123731,
-0.6829771399,
-0.5245753527,
1.0356340408,
0.4179986715,
-0.2754981518,
-0.0362822078,
0.5260461569,
0.0911950171,
0.1471776664,
-0.6809558272,
0.0600198917,
-0.2842842042,
0.02421619,
-0.2837737501,
-0.3862662017,
-0.0835405141,
0.0049881376,
0.9794396162,
-0.2445818484,
0.0809590146,
0.3006815016,
-0.2312383205,
0.0114087518,
0.711748004,
0.838481307,
0.5246966481,
-0.2130648345,
0.1222763956,
0.2192800194,
-0.7169174552,
0.4423801899,
0.3231440485,
-0.3910196126,
0.0956692398,
0.4567997158,
0.7523326278,
0.0404639766,
-0.086392656,
0.6634272933,
0.0568238832,
-0.2544948459,
0.1602781117,
0.0619130209,
-0.4382588863,
-0.0149529241,
0.1551334113,
0.3623374403,
0.1005088612,
0.0433427356,
-0.1212395877,
0.0492519625,
-0.2768091857,
-0.3984986544,
0.6263312101,
0.092100367,
0.0060420255,
0.5262902975,
-0.44106704,
-0.2705564499,
0.4085548222,
0.8047690392,
0.7861620784,
-0.4822446406,
0.5263615251,
0.4129391909,
0.4203974605,
-0.4663873613,
0.3990164399,
0.0008062105,
-0.6709342599,
-0.8221999407,
0.0643366948,
-0.6776924729,
0.0852907076,
-0.8013311625,
0.0834421515,
-0.5838565826,
-0.2330090106,
-0.5432336926,
-0.2275026441,
-0.58385849,
0.2121801376,
-0.2097700238,
0.6941426396,
-1.0058658123,
0.4799231589,
0.6765041351,
-0.3036116958,
-1.2444976568,
-0.0707787499,
0.4674243927,
-0.4242506921,
0.3226593435,
0.1816196442,
-0.3640199006,
0.2366081178,
-0.515425086,
-0.6495815516,
1.0390216112,
0.4526228011,
-0.7097582221,
-0.0478174947,
-0.0170427691,
0.4583784044,
0.2233013362,
0.1019691825,
0.9420013428,
0.5687891245,
0.1896384805,
-1.0751848221,
-0.1300558299,
-0.3185139,
0.198684141,
0.0189592056,
-0.3345631361,
0.6255713701,
-0.1097527519,
-0.222349897,
0.0889315605,
0.4957695305,
0.2426527739,
0.1267336011,
0.2188257128,
0.5206314921,
0.8829861283,
-0.4181698561,
1.0225504637,
0.2517799139,
0.3436757922,
1.3102066517,
-0.3553253412,
0.734007597,
0.4128514826,
-0.1606648117,
0.0547391362,
0.403175056,
0.1842893213,
0.3807338178,
-0.010967982,
-0.3979141712,
0.1979244798,
0.0347545967,
-0.2564919591,
0.1670145392,
0.0790945664,
0.0565358251,
-0.1682451963,
0.307897985,
0.7266544104,
0.0783462673,
-0.6782913208,
0.7598709464,
-0.5076192617,
-0.7366961837,
0.4059576392,
-0.1394060552,
0.7383808494,
-0.5723918676,
-0.1815340072,
-0.3707940578,
0.1829952449,
-0.2214146256,
-0.7284289002,
0.1174826473,
0.448292017,
-0.1044581011,
-0.4148522913,
0.7248895764,
-0.3134163916,
-0.2421490103,
0.000633956,
0.5577214956,
-0.1255906224,
-0.2215012759,
-0.1756972373,
0.0157878678,
-0.130700931,
-0.1736283749,
-0.0236509573,
0.3306624889,
-0.0066702538,
0.2289647311,
0.2101172507,
0.3079616725,
0.1100356057,
0.2297966629,
0.6257733107,
-0.617100656,
-0.3719771504,
-0.8525460958,
0.4275381565,
0.108965382,
-0.3299728036,
0.9911937118,
0.4416431785,
1.0413367748,
-0.4697475433,
0.9493976831,
-0.1629536897,
0.5856335759,
-0.8274602294,
0.2704777122,
-0.0091590937,
-0.0199161116,
-0.4937222898,
-0.8717822433,
-0.9873390198,
0.460793525,
-0.4843143523,
0.2341828644,
1.018275857,
0.8866102099,
0.3426655829,
0.1805331409,
0.3380296528,
0.2187941968,
0.3053148389,
0.4079839885,
0.804294765,
-0.147211954,
0.2675130367,
-0.3839100897,
-0.5027633905,
-0.0617168956,
-0.8831254244,
-0.5932067037,
-0.1180302948,
-0.2829900682,
-0.3151905239,
0.488047868,
0.8700734973,
0.1964696497,
-0.7928813696,
0.0460528955,
-0.469198525,
-0.0891409144,
-0.577378571,
-0.2043393999,
0.3711879253,
-0.5803259611,
-0.8550344706,
0.5890827775,
0.2283664942,
0.5262377262,
0.3595085442,
-0.0168254152,
-0.0815253556,
-0.5427311063,
0.5307575464,
0.5257589221,
-0.5921526551,
-0.3717305958,
0.1451230645,
-0.1655016243,
-0.0835822448,
0.9601759315,
-0.6149250865,
0.4789806902,
0.4127668738,
0.4876965582,
0.1550129652,
0.2593964934,
0.6459787488,
-0.88599962,
-0.1221030056,
0.2224336416,
0.2997108698,
0.4259257913,
-0.4240612388,
0.7661785483,
0.4235788286,
-0.713866055,
-0.0999222696,
-0.1460833848,
-0.9674025774,
0.0925861299,
1.2909271717,
-0.2137791663,
0.1288621277,
0.019406287,
-0.7047360539,
0.478019923,
-0.5015957952,
0.3249391615,
1.1135294437,
-0.393645376,
-0.1492421478,
-0.874417901,
0.7264043689,
0.5464695692,
-0.9023304582,
-0.0014724165,
0.9640762806,
0.0860652849,
-0.0586165227,
0.7814209461,
-0.214118138,
0.5284181237,
-0.2557334006,
0.0249810796,
-0.1993689537,
-0.4329872131,
-0.9117518663,
0.2524292469,
0.1392578036,
-0.2896978557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18153v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18153v2 | Do Large Language Models Know What They Don't Know? | 2023-05-29T15:30:13 | 2023-05-30T15:14:06 | Zhangyue Yin, Qiushi Sun, Qipeng Guo, Jiawen Wu, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have a wealth of knowledge that allows them to
excel in various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. Current research
focuses on enhancing their performance within their existing knowledge. Despite
their vast knowledge, LLMs are still limited by the amount of information they
can accommodate and comprehend. Therefore, the ability to understand their own
limitations on the unknows, referred to as self-knowledge, is of paramount
importance. This study aims to evaluate LLMs' self-knowledge by assessing their
ability to identify unanswerable or unknowable questions. We introduce an
automated methodology to detect uncertainty in the responses of these models,
providing a novel measure of their self-knowledge. We further introduce a
unique dataset, SelfAware, consisting of unanswerable questions from five
diverse categories and their answerable counterparts. Our extensive analysis,
involving 20 LLMs including GPT-3, InstructGPT, and LLaMA, discovering an
intrinsic capacity for self-knowledge within these models. Moreover, we
demonstrate that in-context learning and instruction tuning can further enhance
this self-knowledge. Despite this promising insight, our findings also
highlight a considerable gap between the capabilities of these models and human
proficiency in recognizing the limits of their knowledge. | [
-0.4810116291,
-0.7081297636,
0.9285220504,
-0.0383391529,
0.1753074974,
0.2356037796,
-0.2077277303,
-0.3493845761,
-0.2506073117,
0.469255656,
-0.6299260855,
-0.2563018799,
-0.6659095883,
0.2523180842,
-0.4199800193,
0.6559664011,
-0.0225693863,
-0.1909938157,
-0.3765451014,
-0.0646711737,
-0.5174168348,
-0.2231822163,
-0.2298079133,
-0.4595253468,
0.1539125741,
0.4465874732,
0.2983026206,
0.5601581931,
0.2834563255,
0.3154547811,
-0.0623211674,
0.1751412302,
-0.2887459099,
0.0325759128,
-0.3731060922,
-0.4553416669,
-0.121260114,
-0.2512218356,
0.7274215221,
0.7453658581,
0.0557487831,
0.5113885999,
0.1554341018,
0.6139085293,
-0.6382930875,
0.0936158672,
-0.9448173046,
0.1241368055,
-0.0725976601,
-0.0536025763,
-0.1741445512,
0.0573229268,
0.1604076773,
-0.2675074339,
0.1019592732,
-0.0075461855,
0.5789522529,
0.691386342,
-0.4477719963,
-0.421505779,
-0.6775416732,
0.6166393757,
-0.8978763223,
0.1718905717,
0.6262021661,
0.2510763109,
-0.3263236284,
-0.3192665577,
-0.4665786624,
-0.0178145804,
-0.1133522764,
-0.0593385138,
-0.3441107869,
-0.119317852,
0.2012608498,
0.371951282,
-0.5592173934,
0.5103774667,
-0.3539541364,
-0.2305110097,
0.5847803354,
0.1285461634,
0.2818233371,
-0.3557742536,
-0.3043628633,
0.2014067471,
-0.4242985547,
0.0719336793,
0.2206811607,
-0.0253625568,
0.0326860212,
0.6727816463,
-0.175187543,
0.8785336018,
0.1071572676,
-0.1483160257,
-0.0399390049,
0.0872894302,
-0.3301102221,
-0.2392254919,
0.7382561564,
-0.1782939136,
0.1213731021,
-0.1318043172,
-0.4152189195,
-0.5252411962,
0.1350613385,
-0.3539998531,
0.0017791378,
0.3110722303,
-0.1620655209,
0.0456844978,
-0.200259313,
-0.4958561063,
-0.45643121,
-0.113520205,
0.8850768209,
-0.2324742526,
-0.3264350891,
0.0570850633,
-0.0902790725,
0.2078363746,
0.3703612685,
-0.975640893,
0.0812703446,
0.3687017858,
0.5381265283,
-0.0790520906,
-0.2652100325,
0.0224923249,
0.1098615751,
-0.4859430492,
0.7950517535,
-0.3171821535,
-0.1237603649,
-0.3874059319,
-0.1440078765,
-0.2201602161,
-0.5435153246,
0.1201245636,
-0.5779940486,
0.0428871959,
-0.3318583071,
-1.017408371,
-0.357714504,
0.376344949,
-0.4289953709,
0.8465887308,
0.3598939776,
-0.7492765188,
0.142100662,
-0.4394828379,
-0.0894922912,
0.2089565396,
-0.2835890055,
-0.1352570951,
0.3548735976,
0.4218189418,
0.6586049199,
-0.3493083119,
0.2382388115,
-0.4250119328,
-0.2075357884,
0.4316203594,
-0.5318194628,
0.5037058592,
0.1501850039,
-0.2545985579,
-0.1775815785,
-0.7966749072,
0.3200097084,
0.15887779,
-0.2949155271,
-0.3150184453,
-0.2401351035,
-0.6419979334,
0.2871003449,
0.4700525999,
-0.3676858842,
0.2387257665,
-0.4073168039,
0.4483635128,
0.8817400932,
-0.0004159998,
0.2947264016,
-0.1854739934,
0.6679939628,
-0.1107729822,
0.0056672245,
-0.1275457889,
-0.2063555568,
-1.1356670856,
0.1524525434,
0.1583791375,
0.4271200597,
-0.5411501527,
0.5547084808,
-0.0084807901,
-0.6017360091,
-0.6020154953,
0.5820851326,
0.2244201899,
0.5994607806,
0.4840168059,
-0.0446769968,
-0.4180224836,
-0.8299681544,
-0.3461099863,
-0.1856787503,
-0.1467556357,
0.4022192061,
0.8381410837,
-0.3257585168,
0.9299554825,
-0.3247309029,
-0.1737778038,
-0.213046059,
0.2169506252,
0.1517695636,
0.2070173621,
0.1589998901,
-0.2066789418,
-0.315295428,
-0.03625549,
-1.0715515614,
-0.0831325129,
-0.1233502105,
0.3382282853,
0.0430349223,
0.5083714128,
-0.35508129,
0.2728787661,
0.6906735301,
-0.1707323641,
0.4673200846,
-0.6296423078,
-0.1579948217,
-0.6352998018,
-0.0640536696,
-0.2050797939,
-0.0984942243,
-0.487331301,
-0.2159321755,
0.3066816032,
0.249453336,
-0.046699442,
0.9300442934,
-0.779052496,
-0.3733794689,
-0.3574352562,
0.2388972491,
-0.2379755676,
0.4707214236,
0.0239494797,
0.8222343922,
0.5297629833,
-0.6504119635,
0.0626062006,
0.1280175894,
-0.6227462292,
0.3121175766,
-0.6235084534,
0.3278616369,
-0.2758826613,
-0.0555225834,
-1.0823236704,
-0.4268861413,
-0.0945399702,
-0.5818397999,
0.2452851534,
-0.2522057891,
-0.3017281294,
-0.5996827483,
0.3243330717,
0.290519774,
0.3301618397,
-0.4967193604,
0.6690913439,
0.4333827794,
-0.0472645871,
-0.6997879148,
-0.5496279001,
-0.0314413346,
-0.2363927811,
-0.3081640601,
-0.2549706995,
-0.1169687882,
-0.3597165346,
-0.1390487403,
-0.1925034672,
-0.2486830801,
0.3259159923,
0.3899075687,
-0.0378918424,
-0.1292854398,
0.6935937405,
0.0769539997,
0.0282270703,
0.2950088978,
-0.3667247891,
0.4598772824,
-0.2945051491,
-0.6218206286,
-0.2614935935,
-0.203565836,
0.4639506042,
-0.3106565475,
0.5938897133,
0.4674911499,
-0.2915309072,
-0.4992257655,
-0.8769729137,
-0.0961093232,
-0.4717406631,
0.3557493985,
-0.3471982777,
-1.2101449966,
0.6701708436,
0.0243709143,
-0.323618412,
0.7491198182,
0.5361632109,
-0.1266041398,
0.8072959185,
0.5985238552,
-0.1132107452,
-0.0591401942,
-0.1936342269,
0.0396523513,
-0.9291614294,
-0.1947195232,
-0.3942250609,
-0.0485939197,
-0.4321770072,
-0.498119086,
0.4582851529,
0.0219115149,
-0.3291132152,
0.1941096783,
-0.2680531144,
0.5370714068,
0.3144931197,
-0.0379487574,
0.4597065449,
-0.395396024,
-0.0305050574,
0.1009706259,
-0.7809640169,
-0.4899851382,
1.1605616808,
0.6129957438,
0.8610726595,
-0.0131083969,
0.4932051003,
0.2746394873,
0.2073864192,
-0.6170734763,
0.3053380251,
0.2419123352,
-0.8452568054,
-0.673635304,
-0.5578712821,
-0.7567836642,
0.1309118271,
-0.1540445983,
-0.7149517536,
-0.039520435,
0.1779202819,
-0.6302993298,
0.5443450212,
-0.5572741628,
0.6864191294,
-0.657076776,
-0.0339803696,
-0.0011756493,
-0.5758563876,
0.4473391473,
-0.5976119637,
0.3243750632,
-0.3726973832,
-0.0951117501,
0.7743315101,
-0.0408885404,
0.8108565807,
0.0840377212,
-0.460023284,
0.4053114653,
0.2232583165,
0.3483884037,
0.0231817849,
-0.0726423189,
0.1148255169,
0.0066856625,
-0.1633721292,
-0.7097802162,
0.5447615981,
-0.7950723171,
-0.723385036,
-0.2603524923,
-0.5982862711,
-0.4640824497,
0.2459873408,
0.2461992353,
0.0080812741,
-0.095150426,
0.0901608542,
0.7042084336,
-0.4114707112,
0.3800385594,
0.889149487,
-0.2145927697,
-0.0661110058,
0.5991520882,
0.4502099156,
0.4215913117,
0.4128043056,
0.3312548399,
-0.5033065081,
-0.5466669798,
-0.3940522373,
0.3388259411,
-0.8775809407,
-0.2333385348,
-0.650054276,
-0.3995151818,
-0.3495618403,
0.2361277044,
-0.3507072926,
-0.2418391705,
-0.5232638717,
-0.1570880711,
0.1809298694,
1.2488001585,
-0.1844103932,
0.3458000124,
-0.6471152306,
-0.0545003228,
0.7186005712,
0.3090137541,
0.3226771653,
-1.0548837185,
-0.1451616287,
0.0942367837,
-0.1219536141,
-0.9013625383,
0.5420172215,
0.1054288223,
0.5896311402,
0.4048361778,
0.1934438348,
0.6164243221,
-0.2457727492,
0.4614263475,
-0.1972977221,
-1.0816607475,
0.6152685285,
-0.3221501708,
0.4417774379,
0.4383267462,
0.5137187839,
-0.2962523997,
-0.4839111269,
-0.7413105369,
-0.4009268284,
0.49587062,
0.0570952855,
0.2079096437,
0.0218894836,
0.5391049981,
-0.0035099101,
0.1401700974,
-0.7462263107,
-0.0720932037,
0.037601497,
-0.0781024545,
-0.229562372,
-0.3445464075,
0.0923921317,
-0.3392470777,
0.526527822,
-0.3327840865,
0.1148541793,
0.1337984949,
-0.1582177728,
-0.3246363997,
0.519440949,
0.4418032467,
0.996888876,
-0.2288041562,
0.2799860239,
0.7066193819,
-0.0340230018,
0.1953701079,
-0.247796461,
-0.0031703277,
-0.4598663747,
0.5604329109,
0.6930957437,
0.009532555,
-0.853309989,
0.4477299452,
-0.1342202276,
0.0167842042,
-0.58734411,
0.2129475027,
0.20822981,
0.3616972268,
0.3811498284,
-0.1168177426,
-0.0402838327,
-0.4517271519,
0.1289203167,
0.6007489562,
-0.538341701,
-0.2061637044,
0.4177524149,
-0.1811078936,
-0.1534933746,
0.6018334031,
-0.1586956233,
-0.5090320706,
0.5917629004,
0.6606355906,
0.5018229485,
-0.2876774073,
0.1179758236,
0.4656803906,
0.5804114342,
-0.0632473379,
-0.0408766158,
-0.1213836074,
-1.007984519,
-0.4024639428,
-0.6711190939,
-0.2387929261,
0.571518302,
-0.6658994555,
-0.0750796422,
-0.6217967272,
-0.0776223242,
-0.1767032593,
-0.0420051515,
-0.6937734485,
0.3611403406,
-0.215746209,
0.7786991596,
-0.8178406954,
0.6196976304,
0.2816006839,
-0.2822116911,
-1.0596128702,
0.0206806958,
-0.1173127741,
-1.2349147797,
0.688467741,
0.0781757087,
0.0121138943,
0.1452329904,
-0.61525774,
-1.1015968323,
0.9050372243,
0.3009548485,
-0.6044698358,
-0.0062559852,
0.1552570164,
0.7118545175,
-0.1408465207,
0.4355607331,
0.6591600776,
0.514010489,
0.0885393247,
-1.0154098272,
-0.1524442881,
0.0985386446,
-0.2904654145,
0.1083185002,
-0.4894291759,
0.7854261994,
-0.486101836,
-0.0775835514,
-0.0405548736,
0.7056240439,
-0.0805894956,
0.0285339858,
0.4459356666,
0.5104285479,
0.9209776521,
0.0432458743,
0.7088876367,
-0.2512699962,
0.5872055888,
1.3111889362,
-0.0182686765,
0.8926612735,
0.2953632772,
-0.1959698945,
0.2499787509,
0.5699163675,
-0.0934893563,
0.0493013225,
0.2692554593,
-0.1293115914,
-0.8855229616,
0.1407367587,
-0.261803627,
0.8638564348,
0.5313862562,
-0.3811858296,
-0.2336773872,
0.0699771866,
-0.0301187839,
0.0602205992,
-0.3002046943,
0.9271992445,
0.0857686922,
-0.7546985745,
0.6980530024,
-0.069069162,
0.4232436717,
-0.649494946,
0.1502188295,
-0.2557962537,
0.2137219757,
-0.1008048058,
-1.1696051359,
0.1791203022,
-0.081458129,
-0.0192105211,
0.1367530227,
0.7093867064,
-0.3653352559,
-0.5359532833,
0.3800408244,
0.8959530592,
0.1882531643,
-0.0985155478,
-0.6305630207,
-0.1326911002,
0.1045261398,
0.0304784812,
0.3540625572,
0.5968707204,
0.1619672924,
1.3331671953,
0.2791325748,
0.1300771832,
-0.0021165176,
-0.2117590755,
0.6240330338,
-0.3976079822,
-0.0047567277,
-0.8340998888,
0.1871611029,
0.1808554232,
-0.3397596776,
1.10204494,
0.2326481044,
0.8612214327,
-0.0852590948,
0.9207658768,
0.0832464173,
0.7431213856,
-0.4551900327,
0.690879643,
-0.7315261364,
0.5630624294,
-0.2165147215,
-0.4821163714,
-0.0748803616,
0.7030534744,
-0.7014475465,
0.187643975,
0.3056558669,
0.7048394084,
0.0221029967,
-0.1123866439,
0.5895500779,
0.3750223517,
0.0217094664,
0.5975140333,
1.0906422138,
-0.2565995455,
0.3650225997,
-0.1705025136,
-0.1641669571,
0.1174350455,
-0.7232205272,
-1.1923320293,
-0.6944386959,
0.0810904056,
-0.0022580314,
-0.1051319242,
0.7029750347,
0.6608991623,
-0.6219851971,
-0.2760839462,
0.027533941,
0.331787169,
0.1105037034,
-0.1087060496,
0.3387736976,
-0.5199415684,
-0.1565689594,
0.485135287,
0.2438545525,
0.356790036,
-0.61503613,
-0.0248636659,
-0.1429764479,
0.2088958025,
0.4108022153,
0.4839267433,
-0.678198278,
-0.3437484205,
-0.0134382397,
0.254889816,
-0.1045061499,
0.4867129922,
-0.5386651754,
0.4461094737,
0.2949300408,
0.6179629564,
0.2298609912,
0.0674676448,
0.369720459,
-0.7030106187,
-0.2994304895,
0.2953094542,
0.3585074246,
0.3782761097,
-0.4369186461,
0.3077672422,
-0.0603263006,
-0.9347769022,
-0.5441119075,
0.1630747765,
-0.4509145319,
-0.5218841434,
1.0405176878,
-0.1672530472,
-0.1105794534,
-0.2734893262,
0.0823648125,
-0.0541566275,
0.0324952789,
0.9480004907,
0.6947602034,
-0.1970104724,
-0.3067413867,
-0.7443971038,
0.4534258842,
0.3517214954,
-0.8824816942,
0.1709278971,
0.3441883922,
0.6910915971,
0.0684135482,
0.6011837721,
0.1949996054,
-0.1343473643,
-0.3115674257,
-0.0591122359,
0.1120475829,
-0.4110400081,
-0.4265238345,
0.1928116083,
0.3379819095,
0.3175614476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18152v1 | Extrinsic Factors Affecting the Accuracy of Biomedical NER | 2023-05-29T15:29:49 | 2023-05-29T15:29:49 | Zhiyi Li, Shengjie Zhang, Yujie Song, Jungyeul Park | cs.CL | cs.CL | Biomedical named entity recognition (NER) is a critial task that aims to
identify structured information in clinical text, which is often replete with
complex, technical terms and a high degree of variability. Accurate and
reliable NER can facilitate the extraction and analysis of important biomedical
information, which can be used to improve downstream applications including the
healthcare system. However, NER in the biomedical domain is challenging due to
limited data availability, as the high expertise, time, and expenses are
required to annotate its data. In this paper, by using the limited data, we
explore various extrinsic factors including the corpus annotation scheme, data
augmentation techniques, semi-supervised learning and Brill transformation, to
improve the performance of a NER model on a clinical text dataset (i2b2 2012,
\citet{sun-rumshisky-uzuner:2013}). Our experiments demonstrate that these
approaches can significantly improve the model's F1 score from original 73.74
to 77.55. Our findings suggest that considering different extrinsic factors and
combining these techniques is a promising approach for improving NER
performance in the biomedical domain where the size of data is limited. | [
-0.2075208127,
-0.8272686005,
0.533441782,
-0.0162810795,
-0.2684990168,
0.0922395289,
-0.2843079269,
-1.0872561932,
0.3130009472,
0.3719047606,
-0.0344492681,
-0.2822627425,
-0.7789008021,
0.5845146775,
-0.3870804012,
1.1771668196,
0.0186087824,
0.2931311131,
-0.2258938551,
-0.4926048219,
-0.3031994998,
-0.6607983112,
-1.0016452074,
-0.410936743,
0.5092417598,
0.0456369892,
0.4576887786,
0.7195411325,
1.1874856949,
0.2737442553,
-0.399521172,
0.1786875129,
-0.3172087967,
0.1729812622,
-0.0739846379,
-0.3281713128,
-0.4022609591,
-0.4305306673,
0.5998648405,
0.7173768878,
0.0380759984,
-0.023258362,
-0.0843002945,
0.5730858445,
-0.1499308497,
0.0688805804,
-0.3168068528,
0.0733111426,
-0.2677968144,
-0.3490938842,
-0.3485073745,
-0.2660298049,
0.6021879911,
-0.7941989303,
0.5327827334,
0.076525338,
1.1388956308,
0.3499609828,
-0.4447295964,
-0.3642747104,
-0.792121768,
0.5160790086,
-0.7395147681,
0.4805294871,
0.076363191,
0.0863035396,
-0.2252209336,
-0.6104539633,
-0.3451607525,
-0.122982569,
-0.3472620845,
0.0264369342,
-0.1756922752,
0.1972814202,
0.6712350845,
0.1716811955,
-0.3540977836,
0.0923607722,
-0.5542401075,
-0.298951894,
0.5938600302,
0.2880041599,
0.3254996836,
-0.0994963497,
-0.3642252982,
-0.045803573,
-0.611426115,
0.1120863855,
-0.0556039922,
0.343801558,
0.010927543,
0.6386107206,
-0.1504977345,
0.7169786692,
0.3191747069,
-0.0750062093,
0.6468446255,
-0.5310240984,
-0.1800402552,
0.276067555,
0.556302011,
0.2219757438,
0.0663004443,
-0.0640916973,
-0.0325401202,
-0.0016792652,
0.1747933775,
-0.8190629482,
-0.0672575608,
0.2767654359,
-0.3418400884,
-0.0631931126,
0.0567695946,
-0.7640343308,
-0.5647284985,
-0.4076437354,
0.2871871889,
-0.8890663981,
0.1389865875,
-0.2288959175,
-0.1301796883,
0.0763424486,
0.6729792356,
-0.3679510355,
0.336940676,
0.3405613899,
0.8524032235,
-0.1800138354,
0.1822011769,
-0.5250485539,
0.1613146216,
-0.1435584575,
0.7091158032,
-0.6443038583,
-0.341260314,
-0.3354255557,
0.1929305047,
-0.3124221265,
-0.5312416553,
0.4478420615,
-0.4517200291,
0.025322577,
-0.1836941242,
-0.8702315688,
-0.3037040532,
-0.1458245963,
-0.9167065024,
0.8013006449,
0.1768623739,
-0.8098235726,
0.6324976683,
-0.5694140196,
-0.6641780734,
0.3650394082,
-0.34144786,
-0.4704265296,
0.3548944592,
0.1495386809,
0.408839047,
-0.2345601171,
0.4193557203,
-0.2005773038,
-0.1342215687,
0.72750175,
-0.0494136624,
0.3275416493,
-0.2432713956,
-0.3417666554,
-0.0028158722,
-1.0315535069,
0.048401054,
-0.2200951576,
-0.1852127314,
-0.5508420467,
-0.0860446468,
0.1928107291,
0.3654075563,
-0.0458359271,
-0.8718807697,
-0.2702228129,
-0.7201234102,
0.353130132,
0.4475463629,
0.278241396,
0.4157944024,
-0.345048815,
0.4137232304,
0.116590701,
-0.064479731,
0.1291876584,
-0.598608911,
-0.563854754,
-0.417319715,
0.7342486978,
0.4205931425,
-0.5000912547,
0.0848821551,
-0.4365848303,
-0.5641821027,
-0.7194319367,
-0.1361400336,
0.4005574286,
0.8883726001,
0.6991477609,
-0.0879107341,
-0.6102997661,
-1.0524154902,
-0.0259045865,
-0.0260582659,
0.1746368706,
0.5182413459,
0.6615546942,
-0.3473609388,
0.6902163625,
-0.186716482,
-0.4628320634,
-0.1936536133,
0.160620898,
0.3527869582,
0.5349236727,
0.135016337,
-0.9730693698,
-0.4940958321,
0.4172341526,
-0.690489769,
-0.1947653592,
-0.1798111498,
0.061194323,
0.339545697,
0.425419271,
-0.45322752,
0.9303368926,
0.1595667601,
-0.1594213992,
0.155575484,
-0.5026928782,
0.1108085215,
-0.7200301886,
0.4560664296,
0.2384405583,
-0.2474389821,
-0.7908238173,
-0.0173779223,
0.3818078637,
0.1579566002,
-0.2293207049,
0.7968726158,
-0.6002745628,
0.4758999348,
-0.1288881302,
-0.1838583499,
0.1300446391,
0.0419717543,
0.2852149904,
0.394957155,
0.2389435172,
-0.739682436,
0.0855434462,
0.5179415345,
-0.1984671056,
0.4260530472,
-0.9950708747,
-0.0493900478,
-0.200728178,
-0.0120010693,
-0.6974043846,
-0.4355890751,
0.1522984654,
-0.4898972511,
0.7243136168,
0.1366631538,
-0.324008584,
-0.0816644356,
0.0712750182,
0.3798127472,
0.1986848116,
-0.1982984543,
0.5605806708,
0.3893681765,
-0.3055401444,
-0.5555722117,
-0.7276002765,
-0.0440295264,
-0.0328472368,
-0.4184787571,
0.9009497762,
-0.0018133181,
0.0124140736,
0.1001221463,
0.0163556542,
-0.0816521719,
-0.2530021667,
0.4796992838,
0.5199297071,
0.0006257136,
0.4945168793,
0.1889192164,
-0.2220641077,
-0.144312337,
0.4699588418,
0.0946884602,
0.1210597083,
-0.1191031933,
-0.4542109966,
0.4261497259,
0.5425043702,
-0.1452981085,
0.7718237638,
0.4897723496,
-0.8698506951,
0.0612590238,
-0.6971076131,
-0.1844255328,
-0.3008856773,
0.5138272643,
-0.1593120992,
-0.9667336345,
0.6524506211,
0.1797701716,
-0.4482336342,
0.4290352762,
0.3889437914,
0.020787118,
0.9335861206,
0.5312922597,
0.3772149086,
0.0873238593,
0.1496098787,
0.334703356,
-1.1709965467,
-0.5788259506,
-0.3913187981,
-0.3488522172,
-0.6208481193,
-0.3580182195,
0.6061270833,
-0.2826326489,
0.1600005329,
0.302803427,
-0.6971013546,
-0.0486835837,
0.2847708166,
0.493065834,
0.1604654789,
0.0544259734,
-0.1969327927,
-0.2015304565,
-0.5200118423,
-0.3241462708,
1.0127432346,
0.5309853554,
0.4971697628,
0.1745286584,
0.5123214722,
0.0678256974,
0.2181420475,
-0.5273717642,
0.421086967,
-0.0604597665,
-0.8283399343,
-0.3484052718,
-0.5545682907,
-0.9139375091,
-0.2598680258,
-0.4974407852,
-0.7049663663,
0.6681638956,
-0.1850826442,
-0.7475063205,
-0.1347125322,
-0.3841504157,
0.6119950414,
-0.2413027436,
-0.4906028211,
0.2470081896,
-0.7840874195,
-0.1887142062,
-0.5460776687,
0.084589228,
-0.0131096374,
-0.3331974447,
0.8905665874,
-0.5564498305,
0.6114519835,
-0.043188192,
0.3918804228,
0.0598881505,
-0.2768833339,
0.608430028,
0.1713934094,
-0.1619178653,
0.3986774087,
0.253271997,
-0.1370800734,
-0.4962650537,
0.4203141034,
-0.4687289298,
-0.1884084642,
-0.7343270183,
-0.5084492564,
-0.1793356836,
0.0823652074,
0.7206412554,
0.6377501488,
-0.0845514983,
0.3736458719,
0.7229886651,
-0.378465414,
0.3267963827,
0.4482237697,
0.0080777882,
-0.6856843233,
0.5031939745,
0.4926153421,
-0.0453706942,
0.5997209549,
-0.1651839018,
-0.4901823997,
-0.8988282681,
-0.4004726708,
0.4537079632,
-0.4538446069,
-0.5116140842,
-1.0372428894,
-0.280104816,
-0.3741937876,
0.0308718514,
-0.0184195731,
-0.3867078125,
-0.5851444602,
-0.2601249516,
0.5970907807,
0.3569828272,
-0.0951527357,
0.3377426267,
-0.8394929767,
0.0290273204,
-0.4010258913,
0.2597375512,
-0.3976006806,
-0.7863095999,
-0.2456039786,
-0.1719367355,
0.4618113339,
-1.1144192219,
0.5700406432,
0.3736540079,
0.6866640449,
0.3115946949,
-0.1294469833,
0.8770106435,
-0.420742929,
0.1511941403,
0.1583636105,
-0.7640541196,
0.5357193351,
-0.0048943767,
-0.0751295984,
0.8610398769,
0.4746751487,
-0.2803233862,
-0.0680942833,
-0.7133712769,
-1.1340603828,
0.5035424232,
0.3050534129,
-0.1528712958,
-0.1247450113,
0.5177063346,
0.3429567218,
0.1657809913,
-0.4634769261,
-0.1236189902,
0.4359193444,
-0.221940428,
-0.0340893194,
-0.2193626314,
0.1239565387,
-0.3446770906,
0.9258973598,
-0.1342670321,
0.4029847383,
0.7654575706,
-0.1935389191,
-0.0630602688,
0.2010440677,
0.5586876273,
0.3660726547,
-0.28155604,
-0.1691918969,
0.2785902321,
-0.5665049553,
0.113120243,
0.5110051632,
-0.4170207083,
0.3349955082,
0.3823030591,
0.6866441965,
0.1521172822,
-0.6882099509,
0.5100067258,
0.0059226332,
0.1660740525,
-0.4432140291,
0.0347681567,
-0.306535095,
0.0326914266,
0.2785820365,
0.3606546223,
0.3565160036,
0.0469745658,
0.3232597411,
0.4022761583,
-0.82354182,
-0.1598533541,
0.5347689986,
0.024379516,
-0.0278491881,
0.5854478478,
-0.2475928217,
-0.1739330292,
0.6109095216,
0.599850893,
0.4202010334,
-0.354503572,
0.2668696642,
0.6802254915,
0.2013661712,
-0.0242806412,
0.2704409957,
0.4398958981,
-0.5463854671,
-0.6502741575,
-0.6815074682,
-0.3764912784,
0.0449045897,
-0.8251257539,
0.5092404485,
-0.5361953974,
-0.6396914124,
0.4350280762,
-0.1135396808,
-0.7766676545,
0.6245658398,
0.089295499,
0.8900284171,
-0.5400203466,
0.4477388561,
0.9792464972,
-0.4516500831,
-0.7232367992,
-0.7392501235,
-0.0255270842,
-0.3758161366,
0.7024496794,
0.2477523983,
0.3637594879,
-0.0638566911,
-0.194883123,
-1.0595264435,
0.7995091677,
0.0187623147,
-0.8261457086,
-0.3101400435,
0.2357396334,
0.9293442369,
-0.4840618372,
0.5845047832,
0.25461182,
0.3512430191,
-0.014511195,
-1.0584503412,
0.3830981255,
-0.6755509973,
-0.1037231311,
0.5382969379,
-0.1953417659,
0.5871494412,
-0.4204317927,
-0.2420424223,
0.1489367783,
0.3365222812,
0.2678034008,
0.8828409314,
0.0645815134,
0.5444220304,
1.1503772736,
-0.1974012703,
1.0205049515,
-0.1707496494,
0.1966275871,
0.982875526,
-0.587092042,
0.7080751061,
0.4907119572,
-0.0691394284,
0.6099482775,
0.5557360053,
-0.1883169562,
0.2425715476,
0.0161987431,
-0.2524832487,
-0.0101239439,
-0.3290952444,
-0.5759051442,
0.4829224944,
0.6980257034,
-0.9162285924,
0.1364875585,
0.3443669975,
0.0544661283,
-0.248604551,
-0.199457556,
0.8832362294,
0.0046994714,
-0.3297142684,
0.1323387921,
-0.091131404,
0.3914138675,
-0.5027195215,
-0.1886690557,
0.1303266883,
0.1451130062,
-0.3865095973,
-0.2604206502,
0.3436374366,
-0.1332784444,
-0.3709020615,
0.3598615527,
1.0408023596,
-0.1405804455,
-0.8029648662,
0.4284654558,
0.6552888155,
0.1337270588,
-0.0970136672,
-0.6166678667,
-0.0715553164,
-0.059760645,
-0.0999523923,
0.3059405684,
0.5407096148,
-0.0390153863,
0.4891398847,
0.7357807159,
0.5011433959,
-0.144502148,
-0.2397142351,
0.571369648,
-0.9229040146,
-0.224116683,
-0.701299727,
0.406593591,
-0.4233604968,
-0.3790177703,
0.4583456218,
0.6116734743,
0.6508159041,
0.0289691947,
0.678325057,
-0.1399718523,
0.935197711,
-0.2995455265,
0.6908214092,
-0.2862194777,
0.1697612107,
-0.4093349576,
-0.6076080799,
-0.7019813657,
0.4871344268,
-0.4739775062,
0.1645440012,
0.871152401,
0.7813417912,
0.2341972888,
0.417850256,
0.3554504514,
0.264531672,
0.0267646592,
0.6893627644,
0.6223814487,
-0.5300246477,
0.2377298921,
-0.5008375049,
-0.3921592534,
-0.4110764563,
-0.8522856832,
-0.7090466022,
-0.3858557343,
-0.94722718,
-0.5308075547,
0.1372037083,
0.9893509746,
0.6929090619,
-1.0098876953,
0.5255041718,
-0.1185064912,
-0.3290764093,
-0.2802263796,
-0.1687266827,
0.5862564445,
-0.0512021519,
-0.5612092614,
0.0899614319,
0.4675147533,
0.1543131918,
0.4739342332,
0.1442691833,
-0.1552582532,
-0.0228044465,
0.5291085243,
0.3298599422,
-0.5465473533,
-0.18681328,
0.3490478396,
-0.2371351421,
0.1797696948,
0.4921150208,
-0.9400874376,
0.5810385942,
0.3294794559,
0.915311873,
0.1862699538,
0.062773183,
0.190167442,
-0.3288346827,
-0.5069334507,
0.3434951007,
0.3773776293,
0.5887163281,
-0.7826908231,
0.8337054849,
0.4028188884,
-0.718165338,
-0.8047622442,
-0.3310216069,
-1.1857250929,
0.1013864726,
1.1070005894,
0.0732553452,
-0.3741603494,
-0.4201052189,
-0.1119310483,
0.4374532998,
-0.4962655008,
0.430313766,
0.5640335679,
-0.8103607297,
-0.0445766076,
-0.6938867569,
0.3772120476,
0.5206540823,
-0.6806527376,
-0.3426285386,
0.4746069908,
0.2298243642,
0.4181729555,
0.5092346668,
-0.3481265306,
0.3916229904,
-0.2641390562,
-0.1348085701,
-0.0584906749,
-0.2356619686,
-0.4863531291,
0.3064683378,
-0.2648995221,
0.1738880277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18149v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18149v4 | Multiscale Positive-Unlabeled Detection of AI-Generated Texts | 2023-05-29T15:25:00 | 2024-03-05T08:27:12 | Yuchuan Tian, Hanting Chen, Xutao Wang, Zheyuan Bai, Qinghua Zhang, Ruifeng Li, Chao Xu, Yunhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent releases of Large Language Models (LLMs), e.g. ChatGPT, are
astonishing at generating human-like texts, but they may impact the
authenticity of texts. Previous works proposed methods to detect these
AI-generated texts, including simple ML classifiers, pretrained-model-based
zero-shot methods, and finetuned language classification models. However,
mainstream detectors always fail on short texts, like SMSes, Tweets, and
reviews. In this paper, a Multiscale Positive-Unlabeled (MPU) training
framework is proposed to address the difficulty of short-text detection without
sacrificing long-texts. Firstly, we acknowledge the human-resemblance property
of short machine texts, and rephrase AI text detection as a partial
Positive-Unlabeled (PU) problem by regarding these short machine texts as
partially ``unlabeled". Then in this PU context, we propose the
length-sensitive Multiscale PU Loss, where a recurrent model in abstraction is
used to estimate positive priors of scale-variant corpora. Additionally, we
introduce a Text Multiscaling module to enrich training corpora. Experiments
show that our MPU method augments detection performance on long AI-generated
texts, and significantly improves short-text detection of language model
detectors. Language Models trained with MPU could outcompete existing detectors
on various short-text and long-text detection benchmarks. The codes are
available at
https://github.com/mindspore-lab/mindone/tree/master/examples/detect_chatgpt
and https://github.com/YuchuanTian/AIGC_text_detector. | [
-0.5483345389,
-0.5960645676,
0.6032503843,
0.0737099946,
-0.4070682824,
0.0606126152,
-0.5432181358,
-0.3109855056,
-0.0473152027,
0.2297389507,
-0.5157520771,
-0.3639235795,
-0.6059218645,
0.2250335068,
-0.3495825529,
1.1494305134,
0.2486896217,
-0.1754364371,
-0.0523834601,
-0.3238653839,
-0.067205511,
-0.7966657877,
-0.8779181242,
-0.4791985154,
0.5211488008,
0.3971658349,
0.3808618188,
0.3595460057,
0.2903675437,
0.3005987108,
-0.2697541714,
0.3013068438,
-0.1180265397,
-0.1958501935,
0.1098355725,
-0.3459871411,
-0.3345307112,
0.1870763749,
0.9477598071,
0.1669556201,
-0.1157693118,
0.1091428474,
0.217718333,
0.4616090059,
-0.4686822295,
0.1695857346,
-0.7006138563,
-0.0113428235,
-0.4314118922,
-0.2498244792,
-0.6934050322,
0.0570567437,
-0.3234078884,
-0.1683866531,
0.2254693061,
0.0031089347,
0.7643375993,
0.1501920223,
-0.5333163738,
-0.4882481992,
-0.542768538,
1.0125551224,
-0.8744287491,
0.3556602001,
0.2276094854,
0.2825471461,
-0.1665442884,
-0.3591716886,
-1.0052925348,
-0.2293934375,
-0.3116395473,
-0.1009217426,
-0.3580504656,
0.050411623,
0.120720394,
0.5373532772,
-0.4919168949,
0.4528824091,
0.0936507955,
-0.449003458,
0.2650771141,
-0.222648114,
0.4418888092,
-0.3429658711,
-0.1480262727,
-0.187838763,
-0.5417550802,
-0.1221059337,
0.5509614944,
0.4460329711,
-0.249840349,
0.5260124207,
-0.0523752347,
0.4432015419,
0.0385848507,
-0.6599173546,
0.5242358446,
-0.4723284841,
-0.138621226,
-0.042230729,
1.1078850031,
-0.0417115018,
0.4191091359,
0.0220418219,
-0.337679714,
0.0388223641,
-0.1034368128,
-1.0651999712,
-0.1717853844,
0.1463507861,
-0.4495915771,
-0.4473788142,
-0.3072957993,
-0.6381318569,
-0.5555470586,
-0.4264588058,
0.5555384159,
-0.5489352345,
-0.3258596957,
-0.1693960875,
-0.000112997,
0.006244936,
0.0715257525,
-0.6968798041,
-0.1668270081,
0.3269577622,
0.6868804097,
-0.0920935199,
-0.4684469998,
-0.6091216803,
-0.1982530057,
-0.0767892674,
0.9467583895,
-0.2516417801,
-0.1323265135,
-0.2508681417,
-0.0907150432,
0.0803453028,
-0.5432397127,
0.6379075646,
-0.0006123254,
0.383979857,
0.2340191752,
-0.3370113969,
0.1859941036,
0.6526353359,
-0.3333102167,
0.8426297903,
-0.0578435399,
-1.0896213055,
0.3646921217,
-0.7137266397,
-0.5339629054,
-0.1507775933,
-0.2113319784,
-1.1663577557,
-0.1614443809,
0.6281200647,
0.6977290511,
-0.21313411,
0.1770956814,
-0.2442061454,
-0.2562282383,
0.3250891864,
-1.0027751923,
0.6481575966,
0.0551178977,
-0.3866787553,
0.473320365,
-1.0257532597,
-0.0510569662,
0.0740926266,
-0.5210208297,
-0.2471715212,
0.0618989095,
0.2371193916,
0.0823924169,
0.2175396234,
-0.9157975316,
0.10128548,
0.0174057707,
0.568356514,
0.6645305157,
-0.016811002,
0.571178019,
-0.1692007035,
0.217853561,
0.2481440306,
0.0836026147,
-0.4637852013,
-0.380227983,
-0.8205016851,
-0.8286563158,
0.1403347403,
0.4704031348,
-0.95209378,
0.4788960218,
-0.1331366152,
-0.5449029207,
-0.4032375813,
0.0334692113,
0.3663100302,
0.2625887394,
0.4741422832,
0.1068146452,
-0.3493398428,
-1.0129933357,
-0.1417826563,
-0.2596609294,
-0.4178253114,
0.3659406304,
0.4628401399,
-0.6153254509,
0.6444985867,
-0.3515891731,
-0.5882946253,
-0.2378090024,
0.6644875407,
-0.0529637598,
0.4346775413,
0.5040001869,
-0.8460227251,
-0.4559200108,
0.0208446812,
-0.4371377528,
-0.0579043478,
-0.4551493526,
0.2341450602,
0.089900367,
0.4705081582,
-0.6287716031,
0.2967178822,
0.5542773604,
-0.1422701627,
0.5465139151,
-0.4429034889,
0.3233554661,
-1.1968377829,
-0.0183204003,
0.3772212267,
-0.4117447138,
-0.6488538384,
0.1407502443,
0.4443539083,
-0.1693279296,
-0.3975919187,
0.3595749736,
-0.4303299189,
0.0780625045,
-0.6312477589,
-0.03668743,
-0.148011148,
0.7398929,
0.0681491196,
1.0401501656,
0.2197623998,
-0.5413518548,
-0.1107070148,
-0.1770861447,
-0.1630937159,
0.8970942497,
-0.2419299781,
0.1239374354,
-0.3510116339,
0.4135808051,
-0.9149882793,
-0.0670146197,
0.142679438,
-0.597499311,
0.4122530818,
-0.2439176291,
-0.7732638121,
-0.396743983,
-0.4173061848,
0.6263037324,
0.3063850105,
-0.7674275637,
0.4740646482,
0.3560679257,
0.0208737701,
-0.3414006233,
-0.620508492,
0.0990067348,
-0.321162194,
-0.2700645626,
0.1749185771,
-0.2263803333,
0.1616365761,
-0.3545639515,
0.2214619666,
-0.4091908038,
0.0975036994,
0.1713410914,
0.0343228616,
-0.2838441432,
0.0954146385,
0.1831259429,
-0.1647284925,
-0.1911829263,
-0.2033256143,
0.6466325521,
-0.4219212234,
-0.3071545362,
-0.7007436752,
0.2656551301,
0.8639383912,
-0.524189651,
0.7795951962,
1.2434424162,
-0.5493680239,
0.0196807105,
-0.374181509,
-0.154637441,
-0.4512909055,
0.1880038083,
-0.1385272294,
-1.1236855984,
0.1617107987,
0.1188014746,
-0.1316207051,
0.4738866091,
0.7101022601,
-0.0532668531,
0.9354190826,
0.8234254718,
-0.2970036864,
0.3972361982,
0.0977430195,
0.4733882546,
-0.7448424697,
0.0664101169,
-0.6312209368,
-0.0365729742,
-0.7641230822,
-0.4645385742,
0.1984485239,
0.1121141985,
-0.2896957994,
0.5145682693,
-0.7600032091,
0.6316567659,
0.4262979329,
0.1569538116,
0.2853546441,
-0.1063142866,
0.2506434917,
-0.0738624558,
-0.2732614279,
-0.3388645947,
1.0690659285,
0.3699986339,
0.5650892854,
0.0838827714,
0.8580714464,
0.3322528601,
0.6527835131,
-0.8765126467,
0.260294944,
-0.1547745466,
-0.421641469,
-0.3477244377,
-0.685970962,
-0.8251100779,
0.3261803091,
-0.3933184147,
-0.8149790168,
-0.0546119213,
0.1194610521,
-0.2058850676,
0.5798943043,
-0.8254623413,
0.8469129205,
-0.0420889705,
0.2393388897,
-0.075240314,
-0.228118971,
0.2129087448,
-0.4136415124,
0.3901907206,
-0.1877230257,
0.2430585623,
0.6174910665,
-0.0527020171,
0.7955160141,
-0.1471024007,
-0.1376761347,
0.4815833271,
-0.040300969,
0.4866186678,
0.1910590678,
0.2237792909,
0.2059997022,
-0.1896046549,
-0.4403336346,
-0.0625852048,
0.6793614626,
-0.6217558384,
-0.2308630049,
-0.4404277503,
-0.7065111995,
0.1180083528,
0.5704264045,
0.3717047274,
0.4060441554,
0.0353421159,
0.137185216,
0.6216852665,
-0.3729762733,
0.6479772329,
0.2889727354,
-0.1574365944,
-0.3073768616,
1.1134517193,
-0.405542165,
0.0933828354,
0.5943571329,
0.2241652757,
-0.2035964727,
-0.7703081965,
-0.6407753229,
0.1334133297,
-0.3804143667,
-0.4236037135,
-0.4912195206,
-0.3354054987,
-0.2087198645,
0.0584067032,
-0.6221649051,
0.0373475403,
-0.54399544,
0.1775544137,
0.0754156411,
0.5347363353,
-0.0350049362,
0.5273945332,
-0.6438951492,
0.504247725,
0.0855910555,
0.1177141517,
-0.0091446722,
-0.4974688292,
0.0297316909,
0.2348530591,
-0.1919285208,
-0.439678967,
0.4451098442,
0.1351706982,
0.1760136038,
0.3854365647,
-0.0346624814,
0.4017910361,
-0.6534337997,
0.4828231931,
0.3255079389,
-0.7937390804,
0.3383771181,
-0.3869016171,
0.669670105,
0.464214325,
0.3680590391,
-0.4982843995,
-0.5102743506,
-0.2578091621,
-0.4953199327,
0.463342905,
0.5104119182,
0.118999809,
-0.1912986636,
0.2268708199,
-0.0035749951,
0.1657530963,
-1.249471426,
-0.2529228032,
-0.0797479451,
-0.3568631113,
-0.1919873059,
-0.3525726795,
0.2489383966,
0.0220759623,
0.5542129874,
-0.3565193713,
0.4693471491,
0.0811778903,
-0.1333149225,
0.2676715255,
0.7559156418,
0.5834596157,
0.3036170006,
-0.1802919656,
0.148594588,
-0.085159272,
-0.4751859903,
0.3295481503,
0.1905713975,
-0.0104866205,
-0.1576426029,
0.3168539405,
0.3571501076,
0.0767436773,
-0.4692154825,
0.7186595201,
-0.3662223816,
0.0004679965,
-0.297270596,
-0.4661224484,
0.0491875671,
0.2612548172,
0.4288704693,
0.3273248672,
-0.0248265564,
-0.5655887723,
0.4329820573,
0.4896856248,
-0.3856309056,
-0.1110272482,
0.5507857203,
0.0863393322,
-0.496950537,
0.720133543,
-0.7179992795,
-0.7011631727,
0.5341775417,
0.5751168132,
0.533549726,
0.0971044376,
0.260583967,
0.2707178295,
0.445543468,
0.0493732877,
-0.245692566,
-0.2040208876,
-0.9248069525,
-0.4405806661,
-0.7866736054,
-0.2331333458,
0.5147924423,
-0.4368785918,
0.1197450235,
-0.4564239979,
-0.1180377305,
0.334100157,
-0.1817667931,
-0.4055832028,
0.1632687002,
0.576359272,
0.4829211235,
-0.8387244344,
1.2875794172,
0.3457815945,
-0.2289983481,
-0.5844900012,
0.2690310776,
0.2542878687,
-0.5876726508,
0.1114483252,
0.6218492985,
0.0098279119,
0.0017741653,
-0.2178222984,
-0.4255908132,
0.943937242,
0.1916010976,
-0.4876758754,
0.1266675442,
0.2166846246,
0.6108905077,
-0.2509737909,
0.3405131698,
0.5559617281,
0.3163469434,
-0.1644217819,
-0.9740667939,
-0.0900888145,
0.1056509688,
-0.3216189444,
0.7172549367,
-0.4450032413,
1.0954146385,
-0.1166300848,
-0.1415944397,
0.4200446904,
0.6200810075,
0.3020365238,
0.2553601265,
0.5230365396,
0.612215817,
0.9085875154,
-0.0102466829,
0.9951845407,
0.0598842949,
0.5962435603,
0.9554370642,
0.1769055873,
0.8886728287,
0.4043261707,
-0.050453309,
0.3965937495,
0.6175979972,
0.1370895058,
0.3488450348,
0.0638013333,
-0.551823318,
-0.3560831845,
-0.0152884871,
-0.0708434209,
0.3307330608,
0.2904265523,
-0.1955502629,
-0.4248255789,
0.341825515,
0.2095912546,
0.1363566965,
-0.4622754157,
0.4189715385,
-0.0194155183,
-0.4274071157,
0.3887274563,
0.3884829581,
1.2871944904,
-0.3902131319,
0.1071531251,
-0.2285984606,
0.5879164934,
-0.1681323498,
-0.8327382207,
-0.0450048782,
0.0833908617,
-0.1831841618,
-0.1063134223,
0.9232521653,
-0.6614118218,
-0.5233165622,
0.1879643053,
0.2595163584,
0.1084870622,
-0.5992244482,
-0.7080827355,
-0.2097157687,
0.2469552755,
0.0555940904,
0.6041306257,
0.5633719563,
-0.0976034477,
0.5915104151,
0.7448918819,
-0.3216381669,
-0.2000151873,
0.1167115718,
0.6699572206,
-0.3508628905,
-0.3278793693,
-1.0562114716,
0.1713460535,
-0.1094160005,
-0.2050079107,
0.6899641752,
0.4985797107,
0.92382586,
-0.0468618274,
0.4694086313,
0.0284265149,
0.3331196904,
-0.3281766176,
1.1025836468,
-0.5367790461,
0.1239057407,
-0.1876719743,
-0.9263811111,
-0.4838688076,
0.3996863365,
0.0007824986,
-0.1756738275,
0.731256485,
0.6101694107,
-0.2828152776,
-0.2820843756,
0.3492267132,
-0.0255082678,
0.6647512317,
0.562502563,
0.5043293834,
-0.4358359277,
0.8660689592,
-0.4214813113,
-0.3668532073,
0.0598876476,
-0.9477818608,
-1.3244581223,
-0.5625978708,
-0.2486827672,
-0.0547483005,
-0.290333122,
0.4876638353,
0.7288392782,
-0.7758864164,
-0.0569901913,
-0.116343379,
0.2059796154,
0.2270979732,
-0.2405742407,
0.3464665115,
-0.1647055447,
-0.7197383642,
0.3116798401,
0.3151200712,
0.3428766429,
-0.2020611763,
-0.0313411132,
-0.4228562117,
0.0710981041,
0.8518573642,
0.4067150056,
-0.4324575663,
-0.5834005475,
-0.4525030255,
-0.2620998621,
0.3365526497,
0.7418906689,
-0.6034203172,
0.0054730191,
0.2119352669,
0.6312075853,
0.5457892418,
-0.1654029638,
0.0358984806,
-1.1110483408,
0.5201686621,
0.1212849542,
0.5009660125,
0.5858048201,
-0.3889907002,
0.188403666,
0.2434247732,
-0.6279051304,
-0.6797894835,
0.1670219004,
-0.8688389659,
-0.4048244357,
1.1614762545,
-0.1747935563,
-0.1924679577,
0.3732575476,
-0.4096195698,
0.1666186601,
-0.4321125448,
0.5476619005,
0.6700356603,
-0.0290197618,
-0.2144448161,
-0.018151192,
0.3503804207,
0.1899419129,
-0.9884121418,
0.0443786606,
0.3770239353,
0.259482801,
0.4920726418,
0.6739752889,
-0.0371434651,
0.1478721648,
0.0299175773,
0.2521660626,
-0.001822161,
-0.572283864,
-0.1825131774,
0.1224235147,
0.2357290983,
-0.1732515991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18144v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18144v2 | GripRank: Bridging the Gap between Retrieval and Generation via the Generative Knowledge Improved Passage Ranking | 2023-05-29T15:15:53 | 2023-08-15T17:10:57 | Jiaqi Bai, Hongcheng Guo, Jiaheng Liu, Jian Yang, Xinnian Liang, Zhao Yan, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-enhanced text generation has shown remarkable progress on
knowledge-intensive language tasks, such as open-domain question answering and
knowledge-enhanced dialogue generation, by leveraging passages retrieved from a
large passage corpus for delivering a proper answer given the input query.
However, the retrieved passages are not ideal for guiding answer generation
because of the discrepancy between retrieval and generation, i.e., the
candidate passages are all treated equally during the retrieval procedure
without considering their potential to generate a proper answer. This
discrepancy makes a passage retriever deliver a sub-optimal collection of
candidate passages to generate the answer. In this paper, we propose the
GeneRative Knowledge Improved Passage Ranking (GripRank) approach, addressing
the above challenge by distilling knowledge from a generative passage estimator
(GPE) to a passage ranker, where the GPE is a generative language model used to
measure how likely the candidate passages can generate the proper answer. We
realize the distillation procedure by teaching the passage ranker learning to
rank the passages ordered by the GPE. Furthermore, we improve the distillation
quality by devising a curriculum knowledge distillation mechanism, which allows
the knowledge provided by the GPE can be progressively distilled to the ranker
through an easy-to-hard curriculum, enabling the passage ranker to correctly
recognize the provenance of the answer from many plausible candidates. We
conduct extensive experiments on four datasets across three knowledge-intensive
language tasks. Experimental results show advantages over the state-of-the-art
methods for both passage ranking and answer generation on the KILT benchmark. | [
-0.4382227361,
-0.6298736334,
0.7117348909,
-0.1524796635,
-0.3232947588,
0.4091017842,
0.0259547736,
-0.0274357535,
-0.0896786824,
0.3006187975,
-0.1570563912,
-0.4195144176,
-1.0719524622,
-0.1539797038,
-0.2268156707,
1.0196789503,
0.2169485539,
-0.0536536537,
-0.5782151818,
0.0732251331,
-0.3141976297,
-0.32076478,
-0.6203766465,
-0.4193453193,
0.3164044023,
0.3265126348,
0.6496232152,
0.3304717243,
0.4333762825,
0.2601052523,
-0.4947866499,
0.1313787848,
-0.7440097332,
0.316139549,
-0.159208402,
-0.6289013028,
-0.1793251187,
-0.1037728861,
0.2261073142,
0.7950775027,
-0.4482345879,
-0.0624578558,
0.3408161104,
0.9770689607,
-0.7988255024,
0.0059381556,
-0.7163254619,
-0.1185218245,
-0.4637770951,
-0.3069427013,
-0.307151556,
-0.7692751884,
0.1038512066,
-0.5785147548,
0.4633716345,
-0.1269660294,
0.6588855982,
0.351788789,
-0.3839865625,
-0.4290222824,
-0.2863233387,
0.5607286692,
-0.6269695759,
0.0578410104,
0.307354629,
0.4586456418,
-0.1753682494,
-0.7230282426,
-0.4009032845,
0.0891413093,
0.1736250967,
0.4429351687,
0.3673374951,
-0.0154521205,
0.0272500198,
0.5279434919,
-0.5135170221,
-0.1198405623,
-0.4985134006,
-0.1012514234,
0.5755993128,
-0.032734938,
0.3421966732,
-0.0136801722,
-0.4299248159,
-0.5139115453,
-0.8971480727,
0.1075499877,
0.5162832737,
0.1941258162,
0.2792563736,
0.4332556725,
-0.1576696336,
0.9157580137,
0.2353849709,
0.0369091295,
0.1062301844,
-0.27331236,
0.2428423315,
0.0865245834,
0.6013192534,
0.3544526398,
0.2885731459,
-0.0964843258,
-0.0700923204,
-0.4203797281,
0.3258536458,
-0.932023108,
-0.4507969022,
-0.0481784306,
-0.1749233156,
-0.2955923975,
0.2546817064,
-0.9252269864,
-0.3298193812,
-0.0224799551,
0.3068864346,
-0.4908897579,
-0.3673057556,
0.0573211648,
-0.5592359304,
0.2449908555,
0.3962015808,
-0.9309149384,
0.1101074517,
0.5731734633,
0.9963610768,
-0.2894746959,
0.0757897124,
-0.5125941634,
0.3114722371,
-0.2008100301,
0.6011607647,
-0.6085488796,
-0.7432629466,
-0.0109513933,
-0.5288428068,
-0.2116137743,
-0.8272618651,
0.4448577762,
-0.8933439255,
0.2393349856,
-0.2934031785,
-0.8326974511,
0.1275928319,
-0.0124410959,
-0.5231035948,
1.0182704926,
0.1862960309,
-0.8287748694,
0.4853089452,
-0.4788040221,
-0.3409149051,
0.414726615,
-0.2408766299,
-0.4181339741,
0.1036116928,
0.3663164079,
0.2091354132,
-0.2309468538,
0.4898747802,
-0.1681170911,
-0.3930727243,
-0.0091756368,
-0.2810703218,
0.8902577758,
0.2867934704,
-0.3600634336,
-0.4856731594,
-0.177242741,
0.1565307528,
0.0260096304,
-0.4170791507,
-0.6108086705,
-0.0158207621,
-0.3125849366,
0.0537482947,
0.3253111541,
-0.5567875504,
0.3943085372,
-0.3839526176,
0.1288338304,
0.7985736728,
0.3407005668,
0.533347249,
-0.1102566198,
0.5901893377,
0.3315494955,
0.0279150903,
0.2055565119,
-0.595128417,
-0.6082153916,
0.1082950607,
0.4620584846,
0.4098789692,
-1.0860933065,
0.3376096189,
-0.3323878646,
-0.41296646,
-0.6734210849,
0.4267981052,
0.4988516569,
0.3788317144,
0.5021260381,
-0.3695601821,
0.1156366616,
-0.4363430142,
-0.2875361145,
-0.3201026022,
-0.0911975279,
0.1881690919,
0.2222222388,
0.3285224736,
1.0406033993,
-1.2640943527,
-0.281786412,
-0.3546504676,
0.2430329621,
0.3025230169,
0.2745276093,
0.4762850702,
-1.1606097221,
-0.678183794,
-0.159411937,
-0.7303484678,
-0.1310837567,
0.2752735317,
-0.4029717445,
-0.3045212626,
0.6203109026,
-0.278336525,
0.1749636978,
0.2050690055,
-0.1972426474,
0.3888856769,
-0.1734143794,
0.2509787977,
-1.2986745834,
-0.047671441,
-0.3003021479,
-0.0519242883,
-0.2627342641,
0.1663599163,
-0.1256172955,
-0.1755826622,
-0.1674272567,
0.4683019221,
-0.7151529193,
0.3207328618,
-0.2977171242,
0.4992125034,
-0.031128373,
0.0405689366,
-0.0220502149,
1.1268333197,
0.60104388,
-0.667383194,
0.0537566319,
0.5500634313,
-0.4080877006,
0.4638524055,
-0.517822206,
0.0919457898,
-0.2521558404,
-0.0721874759,
-0.9235716462,
-0.0477987528,
-0.2921632826,
-0.6129752994,
0.6027206779,
-0.2888751924,
-0.2514621317,
-0.286036998,
-0.3153517842,
0.3908699751,
0.6711836457,
-0.5651684403,
0.0369927287,
0.5089338422,
-0.7048273683,
-0.7790036201,
-0.2159657627,
-0.0557167493,
-0.1988983601,
-0.4774615169,
0.2890085876,
-0.0925675556,
0.0044596065,
-0.1137576252,
-0.2885501087,
-0.1272573769,
0.0861261413,
-0.0117482813,
0.1371961385,
0.0235587787,
0.2791673839,
0.5460810661,
-0.1660694331,
0.01037852,
-0.2099743336,
0.3540655673,
0.2556737661,
-0.3728849888,
0.3657791018,
0.2494112998,
0.4489046633,
-0.2364067584,
0.8289701343,
0.3993513882,
0.2093729824,
-0.2679418623,
-0.3410706222,
-0.3662086129,
-0.5329167843,
0.0073453365,
-0.4745524824,
-1.0394283533,
0.2211225033,
-0.4122696519,
0.0016263565,
0.2268477082,
0.2021423429,
-0.154229641,
0.7970148921,
0.5878952742,
-0.191849798,
0.3782443702,
-0.295676291,
0.4390110672,
-0.9410223365,
-0.1536263973,
-0.4026062191,
-0.2318963706,
-0.4597093761,
-0.5506957173,
0.8665180206,
0.6260590553,
0.0825257525,
0.1818981022,
-0.6359192729,
0.43164891,
0.7927133441,
0.2106443346,
0.4043344259,
-0.0445915908,
-0.5595434904,
-0.0515077561,
-0.7554856539,
-0.5152568221,
1.1958922148,
-0.2767855823,
0.6840673089,
0.3899891376,
1.2165648937,
0.4075615108,
0.2196978182,
-0.3281486332,
0.6680130959,
-0.0754077658,
-0.7772138715,
-0.4145109355,
-0.6307728291,
-0.8732008338,
0.5096614361,
0.1200302243,
-0.6272888184,
-0.016014697,
0.1080888733,
-0.1044948474,
0.0876054913,
-0.5863651037,
0.6689618826,
0.0709099174,
-0.4237026274,
-0.0636215433,
-0.8540874124,
0.3973220885,
0.140567258,
-0.0883385092,
0.0755277127,
0.3006598651,
0.5976936221,
-0.6878627539,
0.537009716,
-0.6618962288,
-0.192853421,
0.5837336183,
-0.1207743064,
0.3148311675,
0.2149693221,
-0.1606277227,
-0.2918653786,
-0.2360182852,
-0.4137918055,
-0.7476752996,
0.5699424744,
-0.703260541,
-0.9505170584,
-0.3579277098,
-0.0804355815,
-0.3093605638,
0.1533423513,
0.6668359041,
0.359896034,
-0.1882727146,
0.063919507,
1.0083670616,
-0.111657396,
0.311009109,
0.3697271943,
0.0810822994,
-0.3167330623,
1.0312447548,
0.0947805122,
0.4126146734,
0.7347080708,
0.0293548554,
-0.7188429236,
-0.7044535279,
-0.5796402693,
0.1475688517,
-0.5773505569,
-0.3845157027,
-0.6829164028,
-0.4240790009,
-0.4714335501,
-0.2303350121,
-0.0359175615,
-0.3953438103,
-0.1037191004,
-0.3386239409,
0.3003421426,
0.4820714891,
-0.0439017974,
0.3117514849,
-0.8131022453,
0.3139185607,
0.5165626407,
0.0548665263,
0.1518605798,
-0.4116833806,
-0.0899748355,
0.0932469591,
-0.8260603547,
-1.0094811916,
-0.0277739726,
0.3462849557,
0.6273537874,
0.4579516947,
0.4264065921,
0.6622419953,
-0.5180609226,
0.7416995764,
0.1994092911,
-0.7440934181,
0.9010766149,
-0.1557051539,
0.4191214144,
1.0220963955,
0.4015089571,
-0.2100802809,
-1.0378907919,
-0.5574421287,
-1.2317091227,
0.3100680411,
0.4285672009,
-0.0336088501,
-0.1595075577,
0.2984826267,
0.2569001615,
0.429949373,
-0.5715546608,
-0.2593497932,
-0.0655800179,
-0.203781575,
-0.1800908893,
-0.0084747728,
-0.0230127666,
-0.0554487519,
0.8169358373,
-0.1717979461,
0.0683538243,
0.0686989129,
-0.2842137814,
0.3446389735,
0.5472446084,
0.1841698885,
0.5685517192,
-0.2455549389,
0.1085090339,
-0.238490805,
-0.7745032907,
0.3692638278,
0.2259850204,
-0.4982120097,
0.0251678545,
0.2068886757,
0.4813925624,
-0.2411504239,
-0.4644808173,
0.7891784906,
0.1804316193,
-0.1756535172,
-0.0819412097,
0.4090846479,
0.3107595146,
-0.0119895181,
0.6196843982,
-0.2342805713,
0.5249596834,
-0.1206352711,
0.3936032653,
0.4110435843,
-0.2532588542,
0.0666578487,
0.7971128225,
0.5267326832,
0.19158566,
0.8930999637,
-0.2443754673,
-0.4365805089,
0.4531097412,
0.3651385903,
0.6041890383,
-0.3001661301,
0.5303918123,
0.5769882202,
-0.0483575538,
-0.1443587095,
0.174193427,
-0.5165997744,
-0.5799498558,
-0.2868259549,
-0.8201538324,
-0.3528361022,
-0.1801883876,
-1.0735763311,
-0.1668480039,
0.1053355932,
-0.3214895427,
-0.2713254988,
-0.1102454662,
-0.4420436621,
0.1775050014,
-0.1671268642,
0.8801347613,
-0.8301255107,
0.6095938683,
0.6164429784,
-0.4789787531,
-0.6558510661,
0.363309592,
-0.1493739486,
-0.5843967795,
0.6903114915,
0.2067703754,
-0.3215097189,
0.3888774514,
-0.3425394297,
-0.5519556999,
1.2750138044,
0.2517725229,
-0.5302060843,
-0.0259278119,
0.1130257398,
0.3855171502,
0.1655668467,
0.4396488667,
0.2375285178,
0.3256999254,
0.2858392596,
-0.5148314238,
0.0195788182,
-0.3629884422,
0.237830922,
0.6546440721,
-0.5596141815,
0.2998482287,
-0.471645236,
-0.4041015804,
0.0810423642,
0.677069962,
0.5027484894,
0.3000613749,
0.4161050022,
0.892562449,
0.6759466529,
-0.3677228093,
0.8364903331,
-0.0994119421,
0.2675135136,
1.0932685137,
-0.3804516196,
0.9116340876,
0.6227464676,
-0.3310924172,
0.6736268401,
0.4527323246,
0.3675338328,
1.0281295776,
0.3823102713,
-0.6910508275,
-0.3196916878,
0.0578583777,
-0.6149345636,
0.2453904152,
0.260987699,
-0.2127571702,
-0.4500722885,
-0.0108752018,
-0.212055102,
0.3769540787,
0.0103215668,
1.0858687162,
0.210110262,
-0.8495905399,
0.5080245137,
-0.3604228795,
0.477868706,
-0.512888968,
-0.2290253937,
-0.4059048891,
0.1175599173,
0.1399442106,
-1.0349880457,
-0.0367429145,
-0.0128012057,
-0.2316683084,
-0.4582004249,
0.5959405303,
-0.5967299342,
-0.2869291306,
0.4003393054,
0.9293162823,
0.2536498904,
0.0341163538,
-0.5055010319,
-0.371252656,
-0.0799174756,
-0.2570108473,
0.4764274657,
0.5275688767,
0.2525550723,
0.6837914586,
0.4503514469,
0.092039004,
0.2606333792,
0.2459935546,
1.0465950966,
-0.4610873759,
-0.5768461227,
-0.6513884068,
0.5419802666,
-0.5632579923,
-0.318641901,
0.6600883007,
0.7919685245,
0.7461029291,
-0.1313991547,
0.912443161,
-0.4071305096,
0.5194764137,
-0.6624103785,
0.812630713,
-0.533872366,
0.1775200665,
-0.2440407723,
-0.9197328687,
0.1892045289,
0.4353445768,
-0.2685803473,
0.1105690971,
0.5564617515,
0.8006768227,
-0.018446438,
-0.3460875452,
0.2929991186,
-0.1502064019,
0.2951753139,
0.784198463,
0.7913822532,
-0.4021250308,
0.6144843102,
0.1887168139,
-0.3090713918,
-0.1592295766,
-0.6265995502,
-0.779949069,
-0.708076179,
-0.2960739434,
-0.110239543,
0.4274722934,
0.0844384506,
0.4420916736,
-0.514061451,
-0.1376370639,
-0.4922986031,
0.3460719883,
-0.4111856222,
-0.3752208948,
0.2653307617,
-0.6774474382,
-0.8613556027,
0.3152119219,
0.0730300248,
0.0420869999,
0.0988587439,
-0.0276852008,
-0.1064113602,
-0.213788271,
0.3199740946,
0.0629012734,
-0.3817261457,
0.0534367673,
-0.0528366677,
-0.1326133609,
0.1027526632,
0.946025908,
-0.6094583273,
0.6142387986,
0.4805675745,
0.7502272129,
0.661056757,
0.384362638,
0.8222441673,
-0.9505482316,
-0.2694306076,
0.2986979187,
0.0408876799,
0.350911051,
-0.405479759,
0.5704328418,
0.0117435073,
-0.5487981439,
-0.4489095509,
0.3742090464,
-0.8948848248,
-0.4429416358,
0.9729623199,
-0.4158750474,
0.2150940448,
-0.1758134067,
-0.1119574979,
0.2982915938,
-0.4996767938,
0.9792484045,
0.7867613435,
0.0801925361,
-0.1555899978,
-0.4123809934,
0.5775473118,
0.4342028499,
-0.8031022549,
0.001801099,
0.3831606507,
0.292976439,
0.2720519304,
0.7802507877,
-0.3663311899,
0.0958922207,
0.0016552882,
-0.1333989054,
-0.0521802381,
-0.2630563974,
0.1909711957,
0.440587908,
0.3237332404,
-0.2987105846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18507v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18507v2 | Code Prompting: a Neural Symbolic Method for Complex Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-05-29T15:14:09 | 2023-10-07T08:07:46 | Yi Hu, Haotong Yang, Zhouchen Lin, Muhan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have scaled up to unlock a wide range of complex
reasoning tasks with the aid of various prompting methods. However, current
prompting methods generate natural language intermediate steps to help
reasoning, which can cause imperfect task reduction and confusion. To mitigate
such limitations, we explore code prompting, a neural symbolic prompting method
with both zero-shot and few-shot versions which triggers code as intermediate
steps. We conduct experiments on 7 widely-used benchmarks involving symbolic
reasoning and arithmetic reasoning. Code prompting generally outperforms
chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting. To further understand the performance and
limitations of code prompting, we perform extensive ablation studies and error
analyses, and identify several exclusive advantages of using symbolic
promptings compared to natural language. We also consider the ensemble of code
prompting and CoT prompting to combine the strengths of both. Finally, we show
through experiments how code annotations and their locations affect code
prompting. | [
-0.317358762,
-1.0683852434,
0.5980094075,
0.5387995243,
-0.2563989162,
0.1057472602,
-0.384820044,
-0.3925626576,
-0.1643504947,
0.2378540337,
-0.5880875587,
-0.4503316879,
-0.2996608317,
0.4819090962,
-0.4322736561,
0.6806845069,
-0.0498393811,
0.3144088387,
-0.0512897819,
0.1263088435,
-0.8821139932,
-0.7182851434,
-0.8696008325,
-0.4974932373,
0.8179324865,
0.3731429279,
0.5241401196,
0.4363098443,
0.3169196248,
0.2486167699,
-0.1308612674,
0.2658967078,
-0.1123852432,
0.3540328145,
0.2151667923,
-0.9903184175,
-0.0977116823,
-0.3903938234,
0.3479672372,
0.6103187203,
0.1462486684,
0.210950315,
-0.270134449,
0.7098222971,
-0.7099288106,
0.1291849613,
-0.6578978896,
0.1413086355,
0.0253162701,
-0.3149689734,
-0.7339249253,
-0.5256960392,
-0.3063684404,
-0.1023021117,
0.0685699359,
0.0386458449,
0.2978817523,
0.527314961,
-0.2181343585,
-0.3049398065,
-0.6627975702,
0.5563938618,
-0.6909583211,
0.1015902907,
0.4950311482,
0.071280174,
-0.0911788568,
-0.4238675833,
-0.701163888,
-0.6464638114,
0.0849427208,
-0.1956656873,
-0.4575818181,
0.3333571553,
0.8389138579,
-0.1875219196,
-0.5967738628,
0.0262819473,
-0.4539709985,
-0.0536952801,
0.3606022596,
0.1140452623,
0.5137119293,
0.0404405743,
-0.1186575741,
-0.1579893976,
-1.3466149569,
0.0759057179,
0.3337143362,
0.2723555863,
-0.0543609895,
0.5175679326,
-0.1589854956,
1.0745737553,
-0.0792455599,
0.3391336501,
-0.1761218011,
0.0438756533,
-0.2664798498,
0.4461895227,
0.5397170782,
0.2920596302,
0.7727918625,
0.0849469751,
-0.3627699614,
0.4435648024,
0.2963942885,
-0.6274843812,
-0.2550973892,
0.3926295936,
-0.2986437082,
-0.2536487281,
-0.0897263288,
-0.5102751255,
-0.4051259756,
-0.5302154422,
0.4033260047,
-0.5138779879,
0.0652520284,
0.1763566583,
-0.2640141249,
0.1397619098,
0.4590250254,
-0.9485345483,
-0.0198217761,
0.7856851816,
0.8638079166,
0.1793346554,
-0.3349300623,
-0.6453856826,
-0.0943461731,
-0.6246683002,
0.8684942722,
-0.7187376618,
-0.3238687515,
0.1442828625,
-0.4640214145,
0.1300235838,
-0.664403677,
0.1643087268,
-0.6517256498,
-0.4599422812,
-0.4694932401,
-0.2985797822,
-0.3340132236,
0.3865617216,
-0.6733748317,
0.9743780494,
-0.0351515338,
-0.2151588649,
0.1704354435,
-0.6709039211,
-0.5093353987,
0.1006916687,
-0.4656285644,
0.1590697467,
0.3395442367,
0.3574026823,
0.4335657656,
-0.2843655348,
0.27110219,
-0.1112207025,
-0.5441176295,
0.3701880574,
-0.6286430359,
0.7363000512,
0.3034574389,
-0.4900494516,
0.2227600515,
-0.436144352,
0.0385508388,
0.180870384,
-0.137180388,
-0.2420256138,
-0.205919683,
-0.2983388305,
0.2256087959,
0.0715517923,
-0.1249505281,
0.7006326318,
-0.2411675751,
0.5027287006,
0.8045259714,
0.1228008345,
0.2978467941,
-0.4128012359,
0.7671962976,
0.009360604,
0.0177177582,
-0.5451973081,
-0.5650742054,
-0.6509414315,
0.0033046105,
0.1934118569,
0.511808157,
-0.9144622684,
0.1989787221,
0.2018793672,
-0.2034080625,
-0.2438699901,
0.0722746104,
0.8059806228,
0.1319644153,
0.2053723633,
0.1114992872,
-0.5074703097,
-0.5065386295,
-0.2597874105,
-0.3622797132,
-0.0949265957,
-0.0325061157,
0.4536980689,
0.1032803431,
0.7114252448,
-0.4162082672,
0.1372961998,
-0.276222676,
0.3877913356,
0.2909560502,
0.3553355038,
0.3556828797,
-0.5612865686,
-0.2601881325,
-0.2343667597,
-0.7248271108,
-0.352676183,
-0.5564213395,
0.0334619284,
0.210588336,
0.8343327045,
-0.740991652,
0.3622918427,
0.6281161904,
-0.2722391188,
0.8386692405,
-0.2737779915,
0.2957740724,
-0.5792841911,
-0.0113800978,
-0.0140007902,
0.0935713947,
-0.7734914422,
0.2857650816,
0.3003355563,
-0.0025529361,
-0.530985415,
0.4844000936,
-0.4872644544,
0.0803211108,
-0.287861377,
-0.1349259913,
-0.0423900038,
0.5123785734,
-0.0059114154,
0.96210289,
0.5072574019,
-0.709066987,
0.4882755876,
0.0554232635,
-0.0907791629,
0.1955680698,
-0.8304674029,
0.3167084455,
-0.0698408186,
0.2892844975,
-1.1085832119,
-0.1234344319,
0.1820740104,
-0.3781186044,
0.258476913,
-0.2067550272,
-0.7794445753,
-0.4695079625,
-0.2430532724,
0.6741225719,
0.5855151415,
-0.5718134642,
0.196483776,
-0.2743055522,
-0.0426667891,
-0.4095276296,
-0.6051914096,
0.335937947,
0.0597319491,
-0.3918939233,
0.0117455237,
-0.2060216814,
-0.487046361,
-0.3560346663,
-0.1801758707,
0.0309404954,
-0.0764075518,
0.2890433967,
0.516829133,
-0.3340557516,
0.211073488,
0.2662263215,
-0.2077837735,
0.4309334457,
-0.3338086903,
0.8297804594,
-0.1732054353,
-0.7433835864,
-0.4144443274,
0.316750586,
0.3884368837,
-0.2504877746,
0.3960618973,
0.0967741087,
-0.4989132285,
-0.29337129,
-0.5792385936,
-0.4944963455,
-0.4838432074,
-0.0087386426,
-0.3223133683,
-0.8293898702,
0.3092330992,
-0.1946152449,
0.0619020201,
-0.043306876,
0.6200472713,
0.0994288996,
1.3083897829,
0.2093719095,
0.0254369695,
0.4189118445,
-0.2206208706,
0.4001115859,
-0.4591059685,
-0.1393347234,
-0.8445045948,
-0.3571180999,
0.0111714099,
-0.3943716884,
0.3062957525,
0.3829953969,
-0.3114359081,
0.2501544058,
-0.7421500087,
0.8822821379,
0.516102016,
0.1471758187,
0.2909181416,
0.0205170047,
-0.1927613467,
0.23204723,
-0.6570937037,
-0.3961454928,
0.6904187202,
0.0739136562,
0.9304436445,
-0.0757858455,
0.665964365,
0.168010056,
0.1331167221,
-1.0380702019,
0.7171247005,
0.2095247954,
-0.4512981772,
-0.1634508669,
-0.3415258527,
-0.8254472613,
-0.1322101355,
-0.1067044884,
-0.7501336932,
0.04002437,
0.3402572274,
-0.8143350482,
0.1306326091,
-0.8246614933,
0.4148080945,
-0.2701497078,
-0.0097452663,
-0.1222587377,
-0.5810576081,
0.2366089672,
0.0039500529,
0.0184563063,
0.1148984209,
-0.1019596681,
0.3617927134,
-0.293728441,
0.9727169275,
-0.0720861331,
-0.1228619665,
0.2554243803,
0.7191732526,
0.7730142474,
-0.1947480291,
-0.1190918162,
0.125105992,
-0.2105130702,
-0.1184952334,
-0.75536865,
0.6391299367,
-0.3605948985,
-0.7107245326,
-0.2579470873,
-0.6342551708,
-0.3270449042,
0.232295379,
0.3464569151,
0.4650235474,
0.6129378676,
0.1122926772,
0.8616287708,
-0.2534161508,
0.5958973765,
0.0131297177,
-0.3046711385,
-0.1501592994,
0.6242318749,
-0.0147740105,
0.5193334222,
0.209517464,
0.2166509926,
-0.2400904149,
-0.6683638692,
-0.6068198085,
0.1844554991,
-0.7941302657,
-0.4562095702,
-0.5580266714,
-0.1277753711,
-0.198510617,
-0.6210492849,
-0.0443301238,
-0.3190865815,
-0.0607266277,
-0.1178283021,
0.6285738945,
0.9678363204,
0.2157023698,
0.0974379182,
-1.0978740454,
0.3483256996,
0.1728058904,
0.2164840996,
0.3932082057,
-0.10306862,
-0.0305105876,
0.0529963411,
-0.0439027473,
-0.9859475493,
0.2531340718,
-0.2912730873,
0.358276248,
0.3813824952,
0.1854794025,
0.83210361,
-0.5095106363,
1.0227205753,
0.5343425274,
-1.0945292711,
0.6588062048,
-0.3933145404,
0.7440392375,
0.3963003457,
0.3039068878,
-0.6116622686,
-0.5433020592,
-0.3542027175,
-0.6557641029,
0.4917283356,
0.1217793822,
0.2837864161,
-0.326829195,
0.3856757879,
-0.2036561221,
0.1088440046,
-0.5646413565,
-0.3920733929,
0.1669541895,
-0.0665273145,
0.4163556695,
-0.0437486246,
-0.21621418,
-0.2696337104,
0.3366432488,
-0.3532283008,
0.4056505859,
0.3324237764,
-0.1174443141,
-0.414101094,
0.1791945249,
0.9521543384,
0.6448212266,
0.3437786698,
0.2188641876,
0.4456292987,
-0.2405994684,
0.1603750437,
-0.3552364409,
-0.1062278673,
0.1202146411,
0.3802630305,
0.5623420477,
0.1825851202,
-0.7739460468,
0.3147770166,
-0.0581977554,
-0.3181757033,
0.0251491889,
0.3128662705,
0.1632866859,
0.2749230266,
0.4013429284,
0.2167133987,
-0.0231289472,
-0.3978180587,
-0.0529413968,
0.3452341855,
-0.3471469283,
0.0156710278,
0.6307944655,
-0.0190248732,
-0.5929133296,
0.7340530753,
-0.1357445866,
-0.6320320964,
0.8979088664,
0.7731528878,
0.8194285035,
-0.0633023977,
0.1516440064,
0.4764758945,
0.3000561297,
-0.3846135437,
0.4186757207,
-0.2887496352,
-0.3716244698,
-0.8429178596,
-0.420557797,
-0.4502679706,
-0.2500192523,
-0.4214589894,
0.3834023178,
-0.7282241583,
0.1018575728,
-0.0039430289,
-0.3852370083,
-0.2620233595,
-0.0180545151,
0.4621875286,
1.3072154522,
-0.4536036551,
0.7963858843,
0.6320241094,
-0.4472688138,
-1.4027123451,
0.0169015378,
0.2813942134,
-0.9631134272,
0.7910655737,
0.3692347705,
-0.3008939326,
-0.0121999318,
-0.8903127313,
-0.2486599386,
0.7188908458,
0.3949965239,
-0.7017760277,
-0.090342246,
0.1639429927,
0.5435593128,
-0.2084557265,
0.302700609,
0.3933763504,
0.5733222365,
0.3712940216,
-0.6252660155,
0.475579232,
-0.2944084704,
0.1540828049,
0.4650140107,
-0.3036204278,
0.7711467743,
-0.4789721966,
0.0820731372,
0.1771942824,
0.2319964916,
0.6879341602,
0.3730569184,
0.5496416092,
-0.0075338176,
0.6492109299,
-0.230462119,
1.0588667393,
-0.5385910869,
0.0516747646,
0.7442992926,
-0.3696805537,
0.8547516465,
0.5822712779,
-0.0730564594,
0.5275942087,
0.5743786097,
0.0149912778,
0.087385878,
0.349355489,
-0.5877819657,
-0.3837611377,
-0.0253273528,
-0.4299937189,
0.1224452108,
0.4077063501,
-0.1601845324,
-0.1321691573,
-0.1309501976,
0.2137804031,
-0.1494421512,
-0.3492776155,
0.7710775137,
0.4699830711,
-1.1852202415,
0.8261015415,
-0.3975363374,
0.4706577659,
-0.6739135981,
-0.428159982,
-0.1714537144,
-0.1720888466,
-0.3996433914,
-0.8169240355,
0.2523914874,
0.1384341419,
0.011758225,
-0.3921990395,
0.6802353263,
-0.3669370413,
-0.0304176323,
0.2099370807,
0.3485499918,
0.0754347891,
-0.3643152714,
-0.8479206562,
0.187159881,
-0.0350369737,
-0.190392077,
0.2393481433,
0.5820023417,
-0.230553776,
0.6061347723,
1.1866236925,
0.1337596923,
0.0405485481,
0.4884082973,
0.7376573682,
-0.9353198409,
-0.3513143659,
-1.2389131784,
0.4276695549,
0.2039200813,
-0.1875798702,
0.631465137,
0.1342055351,
0.5614050031,
-0.3330031335,
0.6834936142,
-0.0133583788,
-0.3991432786,
-0.8411858082,
0.5920501947,
-0.3118813932,
0.4690894485,
-0.1566443294,
-0.9099392295,
-0.905985117,
0.5106301904,
-0.2281620055,
0.1123433933,
0.9807409644,
1.1729770899,
0.3920069933,
0.3882953227,
0.5800455809,
0.0990173742,
0.1934243888,
0.593819797,
1.278352499,
0.0374936908,
0.5018947721,
-0.0281181149,
-0.1658074409,
-0.2329123169,
-0.9419313669,
-0.990686655,
-0.2441421896,
-0.1671203226,
-0.6518301368,
0.0966706797,
1.453997612,
0.559482038,
-0.8136257529,
-0.2050347477,
-0.5163217783,
0.2137598991,
-0.4696405828,
-0.1514514685,
-0.0533373952,
-0.5998122096,
-0.6154837012,
0.242137447,
0.5099394917,
-0.034746971,
-0.3043189049,
-0.0901488736,
-0.1318784207,
0.1740572304,
0.660346806,
0.3224430978,
-0.7095497847,
-0.175131157,
0.2256302387,
-0.1352269799,
0.0323831178,
1.3002887964,
-0.708758533,
0.3857820034,
0.8126153946,
0.5288052559,
0.0386617146,
-0.2807139456,
0.664763093,
-0.7264164686,
0.0558329448,
0.3569963276,
0.4012678266,
-0.0925346538,
-0.5444704294,
0.4222979248,
-0.0687748045,
-0.5332272649,
-0.8775680661,
0.2696647346,
-0.8720936775,
-0.3975813687,
1.4759975672,
0.0021693225,
-0.3525395691,
-0.2286592424,
-0.7496685982,
0.0728038102,
-0.5617182851,
0.6825140119,
0.7421019077,
-0.3214447498,
-0.2315795869,
-0.5373383164,
0.437061578,
0.5353964567,
-0.8176113367,
0.257288903,
0.5908924937,
-0.2470238656,
0.2342218906,
0.4487784803,
-0.0215699356,
0.8335223198,
0.197137475,
0.0141920699,
-0.1709581763,
-0.5346735716,
-0.9166511893,
0.0316900164,
0.3296840787,
0.2611007988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18503v1 | From Adversarial Arms Race to Model-centric Evaluation: Motivating a Unified Automatic Robustness Evaluation Framework | 2023-05-29T14:55:20 | 2023-05-29T14:55:20 | Yangyi Chen, Hongcheng Gao, Ganqu Cui, Lifan Yuan, Dehan Kong, Hanlu Wu, Ning Shi, Bo Yuan, Longtao Huang, Hui Xue, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Textual adversarial attacks can discover models' weaknesses by adding
semantic-preserved but misleading perturbations to the inputs. The long-lasting
adversarial attack-and-defense arms race in Natural Language Processing (NLP)
is algorithm-centric, providing valuable techniques for automatic robustness
evaluation. However, the existing practice of robustness evaluation may exhibit
issues of incomprehensive evaluation, impractical evaluation protocol, and
invalid adversarial samples. In this paper, we aim to set up a unified
automatic robustness evaluation framework, shifting towards model-centric
evaluation to further exploit the advantages of adversarial attacks. To address
the above challenges, we first determine robustness evaluation dimensions based
on model capabilities and specify the reasonable algorithm to generate
adversarial samples for each dimension. Then we establish the evaluation
protocol, including evaluation settings and metrics, under realistic demands.
Finally, we use the perturbation degree of adversarial samples to control the
sample validity. We implement a toolkit RobTest that realizes our automatic
robustness evaluation framework. In our experiments, we conduct a robustness
evaluation of RoBERTa models to demonstrate the effectiveness of our evaluation
framework, and further show the rationality of each component in the framework.
