id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18320v1 | Cognitive network science reveals bias in GPT-3, ChatGPT, and GPT-4 mirroring math anxiety in high-school students | 2023-05-22T15:06:51 | 2023-05-22T15:06:51 | Katherine Abramski, Salvatore Citraro, Luigi Lombardi, Giulio Rossetti, Massimo Stella | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models are becoming increasingly integrated into our lives.
Hence, it is important to understand the biases present in their outputs in
order to avoid perpetuating harmful stereotypes, which originate in our own
flawed ways of thinking. This challenge requires developing new benchmarks and
methods for quantifying affective and semantic bias, keeping in mind that LLMs
act as psycho-social mirrors that reflect the views and tendencies that are
prevalent in society. One such tendency that has harmful negative effects is
the global phenomenon of anxiety toward math and STEM subjects. Here, we
investigate perceptions of math and STEM fields provided by cutting-edge
language models, namely GPT-3, Chat-GPT, and GPT-4, by applying an approach
from network science and cognitive psychology. Specifically, we use behavioral
forma mentis networks (BFMNs) to understand how these LLMs frame math and STEM
disciplines in relation to other concepts. We use data obtained by probing the
three LLMs in a language generation task that has previously been applied to
humans. Our findings indicate that LLMs have an overall negative perception of
math and STEM fields, with math being perceived most negatively. We observe
significant differences across the three LLMs. We observe that newer versions
(i.e. GPT-4) produce richer, more complex perceptions as well as less negative
perceptions compared to older versions and N=159 high-school students. These
findings suggest that advances in the architecture of LLMs may lead to
increasingly less biased models that could even perhaps someday aid in reducing
harmful stereotypes in society rather than perpetuating them. | [
-0.6088362336,
-1.0326502323,
0.4935946167,
0.3178710938,
0.0741549954,
0.2795946002,
-0.0402691923,
-0.397452563,
0.4463461936,
0.1745945364,
-0.7124683261,
-0.3625436127,
-0.7682667375,
0.012295967,
-0.3634855449,
0.9392948151,
-0.0615174398,
0.6175028086,
-0.3177983165,
0.2218462974,
-0.4032593668,
-1.0058908463,
-0.6555607319,
-0.724229753,
0.2848244011,
-0.0731665194,
0.9357084632,
0.0027144293,
0.78692168,
0.1348557323,
0.0006791726,
-0.3797048628,
-0.4847415686,
0.22198838,
-0.1100789011,
-0.6192278266,
-0.5148091912,
0.2015997767,
0.4311314523,
1.0654691458,
0.0774921253,
0.0320195891,
0.186844483,
0.7621133924,
-0.3564738631,
0.305080682,
-0.5475338697,
0.2743477821,
-0.2911480069,
-0.0037806442,
-0.0154631818,
-0.3546998501,
0.3846681714,
-0.7811645865,
0.2834726572,
-0.0720013604,
1.003313899,
0.1148563921,
-0.5072792172,
-0.1176657975,
-0.5377086997,
0.7470075488,
-0.2308046222,
0.3921594322,
0.5122309923,
0.192932561,
-0.2538461983,
-0.2680961788,
-0.327075392,
0.0591523014,
0.324095577,
0.4484166205,
-0.4990169704,
0.1142080948,
0.321270436,
0.1870695949,
-0.3140267432,
0.0030353861,
-0.7675760388,
-0.4405809343,
0.2104954273,
0.1754578948,
0.5019930005,
-0.0585227348,
-0.1047236919,
0.0149030797,
-0.9389083982,
-0.2146570086,
0.4995264113,
0.1085680798,
0.0156554263,
0.6186900735,
0.1312408596,
0.4255112708,
-0.1855299622,
0.258267045,
0.2590033114,
-0.050787285,
-0.2135066837,
-0.1556546092,
0.771464169,
0.422068119,
0.6965283751,
0.1208288148,
0.1745463461,
0.7787652612,
0.2015637904,
-0.6964617372,
0.0555114858,
-0.4076935053,
-0.2293802649,
-0.3663251996,
-0.2110110223,
-0.7112643123,
-0.361335963,
-0.5204345584,
0.2376796156,
-0.4536114633,
-0.3064132929,
0.1136353239,
0.0773359016,
-0.0572245605,
0.4509857893,
-0.6264923215,
0.6199609637,
0.7653458118,
0.9581286907,
-0.559456706,
-0.2573317289,
0.1681813598,
-0.2444463223,
-0.4538996518,
0.5630094409,
-0.7009711862,
-0.5211966038,
-0.1555586159,
-0.3503186405,
-0.1065859497,
-0.472650528,
0.4801405072,
-0.476193428,
0.3680357039,
-0.3515858948,
-0.3223662078,
-0.0259549674,
0.41388309,
-0.641613245,
1.06978333,
0.0752887428,
-0.642655313,
0.0087094391,
-0.6929709911,
-0.235110268,
-0.378561765,
-0.6279599667,
-0.3025821447,
0.2469275594,
0.1515400261,
0.2762333453,
-0.6219971776,
0.3536303341,
-0.6801949143,
-0.3320656717,
0.5882220268,
-0.6368578076,
0.8425071239,
0.2685909271,
-0.4054040015,
-0.2204301953,
-0.0338639766,
-0.2470643669,
0.0485505462,
0.1099651605,
-0.5748748779,
-0.1590021253,
-0.4338631928,
0.574375689,
0.0110101542,
-0.4826286137,
-0.071966283,
-0.3761137724,
0.5286847949,
0.9644365311,
0.1210497171,
0.3169800043,
-0.2434643656,
0.6093285084,
0.3830735385,
0.2423610687,
0.2889536917,
-0.7827857733,
-0.5351060033,
0.1103520691,
-0.3430236876,
0.3155092299,
-0.5890171528,
-0.1108238026,
-0.2733609974,
-0.2424750775,
-0.1489668936,
0.0755153,
0.3180184364,
0.4995851517,
0.2495878339,
-0.3227416575,
-0.3870799243,
-1.0407761335,
-0.5540968776,
-0.0440079831,
-0.0340557843,
0.3538269699,
0.5659128428,
-0.1637651026,
0.9958301187,
-0.7690155506,
-0.4835840166,
0.2308108211,
0.0906003639,
0.1525945514,
0.2546729743,
0.4397879541,
-0.5938898921,
-0.2975583375,
-0.3971047103,
-0.7366651893,
-0.1452333033,
0.2691804171,
-0.4078526795,
-0.041961655,
0.2361315638,
-0.5019189119,
0.5019922256,
0.5909548402,
-0.5587430596,
0.4882600605,
0.4354965389,
-0.1548354179,
-1.0621746778,
-0.432867229,
0.5217109919,
0.3602048159,
-0.4660900831,
-0.313598603,
-0.400657922,
-0.2284944206,
-0.1089793444,
0.5685737729,
-0.5827906132,
-0.2903366387,
-0.1323494762,
0.2266795635,
0.0154217184,
0.4359567463,
-0.0874762982,
0.7456632853,
1.0121127367,
-0.3352340758,
0.0753466338,
-0.1760889292,
-0.1523093283,
0.5763693452,
-0.4172818363,
-0.11450544,
-0.1038044393,
0.4311878085,
-0.7868905663,
-0.0974495932,
0.195621714,
-0.5721658468,
-0.112254709,
0.132838726,
-0.1377810985,
-0.4718528688,
-0.1561307013,
0.5629000664,
0.6104978919,
-0.0759767517,
0.5047966242,
0.4819574058,
-0.1861193329,
-0.4794946909,
-0.873770535,
0.0659115985,
-0.1721135229,
-0.5920465589,
0.2015036941,
0.1093335226,
-0.7658129334,
-0.0521700829,
-0.451756686,
-0.3083949983,
0.0663204491,
0.6341406107,
0.5846722126,
-0.2277604491,
0.1597966701,
-0.0260022059,
-0.0417538844,
0.5338667631,
-0.5448836684,
0.4663186371,
-0.5963118076,
-0.6130435467,
0.0121730324,
0.0523237698,
0.6255232096,
-0.0792630613,
0.3099446297,
0.3060439825,
-0.5593809485,
-0.0003486398,
-0.4946234822,
-0.596546948,
-0.389719516,
0.4189161062,
-0.3731349707,
-1.14252913,
0.4516524971,
-0.0116966013,
-0.3332052529,
0.3401161432,
0.7149299383,
-0.0325110331,
0.99387151,
0.1371200383,
-0.1925448775,
0.66295892,
-0.3110909462,
0.2313466966,
-0.9413238764,
0.0725928172,
-0.3526473045,
-0.2900494933,
-0.4447490573,
-0.5429906249,
0.6179546714,
-0.0678841099,
-0.3586054146,
-0.3503007591,
-0.4834032059,
0.4602124393,
0.4420759976,
0.1738711149,
0.1419305503,
0.4445826709,
-0.1566615105,
-0.5057865381,
-0.3024926782,
-0.339305222,
1.4655203819,
0.3210101128,
0.7442298532,
0.1440284848,
0.4782694876,
0.1690976024,
0.7486299276,
-0.7094168067,
0.4879726171,
-0.006603248,
-1.0551044941,
-0.2050623894,
-0.4886373281,
-0.9523815513,
0.2443695515,
-0.2437166721,
-0.8934134841,
0.164304316,
0.1010922268,
-0.1196771562,
0.3456105888,
-0.4447769225,
0.3896631896,
-0.1341383606,
-0.6995143294,
-0.2642314732,
-0.5083467364,
0.7562225461,
-0.2193302214,
0.524810493,
-0.3418532014,
0.3017876446,
0.6652597785,
-0.3960451782,
1.0431857109,
-0.0760454834,
-0.1374554783,
0.6046386361,
0.4189076126,
0.1704953164,
-0.0178876147,
-0.2096153647,
0.4897119403,
-0.1804047525,
-0.3547876477,
-0.6423463225,
0.8474106193,
-1.3841862679,
-0.5905564427,
-0.5965117812,
-0.5730219483,
-0.3808289766,
0.2103071362,
0.2516207993,
0.4607423544,
-0.1242228746,
-0.0720408484,
0.7292026281,
0.0094074542,
0.1220431551,
0.1182614043,
-0.4997791052,
-0.3633691967,
1.0011668205,
0.460247606,
0.458012104,
0.0754638389,
0.3576103151,
-0.0705643594,
-0.1571081281,
0.1474658102,
0.3186566532,
-0.67557621,
-0.0646523759,
-0.5570056438,
-0.2525834143,
-0.3947563171,
-0.2769309282,
-0.2993465066,
-0.5335597396,
-0.2243775427,
-0.331586957,
0.3029887974,
0.7507764697,
0.0966228768,
0.4998509586,
-0.0525826328,
0.0120142959,
0.2259914279,
0.4388456345,
-0.0330315791,
-0.2743827105,
-0.0397252589,
0.1009837314,
-0.6155021191,
-0.8053882122,
0.2465387732,
-0.0736640692,
0.1931981593,
0.497920543,
-0.1660953164,
0.3734337986,
-0.2031666189,
0.8332727551,
0.390029937,
-0.9703943729,
0.0585552827,
-0.5972976089,
-0.1864891946,
0.165738821,
0.358400315,
-0.4744355381,
-0.4660561383,
-0.63585639,
-0.513024509,
0.4100477993,
0.3065152764,
0.130016461,
-0.2137119174,
0.3981737792,
-0.1752829701,
0.0643386766,
-0.8534157276,
-0.407309562,
-0.6809135079,
-0.1564051956,
0.0371532887,
0.0469795242,
-0.2469653636,
-0.2105613202,
0.481207937,
-0.0537517071,
0.4801174998,
0.0994813889,
0.0641474947,
-0.1174026206,
0.3308695853,
0.6321487427,
0.5696585178,
-0.2036091238,
0.4614523053,
0.1563776731,
-0.9262321591,
0.4158047736,
-0.1651302725,
-0.0736386478,
-0.1654610336,
0.2396453023,
0.8636289239,
0.0348194093,
-0.1123951152,
0.6661965847,
0.0330074057,
-0.4002277255,
-0.515365541,
-0.1793269515,
0.1103813872,
-0.1973638982,
0.4204340875,
0.3743045628,
0.0999565572,
-0.4948201478,
-0.0708761588,
0.4744501412,
-0.6516476274,
-0.7015101314,
0.5139016509,
0.139260307,
-0.0688294098,
0.4517821372,
0.1613042951,
-0.6027128696,
0.6956608295,
0.7984740734,
0.8922347426,
-0.018653322,
0.1958055049,
0.2864187956,
0.3788241446,
-0.0720861852,
0.1736195236,
0.4504980147,
-1.1228786707,
-0.2968901694,
-0.5347746015,
-0.4140838385,
-0.0096413698,
-0.6843689084,
-0.0071142926,
-0.5035118461,
-0.6879043579,
-0.3260857165,
-0.1584700495,
-0.8078652024,
0.31340307,
0.1388299763,
0.5710839629,
-0.9721745849,
0.7272284031,
0.9417390823,
-0.1939905733,
-0.865131557,
-0.0985416844,
0.5550922751,
-0.9787526727,
0.9612942338,
0.0837707594,
-0.3899084926,
-0.0381080918,
-0.3710099459,
-1.1914155483,
0.8756250739,
0.1778932363,
-0.4230137169,
-0.3030287325,
0.3960030377,
0.6245949864,
-0.4179803133,
0.5141735077,
0.4304481745,
0.3624121547,
0.0468906909,
-0.5382671356,
-0.0247359388,
-0.2973409593,
0.0080887284,
0.3106296659,
-0.6183221936,
1.3445408344,
0.0240356084,
0.0480090231,
-0.6251941323,
0.4244519174,
0.4419052005,
0.2663455307,
0.2746835351,
0.3725687861,
0.5517142415,
-0.3623206913,
0.8643182516,
-0.4863989651,
0.1648264825,
0.8357676864,
-0.3288943768,
0.3387471437,
0.7382329702,
-0.3191190064,
0.4735746086,
0.6283830404,
0.1971901804,
-0.0301557239,
0.7325977087,
-0.2123874277,
-0.204592362,
-0.1578069925,
-0.4597952664,
0.2077634335,
0.8327924609,
-0.2054116875,
-0.1562114805,
0.0751083121,
0.5477176309,
-0.0634528175,
-0.3965840638,
0.2649341226,
0.4338074625,
-0.5667666197,
0.2884700596,
-0.2273339778,
0.771066606,
-0.6058746576,
0.1492093801,
-0.4243561924,
0.2278327048,
-0.1545232236,
-0.7130876184,
0.1930846274,
-0.0382645093,
-0.1688595861,
-0.1807345748,
0.7082638144,
-0.0294803381,
-0.6589378119,
0.4449931979,
0.82996732,
0.3793523014,
-0.2104174644,
-0.6401954889,
0.2051440626,
-0.0340251029,
-0.3389844596,
0.4836783409,
0.4113927186,
-0.6671857834,
0.7330549359,
0.5772192478,
0.4541279674,
0.2459130287,
0.2087287903,
0.8994054198,
-0.572448194,
-0.2185641825,
-1.1502227783,
-0.0460847728,
0.0309160892,
-0.4561410248,
0.8310289979,
0.4305842519,
0.7903695703,
0.2175082713,
1.0836112499,
0.4311805069,
0.2175540328,
-0.222705707,
0.4476744533,
-0.209104836,
0.3817872107,
-0.7425148487,
-1.0025770664,
-0.4116423428,
0.4961036444,
-0.8449706435,
0.1511577368,
0.8053521514,
0.565684557,
-0.0012685101,
0.1317915618,
0.1132286265,
0.2107604146,
0.5625644326,
0.5800912976,
0.8893323541,
-0.0975485742,
0.4311228693,
-0.2522904575,
-0.4109106064,
-0.014481049,
-0.534588635,
-1.0056937933,
-0.2750717103,
-0.1407144517,
-0.5590911508,
-0.0987827331,
0.9340245724,
0.3557186425,
-0.4027116597,
-0.5666334033,
-0.2756305933,
0.3261544406,
-0.0898162648,
-0.3070277274,
0.4280726314,
-0.1832422316,
-0.4058836102,
-0.0712948442,
0.2452891469,
0.2903960049,
-0.5358493328,
-0.080556117,
0.2074532658,
0.2462155372,
0.5417412519,
-0.0315168723,
-0.8076609969,
-0.1801906824,
0.3805048764,
-0.2278411239,
0.1743545681,
0.8699548841,
-0.6450583935,
0.2916767895,
0.2003466934,
0.4533702731,
0.3926620483,
-0.1033056229,
0.7345185876,
-0.2419740111,
-0.1248712242,
0.1549481302,
0.4014728665,
0.2294234633,
-0.2762569189,
0.6692688465,
0.6570160389,
-0.3415446579,
-0.8209865093,
0.421795249,
-0.4618779123,
-0.3156232834,
0.8951169848,
0.0961051881,
-0.1612448245,
0.0367807858,
-0.1353545487,
0.0845114961,
-0.4946821928,
0.7954292297,
1.0506814718,
-0.4548204541,
0.1559058875,
-0.8469057679,
0.4932724237,
0.8042128086,
-0.7425646186,
-0.0834050253,
0.5095642209,
0.2851344049,
0.3033499122,
0.5494976044,
-0.2653408945,
-0.0550304018,
-0.1046636999,
0.2770495117,
0.0044470099,
-0.1236988828,
-0.1800031215,
0.1249572709,
-0.1450818479,
0.3018231392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18319v1 | Automated Feedback Generation for a Chemistry Database and Abstracting Exercise | 2023-05-22T15:04:26 | 2023-05-22T15:04:26 | Oscar Morris, Russell Morris | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Timely feedback is an important part of teaching and learning. Here we
describe how a readily available neural network transformer (machine-learning)
model (BERT) can be used to give feedback on the structure of the response to
an abstracting exercise where students are asked to summarise the contents of a
published article after finding it from a publication database. The dataset
contained 207 submissions from two consecutive years of the course, summarising
a total of 21 different papers from the primary literature. The model was
pre-trained using an available dataset (approx. 15,000 samples) and then
fine-tuned on 80% of the submitted dataset. This fine tuning was seen to be
important. The sentences in the student submissions are characterised into
three classes - background, technique and observation - which allows a
comparison of how each submission is structured. Comparing the structure of the
students' abstract a large collection of those from the PubMed database shows
that students in this exercise concentrate more on the background to the paper
and less on the techniques and results than the abstracts to papers themselves.
The results allowed feedback for each submitted assignment to be automatically
generated. | [
-0.2060293406,
-0.5576758385,
0.5735656619,
0.1969184279,
0.0691053718,
0.0432645306,
-0.1955182403,
-0.3463428319,
0.2768884897,
0.1672479957,
-0.5509020686,
-0.4442908466,
-0.1409203112,
0.4979739487,
-0.7355583906,
1.4987251759,
-0.1544523388,
0.4895063043,
-0.3752751052,
0.1995147616,
-0.2204652429,
-0.4059354961,
-0.4372122288,
-0.5818743706,
0.7263460755,
0.3007026911,
0.0651574656,
0.3602140248,
0.5695798397,
0.4215776324,
-0.0210454464,
-0.1146015301,
-0.1898498535,
0.2109896392,
-0.4371265471,
-0.6956772208,
-0.4243567586,
-0.1001652405,
0.4057035744,
1.0895998478,
0.2011911124,
0.2509153187,
0.2150323689,
1.0482032299,
-0.4161759019,
0.2890982628,
-0.3488314748,
0.2139801085,
0.4298832417,
0.2890990674,
-0.6202833652,
-0.4160788655,
0.334876895,
-0.34113729,
0.4608606398,
-0.3312748671,
0.8097214699,
-0.0050923293,
-0.082464546,
-0.5947054029,
-0.6928424835,
0.476919502,
-0.570381999,
-0.067061536,
-0.0048532463,
0.4359292984,
-0.0254972354,
-0.9376751781,
-0.442460537,
-0.3426222503,
-0.1570565999,
0.2636101246,
0.3702217638,
0.2717575133,
-0.0524453223,
0.2666811645,
-0.3357950151,
-0.3571246862,
-0.4836384654,
-0.1501009315,
0.8370136023,
0.1334473789,
0.0398206785,
-0.1992904991,
0.0461973622,
-0.1310130656,
-0.3600462377,
-0.01392252,
0.4729972482,
0.4800497591,
0.2381612957,
0.6940122247,
0.0386868566,
0.7058454752,
0.2662644088,
0.3621582687,
0.2414876521,
-0.4814825058,
0.0799256787,
0.286203742,
0.6063047051,
0.2573023736,
0.0592000969,
-0.1738789082,
-0.4853617251,
0.1858190447,
0.5600163341,
-0.9043655396,
-0.6876347065,
0.3147505522,
-0.5654863119,
-0.4050218463,
0.0525736436,
-0.5723984241,
0.0855080783,
-0.654153347,
0.6377301216,
-0.1765432656,
-0.0135004278,
-0.3935491741,
-0.2725830674,
-0.3284236789,
0.5805087686,
-0.8733900189,
0.4972402155,
0.2651193738,
0.7973692417,
-0.3464901447,
-0.0905081928,
-0.0767208263,
-0.0473384149,
-0.0742356405,
0.7797910571,
-0.4569178522,
-0.3374841809,
-0.1993054748,
0.1524708718,
0.1153782979,
-0.5686115026,
0.1105937138,
-0.5009069443,
0.401029408,
0.0508789122,
-0.8534860015,
-0.0948989615,
0.2269813716,
-0.6394271851,
0.8268756866,
0.4269588292,
-0.436103195,
0.1564337611,
-1.0685112476,
-0.3864769936,
-0.2388490289,
-0.2468618006,
-0.7420303822,
0.1632988006,
0.2636346817,
0.1859120131,
0.4945426285,
0.0929362848,
-0.1712060124,
-0.2159198076,
0.469304055,
0.3447552919,
0.5022398829,
0.2742220759,
-0.379740119,
0.3649776876,
-1.0733889341,
0.369071275,
-0.2627880275,
-0.6513279676,
0.1184956729,
-0.1439731419,
0.2829432786,
0.2367519289,
-0.0201378614,
-0.698402822,
0.2343865335,
-0.4076034427,
0.4977191389,
0.8075573444,
0.2261200398,
0.331682384,
-0.4001265466,
0.2024580687,
0.0436012633,
-0.223741889,
-0.4134326577,
-0.1972165406,
-0.7089455724,
0.1246837378,
0.8087958694,
0.3006628752,
-0.5492821336,
0.561326623,
-0.0525391065,
-0.4986951351,
-0.4799618125,
0.3254792988,
0.2346869111,
0.5048488379,
0.2659526467,
-0.5608920455,
-0.8842113614,
-0.7396062613,
-0.1966241747,
-0.2794503272,
-0.3541917205,
0.1600622982,
0.7832118273,
-0.2031762302,
1.118935585,
-0.3864034712,
-0.1854422688,
-0.2673197389,
0.4492125213,
0.3207458258,
0.6057220101,
0.3884542584,
-0.4736113846,
-0.4902469814,
-0.3634310961,
-0.7443495989,
-0.2279659957,
-0.1820732355,
-0.1554976702,
0.3327151835,
0.3721062541,
-0.2253200412,
0.257755667,
0.1549719572,
0.0005189547,
0.5821159482,
-0.1120413095,
-0.121698007,
-0.870436132,
0.2103699744,
-0.1001831591,
-0.2346796989,
-0.2110372186,
-0.1627815813,
-0.0366490148,
-0.3391282558,
-0.4507092834,
0.1611196697,
-0.3543414176,
0.0825655758,
-0.4738443494,
-0.2530246675,
-0.0987014323,
0.3730351925,
0.2137745768,
0.4811890125,
0.1646630615,
-0.9284369946,
0.3645549119,
0.2088512033,
-0.2523683608,
0.3471331596,
-0.977530241,
0.3062987626,
-0.2120614797,
0.4588456154,
-1.340544939,
-0.5002410412,
-0.2053352892,
-0.8008165359,
0.261773169,
-0.0778162777,
-0.2288466543,
-0.5252384543,
-0.3585146368,
0.0051552537,
0.3378937244,
-0.3612738848,
0.8845020533,
0.1031107157,
-0.241950199,
-0.4584949613,
-0.6663661003,
-0.162632972,
0.3354815245,
-0.5927496552,
0.152180925,
-0.2011626363,
-0.0805976689,
0.2221937776,
-0.0211238526,
-0.1988373399,
0.0153953889,
0.4373111427,
0.2925015688,
0.0434917249,
0.4111863673,
-0.0248093382,
0.0403773002,
0.6824391484,
-0.3267953694,
0.3553606272,
-0.2037991285,
-0.1914773136,
-0.5201885104,
0.3305845559,
0.5565013289,
0.2608768642,
0.5379217267,
0.2939707935,
-0.1476216167,
-0.3240497112,
0.0090547213,
-0.7582547069,
-0.4666258693,
0.4605352283,
0.0517960638,
-0.3983291388,
0.6347166896,
-0.0847978294,
0.2857945263,
0.6161627173,
0.956703186,
-0.5943004489,
1.0051976442,
0.6704558134,
0.0644367859,
0.575931251,
-0.514544189,
0.1279494166,
-0.3818602264,
-0.3927591443,
-0.5870251656,
-0.6910800338,
-0.2122281194,
0.247520119,
0.5576800108,
-0.3507103026,
-0.1965206265,
0.0826954395,
-0.8506902456,
0.5198498368,
0.6113089919,
0.5441675186,
0.1193874776,
0.1850255877,
-0.3397423029,
-0.0971304104,
-0.6335527301,
-0.4503087103,
1.5545079708,
0.1672805101,
0.9767041802,
0.0146532282,
0.9234957695,
0.4028434455,
0.7626190782,
-0.9031965137,
0.4868391752,
0.2979429066,
-0.6898024082,
-0.161066547,
-0.4762611687,
-0.9073018432,
-0.0404483229,
-0.2136487663,
-0.1690123379,
-0.1331270486,
0.1686407924,
-0.3088186085,
0.1456069052,
-0.7377563715,
0.4025166929,
-0.1041303948,
-0.6405621171,
0.0939311981,
-1.0229108334,
0.0348139666,
0.0190327428,
0.1788585186,
0.3554794192,
0.3922692537,
1.001704812,
-1.1008576155,
0.9536918402,
-0.3667152524,
-0.0216136258,
0.4683022499,
-0.1166513562,
0.0836920813,
0.0008031731,
-0.0026580524,
-0.5707322955,
0.0337653682,
-0.4041691422,
-0.8181645274,
0.3794265091,
-0.932300806,
-0.2818465531,
-0.4137989879,
-0.7802407742,
0.0582683198,
0.2451627254,
0.3730653524,
0.1709203422,
0.1120109782,
0.0970259532,
0.6112040877,
0.1798969954,
0.5521121621,
0.6060259938,
-0.4772906005,
-0.4793841243,
0.8241240382,
0.2458145469,
0.1996685416,
0.1837948859,
0.0092195831,
-0.3384726048,
-0.4261611402,
-0.4822835326,
0.1146518216,
-0.8342229128,
-0.1889830381,
-0.7454180717,
-0.3656194508,
-0.5977269411,
-0.0825983733,
-0.338170439,
-0.8050531149,
-0.093418695,
-0.124525167,
0.1510558277,
0.9633329511,
-0.221613735,
0.2136073112,
-0.934559226,
-0.0637863204,
0.2708380222,
0.2833529711,
0.2010637969,
-0.2678851187,
-0.4360480309,
-0.0513859205,
-0.5587691069,
-0.9903607368,
0.2683876753,
0.3488641977,
0.301456213,
-0.0146468924,
-0.0107796555,
0.0479243994,
-0.4550788403,
1.0104538202,
0.0284519866,
-0.8621346951,
0.9991172552,
-0.2020326853,
0.3876237273,
0.7893759012,
0.4868287146,
-0.0191801302,
-0.6277284026,
-0.5257319808,
-1.0219074488,
0.4239040315,
0.2556435168,
0.1109006479,
0.1223662049,
0.6104342937,
0.0414579026,
0.4666839242,
-0.8867456913,
-0.3358164728,
-0.2590947747,
-0.4780909717,
0.5104656816,
0.062538363,
-0.3426911533,
-0.7102939487,
0.8067548871,
-0.2008179128,
0.393220067,
0.4306024611,
-0.1431146711,
-0.1446862519,
0.3686039746,
0.349483341,
0.8129851222,
-0.5632750988,
0.0591472648,
-0.0772724375,
-0.7780525088,
0.4568072855,
-0.0082930233,
-0.2142205983,
0.6468214393,
0.2425788641,
0.1422831416,
-0.3114165366,
-0.6044592857,
0.2916764617,
-0.2007552832,
-0.5370748043,
-0.2643670738,
0.1977847964,
-0.265599519,
-0.1963651478,
0.5531545877,
0.2569403946,
0.4039224684,
-0.6099734902,
0.5235641003,
-0.091528751,
-0.3515025973,
-0.2372030914,
0.6629020572,
0.2226092666,
-0.0884104595,
0.6428741813,
0.1428584307,
-0.7269377708,
0.7770213485,
0.6260904074,
0.6984665394,
-0.269544512,
0.0691339523,
0.6226225495,
-0.0520257093,
0.1115958318,
0.4324768186,
-0.191155538,
-0.2232003957,
-0.3217177093,
-0.351464659,
-0.7479067445,
-0.1174073517,
-0.9774968028,
0.0840112567,
-0.5687583685,
-0.2626182437,
0.3375095725,
0.1007471532,
-0.2864120603,
0.3366542161,
-0.2600603402,
0.7103511095,
-1.0635678768,
0.5178793073,
1.192712903,
-0.6081936955,
-0.8744933605,
-0.3150250018,
0.0613186173,
-0.2445114255,
1.0802918673,
0.1243536919,
0.0222263075,
-0.1812586188,
-0.8002305031,
-0.6421436667,
0.652115941,
0.1709423512,
-0.4980210364,
-0.2253024876,
0.0627476275,
0.9271503687,
-0.2624421418,
0.6079604626,
0.3141095042,
0.2953176498,
0.1011268049,
-0.7576211691,
-0.106815435,
-0.8153313398,
-0.1256868243,
0.0101250196,
-0.2384382784,
0.9617019892,
-0.2279946506,
0.1390064359,
-0.0038203986,
0.8397152424,
0.2075654268,
0.2690458596,
0.4632281959,
0.5624402761,
0.7094646096,
-0.1811141372,
1.0016611814,
-0.2676915824,
0.429446429,
1.1844617128,
-0.0481500365,
0.6979691982,
0.577208817,
-0.3743424714,
0.8869726062,
0.6116353273,
-0.2556169331,
0.7056248784,
0.7505761385,
-0.2279500067,
0.0986331925,
0.1274919063,
-0.5717728734,
-0.0000769333,
0.4752131701,
-0.8558175564,
-0.4817066491,
0.1212011799,
-0.2101068795,
0.1555332094,
-0.5181474686,
0.9848795533,
-0.1584672332,
-0.8744106889,
0.5382885337,
-0.1458842307,
0.3389084935,
-0.4674008489,
-0.2273410857,
-0.2150312662,
0.6507493854,
-0.6834387779,
-0.7253572941,
0.5422527194,
-0.0745980442,
-0.5791448355,
0.0619049221,
0.4168581367,
-0.6360760927,
-0.6349975467,
-0.168333292,
0.2677225173,
0.2025883198,
0.2636023462,
-0.5261166096,
-0.0337691233,
-0.0731440932,
-0.1937977225,
0.2491521239,
0.1676367968,
0.2544181943,
0.4113939106,
0.4697341919,
-0.0095609911,
-0.060117092,
-0.0131814834,
1.1060919762,
-0.3451355994,
-0.5304111242,
-0.807323277,
0.433428973,
-0.0855687633,
0.0231060646,
0.8193966746,
0.7892413139,
0.7776355743,
-0.323032707,
1.0509572029,
0.1380845159,
0.6704650521,
-0.4512336254,
0.8788365722,
-0.2199855447,
0.3631500304,
-0.2857209146,
-0.8773751259,
-0.2534463406,
0.8000603318,
-0.0431982949,
0.2379178405,
0.7746558189,
0.4991419315,
0.2522643507,
0.2194006741,
-0.6003605723,
0.0690899193,
0.6231377721,
0.5671361685,
0.6850758195,
-0.4892030954,
0.2963930964,
-0.307612896,
0.0190851036,
-0.2718548179,
-0.6311775446,
-1.1224300861,
-0.4142028689,
-0.4324933887,
-1.0716805458,
0.1172636673,
1.1603941917,
0.7703687549,
-1.2361923456,
-0.2856122851,
-0.4275015295,
-0.0129819624,
-0.0826570988,
-0.3376363814,
0.5713126659,
-0.847330749,
-0.6138219237,
-0.0541474745,
-0.1217956096,
0.2240618467,
-0.2801108658,
0.2538076043,
-0.1695421636,
-0.1522453725,
0.4711411893,
0.1813964844,
-0.2922334373,
0.0061321435,
0.0416078083,
-0.0987246409,
0.2635089755,
0.8486735821,
-0.9409903884,
0.55751127,
0.488820672,
0.8338037133,
0.6630246639,
-0.1188790202,
0.9008188248,
-1.1100438833,
-0.1303986162,
0.4930976927,
0.130388245,
0.1814701408,
-0.33984375,
0.5929247141,
0.2651961744,
-0.7685660124,
-0.7802499533,
-0.3562290668,
-0.7859115005,
-0.4051768482,
0.4609580636,
-0.2084023058,
-0.5655264258,
-0.0233391728,
-0.4055082798,
0.2707207501,
-0.5015887022,
1.3026432991,
1.0156055689,
-0.5729469061,
-0.0284635201,
-0.1215806156,
0.4599631429,
0.7187914848,
-1.0689884424,
-0.3462911844,
0.5555793047,
0.3738523126,
0.4927786887,
0.3654039204,
-0.1130028069,
0.4948207736,
-0.0978037938,
0.0594328195,
-0.1525369585,
-0.4514891207,
-0.2583730519,
0.3963263929,
-0.1700975746,
-0.1801243126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13102v1 | Observations on LLMs for Telecom Domain: Capabilities and Limitations | 2023-05-22T15:04:16 | 2023-05-22T15:04:16 | Sumit Soman, Ranjani H G | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50 | The landscape for building conversational interfaces (chatbots) has witnessed
a paradigm shift with recent developments in generative Artificial Intelligence
(AI) based Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT by OpenAI (GPT3.5 and
GPT4), Google's Bard, Large Language Model Meta AI (LLaMA), among others. In
this paper, we analyze capabilities and limitations of incorporating such
models in conversational interfaces for the telecommunication domain,
specifically for enterprise wireless products and services. Using Cradlepoint's
publicly available data for our experiments, we present a comparative analysis
of the responses from such models for multiple use-cases including domain
adaptation for terminology and product taxonomy, context continuity, robustness
to input perturbations and errors. We believe this evaluation would provide
useful insights to data scientists engaged in building customized
conversational interfaces for domain-specific requirements. | [
-0.3998745084,
-0.8403238058,
0.3870638907,
0.2297584116,
0.0412338525,
0.1960082948,
-0.1327347606,
-0.7959503531,
0.0713418126,
0.6504114866,
-0.5015019178,
-0.4364067912,
-0.3957979977,
0.22557953,
-0.3472535014,
0.7131669521,
0.1105598807,
-0.317825526,
-0.3435631692,
-0.1776502132,
-0.6603186131,
-0.9388399124,
-0.5455935597,
-0.3503093719,
0.168709144,
0.47077474,
0.7967017889,
-0.1902610511,
0.5011389256,
0.3664951622,
-0.0726626664,
0.0688424706,
-0.2934061587,
0.1936732084,
0.2866173387,
-0.4638890028,
-0.7774876356,
-0.1191283315,
0.3650264442,
0.9509505033,
-0.279958576,
0.0371382013,
0.1950201988,
0.5021366477,
-0.1578900367,
0.0987068117,
-1.0228427649,
-0.0074122688,
-0.0435784757,
-0.1201059222,
-0.5317264795,
-0.0555298924,
0.4841297567,
-0.560169816,
0.0268118344,
0.1306142062,
1.0059435368,
0.1586823612,
-0.4184824824,
-0.4456827343,
-0.9571167827,
0.887501955,
-0.8374443054,
0.5864729881,
0.1834735572,
0.5085299611,
-0.2609301209,
-0.7383931875,
-0.4623585045,
-0.6296608448,
0.1605236679,
0.2533482909,
-0.5035204291,
0.1137648597,
0.2621235549,
0.1247621626,
-0.2971585989,
0.5129445791,
-0.3337180912,
0.1674987376,
0.5619259477,
0.4182802439,
0.099100709,
-0.0581817441,
-0.276527673,
0.6381201148,
-0.9926509857,
-0.0151737444,
0.2616515458,
0.2204136252,
-0.264862895,
0.768210113,
-0.384568274,
0.7140192389,
-0.129624486,
0.008664229,
0.0666672513,
-0.0401143767,
-0.5154314041,
-0.3148116767,
0.6253387928,
0.3663140237,
0.162646085,
-0.3541507721,
0.0302368887,
-0.1361539364,
0.380795151,
-0.5642969012,
-0.1160459593,
0.5552839637,
-0.5436410308,
-0.058281973,
-0.3330473304,
-0.3274352551,
-0.2741541862,
-0.1957895756,
0.1247084439,
-0.221909225,
-0.2045111805,
0.1695236415,
-0.0157765914,
0.3863101304,
0.4441336989,
-0.8627573252,
0.2624616921,
0.6577063203,
0.9136461616,
-0.349412322,
0.112846911,
0.1909877211,
0.0881466866,
-0.0656017959,
0.623883009,
-0.4013549984,
-0.836176753,
0.0625836551,
-0.058106117,
-0.1544434279,
-0.7645913363,
0.389811337,
-0.9389795661,
0.025692381,
0.1002658755,
-0.4779295325,
-0.1057214066,
0.0697730109,
-0.4804914296,
0.4743975699,
-0.0118488502,
-0.5224106312,
0.1363326013,
-0.8116781712,
-0.3821080923,
0.3119467199,
0.0460954383,
-0.4338448942,
0.0567653291,
-0.191740185,
0.4705694616,
-0.3208130896,
0.103921622,
-0.4110848308,
-0.0319046341,
0.8044509292,
-0.1900287271,
0.7768678665,
0.5284023285,
-0.1615215093,
-0.0622007251,
-0.7966294289,
0.0068937275,
0.010791067,
-0.2491279989,
-0.0723225102,
0.5434545875,
-0.1311054081,
-0.0473343581,
0.1179810539,
-0.513812542,
-0.0298971776,
-0.2457861304,
0.8346740007,
0.5998604894,
-0.2438741028,
0.3118228912,
-0.3962419629,
0.5816455483,
0.1210361645,
0.0430639684,
-0.1210351661,
-0.7595451474,
-0.907374382,
-0.1959670931,
0.3024404049,
0.58516711,
-0.5648600459,
0.5054942966,
-0.4090920985,
-0.3921518624,
0.0281895548,
0.1231983975,
-0.0856457353,
0.4759231806,
0.1186538786,
-0.3660973012,
-0.5291103721,
-1.0580905676,
0.1055793837,
-0.3406401277,
-0.3130752444,
0.6375457048,
0.1537387818,
-0.3589882255,
1.3018916845,
-0.4378440678,
-0.2370249331,
-0.4019859135,
-0.0800087973,
0.311058104,
-0.0218549054,
0.3367134929,
-0.8115727901,
-0.3680584729,
0.2418561727,
-0.7524684668,
-0.3875363469,
-0.1954294443,
0.454538852,
0.2739446461,
0.3035888672,
-0.8045753837,
0.3266703486,
0.8351488113,
0.2383254915,
0.6639573574,
0.1027356982,
0.0522865914,
-1.066347599,
-0.0896106213,
0.2835465372,
-0.0654931292,
-1.0014533997,
-0.3677695394,
-0.1736093163,
-0.298463285,
-0.5987581015,
0.2505137324,
-0.2791597843,
-0.4236561358,
-0.2293540537,
0.1761749089,
-0.2032841146,
0.2439943552,
0.1885751933,
1.2193444967,
0.3624633253,
-1.1120551825,
0.2040859461,
0.6603650451,
-0.3450407982,
0.5345584154,
-1.0624662638,
0.1181275845,
0.3407096267,
0.1826893836,
-0.9691244364,
-0.1253400445,
0.0202665031,
-0.5240383148,
-0.267462045,
-0.0481576324,
-0.2056390196,
-0.2513730228,
-0.0035764715,
0.1696477234,
0.6247196198,
-0.4947542846,
0.6167795062,
0.4152773619,
-0.3756232262,
-0.2087190896,
-0.6454175115,
0.6156700253,
-0.5138278008,
-0.9899692535,
0.4855515957,
-0.0073158038,
-0.3585348129,
-0.268129766,
0.1298565567,
-0.1089951694,
0.3585309386,
0.5095059872,
0.3996257186,
-0.3438578248,
0.0130011616,
-0.2020275891,
0.0916831344,
0.2779628634,
-0.0877858624,
0.4482076764,
-0.0799515843,
-0.5294372439,
-0.5019487739,
0.1252288967,
0.3657844961,
0.0872946531,
0.4739498496,
-0.0141844461,
0.0065728901,
-0.2576143444,
-0.5736097693,
0.1042046621,
-0.6201592684,
0.4012995958,
-0.6114538908,
-1.2590575218,
0.7054181695,
-0.4551189542,
0.1452533901,
0.289691329,
0.6308111548,
-0.2420051396,
0.7971221209,
0.7106890678,
0.0657039285,
0.4237756431,
-0.0195023473,
0.5659636855,
-1.0972671509,
-0.2490447462,
-0.7002515197,
-0.0018841344,
-0.8024113178,
0.0341136754,
0.5388067961,
-0.160125196,
-0.1530155241,
0.5141889453,
-0.1657400578,
-0.1435193121,
0.1926413029,
0.0628112406,
0.4897990525,
0.2247135937,
0.344214797,
0.0662433431,
-0.726047039,
-0.8585084677,
1.0932747126,
0.578759253,
0.9634920359,
0.4233115315,
0.1062728614,
0.3850444853,
0.3087158501,
-0.8326061964,
0.7415764928,
-0.2147965133,
-0.3570416272,
-0.2306979895,
-0.4488511086,
-1.1037751436,
-0.1110462695,
-0.0596283525,
-1.0527555943,
0.0104856445,
-0.0919068679,
-0.1857697517,
0.1651844382,
-0.7821933627,
0.2768606842,
-0.1641897857,
-0.0242010523,
-0.1154406518,
-0.2661034465,
0.2848084271,
-0.2126563638,
0.006936959,
-0.1755784154,
-0.1746681929,
0.4584000707,
-0.2781360745,
1.1258708239,
0.1994204968,
-0.3032118678,
0.4539042115,
-0.1991255432,
0.1052184254,
-0.1380744725,
-0.1058386266,
0.6496758461,
-0.1405934989,
-0.1724814028,
-0.2541057169,
0.5449252129,
-0.9453350902,
-0.9642372131,
-0.0128006851,
-0.4213932753,
-0.8114068508,
-0.0158354193,
0.0400102437,
0.3720212877,
-0.5773209333,
0.3504764438,
0.4858739972,
-0.5256616473,
0.4895616472,
0.284791708,
-0.1818815172,
-0.01017622,
0.4776807725,
0.0737273619,
0.5945446491,
0.1581586152,
-0.1893749982,
-0.3285306096,
-0.845685482,
-0.3975963593,
-0.0530577935,
-0.6368008256,
-0.1755994856,
-0.7409943938,
-0.5948169827,
-0.2613319755,
-0.1998910457,
-0.0004375265,
-0.593306005,
-0.3526358008,
0.1933304816,
0.2517233789,
0.813906014,
0.4611042738,
0.795119226,
-0.696736455,
0.1637810767,
0.4126366675,
0.2894850671,
-0.1480896026,
-0.5821530223,
-0.0875951946,
0.1189008132,
-0.5203350782,
-0.6146324277,
0.193974033,
0.4010650814,
0.4943841696,
0.1291645169,
-0.0746297613,
0.3712522388,
-0.393777281,
1.1267278194,
0.3413064182,
-0.8677774668,
0.2733119428,
-0.5271388888,
0.0646128654,
-0.0402934663,
0.2992545962,
-0.5526097417,
-0.263166517,
-0.5634794831,
-0.5389069915,
0.3501561582,
0.2518072128,
0.7988578677,
0.17234312,
0.2713422477,
0.1278863549,
0.1926134378,
-0.4546441734,
-0.1577384323,
-0.037021026,
0.0247340351,
0.237380147,
-0.321839571,
-0.1051642895,
0.1270928681,
0.4877067804,
-0.0240435451,
0.497163564,
-0.0765288174,
-0.0179948118,
0.4018257558,
0.482073307,
0.5631949306,
0.9506184459,
-0.0223242957,
-0.3391216993,
0.5186239481,
-0.2412364185,
-0.0179812871,
-0.1219927371,
-0.1121741161,
0.0431824289,
0.0831019878,
0.5676124692,
-0.0298015047,
-0.629483521,
0.2685390413,
0.0269973241,
-0.3349277675,
-0.5710786581,
0.2092874944,
0.1661713719,
0.1150242537,
0.4124012291,
-0.2171327621,
0.0532839894,
-0.3049819767,
-0.0139767788,
0.8163939118,
-0.1850417703,
-0.3351684809,
0.7932255268,
0.5813167095,
-0.412532419,
0.4753342867,
0.1744312495,
-0.3537158072,
0.7129468918,
0.6909019351,
0.8226856589,
-0.0225974955,
0.178964898,
-0.0955449864,
0.0227873791,
0.3281060755,
-0.1911547929,
0.0813120827,
-1.0710206032,
-0.4087241888,
-0.2684409916,
-0.9638403058,
0.1537354738,
-0.2425904274,
0.3983927071,
-0.5689367652,
-0.6284069419,
0.3455810845,
-0.3387975991,
-0.7063688636,
0.014943108,
-0.0309305936,
0.8635832071,
-0.3267769217,
0.8483508825,
0.6620417833,
0.0099919215,
-0.550473392,
-0.2426702827,
-0.1382481307,
-0.9526829123,
1.0254752636,
-0.0693882778,
-0.3210544586,
-0.0878957137,
-0.4105445147,
-0.4254548848,
1.1213774681,
-0.0874336734,
-0.4728004038,
0.0658127591,
0.6983613968,
0.4269686639,
-0.4811885655,
0.2923614383,
0.4732880294,
0.1630597711,
0.1788841784,
-1.2164889574,
-0.2553397119,
-0.0318667851,
0.2992372215,
-0.2343694419,
-0.8047088385,
0.6216634512,
-0.0333658345,
-0.3730213344,
0.3608309925,
0.6886552572,
-0.0853641853,
0.2543336451,
0.528046906,
0.2604549527,
0.3392149508,
-0.135051921,
0.7178792953,
-0.1891305298,
0.2005712241,
0.642354548,
-0.6648589373,
0.7034955621,
0.3051414192,
-0.5494997501,
0.5906714201,
0.5210794806,
0.0637956411,
0.2058496624,
0.1102003455,
-0.4733696878,
0.0353317745,
-0.1292687953,
-0.3304071128,
0.6229394078,
0.6696611047,
-0.0154737299,
-0.0227011591,
-0.1108001471,
-0.0822758302,
-0.1608398259,
-0.0746007338,
0.8287382126,
0.3481401801,
-0.3095059097,
0.6273723841,
0.1171693429,
0.8656309247,
-0.4427830577,
0.1601532996,
-0.094135955,
-0.0109188259,
-0.2941724956,
-0.6057862639,
0.5154030919,
0.0262399651,
0.3135306537,
0.0012396098,
0.7668318152,
0.1837773323,
-0.136203289,
0.0231604297,
0.6597416401,
0.0826734006,
0.2034215927,
-0.7282158136,
0.4122289121,
-0.2939355969,
-0.2757335007,
0.216608122,
0.219073087,
-0.0135803251,
1.0764862299,
0.5365941525,
0.0333623439,
-0.0346349031,
-0.0266185235,
0.8965393901,
-0.5555579066,
-0.2406177819,
-0.4886786938,
0.3546709418,
-0.2063286752,
-0.3646671176,
0.8336486816,
0.4487296045,
0.6684525013,
-0.0702573061,
1.149985075,
-0.2394540757,
0.2085178196,
-0.5568215251,
0.4253922403,
-0.22966066,
0.7207331657,
0.1287522018,
-0.8066821098,
-0.193808049,
0.2929902375,
-0.5720863938,
0.1344322413,
0.5371864438,
0.8892403245,
-0.0825237185,
0.4005087316,
0.5747014284,
-0.0275679026,
0.5637678504,
0.5130364895,
1.1876785755,
-0.0960414633,
0.5080723166,
0.1936331242,
-0.2651427984,
-0.4062882662,
-0.9594651461,
-0.9295061231,
-0.671056509,
-0.3784943819,
-0.3178607821,
0.1497240961,
0.5371664762,
0.8811912537,
-0.7409968376,
-0.4903028309,
0.1584056467,
0.0960424617,
0.1151304394,
-0.1862999648,
-0.0045543928,
-0.5526064038,
-0.5934113264,
0.1901919842,
0.3439112902,
0.115288496,
-0.1794586629,
0.0785727128,
0.4487110972,
0.1824725121,
0.9505230784,
0.3528092206,
-0.7245812416,
-0.4938471615,
0.2352019399,
-0.1377218217,
0.2738133669,
0.8631197214,
-0.5298730135,
-0.0208840072,
0.0426120497,
0.8807763457,
0.27922225,
0.0265664477,
0.5898011923,
-0.3804226816,
0.0948016644,
0.0262334011,
0.2471843511,
0.3471910059,
-0.2534930706,
0.4683559537,
0.0537193976,
-0.7581976056,
-0.4857300222,
0.5993770957,
-1.2922832966,
-0.1201409921,
1.3218450546,
-0.0300468802,
0.1175959855,
-0.5618809462,
-0.1403568834,
-0.284951061,
-0.1687092632,
0.9071449041,
0.5539803505,
-0.4693910778,
-0.1614511162,
-0.9844585657,
0.343408227,
0.3988226354,
-0.9889827371,
0.1255488843,
0.4136357307,
0.3171727657,
-0.0433870628,
0.6573113203,
-0.0763748065,
-0.0473615527,
-0.1005440727,
-0.1732127517,
-0.18097651,
0.0562563241,
-0.1358928829,
0.0667883307,
0.5302790999,
-0.2449617088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13092v1 | Improved Compositional Generalization by Generating Demonstrations for Meta-Learning | 2023-05-22T14:58:54 | 2023-05-22T14:58:54 | Sam Spilsbury, Alexander Ilin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Meta-learning and few-shot prompting are viable methods to induce certain
types of compositional behaviour. However, these methods can be very sensitive
to the choice of support examples used. Choosing good supports from the
training data for a given test query is already a difficult problem, but in
some cases solving this may not even be enough. We consider a grounded language
learning problem (gSCAN) where good support examples for certain test splits
might not even exist in the training data, or would be infeasible to search
for. We design an agent which instead generates possible supports which are
relevant to the test query and current state of the world, then uses these
supports via meta-learning to solve the test query. We show substantially
improved performance on a previously unsolved compositional behaviour split
without a loss of performance on other splits. Further experiments show that in
this case, searching for relevant demonstrations even with an oracle function
is not sufficient to attain good performance when using meta-learning. | [
-0.5578223467,
-0.7105892301,
0.6999105215,
0.1642378122,
-0.4342591465,
-0.0405911468,
-0.3095218837,
-0.0734396651,
0.3793287873,
0.2961608469,
-0.7331928611,
-0.5633883476,
-0.5078803301,
0.0580587424,
0.0033070659,
1.0784014463,
0.1652814746,
-0.0770232379,
-0.4219900668,
-0.3930545449,
-0.5690217018,
-0.0749152601,
-0.6570476294,
-0.4349111021,
0.3884324729,
0.6650839448,
0.4295713305,
0.1654458642,
0.0545904636,
0.2762433589,
-0.056548588,
0.4946967661,
-0.2467576116,
0.3891445398,
-0.2672827244,
-0.7106156945,
-0.0909181312,
0.065392375,
0.5506596565,
0.766386807,
-0.3101674318,
-0.1853376627,
0.2495178282,
0.5328655243,
-0.7643226385,
0.4079529941,
-0.5682765841,
0.0958420932,
0.002993451,
-0.0952603221,
-0.5532436967,
-0.2407755256,
0.0614307746,
-0.8703768253,
0.3121244013,
-0.4081845284,
0.5238583684,
0.3267101347,
-0.4596214592,
-0.3325045705,
-0.8485705256,
0.7117686868,
-0.4162800014,
0.1013894826,
0.5095522404,
0.7746321559,
-0.2052286714,
-0.6559513807,
-0.297105372,
-0.1841746271,
-0.3017978072,
0.4400219023,
0.0205295999,
0.31213516,
0.2859119177,
0.1921540797,
-0.5133706927,
-0.3695975542,
-0.4122263789,
-0.3370420635,
0.5329088569,
0.3648870289,
0.2346265316,
0.0387006365,
0.1001356617,
-0.4025525153,
-0.7073352933,
0.3461402655,
0.3920591772,
0.4433363676,
0.2346460819,
0.5007382631,
-0.2674337327,
0.8240532875,
0.3758567274,
-0.2259881943,
0.190074861,
-0.0542480759,
-0.0940955132,
-0.1727357805,
0.4879513085,
-0.0176841319,
0.1222812608,
-0.1614984572,
-0.0641845986,
0.2050076574,
0.3333464563,
-0.8274308443,
-0.2419314682,
0.0705344006,
-0.2198419124,
-0.1290090829,
0.2953194678,
-0.8144358397,
-0.2444227338,
-0.3204464018,
0.3662297428,
-0.425041765,
-0.4209414423,
0.135351032,
-0.2265127301,
0.5943309069,
0.2116433233,
-1.148905158,
0.3302966058,
0.479813695,
0.7335214019,
0.0662084222,
-0.2517577708,
-0.8088606,
0.1546751261,
-0.4235112369,
0.8705651164,
-0.9408149719,
-0.6104069352,
-0.1403296292,
0.1397021264,
-0.3772472441,
-0.7396122813,
0.4099716246,
-0.3060851395,
0.5873870254,
-0.7349998951,
-0.3363313377,
-0.1597618908,
0.347625345,
-0.63581568,
1.0955724716,
0.1559018791,
-0.6636073589,
0.5453681946,
-0.9233343601,
-0.6147158742,
-0.0852715746,
-0.5390417576,
-0.3540974557,
0.2372457087,
0.3410384059,
0.4481645823,
0.2650694847,
0.0454011522,
-0.2890737057,
-0.6261654496,
-0.1647511721,
-0.0128327627,
0.4153006375,
0.0626867041,
-0.8270439506,
-0.0833709165,
-0.6204444766,
0.0457368456,
0.1193878204,
-0.4260496199,
-0.4029483199,
0.2268078178,
-0.6578741074,
0.0474013649,
-0.347155571,
-0.2302191854,
0.449891001,
-0.618689239,
-0.0642573833,
0.7348008752,
0.2003582567,
0.6398802996,
-0.227309674,
0.9285648465,
-0.0730561092,
-0.0041613155,
-0.2798558474,
-0.5773095489,
-0.7937970161,
-0.4338524938,
0.1167085543,
0.2719287276,
-0.9668748379,
0.1407344639,
0.0639506802,
-0.1911137253,
-0.4045824409,
0.1973986924,
0.37872082,
0.4800907075,
0.3952767849,
-0.0763239488,
-0.5354939103,
-0.8310941458,
-0.2037015408,
-0.0972834602,
-0.0818042234,
0.4994191229,
0.1238480508,
-0.321221441,
1.0829873085,
-0.7160621285,
-0.1284809411,
-0.3325256109,
0.2841285467,
0.0181986205,
0.1098649651,
0.7739949226,
-0.6374990344,
-0.6708795428,
0.1977344155,
-0.7888360023,
-0.2388217449,
0.0611894801,
-0.1317075789,
0.0844519883,
0.6314755082,
-0.4996106625,
0.2961575389,
0.4222619534,
-0.1188964918,
0.4976946712,
-0.0553036593,
-0.08682587,
-1.1730896235,
0.098077476,
-0.3181852996,
-0.4919659197,
-0.4805776477,
0.2504928112,
-0.1221173331,
-0.1267829388,
-0.5318074226,
0.4470012486,
-0.4945055842,
0.020449657,
-0.6817398667,
-0.1726347208,
-0.1952850521,
0.5092392564,
0.1594645828,
1.0252686739,
0.8390281796,
-0.9128452539,
0.2360177785,
0.1244483143,
0.0932156369,
0.5853615999,
-0.6051339507,
0.1152524725,
-0.4866244793,
0.5506064892,
-1.0457845926,
-0.3269450068,
0.4364580512,
-0.1700501591,
0.3306757808,
-0.3097364902,
-0.1832801998,
-0.2179125398,
-0.2704235315,
0.2818070948,
0.5413764715,
-0.6323053241,
0.8337104321,
-0.1983249933,
0.1325615644,
-0.7108760476,
-0.4949434698,
-0.1631942093,
-0.5156122446,
-0.4743310213,
0.2176341414,
-0.1777192354,
-0.0276537016,
0.0217028167,
-0.2262555212,
0.2369610071,
0.2852296233,
0.2880973518,
-0.3214377463,
-0.1764636636,
0.3547591865,
0.3810689151,
-0.3158601522,
0.088004142,
-0.4330623448,
0.5231460929,
-0.2822642922,
-0.446044594,
-0.0744100213,
0.4938066304,
0.5855213404,
-0.2862302661,
0.8031276464,
0.652041018,
-0.2144714147,
-0.5828732848,
-0.2099761218,
-0.3826799095,
-0.5410073996,
0.0251268484,
-0.3634987473,
-0.6777868867,
0.5546321869,
-0.0980117768,
-0.0939217731,
0.2892229855,
0.4020060301,
-0.0938925818,
1.1776176691,
0.4719608426,
0.0050544995,
0.7089521289,
-0.531073451,
-0.2139265984,
-0.5392042994,
-0.3308775425,
-0.2303920984,
-0.2588365972,
-0.4016911983,
-0.2651211619,
0.5888246894,
-0.277987808,
0.105834417,
0.2916449904,
-0.3267354965,
0.8618662953,
0.4720951915,
0.3889392912,
0.152956292,
0.0638171211,
-0.8361464739,
-0.0019698562,
-0.6506436467,
-0.4055733979,
1.1228114367,
-0.2451775223,
0.7794203162,
0.3242408335,
0.8284570575,
0.2571353316,
0.3173365891,
-0.6926252246,
0.5563710928,
-0.0924917161,
-0.730802536,
-0.2113116831,
-0.2540037632,
-1.1344373226,
0.5094208121,
-0.1567990333,
-0.3766179681,
-0.0548370555,
0.2625932693,
-0.3518911004,
-0.0751265287,
-0.766898334,
0.7804507017,
0.023777768,
-0.464276582,
-0.1307479888,
-0.667627871,
0.5021788478,
0.2045413405,
-0.1476272792,
0.4241209924,
0.2029949278,
0.4649395645,
-0.4637306929,
1.2338094711,
-0.5652310848,
-0.018401213,
0.6161719561,
0.0594999231,
0.6298088431,
0.0425867066,
0.0975307077,
-1.0266983509,
-0.1297971308,
-0.8133577704,
-1.1251761913,
0.2452939004,
-0.6219663024,
-0.8357827663,
-0.1756367981,
-0.0279163998,
-0.4552536309,
-0.0871217772,
0.4308303595,
0.2771427035,
-0.3072952926,
0.2670732737,
0.8824701309,
0.0137803499,
0.5200929046,
0.4090313613,
-0.040500395,
-0.4301617444,
0.8521251678,
-0.1621528715,
0.3449380994,
0.1983799934,
0.5685265064,
-0.4031220973,
-0.3641473353,
-0.3936168551,
0.192154035,
-0.7935934067,
-0.0934799314,
-0.685988307,
0.0360623263,
-0.1637449563,
-0.0798148587,
-0.2579087615,
-0.2491873503,
-0.4656950235,
-0.498399049,
-0.0388043933,
0.6512621045,
-0.0869698822,
0.4508289397,
-0.5507701039,
0.1490382105,
1.0284634829,
0.0728694648,
-0.0058827172,
-0.1710721105,
-0.269253701,
0.052045688,
-0.7016848922,
-1.0699242353,
-0.1147768721,
0.5338510275,
0.9796048999,
0.9312582612,
0.0659189373,
0.7187163234,
-0.2383586615,
0.8189480305,
-0.1967967898,
-0.9364709258,
0.8200122714,
-0.5842844844,
0.0689347461,
0.8846282363,
0.4584182203,
-0.433160454,
-0.4533220232,
-0.6991068721,
-0.4295088649,
0.6622914672,
0.0781383216,
0.3460149467,
-0.088210769,
0.4137512743,
0.2936559618,
0.1641277969,
-0.8001127839,
-0.151587531,
-0.3669756949,
-0.0183264017,
-0.1459403932,
-0.0393331684,
-0.2944783866,
-0.2425373346,
0.6602106094,
-0.7046368718,
0.1747792661,
0.1777126193,
-0.2375591099,
-0.0374202989,
0.2688237727,
1.0176454782,
0.3807450831,
-0.0613308027,
0.3249866664,
0.2186937034,
-0.3365101814,
0.4504596889,
-0.1876616925,
-0.0906631723,
-0.2034732401,
0.3906368613,
0.7808662653,
0.0456614308,
-0.5011199713,
0.7894727588,
0.0799857602,
-0.529333353,
0.0835211053,
0.5327403545,
0.0066375965,
0.2805300057,
0.2440864891,
-0.2001180351,
0.1401185095,
-0.7237874269,
0.3198357522,
0.606695652,
-0.2166455239,
-0.6125631928,
0.4340831041,
0.1719829887,
0.0183713306,
0.5254013538,
-0.650056839,
-0.9364916682,
0.5188505054,
0.6882465482,
0.8909360766,
-0.3559599817,
0.782636404,
0.3504466116,
0.2614965439,
-0.2902587652,
0.1927514523,
-0.5355824828,
-0.6506233215,
-0.4236537814,
-0.0130972434,
-0.6103440523,
-0.0668347701,
-0.5931096077,
0.3413164616,
-0.340637356,
0.0755928382,
-0.524027884,
0.1083773375,
-0.528488338,
0.1749241352,
0.0601280034,
0.516598165,
-1.5109933615,
0.4659791887,
1.0315750837,
-0.4101974666,
-0.727021277,
0.2116978914,
-0.2362297326,
-0.6645982265,
0.2909600735,
0.2218623459,
-0.0434573703,
-0.3362971246,
-0.6413526535,
-0.5552647114,
1.1844565868,
0.6022725105,
0.1013319343,
0.0156371444,
0.1776160598,
0.7942827344,
-0.3871824741,
0.4517441988,
0.4319791794,
0.7085537314,
0.3294439018,
-0.3535051346,
0.1609644294,
-0.0690438151,
-0.4634348154,
0.1280898899,
-0.9521968365,
0.6013840437,
-0.037222106,
-0.3647889197,
-0.0774471387,
0.4439997077,
0.3073341846,
0.7559046745,
0.6262593269,
0.6273704767,
0.9095655084,
0.038506303,
0.8398994207,
0.3494682908,
0.3964987695,
0.9880577326,
-0.2498010248,
0.3720081449,
0.3883863091,
-0.1701399237,
0.7829091549,
0.7436150312,
0.2628549039,
0.8558769226,
0.188718766,
-0.5681353211,
-0.6234489083,
0.2561497688,
-0.4230053127,
0.639735043,
0.2628807127,
-0.3333134353,
-0.5831952691,
0.2195943892,
-0.2417807877,
0.1879859418,
0.0008684543,
0.9772428274,
-0.1978423446,
-0.878783226,
0.5378352404,
-0.2321145684,
0.4390537143,
-0.6968439221,
-0.0603194088,
-0.5520176291,
-0.1331958026,
-0.3843704164,
-0.2818556428,
0.6466936469,
-0.250838846,
-0.108155854,
0.0226803329,
0.5944859385,
-0.4146096706,
-0.3818276823,
0.2381347418,
0.6865705848,
0.0895176753,
-0.297100246,
-0.2669396698,
-0.5032985806,
-0.0243372098,
-0.1308952868,
0.3175735772,
0.448672384,
-0.1057486385,
0.5258269906,
0.5341188908,
-0.2834281325,
0.2302458584,
-0.1918057948,
1.0720331669,
-0.5890305638,
-0.5727168918,
-0.809697926,
0.565382123,
0.1131897718,
0.1145338118,
0.5489671826,
0.4634127617,
0.5805387497,
-0.1876844317,
0.876314342,
0.0578494221,
0.206024453,
-0.7148278356,
0.3941403031,
-0.6549089551,
0.1409901232,
-0.2933746874,
-1.1177864075,
-0.3311136961,
0.5120402575,
-0.1043212041,
0.1000329033,
0.9142367244,
0.9075580835,
-0.4678731561,
-0.0634072572,
0.5531834364,
-0.2674406469,
0.5564547777,
0.563953042,
1.0895880461,
-0.2008619606,
0.6343255043,
-0.0613147914,
-0.1138752997,
-0.2116293162,
-0.9359104037,
-1.2110173702,
-0.568643868,
-0.0660111904,
-0.3184025586,
0.0398507901,
0.9624145031,
0.9857088327,
-0.6380619407,
0.1171789095,
-0.3568260968,
0.2986127436,
-0.4152087271,
-0.2232505083,
0.170106262,
-0.6188523769,
-0.7133275867,
0.690397501,
-0.2021902949,
0.1875929087,
-0.131667763,
-0.1944250017,
0.2691179514,
0.1398633271,
0.5634588003,
0.6305779219,
-0.4129127264,
-0.3340047896,
0.1437218934,
0.278896302,
0.1303420365,
1.2175501585,
-0.9676427841,
0.4842121899,
0.4561422765,
0.9913852215,
0.720783174,
0.1716803759,
0.4700957835,
-1.0667898655,
0.0561131611,
0.0738811046,
0.2688599825,
0.1968545765,
-0.268321842,
0.5118548274,
0.4708234668,
-0.1983503401,
-0.5030686855,
0.413272649,
-0.9039668441,
-0.081679523,
1.392244935,
0.0277229957,
-0.076076299,
0.0609888509,
-0.3505262136,
0.0551194586,
-0.3525893986,
0.6749329567,
0.8267246485,
-0.1796374917,
-0.1481704414,
-0.0891516805,
0.3551559746,
0.6170189977,
-0.872292757,
-0.1079481915,
0.3372453451,
0.5380983949,
-0.0803102627,
0.4936099052,
0.1074237004,
0.408901453,
-0.2587623894,
-0.2221908569,
-0.1673797667,
-0.5931084156,
-0.568936944,
0.1128194183,
0.194590643,
-0.4934587181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13091v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13091v2 | Large Language Models are Not Yet Human-Level Evaluators for Abstractive Summarization | 2023-05-22T14:58:13 | 2023-10-20T03:47:27 | Chenhui Shen, Liying Cheng, Xuan-Phi Nguyen, Yang You, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the recent undeniable advancement in reasoning abilities in large
language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and GPT-4, there is a growing trend for
using LLMs on various tasks. One area where LLMs can be employed is as an
alternative evaluation metric for complex generative tasks, which generally
demands expensive human judges to complement the traditional automatic metrics
for various evaluation dimensions such as fluency and consistency. In this
work, we conduct extensive analysis to investigate the stability and
reliability of LLMs as automatic evaluators for abstractive summarization. We
found that while ChatGPT and GPT-4 outperform the commonly used automatic
metrics, they are not ready as human replacements due to significant
limitations. That is, LLM evaluators rate each candidate system inconsistently
and are dimension-dependent. They also struggle to compare candidates with
close performance and become more unreliable with higher-quality summaries by
obtaining a lower correlation with humans. In other words, with better
abstractive summarization systems being introduced at a fast pace, LLMs may
result in misleading and unreliable evaluations. | [
-0.4566141367,
-0.6326134801,
0.7954989672,
0.337672621,
-0.2003082186,
0.3438151777,
-0.4637366533,
-0.5596820116,
-0.0811270103,
0.0375380553,
0.0794362053,
-0.3538992405,
-0.7989538908,
0.3184049726,
-0.5218722224,
1.1934725046,
-0.1860726476,
0.0207712241,
-0.4359288216,
-0.1725268513,
-0.3114621639,
-0.7014527321,
-0.6431320906,
-0.3566535413,
0.3699114025,
0.1026684865,
0.7846708298,
0.161472708,
0.603996098,
0.4137847722,
-0.2336162478,
0.2098907232,
-0.4419859052,
0.1993377656,
0.0348966531,
-0.2677841783,
-0.7764414549,
0.0255576987,
0.8108635545,
0.7961651683,
-0.2684951723,
-0.0477035195,
0.1812084913,
0.6949869394,
-0.4976694882,
0.5656165481,
-0.6225256324,
-0.1083924919,
0.0745876431,
-0.051910989,
-0.2856106758,
-0.5716819167,
0.3760688901,
-0.2101369351,
0.0910727754,
-0.043699313,
0.7224829793,
0.1760714203,
-0.1532094479,
-0.3258127868,
-0.7881329656,
0.6070383191,
-1.0582820177,
0.0975417346,
0.4116666615,
0.3844823837,
-0.1527511477,
-0.5577095151,
-0.3925491571,
-0.6716476679,
-0.0295033809,
0.1858459264,
-0.1435993463,
0.203124553,
0.0398204736,
0.4026049674,
-0.4701464772,
0.2598971128,
-0.4326958358,
-0.2196984291,
0.6657785177,
0.5290655494,
0.2665210068,
-0.2618812323,
-0.2192083746,
0.3794948459,
-0.6398730278,
-0.1297234148,
0.2967531681,
0.040258944,
-0.1421658248,
0.6661952138,
-0.1003563702,
0.5975673199,
0.02151387,
-0.4167118967,
0.2076919228,
-0.3721526861,
-0.0780049711,
-0.1453218609,
1.1104911566,
0.4661592841,
0.3366039991,
-0.086074397,
-0.4525021911,
0.1980527639,
0.1314134747,
-0.684874475,
-0.284173131,
0.3562569022,
-0.3576054275,
-0.1487496346,
0.0273083989,
-0.5005232692,
-0.1760066599,
-0.2105123997,
0.4054576159,
-0.4269299209,
-0.0300844088,
0.095094949,
0.0074468702,
-0.0026369211,
0.5990593433,
-0.8737475276,
0.415622443,
0.6614086032,
1.090765357,
-0.4872986376,
-0.4383465946,
-0.351244837,
-0.0819595456,
-0.3682202101,
0.7976360917,
-0.4068458676,
-0.4304470718,
-0.2182365507,
-0.0971533507,
-0.2031916231,
-0.5417434573,
0.4864381254,
-0.5439642072,
0.1830983311,
-0.090408653,
-0.4778059423,
-0.0276235007,
0.4133400619,
-0.6327234507,
0.612011075,
0.0674999133,
-0.7372466326,
0.1170699671,
-0.5989635587,
-0.3606854081,
-0.0611479096,
-0.2683280408,
-0.54543823,
0.0449799225,
0.1353074312,
0.5301632285,
-0.2390590161,
0.418634057,
-0.3573185503,
-0.6760998964,
0.2427036613,
-0.6989566088,
0.3998255432,
0.1261776686,
-0.0420982987,
0.1194139868,
-0.7634344101,
-0.1274960488,
-0.0098782619,
-0.7558888793,
-0.0473943464,
0.2361098975,
-0.2207292318,
0.1349506527,
0.2703597546,
-0.4431383312,
0.0952881947,
-0.380392164,
0.4955575168,
0.7340618968,
-0.0716296062,
0.1754329503,
-0.4282128215,
0.9271550179,
-0.3178013861,
-0.4185322821,
-0.303753674,
-0.4875992239,
-0.596262157,
-0.2033691108,
0.4053447843,
0.4947352707,
-0.651860714,
0.4801726341,
-0.6515459418,
-0.543595314,
-0.1018178686,
-0.0082304087,
0.5556697249,
0.1336909831,
0.0856251046,
-0.1932773292,
-0.515458703,
-0.8151778579,
-0.1821250767,
-0.3599323332,
-0.2140196115,
-0.1824229956,
0.6173895001,
-0.0522174276,
0.8550607562,
-0.2221086621,
-0.0685979277,
-0.6660090089,
0.1559982598,
0.2304705381,
0.2009097785,
0.482039243,
-0.2195455134,
-0.4281713367,
-0.0076545221,
-0.7886846662,
-0.11963211,
0.0755680352,
0.3615340889,
0.4618636966,
0.2999826074,
-0.9283272028,
0.1367524564,
0.870403707,
-0.2231639922,
0.9184890985,
-0.3790552616,
0.0067058452,
-0.6368209124,
0.1539001465,
0.1025185734,
-0.3509349823,
-0.3442160487,
-0.1652230024,
-0.0912852138,
0.0215376336,
-0.1992019117,
0.4241475761,
-0.4989720881,
-0.3131324351,
-0.3194317818,
0.4083764553,
0.0007617647,
0.3717077672,
-0.0813550502,
0.7406107187,
0.3416322768,
-0.6400929093,
0.3170551062,
0.2117607445,
-0.6358486414,
0.4752539396,
-0.9508797526,
-0.0044833212,
-0.1858469546,
0.624289155,
-1.0195732117,
-0.3624348342,
0.0359961763,
-0.4745889604,
0.3769171238,
-0.0165704694,
-0.5073854327,
-0.1718792021,
-0.5059327483,
0.3821834326,
0.5513257384,
-0.4069761336,
0.5180209279,
0.3307569921,
-0.4638602436,
-0.5058877468,
-0.6510446668,
0.2060615122,
-0.1682222784,
-0.6839351654,
0.0047919387,
0.0910735577,
-0.5070897341,
-0.0280253608,
-0.2295344323,
0.2939499319,
0.0236961059,
0.1616597325,
0.421790868,
-0.1772585362,
0.1325453371,
-0.1265688092,
-0.3418320715,
0.150478512,
0.129274562,
0.3746395111,
-0.4735549092,
-0.5348694921,
-0.3379048407,
0.1296420842,
0.7970373631,
-0.188849777,
0.6363679171,
0.3179441094,
-0.0818390325,
0.1514074951,
-0.6101623774,
0.2139025927,
-0.3937974572,
0.823328197,
-0.4238428771,
-0.9387395978,
0.668520391,
0.268776536,
0.2317732126,
0.6793138981,
0.6646874547,
-0.1249394715,
1.1554441452,
0.1199108884,
-0.1307685077,
-0.0131963603,
-0.0688313618,
0.1302621663,
-0.9694182873,
-0.0560503416,
-0.3894063234,
-0.2163699865,
-0.4109760821,
-0.2351273745,
0.6471449137,
-0.0979035646,
-0.1233692244,
-0.0458672792,
-0.1650733501,
0.5076416135,
-0.1103720963,
-0.2611473203,
0.6855860949,
-0.1973822564,
0.0941919312,
0.1648632437,
-0.6254364848,
-0.872797966,
0.894818902,
0.6217104793,
0.9282318354,
0.2151008993,
0.2474883497,
0.1444835514,
0.4194496572,
-0.8076249957,
0.6209489703,
-0.1775451899,
-0.382276088,
-0.5921542048,
-0.5331047773,
-0.9116709232,
0.7899702787,
0.028095657,
-0.7490298152,
-0.0689227954,
0.1745287627,
-0.3634282649,
0.3629850149,
-0.6630629301,
0.6186355352,
-0.2144566625,
-0.0041279173,
-0.0884684622,
-0.5221089125,
0.6734979749,
-0.2836976647,
0.3183179498,
-0.3211458623,
-0.1190713495,
0.6052180529,
-0.6802595854,
0.8039913774,
-0.0241524614,
-0.3541149199,
0.1493655741,
0.1611062288,
0.5660207868,
-0.0106988922,
-0.2360628247,
0.1476370394,
0.0732882395,
-0.2418309897,
-0.6195147634,
0.7411037683,
-0.7787493467,
-0.7318205237,
-0.5699492693,
-0.3555493355,
-0.389955312,
-0.1082668081,
0.2350697964,
0.4313527346,
-0.1659709811,
0.2374657542,
0.3454874158,
-0.0469221249,
0.5299018621,
0.3416157663,
-0.3625147641,
-0.350935787,
0.8102571368,
0.1897072047,
0.6310930252,
0.1548186988,
0.1064609885,
-0.1550929993,
-0.8852828145,
-0.4937820435,
0.1367636919,
-0.791826725,
-0.0824278891,
-0.7215968966,
-0.3260148466,
0.0575780086,
-0.0198198278,
-0.3733219802,
-0.6203238964,
0.0404957756,
-0.3415672481,
0.1211912185,
0.7849334478,
0.132126227,
-0.0079314783,
-0.9009891152,
0.2181646675,
0.2114370465,
0.4467749894,
0.1982916743,
-0.7166908383,
-0.2889895141,
-0.1899377853,
-0.1845381856,
-0.5434677601,
0.2325781733,
0.2451585531,
0.515828073,
0.2638533115,
-0.167848438,
0.485766232,
-0.4089269936,
0.8382301331,
0.1387764513,
-0.9368538857,
0.0871228352,
-0.5098152161,
0.6239418387,
0.4548018873,
0.1600660235,
-0.4149507582,
-0.694011867,
-0.2385095507,
-0.8492987752,
0.6748992205,
0.2530821264,
0.1788326651,
0.0547705181,
0.189165622,
0.2300663739,
0.098077096,
-0.617561996,
-0.0011232281,
-0.1703912169,
-0.0127807725,
-0.2495177388,
-0.4508170784,
0.1712846011,
-0.2364681959,
0.6605104804,
-0.0183158908,
-0.0018156482,
-0.0082451142,
0.0837614238,
-0.0566793308,
0.4391637444,
0.536359489,
1.0507642031,
-0.1830220073,
0.238012746,
0.39249143,
-0.378172338,
0.2865373194,
0.0159547161,
-0.0541402139,
0.0937229544,
0.641089499,
0.8076143861,
0.4457993805,
-0.9147613049,
0.6056938767,
-0.0544789322,
-0.2739889026,
-0.7214763165,
0.0440316834,
0.2829368114,
-0.0912856683,
0.1670800298,
0.110987626,
-0.0375482962,
-0.5434813499,
-0.1638515592,
0.5510263443,
-0.1425852478,
-0.3893511295,
0.6414504647,
0.2756592929,
-0.0704616979,
0.5130330324,
-0.2408698648,
-0.4398608208,
0.4393984675,
0.3302642405,
0.8979629874,
-0.1987638026,
0.0397556946,
0.3058566749,
0.2504376471,
-0.3835638463,
-0.0606889054,
0.1934315562,
-0.6721112132,
-0.7131877542,
-0.6549515128,
-0.4543278515,
0.0832556337,
-0.2875573039,
0.1161839217,
-0.3792610765,
-0.2905564904,
-0.1438598037,
-0.3781742752,
-0.2410917431,
0.028122453,
-0.0320757478,
0.5883453488,
-0.6232815981,
0.5320821404,
0.558006525,
-0.3298563361,
-0.6383666396,
-0.0419031195,
-0.0546498001,
-0.4161679745,
0.4542847276,
0.0129806753,
-0.3643299341,
-0.4412078261,
-0.1873291135,
-0.9438129663,
1.0371640921,
0.4219557345,
-0.656006217,
-0.4193802476,
-0.1138871461,
0.8353351951,
-0.2074850649,
0.5517119765,
0.6953566074,
0.5434135199,
0.2830447853,
-1.3650043011,
-0.0027702125,
-0.237139836,
0.1868737042,
0.1559224278,
-0.7320483923,
0.7402973771,
-0.3943585157,
-0.187055856,
0.2880222499,
0.4304789007,
0.4786573648,
0.0891577825,
0.3747591376,
0.4298406541,
0.4284738302,
-0.1753120273,
1.3120732307,
-0.1151728183,
0.4275331199,
1.1824792624,
-0.2129493505,
0.8789682984,
0.0897954628,
-0.5812769532,
0.4379581511,
0.3716718554,
-0.186957106,
0.0395947061,
0.279183656,
-0.2345602363,
-0.2405922115,
0.4990401864,
-0.2058764249,
0.5513322949,
0.4013427198,
-0.4329887033,
-0.2746643126,
-0.3064814806,
0.0856807679,
-0.0230208952,
-0.163693741,
0.7012001872,
0.2856224179,
-0.747338593,
0.7998568416,
0.1219247654,
0.6451605558,
-0.5643771291,
0.0688572153,
-0.0784920827,
0.0397374593,
-0.4917915761,
-0.5872966647,
0.3320602477,
0.1383589208,
0.0397246815,
0.2462461442,
0.580168128,
-0.1823362559,
-0.4589936435,
0.0626477078,
0.6095190644,
0.4060528278,
0.1167916358,
-0.2506863177,
0.2097128928,
-0.0813373923,
-0.4835090041,
0.4269152284,
0.2881230712,
-0.1197248846,
0.8842888474,
0.3977161944,
0.1762646437,
-0.1815811843,
0.1699023545,
0.624299109,
-0.5568070412,
-0.3539215624,
-1.2184220552,
0.530854702,
0.0618114397,
-0.0947298035,
0.8313849568,
0.5569586754,
0.478561312,
-0.0681392774,
1.1324259043,
0.1090163887,
0.4006103575,
-0.6356050372,
0.7415630221,
-0.1506628394,
0.7656861544,
-0.3481229842,
-1.216006279,
-0.217316702,
0.3825736046,
-0.411233753,
0.4878415167,
0.8079333305,
0.3792342544,
0.0741922259,
0.0528345518,
0.4716974795,
0.411493808,
0.5982480645,
0.4647811651,
1.0925073624,
0.0556874424,
0.7039314508,
0.1641215831,
-0.2755737901,
-0.2941379547,
-0.7286945581,
-0.9130495191,
-0.3435304463,
-0.2943316102,
-0.1484986544,
0.0854672268,
0.9056789875,
0.4709043801,
-0.7378082871,
-0.1014437005,
-0.023996789,
-0.0233594328,
0.142911464,
-0.2305868417,
0.5556030273,
-0.3950043321,
-0.8884821534,
0.2275515199,
0.5309746861,
0.0915022939,
-0.7423716187,
-0.1771983653,
0.3655786514,
-0.0606016479,
0.8264459968,
0.2686215937,
-1.0390242338,
-0.3547397256,
-0.5863755941,
-0.0290692449,
0.0903495476,
0.5077979565,
-0.7319005728,
0.304928422,
0.4542184472,
0.5984297395,
0.2305933833,
0.2841113508,
0.763789475,
-0.3002435267,
-0.3345588148,
0.2415314019,
0.5687999725,
0.4324199259,
0.0063458919,
0.3953160048,
-0.0510811992,
-0.8229454756,
-0.5895591974,
0.0224884544,
-0.840878427,
0.0088033481,
1.2512998581,
-0.3397544026,
0.0704694018,
-0.2755297422,
-0.3197284341,
-0.2664659023,
-0.5037798285,
1.0792720318,
0.893945992,
-0.5331935883,
-0.0678101182,
-0.4676541984,
0.4020732045,
0.2460396737,
-0.8417349458,
0.1482539177,
0.6245474219,
0.347237289,
0.3261919916,
0.8763416409,
-0.3820603788,
0.3076883554,
-0.0641869083,
-0.1925846636,
-0.0746423081,
-0.0457814373,
-0.4471189082,
0.3204661608,
0.6082468629,
0.0762196109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13088v1 | Should We Attend More or Less? Modulating Attention for Fairness | 2023-05-22T14:54:21 | 2023-05-22T14:54:21 | Abdelrahman Zayed, Goncalo Mordido, Samira Shabanian, Sarath Chandar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | The abundance of annotated data in natural language processing (NLP) poses
both opportunities and challenges. While it enables the development of
high-performing models for a variety of tasks, it also poses the risk of models
learning harmful biases from the data, such as gender stereotypes. In this
work, we investigate the role of attention, a widely-used technique in current
state-of-the-art NLP models, in the propagation of social biases. Specifically,
we study the relationship between the entropy of the attention distribution and
the model's performance and fairness. We then propose a novel method for
modulating attention weights to improve model fairness after training. Since
our method is only applied post-training and pre-inference, it is an
intra-processing method and is, therefore, less computationally expensive than
existing in-processing and pre-processing approaches. Our results show an
increase in fairness and minimal performance loss on different text
classification and generation tasks using language models of varying sizes.