The code will be made public at \url{https://github.com/thunlp/RobTest}. | [
-0.5105934143,
-1.0194242001,
0.3478398919,
-0.0794784725,
0.0063016741,
0.0345538892,
-0.198281914,
-0.2950137556,
-0.3476974964,
0.4640983045,
-0.584418714,
-0.3735325634,
-0.8067081571,
0.1633295417,
-0.6831456423,
1.2645915747,
0.2435364574,
0.1766699702,
-0.0766794384,
-0.3287235796,
-0.291934967,
-0.6516879797,
-0.4473757148,
-0.302734226,
0.0593499392,
-0.229403466,
1.0966467857,
0.6996559501,
0.7045003176,
0.3451434672,
-0.0690320581,
-0.0312816054,
-0.0974349827,
0.3181128502,
-0.2334411144,
-0.294067204,
-0.5388746858,
0.2024219483,
0.33762151,
0.5050510168,
0.0941748172,
0.1624273658,
0.0701797903,
0.5404853225,
-0.5768795013,
-0.1882990897,
-0.9705626965,
-0.0551642142,
-0.0655331016,
-0.1742187142,
-0.4080480039,
0.0530021712,
0.2126006037,
-0.3756809235,
0.3455305398,
-0.1506228149,
1.1240936518,
0.4438848495,
-0.2671830654,
-0.3354839385,
-0.5269326568,
0.8820494413,
-0.8515950441,
0.1656644344,
0.1108407825,
0.3713550866,
-0.3793262839,
-0.4289979637,
-0.3592634201,
-0.75237149,
0.2977267802,
-0.1846781671,
-0.4778877199,
0.0024975785,
0.1498258859,
0.2762664258,
-0.8590531349,
0.1062177867,
0.1259509474,
-0.2100693136,
0.7120320201,
0.118116729,
0.6230143905,
-0.1760521531,
-0.6443386078,
-0.3210195601,
-0.3458300531,
-0.1851071268,
0.7852250338,
0.5591775179,
-0.0069871498,
0.5444602966,
0.1854283363,
0.8838862777,
0.2197851539,
0.1296964288,
-0.1174698398,
-0.370367527,
-0.3069874942,
-0.4641694725,
1.0529257059,
0.0581618845,
0.0526703522,
-0.3227449954,
-0.3240126669,
0.323018223,
0.7810029387,
-0.5880404115,
-0.4685865045,
0.4166177809,
-0.4830456674,
-0.7548788786,
0.1186461151,
-0.9041619301,
-0.3976798356,
-0.2433992773,
0.7383108139,
-0.5788296461,
0.0076749609,
0.0765830055,
-0.2710403502,
-0.1865727752,
0.2243810743,
-0.8800737858,
0.3685404658,
0.8141995072,
0.5269363523,
-0.2588482499,
-0.3259396851,
-0.344021678,
-0.3187090456,
-0.0947229117,
0.7176629901,
-0.1898617297,
-0.0670228526,
-0.3960430324,
-0.1791076809,
-0.3280910552,
-0.3450988531,
0.59326756,
-0.5261523724,
0.39274773,
0.1886504591,
-0.4009208679,
-0.2023536563,
0.7350510955,
-0.7396841645,
0.816599369,
0.0315143093,
-0.9787856936,
0.2341514379,
-0.906865418,
-0.2927545309,
-0.2407439649,
-0.016075775,
-0.6043095589,
-0.1599653214,
0.5433319211,
0.2960178852,
-0.5086686611,
0.2142678946,
-0.6846225858,
-0.0712089539,
0.3302712739,
-0.8656035066,
1.4577839375,
0.1674798876,
-0.4758197069,
0.5064333081,
-0.936922431,
0.1662764698,
0.4153256118,
0.0095817531,
-0.2322944403,
-0.0952399522,
0.0507925674,
-0.168625176,
0.2410627902,
-0.2741714418,
0.2046947479,
-0.705521822,
0.4238109589,
0.8368165493,
-0.0662097409,
0.56537503,
-0.2613316476,
0.653459549,
-0.4915837646,
0.5772123933,
-0.0718198791,
-0.4304674566,
-0.4638028443,
-0.3301113248,
0.4810177386,
0.7389212847,
-0.4980251193,
0.8139280081,
0.0091619827,
-0.57365942,
-0.3056257963,
0.2789114118,
0.2970627248,
0.4311597049,
0.2467778623,
-0.3618477583,
-0.506493926,
-0.6590939164,
-0.2171160877,
-0.3764058053,
-0.2868833244,
-0.3845921457,
0.708984077,
-0.3097019494,
0.6259170175,
0.0329136476,
-0.0993309915,
-0.2988520563,
0.2943131328,
-0.110007681,
0.4603723884,
0.6815835834,
-0.8808811903,
-0.0225843191,
-0.1951471567,
-0.767505765,
-0.0642892867,
-0.0780171826,
-0.1579678804,
0.2172650695,
0.0940795019,
-0.3803099692,
0.4366361499,
0.7445562482,
-0.3305053115,
0.6736284494,
-0.1174119785,
0.0334278531,
-0.9593676329,
0.1860834956,
-0.2233368009,
-0.0975135341,
-0.3977339864,
0.6819767356,
-0.2438421249,
-0.2582108974,
0.0022722913,
0.4333009422,
-0.2367313057,
0.0267278533,
-0.3559105098,
0.1383342147,
0.2831360102,
0.199266538,
-0.4732784033,
0.4447222352,
0.4443697631,
-0.3992288709,
0.5799911618,
0.0319423974,
0.1632757038,
0.6116294861,
-0.694496274,
0.216006875,
0.1974212825,
0.0773286819,
-0.7743366957,
-0.0769531503,
0.3751080036,
-0.8083046675,
0.4247142076,
-0.2000390887,
-0.3732333481,
-0.1792174578,
-0.5007188916,
0.0141787799,
0.0937495977,
-0.5599871278,
0.7691050768,
0.5255286694,
0.1378023475,
-0.7733849287,
-0.4865137637,
0.3312565982,
-0.3029515147,
-0.8600390553,
-0.068090789,
-0.2053741664,
-0.366040051,
0.0293870196,
0.1315757483,
-0.1157084927,
0.6633889675,
0.3156372011,
0.4842931926,
-0.1399364173,
-0.2646305561,
-0.4510936439,
-0.4151719511,
0.2705503702,
-0.4778725207,
0.488322258,
-0.356361568,
-0.650112927,
-0.460167408,
0.3042954504,
0.7220352888,
-0.2284329981,
0.4262679815,
0.7802837491,
-0.3012825847,
-0.3748151362,
-0.3230991066,
-0.2466156185,
-0.3624663949,
0.4491918981,
-0.1850267798,
-0.6192306876,
0.5344129801,
0.2314340025,
0.2459454089,
0.6662014723,
0.5643920898,
0.2831765413,
1.2690021992,
0.668309927,
-0.2697894871,
0.0294144657,
-0.2754095793,
0.2902978063,
-0.6254368424,
0.2569114864,
-0.6732617021,
0.1167355105,
-0.3494648635,
-0.1473953724,
0.2862922251,
-0.1731673479,
-0.3319081664,
0.5805363059,
-0.6765668988,
0.0467663333,
0.4111107886,
-0.220118925,
0.1952142268,
-0.1759598404,
-0.134123385,
-0.1279884279,
-0.6464805007,
-0.7360903025,
1.2836488485,
0.4987480938,
0.6239092946,
0.014311702,
0.4000679851,
0.4177245498,
0.3641639948,
-0.7910243273,
0.4727299511,
-0.2246682644,
-0.6822524667,
-0.2442126274,
-0.4835702181,
-0.7722272277,
0.2069045007,
-0.3487530351,
-0.6534994245,
-0.1521360427,
0.1041397974,
-0.4182154238,
0.4992022514,
-0.3734373748,
1.1403993368,
-0.4631856084,
-0.0666126236,
0.0795392618,
-0.7033082247,
0.3848492503,
-0.0055444022,
0.129851386,
0.0057827332,
0.2051660717,
0.4917070568,
-0.4026243687,
0.4655825198,
-0.0180024356,
-0.1557805836,
0.0765893236,
0.2627135813,
0.2334687859,
0.0963134095,
-0.1691299081,
0.1536028087,
0.0372405238,
-0.2269371003,
-0.8056041002,
0.4988037646,
-0.6075897217,
-0.3302685022,
-0.5287501216,
-0.6336406469,
-0.1726493537,
0.2183990777,
0.3500954211,
0.4420923591,
-0.4894765019,
0.0951690897,
0.5969145298,
-0.0752683282,
0.118895255,
0.3399862349,
-0.23477377,
-0.4295986891,
0.7645248771,
-0.1959908754,
0.4379696548,
0.2020465285,
0.128064841,
-0.1809972376,
-0.7378931642,
-0.8316146135,
-0.3819921315,
-0.6016030312,
-0.3462622762,
-0.4371677339,
-0.1294536144,
-0.5492675304,
-0.1944302022,
-0.6718274951,
-0.2741095126,
-0.036807809,
0.235213995,
-0.0238814186,
0.6233505011,
-0.0490419604,
0.003772638,
-0.5179489851,
0.4403319061,
0.2150060833,
-0.1237278879,
-0.0154802529,
-0.6470936537,
0.0318206921,
0.0863239765,
-0.4611047208,
-0.7124387026,
0.4673922062,
-0.1012856364,
0.331074059,
0.4107291996,
0.151423052,
0.4090113938,
-0.0985631198,
0.7279778719,
-0.1779972166,
-0.9834812284,
0.5958861709,
-0.4608234167,
0.0675644204,
0.6943064928,
-0.0187504906,
0.2339570671,
-0.5832303166,
-0.8827912211,
-1.0148023367,
0.3648299575,
0.2906083763,
-0.0579241067,
0.3295424283,
0.1886232048,
-0.0699133724,
-0.0494663864,
-0.7323483825,
-0.1462002397,
-0.2108184993,
-0.1784102768,
0.2533832192,
-0.0230720434,
-0.5592601299,
0.1225992292,
0.8710489273,
-0.2306207567,
0.0187769476,
0.0645735413,
0.0549326874,
0.0616974831,
0.3587624431,
0.0457903184,
0.4726877511,
-0.3272576034,
0.0138483448,
0.1216720268,
-0.4290550053,
0.1747198552,
0.5807574391,
-0.5684491396,
-0.1743613929,
0.5092054009,
0.4765010774,
0.0436503105,
-0.6880558729,
0.7153902054,
-0.4405008256,
0.0072701322,
-0.4844663441,
0.0597573407,
-0.3133583069,
0.0715062767,
0.3438652158,
0.6525134444,
0.2918564081,
-0.4779479206,
0.2971734107,
0.9217785001,
-0.345254302,
-0.2379268855,
0.7853417993,
-0.2088012695,
-0.0753807724,
0.1981536299,
-0.4441866577,
-0.8111302257,
0.7199636102,
0.3839895725,
1.0007867813,
-0.1506368965,
0.1051517278,
0.1190464124,
0.6799787879,
-0.0135083096,
-0.0548091009,
0.0380265377,
-0.5833031535,
-0.1596440077,
-0.5175942779,
-0.5451658368,
0.1278217733,
-0.898855865,
0.1902227849,
-0.7978038788,
-0.2499115914,
0.122841917,
0.1996770203,
-0.2761453688,
0.4001217782,
0.0827880502,
0.5303885937,
-0.6749312282,
0.5120257735,
0.6963604093,
-0.1819465756,
-0.5896093845,
0.1088844985,
0.590477407,
-0.4478058815,
0.2759214938,
0.0824092329,
-0.2521533072,
-0.6183221936,
-0.5574902892,
-0.6860157847,
0.6987477541,
0.6719840169,
-0.0243520681,
0.087083742,
-0.3125472963,
0.5359720588,
-0.2553500235,
0.2280200273,
0.3393247128,
0.5064409971,
-0.1891950667,
-0.771083653,
-0.0132685862,
-0.556658268,
0.0237451773,
-0.0674691573,
-0.2971684933,
0.8339771628,
-0.0914472416,
-0.2889803052,
0.5438061953,
0.6783339381,
0.1059762985,
0.1502914429,
0.6482827067,
0.7048166394,
0.6294155717,
-0.1325951368,
1.1988010406,
-0.412850529,
0.369507581,
1.1812838316,
-0.1647789627,
0.780007422,
0.1522652805,
-0.1506519169,
0.1901251823,
0.2309933454,
-0.4508865476,
0.0578738824,
0.1611294299,
-0.0396712609,
-0.0767679438,
0.0922828987,
-0.1220323518,
0.7143387198,
0.0846112072,
-0.2366430759,
-0.382217586,
0.0400061533,
0.2723547518,
0.4534359872,
0.1253723353,
0.469156146,
-0.2585441768,
-0.4397947788,
0.5379694104,
0.3559035957,
0.7177420259,
-0.9901888371,
0.1263748407,
0.4301758707,
0.5113387704,
-0.0933116153,
-0.4588594735,
0.4568761885,
0.2369328737,
-0.1988094151,
0.0330644324,
0.7071291208,
0.0567992702,
-0.4945545197,
0.6412892938,
0.0740123987,
-0.3080385923,
-0.2069323361,
-1.1191717386,
0.2453715354,
0.0636126846,
-0.3371514082,
0.4883869886,
0.2445627004,
0.182401076,
0.757450521,
0.890286088,
0.2669698298,
-0.2472837865,
0.182500422,
0.7226445079,
-0.2277795523,
-0.1779620796,
-1.0445899963,
0.3177973032,
-0.0257883202,
-0.5054678917,
1.2184355259,
0.2694819868,
0.6866642237,
0.3185135126,
0.9073451161,
-0.1912777871,
0.5136827826,
-0.43341434,
0.9243103862,
-0.2945990562,
0.3728944957,
-0.4903309941,
-0.5721859932,
-0.6228061318,
0.6384808421,
-0.0858896524,
-0.0009593068,
0.3521508574,
0.7875761986,
-0.0127054509,
0.181136474,
0.0418437235,
0.1761017144,
0.4806657135,
0.395454973,
0.617002666,
-0.7517540455,
0.4793014824,
-0.4298957586,
-0.3014925718,
0.1044023931,
-1.0061072111,
-0.9737895131,
-0.4974550903,
-0.2684838474,
-0.6068612337,
0.3125916421,
0.9514154196,
0.6882146001,
-0.9385061264,
-0.0629233122,
-0.0897176117,
0.1162247807,
-0.1574159265,
-0.3120118082,
0.4732562602,
-0.3874033093,
-0.5936859846,
0.5763689876,
0.3666277826,
-0.0052641407,
-0.7317636609,
0.1319551021,
-0.0824319944,
0.083088994,
0.180431813,
0.3524803817,
-0.5399281979,
-0.0609595552,
-0.1843735874,
-0.0396469906,
-0.2219871581,
0.4755939245,
-0.4692167342,
0.6790575981,
0.2655943334,
0.9041661024,
-0.4528830051,
0.173210904,
0.8193439245,
-0.2704906166,
0.3342324197,
0.4327378869,
0.2825311422,
0.6073008776,
-0.3212734163,
0.4008986354,
0.0921106339,
-0.6447925568,
-1.0473837852,
0.0421713553,
-0.8619346023,
-0.2183834463,
0.7376586795,
-0.4114824533,
-0.3935665786,
-0.1240849867,
-0.0939583182,
0.1503421068,
0.013607787,
0.9297397733,
0.7117758989,
0.0954619423,
0.3905041218,
-0.5953339934,
0.4245918393,
0.569525063,
-0.6219038963,
0.0232968144,
0.2792963982,
0.2491315156,
0.3547270298,
0.1494959444,
-0.4707797468,
0.235476315,
0.2454491705,
-0.098643966,
-0.232943207,
-0.4062195718,
-0.6449952722,
0.470459193,
-0.0423937887,
-0.015803026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18500v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18500v2 | VAST: A Vision-Audio-Subtitle-Text Omni-Modality Foundation Model and Dataset | 2023-05-29T14:34:50 | 2023-10-07T12:58:26 | Sihan Chen, Handong Li, Qunbo Wang, Zijia Zhao, Mingzhen Sun, Xinxin Zhu, Jing Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Vision and text have been fully explored in contemporary video-text
foundational models, while other modalities such as audio and subtitles in
videos have not received sufficient attention. In this paper, we resort to
establish connections between multi-modality video tracks, including Vision,
Audio, and Subtitle, and Text by exploring an automatically generated
large-scale omni-modality video caption dataset called VAST-27M. Specifically,
we first collect 27 million open-domain video clips and separately train a
vision and an audio captioner to generate vision and audio captions. Then, we
employ an off-the-shelf Large Language Model (LLM) to integrate the generated
captions, together with subtitles and instructional prompts into omni-modality
captions. Based on the proposed VAST-27M dataset, we train an omni-modality
video-text foundational model named VAST, which can perceive and process
vision, audio, and subtitle modalities from video, and better support various
tasks including vision-text, audio-text, and multi-modal video-text tasks
(retrieval, captioning and QA). Extensive experiments have been conducted to
demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed VAST-27M corpus and VAST
foundation model. VAST achieves 22 new state-of-the-art results on various
cross-modality benchmarks. Code, model and dataset will be released at
https://github.com/TXH-mercury/VAST. | [
-0.5940787196,
-0.7212016582,
0.5995541215,
-0.0926590785,
-0.3890105486,
-0.0760651976,
-0.3024069667,
-0.3417006731,
0.1499921083,
0.587381959,
-0.7368130684,
-0.4769802392,
-0.3605972528,
-0.070532538,
-0.3294091821,
0.838858664,
-0.0478952602,
0.3073138297,
-0.1325849742,
-0.2824393213,
-0.8091211319,
-0.2279465646,
0.1172462925,
0.0813601315,
0.4888719618,
0.529022038,
0.703892529,
0.6424989104,
0.7807419896,
0.2762848437,
0.3469853997,
0.2592725754,
-0.1494264007,
-0.0862122923,
-0.0660706684,
-0.1799411774,
-0.3995214105,
-0.0498451367,
0.8306350708,
0.6736763716,
0.3240882456,
0.1989612281,
-0.2805694342,
0.5650188923,
-0.5597856641,
0.169715479,
-0.4286933839,
0.4364521801,
-0.1169833317,
-0.4967258275,
-0.1411870122,
0.1130342558,
0.4563382268,
-0.7831581235,
0.3287757933,
0.1264570057,
0.7574795485,
0.5113479495,
-0.5624971986,
-0.0402262881,
-0.7126862407,
0.6009381413,
-0.3923037052,
0.6852474213,
0.3370179534,
0.6614105105,
0.4870874286,
-0.2157734931,
-0.567645371,
-0.3563759029,
0.3204320669,
0.2645342946,
0.2125434577,
0.0976430029,
0.1021941081,
0.8939660192,
-0.53565979,
0.14982903,
-0.4764813185,
-0.0097355796,
0.3682224452,
0.4832576811,
0.5095056295,
-0.464325577,
-0.4634513855,
-0.1383291483,
-0.5064465404,
-0.1429922581,
0.2498752177,
0.2012985647,
-0.5609973073,
1.3205991983,
-0.293466568,
0.7903831601,
-0.1885195971,
-0.2799619138,
0.3843707442,
-0.6575749516,
-0.6482741833,
-0.115429692,
0.8467832804,
0.6522291303,
0.2641281486,
-0.0914404541,
0.0462760516,
0.0797207057,
0.1212884486,
-0.5108812451,
-0.1928138137,
0.0217916798,
-0.4542961121,
-0.0536833107,
0.1538945436,
-0.7143033743,
-0.6071252823,
-0.8518829942,
0.7841019034,
-0.6992474794,
-0.0125333406,
0.2557185888,
0.0157135911,
0.3994263709,
0.3569767773,
-0.7156324983,
0.0935110748,
0.2232664227,
0.7308564186,
-0.2137637883,
-0.388250798,
-0.7618221045,
0.3243721128,
-0.1416817904,
0.2936064899,
-0.6909376383,
0.2403179556,
0.3968040943,
0.055315543,
-0.0469825715,
-0.2507528961,
0.4991520643,
-0.4400395751,
0.5706652403,
-0.1995570511,
-0.3574551642,
-0.2339517772,
0.3298954964,
-1.083286047,
0.4927283823,
-0.3449270427,
-0.6553451419,
0.5077004433,
-0.803737402,
-0.3959428966,
-0.1041909605,
-0.375659585,
-0.2454061508,
0.1147549227,
0.343161732,
0.5486397743,
-0.6046122909,
0.4689794183,
0.0385339335,
-0.1073685288,
0.3140481412,
-0.8736626506,
0.1507280469,
0.0438300371,
-0.3052185178,
0.0931148157,
-0.7357538939,
-0.4765167832,
-0.1173228174,
-0.1963408589,
-0.1060129702,
-0.0413171574,
0.2753286362,
0.0284696352,
0.1337068677,
-0.569452703,
-0.1077791676,
-0.2310181558,
0.4674924314,
0.4889966547,
-0.2529689968,
0.6208944321,
-0.0952478945,
0.5010501146,
-0.052571293,
0.4132991135,
-0.5988669991,
-0.3235408962,
-0.7840160728,
-0.3911281228,
0.035388805,
0.4213313758,
-0.7867562175,
0.1611279845,
-0.3945645392,
-0.1409149617,
-0.0496464297,
-0.0416132361,
0.4139455855,
0.1608353853,
0.4856597185,
-0.2191936821,
-0.568234086,
-0.9891439676,
0.1203199998,
0.0281190202,
-0.1321143806,
0.7331425548,
0.5186871886,
-0.3514095545,
0.8987716436,
-0.573630929,
-0.8042722344,
0.1190431863,
-0.1039270014,
0.2254722863,
0.3885807693,
0.491828084,
-1.1887252331,
-0.464761883,
0.2171040475,
-0.7328754663,
0.0859798491,
-0.1039383188,
0.0389568955,
-0.0495870523,
0.5346369743,
-0.481639564,
0.1319808513,
0.6152690649,
-0.2837198973,
0.7516269684,
-0.0371714421,
0.4112088382,
-1.0534374714,
0.0724559277,
-0.1637346148,
-0.0065209973,
-0.2204141319,
0.0605987534,
-0.1920919716,
-0.2705620229,
-0.5161235332,
0.2911936641,
-0.4885638356,
-0.2919787467,
0.0651481673,
0.1349804252,
-0.0492119938,
0.6184297204,
0.1160651669,
0.612095654,
0.8883897662,
-0.3831176162,
0.6628636122,
0.3703573942,
-0.2940016091,
0.7666903734,
-0.4592601061,
-0.6089713573,
-0.2917679846,
0.0267538354,
-1.116808176,
-0.7962414622,
0.1634627581,
-0.4374936223,
0.1868737936,
-0.0542867854,
-0.4783415198,
-0.2208243161,
-0.1539363861,
0.603286624,
0.062831752,
-0.3188123405,
1.2476241589,
0.277240783,
-0.11496488,
-0.5179526806,
-0.9128961563,
0.322466284,
-0.3266404569,
-0.6079055667,
0.2992290258,
-0.2865039706,
0.0467100963,
-0.0409424901,
-0.217482388,
-0.3942869306,
-0.4795947075,
0.5487288237,
0.4183995724,
-0.311594218,
0.1947034895,
0.0940596908,
0.2233773023,
0.1663363576,
-0.3633599579,
0.4344707131,
-0.0925830007,
-0.4303925633,
-0.1251631081,
0.5351371169,
0.9710432291,
-0.5427289009,
0.4795166254,
0.7591412663,
-0.2431836277,
0.1160562411,
-0.6415788531,
-0.1419072598,
-0.3876976669,
0.6608188748,
-0.4197441041,
-1.0613507032,
0.4370751977,
0.2410602123,
0.1429917067,
0.3180727661,
0.4457572103,
0.0171255395,
0.8617009521,
0.853718996,
0.096597828,
0.6995779872,
-0.3518767953,
-0.1515315771,
-0.6164133549,
-0.438629508,
-0.1234224215,
-0.0562158823,
-0.156701386,
-0.7317824364,
0.4895788431,
-0.3065285981,
-0.4723015428,
0.3677698672,
-0.2377386838,
0.5633843541,
0.4606092274,
0.1030683666,
0.3811677098,
0.3778672218,
-0.329927206,
-0.358160764,
-0.6630551219,
-0.2217322141,
0.9640858173,
0.560123682,
0.8462606072,
0.4506417513,
0.0880036056,
0.4886727333,
0.0319305733,
-0.7637357116,
0.5271170139,
-0.4806330502,
-0.7188476324,
-0.2039468437,
-0.3806507289,
-0.5349155068,
0.1059322432,
-0.3986418843,
-0.3379970193,
-0.108858265,
-0.1375993639,
-0.3662789166,
0.3103846312,
-0.4133884013,
0.9658112526,
-0.4159715176,
-0.3606326282,
-0.0290067606,
-1.0058034658,
0.5481202602,
-0.0983007178,
0.3935533762,
0.2655484676,
-0.1936239153,
0.6611914039,
-0.1679770201,
0.9972264171,
0.2452115417,
-0.4190464318,
0.3163014948,
-0.0034152216,
-0.022791177,
0.1783977747,
0.7040646672,
-0.0899597928,
-0.4001091421,
-0.0573886558,
-0.035347838,
0.5643281341,
-0.9731013179,
-0.1400541812,
-0.2496039122,
-0.7708705068,
-0.2899718285,
0.3684089482,
0.2069113553,
1.0271379948,
-0.1289144903,
0.602765739,
1.0772927999,
-0.6434293389,
0.4492231905,
0.7931627035,
-0.284624517,
-1.0562090874,
0.8262526393,
-0.2046172619,
0.5461195707,
0.8173965812,
0.110609673,
-0.1877117753,
-0.2450284809,
-0.6923270822,
0.2293864191,
-0.6972374916,
-0.3815580308,
-0.7905402184,
-0.142071709,
-0.2243829668,
-0.1841405928,
-0.3833285868,
0.0433941856,
-0.1460300088,
-0.130997166,
0.4243836999,
0.2929515541,
-0.149869591,
0.2673607767,
-0.9724508524,
0.8259494901,
0.707229197,
0.4947029054,
-0.2064472437,
-0.6782120466,
-0.3006913066,
0.0761510804,
-0.0261342991,
-0.7531090379,
0.3455356658,
0.45435974,
0.3997611701,
0.4153195024,
-0.1767089218,
0.4920123219,
-0.8052657843,
0.9644058943,
0.661264956,
-0.8403292894,
0.2466353923,
-0.8305896521,
0.392604202,
0.3268246651,
0.2924450934,
-0.3213299811,
-0.1842716336,
-0.1338130981,
-0.8299122453,
0.4962314069,
0.2927953303,
0.2423375547,
0.3872029483,
-0.1220333874,
0.3291131854,
0.4109033048,
-0.9280933142,
-0.1755908728,
-0.5537998676,
-0.207183674,
-0.0131868962,
0.0836715922,
-0.2877780795,
-0.0090793325,
0.219429791,
-0.5480515957,
0.2126457989,
0.2959797084,
-0.1191192195,
-0.1553557813,
0.2436127663,
0.6028314829,
0.3825078607,
-0.2012609839,
0.1953730881,
-0.0425175279,
-0.6883204579,
-0.1150367782,
0.2409103364,
0.052501712,
0.0125442659,
0.4005243778,
0.8719014525,
0.2257557362,
-1.1073143482,
0.6148260236,
0.2084498703,
-0.4271501005,
-0.5257573128,
-0.2356912792,
-0.1926019639,
0.3450467885,
0.6276760101,
0.2021630555,
0.3009545803,
-0.7574842572,
0.1080874428,
0.3371939361,
-0.7299829125,
-0.1134098992,
0.990003109,
0.2360085249,
0.0962876827,
-0.0341077968,
0.3656441569,
-0.5952250957,
0.491389066,
-0.0958210304,
0.7180555463,
0.3782953918,
0.4724176228,
0.1418419331,
0.3597252667,
0.0349723771,
0.3043627143,
-0.2262631208,
-0.3789252043,
-1.0016102791,
-0.5813192725,
-0.3958320618,
0.289765805,
-0.4095824063,
0.1270804703,
-0.1952660382,
0.0981272087,
0.0607782714,
-0.1559647173,
-0.7146006227,
0.6583717465,
0.5201864243,
0.6786200404,
-1.0802532434,
0.4000861645,
0.8860808015,
-0.8352615237,
-0.6894291043,
-0.2910290658,
-0.1836147159,
-0.400131911,
0.6140606999,
0.2653230727,
0.0374627002,
-0.3758092523,
-0.7945533991,
-0.8923718333,
0.9879453778,
0.2870868146,
-0.6908892393,
-0.0347466059,
0.6236999035,
0.3506172299,
-0.431874156,
0.0551129356,
0.0323112085,
0.5290406942,
0.1486001462,
-1.0936009884,
-0.2410269529,
-0.2036900222,
-0.5273810625,
0.1325093657,
-0.5696755052,
1.0216683149,
-0.0720496848,
0.0837981552,
0.3063902855,
0.6764973998,
0.0911932066,
0.3447987437,
0.4797765315,
0.4835985303,
-0.0173315853,
0.106950298,
0.6624656916,
0.045078706,
0.1420943439,
1.1469970942,
-0.0115058813,
0.4701169133,
0.5440715551,
0.0823813602,
0.3557885587,
0.2257443815,
-0.161511749,
0.5420752764,
0.0496292524,
-0.1611841172,
-0.5275840163,
-0.3903049231,
-0.4678268731,
0.5164182782,
0.098605983,
-0.6897628903,
-0.0832910314,
0.5486859679,
-0.4477514029,
0.1443465799,
-0.4170438051,
0.5482382178,
-0.0544243157,
-0.5184264779,
0.3262153566,
-0.245819822,
0.6922906041,
-0.6729509234,
-0.0998624042,
0.078131251,
0.0349644162,
-0.1206155866,
-0.8569540381,
-0.1510301381,
0.1796502322,
-0.555360496,
-0.0439026393,
0.3625234365,
-0.6608825326,
-0.2490457296,
0.0080347201,
0.4519793689,
0.0677196383,
-0.2528561056,
-0.2748729587,
0.1771967709,
-0.0527138412,
0.1055517644,
0.0427438989,
0.7253085375,
-0.0475890115,
0.3138152063,
0.6006355882,
-0.333337307,
0.24954772,
0.386362493,
1.0627696514,
-0.6876935363,
-0.3829356134,
-0.5634124279,
0.54504776,
0.0072777737,
-0.374938339,
0.8383735418,
0.7820173502,
0.6360068917,
-0.5631477237,
0.8081145287,
-0.4354242086,
0.0016339823,
-0.6952742934,
0.3155815899,
-0.8913012743,
-0.0007236301,
-0.6913332343,
-1.2327034473,
-0.3614415824,
0.2122550756,
-0.0973156318,
-0.3214771152,
0.7576509714,
0.470351398,
-0.2796765864,
0.0279248655,
0.2618634403,
0.0795954168,
0.1910925657,
0.7251060605,
0.9099427462,
-0.6612291336,
0.9076923132,
0.0001825933,
-0.1265204698,
-0.2718549967,
-0.8370213509,
-1.1102800369,
-0.5824052691,
-0.2952119112,
0.0227525886,
-0.1960205138,
0.5241305828,
0.6894959807,
-0.4709200859,
0.0095726168,
-0.1577913165,
-0.4904997945,
-0.0078222631,
-0.2295523435,
0.2248933762,
0.2217472643,
-0.6255464554,
0.4496324956,
0.2312071025,
0.0469741374,
-0.7826119661,
-0.2377284765,
-0.0989996716,
0.1822280437,
0.7664412856,
0.1712335944,
-0.6622375846,
-0.2675165534,
0.488085568,
-0.034055762,
-0.1409496516,
0.7874740362,
-0.5691661239,
0.5370162725,
0.6564750671,
0.558360815,
0.3111834526,
-0.1624853462,
0.6549309492,
-0.5572665334,
-0.1651766896,
0.1209649444,
0.3935692608,
0.4647043049,
0.1185447052,
0.6155395508,
0.2308027893,
-0.3246268332,
-0.7277631164,
0.3627913892,
-1.5028533936,
-0.152857244,
1.3116514683,
0.1783124208,
-0.0208611991,
-0.0882209837,
-0.7028511763,
0.0716924667,
-0.3330937922,
0.3337202072,
0.3671764731,
0.5349280834,
-0.2425412089,
-0.7912154198,
0.0837095827,
0.4387773871,
-0.5285241604,
0.037661273,
1.1300088167,
0.1650378108,
0.4028535485,
0.0207496658,
-0.1694131196,
0.5588860512,
-0.0970669612,
-0.1198923364,
-0.4168893099,
-0.6782095432,
-0.071553655,
0.4913983941,
-0.5895918608,
-0.3285341263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18109v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18109v1 | Medical Dialogue Generation via Dual Flow Modeling | 2023-05-29T14:23:34 | 2023-05-29T14:23:34 | Kaishuai Xu, Wenjun Hou, Yi Cheng, Jian Wang, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Medical dialogue systems (MDS) aim to provide patients with medical services,
such as diagnosis and prescription. Since most patients cannot precisely
describe their symptoms, dialogue understanding is challenging for MDS.
Previous studies mainly addressed this by extracting the mentioned medical
entities as critical dialogue history information. In this work, we argue that
it is also essential to capture the transitions of the medical entities and the
doctor's dialogue acts in each turn, as they help the understanding of how the
dialogue flows and enhance the prediction of the entities and dialogue acts to
be adopted in the following turn. Correspondingly, we propose a Dual Flow
enhanced Medical (DFMed) dialogue generation framework. It extracts the medical
entities and dialogue acts used in the dialogue history and models their
transitions with an entity-centric graph flow and a sequential act flow,
respectively. We employ two sequential models to encode them and devise an
interweaving component to enhance their interactions. Experiments on two
datasets demonstrate that our method exceeds baselines in both automatic and
manual evaluations. | [
-0.3230988383,
-0.6279071569,
0.8958444595,
-0.1849080026,
-0.4417963624,
0.3730116487,
0.244094342,
-0.3127855361,
0.2348522395,
0.863668561,
-0.9852205515,
-0.4162739515,
-0.5362516642,
0.1337127537,
-0.1954892725,
1.060428381,
-0.0960487202,
0.5010504127,
-0.1347189397,
-0.0913220197,
-0.504853487,
-0.2300686985,
-0.8437007666,
-0.5478793979,
0.249277398,
0.1725162864,
0.6431507468,
0.0718675256,
0.3862605095,
0.2944377661,
0.080657959,
0.5559121966,
-0.2510764301,
0.5096209645,
-0.1410376132,
-0.0831122398,
-0.2896512747,
-0.1452977061,
0.6443126202,
0.7498966455,
-0.2769030631,
-0.0569602177,
0.2053957134,
0.3840436637,
0.1274194717,
0.3241680562,
-0.3056931198,
0.2650141418,
0.1332279742,
-0.4683454931,
-0.1990198344,
-0.1768859476,
0.2899513543,
-0.3881409764,
-0.0555940457,
-0.3819559216,
0.6466189027,
0.4497842193,
-0.8530557752,
-0.4642474651,
-0.6970248222,
0.0810844749,
-0.7901341319,
0.1988688707,
-0.1452120692,
0.3736730516,
-0.4054403901,
-1.1423904896,
-0.5912217498,
-0.1107502356,
-0.2049218267,
0.1948784441,
-0.1143218502,
0.4236784279,
0.1286282986,
0.363437742,
-0.1453313082,
0.032969363,
-0.2121766508,
-0.1019445211,
0.5682988167,
0.7001233101,
0.4815421402,
-0.2168561518,
-0.4645923674,
0.0757209361,
-0.4438590407,
0.0401960202,
-0.0279233493,
0.2417264432,
-0.1611190736,
0.3932338357,
0.0365061313,
0.5662180185,
0.3686387539,
-0.4819123149,
0.1460004449,
-0.6088718772,
-0.2665604055,
-0.1775433868,
0.9659600258,
0.5496442318,
-0.1157961935,
0.1360104978,
-0.043314103,
-0.144327119,
0.4313146472,
-1.0550819635,
-0.1305699646,
0.4425463974,
-0.5196248889,
-0.5661950111,
-0.114357397,
-0.9321129322,
-0.6384552717,
-0.4327135682,
0.0285167657,
-0.4094486535,
-0.6639333367,
-0.0472093597,
0.0456385389,
-0.2009934932,
0.4454646111,
-0.4933472574,
0.5266754627,
0.5748566985,
0.7383324504,
-0.0627811328,
0.2757114768,
-0.5755510926,
0.0386759229,
-0.1425538212,
0.6612815261,
-0.7074318528,
-0.7712803483,
0.1892022043,
-0.2350713015,
-0.2567082047,
-0.6311759353,
0.2818284631,
-0.2782540619,
0.2099459618,
0.0617491119,
-0.4854351282,
-0.3528446257,
-0.122756429,
-0.4514491558,
0.648791492,
0.2666425109,
-0.7017160058,
0.3634699881,
-0.7619599104,
-0.6540237665,
0.299806565,
-0.7988449335,
-0.3485122919,
0.1856849641,
0.2242950201,
0.516061306,
-0.6143199801,
0.7843088508,
-0.2933613956,
0.0447792672,
0.3871167004,
-0.4582071006,
0.6922608614,
0.2849247754,
-0.1268467009,
0.0061557512,
-0.7463384867,
-0.0319903195,
0.0974120572,
-0.1680312008,
0.0589861088,
0.0026512814,
-0.4532010853,
0.5391721129,
-0.2079613358,
-0.291560024,
0.1904503554,
-0.4235422313,
0.2438832372,
0.5286281109,
0.7345257998,
0.2162054628,
-0.312723726,
0.7269144654,
0.606824398,
-0.1031805575,
-0.3623521924,
-0.6167244911,
-0.4593851268,
-0.4193759263,
0.0914913639,
0.6642600298,
-1.0531033278,
0.2490083128,
-0.2420063317,
-0.2101084143,
-0.469822526,
-0.1037843972,
0.3769088089,
0.8339030743,
0.1005822718,
-0.4294979572,
-0.4456162453,
-0.6466468573,
0.0458738916,
-0.5068493485,
0.0136992196,
0.6776071787,
0.0527253486,
-0.3423210382,
0.7016782165,
-0.6694232821,
0.0901956707,
-0.3349150717,
0.199709475,
0.1625184715,
0.3486807644,
0.419141531,
-0.7157710791,
-0.4020450115,
-0.1558685303,
-0.7190813422,
-0.2406650484,
-0.3659382164,
-0.2668372691,
-0.1572347879,
0.2991379797,
-0.3691589832,
0.5915048718,
0.4935182631,
-0.5198087692,
0.289254427,
-0.1425548643,
0.4007899165,
-1.4868030548,
0.0165424757,
-0.0742902383,
-0.3142036796,
-0.8995611072,
-0.3011211157,
-0.1818474829,
-0.3479907513,
-0.0514814742,
0.376578778,
-0.351937592,
0.2760092616,
-0.1359515041,
-0.3130067885,
0.1404550225,
0.4257965088,
0.2030463517,
0.4030150473,
0.5859481692,
-0.5872923136,
0.2495007217,
0.3511101902,
-0.2086117119,
0.7887764573,
-0.3558351696,
0.2403310537,
-0.0194004998,
0.4992946982,
-0.9954822659,
-0.1644033641,
0.5001907945,
-0.2501755059,
0.844227314,
-0.4267730117,
-0.2258173525,
-0.6491391063,
0.101563938,
0.1440190971,
0.4663698077,
-0.3162448108,
0.6947726607,
0.6609753966,
-0.5142745972,
-0.3043389618,
-0.3214327991,
0.1729185134,
-0.1165497005,
-0.8053202033,
0.0226283167,
-0.0630366206,
-0.0674694702,
-0.1591828018,
-0.0913371667,
-0.2279713005,
-0.0174886696,
0.6306602359,
0.4978531003,
-0.3522479236,
0.2074638903,
0.658659935,
-0.0221411921,
0.2284141183,
-0.3507732749,
0.5297765136,
0.3528232872,
-0.4612002969,
-0.7054876089,
0.791867733,
0.8948082924,
-0.137414366,
0.7370742559,
0.3590724468,
-0.4607473314,
0.0317544639,
-0.4110798836,
-0.4065532088,
-0.42248559,
0.2911456823,
-0.4140963256,
-0.5755686164,
0.5355657935,
-0.6210833192,
0.3078653812,
0.3495222926,
0.8056507707,
-0.071293883,
1.2761592865,
0.1633600891,
0.6434891224,
0.2588392198,
-0.3379528821,
0.1967701614,
-0.9217369556,
-0.4200493097,
0.0087132724,
-0.1703977138,
-0.2858290374,
-0.5895528793,
0.8093748689,
0.0018947861,
0.1727167815,
-0.0656061098,
-0.3246867657,
-0.2776954174,
0.1737006158,
0.3002530932,
0.2407624274,
0.1720258147,
-0.7049524188,
-0.0823335722,
-0.6537334323,
-0.4995420277,
0.9387159348,
0.5250354409,
0.577380538,
0.0384919941,
0.899109602,
-0.0473167077,
0.317214489,
-0.5843042135,
0.4726702571,
-0.1531333178,
-0.4300618172,
-0.0551728234,
-0.5211390257,
-0.8283825517,
0.376843065,
-0.3314323425,
-0.5677875876,
0.2419701368,
0.1786972433,
-0.861071527,
0.2033087611,
-0.5451844335,
0.591884315,
-0.0362639204,
-0.1257103682,
-0.311098963,
-0.8571444154,
0.4235852957,
-0.085543476,
0.2144689709,
-0.1402140707,
0.1382997036,
0.4874945283,
-0.961044848,
0.9279464483,
-0.4150957167,
-0.1851848662,
0.4995438457,
0.1308698356,
0.3530406058,
0.5728750229,
0.1437162161,
0.1086569205,
0.1216598675,
0.2598208785,
-0.7327725291,
0.4839631617,
-0.3160283267,
-0.6505496502,
-0.1993643641,
-0.3363077939,
-0.5428683162,
0.0127577279,
0.1053485721,
0.9126996994,
-0.4335182309,
-0.3848287463,
0.3676317632,
-0.0022170781,
0.1339955479,
0.7215189934,
-0.1367100179,
-0.4412940145,
0.270414561,
0.1998296529,
0.3408638835,
0.0609527528,
0.2310554981,
-0.4601062536,
-0.6509321332,
-0.948350966,
0.4338011742,
-0.5451039672,
-0.4181800783,
-0.9914213419,
-0.3507528603,
-0.5007402301,
0.2605995834,
-0.0435001776,
-0.4282181263,
-0.5317385793,
-0.0425146632,
0.2560705841,
0.8858606219,
-0.1525638103,
-0.0773998946,
-1.096247673,
0.382773459,
0.2898826301,
0.2869599462,
-0.0457637198,
-0.3515638113,
-0.0322048962,
0.2234414518,
-0.37981987,
-1.1805038452,
0.2398858517,
0.0808646604,
0.5330989957,
0.5930618048,
0.0567449965,
0.7099440694,
-0.929774642,
0.7494984269,
0.6212437153,
-0.5178368092,
0.6222100854,
-0.0016900648,
0.1021763682,
0.4962952733,
0.1524757892,
-0.688621819,
-0.4703734517,
-0.5879354477,
-0.5821262598,
0.7455089092,
0.0596387349,
0.0645877644,
-0.0784452409,
0.2865442634,
0.2668175995,
0.1613918692,
-0.0057981606,
-0.1904366612,
0.0309924055,
-0.6407729983,
0.1651185006,
-0.2248468548,
-0.565489471,
-0.1313249916,
0.3909879923,
-0.1508924067,
0.2207387984,
0.3552894592,
0.1350240707,
-0.2376497835,
0.1214004755,
0.3523667753,
0.3332288861,
0.2167941034,
-0.1416917592,
0.0169871021,
-0.6904397011,
0.2155732214,
0.2178391367,
0.0418026149,
0.2412410378,
0.1719638854,
1.0589016676,
0.1481196135,
-0.6730245948,
0.5004755855,
-0.1534686983,
-0.0026201108,
-0.0929864049,
0.108656764,
-0.004946054,
0.5278688669,
-0.0386351421,
0.1763366759,
0.5590540171,
-0.5728712082,
0.3894981742,
0.360740453,
-0.5516569018,
-0.2623386383,
0.4566245973,
0.7381731868,
-0.2898400128,
0.6254244447,
0.0173145104,
-0.4256670773,
0.3364177942,
0.5667447448,
0.9492519498,
-0.1810878366,
0.2490312904,
0.4663918316,
-0.2662756443,
0.1576781869,
0.2401331812,
-0.1504999399,
-0.5276710391,
-0.2566007674,
-0.5009334087,
-0.3324603736,
-0.0843277872,
-0.7653479576,
0.3450894356,
-0.2340207696,
-0.5911222696,
0.0794947892,
0.0033612705,
-0.7549034357,
0.2046493888,
0.391004324,
0.6377040744,
-0.5581387281,
0.5710645318,
0.5533687472,
-0.3330607712,
-0.8393726945,
0.0904902518,
0.2654680312,
-0.9009796381,
0.3573920429,
-0.0199047476,
-0.3414533436,
-0.1599194258,
0.0369714871,
-0.5922481418,
1.0724129677,
0.2282916605,
-0.5242220163,
-0.2642193735,
0.0843147263,
0.4906816781,
-0.8840418458,
0.1630458832,
0.5090448856,
0.0714575574,
0.5372226834,
-1.1308463812,
0.3969362378,
-0.2422521114,
-0.0035677054,
0.3817235827,
-0.3151055276,
0.5434128046,
-0.6166961193,
-0.6907716393,
0.1047024503,
0.3052400053,
0.0330548994,
0.5179077387,
0.7048370242,
0.3454892039,
0.9393327236,
0.0435399301,
1.0221419334,
-0.4520225227,
-0.0547566637,
1.0718609095,
-0.489998281,
0.5116198659,
0.2234747857,
-0.0968743935,
0.8366162181,
0.4332369268,
0.3194494843,
0.4234606028,
0.0902297124,
-0.4985244274,
-0.2589281499,
-0.0360466242,
-0.497014612,
0.4264452755,
0.7402225733,
-0.825314045,
0.0701674148,
0.089389652,
0.0612406209,
-0.2665932775,
-0.0989461094,
1.3947989941,
0.2018539459,
-0.9351979494,
0.5618761182,
-0.4938762188,
-0.0424483828,
-0.5146210194,
-0.2445158511,
-0.0340908282,
-0.0937400758,
-0.0090604583,
-0.937607646,
0.0375267714,
-0.0154893287,
0.0398907475,
-0.2725093067,
0.6370408535,
-0.6313328147,
-0.5758289695,
0.1736843139,
0.5192917585,
0.2148916274,
0.2674349844,
-0.7907841802,
-0.2011740804,
0.2642074525,
-0.0550233759,
0.0809134021,
0.4232769907,
0.1352554262,
0.5134317279,
0.4404262304,
0.162281245,
-0.1259345114,
0.4270365536,
1.0230774879,
-0.4237487912,
-0.4794674218,
-0.6003687978,
0.8704904914,
-0.5003893971,
-0.2177127153,
-0.0409756824,
0.3575760722,
0.1284142584,
0.1594134867,
0.821002841,
0.2171744257,
0.8557335734,
-0.6993038058,
0.6417405009,
-0.4866914451,
0.1569187045,
-0.1560006291,
-0.2812637091,
0.020035401,
0.1467704028,
0.16892986,
-0.0768380314,
0.7145348191,
0.6046120524,
0.0404694155,
0.1979583055,
0.2250306159,
0.2432960868,
0.367393434,
0.5706254244,
0.8881059289,
-0.1761417091,
0.3994149268,
-0.0954423621,
-0.404492259,
-0.3285479844,
-0.3865588903,
-0.8426118493,
-0.6137830019,
-0.5624887347,
-0.6775386333,
-0.2030289024,
0.8945756555,
0.6812619567,
-0.7358394861,
0.0706479177,
0.1251685768,
-0.0867357701,
-0.1172059178,
-0.1342487484,
-0.0365348645,
-0.2135331929,
-0.5931520462,
0.4886591136,
0.644888103,
0.414627552,
-0.3276170194,
-0.1292372346,
0.2748187482,
0.4422830045,
0.3867743015,
0.0491824932,
-0.6553595662,
-0.1969544441,
-0.2348817289,
-0.064299196,
0.2046072185,
1.3519389629,
-0.8490706682,
0.7501567602,
0.2868402898,
0.3425326049,
0.4248804748,
-0.1207622215,
0.9522471428,
-0.3261597455,
-0.0500289276,
0.4998033345,
0.444100678,
0.2363162488,
-0.504907012,
0.3458079994,
0.1604483724,
-0.2646123767,
-0.8876097202,
0.6256846786,
-0.8060093522,
-0.1439717859,
0.9895877242,
-0.2976946831,
0.3798606992,
-0.3772966266,
-0.4560552835,
0.5427510142,
-0.2615619004,
0.36980021,
0.43576473,
-0.703570962,
0.1217665896,
-0.291888535,
0.5796685219,
0.0994748026,
-0.6398237944,
-0.063463673,
0.5886628628,
0.2633345723,
0.0420235582,
0.8650898337,
-0.3174059093,
0.249911353,
0.2225647122,
-0.4643041492,
0.026889924,
-0.1871048361,
-0.3561030328,
0.1286866665,
-0.2395380586,
-0.274636507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18498v2 | ANPL: Towards Natural Programming with Interactive Decomposition | 2023-05-29T14:19:40 | 2023-11-30T16:08:54 | Di Huang, Ziyuan Nan, Xing Hu, Pengwei Jin, Shaohui Peng, Yuanbo Wen, Rui Zhang, Zidong Du, Qi Guo, Yewen Pu, Yunji Chen | cs.PL | cs.PL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Though LLMs are capable of generating plausible programs, it's challenging to
interact with the LLMs further to revise the program, especially if the user's
specific requirements are different from the initial proposal. In this paper,
we introduce ANPL, an interactive programming system that ensures users can
always refine the generated code towards their specific programmatic intents
via structured decompositions. Borrowing the paradigm of sketching from program
synthesis, an ANPL program consists of a set of input-outputs that it must
satisfy, a ``sketch'' -- control/data flow expressed in precise code (e.g.
Python), and ``holes'' -- sub-modules to be implemented by the LLM specified
with natural language. The user revises an ANPL program by either modifying the
sketch, changing the language used to describe the holes, or providing
additional input-outputs to a particular hole, turning it into a sub-ANPL
program that can be solved recursively. This workflow allows the users to
offload programming burdens to the LLM as much as possible while retaining the
ability to pinpoint and resolve bugs locally, without exposing the rest of the
program to the LLM. We deploy ANPL on the Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus
(ARC), a set of unique tasks that are challenging for state-of-the-art AI
systems, showing it outperforms baseline programming systems that (a) without
the ability to decompose tasks interactively and (b) without the guarantee that
the modules can be correctly composed together. Additional evaluations on APPS,
HumanEval, and real-world programming tasks have validated that the ANPL
framework is applicable to multiple programming domains. We release the ANPL
solutions to the ARC tasks as a dataset, providing insights into how humans
decompose novel tasks programmatically. See our code at
https://iprc-dip.github.io/ANPL/. | [
-0.3536232412,
-0.6961773634,
0.4671144485,
0.4335928857,
0.2714769244,
0.6415959001,
-0.3791440725,
-0.3918988407,
0.1029325426,
0.6765124798,
-0.9150934815,
-0.5059396625,
-0.0419315062,
0.348821342,
-0.3354833126,
0.4779871702,
-0.1232208312,
-0.2921658158,
-0.3550983667,
-0.0090641966,
0.0346477181,
-0.3836239278,
-0.7094233036,
-0.4164555073,
0.1460531354,
0.3951035738,
0.6149052382,
0.6533414721,
0.4759574234,
0.3535746634,
0.1112679243,
0.3556800783,
-0.4046793878,
0.2102125585,
-0.1008341089,
-0.6027971506,
-0.2266106158,
-0.073855035,
0.2860862911,
0.6917004585,
-0.0881226808,
0.0240710061,
-0.1996436268,
0.696115315,
-0.5540193319,
0.310005635,
-0.2710876167,
0.2188969702,
-0.0296624061,
-0.3015623093,
-0.4603339136,
-0.5090664029,
-0.0248443335,
-0.8818935752,
-0.0425194912,
-0.0117974458,
0.593645215,
0.6057014465,
-0.0884985849,
-0.4929996729,
-0.9388332963,
0.7339990735,
-0.8423851728,
-0.0764147788,
0.1045182124,
0.485599488,
-0.4123907089,
-0.849009037,
-0.6867386699,
-0.4342792034,
-0.1665939689,
-0.0622928478,
-0.0482143126,
0.3318681419,
0.3666643798,
0.5456140637,
-0.360814333,
0.0624962114,
-0.2082612664,
-0.325602591,
0.7927241921,
0.3016573191,
0.780190587,
-0.0510622934,
-0.3667950034,
0.1509259343,
-0.8152244687,
0.1179793254,
0.6192685366,
0.0327162668,
-0.2014151216,
0.7872508764,
-0.2260339409,
0.6568217874,
-0.1262165308,
0.0558991991,
0.1291986555,
-0.3669915497,
-0.0128806354,
-0.1662167758,
0.5066201687,
0.0941901654,
0.3363717198,
-0.0694747493,
-0.347933054,
0.1381714344,
0.4004602134,
-0.3541682363,
-0.6434608102,
0.4806106389,
-0.3235096931,
-0.2011478245,
-0.1444799006,
-0.3677598834,
-0.3970601857,
-0.6750823855,
0.126003921,
-0.5186826587,
-0.1035381705,
0.0846177638,
-0.0830856562,
0.1089765951,
0.7120440006,
-0.6701826453,
0.4836293757,
0.6294945478,
0.6187558174,
-0.2761530876,
-0.2824899852,
-0.3006823957,
0.2519239783,
-0.1099839136,
0.7826685309,
-0.7007375956,
-0.2840600908,
-0.1057101414,
-0.3714266121,
-0.1734100282,
-0.6639209986,
0.0415596366,
-0.2184547186,
0.2629101574,
-0.1518123895,
-0.5292508602,
-0.3535229862,
0.4557179809,
-0.5254914761,
1.0467451811,
0.1253973991,
-0.7179531455,
0.0262357946,
-1.1485655308,
-0.2833274603,
0.0650329888,
-0.4480155706,
-0.2062571347,
0.045418907,
0.0587604083,
0.0074507804,
0.1864747703,
0.0970302969,
-0.3524742424,
-0.3446602821,
0.140337497,
-0.1199853867,
1.0458858013,
0.221558094,
-0.2294018567,
0.4725907743,
-0.9014682174,
0.057772208,
-0.0786108524,
-0.6161485314,
0.1354708225,
0.1992413104,
-0.2948950231,
0.240701884,
0.3760516047,
-0.7841476202,
0.6988878846,
-0.6120806932,
0.7249218822,
0.5319785476,
0.2595837712,
0.5389345884,
-0.4666405618,
0.5665032268,
-0.4174042344,
0.0908090919,
-0.4154323339,
-0.4674123526,
-0.9193270206,
-0.4428284764,
0.0269510914,
0.7418763638,
-0.7575185299,
0.35409078,
0.1201230735,
-0.1467588693,
-0.5155827999,
0.1137078628,
0.0951078162,
0.5497224927,
0.3625181913,
-0.4169071913,
-0.6110767126,
-0.7267258763,
0.0343505777,
-0.460952282,
-0.4104265869,
0.4339441359,
0.3452864587,
-0.2819549441,
1.2517623901,
-0.3874217272,
-0.3052614927,
-0.4794396162,
0.3925461173,
0.1158204675,
0.4918489158,
0.4473206699,
-0.6165543199,
-0.4265624583,
0.0781841949,
-0.6775824428,
-0.4321283102,
-0.5285483599,
-0.1277337223,
0.14097628,
0.318666786,
-0.6925503016,
0.8587594628,
0.2025221139,
-0.1134196296,
0.7673113346,
-0.5915871859,
-0.1833010167,
-0.1794203222,
0.5223635435,
-0.6787668467,
-0.0357681476,
-0.5498629212,
0.25065431,
-0.1973444223,
-0.3716223538,
-0.459569782,
0.650054276,
-0.3554308116,
-0.3475181758,
-0.3737359941,
-0.3913974464,
0.2104189992,
0.7145451903,
0.3209902346,
0.5102971792,
0.7430298328,
-0.63817662,
0.506659925,
0.2012486458,
-0.1499870718,
-0.0308534689,
-0.5668513179,
0.206283465,
-0.1491605043,
0.2959394753,
-1.0261231661,
-0.3054589927,
0.2697534263,
-0.178567335,
0.19893457,
-0.0085279997,
-0.5668234825,
-0.2200862616,
-0.4679177701,
0.3340295255,
0.2600455284,
-0.4929725528,
0.7221764326,
0.1200541928,
-0.3023150861,
-0.3332642317,
-0.6063730121,
0.2938967049,
0.0051804255,
-0.7390169501,
0.6033491492,
-0.3220637441,
-0.4028165936,
0.3965184689,
-0.0547142588,
0.0039452184,
0.0563577525,
0.1600459516,
-0.0190096013,
0.1270596683,
-0.1018542945,
-0.0025176692,
-0.3562192917,
0.0329689346,
0.0009071125,
0.5199904442,
0.038274426,
-0.5668259263,
-0.4147913158,
0.4482047558,
0.5741572976,
-0.4137615263,
0.2348200679,
0.5465553999,
-0.3781600893,
-0.4780312777,
-0.3503112793,
0.1058632135,
-0.4737216532,
-0.1882523596,
-0.1800088882,
-0.5226536393,
0.7466792464,
-0.3514067829,
0.6333415508,
0.073819153,
0.7034561634,
-0.0521298423,
1.0275925398,
0.8851856589,
0.2428561002,
0.3268220127,
-0.5566892028,
0.3057549894,
-0.7125071287,
-0.4055450559,
-0.2668724954,
-0.5924697518,
-0.1410529912,
-0.4634309709,
0.2879752517,
-0.0582418106,
-0.1619693041,
0.054600466,
-0.703245759,
0.5258069634,
0.7817890048,
-0.108280696,
0.3307954669,
-0.3077916801,
-0.3123342693,
0.2394062579,
-0.5369927287,
-0.5657021403,
0.8592492938,
0.2661101818,
0.7381199002,
-0.0960292742,
1.0272562504,
0.4512595236,
0.4284135699,
-0.9115207195,
0.6595364213,
-0.0192046743,
-0.359247148,
-0.27251634,
-0.3632465005,
-0.6922727823,
-0.0497257374,
0.0611420684,
-0.8539183736,
0.2413551956,
0.3166070282,
-0.3946676552,
0.2010140866,
-0.817501545,
0.7421756983,
-0.3200716376,
-0.4310268164,
-0.2400762737,
-0.6559308171,
0.4302912951,
0.3008120954,
0.2343341112,
-0.4574713707,
-0.1431434453,
0.274876982,
-0.8653323054,
0.9659004807,
-0.3164740503,
0.0944449455,
0.5047124624,
0.3827112317,
0.2540834844,
0.2795721591,
-0.3974668682,
-0.2071053237,
-0.1698677093,
-0.3341406882,
-0.64511621,
0.6835859418,
-0.6278609037,
-0.5728667974,
-0.2944760919,
-0.7745312452,
0.1288222969,
0.370282501,
0.0781635717,
0.512477994,
0.0162044689,
-0.2942994535,
0.2882494032,
-0.6007644534,
0.7205031514,
0.256493479,
-0.3326761723,
-0.0344395749,
0.7147023082,
-0.083802104,
0.0835274309,
0.3634188771,
0.180988729,
-0.3871390522,
-0.6520168781,
-0.3562501073,
0.1093240082,
-0.6908634901,
-0.1396414638,
-0.3148794472,
-0.2298051268,
-0.04466011,
-0.5231420994,
-0.4326454103,
-0.7957300544,
-0.0466165207,
0.115327917,
0.0314375088,
0.940166235,
-0.1345448792,
-0.2616253495,
-0.4315167069,
0.6330151558,
0.243602708,
0.316812247,
-0.1598341018,
0.0017586647,
0.2135304511,
0.0076391157,
-0.2905399501,
-0.6264262199,
0.6169351935,
0.4838106036,
0.716758728,
0.1549351066,
0.4253420532,
0.4752131999,
-0.4853636026,
0.7314089537,
-0.1667550951,
-0.8664759994,
0.803791225,
-0.0500791706,
0.6798397303,
0.7173337936,
0.3380607367,
-0.2592056096,
-0.7342121601,
-0.4379736483,
-0.9067827463,
0.800752759,
0.2776595652,
-0.0660929605,
0.1551035345,
0.3677476645,
0.3518112898,
0.3439220786,
-0.7527887821,
-0.1638521403,
-0.3203954101,
0.0231938493,
0.3462709188,
0.0037645313,
-0.1018617973,
-0.3514909148,
0.3856956363,
0.0196192488,
0.2977322936,
0.1467957795,
-0.17483446,
-0.0103823068,
0.0354862809,
0.3931808174,
0.9492583275,
-0.2572552264,
0.3956206739,
-0.3732608557,
-0.2357638627,
0.0083215134,
-0.0970856994,
-0.4199851453,
-0.1248798892,
0.5134238601,
0.4166652262,
0.1583615392,
-0.9658461809,
0.2375581861,
-0.0974778235,
-0.2033569962,
-0.332602948,
0.3462880552,
-0.2078584433,
-0.0133814588,
0.4568815827,
0.4594827592,
0.1881681979,
-0.6235084534,
0.3532853723,
-0.0271108188,
-0.0048692441,
-0.5592603683,
0.6961950064,
0.4547112584,
-0.6460132599,
0.9574410915,
-0.7054054141,
-0.6322683096,
0.6558684707,
0.3552737534,
0.8856851459,
-0.0828595832,
0.3233481944,
0.2952948511,
0.1751639545,
0.3658879399,
0.5268107653,
-0.3152917325,
-0.6366026402,
-0.7590785623,
-0.6031618118,
-0.7994714379,
-0.0693025216,
-0.2941507697,
0.2936607301,
-0.7972701788,
0.332259953,
-0.2398016751,
0.1296559721,
-0.4805882573,
-0.145295158,
0.252109617,
0.8825737238,
-0.679130733,
0.8730732799,
1.1689375639,
-0.1198779419,
-0.4684309065,
-0.0920830667,
0.1900029778,
-0.6902982593,
0.4961998463,
0.3759886026,
0.1903095096,
-0.0124940975,
-0.5068347454,
-0.7304857373,
0.8175532222,
0.6783919334,
0.2510409057,
-0.057717409,
0.2378201634,
0.5952203274,
-0.3801899254,
0.219689846,
0.4810136557,
0.5956094265,
0.2346417904,
-0.9899527431,
-0.011211101,
-0.6430359483,
-0.3372498155,
0.0798953325,
-0.2813140452,
0.6715481281,
-0.4634178579,
-0.4544323683,
-0.0423464812,
0.3496879935,
0.2471501678,
0.2960555255,
0.3601002991,
0.3454481661,
0.7316994667,
-0.1053700596,
1.0201952457,
-0.4166839719,
0.0841674954,
0.8075778484,
-0.2382140458,
0.7177262306,
0.4677920341,
-0.2362755984,
0.727897346,
0.3729226589,
0.2017712444,
0.5239988565,
0.5694604516,
-0.4133548141,
-0.2574339211,
-0.168934986,
-0.0492588803,
0.5538778305,
0.6480638385,
0.3792179525,
-0.5512263775,
-0.0285263062,
-0.3912064433,
0.3312296271,
-0.1514080614,
0.6185315847,
-0.0755567923,
-0.5670491457,
0.4852598608,
0.0766626373,
0.3732379675,
-0.7366161942,
-0.3727306724,
-0.3588717282,
-0.0052082879,
-0.6764418483,
-0.7855085135,
0.8274540305,
-0.0751220658,
0.1979009509,
-0.6995734572,
0.881759882,
-0.3470260799,
-0.1829534024,
-0.0996547267,
0.3162292242,
0.0193571448,
0.2316269875,
-0.8026713133,
0.336660713,
0.1941647679,
-0.4298638403,
0.1770498306,
0.4166381061,
0.0056323102,
1.2640626431,
0.5693600178,
0.0490579829,
0.2666966021,
-0.0067768395,
1.0552139282,
-0.4181660414,
-0.6674841046,
-0.5248860121,
0.7104976773,
-0.1097466946,
-0.0642107502,
0.644035399,
0.6760615706,
0.8661633134,
0.0083962679,
0.8342738152,
-0.3880889118,
0.4035389721,
-0.4570541978,
0.2786000073,
-0.159002766,
0.9406715035,
0.1037053466,
-0.9193583131,
-0.6233167052,
0.820364356,
-0.3174025118,
-0.2756702304,
0.3735721409,
0.5093684793,
-0.1194379851,
-0.1788703501,
-0.162043035,
-0.0078055128,
0.5439573526,
0.602977097,
0.9959565997,
0.3348095417,
0.4469429553,
-0.8027875423,
-0.3817834556,
-0.1086261719,
-1.1009913683,
-0.7213147879,
-0.0628234297,
-0.6579883099,
0.3695222437,
-0.2447892874,
0.7393797636,
0.3768831193,
-0.8016398549,
-0.5089700222,
-0.5484037995,
0.2947400212,
-0.3859772086,
-0.2936069965,
0.2970375717,
-0.6127838492,
-0.7210962176,
0.7500652075,
0.8994215131,
-0.1983937472,
-0.4228727221,
-0.1358100921,
-0.1774671227,
-0.1876244992,
0.4333306849,
0.8280485868,
-0.549477756,
-0.5280893445,
0.0868786424,
0.1221409366,
0.0124026872,
0.9008895755,
-0.9930211306,
0.8422977924,
0.797033608,
0.7475489378,
0.5777662992,
0.1663932651,
0.958915174,
-1.1343209743,
0.0721277818,
0.5818379521,
0.1478380859,
0.1319813281,
-0.3241713047,
0.6340454817,
0.0676856041,
-0.4049251974,
-0.9457439184,
0.3760559261,
-0.9809208512,
-0.2769509852,
0.8299946785,
-0.4256199598,
-0.058553692,
-0.5218236446,
-0.4105240703,
-0.1281066686,
-0.1015461832,
0.8622972369,
0.464114368,
-1.1148966551,
-0.0319974124,
-0.2376386374,
0.6018376946,
0.2296965122,
-0.8009824157,
0.2560800612,
0.3838242292,
0.017473815,
0.2416650504,
0.9033033848,
-0.0376856364,
0.3303134441,
-0.0573243573,
0.2119477987,
-0.6507216692,
-0.3126946092,
-0.1248842403,
0.2359556705,
0.2231779844,
-0.0122320121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18099v1 | Writing user personas with Large Language Models: Testing phase 6 of a Thematic Analysis of semi-structured interviews | 2023-05-29T14:09:14 | 2023-05-29T14:09:14 | Stefano De Paoli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | The goal of this paper is establishing if we can satisfactorily perform a
Thematic Analysis (TA) of semi-structured interviews using a Large Language
Model (more precisely GPT3.5-Turbo). Building on previous work by the author,
which established an embryonal process for conducting a TA with the model, this
paper will perform a further analysis and then cover the last phase of a TA
(phase 6), which entails the writing up of the result. This phase was not
covered by the previous work. In particular, the focus will be on using the
results of a TA done with the LLM on a dataset of user interviews, for writing
user personas, with the model building on the TA to produce the personas
narratives. User personas are models of real users, usually built from a data
analysis like interviews with a sample of users. User personas are tools often
used in User Centered Design processes. The paper shows that the model can
build basic user personas with an acceptable quality deriving them from themes,
and that the model can serve for the generation of ideas for user personas. | [
-0.3767772615,
-0.7469530106,
0.7007584572,
0.1469267905,
-0.0381390341,
0.2114398628,
-0.0224782024,
-0.5416190624,
0.1681193411,
0.6251266599,
-0.6775678396,
-0.4427731335,
0.0409869365,
0.3512836397,
-0.557495594,
0.9863767028,
-0.0870529637,
-0.0410571024,
0.0664138645,
0.1829170883,
-0.6859437227,
-0.722381711,
-0.7671130896,
-0.2469862252,
0.6391358972,
0.5107872486,
0.449142158,
0.1411969066,
0.1821368486,
0.3339289129,
0.090244025,
-0.461869508,
-0.567568481,
0.2520158291,
-0.2867584825,
-0.4617957473,
-0.3044391274,
0.1609308124,
0.6263082623,
0.7258147001,
-0.0542207547,
0.2804190516,
-0.1027185619,
0.245402351,
-0.1545757651,
0.2060537636,
-0.4713106751,
0.2073051482,
-0.299163878,
-0.1255096793,
-0.5786088109,
-0.4337050319,
0.0108247967,
-0.1983313859,
0.1805350929,
0.2655564845,
0.7380622029,
-0.1935302466,
-0.4788682759,
-0.0223415047,
-1.2777860165,
0.6760339737,
-0.7405942678,
-0.0823493078,
0.2558410168,
0.4265114069,
-0.1614618152,
-0.9032201767,
-0.7892716527,
-0.2585711777,
0.077484414,
0.2124855518,
0.040972922,
0.0984560177,
0.5408034325,
0.3211737573,
-0.4396513104,
0.1274391413,
-0.4459166527,
-0.1438893378,
0.6764991283,
0.4698157609,
0.5955957174,
-0.4070764482,
-0.3663114607,
0.2014328241,
-0.7611605525,
-0.1205489933,
0.5894140601,
0.1596813202,
0.0827325433,
0.8880231977,
-0.0508689135,
0.3663478494,
-0.0400600284,
-0.4293015897,
0.0082677091,
-0.7011425495,
-0.1587595493,
-0.1453458816,
0.7496167421,
0.4863618016,
0.8618856668,
-0.0183133073,
-0.4657473564,
0.0406860411,
0.5472018719,
-0.6522153616,
-0.101289548,
0.3779773712,
-0.4587351382,
-0.279531002,
-0.0762643069,
-0.7796040773,
-0.3866608441,
-0.5114488006,
0.1239895672,
-0.344369024,
-0.288051039,
0.2388100475,
0.0255261641,
0.4003526568,
0.3495742381,
-0.8156752586,
0.3477347493,
0.4045036733,
0.5998908281,
0.0142917354,
-0.5117998123,
-0.1558226049,
0.313645035,
-0.2299596369,
0.7880390882,
-0.4598048329,
-0.633867383,
0.3080308139,
-0.2233714759,
-0.2248979062,
-0.254319042,
0.4480312467,
-0.1968133152,
0.5267013311,
-0.4236907661,
-0.5810567737,
0.0699893534,
0.2024848759,
-0.3416535258,
1.2826709747,
0.6061346531,
-0.7970724702,
0.1712842733,
-0.7073348761,
-0.3629802465,
0.1798861623,
-0.2733178139,
-0.1296910942,
0.4433533251,
-0.1940042824,
0.5749747753,
-0.4732137322,
0.4361112118,
-0.2401807308,
-0.3482755125,
0.4733839929,
0.2637186348,
0.7100609541,
0.1368762851,
-0.5372601151,
0.1937396675,
-0.5754472613,
-0.0939674377,
0.2383708358,
-0.1318698525,
-0.1097308099,
0.1311024278,
0.4452537596,
0.4357188344,
-0.1043077931,
-0.7375420332,
0.3366044462,
-0.3072696328,
0.4037421048,
0.6410824656,
0.0975859985,
0.0474015325,
-0.3680123389,
0.8319380283,
0.0989867002,
0.0026365439,
-0.2023072392,
-0.4851633608,
-0.8716286421,
-0.0591883212,
0.3160135746,
0.3657304049,
-0.8394314051,
0.6628200412,
-0.2433623523,
-0.5454695225,
-0.2216861844,
-0.0585362576,
0.4033669233,
0.7499731183,
-0.1721672416,
-0.7685490251,
-0.696936965,
-1.0205554962,
-0.2254804075,
-0.5336693525,
-0.1556219757,
0.0801798925,
0.941167295,
-0.0469915792,
1.0166164637,
-0.5023270249,
-0.0735529363,
-0.8310100436,
0.5035274625,
-0.0344061069,
0.3551663756,
0.6936118603,
-0.6284241676,
-0.5797879696,
-0.2361333966,
-0.7189357877,
-0.2441840619,
-0.1481637508,
0.1322353035,
-0.0175760519,
0.1468002647,
-0.5888967514,
0.37391451,
0.0510686003,
-0.81015414,
0.6122480631,
0.0148614831,
0.1753367782,
-1.2822802067,
0.3475372195,
0.4704633355,
-0.2703189254,
-0.9299767017,
0.1240136251,
-0.2892960608,
-0.3703721762,
-0.3956457973,
0.6439007521,
-0.43536672,
-0.3835171163,
-0.3047201633,
-0.2712003589,
-0.1147430837,
0.5417848825,
-0.037076842,
0.8881946206,
0.2324357778,
-0.1973751038,
0.1524457335,
0.2429705858,
-0.5998866558,
0.7570063472,
-0.9144796729,
0.4422881603,
-0.1547039896,
0.3522146344,
-1.4343196154,
-0.4189729095,
0.1351746768,
-0.1791194081,
0.1043812186,
-0.0828069746,
-0.9898838997,
-0.5474038124,
-0.3159503043,
0.3024794459,
0.590503633,
0.0218412001,
0.6379135251,
0.6595316529,
-0.5882741809,
0.1717545688,
-0.4800887406,
0.2193187326,
-0.7379507422,
-0.8559747338,
0.0896760598,
-0.3699160218,
-0.298861295,
-0.5253532529,
0.3020339608,
-0.2750434279,
0.2141805738,
-0.0113021377,
0.2201488465,
-0.2398546338,
-0.3758373857,
-0.2672357857,
-0.2055852562,
0.2035158873,
-0.2534882128,
0.6698616743,
-0.1046405807,
-0.2571237385,
-0.5153605342,
0.587479949,
0.6362184286,
-0.2107125819,
0.4706915915,
0.4779981673,
-0.3858121932,
0.0667105913,
-0.7653548121,
-0.0385022201,
-0.4338079393,
0.1186463684,
-0.5195738077,
-1.0212513208,
0.9531360865,
0.0372337699,
0.0060967379,
0.569082737,
1.079862237,
-0.2653148472,
0.8944387436,
0.8074379563,
-0.0813223347,
0.2644515634,
-0.1139321402,
0.4292445779,
-0.6816331148,
-0.4103714526,
-0.7861146331,
-0.6402224898,
-0.3974249363,
-0.1103873625,
0.5011899471,
-0.517645359,
-0.0554685667,
0.1998128146,
-0.1241585091,
0.3609192967,
0.5474715829,
-0.1814807057,
0.1808832586,
-0.169170022,
-0.1251212955,
-0.4395251572,
-0.219366461,
-0.5406187773,
0.7929686308,
0.4889783561,
0.7039058805,
0.0830782726,
0.3656734228,
0.1555080414,
0.0273828078,
-0.6935020685,
0.6820097566,
0.3701916039,
-0.8072853684,
-0.2899720669,
0.0540095754,
-0.8225824237,
0.0650104955,
0.1480848342,
-1.2123503685,
0.24602139,
-0.0611584,
-0.3520054221,
0.0300922971,
-0.8541039228,
0.9380843043,
0.0534702875,
-0.2220705897,
0.1886511743,
-0.9092153311,
0.5568230748,
-0.2761304975,
-0.2065116316,
-0.0767232701,
0.1516089737,
0.9520964622,
-0.1424994618,
1.1340309381,
-0.215690583,
0.0159378778,
0.4950411618,
0.1841949224,
0.2534396946,
0.0137993405,
0.0323067941,
-0.275282532,
0.2087394148,
-0.2644657195,
-0.6728128791,
0.420807898,
-0.6664865017,
-0.5816518068,
-0.5237235427,
-0.849396646,
-0.3503523171,
0.2885822356,
-0.1728751361,
0.5537657142,
-0.2408195734,
0.225423649,
0.7052195668,
-0.0927990153,
0.1985233426,
0.4771949053,
-0.4334534407,
0.0274511985,
0.4726039469,
0.1474027336,
0.0065811388,
0.0848810524,
0.4454684258,
-0.3610427082,
-0.8684301376,
-0.129469797,
0.2962099016,
-0.4101572633,
0.1179226339,
-0.4212796986,
-0.2804535031,
-0.3903702199,
-0.0023102099,
-0.2702033222,
-0.26700598,
0.2338342518,
-0.0800580084,
-0.0609560572,
1.0110296011,
0.3874387443,
0.5402276516,
-0.4105274379,
0.3001642525,
-0.1123164892,
-0.0346568562,
-0.1697996855,
-0.4346151948,
-0.1894716322,
-0.2244132757,
-0.3244131804,
-1.0013520718,
0.2952286899,
-0.2519608438,
0.2797380388,
0.0702441037,
-0.2357731164,
0.6007601619,
-0.4331044853,
0.9830442071,
0.1845019907,
-0.8399915099,
0.7393052578,
-1.0169796944,
0.3600035012,
1.0096127987,
0.4741068184,
-0.6659974456,
-0.5115699172,
-0.9218980074,
-0.655215323,
0.7099059224,
0.4581262469,
0.1681120694,
0.0993967503,
0.6383648515,
0.0391515568,
0.3245629668,
-0.7407636642,
-0.1341339052,
0.130091697,
-0.3269793391,
-0.1718164235,
-0.8624474406,
-0.2964116633,
-0.4235873222,
0.1977292299,
-0.1246162057,
0.3677241802,
-0.0621569343,
0.4109173119,
0.0245415419,
0.2462588102,
0.5866109729,
1.1177382469,
-0.1430471838,
-0.0402093343,
-0.1679684222,
-0.3742419779,
0.242885232,
-0.1643247008,
-0.3061389029,
-0.0823863298,
0.216187492,
0.5191152692,
0.4599857032,
-0.4822270572,
0.5578083992,
-0.3260071874,
-0.2691446543,
-0.5107170343,
0.0635774881,
0.1903560609,
-0.0956344754,
0.1055087149,
-0.4259424508,
0.1502472311,
-0.9051759243,
0.2201675624,
0.088080965,
-0.12012624,
-0.705321908,
0.5452703238,
0.2834498286,
-0.2686356008,
0.7848851681,
0.1886813939,
-0.2755203843,
0.5237326622,
0.7430485487,
1.104629755,
-0.4568873346,
0.325358808,
0.2501462102,
0.1829025894,
-0.0331849121,
0.8182263374,
0.3083009124,
-0.5506472588,
-0.4871496558,
-0.5704408884,
-0.3888067305,
0.266769588,
-0.6782452464,
0.2407691032,
-0.4769515693,
0.0496393777,
0.1330749243,
0.1528647244,
-0.5436172485,
0.4568082392,
-0.224510178,
0.8531002998,
-1.0933666229,
0.7923407555,
0.8039411306,
-0.5664044619,
-0.996009469,
0.0554445535,
0.3123887181,
-0.7428181767,
0.4682135284,
-0.0149642639,
0.1323983967,
0.1923212558,
-0.4462482333,
-0.6207649708,
1.0781458616,
0.3631284833,
-0.225938797,
-0.2222387046,
0.3625647426,
0.9039772749,
-0.6382104754,
0.4264923632,
0.69392699,
0.5307382941,
0.4893608689,
-0.8911657333,
-0.1237099543,
-0.320723772,
0.3791178763,
-0.0183541253,
-0.459905237,
0.7434529066,
0.2308828384,
-0.1077139601,
0.3207211494,
0.8431341648,
0.2471367568,
0.0646461621,
0.584878087,
0.3375307024,
0.6644189358,
-0.1686182171,
1.5328068733,
-0.3055201471,
0.2946535051,
1.0131549835,
-0.4727518559,
0.6773331165,
0.5928915143,
-0.1670048088,
0.5369132161,
0.8175827265,
0.0456182845,
0.2063354701,
0.4445605874,
-0.140284583,
-0.0813804343,
-0.3668083251,
-0.1711566895,
0.6217681766,
-0.0406989306,
-0.1632147282,
-0.1927649826,
-0.0736301392,
0.281339258,
0.1830776781,
0.0119722402,
0.5231727958,
0.0673755854,
-0.8000447154,
0.0047346749,
0.3717037141,
0.098356992,
-0.7456911802,
0.23999089,
-0.4861069322,
0.0169090889,
-0.0376634002,
-0.9159056544,
0.443752408,
0.2923133373,
-0.0842249095,
-0.5103219748,
1.0206156969,
-0.2322712243,
-0.9016172886,
-0.1217659488,
0.74442029,
0.3380036056,
0.0293295309,
-0.6245253086,
0.1532961726,
-0.085797295,
-0.3254189789,
0.4680170715,
0.3674116731,
-0.0503656231,
0.5368301272,
0.2568147182,
-0.0837477818,
-0.1150124297,
0.5783359408,
0.7713250518,
-0.8930832148,
-0.6131052971,
-0.9020081758,
0.9656662345,
-0.0133793829,
-0.5802998543,
0.8539075255,
0.8411554098,
0.7057907581,
-0.1448740214,
0.8770515919,
-0.2505599856,
0.6359460354,
-0.5699677467,
0.3807770908,
-0.3058314323,
0.0633422211,
-0.5161272883,
-0.9929376841,
-0.0858403295,
0.462970525,
-0.0978810266,
0.4824969471,
1.0437368155,
0.6461793184,
-0.1299131513,
0.2125122696,
0.4201083779,
0.4417847991,
0.4719038606,
0.6672852635,
1.1491271257,
-0.23984164,
-0.2696804106,
-0.2677064836,
-0.2086372077,
0.2177747339,
-0.6796697974,
-1.3502800465,
-0.860771656,
-0.2786827683,
-0.3542746305,
-0.1198853552,
0.3255541623,
0.2383337766,
-0.5771765113,
-0.6869710684,
0.3192059696,
-0.1779796779,
0.3178921938,
-0.2064219564,
-0.0663603991,
-0.1024842933,
-0.9888484478,
0.2503918111,
0.3421761096,
-0.0124489544,
-0.8680945039,
0.2681463957,
-0.3145839572,
-0.0695268884,
0.4359642267,
0.2395047098,
-0.6827828288,
-0.8148027658,
-0.0691632777,
-0.0754274204,
0.1732964963,
1.3318567276,
-0.413658917,
0.3260583282,
0.4301458597,
0.5269002914,
0.5435966849,
0.1350358725,
1.107724905,
-0.7236794233,
-0.1199847236,
0.2370116115,
0.5295873284,
0.2818926275,
-0.274408102,
0.6640379429,
0.3461194634,
-0.5311228633,
-0.7166109681,
0.2694402933,
-1.3420479298,
0.0430665687,
1.40558815,
0.0406438671,
-0.1528110057,
-0.4104502797,
-0.389151305,
-0.0322253667,
-0.02103623,
0.8673582077,
1.0341284275,
-0.2429085076,
0.1008494347,
-0.7186239958,
0.2739745677,
0.2377579659,
-1.0878429413,
-0.1584157497,
0.424475044,
0.3950775266,
-0.0850588307,
1.1452496052,
-0.0718804598,
0.0654472411,
-0.2179983854,
0.0384333059,
0.0860951766,
-0.5810171366,
-0.184188351,
0.3384038508,
0.3336979151,
0.2774863839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18098v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18098v3 | BigTranslate: Augmenting Large Language Models with Multilingual Translation Capability over 100 Languages | 2023-05-29T14:07:52 | 2023-11-21T11:01:24 | Wen Yang, Chong Li, Jiajun Zhang, Chengqing Zong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate promising translation performance
among various natural languages. However, many LLMs especially the open-sourced
ones, such as BLOOM and LLaMA, are English-dominant and support only dozens of
natural languages, making the potential of LLMs on language translation less
explored. In this work, we present BigTranslate which adapts LLaMA that covers
only 20 languages and enhances it with multilingual translation capability on
more than 100 languages. BigTranslate is built upon LLaMA-13B and it is
optimized in three steps. First, we continue training LLaMA with massive
Chinese monolingual data. Second, we continue training the model with a
large-scale parallel dataset that covers 102 natural languages. Third, we
instruct-tune the foundation model with multilingual translation instructions,
leading to our BigTranslate model. The preliminary experiments on multilingual
translation show that BigTranslate performs comparably with ChatGPT and Google
Translate in many languages and even outperforms ChatGPT in 8 language pairs.
We release the BigTranslate model and hope it can advance the research
progress. | [
-0.1353368759,
-0.3035817742,
0.4343499541,
0.8396376967,
-0.34707582,
0.2732661366,
-0.7699645162,
-0.7345318198,
0.2635860145,
0.4578973055,
-0.4436831176,
-0.4251495302,
-0.9597172141,
0.3958943784,
-0.4349476993,
1.1185652018,
-0.1320155859,
0.253123492,
0.1044674665,
-0.1653694212,
-0.2207891941,
-0.250968039,
-0.4718131423,
-0.243714124,
0.4702311158,
0.2263673097,
0.7981593013,
0.5243478417,
0.6527970433,
0.3422060013,
-0.4365592897,
0.3588818908,
-0.6561946869,
-0.1062711105,
-0.1333043426,
-0.3944786787,
-0.6647763252,
-0.5267906785,
0.9841685891,
0.4421764612,
-0.12428087,
0.4730177522,
-0.0718070269,
0.3512883186,
-0.4637355506,
0.3423044682,
-0.6303885579,
-0.1744945198,
-0.3869032562,
0.1321265996,
-0.5801852345,
-0.2669498622,
-0.3463309705,
-0.6277294159,
-0.2563327551,
-0.0159186069,
0.6788422465,
0.3272481859,
-0.7478681803,
-0.0865363032,
-0.8772802353,
0.8232774138,
-0.7696492672,
0.4844260514,
0.3422250748,
0.3771656454,
-0.1024284214,
-0.7788536549,
-0.571822226,
-0.2117313147,
-0.0182049908,
-0.1416658312,
-0.1186374947,
-0.3085685968,
-0.0278991982,
0.6936436296,
-0.6915051937,
0.3857934773,
-0.2710970342,
-0.2150684297,
0.6414553523,
0.1975119263,
0.3725081086,
0.1020369604,
-0.5605084896,
-0.3103523254,
-0.8415464163,
-0.2021116763,
-0.0508542582,
0.5716638565,
-0.3405350447,
0.4507277906,
0.0344487503,
0.7578755617,
-0.2971881628,
-0.4609671235,
0.4933443069,
-0.4587560296,
-0.1890328377,
0.0465967096,
0.9300803542,
0.0539377816,
0.2351241112,
-0.1588472873,
-0.1908243597,
-0.1072714031,
-0.1798239201,
-0.8743368387,
0.2942704856,
0.196056217,
-0.0888394862,
-0.0381115265,
-0.3095861375,
-0.5432248116,
-0.1317846328,
-0.2941065729,
0.2493091822,
-0.4375852644,
-0.5362043977,
0.585627079,
0.3402250409,
0.2516514957,
0.3294590116,
-0.6903793216,
0.0630468205,
0.688780427,
0.9691143632,
-0.1850881726,
-0.9784533381,
-0.5167169571,
0.4595669806,
-0.5594569445,
0.5990922451,
-0.3809098899,
-0.0455026291,
0.1501253545,
0.3658851683,
0.1710031033,
-0.4245024621,
0.4554432333,
-0.5990634561,
-0.0214616302,
-0.3418634832,
-0.0754833445,
-0.1874751449,
0.417032212,
-0.849627614,
0.8755603433,
-0.0336825438,
-0.1638500839,
0.0724617913,
-0.6390922666,
-0.793410182,
0.1990572661,
0.4330135584,
-0.2189736068,
0.0073215887,
0.3454643786,
0.295003593,
-0.4427627027,
0.4462630749,
-0.0014090588,
-0.2497678846,
0.1899582148,
-0.2953055799,
0.8231663108,
0.3332729042,
-0.1129186153,
0.093033433,
-0.4002438486,
-0.3660626709,
0.2636571229,
-0.6548992395,
-0.2579597235,
-0.2962837517,
0.3108481765,
0.2798116207,
0.4254557788,
-0.6544981599,
0.2095590234,
-0.1635803282,
0.5154697895,
0.5143399835,
-0.486238867,
0.5309599638,
0.0419769287,
0.52722013,
0.293797493,
-0.1163805425,
-0.2947055399,
-0.603997767,
-0.6714709997,
-0.4008614123,
0.543923378,
0.4173384905,
-0.8372776508,
0.1796052456,
-0.9058333039,
-0.4301655591,
-0.7118541002,
0.4649398923,
0.2700867057,
-0.0776554644,
0.6624621153,
-0.1776443273,
-0.2904464006,
-0.7137656808,
0.0915545821,
0.1348461509,
0.1039293632,
-0.2834353149,
0.2900574803,
-0.4406393766,
0.1437373459,
-0.3937509358,
-0.4623196125,
-0.4403017461,
-0.0996005535,
0.3062267005,
0.2559620142,
0.7499865294,
-0.6533933282,
-0.6050210595,
0.6267629862,
-0.4432652891,
0.1119527668,
0.0347547084,
-0.5207918882,
0.0639685765,
0.4606661201,
-0.7455883026,
0.0435925797,
1.1898739338,
-0.0383317545,
0.2887420356,
-0.185108155,
0.0664562136,
-1.2813252211,
0.1502030045,
-0.114045009,
-0.2807294726,
-0.504112184,
0.3859027922,
0.4100726545,
-0.3142773509,
-0.5918290615,
0.5785934329,
-0.4872009754,
-0.1329254657,
-0.3770296574,
-0.0637259409,
-0.049899593,
0.288131237,
0.1649195552,
0.9003742933,
0.2698179483,
-0.6046752334,
0.5049446821,
0.5294533372,
-0.3643007278,
0.2515088618,
-0.3603317142,
-0.0064305048,
-0.0869096145,
0.6680679917,
-1.0333188772,
-0.3073507249,
0.0660744011,
-0.1801852435,
0.4282603264,
-0.0728483945,
-0.5155581236,
-0.3997681737,
-0.0628110617,
0.4321025312,
0.1943326592,
-0.868904829,
0.6024731398,
0.1610987335,
-0.2114404887,
-0.5863207579,
-1.1463149786,
0.6414895058,
-0.0680388659,
-0.6756303906,
0.4885313213,
-0.3101020157,
0.1020347849,
-0.2450220436,
0.3321262896,
-0.0305700209,
-0.1881600022,
-0.1915515214,
0.1245650053,
-0.4988383949,
0.2985270023,
0.1432240009,
-0.1383551657,
-0.1931769848,
-0.4488760233,
0.7760593295,
-0.0762831047,
-0.3632293642,
-0.0477064475,
0.3886015117,
0.9578441978,
-0.9211401343,
0.9934795499,
0.6722166538,
-0.2382296473,
-0.2542699277,
-0.4201439023,
0.1900150478,
-0.4075287282,
0.5877664685,
-0.5145547986,
-0.8106228113,
0.4272196293,
-0.1577171236,
0.316396445,
0.4005417526,
0.9966059923,
0.4522531331,
0.7443396449,
0.6271406412,
-0.5623515248,
0.3431613743,
-0.1027428657,
0.1439959854,
-0.5148922801,
-0.1335800141,
-0.5308715701,
-0.4959605336,
-0.5484818816,
-0.6795059443,
0.1087796837,
-0.3413291276,
-0.1516634971,
0.7547815442,
-0.2538217902,
0.4300738871,
0.3323689103,
0.1660270095,
0.643802166,
0.3029471338,
0.2418176532,
0.0304689966,
-0.5008900762,
-0.3349402845,
1.0618727207,
0.407138288,
0.6482919455,
0.6710296273,
0.3097654581,
-0.1741808653,
0.4413294196,
-0.8036198616,
0.4001537859,
-0.5149368048,
-0.7808722854,
-0.2250574082,
-0.3520826399,
-0.7943139672,
0.3230806291,
-0.0947577581,
-0.1640624702,
-0.0243722331,
-0.1385523826,
0.1368170083,
0.3460617959,
-0.6197155714,
0.6967715025,
-0.6571463943,
-0.3933095038,
-0.2838478088,
-0.3687434793,
0.6340682507,
-0.4115518332,
0.2751589715,
0.0961805955,
-0.1870137006,
0.1665956974,
0.0246564783,
0.7023391724,
0.318926245,
-0.6793240309,
-0.0897616595,
0.1843361557,
0.5720447302,
-0.1411037296,
-0.1762907356,
0.5758033395,
-0.2517858744,
-0.537992239,
-0.2102637142,
0.8312683105,
-0.8105986714,
-0.4105657041,
-0.2291805744,
-0.7213708758,
-0.0593834892,
0.190774858,
0.096170187,
-0.0472904555,
-0.141105786,
0.2080838978,
0.3864049613,
-0.4083452821,
0.5262202621,
0.6615517139,
-0.5483403206,
-0.2797828019,
0.9843614697,
-0.0972624719,
0.4558200538,
0.5344093442,
0.1591747254,
-0.2945302427,
-0.4588855505,
-0.9811958671,
0.5078151822,
-0.6015408039,
-0.4235035777,
-0.4492489398,
-0.2104885131,
-0.4973407388,
0.2255190611,
-0.4851073921,
-0.1590068042,
0.0038943121,
-0.0910674632,
0.5357477069,
0.5797024965,
-0.0842382684,
0.365804404,
-0.9123573899,
0.3376304507,
0.3039094508,
0.2443799973,
0.0817135572,
-0.7431899309,
-0.5561185479,
0.2272429019,
-0.1436828077,
-0.5796707273,
0.4786185324,
0.3004401028,
0.4452594519,
0.2627744377,
-0.3069855869,
0.8173618913,
-0.6290547848,
0.6436085105,
0.2335128784,
-0.820640862,
0.1137172431,
-0.4239168763,
0.4200080931,
0.2640001178,
0.5609265566,
-0.6777255535,
-0.0939894319,
0.0459867828,
-0.6897410154,
0.6293047667,
-0.102156505,
0.4134466052,
0.0240401719,
-0.1048578173,
-0.0113659631,
0.1118681282,
-1.0849684477,
0.2189694345,
-0.1642098576,
-0.1796321571,
-0.5538417101,
-0.2078579217,
-0.1714822948,
-0.2081563473,
0.4730985165,
-0.2118482143,
0.0365411602,
-0.3040761948,
-0.3872796297,
-0.3061891794,
0.231801644,
0.821608305,
0.674292028,
0.0856665969,
0.000755952,
0.341168344,
-0.6208322048,
0.2942059934,
0.2161479741,
0.0777720138,
-0.0472011566,
0.4832002521,
0.7782039642,
0.1276681423,
-0.6307758093,
0.4426985979,
0.2002223134,
0.0238995161,
-0.1814862788,
-0.2952558398,
0.5028807521,
0.2453137636,
0.2167318463,
-0.2585222721,
-0.199747771,
-0.4161077142,
-0.2633310258,
0.2511374056,
0.0180526543,
-0.2565275431,
0.7061218619,
0.2442114204,
-0.2188301682,
0.3925175667,
-0.0529153161,
-0.5206533074,
0.4089071751,
0.9335011244,
0.5177030563,
-0.5874567032,
0.0126704965,
0.5360392928,
0.5951516032,
-0.4278565943,
-0.1721431762,
0.1244376376,
-0.534106791,
-1.2377675772,
-0.7653393149,
-0.3227066696,
0.3219728768,
-0.419049859,
0.3836609125,
-0.0609701313,
0.075709559,
-0.2715193629,
-0.2330300212,
-0.6425800323,
-0.0412293784,
0.4003547728,
1.0456084013,
-1.0524064302,
1.0599226952,
0.8722846508,
-0.2759185135,
-0.629745245,
-0.0557842776,
-0.1575812399,
-0.9182562232,
0.720567584,
-0.0086069861,
-0.1129413098,
0.1431642771,
-0.5817118883,
-1.022939086,
0.9044527411,
0.7484871745,
-0.7169433832,
0.0773952454,
0.6017519832,
0.5731590986,
-0.2563847303,
-0.0001819684,
0.4540665746,
0.6632106304,
0.2298816293,
-1.1198018789,
-0.0312517285,
-0.0963550434,
0.0831319541,
0.3259190321,
-0.8585909605,
0.7709493041,
-0.0597280227,
0.0958151892,
0.2678201199,
0.5495063663,
0.3273012042,
-0.0901259184,
0.238306731,
0.6387104988,
0.4530704618,
-0.0165818166,
1.0924043655,
-0.3570632339,
0.1499010175,
0.9640296102,
-0.2620051503,
1.0530003309,
0.4412867725,
-0.1761756837,
0.3197852075,
0.5534675121,
0.1593640596,
0.4133194685,
0.1202401966,
-0.4820491374,
-0.4545021951,
-0.1773003042,
-0.5491113067,
0.7059076428,
0.5014368892,
-0.3920049369,
-0.2748034596,
0.1024785265,
0.2077962309,
0.0461274236,
-0.229015559,
0.4206442237,
0.1327682436,
-0.6202098131,
0.6567727923,
0.3590459526,
0.7461402416,
-0.8838911653,
-0.0063701072,
-0.59060359,
0.3631120026,
-0.1164951324,
-0.7397281528,
-0.0484413058,
-0.0652339384,
-0.0046884255,
-0.2817205489,
0.3388235867,
-0.6705752015,
-0.929477632,
0.6201534271,
0.4551430345,
0.0873277709,
-0.1631339043,
-0.4283268154,
0.2904821634,
0.0927617177,
-0.2550444901,
0.5049621463,
0.6720278263,
-0.201061517,
0.6977910995,
0.9633671641,
0.4289814234,
0.1655508131,
-0.1143254861,
0.8719891906,
-0.5731298923,
-0.401643306,
-0.7297267318,
0.4635169506,
0.0941587165,
-0.4122220278,
0.7084081769,
0.5492277145,
0.8173057437,
-0.2138557136,
0.4588716924,
0.2184831798,
0.348692894,
-0.5219466686,
0.6622037888,
-0.5864370465,
0.0803915933,
-0.2954951823,
-1.1426753998,
-0.4657503664,
0.3160609305,
-0.1903748661,
-0.2585430741,
0.4975143969,
0.7786982059,
-0.4206820428,
-0.3032232821,
0.3133384883,
0.2135540545,
0.3666715622,
0.8498136401,
0.6478810906,
-0.4723133147,
0.9497983456,
-0.0495496839,
-0.1581656933,
-0.1387318224,
-1.0252547264,
-0.692450285,
-0.3735952377,
0.0251018051,
-0.2478310764,
-0.3118034303,
0.5509467721,
0.6091060638,
-0.6928251982,
-0.5298497677,
0.3017646074,
-0.1356876045,
-0.2266106457,
-0.0536840148,
0.1874114871,
-0.2569533587,
-1.0500507355,
0.7026438117,
0.2203809917,
0.1154386178,
-0.4960333109,
-0.3655667007,
-0.3395847082,
-0.3337720335,
0.9547750354,
0.1833772063,
-0.5520687103,
0.154437989,
0.1417835355,
-0.2509340644,
0.0928417295,
0.5639448166,
-0.4093896151,
0.3205961585,
0.3092092276,
1.0130815506,
1.0059876442,
-0.1308514178,
0.5921806097,
-0.5457612276,
0.7060038447,
-0.1530217081,
0.3112607598,
0.6203314066,
-0.2564992905,
0.5116926432,
-0.1115008071,
-0.3845378458,
-0.6461160183,
0.1098404676,
-0.7734826803,
-0.3039105535,
1.4094983339,
-0.0089799473,
-0.2339082509,
0.1874957532,
-0.1028454676,
0.1351277232,
-0.1344164908,
0.3753139675,
0.7529918551,
0.6361085176,
-0.2117125839,
-0.7833504081,
0.0700397789,
0.3266396821,
-0.6260825992,
0.107075192,
0.3653352261,
0.2146571726,
0.3232019842,
0.3935259879,
-0.1604179144,
0.1987964511,
-0.2088826001,
0.2624959648,
-0.1492309272,
-0.2559821308,
-0.3070470393,
-0.1911325902,
0.3666005731,
-0.2096561193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18096v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18096v2 | Improving Textless Spoken Language Understanding with Discrete Units as Intermediate Target | 2023-05-29T14:00:24 | 2023-07-08T07:25:14 | Guan-Wei Wu, Guan-Ting Lin, Shang-Wen Li, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Spoken Language Understanding (SLU) is a task that aims to extract semantic
information from spoken utterances. Previous research has made progress in
end-to-end SLU by using paired speech-text data, such as pre-trained Automatic
Speech Recognition (ASR) models or paired text as intermediate targets.
However, acquiring paired transcripts is expensive and impractical for
unwritten languages. On the other hand, Textless SLU extracts semantic
information from speech without utilizing paired transcripts. However, the
absence of intermediate targets and training guidance for textless SLU often
results in suboptimal performance. In this work, inspired by the
content-disentangled discrete units from self-supervised speech models, we
proposed to use discrete units as intermediate guidance to improve textless SLU
performance. Our method surpasses the baseline method on five SLU benchmark
corpora. Additionally, we find that unit guidance facilitates few-shot learning
and enhances the model's ability to handle noise. | [
-0.1789291203,
-0.604508698,
0.8302077055,
-0.1447994262,
-0.6267871857,
0.1660350561,
-0.3576628566,
-0.2295755148,
0.020992374,
0.4177909791,
-0.617454648,
-0.6778156757,
-0.467466861,
0.063711226,
-0.3908997178,
0.9699750543,
0.479560405,
-0.0594285168,
-0.3283836544,
-0.2411888391,
-0.5225179195,
-0.1700933576,
-0.6324262023,
-0.5722019672,
0.6116598845,
0.5676813722,
0.4542220831,
0.5491225719,
0.0945853889,
0.363132745,
-0.0664789677,
0.0278857145,
-0.5208446383,
-0.2023871988,
-0.0778533295,
-0.3651249707,
-0.4073123634,
-0.0198932961,
0.9075997472,
0.8208792806,
-0.2872440815,
-0.0437684432,
0.1127375588,
0.7243680358,
-0.5232278109,
0.3311713934,
-0.7550372481,
-0.1831148416,
-0.2362876683,
0.0283975638,
-0.8000003695,
-0.0436059013,
0.1298302114,
-0.8644323945,
0.1035450995,
-0.346956104,
0.6764924526,
0.6947079301,
-0.2749229074,
-0.3469366133,
-0.7396184206,
0.7460202575,
-0.8014159203,
0.4644010961,
0.6278351545,
0.0939814076,
0.006257432,
-0.7150905728,
-0.439663589,
-0.0031306194,
-0.4505806863,
0.2098194957,
-0.6287520528,
0.3456932306,
0.2587538958,
-0.0774166435,
-0.6060231328,
0.132234022,
-0.3741499484,
0.0748520568,
0.6393658519,
-0.1425415277,
0.1448226273,
-0.3242279589,
-0.2126493603,
0.137005806,
-0.428183198,
0.0529214107,
0.082294859,
0.4285971522,
-0.39945364,
0.1843491346,
-0.1327991784,
0.8024446964,
0.173973009,
-0.3100474775,
0.3434097469,
-0.2519541085,
-0.2844386399,
0.4773181379,
0.6306430697,
-0.2143851072,
0.1013022661,
-0.5113881826,
-0.1969613582,
0.2365754247,
0.294207871,
-0.6282998323,
-0.4270749092,
0.0701219514,
-0.1877129227,
-0.0488087796,
-0.2119001746,
-0.3691242337,
0.1290408075,
-0.6727223992,
0.452716291,
-0.7991443872,
-0.30365628,
-0.0934913531,
0.1028187573,
0.1800111979,
0.4109245241,
-1.2342610359,
0.5657241344,
0.6233340502,
0.8332030177,
-0.2504530251,
-0.1804937869,
-0.6932412386,
0.3084948063,
-0.355877161,
0.6015401483,
-0.5053322315,
-0.5354769826,
-0.5003685951,
-0.3397892416,
-0.2260929197,
-0.3935676813,
0.3696752489,
-0.3685190976,
-0.1322639883,
0.009988945,
-0.5645817518,
-0.1826084256,
-0.1759723127,
-0.4536071718,
0.9585983157,
0.0162300598,
-0.4290976226,
0.0514433272,
-0.4646840394,
-0.4967790544,
0.4204690158,
-0.7885885835,
-0.2457749397,
0.4442264438,
0.200548932,
0.270614475,
0.29442361,
0.2984474599,
0.2268666625,
-0.4822894037,
0.2372680008,
-0.6202735901,
0.353900969,
0.0033745447,
-0.4980137944,
0.0278824512,
-1.0218389034,
0.0259302333,
-0.2471034825,
-0.155654043,
-0.6839377284,
0.0433727466,
-0.135351941,
-0.1020348892,
0.2340058833,
-0.4220069051,
-0.1326625645,
-0.2726623714,
0.2886484563,
0.7856389284,
-0.1599413753,
0.7972168922,
-0.0256691333,
0.1552973241,
0.0221559089,
-0.1267545819,
-0.1102078706,
-0.3619581759,
-0.9361080527,
-0.2651658654,
0.2589361966,
0.1584403068,
-0.9749293327,
0.1572498679,
-0.2886467278,
-0.3396113217,
-0.8523319364,
0.1909767687,
0.5802057385,
0.7525404096,
0.5172117949,
-0.0821676925,
-0.3488616943,
-0.5635259748,
0.003757755,
-0.3186942935,
0.0644344985,
0.3108522594,
0.2095857561,
-0.3167006075,
1.0309755802,
-0.4789845049,
-0.2473277152,
-0.2562431395,
0.4556906521,
0.2926199436,
0.3595486581,
-0.0065339357,
-0.8860946298,
-0.4289945662,
0.1768947095,
-0.8299567699,
-0.0361736417,
-0.2524495721,
-0.0025317438,
0.1406391114,
0.6020234227,
-0.3479869366,
0.4392669499,
0.6212458014,
-0.1567917466,
0.2184960097,
-0.4471157491,
-0.2864459455,
-0.7294017673,
-0.0739410296,
0.0672868416,
-0.3698619306,
-1.1485110521,
-0.2315515727,
0.1397880167,
-0.054272186,
-0.5096289515,
0.2509787381,
-0.4311409593,
-0.1943518519,
-0.5632886887,
0.6381790638,
0.0413706377,
0.527113378,
0.2800137699,
0.7357665896,
0.2947875559,
-0.6707980037,
-0.0972947627,
0.2071845382,
-0.1421848983,
0.3753943443,
-0.6772446036,
0.3994807899,
-0.4463323653,
0.0335892439,
-0.8871889114,
0.1474432349,
-0.0448496006,
-0.503007412,
0.4915336967,
-0.1843713224,
-0.0949423686,
0.2943447232,
0.1273358017,
0.5403084159,
0.4468265772,
-0.4075819552,
0.5193766356,
0.2425280958,
0.021830542,
-0.3938074112,
-0.7656720281,
-0.1739610732,
-0.0383402966,
-0.2753781676,
0.5711937547,
-0.1968465149,
-0.2792670727,
0.0250153188,
-0.2331201285,
-0.1060234904,
-0.070394285,
0.3857971132,
0.2658221424,
-0.3209736645,
0.3361204565,
-0.0062103975,
-0.6406035423,
-0.0578993931,
-0.2113177031,
0.469430536,
-0.221701026,
-0.2144007534,
-0.706910193,
0.333743602,
0.3767139316,
-0.1674741507,
0.5101022124,
0.7396389842,
-0.3995990455,
-0.005146422,
-0.3715313375,
-0.1343477815,
-0.5218849778,
0.2206647098,
-0.6446329355,
-0.8271331191,
0.0292246919,
0.0430111438,
-0.0312177297,
0.2497537136,
0.2038448155,
-0.2659025192,
0.5941416621,
0.7521405816,
-0.2355442792,
0.3999817371,
-0.389827162,
0.0459207632,
-0.7731404901,
-0.3824220598,
-0.3302493393,
-0.128663063,
-0.5222676396,
-0.4644191265,
0.4165296555,
0.3440931439,
0.1491573304,
0.4676487744,
-0.3973159492,
0.3774791658,
0.4732497334,
0.3339588642,
0.6143606305,
0.0452757366,
0.0266945399,
-0.3227481544,
-0.7982683778,
-0.2913862169,
0.5506801009,
0.3715593815,
0.8658614755,
0.2620088458,
1.0200009346,
0.1605264097,
-0.1906974614,
-0.9170124531,
0.3921115398,
-0.5317236781,
-0.0082568834,
-0.6899252534,
-0.6479035616,
-0.9081544876,
0.5006904602,
0.1108566523,
-0.6919564009,
0.3416341841,
-0.0005282224,
-0.5618596673,
-0.0846590772,
-0.7898801565,
0.6036590934,
-0.1426109076,
-0.0154291913,
-0.2732646763,
-0.5487955809,
0.1829790622,
-0.2356260419,
0.4856325388,
-0.264742285,
-0.1162787825,
0.7555021048,
-0.3449211717,
0.9065435529,
-0.0733352974,
-0.0465802737,
0.1334624738,
-0.2374148071,
0.2659442425,
0.1306732297,
-0.1627325565,
0.2434483171,
-0.2877421975,
-0.4251433313,
-0.6302563548,
0.7009717822,
-0.9696511626,
-0.2853901982,
-0.4567375481,
-0.5431634784,
0.0808290914,
0.0241891704,
0.3355613947,
0.7526048422,
-0.0477025732,
0.1214963347,
1.0136384964,
0.1292548776,
0.9249215126,
0.8687422276,
0.2592360079,
-0.3488902152,
1.0554236174,
0.034080442,
0.531742692,
0.7045726776,
0.222103551,
-0.567966938,
-0.7124928832,
-0.4350602925,
0.3205114007,
-0.5166475773,
-0.2278037667,
-0.5205702782,
-0.3738688231,
-0.5245323777,
-0.0541117974,
-0.4532689154,
-0.119361639,
-0.803653717,
-0.0553700328,
0.4501461685,
0.8823561668,
-0.2789929807,
0.7491933107,
-0.6861028075,
0.5337965488,
0.3420461416,
-0.0549536683,
-0.0796665922,
-0.7355809212,
-0.2277203053,
0.0736055076,
0.0798051879,
-0.6827018261,
0.386113286,
0.5148958564,
0.5712000728,
0.564925909,
0.3028624654,
1.1501736641,
-0.6948473454,
0.3724349439,
0.4063685536,
-1.2900276184,
0.9199652672,
-0.2037873864,
0.7436459661,
0.8486597538,
0.3457332253,
-0.57172966,
-0.2227764279,
-0.6329502463,
-0.619690001,
1.0077044964,
0.4861863554,
-0.0188161563,
0.0084701711,
0.3234891295,
-0.0730854571,
0.0584359467,
-0.9765010476,
-0.4828558862,
0.0007335585,
-0.221110329,
-0.2997365892,
-0.0450467244,
0.1340599954,
-0.2662228644,
0.7339353561,
-0.1559284925,
-0.0600701869,
0.3077760637,
-0.4152493775,
-0.0601324514,
0.3416472375,
0.5175064206,
0.5567886233,
-0.120958589,
0.302906096,
0.2981166542,
-0.7451840043,
0.2235505134,
0.1507601589,
-0.3650943637,
0.4352665842,
0.3773154616,
0.9158437252,
0.6243755221,
-0.4059492052,
0.4132894278,
-0.2778368294,
0.0055163116,
-0.2799889445,
-0.0679050237,
-0.0873802677,
0.1425890923,
0.4275195301,
-0.1321090162,
-0.0184848122,
-0.5461170077,
0.5783240795,
0.1315504611,
-0.8265966773,
-0.1827440709,
0.3029003143,
0.216295898,
-0.2935734093,
0.5987687111,
-0.3286557794,
-0.0781654269,
0.1994773895,
0.6580539942,
0.4939131737,
-0.4172104299,
0.5937739015,
0.0199317578,
0.3411340714,
0.1222848818,
-0.0628502145,
-0.4233987629,
-0.6078416109,
-0.4943630993,
-0.6559609771,
-0.344406724,
0.1724027395,
-0.8265798092,
0.2712357938,
-0.2925802767,
0.1357500702,
0.1695999354,
0.1466796249,
-0.267090559,
0.3252857327,
0.2618429065,
0.4990144968,
-0.6952489614,
1.3441368341,
0.285518527,
-0.4020400643,
-0.9069875479,
-0.1412823796,
-0.1086380258,
-0.6248599291,
0.2835114002,
0.0459806211,
-0.2918879986,
0.3829529881,
-0.1101372689,
-0.8158475161,
1.1402347088,
0.4133877456,
-0.9309976697,
-0.1080343351,
0.388903141,
0.2925229371,
-0.1757414192,
0.4428287745,
0.8307171464,
0.0591306947,
0.5205463171,
-0.6522642374,
-0.1392748207,
0.0781477764,
-0.0691297427,
0.302976191,
-0.4577541053,
0.8076713085,
0.006688504,
-0.3194026053,
0.032970693,
0.8583706021,
0.2629529238,
0.6264610887,
0.571334064,
0.579862833,
0.9077364802,
-0.0721947923,
0.5036092401,
0.18094486,
0.2993283272,
1.6240986586,
0.0258022193,
1.134437561,
0.3984928429,
-0.0759504437,
0.7110387683,
0.4227112234,
0.3462238312,
0.7828817964,
0.042836342,
-0.7763829231,
-0.1903499961,
-0.0806394666,
-0.3470936418,
0.7423383594,
0.6564498544,
-0.1359224766,
-0.4321305156,
0.1041777059,
-0.0024634055,
0.2716085315,
-0.4232333004,
1.2026482821,
0.384873569,
-0.3270742297,
0.785450995,
-0.0623157285,
0.6836550236,
-0.8080754876,
-0.0428869203,
-0.2758450508,
0.0668631941,
-0.4286054671,
-0.4302898347,
0.38519907,
0.1192812845,
-0.1904095113,
-0.2791608274,
0.7739328146,
-0.6613121033,
-0.536064446,
0.381400317,
0.3919190168,
0.5755661726,
-0.2884601653,
-0.6331560612,
0.0784875974,
0.1702101678,
0.5823131204,
0.2932926416,
0.6297147274,
0.376624316,
0.2961512208,
0.630847156,
-0.0887077972,
-0.0053700521,
0.2873492837,
0.8848310113,
-0.5512585044,
-0.3843297362,
-1.1117218733,
0.455141902,
-0.0260686055,
-0.1429100335,
0.6541716456,
0.605001688,
0.8532006145,
0.2126412392,
0.5790815949,
0.1241714731,
0.2002556473,
-0.6488138437,
0.8818265796,
-0.3006455302,
0.2115378976,
-0.3814084232,
-0.5836104751,
-0.0712212697,
0.752540946,
-0.1670754999,
-0.3931517601,
0.6581302881,
0.5899848342,
-0.0542844348,
0.0758172348,
0.9004018903,
0.1614585519,
0.0152732022,
0.6078513265,
0.5335189104,
-0.6432527304,
0.6507011652,
-0.4265415967,
-0.3529154062,
0.2666540146,
-0.5667983294,
-0.8880674839,
-0.5517903566,
-0.5052475929,
-0.1356802583,
0.1838312447,
0.6174929738,
0.9635254741,
-0.6769268513,
-0.4156314135,
-0.3465144634,
0.3002030253,
0.189397186,
-0.1683632284,
0.2215469331,
-0.5550770164,
-0.7718356252,
0.8500842452,
0.3553835154,
0.2167912424,
-0.1223169863,
-0.3545167148,
-0.3074595928,
-0.1336191595,
0.8146663308,
0.2417903095,
-0.6954268217,
-0.0173391756,
-0.2038601488,
-0.0249103252,
0.2484218031,
0.692720592,
-1.0189436674,
0.3296609223,
0.1217572242,
0.531479001,
0.8031010032,
0.1885806322,
0.3813425303,
-1.2903740406,
0.355484724,
0.2522080243,
0.0820231736,
0.2662465274,
-0.4048297405,
0.3149560392,
0.1235516369,
-0.367272675,
-0.4982249737,
0.1384405792,
-1.1513866186,
-0.2506240606,
1.0899963379,
-0.2562693655,
-0.2920678258,
-0.2114629298,
-0.0241954867,
0.4419366419,
-0.7165236473,
0.3054457307,
0.2899338603,
-0.3138989508,
-0.4845969081,
-0.3984158337,
0.5157997012,
0.436239779,
-1.0504213572,
-0.1186119318,
0.2651048303,
-0.0748390406,
0.174720481,
0.9520370364,
0.0894661024,
0.1157698706,
0.0564755574,
-0.2907992303,
0.3762461841,
-0.4458302557,
-0.6938583851,
-0.2937687039,
-0.0586396046,
-0.6072760224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18486v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18486v4 | A Systematic Study and Comprehensive Evaluation of ChatGPT on Benchmark Datasets | 2023-05-29T12:37:21 | 2023-07-05T16:19:38 | Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, M Saiful Bari, Mizanur Rahman, Md Amran Hossen Bhuiyan, Shafiq Joty, Jimmy Xiangji Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The development of large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT has brought a
lot of attention recently. However, their evaluation in the benchmark academic
datasets remains under-explored due to the difficulty of evaluating the
generative outputs produced by this model against the ground truth. In this
paper, we aim to present a thorough evaluation of ChatGPT's performance on
diverse academic datasets, covering tasks like question-answering, text
summarization, code generation, commonsense reasoning, mathematical
problem-solving, machine translation, bias detection, and ethical
considerations. Specifically, we evaluate ChatGPT across 140 tasks and analyze
255K responses it generates in these datasets. This makes our work the largest
evaluation of ChatGPT in NLP benchmarks. In short, our study aims to validate
the strengths and weaknesses of ChatGPT in various tasks and provide insights
for future research using LLMs. We also report a new emergent ability to follow
multi-query instructions that we mostly found in ChatGPT and other
instruction-tuned models. Our extensive evaluation shows that even though
ChatGPT is capable of performing a wide variety of tasks, and may obtain
impressive performance in several benchmark datasets, it is still far from
achieving the ability to reliably solve many challenging tasks. By providing a
thorough assessment of ChatGPT's performance across diverse NLP tasks, this
paper sets the stage for a targeted deployment of ChatGPT-like LLMs in
real-world applications. | [
-0.3307366371,
-0.8086469173,
0.3133583963,
0.4022378623,
-0.0471571572,
0.1899618208,
-0.5942726135,
-0.2196667045,
-0.2512402236,
0.19399257,
-0.5411129594,
-0.563457787,
-0.6444829702,
0.1137282625,
-0.6193103194,
1.0898250341,
0.0896039009,
0.0996532813,
-0.1605172455,
0.0759289414,
-0.5913735628,
-0.6553692222,
-0.6300084591,
-0.253954798,
0.2385412157,
0.3214167356,
0.4753637016,
0.2245837897,
0.8551774025,
0.2332881689,
-0.1239029095,
0.1845830828,
-0.7696442604,
0.1963871419,
0.0776527673,
-0.4260058403,
-0.2175636292,
-0.1935781091,
0.7743269205,
0.6108096838,
-0.4331629574,
0.2372942269,
0.3700676858,
0.6441312432,
-0.282676816,
0.4102922082,
-0.8293146491,
0.0516789518,
-0.3646717072,
0.0333549604,
-0.4660879374,
-0.367815733,
0.1717443615,
-0.3778263032,
0.1861391962,
0.2739854455,
0.6570169926,
0.2850393355,
-0.2107407451,
-0.2992941439,
-0.5984483957,
0.814663589,
-0.763107419,
0.3834250569,
-0.0212073792,
0.5736835599,
-0.3700609207,
-0.8014954925,
-0.3279166222,
-0.3554510176,
0.0386404097,
0.3158098459,
-0.0616485253,
-0.041093342,
0.4062784612,
0.481096983,
-0.7896516919,
0.075958401,
-0.1035855263,
0.006681792,
0.3777484596,
0.2186780572,
0.3017078638,
-0.1352588832,
-0.2806337178,
-0.0709273443,
-0.6526414156,
-0.1713335514,
0.2068971694,
0.3041480482,
-0.0507681668,
0.6799409986,
-0.3624241054,
0.5899543166,
-0.5776762366,
0.2045487016,
0.0612313896,
-0.3399462104,
-0.0222511385,
-0.3376582265,
1.0796025991,
0.3990093768,
0.4990198314,
-0.3762642741,
-0.1152734384,
0.0275213849,
0.28665483,
-0.7768111229,
-0.1958978027,
0.1136769354,
-0.2359484583,
-0.0862797946,
-0.3806481957,
-0.7659358978,
-0.334282279,
-0.1156112105,
0.0621715449,
-0.6894893646,
-0.1446965933,
0.2700384855,
0.0541591123,
0.4262050688,
0.2897622883,
-0.8071334958,
0.5082108974,
0.9758105874,
0.8848060369,
-0.4987700284,
-0.3271260262,
-0.1505376697,
-0.2602325976,
-0.1232448518,
0.8732429147,
-0.5977140665,
-0.2783182859,
0.0500576496,
-0.3442205489,
-0.4165361226,
-0.482733041,
0.8967626095,
-0.4153399765,
0.0132782329,
-0.3378851414,
-0.7641522884,
0.0239366964,
0.5253879428,
-0.366656661,
1.0912282467,
-0.1572871953,
-0.8909590244,
0.2398746759,
-0.6599166989,
-0.1965740621,
0.2057502121,
-0.1710298508,
-0.2512103319,
-0.0814621001,
0.2379677892,
0.448486656,
-0.5210463405,
0.3420179486,
-0.227960825,
-0.5311093926,
0.4593485594,
-0.7397662997,
0.5249879956,
0.0595003366,
-0.2722955048,
-0.1422785521,
-0.6150517464,
0.2421845496,
0.1448104084,
-0.3110223711,
0.1544995457,
0.2346674651,
0.2059633285,
0.0643108562,
0.1334984899,
-0.5240684152,
0.2801979482,
-0.1779082865,
0.4900653064,
0.5235549212,
-0.0998004377,
-0.1772794127,
-0.3570944667,
0.5344637632,
-0.5878896117,
0.0598064847,
-0.1563393176,
-0.7111679912,
-0.8002937436,
-0.1899938732,
0.3845247924,
0.730774045,
-0.4230087399,
0.1839356273,
-0.4738590717,
-0.6829403043,
-0.4874456823,
0.0566070005,
0.5555785298,
0.3710778952,
0.3047583699,
-0.294195056,
-0.3488768041,
-0.9661206007,
-0.4635601044,
-0.0502000824,
-0.2823668718,
0.5152150989,
0.4145878553,
-0.0632746369,
0.6420863867,
-0.3732750118,
-0.1182342246,
-0.1931425184,
0.255831331,
0.3384561837,
0.2384574562,
0.1129109934,
-0.4380310476,
-0.4934700727,
-0.0005578399,
-0.7044416666,
-0.2412517071,
-0.0434661098,
-0.11705257,
-0.2697117329,
0.3478136063,
-0.6367038488,
-0.0431913435,
0.6131370664,
-0.0132405227,
0.7683542371,
0.0781854838,
0.2123621553,
-0.8174889684,
0.1672662348,
-0.0322573483,
-0.1862864494,
-0.5067113638,
0.1839589775,
-0.0460778177,
-0.2104022205,
-0.2906109691,
0.2435314506,
-0.2309059203,
-0.2471111566,
-0.000085706,
0.4032787383,
-0.3003686965,
0.4736029506,
0.0428923257,
0.9323779941,
0.4741730392,
-0.2759818733,
0.4539528191,
0.4424786568,
-0.6303546429,
0.3306418657,
-0.932605505,
0.1952300668,
0.1401274502,
0.1705206633,
-1.1378849745,
-0.1041360274,
-0.0384895392,
-0.3214445412,
0.1519369036,
-0.3365156353,
-0.8401861191,
-0.2142429054,
-0.0504932106,
0.1316968203,
0.5831964612,
-0.2962527573,
0.2101970315,
0.2028290927,
-0.3693518937,
-0.5317174196,
-0.4741366208,
0.2667730153,
-0.191213578,
-0.6583974361,
0.2639311254,
-0.0074962387,
-0.1943069845,
-0.3413508534,
-0.0598599911,
0.1564244777,
0.0130839944,
0.1725376099,
0.0775389969,
-0.1425533593,
0.1203525662,
-0.2888295352,
-0.064127475,
0.0827106982,
0.0676278397,
0.8802124858,
-0.5814417005,
-0.7782381177,
-0.0899214596,
0.0510733724,
0.2718278766,
-0.2911405861,
0.5298622847,
0.5849137306,
0.0426828749,
-0.2878983319,
-0.6645881534,
-0.1445019394,
-0.4077459276,
0.5717852116,
-0.2420688868,
-0.8091919422,
0.5419353843,
-0.2272966057,
0.5046150684,
0.3382749856,
0.5524514914,
0.009004565,
0.7335632443,
0.1370787919,
0.0070076324,
0.2614184916,
-0.0767130107,
0.215006426,
-0.9613173604,
-0.1128294393,
-0.6086362004,
-0.1133076921,
-0.7884568572,
-0.4866384566,
0.2391349673,
-0.0482631475,
-0.1454745382,
0.2965016067,
-0.5030112863,
0.4014723003,
0.3754158616,
0.0886148214,
0.4308464229,
-0.1466171145,
-0.038450636,
-0.076968573,
-0.8347755671,
-0.7299847007,
1.2231632471,
0.3314956129,
0.7714506984,
0.0979560167,
0.454297483,
0.1628603041,
0.3451360166,
-0.747956872,
0.6878623962,
-0.2764876783,
-0.4868146777,
-0.2913188338,
-0.4452111125,
-0.8360742927,
0.4601786733,
-0.1116962805,
-0.8363949656,
-0.4991966188,
-0.0431654863,
-0.0127172703,
0.0810247809,
-0.8735620975,
0.9793493152,
-0.2391623557,
-0.3766689897,
-0.1625683606,
-0.4455263019,
0.4746591151,
-0.0689670071,
0.0673330128,
-0.3765886426,
0.002211527,
0.7456697226,
-0.0267946236,
0.8570264578,
0.1482336819,
0.0140970554,
0.121862188,
0.060801845,
0.3690713942,
0.1793351024,
-0.1364462823,
0.3184095621,
0.1437038928,
-0.2755014598,
-0.4975493252,
0.7332978845,
-0.5230571628,
-0.4954132438,
-0.2801128924,
-0.5303840041,
-0.5623186231,
0.1464936733,
0.0774990842,
0.3703966737,
-0.5088942647,
0.3270706236,
0.6384751201,
-0.3402367234,
0.3160131872,
0.4590361416,
-0.3218777478,
-0.0205681901,
0.7530928254,
-0.0283173583,
0.3031267524,
0.3776168823,
0.0643725619,
-0.3069593906,
-0.7599621415,
-0.5374737978,
0.0167929903,
-0.6057392955,
-0.0097293109,
-0.5397791266,
-0.3364767432,
-0.1246794015,
0.1577317864,
-0.5422950387,
-0.3559230566,
0.3410476446,
0.2215170562,
0.2292824537,
0.5552057624,
0.438250035,
0.3986309171,
-0.6165502071,
0.243373245,
0.3082966805,
0.6019389033,
-0.0393841118,
-0.3887811899,
0.0760755017,
0.0778154656,
-0.3201361299,
-0.6010577679,
0.1396238953,
0.2886683941,
0.6564144492,
0.0425552428,
-0.0585433766,
0.5216276646,
-0.8122438788,
0.7810521722,
-0.162339747,
-0.7215160728,
0.3065221012,
-0.586635828,
0.4388684332,
0.5902017355,
0.2535307109,
-0.7674247622,
-0.4840809703,
-0.5700435042,
-0.8555785418,
0.5153884888,
0.638518095,
0.2328764349,
0.0640132204,
0.140550077,
0.0530201271,
0.2773812115,
-0.5735140443,
-0.1646230221,
-0.0179022364,
-0.0073795193,
0.0381552428,
-0.1859081686,
-0.0898799375,
0.1786106825,
0.6422811151,
-0.0332498439,
0.3720386922,
-0.2528704405,
-0.1127730757,
0.5778986216,
0.5575045943,
0.3211249113,
0.7680453658,
-0.3349233866,
-0.1384171546,
0.3037496507,
-0.4844502509,
-0.3351298273,
0.4214353859,
-0.0542805903,
0.0581011027,
0.4382754266,
0.5325909853,
0.3721538484,
-0.9046654105,
0.4990172684,
-0.3220968843,
0.0548135787,
-0.1667748243,
0.1806328148,
0.2742680907,
0.0470063239,
0.3285847902,
-0.1190932244,
0.2023598552,
-0.2903815806,
0.2311980426,
0.6128988266,
-0.2459085435,
-0.0202432852,
0.4792293608,
0.1316055954,
-0.1751517653,
0.8477143049,
-0.0233143438,
-0.5551384091,
0.5959960222,
0.4238565862,
0.6394329667,
-0.0184057485,
0.0939389542,
0.3703459799,
0.3967048824,
-0.236592412,
0.112682566,
-0.0625503063,
-0.7422561646,
-0.7672749162,
-0.6693605781,
-0.7784811854,
0.0892126039,
-0.5275797248,
0.1989608705,
-0.2139111161,
-0.079107441,
0.0094555477,
-0.0672625527,
-0.6610689759,
-0.0216953531,
-0.0327483378,
0.8153179884,
-0.5839887857,
0.6065101624,
0.3903062642,
-0.082022652,
-0.6158903837,
-0.009971804,
0.0069926912,
-1.1286540031,
0.4585733116,
0.2531057596,
0.0563433729,
-0.0680737048,
-0.4253504872,
-0.632663548,
0.8575661182,
0.3252673149,
-0.8292603493,
0.0870105699,
0.3612006605,
0.7331979871,
-0.0055817682,
0.7124530673,
0.5504621267,
0.3006318808,
0.1027855054,
-1.1862834692,
-0.101646632,
-0.3194787502,
-0.0201241747,
0.1254554987,
-0.8153074384,
0.5162305832,
0.1584320813,
-0.2051118016,
-0.0951540321,
0.3325391412,
0.3537091315,
-0.1326693147,
0.2316777557,
0.4569530785,
0.6262001991,
-0.3302088678,
1.0896505117,
-0.3983156979,
0.4131032526,
1.2324252129,
-0.335350275,
0.9395525455,
0.3162491918,
-0.5593289137,
0.1283475012,
0.4920991659,
-0.2604420781,
0.2905821502,
0.5736067891,
-0.2647981048,
-0.1700044423,
-0.1444466859,
-0.3603933752,
0.4794437885,
0.4020788372,
-0.0278372616,
-0.3735306263,
-0.263602823,
-0.0112298578,
-0.0713950694,
-0.0078202449,
0.7437797785,
0.1616964042,
-0.6785184741,
0.5668769479,
-0.0835839733,
0.6747536659,
-0.6869959831,
-0.1381639838,
-0.2197130769,
0.0845548511,
-0.0641743913,
-0.988261044,
0.251622349,
0.2747362852,
0.3003424108,
-0.3898755014,
0.6835991144,
-0.1445767879,
-0.4426853657,
0.0586347282,
0.4849882424,
0.451045841,
-0.2029194236,
-0.7221316695,
0.1368634999,
0.0176142156,
-0.3863297701,
0.3998228312,
0.4292979836,
0.1487202793,
0.9783886671,
0.5848873854,
0.0719950274,
0.1265592128,
0.2422209382,
0.8150428534,
-0.4017350376,
-0.0906170309,
-0.8282061815,
0.3532577753,
-0.1650680602,
-0.40144822,
0.9111766219,
0.7413625121,
0.7770934105,
0.0416877195,
0.8515375853,
-0.1646889299,
0.6477418542,
-0.5104492903,
0.5187041163,
-0.0447219983,
0.4995798767,
-0.2862017155,
-0.9428174496,
-0.162918821,
0.4645307064,
-0.4654197395,
0.1020560488,
0.617428124,
0.761323452,
-0.0236809999,
0.2417289913,
0.3169313371,
0.024219133,
0.4401844144,
0.5951244831,
0.995129168,
-0.4160225093,
0.8481177688,
-0.1996071041,
-0.1549498737,
-0.0964859873,
-0.9857481718,
-0.994759798,
-0.419038415,
-0.2388660908,
-0.116525799,
0.201686129,
0.6061810255,
0.5780618787,
-0.7649279833,
-0.2700206637,
-0.1719992906,
-0.0763941109,
-0.2635049522,
-0.2149358243,
0.3997321427,
-0.598790288,
-0.7529242635,
0.3259176612,
0.1160635129,
-0.2706475854,
-0.2041136175,
0.1915665865,
-0.0320671946,
-0.1802026778,
0.5835562944,
0.095028393,
-0.5481377244,
-0.0123662949,
0.1047479808,
-0.149665311,
0.0928808674,
0.686880827,
-0.4325392544,
0.2650986314,
0.4095637202,
0.8526152372,
0.7310138345,
0.0235099513,
0.6174448133,
-0.6563611031,
-0.2581140101,
0.3473905325,
0.3270993233,
0.4544089437,
0.0300093926,
0.7397065163,
-0.1441954821,
-0.7994918227,
-0.6549308896,
0.0328108855,
-1.0599141121,
0.0088795098,
1.2940095663,
-0.2387334704,
0.120140709,
-0.0838505551,
-0.3362271488,
0.0552570373,
-0.4664370418,
0.9158376455,
1.0237617493,
-0.25936836,
-0.2997202873,
-1.130401969,
0.371768266,
0.5784953237,
-0.9020792246,
0.4090344906,
0.411499083,
0.200706616,
-0.0491166562,
0.4445643127,
-0.1787834466,
-0.1200130209,
0.0251502022,
0.0816200674,
0.0592554361,
0.1810479462,
0.0049616061,
0.149780646,
0.271116972,
-0.1448781639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04480v1 | Exploring the Compositional Generalization in Context Dependent Text-to-SQL Parsing | 2023-05-29T12:36:56 | 2023-05-29T12:36:56 | Aiwei Liu, Wei Liu, Xuming Hu, Shuang Li, Fukun Ma, Yawen Yang, Lijie Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | In the context-dependent Text-to-SQL task, the generated SQL statements are
refined iteratively based on the user input utterance from each interaction.
The input text from each interaction can be viewed as component modifications
to the previous SQL statements, which could be further extracted as the
modification patterns. Since these modification patterns could also be combined
with other SQL statements, the models are supposed to have the compositional
generalization to these novel combinations. This work is the first exploration
of compositional generalization in context-dependent Text-to-SQL scenarios. To
facilitate related studies, we constructed two challenging benchmarks named
\textsc{CoSQL-CG} and \textsc{SParC-CG} by recombining the modification
patterns and existing SQL statements. The following experiments show that all
current models struggle on our proposed benchmarks. Furthermore, we found that
better aligning the previous SQL statements with the input utterance could give
models better compositional generalization ability. Based on these
observations, we propose a method named \texttt{p-align} to improve the
compositional generalization of Text-to-SQL models. Further experiments
validate the effectiveness of our method. Source code and data are available. | [
0.0676745027,
-0.8880728483,
0.6195681095,
0.2316703796,
-0.3408280015,
-0.1837381274,
-0.2520516217,
-0.2673182189,
0.0419347957,
0.6361397505,
-0.6884396076,
-0.7270893455,
-0.2975917459,
0.2709743679,
-0.3625940382,
0.816830337,
0.0326465406,
0.1258477569,
-0.5195688009,
-0.0889898241,
-1.1555927992,
-0.6725458503,
-0.3578655124,
-0.0805344358,
0.1908138692,
0.1980210096,
0.2597893178,
0.6308557391,
0.4627678692,
0.2594159842,
-0.0755849034,
-0.0061045694,
-0.4139486849,
0.5124875903,
-0.7082520723,
-0.5607034564,
-0.3818251789,
-0.2255738676,
0.5083374381,
0.8792379498,
-0.2767145336,
-0.2017694861,
0.1755745262,
0.5219092369,
-0.763374269,
0.2371207327,
-0.8360094428,
0.0453376547,
-0.0120741576,
-0.132440269,
-0.8408045173,
0.1008962467,
0.259635061,
-0.5073210597,
0.3028766215,
0.1863027364,
0.565895617,
0.1253207922,
-0.5874508619,
-0.2922474146,
-0.5460805297,
0.9967044592,
-0.4447096884,
0.3203997016,
0.0939741209,
0.264770329,
-0.1667230129,
-0.7233709693,
-0.3598524332,
-0.1445568949,
-0.6058122516,
-0.0331390575,
0.0874678567,
0.0647065789,
0.0431209765,
0.536513567,
-0.5128015876,
-0.2309051454,
0.2417513877,
-0.0902820751,
0.6164408326,
0.3770926297,
0.4251621068,
-0.0921034515,
-0.4984824955,
0.0594150759,
-0.6069472432,
0.1068612859,
-0.3046490848,
0.4747860432,
-0.15829584,
0.762424469,
-0.3766291738,
1.1185362339,
0.33450526,
0.2734142244,
-0.1944860667,
-0.6491171122,
-0.5255694389,
0.0334538557,
0.723154366,
0.4367144406,
-0.0265230667,
-0.524602592,
-0.0981587023,
0.1489280462,
0.222386986,
-0.6902340055,
-0.1519985944,
0.2446072102,
-0.3786653876,
-0.0752089918,
0.0928269327,
-0.6246417165,
-0.3803071678,
-0.5853757262,
0.3983502984,
-0.2610937953,
0.0940855443,
0.0005706814,
0.0042456202,
0.3725792766,
0.3546411097,
-1.1156944036,
0.40140149,
0.9210137129,
0.7255125642,
-0.7074787021,
-0.1783287078,
-0.4000151753,
0.6867541075,
-0.1560819894,
0.8553997874,
-0.6888110042,
-0.4997032881,
-0.1097719148,
0.1438579112,
-0.4338431358,
-0.6712749004,
0.626198411,
-0.462826997,
0.4947804213,
-0.8337987661,
-0.8492153883,
0.0894932225,
0.2734463513,
-0.5034125447,
0.7251323462,
0.2131674588,
-0.627384901,
0.5247061253,
-0.5137050152,
-0.5975632071,
-0.0999619216,
-0.5487806797,
-0.4077387452,
0.2684469223,
0.2012224346,
0.2703240514,
-0.4196535945,
0.4719593227,
-0.0945915654,
-0.4575034976,
0.1105522886,
0.2121233046,
0.7570599318,
0.011872841,
-0.2390775383,
0.0368736759,
-0.7717922926,
0.018086195,
0.0434255712,
-0.3213192523,
-0.303610146,
0.3708919585,
-0.1924109608,
-0.0133030424,
0.1885881126,
-0.4098967314,
0.1549835205,
-0.5533128977,
0.3085391819,
0.6102954149,
0.2203481048,
0.657315135,
-0.2831402421,
0.2574683726,
0.1715010703,
-0.1400123388,
-0.3194736838,
-0.0228253398,
-0.5277612805,
-0.3611451387,
0.2447482646,
0.6038458943,
-0.476447314,
0.6425501704,
-0.1330771893,
0.0137844495,
0.2344713807,
-0.1451585144,
0.2508368492,
0.7149000168,
0.5768427849,
-0.2414062768,
-0.7508141994,
-0.9187158942,
-0.9702964425,
0.0896705985,
0.0201582164,
0.3188604712,
0.2663152814,
0.0965275094,
1.3858988285,
-0.7677874565,
-0.4429422319,
-0.040480841,
-0.2052898258,
0.0017332977,
0.771822691,
0.4898748398,
-0.6034114361,
-0.8565829992,
0.0796719193,
-0.6057620645,
-0.1737643033,
0.1169113293,
-0.2619153559,
0.1830164343,
0.6445448399,
-0.4135064781,
0.2248555571,
0.4727862179,
-0.5663479567,
0.4665347636,
0.2596411109,
0.1922466159,
-1.1580845118,
0.0338154994,
-0.1671335995,
-0.1356072873,
-0.7033757567,
0.1103431955,
-0.0587745905,
-0.136787653,
-0.2869186103,
0.233065024,
-0.535741508,
-0.0072718752,
0.0043259999,
-0.2848273516,
0.2257531285,
0.4198126793,
0.1742953509,
0.9277391434,
0.4132227898,
-0.5626565218,
0.0011090349,
0.248203814,
-0.1910355985,
0.7645878792,
-0.9345524311,
0.1633546948,
-0.003156496,
0.4234111309,
-1.2362024784,
-0.1552582979,
0.2685440183,
-0.1341204494,
0.2011071295,
-0.3008722365,
-0.2641401589,
0.3930872083,
-0.0725444406,
0.4044776559,
0.0129854111,
-0.4461763799,
0.9188448191,
0.1022160798,
-0.0198590215,
-0.4135202467,
-0.9058991671,
0.129875496,
-0.1756849438,
-0.6915337443,
0.9988857508,
-0.0059939236,
-0.3619385362,
-0.323861748,
-0.2219505012,
-0.2234447747,
-0.1643761843,
-0.0490807332,
0.2346519679,
-0.2713036239,
0.0477631539,
0.3509578705,
0.1803476661,
-0.0082385857,
-0.0766596124,
0.6219167113,
0.0313301906,
-0.2104420364,
-0.5489364266,
0.6956810951,
0.0502218865,
-0.3141628206,
0.9361363053,
0.1166979223,
-0.2323071659,
-0.1190868542,
-0.4729220867,
-0.248001799,
-0.4534222782,
0.2359762937,
-0.5219584703,
-1.0193907022,
0.4297351837,
-0.0781687126,
-0.2420294881,
0.5403883457,
0.3090120554,
-0.1038321629,
0.9712578654,
0.5387826562,
0.2840771377,
0.6112142205,
0.0516379103,
0.0996275321,
-0.5838355422,
-0.2459509075,
-0.6956074834,
-0.0434659757,
-0.5140457749,
-0.2872381806,
0.1660631597,
-0.0967645422,
-0.0299277548,
0.5026579499,
-0.5754679441,
0.8203929067,
-0.0505078174,
0.2505503893,
0.4848042727,
0.1318510324,
-0.1251164824,
-0.3108178675,
-0.3474850655,
-0.1146367639,
0.8698427081,
-0.1759571731,
0.464648962,
0.3304323554,
0.6900752783,
0.3462180197,
0.1430522799,
-0.6011033654,
0.6096916199,
-0.5281391144,
-0.4759454727,
-0.0034141734,
-0.3568902314,
-0.8153645992,
0.5412128568,
-0.1306257546,
-0.8033127189,
0.3405521214,
0.2032221258,
0.110400714,
-0.3585937917,
-1.1569783688,
1.0180578232,
0.0489358902,
-0.6529685855,
0.0233893041,
-0.6374221444,
0.2928619981,
0.3305760622,
-0.0772430301,
0.3447375298,
-0.1761593819,
0.3577394485,
-0.661626637,
0.8557995558,
-0.226969406,
-0.3342449665,
0.2446320653,
0.04881249,
0.6964836121,
-0.0517313145,
-0.0966913328,
-0.169709906,
0.0781350136,
-0.419151634,
-0.6342839003,
0.6906973124,
-0.2920374572,
-0.5552067757,
-0.3590064347,
-0.3919983208,
-0.5144261122,
0.1995711923,
0.2545146942,
0.1873852611,
-0.4640169144,
0.3018237054,
0.70061028,
0.0016437513,
0.3532533348,
0.4943629503,
-0.1738895327,
-0.320246309,
0.5351322889,
-0.1763617545,
0.1342112571,
0.8489211202,
0.1185550541,
-0.420283854,
-0.553784132,
-0.2838208675,
0.0692264438,
-0.5209217072,
-0.1044729874,
-0.6845012903,
0.2620114088,
-0.4192725718,
-0.1704611331,
-0.0171736702,
-0.4587038755,
-0.5628836155,
0.3188898861,
-0.1589017361,
0.4366557896,
0.6979056001,
0.6290027499,
-0.5720399022,
0.0917769819,
0.3215630949,
0.5211870074,
-0.1840043068,
-0.2930442095,
-0.0995908901,
-0.1791618019,
-0.3427525461,
-1.1746257544,
-0.0819861814,
0.41389516,
0.3743656278,
0.0393772013,
-0.1011976376,
0.6127957106,
-0.3897978961,
0.9459294081,
0.098713398,
-1.2806255817,
0.7090144157,
-0.5958387852,
0.1370534748,
0.8651009202,
-0.0918345824,
-0.4296278656,
-0.0015397209,
-0.2341600209,
-0.666487515,
0.6870492697,
0.1128285378,
0.0014552637,
0.0393405296,
0.5744506717,
0.2373098284,
0.2196201086,
-0.8726934195,
-0.1159135997,
0.0079912981,
-0.157185182,
0.057844121,
-0.2773704827,
-0.0406188406,
-0.3682567775,
0.3292609453,
-0.088391386,
0.052806437,
0.199354127,
-0.4802223444,
0.214002341,
0.4427306056,
0.6839373708,
0.6916360855,
-0.0638922676,
-0.0353518538,
0.0062261247,
-0.1712508351,
0.058653824,
-0.0207105055,
-0.2321057022,
-0.0742365718,
0.0840672404,
0.5389835238,
0.0597201437,
-0.6053451896,
0.6165013313,
-0.2448613793,
-0.016182689,
0.0615135618,
0.2457659692,
0.1405062228,
0.0244377907,
0.0666426569,
-0.0270764604,
0.4017787874,
-0.6006002426,
0.1057231352,
0.5522584319,
-0.2281287611,
-0.2204275727,
0.523888588,
0.0964803323,
-0.1351877898,
0.1889992952,
0.0235000271,
-0.3420830667,
0.364536643,
0.8182298541,
0.8178642988,
-0.3919970691,
-0.1231080666,
0.3544640243,
-0.0484763868,
0.0037058957,
0.2836514711,
-0.3601562381,
-0.4834523499,
-0.5657019019,
-0.2844929993,
-0.3998333216,
-0.2416622043,
-0.600401938,
0.5116878748,
-0.3556753397,
0.0087840995,
-0.0392637402,
-0.1806485057,
-0.2227025032,
0.4039611816,
-0.5510781407,
0.4767570198,
-0.884277463,
0.5086010695,
0.9055584669,
-0.2526608109,
-0.5865427852,
0.2018088251,
-0.28898862,
-0.447578609,
0.2094700933,
0.033172328,
0.1457417756,
-0.1991226226,
-0.5098246336,
-0.5414732695,
0.9821888208,
0.5095552802,
-0.5074617863,
-0.2070236802,
0.4778341651,
0.676797688,
-0.6414089203,
-0.1272539943,
0.8337100148,
0.3292126358,
0.06223654,
-0.5918357372,
0.347251147,
-0.0711974427,
0.3211762309,
0.3012533188,
-0.5919736624,
1.0521749258,
0.2317591608,
-0.2882263958,
0.1449395567,
0.651723206,
0.1975737512,
0.4100147188,
0.3196980655,
0.635573566,
0.265350163,
-0.2104814649,
0.8000563979,
-0.1506468952,
0.5424051285,
1.5254671574,
-0.4222967327,
0.6890809536,
0.7171353102,
-0.4078557789,
0.7659347057,
0.2488750368,
-0.0604918152,
0.5380246639,
0.1944904774,
-0.4677894115,
0.0567591265,
-0.1691517383,
-0.491581887,
0.5813487768,
0.3287100196,
-0.7517267466,
-0.2430578172,
-0.3989498019,
-0.0155538591,
0.3826730251,
-0.0684621707,
1.0946930647,
-0.2028868794,
-0.9822258949,
0.5299345851,
0.2555819154,
0.5344544053,
-0.4117692113,
0.0187493395,
-0.0932390168,
0.1152133122,
-0.3729596734,
-0.4253557622,
0.6578420401,
-0.2161542028,
-0.4448426962,
-0.0865879878,
0.8726154566,
-0.6676363945,
-0.0752513111,
-0.0184207447,
0.2851712108,
-0.4142436981,
-0.4568119645,
-0.3483644128,
0.1977604926,
0.1302256286,
0.0984331742,
0.4882467687,
0.1853611022,
0.0353187434,
0.004341885,
0.2760611773,
-0.303163141,
-0.017904019,
0.0316583775,
0.7474814057,
-0.6360217929,
-0.6937587261,
-1.0295433998,
0.4739055037,
-0.1276172847,
0.0011417265,
0.6575462222,
0.8401542306,
0.6420112252,
-0.3189082742,
0.6728678942,
-0.1590865552,
0.5026408434,
-0.6173297167,
0.4739620686,
-0.4982355237,
0.3939007819,
-0.3081609607,
-1.0760455132,
-0.2434120476,
0.2171377391,
-0.2815109789,
0.1871617734,
0.9799403548,
0.8288581967,
0.0025171356,
0.3477814198,
0.138936311,
-0.0249767862,
0.3110532463,
0.4508955181,
0.6815806031,
-0.4948123395,
0.2216908783,
-0.1593609303,
-0.0881997123,
-0.1743887216,
-1.0741342306,
-0.6509370208,
-0.6181997657,
-0.2213992625,
-0.4571259022,
0.1602001041,
0.7075839043,
0.5049914122,
-0.9680333734,
-0.3509263694,
-0.6008523703,
0.0018319978,
-0.1467563212,
-0.3289847672,
0.3448533118,
-0.4057893455,
-0.6062251925,
0.4498476982,
0.2318962067,
0.0737488642,
0.2984259129,
0.3631284833,
-0.2428991497,
0.0964069143,
0.881166935,
-0.0002130994,
-0.4944740534,
-0.1736679673,
0.0957246572,
-0.009532203,
0.3928658664,
1.2937672138,
-0.5729060173,
0.2775100768,
0.6326627731,
0.7029001713,
0.4612592161,
0.4055987,
0.6420331001,
-1.1496777534,
-0.1673179716,
0.2179965526,
0.2143356353,
0.2450553924,
-0.471204102,
0.3611352444,
0.4417885542,
-0.4233743846,
-0.6963098645,
0.4192587435,
-1.322977066,
-0.2819046676,
0.9652789235,
0.0843317807,
-0.1054347828,
0.0712782294,
-0.4283875525,
0.1320235133,
-0.3188111186,
0.6316606998,
0.872261107,
-0.3384720683,
-0.0836823806,
0.353862673,
0.4107161462,
0.8614843488,
-1.104806304,
0.1943447888,
0.7066067457,
0.4098284245,
-0.2756285369,
0.6003178358,
-0.2472588718,
0.2817316651,
-0.2757870555,
-0.3476340771,
0.2715025544,
-0.0126555795,
-0.4712159038,
0.2991114855,
-0.1575267464,
0.025443323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18034v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18034v3 | A Corpus for Sentence-level Subjectivity Detection on English News Articles | 2023-05-29T11:54:50 | 2024-05-24T12:17:28 | Francesco Antici, Andrea Galassi, Federico Ruggeri, Katerina Korre, Arianna Muti, Alessandra Bardi, Alice Fedotova, Alberto Barrón-Cedeño | cs.CL | cs.CL | We develop novel annotation guidelines for sentence-level subjectivity
detection, which are not limited to language-specific cues. We use our
guidelines to collect NewsSD-ENG, a corpus of 638 objective and 411 subjective
sentences extracted from English news articles on controversial topics. Our
corpus paves the way for subjectivity detection in English and across other
languages without relying on language-specific tools, such as lexicons or
machine translation. We evaluate state-of-the-art multilingual
transformer-based models on the task in mono-, multi-, and cross-language
settings. For this purpose, we re-annotate an existing Italian corpus. We
observe that models trained in the multilingual setting achieve the best
performance on the task. | [
-0.4744932055,
-0.6989125609,
0.6003016233,
0.2949280739,
-0.3422145247,
-0.360342294,
-0.3268270493,
-0.254075557,
0.0707764775,
0.4436413646,
-0.4189901054,
-0.8603816628,
-0.6468519568,
0.3666790426,
-0.5330733657,
1.2514361143,
0.1061767638,
0.2172333598,
-0.2179528326,
-0.2952897847,
0.002619378,
-0.4071296155,
-0.4066978097,
0.2790034413,
0.66426754,
0.3539448977,
0.520246923,
0.1024418622,
0.604434967,
0.2432885617,
-0.321660012,
0.0489151366,
-0.0454069711,
0.2739787102,
-0.5451945662,
-0.3993633687,
-0.3696771264,
0.1852838397,
0.4895998836,
0.6328001618,
0.2843725979,
0.3542146087,
-0.1152894795,
0.4083715081,
-0.6076787114,
0.020367682,
-0.5199728012,
0.1906218082,
-0.0709008202,
-0.057794556,
-0.6990986466,
-0.3335626423,
0.1073439494,
-0.4901138246,
0.3953247964,
-0.2953864634,
0.7554060817,
0.350025326,
-0.6830364466,
-0.1264667213,
-0.4957461953,
0.9266747236,
-0.6603255868,
0.5841782689,
0.4063218236,
-0.5051208138,
0.4417212009,
-0.4571474195,
-0.2372898757,
-0.3125244081,
-0.2427872568,
0.0601927452,
-0.3556811213,
-0.3339247704,
0.3551906347,
0.225793317,
-0.6121682525,
-0.0332346186,
-0.6867852807,
-0.3698020577,
0.6074745059,
-0.2243646532,
0.1925737262,
-0.392265588,
-0.1505999863,
0.4650082588,
-0.562586844,
0.0860981941,
0.4928174913,
0.2217623591,
-0.228628844,
0.6715595126,
-0.2823515236,
0.4978136122,
0.2435885668,
-0.3554755747,
0.5815809965,
-0.3137954772,
0.413566798,
0.1025950685,
0.5421459079,
0.7331020236,
0.3545464873,
-0.2218652964,
-0.0715998337,
0.1618304551,
0.4604980648,
-0.8867126107,
0.152702868,
0.2428920418,
-0.6065181494,
-0.6002445221,
-0.032677602,
-0.770128727,
-0.3417390287,
-0.2967185378,
-0.0296994038,
-0.2081256211,
-0.4644058049,
0.1147243232,
-0.1147841215,
0.1425683498,
0.0334848017,
-0.4399888217,
-0.1908985227,
0.5761702061,
0.7366651297,
-0.5551176667,
-0.2150110602,
-0.5682532787,
0.2880576849,
-0.14904055,
0.9374924898,
-0.6766452789,
-0.1702477038,
0.1943858862,
0.383117795,
0.3394295275,
-0.1723017842,
1.3159632683,
-0.1739819795,
0.6954945326,
-0.1368051767,
-0.390799284,
-0.2193290144,
0.2926445603,
-0.7444568872,
0.81026721,
-0.1720403284,
-0.9382092357,
0.549251914,
-0.7306656837,
-1.074703455,
-0.1704150289,
0.1651597023,
-0.4249575734,
0.2911663353,
0.2253543735,
0.6437739134,
0.073431246,
0.6953844428,
-0.1585625112,
-0.225767076,
0.0436157957,
-0.3505998552,
0.562201798,
0.3429604471,
-0.2825010419,
0.1502609104,
-0.7924550176,
-0.313031882,
-0.4484367669,
-0.3144616783,
-0.63325423,
0.1411030143,
0.1981187314,
0.3971575499,
0.256010443,
-0.8923875093,
-0.1930683404,
-0.3207817078,
0.6481178403,
0.1871072203,
0.1697833687,
0.452034384,
-0.0202893149,
0.3678406477,
0.4451492131,
0.1381643862,
-0.3398899138,
-0.6103106737,
-0.5024480224,
-0.171457395,
-0.0123045845,
0.5006542206,
-0.476565212,
0.680562675,
0.0653668195,
-0.3649107814,
-0.5987455845,
-0.1447049677,
0.2010306418,
0.5389775038,
0.4418947995,
0.1314355731,
-0.6063216329,
-1.1755042076,
-0.465764761,
0.0737232491,
0.1976542324,
-0.0953925475,
0.2019650638,
0.0412870981,
0.8296892643,
-0.4114165604,
-0.3507350981,
-0.1575129926,
0.5574994087,
0.0928983465,
0.4906986654,
0.5671958923,
-1.3132474422,
-0.2162996083,
-0.0541042686,
-0.9103700519,
-0.3462437391,
0.0417556204,
0.1645861864,
0.4187602401,
0.7113617063,
-0.4714825749,
0.4510829151,
0.4751081467,
-0.3526403904,
0.1096965969,
0.2252630889,
0.4619069099,
-1.1701779366,
0.0933855027,
0.6751122475,
-0.3531374037,
-0.6016325951,
-0.030233847,
0.0359060094,
-0.2772244811,
-0.9030618668,
0.3027718961,
-0.3341281712,
0.1031796411,
-0.40068838,
0.1508732885,
0.2715401351,
0.5519305468,
0.6339283586,
0.66490978,
0.5712893605,
-0.3427363336,
0.0682428926,
0.1166772246,
-0.1091903448,
0.8206239343,
-0.5691147447,
-0.0479090847,
-0.503072083,
0.043802958,
-1.0281490088,
-0.0034314459,
-0.0437962003,
-0.3759149909,
-0.1312668324,
-0.0509936735,
0.0073915944,
-0.3109607995,
-0.5219622254,
0.3502530158,
0.142340377,
0.0168880466,
0.5788815618,
0.6108095646,
-0.336610049,
-0.4800310135,
-0.8835601211,
0.0879049376,
-0.3197784126,
-0.382094264,
0.2308224887,
-0.0158844907,
-0.2874847353,
0.2587457299,
-0.0806391761,
-0.3741253316,
0.1117849499,
0.2643927336,
0.0980248451,
-0.2757145464,
0.0092395144,
0.4134497046,
-0.0403949209,
0.2206510603,
-0.0729489326,
0.3306233287,
-0.1640805453,
-0.0677513853,
-0.6676332951,
0.7308369875,
0.6871801615,
-0.5955567956,
0.5322582126,
0.9428200722,
-0.5415003896,
0.1335018277,
-0.6137731671,
-0.2391871363,
-0.3506499231,
0.6288793087,
-0.4590826333,
-0.8861690164,
0.2530687451,
0.2118364722,
-0.0771074444,
0.5371729136,
0.8369724154,
0.1171603277,
1.2064800262,
0.5189068913,
-0.0372672565,
0.3567570448,
0.0126944855,
0.2709999382,
-0.5268784165,
-0.1781154722,
-0.5463813543,
-0.2795048654,
-0.5930454135,
-0.0029545827,
0.238352865,
-0.4288001359,
-0.1477695107,
0.3508989811,
-0.7334137559,
0.483356148,
0.3834462762,
0.2753383219,
0.5295650959,
-0.0433803946,
0.470435977,
-0.3196228743,
-0.1802551597,
-0.713735044,
1.0141712427,
0.3260637522,
0.6576424241,
-0.0109610464,
0.5479920506,
0.503026247,
0.5095595121,
-0.7586176395,
0.4704721868,
-0.4444307089,
-0.8954949379,
-0.1595157385,
-0.1674361974,
-0.63961941,
0.0554015413,
0.0171110164,
-0.564106524,
0.4623057842,
-0.2710946202,
-0.2623954713,
0.2849090695,
-0.8859789371,
1.0039100647,
-0.0558759384,
-0.5281291604,
-0.1603223532,
-0.515422821,
0.3800904453,
0.0661515817,
0.3526121378,
-0.1970105469,
-0.4355610609,
0.6824808121,
0.4347005785,
0.8247816563,
-0.3051813543,
-0.4292199612,
0.0779528916,
-0.0801778287,
0.1475280225,
0.2325364947,
-0.2849878669,
0.293017894,
-0.1360597163,
-0.352326721,
0.1097029969,
0.7446252704,
-0.6230806708,
-0.7019159198,
-0.2946412861,
-0.755150795,
-0.2166519165,
0.309473753,
0.4044005275,
0.2837053835,
-0.3879316151,
0.5711030364,
0.6411539912,
0.0523629487,
0.5738326907,
0.7216972709,
0.0114912875,
-0.2862055898,
0.8444945812,
-0.0224710088,
-0.0312423427,
0.5728412867,
-0.0615269952,
-0.1999172568,
-0.5624044538,
-0.3605720997,
0.0060694045,
-0.3271941841,
-0.2425703108,
-0.8982062936,
0.0602839515,
-0.3921435475,
-0.0228577163,
-0.2524424493,
-0.369899869,
-0.3055534661,
-0.3731615543,
0.1119533554,
0.510193944,
0.1553097516,
-0.0411687531,
-0.6566516161,
0.4856899679,
-0.0900000259,
0.1330278665,
-0.6691614985,
-0.5230500698,
-0.1837281585,
0.0196147822,
-0.329713881,
-1.110640645,
0.2300482243,
-0.0383333787,
0.3848780692,
0.4580245018,
0.2677643895,
-0.0707424656,
-0.3563512564,
0.9203744531,
-0.102368407,
-1.0747330189,
0.7705940008,
-0.5272843242,
0.0367814712,
0.728748858,
0.7937093973,
-0.353449285,
-0.9855389595,
-0.4038971663,
-0.6346465945,
0.6436195374,
-0.1738150567,
0.3163956702,
-0.1983666867,
0.4364125133,
0.3126889467,
0.4672550857,
-1.2988564968,
-0.0630559176,
-0.3674827218,
-0.4679154158,
0.1734590083,
-0.3544208109,
-0.2154865414,
-0.3309756815,
0.6714996696,
-0.1969832331,
-0.0488373227,
0.4227003157,
-0.3348516226,
-0.1597977728,
0.3526284397,
0.6527174115,
0.7583036423,
-0.1992730647,
0.2986871898,
-0.0389428064,
-0.5643538833,
0.3373313248,
0.3113167882,
-0.6194943786,
0.3888449073,
0.3152904212,
0.7201657891,
0.3186419606,
-0.6006211042,
0.902489543,
0.194471702,
-0.3107843399,
-0.2814586163,
-0.313200444,
0.0526586175,
0.2635729909,
0.3921615779,
0.1179539859,
0.537216723,
-0.6101456881,
0.4699976146,
0.2494438142,
-0.4284085333,
-0.4688916504,
0.7563931942,
0.4964576364,
-0.1637708098,
-0.1768170893,
-0.4703110754,
-0.6029620171,
0.4695601463,
0.297388494,
0.9004368186,
-0.3408298492,
0.5976797938,
0.3554206789,
0.4237768054,
0.0289134346,
0.2669436336,
0.0983537808,
-0.8671016693,
-0.6133980751,
-0.2551451623,
-0.3522440493,
0.152761966,
-0.8755037785,
0.5009204149,
-0.1471455842,
-0.0290400852,
0.3856463134,
-0.1061630696,
-0.2887059152,
0.2246933877,
0.5618095398,
0.7028676271,
-1.1474312544,
0.7142024636,
1.033095479,
-0.6057855487,
-0.2875271142,
0.1714972407,
-0.1764923632,
-0.5074414611,
0.4787284434,
0.3302597404,
0.1746956408,
-0.1209642962,
-0.4159036875,
-0.5037683249,
0.7901302576,
0.5386221409,
-0.4828565419,
-0.1281794906,
0.0399999991,
0.5367399454,
-0.4652774632,
0.1192764565,
0.3281531632,
0.8660060763,
-0.4337641001,
-0.4555950463,
-0.0289681777,
-0.2449271232,
-0.4701466262,
0.1713110507,
-0.8585160375,
0.8636530042,
0.025514178,
0.0574567132,
-0.2342991978,
0.8451325893,
-0.2687834799,
0.566125989,
0.6042814851,
0.6316644549,
0.5316445231,
-0.1287054121,
0.7506555319,
-0.6991189122,
0.4805930853,
0.86856848,
-0.5743543506,
0.7187418938,
0.3886377513,
0.0797577798,
0.5779854059,
0.3767915368,
-0.0669162124,
0.6543605924,
-0.1723888516,
-0.3739092946,
-0.3349251449,
-0.6023937464,
-0.2073805481,
0.4170051217,
0.0515388139,
-0.4718492329,
-0.3511901796,
0.6986521482,
0.4528464079,
0.4295451343,
-0.5688623786,
0.674230814,
-0.1937673986,
-0.9673697352,
0.1500661075,
0.2281699777,
0.9095496535,
-0.2295102328,
0.317828238,
-0.2846590579,
0.1293725669,
-0.5687918067,
-0.9214615226,
0.5711460114,
0.3717292547,
-0.4677619636,
-0.2612220049,
0.8034598231,
-0.6713051796,
-0.7739923596,
0.1813369542,
0.7724093795,
0.1639836431,
-0.2830379903,
-0.4302477539,
0.1038654596,
0.192220211,
-0.5735034347,
-0.0501769558,
0.8194596171,
-0.0880313739,
0.1867822409,
0.4629865587,
-0.187479496,
-0.0531832986,
0.3070850074,
0.8155002594,
-0.599050045,
-0.3627383709,
-0.7150258422,
0.4045462906,
-0.3320327997,
-0.6119526625,
0.751965642,
0.9728763103,
0.6070353985,
-0.151076436,
0.7583701015,
-0.133219853,
0.6173531413,
-0.3221569955,
0.3364254236,
-0.5615685582,
-0.1449594349,
-0.0783235431,
-0.7624954581,
-0.3394728303,
0.5904927254,
-0.5005241632,
-0.2091398388,
0.8668297529,
0.798602879,
0.0613402762,
0.4182131886,
0.3399891853,
0.3139330745,
0.0065600271,
0.4739479721,
0.8550054431,
-0.0088256169,
0.4482932389,
-0.378259629,
-0.1941811889,
0.2316744328,
-1.0358968973,
-0.9760141373,
-0.6659322977,
-0.6389384866,
-0.1167475134,
0.0455495194,
0.709664166,
0.7113596797,
-1.1047222614,
0.2088623196,
-0.0908226743,
0.1808360219,
-0.0977827609,
-0.2663829029,
0.1681348681,
-0.5642576218,
-1.1499454975,
0.2259164155,
0.1648098528,
-0.502715826,
-0.650857687,
0.3588826656,
-0.6050441861,
-0.0952150896,
0.5715397,
-0.0782806352,
-0.5517050624,
-0.6223594546,
-0.0079611782,
-0.2147791386,
0.0276453868,
0.9861401916,
-0.4807296693,
-0.2448572367,
0.325684458,
0.3226392269,
0.5955428481,
0.1290722489,
0.2543439269,
-1.0748305321,
0.8933542967,
0.4462192059,
0.407949537,
0.4583670497,
-0.4788262546,
0.5787177086,
0.4884087741,
-0.3520023823,
-0.8803156018,
0.0368523784,
-1.0592639446,
-0.4151037633,
1.3616094589,
-0.2428154498,
-0.210556671,
-0.1592947245,
-0.4370719194,
0.0067357207,
-0.6004391313,
0.5096431971,
1.0175341368,
0.2482299656,
-0.1705358922,
-0.4571814835,
0.4001126587,
0.4527453184,
-0.8802983761,
-0.1387504637,
0.5209695101,
0.1224191785,
0.5028780103,
0.1273425817,
-0.150674358,
0.2258009017,
-0.5445037484,
0.2092324346,
-0.0265722964,
-0.4036349058,
-0.2136832327,
0.5978246331,
-0.2484844029,
-0.1769374609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18029v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18029v2 | Faithfulness Tests for Natural Language Explanations | 2023-05-29T11:40:37 | 2023-06-30T15:41:47 | Pepa Atanasova, Oana-Maria Camburu, Christina Lioma, Thomas Lukasiewicz, Jakob Grue Simonsen, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | Explanations of neural models aim to reveal a model's decision-making process
for its predictions. However, recent work shows that current methods giving
explanations such as saliency maps or counterfactuals can be misleading, as
they are prone to present reasons that are unfaithful to the model's inner
workings. This work explores the challenging question of evaluating the
faithfulness of natural language explanations (NLEs). To this end, we present
two tests. First, we propose a counterfactual input editor for inserting
reasons that lead to counterfactual predictions but are not reflected by the
NLEs. Second, we reconstruct inputs from the reasons stated in the generated
NLEs and check how often they lead to the same predictions. Our tests can
evaluate emerging NLE models, proving a fundamental tool in the development of
faithful NLEs. | [
-0.6314080358,
-1.1199792624,
0.8937245011,
0.2261205763,
-0.4282394946,
-0.5519753695,
-0.1071934253,
-0.3915654421,
0.0374214798,
0.5173323154,
-1.02731359,
-0.1624637395,
-0.4613413215,
0.4557108581,
-0.6959186196,
1.0185158253,
-0.3188822269,
0.157134518,
-0.3926046789,
-0.2035309821,
-0.6823055148,
-0.03566866,
-0.6407172084,
-0.3823283315,
0.639370203,
-0.063301079,
1.103025198,
0.3101426065,
0.3139694333,
0.3787444532,
0.1602364033,
0.028123552,
-0.2264463902,
0.2885917425,
-0.5274718404,
-0.3742225468,
-0.1174417958,
0.2897251844,
0.2317991853,
0.7183855772,
0.2255228758,
0.1905760318,
0.1040921882,
0.4816376865,
-0.5399243236,
-0.2019099444,
-0.6978301406,
0.1487992704,
0.1064791977,
-0.1836088002,
-0.5270132422,
-0.7460798025,
0.4975049794,
-0.3829967678,
0.5525203347,
0.1315759569,
1.0868422985,
0.3914809227,
-0.1467174292,
-0.2413853407,
-0.5787912607,
0.8678796887,
-0.8593397141,
0.6983959079,
0.5789935589,
0.2244330347,
-0.2490493357,
-0.6581012011,
-0.7995821834,
-0.5925534964,
-0.2720147967,
0.1644481719,
-0.3666342199,
0.0222673956,
0.1976329684,
0.3650935888,
-1.0869466066,
-0.1944779754,
0.1696447581,
-0.2075070739,
0.5178166032,
-0.192775622,
0.5430682302,
0.0002133962,
-0.3289892375,
-0.0217735805,
-0.4782173634,
-0.1746870875,
0.3276732862,
-0.0463185348,
0.1938170791,
0.5852218866,
0.1618209481,
0.8506649733,
0.1638588756,
0.3318826854,
-0.1986648589,
-0.6644368768,
-0.3988900781,
-0.0512232855,
0.6969204545,
0.5712137818,
0.5858870149,
-0.6002381444,
-0.1483630687,
0.3575980663,
0.5528820753,
-0.4914307594,
-0.040655531,
0.4123506248,
-0.4561435282,
-0.4120188951,
-0.068295449,
-0.8089329004,
-0.1900661439,
-0.4443553984,
0.4501907229,
-0.5558867455,
0.0430732816,
-0.070139721,
-0.3625309169,
-0.0205321666,
0.2215005457,
-0.8884657621,
0.2597835958,
0.5048356652,
0.5856795311,
-0.1366468966,
-0.6638134718,
-0.5416305065,
-0.4624128938,
-0.6119362712,
0.7438001633,
-0.3468972743,
-0.1722437441,
-0.0653008521,
0.2050238997,
-0.030658057,
-0.4913518131,
0.518691957,
-0.5752663612,
0.39419806,
-0.6212553978,
-0.5603162646,
-0.4900767505,
0.4452959895,
-0.570851326,
1.0323812962,
0.1023198813,
-0.588078022,
0.4930145144,
-0.7466164827,
-0.068134442,
-0.3639889359,
0.008962756,
-0.4922282398,
0.4083571136,
0.1431263536,
0.1077547148,
-0.0688170716,
0.6434434056,
-0.4487090111,
-0.3831121027,
0.7825871706,
-0.9709717035,
1.031791091,
-0.1538910568,
-0.6128618717,
-0.0404752046,
-0.4174648821,
-0.1194401607,
0.2266106755,
0.0085158404,
-0.3880675435,
0.1297796369,
-0.2363983542,
-0.0146147525,
0.0383723825,
-0.5470552444,
-0.0177828688,
-0.6595206857,
-0.0599535815,
0.7373015285,
0.1600997597,
0.2561450005,
-0.362008214,
0.4288389981,
-0.0051424173,
0.446937263,
-0.2261134237,
-0.7033063769,
-0.7308827043,
0.3617635071,
0.3974285722,
0.3370425105,
-0.7249564528,
0.1932322383,
0.0435713939,
-0.2770443857,
-0.5842997432,
0.1397669166,
0.5571959019,
0.5176374316,
0.477727741,
-0.2266256958,
-0.8233035803,
-1.1335693598,
-0.7772889733,
-0.1713661551,
-0.1202793419,
0.1125473753,
0.7322722673,
-0.3015325367,
1.0650157928,
0.0899313092,
0.3815729022,
0.1024609059,
0.3625404239,
0.0699597225,
0.3385293186,
0.8271075487,
-0.835049212,
-0.2274624109,
-0.4577142298,
-0.7649301887,
-0.3374275267,
-0.4769816697,
0.07120388,
0.2652719319,
0.3781500459,
-0.5105541945,
0.7718699574,
0.8811969757,
-0.4605790377,
0.8098558784,
0.0191036947,
0.1775976866,
-0.4310999811,
-0.0306156371,
-0.0100486856,
-0.2790736556,
-0.5448662639,
0.2831459939,
-0.1984269172,
0.252338618,
-0.2292968482,
0.5354573131,
-0.2353529632,
-0.1376729161,
-0.0649197549,
0.3561149836,
0.3766759932,
0.3655428886,
-0.2200310826,
0.7650406361,
0.3226113319,
-0.541387856,
0.4439173639,
0.1430943906,
0.0734289214,
0.3562842309,
-0.8527101874,
0.2459518909,
-0.2959145606,
-0.0518168062,
-1.1896318197,
-0.009265949,
0.1376218647,
-0.6858156323,
-0.085442774,
-0.161102742,
-0.4305183291,
-0.2501289546,
-0.3517907262,
0.0897625163,
0.2618702948,
-0.7595489621,
0.6973273158,
-0.3302889466,
0.1900107265,
-0.5714858174,
-1.1317849159,
0.144514814,
-0.0084483763,
-0.5489593148,
0.2517675757,
-0.3557882905,
-0.5439171791,
0.1873583794,
-0.2169035971,
-0.239835754,
0.3880201578,
0.3545165956,
0.3959754407,
-0.5842715502,
-0.0503063761,
0.0369997844,
-0.0441117398,
0.5155904889,
-0.1742067486,
0.3575551212,
-0.2482674271,
-0.5468167663,
-0.395937115,
0.2821367681,
0.4565078318,
-0.1866221726,
0.7215459347,
0.5259909034,
-0.4322980344,
-0.2084560096,
-0.7148091793,
-0.4318160117,
-0.476929903,
0.2189614624,
-0.1373615563,
-0.4010664523,
0.6498388052,
0.1235278398,
0.2554135621,
0.6135219932,
0.2719569504,
-0.2155967951,
1.02307868,
0.0065549291,
0.4221881032,
0.1153556854,
0.0005516452,
0.3655360043,
-0.574126184,
-0.149298504,
-0.5164554119,
-0.0008220847,
-0.548537612,
-0.0660661161,
-0.0302964374,
0.0785000324,
0.1467172354,
0.3106642365,
-0.3091086447,
0.828341186,
0.529589951,
-0.0923241675,
0.1310535073,
-0.3408442438,
-0.3019016683,
-0.3313015997,
-0.3434802592,
-0.7650423646,
0.7127271295,
0.3024857044,
0.1789674461,
0.1434120834,
0.4308152497,
0.0470191762,
0.5807334185,
-0.6877108216,
0.502756834,
-0.384388268,
-0.7532385588,
-0.3445930779,
-0.1628364325,
-0.7819411755,
0.200544402,
-0.3828029335,
-0.6899667382,
0.2473980933,
0.5209428668,
-0.3816684186,
0.1791958958,
-0.6977719665,
1.0925738811,
-0.2879310548,
-0.5732544065,
0.1162520424,
-0.3837296069,
0.4623529315,
0.030939037,
-0.1098864377,
0.2936947346,
0.4010432065,
0.5905037522,
-0.2632347047,
0.7138977051,
-0.1383210719,
-0.066502966,
0.1544884741,
0.6057295799,
0.3864450753,
0.4128395021,
-0.2930356264,
0.2703563273,
-0.2203010768,
-0.1226357222,
-1.1232764721,
0.5933170915,
-0.3130732775,
-0.5667356849,
-0.3022924066,
-0.3382996321,
-0.3167896867,
0.3451491594,
0.426410228,
0.4785210788,
-0.52390486,
0.0222384762,
0.9900968075,
-0.3922237158,
0.4930151999,
0.6076678038,
-0.5365487933,
0.00965543,
0.5690671206,
-0.0401776545,
0.2533249855,
-0.0411006995,
0.4684761763,
-0.4567433596,
-0.9038758874,
-0.5213497877,
-0.0010223266,
-0.4995686412,
0.160298124,
-0.1190944389,
-0.0549050085,
-0.1634100229,
-0.3978019953,
-0.5418317914,
0.0080780592,
-0.3567086756,
-0.0609552264,
0.1753709465,
0.746481061,
0.0327975303,
0.0149854645,
-0.6331721544,
0.8164722919,
0.6715222001,
0.5452558398,
0.012413945,
-0.3862631619,
0.2803972065,
0.4904683828,
-0.2195682228,
-1.328122735,
0.2424773723,
-0.0508569665,
0.5170728564,
0.4391993284,
-0.1998060048,
0.7414675951,
-0.5250179172,
1.0158269405,
-0.0830694214,
-1.118411541,
0.6891725063,
-0.2731406093,
0.3450396061,
0.8596726656,
0.3387074471,
-0.5185514092,
-0.7783564329,
-0.7209416628,
-0.3455435634,
0.5076996088,
0.3237292171,
0.1152198613,
-0.1281766146,
0.6141268611,
0.4214114547,
-0.0704706162,
-0.7591981888,
-0.374224484,
-0.6596559286,
0.0114225876,
0.1498571932,
-0.2581361234,
-0.0180662908,
-0.0261949822,
0.6802920699,
-0.0057164514,
0.1637318432,
0.6452022195,
-0.096098274,
-0.3429000974,
0.2803906202,
0.8324735165,
0.7651601434,
-0.4137304425,
0.3869397938,
0.4118800759,
-0.290371716,
-0.158884868,
-0.0376172215,
-0.3167194724,
0.7198664546,
0.5452437401,
0.8790487647,
0.1716798246,
-0.3648191392,
0.6801967025,
-0.4071341455,
-0.3332161903,
-0.4036560059,
-0.0280448887,
0.1364126801,
-0.2215042114,
0.1132342741,
0.4649118781,
0.2803889215,
-0.7163743973,
0.3120115995,
0.5188590288,
-0.5209870338,
-0.5878558755,
0.6438396573,
-0.182325542,
-0.4412698746,
0.7487775683,
-0.4197394252,
-0.8008028865,
0.7342548966,
0.4938174784,
1.0198634863,
-0.3788001835,
0.309491694,
0.308409214,
0.7991994619,
0.0333036222,
0.3285089731,
0.365121454,
-0.6789616942,
-0.721493125,
-0.2690250576,
-0.3961134553,
0.3540912569,
-0.7192831635,
-0.046633441,
-0.2032937706,
-0.1183748618,
0.3665117025,
-0.3796809912,
-0.6260495782,
0.404430896,
-0.0746979713,
0.9381159544,
-1.0530503988,
0.4547292292,
0.4254446626,
-0.4742257595,
-0.480763495,
0.1965524554,
-0.0053719948,
-0.8577201366,
0.5776993632,
-0.0844021589,
-0.1846275479,
-0.6006411314,
-0.6915763021,
-0.5351231098,
0.3639402092,
0.7862058282,
-0.5562608242,
0.0067793503,
0.230324775,
0.7648000121,
0.1873047352,
0.3844010532,
0.3947215378,
0.8764070272,
-0.4198079705,
-0.8977668285,
0.2748645246,
-0.0945158675,
0.0617791712,
0.0685377568,
-0.0799237117,
0.6897127628,
-0.1488789916,
-0.1308271289,
0.0168927237,
0.4077829719,
0.1545688808,
0.4214272499,
0.7992486358,
0.523845017,
0.3499151766,
-0.3663128912,
1.3229372501,
0.126926735,
0.356310457,
1.1553730965,
0.1027781218,
0.6186439991,
0.9211698174,
0.0039915848,
0.8180418015,
0.4980227947,
-0.3092536926,
0.4168594778,
0.034581162,
0.204261601,
-0.2620552182,
-0.1947031021,
-0.0416725129,
0.5242815018,
0.0302312858,
-0.5239945054,
-0.3638599217,
-0.2139068991,
-0.0763696954,
0.1727947444,
0.0327296369,
0.6074284911,
-0.02287025,
-1.1303526163,
0.6603419781,
-0.1195082366,
0.3112889826,
-0.4767629802,
-0.358654201,
-0.3934620321,
-0.0912424028,
-0.261806339,
-0.7625755668,
0.8641434312,
0.0429465361,
-0.2202510983,
-0.2971109748,
0.4163076878,
-0.2611138225,
-0.2203268111,
0.2879882753,
0.251550287,
-0.0498080999,
-0.1228483543,
-0.8648717999,
-0.0482536778,
0.0335764289,
-0.3378507495,
-0.0413907245,
0.2947551012,
-0.0495950654,
0.4748954177,
0.6546878219,
-0.0516030081,
0.0788386762,
0.0930377543,
0.4463073313,
-0.4553407431,
-0.1728969365,
-1.235771656,
0.5318868756,
0.0487331226,
-0.5339198112,
1.0517138243,
0.3917801678,
0.618003726,
-0.1834717989,
0.5920869708,
0.458430618,
0.2937606275,
-0.7018623948,
0.5298102498,
-0.5498623252,
0.1194462851,
-0.2444277406,
-0.8314347267,
-0.2452028245,
0.5935332775,
-0.077353999,
-0.0348794423,
1.1448550224,
0.6819765568,
-0.263558805,
0.5902351737,
0.107769236,
0.3991701007,
-0.1973850131,
0.3805896938,
1.072080493,
-0.7135075927,
0.2547119856,
-0.409240067,
0.1866912246,
-0.0741387978,
-1.1975333691,
-0.9465444088,
-0.3568280339,
-0.507450521,
-0.2863839567,
0.2708674669,
0.4672854841,
0.42922315,
-1.1256270409,
0.354362905,
-0.5371460915,
0.2971925437,
-0.3677844405,
-0.2364885956,
0.3148891032,
-0.0125690307,
-0.5865729451,
0.5505610108,
0.1037962809,
0.3106672466,
-0.4635751545,
0.0762462094,
-0.1052609012,
0.26993981,
0.1787100136,
0.0693241283,
-1.058188796,
-0.4262732565,
0.23342067,
0.2388532311,
-0.0809633955,
0.7031000853,
-0.6088753939,
0.5869674683,
0.4707900584,
0.4658985138,
0.0679340884,
-0.1749441475,
0.7954860926,
-0.7740176916,
-0.2107927203,
0.2315674424,
0.4426283538,
0.2859607637,
-0.2205786258,
0.2912939191,
-0.1366251707,
-0.4265404046,
-1.0064771175,
0.0845630765,
-0.8892742991,
-0.3786972463,
0.9386882186,
-0.2922347486,
-0.1823754013,
-0.4287667274,
-0.0664524436,
0.3628707826,
-0.0426798463,
0.946854651,
0.8782007098,
0.0732670948,
0.0491157211,
-0.8241411448,
0.4866851866,
0.876555264,
-0.6909996271,
0.1398367584,
0.2590042055,
0.178465724,
0.3692638874,
0.2477703542,
-0.0614216663,
0.7003630996,
-0.0344536826,
-0.1871007085,
-0.0954387784,
-0.127831459,
-0.5301107168,
-0.1174517423,
0.0968644097,
-0.0758526698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18028v1 | ADAPTERMIX: Exploring the Efficacy of Mixture of Adapters for Low-Resource TTS Adaptation | 2023-05-29T11:39:01 | 2023-05-29T11:39:01 | Ambuj Mehrish, Abhinav Ramesh Kashyap, Li Yingting, Navonil Majumder, Soujanya Poria | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | There are significant challenges for speaker adaptation in text-to-speech for
languages that are not widely spoken or for speakers with accents or dialects
that are not well-represented in the training data. To address this issue, we
propose the use of the "mixture of adapters" method. This approach involves
adding multiple adapters within a backbone-model layer to learn the unique
characteristics of different speakers. Our approach outperforms the baseline,
with a noticeable improvement of 5% observed in speaker preference tests when
using only one minute of data for each new speaker. Moreover, following the
adapter paradigm, we fine-tune only the adapter parameters (11% of the total
model parameters). This is a significant achievement in parameter-efficient
speaker adaptation, and one of the first models of its kind. Overall, our
proposed approach offers a promising solution to the speech synthesis
techniques, particularly for adapting to speakers from diverse backgrounds. | [
-0.5453416705,
-0.3461719751,
0.2732076347,
0.2921837568,
-0.3601251841,
0.1384202093,
-0.2698677182,
-0.2159618586,
0.3061270714,
0.2135356963,
-0.4348978102,
0.0305624194,
-0.5968334079,
0.1904733628,
-0.2596974075,
0.7676225305,
0.422242552,
0.0749654248,
0.3197583258,
-0.3302562833,
-0.7527164817,
-0.0532206297,
-0.5494745374,
-0.3016148806,
0.2662109733,
0.7850216627,
0.459292829,
0.5186220407,
-0.0043935748,
0.2525172532,
-0.2671103477,
0.1316192597,
-0.5176445246,
0.0460335314,
-0.5385180712,
-0.4550868869,
-0.4004178345,
-0.3001670241,
0.8677092195,
0.7783188224,
-0.3108246326,
-0.0237899683,
0.3909720778,
0.5013461113,
-0.6511433721,
-0.3892132342,
-0.98573488,
0.0273764282,
-0.0357365198,
-0.2658920884,
-0.56592381,
-0.0936834067,
0.3037236929,
-0.623491168,
0.1900428385,
0.127972737,
-0.0143380668,
0.0368812419,
-0.3381866515,
0.1560984105,
-1.0382977724,
0.9591875076,
-0.7254613042,
0.5587356687,
-0.1010239795,
0.4829372168,
-0.2363260239,
-0.4517374337,
-0.6574546099,
0.0656797141,
0.2172470838,
0.2243177146,
-0.1837763935,
-0.0625846907,
-0.0499398224,
0.3034938276,
-0.456009984,
0.1809663773,
-0.3348851204,
-0.1472100019,
0.3471593559,
0.0187502988,
0.370343864,
-0.1038814113,
-0.2466267049,
-0.281614989,
-0.3716754913,
-0.0613610968,
0.1271503419,
0.8408542871,
-0.4945043921,
0.4396276176,
0.0052217771,
0.8177585602,
0.3139057159,
-0.5493416786,
0.2010615468,
-0.2691088915,
-0.0406792872,
0.2588974237,
0.5217798352,
0.213382557,
0.1330247819,
-0.2925044894,
-0.1263878793,
-0.1625258923,
0.0169566423,
-0.7895517349,
-0.2291223705,
0.0716759935,
-0.5294207335,
-0.0082521355,
-0.3109199405,
-1.1831760406,
-0.5444488525,
-0.2698279917,
0.7327972054,
-0.5532301068,
-0.4676671326,
0.0496969558,
-0.6199561954,
0.1810429096,
0.2652536631,
-1.3043262959,
0.6618611217,
0.3453873396,
0.9379241467,
-0.4430097938,
-0.2413166463,
-0.8613600135,
0.226987645,
-0.2240618765,
0.7858165503,
-0.5837166309,
-0.8831828833,
-0.3672896326,
-0.1716480106,
-0.3707103729,
-0.7056787014,
0.536328733,
0.1886003762,
0.0867471769,
-0.1918708682,
-0.341887176,
0.2685184479,
-0.1902300119,
-0.3403413892,
0.945679903,
0.4834149182,
-0.5362120271,
0.2252738476,
-0.6203090549,
-0.3833996356,
-0.0615134314,
-0.1670576036,
-0.093387343,
0.4925822616,
0.3039777279,
0.1418972611,
-0.4466025531,
-0.1673939526,
-0.2700981796,
-0.2884598076,
0.3450217843,
-0.3249920011,
0.4448557198,
0.3037665486,
-0.1480963826,
0.0212435853,
-1.0915950537,
-0.2763449848,
0.0404427648,
-0.3284802139,
-0.4518718719,
0.04087184,
0.5535034537,
0.1687158048,
-0.2400129735,
-0.4910134673,
-0.1784767509,
-0.5947813988,
0.5040963292,
0.8079957366,
-0.0414343737,
0.7429254055,
-0.5780048966,
0.4871472418,
0.2828406096,
0.0187210124,
-0.3045831025,
-0.4769181013,
-1.09889853,
-0.2058401108,
0.2870979011,
0.5449435115,
-0.9624536633,
0.4626955688,
-0.4005631208,
-0.795828104,
-0.4581950903,
-0.0162533764,
0.1991057396,
0.7168531418,
0.430642426,
-0.4945796728,
-0.4865234196,
-0.7533305287,
-0.4074419439,
-0.2487317175,
-0.2486721128,
0.3371424377,
0.1610930264,
-0.0629607067,
1.0183275938,
-0.2998491824,
0.168236509,
-0.2492772788,
-0.1861993372,
0.1709680855,
0.7081485987,
1.0656340122,
-0.5902321339,
-0.5165368915,
0.2957127094,
-0.1479973495,
0.0724439621,
0.0793500319,
0.1122402549,
-0.2596637905,
-0.0162281524,
0.1980125457,
0.0045082876,
0.730981648,
-0.250293225,
0.3621401191,
-0.1707004011,
-0.0226720497,
-1.4084515572,
-0.1559906304,
0.2407336384,
-0.2788105607,
-1.1294865608,
-0.4824997187,
-0.2796534002,
-0.5134444833,
-0.6344744563,
0.749342382,
-0.0324694812,
-0.0810282677,
-0.3856328428,
0.2057119161,
-0.1802555174,
0.3483883739,
-0.0961435363,
1.1479070187,
0.6554322243,
-0.6864655614,
0.0939483941,
0.3445781767,
-0.1354563087,
0.7906739116,
-0.5364283919,
0.3630769551,
-0.1629736274,
0.0850285217,
-1.1617493629,
-0.0642289817,
0.2354975939,
-0.2088627815,
0.0527860112,
-0.2590744197,
0.019863395,
0.0406696238,
-0.2357656509,
0.4672956169,
0.589684844,
-0.6693680882,
1.1308925152,
0.5290647149,
-0.6160250902,
-0.0536164828,
-0.7792835832,
0.0957878157,
-0.4655157924,
-0.5173652172,
0.4659109116,
-0.3193033934,
-0.0771789998,
-0.3056046069,
-0.2220924348,
-0.2868447304,
0.1179936379,
-0.1529324949,
0.0341167077,
-0.4407065511,
-0.1460214406,
0.3263734579,
-0.2697557509,
-0.5197210908,
-0.5379536152,
0.3876927197,
0.2534759343,
-0.2737860084,
-0.4399507642,
0.5500995517,
0.5717560649,
0.1038528681,
0.6080574989,
0.712352097,
-0.2211732864,
-0.3194797039,
-0.492913723,
-0.3815247416,
-0.5098884702,
0.5000542402,
-0.4620710015,
-0.8609758615,
0.5681408048,
-0.2608701289,
-0.1379948556,
0.2109095603,
0.3832875192,
0.2355395555,
0.7397093773,
0.725581944,
-0.2263452858,
0.9431809187,
0.2879382074,
0.2359591872,
-0.8341429234,
0.0596983209,
-0.8958231807,
-0.3189681172,
-0.9306736588,
-0.3639524877,
0.601182878,
-0.3175109923,
-0.0049340706,
0.3291145265,
-0.5360859036,
0.3003462255,
0.6191208959,
0.3378600478,
0.0542687029,
0.1262164712,
-0.0054672123,
-0.1278851479,
-0.9295973182,
-0.1285254955,
1.0744357109,
0.2300700545,
0.6417014003,
0.3028500378,
0.5322661996,
0.1897001266,
-0.1152009815,
-0.7820896506,
0.3629393578,
-0.5566133261,
-0.2813041508,
-0.1489043534,
-0.3596233428,
-0.6742526889,
0.4573570788,
-0.46638304,
-1.069254756,
0.8351495266,
0.2503141463,
-0.5468711257,
0.2086643428,
-0.9793788195,
0.5279729366,
0.0189011693,
-0.1689604372,
-0.2542698681,
-0.6202202439,
0.0163273811,
-0.3969063759,
0.4343728423,
-0.0147361383,
0.1629372984,
0.8863690495,
-0.1349804997,
0.6847159863,
-0.2514383495,
0.1615359932,
0.1510050148,
-0.05235314,
0.4412528276,
-0.1309141517,
-0.28137815,
-0.1847397089,
0.1076430753,
-0.5557902455,
-0.5378348231,
0.446053803,
-1.0287972689,
-0.4135389924,
-0.1627734601,
-0.7010810375,
-0.6277172565,
-0.0087726889,
-0.0264590997,
0.5710868835,
-0.3558087051,
0.310572505,
0.6807777882,
-0.3627422452,
0.4495458901,
0.4905433953,
-0.0711335093,
-0.7640352845,
1.1853144169,
-0.0480331853,
0.569783628,
0.256958127,
0.4993846714,
0.002743114,
-0.840257585,
-0.4273740649,
0.2004126161,
-0.5418219566,
0.2433381677,
-0.4689763784,
-0.1945525259,
-0.4598270655,
-0.0509878136,
-0.4906595647,
-0.6856626272,
-0.470749259,
0.2515744567,
0.2569692731,
0.3142032623,
0.0679162517,
0.9874998927,
-0.886205852,
0.4838234782,
0.590395987,
0.1889896989,
-0.1461618543,
-1.0261372328,
-0.3317436576,
0.0215735007,
-0.3335591853,
-0.918369472,
0.2849328518,
0.4681763649,
0.6626808047,
0.3169359565,
-0.0136147812,
0.782715261,
-0.5328791142,
0.8261728883,
0.3271621168,
-1.0949304104,
0.6214222312,
-0.4252794087,
0.1938862652,
0.5200775266,
-0.1878775954,
-0.5448783636,
-0.1422165781,
-0.3163279593,
-0.7603016496,
0.9828130603,
0.3601438403,
0.3532348573,
0.4749989212,
0.300057441,
0.2548755109,
-0.0412202701,
-0.4936117232,
-0.3677597344,
-0.3520408571,
-0.2964653671,
-0.3480892777,
-0.3716149926,
-0.3357662261,
-0.2915330529,
0.7004861832,
-0.3241005838,
0.2912782431,
-0.061784707,
0.0260028448,
-0.0709462836,
0.6843423247,
0.7178424597,
0.6455492973,
-0.2062401921,
0.0889419317,
0.4766527116,
-0.5005479455,
0.3530575335,
0.2916688919,
0.055156175,
0.1469403654,
0.083487846,
1.1087118387,
0.311606735,
-0.4931886196,
0.282266587,
-0.2055666894,
-0.0065982551,
0.0528080165,
0.4552077055,
0.028198719,
0.0802135393,
0.4779032767,
0.535705328,
0.1379631758,
-0.3683627546,
0.1047441065,
0.0653041452,
-0.4301630259,
-0.5292056203,
0.5499866009,
0.6028662324,
-0.5846320391,
-0.0182951391,
0.1551381201,
-0.0074295653,
0.3011939228,
0.9813992381,
0.9067627788,
-0.9036117792,
-0.0227473583,
-0.0197876412,
0.1844093055,
-0.0179787911,
0.3069050014,
-0.0822792798,
-0.9030831456,
-0.1466179937,
-0.5045066476,
-0.6271512508,
-0.1502006501,
-0.5729177594,
0.552488625,
-0.2614530623,
-0.2172547728,
0.1893873364,
-0.5783065557,
-0.3751810491,
0.1988947392,
0.1018584222,
0.9116199613,
-1.2836629152,
0.944394052,
0.6202570796,
0.0926036909,
-0.5269973874,
0.0846101791,
0.0049311952,
-0.6456536651,
0.022568563,
-0.2968268096,
-0.0902757868,
0.2173330337,
0.0917078182,
-0.6900390983,
0.8915702105,
0.7846731544,
-0.7267227769,
0.1990297437,
0.3784875572,
0.2366687506,
-0.3859111369,
0.2856454849,
0.7225024104,
0.3324275613,
0.1905843019,
-1.1873278618,
-0.2371190041,
-0.1935820132,
0.4408338964,
-0.0897804126,
-0.5792693496,
0.8342446089,
0.2442048043,
0.1574391425,
0.0783001259,
0.5359208584,
0.3945639133,
0.2548011243,
0.8813918829,
0.1576075554,
0.6399994493,
0.0171481278,
0.7066874504,
-0.412586391,
0.0756311566,
1.1204478741,
-0.2342703938,
0.705956161,
0.7281205058,
-0.4415943027,
0.2413515896,
0.3668462038,
0.4271079302,
0.7617166638,
-0.1361424327,
-0.4771789312,
-0.2024902105,
-0.362479955,
-0.5009243488,
0.5683614612,
0.4024070799,
-0.2627191246,
-0.1011806056,
0.3321738839,
-0.2413573563,
0.1092327908,
-0.1491593271,
0.942756176,
0.2185246199,
-0.3907015622,
0.498948276,
-0.072851263,
0.595012486,
-0.5124886036,
0.1718438566,
-0.0991250202,
0.2492925376,
-0.0701980218,
-0.4677659273,
0.2124938816,
-0.1247617006,
-0.343136549,
0.0557709672,
0.7673766017,
-0.3232544661,
-0.5570172071,
0.3454789519,
0.6569646597,
-0.2696298063,
0.176767692,
-0.4100836515,
-0.0195934344,
0.098321259,
0.272667259,
0.5212559104,
0.4853227139,
0.2993036211,
0.4775978923,
0.6011455059,
0.2036199719,
0.0701480135,
0.0987381339,
1.1326512098,
-0.4042612016,
-0.7380328178,
-0.7998023033,
0.7423139811,
0.0547896549,
-0.2565538287,
0.5575333238,
0.6374871731,
0.5290541053,
-0.1442158669,
1.1312484741,
0.2569951713,
0.6361405849,
-0.3986058533,
0.3797703981,
-0.4808906019,
0.1878171861,
-0.5645763278,
-1.006284833,
-0.0130706364,
0.3018781841,
0.0558340363,
0.0382756628,
0.5281262398,
0.8063305616,
-0.4479310513,
0.3392421007,
0.3899904788,
0.033016216,
0.3976404965,
0.3470976949,
0.7048290372,
-0.5486438274,
0.5369488001,
-0.2642526031,
-0.4369307756,
-0.3031238914,
-0.7204053402,
-0.7103144526,
-0.5030865669,
-0.2182124704,
-0.342582345,
0.2098389715,
1.0583158731,
0.8876271844,
-1.1043272018,
-0.5731014609,
0.0590393245,
0.0961044356,
-0.2830082476,
-0.1394855082,
-0.0191845577,
-0.1096607372,
-0.8652545214,
0.8025694489,
0.4219658971,
0.2798281312,
0.1260297894,
-0.1331291795,
0.1599781513,
0.264549464,
0.4126678705,
0.1578837931,
-0.5268788338,
-0.4061200321,
-0.1115633547,
0.356675595,
0.3931820691,
0.7820301056,
-0.6023566127,
0.8238646388,
0.4642393291,
0.7961674929,
0.5271753073,
-0.0471826643,
0.705188036,
-0.7950996161,
0.7007372379,
0.0928720683,
0.4899997115,
0.4149169922,
0.0986908078,
0.0364824943,
0.3905035257,
-0.4104743004,
-0.8637791276,
0.1963623911,
-1.4100474119,
-0.035477221,
1.169776082,
0.0890188441,
-0.0372925438,
-0.1804872751,
-0.3788346648,
0.2853245735,
-0.6719921827,
0.6823191643,
0.3110999465,
-0.1138459891,
-0.2313297838,
-0.2769705951,
0.0847316682,
0.3979192972,
-0.7888410687,
-0.2944604754,
0.1018540189,
0.5324671865,
0.2095122337,
0.6277757883,
0.2418234497,
0.0370252281,
0.0666807592,
-0.2096648514,
0.3962696791,
0.0534050465,
-0.5253757238,
0.009899728,
0.3644555807,
-0.520956099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18026v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18026v2 | Semantic Role Labeling Guided Out-of-distribution Detection | 2023-05-29T11:34:14 | 2024-03-18T23:53:50 | Jinan Zou, Maihao Guo, Yu Tian, Yuhao Lin, Haiyao Cao, Lingqiao Liu, Ehsan Abbasnejad, Javen Qinfeng Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Identifying unexpected domain-shifted instances in natural language
processing is crucial in real-world applications. Previous works identify the
out-of-distribution (OOD) instance by leveraging a single global feature
embedding to represent the sentence, which cannot characterize subtle OOD
patterns well. Another major challenge current OOD methods face is learning
effective low-dimensional sentence representations to identify the hard OOD
instances that are semantically similar to the in-distribution (ID) data. In
this paper, we propose a new unsupervised OOD detection method, namely Semantic
Role Labeling Guided Out-of-distribution Detection (SRLOOD), that separates,
extracts, and learns the semantic role labeling (SRL) guided fine-grained local
feature representations from different arguments of a sentence and the global
feature representations of the full sentence using a margin-based contrastive
loss. A novel self-supervised approach is also introduced to enhance such
global-local feature learning by predicting the SRL extracted role. The
resulting model achieves SOTA performance on four OOD benchmarks, indicating
the effectiveness of our approach. The code is publicly accessible via
\url{https://github.com/cytai/SRLOOD}. | [
-0.2601796687,
-0.7143537998,
0.4530595541,
-0.1832058132,
-0.3950919807,
-0.3236193657,
-0.0263461769,
-0.5022899508,
0.1847463846,
1.0200041533,
-0.8075132966,
-0.6916152835,
-0.5039686561,
0.1323227733,
-0.2100753784,
0.9625076056,
0.0908124968,
-0.1742002368,
-0.4475355744,
-0.2184958905,
-0.3923696876,
-0.3198163211,
-0.2837482989,
-0.261125654,
0.0939098895,
0.6888621449,
0.4058454931,
0.6227927208,
0.3488380313,
0.2112267762,
0.1159741506,
0.3083502352,
-0.2396049201,
0.0638599023,
-0.3042691946,
-0.349288106,
-0.2062264532,
-0.1283260882,
0.6394959092,
0.3024703264,
-0.2618169487,
0.153475672,
-0.0343162678,
0.3816508055,
-0.5869334936,
0.3299834728,
-0.7018736005,
0.0837395415,
-0.5466766953,
-0.2335965633,
-0.6711015105,
0.1027488336,
0.0894694328,
-0.6109637618,
0.2912149131,
-0.0014800535,
0.653593123,
0.3071938157,
-0.5271120667,
-0.5277897716,
-0.0517124832,
0.8250911236,
-0.5454486012,
0.2366425842,
0.2917535603,
0.2373311967,
-0.5264917612,
-0.3541421592,
-0.4745801389,
-0.0521850362,
-0.2268784195,
0.2577482462,
0.0071575739,
-0.0896423161,
-0.3370295465,
0.1786457002,
-0.5081779361,
0.3963458836,
-0.2018580735,
-0.1124276444,
0.6688436866,
-0.3166440427,
0.4444990456,
-0.4244692326,
-0.7556973696,
-0.0732194483,
-0.4728920162,
0.0201511029,
0.4636542499,
0.39912799,
-0.0901672766,
0.54297328,
-0.0457906239,
0.4435949922,
-0.1308365315,
-0.0170645956,
0.1370884776,
-0.0837196484,
-0.2721684873,
0.489433378,
0.5758039355,
0.1364204586,
0.0224674027,
0.1539196074,
0.018325774,
-0.0438784249,
0.1875344664,
-0.6297251582,
0.004548871,
-0.2387919873,
-0.5345290899,
-0.3445520401,
0.2376403213,
-0.979980588,
-0.5871487856,
0.2240958214,
0.3505769372,
-0.4793205261,
-0.1762348115,
0.1419097781,
-0.0685474575,
-0.0889493525,
-0.1084796116,
-0.823792398,
0.1055991426,
0.3857691586,
0.6202715039,
-0.3666535318,
-0.1164609492,
-0.8088452816,
0.3019072711,
-0.1627083719,
0.9335770607,
-0.649413228,
-0.1889217645,
-0.024293026,
0.0817452893,
-0.2352240384,
-0.7261795998,
0.40901196,
-0.4584525526,
0.1562215239,
0.2185735106,
-0.5201372504,
0.0036561706,
0.0495952442,
-0.478143841,
1.0752784014,
0.1854553223,
-0.8611917496,
0.5470975041,
-0.7411727309,
-0.2279499024,
0.0686938763,
-0.3059853017,
-0.6326599717,
0.1785676777,
0.317273885,
0.4016781747,
-0.1420348734,
0.0668157563,
-0.284483254,
-0.187901184,
0.0363162905,
-0.1628117114,
0.6523946524,
0.1776535958,
-0.2274366915,
0.2102902085,
-0.8798463345,
-0.0174016096,
0.0181177221,
-0.0099322693,
-0.7656443715,
-0.1603309512,
-0.2290457934,
0.1499111801,
0.0209847689,
-0.5065333843,
0.3304089904,
-0.4040720165,
0.4395248592,
0.6866214871,
0.2499285787,
0.6079919338,
0.4755704105,
0.5981646776,
0.26020962,
0.2767398357,
0.0241732821,
-0.587888658,
-0.2384424955,
-0.8647190928,
0.2534052432,
0.4605332911,
-0.8062820435,
1.0090222359,
0.0974137634,
-0.1245385334,
-0.5427761078,
0.309726119,
0.4497047067,
0.7171443105,
0.7070012689,
-0.3914240897,
-0.3600453734,
-0.8564603925,
-0.2100240737,
-0.0756440088,
0.1633353829,
0.0236567073,
0.5693413615,
-0.7781525254,
1.3256356716,
-0.6386650801,
-1.1845445633,
-0.5611398816,
0.314761281,
-0.1400579065,
0.2345015854,
0.1538957357,
-0.7945751548,
-0.2818688154,
0.1635477841,
-0.7276271582,
-0.419066757,
-0.0482525676,
-0.2628088295,
0.3695181906,
0.7989616394,
-0.6151220798,
0.7657755017,
0.4747408628,
-0.4877713621,
0.2398921102,
-0.7130132318,
-0.3242553174,
-0.9688094258,
-0.1714451313,
-0.126006797,
-0.0666425154,
-0.282674253,
-0.1654362679,
0.2356593609,
0.0939708203,
-0.2607263923,
0.3883116245,
-0.5784805417,
-0.3213281631,
-0.1044251323,
0.425443083,
0.0098764505,
0.2107471675,
0.233609587,
0.5916269422,
0.544375658,
-0.5042282939,
0.042700503,
0.2992579341,
-0.5983316898,
0.3760444522,
-0.1738693416,
-0.2574600875,
-0.5076815486,
0.4403867424,
-1.159155488,
-0.1601557583,
0.3657765388,
-0.1622361541,
0.1086360887,
-0.4556163847,
-0.4593492746,
0.0099437432,
-0.2138893157,
0.4567482173,
0.2735134363,
-0.53042382,
0.3971297443,
0.5906679034,
0.1030691639,
-0.5893937945,
-0.8336511254,
-0.4762946367,
-0.3542876542,
-0.4831756055,
0.5334783196,
0.3230867684,
0.0598438978,
0.1698891073,
-0.2423475087,
-0.1910554618,
-0.0536720864,
0.1427708119,
0.0934894457,
0.0403982252,
0.4312548339,
0.2525690496,
-0.362010181,
-0.1608377695,
-0.1577282101,
0.393819958,
0.1831398755,
-0.2583917677,
-0.3090623915,
0.4934748709,
0.1796667427,
-0.2679947019,
0.5023571253,
0.7625065446,
-0.082238853,
-0.5677430034,
-0.0475514196,
-0.1537533402,
-0.4418167472,
0.427685827,
-0.1463294327,
-0.5150901079,
0.3745483458,
-0.0635903031,
-0.4990032315,
0.2938709259,
0.0058304733,
0.0775327832,
0.8090733886,
0.807997942,
0.1049549952,
0.5619112849,
-0.5638505816,
0.4551097155,
-0.6691935062,
-0.1380802691,
-0.1118059829,
0.0583468303,
-0.5128860474,
-0.5495564342,
0.4943739474,
0.4391997159,
0.3554671407,
0.2553860545,
-0.5721569061,
0.2761956453,
0.4276379049,
0.0177889634,
0.3461572528,
0.063247636,
-0.109724842,
-0.0280585345,
-0.4964597225,
-0.3220469952,
0.5730667114,
0.2226311862,
0.7074921727,
0.1864557564,
1.1027402878,
0.7364513278,
0.1786452085,
-0.6570354104,
0.7532265186,
-0.3323591948,
-0.2639753819,
-0.5965803862,
-0.37464872,
-0.967042625,
0.4628314674,
-0.0591343231,
-0.7149006724,
0.3627952635,
0.0730505735,
-0.2925928235,
0.0135950306,
-1.0853363276,
1.3950192928,
-0.0533538796,
0.1018030643,
0.0011997763,
-0.6659637094,
0.1517034918,
0.2463834435,
0.42809847,
-0.2012847215,
0.0408191346,
0.4521812499,
-0.5146183968,
0.85448277,
-0.4535879493,
-0.2947435677,
0.5198430419,
-0.1581491828,
0.5294076204,
0.2915861309,
0.0226782393,
-0.0207312908,
-0.0549791604,
-0.1303192526,
-0.4778764248,
0.7342590094,
-0.5394507051,
-0.3012365997,
-0.4854105115,
-0.3752593994,
-0.1275777817,
0.3803763092,
0.6152995825,
0.4257560372,
-0.0127030285,
0.0986671001,
0.6567198038,
-0.2332088351,
0.4396408498,
0.2668031454,
-0.1482723355,
-0.2643572688,
0.780158639,
0.3112856448,
0.1775124073,
0.4690805078,
0.4056266546,
-0.7324769497,
-0.3558273017,
-0.5558783412,
0.0903854296,
-0.7999386191,
-0.3288956285,
-0.5266880393,
0.1119635776,
-0.6336545348,
-0.0390377715,
-0.2637155354,
0.1414323747,
-0.3463708162,
-0.2061544806,
0.4080970585,
0.4192726016,
0.0707563385,
0.2916199267,
-0.4241772294,
0.3961061537,
0.2837425768,
0.2297259718,
-0.3058928847,
-0.5471609235,
-0.0001814919,
-0.2165584117,
-0.0585254543,
-0.7719253898,
0.5923287868,
0.3255758286,
0.7388389707,
0.5317907929,
0.6022732854,
0.7808463573,
-0.307030499,
0.5557730198,
0.2000865191,
-0.8522954583,
0.7598492503,
0.0265746452,
0.1848743707,
0.4452180266,
0.1434766501,
-0.0875592828,
-0.2742042542,
-0.5121105313,
-1.0544176102,
1.0280462503,
0.0510902181,
-0.1791473776,
-0.3492527306,
0.0825023353,
0.4806390405,
-0.0230746325,
-0.7937594652,
-0.232905373,
-0.0371255539,
-0.4356635213,
-0.002774646,
-0.4056630731,
0.1424286067,
0.255810827,
0.5337019563,
-0.3106708825,
0.0975571796,
0.6100203395,
-0.5192633867,
0.0074050757,
0.5960398316,
0.4848170578,
0.3748348057,
-0.3633131683,
0.3672285378,
-0.0612497367,
-0.4132007062,
-0.1307637691,
0.1466528326,
-0.2375130653,
0.1205755323,
0.2709051669,
0.456659168,
0.2813839018,
-0.9366071224,
0.6763392091,
0.2277717143,
0.0549960844,
-0.3326815069,
-0.0214913767,
-0.3502562046,
0.3058496416,
0.3812030852,
-0.0151985819,
0.5260241628,
-0.997264564,
0.5071810484,
0.327029556,
-0.6537390351,
-0.1165376827,
0.1935700327,
-0.003469306,
-0.0467191748,
0.2242040485,
-0.3360491395,
-0.2586385906,
0.5358586311,
0.7447249293,
0.7132396698,
-0.0986015424,
0.697876215,
-0.3880312443,
-0.0067646238,
-0.179396376,
0.0926272869,
-0.1639862657,
-0.7813494205,
-0.0813031346,
-0.3004621863,
0.0129331946,
-0.0443540215,
-0.8739875555,
0.1956464052,
-0.1476627886,
0.0205107592,
0.064374581,
-0.0696096644,
-0.2383910269,
0.1658707559,
0.0152359419,
0.4603461027,
-0.7927572131,
1.2084743977,
0.7823224664,
-0.3353641927,
-0.1364740729,
0.2486200929,
-0.1651308239,
-0.6543421745,
0.8567348123,
0.5442429185,
-0.5060806274,
0.0527179129,
-0.1452547908,
-0.6705953479,
1.1480112076,
0.4515713751,
-0.0516727529,
0.3747384846,
0.1346039176,
0.4897190332,
-0.6621969342,
0.1998828501,
0.3539783657,
0.2071400434,
-0.0669879317,
-0.5563724041,
-0.0173825175,
0.199906677,
0.2040780932,
0.3137740195,
-0.57673949,
0.6359837651,
-0.1700195372,
-0.346485883,
-0.1105059758,
0.6859325171,
0.4153144956,
0.6120287776,
0.6277420521,
0.3457801044,
0.6496194005,
0.3395729065,
0.8312889338,
0.2369356453,
0.4711560011,
0.9426776171,
-0.4646926522,
0.9128552079,
0.584179461,
0.3771601617,
0.6829499006,
0.2262809128,
0.284135133,
1.0975168943,
0.2464614064,
-0.0749345422,
-0.4629006684,
-0.3089412451,
-0.3099585772,
0.5691392422,
0.2927991152,
-0.3807171583,
-0.5000036359,
0.2967143059,
-0.2371442169,
0.3514722884,
-0.3602458835,
0.4508657455,
-0.1230251417,
-0.4321961105,
0.3185345531,
-0.0547298007,
0.7739868164,
-0.6176911592,
-0.3233692646,
-0.353851378,
0.6892505288,
-0.1287878305,
-0.6885299683,
0.1790934205,
-0.2493903041,
-0.2971255779,
-0.4537523091,
0.80954808,
-0.5012322068,
-0.3212389052,
0.6132232547,
0.0901751965,
0.1375488639,
-0.0087981336,
-0.4611703455,
-0.0293511227,
-0.1533284336,
-0.0326739401,
0.5678178072,
0.7910814881,
-0.5607005358,
0.7698338628,
0.2972155809,
-0.1535807252,
0.1302528232,
0.0985015407,
0.4921692908,
-0.6375252008,
-0.9559558034,
-0.6521931291,
0.3192231357,
-0.359231621,
-0.4924806356,
0.7795381546,
0.4238304794,
1.0108375549,
-0.4227372706,
0.5792465806,
-0.1107938588,
0.4479529858,
-0.6969348788,
0.2755241096,
-0.5467860103,
0.3453092277,
-0.0026002307,
-0.4016780853,
-0.44403404,
0.766317606,
-0.3921059072,
-0.3023368418,
0.6676639318,
0.8241941929,
-0.1487152874,
-0.2875804901,
0.4733219445,
0.0052999528,
0.2364417315,
0.1295096725,
0.6515091062,
-0.4785085917,
0.8257568479,
-0.0289338604,
-0.3235723078,
-0.6555299759,
-0.9070038199,
-0.9352934957,
-0.3966194689,
-0.5253828168,
0.0651690662,
0.0721648186,
0.9358525276,
0.8364497423,
-0.8004996777,
-0.0457371064,
-0.3976551592,
0.3318861127,
-0.7049124241,
-0.3307598829,
0.5473737717,
-0.4164957404,
-0.4094709754,
0.6769317389,
0.4809904099,
-0.411953032,
-0.078998886,
0.163611725,
-0.3365993202,
-0.0307219196,
0.6564195752,
0.1372191012,
-0.7619141936,
-0.4188233614,
-0.2658474445,
-0.0907040909,
-0.2054132968,
0.7748048306,
-0.6420230269,
0.4718794227,
0.5095339417,
0.3567923009,
0.276735425,
0.2246466726,
0.2286166698,
-1.2514364719,
0.3084148467,
-0.047301691,
0.2018347383,
-0.0062471428,
-0.7129408717,
0.4938774109,
0.3317346573,
-0.3374659717,
-0.9906642437,
0.3318357468,
-1.0591472387,
-0.3933461607,
1.115522027,
-0.2170591652,
-0.3008487225,
-0.4817150831,
-0.4000988901,
0.145956248,
-0.6453558803,
0.8097368479,
0.1843750179,
-0.4145026207,
-0.3252918124,
-0.3939937651,
0.6100469828,
0.1865534931,
-0.7463776469,
0.2929741144,
0.4106886983,
0.1926646531,
0.2265159488,
0.6398483515,
-0.0358275436,
-0.1562846899,
-0.2170770466,
0.1996728778,
-0.1353636682,
-0.3455567658,
-0.0790065154,
0.2264446467,
-0.2761842906,
-0.7027150393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18023v1 | Abstractive Summarization as Augmentation for Document-Level Event Detection | 2023-05-29T11:28:26 | 2023-05-29T11:28:26 | Janko Vidaković, Filip Karlo Došilović, Domagoj Pluščec | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based models have consistently produced substantial performance
gains across a variety of NLP tasks, compared to shallow models. However, deep
models are orders of magnitude more computationally expensive than shallow
models, especially on tasks with large sequence lengths, such as document-level
event detection. In this work, we attempt to bridge the performance gap between
shallow and deep models on document-level event detection by using abstractive
text summarization as an augmentation method. We augment the DocEE dataset by
generating abstractive summaries of examples from low-resource classes. For
classification, we use linear SVM with TF-IDF representations and RoBERTa-base.
We use BART for zero-shot abstractive summarization, making our augmentation
setup less resource-intensive compared to supervised fine-tuning. We experiment
with four decoding methods for text generation, namely beam search, top-k
sampling, top-p sampling, and contrastive search. Furthermore, we investigate
the impact of using document titles as additional input for classification. Our
results show that using the document title offers 2.04% and 3.19% absolute
improvement in macro F1-score for linear SVM and RoBERTa, respectively.