WARNING: This work uses language that is offensive. | [
-0.3949436545,
-0.3937930167,
0.3533512056,
0.4559773207,
-0.0983213708,
-0.4433127046,
-0.228655979,
-0.6370180249,
0.0226294659,
0.3930592239,
-0.4964514971,
-0.0312342215,
-0.7660676241,
0.1465043128,
-0.157013312,
1.212628603,
0.4234031737,
0.2634927034,
-0.2963721454,
-0.1477679759,
-0.4309482574,
-0.6934617758,
-0.9032886624,
-0.3037869036,
0.6199921966,
-0.075082019,
0.6911607385,
0.5415614843,
0.626257658,
0.3307635188,
-0.2721479833,
-0.0248854402,
-0.7237023711,
0.0474349223,
-0.4935393035,
-0.8286638856,
-0.4834531546,
0.445597887,
0.6451550126,
0.9084324241,
0.1339173615,
0.6409307122,
0.2918420136,
0.9138413668,
-0.8564695716,
0.062775515,
-0.7431268692,
0.4062367678,
-0.1377050877,
-0.2826579809,
-0.4903838336,
-0.2820983231,
0.1869771332,
-0.5385786891,
0.4134117663,
0.1441633403,
0.4976416826,
0.6313266754,
-0.1175859347,
0.1206493601,
-0.4507720172,
0.9866779447,
-0.4884926975,
0.3846628368,
0.709772408,
-0.0969106555,
0.0800362304,
-0.4456522167,
-0.4520817697,
0.1224421188,
-0.0389024764,
0.0291610435,
-0.1109550819,
0.2171735317,
0.6869930029,
0.1302467585,
-0.0398227647,
-0.2248845249,
-0.3378200233,
0.0698031262,
0.5497373939,
-0.0053215409,
0.2377219796,
-0.0213204827,
-0.0189435221,
-0.0145358713,
-0.1371228695,
0.0651535615,
0.5837413073,
0.3581619561,
-0.1022771671,
0.5038222671,
-0.4005177021,
0.6515479088,
0.3660997748,
0.1564355493,
0.2546774149,
-0.1423449367,
-0.4233337939,
0.305338949,
0.4178892672,
0.7314630747,
0.4703213871,
-0.1996982247,
-0.0247705504,
0.296341598,
0.3652931452,
-0.6003140807,
0.0161353759,
0.0237567984,
-0.6639642715,
-0.4965861142,
-0.3088589609,
-0.665250361,
-0.3642371297,
-0.5103740096,
0.2985969484,
-0.011635676,
0.0084198043,
0.2707786262,
-0.2186715007,
0.020049151,
0.2707360685,
-1.0955276489,
0.3104317784,
0.598410368,
0.7340531945,
0.1539961696,
0.0726946741,
-0.6242066026,
0.3633672297,
-0.1750961542,
0.4990057945,
-0.7269925475,
0.2858335972,
-0.2790588439,
-0.172271356,
-0.0259807166,
-0.3157709539,
0.5997409225,
-0.6234936714,
0.3882788718,
-0.4116771221,
-0.1532060802,
-0.0662520006,
0.1396924406,
-0.529822588,
0.7744134665,
0.0400424115,
-1.3066583872,
0.4741474092,
-0.9744342566,
-0.7283110619,
-0.0876754075,
0.0669344515,
-0.2752468884,
0.2551887333,
0.3998036683,
0.2825187445,
-0.2636591494,
0.3258545399,
-0.4371078908,
-0.2971151471,
0.2273414433,
-0.6041827798,
0.9058300853,
0.2287733108,
-0.6384985447,
-0.1242563054,
-0.5277438164,
-0.076831989,
-0.085990034,
-0.2010429502,
-0.4527137578,
-0.0203804187,
0.1342074722,
0.4661074877,
0.0807980001,
-0.3942013681,
-0.3989846706,
-0.9000398517,
0.2255781889,
1.0828032494,
-0.4614883661,
1.0045450926,
-0.2312692255,
0.3404814601,
-0.1244124323,
0.3022859693,
0.0665027425,
-0.5091991425,
-0.6211066842,
-0.1556249559,
0.4829753339,
0.4497621953,
-0.5858321786,
0.3047224283,
-0.1110364422,
-0.0302068982,
-0.9346005321,
0.1264420897,
0.3175968528,
0.3531692922,
0.1806386858,
-0.4461671412,
-0.5660580993,
-0.7700644732,
-0.626701951,
-0.0130055929,
-0.2085349411,
0.3411768377,
0.0575911626,
-0.0223694276,
0.9883645773,
-0.3492968678,
-0.4752677381,
-0.1770416051,
-0.119859077,
-0.120725587,
0.478839606,
0.5914965868,
-0.8150989413,
-0.4020911455,
-0.163506344,
-0.6905574799,
-0.3666700125,
-0.0521391109,
-0.4578038156,
0.204779759,
0.5307987928,
-0.2942478359,
0.502317369,
0.339510709,
-0.4207072556,
0.0029969432,
0.1938060373,
0.204449445,
-0.7006495595,
0.0816067532,
0.1035394967,
-0.5174998641,
-0.4584490955,
0.0244680438,
-0.2970147729,
-0.0021632682,
-0.4029096067,
0.7259152532,
-0.3594497442,
-0.0780253187,
-0.3231316507,
0.0560668111,
0.1071989611,
0.5228284597,
0.0020397706,
0.2673983872,
0.523663938,
-0.5752200484,
0.0964016989,
-0.1396698654,
-0.19591631,
0.6709003448,
-0.5035848022,
0.1952651739,
-0.7710757256,
0.2107586563,
-0.8667327762,
-0.2953228056,
0.4369044304,
-0.5963302851,
0.2124085277,
-0.0548079014,
-0.4386710525,
-0.1967663914,
-0.5900077224,
0.6694842577,
0.2222789228,
-0.3639052212,
0.4778519571,
0.7575445771,
-0.1366132498,
-0.6189029217,
-0.9328238964,
-0.0440644063,
-0.1994097829,
-0.5336838365,
0.1320541948,
0.0033852546,
-0.4181453586,
-0.0556119233,
0.0650769919,
0.07785777,
0.2537597418,
0.1989775598,
-0.1694198251,
0.1031679511,
0.2241007686,
0.1585208774,
-0.1462581605,
0.0984542668,
-0.2909944654,
0.5284065008,
0.2109222412,
-0.0790247545,
-0.6798619032,
0.5099368095,
0.2591688335,
-0.3193175495,
0.8635132909,
0.7311815023,
-0.5515937209,
-0.0951270238,
-0.5973258018,
-0.4458430707,
-0.4874764085,
0.493773371,
0.0925318375,
-0.8086423278,
0.2931672633,
0.5338788033,
0.2072751522,
0.0681484714,
0.6143807173,
-0.1146109924,
1.2738778591,
0.9293287992,
-0.3016451597,
1.00174582,
0.3847474456,
0.3208788633,
-0.7640844584,
0.0029984924,
-0.6478876472,
-0.6008788943,
-0.5544389486,
-0.5535697937,
0.1073385477,
-0.1479929239,
-0.0715385452,
-0.2371808141,
-0.7298095226,
0.6534132361,
0.6526563764,
0.2762147784,
0.0409250185,
0.15870139,
0.5433555841,
-0.317894429,
-0.8936434984,
-0.3811725676,
1.1820271015,
0.4179147482,
0.6907708049,
-0.1120886505,
0.5078665018,
0.297830075,
0.6991292238,
-0.3890842795,
0.3458994627,
-0.1027161628,
-0.8925820589,
-0.4227743745,
-0.6080470681,
-0.7708941102,
0.3113897443,
-0.0634216517,
-0.7580053806,
0.2736009359,
0.4075196683,
-0.4792264104,
0.1567126662,
-0.9917427301,
0.7766955495,
0.0971606001,
-0.5994270444,
-0.2188168019,
-0.8028675914,
0.3859994709,
0.1041634679,
0.3821602166,
-0.3159816563,
0.0751153901,
0.9934505224,
0.1195540875,
0.9517323375,
-0.2256983221,
-0.0021992233,
-0.0193413366,
-0.2166628689,
0.3559034467,
0.4136486948,
-0.2735112607,
0.028095359,
-0.4201378524,
-0.4579133987,
-0.3779247403,
0.3790909052,
-0.5710905194,
-0.634304285,
-0.4323296547,
-0.7465609908,
-0.0630904883,
0.0517829172,
0.0856453255,
0.124668248,
0.2274233699,
0.1960293204,
0.8760409951,
-0.2094887048,
0.425367862,
0.1712551713,
0.0915730596,
-0.052201461,
0.6182162762,
0.138591066,
0.3329869509,
0.3664087653,
0.0340580903,
-0.0773720741,
-0.1806243509,
0.0160931665,
-0.0132814869,
-0.5885012746,
-0.2381884456,
-1.2819912434,
0.0117222173,
-0.8654854894,
-0.325586915,
-0.3161039352,
-0.3292105198,
-0.3810372651,
-0.0660598129,
0.1608837247,
0.1877464354,
-0.3699455559,
0.392606616,
-0.3279956877,
0.6348857284,
0.526397109,
0.554982543,
0.2577039897,
-0.6478051543,
-0.2203126699,
0.0815655142,
-0.1553188413,
-0.6249477863,
0.3044168055,
0.1140792444,
0.4950967133,
0.251850009,
0.1340714693,
0.3291543722,
-0.5814345479,
0.4411945939,
0.2293992043,
-0.8871302009,
0.514932096,
-0.2509929538,
0.5101465583,
0.7012418509,
0.1112444401,
-0.5771712065,
-0.8120259643,
-0.6981313825,
-0.9989312291,
1.298583746,
0.2764499187,
0.4971935451,
-0.1958449483,
0.3348427415,
-0.2123950571,
0.5302814841,
-1.2987703085,
-0.3688056171,
-0.0661446229,
-0.191015318,
0.1202000454,
-0.4619502127,
-0.0943428576,
-0.2604257464,
0.652564168,
-0.033098802,
0.3186174929,
0.2089712471,
-0.1937113553,
-0.2270415574,
0.1084807515,
0.4284439385,
0.4135559201,
-0.2466003746,
0.1459463835,
0.2287711948,
-0.572996974,
-0.0548729487,
0.0108961239,
-0.4408342242,
-0.0306476373,
0.0912783295,
0.6809718013,
0.0406632908,
-0.395691663,
0.4495666623,
-0.2322723418,
0.0711918324,
0.3206736147,
0.1374588311,
-0.0115618575,
0.3704909384,
0.1647143215,
0.3194188178,
0.5533520579,
-0.5726997852,
0.0858897939,
0.4546631575,
-0.643863976,
-0.0955507904,
1.0534796715,
0.3340170383,
-0.2820364237,
0.1304263771,
-0.314383477,
-0.5001980066,
0.6117845178,
0.3563800752,
0.7886417508,
-0.2214159369,
0.1228438616,
0.2953547239,
0.7244433761,
-0.1027776748,
0.1287571341,
-0.2205936313,
-0.7106807232,
-0.484847486,
-0.8866770864,
0.1490751505,
-0.146610111,
-0.5695854425,
0.1899104118,
-0.5278424621,
-0.4781900942,
0.0784773752,
-0.3054300547,
-0.8569046855,
0.3857709765,
0.4327627122,
0.4216532409,
-0.9363342524,
0.2675239146,
0.5605772734,
-0.0450414345,
-0.2657940388,
0.1177371591,
-0.3153238297,
-0.4246847332,
0.5852440596,
0.4427132905,
-0.0532376096,
-0.0084086759,
-0.6932718754,
-0.881854713,
0.3537970781,
0.8108838797,
-0.5480302572,
-0.0506437011,
0.085139662,
0.4382235408,
-0.0763537958,
0.2352908105,
0.4522409737,
0.4459517896,
-0.5565009713,
-0.7326349616,
-0.061044652,
-0.027313659,
0.0677453578,
-0.0939244106,
-0.6397737861,
0.6157230735,
-0.2703215778,
-0.1701362729,
-0.5785440207,
0.6280595064,
0.1701300591,
0.375556916,
0.5104208589,
0.4353049099,
0.7656164765,
-0.0830878466,
1.1752114296,
0.0482293367,
0.1979737729,
1.2739025354,
-0.3532876372,
0.3252435029,
0.7447474003,
-0.202454254,
-0.1286310852,
0.4301580191,
0.387765497,
0.6999157667,
0.4090556204,
-0.1646302938,
-0.1887726188,
-0.5496687889,
-0.3292229176,
0.1542012244,
0.0708436593,
-0.4735657275,
-0.1597401202,
0.2315159589,
0.013467364,
0.3461004496,
-0.6606722474,
0.7726139426,
0.1820938736,
-0.5005885959,
0.05295977,
0.2325143218,
1.050150156,
-0.266664654,
0.0999371707,
-0.1837443858,
0.08041583,
-0.2505610287,
-0.4090514481,
0.2648788095,
0.0193696376,
-0.8201280236,
-0.4300415814,
0.6258546114,
-0.4786418676,
-0.6415067315,
0.2635928392,
-0.0664285347,
-0.0547600463,
-0.3409307897,
-0.6342222095,
-0.0152060036,
0.1471675336,
-0.3299515545,
0.4704058468,
0.6251398325,
-0.0903757587,
0.5807008147,
0.6327422261,
-0.1100799069,
0.4232138395,
0.4264241755,
0.6295371056,
-0.4250810444,
-0.9012241364,
-0.9485960603,
0.4699083567,
-0.3159991205,
-0.1117829531,
0.5009236932,
0.3140239716,
0.9609571099,
0.0527723022,
0.732060492,
0.0634658039,
0.3554808795,
-0.3075780272,
0.8467197418,
-0.4401296377,
-0.0106314048,
-0.6018491387,
-0.8629892468,
-0.4449717999,
0.8142607212,
-0.5055523515,
0.2524249554,
0.4276021421,
0.6077951193,
0.1548099071,
-0.1288028359,
0.2636457682,
-0.050320182,
0.1388345063,
0.5451289415,
0.5149053931,
-0.4295742512,
0.3196528554,
-0.1311359853,
-0.2654532194,
-0.2394089103,
-0.7505098581,
-0.9698780775,
-0.1557728797,
-0.2520844936,
-0.3255622089,
0.262411505,
0.9854583144,
0.6404888034,
-0.5032853484,
0.0636112988,
0.1497482955,
0.4224669635,
-0.0494042262,
-0.2843619585,
0.1979432553,
-0.72797364,
-0.9646676183,
-0.3171967864,
0.4160767496,
-0.2102726549,
-0.0188427996,
0.2545597255,
-0.3532362878,
0.1190124527,
0.8858691454,
-0.2296664268,
-0.3166175187,
-0.1927852333,
-0.2683902979,
-0.2888909876,
0.0095952768,
0.597219348,
-0.6893687844,
0.4893155098,
0.5122058392,
0.7333272099,
0.22410357,
-0.0785874799,
0.7317841053,
-0.8906235099,
0.6021053791,
0.4012129605,
0.1168168783,
0.4686710536,
-0.7645327449,
0.4974218607,
0.239223823,
-0.3316400051,
-1.2187210321,
0.0570848398,
-0.6247797012,
-0.1710962653,
1.0072475672,
0.3344534039,
-0.4755928814,
-0.30099684,
-0.3452558815,
0.4162275195,
-0.5624397397,
1.0946816206,
0.6920297742,
0.2385174334,
-0.064119406,
-0.7340279818,
0.8328562975,
0.7656438351,
-0.7287148833,
0.3245595396,
0.275542438,
0.002144296,
0.0893336684,
0.9043297172,
-0.2258821279,
0.4927701056,
-0.2814950049,
0.2749279439,
0.4334869385,
-0.3488959372,
-0.3141595423,
0.2321621031,
-0.237049222,
-0.0838338211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13086v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13086v1 | LMGQS: A Large-scale Dataset for Query-focused Summarization | 2023-05-22T14:53:45 | 2023-05-22T14:53:45 | Ruochen Xu, Song Wang, Yang Liu, Shuohang Wang, Yichong Xu, Dan Iter, Chenguang Zhu, Michael Zeng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Query-focused summarization (QFS) aims to extract or generate a summary of an
input document that directly answers or is relevant to a given query. The lack
of large-scale datasets in the form of documents, queries, and summaries has
hindered model development in this area. In contrast, multiple large-scale
high-quality datasets for generic summarization exist. We hypothesize that
there is a hidden query for each summary sentence in a generic summarization
annotation, and we utilize a large-scale pretrained language model to recover
it. In this way, we convert four generic summarization benchmarks into a new
QFS benchmark dataset, LMGQS, which consists of over 1 million
document-query-summary samples. We thoroughly investigate the properties of our
proposed dataset and establish baselines with state-of-the-art summarization
models. By fine-tuning a language model on LMGQS, we achieve state-of-the-art
zero-shot and supervised performance on multiple existing QFS benchmarks,
demonstrating the high quality and diversity of LMGQS. | [
-0.3787938952,
-0.6612180471,
0.3529384732,
-0.1622743905,
-0.3368678689,
0.1368513107,
-0.0575409383,
-0.1270607561,
0.4108668864,
0.8104652762,
-0.6435195804,
-0.7184930444,
-0.5668439865,
0.1804929823,
-0.6717087626,
1.2912977934,
0.113229543,
-0.1505317986,
-0.1549049169,
-0.311942935,
0.027998982,
-0.5351679921,
-0.308239609,
0.0905795321,
0.7084638476,
0.3143637478,
0.6360402107,
0.4098652601,
0.4368629754,
0.0532270297,
-0.1065193787,
0.3276782632,
-0.9671701193,
0.2699801624,
0.0204905886,
-0.4539426565,
-0.4139629602,
-0.0737094879,
0.9524484277,
0.867146492,
-0.2474441528,
0.3590407968,
0.0636981949,
0.7762198448,
-0.9863325357,
0.0848448575,
-0.5865690708,
0.2509581149,
-0.087540932,
-0.0037266444,
-0.2858915925,
-0.6142566204,
0.0476496257,
-0.5950461626,
0.3770226836,
0.1091920286,
0.8800553679,
0.0663406625,
-0.77442348,
0.1026015356,
-0.4313481152,
0.618213594,
-0.8180935979,
0.1322675794,
0.3592337966,
0.6175780892,
-0.091751568,
-0.9829852581,
-0.3518723845,
-0.0443497747,
-0.154584378,
0.1960145235,
-0.1494799852,
0.2280224264,
0.3626049757,
0.7594025731,
-0.7534344792,
0.0303645432,
-0.2586711645,
-0.0917773545,
0.6543346047,
0.5458583236,
-0.0584699251,
0.0128036058,
-0.0584419928,
0.0973487124,
-0.9300950766,
0.2241701186,
-0.0388385169,
0.3975564837,
0.128591612,
0.6254059076,
-1.0480686426,
0.8245569468,
-0.1918392032,
-0.2364713401,
0.1503777504,
-0.3562297821,
-0.4139325321,
-0.2828674912,
0.9634726644,
0.6617012024,
0.3222754896,
-0.3890846968,
-0.3918420076,
-0.4090649784,
-0.0213299636,
-1.2496579885,
-0.0371413939,
0.4015339613,
-0.3274244964,
-0.3448774517,
0.0270149987,
-0.2380633354,
-0.3595431447,
-0.0458172746,
0.4352612197,
-0.1089197248,
-0.0873000547,
0.0541297607,
-0.3257496357,
0.1191132814,
0.171043396,
-0.8643795848,
0.2002390623,
0.5980494618,
0.6387894154,
-0.2534154356,
-0.3629779816,
-0.5781905651,
0.3692774773,
-0.4255689085,
0.8784416914,
-0.401358813,
-0.5065922141,
0.090245679,
0.1815530956,
-0.0452530682,
-0.7112361789,
0.3592673242,
-0.4915295541,
0.2655811012,
-0.4955964983,
-0.5966798067,
-0.1659360677,
0.5929690003,
-0.5085261464,
1.1881505251,
0.3138923645,
-0.7452480197,
0.4153213501,
-0.3599492908,
-0.5119014382,
0.0158842709,
-0.1684396118,
-0.3461436629,
0.1791430414,
0.4769540131,
0.5878136754,
-0.395396471,
0.5812367201,
-0.2950000763,
-0.6597132683,
0.0851889998,
-0.0643587857,
0.4144013524,
0.0436502323,
-0.063735269,
0.3056992292,
-0.62693578,
0.0566352494,
0.1985744089,
-0.1846895367,
-0.0711925477,
0.0788469464,
-0.348578006,
0.0988469124,
0.2502190471,
-0.3612287045,
0.2634093761,
-0.2238166183,
0.249226138,
0.202674672,
0.2620531023,
0.2592299283,
-0.2185102999,
0.6610022187,
-0.0954217762,
0.323045969,
-0.5788255334,
-0.0767132491,
-0.3908846974,
-0.3535649776,
0.3516537249,
0.321136415,
-0.8284701109,
0.1239483654,
-0.3773025572,
-0.4589353204,
-0.4148640037,
-0.0528246611,
0.4048409462,
0.685152173,
0.220322758,
-0.0591411367,
-0.1822089255,
-1.1869674921,
-0.4578437507,
0.2161248475,
-0.4283326268,
0.1973427832,
0.3380674422,
0.2112086117,
0.912730217,
-0.9654006958,
-0.4291018546,
-0.3939476013,
-0.0367557034,
0.4278204441,
0.2169083208,
0.6756324768,
-0.5467615128,
-0.3141729832,
-0.353510797,
-0.9314079285,
0.0740258992,
0.2541981936,
-0.2325080484,
-0.292781204,
0.8351260424,
-0.6387062073,
0.1866634488,
0.3191333115,
-0.3368982673,
0.6282867789,
0.0347841643,
0.2675222456,
-1.2146657705,
0.1754151136,
-0.3414636254,
-0.2524779737,
-0.4148311615,
0.4181209505,
0.2264827043,
-0.3667195439,
-0.2717180848,
0.2284284681,
-0.5220359564,
-0.1505246013,
-0.2818078697,
0.33079651,
0.2264712602,
0.6395251155,
-0.151223734,
0.8195717931,
0.5839607716,
-0.4818047583,
0.2962660789,
0.1728734672,
-0.2628677487,
0.41390118,
-0.9663484097,
-0.1346307695,
-0.4470158815,
0.4798522592,
-0.9712580442,
-0.295066148,
-0.0813950151,
-0.465419203,
0.1538463682,
-0.2727141976,
-0.6042584777,
-0.1556367278,
-0.5798493624,
0.1776125431,
0.2488039285,
-0.2966026068,
0.5847831368,
0.5924975276,
-0.362695992,
-0.7372332811,
-0.3990940452,
0.1285571605,
0.061140433,
-0.2766800523,
0.1643363088,
0.1774072945,
0.0167539138,
-0.0896073878,
-0.0254714582,
-0.0077969246,
0.0930868536,
0.3356942236,
0.0313185044,
-0.400182426,
0.2131346464,
0.4159618616,
0.1871528029,
0.1282808483,
-0.225883022,
0.3201550841,
0.0879952088,
-0.1016400307,
0.0235130452,
0.6199430227,
0.6483103037,
-0.6522861123,
0.8757568598,
0.4599660635,
-0.2956643403,
-0.1797512472,
-0.3898963928,
-0.0011282091,
-0.4119464755,
0.553719461,
-0.4327697158,
-1.2857542038,
0.4960946143,
-0.0461964719,
0.3815789819,
0.6803461909,
0.1816924065,
-0.1159924343,
1.1177177429,
0.5658759475,
-0.3089744747,
0.3841319382,
-0.3451233804,
-0.2071118802,
-0.8023120165,
-0.2814518809,
-0.4955714643,
-0.2161900997,
-0.3990820646,
-0.0856333375,
0.4799928367,
0.189318791,
-0.2650671899,
0.0697467104,
-0.2785320878,
0.6599628329,
0.4512403607,
0.062380258,
0.3283212483,
-0.0869555697,
-0.094882749,
0.2355662584,
-0.6316322088,
-0.2557562888,
1.237523675,
0.0051435069,
0.447196275,
0.3186432421,
0.7110792994,
0.2961243689,
0.3242965639,
-0.7428957224,
0.5908682942,
-0.1762192398,
-0.618209362,
-0.4843128622,
-0.6411322355,
-1.154643774,
0.6537586451,
-0.3461244702,
-0.6112679839,
-0.1043652594,
0.0759587958,
-0.5053602457,
0.0485506579,
-0.7951796055,
0.9534853697,
0.1625083238,
-0.1583860517,
-0.0812055543,
-0.6137577891,
0.5511175394,
0.0435002111,
0.086047627,
-0.4314069748,
0.0253315307,
0.7150936127,
-0.5400832295,
0.5243836641,
-0.2583705187,
-0.1276222765,
0.2518330514,
0.0927551687,
0.4865794778,
0.0796537027,
-0.0050736088,
-0.1915260702,
0.1924937218,
-0.6300007701,
-0.6150414944,
0.5304599404,
-0.3686799407,
-0.6843422651,
-0.1127933785,
-0.5905847549,
-0.5403508544,
0.4597814381,
0.3160884976,
0.6686276793,
-0.4219608605,
0.2715547383,
0.5632424355,
-0.0323449522,
0.4849608839,
0.7818090916,
-0.5339779854,
-0.361605227,
0.7595028281,
0.2693102658,
0.1800196916,
0.4726079106,
-0.1847566962,
-0.1825373918,
-0.8391273618,
-0.4855397344,
0.239216581,
-0.5252331495,
-0.3221482635,
-0.7176206708,
-0.0516070947,
-0.5565588474,
0.1213637143,
-0.1684058607,
-0.6181883216,
-0.1395893246,
-0.1830717027,
0.276902765,
0.6176268458,
0.534236908,
0.3108016253,
-1.1004698277,
0.6895651817,
0.2445510328,
0.446480751,
-0.0112418244,
-0.6167122722,
-0.5368368626,
-0.1370092481,
-0.1226452813,
-0.7656433582,
0.3810227215,
0.2894656658,
0.5463689566,
0.5012427568,
0.4099614024,
0.3712925911,
-0.3130146265,
0.8926733136,
-0.0626497567,
-0.5718895793,
0.657497704,
-0.6938915253,
0.7756214738,
0.8440623879,
0.491832763,
-0.4270496368,
-0.4634645283,
-0.3778418005,
-0.944758296,
0.5235424638,
0.0782319754,
-0.0567972623,
0.0434996895,
0.4361953139,
-0.0180182923,
0.4439484775,
-0.2968020439,
-0.1418486238,
-0.0283289105,
-0.2000894547,
-0.4243633449,
-0.3291870356,
-0.23798953,
-0.0877992436,
0.4842373133,
-0.4005245864,
-0.1850548983,
0.0707183555,
-0.278101325,
0.1601381153,
0.1400343031,
0.5186182857,
0.6789085865,
-0.5433056951,
-0.0308102611,
0.2109257132,
-0.6147583127,
-0.178897202,
0.3810956478,
-0.3602838218,
0.1301171035,
0.2496475279,
0.6775405407,
0.1503687799,
-0.8511869907,
0.5688230991,
-0.3491672277,
-0.2312497199,
-0.2155371159,
0.0726259574,
0.2081687897,
0.1891020089,
0.7139056325,
-0.528463304,
0.4955613315,
-0.5197429061,
0.0566990636,
0.4874820709,
-0.3477558494,
-0.0896932185,
0.640545547,
0.182330817,
0.2364753038,
0.4762954712,
-0.1104172692,
-0.2110626996,
0.4582873583,
0.1577520818,
0.7541213632,
0.0352573022,
0.1150848493,
0.5802173018,
0.2974893153,
-0.1230777726,
0.2548677325,
-0.3978106081,
-0.3646368682,
-0.4744345248,
-0.565413177,
-0.560349226,
-0.0726451203,
-1.0648787022,
-0.0328222252,
-0.4093306661,
-0.2350873947,
-0.0081596179,
-0.0304803625,
-0.1117277518,
0.47814399,
-0.2330730259,
0.9069353938,
-0.5210130811,
0.6428067088,
0.3424348235,
-0.4868514538,
-0.6962968707,
-0.0133094033,
-0.2739815712,
-0.6972690225,
0.1587673128,
0.0438383259,
-0.0608451255,
0.0400837027,
-0.6068653464,
-0.9195497036,
1.2711327076,
0.3893285096,
-0.605216682,
-0.2145423144,
0.1484336257,
0.3682429492,
-0.3068604171,
0.2228397727,
0.7255578637,
-0.0881463289,
0.0309843794,
-0.8360306621,
0.190847069,
-0.3106649816,
-0.1711554229,
0.494141221,
-0.7609227896,
0.8307263851,
-0.266510129,
-0.0600160919,
-0.1662591547,
0.6750389338,
0.2501757741,
0.3468341827,
0.0168479923,
0.5413999557,
0.6469804645,
-0.2311006188,
1.2491173744,
-0.2713452876,
0.3953803778,
1.3005834818,
-0.2367763519,
1.0577977896,
0.1243880019,
-0.1725387275,
0.1000041068,
0.5459667444,
0.0761200637,
0.4874581397,
0.2574963272,
-0.3056995869,
-0.1354992539,
-0.1773614734,
-0.6268747449,
0.2890296578,
0.3486038148,
-0.5557480454,
-0.4100250304,
-0.2136799246,
0.0910511836,
-0.2427925915,
-0.5705544949,
0.9376396537,
-0.0255443919,
-0.7566674948,
0.8877612352,
-0.1344794035,
0.6237513423,
-0.7471511364,
0.2505292594,
-0.685146451,
-0.0651416555,
-0.1950888485,
-0.7864717841,
0.1194408685,
-0.0132383406,
-0.2805525362,
0.1430877,
0.5532183051,
-0.4191747904,
-0.4335053861,
-0.0851327926,
0.5465732217,
0.1955391616,
-0.5914493203,
-0.2498170435,
-0.2709540129,
-0.0530725531,
-0.3208155632,
0.6812905073,
0.5804125071,
-0.0117733264,
0.5507828593,
0.5416999459,
-0.0834718272,
-0.2481768727,
0.4529542625,
1.0432165861,
-0.9487035275,
-0.5620301366,
-0.5928704143,
0.2795603871,
-0.1459701955,
-0.4582148492,
0.7922389507,
0.8862306476,
0.5656919479,
-0.0439722277,
0.7740757465,
0.4930655062,
0.89739573,
-0.5370956063,
1.0083751678,
-0.6364245415,
-0.050881546,
-0.1774023324,
-0.7674809098,
-0.314943552,
-0.0218195412,
-0.0376012027,
-0.0247567538,
0.3780839741,
0.8613991737,
0.2674071789,
-0.1473702937,
0.5411862731,
0.1655079722,
0.1272037029,
0.4666385353,
0.817484498,
-0.4243537486,
0.7603104115,
0.0577367619,
-0.0845419317,
-0.2978827357,
-0.6342988014,
-0.9436739683,
-0.3968534768,
-0.1880987883,
-0.2442627251,
0.1185703874,
0.5691380501,
0.4562940598,
-0.7515455484,
-0.1916219145,
0.2615598738,
-0.0334855244,
-0.0060036709,
-0.2140746713,
0.4598897099,
-0.1076900065,
-0.4865071177,
0.3583130538,
0.3117285669,
0.0969675258,
-0.0628511235,
0.2370738834,
0.0258433707,
0.0686885566,
0.8887437582,
0.3952074051,
-0.4329347014,
0.169993028,
0.2179735005,
-0.1986227185,
-0.0778010339,
0.8261713386,
-0.8916681409,
0.1399219334,
0.2159884572,
0.4551235735,
0.9373164177,
-0.0110834213,
0.594632566,
-0.8695729971,
0.0441958196,
0.2165602893,
0.3804453313,
0.1265580952,
-0.2413361967,
0.4455264211,
-0.0732827485,
-0.2542127967,
-1.0017328262,
0.0979805663,
-0.9336068034,
-0.3854947388,
1.0222004652,
-0.2772604525,
-0.1285758317,
0.0701132938,
-0.2978446186,
0.1669037044,
-0.3463567197,
0.5891172886,
0.3653513789,
-0.1163368672,
-0.3850862086,
-0.4012456536,
0.5545130968,
0.4425954521,
-0.8951622248,
0.2226522863,
0.7231447697,
0.3770500422,
-0.2528384924,
0.7553901672,
-0.2220557183,
0.2620745003,
0.022241028,
0.0389054865,
-0.2980827391,
0.0266770385,
-0.2638285458,
0.8027437329,
0.0993831083,
-0.2365217954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13085v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13085v2 | Decomposed Prompting for Machine Translation Between Related Languages using Large Language Models | 2023-05-22T14:52:47 | 2023-10-23T02:30:20 | Ratish Puduppully, Anoop Kunchukuttan, Raj Dabre, Ai Ti Aw, Nancy F. Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study investigates machine translation between related languages i.e.,
languages within the same family that share linguistic characteristics such as
word order and lexical similarity. Machine translation through few-shot
prompting leverages a small set of translation pair examples to generate
translations for test sentences. This procedure requires the model to learn how
to generate translations while simultaneously ensuring that token ordering is
maintained to produce a fluent and accurate translation. We propose that for
related languages, the task of machine translation can be simplified by
leveraging the monotonic alignment characteristic of such languages. We
introduce DecoMT, a novel approach of few-shot prompting that decomposes the
translation process into a sequence of word chunk translations. Through
automatic and human evaluation conducted on multiple related language pairs
across various language families, we demonstrate that our proposed approach of
decomposed prompting surpasses multiple established few-shot baseline
approaches. For example, DecoMT outperforms the strong few-shot prompting BLOOM
model with an average improvement of 8 chrF++ scores across the examined
languages. | [
-0.3597030044,
-0.7473602891,
0.4560796022,
0.0819525495,
-0.461689204,
-0.1656746417,
-0.2389484644,
-0.2786162496,
-0.1413686126,
0.2936561108,
-0.9200285077,
-0.4647399485,
-0.4412661195,
0.5379093885,
-0.3864979744,
0.8687726259,
-0.023641251,
0.061720971,
0.1795764863,
-0.2437838167,
-0.5998573899,
-0.2229946107,
-0.5410601497,
-0.4323158562,
0.5119180679,
0.469860673,
0.6524912715,
0.6804449558,
0.5178664327,
0.3004226387,
-0.2462200224,
0.258713305,
-0.432839334,
0.2251936346,
-0.0125860134,
-0.4727456868,
-0.1492105126,
-0.3963447809,
0.7267381549,
0.8356258869,
0.2694189548,
0.3034538627,
0.3112272918,
0.6036342978,
-0.5289679766,
0.0700007305,
-0.6115499139,
-0.0311912429,
0.0049804151,
-0.3959359527,
-0.6218360066,
-0.3244885504,
-0.1111721396,
-0.1646618545,
0.3029481471,
-0.1221422702,
0.6251892447,
0.2999456525,
-0.2949393094,
-0.0569905601,
-0.6669645309,
0.7178093195,
-0.6314219236,
0.2476415485,
0.3976806402,
0.2145464122,
-0.2283465564,
-0.3189623952,
-0.4820850194,
0.0368198603,
-0.2290680408,
0.0965268239,
-0.3475840688,
0.0353738442,
0.1887040883,
0.1747622341,
-0.8179633021,
0.1731228381,
-0.3893437982,
-0.0315532722,
0.2337708175,
0.480433166,
0.3522360027,
-0.3876844645,
-0.5472474098,
-0.2772188485,
-0.8187199831,
-0.026976835,
0.1016432345,
0.7875504494,
-0.2666483223,
0.5706329346,
-0.2590183318,
0.8616460562,
-0.0249505192,
-0.2155487984,
0.0058957012,
-0.5930341482,
-0.1906982064,
0.2955458164,
0.8171737194,
0.3807815313,
0.1975107938,
0.188155517,
-0.1484895945,
0.0095725283,
-0.1337030679,
-0.7523310781,
-0.0356463902,
0.1379711032,
-0.5803681016,
-0.2041240931,
-0.0946809724,
-0.648812592,
-0.224326998,
-0.1714205593,
0.4469933212,
-0.6520482898,
-0.104775466,
0.0456249267,
-0.0700921938,
0.3991640508,
0.2446067035,
-0.9496557117,
0.1622385234,
0.9708971977,
0.9932848811,
-0.1974967867,
-0.7104564309,
-0.6303088069,
0.0642849505,
-0.375649035,
0.6225420237,
-0.503562212,
-0.5353051424,
0.0180856679,
-0.221333921,
-0.0723661333,
-0.5421900749,
0.1242623702,
-0.5103619099,
0.2219096571,
-0.2314364463,
-0.3430764675,
-0.2293312848,
0.6210901737,
-0.4358535707,
0.8961639404,
0.1574837416,
-0.7592615485,
0.29990834,
-0.6213023067,
-0.4344355166,
0.1579501182,
0.1274575442,
-0.299045831,
0.1428178102,
0.3401048183,
0.4109443724,
-0.1166478172,
-0.1114494428,
-0.0438483246,
-0.3500228226,
0.0155827701,
-0.4701784849,
0.8439348936,
0.3285855055,
0.0189381037,
0.2815286219,
-0.3648501039,
0.026024824,
0.0860405341,
-0.3885595202,
-0.3604774773,
-0.4686915576,
-0.1959125251,
0.251952678,
0.1635049582,
-0.1333817691,
0.5300432444,
-0.6949318051,
0.4698467255,
0.4534676373,
0.4082972705,
0.5298407674,
-0.0669945106,
0.7280998826,
0.0909265503,
-0.1289684772,
-0.945343852,
-0.5133452415,
-0.47388044,
-0.5205402374,
0.2704698741,
0.6587285399,
-0.5240826607,
0.1813054085,
-0.5433697701,
-0.0607853197,
-0.8520631194,
0.2661623657,
0.5890456438,
0.5694372654,
0.4066642821,
-0.0842161998,
-0.3785425723,
-0.6008737087,
-0.1524213105,
-0.2170030624,
-0.0041809855,
-0.3814594746,
0.3202749491,
-0.2580052614,
0.6607875228,
-0.3705335259,
-0.09109658,
-0.4593518376,
0.5541368723,
0.2237311453,
0.4349627197,
0.3536126614,
-0.422993511,
-0.442084074,
0.3818297684,
-0.3701778054,
0.0702067539,
-0.1613382399,
-0.1546759903,
0.2701057792,
0.5308583975,
-0.5851675272,
0.2665949762,
0.5058194399,
0.0597591326,
0.4106697738,
-0.1174756214,
0.454452306,
-1.3666769266,
0.2836745977,
-0.473616451,
-0.5132110119,
-0.5512771606,
0.4396117926,
0.0072168536,
-0.2439781129,
-0.7164245248,
0.5232736468,
-0.5729988217,
-0.208079502,
-0.4355466962,
0.0689443946,
-0.1075831726,
0.2528958023,
0.0711655319,
0.7088928223,
0.3900195956,
-0.6751055121,
0.1730124354,
0.3700319231,
-0.1607932299,
0.4494103491,
-0.5096901059,
0.1207366884,
-0.0592398122,
0.0119686536,
-1.2076150179,
-0.2783277631,
0.177504614,
-0.5592602491,
0.3333767653,
-0.4938772917,
-0.7293877602,
-0.3033639789,
-0.3484559357,
0.5742532611,
0.7804409862,
-0.2904699445,
-0.0058992328,
-0.2999849617,
-0.3564631641,
-0.2774375975,
-0.8006383181,
0.0010677935,
-0.2164364159,
-0.5771573782,
0.2142302096,
0.0777756795,
-0.1397472918,
-0.0605487898,
0.0663713589,
-0.1528446227,
-0.0036483838,
-0.0582514703,
0.3284520507,
-0.4834028482,
0.0683804378,
0.292560935,
-0.3619948626,
-0.2369040549,
-0.3533521891,
0.7443360686,
0.0051872903,
-0.3147308528,
-0.5157305598,
0.5346013904,
0.6475440264,
-0.3518180251,
0.7369543314,
0.6027872562,
-0.3989760876,
-0.0185078997,
-0.1680695415,
-0.5564280152,
-0.4375831783,
0.0678652525,
-0.7961438298,
-0.7330185175,
0.5593965054,
-0.2375017554,
0.1767005622,
0.2511141002,
0.8712437153,
-0.0209331606,
1.3135119677,
0.6004448533,
-0.1298623979,
0.4960363805,
-0.104668133,
0.1158859506,
-0.4624741077,
0.2475883514,
-0.6130680442,
-0.4461101592,
-0.4836678207,
-0.3539929688,
0.4172107577,
0.3309255838,
0.0034618902,
0.7351967692,
-0.4403320849,
0.7711127996,
0.5856619477,
-0.0603593588,
0.5644342303,
0.1541509181,
-0.367146641,
-0.0174112879,
-0.7650702596,
-0.5215697885,
0.4705687463,
-0.0408838205,
0.5557450056,
-0.055934988,
1.2622205019,
-0.0740062743,
-0.0401931815,
-1.1491364241,
0.4205613434,
0.024671264,
-0.4343481362,
-0.2596521676,
-0.4540663362,
-1.2678558826,
0.1607627571,
-0.1449243575,
-0.7305633426,
-0.1962287277,
0.1756071448,
-0.4238091707,
-0.1047197804,
-0.6401082277,
1.0045949221,
0.0391409509,
-0.0778507069,
-0.2666799724,
-0.9452109337,
0.5219689608,
0.0816423893,
-0.0004074082,
0.0330584869,
0.0303526372,
0.2206948251,
-0.4887092412,
0.7187644839,
0.2287431061,
-0.1043861955,
0.3137176335,
0.7335915565,
0.4943336546,
-0.3673089445,
-0.2513383627,
-0.0410978161,
0.1892049164,
-0.4792760909,
-0.5847017169,
0.7332714796,
-0.3451187015,
-0.4325442612,
-0.0154440394,
-0.6417247057,
-0.0151264723,
0.5664684772,
0.6588025689,
0.141221866,
0.0377294123,
-0.2780700922,
0.3711332083,
0.0371208116,
0.5114574432,
0.2730122507,
-0.3810186684,
-0.3999647498,
0.6635155082,
-0.1147098094,
0.4765492976,
0.4964714646,
0.425663501,
-0.2779019177,
-0.4184177518,
-0.7192817926,
0.3115884066,
-0.783532083,
-0.3347734213,
-0.424548924,
0.2666269243,
-0.5786368251,
-0.4367363751,
-0.2539734244,
-0.3594401777,
-0.1070207432,
-0.1024951488,
0.3190704286,
0.6432420611,
0.1979346722,
0.2270601839,
-1.4995030165,
0.4311712682,
0.0981997475,
-0.1914948821,
-0.1218467504,
-0.5892158747,
0.0670867488,
-0.0023913775,
-0.2602275312,
-1.0901869535,
0.4111120105,
0.0431583859,
0.2345940769,
0.4751374424,
0.2317390442,
1.1601915359,
-0.798568368,
0.8169455528,
0.4267377853,
-1.1441925764,
0.7190638185,
-0.3914296031,
0.803755343,
0.8240020275,
0.4317752719,
-0.7113128901,
-0.4310739338,
-0.3294067681,
-0.6304020882,
0.6910523772,
0.0147585245,
0.3245049119,
-0.1973402351,
0.0576736555,
0.2544027567,
-0.0109362192,
-0.4548541605,
-0.0929427743,
0.2821806073,
-0.4409856796,
0.177185148,
0.0755496249,
-0.0774055347,
-0.1148444563,
0.2467557937,
-0.1441466659,
0.1018142849,
0.0894455388,
-0.2608959973,
-0.2412984073,
0.533864975,
0.8268085122,
0.3878546655,
0.2302096188,
0.4106631577,
0.3018911183,
-0.0447803549,
0.3039454222,
-0.1667318642,
-0.3577632606,
0.113412112,
0.5502773523,
0.5735932589,
0.2498793155,
-0.4393357038,
0.2860919833,
0.3687042892,
-0.0054548825,
0.4698602557,
-0.2012643367,
0.1463046968,
0.0222669691,
0.1091113985,
0.0512924567,
0.2348625958,
-0.6677296758,
0.2442664355,
0.2813539505,
-0.482185185,
-0.4841901958,
0.3999975622,
0.1720680296,
-0.3625461459,
0.6706746817,
-0.4348323941,
-0.7650785446,
0.2346806228,
0.7315754294,
0.9316582084,
-0.3835052252,
0.0225056615,
0.7114687562,
0.4622107744,
-0.3384833336,
0.2014843374,
-0.2740341127,
-0.3049963117,
-0.5715253353,
-0.4450813532,
-0.233704105,
-0.1591886133,
-0.493802458,
0.6518520713,
-0.1933317631,
0.0015611723,
-0.1793678254,
-0.4151339829,
-0.373455584,
-0.297318399,
0.2865729332,
0.7063226104,
-0.8567131162,
0.7871592045,
0.7881249785,
-0.5789227486,
-0.8541669846,
0.1318493783,
0.2849474251,
-0.6854386926,
0.6425901651,
0.3171778023,
-0.4270400703,
0.3216536343,
-0.3811989725,
-0.4262361526,
0.716319263,
0.5474786162,
-0.2803399563,
0.1194963008,
0.2010440975,
0.4817553461,
-0.1230062097,
-0.0695394129,
0.4967584312,
0.4493302703,
0.2267518789,
-0.9285883307,
0.259662658,
0.0549718291,
-0.0619596317,
0.6518669724,
-0.3298325241,
0.4881375134,
-0.3086171448,
-0.6250206828,
0.1888350397,
0.526971519,
0.1253699213,
0.3215949237,
0.1953469813,
0.2889581323,
0.4699947536,
0.2188797295,
0.9110882878,
-0.2968017757,
0.3662227094,
1.1731764078,
-0.2599629164,
1.1664277315,
0.7409647703,
-0.1093805581,
0.2059069127,
0.4778106809,
0.2253458798,
0.4155850112,
-0.0405146629,
-0.3588298857,
-0.3074506819,
-0.0040948647,
-0.2380004823,
0.3546443582,
0.1912166476,
-0.4974426329,
-0.5013792515,
0.1248401925,
0.1599085927,
0.1086706668,
-0.2805027664,
1.0566655397,
0.2455048561,
-1.0845929384,
1.0807811022,
0.072463423,
0.5149086118,
-0.5317419171,
-0.2147427201,
-0.3297612965,
-0.004335654,
-0.3016726971,
-0.7221989036,
0.5457212925,
0.2816318572,
-0.2684985995,
-0.2857641578,
0.5814991593,
-0.6778680086,
-0.3574056029,
0.0157544911,
0.5361236334,
0.3450828195,
0.1038510501,
-0.7023541927,
0.1162910983,
-0.189575538,
-0.0218388587,
0.1495133787,
0.3373663127,
-0.1172521636,
0.5040080547,
0.6011698842,
-0.0692293197,
0.4654116333,
0.0906108022,
0.4251637757,
-0.5763550997,
-0.4358813465,
-1.148625493,
0.4984116554,
0.3928509355,
-0.2609536946,
0.825433135,
0.4542472363,
0.7401429415,
-0.348008424,
0.4114972353,
0.1987600923,
0.2043869048,
-0.6100019217,
0.5369806886,
-0.3682680428,
0.0348328874,
-0.3600217402,
-1.014341712,
-0.6738945842,
0.3946902454,
-0.1674289107,
-0.215478614,
0.8276715279,
0.9917953014,
-0.2857724726,
-0.2898119688,
0.5704163909,
-0.2213276178,
-0.0708423033,
0.5664569139,
0.6743558049,
-0.4674776495,
0.9041836858,
-0.057813324,
-0.0471978299,
-0.4076667428,
-0.8272736669,
-0.7790209651,
-0.4271585643,
-0.4788651764,
-0.269400239,
-0.2025130093,
1.2156527042,
0.6111194491,
-0.8574514389,
-0.1173352674,
-0.1895736903,
0.2456659526,
-0.6694595814,
-0.2219215035,
0.1696854979,
-0.611671567,
-0.9753755927,
0.5439204574,
0.4128394723,
0.2761414945,
-0.220531106,
-0.0592447296,
-0.101232931,
-0.0209505092,
0.6467667222,
0.3060820103,
-0.7838790417,
-0.0801755637,
0.174785912,
-0.4288880229,
0.1679520905,
0.9985193014,
-0.635134697,
0.623088181,
1.193400383,
0.7857148647,
0.4005302191,
0.2236031741,
0.5270738602,
-0.9850062728,
0.185629949,
0.010714584,
0.1259747595,
0.3093596399,
-0.1467157304,
0.3455593884,
0.0340326875,
-0.1236389056,
-0.8331276178,
0.6617994308,
-0.9043417573,
-0.2969064116,
1.0300955772,
-0.3513345122,
-0.3394345939,
0.0267019607,
-0.5065940619,
0.3553576171,
-0.2366387397,
0.5124527216,
0.653854847,
-0.0037787047,
-0.4252356887,
-0.0939607993,
0.2813231945,
0.5522164106,
-0.5877272487,
0.2359493226,
0.4248552322,
0.0974403396,
0.2510525286,
0.3396182358,
-0.2876242101,
0.4994571805,
0.040147353,
-0.0742936432,
0.0253754202,
-0.0706829801,
-0.913212359,
0.0997423604,
0.3092423379,
-0.3743132949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13083v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13083v1 | InheritSumm: A General, Versatile and Compact Summarizer by Distilling from GPT | 2023-05-22T14:52:32 | 2023-05-22T14:52:32 | Yichong Xu, Ruochen Xu, Dan Iter, Yang Liu, Shuohang Wang, Chenguang Zhu, Michael Zeng | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large models such as GPT-3 demonstrate exceptional performance in
zeroshot and fewshot summarization tasks, their extensive serving and
fine-tuning costs hinder their utilization in various applications. Conversely,
previous studies have found that although automatic metrics tend to favor
smaller fine-tuned models, the quality of the summaries they generate is
inferior to that of larger models like GPT-3 when assessed by human evaluators.
To address this issue, we propose InheritSumm, a versatile and compact
summarization model derived from GPT-3.5 through distillation. InheritSumm not
only exhibits comparable zeroshot and fewshot summarization capabilities to
GPT-3.5 but is also sufficiently compact for fine-tuning purposes. Experimental
results demonstrate that InheritSumm achieves similar or superior performance
to GPT-3.5 in zeroshot and fewshot settings. Furthermore, it outperforms the
previously established best small models in both prefix-tuning and full-data
fine-tuning scenarios. | [
-0.3887417018,
-0.3958479464,
0.5939460397,
0.0413057804,
-0.7090634704,
0.1213819459,
0.0102736717,
-0.4927964211,
0.1832916439,
0.1634035259,
-0.4221922755,
-0.1668920964,
-1.0715843439,
0.076057367,
-0.2350980043,
1.5653367043,
-0.2091949284,
-0.2614578009,
-0.0152008422,
-0.0883214474,
-0.503698349,
-0.1210863218,
-0.4159405529,
-0.6235163212,
0.4935924709,
0.6156179309,
0.6556683779,
0.6939464211,
0.4208574891,
0.1476822495,
-0.1530397385,
0.3218373358,
-0.8876190186,
-0.1391143203,
-0.1924499422,
-0.5142211318,
-0.9288707376,
0.0278234612,
0.5293534398,
0.59004879,
0.0512828752,
0.3512455523,
0.3278770149,
0.8159218431,
-1.1136997938,
0.1135385633,
-0.4769122899,
-0.301671356,
0.1539826542,
-0.1240736246,
0.009896175,
-0.537165761,
0.0684162751,
-0.5073652864,
0.6485996842,
-0.1492894143,
0.8155998588,
0.4524884522,
-0.4377903938,
-0.1351511627,
-0.8884560466,
0.6338871717,
-0.7667790055,
-0.2502074242,
0.0820376351,
0.4707036018,
0.2338937968,
-0.7291751504,
-0.3834029734,
0.0348525606,
-0.2764090598,
0.5260976553,
-0.318492204,
-0.1039617807,
-0.2257982492,
0.7607383728,
-0.6715680957,
0.1400676817,
-0.3743783832,
0.2624995112,
0.489677608,
0.6275467873,
0.1190430224,
0.0656202137,
-0.3824225068,
0.3617938459,
-0.8793210983,
-0.6938939095,
0.2225119919,
0.2999908924,
-0.2906686068,
0.4218291342,
-0.4259068966,
0.7463652492,
0.0582743473,
-0.1813309789,
-0.1952328384,
-0.5401592255,
-0.44881019,
0.1315341592,
0.423088342,
0.6019781232,
0.2516455054,
0.0490713231,
-0.2053182423,
-0.0135013117,
0.0769500732,
-1.2472463846,
-0.814861834,
0.0188175961,
-0.3472282588,
-0.1835401505,
0.2920425832,
-0.2977547646,
-0.2168818861,
-0.4704305828,
0.6708496809,
-0.5902098417,
-0.006132842,
0.0280858483,
-0.7941411138,
0.0858701095,
0.9686415792,
-1.3037563562,
0.5318894982,
0.9255951643,
1.2141606808,
-0.6185527444,
-0.1974765658,
-0.2360925078,
0.4072375,
-0.2614429891,
0.8483715653,
-0.1383896768,
-0.7669047713,
-0.8340670466,
-0.16164805,
-0.0300321989,
-0.7113021016,
0.4918656647,
-0.1853681654,
0.1823362559,
-0.1055976078,
-0.7381396294,
-0.3716065586,
0.1350243986,
-0.5146131516,
0.4660639465,
0.4827601016,
-0.8435766697,
0.8946911693,
-0.6490163803,
-0.4631829858,
0.2847680151,
0.2021194696,
-0.6495930552,
0.5745293498,
0.336215198,
0.5179052949,
-0.0415718891,
-0.1600086391,
-0.4217785597,
-0.6518441439,
-0.7345426679,
-0.341942668,
0.5153008103,
0.4362785816,
-0.0838560537,
0.0452197343,
-0.5043007731,
-0.258074671,
0.1954050958,
0.0063858656,
-0.6384278536,
-0.0980293825,
-0.0938686281,
-0.1246568263,
0.2387393415,
-0.2887032032,
0.4995720983,
-0.0618706681,
0.2629748285,
0.355838865,
0.4717431664,
0.6234758496,
-0.9838901758,
0.5643570423,
0.0684326217,
-0.1003580242,
-0.3497259617,
-0.2040979564,
-0.594148159,
-0.8535977602,
0.2131396532,
0.3187965155,
-0.2626335919,
0.4223750532,
-0.5641571283,
-0.7401911616,
-0.0678562298,
0.1592882127,
-0.1083233804,
0.5705607533,
0.3762112558,
-0.1144879684,
-0.4907776415,
-0.9853736162,
-0.2728756964,
0.0581455976,
-0.3096097708,
0.1435522735,
0.7463163733,
0.0111515466,
1.2070485353,
-1.0176618099,
-0.4324167669,
-0.860150516,
0.3863869905,
0.3265866339,
0.4997555315,
0.8849141598,
-0.6816624403,
-0.6942088604,
-0.1343771219,
-0.4549872279,
-0.2096478343,
-0.0615663491,
0.2173978835,
-0.2171380222,
-0.0966894329,
-0.4551721215,
0.2855848968,
0.2845548689,
-0.431956768,
0.6976562142,
-0.3440124094,
0.2723956406,
-1.3387922049,
0.1244172454,
-0.2487011701,
-0.7173607349,
-0.3348873556,
-0.001557186,
0.2434309274,
0.2729937434,
-0.3039231598,
0.5099623799,
-0.5958333611,
0.110460721,
-0.5349779725,
0.0970183834,
0.1535490304,
-0.002029265,
-0.0312260389,
0.6707080603,
0.0448801182,
-0.774537921,
0.0937544256,
0.3377625644,
-0.1064281985,
0.8486737013,
-1.0592617989,
-0.406247437,
-0.2857439518,
0.3125198781,
-0.944511354,
-0.414937526,
-0.1267575175,
-0.3546387553,
0.6304407716,
-0.3095355034,
-0.4126113951,
-0.0204788521,
-0.6198874712,
0.0903647915,
0.7736752629,
-0.5524845123,
0.605022192,
0.1422659457,
-0.5973373055,
-0.0713034496,
-0.5347370505,
0.1025847718,
-0.5486444831,
-0.356621623,
0.3768349588,
0.1054783762,
-0.2252690345,
-0.0102787279,
-0.2122552693,
0.1702070534,
0.2823436856,
0.3615373969,
0.5839559436,
-0.2188174427,
-0.2083218098,
0.3024935424,
-0.122792922,
-0.5411575437,
-0.4438443482,
0.1313659698,
-0.0962075666,
-0.058386635,
-0.0271719526,
0.136016652,
0.5872532129,
0.0955362096,
0.5034864545,
0.124875173,
-0.136622414,
-0.3227729201,
-0.3074027002,
-0.071107097,
-0.3729357123,
0.3922206759,
-0.3312186897,
-0.8886240721,
0.6006797552,
-0.1278173476,
0.4012122452,
0.8865810633,
0.6344632506,
-0.1104278713,
0.7406322956,
0.6803559661,
-0.2094510943,
0.2924149632,
-0.2626982033,
-0.3248397112,
-0.8599792123,
0.1602716148,
-0.4928482175,
-0.6089049578,
-0.3687790334,
-0.0113012986,
0.5113620758,
0.1872322708,
-0.1586369425,
0.5424777865,
-0.4022704661,
0.8517405987,
0.3047524989,
-0.0958734676,
0.8415958285,
-0.4988350272,
0.5177847743,
0.2409641147,
-0.6865277886,
-0.6437323689,
0.9874455929,
0.0692201704,
0.9708272815,
0.3036312163,
1.0761752129,
0.3550183773,
0.4673052132,
-0.6747972965,
0.0394095331,
-0.5756422281,
-0.6744832397,
-0.2278071642,
-0.5894615054,
-0.6738446951,
0.6423949003,
0.1215011328,
-0.7476034164,
-0.0435233265,
0.389598906,
-0.7276459932,
0.4320257902,
-0.9464502931,
0.6371061802,
0.0948068202,
-0.2696196139,
-0.1380620003,
-0.6017495394,
1.003406167,
-0.3267800808,
-0.1631238163,
-0.3627662361,
-0.2910859883,
0.4814015031,
-0.7441412807,
0.6022141576,
-0.1771383584,
0.086718522,
0.1765860468,
0.3149137199,
0.3630469441,
0.1256686896,
0.251786828,
-0.1804531515,
0.2773259878,
-0.3688383698,
-0.6683177948,
0.8824900985,
-0.6669054031,
-0.3916682899,
-0.3497366309,
-0.4192635715,
-0.1795693785,
0.4435956776,
0.6563205719,
0.161480695,
-0.5030126572,
0.1742882729,
0.3624766171,
0.1436548829,
0.6031255126,
0.5652483106,
0.0796551704,
-0.1280068606,
0.7580833435,
0.053112071,
0.5786709189,
0.5415565372,
0.4673413038,
-0.1500235498,
-0.6530438066,
-0.5513215661,
0.0019482234,
-0.383403033,
-0.3302129805,
-0.7125968337,
0.1449909508,
-0.1894228458,
-0.3231686652,
-0.4956344664,
-0.9832298756,
-0.4655365646,
-0.25057742,
0.3295637667,
0.7338010073,
-0.1803464592,
0.5908629298,
-0.8501117826,
0.8028271794,
0.3915315568,
0.3492184579,
-0.1340574026,
-0.9610626101,
0.0618411973,
-0.072246626,
-0.4263994396,
-0.4727954268,
0.2850414217,
0.7383658886,
0.2516394258,
0.5467636585,
0.1316656768,
0.7329632044,
-0.4088720679,
0.8335411549,
0.0487514995,
-0.8120635748,
0.3993219733,
-0.6120680571,
0.8041520119,
1.1459252834,
0.3308950365,
-0.1595315337,
-0.3807210028,
-0.6631835699,
-0.7483386993,
0.6686913371,
0.1481934637,
-0.0155675635,
0.3790918887,
0.2377180755,
0.673920393,
0.1047058031,
-0.2272400856,
-0.1501035094,
-0.2370733917,
-0.1105966419,
-0.4001216292,
-0.1586456597,
0.0561591014,
-0.1480427533,
0.6405633092,
-0.0093558999,
-0.2066426724,
0.0938104764,
-0.276652813,
0.2789878547,
0.1376444548,
0.7253656983,
0.701554358,
-0.4733718038,
0.5083009601,
0.3200637996,
-0.6925623417,
0.2755047977,
0.0518241823,
-0.3651068807,
0.003806344,
0.5068926811,
0.7329381704,
0.3626491129,
-0.2099246383,
0.4595784843,
-0.0481549613,
-0.4499924481,
0.0918811634,
0.4658522904,
0.2095991224,
-0.2973531187,
0.3334279358,
-0.0435061641,
0.5787468553,
-0.5514343977,
0.3464678526,
0.1926559508,
-0.236198619,
-0.1829027832,
0.9999796748,
0.0988352224,
0.3084427118,
0.4804096222,
-0.2432048172,
-0.2223955244,
0.5760390759,
0.4154692888,
1.2585326433,
0.0438317992,
-0.0404271372,
0.166809544,
0.2931089401,
-0.2235159129,
-0.0575842671,
-0.346560359,
-0.4390844405,
-0.201246962,
-0.6169483066,
-0.6006061435,
-0.3894591331,
-0.5421346426,
0.3681704998,
-0.2931036055,
0.0934026018,
0.3097761273,
-0.1040055901,
-0.3421529233,
0.1856242418,
-0.0562141649,
1.0431382656,
-0.8403667212,
0.5097438097,
0.3610359728,
-0.2493904382,
-0.5951102376,
-0.2330158353,
0.2280604839,
-0.395319432,
0.2418861985,
-0.1194062158,
-0.3526552916,
0.0501846634,
-0.3483815491,
-0.3449123204,
1.3482261896,
0.4109641016,
-0.426604867,
0.0175477061,
-0.3491600752,
0.3587851226,
-0.1723846197,
0.3770297468,
0.8808805346,
0.3631884456,
0.5749979019,
-0.9935441613,
-0.1093043014,
-0.0266833808,
-0.2315475047,
0.4857513309,
-0.7814291716,
0.8600823283,
-0.5553908348,
-0.3761839569,
0.2214921564,
0.36887151,
0.3172954023,
0.3676029742,
0.1813577414,
0.4627622068,
0.4029484987,
-0.3143424094,
1.1151399612,
-0.1239469275,
0.286596328,
1.8735660315,
-0.300663054,
0.5265626907,
0.1827719361,
-0.3362691998,
0.2110819966,
0.4766370952,
-0.219168216,
0.4594393373,
0.0280734058,
-0.2448497564,
0.0354653522,
0.4891216159,
-0.2591200471,
0.5870161057,
0.0429848135,
-0.3468120098,
-0.7394598126,
-0.4995789826,
0.0096114054,
-0.1575758606,
-0.5514258742,
1.1152248383,
0.2296955884,
-0.5900050402,
0.3476352692,
0.0466309674,
0.7590061426,
-0.9068267941,
0.0473083109,
-0.4561421871,
0.2190632224,
-0.4051570296,
-0.479783237,
0.5225945711,
-0.0037423971,
-0.0168799087,
-0.1246176213,
0.6957070231,
-0.1263844371,
-0.3233254552,
-0.4366765022,
0.5293263793,
0.1802953184,
-0.3333381414,
-0.0740219802,
-0.5373871326,
-0.2486494035,
-0.1687496752,
0.4033063054,
0.284761101,
-0.0541286953,
0.546030581,
0.2643355131,
0.4334998131,
-0.1799898446,
-0.0076111509,
0.7154425979,
-0.4559550881,
-0.9488780499,
-1.3038297892,
0.3400556445,
-0.1330974996,
-0.4739687443,
0.9848321676,
1.0166364908,
0.2235194445,
-0.4136146307,
0.9789107442,
-0.0118564824,
0.572257936,
-0.189175427,
0.9787453413,
-0.5560312271,
-0.0890603438,
-0.5680577755,
-1.2043038607,
-0.5372641683,
0.203248933,
-0.2684237957,
0.2347395271,
0.2721896768,
0.1090898886,
-0.3754281104,
0.189756304,
0.4544772208,
-0.2879943848,
0.2721637785,
0.6693912148,
0.836376369,
-0.0630892813,
0.0910759941,
0.0592027009,
-0.6238673329,
-0.5239032507,
-1.0703626871,
-0.6887479424,
-0.1543640047,
-0.2149902731,
0.4612558186,
-0.1401056051,
0.6252804995,
0.9236616492,
-0.8055981994,
0.1918874532,
-0.0402916856,
0.0525031127,
-0.169025138,
-0.1905049086,
0.1825001091,
-0.1007329598,
-0.8900483847,
0.0996049419,
0.6539791226,
0.5382847786,
0.0838655382,
0.0018773592,
0.4695483744,
0.048487179,
0.6342126727,
0.2123596072,
-0.1496184915,
-0.1122035757,
-0.4353193343,
0.0136251645,
-0.1350420862,
0.9231266975,
-0.5014383793,
0.3230976462,
0.5850402117,
0.2641250491,
0.8081302643,
0.7123789787,
0.8163032532,
-0.6417835951,
-0.0092264079,
0.4436757267,
0.4230609834,
0.1465188861,
-0.2812900543,
0.6169518232,
-0.0177505501,
-0.5616540909,
-0.4405801594,
0.1854554266,
-1.0383480787,
-0.3598873019,
0.9145165682,
0.0388378836,
0.2532489598,
-0.0326705389,
-0.4124717414,
0.1264231652,
-0.2447826564,
0.8309486508,
0.5390532613,
-0.5381063223,
-0.0428975523,
-0.3949639499,
0.5865415335,
0.1303761303,
-0.9235368967,
0.3236138821,
0.5796881318,
0.5280275941,
-0.2133439779,
0.5702568889,
-0.3764860034,
0.2515143454,
0.2460514754,
-0.1657593995,
-0.5382665396,
-0.1539940834,
-0.5000867844,
0.3690687716,
0.3271181583,
-0.3522072136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13080v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13080v1 | Mitigating Catastrophic Forgetting for Few-Shot Spoken Word Classification Through Meta-Learning | 2023-05-22T14:51:15 | 2023-05-22T14:51:15 | Ruan van der Merwe, Herman Kamper | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, eess.AS, I.2.7; I.2.6 | We consider the problem of few-shot spoken word classification in a setting
where a model is incrementally introduced to new word classes. This would occur
in a user-defined keyword system where new words can be added as the system is
used. In such a continual learning scenario, a model might start to misclassify
earlier words as newer classes are added, i.e. catastrophic forgetting. To
address this, we propose an extension to model-agnostic meta-learning (MAML):
each inner learning loop, where a model "learns how to learn'' new classes,
ends with a single gradient update using stored templates from all the classes
that the model has already seen (one template per class). We compare this
method to OML (another extension of MAML) in few-shot isolated-word
classification experiments on Google Commands and FACC. Our method consistently
outperforms OML in experiments where the number of shots and the final number
of classes are varied. | [
-0.2853090763,
-0.6659605503,
0.2627117634,
-0.1921024621,
-0.1969896257,
0.1043462902,
-0.1078218892,
-0.090796046,
-0.1314450055,
0.3730067909,
-0.6341841817,
-0.729331851,
-0.4064807594,
0.0494368188,
-0.0942842588,
0.9969158769,
0.2440454513,
0.0366789736,
-0.1577614248,
-0.6592019796,
-0.4938205481,
-0.3194724321,
-0.9377760291,
-0.5985237956,
0.5664518476,
0.7350013256,
0.3132833242,
0.3224131465,
0.3873175979,
0.1839921474,
-0.0226428006,
0.3416881859,
-0.6135471463,
-0.0498544052,
-0.2187352329,
-0.5932943821,
-0.3993629515,
0.0313355029,
0.7970432639,
0.8057689071,
-0.554443121,
0.2618216574,
0.2144025266,
0.6879287958,
-1.1536525488,
-0.0044597196,
-0.9965718985,
0.3154221475,
-0.1423335522,
-0.2235953957,
-0.6124101281,
-0.1426960826,
0.2861523032,
-0.3744193912,
0.322927624,
-0.1337592602,
0.3010193706,
0.2176548839,
-0.011814815,
-0.2986618876,
-0.9085379839,
0.656603992,
-0.5795744658,
0.345207274,
0.4441276789,
0.481281966,
0.0434500352,
-0.4635275006,
-0.7238284945,
-0.2217685282,
0.3107957244,
0.4690080583,
-0.1713716388,
0.2833509743,
0.1340692937,
0.1006096303,
-0.5089640617,
0.2360984832,
-0.256432265,
-0.2673140168,
0.3106261194,
0.5495641828,
0.0279718135,
-0.0200502388,
-0.1853879541,
0.0906564891,
-1.0103735924,
-0.231509611,
0.1654505432,
0.6115350723,
0.0577472672,
0.3743962049,
0.0551661737,
0.6432302594,
-0.083821848,
-0.4302556217,
0.2488334328,
-0.1387829334,
-0.282248199,
0.0309245698,
0.6942490935,
0.088190943,
0.22162503,
-0.0345130786,
-0.034888912,
-0.0447613411,
0.1220396012,
-0.3698061109,
-0.3373822868,
-0.0103434464,
-0.3020360768,
-0.2052263618,
-0.0438770615,
-0.4432529807,
-0.3720537424,
0.0691410154,
0.82900846,
-0.4584160149,
0.0038185976,
0.0540166125,
-0.1607484967,
0.0120089799,
0.2578281462,
-0.8914280534,
0.2178092897,
0.3924783766,
1.071980238,
0.1112650409,
-0.6194230914,
-0.6226348877,
0.2515461147,
-0.3739412725,
0.8174898028,
-0.6658372283,
-0.7931313515,
0.0849084333,
-0.3161614835,
-0.2653288841,
-0.6811835766,
0.2979901135,
-0.134456113,
0.4857873321,
-0.2437325567,
-0.6919912696,
-0.279915005,
0.36318928,
-0.2069453448,
0.8128433228,
-0.0227137562,
-0.6038997769,
0.5089059472,
-0.6372421384,
-0.2298466414,
0.0219757687,
-0.1805400103,
-0.6248134971,
0.2683185339,
-0.2000536323,
0.4395335019,
0.0237700846,
-0.1343216598,
-0.44969365,
-0.316188246,
-0.0659154132,
-0.4907905161,
0.2858780026,
-0.0242068246,
-0.1848448366,
-0.0814725682,
-0.8453999162,
-0.1410427392,
0.1068435162,
-0.6477450728,
-0.3846465945,
-0.0047868253,
-0.2414657176,
0.1756894439,
-0.3329804242,
-0.5235403776,
0.3322776854,
-0.4636982977,
0.2060004175,
0.7959638238,
0.082990922,
0.440800786,
-0.5731485486,
0.330070734,
0.2976623476,
0.0798410848,
-0.7819133401,
-0.3632559776,
-1.1693108082,
-0.1247102991,
0.2643992603,
0.5632893443,
-0.6767217517,
0.2945009172,
-0.2001101822,
-0.5565613508,
-0.4424198568,
0.2359360158,
0.5451393723,
0.6407133341,
0.5186071992,
-0.5179628134,
-0.3873406947,
-0.6438882947,
-0.3719715476,
-0.2467143089,
0.0006530442,
0.5958791375,
0.518440783,
-0.387902081,
0.9989361763,
-0.5418050289,
-0.792293489,
-0.3241589665,
0.5583560467,
-0.0689552724,
0.2046913952,
0.5658262968,
-0.1789258122,
-0.5428763032,
-0.1594371796,
-0.5994259119,
-0.0951670185,
-0.2881469727,
0.4028965831,
0.3041237295,
0.4814882576,
-0.5017498136,
0.5066534281,
0.1913309097,
0.1402533054,
0.6623356342,
-0.1757022142,
-0.3769669235,
-0.8111514449,
0.03027872,
-0.313239783,
-0.1628215462,
-0.640391171,
-0.2732126117,
0.0040037772,
-0.1044408008,
-0.6392720938,
0.5518019795,
-0.4078727663,
0.131966278,
-0.7418483496,
-0.0037430145,
-0.3026385903,
0.416241169,
-0.0040398217,
0.708137095,
0.8451473117,
-0.8983790874,
0.0303696971,
0.2517823875,
0.0089182938,
0.489744097,
-0.2762413919,
0.4209612906,
-0.5335232615,
0.5565954447,
-0.8643744588,
0.0072324602,
0.3138813674,
-0.413844496,
0.4511966407,
-0.1616589129,
-0.2057183981,
-0.3910545409,
-0.1837879121,
-0.0428714491,
0.3769974113,
-0.5453115702,
0.7335493565,
0.1168771163,
0.0189583078,
-0.6376331449,
-0.4922578335,
0.1740482897,
-0.1524880975,
0.018952664,
0.1451003999,
-0.0660900325,
0.0171226077,
0.0795711204,
-0.2607287765,
0.1023376286,
0.0956225619,
0.1795713454,
-0.0737034529,
-0.1358449459,
0.8042954206,
-0.2503426075,
-0.4198536873,
-0.2548458576,
-0.6849347353,
0.6610699296,
-0.2246116996,
-0.494491756,
-0.238121599,
0.4126119018,
0.7869229913,
-0.0466191173,
0.7772072554,
0.8305413127,
-0.3987615407,
-0.4144744277,
-0.5601824522,
-0.1453718245,
-0.4437330365,
0.2155858874,
-0.2505342662,
-0.6797103286,
0.5221018791,
-0.1274992973,
0.2833880484,
0.5252177119,
0.4309251308,
-0.3692855239,
0.500666678,
0.9421548843,
-0.4205198586,
0.4990320504,
-0.3615142107,
-0.204455629,
-0.7844448686,
0.0204808656,
-0.1909957826,
-0.3546868265,
-0.1728173345,
-0.2777447999,
0.6525865793,
-0.1234137639,
-0.208107695,
0.1353960484,
-0.0607357807,
0.6810996532,
0.6434932351,
0.256474942,
0.2014862895,
-0.1134801582,
-0.3843190372,
0.1384698898,
-1.0002304316,
-0.2824949324,
1.3790521622,
0.0915405601,
0.8028701544,
0.064548403,
0.9794393182,
0.2774257064,
0.5394197702,
-0.8224945664,
0.4596964121,
-0.2066548914,
-0.7002973557,
-0.2354786247,
-0.3283599615,
-0.7805303931,
0.3034329414,
-0.3710941076,
-0.5935444236,
-0.0411028266,
0.5199659467,
-0.7857416272,
0.5432727337,
-0.4248856902,
0.5024217367,
-0.0770405456,
-0.3152131438,
-0.5182333589,
-0.6878398657,
0.2945594192,
-0.3356926739,
-0.0419489071,
-0.113824442,
0.0235103667,
0.696462512,
-0.4869254231,
1.1436723471,
-0.2135501504,
0.1366635114,
0.6146739125,
-0.0669185817,
0.4517884552,
-0.3317715824,
0.1513843387,
0.0172960702,
-0.5651744008,
-0.2437463999,
-0.4408228695,
0.3371379077,
-0.3858678043,
-0.5547540188,
-0.4973722398,
-0.1153251529,
-0.3486851156,
0.1140366793,
0.7475739121,
0.4368773699,
-0.3685826361,
0.1357605308,
0.7766823769,
-0.4043239355,
0.715503335,
0.8441575766,
-0.0777417719,
-0.5044385195,
0.7865643501,
0.404489249,
0.5877417922,
0.3393811882,
0.6095551848,
0.0047115716,
-0.6797066331,
-0.2468643486,
0.2758539021,
-0.8516573906,
-0.3336344659,
-0.8866872787,
-0.1552459598,
-0.3084626198,
-0.0813943148,
-0.3947274387,
-0.2288525999,
-0.6119965911,
-0.0704751611,
0.1963839829,
0.4925194681,
-0.3960967064,
0.5703375936,
-1.1013653278,
0.2978772223,
0.5124650002,
0.2600151598,
0.2560444176,
-0.8783178329,
-0.1320079714,
-0.1013183445,
-0.7487450242,
-0.731895566,
0.2183676213,
1.1069666147,
0.6085160971,
0.8535161018,
-0.086884968,
0.8465597034,
-0.9286208153,
0.6718179584,
0.5330644846,
-0.8928827643,
0.6695674062,
-0.3865951896,
0.7725681663,
0.8752284646,
0.4282849431,
-0.9272025228,
-0.3429431319,
-0.7739916444,
-0.6375180483,
0.4092285037,
-0.2198317498,
0.4353543222,
-0.2470232546,
0.275613308,
0.3167862594,
0.2393218577,
-0.6022014022,
-0.4405284226,
0.0136389052,
-0.0676425919,
-0.271130383,
-0.4159715772,
-0.0296099074,
-0.2033606917,
0.6593722105,
-0.320879221,
0.0829315335,
0.0894061849,
-0.3052717745,
-0.1553127915,
0.3000088334,
0.8855500221,
0.3317968547,
-0.1430743188,
0.1886367798,
0.7050385475,
-0.7208167911,
0.1063973159,
-0.5822817683,
-0.1193059087,
0.2006776631,
0.6439365149,
0.678534627,
0.5525856614,
-0.4370131195,
0.4103777111,
0.3539061546,
-0.1952756345,
-0.3362999558,
0.2143192142,
0.0269256886,
0.0397984385,
0.4415474832,
0.4002953172,
0.0338470004,
-0.8335650563,
0.4851423204,
0.4216386974,
-0.5496406555,
-0.39563483,
0.4192705452,
0.3766939938,
-0.336237818,
0.5795965791,
-0.2174936533,
-0.8281434774,
0.1280813664,
0.6472839117,
1.3107918501,
-0.5518622398,
0.1190733314,
0.4703620672,
0.5044071674,
-0.2091854066,
0.072712712,
-0.1888647228,
-0.7412887812,
0.1298689991,
-0.3983633518,
-0.6134144068,
0.1515376121,
-0.4258189201,
0.2909493148,
-0.8012881279,
-0.3182989955,
-0.2230058163,
-0.3593052626,
-0.663123548,
-0.0014203938,
0.4637919962,
0.965462029,
-1.1454629898,
0.7373608947,
0.4631465971,
-0.360332489,
-0.3733127117,
0.1668019742,
0.5193127394,
-0.7451459169,
0.4938607514,
0.2395946383,
-0.4820518792,
0.0832868144,
-0.5150831938,
-0.7272190452,
1.117934823,
-0.0464109778,
-0.6730818748,
0.20388183,
0.038796477,
0.411985606,
-0.3250974417,
0.1731419265,
0.5127758384,
0.251009047,
0.2509012818,
-0.9944770336,
-0.6574491858,
0.2403832823,
-0.4416593611,
0.1007987484,
-0.59953475,
0.6956144571,
-0.6914134026,
-0.4735361338,
-0.1361991912,
0.6483060122,
0.012067521,
0.7018479705,
0.4621497393,
0.9292348623,
1.062364459,
0.0688626021,
0.7416826487,
0.3173933625,
0.5788401961,
1.5244861841,
-0.307326287,
0.9304249287,
0.107641682,
-0.2663124204,
0.2233918309,
0.5086699128,
0.1045805588,
0.7056056857,
0.0190766659,
-0.6155309081,
-0.4395799935,
-0.0053156842,
-0.3234985471,
0.7791183591,
0.469006896,
-0.3271420002,
-0.5264424682,
0.4175387621,
0.0194650441,
-0.2203823626,
-0.4519681633,
1.0885719061,
0.3847190142,
-0.2329758704,
0.6811031103,
-0.2461894304,
0.6715379953,
-0.6451957822,
0.1561617702,
-0.3079054058,
0.2546895742,
-0.096076563,
-0.3512626886,
0.3039296269,
-0.103720665,
-0.2401442379,
0.165901944,
0.7289334536,
-0.6215539575,
-0.3936337233,
0.0387327857,
0.3961797655,
0.0037868239,
-0.0278835483,
-0.7498995066,
-0.2333584577,
-0.3046308756,
0.1430707723,
0.0996936113,
0.1380579323,
0.2833060324,
1.0758732557,
0.4532191157,
-0.0418228507,
0.2223972082,
0.0050526913,
0.6913270354,
-0.6890730262,
-0.5561130047,
-1.1417948008,
0.2609084845,
0.2123299837,
-0.4309457242,
0.7645205259,
0.4357171357,
0.6980387568,
-0.2834875882,
0.9622267485,
0.3360964954,
0.4982770681,
-0.574527204,
0.7148308754,
-0.4305587709,
0.1274251789,
-0.4068297744,
-0.8529794812,
-0.6432375312,
0.455731988,
-0.1386609972,
-0.1832187623,
0.8156073689,
0.5323786139,
-0.075121969,
-0.1490261555,
0.5692805052,
0.030278137,
0.2131497711,
0.7168490291,
0.88478297,
-0.2818438113,
0.3616993427,
0.0755295381,
-0.1161170453,
-0.437923342,
-0.9025863409,
-0.9023790956,
-0.3984842598,
-0.4271291494,
-0.0331048258,
-0.014569588,
0.9044390321,
0.5451323986,
-0.7068718672,
0.0754905418,
0.0482359715,
0.1969173253,
-0.2346518487,
-0.1184745058,
0.1693700999,
-0.4275146723,
-0.4213503897,
0.4986932874,
0.7086331248,
0.2199838459,
-0.1840838045,
0.0244554579,
-0.1281468272,
0.2219285816,
0.5920109153,
0.620419085,
-0.6722105742,
-0.4699804783,
-0.2058888227,
0.0291785318,
0.1733204871,
0.8754344583,
-0.8664577603,
0.6805458665,
0.3133716881,
0.5676124096,
0.2254138291,
-0.0779956356,
0.2531498969,
-0.8611500263,
0.0182035547,
0.3352176249,
0.3108317852,
0.281585902,
0.113907598,
0.3338908255,
0.591760993,
-0.2283436805,
-0.7148794532,
0.412253499,
-0.6849415302,
-0.181518808,
1.0144999027,
-0.0976371542,
0.1203509942,
-0.1709624231,
0.0896328837,
0.0646808371,
-0.0700964481,
0.8859218359,
0.7458981872,
0.0496327505,
-0.2195181102,
-0.2247939408,
0.3786459863,
0.2748431563,
-0.5719541907,
0.1173849776,
0.382099539,
0.4522905052,
0.2506731153,
0.8379423618,
0.062251471,
0.3853911757,
-0.0156517271,
0.0185864586,
-0.0977909118,
-0.8144133091,
-0.5445547104,
0.1288691312,
-0.1124654189,
-0.5334736705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13076v1 | An Abstract Specification of VoxML as an Annotation Language | 2023-05-22T14:47:59 | 2023-05-22T14:47:59 | Kiyong Lee, Nikhil Krishnaswamy, James Pustejovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | VoxML is a modeling language used to map natural language expressions into
real-time visualizations using commonsense semantic knowledge of objects and
events. Its utility has been demonstrated in embodied simulation environments
and in agent-object interactions in situated multimodal human-agent
collaboration and communication. It introduces the notion of object affordance
(both Gibsonian and Telic) from HRI and robotics, as well as the concept of
habitat (an object's context of use) for interactions between a rational agent
and an object. This paper aims to specify VoxML as an annotation language in
general abstract terms. It then shows how it works on annotating linguistic
data that express visually perceptible human-object interactions. The
annotation structures thus generated will be interpreted against the enriched
minimal model created by VoxML as a modeling language while supporting the
modeling purposes of VoxML linguistically. | [
-0.4268669784,
-1.1504911184,
0.515625,
-0.0068650125,
-0.2993091345,
-0.186760366,
-0.202142939,
-0.6493178606,
-0.0980880409,
0.336789012,
-0.2083375901,
-0.754134059,
-0.0435821675,
0.2537462413,
-0.3016814291,
0.3851134777,
0.0691581964,
-0.1669288129,
-0.7245873809,
-0.1515896469,
-0.1890899092,
-0.8308939338,
-0.293753624,
0.0691795424,
0.4894513488,
0.1218155846,
0.9795619249,
0.9761013389,
0.4070049822,
0.410523653,
-0.0741301104,
-0.0378365815,
-0.3974637687,
-0.1361590326,
0.0162269883,
-0.3454474509,
-0.4810089469,
-0.1786776334,
0.7434251308,
0.5494955182,
-0.0329212397,
-0.0296689998,
-0.0145911397,
-0.0797020644,
-0.5400754213,
0.5897797346,
-0.4516389072,
0.1305092722,
-0.0659260303,
-0.2943852544,
-0.3458071947,
0.0574434176,
0.1037318632,
-1.084985137,
0.0603625216,
0.1863562167,
0.9023994207,
0.3234888911,
-0.2657410502,
0.1508313864,
-0.4333020747,
0.8022802472,
-0.5779237747,
0.2289206088,
0.4468382299,
0.6492230296,
0.0728057846,
-0.7445032001,
-0.9937027693,
-0.233689025,
-0.6112473607,
-0.0831741244,
-0.0428202897,
0.3488787711,
0.3744796813,
-0.1367030293,
-0.1912456751,
-0.0132690426,
-0.6291704178,
-0.2570431828,
0.7974301577,
0.45568344,
0.6828163266,
-0.633859396,
-0.8396975398,
0.1079818383,
-0.8689843416,
-0.1636674106,
0.0090694567,
0.6253308058,
-0.5360585451,
0.7148587108,
-0.0583104491,
1.0664513111,
-0.9536916018,
0.1042715609,
0.1434327066,
-0.3525113463,
-0.4879102409,
0.0106406827,
0.863576591,
0.3814404607,
0.4411879778,
0.0271511711,
-0.0401330851,
-0.0062866225,
0.4909147322,
-0.6387982965,
-0.0743193999,
0.200412035,
-0.4092056453,
-0.5845370889,
-0.0561744459,
-0.4656161964,
-0.3456814885,
-0.5992402434,
0.5056528449,
-0.436309278,
-0.424238503,
0.1206766665,
-0.073884733,
0.2910850346,
0.656829536,
-0.5993593335,
0.212862432,
0.859574914,
0.8877668977,
0.0848124027,
-0.5879762173,
-0.1835564673,
0.5223961473,
-0.276866436,
0.986230135,
-0.7435438037,
-0.8275966048,
0.1179062575,
0.1021983176,
0.1663854867,
-0.2665966153,
0.3799256086,
0.0063608112,
0.3240165412,
-0.3321299553,
-0.4609398544,
-0.6124412417,
0.2650154233,
-0.5237802863,
0.5790609121,
0.2177383751,
-0.5402210951,
0.6319522858,
-0.983757019,
-0.0975917578,
0.7334712148,
-0.4279472232,
-0.189394623,
-0.1708048433,
-0.1981380433,
0.5421556234,
-0.0379673094,
0.0692982003,
-0.3348373473,
-0.432272613,
0.4287688732,
-0.2248588204,
0.5845879316,
0.0573930591,
0.0066703348,
0.4246982038,
-0.6244453192,
-0.0797532648,
0.0275977869,
-0.4503398836,
-0.3165924251,
0.3829768896,
0.701335609,
0.2135859579,
-0.0079421559,
-0.4797126651,
0.3668411076,
-0.3313125968,
0.5852408409,
0.4896989763,
-0.0680090189,
0.3576954305,
0.0035278257,
0.2901893258,
-0.0912112668,
0.2033258826,
-0.3132027984,
-0.5966468453,
-0.5865086317,
-0.5152321458,
-0.0338248946,
0.3265536129,
-0.5548996925,
0.1136311218,
-0.327658236,
-0.0725237429,
-0.5588402152,
-0.0809165537,
0.2159826607,
0.5745372772,
0.4223876595,
0.0540148467,
-0.8142533302,
-1.2850067616,
0.2432471663,
-0.4541350007,
-0.1811569035,
0.5197638273,
0.2817018628,
-0.3833321631,
1.1433982849,
-0.121554032,
-0.4565330148,
-0.3705409467,
0.2698780596,
-0.345220983,
0.4096310139,
0.7293026447,
-0.9528203011,
-0.1790482849,
0.4770756662,
-1.0138437748,
0.0105756372,
-0.0906090364,
-0.2097493559,
0.1755753011,
0.4605414271,
-0.6340696812,
0.747628212,
0.089071095,
-0.578982532,
0.2255170792,
-0.0487977862,
0.017923601,
-0.8422212601,
0.1448558569,
-0.3165382445,
-0.4415815175,
-0.7519981265,
-0.0055040577,
-0.1732251495,
-0.0770023316,
-0.9696002603,
0.7204025984,
-0.3995618224,
-0.1058689207,
-0.3418554068,
0.3785560131,
0.0014857855,
0.3830884695,
0.6706601977,
0.7572231293,
0.6687806249,
-0.4762643576,
0.3308843374,
0.5186519027,
0.0004983784,
0.6002536416,
-0.8033698797,
-0.1766593903,
-0.1596804112,
-0.2579342425,
-0.6352787018,
-0.2402793616,
0.3668115735,
-0.2437818497,
-0.0224308353,
-0.3350591063,
-0.3846355379,
0.1154624298,
0.0125782788,
0.4814886451,
0.3128896058,
-0.2903232574,
0.8830994964,
0.572589159,
0.1192333996,
-0.3103860021,
-0.5743275881,
0.202590093,
-0.2275593877,
-0.3993609846,
-0.1769085526,
0.2326028198,
-0.6246459484,
0.0461017489,
0.6659248471,
-0.2455893308,
0.1816146672,
0.6913009882,
0.5205029249,
-0.3330288231,
0.2276437879,
-0.2775866389,
-0.216406092,
0.0896184444,
0.125595361,
0.2062956095,
-0.4931037426,
-0.5690293312,
-0.4762513041,
0.3211046159,
0.362092942,
0.0827493593,
0.6748911142,
0.5337197185,
-0.4112254381,
0.08429721,
-0.3118456602,
-0.0819890648,
-0.4801326692,
0.6392851472,
-0.4322819412,
-0.5966863632,
0.2012184411,
0.3999275863,
0.0528294332,
0.392246455,
0.6398356557,
-0.1746953726,
0.708686173,
0.5086909533,
0.1604484767,
0.2220501006,
-0.2284682393,
-0.0110858744,
-0.8421725035,
-0.4053914547,
-0.3366870582,
-0.3967110813,
-0.4303734303,
-0.993065834,
0.1420672238,
-0.1530977488,
-0.0385134108,
0.4829916954,
-0.4958503842,
0.461984098,
0.4069387019,
-0.3368983269,
0.2654399574,
-0.0135622686,
0.0564552695,
-0.1424677521,
-0.7109783292,
-1.0134267807,
0.7698176503,
0.3770077527,
0.563760519,
0.0501887463,
0.3182013929,
0.2160042226,
0.450116694,
-0.7737300396,
0.7612639666,
0.4833189845,
-0.5950678587,
-0.4383137524,
-0.1341695338,
-1.034584403,
0.5286937356,
-0.5202501416,
-0.9205969572,
0.2909558117,
0.1386194527,
-0.0894212052,
0.4078012109,
-0.8587417006,
1.0507415533,
-0.248541683,
-0.5328356028,
-0.2961401939,
-0.369102627,
-0.0352939814,
0.4673490226,
0.2382757068,
-0.3500131071,
-0.3722765744,
0.267095834,
-0.1187878624,
0.9757553339,
-0.078362748,
0.3223777711,
0.666208148,
0.4426520467,
0.064389281,
0.2791443765,
0.4240424633,
0.5324062109,
0.236601755,
-0.5354383588,
-0.3164074123,
0.3060517609,
-0.6512970328,
-0.4340785742,
-0.3336530924,
-0.6442312002,
0.0293328911,
0.2237205654,
-0.1783181429,
0.4596371353,
-0.6354439259,
0.224031955,
0.1061526239,
-0.3714307845,
0.454331398,
0.4211918116,
-0.6721801758,
0.175289914,
1.0095828772,
-0.1544536054,
0.1369307339,
0.6380935907,
0.0465636589,
-0.3138949871,
-0.3263914585,
-0.3708551526,
0.1177555546,
-0.4666393399,
-0.0365084223,
-0.8002824783,
-0.233492583,
0.0576667935,
-0.3348402083,
-0.0353349708,
-0.6456491351,
-0.1679804623,
-0.5152956247,
0.3251174688,
0.9698401093,
0.1035950854,
0.0295137763,
-0.5958303213,
0.307112515,
0.53224051,
0.2845542729,
-0.3176507354,
0.0779773593,
-0.2592926323,
0.1658604443,
0.1844345182,
-0.8289555311,
0.2300746143,
0.1531371474,
0.6909805536,
0.4537295997,
-0.3876928687,
0.4735217094,
-0.3142956793,
0.8173551559,
-0.0616155416,
-0.8076679707,
0.3838938177,
-0.7407815456,
0.1046014801,
-0.0015607433,
-0.0845414326,
-0.6879847646,
-0.3851384521,
-0.6363555789,
-0.8738207221,
0.5751025081,
0.41509372,
0.2927029729,
-0.1269454807,
-0.0351054557,
0.1088653281,
0.466180861,
-0.8216795921,
0.1405220628,
-0.4787929654,
-0.1615389436,
0.0533226505,
-0.6334145069,
-0.3638511598,
-0.3067582548,
0.3576506078,
-0.1114472151,
0.4884076715,
0.0556445271,
-0.3167689741,
0.1266649216,
0.1530516297,
0.6586689353,
0.7578474283,
-0.0953942537,
0.2478776574,
0.3419413567,
-0.3672906458,
-0.2182786614,
-0.0021454699,
-0.198740676,
0.1400590241,
0.623896122,
0.843804121,
0.3713030517,
-0.9303084016,
0.4762391448,
0.0191507284,
0.0092855021,
-0.3471181691,
0.0581296645,
0.3280694783,
-0.0009374176,
0.0677325577,
-0.2193608284,
0.1623276025,
-0.2948009372,
0.1252955347,
0.5764636993,
-0.6277893186,
-0.5863078237,
0.781698823,
0.463517487,
-0.3231366873,
0.3337164521,
-0.1220458597,
-0.250582248,
0.5272775888,
0.2221751511,
0.8489284515,
-0.0728519484,
0.2901105285,
0.5192611217,
0.4067621827,
0.525549531,
0.3069501817,
-0.3727709651,
-0.6865429282,
-0.2005270123,
-0.6862339377,
-0.2760778069,
-0.2698764503,
-0.3484996557,
0.4428600967,
-0.2998167276,
-0.0171768516,
0.0090722293,
-0.6419487,
-0.8156447411,
0.1256064475,
0.4977711141,
0.721308887,
-0.6905269623,
0.6839141846,
0.9719552994,
-0.6394072175,
-0.7486830354,
-0.4942084253,
0.2043458819,
-0.8476080894,
0.7033604383,
-0.0295373574,
-0.0892667249,
-0.2850885987,
-0.4867551029,
-0.6192098856,
0.8903076053,
0.265727818,
-0.1989362836,
0.0971236452,
0.4797436297,
0.8042651415,
-0.5941382647,
0.2896979451,
0.3418807685,
0.6577663422,
-0.224276498,
-0.7045994401,
-0.0026992117,
-0.3828073442,
0.2827834487,
-0.0008160933,
-0.3817871809,
0.6533710957,
-0.113900736,
-0.5238201618,
-0.0270560849,
0.557808876,
-0.1562295407,
0.2085380703,
0.3724982738,
0.2432640642,
0.1324297041,
-0.4319934249,
1.3134970665,
-0.051919356,
0.3928392529,
0.9718264341,
0.0063632345,
0.9853270054,
0.5861811638,
-0.2899312973,
0.5203678012,
0.2401850522,
0.0026651141,
0.0196259283,
0.1145103127,
-0.2423883975,
-0.2278568596,
-0.3989675939,
-0.3033867776,
0.6320904493,
0.5061827302,
-0.2413249016,
-0.1837442666,
-0.0575616881,
0.0030417494,
0.1281271279,
-0.1014943272,
1.0939323902,
0.0025139665,
-0.0994531885,
0.4124737382,
-0.3986034691,
-0.0534917414,
-0.3151904047,
-0.3366080225,
0.3255354762,
-0.2382973284,
-0.2585756481,
-0.9287913442,
0.5085890293,
-0.2520520985,
0.0818523541,
-0.2535211146,
0.5445050001,
-0.6002950072,
-0.6653143764,
0.2663224936,
0.5195790529,
0.2865680456,
0.1310432106,
-0.5509393215,
0.1428598762,
-0.3327742219,
-0.1680387259,
0.0846396312,
0.4683939815,
-0.0885817111,
0.7557253242,
0.5643213987,
0.1981804073,
0.0157954898,
0.212820217,
0.7140141129,
-0.6534084082,
-0.5529525876,
-0.8024072051,
0.8796234131,
-0.2380634844,
0.0440356061,
0.5717931986,
0.6501046419,
0.6333428025,
-0.1841574013,
0.9488652945,
-0.3037681878,
0.4282758534,
-0.3520250916,
0.8764107823,
-0.4916440845,
0.1625678539,
-0.0785124078,
-0.8694906235,
-0.2169843018,
0.8490922451,
-0.2580664158,
-0.0856465027,
0.4896597862,
0.764449358,
-0.1703518778,
-0.1935169697,
0.6626729965,
0.472563833,
0.1222000346,
0.3205593228,
1.1238732338,
0.0676048324,
0.3921073079,
-0.3303168416,
0.2434038818,
-0.2934184968,
-0.7025728226,
-0.9606068134,
-0.9139246941,
-0.2706266046,
-0.1851156205,
-0.0813399702,
0.8508227468,
0.8571988344,
-0.6707414389,
-0.5335745215,
-0.0173492059,
0.1752369851,
-0.1938493103,
-0.2629118562,
0.1582627892,
-0.2240222394,
-0.9249697924,
0.1723656356,
0.7831620574,
0.2953799069,
-0.4974864721,
-0.1619489789,
-0.0720960572,
0.0833026245,
0.5757952332,
0.3910960257,
-0.9854722023,
-0.6181218028,
-0.3530739844,
-0.1792274565,
0.2959299088,
0.765288651,
-0.9846531153,
0.9602336884,
0.3497795165,
0.178249523,
0.2010242492,
0.3789153099,
0.822530508,
-0.7388991714,
0.8017776608,
0.2508931458,
0.4758343995,
0.5075535178,
-0.3265864849,
0.4495016932,
0.2259506732,
-0.1280964911,
-0.7915539145,
0.3979949951,
-1.0573451519,
-0.1785537899,
1.240031004,
0.127459079,
-0.6033067107,
-0.398255229,
-0.7577111125,
-0.1234115884,
-0.1300420612,
0.9152663946,
0.4841767251,
0.1220793575,
-0.2947514057,
-0.6298453808,
0.7684582472,
-0.1051481292,
-0.9686691165,
-0.0498787388,
0.7114893198,
-0.1091176942,
0.2768874168,
0.5244809389,
-0.0542870201,
0.4243887961,
0.0949440375,
0.3120196462,
-0.6190521717,
-0.0243550651,
0.0851163343,
0.1784768999,
0.1534326226,
-0.360434711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13073v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13073v2 | Text-to-SQL Error Correction with Language Models of Code | 2023-05-22T14:42:39 | 2023-05-28T15:32:26 | Ziru Chen, Shijie Chen, Michael White, Raymond Mooney, Ali Payani, Jayanth Srinivasa, Yu Su, Huan Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.LG | Despite recent progress in text-to-SQL parsing, current semantic parsers are
still not accurate enough for practical use. In this paper, we investigate how
to build automatic text-to-SQL error correction models. Noticing that
token-level edits are out of context and sometimes ambiguous, we propose
building clause-level edit models instead. Besides, while most language models
of code are not specifically pre-trained for SQL, they know common data
structures and their operations in programming languages such as Python. Thus,
we propose a novel representation for SQL queries and their edits that adheres
more closely to the pre-training corpora of language models of code. Our error
correction model improves the exact set match accuracy of different parsers by
2.4-6.5 and obtains up to 4.3 point absolute improvement over two strong
baselines. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/OSU-NLP-Group/Auto-SQL-Correction. | [
0.2563100755,
-0.7704409957,
0.4465313256,
0.2639945149,
0.1237542406,
-0.0874380916,
-0.1489176005,
-0.4408530295,
0.1219765618,
0.7008264065,
-0.3866368532,
-0.6329364777,
-0.2685360909,
0.3468098342,
-0.5391597748,
0.8227695823,
0.0849080533,
0.2576374412,
-0.1256276071,
-0.335106343,
-0.8011270761,
-0.7442550063,
-0.4065366685,
0.2911237776,
0.1943207085,
0.1513330936,
0.7252930403,
0.7166703939,
0.2800372541,
0.2252237797,
-0.1575202793,
0.3707652688,
-0.2292453945,
-0.0818736702,
-0.6756145954,
-0.6452533007,
-0.8518230319,
-0.4194030762,
0.5823631883,
0.9237538576,
-0.2400504649,
-0.2788327634,
-0.2756364644,
0.7345617414,
-0.4654270709,
0.1273331493,
-1.1610541344,
0.0891468078,
0.106202431,
-0.0562900975,
-0.6804115176,
-0.3517997265,
-0.2728402019,
-0.4750808775,
0.3423431516,
0.2328987271,
0.6432074904,
0.4977572262,
-0.4849340916,
-0.3385794163,
-0.470929116,
0.4279156923,
-0.942766428,
0.1203395352,
0.419352293,
-0.1417074651,
-0.4963957369,
-0.5538939238,
-0.5007589459,
-0.0690346956,
-0.4245423973,
-0.3488594294,
0.0448043309,
0.313300401,
0.3968039453,
0.2362740636,
-0.314568609,
-0.1078052744,
-0.1309082955,
-0.0059484481,
0.5284837484,
0.2991380095,
0.2824895382,
-0.0834462419,
0.0678979382,
0.3574495018,
-0.715631485,
-0.1640444398,
0.0532673039,
0.5055024028,
0.2154679447,
0.9709815979,
-0.3129516244,
1.223631978,
-0.0063862591,
0.4540916085,
-0.0662316456,
-0.543806076,
-0.3418265581,
0.1045435369,
0.5470123887,
0.4317134023,
0.1647313982,
-0.1953956932,
-0.3603667319,
0.0650998577,
0.3130719364,
-0.4548850656,
-0.3903621435,
0.4758834541,
-0.2853445113,
-0.2726585567,
-0.0398589447,
-0.3535506427,
-0.5168440342,
-0.3316256106,
0.5315053463,
-0.3241239488,
-0.0173396915,
0.2692323029,
-0.0755727068,
-0.0648625121,
0.4868057072,
-0.607393384,
0.345716238,
0.4692322016,
0.5514516234,
0.0686341077,
-0.2511642873,
-0.684817493,
0.2641363442,
-0.7021656036,
0.8162507415,
-0.5342289805,
-0.2304102033,
0.116696775,
0.0967848599,
-0.2232328802,
-0.5223064423,
0.3934263587,
-0.5967316031,
0.4057234824,
-0.3316781521,
-1.010453105,
0.4023208022,
0.0100002158,
-0.5347088575,
1.0528600216,
0.2720611989,
-0.6876866817,
0.3033565581,
-0.918105185,
-0.3662495613,
-0.1416658312,
-0.0095844613,
-0.3098211288,
0.2214728445,
0.4279071689,
0.0220882688,
0.0052334969,
0.1983153522,
-0.18123281,
-0.4972292781,
0.2228669077,
0.1407268792,
1.1287643909,
-0.038430918,
-0.2070533782,
0.4392032325,
-0.9559676051,
0.2426251024,
-0.0175744276,
-0.3066826761,
-0.4144559801,
0.1729753017,
-0.2500643432,
0.167950049,
0.111839205,
-0.4636906385,
0.4112866819,
-0.5447993279,
0.5890767574,
0.6004118323,
-0.3090761006,
0.5087855458,
0.2009077519,
0.1792363971,
0.1269607693,
0.0133354412,
-0.4237418771,
-0.2454471141,
-0.8612835407,
-0.1068877503,
0.5643166304,
0.7942537069,
-0.7454395294,
0.8013488054,
-0.0879741535,
-0.1874886006,
-0.5052482486,
-0.035564471,
0.3803624511,
0.5914695263,
0.6167750359,
0.0030494621,
-0.7874869108,
-0.3650364876,
-0.9669632912,
-0.3654202819,
0.1022125706,
0.1144292727,
0.4608598948,
-0.2715683281,
1.324000597,
-0.6911363006,
-0.5810546875,
0.0672816187,
-0.2260965556,
0.1301832646,
0.7354467511,
0.4130764306,
-0.3974795938,
-0.3780432045,
-0.107398279,
-0.5568406582,
-0.2261423022,
0.0254765153,
-0.0640850663,
0.6850165725,
0.6828382611,
-0.5988930464,
0.4823091328,
0.1569277048,
-0.8019282222,
0.6231485605,
-0.4119579494,
0.1486396939,
-1.079671979,
-0.0760497078,
-0.2038160264,
-0.3408198059,
-0.6227567792,
0.0305066388,
0.5619080067,
-0.2221839577,
-0.2093241066,
0.2917723954,
-0.4245946109,
-0.1718933731,
-0.0929156542,
-0.0933102593,
0.1346217841,
0.3244408071,
0.1239396557,
0.7112907171,
0.4004854262,
-0.3668450415,
0.4903830886,
0.443038702,
-0.133007735,
0.7700822353,
-0.7371758223,
0.2395420671,
0.0126943868,
0.4627880454,
-0.9241112471,
-0.3115158379,
0.1289169192,
-0.4811506569,
0.0820647702,
-0.4716426134,
-0.5298427343,
-0.055748485,
-0.0719285831,
0.239121452,
0.178178221,
-0.7299507856,
0.4646631181,
0.2494307756,
0.0107287774,
-0.7632811069,
-0.7872644663,
0.4424795508,
0.1950196773,
-0.5629771352,
0.5467811823,
0.2092310339,
-0.1896679401,
0.2637458146,
-0.0492120534,
-0.5455714464,
-0.2397649735,
-0.1315028965,
0.3771342337,
-0.3710514605,
0.3848306537,
0.0646883771,
0.0373727493,
-0.0068105594,
-0.4653320909,
0.3101914227,
-0.2972905636,
-0.3050049543,
-0.3516377807,
0.2706130445,
0.1876291484,
-0.494151175,
1.0218350887,
0.0266005006,
-0.5635324717,
-0.1397633851,
-0.6193388104,
-0.0325306021,
-0.3913896382,
0.4897549748,
-0.3334226906,
-0.6832761168,
0.5480815768,
0.2078382522,
-0.0366731435,
0.696421206,
0.0858355612,
-0.1967002898,
0.9079307914,
0.5836083889,
0.3435083926,
0.4113319814,
0.1870854646,
0.2766644955,
-0.3958649039,
-0.1409289539,
-1.0237339735,
0.3915350139,
-0.4084973931,
-0.6265255809,
-0.0583271869,
0.1052549705,
-0.1590923816,
0.6540666223,
-0.4900006652,
0.7849004865,
0.1156557426,
-0.0884127915,
0.4457964599,
0.038624648,
0.1083304062,
-0.1301497668,
-0.7330912352,
-0.2318264842,
0.8296231627,
-0.0355290808,
0.8131846189,
-0.1262600571,
0.5484325886,
0.2642828524,
-0.1252637208,
-0.4712378681,
0.3876662552,
-0.3361413777,
-0.6104456186,
-0.3074817359,
-0.6427807212,
-0.4504701495,
0.1996651441,
-0.263028264,
-0.3599082232,
0.3623279631,
0.4850900769,
-0.1117895991,
0.4310315251,
-0.9757454395,
1.328322053,
-0.0075662779,
-0.2890922725,
-0.04208057,
-0.7550730705,
0.0325122587,
-0.0362355076,
0.1795278043,
0.1354358196,
-0.263135761,
0.3448251486,
-0.96502918,
0.7411131263,
-0.3099205196,
-0.2190666646,
0.1966518909,
0.0019534691,
0.7531366348,
-0.0442921035,
-0.4697836936,
0.0860894993,
0.2561805546,
-0.5758908987,
-0.6051517725,
0.4833120704,
-0.3084600866,
-0.1916195899,
-0.3968641162,
-0.5981690288,
-0.1276749223,
0.2001052797,
0.0578391552,
0.5098902583,
-0.1374842227,
0.0656437799,
0.580399394,
-0.2035034448,
0.355068624,
0.49673599,
-0.1796628833,
-0.2847786248,
0.5483494401,
0.0606367886,
0.2066669613,
0.4577695727,
-0.2379977852,
-0.5534302592,
-0.3030872345,
-0.7463330626,
0.0549975,
-0.9013852477,
-0.2652880847,
-0.8114154935,
0.0143258236,
-0.5278965235,
-0.0754299238,
-0.336672157,
-0.7850993872,
-0.2687183619,
0.1404583752,
0.4989732206,
0.7562738657,
0.3351897597,
0.3443255424,
-0.8233430386,
0.1497286409,
-0.1453448385,
0.7574439645,
-0.4187178314,
-0.4836451113,
-0.2523632944,
0.0364248008,
0.2391066551,
-0.9583243728,
0.1999190301,
0.5847665668,
0.150618434,
-0.5203030109,
0.2076476812,
1.0831295252,
-0.6871274114,
0.895001471,
0.0919365361,
-1.4154555798,
0.8596409559,
-0.1810382754,
0.0599992052,
0.5788300633,
-0.1988731772,
-0.5666923523,
-0.2871252894,
-0.5101441145,
-0.6378365755,
0.9869263172,
0.2023666054,
0.0428297073,
-0.1025878042,
0.6157572269,
-0.1697218418,
0.1900267899,
-0.8122174144,
-0.0712874681,
-0.4234596789,
-0.3705790043,
0.2222283334,
-0.2335674614,
0.0885492712,
-0.3551059961,
0.5902580023,
-0.3258745074,
0.1530392319,
0.2998740673,
-0.4240370393,
-0.202388674,
0.3001582623,
0.333226949,
1.0026829243,
-0.258841306,
-0.0668711364,
0.5242566466,
-0.1080272049,
-0.0660628304,
0.0024259824,
0.0832103416,
0.2716184855,
0.0945112482,
0.5420354605,
-0.0652440563,
-0.8196883798,
0.5388903022,
-0.2399461567,
0.2320208102,
-0.2895679176,
0.0083798384,
0.2075818032,
-0.2121966779,
0.1232542247,
0.4595271349,
0.043033652,
-0.4634748697,
0.1419414282,
0.2468832582,
-0.4548700154,
0.0771210939,
0.7287211418,
0.2823351324,
-0.4604400992,
0.5997296572,
-0.1877645105,
-0.3575541377,
0.5840328336,
0.7493487,
0.5694596171,
-0.2546668947,
-0.1497593671,
0.4004069269,
0.3530008197,
-0.1323618144,
0.2707135379,
0.2862914503,
-0.4834614694,
-0.7072111964,
-0.3689623177,
-0.3329747021,
-0.3623316884,
-0.4248694777,
0.5541790724,
-0.3991733193,
0.1241800487,
-0.0508728586,
-0.2217516005,
-0.0701395199,
0.4190426767,
-0.5573111176,
0.8822551966,
-0.6253662109,
1.1218520403,
0.8219909668,
-0.3830290139,
-0.5884700418,
-0.1517011821,
-0.4810459018,
-0.3791832626,
0.4170558751,
-0.0797215104,
0.1468342841,
-0.1192202345,
-0.4337036908,
-0.5505365729,
0.4015088081,
0.5023081899,
-0.5124204755,
-0.3660866022,
0.3449459076,
0.6904965639,
-0.4945548177,
0.0777608752,
0.6524866819,
0.0511393398,
-0.1713603139,
-0.8838397861,
0.0554692335,
-0.1085715517,
0.3374795318,
0.4540336132,
0.0450402312,
0.8786316514,
-0.2389892936,
0.2511003613,
0.171257779,
0.7283861041,
-0.0573548116,
0.000819313,
0.5464705229,
0.525008738,
0.7182661295,
-0.2313958108,
0.9218675494,
-0.2101265639,
0.5825155973,
1.4467693567,
-0.3490359485,
0.8548406959,
0.4343517125,
-0.3351149857,
0.4089873731,
0.4922893047,
0.0358098485,
0.1442768872,
0.0817888007,
-0.0438110866,
-0.087356545,
0.1821212023,
-0.4250462055,
0.0995336324,
0.5028030872,
-0.3657553792,
-0.1198052466,
-0.46238029,
0.0467755422,
0.345561415,
-0.2506096959,
0.7365201116,
-0.2375678122,
-0.5846944451,
0.6984170079,
0.2583371401,
0.6468123198,
-0.3594687879,
-0.1463352293,
-0.2817929685,
0.3108527362,
-0.6465022564,
-0.6204044223,
0.8259418011,
0.3588400483,
-0.272873491,
0.1202648878,
0.7757559419,
-0.6761448383,
-0.36534518,
0.1593685597,
0.0711724535,
-0.0389896184,
-0.4027239978,
-0.9032997489,
-0.0154853705,
0.1585472822,
0.3305426538,
0.032217402,
0.3791880906,
-0.0589761697,
0.15817523,
0.5442242622,
0.0562481359,
0.4053341746,
0.0585867688,
0.5172845721,
-0.8398262262,
-0.5733079314,
-0.7399088144,
0.6324284673,
-0.4713045657,
-0.2816922069,
0.3453625441,
0.7171288133,
0.8269955516,
-0.4158826768,
0.5116225481,
-0.3695201874,
0.4985925555,
-0.5653051138,
0.6263670921,
-0.5953124166,
0.5879687667,
-0.3175648749,
-1.1376596689,
-0.677605927,
0.6462856531,
-0.2130184323,
-0.0931194425,
0.8330116868,
1.1220816374,
0.1846528649,
0.1516164094,
0.1732768118,
0.5245354772,
0.3833504319,
0.2840307057,
0.7179368734,
-0.7686303854,
0.4837639034,
-0.2264005542,
-0.0635891035,
-0.4066404998,
-0.9451315403,
-0.750846386,
-0.4843691885,
-0.4807856083,
-0.8143144846,
0.4394936562,
1.1860604286,
0.3952914178,
-0.9851933122,
-0.2846460342,
-0.4125139415,
0.2210007459,
-0.2714159489,
-0.1727132499,
0.5928282738,
-0.9867843986,
-0.6431495547,
0.42846331,
0.1865697801,
-0.1653029174,
0.3210832775,
0.1511524618,
-0.2521914244,
0.2180818915,
0.7541059256,
0.1780804992,
-0.7709531188,
-0.1962902844,
-0.0275962315,
-0.4585643709,
0.3262759149,
0.8142784834,
-0.6010291576,
0.3841661811,
0.5085142255,
0.618797183,
0.0625803098,
-0.0367475301,
0.633943975,
-0.8615964055,
0.0979621485,
0.2428656071,
0.5593454242,
0.4524522722,
-0.3797130287,
0.7432735562,
0.4060117006,
-0.5157359242,
-0.9993649125,
0.0613999292,
-0.9357046485,
-0.3858941495,
0.8613992333,
-0.2639466226,
-0.3141553998,
-0.3231342733,
-0.7029305696,
0.2191391289,
-0.0295912009,
0.5764315724,
0.4603848755,
0.0490376391,
0.1515287757,
-0.0508178882,
0.775647223,
0.7162405252,
-1.0219758749,
0.4879161119,
0.7863653302,
0.4223357439,
-0.1046407446,
0.5452061892,
-0.4140503705,
0.4402657747,
0.0702090338,
0.148550421,
0.1567078382,
-0.1451767683,
-0.5042979121,
0.0514188223,
0.1483606994,
0.1297152489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13071v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13071v2 | Machine-Created Universal Language for Cross-lingual Transfer | 2023-05-22T14:41:09 | 2023-12-17T03:20:13 | Yaobo Liang, Quanzhi Zhu, Junhe Zhao, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL | There are two primary approaches to addressing cross-lingual transfer:
multilingual pre-training, which implicitly aligns the hidden representations
of various languages, and translate-test, which explicitly translates different
languages into an intermediate language, such as English. Translate-test offers
better interpretability compared to multilingual pre-training. However, it has
lower performance than multilingual pre-training(Conneau and Lample, 2019;
Conneau et al, 2020) and struggles with word-level tasks due to translation
altering word order. As a result, we propose a new Machine-created Universal
Language (MUL) as an alternative intermediate language. MUL comprises a set of
discrete symbols forming a universal vocabulary and a natural language to MUL
translator for converting multiple natural languages to MUL. MUL unifies shared
concepts from various languages into a single universal word, enhancing
cross-language transfer. Additionally, MUL retains language-specific words and
word order, allowing the model to be easily applied to word-level tasks. Our
experiments demonstrate that translating into MUL yields improved performance
compared to multilingual pre-training, and our analysis indicates that MUL
possesses strong interpretability. The code is at:
https://github.com/microsoft/Unicoder/tree/master/MCUL. | [
-0.4503474236,
-0.6571973562,
0.2562003732,
0.3116080761,
-0.1938912868,
0.366786927,
-0.1794319898,
-0.7194071412,
0.0244329982,
0.3088856041,
-0.4210501015,
-0.1610804349,
-0.5162777305,
0.3215260804,
-0.2978961468,
1.1451910734,
-0.2362914532,
0.0537730791,
0.1273534,
-0.4000095427,
-0.3265635669,
-0.7174537778,
-0.5401883125,
-0.4796314538,
0.5629910827,
0.3430272043,
0.8998225927,
0.3699924946,
0.5505341291,
0.342441678,
0.3600852489,
0.14219217,
-0.324118644,
-0.4736366868,
-0.4057877362,
-0.2876051664,
-0.6293156743,
-0.1280599385,
0.7477921844,
0.8808760047,
0.210874185,
0.1970061511,
0.3187938035,
0.6937097311,
-0.6025910974,
0.1384726018,
-0.661403358,
0.0733095184,
-0.2970464528,
-0.1108031943,
-0.4685118794,
-0.0766718239,
-0.0990720615,
-0.7017465234,
0.0060106665,
0.0520316996,
0.7597923279,
-0.0599580556,
-0.570081234,
-0.275690794,
-0.700967133,
0.64966923,
-0.3704762757,
0.9391338825,
0.0472008735,
0.3892399371,
0.0453346707,
-0.8278459311,
-0.7602763176,
-0.2061421573,
-0.1998874843,
0.2550202012,
-0.2065350711,
0.028957434,
-0.0745143518,
0.0746956244,
-0.8371296525,
-0.0178052187,
-0.2989577055,
-0.2847889662,
0.5946329832,
-0.0079075145,
0.785317421,
0.0944549665,
-0.4990942478,
0.0536597893,
-0.7943808436,
0.1568896025,
0.0785542503,
0.4194158614,
-0.0320279449,
0.4453370571,
-0.1180873513,
0.5960746408,
-0.2004160732,
-0.0745791495,
0.3381253183,
-0.4984845519,
-0.2221550494,
0.1746174246,
0.7441294789,
0.1695775837,
0.5614551306,
-0.3082289994,
-0.1314677596,
0.1849195212,
-0.0076117869,
-0.866492033,
-0.1303895563,
-0.2228356004,
-0.4035506845,
-0.0261881519,
0.1556178033,
-0.2698556483,
0.0466956943,
-0.461994499,
0.3881332576,
-0.5709386468,
-0.3535536528,
0.2424723655,
0.3242059648,
0.051147826,
0.2464809418,
-0.7005728483,
0.3721186817,
0.4143536091,
0.6080389023,
-0.4628240168,
-0.7324256301,
-0.6251520514,
0.3915337622,
-0.3904705644,
0.6539609432,
-0.4631708562,
-0.4152775705,
-0.063768521,
0.1901493967,
-0.3492076099,
-0.3837690055,
0.2766248286,
-0.4971187115,
0.2691509128,
0.0354787856,
-0.2263587117,
-0.2629530132,
0.1636981219,
-0.604079783,
0.8314986825,
0.0744845793,
-0.6946025491,
0.2249073237,
-1.1875498295,
-0.7742457986,
0.1498551071,
-0.2108267397,
0.0507398061,
-0.0338401124,
0.2260830849,
0.3040079474,
-0.1613024026,
0.1818982065,
-0.2522360682,
-0.4028884172,
0.27551651,
-0.5334708691,
0.7868314981,
0.52663517,
-0.2897568941,
-0.1451989561,
-0.6319754124,
0.2475445718,
0.0314913802,
-0.4511018097,
-0.3089717329,
-0.2771929204,
0.3039042354,
0.5068101287,
0.4307266176,
-0.5538892746,
0.122867614,
-0.27792418,
-0.0714643076,
0.5184221864,
-0.4939816296,
0.6676995158,
0.0255315434,
0.6668338776,
0.0489908718,
0.108448185,
-0.0183307622,
-0.4521427453,
-0.7913141251,
-0.1285424829,
0.3228375316,
0.7961662412,
-0.9454883933,
0.2717926204,
-0.4158783555,
-0.0386248082,
-0.8371660709,
0.3697812855,
0.6011669636,
0.2094478607,
0.3976309299,
-0.165855661,
-0.6669237614,
-0.8506563902,
-0.3098724782,
-0.1319625527,
-0.0179804247,
-0.1199611053,
0.2236713022,
-0.5080888271,
0.628921926,
-0.1974647194,
-0.241164133,
-0.4927408397,
0.1861857027,
0.0321148261,
0.5698528886,
0.3908374012,
-0.7867190838,
-0.9009928703,
0.7115731835,
-0.7137231827,
-0.1334947348,
-0.1696212143,
-0.5101541281,
0.4493995011,
0.6416145563,
-0.3937237561,
0.4600341022,
0.8837980628,
-0.3355660141,
0.5175654292,
-0.3967185616,
0.2899658382,
-1.1345849037,
0.5041763783,
-0.537463963,
-0.3277286887,
-0.5387808681,
0.1670336723,
0.3461822271,
-0.2634957433,
-0.798931241,
0.8596718907,
-0.6981612444,
-0.0779985636,
-0.2293450236,
-0.0109700346,
0.0069565289,
0.3410711288,
0.0212363284,
0.9258263707,
0.4979343116,
-0.5821967721,
0.0490959063,
0.0767454579,
-0.1298469603,
0.7988567948,
-0.4169256091,
0.2352907211,
0.114767544,
0.0092119798,
-0.837908566,
0.1567399949,
0.2170239538,
-0.4729369283,
0.4940228462,
0.0940197185,
-0.4246434569,
-0.320537746,
0.2506300807,
0.4886787236,
0.3000603616,
-0.5629622936,
0.4388301969,
0.125674367,
-0.1272173673,
-0.5848206282,
-0.8850373626,
0.259246856,
0.0932550207,
-0.6357516646,
0.2827103436,
-0.6068621278,
-0.0148121892,
0.0296490565,
0.1072725505,
-0.2770433128,
0.1653911769,
-0.0442405231,
0.3710080087,
-0.5321249962,
0.0198090412,
0.1928516775,
-0.2883319557,
-0.2177022845,
-0.3557431996,
0.4399623573,
-0.4210702777,
-0.3931786418,
-0.2437935472,
0.6567905545,
0.7172737718,
-0.4767253399,
0.483532697,
0.8107044697,
-0.1863248497,
-0.0140488669,
-0.2448003292,
0.1319676787,
-0.5059870481,
0.549562037,
-1.0484938622,
-0.7090446353,
0.289024502,
-0.0990951136,
0.1097802967,
0.3724875748,
0.5314446688,
-0.0229351316,
1.3495004177,
0.9051027894,
-0.1383847445,
0.2903839648,
0.0259628035,
0.0453534126,
-0.5931094885,
-0.0284505561,
-0.3250905573,
-0.3288499117,
-0.4075709581,
-0.3678670824,
0.0276446883,
0.3038910925,
-0.1834826618,
0.4386676252,
-0.3107168078,
0.589394629,
0.1707191169,
-0.3317880034,
0.4828894138,
0.1649881005,
-0.5261788964,
-0.1176180243,
-0.5380958319,
-0.5642263889,
0.9401930571,
0.0218161345,
0.7718705535,
0.1908008754,
0.643350184,
0.2257058322,
0.6930705309,
-0.394731015,
0.4970234632,
-0.5486166477,
-0.5244609714,
-0.2157768309,
-0.3496497273,
-1.3869261742,
0.5640850663,
-0.073966071,
-0.6992923617,
-0.3150584698,
-0.0511412099,
0.1159447134,
0.4959543347,
-0.6648005247,
1.0704126358,
-0.6687480211,
0.0144395893,
-0.0180739649,
-0.6486144066,
0.3434776068,
-0.3772829175,
0.4994605184,
0.0151397744,
-0.1352611333,
0.4452824891,
-0.184985891,
0.3926276565,
0.1167822182,
-0.1658194661,
0.0583469495,
0.4443641603,
0.3615196645,
-0.1119094118,
-0.0982870013,
0.2195750028,
-0.0118841436,
-0.4862262607,
-0.7228193283,
0.6721807718,
-0.8027706146,
-0.4402991831,
-0.171438098,
-0.9967125058,
-0.1448708177,
0.5117339492,
0.2621252239,
0.1999391019,
-0.4080350697,
0.0769820958,
0.2105430812,
-0.0852433592,
0.4307943583,
0.927855134,
-0.7032033801,
-0.1790845394,
1.0882570744,
0.0991579071,
0.4208362699,
0.6883981228,
0.2683523595,
-0.5228052735,
-0.4014406204,
-0.860217452,
0.1541401148,
-0.4684426188,
0.2013129443,
-0.6936693788,
-0.2115366608,
-0.552770853,
-0.4036758244,
-0.4045450389,
-0.2767204344,
-0.2537721395,
0.0961198285,
-0.2056100816,
0.5289642215,
-0.2026579082,
0.1568717957,
-1.0366832018,
0.4083096981,
0.1714077592,
0.1454491615,
-0.352085948,
-0.5633416772,
-0.2650302351,
0.2518317103,
-0.1569745243,
-0.5842108727,
0.2784557343,
0.4313820899,
0.7405902147,
0.3941475153,
-0.0198149905,
0.8752636909,
-0.7500601411,
0.3087102771,
0.6876266599,
-1.0917186737,
0.2679527998,
0.0528645255,
0.4931410551,
0.5836594701,
0.4779177904,
-0.8734618425,
-0.5367329121,
-0.4600603282,
-0.439278841,
0.5629888177,
0.0609368347,
0.1537171006,
0.1044238582,
-0.2039381415,
0.2966367006,
0.014713848,
-0.7446537018,
-0.3333240449,
-0.0894189253,
-0.2316249758,
-0.4182918668,
0.120752953,
0.2342511564,
-0.2796338201,
0.3661675155,
-0.3078812063,
0.0726176128,
0.0093256636,
-0.6528926492,
-0.0152547397,
0.4164409637,
0.3161777854,
0.7474060059,
-0.0857404619,
0.4989629388,
0.3028381169,
-0.4897457659,
0.3474456668,
0.2117383629,
-0.0865733474,
0.1643722504,
0.2483709157,
0.5500722528,
0.2641815543,
-0.5554200411,
0.3726804554,
0.2076832205,
-0.1027279869,
0.0715046301,
-0.2388386726,
0.2259388268,
0.0053911228,
0.1416419148,
0.101080358,
0.1595360041,
-0.7327120304,
0.5191963911,
0.3285971582,
-0.5678396225,
-0.5658211112,
0.6970672607,
0.3310061097,
-0.424009949,
0.4441808164,
-0.2571007609,
-0.6745735407,
0.2067911327,
0.9765741229,
0.6764336228,
-0.6071386337,
0.3458825946,
0.122483857,
0.6105268002,
0.3819736838,
0.4904718101,
-0.0328770205,
-0.7455816865,
-0.4644276798,
-0.6119600534,
-0.0978826359,
-0.0501889996,
-0.4645995498,
0.0827888772,
-0.0723245367,
0.1726291329,
-0.1063328236,
-0.0939120054,
-1.0692001581,
0.1857899874,
0.4357294142,
0.7212030292,
-0.773850143,
1.3740752935,
1.0011912584,
-0.5077614188,
-0.7148101926,
-0.2320385277,
-0.1808951497,
-0.9466690421,
0.9526414275,
0.1869130433,
-0.2740228772,
0.0977487639,
-0.1318041533,
-0.8550608754,
0.8111024499,
0.6178148389,
-0.4702571929,
0.0827301592,
0.6974182129,
0.4309330881,
-0.4454458356,
0.1691268533,
0.4090314209,
0.6057379246,
0.0556304157,
-1.0446432829,
0.1915472597,
-0.3735870123,
0.0768579766,
0.3415771425,
-0.2460543662,
0.9788818359,
-0.230638206,
-0.5386758447,
0.0112668918,
0.7398110032,
0.0730717033,
0.3790662885,
0.5115061998,
0.3696649969,
0.7198271155,
0.2684957981,
1.0930606127,
-0.3052994907,
0.1658284664,
1.1430578232,
-0.4140685201,
0.9155423641,
0.5519090295,
-0.3763946295,
0.4766469002,
0.3592155278,
0.3889840245,
0.2653475106,
0.2133826613,
-0.1573728323,
-0.2704022229,
-0.1296011955,
-0.456553489,
0.2983305156,
0.1095113084,
-0.1421375424,
-0.3635669649,
0.1615281403,
0.1322868466,
0.0118763065,
-0.2218997777,
0.4188523889,
0.0972608402,
-0.5318239331,
0.747998476,
-0.1308943778,
0.8191153407,
-0.8349047303,
-0.0214850679,
-0.4285039008,
0.3654046357,
-0.0076187965,
-0.8208306432,
0.3172614276,
-0.1515008062,
0.0299950559,
-0.2953902185,
0.7107151151,
-0.8171799183,
-0.8342934847,
0.5531209111,
0.84115237,
0.4954459071,
-0.204068318,
-1.0893741846,
-0.1801586896,
0.1071801111,
-0.1132665128,
0.4245713353,
0.6612955928,
-0.2047463655,
0.6246494055,
1.0217702389,
0.0232492182,
0.2895555496,
0.0593740977,
0.4633016586,
-0.4792418182,
-0.5978422761,
-0.598538816,
0.465287745,
0.1724338084,
-0.2638229728,
0.7372457981,
0.7517761588,
1.0759707689,
-0.176461339,
0.8835175633,
-0.1143306941,
0.1895686686,
-0.4911189675,
1.0244377851,
-0.9653973579,
-0.2722336948,
-0.3407719433,
-0.8869318366,
-0.4385603368,
0.3318630755,
0.2153254747,
-0.2076209933,
1.0432726145,
0.7139524817,
-0.4079402387,
-0.2597788572,
0.9438369274,
-0.0470947884,
0.3168923259,
0.7695021033,
0.8513890505,
-0.3013007939,
1.0691168308,
-0.0779276043,
-0.1138606668,
-0.1092329621,
-0.7361337543,
-0.7198410034,
-0.4547542632,
-0.2263560742,
-0.2454569042,
0.0453256369,
0.6518828273,
0.6715047956,
-0.8917632699,
-0.5932341218,
0.0450842232,
0.0824798122,
-0.2911720872,
-0.159382239,
0.3676143885,
-0.521487236,
-0.841219008,
0.4500901699,
0.2463975251,
0.177156657,
-0.251204133,
-0.5730454922,
-0.4082450867,
-0.0288318712,
0.878113389,
0.4119891524,
-0.6804175973,
-0.3296969533,
0.132467404,
-0.3729856908,
0.0455250069,
0.9180806279,
-0.4334692657,
0.6097325087,
0.3828154802,
0.8303262591,
0.3049088717,
-0.3960259259,
0.6470522881,
-0.505340457,
0.1923952699,
-0.1113919169,
0.4396412373,
0.1575879157,
-0.1256634891,
0.6400803328,
0.2881591022,
-0.2049380243,
-0.5116966963,
0.280316323,
-0.9204057455,
-0.4894389808,
1.0307170153,
-0.2102297693,
-0.1791889518,
-0.3162897229,
-0.4507068992,
0.453137368,
-0.1234379858,
0.3091345131,
0.4534745514,
0.1106870547,
0.0899959579,
-0.4102783501,
0.1496158987,
0.4994976521,
-0.9135931134,
-0.1358242929,
0.2387065887,
0.2781347334,
0.1380589902,
0.720903933,
-0.1488573253,
0.331287235,
-0.097278513,
0.4992104769,
-0.1042666808,
-0.4173330963,
-0.1069968417,
-0.0679619759,
-0.125151515,
-0.5815305114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13067v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13067v2 | Distilling Robustness into Natural Language Inference Models with Domain-Targeted Augmentation | 2023-05-22T14:37:05 | 2024-05-30T10:00:14 | Joe Stacey, Marek Rei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | Knowledge distillation optimises a smaller student model to behave similarly
to a larger teacher model, retaining some of the performance benefits. While
this method can improve results on in-distribution examples, it does not
necessarily generalise to out-of-distribution (OOD) settings. We investigate
two complementary methods for improving the robustness of the resulting student
models on OOD domains. The first approach augments the distillation with
generated unlabelled examples that match the target distribution. The second
method upsamples data points among the training set that are similar to the
target distribution. When applied on the task of natural language inference
(NLI), our experiments on MNLI show that distillation with these modifications
outperforms previous robustness solutions. We also find that these methods
improve performance on OOD domains even beyond the target domain. | [
-0.3004094362,
-0.7812575102,
0.5353546739,
-0.2201863676,
-0.2400542498,
0.2058264464,
-0.3931773305,
-0.4508602619,
-0.2946103811,
0.4660482705,
-0.4369214177,
-0.2614614964,
-0.6036546826,
0.2090766877,
-0.1951731294,
0.893417418,
0.2791955769,
0.013578522,
-0.4938189387,
-0.213133201,
-0.3947606385,
-0.5868938565,
-0.5525624752,
-0.6938901544,
-0.017879473,
0.2981990278,
0.7585520148,
0.5855529308,
0.482927084,
0.2871625721,
-0.3645414114,
0.4227365255,
-0.4867138565,
0.389778167,
-0.2925120592,
-0.5962186456,
-0.292916894,
-0.0196862724,
0.3960820436,
1.0974636078,
-0.0590009056,
-0.1720817536,
0.5735295415,
0.6274136901,
-0.9626783729,
-0.1041210964,
-0.7556065917,
-0.2335639894,
0.1047645211,
0.0305698924,
-0.5578945875,
-0.3858034611,
0.4252024591,
-0.6183079481,
0.5001155734,
0.0092993807,
0.7954519391,
0.4586752951,
-0.5061221123,
-0.3546439409,
-0.9149970412,
1.3160034418,
-1.0848754644,
0.1573756188,
0.6782873869,
0.5247498155,
-0.329303056,
-0.6856580973,
-0.523462534,
-0.1568749696,
-0.1062680781,
-0.1226130575,
-0.2085674703,
0.0759616196,
0.3150330782,
0.5736720562,
-0.1571988761,
0.0442665257,
-0.1184073463,
0.0957486108,
0.6091140509,
-0.1721399873,
0.1059238985,
0.0956587642,
-0.3808498681,
-0.3136332631,
-0.4167917371,
-0.0928563997,
0.6087675095,
0.4785220921,
0.3064315915,
0.6024932861,
-0.1204256266,
0.8865074515,
0.2807253599,
-0.5684270263,
0.1568714529,
-0.5467763543,
-0.2550105453,
0.0257277861,
0.3078655601,
0.2826369107,
0.3354263604,
-0.1479544044,
-0.284098655,
-0.0003534066,
0.2639602423,
-0.8051570654,
-0.5527004004,
0.2048150897,
-0.379245311,
-0.4789335728,
-0.0146804778,
-0.7737366557,
-0.3969647586,
-0.459644407,
0.3708950281,
-0.6244418621,
-0.4160556793,
0.1251203567,
-0.4873750806,
-0.2728531659,
0.0257248376,
-1.1520363092,
0.3992339075,
0.6816140413,
0.7378223538,
-0.1834706962,
-0.1181935742,
-0.517909646,
0.2577426732,
-0.0671709254,
0.5559237003,
-0.6698400974,
-0.3151103258,
-0.062397372,
-0.4198868871,
-0.0802279785,
-1.0379765034,
0.6805685163,
-0.4519100487,
0.2598393261,
-0.1434088051,
-0.7579299212,
-0.1265149415,
0.2549033463,
-0.650167942,
1.3325403929,
0.2333702296,
-0.8858442307,
0.6628547907,
-0.6537356973,
-0.488578707,
-0.4021012187,
0.3010392785,
-0.4677078426,
0.3628582358,
0.494843483,
0.3182663918,
-0.0332187042,
0.3477889597,
-0.5296990871,
-0.0956543311,
0.1609408855,
-0.7276828885,
0.9374677539,
0.2545844316,
-0.1686437279,
-0.2601486444,
-1.0070081949,
-0.0428997427,
0.0113014961,
-0.2203840315,
-1.0918531418,
-0.0295805503,
-0.1234103218,
-0.2199289203,
-0.0819882527,
-0.4274076223,
0.3022965789,
-0.7266744971,
0.551051259,
0.3901304007,
0.3076224625,
0.8260855675,
-0.2154166698,
0.2966440022,
0.081461221,
0.2219756395,
0.0680714995,
-0.6111263633,
-0.3403785527,
-0.6351754665,
0.3375579715,
0.3351516724,
-1.185005784,
0.4292411506,
-0.2318027318,
-0.3678194284,
-0.3716886044,
0.3157046437,
0.1822439879,
0.9005582333,
0.4548955858,
-0.0790963471,
-0.4438678026,
-0.5528886318,
-0.4228027463,
-0.2738865316,
-0.2040809244,
-0.1839081496,
0.411803633,
-0.1857531816,
1.3106393814,
-0.624610126,
-0.1955035925,
-0.4640084207,
0.21964553,
0.2853980064,
0.47404176,
0.8538768888,
-1.1114023924,
-0.6257959604,
-0.0913267061,
-0.5287234187,
-0.1083971485,
0.016567355,
-0.2288703322,
0.0339831002,
0.0862571374,
-0.416639477,
0.6023233533,
0.3002551496,
-0.1992995739,
0.2368907183,
-0.2394279391,
0.1268024892,
-1.3849449158,
-0.2097846866,
0.0783036202,
-0.3321611881,
-1.0537964106,
0.0505773239,
-0.0611650012,
0.0835481063,
-0.3592437506,
0.2934629023,
-0.5123015642,
0.2475370616,
-0.5469006896,
0.2258967906,
0.5536046028,
0.0497263372,
-0.0128134806,
0.6640890241,
0.6666105986,
-0.7750812173,
0.3152239621,
0.2630671561,
-0.3234266639,
0.7896103859,
-0.6153792739,
-0.034675464,
-0.263735801,
-0.0263666175,
-1.0491341352,
-0.3050677776,
0.0233763196,
-0.3406502604,
0.5942609906,
-0.3155980706,
-0.2952607572,
-0.2689465284,
-0.4576054513,
0.3482461572,
0.6488668919,
-0.9373809099,
0.657199502,
0.2155486047,
0.1934934109,
-0.665240407,
-1.096414566,
-0.1255710125,
-0.6789257526,
-0.4968836606,
0.3526160717,
-0.0436428115,
-0.6545753479,
0.1722825468,
-0.1734569222,
-0.53840065,
0.2918299735,
0.0307197887,
0.3397949338,
-0.1706829965,
0.0915292054,
0.2722405493,
0.0752420872,
-0.0484210514,
-0.4677246511,
0.1981454194,
0.3620741665,
-0.4871584773,
-0.2980143428,
0.4418403804,
0.2718346417,
-0.0228338595,
0.9989103079,
0.3104625046,
-0.6082730889,
-0.5292127728,
-0.4222999215,
-0.6029479504,
-0.5279102921,
0.0622382388,
-0.384875387,
-0.5317209959,
0.2779639363,
-0.1451478899,
0.1372274756,
0.1894559264,
0.2239926308,
0.0983423367,
0.8581204414,
0.8145228624,
-0.141844511,
0.4201444387,
-0.2856534123,
0.5299561024,
-0.6374796033,
0.0407233164,
-0.7012556195,
-0.1576008201,
-0.0742738321,
-0.4000036716,
0.2292585671,
0.3798354864,
0.3465559483,
0.5053399801,
-0.506293118,
0.5864720941,
0.774638176,
0.0490130484,
0.6310269833,
0.3926801383,
-0.1273433566,
-0.3018485606,
-0.8236311078,
-0.6598128676,
1.1754715443,
0.2903693318,
0.7364048362,
0.2591926157,
0.8630310297,
0.1477256268,
0.4943413138,
-0.5538548231,
0.0928832516,
-0.1183904856,
-0.7693363428,
-0.3789461553,
-0.575144887,
-0.6300247312,
0.221561715,
-0.1563415676,
-0.7136930227,
0.5211680532,
0.3815628886,
-0.3693075478,
0.4720392227,
-1.0058240891,
0.6535001397,
0.1698150188,
-0.250939548,
0.1437486559,
-0.4701333642,
0.4179022014,
-0.1949278712,
0.1611924767,
-0.0394828171,
0.1664181203,
0.2259591371,
-0.7663174868,
0.8573488593,
-0.2770802677,
-0.1923842281,
0.6336246133,
-0.2393473238,
0.5371904373,
0.0781288072,
-0.5174770355,
-0.1115497053,
-0.0208375622,
-0.4838101566,
-1.0257657766,
0.6222675443,
-0.4531466365,
-0.5982034802,
-0.157631442,
-0.6193989515,
-0.471752435,
0.098822549,
0.426769942,
0.6560809612,
-0.0106488252,
0.2578567266,
0.8886470199,
0.0754661784,
0.5842400193,
0.1854467541,
0.0144474441,
-0.35053128,
0.7824698091,
0.028554108,
0.9024305344,
0.3717630208,
0.2445544749,
-0.7341151834,
-0.7860689759,
-0.4852535427,
-0.1401782185,
-0.9403278232,
-0.1789924204,
-0.513520956,
-0.0146965003,
-0.7524706721,
-0.0594765246,
-0.3318295181,
-0.4019878507,
-0.4792868197,
-0.1925231814,
0.4427866936,
0.5639556646,
-0.0932095423,
0.2208214849,
-0.6032083035,
0.4051336348,
0.38515535,
0.027629165,
-0.0637819096,
-0.8920596242,
0.035323292,
0.4816996753,
-0.2930946052,
-0.8743356466,
0.4061318934,
0.7772036195,
0.6022803187,
0.6021364331,
0.7114928961,
0.8756157756,
-0.224819079,
0.7027561665,
0.0691646188,
-0.7602306008,
0.7632110119,
-0.0569522083,
0.220240131,
0.9399914742,
0.5328059196,
0.1851426363,
-0.6310256124,
-0.3487985432,
-0.7769463658,
0.4072163403,
0.4521385431,
0.3392326534,
-0.0404516496,
0.3257316053,
0.3603697121,
0.173655048,
-0.5521985888,
-0.3804685175,
-0.0831000134,
-0.5014976263,
-0.0646493807,
-0.255928427,
-0.1390914023,
-0.2792150974,
0.8988111615,
-0.2407864034,
-0.3049408197,
0.2351426482,
-0.0524692796,
0.0685131326,
0.1337005496,
0.2874143422,
0.7242563367,
-0.2917184532,
0.3998725116,
0.2698556185,
-0.7740647793,
0.2731810212,
0.145612821,
-0.3034686148,
0.2141545117,
0.358045578,
0.7401365042,
0.0049228803,
-0.5774915814,
0.437125802,
-0.1132525876,
-0.2241367549,
0.1265851408,
0.2441020608,
-0.1786388159,
0.3099453151,
0.5425776839,
0.3283318877,
0.4741865993,
-0.5934309363,
0.193392992,
0.2859048247,
-0.2728774846,
-0.0952688381,
0.8126845956,
-0.0130986227,
-0.0175806265,
0.4128369689,
-0.2591599226,
-0.279427141,
0.4326156676,
0.6847957373,
0.7659413815,
-0.1752044857,
0.1400090009,
0.3111722171,
0.2744980752,
-0.3238071501,
0.0189037137,
-0.1785341799,
-0.6967153549,
-0.5138046741,
-0.4935482442,
-0.4436173439,
-0.1180168539,
-0.991627574,
0.1435501724,
-0.0049246182,
-0.4750590324,
0.1370245516,
-0.1341801435,
-0.3551219404,
0.1959150285,
-0.1248912737,
0.8397603631,
-0.9451158047,
1.0021790266,
0.8506244421,
-0.1162511036,
-0.7503999472,
0.3239023089,
-0.0844423771,
-0.1703080982,
0.3174450994,
0.0350438505,
-0.0372682847,
-0.0719332695,
-0.2728773057,
-0.7466566563,
1.0714169741,
0.5775242448,
-0.3901599646,
0.273524493,
0.4338483512,
0.6078392267,
-0.1737581491,
0.0000718305,
0.7240036726,
0.2054003328,
0.2715305984,
-0.6899489164,
-0.2364481539,
-0.104350172,
0.1260055006,
0.1474094391,
0.0244469661,
0.537032187,
-0.3341604769,
-0.3054989576,
-0.0556711741,
0.7801530361,
0.2648059726,
0.6289131045,
0.6642010808,
0.6860913038,
0.9925749898,
-0.1026387736,
1.0572705269,
-0.0460960679,
0.3728398085,
1.3027745485,
-0.3948675394,
0.7397628427,
0.7924889326,
-0.2175317407,
0.2452946603,
0.3655801713,
0.2526322305,
0.9361599684,
-0.0781839713,
-0.5226064324,
-0.0960399732,
-0.2374041826,
-0.3489997089,
0.0757112354,
0.1331087649,
-0.3115551174,
-0.3284644783,
0.3872330785,
-0.0386513993,
0.5630902052,
-0.0108270068,
0.7179355025,
0.081221804,
-0.7203488946,
0.7610443234,
-0.0977385491,
0.6657028794,
-0.3082155585,
-0.0648941547,
-0.2925704718,
0.4951714277,
-0.0447681583,
-0.4777554274,
0.6835640073,
0.0876355022,
-0.3367018104,
-0.2646788955,
1.1046909094,
-0.5678746104,
-0.5439549685,
0.1651065648,
0.2806940079,
-0.0855526477,
-0.2853791416,
-0.373857677,
-0.1036525369,
0.0011979891,
-0.2535108328,
0.2952488065,
0.6416404843,
0.1468335539,
0.7033416629,
0.5792757869,
-0.0916459262,
0.2275975347,
0.1799885184,
1.0673192739,
0.0581348687,
-0.1996891499,
-1.0859810114,
0.6030678153,
-0.5303468704,
-0.3019753695,
1.0758943558,
0.3989778161,
0.8873543739,
-0.2707374692,
0.7708352804,
-0.0131162237,
0.6218323112,
-0.3886392713,
0.5582636595,
-0.4716111124,
0.3832942247,
-0.2155883908,
-1.1951286793,
-0.3535572588,
0.4596421421,
-0.3646148443,
-0.0035621857,
0.4823775887,
0.7758617401,
-0.2673931122,
0.012691007,
0.4552039504,
-0.2094704807,
0.2175037265,
0.4015465677,
0.8597285748,
-0.4870668054,
0.3213243783,
-0.7770876884,
-0.1304739118,
-0.0080608027,
-1.0040777922,
-1.3259905577,
-0.3557446003,
-0.5568030477,
-0.1941089481,
0.1078323424,
0.7456177473,
0.9278547168,
-0.9967726469,
0.248342827,
-0.2408463508,
0.1748460531,
-0.3986137211,
-0.2498350143,
0.0504253581,
-0.3972007036,
-1.0779187679,
0.5895830989,
0.1346154958,
0.225464046,
-0.2321832925,
0.0941282958,
-0.0880369246,
0.175413698,
0.5046002269,
-0.0513979867,
-0.4700943828,
-0.2572606206,
-0.0446285047,
0.0424305499,
-0.1099671274,
0.5991166234,
-0.5828151703,
0.4703979194,
0.4595997334,
0.6759582758,
0.1337573826,
0.3733402789,
0.6147873402,
-1.1993714571,
0.4453581572,
0.1862484813,
0.2027001083,
0.4699917436,
-0.28725335,
0.5449986458,
0.2354021519,
-0.3475658596,
-1.2285497189,
0.1203570366,
-0.6774839759,
-0.328273356,
1.1272752285,
-0.3981814682,
-0.2320960611,
-0.5546774268,
-0.2017953247,
0.1964048594,
-0.1306943595,
0.7864512205,
0.6860396862,
0.1996781975,
0.1689727157,
-0.6082718372,
0.5713912249,
0.4175462425,
-0.7846949697,
-0.033689037,
0.2582571805,
0.2598175406,
0.1535694301,
0.1064331457,
0.1401322782,
-0.1762119085,
0.1490634829,
-0.2913471162,
-0.1267599761,
-0.2659115493,
-0.157557562,
0.2618441582,
0.2338026017,
-0.2910799682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13068v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13068v3 | Making Language Models Better Tool Learners with Execution Feedback | 2023-05-22T14:37:05 | 2024-03-14T08:15:27 | Shuofei Qiao, Honghao Gui, Chengfei Lv, Qianghuai Jia, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG | Tools serve as pivotal interfaces that enable humans to understand and
reshape the environment. With the advent of foundation models, AI systems can
utilize tools to expand their capabilities and interact with the real world.