Augmentation via summarization further improves the performance of linear SVM
by about 0.5%, varying slightly across decoding methods. Overall, our
augmentation setup yields insufficient improvements for linear SVM compared to
RoBERTa. | [
-0.3289161921,
-0.4635937214,
0.4892985821,
-0.2314134836,
-0.3199375868,
0.148678124,
-0.1977272332,
-0.6509413719,
0.0501342826,
0.1449393183,
-0.2820675671,
-0.7229685783,
-0.7121140957,
0.171207428,
-0.6377648115,
1.1179784536,
0.0786344707,
-0.3910161555,
-0.34588781,
-0.0018199175,
-0.2333150506,
-0.4454841912,
-0.8397416472,
-0.3201808631,
0.1830348074,
0.2663665712,
0.3240838051,
0.4756082296,
0.5961306691,
0.3410152197,
-0.3016288579,
0.3767837584,
-0.2179758847,
0.1344479173,
0.0007200784,
-0.4889960587,
-0.6699741483,
-0.1483616233,
0.5606197119,
0.5752488375,
0.1913736165,
-0.1289994717,
-0.0996855274,
0.5296096206,
-0.7624134421,
0.3263074756,
-0.488381356,
0.2180610895,
-0.0970081612,
-0.4118823111,
-0.3893891871,
0.0337066762,
-0.0182947628,
-0.5177465677,
0.7528322935,
-0.387609601,
0.7640109658,
0.2348820418,
-0.2594568431,
-0.2941538095,
-0.7555297017,
0.5519661903,
-0.9661695957,
0.018750634,
0.2415237427,
-0.0725867823,
0.2156712711,
-0.876609087,
-0.6240113378,
0.0313123651,
-0.3012667894,
0.358225137,
-0.403979063,
0.2790121734,
0.3459581733,
0.5736421943,
-0.5561016798,
0.3538602293,
-0.4125608802,
-0.0044795875,
0.589251101,
0.4960395992,
0.2178894728,
-0.2898571193,
0.264338553,
-0.1092375815,
-0.179704383,
0.035589423,
0.3411098421,
0.1988273412,
-0.2375324816,
0.4633869827,
-0.1446148455,
0.5322631598,
0.2004102468,
-0.3009843826,
0.3085376918,
-0.6800009012,
-0.0908941403,
0.1135292202,
0.5756223798,
0.4843379259,
0.0823993906,
-0.2333793193,
-0.2270320803,
0.1250482798,
0.2290979177,
-1.1917103529,
-0.0628686026,
0.2972604632,
-0.5661417246,
-0.5858736634,
0.0095630819,
-0.4011516571,
-0.2673791349,
-0.306928426,
0.1169216558,
-0.5644821525,
-0.0231883116,
0.1216007695,
-0.6299268007,
0.3657253683,
0.6791695952,
-0.9595731497,
0.3061326444,
0.7754448652,
0.9821970463,
-0.2713916302,
0.1035734117,
-0.5900773406,
0.1042985097,
-0.4389119744,
0.910104394,
-0.5379033089,
-0.688292861,
-0.112791568,
-0.0456707552,
0.0439044908,
-0.3090433478,
0.7621466517,
-0.423537612,
0.3898197412,
0.0838553905,
-0.7007454038,
0.116125688,
0.215841502,
-0.4355616271,
0.9918584824,
-0.0161068998,
-0.9429599047,
0.463329792,
-0.5901089311,
-0.8126721978,
0.0866245702,
-0.335641712,
-0.5286294222,
0.3019921482,
0.5804501176,
0.5029776692,
0.1242554188,
-0.0884675831,
0.2685526311,
-0.4146340787,
-0.0591917783,
-0.4366928041,
0.0255404357,
-0.0891622901,
-0.2307746708,
0.0261223726,
-1.0404976606,
-0.3714354932,
-0.1180570647,
-0.4355178475,
-0.5044034123,
0.0945985988,
0.2613903284,
0.085950233,
0.2158907503,
-0.432826072,
0.1946646571,
-0.8354796171,
-0.0443045907,
0.4930061996,
0.1654578149,
0.8216748238,
-0.2143369615,
0.6238741279,
0.0339310355,
-0.1882373095,
-1.0016077757,
-0.3169573247,
-0.4993444085,
-0.3059023321,
0.374142617,
0.4267719388,
-0.694606781,
0.5257470608,
-0.3290774524,
-0.2776501179,
-0.2907285988,
-0.2785094976,
0.3275699615,
0.719925046,
0.4882231653,
-0.1398190707,
-0.5315061212,
-0.6843762994,
-0.0884606391,
-0.0968015492,
-0.3441978097,
0.1494613588,
0.5628489852,
-0.0282256715,
0.7775015831,
-0.7157215476,
-0.4833549857,
-0.4285445809,
0.6102110744,
0.2686386406,
0.386626184,
0.7656300068,
-0.7223168015,
-0.3579133451,
0.1839394271,
-0.7642924786,
-0.2388185114,
-0.1119887307,
0.6394940019,
0.5945256352,
0.5847483873,
-0.3032398522,
0.6332548857,
0.1389897764,
-0.3242863417,
0.3210689425,
-0.5877190232,
0.2386289537,
-1.1785992384,
-0.0063011893,
-0.0325999446,
-0.2785002291,
-0.678262651,
0.0254591499,
0.1108631715,
-0.2453276068,
-0.1224136502,
0.2536281049,
-0.4008320868,
-0.1866814643,
-0.822437346,
0.1864062399,
0.2967222333,
0.2704732418,
0.2859844565,
0.7030979991,
0.2984611988,
-0.4944041669,
-0.0028877973,
0.2869089246,
-0.1154582575,
0.4452906549,
-0.7361115217,
-0.252610445,
-0.5364827514,
0.5103619695,
-1.0113350153,
-0.2070815116,
-0.1692836136,
-0.6425526142,
0.6659419537,
-0.1584477723,
-0.4142294526,
-0.0312812179,
-0.655867815,
0.2512856424,
0.5092472434,
-0.4665091336,
0.936283648,
0.1523481011,
-0.3199004829,
-0.5790677667,
-0.7521620393,
0.1975527853,
0.0765663981,
-0.7234375477,
0.622497201,
0.3987047374,
-0.0544541068,
0.139448002,
-0.4130412936,
0.2129336745,
0.0213941112,
0.2221659273,
0.1573155075,
-0.1708837748,
0.0531039163,
0.3796941936,
-0.4164091647,
-0.0098294737,
-0.310003221,
0.3390179574,
-0.0473668687,
-0.1715786904,
-0.3937918246,
0.5020045042,
0.4390506744,
-0.3916479945,
0.6604251266,
0.8878909945,
-0.3880070746,
0.0020253304,
-0.4193308651,
-0.2784295976,
-0.3804478347,
0.3277924657,
-0.2972653806,
-0.7186333537,
0.5943364501,
0.0969446823,
0.1028464139,
0.6565246582,
0.2420880646,
-0.2906448245,
0.9371579289,
0.4946394265,
-0.133789897,
0.6149912477,
-0.6264330149,
0.1464519203,
-0.818936944,
-0.1191123128,
-0.680739522,
-0.247553423,
-0.5100792646,
-0.4672819972,
0.5732147098,
-0.0913395509,
0.4368956387,
0.1995474845,
-0.4582850337,
0.5309022069,
0.1973475814,
-0.1088649854,
0.7306648493,
-0.140551433,
0.3748954237,
-0.1846592873,
-0.6148208976,
-0.3721183538,
1.1003805399,
0.1388257742,
0.8050903082,
-0.0402066335,
0.7802960277,
0.5383828878,
0.0136010014,
-0.5943974853,
0.321279943,
-0.4198940694,
-0.1003319845,
-0.3276999593,
-0.3334048986,
-0.8943605423,
0.4944736063,
-0.4274434745,
-0.4654362798,
0.4325182438,
-0.0629736632,
-0.1772160232,
0.1426578909,
-0.4252023995,
0.6460449696,
0.1610763371,
0.0308235176,
-0.4554880559,
-0.4479513466,
0.2843621075,
-0.0466232114,
0.2587193549,
0.1458352357,
-0.2403657436,
0.5787962675,
-0.4365351498,
0.6678194404,
0.0922014564,
-0.1102003679,
-0.0340407863,
-0.2831854522,
1.0241146088,
0.1738019586,
0.0525660254,
-0.1525014639,
-0.3257423341,
-0.1546416581,
-0.6292794347,
0.633605361,
-0.4996708035,
-0.4357084632,
-0.5221579671,
-0.5336087346,
0.164892301,
-0.0234053265,
0.484547466,
0.9300159216,
-0.1677382886,
0.3008809388,
0.8704171181,
-0.2136043906,
0.7757133245,
0.7994648814,
0.0592527837,
-0.1016145796,
0.7485727072,
0.0645397007,
0.0237285364,
0.8447180986,
-0.0699091628,
-0.1411247253,
-0.9976106882,
-0.2717956007,
-0.1781277508,
-0.6272001266,
-0.3421407044,
-1.2301018238,
-0.188522175,
-0.4956857562,
-0.4952792227,
-0.1300425082,
-0.7804973722,
-0.44212538,
-0.3611035645,
0.1904151738,
0.2179449499,
-0.2175970525,
0.3493211865,
-0.7498207688,
0.6942673326,
-0.0080884472,
-0.0576602928,
0.0201219581,
-0.6639505625,
-0.2655335665,
-0.4541963637,
-0.3028576076,
-0.643869102,
0.3314410746,
0.2929293811,
0.351767689,
0.4729505479,
0.2971246839,
0.2724087536,
-0.2786716819,
0.7052158713,
0.0263300613,
-0.8197928667,
0.781738162,
-0.3783299923,
0.5223455429,
0.3797892034,
0.049142506,
-0.3695020974,
-0.9393069148,
-0.79666394,
-1.2444629669,
1.0537344217,
0.4390729964,
0.2354422361,
-0.0704610869,
0.1949140429,
-0.0666089728,
0.1456344426,
-0.5389820933,
-0.3049929738,
-0.047749348,
-0.1127759591,
0.0122123454,
-0.1824491024,
0.2478945404,
-0.1403693855,
0.6456238627,
-0.1750093102,
-0.1674743444,
0.3444002569,
-0.2272162139,
0.0717540607,
0.423746556,
0.7604422569,
0.6632509828,
-0.3986480832,
-0.01612496,
0.3725433946,
-0.3993040621,
-0.1052095965,
0.5386614799,
-0.2646410465,
0.5422124267,
0.9149976969,
0.7499533296,
0.3473997116,
-0.6186845899,
0.747982502,
-0.2087530494,
-0.1965761632,
-0.2629441917,
0.1630681753,
-0.1806630939,
0.1690381169,
0.6307615042,
-0.0625202432,
0.5672979355,
-0.4017474651,
0.0745659322,
0.4035511613,
-0.1173263788,
-0.0989540815,
0.7172097564,
0.4648930728,
-0.0260894261,
0.2382975221,
-0.1848651767,
-0.2781398296,
0.8162651062,
0.341971755,
0.7750154734,
-0.0299267154,
0.1555945128,
0.3002661467,
0.495744139,
0.2615230083,
-0.0159675069,
-0.420473814,
-0.4818600416,
-0.749227047,
-0.6386922598,
-0.4146614671,
0.4059532583,
-0.6107794046,
0.1787717491,
-0.0321493708,
0.0568378083,
0.4678498209,
0.0018466027,
-0.2673802674,
0.1531998962,
0.2384763658,
1.0654374361,
-0.664830327,
0.3114967644,
0.4980530739,
-0.4378127456,
-0.1697329432,
-0.0148926517,
-0.3042789102,
-0.1085475087,
0.3574010134,
0.1517811418,
0.021005882,
-0.1863982528,
0.1374414265,
-0.3390713334,
1.069912672,
0.0129847061,
-0.4158314466,
-0.42863819,
0.1028707623,
0.8176304698,
-0.2465674579,
0.4667967856,
0.5206921697,
0.4279470146,
0.0543122068,
-0.6406041384,
-0.1916428357,
-0.158316806,
0.168005079,
0.5068952441,
-0.0920323059,
0.5862281322,
-0.1685187072,
-0.2815581858,
-0.1835440993,
0.8339547515,
-0.1108539924,
0.7542142868,
0.1604047567,
0.5758119822,
0.5789019465,
-0.1166408658,
1.3327281475,
-0.2162169665,
0.121395357,
1.11452353,
0.0958547518,
0.3755626678,
0.0943692401,
-0.10212183,
0.3575477302,
0.2683469653,
-0.0279765967,
0.457285434,
-0.1254017055,
-0.4590171576,
-0.0437719524,
0.0204081349,
-0.640222013,
0.417540729,
0.4778850079,
-0.5640175343,
-0.658331871,
0.2722143829,
-0.0457766056,
0.2075495124,
-0.6657355428,
1.1252319813,
0.0073168091,
-0.405811131,
0.1617937833,
0.3995099962,
0.8274270296,
-0.5388236046,
0.0258673951,
-0.3449793756,
0.3386895955,
-0.4526517689,
-0.6566783786,
0.4943987429,
0.2039619982,
-0.6895649433,
-0.0420386977,
1.1035174131,
-0.4072759449,
-0.5441134572,
0.0906228498,
0.2958022654,
-0.0065647764,
-0.1644099057,
-0.0849582925,
-0.1377291232,
-0.4204911292,
-0.1516765803,
0.3791761994,
0.3991451263,
-0.1445702165,
0.2211826444,
0.6526939273,
-0.1692529768,
-0.2263627648,
0.3092104197,
0.8541793227,
-0.3877567649,
-0.8527095914,
-0.8473784328,
0.4053382874,
-0.4064241648,
-0.0976437703,
0.5989189148,
0.9180199504,
0.6783693433,
-0.2070644498,
0.9718055725,
0.0397668667,
0.2201604098,
-0.464163661,
0.4207522869,
-0.41008991,
0.3223671317,
-0.3479815423,
-0.4897499382,
-0.1126989573,
0.3262950182,
-0.2594012916,
-0.2929956317,
0.537504673,
0.4195246398,
-0.1274244636,
0.0043721143,
0.3379070759,
-0.0966007859,
0.4008129835,
0.3766267002,
0.6068706512,
-0.6395101547,
0.6794625521,
0.0138934692,
-0.2806474864,
-0.470380336,
-0.884837389,
-1.0430818796,
-0.571118772,
-0.5092645884,
-0.1238656342,
0.1138343588,
0.5186002254,
0.5323691964,
-0.84536165,
0.354894489,
-0.1650307178,
0.2670724094,
-0.0518703274,
-0.3312072456,
0.4810207188,
-0.7777838111,
-0.9881902933,
0.4922189116,
0.3949998915,
0.1427925825,
0.2140572816,
0.1529881358,
0.1635386944,
0.0895624086,
0.7962119579,
0.2361400723,
-0.3031074405,
0.0624208339,
-0.2622689605,
-0.0886567831,
0.0340922922,
0.8842350245,
-0.8352200389,
0.1657287776,
0.6825831532,
0.7540148497,
1.1916360855,
0.075630866,
0.5790629983,
-1.1971783638,
0.282564193,
0.1852558255,
0.3350662589,
0.2536535263,
-0.5508707166,
0.5663675666,
0.132981658,
-0.2903875113,
-0.8272953033,
0.0489614122,
-0.9831677079,
-0.3536156416,
0.7677431107,
0.1174164787,
0.1520642191,
-0.1213962436,
-0.2261777371,
0.1447620243,
-0.5213590264,
0.6772753596,
0.4720437229,
-0.3202754259,
-0.2604312003,
-0.1466375589,
0.647582829,
-0.093476139,
-0.9822815061,
-0.1493531018,
0.6330373287,
-0.0798112527,
0.4750184119,
0.6534597278,
-0.1223810986,
0.5155641437,
-0.12645109,
0.0468067974,
-0.5465351939,
-0.2003458142,
-0.5157677531,
0.3766149282,
-0.3697167933,
-0.1350482851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18011v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18011v1 | Can We Trust Explainable AI Methods on ASR? An Evaluation on Phoneme Recognition | 2023-05-29T11:04:13 | 2023-05-29T11:04:13 | Xiaoliang Wu, Peter Bell, Ajitha Rajan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Explainable AI (XAI) techniques have been widely used to help explain and
understand the output of deep learning models in fields such as image
classification and Natural Language Processing. Interest in using XAI
techniques to explain deep learning-based automatic speech recognition (ASR) is
emerging. but there is not enough evidence on whether these explanations can be
trusted. To address this, we adapt a state-of-the-art XAI technique from the
image classification domain, Local Interpretable Model-Agnostic Explanations
(LIME), to a model trained for a TIMIT-based phoneme recognition task. This
simple task provides a controlled setting for evaluation while also providing
expert annotated ground truth to assess the quality of explanations. We find a
variant of LIME based on time partitioned audio segments, that we propose in
this paper, produces the most reliable explanations, containing the ground
truth 96% of the time in its top three audio segments. | [
-0.0529945269,
-0.3985872865,
0.4565958679,
0.2907427549,
-0.426218152,
0.2038009018,
-0.0809435099,
-0.5532231927,
-0.0942440554,
0.0621524304,
-0.5096957684,
-0.0868020207,
-0.3450843692,
-0.0998474807,
-0.5585073233,
0.4969228506,
0.06024158,
0.2958764136,
0.1798129082,
-0.4425808489,
-0.822389245,
-0.3676153421,
-1.1164970398,
-0.7867112756,
0.1771027446,
0.5872098804,
0.8883605599,
0.867258966,
0.1084223688,
0.3102289438,
-0.1553715318,
-0.0188810546,
0.1705673337,
-0.1103965119,
-0.2044631541,
-0.6046491265,
-0.3589520156,
0.2973333597,
0.4620105922,
0.4968247712,
-0.1640361696,
0.0283149704,
-0.1256537288,
0.5285117626,
-0.2557941377,
-0.0265631489,
-0.7915259004,
0.1232325509,
-0.1055429801,
-0.4884134531,
-0.3067837059,
-0.331777513,
0.28668648,
-0.5688909292,
0.3045394719,
-0.0424065515,
0.9707590342,
0.4177961051,
-0.2903074026,
-0.5242168903,
-1.0162550211,
0.758402288,
-0.4153569043,
0.5620618463,
0.4833751917,
0.8673593998,
0.1693596542,
-0.5371763706,
-0.8241901994,
-0.3177312016,
0.0301783457,
0.2284011841,
-0.2035952657,
-0.0014884936,
0.1353070885,
0.7000271678,
-0.5611060262,
0.1871503741,
-0.1931744665,
-0.4555619657,
0.5222634673,
-0.1609122604,
0.2309726179,
-0.1683612913,
-0.5529547334,
-0.1150211841,
-0.638543129,
0.4239549935,
0.162834391,
0.1333518326,
-0.2203937173,
0.2947613597,
0.0588510372,
0.4644596279,
0.3168816268,
-0.0587375723,
0.1681447774,
-0.2257101387,
-0.4258484542,
0.4850522876,
0.6119334698,
0.3400988877,
0.3732518852,
-0.3540158272,
-0.0997899026,
0.3472695947,
0.085687831,
-0.7779870629,
-0.1507465839,
0.4652760327,
-0.4803059995,
-0.4813088775,
-0.1797170937,
-0.263450861,
-0.4344846904,
-0.2019593418,
0.5450443625,
-0.6377000213,
-0.2551848292,
-0.087811783,
-0.1094007045,
0.5081062913,
0.498598367,
-0.4463005364,
0.3734805882,
0.4012444913,
0.8971268535,
0.1457460821,
-0.1041763127,
-0.6720579863,
-0.0841053799,
-0.4078107178,
0.6474020481,
-0.3902837336,
-0.400942862,
-0.4461122751,
-0.1345585585,
-0.1360968053,
-0.6277496815,
0.583355844,
-0.4735276401,
0.1881606728,
-0.0868430659,
-0.467214942,
-0.4982829392,
0.0179647524,
-0.6250731945,
0.5678545237,
-0.1374849826,
-0.5904874802,
0.5137879252,
-0.9430709481,
-0.4508879781,
-0.035064064,
-0.3285199702,
-0.2630482316,
0.1297854483,
0.4017751813,
0.2467383444,
-0.1862425506,
0.3250496089,
-0.0497954711,
-0.4521794021,
0.9241667986,
-0.8990465403,
1.3233534098,
0.6545964479,
-0.7518482208,
0.1175024062,
-0.9617296457,
0.2179519236,
0.0341938697,
-0.1065872237,
0.0121869436,
-0.2293636054,
-0.3027369082,
-0.0140025755,
-0.0580732748,
-0.7285263538,
-0.4720023274,
-0.282825619,
0.6546455026,
0.7544367313,
-0.2461030632,
0.3690357208,
-0.3720903695,
0.4284113348,
0.0771078542,
0.0403146483,
-0.4937048554,
-0.3573502302,
-0.5730742216,
-0.2801961601,
0.6220912337,
0.5900240541,
-0.5345173478,
0.3016474545,
-0.4108427465,
-0.4116310775,
-0.6816992164,
-0.1662856787,
0.4235145152,
0.5161150694,
0.1086526737,
-0.410179764,
-0.4025696218,
-0.8621138334,
-0.4267581105,
-0.3632728755,
-0.0873953551,
0.6236746907,
-0.0358138941,
-0.0914362371,
1.1778594255,
-0.0015749834,
-0.1033517867,
-0.0328182578,
0.4281754494,
0.1798446327,
0.4295946956,
0.4609360397,
-0.9052189589,
-0.3350850344,
0.1179905608,
-0.7284619212,
-0.1607075036,
-0.4546756148,
0.3319206238,
-0.0496170558,
0.3258903921,
-0.437468797,
0.6243337393,
0.3366146684,
-0.4213224649,
0.3491421342,
-0.2137950808,
0.3343147039,
-0.7595923543,
0.053739354,
0.0246942006,
-0.8358337879,
-0.6372466683,
0.215529114,
-0.0098029329,
-0.3301431835,
-0.2184208184,
0.4547471404,
-0.4839655459,
-0.1953162551,
-0.585821569,
0.0015697199,
0.114709273,
0.1351543814,
0.0449516252,
0.8343893886,
0.8614923954,
-0.4288766086,
0.1265513599,
0.1985844523,
-0.3272179961,
0.3143214881,
-0.8142488003,
0.618761301,
0.114659518,
0.2517690063,
-0.9674531221,
-0.120898433,
0.2694170773,
-0.9810460806,
0.1909019798,
-0.3648652434,
-0.2316105217,
-0.0417631939,
-0.0788793638,
0.3217083514,
0.6068913341,
-1.0355604887,
0.8184099793,
0.1400238425,
-0.0199877732,
-0.5960745811,
-0.6450981498,
0.0401253738,
-0.4060219228,
-0.6720781922,
0.2962783575,
-0.1940416545,
-0.5187069178,
-0.251079917,
-0.7021855712,
-0.6508737206,
0.4163631201,
0.7089910507,
-0.0075655947,
-0.3618688881,
-0.1852458864,
-0.0852508545,
-0.2758053243,
0.2180683017,
-0.1173171476,
0.2355613112,
-0.1841093898,
-0.1933834702,
-0.8947919607,
0.1371461153,
0.68759197,
-0.2369565666,
0.1261779368,
0.7598477006,
-0.4210370779,
0.0194580182,
-0.5191193819,
-0.0627203882,
-0.5111742616,
-0.1552389711,
-0.4893606603,
-0.7653809786,
0.5726310015,
-0.0398255065,
-0.0491592437,
0.1627432257,
0.1238338426,
-0.1539029777,
0.9279248118,
0.5261232853,
-0.2684655786,
0.3958231509,
-0.2208027095,
0.0175611638,
-0.2580882311,
0.0479728542,
-0.4992598891,
-0.1108010486,
-0.4211041331,
-0.4646725059,
0.0542189814,
-0.1181566194,
0.0868572518,
0.0734387264,
-0.2531579435,
0.5012055039,
0.6466032267,
0.2854130566,
0.3186013997,
0.2760272622,
0.2342083305,
0.3075287938,
-0.3826368749,
-0.4250125885,
0.6446475387,
0.6445809603,
0.6186996698,
-0.0387344286,
0.479421407,
0.5521786809,
-0.0240909271,
-0.7273560762,
0.4394515157,
-0.2211815715,
-0.9429222345,
-0.4123137295,
-0.4051923156,
-0.8303527832,
-0.0301268231,
0.0281580407,
-0.7406689525,
0.2869818509,
0.533544302,
-0.7037172318,
0.0680859312,
-0.832033515,
0.5126494169,
-0.3572640121,
0.1151231155,
-0.620229423,
-0.7426233292,
0.0310666673,
-0.0665246174,
0.3266938329,
-0.1130571812,
0.4297204018,
0.9381141663,
-0.5806561708,
0.7380803823,
-0.6044035554,
0.1322264671,
0.5596900582,
-0.0456736833,
0.1226400062,
0.0852073878,
-0.239395231,
0.3386282623,
-0.2348873913,
-0.2712252736,
-0.9197380543,
0.5628050566,
-0.8668641448,
-0.7455061674,
-0.2609451115,
-0.5091916323,
0.0389614776,
0.0648858473,
0.2739088535,
0.8364966512,
0.0988791734,
0.0720811263,
0.6526358724,
-0.0403163061,
0.3091625869,
0.4647886157,
-0.009028242,
-0.3662298918,
1.0541498661,
0.1813961565,
-0.0045788842,
0.2462467402,
0.6184350252,
-0.2012559026,
-0.9452701211,
-0.7267717123,
-0.2015972883,
-0.6847407222,
0.0387177728,
-0.1794264615,
-0.3236561418,
-0.151237905,
-0.0716683418,
-0.2682265341,
-0.792524755,
-0.0651497021,
-0.1338481009,
0.3353582919,
0.6164010167,
-0.0969068483,
0.7824547291,
-0.5434325933,
0.5547114611,
0.4219112396,
0.4386789501,
-0.1578281671,
-0.8876903057,
-0.1427249312,
0.305848062,
0.0098666977,
-0.9570224285,
0.0702373311,
0.3926112354,
0.5184764862,
0.6252211332,
0.0427287221,
0.948047936,
-0.370338589,
0.7386283875,
0.0636277497,
-1.2070714235,
0.6513341665,
-0.1237228066,
0.1489902884,
0.4581212699,
0.2794125378,
-0.0580138117,
-0.1660128385,
-0.7627338767,
-0.6165719628,
0.6076185703,
0.4945919812,
-0.014420297,
0.3956958055,
0.5992152691,
0.5833159685,
-0.0362856723,
-0.7243715525,
-0.5103038549,
-0.5467321873,
-0.0171995778,
0.0252716411,
-0.1532250941,
-0.1122029945,
-0.0137548493,
0.6992743015,
-0.1342700273,
0.5606187582,
0.3792063594,
-0.4248602688,
-0.1814217567,
0.48815611,
0.4346841574,
0.8370267153,
-0.3038978279,
0.2097414434,
0.0729596168,
-0.5489429235,
0.3646343946,
0.4020599723,
0.0158158131,
0.2491537482,
0.346244961,
0.8368369341,
-0.4361856282,
-0.40405038,
0.6069352627,
-0.3965194523,
-0.1357714683,
-0.7729158998,
0.1868871599,
-0.2818864584,
0.3655004203,
0.5530064106,
0.5052751899,
0.3007234633,
-0.6166135073,
0.1143484563,
0.3438602686,
-0.7245326638,
-0.4930128753,
0.7241696715,
0.2174032331,
-0.4940054119,
0.4893547297,
-0.1483478546,
-0.4656333923,
0.50702703,
0.3641791046,
0.9372905493,
-0.4975663722,
0.1730225682,
-0.0938326195,
0.2155229896,
0.2910213768,
0.437324971,
-0.3099958599,
-0.9609423876,
-0.5838541389,
-0.1351232231,
-0.5523713827,
0.3868355453,
-0.8657194376,
-0.0846925974,
-0.6457846165,
-0.0121982191,
0.5611401796,
-0.1616332829,
-0.6114556789,
0.8464912176,
0.2794678807,
1.2546830177,
-1.0963329077,
0.95893085,
0.7572653294,
-0.1515224576,
-1.1627509594,
0.3172985911,
-0.0194921102,
-1.1784011126,
0.5239881873,
0.4048059881,
-0.3908891082,
-0.2500178218,
-0.7156444192,
-0.5496382117,
1.0982558727,
0.4341699779,
-0.345428437,
0.2909746468,
-0.0700313449,
0.3661548197,
-0.2004834116,
0.4910426438,
0.4887248576,
0.4156683385,
0.2037644237,
-1.1452555656,
0.1340602785,
-0.4472095072,
-0.3037952781,
-0.317155391,
-0.4964961708,
0.2864429653,
-0.3592609167,
-0.2317146361,
0.2318506986,
0.8159137368,
0.1974501312,
0.7991236448,
1.2185914516,
0.221809864,
0.9768638611,
0.0262525175,
0.9444919825,
-0.1221426204,
-0.2241949439,
1.1695330143,
-0.1317610145,
0.5605620146,
0.2563540637,
-0.0894882157,
0.6520906091,
0.7620385885,
0.1707264781,
0.5181956887,
0.0898762494,
-0.1900793165,
-0.3203386068,
-0.2449111789,
-0.0395753309,
0.8196381927,
0.2560065985,
-0.5512703657,
0.0396312699,
0.0884200782,
-0.0660375655,
-0.1658387333,
-0.4756805301,
0.7135612965,
0.0746824592,
-0.4318437576,
0.7097531557,
-0.2133578211,
0.2341018468,
-0.3077961802,
-0.0733070225,
-0.0527137145,
0.2628462315,
-0.2976918221,
-0.7359190583,
0.2350255847,
0.1215538979,
-0.3741615117,
-0.2247722298,
0.9502497911,
-0.127449885,
-0.1671852469,
0.0348911062,
0.5104551911,
0.6094526052,
-0.2848634124,
-0.7553623915,
-0.1148882359,
0.3173239827,
0.1630846709,
-0.0663693771,
0.4979611039,
-0.2454052716,
0.9402156472,
0.4278453588,
-0.0111391731,
-0.0261066277,
0.1481504142,
0.6573847532,
-0.6018139124,
-0.8039246798,
-0.8095131516,
0.6075515151,
-0.1760204732,
0.0371735804,
0.6056505442,
0.4866903126,
0.4782977402,
0.1838362366,
1.0414357185,
0.1106052771,
0.6156155467,
-0.4702996612,
0.7347341776,
-0.3527156413,
0.3167006075,
0.0100983437,
-0.5362702012,
-0.1349658817,
0.8411105871,
-0.0287691541,
0.1235783249,
0.657245636,
0.6585568786,
-0.2298077494,
0.5678491592,
0.2967790365,
0.4824299514,
0.1599305272,
-0.1432351768,
0.9595295191,
-0.3349157572,
0.8632702231,
-0.4302844405,
-0.3898679912,
0.1013807505,
-0.8761044741,
-0.851983726,
-0.4336054921,
-0.7060126662,
-0.2920704186,
0.3722901344,
0.8919678926,
1.0105118752,
-0.9455507994,
-0.1741272509,
-0.0516408309,
0.0235105734,
-0.5034370422,
-0.1992925256,
0.3632728159,
0.1033291817,
-0.3486513495,
0.8953191042,
-0.0830839947,
0.104403168,
0.1312005371,
-0.1197280511,
0.4397278428,
-0.0589540079,
0.2064248174,
0.3352406323,
-0.8648989797,
-0.5821536183,
0.0349748097,
0.46779266,
0.4169058204,
0.9549341798,
-0.9534019828,
0.4725944698,
0.250102818,
0.5302743316,
0.2503462434,
0.1563133597,
0.9168020487,
-0.659384191,
-0.1367013305,
-0.0508917235,
0.5836924911,
0.6245754957,
-0.4568759501,
0.5769229531,
-0.0799707845,
-0.5986450911,
-0.7510772347,
0.0694066137,
-1.1991848946,
-0.0280282684,
0.9569085836,
-0.6861352324,
-0.2657024264,
-0.3020990789,
-0.18028377,
0.4318325222,
-0.4171823859,
0.7240697145,
0.3178064227,
-0.2159715444,
-0.3820391297,
-0.2958808243,
0.2359194458,
0.4322512746,
-0.3858328462,
0.1505037099,
0.1726231873,
0.5526527166,
0.4338606596,
0.5761919618,
-0.0783364102,
0.6760977507,
-0.0307634287,
-0.1225821972,
-0.2517110705,
-0.3543986082,
-0.7577763796,
-0.1058840752,
0.5975485444,
-0.7098731995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18004v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18004v2 | The Effects of Political Martyrdom on Election Results: The Assassination of Abe | 2023-05-29T10:33:08 | 2023-08-28T09:34:39 | Miu Nicole Takagi | cs.CL | cs.CL | In developed nations assassinations are rare and thus the impact of such acts
on the electoral and political landscape is understudied. In this paper, we
focus on Twitter data to examine the effects of Japan's former Primer Minister
Abe's assassination on the Japanese House of Councillors elections in 2022. We
utilize sentiment analysis and emotion detection together with topic modeling
on over 2 million tweets and compare them against tweets during previous
election cycles. Our findings indicate that Twitter sentiments were negatively
impacted by the event in the short term and that social media attention span
has shortened. We also discuss how "necropolitics" affected the outcome of the
elections in favor of the deceased's party meaning that there seems to have
been an effect of Abe's death on the election outcome though the findings
warrant further investigation for conclusive results. | [
-0.457164824,
-0.9063292146,
1.0177209377,
0.0956420526,
-0.4946061373,
0.2970530391,
-0.1721106619,
0.0825810954,
0.5640873909,
0.7885195613,
-0.3943251371,
-0.637870729,
-0.872536242,
-0.0363567136,
-0.1629481763,
0.6232147217,
0.3929885328,
0.1728022397,
0.4293953478,
-0.2007766217,
-0.1614620388,
-0.3061133325,
-0.8981734514,
-0.1117451414,
0.3646440208,
0.3586775362,
0.5417134762,
0.1179129034,
0.499900341,
0.2731826305,
0.1395364553,
-0.338631779,
-0.9836855531,
-0.0496908575,
0.114679493,
-0.3367516398,
-0.4535105526,
0.3160411716,
0.5825093389,
0.3945115805,
0.1402141899,
-0.4002160132,
0.0189157054,
0.6767061353,
-0.6845075488,
-0.005012861,
-0.6963429451,
-0.5252360106,
-0.4379792511,
-0.4808448255,
-0.2833730876,
-0.8701087236,
-0.0704226643,
-0.3945802152,
0.0218013003,
-0.3162874877,
0.5529482961,
0.2890262306,
-0.4354239106,
-0.5872114897,
-0.7411779761,
0.9373429418,
-0.6879082918,
0.0272828322,
0.0992024094,
0.1717980057,
-0.1413654685,
-0.3003104627,
-0.262203902,
0.0814731494,
-0.0483267866,
0.5921626687,
0.1397083402,
0.392680645,
0.1329374313,
0.2267211527,
0.1455754638,
-0.2307697684,
-0.3397299349,
0.0730938911,
0.6261107922,
0.3600780964,
0.685344696,
-0.9080862999,
-0.1677406877,
0.1596395075,
-0.6248794198,
-0.0802865997,
0.5765439868,
0.3078722656,
-0.1529293209,
0.3776273727,
-0.1885697842,
0.265647918,
-0.0914230049,
-0.191437304,
-0.1277188212,
-0.3928354979,
0.1809777617,
0.026461836,
1.0914520025,
0.5131549239,
0.481423825,
0.0245158691,
0.2422987521,
0.5792147517,
-0.0256866999,
-1.1552141905,
-0.005524247,
0.3671236634,
-0.5239672065,
-0.4818543494,
0.3025527894,
-1.1585587263,
-0.4727125168,
0.1906040162,
0.1295633912,
-0.071681954,
-0.2728131413,
-0.248771295,
-0.5390028358,
-0.0171243604,
0.4950535297,
-0.2305783778,
0.2311368734,
0.6801956296,
0.6706457734,
-0.0734181926,
0.2730918229,
-0.2058723122,
-0.0374965332,
-0.6287348866,
0.5563151836,
-0.7521528602,
-0.7193455696,
0.0244160797,
0.0168508608,
0.2049513906,
-0.3036039472,
0.2845044732,
-0.4932079911,
-0.1449089646,
-0.4261218309,
-0.3378163874,
-0.1090848669,
-0.1922741681,
-0.553009212,
0.2954620123,
-0.1866018921,
-0.4727144837,
0.5584088564,
-0.4996718168,
-0.5827436447,
-0.0327357948,
-0.2463922799,
-0.396363765,
0.4036287665,
-0.1274487078,
0.5996884704,
-0.0801774412,
0.2490000129,
-0.6670079827,
-0.2895466089,
-0.0786971152,
-0.1030530706,
0.9122982025,
-0.2705074847,
-0.4145498872,
-0.4354610443,
-0.5123022199,
-0.1054632589,
0.0556139648,
-0.0122956298,
-0.4509343505,
0.3953797817,
0.0997311696,
-0.0760377273,
-0.2411787808,
-0.9628797174,
0.2961952686,
-0.2204792649,
0.3980627358,
0.6288601756,
1.2949430943,
0.7336259484,
-0.1017835662,
0.3604643345,
-0.24367176,
0.4160263836,
0.193816036,
-1.0173171759,
-0.4299920201,
0.3038780391,
-0.1417580247,
0.5081110001,
-0.3312804401,
-0.0396991149,
-0.2712236345,
-0.5972497463,
-0.1353362352,
-0.5059974194,
0.0438162796,
0.1783898026,
-0.2323821187,
-0.2112479359,
-0.6099804044,
-0.5094951987,
-0.3288734257,
-0.5149843693,
0.489064306,
0.3489077985,
0.5921132565,
-0.3739233315,
0.9689034224,
-0.4565765858,
-0.3933917284,
0.1122574285,
0.2560279965,
-0.0253381636,
0.1161657721,
0.5238572359,
-0.9441393614,
-0.257781446,
0.1483454853,
-0.4823177457,
-0.2490557432,
-0.094432883,
0.0573014244,
0.0753465667,
0.3988927305,
-0.2972366512,
0.8941881061,
0.0870962068,
0.2827435732,
0.3333082199,
0.717028439,
0.9447165728,
-1.1196080446,
0.0499782972,
-0.4814999104,
-0.322454989,
-0.713544488,
-0.2780594528,
0.0450093597,
-0.2215288877,
-0.562789917,
0.4701341391,
0.0438015684,
-0.3858551085,
-0.3351209462,
0.4084036946,
-0.1818105131,
-0.0123853022,
0.1488336623,
0.7201129198,
0.0574280657,
-0.3601210415,
0.1044763029,
0.3502997756,
-0.440287143,
0.0938522145,
-0.3107238412,
0.2117173672,
-0.3380219638,
0.0182574317,
-1.5311625004,
-0.5225548744,
0.2859990001,
-0.8438919783,
0.0692608505,
-0.233508274,
0.0107800094,
-0.1666800678,
-0.3558104932,
-0.1473919004,
0.5270155668,
0.0806689784,
0.7591276765,
0.6237437725,
0.055747319,
-0.3493358493,
-0.4674372077,
0.2423112243,
-0.2614206672,
-0.0642114207,
0.0484616421,
0.2246224731,
-0.7392739058,
0.3370007873,
0.1926548779,
0.2932637632,
0.2098763138,
0.5504931808,
-0.0864234492,
0.0072770738,
-0.1110895649,
0.0308195539,
-0.3226332366,
-0.0422347635,
0.3668977022,
0.5856412649,
0.0976142287,
-0.1028095558,
-0.5158191323,
0.5644699931,
0.7770390511,
0.0839436054,
0.6016905904,
0.1087323055,
-0.4600207508,
0.0553008206,
-0.5263630152,
-0.2658624351,
-0.433781296,
0.6688294411,
-0.0103996526,
-0.2955616415,
0.9453579783,
-0.2591804564,
0.2324591279,
0.6974338889,
0.5470077395,
-0.25635162,
1.1242208481,
0.2693881691,
-0.4247048795,
0.5955555439,
-0.6329866052,
0.0730527565,
-0.9041290879,
-0.183148548,
-0.5843636394,
-0.1539852023,
-0.8369290829,
-0.0371945873,
0.2962398529,
-0.1538607925,
-0.1381448656,
-0.0559666269,
-0.5189728737,
0.2979720831,
0.0443623886,
0.1670482606,
-0.0683956742,
-0.3166477084,
0.74048841,
-0.3759174049,
-0.2556877732,
-0.4968136549,
0.7595285177,
-0.4508208334,
0.6489793658,
-0.1422453821,
0.795891881,
0.4418056011,
0.7316094041,
-0.3990419805,
0.5765249729,
-0.1844933629,
-0.7610443234,
-0.4066748917,
-0.2469218075,
-0.7275460958,
-0.192840293,
0.2317102849,
-0.666923821,
0.4283773601,
-0.3657710552,
-0.3117992878,
0.3335435688,
-0.3005320132,
0.5683523417,
-0.442646116,
-0.0256634429,
-0.4440435767,
-0.3797942102,
0.299113065,
0.0405278094,
0.4824801087,
-0.4694902599,
-0.5669859052,
1.1129678488,
-0.4146979153,
0.8766245842,
-0.4419825673,
0.7671780586,
-0.0401689932,
-0.2349233776,
0.5281400084,
0.2901852727,
-0.325206399,
-0.2944346666,
-0.4214943349,
-0.5083859563,
-0.3763733208,
0.888282299,
-1.0199050903,
-0.8092636466,
-0.1948762387,
-0.2472765893,
0.1186898798,
0.0539300181,
0.922234118,
0.6425611377,
-0.7153121233,
0.0048687849,
0.2283241153,
-0.0696814209,
0.8218460679,
0.1227274388,
-0.1920174211,
-1.0054110289,
0.592658639,
0.4285355806,
0.5099375248,
-0.138981536,
0.2047211826,
0.0970678926,
-0.4036580324,
-0.4689351022,
0.3450286686,
-0.7329209447,
-0.1108334586,
-0.6120250225,
0.2542869151,
-0.2253944278,
-0.5651530623,
-0.5530180931,
-0.0249859411,
-0.5700567961,
0.1455324441,
0.5313333273,
1.007645607,
0.1833927482,
0.8656401038,
0.0213052928,
0.3875901997,
-0.0392916575,
0.1712662429,
-0.2018546909,
-0.453405261,
-0.0364453048,
-0.0858368874,
-0.4051214159,
-1.6440814734,
0.116592966,
0.3908043504,
0.0505723804,
1.1229536533,
0.2757773995,
0.8004207611,
-0.1016909257,
0.7490777969,
0.0541597866,
-0.5993875861,
0.8078358769,
-0.6429411173,
0.2619040906,
0.9529352188,
0.2741416991,
-0.4247417748,
-1.0226742029,
-1.0225701332,
-0.5080506802,
0.6634533405,
0.1446514279,
0.4080267549,
-0.266349107,
0.5325739384,
0.0335961096,
0.1760042608,
-0.4153686762,
-0.7340047359,
0.0458998866,
0.3081760108,
-0.0413755588,
-0.3870134354,
0.3352384865,
-0.147056818,
0.7765166163,
0.2571217418,
0.1193939894,
0.2209511399,
0.4011832178,
-0.3696120977,
-0.2357141376,
0.2858865559,
0.9466654062,
-0.4289470315,
-0.3906361461,
0.1126202866,
-0.2743010223,
0.3736683726,
-0.2277610451,
-0.4281817377,
0.4585653245,
0.8303933144,
0.5923519135,
0.5546206832,
-0.1216712594,
0.6311244369,
0.2261614203,
-0.0257382318,
-0.465275526,
-0.2066614628,
0.397118479,
-0.2413019985,
0.8890680075,
0.3834075034,
0.243926838,
-1.1738916636,
0.3100900352,
0.6344820857,
-0.3535243273,
-0.6963410378,
0.6285449862,
0.3299335837,
-0.6528618336,
0.2937407196,
-0.1769077927,
-1.3647087812,
0.9728409648,
0.0936217308,
0.6292221546,
-0.8651960492,
0.3276849687,
0.3469194174,
0.4559229016,
0.3661035597,
0.4753576219,
0.0840921551,
-0.5377280712,
-0.3357578516,
-0.1787335426,
-0.4016683698,
0.1899578273,
-0.4635859132,
0.2524854243,
-0.7578825355,
-0.6151934862,
0.1211731061,
0.4151112437,
-0.1853440404,
0.4416995943,
-0.0664065033,
0.2182157934,
-1.1862910986,
0.2532408535,
0.2516725063,
-0.3251168132,
-0.5646933317,
0.25670892,
-0.1593140066,
-0.5603881478,
0.2060656697,
0.275529474,
0.1393245906,
0.1387814432,
-0.2267583162,
-0.9544304609,
0.484844178,
0.2439403832,
-0.4556265473,
0.1740502268,
0.4330840111,
0.3084129989,
-0.3074879348,
0.2671370208,
0.5502305627,
0.6914761066,
-0.4233805537,
-0.219788596,
-0.1717649698,
0.1899584532,
-0.4248645902,
0.9457291365,
-1.026042223,
0.4423148036,
0.0030164488,
-0.5782620907,
0.0128080463,
0.2173780501,
-0.1106575355,
0.5944045782,
0.3676855862,
0.4762655199,
0.3281428516,
-0.177250132,
1.2923305035,
-0.0827030167,
0.2986866832,
0.2431543916,
-0.0374872237,
0.5378960371,
0.6257859468,
-0.2877450287,
0.43516168,
0.5200625062,
0.5041012168,
0.8275896311,
-0.223451823,
-0.0323333591,
-0.3353395164,
-0.2759461999,
-0.0762792602,
0.1387961954,
0.6319876909,
-0.1149227768,
-0.241592288,
0.4670397043,
0.0442063436,
0.1432406604,
-0.3330857456,
0.7222378254,
0.5576735735,
-0.3985098898,
-0.0396750234,
-0.2948468328,
0.071582675,
-0.2569746375,
-0.0023888254,
-0.013170219,
0.0955358073,
-0.1939433515,
-0.7690728903,
0.5698437095,
-0.2198503315,
-0.0635391697,
0.2395763546,
0.7975485921,
0.1521840394,
-0.5761612058,
0.7919089794,
0.4027812779,
0.0872009099,
-0.2942179739,
-0.4996674359,
0.3550796211,
0.0823481232,
-0.8599974513,
-0.2323562652,
0.173990503,
-0.0771040693,
0.4523011148,
0.4745685756,
0.2713783681,
-0.3098464012,
0.0015652231,
0.7486778498,
-0.361007601,
-0.2405508161,
-1.0497875214,
0.2244385034,
-0.4781188667,
-0.4431635737,
0.6450198889,
0.8530668616,
0.2828472853,
0.2032542527,
0.955596447,
-0.5384614468,
0.612955153,
-0.1717067212,
0.9921998382,
-0.7412107587,
-0.121319145,
-0.4584658146,
-0.5195435882,
-0.0170680545,
0.2137997001,
-1.060300827,
0.1879915893,
0.4014670551,
0.6277457476,
0.0647062436,
-0.128633827,
0.3026547432,
0.2292515188,
-0.1961465478,
0.1819262952,
0.9520827532,
-0.5863496661,
0.4392296374,
-0.687158823,
-0.0740412474,
-0.5900999904,
-0.311212182,
-0.9211149812,
-1.0153515339,
-0.0976185724,
0.0596896075,
0.3672068715,
0.1385090202,
0.5614762902,
-0.6485485435,
0.1161838099,
-0.1241263524,
0.3445357382,
0.4315835834,
-0.2275170088,
0.8963061571,
0.217122376,
-0.7909119129,
-0.116805397,
0.2403197289,
-0.2771713734,
0.3215351403,
0.0536556393,
-0.0005332506,
0.2018163204,
0.3027232289,
-0.165536359,
-1.2445497513,
-0.4004560709,
0.0662766248,
-0.0458094552,
0.2315936238,
0.7184829116,
-0.928491056,
0.0666717961,
0.6658598781,
-0.0655697063,
0.2079835236,
0.6009050608,
0.5067014694,
-0.3370589018,
0.1992636919,
0.5014990568,
0.3098456264,
0.2746987641,
-0.6178889275,
0.3604712784,
0.4363499582,
-0.6652472019,
-0.8401916623,
0.1606587321,
-0.9519104362,
-0.2249798626,
0.9348347187,
0.4918459654,
-0.2840484977,
-0.0998365059,
-0.3568252325,
0.4298227131,
-0.8010944128,
0.581707418,
0.6384789944,
0.0140645262,
-0.1844023168,
-0.8365104795,
0.4815657437,
0.1649924368,
-0.9197112918,
0.0396964401,
0.3607933223,
0.1689770371,
0.1202622876,
0.8706071973,
0.0878379866,
0.7749170065,
-0.2004080862,
-0.0679537952,
0.2052376419,
0.034813717,
0.0471979193,
0.2642991245,
-0.3496293724,
-0.1189803854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17984v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17984v1 | minOffense: Inter-Agreement Hate Terms for Stable Rules, Concepts, Transitivities, and Lattices | 2023-05-29T09:47:36 | 2023-05-29T09:47:36 | Animesh Chaturvedi, Rajesh Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRGXiJGp3Cc&list=PLtvWi5o3JBnF3yxcjGdT4KCDLxRBIpsyR | Hate speech classification has become an important problem due to the spread
of hate speech on social media platforms. For a given set of Hate Terms lists
(HTs-lists) and Hate Speech data (HS-data), it is challenging to understand
which hate term contributes the most for hate speech classification. This paper
contributes two approaches to quantitatively measure and qualitatively
visualise the relationship between co-occurring Hate Terms (HTs). Firstly, we
propose an approach for the classification of hate-speech by producing a Severe
Hate Terms list (Severe HTs-list) from existing HTs-lists. To achieve our goal,
we proposed three metrics (Hatefulness, Relativeness, and Offensiveness) to
measure the severity of HTs. These metrics assist to create an Inter-agreement
HTs-list, which explains the contribution of an individual hate term toward
hate speech classification. Then, we used the Offensiveness metric values of
HTs above a proposed threshold minimum Offense (minOffense) to generate a new
Severe HTs-list. To evaluate our approach, we used three hate speech datasets
and six hate terms lists. Our approach shown an improvement from 0.845 to 0.923
(best) as compared to the baseline. Secondly, we also proposed Stable Hate Rule
(SHR) mining to provide ordered co-occurrence of various HTs with minimum
Stability (minStab). The SHR mining detects frequently co-occurring HTs to form
Stable Hate Rules and Concepts. These rules and concepts are used to visualise
the graphs of Transitivities and Lattices formed by HTs. | [
-0.7649817467,
-0.81172961,
0.0865776613,
0.0606360026,
-0.3165950477,
0.2589944899,
-0.0828153491,
-0.3245108724,
0.6312665939,
0.3353104293,
-0.2823403478,
-0.5813993812,
-0.7008326054,
-0.0785822794,
-0.4029387236,
1.0605329275,
0.2700039148,
-0.1105574891,
-0.1275787055,
-0.7143647075,
-0.2745677233,
-0.7169587612,
-0.7411245108,
-0.0410526358,
0.8641682267,
0.3079334795,
1.1050628424,
0.6066975594,
0.563462019,
0.2411328107,
0.0795539171,
-0.0958040357,
-0.7284064889,
0.0541611351,
-0.264154762,
0.0219029114,
-0.4082003832,
-0.0340615176,
0.1777242422,
0.2256002277,
-0.3238692582,
0.2173361927,
0.1575860381,
0.2225197703,
-0.4327572882,
-0.1189193279,
-0.626047194,
0.0658395812,
-0.5954075456,
-0.129988417,
-0.0747118741,
-0.4171833396,
0.1962460279,
-0.6101289392,
-0.0841502845,
0.3033689559,
0.8367666602,
0.1262422204,
-0.2081374973,
-0.4565158784,
-0.4018897116,
0.725369215,
-0.6045100093,
0.4833491147,
0.345007956,
0.3831145167,
0.0616537295,
-0.453317523,
-0.6072583199,
-0.3119906187,
-0.4009234011,
0.1538867503,
-0.5732866526,
0.0187061485,
0.216021046,
0.2820100188,
-0.4146465659,
0.3651176989,
-0.2085007131,
-0.3142465949,
0.586561799,
0.4430778027,
0.3453049362,
-0.3275127113,
-0.6169719696,
0.1819823086,
-0.5185098648,
-0.2257380784,
0.4598918557,
0.5767598152,
-0.56703794,
0.4653526843,
-0.052308891,
0.2463392615,
0.1095626801,
-0.2547038496,
0.0826363489,
-0.0269319229,
0.0071641831,
-0.0687669814,
0.8971467018,
0.3277953863,
0.1882832795,
-0.2595668733,
0.0158456229,
0.6143478155,
0.1887068152,
-0.7613414526,
-0.2921971679,
-0.0778747201,
-0.363199532,
-0.5433906317,
-0.5106126666,
-1.0238052607,
-0.9093645215,
-0.44735232,
0.49575454,
-0.5020109415,
-0.4781121314,
-0.8100400567,
-0.2832515836,
-0.1374676377,
0.1703404337,
-0.430257082,
0.6789879799,
0.5240060687,
0.9367380142,
-0.2824507952,
-0.0235199891,
-0.4328730702,
-0.0005501899,
-0.2172485888,
0.4109392762,
-0.4904473424,
0.1900146157,
0.1098278463,
-0.6438338757,
0.2493360341,
-0.5040361881,
0.8169095516,
-0.5564417243,
0.1806296557,
-0.0329955555,
-0.6341270804,
-0.0508466028,
0.5346865058,
-0.4457003474,
0.7862017155,
0.2550826669,
-1.1190452576,
0.2568906844,
-0.7127125859,
-0.2217157632,
0.3133316338,
-0.3692705035,
-0.5015081167,
-0.263173461,
-0.4018316269,
0.3950802386,
-0.2679179311,
0.1524132192,
-0.6984658837,
0.0201424286,
0.1709810197,
0.0202763956,
0.6825103164,
0.4922152758,
-0.3299871385,
0.2024025172,
-0.6203722954,
-0.2161823362,
0.0106927278,
0.0079753418,
-0.7793107033,
0.2282868922,
-0.0272921156,
0.3688864112,
-0.0221090838,
-0.5556173325,
-0.2869734168,
-0.2659939826,
0.3042645454,
0.8725141287,
-0.0584676079,
0.1880433261,
-0.4089980721,
0.4664307833,
0.2552180886,
0.3234895468,
0.700274229,
-0.3429913819,
-0.5590958595,
-0.0280038696,
0.011204185,
0.5886795521,
-0.8697993755,
0.0758378431,
-0.316765666,
-0.7068192363,
-0.0969646871,
-0.2042361945,
0.6391779184,
0.5087311268,
0.5666062236,
-0.1210150197,
-0.9435975552,
-1.0110474825,
-0.4705995917,
-0.3545942605,
0.4936312437,
0.033853896,
0.212131232,
-0.1879296005,
0.9597215652,
-0.2741888165,
-0.4052949846,
0.0471869297,
0.3665070832,
0.0044167731,
0.2150104791,
0.8475419879,
-0.9678372145,
-0.7809247375,
-0.0070302733,
-0.3610564172,
-0.0648265406,
0.490608871,
-0.3676702976,
-0.1188281178,
0.2556643486,
-0.0308486074,
0.4474021792,
0.4468109906,
-0.367607981,
0.5686330795,
0.6810416579,
0.2819035649,
-1.1154108047,
-0.4484254718,
0.1741303802,
-0.1400779039,
-0.9754904509,
-0.0424233004,
-0.5470329523,
0.029970035,
-0.5428289175,
0.4373154342,
0.0320598371,
0.1500770152,
0.0647614673,
0.4115965068,
-0.4474453628,
0.5454128981,
-0.1703811288,
0.3794955015,
0.3305841386,
-0.783570528,
0.5173226595,
0.2683446407,
-0.0615539551,
0.8656265736,
-0.1254399866,
-0.0335571133,
0.0295732748,
-0.3939149976,
-0.8380545974,
-0.0415582806,
0.7471928,
-0.5700998306,
-0.0340771675,
-0.3629014492,
-0.2271637917,
-0.2703548074,
-0.3887300491,
0.5274918675,
0.5080715418,
-0.2947695851,
0.6473643184,
0.9251877666,
-0.0890987813,
-0.691069901,
-0.3753180802,
-0.0384859554,
-0.8881745338,
-0.5629768372,
0.4656912684,
-0.185482353,
-0.7409849167,
0.0446283258,
0.1946477741,
-0.3579838872,
-0.1380989701,
0.4651937187,
-0.0982652456,
-0.145155862,
0.0426815562,
-0.0013279491,
0.180106923,
0.0123165678,
0.0823976472,
0.5061267018,
-0.0277703181,
0.397200048,
-0.3013072312,
0.2039940655,
0.6438070536,
0.3683999181,
0.5052562952,
0.7335928082,
-0.4983877838,
-0.0778227225,
-0.3718467653,
0.0859232321,
-0.3919936419,
0.1560117006,
-0.5276117325,
-0.7938986421,
0.6006788015,
0.2289496213,
0.2810259759,
0.5112346411,
0.6397212148,
-0.1860316992,
0.7941114306,
0.4039334059,
-0.0743528381,
0.6103434563,
0.1009305716,
0.0879480168,
-0.4807508588,
0.0755437389,
-0.5396148562,
-0.2551689744,
-0.6298403144,
-0.1755485237,
0.5258567929,
0.0034783201,
-0.447686702,
0.5430114865,
-0.2180139869,
0.2249130905,
0.0371390842,
0.0360346846,
0.0492780581,
0.4711221755,
-0.0722768232,
-0.4936510623,
-0.6579245329,
-0.1723874509,
0.5680505633,
0.357081145,
0.4816274643,
0.51345855,
0.6847852468,
0.8577820063,
0.6076635122,
-0.8850620985,
0.5082137585,
-0.6300165057,
-0.4443619549,
-0.3807134628,
-0.8315021992,
-0.8202313185,
0.3425359726,
-0.2658962905,
-0.5592763424,
0.0839122683,
0.4998622835,
-0.3719414771,
0.3474430442,
-0.2710775733,
0.8187241554,
-0.2440740168,
-0.6265231371,
-0.4851978719,
-0.375369668,
0.4917616546,
0.2294528633,
0.8002226353,
-0.3132739663,
0.0898072496,
1.4670315981,
-0.5782163143,
0.8272263408,
-0.3667962551,
-0.1667508781,
0.4671217501,
0.3619966805,
0.3351042867,
-0.4195282161,
-0.0515275747,
0.2786378264,
0.0603391714,
-0.1978307068,
-0.503005147,
0.47588557,
-0.7790452242,
-0.2148869783,
-0.3752428889,
-0.2740746737,
-0.2333274484,
0.2848194838,
0.2856022716,
0.5443517566,
-0.4046658576,
-0.1744007617,
0.3313852847,
-0.0344695598,
-0.0902983695,
0.360068351,
-0.416124016,
-0.7154482603,
1.042396307,
0.423374176,
0.1963512897,
0.3086700141,
0.5470110774,
-0.3239899278,
-0.6323624253,
-0.1869472265,
0.2105352134,
-0.5529155731,
-0.4225174785,
-0.5099185705,
-0.0259478651,
-0.5618017912,
0.0091810571,
0.0302254837,
-0.3977850974,
0.0672472417,
0.1924374998,
0.6888074279,
0.7162940502,
-0.4017152786,
0.5997943282,
-0.4740775824,
0.6868394613,
0.1166361719,
0.3408007622,
-0.1808322072,
-0.850897789,
-0.4111646116,
0.19977507,
-0.05779377,
-1.2231297493,
0.1928510964,
-0.0361880735,
0.2898823321,
0.5015297532,
0.3307148218,
1.0969686508,
-0.3061160743,
0.6050958037,
0.705253005,
-0.9964378476,
0.2078798413,
-0.3420120478,
-0.5978088379,
0.4123158455,
0.6889228225,
-0.9139583707,
-0.4573880434,
-0.747577548,
-0.6318956017,
0.7090728283,
0.2747714818,
-0.0450799987,
0.0044918228,
0.059987925,
0.044420436,
0.1522040665,
-0.6968914866,
-0.3180410266,
-0.1932679564,
-0.4322614968,
0.2600646019,
-0.2677392066,
-0.4664608538,
-0.2852113545,
0.784502387,
0.1697622091,
0.0520603284,
-0.4307885766,
-0.1643966585,
-0.0307299942,
0.4165598154,
0.3560474515,
0.674798429,
-0.2753394544,
0.3416270018,
0.2136895061,
-0.5123957992,
0.0839324147,
-0.274471432,
-0.1028645411,
0.1250636876,
0.0728108734,
0.62375772,
0.0532226562,
-0.2412490398,
0.6468728781,
-0.0369256288,
-0.0790499225,
-0.5602161884,
-0.129224211,
-0.1599887758,
0.094708629,
-0.2680389285,
0.1571322978,
0.1004660502,
-0.5583949089,
0.4555491805,
0.2978073955,
-0.5004115105,
-0.1864077747,
0.2309903055,
0.1783137619,
-0.1935696155,
0.3234702349,
-0.3340338767,
-0.795404613,
0.3918364644,
0.2448941618,
0.6402546167,
-0.344694674,
0.316426903,
0.581038177,
0.3055140674,
0.4904068708,
0.0118058994,
-0.0284922458,
-0.9219147563,
0.1129924357,
-0.6739256382,
-0.4125366211,
0.1739058793,
-0.7956153154,
0.4102778435,
-0.7133060694,
-0.3290552199,
0.1996954978,
-0.1953324676,
-0.459308058,
0.0916027501,
0.3544073403,
0.4612526894,
-0.9772888422,
0.4088050127,
0.3891771734,
-0.4201934636,
-0.6667200327,
-0.2956629395,
0.0868262947,
-0.7119827867,
0.4730526507,
-0.2743924856,
-0.3943335712,
-0.1400153339,
-0.539888978,
-0.7647556067,
0.5904735327,
0.0021730666,
-0.7416015267,
0.215119496,
0.2370890528,
0.4865625203,
-0.2976119816,
0.0757178068,
0.6515613794,
0.4643369317,
0.0279207304,
-0.6741148233,
0.2239699662,
-0.0512057729,
-0.2516313791,
0.6231513619,
-0.6117696762,
0.8891425729,
0.0851317197,
-0.5681644678,
-0.0776827112,
0.626701057,
0.0639356822,
0.7129169703,
0.8903630972,
0.9309898615,
0.5237279534,
-0.0469588973,
0.5782796144,
0.115004994,
0.298224926,
1.2117828131,
0.0460321344,
0.7076770067,
0.1911344528,
-0.5085613728,
0.6194538474,
0.3788594604,
0.1324112564,
0.3493652046,
0.5079957247,
-0.07210996,
-0.0177135468,
-0.3016809225,
-0.3842422068,
0.1176735982,
0.6482794285,
0.0426781811,
-0.2711309493,
0.2596027255,
0.460424602,
0.1890542209,
-0.4948438406,
0.9275286794,
0.102867566,
-0.1424119622,
0.7163029313,
0.1379061788,
0.9231637716,
-0.5606546402,
-0.0062661371,
-0.0657773614,
0.0229590181,
-0.5664957762,
-0.6396183372,
0.4648854136,
0.212095499,
-0.158007741,
0.1721627563,
0.4725491107,
-0.5524405241,
0.0363989696,
0.5168753266,
0.1670058668,
0.3980118036,
0.083826527,
-0.8624554873,
0.1793896109,
-0.1383517385,
0.3112517297,
0.3038557768,
0.4663062394,
-0.296135813,
0.1420181394,
0.4620216787,
0.1582927257,
0.5638964772,
0.2112201303,
0.7249776125,
-0.5606431961,
-0.6738801599,
-0.8604671359,
0.3201817572,
-0.221031934,
-0.3844500184,
0.8421735764,
0.5757756829,
0.7324268222,
0.2561196089,
0.6920522451,
-0.5837700963,
0.9621182084,
-0.3263478279,
0.4544613063,
-0.5267766714,
-0.0980916843,
-0.556450367,
-0.7288044095,
-0.2979202569,
0.3130742908,
-0.4413246214,
-0.400649339,
0.5392027497,
0.8134976029,
-0.1952069253,
-0.0305942465,
0.3707564473,
0.6581558585,
0.320129782,
0.1668834537,
1.1994180679,
-0.4121075273,
0.7647994757,
-0.6256098747,
-0.259134829,
-0.1652999371,
-0.4218396246,
-0.555216372,
-0.5559347868,
-0.5400951505,
-0.7568297982,
0.0224896651,
0.8869557381,
0.5642542839,
-0.8384253979,
-0.6357626319,
0.2437524498,
0.3311333358,
-0.2974136174,
-0.3434294462,
0.2472526431,
-0.1015617847,
-0.3667986691,
0.0754400194,
0.1780975163,
-0.0259525608,
0.1168686226,
-0.4818915725,
-0.1545929462,
0.1415209919,
1.0314493179,
0.4117807746,
-0.6758310795,
-0.2455866337,
-0.5520832539,
0.0992901996,
0.065528065,
0.9831854105,
-0.4214681983,
0.1023866013,
0.5418348312,
0.3904255629,
0.2114662081,
0.2616634071,
-0.1927653551,
-0.749147296,
0.144133985,
0.5085439682,
0.2557429075,
0.0186288804,
-0.1068643704,
0.4285160899,
0.3723001778,
-0.2556599379,
-0.9129062295,
0.6333832741,
-1.0618940592,
-0.0070403377,
0.8394322395,
0.081129767,
-0.0503257476,
-0.4872869849,
0.0177993271,
0.3761025369,
-0.4928423464,
0.6031375527,
0.4891501963,
-0.4572982192,
-0.0245374236,
-0.0550676137,
0.7721020579,
0.1825143248,
-0.7482801676,
0.1267646998,
0.7990090847,
0.2015324086,
0.6617321968,
0.7455393672,
-0.2234652638,
-0.0473797359,
0.0722020045,
-0.1891615242,
0.1963496208,
-0.4950156212,
0.0686145723,
0.5121523142,
-0.2159295827,
-0.2013863921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17968v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17968v1 | Data Augmentation for Low-Resource Keyphrase Generation | 2023-05-29T09:20:34 | 2023-05-29T09:20:34 | Krishna Garg, Jishnu Ray Chowdhury, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL | Keyphrase generation is the task of summarizing the contents of any given
article into a few salient phrases (or keyphrases). Existing works for the task
mostly rely on large-scale annotated datasets, which are not easy to acquire.
Very few works address the problem of keyphrase generation in low-resource
settings, but they still rely on a lot of additional unlabeled data for
pretraining and on automatic methods for pseudo-annotations. In this paper, we
present data augmentation strategies specifically to address keyphrase
generation in purely resource-constrained domains. We design techniques that
use the full text of the articles to improve both present and absent keyphrase
generation. We test our approach comprehensively on three datasets and show
that the data augmentation strategies consistently improve the state-of-the-art
performance. We release our source code at
https://github.com/kgarg8/kpgen-lowres-data-aug. | [
-0.2802011669,
-0.549900949,
0.4263973534,
0.0278569385,
-0.743819952,
0.1284335107,
-0.3636467457,
-0.3860343695,
0.3044422865,
0.5170328021,
-0.7021179199,
-0.4805420041,
-0.2788023949,
0.5980548263,
-0.198088333,
1.1624135971,
-0.0172806531,
-0.118792817,
-0.1095463261,
-0.1982209533,
-0.3645774722,
-0.5102695227,
-0.1036351174,
-0.1141423881,
0.3625710011,
0.7273826003,
0.6091244817,
0.8692224026,
0.6520266533,
0.1648419797,
-0.2025105357,
0.4415124357,
-0.6044180393,
0.4302070439,
-0.0498734936,
-0.2118891776,
-0.1019295081,
-0.2349972576,
0.436416626,
0.8340628147,
0.3991581202,
0.191474095,
0.0749185979,
0.7742412686,
-0.9639696479,
-0.039483916,
-0.8145744801,
0.1410210282,
-0.6267982721,
-0.1821786016,
0.0402109995,
-0.4725958407,
0.0765832737,
-0.7550077438,
0.3476121724,
0.1862367392,
0.4868448377,
0.0895152688,
-0.1938304901,
-0.3812898993,
-0.4732128382,
0.7619422674,
-0.5961476564,
0.2378801405,
0.5502884984,
-0.254363358,
-0.0661273748,
-0.8363155723,
-0.5938807726,
-0.1330152005,
-0.2635684609,
-0.0285807271,
0.0473435745,
0.1811477989,
0.4425514042,
0.5718600154,
-0.5553440452,
-0.0390714854,
-0.5520220399,
-0.1023260057,
0.7264841795,
-0.0317285508,
0.0424194671,
-0.5214816928,
0.1641259789,
-0.3780569434,
-0.8628650904,
-0.1152204126,
0.3677939177,
0.446924299,
0.0738364086,
0.7836607695,
-0.4854951799,
0.5238313079,
0.0712153092,
-0.0822809041,
0.5449043512,
-0.9186231494,
0.0515887439,
0.3925388157,
0.6348867416,
0.2041977048,
-0.029011216,
-0.3878875971,
-0.2134511322,
-0.0336117446,
0.2490263134,
-0.9616240263,
-0.6024709344,
0.2708508372,
-0.5443367362,
-0.6332838535,
-0.0391971245,
-1.0446426868,
-0.2875846624,
-0.081691213,
0.5172208548,
-0.4905225635,
0.1241298914,
-0.1879842728,
-0.2875811458,
-0.2608956397,
-0.0331197232,
-0.6535081267,
0.0527726896,
0.429776907,
1.1312221289,
-0.2873282731,
-0.0710851401,
-0.595736742,
0.1662036777,
-0.3244093657,
0.63432163,
-0.7566069365,
-0.7508969903,
0.0696515962,
-0.0877686068,
0.0494973697,
-0.3889462352,
1.0497088432,
-0.5807741284,
0.1915524155,
-0.3943302035,
-0.5602466464,
0.1306771934,
-0.0347375087,
-0.7906685472,
0.9679458141,
0.1668302417,
-0.7493211031,
0.3049792945,
-1.1610238552,
-1.0440282822,
0.157003209,
-0.0221241899,
-0.6380614638,
0.4430274963,
0.5107613802,
0.1095145866,
-0.1768648177,
-0.2318016887,
-0.2264223248,
-0.3749555647,
0.4179304242,
-0.3679763377,
0.4967834651,
0.5132693052,
-0.3321503997,
-0.4380917549,
-0.6778547764,
0.393604815,
0.2262126207,
-0.1743903905,
-0.5629843473,
-0.1435144395,
0.2698478997,
-0.0099955313,
0.3770661056,
-0.5482937694,
0.3590328097,
-0.6677789092,
0.404058665,
0.5164130926,
0.6462978721,
0.5515595675,
-0.2309415489,
0.4391809404,
-0.0826980993,
0.1781515777,
-0.3440904915,
-0.224667564,
-0.3614198864,
-0.3075777888,
0.5505874157,
0.2928397954,
-1.1540259123,
0.4012690485,
-0.4542685449,
-0.4095543027,
-0.7349017859,
0.6143847704,
0.4077420831,
0.488684684,
0.5049059987,
-0.0928523764,
-0.572680831,
-0.76673311,
-0.1254141331,
0.0504657142,
-0.0147265317,
0.24038589,
0.5347296596,
0.0989304408,
0.6602118015,
-0.8691917658,
-0.3109590709,
-0.2666836381,
0.2158789337,
0.1994894296,
0.4930650592,
0.3704981804,
-1.1528965235,
-0.4178172946,
-0.2903580964,
-0.5917327404,
-0.3803098798,
-0.091952756,
-0.0922388136,
-0.2500370741,
0.3943323195,
-0.6151435971,
0.0657592267,
0.2348359823,
0.1234284937,
0.3184244931,
-0.2920843363,
0.2509193718,
-1.125921011,
0.3638209999,
-0.1311916262,
0.1853754371,
-0.7785443664,
0.1551635861,
0.1041234657,
-0.5382931828,
-0.3286532462,
0.4355707467,
-0.5435000062,
0.1864675581,
-0.4725277424,
0.1407918781,
0.0697639063,
0.3283931017,
0.0641445518,
1.0138373375,
0.3417720795,
-0.5193017721,
0.2294133455,
0.5043671131,
-0.1476967186,
0.4616405368,
-0.6784012318,
0.0859595686,
-0.099589698,
0.137327224,
-0.804921627,
-0.5197688937,
0.2371594012,
-0.2685560584,
0.0659602284,
-0.2194906473,
-0.6582378149,
-0.3780157566,
-0.8517990112,
0.5362150669,
0.4852842391,
-0.5094551444,
-0.1220479161,
0.4931707978,
-0.4192626774,
-0.2468330264,
-0.4617916346,
0.2826821804,
-0.2377135009,
-0.3953714967,
0.5495551229,
0.005559227,
-0.0131229442,
0.125211522,
-0.0828269497,
-0.2395114452,
0.0487246513,
0.133708328,
0.2167231441,
0.0730284452,
0.2708050013,
0.3247585893,
-0.0183307957,
-0.3928409517,
-0.3718923032,
0.2633983493,
0.3859852552,
-0.4527603686,
-0.294052422,
0.5000278354,
0.5354265571,
-0.5196623802,
0.4142919183,
0.4523677826,
-0.3955990076,
-0.0312680528,
-0.2007984668,
-0.3663346469,
-0.4910202622,
0.2675822675,
-0.0813173801,
-0.6356322169,
0.0770162866,
-0.1620884538,
0.2431197613,
0.3483519554,
0.3229596913,
-0.233917594,
0.9255840778,
0.3485439122,
-0.2295399904,
0.445804894,
-0.2967469692,
0.4308961034,
-0.768358469,
0.0767721832,
-0.5796100497,
-0.6062321067,
-0.8318687081,
-0.2330361009,
0.6861020327,
0.0932557955,
0.2868650258,
0.2852854729,
-0.7885681987,
0.4769325554,
0.7229290605,
0.1881835163,
0.1777974516,
0.309073329,
0.1604767144,
-0.2568849623,
-0.6182242036,
-0.2299537063,
1.5617134571,
-0.2739031017,
0.7239050865,
-0.0848016217,
0.8750821948,
0.623372376,
-0.0529618412,
-0.5083047748,
0.3680533767,
-0.1896895319,
-0.5642912984,
-0.2784891725,
-0.6323007345,
-0.9415320754,
0.1617251337,
-0.5578911901,
-0.3457552493,
0.2731748223,
0.1871156991,
-0.4021908939,
-0.0417773947,
-0.6590225101,
0.8117830157,
-0.3726292551,
-0.2236120999,
-0.0308492649,
-0.5899946094,
0.281607002,
-0.5622336268,
-0.0197482556,
0.2769104838,
-0.1324405968,
0.7742138505,
-0.5468138456,
0.4474448264,
-0.3402536511,
0.2529612184,
0.374137938,
-0.3734007776,
0.9426933527,
0.0206930414,
0.0394449718,
-0.1032544374,
-0.2679665387,
-0.294668138,
-0.4305643439,
0.5878182054,
-0.3132174313,
-0.0103580719,
-0.1633895785,
-0.4889798164,
-0.3528228998,
0.3503776789,
0.635328114,
0.2627450228,
-0.015806824,
0.4278506935,
0.9055199027,
0.0636479557,
0.4034498036,
0.1521984935,
0.3671770692,
-0.62933743,
1.0462759733,
0.2352413684,
0.0128861386,
0.3821486235,
-0.1453947723,
-0.5290453434,
-0.8822746873,
-0.3246370256,
0.0365899242,
-0.4244281054,
-0.4684123099,
-0.6204057932,
-0.177730754,
-0.5455841422,
-0.2295321524,
-0.1835660785,
-0.7923207283,
-0.1767725348,
-0.1869052052,
0.6272980571,
0.1106812581,
-0.2553523779,
0.7248101234,
-0.9686776996,
0.7331418991,
0.1505725086,
-0.0434541851,
-0.2017982155,
-0.3221360445,
-0.6000317931,
0.2269628495,
-0.4399662018,
-0.8928976655,
0.1653458178,
0.4841893315,
0.374330014,
0.2683022916,
0.5191779733,
0.6410917044,
-0.4238770604,
0.7138959765,
0.0171107501,
-0.6149500012,
0.7471755147,
-0.087628454,
0.3333166838,
1.067032814,
0.1689308882,
-0.3688285649,
-0.4603565335,
-0.6824445128,
-1.1133720875,
0.6312739849,
0.8162101507,
0.2475234717,
0.1521185488,
0.5014095306,
0.1334609687,
0.4926273525,
-0.4178304076,
-0.2596508265,
-0.2571747899,
-0.5192953348,
0.0548989475,
-0.1250871867,
-0.1548478603,
0.0964666829,
0.7983381748,
-0.0885425955,
-0.0038289418,
0.1985065192,
-0.4744406641,
-0.165332064,
0.3440672457,
0.4825981855,
0.3000201285,
-0.1863636225,
0.0626962706,
0.1203014776,
-0.8542848825,
0.2276464701,
0.4878132343,
-0.5453967452,
0.3016223013,
0.3986493349,
0.5784432292,
0.200043112,
-0.6948357821,
0.531496346,
0.0738967061,
-0.1709137261,
0.1470169872,
0.0491072536,
-0.3515480757,
0.1434918493,
0.743375361,
-0.207485199,
0.2049268484,
-0.2765480578,
0.3922320008,
0.3935089409,
0.1367747337,
-0.3827808201,
0.6458989382,
0.1791893691,
0.1161754951,
0.4988586605,
-0.416508615,
-0.3965113163,
0.0620575026,
0.3362590671,
0.9241642952,
0.1979189068,
0.2114693224,
0.1560459435,
0.4346490502,
-0.0244119801,
0.3617837727,
-0.5321039557,
-0.3782204092,
-0.4554765821,
-0.5826360583,
-0.4108743966,
0.4339196384,
-0.3695125282,
-0.0819385424,
-0.2161098421,
-0.268147856,
-0.0143400105,
0.3207131326,
-0.4821234345,
0.2051728666,
-0.0165429097,
0.5996578336,
-0.9204133749,
0.4498828351,
0.7965127826,
-0.5307187438,
-0.1024861336,
0.2152842879,
-0.3095265329,
-0.7215759754,
0.4433613718,
-0.15182136,
0.3132880628,
-0.1392423958,
-0.4172855914,
-0.7056629658,
0.9650722742,
0.2143911421,
-0.3638028502,
-0.2316168398,
0.3889534473,
0.4267088175,
-0.059396185,
-0.3712691665,
0.2444249839,
0.6402750611,
-0.1743354648,
-0.569496274,
-0.0702202842,
-0.2075672597,
0.1276803613,
0.2387769818,
-0.2071766257,
0.5247062445,
-0.0150817577,
-0.1044189036,
0.0535090119,
0.6453847289,
0.2428067923,
0.2351065725,
0.4664772451,
0.6598747373,
0.6954671144,
0.0516196638,
0.7581649423,
-0.6936135292,
0.1347833574,
1.0195370913,
-0.1753827482,
0.4853407741,
0.5839945674,
0.0919199511,
-0.1942480654,
0.6143250465,
-0.1222844198,
1.0606257915,
-0.1313337684,
-0.4613935947,
-0.0208736975,
-0.3381390572,
-0.4043883383,
0.4880284071,
0.3055040538,
-0.5360729098,
-0.4503743947,
0.259422183,
0.1016085744,
-0.1270435005,
-0.3278495371,
0.8161802888,
0.0167635102,
-0.4128135443,
0.4012502134,
0.0306634866,
0.5130646229,
-0.6134775877,
-0.0033484215,
-0.270958215,
0.0027025351,
-0.2125100642,
-0.7660287619,
0.0720613524,
0.4637186825,
-0.214445889,
-0.2716353238,
0.9749812484,
-0.3248424232,
-0.6060280204,
-0.3111628294,
0.5849783421,
0.0602976941,
-0.1888041049,
-0.6500190496,
-0.0361100882,
0.0890671015,
-0.1547868997,
0.3690055609,
0.5749301314,
0.1037473008,
0.1382045597,
0.9113526344,
0.4711205363,
-0.1526821852,
-0.1809216589,
0.9744305015,
-0.3759289682,
-0.5175907612,
-0.7713131905,
0.1713723838,
-0.4842673838,
-0.339643389,
0.7775005102,
0.789050281,
0.6926087737,
-0.0894267261,
1.0867904425,
-0.071919024,
0.5209849477,
-0.6306666136,
0.7986909151,
-0.5541641712,
-0.0416917801,
-0.397818327,
-1.0311303139,
-0.1282608062,
0.4535633326,
-0.0990302041,
-0.1718767285,
0.442750901,
0.7558118105,
-0.1938637495,
0.0245694835,
0.0692799687,
-0.1536421329,
0.1630784571,
0.3115510643,
0.3810341954,
-0.4431504309,
0.7984054089,
-0.6370083094,
-0.0208987799,
-0.457816869,
-0.6645635366,
-0.4788394272,
-0.6557455063,
-0.2292935401,
-0.0490473397,
0.2049411088,
0.9064605832,
0.515866518,
-0.6570060849,
0.1924439818,
-0.0872596726,
0.1782302856,
-0.0710709691,
-0.2271707803,
0.6190833449,
-0.5611501336,
-0.4401713312,
0.5853010416,
0.2209477872,
0.0244672671,
0.1193631142,
0.1052342355,
-0.0308808945,
-0.0200163908,
0.4943984747,
0.4651540816,
0.0997320339,
-0.0682305694,
0.1436933577,
0.008126948,
0.1052090973,
0.9528645873,
-0.5385304093,
0.3988876343,
0.4371184409,
0.9087423086,
0.3277528882,
0.1738029271,
0.2642261386,
-1.1356291771,
0.0594281144,
0.3168948293,
0.2368438095,
0.4000999629,
-0.3525030613,
0.5851631761,
0.4858089983,
-0.3667232394,
-1.0657712221,
0.1255621612,
-0.6164592505,
-0.1142957434,
0.797621429,
0.1268305629,
-0.2341544777,
-0.0375464894,
-0.1395360529,
0.2147729993,
-0.4495429397,
0.9319574237,
0.4016577005,
-0.0609151684,
0.1568742692,
-0.4150516987,
0.7339007854,
0.2277383357,
-0.9089414477,
0.3064932227,
0.6238126159,
-0.0560400113,
0.3337347507,
0.6765344143,
-0.1221172586,
0.3534817696,
-0.0901004151,
-0.1973744482,
-0.2308973223,
0.0021816513,
-0.0690877587,
0.3151874542,
-0.1153438464,
-0.4416430891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17951v1 | ContrastNER: Contrastive-based Prompt Tuning for Few-shot NER | 2023-05-29T08:24:42 | 2023-05-29T08:24:42 | Amirhossein Layegh, Amir H. Payberah, Ahmet Soylu, Dumitru Roman, Mihhail Matskin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompt-based language models have produced encouraging results in numerous
applications, including Named Entity Recognition (NER) tasks. NER aims to
identify entities in a sentence and provide their types. However, the strong
performance of most available NER approaches is heavily dependent on the design
of discrete prompts and a verbalizer to map the model-predicted outputs to
entity categories, which are complicated undertakings. To address these
challenges, we present ContrastNER, a prompt-based NER framework that employs
both discrete and continuous tokens in prompts and uses a contrastive learning
approach to learn the continuous prompts and forecast entity types. The
experimental results demonstrate that ContrastNER obtains competitive
performance to the state-of-the-art NER methods in high-resource settings and
outperforms the state-of-the-art models in low-resource circumstances without
requiring extensive manual prompt engineering and verbalizer design. | [
-0.49870345,
-0.5282160044,
0.4939531088,
0.2398709804,
-0.3513692617,
-0.0539517775,
-0.1639539152,
-0.3320767879,
0.0920109823,
0.311965704,
-0.672362566,
-0.1939864308,
-0.4829834104,
0.5831832886,
-0.0635905042,
1.2063832283,
0.1724496782,
0.2564451098,
0.0177940223,
-0.1185512468,
-0.5462085605,
-0.07786531,
-1.4235658646,
-0.5213301182,
0.8743187785,
0.551671505,
0.4372576773,
0.4639032781,
0.7241262794,
0.4335284531,
-0.2527305186,
-0.0989955813,
-0.4472233653,
0.290949434,
-0.2947867215,
-0.3596371412,
0.0302647799,
-0.3729586005,
0.5367969275,
0.5198280811,
-0.1148674563,
-0.0918960944,
0.1662848145,
0.3236647844,
-0.6158979535,
0.0605883151,
-0.6702861786,
-0.1706856191,
-0.2426567078,
-0.0189469792,
-0.4492467642,
-0.2872232795,
0.2003352195,
-0.8387477398,
0.4759433866,
0.3185894191,
0.9918339252,
0.51541394,
-0.2697760165,
-0.2735930979,
-0.5563626289,
0.8441973329,
-0.5516741276,
0.1977041215,
0.1089139581,
0.6871643066,
-0.1103451923,
-0.8608534336,
-0.6753901839,
-0.1541997194,
-0.3228329718,
0.1408490539,
-0.253855288,
0.1775558293,
0.4295699298,
0.1606845409,
-0.5417633057,
0.4848684072,
-0.0601615719,
-0.123874858,
0.0738388896,
0.5074832439,
0.0855602622,
-0.1642780304,
-0.3351076543,
0.0270127542,
-0.4303483665,
0.1345456839,
0.0821293741,
0.6510716081,
-0.3817745447,
0.2913273275,
-0.3801265657,
0.7586013675,
0.6129099131,
-0.0711413771,
0.0215519723,
-0.0583513342,
-0.1250693798,
0.1770249754,
0.701436758,
0.3925537169,
0.0769108459,
-0.0274791699,
-0.5587717295,
0.2972156107,
-0.090802595,
-1.2384394407,
-0.6130980849,
-0.0775679126,
-0.3707288802,
-0.218772009,
-0.285290271,
-1.0552459955,
-0.6254444718,
-0.2895078957,
0.3406533003,
-0.4342216253,
0.055167295,
-0.286551863,
-0.274887681,
0.3777142465,
0.3409288526,
-0.9268702865,
0.6014550924,
0.5422444344,
0.8349331617,
-0.2085971087,
-0.1636408567,
-1.2034316063,
-0.2882466614,
-0.253985256,
1.0954899788,
-0.991304338,
-0.62825495,
-0.1942325532,
-0.2661046088,
0.0280379765,
-0.6733110547,
0.3855277598,
-0.7682311535,
0.2244692445,
-0.3597693741,
-0.5967416167,
0.1296031773,
0.2900128067,
-0.8806868196,
0.8263735175,
0.1273329258,
-0.8905523419,
0.5882968903,
-0.6799640059,
-0.1796990931,
0.5194660425,
-0.433252424,
-0.3580079973,
0.1132785231,
0.2559080422,
0.1727731824,
-0.4042005837,
0.0278006624,
0.0389059819,
-0.5525662899,
0.3190363646,
-0.3297060132,
0.2055422962,
0.2257610261,
-0.2409836054,
0.406632334,
-1.0686184168,
-0.2475051135,
0.0006313932,
-0.3661656082,
-0.2639780939,
-0.1098193377,
0.299654156,
0.3192821741,
-0.0012111026,
-0.4226960838,
-0.0459432937,
-0.6073731184,
0.1501521319,
0.603811264,
0.2617310286,
0.5528634787,
-0.3692704141,
0.7729492188,
0.4007951319,
-0.1586320996,
-0.5352900028,
-0.2748335004,
-1.0134619474,
-0.462082088,
0.5641855597,
0.6713764668,
-1.1244320869,
0.2141064107,
-0.3128498495,
-0.227551952,
-0.6266810894,
-0.0966328904,
0.534445405,
1.0960373878,
0.5343698263,
0.0627387688,
-0.533024013,
-0.8214563131,
-0.1359256208,
-0.0019786106,
-0.1269295663,
0.5550677776,
0.5098462105,
-0.0318349637,
0.9070453644,
-0.5374646187,
-0.1754568517,
-0.2591760457,
0.1985458732,
0.5461445451,
0.5000111461,
0.2976137102,
-0.8884495497,
-0.5907096863,
-0.0946345329,
-0.5217267871,
-0.0877380744,
-0.2513456047,
0.1118157804,
-0.0815467238,
0.6344594359,
-0.3624581993,
-0.0292434879,
0.3719517589,
-0.3552641571,
0.372251153,
0.0850878656,
0.035696093,
-1.0433187485,
-0.0255634356,
0.1728382111,
-0.2253037691,
-0.5394617319,
-0.2166083902,
-0.0977510288,
-0.2632320523,
-0.6027688384,
1.0778864622,
-0.3424863815,
0.3193996847,
-0.3344683945,
0.2674048245,
-0.1223647296,
0.2487874925,
0.075298965,
0.9968365431,
0.6763777137,
-0.9369366169,
0.2359262854,
0.2421567738,
-0.2557115853,
1.1463832855,
-1.0397604704,
0.2195857763,
-0.3829628229,
0.0873103738,
-0.8128287792,
-0.3893102705,
0.3939291835,
-0.2146326452,
0.4685124457,
-0.439268887,
-0.1793500781,
-0.0812817216,
0.008388238,
0.404366374,
0.4663828909,
-0.7518902421,
0.7920627594,
-0.2021062523,
-0.4125210941,
-0.5114027262,
-0.5059255362,
-0.0781288594,
-0.3322597444,
-0.1595785022,
0.5589212179,
-0.1686864793,
-0.2355498374,
0.0457875244,
-0.1327847093,
-0.0739751309,
0.1374442726,
0.2552607656,
0.3759204149,
-0.3943650723,
0.3115544617,
-0.0199198909,
-0.5794132948,
-0.2712433934,
-0.0810485259,
0.469214946,
-0.0651196465,
-0.0695612431,
-0.4289081097,
0.31469208,
-0.0177819729,
-0.1962983012,
0.7476540208,
0.4520578086,
-0.3952208757,
-0.2500486672,
-0.4044747651,
-0.3074578047,
-0.5666087866,
0.1658272296,
-0.9314477444,
-0.9919130802,
0.4811726809,
-0.466003865,
-0.1037547886,
0.3667775691,
0.1981113106,
0.085644722,
0.817786932,
0.6379868984,
0.0260261819,
0.7954779267,
0.1256193966,
-0.0927606523,
-0.6935186982,
-0.1909410357,
-0.734840095,
-0.4295849204,
-0.7833864093,
0.0973940939,
0.2919398546,
0.1570293009,
-0.4816131592,
0.1771977842,
-0.3947693706,
0.955601871,
0.5526996851,
0.0674441904,
-0.0142188203,
-0.3343156576,
-0.4564967453,
-0.2294311076,
-0.5684686303,
-0.5054339767,
0.3328793347,
-0.1369111091,
0.7110157609,
0.0456138477,
1.0306210518,
-0.1048322693,
0.1296084821,
-0.9313623309,
0.5367011428,
-0.1986880153,
-0.298930794,
-0.264783442,
-0.4372479916,
-1.0635802746,
0.3200981617,
-0.2661952674,
-0.6163999438,
0.5067703724,
0.3275598288,
-0.5939064622,
-0.098602064,
-0.5312964916,
0.7784389257,
-0.0183435753,
-0.1622291356,
0.1092886627,
-0.7154833078,
0.0276305489,
-0.0339219682,
-0.0246124286,
-0.092662774,
-0.3152212799,
0.5226268768,
-0.0998619646,
0.8504023552,
-0.2721880078,
0.3554453254,
-0.087868683,
0.1352118254,
0.7790918946,
0.2309779674,
-0.4075207412,
-0.2980199754,
-0.3735456169,
-0.4262459576,
-0.6909577847,
0.7793491483,
-0.5449052453,
-0.4066851139,
-0.3626973033,
-0.0044624447,
-0.0976241902,
0.4885003269,
0.7502838969,
0.5517047644,
-0.5594348311,
-0.1466270536,
0.7405747771,
-0.1463153958,
0.7309665084,
0.5792303681,
-0.0339028537,
-0.6806744933,
0.9516969323,
-0.2451929897,
-0.1269028336,
0.7451921701,
0.149981156,
-0.1348057538,
-0.5119313002,
-0.3381578922,
0.1783680022,
-0.8086985946,
-0.4258073866,
-0.5107457638,
-0.0528375246,
0.0863877609,
-0.4283920228,
-0.0601840839,
-0.1899377704,
-0.7713971138,
-0.0328872912,
0.420786202,
0.5154678226,
0.2286460698,
0.6696155667,
-0.6142024398,
0.576245904,
0.4965013564,
0.4435831904,
-0.3702120483,
-0.4884474277,
0.0619794987,
-0.4784238338,
0.0232574996,
-0.7067001462,
0.2424651533,
0.419415921,
0.4906395078,
0.5091248155,
0.1539275646,
0.5825279951,
-0.7760661244,
0.7787044048,
0.3810127378,
-0.9389877319,
0.8099309802,
-0.1032377779,
0.5636839867,
0.9654282928,
0.4458099306,
-0.7148547173,
0.1240181699,
-0.3445992172,
-0.8025932312,
0.7605381608,
-0.0659747869,
0.239113763,
-0.4587325156,
0.2138171792,
0.212849915,
0.1653932631,
-0.5613897443,
-0.3772856891,
-0.2697246969,
-0.4432042837,
-0.1422226876,
-0.2046086937,
0.1201760098,
0.2664096355,
0.5632598996,
-0.308747828,
-0.0142778326,
0.1036452278,
-0.2843990624,
0.1443279684,
0.7751379609,
0.4706673324,
0.2769728601,
0.1038978994,
0.2170124799,
0.4069978297,
-0.1273142993,
0.1721329242,
0.4133069515,
-0.501090467,
0.1841448247,
0.2671999335,
1.2169449329,
0.6894666553,
-0.4726723433,
0.3921452463,
-0.1270326972,
0.1615945399,
-0.0133319143,
0.2805238068,
-0.1793677956,
0.4055970907,
0.0250738338,
0.2156579047,
0.3987981081,
0.0703010857,
0.0698840246,
0.1351361722,
-0.6469047666,
-0.3856312633,
0.6810487509,
0.4972107708,
-0.5251267552,
0.9210612774,
-0.5346913934,
-0.2584104836,
0.4711402655,
0.7754881978,
0.8899394274,
-0.3400825858,
0.1385344565,
0.4717644751,
-0.1391237676,
-0.0472927392,
0.3993947208,
-0.0111654662,
-0.7602292895,
-0.0330047831,
-0.5527884364,
-0.5888551474,
0.0518074222,
-0.6658818126,
0.5088455677,
-0.6138684154,
-0.3705070615,
0.4904472232,
-0.0834415182,
-0.9153654575,
0.2327299267,
0.0886595547,
0.7980662584,
-0.5537086725,
0.45195207,
0.9020193219,
-0.739195168,
-0.5127776861,
-0.0004031229,
0.192479521,
-0.3123681545,
0.8155910969,
0.2501608133,
-0.3575659096,
0.3526101708,
-0.3579877019,
-0.6369911432,
0.8661417961,
0.4484437704,
-1.0634608269,
-0.2423183471,
-0.4224176109,
0.3656497896,
-0.4117798507,
0.4961111844,
0.412165761,
0.2854551077,
0.2298413068,
-0.7037882805,
0.0648714453,
-0.311886847,
0.4266990721,
0.3412954807,
-0.5543957949,
0.7713301182,
-0.295047462,
-0.3913581967,
0.1819943935,
0.7580718994,
0.4966804385,
0.3017899692,
0.5476403832,
0.2270949185,
0.997091651,
-0.0324740037,
0.9512438774,
-0.2865858376,
-0.0071114069,
1.4713171721,
-0.5745004416,
0.8681045771,
0.4343771338,
0.0032119476,
0.8641923666,
0.4710106254,
-0.3351609409,
0.7688697577,
0.3349108994,
-0.6244255304,
-0.2989183366,
-0.4442229569,
-0.0705651641,
0.2646045089,
0.302272588,
-0.2531892657,
-0.246055752,
0.0915497616,
-0.1036712378,
0.170626834,
-0.3705162704,
1.1630395651,
0.2444608361,
-0.5730091333,
0.2665179074,
-0.0251909923,
1.056588769,
-0.4539875686,
-0.243009001,
-0.2569037378,
0.1377583146,
-0.0355891213,
-0.3758108914,
-0.0454111621,
0.1547421366,
-0.3917477727,
0.1044740453,
0.7865415215,
-0.2611657679,
-0.3949860036,
0.1265865862,
0.3887344003,
-0.0307895988,
0.0488562919,
-0.5815370083,
-0.2399761379,
-0.5560349822,
-0.0272100586,
0.2146494538,
0.5806903839,
0.0698530823,
0.6317926049,
0.320867002,
0.035035044,
-0.1314759105,
0.4307726622,
0.8518441916,
-0.8991090655,
-0.7232640982,
-0.9184392691,
0.5332661867,
-0.1180891544,
-0.5584774017,
0.367100209,
0.6379571557,
0.7411273122,
-0.1145842746,
0.493614912,
0.3556047082,
0.5691885352,
-0.7019474506,
0.3280840218,
-0.0445320494,
0.2327185422,
-0.1708575636,
-0.6234440804,
-0.3567248881,
0.4513247013,
-0.170650214,
0.1669318825,
0.6107740998,
0.8427785635,
-0.0628168285,
-0.2571935654,
0.3734248281,
-0.0589870587,
0.1145420447,
0.3763005733,
1.0267297029,
-0.2222397178,
0.625341177,
-0.1360503286,
-0.0791232213,
-0.2125475705,
-0.9003276825,
-0.9750398993,
-0.3996165395,
-0.5316326618,
-0.0212004855,
0.177886337,
1.2041640282,
0.661852777,
-1.1081326008,
0.1332193911,
-0.2654630244,
0.1986251473,
-0.1683163494,
-0.2187647372,
0.0698714107,
-0.7589018345,
-0.681135416,
0.5601501465,
0.1058993712,
0.2357920408,
0.4210214615,
-0.1495246291,
0.3048706949,
0.216043666,
0.4613244236,
0.2236978412,
-0.8560180068,
-0.0729046836,
0.1207383648,
-0.1285295933,
0.2234353572,
0.839404285,
-1.1893142462,
0.2793894708,
0.4170953333,
0.6006339788,
0.5587493777,
0.0344584882,
0.3000325263,
-1.0409080982,
-0.066999495,
0.3263240159,
0.4115948975,
0.5203501582,
-0.4017212689,
0.2398902178,
-0.0358976759,
-0.4520510733,
-0.5474843383,
0.4912875295,
-0.8579502702,
-0.0858285427,
0.8785281181,
-0.0691811368,
0.1676046401,
-0.145932138,
-0.3443706632,
0.255503118,
-0.8062883019,
0.4665105045,
0.4183573127,
-0.2082811594,
-0.6914098859,
-0.0128957871,
0.6554986835,
0.115822278,
-0.8933689594,
-0.3527138531,
0.675106287,
0.3640922904,
0.0161261316,
0.663382113,
0.2571209073,
0.3290058076,
0.1866443604,
-0.1745397896,
0.0703310519,
-0.3265563548,
-1.0087047815,
0.091263406,
0.3507002294,
-0.253063798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18466v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18466v3 | Test-Time Training on Nearest Neighbors for Large Language Models | 2023-05-29T08:03:28 | 2024-02-02T20:28:27 | Moritz Hardt, Yu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Many recent efforts augment language models with retrieval, by adding
retrieved data to the input context. For this approach to succeed, the
retrieved data must be added at both training and test time. Moreover, as input
length grows linearly with the size of retrieved data, cost in computation and
memory grows quadratically for modern Transformers. To avoid these
complications, we simply fine-tune the model on retrieved data at test time,
using its standard training setup. We build a large-scale distributed index
based on text embeddings of the Pile dataset. For each test input, our system
retrieves its neighbors and fine-tunes the model on their text. Surprisingly,
retrieving and training on as few as 20 neighbors, each for only one gradient
iteration, drastically improves performance across more than 20 language
modeling tasks in the Pile. For example, test-time training with nearest
neighbors significantly narrows the performance gap between a small GPT-2 and a
GPT-Neo model more than 10 times larger. Sufficient index quality and size,
however, are necessary. Our work establishes a first baseline of test-time
training for language modeling. | [
-0.4729177356,
-0.6318419576,
0.4503526986,
-0.0375167504,
-0.0353019834,
-0.0312039573,
-0.3074729145,
-0.481667906,
-0.0378165059,
0.1783991307,
-0.3100390732,
-0.2037416846,
-0.4790099859,
-0.0267162789,
-0.4842525423,
1.0655663013,
0.128236562,
-0.1960735172,
0.0644784495,
-0.2233804464,
0.0744494349,
-0.34324494,
-0.761508882,
-0.1137999073,
0.4159718454,
0.3895714581,
0.8629644513,
0.919557929,
0.536187768,
0.2681616545,
-0.1239487156,
-0.0577129126,
-0.5353940129,
-0.1146093905,
-0.0364718325,
-0.5060792565,
-0.1886283457,
0.0730912089,
1.0791811943,
0.8119885921,
-0.1487544477,
0.2876934111,
-0.1417896003,
0.5775253177,
-0.5046648383,
0.0968298763,
-0.6234083176,
0.1833018512,
-0.3297025561,
-0.1475634724,
-0.2605178356,
-0.6385732293,
0.1491660029,
-0.2720796764,
0.6617866158,
0.1259720474,
1.0942473412,
0.2845031619,
-0.3082407117,
0.1342539042,
-0.8251596689,
0.74844414,
-0.4252735674,
0.5787632465,
0.5297830701,
0.4504333735,
-0.0580670163,
-0.2916576266,
-0.6027314067,
-0.3987771571,
-0.120883584,
-0.1589408219,
-0.047031913,
0.020946119,
0.4936340451,
0.5617743731,
-0.8229157925,
0.2972435057,
-0.3704457879,
-0.0676157698,
0.5434294939,
0.3564747274,
-0.0092570167,
-0.0703158155,
-0.1074073911,
-0.3889963627,
-0.651989162,
-0.0411545262,
0.3746379912,
0.4474711418,
0.0430166349,
0.4707840979,
-0.2747413814,
0.6318998337,
0.0173279364,
0.0920620635,
0.3260781169,
-0.3219699264,
0.0989799574,
-0.1762205511,
0.7691781521,
0.1081718355,
0.4527471662,
-0.2007064968,
-0.3797365725,
-0.0112643195,
0.1300506443,
-1.0684945583,
-0.2869712412,
-0.0262079388,
-0.323730886,
-0.4105215371,
-0.0921951756,
-0.8455104828,
-0.3582416475,
-0.1789612919,
0.3942952454,
-0.323577255,
-0.3582497835,
-0.048811201,
-0.0588312894,
0.2476993501,
-0.1200167164,
-0.9925082326,
0.5283096433,
0.7425611615,
1.1008373499,
-0.1051983684,
-0.4623678625,
-1.05248034,
-0.1908867359,
-0.5406992435,
0.870244503,
-0.6919304729,
-0.1753252,
0.0356828012,
-0.0300426502,
-0.0649132431,
-0.7980594635,
0.0076503176,
-0.5053279996,
0.2977596223,
0.0414484031,
-0.4984496832,
0.381423831,
0.312182188,
-0.6457420588,
1.6315604448,
0.5291951299,
-0.9790697098,
0.2689926922,
-0.5454367995,
-0.5836737752,
-0.0992061123,
0.0562570356,
-0.6156932116,
0.2127870172,
0.2921107113,
0.544041872,
-0.3007194102,
0.0194829311,
-0.4035737514,
-0.6911529899,
-0.2262975425,
-0.1541813612,
0.5535814166,
0.0946496874,
-0.3464620411,
-0.2058459967,
-0.8310364485,
-0.0028332672,
0.2238534093,
-0.3619278669,
-0.4507374763,
-0.0265425928,
-0.0978836417,
0.0894113109,
0.1478681415,
-0.7493812442,
0.2602721155,
-0.628888607,
0.3608742654,
0.8098669052,
-0.2161809653,
0.5071246028,
-0.4334538579,
0.5652660131,
-0.0468609743,
0.1702293158,
-0.0531582609,
-0.1337096542,
-0.7325683832,
0.023765821,
0.4234443903,
0.3477341831,
-0.5028234124,
0.2387715727,
-0.7692486048,
-0.7285921574,
-0.4387738705,
-0.0561424717,
0.0613358393,
0.0933417678,
0.25702703,
-0.2539282739,
-0.4690694809,
-0.8370984793,
0.1759687364,
-0.1923174411,
-0.405620873,
0.465754509,
0.5790171027,
-0.20777601,
1.0757328272,
-0.7261362672,
-0.156902194,
-0.0924628451,
-0.0083095366,
0.2151740491,
0.254421562,
0.4836143553,
-0.4955044389,
-0.6580787897,
0.1697573662,
-0.2302427888,
-0.0392151438,
0.1955027729,
0.0451355465,
0.0536184274,
0.4615391195,
-0.2848596275,
0.1270470768,
0.9965232611,
-0.0701098368,
0.6340822577,
-0.2277754843,
-0.1406495422,
-1.1799815893,
0.0971355215,
-0.1626152396,
-0.3850527704,
-0.3935462832,
-0.0576349422,
0.1090164408,
-0.2735155225,
-0.1024092361,
0.8119789362,
-0.2552272975,
-0.3341782093,
-0.2294050306,
0.3414354324,
-0.2308218628,
0.457269907,
-0.0465770289,
1.0603129864,
0.5029104352,
-0.7603234053,
0.1248945445,
0.1337365657,
-0.4624574184,
0.5678576827,
-0.7182923555,
0.363219589,
-0.176781863,
0.175228253,
-0.6048904061,
0.0137006007,
-0.3278815448,
-0.2972907722,
0.2414728552,
-0.1640379727,
-0.644098103,
-0.4731197059,
-0.2251835465,
0.3988245726,
0.6292051077,
-0.8883422017,
0.468516469,
0.4375928044,
-0.1469907165,
-0.4190264642,
-0.2673079967,
-0.2204189599,
-0.2034744769,
-0.4528189003,
0.2740160823,
-0.0287531428,
0.0575317368,
-0.0662184283,
0.0630791038,
-0.3766160011,
0.0950546861,
0.2320964187,
-0.2364321053,
-0.0901872143,
0.5116098523,
-0.1978463233,
-0.2638408542,
-0.0634894222,
-0.2973349094,
0.6727615595,
-0.1694108695,
-0.0826462805,
-0.0982825831,
0.308476001,
0.4129746556,
-0.5310150385,
0.876101613,
0.5959486961,
-0.4252742529,
-0.4496911466,
-0.5081093907,
-0.3005922139,
-0.4877092838,
0.6785200238,
-0.477620244,
-1.1368578672,
0.4700686038,
-0.1727110445,
-0.0367641747,
0.341447562,
0.2865683436,
-0.0978691503,
1.0563948154,
0.9349038601,
-0.4276704788,
0.7348678112,
-0.2223796099,
0.2060791403,
-0.7321695685,
0.1576198637,
-0.8236925006,
-0.1363471746,
-0.6730447412,
-0.4962180853,
0.2509319782,
-0.1812934726,
-0.5269982815,
0.5111289024,
-0.2611634135,
0.7082700133,
0.493283242,
0.1520740837,
0.2003125101,
0.0048586535,
-0.274274528,
-0.2017681599,
-0.7801960111,
-0.1141261011,
0.9035866857,
0.5254715085,
0.5231758952,
-0.1267109364,
0.6083640456,
-0.1196127981,
0.370398432,
-0.6041392684,
0.40222615,
-0.3254962265,
-0.5259588361,
-0.344101876,
-0.8064454794,
-1.1143300533,
-0.0743759722,
0.1573129594,
-0.4610526562,
-0.1557215899,
0.053834185,
-0.2350032479,
0.524079144,
-0.4486929774,
0.7190182805,
0.0924195275,
-0.0470851064,
-0.3047294021,
-0.3597273827,
-0.0056334469,
-0.3148244917,
0.1342888325,
-0.0416246429,
0.185119763,
0.6874929667,
-0.4228136539,
0.5645565987,
-0.0916625783,
-0.0499719419,
0.0603556819,
0.3935080469,
0.9101247191,
-0.0998892859,
-0.0774312168,
0.0800414681,
-0.0943712071,
-0.5411303043,
-0.7009174824,
0.551463306,
-0.6965417862,
-0.2659665346,
-0.2581626177,
-0.5161890388,
-0.1807399839,
0.0450388268,
0.0031631435,
0.5427469611,
-0.14438577,
0.2503421009,
0.6843904853,
-0.2722148597,
0.3920357227,
0.5254924893,
-0.165967688,
-0.1137352809,
0.9443175197,
-0.0453948565,
0.4542668164,
0.4504151344,
0.4687598944,
-0.2707613707,
-0.4645466208,
-0.1212654188,
0.4033885002,
-0.34959203,
0.0021677685,
-0.7060383558,
-0.3316426575,
-0.0493224747,
0.1318787932,
-0.9472483993,
-0.1860714555,
0.2005042583,
-0.0042301854,
0.4689929485,
0.8679866195,
-0.1364737153,
0.2792776823,
-0.9835956693,
0.0833933502,
0.3082239628,
0.9293553233,
0.0787989721,
-0.6703129411,
-0.6800966859,
-0.0289463177,
-0.0271245874,
-0.4489917457,
0.2134918123,
0.2831601799,
0.1648306251,
0.2200152278,
-0.1171039939,
0.6967907548,
-0.907818079,
0.6093120575,
-0.3881549835,
-0.7719743848,
0.5326607823,
-0.4399267733,
0.4456249177,
0.5156533718,
0.5011830926,
-0.7668545842,
-0.2884686589,
-0.5635714531,
-0.4056060612,
0.4518252313,
0.0293363072,
0.2702563107,
-0.1335212886,
0.3072330952,
0.0493766665,
-0.021705443,
-0.5406557918,
-0.1350462884,
0.3519658744,
-0.0834393054,
-0.4060950875,
-0.1280033886,
0.1637758315,
-0.3609367013,
0.4592417777,
-0.2794590592,
0.3542566001,
-0.0564886667,
-0.0341658741,
-0.1836842597,
-0.0053283912,
0.3154123425,
0.439350009,
-0.3011148274,
0.0039279014,
0.4460812509,
-0.463519305,
0.1503443569,
0.2474929094,
-0.0916677266,
0.0689147636,
0.1780112088,
0.6813209653,
0.2154194713,
-0.5473528504,
0.6391374469,
-0.119126156,
-0.1321732104,
-0.2598582804,
0.0637818798,
-0.1614939123,
0.3060960174,
0.2382183969,
-0.1110258177,
-0.1059082299,
-0.2972762287,
0.4618117511,
0.424949199,
-0.5198646784,
-0.3490529656,
0.5398205519,
-0.0720506683,
-0.3303415179,
0.9221093655,
-0.3659591079,
-0.8682610393,
0.5391048789,
0.342387706,
0.6411277652,
-0.3539542258,
0.3579649925,
0.7515203357,
0.3899589181,
-0.2762040794,
-0.0900074616,
0.1116924435,
-0.5495445728,
-0.6941943765,
-0.7365862131,
-0.3664908409,
0.2082755268,
-0.3410360515,
0.265404284,
-0.266810298,
0.0950925127,
-0.47252056,
0.3083117306,
-0.7965634465,
0.1749554276,
-0.1318422854,
0.7164931893,
-1.0137399435,
0.6820251346,
0.4344825149,
-0.0128309242,
-0.8942974806,
0.0146621028,
-0.4612140954,
-0.5452057719,
0.5670941472,
0.4171551168,
0.2471772432,
0.1947188079,
-0.2947966158,
-1.1304603815,
0.7285677791,
0.1588851362,
-0.7273747921,
0.041710984,
0.1549626738,
0.8534172773,
-0.1928617656,
0.4733426571,
0.7153016329,
0.1461423188,
-0.2913884819,
-1.1621037722,
0.0031513884,
-0.2248257101,
0.1619935781,
0.8064876795,
-0.7093655467,
0.790184617,
-0.2425981909,
-0.3060823977,
-0.0675742999,
0.4866780043,
0.1160928011,
-0.0335739404,
0.7906588912,
0.6567094922,
0.9030068517,
-0.1384685785,
1.4140617847,
-0.120762445,
0.5507870317,
1.2336463928,
-0.1458420455,
1.0832808018,
0.077765502,
-0.4853898585,
0.2599095702,
0.662907362,
-0.0875005424,
0.4475035369,
0.4698196352,
0.015096874,
-0.1708647609,
-0.3047061563,
-0.4782620072,
0.4202346504,
0.0341516137,
-0.136681512,
-0.3298588991,
-0.0315848924,
-0.2345566303,
0.0713495389,
0.0768014416,
0.4875672758,
-0.1137856394,
-0.407204777,
0.4567890465,
-0.2236698568,
0.5802058578,
-0.3382580876,
0.0922327116,
-0.4890582561,
0.2926059067,
0.1298464835,
-0.4440167546,
0.1637216806,
-0.1396123618,
-0.1495836377,
-0.1206117421,
0.1725071222,
-0.5311201215,
-0.4450671375,
0.2921256423,
0.2720218599,
0.3225607574,
-0.3203990161,
-0.4395762384,
-0.1365867555,
-0.2014158964,
-0.350586921,
0.4575777352,
0.3774704933,
-0.1102685854,
0.7942919731,
0.6185698509,
0.2888233066,
0.208554402,
0.149187848,
0.8752299547,
-0.5404631495,
-0.3587767184,
-0.7148940563,
0.2719982266,
0.0576903671,
-0.3502168357,
0.4429844618,
0.6966980696,
1.0995596647,
0.197089985,
0.4637561142,
0.0160648208,
0.8017398715,
-0.1962771863,
0.4997670949,
-0.5750164986,
-0.1185706332,
-0.1329661012,
-1.3666375875,
-0.2141962498,
0.6403298974,
-0.2930671573,
0.2662834227,
0.973511517,
0.9421995878,
-0.1218756437,
-0.1983261108,
0.155306384,
0.2430907488,
0.5162962675,
0.7575143576,
0.7684315443,
-0.7385361791,
0.6489034295,
-0.6735420823,
-0.0967335701,
-0.0612652563,
-0.8516715169,
-1.0951154232,
-0.6070876718,
-0.2143663615,
-0.3037361503,
-0.0400086381,
0.6770054698,
0.7189338207,
-0.7022355795,
-0.0428956337,
-0.0603526123,
-0.2216444463,
-0.1360259205,
-0.2551395297,
0.5273201466,
-0.2851555049,
-0.9170087576,
0.3536557257,
0.0606509969,
0.0305915009,
-0.3047177792,
-0.1544663608,
-0.0916588679,
-0.2414657772,
0.3202424943,
0.0275344029,
0.0140873315,
-0.5165430903,
0.1392148137,
-0.3112721443,
0.2023337632,
0.6823094487,
-0.6881080866,
0.5114011168,
0.4689677358,
0.9193947911,
0.7634811997,
0.0271676928,
0.6946468949,
-1.0125257969,
0.2513892651,
0.2090592533,
0.0959806219,
0.3247622252,
-0.295332998,
0.7143673897,
-0.0087587805,
-0.7732105255,
-1.0015724897,
0.117672801,
-0.2948830426,
0.1591624469,
0.9837714434,
0.0300244614,
-0.0823883265,
0.1013369262,
0.0829683989,
0.2469096184,
-0.1001813859,
0.9264786243,
0.787376225,
0.320322156,
-0.1047195792,
-0.7647864819,
0.5667978525,
0.6325199008,
-0.7445235252,
0.0500187501,
0.1542595774,
0.3181393743,
0.1096309647,
0.4341272414,
0.0205273852,
0.1221984103,
0.1514964551,
-0.1816514283,
-0.0287315138,
-0.5381475091,
-0.4269955456,
0.0112954229,
0.0691716,
-0.1059607342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17926v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17926v2 | Large Language Models are not Fair Evaluators | 2023-05-29T07:41:03 | 2023-08-30T13:22:35 | Peiyi Wang, Lei Li, Liang Chen, Zefan Cai, Dawei Zhu, Binghuai Lin, Yunbo Cao, Qi Liu, Tianyu Liu, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | In this paper, we uncover a systematic bias in the evaluation paradigm of
adopting large language models~(LLMs), e.g., GPT-4, as a referee to score and
compare the quality of responses generated by candidate models. We find that
the quality ranking of candidate responses can be easily hacked by simply
altering their order of appearance in the context. This manipulation allows us
to skew the evaluation result, making one model appear considerably superior to
the other, e.g., Vicuna-13B could beat ChatGPT on 66 over 80 tested queries
with ChatGPT as an evaluator. To address this issue, we propose a calibration
framework with three simple yet effective strategies: 1) Multiple Evidence
Calibration, which requires the evaluator model to generate multiple evaluation
evidence before assigning ratings; 2) Balanced Position Calibration, which
aggregates results across various orders to determine the final score; 3)
Human-in-the-Loop Calibration, which introduces a balanced position diversity
entropy to measure the difficulty of each example and seeks human assistance
when needed. We also manually annotate the "win/tie/lose" outcomes of responses
from ChatGPT and Vicuna-13B in the Vicuna Benchmark's question prompt, and
extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach successfully mitigates
evaluation bias, resulting in closer alignment with human judgments. We release
our code and human annotation at \url{https://github.com/i-Eval/FairEval} to
facilitate future research. | [
-0.2459042221,
-0.3353258669,
0.7171583176,
0.1120586395,
-0.2030750066,
0.0369827934,
-0.3470222056,
-0.2303458601,
-0.2454737276,
0.4100202024,
-0.1957015097,
-0.3221412003,
-0.5706564784,
-0.0564495027,
-0.2151553929,
1.220878005,
0.1659620553,
0.5271103382,
-0.0440313406,
-0.3069695532,
-0.4977892935,
-0.5182859302,
-0.5419136286,
-0.6627234817,
0.3972961009,
0.2184987515,
0.8689122796,
0.4012854397,
0.4777167141,
0.3203775883,
-0.0309920311,
-0.0182029828,
-0.7636935711,
-0.1289859712,
-0.3814936578,
-0.7445704341,
-0.4650132656,
0.1840714663,
0.5161998868,
0.4279421866,
-0.399916023,
0.1968619674,
0.1197313219,
0.7139180303,
-0.7623868585,
0.022899216,
-0.7788696289,
-0.1229690239,
-0.250931561,
-0.3838823438,
-0.5629515052,
-0.6506845951,
0.0337818526,
-0.3509439826,
0.1398098618,
0.0186294653,
0.7163131833,
0.2597717345,
-0.4850016236,
-0.1993280202,
-0.6321891546,
0.8667262793,
-0.9398310781,
0.1503066272,
0.3890265524,
0.6636150479,
-0.0986049995,
-0.2789517641,
-0.4807938933,
-0.2158801705,
0.2963027358,
0.1537700146,
0.0981965438,
0.1131156832,
0.3058442473,
0.3059636056,
-0.5676698089,
0.1676721871,
-0.4043472409,
-0.3712620139,
0.6533082128,
0.1136007756,
0.1021552533,
0.0141316131,
-0.1844602078,
-0.2945116162,
-0.7679630518,
-0.0506153107,
0.7498455048,
0.3744229674,
0.0875625387,
0.5542595387,
-0.1148015186,
0.7026403546,
0.2035810798,
-0.1278343946,
0.4359327555,
-0.2255886197,
-0.2195535898,
-0.0121353297,
0.8856126666,
0.490611136,
0.211400196,
-0.0222432688,
-0.4132775366,
0.2994717658,
0.2652862668,
-0.8262230754,
-0.1939768791,
0.1476198882,
-0.3080306649,
-0.3786215186,
0.1272457391,
-0.8619620204,
-0.6107907295,
-0.319801867,
0.6631078124,
-0.1344884634,
-0.057219442,
0.2224748731,
0.0407806933,
0.404109776,
0.4331482947,
-0.6574190855,
0.2585736215,
0.798615396,
0.4379930496,
0.0651643425,
-0.2646268308,
-0.6642498374,
-0.3027245104,
-0.3828910291,
0.4661162794,
-0.5467619896,
-0.1794414073,
-0.0055144085,
-0.2746045291,
0.156729579,
-0.4638933837,
0.6225036383,
-0.7066022754,
0.6118958592,
-0.4509389102,
-0.340878129,
-0.1335191727,
0.3005973101,
-0.6298202276,
0.8087624907,
0.1314512938,
-0.7084203362,
0.347920686,
-0.4811219275,
-0.0594851077,
-0.1508085132,
-0.330466032,
-0.2385043204,
0.0136372037,
0.2553358674,
0.1036818177,
-0.5386124849,
0.5954436064,
-0.4550167322,
-0.6541228294,
0.1691519916,
-0.701192975,
0.8549739122,
0.2804384828,
-0.5324435234,
0.0803207159,
-0.5824314356,
0.2046018392,
-0.034128353,
-0.502543509,
-0.1586806029,
-0.0401357077,
-0.0081883119,
0.3261666596,
0.0475578308,
-0.468403101,
0.0693107247,
-0.3827896714,
0.2572158575,
1.0126439333,
-0.4240126312,
0.4867193997,
-0.3922321796,
0.6861514449,
-0.2045910656,
0.1082452908,
0.057752911,
-0.3430264294,
-0.5195477605,
-0.1105628386,
0.5093138814,
0.4732845724,
-0.784057796,
0.3911244571,
-0.5311626196,
-0.5837352276,
-0.7917051911,
0.2185413092,
0.5576327443,
0.3618942797,
0.1274659932,
-0.340284586,
-0.346898973,
-0.9144144654,
-0.5716074705,
-0.3741315603,
-0.1980439872,
0.2331912667,
0.4084765613,
0.0283625089,
0.8210050464,
-0.1495852768,
-0.1963615119,
0.0162027963,
0.0246081352,
0.3878417313,
0.3178307116,
0.596950531,
-0.6449893117,
-0.1509990394,
-0.0480421335,
-0.6481074691,
-0.3780378699,
0.1629957259,
-0.0954113454,
0.0260339975,
0.1808069497,
-0.4398286939,
0.2288047224,
0.7301911116,
-0.3842566311,
0.5431551337,
0.0348047651,
0.4223027825,
-0.7826283574,
0.0954426378,
-0.0030771913,
-0.455668211,
-0.3329003155,
0.3328301907,
0.0991510674,
0.2414793521,
-0.3452485502,
0.5982204676,
-0.2343719602,
0.0594334379,
-0.2957545519,
0.3166427314,
0.2238351256,
0.4222680628,
-0.3701703548,
0.6219922304,
0.0448103212,
-0.1977133453,
0.3939040601,
-0.0627187118,
-0.6393723488,
0.6434016228,
-0.5969187021,
0.3769416213,
-0.2261916548,
0.5996679664,
-1.0173888206,
-0.0856199637,
0.1655744761,
-0.3911399841,
0.2666098475,
-0.2205635756,
-0.4041848481,
-0.3530876935,
-0.5202542543,
0.6858515143,
0.4234070182,
-0.5539361238,
0.4703489542,
0.3608852923,
0.0237368587,
-0.8711023927,
-0.7348617315,
-0.0208459646,
-0.2941836417,
-0.4326427877,
0.0633805841,
-0.2229240239,
-0.2939479947,
-0.2739741206,
-0.232227549,
0.1098034009,
0.0066060298,
0.1737579852,
0.3498056829,
-0.3199265003,
0.0307158232,
-0.3550907373,
0.0670048669,
-0.0870538652,
-0.0054161609,
0.5966690779,
-0.3069189489,
-0.6740979552,
-0.3331439197,
-0.0471519418,
0.6111671925,
-0.1147868484,
0.3812603652,
0.5175434947,
-0.2695233822,
0.0283474587,
-1.0364063978,
-0.1669139117,
-0.4673413634,
0.524174571,
-0.3928185105,
-0.9242245555,
0.5135201812,
0.2367496043,
0.2826899886,
0.3611479998,
0.8134115338,
0.3662709594,
1.1316133738,
0.3381693661,
-0.3149238229,
0.3368784189,
0.0243030582,
0.3661868274,
-0.8758496642,
-0.0212118719,
-0.8233190179,
-0.3876654804,
-0.6344979405,
-0.5510274172,
0.1256811023,
0.1447839737,
-0.5374974608,
0.1552753747,
-0.5600535274,
0.6741062999,
0.3326892853,
0.1417013854,
0.2082160264,
-0.2348900288,
-0.1669614315,
-0.137984395,
-0.5982180834,
-0.792386353,
1.3263344765,
0.5356115699,
1.03873384,
0.2264169753,
0.5878311396,
0.1802964061,
0.7367364764,
-0.6658416986,
0.4252194762,
0.1010372415,
-0.7311810255,
-0.3608603776,
-0.7068402767,
-0.6027666926,
0.6807292104,
0.0642367303,
-0.8338755369,
0.2207416296,
0.1061476544,
-0.4454231262,
0.1236912832,
-0.8385530114,
0.8164219856,
-0.3754132986,
-0.5241641998,
-0.1459181309,
-0.371417582,
0.5906451941,
-0.2246220857,
0.5295155644,
-0.2250123024,
0.1695823073,
0.6836854219,
-0.3482768238,
0.6750186682,
-0.4023971558,
-0.2253063321,
0.129790619,
0.2360512018,
0.3892942071,
0.0150368791,
-0.5577334166,
0.0785592794,
0.1153595299,
-0.4410735667,
-0.6352297664,
0.7462799549,
-0.7572654486,
-0.6982130408,
-0.4888647199,
-0.2374985963,
-0.2293762267,
0.0696540698,
0.1878241301,
0.2670073509,
-0.2783924639,
0.2336191833,
0.155269146,
-0.3423368037,
0.0889491662,
0.4955939353,
-0.3203605413,
-0.4479219913,
0.7707642913,
-0.1159052029,
0.2686937451,
0.214586854,
0.2811762393,
-0.2960789502,
-0.3250359893,
-0.3148119152,
0.1765484959,
-0.8284013867,
-0.3996641636,
-0.2267992347,
-0.0601532571,
-0.2612587512,
0.100945361,
-0.4399190545,
-0.236477077,
0.1610935628,
-0.0218084659,
-0.0873112679,
0.6610185504,
0.1745806932,
0.4248718023,
-0.2957944274,
0.1722177863,
0.3051124513,
0.4785295129,
0.0722609833,
-0.7921082377,
-0.087992087,
0.2609938085,
-0.4787627161,
-0.7575390935,
0.1259827465,
0.0584649853,
0.5670741796,
0.3540127575,
-0.0397983454,
0.795627594,
-0.5594659448,
0.7696204185,
0.1861033291,
-1.0287032127,
0.2634355128,
-0.2156612277,
0.4439085126,
0.8526679277,
-0.06709034,
-0.4876686335,
-0.4284596741,
-0.3736702502,
-0.811755836,
0.833214283,
-0.007448358,
0.2814433277,
0.0916056111,
0.2262695432,
0.0339242518,
0.3063405454,
-0.9156752229,
0.0095110387,
-0.1884123683,
-0.2851903737,
-0.1855193377,
-0.244403705,
-0.3064456582,
-0.0551301576,
0.8165388703,
-0.3584787846,
0.047362458,
0.055313509,
-0.210228011,
-0.1963582337,
0.4189026356,
0.5118393898,
0.9699792266,
-0.2736186385,
0.0784300566,
0.0635050982,
-0.2402335107,
0.16983518,
0.0558367111,
-0.1334494352,
-0.0098187299,
0.3460028172,
0.7322359681,
0.2908198833,
-0.5704084635,
0.9145380855,
-0.1715633124,
-0.1630930305,
0.0280048847,
-0.0317414179,
-0.0490712933,
0.287491709,
0.4028075039,
-0.0131779071,
0.1201002002,
-0.4730451107,
0.0763419047,
0.6158671975,
-0.286309123,
-0.3085022867,
0.7732844353,
0.2295026779,
-0.3088648617,
0.485321939,
-0.084183082,
-0.762634635,
0.4801273346,
0.291117847,
0.6822947264,
-0.4826394022,
0.1439543962,
0.3426014185,
0.3917865753,
-0.5029122233,
0.1550105363,
0.0485506579,
-0.7391293645,
-0.5798338652,
-0.7147536278,
-0.363818109,
0.2220514417,
-0.5434528589,
0.3328503966,
-0.3710431755,
-0.3003178239,
0.0900506005,
0.0041300603,
-0.9644896984,
0.0195988622,
0.1523215473,
0.8508172631,
-0.8487030864,
0.6205588579,
0.4952391088,
-0.2656624019,
-0.783911109,
-0.1173088551,
0.2755614519,
-0.8476142883,
0.520246923,
0.1924595833,
0.0213907231,
-0.4322230816,
-0.5696435571,
-0.6010242105,
0.8577958941,
0.7602217793,
-0.7121882439,
-0.1765830964,
-0.0177662056,
0.5975808501,
-0.2142642736,
0.8444529176,
0.4775570333,
0.5156368613,
-0.1183907837,
-1.2726824284,
0.0703292936,
-0.2255525142,
0.1088906676,
0.0391130485,
-0.7178092599,
0.6230949759,
-0.1105829626,
0.0219765343,
0.2481761724,
0.2796382606,
0.4228916168,
0.1663391292,
0.5430487394,
0.4400579035,
0.6662819982,
-0.2733985484,
1.0919849873,
-0.0950478017,
0.5915179253,
1.3549463749,
-0.4996508062,
0.7663121819,
0.6157395244,
-0.3113178611,
0.2714228332,
0.5600668788,
0.0102773719,
0.4191500247,
0.6046013832,
-0.099459298,
-0.3532093465,
0.161769703,
-0.2529026568,
0.5982556343,
0.1236863583,
-0.2672763467,
-0.3997596204,
-0.1905848682,
-0.0435664542,
0.1473865062,
-0.0518088639,
0.5285143852,
0.1784720272,
-0.881663084,
0.5736169219,
0.2264193147,
0.7174686193,
-0.451962024,
-0.0508314818,
-0.1336746216,
0.2423663884,
-0.2243169397,
-0.7160452008,
-0.1443670988,
0.0966206938,
0.0264991485,
-0.0608934462,
0.245173052,
-0.3283060193,
-0.3275925815,
0.2786646485,
0.487755686,
0.208593592,
-0.1527977437,
-0.6858443022,
0.2301375121,
0.1106507927,
-0.5657690763,
0.3293706477,
0.347668618,
-0.2049270868,
0.5650948882,
0.5298352838,
0.086706683,
-0.1164326444,
0.3750854135,
0.634562552,
-0.4063180685,
-0.3213673234,
-1.019080162,
0.3472910821,
0.0270828567,
-0.2242694199,
0.536942184,
0.657095015,
0.8252342939,
0.214426592,
0.653482914,
0.100039877,
0.3380727768,
-0.356552124,
0.7113761306,
-0.3902161419,
0.6317887306,
-0.385587275,
-1.2550681829,
-0.2813938558,
0.7454208136,
-0.4527773261,
0.4559955597,
0.4115069807,
0.8948731422,
-0.0288717002,
-0.1063824147,
0.4625928104,
0.3071542084,
0.5978047252,
0.7268246412,
0.7463394403,
-0.619248271,
0.560401082,
0.0539445803,
-0.3724799454,
-0.3593586981,
-0.9144156575,
-0.6542075276,
-0.2890211344,
-0.1096381545,
-0.6078030467,
0.1517165005,
0.9667389393,
0.733448863,
-0.7515032887,
-0.4161287546,
0.3421246111,
0.1228948087,
0.0565257482,
-0.2515552044,
0.2653836608,
-0.1314995438,
-0.7912564278,
0.2082978934,
0.0905142874,
-0.3679417968,
-0.3662755489,
-0.2029754966,
0.0080445036,
-0.0574593879,
0.4669562876,
0.1336413622,
-1.046577096,
-0.4936959445,
-0.2799798548,
-0.3790355325,
0.1202789918,
0.5737477541,
-0.9026985168,
0.6442265511,
0.4239976108,
0.7052173615,
0.3026066422,
0.1073922515,
0.8192542791,
-0.4884056747,
-0.0862082168,
0.338522017,
0.373344481,
0.50997895,
-0.1692833602,
0.6352594495,
-0.1254258603,
-0.7248380184,
-1.0728720427,
-0.0866312832,
-0.9213246107,
0.0113693858,
1.1716946363,
0.0100076739,
-0.17305547,
0.2987719178,
-0.361628592,
0.0729591697,
-0.4469519258,
1.0111761093,
1.0278160572,
0.2593549192,
0.0303620789,
-0.7939484119,
0.3401369452,
0.5268027782,
-0.4843355417,
0.0786541626,
0.5395675302,
0.5106186867,
0.1456911862,
0.741699338,
-0.4224199653,
0.4438860416,
-0.3038092554,
0.1174125001,
0.2766423821,
0.0873107687,
-0.7166942358,
0.0000110226,
0.4229928851,
0.0846239626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18462v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18462v2 | Membership Inference Attacks against Language Models via Neighbourhood Comparison | 2023-05-29T07:06:03 | 2023-08-07T06:32:56 | Justus Mattern, Fatemehsadat Mireshghallah, Zhijing Jin, Bernhard Schölkopf, Mrinmaya Sachan, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Membership Inference attacks (MIAs) aim to predict whether a data sample was
present in the training data of a machine learning model or not, and are widely
used for assessing the privacy risks of language models. Most existing attacks
rely on the observation that models tend to assign higher probabilities to
their training samples than non-training points. However, simple thresholding
of the model score in isolation tends to lead to high false-positive rates as
it does not account for the intrinsic complexity of a sample. Recent work has
demonstrated that reference-based attacks which compare model scores to those
obtained from a reference model trained on similar data can substantially
improve the performance of MIAs. However, in order to train reference models,
attacks of this kind make the strong and arguably unrealistic assumption that
an adversary has access to samples closely resembling the original training
data. Therefore, we investigate their performance in more realistic scenarios
and find that they are highly fragile in relation to the data distribution used
to train reference models. To investigate whether this fragility provides a
layer of safety, we propose and evaluate neighbourhood attacks, which compare
model scores for a given sample to scores of synthetically generated neighbour
texts and therefore eliminate the need for access to the training data
distribution. We show that, in addition to being competitive with
reference-based attacks that have perfect knowledge about the training data
distribution, our attack clearly outperforms existing reference-free attacks as
well as reference-based attacks with imperfect knowledge, which demonstrates
the need for a reevaluation of the threat model of adversarial attacks. | [
-0.3706561327,
-0.6049232483,
0.4255033135,
-0.3793806434,
-0.0471941195,
-0.0707539394,
0.2041182518,
-0.6097776294,
0.0672374293,
0.3251960278,
-0.5801659226,
-0.5350795388,
-0.6436929703,
-0.0341179669,
-0.5392347574,
0.6944236755,
0.5247339606,
0.1388665289,
-0.4063582718,
-0.2749873996,
-0.11344897,
-1.0530799627,
-0.4087105095,
-0.036069598,
0.4828679264,
-0.1849012971,
0.9104427099,
0.5331964493,
0.7273995876,
0.3934437037,
-0.1651940048,
-0.2478501052,
-0.3323656917,
0.1702125221,
-0.1895516217,
-0.885951221,
-0.377743572,
0.0612812378,
0.4792942107,
0.73867172,
0.1887008995,
-0.022839224,
-0.1665119976,
0.705119133,
-0.8223025203,
-0.0273929778,
-0.9218105674,
0.0948981419,
-0.2736720145,
-0.0002875942,
-0.4240840673,
-0.4651868939,
0.1680398285,
0.0533322804,
0.5633819103,
-0.0437347628,
1.017726779,
0.1510108709,
-0.2806486785,
-0.2611829937,
-0.3358177841,
0.6293432117,
-0.7615329027,
0.4205164611,
0.7185338736,
0.4790385962,
-0.3622601628,
-0.3310251236,
-0.5027239323,
-0.2715456784,
-0.1654360145,
0.0192555916,
-0.3550437391,
0.1121361703,
0.3251690865,
0.4271409214,
-0.4862856269,
0.034167666,
-0.4676687717,
-0.0293135755,
0.4614672065,
0.0276295301,
0.1210920438,
-0.3891067505,
-0.464653194,
-0.1474544406,
-0.7585732341,
-0.1818066835,
0.6865974665,
0.397200495,
-0.3305394948,
0.1932809055,
-0.166823402,
0.6228450537,
-0.0390540957,
0.0045109848,
0.1265477091,
-0.2930134535,
-0.2263873965,
-0.3333266079,
0.9338955283,
0.1969749331,
0.280685544,
-0.5014830828,
-0.1063537821,
-0.051955428,
0.2669116557,
-0.6192422509,
-0.4157652259,
0.2474948466,
-0.3906970322,
-0.6003424525,
0.4552582204,
-0.9092021585,
-0.2364834994,
0.1842265278,
0.2519022822,
-0.4238694906,
-0.0654039234,
-0.1528511345,
0.013791061,
-0.0669576302,
0.0580243655,
-0.7666378021,
0.2735948563,
0.5345807076,
0.8745216131,
0.1549171209,
-0.3781195879,
-0.522102952,
0.0406815745,
-0.296233952,
0.7659596801,
-0.6225942969,
-0.5194523335,
0.0167139731,
-0.3802945614,
-0.3308570683,
-0.7551550269,
0.2296047062,
-0.7310513854,
0.1829092056,
-0.282512635,
-0.3991580904,
-0.0859159082,
0.3519324362,
-0.7165753841,
0.9838019013,
0.2064960748,
-1.0974678993,
0.1998127401,
-0.437530905,
-0.1366446316,
-0.4680830538,
-0.0815875903,
-0.5669249296,
0.2279381603,
0.1700796187,
0.4222866595,
-0.1860422939,
-0.183915168,
-0.7846598029,
-0.2010006607,
0.5794593692,
-0.5545683503,
0.9507024884,
0.28247118,
-0.4026330709,
-0.081423685,
-0.5621055961,
0.0810198486,
0.1054424718,
-0.2284241915,
-0.6545705795,
0.2711108625,
-0.644162178,
0.1363309175,
0.0219344292,
-0.2944880426,
0.172555998,
-0.593028605,
0.0825880095,
0.7757698298,
0.2173996866,
0.3423857987,
-0.4249419272,
0.5435615182,
0.0895912871,
0.3671465516,
-0.0391974635,
-0.2702976167,
-0.6088114381,
-0.3811223209,
0.7225430012,
0.4053735137,
-0.6705701947,
0.5107722282,
-0.3598112464,
-0.5550492406,
-0.5562284589,
-0.033819247,
0.4670478404,
0.3061769605,
0.3321457505,
-0.2724834681,
-0.2588805556,
-0.861954391,
-0.0754299983,
-0.5541497469,
-0.2230472714,
0.2819733322,
0.5949395895,
-0.0648870766,
0.9595348239,
-0.5147253871,
-0.1602254063,
0.052296102,
-0.148842901,
-0.101078853,
0.5198934078,
1.1290916204,
-0.639074266,
-0.3682450056,
-0.2330389619,
-0.9838454127,
-0.2012582719,
-0.0954736099,
-0.0786977112,
-0.0424996018,
0.3378981054,
-0.4745975733,
0.5091170669,
0.6317408085,
-0.3466416299,
0.5862118006,
0.1242462844,
0.1091312841,
-1.2455253601,
-0.1199209988,
-0.2987128794,
-0.3630889356,
-0.6424592137,
0.8018929958,
-0.1807345301,
-0.0153467804,
-0.3351535797,
0.2635983527,
-0.4002842903,
-0.1204111278,
-0.0176785719,
-0.0477707461,
-0.0487558581,
0.3923432231,
-0.150046736,
0.6883733273,
0.7378253937,
-0.3326785564,
0.1115068272,
0.0870830938,
-0.3122868538,
0.4148214757,
-0.4253429472,
0.6104117036,
0.1351611167,
0.0983621702,
-0.6897563338,
-0.1337065399,
0.3385069072,
-0.808034122,
0.2979647815,
-0.3026125729,
-0.5299524665,
0.0244894251,
-0.5746508837,
0.2011692077,
0.2087122202,
-0.7165757418,
0.5753480196,
0.3465715945,
0.0779341385,
-0.8881209493,
-0.7074753642,
0.0107437382,
-0.397403121,
-0.4165577292,
-0.1677678376,
-0.0004321991,
-0.4761411548,
0.0421855189,
-0.1895837337,
-0.4169837534,
0.5593112707,
0.3430701792,
0.0309884064,
-0.1458324045,
-0.3429107666,
-0.0979660228,
-0.0568272695,
0.4562584758,
0.0033549569,
0.4918028116,
0.0718864128,
-0.7422038317,
-0.5194541812,
0.525475204,
0.8460053205,
-0.0515602976,
1.1773152351,
0.0315261856,
-0.3605090082,
-0.257973969,
-0.4046517909,
-0.3145105243,
-0.5002866387,
0.4918853343,
-0.5251117945,
-0.5578663945,
0.7065725327,
0.1403451711,
0.206256941,
0.2393313497,
0.1958744079,
-0.2312471867,
0.7186319828,
0.3472116888,
-0.4906799197,
0.4769279063,
-0.1309671998,
0.1622555107,
-0.3989166915,
-0.2621978521,
-1.0264830589,
0.0239316244,
-0.4567957222,
-0.5254980326,
0.1783799678,
0.3241536617,
-0.0279264953,
0.4027009308,
0.0100702858,
0.636760056,
0.5206247568,
0.1318875104,
0.1782817543,
0.2523858845,
-0.3594230413,
-0.149767369,
-0.8798602223,
-0.354183346,
1.0949654579,
0.4715080857,
0.6053714156,
0.6249254942,
0.7551425099,
0.4233775735,
0.5091731548,
-0.6058012843,
0.5288730264,
0.0100076711,
-0.6280573606,
0.0844693035,
-0.825188756,
-0.712680161,
0.3959332705,
-0.3835741878,
-0.9268966317,
0.5525113344,
-0.0179499835,
-0.1649676859,
0.6162654757,
-0.6101679802,
0.6897060871,
0.0483348891,
-0.2570614815,
-0.0435823016,
-0.5964721441,
0.4517995417,
-0.4808368385,
0.3106774688,
0.1788377613,
0.4358589351,
0.5522387624,
-0.6916500926,
1.1156169176,
-0.1897621751,
0.1966559291,
0.2704589367,
0.431504339,
0.3477293551,
-0.0117142787,
-0.4633329809,
0.5967901349,
0.040677812,
-0.5516420007,
-0.8018558025,
0.455239594,
-0.7953609228,
-0.8133564591,
-0.5708563924,
-0.3252783716,
-0.2034798115,
-0.1046287939,
0.1840085387,
0.4049350619,
-0.1042078733,
0.4042068124,
0.4306679368,
0.0350120328,
0.2346129566,
0.5939813852,
0.0401029475,
-0.5005023479,
0.7657565475,
-0.134419024,
0.7350355983,
0.3371249139,
-0.0142898019,
-0.2740977407,
-0.7984287739,
-0.2617028654,
0.0644640401,
-0.6764374971,
-0.4322288036,
-0.3810264766,
-0.2127345204,
-0.4030687809,
-0.0515488461,
-0.3322406411,
-0.1865012497,
0.0430762321,
-0.1700002253,
0.0077853277,
0.6143860817,
-0.1271946728,
0.4526500702,
-0.9733073115,
-0.0879274234,
0.1931389719,
0.0164176933,
0.0898138359,
-0.4900587499,
-0.3753581047,
-0.090077661,
-0.2794778645,
-1.3794560432,
0.1462644339,
0.1176950857,
0.5769922137,
0.8647937179,
0.2679537237,
0.6549051404,
-0.5285981297,
0.6355968118,
-0.1114169881,
-0.8737221956,
0.3172739744,
-0.3854844868,
0.1238623559,
0.9004859328,
0.4405639172,
-0.0201219171,
-0.608520329,
-0.9787846804,
-0.5033192039,
0.630224824,
0.666603446,
0.1162672117,
-0.0818648711,
0.6903048158,
-0.2979718149,
0.1360773593,
-0.8490617275,
-0.4582836032,
-0.0150849409,
-0.0330355056,
0.3652846813,
-0.2352875769,
-0.1232757121,
0.028875893,
0.4949375391,
-0.0684388727,
0.295527339,
0.1160150394,
0.2075219005,
-0.0111846467,
-0.0175550785,
0.1358067989,
0.4413733482,
-0.2714860141,
0.1678922027,
0.3972623944,
-0.4237653017,
0.0621292368,
-0.0638228655,
-0.3513486981,
0.2047026157,
0.8792873621,
0.443742007,
0.1441720426,
-0.4720338285,
0.5788896084,
-0.2656140029,
-0.1923294365,
-0.176958397,
0.309322089,
0.0254888013,
0.1165148765,
0.1579556018,
0.5048422217,
-0.046071291,
-0.7268484831,
0.4710087776,
0.7255331874,
-0.4762431085,
-0.4957691133,
0.5700893402,
-0.0472489074,
-0.3943149149,
0.5148292184,
0.0907460451,
-0.9288371205,
0.702134788,
0.4809516966,
0.7504841685,
-0.7221333385,
-0.037151847,
0.2572799027,
0.6381585598,
0.2574534118,
-0.1906399131,
-0.2093659341,
-0.7203271985,
0.0711223409,
-0.6958453655,
-0.4819046259,
0.3354005516,
-1.0358104706,
-0.2209958285,
-0.6660954952,
-0.1261617243,
-0.3004395366,
-0.060417369,
-0.1855321825,
0.2948063612,
-0.1608383507,
0.9150995612,
-0.9737299681,
0.9936426282,
0.5128852725,
-0.1122599542,
-0.4700535536,
0.5739938021,
0.0854934156,
-0.2407270074,
0.6602205038,
0.0330460072,
-0.1304817051,
-0.5423383713,
-0.2366104126,
-0.8232300282,
0.5884360671,
0.5853811502,
-0.3808916211,
-0.0667280853,
0.3060832024,
0.5329473615,
-0.1748783886,
0.075539127,
0.5427673459,
0.0313986465,
-0.0398730747,
-0.654558897,
-0.0618649945,
-0.1720393896,
-0.4660065174,
0.1267070472,
-0.6352776885,
0.8320721388,
-0.0163289178,
-0.2231388241,
0.1117735282,
0.9171200395,
0.2180409878,
0.2604319453,
0.6285716891,
0.4583173394,
0.7773475647,
-0.0620219111,
1.2577198744,
-0.251457721,
0.4542073011,
1.32639575,
-0.2190850377,
1.0716789961,
0.1390670836,
-0.4022143781,
0.3679050803,
0.6435578465,
0.0619455762,
0.7214007974,
0.1226024777,
-0.4719086587,
-0.2438583821,
0.238316372,
-0.3926738799,
0.4923968315,
0.2885746062,
-0.2998001873,
-0.423607856,
-0.4508546293,
0.1867838055,
0.2694483995,
0.1315462291,
0.7163325548,
0.1026299223,
-0.1154227778,
0.4304630756,
0.1789940894,
0.307230711,
-0.9645116329,
0.0974361524,
-0.3590033948,
0.2389884442,
-0.0950117633,
-0.1193599328,
0.537070632,
0.1758212,
-0.2025439739,
0.446412921,
0.2614101768,
-0.040758647,
-0.3615546525,
0.5111739635,
0.4181864858,
0.2811511457,
0.0135257905,
-0.9449715614,
-0.1952796578,
0.160991922,
-0.2531808019,
0.7864596844,
0.1689147651,
0.0065125357,
0.6854971647,
0.7919951677,
0.3264282048,
-0.0207977202,
-0.06584014,
1.0303174257,
-0.2722550333,
-0.5354127288,
-1.1101124287,
0.0343409069,
-0.2610026002,
-0.1696292013,
0.8744359612,
0.5978630781,
1.0427238941,
0.130347833,
0.6269410253,
0.1940326095,
0.3802720606,
-0.7641116381,
1.0102876425,
-0.3360171318,
0.6474570632,
-0.3102082908,
-0.8746684194,
-0.4297573268,
0.7312387824,
-0.5385324955,
0.1934473217,
0.8444668055,
1.0851329565,
-0.1144916341,
-0.0652187467,
0.4668826163,
0.2162032872,
0.3843749762,
0.3095880747,
0.7347149253,
-0.5156903863,
0.286954999,
-0.4093248844,
-0.0513276756,
0.2034113407,
-0.6750407815,
-1.5204591751,
-0.4176934361,
-0.0885085911,
-0.5771910548,
0.4163052738,
0.7389080524,
0.7754837871,
-1.0002613068,
0.0128946146,
0.3305507302,
0.1150655821,
-0.0300223045,
-0.2567528486,
0.7038380504,
-0.0422736704,
-0.8504769802,
0.7452824116,
-0.1964871734,
0.1105934307,
-0.3140437007,
0.1252938658,
-0.1603936851,
0.3037620485,
-0.0024047468,
0.1433778703,
-0.4731732607,
-0.4604014158,
-0.4422852099,
-0.1842676401,
0.0240833852,
0.681253314,
-0.7586585879,
0.2426864952,
0.3424140513,
0.7209218144,
-0.1446052045,
0.2881855071,
0.4779363871,
-1.0450185537,
0.3172372878,
0.0382972769,
0.5567421317,
0.3173155487,
-0.585940659,
0.4599254727,
0.4806165993,
-0.2134441733,
-1.0082685947,
0.3663202226,
-0.65454036,
-0.5157812238,
0.7368272543,
-0.7135930061,
-0.5358951092,
-0.2695787847,
0.2342962474,
-0.1026032418,
-0.2154517919,
1.223064661,
0.472130239,
0.434902072,
0.3254526854,
-0.578994453,
0.511780262,
0.4396449924,
-0.8190230727,
0.2167918384,
0.4439686537,
0.4680604637,
0.2388597429,
0.3027273118,
-0.1993964314,
0.2668468654,
0.3709302545,
-0.3465378582,
-0.277402252,
-0.4396769404,
-0.4367460608,
0.7556151152,
-0.0711982325,
-0.2154891193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17911v1 | TotalDefMeme: A Multi-Attribute Meme dataset on Total Defence in Singapore | 2023-05-29T06:43:37 | 2023-05-29T06:43:37 | Nirmalendu Prakash, Ming Shan Hee, Roy Ka-Wei Lee | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, I.2.7 | Total Defence is a defence policy combining and extending the concept of
military defence and civil defence. While several countries have adopted total
defence as their defence policy, very few studies have investigated its
effectiveness. With the rapid proliferation of social media and digitalisation,
many social studies have been focused on investigating policy effectiveness
through specially curated surveys and questionnaires either through digital
media or traditional forms. However, such references may not truly reflect the
underlying sentiments about the target policies or initiatives of interest.