Existing tool learning methodologies, encompassing supervised fine-tuning and
prompt engineering approaches, often induce large language models to utilize
tools indiscriminately, as complex tasks often exceed their own competencies.
However, introducing tools for simple tasks, which the models themselves can
readily resolve, can inadvertently propagate errors rather than enhance
performance. This leads to the research question: can we teach language models
when and how to use tools? To meet this need, we propose Tool leaRning wIth
exeCution fEedback (TRICE), a two-stage end-to-end framework that enables the
model to continually learn through feedback derived from tool execution,
thereby learning when and how to use tools effectively. Experimental results,
backed by further analysis, show that TRICE can make the large language model
selectively use tools by improving the accuracy of tool usage while enhancing
insufficient tool learning and mitigating excessive reliance on tools. Code is
available at https://github.com/zjunlp/TRICE. | [
-0.1780459285,
-0.7039907575,
0.5093916059,
0.0664191991,
-0.206309244,
0.4261131585,
-0.4544505775,
-0.3592339754,
-0.4429409504,
0.4337804019,
-0.4055016637,
-0.6491122246,
-0.4284799397,
-0.1244250536,
-0.6432481408,
1.0003705025,
-0.0109983049,
0.12054535,
-0.0976016745,
0.0002643414,
-0.5567575693,
-0.3388321996,
-0.924756825,
-0.4159242511,
0.2727529705,
0.799210906,
0.753341198,
0.356697917,
0.2392970622,
0.3419001997,
0.0675763264,
0.0630358011,
-0.4576792717,
-0.1235146895,
-0.2627750337,
-0.8498239517,
-0.2972025871,
0.1086913273,
0.4093505442,
0.9866110682,
-0.2764892876,
0.3627272248,
0.4048098326,
0.1484731585,
-0.6405200958,
0.1207441315,
-0.3847201169,
-0.2084802985,
-0.0692952573,
-0.0175409093,
-0.7496601939,
-0.5101168752,
0.132709533,
-0.5025566816,
0.277608633,
0.0296200737,
0.5618023276,
0.4875270724,
0.0382524878,
-0.180772543,
-0.9001421332,
1.0151458979,
-0.8304149508,
0.5592960119,
0.3049064875,
0.4468657076,
-0.1132748872,
-0.7706673741,
-0.4684383869,
-0.5339348912,
0.0890042186,
-0.1817438006,
0.1877297014,
0.1678549647,
0.4124982655,
0.0936387405,
-0.1703148484,
0.1881143898,
-0.344917655,
-0.1531268507,
0.5511568785,
0.113843739,
0.5002254248,
0.1558942348,
-0.0082710776,
-0.3137737513,
-0.5499989986,
0.1319668889,
0.3790538311,
0.3301309645,
-0.2208947837,
0.3225799799,
0.1402443945,
0.8288397789,
-0.0098254057,
-0.0359568112,
0.2013655007,
-0.0820274055,
-0.2659886479,
-0.2556369305,
0.4260477424,
0.3467942476,
0.3864897192,
-0.4166967571,
-0.301880002,
0.1321567595,
0.5361805558,
-0.658856988,
-0.1186701581,
0.418577522,
-0.2086447477,
-0.4895005226,
-0.0055610519,
-0.6917344928,
-0.3883626759,
-0.4927511811,
0.3493745625,
-0.2350269556,
-0.3789738119,
0.2527282238,
-0.0537603647,
0.1297718585,
0.3374353945,
-0.5076714754,
0.5296775103,
0.6694436073,
0.9446942806,
0.0248941816,
-0.4670828581,
-0.9202018976,
-0.0734223351,
-0.659465611,
0.5267348289,
-0.684330523,
-0.6328889728,
-0.062618643,
0.0395459756,
0.1856669784,
-0.5071361661,
0.1307454407,
-0.4055514336,
0.4629781544,
-0.1778241843,
-0.2792020142,
-0.370185554,
-0.1383634955,
-0.5650741458,
1.2666431665,
0.3409967721,
-0.4799832702,
0.3852006197,
-0.8153977394,
-0.4652290046,
-0.0877669081,
-0.0128995618,
-0.4649972022,
0.3536000848,
0.1156891063,
0.4233256578,
-0.3637016714,
0.3043934703,
-0.6185212731,
-0.4191082716,
-0.2324746996,
-0.0509593748,
0.7712031007,
-0.0849866495,
-0.6606530547,
0.2921809852,
-0.5918325782,
0.2010836452,
0.0440198854,
-0.1015873477,
-0.0853300318,
0.0768691525,
0.0755243972,
0.2124372423,
0.0275713094,
-0.6780687571,
-0.0326218121,
-0.707380414,
0.1512832493,
0.6318442822,
-0.0715891421,
0.4646706283,
-0.2930842638,
0.566934824,
-0.2731479406,
0.14736256,
0.2468545437,
0.076103285,
-0.9608034492,
0.3262110651,
0.3201331794,
0.4992691278,
-0.8192874193,
0.0654681027,
-0.0225084499,
-0.5869547725,
-0.6067955494,
0.4858172238,
0.4686139226,
0.317540437,
0.1989419311,
-0.4424596727,
-0.6131654978,
-0.6140214801,
-0.2641752958,
-0.3420400023,
-0.1889269501,
0.3509064317,
0.3199491799,
0.1361294538,
0.9692307115,
-0.2345272303,
0.0353389904,
-0.6907660365,
0.3722109497,
0.0723855942,
0.2632763982,
0.5749859214,
-0.5919358134,
-0.4791586697,
0.06826967,
-0.509381175,
-0.3523193598,
-0.0657607764,
0.0516271889,
0.0897235498,
0.6120986342,
-0.0396098271,
0.3157345951,
0.4354654849,
-0.1622412205,
0.5587848425,
-0.0690778121,
-0.2011071444,
-0.9807022214,
0.2307650894,
-0.2927642465,
-0.4729587734,
-0.5553039908,
-0.1552928835,
-0.0102269761,
-0.0145521248,
-0.5997213125,
0.6545649767,
-0.3131574392,
-0.1995692849,
-0.5444235206,
0.1093981415,
-0.0765413865,
0.3773467541,
0.0963543877,
1.1520279646,
0.4196792245,
-0.6456333399,
0.2792441547,
0.0164712239,
-0.3125167489,
0.4275875688,
-0.9319375157,
0.2821806073,
0.0642211214,
-0.091988273,
-0.5922046304,
-0.2885863185,
0.0181074478,
-0.4656098783,
0.4805834591,
0.0004849631,
-0.6098601818,
-0.3817530572,
-0.258569628,
-0.1729581654,
0.461864382,
-0.5326980948,
0.552688241,
0.3933487833,
-0.123755239,
-0.6941476464,
-0.4211242199,
-0.0735839531,
0.1804597527,
-0.3510665298,
-0.1282009631,
-0.1128860265,
-0.1503093094,
-0.0612322204,
-0.1194484383,
-0.02057519,
0.5595600605,
0.3867681623,
0.2724491656,
0.0698150247,
0.5298178196,
-0.2821311951,
-0.2704514563,
0.2150511891,
-0.3241331279,
0.6376703382,
-0.3972781897,
-0.6732909679,
-0.3692073226,
0.1398985982,
0.7101603746,
-0.4303783476,
0.5340287089,
0.7584456205,
-0.2611654997,
-0.4301138818,
-0.6060761213,
-0.3923714757,
-0.4464741051,
0.6285615563,
-0.186031729,
-0.8437301517,
0.2605862916,
-0.4792862535,
0.6057676673,
0.1418802589,
0.7797034383,
-0.2041338235,
1.1783026457,
1.1700303555,
-0.1837495267,
0.6463227868,
-0.4711339474,
0.1789423823,
-0.9590311646,
0.0557320938,
-0.5447594523,
-0.1581258327,
-0.1344831735,
-0.3192403615,
0.1610499471,
0.2196185738,
-0.1360999048,
0.2667860687,
-0.437713176,
0.6507188678,
0.6341110468,
0.2242358923,
-0.0879825354,
-0.1544466168,
-0.3771726489,
0.2532135248,
-0.6534458995,
-0.7838275433,
1.2521207333,
0.3335846364,
0.7194091082,
-0.1860530227,
0.7918004394,
0.21580562,
0.4571316242,
-0.5720620751,
0.3662372231,
0.0256394017,
-0.4127781689,
-0.2836834788,
-0.0712942258,
-0.5080140829,
-0.0775355995,
0.1397085041,
-0.8370136619,
0.0710429922,
0.2626521885,
-0.6248247027,
0.4889532626,
-0.9135663509,
0.9378409386,
-0.3763484359,
-0.7106062174,
-0.4011005759,
-0.5676282644,
-0.1059882492,
0.0956939161,
0.5393142104,
0.0801199898,
0.0538519397,
0.5907096267,
-0.3868603408,
1.3547222614,
-0.3289978206,
-0.0252831932,
0.4208625853,
0.3442207873,
0.5519525409,
-0.0066655152,
-0.080701828,
-0.1923232526,
0.0619207658,
-0.3601938486,
-0.7577691674,
0.3017998636,
-0.7946742773,
-0.6498909593,
0.0083767688,
-0.5600660443,
-0.2783881426,
0.2793262899,
0.0191687923,
0.4820703864,
-0.0437359922,
0.1773460209,
0.394551605,
-0.1153848767,
0.508898735,
0.3768067658,
-0.4387829304,
-0.0224541575,
0.9575965405,
-0.2283254266,
0.5547806621,
-0.0659393817,
0.0300856475,
-0.0125931138,
-0.4815501869,
-0.3245094419,
0.1458586901,
-0.6935837865,
-0.0442753434,
-0.5694714785,
-0.0656873435,
-0.039133694,
-0.2650369108,
-0.5145196915,
-0.2779661715,
-0.2625337839,
-0.0947027355,
0.1939949393,
0.9721236229,
-0.0844694003,
0.7257204056,
-0.6853716969,
-0.016184995,
0.2863279283,
0.7108565569,
0.1196360365,
-0.291998446,
-0.3570506871,
0.1277235746,
-0.3497992158,
-0.7881116271,
0.0350825675,
0.2913775742,
0.5238525867,
0.0552669503,
-0.0319688804,
0.3685358465,
-0.2667067647,
0.7329538465,
-0.2339775264,
-1.1430017948,
0.6328796744,
0.0639106855,
0.4702403247,
0.5212627053,
0.1396112591,
-0.7967042923,
-0.6228642464,
-0.642449677,
-0.4825045466,
0.9079675078,
-0.0590264611,
0.1065193266,
0.2122749835,
0.2248623967,
0.201234743,
0.3209960759,
-0.6283462048,
0.2926231325,
-0.0166714676,
-0.331708163,
0.0664322451,
-0.2018889785,
-0.0529171079,
0.0972261205,
0.8247381449,
-0.4237251282,
-0.1511260867,
-0.1590382457,
-0.4968054593,
-0.2797994018,
0.4089176655,
0.2449469119,
0.8293913603,
-0.0960441381,
0.0502290986,
0.6001715064,
-0.339268744,
0.0576088242,
-0.3264487088,
-0.0730946139,
-0.0726232082,
0.6355713606,
0.6604283452,
0.5082198977,
-0.6348552704,
0.392866075,
-0.0272958539,
0.1565651894,
0.0017535123,
0.4280024767,
0.2267871797,
0.3537713289,
-0.1100562662,
-0.047315862,
0.1802300066,
-0.2848895192,
0.3964447379,
0.2649229765,
-0.5792833567,
-0.418409586,
0.3951948285,
0.4174751937,
-0.4554222524,
0.4688251019,
-0.1616234034,
-0.7845174074,
0.5542286038,
0.3439561129,
0.943875432,
-0.3450604677,
0.282210201,
0.3630907834,
0.4514403343,
-0.0787521601,
0.4449373782,
-0.1896510422,
-0.3861555755,
-0.6340366602,
-0.6487439871,
-0.5442774296,
-0.1105832905,
-0.4800025225,
0.611363709,
-0.6184592247,
-0.1274743676,
-0.2310180962,
0.0768577531,
-0.7106150985,
0.0642305538,
0.012718563,
0.9176956415,
-0.8974442482,
0.7316203713,
0.7999695539,
-0.4993359447,
-0.8880316019,
-0.2146936357,
0.1643695682,
-0.5696848035,
0.4418029189,
0.2262205631,
-0.3286029994,
0.1652251184,
-0.8400887251,
-0.7558515668,
0.7012313604,
0.3544855714,
-0.5310189128,
-0.2985386848,
0.1388069987,
0.5646452308,
-0.2484347522,
0.5661361814,
0.5397285819,
0.2463759035,
-0.0275608599,
-1.1961826086,
-0.1834733039,
-0.0753888264,
0.0737327635,
0.206905961,
-0.3777745664,
0.5269833207,
-0.539996624,
-0.5182982683,
-0.1993237585,
0.3613509834,
0.0742915645,
0.0323740952,
0.706011951,
0.5051604509,
0.4683107436,
-0.0634511262,
1.1910936832,
-0.289678365,
0.5185393095,
1.4530755281,
-0.1212784573,
0.7795879841,
0.3280297816,
-0.2315868884,
0.6110838056,
0.6613095403,
0.1897576302,
0.2492325008,
-0.0250508282,
0.1535547525,
-0.621553719,
-0.252086103,
-0.0841087848,
0.4373520911,
0.3666167259,
-0.0383333564,
-0.6419160962,
0.229941234,
0.0612364896,
0.0626831502,
0.0870091617,
0.8061588407,
0.1703802496,
-0.4883112609,
0.419837296,
-0.2375962287,
0.1814193428,
-0.4065599442,
-0.353418678,
0.1461082846,
0.2834703028,
-0.2428356111,
-0.7860842943,
0.3961288631,
-0.0772632658,
-0.1464132816,
0.0975934416,
0.4698194563,
-0.4546515644,
-0.5566651225,
0.4299378097,
0.41408059,
-0.1356482059,
0.1153587401,
-0.6934749484,
0.1372143179,
-0.0107423132,
-0.0403927639,
-0.263356775,
0.1413089186,
-0.1768567115,
0.9425423145,
0.6831588149,
0.3234900534,
-0.0676015094,
0.2275727093,
0.7266047001,
-0.2897311747,
-0.469337225,
-0.7801734209,
0.5957878232,
-0.355310142,
-0.0408127457,
0.4506024718,
0.3446673155,
1.2058769464,
0.2050408125,
0.9852529168,
-0.1574733108,
0.9530790448,
-0.2788558006,
0.4726814926,
-0.6616716385,
0.3894419074,
-0.1875187755,
-0.8637880087,
-0.2651265562,
0.4189200103,
-0.483715415,
0.3187281489,
0.6635219455,
0.6306895018,
-0.2543586791,
0.0508783646,
0.146914199,
0.2063233107,
0.5458446145,
0.4737613797,
0.6221467257,
-0.0775610581,
0.3796282411,
-0.603582859,
-0.3788982034,
-0.4311205149,
-0.7266838551,
-0.980404973,
-0.4523662627,
-0.1330908239,
-0.1952724904,
0.2139787078,
1.0729490519,
0.9466525316,
-0.9363780618,
-0.5543169379,
-0.0955572203,
0.3070274293,
-0.174446702,
-0.1564413607,
0.3323260248,
-0.9193536043,
-0.7371346354,
0.0730808005,
0.3416294456,
-0.1250427365,
-0.2820481658,
-0.0810644701,
-0.1063048467,
-0.2473624349,
0.3343731165,
0.3062699139,
-0.8643627167,
-0.6040899158,
0.0815762877,
0.1102297902,
-0.1398219019,
0.8839502931,
-0.8493604064,
0.7677434683,
0.2630476952,
0.7830172777,
0.1344473958,
-0.3196299076,
1.0272026062,
-0.8254729509,
0.142846331,
0.2092646807,
0.2568291724,
0.4879614115,
-0.3615416884,
0.6787000299,
-0.0781690031,
-0.3830398321,
-0.9449814558,
0.1588700712,
-0.3287705779,
-0.2545364797,
0.8403895497,
0.0419265181,
-0.3254240751,
-0.1420697123,
-0.4841373563,
0.623097837,
-0.1991447508,
0.8745663762,
0.8915082216,
0.0829226002,
-0.3748443425,
-0.8146951199,
0.585210979,
0.6173847914,
-0.8705723286,
0.3464588821,
0.1790561527,
0.4813267887,
0.1528556943,
0.0982479975,
-0.0081282016,
0.7857636213,
-0.227199927,
0.4122482538,
-0.1374079436,
-0.5998973846,
-0.1454783976,
-0.0381681025,
0.4269595146,
-0.1422302723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13066v2 | Biomedical Named Entity Recognition via Dictionary-based Synonym Generalization | 2023-05-22T14:36:32 | 2023-10-13T11:19:19 | Zihao Fu, Yixuan Su, Zaiqiao Meng, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Biomedical named entity recognition is one of the core tasks in biomedical
natural language processing (BioNLP). To tackle this task, numerous
supervised/distantly supervised approaches have been proposed. Despite their
remarkable success, these approaches inescapably demand laborious human effort.
To alleviate the need of human effort, dictionary-based approaches have been
proposed to extract named entities simply based on a given dictionary. However,
one downside of existing dictionary-based approaches is that they are
challenged to identify concept synonyms that are not listed in the given
dictionary, which we refer as the synonym generalization problem. In this
study, we propose a novel Synonym Generalization (SynGen) framework that
recognizes the biomedical concepts contained in the input text using span-based
predictions. In particular, SynGen introduces two regularization terms, namely,
(1) a synonym distance regularizer; and (2) a noise perturbation regularizer,
to minimize the synonym generalization error. To demonstrate the effectiveness
of our approach, we provide a theoretical analysis of the bound of synonym
generalization error. We extensively evaluate our approach on a wide range of
benchmarks and the results verify that SynGen outperforms previous
dictionary-based models by notable margins. Lastly, we provide a detailed
analysis to further reveal the merits and inner-workings of our approach. | [
-0.2771549225,
-0.5083498955,
0.6032224894,
0.0013061792,
-0.370708257,
0.0151421558,
-0.3305692971,
-0.7792878747,
0.8108406663,
-0.1098151579,
-0.5298033953,
-0.4597353637,
-0.8167098761,
0.6162725091,
-0.3450720906,
0.7220925093,
-0.0849818736,
0.281324178,
-0.3010214269,
-0.2132869661,
-0.3346965611,
-0.2384635359,
-0.4784185886,
-0.1915974021,
0.6405583024,
-0.0158398487,
0.3556191027,
0.8027327061,
0.6830335855,
0.2564869523,
-0.3782404065,
0.1006566584,
-0.1704952568,
0.1185969859,
-0.1810761243,
-0.1122817844,
-0.3568757176,
-0.0013842536,
0.839527905,
1.0198557377,
-0.0768339112,
-0.0290835444,
-0.0928847268,
0.4648737311,
-0.4291428328,
-0.0036004412,
-0.8214351535,
0.0805943534,
-0.4623502791,
0.1637183726,
0.2013235092,
0.0412340201,
0.1273111552,
-0.8297067881,
0.4197591245,
-0.0596721135,
1.2755423784,
0.273314476,
-0.0510881171,
-0.1847452521,
-0.3224272132,
0.8051170707,
-0.7707127333,
0.6921371222,
0.0491665937,
0.292059958,
-0.303832531,
-0.890919745,
-0.7717264891,
-0.0361110903,
-0.0816821083,
0.2582861781,
-0.3263267875,
0.3947780132,
0.1428963542,
0.3163886964,
-0.3082810938,
0.2066777647,
-0.4593443871,
-0.4601152539,
0.2579038441,
0.048386775,
0.167675972,
-0.224211514,
-0.6195150614,
0.1475710869,
-0.504639864,
0.0170301627,
-0.0531812087,
0.4149546325,
-0.0197287295,
0.3814852536,
-0.506119132,
0.5244172812,
-0.0249444377,
0.013439971,
0.5446255207,
-0.3422502875,
-0.1403584033,
-0.0387527272,
0.7536295056,
0.3585518897,
-0.1079330221,
-0.6497955322,
0.0281536579,
0.1962696016,
0.0224785283,
-0.7947815657,
-0.069000259,
0.3757984638,
-0.6509093046,
-0.2633780539,
0.1142934337,
-0.9820333719,
-0.2180329412,
-0.1077873111,
0.5024943948,
-0.5435916185,
-0.0074742408,
0.0273048691,
-0.4262339771,
-0.124938041,
0.26467821,
-0.7819204926,
0.3786537945,
0.5835666656,
1.0122098923,
-0.4530161321,
-0.0897767842,
-0.4275423586,
0.4084588289,
-0.001152952,
0.6945564151,
-0.4330399334,
-0.491335839,
-0.4430320859,
-0.1436410546,
-0.0398689471,
-0.6802603006,
0.3504941165,
-0.2965393662,
0.1334861368,
-0.3786423802,
-1.0597784519,
0.1490698457,
0.18596825,
-0.5728651285,
0.5351911187,
0.0094183013,
-1.1116713285,
0.5682450533,
-0.6479901671,
-0.3591857255,
0.3581688404,
-0.4269780517,
-0.2735593915,
0.1578148603,
0.0450355895,
0.5019760728,
-0.2184115946,
0.1439550817,
-0.3255984187,
-0.1305610389,
0.0792277157,
0.1111225933,
0.4282923043,
-0.0642955452,
-0.1611865014,
0.0115630329,
-0.7060160041,
-0.094278872,
-0.0201038457,
-0.1502691507,
-0.7086456418,
0.1315311193,
-0.119458504,
0.0422164313,
0.2460532337,
-1.0097289085,
0.1558147371,
-0.8531368375,
0.2464822233,
0.6331376433,
-0.0439395159,
0.3238466084,
-0.2220410705,
0.382723242,
0.1494953632,
-0.1915493011,
0.4805929959,
-0.4226690829,
-0.2638679445,
-0.6052138805,
0.8890835047,
0.4726994634,
-0.6477701068,
0.4286886156,
-0.3788520694,
-0.3946227729,
-0.4702760279,
0.1560166925,
0.2124295533,
0.8829942346,
0.8910998702,
-0.4303453565,
-0.6796585321,
-0.9237757921,
-0.3765224516,
-0.1029591933,
-0.3275425136,
0.3369152248,
0.5088629127,
-0.7486312389,
1.124270916,
-0.5600133538,
-0.5938794613,
-0.0893618166,
-0.097577244,
0.2586628795,
0.3577282429,
0.2520582974,
-0.7878577709,
-0.0282246824,
-0.2366384119,
-0.552775085,
-0.2077511549,
0.0493093766,
-0.0800238773,
-0.33278355,
0.4705159366,
-0.599250555,
0.3431092799,
0.3749099076,
-0.0303370766,
0.667765975,
-0.1015262529,
-0.3423555791,
-1.390511632,
0.2304779291,
0.1413352638,
-0.017730305,
-0.6593521237,
-0.0445481613,
-0.0640242621,
0.3831853867,
-0.1479357928,
0.9401590228,
-0.4003814459,
0.0898853838,
-0.0016476498,
0.1188121513,
-0.2548574209,
-0.1647403687,
0.306248486,
0.4661560059,
0.5297721028,
-0.5754847527,
0.4676692784,
0.3419920802,
0.0638316721,
0.5040310025,
-0.8484563231,
-0.405950278,
-0.1538759917,
0.3731949925,
-0.6232085824,
-0.2528478503,
0.1397535205,
-0.6266063452,
0.2938779294,
0.4126166999,
-0.4331321716,
-0.435148567,
-0.227796942,
0.3445613682,
0.4321452975,
-0.49743402,
0.3830370903,
0.6123329401,
0.0092221536,
-0.4447958767,
-0.6178432703,
0.1295524538,
-0.21845074,
-0.2503265738,
1.0191081762,
0.2159704864,
-0.1299032569,
0.0274235252,
-0.5063980222,
-0.2173036933,
-0.0037561955,
0.3999617696,
0.3263628781,
0.0662315711,
0.7034777999,
0.2024642229,
-0.0722951964,
-0.0086195394,
-0.2165181637,
0.2772437036,
0.0957946107,
0.2325709611,
-0.4414667785,
0.3048179746,
0.1247689202,
-0.1683867574,
0.6428174973,
0.6950637102,
-0.8899761438,
-0.202242896,
-0.5382091999,
-0.322124213,
-0.4686028361,
0.4570416808,
-0.203122139,
-0.8936086893,
0.4974534512,
-0.4762190878,
-0.2911067009,
0.6186500788,
0.4791387916,
-0.3957514465,
0.4163060188,
0.5572863221,
-0.1707173139,
0.1140078902,
-0.113675952,
0.0609176755,
-0.9413819313,
-0.1865222454,
-0.3988202214,
-0.5259000659,
-0.2833968699,
-0.3556635976,
0.4415743053,
0.1516066045,
0.2736818194,
0.5866096616,
-0.571426332,
0.2431646585,
0.4168115854,
0.1216007546,
0.1911994666,
0.0946156532,
-0.7019593716,
-0.0290429406,
-0.6102982163,
-0.2675377131,
0.8846737146,
0.3390143216,
0.290271908,
-0.0017960895,
1.2887132168,
0.0098533174,
0.2756475508,
-0.721572876,
0.6439198256,
-0.4294539988,
-0.4130268097,
-0.3072800934,
-0.7606674433,
-1.398709178,
-0.0233872682,
-0.4956322312,
-0.8917533755,
0.2536902428,
0.0396837592,
-0.3961310685,
0.4179555178,
-0.186633423,
0.8749650717,
0.0849881321,
0.104494676,
-0.249527961,
-1.0249272585,
0.1587908417,
-0.1880661547,
0.3809003532,
-0.1605164409,
-0.4059093297,
0.9053464532,
-0.5096571445,
0.4969599843,
-0.1244560629,
0.1133572534,
-0.1747656167,
-0.1902424842,
0.0211765766,
-0.0218348596,
0.0310207922,
0.6222260594,
0.393920958,
-0.2383913994,
-0.1762645096,
0.6467272043,
-0.3586149514,
-0.1121656373,
-0.2403743863,
-0.5104885101,
-0.5068826079,
0.507534802,
0.6058572531,
0.172832042,
-0.2654045224,
-0.1744594574,
0.4193915725,
-0.2983226776,
0.2846888304,
0.3053155541,
0.0220481269,
-0.4714597762,
0.9624838829,
0.0418627411,
0.0339050069,
0.5035541654,
0.1783719063,
-0.4742942154,
-0.4243663549,
-0.2543727458,
0.4983876646,
-0.3282984495,
-0.4068165421,
-0.6235974431,
0.0742175803,
-0.427008301,
0.0009304892,
-0.1387697607,
-0.3778823912,
-0.4621028006,
0.2431808114,
-0.0013415881,
0.2807080746,
-0.1722842604,
-0.0502648391,
-0.8930212259,
0.7140071988,
0.1951990426,
0.5329963565,
-0.3082059622,
-0.1378329247,
-0.0412748531,
0.0740397722,
-0.0799752399,
-1.1830462217,
0.316667825,
0.505105257,
0.5958234668,
0.3308866322,
-0.1102495715,
0.7707511783,
-0.6922008991,
0.5135733485,
0.4878339171,
-0.9137901068,
0.5990691781,
-0.0332539082,
-0.0855353847,
0.5409734845,
0.3163032532,
-0.6726141572,
-0.3522000611,
-0.8951131701,
-0.8325310946,
-0.0152216787,
0.1823118627,
-0.0124868173,
-0.4028280079,
0.5284418464,
0.0555030704,
0.3053187728,
-0.2247074842,
-0.276286155,
0.1985518038,
-0.3011256754,
0.0756571889,
0.0939645618,
0.0449772626,
-0.3413994908,
0.5556144714,
-0.0403675102,
0.4423341751,
0.5793465972,
-0.0662862733,
-0.0806822851,
0.2750036716,
0.230777353,
-0.0381190069,
-0.1075251848,
-0.0224499423,
0.3697119057,
-0.4385492802,
0.0130244764,
0.679268837,
-0.0686913207,
0.5811648369,
0.3073824346,
0.1306238174,
0.0343437009,
-0.9430919886,
0.6710568666,
0.2097798586,
-0.2219603509,
-0.0435149446,
-0.1975641251,
0.1340412498,
0.2888913453,
0.1931862831,
0.0954596251,
0.4381659925,
-0.0261253249,
0.4371131957,
0.8389683962,
-0.1832404584,
-0.1165723801,
0.9377636909,
-0.046662882,
0.1697578132,
0.3105043471,
-0.3516595364,
-0.4788557291,
0.6883847117,
0.4042320251,
0.7440499067,
-0.1143938079,
-0.0379303284,
0.3514959216,
-0.22521694,
-0.1733798087,
0.2039805204,
-0.0680132061,
-0.9026101828,
-0.3577629328,
-0.9593445063,
-0.306853652,
-0.131843403,
-0.5992678404,
0.2376167625,
-0.4735940397,
-0.5575968623,
0.5469011664,
-0.0705519915,
-0.4665121138,
0.3355166912,
0.3572764397,
0.9150959849,
-0.6688956618,
0.938049078,
0.9433136582,
-0.2395475656,
-0.7630898952,
0.1758973449,
0.0057852599,
-0.4486353993,
0.8748570681,
0.278481096,
0.11242228,
0.0252569411,
-0.1067543104,
-0.7770586014,
1.1982001066,
0.039303571,
-0.7356478572,
-0.4981718361,
-0.1535954475,
0.7257270217,
-0.050536532,
-0.28344962,
0.3956993222,
0.3731321692,
0.0929765701,
-1.2465894222,
0.2111757845,
-0.2784952819,
0.2108797282,
0.2826565206,
-0.254131496,
0.6723968983,
-0.3032295108,
-0.3630174696,
0.4661477506,
0.7591452003,
0.1613903642,
0.4137680233,
0.4411299527,
0.7671715021,
0.8016064167,
-0.079126589,
0.7840023637,
-0.2844890654,
0.572897017,
0.8293159008,
-0.1645803601,
0.7873102427,
0.7849136591,
-0.5744552612,
0.4538386762,
0.456913203,
-0.278385371,
0.354131937,
0.4623335004,
-0.3228743076,
0.0078257397,
-0.2616834641,
-0.5518049598,
0.3211418092,
0.4743339419,
-0.4993354082,
-0.3864175975,
-0.0633087009,
-0.2311943769,
0.0506361574,
-0.3880136609,
0.7685325146,
-0.0033923553,
-0.0351296738,
0.4595011175,
0.152920559,
0.9511312842,
-0.507356286,
0.0347247832,
0.1497765481,
0.1088410988,
-0.1113872826,
-0.150682196,
0.2444241941,
-0.2677747309,
-0.1239697635,
0.2306022793,
0.7476333976,
-0.7238075137,
-0.5379247665,
0.2850681245,
0.4615309238,
0.1076789945,
0.0954049677,
-0.7189269066,
-0.3064742088,
-0.4190203846,
0.2307272553,
0.2508158982,
0.0816353336,
0.1675567031,
0.4517232478,
0.3675161898,
0.8584145308,
-0.092047818,
-0.2469340116,
0.7408864498,
-0.4732127786,
-0.4704488814,
-0.8287023306,
0.0432334505,
-0.2060265392,
-0.259868443,
0.4894865453,
0.5398977399,
0.7574259639,
-0.0231735129,
0.6604873538,
-0.1776534915,
0.9771333337,
-0.3709473312,
0.5394358635,
-0.7709691525,
0.2158170491,
-0.6720110178,
-0.6731870174,
-0.7885055542,
0.5353140831,
-0.1862950623,
-0.0051499805,
0.6156925559,
0.6807058454,
0.0342867859,
-0.1490969062,
0.1309907585,
0.2210542411,
0.1346376985,
0.7187779546,
0.3061468601,
-0.2784352303,
0.027464008,
-0.4698490798,
-0.1602450907,
-0.1184112951,
-0.8893250227,
-0.6422811747,
-0.544578135,
-0.3469711244,
-0.4606853127,
0.2608439922,
1.1475895643,
0.5336979032,
-0.9515712261,
0.2217410952,
-0.3064939082,
-0.0198477805,
-0.5153256655,
-0.179017365,
0.583468616,
-0.4789367914,
-0.5521665812,
0.4086596966,
0.2173131555,
0.1421471387,
0.2046760172,
0.0992178023,
-0.0835033953,
-0.0009292086,
0.2066094279,
0.4646598697,
-0.8938058615,
-0.1937134713,
-0.2357102782,
-0.2322402149,
-0.143590495,
0.4202963412,
-1.0598829985,
0.5677629113,
0.2638859451,
0.8952718377,
-0.0224375632,
0.2078882903,
0.3229924738,
-0.842248559,
0.022728689,
0.3376399279,
0.4615901113,
0.151014477,
-0.2300033867,
0.4588750601,
0.8859336376,
-0.1643465608,
-0.7055355906,
0.2408189327,
-1.0838131905,
-0.4471899569,
1.1836669445,
0.1572629511,
0.0643904135,
0.1681251228,
0.0444554575,
0.5210159421,
-0.2286003828,
0.9503638744,
0.3959731758,
-0.1768939495,
0.2436830252,
-0.3787722886,
0.639686048,
0.5149164796,
-0.6884980798,
-0.2776757479,
0.4063369334,
0.4859608412,
0.1377512664,
0.3698439598,
-0.1431818455,
0.3142611086,
-0.2726942003,
0.1656685621,
-0.0290279835,
0.008968723,
-0.3864415586,
0.0641836002,
-0.3103852868,
-0.2923199534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13062v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13062v4 | Table Meets LLM: Can Large Language Models Understand Structured Table Data? A Benchmark and Empirical Study | 2023-05-22T14:23:46 | 2024-02-17T08:28:05 | Yuan Sui, Mengyu Zhou, Mingjie Zhou, Shi Han, Dongmei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) are becoming attractive as few-shot reasoners to
solve Natural Language (NL)-related tasks. However, there is still much to
learn about how well LLMs understand structured data, such as tables. Although
tables can be used as input to LLMs with serialization, there is a lack of
comprehensive studies that examine whether LLMs can truly comprehend such data.
In this paper, we try to understand this by designing a benchmark to evaluate
the structural understanding capabilities (SUC) of LLMs. The benchmark we
create includes seven tasks, each with its own unique challenges, e.g., cell
lookup, row retrieval, and size detection. We perform a series of evaluations
on GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. We find that performance varied depending on several
input choices, including table input format, content order, role prompting, and
partition marks. Drawing from the insights gained through the benchmark
evaluations, we propose \textit{self-augmentation} for effective structural
prompting, such as critical value / range identification using internal
knowledge of LLMs. When combined with carefully chosen input choices, these
structural prompting methods lead to promising improvements in LLM performance
on a variety of tabular tasks, e.g., TabFact($\uparrow2.31\%$),
HybridQA($\uparrow2.13\%$), SQA($\uparrow2.72\%$), Feverous($\uparrow0.84\%$),
and ToTTo($\uparrow5.68\%$). We believe that our open source benchmark and
proposed prompting methods can serve as a simple yet generic selection for
future research. | [
-0.2487543672,
-0.9139065742,
0.8983058929,
0.3522086442,
-0.40965119,
0.0825610608,
-0.1839250922,
-0.4370025098,
-0.1743873507,
0.2622909844,
-0.54007864,
-0.7873951197,
-0.240228191,
0.3252709806,
-0.3853664398,
0.9277333021,
-0.2348564565,
0.1504358798,
-0.3736907244,
-0.0268158577,
-0.6385425329,
-0.4831971526,
-0.2237942815,
-0.2572138309,
0.540342927,
0.4623902738,
0.4377194345,
1.0005624294,
0.3731563687,
0.3230521977,
-0.3268399239,
0.1360805631,
-0.4237263501,
0.2316679507,
-0.0806265771,
-0.489703089,
-0.5994272232,
-0.2453095764,
0.8021330833,
0.8218607306,
-0.094116427,
0.3092573583,
0.3927202523,
0.8130770922,
-0.2720475197,
0.4910378158,
-0.7032638788,
0.2851039171,
-0.3142687976,
-0.1739802659,
-0.4482755959,
-0.1846080124,
-0.2325558811,
-0.5537893176,
0.1708383709,
0.1529419869,
0.393165797,
0.3763225675,
-0.5202739239,
-0.238324061,
-0.5533064604,
0.3041086793,
-0.6049787402,
0.7454612255,
0.2739199698,
0.1917648911,
-0.5114642978,
-0.6535400152,
-0.525908649,
-0.5607261658,
-0.2235720158,
0.107114546,
-0.1170443594,
0.1416003853,
0.575137496,
0.5900838971,
-0.9959359169,
0.2572068274,
-0.3606228232,
0.0286197886,
0.3843068182,
0.2378737479,
0.2674275637,
-0.2483997196,
-0.3117561042,
-0.0112838382,
-0.7684828639,
0.1254553199,
0.1209068373,
0.3209854364,
-0.1542747915,
0.6488178372,
-0.4017234147,
0.8295753002,
-0.0355214104,
0.2332727164,
0.2215552628,
-0.5374340415,
-0.3197707236,
-0.1183775589,
0.6963867545,
0.0509547591,
0.3676616549,
-0.2724111378,
-0.2532151639,
-0.0700232759,
0.2970308363,
-0.5776807666,
-0.2186585069,
0.0615696348,
-0.3333020508,
0.0574857704,
-0.2171586603,
-0.629217267,
-0.4225508273,
-0.3073338866,
0.4748239219,
-0.3685194254,
0.0734263361,
-0.1520129591,
0.0838624611,
0.3966386914,
0.1996688098,
-1.0008858442,
0.2917612493,
0.7706879377,
0.9472094178,
-0.4643001258,
-0.1242906526,
-0.6106426716,
0.1477550715,
-0.3592463434,
0.9961732626,
-0.3203355968,
-0.5441077352,
-0.1838213205,
-0.2006390095,
-0.0867309198,
-0.6839087605,
0.5634812713,
-0.3599792719,
-0.101086393,
-0.4907051027,
-0.4702532589,
0.1183856875,
0.4526835382,
-0.6319903731,
1.1855942011,
0.0940511003,
-0.4278963208,
0.6509951949,
-0.6970689893,
-0.4365472794,
0.284078896,
-0.424634397,
-0.3509637713,
0.3096216023,
0.476416558,
0.5204104185,
-0.1263183504,
0.4224944711,
-0.5135490298,
-0.3193439245,
0.3191861212,
-0.3545006216,
0.1228655279,
0.0812137648,
-0.237318188,
0.4996650815,
-0.8350772262,
0.0832163543,
0.0311510805,
-0.4342289865,
0.0145043433,
0.0645374283,
-0.2596831918,
0.0568299443,
0.0418490767,
-0.3197565377,
0.3171145618,
-0.4514915347,
0.3951226771,
0.7836636901,
0.0079949396,
0.3698953986,
-0.1686200798,
0.4625144601,
-0.0708946437,
-0.0970373899,
-0.1164541021,
-0.1081402153,
-0.582523644,
-0.1306239069,
0.2653788626,
0.3402636945,
-0.6121602654,
0.224222362,
-0.2535530031,
-0.3354755342,
-0.1791493446,
0.3677485287,
0.3729166985,
0.7149527669,
0.6911548376,
-0.0660590082,
-0.536038518,
-1.0479152203,
-0.4182548821,
-0.222591877,
-0.2856903076,
0.2328362763,
0.4677948356,
0.1115842834,
0.808324635,
-0.2895762324,
-0.2233918309,
-0.571936667,
0.1252499521,
0.4453050792,
0.3749862909,
0.1016800404,
-0.4622409642,
-0.5283463597,
0.0212375075,
-0.891661644,
-0.2196808308,
-0.0927880332,
0.1799213588,
0.0763652325,
0.7182712555,
-0.5406326056,
0.4939170778,
0.3044074774,
-0.2032818645,
0.6093280911,
-0.1949094832,
-0.0731064975,
-0.9643730521,
0.0654330626,
0.0277670529,
-0.1613797694,
-0.7311994433,
-0.0364494994,
0.3274232447,
-0.031109266,
-0.2821669579,
0.4828022122,
-0.9225693345,
-0.5060081482,
-0.0862724707,
0.1536337882,
-0.1710629612,
0.5194510818,
-0.087582618,
1.0736629963,
0.2593595982,
-0.5225530267,
0.0157011524,
0.359149605,
-0.4918318987,
0.5912776589,
-0.9888119698,
0.2326746732,
-0.1068802625,
0.3702596724,
-1.1623330116,
-0.2312934399,
0.2131917477,
-0.3733351827,
0.3275620341,
-0.2600931525,
-0.4850145876,
-0.3928785324,
-0.1974542141,
0.2319543511,
0.198093012,
-0.6427512765,
0.7653556466,
0.1882018596,
-0.1835125387,
-0.6628671885,
-0.6090280414,
0.1894514114,
-0.2206150293,
-0.639946878,
0.4008868337,
-0.302382946,
-0.1981044263,
-0.1559829712,
-0.5927608013,
0.0056469068,
0.0860543326,
0.4450890124,
0.3321818411,
-0.333216399,
0.2697505057,
0.0280614886,
-0.065395318,
0.2603341341,
-0.0689333081,
0.7118291259,
-0.4729475379,
-0.2929618061,
-0.3900885582,
0.0585106164,
0.3524878919,
-0.2727083862,
0.6098749042,
0.4154221416,
-0.1944283694,
-0.3392707705,
-0.6850908399,
-0.2576845288,
-0.545093596,
0.4543007314,
-0.6975206137,
-0.9020751119,
0.7535843849,
0.1478266716,
0.0528906174,
0.4534625411,
0.6760066748,
-0.2642386854,
0.7850778699,
0.2989939451,
-0.0358781479,
0.3179062605,
-0.1645272076,
-0.045635175,
-0.9368662834,
-0.3440259397,
-0.611894846,
-0.410502702,
-0.2666981518,
-0.3719372451,
0.5896606445,
0.0137311202,
0.0527424812,
0.3081253469,
-0.2867908776,
0.5770952702,
0.275300771,
0.0838315338,
0.4740328491,
-0.1324045658,
-0.2125581354,
0.1524298638,
-0.6589383483,
-0.329744488,
0.8115677834,
0.4888862669,
0.850605011,
-0.0681384131,
0.7467080951,
0.2350209206,
0.4823903441,
-0.8654028177,
0.8013032675,
0.1652169973,
-0.4619241655,
-0.412743181,
-0.7157436013,
-1.081494689,
0.3354314268,
-0.1235267669,
-0.7547576427,
0.1518962383,
0.347057879,
-0.2743454278,
0.0155784162,
-0.6275644302,
1.1042481661,
-0.253403753,
-0.3732278645,
-0.133456558,
-0.4884703755,
0.2711904049,
0.098185882,
0.2275905311,
-0.1440436393,
0.0237734839,
0.6768332124,
-0.2681674063,
0.7518926263,
-0.1320976168,
-0.1041572094,
0.0256914478,
0.2417786419,
0.6255342364,
0.1888887435,
-0.2024160773,
0.0707477182,
0.004805583,
-0.0813635439,
-0.8085120916,
0.5523497462,
-0.4756788313,
-0.7048912644,
-0.2657211125,
-0.7375844121,
-0.5041803122,
0.0555018261,
0.0436508581,
0.5363476276,
-0.1535918713,
0.5672262311,
0.5390765667,
0.0393724442,
0.4770047963,
0.6985803843,
0.0496216603,
-0.2434052974,
0.5817678571,
0.2890869081,
0.0705381036,
0.3695445359,
0.3157164156,
-0.7011755705,
-1.0403647423,
-0.6803253293,
0.181581229,
-0.6682315469,
-0.3418223858,
-0.6631717682,
-0.1130302027,
-0.2888170779,
0.1044602916,
-0.0009497547,
-0.2477671951,
-0.3230898678,
-0.4681043029,
0.1271387041,
0.7982096672,
0.0741223618,
0.2279741913,
-0.8565045595,
0.3020099699,
0.208263889,
0.5476600528,
-0.0180537459,
-0.6722281575,
-0.0416313633,
-0.3166002333,
-0.0125594772,
-1.1442307234,
0.2541930377,
0.0682376847,
0.9100925326,
0.0231490228,
-0.0706130341,
0.8082376719,
-0.4886721671,
0.5319340825,
-0.244213596,
-1.0255129337,
0.4566414952,
-0.4176330268,
0.415145129,
0.7950252295,
0.3781471252,
-0.4660715461,
-0.2143685818,
-0.2441967428,
-0.7048412561,
0.6572630405,
0.0165288243,
-0.0878318176,
0.0619521849,
0.4997119308,
0.0586579219,
0.1046977714,
-1.1679934263,
0.1280350983,
0.1029703766,
-0.2230101675,
0.039646823,
-0.3522745371,
0.1245593131,
-0.1257065833,
0.364356339,
-0.2588359118,
-0.0568936057,
0.262190491,
-0.4605552852,
-0.0501525998,
0.6094271541,
0.5473780036,
0.8073914647,
-0.1461153179,
0.2835846841,
0.5957776904,
-0.2396414727,
-0.0434006974,
0.1229771376,
0.0152167222,
-0.3164045811,
0.4471108019,
0.7386693358,
0.2681119442,
-0.4794977605,
0.1232029274,
-0.0236954093,
-0.2874922454,
-0.0411679,
0.1626096666,
-0.0345779061,
0.3270378113,
0.4457991421,
-0.6210044622,
0.307030499,
-0.7633661628,
0.2917316258,
0.6388961673,
-0.3785343468,
-0.3241433501,
0.5825551748,
-0.0712002441,
-0.3681150079,
0.5368396044,
-0.1783610135,
-0.5509501696,
0.3907504976,
0.7165032625,
0.6277194023,
-0.234544754,
0.1227375343,
0.3861835301,
0.3997939229,
0.0477267839,
0.3781193495,
-0.4362268448,
-0.5626747608,
-0.5555969477,
-0.6911646128,
-0.460772723,
0.3210112154,
-0.5158766508,
-0.1352414042,
-0.3731515706,
0.1137983501,
0.0829699785,
-0.0140080852,
-0.5297009945,
-0.0490961596,
-0.0362248383,
0.9149528742,
-0.7019734979,
0.7195993662,
0.502178371,
-0.2400429249,
-1.0192604065,
-0.12779966,
0.0634163842,
-0.9372521043,
0.6701691151,
0.246429652,
0.064103432,
-0.1281553805,
-0.32002002,
-0.7486314774,
0.7838792801,
0.174830392,
-0.6108089089,
-0.1226583645,
0.3828439415,
0.6559769511,
-0.1656064093,
0.2881385684,
0.7340471148,
0.8075734973,
0.137816444,
-0.8719171882,
0.2801735997,
-0.3426899314,
-0.2152489722,
0.3202652931,
-0.2599841952,
0.6272935271,
-0.0962043628,
-0.3225337267,
-0.1254496276,
0.8974248767,
0.3012419343,
0.5081023574,
0.6777666211,
0.388376534,
0.5358077884,
-0.1606387645,
0.7987647653,
-0.2352647483,
-0.0630486608,
1.3393422365,
-0.3501759768,
0.8897717595,
0.3695212901,
-0.2982093096,
0.4502164721,
0.6060572267,
-0.2047185153,
-0.0044138734,
0.4358042181,
-0.0220929552,
-0.0980569199,
0.0309060533,
-0.4886622429,
0.4762913287,
0.4962034225,
-0.1735212654,
-0.3619997501,
-0.2457159907,
-0.232879892,
0.054319825,
-0.2431663275,
0.9999027252,
0.1012369543,
-0.628804028,
0.4723219573,
-0.281219095,
0.1745656133,
-0.6638911963,
0.0304148477,
-0.4101086259,
-0.0397169888,
-0.2693543732,
-0.9945716262,
0.4044107497,
-0.0418684818,
-0.0173933245,
-0.3060591817,
0.6182629466,
-0.5124567747,
-0.1960803121,
0.050749775,
0.6240478754,
0.1019284055,
-0.2842287719,
-0.5100429654,
0.3311055005,
-0.20305942,
-0.2603201568,
0.3524935246,
0.2665832639,
-0.1281871796,
0.6903375983,
0.7472695708,
-0.064612478,
-0.1242494285,
0.1962593049,
0.9537126422,
-0.6742761135,
-0.4840752184,
-1.1057456732,
0.3590480387,
-0.0968175307,
-0.2064414322,
0.8987352848,
0.7612640262,
0.6174231172,
-0.1184060946,
0.2142360955,
0.3091426194,
0.3053238094,
-0.7685300112,
0.561992228,
-0.5277814269,
0.3023121357,
-0.1836644113,
-1.1227362156,
-0.2621350586,
0.4777292311,
-0.5541734099,
0.0576188155,
0.6128757,
0.8538764715,
0.0022557441,
0.0514718629,
0.3048505783,
0.4203981459,
0.3743215203,
0.3691654503,
1.0856536627,
0.1341819018,
0.6816236377,
0.1466261744,
-0.1656634808,
-0.1144273207,
-0.7875230908,
-1.0388333797,
-0.5090352893,
0.1041515991,
-0.1958658695,
0.0716513097,
0.9156525135,
0.6204907298,
-0.5656222701,
-0.3681486845,
-0.2238018364,
0.198041752,
0.0551682599,
-0.182669878,
0.3243434429,
-0.4268299043,
-0.3167216182,
1.0608291626,
0.4592285454,
0.0878871009,
-0.1987318695,
0.2310773283,
0.0893205628,
-0.1052412912,
0.576685667,
0.4130285382,
-0.6227160096,
-0.2143675834,
0.1827409416,
0.1490591913,
0.3742660284,
0.951158464,
-0.8221206069,
0.1840468347,
0.5490509868,
0.7192295194,
0.8544251919,
0.1877806634,
0.5469889045,
-0.7577143312,
-0.2563672364,
0.2084007412,
0.4638169706,
0.1997563988,
-0.4415886998,
0.6912164092,
-0.0107586626,
-0.6346233487,
-0.9754468799,
0.2574073374,
-1.1612015963,
-0.0884439498,
0.8889394999,
0.1213388443,
-0.3130467236,
-0.225983724,
-0.1037402898,
0.120263882,
-0.3924258351,
0.7944083214,
0.4054997861,
-0.2309572995,
-0.2645089328,
-0.4602445066,
0.5107267499,
0.6463264227,
-1.2360460758,
0.346157074,
0.6241261363,
0.1536991447,
-0.1320711374,
0.5864043832,
-0.0964967608,
0.2241702676,
-0.2792004347,
-0.2041708529,
-0.400831759,
-0.5196095109,
-0.4425569177,
0.2895543575,
-0.038175635,
0.2046200931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13058v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13058v1 | Retrieval-augmented Multi-label Text Classification | 2023-05-22T14:16:23 | 2023-05-22T14:16:23 | Ilias Chalkidis, Yova Kementchedjhieva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-label text classification (MLC) is a challenging task in settings of
large label sets, where label support follows a Zipfian distribution. In this
paper, we address this problem through retrieval augmentation, aiming to
improve the sample efficiency of classification models. Our approach closely
follows the standard MLC architecture of a Transformer-based encoder paired
with a set of classification heads. In our case, however, the input document
representation is augmented through cross-attention to similar documents
retrieved from the training set and represented in a task-specific manner. We
evaluate this approach on four datasets from the legal and biomedical domains,
all of which feature highly skewed label distributions. Our experiments show
that retrieval augmentation substantially improves model performance on the
long tail of infrequent labels especially so for lower-resource training
scenarios and more challenging long-document data scenarios. | [
-0.2353981882,
-0.0837674811,
0.3768548965,
-0.0735483691,
-0.0825711414,
0.2744357586,
-0.0998777971,
-0.7098945975,
0.3631902337,
0.6145206094,
-0.2851446569,
-0.3536726236,
-0.836853981,
0.3330931365,
-0.4496263862,
1.2839378119,
0.187362209,
-0.0227602459,
-0.3493215144,
-0.6024402976,
-0.1010876819,
-0.9428858757,
-0.2200510353,
-0.4270401895,
0.892219007,
-0.0356517881,
0.4750577807,
0.4394752085,
0.7393836379,
0.252933681,
-0.2808367312,
0.360081315,
-0.4320799708,
0.1872887313,
-0.1109008566,
-0.4757692516,
-0.2795808911,
0.1139478683,
0.6166731715,
0.6473445892,
0.1283996254,
0.0381761678,
0.2382730544,
0.5184137225,
-1.0614720583,
-0.1572847664,
-0.34302935,
0.1036308706,
-0.1359155178,
-0.4284425974,
-0.7257313132,
-0.1242328435,
0.1084434539,
-0.5782791376,
0.5236168504,
0.0948711559,
0.6472737789,
0.3708053529,
-0.5139253139,
-0.458928436,
-0.537630558,
0.5680561066,
-0.1781678796,
0.7826422453,
0.5163155794,
0.253678292,
0.0900889114,
-1.0413843393,
-0.2740611136,
-0.1793379933,
-0.357462585,
0.2208425403,
0.1239082739,
0.064197056,
0.5151004791,
0.3270879686,
-0.2842009962,
0.0496480502,
-0.4538511038,
-0.2739217579,
0.4086611569,
-0.0964424908,
-0.0022059239,
0.061076507,
-0.1288226098,
-0.3298175931,
-0.4710865915,
0.0019638324,
0.3397962451,
0.3173002005,
0.5286081433,
0.8567604423,
-0.0327153616,
0.8366997838,
0.2246203721,
-0.1266019493,
0.8316254616,
-0.471802026,
-0.1391213387,
0.3436127901,
0.4241654277,
-0.0027440742,
-0.3724777997,
-0.158388555,
-0.2652696669,
-0.4542871714,
0.6461994052,
-0.7962361574,
-0.2240585685,
0.1353539973,
-0.4889772236,
-0.2008572221,
0.261435926,
-0.4889764488,
-0.6289281845,
-0.375667125,
0.4890702963,
-0.2821208835,
0.4219064116,
-0.0688548312,
-0.4515869021,
0.0412148461,
0.3645763695,
-0.7402309179,
-0.1968130022,
0.4828997254,
0.710554719,
-0.1448186338,
0.0734039843,
-0.706970036,
0.3648553193,
-0.0258776788,
0.7850882411,
-0.9839702249,
-0.4049265683,
-0.0554816239,
0.1990686953,
0.1268835366,
-0.5677731037,
0.74781847,
-0.5607477427,
0.1592279375,
-0.0495407619,
-0.4458845556,
0.0025845277,
0.542617619,
-0.9821599126,
1.3134257793,
0.1699372977,
-1.0334576368,
0.4822318554,
-0.4773033261,
-0.5836699605,
0.2560168207,
-0.0639121085,
-0.5501186848,
-0.2038125247,
0.4965198636,
0.5531251431,
-0.0043056575,
0.0298945475,
-0.3315646052,
-0.3622897565,
0.2210988849,
-0.4872398674,
0.6707922816,
0.086603187,
-0.0698188841,
-0.0510697328,
-0.9736046791,
-0.0271977242,
-0.4688361287,
-0.7283912301,
-0.840688765,
-0.3266794086,
0.1114515141,
0.181467846,
0.1992996782,
-0.5952898264,
0.4248321652,
-0.3343468606,
0.0138075035,
0.3746792376,
-0.0196773,
0.592102468,
-0.1320110857,
0.1066052914,
0.0370770246,
0.0560713001,
-0.3738295734,
-0.4802742898,
-0.622074604,
-0.5798030496,
0.6057328582,
0.5040781498,
-1.0668845177,
0.5301728249,
-0.4308584034,
-0.4077129662,
-0.9766580462,
0.0111351945,
0.3119123876,
0.3749776781,
0.7714214325,
-0.1120695546,
-0.4302939177,
-0.9258393645,
-0.2409780025,
0.3254511952,
-0.3758197725,
0.4413995743,
0.424169451,
-0.5034948587,
0.5824759007,
-0.5185965896,
-0.3999513388,
-0.0522176325,
0.3794954121,
0.2181246281,
0.3448999822,
0.4892934561,
-1.0519486666,
-0.477694869,
0.292701602,
-0.4494535029,
0.0137073481,
-0.0735480562,
-0.0877689198,
0.0741061345,
0.3868191838,
-0.3560039401,
0.5818250775,
0.0752084181,
-0.0012155427,
0.4241224527,
-0.5719231963,
0.485339731,
-0.7865920067,
0.0595268048,
0.1235245317,
-0.2303062975,
-0.7131074667,
0.0409398191,
0.5716763735,
0.0775807053,
-0.3076690137,
0.2949759662,
-0.4504069388,
0.0251029823,
-0.4389672577,
-0.1048444733,
0.3379534781,
0.3020175993,
0.0589487478,
0.7739484906,
0.4192158878,
-0.7003206015,
0.3375044167,
0.1725216657,
-0.0818691626,
0.8138524294,
-0.2471827865,
0.245456636,
-0.6130685806,
0.5928349495,
-0.6712963581,
-0.1756371111,
0.25037691,
-0.3446276188,
0.5827019215,
0.0028984873,
-0.6415355206,
-0.5344434381,
-0.3312114775,
0.3889766634,
0.1440604329,
-1.0655115843,
0.8595396876,
0.3752202988,
0.2084122151,
-0.9327040315,
-0.8491513729,
-0.0489573777,
0.0532267466,
-0.0189259797,
0.5454452634,
0.0228256248,
0.2442421019,
-0.0917738378,
-0.0568784699,
-0.1052650884,
-0.3581745028,
0.1814225614,
0.0872220173,
0.1536851227,
0.6278415918,
0.1533484161,
0.1153642163,
-0.3093543053,
-0.4648332298,
0.0862366334,
0.3967773914,
-0.2896297276,
0.0773053169,
0.4603055716,
0.258028388,
-0.3899102807,
0.7557877302,
0.7763208747,
-0.4181391299,
0.010151349,
-0.7429240942,
-0.1162556112,
-0.4386554956,
0.3269506395,
-0.6049173474,
-0.873906374,
0.2875402272,
0.0879293308,
-0.001522589,
0.4269424975,
0.5322455764,
-0.3285108507,
0.7316365242,
0.5060968399,
-0.0955161676,
0.4113510847,
-0.1371693313,
0.1414014697,
-0.9291853309,
-0.6791430116,
-0.8433882594,
-0.2865011692,
-0.4939060509,
-0.76235497,
0.4829421937,
-0.1959900856,
0.0291608106,
0.4867979288,
-0.9460024238,
0.4207372069,
0.7023227811,
0.6926807761,
0.3455904424,
0.1344655752,
-0.0923182815,
0.0515680313,
-0.6623470783,
-0.1307273507,
1.2281776667,
0.2393662483,
0.6608512402,
-0.0742858201,
0.7887155414,
0.2894434333,
0.6223183274,
-0.5525342226,
0.0764798447,
-0.3661807477,
-0.652530849,
-0.130218789,
-0.4690259397,
-1.0257649422,
0.5300327539,
-0.5068558455,
-0.6654799581,
0.6776659489,
-0.0820847899,
-0.2279299349,
0.1450002789,
-0.5680629015,
0.5036579967,
-0.2543567717,
-0.0870446637,
-0.0793751925,
-0.7476235032,
0.2605572343,
-0.268486917,
-0.0277411658,
0.2212584317,
-0.1783638597,
0.6802065372,
-0.2610059381,
0.4621657431,
0.0871265978,
-0.0312284119,
0.3580466807,
-0.674749136,
0.578178823,
-0.1994292438,
-0.2484356761,
-0.3146381676,
-0.0337085687,
-0.3611765802,
-0.9673552513,
0.4920634329,
-0.4461065531,
-0.2209892273,
-0.4299536347,
-0.6881024837,
-0.2917118669,
0.0849251822,
0.2500013113,
0.4710844457,
0.1144135743,
0.4599749148,
0.8419108987,
-0.1402161866,
0.1710497439,
0.2522361279,
0.1168908775,
-0.4944432676,
0.9234341383,
0.3465433121,
0.0092684003,
0.6845050454,
-0.1483824551,
-0.6417616606,
-0.3077776134,
-0.2143755257,
0.0483206101,
-0.9624921083,
-0.4831431806,
-1.0422950983,
-0.2761972249,
-0.6928045154,
0.2886459231,
0.0125378007,
-0.4515516162,
-0.5674875975,
-0.2334501594,
0.4013181329,
0.4847127497,
0.1180465668,
0.3454144597,
-1.0644458532,
0.5408997536,
0.0301263407,
0.3484318852,
-0.1130097806,
-0.6771739125,
-0.4443758428,
-0.1149640158,
-0.1954364628,
-0.9986565709,
0.2019230425,
0.20287323,
0.736627996,
0.088744998,
0.2219077647,
0.6549454331,
-0.5644236207,
0.3034330606,
0.217831105,
-0.3820666969,
0.3720899224,
0.1766206771,
0.2751155198,
0.6625636816,
0.7115826011,
-0.2025084496,
-0.4635086954,
-0.5524827838,
-0.9718753099,
0.6056311727,
0.2405825704,
0.0387800112,
0.2556133568,
0.4582493305,
0.11618644,
0.1169106364,
-0.5680590868,
-0.3532916307,
-0.2249821275,
-0.4674622118,
-0.0419944823,
-0.2394756973,
-0.1329670995,
-0.3645824194,
0.8251428008,
-0.2266055644,
0.1717715561,
0.3958643973,
-0.2854862213,
0.4814454615,
0.3529877365,
0.3291707933,
0.0810771137,
-0.2560707629,
0.3222815394,
0.1529910713,
-0.7154763341,
0.3202441633,
0.5585086346,
-0.2146334648,
0.172914803,
0.1791728437,
0.8450741172,
0.1356776804,
-0.5345160365,
0.2047134042,
0.1296876222,
-0.2094811946,
0.3017729819,
-0.0960187837,
-0.1694399565,
0.2847215831,
0.8645578623,
0.0494146347,
0.7352267504,
-0.321575284,
0.5099967718,
0.3699846864,
-0.5069787502,
0.3278444111,
0.3305259645,
-0.0106883328,
-0.1726370603,
0.5276497602,
-0.2111113518,
-0.4865666926,
0.4220846891,
0.3763152361,
0.4781880379,
-0.0185386073,
0.149110049,
0.4679464102,
0.3380815089,
-0.3009414673,
-0.2856230736,
-0.2948533297,
-0.4728051424,
-0.4130660892,
-0.4466477931,
-0.3274707198,
-0.1581341028,
-0.6721811295,
0.0634614676,
0.0741208941,
-0.417104274,
0.0919444039,
-0.1199485362,
-0.5624313951,
0.3508421779,
0.0381850004,
0.7170749307,
-0.4439698756,
0.8693412542,
0.5754522085,
-0.3478042483,
-0.4863752723,
-0.1919773668,
-0.3729355633,
-0.2222417891,
0.6703563333,
0.4475796819,
0.0350868851,
-0.0293431189,
-0.3800248802,
-0.7462537885,
0.9035899639,
-0.0308097433,
-0.720420301,
-0.0856823698,
0.2132825106,
0.7654756308,
-0.2290711403,
0.6326474547,
0.7216605544,
0.5118983388,
0.1887647659,
-0.8878344297,
-0.1093425229,
-0.2624910772,
-0.098522678,
0.140185684,
-0.1027166769,
0.3625811934,
-0.1144536287,
-0.1049008518,
-0.2423924059,
0.8367148042,
0.3739778996,
0.4629986882,
0.3152174652,
0.6316956282,
1.0678532124,
-0.1258277446,
1.274191618,
-0.0244305935,
0.4716747999,
1.1118906736,
-0.1490397751,
0.7373681068,
0.5716130137,
-0.2863295972,
0.1780543625,
0.6463167071,
-0.1861885935,
0.4306406975,
0.0630208254,
-0.349737674,
-0.0566168875,
-0.2860184014,
-0.3016408682,
-0.0474416092,
0.467815429,
-0.5348203778,
-0.1653689295,
0.6746230125,
-0.6882100701,
-0.125265345,
-0.5354719758,
0.7656558156,
-0.0319537781,
-0.4009083509,
0.3839275837,
0.0140827177,
0.9159182906,
-0.1818640083,
-0.1068613976,
0.1785412878,
0.2738840282,
-0.3172708154,
-0.9723887444,
0.1145624444,
-0.1896688193,
-0.4360976517,
-0.1058566645,
1.0152106285,
-0.8193105459,
-0.7791494131,
0.2735454738,
0.1310040653,
0.2456208616,
-0.2162327021,
-0.6965813041,
-0.0715112165,
-0.1142785549,
-0.1385911256,
0.4434010684,
0.4416648746,
-0.0553477854,
0.6235952377,
0.6239668727,
-0.2111304104,
0.363415122,
0.2650773227,
0.8841927052,
-0.4414934516,
-0.4337008893,
-0.3951701224,
0.3203304708,
-0.2834450901,
0.0811844394,
0.4839026928,
0.8242642879,
0.6578397751,
-0.2785687447,
0.7167460322,
-0.0211590715,
0.6287173033,
-0.3800834715,
0.6194307804,
-0.5964079499,
0.0432880037,
-0.0124903182,
-0.8999479413,
-0.5494837165,
0.5116349459,
-0.1139814854,
0.0483650155,
0.577147305,
0.7162623405,
-0.1346071661,
-0.1936744303,
0.2648615241,
-0.3151113689,
0.1871339828,
0.423948735,
0.5587911606,
-0.652723074,
0.8009951711,
-0.4090191424,
-0.035564132,
-0.2702747881,
-0.4773264825,
-0.927918613,
-0.6225454807,
-0.1957417279,
-0.5571294427,
0.2829504609,
0.7690094709,
0.5871744156,
-0.7585881948,
0.3893378079,
0.5803554058,
0.0637018085,
-0.1284083873,
-0.2588530779,
0.5506587625,
-0.4884693027,
-0.8938291669,
0.1492387056,
0.2672879696,
0.2179520875,
-0.0728592053,
-0.0118490914,
-0.4453301728,
-0.2705486417,
0.8231176138,
0.1856465042,
-0.4558363259,
-0.1689139158,
0.011118127,
-0.5543467402,
0.397962898,
1.030151248,
-1.030615449,
0.5549461842,
0.5986568332,
1.1620978117,
0.7451602221,
0.2710478008,
0.130837515,
-0.9972476959,
0.2426474541,
0.4122986197,
0.1609719694,
0.3424524367,
-0.6173502207,
0.4850456715,
0.158612445,
-0.3722298741,
-0.8149921894,
-0.1869372278,
-0.8688710332,
-0.2419007421,
0.8307936788,
-0.110563837,
-0.3716217875,
-0.3107676208,
-0.3920330703,
0.3272827864,
-0.3491642177,
0.4035438597,
0.6930351853,
-0.0471537746,
-0.3820059001,
-0.3653116822,
0.198019892,
0.1836403161,
-0.8619801402,
-0.1208681539,
0.4744616151,
-0.0273631494,
0.6399621964,
0.5140476227,
-0.0072387708,
0.1068441793,
-0.1842897683,
0.1773821712,
0.0151527785,
-0.4785307348,
-0.2379649132,
0.4209939241,
-0.4514611065,
-0.0835841522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13052v1 | Federated Learning of Medical Concepts Embedding using BEHRT | 2023-05-22T14:05:39 | 2023-05-22T14:05:39 | Ofir Ben Shoham, Nadav Rappoport | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DC | Electronic Health Records (EHR) data contains medical records such as
diagnoses, medications, procedures, and treatments of patients. This data is
often considered sensitive medical information. Therefore, the EHR data from
the medical centers often cannot be shared, making it difficult to create
prediction models using multi-center EHR data, which is essential for such
models' robustness and generalizability. Federated Learning (FL) is an
algorithmic approach that allows learning a shared model using data in multiple
locations without the need to store all data in a central place. An example of
a prediction model's task is to predict future diseases. More specifically, the
model needs to predict patient's next visit diagnoses, based on current and
previous clinical data. Such a prediction model can support care providers in
making clinical decisions and even provide preventive treatment. We propose a
federated learning approach for learning medical concepts embedding. This
pre-trained model can be used for fine-tuning for specific downstream tasks.