People are more likely to express their sentiment using communication mediums
such as starting topic thread on forums or sharing memes on social media. Using
Singapore as a case reference, this study aims to address this research gap by
proposing TotalDefMeme, a large-scale multi-modal and multi-attribute meme
dataset that captures public sentiments toward Singapore's Total Defence
policy. Besides supporting social informatics and public policy analysis of the
Total Defence policy, TotalDefMeme can also support many downstream multi-modal
machine learning tasks, such as aspect-based stance classification and
multi-modal meme clustering. We perform baseline machine learning experiments
on TotalDefMeme and evaluate its technical validity, and present possible
future interdisciplinary research directions and application scenarios using
the dataset as a baseline. | [
-0.8249897361,
-0.8452449441,
0.4348093867,
0.3694791198,
-0.2709948123,
0.455625236,
0.0307868142,
-0.0681552961,
0.7501366138,
0.0190742388,
-0.7804480195,
-0.6067459583,
-0.737054348,
0.3067511022,
-0.1393900216,
0.7343116403,
-0.1638416648,
-0.091119267,
-0.1074445769,
-0.3866540492,
-0.2559702992,
-0.8788866997,
-0.4622471631,
-0.0493677109,
0.3945998251,
0.6360752583,
0.5385829806,
0.011858576,
0.7100361586,
0.204383567,
0.1097781435,
-0.0937318057,
-0.2176796943,
-0.0937431157,
-0.6474549174,
-0.218661502,
-0.5576074719,
0.2628231347,
0.4497918487,
0.1992301494,
-0.0638541728,
-0.002681653,
-0.2752070129,
0.4710976481,
-0.5969092846,
-0.1631434709,
-0.4291568995,
0.2226625532,
-0.0684708506,
0.1677046269,
0.1276656538,
-0.1018981934,
-0.0018363412,
-0.3060539365,
-0.111955151,
-0.4229738712,
0.8695607781,
0.1997103691,
-0.5412045717,
0.0599434786,
-0.6674484015,
0.7448081374,
-0.5131747723,
0.0841573924,
0.4741425812,
0.4349460006,
0.0897232369,
-0.3294049203,
-0.6909896731,
-0.0347843245,
0.0751476064,
0.4845574498,
-0.1993277222,
0.0650162995,
0.2113686353,
0.1542980522,
-0.4885194302,
-0.2690238655,
-0.216227293,
-0.1887827367,
0.6530355215,
0.0626582503,
0.278635025,
-0.3688617945,
-0.8880138397,
-0.3655029535,
-0.4737688601,
0.2369929552,
0.074516207,
-0.0365412943,
-0.5349084735,
0.6640894413,
-0.3600254953,
0.2052798718,
0.0378431603,
-0.2072122097,
0.3083924949,
-0.5824454427,
-0.3211065531,
-0.0084927622,
0.7911198735,
0.4090956748,
0.2443059385,
0.176806584,
-0.2845830321,
0.4016015828,
0.5633964539,
-0.8819397092,
0.2048345953,
0.3376717269,
-0.265563786,
-0.707621932,
0.4629728198,
-0.9009085298,
-0.3391794264,
-0.6354392171,
0.1092469394,
-0.3505865037,
-1.0012321472,
0.0937714428,
-0.2300271392,
0.2422090918,
0.1492172927,
-0.2711950541,
0.0976144224,
0.8947148919,
1.046333313,
-0.0020872729,
-0.1700740755,
0.0285540167,
0.0413044617,
-0.4517017603,
0.9655262828,
-0.9397972822,
-0.645712316,
-0.2930877209,
0.2408313453,
-0.2518359125,
-0.5031033158,
0.8661477566,
-0.1502281725,
0.0908227414,
-0.3170531094,
-0.3697825372,
-0.4329752624,
0.6739810109,
-0.7764627337,
0.6000703573,
0.3185791671,
-0.5389214158,
0.5778878927,
-1.0188707113,
-0.7526817918,
-0.2573546767,
-0.4578677714,
-0.6559427381,
0.1399148256,
0.1127756312,
0.8643184304,
-0.5304093361,
0.5569120049,
-0.7905775309,
-0.1559211165,
0.170139119,
-0.4730684161,
0.7353565097,
0.3643655181,
-0.4772909582,
0.1093523502,
-0.4207074046,
-0.4302479029,
0.0989302322,
-0.0260663386,
-0.243884474,
-0.2072114497,
-0.2311892509,
0.5161478519,
0.0389750376,
-0.8680995107,
0.1782402545,
0.0195155181,
0.4588494003,
0.698779285,
0.3152176142,
0.3981975913,
-0.7207852006,
0.6057395339,
0.6407725215,
0.3879508972,
0.0538373925,
-0.262218833,
0.037858624,
-0.9222701788,
0.0572910532,
0.4994695783,
-0.8161842823,
0.3334516883,
-0.3747559488,
-0.2835606337,
-0.34665066,
-0.1075767204,
-0.0777456984,
0.2627783418,
0.1151091903,
-0.3111734092,
-0.6197328568,
-0.9467908144,
0.2545673847,
-0.2724527419,
0.1096609235,
0.433585912,
0.4949134886,
-0.4145766199,
0.7622080445,
-0.2901756763,
-0.4446593821,
-0.0877883732,
0.2205574363,
0.0379057154,
0.0999621376,
1.0767233372,
-1.0614427328,
-0.3652660251,
-0.2202492654,
-1.0716490746,
0.1909130365,
-0.1772450954,
-0.3667668402,
0.0247757286,
0.0813676268,
-0.6051838398,
0.0674035326,
0.2350517362,
-0.4018065631,
0.8373872638,
0.4662317038,
0.7735282779,
-1.3076429367,
0.0916201994,
0.3556233644,
-0.0554991663,
-0.5526999831,
0.2987568378,
-0.0108328322,
-0.4949681163,
-0.5143327713,
0.3700856268,
0.1935414821,
0.1094940677,
0.0480893664,
-0.2837017179,
0.0150301624,
0.378200829,
-0.1779766381,
1.1564780474,
0.7097598314,
-0.7439832091,
0.5308700204,
0.0295160953,
-0.0188858118,
1.3412117958,
-0.3378769159,
-0.0364882834,
-0.1107078567,
0.1740975827,
-1.1656045914,
-0.4460787177,
0.456355691,
-0.2282083184,
0.4700037539,
0.2877416611,
-0.135809809,
-0.4778591692,
-0.9225823283,
0.2877052128,
-0.0394648761,
-0.3585200906,
0.8027778268,
0.7412432432,
-0.1083358824,
-0.792011559,
-0.3919556439,
0.41082564,
-0.5412896276,
-0.6153981686,
0.3232371211,
0.0744837672,
-0.4511499405,
0.1243475378,
-0.2850311697,
-0.1199757829,
0.3197431862,
0.3145954013,
-0.0393959358,
-0.5976269245,
-0.0982716456,
-0.0275077652,
-0.0627808124,
0.0949655473,
-0.1016779914,
0.5430884957,
0.0197515171,
-0.6014822125,
-0.470793575,
0.2086283714,
1.0040049553,
-0.0831740573,
0.5192814469,
0.5611895323,
-0.0719217509,
0.0674410984,
-0.4074351192,
-0.0022390396,
-0.4012964666,
0.1753492951,
-0.7534943819,
-0.5552990437,
0.1574148685,
-0.63903898,
0.3343213499,
0.5702955723,
0.2091141045,
-0.3786296844,
0.7083140612,
0.3658234775,
-0.8916869164,
0.3841376901,
-0.3272829652,
0.0749817714,
-0.3838692009,
-0.0310707986,
-0.1477197409,
-0.6218648553,
0.0242346264,
-0.3299077451,
0.2354559749,
0.0195206217,
-0.3549190462,
0.2869693339,
-0.4887337387,
0.1130253598,
0.1718343794,
0.519931078,
-0.1210937947,
0.5173509717,
-0.172901392,
-0.0758951679,
-0.2475565523,
-0.5049151182,
1.2232222557,
0.0785877481,
0.512537241,
0.4325267076,
0.4628753066,
1.0225634575,
0.1259989291,
-0.9172306061,
0.4981792569,
-0.1942353249,
-0.3883957267,
-0.1714194715,
-0.3646739125,
-0.6107985377,
0.0889165327,
-0.1608919948,
0.0631848574,
0.0699071884,
-0.4810906649,
-0.1566564739,
0.5087429285,
-0.3433159292,
0.4602363706,
-0.3805336952,
-0.2597402036,
-0.6738619208,
-0.2263316661,
0.4982396662,
-0.1875126809,
0.1540154666,
-0.2494352311,
-0.0528197438,
0.6752308011,
-0.0218509343,
0.8244506717,
-0.4464766085,
-0.1983541548,
0.4148049355,
-0.0793407336,
0.0228748452,
-0.1136028245,
-0.1740833223,
0.2657162845,
-0.1410279721,
-0.670951128,
-0.4198969901,
0.7058563828,
-0.9716371894,
-0.6772207618,
-0.3403972983,
0.0033693674,
-0.1335506886,
-0.1092336476,
-0.2459042519,
0.5605242848,
-0.7691273689,
0.2380019575,
0.7591407895,
-0.179331556,
0.5067235827,
0.4879919291,
0.0092445174,
-0.5376851559,
1.1170965433,
0.1731292158,
-0.10549777,
0.5459403992,
0.0934002176,
-0.405139029,
0.3640382886,
-0.7093164921,
0.0170028545,
-0.2906470597,
-0.3004739285,
-0.4618404806,
-0.1753035784,
-0.1408450156,
-0.201636821,
-0.0874689296,
-0.6485508084,
0.0028398321,
-0.5361782908,
0.5700808764,
0.7765935659,
-0.3527189791,
0.2399717867,
-0.1869692355,
0.5886700153,
0.0239161123,
0.2594973147,
-0.082146056,
-0.190199092,
0.2567260265,
0.3204428852,
-0.5310311913,
-0.6953376532,
-0.0461751483,
0.3339286447,
0.5022480488,
0.7714415193,
0.2287513167,
0.3554380238,
-0.0545724146,
0.8070020676,
0.1611379087,
-0.3058215976,
0.2653497159,
-0.232031256,
0.190297842,
0.3966063261,
0.79344666,
-0.2026772946,
-0.0420710072,
-0.8232362866,
-0.4083569944,
0.5252796412,
-0.166877687,
0.261816889,
0.0731408894,
-0.0406575203,
0.0000850233,
0.2792272866,
-0.0003066244,
-0.2166210264,
-0.4554553032,
-0.3171885014,
-0.0207921248,
-0.4108524024,
-0.3676998019,
-0.2760489881,
0.7900361419,
0.0429450944,
0.3261831701,
-0.0758897141,
-0.0818507895,
0.0155686317,
0.5012037754,
0.7781419158,
0.6761286259,
-0.115069516,
0.2047397345,
0.0958265066,
-0.5898928642,
0.7328643203,
-0.1357650161,
-0.27218467,
0.1152899861,
-0.0441952981,
0.495089978,
0.2748209834,
-0.4539685249,
0.820017457,
-0.0641719401,
-0.8207858205,
-0.3526200354,
-0.3290506303,
-0.0847798213,
-0.0455504842,
0.3283143342,
0.2772805095,
-0.1577137858,
-0.5871890187,
0.9171227217,
0.5099315643,
-0.5181943774,
-0.4777834713,
0.5240525007,
0.2556195259,
0.0230550319,
-0.095485881,
-0.117420584,
-0.7123293281,
0.719360888,
0.1198726892,
0.8522782922,
-0.2854546905,
0.8025255799,
0.3316649497,
0.3250373304,
0.1216356829,
0.4395444989,
-0.2146220505,
-0.4610903561,
-0.2636016905,
-0.6959730387,
-0.4048900306,
0.4458241463,
-0.3560781181,
0.2997268438,
-0.9833679199,
-0.3866743743,
-0.0482982844,
0.0983760729,
-0.6423152685,
0.2765826881,
0.1425933838,
0.7965031862,
-0.8654766679,
0.3284476101,
1.1960031986,
-0.8561907411,
-0.3683333993,
0.0845648274,
0.4787462056,
-0.707442522,
0.2294765562,
0.1105196923,
-0.2037623525,
-0.3934290111,
-0.7032927275,
-0.6730507016,
0.8617475629,
0.1146311983,
-0.2940525115,
0.4928569496,
0.5850204229,
0.1738006771,
-0.3522363603,
0.404110074,
0.5547416806,
0.5902335644,
0.1194416955,
-0.5625296235,
0.1725633144,
-0.0841556042,
-0.4004089534,
0.2408915013,
-1.0459698439,
0.6716058254,
0.2871985734,
-0.2976254523,
-0.5865104198,
0.396356076,
-0.0462388061,
0.3947061896,
0.4153694808,
0.8383061886,
0.6504125595,
0.0212852359,
0.9134392738,
-0.3987909853,
-0.0035338385,
0.3827380836,
-0.4312053919,
0.5817724466,
-0.1383369416,
-0.3368776739,
0.3289371729,
0.4965505302,
0.066670239,
0.5848249793,
-0.1795451641,
-0.625872016,
0.0800744072,
-0.3425794542,
-0.2800175548,
0.4504104853,
0.4404433966,
-0.0757004395,
-0.5585981607,
0.2747670412,
0.2125013322,
0.0727420747,
-0.4572372139,
1.1392860413,
0.1124455854,
-0.0315046571,
0.6058382392,
0.017454356,
0.9923093319,
-0.5157026649,
0.0254121516,
-0.274081558,
0.1643264741,
-0.3157702386,
-1.1358273029,
0.5219603181,
-0.0208239444,
-0.3229583502,
0.0359560288,
0.7962716222,
-0.1005890071,
-0.5456392169,
0.1786665618,
0.7299363017,
0.155997619,
-0.5025547147,
-1.0950832367,
-0.4021144509,
0.0020448046,
-0.0993644819,
0.5722961426,
0.7478500009,
-0.1838693172,
0.5121350884,
0.469604224,
0.0094798896,
-0.3158357143,
0.1227061152,
0.9163128734,
-0.5949120522,
-0.167812556,
-1.0315103531,
0.2575185001,
-0.6161074638,
-0.2455072552,
0.6864539385,
0.6514134407,
0.7170065045,
0.1418819427,
1.2429505587,
-0.2993939817,
0.6116082072,
-0.0283231009,
0.6869675517,
-0.6208897233,
-0.1889435798,
-0.2082676291,
-0.7993218899,
0.162142694,
0.4872252941,
0.0794410557,
-0.5514255166,
0.2950941026,
0.8808218241,
-0.5705022812,
0.4872762561,
0.4363926351,
0.0470706783,
0.4073631763,
0.0866265446,
0.7757634521,
-0.1012314484,
0.1905632466,
-0.3245293796,
-0.3748120368,
0.1603074521,
-0.4528597593,
-0.9626105428,
-0.4719568789,
-0.014567907,
-0.0962227583,
0.0682295784,
1.1844387054,
0.5425139666,
-1.1572494507,
-0.2742242217,
0.4061642587,
-0.0121156387,
-0.2763973176,
-0.2847183645,
0.1880965233,
-0.2113580853,
-0.1318741143,
0.3006104827,
0.2195462883,
-0.0922070593,
-0.2876480818,
0.1982085109,
-0.5375063419,
0.1684235185,
1.0766046047,
0.3151328266,
-0.478140384,
0.0017488576,
0.0138604362,
-0.2105893195,
0.144156754,
0.6812961698,
-0.5050957799,
0.2182362676,
0.1818737686,
1.1810177565,
0.2458022833,
0.4313979447,
0.8135353923,
-0.801566124,
0.1682184339,
-0.0020807323,
0.2700363398,
0.400917083,
-0.3078911901,
1.031740427,
0.4671932757,
-0.059490487,
-0.4261697233,
0.0511454418,
-0.5703272223,
-0.5974937677,
1.1637089252,
-0.0294042379,
-0.1213566735,
-0.1560163796,
-0.3912415206,
-0.0198518299,
-0.8616440892,
0.6881291866,
0.8891129494,
0.1650367528,
-0.0577414297,
-0.3927999735,
0.3686394989,
0.406378597,
-0.7437530756,
-0.2219839543,
0.4627506435,
0.1211205348,
0.0547080971,
0.6138461828,
0.1682289541,
0.0596454553,
-0.040000502,
-0.3044899106,
-0.0624599122,
-0.6281818748,
-0.075779058,
0.4186414182,
-0.4716004729,
-0.136431694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17906v1 | Byte-Level Grammatical Error Correction Using Synthetic and Curated Corpora | 2023-05-29T06:35:40 | 2023-05-29T06:35:40 | Svanhvít Lilja Ingólfsdóttir, Pétur Orri Ragnarsson, Haukur Páll Jónsson, Haukur Barri Símonarson, Vilhjálmur Þorsteinsson, Vésteinn Snæbjarnarson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grammatical error correction (GEC) is the task of correcting typos, spelling,
punctuation and grammatical issues in text. Approaching the problem as a
sequence-to-sequence task, we compare the use of a common subword unit
vocabulary and byte-level encoding. Initial synthetic training data is created
using an error-generating pipeline, and used for finetuning two subword-level
models and one byte-level model. Models are then finetuned further on
hand-corrected error corpora, including texts written by children, university
students, dyslexic and second-language writers, and evaluated over different
error types and origins. We show that a byte-level model enables higher
correction quality than a subword approach, not only for simple spelling
errors, but also for more complex semantic, stylistic and grammatical issues.
In particular, initial training on synthetic corpora followed by finetuning on
a relatively small parallel corpus of real-world errors helps the byte-level
model correct a wide range of commonly occurring errors. Our experiments are
run for the Icelandic language but should hold for other similar languages,
particularly morphologically rich ones. | [
-0.1118724346,
-1.0924794674,
0.2936564386,
0.0883215442,
0.0002972182,
0.186020121,
-0.0991109088,
-0.4234804809,
-0.0156780537,
0.2428751886,
-0.5519046783,
-0.7075683475,
-0.466329217,
0.4744280279,
-0.504222393,
0.8405288458,
-0.0132028507,
0.3591570556,
-0.4189579189,
0.1221626177,
-0.6170906425,
-0.7189403772,
-0.7827894092,
0.0440422483,
0.6049044132,
0.5955626369,
0.6540547013,
0.4571963251,
0.3639605939,
0.3593416512,
-0.2811593413,
0.5905495882,
-0.4548095763,
-0.0879101455,
-0.4221921861,
-0.6441490054,
-0.4229717851,
-0.2599009871,
0.7203490734,
0.9570028186,
-0.1382864267,
0.0050882907,
0.0331253037,
0.8636285663,
-0.5984880924,
0.0325882062,
-0.4906024337,
0.2408867776,
-0.1636646241,
0.0538538173,
-0.5607512593,
-0.316940397,
-0.2741875052,
-0.7064169645,
0.6909049749,
0.273917377,
0.5714024901,
0.1668182611,
-0.2456583977,
-0.4515129626,
-0.9263367653,
0.4563013315,
-0.7627403736,
0.3868927062,
0.4209189117,
-0.1840088964,
-0.4805026054,
-0.4410891831,
-0.733104229,
-0.1011902541,
-0.3255809844,
0.1538487822,
-0.2067415565,
0.3687236607,
0.380713433,
0.4507349133,
-0.7039572597,
0.0749524832,
-0.7631178498,
-0.3028286099,
0.3282144666,
0.1838547736,
0.5416013598,
-0.1388097405,
0.144419089,
-0.1435386539,
-0.7019130588,
-0.0542905629,
0.8058320284,
0.3189888895,
0.0762220845,
0.6747493744,
-0.2346159965,
0.7493759394,
0.4039983153,
0.0007056167,
0.0406049117,
-0.2829299569,
-0.3149134517,
0.3932875097,
0.3435180783,
0.1665555835,
0.2748389244,
-0.1556505263,
-0.2127145678,
0.4490831494,
0.4757170379,
-0.3341395557,
-0.1453500688,
0.2952796519,
-0.1826450527,
-0.2610999942,
0.035224054,
-0.7290967107,
-0.2749702632,
-0.5989949107,
0.4665674567,
-0.5032103658,
0.0140267164,
0.2349646837,
-0.0577506721,
-0.134218514,
0.1953178197,
-1.2260004282,
0.349448204,
0.6780456305,
0.6590225697,
0.1341647506,
-0.4055339992,
-0.5540736914,
0.0359116904,
-0.7909860611,
0.9844275117,
-0.4680503905,
-0.5242106318,
0.2241479158,
0.0915746763,
-0.1783238947,
-0.6738122702,
0.382140249,
-0.3862015903,
0.3066607416,
-0.1692020297,
-0.7408934832,
0.0160568524,
0.0911761746,
-0.5944441557,
1.2243249416,
0.231762439,
-0.6826696396,
0.3565191031,
-0.342779696,
-0.5675575733,
0.0729691386,
-0.0003727004,
-0.0574355386,
0.3478378654,
0.220511958,
0.3859104812,
0.0270467587,
0.1176694408,
0.1388654262,
-0.482363373,
-0.0046612485,
-0.1846830994,
0.6028034091,
0.0639865994,
-0.1790207028,
0.0503469333,
-1.2268996239,
0.0035796918,
-0.1757137924,
-0.5331647992,
-0.4136144221,
-0.0661078542,
-0.24776043,
0.0428827032,
-0.0179171413,
-0.7206465006,
0.2119835168,
-0.4435642064,
0.4968714118,
0.4897512794,
-0.1083575413,
0.4844166934,
-0.1846312582,
0.5044236183,
0.1534388959,
0.0075255143,
-0.052518025,
-0.335788548,
-0.9305440784,
-0.0828578621,
0.5270919204,
0.9451708198,
-0.8454757333,
0.3530699909,
-0.1606278569,
-0.4748880863,
-0.7086239457,
0.0840780437,
0.7201199532,
0.4956876934,
0.3759326637,
-0.1851276755,
-0.7278602123,
-0.6091034412,
-0.2264583707,
-0.3889043927,
0.0852604881,
-0.0165503696,
0.3932234943,
-0.3312661648,
0.7731740475,
-0.1915795952,
-0.2416835576,
-0.1067323387,
0.4645254016,
-0.1001656875,
0.7370713949,
0.241621837,
-0.4712647796,
-0.2484420687,
0.048329819,
-0.5796002746,
-0.3110176027,
-0.1765183359,
-0.2377468348,
0.7709696889,
0.7337841988,
-0.465682745,
0.2697638869,
0.6213926077,
-0.5340070724,
0.7777713537,
-0.6804632545,
0.3041618466,
-0.9609502554,
-0.1694146246,
-0.248434335,
-0.2276978344,
-0.7286490798,
-0.0068556308,
0.1858346611,
0.022109814,
-0.4667830169,
0.2017953247,
-0.4038868546,
-0.0622623228,
-0.0603903458,
-0.1679781675,
0.0081258891,
0.3187867999,
-0.1821667701,
0.8325274587,
0.2157653272,
-0.4266070127,
0.5546535254,
0.2650693953,
-0.3030219376,
0.7484421134,
-0.5055136085,
0.4477784336,
-0.4510735273,
0.015769586,
-1.0690745115,
-0.4700046778,
0.0918332785,
-0.5294726491,
0.6454598308,
-0.1891515255,
-0.624946177,
-0.332026422,
0.1050502881,
0.4168846309,
0.393761605,
-0.5216193199,
0.4655585587,
0.0790980905,
-0.1993142217,
-0.6399796605,
-0.9235016108,
0.0484713353,
0.2120950967,
-0.8336173892,
0.3421918154,
0.140366897,
-0.1659265161,
0.1980952173,
-0.0810600743,
0.0056864773,
-0.1740909219,
0.1179945543,
0.4269603789,
-0.1790394336,
0.1238776892,
0.1490318626,
-0.0228031892,
-0.1121546552,
-0.5236433148,
0.4622530937,
-0.3120894432,
-0.3400915861,
-0.1238236725,
0.6121220589,
0.4040445685,
0.1305798292,
0.8951654434,
0.4305755496,
-0.6229195595,
-0.2369705737,
-0.7623959184,
0.0388145484,
-0.4288084507,
0.3515991867,
-0.3329962492,
-0.8744405508,
0.5943608284,
0.4076571763,
-0.2672774196,
0.5851754546,
0.4079956114,
-0.3689113855,
0.7482107282,
0.6367322206,
0.1910586953,
0.2506542802,
0.0205006935,
0.2492610961,
-0.5640986562,
-0.3013066351,
-0.6010823846,
-0.2957275808,
-0.7514665127,
-0.2684278488,
0.2067610025,
0.2828609645,
-0.2304140776,
0.505345881,
-0.3509076834,
0.5718607903,
0.8012968302,
0.0775806382,
0.2921913564,
0.3728550076,
-0.4722914398,
-0.0387519263,
-0.8722544312,
-0.5282263756,
0.624392271,
0.0467923954,
0.6996461153,
-0.0331575945,
0.7206471562,
0.414075762,
-0.1801900268,
-0.6865366697,
0.4546342492,
-0.6454511285,
-0.692689538,
-0.265191108,
-0.3892976642,
-0.6129493713,
0.0229568556,
-0.4625510871,
-0.4644277394,
0.4383120239,
0.5413706899,
-0.5206359625,
0.410484314,
-1.0029988289,
1.0488343239,
0.2552102208,
-0.3354488909,
-0.1892074347,
-0.6634197235,
-0.0642318726,
0.085929513,
0.2713708282,
0.2138624936,
0.2071579844,
0.4983704388,
-0.4469642043,
0.9986186624,
-0.0532059148,
-0.133533746,
0.4522007704,
0.3132075369,
0.5591448545,
-0.3657396436,
0.2034259588,
0.2370326817,
0.2360908687,
-0.4308740497,
-0.4343358576,
0.3719574809,
-0.7643504143,
-0.4362874031,
-0.4444863498,
-0.4607111514,
-0.3079379797,
-0.029703619,
0.4999246895,
0.6796793938,
-0.2804528177,
0.104121998,
0.6252259016,
-0.3222980201,
0.1375699341,
0.4075246155,
0.0811395198,
-0.4149080515,
0.737048924,
0.3257135749,
0.4652715921,
0.4325390458,
-0.0222524479,
-0.0477193929,
-0.5924268961,
-0.7405086756,
0.0613861941,
-0.9581114054,
-0.0510372184,
-0.6187567711,
-0.119762294,
-0.6492849588,
-0.33636567,
-0.3658477366,
-0.4457716644,
-0.2376186401,
-0.2390023023,
0.3011321127,
0.5986427665,
-0.3037826419,
0.2728595436,
-1.1329892874,
0.1797806621,
0.137463063,
0.1922912002,
-0.3027739227,
-0.6887208223,
-0.1520828456,
0.0297871139,
0.1469350308,
-0.6732305288,
0.4468824267,
0.187538296,
0.1618558466,
-0.2057214379,
-0.4664663076,
0.8789577484,
-0.8118059635,
0.9880405664,
0.090874292,
-1.0922515392,
0.55988276,
-0.4071792364,
0.2687017322,
0.4612173438,
0.1935978681,
-1.1600334644,
-0.3193002343,
-0.5887515545,
-0.8310608864,
0.6650370359,
0.0773845464,
0.2071492672,
-0.4599523544,
0.6189251542,
0.1225744411,
0.1042580232,
-0.440228045,
0.0483345948,
0.0175023749,
-0.5375059247,
0.1081020162,
-0.6580438018,
0.0702426285,
-0.2005284727,
1.0837506056,
-0.0906137154,
0.2796624601,
0.5180952549,
-0.3332673311,
-0.367194891,
0.4579084516,
0.7444814444,
0.4464834034,
-0.015156745,
0.2659532726,
0.5081220269,
-0.7636649609,
0.2322978079,
-0.1237131432,
-0.2157943696,
0.0286142714,
0.5084767938,
0.6467029452,
0.1776268929,
-0.5273730159,
0.1436712295,
0.2071338594,
-0.1962924004,
-0.3375844657,
-0.0174880307,
0.1756837964,
0.064108938,
0.0888961032,
0.2347447574,
0.0075606429,
-0.681214273,
-0.1391702741,
0.0381910913,
-0.0084183365,
-0.2175973058,
0.4606824815,
0.1105361506,
-0.1910975575,
0.8168053627,
-0.4205569327,
-0.3152550459,
0.6729465127,
0.7986950874,
0.6992340088,
-0.2447129935,
0.2370928079,
0.5441920757,
0.3897407353,
-0.3478778303,
0.3261739314,
0.4667114615,
-0.9218746424,
-0.5766493678,
-0.7943642735,
-0.3306105137,
-0.0537346601,
-0.5605027676,
0.2051363736,
-0.5771016479,
0.1519838274,
0.0849647522,
-0.2787563801,
-0.555256784,
0.3993435204,
0.3699078858,
0.6588426232,
-0.8907814026,
0.5354084373,
1.0039964914,
-0.3743870854,
-0.8381912112,
-0.4376811981,
0.0555829331,
-0.7031069398,
0.7447474003,
-0.0263065584,
-0.229735136,
0.044622954,
-0.3521102071,
-0.7728582621,
0.8183072805,
0.2980980277,
-1.1016622782,
-0.1567822546,
0.5870041251,
0.8899441957,
-0.3040920496,
-0.0726819634,
0.7422264218,
0.2055028677,
0.0627638102,
-0.8205930591,
-0.1544660628,
-0.2223143429,
0.4270685315,
0.254511416,
-0.230762437,
0.7466803789,
0.042685844,
-0.1744982749,
0.0460482351,
0.799121201,
-0.0798649639,
0.0432381928,
0.5213314891,
0.7443960309,
1.0190623999,
-0.2101716399,
1.0173325539,
-0.0629916489,
0.1928403229,
0.9720289707,
0.0102831339,
0.7981746793,
0.370809406,
-0.2704837918,
0.6094666719,
0.6966294646,
-0.0442068279,
0.3001306653,
0.2351462841,
-0.3583981395,
0.0069750352,
0.1896152198,
0.0263649952,
0.1657038033,
0.4952686131,
-0.1758115888,
0.0271121375,
0.1322768629,
0.0860541239,
0.2024596781,
-0.7107400894,
0.8157795668,
-0.1625497192,
-0.8456131816,
0.5878704786,
0.2426874191,
0.6806212068,
-0.2385646552,
0.0171319004,
-0.5009214282,
0.4654183984,
-0.4872874618,
-0.5738977194,
0.6332995296,
0.3515402973,
-0.5085191727,
0.1382061243,
1.0282793045,
-0.7573074102,
-0.7869032621,
0.0329091214,
0.191558674,
0.2473632395,
-0.04306769,
-0.3137413263,
-0.032648392,
-0.2380853593,
0.2442304194,
-0.0164390057,
0.4507282078,
-0.0748250932,
0.1716663837,
0.5866072774,
0.1471384913,
0.5077749491,
0.2649473548,
0.3744346499,
-0.6108974814,
-0.425536871,
-0.8210403323,
0.5305440426,
0.1288095415,
-0.2998702824,
0.3590766191,
0.4057754278,
1.4397525787,
-0.5371488333,
0.7690582871,
-0.1749503911,
0.3293886483,
-0.8256521821,
0.2037244141,
-0.1847370118,
-0.0509901643,
-0.0968638808,
-0.999642849,
-0.398982197,
0.6817517281,
-0.1905753314,
-0.1377384365,
0.9593678713,
0.9819444418,
-0.0555772185,
0.2028054297,
0.3670096397,
0.355945617,
-0.0697185323,
0.3840206563,
0.8389126658,
-0.3987716138,
0.3767428994,
-0.3166826963,
-0.1441065669,
-0.1176108569,
-0.7868353128,
-0.8303797245,
-0.4493961632,
-0.4136406779,
-0.6588351727,
0.6337250471,
1.3499543667,
0.363012135,
-1.1038734913,
0.0758373886,
-0.4935642779,
-0.3073862493,
-0.3899081349,
-0.1837709248,
0.2630311847,
-0.7714782357,
-0.9430841208,
0.368160367,
0.1118987724,
0.2104115039,
-0.1826699823,
0.1949769258,
-0.0740855932,
0.1940173209,
0.6205225587,
0.1891543865,
-0.5405558944,
-0.585234642,
0.0795781985,
-0.3807076216,
0.1174280867,
0.7913694978,
-0.5391068459,
0.4745286107,
0.7270271778,
0.7295103073,
0.3135744035,
-0.1719468832,
0.493311733,
-1.0237007141,
0.1759046167,
-0.0420319885,
0.4630440474,
0.6048021317,
-0.6721740365,
0.6179834008,
0.5903983116,
-0.4702192843,
-0.5016699433,
-0.0538191423,
-0.8588412404,
-0.1806005836,
1.3081064224,
-0.1783472598,
-0.3933998048,
0.1013705507,
-0.5224647522,
0.4917907715,
-0.0562485829,
0.7569898963,
1.2887775898,
0.285580337,
0.2730376422,
-0.6204292178,
0.617554307,
0.682281971,
-0.6909244061,
0.0093342876,
0.8495092392,
0.4142891467,
0.3049509823,
0.2112289369,
-0.2540701032,
0.4468019009,
0.3502872884,
0.253906548,
-0.0561514646,
-0.5938975811,
-0.4644850791,
-0.069274202,
-0.2021233886,
-0.140903607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17888v1 | LLM-QAT: Data-Free Quantization Aware Training for Large Language Models | 2023-05-29T05:22:11 | 2023-05-29T05:22:11 | Zechun Liu, Barlas Oguz, Changsheng Zhao, Ernie Chang, Pierre Stock, Yashar Mehdad, Yangyang Shi, Raghuraman Krishnamoorthi, Vikas Chandra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Several post-training quantization methods have been applied to large
language models (LLMs), and have been shown to perform well down to 8-bits. We
find that these methods break down at lower bit precision, and investigate
quantization aware training for LLMs (LLM-QAT) to push quantization levels even
further. We propose a data-free distillation method that leverages generations
produced by the pre-trained model, which better preserves the original output
distribution and allows quantizing any generative model independent of its
training data, similar to post-training quantization methods. In addition to
quantizing weights and activations, we also quantize the KV cache, which is
critical for increasing throughput and support long sequence dependencies at
current model sizes. We experiment with LLaMA models of sizes 7B, 13B, and 30B,
at quantization levels down to 4-bits. We observe large improvements over
training-free methods, especially in the low-bit settings. | [
-0.2275161445,
-0.4834286273,
0.6463122368,
0.0520469993,
-0.6340987086,
0.166299805,
-0.1717356443,
-0.1006076038,
0.0058534308,
0.4642160833,
-0.3151159286,
-0.3990409076,
-0.6701030135,
0.0279381424,
-0.6481965184,
0.7711905241,
0.0635267645,
0.0885679722,
-0.2514885068,
0.0993833467,
-0.2509474456,
-0.7179269791,
-0.5912713408,
-0.1434690952,
0.4123818576,
0.3228962421,
0.5757732391,
0.8841484785,
0.4174253345,
0.2073116153,
-0.2159496546,
-0.1170838103,
-0.546933949,
0.2530234754,
0.2851158381,
-0.8195447326,
-0.6482279897,
-0.1198227778,
0.8065692782,
0.5120496154,
-0.3160477579,
0.2997205853,
-0.0789566189,
1.0212374926,
-0.6322637796,
0.0224920735,
-0.8749964833,
0.0371608473,
-0.2499267608,
-0.0328396149,
-0.4268538654,
-0.5419539809,
-0.1620836854,
-0.59382689,
0.3891266286,
-0.0647343919,
0.7026292086,
0.4367066622,
-0.7002139688,
0.0257732794,
-0.9832422733,
0.8414001465,
-0.7828288674,
0.4735541344,
0.6749558449,
0.2704820037,
0.0655806065,
-0.8038277626,
-0.5455064774,
-0.2636849284,
0.3014357388,
-0.0866176933,
-0.3024495542,
0.278752923,
0.4894724786,
0.9724811912,
-0.6495018005,
0.0052567665,
-0.214477852,
-0.0226770137,
0.4071908891,
0.036265675,
-0.1083886549,
0.273923099,
-0.1624880433,
-0.1819655448,
-1.1621932983,
-0.338996768,
0.279501617,
0.0147741353,
0.0102787009,
0.5886025429,
-0.6058477759,
0.4612421989,
0.1434262693,
-0.040115416,
0.0970931798,
-0.2973089218,
-0.4216605723,
-0.0040329122,
0.6612176299,
-0.1359764785,
0.2277530134,
0.0519983023,
-0.4533240199,
0.1095619723,
-0.1103115678,
-1.2915325165,
-0.5641031265,
0.1565855145,
-0.3480116427,
-0.279075861,
-0.3380117118,
-0.4598655403,
-0.3466528356,
-0.3409381211,
0.6458978057,
-0.3537638485,
-0.3103432357,
0.2571271658,
0.0202237498,
0.2676425874,
0.2706568241,
-1.0939054489,
0.1517969817,
0.4050445557,
0.7434281707,
0.4509857893,
0.1600037664,
-0.8290565014,
0.1411838979,
-0.3731777072,
0.4876163304,
-0.3807566464,
-0.3595426381,
-0.16930978,
-0.3116213083,
0.3526206613,
-0.7812860608,
0.0658558235,
-0.8420509696,
-0.2488316596,
-0.2735188007,
-0.8033861518,
-0.0769754574,
0.0375190414,
-0.9497187734,
0.9651043415,
0.0918953493,
-0.5642672181,
0.4428068995,
-0.2660274804,
-0.1837441027,
0.1218806505,
0.0689457208,
-0.6364397407,
0.546261251,
0.4205160439,
0.3180112541,
-0.4353157878,
0.3391419053,
-0.4333935976,
-0.3651699126,
0.183278963,
-0.8436276913,
0.8166832328,
0.1402990967,
-0.2326591909,
0.0809678882,
-1.0326846838,
0.0508962274,
0.1854616404,
-0.4521309137,
-0.311039716,
-0.1370805651,
-0.4529801309,
0.0304711144,
0.3838198483,
-0.4569582641,
0.5295149684,
-0.2671783864,
0.682795465,
0.7117112875,
-0.0853278115,
0.3920257688,
-0.1940935403,
0.6591129899,
0.1014141589,
0.24037458,
-0.0610569231,
-0.1795662493,
-1.0738682747,
-0.5765023232,
0.7028136253,
0.4022125304,
-1.059499383,
0.4718314111,
-0.5334198475,
-0.5015893579,
-0.6410814524,
0.2043531388,
0.2648594081,
-0.0078857038,
0.1753680706,
-0.3024044037,
-0.5421099067,
-0.7429969907,
0.247694537,
-0.1810136884,
-0.2425064594,
-0.3874485195,
0.5410875678,
-0.0591422506,
0.8490011096,
-0.4301391244,
-0.060365431,
-0.2214234322,
0.1699323803,
-0.0392658003,
0.4337084293,
0.1473229527,
-0.5597725511,
-0.3973406553,
-0.0771885961,
-0.5386536121,
-0.090076074,
0.2065794319,
-0.0621079803,
0.072625421,
0.5087623,
-0.4622137249,
0.3646282554,
0.8398616314,
-0.0553575605,
0.4599649012,
-0.1997279376,
0.000461791,
-1.2222892046,
-0.1205295399,
-0.1655022353,
-0.5658954382,
-0.7564488649,
-0.1724105477,
0.2484493107,
0.0246781874,
-0.5577594042,
0.3157728314,
-0.4506525993,
-0.1340553761,
-0.3011841774,
-0.1702108979,
0.2064107955,
0.311599344,
0.0897570327,
0.9320084453,
0.5017644167,
-0.510496676,
0.3771468997,
0.1578165591,
-0.5416837931,
0.3024790585,
-0.6217989326,
0.3460477889,
-0.0780460536,
0.2266146541,
-0.8160864711,
0.0475968122,
-0.2399798632,
-0.3309372067,
0.1381337345,
-0.3932018876,
-0.7869958282,
-0.0934813991,
-0.4629094899,
0.7475836873,
0.7893599868,
-0.5718647838,
0.4009513557,
0.0631021112,
-0.0000185554,
-0.3311728537,
-0.5940166116,
-0.1155851781,
-0.6457305551,
-0.3171393871,
0.1625991911,
-0.2088242918,
-0.0530678444,
-0.2506579757,
-0.124189429,
-0.3439159989,
0.1887459755,
0.0839846879,
0.140030995,
-0.1548603326,
0.2313293815,
0.1139173284,
-0.13889575,
-0.1620937884,
-0.4938554764,
0.8131663799,
-0.1957709938,
-0.1545495689,
-0.5447514057,
0.0949268043,
0.3493041992,
-0.5548282266,
0.6979320049,
0.5215100646,
-0.4387077689,
-0.0767683834,
-0.4528652728,
-0.1739834547,
-0.5216693282,
0.2980954647,
-0.4429829121,
-1.269716382,
0.4723632932,
-0.131206125,
-0.1709522456,
0.3435873389,
0.7449399233,
0.0066876421,
1.054095149,
0.6979528069,
-0.0690091997,
0.6717691422,
-0.4267610013,
0.1185555756,
-0.7266577482,
0.2090112716,
-0.3836682439,
-0.1874651909,
-0.4423316121,
-0.4919106066,
0.3359518349,
0.5244084597,
-0.3855864108,
0.1796167493,
-0.2223647535,
0.6796733737,
0.8006365299,
-0.0081303893,
0.5301247239,
0.0973478034,
0.3492534161,
0.0943829045,
-0.5888175368,
-0.3230732083,
1.4255369902,
0.1853316575,
0.8237104416,
0.0235046614,
0.9164760709,
0.2620537579,
0.3166019022,
-0.8549218178,
0.4766605794,
-0.3447141051,
-0.4038655758,
-0.4131575823,
-0.6930891275,
-0.8545827866,
0.1370809525,
0.0177814234,
-0.4190550447,
0.1130540967,
0.4197379649,
-0.5337095857,
0.4561365247,
-0.5299161077,
0.5965289474,
-0.1332335919,
0.1556497514,
-0.2282616347,
-0.4564747214,
0.5070480704,
-0.323672086,
-0.0473722331,
-0.3267702758,
0.0944981501,
0.6848224998,
-0.6172208786,
0.7857860923,
-0.2264675051,
-0.4432380199,
0.4494462311,
0.2782746553,
0.5322146416,
-0.0574245416,
0.2598133087,
0.2330674678,
0.2242818326,
-0.517546773,
-0.5538263321,
0.3372328579,
-0.7288685441,
-0.6269862652,
-0.0945721269,
-0.5469897985,
-0.1947422475,
0.010796818,
0.1972482949,
0.298530817,
0.0761642531,
0.484657526,
1.0145168304,
-0.1235831976,
0.2646074891,
0.3054507077,
-0.251832962,
-0.6762012839,
0.9914391041,
0.1033366174,
0.6976866722,
0.6905578375,
0.2560119033,
-0.321496278,
-0.8750752807,
-0.3214302361,
0.1165106744,
-0.58368963,
-0.5006945729,
-0.3204446435,
-0.2741575241,
-0.3571046293,
0.2366020828,
-0.60236305,
-0.7474957705,
-0.2743615508,
-0.1980173588,
0.65808779,
0.4545739293,
-0.147766456,
0.8752728701,
-1.0365194082,
0.3230212927,
0.5854533911,
0.2285665423,
-0.036250446,
-0.7493510246,
-0.540207088,
0.1673225909,
-0.2668091655,
-0.6015250087,
0.4818911552,
0.3933730125,
-0.0783846602,
0.3346874118,
-0.0076532126,
0.6423695087,
-0.4151293337,
0.7425990105,
0.0459986255,
-1.3159121275,
0.5708367229,
-0.2156696022,
0.3414620459,
0.5395597219,
0.3114997149,
-0.4244189858,
-0.2724303603,
-0.3329868317,
-0.8516873717,
0.282076627,
0.070428133,
0.1289146394,
0.0220453218,
0.3862814307,
0.2242178023,
0.4808784127,
-0.9490389228,
-0.0155034531,
-0.0204297472,
-0.3443793356,
0.1197642013,
-0.4388826787,
0.1369247139,
-0.31443277,
0.7015174627,
-0.0983129963,
0.1211747527,
-0.0978659242,
-0.2963012457,
-0.0308209248,
0.3200585842,
0.3279420137,
0.4187332094,
-0.2125079036,
0.2300420851,
0.1209935769,
-0.5833842158,
0.6062829494,
-0.0445449315,
-0.2128658444,
-0.33594805,
0.0415449142,
1.0556261539,
-0.2220700383,
-0.6536276937,
0.4724164605,
-0.1889451295,
-0.4676299691,
-0.2548071444,
-0.0713143498,
0.1492308229,
0.4848538935,
0.1538720578,
-0.6690371037,
0.0574991144,
-0.2078859508,
0.1319452971,
0.4233976305,
-0.0017276048,
-0.4457216561,
0.8184372783,
-0.0940188468,
0.1610117555,
0.9490882158,
-0.3784090579,
-0.2172970623,
0.50235039,
0.3689067364,
0.9715734124,
-0.3436065316,
0.1523450166,
0.1518812031,
0.2612154782,
-0.2753216624,
0.3649438918,
-0.1589452177,
-0.7240094543,
-0.7514569163,
-0.9080989361,
-0.2284616977,
0.4537855685,
-0.7192538977,
0.0975590199,
-0.4277105331,
-0.1822426915,
-0.2302270383,
0.0124837821,
-0.6548200846,
0.3439749777,
0.2785577774,
0.6375865936,
-0.8040873408,
1.3619071245,
0.2223231643,
-0.2888816297,
-0.6519767046,
-0.101976648,
-0.2294554114,
-0.8781489134,
0.7133362293,
0.0797634348,
0.05888284,
0.4356640577,
-0.5943421721,
-1.1394644976,
1.3743978739,
0.6841599345,
-1.050262928,
-0.0907657817,
0.4462582767,
0.4203273952,
0.0805165991,
-0.0513374843,
0.7885417342,
0.0739957765,
0.1321851164,
-0.8261344433,
-0.1023795158,
-0.0394036509,
0.348567158,
0.5342788696,
-0.6384323835,
0.9178791046,
0.0910823345,
-0.2193016559,
0.3529118896,
0.9364745617,
0.3853171766,
-0.0311801266,
0.5441302061,
0.8561664224,
0.7709189653,
-0.1037768051,
0.8639599085,
-0.2491090447,
0.3928479254,
0.9845172763,
-0.3377725184,
0.9771242142,
0.602766335,
-0.4803547859,
0.1607355326,
0.6438179612,
0.217758581,
0.7010195255,
0.6091060042,
-0.6565150619,
-0.3023531139,
0.1204298586,
-0.2254379392,
0.2076156437,
0.2703390121,
-0.1183336973,
-0.0584883988,
0.118883878,
-0.0433392972,
-0.3568821251,
-0.4391832948,
0.8255575895,
0.2261763215,
-0.1183401346,
1.02331388,
-0.1708103269,
0.592874527,
-0.6145816445,
0.0320170596,
-0.4966576099,
0.0752653629,
0.1007795781,
-0.3289552033,
0.1061675996,
0.1501298994,
-0.2113274187,
-0.0989390463,
0.4013748467,
-0.6748223901,
-0.545183897,
-0.1064857692,
0.6192312241,
0.1602830142,
-0.4836634994,
-0.246736601,
0.090286158,
0.0360095352,
-0.4809260368,
0.5992336273,
0.6570008397,
-0.1791522503,
0.6150598526,
0.5332096815,
0.1683652848,
0.4861634374,
0.237223506,
0.7973572016,
-0.7240602374,
-0.1557273716,
-0.9674898982,
0.3855589628,
0.4025324285,
0.0247902144,
0.4203234315,
0.5968483686,
1.0556111336,
-0.059285745,
0.8460162282,
0.1278173625,
0.1057539657,
-0.8078241944,
0.4402461946,
-0.5578333139,
0.2144086957,
0.3256537318,
-1.1612173319,
-0.340531528,
0.4638643265,
-0.2994583547,
0.1417108774,
0.5542901754,
0.6984419227,
0.1443952769,
-0.1452485323,
0.621216774,
0.1273871809,
0.5750256777,
0.7505393028,
0.9910393357,
-0.3648746908,
0.5554072261,
-0.4480622411,
-0.2369387746,
-0.0237424504,
-0.9513660669,
-0.7258836031,
-0.5323924422,
-0.349762857,
-0.0579595789,
0.0439777412,
0.7704253793,
0.6092851162,
-0.6004037857,
-0.2337624133,
-0.258767426,
-0.4059034884,
-0.0804088116,
-0.1476552784,
0.4454567134,
-0.1590442359,
-0.71650213,
0.3932469785,
0.213477686,
0.5035851002,
-0.388902396,
0.092541188,
0.1093179435,
0.1233255193,
0.7012066245,
0.0578793809,
-0.4505160451,
-0.1884075403,
-0.1803892404,
0.0570653416,
0.3476313949,
0.9055222273,
-0.823770225,
0.29562971,
0.3631360233,
0.6551371813,
0.8138862848,
-0.0171282813,
0.4849478304,
-0.9493735433,
0.2651247084,
0.2602615952,
0.2986272573,
0.3507091999,
-0.1406473368,
0.2983708978,
0.1855926514,
-0.6736508608,
-0.9332709908,
0.336755991,
-0.7963893414,
-0.0304527134,
1.0711555481,
-0.1332633495,
-0.156476289,
0.3923524022,
-0.0103088394,
0.5708064437,
-0.2229525894,
0.8183104396,
0.6129659414,
0.1964499056,
-0.2651322484,
-0.6630559564,
0.6239997745,
0.4778913558,
-0.8952981234,
0.4409820139,
0.5138019919,
0.3171258271,
-0.3884004951,
0.9003452063,
-0.1564370096,
0.0094255619,
0.0461649224,
0.3526492119,
0.1179842278,
-0.3832268119,
-0.6734157205,
-0.1221745536,
0.6030849218,
-0.1632026583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17878v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17878v1 | Ask an Expert: Leveraging Language Models to Improve Strategic Reasoning in Goal-Oriented Dialogue Models | 2023-05-29T04:19:35 | 2023-05-29T04:19:35 | Qiang Zhang, Jason Naradowsky, Yusuke Miyao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Existing dialogue models may encounter scenarios which are not
well-represented in the training data, and as a result generate responses that
are unnatural, inappropriate, or unhelpful. We propose the "Ask an Expert"
framework in which the model is trained with access to an "expert" which it can
consult at each turn. Advice is solicited via a structured dialogue with the
expert, and the model is optimized to selectively utilize (or ignore) it given
the context and dialogue history. In this work the expert takes the form of an
LLM. We evaluate this framework in a mental health support domain, where the
structure of the expert conversation is outlined by pre-specified prompts which
reflect a reasoning strategy taught to practitioners in the field. Blenderbot
models utilizing "Ask an Expert" show quality improvements across all expert
sizes, including those with fewer parameters than the dialogue model itself.
Our best model provides a $\sim 10\%$ improvement over baselines, approaching
human-level scores on "engingingness" and "helpfulness" metrics. | [
-0.4152569175,
-0.982581377,
0.9926093817,
-0.1175535992,
0.0097933421,
0.1187831014,
-0.1248174608,
-0.3395825028,
0.0490966812,
0.6938867569,
-0.841249764,
-0.429387033,
-0.6373273134,
0.0145715307,
0.0295958519,
0.5701075196,
0.1005639136,
0.4292114973,
-0.1304573268,
-0.0017096035,
-0.6765899062,
-0.3144593835,
-1.2975320816,
-0.3495337367,
0.4006785154,
0.6307159662,
0.9698802233,
0.221287027,
0.4821252525,
0.3759754002,
0.0238898043,
0.3722141087,
-0.4787688553,
0.2936432362,
-0.4416841269,
-0.5106347203,
-0.6217775941,
0.0803115144,
0.0100934813,
0.8338345885,
-0.4437697232,
-0.0552811027,
-0.3196663558,
0.2902163267,
-0.3656065464,
0.2407114655,
-0.7830824256,
0.0467657596,
0.4042537808,
-0.278044194,
-0.2890369892,
-0.169466421,
0.5695841908,
-0.7870761156,
0.0097121969,
0.0979946032,
0.6341615319,
0.447987169,
-0.2585766912,
-0.0760062858,
-0.8389187455,
0.6086078286,
-0.970597744,
0.2526953518,
0.4725078344,
0.390702635,
-0.4193660319,
-0.3973578513,
-0.3660485446,
-0.1083293259,
0.0505616814,
0.1684044898,
-0.5833510756,
0.3865938485,
0.3272913396,
-0.2844256759,
-0.3522446454,
-0.0378884971,
-0.0740471184,
0.0371360071,
1.0408399105,
0.1890878975,
0.0794172138,
0.0629237816,
-0.2622011006,
0.2137280852,
-0.2830926478,
-0.0116650257,
0.1182549968,
0.0144395707,
0.2894617319,
0.3847697973,
-0.2943627536,
0.7530306578,
0.5138790607,
-0.1508917511,
-0.2289844751,
-0.1129735261,
-0.0509515405,
-0.0207067672,
0.4663466215,
0.7931390405,
0.4308215678,
-0.0702922717,
-0.2449217737,
-0.2321084589,
0.658795774,
-0.5291540027,
-0.37756899,
0.1492900401,
-0.5322182178,
0.0557476841,
-0.2291943431,
-0.5902029276,
-0.6739380956,
-0.5720756054,
0.381342411,
-0.3984401822,
-0.4090206623,
0.3629014194,
-0.2139319181,
0.1516410261,
0.4693561196,
-0.6683867574,
0.3211980462,
0.5073983073,
0.4591497779,
-0.0543032624,
0.1934126914,
-0.3224138618,
0.3004175723,
-0.4197314084,
1.0408066511,
-0.6900141835,
-0.7943570614,
-0.0970460251,
-0.2356304079,
-0.1891017258,
-0.7501924038,
0.4597081542,
-0.1493999064,
0.3974342346,
-0.27298823,
-0.5247473717,
-0.2546080351,
0.3724464178,
-0.1003059894,
0.8293354511,
0.2275343686,
-0.4561822414,
0.2939845622,
-0.7649059296,
-0.2278162837,
0.411178261,
-0.4619409442,
0.0067720395,
0.2252224684,
0.6147326231,
0.3882014751,
-0.55268538,
0.5650866628,
-0.5003876686,
-0.0527380221,
0.4139298797,
-0.5106111765,
0.4573424757,
0.2494156808,
-0.2741097212,
0.2200091183,
-0.5311928391,
0.1887537241,
0.2949425876,
-0.1301881373,
-0.3863249123,
0.2144470513,
-0.3938405216,
0.117459178,
0.0962710828,
-0.3947081268,
0.1726666987,
-0.5114420056,
0.3291985095,
0.6740586758,
0.5052297711,
0.394400686,
-0.6627489328,
0.6927860975,
-0.2528370321,
0.3949228525,
0.0332600102,
-0.7256481051,
-0.7126374245,
-0.2211987823,
-0.2139672041,
0.7322365046,
-0.8128110766,
0.2523284256,
0.0160517767,
-0.4056819677,
-0.72530514,
0.0570620932,
0.1716252267,
0.9669776559,
0.3389849663,
-0.5257232785,
-0.5342169404,
-1.0533978939,
-0.4294849336,
-0.5060065985,
0.0177335721,
0.5185592771,
0.2765640914,
-0.2804255486,
1.3807083368,
-0.7518960238,
0.1500631869,
-0.484025985,
0.0913315937,
0.0615308322,
0.2843879759,
0.3766433895,
-0.7393777966,
-0.4898578823,
-0.2434685379,
-0.7147260904,
-0.2251775861,
-0.124542892,
-0.3566305935,
-0.0625492483,
0.3861789405,
-0.7991840839,
0.3960272968,
0.2547557056,
-0.2562803626,
0.5772858858,
-0.3023596406,
0.1511886716,
-1.0342003107,
-0.0141064543,
0.0882403255,
-0.1996926367,
-1.0181542635,
-0.1300016493,
-0.5973923206,
-0.2831290662,
-0.2122269124,
0.6027364135,
0.0750414878,
0.315518409,
-0.267354697,
0.0667833164,
-0.1646695286,
0.4753928185,
0.3908649385,
0.7020626664,
0.4662748575,
-0.3719995022,
0.3730641901,
0.2892678976,
-0.2973500788,
1.1767578125,
-0.8101892471,
0.2676629722,
-0.1247603446,
0.1956006885,
-0.9902655482,
-0.3071106076,
0.482370764,
-0.4365386665,
0.2049386352,
-0.0879786536,
-0.1280316114,
-0.4082241654,
0.2039111853,
0.1246697083,
0.2673273385,
-0.0776326284,
0.7485678792,
0.6628909111,
-0.5744380951,
-0.4233874679,
-0.356010884,
0.2332945615,
-0.2799146771,
-0.7182878852,
0.0754981861,
-0.4823336601,
-0.5085482001,
0.0104091028,
-0.3088594973,
-0.372446835,
0.2398233861,
-0.0283753444,
0.1650384665,
-0.1630166024,
0.1344013065,
0.0742715076,
-0.4131655097,
0.580455184,
-0.4584687948,
0.3123888969,
-0.1820704341,
-0.4780735373,
-0.4358037412,
0.7710353732,
0.3326503336,
-0.177371487,
0.4400849342,
0.2388701141,
-0.4626444876,
-0.1099559218,
-0.7928003669,
-0.4824008644,
-0.50663203,
0.5570526123,
-0.2780406475,
-0.6206334233,
0.2313034683,
-0.4173313975,
0.1101947576,
0.1532793641,
0.4610238373,
-0.3505186141,
1.7410701513,
0.5305557251,
0.0818860978,
0.2786958218,
-0.2222260833,
0.5224797726,
-0.2555351555,
-0.3996154666,
-0.1918860376,
0.0003947961,
0.0391275547,
-0.5415312648,
0.5812092423,
-0.0649029613,
-0.3425604105,
0.1847805083,
-0.4852500856,
0.2271217853,
0.5042910576,
0.3358515501,
0.1441769451,
-0.1809595227,
-0.2848568857,
-0.1091177016,
-1.0908721685,
-0.5773705244,
0.6046105027,
0.5647423863,
0.7169131637,
0.0517663658,
0.6169552803,
0.1953299344,
0.1987163275,
-1.0213444233,
0.8327375054,
0.5194936395,
-0.814643383,
-0.3465259373,
-0.4051845372,
-0.6575897336,
0.2251861989,
-0.361882925,
-0.7289206982,
0.2560476661,
0.2513980269,
-0.5255307555,
0.2886196077,
-0.6808690429,
0.874591887,
-0.5600430965,
-0.0841058195,
-0.4329267442,
-0.563024044,
-0.0808221251,
0.0059756883,
0.437292546,
-0.3662377,
-0.0682604685,
0.60065943,
-0.4154013395,
0.8213655949,
-0.3396843672,
-0.0993094221,
0.3177263141,
0.2360012829,
0.4766084552,
0.0220353492,
-0.0986995399,
-0.2378079891,
-0.0052498109,
-0.3788748384,
-1.1171066761,
0.0855364725,
-0.7833812237,
-1.2793899775,
-0.0640412122,
-0.7516859174,
-0.7414762378,
0.1209004894,
0.0452545099,
0.4266399145,
-0.2663019896,
-0.1223626956,
0.8383077383,
-0.0695051923,
0.01226795,
0.8382264972,
0.230873242,
-0.1824864745,
0.6180066466,
-0.1003314778,
0.3339904249,
0.2997254431,
0.3511419296,
-0.3394462466,
-0.6196588874,
-0.2239925414,
0.1952132583,
-1.0069633722,
-0.1939231008,
-0.5733447075,
-0.1023191735,
-0.3459613025,
-0.3291690052,
-0.3686341345,
-0.3183989227,
-0.1849711835,
-0.2535683513,
0.3959302902,
0.75090307,
0.0551977083,
0.3771258295,
-0.5730453134,
-0.1041866019,
0.3713956177,
0.0202077013,
0.0668734759,
-0.4737437665,
-0.2613767087,
0.080138959,
-0.3576465547,
-1.209002614,
0.4412798882,
0.0427123234,
1.1976441145,
0.6323291063,
0.3153629601,
0.6123813391,
-0.427608043,
0.6301823258,
0.2390137315,
-0.7365809679,
0.6923690438,
-0.5815278292,
0.3913980126,
0.644705236,
0.7373572588,
-0.5046640635,
-0.7198691964,
-0.7010581493,
-0.7021033764,
0.5989655852,
-0.212548852,
0.0925239399,
-0.0444402546,
0.3839347363,
-0.0806834251,
0.2485171109,
-0.3583711386,
-0.257812053,
-0.0739167407,
-0.2592149675,
0.001171643,
-0.1335176229,
-0.5941871405,
-0.356464684,
0.5499392152,
-0.3448499441,
0.4938971996,
0.3236502111,
0.1275217682,
-0.3300956786,
0.3247059286,
0.2735950947,
0.8793647885,
-0.0008455204,
-0.0462197922,
0.7430557013,
-0.0337682888,
-0.0156167354,
0.1326451004,
-0.092303589,
-0.1049690917,
0.2502605319,
0.7814742923,
0.4935293794,
-0.8413562775,
0.2483334094,
-0.0776647851,
-0.399925679,
-0.0651508272,
0.3369679153,
0.0921353847,
0.5181177855,
0.4116003215,
0.0808995888,
0.2723153234,
-0.4387325048,
0.2436546236,
0.4811151922,
-0.5749340057,
0.0605949908,
0.5290551782,
0.3879832625,
-0.7551165223,
0.4194204807,
0.1172152162,
-0.7058266997,
0.362470746,
0.4083937109,
0.6358081698,
-0.332385689,
0.5587520003,
0.0628599152,
0.0982272178,
0.0569989197,
0.3502530754,
-0.0333997458,
-0.7754412293,
-0.212939769,
-0.01143899,
-0.883857131,
-0.0411931835,
-0.6205854416,
0.0649139509,
-0.4865196943,
-0.5375990868,
-0.0392938629,
0.1372286379,
-0.7397913337,
0.25188151,
0.0753358677,
0.9953764677,
-0.5896870494,
0.4784887731,
0.9142507315,
-0.2834655344,
-0.9302705526,
-0.0623129904,
0.2075845003,
-0.8165943623,
0.2960672379,
-0.0321208909,
-0.2376140952,
0.027211247,
-0.5889160633,
-0.8579730392,
0.9337004423,
0.5704817772,
-0.4513844848,
-0.1525433958,
0.0613035783,
0.5280771852,
-0.7742947936,
0.650135994,
0.7113393545,
0.5384126306,
0.1550727338,
-0.7902039886,
-0.0031736779,
-0.2575415075,
-0.1244909391,
-0.2511301637,
-0.4436443448,
0.2876686156,
-0.5240139961,
0.0260266531,
0.1231988743,
0.5491001606,
0.2069182247,
0.2679546773,
0.7840331197,
0.2002829164,
1.1218155622,
0.1183695048,
1.0524172783,
-0.412789613,
0.0021353618,
0.9983680844,
-0.172381863,
0.7675464153,
0.2108357251,
0.1693814993,
0.6945443153,
0.7570205927,
-0.0072801262,
0.52862674,
-0.02616865,
-0.4208225608,
-0.7260525227,
-0.3156759441,
-0.1050597951,
0.3935855031,
0.6320765018,
-0.213655591,
-0.2463904172,
-0.0987889096,
0.1945639551,
0.2868532538,
-0.1921884865,
0.8839457631,
0.2342576087,
-0.9235229492,
0.3993587196,
0.2054769099,
0.1817709357,
-0.6556700468,
0.0767484382,
-0.1806139052,
0.24328731,
-0.0283465069,
-0.6241039038,
0.0861620009,
-0.0496376492,
-0.243610248,
-0.3012650311,
0.7878451347,
-0.4727165103,
-0.447655648,
0.3214329779,
0.7807721496,
0.153378576,
0.0655156299,
-1.3514178991,
-0.3524030149,
-0.2970013618,
-0.2343857437,
0.1077273712,
0.2118621916,
-0.0203247312,
0.9995992184,
0.4517561793,
0.1605313867,
-0.3195913732,
0.1418987811,
0.840308845,
-0.3565970063,
-0.3236684799,
-0.4445939958,
0.4302112758,
-0.1856237203,
-0.3253137171,
0.799071908,
0.1515707672,
0.7904553413,
0.1142956093,
0.8284946084,
0.2553342879,
0.520934999,
-0.2475926578,
0.5652323365,
-0.5461442471,
0.1577707678,
-0.2230918556,
-0.5971449614,
-0.0243227948,
0.9758968949,
-0.7450279593,
0.1890070587,
0.5040448904,
0.9647490978,
0.1927967668,
0.3189561963,
0.2112660408,
0.2235905975,
0.5885355473,
0.6657258272,
1.0844861269,
0.2429626435,
0.3010873795,
-0.1865641922,
-0.3782338798,
-0.0134447077,
-0.7516376972,
-1.0118926764,
-0.2180658877,
-0.3653196096,
-0.0506571606,
0.4381499588,
1.4018120766,
0.970133841,
-0.6290207505,
-0.4049273431,
0.062119931,
0.0939760655,
-0.1945718527,
-0.1735080332,
-0.1461236626,
-0.4146147072,
-0.5153553486,
0.7240032554,
0.1221314669,
-0.0472287573,
-0.3422470689,
-0.2721547186,
-0.0914321169,
0.6017073989,
0.4134241343,
0.2211519331,
-0.7265631557,
-0.4032348692,
0.1754140258,
0.1200101525,
0.0210304409,
0.8857983351,
-0.5758159757,
0.7586627007,
0.1405436993,
0.8091971278,
0.1427834183,
0.1646121889,
1.1235966682,
-0.3792150617,
-0.1488404721,
0.4672023952,
0.2022265196,
0.3178211749,
-0.486502856,
0.3862113059,
0.3018684387,
-0.5265809298,
-0.4895748198,
0.2974595726,
-0.7251114249,
-0.4907649159,
1.1182166338,
-0.3734644055,
0.2763253152,
-0.4196392298,
-0.6649084091,
-0.0292043574,
-0.6385627389,
0.6497319341,
0.7669035196,
-0.4670007825,
-0.3335921168,
-0.7222040892,
0.5710086226,
0.7255976796,
-0.70106709,
-0.1609593928,
0.259193331,
0.2912755907,
-0.1769543141,
0.8144012094,
0.3440088332,
0.2875416875,
-0.1910267025,
-0.2931337655,
-0.1228164509,
-0.5118143559,
-0.1925791353,
-0.1015951782,
0.3232493699,
0.2854892612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18449v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18449v1 | Taming AI Bots: Controllability of Neural States in Large Language Models | 2023-05-29T03:58:33 | 2023-05-29T03:58:33 | Stefano Soatto, Paulo Tabuada, Pratik Chaudhari, Tian Yu Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SY, eess.SY | We tackle the question of whether an agent can, by suitable choice of
prompts, control an AI bot to any state. To that end, we first introduce a
formal definition of ``meaning'' that is amenable to analysis. Then, we
characterize ``meaningful data'' on which large language models (LLMs) are
ostensibly trained, and ``well-trained LLMs'' through conditions that are
largely met by today's LLMs. While a well-trained LLM constructs an embedding
space of meanings that is Euclidean, meanings themselves do not form a vector
(linear) subspace, but rather a quotient space within. We then characterize the
subset of meanings that can be reached by the state of the LLMs for some input
prompt, and show that a well-trained bot can reach any meaning albeit with
small probability. We then introduce a stronger notion of controllability as
{\em almost certain reachability}, and show that, when restricted to the space
of meanings, an AI bot is controllable. We do so after introducing a functional
characterization of attentive AI bots, and finally derive necessary and
sufficient conditions for controllability. The fact that AI bots are
controllable means that an adversary could steer them towards any state.
However, the sampling process can be designed to counteract adverse actions and
avoid reaching undesirable regions of state space before their boundary is
crossed. | [
-0.1563855261,
-1.0571439266,
0.5506789088,
0.1500980556,
-0.0012125453,
0.3509550989,
-0.3865660727,
-0.5813133121,
0.1874517649,
0.4367902875,
-0.2692083716,
-0.0593333319,
-0.8449422121,
0.0391688906,
-0.6684011817,
0.9264313579,
-0.135794431,
-0.0896987617,
-0.3410764337,
-0.1923266798,
-0.3704466522,
-0.7054901719,
-0.6321052313,
-0.3415135443,
0.5578122735,
-0.1375503093,
1.1000839472,
0.8781934381,
0.4862986207,
0.4358664453,
-0.2171830684,
-0.1120676696,
-0.4504377246,
0.3972887695,
-0.2371414602,
-1.0064353943,
-0.1374438554,
0.2984676063,
0.7320118546,
0.5998151302,
0.016439857,
-0.2812130451,
-0.0636516288,
0.2496599704,
-0.4350164235,
0.1556415707,
-0.7576117516,
0.1214454025,
-0.2631826699,
0.0617420077,
-0.3547912538,
-0.3424063921,
-0.0870266259,
-0.4574317336,
-0.164757058,
0.2455137223,
0.9967767,
0.5768556595,
-0.1079664975,
-0.2164180577,
-0.8047936559,
0.795638144,
-0.5092779994,
0.2350973189,
0.7932067513,
0.4005320072,
-0.3673308492,
-0.5230354071,
-0.9814728498,
-0.6919443011,
-0.0165488943,
-0.0652531832,
-0.5907443762,
0.2268429846,
0.4714711308,
0.1272886544,
-0.3169536293,
0.2329422385,
-0.2416571081,
-0.4198258817,
0.5848953724,
0.2603392601,
0.6278465986,
-0.0486178361,
-0.4686329365,
-0.0651565492,
-0.5755188465,
0.1797093004,
0.3546557724,
0.2400820702,
-0.1161119714,
0.913017571,
0.2246309221,
0.5636618733,
-0.2088496983,
0.0355125964,
-0.2090007216,
-0.2801438272,
-0.2678013742,
-0.2722125053,
0.7990924716,
-0.1644471884,
0.613941133,
-0.3532654047,
-0.4988619387,
0.0601415299,
0.5778359771,
-0.2770506442,
0.0329283774,
0.3890112936,
-0.4118185937,
-0.2457568049,
-0.0939287096,
-0.3257553279,
-0.5263406038,
-0.4839223325,
0.4250256717,
-0.4621734023,
-0.1562173218,
-0.3174929917,
-0.1411444545,
0.565417707,
0.3268653452,
-0.6556369066,
0.3419815302,
0.7881231904,
0.7687811852,
-0.3304613233,
-0.3844736814,
-0.2036299855,
-0.0918268785,
-0.5592126846,
0.3188650906,
-0.5474501848,
-0.2585052252,
0.0875737667,
-0.0066025578,
-0.1389376819,
-0.490505904,
-0.2532400191,
-0.8641399741,
-0.1072760895,
0.1178039908,
-0.5982401371,
-0.1063793525,
0.5866528153,
-0.62509197,
0.4095650911,
-0.0478663594,
-0.1913767606,
0.1565239429,
-0.6013371348,
-0.6356749535,
-0.0741923153,
-0.372271806,
-0.0293224957,
0.0172916763,
-0.4525761306,
0.3966379464,
0.0416502468,
0.129262358,
-0.2668518126,
-0.0576797612,
0.7297301888,
-0.6164129972,
1.0031793118,
0.3083184063,
-0.2177275866,
0.4252644777,
-0.3425526321,
0.002357173,
0.1088365391,
-0.2138538063,
-0.2358492613,
0.2602567971,
-0.119207643,
0.1330030859,
0.2997331619,
-0.3841997981,
0.1739888787,
-0.4134714603,
0.7363011837,
1.034610033,
-0.3454175293,
0.7575063705,
-0.3908984363,
0.786837697,
-0.2048894167,
0.0863426104,
0.0006578243,
-0.2875469327,
-0.6552180052,
-0.6897041798,
0.2291332036,
0.7607650757,
-0.7579356432,
0.7053944468,
0.0352081619,
-0.4194760025,
-0.5832256675,
0.0074424148,
0.1361318231,
0.2226577401,
0.258918345,
-0.0103933606,
-0.0141403098,
-0.8762501478,
-0.1367792487,
0.0228484143,
-0.021004701,
0.3232828975,
0.6100692749,
0.0443929546,
0.8325674534,
-0.1759325862,
-0.2794634104,
-0.4299125671,
-0.1265724748,
0.0549236275,
0.5075910687,
0.2177923024,
-0.7847688794,
-0.2292371243,
-0.1388393193,
-0.7739727497,
0.3109776974,
-0.3526861966,
-0.0352821238,
0.1325752735,
0.9116460085,
-0.8525110483,
0.8098624945,
0.1003816202,
-0.3148159683,
0.2338189632,
-0.271293819,
-0.1763022393,
-0.9214593768,
0.1582549959,
-0.2869471014,
-0.4499577582,
-0.5634964108,
0.3256899416,
-0.2711027265,
-0.143115744,
-0.5314420462,
0.8816720843,
-0.2003044635,
0.1674429327,
-0.6528141499,
0.1818210334,
-0.4036828578,
0.3235633373,
-0.0333629996,
0.5049758554,
0.5256094337,
-0.7551380992,
0.5818088651,
0.2353789508,
-0.1998143941,
0.5266261697,
-0.8334241509,
-0.0593077838,
-0.0964694917,
0.3928984106,
-1.0451577902,
-0.116102919,
0.5069696307,
-0.7520240545,
0.2060637623,
0.1749237925,
-0.6073346734,
-0.0740155205,
0.0254841913,
0.3966849446,
0.6956961155,
-0.1287240088,
0.6537358165,
0.3968518972,
0.0263724588,
-0.4522632957,
-0.6042116284,
0.1189353168,
-0.2087000459,
-0.1237751842,
-0.0111536561,
-0.0838618353,
-0.5701694489,
0.0406857505,
0.2550938725,
-0.217855081,
0.4673618376,
0.4574065506,
0.1656365097,
0.2721073925,
0.2593020499,
-0.0800281838,
-0.2335503548,
0.2715459764,
-0.130207479,
0.7053723931,
0.1759347767,
-0.4959148467,
-0.5989046693,
0.2282139361,
0.6797227263,
-0.369662106,
0.7192025781,
0.4078352749,
-0.7391848564,
-0.251750946,
-0.1280576289,
-0.2363658845,
-0.4428954422,
0.2782584727,
-0.4601424932,
-0.8068948388,
0.6881880164,
0.298203975,
0.1145834923,
0.3826244473,
0.6680651903,
-0.2988034189,
0.9725634456,
0.6231080294,
-0.57452631,
0.4961844385,
-0.0302409846,
0.2482243925,
-0.4318965971,
-0.149952665,
-0.8796801567,
-0.6456928253,
-0.8523661494,
-0.322812885,
0.1510290354,
-0.0643699616,
-0.402313143,
0.1117214113,
-0.2619112134,
0.6106060743,
0.9011574984,
-0.0182563253,
-0.1352049261,
-0.2188185006,
0.1256424934,
0.1285227537,
-0.5688537955,
-0.4685871601,
0.8431972861,
0.41530478,
0.8151346445,
0.18339324,
0.3021783233,
0.5270218253,
-0.0104332939,
-0.9449176788,
0.5734312534,
0.1591962874,
-0.8075062633,
-0.4315144718,
-0.1217033789,
-1.2365700006,
-0.0465993322,
-0.3009653389,
-1.0835819244,
-0.1140160561,
0.1147031337,
-0.3021374643,
0.62831074,
-0.3326568604,
0.4105624259,
-0.2386175692,
-0.1044908389,
-0.3863063157,
-0.9094915986,
0.1466484219,
0.0145317009,
-0.0747116059,
-0.183950603,
-0.2880968153,
0.5201922059,
-0.409372896,
1.0232423544,
-0.1161643341,
-0.0843584463,
0.373491019,
0.4295154512,
0.3174212575,
-0.1422316432,
0.1827823371,
0.2903732061,
0.0710370764,
-0.7451398373,
-0.6885834932,
0.3648904562,
-0.8769064546,
-0.6469787359,
-0.4327315688,
-0.7291838527,
0.045730073,
0.3870788217,
0.2236531228,
0.127787292,
-0.1155338958,
0.2109710574,
0.6953766346,
-0.2493641376,
0.4534513652,
0.1177463606,
-0.0962908566,
-0.0658557713,
1.0000475645,
0.0314715728,
0.4424362481,
0.4835963547,
0.0758848116,
-0.3711162806,
-0.3254935443,
-0.2202279419,
0.0074719721,
-0.4039241076,
-0.0319072492,
-0.1917637438,
-0.4926258028,
-0.014518545,
-0.2607575953,
-0.2423841059,
-0.3045097888,
-0.3895881772,
0.0502563789,
0.2077475041,
0.790958643,
-0.1894382834,
0.4726335406,
-0.5810226202,
0.4004457295,
0.0989703313,
0.2882547975,
-0.0045771585,
-0.5306706429,
0.0332849957,
0.1747016758,
-0.1005926281,
-0.8762981296,
0.2142093331,
-0.1609955579,
0.6658529043,
0.5931884646,
0.0682113469,
0.1716550589,
-0.4163334072,
0.8762885928,
0.0168240927,
-1.0070983171,
0.5603827238,
-0.3206535876,
0.1101372167,
0.2952355742,
0.5473046303,
-0.4714511931,
-0.6981955767,
-0.829144001,
-0.7123073339,
0.5076825619,
0.0373773202,
0.8010860682,
0.0476285182,
0.4351625741,
-0.0582147725,
0.4046441317,
-0.7462084293,
-0.2831194997,
-0.0819437802,
-0.4106920958,
-0.2643559277,
-0.0366154499,
-0.5522541404,
-0.0333425254,
0.2709837258,
0.1041033864,
0.534709394,
-0.1581648141,
-0.1662011594,
0.093939282,
0.0989479646,
0.7055451274,
0.5187964439,
0.2163233161,
0.2437879443,
-0.1791439056,
-0.3065438271,
0.270974189,
0.1244047657,
-0.3469415009,
-0.4273828864,
0.5798588991,
0.6752100587,
-0.4889574647,
-0.6882783175,
0.4851871431,
0.1054654047,
0.0030106418,
-0.3893457353,
0.3794963062,
-0.4017519653,
0.4192719162,
0.0963632092,
0.1250004023,
-0.2898132503,
-0.4578834176,
0.0689255297,
0.7908060551,
-0.6471916437,
-0.3925825357,
0.6523728371,
-0.0883083642,
-0.7179097533,
1.007537961,
-0.2305912971,
-0.6200303435,
0.8916967511,
0.5760580301,
0.743796289,
-0.0750517696,
-0.0726843849,
0.0252893344,
0.6246722937,
0.3570515811,
0.1365672648,
-0.1412323713,
-1.1255608797,
-0.2317670882,
-0.1837317944,
-0.5084001422,
0.2337259501,
-0.5369313359,
-0.1374406517,
-0.8542907834,
-0.1286990345,
-0.0689631477,
-0.1998366565,
-0.5160428286,
0.235892266,
0.1157366857,
0.9366582036,
-0.6562774181,
0.5774027705,
0.5316533446,
-0.5108236074,
-0.7124003172,
-0.0178612042,
0.1293254644,
-1.0152056217,
0.3714734316,
-0.0856942311,
0.1318821758,
0.0653002039,
-1.2214566469,
-0.6463416815,
0.7511597872,
0.215123415,
-0.2123818398,
0.190790996,
0.1575177759,
0.5443552136,
0.0039810427,
0.0715488568,
0.6835748553,
0.60893929,
-0.2389030606,
-0.7991743684,
0.0022905348,
-0.1464499533,
-0.3649447858,
0.0568649098,
-0.6344611049,
0.5943547487,
-0.2741573453,
-0.136694923,
0.299336493,
0.7942696214,
0.0781120136,
0.0940126255,
0.559594214,
0.3482823074,
0.8332643509,
-0.4072667956,
1.200635314,
-0.1671944261,
-0.0662659332,
0.7932958603,
-0.0570561849,
0.8750874996,
0.4566035271,
-0.2729886174,
0.0018390511,
0.5718128085,
-0.0629491881,
0.3065326214,
0.6903838515,
-0.0992560163,
-0.3344904184,
-0.2664455473,
-0.018655844,
0.805413723,
0.4175550342,
-0.2482888699,
0.0265705734,
0.2989454567,
0.2246006131,
0.2541501522,
-0.2670936584,
0.7811996341,
0.0924473256,
-0.4974147677,
0.4702296555,
-0.1969691366,
0.4023991823,
-0.7674187422,
-0.0503927171,
-0.2476193458,
0.0713377371,
0.0650950149,
-0.8760015965,
0.2043736279,
-0.0044616489,
-0.2118528336,
-0.2443629056,
0.631608367,
-0.2027555108,
-0.1746060997,
0.1657788306,
0.6919411421,
0.3449076712,
0.1812771857,
-0.7340840697,
0.0331116132,
-0.1063166261,
-0.2548573911,
0.2362539023,
0.1335570067,
-0.2645212114,
1.0602332354,
0.527980566,
0.5302845836,
0.1934547871,
-0.3540984094,
0.7062353492,
-0.6652464271,
-0.4454797208,
-0.896204412,
0.2906209826,
0.2115958929,
-0.1838718206,
0.4565818012,
0.0181152467,
0.8948304653,
0.2070562541,
0.9544875026,
-0.3263657093,
0.3036968112,
-0.4710400701,
1.0944223404,
-0.6008473039,
-0.0847214162,
0.2367416322,
-0.7449932098,
-0.3923047483,
0.6474009752,
-0.2823301554,
0.1634712964,
0.2677936852,
0.5857499838,
0.1502802223,
-0.3099030554,
0.4492855966,
0.3750549257,
0.5590291619,
0.3204565644,
1.2208498716,
0.1913019717,
0.2025535107,
0.1088083759,
-0.1814421713,
0.0294981338,
-0.5874409676,
-0.7116039395,
-0.5375738144,
0.0253981072,
-0.4932257831,
-0.0564567149,
0.9037311673,
0.6051954031,
-0.7310272455,
-0.2160544842,
-0.0270359386,
0.6686292291,
-0.1761622578,
-0.1812721491,
0.3888983428,
-0.547508955,
-1.1149272919,
0.3890791833,
-0.0669333264,
0.3557463586,
-0.5060617328,
0.0269698426,
-0.0931906849,
0.3590137064,
0.3982551098,
0.7270953655,
-0.7849393487,
-0.4234383404,
0.0074947355,
-0.2856935859,
-0.1525370181,
0.6593924761,
-0.571968317,
0.5764788985,
0.4797379673,
0.9467235208,
-0.2515120208,
-0.0891822353,
0.6074527502,
-0.6787945032,
0.2805778086,
0.446313411,
0.2171055675,
0.0116832387,
-0.2218344361,
0.20563519,
0.1698205322,
-0.3908670247,
-0.6617844105,
0.2635867596,
-0.8514847159,
-0.3840454519,
1.1707062721,
-0.2101809829,
-0.2543753386,
-0.0232251436,
-0.0124695972,
0.3771804571,
-0.1361104399,
0.7625626922,
0.8307592273,
-0.1681671441,
0.2588953376,
-0.5419217348,
0.5680770874,
0.3405029476,
-0.832085669,
-0.0371845812,
0.4382019937,
0.0402788781,
0.3030380011,
0.581444025,
0.0359525457,
0.0959256515,
-0.1934478581,
-0.0459755361,
-0.1039765924,
-0.6064487696,
-0.6419590116,
0.0751431063,
0.1498857439,
-0.5415120721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17855v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17855v1 | Vec2Gloss: definition modeling leveraging contextualized vectors with Wordnet gloss | 2023-05-29T02:37:37 | 2023-05-29T02:37:37 | Yu-Hsiang Tseng, Mao-Chang Ku, Wei-Ling Chen, Yu-Lin Chang, Shu-Kai Hsieh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Contextualized embeddings are proven to be powerful tools in multiple NLP
tasks. Nonetheless, challenges regarding their interpretability and capability
to represent lexical semantics still remain. In this paper, we propose that the
task of definition modeling, which aims to generate the human-readable
definition of the word, provides a route to evaluate or understand the high
dimensional semantic vectors. We propose a `Vec2Gloss' model, which produces
the gloss from the target word's contextualized embeddings. The generated
glosses of this study are made possible by the systematic gloss patterns
provided by Chinese Wordnet. We devise two dependency indices to measure the
semantic and contextual dependency, which are used to analyze the generated
texts in gloss and token levels. Our results indicate that the proposed
`Vec2Gloss' model opens a new perspective to the lexical-semantic applications
of contextualized embeddings. | [
-0.2678025663,
-0.7716972828,
0.2744043469,
0.1252594739,
-0.3650992811,
-0.2288002968,
-0.1890459508,
-0.6876107454,
0.3243822157,
0.5899771452,
-0.2892799675,
-0.4793124795,
-0.6735732555,
-0.101102449,
-0.5185918212,
0.8216579556,
-0.0915907696,
0.0036437456,
-0.3062906265,
0.0231658425,
-0.5472353101,
-0.4637196958,
-0.262293458,
-0.1355064809,
0.4731598198,
0.4083008468,
0.9758607149,
0.8967286348,
0.3374736011,
0.2304948568,
-0.3011316359,
0.1860038787,
-0.5942352414,
-0.1141637042,
-0.2173837572,
-0.2047473192,
-0.3248165846,
0.308038801,
0.5066171885,
0.7364848852,
-0.1658573598,
0.009240442,
0.2293893397,
0.0812648684,
-0.5931265354,
0.1409478784,
-0.7532213926,
0.1751703918,
-0.1643552035,
-0.1237287372,
-0.013334889,
0.2351188809,
0.4931817353,
-0.8516027927,
0.0487826727,
0.1183732226,
1.2739936113,
-0.0895096362,
-0.2503158748,
-0.6209111214,
-0.7242927551,
0.5705904365,
-0.5576995611,
0.1355722845,
0.323101759,
0.5043739676,
0.149750635,
-1.26758039,
-0.5889585018,
-0.2823573947,
-0.2193018347,
0.4177692235,
-0.043753773,
-0.2519972026,
-0.1225593239,
0.2861557007,
-0.2789892256,
0.1559081525,
-0.5195177197,
-0.1937326789,
0.4574499726,
0.2332050651,
0.6874573231,
-0.6147825122,
-1.1039469242,
0.2098465264,
-0.7491408587,
-0.1186113954,
-0.0900188312,
0.2174746245,
-0.1972917169,
0.7162013054,
-0.0513042472,
0.4221223295,
-0.5556393266,
0.1061234102,
0.2332082838,
-0.5861188769,
-0.2401741147,
-0.0617509447,
0.3717657626,
0.5210347772,
0.2132148147,
-0.2961835563,
-0.3049279451,
-0.0252257939,
0.5348863602,
-0.7919753194,
0.1295282692,
0.1682736427,
-0.3181953728,
-0.2622154653,
0.1891990453,
-0.4251632988,
-0.3434592783,
-0.7229952216,
0.360589087,
-0.452173382,
-0.2968632579,
0.1451535672,
-0.3757413924,
0.5565463901,
0.3615053594,
-0.8901547194,
0.3294596076,
1.0192950964,
1.1701630354,
-0.2662798166,
-0.255903244,
-0.2895722687,
0.3429073095,
-0.3791336119,
0.6345363855,
-0.3753244579,
-0.5123339295,
0.5118693113,
0.0025976009,
0.3582438827,
-0.3936233222,
0.4310892224,
-0.3253110945,
0.0462284535,
-0.4322659373,
-0.6518440247,
-0.3395348191,
0.236473605,
-0.5330139995,
0.8940443993,
0.3391996324,
-0.8127302527,
0.3968036473,
-0.397706449,
-0.3965571225,
0.7244522572,
-0.3579351902,
0.0533052459,
0.4342089593,
-0.3171870112,
0.2804362178,
-0.4792492688,
0.28513515,
-0.2210419029,
-0.2553083301,
-0.1568745077,
-0.0015381456,
0.7143082023,
0.0721145272,
-0.1750572771,
0.1584059,
-0.4684012532,
0.0229538474,
-0.0205644388,
-0.2168982625,
-0.7469738126,
0.3333778679,
0.4674789011,
0.4725655019,
0.4247600734,
-0.3475880921,
-0.0070091523,
-0.7306051254,
0.5506409407,
0.6105220914,
-0.4906257987,
0.3320885897,
0.1538092941,
0.1549505442,
0.0781534463,
0.2800465524,
0.1377510577,
-0.5402359962,
-0.6789906621,
-0.0513181239,
0.3412441015,
0.667022109,
-0.853450954,
0.3496298492,
-0.4904880524,
-0.4054655135,
-0.0524812415,
0.2305034399,
0.2124019861,
0.4102832973,
0.2329472899,
-0.1903303415,
-0.3959703147,
-1.0738353729,
0.210906148,
-0.0006553732,
-0.3846430779,
0.5664750338,
0.7028523684,
-0.3615847826,
0.9297739267,
-0.4878338873,
-0.5360484123,
-0.1896234304,
0.0230971333,
-0.1740523577,
0.159391433,
0.475468576,
-0.9182837605,
-0.2945665717,
0.1412631571,
-1.0423260927,
-0.0436019078,
0.2341913581,
-0.4307685494,
-0.1522008479,
0.5481923819,
-0.2234389633,
0.593937397,
0.4727597833,
-0.4966736436,
0.584223032,
-0.4184291065,
-0.530141294,
-1.1777861118,
0.0960382745,
-0.0306345932,
-0.1029130146,
-0.7893134356,
0.2002249956,
0.1375438124,
-0.0193116125,
-0.6553362012,
0.5791963935,
-0.3627729416,
-0.2573246956,
-0.4761073291,
0.9142146111,
0.1858487278,
0.1504137069,
0.2311113775,
0.550889194,
0.717536211,
-0.6939769387,
0.4087840319,
0.5381111503,
-0.4163072109,
0.3088780046,
-1.1497892141,
-0.2200101912,
-0.0574404821,
-0.0957605913,
-1.087900281,
-0.2374953181,
0.3250947893,
-0.2252112776,
0.1616287231,
0.0664873421,
-0.5882850289,
-0.2323435694,
-0.4239413738,
0.3424797952,
0.247578457,
-0.6326318979,
0.6474735141,
0.7671898603,
-0.0718094856,
-0.2530176044,
-0.8102751374,
0.3558749259,
-0.0215960164,
-1.0710517168,
0.9360422492,
0.3322305679,
-0.1727376282,
0.046347484,
0.2591838241,
0.2616568208,
0.1991815418,
0.4608311951,
0.4827196002,
-0.0424826741,
0.3785666525,
-0.1262364686,
-0.1220487803,
0.1399298459,
-0.4922484756,
0.4264058471,
-0.0827246234,
0.1657266617,
-0.0513453782,
0.442327857,
0.0869141743,
-0.3281048238,
0.6491761208,
0.7960461974,
-0.5168374777,
-0.2658948302,
0.0342411213,
-0.0248956494,
-0.4268761873,
0.4448287785,
-0.2380266041,
-0.9692759514,
0.5149709582,
-0.2127601504,
-0.0169347748,
0.3581259549,
0.7777554393,
0.141024664,
0.9532637,
0.8750036955,
0.1554159671,
0.298730284,
-0.1856323481,
0.1368370205,
-1.0033794641,
-0.1691150367,
-0.2281429172,
-0.0196476169,
-0.9179732203,
-0.617251277,
0.4886660576,
0.1823759824,
0.1085582823,
0.241673857,
-0.3383509815,
0.0666813329,
0.6037303805,
-0.2169010788,
-0.2701984346,
0.3069150448,
-0.3843960762,
0.1741361171,
-0.3989281654,
-0.688657403,
0.7070679665,
0.4183220267,
0.2581642568,
0.377941221,
0.1393649131,
0.3294401765,
0.1746134162,
-0.8767604232,
0.3580808342,
-0.448362112,
-0.6183397174,
-0.2424504012,
0.0010179915,
-0.8424015641,
0.4304937124,
-0.3244311213,
-1.0052189827,
0.0000205311,
-0.0352224931,
-0.2011153251,
-0.0409426428,
-0.3507383168,
0.9417820573,
-0.0430953912,
-0.452937603,
-0.160740599,
-0.51337713,
0.499199152,
0.1590851843,
0.2016689479,
-0.2241433561,
-0.3647418618,
0.6621037126,
-0.7584547997,
0.6534613371,
0.0380343124,
-0.4264552295,
0.5625177622,
-0.0726969838,
0.3812312186,
0.3149771988,
0.0996856615,
0.4681335092,
-0.0521211028,
-0.4459550083,
-0.5055574179,
0.7746134996,
-0.6955498457,
-0.7488554716,
-0.2678768933,
-0.1238068864,
0.1407222748,
0.1572567672,
0.3562881052,
0.6933511496,
-0.2284914404,
-0.1619552821,
0.0855131298,
-0.5010845065,
0.1863277107,
0.2830834687,
-0.6967340708,
-0.2245130092,
1.0473297834,
0.2490748614,
0.2983749211,
-0.0129225943,
0.3513446152,
-0.3511061966,
-0.3781161904,
-0.4195327461,
0.1923871934,
-0.8468371034,
0.128343299,
-0.2758258879,
-0.4225031137,
-0.3056631982,
-0.0509530567,
-0.1599114388,
-0.1912733614,
-0.2929916382,
-0.0248238593,
0.0159314219,
0.9619190097,
-0.1896196455,
0.3443257809,
-0.3504140675,
0.3674919307,
0.3071496487,
0.3526884615,
-0.2125206143,
-0.5539744496,
-0.4970847666,
0.0816364884,
-0.0863105878,
-0.6902678609,
0.5944393277,
0.1288131624,
0.2740672231,
0.5224955678,
-0.3022445142,
0.26473248,
-0.6661068797,
1.0179362297,
0.0167689268,
-1.0827510357,
0.5718262196,
-0.1004117057,
0.217021063,
0.1935315281,
0.324380964,
-0.8409980536,
-0.2235847265,
-0.3021887243,
-1.2451246977,
0.5715891123,
0.3242818415,
0.5556759834,
-0.2558389008,
0.5135461688,
-0.1108000129,
0.0479576513,
-0.2356981337,
-0.4812072814,
-0.3727147281,
0.2610141039,
-0.0406557284,
-0.9302815199,
0.0837924406,
-0.0688598156,
0.4758712351,
0.0013476042,
0.3258309066,
0.1068446413,
-0.0993097574,
0.2661921084,
-0.2249692827,
0.6678296924,
0.6212986708,
-0.0730434358,
0.3950544596,
-0.0228891578,
-0.5830634832,
-0.400292486,
-0.0334079191,
-0.52429533,
0.2719477117,
0.4504921138,
0.8598762155,
0.231688723,
-0.4575951695,
0.6808079481,
-0.1173218265,
-0.1986522526,
-0.8105570078,
-0.1139166877,
0.2910144329,
-0.1805957407,
0.1186560839,
-0.2069530785,
0.359818846,
-0.4154439569,
0.402644366,
0.505209744,
-0.7868250012,
-0.2970488369,
0.677975595,
0.1718016416,
-0.0500336401,
0.7607235312,
-0.3498698175,
-0.6761189699,
0.407538116,
0.4463966191,
0.7330542207,
0.0957977697,
0.2293428779,
0.5395905375,
0.0301871728,
0.2472139299,
0.2477849424,
0.1947033405,
-0.9129926562,
-0.3292265832,
-0.7446902394,
0.1420341432,
0.0422125086,
-0.5898997188,
0.5651804805,
-0.4835856557,
-0.137063697,
0.4345368743,
-0.2766853869,
-0.5823729634,
0.0196357202,
0.7182281017,
0.8919171691,
-0.6095010042,
0.9155293703,
0.4797324836,
-0.4387154281,
-0.6680318117,
-0.0932002291,
0.1901731938,
-0.8209661245,
0.9532315135,
0.5108370185,
-0.2239861339,
0.0147363925,
-0.6182371974,
-0.9342425466,
1.1822361946,
-0.2995204926,
-0.3734195232,
0.0309696347,
0.3913060129,
0.5575196147,
-0.5513615608,
0.2987732589,
0.4344348311,
0.5492042303,
0.1227683425,
-0.5034725666,
0.056734141,
-0.4521951675,
0.632410109,
-0.3092875481,
-0.2044755071,
0.9919463992,
-0.0210542176,
-0.8631368876,
0.0179744419,
1.0311223269,
-0.169570744,
-0.1104968339,
0.4534282684,
0.2646658719,
0.5433942676,
-0.0126938997,
1.3660897017,
-0.5352018476,
0.4741506279,
1.1000235081,
-0.2905226052,
0.9211645126,
0.2353731245,
0.044062376,
0.3493455052,
0.3769124448,
-0.193054527,
0.4056168199,
0.673933804,
-0.2943461537,
-0.2440087944,
-0.5521969199,
-0.0979226604,
0.8351077437,
0.6738509536,
-0.318053335,
-0.478811413,
0.0657619014,
-0.0124375718,
0.1427841485,
-0.3666256666,
0.6789883375,
0.2400191128,
-0.4809418321,
0.8339164257,
0.438451618,
0.5869215131,
-0.4031701386,
-0.042054832,
0.0450272858,
0.0025520958,
-0.0288937688,
-0.741930902,
0.3578493297,
-0.2349437326,
0.0071742409,
0.0279768761,
0.7399155498,
-0.4739105403,
-0.6419356465,
0.7712479234,
0.5418220162,
0.151665315,
0.0554045625,
-0.7468652129,
-0.1248269975,
-0.3337213695,
-0.2708782554,
0.1117667332,
0.4104991853,
-0.1257322431,
0.4648430347,
0.250080198,
-0.1059150323,
0.0161437783,
0.3899269998,
0.6973483562,
-0.497055769,
-0.3796874881,
-0.9012638927,
0.3793979585,
-0.0834412575,
-0.4512320459,
0.772115767,
0.4968821406,
0.6995072961,
0.0560805723,
1.0610822439,
-0.3113132715,
0.1868993789,
-0.5207405686,
0.6426280141,
-0.8132192492,
0.1866528839,
0.0866795704,
-0.4514949024,
-0.3142857254,
0.2586140037,
-0.2592869699,
-0.1305830479,
0.4072299302,
0.8130591512,
0.0094165746,
0.0331386551,
0.493850857,
0.2509408295,
0.29474473,
0.4669473767,
0.8468397856,
-0.3500052691,
0.1550573558,
-0.1224342808,
-0.2187314183,
-0.5524560809,
-0.7091731429,
-0.7247893214,
-0.8177560568,
-0.1227626279,
-0.4294271171,
-0.1300305128,
0.5067744851,
0.4730219245,
-0.6242550015,
-0.1739833206,
-0.2083862871,
0.0952857658,
-0.1918590218,
-0.2151349187,
0.5991532803,
-0.5861642361,
-0.7157922387,
-0.0060314713,
0.4245174527,
0.0997330695,
-0.5985910296,
-0.0431633629,
-0.2067621946,
0.140590176,
0.9181070924,
-0.1432387382,
-0.9779680371,
-0.6424395442,
-0.2188222855,
-0.4388485551,
-0.0047528981,
0.5914235115,
-0.608702004,
0.4467931688,
0.5001654625,
0.2530711889,
0.3310930133,
-0.0170195494,
0.6671252251,
-0.5578073263,
-0.042997133,
-0.3532874584,
0.3957175314,
0.3238318563,
-0.2207860947,
0.6037797332,
0.2343296558,
-0.089657627,
-0.3799901307,
0.4262793064,
-1.0277420282,
-0.5503118038,
1.4827541113,
-0.3589523733,
-0.6177585125,
-0.022122873,
-0.1369967312,
0.3885789216,
0.246079579,
0.5031926632,
0.5888623595,
0.4076176286,
0.2805643678,
-1.0286542177,
0.6577270627,
0.0659057572,
-0.5437899828,
0.1597016156,
0.3008489311,
0.1705818325,
0.4187141061,
0.1077816412,
-0.1138573587,
0.210731864,
0.0966846198,
0.1224655658,
-0.1240263134,
-0.2800050378,
-0.0344413407,
0.141612336,
-0.0958625674,
0.076278396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17854v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17854v1 | E-NER: Evidential Deep Learning for Trustworthy Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-29T02:36:16 | 2023-05-29T02:36:16 | Zhen Zhang, Mengting Hu, Shiwan Zhao, Minlie Huang, Haotian Wang, Lemao Liu, Zhirui Zhang, Zhe Liu, Bingzhe Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most named entity recognition (NER) systems focus on improving model
performance, ignoring the need to quantify model uncertainty, which is critical
to the reliability of NER systems in open environments. Evidential deep
learning (EDL) has recently been proposed as a promising solution to explicitly
model predictive uncertainty for classification tasks. However, directly
applying EDL to NER applications faces two challenges, i.e., the problems of
sparse entities and OOV/OOD entities in NER tasks. To address these challenges,
we propose a trustworthy NER framework named E-NER by introducing two
uncertainty-guided loss terms to the conventional EDL, along with a series of
uncertainty-guided training strategies. Experiments show that E-NER can be
applied to multiple NER paradigms to obtain accurate uncertainty estimation.
Furthermore, compared to state-of-the-art baselines, the proposed method
achieves a better OOV/OOD detection performance and better generalization
ability on OOV entities. | [
-0.3210785687,
-0.6712667346,
0.7769094706,
-0.4220741987,
-0.0858890861,
0.1530304998,
-0.114735201,
-0.7733727098,
0.0319541991,
0.2138506919,
-0.2602760792,
-0.3758150041,
-0.8612342477,
0.190177083,
-0.2989217937,
0.8777034879,
-0.2132194489,
0.2016886026,
-0.0322080664,
-0.0661798641,
-0.1029677242,
-0.327886492,
-0.9730172157,
-0.151705578,
0.5061280131,
0.2532393932,
0.3467127681,
0.5170629025,
0.5931888819,
0.2138665617,
0.1069861725,
0.3068090379,
-0.3342356682,
0.4107421041,
-0.2631835043,
-0.4291831255,
-0.5679548383,
-0.3527046442,
0.5937806368,
0.4836411774,
-0.5349771976,
0.0076744352,
-0.0368376262,
0.4366900325,
-0.8409673572,
-0.0430118553,
-0.6244096756,
0.1744183451,
0.1094340906,
0.071932666,
-0.3490663767,
-0.2959637642,
0.4658924043,
-0.9970202446,
0.1181343049,
0.4577668905,
1.1248538494,
0.5057057142,
-0.1803828627,
-0.1861994863,
-0.9454818368,
0.7992714047,
-0.3796134591,
0.8686470985,
0.3161509335,
0.4927762151,
-0.1431695223,
-0.7602133155,
-0.6510092616,
0.1278325468,
0.2437983006,
0.0737192035,
-0.1680882275,
0.0826041102,
0.1413487345,
0.1409145147,
-0.3606938124,
0.3665089011,
-0.0407834463,
-0.3370119035,
0.2934945822,
-0.1409756094,
0.011695642,
0.4675134718,
-0.6135921478,
-0.213341102,
-0.6409190893,
-0.0723591894,
0.3426312506,
0.103227891,
0.0774370357,
0.1705810577,
-0.3568252325,
0.5305606723,
0.4811483622,
-0.2988126576,
0.218791917,
0.2070769966,
-0.4365382791,
0.533159852,
0.599044621,
0.2349243462,
-0.0852504224,
-0.0972558558,
-0.5681194663,
-0.2388637811,
-0.1043725163,
-1.0094844103,
-0.1545290202,
0.0865662545,
-0.2914135754,
-0.3901339769,
0.3075379133,
-0.7602868676,
-0.5921326876,
-0.2148370743,
0.6735202074,
-0.4391503036,
-0.4264228642,
0.1073394045,
-0.0201404132,
0.2141953856,
0.8171329498,
-0.4264782965,
0.4941906035,
0.7188122869,
0.5253834128,
0.0927439928,
-0.0032996184,
-0.7679392695,
0.2230800837,
-0.297742486,
0.448769331,
-0.5320261121,
0.1541536152,
-0.262883842,
-0.0792751238,
0.1255682409,
-0.3118005097,
0.6171393991,
-0.7708466053,
-0.0624791943,
0.0235615466,
-0.7518200278,
-0.3229221106,
0.421901077,
-0.8076015115,
0.7594150901,
-0.1566845328,
-0.6077388525,
0.9250156879,
-0.3026730716,
-0.0215693116,
0.1543305665,
-0.5004486442,
-0.6033970118,
0.3295308053,
0.3681003451,
0.5386769176,
-0.3583463728,
0.3840868473,
-0.3869410753,
-0.1643779427,
0.2414864451,
-0.6744629741,
0.3780029714,
0.1689707339,
-0.3843120039,
-0.3259543478,
-0.9698112607,
0.2357510924,
0.1793090999,
-0.1737494767,
-0.6270327568,
0.00279414,
0.0131097296,
-0.1150641516,
0.0605912097,
-0.7636048794,
-0.2097073942,
-0.4495225549,
0.4568315446,
0.6797891259,
-0.0024478987,
0.4225127399,
0.1108630374,
0.1749354601,
0.1777041703,
0.1148205027,
0.0927293673,
-0.4147772491,
-0.8719536066,
-0.1802870482,
0.5726423264,
0.4201391935,
-0.5883244276,
0.4287777245,
-0.4151437879,
-0.4015401304,
-0.3269482851,
-0.2639200091,
0.3768955767,
0.6854224801,
0.4076431692,
-0.0582434013,
-0.6163047552,
-0.8185821772,
-0.1366586238,
-0.2622710764,
0.0144245028,
0.5462105274,
0.7777802348,
-0.1900476962,
0.6755798459,
-0.2893566787,
-0.2865394354,
0.1815463156,
0.1339823306,
-0.0333031341,
0.6077332497,
0.1577907652,
-1.1117795706,
-0.4973605871,
0.1590664089,
-0.6332603693,
0.4490310252,
-0.1345328987,
0.2201979607,
0.0274039805,
0.4316129684,
-0.351038605,
0.4724608958,
0.1568771303,
-0.1586465687,
0.1579293609,
-0.2280989736,
0.0010636877,
-0.8912829161,
-0.3284981847,
-0.1854092032,
-0.3816436231,
-0.4754582047,
0.1332407594,
0.1941945404,
0.0604635738,
-0.3843109608,
0.3687951565,
-0.6817105412,
0.1227770299,
0.1159044877,
-0.0343344659,
0.3294677734,
-0.1491652727,
0.3007446527,
0.4839171767,
0.9594275951,
-0.861415863,
0.1541782469,
0.0449232534,
-0.2957521677,
0.9636259675,
-0.7144291997,
0.308722049,
-0.2318497747,
-0.0518970937,
-0.1679867357,
-0.4088667035,
0.4614157081,
-0.4647520185,
0.9587955475,
-0.153169319,
-0.2125507146,
-0.0486499034,
0.1725918204,
0.5201237202,
0.4058458507,
-0.7262269258,
0.8413150907,
0.1956824511,
0.1885034591,
-0.8865183592,
-0.7974853516,
0.1596252173,
-0.1247552186,
-0.2885116041,
0.6594613791,
0.229648158,
-0.3024302125,
0.3571297526,
-0.5123591423,
-0.6143426895,
0.2704386413,
0.38256073,
-0.0223003682,
-0.3875070214,
0.4667900503,
0.0900413916,
-0.2306780964,
0.0284225419,
-0.6064617634,
0.0284491107,
-0.555434227,
-0.5708049536,
-0.533313036,
0.2476466596,
0.1218636855,
-0.2157873511,
0.8533435464,
0.636444211,
-0.9007437825,
-0.4886811078,
-0.6723248959,
-0.1533194333,
-0.4247506857,
0.3982042968,
-0.4150052369,
-0.9256065488,
0.197587356,
-0.2195787728,
-0.3224870861,
0.5364184976,
-0.1025256366,
-0.0600656569,
0.6315627098,
0.8022426367,
0.2222199291,
0.049409315,
-0.0246759336,
0.3330040872,
-0.6928334236,
-0.4886556864,
-0.2794497609,
-0.1692727208,
-0.2824340761,
-0.3328302205,
-0.0490897372,
0.2439061999,
-0.4351338446,
0.3004103303,
-0.5814798474,
0.4396714568,
0.4809461832,
0.3324684501,
0.2481181622,
-0.0060095591,
-0.0894499868,
0.0030474486,
-0.3103691638,
-0.4887807071,
1.0641337633,
0.4719992578,
0.8944292068,
0.2939014137,
1.2185688019,
0.0399975851,
0.0212838389,
-0.7021571398,
0.3012156188,
0.4241222143,
-0.6167365909,
-0.5294103622,
-0.4179629982,
-0.5668994784,
-0.1544241756,
-0.3499823511,
-0.7420182824,
0.7944270968,
0.0096194791,
-0.7820361257,
0.6066917777,
-0.3620103598,
0.4262508154,
-0.4955063164,
-0.1515067965,
0.0292801876,
-0.6567810774,
-0.1083069071,
-0.1754404157,
-0.0583241135,
0.0374255702,
-0.5108960271,
0.6620292068,
-0.2940205634,
0.4760642052,
-0.1800796837,
0.1938772798,
0.2432320863,
-0.047026068,
0.8639236093,
0.4577067792,
-0.1347907484,
0.4036230445,
-0.2663008571,
0.0825381204,
-0.6997939348,
0.6798279881,
-0.5959231853,
-0.4443484545,
-0.7432724833,
-0.2407781184,
0.0711411685,
0.4653345942,
0.4121387303,
0.3327412009,
-0.325263083,
0.4145041108,
1.3274152279,
-0.1830924898,
0.3900635242,
0.3184829056,
0.1053293049,
-0.5927228332,
0.9118679166,
0.1878213286,
0.1637835652,
0.8049252629,
-0.0734789744,
-0.1363352239,
-0.9956626296,
-0.5349475145,
-0.3199063241,
-0.5589476228,
-0.4048350453,
-0.7492498755,
-0.279343605,
-0.1063044518,
-0.0960614383,
-0.5596777797,
-0.2645345032,
-0.5502443314,
-0.3655384183,
0.3569248319,
0.5829231739,
-0.0021302032,
0.0319041051,
-0.4733159244,
0.2404152751,
0.3368320763,
0.5798356533,
-0.30315727,
-0.3555744588,
0.0706399754,
0.1550113857,
0.2094703466,
-0.8593360186,
0.3392512202,
0.7998187542,
0.6311564445,
0.9091386795,
0.3984092474,
0.6379718781,
-0.5152103305,
0.2510460615,
0.2833046913,
-0.8122998476,
0.5347002745,
0.057965681,
-0.6278347969,
0.8132908344,
0.5422894359,
0.1949342638,
0.198581323,
-0.6006878018,
-0.7440182567,
0.3853136897,
0.1550257206,
-0.2342514396,
0.1736462265,
0.4134687483,
0.3257016838,
0.3890249133,
-0.6330823898,
-0.3497263491,
-0.2649931312,
-0.0727141201,
0.2205034792,
-0.2805041075,
-0.0149449436,
-0.0196586475,
0.6867545247,
0.0292041525,
0.3813779056,
0.6891508698,
-0.3465572,
-0.0901711434,
0.5367776155,
0.2636144757,
0.210617438,
-0.3492996693,
0.3114994764,
0.3466527164,
-0.5367252827,
0.3550031781,
0.3088693619,
-0.5695507526,
-0.0177176353,
0.0469498262,
0.7980672121,
0.063334547,
-0.4378534257,
0.6151857972,
-0.0996911377,
-0.2521853447,
-0.8386945128,
-0.1345530152,
-0.2324260473,
0.3659221232,
0.4429254532,
0.5213443637,
0.5642861724,
-0.1861187071,
0.2792240381,
0.2634423077,
-0.9309927225,
-0.0710996911,
0.6848896146,
-0.0147353914,
-0.1769232452,
0.6231047511,
-0.6691442728,
-0.5325830579,
0.7492231727,
0.5133526921,
1.013461709,
-0.2648293972,
0.0838586912,
0.4373794496,
0.5261511803,
-0.2172455639,
0.3618847132,
0.1383628398,
-0.8598689437,
-0.1176186055,
-0.6070161462,
-0.4084069729,
0.1033543497,
-1.0080956221,
0.1358036697,
-0.7573805451,
-0.2538800538,
-0.0261320136,
-0.3258593082,
-0.9689765573,
0.4245957136,
0.3805305064,
0.6511904597,
-0.4985230267,
0.4847792685,
0.7396380305,
-0.3075043261,
-0.9113610983,
-0.0872591734,
0.0776777565,
-0.4410963058,
0.9279597998,
0.4624550343,
-0.1356779784,
0.0515443869,
-0.3196206987,
-1.1329065561,
1.4033926725,
0.2322430164,
-0.9728153348,
0.1812281907,
-0.1607508808,
0.2476018816,
-0.5396035314,
0.2849840522,
-0.0610841364,
0.6434371471,
-0.1251729429,
-0.6759418249,
0.2689122558,
-0.0234859698,
-0.2145967782,
0.3950409293,
-0.3414670527,
0.9097430706,
-0.6106808186,
-0.5976735353,
-0.0098868962,
0.9432548285,
-0.0928524658,
0.6503304243,
0.5314509869,
0.9138982892,
1.320286274,
-0.312430203,
0.7891992331,
-0.0215552561,
0.2782031894,
1.405282855,
-0.4699535668,
1.0305653811,
0.4796827435,
-0.0714182332,
0.5072618723,
0.4915885329,
-0.3408555388,
0.6418347955,
-0.0700317845,
-0.2890188694,
-0.4949796498,
-0.3839389086,
-0.5190705657,
0.2512201667,
0.6802825332,
-0.5227481723,
-0.013579037,
-0.0213139914,
-0.2609751821,
-0.1381644905,
-0.5384451747,
0.6047708988,
0.2357799262,
-0.0596781857,
0.0081699621,
-0.1586573869,
0.6266022325,
-0.1664802283,
-0.3842502832,
0.5721886158,
0.2659969628,
-0.2749056518,
-0.452490896,
-0.0074560344,
-0.2531122267,
-0.1690083444,
-0.0463741571,
1.0732547045,
-0.2085407376,
-0.5169476867,
0.3247039318,
0.6000406146,
0.1208552271,
-0.3576261401,
-0.5000504851,
-0.520768106,
-0.3787103295,
-0.2580910921,
0.2794620395,
0.6152819395,
0.2202337384,
0.8185759187,
0.5306692123,
-0.0439669043,
0.0301274024,
-0.0312161446,
0.5274448395,
-0.3226154745,
-0.3528910577,
-0.6989662051,
0.19428657,
-0.2659769058,
-0.2574210763,
0.6002008319,
0.4170826077,
1.0143539906,
-0.0038461669,
0.6944378018,
-0.2675969005,
0.4051055312,
-0.451205492,
0.8341828585,
-0.4668713808,
0.2048772424,
-0.0569364652,
-0.8443478942,
-0.3384163082,
0.6962501407,
-0.0395820364,
0.0910008103,
0.6589794755,
0.6473237872,
-0.0244759917,
-0.0587885119,
0.4782450199,
0.2098744214,
-0.0387431085,
0.8230044842,
0.8785003424,
-0.8095146418,
0.4594518542,
-0.5587415099,
0.0275094155,
-0.1858526319,
-1.1272166967,
-0.6334144473,
-0.3013435006,
-0.6572717428,
-0.1139981225,
0.3436283469,
1.027567029,
0.6783360243,
-1.1136430502,
0.7098611593,
-0.5065931678,
0.1677027196,
-0.4884359539,
-0.1501340568,
0.3077475131,
0.2405285388,
-0.663967073,
0.4972938001,
0.2081880569,
0.242927447,
0.0494514145,
-0.3716846108,
0.099258922,
-0.1671991795,
0.1475594938,
0.3249424696,
-0.9891364574,
-0.5144844055,
0.1105024219,
-0.0312116761,
-0.1943790168,
0.1993107498,
-0.73351264,
0.5070774555,
0.3734274507,
0.8879076838,
0.153479293,
-0.2896104455,
0.4920954704,
-0.4691388011,
-0.2951385975,
0.5299472809,
0.5696018338,
0.3271236718,
-0.6841255426,
0.5379072428,
0.0301714931,
-0.5394713283,
-0.9430009127,
0.2489529848,
-1.009765029,
0.2223253548,
0.7820409536,
-0.4923335016,
-0.0403794162,
-0.4117501676,
0.2749656439,
0.1952567399,
-0.7515398264,
0.1918887645,
0.3321190774,
0.1205984578,
-0.2980122864,
-0.559643805,
0.2549141645,
0.0565258525,
-0.4883041978,
-0.5759605765,
0.3361471295,
0.2467344254,
0.3095792532,
0.0554679558,
0.1359335929,
0.2542226017,
0.3680275679,
0.147437498,
-0.6130977273,
-0.7915731668,
-0.4200473428,
0.3260782361,
0.1805522442,
-0.0706138834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17846v1 | Retraining-free Customized ASR for Enharmonic Words Based on a Named-Entity-Aware Model and Phoneme Similarity Estimation | 2023-05-29T02:10:13 | 2023-05-29T02:10:13 | Yui Sudo, Kazuya Hata, Kazuhiro Nakadai | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | End-to-end automatic speech recognition (E2E-ASR) has the potential to
improve performance, but a specific issue that needs to be addressed is the
difficulty it has in handling enharmonic words: named entities (NEs) with the
same pronunciation and part of speech that are spelled differently. This often
occurs with Japanese personal names that have the same pronunciation but
different Kanji characters. Since such NE words tend to be important keywords,
ASR easily loses user trust if it misrecognizes them. To solve these problems,
this paper proposes a novel retraining-free customized method for E2E-ASRs
based on a named-entity-aware E2E-ASR model and phoneme similarity estimation.
Experimental results show that the proposed method improves the target NE
character error rate by 35.7% on average relative to the conventional E2E-ASR
model when selecting personal names as a target NE. | [
-0.2249800861,
-0.3967700303,
0.314797014,
-0.2202171981,
-0.4222583175,
0.2371296734,
-0.4842247963,
-0.5609847307,
0.6889344454,
0.5100408792,
-0.4572570026,
-0.3941702843,
-0.5079943538,
0.3826718926,
-0.1637011617,
0.5348952413,
-0.2663423121,
0.0246842057,
0.0808891058,
-0.3121225536,
-0.5182597041,
-0.1723500043,
-1.1814324856,
-0.4470133185,
0.3582182825,
0.4120363593,
0.3937869668,
0.5118125677,
0.1516983956,
0.3205119967,
-0.0378204584,
0.0938779488,
0.0317189172,
0.2223834246,
-0.1313624382,
-0.6254576445,
-0.5203981996,
-0.2353583872,
0.5164579153,
0.3535573781,
-0.4512450695,
0.1778439283,
0.0309976675,
0.5089403391,
-0.6441631317,
-0.0718102679,
-0.8462843895,
0.0832554623,
-0.1178334951,
-0.359757632,
-0.2617256343,
-0.28418836,
0.1182781085,
-1.0076961517,
0.4084059298,
0.1702045053,
1.0169070959,
0.348136276,
-0.0240358692,
-0.2977657616,
-0.5537739992,
0.8432660103,
-0.8472133279,
0.9367457628,
0.6037472486,
0.504200995,
0.0653847456,
-0.4530653059,
-0.5811017156,
-0.2537270486,
0.1559184045,
0.2924792171,
-0.1069662422,
0.1663668007,
0.3488962948,
0.0156875234,
-0.409011215,
0.1171990484,
0.0705285817,
-0.3400467038,
0.6094762087,
-0.0636064038,
0.5058630109,
0.1342956722,
-0.2687517107,
-0.0012138752,
-0.5976234078,
-0.009613649,
0.5071419477,
0.3726768792,
-0.0168183614,
0.2830990553,
-0.3526073992,
0.3181888163,
0.5404140353,
-0.2066145837,
0.7056592107,
0.2465240657,
-0.3106875718,
0.7267898917,
0.4622869492,
0.408380121,
0.5217386484,
-0.5448333621,
-0.44940418,
-0.0432468094,
0.0549986959,
-0.9166445136,
-0.2281703651,
0.0193004068,
-0.3617472649,
-0.0907543749,
-0.220802024,
-0.5954484344,
-0.1446811855,
-0.4198143184,
0.615127027,
-0.5593476295,
-0.4094914496,
-0.0876301751,
-0.1122334152,
0.1611909419,
0.3480199277,
-0.8719107509,
0.5328415632,
0.4361791611,
0.6045948863,
-0.0276766624,
-0.0590856336,
-0.5467701554,
0.4708387554,
-0.1449078023,
0.6626296043,
-0.830178082,
-0.6408571601,
-0.3863070905,
0.0248955954,
-0.3718011081,
-0.825702548,
0.2887251377,
-0.5377146006,
0.1418615133,
-0.2119171172,
-0.8729992509,
-0.2687638402,
0.1457857043,
-0.4247117341,
0.4960027337,
-0.166961357,
-0.7185840011,
0.4202211797,
-0.3686161339,
-0.2548111379,
0.1925293356,
-0.3229229748,
-0.4510065615,
0.0812545791,
0.1877688318,
-0.0314229541,
-0.3436505198,
0.1219798997,
-0.0351063982,
-0.4836487174,
0.2054810822,
-0.312281698,
0.4745214581,
0.1014637873,
-0.473626107,
0.0360779539,
-1.0549170971,
0.513898313,
-0.0522126034,
-0.3916021883,
-0.6520350575,
-0.0554730892,
-0.0018047014,
-0.2976011634,
0.3782349229,
-0.8783451915,
-0.3889427483,
-0.6282922029,
0.2230049819,
0.5485987067,
0.0853026435,
0.3398072422,
-0.3372482657,
0.5215629339,
-0.0110932803,
-0.2228108793,
0.1004719734,
-0.648923099,
-0.8557316065,
-0.3515007794,
0.5909947157,
0.6854853034,
-0.6144185662,
0.4993356168,
-0.2637107968,
-0.3718942702,
-0.6574842334,
-0.1447508037,
0.7102000117,
0.5086801648,
0.5366889238,
-0.6004279852,
-0.837210536,
-0.9151441455,
-0.8966623545,
0.0313802361,
-0.2643523514,
0.5059622526,
0.1569600105,
-0.5718368888,
0.7413985133,
-0.4041080475,
-0.2705809772,
0.0886602402,
0.0123592643,
-0.1759593189,
0.4179520607,
-0.0361009799,
-0.6174282432,
-0.6953353882,
-0.1561951935,
-0.2810661197,
-0.3126852512,
-0.0482216738,
0.1152736768,
0.0569469556,
0.5090582967,
-0.2575422823,
0.1864316612,
0.1938715875,
-0.2476281226,
0.4357237518,
-0.3075830638,
0.1709405184,
-1.3733942509,
0.1175537258,
0.1651601046,
-0.3052421212,
-0.6235966682,
0.0178004242,
0.1732901484,
-0.0879485607,
-0.1556293666,
0.505851388,
-0.6942797899,
-0.0415580794,
-0.473985523,
0.3541517258,
-0.2618566155,
0.3690876365,
0.1064980701,
0.7155140042,
0.5607709885,
-0.6792234778,
0.1570678502,
0.3282528222,
-0.2845233083,
0.7808657885,
-0.6755810976,
0.511711657,
-0.1534988582,
-0.1031326875,
-0.4344500601,
-0.0602930225,
0.2839430869,
-0.5422364473,
0.6274675727,
-0.0455340967,
-0.1475533098,
0.0981396958,
0.0475302339,
0.2219587117,
0.4795416296,
-0.5268205404,
0.5811615586,
0.3685978055,
-0.0099574178,
-0.357891798,
-0.4917786419,
0.1613866985,
-0.4324852526,
-0.2990038991,
0.8211221099,
-0.0051103788,
0.028768776,
0.0590207912,
-0.2468750328,
-0.392632544,
0.0190235171,
0.3961742222,
-0.1612088531,
-0.0938289389,
0.2411523759,
0.0743330196,
-0.5232810378,
-0.2615907788,
0.0789068788,
0.3847877979,
-0.024255719,
-0.2105187029,
-0.781994164,
0.304389745,
0.2508111596,
-0.448879391,
0.3137852848,
0.562674582,
-0.8069924116,
-0.1427509487,
-0.6570824385,
-0.3605818152,
-0.5366212726,
0.3542467654,
-0.597763896,
-0.832008183,
0.4998853803,
-0.0607391484,
-0.0898401365,
0.0625032932,
0.0690111145,
0.2452313155,
0.8485378623,
0.4841617048,
-0.0520325638,
0.6196793318,
0.0665912628,
0.327581346,
-1.3490619659,
-0.3387839496,
-0.2549258471,
-0.5848261714,
-0.6023182869,
-0.302020967,
0.0020099676,
-0.0484685563,
-0.4373770058,
0.7425789833,
-0.3764821589,
0.3436193466,
0.5234542489,
0.2293917239,
0.4290313721,
0.4193499982,
-0.0866350085,
-0.311264962,
-0.0799270049,
-0.3259512782,
0.8656196594,
0.1301882714,
0.7714155912,
0.1638986915,
1.2026815414,
-0.1389364004,
0.031753283,
-0.7729115486,
0.688113749,
-0.1827767938,
-0.2890712321,
-0.4150696695,
-0.4885031879,
-0.9593357444,
0.0081548672,
0.0185841359,
-0.9230270982,
0.3168995082,
0.2987519205,
-0.554713726,
0.2156024724,
-0.3606333137,
0.2577915192,
-0.1042460725,
0.1881048977,
-0.4062152505,
-0.238217622,
-0.1969976723,
-0.2446133345,
-0.1206263676,
-0.2678045928,
-0.2966988981,
0.9381745458,
-0.4503632486,
0.5108475685,
-0.4387162626,
0.2265629768,
0.2513702214,
-0.0441271253,
0.6783775091,
-0.0689435452,
-0.2386038601,
0.2203413248,
-0.2335049957,
0.2248953581,
-0.6864796281,
0.900767386,
-0.796438098,
-0.5001856685,
-0.0135162724,
-0.0829198882,
-0.3603968024,
0.3234447837,
0.7714465261,
0.4918054044,
-0.1856784523,
0.1218914837,
0.7076638341,
-0.3315684497,
0.2337963134,
0.9068219066,
0.1274059862,
-0.7099538445,
1.0543228388,
0.5314984918,
0.0191363674,
0.4097541273,
0.1998396665,
-0.183911413,
-0.3505800068,
-0.5678015947,
0.1539808363,
-0.1874650568,
-0.2372645885,
-0.8562609553,
-0.1414542347,
-0.1311844289,
-0.2958209515,
-0.5851274133,
-0.3297085166,
-0.4312370121,
0.0779768899,
0.4701107442,
0.0578033291,
0.1576249599,
0.290446043,
-0.5681235194,
0.3842875063,
0.3428985476,
0.7312380672,
0.0351785049,
-0.9817684889,
-0.0663325563,
0.2823318839,
-0.1124476567,
-1.0667021275,
0.617814064,
0.754458487,
0.5600384474,
0.2675868869,
-0.0907813907,
1.0204274654,
-0.8736099005,
0.1844976693,
0.4967918396,
-0.9709920287,
0.6175821424,
0.0315314196,
0.0374299102,
0.6986051202,
0.0750120357,
-0.8099098206,
-0.1525516212,
-0.6979833245,
-1.0191301107,
0.4296759963,
0.1158157438,
0.0115171419,
-0.028587861,
0.4021246135,
-0.0085989526,
0.4261232018,
-0.2178556472,
-0.2461931258,
-0.0781953186,
-0.4276461005,
-0.00904107,
-0.237421304,
0.2623803914,
-0.0646677241,
0.9450684786,
0.036290735,
0.4753432274,
0.313308239,
-0.3243497908,
-0.279386878,
0.3846696019,
0.1639526635,
-0.1575623006,
-0.1371006072,
-0.1707507819,
0.6789411902,
-0.5377435088,
0.3803599179,
-0.0682631731,
-0.5031498671,
0.2625983357,
-0.2499636263,
1.0267902613,
0.6224948168,
-0.5664693117,
0.3425128758,
0.0197009202,
-0.0773241445,
-0.8257568479,
0.2517744899,
0.2090438604,
0.2206847668,
-0.0177707989,
0.1385239959,
0.3365693688,
-0.3120186031,
0.3328790665,
0.3344331086,
-0.5076649785,
-0.40702793,
0.7514899373,
0.29178074,
-0.7679774165,
0.6894571185,
-0.345240891,
-0.3562615812,
0.7270687819,
1.0197808743,
1.4562498331,
-0.7925378084,
-0.0414793268,
0.7265859246,
0.0716493502,
-0.2045565546,
0.5067999959,
0.0749252513,
-1.1197701693,
0.0606278703,
-0.6226972342,
-0.4482893944,
0.0492808446,
-0.9618989825,
0.2410379648,
-0.8212687373,
-0.4232845306,
-0.1437867582,
-0.0340159424,
-0.668091476,
0.5057459474,
0.2308557332,
0.6285182834,
-0.4332775772,
0.7273589373,
0.8058897853,
-0.0733902976,
-1.0906419754,
0.239535585,
-0.0131565286,
-0.6932425499,
0.4179542065,
0.5271311402,
-0.3500148356,
0.4113659859,
0.0835388526,
-1.241904974,
1.2827063799,
0.2712666094,
-1.109588027,
0.0156924855,
-0.1713735312,
0.4726638198,
-0.4637947381,
0.2932775021,
0.4093494415,
0.3468872607,
-0.2803853154,
-1.0947819948,
0.1836856753,
-0.3573950827,
0.2658501267,
0.2851005495,
-0.7850906253,
0.4874127805,
-0.37232548,
-0.5165308714,
-0.0353035107,
0.7160300016,
0.1976636797,
0.4024823606,
0.8073267937,
0.7126809359,
1.1466642618,
0.2285018265,
0.4608905613,
-0.6337903738,
0.2013007253,
1.4288787842,
-0.3466853797,
1.1235860586,
0.1606448591,
-0.0281604622,
0.6157235503,
0.3269040585,
-0.2037869394,
0.6742984056,
0.1913590133,
-0.5420531631,
-0.3795060217,
0.050834626,
-0.3604291379,
0.6010863185,
0.3349531591,
-0.4274990857,
0.0120155122,
-0.0042857593,
-0.0584336482,
0.0025375059,
-0.319840014,
0.7278663516,
0.3534042537,
-0.323599726,
0.4669242501,
0.2921288908,
1.0505774021,
-0.3239575028,
0.3153931201,
0.0413265787,
0.1417175233,
-0.373413831,
-0.0552036837,
0.2927752137,
0.201419577,
-0.1762467474,
0.1700068265,
0.8312191963,
-0.6784132719,
-0.329013288,
0.3108156025,
0.174604252,
0.3376805484,
-0.2118524462,
-0.6154245734,
-0.3652023971,
0.1942042559,
-0.1908835173,
0.3095796406,
0.0002335438,
0.1231235415,
0.7993610501,
0.4463135302,
0.125607565,
0.1079507694,
0.3672501743,
0.2115451097,
-0.6761007309,
-0.6733749509,
-0.6184896231,
0.0275844615,
-0.0788701549,
-0.3475200236,
0.8129900694,
0.5473114848,
0.9094368815,
-0.0819266513,
0.6895651221,
0.215402931,
0.8161430955,
-0.2545934618,
0.844340682,
-0.6293635964,
0.0962308869,
-0.2391301095,
-0.8383431435,
-0.0006093457,
0.8763037324,
-0.1212232113,
0.2088011354,
0.3534784019,
1.0375295877,
0.0776084885,
0.1258196682,
0.6289859414,
-0.024140656,
0.1071983799,
0.6121937037,
0.2573995292,
-0.6703807116,
0.1104218587,
-0.1352142692,
-0.0597271621,
-0.3334059715,
-0.440556258,
-0.5744888186,
-0.4386342466,
-0.8824003339,
-0.0529834554,
0.3273750842,
1.3109223843,
0.2870866954,
-0.9654880762,
0.0658761263,
-0.1429630965,
-0.4230274558,
-0.2742600143,
-0.1099596396,
0.3202057183,
-0.0525535643,
-0.7821993232,
0.6243733168,
0.0475267731,
0.1705106348,
0.4528386891,
-0.2800117433,
0.4327361286,
0.3164556324,
0.3075308502,
0.3480379879,
-0.7207207084,
-0.5356794,
-0.0913849473,
0.0092243338,
0.0164715759,
0.5674232841,
-0.7349078059,
0.6967158914,
0.2518073916,
0.4999838471,
0.1288881153,
-0.0217353888,
0.4531233311,
-0.6833931804,
-0.0811214894,
0.1342330128,
0.5122894049,
0.6610697508,
-0.3837403655,
0.1287886202,
0.372451216,
-0.4584111869,
-0.6877402067,
0.3997181356,
-0.6497734189,
0.2096049786,
1.2031517029,
-0.2066497505,
-0.0314661004,
-0.1416312456,
-0.0193390343,
0.7653279901,
-0.5476878285,
0.6721453071,
0.1312129498,
0.0733140931,
-0.053168904,
-0.4366951585,
0.4342552722,
0.6185520887,
-0.4112886786,
-0.1361616701,
0.1123553291,
0.9181811213,
0.0579560138,
0.7515765429,
0.0609006099,
0.0906725675,
0.0933104604,
0.4211797714,
-0.2829427123,
-0.2231074423,
-0.2993209064,
-0.2174056023,
0.138438046,
-0.4599985182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17826v1 | NOTABLE: Transferable Backdoor Attacks Against Prompt-based NLP Models | 2023-05-28T23:35:17 | 2023-05-28T23:35:17 | Kai Mei, Zheng Li, Zhenting Wang, Yang Zhang, Shiqing Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Prompt-based learning is vulnerable to backdoor attacks. Existing backdoor
attacks against prompt-based models consider injecting backdoors into the
entire embedding layers or word embedding vectors. Such attacks can be easily
affected by retraining on downstream tasks and with different prompting
strategies, limiting the transferability of backdoor attacks. In this work, we
propose transferable backdoor attacks against prompt-based models, called
NOTABLE, which is independent of downstream tasks and prompting strategies.
Specifically, NOTABLE injects backdoors into the encoders of PLMs by utilizing
an adaptive verbalizer to bind triggers to specific words (i.e., anchors). It
activates the backdoor by pasting input with triggers to reach
adversary-desired anchors, achieving independence from downstream tasks and
prompting strategies. We conduct experiments on six NLP tasks, three popular
models, and three prompting strategies. Empirical results show that NOTABLE
achieves superior attack performance (i.e., attack success rate over 90% on all
the datasets), and outperforms two state-of-the-art baselines. Evaluations on
three defenses show the robustness of NOTABLE. Our code can be found at
https://github.com/RU-System-Software-and-Security/Notable. | [
0.0184935164,
-0.6681089997,
0.5747284889,
0.1911737472,
0.1576790512,
0.0959498957,
-0.1130023077,
-0.0624553822,
-0.027092563,
0.526139617,
-0.5907526016,
-0.6062514782,
-0.6913990974,
0.1388549209,
-0.5282919407,
0.8729230762,
0.3439320326,
-0.2479991764,
0.1833806187,
-0.2860721052,
-1.1945394278,
-0.6373957992,
-0.6703342199,
0.1807865053,
0.6049677134,
0.0125928484,
0.7251045108,
0.0393999331,
0.194207713,
0.2045053244,
-0.0955687538,
-0.3692606688,
-0.3118088543,
0.4429034293,
-0.8453215957,
-0.6180201769,
-0.3854020834,
-0.10400749,
0.693277657,
0.3443888128,
0.114825815,
-0.0401958637,
0.2340093553,
0.5926308632,
-0.4978952408,
-0.1041335091,
-0.9889554381,
0.1662351936,
-0.1196297929,
-0.1848324388,
-0.8087586761,
-0.2505020797,
0.0359912924,
-0.3566128314,
0.0902214572,
-0.029365968,
0.4858062863,
0.1840743124,
0.0779730529,
-0.483187288,
-0.0495411642,
0.7530807257,
-0.7146135569,
0.4562855065,
0.1890719086,
0.4578269422,
-0.4619736075,
-0.6807050705,
-0.3108137846,
-0.5243525505,
-0.0362330303,
0.0673780367,
-0.6093766093,
-0.0882707983,
0.6903261542,
-0.0023620003,
-0.7574333549,
0.4778155386,
0.0131612727,
-0.2401814312,
0.1036860496,
0.0935662985,
0.5203101635,
-0.2522254884,
-0.4327067137,
-0.0825048983,
-0.9427214265,
0.4478672445,
0.2181877196,
0.5475422144,
-0.2468063682,
0.3377120793,
-0.1475958228,
0.821723938,
0.0452275611,
0.089305684,
0.1066375002,
-0.1054808646,
0.1811607033,
-0.0417035036,
0.3856640458,
0.1454097033,
-0.0466293916,
-0.3380721211,
-0.4421979487,
-0.0479646064,
0.3844326138,
-0.6087264419,
-0.3108672798,
0.4468862414,
-0.3861935437,
-0.2843030989,
0.1604075879,
-0.7659268379,
-0.3829651475,
0.3566963673,
0.864751339,
-0.5790655613,
0.2092365772,
-0.3585011661,
-0.440454334,
0.3775939941,
0.3851773143,
-0.5890371203,
-0.1568808109,
0.9971318841,
1.1411577463,
-0.2416227162,
-0.4143645465,
-1.2503656149,
0.2223999649,
-0.1787404269,
0.3846734166,
-0.7035799623,
-0.477330476,
0.2055622935,
0.188302651,
-0.201159209,
-0.3084959388,
0.4295386672,
-0.7744319439,
0.1186746433,
-0.4382296503,
-0.4715305865,
-0.2977845967,
0.5485348701,
-0.6746234298,
0.6848861575,
-0.0380310714,
-0.6601524949,
0.1439424753,
-0.3888373077,
-0.4702289701,
0.0495797247,
-0.1315361261,
-0.1733449847,
0.0994965062,
0.3031552732,
0.6221279502,
0.1710562408,
0.0757847801,
-0.1647898853,
-0.3326273859,
0.6239013672,
-0.4116155505,
0.9674753547,
0.0506994799,
-0.5166072249,
0.3774456978,
-0.9366114736,
-0.3658010364,
-0.0981777161,
-0.1571596414,
-0.3704222441,
-0.2989814579,
-0.609538734,
0.2035664618,
0.290527463,
-0.4834338129,
0.2199309468,
-0.4149930179,
0.4367617369,
0.9109591246,
0.2843617201,
0.429045707,
-0.5900614858,
0.734805882,
-0.2431396693,
0.3796361685,
-0.7502743006,
-0.8964888453,
-0.2659272552,
-0.6247822642,
0.1777665317,
0.7651845813,
-0.9348645806,
0.4491798878,
-0.0185406059,
-0.7566217184,
-0.0479828566,
-0.1317273378,
0.3709931374,
0.7560089827,
0.426083684,
-0.2081065327,
-0.0022614258,
-0.4833647609,
-0.814919889,
-0.070177637,
-0.1732634157,
0.3219242096,
0.3200132549,
-0.1824371368,
0.7813945413,
-0.257342428,
-0.2457168251,
-0.084188886,
0.0256943852,
0.4530948997,
0.7168883681,
0.8509110808,
-0.3685580492,
-0.4116193354,
-0.3427686691,
-0.7810360789,
-0.2155149728,
-0.6059866548,
0.0641923398,
-0.2936842144,
0.4358453751,
-0.672021687,
0.5070050955,
0.5599581599,
-0.4340454042,
0.5090444088,
0.0299511217,
-0.0482172258,
-0.9188399315,
0.0821052715,
-0.3137498796,
-0.2645793259,
-0.6440158486,
0.528570056,
0.1848017126,
-0.5326744914,
-0.5092069507,
0.6336981058,
-0.2668805122,
-0.2581041753,
-0.0374683663,
-0.1149288639,
-0.0981336087,
0.625372529,
-0.206397742,
0.770286262,
1.0839284658,
-0.6949056387,
0.3830625415,
0.3798218668,
-0.0112242475,
0.607452929,
-0.7399961352,
0.3060104549,
0.3980620205,
0.3142415285,
-1.0183668137,
0.2401100099,
0.7375585437,
-0.7260807753,
0.4989872575,
-0.3941167295,
-0.2793316841,
0.0063947896,
-0.5838019848,
-0.0711175352,
0.7677848935,
-0.9359095693,
0.778616786,
-0.206253469,
-0.4742117822,
-0.5336795449,
-0.5222635269,
0.3506196737,
-0.2238617688,
-0.416377008,
0.2134593278,
0.0190382879,
0.2100587338,
-0.2963160872,
-0.0425603837,
0.2109930813,
0.3751873672,
0.4598767757,
0.1659371853,
-0.1067866832,
-0.1296076775,
0.0473052748,
-0.0856493711,
0.3192829192,
-0.4513793886,
0.3180097342,
0.2271052301,
-0.470983237,
-0.7072951198,
0.4176042974,
0.6799492836,
-0.1208694726,
0.8030838966,
0.4065613747,
-0.2730396688,
-0.480099529,
-0.4058228135,
-0.6708880663,
-0.5100732446,
0.3507886529,
-0.4897331893,
-0.8036328554,
0.6822865009,
-0.0367531106,
0.575387001,
0.0662192628,
0.2750677168,
0.2132708281,
0.8327805996,
0.4392966628,
0.0527009442,
0.6787049174,
0.133791104,
-0.1443689167,
-0.6801139116,
-0.1470460147,
-0.6257126331,
-0.1458595991,
-0.4403706789,
-0.1594293118,
-0.0476025976,
-0.1243700534,
-0.0882416964,
0.4978202283,
-0.3698205352,
-0.0740445703,
0.6518310308,
0.1511571556,
0.1969099343,
0.0107853347,
-0.1725112051,
-0.1732397527,
-0.8206403255,
-0.3784852028,
1.0698430538,
0.6238711476,
0.9161734581,
0.2747633159,
0.549061954,
0.5945236087,
0.1877609491,
-0.6876772046,
0.7411723733,
-0.0880549997,
-0.2101801485,
-0.0816028416,
-0.3498484492,
-0.9122111797,
-0.0272147395,
-0.1997722685,
-0.732445538,
0.3390411735,
0.0202284753,
-0.5912429094,
0.3533832431,
-0.7017740607,
0.6562158465,
-0.1173198745,
-0.2771530151,
-0.1402473003,
-0.6813210845,
0.0429607853,
-0.3334246874,
0.1351580769,
0.1505812854,
-0.0070590344,
0.9295277596,
-0.3151780963,
1.1479138136,
-0.5488278866,
0.0027140274,
-0.0549078286,
0.2734342217,
0.9771514535,
0.2236168832,
0.1007208079,
0.469329834,
-0.2447666973,
-0.4335743189,
-0.8494854569,
0.6990843415,
-0.4737939537,
-1.0585786104,
-0.5006006956,
-0.3272948861,
-0.2047053576,
0.1067946553,
0.3087362349,
0.5323600769,
0.1088405997,
0.0953780636,
0.7595286369,
-0.6186685562,
0.5810328722,
0.703856945,
-0.0032817197,
-0.3608434498,
1.0806561708,
0.1409166902,
0.2880898416,
0.5205903649,
0.2274364531,
-0.0503676943,
-0.6956780553,
-0.3073643148,
0.0526367538,
-0.7549085021,
-0.3069472909,
-0.7942042947,
-0.254229635,
-0.5263846517,
-0.4500530064,
-0.3499317765,
-0.4713864923,
-0.3233587146,
0.0928855985,
0.4813795686,
0.5090423822,
-0.0582953468,
0.4268651903,
-1.0840045214,
0.2041254342,
0.7063896656,
-0.0477474779,
0.1233121529,
-1.2315096855,
0.0604513995,
-0.4459986985,
-0.0368705206,
-1.3248971701,
0.3682442605,
0.0823557228,
0.7993263602,
0.446429342,
0.2930712104,
0.0965370089,
-0.4954091907,
0.9331566691,
0.2260251194,
-0.8875653148,
0.753229022,
-0.2425469309,
0.2978738546,
0.3767846823,
0.3341329992,
-0.3371591568,
-0.5557115674,
-0.615863502,
-0.7027177811,
0.5372517705,
0.072775729,
0.2815866172,
0.1576037854,
0.3225033879,
0.5222320557,
0.251958698,
-0.4908260405,
-0.1434669346,
-0.3194978833,
0.1878921539,
0.4212954938,
-0.3695506454,
-0.0539678074,
0.2714777887,
0.7055747509,
0.0741500929,
0.0447718948,
0.1943938732,
-0.4138542414,
0.5980780125,
0.4507325292,
0.4194790423,
0.5207937956,
-0.0854645446,
0.0430167131,
0.2637893856,
-0.6471183896,
-0.0785702094,
0.2892337143,
-0.5142557621,
0.2541929483,
0.4927719235,
0.5459507108,
0.4331970215,
-0.4624655247,
0.718111515,
-0.1933366209,
0.3316649795,
-0.2397088856,
0.197368741,
-0.5169644356,
0.3976825774,
0.5610799193,
0.2623091638,
-0.0340144448,
-0.5598243475,
0.3591897488,
0.4676660299,
-0.6990141273,
-0.6972703338,
0.3652209938,
0.2940171957,
-0.4826559424,
0.4685324132,
-0.0714936927,
-0.8394036293,
0.2669555247,
0.5764540434,
0.9045371413,
-0.4697624445,
-0.0081438283,
0.2426746339,
0.5421796441,
0.0696857423,
0.1623704433,
-0.2060445398,
-0.4617295563,
-0.0887505263,
-0.2011499703,
-0.639251709,
-0.0811051726,
-0.6258273721,
0.2195091099,
-0.9132571816,
-0.1791607738,
-0.2957668006,
-0.4937537611,
-0.4802250266,
-0.1845925599,
-0.1510521621,
1.0384602547,
-0.881588757,
0.6268650293,
0.6847090721,
-0.2553363442,
-0.5734093189,
0.0422539227,
-0.1001508981,
-0.937718451,
0.5859687924,
0.3186141849,
0.1797704846,
0.0339209624,
-0.3992328644,
-0.554964602,
0.8642419577,
0.3796917498,
-0.6536883712,
-0.2130745649,
-0.4404565394,
-0.0794092789,
-0.0828623101,
-0.0599025004,
0.2777436674,
0.3285829425,
-0.0520481765,
-0.7132049203,
0.5206528902,
0.0971324295,
-0.2713900506,
-0.3035430908,
-0.5211919546,
0.8505299687,
-0.1413062662,
-0.3012414575,
0.2759810686,
0.8484962583,
0.6907362342,
0.5378735065,
0.3135267198,
0.6328396201,
0.7098501325,
0.1157454774,
0.7854123116,
-0.3203961551,
-0.2393474579,
1.2410339117,
-0.2634756267,
0.8215534687,
0.3766604364,
-0.0666662902,
0.5197053552,
0.1888764501,
-0.3715829849,
0.6449457407,
-0.1466111839,
-0.1742907614,
0.0917235017,
-0.0372740105,
-0.7250503302,
0.2300387174,
0.4468307793,
-0.491019696,
-0.2579255104,
0.3813140988,
0.1794241667,
0.0656128004,
-0.5439019203,
0.6873189807,
0.2780278921,
-0.5906012654,
0.2044133246,
-0.1076321453,
0.9401703477,
-0.9002199173,
-0.2179788947,
-0.1767782718,
-0.1034401208,
-0.2473151535,
-0.6527841687,
0.062615633,
0.1173580736,
0.0138270734,
-0.2287014276,
0.879737556,
0.0690625235,
0.0992007852,
0.0653681979,
0.4036598802,
0.1356317997,
-0.3101420701,
-0.7844523191,
0.0437053405,
0.0545412563,
-0.160232082,
0.5479521751,
0.3738831878,
-0.0118282847,
0.5987556577,
0.8690202832,
0.2656383812,
0.265091598,
0.081823647,
0.9056987762,
-0.8262274265,
-1.1356163025,
-0.9030001163,
0.2938807309,
-0.0178650897,
-0.0888969973,
1.3833303452,
0.3193279803,
0.5093548298,
-0.1118460372,
0.6245648861,
0.3200137615,
0.4584263861,
-0.7716223598,
0.9272135496,
0.1023474187,
0.5402622223,
-0.3017948568,
-0.7589666843,
-0.1257882416,
0.2652503252,
-0.2858785987,
-0.0896343142,
0.6147943735,
0.9068552256,
0.4533845484,
0.0255172234,
0.5749884248,
0.3573353589,
0.5399924517,
0.5371825099,
1.1522344351,
-0.094112359,
0.4225811362,
0.0540309511,
-0.5294801593,
-0.1180943027,
-0.953794539,
-1.3138486147,
-0.2217862606,
-0.4867585301,
-0.5536610484,
0.5759385824,
0.4750399292,
0.4895410836,
-0.9711213708,
0.3890618086,
-0.0236502551,
0.4046881497,
-0.3606210053,
-0.2438777983,
0.3938853443,
-0.3308702409,
-0.1556664407,
0.7475113869,
0.3176629841,
-0.1069131568,
-0.1625535637,
0.236784175,
-0.0084808078,
-0.0904114544,
0.4214196801,
0.7826341987,
-0.6750414371,
-0.472327739,
-0.0883100703,
-0.036294993,
-0.2666914463,
0.7376931906,
-1.1143906116,
0.2443204671,
0.6724464893,
1.0916662216,
-0.3013638556,
-0.0721308291,
0.6024961472,
-1.0120404959,
0.1745928377,
0.3066323102,
0.352481097,
0.4938798845,
-0.5780485272,
0.0721351728,
0.5520629883,
-0.342125982,
-0.8288944364,
0.3153472841,
-0.9639506936,
-0.4504399896,
1.0666482449,
-0.6032173634,
-0.3407366872,
-0.3358994722,
-0.0316389501,
-0.0153580653,
-0.7908945084,
0.6819585562,
0.4051892459,
0.2277807146,
0.0243917964,
-0.5971678495,
0.4075933099,
0.6011033654,
-0.4033849835,
0.0822367072,
0.3268353343,
0.3083125651,
0.1523508728,
-0.0341531858,
-0.2597866952,
0.6447484493,
0.0619090348,
-0.3481746316,
-0.3323082924,
-0.3441707194,
-0.8784071803,
0.5355710983,
0.1118397713,
-0.3681678176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17819v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17819v2 | Large Language Models, scientific knowledge and factuality: A systematic analysis in antibiotic discovery | 2023-05-28T22:46:21 | 2023-12-05T09:51:55 | Magdalena Wysocka, Oskar Wysocki, Maxime Delmas, Vincent Mutel, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Inferring over and extracting information from Large Language Models (LLMs)
trained on a large corpus of scientific literature can potentially drive a new
era in biomedical research, reducing the barriers for accessing existing
medical evidence. This work examines the potential of LLMs for dialoguing with
biomedical background knowledge, using the context of antibiotic discovery. The
systematic analysis is applied to ten state-of-the-art models, from models
specialised on biomedical scientific corpora to general models such as ChatGPT,
GPT-4 and Llama 2 in two prompting-based tasks: chemical compound definition
generation and chemical compound-fungus relation determination. The work
provides a systematic assessment on the ability of LLMs to encode and express
these relations, verifying for fluency, prompt-alignment, semantic coherence,
factual knowledge and specificity of generated responses. Results show that
while recent models have improved in fluency, factual accuracy is still low and
models are biased towards over-represented entities. The ability of LLMs to
serve as biomedical knowledge bases is questioned, and the need for additional
systematic evaluation frameworks is highlighted. The best performing GPT-4
produced a factual definition for 70% of chemical compounds and 43.6% factual
relations to fungi, whereas the best open source model BioGPT-large 30% of the
compounds and 30% of the relations for the best-performing prompt. The results
show that while LLMs are currently not fit for purpose to be used as biomedical
factual knowledge bases, there is a promising emerging property in the
direction of factuality as the models become domain specialised, scale-up in
size and level of human feedback. | [
-0.0533331856,
-0.9440852404,
1.17299366,
-0.2830371857,
0.0321894996,
0.0864449441,
-0.19217363,
-0.5700727701,
0.3236328959,
0.4911925793,
-0.2480816543,
-0.6548650265,
-0.7879635096,
0.4273867905,
-0.4550965726,
1.0588946342,
0.1544809341,
0.3533673584,
-0.3880847991,
-0.1783427745,
0.0016956504,
-0.7299520969,
-0.3297941685,
-0.4115213454,
0.863943994,
0.1358483732,
0.4157263041,
0.5865561962,
0.7306485772,
0.2748647928,
-0.4051239491,
0.2217741311,
-0.3470796049,
0.0877342746,
-0.6689725518,
-0.6758052707,
-0.5856954455,
0.0120749194,
0.7053428888,
0.9741988778,
0.0140718874,
0.3241382837,
-0.3754676878,
0.4761802852,
-0.1596896946,
0.1738993973,
-0.5143417716,
0.0065128128,
-0.1473530978,
-0.1592703611,
-0.3595945835,
-0.1763763428,
0.5206056833,
-0.7063768506,
0.2695946991,
0.2104322314,
0.7428039908,
-0.0230907425,
-0.4952782989,
-0.6032540798,
-0.4881826639,
0.5639096498,
-1.0558390617,
0.4808546603,
0.100520201,
0.0407663733,
-0.4909994602,
-0.8954966068,
-0.5347946286,
-0.6603294611,
-0.167061165,
-0.0294453092,
-0.1213515848,
0.192079708,
0.5517292023,
0.377930969,
-0.4724330604,
0.0066689248,
-0.6995162964,
-0.2075869292,
0.2190393955,
0.0400829129,
0.4564212859,
-0.1365721673,
-0.4135629237,
0.2888810635,
-0.9231527448,
0.0805188566,
0.1016122848,
0.2373982519,
-0.0114489952,
0.591224432,
-0.0366438441,
0.4169535637,
-0.039878808,
-0.4122518897,
0.1652464718,
-0.6326995492,
-0.1690127701,
-0.0294600502,
0.7355587482,
0.3413508236,
0.1519604474,
-0.0489438102,
-0.132566005,
0.2678541839,
0.1753134876,
-0.9678403139,
-0.1555427611,
0.3189923167,
-0.3530551791,
-0.1834307313,
-0.0341424011,
-0.5994560122,
-0.2037197948,
-0.3799653053,
0.1583787501,
-0.3960218728,
-0.2350036949,
0.1188225523,
-0.1975083053,
-0.1147993058,
0.3260739744,
-0.7123593688,
0.411979109,
0.6109445691,
0.8992707729,
-0.2878949344,
-0.0022652957,
-0.4635691643,
0.3233951032,
-0.5058278441,
0.8667239547,
-0.4718848765,
-0.5494044423,
0.0324105583,
0.2493052483,
-0.0439956784,
-0.7590799332,
0.5183511376,
-0.4836309254,
-0.0430053435,
-0.6624392867,
-0.771609962,
-0.143775925,
0.1466985941,
-0.5123800635,
0.3907089233,
0.0062992484,
-1.0248686075,
0.287560463,
-0.7194500566,
-0.3475478292,
0.2088081241,
-0.2867183983,
-0.0910047293,
-0.0569935106,
-0.1518926471,
0.2651409209,
-0.3920798898,
0.8067028522,
-0.4267852604,
-0.2025907338,
0.6365648508,
-0.0846827254,
0.6620956659,
0.184552893,
-0.1331659108,
0.050893534,
-0.5407196283,
-0.4859012961,
-0.1447422057,
-0.345463872,
-0.1881480664,
0.0272672512,
-0.4389727712,
-0.0547302142,
0.1949403882,
-0.8899008632,
0.4371184111,
-0.6699357629,
0.6357902288,
0.4408590794,
0.1965233684,
0.2542371452,
-0.276430279,
0.2272035033,
0.0916620791,
0.1083056778,
-0.328080833,
-0.6331249475,
-0.5991880894,
-0.3796234429,
0.5462666154,
0.5952544808,
-0.4012506306,
0.2659324706,
-0.3368883133,
-0.1830686629,
-0.3629279733,
0.330158025,
0.2502423227,
0.6687266827,
0.3490990698,
-0.4286642969,
-0.4680127501,
-1.0806061029,
0.0363602489,
-0.4173526168,
0.0568973422,
0.2112539709,
0.8235363364,
-0.8416572213,
0.835596621,
-0.4576694965,
0.056587629,
-0.1669175029,
0.0460525863,
0.5124752522,
0.1618399769,
0.323579073,
-0.610375762,
-0.0584421977,
0.2495138347,
-0.9270423055,
-0.2371110022,
0.3907319009,
0.0674141571,
0.0372331329,
0.4326047301,
-0.9225270748,
0.1469002217,
0.2308605611,
0.016376581,
0.4488969743,
-0.1717146486,
0.085069254,
-0.8359904289,
0.3217816055,
0.0901827961,
-0.0826334432,
-0.9621062875,
0.0369692743,
-0.0322476886,
0.1489848942,
-0.2198091,
0.6656133533,
-0.3451313376,
0.1286599934,
-0.2118449956,
0.10511446,
-0.0064893956,
0.1330306232,
0.1060432419,
0.4558460712,
0.3628178835,
-0.4659668803,
0.5585620999,
0.1928301305,
-0.1229938567,
0.1853128821,
-0.6840501428,
-0.2547097206,
0.0086673927,
0.5312767029,
-0.9419198632,
-0.5339143276,
0.3029985428,
-0.3942685723,
0.3423916996,
-0.3194532394,
-0.6142585278,
-0.5066997409,
-0.062082205,
0.2838231027,
0.4200437665,
-0.3321009576,
0.3059898317,
0.4103474617,
-0.6015977859,
-0.3305239081,
-0.4493540227,
0.0734171495,
-0.0341849625,
-0.7293866873,
0.0425047837,
-0.0974365249,
-0.650193572,
-0.1200604662,
-0.2960292101,
0.0096456772,
-0.1573496461,
0.1427642107,
0.6231626868,
-0.3768844306,
0.422586441,
-0.0138559071,
-0.0003903717,
0.341909796,
-0.2840366364,
0.138668254,
-0.0905669183,
-0.378595978,
-0.0724168047,
0.247643292,
0.6657220721,
0.0450227447,
0.4725913405,
0.424576968,
-0.2740316689,
-0.0662894472,
-0.5240202546,
-0.4333191812,
-0.3696142137,
0.2323810756,
0.0582123995,
-0.724747479,
0.4531705081,
-0.3460797369,
0.0283359829,
0.4291911125,
0.6449437737,
-0.1009129658,
0.4361177385,
0.5124208331,
0.0761924684,
-0.1282195896,
-0.2251762748,
0.4073968232,
-0.501020968,
-0.3483173251,
-0.2128107548,
0.284149766,
-0.4159209728,
-0.6414253116,
0.6766186953,
-0.2414004803,
-0.0991733149,
-0.0888312086,
-0.1077586114,
0.0054958984,
0.4720793366,
0.2372718006,
0.3692176044,
0.0256842952,
-0.4847847521,
0.2999781668,
-0.8621710539,
-0.7656508684,
1.2231469154,
0.6870433092,
0.4357782602,
0.0267193951,
0.3383897543,
0.2502321899,
0.4690719843,
-0.7920607924,
0.5401441455,
-0.0160443261,
-0.8998480439,
-0.1540617496,
-0.4963580966,
-0.6989075541,
-0.0620641112,
-0.4239155054,
-0.5913555622,
0.0824007019,
-0.0033805252,
-0.5704603791,
0.3514639735,
-0.7397888303,
0.4092527032,
-0.240150556,
-0.4014250338,
-0.0064786253,
-1.0489397049,
0.5472340584,
-0.3308831453,
0.5891394615,
-0.0015099184,
0.0448981859,
0.8094418645,
-0.3533167839,
1.1249212027,
0.1048476622,
-0.4307344854,
0.3239753246,
0.0209063496,
0.2536016703,
0.2716202736,
-0.0062869671,
0.2532861531,
0.3390414119,
-0.2955394387,
-0.5373836756,
0.6968557239,
-0.5695574284,
-0.9339776039,
-0.554328382,
-0.4173636138,
-0.2508707345,
0.1475786865,
0.2546683252,
0.6432671547,
-0.3580537736,
0.1173848733,
1.0537552834,
-0.4193925261,
0.0327843204,
0.8572530746,
-0.3006479442,
-0.3359991312,
0.7057218552,
0.2300198078,
0.3603270352,
0.4833488762,
0.1691825837,
-0.3369614482,
-0.6982592344,
-0.4374538064,
0.591789186,
-0.6729825735,
-0.1263441145,
-0.847211659,
-0.3614163697,
-0.6804609299,
0.1452497989,
-0.1078186929,
-0.2274829894,
-0.0698953122,
-0.4027685821,
0.4990407526,
1.2235697508,
-0.2257643938,
0.0832557902,
-0.9415906668,
0.4360285997,
0.0600909181,
0.1406460553,
-0.3199924827,
-0.4747627378,
-0.3244078457,
0.2063468248,
-0.1783679575,
-0.9835613966,
0.3788485825,
-0.0279459339,
0.727324307,
0.6280005574,
-0.235072121,
0.0592000782,
-0.5816155076,
0.7557483315,
0.0946466476,
-0.574015975,
0.4370408952,
-0.6843298674,
-0.0173445549,
0.1230389029,
0.6339613795,
-0.357098639,
-0.3207359612,
-0.6954640746,
-0.7509084344,
0.2475538552,
0.0722427368,
-0.2344739735,
-0.0517412238,
0.3551569283,
0.1369441599,
0.1818927228,
-0.4220809937,
-0.1402443051,
0.0928656608,
-0.2304351926,
-0.0455601588,
-0.5114084482,
-0.5873267651,
-0.1992779374,
0.5155374408,
0.0064892527,
0.1109963879,
0.5067732334,
0.0487265177,
-0.1407015771,
0.4714789093,
0.5077819228,
0.8094555736,
-0.3201390207,
0.2648020387,
0.2839364409,
-0.5592805743,
0.1174938381,
0.0759495646,
-0.1138279065,
0.0309369639,
0.7963498235,
0.3288300931,
0.1962719262,
-0.9543980956,
0.4082683921,
0.38413468,
-0.2075016797,
-0.0509023294,
0.0001329241,
0.2271468192,
0.3704510629,
0.419547081,
0.1023974419,
0.3712956905,
-0.9005014896,
0.3244551718,
0.3484531939,
0.0287365187,
-0.5269160271,
0.2347721606,
0.1213904917,
0.057710927,
0.1798377931,
0.0291319005,
-0.6001982689,
0.5796017647,
0.590975821,
0.3156100512,
-0.2332669348,
0.2420676351,
0.4769525528,
0.0938841477,
-0.0457550474,
-0.1334443539,
0.1938828677,
-0.7456409931,
-0.1974245906,
-0.6996523142,
-0.6660938263,
0.0676449686,
-0.2681361139,
0.2019951791,
-0.5178551078,
-0.4180993438,
0.2690674961,
0.1327982992,
-0.1750611812,
0.1848697066,
0.0525857434,
0.8810728192,
-0.8941428065,
0.8220251203,
0.5724788904,
-0.3941084743,
-0.5694852471,
-0.303963989,
0.1602092832,
-0.5678837895,
1.0108433962,
-0.0450779758,
-0.0414125249,
-0.5627866983,
-0.5885455608,
-0.9214336276,
1.0226781368,
0.1976399124,
-0.7664242983,
-0.1914715469,
0.1239358038,
0.7788469791,
-0.5759217143,
0.3230556548,
0.5210319757,
0.5527563691,
0.1944577992,
-0.8445384502,
0.1570243388,
-0.5202785134,
-0.2024996877,
-0.1475270092,
-0.3675169945,
0.8638433218,
-0.419195354,
-0.2201069146,
0.1840498298,
0.4583108425,
0.4910007119,
0.505315721,
0.1003410071,
0.2022189051,
0.9940747619,
0.0613209531,
0.9817807674,
-0.2748628259,
-0.1277111024,
0.7825841308,
-0.5292458534,
0.7987564206,
0.4614524245,
-0.1724959016,
0.5702578425,
0.7657166123,
-0.1914749295,
0.1731431037,
0.4335231483,
-0.4211285114,
-0.0771844909,
-0.1912727356,
-0.4483596087,
-0.1453111619,
0.7815063596,
-0.6048458219,
0.0827471092,
-0.1685760915,
0.1399988979,
-0.0911195949,
-0.2264572829,
0.7992938161,
0.3229938447,
-0.6469711065,
0.5322391987,
-0.1029493585,
0.3393101096,
-0.6819370389,
-0.1151862293,
-0.1833611131,
0.0438198969,
-0.3456709385,
-0.5861712694,
-0.0502483658,
-0.0026670364,
-0.4498672187,
0.1389375478,
0.7682999372,
-0.4924103022,
-0.6375401616,
0.4073103964,
0.5587856174,
0.1831293553,
0.3673954904,
-0.1484878063,
-0.0922564715,
-0.0108331628,
-0.0384155475,
0.1554809213,
0.5638439655,
-0.0664167255,
0.727918148,
0.9077153802,
0.4632839859,
-0.0853882432,
-0.081144616,
0.9698466659,
-0.5940458775,
0.0627743602,
-0.7976663709,
0.1195458099,
0.0089025162,
0.0924549773,
0.7614285946,
0.4683528543,
0.5665586591,
-0.1439443231,
1.0632102489,
0.4684723318,
0.7991128564,
-0.6458147764,
0.545823276,
-0.2208151668,
0.4484606385,
-0.2115725726,
-0.4646939933,
-0.2245223075,
0.1989079714,
-0.4306683838,
-0.2407979518,
0.9333859086,
0.7684269547,
-0.0972678438,
0.1652160436,
0.2104647756,
0.7856536508,
0.2891080081,
0.3646428883,
0.9035900831,
-0.0982309952,
-0.0405172259,
0.1905210912,
-0.4409231842,
-0.1481801867,
-0.5948243737,
-1.0556406975,
-0.3781889975,
-0.0292674452,
-0.3214261234,
0.410751164,
1.1481385231,
0.4738609195,
-0.8757508993,
-0.3247255087,
0.1314825714,
0.0419182926,
0.4690742195,
-0.0871391296,
0.1588397324,
-0.3506753445,
-0.2662306726,
0.6083195806,
0.3812994659,
0.1638668925,
-0.2555709779,
0.0051875864,
-0.2749806046,
0.3908033073,
0.8310084939,
0.3731970787,
-0.8895256519,
0.1105645373,
0.2069003582,
-0.2066293061,
0.0049693463,
0.8432348967,
-0.5225528479,
0.1763302237,
0.3679976761,
0.4901305735,
0.3386850655,
-0.1780722737,
0.9473404288,
-0.1442501098,
-0.0752196535,
0.0988285616,
0.6614032388,
0.3853885531,
-0.2324551046,
0.6262836456,
0.5804277062,
-0.4366535246,
-0.7875288725,
0.2541783154,
-0.8982537985,
-0.4504508376,
1.5113618374,
-0.2306908667,
-0.3728992045,
-0.1393119246,
-0.3690005839,
0.1995530576,
-0.3996766508,
0.5337754488,
0.7134648561,
0.0680614039,
0.1906647384,
-0.7528885007,
0.5084347129,
0.1070864946,
-0.6733097434,
0.0785486102,
0.5611985922,
0.466627568,
0.4420728981,
0.6315113306,
-0.1992191821,
0.1152929515,
-0.189970389,
-0.1009992585,
0.0908405185,
-0.4492593408,
-0.0268852264,
0.0699463859,
0.1313605458,
0.5374450684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17817v1 | Transfer Learning for Power Outage Detection Task with Limited Training Data | 2023-05-28T22:36:35 | 2023-05-28T22:36:35 | Olukunle Owolabi | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP | Early detection of power outages is crucial for maintaining a reliable power
distribution system. This research investigates the use of transfer learning
and language models in detecting outages with limited labeled data. By
leveraging pretraining and transfer learning, models can generalize to unseen
classes.
Using a curated balanced dataset of social media tweets related to power
outages, we conducted experiments using zero-shot and few-shot learning. Our
hypothesis is that Language Models pretrained with limited data could achieve
high performance in outage detection tasks over baseline models. Results show
that while classical models outperform zero-shot Language Models, few-shot
fine-tuning significantly improves their performance. For example, with 10%
fine-tuning, BERT achieves 81.3% accuracy (+15.3%), and GPT achieves 74.5%
accuracy (+8.5%). This has practical implications for analyzing and localizing
outages in scenarios with limited data availability.