Our approach is based on an embedding model like BEHRT, a deep neural sequence
transduction model for EHR. We train using federated learning, both the Masked
Language Modeling (MLM) and the next visit downstream model. We demonstrate our
approach on the MIMIC-IV dataset. We compare the performance of a model trained
with FL against a model trained on centralized data. We find that our federated
learning approach reaches very close to the performance of a centralized model,
and it outperforms local models in terms of average precision. We also show
that pre-trained MLM improves the model's average precision performance in the
next visit prediction task, compared to an MLM model without pre-training. Our
code is available at https://github.com/nadavlab/FederatedBEHRT. | [
-0.1048798412,
-0.9327220917,
0.4768542051,
-0.1312114149,
-0.233630091,
0.1164770871,
-0.0800786987,
-0.483727783,
0.3940368891,
0.4346274137,
-0.6370870471,
-0.6127354503,
-0.5845367908,
0.0012572946,
-0.0313241556,
0.8901727796,
-0.278983891,
0.5229138732,
-0.5812423825,
-0.2131762505,
-0.2807021141,
-0.6723347306,
-0.4109886587,
-0.8090183139,
0.1818929166,
0.390502274,
0.5352566838,
0.6613335609,
0.836736083,
0.2977770567,
0.402446866,
-0.1084940359,
-0.3023817241,
0.3196218014,
-0.1989958733,
-0.5432866812,
-0.4085711241,
-0.167675674,
0.5834465027,
0.836515069,
-0.3805423081,
0.0799761415,
-0.1933272034,
0.7473323941,
-0.5626376271,
0.4047926962,
-0.1971476674,
0.6326742172,
-0.1024208739,
-0.2114616036,
-0.3276847899,
-0.4195077419,
0.623290956,
-0.4089997113,
0.2695429325,
0.2000337094,
0.7947408557,
0.4341731071,
-0.2325311452,
-0.12982741,
-0.6325107813,
0.5970728993,
-0.4449612796,
0.5825107694,
0.2673364878,
0.5256896615,
0.0751577169,
-1.0098611116,
-0.2791713774,
0.1128589436,
-0.2654850483,
0.2607729435,
-0.5258529782,
0.1796209812,
0.1255956292,
0.6139919162,
-0.6021313667,
0.1596920639,
-0.1648273766,
-0.1151776537,
0.5787380338,
0.0860327408,
0.1409267634,
-0.0374165066,
-0.6976822615,
-0.1850917637,
-0.6245242953,
-0.1233416721,
-0.2978754342,
0.3036648631,
-0.222146526,
0.3928297162,
-0.2454745471,
0.2878158391,
0.3363140225,
0.0233031884,
0.590148747,
-0.0679334477,
-0.6970822215,
0.2698227465,
0.672590971,
-0.0487515107,
-0.1364062428,
-0.2523986101,
-0.3940533996,
-0.1067403033,
0.2374881655,
-0.8093063235,
-0.2799783051,
0.24689807,
-0.6945187449,
-0.1542116255,
0.1880733222,
-0.4910797477,
0.0239408873,
-0.4698973298,
0.6676985621,
-0.4885984063,
-0.1550999284,
-0.1054584458,
0.2565250397,
0.1418490261,
0.2582268417,
-0.8470580578,
0.6249336004,
0.7804906368,
0.9984562993,
-0.0544602387,
-0.268624723,
-0.8657118678,
-0.0752403364,
-0.0120854089,
0.5089187622,
-0.4773643613,
-0.3227864802,
0.262434423,
0.0867910758,
-0.227857843,
-0.4940710068,
0.0482842103,
-0.6424555182,
0.1351331174,
-0.1802939475,
-1.0627067089,
-0.3365863264,
0.3109082878,
-0.6956524849,
0.2490825653,
0.3248598278,
-0.8105609417,
0.205381915,
-0.7352725863,
-0.6362917423,
0.2110070288,
-0.28845945,
-0.8401380181,
0.1352618635,
0.2030725181,
0.8556791544,
-0.1587893814,
0.3911767304,
-0.2153498232,
-0.1323445886,
0.0428307764,
-0.011500584,
0.6064774394,
0.1881159693,
-0.3312432468,
0.1588134617,
-0.3963249922,
-0.0417837054,
0.0278166402,
-0.1042097509,
-0.4246190488,
-0.0880905688,
-0.0470050015,
0.1249324381,
0.0743178651,
-0.4690876305,
-0.0488311984,
-0.5252221823,
0.2653428614,
0.6428018808,
0.1777911633,
0.4042529762,
-0.709934175,
0.6190363169,
0.2580699921,
0.2000575215,
-0.1967692524,
-0.3772597909,
-0.4262861609,
-0.053449668,
0.138533324,
0.4722825587,
-0.6814721823,
0.3978723288,
-0.4608237445,
-0.3991868496,
-0.520209074,
-0.1382766068,
0.6100204587,
0.6615418196,
0.6166684628,
-0.3555069864,
-0.4477996528,
-0.6902361512,
0.2139875591,
0.0916423127,
-0.0443494208,
0.257802546,
0.679233849,
-0.6475411654,
0.5677306056,
-0.5691008568,
-0.6390526295,
-0.0152643742,
0.0596811809,
0.073862195,
0.641910255,
0.1247739121,
-0.827293992,
-0.5872456431,
0.2973575592,
-0.875939548,
0.4283989072,
0.1867275834,
-0.0077017415,
0.0980703831,
0.3851355016,
-0.3671901226,
0.3382379413,
0.6498861909,
-0.3126071692,
0.4398271441,
-0.4137494266,
-0.0052398923,
-1.5176246166,
0.0328214243,
-0.2280284166,
-0.4624527693,
-0.6136451364,
0.1588438451,
-0.1477857381,
-0.1946499348,
-0.126569882,
0.2720644176,
-0.4173016846,
-0.0944601372,
0.0423312895,
-0.3044696748,
-0.0422856063,
0.280625999,
0.2933478355,
0.303989917,
0.7005203962,
-0.3144001961,
0.3134431243,
0.6241967082,
-0.1663338542,
0.5969403386,
-0.7032465339,
0.0955321342,
0.1258329898,
0.2267320007,
-0.3382587731,
-0.5531467795,
0.0403943136,
-0.4659626782,
0.441444695,
0.0230371226,
-0.4474869668,
-0.1926804781,
-0.0242854953,
0.1463726312,
0.5271164179,
-0.6434922218,
0.5388395786,
0.5935534835,
-0.0221563578,
-0.6809765697,
-0.7214244604,
-0.6200216413,
0.1095796004,
-0.4872873724,
0.5893542767,
0.3365551233,
-0.0086527737,
0.2612164617,
-0.0392313264,
-0.2165825516,
0.0585795678,
0.5204276443,
0.1264694631,
-0.5619820356,
0.5937591195,
0.2885316312,
-0.2739104331,
0.2576137185,
-0.5331321955,
0.5037977099,
-0.2093215585,
-0.6725595593,
-0.5455421805,
0.5507089496,
0.4737327993,
-0.4270892143,
0.7751892805,
0.6000390649,
-0.9281272888,
-0.1224898025,
-0.4292663336,
-0.5193442702,
-0.3952016234,
0.1460954845,
0.013328379,
-1.165536046,
0.5595982671,
-0.2083087415,
0.1019971222,
0.1120645627,
0.5936425924,
-0.2024157941,
0.6063944697,
0.8733876348,
-0.0356725156,
0.3242642581,
-0.2795549929,
0.131520614,
-0.4836452007,
-0.4465216398,
-0.0834037811,
-0.3013260961,
-0.8160718679,
-0.6333353519,
0.5052707195,
-0.0928797349,
-0.422421515,
-0.0954707786,
-0.3075264096,
0.2012403309,
0.685956955,
0.6571745276,
0.2937746048,
0.1578674316,
-0.371399045,
0.1996009201,
-0.7070165873,
-0.0303948801,
1.1699026823,
0.5444982052,
0.7124958634,
0.0319195874,
1.0788564682,
0.156843707,
0.5667136908,
-0.70065552,
-0.1522732526,
-0.3584729433,
-0.4246251285,
-0.2841900587,
-0.3475189507,
-0.8390474916,
-0.1553738713,
-0.4778558612,
-0.4878394008,
0.256043762,
0.3580298424,
-0.6023569703,
0.4621179402,
-0.4664331079,
0.6738736033,
0.0849119201,
-0.3584796786,
-0.2527181208,
-0.9043273926,
0.102626808,
-0.1877418756,
-0.1062520668,
0.3836963475,
0.4095876813,
0.6693133116,
-0.6496481895,
0.7662388086,
-0.1570858061,
0.5298346877,
0.0222588517,
-0.1936712265,
0.3643750846,
0.2119118124,
0.0976752713,
0.3354217112,
0.0431822836,
-0.3920374215,
-0.5463657975,
0.4882196784,
-0.8527574539,
-0.4092666209,
-0.4455557764,
-0.1687085629,
-0.2936426401,
0.363668859,
0.4026363194,
0.4977821708,
-0.2856453955,
0.3882284462,
0.8379043341,
-0.1707718819,
0.096360147,
0.323638916,
-0.1592228711,
-0.4331980646,
0.481637001,
0.044613108,
0.2228205502,
0.8683980703,
0.5117660761,
-0.3323608637,
-0.3507497609,
0.0480987467,
0.2030303627,
-0.7163327336,
-0.5646874309,
-0.7665082216,
-0.5240499377,
-0.3144511878,
-0.5012879372,
-0.4203754365,
0.1413059682,
-0.2170772702,
-0.304240793,
0.5050902963,
0.6172053218,
-0.2953623533,
0.5262935162,
-0.9870007634,
-0.0744535178,
0.2743161917,
0.4609895349,
0.0428587198,
0.0214432068,
-0.3773375154,
0.2055119127,
-0.2056392282,
-0.7285943031,
0.3832376301,
0.1733285338,
0.6211724877,
0.7542615533,
0.075580284,
0.5515321493,
-0.7275370359,
0.2432956547,
0.3192661405,
-0.9742532372,
0.8176990747,
-0.0309045874,
0.1251679063,
0.7265584469,
0.6632108092,
-0.2816808224,
0.0324574113,
-0.8307532668,
-0.4444364607,
0.4268715382,
-0.012033416,
0.0369864963,
-0.0185437221,
0.316426903,
0.2781662643,
0.2789792717,
-0.3608298898,
-0.4950111806,
-0.2180876732,
-0.1276816428,
-0.2621540427,
0.032110583,
-0.0738603473,
-0.3306999505,
0.4746366143,
-0.0268625915,
0.5054952502,
0.4749052525,
-0.250787437,
-0.4278613329,
0.1147906035,
0.220881328,
0.4290980697,
-0.376441747,
0.0490955636,
-0.0241394881,
-0.6649698615,
0.0270388424,
0.4041550457,
-0.036039345,
0.2677551806,
0.5219191909,
0.8960986733,
0.3563348651,
-0.3746128678,
0.6518145204,
0.086538136,
-0.2489936203,
-0.3995848894,
-0.1696594507,
-0.0653644577,
0.4059644043,
0.0200045556,
0.1164581403,
0.1381223798,
-0.4086474776,
0.9007409811,
0.3595012724,
-0.6289084554,
-0.4742551744,
0.5987429619,
0.1429636329,
-0.2533776164,
0.9610871077,
0.1117908657,
-0.6764698029,
0.5016471148,
0.6670466661,
0.822175622,
-0.7209407091,
0.400902003,
0.4616124034,
0.0445631854,
-0.1632506996,
0.2066287845,
-0.2171226591,
-0.7926799655,
-0.2482813895,
-0.6838694811,
-0.5726007223,
-0.0684695765,
-1.0923867226,
0.0948338062,
-0.6177039742,
-0.0813580006,
-0.0675949231,
0.2655575573,
-1.1310560703,
0.1917299628,
-0.0134355491,
0.8287649155,
-1.0917773247,
0.8748154044,
0.8346288204,
-0.4970079362,
-1.0426934958,
0.0907085761,
0.0119660087,
-0.7111423612,
0.6225067377,
0.3737176359,
0.1967074871,
0.1470270306,
-0.2943863869,
-0.6988562942,
1.4180059433,
0.0748675987,
-0.6953354478,
-0.103538312,
0.0118656429,
0.5776972175,
-0.6773330569,
-0.0095314691,
0.2660065293,
-0.0558099486,
-0.0087039005,
-0.8966049552,
0.2518673837,
0.049467355,
-0.3331769109,
0.0482456535,
-0.392332077,
1.005136013,
-0.5825233459,
-0.2559203506,
-0.4394207299,
0.5060494542,
0.1947935075,
0.7365966439,
0.2625539899,
0.6686790586,
1.0872700214,
0.0506244749,
1.047477603,
-0.0276774243,
0.681843698,
1.1526937485,
-0.2777440548,
1.0089689493,
0.4353048503,
-0.1587661207,
0.5668106079,
0.571703136,
0.0146308644,
0.7691015005,
0.0573529787,
-0.3371351063,
-0.1372176111,
0.0442406833,
-0.5924620032,
0.5611696243,
0.5860322118,
-0.7672373056,
-0.3994548917,
0.3558621705,
-0.0101370653,
-0.0428671837,
-0.1792982966,
0.9833698869,
0.3019696474,
-0.3691032529,
0.2654515803,
-0.3146288395,
0.3422299325,
-0.4924070537,
-0.2064424455,
-0.1444205344,
0.2125402987,
-0.2484648526,
-0.2765934467,
0.4261909723,
-0.3595795631,
-0.3619301617,
-0.2089513987,
0.5978241563,
-0.3354429603,
-0.4175072908,
0.2826764882,
0.9757125974,
-0.0355448425,
0.2172601819,
-0.7709266543,
-0.3457441926,
-0.1246558949,
-0.038649898,
0.2703858912,
0.3534343839,
0.0505960472,
0.7418296933,
0.8201011419,
0.10489963,
-0.2334515899,
-0.0386499017,
0.8592262268,
-0.2194823027,
-0.6377391219,
-0.8450521827,
0.1938815713,
0.0485872738,
0.0181691051,
0.2874646485,
0.3759427369,
0.9740431309,
-0.1817053705,
0.6782184243,
0.1096119806,
0.5578445196,
-0.6529256105,
1.0633178949,
-0.4629768729,
0.0770808533,
-0.1350615174,
-0.5557137132,
-0.441210866,
0.8696201444,
-0.2905766666,
-0.1758330762,
0.803106308,
0.5257749557,
-0.2284664214,
0.1802612096,
0.4375282824,
0.1379398853,
0.210492909,
0.7097458839,
0.3132358491,
-0.4025478959,
-0.3741281033,
-0.8095998168,
-0.2657367587,
-0.4462933838,
-0.6501682401,
-0.9335321188,
-0.7456784248,
-0.4262447357,
-0.2542455196,
0.2112190723,
1.2745463848,
0.84281528,
-1.0078575611,
0.2464516163,
-0.2722689211,
0.2381901592,
-0.4199022949,
-0.1574890614,
0.8536735773,
-0.2857658863,
-0.3405321538,
0.0126626855,
0.1825792342,
0.1220581979,
-0.1119178534,
0.0228385292,
-0.2247863859,
-0.4233133793,
0.4699385464,
0.1058811247,
-0.4974656701,
-0.2375664711,
0.1124267951,
0.0244642142,
0.1144270897,
0.8436880112,
-0.8081724644,
0.6818951368,
0.3176999986,
1.0188410282,
0.1649846584,
0.1450129747,
0.6650487185,
-0.7299083471,
-0.0657282323,
0.4546029568,
0.4793584943,
0.3098849952,
-0.6462136507,
0.2833672762,
0.1312075108,
-0.5746119618,
-0.6854004264,
-0.0165164452,
-0.668833375,
-0.0676093027,
0.6504817605,
-0.6036892533,
-0.0605956912,
-0.0674766302,
0.6554016471,
0.5947388411,
-0.1657939255,
0.6917366982,
0.4079200625,
-0.2797533274,
-0.0614669994,
-0.4955171943,
0.5354569554,
0.2117724866,
-0.9921874404,
-0.264075011,
0.3446436822,
0.4372802079,
0.183366552,
0.6480408311,
-0.158056125,
0.3379247189,
-0.0633282885,
-0.1675379872,
-0.1890135407,
-0.149768576,
-0.4707728326,
0.0166308247,
-0.3296271563,
-0.5241858363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13048v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13048v2 | RWKV: Reinventing RNNs for the Transformer Era | 2023-05-22T13:57:41 | 2023-12-11T03:58:56 | Bo Peng, Eric Alcaide, Quentin Anthony, Alon Albalak, Samuel Arcadinho, Stella Biderman, Huanqi Cao, Xin Cheng, Michael Chung, Matteo Grella, Kranthi Kiran GV, Xuzheng He, Haowen Hou, Jiaju Lin, Przemyslaw Kazienko, Jan Kocon, Jiaming Kong, Bartlomiej Koptyra, Hayden Lau, Krishna Sri Ipsit Mantri, Ferdinand Mom, Atsushi Saito, Guangyu Song, Xiangru Tang, Bolun Wang, Johan S. Wind, Stanislaw Wozniak, Ruichong Zhang, Zhenyuan Zhang, Qihang Zhao, Peng Zhou, Qinghua Zhou, Jian Zhu, Rui-Jie Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformers have revolutionized almost all natural language processing (NLP)
tasks but suffer from memory and computational complexity that scales
quadratically with sequence length. In contrast, recurrent neural networks
(RNNs) exhibit linear scaling in memory and computational requirements but
struggle to match the same performance as Transformers due to limitations in
parallelization and scalability. We propose a novel model architecture,
Receptance Weighted Key Value (RWKV), that combines the efficient
parallelizable training of transformers with the efficient inference of RNNs.
Our approach leverages a linear attention mechanism and allows us to
formulate the model as either a Transformer or an RNN, thus parallelizing
computations during training and maintains constant computational and memory
complexity during inference. We scale our models as large as 14 billion
parameters, by far the largest dense RNN ever trained, and find RWKV performs
on par with similarly sized Transformers, suggesting future work can leverage
this architecture to create more efficient models. This work presents a
significant step towards reconciling trade-offs between computational
efficiency and model performance in sequence processing tasks. | [
-0.1750243902,
-0.2566933632,
0.2429693788,
0.2670169771,
-0.0437093601,
-0.1037198603,
-0.1336507201,
-0.305408597,
0.0359688438,
0.5507642031,
-0.5569655895,
0.1118177474,
-0.7622411847,
0.0438694619,
-0.7126988769,
0.9898369908,
0.5335671306,
-0.0858274549,
-0.1452659667,
-0.407345891,
-0.242940098,
-0.1859325171,
-0.6359863281,
-0.7491040826,
0.8198414445,
0.1766830087,
0.9090284109,
0.8028261662,
0.6333023906,
0.3824557066,
-0.036122337,
-0.1447672099,
-0.6771178842,
0.4091358483,
-0.1105511412,
-0.4380259812,
-0.2930159569,
-0.1947719902,
0.5967890024,
0.6451127529,
-0.3907726109,
0.2351865917,
-0.0876715258,
0.8234764934,
-0.4321899414,
0.2230533063,
-0.6965505481,
0.3694560826,
0.1111645922,
-0.1245305166,
-0.7051054239,
-0.2682951689,
0.4703324437,
-0.7026147246,
0.5730506778,
0.032020051,
0.7463300228,
0.513820231,
-0.0966871902,
0.2316184193,
-0.9324688911,
1.0380131006,
-0.7378996611,
0.7549993992,
-0.2490348518,
0.1825207472,
-0.1753255576,
-1.3720524311,
-0.4212801158,
-0.1412781477,
-0.0925665125,
0.0520110875,
-0.4050202966,
-0.0097946189,
0.5039913654,
0.5202383995,
-0.5661843419,
-0.1843844205,
-0.5033478141,
0.0162099283,
0.3484097719,
0.3552477658,
-0.0383737013,
-0.1986312866,
-0.275618583,
-0.2172978669,
-0.1794294864,
0.0732813999,
-0.0360951535,
0.3491047919,
0.0854918435,
0.4172365963,
-0.2581072748,
0.8797219992,
0.2118284404,
-0.0656818822,
0.165109843,
-0.1218457818,
-0.4907263517,
-0.1966252178,
0.8664332032,
0.0917653367,
0.3630377054,
-0.4295070171,
-0.0244569257,
-0.2200233936,
1.1419939995,
-0.8031620383,
-0.2727644444,
0.0985351801,
-0.7479205132,
-0.6872850657,
-0.1226108894,
-0.8462257981,
-0.3056155741,
-0.2519729137,
0.3139370382,
-0.3445049226,
-0.1614046097,
0.133126691,
-0.4409823716,
0.4977275729,
0.0847815946,
-1.1585412025,
0.2308627814,
1.0012773275,
0.7868791819,
-0.0622823723,
-0.2073245943,
-0.1904717088,
-0.169936806,
0.0595026799,
0.5364450216,
-0.5586267114,
-0.1932450831,
-0.2606520355,
-0.1704422086,
0.141893819,
-0.1996318102,
0.4946779013,
-0.7331808209,
0.2153756768,
0.0316785276,
-0.2878033817,
-0.2034827024,
0.2000643164,
-0.8661661744,
1.1684753895,
0.3604566753,
-0.9190587401,
0.1922580302,
-0.2793773413,
-0.5528532267,
0.134154737,
-0.1164619178,
-0.8228660226,
0.3366718292,
0.1454558223,
0.4019587934,
-0.683796823,
0.2923660278,
-0.1477122158,
-0.4169769883,
0.1525003761,
-0.6820732951,
0.5067031384,
0.0662492439,
-0.1909427941,
0.3053894639,
-0.9861553907,
0.1067674458,
0.1741579622,
-0.3948609829,
-0.141288206,
-0.0245920364,
-0.064584665,
0.0170086883,
0.0473378599,
-0.6962972283,
0.2205791473,
-0.8180639148,
0.9854024053,
0.5864832997,
-0.2401567698,
0.6313095093,
-0.3085029721,
0.5539429188,
-0.2946612537,
0.3064141273,
-0.1746161878,
-0.6800681949,
-0.862334609,
-0.099195078,
0.2007496059,
0.4650639296,
-0.4425686896,
0.2255222499,
-0.6799187064,
-0.6303334832,
-0.6126765609,
-0.350055784,
0.1142410636,
0.789362967,
0.4509604573,
-0.1095756143,
-0.6823422909,
-1.1585226059,
-0.4450246394,
0.053942956,
-0.4421531856,
0.25516361,
0.2277987152,
-0.0447760224,
1.0551613569,
-0.3483767807,
-0.1169906706,
-0.4487784505,
0.2730339468,
0.4618174732,
0.2845411003,
-0.0622030534,
-0.7758154273,
-0.1630178243,
0.0707602352,
-0.537822783,
0.0975743607,
-0.2730505466,
0.197715953,
-0.1384744495,
0.476272583,
-0.7023539543,
0.4212699533,
0.3522770703,
0.0246495046,
0.2568279207,
-0.1278568506,
-0.0879220665,
-0.9723086357,
0.1063474417,
-0.1776048094,
-0.3626500666,
-0.7849590778,
-0.0335977748,
0.1712696552,
-0.1850825995,
-0.3052134812,
0.2119539827,
-0.1418506354,
-0.210406065,
-0.2890229821,
-0.216971159,
0.116551578,
0.6703414321,
0.0270251371,
0.7833742499,
0.1366384178,
-0.4189715087,
0.5637853146,
0.2593242526,
-0.2259658873,
0.2725958228,
-1.0492968559,
-0.0405166186,
-0.3531267941,
0.3953045905,
-0.832682848,
0.1112182587,
0.037844684,
-0.6848371029,
0.1309064776,
-0.0316675715,
-0.0267715994,
-0.5490880609,
-0.1408452243,
0.613665998,
0.5748721361,
-0.4147548378,
1.3569242954,
0.0247759093,
0.021805523,
-0.9195818901,
-0.8762190938,
-0.0217745472,
-0.1067456156,
-0.663941741,
0.4408539534,
0.6399648786,
0.1224296689,
-0.01413495,
-0.0812228769,
-0.0001358794,
-0.1123536155,
0.4160220921,
0.1979186535,
-0.347394079,
0.3679720163,
-0.3971393108,
-0.4575643241,
0.1349745393,
-0.6148053408,
0.4112624824,
-0.0881508514,
0.0075940499,
-0.3993828297,
0.3294371367,
0.8965315819,
-0.4071537554,
0.8478705287,
0.6099408865,
-0.17922692,
-0.4875458777,
-0.5362761617,
-0.4665953517,
-0.4765906334,
0.6073402762,
-0.2121801823,
-1.0470610857,
0.2939885557,
0.0226627719,
0.3798871338,
0.4801686108,
0.5479230285,
0.1084315926,
0.657951355,
0.617308557,
-0.1410270929,
0.5447304845,
-0.1289941669,
0.6717331409,
-0.8310477138,
-0.1704605222,
-0.3734683096,
-0.673471868,
-0.5164059997,
-0.5617955327,
0.3299828768,
-0.5095772147,
-0.5104604959,
0.4920846224,
-0.8459952474,
0.2433864623,
0.6926945448,
0.1036266237,
0.2640537322,
-0.1015157625,
0.0271179359,
-0.1385944784,
-0.9943374395,
-0.0039043941,
1.3245536089,
0.6357728243,
0.7804530263,
-0.2199636847,
0.3265199065,
0.2411472797,
0.3981107175,
-0.9470348954,
0.4020875692,
-0.1839539707,
-0.2831648588,
-0.5521169901,
-0.5030972958,
-0.8671960831,
0.5010685921,
-0.3158054352,
-0.3076132238,
0.0152430655,
0.2231580466,
-0.6391797066,
0.3696252406,
-0.3357230425,
0.7898582816,
0.303679347,
-0.2933051288,
-0.3848399222,
-0.8181375265,
0.4553174078,
0.3159877658,
-0.1931947619,
0.2592132986,
0.0589483231,
0.6066064835,
-0.5051421523,
0.6981434226,
0.2001913637,
0.1304156482,
0.0658224002,
-0.1665827483,
0.7272830009,
0.2081936449,
-0.07333529,
0.0765091181,
-0.3944329619,
-0.2562914193,
-0.838478148,
0.6184276938,
-0.6372583508,
-0.4460473359,
-0.4693560898,
-0.8962596059,
-0.0741025135,
0.2064412683,
0.2565308213,
0.535698235,
-0.1458477676,
0.5897203684,
1.0245395899,
-0.1915925592,
0.3592895269,
0.2478396147,
0.1190305054,
-0.5718865991,
0.6116145253,
-0.1156795844,
0.4886554778,
0.6069929004,
0.2767034173,
-0.0893598497,
-0.3285462856,
-0.1912771612,
0.1631116122,
-0.4730452299,
-0.3300022781,
-0.9333924055,
-0.5620851517,
-0.3428711295,
-0.113748759,
-0.8637487888,
-0.573685348,
-0.0623290986,
-0.095220916,
0.6293599606,
0.6982927322,
0.1152667031,
0.2728192508,
-0.6942548752,
0.6882208586,
0.695972681,
0.514287293,
0.5537025332,
-0.7689452767,
-0.1354270279,
-0.2210613787,
-0.2755248547,
-0.4241506159,
0.3524075449,
0.0435958803,
0.1377151459,
0.1040583774,
-0.1135432273,
0.4178226292,
-0.8646863699,
0.5317949653,
0.1545179635,
-0.7048199177,
0.0568921454,
-0.2776866555,
0.6553786993,
0.282736063,
-0.0523702763,
-0.8669860959,
-0.3478344381,
-0.5366172194,
-0.9662057757,
0.6463037729,
0.3461787403,
0.1867382079,
0.084815301,
0.5754002929,
-0.0642751455,
0.0728398487,
-0.8713932633,
-0.3810165823,
-0.480448842,
-0.2834763527,
0.3009052575,
-0.2480205148,
0.0916792825,
-0.3766500056,
0.5267565846,
0.0410029106,
0.4366816282,
0.3332284093,
0.1759787202,
0.0569083579,
0.3424054086,
0.5844484568,
0.4281855524,
-0.0835882872,
-0.0367897674,
0.3202952445,
-0.6392441392,
0.1013653949,
-0.0133260507,
-0.2065017223,
-0.1938516051,
0.4312164783,
0.8968454003,
0.6993240714,
-0.4028235078,
0.3660580218,
-0.3749304116,
-0.3161429763,
-0.3972497582,
0.0118835038,
0.4109986126,
0.4433466792,
0.3438502252,
0.280275017,
-0.0333800316,
-0.0438871533,
0.5242561102,
0.3872147799,
-0.416007638,
0.0552642383,
0.7794697285,
0.2564002573,
-0.5799702406,
1.0630338192,
0.2352118045,
-0.4272432029,
0.6256742477,
0.3734598458,
0.9568765163,
-0.1852673888,
-0.0048283152,
0.5468522906,
0.3700984418,
-0.2652380168,
0.0816938132,
-0.1265592426,
-0.7563151717,
-0.5372412205,
-0.7480095625,
-0.2251208127,
0.1152550578,
-0.8944111466,
0.1036973745,
-0.6245341897,
-0.163281709,
0.1751933843,
-0.5839330554,
-0.6223769188,
0.1800603122,
0.0486985818,
0.8629202843,
-0.5525861382,
0.8991459608,
0.0975672901,
-0.0491756164,
-0.7373246551,
-0.3186147511,
-0.2675089836,
-0.7818275094,
0.713147819,
0.2496139854,
-0.2419471741,
0.1710292995,
-0.141059041,
-1.0160739422,
1.2022389174,
-0.0805066526,
-0.7486107349,
-0.3965025544,
0.3126372695,
0.568700254,
-0.2756234407,
0.308929801,
0.7295423746,
0.2963757217,
0.0815658197,
-0.6819640398,
-0.0953787491,
0.0109663997,
0.4312821925,
0.5507438779,
-0.5563318729,
0.7548333406,
-0.1594903618,
-0.0706580803,
0.0743351653,
1.2088092566,
0.0196423605,
-0.1766948104,
0.4372219145,
1.044367671,
0.3301333487,
-0.1763512194,
1.0208300352,
-0.1211743429,
0.3647752106,
1.1453077793,
0.0176186822,
0.8590819836,
0.5362827778,
-0.3546696007,
0.4643362761,
-0.0651013032,
-0.234494701,
0.3265618384,
0.3304947019,
-0.1943649203,
-0.2295209318,
0.1886055022,
-0.2548362017,
0.4107624888,
0.1965574175,
-0.6579460502,
-0.2718574405,
0.1012589186,
-0.2502551675,
0.1921805292,
-0.2471533865,
0.6622413993,
0.1218862459,
-0.618596375,
0.3468548357,
0.037754938,
0.8044947982,
-0.7525563836,
-0.0839458704,
0.0430853367,
0.4486724436,
-0.0804487839,
-0.5844191313,
0.6211643815,
-0.2648974359,
-0.6835707426,
-0.4522678852,
0.6253006458,
-0.3030567169,
-0.6738759875,
0.2029305845,
-0.1287153661,
-0.4355334938,
0.0152562186,
-0.6369769573,
0.0578569956,
-0.0265620183,
-0.5275430679,
0.2196424603,
0.2258870751,
0.2262947559,
1.0373343229,
0.4794889688,
-0.0991376117,
0.2985479832,
0.2824407816,
0.8081818819,
-0.8960466385,
-0.4434862733,
-0.6779667735,
0.5832229853,
0.020307593,
-0.3592005074,
0.5509538054,
0.2960957587,
0.5178206563,
-0.1844650805,
0.6662948132,
0.0461287238,
0.6446657777,
0.0658995435,
0.6706396937,
-0.198256284,
-0.0252509434,
0.1226683483,
-0.6703987122,
-0.2989768684,
0.6285561323,
-0.0552764498,
-0.0309586693,
0.5299366117,
0.7397105694,
-0.0755405501,
0.3771037161,
0.1670990139,
0.2857500911,
0.3963045776,
0.7099209428,
0.4668657482,
-0.779170692,
0.7154201865,
-0.3220547736,
-0.1136418208,
0.0525760911,
-0.9452422261,
-0.7357807755,
-0.4094761908,
-0.0892897025,
-0.3411542475,
-0.0278583616,
0.6589196324,
0.6074179411,
-0.7541521192,
-0.0439457409,
-0.5810570121,
0.1333464533,
-0.4142345488,
-0.3112169802,
-0.0051152706,
-0.4059517384,
-0.4884350896,
0.3245224953,
0.5600909591,
-0.3192172945,
-0.5064672232,
0.1833544075,
-0.0985333622,
0.1651897877,
0.686614573,
0.4741958976,
-0.9508101344,
-0.3606409431,
0.0754205287,
-0.1370099932,
0.1411186159,
1.134703517,
-1.2313787937,
0.429428637,
0.6796577573,
1.0391005278,
0.4416261911,
0.0433027335,
1.06044209,
-0.5333788395,
0.3112022281,
0.5182086825,
0.0937169939,
0.1825045943,
-0.4103629887,
0.242601037,
0.0796560124,
-0.835416913,
-0.7103118896,
0.3737786412,
-0.8993674517,
-0.1400277466,
0.7561830282,
0.1191753522,
-0.2166616619,
-0.1098410711,
0.1748048067,
0.240588367,
-0.2784987688,
0.7985085845,
0.5515077114,
0.0199548472,
-0.4533405602,
-0.5946115255,
0.5542061925,
0.639495194,
-0.2101216763,
0.3284228742,
-0.076015912,
0.2434802949,
0.0360088982,
0.2718888521,
-0.129444778,
0.3904250264,
0.0242203455,
0.0695270821,
-0.2416252196,
-0.3771881163,
-0.4838444293,
0.4401230216,
-0.2394956201,
0.0115420381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13047v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13047v1 | Automated stance detection in complex topics and small languages: the challenging case of immigration in polarizing news media | 2023-05-22T13:56:35 | 2023-05-22T13:56:35 | Mark Mets, Andres Karjus, Indrek Ibrus, Maximilian Schich | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated stance detection and related machine learning methods can provide
useful insights for media monitoring and academic research. Many of these
approaches require annotated training datasets, which limits their
applicability for languages where these may not be readily available. This
paper explores the applicability of large language models for automated stance
detection in a challenging scenario, involving a morphologically complex,
lower-resource language, and a socio-culturally complex topic, immigration. If
the approach works in this case, it can be expected to perform as well or
better in less demanding scenarios. We annotate a large set of pro and
anti-immigration examples, and compare the performance of multiple language
models as supervised learners. We also probe the usability of ChatGPT as an
instructable zero-shot classifier for the same task. Supervised achieves
acceptable performance, and ChatGPT yields similar accuracy. This is promising
as a potentially simpler and cheaper alternative for text classification tasks,
including in lower-resource languages. We further use the best-performing model
to investigate diachronic trends over seven years in two corpora of Estonian
mainstream and right-wing populist news sources, demonstrating the
applicability of the approach for news analytics and media monitoring settings,
and discuss correspondences between stance changes and real-world events. | [
-0.5177246332,
-0.8563981056,
0.5161079764,
0.1571677923,
-0.3022591472,
0.1900391281,
-0.2689123452,
-0.2294102907,
0.1887577772,
0.2179625779,
-0.3442928791,
-0.7795731425,
-0.8504385352,
0.0121559948,
-0.4067904353,
0.9622219801,
-0.1536948234,
0.1842665076,
0.1721370518,
-0.4709375799,
-0.2408018261,
-0.5374910235,
-0.7712332606,
-0.2583778799,
0.2383072972,
0.5140528679,
0.9377028942,
0.5153743625,
0.4385395646,
0.2267364115,
-0.1352327764,
-0.2336340696,
0.0922247842,
-0.0062025008,
-0.1235643476,
-0.5530219078,
-0.2935677171,
0.2432823628,
0.6349203587,
0.719230175,
-0.0630429909,
0.0056816633,
-0.230720222,
0.5431065559,
-0.1940080523,
0.2442200631,
-0.5848194957,
0.2415513694,
-0.2564425468,
0.2667372227,
-0.2719491422,
-0.139294818,
-0.1482176185,
-0.015621285,
0.2197360098,
0.0693266168,
0.9030308723,
0.3066813648,
-0.5290450454,
-0.3929245472,
-0.6055870056,
0.8165481091,
-0.5989685059,
0.6983335018,
0.3752695024,
0.079878293,
-0.1796781868,
-0.2017206252,
-0.828209877,
-0.462069422,
0.0152676143,
0.2480820119,
-0.3819945455,
-0.1181932911,
0.1643211544,
0.1129501015,
-0.6186116934,
0.4813264906,
-0.1150231957,
-0.1590925902,
0.4454889894,
0.0401236154,
0.373776406,
-0.5474684238,
-0.1201564521,
0.0125596048,
-0.5446344614,
0.3176171184,
0.6732575297,
0.5351728797,
-0.3788387477,
0.7187879682,
-0.1966486871,
0.5892473459,
0.2890882194,
0.1695108116,
-0.0153827863,
0.0254400969,
0.1680074334,
-0.1902403831,
0.9073371291,
0.1393268406,
-0.0081968019,
0.2504698932,
-0.2032622248,
0.0876326561,
-0.0467748605,
-0.5992334485,
-0.2168965042,
0.4564845264,
-0.4498699903,
-0.324803859,
0.1052571237,
-0.7244892716,
-0.5079880357,
-0.6579417586,
-0.1680782735,
-0.1829396486,
-0.402190268,
0.1060179397,
0.1315492392,
0.5805262923,
0.473117739,
-0.7571662068,
-0.1317868084,
0.9472877383,
1.0159366131,
-0.2820842862,
0.0767116621,
-0.5335629582,
-0.36696437,
-0.5488590598,
0.8124328852,
-0.6474269032,
-0.165136084,
-0.012726591,
0.110385716,
-0.0409717113,
-0.4220707715,
0.5988141298,
-0.5853721499,
0.177771911,
0.151883617,
-0.4958447814,
0.0763659626,
0.6957741976,
-0.7175238729,
0.7724328637,
0.0678974912,
-0.7369304895,
0.6353046298,
-0.6948211789,
-0.4879509807,
-0.0824071392,
-0.3803859055,
-0.7067027092,
-0.2244945318,
-0.0550423078,
0.5350949168,
0.2024077773,
0.4497715831,
-0.4137666225,
-0.0352783352,
-0.0957385227,
-0.3340753317,
1.1590886116,
0.1834702194,
-0.4661135674,
0.0131177679,
-0.5449572802,
-0.5774083138,
0.0445376113,
-0.6255425215,
-0.4552623332,
0.1699415445,
-0.0408562571,
0.2399829477,
-0.0083355177,
-0.6078504324,
0.3315060735,
-0.20784612,
0.3011963069,
0.4121384621,
-0.090538606,
0.500053823,
0.190668121,
0.5773131847,
0.3197877705,
0.1662500948,
0.0110823298,
-0.4315783679,
-0.760933578,
-0.3438875079,
0.5349271894,
0.9123306274,
-0.5526615977,
0.5636318326,
0.0437517129,
-0.3872920871,
-0.4146468341,
0.2443915904,
0.1082398146,
0.3192155957,
0.1640245616,
-0.3407287002,
-0.5755378008,
-0.8417628407,
-0.3412003517,
-0.6201937199,
0.0878457129,
0.0174384844,
0.5104307532,
-0.3025205731,
1.0738009214,
-0.1567612886,
-0.255864054,
-0.2804231942,
0.669085145,
0.221122086,
0.2318981886,
0.6797907948,
-1.1340985298,
-0.6299114227,
0.2500759959,
-0.6314913034,
-0.0389479809,
-0.1884133518,
-0.0259087868,
0.4931468964,
0.7428337336,
-0.7610694766,
0.1712459475,
0.5224105716,
-0.4443678856,
0.3539918959,
0.2197913527,
0.0747156441,
-1.1874029636,
-0.1020636111,
0.373768121,
-0.415119499,
-0.8775264621,
-0.1276584268,
-0.0226189084,
-0.0671938285,
-0.6825733781,
0.4771131873,
-0.0983559415,
0.1309007704,
-0.2341719866,
-0.0331852213,
-0.3509367406,
0.1675251722,
0.5455679297,
0.3076771498,
0.3821668327,
-0.3091128767,
0.3471647799,
0.2469775975,
-0.1464539915,
0.813816905,
-0.1605623364,
0.0320419222,
-0.5476273894,
0.3762530684,
-1.0014823675,
-0.3498538733,
0.4297592044,
-0.4556820989,
0.3587513566,
-0.7453251481,
-0.3117182553,
-0.3499379456,
-0.3431402445,
0.0502036884,
0.3889828622,
-0.3926510811,
0.5575581789,
0.6459052563,
-0.319940418,
-0.6617833972,
-0.3283458352,
0.2396400869,
-0.5842298865,
-0.1531590819,
-0.1565580666,
0.2880797088,
-0.7116602659,
-0.1488930881,
0.1769893318,
-0.1568730026,
0.1269162595,
0.1903747767,
0.0701505914,
-0.2793313861,
0.0927001834,
-0.0073796916,
-0.1751612276,
-0.1091190279,
-0.3975322843,
0.5772717595,
-0.4442810714,
-0.4548311234,
-0.5727029443,
0.4702120721,
0.973146677,
-0.0917317867,
0.6662697792,
0.868158102,
-0.2823217213,
0.0585945547,
-0.3599063456,
-0.0616430417,
-0.3407889605,
0.2764108479,
-0.0745460466,
-0.6557581425,
0.5144337416,
-0.0093718087,
0.3842805624,
0.4971976876,
0.7290878296,
-0.4048897922,
1.25306499,
0.6386514306,
-0.598862052,
0.6789934635,
-0.1188628301,
0.4170926511,
-0.1726407111,
-0.0105623072,
-0.7011829615,
-0.2189320773,
-0.7478385568,
-0.2389822006,
0.1771437526,
-0.1385015547,
-0.0561215021,
0.4344646633,
-0.133726418,
0.3294454813,
0.3693222404,
-0.1730343103,
0.4036450982,
-0.0094585083,
0.2355515212,
-0.0682906285,
-0.5110219717,
-0.7550061941,
0.5587385893,
0.5446484089,
0.5999476314,
-0.0270870421,
0.571998179,
0.6103132367,
0.5281487107,
-1.2697758675,
0.4770488739,
-0.5068952441,
-0.3780026734,
-0.3872307539,
-0.2527465224,
-0.8486377001,
0.2921774387,
-0.188925162,
-0.2720294893,
0.3068024516,
0.3197562397,
-0.2832068503,
0.3750455678,
-0.5967975259,
0.8196598291,
-0.171853736,
-0.2074305713,
-0.0906101838,
-0.4864952862,
0.0196085479,
-0.1434667557,
0.4465645254,
-0.1800905317,
0.0603735447,
0.6390532255,
-0.1261190176,
1.2436282635,
-0.4734685421,
-0.3336620927,
0.3837942183,
0.0546104908,
0.3219841719,
-0.0014627354,
-0.0941596106,
0.3439840972,
-0.1392398328,
-0.3824102283,
-0.133014366,
0.4375178516,
-0.7393339276,
-0.6800800562,
-0.1800522208,
-0.4589539766,
-0.1749402136,
0.0924306437,
0.1497684717,
0.0300071295,
-0.2240348309,
0.3023572266,
0.4902872145,
0.0246951208,
0.5440277457,
0.6147089601,
0.0236728117,
0.2313975692,
0.8475942612,
0.2694238126,
-0.2098887861,
0.3409060836,
0.3449321985,
-0.2739076912,
-0.6248083115,
-0.7736202478,
-0.0098748626,
-0.466004312,
0.0272917971,
-0.7561357617,
0.1522466391,
-0.1957086325,
-0.2178543508,
-0.6263391972,
-0.516012609,
0.0515367165,
-0.183583349,
0.1778022647,
0.4307868183,
-0.0770077035,
0.2064620107,
-0.5802064538,
0.2785902917,
0.2225815356,
0.1429155171,
-0.5569957495,
-0.424977839,
-0.0141070364,
0.0732888505,
-0.2897647619,
-0.8872458339,
0.138124764,
0.0791873038,
0.4819194376,
0.5704643726,
0.1638773531,
0.1997029036,
-0.3583112359,
0.7755571604,
-0.0532107726,
-0.7334685922,
0.6512538195,
-0.7823960185,
0.1845777482,
0.5194917321,
0.8652102947,
-0.4663664401,
-0.810461998,
-0.4390405118,
-0.6877456903,
0.6118792295,
-0.0031856669,
0.4141402245,
-0.072134316,
0.2444071025,
0.1806600094,
0.1196673736,
-0.8991824985,
0.3045908511,
-0.0997961313,
-0.5303872228,
0.1163759157,
0.1093298346,
-0.0516918078,
-0.3406018913,
0.5782315731,
-0.2809840739,
-0.0910229534,
-0.0863538757,
-0.3113597929,
-0.0694316924,
0.4087359905,
0.3837145567,
0.2391000688,
0.1439253837,
0.19723171,
0.2863222361,
-0.473163873,
0.1710959375,
-0.0353113301,
-0.521222353,
0.3343605697,
0.2045327574,
0.621614337,
-0.1275519431,
-0.5583916903,
0.6307252645,
0.106080763,
-0.2576948404,
-0.490023613,
-0.219415009,
-0.0683399737,
0.3739381135,
0.0494864993,
-0.0356974341,
0.0332728215,
-0.8444994092,
0.2720423639,
0.758492291,
-0.6898292303,
-0.4567674398,
0.3948822916,
0.0710712895,
-0.3637556434,
0.4636413455,
-0.2492242455,
-0.8391378522,
0.7511826754,
0.1818193048,
0.5581266284,
-0.355982542,
0.5230791569,
0.2620991468,
0.1590817869,
-0.2369225323,
-0.0291464794,
-0.0291308798,
-0.8565109372,
-0.1652473956,
-0.4745810926,
-0.6127226949,
0.0795038342,
-0.5579504967,
0.6487356424,
-0.4686826468,
-0.3028211296,
0.1523828208,
-0.0520476513,
-0.44604972,
-0.0138676595,
0.5200296044,
0.6100800037,
-1.4850498438,
0.5588592887,
1.1838285923,
-0.2253729552,
-0.2629826367,
0.3158684671,
0.4381254613,
-0.5652703047,
0.3241071701,
0.0169996712,
-0.2469739765,
-0.1944994479,
-0.5231266618,
-0.1251107156,
0.5481648445,
0.2863646746,
-0.4308719039,
0.2083189934,
0.3809518218,
0.7881940603,
-0.2018850446,
-0.0035913654,
0.754121244,
0.5486083627,
-0.1583532244,
-0.7316640019,
-0.3344483972,
0.0240396727,
-0.4938418269,
0.3837684393,
-0.991604805,
0.8594813943,
0.084301576,
-0.1776897907,
-0.3948453963,
0.4797061384,
-0.0767085329,
0.5270167589,
0.926989615,
0.3840610087,
0.5939743519,
-0.1619354784,
0.7373858094,
-0.2302662581,
0.3740265071,
0.5509137511,
-0.192495212,
1.0297175646,
0.4480491877,
-0.0924406573,
0.5467841625,
0.7824988961,
0.0048201145,
0.2425569743,
-0.0476774313,
-0.2487986833,
-0.3989937901,
-0.1829937398,
0.2180231065,
0.7645156384,
0.4335356355,
-0.147092402,
-0.4436410069,
0.2002601773,
0.4149112105,
0.063437216,
-0.4573703408,
0.7571531534,
0.1151447371,
-0.7678930759,
0.1347750872,
0.0528683737,
0.553594768,
-0.1810724288,
0.078066133,
-0.449663341,
0.0857056305,
-0.3722931445,
-0.9869943857,
0.471914351,
0.3654268682,
-0.0803442746,
-0.2505354881,
0.6121006608,
-0.4771794975,
-0.3965644836,
0.1775087416,
0.7278141379,
0.1601323038,
0.0462797061,
-0.7303691506,
-0.1032478586,
-0.1464031488,
-0.4442844689,
0.3751766384,
0.4366136491,
-0.6698417068,
0.4231167436,
0.540669024,
-0.1421661228,
-0.0788056776,
0.2181688696,
0.5517658591,
-0.3962295055,
-0.5248354673,
-1.0278228521,
0.3284309208,
-0.0380362645,
-0.0221795961,
0.538027823,
0.5488393307,
0.8309628963,
-0.0059026177,
0.8279846907,
-0.3174065948,
0.4293556809,
-0.502840519,
0.6421063542,
-0.4695672691,
0.0536936037,
-0.0116323661,
-0.7300046682,
-0.7157214284,
0.64893502,
-0.4293068349,
-0.3744487166,
0.2793714106,
0.654461503,
-0.3379050195,
-0.1207198426,
0.1158911139,
0.125530377,
0.3680050969,
0.1862677634,
1.0492618084,
0.2074423283,
0.5769671202,
-0.0964433774,
-0.2409269512,
-0.2993598282,
-0.8205563426,
-1.0702165365,
-0.6225248575,
-0.6165827513,
-0.1210096925,
-0.0940786675,
1.1583679914,
0.8202832341,
-1.0537346601,
-0.0370010063,
-0.0884138271,
0.1752583534,
0.0419286415,
-0.2369099855,
0.3062388003,
-0.2811226249,
-1.0383366346,
0.161046505,
0.0923919529,
0.1577190161,
-0.3045739233,
0.2147536129,
-0.1549185514,
0.0044908077,
0.8171210289,
0.7742630243,
-0.6668798923,
-0.499364078,
-0.0870896354,
-0.1010300741,
0.193603307,
0.7996004224,
-0.4257330298,
0.1680135876,
0.5566900969,
0.6374176741,
0.2690482736,
0.3048779666,
0.2734104991,
-0.8841090798,
0.4696033299,
0.4066042006,
0.4151850641,
0.3787045777,
-0.3286328912,
0.4030010998,
0.2078523785,
-0.2109632045,
-0.7857539058,
0.3551221192,
-0.8499495387,
-0.0787825659,
1.2849398851,
-0.0934899747,
-0.0559221208,
-0.6802206635,
-0.342151016,
0.1449536532,
-0.3902517855,
1.0366549492,
0.8515239358,
-0.2973908782,
-0.2391558439,
-0.7677029371,
0.3270018995,
0.4640634656,
-0.6449824572,
0.0571934581,
0.4212626815,
0.1367038637,
0.3245179355,
0.5729284286,
-0.1246904284,
0.0484693907,
-0.2759144306,
-0.1071892306,
0.3687620163,
-0.3812135458,
-0.4177115858,
0.2035829425,
0.2023596317,
-0.0931383893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13040v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13040v5 | SpokenWOZ: A Large-Scale Speech-Text Benchmark for Spoken Task-Oriented Dialogue Agents | 2023-05-22T13:47:51 | 2024-03-12T08:52:02 | Shuzheng Si, Wentao Ma, Haoyu Gao, Yuchuan Wu, Ting-En Lin, Yinpei Dai, Hangyu Li, Rui Yan, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Task-oriented dialogue (TOD) models have made significant progress in recent
years. However, previous studies primarily focus on datasets written by
annotators, which has resulted in a gap between academic research and
real-world spoken conversation scenarios. While several small-scale spoken TOD
datasets are proposed to address robustness issues such as ASR errors, they
ignore the unique challenges in spoken conversation. To tackle the limitations,
we introduce SpokenWOZ, a large-scale speech-text dataset for spoken TOD,
containing 8 domains, 203k turns, 5.7k dialogues and 249 hours of audios from
human-to-human spoken conversations. SpokenWOZ further incorporates common
spoken characteristics such as word-by-word processing and reasoning in spoken
language. Based on these characteristics, we present cross-turn slot and
reasoning slot detection as new challenges. We conduct experiments on various
baselines, including text-modal models, newly proposed dual-modal models, and
LLMs, e.g., ChatGPT. The results show that the current models still have
substantial room for improvement in spoken conversation, where the most
advanced dialogue state tracker only achieves 25.65% in joint goal accuracy and
the SOTA end-to-end model only correctly completes the user request in 52.1% of
dialogues. The dataset, code, and leaderboard are available:
https://spokenwoz.github.io/. | [
-0.2904467583,
-0.8081094623,
0.4614316225,
0.1535273939,
-0.0962889642,
0.0487753563,
-0.2554878294,
-0.424572587,
-0.1788941771,
0.8492020369,
-0.7608024478,
-0.435067445,
-0.4370052218,
0.0391650535,
-0.5428823829,
0.6086710691,
0.3143596053,
-0.0727184266,
-0.4961282015,
-0.2415387928,
-0.5416155457,
-0.5065826178,
-0.5321937799,
-0.586388588,
0.3141024709,
0.3194694221,
0.73893857,
0.3514715135,
0.1305996031,
0.348113656,
0.049896352,
0.2870174944,
-0.2493502796,
0.5027092695,
-0.0141078355,
-0.3130958676,
-0.8639080524,
0.0298980102,
0.4388763011,
0.8542848825,
-0.4056816399,
-0.152647987,
-0.1033210531,
0.2961153686,
-0.2930337489,
0.4106641412,
-0.6367704272,
-0.0966908261,
-0.4456525445,
0.0608700104,
-0.389490068,
-0.1556363255,
0.4912574887,
-0.6729427576,
-0.0841854364,
-0.0050909454,
0.5252261758,
0.3633954823,
-0.4545719028,
-0.2699712813,
-0.7318022251,
0.838757813,
-1.022551775,
0.5156587958,
0.3195438087,
0.3234866261,
-0.4574938118,
-0.6316173077,
-0.8798652887,
-0.2612634897,
0.474147886,
0.1475134939,
-0.4865484536,
0.0885757431,
0.447997272,
0.003994057,
-0.3526306748,
0.1329641044,
0.1678459197,
-0.1934034526,
0.6464971304,
0.5149306655,
0.3565814793,
0.007188404,
-0.3737533987,
-0.2502913773,
-0.5862505436,
0.2254559249,
0.2561690807,
0.4689607918,
-0.1346296221,
0.5991202593,
-0.4336249232,
0.9244115949,
-0.077324532,
-0.2941662669,
0.3772408366,
-0.2111205757,
-0.1054876,
-0.2773402929,
1.039360404,
0.4578851759,
0.2150817513,
-0.2597059906,
-0.1481528133,
-0.2068224549,
0.2807222605,
-0.5356696844,
-0.0138746072,
0.2152469158,
-0.1300715804,
0.1258667111,
-0.2837221026,
-0.5109233856,
-0.5328840017,
-0.23194094,
0.3332821429,
-0.3840447664,
-0.1836404949,
0.1064091772,
-0.3029607832,
0.2920584977,
0.6344560385,
-0.6359587908,
0.4029551148,
0.8227536082,
0.6475838423,
-0.3155999482,
-0.3651838899,
-0.466861248,
0.0302442349,
-0.3226213157,
0.875177145,
-0.5972548127,
-0.4621869028,
-0.0085113877,
-0.202505663,
-0.2171191275,
-0.6590577364,
0.6910879016,
-0.0713317394,
0.098235324,
-0.1624673605,
-0.4703944921,
-0.0194783863,
0.4281055629,
-0.4257751405,
1.0997511148,
0.0591198727,
-0.4644618034,
0.2394991368,
-0.5063250661,
-0.5712125301,
0.0170343295,
-0.2023741603,
-0.1969822794,
-0.1141337305,
0.1564840525,
0.350291729,
-0.623113215,
0.3848042488,
-0.1891524196,
-0.2849615812,
0.650767982,
-0.4847404063,
0.6813870668,
-0.1107849106,
-0.4073861837,
0.3319936991,
-0.8901948929,
0.247951299,
-0.0901279077,
-0.1386679709,
-0.2020614743,
0.3146641552,
-0.0394059643,
0.2374795228,
0.1893834323,
-0.9213070273,
0.051684767,
-0.3315906227,
0.6472472548,
0.4714927077,
-0.3378849328,
0.0148806134,
-0.2029911578,
0.3706001639,
-0.0779165626,
0.1982204914,
0.0555029847,
-0.7814240456,
-0.7430309653,
-0.3006551266,
0.1255097389,
0.5633508563,
-0.9756689668,
0.549808681,
-0.3371702731,
-0.5998686552,
-0.2218308449,
-0.2410990596,
0.4986994267,
0.5905020237,
0.0794361085,
-0.315099299,
-0.167162478,
-0.7777312994,
-0.2279702574,
-0.3324822783,
-0.3025899827,
0.5573729277,
0.2099197954,
-0.3030231297,
1.1409727335,
-0.2417589575,
-0.2427525967,
-0.4856495559,
0.1014335454,
0.1511045545,
0.2406797707,
0.0124095064,
-0.7176890373,
-0.488027066,
0.0791454017,
-0.4504176378,
-0.3672245443,
0.1816355735,
0.2439026535,
0.0031921407,
0.3554235399,
-0.86106354,
0.2939057946,
0.7143412828,
-0.3404181898,
0.3826411664,
-0.0573312417,
0.0928710923,
-0.7382284999,
-0.0579693876,
-0.1014622897,
-0.5239017606,
-0.9039811492,
-0.45648247,
-0.2782122195,
-0.4868276119,
-0.1456155181,
0.4835531414,
-0.1057515666,
-0.3739174008,
-0.4184853435,
0.5020502806,
-0.0933493301,
0.7294732332,
0.0611997247,
0.9433704615,
0.4857921004,
-0.5170742273,
0.6149522662,
0.5089343786,
-0.4145306349,
0.6177607775,
-0.8183785081,
0.5069797039,
0.4773452878,
0.5294786096,
-0.7232657671,
-0.1350353509,
0.1774321645,
-0.4394128919,
-0.0019415345,
-0.081957832,
-0.327929616,
-0.2610468864,
0.0339181758,
0.1563531011,
0.3066977859,
-0.3908592761,
0.9280779362,
0.7429258227,
-0.6245815754,
-0.4797444046,
-0.197747618,
0.2149581164,
0.1562191844,
-0.8491491079,
0.2894157469,
0.1415240914,
-0.2193795294,
-0.2744629979,
-0.2496854961,
-0.0905145779,
0.0062384484,
0.5443576574,
0.0982500166,
0.1278268695,
-0.0460908785,
-0.3257082105,
-0.2384570837,
-0.0725534409,
-0.2054318935,
0.7701950669,
-0.1163848341,
-0.4457382262,
-0.3522034883,
0.4396659732,
0.7259548306,
-0.193908453,
0.3302098215,
0.44991225,
-0.2268516719,
-0.3427223563,
-0.5095077157,
0.2424757481,
-0.4414286315,
0.392901659,
-0.5038481951,
-0.947660923,
0.5346393585,
-0.0417073779,
0.3376510143,
0.2176513225,
0.526668489,
-0.373457998,
1.2231820822,
0.4651492238,
-0.050913699,
0.5778023601,
0.0639136732,
0.3646875322,
-0.8129191399,
-0.3761230409,
-0.7372778654,
-0.028265262,
-0.3878509998,
-0.8331847787,
0.459857583,
-0.3973442614,
-0.0023302024,
0.4201208949,
-0.0508822687,
-0.0610816441,
0.6937568784,
-0.0917143747,
0.3121539354,
-0.4597271383,
0.130801633,
0.108460851,
-0.6607074142,
-0.4431824386,
0.8528555036,
0.3842293322,
0.7979453206,
-0.0304622538,
0.193554312,
0.4538933039,
-0.2343645245,
-0.8054989576,
0.8737650514,
-0.0997737572,
-0.485479027,
-0.7482947707,
-0.4645473361,
-0.8794301152,
0.214041397,
-0.0488944687,
-0.7679309249,
0.2184675932,
0.0637722313,
-0.149410218,
0.0021783365,
-0.5570806265,
0.8840110898,
0.0342061445,
0.048307959,
-0.2566989362,
-0.536203146,
-0.2200824171,
0.3051533103,
-0.0072705126,
-0.6160860658,
0.1789334863,
0.8321441412,
-0.6939173341,
0.8864533901,
-0.3930025399,
-0.3244166076,
0.4782061875,
-0.2402268201,
0.8041135073,
-0.2749522924,
0.0399737321,
0.24578996,
0.0022555997,
-0.3236919045,
-0.572190702,
0.3170966208,
-0.5207817554,
-0.6419926286,
-0.221661821,
-0.8575877547,
-0.8105406761,
0.0174374841,
0.1072358266,
0.9595305324,
-0.3930865526,
0.2755978405,
0.6666219831,
-0.2913974822,
0.3247781396,
0.639447391,
-0.0267806668,
-0.1590813696,
0.9639761448,
-0.0064772395,
0.2709989846,
0.1958574802,
0.003343035,
-0.1821810752,
-0.8187010884,
-0.7030475736,
-0.1863853186,
-0.4039338827,
-0.0785731822,
-0.7797961235,
-0.1068819463,
-0.3807527423,
0.2262302339,
-0.754144907,
-0.3655196726,
0.1926799268,
0.138915658,
0.1812946945,
0.5369605422,
0.2490579784,
0.2129777223,
-0.6710213423,
0.3912138343,
0.5446502566,
0.3230964541,
-0.1377333403,
-0.3763344884,
-0.2213660926,
0.1615553051,
-0.151904881,
-0.4993098676,
0.3257028461,
0.1854654849,
0.6647182107,
0.318010807,
0.2142494768,
0.4852711558,
-0.4764701426,
0.8303758502,
0.1758545786,
-1.0723714828,
0.3758508563,
-0.679333508,
0.3438366055,
0.4013645053,
-0.2122449428,
-0.7838848233,
-0.6805761456,
-0.447093606,
-0.5713838935,
0.8553242683,
0.3429165184,
0.0934229642,
0.0601257682,
-0.2658469081,
0.2866247892,
0.199307099,
-0.3911068439,
-0.0945506096,
-0.2614117265,
-0.3059064746,
-0.1317643374,
-0.0926801711,
-0.2407400608,
0.0726125464,
0.7114302516,
-0.2993938923,
0.2729029059,
0.1956989467,
-0.1174492911,
0.0432838984,
0.6030112505,
0.5018967986,
0.7213613987,
-0.2296013385,
-0.1628576815,
0.0247655101,
-0.5427641869,
-0.0182182342,
0.4717593789,
-0.2225504965,
0.0339999422,
0.3942057788,
0.9737970829,
0.251106292,
-1.2632601261,
0.5673553348,
-0.0779898688,
0.0589719079,
-0.3234339654,
0.2080010474,
-0.0572404712,
0.5686143041,
0.4747508764,
-0.0909782127,
0.2580311298,
-0.8781144023,
-0.1590097994,
0.6440515518,
-0.7086552382,
-0.2552447319,
0.2671487927,
0.7512269616,
-0.4979574382,
0.5327311754,
-0.0437070951,
-0.7291442752,
0.500066638,
0.2954111993,
0.7887818217,
0.1039650291,
0.1668007672,
-0.0767364725,
0.0273150653,
0.0157312527,
0.1576597691,
-0.3199367225,
-0.979601562,
-0.1784826219,
-0.1982106268,
-1.0129905939,
-0.151632145,
-0.6997855902,
-0.1837204099,
-0.2515402436,
-0.5996243358,
0.1871012896,
0.1629826725,
-0.3722961545,
0.1490568668,
0.1112250909,
0.7371811867,
-0.5029963851,
1.0167502165,
0.5072853565,
0.1861371696,
-0.6684850454,
0.0577399991,
-0.0214480963,
-0.7477579713,
0.1651253849,
0.0063529308,
-0.3855903745,
-0.1069470122,
-0.3079053462,
-0.5734319091,
1.0194300413,
0.0734540895,
-0.6946001649,
-0.1306486726,
0.0621495843,
0.5391472578,
-0.3621251583,
0.1078234464,
0.7466105819,
0.1404681355,
0.0217523519,
-1.2981563807,
-0.2399228662,
-0.2653644383,
-0.1732403189,
0.4099219143,
-0.8199985027,
0.8460637927,
-0.0188012887,
-0.1877570748,
0.1249829009,
0.5721006393,
0.22913526,
0.62985605,
0.8739285469,
0.5055148005,
0.7641009092,
-0.4098736942,
0.9088327885,
0.2777435482,
-0.0658144951,
1.2397046089,
-0.6905537844,
0.8265999556,
0.2313477844,
-0.2335924655,
0.4506962597,
0.1198931709,
-0.0215887073,
0.3558619618,
-0.134113282,
-0.2381774038,
-0.5143831372,
-0.3681130707,
-0.1432102174,
0.8335888982,
0.4362725616,
0.1881848574,
0.1560139209,
0.3010187745,
-0.2215009779,
0.0186753999,
-0.1030571312,
0.9662641883,
0.0100327004,
-0.7127950788,
0.1701336652,
-0.2097609639,
0.586956203,
-0.5341786742,
0.0967080221,
-0.2142441571,
0.1531079262,
0.1959231794,
-0.689027667,
-0.0999000445,
0.308385998,
-0.1522484273,
-0.2483210564,
0.8967090249,
-0.4212697148,
-0.0640975311,
0.2542522848,
0.5741622448,
0.0316585824,
-0.1211003363,
-0.4520338178,
0.2613960505,
0.078141205,
-0.0989293009,
0.2281400859,
0.5884124637,
-0.1883802563,
1.1019917727,
0.3947761059,
-0.0353353061,
-0.0222237725,
0.4448716342,
0.7347712517,
-0.8564802408,
-0.5584549308,
-0.3677220345,
0.3365395963,
-0.3301925659,
-0.4239959717,
0.8353590965,
0.399245888,
0.5987823606,
0.2167822421,
0.7338016629,
-0.2006710619,
0.9847180843,
-0.3813166022,
0.4873771071,
-0.240587309,
0.0404659547,
-0.2655097544,
-0.6850839257,
0.3758580387,
0.4366324544,
-0.2094349414,
-0.064220883,
0.1560654193,
0.469982177,
0.3170056343,
0.2096117139,
0.5564032793,
0.2758543789,
0.4750255346,
0.5784063339,
1.2687059641,
-0.3032456636,
0.7052409649,
-0.1137645319,
-0.0667637065,
-0.2208475322,
-0.4755994678,
-1.0864013433,
-0.7738385201,
-0.4500788748,
-0.114004299,
0.0581756532,
0.831852138,
0.7323919535,
-0.5952083468,
-0.2473057956,
0.0608712696,
0.1246194392,
-0.4131564498,
-0.1500103027,
-0.0782549679,
0.0331452638,
-0.8891169429,
0.729804337,
0.5499238968,
-0.1497398317,
-0.0021586553,
-0.0843289718,
0.1388836056,
0.3106975853,
0.5820168257,
0.3487558365,
-0.8859012723,
-0.3090518117,
-0.1339166015,
-0.3271656632,
0.0497307256,
1.0489830971,
-0.5977861881,
0.5238856673,
0.235345602,
0.3582957983,
0.6525620818,
0.0349184312,
1.0214312077,
-0.6690669656,
0.2043018341,
0.5602221489,
0.1677734256,
0.3983773589,
0.141895473,
0.4039917588,
0.0060046446,
-0.4375681281,
-0.9984396696,
0.0217186045,
-1.3698810339,
-0.0417571962,
0.8282114863,
-0.3626460135,
0.0694352314,
-0.5596576333,
-0.1449275911,
0.317676574,
-0.5836127996,
0.4827020764,
0.6797071695,
-0.3189189732,
-0.1569124013,
-0.5674100518,
0.5637284517,
0.3354912102,
-1.032504797,
0.6052029133,
0.6226924062,
0.0365123264,
0.1250969023,
0.7866747975,
0.1621004492,
0.3549538553,
0.314766705,
0.0311664827,
-0.1213287786,
-0.2757183611,
0.0854020566,
0.0059650782,
-0.0020066116,
-0.1413529515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13034v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13034v2 | Nearest Neighbor Machine Translation is Meta-Optimizer on Output Projection Layer | 2023-05-22T13:38:53 | 2023-10-24T10:22:05 | Ruize Gao, Zhirui Zhang, Yichao Du, Lemao Liu, Rui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Nearest Neighbor Machine Translation ($k$NN-MT) has achieved great success in
domain adaptation tasks by integrating pre-trained Neural Machine Translation
(NMT) models with domain-specific token-level retrieval. However, the reasons
underlying its success have not been thoroughly investigated. In this paper, we
comprehensively analyze $k$NN-MT through theoretical and empirical studies.