Our evaluation provides insights into the potential of few-shot fine-tuning
with Language Models for power outage detection, highlighting their strengths
and limitations. This research contributes to the knowledge base of leveraging
advanced natural language processing techniques for managing critical
infrastructure. | [
-0.2298169285,
-0.6257691383,
0.6158452034,
-0.0333371423,
-0.4054892659,
-0.0664709285,
-0.4489616752,
-0.4406087101,
-0.30094257,
0.4700213075,
-0.5302728415,
-0.2016912401,
-0.7284686565,
-0.0569718406,
-0.5253760815,
1.0385996103,
-0.1394123435,
-0.1016809493,
0.3924171031,
-0.0420793109,
-0.5761914849,
-0.0532321259,
-0.4703266919,
-0.8478099108,
-0.1467979103,
0.7304844856,
0.793461442,
-0.0766685754,
0.8447750211,
0.1627833247,
0.5740992427,
0.2524149716,
-0.7702577114,
-0.1696315855,
-0.2329948246,
-0.1290098578,
-0.0411140658,
-0.2303293645,
0.8024737239,
0.6395530701,
-0.008057354,
0.0966876,
0.1769856811,
0.7356900573,
-0.5320868492,
0.3419736922,
-1.0903728008,
-0.0469898842,
-0.195555985,
-0.3195315599,
-0.540483892,
-0.2069206089,
0.2893784046,
-0.564201355,
0.2858971655,
-0.1313333362,
1.1252114773,
0.3012555838,
-0.3759412169,
0.0116817802,
-0.7717109323,
0.8857198358,
-0.4954920113,
0.2131253481,
0.6060906649,
0.5026441813,
0.039358478,
-0.5801963806,
-0.5428981781,
-0.0544354543,
-0.1808326393,
0.0920135453,
-0.5464637876,
0.0109781846,
0.2447082847,
-0.2274161428,
-0.3601787984,
0.1804570258,
-0.3266942799,
0.1121279746,
0.6659775972,
0.1079821363,
-0.0462607667,
-0.549267292,
-0.3478280902,
0.1055807173,
-0.5455821753,
-0.1063762158,
0.3249354362,
0.5935441852,
-0.3242140412,
0.1402560174,
0.1453360319,
0.7440707088,
-0.144197911,
0.2179297805,
-0.1196406037,
-0.1754741818,
-0.5726220608,
0.0638244003,
0.850705564,
0.1952121258,
0.554944098,
-0.2301337719,
-0.1120931059,
-0.5827138424,
0.2614473999,
-0.66410321,
-0.6589123607,
-0.2538216114,
-0.68966645,
-0.2988342941,
0.0973214805,
-0.4735984504,
-0.6426923871,
-0.1533608437,
0.6976254582,
-0.6850575209,
-0.4993506968,
0.1946779639,
0.1164040044,
-0.0618556589,
0.1197796166,
-0.8661363721,
0.2860865593,
0.2502633631,
1.1273882389,
-0.0714960173,
-0.1495518088,
-0.5465923548,
-0.0139868548,
-0.2293208241,
0.9916148782,
-0.2584034503,
-0.23454386,
-0.016136704,
0.3267528713,
-0.3400775194,
-0.3731564879,
0.351216048,
-0.3783148229,
-0.3221907616,
-0.0724361539,
-0.5364772677,
-0.0164900199,
-0.1589636803,
-0.4900706708,
0.8036623597,
0.4702033699,
-0.8569350839,
0.3465591967,
-0.7174260616,
-0.5327478051,
0.1949816942,
0.2595688403,
-0.7077322006,
0.1041135117,
-0.0991347954,
0.712180078,
-0.1341108382,
-0.0269437265,
-0.3511786759,
-0.2569400668,
0.0262558851,
-0.2839646935,
0.6159287691,
0.3126342595,
-0.1816608906,
-0.0852816626,
-0.928702414,
0.0898998827,
0.1546083093,
-0.0636087134,
-0.317358166,
0.087533325,
0.1271455139,
-0.0561025329,
-0.0764516145,
-0.5484875441,
0.0430571511,
-0.3808534145,
0.2791630924,
0.7243812084,
0.0414101854,
0.6909133196,
-0.4653782845,
0.4294867218,
0.058114849,
0.0693330169,
-0.0182182789,
-0.2445195913,
-0.7631120682,
0.3065185249,
0.1331562251,
0.5866160989,
-0.7916533351,
0.7675914168,
-0.2967584133,
-0.466093272,
-0.5467748046,
0.2306737751,
-0.1833969653,
0.80367589,
0.6223314404,
0.1414189488,
-0.6723822951,
-0.5081738234,
-0.2197707444,
-0.0554453321,
-0.002174438,
0.0264837611,
0.4142580032,
-0.1012637317,
1.0268752575,
-0.4801668823,
-0.5551480651,
-0.8259620667,
0.2425233424,
0.2673091888,
0.173872292,
0.5606274605,
-0.3645062149,
-0.7262682915,
0.1802389771,
-0.6622734666,
-0.0980588943,
-0.461583972,
0.1862953305,
-0.0228914451,
0.2390947491,
-0.0550759286,
0.3670983613,
0.7019930482,
0.0652387217,
0.4162918627,
-0.3616502285,
-0.1017499864,
-1.0973309278,
-0.0431260727,
-0.1588984132,
-0.3219919205,
-0.8230023384,
-0.4831437469,
0.2107868344,
-0.444417119,
-0.6396613121,
0.1106122956,
-0.4371917844,
0.0303135831,
-0.4323532581,
-0.214430809,
-0.272983402,
0.0718698055,
-0.096173875,
0.520031333,
0.7016172409,
-0.6097815037,
0.3984881639,
0.0417722613,
-0.6439734101,
0.1869838089,
-0.3832094669,
0.2701264918,
-0.1128645167,
0.0190308355,
-0.8798101544,
-0.135216713,
0.1633592546,
-0.0389591046,
0.3792836666,
-0.4421032071,
-0.3555832505,
-0.2037554681,
-0.0681499615,
-0.01431752,
0.5954423547,
-0.5496405959,
0.3330031633,
0.2737919986,
0.3777794838,
-0.1226026192,
-0.6583262682,
-0.0470771566,
-0.0048197247,
-0.6067138314,
0.2584753335,
0.2741786242,
-0.012033063,
0.1434637457,
0.1783702374,
-0.2758952081,
0.3462128937,
0.3388935328,
-0.0997023657,
0.0798239931,
0.5385220051,
-0.2266287804,
-0.0659352839,
-0.1889892519,
-0.3278727531,
0.6404221058,
-0.0767887831,
-0.3912664652,
-0.6443243027,
0.416164726,
0.2262451351,
0.2155543715,
0.8309736252,
0.4213982522,
-0.4547030032,
-0.1557803601,
-0.1273825318,
-0.3797595203,
-0.4279766381,
0.1468924284,
-0.1134720445,
-0.4346845746,
0.3435586691,
-0.2227916569,
-0.1687074751,
0.3265795708,
0.0395932868,
-0.3138682246,
0.6400218606,
1.1047894955,
-0.3705838621,
0.9451284409,
-0.5727032423,
0.4747492075,
-0.3428194225,
0.2079419792,
-0.4155672193,
-0.2141966522,
-0.6674003601,
0.0405206122,
0.3493351936,
0.1462395936,
-0.0737190545,
0.5182964802,
-0.3542849123,
0.515935719,
-0.1561767161,
0.3752218783,
0.1893011034,
0.1890873313,
0.4796400964,
0.0216655936,
-0.632132709,
-0.3278746903,
1.0874130726,
0.2397230268,
0.9699817896,
-0.1090049446,
0.6660186648,
0.4652699828,
0.4261628389,
-0.8866258264,
0.1360764205,
-0.2429486662,
-0.2902957499,
-0.5753073096,
-0.5741893649,
-1.2023419142,
-0.1495220363,
-0.3357544541,
-0.6297096014,
0.2018334419,
0.2560983002,
-0.4688502252,
0.5253837705,
-0.9336177111,
0.6052182913,
-0.0856820121,
0.1559455991,
-0.266184479,
-0.5186658502,
0.3105297983,
-0.1520995945,
0.14182356,
-0.281964004,
0.5488875508,
0.5404333472,
-0.5217264891,
0.7007884383,
-0.1595306247,
0.0782618523,
0.4874720573,
-0.247386083,
0.8675528169,
-0.2855825126,
-0.2969290316,
0.2321276516,
-0.1848584861,
-0.5505036712,
-0.3625171185,
0.436534971,
-0.8256775737,
0.073331967,
-0.3500521779,
-0.2709439695,
-0.2848317325,
0.2606989741,
0.8766409755,
0.1604225188,
0.0489554517,
0.2394471765,
0.5572855473,
0.1783626825,
0.7988783121,
0.5910004973,
0.1032896638,
0.0327922888,
0.9595737457,
0.5585970879,
0.409552902,
0.3300347328,
0.2426249087,
-0.1874699146,
-0.4970657825,
-0.1585982591,
0.0718594193,
-0.591793716,
-0.5343658328,
-0.7389686704,
-0.4585189521,
-0.4720524848,
-0.0975135937,
-0.328843087,
-0.0924575776,
-0.6259533763,
-0.1908159852,
0.4776402116,
0.6392284036,
-0.2570212483,
0.829369843,
-1.0185978413,
0.3944267035,
0.3506108522,
0.3044216931,
0.0164837856,
-0.4903025627,
-0.3091723919,
-0.1634707451,
-0.6338060498,
-1.2229415178,
0.4840719104,
0.6684982181,
0.2399222702,
0.4382413328,
0.431937784,
0.6961398721,
-0.3367076814,
0.5395591855,
0.7025616169,
-0.9934166074,
0.7337568402,
-0.1677248329,
0.2470598519,
0.6558104753,
0.2743472159,
-0.4403916597,
-0.0635649189,
-0.6827603579,
-0.6524735093,
0.8178754449,
0.1337605864,
0.1147739291,
-0.0089349765,
-0.1582678407,
0.07418897,
0.0710192397,
-0.3821254969,
-0.0888459906,
-0.3014920056,
0.1150636151,
-0.091082111,
-0.0234632753,
0.1617548168,
-0.1949515045,
0.3989444077,
-0.3067663908,
0.1445384175,
-0.1068225503,
-0.379692018,
-0.6659432054,
0.5713170171,
0.5166850686,
0.8902871013,
-0.5683397055,
0.0776605755,
0.7222348452,
-0.5377943516,
0.2526641488,
0.1279791743,
-0.1797798127,
0.4674469531,
0.2972459495,
0.8284542561,
0.2649480104,
-0.3970880508,
0.5123571157,
-0.0209090132,
-0.0123677421,
-0.218997404,
-0.0912818536,
-0.3078555167,
-0.0031170526,
0.6296713352,
0.1877378076,
0.0692648739,
-0.5767450929,
0.0539378561,
0.450961709,
-0.3960072696,
-0.6631454825,
0.2262486815,
0.2497396171,
-0.0731486231,
0.502155304,
-0.0509854555,
-0.3257001042,
0.5426381826,
0.5402291417,
0.9247076511,
-0.2082376033,
0.3844323754,
-0.0574110076,
0.5785850883,
-0.0381311737,
0.4363300204,
0.0001902812,
-0.9326119423,
-0.4282037914,
-0.5768904686,
-0.3224284351,
0.5968404412,
-0.646134913,
0.6855207682,
-0.5070297122,
-0.2585647702,
-0.1599327773,
0.1938996911,
-1.0565683842,
0.1021102741,
-0.0940963849,
0.9402105808,
-1.3315033913,
0.9543933272,
0.613031745,
-0.1002996787,
-1.0840426683,
0.0411741398,
-0.6211286783,
-0.7587023973,
0.6538597941,
0.0468710512,
0.144971624,
0.3527486622,
-0.4889067411,
-0.6816802621,
0.9750700593,
0.7228745222,
-0.6981832385,
0.1482396424,
-0.0500849597,
0.4333630502,
-0.0213532653,
0.2349944711,
0.6451208591,
0.4957079589,
-0.1371297836,
-1.0456361771,
-0.2551713288,
0.5150216222,
-0.272654146,
0.5831214786,
-0.7265356779,
0.497285217,
-0.3154394031,
-0.4025342464,
-0.3548199534,
0.7225798368,
-0.2487332076,
0.6075068712,
0.5559592247,
0.4397390187,
0.7161420584,
0.0269862376,
0.9495076537,
0.013610228,
0.7803416848,
0.9728787541,
-0.2665703893,
0.6639992595,
0.2191078961,
-0.18043226,
0.3018601537,
0.3561136127,
0.1931756586,
1.071742177,
-0.187063545,
-0.3299566507,
-0.5320659876,
-0.3703641891,
-0.5520362854,
0.2857055664,
0.1755892187,
-0.3857917488,
-0.8673442602,
0.3627160788,
0.0247269478,
-0.29247877,
-0.3292369246,
0.7301499248,
0.2341283858,
-0.3120456338,
0.7266180515,
-0.2903109193,
0.3641334176,
-0.5941490531,
0.1413454413,
0.0040478697,
0.3295490742,
-0.5252285004,
-0.7787281275,
0.4927268028,
0.0192652605,
-0.1821686029,
-0.4474569857,
1.0229314566,
-0.1547347158,
-0.3143875599,
0.3227690458,
0.1484868824,
0.3423630893,
-0.0246170536,
-0.4354670942,
-0.1184855625,
-0.0753960684,
0.0915016904,
0.5308513641,
0.4631061852,
0.0530142039,
0.5763476491,
0.6101415753,
0.4188523889,
0.105483301,
0.3589399159,
0.8983277678,
-0.2632425427,
-0.2863767743,
-0.8339914083,
0.2564302981,
-0.201161623,
-0.3050984442,
0.5180041194,
0.1727316529,
0.6442181468,
-0.2250817418,
1.2844455242,
0.1140823811,
0.3603442311,
-0.4250060916,
0.6045520306,
-0.2226039916,
-0.0053736563,
-0.048535578,
-0.4423364997,
-0.1538639665,
0.3419935405,
-0.514046371,
-0.3783144653,
0.6362934113,
0.3174313307,
-0.3450796306,
-0.1355117112,
0.6494340897,
0.0289925318,
0.5027759075,
0.58507967,
0.8362329006,
-0.6212623119,
0.7559754848,
-0.4676954448,
-0.2921722531,
-0.5793260336,
-1.1421874762,
-0.766438365,
-0.2940780222,
-0.3126945198,
-0.2122748643,
0.042040363,
0.8667480946,
0.8840408921,
-1.1062343121,
0.0532850362,
-0.4317430854,
0.2776509523,
-0.2369461358,
-0.2417041361,
0.4056244493,
-0.7290171981,
-0.039545197,
0.4321308136,
0.1783120334,
0.1631273031,
0.0862681419,
0.1690051854,
-0.2001717389,
-0.000473148,
0.4482662976,
0.2661404908,
-0.0229147766,
-0.6250376701,
-0.0468574725,
0.1602105647,
-0.1804445684,
0.832629025,
-0.6728976965,
0.2957505584,
0.7251487374,
0.559251368,
0.272810787,
0.1126177162,
0.1869159937,
-1.1312193871,
0.1602860689,
0.2556564808,
0.447095871,
0.5362538099,
-0.551255703,
0.3150999248,
0.403298974,
-0.7330797315,
-0.8657208681,
0.373316586,
-0.6488867998,
-0.0569740459,
1.0261931419,
-0.1552478373,
0.1046737507,
-0.3850280941,
-0.0638280809,
0.3579901159,
-0.3838026822,
0.8451735377,
0.6299509406,
-0.4348500073,
-0.3688179851,
-0.49566558,
0.5714143515,
0.1250182092,
-0.9516268373,
0.0442993529,
-0.0762538835,
0.3880536556,
0.120468013,
0.5805074573,
0.5285137892,
0.2640794218,
-0.6108729243,
-0.3352147639,
0.1696462631,
-0.4140574932,
-0.4874810576,
0.2667762935,
-0.1756256521,
-0.6019417644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03763v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03763v4 | ChatGPT Informed Graph Neural Network for Stock Movement Prediction | 2023-05-28T21:11:59 | 2023-09-18T20:26:04 | Zihan Chen, Lei Nico Zheng, Cheng Lu, Jialu Yuan, Di Zhu | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.CP, I.2.7; J.1 | ChatGPT has demonstrated remarkable capabilities across various natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. However, its potential for inferring dynamic
network structures from temporal textual data, specifically financial news,
remains an unexplored frontier. In this research, we introduce a novel
framework that leverages ChatGPT's graph inference capabilities to enhance
Graph Neural Networks (GNN). Our framework adeptly extracts evolving network
structures from textual data, and incorporates these networks into graph neural
networks for subsequent predictive tasks. The experimental results from stock
movement forecasting indicate our model has consistently outperformed the
state-of-the-art Deep Learning-based benchmarks. Furthermore, the portfolios
constructed based on our model's outputs demonstrate higher annualized
cumulative returns, alongside reduced volatility and maximum drawdown. This
superior performance highlights the potential of ChatGPT for text-based network
inferences and underscores its promising implications for the financial sector. | [
0.3290133476,
-0.7614345551,
0.0385328494,
0.0375480205,
-0.1868537217,
0.6820937991,
0.1106523797,
-0.5358142853,
0.3786279261,
0.3803444207,
-0.5967774391,
-0.5920177102,
-0.7824487686,
-0.4949109852,
-0.6991577148,
1.0513682365,
0.1900665015,
0.0393223353,
0.352321744,
0.2217577994,
-0.3726824522,
-0.5003998876,
-1.0316132307,
-0.498142451,
0.4723372161,
-0.1666080356,
0.966311276,
0.5176656246,
0.536103189,
0.3228503466,
-0.1585555822,
0.2946633399,
-0.371410042,
-0.0317061953,
0.4973053932,
-0.0898588598,
-0.3332784772,
-0.1763927937,
0.4569617808,
0.7706629038,
-0.3076786399,
-0.0987683982,
0.2308520973,
0.6882357597,
-0.1893201619,
0.7680776119,
-0.5011644959,
0.3913612664,
-0.2285751551,
-0.0731076971,
-0.4832618237,
-0.3577563465,
0.5500879288,
-0.6305807233,
0.1445970982,
0.3388310671,
0.8850412369,
-0.1072077677,
-0.5500056148,
-0.1166303903,
-0.5089356303,
0.1445515901,
-0.6171936393,
0.4361975193,
0.236733377,
0.368418932,
-0.2288399786,
-1.3211436272,
-0.0161735993,
-0.2303940505,
0.0081041399,
0.325615555,
-0.2558504939,
-0.0801631287,
-0.0717183053,
0.1706147045,
-0.5856503248,
0.0141001018,
-0.4669608772,
-0.0819034576,
0.330650121,
0.0233885553,
0.2384389788,
-0.0165566616,
-0.6176102757,
-0.1155193076,
-0.4244011045,
0.0326805711,
0.6559207439,
0.6127601266,
-0.126170978,
0.3607130051,
0.012024045,
0.4856775403,
-0.0902553648,
0.4006211758,
0.3733387589,
-0.1314449012,
-0.3575210571,
0.2785637975,
0.7751070857,
0.4503310621,
0.2128255963,
-0.5116391778,
0.0788692087,
-0.2264016122,
0.1105900556,
-0.8707248569,
-0.899979353,
-0.0722211748,
-0.5168368816,
-0.5065358877,
0.1532329619,
-0.9772580266,
-0.5387445688,
-0.2879952788,
0.2023585588,
-0.7078835964,
-0.2814055085,
0.3413095474,
-0.4904612601,
-0.0119336993,
0.2679543495,
-0.9799032807,
0.2133559436,
1.0041706562,
1.0792981386,
-0.2078448683,
-0.1576906294,
-0.7891563773,
0.2272963673,
-0.392624855,
0.8459960222,
-0.4968476593,
-0.2899230421,
-0.0621390864,
-0.2462572306,
-0.4656732082,
-0.1084050611,
0.1791367382,
-0.7908163667,
0.2029163837,
-0.0257735178,
-0.6678732038,
-0.5286776423,
0.323818475,
-0.6553163528,
0.8674847484,
-0.0787554905,
-0.9685117602,
0.4779727161,
-0.9318472147,
-0.5795431733,
0.1793026626,
-0.0345754325,
-0.448681891,
-0.3601377308,
0.4761219621,
0.3653871715,
-0.0013606953,
0.1477618963,
-0.575350225,
-0.3071310818,
0.4172872901,
-0.8044719696,
0.4474276304,
0.0308941919,
-0.0500698611,
0.111597836,
-0.7176439762,
-0.0062536094,
0.1215429753,
0.0002027819,
-0.1025573686,
0.3847463727,
-0.2068202198,
-0.1803347319,
-0.0053800875,
-0.4087362289,
0.2340172827,
-0.6347387433,
0.8332891464,
0.94282341,
0.1020159051,
0.3842758238,
-0.1520669609,
0.5851067305,
-0.1264048219,
0.0729426965,
0.0071230261,
-0.4811839163,
-0.054633677,
-0.1375991106,
0.5795801878,
0.8000596166,
-0.547647953,
0.1314403862,
-0.4259874523,
-0.3108220398,
0.2396119088,
-0.1212811992,
-0.2290246487,
0.6898088455,
0.1950526536,
-0.1987056583,
-0.4460502565,
-0.5350803733,
-0.2892385721,
-0.2762386501,
-0.1007112488,
0.1967526078,
0.0696770176,
-0.2639770806,
0.813185513,
-0.7887273431,
0.0474453792,
-0.1701579392,
0.3594264686,
0.5248330235,
0.103522405,
0.3687832654,
-0.8669399619,
-0.3696251214,
0.4004921019,
-0.4541202188,
0.3315239549,
-0.2691656947,
-0.3708582819,
-0.3442753553,
0.6703526974,
-0.5499473214,
0.6673737764,
0.54802984,
-0.536780715,
0.3677499592,
-0.0052961065,
-0.3370744288,
-1.2913256884,
-0.1518668234,
0.2338660359,
-0.5094873905,
-0.2257104516,
-0.6294547319,
-0.2680640221,
-0.3629235923,
-0.0241271984,
0.4937150776,
-0.2298133969,
-0.3334091008,
-0.0643989742,
0.216794759,
-0.0239808634,
0.3175267279,
-0.1574442238,
0.7146292329,
0.556432128,
-0.4102016985,
0.3838793635,
0.4607794583,
-0.2856422961,
-0.1671325117,
-0.6214669347,
-0.102086097,
0.0726014227,
0.3258574307,
-1.265652895,
-0.044978898,
0.4767098427,
-0.4322837889,
0.3746106923,
-0.3688598573,
-0.2616354227,
-0.5107733607,
0.0127182659,
-0.1166509315,
0.2064249665,
-0.4157220721,
0.6866539717,
0.130256027,
-0.3876031637,
-0.7117868662,
-0.8961817026,
0.2805989385,
-0.0186614972,
-0.6232117414,
0.1496726424,
0.1216565669,
-0.0167927854,
0.0320873782,
-0.2223615795,
-0.0837878436,
0.1505815983,
0.4331830144,
0.5905704498,
-0.330807656,
0.4490231574,
-0.2578334212,
-0.3964420855,
0.1132331118,
-0.8326382041,
0.6182253957,
-0.3492585719,
-0.3243426085,
-0.3582671583,
-0.0914497823,
0.2255554199,
-0.318348974,
0.6218768358,
0.7066212893,
0.0369150601,
-0.0295701344,
0.1161248088,
-0.1217750162,
-0.5518822074,
0.6623153687,
0.1933771223,
-0.8065137267,
0.5975723863,
-0.5196214914,
0.0993015692,
0.6568720341,
0.1862971634,
-0.1974751055,
0.8492257595,
0.3749051094,
-0.1971875876,
0.9269798994,
-0.5272067189,
0.50328511,
-0.4206308126,
-0.0663669109,
-0.1016858667,
-0.7893018723,
-0.691021204,
-0.231466651,
-0.0756631941,
-0.1701606512,
-0.4544052482,
0.3537759185,
-0.3293343782,
0.3071858883,
0.4212571681,
0.2212537676,
0.2406644374,
0.381644994,
-0.3515468836,
0.2356841266,
-0.6940716505,
-0.1813938916,
1.1689018011,
0.4152438045,
0.762100637,
-0.1394533217,
0.2731370628,
0.5774341822,
0.5055736899,
-0.7167699933,
0.3732697666,
-0.4484315217,
-0.02804818,
-0.2383670658,
-0.6160686612,
-0.9120434523,
0.0077372408,
-0.154133141,
-0.9865122437,
0.215097934,
-0.0506521426,
-0.5009551048,
0.5407174826,
-0.8112835884,
0.8794509768,
-0.3913428783,
-0.0344272703,
0.0507304184,
-0.4843485951,
-0.0520755462,
-0.0593747273,
-0.08571174,
-0.3004379272,
-0.1383717358,
0.6472160816,
-0.6006743908,
1.1264209747,
-0.0236309208,
0.2431980371,
0.2435877472,
0.0088874437,
0.86318928,
0.3424127102,
-0.3339531422,
0.2507789135,
-0.1891340464,
-0.2645928562,
-0.4802696109,
0.3174981475,
-0.5383748412,
-0.0463327356,
-0.3615870178,
-0.515252769,
-0.3457561731,
0.2894152403,
0.2775803804,
0.3920002878,
-0.2800683975,
0.3133850396,
-0.0557615235,
0.2893747687,
0.8181109428,
-0.0492060445,
-0.4801853895,
-0.7506632209,
0.7705572844,
0.2078419328,
-0.0384099483,
0.4797432125,
0.3644459546,
-0.5600902438,
-0.6847636104,
-0.3900884688,
-0.2733954787,
-0.4919102192,
-0.231454879,
-0.6069470644,
-0.3826921284,
-0.340659678,
-0.1270193011,
-0.4573762715,
-0.3994813859,
-0.3269294202,
-0.5785079598,
0.6047146916,
0.6886724234,
0.2756322026,
0.6010728478,
-0.7882425189,
0.0015076543,
0.4078326225,
0.4913318455,
0.0236516837,
-0.2319740504,
-0.3108974695,
0.4148209989,
-0.5372713804,
-0.7573773861,
0.6491732001,
0.2449727356,
0.2185445279,
0.5281400084,
0.0048053381,
0.6125732064,
-0.1742039621,
0.5504937172,
0.4003058374,
-0.5147747397,
0.2410350144,
-0.6608987451,
0.2558681667,
0.1336822808,
0.1360792369,
-0.6207033992,
-0.1374777853,
-0.6836858392,
-0.9176014066,
0.2702741623,
0.3532496393,
0.193838805,
-0.0503173023,
0.4836378396,
0.0829520524,
0.454544425,
-0.6262637973,
0.1149613634,
-0.4569846988,
-0.1994096339,
0.0641434044,
0.1149093285,
0.1994306296,
-0.1445414424,
0.571353972,
-0.5595889091,
0.4419736266,
0.0477817096,
0.3175549507,
0.1259617805,
-0.3402341008,
0.1526306421,
0.745829165,
-0.2025210857,
-0.3852441311,
0.2846214473,
-0.5820646286,
-0.1775361896,
0.6341170073,
-0.2427765876,
-0.0073429854,
0.3367491066,
1.0299953222,
0.3782888353,
-0.3002629876,
0.3900547326,
-0.4099374413,
-0.2833228707,
-0.4591432512,
-0.1134020463,
0.1944489479,
0.8007287979,
0.5244954228,
0.5228697658,
0.1577746123,
-0.1848014742,
0.4508911371,
0.3029984534,
-0.7724283934,
-0.234775573,
0.8753967881,
-0.1445817351,
-0.03255485,
0.8734487891,
0.0995785594,
-0.5127526522,
0.9718694687,
0.3360181153,
1.2916544676,
0.232412979,
0.4598435462,
0.1147398651,
0.0994306132,
-0.1173016801,
0.1193404123,
0.2148911953,
-0.7990264893,
-0.6242884398,
-0.4297507703,
-0.5981626511,
-0.2244937718,
-0.2054782957,
0.2935985327,
-0.6464229822,
-0.5703749657,
0.2331741154,
-0.1500205398,
-0.3970624804,
0.0828945041,
0.2142112553,
0.7863503695,
-0.3398149312,
0.5769315362,
0.438610822,
0.0412736125,
-0.7437155247,
0.1920719743,
-0.107539624,
-0.8740006089,
0.5048800111,
0.4104188383,
-0.0016087954,
-0.1210734919,
-0.366782397,
-0.8265554905,
1.1189056635,
0.5215725899,
-0.5946311355,
-0.1194530129,
-0.0948324278,
0.3232092559,
-0.4221301377,
0.1953984052,
0.0170444641,
0.3004813194,
0.7079023123,
-0.3383468986,
-0.4363124073,
-0.2614681423,
-0.1703575701,
0.4401007295,
-0.7583530545,
0.7868808508,
-0.0781529546,
-0.1006494462,
-0.0952413082,
0.9373311996,
-0.2148796022,
0.4795386195,
0.3853969276,
0.3481206298,
1.07614398,
-0.1277185231,
1.2425947189,
-0.5489597321,
0.4485757351,
1.3916893005,
-0.2204153985,
0.9695136547,
-0.1156793088,
-0.1014830247,
0.6206948161,
0.9279980063,
-0.2075252384,
0.4749525487,
0.0013990153,
-0.1571754664,
-0.2698347867,
0.1187630966,
-0.5085096359,
0.6396969557,
0.3393331766,
-0.5750630498,
-0.1061988175,
-0.3294145763,
0.0377609357,
-0.4587581456,
-0.2851836681,
0.5068584681,
0.0995303616,
-0.1897840649,
-0.2135607749,
-0.2765458524,
0.2323931307,
-0.9058758616,
0.2629760504,
-0.0855890885,
0.269570291,
0.1509075612,
-0.74511379,
0.3514536917,
-0.5245578885,
0.1840164661,
-0.4545757473,
1.1273397207,
-0.216284886,
-0.6648700237,
0.3614580929,
0.3462948501,
-0.2469742,
-0.3187323511,
-0.700719595,
-0.720177114,
0.089023523,
-0.5176913738,
0.3299821913,
0.6550272107,
0.142443791,
0.9031121731,
1.1537555456,
-0.0022101554,
-0.0525716767,
0.0035970656,
0.9784629345,
-0.6165021658,
-0.9926367402,
-0.9091501236,
0.2224126309,
-0.4040656984,
-0.1798482388,
0.4384256005,
0.714945972,
0.1508378088,
0.1772065759,
0.7638406157,
0.5360384583,
0.2735096216,
-0.5664046407,
0.803101182,
-0.0208135694,
0.2340823412,
-0.1782199144,
-0.6828260422,
-0.2548543215,
0.2483621091,
-0.6160594821,
-0.0245153364,
0.6422451735,
0.4755707383,
-0.173903361,
0.8495925069,
-0.0017962861,
0.1958535165,
0.2704660594,
0.1879225373,
0.3817133605,
-0.4745777547,
0.8157624006,
-0.1281249821,
0.2415246516,
-0.181048125,
-1.2709511518,
-0.5854340196,
-0.1508871764,
-0.5469787717,
-0.2215261012,
0.1450390518,
0.7250823975,
0.8044654131,
-0.5489835143,
-0.088004522,
-0.317553252,
0.0068391631,
-0.5150064826,
-0.2116156667,
0.6547370553,
-0.2315839678,
-0.2271778882,
0.4081623852,
0.5842286348,
0.447368443,
0.080666557,
-0.1227481812,
-0.0928323641,
-0.0546880923,
0.7411755323,
0.3076741993,
0.0366404392,
-0.3247628212,
0.0853755325,
0.1573410928,
0.2423392385,
0.6778573394,
-0.5760430098,
0.1935868114,
0.6163383126,
0.8969854116,
0.7936047912,
0.2225932032,
0.7957569361,
-0.74919945,
0.2404382974,
0.2582146227,
0.508174479,
-0.0546716489,
-0.5248249173,
0.6302083135,
0.5087064505,
-0.517157793,
-0.159468025,
-0.2653458714,
-0.9543861747,
-0.1981039643,
0.9028493762,
0.0637075678,
-0.4623548687,
0.0780419633,
-0.1904234588,
0.2595276237,
-0.7189522982,
0.5423980951,
0.5922166109,
-0.1120029539,
-0.2997972667,
-0.9019485712,
0.1916480511,
0.0790317282,
-0.6154046655,
0.3417819142,
0.2949153185,
-0.0967485309,
-0.2119651288,
0.4800513685,
0.0477134846,
0.0992065519,
0.2004519552,
-0.2784274518,
-0.2859373391,
-0.0400395729,
0.3477811217,
0.495668143,
-0.302700609,
-0.5035330057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17812v1 | Tab-CoT: Zero-shot Tabular Chain of Thought | 2023-05-28T20:49:52 | 2023-05-28T20:49:52 | Ziqi Jin, Wei Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The chain-of-though (CoT) prompting methods were successful in various
natural language processing (NLP) tasks thanks to their ability to unveil the
underlying complex reasoning processes. Such reasoning processes typically
exhibit implicitly structured steps. Recent efforts also started investigating
methods to encourage more explicitly structured reasoning procedures to be
captured. In this work, we propose Tab-CoT, a novel tabular-format CoT
prompting method, which allows the complex reasoning process to be explicitly
modelled in a highly structured manner. Despite its simplicity, we show that
our approach is capable of performing reasoning across multiple dimensions
(i.e., both rows and columns). We demonstrate our approach's strong zero-shot
and few-shot capabilities through extensive experiments on a range of reasoning
tasks. | [
-0.551869154,
-1.422399044,
0.9878738523,
0.3356361687,
-0.245132789,
0.241779536,
-0.2567670047,
-0.1157298088,
0.1544933617,
0.485858351,
-0.587790668,
-0.8263136148,
-0.0073286733,
0.163674444,
-0.5050850511,
1.0872001648,
-0.3763255477,
-0.2227039933,
0.1463020742,
0.0722961873,
-0.817661643,
-0.3673502803,
-0.4030223191,
-0.284401387,
0.9267488718,
0.8266307116,
0.4287341535,
0.3621260822,
0.1722418219,
0.1399465203,
-0.0547939949,
0.327467978,
-0.1833112985,
0.5029463768,
-0.1793334335,
-0.8391823173,
-0.6226814985,
-0.0797559991,
0.6353328824,
0.6587365866,
-0.2058687359,
0.2968886495,
-0.1106785014,
0.6434112191,
-0.794926405,
-0.1306507736,
-0.7943776846,
0.2643245161,
-0.0562986694,
-0.3397631943,
-0.9590171576,
-0.2527851462,
-0.19492203,
-0.3817719221,
0.3064365089,
0.2121956795,
0.505128324,
-0.0585722849,
-0.3069998026,
-0.2222481966,
-0.9445172548,
0.4350979626,
-0.4082725644,
0.1821166426,
0.2369944155,
0.5160831809,
-0.4404307306,
-0.7170106173,
-1.043471694,
-0.4407331049,
0.036952991,
-0.1313589215,
0.2139953077,
0.2340524048,
0.5056467652,
-0.0192112029,
-0.7458683252,
-0.397341758,
-0.406096071,
0.2690292895,
0.2805649042,
0.2456165552,
0.1890902966,
-0.2420926988,
-0.7807113528,
0.0973355025,
-0.5879686475,
0.2276552469,
0.0318455622,
0.6359095573,
-0.2688988745,
0.731113255,
-0.3069498539,
0.9920742512,
0.0310702864,
0.0216564126,
-0.1418957263,
-0.1358562708,
-0.499357909,
0.3346109986,
0.61956954,
0.040023122,
0.121616751,
-0.0788669437,
0.0564917289,
0.3054324687,
0.4511609972,
-0.1846572459,
-0.1598145515,
0.5643638968,
0.1292057186,
-0.2643660009,
-0.1087585166,
-0.8625923395,
-0.273560077,
-0.3165937066,
0.5495473146,
-0.4659446478,
0.1615145653,
0.1457617879,
-0.2326370329,
0.4384934008,
0.5302454233,
-0.6510390639,
0.4589805007,
0.5839135647,
0.8833726645,
0.037667606,
-0.3087946773,
-0.7310121655,
0.4259309471,
-0.7044487,
1.4583090544,
-0.6834748387,
-0.1370477378,
-0.2356249988,
-0.2794087529,
0.0455697328,
-0.0314739309,
0.5949510932,
-0.1042518988,
0.0345814303,
-0.6208666563,
-0.1251827031,
-0.0108510684,
0.949688673,
-0.5506198406,
1.0796829462,
-0.0241624843,
-0.3853271306,
0.5973399878,
-0.8602715731,
-0.2321064025,
0.1176106408,
-0.5402427316,
-0.2318654209,
-0.2104742229,
0.3836061358,
0.2503685951,
-0.266353935,
0.239991188,
-0.4147371352,
-0.2256530374,
0.1531229168,
-0.4138664901,
0.5513653755,
-0.0155088278,
-0.4240738153,
0.1599377543,
-0.6147817969,
0.353831917,
-0.0881016031,
-0.0621323213,
0.1187432185,
-0.4991321564,
-0.2999463081,
0.4099396169,
-0.2289979011,
-0.5691563487,
0.6932024956,
-0.1392056048,
0.2108559012,
0.4659452736,
0.2162123024,
0.6671266556,
-0.2093262523,
0.6994125247,
0.1158937067,
0.1618205607,
-0.1561639607,
-0.5350132585,
-0.6046500802,
-0.2887957096,
0.2296224684,
0.4371629655,
-0.9555601478,
-0.0119739696,
0.3088565469,
-0.3788487911,
-0.1916080415,
0.028034376,
0.5564092994,
0.6649264693,
0.5763237476,
0.1378196329,
-0.4840617776,
-0.593133688,
-0.3171377182,
-0.1322606802,
0.1004947945,
0.1406998485,
0.4464520216,
0.1756449342,
0.958712399,
-0.7588131428,
-0.3455393612,
-0.7877623439,
0.6398533583,
0.2983225286,
0.4182593822,
0.3501386642,
-0.5159602761,
-0.6090549231,
0.0100156898,
-0.6618551016,
-0.0454028621,
-0.5852444768,
-0.5736467242,
0.2937435508,
0.4651100636,
-0.9150476456,
0.9344673753,
-0.1097029299,
-0.5142612457,
0.9358616471,
-0.1432528347,
0.1501556784,
-0.7179746032,
0.0114289774,
-0.1901881695,
-0.2862419188,
-0.7539725304,
0.0269526076,
-0.0130627593,
0.0159137826,
-0.4462460876,
0.4028310478,
-0.6083468795,
-0.0079687173,
-0.1788565665,
0.5318474174,
0.5815815926,
0.7576562166,
0.053156741,
0.6430240273,
0.3891118467,
-0.7525296807,
0.4136741757,
0.4114535153,
0.0907475427,
0.7185903788,
-0.4330464303,
0.1051711217,
-0.4378101528,
0.6950771809,
-1.090444088,
-0.1365737468,
0.1987252384,
-0.3919884562,
0.2653651536,
-0.0396307632,
-0.2260054648,
-0.5952513814,
-0.5622386336,
0.3685488105,
-0.1481687278,
-0.2742933035,
0.5868756175,
0.0196281094,
0.0966756046,
-0.6704368591,
-0.7031962276,
0.2839843929,
-0.0124813821,
-0.0695776269,
0.3121288717,
0.2401982546,
-0.1406614482,
-0.1036443785,
-0.3585673273,
-0.2672282457,
-0.436676383,
0.050093703,
0.4821044505,
-0.2970867157,
0.1564106643,
0.2221731395,
-0.0972142667,
-0.082484208,
-0.3018779755,
0.8543516994,
-0.4923632145,
-0.2174624801,
-0.5358567834,
0.381526798,
0.3944191039,
-0.0424288549,
0.7846665978,
0.488864243,
-0.3899775743,
-0.6513161659,
-0.5078044534,
-0.0068832147,
-0.3999578655,
-0.2947125435,
-0.5873069763,
-0.3622182906,
0.5683564544,
-0.0504461192,
0.1001079455,
0.0876776651,
0.6191286445,
-0.3013119698,
0.7418846488,
0.380564034,
0.5632285476,
0.1920718104,
-0.7311605215,
0.7460535169,
-0.9981803298,
-0.6404626369,
-0.7021752596,
-0.3148494363,
-0.2777865529,
-0.5915858746,
0.54823035,
0.3107959628,
-0.4119638205,
0.6806124449,
-0.6377106905,
0.7134030461,
0.4738023877,
0.2668304443,
0.2330393195,
-0.345572561,
-0.6606531143,
0.5101092458,
-0.6828690767,
-0.7089173198,
0.631996274,
-0.0520071909,
0.7770596743,
0.0222053807,
0.6622980237,
0.368176192,
0.0921820775,
-0.8335001469,
0.6430704594,
0.1889444739,
-0.7458918691,
-0.7341179252,
-0.1276986897,
-0.9500725269,
0.1426733136,
-0.4289301634,
-1.3195031881,
0.2323660105,
0.3467209935,
-0.7422119379,
0.496674031,
-0.8597112298,
0.8532066345,
-0.0228845552,
-0.5298326612,
0.1360786557,
-0.7259764075,
0.4410529435,
0.4118542969,
-0.0278127547,
-0.2477968484,
0.2631700933,
0.2430366427,
-0.4493507445,
0.6225311756,
-0.200914368,
0.1358980685,
0.8542172313,
0.6862955689,
0.3123666346,
0.1939881444,
0.125013724,
-0.3501935899,
0.2500264645,
-0.4794980586,
-1.0024416447,
0.5367639065,
-0.1804867387,
-0.5828750134,
-0.2819976211,
-0.6969225407,
-0.4303145409,
0.1384521127,
0.0780950189,
0.6540152431,
0.1920595765,
0.0738947466,
0.3124760389,
-0.0414835885,
0.5009069443,
-0.017501805,
-0.3317985237,
-0.2900182903,
0.5222747326,
0.1419279575,
0.3364250362,
0.5159403086,
0.1914199293,
-0.4683384597,
0.0389449932,
-0.6792649627,
0.0274520647,
-0.6179850698,
-0.5921765566,
-0.6714028716,
-0.1880892515,
-0.2416253835,
-0.7463302016,
-0.2672335505,
-0.785166204,
0.2288665026,
-0.4603065252,
0.2759811878,
0.7933209538,
0.1337554008,
0.1859032065,
-0.6258334517,
1.0046186447,
0.3819703758,
0.5838082433,
0.1766636372,
0.0996219441,
0.1871117204,
0.0393005423,
-0.5173732638,
-1.1112746,
0.2256136537,
-0.1405255944,
0.5134423971,
0.2074339092,
0.3231272101,
1.0399401188,
-0.4844709635,
0.9501734376,
0.2483685911,
-1.095293045,
0.7443177104,
-0.3775610924,
0.4202076495,
0.6455050111,
0.200951159,
-0.2645080984,
-0.595584631,
-0.4739872515,
-0.8380612731,
0.6343792081,
0.2944613099,
-0.2828330398,
-0.2622121871,
0.3861173689,
0.2381063551,
0.1743950248,
-0.916924119,
-0.0357522778,
-0.036937084,
0.0597594008,
0.5989996195,
-0.1158963963,
-0.1186844185,
-0.3321897089,
0.3786911964,
-0.264323473,
0.4395073056,
0.7538248301,
-0.1116686612,
-0.0871897116,
0.7161539793,
0.677621901,
0.6701313257,
-0.1312878579,
0.5185629129,
0.4339082241,
-0.3601851165,
0.3638447821,
-0.659475863,
-0.1762920916,
0.0083523169,
0.1219823509,
0.641254425,
0.0735806674,
-0.3619380593,
0.3148379326,
-0.0504390262,
-0.3104974926,
-0.0858701319,
0.048528377,
-0.3150203526,
0.2673117816,
0.2391042113,
-0.1450031847,
0.3049467802,
-0.9133371115,
0.2316985726,
0.3005814552,
-0.3820216656,
-0.0068494338,
0.6433540583,
-0.1654961705,
-0.4450801015,
0.3417524099,
-0.393950969,
-0.4034986198,
0.609383285,
0.8525342941,
0.84413445,
0.1479563564,
0.8384568095,
0.3582164049,
0.256888032,
0.0190217048,
0.6244522929,
-0.7101400495,
-0.4700112343,
-0.4491072297,
-0.4694214761,
-0.6944729686,
-0.0505760573,
-0.7772753239,
0.5569364429,
-0.6443523169,
-0.2874187827,
0.2017546892,
-0.1026168913,
-0.5916065574,
0.169866994,
0.3656856716,
1.0817087889,
-0.5663303137,
0.6197923422,
0.4124896824,
-0.4242598712,
-1.1653399467,
0.1400324851,
-0.1431230903,
-0.4216816127,
0.2979743779,
0.3777898848,
-0.5437241197,
-0.3336594403,
-0.778685689,
-0.4503689706,
0.849544704,
0.204682216,
-0.3212657571,
-0.2413591892,
0.2110406309,
0.6084587574,
-0.3019646704,
0.2544284463,
0.8302505612,
0.4940958917,
0.3331117332,
-0.8932004571,
0.2656960487,
0.0257395282,
-0.0862855613,
0.4532803893,
-0.3024919629,
0.8516398668,
-0.5545158386,
-0.1460578442,
-0.202128619,
0.3259511888,
0.6720781326,
0.6907779574,
0.3537315428,
0.3708464801,
0.793276608,
0.0194201972,
0.7469981909,
0.0013112613,
0.2501139939,
1.2342382669,
-0.4688092768,
0.9573820829,
0.4942283928,
-0.1363821477,
1.1383968592,
0.0106484322,
0.2390130162,
0.2800495327,
0.006621174,
-0.3567896187,
-0.2572199404,
-0.051492691,
0.0294364002,
0.5836143494,
0.6454114914,
0.1661379486,
-0.5134077668,
-0.1071993783,
0.0143970726,
0.1859323084,
-0.4574716389,
0.7923128009,
0.1808704138,
-0.875520587,
0.6453819275,
-0.2526654899,
-0.0554560274,
-0.3504589796,
-0.4425546825,
0.1968131363,
-0.1404558122,
-0.3147434294,
-1.2231923342,
0.408457011,
0.2001582682,
0.029530447,
-0.2113285661,
0.5127642751,
-0.4370346665,
-0.3965294361,
0.1313078552,
0.5685540438,
0.0985716656,
0.0560495965,
-0.4424911737,
-0.2120519131,
-0.2666813135,
-0.1911769658,
-0.0911781713,
0.7857657075,
-0.4359389544,
0.6455942392,
0.6829044223,
0.0070231794,
0.1070169285,
0.366401881,
0.9864180684,
-1.0812654495,
-0.5941989422,
-1.0145395994,
0.6137874722,
-0.1406643093,
-0.1064063087,
0.3526466787,
0.3660541475,
0.4530678391,
-0.0205516145,
0.4032913446,
-0.1894971877,
0.2210267931,
-0.5598169565,
0.3413828015,
-0.0862579718,
0.1761477143,
-0.4404896498,
-0.77412045,
-0.6846823692,
0.6268845797,
-0.4558976889,
-0.1626416594,
1.1742771864,
0.5790101886,
0.2288453579,
0.0529214069,
0.3537789583,
0.380376339,
0.2872627676,
0.4545598328,
0.6493906975,
-0.0955748931,
0.5353657603,
-0.2245573699,
-0.118180871,
-0.0446571521,
-0.8857383728,
-1.0566831827,
-0.5440804958,
0.0726226345,
-0.436965853,
-0.0581558272,
1.1470952034,
0.4858022928,
-0.7561966181,
0.0294223428,
-0.7018074989,
0.5153431892,
-0.2026734501,
-0.2987850904,
0.1924398094,
-0.6520546675,
-0.1331067085,
0.1969963461,
0.7488085032,
-0.1592632532,
-0.2322606593,
0.4766257107,
-0.6344504952,
0.4270659983,
0.8231006265,
0.3044709563,
-0.8311379552,
-0.1834956557,
0.0642909482,
0.037545383,
0.3895078599,
1.0025376081,
-1.2408716679,
0.5172855258,
0.5884354115,
-0.0732225925,
0.7746862173,
0.2481125593,
0.6545162797,
-0.9054817557,
0.3948659897,
0.4280641079,
0.2675668001,
0.0321857929,
-0.6014095545,
0.2965862453,
-0.2150615752,
-0.4322732687,
-1.1294512749,
0.3813307583,
-1.3519663811,
-0.3236047029,
1.0507071018,
0.0289389826,
-0.5783210993,
-0.3465765715,
-0.7433462739,
0.1900354475,
-0.4867025614,
0.9881430268,
0.3790785968,
-0.5508072972,
-0.3071155548,
-0.4392719269,
0.3276070058,
-0.0871222243,
-1.0846340656,
0.0679869428,
0.1100565866,
-0.1854358763,
0.2822852433,
0.7037767768,
-0.1026147455,
0.5257269144,
0.4298422635,
0.0402238034,
0.0115811806,
-1.1108709574,
0.162519604,
0.4762973189,
-0.038180884,
-0.0882791281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.01768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.01768v1 | A Quantitative Review on Language Model Efficiency Research | 2023-05-28T20:25:20 | 2023-05-28T20:25:20 | Meng Jiang, Hy Dang, Lingbo Tong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Language models (LMs) are being scaled and becoming powerful. Improving their
efficiency is one of the core research topics in neural information processing
systems. Tay et al. (2022) provided a comprehensive overview of efficient
Transformers that have become an indispensable staple in the field of NLP.
However, in the section of "On Evaluation", they left an open question "which
fundamental efficient Transformer one should consider," answered by "still a
mystery" because "many research papers select their own benchmarks."
Unfortunately, there was not quantitative analysis about the performances of
Transformers on any benchmarks. Moreover, state space models (SSMs) have
demonstrated their abilities of modeling long-range sequences with
non-attention mechanisms, which were not discussed in the prior review. This
article makes a meta analysis on the results from a set of papers on efficient
Transformers as well as those on SSMs. It provides a quantitative review on LM
efficiency research and gives suggestions for future research. | [
-0.2153365314,
-0.5215650201,
0.5341439843,
0.3724695146,
0.0990081728,
-0.2362199277,
-0.3478307724,
-0.1618823707,
-0.0946788117,
0.282938391,
-0.1139899865,
-0.0839298815,
-0.6517928243,
0.1493290067,
-0.8841878176,
0.6663321853,
0.1836785525,
0.1836023927,
-0.2121034861,
-0.3435785472,
-0.0137491487,
-0.4603909552,
-0.587187767,
-0.3386875689,
0.3835152686,
0.0166493561,
0.7997566462,
0.3919775486,
0.994744122,
0.4541166127,
-0.3117191792,
-0.1732047498,
-0.5627713799,
0.0390210561,
-0.0485571176,
-0.4373885393,
-0.5792890787,
-0.0824798793,
1.0454950333,
0.7941712737,
-0.1897631437,
0.3665847778,
0.1182124391,
0.8942848444,
-0.7515131831,
-0.0072366311,
-0.4857475758,
0.0400881991,
0.0025216001,
-0.1285521239,
-0.6937856078,
-0.7130706906,
0.1492521763,
-0.2925240397,
0.1595167071,
0.0799863636,
0.610861659,
0.3781755865,
-0.3044236898,
-0.1038871184,
-1.1762448549,
0.9802498817,
-0.6362925768,
0.6825143099,
0.0838391408,
0.3286729455,
0.0697625354,
-0.8812410831,
-0.3380182087,
-0.3089723885,
-0.146352917,
0.0996587574,
-0.7671045065,
0.0742816031,
0.4267742932,
0.5295945406,
-0.4275061488,
-0.0859006643,
-0.4678277969,
-0.0623275116,
0.3206585944,
0.3689607084,
0.1968270689,
-0.2636978626,
-0.2784019411,
-0.0446832776,
-0.3454313874,
0.0313115641,
0.0948980078,
-0.0091953063,
0.2275960594,
0.9505844712,
0.0971343294,
0.6663514376,
-0.2464850247,
-0.1374884993,
-0.1399782002,
-0.4215253592,
-0.2525463998,
-0.4293343723,
0.8759894371,
0.2570547163,
0.3368955255,
-0.487994194,
-0.4223124087,
0.1317756176,
0.630264163,
-0.9098694324,
-0.0399646349,
0.0598475486,
-0.5871098638,
0.1221854463,
-0.2033858746,
-0.4467472732,
-0.0406690612,
-0.1118992642,
0.4075995684,
-0.5169888735,
-0.3243893683,
0.1767493486,
-0.2252339274,
0.1175025031,
-0.1710270345,
-0.6256315708,
0.5525754094,
0.8808268309,
1.0110621452,
-0.2124394774,
-0.0644949079,
0.0408084244,
-0.230234161,
-0.4587365985,
0.758916676,
-0.274841994,
-0.2400939167,
-0.0325580016,
-0.0698189363,
-0.3034596741,
-0.5389606357,
0.681833446,
-0.7220698595,
0.184359923,
-0.3601549566,
-0.5534991026,
-0.1758245677,
-0.3159746528,
-0.9769582748,
1.0307155848,
0.3637554944,
-0.6552767158,
0.2964145541,
-0.8884627819,
-0.1843852699,
-0.0322813839,
0.223305434,
-0.3398734629,
0.442759037,
-0.1659810543,
0.3209415972,
-0.3129890859,
0.6004757285,
-0.120105207,
-0.7119863033,
0.3999940157,
-0.4318898618,
0.6268761158,
0.2684245408,
-0.4213860035,
0.136064589,
-0.6359245777,
0.0830038488,
-0.0893083364,
-0.3324051499,
-0.394100666,
0.131605342,
-0.1782520711,
-0.0369294621,
-0.010697037,
-0.3981516063,
-0.1028194726,
-0.4292598963,
0.3923026323,
0.4165254831,
-0.4112112224,
1.0140259266,
-0.2730419338,
0.6881120205,
-0.438509196,
0.3303330243,
-0.0574368872,
-0.2800196707,
-1.2107665539,
-0.3319249749,
0.5971121192,
0.3002072275,
-0.5017898679,
0.432798624,
-0.3320220113,
-0.5970752239,
-0.7801091671,
-0.3120777905,
0.2357154638,
0.1621886641,
0.3228291869,
-0.1675066203,
-0.494549185,
-1.138284564,
-0.7458432317,
-0.0122546582,
0.008384834,
0.2075087428,
0.4064075351,
0.0933490172,
1.0100470781,
-0.3697732091,
0.2690669894,
-0.4877377152,
0.0779507384,
0.3267948925,
0.1370486319,
0.5245043635,
-0.5065633655,
-0.4440647364,
-0.4783938527,
-0.605025351,
-0.1486918181,
0.2301441431,
-0.005042227,
0.1594285667,
0.5526759028,
-0.7523289919,
0.131423682,
0.582681179,
-0.1687168777,
0.2712970078,
-0.0697719827,
0.0180469174,
-0.3829115033,
0.4761181176,
0.2253424823,
-0.09708938,
-0.9604448676,
0.0355413966,
0.4162074625,
-0.2654235065,
-0.1439448297,
0.4225298464,
-0.4942286909,
-0.2736226618,
-0.5671923161,
0.2372485995,
-0.3182996213,
0.4701355696,
-0.1220511869,
0.8193866014,
0.1287733018,
-0.7314370275,
-0.0847357437,
-0.2704120278,
-0.7521567345,
0.2822746634,
-0.8149214983,
-0.0142268492,
-0.3491521478,
0.1042635664,
-0.9876452684,
0.2496682107,
0.1931850612,
-0.2118166238,
0.0954356566,
0.3500609696,
-0.4132919908,
-0.4225316346,
-0.2736427188,
0.3022407293,
0.7101662159,
-0.2717546821,
0.5372245312,
0.4295299053,
0.0404084474,
-0.680469811,
-0.3993396163,
-0.2407310456,
-0.2999607325,
-0.5502202511,
0.0744007304,
0.1017730162,
-0.5389357209,
0.2953205705,
-0.2486411333,
0.0416073836,
0.2620151639,
-0.1142410114,
0.0213164147,
-0.3944389224,
0.532735467,
-0.2953308523,
-0.2964727283,
0.3564621806,
0.0055893832,
0.5355198383,
-0.3162638843,
-0.1890489459,
-0.4706424773,
0.0721510872,
0.3406692743,
-0.0689554513,
0.7431350946,
0.6183281541,
-0.1367883384,
-0.0487184487,
-0.6260392666,
-0.1999614835,
-0.4521614313,
0.651968956,
-0.230903402,
-0.8130202293,
0.1455844641,
-0.2934156358,
0.1049213707,
0.8942549229,
0.2643741369,
-0.0909586921,
0.9389492273,
0.9405261874,
0.065218918,
0.5903334618,
-0.3742235601,
0.5044365525,
-0.903401494,
-0.125587821,
-0.8071447015,
-0.5001862049,
-0.6156663299,
-0.5699090362,
0.4023122191,
0.2135656923,
-0.185494706,
0.5607625246,
-0.4118267894,
0.2618922591,
0.3778052926,
-0.1670315713,
0.3760102093,
-0.1514233351,
0.2519003153,
-0.1966608614,
-1.0930211544,
-0.6756269336,
0.9433521628,
0.4255868196,
0.8235190511,
0.1235806271,
0.0525560379,
0.1258533001,
0.4154711068,
-0.9111371636,
0.7246432304,
-0.2067416906,
-0.6859608293,
-0.5395002961,
-0.6008912325,
-1.0762437582,
0.4489031136,
-0.0954756811,
-0.3987218142,
0.1526325047,
-0.0050251205,
-0.3396675587,
0.3160283864,
-0.6756531,
0.5596345067,
-0.1512490809,
-0.1271764636,
-0.3995300233,
-0.3254482746,
0.7254018188,
-0.1768743545,
0.1303030252,
-0.0933520719,
-0.2309417725,
1.0638717413,
-0.3200004995,
0.3884947896,
-0.2376182526,
0.0713785142,
0.3701844215,
-0.0897045955,
0.2653209567,
-0.4654501677,
-0.3068952262,
0.069928579,
-0.1172370762,
-0.17800349,
-0.775128603,
0.475264132,
-0.4137274325,
-0.4328980148,
-0.4160860479,
-0.4310941398,
-0.0710004196,
-0.0206629019,
-0.0477116816,
0.336596638,
-0.2419591993,
0.6080956459,
0.6452633739,
-0.2825176716,
0.6610401869,
0.5799564123,
-0.2025189698,
-0.138593778,
0.5135877132,
0.4741841853,
0.3173634112,
0.4748851359,
0.2348778695,
-0.4387377203,
-0.164867714,
-0.2438195795,
0.3438483775,
-0.604126513,
-0.1116626114,
-0.9027616978,
-0.2390775532,
-0.3574436605,
0.4022436142,
-0.6811512709,
-0.6942735314,
0.1120584905,
0.0715941191,
0.1954368651,
0.8423403502,
-0.0122118862,
0.5828111172,
-0.5212049484,
0.5544905663,
0.1382065415,
0.4664807916,
0.4684924185,
-0.7209798694,
-0.5256935954,
-0.1938190311,
-0.3211649358,
-0.6575884223,
0.2869543135,
0.10171213,
0.7696645856,
0.1764575392,
-0.0284892712,
0.6124264598,
-0.4795660377,
0.664231956,
0.1168679669,
-0.9995313287,
0.0792617425,
0.1147555038,
0.5048031211,
0.0394014977,
0.7099914551,
-0.549972713,
-0.2478895634,
-0.5832099915,
-0.8692497611,
0.7589903474,
0.2065804005,
0.123671487,
0.1767639816,
0.2902886868,
-0.0708723441,
0.2348112166,
-0.7445706129,
-0.3511967361,
0.0778706893,
0.0430127569,
-0.2243937105,
-0.5332702994,
0.0485000163,
-0.2627032995,
0.536657691,
-0.0128246555,
0.4680845439,
0.0309514776,
-0.3308457732,
-0.0927495286,
0.4338372648,
0.4139651656,
0.765221417,
-0.0544156283,
0.0540086031,
0.2796753943,
-0.1747979075,
0.1806722432,
-0.394318223,
-0.0946109965,
0.2375078797,
0.3636446297,
0.846663177,
0.6338069439,
-0.3520879447,
0.4221630991,
-0.182047233,
-0.1129501909,
-0.2546256185,
0.0571045838,
0.2459355295,
0.3684096634,
0.3293357193,
0.2037759125,
0.2827031016,
-0.5652382374,
-0.0625229552,
0.4846339226,
-0.2401671261,
-0.199359715,
0.4436282814,
0.2303126752,
-0.5582478046,
0.8220364451,
0.0954867229,
-0.4780851007,
0.5268641114,
0.4589885175,
0.9621028304,
-0.3095837831,
0.0313678347,
0.5791270733,
0.5773972273,
-0.3536772132,
0.3254522383,
-0.2127444744,
-0.6035400629,
-0.5673707724,
-0.6342639923,
-0.3046609163,
0.2160341144,
-0.6398890615,
0.1575053483,
-0.0633567423,
-0.7173691988,
-0.0147867119,
-0.1292700022,
-0.5299277306,
0.1805173904,
-0.2987349629,
1.0378820896,
-0.7099456787,
0.5566928387,
0.1571965516,
0.1924613267,
-0.4357435405,
-0.1424094141,
-0.5060864687,
-0.5734983683,
0.5615129471,
-0.0739643052,
-0.4049018919,
-0.1829787791,
-0.2177812308,
-1.1010497808,
0.8915972114,
0.3898993433,
-0.6464514136,
-0.0310874674,
0.1215629056,
0.8654145002,
-0.033536952,
0.736682117,
0.5951676965,
0.5577166677,
-0.4053493738,
-0.7845018506,
-0.0716785043,
-0.2805847526,
0.3157692552,
0.4295415878,
-0.9312315583,
0.6456670761,
-0.2097337693,
-0.4848606586,
0.1997077167,
0.7941897511,
-0.128886506,
0.1850678772,
0.5849142075,
0.329551369,
0.4393716753,
-0.2695336044,
1.1389135122,
-0.5701624751,
0.4091098607,
0.7878879905,
-0.1652858555,
0.8586468101,
0.4096425772,
-0.5857396722,
0.309784472,
0.1977565885,
-0.1178138405,
0.3536171019,
0.4667922854,
0.0461834148,
-0.2370181531,
-0.0135753611,
-0.2275214493,
0.5483114123,
0.084136948,
-0.5162118077,
-0.048909869,
-0.2958999276,
-0.1756634414,
0.0253658611,
-0.0534837283,
0.7447058558,
0.153777197,
-0.7444769144,
0.4843800962,
0.3014049232,
0.5716826916,
-0.7256334424,
0.2706087828,
-0.1865436435,
0.1817229837,
-0.099831365,
-0.4398013055,
0.6010962725,
0.2028476745,
-0.2856378555,
-0.3700470626,
0.7982048392,
-0.1884559393,
-0.3305350542,
0.3798673451,
0.6720217466,
0.3807457089,
0.0807015449,
-0.5044686198,
0.063521713,
-0.316370219,
-0.4979030788,
0.1052824855,
0.2104062736,
0.0871969014,
0.8669481277,
0.305734396,
0.0321980268,
0.2415626943,
0.3055524528,
0.4872927368,
-1.0657551289,
-0.0520711392,
-0.9172170162,
0.461437583,
-0.199347645,
-0.2534817755,
0.9918029904,
0.7923055887,
0.6545292735,
-0.0780237988,
0.5521256924,
0.1145719737,
0.6360506415,
-0.3491597176,
0.6774877906,
-0.4512622058,
0.1379877776,
-0.1306113154,
-1.1841481924,
0.0883391947,
0.4886566401,
-0.2361991107,
0.5233753324,
1.041524291,
0.6948662996,
-0.0394499898,
0.257062912,
0.459479481,
0.2417830676,
-0.0324261747,
0.2290712595,
1.1213074923,
-0.7139086127,
0.4804533422,
-0.4266584218,
-0.1815637499,
-0.1931395382,
-0.7988395095,
-0.550275445,
-0.5409419537,
-0.0584479757,
-0.0044205519,
0.0482349731,
0.4384990036,
0.6662093401,
-0.511898756,
-0.5904887319,
0.1402450353,
0.0739852116,
-0.2903448343,
-0.1991487741,
0.4993165433,
-0.4420562685,
-1.0500442982,
0.419503212,
0.2860065699,
-0.2250707299,
-0.4873110056,
0.1313100755,
0.0261301361,
0.1492412388,
0.7891411185,
-0.1157981604,
-0.6043121815,
0.1156019643,
0.3478263021,
-0.3603727818,
-0.1239700839,
1.1973267794,
-0.6476653814,
0.1014744192,
0.7812175751,
0.4906209409,
0.3838752508,
0.0695002154,
0.599363625,
-0.2073605508,
-0.2336385697,
0.3621171117,
0.3226927221,
0.2807490528,
0.0925001204,
0.6648118496,
0.0071268594,
-0.8993858695,
-0.8740144968,
-0.0789589509,
-0.699867487,
-0.1962019354,
1.2386012077,
-0.0297169816,
-0.3217665255,
0.1924961954,
0.0672980174,
0.4028663933,
-0.273188591,
0.7903953195,
0.6354570389,
-0.292555213,
-0.0304909851,
-0.5763413906,
0.4745813012,
0.7604926825,
-0.5506014228,
-0.0361613967,
0.0672262162,
0.043627549,
0.2193109542,
0.5269648433,
-0.1890538931,
0.097577028,
0.0222046133,
0.0722437501,
0.399938941,
-0.464926213,
-0.6602188349,
0.1708586216,
0.1513663828,
0.1507425159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17804v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17804v1 | Targeted Data Generation: Finding and Fixing Model Weaknesses | 2023-05-28T19:36:50 | 2023-05-28T19:36:50 | Zexue He, Marco Tulio Ribeiro, Fereshte Khani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Even when aggregate accuracy is high, state-of-the-art NLP models often fail
systematically on specific subgroups of data, resulting in unfair outcomes and
eroding user trust. Additional data collection may not help in addressing these
weaknesses, as such challenging subgroups may be unknown to users, and
underrepresented in the existing and new data. We propose Targeted Data
Generation (TDG), a framework that automatically identifies challenging
subgroups, and generates new data for those subgroups using large language
models (LLMs) with a human in the loop. TDG estimates the expected benefit and
potential harm of data augmentation for each subgroup, and selects the ones
most likely to improve within group performance without hurting overall
performance. In our experiments, TDG significantly improves the accuracy on
challenging subgroups for state-of-the-art sentiment analysis and natural
language inference models, while also improving overall test accuracy. | [
-0.3007494211,
-0.7765218019,
0.4563373923,
0.0065891985,
0.1056890115,
0.349840343,
-0.0120879514,
-0.2339430302,
-0.2216732204,
0.5744493604,
-0.8054298162,
-0.9265056252,
-0.6177655458,
-0.0026296081,
-0.6369202137,
1.0803678036,
0.2258747071,
-0.0933878571,
-0.224080354,
0.097865209,
-0.6228760481,
-0.6906538606,
-0.6980744004,
-0.4113523364,
0.5733715296,
0.6401890516,
0.7371061444,
0.6741142273,
0.5375154614,
0.1670470834,
0.1666542143,
0.1845806539,
-0.5841769576,
0.0187029038,
-0.0907861218,
-0.6558452249,
-0.6732376218,
0.0371253006,
0.4659828246,
0.9281901121,
-0.2252881527,
0.1354049295,
0.0319973566,
0.6715518832,
-0.4239990711,
-0.1730497479,
-0.8665712476,
0.1711798012,
-0.4972763062,
-0.0257523805,
-0.4196478426,
-0.59627527,
0.0410285592,
-0.2002976388,
0.7366108298,
0.1652375013,
0.8372615576,
0.4136004746,
-0.5315228701,
-0.3042514324,
-0.6678748131,
0.8264576793,
-0.8645123243,
0.018918287,
0.4802042246,
0.1552588344,
-0.5230727792,
-0.5001274943,
-0.4268556535,
-0.118319504,
-0.0441542342,
-0.1005244926,
-0.2693215907,
-0.0409195013,
0.6122953892,
0.4361916482,
-0.7001683712,
0.201412797,
-0.2949901521,
-0.1373828948,
0.9550788999,
0.3549812734,
0.3697344363,
-0.3892588317,
-0.1406049579,
-0.0142723797,
-0.8737729192,
-0.1339311749,
0.5026975274,
0.6809526682,
0.2948141396,
1.0365847349,
-0.1819272041,
0.7754904032,
0.2011070997,
0.0575478412,
0.2853324413,
-0.3266875744,
-0.1471692771,
0.1335497797,
0.5004734993,
0.4435184598,
0.2368808091,
-0.0997817367,
-0.3500106037,
0.3609629571,
0.3984650671,
-0.4080536067,
-0.0681375638,
0.3606510758,
-0.2473373413,
-0.6021102071,
0.0610753372,
-0.8195536733,
-0.4220730662,
-0.1962351203,
0.1788421124,
-0.3012851179,
-0.1637849957,
0.1106777489,
-0.1957453638,
-0.0013761327,
-0.1335264295,
-0.8740836978,
0.1598712802,
0.667222321,
0.7790507078,
-0.4955432415,
-0.0783010051,
-0.6200621724,
0.4328103662,
-0.1601420939,
0.63671875,
-0.5180571079,
-0.6088601351,
0.021739766,
-0.424290061,
-0.116300106,
-0.7279807329,
0.5453366637,
-0.1751144975,
0.5541524291,
-0.5412251949,
-0.7294059992,
0.1459213048,
0.3739416301,
-0.7367101312,
1.270296216,
0.4885024726,
-0.7146585584,
0.7760203481,
-0.7448821664,
-0.3664219379,
0.1071959361,
-0.0767261758,
-0.6054551601,
0.322358191,
0.3936175108,
0.5212573409,
-0.4200184643,
0.7133713365,
-0.2738899589,
-0.1124685034,
0.1606721133,
-0.0603319369,
0.4761364162,
0.0372606069,
-0.3571067154,
0.2017076164,
-0.7833849788,
0.1090027541,
0.2724042535,
-0.3334262371,
-0.2900410593,
0.1419858932,
0.0105998227,
0.1660327762,
-0.0183984861,
-0.4978908896,
0.3293105066,
-0.1194890589,
0.0982063338,
1.012029767,
-0.0820723474,
0.3855021596,
-0.5417699814,
0.7888522744,
-0.0209808834,
-0.097777985,
0.1447995156,
-0.5392781496,
-0.5265609622,
0.1182739511,
0.4610582888,
0.4591373205,
-0.8059091568,
0.5716780424,
-0.3668820858,
-0.441934973,
-0.2888569832,
0.234128207,
0.2191571891,
0.9320523739,
0.3027718365,
-0.3633705974,
-0.4920251667,
-0.9070488214,
-0.3841823041,
-0.4057276845,
-0.4301228821,
0.5101166368,
0.1313504279,
-0.4056271017,
1.0957722664,
-0.6522892118,
-0.2678336501,
-0.6020437479,
0.3173847497,
-0.0935047567,
0.3227525055,
0.4563108981,
-0.749760747,
-0.4035505056,
-0.2059361637,
-0.6580384374,
-0.5033999681,
0.0261951294,
-0.0116645573,
0.0942533091,
0.200345695,
-0.460839659,
0.3339150548,
0.6398060322,
-0.3911470473,
0.420207262,
0.3365059793,
0.1182802543,
-1.1523468494,
-0.0195303485,
0.345385313,
-0.229377538,
-0.6829903722,
-0.3879194558,
-0.1484694183,
-0.3216042221,
-0.2074417323,
0.3943301737,
-0.0054626209,
0.1535970569,
-0.1620863229,
-0.0530774221,
-0.1220948696,
0.1500549614,
-0.2329620719,
0.7693970799,
0.331004262,
-0.5964725614,
0.3550253808,
0.3692554533,
-0.1965619922,
0.4769115448,
-0.7719866037,
0.2685547769,
-0.2144579887,
0.0731435642,
-0.7632499933,
-0.8757205606,
0.0893157274,
-0.681792438,
0.3122560978,
0.0509869531,
-0.2940286994,
-0.4969535768,
-0.1766378284,
0.3960972428,
0.6213297844,
-0.5086692572,
0.4064972103,
0.5419186354,
-0.1630141735,
-0.4989362657,
-0.6805388331,
0.2461516857,
-0.6085348129,
-0.7907697558,
0.3987853229,
0.3370648324,
-0.275269717,
0.097072497,
0.1092945635,
0.1846747249,
-0.0329310559,
-0.0059774066,
0.0136675881,
0.0122484863,
0.4483550787,
-0.2622116208,
-0.0494250096,
0.2481024861,
-0.0591497868,
0.6440201998,
0.1653387994,
-0.4688259959,
-0.03010986,
0.5419986844,
0.2554556727,
-0.1531102955,
0.4866836965,
0.5451303124,
-0.5315487981,
-0.5814058185,
-0.512022078,
-0.2322056144,
-0.5130488873,
0.5762478113,
-0.1797500849,
-0.9493437409,
0.4100684822,
-0.1845276803,
0.0523293875,
0.3967361152,
0.4521763325,
0.0323861837,
1.4008800983,
0.7888634205,
-0.3176173568,
0.2454562485,
0.0771117806,
0.33447963,
-0.5401511192,
-0.2693567872,
-0.6026726961,
-0.4189473391,
-0.5659176111,
-0.2235764414,
0.4035597146,
-0.111523442,
0.1068865582,
0.1992200315,
-0.6210964918,
0.1708998084,
0.6137901545,
0.207756862,
0.158528775,
0.1415185034,
0.1386915147,
-0.2790983617,
-0.9291009903,
-0.617945075,
1.5078946352,
0.2750001848,
0.8992563486,
-0.0032535319,
0.7282451391,
0.7058007717,
0.427470088,
-0.7170802355,
0.5081358552,
-0.2151759565,
-0.7567375898,
-0.212067768,
-0.7276212573,
-1.024220705,
-0.403199017,
-0.0976422876,
-0.6144320965,
-0.0648025572,
0.4869174063,
-0.1492886394,
0.3563872576,
-0.7446525097,
0.7657310963,
-0.254465878,
-0.2863357961,
0.1850884557,
-0.3048486412,
0.6310454011,
-0.3458220959,
-0.0375283547,
-0.2634232938,
0.266214937,
0.7935010195,
-0.4126183391,
0.702865541,
-0.3908116817,
-0.1218447238,
0.3222230971,
-0.1668083072,
0.5775247216,
-0.099989526,
-0.3026845455,
0.0309106354,
-0.7618072033,
-0.5468472838,
-0.6168055534,
0.4901599288,
-0.2329746336,
-0.7547366023,
-0.3752610981,
-0.7710028291,
-0.4965258837,
-0.0111463787,
0.306676805,
0.0784527883,
-0.2747884095,
0.2310826778,
0.5543259978,
-0.2770755291,
0.1739644855,
0.1672284454,
-0.0542287007,
-0.1077479273,
0.7175305486,
-0.0636262298,
0.3385474384,
-0.1746051162,
0.0421006642,
-0.4244112968,
-0.7074745893,
-0.3311351538,
0.0521909371,
-0.255043447,
-0.2949486673,
-0.5098218322,
-0.1214606613,
-0.4249153733,
-0.0531551689,
-0.32994169,
-0.2887330949,
-0.2393244058,
-0.3315100968,
0.259527415,
0.6981082559,
-0.0371004976,
0.5430389643,
-0.9874779582,
0.3456794918,
0.3198170662,
0.1750876307,
-0.2602078021,
-0.3399473727,
-0.1779892594,
0.1086979136,
-0.4159318209,
-0.8947021365,
0.5022497773,
0.0809061751,
0.3942325115,
0.0138223162,
-0.0616638102,
0.5930672288,
-0.3292938769,
0.7394942045,
0.0608338229,
-1.0533211231,
0.9656183124,
-0.6706405282,
0.2872671783,
0.5729128122,
0.2945062816,
-0.5278528929,
-0.3787248731,
-0.5486091971,
-0.8626180887,
0.6754359007,
0.2691546381,
0.1079766899,
-0.108438842,
0.7100086212,
-0.0566743277,
0.3482524157,
-0.8272635937,
0.0106983762,
0.2569603622,
-0.5718484521,
0.0428294539,
-0.2361825854,
-0.1969696283,
-0.0493278839,
0.656740129,
-0.3950893879,
0.0823000818,
0.0466508046,
0.2063868493,
-0.5403131247,
0.1552074254,
0.2222394943,
0.7702758908,
-0.1768334806,
-0.182638377,
0.0276480373,
-0.3456471562,
0.3056145012,
0.0547224917,
-0.4491939545,
-0.0795429125,
0.3568630815,
0.5635942221,
-0.3102642298,
-0.7810747027,
0.3427752554,
-0.03111545,
-0.2400985509,
-0.1834380478,
0.4288732708,
-0.1235704944,
-0.0285330359,
0.6765578985,
-0.0601618327,
0.0177398715,
-0.4218460023,
0.4816690683,
0.6077920198,
-0.4176180959,
-0.21303913,
0.7989334464,
0.0285636541,
-0.3944333792,
0.8237131238,
-0.1226842254,
-0.5862411261,
0.7653870583,
0.5326712728,
0.824133873,
-0.4461800158,
0.439712435,
0.3553986549,
0.4830471277,
-0.110303171,
0.3199132085,
0.4992122352,
-0.8600390553,
-0.480434835,
-0.4058071077,
-0.4246061742,
0.1972453892,
-0.8472925425,
0.3805866838,
-0.2466822565,
-0.497895211,
-0.0453361273,
-0.1826730072,
-0.6155569553,
0.5795933008,
0.0546514168,
0.568696022,
-0.9949210882,
0.5803287029,
0.5138554573,
-0.0797345415,
-0.8347377181,
0.1287450641,
0.1117234379,
-0.6611450315,
0.3563599288,
0.0977024361,
0.332546562,
0.0067651286,
-0.7142902017,
-0.7350508571,
1.0726089478,
0.3060115576,
-0.6401998401,
-0.1031528041,
0.6280526519,
0.5163238645,
-0.4496321976,
-0.3651601672,
0.6678282619,
0.4889118969,
0.0090842312,
-0.7860940695,
0.1707292199,
-0.1537830681,
-0.1271977127,
0.3697728515,
-0.5217999816,
0.7200698256,
-0.2566103935,
-0.1130517498,
-0.4175879359,
0.4385633767,
0.4977639318,
0.5496486425,
0.6121040583,
0.9602572918,
0.9364763498,
-0.4556539357,
1.2299540043,
0.179395631,
0.1572645158,
1.0586885214,
-0.5173962712,
0.2401229143,
0.292558223,
-0.1837314218,
0.1813718528,
0.7500975132,
-0.3602046967,
0.3152885437,
0.2757390141,
-0.337046504,
-0.1413556039,
-0.3585602939,
-0.3398396373,
0.5633451343,
0.380035311,
-0.4608867764,
-0.1756087542,
-0.0246039238,
-0.0112468237,
0.1420907527,
-0.1644943506,
0.687415123,
-0.0577604808,
-0.6799628735,
0.4424300492,
0.2280581295,
0.491985023,
-0.5397399068,
0.0737851337,
-0.2976461947,
0.0540109091,
-0.4037311375,
-0.4540037811,
0.5874192119,
0.3337856233,
-0.2198489159,
-0.179461211,
0.8346280456,
-0.4069092572,
-0.711269021,
0.2182391435,
0.6329613924,
-0.2298436761,
-0.2775194645,
-0.6580953002,
-0.0034139471,
0.4491235912,
-0.3733207583,
0.124628596,
0.310616076,
-0.1085467637,
0.7011232972,
0.629463613,
0.1181394532,
0.1890823394,
0.1523614377,
1.0463519096,
-0.9146741033,
-0.0414420813,
-0.9182744026,
0.6403593421,
-0.3514060378,
-0.2302848101,
1.0036197901,
0.65881145,
0.7560871243,
0.1552231759,
1.1438916922,
-0.1465201974,
0.8018060923,
-0.4265084863,
0.3839647174,
-0.6246716976,
0.4382716119,
-0.2949728966,
-1.031219244,
-0.4806478322,
0.1717945635,
-0.2897720635,
0.2241643965,
0.3872847259,
0.8796402812,
-0.0464430004,
-0.0956699327,
0.1088733301,
0.0609262548,
0.7476214767,
0.8124318123,
0.7570363879,
-0.4305472672,
0.3821311891,
-0.1910346597,
-0.1856634319,
0.1624444425,
-0.7139204741,
-1.0621153116,
-0.1739419848,
-0.3627320826,
-0.4647394121,
-0.0804271251,
0.7182107568,
0.5717135072,
-0.8992619514,
-0.0445888788,
-0.4387423098,
0.1187755987,
0.3236342072,
-0.3347128928,
0.2133084834,
-0.3493880928,
-0.9132022262,
0.4039707482,
0.0212216545,
0.1464863271,
-0.2822318971,
0.0711812824,
-0.009567203,
0.1256776005,
0.3411939144,
0.098145619,
-0.4138687849,
-0.3205683231,
0.1511851996,
-0.0856745541,
0.0020006793,
1.0355710983,
-0.7105200887,
0.1717121452,
0.2193835676,
0.8287526369,
0.43193537,
0.5889431238,
0.9660679102,
-1.1275690794,
-0.1101015285,
0.6036551595,
0.0236684438,
0.5806260705,
-0.6957322955,
0.6535960436,
0.2616648674,
-0.5513297319,
-1.0516272783,
0.4021987617,
-0.6764227152,
-0.0407596529,
1.1431522369,
0.1154354513,
-0.0346595719,
-0.1464131176,
-0.0530474409,
0.1978346556,
-0.3250782788,
1.3257701397,
0.9285250306,
-0.1602267772,
0.0065694628,
-0.397552073,
0.7453644872,
0.687715888,
-1.1308522224,
0.0515707657,
0.7259989381,
0.0160071403,
-0.0787419602,
0.5950444937,
-0.1476625204,
-0.0457104668,
-0.1603425443,
0.0169663373,
0.1430736631,
-0.215399608,
-0.1389744431,
0.4781219065,
-0.0966030359,
0.0512330197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18419v1 | Semantic Segmentation with Bidirectional Language Models Improves Long-form ASR | 2023-05-28T19:31:45 | 2023-05-28T19:31:45 | W. Ronny Huang, Hao Zhang, Shankar Kumar, Shuo-yiin Chang, Tara N. Sainath | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | We propose a method of segmenting long-form speech by separating semantically
complete sentences within the utterance. This prevents the ASR decoder from
needlessly processing faraway context while also preventing it from missing
relevant context within the current sentence. Semantically complete sentence
boundaries are typically demarcated by punctuation in written text; but
unfortunately, spoken real-world utterances rarely contain punctuation. We
address this limitation by distilling punctuation knowledge from a
bidirectional teacher language model (LM) trained on written, punctuated text.
We compare our segmenter, which is distilled from the LM teacher, against a
segmenter distilled from a acoustic-pause-based teacher used in other works, on
a streaming ASR pipeline. The pipeline with our segmenter achieves a 3.2%
relative WER gain along with a 60 ms median end-of-segment latency reduction on
a YouTube captioning task. | [
-0.1985954791,
-0.6917194724,
0.5497211814,
0.1959415823,
-0.7028905153,
0.2033055574,
-0.2710414529,
-0.54452461,
0.0045861755,
0.736687839,
-0.4654545784,
-0.4196909368,
-0.6400348544,
0.2146345675,
-0.4647741318,
0.8053253889,
0.0547003075,
0.2603859305,
-0.5790534019,
0.057277821,
-0.4612529576,
-0.4516273141,
-0.6994950175,
-0.3633212149,
0.5276153684,
0.5560984015,
0.3947941065,
0.7260497212,
0.5703594089,
0.3500747681,
-0.5542674065,
-0.0779705718,
-0.1123771667,
0.3075352907,
-0.1944891959,
-0.2495652139,
0.1230265498,
-0.0441322997,
0.8633603454,
1.1833417416,
-0.1173721179,
-0.3241043091,
-0.0155337779,
0.7874825597,
-0.5798903704,
0.1115921959,
-0.4365387559,
0.0301440135,
-0.2359198779,
0.0186523423,
-0.2460307032,
-0.3128833175,
0.4737146497,
-0.1804405749,
0.062662743,
-0.2067244053,
0.8369128704,
0.5822994113,
-0.4374273717,
-0.4099054039,
-0.8148517609,
0.7075642347,
-0.5285028815,
0.6783422232,
0.3923581541,
0.3201830089,
0.1251779944,
-0.8154705763,
-0.7785529494,
-0.1466169953,
0.1185686663,
0.152795732,
0.0341249332,
0.2479998022,
0.3345316052,
0.3789656162,
-0.3808900416,
0.0705143958,
-0.8745864034,
-0.2082363814,
0.391756624,
-0.1458124667,
0.3051663935,
-0.2967637777,
-0.7255235314,
-0.1353897899,
-0.5761905909,
0.2588723898,
0.4835823178,
0.1230583042,
0.1655550897,
0.5472044349,
-0.1283383369,
0.9485112429,
-0.2278835028,
-0.1893924773,
0.0244339965,
-0.1595023423,
-0.0437430888,
0.4281129837,
0.6761081815,
0.4091843665,
0.4529895484,
-0.139852345,
-0.0702110454,
0.2622185349,
-0.1221179962,
-0.9881339669,
-0.4286611974,
0.0106438529,
-0.0571252219,
-0.0499644428,
0.2069871575,
-0.4963401556,
-0.0111357411,
-0.4648863077,
0.1365816146,
-0.5899279714,
0.2330597043,
0.4335994422,
-0.4195158482,
0.3447747231,
0.2287619561,
-0.5551442504,
0.468469739,
0.5527891517,
0.8471679688,
-0.1579123288,
-0.3254176974,
-0.6983225346,
0.3953343034,
0.1037262902,
1.0379517078,
-0.6726848483,
-0.3652279973,
-0.1680727899,
0.0504411869,
-0.318059504,
-0.7341827154,
0.7592454553,
-0.686270833,
0.6293617487,
-0.0383052751,
-0.7773776054,
-0.2596942484,
0.1799718589,
-0.7919567823,
0.6565810442,
-0.2412048429,
-0.5986011028,
0.5215631127,
-0.6240514517,
-0.6911814213,
-0.1094031036,
0.0728791356,
-0.4751769006,
-0.2430142462,
0.3408434093,
0.1999277174,
-0.1040419191,
0.3422761261,
0.0875339657,
-0.2810182571,
0.3858031034,
-0.4624845982,
0.7221734524,
0.2024061382,
-0.2016214728,
0.2224383503,
-0.8676075339,
-0.1478682458,
-0.1382237822,
-0.4370892048,
-0.4665006697,
0.3310197294,
0.3386432528,
0.2679401636,
0.0337144919,
-0.8517856002,
-0.2732478976,
-0.6802455187,
0.6256593466,
0.5722157359,
0.0491060019,
0.2984313965,
-0.1241023839,
0.1988941878,
0.3851687908,
-0.0990555733,
-0.3159255981,
-0.0490564257,
-1.0082749128,
-0.6485489607,
0.3692294359,
0.4039402902,
-0.5328378081,
0.6281988621,
-0.3414852023,
0.0764224008,
-0.3335215151,
0.1159315109,
0.3962232172,
0.7759436369,
0.4373416007,
-0.5460532904,
-0.6252006292,
-0.7360425591,
0.0232069008,
0.0427805446,
-0.0720341504,
-0.0097820796,
0.2917410135,
-0.0789418519,
1.2165842056,
-0.7691676021,
-0.2341153771,
-0.258415997,
-0.2368305027,
0.0214271713,
0.4920093715,
0.0283239372,
-1.0077079535,
-0.6395030618,
-0.3619731367,
-0.3698329329,
-0.0375034176,
0.1463384032,
-0.0639045686,
0.1324828416,
0.74597013,
-0.6879873276,
0.3952043653,
0.160079971,
-0.5749655962,
0.226494357,
-0.1399696171,
-0.1339580864,
-1.055021286,
0.1093186364,
-0.3392330408,
-0.5251399279,
-0.5232897401,
-0.2293490171,
-0.1177293435,
-0.4499917328,
-0.4868404865,
0.2157983333,
-0.5378094316,
-0.0070112441,
-0.3951479495,
0.4232254028,
0.3268533051,
0.1496933103,
0.542026341,
0.695541501,
0.467037946,
-0.4399670959,
0.3728784025,
0.5101073384,
-0.3526441157,
0.5443122983,
-0.9982896447,
0.0703372285,
-0.2149793953,
0.3517380059,
-0.955080092,
-0.0327465199,
0.1791148633,
-0.216936484,
0.2516798377,
-0.25031057,
-0.322984606,
-0.3757413924,
-0.2082104832,
0.3508722186,
0.5030738115,
-0.4715268314,
0.0606670789,
0.1988271326,
-0.3155634403,
-0.2010518909,
-0.4536342919,
0.0232342929,
-0.2611052096,
-0.9616678357,
0.2180244923,
-0.1007350311,
-0.230640471,
-0.15042153,
-0.205723092,
-0.2463917285,
-0.0292714871,
0.3078524172,
0.3575107753,
-0.1913022697,
-0.0004690207,
-0.0057336944,
-0.3134884238,
0.2200815678,
-0.4066024125,
0.6319206357,
0.2072267383,
-0.4662259221,
-0.6405659318,
0.4746503234,
0.4600846171,
-0.41707775,
0.6723515391,
0.4543046951,
-0.166154176,
-0.0325065367,
-0.6518155932,
-0.2829598188,
-0.3981806934,
0.1344458759,
-0.3159018755,
-1.0041246414,
0.3051761985,
0.0301423818,
-0.3865553141,
0.2376024425,
-0.0341508612,
-0.1107896939,
0.606908977,
0.6459947228,
-0.0304776356,
0.6755312085,
-0.2394121885,
0.2185314745,
-0.7870862484,
-0.2505803406,
-0.4226133227,
-0.0473309532,
-0.2439613193,
-0.5649299622,
0.2024612725,
0.2563208342,
0.0045403,
0.0211265832,
-0.4979568124,
0.7989448905,
0.6262694001,
0.0798507482,
0.3413549364,
0.1049037576,
0.1016266644,
0.007637186,
-0.3610936999,
-0.4665012062,
0.6325342655,
0.3435390294,
0.5215888619,
-0.0014701579,
0.796135366,
0.0789918602,
-0.2906436622,
-0.9638546109,
0.4480229616,
-0.2147073895,
-0.3264738023,
-0.5928957462,
-0.2896285057,
-0.9015157819,
0.2697886527,
0.3515702486,
-0.4978260398,
-0.0569663346,
-0.2394192964,
-0.5267807245,
0.0449680611,
-0.5962840915,
0.8771522045,
0.1401100755,
-0.3358068466,
-0.0462068543,
-1.0617969036,
-0.112100184,
0.2065657377,
-0.0617080741,
-0.2347284406,
0.1707374752,
1.0661070347,
-0.8209177852,
0.7883444428,
-0.4537243545,
0.0826028734,
0.7109117508,
-0.2633756995,
0.4523897469,
-0.2360584736,
0.2933216393,
-0.0517696738,
0.1110127047,
-0.366921097,
-0.3972144425,
0.3791136444,
-0.7851793766,
-0.4492822289,
-0.4774259925,
-0.4416937232,
-0.2299006879,
0.1770270169,
0.0916921124,
0.4623861015,
-0.1064854264,
0.1743665338,
0.6697310805,
0.2767148614,
0.77806288,
0.3927174807,
0.2158109695,
-0.6563808322,
0.6144288778,
-0.0892957598,
0.2588388324,
0.5267627835,
0.2419614047,
-0.6026986241,
-0.6163659096,
-0.4036091864,
0.4137051105,
-0.758390069,
-0.1282598227,
-0.6487293839,
-0.3909223676,
-0.3958551884,
-0.2901055813,
-0.2588301003,
-0.5645093322,
-0.4451961219,
-0.1223247126,
0.3240350187,
0.5996984839,
0.0402350016,
0.5535879731,
-0.7878991961,
0.0127347475,
0.3816258907,
0.1202906147,
-0.337628454,
-0.6432417631,
-0.0642694384,
0.0047274916,
-0.1821335256,
-0.5571149588,
0.3969310224,
0.3577405512,
0.2270063162,
0.5260352492,
-0.0255414192,
1.0008658171,
-0.7920150161,
0.7747862935,
0.5102474093,
-1.0707737207,
0.6673970222,
-0.1665468514,
0.39338094,
0.5403715968,
0.265927434,
-0.6925200224,
-0.2601420283,
-0.2165050358,
-1.0712403059,
0.7223265767,
0.101531893,
-0.0002085583,
-0.2302178144,
0.0691577792,
0.1149459183,
0.062347997,
-0.71720469,
0.0907870382,
-0.2268190086,
-0.3420402408,
-0.1549327374,
-0.7547218204,
-0.1430399418,
-0.173666209,
0.4965915978,
-0.048302494,
-0.2943918705,
0.41173172,
-0.4512640238,
0.0443107896,
0.4082821906,
0.5779646039,
0.7914097905,
-0.2655358016,
0.4786398411,
-0.0762920231,
-0.6345504522,
-0.0119274287,
0.6512162685,
-0.2114830166,
0.1270880103,
0.3661682308,
0.695479095,
0.3092686832,
-0.792902112,
0.7403078675,
0.1644503027,
0.0224522874,
-0.5343924165,
-0.2056213915,
0.117642723,
0.4176356494,
0.1761143953,
-0.1457363963,
0.3345648348,
-0.3333945274,
0.4016393721,
0.1795501709,
-0.6909552813,
-0.3376946449,
0.6146942377,
0.4086203277,
0.0192924775,
0.8528715372,
0.2620086372,
-0.7727882266,
0.4402241707,
0.7661328912,
0.8297606111,
-0.1484412551,
0.0845649242,
0.1488469839,
-0.1780579388,
0.1038597003,
0.2065331936,
-0.6065180302,
-0.573841989,
-0.4939844608,
-0.9801363945,
-0.2379395217,
-0.3587127328,
-0.7604306936,
0.2289516181,
-0.3207811713,
0.1304795593,
0.2577669919,
-0.0792229176,
-0.3014205694,
0.3569127917,
0.4608339071,
0.707069397,
-0.7430891395,
0.7927342057,
0.7399696708,
-0.4812810421,
-0.6500285268,
-0.0314596742,
-0.5298483968,
-0.5704776049,
0.850346148,
0.3754509985,
-0.3533752859,
-0.1269032657,
-0.4710990191,
-0.9446240067,
1.0067439079,
0.15494214,
-0.6138350368,
-0.102878049,
0.4403403699,
0.3806276321,
-0.2389633507,
0.0083698472,
0.5144181848,
0.1010690853,
0.7754661441,
-0.9076813459,
-0.0828627497,
0.055221688,
0.1904828101,
0.3994302452,
-0.5683405995,
0.6883649826,
-0.1718955785,
-0.2426442653,
-0.0995422006,
0.8075349331,
0.11320851,
0.5391533971,
0.6643343568,
0.5782753229,
0.6106868982,
0.0689576119,
0.6500709057,
-0.2607153356,
0.2355944812,
1.166469574,
-0.3287320733,
1.0014904737,
0.8755815625,
-0.1906105727,
0.7421575189,
0.4948461354,
0.3101212978,
0.6982151866,
0.1415321529,
-0.571762383,
-0.3553329706,
-0.2788594663,
-0.1287361681,
0.773358047,
-0.030501416,
-0.3547010422,
-0.1969299316,
0.2726409733,
0.3552654982,
0.3016976118,
-0.2068042606,
0.9975520372,
0.1372599155,
-0.6172475815,
0.4922828674,
-0.1970260292,
0.4655723274,
-0.5307822824,
0.0822815821,
-0.1584061831,
0.2852945626,
-0.0628289357,
-0.6780976653,
0.5292897224,
0.0297970381,
-0.4710649252,
-0.2119043618,
0.8164415359,
-0.9334874153,
-0.4267371893,
0.0920005664,
0.4208516181,
0.3426906765,
-0.3460038006,
-0.1980987042,
0.1878422499,
0.1108921468,
-0.0637655258,
-0.071748741,
0.392600745,
0.0116350381,
0.5187621117,
0.7659742832,
0.0619912371,
0.0341045335,
0.3037303984,
1.1963723898,
-0.9215149283,
-0.7102949023,
-1.0540264845,
0.6041990519,
-0.3408706784,
0.0226990171,
0.6516409516,
0.8980079889,
0.9288034439,
-0.0812927708,
0.4578887522,
0.048742976,
0.6252707243,
-0.5740578175,
0.661968708,
-0.1059483513,
0.0714926422,
-0.1136855036,
-0.8998371363,
-0.41782552,
0.7092475295,
-0.6062610745,
-0.4388176799,
0.738853395,
0.4000393152,
-0.1179626212,
0.0477644689,
0.5546497107,
-0.1071378887,
0.2423763424,
0.3699916303,
1.1806224585,
-0.3682683408,
0.6173789501,
-0.473069787,
-0.0057717995,
0.1604568064,
-0.4928128421,
-1.0677953959,
-0.6285915375,
-0.4214147925,
-0.0588470064,
0.2436374575,
0.8395132422,
0.6629039049,
-0.7764769197,
-0.3846249282,
-0.0526482686,
0.1809660941,
0.2552444041,
-0.2640458345,
0.4892275333,
-0.3568402231,
-0.8036233187,
0.450104028,
0.3341979682,
0.0534424484,
0.0284029767,
0.062862888,
-0.2531356514,
0.0537902452,
0.8405917287,
0.0064078243,
-0.6684676409,
-0.4689027369,
-0.1353536546,
0.0352931358,
0.2567797601,
0.738202095,
-0.7365389466,
0.5566830039,
0.1495970488,
0.247656554,
0.6118047237,
0.2131632119,
0.2996317744,
-0.6818707585,
0.4112679064,
0.511615634,
0.2377644628,
0.6761485338,
-0.0750067681,
0.3152356744,
0.4845912755,
-0.5192267299,
-0.7231216431,
0.1256736666,
-1.1326069832,
-0.1322687268,
1.2130880356,
-0.1701698303,
-0.4597858787,
-0.0694753751,
-0.3004142642,
0.3294828832,
-0.3180770576,
0.3913358748,
0.4832984805,
-0.0608222596,
-0.2309578657,
-0.0320225842,
0.4774405062,
0.2759463787,
-0.6489710808,
-0.1049664468,
0.9619080424,
0.698024869,
0.0822211951,
0.4749567509,
-0.0386830308,
0.1483156979,
0.1177701354,
0.1579112709,
-0.179056704,
-0.4312230945,
-0.3388171494,
0.2269099206,
0.0945251286,
-0.5949656367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13089v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13089v3 | GIMLET: A Unified Graph-Text Model for Instruction-Based Molecule Zero-Shot Learning | 2023-05-28T18:27:59 | 2023-10-22T18:13:40 | Haiteng Zhao, Shengchao Liu, Chang Ma, Hannan Xu, Jie Fu, Zhi-Hong Deng, Lingpeng Kong, Qi Liu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.BM | Molecule property prediction has gained significant attention in recent
years. The main bottleneck is the label insufficiency caused by expensive lab
experiments. In order to alleviate this issue and to better leverage textual
knowledge for tasks, this study investigates the feasibility of employing
natural language instructions to accomplish molecule-related tasks in a
zero-shot setting. We discover that existing molecule-text models perform
poorly in this setting due to inadequate treatment of instructions and limited
capacity for graphs. To overcome these issues, we propose GIMLET, which unifies
language models for both graph and text data. By adopting generalized position
embedding, our model is extended to encode both graph structures and
instruction text without additional graph encoding modules. GIMLET also
decouples encoding of the graph from tasks instructions in the attention
mechanism, enhancing the generalization of graph features across novel tasks.
We construct a dataset consisting of more than two thousand molecule tasks with
corresponding instructions derived from task descriptions. We pretrain GIMLET
on the molecule tasks along with instructions, enabling the model to transfer
effectively to a broad range of tasks. Experimental results demonstrate that
GIMLET significantly outperforms molecule-text baselines in instruction-based
zero-shot learning, even achieving closed results to supervised GNN models on
tasks such as toxcast and muv. | [
0.1710983813,
-0.9658603072,
0.601567328,
-0.4332455993,
-0.2204637676,
0.0483202599,
-0.2580231726,
-0.4268980622,
-0.0348624028,
0.6332581043,
-0.2665640414,
-0.9966647029,
-0.8608695865,
-0.3026624024,
-0.1939674318,
1.4146181345,
-0.131102398,
-0.0843091831,
-0.3971331418,
0.1674425304,
-0.3577531874,
-0.2928498983,
-0.1756928861,
-0.3420205712,
0.428525269,
0.5436165333,
0.4585582614,
0.7895624638,
0.443213135,
0.22251302,
0.0629752204,
-0.1401447505,
-0.6401103735,
-0.0540728606,
-0.079142116,
-0.2253405452,
-0.5180904269,
0.2182434201,
0.3432960212,
0.6584709287,
-0.1401053518,
0.1107927486,
0.0246212892,
0.3931520879,
-0.5683397651,
0.4904599488,
-0.5651304722,
0.1063880995,
0.120043084,
-0.0341121405,
-0.570515573,
0.0502309948,
0.3894984126,
-0.8130587935,
0.3606090844,
-0.2762670517,
0.9732529521,
0.0118131479,
-0.6246853471,
-0.4787067473,
-0.529522121,
0.5921297073,
-0.4245621264,
-0.1378671676,
0.2232955247,
0.4495574832,
-0.0443783589,
-0.743539691,
-0.0615055226,
-0.6836816669,
-0.2256365418,
0.114324823,
0.1391914785,
0.5589347482,
-0.0942154601,
0.2054138333,
-0.780348599,
-0.2976616621,
-0.3422485292,
0.0239471737,
0.2920798063,
-0.0941123441,
0.5533192754,
-0.1629173905,
-0.5209465623,
-0.1035188437,
-0.3786972165,
-0.2258913219,
0.0422271378,
0.4810445309,
-0.0554773025,
0.8126142621,
-0.1388561875,
0.9330529571,
-0.0831531584,
0.2462565303,
-0.1032044068,
-0.3564528227,
-0.5353384614,
0.4083692133,
0.6365796328,
0.0720060542,
0.5540107489,
-0.4315031469,
0.0848145559,
0.0454507247,
0.3045508265,
-1.2318120003,
-0.5940552354,
0.2399558425,
0.2427956313,
-0.2643142343,
0.1754198968,
-0.7021369338,
-0.2378896922,
-0.2446707934,
0.6562756896,
-0.4946534336,
0.1401678026,
0.18527174,
-0.3899105191,
-0.3367792368,
0.1911403388,
-1.1588224173,
0.211375922,
0.6046119332,
0.9471629858,
0.0791082829,
-0.3524024785,
-0.5667781234,
0.6521070004,
0.0008996754,
0.6742061973,
-0.8528997302,
-0.6273739338,
-0.5089644194,
-0.0148630077,
-0.3244849741,
-0.2827079594,
-0.3201901019,
-0.116633527,
0.4240010977,
0.3888312876,
-0.9438983202,
-0.2694798708,
0.244247064,
-0.3957520723,
0.6183432341,
0.4754202664,
-0.419880569,
0.2305960953,
-0.95946455,
-0.4275757968,
0.0770281628,
-0.3455068171,
-0.4703208506,
-0.0697074309,
0.110766761,
0.6872454286,
0.095721826,
0.2604591548,
-0.2440797836,
-0.5065690279,
-0.0380272716,
-0.2845837176,
0.6304790378,
-0.3866413236,
-0.5897806883,
0.1750554144,
-0.7727054954,
0.2205919921,
0.108899653,
-0.3320843279,
-0.0781284794,
-0.4758379757,
-0.2707202733,
-0.0623954684,
0.2427751273,
-0.5667175055,
0.6074314117,
-0.3066399992,
0.3796798587,
0.5494903922,
0.208848387,
0.7938332558,
0.2797576189,
0.5370587707,
-0.0028802024,
-0.0033810588,
-0.2865277529,
-0.7197232842,
-0.4228003323,
-0.2096609473,
0.2737916112,
0.7730116248,
-0.6817318797,
0.0626466721,
-0.3144181669,
-0.5861400962,
-0.213848561,
0.4123328626,
0.8156742454,
0.7679696083,
0.6972211003,
-0.1941419691,
0.0139395148,
-0.644664228,
-0.1713653654,
0.0786900744,
-0.2040949315,
0.3999942839,
0.520793438,
-0.2756780386,
0.7402393818,
-0.7626953721,
-0.3744150102,
-0.1627689451,
0.5498772264,
0.2289365232,
0.3452208638,
0.4034931064,
-0.5084158182,
-0.7499454021,
0.6188312769,
-0.9237907529,
0.1660530269,
0.0341087095,
-0.2880868912,
0.3299455047,
0.1379980892,
-0.7829355001,
0.5199352503,
0.5128359199,
-0.5591464043,
0.4830641747,
-0.4185166657,
-0.037061993,
-0.8429823518,
0.0947485492,
0.0124460738,
-0.1471680105,
-0.9304643273,
-0.1155906469,
0.0002274442,
-0.3477705717,
-0.6093324423,
0.6908726692,
-0.7503420115,
0.0177918877,
-0.2942599058,
0.1466203481,
0.3479346335,
0.814358294,
-0.0256537199,
0.9053408504,
0.5752083063,
-0.4592718482,
0.2296911329,
0.2307327092,
-0.1108101085,
0.3452475369,
-0.6461043954,
0.1996014267,
-0.2642441988,
-0.1109649017,
-1.0775029659,
-0.4660909176,
0.5119275451,
-0.5699719191,
0.7976442575,
-0.4555326998,
0.1040147766,
-0.1012547538,
-0.1723403335,
0.0175596792,
0.3715094328,
-0.1700315326,
0.4680711031,
0.2461771369,
-0.0185377654,
-0.8018119335,
-0.6081225872,
-0.0334755406,
0.0502129011,
-0.3181453645,
0.1403660923,
0.263620764,
0.3566748798,
0.3957366347,
-0.1464516968,
-0.3373095989,
-0.0447278507,
0.3737733364,
0.2959255278,
-0.1771843433,
0.4430271387,
-0.2282874137,
-0.306666106,
-0.2034110278,
-0.7139148712,
0.1800743341,
-0.0867723152,
0.0004480494,
-0.1369441599,
0.0980641991,
0.3652037978,
-0.101363346,
0.791582346,
0.4990142584,
0.0605411269,
-0.3320248425,
0.2804122865,
-0.2097836137,
-0.4814273417,
0.696580112,
0.0282655694,
-0.8887230754,
-0.0438282117,
0.0696111247,
-0.2232014239,
0.1031655222,
0.2967477441,
-0.3526651859,
0.6412560344,
0.7543511987,
-0.0230042059,
0.4818867445,
-0.510222733,
0.3114178777,
-0.5126008987,
-0.124690555,
-0.1963649839,
-0.3665316999,
-0.1928197145,
-0.6184656024,
0.3954846561,
0.2544873059,
-0.4983966649,
0.6622618437,
-1.0707292557,
0.7425119877,
0.5597040057,
0.2134369314,
0.0011623172,
0.5579994917,
-0.1507036835,
0.2063633353,
-0.5817654729,
-0.5078305006,
1.3008829355,
-0.2413745373,
0.5302287936,
-0.228524074,
0.573315382,
0.3051991463,
0.4693205953,
-0.6620978117,
0.6199719906,
-0.3454596698,
-0.7023337483,
-0.6528973579,
-0.6562814713,
-0.976160109,
0.1544823498,
0.1487784237,
-1.0782858133,
-0.2284235954,
0.4332745075,
0.0378616825,
0.3717884123,
-1.0945491791,
1.4793919325,
-0.3372350335,
-0.3806664348,
0.2378664911,
-0.6870726943,
0.2523985207,
0.3111408949,
-0.1661154479,
-0.4700382054,
0.1468791366,
0.2845416367,
-0.4651058316,
0.8224345446,
-0.4348638058,
-0.0295163635,
0.6345378757,
-0.0064701601,
0.4005623758,
-0.2636338472,
0.0083464831,
0.176689595,
-0.0979880989,
-0.5548206568,
-0.9132758975,
0.4709998667,
-0.6431401372,
-0.477031678,
-0.0801096633,
-0.3335065544,
-0.1777419746,
0.2917737961,
0.3761887848,
0.4501382113,
-0.3075412214,
-0.2169132084,
0.3898402452,
-0.0351042189,
0.2295106947,
0.2159339786,
-0.3490573764,
-0.4172614515,
1.4344642162,
0.3065722585,
0.5953450799,
0.6494503021,
-0.004054043,
-0.1514064074,
-0.2041578293,
-0.8125930429,
0.1286497563,
-0.8160848618,
-0.111967884,
-0.4799151719,
-0.1488187909,
-0.1515766829,
-0.3226079345,
-0.2059124559,
-0.5605991483,
-0.3509583771,
-0.3431071043,
0.4845223129,
0.7708178163,
0.2821146846,
0.3764134347,
-0.8324811459,
0.3787505627,
0.5527035594,
0.2860377431,
-0.1531387717,
-0.2155624777,
-0.5166085958,
0.413033694,
-0.3482375443,
-0.8996853232,
0.1421506554,
0.5061699152,
0.2702611685,
0.2022013515,
-0.329492867,
0.4379008412,
-0.6774366498,
0.6087607145,
0.1029376835,
-0.9080044627,
0.6971330047,
-0.4439655244,
0.4009762704,
0.4560208619,
0.4492589831,
-0.3978121877,
-0.302066505,
-0.4316029251,
-0.7887780666,
0.5376109481,
0.2481377274,
0.1694647223,
-0.0085727116,
0.397856921,
0.0351187438,
0.5099710226,
-0.6162397265,
-0.0203169808,
-0.3310089707,
-0.3761300147,
-0.19212237,
-0.1018876582,
-0.0307383966,
-0.4164994657,
0.5939031243,
-0.4225779176,
0.6610298157,
0.1415978819,
-0.2746821344,
0.1604168713,
0.3522244692,
0.6694877744,
0.3794135451,
-0.5524822474,
0.1269328445,
-0.0555664673,
-0.7573051453,
0.5961239934,
0.0957936794,
-0.1913364977,
0.1899119616,
0.3569093049,
1.0741283894,
0.3493588567,
-0.6388821006,
0.55456388,
0.1925446093,
-0.2082771659,
0.3489614129,
0.4028756022,
0.3559756577,
-0.2493794113,
-0.0570205003,
-0.1297385693,
0.1745060086,
-0.5054201484,
0.4076847434,
0.2961339951,
-0.810408771,
-0.3750961423,
0.766928494,
0.0446043089,
-0.0637818426,
0.6046826839,
-0.27361238,
-0.210483551,
1.0322241783,
0.393093884,
0.8210430741,
-0.2100981772,
0.6959090829,
0.136921227,
0.0311450195,
0.3901410103,
0.0673473552,
-0.1325763017,
-0.486977309,
-0.2489178479,
-0.4197709858,
-0.6688566208,
-0.3329361379,
-0.3482924104,
-0.0102532534,
-0.647641778,
-0.0633476898,
0.0898583159,
-0.0709238946,
-0.4694958031,
0.2536307871,
0.1798345,
0.3957886994,
-0.4194545746,
0.9288936257,
0.8107887506,
-0.3013517857,
-0.593678534,
-0.3778753877,
0.0959699303,
-0.7444500923,
0.4640037119,
0.6816176772,
-0.1519488394,
0.1189957336,
-0.6917731166,
-0.5761737227,
1.219820857,
0.6467626095,
-0.4213503897,
-0.212338075,
0.5612190366,
0.5310797095,
-0.2652571797,
0.3579331338,
0.4616862535,
0.5376935601,
0.1941977441,
-0.5209593773,
-0.2166958004,
-0.217715472,
-0.1816556454,
0.3151610792,
-0.3104096055,
0.8927013874,
-0.3392120898,
-0.4478362799,
-0.218370527,
0.3944043219,
0.0266999975,
0.2204641402,
-0.1742450148,
0.4989599586,
0.8594099283,
-0.0058135777,
1.3770414591,
-0.3393006027,
0.6318631768,
1.333070159,
-0.3358271122,
0.7103826404,
0.2404841483,
-0.0949961171,
0.5223112702,
0.2228653282,
-0.1903780699,
0.6345899105,
0.3403118849,
-0.3830072284,
0.0679927096,
-0.0929455534,
-0.2180444151,
0.3569796681,
0.4398371577,
-0.2113602012,
-0.5044307709,
0.0162024256,
0.1229548305,
-0.1023161709,
-0.3330934346,
0.6309063435,
-0.0144280121,
-0.305362761,
0.5678972006,
-0.2180223316,
0.3211523592,
-0.7121106386,
-0.3689680696,
-0.0065970928,
0.2630991042,
0.0473123156,
-0.9198676944,
0.16037184,
-0.1565537304,
-0.173940748,
-0.0030616038,
0.9367093444,
-0.80880934,
-0.6483359933,
0.4486947358,
0.2213055491,
0.2599335015,
-0.2771239877,
-0.6199684739,
-0.5690732598,
0.0529910401,
-0.4103075564,
0.2996847928,
0.5430920124,
0.2406027764,
0.6080299616,
0.2689085603,
-0.1158727482,
0.1500501037,
-0.4331998527,
0.7245110869,
-0.7285773158,
-0.1085521132,
-0.8167268038,
0.6750823855,
-0.0915667117,
-0.28579849,
0.6986692548,
0.3292101324,
0.8491001725,
-0.4044322371,
0.7904589176,
0.2656982541,
0.0373735242,
-0.7598837614,
0.8046765327,
-0.4325517416,
-0.1171524376,
-0.0192115977,
-0.9466943145,
-0.442953676,
0.3807397187,
-0.3600193858,
0.2816738784,
0.6742660403,
0.8961245418,
-0.2630129158,
-0.0760231987,
0.4690696895,
0.1157624871,
0.4009649158,
0.9298714399,
0.2424545288,
-0.4284022748,
0.5038704276,
-0.1321960539,
0.1456590444,
-0.2548324466,
-0.8587679863,
-1.1456131935,
-0.0709839836,
-0.3346328139,
0.0153309349,
0.4081085622,
0.6199423075,
0.7951403856,
-0.8980048895,
-0.1968372911,
-0.4313580096,
0.05516617,
0.0168449562,
-0.2309886217,
0.4342801273,
-0.3451042771,
-0.606338501,
0.4015296996,
0.8074755669,
0.5127804875,
0.00620662,
-0.0869615525,
-0.2839696407,
-0.1395256221,
0.4358988106,
0.4689084589,
-0.3649664521,
-0.3702369034,
0.0328411311,
-0.4775410295,
0.4088692367,
0.6101414561,
-0.6006078124,
0.6876972914,
0.2158900648,
0.7082550526,
0.68105793,
0.0672155619,
0.6719856858,
-1.2756890059,
0.2860386372,
-0.0123851374,
0.0783238336,
0.3379457891,
-0.6164537072,
0.7143058777,
0.1817394644,
-0.4937908351,
-0.3486092985,
-0.0629710034,
-0.8366248012,
-0.6245049834,
0.8535093069,
-0.370395124,
-0.6411729455,
0.0935303196,
-0.2904908657,
0.3895007968,
-0.3744752407,
0.5281029344,
0.7613515854,
-0.1096107215,
-0.196652174,
-0.6585710645,
0.370941937,
0.3650242686,
-0.8737276793,
0.1420918107,
0.4442611337,
0.1440208256,
0.1667617112,
0.5265493393,
0.2390946597,
0.3098120987,
0.1499220133,
0.38173908,
-0.605291903,
-0.8248589635,
-0.1976576447,
0.230542168,
-0.3243257701,
-0.2708912194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17782v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17782v1 | RASR2: The RWTH ASR Toolkit for Generic Sequence-to-sequence Speech Recognition | 2023-05-28T17:48:48 | 2023-05-28T17:48:48 | Wei Zhou, Eugen Beck, Simon Berger, Ralf Schlüter, Hermann Ney | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Modern public ASR tools usually provide rich support for training various
sequence-to-sequence (S2S) models, but rather simple support for decoding
open-vocabulary scenarios only. For closed-vocabulary scenarios, public tools
supporting lexical-constrained decoding are usually only for classical ASR, or
do not support all S2S models. To eliminate this restriction on research
possibilities such as modeling unit choice, we present RASR2 in this work, a
research-oriented generic S2S decoder implemented in C++. It offers a strong
flexibility/compatibility for various S2S models, language models, label
units/topologies and neural network architectures. It provides efficient
decoding for both open- and closed-vocabulary scenarios based on a generalized
search framework with rich support for different search modes and settings. We
evaluate RASR2 with a wide range of experiments on both switchboard and
Librispeech corpora. Our source code is public online. | [
0.0424736999,
-0.2805428803,
0.0514174514,
0.2215915322,
-0.3868026137,
0.1065936387,
-0.1583823711,
-0.3242168427,
0.1134884283,
0.2701159418,
0.0700780973,
-0.2449053973,
-0.5590692759,
0.0611647181,
-0.5478745699,
0.7929759026,
-0.115584448,
0.3563447297,
-0.0289391913,
-0.1506958306,
-0.2011971474,
-0.464785248,
-0.7681251168,
-0.3038158715,
0.6045603156,
0.5322028399,
0.3829703927,
0.3584685028,
0.3772059083,
0.1055134386,
-0.3531424105,
0.1208259761,
-0.3935163617,
0.2973529696,
-0.1912117153,
-0.1203464493,
-0.5170015097,
-0.5532051325,
0.6111900806,
0.1558638066,
-0.3758591115,
0.3142760992,
0.0827082843,
0.4702640176,
-0.6567077637,
0.0835597664,
-0.4497324526,
-0.0313227847,
-0.3834718764,
-0.1912651211,
-0.4712861478,
-0.2923553586,
0.2562127411,
-0.3422428668,
0.343963623,
-0.2491151989,
0.5535190105,
-0.0399253257,
-0.2608579695,
-0.5591118336,
-0.7586840391,
0.4417769611,
-0.5370926261,
0.7948970199,
0.4153431952,
0.5300815701,
-0.0481936149,
-0.9303705096,
-0.4579480588,
0.0013432351,
0.0359159,
0.1441584677,
-0.3324314356,
0.1205872893,
0.056481082,
0.2626247406,
-0.814963758,
0.020225944,
-0.6585369706,
-0.1537882984,
0.2719035745,
-0.1765671074,
0.078799203,
-0.0304141063,
-0.0420161299,
-0.2017853856,
-0.5682406425,
0.0831279904,
0.2657580376,
0.5154101253,
-0.3476508856,
0.6448855996,
0.139057368,
0.5623543859,
-0.2405902147,
0.0684409589,
0.1909692287,
0.1594703794,
-0.0203169789,
0.1254832298,
0.3871317506,
-0.0019487618,
0.0354088694,
-0.4064064622,
-0.4542101622,
0.3293020725,
0.017525617,
-0.7253116369,
-0.2715425193,
0.2585274577,
-0.4248003364,
-0.0033847487,
0.1285794824,
-0.6679306626,
0.0243954491,
-0.316326648,
0.2091753483,
-0.0913718715,
-0.6012321115,
0.1958551556,
-0.5033648014,
0.5118335485,
0.0300998725,
-0.65258044,
0.7131823897,
0.7042045593,
0.9054695368,
-0.4847379923,
0.1455070525,
-0.6315581799,
0.2095306516,
-0.1621857435,
0.5944833755,
-0.5705351233,
-0.8533343673,
0.1048682854,
-0.2198573947,
0.2422311753,
-0.5849481225,
0.5187342167,
-0.7891631722,
-0.0795507655,
-0.3140351176,
-0.2587943673,
0.0598693416,
-0.080436565,
-0.3831712604,
1.0913513899,
-0.0896545723,
-0.7243471742,
-0.1176366359,
-0.7847365737,
-0.5643111467,
0.0368019342,
-0.5232478976,
-0.5103491545,
0.2021772116,
-0.2566868663,
-0.0666046143,
-0.3589855433,
0.4206939936,
-0.0711699128,
-0.3544104695,
0.246586144,
-0.4456785023,
0.6077125669,
0.593396008,
-0.1815531105,
0.2475935519,
-0.7743574381,
0.0418950729,
0.0677980632,
-0.5998265743,
-0.1677849889,
0.0957239419,
0.762380898,
-0.0800180733,
0.1537972391,
-0.6519550085,
-0.0060159299,
-0.1715499759,
0.6260682344,
0.2628762424,
-0.3569814861,
0.1978068948,
-0.0336950496,
0.4189379811,
-0.1299151778,
-0.2611225843,
0.292745024,
-0.5838071108,
-0.6773388982,
-0.2358389348,
0.3887575865,
0.6300694346,
-0.7000579238,
0.3695420623,
-0.4184791148,
-0.1969075203,
-0.5951270461,
-0.5080537796,
0.7781764269,
0.3561012745,
0.5076678395,
-0.387583524,
-0.8927375078,
-0.6722724438,
-0.1107337251,
0.0754435584,
-0.4305800498,
0.2820799351,
0.2220750749,
-0.4807081223,
1.2418210506,
-0.2908022106,
-0.0615787432,
-0.3969933689,
0.0268041994,
-0.0021581294,
0.4476235807,
0.0787591711,
-0.716321826,
-0.1887710392,
-0.0265368167,
-0.2660792172,
0.0887808278,
0.4549894035,
0.2612226605,
0.2030706108,
0.5807561874,
-0.4016830623,
0.4542836249,
0.7421652079,
-0.1866880357,
0.526889801,
-0.3498384058,
-0.1498552412,
-1.0604301691,
0.6273137927,
-0.2812247872,
-0.1514965743,
-0.9521879554,
0.0046684169,
0.1464487463,
-0.4888778627,
-0.3287473619,
0.6461564898,
-0.440182656,
-0.7136304975,
-0.2520109713,
0.0561953075,
-0.2903442681,
0.0471925549,
0.5600207448,
0.9276180267,
0.4193609655,
-0.7072893381,
-0.0272787455,
0.5095867515,
-0.2442931086,
0.0621145964,
-0.919167757,
0.6790094972,
-0.2960866392,
0.4045231938,
-0.9444244504,
-0.3648759723,
0.1523262858,
-0.8181439042,
0.5228607655,
-0.1816476136,
-0.4412245154,
-0.377853781,
-0.0830787569,
0.8087493777,
0.5165511966,
-0.69136554,
0.6403163671,
0.4713696539,
-0.1122529209,
-0.4517596364,
-0.9915851355,
0.0956385657,
0.1639298201,
-0.2752270699,
0.3591187298,
-0.0044681435,
-0.0431345254,
-0.1751413792,
-0.411790967,
-0.1875380278,
-0.4680408537,
0.2719464004,
0.1321983635,
-0.3154473901,
-0.0945032611,
0.0305199791,
-0.3743556738,
-0.243676737,
-0.1721073985,
0.5927234888,
0.0668130741,
-0.31957075,
-0.2644633353,
0.3109906912,
0.3163742125,
-0.3382925987,
0.0260831993,
0.371868968,
-0.3017968237,
-0.2036554813,
-0.4257384837,
-0.1994423568,
-0.5321707129,
0.5478445888,
-0.5432133675,
-1.1038113832,
0.3049349785,
0.1631801873,
0.1003548801,
0.0129883233,
0.4671395421,
0.0829385594,
0.5228774548,
0.2524072528,
-0.1543849409,
0.2254437953,
-0.074804917,
0.2899934351,
-0.9344992042,
-0.3649059534,
-0.5863836408,
-0.354331255,
-0.4466276765,
-0.6632094979,
0.433650434,
-0.2064116001,
-0.3174454272,
0.4473155737,
-0.7603490353,
0.3678788841,
0.4368756413,
0.0570598356,
0.1316732913,
0.3660055697,
0.2457786798,
-0.0290058423,
-0.6860692501,
-0.2989432216,
0.8449002504,
0.5921314359,
0.7868576646,
0.3407375216,
0.5012462139,
0.2121448964,
0.065549098,
-0.8475063443,
0.5051137805,
-0.5161769986,
-0.6633114219,
-0.2359818369,
-0.4012274444,
-1.104105711,
-0.0412442796,
0.2825959623,
-0.4306426644,
0.3611717522,
0.3580195308,
-0.3044586182,
0.368108958,
-0.2998829186,
0.4469986856,
0.0300892461,
0.2530548275,
-0.1881129444,
-0.7971941233,
0.1249276996,
0.4374450743,
0.0491132177,
0.1244109347,
-0.097203888,
0.7649806142,
0.0113827474,
0.7217940092,
-0.3286091983,
0.112218,
0.2330477387,
0.2573282123,
0.3697290123,
-0.09987434,
-0.070869565,
0.1525583863,
0.0441123582,
-0.2336649448,
-0.1688198596,
0.4707249999,
-0.9013433456,
-0.041974768,
-0.4562489092,
-0.4178205132,
-0.3604775667,
-0.0798081979,
0.5662093163,
0.7877953053,
-0.2330143303,
0.1649494767,
0.9136966467,
-0.2568445206,
0.2189110518,
0.6087534428,
-0.1234291196,
-0.5991056561,
0.9884385467,
-0.1245794371,
0.2514291108,
0.6586217284,
0.1653909683,
-0.3835301697,
-0.6294294,
-0.3124207258,
0.1270146072,
-0.4496852756,
-0.3725465238,
-0.5303754807,
-0.456394732,
-0.5155171752,
-0.1298725754,
-0.5175093412,
-0.422863394,
-0.4966514409,
-0.0889919102,
0.5111698508,
0.6321510673,
-0.3452451527,
0.1187714934,
-0.5698257089,
0.7467332482,
0.4242603481,
0.5834613442,
-0.0473513007,
-0.7978468537,
0.13987948,
-0.1476314366,
0.031940978,
-0.6818913817,
0.1833725274,
0.2786995769,
0.142386049,
0.3843604624,
-0.0112548564,
0.5363134146,
-0.5607069731,
0.466005832,
0.3429501653,
-0.8353360295,
0.5498562455,
-0.2515501082,
0.281696409,
0.4722939432,
0.0779602155,
-0.7714831829,
-0.0175462812,
-0.2448054552,
-0.8616715074,
0.6742528677,
0.1035232022,
-0.0609427281,
-0.0561028235,
0.3017198145,
0.0889213532,
0.0596989281,
-0.4366508126,
-0.4732036889,
-0.3386334181,
-0.1896466315,
-0.1940324157,
-0.5528106093,
-0.0949257761,
-0.0465071462,
0.4735911489,
0.2609259486,
0.5894227028,
0.3360915482,
-0.0327637903,
-0.0666646808,
0.4563655853,
0.6590527296,
0.2196801305,
-0.3016512096,
0.2357590497,
0.1765375584,
-0.6167368293,
0.1734663099,
0.3354796767,
-0.2698921561,
0.4187366366,
-0.0465810783,
0.8023276925,
0.3811281025,
-0.6269870996,
0.3978284299,
0.1016557962,
-0.2213556468,
-0.3008802533,
-0.2080066949,
0.1902715713,
0.1351942718,
0.204395622,
0.0444358885,
0.5795875192,
-0.439285785,
0.3397251368,
0.1330368072,
-0.4216097593,
-0.4712168276,
0.644641459,
0.282621026,
-0.7197377682,
0.5104375482,
-0.4981725812,
-0.2490079552,
0.3897617459,
0.7065448761,
0.9936856031,
-0.4210301638,
0.0035237574,
0.5228970051,
-0.1147974357,
-0.4512812197,
0.6756016016,
-0.0081084045,
-0.5747261643,
-0.2542511821,
-0.555229187,
-0.5252123475,
0.3334813416,
-1.0301647186,
0.3719844222,
-0.459730655,
-0.1572833508,
-0.3239605725,
-0.6053204536,
-0.3878810108,
0.0316024795,
0.1582005024,
1.2273465395,
-0.2517632544,
1.335791707,
0.5621185899,
0.0415265821,
-0.6930764318,
-0.0608680733,
0.1113989726,
-0.7581517696,
0.5970355868,
0.0412056893,
-0.5893553495,
0.0479401201,
-0.2680461109,
-0.8407366276,
1.0945341587,
0.1537917703,
-0.9024082422,
-0.3078313172,
0.1211034507,
0.4068352282,
-0.0304244403,
-0.0946474224,
0.6997571588,
0.2265702635,
0.329359889,
-1.1962051392,
-0.2116014063,
-0.1679227352,
0.3231434226,
0.1205078214,
-0.2665850222,
0.3839437366,
-0.2125634253,
-0.2972303331,
0.4319059849,
0.6445878744,
0.6235517263,
0.4864266515,
0.1678390056,
0.4682357013,
0.3555582166,
-0.0412263907,
0.6095381975,
-0.0779689774,
0.2084498554,
1.2671686411,
-0.0797816589,
1.3758306503,
0.2973064482,
-0.3350852132,
0.1859610379,
0.2195796669,
0.1739556789,
0.8509758711,
0.3661808968,
-0.4245115817,
0.2167725265,
0.1567208618,
-0.61529392,
0.3769613802,
0.5578809977,
0.1022961587,
-0.2596518993,
-0.0593726486,
-0.1947351396,
-0.0182599109,
-0.2704413831,
0.6702043414,
0.2435400039,
-0.2554033399,
0.3297465742,
0.1075821444,
0.9765293002,
-0.8335832357,
0.1408982575,
0.0531367399,
0.108365342,
-0.2457888126,
-0.7028794885,
0.4728940725,
0.2355938703,
-0.0997304469,
-0.1156036779,
0.787042141,
-0.6252819896,
-0.173707515,
0.3425019681,
0.1928421259,
0.2563344836,
0.2454571128,
-0.4950222075,
0.3998904824,
-0.0769316405,
0.0570051931,
0.2980810106,
0.1438026279,
0.3537346423,
0.4161874056,
0.4550790191,
0.0687723234,
-0.1629225463,
0.3182828128,
0.740375638,
-0.5380804539,
-0.571429193,
-0.1676996797,
0.48270455,
0.198214978,
-0.306756407,
0.2473226041,
0.9723795652,
0.7234970927,
-0.2024789453,
0.8364130259,
-0.1912610531,
0.9713594317,
-0.2837292552,
0.5042007565,
-0.213910237,
0.0828031152,
0.187199533,
-0.5293073058,
-0.3213257492,
0.6646158099,
-0.1976420432,
-0.1660856009,
0.1097763926,
0.9354735613,
-0.297360301,
0.0129826292,
0.2160069346,
0.0048147123,
0.308383584,
0.2122378498,
0.5673336387,
-0.3321504891,
0.6710203886,
0.3520460427,
-0.210996747,
-0.3701339662,
-0.5196656585,
-0.6913946271,
-0.6805725098,
-0.1993444115,
-0.6167996526,
0.5387055874,
1.0225313902,
0.5452142358,
-1.173257947,
-0.7057003379,
-0.1786769032,
-0.3097994626,
0.1295379251,
-0.1897190958,
0.3322756886,
-0.2063912302,
-0.3180889189,
0.6711582541,
0.2668815255,
0.0675569326,
0.0898556262,
-0.4333198071,
0.2253094912,
-0.0684231147,
0.5514588356,
0.9065633416,
-0.7446839809,
-0.1931704283,
-0.0073654167,
-0.0780014396,
0.2135696709,
1.1973834038,
-0.476844877,
0.5099052787,
0.5793619752,
0.6606580019,
0.747277081,
-0.2597824335,
0.5368127227,
-0.7464736104,
0.1820611209,
0.6084157825,
0.1004082039,
0.3534290493,
0.2425069809,
0.3800619841,
0.0333129428,
-0.4905876815,
-0.8798511028,
0.4516614676,
-1.2741500139,
-0.1771435589,
1.4884729385,
0.0915347338,
0.4094987512,
-0.2770606875,
-0.3208109438,
0.4297654033,
-0.7056792378,
0.4879006147,
0.1075569838,
-0.1293558478,
-0.0565863177,
-0.6079187989,
0.7193142772,
-0.0329033136,
-0.4802293181,
0.0550704896,
0.2918717861,
0.4986027181,
-0.0105549349,
0.7990932465,
-0.2221483588,
0.4842651486,
0.0258420445,
0.1717254817,
-0.0636085048,
-0.3516861498,
-0.5840802789,
-0.0279420596,
0.3238320053,
-0.3817598522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17779v1 | Generating EDU Extracts for Plan-Guided Summary Re-Ranking | 2023-05-28T17:22:04 | 2023-05-28T17:22:04 | Griffin Adams, Alexander R. Fabbri, Faisal Ladhak, Kathleen McKeown, Noémie Elhadad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Two-step approaches, in which summary candidates are generated-then-reranked
to return a single summary, can improve ROUGE scores over the standard
single-step approach. Yet, standard decoding methods (i.e., beam search,
nucleus sampling, and diverse beam search) produce candidates with redundant,
and often low quality, content. In this paper, we design a novel method to
generate candidates for re-ranking that addresses these issues. We ground each
candidate abstract on its own unique content plan and generate distinct
plan-guided abstracts using a model's top beam. More concretely, a standard
language model (a BART LM) auto-regressively generates elemental discourse unit
(EDU) content plans with an extractive copy mechanism. The top K beams from the
content plan generator are then used to guide a separate LM, which produces a
single abstractive candidate for each distinct plan. We apply an existing
re-ranker (BRIO) to abstractive candidates generated from our method, as well
as baseline decoding methods. We show large relevance improvements over
previously published methods on widely used single document news article
corpora, with ROUGE-2 F1 gains of 0.88, 2.01, and 0.38 on CNN / Dailymail, NYT,
and Xsum, respectively. A human evaluation on CNN / DM validates these results.