Initially, we provide new insights into the working mechanism of $k$NN-MT as an
efficient technique to implicitly execute gradient descent on the output
projection layer of NMT, indicating that it is a specific case of model
fine-tuning. Subsequently, we conduct multi-domain experiments and word-level
analysis to examine the differences in performance between $k$NN-MT and
entire-model fine-tuning. Our findings suggest that: (1) Incorporating $k$NN-MT
with adapters yields comparable translation performance to fine-tuning on
in-domain test sets, while achieving better performance on out-of-domain test
sets; (2) Fine-tuning significantly outperforms $k$NN-MT on the recall of
in-domain low-frequency words, but this gap could be bridged by optimizing the
context representations with additional adapter layers. | [
-0.6614790559,
-0.6158239841,
0.4088637829,
-0.2581710815,
-0.3838050961,
-0.1595991105,
-0.3557491899,
-0.1841219515,
-0.1255858392,
0.4042405486,
-0.3994404078,
-0.3568554819,
-0.7715264559,
0.3814490736,
-0.0221277419,
0.9289718866,
-0.0988576263,
0.0375609919,
0.08039473,
-0.1663984209,
-0.5840955377,
-0.4413457215,
-0.6108216643,
-0.3219359815,
0.5942103863,
0.4542887211,
0.7025068998,
0.8660749197,
0.8492460251,
0.3135378957,
0.0252247881,
0.2096363008,
-0.4695630968,
-0.4467337728,
-0.1249510646,
-0.6326164007,
-0.5108228922,
-0.0787402093,
0.9181678891,
0.6137822866,
0.2279315889,
0.2513781786,
0.1801487356,
1.1255404949,
-0.5053858757,
-0.0123625603,
-0.7385988832,
0.1099995002,
-0.2061330378,
-0.3264971972,
-0.3233749568,
-0.2924429476,
0.3372465968,
-0.485134542,
0.1910893619,
0.1996571422,
0.8868476748,
0.3815433979,
-0.5751148462,
-0.234465614,
-0.5966504216,
0.8176855445,
-0.8523501754,
0.5170266032,
0.3831239343,
0.4771720767,
-0.3539781272,
-0.6743089557,
-0.5522955656,
-0.274466753,
-0.0362271816,
0.1239227578,
-0.1203543618,
0.031052798,
0.0591308959,
0.452937901,
-0.3593877554,
-0.0614201762,
-0.2861785889,
-0.0707279518,
-0.068621397,
0.1701965332,
0.0469097756,
-0.3487585187,
-0.371581465,
-0.0087985573,
-0.5764748454,
-0.2292827815,
0.0432210118,
0.542817235,
0.0085598128,
0.4652628899,
-0.2240022719,
0.8291381001,
0.0741956234,
-0.0348520018,
0.170447275,
-0.3681115806,
-0.2932142913,
-0.013125564,
0.5278075337,
0.6617372632,
0.3052587211,
-0.299108386,
-0.3316183686,
-0.2424107194,
0.3406511843,
-0.9510546923,
-0.2997440398,
-0.2807229757,
-0.8303298354,
-0.2096711546,
-0.084890008,
-0.5036138296,
0.0745785981,
-0.5678759813,
0.8029034734,
-0.5872493386,
-0.3623819351,
-0.1080772728,
-0.0465688519,
0.1179215983,
-0.1207024008,
-0.493845433,
0.3089751005,
0.8013957143,
1.3375879526,
-0.2674674988,
-0.3784680665,
-0.4072932005,
-0.0895317793,
-0.5539534092,
0.4795230925,
-0.5307489038,
-0.1074948087,
-0.1433514953,
0.1228447929,
-0.5239556432,
-0.8425554633,
0.4109956622,
-0.7518748045,
0.1863286793,
-0.4545471072,
-0.4783649147,
-0.2265538424,
0.1937108338,
-0.4374656975,
0.838278234,
0.2763333321,
-0.7853718996,
0.4100457132,
-0.9607265592,
-0.2260015607,
-0.3721864522,
0.5022473931,
-0.3459129632,
0.6246430874,
0.1121443734,
0.4916909039,
-0.1996965855,
-0.1674038917,
-0.1082090437,
-0.5487366915,
0.1479599327,
-0.1894668341,
0.1752300113,
0.2790264189,
-0.2504894435,
-0.0308463294,
-0.7273468971,
-0.1257128268,
0.1307533383,
-0.3004239798,
-0.527798295,
-0.2259444743,
-0.2547543347,
0.5243867636,
0.0178276785,
-0.4428451955,
0.1000195667,
-0.598936975,
0.5643706918,
0.7605080605,
-0.0129909115,
0.809238553,
-0.3385142386,
0.4013688266,
0.1172129661,
0.0632761046,
-0.0348820426,
-0.3327313364,
-0.607180059,
0.0695132613,
0.8508893251,
0.2451576144,
-1.0555733442,
-0.0840369239,
-0.5818060637,
-0.1438338608,
-0.6622219086,
-0.1789470613,
0.5476346016,
0.7689374089,
0.2812227607,
-0.2273867875,
-0.200037837,
-1.081273675,
-0.3821786642,
0.330893755,
0.0141326683,
0.3295108974,
0.5527128577,
-0.1252518743,
0.6333011389,
-0.3747698367,
-0.5006930232,
0.0566490851,
-0.0333385617,
0.4672629535,
0.4062148929,
0.6246689558,
-0.746301353,
-0.8846864104,
0.4861504436,
-0.3149797618,
0.0231947806,
0.0954233035,
-0.383754164,
0.1038070992,
0.2956333756,
-0.265131712,
0.2082745433,
0.723336637,
0.2054690123,
0.4159677327,
-0.3618178368,
0.2202484906,
-1.1308883429,
0.1000364423,
-0.3146123588,
-0.3318017721,
-0.8279319406,
0.3269371986,
0.189997524,
0.1371106058,
-0.3241564035,
0.1712841839,
-0.3819266856,
-0.216763854,
-0.7437261343,
0.3848918378,
-0.2824636996,
0.6259262562,
-0.168179661,
0.951238811,
0.1503070295,
-0.9662242532,
-0.1187412888,
-0.0067086429,
-0.2091789395,
0.6175879836,
-0.4170458317,
0.5444638133,
-0.0213178955,
0.0021116091,
-0.7173268199,
-0.0408278108,
0.2879312336,
-0.5622951388,
0.2622564733,
-0.3346141875,
-0.574205339,
-0.3147214055,
-0.1291096658,
0.2868686318,
0.3727473021,
-0.6506465077,
0.4540278912,
0.0932190567,
0.1399184912,
-0.3501729965,
-0.699642241,
0.0245177597,
-0.2053907663,
-0.5037353635,
0.425288707,
0.0904156491,
0.188898474,
-0.0431083962,
-0.286154449,
-0.0628781393,
-0.0265922751,
0.0614251159,
-0.0265767556,
-0.6756343246,
-0.1988321543,
0.1470136642,
-0.39293769,
0.0333707444,
-0.7108038068,
0.5186721683,
-0.1709118038,
-0.07366056,
-0.3965647221,
0.1029437259,
0.3946977854,
0.0074950461,
0.9980534315,
0.7776207924,
-0.2449094802,
-0.176368475,
-0.2464545816,
-0.0660360754,
-0.5152102113,
0.6386523247,
-0.8584993482,
-0.8379876018,
0.447339654,
-0.5898951292,
-0.1050669476,
0.5906504393,
0.4582166076,
-0.0187984165,
0.9999540448,
0.695070982,
-0.0342531092,
0.4472978115,
-0.2207320333,
0.2625868917,
-1.3233271837,
-0.0248692986,
-0.4656720459,
-0.7570493221,
-0.6375699043,
-0.6048431993,
0.3699792922,
0.2629445493,
0.0181874987,
0.5791245103,
-0.5478846431,
0.5518711209,
0.7152072787,
0.0572402552,
0.195524931,
0.0028432014,
-0.5379818678,
-0.4194587469,
-0.8432122469,
-0.375261575,
0.9362034798,
0.200230822,
-0.0590086766,
0.1253281236,
0.4553538263,
0.1552128345,
0.2986501455,
-0.5724537373,
0.4377501309,
-0.3950885236,
-0.3908147216,
-0.0320883803,
-0.7019277215,
-0.746970892,
0.3531488776,
0.0986493677,
-0.3184352517,
0.0613956526,
0.2198432386,
0.0419654213,
0.5002273917,
-0.7794145346,
0.9075048566,
0.1592331976,
0.1240929067,
-0.1812028587,
-0.7783769965,
0.1942233592,
-0.4924509525,
0.1483983845,
0.0868364349,
-0.1178237945,
0.4229051769,
-0.2129297704,
0.359236002,
-0.2321127653,
-0.0355197899,
0.0467069931,
0.4343785644,
0.6118181944,
-0.3215210736,
-0.2553789914,
0.3122369051,
-0.1897374243,
-0.3973783553,
-0.7417699695,
0.8825342059,
-0.5824471712,
-0.3198401928,
-0.0029546777,
-0.5406675935,
-0.1927132905,
0.5727000237,
0.3781611919,
0.4543386698,
-0.0114900125,
0.2979018986,
0.4543245733,
-0.2547782063,
0.3782136738,
0.4955813885,
-0.3512836099,
-0.5774973631,
1.250330925,
0.1475472152,
0.739510715,
0.837893486,
0.4722040892,
0.0075749275,
-0.870661974,
-0.6081947088,
0.0914799646,
-0.5839517713,
-0.3511125743,
-0.4952121675,
-0.0673452169,
-0.0787403435,
0.025434142,
-0.4316177368,
-0.4152520597,
0.0920139477,
0.0466060415,
0.1259994954,
0.7686610818,
-0.1259945184,
0.6469773054,
-0.6774215698,
0.4191533923,
-0.0789737999,
0.4333230257,
0.160413146,
-0.899492383,
-0.6740497947,
0.1869930178,
-0.2661297619,
-0.558737278,
0.2037447989,
0.3815153837,
0.1091319025,
0.3686267138,
0.0079113944,
0.8713104725,
-0.8203675151,
0.6202065349,
-0.1041018963,
-0.864422977,
0.3170488775,
-0.3598462045,
0.5860690475,
0.5026755929,
0.3341661394,
-0.4522206783,
-0.1726161838,
-0.1718859076,
-0.513266921,
0.9621531963,
0.396607846,
0.2309808284,
0.0035877393,
0.5950222015,
0.1600269228,
0.1894143075,
-0.3537374735,
-0.4905427694,
-0.0819779411,
0.1392481923,
-0.0524056181,
-0.1540650278,
0.2683280706,
-0.236799702,
0.5753512383,
-0.1750738025,
0.6431089044,
0.2515704334,
-0.1967284381,
-0.216450572,
-0.118721813,
0.9348587394,
0.5114506483,
-0.3653520048,
0.1151796952,
0.520706892,
-0.4356508851,
-0.4247200787,
-0.3720959723,
-0.1674024016,
0.253898263,
0.3233007193,
0.7491713166,
0.2446133196,
0.081256628,
0.4521303773,
0.0755232424,
-0.4972933233,
0.2599802613,
-0.1677941084,
0.0456634462,
0.1456972659,
0.213634178,
0.5682786703,
0.1990730166,
-0.3014977574,
0.2899706066,
0.3279599249,
-0.4268385768,
-0.5170935392,
0.6739392281,
-0.1466515213,
-0.6200946569,
0.4639223516,
-0.1231130287,
-0.8365930319,
0.4230475426,
0.8471915126,
0.8056257963,
-0.2010207921,
-0.0778300539,
0.4172863662,
0.4456548393,
0.1301099658,
-0.1104937866,
-0.0813831761,
-0.2721357942,
-0.5599735379,
-0.5877071023,
-0.0561549291,
-0.1759849638,
-0.5079275966,
-0.0006899461,
-0.2512028813,
-0.4190222025,
-0.1980601102,
-0.0665699244,
-0.5897300839,
0.1782016009,
-0.1707759202,
0.8099765778,
-0.2878839672,
0.8991928697,
0.6052911282,
-0.1266557723,
-0.622102201,
0.3096892834,
-0.3851957619,
-0.7942020893,
0.8128417134,
0.0844792426,
-0.2969298065,
0.0790442005,
-0.1590599269,
-0.8597151637,
0.9874922037,
0.4021847248,
-0.5127049685,
-0.0400762036,
0.536172986,
0.5525587797,
-0.4682291448,
0.0101209758,
0.464050889,
0.4727661014,
-0.1612236202,
-1.1248614788,
0.0095859859,
-0.0639371425,
0.4088678956,
0.6580123305,
-0.6680285931,
0.6214667559,
0.0434402637,
0.0365254916,
0.1500688046,
0.6642533541,
-0.2826680541,
0.4801979065,
0.4097011089,
0.2723330557,
0.3575713933,
-0.022253463,
1.1434876919,
-0.3687361181,
0.3061797321,
1.0163240433,
0.2910631895,
0.9589195848,
0.4787924886,
-0.2022552788,
0.3386453688,
0.2979246378,
0.1731134802,
0.8792448044,
0.2526481152,
0.1476383507,
0.0479076803,
-0.1266527772,
-0.5469096303,
0.1800641716,
0.0449181423,
-0.7206242085,
0.0638789311,
0.0720740557,
-0.1924246699,
0.0221012887,
-0.4021575153,
0.7537528872,
0.4327823222,
-0.4534788132,
0.6900849938,
0.2458297759,
0.555958271,
-0.3264704049,
-0.0292839985,
-0.149439171,
0.3915654719,
-0.0572913475,
-0.2230828553,
0.5184793472,
-0.2397885472,
-0.2720796764,
-0.0735324845,
0.8240992427,
-0.0861957893,
-0.2798897624,
0.2880198658,
0.3357672691,
0.2069126964,
-0.3997878134,
-0.7015635967,
-0.1799197793,
-0.0271213148,
-0.0952562764,
0.6276023984,
0.9160385132,
0.2156680524,
0.4861781001,
0.7694988847,
0.120268248,
0.355496347,
-0.119834125,
0.7349082232,
-0.6509388089,
-0.2169950306,
-0.868821919,
0.1422116011,
0.0868470222,
-0.3570007384,
0.9515343308,
0.6102443337,
0.8849707842,
-0.2777840793,
0.0836036652,
0.2689943612,
0.4043717086,
-0.5306118727,
0.5507960916,
-0.6969910264,
-0.04734236,
-0.554058671,
-1.3086488247,
-0.2802439332,
0.4313962758,
-0.3239307702,
0.1014709547,
0.8446193337,
0.6702754498,
-0.3354846537,
-0.0609045066,
0.6241725683,
0.016117638,
-0.1570714563,
0.6266668439,
0.7422248721,
-0.783182025,
0.719050467,
-0.4362514019,
0.1087153181,
-0.1599577069,
-0.9535464644,
-1.0749217272,
-0.5858742595,
-0.1779210716,
-0.3268128932,
0.0572691709,
0.7763583064,
0.6636964083,
-0.7728488445,
0.1954761744,
-0.0728020519,
0.0310869459,
-0.3082185388,
-0.1828159988,
0.4744679928,
-0.2392842025,
-0.748539567,
0.3054668605,
0.3177349865,
-0.3231950998,
0.2757624686,
-0.3200834095,
0.0740007013,
-0.1100989878,
0.5733947754,
-0.2924441099,
-0.5969137549,
-0.0446455441,
0.1451491714,
0.0042961678,
0.3331722319,
0.9214429855,
-0.4890535176,
0.4294568896,
0.3668642938,
0.9431855679,
0.2932644486,
0.0171706416,
0.7909051776,
-0.6723765135,
-0.3077920377,
-0.0800242946,
-0.0879115462,
0.1599708349,
-0.1907514781,
0.4523496628,
0.1094964147,
-0.8219502568,
-0.8171849251,
0.0464137606,
-0.443008095,
-0.0566252545,
0.9358775616,
-0.0009968042,
-0.3104487658,
0.0296737179,
-0.2554388344,
0.377214402,
-0.1946315467,
0.5839136839,
0.7379453182,
0.0991599336,
-0.0041721622,
-1.0891127586,
0.4824418426,
0.6769533753,
-0.1551377177,
-0.1218059584,
-0.0747931078,
0.3123066425,
0.1647512913,
0.3264353871,
-0.0707334653,
0.0782324374,
-0.2109769285,
-0.4840353131,
-0.318605125,
-0.2273265123,
-0.4130682647,
0.122085765,
0.0935726166,
-0.573679924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13026v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13026v2 | DUMB: A Benchmark for Smart Evaluation of Dutch Models | 2023-05-22T13:27:37 | 2023-10-13T10:43:05 | Wietse de Vries, Martijn Wieling, Malvina Nissim | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce the Dutch Model Benchmark: DUMB. The benchmark includes a
diverse set of datasets for low-, medium- and high-resource tasks. The total
set of nine tasks includes four tasks that were previously not available in
Dutch. Instead of relying on a mean score across tasks, we propose Relative
Error Reduction (RER), which compares the DUMB performance of language models
to a strong baseline which can be referred to in the future even when assessing
different sets of language models. Through a comparison of 14 pre-trained
language models (mono- and multi-lingual, of varying sizes), we assess the
internal consistency of the benchmark tasks, as well as the factors that likely
enable high performance. Our results indicate that current Dutch monolingual
models under-perform and suggest training larger Dutch models with other
architectures and pre-training objectives. At present, the highest performance
is achieved by DeBERTaV3 (large), XLM-R (large) and mDeBERTaV3 (base). In
addition to highlighting best strategies for training larger Dutch models, DUMB
will foster further research on Dutch. A public leaderboard is available at
https://dumbench.nl. | [
-0.4781864583,
-0.4435233474,
-0.1123566628,
0.3918188512,
0.01356705,
-0.3030426204,
-0.6337231994,
-0.4622312188,
0.2509485185,
0.4696444869,
-0.3127308786,
-0.2977379262,
-0.4769817293,
0.3473488986,
-0.4272035658,
0.924257338,
-0.0364259481,
0.3093118668,
-0.5149395466,
-0.3480978906,
-0.6489956975,
-0.3880028129,
-0.2152879685,
-0.3887568414,
0.7305935621,
0.6426405311,
0.578132093,
0.4835005999,
0.8458044529,
0.3649700284,
0.0027233183,
-0.1123568267,
-0.722189188,
0.1507876515,
-0.3296632767,
-0.4058894515,
-0.6198021173,
0.0515032075,
0.3701595664,
0.9384104609,
-0.0243316423,
0.4393363595,
-0.0400817394,
0.6496906281,
-0.8606568575,
0.4478469789,
-0.3918441832,
-0.1132167205,
-0.365660131,
0.0957554877,
-0.2601362765,
-0.4699214995,
0.2850824893,
-0.5206831694,
0.1576408297,
0.1327618659,
1.0489523411,
0.096694231,
-0.2844815552,
0.1577077806,
-0.444257021,
1.0864297152,
-0.4914388061,
0.347388953,
0.5532189012,
0.5213298798,
0.0705561861,
-0.5741975904,
-0.5782395005,
-0.1362944245,
0.2685856223,
0.3376759291,
-0.0112979049,
-0.0781206861,
0.242298767,
0.1953653246,
-0.4099359512,
-0.0364320613,
-0.5989335179,
-0.1306093484,
0.5201225281,
0.1102501377,
-0.0675963461,
-0.3522222936,
-0.1208269224,
-0.4250472188,
-0.5367596745,
-0.1601472497,
0.4596818089,
0.4611754417,
-0.2624262571,
0.6910374761,
-0.3806990087,
0.6073715687,
-0.370989114,
-0.1448025405,
0.3791025877,
-0.3089062274,
-0.0260755531,
-0.0714747459,
0.4663894176,
0.3434790075,
0.9718550444,
-0.1575073898,
-0.6751492023,
0.1623318642,
0.3379200399,
-0.7041914463,
-0.667549789,
-0.2321825325,
-0.4044004083,
0.0054401834,
-0.2278884351,
-0.2538435757,
-0.0772185475,
-0.5842873454,
0.5260059834,
-0.4131001532,
-0.2116346955,
0.335106492,
-0.1793853939,
-0.0483335927,
0.4265405238,
-0.4896641374,
0.5452229381,
0.5794004798,
0.4439436197,
-0.116521515,
-0.3534393609,
-0.1553597301,
0.0144223198,
-0.4708459973,
0.8786647916,
-0.1830834001,
-0.2036818117,
0.0168027766,
-0.4001043737,
0.0434435271,
-0.8074610829,
0.4792143703,
-0.5407544374,
0.2822253108,
-0.647510469,
-0.4042292535,
-0.3922529221,
0.4824092686,
-0.7756354213,
1.1131777763,
0.1582238376,
-0.9239603281,
0.7353727818,
-0.5962005854,
-0.3239600062,
-0.1688827723,
0.0737585127,
-0.2073437274,
0.2424416691,
0.11475081,
0.4164287448,
-0.656842649,
0.0737286657,
-0.6895239949,
-0.5171355605,
0.0145829339,
-0.3552639484,
0.7494705915,
0.0512279309,
0.1821743846,
0.02691276,
-0.9471849799,
0.2158126831,
0.2338278294,
-0.4862542748,
-0.6256170869,
-0.1075797081,
0.536038518,
0.4235981107,
0.3679279685,
-0.3900041282,
0.1166254282,
-0.4371993542,
-0.0076942691,
0.6698839068,
-0.4455821812,
-0.0461604744,
-0.3193202615,
0.348417908,
0.1296187639,
0.1911425292,
0.1210219413,
-0.3116019964,
-1.0572315454,
-0.4825200737,
0.9145397544,
0.7598999739,
-0.7630235553,
0.486731112,
-0.9076033831,
-0.3062838912,
-0.4624419808,
0.3011237383,
0.6057960987,
0.5582716465,
0.3265751898,
-0.7324473262,
-0.5175385475,
-1.2679284811,
-0.259534508,
-0.3002220988,
-0.0172567889,
-0.009442619,
0.7341784239,
0.0790663958,
1.0617084503,
-0.0053881118,
-0.2339637727,
-0.350679487,
0.355628401,
0.3072779477,
0.4610201716,
0.6007546186,
-0.6118257046,
-0.4707311988,
-0.0988498554,
-0.8128101826,
-0.1256369054,
0.4674322009,
0.1925510913,
0.0030657717,
0.3916973472,
-0.3897906244,
0.3135071993,
0.4140534401,
-0.013850905,
0.6530461311,
-0.317435354,
0.0276140124,
-0.7319437265,
0.2665592432,
-0.05999339,
-0.170058161,
-0.2694465518,
-0.2837577164,
0.2670071125,
0.027951505,
-0.5508887768,
0.8467307091,
-0.3548753262,
-0.3283900619,
-0.1967272609,
-0.0222662482,
-0.0596737973,
0.4869635403,
-0.2144491076,
0.7293941379,
0.5824061632,
-0.3840585649,
0.178824693,
0.22918199,
-0.8999122381,
0.6510388255,
-0.8002354503,
0.0032277254,
-0.1140408739,
-0.0524664707,
-0.7634170055,
-0.2068543583,
-0.1381971389,
-0.0854160488,
0.3732747138,
0.1156004593,
-1.0074877739,
-0.7244778872,
-0.1936198026,
0.5082403421,
0.4011856616,
-0.2205126137,
0.4788151085,
0.3590553403,
-0.3076661527,
-0.746946156,
-0.8583464622,
-0.0051662498,
-0.0387186147,
-0.744113028,
0.1078777388,
0.2301711142,
-0.3593663871,
0.0802760422,
-0.3309440017,
-0.3237476647,
-0.0337771624,
-0.126400575,
0.0067252722,
-0.314932704,
0.0232052077,
-0.3022790849,
-0.2453977317,
-0.1303201914,
0.0185713042,
0.1335507184,
-0.2381448001,
-0.1987702101,
-0.3487849832,
0.1446142495,
0.5874062777,
-0.1993921399,
0.5210815072,
0.158812061,
-0.3774040639,
-0.1523708552,
-0.8410590291,
-0.2721147239,
-0.4334715605,
0.5782551765,
-0.6281315088,
-0.3194358051,
0.7462697029,
0.1390177011,
0.1823620498,
0.1567595154,
0.4040137529,
-0.00184055,
0.9667739868,
0.9278600812,
-0.0067020697,
0.383534044,
-0.092769891,
0.2237266451,
-0.2247142792,
0.0229824763,
-0.5542468429,
-0.4325937331,
-0.3998843133,
-0.4288310409,
0.2943865657,
0.3529216647,
-0.4000132382,
0.5673786998,
-0.0855065435,
0.3793060482,
0.7313996553,
-0.2149614841,
0.1186948344,
-0.0964720771,
-0.4226056635,
-0.2490257919,
-1.1133775711,
-0.6084096432,
1.2174224854,
0.1036514789,
0.7231212854,
-0.1150912121,
0.518717885,
0.0860567987,
0.5765053034,
-0.6049875617,
0.7673526406,
-0.2226070017,
-0.8493432999,
-0.0572144724,
-0.5948209167,
-0.9146985412,
0.3709720075,
-0.0896394402,
-0.3122835457,
0.0429087617,
0.3504473269,
-0.125961408,
-0.0346883908,
-1.0545451641,
1.1255362034,
-0.2559719086,
-0.2870597243,
-0.3977901042,
-0.4860636294,
0.4675222337,
-0.1920525432,
0.0174431,
-0.3725808859,
-0.1044932604,
0.9442451,
-0.3786633909,
0.6799380779,
-0.209195137,
0.216611743,
0.0941364244,
0.0121492743,
0.4855128825,
-0.2405885309,
-0.3220259547,
0.4394504726,
-0.0855725855,
-0.6980480552,
-0.4081167579,
0.6936126947,
-0.7030332088,
-0.3169033229,
-0.3019404709,
-0.6500046253,
-0.4988887608,
0.2945230901,
-0.098860383,
0.3426063657,
-0.172483936,
0.272369206,
0.4666015208,
-0.2367133498,
0.2649286985,
0.6911196709,
-0.0856582373,
-0.1616227627,
0.7611963749,
0.4175406098,
-0.0338556133,
0.3901135027,
0.1791201085,
-0.2891128659,
-0.6366656423,
0.0431117937,
0.0863809362,
-1.0117651224,
-0.1377685964,
-0.7226732373,
0.3173705339,
-0.3669937849,
-0.0459336005,
-0.9031584859,
-0.5631458759,
0.2275122255,
0.0923876092,
0.2326235771,
0.4247840643,
-0.1485716552,
0.1272395402,
-0.4097847939,
0.3675091863,
0.3764520586,
0.515732646,
-0.1666799933,
-0.3432824314,
-0.3787906468,
-0.3348018229,
-0.0309358444,
-0.299798429,
0.202045843,
-0.0343686566,
0.4388462007,
0.3602050841,
0.1686036289,
0.8335882425,
-0.6282347441,
0.3463172913,
0.3617697954,
-0.829800725,
0.3080833554,
-0.3741830587,
0.5296450853,
0.9677007198,
0.135656327,
-0.3573258817,
-0.2310189754,
-0.5395988822,
-1.0694235563,
0.641078949,
0.021356836,
-0.0448086038,
-0.2321161479,
-0.025413679,
0.2263147086,
0.3504295647,
-0.7293336987,
-0.1502740383,
-0.1792461425,
-0.147671774,
0.068713069,
-0.2247830778,
-0.0952853784,
-0.3575462401,
0.6316443682,
-0.106571421,
0.2003438622,
-0.3137274683,
-0.2349888831,
0.0665337816,
-0.0956025943,
0.375760287,
1.0011954308,
-0.3522821069,
-0.0256090742,
0.3855302036,
-0.3158575296,
-0.2828941643,
-0.0252367668,
0.1248284727,
-0.0170246698,
0.4941627383,
0.5416151285,
0.7374105453,
-0.8231890798,
0.6811651587,
-0.0470045581,
-0.0325791687,
-0.2520697415,
-0.0652405545,
-0.0813729465,
-0.1577631831,
0.0197551139,
0.3344459236,
-0.1439438909,
-0.1749031991,
0.2612131536,
0.1658471078,
-0.4270600379,
-0.4685954154,
0.4610278606,
0.4458346665,
0.0746951997,
0.6920256615,
-0.1564334631,
-0.2858645618,
0.5415343642,
0.0709949359,
0.7184686661,
0.0074240696,
-0.2823808789,
0.2747294009,
0.4848684967,
-0.4753416181,
0.7415450811,
0.1058438495,
-0.5823230147,
-0.8542030454,
-0.4984484315,
-0.4137766063,
0.142081961,
-0.7292659283,
0.5049574375,
-0.1604956836,
-0.0554676577,
-0.0359457545,
0.094932586,
-1.1233881712,
0.2682763338,
-0.1065838262,
1.1744316816,
-0.6175743341,
1.1400316954,
0.7821310163,
-0.1970777512,
-0.3476344049,
-0.2066633701,
-0.0232857335,
-0.7061030269,
1.0874511003,
0.2964801192,
0.0245838463,
-0.4248148203,
-0.2174184024,
-0.8846241236,
0.4418039918,
0.6151435375,
-0.5787001252,
0.0924780592,
0.0139412293,
0.5258564949,
0.1807557344,
0.4022582173,
0.2576057911,
0.8287032843,
-0.4391681552,
-1.2472090721,
-0.3894472718,
-0.4027570784,
0.1857229173,
0.1433917284,
-0.5334631205,
0.9224933982,
0.0787775666,
-0.1553695202,
0.1125224084,
1.0325901508,
0.1561590135,
-0.0639806986,
0.458820641,
0.5985535383,
0.585025847,
-0.3021788895,
1.441087842,
-0.5521510243,
0.2486201972,
0.969627142,
-0.6177759171,
0.8089790344,
0.621422112,
0.0094117746,
0.1182995364,
0.3137484491,
0.166347757,
0.6623197794,
0.6479939818,
0.2254888266,
-0.3755280972,
0.1456147134,
-0.3290373981,
0.6805815101,
0.1413088441,
0.3225557804,
-0.4054915905,
0.2429461926,
-0.0440817773,
0.1416692287,
-0.329338342,
0.3150886893,
-0.0911085308,
-0.7196884751,
0.6770145297,
0.1056373939,
0.9293504953,
-0.7773686647,
0.2247037441,
-0.1871491373,
0.6565033793,
0.3803372681,
-0.4977004528,
0.2892695963,
-0.1364420652,
-0.5075685978,
-0.4937680066,
0.5877156258,
-0.223723188,
-0.5792400241,
0.4535965621,
0.7294357419,
0.2534738779,
0.0577089302,
-0.9998682737,
-0.1025740281,
-0.5159602165,
-0.5777921081,
0.3042680919,
0.6661551595,
-0.4686570168,
0.9133344293,
0.3591293395,
0.2423314452,
0.032054659,
0.255736351,
0.502651751,
-0.7012657523,
-0.6228612661,
-0.1876091361,
0.3191264868,
-0.1700715721,
-0.8286162019,
0.9511362314,
0.6699047685,
1.3274592161,
-0.274549067,
0.642942667,
0.0251207612,
0.7532602549,
-0.1287847161,
0.6064527631,
-0.5522833467,
0.0272089783,
-0.1676619202,
-1.0758339167,
-0.3280548751,
0.6833151579,
-0.6210549474,
0.2697710991,
0.5929472446,
0.7342671156,
-0.4559364319,
-0.0637950525,
0.5082629323,
0.1969434172,
-0.0051553473,
0.3322012424,
0.7231225967,
-0.4327116311,
0.5945631862,
-0.5569068193,
-0.0245475806,
-0.3899752498,
-1.0137985945,
-0.9918915033,
-0.2264090627,
-0.6112917066,
-0.0512800403,
0.3950818777,
0.7490670085,
0.9263468385,
-1.1501744986,
-0.5211207867,
0.0746055543,
-0.1069922149,
-0.8079462051,
-0.2159576267,
0.3420012891,
-0.3560794592,
-0.7187247872,
0.4663431346,
0.396147728,
-0.2164451629,
-0.2529007494,
0.0234678946,
-0.2083500624,
0.2533601224,
0.5319266319,
0.4246095121,
-0.5257006288,
-0.2969352603,
-0.2044832408,
-0.3137607872,
-0.1367007494,
0.8013644814,
-0.8108595014,
0.5551755428,
0.7766437531,
0.5430060029,
0.4048738182,
-0.4996911585,
0.6610490084,
-0.882650733,
0.4072967768,
0.4885297716,
0.5298384428,
0.4087019563,
0.4631638825,
0.6093167067,
0.1932425797,
-0.3275332451,
-0.9586177468,
-0.1821898222,
-0.8875520229,
-0.3617391586,
0.8707672954,
-0.1751281321,
-0.3373551667,
-0.5663354397,
0.2375402302,
-0.0032983655,
-0.1807068288,
0.9990611672,
0.9640194178,
0.1493238211,
0.2331512272,
-1.0129369497,
0.2376657724,
0.9302411675,
-0.5793378353,
0.2099760026,
0.3145394325,
0.1471690834,
0.2729241848,
0.40243119,
-0.1843689233,
0.4650020003,
0.0708379596,
0.5943119526,
-0.0405972935,
-0.5639400482,
0.1512956172,
0.3043470681,
-0.2402631789,
-0.1218089536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13016v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13016v3 | Iterative Forward Tuning Boosts In-Context Learning in Language Models | 2023-05-22T13:18:17 | 2024-06-04T05:49:01 | Jiaxi Yang, Binyuan Hui, Min Yang, Bailin Wang, Bowen Li, Binhua Li, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the advancements in in-context learning (ICL) for large language
models (LLMs), current research centers on specific prompt engineering, such as
demonstration selection, with the expectation that a single iteration of
demonstrations processing can generalize effectively to a given test sample.
However, this perspective overlooks the potential benefits derived from
multiple iterations involving demonstrations, a practice aligning more closely
with the iterative decision-making process exhibited by humans, who often learn
through analogy. In this study, we introduce a novel two-stage framework to
boost ICL in LLMs. Specifically, our framework delineates the ICL process into
two distinct stages: Deep-Thinking and test stages. The Deep-Thinking stage
incorporates a unique attention mechanism, i.e., iterative enhanced attention,
which enables multiple rounds of information accumulation. This mechanism
operates by manipulating the Key-Value matrices without training, fostering
enhanced understanding capabilities in LLMs by thinking demonstrations multiple
times. We evaluated Deep-Thinking across a range of benchmarks and LLMs,
showing its superior performance over vanilla ICL methods and its effectiveness
in challenging tasks where demonstration selection is infeasible. | [
-0.5134292245,
-0.7950893641,
0.5264819264,
0.5022634268,
-0.3158726692,
0.2365416884,
-0.5593054295,
-0.145974189,
-0.489323169,
0.0641374663,
-0.7773280144,
-0.5255542994,
-0.2563028336,
-0.0801124349,
-0.2911897004,
0.7824586034,
-0.1169777811,
0.0011758881,
-0.1385061145,
0.1376301944,
-0.6904626489,
0.0137183079,
-0.9760143161,
-0.5474998951,
0.3402032852,
0.8014601469,
0.2436050773,
0.4849324822,
0.0718730837,
0.1916482896,
-0.0449017957,
-0.0189215951,
-0.498121649,
0.2121333927,
-0.3099323809,
-0.2139406353,
0.0301377233,
0.0228053704,
0.7760719061,
0.7270789742,
-0.0339915529,
0.1459514946,
0.2667377293,
0.7030246258,
-0.6496542692,
0.190724194,
-0.9654215574,
-0.0235001538,
0.0027666721,
-0.1771962643,
-0.4591970742,
-0.1758942008,
0.1134735718,
-0.3993547261,
0.0046045273,
-0.1030346975,
0.5471871495,
0.2625749409,
-0.1257737875,
-0.189540267,
-0.541379571,
0.6408107281,
-0.626927495,
0.6171754003,
0.2656132281,
0.3613670468,
-0.0397790298,
-0.6427207589,
-0.5087069273,
-0.4720688462,
0.1795392483,
-0.0022095195,
0.1984733045,
-0.036718078,
0.2861997783,
0.3715876937,
-0.3995477259,
0.474124074,
-0.2433783412,
-0.0982191041,
0.262190789,
-0.0181350037,
-0.1020380259,
0.4052437842,
-0.3652867377,
-0.2437015176,
-0.9809753895,
0.35213691,
-0.1258004159,
0.4926626086,
0.0650169402,
0.2102817446,
-0.3884516656,
0.5902760029,
0.3626657724,
-0.0425348394,
0.2206537575,
-0.2212785333,
-0.3064440489,
0.0963129327,
0.4410140514,
0.0617446601,
0.2585855722,
-0.2256023586,
-0.2025638521,
0.1484717727,
0.181021601,
-0.8834130764,
-0.0336991288,
0.2225177586,
-0.2142093182,
-0.0750995278,
-0.1003658175,
-0.7125046849,
-0.3566004932,
-0.3909768462,
0.4999515414,
-0.4144816399,
-0.2630759478,
0.2257204652,
0.0787605047,
0.3008094728,
0.1880380809,
-0.7184386253,
0.2630391121,
0.8160665035,
0.6554091573,
-0.1844605953,
-0.5228469372,
-0.8225459456,
0.0339345708,
-0.525041759,
0.7798548937,
-0.7416765094,
-0.2631826103,
-0.056079831,
-0.3146810532,
-0.1513029039,
-0.5281623006,
0.5134163499,
-0.5730133653,
0.1501205713,
-0.1326613277,
-0.5640326738,
-0.14391765,
0.3591287732,
-0.303568989,
1.1135234833,
-0.0391937941,
-0.5908583999,
0.6515479684,
-0.6940646768,
-0.7777596712,
0.0174577031,
-0.321828723,
-0.3405377269,
0.2000739723,
0.2843806744,
0.5649995208,
-0.3134410977,
0.2773160338,
-0.3622621596,
-0.5721313357,
0.1746781021,
-0.2575170994,
0.3775414228,
0.1421682239,
-0.794023931,
0.3630150259,
-0.7139528394,
0.2165290266,
-0.1196186021,
-0.3641678393,
-0.1745439768,
-0.0459339842,
-0.371560514,
0.6355458498,
-0.2524701357,
-0.3409619629,
0.2166461349,
-0.7200174332,
0.4305242598,
0.7013620138,
-0.0474791415,
0.5940985084,
-0.0295208339,
0.393283695,
0.2223272175,
0.0363131091,
-0.5907424688,
-0.2298324704,
-0.9586308002,
-0.126899302,
0.0688834116,
0.426559329,
-0.6559540033,
0.1336409599,
-0.0234300848,
-0.2473962009,
-0.7196325064,
0.1226950288,
0.5453835726,
0.6986290216,
0.3802499473,
-0.0743678063,
-0.3014312088,
-0.7998518348,
-0.2569050491,
0.009097469,
0.0830468163,
0.1587548554,
0.5769078135,
-0.0703979209,
0.5176552534,
-0.1898664683,
-0.2901721299,
-0.2055274695,
0.1569386572,
0.1658566147,
0.5224072337,
0.2153216302,
-0.6170201898,
-0.5208873153,
0.0785029605,
-0.3030871749,
0.1054297015,
-0.3093380928,
-0.0938584581,
0.1685070992,
0.6437790394,
-0.3901926577,
0.3786432445,
0.079377681,
-0.330294013,
0.2493311465,
-0.1884485483,
0.0883355066,
-0.804013133,
0.0215565041,
-0.0019154157,
-0.0098821353,
-0.5322508812,
0.2205220014,
0.3930813372,
0.0330300704,
-0.3210648,
0.8284754157,
-0.5451077819,
-0.2306042612,
-0.400303632,
0.3008864224,
-0.1642009318,
0.5876963139,
0.0177578311,
1.0003688335,
0.9390514493,
-0.8381438851,
-0.2226702571,
0.1392278373,
-0.6469901204,
0.3071624637,
-0.2779345214,
0.4070854187,
-0.1265882105,
0.1257691681,
-1.1018925905,
-0.0532854535,
0.0323708095,
-0.3567821085,
0.5266398191,
0.2481615245,
-0.3675755262,
-0.4237983823,
-0.4236310422,
0.1795711815,
0.4210898578,
-0.7677156925,
0.3452573717,
0.0730768293,
-0.266649127,
-0.6578293443,
-0.5909288526,
0.0472058915,
-0.369633913,
-0.27023229,
0.3767593503,
-0.2537742555,
-0.4065535367,
-0.3440733552,
-0.1862169802,
0.082209304,
0.4767290354,
0.0248709805,
-0.1464729309,
-0.0954108462,
0.412558943,
0.3208072484,
-0.1384003609,
-0.0898092464,
-0.5837293863,
0.4705610871,
-0.1842205226,
-0.3768016398,
-0.5266937613,
0.4918839931,
0.496881038,
-0.4348529577,
0.3459870517,
0.4389077723,
-0.2086703032,
-0.5718066692,
-0.4975095093,
-0.4086188972,
-0.4451210797,
0.3920974135,
-0.6478996873,
-1.0138477087,
0.3636167645,
-0.3846367896,
0.2408258021,
0.1397437304,
0.6909466386,
-0.0006821289,
1.2707358599,
0.7511758804,
-0.0749563798,
0.5478246808,
-0.1528780907,
0.0991658643,
-0.9069576263,
-0.2008440793,
-0.4902031124,
-0.2503379583,
-0.1781437397,
-0.442856133,
0.3297992647,
0.3794310391,
-0.5871542096,
-0.2144755423,
-0.2370561212,
0.6888546348,
0.4015693069,
0.1813874841,
0.3156454563,
0.0244197566,
-0.5311889648,
-0.0404744186,
-0.6250744462,
-0.3092089295,
0.791082561,
0.2705741227,
0.5843407512,
-0.2023065239,
0.3954643309,
-0.1308727562,
0.5270497799,
-0.806302309,
0.4363645017,
-0.0084783118,
-0.3496271968,
-0.2372506857,
-0.0333183296,
-0.6272518635,
0.347114414,
0.0261995643,
-0.893355906,
-0.0007542133,
0.3033407629,
-0.4677863121,
0.0952938572,
-0.4720336497,
0.6982467771,
-0.2645086646,
-0.622046113,
-0.7730244398,
-0.696618259,
0.2969577312,
-0.07371898,
0.260121882,
0.1340540648,
0.0706425756,
0.2653284371,
0.1753632724,
0.761736691,
-0.2451348305,
-0.3543796241,
0.11393933,
0.2248470634,
0.553745091,
0.3656992316,
-0.2277210653,
-0.2601721883,
-0.6111425757,
-0.1926368773,
-0.5739686489,
0.7613447309,
-0.2725567818,
-0.7852807641,
0.0090655442,
-0.5245304704,
-0.5915207267,
0.1587005854,
0.129354313,
0.4372596145,
-0.040091306,
0.2257138044,
0.8714876771,
-0.2076322287,
0.5254764557,
0.5378664732,
-0.2593269944,
-0.2938378453,
0.6883274317,
-0.2309861332,
0.5415337086,
0.4784237444,
0.2193896323,
-0.2790323198,
-0.8023619652,
-0.3840381503,
0.0683232024,
-0.9053273797,
-0.1063204482,
-0.626160264,
0.096287787,
-0.2472871095,
-0.1208642051,
-0.3930179477,
-0.2012096643,
-0.1745940447,
-0.2709689438,
-0.0087775514,
0.5025303364,
0.0056517897,
0.1325481981,
-0.3080166876,
0.1822037548,
0.4253002107,
0.5008825064,
0.3039384186,
-0.4764812589,
-0.3378029764,
0.0144842798,
-0.381229341,
-0.4921363592,
0.0909690931,
0.417596966,
0.6512807608,
0.4420914352,
-0.2013956159,
0.940171361,
-0.5051643848,
0.6270439625,
-0.1596748829,
-1.0723649263,
0.6242960691,
-0.1340632141,
0.5955209732,
0.7723934054,
0.2597959042,
-0.4679878652,
-0.4563720822,
-0.2558268309,
-0.8332335353,
0.678296268,
-0.0650360137,
0.020316327,
-0.0048084958,
0.4677661657,
0.4090649486,
0.3208679855,
-0.5655469298,
-0.0439320356,
-0.033068981,
0.0271107107,
-0.2165462226,
-0.0888005197,
-0.1137185171,
-0.6385753751,
0.7583861351,
-0.634013772,
0.171070531,
0.0815569907,
-0.3360620141,
-0.1457569301,
0.4449960887,
0.774905026,
0.7677834034,
0.0898040161,
0.0564375967,
0.4123352766,
-0.0048024273,
-0.0224301834,
0.0827344209,
-0.0797972381,
-0.3738290071,
0.274217844,
1.2238374949,
0.6583470702,
-0.6760115027,
0.3700946867,
-0.0630697086,
-0.0722187161,
-0.1147440746,
0.0501431823,
0.1174669042,
0.5994384289,
0.4148298204,
-0.0344781429,
0.1735357791,
-0.696731925,
0.3601884246,
0.4744880199,
-0.4883836806,
-0.3861517906,
0.680550158,
0.0798358023,
-0.3046426773,
0.6452303529,
-0.1931763142,
-0.5677158237,
0.5651341677,
0.8015788794,
1.1495535374,
-0.0803803131,
0.1589688361,
0.4313065112,
0.0286884475,
-0.1552022249,
0.4790878594,
-0.5697847605,
-0.6246247888,
-0.7451903224,
-0.4315350652,
-0.1753263772,
0.2584946752,
-0.5642260313,
0.2331065685,
-0.3826929331,
0.2313452065,
-0.1330391169,
-0.0526624247,
-0.6379426122,
0.2262264341,
0.3390415609,
1.2896813154,
-0.576223135,
1.0889847279,
0.6376922727,
-0.0815286264,
-0.8138167262,
0.4975357056,
-0.2268866003,
-0.6846146584,
0.9021297097,
0.6118958592,
-0.2311393768,
0.3398857713,
-0.4561284184,
-0.7237059474,
1.0188113451,
0.3626865149,
-0.7292345166,
0.0193396639,
-0.3970222473,
0.4134388566,
-0.6275187135,
0.243353948,
0.7543460131,
0.4877845943,
0.2156862617,
-0.9132301211,
-0.0445614606,
-0.0852761716,
-0.0520375445,
0.1118559539,
-0.6597377062,
0.81161654,
-0.6168669462,
-0.4210364521,
0.0999747738,
0.665869534,
0.4233566225,
0.2126653492,
0.6199207306,
0.4406685829,
0.7031908631,
-0.1008993536,
0.9705191851,
-0.2659843862,
0.1878612638,
1.2601248026,
-0.3871610463,
0.8029052615,
0.5819440484,
0.0823410675,
0.5285763144,
0.7505167127,
0.3933407962,
0.8021016717,
0.23824884,
-0.1208129823,
-0.4845753908,
0.1075233743,
-0.3181352019,
0.3891412914,
0.5385198593,
-0.1689234078,
-0.2783554196,
0.3228203952,
-0.0424143858,
0.2549889088,
-0.4940465987,
0.9495182037,
0.0893345624,
-1.0394387245,
0.5936545134,
-0.2908388674,
0.6506279111,
-0.4950069487,
-0.1356378794,
-0.2448081523,
0.4938122332,
0.2141714841,
-0.8679772019,
0.0267431289,
-0.1410240829,
-0.1181498393,
-0.5558820963,
0.5904096961,
-0.5408568382,
-0.2428493351,
0.4355634451,
0.2177399993,
-0.2204137594,
-0.1532157362,
-0.6840368509,
-0.0126206148,
0.0023367514,
-0.417757839,
0.3973675668,
0.323500067,
-0.2584586143,
0.9089682102,
0.3174930215,
-0.1524792761,
-0.0928341374,
0.3723219037,
1.0596222878,
-0.6457281709,
-0.600626111,
-1.0200115442,
0.6744586825,
-0.1843413562,
-0.4677375555,
0.6457852125,
0.4289688766,
1.1234394312,
-0.0026414553,
0.8084369302,
0.3656001389,
0.4643937945,
-0.6304772496,
0.3231815398,
-0.4941794574,
0.2304450125,
-0.2219680548,
-0.6066188812,
-0.372553736,
0.6504781842,
-0.2295622826,
-0.0242823176,
0.8255161047,
0.6839853525,
0.0313107371,
0.0626845434,
0.2512556016,
0.2913576961,
0.4000315666,
0.6951406598,
1.003898859,
-0.1347583681,
0.1381081492,
-0.3157792985,
-0.1555567682,
-0.0110954503,
-0.8544414043,
-1.1168652773,
-0.5845174193,
-0.1749437898,
-0.1218604967,
0.0261033196,
1.1767135859,
0.7468671203,
-0.8399013877,
-0.2773223221,
-0.3409370184,
0.1304880232,
-0.5482341051,
-0.1948590428,
0.250962913,
-0.7436612844,
-0.6754776835,
0.8369264603,
0.5730472207,
-0.2309208214,
-0.4370235503,
-0.0454093777,
-0.2428455651,
-0.1666869223,
0.6710047126,
0.1754819006,
-0.7445267439,
-0.2352172881,
-0.0654209629,
0.1393032223,
0.1261465549,
1.0410624743,
-1.2168308496,
0.5091782212,
0.3451633751,
0.7715235353,
0.615580678,
-0.2227831185,
0.6313088536,
-0.7820700407,
0.4292840064,
0.2506304681,
0.0896956772,
0.34328565,
-0.3467891812,
0.2899376452,
-0.162077859,
-0.4409469068,
-0.8289121389,
0.5103638768,
-0.5354253054,
-0.5493971109,
1.0880230665,
0.066239059,
0.0781525299,
0.0393008478,
-0.3092409074,
0.1828207225,
-0.4575491846,
0.9440595508,
0.5201764703,
-0.0725182444,
-0.2402473539,
-0.4450892806,
0.6285952926,
0.4883817136,
-0.8293286562,
0.2351235598,
0.2384496182,
0.2502078712,
-0.1025827527,
0.4416377544,
0.0586909913,
0.2475111932,
-0.3919930756,
-0.3173264563,
-0.0411208086,
-0.610186398,
-0.6274587512,
0.2405195534,
0.2565712333,
0.0113211991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13015v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13015v2 | 3D Rotation and Translation for Hyperbolic Knowledge Graph Embedding | 2023-05-22T13:17:23 | 2024-02-03T06:35:31 | Yihua Zhu, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | The main objective of Knowledge Graph (KG) embeddings is to learn
low-dimensional representations of entities and relations, enabling the
prediction of missing facts. A significant challenge in achieving better KG
embeddings lies in capturing relation patterns, including symmetry,
antisymmetry, inversion, commutative composition, non-commutative composition,
hierarchy, and multiplicity. This study introduces a novel model called 3H-TH
(3D Rotation and Translation in Hyperbolic space) that captures these relation
patterns simultaneously. In contrast, previous attempts have not achieved
satisfactory performance across all the mentioned properties at the same time.
The experimental results demonstrate that the new model outperforms existing
state-of-the-art models in terms of accuracy, hierarchy property, and other
relation patterns in low-dimensional space, meanwhile performing similarly in
high-dimensional space. | [
-0.3285900652,
-0.8866328001,
0.7099317312,
0.0325445272,
-0.431491226,
-0.172630772,
0.4337077439,
-0.5053946376,
0.5127685666,
0.3897275031,
-0.2396219075,
-0.8340644836,
-0.7475492954,
-0.103772752,
-0.211737588,
0.645506084,
-0.3079130948,
-0.107982792,
-0.2826023102,
-0.3008500934,
-0.2428260446,
-0.4673363566,
0.0143829416,
-0.4660562873,
0.4201709926,
0.4180368781,
1.2460486889,
1.2797999382,
0.5152385235,
0.1528742015,
0.0346403942,
0.1757057905,
-0.5209192038,
-0.0397679992,
0.2475703061,
-0.257496953,
-0.5769770741,
0.2347207367,
0.7060380578,
0.9520787001,
-0.2471065372,
-0.1416627765,
0.06297189,
0.7028266788,
-0.6262046099,
0.7104154229,
-0.1309348345,
0.0801746175,
-0.2015866786,
-0.0922286287,
-0.0131944986,
-0.7206148505,
0.1354374141,
-1.3499326706,
0.0763816163,
0.2657154202,
0.6793553233,
0.1433531642,
-0.725843966,
-0.2924263775,
-0.6644586921,
0.4391158819,
-0.4352347553,
0.8374589682,
0.3825458884,
0.5296248794,
-0.0083523793,
-0.5519108772,
-0.8026227355,
0.3067103326,
-0.0409496948,
0.2077497542,
-0.1457036734,
-0.2233991176,
-0.0110865328,
0.372055918,
-0.267701894,
-0.2685355544,
-0.2117436081,
-0.1277044564,
0.2718059421,
0.3316919804,
0.1312090456,
-0.5772167444,
-0.5378440022,
-0.3825737536,
-0.9092746377,
-0.2963927984,
0.3454944491,
0.142038554,
-0.3580208719,
0.8988339901,
-0.0026934498,
0.8742403388,
-0.2540525496,
-0.3451684117,
0.3845369518,
-0.0363101549,
-0.0190728586,
-0.1701141,
0.5988670588,
0.6332486272,
0.0632149428,
-0.2150333375,
0.1281275004,
-0.1492139995,
-0.0307342354,
-0.7915946245,
-0.3008880317,
-0.1566429883,
-0.6360269785,
-0.2661674619,
0.0906037688,
-0.6640332937,
-0.5768637657,
-0.2942039371,
0.2997654378,
-0.703542769,
-0.6034528613,
0.4029912651,
-0.2271341383,
0.2527230978,
0.3041557372,
-0.6756519079,
0.0234931596,
0.6843085289,
0.9693787694,
-0.4162870944,
-0.4405127466,
-0.1808138192,
0.8515611887,
-0.2203425616,
0.4786407053,
-0.6013267636,
-0.4069292247,
0.1896426827,
-0.4606916606,
-0.1058835238,
-0.3106040061,
-0.0760241449,
-0.8891427517,
0.016815573,
-0.3888038695,
-0.8187196851,
-0.4644613862,
0.5901616812,
-0.8608682156,
0.7277446985,
0.5089876056,
-0.7409309149,
0.1892196685,
-0.5401648283,
-0.2255364209,
-0.048370149,
-0.1904963106,
-0.4900768101,
-0.1545553803,
0.2198349088,
0.5443664193,
-0.4365986586,
-0.1139960587,
-0.6211413145,
-0.1677203327,
-0.0872736424,
0.1638737172,
0.6903118491,
0.0506989062,
0.1389394701,
-0.2982376814,
-0.6561295986,
-0.1596062183,
0.1795679629,
-0.4316719472,
-0.5296835899,
-0.206085816,
-0.2582059503,
0.3336191773,
0.2919977009,
-0.6754109859,
0.4729405046,
-0.249281168,
0.1190505177,
0.3983219266,
0.322378993,
0.4743694365,
-0.2576477826,
0.5279753804,
0.5434239507,
0.021580413,
0.293877691,
-0.9474611282,
-0.1764443815,
-0.2339846939,
-0.0270797256,
0.2824074328,
-1.1277743578,
0.2991352975,
-0.7129788995,
-0.6484071612,
-0.2547641695,
0.2754412293,
0.4371722341,
0.5114020109,
0.5787682533,
0.0248832293,
-0.2725577354,
-0.7244047523,
-0.2523422837,
-0.2547087371,
0.3392045796,
0.1752149165,
0.5787161589,
-0.3652704358,
0.7091553807,
-0.9263597727,
-0.5665946007,
-0.2239190191,
0.0540363193,
0.1885317862,
0.3361676931,
0.7776665688,
-0.7175000906,
-0.6484219432,
0.2736591697,
-1.0163528919,
0.5119007826,
0.6188752651,
-0.4051614404,
-0.0738833919,
0.4477991164,
-0.8608247638,
0.5493847132,
0.5763272643,
-0.3419257104,
0.026365744,
0.0390401743,
-0.0324153788,
-1.3234277964,
-0.1569513083,
-0.0844260603,
-0.1722763777,
-0.507812202,
0.009512092,
0.3055659831,
-0.1954316944,
-0.5613372922,
0.3807421923,
-0.2851416469,
-0.0067478959,
-0.0678461567,
0.3327788711,
-0.1028938666,
0.8049641252,
0.0966731161,
0.1822336763,
0.4508681595,
-0.9642648697,
0.4188533127,
0.5918380618,
-0.4896481037,
0.7819076777,
-0.4401650131,
0.1620324701,
-0.0642019957,
0.114333719,
-0.7695325613,
-0.3545992076,
0.3614531457,
-0.2768061757,
0.15965496,
-0.2858605087,
-0.6530191898,
-0.4661866128,
-0.3615455031,
0.693285048,
0.36022982,
-0.5399340987,
0.7551413774,
0.7090568542,
0.3005979359,
-0.4714946151,
-0.256126076,
-0.5353764892,
-0.1158742011,
-0.4612387717,
0.5561472178,
0.4078068733,
0.1181436628,
0.4324713647,
-0.2071439326,
0.1896134019,
-0.2225404233,
0.0841234028,
0.190628618,
-0.1540941596,
-0.1476852745,
0.0036525528,
-0.2151881754,
-0.0207511056,
-0.6049155593,
0.5484006405,
0.0214605555,
-0.5790547132,
-0.6568795443,
0.2384544015,
1.2290349007,
0.0676555112,
0.8511129022,
0.4583386779,
-0.6934543252,
0.3869614303,
-0.4025373459,
0.1564823091,
-0.4016540051,
0.6309854388,
-0.3977662027,
-0.5300424695,
0.5863056183,
0.012439169,
-0.1193943098,
0.5176459551,
0.4067800045,
-0.2731675804,
1.3402780294,
0.7449875474,
-0.1664679348,
0.2276965231,
-0.6806483865,
0.4364999831,
-0.957541883,
-0.5965184569,
-0.3755058348,
-0.4072323442,
-0.7550553083,
-0.2759755552,
0.8986491561,
0.3428345919,
-0.4764880538,
0.4674635231,
-0.1848374009,
0.2232218087,
0.4035397172,
0.0459268913,
0.4224059582,
0.1939038783,
-0.3947159052,
-0.2431160361,
-0.7222633362,
-0.2856934369,
0.9850429893,
0.2433561385,
0.6043292284,
0.5947585702,
0.6951471567,
-0.1308445036,
0.5373183489,
-0.8188308477,
0.2455088198,
0.0097863125,
-0.45832932,
-0.4504925311,
-0.5316801667,
-0.8476436138,
0.4517302811,
0.005196502,
-0.3767405748,
0.3970708251,
0.2957303822,
-0.1774246544,
0.7423095107,
-0.4548315406,
0.6895605326,
0.1999237388,
-0.08954864,
-0.2057151198,
-0.4101535678,
0.3163720071,
0.0531612337,
0.2634200752,
0.0130153736,
0.2253007591,
0.9060280323,
-0.4399321377,
0.6755927801,
-0.6997932196,
-0.1866341233,
0.2299241275,
0.4863066375,
0.7453943491,
0.0835116506,
-0.0545290671,
-0.004857291,
0.1073581576,
-0.3165254295,
-0.9179815054,
0.6507630348,
-1.3413161039,
-0.6610626578,
-0.2775375843,
-0.8443526626,
-0.5385068655,
0.376090914,
0.0374716185,
-0.0229106937,
-0.2137683779,
0.4473080635,
0.3356784582,
0.0868124515,
0.1117117554,
0.4037485421,
-0.631451726,
-0.5545786619,
1.0410300493,
0.1368993968,
0.0746765062,
0.3775683641,
0.2063730657,
-0.4789999425,
-0.3153805733,
-0.279255718,
0.5053827763,
-0.7989147902,
-0.6084462404,
-0.8267980814,
-0.1999914348,
-0.4409754872,
0.0619308613,
-0.5639124513,
-0.7536984086,
-0.052178327,
-0.175603047,
0.3881833553,
1.1575827599,
-0.0609437376,
0.4686138034,
-0.7305514812,
0.7244701982,
0.5608872175,
0.3152779043,
0.1021505073,
-0.2325412929,
-0.5336219668,
0.2714504898,
-0.8045467734,
-0.9984968901,
0.3270403743,
-0.1885255575,
0.5134992003,
0.4962259829,
-0.310844779,
0.7871983051,
-0.1320458204,
0.4142372012,
0.4387974143,
-0.7955216765,
0.3187421858,
-0.5455793738,
0.0778403953,
0.0810605735,
0.6498634219,
-0.4920782447,
-0.1093565822,
-0.3851603568,
-0.5593082309,
0.5987261534,
0.2870642543,
-0.0312192682,
-0.1258661449,
0.4627004266,
-0.02727459,
0.3046753407,
-0.5826990008,
-0.4280840158,
-0.7399475574,
-0.0980936438,
0.2692596018,
-0.1628310531,
-0.1766259968,
-0.6543591619,
0.534093976,
-0.0091627082,
0.544929564,
-0.0697769821,
-0.1423362046,
-0.2385738194,
-0.3666503131,
0.3551178873,
0.552233994,
-0.2421336323,
0.2429738194,
-0.0518851578,
-0.6316050291,
0.2125627995,
0.0199009832,
0.0010106448,
-0.1601667702,
0.4793388546,
0.6090151668,
0.1105202436,
0.4540341496,
0.670928359,
0.4619761705,
-0.2763584256,
0.1160525531,
-0.0813162923,
0.348282516,
0.0553328618,
0.2203098238,
0.1459222138,
-0.2101587355,
-0.4347887635,
-0.2033733279,
0.1649220586,
-0.4696033597,
-0.483932972,
0.6115130782,
-0.023580987,
-0.078501083,
0.9110383391,
-0.2663346827,
-0.5258299708,
0.425228864,
0.8638663888,
0.3981323242,
-0.3902551234,
0.2507447302,
0.4015281796,
0.0492922217,
-0.0342556871,
0.562174201,
-0.0561536141,
-1.1401212215,
0.0476076975,
-0.3921767771,
-0.3575229645,
-0.0434986763,
-0.8857340217,
0.2469615042,
-0.2874086499,
-0.103848286,
-0.2266220599,
-0.2948236167,
-1.0062043667,
-0.187293604,
-0.2926944196,
0.6683112383,
-0.775793314,
1.1603933573,
0.6936004758,
-0.3041966259,
-0.5949350595,
-0.0895837098,
0.0120631624,
-1.0003526211,
0.6207585335,
0.1298002154,
-0.5043003559,
0.2860552073,
-0.4739363492,
-1.1417784691,
1.4878658056,
0.574513793,
-0.2267813087,
-0.2674306035,
0.5077023506,
0.3890917003,
-0.5553862453,
-0.4864938557,
0.5283694863,
0.6342620254,
0.1573396027,
-0.4300236702,
-0.0434149578,
-0.288883239,
0.1514928192,
0.1927423775,
-0.5649289489,
0.6757813096,
-0.0741646215,
-0.2040228397,
-0.2858727872,
0.7999654412,
0.4663887322,
-0.0074680476,
0.3224122524,
0.9653935432,
0.8293629885,
-0.0591751039,
1.2752648592,
-0.5481122732,
0.4184081554,
0.7723751068,
-0.3556102514,
0.6048623323,
0.6142503619,
-0.042959597,
0.5053853989,
0.1017630845,
0.3149963319,
0.8723506927,
-0.096419163,
0.216935873,
-0.2191542834,
0.0994555727,
-0.7697024345,
0.5140783787,
0.7880747318,
-0.0055707255,
-0.207474187,
-0.0367519744,
0.1015246212,
-0.0707818642,
-0.0918711498,
0.5311434865,
0.0969936848,
-0.574755013,
0.5909769535,
0.1461468637,
0.1438816935,
-0.29374367,
-0.2478821725,
-0.1242185757,
0.1792268157,
0.001945946,
-0.8483282328,
0.3950569332,
-0.6595047116,
-0.008250596,
-0.3191258609,
0.1754154712,
-0.1694975197,
-0.3873794079,
0.519041419,
0.7969813347,
-0.2734836042,
0.0664817244,
-0.2351103425,
-0.1695146561,
-0.2207689583,
-0.2939932942,
-0.1475538313,
0.8139240742,
-0.0533415489,
0.5717627406,
0.4789050221,
0.0215882584,
0.1624327004,
-0.0470455699,
0.8920307755,
-0.7031564713,
-0.6350435019,
-0.7768333554,
0.1127893776,
0.0670195371,
-0.3255360126,
0.7181692719,
0.6720967293,
0.7595347166,
-0.0755589753,
0.5880615115,
0.1183081269,
0.2219316363,
-0.6723458767,
0.7338155508,
-0.3585856259,
0.0888203084,
-0.4560419321,
-1.1589015722,
-0.73662889,
0.6566736698,
-0.1272275448,
0.078274183,
1.0232594013,
0.7027631998,
-0.3550434113,
0.2413205653,
0.3952779472,
0.2133501768,
0.4349229634,
0.607734859,
0.9243958592,
-0.6028710604,
0.6034932137,
-0.3004490435,
-0.0444202945,
-0.1997184902,
-0.6058850884,
-0.9236184359,
-0.9144998789,
-0.2619711161,
-0.4418928325,
-0.2313985378,
0.6461138129,
0.6842275262,
-0.5495766997,
-0.1285144985,
-0.05233505,
0.4153841436,
-0.3980745077,
-0.1589892209,
0.7885945439,
0.2915049195,
-0.4556227922,
0.056807708,
0.3395625949,
0.4267851114,
-0.2038972825,
-0.3944846988,
-0.1182788387,
-0.2661726475,
0.6112319827,
0.0879691914,
-0.4478752315,
-0.4123782516,
0.0577042736,
-0.2232264131,
0.1641948521,
1.0289750099,
-0.5371188521,
0.3337739706,
0.6161287427,
0.4963374138,
0.9396073222,
-0.2049680501,
0.6268390417,
-0.661429882,
0.0066228565,
-0.0773067027,
0.4968302548,
0.3216718435,
-0.3336458802,
0.3207059801,
0.4692786336,
-0.0068494272,
-0.4783530831,
0.3754335344,
-0.6457424164,
0.0911177546,
1.0295722485,
-0.02921593,
-0.1769056022,
-0.3900050223,
0.272174865,
0.774549365,
-0.0027564573,
0.8833458424,
0.8580620885,
-0.3440827429,
0.1943425834,
-0.4834644198,
0.4412671626,
0.0218968373,
-0.476202935,
-0.0213965401,
0.2671291828,
0.0545764454,
0.4316242337,
0.4278525412,
-0.7266462445,
0.4094913006,
-0.3222776353,
-0.1179004908,
-0.4541515708,
-0.5229057074,
0.310978055,
0.5384850502,
-0.0341448709,
-0.2521202862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13014v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13014v4 | Can Large Language Models emulate an inductive Thematic Analysis of semi-structured interviews? An exploration and provocation on the limits of the approach and the model | 2023-05-22T13:16:07 | 2023-12-11T08:52:35 | Stefano De Paoli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful generative Artificial
Intelligence solutions which can be applied to several fields and areas of
work. This paper presents results and reflection of an experiment done to use
the model GPT 3.5-Turbo to emulate some aspects of an inductive Thematic
Analysis. Previous research on this subject has largely worked on conducting
deductive analysis. Thematic Analysis is a qualitative method for analysis
commonly used in social sciences and it is based on interpretations made by the
human analyst(s) and the identification of explicit and latent meanings in
qualitative data. Attempting an analysis based on human interpretation with an
LLM clearly is a provocation but also a way to learn something about how these
systems can or cannot be used in qualitative research. The paper presents the
motivations for attempting this emulation, it reflects on how the six steps to
a Thematic Analysis proposed by Braun and Clarke can at least partially be
reproduced with the LLM and it also reflects on what are the outputs produced
by the model. The paper used two existing datasets of open access
semi-structured interviews, previously analysed with Thematic Analysis by other
researchers. It used the previously produced analysis (and the related themes)
to compare with the results produced by the LLM. The results show that the
model can infer at least partially some of the main Themes. The objective of
the paper is not to replace human analysts in qualitative analysis but to learn
if some elements of LLM data manipulation can to an extent be of support for
qualitative research. | [
-0.2542286813,
-0.9253361821,
0.8617892861,
0.0203399267,
-0.3395386934,
0.2220572084,
-0.4414631426,
-0.4662426412,
0.1714993864,
0.4393955469,
-0.6913115978,
-0.5699403882,
-0.1924659759,
0.267711252,
-0.7567622066,
0.9794555306,
-0.0141179971,
0.124931857,
-0.097406067,
-0.0490442105,
-0.4630847871,
-0.4857006669,
-0.500952363,
-0.4017753303,
0.4297039211,
0.3677437007,
0.5768146515,
0.2350197583,
0.5419718027,
0.2758007944,
-0.1045310348,
-0.2054745257,
-0.6855531335,
0.028862372,
-0.3144655526,
-0.5357470512,
-0.0247055851,
0.3824433386,
0.7461810708,
0.6565059423,
-0.3453789651,
0.2903036177,
0.1940164119,
0.0525038838,
-0.0951404274,
0.3196099102,
-0.8415170312,
0.0954867154,
-0.1078889295,
-0.2760569155,
-0.4828614295,
-0.3879109323,
-0.1856044233,
-0.2053873688,
0.144410193,
-0.100512445,
0.6119232774,
0.0879587084,
-0.2292777449,
-0.2722039521,
-1.4078940153,
0.8350173235,
-0.930783987,
-0.1794923842,
0.1856757253,
0.3940494657,
-0.183582291,
-0.7686779499,
-0.7826265097,
-0.2621403635,
-0.1041864529,
0.1002311632,
-0.0661085099,
-0.0607985631,
0.330073595,
0.3899505734,
-0.399323374,
0.4151383638,
-0.525485456,
0.3612680435,
0.640568018,
0.5820993781,
0.2945942879,
-0.1778604239,
-0.1941894442,
0.1981974542,
-0.8959315419,
-0.1825555861,
0.2217589468,
0.2976286113,
-0.0259080995,
0.7834357619,
-0.1086510643,
0.5405030251,
-0.0242736749,
-0.207202211,
0.0210329872,
-0.3707236052,
-0.2710532248,
0.1105087101,
0.9520924091,
0.2051604688,
0.4907707572,
-0.1790115684,
-0.1223687753,
0.0023292145,
0.3551073372,
-0.6408218741,
0.0103348009,
0.2794410586,
-0.3868565857,
-0.2673546076,
0.0269826502,
-0.9033063054,
-0.3659603596,
-0.4599236846,
-0.0057799215,
-0.3635762334,
-0.2094691545,
0.0681320578,
0.1979420036,
0.7166699767,
0.35786286,
-0.6589782834,
0.1505330652,
0.8581212759,
0.8281925917,
-0.0478936955,
-0.3029462993,
-0.1416773349,
0.1989077777,
-0.2333222032,
0.6795932651,
-1.0004132986,
-0.5265859365,
0.1883199364,
-0.0669310912,
0.0498951972,
-0.5084759593,
0.4395234883,
-0.376332581,
0.1612003595,
0.0663136542,
-0.5529421568,
-0.1818101406,
0.2016076297,
-0.5150027871,
1.0279662609,
0.221043393,
-0.6238740087,
0.1570320278,
-0.4786050618,
0.0043593426,
0.250079155,
-0.6704285145,
-0.2413097918,
0.3931952119,
-0.1744452268,
0.4994255304,
-0.7793646455,
0.6796118021,
-0.5517004132,
-0.5585069656,
0.3781683743,
-0.1089494377,
0.9049793482,
0.0138480673,
-0.499984175,
0.0546616875,
-0.7415424585,
-0.017668603,
0.3443846107,
-0.1225071624,
-0.3890023232,
0.125929594,
-0.0672069415,
0.3460532427,
-0.4192166328,
-0.748708725,
0.2823429704,
-0.3618730009,
0.4531432986,
0.5210133195,
0.1085955054,
0.2198789269,
-0.2581083775,
0.8482036591,
-0.1523545831,
-0.2361755222,
-0.06006651,
-0.3511392176,
-0.6120133996,
-0.3656401038,
0.3268379867,
0.4234352112,
-0.7831125855,
0.4112103581,
-0.4507990181,
-0.5775688887,
-0.6128792763,
0.1584633887,
0.0482350588,
0.1934086531,
0.0124978758,
-0.3584363759,
-0.5773136616,
-0.7942841053,
-0.2265506536,
-0.2033431679,
-0.1872830093,
0.0155474115,
0.7589054108,
0.125463903,
1.2060798407,
-0.24427782,
-0.1741428822,
-0.5057439208,
0.587369144,
0.4496215284,
0.4444589913,
0.5453702211,
-0.501132369,
-0.3125230074,
-0.0863989592,
-1.058458209,
-0.203777194,
-0.2116062641,
0.1792833209,
-0.3477301598,
0.5666690469,
-0.7763226032,
0.5046736002,
0.217923373,
-0.2989734411,
0.5864248872,
0.0891719833,
-0.1761673838,
-1.0088657141,
0.0267286319,
0.1885359138,
0.0437279604,
-0.7821782231,
0.417719245,
-0.3228777945,
-0.2170680761,
-0.4968588054,
0.5100916624,
-0.3425984085,
0.001179889,
-0.2188958377,
-0.0692118108,
-0.2125291675,
0.4338139296,
0.0152856568,
0.632969141,
0.1554871202,
-0.2669315934,
0.3700555563,
0.162525773,
-0.7697433829,
0.606161356,
-0.7426896095,
0.4353901446,
-0.3665525615,
0.2865159214,
-1.2811337709,
-0.0680754259,
0.250012964,
-0.1786329001,
0.3274236917,
-0.0134010157,
-0.7800488472,
-0.3019345999,
-0.4407176077,
0.5251085162,
0.5698437691,
-0.2308154702,
0.7152203918,
0.2480923086,
-0.5336295962,
0.0391935557,
-0.5495721102,
0.1949401945,
-0.8636989594,
-0.289681077,
0.067151241,
-0.0047538262,
-0.7278060317,
-0.2064353526,
0.3825153112,
0.0756139457,
0.230305478,
0.1700892746,
0.344195962,
-0.2585272193,
-0.0982015654,
-0.2186463922,
0.0218970701,
0.3404043615,
-0.2530288994,
0.535990417,
0.0641085953,
-0.5169585943,
-0.5822372437,
0.4136864245,
0.6218475699,
-0.3982292414,
0.7060235143,
0.6329587102,
-0.2238964438,
0.0295562074,
-0.661111176,
-0.179928422,
-0.4146150947,
0.2304499894,
-0.3253172934,
-0.984598577,
0.5427766442,
-0.1129731983,
-0.0500692725,
0.5757943988,
0.9152049422,
-0.2606846094,
0.8121115565,
0.4583509266,
-0.1889417171,
0.3741383255,
-0.4158285558,
0.3144450486,
-0.8665531278,
-0.3260499835,
-0.7981624603,
-0.4400854409,
-0.7600141168,
-0.4692343771,
0.4308004081,
-0.2332181782,
-0.2499808669,
-0.2251344919,
-0.1007580608,
0.2917853892,
0.3323816061,
-0.0636075735,
0.3667525649,
0.126381278,
-0.0505227149,
-0.1447379291,
-0.5588243008,
-0.5344745517,
0.8112267256,
0.4429264963,
1.0939228535,
0.0402253009,
0.5715475678,
0.2273928672,
0.5276238322,
-0.905941546,
0.7234617472,
0.1819972843,
-0.5201732516,
-0.3857463896,
-0.2162663639,
-0.8605061173,
0.2933345735,
-0.0411597155,
-1.0752218962,
0.2437837869,
-0.5389688015,
-0.2836802304,
0.2846064866,
-0.4065216184,
0.4510054588,
-0.0248579718,
-0.5043782592,
-0.1611292511,
-0.474624604,
0.5713208914,
-0.2277472317,
0.2463113666,
-0.1123234704,
0.4644703269,
0.7408011556,
-0.0941016898,
1.289532423,
-0.1744259596,
-0.3440835774,
0.6621143222,
0.2883052528,
0.5207721591,
-0.1335445046,
-0.1940672398,
0.0184225421,
-0.0171440504,
-0.2378412932,
-0.8607515693,
0.5442714095,
-0.5966900587,
-1.0656282902,
-0.4118224382,
-0.71753335,
-0.2119470835,
-0.0350629538,
-0.498272419,
0.4189997315,
-0.2841780186,
0.5202978253,
0.3314512074,
-0.2640278935,
0.3224500418,
0.580373168,
-0.3706146181,
0.1048248559,
0.5448124409,
0.0818109587,
0.200908199,
0.2430908233,
0.4161230028,
-0.1319598854,
-0.7246644497,
-0.24742347,
0.4085611999,
-0.5144991875,
-0.0830798075,
-0.4946552813,
-0.2211802751,
-0.2327089012,
0.1761280447,
0.0209738594,
-0.2861894071,
-0.1451789141,
-0.3581171334,
0.336233288,
0.9945605993,
0.2707996368,
0.2949071825,
-0.6210398674,
0.0190109406,
0.1416729242,
-0.0158521365,
0.1659641713,
-0.5341265798,
-0.1683000028,
0.0138360476,
-0.2037917376,
-0.9964501262,
0.3334392011,
-0.0713730603,
0.3925109506,
0.3172035515,
-0.0989434347,
0.6410205364,
-0.4970216453,
0.7835069299,
-0.1208825707,
-0.6479694247,
0.3887329996,
-0.770870626,
0.3746887743,
0.7741042972,
0.4570157826,
-0.3838938475,
-0.8158923984,
-0.7164205313,
-0.6642218828,
0.7130096555,
0.2335365266,
0.179009214,
0.0053472905,
0.5582567453,
0.1563178301,
0.2272670865,
-0.6067700982,
0.1738217324,
0.2539479434,
-0.3344351351,
-0.2636738122,
-0.5846486688,
-0.1851375252,
-0.388225317,
0.2501009107,
-0.0801089481,
0.3848334849,
-0.0297209378,
0.1703106016,
0.1742176414,
0.4586556554,
0.3096195459,
0.855250001,
-0.2773075998,
0.172921285,
0.1987230778,
-0.1583351195,
0.2723372877,
-0.0692486987,
-0.2544772327,
-0.0491146594,
0.4660666287,
0.463278234,
0.1851194501,
-0.6758033037,
0.1383567303,
0.0840020627,
-0.0457756743,
-0.4492095113,
-0.1100631803,
0.187412709,
0.3631572723,
0.2501676679,
-0.8709561229,
0.066897288,
-1.1358137131,
0.0576174855,
0.4760080278,
-0.3099140525,
-0.4255294204,
0.4756065011,
-0.0919588432,
-0.3163042665,
0.9133242965,
-0.212484628,
-0.3382314742,
0.6668399572,
0.8418724537,
0.9454874992,
-0.3534200191,
0.4407032132,
0.1323472857,
0.2612781823,
0.0471047834,
0.4394131303,
0.1475024819,
-0.6992046833,
-0.639473021,
-0.7683689594,
-0.3315079212,
0.326588124,
-0.8562681079,
0.0931236297,
-0.2438388467,
0.2121515423,
0.0074998271,
-0.2072127312,
-0.7973983884,
0.1198618263,
-0.0278166421,
0.8151580691,
-0.9618825912,
0.9746267796,
0.6698425412,
-0.4241590202,
-0.7919232845,
0.0934565738,
0.1966231316,
-0.9228709936,
0.707455337,
-0.1371610016,
-0.0792848319,
-0.0157028027,
-0.4913920164,
-0.6129569411,
1.2135782242,
0.2658945918,
-0.3680289686,
-0.1709669083,
0.3501374125,
0.8604106307,
-0.7294254303,
0.5333564281,
0.9763638377,
0.4742074609,
0.2898650765,
-0.8773872852,
0.2672465742,
-0.2074792236,
0.1865067929,
0.0525890067,
-0.5894679427,
0.7523010969,
-0.010747971,
-0.1896343231,
0.3642967641,
0.7009319067,
0.1427057087,
0.1648792922,
0.3766846955,
0.3876474202,
0.5558142066,
0.0218975879,
1.3059669733,
-0.1902547479,
0.6313414574,
1.2444139719,
-0.6779937148,
0.725687623,
0.6336100101,
-0.4174481332,
0.5736832023,
0.5262190104,
-0.1585531533,
0.3901425004,
0.6217196584,
-0.3172513843,
-0.0127052898,
-0.4652652144,
-0.1285528541,
0.9534994364,
0.4474651515,
-0.4023609459,
-0.4710585177,
-0.0276090819,
0.0505607165,
0.0413237847,
-0.3091917634,
0.7448855042,
0.1342197657,
-0.5630640388,
0.4375690222,
0.2528043389,
0.1986606121,
-0.6535053253,
-0.1788969636,
-0.2844538689,
-0.0228360556,
-0.0452729613,
-0.7896252871,
0.5004088283,
0.1329395622,
0.2493630201,
-0.2444354743,
0.7540381551,
-0.4342012405,
-0.8863592744,
0.1939436197,
0.8095354438,
0.3419516385,
0.0504976436,
-0.2957874238,
0.0195849221,
0.0056430292,
-0.1566833556,
0.475025475,
0.6262022853,
0.0104283476,
0.423207283,
0.26858446,
0.0714283213,
-0.1673941016,
0.2620355785,
0.8788300157,
-1.0258877277,
-0.2676458955,
-1.217446208,
0.3482223749,
0.179557398,
0.0100640571,
0.8050590754,
0.4968085289,
0.852078855,
0.0368791893,
0.8491628766,
-0.1780826747,
0.4453931451,
-0.8264943361,
0.1857541054,
-0.3730810285,
0.3504574299,
-0.3682748079,
-0.9416643977,
-0.1012232751,
0.5184285641,
-0.5553714037,
0.2451934367,
0.9090235829,
0.7533994913,
-0.1014750525,
0.4259264171,
0.2693293691,
0.588775754,
0.3581621051,
0.4245307744,
1.3643705845,
0.276176244,
0.0873641223,
0.0049634073,
-0.220508948,
0.0830606744,
-0.6989764571,
-1.0536507368,
-0.5190187693,
-0.0312085673,
-0.4056694806,
-0.0208138712,
0.8669127822,
0.1195236295,
-0.574385941,
-0.548935473,
0.3182198703,
-0.0854321942,
-0.0950275958,
-0.27739501,
0.2584536374,
-0.0333815701,
-0.867215693,
0.4229928255,
0.2511881888,
-0.113579683,
-0.7393501401,
0.4511103928,
-0.4112635255,
-0.0579122156,
0.6686761975,
0.0756775364,
-0.7328180671,
-0.5953084826,
-0.2638872564,
0.2100753188,
0.1860204339,
1.4051852226,
-0.7275635004,
0.2458923012,
0.1958485097,
0.7735002637,
0.548622787,
0.0073953173,
0.6873925328,
-0.5640059114,
0.0706577599,
0.3008458614,
0.3091897368,
0.1512594819,
-0.2296990603,
0.6977465153,
0.0874946117,
-0.1965486556,
-0.7907830477,
0.2189571559,
-0.871774137,
-0.1010911018,
1.6021432877,
-0.2674188614,
-0.1168191135,
-0.232644707,
-0.0924692154,
0.181271106,
-0.0868412405,
1.0204657316,
0.9936577678,
-0.1783828884,
0.0048715863,
-0.8320425153,
-0.051786989,
0.3652003109,
-0.8607584238,
-0.0393245406,
0.2069576979,
0.1588421166,
0.0397216231,
0.6799233556,
-0.2430852652,
-0.1766041368,
-0.2763504982,
-0.1226195395,
0.1434907764,
-0.3180121779,
-0.6132105589,
0.3074487448,
0.3484485149,
0.2174215317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13009v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13009v3 | Textually Pretrained Speech Language Models | 2023-05-22T13:12:16 | 2024-01-30T11:52:51 | Michael Hassid, Tal Remez, Tu Anh Nguyen, Itai Gat, Alexis Conneau, Felix Kreuk, Jade Copet, Alexandre Defossez, Gabriel Synnaeve, Emmanuel Dupoux, Roy Schwartz, Yossi Adi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech language models (SpeechLMs) process and generate acoustic data only,
without textual supervision. In this work, we propose TWIST, a method for
training SpeechLMs using a warm-start from a pretrained textual language
models. We show using both automatic and human evaluations that TWIST
outperforms a cold-start SpeechLM across the board. We empirically analyze the
effect of different model design choices such as the speech tokenizer, the
pretrained textual model, and the dataset size. We find that model and dataset
scale both play an important role in constructing better-performing SpeechLMs.
Based on our observations, we present the largest (to the best of our
knowledge) SpeechLM both in terms of number of parameters and training data. We
additionally introduce two spoken versions of the StoryCloze textual benchmark
to further improve model evaluation and advance future research in the field.
We make speech samples, code and models publicly available:
https://pages.cs.huji.ac.il/adiyoss-lab/twist/ . | [
-0.1688378006,
-0.4681153893,
0.196735546,
-0.0507582091,
-0.5831127167,
0.2635171711,
-0.4698812068,
-0.3913625479,
0.1072580069,
0.5799582005,
-0.730361402,
-0.4596699476,
-0.4197235107,
0.1535240114,
-0.8159371614,
1.4182904959,
0.3643084466,
0.1576852202,
-0.015987711,
-0.0003100061,
0.0956070498,
-0.5584523082,
-0.4041193724,
-0.5612273812,
0.7353171706,
0.0191563014,
0.8397421837,
0.5427439213,
-0.023401143,
0.2915573418,
-0.2716685236,
-0.0420360826,
-0.5961840749,
0.1221168563,
0.2560439408,
-0.3519686759,
-0.151646778,
0.4819504321,
0.3254577219,
0.7122702599,
-0.441287756,
0.4123659134,
-0.160374403,
0.4153842032,
-0.2589313984,
-0.3854666054,
-0.769697845,
-0.0640300512,
-0.4339335859,
0.0642961413,
-0.5897491574,
-0.6773994565,
0.5985047221,
-0.4598832428,
0.3913826346,
0.2951585948,
0.8445481062,
0.0654250085,
-0.4535850883,
-0.4314073026,
-0.7948133945,
0.6856617332,
-1.2001240253,
0.6422293186,
0.3039911985,
0.2324783802,
0.2386258692,
-0.8991695046,
-0.5432775021,
-0.3335573971,
0.0264942348,
-0.2415349633,
0.0349786691,
-0.1229099482,
0.225495711,
0.1608923227,
-0.7409791946,
0.2572527528,
-0.637901485,
-0.1666897088,
0.7928254008,
0.135329172,
0.2465684265,
-0.1154639125,
-0.3795701861,
-0.3296169043,
-0.5809059739,
0.0879313722,
0.6581899524,
0.6642932892,
-0.2806384861,
0.4958854616,
0.054697942,
0.5581934452,
0.1061861441,
-0.0552189089,
0.5800165534,
-0.1210000664,
-0.2483010143,
0.3696080446,
0.7528210878,
0.03678203,
0.355561465,
-0.3373649716,
-0.2869468033,
-0.3386336267,
0.2919487357,
-0.6767484546,
-0.1802576035,
0.2306279987,
-0.3006642759,
-0.3941958845,
-0.0330200419,
-0.5475839376,
-0.4467265308,
-0.6618379951,
0.3407677412,
-0.5676012039,
-0.5870730877,
0.0686389357,
-0.2756502032,
0.2824588418,
0.1172411963,
-0.710934639,
0.408695519,
0.5444179177,
0.7745919824,
-0.295143038,
-0.3510874212,
-0.4309566915,
-0.1000201553,
-0.3278418183,
0.6429370046,
-0.3264737129,
-0.4381447136,
0.1529102176,
-0.5173888803,
-0.0373857729,
-0.379696846,
0.6378389597,
-0.3427519202,
0.714866519,
0.0508359708,
-0.7013030052,
0.1444685459,
-0.0925432891,
-0.7479580045,
1.2492406368,
0.0294165015,
-0.9906965494,
0.6022526026,
-0.549685955,
-0.507009685,
0.0298259538,
0.0926448405,
-0.5253757834,
0.1344862729,
0.4373162091,
0.2890393138,
-0.1933883876,
0.4285191,
-0.1441940963,
-0.2689225972,
0.3897002637,
-0.3808898032,
0.9591613412,
0.1583302766,
-0.3075655401,
0.4931332171,
-0.8665855527,
0.364068687,
0.1870138496,
-0.2620067,
-0.3149447441,
-0.3273279369,
0.5069201589,
0.1574624926,
0.0279454179,
-0.5454188585,
0.1322595924,
-0.81812042,
0.5750491023,
0.5269748569,
-0.3473162353,
0.3367210329,
-0.1198436618,
0.4425618947,
-0.1333333552,
0.1048379168,
-0.2692358196,
-0.2693649828,
-0.6364781857,
-0.2381750196,
0.4824522734,
0.3259669244,
-0.9253292084,
0.2572741807,
-0.1142154187,
-0.7393093705,
-0.8527626991,
0.057660047,
0.4696395993,
0.4550735056,
0.3942812979,
0.2808100283,
-0.741785109,
-0.6340595484,
-0.673855722,
-0.1530530453,
-0.3585349321,
0.0658143908,
0.2332565337,
0.1872891784,
1.2914714813,
-0.3116487265,
0.0688766688,
-0.4582936168,
0.5339385867,
0.5009330511,
0.2488985062,
0.4519082308,
-0.7872638702,
-0.1541555822,
-0.3251608908,
-0.557895124,
-0.1659362316,
0.1152110472,
0.2306408882,
0.1146151498,
0.5090237856,
-0.720651865,
0.4910479486,
0.5494756699,
-0.4941686392,
0.8377459049,
-0.1533724517,
-0.0595206246,
-0.8637151718,
-0.0646039173,
-0.3920403123,
-0.236951977,
-1.0397132635,
-0.2962580919,
-0.0926741064,
-0.5056097507,
-0.9065887332,
0.6910974979,
-0.4458833635,
0.0488993451,
-0.2554171681,
0.1328021735,
-0.0457839482,
0.477280587,
0.1575885117,
0.6449438334,
0.4038465023,
-0.5476221442,
0.3423983455,
0.1614437252,
-0.461782366,
0.0448119082,
-0.9931438565,
0.7061632872,
-0.0156404227,
0.0816968009,
-0.5998508334,
0.0240787528,
-0.3388860226,
-0.4815137982,
0.3197824359,
0.2019511163,
-0.2372113168,
-0.6172336936,
-0.3556451499,
0.3919343352,
0.6826221347,
-0.5612258315,
0.4845922887,
0.1701042801,
-0.1870429516,
-0.2207427174,
-0.4733604491,
0.1700457036,
-0.4375123084,
-0.5041157603,
0.0221217759,
0.0226559285,
-0.1895792782,
-0.2612455189,
0.0594268367,
-0.0977734923,
-0.2918488085,
0.1833128333,
0.1181098074,
-0.3664329648,
0.324079752,
-0.0035300858,
-0.0201189965,
-0.0368704125,
-0.3731893897,
0.7046017051,
-0.1315245479,
-0.1326306462,
-0.4712298512,
0.2042376697,
0.4170026779,
-0.2209268361,
0.5041004419,
0.6242129207,
-0.2019407749,
-0.1961991787,
-0.54366678,
-0.3319570124,
-0.4992174804,
0.1040912941,
-0.1056029946,
-0.7402410507,
0.1226175874,
-0.0354178995,
0.2528980076,
0.2487139255,
0.5709185004,
-0.1254386008,
0.7668166757,
0.5863772631,
-0.0262702666,
0.4491722882,
-0.0039833239,
0.1653386354,
-0.6672933698,
-0.306121707,
-0.7193338275,
0.0418887101,
-0.2848342955,
-0.1907823682,
0.4023536444,
0.0272015743,
-0.2426229417,
0.4113747776,
-0.3731746972,
0.2745664716,
0.6605756283,
0.0225164685,
0.1716220379,
-0.1633267254,
-0.33902964,
-0.082778126,
-0.6201164126,
-0.74218297,
1.2994840145,
0.3213266432,
0.6342308521,
-0.229804799,
0.7593128681,
0.2677972317,
0.0737127662,
-0.5933783054,
0.2171561867,
0.0221870728,
-0.6766276956,
-0.80335778,
-0.2890423536,
-1.0072348118,
0.2339950949,
-0.4058772624,
-0.5300686955,
-0.1185674071,
0.0457838401,
-0.1517514735,
0.1368104666,
-0.7470063567,
0.3454200029,
-0.2994874418,
0.0204203855,
0.0651976019,
-0.5723797679,
0.294172436,
-0.0594229549,
0.4570348561,
-0.1979731768,
0.1782054603,
1.2805914879,
-0.6303932071,
0.7565008998,
-0.3274717331,
-0.0933763236,
0.341170013,
-0.0713378936,
0.3435269296,
0.0527640171,
-0.433011353,
0.2897900045,
-0.0653233975,
-0.3670609593,
-0.6206874847,
0.1025585011,
-0.8776122332,
-0.5540912747,
-0.308262527,
-0.296233654,
-0.4654137492,
0.4614118934,
0.5442578793,
0.8457975984,
-0.3162804544,
0.1233405098,
0.5498587489,
-0.0828084797,
0.7335082293,
0.5805487037,
-0.5944141746,
-0.3807410896,
0.4708828926,
-0.0761775449,
0.1410024017,
-0.0517098382,
0.5932140946,
-0.4172508419,
-0.7923387885,
-0.502066493,
0.1841296703,
-0.4023590982,
-0.0253346339,
-0.5635941029,
-0.3606930673,
-0.652146101,
-0.0112167411,
-0.5545153022,
-0.3557919562,
-0.168548286,
-0.3076496124,
0.4736037254,
0.9193364382,
0.2220243663,
0.3865720034,
-0.6080668569,
0.1536133885,
0.3489339948,
0.0642862469,
-0.1004163101,
-0.6752691865,
-0.3174773753,
0.2194098532,
0.1801239699,
-0.7166696191,
0.4033180475,
0.3757393956,
0.3962554634,
0.3996853828,
0.2655718029,
0.4127801061,
-0.886261642,
0.9967744946,
0.4387353063,
-1.1912438869,
0.7238924503,
-0.4249181747,
0.8106745481,
0.5502775311,
0.3133389056,
-0.412463516,
-0.596704185,
-0.6609514356,
-0.9499924779,
0.5613723993,
0.4331943691,
0.2431999892,
0.3481035829,
0.2432335913,
0.4964480698,
0.4350713491,
-0.4568155706,
-0.0558584034,
-0.4965969026,
-0.1712458879,
-0.1677563787,
-0.1480732262,
0.0118286526,
-0.3953694105,
0.641936183,
0.0051821526,
0.0518062226,
-0.0222735796,
-0.3074953556,
0.113918826,
0.2408115715,
0.6862796545,
0.8392927647,
-0.1159198731,
0.1377819777,
0.1558008343,
-0.7675836086,
0.0157273021,
-0.2352155447,
-0.1897125542,
0.3309082687,
1.0226037502,
1.2428466082,
0.4891997278,
-0.7170476913,
0.4306637347,
-0.164864555,
-0.2042115778,
-0.1392038316,
0.0022371847,
0.1255909652,
0.0018515732,
0.5458053946,
-0.2825398147,
0.1798244864,
-0.3061522245,
0.3698965907,
0.0898188949,
-0.3902921677,
-0.5210510492,
0.4537269473,
0.4300445914,
-0.6353294849,
0.9041836262,
0.3015448153,
-0.6560750008,
0.3518993556,
0.5857527256,
0.8841684461,
-0.4671738744,
0.2696852982,
0.1588892639,
0.3089390695,
0.3053114414,
0.1165005639,
-0.0035139469,
-0.5188336968,
-0.1585088968,
-0.8111420274,
-0.3744606376,
0.0558092408,
-0.9308902025,
0.5910749435,
-0.3662202656,
-0.2322472036,
0.0892441124,
-0.0175316706,
-0.7539792657,
0.4801584482,
0.2927828133,
0.8937052488,
-0.7278975248,
1.1112771034,
0.523153007,
0.0125295194,
-0.8389592767,
-0.1400838792,
0.0464221686,
-0.8827096224,
0.5566015244,
0.1112565547,
-0.3336763382,
-0.0148085421,
-0.6255732775,
-0.9521698952,
0.7310977578,
0.3002794385,
-0.6705342531,
-0.2481559068,
0.2770421505,
0.6044914722,
-0.4403380156,
0.5062330365,
0.5717709661,
0.2157417834,
0.3677594066,
-1.3092427254,
-0.2637079656,
-0.1944666058,
-0.0234025735,
0.0096643856,
-0.0733225569,
0.9827993512,
-0.36210379,
-0.3365313411,
-0.0870802402,
0.8238419294,
0.0699886233,
0.4642108083,
0.7553581595,
0.2255961597,
1.1340398788,
0.013123027,
0.8166525364,
-0.0151282325,
0.3210917711,
1.3858929873,
-0.4718225002,
1.021751523,
0.4315481186,
-0.2131566554,
0.4681016207,
0.6214870214,
0.3157849312,
0.4945017099,
0.27811414,
0.0274731107,
-0.0797537491,
0.1388934106,
-0.4958159626,
0.5989874005,
0.1782821417,
-0.0575086772,
-0.2905863225,
0.5541297793,
0.1886441559,
0.1381686926,
-0.2289181203,
0.9036957026,
0.1070120707,
-0.1956087798,
0.7549462318,
-0.2201088965,
0.6941752434,
-0.6289191842,
0.4888536334,
-0.0476372316,
-0.1166754067,
-0.1692285389,
-0.4697254896,
0.2716141939,
0.2744910419,
-0.0139218755,
-0.3366084397,
0.6210356355,
-0.6347241998,
-0.5733309984,
-0.0729950517,
0.3979332149,
0.2219442576,
0.0267183855,
-0.5663017035,
0.1886107624,
-0.3180496693,
-0.6855208874,
0.1551603675,
0.4097449481,
-0.032168828,
0.6257930398,
0.8255779743,
0.0209258255,
0.3714211881,
0.2371602356,
0.9046739936,
-0.8531844616,
-0.6980972886,
-0.7313259244,
0.4567784369,
-0.2408535928,
-0.6995478868,
0.7558330297,
0.6308721304,
0.4486058354,
-0.0024102516,
0.6451382041,
0.2424732745,
0.831764102,
-0.8722919822,
0.8780354857,
-0.0656647831,
-0.1282427162,
-0.2147731632,
-0.8229017258,
0.0157249086,
0.1436455399,
-0.2555989623,
0.164743945,
0.7744345069,
0.2059280872,
0.2169480324,
0.5119624734,
0.3639934361,
0.3155388236,
0.3925679028,
0.1331374198,
0.7874535918,
-0.2685075998,
0.2866255641,
-0.0244606268,
-0.2375204712,
-0.054575298,
-1.0798002481,
-1.3815939426,
-0.7343603969,
-0.2957488596,
-0.1766540706,
-0.0356006175,
1.0271339417,
0.9757431746,
-0.6640501022,
-0.475961417,
0.306783855,
0.1043172106,
-0.1170517057,
-0.1338013858,
0.4525092542,
-0.4019536972,
-0.5840175748,
0.6118149161,
0.0112736123,
0.0228242502,
-0.2675586343,
-0.1501108706,
-0.2286528945,
0.371688813,
0.6594058275,
0.1145495698,
-0.7483224869,
-0.0774334818,
-0.0784223154,
0.0758706778,
-0.1098024324,
1.3056302071,
-1.0952922106,
0.2239696085,
0.132589072,
0.2597382963,
0.9119746685,
-0.292858541,
0.6214279532,
-0.742444694,
0.4580164552,
0.4916651845,
-0.0877828151,
0.4093631208,
-0.3003070056,
0.1326286048,
-0.0384611227,
-0.1556566358,
-1.0876294374,
-0.0264715999,
-0.7646359205,
-0.212423116,
1.1135184765,
0.0173353869,
-0.3348310292,
-0.1621552557,
-0.2105147839,
0.3853991032,
-0.3753916025,
0.5294374228,
0.6195386052,
-0.0741279498,
-0.0731887296,
-0.1971341223,
0.7954275608,
0.1175654382,
-0.7894408107,
0.2071733326,
-0.0374791175,
0.2746964097,
-0.0803661793,
0.3977888227,
0.0044943145,
-0.0436939448,
-0.0173313729,
0.0649569705,
-0.3463954329,
-0.2640260458,
-0.3687966466,
0.1976294667,
-0.0393811092,
0.195251748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13002v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13002v1 | Rethinking Semi-supervised Learning with Language Models | 2023-05-22T13:07:35 | 2023-05-22T13:07:35 | Zhengxiang Shi, Francesco Tonolini, Nikolaos Aletras, Emine Yilmaz, Gabriella Kazai, Yunlong Jiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Semi-supervised learning (SSL) is a popular setting aiming to effectively
utilize unlabelled data to improve model performance in downstream natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. Currently, there are two popular approaches to
make use of unlabelled data: Self-training (ST) and Task-adaptive pre-training
(TAPT). ST uses a teacher model to assign pseudo-labels to the unlabelled data,
while TAPT continues pre-training on the unlabelled data before fine-tuning. To
the best of our knowledge, the effectiveness of TAPT in SSL tasks has not been
systematically studied, and no previous work has directly compared TAPT and ST
in terms of their ability to utilize the pool of unlabelled data. In this
paper, we provide an extensive empirical study comparing five state-of-the-art
ST approaches and TAPT across various NLP tasks and data sizes, including in-
and out-of-domain settings. Surprisingly, we find that TAPT is a strong and
more robust SSL learner, even when using just a few hundred unlabelled samples
or in the presence of domain shifts, compared to more sophisticated ST
approaches, and tends to bring greater improvements in SSL than in
fully-supervised settings. Our further analysis demonstrates the risks of using
ST approaches when the size of labelled or unlabelled data is small or when
domain shifts exist. We offer a fresh perspective for future SSL research,
suggesting the use of unsupervised pre-training objectives over dependency on
pseudo labels. | [
-0.0871427953,
-0.5906131864,
0.325869292,
0.0579483435,
-0.4684229493,
0.4348243177,
-0.3502918184,
-0.4743891358,
-0.1199552268,
0.281070441,
-0.201281473,
-0.145705834,
-0.5432024002,
0.1708632112,
-0.4810641706,
1.1909160614,
-0.1898490638,
-0.0442542695,
-0.0944102407,
0.1596364975,
-0.3973105848,
-0.7677437663,
-0.4265343249,
-0.2485131323,
0.112015076,
0.1648736596,
0.4670079947,
0.4272674322,
0.2208200097,
0.2425421327,
0.1625770926,
0.2199010551,
-0.5723975301,
-0.2109663486,
-0.2820068896,
-0.3731531203,
-0.0499133356,
0.1540976465,
0.503099978,
0.7996785045,
-0.0291030519,
0.3564763665,
0.5008935928,
0.6726310849,
-0.668413341,
0.1901699454,
-0.6657502651,
0.0944657549,
-0.3629819155,
-0.2694283426,
-0.6238517761,
0.1715305895,
0.4897591174,
-0.4991867244,
0.4067339003,
0.1579456031,
0.7288784981,
0.388579011,
-0.317663759,
-0.1756011844,
-0.9405969977,
0.7912365198,
-0.5495355725,
0.5979835987,
0.4146449268,
-0.0282720383,
-0.1606321782,
-0.8375586271,
-0.0491391569,
-0.0719677731,
-0.1401694417,
0.2765394449,
-0.3349146843,
-0.1714242548,
0.1964457929,
0.2469832748,
-0.4501896501,
0.3661009967,
-0.5989233851,
-0.2491252422,
0.6517726183,
-0.2455288917,
0.3183660805,
0.1436960697,
-0.738941133,
0.0843672603,
-0.7863752842,
0.3115678132,
0.1307074428,
0.6591922641,
-0.2066510618,
0.3904517889,
0.0248430092,
0.9428921938,
0.3614852726,
0.1843921095,
0.0552659482,
-0.3294095993,
-0.2087123692,
0.1648090482,
0.8172698617,
-0.0410278067,
0.6089667082,
-0.2732068002,
-0.1960896701,
-0.1357614398,
0.5353623629,
-0.4343122542,
-0.804238081,
-0.1688215882,
-0.2702333331,
-0.0970760882,
-0.2370532006,
-0.6023069024,
-0.1323585659,
-0.5609436631,
0.4654106498,
-0.1175971851,
-0.2566767335,
-0.0022496139,
0.2039088309,
-0.0717113614,
0.3091071844,
-0.7954695225,
0.2645917237,
0.193151474,
0.7377998829,
-0.6288322806,
-0.4002056718,
-0.2246766239,
-0.0229803678,
-0.5741159916,
0.6480548382,
-0.470297277,
-0.395018369,
-0.0144790411,
-0.085332267,
-0.4097967446,
-0.4910639226,
0.3553297818,
-0.5611874461,
0.1753992587,
-0.1439737231,
-0.570545435,
0.3305076063,
-0.2047675103,
-0.5236597061,
1.3492221832,
0.0165392123,
-0.9506812692,
0.5425385833,
-0.596292913,
-0.6108715534,
-0.0802840143,
0.1290662885,
-0.5717249513,
0.3485795259,
0.1552562118,
0.6263081431,
0.0326567329,
0.3553588092,
-0.2990148962,
-0.2784560919,
0.271771729,
-0.3627416492,
0.6014646292,
0.1998514086,
-0.2845322788,
-0.061900802,
-0.6970099211,
-0.0502441265,
0.2010025829,
-0.2081225365,
-0.5843240023,
0.0932239592,
-0.1282544434,
0.3615057468,
-0.0203024652,
-0.5516123772,
-0.2077791393,
-0.5485712886,
0.4526805282,
0.8630069494,
-0.1320678145,
0.6303307414,
0.0430093594,
0.2154914141,
0.0107091218,
0.0883833244,
0.1545730829,
-0.092795603,
-0.5912422538,
-0.2680892944,
0.6337549686,
0.2708793581,
-0.9048029184,
0.0726364329,
-0.1051828563,
-0.5106250644,
-0.8162168264,
0.38977319,
0.5487310886,
0.6147186756,
0.7638010383,
-0.2453452796,
-0.5350883007,
-0.7734403014,
-0.5603892803,
-0.1611451209,
0.1156215891,
0.0208169334,
0.3744038045,
0.3604133129,
1.1356357336,
-0.2182067335,
-0.2727942467,
-0.4524567723,
0.2499528974,
-0.1318530589,
0.4499814212,
0.3625317514,
-0.9070057869,
-0.8964501619,
-0.2523947358,
-0.601197958,
0.005021865,
-0.2392099947,
0.2178248018,
0.1533014327,
0.2926934063,
-0.2638863027,
0.6726680994,
0.4140119255,
0.0439326018,
0.4164772034,
-0.4374508858,
-0.2502625883,
-0.9377902746,
-0.2844117284,
0.2189206779,
-0.3557895422,
-1.0483646393,
-0.2848681509,
0.3765518665,
-0.1090939939,
-0.8147670627,
0.4333055019,
-0.8289942741,
-0.2313651145,
-0.5854031444,
-0.2291816622,
-0.2555229962,
0.3985533416,
0.557076633,
1.1072467566,
0.6729014516,
-0.7381262779,
-0.1147138327,
0.0367109664,
-0.2703467607,
0.1304624081,
-0.6267963052,
0.2511895299,
0.1536811739,
0.273612082,
-0.9105624557,
0.2617022991,
-0.0468814149,
-0.3376984894,
0.6082801223,
-0.1258527189,
-0.4551720917,
-0.462851584,
-0.1707564443,
0.5052479506,
0.4495531321,
-0.7357763052,
0.4187802672,
0.4982594848,
0.1638621092,
-0.4833527505,
-0.6563065052,
-0.0180453565,
-0.2339125127,
-0.023469843,
0.2267705798,
0.2050957531,
0.1397907436,
-0.0334497504,
-0.4582344592,
-0.1337990016,
0.4097447395,
0.130188942,
0.3689733148,
-0.0115566794,
0.0462816209,
-0.1582369953,
-0.3069969714,
-0.0075552436,
-0.4247468114,
0.3912580609,
-0.0703363046,
-0.3614419103,
-0.4977021217,
-0.0146546103,
-0.0794545412,
-0.500115931,
0.6838660836,
0.3344078958,
-0.1685467213,
-0.5328852534,
-0.2367067635,
-0.1421869993,
-0.4366801977,
0.1254917234,
-0.4017514586,
-1.1711292267,
0.0657259375,
-0.2568263412,
0.2073209286,
0.3289754093,
0.7652680278,
-0.730158627,
0.5414149165,
0.8563014865,
-0.0776186958,
0.3956931829,
-0.066816166,
0.7566866279,
-0.7586852312,
0.0691654161,
-0.353713274,
-0.2339757085,
-0.5480819345,
-0.4045477211,
0.0145485112,
0.0051226756,
0.2085960209,
0.572871089,
-0.4087403417,
0.2566204667,
0.5163093805,
0.088326253,
0.0657274053,
-0.2319863886,
0.1271343529,
-0.1139361113,
-0.8698050976,
-0.3068487048,
1.3705832958,
0.2378501892,
0.8821591735,
-0.3271483481,
0.6537531018,
0.6083447933,
0.1199824885,
-0.3523937464,
0.2953768969,
-0.2151346505,
-0.9201413393,
-0.4230331779,
-0.1401084512,
-1.121419549,
0.405631274,
-0.2180079073,
-0.6979262233,
0.1542775929,
0.5897215605,
-0.2648881972,
0.4750893414,
-1.0297323465,
0.8758572936,
-0.4839923084,
-0.3765987456,
0.242265746,
-0.7979295254,
0.0636745244,
-0.6174991131,
0.2871955335,
0.0378293917,
0.1831686646,
0.9632344246,
-0.1648570895,
1.3469842672,
-0.327981174,
-0.026501229,
0.3492521942,
-0.0333650969,
0.5572235584,
-0.279366374,
0.3507734835,
0.0802751482,
0.1794199347,
-0.6195815206,
-0.3998990357,
0.3931693435,
-0.855193913,
-0.5449411273,
-0.5038499832,
-0.4549330771,
-0.6156888008,
0.1103228107,
0.2937097847,
0.2840020061,
-0.0454438776,
0.1950330287,
0.7463822961,
-0.0988852084,
0.3696635664,
0.6819467545,
0.0787531435,
0.2436338216,
0.8423372507,
0.474788934,
0.5789842606,
0.4986721277,
0.2148172557,
-0.5972680449,
-0.8875903487,
-0.3052743971,
0.1343970597,
-0.3756110072,
-0.064625904,
-0.630789876,
-0.2374003828,
-0.4845167994,
-0.1564431638,
-0.9139477015,
-0.1302914321,
-0.4631415606,
-0.4394784868,
0.1311579049,
0.2662626803,
0.0877521038,
0.37135759,
-0.4260259569,
0.3264749944,
0.1439968348,
0.1341189444,
-0.14268893,
-0.8713233471,
-0.3425986767,
0.0983504057,
0.1505140215,
-0.6941736341,
0.150086835,
0.1275870949,
0.5433345437,
0.0408045053,
0.5226848125,
0.8571587801,
-0.6421762109,
0.7484049201,
0.1418116689,
-0.784992218,
0.5886316299,
-0.0059567145,
0.1120512635,
0.6797472835,
0.6070793867,
-0.1529697329,
-0.44262743,
-0.8402001858,
-0.6851852536,
0.7695847154,
0.1869747639,
0.2508523166,
0.3552062809,
0.1528739184,
0.373657912,
0.0757776201,
-0.8962383866,
-0.2475095391,
-0.2435596734,
-0.1837168038,
-0.3674552143,
-0.283005178,
0.1289836317,
-0.2837384343,
0.6826433539,
-0.0756164938,
0.2256114334,
-0.0330608003,
-0.5678006411,
0.1059568226,
0.3491342664,
0.1059212536,
0.9150669575,
-0.0623055883,
0.476690799,
0.4313238561,
-0.1981298178,
0.1081601009,
-0.0095110256,
-0.322730124,
-0.0262304507,
0.5784035325,
1.0879392624,
0.5496602058,
-0.4529635608,
0.5684874654,
0.2011816949,
-0.2762588859,
0.0097296946,
-0.0876242146,
0.0039097131,
-0.011337854,
0.1444251835,
-0.0539500788,
0.0285021439,
-0.48974967,
0.3574105799,
0.2150144875,
-0.5625788569,
-0.6466288567,
0.6430451274,
-0.0043271952,
-0.1814064384,
0.3127702475,
0.1571838409,
-0.4657122791,
-0.0048237769,
0.9608661532,
0.6089306474,
-0.3256861269,
0.5102808475,
0.0546814539,
0.4210190773,
-0.084963493,
-0.1346746981,
-0.4285704792,
-0.787227273,
-0.391530931,
-0.5966866016,
-0.2205774933,
0.0767116323,
-0.7273292542,
-0.0841323659,
-0.4043367803,
-0.0245955922,
0.054966066,
-0.0994847491,
-0.6997740865,
0.4616321027,
-0.0624682046,
0.6989827156,
-1.4338799715,
1.1725876331,
0.9465378523,
-0.1428997219,
-1.0220327377,
-0.0360530019,
-0.0783649534,
-1.0384565592,
0.4402810931,
-0.1874487996,
-0.0367348269,
0.1575624198,
-0.2121277303,
-0.8320872784,
0.6423379183,
0.1079357639,
-0.3671522439,
0.0377419591,
0.3613275886,
0.8633668423,
-0.0824580193,
-0.1795208454,
0.552431345,
0.0653993934,
-0.0705035925,
-0.9813939333,
-0.2069360018,
-0.0644743145,
0.1744039804,
0.3144191206,
-0.5558800101,
0.393171072,
0.0244588908,
-0.3966525793,
-0.4978294969,
0.906054616,
-0.0502788909,
0.4079544246,
0.5899373293,
0.3713397682,
0.5912469625,
-0.1077293307,
0.9044420123,
0.1124702096,
0.4241670668,
1.3585436344,
-0.3639781177,
0.8120909929,
0.697335422,
-0.6229885817,
-0.1501100063,
1.0923676491,
-0.0676675886,
0.7947469354,
0.0585597083,
0.2128662914,
-0.4743571281,
-0.0114444243,
-0.224550575,
0.4721378088,
-0.091845423,
-0.220938772,
-0.4521023929,
0.5142841339,
-0.1028319672,
0.2632754147,
-0.2364953458,
0.8257023692,
0.1592679769,
-0.3658879995,
0.4923462272,
-0.2485358119,
0.5590366125,
-0.381919533,
0.4711313844,
-0.04909271,
0.1761049479,
-0.1293605417,
-0.86302948,
0.1386281848,
0.4088051021,
-0.0327283069,
-0.7366578579,
1.1956778765,
-0.3188214302,
-0.5727104545,
0.4177978337,
0.6893273592,
0.312885046,
0.0974457413,
-0.8991392255,
-0.2244613022,
0.2054301202,
-0.2433656901,
0.813491106,
0.303535223,
-0.2924090922,
0.6353231072,
0.7999075651,
0.180059284,
0.4637214839,
0.0107045285,
0.9102131724,
-0.3027575314,
-0.5111823678,
-0.718988955,
0.413235724,
0.0864488855,
-0.2598635554,
0.9336345196,
0.7322695255,
1.3650766611,
-0.1516540945,
0.6943784356,
0.0336790197,
0.8488194346,
-0.5643378496,
0.352324307,
-0.6644206643,
0.1355378479,
-0.2338412702,
-0.7187395692,
-0.1636784524,
0.3425069749,
-0.5912287831,
0.0842282698,
0.5602695942,
0.3780671656,
-0.2562360168,
0.163973406,
0.2637110054,
-0.065040797,
0.2228615433,
0.335163027,
1.1047817469,
-0.0570380874,
0.2051836848,
-0.5252433419,
-0.1251499653,
0.0873940885,
-0.5200247169,
-1.1879714727,
-0.753441751,
-0.336589694,
0.1735509634,
0.2031283081,
0.8009818196,
0.6938958764,
-0.9473651648,
-0.1740422845,
0.1841749549,
-0.2147932351,
-0.2373998016,
-0.1050235853,
0.7170777917,
-0.534266293,
-0.6092003584,
0.5403805971,
0.2851790488,
0.0022739938,
0.1256926209,
0.091824986,
-0.4366511405,
-0.2760950029,
0.5616918206,
0.550496459,
-0.6296182275,
-0.2262514234,
-0.1927449107,
0.0767036155,
0.1524566859,
0.7864539027,
-0.6146391034,
0.5893905759,
0.1433009058,
1.1337380409,
0.782992959,
0.1792192608,
0.4193375707,
-0.7148251534,
-0.1239307225,
0.1780052483,
0.1384110302,
0.1427040696,
-0.2224422991,
0.4758196473,
0.2990548611,
-0.2743229866,
-1.0689356327,
-0.0747166052,
-0.7989084125,
-0.4233857095,
0.8704036474,
-0.2727701962,
-0.1991281807,
-0.3152311742,
0.0782135651,
0.4077985883,
-0.1927455813,
0.783172071,
0.630653441,
-0.3789865971,
-0.2842952311,
-0.5626054406,
0.6540153027,
0.56929636,
-0.6968221068,
0.275180161,
0.0765923709,
0.3035156727,
-0.1005000696,
0.7429108024,
0.0088229673,
0.0268560741,
-0.5312106013,
-0.2701313794,
-0.1832257062,
-0.6428910494,
-0.0966180339,
0.0735119507,
0.071594432,
-0.4024100006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13000v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13000v1 | Bidirectional Transformer Reranker for Grammatical Error Correction | 2023-05-22T13:04:48 | 2023-05-22T13:04:48 | Ying Zhang, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Manabu Okumura | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained seq2seq models have achieved state-of-the-art results in the
grammatical error correction task. However, these models still suffer from a
prediction bias due to their unidirectional decoding. Thus, we propose a
bidirectional Transformer reranker (BTR), that re-estimates the probability of
each candidate sentence generated by the pre-trained seq2seq model. The BTR
preserves the seq2seq-style Transformer architecture but utilizes a BERT-style
self-attention mechanism in the decoder to compute the probability of each
target token by using masked language modeling to capture bidirectional
representations from the target context. For guiding the reranking, the BTR
adopts negative sampling in the objective function to minimize the
unlikelihood. During inference, the BTR gives final results after comparing the
reranked top-1 results with the original ones by an acceptance threshold.
Experimental results show that, in reranking candidates from a pre-trained
seq2seq model, T5-base, the BTR on top of T5-base could yield 65.47 and 71.27
F0.5 scores on the CoNLL-14 and BEA test sets, respectively, and yield 59.52
GLEU score on the JFLEG corpus, with improvements of 0.36, 0.76 and 0.48 points
compared with the original T5-base. Furthermore, when reranking candidates from
T5-large, the BTR on top of T5-base improved the original T5-large by 0.26
points on the BEA test set. | [
0.0845128521,
-0.5224878788,
0.3870722651,
0.4332796335,
-0.2231276929,
-0.0345619842,
-0.3798421323,
0.0872859135,
0.3618111908,
0.3557158709,
-0.398164928,
-0.530076623,
-0.6900801659,
0.3055977821,
-0.5163272619,
0.8493236899,
0.2778889239,
0.1460104734,
-0.2191493213,
0.3095180094,
-0.6889292002,
-0.5219956636,
-0.3949013948,
-0.1143286973,
0.6541889906,
0.6639761329,
0.5309809446,
0.283184737,
0.5313227177,
0.4322620928,
-0.1556817442,
-0.2211119533,
-0.5341939926,
0.1902006567,
-0.3317048848,
-0.6210233569,
-0.5289796591,
0.0165152289,
0.702240169,
0.7024193406,
-0.2062073648,
0.1313349009,
0.164430961,
0.6831731796,
-0.6253167987,
0.0668223351,
-0.5615563393,
-0.0347857103,
-0.4263210893,
-0.0081343986,
-0.8033947945,
-0.5497897267,
-0.1208944097,
-0.217995137,
0.6093211174,
-0.1042237058,
0.7169114947,
0.4227411747,
-0.5381569862,
0.2054517716,
-0.6302766204,
0.6691894531,
-0.6381171942,
0.6477284431,
0.2145971805,
0.2131107599,
-0.066190958,
-0.70461905,
-0.6171824336,
0.0217024758,
-0.2977184355,
0.3907907903,
-0.3039876819,
0.1618858427,
-0.0246056728,
0.1700977981,
-0.555803895,
0.0279860962,
-0.4005062878,
-0.2604010701,
0.5957548618,
-0.2587487996,
-0.0361760817,
-0.3285751641,
0.0204427354,
-0.3867249489,
-0.5142033696,
-0.002164264,
0.3119057715,
0.2806222439,
0.326739043,
0.5437260866,
-0.1638260782,
0.4419788122,
0.5383682847,
0.1221854985,
0.6557571888,
-0.3274065256,
-0.2251899391,
0.1621991992,
0.5133523941,
0.4040446877,
0.2861380577,
-0.1707288027,
-0.3319738805,
0.0356806479,
0.5489764214,
-0.6479734778,
-0.4485304058,
0.0305515528,
-0.3836669922,
-0.4132882357,
0.2147240341,
-0.9074905515,
0.0772040412,
0.0068114712,
0.635201633,
-0.1610061675,
-0.0487009808,
-0.0414794944,
0.0384757966,
0.1364752501,
0.2912164629,
-0.73895365,
-0.0205840878,
0.4767757952,
0.5600667,
-0.0141277369,
-0.4208430052,
-0.56724298,
-0.0495809987,
-0.30637151,
0.8033074737,
-0.3434773386,
-0.3257212639,
0.2174732238,
0.3752391934,
-0.6004205942,
-0.3682723641,
0.8778495789,
-0.6011823416,
0.5679548383,
-0.1804928035,
-0.3815174699,
-0.0854434818,
0.1058680862,
-0.6921474934,
1.0069935322,
0.0301210545,
-0.6169682145,
0.2122618109,
-0.408662349,
-0.6488421559,
-0.1566095352,
0.2096981406,
-0.8600383401,
0.1291224509,
0.3224020004,
0.2729387879,
0.0278269053,
0.4511939287,
-0.0794118345,
-0.6060739756,
0.2140897065,
-0.5218936801,
0.7053403854,
-0.1950003207,
-0.6144049764,
0.2083872259,
-0.5969412923,
0.0374533497,
-0.0066487174,
-0.4114133716,
-0.0650672615,
-0.0906281248,
0.1259777397,
0.2377788275,
0.1167031601,
-0.8538923264,
0.0246251374,
-0.5358300209,
0.295124948,
0.8678687811,
-0.2804367542,
0.4909472764,
-0.1862036884,
0.4262797832,
0.0851423144,
-0.0093455426,
0.0467717834,
-0.2650830746,
-1.1270688772,
-0.097447522,
0.7771272063,
0.6408199668,
-0.5092223883,
0.6638256907,
-0.565300703,
-0.5148444772,
-0.8787699938,
0.0358949602,
0.6501520276,
0.5204125643,
0.5539960861,
-0.0360325314,
-0.6991369128,
-0.9270370603,
-0.2839513719,
-0.2257148623,
-0.0197940972,
0.0705755129,
0.341566354,
-0.3571512401,
0.8318616748,
-0.4138841927,
-0.5596628189,
-0.3894023299,
0.117330268,
0.3536471128,
0.5131064653,
0.2589413226,
-0.7473419905,
-0.3718950748,
-0.3631059527,
-0.322930932,
-0.4375630319,
0.1584588885,
-0.1426410228,
0.593285799,
0.5150414705,
-0.5401132703,
0.3501032591,
0.4609010816,
-0.4839353263,
0.4043234587,
-0.2526758611,
0.1390970945,
-1.2026158571,
-0.0541934483,
-0.1554834694,
-0.3009699881,
-0.5801382661,
-0.1869388074,
0.3320622742,
0.2407463491,
-0.213403061,
0.0284880195,
-0.1967868507,
0.0728449747,
-0.094238475,
0.0491282456,
0.0081857322,
0.3860964179,
-0.0224367622,
0.8271769881,
0.074016735,
-0.2415603995,
0.2143741399,
0.4156037271,
0.0789810419,
0.2788344026,
-0.8645288944,
0.2283947021,
-0.4199280739,
0.2256147861,
-1.4477267265,
0.0388947837,
-0.0129695889,
-0.5036682487,
0.4721412957,
-0.2246826738,
-0.1794276237,
-0.6211733818,
-0.3268531263,
0.3617942333,
0.4775018394,
-0.5628742576,
0.5269249678,
0.0447449572,
-0.2908455431,
-0.6835238934,
-0.7105095983,
-0.0557922497,
0.0795362815,
-0.6336145997,
0.5995975137,
0.1327581555,
0.1063414738,
-0.022997709,
0.0533726066,
0.2574198246,
-0.1861912459,
0.36577788,
0.3476618826,
-0.1750549823,
0.2811819017,
0.1356733143,
-0.326084286,
0.1682437062,
-0.2329499274,
0.5155538917,
-0.2094412148,
-0.3857551813,
-0.2204776406,
0.1252272725,
0.5306796432,
-0.2088195682,
0.5384600163,
0.504747808,
-0.1903352737,
0.2099449039,
-0.9299660325,
-0.1859985292,
-0.4721648097,
0.4245504737,
-0.4638225138,
-0.8607238531,
0.1822037846,
0.2841714919,
-0.2293118387,
0.5777010918,
0.5479835272,
-0.2723139524,
0.7994124293,
0.5284330845,
-0.1571430862,
0.3737802505,
-0.0533483922,
0.4393822253,
-0.6330650449,
-0.2513200045,
-0.5322791934,
-0.432018429,
-0.944242239,
-0.3025599718,
0.4233525693,
-0.0645463988,
-0.1842509508,
0.2903195024,
-0.3537378907,
0.4428372383,
1.1300991774,
0.2049178034,
0.1559214592,
0.1546465307,
-0.0930292979,
-0.2993439436,
-0.5462795496,
-0.2159874737,
1.2593024969,
0.1875776649,
0.6381838322,
0.4374115765,
0.9308055639,
0.3495080471,
0.2109932303,
-0.594668746,
0.4877029061,
-0.425873071,
-0.3012831807,
-0.5601855516,
-0.2265639901,
-0.874800384,
0.3667771816,
-0.1446969211,
-0.2498525381,
0.3990409374,
0.2316722274,
-0.314409107,
-0.0065889326,
-0.7261602879,
1.0511231422,
0.1834780276,
-0.4186612368,
-0.0563798361,
-0.8044843674,
0.1655193865,
-0.1234539673,
-0.0823765844,
0.2616588175,
0.4621752203,
0.8213424683,
-0.3552599251,
0.8489230871,
-0.2847567797,
0.1189713702,
0.066481486,
0.0666208938,
0.5473752618,
-0.1281813979,
-0.1607175767,
0.1193416044,
-0.1380157918,
-0.2844753563,
-0.5165863633,
0.4175073206,
-0.9217445254,
-0.9398114681,
-0.5514196157,
-0.2824446857,
-0.0159783363,
0.3241941333,
0.3755222559,
0.2168894261,
-0.2370397598,
0.4407545626,
0.4479959011,
0.2152347714,
0.56369555,
0.3954649866,
0.1094142869,
-0.5285412669,
0.670719862,
0.0728155971,
0.0496292636,
0.5469269156,
0.0819564089,
-0.5874341726,
-0.4231939316,
-0.278598249,
0.3746888041,
-0.5421003103,
-0.5179105997,
-0.7742506266,
-0.3863007426,
-0.6920431852,
-0.1937842667,
-0.3692248166,
-0.4655538201,
-0.2133062035,
-0.2781202495,
-0.0162778422,
0.5052651763,
-0.1963271946,
0.3501464427,
-0.5285616517,
-0.0418339185,
0.4846041799,
0.243680656,
-0.3473772407,
-1.0181500912,
0.0534017608,
-0.0031465907,
-0.2407649904,
-0.8725592494,
0.5476552844,
0.1886383891,
0.2698596716,
0.1966916025,
-0.0992937833,
0.6948111653,
-0.7387874722,
0.5756980181,
0.037981566,
-1.1074988842,
0.6443145871,
-0.03976411,
0.1111010686,
0.6647833586,
-0.0397964939,
-0.5749306083,
-0.3587478399,
-0.499091059,
-0.6280917525,
0.72336483,
0.2358617634,
0.1509628296,
-0.1822275966,
0.3361940682,
-0.235050112,
0.147779122,
-0.900194943,
-0.1853200048,
-0.5355240703,
-0.5001077652,
-0.5083922744,
-0.8917159438,
0.1898398697,
-0.2231670916,
0.9211419225,
-0.0351449996,
0.3633640707,
0.4088993967,
-0.3447399735,
-0.2151067406,
0.6333782077,
0.5122036338,
0.3696638346,
-0.4694997668,
0.5061255097,
0.1114933714,
-0.6279799342,
0.322710216,
0.4867710173,
-0.3667549491,
0.1666623205,
0.3799383044,
0.4208501279,
0.2974658012,
-0.440105021,
0.8800452352,
0.0797803849,
-0.2407578528,
-0.3997000456,
-0.3269175291,
0.0793946162,
0.400842905,
0.3361766636,
-0.0013261699,
0.236879468,
-0.1924131662,
0.3179010451,
0.2915240526,
-0.2836281955,
-0.3386792541,
0.758202374,
0.2829555571,
-0.3427146375,
0.8339046836,
-0.2891820073,
-0.8528155088,
0.4030331671,
1.0409929752,
0.9328684211,
-0.7085236311,
0.3241465986,
0.3564342558,
0.4747660756,
-0.0533837453,
0.2653056383,
0.2777192891,
-0.9120235443,
-0.3106554747,
-0.6137321591,
-0.1070824191,
-0.2438710332,
-0.6507021785,
0.2557210922,
-0.0334565677,
-0.0351868011,
-0.0892857388,
-0.138823241,
-0.552308917,
0.2868336141,
-0.0067469934,
0.4575564265,
-0.9214570522,
0.7951316237,
0.7079634666,
-0.3247836232,
-0.6494819522,
0.1437866092,
-0.2107304335,
-0.6867732406,
0.9142668247,
0.1937064379,
-0.1802708805,
0.1500425637,
0.0312449224,
-1.1175699234,
1.1795406342,
0.2683583796,
-0.8922708035,
-0.1423567832,
0.3115772605,
0.5090041757,
-0.1427764893,
0.457593739,
0.4903215766,
0.2233068645,
0.1440733373,
-1.0000814199,
0.1068844423,
-0.3523018062,
0.2860960066,
0.2489218563,
-0.6082820892,
0.9377547503,
-0.3546540141,
-0.0514354184,
-0.2028813362,
0.7655634284,
0.1126900539,
0.2438753247,
0.6261387467,
0.5862140656,
0.6355533004,
-0.1702317595,
0.6027068496,
-0.0911341459,
0.5519795418,
1.1248888969,
-0.1783459485,
1.0498725176,
0.6214938164,
-0.2331934422,
0.7746334076,
0.3878305554,
0.0398698114,
0.6061636209,
-0.02564466,
-0.0105904527,
-0.3596202135,
0.1023018211,
-0.2564766407,
0.5211194754,
-0.0536129326,
-0.5720980763,
-0.1610046923,
-0.0205865055,
-0.0339730792,
0.2007150054,
-0.1921267509,
0.5579074621,
-0.3244268596,
-0.7132073641,
0.4637619257,
0.2499458194,
0.5857112408,
0.0293478202,
-0.0413865335,
-0.6005914807,
0.5317484736,
-0.0596880727,
-0.6683536172,
0.2162943631,
-0.1537047625,
-0.3921556175,
-0.2586003542,
0.9002344608,
-0.7587900758,
-0.8409181833,
0.1814933866,
0.4721017182,
-0.1338257343,
-0.2795872092,
-0.2955046296,
-0.0699279234,
0.1625252068,
-0.2132014483,
-0.0986021012,
0.2257553637,
0.019501213,
0.4367686808,
0.4559822977,
-0.2233860195,
0.1382391453,
0.3913775384,
0.7180054188,
-0.7731055617,
-0.5484287739,
-0.7943282723,
0.3831073642,
-0.0213924907,
-0.0005837141,
0.7409357429,
0.5792261958,
0.8736115694,
-0.239695847,
0.5325850248,
0.1299828887,
0.7162441015,
-0.4383429885,
0.4291746914,
-0.310251832,
0.0663464889,
-0.2639248073,
-0.9084388614,
-0.4986031651,
0.6926885247,
-0.5672613978,
-0.016782973,
0.6385535598,
0.9288288951,
0.0349685699,
-0.1035467163,
0.3273461163,
0.3661318719,
0.1713934541,
0.642203033,
0.511962235,
-0.7795642018,
0.6347601414,
-0.3415481448,
-0.1529261023,
-0.5807862282,
-0.4530173242,
-0.9295608997,
-0.5355293155,
-0.2570545077,
-0.6551042795,
0.4319405854,
0.9126604199,
0.3331320584,
-0.8965654969,
0.079304792,
-0.0936508477,
0.183969304,
-0.1650139987,
-0.2723359168,
0.6245914698,
-0.438632369,
-0.8982104659,
0.2249459177,
0.0456295237,
-0.1023450792,
0.0768351853,
0.1924678534,
-0.2583283186,
-0.1669177562,
0.7462881207,
-0.2075033337,
-0.7941609621,
-0.4981546402,
0.2278840244,
-0.2407889217,
0.0371220186,
0.5488948822,
-0.7812053561,
0.3696556687,
0.2661713958,
0.626758635,
0.4298488498,
0.2032542229,
0.4544903338,
-0.7552442551,
-0.0272443481,
0.1286907196,
0.4512014389,
0.279943645,
-0.4467805624,
0.4587420225,
0.5193700194,
-0.5548635125,
-0.6154661775,
-0.1168709844,
-0.882740438,
0.0728642642,
1.1699655056,
0.049735073,
-0.2557569146,
0.1456242353,
-0.2321864069,
0.369738102,
-0.2699169517,
0.9100138545,
0.6134970784,
0.3020841777,
-0.3757585883,
0.0588110387,
0.2823435366,
0.9406767488,
-0.3896797299,
-0.0565547347,
0.4928120971,
0.5289554596,
0.2381535023,
0.5209171176,
-0.0490125455,
0.434253633,
-0.1691177934,
0.3010317683,
0.062208578,
-0.4502995312,
-0.5187829137,
0.1493766159,
-0.0118960449,
-0.5172243714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12995v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12995v1 | MaNtLE: Model-agnostic Natural Language Explainer | 2023-05-22T12:58:06 | 2023-05-22T12:58:06 | Rakesh R. Menon, Kerem Zaman, Shashank Srivastava | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Understanding the internal reasoning behind the predictions of machine
learning systems is increasingly vital, given their rising adoption and
acceptance. While previous approaches, such as LIME, generate algorithmic
explanations by attributing importance to input features for individual
examples, recent research indicates that practitioners prefer examining
language explanations that explain sub-groups of examples. In this paper, we
introduce MaNtLE, a model-agnostic natural language explainer that analyzes
multiple classifier predictions and generates faithful natural language
explanations of classifier rationale for structured classification tasks.