Similarly, on 1k samples from CNN / DM, we show that prompting GPT-3 to follow
EDU plans outperforms sampling-based methods by 1.05 ROUGE-2 F1 points. Code to
generate and realize plans is available at
https://github.com/griff4692/edu-sum. | [
-0.13072896,
-0.6334849,
0.4710335732,
0.040557716,
-0.4110859036,
0.4989792407,
-0.0210923292,
-0.0056320545,
0.8519483805,
0.5990976691,
-0.1790016294,
-0.8252677917,
-0.5085518956,
0.1333602965,
-0.5777168274,
1.2352210283,
0.1350277364,
-0.1932105869,
-0.0189769119,
0.196513921,
-0.3261967301,
-0.0596001111,
-0.7784252167,
-0.2043371499,
0.6128255129,
0.6913622022,
0.4646151066,
0.7011977434,
0.3170071244,
0.1526025683,
-0.0377804711,
0.2496535033,
-0.665894866,
0.2357671708,
-0.0790940821,
-0.0615736917,
-0.9499229789,
0.2252571285,
0.7490152121,
0.6674675345,
-0.3854832053,
0.1498650014,
0.1524416357,
0.6573190093,
-0.7333697677,
0.0942135677,
-0.694943428,
-0.2925319076,
-0.0518088527,
-0.724799335,
-1.0152571201,
-0.5521219373,
-0.1222339496,
-0.4799473584,
0.4092153013,
-0.1875398159,
0.8618257642,
0.1344023794,
-0.6443017721,
-0.0184813347,
-0.538854301,
0.5249187946,
-0.5693794489,
0.0698884875,
0.2728829384,
0.155709967,
-0.0073979436,
-1.0003243685,
-0.0551252775,
0.1666692495,
-0.351446718,
0.5184285045,
-0.09395051,
0.1968019903,
-0.0415737666,
0.3198078275,
-0.7188575864,
-0.0279408805,
-0.7167068124,
-0.1124525964,
0.9937027693,
0.1601764709,
0.0770935863,
-0.3593453467,
-0.145009622,
-0.400160253,
-0.9746770263,
-0.0033427868,
0.5045626163,
0.2874453962,
0.2661590278,
0.3343266547,
-0.454870075,
0.5800779462,
0.0447451472,
0.0818608776,
0.1219578236,
-0.4116483033,
-0.0962600261,
0.1322082281,
0.6569636464,
0.4440211654,
-0.0484307408,
-0.0799380094,
-0.2776306272,
-0.3619969785,
0.5448564887,
-0.869396925,
-0.6622784734,
0.1656260639,
-0.4988980293,
-0.3821482062,
0.129952684,
-0.9998604059,
0.1501982808,
-0.3253703415,
0.202808857,
-0.267531842,
-0.4001334906,
-0.0606362894,
-0.298370868,
0.2955244184,
0.4158772528,
-0.845277071,
0.2606611848,
0.5500739813,
0.7507735491,
-0.4799997211,
-0.1840988696,
-0.7086301446,
0.0498928167,
-0.7036961913,
1.0473222733,
-0.5550793409,
-0.4526942372,
0.253731221,
-0.2273198068,
-0.0038309074,
-0.4416548908,
0.7564205527,
-0.5395573378,
0.2674241066,
-0.142146796,
-0.4410892427,
0.1214603558,
0.0958325714,
-0.7422315478,
0.9349607229,
0.059172079,
-0.5676583648,
0.264673084,
-0.5022421479,
-0.6338390112,
0.0189969186,
-0.3231753409,
-0.2907032371,
0.1042396873,
0.5373305678,
0.3280751705,
0.1437067688,
0.3835272491,
0.464892447,
-0.4210966229,
-0.4024305642,
-0.4730555713,
0.7046273947,
0.1333425194,
-0.0804282129,
0.3706128895,
-0.7502548695,
0.2607161403,
0.1832231581,
-0.6670539975,
-0.2588430047,
0.0049282862,
-0.0112853469,
-0.0512613021,
0.0201395433,
-0.4243612587,
0.440666914,
-0.3536982834,
0.0988326073,
0.8366297483,
0.1829119027,
0.5898808241,
-0.1389902681,
0.5346642733,
-0.4359973073,
-0.2485460788,
-0.5795007348,
-0.3818309307,
-0.6446694136,
-0.333116889,
0.4638500214,
0.4136564434,
-0.7574606538,
0.1949597597,
-0.5868106484,
-0.5363877416,
-0.7067934275,
-0.365467757,
0.3334994018,
0.2703255117,
0.6346308589,
-0.0408844501,
-0.3940816224,
-1.0517230034,
-0.3651534915,
-0.1212428957,
-0.1820583642,
0.0492524169,
0.2111040503,
0.1753553599,
0.9471033812,
-0.8727825284,
-0.0916931033,
-0.6286953688,
0.4727057815,
0.2191413492,
0.2592565417,
0.1981283277,
-0.7310000658,
-0.4427189231,
-0.2638892531,
-0.6418414712,
-0.2401128262,
-0.3148822188,
-0.188840732,
0.1353186518,
0.515532434,
-0.3793053031,
0.5091074109,
0.1876613051,
-0.3871934712,
0.5532458425,
-0.158631742,
0.3533884585,
-1.316883564,
0.0746470764,
-0.2522580922,
-0.3589065075,
-0.5430383682,
0.3452936113,
-0.0726863965,
-0.21151416,
-0.1843132675,
0.4957841039,
-0.54152143,
-0.0255489871,
-0.6000309587,
0.3907755315,
0.1028276458,
0.5464307666,
0.2206969112,
0.5532243848,
0.2475320846,
-0.5561941862,
-0.1465069056,
0.2855742574,
-0.133885622,
0.1813263595,
-0.7328443527,
0.1798597425,
-0.2019579709,
0.6289027333,
-1.0170753002,
-0.0970954299,
0.047863517,
-0.3496965468,
0.7158376575,
-0.1674180776,
-0.1512183249,
-0.0707700476,
-0.4307759702,
0.5403416753,
0.4369761944,
-0.4361261129,
0.6334230304,
0.3768473566,
-0.6372072101,
-0.7353503704,
-0.4013559818,
0.3334695399,
0.054396905,
-0.3396881223,
0.7751479745,
0.1022720858,
-0.015436097,
0.1487029642,
-0.2098929584,
0.1831427962,
-0.1261349469,
0.0729934946,
0.4632490873,
0.0003915455,
-0.2287834883,
0.5446098447,
-0.3707970083,
0.1494544148,
-0.0827569515,
0.4875680804,
0.2258110046,
-0.2649451792,
-0.311455071,
0.7369008064,
0.4059204459,
-0.3700066507,
0.2668847442,
0.412211895,
-0.2163337767,
-0.3302192092,
-0.2744806409,
-0.6186338067,
-0.4179815054,
0.4297601283,
-0.2393455356,
-0.4442492723,
0.2555801272,
-0.0964838639,
0.8880411983,
0.4329199493,
0.4028218687,
0.2197763175,
0.8531976342,
0.5329096913,
-0.0288028959,
0.3815129697,
-0.6038770676,
0.2122324556,
-0.6845287681,
-0.2331063896,
-0.3577284813,
-0.6036149859,
-0.5870804787,
-0.2016810924,
0.2378777266,
-0.0648827031,
0.2653069496,
0.4094153345,
-0.7606050372,
0.5429716706,
0.5821230412,
-0.0344706737,
0.6013177633,
0.2164956629,
0.0000363048,
0.0615284815,
-0.6697050929,
-0.6971643567,
1.3523118496,
0.1256691962,
0.7642492652,
0.1346757561,
1.1653363705,
0.4792145193,
0.4831328392,
-0.5561044812,
0.807107389,
-0.0357827879,
-0.3772812784,
-0.3301311135,
-0.4671872556,
-1.0681259632,
0.6199815869,
-0.1471131593,
-0.5524603724,
0.191678077,
-0.0846085027,
-0.2974569499,
0.1541266143,
-0.3095062077,
0.4871218801,
0.1337069273,
-0.2371012568,
-0.447229594,
-0.5496062636,
0.2739653587,
0.1391327381,
-0.0162657276,
0.132498458,
0.1171110496,
0.9589011669,
0.0463113524,
0.4343935847,
-0.0439383537,
-0.0478406399,
0.2406067997,
0.0177900586,
0.5720162988,
0.306353122,
-0.1451483518,
0.1143881157,
-0.2403959334,
-0.4317762852,
-0.4724855721,
0.5658088923,
-0.5243772268,
-0.9414750338,
-0.3389950395,
-0.5322239399,
0.2678894401,
0.372844547,
0.6533210874,
0.6713828444,
-0.3475278914,
0.1883821934,
0.4750521183,
-0.0333224423,
0.5809149146,
0.4979899228,
-0.2501274347,
-0.5574753284,
1.0421760082,
0.0242176335,
0.3240303993,
0.4838266969,
-0.1089452505,
-0.0957295448,
-0.811994195,
-0.4397036135,
0.1950539351,
-0.6693618894,
-0.2884116173,
-0.6782227159,
-0.5132793784,
-0.5528470278,
-0.292984277,
-0.5996665955,
-0.4630721509,
0.0127060637,
-0.4852510989,
-0.3515446484,
0.7674536109,
-0.1344091743,
0.0109049184,
-0.5024923682,
0.2856636643,
0.1316583753,
-0.1323120445,
-0.2090612948,
-0.61443156,
-0.249662444,
-0.0242384765,
-0.6501575708,
-1.1057846546,
0.5442477465,
0.1477466822,
0.8407772779,
0.4865547121,
0.3678692281,
0.4312206209,
-0.5957814455,
0.6804412007,
-0.1934681833,
-0.3707127273,
0.812856853,
-0.3000105619,
0.1026587859,
0.7352023721,
0.3868175447,
-0.0234576575,
-0.8580724001,
-0.6856330633,
-1.1392157078,
0.7748590112,
0.4863395393,
0.1282829493,
-0.2611292899,
0.2098672986,
0.0122621842,
-0.0255533587,
-0.6873954535,
-0.5586838722,
-0.1895581037,
-0.0499762334,
0.2183010578,
-0.4346443415,
-0.2209055722,
-0.0917068049,
0.7141685486,
-0.1196404099,
0.2390676141,
0.3439931273,
0.2082679868,
-0.0421598814,
0.431412667,
0.4958493114,
0.7764677405,
-0.3733645678,
0.0948021859,
-0.1467827708,
-0.5547831059,
0.0239249114,
0.2580026388,
-0.4988570213,
0.4989701211,
0.4618737996,
0.3290132284,
0.2929648459,
-0.4930338264,
0.3923041224,
-0.2260463089,
-0.3889596164,
-0.2149002403,
-0.0871354938,
-0.1536743045,
0.0188796334,
0.7867676616,
-0.109363012,
0.4232105911,
-0.5709878206,
0.5007746816,
0.2743427455,
0.025900038,
-0.2953308523,
0.5563027859,
0.3576233983,
-0.4051572978,
0.7415838242,
-0.4494380355,
-0.3045703769,
0.4567550421,
0.6943778992,
0.8229194283,
-0.4159617126,
0.5358544588,
0.7907022238,
0.3207804263,
-0.1862511933,
0.1672722101,
0.1789372116,
-0.3757381737,
-0.327490747,
-0.4169423282,
-0.1298663169,
0.0792608038,
-0.9679163694,
0.4828805923,
-0.1560017318,
0.0951792225,
-0.1618633419,
-0.0744940937,
-0.2299579084,
-0.0743649229,
-0.0859745815,
0.906667769,
-0.7134623528,
0.6139894128,
0.6461122036,
-0.2509113252,
-0.9918530583,
0.2853670716,
-0.0602202788,
-0.320836544,
0.2572733462,
0.0890151039,
-0.106045559,
0.1822090149,
-0.1357295513,
-0.8608334064,
1.3948025703,
0.3217187822,
-0.3790144324,
-0.3871294558,
-0.2947279215,
0.260987252,
-0.5202854276,
0.391792208,
0.4673475325,
0.165854007,
0.3512852192,
-0.6234487295,
0.1230852827,
-0.2780208886,
-0.5629315972,
0.3598508239,
-0.3103952408,
0.9353923798,
-0.4386660755,
-0.7477686405,
-0.0593716353,
0.7175974846,
0.3682869673,
0.5689377785,
0.0882487893,
0.5757554173,
0.7129601836,
0.0907305852,
0.9303675294,
-0.3359824717,
0.306604147,
1.3421981335,
0.1572621465,
1.0367619991,
0.0929383636,
0.1552495509,
0.7600704432,
0.6139166355,
0.1798159927,
0.8225764036,
-0.0942180008,
0.0459717959,
-0.2869494557,
0.0634754598,
-0.4760888219,
0.5661736131,
0.2303235978,
-0.5507007241,
-0.5519817472,
-0.353497237,
0.0773024037,
0.2216921598,
-0.2134686261,
0.8045375943,
0.0957319513,
-1.017290473,
0.4868385792,
0.0827417597,
0.2804198861,
-0.459867835,
-0.4068834484,
-0.639025569,
-0.2044878453,
-0.209635213,
-0.7664519548,
0.260491848,
-0.0957764611,
0.0448124334,
-0.5191485286,
0.6417321563,
-0.6339509487,
-0.5334065557,
0.0771439373,
0.7232047319,
0.2246283442,
0.0962503329,
-0.2713675201,
-0.3056423068,
0.142894581,
-0.4163845479,
0.3154521585,
0.0943672284,
0.0973296016,
0.5129516125,
0.5699281693,
0.0975407287,
-0.272549659,
0.0972960964,
0.9810630679,
-0.5012993217,
-0.5622618794,
-0.8481165171,
0.5050744414,
-0.370811373,
-0.2637274861,
0.5616745353,
0.9010745287,
0.730504632,
0.1440700889,
0.4624888897,
-0.0070858453,
0.2703580856,
-0.5752210617,
0.6977646351,
-0.6375744939,
0.4976924062,
-0.2587478161,
-1.0166779757,
0.0749121457,
0.4938565493,
-0.0591808185,
-0.1605240107,
0.8298020363,
0.6176766157,
0.077415891,
-0.1015591025,
0.1889226735,
-0.0982669666,
0.5978651047,
0.5526739359,
0.4411051273,
-0.4888725579,
0.8450108767,
0.1291142702,
-0.313212961,
-0.2496341616,
-0.5156684518,
-0.7620835304,
-0.6225209236,
-0.47364977,
-0.2580911517,
0.0095989611,
0.681917429,
0.6800454855,
-0.4430038929,
0.0357177593,
0.1560317874,
0.3517337739,
-0.3935408592,
-0.280408591,
0.6954252124,
-0.288959682,
-0.9188930988,
0.6343460083,
0.2826758623,
-0.4620918036,
-0.1524269283,
-0.0145556405,
-0.2493098527,
0.1049789861,
0.5284113288,
0.1628241688,
-0.6483217478,
-0.1156656966,
0.1452752352,
-0.2190936804,
-0.0113521041,
1.0478470325,
-0.8814093471,
0.1162981316,
0.5242994428,
0.5830894709,
0.3426508904,
0.416469723,
0.5528685451,
-0.9412197471,
-0.3406450152,
0.4587450624,
0.324585706,
0.1035234034,
-0.3189662993,
0.6834570765,
0.0035114079,
-0.6589123011,
-0.7496308088,
0.3327192068,
-1.0914202929,
-0.437641412,
1.315033555,
-0.0995357931,
0.1380498111,
-0.1017763317,
-0.2045319378,
0.1887841523,
-0.6796337366,
0.9529797435,
0.1781938672,
-0.1337432265,
-0.151718393,
-0.4167797267,
0.4163939953,
0.0981560051,
-0.8346417546,
0.2146381736,
0.5299434662,
0.2000152916,
0.3820407093,
0.9681808352,
-0.1035384312,
0.2668597996,
0.1590193957,
-0.1772674173,
-0.2800836265,
-0.7335550189,
0.0735669285,
0.4243975878,
-0.1917097121,
-0.2646198869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18410v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18410v1 | Understanding Breast Cancer Survival: Using Causality and Language Models on Multi-omics Data | 2023-05-28T17:07:46 | 2023-05-28T17:07:46 | Mugariya Farooq, Shahad Hardan, Aigerim Zhumbhayeva, Yujia Zheng, Preslav Nakov, Kun Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.GN, stat.ME | The need for more usable and explainable machine learning models in
healthcare increases the importance of developing and utilizing causal
discovery algorithms, which aim to discover causal relations by analyzing
observational data. Explainable approaches aid clinicians and biologists in
predicting the prognosis of diseases and suggesting proper treatments. However,
very little research has been conducted at the crossroads between causal
discovery, genomics, and breast cancer, and we aim to bridge this gap.
Moreover, evaluation of causal discovery methods on real data is in general
notoriously difficult because ground-truth causal relations are usually
unknown, and accordingly, in this paper, we also propose to address the
evaluation problem with large language models. In particular, we exploit
suitable causal discovery algorithms to investigate how various perturbations
in the genome can affect the survival of patients diagnosed with breast cancer.
We used three main causal discovery algorithms: PC, Greedy Equivalence Search
(GES), and a Generalized Precision Matrix-based one. We experiment with a
subset of The Cancer Genome Atlas, which contains information about mutations,
copy number variations, protein levels, and gene expressions for 705 breast
cancer patients. Our findings reveal important factors related to the vital
status of patients using causal discovery algorithms. However, the reliability
of these results remains a concern in the medical domain. Accordingly, as
another contribution of the work, the results are validated through language
models trained on biomedical literature, such as BlueBERT and other large
language models trained on medical corpora. Our results profess proper
utilization of causal discovery algorithms and language models for revealing
reliable causal relations for clinical applications. | [
0.0684839562,
-0.8405498266,
1.0170878172,
0.2391029447,
-0.0257687662,
-0.2853824496,
0.0255374312,
-0.0602609478,
-0.1533028036,
0.5697746873,
-0.525752008,
-0.5679811835,
-0.8872252107,
0.1711103171,
-0.1739402711,
0.7110335231,
0.2103381455,
0.3931694031,
-0.1114202663,
-0.3319429755,
-0.4836453795,
-0.2815936506,
-0.9028083086,
-0.2704566419,
1.0109783411,
0.1724013537,
0.6307472587,
0.8871561289,
0.4514749646,
0.2151218057,
0.0214804094,
0.0556326061,
-0.5467208028,
0.0676899031,
-0.0954208598,
-0.3987248242,
0.0635675862,
-0.2414145768,
0.5734288096,
1.1516734362,
-0.0242088549,
-0.096757479,
-0.029339416,
0.7128708959,
-0.6045798063,
0.1863832623,
-0.1842395216,
0.0852005705,
-0.0458371155,
-0.4096120894,
-0.4427948594,
-0.8488095999,
0.1441892684,
-0.4434350729,
0.0382387862,
-0.1402068585,
0.5155192018,
0.2068513185,
-0.8964550495,
-0.317032069,
-0.7177710533,
0.7289159894,
-0.8238838911,
0.2946382165,
0.3074718714,
0.3185239732,
-0.5438383222,
-0.4866011441,
-0.3541072309,
-0.4301013947,
0.0125007825,
0.1577854753,
-0.2272241265,
0.2431394607,
0.3168926537,
0.1222653687,
-0.5582826734,
0.3139491081,
-0.191932708,
-0.2742584944,
0.2734802663,
0.259968996,
0.7449476719,
-0.1176028624,
0.0086334962,
0.0657476336,
-1.149984479,
0.0582606755,
0.4079525173,
0.3125139475,
-0.0134874554,
0.6608391404,
-0.0071524731,
0.9661434889,
-0.517649591,
-0.1741964519,
-0.0023338604,
-0.450707227,
-0.1527920216,
0.1253451407,
0.6767904162,
0.0698465556,
-0.0917811766,
-0.3467147648,
0.7801942229,
0.1717548817,
0.1514589489,
-0.8278100491,
-0.0669443309,
0.2344742715,
-0.6039074659,
-0.0267425645,
-0.0295823328,
-0.6001098752,
-0.4645755291,
-0.1565108448,
0.5871480107,
-0.2352551669,
-0.0325717516,
0.5701503754,
-0.0809428692,
-0.2640983164,
0.0884888396,
-0.4274476767,
-0.0331266522,
0.4206147194,
0.544554472,
0.4665924013,
-0.3400614858,
-0.745057404,
0.286901772,
-0.3224934638,
0.4761209488,
-0.4100957215,
-0.2816801667,
0.0566203296,
0.2041929811,
-0.4485685527,
-0.1095615923,
0.9036002159,
-0.3566815853,
0.1326760948,
-0.9283389449,
-0.5776776671,
-0.4181762934,
-0.2641021311,
-0.6809392571,
0.1240564883,
-0.2242194414,
-0.9459199309,
0.4742167294,
-0.5924478173,
-0.5696165562,
-0.2804093063,
-0.0087487977,
-0.590035677,
0.1644283086,
-0.0847922042,
0.6785147786,
-0.5470656157,
0.472374171,
-0.79682374,
-0.2962319553,
0.1751909405,
-0.3129035532,
0.9683445692,
0.1257288456,
-0.2880733609,
0.0187664535,
-0.8241006732,
-0.5774994493,
0.1960113049,
-0.3379798532,
-0.4447624683,
0.5608557463,
-0.4100628793,
0.2610867321,
-0.2409615964,
-0.6967999935,
-0.0050725527,
-0.4026787579,
0.3919100463,
0.5222253799,
0.2632285655,
-0.1099512801,
-0.2605670989,
0.1638944447,
0.01638267,
0.3820596635,
-0.2640918195,
-0.6324313879,
-0.4271402657,
-0.2025108933,
0.2333393544,
0.3168476224,
-0.285600096,
0.1539069861,
-0.2707468271,
-0.4543637335,
-0.565464139,
-0.2164855599,
0.5436205864,
0.963509202,
0.4680116773,
-0.1821547449,
-0.5547130108,
-0.9470534325,
-0.1724798083,
-0.1455374658,
0.1443561167,
0.4610608518,
0.1120404676,
-0.6389013529,
0.744038403,
-0.5468586087,
0.2374006361,
0.1602448374,
0.2281693071,
0.1663375497,
0.2111457288,
0.4176435471,
-0.710753262,
0.189961195,
0.0863063037,
-0.9816865325,
-0.3849402964,
0.2285708934,
-0.0991907194,
-0.2418810725,
0.2889912426,
-0.1832325011,
0.4476832747,
0.5013818741,
-0.5213499665,
0.5236415267,
-0.3585283458,
0.4706493318,
-0.7229417562,
0.2729824781,
0.2019432187,
-0.0328326821,
-0.5956446528,
-0.3181384504,
-0.1325741559,
-0.0062419591,
-0.0036527417,
0.3984460235,
-0.3320947289,
-0.0282311942,
-0.1431011856,
-0.2900910676,
-0.0781288818,
0.0991261974,
-0.0653781295,
0.2478938848,
0.4419720471,
-0.6730961204,
-0.1765717566,
0.1913146526,
-0.1554375738,
0.2653053701,
-0.7025375366,
-0.3610723913,
-0.3499643207,
0.1568444073,
-1.0628244877,
-0.0485335104,
0.1707647592,
-0.3932133019,
0.0652085245,
-0.3925012052,
-0.6322800517,
-0.5155984163,
-0.0917431712,
0.209256798,
0.1976853311,
-0.3859456778,
0.3090859354,
0.4946790636,
-0.2708163857,
-0.6746488214,
-0.4738776684,
-0.0630542263,
-0.3090007901,
-0.7329164743,
-0.2423827797,
-0.1996097267,
-0.1308222264,
0.0052593187,
0.1231838614,
0.0105600497,
0.4163440764,
0.4616285861,
0.1222662628,
-0.1668297797,
0.3186629713,
0.4133501053,
-0.2003180683,
0.1717201322,
-0.1745839417,
0.1485829502,
0.2430014163,
-0.4949412942,
-0.1348709166,
0.4071057737,
0.6050316095,
0.0245091207,
0.9686816335,
0.4453494847,
-0.4849075675,
0.4101545215,
-0.5421074033,
-0.0639489144,
-0.2028138638,
0.284670949,
-0.1658533663,
-1.0643745661,
0.6075095534,
-0.2460525036,
-0.0547743775,
0.690913558,
0.7603855133,
0.2403751016,
1.1321216822,
0.7682501674,
-0.154418394,
-0.0182579085,
0.1871888936,
0.4041335881,
-0.5200903416,
-0.2447970957,
-0.8851454258,
0.3276791871,
-0.3990612626,
-0.180096209,
0.8111106753,
0.1222494468,
-0.5652447939,
0.2055785209,
-0.1941073239,
0.0419158861,
0.294472456,
0.3971416354,
0.3800255656,
-0.2248340398,
-0.2987900972,
0.1769569516,
-0.9098402262,
-0.4152522385,
1.2929484844,
0.2725570798,
0.4171894789,
0.1837437898,
0.3760275543,
0.0163587406,
0.1500186175,
-0.1804491878,
0.0471776985,
-0.1535462141,
-0.5722581744,
-0.2376052439,
-0.8655742407,
-1.2740484476,
0.0436420366,
-0.3487150967,
-0.6577526331,
0.4015814364,
-0.0132914102,
-0.4372700453,
-0.0092764711,
-0.7527048588,
1.1724873781,
-0.2431579083,
-0.4554685652,
-0.2460589558,
-1.001247406,
0.5359779,
-0.0808491558,
0.5978770256,
0.0415199921,
0.3028806746,
0.8268453479,
-0.3533439636,
0.657183826,
-0.004890441,
0.058803767,
-0.0598386303,
0.1230161563,
0.0247223824,
0.0854193196,
-0.2141597569,
0.2730260193,
0.1665210426,
-0.5144102573,
-0.3396187723,
1.0071952343,
-0.6197425723,
-0.1099101976,
-0.0406450368,
-0.2933282256,
-0.2111721933,
0.3083681762,
0.2152964473,
0.5590603948,
-0.2592809498,
-0.1227071658,
0.5723893642,
-0.6565591693,
0.329362154,
0.622703135,
0.0889595449,
-0.0790607184,
0.8453236222,
0.1842994541,
-0.068861194,
0.4266860783,
0.6037531495,
-0.2445005924,
-0.4973511398,
-0.2672777474,
0.3688924015,
-0.61433357,
-0.0868272707,
-0.9810330868,
0.2759315968,
-0.2830804288,
0.0039166356,
-0.0596466176,
-0.1800484359,
-0.3430403769,
-0.1711788476,
0.1938293427,
0.7006250024,
-0.3707954288,
-0.0235479586,
-0.9774544835,
0.233920157,
0.2889218628,
0.1024068072,
0.0913863108,
-0.2162069827,
-0.4150363803,
0.0426118337,
0.0234425124,
-1.2684437037,
0.2358088344,
0.0087376609,
0.7507348061,
0.4906263947,
-0.2769989073,
0.4412656128,
-0.5147875547,
0.3969599903,
0.1918048412,
-0.7588761449,
0.5312785506,
-0.6663287282,
-0.1293373555,
0.2560956478,
0.7528712153,
-0.4306243956,
0.0111786425,
-0.7855330706,
-0.7027736306,
0.3811463416,
0.3192989826,
-0.4491734803,
-0.1214648038,
0.4912424386,
0.187019527,
0.1922435611,
-0.3658389151,
-0.4549075067,
0.1203517839,
-0.1869930029,
-0.3810293376,
-0.5901940465,
-0.3739224672,
-0.0250189956,
0.6651884913,
-0.0498511866,
0.3534505963,
0.1435370445,
0.0282974523,
-0.2635443211,
0.2874917388,
0.5111435056,
0.7689470053,
-0.1789384186,
0.0561729334,
-0.1163642481,
-0.1840055287,
-0.0605058037,
0.4421442449,
0.0106735658,
-0.1680364907,
0.6747618318,
0.6911272407,
0.4477044642,
-0.7404157519,
0.5185579658,
-0.1057976857,
0.3512486815,
0.1512500346,
-0.2144603282,
0.2157400399,
0.2025972754,
0.2176666558,
0.06152042,
0.6035100818,
-0.5854582787,
-0.0062379413,
0.4469053149,
-0.3971209824,
-0.3822830617,
0.638676703,
-0.1150358319,
0.1282733232,
0.1994014084,
0.1469920427,
-0.3506978154,
0.6523197293,
0.3885765076,
0.4749242961,
-0.3444199264,
0.2486260086,
0.5292032361,
0.3142071664,
-0.2597295046,
0.0450220555,
0.2716057599,
-0.6195440292,
-0.5480214357,
-0.5621233582,
-0.3270475566,
-0.1032697856,
-0.3208378255,
0.243969515,
0.0134098157,
-0.0273683239,
0.2888720036,
-0.0349834412,
-0.4086525142,
0.3329672515,
-0.0543786958,
0.2837972343,
-1.2410788536,
0.446801424,
0.2257375717,
-0.4255674481,
-0.8169104457,
-0.3693259656,
0.0160643943,
-0.4583480656,
0.5283418894,
0.0484647602,
0.0638359562,
-0.0252416246,
-0.4313677251,
-0.7236018777,
0.6748238206,
0.72926718,
-0.3900320232,
0.1752174497,
-0.2535072267,
0.5537038445,
-0.1072515845,
0.4521232247,
0.3561548889,
0.7469161749,
-0.0734864771,
-0.7735381722,
0.1164148003,
0.0135435564,
-0.2485136986,
0.1137197241,
-0.1422213763,
0.7940699458,
-0.4164611697,
-0.0213664137,
0.0128526175,
0.1981856823,
0.2246230096,
0.5615571737,
0.078030251,
0.8591884375,
0.8013166189,
-0.0771401376,
1.4167532921,
-0.0409958512,
0.5509167314,
0.4819316864,
-0.0810961649,
0.4030926228,
0.1064243466,
-0.3908627927,
0.5078380704,
0.6920230389,
0.3825416565,
0.2627856433,
0.3264101446,
-0.2609185576,
-0.3444003165,
-0.0704479963,
-0.296158731,
-0.0627346858,
0.2852404118,
-0.5307896733,
-0.279612869,
0.3029061258,
0.3687301278,
-0.1220047623,
-0.1331356019,
0.4703041315,
-0.0063397805,
-0.3903032839,
0.3450725377,
0.1291215867,
0.0591434836,
-0.6581011415,
-0.1666770279,
0.0356949419,
0.0825455189,
-0.2856784761,
-0.3086231351,
0.262296766,
-0.3202569783,
-0.3606826067,
0.5306330919,
0.61453861,
-0.1692408472,
-0.6550695896,
0.5649039149,
0.4671877027,
0.1153646857,
-0.0724816173,
-0.3410182595,
0.2199012935,
-0.1754711419,
-0.0204183292,
0.3354099989,
0.2145134509,
-0.0132806776,
0.7454671264,
0.7479439378,
0.1677280217,
0.0481831655,
-0.1344946325,
0.7321556211,
-0.5132501721,
-0.136977762,
-1.0680807829,
0.3098762929,
0.2703177333,
0.0175239183,
0.9736042023,
0.4478853941,
0.1275361329,
-0.0373449847,
0.7788484097,
0.2694419622,
0.6782549024,
-0.7025806904,
0.8308618069,
-0.4209443629,
0.0833409578,
-0.6346802115,
-0.5625737309,
-0.6997115612,
0.3799372017,
-0.5485450029,
0.182827726,
0.8543008566,
0.5514563918,
0.0674893036,
-0.0440644324,
0.2542230189,
0.707454443,
0.3112754226,
0.6797572374,
0.377892375,
-0.5047929287,
0.0248693153,
0.0487147383,
-0.638559103,
-0.3105511069,
-0.9882381558,
-0.6496129632,
-0.7759378552,
-0.2765816152,
-0.31762591,
0.559628427,
0.4764679074,
0.6127788424,
-0.3826125562,
-0.0879667178,
-0.1561475098,
0.547670424,
-0.150064528,
-0.0597305484,
0.7186535597,
0.02537499,
-0.3246730268,
0.7706218362,
0.5774683952,
-0.304420054,
-0.1182563752,
-0.0219246428,
-0.3204712272,
0.1201753616,
0.6880484819,
0.6658769846,
-0.4741597474,
-0.0434860066,
-0.3476966918,
0.0929467306,
-0.3244855404,
0.7372298837,
-0.7717574835,
0.5694260597,
0.313354671,
0.7546399236,
0.2209551483,
-0.2227437049,
0.6383937597,
0.1043198481,
-0.2625600994,
-0.0106483959,
0.7064031363,
0.3874302506,
-0.557879746,
0.4032457769,
0.4939585924,
-0.7063956261,
-0.6796959043,
0.2246643007,
-0.9288346171,
-0.3891434073,
1.1576162577,
-0.2451441437,
-0.1257600635,
-0.325553,
-0.1733148992,
0.4072030187,
-0.0184752494,
0.6842980385,
0.4637691081,
-0.1706793755,
0.0640032589,
-0.5648325682,
0.384689182,
0.3224670589,
-0.7422506809,
-0.1543528289,
0.6875408888,
0.362675488,
-0.0901697502,
0.6268010736,
-0.3459779024,
0.3546697795,
-0.3785082996,
-0.141042918,
-0.0730135292,
-0.3687547743,
-0.4438143373,
0.3927671313,
-0.0418115221,
0.0961376131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17760v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17760v6 | Language Models are Bounded Pragmatic Speakers: Understanding RLHF from a Bayesian Cognitive Modeling Perspective | 2023-05-28T16:04:48 | 2024-01-01T21:06:57 | Khanh Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | How do language models "think"? This paper formulates a probabilistic
cognitive model called the bounded pragmatic speaker, which can characterize
the operation of different variations of language models. Specifically, we
demonstrate that large language models fine-tuned with reinforcement learning
from human feedback (Ouyang et al., 2022) embody a model of thought that
conceptually resembles a fast-and-slow model (Kahneman, 2011), which
psychologists have attributed to humans. We discuss the limitations of
reinforcement learning from human feedback as a fast-and-slow model of thought
and propose avenues for expanding this framework. In essence, our research
highlights the value of adopting a cognitive probabilistic modeling approach to
gain insights into the comprehension, evaluation, and advancement of language
models. | [
-0.3371859491,
-1.2625991106,
0.7610645294,
0.1379810423,
-0.1333257556,
-0.063122876,
-0.4988904297,
-0.4443283379,
-0.1165330932,
0.8404861093,
-0.8051629663,
-0.0790977255,
-0.332545042,
-0.2614853978,
-0.0301815774,
0.8933590651,
0.2919703722,
-0.1368729919,
0.2049179077,
0.086089626,
-0.4851464331,
-0.3252364099,
-0.4891278744,
-0.7500622869,
0.4172793031,
0.3627508283,
1.4616702795,
0.663615644,
0.2680585682,
0.2639637589,
0.0371529795,
-0.3766701221,
-0.332711637,
0.3110893071,
-0.4567182362,
-0.4328684509,
-0.201108709,
0.1155706942,
0.8479232192,
1.0280106068,
-0.7870917916,
-0.1709387898,
-0.1933828294,
0.5986531377,
-0.4935215116,
0.4344841838,
-0.3266381025,
0.083464995,
-0.0318928771,
0.1747160405,
-0.6758669019,
-0.2852374315,
0.3521105349,
-0.5784332752,
0.2615512311,
-0.0276825409,
0.4874134958,
0.0547516719,
-0.444765389,
-0.1697103083,
-1.0724225044,
0.8880615234,
-0.8460053205,
0.5446746349,
0.5691339374,
0.365062207,
-0.5662033558,
-0.5158390403,
-0.7871695757,
-0.6403940916,
-0.0818075389,
-0.093123816,
0.247082442,
0.3319315314,
0.1491876543,
0.1087261438,
-0.5814079046,
-0.0496424027,
-0.0935145691,
-0.1741472334,
0.8497459292,
0.087655507,
0.120557636,
0.1143728793,
-0.097479105,
-0.2181528509,
-0.1980905235,
-0.0046278583,
0.3568973243,
0.3244704902,
0.1023769379,
0.2886492908,
-0.3061817884,
1.2348686457,
-0.1472509354,
-0.3295187056,
-0.0808589831,
0.0836379901,
-0.2331357449,
-0.3087907434,
0.599798739,
-0.0606315583,
0.8615226746,
-0.0003682974,
-0.3710350394,
0.0373915061,
0.3445878029,
-0.5229004622,
-0.5403834581,
0.1434995532,
-0.5233146548,
0.0694728494,
0.0050669694,
-0.6580631137,
-0.2831061184,
-0.1827188432,
0.1215919778,
-0.316847682,
-0.792509973,
0.3869071007,
0.1398953944,
-0.1415275335,
0.276935935,
-0.9484673142,
0.4841203392,
0.822598815,
0.2970385849,
-0.0181174707,
-0.5519500971,
-0.3686342537,
0.022030998,
-0.5348189473,
0.7278348804,
-0.8291177154,
-0.7204269767,
0.2894181609,
0.003548604,
-0.1600435823,
-0.7062520385,
0.4519213438,
-0.7496724129,
0.129425168,
0.0207972415,
-0.7419831157,
-0.4091617167,
-0.033540193,
-0.6196728349,
0.59661901,
0.2826021016,
-0.6864875555,
0.2347321659,
-0.1289587617,
-0.5275726318,
0.4614806473,
-0.1894723475,
-0.2384240478,
0.1591467261,
-0.1884879619,
0.4102628827,
-0.1704391837,
0.7146317959,
-0.5052015185,
-0.2811325192,
0.8084616661,
-0.3817769587,
0.5554438829,
0.2797318697,
-0.1398916543,
0.3741770983,
-0.8054174185,
0.167451933,
0.2011297941,
-0.5864476562,
-0.1273510009,
0.3606631458,
0.1918132603,
0.2826041281,
-0.0243243892,
-0.3814464509,
0.0340524279,
-0.5460444093,
0.5972129703,
0.6096665263,
0.286542803,
0.4494177699,
-0.4033041298,
0.7540143132,
-0.1214012727,
0.3427369297,
-0.0812630579,
-0.4318341017,
-0.6271718144,
-0.2445951998,
0.1324360967,
0.5560942888,
-0.4710593224,
0.0825398937,
0.1384058297,
-0.36170277,
-0.5909197927,
-0.0040577762,
0.4700638354,
0.3455394804,
0.1044579372,
-0.4301887155,
-0.0840873793,
-1.1113290787,
-0.4418067336,
-0.6281318069,
0.091961503,
0.2181448638,
0.5292909741,
-0.0889438391,
0.8963161707,
-0.4028390348,
0.1928088069,
-0.501440227,
0.2394158393,
0.3147702813,
0.4314214289,
-0.0750696883,
-0.7382934093,
-0.2036332488,
-0.2351640761,
-0.3157599568,
0.202078104,
-0.3067558408,
0.1561862379,
0.0441053174,
0.3133945465,
-0.8451824784,
0.4751826227,
0.3214913905,
-0.4215418994,
0.8142617941,
-0.5040469766,
-0.2026473135,
-0.3387799263,
-0.2425134778,
0.097489588,
-0.2710005641,
-0.6769130826,
0.2359090894,
-0.0273077656,
-0.0144674061,
-0.4228791595,
0.659799993,
-0.3755630851,
-0.2010822445,
-0.5805088878,
0.247588858,
-0.4558790922,
0.7755246758,
0.5476768613,
0.3768627048,
0.3670138121,
-0.8671700954,
0.2139984965,
0.0090687461,
-0.7994493842,
0.5035673976,
-0.7975532413,
-0.0268482305,
-0.2109552026,
0.5088636279,
-0.7720769644,
-0.3129230738,
0.2719139159,
-0.3438910544,
0.2763780653,
0.0278900694,
-0.5100764632,
-0.2880093455,
0.3992626369,
0.376385957,
0.5886688232,
-0.2144490629,
0.4319797456,
0.5191712976,
-0.2889562845,
-0.4332815707,
-0.6035577655,
-0.3687384725,
0.1364864558,
-0.3735187352,
0.2487038821,
-0.0287876446,
-0.7334603071,
0.0011179538,
0.0358335227,
-0.1623509824,
0.2359873056,
0.4075121582,
0.1557445377,
0.0241534021,
0.2243025303,
-0.4882854223,
-0.0879073516,
0.0981398597,
-0.3351964056,
0.2504304945,
-0.0181883182,
-0.3939652145,
-0.4992237985,
0.2779830396,
0.3620132804,
-0.2760892808,
0.6138883233,
0.3755514026,
-0.0994195566,
-0.4746322632,
-0.3241562247,
-0.4509042203,
-0.3751128912,
0.586086154,
-0.3683504164,
-1.1704486609,
0.3757989109,
0.2427010089,
0.0486767553,
0.2299526185,
0.6900517344,
-0.0664137527,
1.0555448532,
0.9285338521,
0.1782779247,
0.62073493,
0.2663337886,
0.1973436326,
-0.4112468064,
-0.0488770083,
-0.3988629878,
0.0338536911,
-0.9369823933,
-0.4833735824,
-0.1195151508,
0.2208765149,
-0.4375656545,
-0.0079073394,
-0.2488208413,
0.2683696747,
0.5953378081,
0.1214240268,
0.0400594808,
-0.4715293944,
-0.2614006996,
0.0649551153,
-0.9189109802,
-0.3875810504,
0.6827480793,
0.5930712223,
0.8991217017,
0.072020404,
0.27196455,
0.3563385904,
0.3938215077,
-0.7484344244,
0.7974832654,
0.4561618865,
-1.0524855852,
-0.4952391386,
-0.3982248008,
-0.8337019086,
0.55468297,
-0.0475106798,
-0.7259805799,
0.150631398,
0.2076863945,
-0.3347035944,
0.0970571339,
-0.3761693537,
0.8762685061,
-0.1377504319,
-0.5172286034,
-0.8234929442,
-0.790732801,
0.5354766846,
0.1201816797,
0.6294158101,
-0.2819670439,
0.2543484569,
0.8943527937,
-0.3843080699,
0.8413924575,
-0.4098013043,
-0.1267140806,
0.7285985351,
0.4357223511,
0.507101953,
0.114129737,
0.2336945683,
-0.2770534456,
0.0066240109,
-0.6730589867,
-0.5201638937,
0.2790558338,
-0.6199964285,
-0.8880988955,
-0.533716023,
-0.6858138442,
-0.4650919735,
0.0685980022,
-0.2035655826,
0.0069270842,
-0.4504980743,
-0.2340545654,
0.8157638907,
-0.3812742531,
0.5199964643,
0.9069488049,
-0.5786039233,
-0.2497439981,
0.7064324617,
-0.0046980148,
0.3489937484,
0.4651858509,
0.0116575928,
-0.2024651766,
-0.273094207,
-0.1273829788,
0.6393064857,
-0.6156912446,
0.5207159519,
-0.4807655513,
0.0213255044,
-0.2770263553,
0.0895858109,
-0.2467654347,
-0.4376040697,
-0.0327709541,
-0.1695884764,
-0.0011082295,
0.9537648559,
0.1240702942,
0.6262773871,
-0.6225218773,
0.0290072542,
0.5918776989,
0.3277608752,
0.3879435658,
-0.6675686836,
-0.4429560304,
-0.0145342667,
-0.1132406965,
-1.0775578022,
0.3821554482,
0.1626858115,
0.8131133318,
0.3345320225,
0.0214070808,
0.2441737205,
-0.4547025263,
0.6789566875,
0.0203768108,
-0.7198668718,
0.4955416024,
-0.4146326482,
0.6261741519,
0.1975039691,
0.1868986487,
-0.6806258559,
-0.4510835707,
-0.8326132298,
-0.4664240777,
0.6252741218,
-0.2246041596,
-0.1684206575,
-0.290910244,
0.3386983275,
0.0476434268,
0.2352145612,
-0.6868650317,
0.0868691951,
0.0005198391,
0.0199462567,
-0.4745508432,
-0.476193279,
0.0633017197,
-0.0275002364,
0.766515851,
-0.165651679,
0.2328376323,
0.0701551512,
-0.3850201368,
-0.2811412811,
0.5569688678,
0.7994214892,
0.892123878,
-0.3389015794,
0.0451367907,
-0.3161714971,
-0.2168599665,
0.161613062,
-0.0598035716,
-0.1547717154,
0.0565121435,
0.6631312966,
0.9281823039,
0.324844569,
-0.9582648873,
0.1531150341,
-0.0843391716,
-0.0987156332,
-0.2640669048,
0.238751933,
0.2746851742,
0.3267293572,
0.1226089448,
-0.0561761186,
-0.2635469139,
-0.8385460973,
0.4853341877,
0.2491274625,
-0.5492390394,
-0.6275638938,
0.6866746545,
0.1385953873,
-0.7165901065,
0.8594948053,
-0.0753109083,
-0.6891560555,
0.4800277054,
0.5839840174,
0.7479946017,
-0.3254432976,
0.4774772823,
0.2983649075,
0.2789772451,
-0.4077018499,
0.3347391784,
-0.4226537943,
-0.907861948,
-0.6202668548,
-0.687964201,
-0.5261049271,
-0.1921451688,
-0.8014037609,
-0.2962341905,
-0.733074069,
-0.5814471841,
0.0150942011,
0.0363464504,
-0.5469422936,
0.5014228821,
0.0986584947,
1.0103722811,
-0.7651954293,
1.3007301092,
0.4988339841,
-0.4043358266,
-0.6366866231,
0.2293857485,
-0.2916930914,
-0.8333211541,
0.7520971894,
-0.1387858242,
-0.0015103634,
-0.0279402863,
-0.3425819874,
-0.6164511442,
0.4362675846,
0.0951117724,
-0.8891442418,
0.1841112822,
-0.2528303266,
0.6255562901,
-0.3354568481,
0.2082006484,
0.7768393159,
0.5045638084,
-0.2098861486,
-0.8737937808,
-0.1525849104,
0.1543302536,
0.239784807,
0.2071653455,
-0.7108127475,
0.8737174273,
-0.6121575236,
-0.1414801329,
-0.1355309337,
1.011873126,
0.3464541137,
-0.0186102819,
0.631403625,
0.4967695475,
0.6524738073,
0.2553877831,
1.0522831678,
-0.2266488224,
0.3827575445,
1.4055274725,
-0.4060640037,
1.0314074755,
0.3429122567,
-0.5164987445,
0.7289817333,
0.8293038607,
0.3717612326,
0.7565410733,
0.5392264128,
-0.250900656,
-0.5339343548,
-0.1303539574,
-0.0590940081,
0.0761611015,
0.6081296206,
-0.201777935,
0.1620627642,
0.0486466028,
-0.0488924608,
0.4195392728,
-0.2713607252,
0.7159472108,
0.1244892403,
-1.2551916838,
0.4101143181,
0.3518586755,
0.464317292,
-0.4466460049,
0.1741853654,
-0.1468871981,
0.3769186139,
0.0915343091,
-1.0214192867,
0.189227283,
-0.398444742,
-0.2811964452,
-0.2262636572,
0.6227391362,
-0.4994984567,
-0.2645342946,
0.3943271339,
0.4781739712,
0.0964920297,
0.1917290837,
-0.9268218279,
-0.0142263379,
0.1216438487,
-0.5032629967,
0.3429622948,
0.2450930029,
-0.2356678694,
0.9620233178,
0.3529435992,
0.2071163058,
-0.0084498646,
0.1029644758,
0.1092707515,
-0.8923438191,
-0.7539102435,
-0.7932555676,
0.1888679266,
0.425660044,
-0.3530766368,
0.3548373878,
-0.06492275,
1.0444407463,
-0.1321259141,
0.7408435345,
0.2482015043,
0.7090646029,
-0.3042300642,
0.4306000173,
-0.1159517914,
0.0351096205,
0.0576271303,
-0.7148657441,
-0.0585487932,
0.9282848835,
-0.5208768249,
0.2366903275,
0.6892875433,
0.7465625405,
0.3606501818,
0.2072992772,
0.5213478208,
0.3098018765,
0.0912738666,
0.6373650432,
0.9342804551,
0.1776656657,
0.0325456187,
-0.1918833107,
-0.2047836185,
-0.4220163226,
-0.5260449648,
-0.6785169244,
-0.6427507997,
-0.5003747344,
-0.3186425865,
0.1317328364,
0.7154901028,
0.9486871958,
-0.7538408637,
-0.6317639947,
-0.3472259045,
0.3543512225,
-0.5648486614,
-0.2596211433,
0.0180511978,
-0.1970863342,
-0.424726814,
0.3307255805,
0.3108383417,
-0.0592353791,
-0.5536599755,
-0.3201596439,
-0.4725990891,
0.4677928984,
0.236597985,
0.5492224097,
-0.9215083718,
-0.1469792277,
-0.3583595753,
-0.0913681313,
-0.2504786551,
0.9032549262,
-0.8608733416,
0.5637013316,
0.2479994744,
0.4736843407,
0.5631105304,
-0.1708513647,
0.6490601897,
-0.3523962796,
0.4789969921,
0.4353296757,
0.1652910709,
0.2897253931,
-0.041965194,
0.344310075,
0.4633405507,
-0.7808264494,
-0.7787389159,
0.8329342604,
-0.5805917382,
-0.7024202347,
0.9406594634,
-0.2662718892,
-0.3605129123,
-0.053743124,
0.0842910856,
0.2206976265,
-0.3051736951,
0.5503314137,
0.9197508693,
-0.2880234718,
-0.4655073881,
-0.9470356703,
0.4970270693,
0.7407870293,
-0.3321685493,
0.3151260614,
0.595073998,
0.3053367436,
-0.1719881296,
0.9119922519,
0.3152145147,
0.295368582,
0.0670465678,
0.0394734442,
0.3563340902,
-0.3775861561,
-0.3199822605,
0.2809463739,
0.5041909814,
0.0881880894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.19148v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.19148v3 | Mitigating Label Biases for In-context Learning | 2023-05-28T15:37:39 | 2023-08-04T15:43:19 | Yu Fei, Yifan Hou, Zeming Chen, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Various design settings for in-context learning (ICL), such as the choice and
order of the in-context examples, can bias a model toward a particular
prediction without being reflective of an understanding of the task. While many
studies discuss these design choices, there have been few systematic
investigations into categorizing them and mitigating their impact. In this
work, we define a typology for three types of label biases in ICL for text
classification: vanilla-label bias, context-label bias, and domain-label bias
(which we conceptualize and detect for the first time).
Our analysis demonstrates that prior label bias calibration methods fall
short of addressing all three types of biases. Specifically, domain-label bias
restricts LLMs to random-level performance on many tasks regardless of the
choice of in-context examples. To mitigate the effect of these biases, we
propose a simple bias calibration method that estimates a language model's
label bias using random in-domain words from the task corpus. After controlling
for this estimated bias when making predictions, our novel domain-context
calibration significantly improves the ICL performance of GPT-J and GPT-3 on a
wide range of tasks. The gain is substantial on tasks with large domain-label
bias (up to 37% in Macro-F1). Furthermore, our results generalize to models
with different scales, pretraining methods, and manually-designed task
instructions, showing the prevalence of label biases in ICL. | [
-0.4574185014,
-0.4635569453,
0.2979033887,
0.0547072552,
-0.2333317697,
0.1152243987,
-0.1530369669,
-0.4791063368,
-0.3764124811,
0.4719108641,
-0.4698060453,
-0.5664404035,
-0.5280662179,
-0.0554963797,
0.1197468713,
1.4829300642,
-0.2456375808,
0.1894538701,
-0.5957893729,
-0.1129936203,
-0.6334360242,
-0.7338328958,
-0.4594092369,
-0.7720209956,
0.3622386754,
0.3964961171,
0.3202703893,
0.1974153668,
0.2212528139,
-0.0168084856,
-0.2334628701,
0.2135128528,
-0.508000195,
-0.1214172468,
-0.1119775996,
-0.3498190641,
-0.3328696489,
0.1845192015,
0.4450123906,
0.5737655759,
0.3576633036,
0.3056689799,
0.5083366632,
0.6680544615,
-0.9358910322,
0.3410015404,
-0.4936916828,
0.1652326435,
-0.3897857666,
-0.2685545981,
-0.7688502073,
-0.2101624757,
0.4209869504,
-0.5874006748,
0.1527374983,
0.2592102885,
0.6091200113,
0.3876491189,
-0.5238416195,
-0.3058457375,
-0.6001622677,
0.9697068334,
-0.6237909198,
0.3946483433,
0.8049843907,
0.1278384179,
0.1397532076,
-0.3046321869,
-0.1251845509,
-0.1452105045,
-0.2771477699,
0.093764998,
0.2378055006,
0.1629390121,
0.3794072866,
-0.0027517856,
-0.4003937244,
0.2448245436,
-0.1087696031,
-0.3448281288,
0.1150618717,
-0.1586287469,
0.2357027978,
0.1688487977,
-0.51410532,
-0.11364948,
-1.1587150097,
0.0954778567,
0.2203301936,
0.2310666591,
0.0161757357,
0.2563001812,
0.1376331002,
0.9153413177,
0.0888548195,
-0.4443281293,
0.288741827,
-0.1644840837,
-0.264682889,
0.205692932,
0.1826673299,
0.3847491443,
0.3022156358,
-0.2016313225,
-0.2232800722,
-0.0701138079,
0.0809872001,
-0.7916657925,
-0.0993952155,
-0.1704283953,
-0.2285887897,
-0.2509996295,
-0.2613435686,
-0.4485505521,
-0.458609432,
-0.4281910062,
0.5582967401,
-0.2077775747,
0.2038291097,
-0.1429966092,
0.0388712659,
-0.0845602304,
0.2479923666,
-0.799882412,
0.3904619217,
0.3977322578,
0.4206970334,
-0.3102376759,
-0.1543979794,
-0.4783096015,
0.3775208592,
-0.1854975373,
0.7271696925,
-0.4670607448,
-0.3398927748,
0.0497773737,
-0.4127011001,
-0.1091502756,
-0.5229165554,
0.4140352607,
-0.6466982961,
0.2781518698,
-0.2827032506,
-0.5859199166,
-0.3772438169,
0.3481695354,
-0.5783089399,
0.8646251559,
0.0681865066,
-1.0719878674,
0.9219691753,
-0.4140217602,
-0.5243871212,
0.0186948366,
-0.3302874863,
-0.5033296943,
-0.1138632298,
0.2057088464,
0.4073192477,
-0.4021266401,
0.282680124,
-0.1305007488,
-0.6055845022,
0.221704036,
-0.3745133281,
0.6734524369,
0.1548482627,
-0.5976350904,
-0.118619889,
-0.4217890203,
0.1682649553,
-0.3888686299,
-0.4034133554,
-0.7934731841,
0.1996236444,
0.1701601148,
0.4099939764,
-0.1062903032,
-0.474940747,
-0.0677772164,
-0.3027741015,
0.1730827391,
0.7190420032,
-0.1032176316,
0.6850363612,
-0.4864612818,
0.4187926352,
0.1566423327,
-0.0470300131,
0.086765334,
-0.320238173,
-0.6146555543,
-0.3001377583,
0.4054670632,
0.3580545187,
-0.8580297828,
-0.009221958,
-0.144990921,
-0.2059255242,
-0.123372227,
0.0969793499,
0.8690620065,
0.7292989492,
0.4654471874,
-0.1508750916,
-0.254042387,
-0.8928005099,
-0.65642941,
0.0088918852,
-0.1348250061,
0.4859169424,
0.3914503455,
-0.1972295642,
1.1384124756,
-0.4203372002,
-0.5649856925,
-0.1108235046,
0.2180929631,
-0.1450239569,
0.4509331882,
0.5628511906,
-0.7881461382,
-0.708078146,
-0.2040882558,
-0.2343636453,
-0.4203081429,
0.0547369272,
0.0274508558,
0.4860790074,
0.3842908144,
-0.1396370083,
0.5858342052,
0.1727807075,
-0.205732286,
0.3516078889,
0.1479578316,
-0.1604780704,
-0.6512382627,
-0.1846196204,
0.4181188047,
-0.0274697207,
-0.6718366146,
-0.1519670933,
0.5125668049,
0.3213901222,
-0.5555756092,
0.8506931067,
-0.2657578588,
0.2093141973,
-0.3160011768,
0.0005722559,
0.2437462658,
0.5182504058,
0.1447087526,
0.8538937569,
0.2365865856,
-0.676708281,
-0.6130856872,
0.0895417929,
-0.3824027479,
0.561983943,
-0.1507733762,
0.1269813776,
-0.2628662288,
0.669480443,
-0.8980343938,
0.0990677848,
0.3365293741,
-0.1841049641,
0.6264591217,
-0.1672565639,
-0.5086945295,
-0.2600381076,
-0.2197591215,
0.9423041344,
0.1168074161,
-0.7293510437,
0.3176312149,
0.4643106461,
0.2618030608,
-0.6427212954,
-0.8241730928,
-0.3570303023,
-0.4001155496,
-0.1038681641,
0.8288789988,
-0.5037931204,
-0.2004170567,
-0.3260399997,
-0.4646450579,
-0.2287703454,
-0.1270929724,
0.1722414196,
0.3338259161,
0.1955345273,
0.2093343586,
0.0905305222,
0.0496464781,
0.0126655269,
-0.4718969762,
0.344014287,
0.0205316804,
-0.0967375189,
-0.1204007044,
-0.0274363272,
0.4720390439,
-0.043850787,
0.4399924874,
0.3829942942,
-0.4448213875,
-0.527382195,
-0.6414362788,
-0.1704855859,
-0.4317628443,
0.1623287201,
-0.3756580055,
-0.951523602,
0.1330147684,
0.0221266877,
-0.001629715,
0.1233915016,
0.4180838168,
-0.0339124985,
1.019759655,
0.6302526593,
-0.2415813953,
0.424474299,
-0.1397327185,
0.3170426488,
-1.0934764147,
-0.1414043754,
-0.4025603235,
-0.2241693586,
-0.5266291499,
-0.315405786,
0.4526120126,
-0.3118675351,
-0.476818949,
0.1574926078,
-0.5082201958,
0.6137530804,
0.6822358966,
0.3112891614,
0.0216813963,
0.0902106762,
-0.3800289333,
-0.2287376225,
-0.6665112972,
-0.4249690175,
1.0965709686,
0.1591485441,
0.7921665311,
-0.2568235993,
0.6049714684,
0.3216854036,
0.8210003972,
-0.5624092221,
0.2488044649,
-0.1430454254,
-0.9616449475,
-0.0285575222,
-0.2734132707,
-0.4175961018,
0.3861724734,
-0.0053036911,
-0.9595030546,
0.1057690531,
0.2134095132,
-0.2255784422,
0.2933763564,
-0.6866140366,
0.698876977,
-0.16920048,
-0.5108438134,
0.1066354513,
-0.4874926805,
0.5124642253,
-0.3630779386,
0.4596866965,
-0.1270235479,
0.1589051187,
0.7261657119,
-0.1716527641,
1.1561164856,
-0.0885603949,
-0.1029799506,
0.4407125115,
0.1446839124,
0.4196280539,
-0.0007444539,
-0.0044500371,
-0.0332360528,
-0.0563557446,
-0.3139846921,
-0.2043780535,
0.6856396198,
-0.7650714517,
-0.3441976309,
-0.4873315096,
-0.6907200217,
-0.6647539139,
0.1056518927,
0.6063802242,
0.6656891108,
-0.085720256,
-0.0410221517,
0.8090185523,
-0.2271160483,
0.3382327557,
0.578659296,
0.0176488739,
-0.3261808455,
0.9815157652,
0.33789289,
0.4526982307,
0.6702671647,
0.113796249,
-0.1745936722,
-0.4161804616,
-0.1398395449,
0.0144955842,
-0.9877002239,
-0.440271318,
-0.3533763289,
-0.1221005097,
-0.1861825734,
-0.2392684668,
0.0878232494,
-0.3374007344,
-0.5357797146,
-0.0359895341,
-0.064996995,
0.5810590982,
0.3657916784,
0.5352550149,
-0.2772099078,
0.060650941,
0.2329282314,
0.5303504467,
0.0140556404,
-0.5959029794,
-0.3754080832,
0.0329477116,
-0.5990219116,
-0.6108839512,
0.3811076581,
0.2335846871,
0.5003421903,
0.2104188353,
0.107359454,
0.4388591051,
-0.6073406935,
0.640730381,
0.0620971508,
-0.9975370169,
0.4082446396,
-0.1824314594,
0.4764196873,
0.5909665227,
0.3887580037,
-0.3458084762,
-0.3422339857,
-0.3469542563,
-0.798129499,
0.7153232694,
0.1177322641,
-0.1355947852,
-0.0983481631,
0.2339393497,
0.2431421131,
0.2354307026,
-1.0285494328,
-0.4922920167,
-0.0513596274,
-0.0727911144,
-0.1979581416,
-0.4886673689,
-0.1973154843,
-0.2754463255,
0.8340434432,
-0.284507513,
-0.0154840881,
0.0504269339,
-0.4744237959,
-0.0634946078,
0.1867784411,
0.7875686884,
0.694275856,
-0.4064859748,
0.2846221924,
0.1775918603,
-0.496917069,
0.1995248199,
0.1250934005,
-0.596688807,
-0.1595261842,
0.0762679204,
0.6780445576,
0.5536800623,
-0.4665172398,
0.3610138297,
-0.0190479681,
-0.1338891089,
-0.0478710234,
-0.0613252372,
-0.366748333,
-0.122153528,
0.3732303977,
0.236288175,
0.1956539899,
-0.096674256,
0.1058359444,
0.4467128217,
-0.6302373409,
-0.1894575357,
0.7320150733,
0.1189997047,
-0.113609992,
0.2419897914,
0.0545437373,
-0.5569735765,
0.7387750745,
0.9361149669,
1.02247262,
0.0415222831,
0.2545242906,
0.2317345291,
0.2773942351,
0.0766231716,
-0.1370021105,
-0.2860962451,
-0.822629869,
-0.328795433,
-0.4901247919,
-0.5535324216,
0.1570808291,
-0.4556228817,
0.0443027541,
-0.2397520393,
-0.3508724868,
-0.0806812719,
0.0218280386,
-0.8605493903,
0.4901809394,
0.4788414538,
0.8960824609,
-0.7120021582,
1.0130754709,
0.7637742758,
-0.0970681161,
-0.5140155554,
0.2467806041,
0.2852666974,
-0.4761031866,
0.9864577055,
0.5027629733,
-0.1807298362,
0.0169433542,
-0.4403711855,
-0.9903110862,
1.0365815163,
0.014715476,
-0.2632468343,
0.042953562,
0.2753131092,
0.2814211249,
-0.5500207543,
0.2640856802,
0.568723917,
0.4006097913,
-0.2700950205,
-0.9343490005,
-0.0405856147,
-0.0149354786,
0.1847731471,
0.0824965984,
-0.3453170657,
0.4525719285,
0.1200411171,
-0.0362328812,
-0.2336063087,
0.3066866398,
0.4522266686,
0.4761712253,
0.5128986239,
0.3397355378,
0.6323139668,
-0.1968423277,
0.9779710174,
-0.315444231,
0.2362885177,
1.1771960258,
-0.2559387684,
0.2546401024,
0.6962331533,
0.0182060432,
0.2092569619,
0.9151818156,
0.4866266251,
0.769980967,
0.4794920981,
-0.4711538851,
0.0128975073,
-0.2513915598,
-0.2490785122,
0.1695504338,
0.6487969756,
-0.2199853063,
-0.1077488363,
0.2983978987,
0.2021337897,
-0.1816303432,
-0.4509682059,
0.4867125452,
0.1004291028,
-0.8486417532,
0.6724851131,
-0.186477378,
0.7923187017,
-0.3592320681,
0.1897535771,
-0.1270460188,
0.3684284985,
-0.0117109502,
-0.6289820671,
-0.1397618502,
-0.2572612464,
-0.4081235528,
-0.5200012326,
0.7570736408,
-0.5366130471,
-0.2666649818,
0.2426688969,
0.2102416754,
-0.2746834159,
-0.0529000573,
-0.4071861506,
0.0819392428,
0.0532209352,
-0.2073345929,
0.6229373813,
0.1323560029,
-0.2825670838,
0.6395028234,
0.0910418108,
-0.2596621215,
0.0122216698,
-0.0181030091,
0.8295693994,
-0.2760659158,
-0.3242578804,
-0.6946246624,
0.317353934,
0.1567342579,
-0.4094917178,
0.6265991926,
0.5687177777,
1.2576391697,
-0.1777361929,
0.9013139606,
0.2113848925,
0.3766567409,
-0.4532964528,
0.6082035899,
-0.5192580819,
0.4724915028,
-0.5731970072,
-0.8346562982,
-0.6337393522,
0.3379726112,
-0.5295847058,
0.0846500248,
0.7415088415,
0.5178915858,
0.0436651744,
-0.0044190441,
0.2576130331,
-0.1016014591,
0.3303655386,
0.4786380827,
0.6531802416,
-0.2267131358,
0.4240022302,
-0.6171101332,
-0.3450332284,
-0.2079574615,
-1.014539361,
-1.0362949371,
-0.4810051918,
-0.351066649,
-0.3112492561,
0.1576585472,
0.7063710093,
0.7959519625,
-0.7470763922,
-0.3142216504,
0.0294043794,
0.3683106303,
-0.2176964879,
-0.2390849143,
0.4253712893,
-0.5635000467,
-0.6564827561,
0.207124263,
0.0749292001,
0.1210529879,
0.1927980185,
-0.0682165176,
0.0001385307,
-0.0140638836,
0.8289858103,
0.2723585963,
-0.8097692132,
-0.3524054289,
-0.1916272193,
-0.267126441,
0.0462374464,
0.8838341236,
-1.0088539124,
0.5297641158,
0.3163541257,
0.4320989549,
0.5626271367,
-0.0936000198,
0.4999051988,
-0.9373149872,
0.0491767749,
0.2611932456,
0.192012921,
0.2012115419,
-0.3784358799,
0.547267437,
-0.0280170962,
-0.7857536077,
-0.6452174783,
0.2399783283,
-0.5442264676,
-0.4119647741,
1.1442114115,
0.14396891,
0.0475630201,
-0.0161456913,
-0.3455318511,
0.1422417015,
-0.1167161241,
0.7911046147,
0.8936401606,
-0.0623308383,
0.1967140287,
-0.8678724766,
0.9182395339,
0.5026032925,
-0.3925899267,
0.0042255493,
0.4899541438,
0.2127387375,
-0.0673637837,
0.5945055485,
0.0640057102,
0.1887621433,
-0.7115155458,
0.06038028,
0.2429477125,
-0.4772108197,
-0.0231203996,
-0.0682640299,
-0.0016619124,
-0.0050978255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18404v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18404v3 | Conformal Prediction with Large Language Models for Multi-Choice Question Answering | 2023-05-28T15:26:10 | 2023-07-08T02:20:29 | Bhawesh Kumar, Charlie Lu, Gauri Gupta, Anil Palepu, David Bellamy, Ramesh Raskar, Andrew Beam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | As large language models continue to be widely developed, robust uncertainty
quantification techniques will become crucial for their safe deployment in
high-stakes scenarios. In this work, we explore how conformal prediction can be
used to provide uncertainty quantification in language models for the specific
task of multiple-choice question-answering. We find that the uncertainty
estimates from conformal prediction are tightly correlated with prediction
accuracy. This observation can be useful for downstream applications such as
selective classification and filtering out low-quality predictions. We also
investigate the exchangeability assumption required by conformal prediction to
out-of-subject questions, which may be a more realistic scenario for many
practical applications. Our work contributes towards more trustworthy and
reliable usage of large language models in safety-critical situations, where
robust guarantees of error rate are required. | [
-0.3356690407,
-0.7598796487,
0.9906997085,
0.2028866857,
0.0602594838,
-0.2266408354,
-0.1912025809,
-0.7917962074,
-0.2188792974,
0.4092299342,
-0.3334482014,
-0.1183541715,
-0.6234446168,
-0.2273444086,
-0.2144237012,
0.547362864,
-0.1457093507,
0.2557294071,
-0.2971476912,
-0.087988466,
-0.4841457009,
-0.7782263756,
-0.4464707077,
0.0423142388,
0.3754970729,
0.2794298828,
0.9922369719,
0.3430757523,
0.4560035765,
0.2025734186,
-0.2557825446,
-0.4044972956,
-0.1048960909,
0.5913156867,
-0.0301794037,
-0.5925729871,
-0.4408346117,
-0.121059075,
0.9305266738,
0.6090321541,
-0.4808877707,
0.1954825521,
-0.0931712538,
0.3238314092,
-0.7286100984,
0.1827340424,
-0.8789195418,
-0.3174990416,
0.0599347018,
0.4757317901,
-0.457203418,
-0.4970739782,
0.4180679023,
-0.54422158,
-0.1782461256,
0.1123622879,
0.5944714546,
0.2026691735,
-0.4884582758,
-0.1842886657,
-0.8042835593,
0.8700889945,
-0.7042284608,
0.732768774,
0.5630888343,
0.5716984272,
-0.0674373731,
-0.6423309445,
-0.5188036561,
-0.0777724609,
0.1729936451,
0.175631851,
0.215275377,
0.2198970765,
0.105153963,
0.1253447235,
-0.4652745426,
-0.108498916,
-0.5094522834,
-0.2928120196,
0.4996120632,
-0.0682425499,
-0.1212585792,
0.1775391698,
-0.211232692,
-0.0076986207,
-0.4797062874,
0.3805681765,
0.33781299,
0.3609437346,
-0.0501941219,
0.5289554,
-0.3252378404,
0.9326733947,
0.0604249872,
-0.0478853248,
-0.0459371731,
-0.3524380028,
-0.1527746022,
-0.2655381858,
0.6681500673,
0.1238338873,
0.4057950079,
0.1153432354,
0.0226704031,
-0.1789385825,
0.1581756622,
-0.725908637,
-0.0987919644,
0.5143232346,
-0.3258202374,
-0.1907226592,
0.2527310848,
-0.9304821491,
-0.311552763,
0.0163067244,
0.2299468964,
-0.2718891501,
-0.3113948703,
0.4117926359,
-0.0373958051,
0.1018292904,
0.5191717744,
-0.7306236029,
0.0036072307,
0.514595449,
0.5121358037,
-0.0504981875,
-0.3181257248,
-0.4882879853,
0.389260143,
-0.1630947739,
0.76361835,
-0.8500837088,
-0.1885883957,
0.0997915119,
-0.1170320213,
-0.1119792834,
-0.2174831331,
0.5398800373,
-0.8563337326,
-0.2006086856,
-0.0696099401,
-0.5398935676,
-0.2008051723,
0.3257882595,
-0.8946716189,
0.6224995852,
0.212378338,
-0.6589981914,
0.355215162,
-0.1589180082,
-0.1941615343,
-0.2411120534,
0.208287403,
-0.6451014876,
-0.0568283908,
0.0565632433,
0.4921354353,
-0.34148404,
0.2470261753,
-0.9375450015,
-0.0961139575,
0.7083960772,
-0.47225824,
0.4745279849,
0.2725741267,
0.095326215,
-0.0890290514,
-0.4313976765,
0.4480131865,
-0.3412964642,
-0.4036642909,
-0.3041226268,
-0.1038631499,
0.1113814637,
0.3521962762,
0.3472872376,
-0.537522018,
-0.0573083647,
-0.1928299665,
0.2520290613,
0.6556606889,
0.1577609777,
0.4676547348,
-0.2102050632,
0.7504072189,
0.0564551204,
0.4012628794,
0.2077589482,
-0.9869919419,
-0.1089080125,
-0.0857183039,
0.337441504,
0.495495975,
-0.183364585,
0.0263044089,
0.0337097123,
-0.6479328275,
-0.2797443867,
-0.0150455013,
0.2464339733,
0.2121607512,
0.2183280587,
0.3818701208,
-0.4102227092,
-0.5605456233,
-0.2893854082,
-0.7136942148,
0.0371434204,
0.0605247244,
0.3523671031,
-0.1740866899,
0.9265872836,
-0.7642375827,
0.1058589071,
-0.0954959318,
0.060638018,
0.1284967661,
0.4929662049,
0.4125056863,
-1.2691167593,
-0.6372475624,
-0.1416386366,
-0.2646949589,
0.3319377005,
-0.0668817163,
-0.1156258881,
-0.0207798555,
0.5574794412,
-0.4864838719,
0.1098694429,
0.9660890102,
-0.2161582261,
0.7115697265,
-0.1627965868,
0.1040423214,
-1.1111857891,
-0.0916614532,
0.0553356111,
-0.2026747763,
-0.714627862,
0.1047739759,
0.3823163211,
0.0428488776,
-0.5292403102,
0.4778829515,
-0.1682150662,
0.1578848511,
0.0979081094,
-0.066547364,
0.0270098429,
0.0203187633,
0.4437601268,
0.9137458801,
0.8271642327,
-0.5266837478,
0.0914382935,
0.4232616127,
-0.2195921242,
0.5214595199,
-0.7603466511,
-0.1829292327,
-0.1167103201,
0.201100409,
-1.1221971512,
-0.3811272681,
-0.2191047817,
-0.4835543931,
0.1934939474,
-0.172188133,
-0.1572464705,
-0.3139281571,
-0.1695695519,
0.6386155486,
0.3719464242,
-0.0591633469,
0.4485923648,
0.6001833677,
-0.4246107638,
-0.7235902548,
-0.6228547692,
-0.4537085295,
-0.2744378448,
-0.3734072149,
-0.1908337921,
-0.4248546958,
-0.1301740557,
-0.4325639904,
-0.190820083,
-0.6554966569,
0.2949706912,
0.298874855,
0.4543842375,
-0.1590216309,
0.0839110315,
0.1582615077,
-0.0201379694,
0.1718599498,
-0.3199945986,
0.1656241715,
-0.603697896,
-0.4534189403,
-0.0124271661,
0.446220696,
0.9331259727,
-0.3236603141,
1.0033909082,
0.4069384634,
-0.5848298073,
0.2742801905,
-0.6445892453,
-0.061940264,
-0.4248396754,
0.3244614899,
-0.5037942529,
-0.9507194757,
0.7521982193,
0.1043130457,
-0.1406950802,
0.4282447398,
0.3973203897,
-0.3629547954,
1.1156349182,
0.4518234432,
0.09190128,
0.3509169221,
0.095536463,
0.0147054559,
-0.7526698709,
-0.0156745706,
-0.7019369602,
0.2637093365,
-0.6261891723,
-0.2545189857,
0.6004582047,
0.2767565548,
-0.3546223938,
0.2978894413,
-0.0567796342,
0.2771203518,
0.528929472,
0.0639541745,
0.3226284981,
-0.4793285728,
0.0549133606,
0.1437361389,
-0.329944253,
-0.3587917686,
1.185292244,
0.4865696728,
1.0318119526,
0.1698900014,
0.3040798306,
-0.2449938506,
0.4390885532,
-0.6592869163,
0.2068784237,
0.0779208988,
-1.0558228493,
-0.8447897434,
-0.1915225834,
-0.7232021093,
0.1954067498,
-0.3272090554,
-0.7960345745,
0.2677427232,
0.2415673435,
-0.6863816977,
0.2702379525,
-0.6061885357,
0.8911342025,
0.1714105159,
0.0245975833,
-0.0889732614,
-0.9790645838,
0.3132843971,
-0.513673842,
0.2062930018,
0.0886674672,
-0.019718498,
0.5111286044,
0.1431659162,
0.8167962432,
0.0474022031,
-0.2765271962,
0.4770057797,
0.1477640718,
0.5379005671,
0.3569622934,
-0.7699300647,
0.3126269281,
0.7377419472,
-0.1961454898,
-0.4917518795,
0.4918935299,
-0.6891760826,
-0.5447368026,
-0.4684099555,
-0.7070528269,
-0.6127973795,
0.2105702907,
0.3485476971,
0.259041965,
-0.0966968834,
0.2794064581,
0.65367347,
0.1132998243,
0.3824386299,
0.2178441286,
0.0745825917,
-0.4812711775,
0.4106043577,
0.1412110627,
0.7423953414,
0.4183515012,
0.3909006119,
-0.6950451732,
-0.7173438072,
-0.3026508987,
0.1715756804,
-0.7677205205,
-0.3290635943,
-0.4122672081,
-0.2735616863,
-0.5500559211,
-0.3431080878,
-0.4285162687,
-0.4535994828,
-0.0584308282,
-0.2274820805,
0.1290890723,
0.6948432326,
0.0690897033,
0.3314838409,
-0.9589561224,
0.2807916701,
0.4173243344,
0.7515479326,
-0.2857198417,
-0.3872282505,
-0.3403278589,
0.4462933242,
-0.2209138572,
-1.1214449406,
-0.0190695375,
0.1745337695,
0.6650673747,
0.3841197193,
0.5006619096,
0.5429827571,
-0.2978737056,
0.7093139291,
0.1220132858,
-0.9103523493,
0.5573515296,
-0.4508778155,
0.2129553407,
0.8142140508,
0.480576843,
-0.5190595388,
-0.8422546387,
-0.6233711839,
-0.5682560802,
0.4237295985,
0.0453064367,
-0.1060763225,
0.1235776916,
0.3908153474,
0.3424830437,
0.4264799356,
-0.8197191954,
-0.12772201,
-0.0915201679,
-0.1140178964,
-0.0983424634,
-0.4202663898,
0.1147690043,
-0.1053419784,
0.6548131108,
-0.2710365057,
0.3380598426,
-0.0360367633,
0.1169507056,
-0.3879748285,
0.4574691951,
0.6510533094,
0.8408486843,
-0.4663603902,
0.0379173532,
0.4522138834,
-0.6555401683,
0.2735297084,
-0.0109873889,
-0.1184506938,
-0.2452411354,
-0.0846799612,
0.3656240404,
-0.1996912062,
-0.7164006829,
0.5821672082,
-0.0278574545,
0.0264435522,
-0.6672530174,
-0.2626058161,
0.0719269067,
0.2234693766,
0.135722518,
0.3246159554,
0.1874266416,
-0.329059273,
0.4122872949,
0.6705292463,
-0.6188001633,
-0.3266681433,
0.8795285225,
-0.2039897293,
0.187463969,
0.2575010657,
0.113587074,
-0.4285995066,
0.586740613,
0.5654332042,
0.8784133196,
-0.6400635839,
0.2666746676,
0.4321567416,
0.1423977315,
-0.3530231714,
0.4262392819,
0.3416360915,
-0.8534261584,
-0.4468292296,
-0.6652013063,
-0.7083838582,
0.1132293195,
-0.8132596612,
0.175202623,
-0.1940893382,
-0.3854905963,
-0.1114692688,
-0.4115117788,
-0.3391681015,
0.3263938427,
0.2387937605,
0.8539248705,
-0.9214410186,
0.8451424241,
0.8580815196,
-0.2711620033,
-0.8805230856,
0.3992313445,
-0.3350350261,
-0.444819212,
0.4283665419,
0.01678361,
-0.199219346,
-0.2106706202,
-0.3198949397,
-1.2720024586,
0.9359103441,
0.5762860775,
-0.232640177,
-0.0230128057,
0.3097224236,
0.3489632905,
-0.1363301575,
0.3208538294,
0.3201171458,
0.7378419638,
0.3859207332,
-1.0730924606,
0.124936074,
0.323962003,
0.0201973487,
0.0914661586,
-0.589789629,
0.933924973,
-0.3498039544,
0.1162382141,
0.2745918632,
0.936399281,
0.3474320769,
0.2298564315,
0.5843221545,
-0.0270231962,
0.8617597818,
-0.049102217,
1.0040985346,
-0.4186967611,
0.5260974169,
0.8753700852,
-0.3249834478,
1.2097440958,
0.6361508369,
-0.1872940063,
0.3658251166,
0.7444183826,
0.3749613762,
0.4763904214,
-0.1888426691,
-0.1926488876,
-0.5535146594,
0.2122726589,
-0.4003211558,
0.3906044364,
0.4934106469,
0.0880182683,
0.0103982855,
0.0757839009,
-0.1195334494,
-0.068620339,
-0.2401903868,
0.5294695497,
-0.1063937247,
-0.8285520673,
0.479799509,
-0.1955741197,
0.4020412862,
-0.6051195264,
0.0758989006,
0.3184451163,
0.2706060112,
0.1025249884,
-1.2665141821,
0.4053513706,
-0.7387574911,
-0.1610032469,
-0.3441221714,
0.5898284316,
-0.646714747,
-0.4989218116,
-0.0003597837,
0.504372716,
-0.168486163,
-0.5149889588,
-0.4517637789,
-0.3754593134,
-0.3124518096,
-0.255602777,
0.2785726488,
0.4123630524,
-0.1650414467,
0.9393258691,
0.4219240844,
0.185970068,
0.1177706197,
-0.3588823974,
0.6537469625,
-0.3405602276,
-0.8575870395,
-0.5407401323,
0.5816867352,
0.1867432296,
-0.1723930091,
0.4161417484,
0.3421072662,
0.5333500504,
-0.4301583171,
0.9935950041,
0.1506924927,
0.4530879259,
-0.5079152584,
0.6559225917,
-0.2387712747,
-0.0621454418,
-0.325909555,
-0.8265267015,
-0.2894324064,
0.4641760588,
-0.2709574401,
0.0791286081,
0.8998516798,
0.5923830867,
-0.0630251318,
0.2339835465,
0.51903373,
0.0972771272,
0.2046499252,
0.5053998232,
0.8299919367,
-0.455046922,
0.6471102834,
-0.2892363667,
-0.0531644858,
-0.1413999349,
-0.8791448474,
-0.5892521143,
-1.1199890375,
-0.3715343475,
-0.5141334534,
-0.1176872328,
0.5605891347,
0.7744150162,
-1.2195439339,
-0.2501749992,
0.0022838351,
0.3080887794,
-0.4817919433,
-0.1697542369,
0.1491885483,
-0.1824926585,
-0.7627766728,
0.0639820173,
-0.0951117948,
0.5212649703,
-0.1553691477,
0.0084182862,
-0.3172937632,
0.2953739166,
0.3792756498,
0.3181883395,
-0.6394590735,
-0.5978221893,
0.2627297044,
-0.063506566,
-0.1415135264,
0.6190239191,
-0.4418501258,
0.2244039774,
0.4441381693,
0.5403959155,
0.3363561332,
0.2342962474,
0.8847024441,
-0.6125522256,
0.0972367078,
0.2192097008,
0.5195673704,
0.0450313911,
-0.5683040619,
0.1926925778,
-0.1554144025,
-0.6036017537,
-0.6421506405,
0.558778882,
-1.0946704149,
-0.1721224189,
1.480119586,
-0.3625669181,
-0.048852127,
-0.5119445324,
-0.1674453169,
0.039574787,
-0.4143981934,
0.6093705893,
0.9684324265,
-0.0162614975,
-0.1197934151,
-0.5784938335,
0.4965328872,
0.2861154377,
-0.7711935043,
0.341919452,
0.5321429968,
0.2026243955,
0.3294679523,
0.2950118184,
0.0425208248,
0.4021501243,
-0.3515562713,
-0.1918429732,
0.1383668482,
-0.3372232318,
-0.3143501282,
0.4815119505,
0.3863967657,
-0.1866779625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17750v1 | Reliable and Interpretable Drift Detection in Streams of Short Texts | 2023-05-28T15:14:54 | 2023-05-28T15:14:54 | Ella Rabinovich, Matan Vetzler, Samuel Ackerman, Ateret Anaby-Tavor | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data drift is the change in model input data that is one of the key factors
leading to machine learning models performance degradation over time.
Monitoring drift helps detecting these issues and preventing their harmful
consequences. Meaningful drift interpretation is a fundamental step towards
effective re-training of the model. In this study we propose an end-to-end
framework for reliable model-agnostic change-point detection and interpretation
in large task-oriented dialog systems, proven effective in multiple customer
deployments. We evaluate our approach and demonstrate its benefits with a novel
variant of intent classification training dataset, simulating customer requests
to a dialog system. We make the data publicly available. | [
0.0380240045,
-0.6364338398,
0.7092499733,
-0.1073749512,
-0.1442450881,
-0.2611550689,
0.0034215299,
-0.3081115186,
-0.2220899165,
0.5307415128,
-1.0239948034,
-0.5434774756,
-0.3707958162,
-0.1620382965,
-0.6576654911,
1.1839852333,
-0.1684809923,
-0.1326101124,
-0.2570202053,
-0.3541380465,
-0.4039925933,
-0.2670102715,
-0.7797473669,
-0.312802434,
0.2334576845,
0.0888175219,
0.6600934267,
0.5108415484,
0.2052394599,
0.2289044112,
-0.2069600821,
-0.0578012876,
-0.4601750374,
0.6674587131,
-0.2110413164,
-0.9597297311,
-0.4187225401,
-0.0733295679,
0.5242246389,
0.327404052,
-0.3686044514,
0.2967555225,
-0.0904881209,
0.4580683708,
-0.4313141406,
0.3263674676,
-0.762563765,
-0.213661477,
-0.2405703813,
-0.1812886596,
-0.801915884,
-0.086240463,
0.3604415953,
-0.6200639606,
0.4519088268,
-0.1291089058,
0.7538747787,
0.6716322899,
-0.4120709002,
-0.6135829687,
-0.5994498134,
0.8766032457,
-0.8705015779,
0.5646515489,
0.043143142,
0.4901590347,
-0.199665904,
-0.5762941837,
-0.5069506168,
-0.222903654,
0.2100632638,
0.0731980279,
-0.1044706106,
-0.1194985211,
0.1195027307,
0.2162409127,
-0.2687193155,
0.0601803102,
0.0545520894,
-0.1328812838,
0.6196883917,
0.5428944826,
0.1816955507,
0.0144332554,
-0.2135110497,
0.2520399988,
-0.579390347,
0.0969103277,
0.4543824792,
0.2656319439,
-0.228663221,
0.196110934,
-0.2820196748,
0.8253749609,
0.184510231,
0.0916420147,
0.2544105649,
-0.1435640901,
-0.2025891989,
-0.0519873239,
0.516815424,
0.5378918052,
-0.1662181318,
0.0034146125,
-0.2787981629,
0.0115466714,
0.3456942737,
-0.7179011106,
-0.1640431732,
0.2186503112,
-0.8051446676,
-0.4003443122,
-0.2652963102,
-0.458363235,
-0.4009186924,
-0.6032813787,
-0.0806624442,
-0.4393231571,
-0.4520220459,
0.0343880318,
-0.0476415753,
-0.0204792935,
0.6984739304,
-0.8181341887,
-0.0774019733,
0.822153151,
1.0686821938,
-0.3276468217,
-0.1048439518,
-0.332139045,
0.2114608735,
-0.1400744617,
0.8494562507,
-0.5845159888,
-0.2725200951,
-0.0420654938,
0.1888609082,
-0.3865469992,
-0.5865309238,
0.7101619244,
-0.6038144827,
0.3711763024,
0.1836317629,
-0.9470392466,
-0.2915438414,
0.3959909976,
-0.5007675886,
0.7201262116,
0.2786462307,
-0.5151736736,
0.5912494659,
-1.0249465704,
-0.1714441031,
0.0275255628,
0.1407114714,
-0.614325881,
0.2603523135,
-0.0889603794,
0.4542133212,
-0.0089485105,
0.2616144717,
-0.6270490289,
-0.0621513091,
0.4418533444,
-0.6687536836,
0.6619225144,
0.4310355186,
-0.2588679194,
0.1763620377,
-0.7198932767,
-0.0104055665,
-0.162201032,
-0.4271120727,
-0.1963662505,
0.4748731852,
0.0719755664,
0.1434841752,
0.1388075948,
-0.5151916742,
0.2847479582,
0.1017745212,
0.5738012791,
0.7041938305,
0.1513789147,
0.1304878294,
-0.3211630583,
0.478178978,
0.3114964068,
0.3409478664,
-0.5487064123,
-0.6854895949,
-0.5705785155,
-0.1064795554,
0.1319813728,
0.4579261541,
-0.4788869917,
0.285571456,
-0.4272738099,
-0.195533067,
-0.3960695565,
0.0815151557,
-0.0560357571,
0.6271150708,
0.1555920392,
0.0822588429,
-0.1888450086,
-0.4983914196,
-0.358201921,
-0.2542981803,
-0.299723804,
0.1938384771,
0.2211273909,
-0.8240434527,
1.1281243563,
-0.4476900399,
-0.0715442896,
-0.2551545799,
0.2942635715,
0.0246007517,
0.3199028671,
0.577670157,
-0.8631427288,
-0.5537497401,
-0.063214995,
-0.749106884,
-0.104507722,
-0.4410908818,
-0.0664851218,
0.3591049314,
0.6316912174,
-0.5607845187,
0.4942387044,
0.6376907825,
-0.5150722265,
0.4452168047,
0.184676975,
0.0306989215,
-0.9642444253,
-0.0627152249,
0.1560409069,
-0.5202696919,
-0.8763988614,
-0.5276636481,
-0.0228211246,
-0.0098570734,
-0.4106402993,
0.350959003,
0.1316657811,
0.0872500166,
-0.4437097907,
-0.2007643282,
-0.069511801,
0.1687780172,
0.1322988123,
0.4880194366,
0.4118671715,
-0.8924546838,
0.2954004705,
0.5421172976,
-0.3371241689,
1.0145947933,
-0.3934163153,
0.1727973223,
-0.202553302,
0.4626453221,
-0.7482583523,
-0.3598376513,
0.4022601843,
-0.7087164521,
0.0970644504,
-0.536860764,
0.0680731386,
0.1171378046,
0.1094354391,
-0.0223309547,
0.2657728195,
-0.541492939,
0.5018909574,
0.1729848385,
-0.0995167568,
-0.1837799251,
-0.5633825064,
-0.0662864521,
-0.2595494688,
-0.6040055752,
-0.0386768989,
-0.0256551225,
-0.1020514295,
0.0877925232,
-0.2148521245,
-0.2006683052,
0.2773396373,
0.4025627375,
0.1187972203,
-0.0831132308,
0.328458488,
0.02581634,
-0.2009930611,
0.2489050478,
-0.5040977597,
0.4558472633,
0.0631375089,
-0.5041775703,
-0.9145755172,
0.1425107121,
1.0510917902,
0.3155953884,
0.5235786438,
0.454888612,
-0.1628280133,
-0.4168549776,
-0.1753866225,
0.0488444343,
-0.4826506078,
0.2443672717,
-0.3011811078,
-0.6056609154,
0.6182397008,
-0.2460400313,
0.4013904929,
0.4375499785,
0.4458636045,
-0.3398498595,
1.2262847424,
0.6570764184,
-0.0056685545,
0.7504940629,
0.0358202606,
0.1332688183,
-0.8108101487,
-0.2308486402,
-0.2257539928,
-0.2941967249,
-0.2216771841,
-0.1958669871,
0.1551185548,
-0.1192014217,
0.1186916456,
-0.0046557286,
-0.2365435362,
0.1179705635,
0.1094468907,
0.1133378819,
0.3307840228,
-0.1446899921,
0.4690529704,
0.0281575266,
-0.2619202137,
-0.5366578102,
1.2193281651,
0.581599474,
0.8033953905,
0.1368669122,
0.3441273272,
0.6556143165,
0.5021939874,
-0.8417791724,
0.289398849,
0.280110985,
-0.7250537872,
-0.4558775425,
-0.5768744946,
-0.7359433174,
0.0395596176,
0.2454619259,
-0.7316110134,
0.1009964272,
0.6163552403,
0.0035643249,
0.3752780259,
-0.7039732933,
1.035250783,
-0.1837354302,
0.0952646732,
-0.3725686371,
-0.2488501966,
0.207778424,
0.0259426683,
-0.0147114359,
-0.4595708847,
0.0301369578,
0.6897012591,
-0.4667422473,
0.7827224135,
-0.607719481,
-0.2168394923,
0.4837388694,
0.0893797278,
0.7066808343,
0.2227583826,
-0.1367546767,
0.1388341784,
-0.1310228556,
-0.4058105052,
-0.7658174038,
0.4568244815,
-0.4764171839,
-0.1213202924,
-0.1166655049,
-0.5332401395,
-0.2573353648,
0.0064672166,
0.4583848715,
0.4095412791,
0.0213955212,
0.2020523697,
0.8263349533,
0.2128848881,
0.2688923776,
0.6004395485,
-0.2747704387,
0.2726273239,
0.9212485552,
-0.1548739523,
0.5370102525,
0.1728907824,
-0.020586662,
-0.5082296729,
-0.9229372144,
-0.7012777328,
-0.225182265,
-0.7852147818,
0.0224005729,
-0.5814927816,
0.0860951617,
-0.1161056533,
-0.1503312588,
-0.5429869294,
-0.2123838216,
-0.374571085,
-0.0040750243,
0.3658359349,
0.8087967634,
0.223003,
0.5096417665,
-0.7709349394,
-0.0135539798,
0.1706175655,
0.4151480198,
-0.302654773,
-0.6374095082,
-0.3059574068,
0.4440542161,
-0.2768827379,
-0.6915395856,
0.1587269753,
0.36832425,
0.6388682127,
0.6368405819,
-0.048947379,
0.138061434,
-0.1704482734,
0.8811733723,
0.2019989043,
-1.2248450518,
0.7640638947,
-0.7439659238,
0.7323615551,
0.7277032137,
0.3625873923,
-1.0549039841,
-0.304870069,
-0.5234731436,
-0.4947647154,
0.9037376642,
-0.1486272812,
0.027599683,
0.3118763566,
0.4730913341,
0.332182169,
0.35877496,
-0.5538358688,
-0.1607398242,
-0.3488503397,
-0.5829229355,
0.0280015487,
-0.0371020362,
0.0765532032,
0.0615957975,
0.6632583737,
-0.4990419447,
0.3951581717,
-0.188358441,
-0.4585919082,
-0.121671848,
0.3109572828,
0.5396570563,
0.924335897,
-0.2334126681,
-0.2520901263,
0.162269026,
-0.7893748879,
0.2283280492,
-0.281301856,
-0.68996948,
0.4764313698,
0.0692776218,
0.9308765531,
0.2600082755,
-0.7365592718,
0.5175817013,
-0.1355118006,
-0.12969096,
-0.3420644999,
0.2054509521,
-0.2140030116,
0.0409102328,
0.1737888753,
0.3119036555,
0.2869217098,
-0.645727098,
0.2664967477,
0.1466183364,
-0.9436656237,
-0.5457687974,
0.4594362974,
0.3127470911,
-0.2035456598,
0.7186742425,
-0.3827020824,
-0.6437856555,
0.2840756774,
0.2197490782,
0.8318451047,
-0.6055813432,
0.5139018297,
-0.0273180567,
-0.0394600704,
0.0025314083,
0.0940869823,
-0.094697848,
-0.6921121478,
-0.4399543405,
-0.349642396,
-0.6198088527,
0.3861173093,
-0.8725367188,
0.4529179633,
-0.3022301495,
-0.1062706485,
0.0389689729,
-0.6591066718,
-0.3372786045,
0.1353875548,
0.3485734165,
0.729390204,
-0.9003130794,
0.6798679233,
0.7385743856,
0.3011801839,
-0.2681936324,
0.1605707109,
0.390907824,
-0.5468316674,
0.5172258019,
0.2874905169,
-0.1339639276,
-0.3234658241,
-0.6719532013,
-0.9053723812,
0.9296639562,
0.1025320888,
-0.6013879776,
-0.0602970533,
0.0932783186,
0.5235430598,
-0.3932456672,
0.3908871114,
0.6690243483,
0.1113376096,
0.1107639968,
-0.802013576,
-0.2082542628,
-0.0463605635,
-0.185882628,
0.498106122,
-0.5716365576,
0.7919524312,
0.2063567787,
-0.3988322914,
-0.2345209122,
0.598405838,
-0.113009207,
0.800717473,
0.7386519909,
0.6623170972,
0.9142285585,
-0.2483910322,
0.6100506783,
-0.2848479748,
0.5690026879,
1.0168452263,
-0.3058859408,
0.8083250523,
0.073381193,
0.08168827,
0.7057192326,
0.7001470923,
0.1123300344,
0.6445980668,
-0.0359587781,
-0.3787963688,
-0.3793745041,
-0.0277191419,
-0.2348601818,
0.31907022,
0.925022006,
-0.3123544753,
-0.4022847414,
0.248051405,
0.1921681315,
-0.3752171099,
-0.5279286504,
0.6657471657,
-0.1628319323,
-0.7239322066,
0.4716150761,
-0.3404895365,
0.7458565831,
-0.4933235943,
0.1771125793,
0.2466579527,
0.5673567653,
-0.3449652195,
-0.6776355505,
0.4440476,
-0.0019049722,
-0.3630851507,
-0.2816164792,
0.6382598877,
-0.1750003994,
-0.1291529238,
-0.0572011471,
0.0981251523,
0.0519969277,
-0.1249649152,
-0.9767468572,
0.3041023612,
0.3678617775,
-0.3439516127,
0.1633846164,
0.2626781166,
-0.14134942,
1.0219599009,
0.5076776147,
-0.3864634633,
0.2756252289,
-0.0315970369,
0.5972083807,
-0.3829070628,
-0.768610239,
-0.4996089637,
0.6647076607,
-0.3220554888,
-0.5760948658,
0.6370626092,
0.3388680816,
0.7023001909,
0.0872834772,
1.192171216,
-0.0286645629,
0.9006399512,
-0.6062444448,
0.454331398,
-0.2123470753,
0.2348403931,
0.2778297961,
-0.8573613763,
0.2584216893,
0.3877501786,
-0.4711377323,
-0.2163272798,
0.4974745214,
0.2586904466,
-0.1442511529,
0.6148836613,
-0.0004354691,
0.0642166957,
0.7590802312,
0.3768630326,
1.2705520391,
-0.2603566647,
0.4515195787,
0.1632206589,
-0.0645349324,
-0.5888873935,
-0.6034613848,
-0.8020609617,
-0.6550941467,
-0.6088204384,
-0.2247066349,
-0.0491581298,
0.5825330019,
0.9626566768,
-0.932238996,
0.0253273509,
-0.3754231334,
-0.0204495229,
-0.1938466877,
-0.2580695152,
-0.0215700027,
-0.744140625,
-0.6551089287,
0.423463136,
0.2928022742,
0.1987812966,
-0.2650544941,
-0.1656387299,
0.0621899702,
-0.1042315438,
0.4192047715,
0.4159425497,
-0.5234826207,
-0.3217938244,
-0.0942516178,
0.1231561601,
-0.0091109201,
0.991810143,
-0.4871361554,
0.4154633582,
0.279964298,
0.5658012629,
0.7320774794,
0.0535381176,
0.5482817292,
-0.5786650777,
0.1813637912,
0.3369513452,
0.179003045,
0.3723211884,
-0.4783418775,
0.2756059468,
0.2135582417,
-0.6711464524,
-0.8452321291,
0.4935596287,
-0.8132615685,
-0.2357968539,
1.0505322218,
-0.4487033188,
-0.2974645197,
-0.6110104918,
0.0279557221,
-0.1314378083,
-0.5196200609,
0.5970923305,
0.7135965228,
-0.5118240118,
-0.1217287257,
-0.8160800338,
0.7645702362,
0.4504406154,
-0.9447122216,
0.2620417178,
0.7008969188,
0.4642188847,
0.3859870732,
0.3163335025,
0.2664161623,
0.2134809941,
-0.1287717372,
-0.3802961707,
0.0092736017,
-0.2921168506,
-0.4330221117,
-0.0485602058,
0.017702492,
-0.3674272597
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.