MaNtLE uses multi-task training on thousands of synthetic classification tasks
to generate faithful explanations. Simulated user studies indicate that, on
average, MaNtLE-generated explanations are at least 11% more faithful compared
to LIME and Anchors explanations across three tasks. Human evaluations
demonstrate that users can better predict model behavior using explanations
from MaNtLE compared to other techniques | [
-0.305067271,
-0.9300923944,
0.3730139732,
0.1439211071,
-0.2794214189,
-0.1888609678,
-0.1878642142,
-0.2151247412,
-0.4434924424,
0.4510766566,
-0.8200319409,
-0.310734868,
-0.4083748162,
-0.0192019586,
-0.4489244223,
1.1661583185,
-0.0837949812,
-0.151273936,
-0.279764235,
0.1575482935,
-0.566429615,
-0.2266901731,
-0.7141386867,
-0.6880010962,
0.4204601049,
0.3028565347,
1.1542246342,
0.8840655684,
0.2060017437,
0.2804659307,
0.3792048097,
0.1251589805,
-0.024222061,
0.2089990675,
-0.3753160536,
-0.5143929124,
-0.1974094212,
0.0660701767,
0.4487640858,
0.8146784902,
-0.0102782641,
0.3289906383,
-0.0119903283,
0.5388324261,
-0.5405827165,
0.2591570616,
-0.9632634521,
0.0676998794,
-0.0417280421,
-0.3389464021,
-0.5851027966,
-0.2787128687,
0.3495903015,
-0.6795881391,
0.8017466664,
0.1490455866,
0.6331062317,
0.5733135343,
-0.401030153,
-0.5098136663,
-0.8371400833,
0.9827613831,
-0.3900409639,
0.3798416257,
0.2486930639,
0.707633853,
-0.1254911721,
-0.3905800879,
-0.9194911122,
-0.1583417505,
-0.1469921023,
0.2928704619,
0.0392997004,
0.1090389937,
-0.1997285038,
0.5530314445,
-0.746198833,
0.0509695038,
-0.1234747916,
-0.2911498547,
0.648317039,
0.0333094299,
0.3371616304,
-0.2523699403,
-0.2711360157,
0.0021496895,
-0.5457698107,
0.2650963664,
0.4334262908,
0.3124564886,
0.1166925877,
0.4976765811,
0.1912396103,
1.1754826307,
-0.0864453986,
-0.2333145738,
-0.1764490902,
0.2500157654,
-0.6676821113,
0.5852898955,
0.6046484709,
0.2300367951,
0.2546339035,
-0.7050352693,
0.1883082986,
0.9077270031,
0.4577590823,
-0.8265390992,
-0.5334932804,
0.6191520691,
-0.5170043707,
-0.6087520719,
-0.2031194121,
-0.3926994503,
-0.5051921606,
-0.52631253,
0.2084578276,
-0.4020653069,
-0.365101099,
0.1323619634,
-0.4148693681,
-0.0135571733,
0.4348421395,
-0.8757402301,
0.3610987067,
0.6377403736,
0.5362273455,
-0.0973636732,
-0.1321279109,
-0.4291256666,
0.307307899,
-0.3099239469,
0.8248426318,
-0.6209564805,
-0.3053381741,
-0.1980043799,
0.0301394351,
-0.1244283244,
-0.362044245,
0.6851687431,
-0.4012575746,
0.6230319738,
0.0831149593,
-0.4973277152,
-0.706780076,
0.3085617423,
-0.3411273658,
1.1811538935,
-0.1728519648,
-0.8864069581,
0.4371069372,
-0.9962676167,
-0.2672187388,
0.0546121486,
0.0181095172,
-0.1781803966,
0.2059042454,
0.3113974035,
0.6443486214,
-0.5245438814,
0.5653838515,
-0.3746678829,
-0.1584659815,
0.2043622732,
-0.7792730331,
0.9845027328,
0.449075371,
-0.4516732395,
0.2405147851,
-0.6874988079,
0.0880522877,
0.342789501,
-0.1224086359,
-0.1380633414,
0.2847358286,
-0.2403826714,
0.0301464833,
-0.1682233363,
-0.4434189796,
-0.0390539654,
-0.3975221515,
0.5103809834,
0.6413269043,
-0.2515848577,
0.4029605985,
-0.41997841,
0.5093280673,
-0.0634071901,
0.0147965485,
-0.5829077363,
-0.4671678245,
-0.4934027791,
-0.3191798925,
0.0246033948,
0.5039784312,
-0.405315876,
-0.0634096786,
-0.3564543128,
-0.5628599524,
-0.8755842447,
0.1925368458,
0.4123702645,
0.8085433245,
0.4762695432,
0.056184873,
-0.4024689794,
-0.988579154,
-0.8576937914,
-0.2574402392,
-0.139040187,
0.3804189563,
0.3613016009,
-0.2713705003,
1.3707959652,
-0.077034995,
0.1076314449,
-0.2696084976,
0.2471006811,
0.4233018756,
0.2464665025,
0.4915610552,
-1.098519206,
-0.5154072642,
0.1357612461,
-0.8555966616,
0.1527219415,
-0.3425464034,
-0.1059470773,
0.1588701904,
0.2415386736,
-0.5076426268,
0.4933022261,
0.536441505,
0.0868913755,
0.5950944424,
-0.3112672269,
-0.2394696772,
-0.8448597193,
-0.0997149572,
0.1736145169,
-0.2960494459,
-0.7149071097,
0.164865464,
-0.1308693439,
-0.0370847285,
-0.1814010441,
0.6748619676,
-0.4687689245,
0.0402469002,
-0.3762599826,
0.346480757,
0.1826655716,
0.1925099641,
0.102262862,
0.3775054514,
0.8516395688,
-0.9819289446,
0.4865718484,
0.1352788806,
-0.040693488,
0.2130277902,
-0.8268439174,
0.1644400805,
-0.4102786183,
0.4787514806,
-1.1946378946,
-0.581299305,
0.1656970084,
-0.611087501,
0.2224782705,
-0.6293790936,
-0.3838577271,
-0.9020382166,
-0.0096395155,
-0.0151240621,
0.4078993797,
-0.8463763595,
0.9111666679,
0.1806032509,
0.1935595274,
-0.7219555378,
-0.6438435316,
-0.1744743586,
-0.3658943772,
-0.8866409659,
0.6130247116,
-0.2805221379,
-0.4684293866,
0.214875564,
-0.4656279981,
-0.2278272659,
0.7003186941,
0.6452963352,
0.3458093405,
-0.3402451277,
0.3756811917,
0.0568068251,
-0.1683507562,
0.3818732798,
-0.6555732489,
0.3643896878,
-0.3773842156,
-0.3903293312,
-0.6523378491,
-0.1902382076,
0.4704393148,
0.0498416685,
0.8902356029,
0.7199562192,
-0.3110282421,
-0.3280411065,
-0.3810933828,
-0.1892274469,
-0.4394702613,
0.0546494164,
-0.5989977121,
-0.4793123007,
0.4329547286,
-0.0833736062,
0.4548573196,
0.7751989961,
0.5263182521,
-0.0378689878,
1.3539500237,
0.3368887305,
-0.0883687958,
-0.0835102201,
0.0558840446,
0.3927654922,
-0.5063792467,
-0.1259067059,
-0.520791769,
-0.1496616602,
-0.5044311285,
-0.2368446141,
0.120575361,
0.2375208586,
-0.232077986,
0.1424367577,
-0.976051867,
0.6280272603,
0.3974725604,
-0.2333411276,
0.0495624952,
-0.0969459862,
-0.1246980727,
0.2238598168,
-0.7437630892,
-0.7273373008,
0.7910946012,
0.3604103327,
0.5631879568,
0.1882988811,
0.4558071792,
0.2619844377,
0.7244622707,
-0.7818539143,
0.083961308,
-0.0463148579,
-1.2678451538,
-0.308532536,
-0.3188120723,
-0.8300319314,
0.6251647472,
-0.3988896012,
-0.5423762202,
-0.5477790236,
0.8455408812,
-0.1647447944,
0.2837888002,
-0.740000844,
1.1950801611,
-0.335016191,
-0.246841684,
-0.2747631371,
-0.6731549501,
0.5788105726,
0.2126286626,
0.7113150358,
-0.0848257169,
0.5144335032,
0.3680818379,
-0.3811166883,
0.8586764336,
-0.4662821293,
0.0789571851,
0.3538953364,
0.4555975795,
0.3726190329,
0.0461593047,
-0.492940098,
-0.2275240719,
-0.3888188004,
-0.4011420608,
-0.7882583737,
0.5866532326,
-0.6766593456,
-0.765242219,
-0.1109091118,
-0.5607356429,
0.0397969782,
0.1415558308,
0.2165035456,
0.5968886018,
0.0203542132,
0.136714071,
0.7230352759,
-0.2827704549,
0.3437430859,
0.1962389648,
-0.190077737,
0.0445338376,
1.0430464745,
-0.3194803894,
0.1043730229,
0.3456825614,
0.735039711,
-0.3540378511,
-0.7682338357,
-1.0144549608,
0.0325280316,
-0.7061853409,
0.1793014407,
-0.6832692623,
0.0493123308,
-0.2408276051,
-0.5129380822,
-0.0748068914,
-0.6149727702,
-0.0760624781,
-0.2267025858,
0.220672816,
0.7983955145,
0.4634441137,
0.7432501316,
-0.6259897351,
0.5502092838,
0.424898088,
0.1233606264,
0.0573707856,
-0.696388185,
0.1042810753,
0.2729868591,
-0.3492262065,
-0.9315927625,
0.4320308566,
0.4303105175,
0.8119421601,
0.6273385882,
0.0722425058,
0.88355726,
-0.5204070807,
0.902173996,
0.1368665099,
-1.1733640432,
0.7197089791,
-0.3772490323,
0.2312525958,
0.2615042925,
0.6271108985,
-0.484767735,
-0.3942704797,
-0.7376452088,
-0.7749380469,
0.9596472383,
0.1604696363,
0.0902934223,
-0.0274500772,
0.5038936734,
0.561168313,
0.2551053166,
-0.8950491548,
-0.4609750509,
-0.7683132887,
-0.3078120053,
-0.0589604191,
0.0636009425,
-0.163529709,
0.0718196183,
1.0473614931,
-0.4634956419,
0.2168675214,
0.0603054762,
-0.6281339526,
-0.2322823852,
0.2354656756,
0.4746188521,
0.7007200122,
-0.1379934847,
0.5583140254,
0.182195425,
-0.1261721104,
-0.3628750145,
0.11467655,
0.1645907462,
0.1522220075,
0.5163168311,
0.7750894427,
-0.0525316186,
-0.2362601012,
0.2659599185,
-0.0272486322,
-0.2720782459,
-0.5863746405,
0.2471513152,
0.2155680805,
-0.1514329463,
0.3007726669,
0.4305302799,
0.2467685193,
-0.6503705978,
-0.2046426237,
0.5435855985,
-0.7292433977,
-0.5770789981,
0.9223684669,
0.0407794788,
-0.2149447501,
0.5583776832,
-0.1947558075,
-0.8397215009,
0.513864398,
0.6501809955,
0.6075662374,
-0.3335565627,
0.4061373174,
0.1180568337,
0.3449744582,
-0.000775061,
0.0198814236,
-0.3427885175,
-0.9183350205,
-0.5278835297,
-0.5859418511,
-0.5016980767,
-0.2032813132,
-0.6791556478,
0.0936299115,
-0.3981848657,
0.167811811,
0.70765692,
-0.2912211716,
-0.7645316124,
0.4199205935,
0.2302563936,
0.8392932415,
-0.9691645503,
0.7057614326,
0.8330094814,
-0.2137578726,
-0.7221079469,
-0.2321055233,
0.2674372792,
-1.1234652996,
0.8296001554,
0.5647078156,
-0.3730529547,
-0.2936547399,
-0.529181242,
-0.4438186288,
0.9150201082,
0.4548392296,
0.0479281172,
0.0924455225,
0.0018030249,
0.519694984,
-0.3668790758,
0.7900964022,
0.1647115052,
0.6691319942,
-0.0408964641,
-0.8675840497,
0.0272647981,
-0.219711706,
-0.0798214376,
0.085702002,
-0.2286504507,
0.7253516316,
-0.2113333493,
-0.2144346237,
-0.3813855052,
0.6819708347,
0.1815948486,
0.5206074715,
0.8319599032,
0.3623718619,
1.095782876,
-0.1266016513,
1.570417881,
-0.25972417,
0.1362773776,
1.0082814693,
-0.0016919668,
0.4162280262,
0.1288655251,
-0.1049352959,
1.1564321518,
0.8264758587,
0.3632971048,
0.2594201267,
0.3799568117,
-0.2024193704,
-0.6421812773,
-0.0415848307,
-0.1201434657,
0.4056616724,
0.4056141675,
-0.42157951,
-0.2467615455,
-0.1313052773,
0.0891203433,
-0.0748635381,
-0.3163366616,
0.5523420572,
-0.2009113729,
-0.8329971433,
0.5575219989,
0.0444528237,
0.2677144408,
-0.3303540051,
-0.0094031328,
0.4236354828,
0.4962769449,
-0.3980767429,
-0.5970901847,
0.3943471909,
-0.1103813574,
-0.6014668345,
-0.6178582311,
0.7448957562,
-0.1740970314,
-0.2810460627,
-0.0440348573,
0.18968907,
0.5148935914,
-0.3871145248,
-1.0050077438,
-0.3132573962,
0.0520255603,
-0.2346361578,
-0.019863952,
0.6372188926,
-0.2757257223,
0.9693511128,
0.9114269018,
-0.3863206804,
0.1152001545,
-0.0751654655,
0.7731510997,
-0.3913487494,
-0.4549447894,
-1.0203396082,
0.6692681909,
-0.016492147,
-0.0918030217,
0.869535327,
0.4703217745,
0.5989931822,
-0.1234875247,
1.139460206,
0.0858667195,
0.6830376983,
-0.2737500966,
0.2791927457,
-0.4529641271,
0.16511859,
0.0185520891,
-1.0580925941,
-0.3141091466,
0.8753113747,
-0.2262083739,
-0.1247343048,
0.6417612433,
0.3564661443,
-0.3369621634,
0.6584078074,
-0.0533886701,
0.3679923713,
0.3553555906,
-0.1500945389,
0.7961689234,
-0.108619459,
0.5262566805,
-0.1431212425,
-0.1572368145,
-0.3022786975,
-1.1843329668,
-1.143843174,
-0.1898769736,
-0.2975877523,
-0.2340894192,
-0.0535865724,
0.9153364897,
1.0403918028,
-0.9450961947,
-0.0725431889,
-0.4575199485,
0.3714452386,
-0.2730284035,
-0.3176993728,
0.3406426907,
-0.5096701384,
-0.4914464951,
0.619089663,
0.0112757552,
-0.2574304342,
-0.3806315064,
-0.0991595984,
0.4926231802,
-0.0333903842,
0.4108262658,
0.1384885609,
-1.1306428909,
-0.2367413193,
0.0616624244,
0.4892309308,
-0.2575110793,
0.8035565019,
-1.1197400093,
0.7609840035,
0.3001467884,
0.5963582397,
0.6122748256,
-0.0638021678,
0.6574686766,
-0.5705065131,
-0.0457236767,
0.1058876365,
0.1670431942,
0.3693309724,
-0.3665519357,
0.4732550979,
0.0713600665,
-0.4734886587,
-0.9822487831,
0.2463758141,
-0.8939156532,
-0.5206996799,
0.8412787318,
-0.1861053705,
-0.4352097213,
-0.39239043,
-0.0255938563,
0.3370589018,
-0.2874368131,
0.7629934549,
0.6935684085,
-0.3170223832,
-0.0412287824,
-0.8699625731,
0.5213570595,
0.4333570004,
-0.6928109527,
0.3185520768,
0.3065426648,
0.276281476,
0.3391250372,
0.1345127076,
0.0473582484,
0.2557958066,
-0.2425411195,
0.1479679942,
-0.2592679262,
-0.4569745362,
-0.0162443183,
0.1288871765,
-0.0389148258,
0.0034088658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12990v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12990v2 | Sentence Representations via Gaussian Embedding | 2023-05-22T12:51:38 | 2024-02-20T14:23:58 | Shohei Yoda, Hayato Tsukagoshi, Ryohei Sasano, Koichi Takeda | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent progress in sentence embedding, which represents the meaning of a
sentence as a point in a vector space, has achieved high performance on tasks
such as a semantic textual similarity (STS) task. However, sentence
representations as a point in a vector space can express only a part of the
diverse information that sentences have, such as asymmetrical relationships
between sentences. This paper proposes GaussCSE, a Gaussian distribution-based
contrastive learning framework for sentence embedding that can handle
asymmetric relationships between sentences, along with a similarity measure for
identifying inclusion relations. Our experiments show that GaussCSE achieves
the same performance as previous methods in natural language inference tasks,
and is able to estimate the direction of entailment relations, which is
difficult with point representations. | [
-0.2130785137,
-0.5899171233,
0.8732915521,
0.4012328684,
-0.2966946959,
-0.229868114,
-0.1655323505,
-0.1917062998,
0.5133139491,
0.3507905006,
-0.576489985,
-0.7436414361,
-0.5886089206,
-0.0793118775,
-0.3190873265,
0.5714245439,
-0.088576287,
0.1213318557,
-0.7146838903,
-0.3232690096,
-0.161650762,
-0.5411261916,
-0.2236117423,
-0.0219241139,
0.2647442818,
0.1455084831,
0.8162745833,
0.4089205563,
0.2930026054,
0.2228622437,
0.0526262224,
-0.1757255793,
-0.1690410525,
0.5889427662,
-0.2918245494,
-0.4758390486,
0.4577656984,
0.1107208356,
0.4745750129,
1.0411721468,
-0.160356164,
-0.3532939851,
0.4934541583,
0.3869954348,
-0.7457104325,
0.1875875592,
-0.2200417221,
0.268918246,
0.210447982,
0.0219735634,
-0.1795320958,
-0.3615117967,
0.4016452134,
-0.540553689,
0.5096316934,
0.1074128672,
1.0754853487,
-0.0881442502,
-0.6512318254,
-0.9455019832,
-0.3574384451,
0.8748714328,
-0.5199155211,
0.4270348251,
0.3703271747,
0.2433786392,
-0.1952682287,
-0.4052696228,
-0.5865972638,
-0.4951029122,
-0.2232973427,
0.142541036,
-0.122346215,
-0.0196638443,
-0.0421587713,
0.2392946929,
-0.518728137,
-0.2631393373,
0.2375466079,
0.2177091688,
0.6091545224,
0.1286199093,
0.3432801664,
-0.1541476697,
-0.5679591894,
-0.3727017343,
-0.462003082,
0.0611028709,
0.3041166961,
0.2435225099,
-0.3109241724,
0.6023982167,
0.0139549496,
0.1583327651,
-0.1331588328,
0.6267547011,
0.45853585,
-0.2035770416,
-0.390376389,
-0.3100890815,
0.8478298783,
0.2422671467,
0.1303108186,
-0.3196112514,
0.1496769041,
0.264922291,
0.150301829,
-0.7629957199,
-0.4481917024,
-0.0395641476,
-0.3638572693,
-0.1120996401,
0.5688030124,
-0.7896168828,
-0.478554219,
-0.0959180892,
0.1649829298,
-0.784642756,
0.3155511916,
-0.0016756554,
-0.3315322697,
0.2662110627,
0.1142079905,
-1.0567350388,
0.6838153601,
0.5266051888,
0.951793611,
0.0785241276,
-0.2065196782,
-0.5952028036,
0.3254685402,
-0.2537465692,
0.664635241,
-1.0874239206,
-0.4085270762,
0.4508046806,
-0.0206470769,
-0.1632151753,
-0.3305145204,
0.5990983844,
-0.2658251822,
0.2705518007,
-0.3189684749,
-0.8316506743,
-0.4284066856,
0.0848173872,
-0.4219053388,
0.6921308637,
-0.0471947566,
-0.7972396016,
0.4081905186,
-0.1720026881,
-0.3884627819,
-0.2011538148,
-0.6099292636,
-0.7359058261,
0.3359417915,
0.4562374055,
0.8206905723,
0.0875936523,
-0.110684447,
-0.7451973557,
-0.3412377536,
0.1744209528,
-0.1627130657,
0.9627387524,
0.1092041582,
0.0103015099,
0.0132300491,
-0.591514945,
-0.340623647,
-0.048552148,
0.0138342502,
-0.8204742074,
0.2515219152,
0.1090952158,
0.1338877976,
-0.0645303056,
-0.6039515734,
-0.0803204551,
-0.524646759,
0.3586764932,
0.2140824944,
0.4273302853,
0.8766403198,
-0.08419168,
0.4679562747,
0.512129128,
-0.5209963322,
-0.1131438538,
-0.6269373298,
-0.50069803,
-0.2728539705,
-0.0106601128,
0.5536851287,
-0.4925578833,
0.6618284583,
-0.0649243668,
-0.0409761406,
-0.395198822,
0.2136165202,
0.0124910874,
0.066697374,
0.5337033272,
0.0164978243,
-0.3561833501,
-0.8817974329,
-0.2565861642,
0.1557367295,
-0.5889572501,
0.2585515976,
0.6144727468,
-0.1129685789,
0.7992301583,
-0.6970120668,
-0.3851630688,
-0.2310959995,
0.2963019609,
0.0485186465,
0.5125530958,
0.6788005233,
-0.6164106131,
-0.7041843534,
-0.0389151499,
-0.7733823061,
0.0876469389,
-0.1474382281,
-0.0303155351,
-0.1703017652,
0.753407836,
-0.3358719349,
0.5211639404,
0.4235464036,
-0.7398310304,
0.0427486077,
-0.6069427133,
0.1539867818,
-1.1099945307,
-0.3414960802,
0.3564532995,
-0.1755809635,
-0.4404201508,
0.0279304422,
0.2407140583,
-0.3037808537,
0.0817311555,
-0.0616896115,
-0.6535624862,
0.0970559642,
0.1499807388,
0.6335813999,
0.0870973319,
0.5414079428,
0.1562516838,
0.3056660295,
0.7759977579,
-0.4420779943,
0.1043435782,
0.4346040189,
-0.1407100707,
0.8315166235,
-0.5478101373,
-0.1410291195,
-0.4184319377,
0.1325180829,
-0.9139578342,
0.0828770027,
0.3692168891,
-0.4637846947,
0.0145702558,
0.1110844165,
-0.1690582633,
0.0590136424,
-0.6510360837,
0.182194531,
0.2409028858,
-0.3735857308,
0.5182503462,
0.0258258246,
-0.345012784,
-0.5545539856,
-0.9951671958,
-0.0538273305,
-0.3171366453,
-0.5785104632,
0.4481807053,
0.463442564,
-0.1931428462,
0.4153872132,
0.3577612638,
-0.1057888642,
-0.0505333208,
0.3841230571,
-0.0314208716,
-0.2887274623,
0.5953801274,
0.2861837745,
-0.0048154802,
0.0916057378,
-0.031214226,
0.2803004384,
0.2298180759,
-0.4941520989,
-0.2010345459,
1.0391130447,
-0.1288366318,
-0.1157238856,
0.7862561941,
0.4657497704,
-0.5058871508,
-0.4656342864,
-0.1124327257,
-0.1205929592,
-0.3831225634,
0.5460216999,
-0.3479186893,
-0.9994748831,
0.5203633904,
0.4021855593,
-0.2405617088,
0.3264986873,
0.1233697906,
-0.4096712172,
0.8489490151,
0.7637983561,
-0.1598114222,
0.4501647651,
-0.1335564256,
0.3710731268,
-0.5268670917,
-0.2265059501,
-0.7946275473,
-0.2873719931,
-0.682770133,
-0.7465903759,
-0.1076339334,
0.3442811072,
-0.4809228182,
0.2848907709,
-0.0355677716,
0.1942376643,
0.5119106174,
0.1521208286,
0.1408382952,
0.1602398008,
-0.3805162609,
-0.2934126258,
-0.4476222694,
-0.522269249,
0.6605679989,
0.3367261589,
0.5780572295,
0.1565535516,
0.9205360413,
-0.0378013775,
-0.1435440928,
-0.5587278605,
0.2836214006,
-0.4243475497,
0.2262983471,
-0.1326388866,
-0.3915519714,
-0.8034051657,
0.5629508495,
-0.4502332509,
-0.9222591519,
0.7404518723,
-0.2292406857,
-0.2224476635,
-0.0140013276,
-0.5662608743,
0.7789221406,
0.4037884474,
-0.1634705961,
-0.4326747656,
-0.4931829572,
-0.1471710354,
0.7858415842,
-0.137915194,
-0.1236101538,
-0.2668996751,
0.5962475538,
-0.4616899192,
0.6764088273,
-0.3902426362,
0.2988759875,
0.2424807698,
0.0068021747,
0.4217735231,
0.4245684445,
-0.0001299083,
-0.1494606435,
-0.1572364271,
-0.7272881269,
-1.0314958096,
1.0178955793,
-0.5859258175,
-0.2827661335,
-0.5431154966,
-0.6513708234,
-0.5663240552,
-0.2571533024,
0.0157193411,
0.3434026539,
-0.379003793,
0.2290286571,
0.5098346472,
-0.3178977072,
0.5631132722,
-0.0416220054,
-0.100646697,
-0.4862267673,
0.6136740446,
-0.050171338,
0.0741562098,
0.4596770406,
0.0411043428,
-0.3866128325,
-0.3919974864,
-0.111925438,
0.4032304883,
-0.6773332357,
0.1036213189,
-0.8524235487,
-0.0244984571,
-0.4215137661,
-0.8424864411,
0.307726264,
-0.2608130574,
-0.4837904274,
-0.3177853823,
0.247598514,
0.7551594377,
0.0208272859,
0.1642945558,
-0.4202589393,
0.1285537481,
0.2331212014,
0.1699805856,
-0.0047808676,
-0.1279070377,
-0.1222013682,
0.1025551781,
-0.5187430978,
-1.0725976229,
0.5210300088,
0.414740622,
0.6847016811,
0.6759801507,
-0.032330431,
0.507886827,
-0.4054140449,
0.8325863481,
0.2579464912,
-0.8827578425,
0.413305074,
0.0383464023,
0.2165374309,
0.4990259111,
0.6741776466,
-0.5686073303,
-0.6856697798,
-0.5649625063,
-0.6997491717,
0.1363661885,
0.2989761233,
0.5499081612,
-0.4641366601,
0.0034413727,
-0.0390020311,
0.13834548,
-0.5310761929,
-0.009579313,
-0.3782684505,
-0.7810093164,
-0.2473482043,
-0.2893381417,
0.2530554831,
-0.011244989,
0.416320622,
-0.0469653159,
0.6286933422,
0.3114445508,
-0.3673658967,
0.3778031468,
0.3657127321,
0.1842096746,
0.1380732507,
-0.2051444352,
0.4338982105,
0.1710454971,
-0.423455894,
0.0607048087,
0.364723146,
0.0023066471,
0.1327808052,
0.4840329289,
0.3641633391,
0.4326300025,
-0.4199900031,
0.9656144977,
0.2137799412,
-0.2522478402,
0.0431105271,
-0.1801512092,
0.5007303953,
0.4664247334,
0.2641503215,
-0.097521238,
0.4006515741,
-0.6969967484,
0.3793673813,
0.6232864261,
-1.0385630131,
-0.0601301193,
0.5917997956,
0.0671883896,
-0.0627952591,
0.6785470843,
-0.3448552191,
-0.4181133211,
0.4188455045,
0.5561673641,
0.9082790613,
-0.1396166235,
0.5499847531,
0.4259223938,
-0.0581168979,
0.1684117466,
0.3732935786,
-0.3273030519,
-0.7778430581,
-0.1287422329,
-0.3934318125,
-0.2245938778,
-0.4945934713,
-0.6435757875,
0.2769291997,
-0.4489813447,
0.4277586043,
-0.2832460105,
-0.0194565002,
-0.6726734042,
0.078352049,
0.0373200625,
0.7415128946,
-1.2840056419,
0.6668649316,
0.6245927811,
-0.7774012089,
-0.3476141095,
0.2553653121,
-0.2905780077,
-0.4027236998,
0.4438619912,
0.3621650636,
-0.0900139883,
-0.3962500691,
-0.3346813023,
-0.4863757789,
1.1600760221,
0.5085977316,
-0.4009135067,
0.12364503,
0.4187469482,
0.55706352,
-0.801646769,
0.2108972222,
0.1701548845,
-0.1256514937,
0.0105667748,
0.0115427719,
0.3060739636,
-0.1984342486,
0.5122916698,
-0.0616599135,
-0.0346836001,
0.7292370796,
-0.1762821674,
-0.493737638,
-0.023338737,
1.197508812,
0.1168491915,
0.2573344111,
0.3079208434,
0.5813278556,
0.8121938705,
0.0991124809,
0.8352410793,
0.0574852824,
0.5137759447,
1.0470715761,
-0.1143549681,
1.1753566265,
0.642072618,
-0.1178640351,
1.0079418421,
0.2048783898,
-0.0108813467,
0.8091552854,
0.2911652029,
-0.4405867159,
-0.1661948711,
0.2050243616,
-0.1427351087,
-0.1563835293,
0.4813117087,
-0.7827082872,
-0.4779702127,
0.1581228673,
-0.1482154429,
0.8378350735,
-0.1218992695,
0.5788090229,
0.4382546544,
0.1386056691,
-0.0234507136,
-0.1295350492,
0.7224009633,
-0.3891748786,
-0.3145893812,
-0.0034859679,
0.1443041563,
-0.0718322769,
-0.8452720046,
0.5101655722,
-0.5124578476,
-0.2205209732,
-0.0489114821,
0.4249464571,
-0.7978693843,
-0.616451323,
0.5189611912,
0.1403177232,
-0.2704616487,
-0.042001754,
-0.3617707491,
-0.3989623189,
-0.2450838238,
-0.138518393,
0.3706583381,
0.7060150504,
-0.0064742523,
0.6005997658,
0.0642997772,
-0.0714647919,
-0.0714612007,
0.0319840424,
0.5596631765,
-0.8232859969,
-1.0764123201,
-0.7310138345,
0.51618433,
-0.5334492922,
-0.2898978293,
0.7646229863,
0.3667882085,
0.6180042624,
-0.2015030831,
0.7647501826,
0.0920256898,
0.4751251638,
-0.3857315481,
0.426655978,
-0.0734437034,
0.0573226027,
-0.3020370007,
-0.989577353,
-0.5973421335,
1.1570044756,
-0.5047972798,
-0.1916551739,
0.9469079375,
0.8024166226,
-0.3265237212,
0.3968015313,
0.4260320365,
0.0422926731,
0.2277281582,
0.7409528494,
0.6029277444,
-0.4234297574,
0.4464176893,
-0.3534565568,
-0.0810244903,
-0.0851504281,
-0.7767746449,
-0.916626215,
-0.809484601,
-0.3248944879,
0.0607050136,
0.2703551948,
1.0366427898,
0.1903818697,
-1.1584976912,
-0.1803123504,
-0.3998280466,
-0.0519358069,
-0.6736046672,
-0.1775809824,
0.6045330763,
-0.6090329289,
-0.6543399692,
0.2084532827,
0.363045305,
-0.1549061537,
-0.2247392982,
-0.0596915185,
-0.4353893995,
0.2412576675,
0.5430487394,
-0.2874424756,
-0.4176056385,
-0.7514682412,
-0.3322622478,
-0.3660258055,
0.0628544912,
0.8269985318,
-0.5342716575,
0.2701960802,
0.673824966,
0.7743101716,
0.5276129246,
-0.0700111687,
0.8258045316,
-0.8833366036,
0.1799806058,
0.3537822068,
0.6668165326,
0.3547940552,
-0.1673705876,
0.1568622887,
0.0789231658,
-0.3111644685,
-0.2211731523,
0.2170131207,
-1.0149154663,
-0.1748014987,
0.9508494735,
-0.6908646226,
-0.0946663246,
-0.4167478383,
-0.0846465528,
0.0553007461,
-0.3326824009,
0.3779740334,
0.6181027889,
-0.000516319,
-0.2193209678,
-0.4500267208,
0.3333407342,
0.3427806795,
-0.5172379613,
-0.0801135004,
0.4792785347,
0.1867033988,
0.1100114211,
0.1082971245,
0.0054101557,
0.0815053508,
0.3811358511,
-0.1449164152,
0.0961862057,
0.1412519366,
-0.5155788064,
0.7360452414,
-0.2373555601,
-0.4363838136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12987v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12987v2 | GPT-SW3: An Autoregressive Language Model for the Nordic Languages | 2023-05-22T12:47:48 | 2023-05-23T06:59:16 | Ariel Ekgren, Amaru Cuba Gyllensten, Felix Stollenwerk, Joey Öhman, Tim Isbister, Evangelia Gogoulou, Fredrik Carlsson, Alice Heiman, Judit Casademont, Magnus Sahlgren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper details the process of developing the first native large
generative language model for the Nordic languages, GPT-SW3. We cover all parts
of the development process, from data collection and processing, training
configuration and instruction finetuning, to evaluation and considerations for
release strategies. We hope that this paper can serve as a guide and reference
for other researchers that undertake the development of large generative models
for smaller languages. | [
-0.3965319097,
-0.5862263441,
0.426392138,
0.0818114728,
-0.3972752392,
-0.1646666378,
-0.1518473029,
-0.4539754987,
-0.0826015845,
0.3732774258,
-0.5576793551,
-0.3835578561,
-0.6189388037,
0.1943693012,
-0.4801358581,
1.0112645626,
-0.38843894,
-0.0142063489,
0.461250335,
0.0284122992,
-0.2773600221,
-0.7635179758,
-0.8381245732,
-0.1099640653,
0.2580831051,
0.1339000911,
0.7739784718,
0.5663718581,
0.6214981079,
0.2223341167,
-0.0192541629,
-0.6849063039,
-0.2946415544,
0.2984028161,
-0.0440403372,
-0.3051106334,
-0.5414347649,
-0.1325033605,
0.7892833948,
0.2281436622,
-0.2625468671,
0.2464699596,
0.0553985722,
0.6175997853,
-0.0669435039,
0.4704118073,
-0.2386722565,
0.1652768105,
-0.4706915319,
0.198958382,
-0.1977616549,
-0.4950674474,
0.0702078417,
-0.4252977967,
0.7592958212,
-0.0633547604,
0.5076802969,
-0.060262721,
-0.3848193884,
-0.2141649425,
-0.897170186,
0.7152904272,
-0.7934783101,
0.3702142239,
0.519127667,
0.3021557033,
-0.0416983441,
-0.5282016397,
-0.4741105139,
-0.2128397375,
0.1202464998,
-0.0170464534,
0.1331977695,
0.0470171683,
0.0619571656,
0.6675643325,
-1.065335989,
0.2251506597,
-0.7091926932,
0.0632780939,
0.8873615861,
0.2494353205,
0.1660975218,
-0.1902210861,
-0.3021298647,
0.0817066655,
-0.9439680576,
-0.8648613095,
0.4559262693,
0.4344370961,
-0.3445468843,
0.8904816508,
0.0473446697,
0.789514482,
-0.2309688777,
0.0128199626,
0.2276848853,
-0.3700158596,
-0.0940543264,
-0.330347389,
0.9186972976,
0.0506352261,
0.026192341,
0.0697145909,
-0.7495715022,
-0.0830623358,
0.0691567212,
-0.4118942618,
-0.4563307166,
0.0142981336,
-0.6001156569,
-0.1359761506,
-0.3607578576,
-0.4147653878,
0.0797056779,
-0.3438211977,
0.2590679526,
-0.3560402095,
-0.9359593391,
0.1021979675,
0.0116656264,
0.3848009706,
0.316862613,
-1.1567856073,
0.3001844883,
0.7596937418,
0.8626023531,
-0.443325907,
-0.4264269471,
0.1233092397,
0.1452175379,
-0.4143300951,
0.5508019924,
-0.1090671942,
-0.7191294432,
0.0175300818,
0.0338348933,
0.2112615705,
-0.1888866723,
0.0829448327,
-0.6294062138,
0.4104188979,
-0.0087846899,
-0.3293252587,
0.0316677876,
0.2100182176,
-0.8073992729,
1.0478333235,
0.6200970411,
-0.7878084183,
0.5029925108,
-0.9208238125,
-0.355045855,
0.5291803479,
-0.1825910807,
-0.0921439677,
0.3513209224,
-0.153121978,
0.5583145618,
-0.6570526958,
0.4736530483,
-0.0157077126,
0.0284017976,
-0.5207170248,
-0.5001263022,
0.8045179248,
0.5136091709,
-0.4344367385,
-0.1325435191,
-0.6288357377,
-0.2171992958,
0.4037513137,
-0.4292693138,
-0.2471736223,
-0.1173030734,
0.1298970133,
0.3095389307,
0.277066648,
-0.6179505587,
0.264647752,
-0.0375990793,
0.36598894,
0.6685083508,
0.0527817421,
0.3352468014,
-0.0100453869,
0.8568153381,
-0.2303210944,
0.4912164807,
0.0011589426,
-0.7720910311,
-0.5642247796,
0.0417390503,
0.2507849038,
0.3995438218,
-1.0793322325,
0.2537579834,
0.0071502617,
-0.4664161205,
-0.288954258,
0.1770096123,
0.5093763471,
-0.0002849462,
0.0796547085,
-0.1738983393,
-0.5736826658,
-1.0856209993,
0.2995134294,
-0.581043005,
0.0156497452,
-0.3112333119,
0.6031155586,
-0.2501425445,
0.7622292638,
-0.4276154041,
-0.063530311,
-0.3667932153,
0.7091451883,
0.1081097275,
0.787883997,
0.648665905,
-0.8998413682,
-0.7710428834,
0.1604693383,
-0.5890838504,
0.1324765086,
0.4489034116,
0.0890292823,
0.5634672642,
0.5253298879,
-0.6924808621,
0.4408199489,
0.8615925908,
-0.3226759434,
0.7381290793,
-0.1355402917,
-0.1261212826,
-1.0617681742,
0.189741239,
0.0370792858,
-0.1734424829,
-0.4687081873,
0.2039567828,
-0.1118097827,
-0.3007973433,
-0.5383249521,
0.7724967599,
-0.8567823172,
-0.2454791814,
-0.0553276986,
-0.126193732,
-0.321747303,
0.2963883877,
0.489394635,
0.8964844346,
0.5552814603,
-0.6995294094,
0.3903074563,
0.2678122222,
-0.3591260314,
0.4477954507,
-0.7308641076,
0.0049383608,
-0.2254205346,
-0.008530952,
-0.7567380667,
-0.1366342753,
-0.1151678637,
-0.3929246068,
0.4029996693,
-0.5812658668,
-0.9129074216,
-0.8496188521,
0.4113720655,
0.3800131679,
0.6907320023,
-0.2922474146,
0.3553955555,
0.6240353584,
-0.8204276562,
0.0015003209,
-0.8086385727,
-0.1129821166,
-0.1201898083,
-0.3931170702,
-0.0193693824,
-0.0061809104,
-0.3338742554,
-0.1643569022,
0.2999279499,
-0.1142728701,
-0.1759001911,
-0.2322319448,
0.3272827566,
-0.5453446507,
0.0741568953,
-0.3485816419,
-0.2522674799,
0.0317446589,
-0.1907112002,
0.5177922249,
-0.3451980948,
-0.3427403867,
-0.1356337517,
0.680111289,
0.5219674706,
0.0090190778,
0.3850870728,
0.7314119935,
-0.1838122308,
0.11199449,
-0.671354413,
-0.0403235108,
-0.4777217507,
0.3157307506,
-0.5721587539,
-0.9786374569,
0.6761889458,
0.2896828651,
0.3064095378,
0.8273854256,
0.5437051058,
0.2390612066,
1.5650366545,
0.9691932201,
0.0144831883,
0.372772783,
-0.2495231628,
-0.0437621437,
-0.9062102437,
-0.0170024242,
-0.5231683254,
0.1070958897,
-0.5812889934,
-0.5157789588,
0.3133237958,
0.0121784434,
-0.5157904625,
0.4373530149,
-0.5713195205,
0.2612664104,
0.3935417533,
-0.6169974804,
0.2498322129,
-0.296680361,
-0.3021636903,
-0.0727633312,
-0.8139151931,
-0.3536330163,
0.8784111738,
0.5853465199,
0.9857613444,
0.5291489363,
0.8508426547,
0.1887565404,
0.8572730422,
-0.4142258763,
0.3597559929,
-0.2673842013,
-1.0548839569,
-0.511425972,
-0.3174632192,
-0.8268668652,
0.3454316258,
0.1332444549,
-0.4909648597,
0.1206123978,
0.2231670916,
-0.040332552,
0.2278016806,
-0.904589951,
0.9203140736,
-0.3492980897,
0.0051097106,
0.1247148886,
-0.5885578394,
0.5622153282,
-0.0737738684,
0.2285198718,
-0.146772787,
0.0161502007,
0.8081854582,
-0.4420903623,
0.9861667752,
-0.5627908707,
-0.6000223756,
0.3775364757,
0.470701158,
0.7152641416,
-0.1124285832,
-0.0233788677,
-0.1315568537,
-0.1633029133,
-0.3740147352,
-0.227927357,
0.6816174388,
-0.6425367594,
-0.5606472492,
-0.3496499956,
-0.1677963734,
-0.205296427,
0.3843931556,
0.4425846338,
0.1971013993,
-0.7724123001,
-0.038982369,
0.6167575717,
0.016475698,
0.6024981737,
0.9386128783,
-0.7646769285,
-0.5177785158,
0.7485305667,
0.0973996818,
0.4026756883,
0.0007795388,
0.2592304647,
-0.4802231789,
-0.8797149658,
-0.4905329049,
0.4408180714,
-0.5371749997,
-0.200887084,
-0.5533488989,
-0.1496416479,
-0.4873814881,
-0.2185163647,
-0.7561573386,
-0.389602989,
-0.2828690112,
-0.241813764,
0.5275021791,
1.4796401262,
-0.3350091577,
0.4829792976,
-0.7851758003,
0.4098789394,
0.4941213131,
0.4997287691,
-0.0938733667,
-0.4039252996,
-0.2167750597,
-0.0059881634,
-0.0087233316,
-0.4723316431,
0.6550605297,
-0.0625765249,
0.6300224662,
0.0348281823,
-0.1858331412,
0.2485693693,
-0.4349081516,
1.20617342,
0.5970447063,
-0.8290004134,
0.6091451645,
-0.8852671385,
0.6277223825,
0.3291019797,
0.3746391535,
-0.4910337329,
-0.3973229527,
-0.9307684898,
-1.0319658518,
0.5600495934,
-0.0697047859,
0.0442974418,
-0.3872898817,
0.03963162,
0.4261214733,
0.1735780537,
-0.7982690334,
0.0138041861,
-0.2256821394,
0.1524780244,
-0.4665574133,
-0.3189999461,
-0.143663004,
-0.3942338824,
0.6739106178,
-0.2200851142,
0.4849359989,
-0.0351834893,
-0.1264364719,
0.0480622761,
0.0706231892,
0.7480258346,
0.62113446,
-0.1226690486,
-0.1340483874,
-0.1215057224,
-0.7370241284,
0.2843210697,
0.1014409959,
-0.0601836033,
0.2330168635,
0.1540990174,
1.0419552326,
0.0615997687,
0.0156083554,
0.6074817777,
-0.1189585254,
-0.5403608084,
-0.6901204586,
-0.1745680273,
-0.0839520842,
-0.0950639024,
0.5240347385,
-0.3898217678,
0.0062371781,
-0.3347015083,
0.1946909577,
0.2839108109,
-0.4212736785,
-0.6023390889,
0.7219609022,
0.4670535326,
-0.0891300812,
0.6471936703,
-0.2429997474,
-0.5720264316,
0.5635994077,
0.9804039598,
1.1817957163,
-0.5782230496,
0.5656569004,
0.4560355544,
0.4693501592,
-0.5728983879,
0.6678211093,
0.101880379,
-0.4533678591,
-0.6673550606,
-0.7115481496,
-0.1925233305,
0.2514950335,
-0.8219846487,
0.1094759479,
-0.2389310449,
-0.5173245072,
-0.296708405,
-0.1841343641,
-0.8857103586,
0.2369680256,
0.0666856915,
0.9764899611,
-1.0986719131,
0.9174741507,
0.4364234507,
-0.3337804675,
-0.5334160328,
-0.2141188681,
0.0342841223,
-0.9016817808,
0.9458255172,
-0.5197473764,
-0.1141305342,
0.2864278257,
-0.6542409658,
-1.3473988771,
0.7706149817,
0.0036294162,
-0.462092191,
-0.0412826687,
-0.1408017278,
0.7786231637,
-0.4940767884,
-0.2115599811,
0.6476585269,
0.6672509909,
0.0995491147,
-1.1001273394,
-0.1847717762,
-0.3995304406,
0.4380713701,
0.6064670682,
-0.6333119869,
1.1354917288,
-0.2292060554,
-0.3651074171,
0.1548451781,
0.6891160011,
0.1019365937,
-0.5399640799,
0.07914453,
0.4231298566,
0.2193976939,
-0.0859395415,
1.2766765356,
-0.0731283575,
0.3065034151,
1.2325839996,
-0.2960003316,
1.0342589617,
0.3920807838,
-0.3823024929,
0.1537317932,
0.4846912026,
-0.029140329,
0.5382617116,
0.3693289459,
-0.3879885674,
0.2571173906,
0.451073736,
-0.6705345511,
0.3093231022,
0.6985667944,
-0.486867398,
-0.2716693878,
0.2982739806,
0.1742745936,
-0.4242222011,
-0.3744394481,
0.9608510137,
-0.0100764763,
-0.7851068974,
0.8347638845,
-0.0619036034,
0.7008653879,
-0.6984586716,
-0.0183439758,
-0.2066368312,
-0.111469619,
0.0192287099,
-1.106289506,
0.5041177273,
0.0500917658,
-0.1780082732,
-0.4332532287,
0.3269006908,
-0.6034684777,
-0.4179175794,
0.1451926529,
0.5133372545,
0.2908908725,
0.3518240452,
-0.7664043307,
0.2438050359,
0.0203347746,
-0.4219916761,
0.2494674325,
0.5225641727,
-0.1138855815,
0.5120872855,
0.4656050205,
0.2600402236,
0.1990265101,
0.1732479632,
0.6131840944,
-0.6967249513,
-0.5090839863,
-0.497938782,
0.6271978617,
0.166606918,
-0.472404331,
0.7385490537,
0.7040884495,
0.6764399409,
-0.4448316395,
1.3303169012,
-0.4888481498,
0.7263678908,
-0.511441052,
0.6832067966,
-0.0445595421,
-0.0761045069,
-0.1641436517,
-1.2187646627,
-0.4861725271,
0.5910778642,
-0.2787028253,
0.1598638147,
0.7328006029,
0.4598084092,
-0.0323541015,
0.1664253771,
0.3221462071,
0.3574511111,
0.294095099,
0.1809840351,
0.7274824977,
-0.3602423668,
0.1614052057,
-0.3043114245,
-0.2111121267,
-0.0517721809,
-0.9704049826,
-0.5775333643,
-0.9586086869,
-0.3625380993,
-0.2198587805,
0.0570573285,
0.5700284839,
0.7406346798,
-0.7054037452,
-0.3625614941,
-0.3622784913,
-0.2251044214,
-0.0761254355,
-0.2764407098,
0.3813276887,
-0.1855215728,
-0.4723670781,
0.3383655846,
0.0261787605,
0.9545347095,
-0.9121068716,
-0.2014632672,
-0.0962831452,
-0.3390376866,
0.7346119285,
0.7149451375,
-0.5800817013,
-0.209920764,
-0.38388592,
-0.2108134478,
-0.1793248951,
1.0057595968,
-0.3684546351,
0.3928557932,
0.4346913695,
-0.089849934,
0.8839764595,
-0.1979056895,
1.4436020851,
-0.7089244723,
0.321921438,
0.4172960222,
0.0730025992,
0.5420843363,
-0.3037866652,
0.7635495067,
-0.0267695878,
-0.6674106717,
-0.8019462228,
0.279240191,
-0.3409860134,
0.1040263101,
1.3391112089,
0.0363049917,
-0.2387778759,
-0.5894070268,
-0.072615914,
-0.141297847,
-0.1453069299,
0.401589781,
0.7904154658,
-0.0707743168,
-0.2721609175,
-0.9477074742,
0.9649390578,
-0.2675897181,
-0.5252197385,
0.428943336,
0.562722981,
0.2856117487,
0.1126474142,
1.0137876272,
-0.6040608287,
0.1853146851,
0.4283341467,
0.5634282231,
0.3547537923,
-0.3278754652,
-0.4711457491,
-0.0413483866,
0.5174971223,
0.1412873864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12962v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12962v2 | Distilling ChatGPT for Explainable Automated Student Answer Assessment | 2023-05-22T12:11:39 | 2023-10-24T10:59:50 | Jiazheng Li, Lin Gui, Yuxiang Zhou, David West, Cesare Aloisi, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Providing explainable and faithful feedback is crucial for automated student
answer assessment. In this paper, we introduce a novel framework that explores
using ChatGPT, a cutting-edge large language model, for the concurrent tasks of
student answer scoring and rationale generation. We identify the appropriate
instructions by prompting ChatGPT with different templates to collect the
rationales, where inconsistent rationales are refined to align with marking
standards. The refined ChatGPT outputs enable us to fine-tune a smaller
language model that simultaneously assesses student answers and provides
rationales. Extensive experiments on the benchmark dataset show that the
proposed method improves the overall QWK score by 11% compared to ChatGPT.
Furthermore, our thorough analysis and human evaluation demonstrate that the
rationales generated by our proposed method are comparable to those of ChatGPT.
Our approach provides a viable solution to achieve explainable automated
assessment in education. Code available at
https://github.com/lijiazheng99/aera. | [
-0.5590454936,
-1.0680935383,
0.4656397402,
0.102625601,
-0.1502587944,
0.253462702,
-0.2589779198,
-0.164129287,
-0.3190761507,
0.0936947837,
-0.6915795803,
0.0111980634,
-0.3048394024,
-0.0268827267,
-0.3610295653,
1.2480608225,
-0.2684078217,
0.0948964655,
-0.2495999932,
-0.2040614188,
-0.687538445,
-0.3870718479,
-0.9120315909,
-0.4520589411,
0.4717441797,
0.5297731757,
0.5820714831,
0.4789867103,
0.5052976012,
0.2864224911,
0.2566944063,
0.0468894839,
-0.3454841971,
0.036923714,
-0.2404624224,
-0.1537807882,
-0.415153712,
0.1670501083,
0.4623006284,
0.8220677972,
-0.3520437479,
0.4346610904,
0.5173328519,
0.3587790132,
-0.3004667461,
0.3661532402,
-0.3495930731,
-0.3256551623,
0.0901878253,
-0.065191403,
-0.5285593867,
-0.5340622663,
0.3631616533,
-0.5112111568,
0.0889188871,
-0.1536082476,
0.7506635189,
0.3993087113,
-0.352168262,
-0.3881976306,
-0.5668533444,
0.7556481957,
-0.426007241,
0.0789465606,
-0.0616125874,
0.7019427419,
-0.0211453568,
-0.9304870963,
-0.6758609414,
-0.3202917278,
-0.0954635814,
0.4507465363,
0.1108336225,
0.1698711812,
0.2502034903,
0.4781826437,
-0.5550590158,
-0.1434945166,
-0.2799687386,
-0.0851125494,
0.6561379433,
0.3133676052,
0.3605208993,
-0.0242461152,
-0.3463255167,
-0.1491760164,
-0.3723305166,
0.4359454811,
0.3102182746,
0.1742292643,
0.2190418541,
0.5844666362,
-0.1322445571,
0.6196061969,
0.1256609708,
0.1074042097,
-0.1797194183,
-0.2175412476,
-0.0089516593,
-0.1397131085,
0.8323780298,
0.368951261,
0.3113771975,
-0.0965819359,
0.0010768246,
0.4170570672,
0.1923115551,
-1.1871575117,
-0.5305716395,
0.4258109033,
-0.0693451464,
-0.2801611125,
0.0012444601,
-0.8849974275,
-0.1269827783,
-0.6054284573,
0.5228973031,
-0.4194929302,
-0.1515638381,
0.2675152123,
-0.0369616114,
0.3695859313,
0.7624924183,
-0.7076307535,
0.4006300867,
0.6555196047,
0.5069885254,
-0.2474486083,
-0.4071413279,
-0.5472472906,
-0.3096493185,
-0.2383243442,
0.8681156635,
-0.6922759414,
-0.110403873,
-0.3412077129,
-0.1758597791,
-0.2942350209,
-0.1618405879,
0.4906713665,
-0.4571811855,
0.702428937,
-0.2222183794,
-0.8010143042,
-0.5118703246,
0.389993757,
-0.4045239389,
1.1150605679,
0.2349333167,
-0.7046284676,
0.2694825828,
-0.7962517142,
0.0843231678,
0.3094882071,
-0.084504582,
-0.3301469088,
-0.2779510021,
0.337782234,
0.1458689123,
-0.2956322432,
0.4815064073,
-0.2040953934,
-0.318614006,
0.5100980997,
-0.8073340058,
0.7754693627,
0.1545809507,
-0.2736345232,
0.0103560658,
-0.5776106715,
0.5503140092,
0.0363110788,
-0.4390207231,
-0.0416011885,
0.0241964459,
0.0927118957,
0.1865661442,
0.2737923861,
-0.4231687784,
0.2265490294,
-0.0905731618,
0.6615766287,
0.7078946829,
0.1874436289,
0.243410334,
-0.5938922763,
0.7196813226,
-0.3516548574,
0.097315453,
-0.4886605144,
-0.5656926632,
-0.6135615706,
-0.3452224433,
0.5307307243,
0.506716013,
-0.489939779,
0.1037662178,
-0.1666833311,
-0.5335672498,
-0.723918736,
0.0703726634,
0.2222577035,
0.6608379483,
0.3320248425,
-0.3203718066,
-0.2979306579,
-0.5661574006,
-0.3357072473,
-0.511298418,
-0.3635320663,
0.1361169219,
0.4329363406,
0.0215237495,
1.1864807606,
-0.3625848591,
0.1055632383,
-0.2867199481,
0.2838141322,
-0.0265196636,
0.5504184961,
0.2754717171,
-0.7299615145,
-0.6566249728,
-0.0599368587,
-0.5715531111,
-0.4314771593,
-0.3667613566,
-0.2753456235,
-0.2728897035,
0.2528632879,
-0.4979144633,
0.1737349927,
0.1200346425,
-0.3250054419,
0.6682194471,
0.1216753945,
0.234015584,
-0.9639703631,
0.0301842317,
-0.2969397604,
-0.3283293545,
-0.1937713772,
0.4759760499,
-0.1167323515,
-0.1398318857,
-0.1657510698,
0.5229554176,
-0.1170931756,
0.3373707533,
-0.3171656132,
0.4508781135,
0.2880575061,
0.5832263231,
-0.2728615999,
0.7177646756,
0.3950731158,
-0.1672518551,
0.4916323423,
0.1651059836,
0.002544475,
0.5625709891,
-1.0582327843,
0.1426800191,
-0.0766610801,
0.4519324601,
-1.2460976839,
-0.4626812935,
0.2182183415,
-0.5204479694,
0.0674667135,
-0.5565689802,
-0.2474883646,
-0.3060102463,
-0.2354820967,
0.4776287377,
0.7629431486,
-0.6865922809,
0.6893788576,
0.281902343,
-0.4354324043,
-0.2620503008,
-0.1323226839,
-0.2178625464,
-0.4526595473,
-0.7200428843,
0.0825696215,
-0.4853908718,
-0.4144860506,
-0.0379761793,
-0.1331785172,
-0.3431811035,
0.2747460604,
0.1925197989,
0.4664555788,
-0.4037830234,
0.3491017818,
0.0006236725,
-0.0986309499,
0.3028228581,
-0.2884331346,
0.4936939478,
-0.5332719684,
-0.5497051477,
-0.3936967552,
0.4915792346,
0.7608997822,
-0.300109446,
0.2542229891,
0.4668737948,
-0.1339137554,
-0.3653999269,
-0.2730367482,
-0.4030268788,
-0.4914081991,
0.3400873542,
-0.2822384834,
-0.8119233847,
0.5817474127,
-0.1703191549,
0.5724611878,
0.3757403195,
0.6934401989,
-0.0607659929,
1.2420274019,
0.1725066304,
0.3116564155,
0.3215705752,
0.0757696182,
0.3299385011,
-0.5554044247,
-0.0503377616,
-0.4681303203,
0.0242419783,
-0.4945969284,
-0.2733666301,
0.151383251,
0.4510708451,
-0.087788187,
-0.066144824,
-0.607937634,
0.8754054904,
0.2938116789,
-0.0385082439,
0.1888032109,
-0.2277666181,
-0.1861601323,
0.1430443376,
-0.5980474949,
-0.8073534966,
0.9613609314,
0.3399130106,
0.6204398274,
0.0603069961,
0.6618467569,
-0.0101598399,
0.6701399684,
-0.976783216,
0.4670883119,
0.2485901713,
-0.5100415349,
-0.5770143867,
-0.3558543921,
-0.8351950049,
0.6173880696,
0.1487759501,
-0.730594933,
-0.5949710011,
0.2030830532,
-0.4484766424,
-0.3652229607,
-1.1855658293,
1.025275588,
0.0736116543,
-0.8079164624,
0.0081999442,
-0.2977111042,
0.3083431423,
-0.2513431013,
0.1148473397,
-0.2030798197,
0.3106561303,
0.8670914173,
-0.8555606008,
0.8000443578,
-0.1682643592,
-0.1283968538,
0.7823965549,
-0.0166372918,
0.2745069861,
0.5955178142,
-0.1188526228,
-0.3699546754,
0.3976493776,
-0.5270305872,
-1.0025060177,
0.608861804,
-0.5919873714,
-0.8674966693,
-0.2620078623,
-0.6853088737,
-0.2605436742,
0.0377101153,
-0.1046537012,
0.5807232261,
-0.0664585605,
-0.1101454496,
0.4426780939,
0.1050809398,
0.3040355444,
0.730723083,
-0.4275805652,
0.0562450513,
0.8755873442,
0.1151982844,
0.1405540705,
-0.2472613603,
0.4932036102,
-0.5577781796,
-0.2908644378,
-0.7685052156,
-0.0360914469,
-0.8087022305,
0.1067431122,
-0.389921993,
-0.2443893254,
-0.2584482431,
-0.22586824,
-0.3152043521,
-0.6331545115,
0.170667097,
-0.0387579612,
0.313885659,
0.6930269003,
0.1668215692,
0.5204299092,
-0.6884625554,
0.2156309783,
0.7495340109,
0.2979957759,
0.0038796386,
-0.6619166732,
0.1698563844,
0.4252172709,
-0.4958639145,
-0.7160790563,
0.1165644675,
0.3079390228,
0.4659767449,
0.1270665675,
0.4258261919,
0.8000219464,
-0.4892807305,
0.8250275254,
-0.0536123812,
-1.0876536369,
0.5309262276,
-0.3788151145,
0.4805473387,
0.7096813917,
0.1153036281,
-0.4496694207,
-0.7121444345,
-0.5928596854,
-1.0138667822,
0.6180928349,
0.257727325,
0.1791348457,
0.1005653217,
0.1982460767,
0.2730413675,
-0.1821151972,
-0.717246294,
0.0093813613,
-0.3393249512,
-0.5464764833,
0.2692273855,
-0.0032645932,
-0.2815111578,
-0.290120095,
0.678938508,
-0.2939412594,
-0.1340706944,
0.0591422133,
-0.0362954475,
0.1986138374,
0.5699336529,
0.174284488,
0.767806232,
-0.1042911559,
-0.0622061603,
0.1955922842,
-0.7085161805,
0.0287753157,
0.3620546162,
-0.0830074102,
0.0202178136,
0.3064987063,
0.3635199666,
-0.0934708267,
-0.8084763885,
0.6427881122,
-0.5800440907,
-0.2320039421,
-0.4837118387,
0.2609826922,
-0.0044809142,
0.0722876489,
0.3737384081,
0.0021630705,
0.1886146963,
-0.2500573695,
0.4591853917,
0.1262875944,
-0.3803651333,
-0.3361825049,
0.6035925746,
0.2777015269,
-0.0626775771,
0.6069961786,
-0.1981710047,
-0.5868751407,
0.72251755,
0.4073323309,
0.7365763783,
-0.3190829456,
0.4572999775,
0.5795850158,
0.1080855802,
-0.1127189398,
0.2634324431,
-0.3154137731,
-0.457421571,
-0.5744509697,
-0.7515354753,
-0.7932527661,
-0.0502879433,
-0.853054285,
0.2781676948,
-0.2328815609,
0.2344079614,
0.3956583738,
-0.119140625,
-0.3426603079,
0.2538071871,
-0.1781843305,
0.4185006618,
-0.7779896855,
0.8283832073,
0.7069675922,
-0.4694704115,
-1.4742093086,
0.110825941,
-0.0741713271,
-0.6857082248,
0.3215076625,
0.3179688454,
0.0597587898,
0.1506405175,
-0.3399318755,
-0.5013836622,
0.7294186354,
0.307155937,
-0.4485167265,
0.0331865437,
0.3496960402,
0.6942017674,
-0.1831707954,
0.8188048601,
0.5656898618,
0.3912006915,
0.2896668911,
-0.7812069654,
0.0166926868,
-0.4713787735,
-0.3964491189,
0.0844329745,
-0.4698830545,
0.7417899966,
-0.201627329,
-0.3794181049,
-0.1587205231,
0.3247722387,
0.3248651326,
0.3952349424,
0.4739055336,
0.3444882035,
0.8495958447,
-0.2209455967,
0.8104307055,
-0.1757367253,
0.5246284008,
1.3933393955,
-0.1114288419,
0.8059021235,
0.6467437744,
-0.3240997493,
0.4157357514,
0.6885874867,
0.0606897771,
0.116565071,
0.4901543856,
-0.3130158484,
-0.5099030137,
-0.028932754,
-0.2183493674,
0.7252534032,
0.3108492494,
-0.0143982694,
-0.6057460308,
0.0666997135,
-0.0635754317,
0.1273640096,
-0.2775451839,
0.6606725454,
-0.0316649191,
-1.2296512127,
0.6683818102,
-0.2578938305,
0.0424357727,
-0.4680739045,
-0.2250868529,
-0.2852655053,
0.2622843087,
-0.1606470793,
-0.8840223551,
0.3296435773,
0.2628653347,
-0.0325598046,
-0.2302675247,
0.2681724131,
-0.5910286307,
-0.4308973253,
-0.0636513755,
0.4679891467,
0.0973053649,
0.0785235763,
-0.6421784163,
-0.2420999408,
0.1969261467,
-0.3471593559,
0.1573310643,
0.7223755121,
-0.2062029243,
0.8027092218,
0.6982142925,
-0.3654106259,
0.2454785705,
0.1530578136,
0.9150810838,
-0.0992311016,
-0.6088200808,
-0.7424576879,
0.6584139466,
-0.0673828498,
-0.3381675482,
0.737598598,
0.4244795144,
0.7889103889,
0.1387792677,
1.0188852549,
-0.180248037,
0.7030500174,
-0.306861192,
0.6511883736,
-0.3208498955,
0.5558106303,
-0.2535531819,
-0.7472817302,
0.023919709,
0.5769115686,
-0.3264417052,
-0.1027534679,
0.8286933899,
0.5917179585,
-0.0093229394,
0.2681966424,
0.1339779198,
-0.0403917432,
0.4526233971,
0.6348325014,
1.3114420176,
-0.5649130344,
0.9581888914,
-0.1658589989,
-0.4349384308,
0.0585448816,
-0.591147244,
-0.9500690699,
-0.5530771613,
-0.8745608926,
-0.2552773356,
-0.1084415019,
0.7740308642,
0.4219781756,
-0.7838889956,
0.0323597454,
-0.2348079085,
0.0145096118,
-0.2569498122,
-0.3779712021,
0.3303247392,
-0.6977412701,
-0.8555216789,
0.005271873,
-0.0920026228,
-0.0189730059,
-0.0367449112,
-0.0439150743,
0.4438171983,
0.3394973278,
0.4017457366,
0.1678109318,
-0.7393199801,
-0.495436877,
-0.0475793034,
-0.2065968513,
-0.1168160439,
0.6239537597,
-0.7233330607,
0.5074154735,
0.5394661427,
0.6161317825,
0.1973290741,
0.299872905,
0.7122424841,
-0.4087678492,
-0.0949202776,
0.4036640227,
0.274538219,
0.1056157649,
-0.1461807191,
0.4304308593,
-0.0945888385,
-0.7511773705,
-0.7796003222,
0.0519201495,
-1.3652536869,
-0.2122395337,
0.9330233932,
-0.7385166287,
-0.1261850744,
-0.4237613678,
-0.6784693003,
0.1588356644,
-0.3326089382,
1.2416877747,
0.7937987447,
-0.0467362963,
-0.3146577477,
-0.4852965772,
0.4303995073,
0.512026906,
-0.9254380465,
0.3920127153,
0.5417707562,
0.364944458,
0.0450425595,
0.5188483596,
-0.2590481043,
0.5901605487,
0.131148234,
-0.168084085,
-0.0560556017,
0.0580399483,
-0.1138931066,
0.5201357603,
0.2108540088,
-0.2799898684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12951v1 | Cross-functional Analysis of Generalisation in Behavioural Learning | 2023-05-22T11:54:19 | 2023-05-22T11:54:19 | Pedro Henrique Luz de Araujo, Benjamin Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In behavioural testing, system functionalities underrepresented in the
standard evaluation setting (with a held-out test set) are validated through
controlled input-output pairs. Optimising performance on the behavioural tests
during training (behavioural learning) would improve coverage of phenomena not
sufficiently represented in the i.i.d. data and could lead to seemingly more
robust models. However, there is the risk that the model narrowly captures
spurious correlations from the behavioural test suite, leading to
overestimation and misrepresentation of model performance -- one of the
original pitfalls of traditional evaluation. In this work, we introduce BeLUGA,
an analysis method for evaluating behavioural learning considering
generalisation across dimensions of different granularity levels. We optimise
behaviour-specific loss functions and evaluate models on several partitions of
the behavioural test suite controlled to leave out specific phenomena. An
aggregate score measures generalisation to unseen functionalities (or
overfitting). We use BeLUGA to examine three representative NLP tasks
(sentiment analysis, paraphrase identification and reading comprehension) and
compare the impact of a diverse set of regularisation and domain generalisation
methods on generalisation performance. | [
-0.5229526162,
-0.8361778259,
-0.0158012677,
0.543794632,
-0.1077615321,
-0.0550405085,
-0.0110617569,
-0.3244221807,
-0.0336222686,
0.2596887052,
-0.5461663604,
-0.2789036036,
-0.5705635548,
-0.0943458602,
-0.4685295522,
0.9912363887,
0.135210529,
-0.0517493226,
-0.5499653816,
-0.4227851629,
-0.7822291255,
-0.8133237362,
-0.6096800566,
-0.6057600379,
0.3920403719,
-0.1790800989,
0.3417471647,
-0.057341896,
0.2454859912,
0.1084832773,
-0.4125027359,
0.0425092578,
-0.5347147584,
-0.3768260777,
-0.5236174464,
-0.6744866967,
-0.2595079839,
0.1055611446,
0.6106380224,
0.9555809498,
-0.2970034182,
0.1283970773,
0.5429121852,
0.6814203858,
-0.7369571924,
0.481025964,
-0.2083127052,
0.3618099689,
0.3460063934,
0.0234556012,
-0.2177234739,
-0.4614509344,
0.1739783883,
-0.3816672266,
0.1281906515,
-0.1522301584,
0.7439951301,
0.2486830354,
-0.3277925551,
-0.5012447238,
-0.7546387315,
1.01301229,
-0.4089201093,
0.5554249883,
0.6041972041,
0.2526116371,
0.0631553531,
-0.3776706457,
-0.2213409692,
-0.1601338834,
-0.4673626423,
0.2098496854,
-0.0904213488,
-0.1189410016,
0.1960071027,
0.3124592304,
-0.6852013469,
0.0315850191,
-0.5777518749,
-0.3052647114,
0.7760916948,
0.1451172084,
-0.0494740605,
0.0492363423,
-0.0149990711,
-0.307646066,
-0.4257442653,
0.4669825733,
0.3438108563,
0.2726571858,
-0.1862494051,
0.2818250656,
-0.0750447735,
0.5763026476,
0.1305936426,
-0.0680559576,
0.448522985,
-0.3750554919,
-0.3448880315,
-0.1982606202,
0.5481134057,
0.1019740626,
0.210496828,
-0.3629605174,
-0.2020693421,
0.1724206209,
0.5125018358,
-0.631298542,
0.0238000546,
0.197739929,
-0.5017874241,
-0.5214270949,
-0.1138511673,
-0.8812231421,
0.0317052156,
-0.2842899561,
0.5019333959,
-0.6569575071,
-0.1488219202,
0.3507508337,
-0.0623707138,
0.4905382991,
-0.1100857407,
-1.0185006857,
0.708789289,
0.8187564611,
0.7573149204,
0.0164091624,
-0.3266766369,
-0.5263009667,
0.0410504304,
-0.5029522181,
0.4365414381,
-0.6531960964,
-0.8113140464,
0.0879266933,
-0.1886754334,
-0.6103360057,
-0.7253126502,
0.4610902071,
-0.5346445441,
0.3357224762,
-0.4043708742,
-0.3477826715,
-0.5531620979,
0.369985491,
-0.4607457817,
1.3364566565,
0.3370347321,
-0.5033977628,
0.8273131847,
-0.7009957433,
-0.8452849388,
-0.411518693,
-0.139926821,
-0.5986666083,
0.1640270203,
0.2059146464,
0.6240139604,
-0.1756636351,
0.3552171886,
-0.3185991049,
-0.3161176145,
0.3635963202,
0.056394916,
0.5193787813,
-0.0022853627,
-0.2610092163,
0.0013048929,
-0.795209825,
-0.0866713524,
-0.205939427,
-0.3978746533,
-0.7471498251,
-0.1414460987,
-0.2558888197,
0.0839718431,
0.0135804256,
-0.3402661979,
0.184634611,
-0.0723634064,
0.2153083533,
0.4290828109,
-0.0591810159,
0.130307585,
-0.59027493,
0.4811437428,
-0.021153504,
0.463875562,
0.1240973175,
-0.55578053,
-0.3012978137,
-0.3142688572,
0.6543924809,
0.4744860232,
-0.3381019235,
0.6011604667,
0.0665626824,
-0.2714854479,
-0.3309956491,
0.1339273006,
0.6933264732,
0.3514668047,
0.430593431,
-0.6653080583,
-0.3323219121,
-0.7008885741,
-0.1947126091,
-0.1238997206,
-0.1808651984,
0.2435986698,
0.7910156846,
-0.7144985199,
0.8122239113,
-0.4255300462,
-0.4387649596,
-0.3083131611,
0.4876728952,
-0.0654351562,
0.5776022673,
0.8885447383,
-0.7623704672,
-0.0491055176,
0.2050151378,
-0.6216606498,
-0.229203254,
-0.1630913615,
0.1150585115,
0.1803614199,
0.3187339008,
-0.2109322697,
0.5403649807,
0.5863935351,
-0.0978418514,
0.8426032066,
-0.12028303,
0.0459934436,
-0.4543666244,
0.3206928372,
0.1341196895,
-0.1232980862,
-0.4182894826,
0.2587243319,
0.0521944202,
-0.1510663927,
-0.0028952421,
0.253225565,
-0.0120858541,
-0.4714561999,
0.2062704563,
-0.0908980817,
0.1585455984,
0.6573333144,
0.0268037114,
0.6603677273,
0.7799084187,
-1.0023018122,
-0.0398304909,
0.1906669885,
0.0235456694,
0.5121346116,
-0.7287403941,
-0.0088103954,
0.0640446693,
-0.1565154046,
-1.0208098888,
-0.0198352505,
0.0573940836,
-0.4382334948,
0.326831013,
-0.1402635574,
-0.1711424589,
-0.1486723572,
-0.3250018358,
0.2550156116,
0.6125025153,
-0.4641273618,
0.8811798096,
0.1583212316,
0.186632663,
-0.4030991793,
-0.7237300277,
-0.4962006211,
-0.4736381769,
-0.5676656365,
0.0862091109,
0.0597561151,
0.0050451388,
-0.3036865294,
-0.2840740085,
-0.2012580484,
0.1850624532,
0.0180680528,
-0.0150924744,
0.007032719,
-0.0134205855,
0.1883213669,
0.1330380291,
0.4598125219,
-0.0177385099,
0.7059717774,
-0.2911072075,
-0.2143415362,
-0.1044645384,
0.128378585,
0.2461619079,
-0.318519026,
0.5988026857,
0.719050467,
-0.2334146053,
-0.454836905,
-0.293787688,
0.0643284768,
-0.472783953,
0.3583484888,
-0.5323215127,
-0.4708218277,
0.7874354124,
-0.0268758759,
-0.075400658,
0.1837770343,
0.2241597772,
0.0079118386,
0.8090871572,
0.8620037436,
-0.0337790288,
0.317309916,
-0.6410278678,
0.2476281375,
-0.9643888474,
-0.6744800806,
-0.3875512481,
-0.0127144894,
-0.3453148901,
-0.325766474,
0.2253569365,
-0.09916877,
0.1156007349,
0.1867823303,
-0.3173196614,
0.0679462701,
0.4978046715,
0.1577396691,
0.1246080846,
-0.2022681981,
-0.5271846652,
0.0614839233,
-0.7220066786,
-0.2183744162,
1.3450584412,
0.3023107648,
0.7622041702,
0.0764753446,
0.6483209729,
0.4416251481,
0.3704215288,
-0.9284344912,
0.5352041125,
-0.0238492955,
-0.4918670058,
-0.2128593922,
-0.5657627583,
-1.1253992319,
0.4360060692,
-0.0983300582,
-0.7704671025,
0.3102338314,
-0.0298349559,
-0.5265957713,
0.0699994788,
-0.54597646,
0.8451634645,
-0.2047156543,
-0.3827182353,
-0.5359562039,
-0.2474844158,
0.6995074153,
-0.4633399546,
0.347350508,
0.4712035954,
0.1775430143,
1.0446923971,
-0.0581467561,
0.9990798831,
-0.0080593526,
-0.0528007969,
0.282381326,
0.2566021383,
-0.0498033911,
-0.014365484,
-0.0176149849,
0.2165680826,
0.4792689085,
-0.5255381465,
-0.8249879479,
0.3423966169,
-0.698045671,
-0.3805530667,
-0.6393969655,
-0.3370352387,
-0.6012868285,
-0.0627261102,
-0.0620062687,
0.6626828909,
-0.4825631082,
0.146418035,
0.8897081614,
-0.3149310946,
0.1683723181,
0.4511836469,
-0.6519636512,
-0.2894850969,
0.936237812,
0.0142878657,
0.2965441048,
0.1496682763,
0.4423162341,
-0.387450695,
-0.6935477853,
0.0657367036,
0.2196968794,
-0.5769645572,
0.2903450131,
-0.3580201268,
0.0321950503,
-0.6070138216,
-0.2170036435,
-0.1504285038,
-0.0810317546,
-0.178305313,
-0.042933438,
-0.130002588,
0.9136421084,
-0.5024063587,
0.555624485,
-0.6145803332,
0.3249258995,
0.5403932929,
0.4760402441,
0.1301570535,
-0.4572711587,
-0.3097131848,
-0.0608384795,
-0.5539289117,
-0.6647102237,
0.3955738842,
0.1462052464,
0.8348276615,
0.5749906301,
-0.2328086793,
0.6624425054,
0.1491547376,
0.5425515771,
0.2888362706,
-0.9113869071,
0.4660572112,
-0.2008686066,
-0.0719668269,
0.5428437591,
0.7706004381,
-0.4276149273,
0.0855725333,
-0.6290297508,
-0.5688932538,
0.5562976003,
0.2898773551,
-0.1847614646,
0.2948377728,
0.4763120413,
0.3716364801,
0.1911821663,
-0.7426435947,
0.0493054204,
-0.297819525,
0.133629635,
-0.1413139552,
-0.1002220511,
-0.4338744283,
-0.5077691674,
0.6973112226,
-0.278714627,
0.1198973209,
0.2925872505,
-0.1094923466,
0.0672918633,
0.0448977202,
0.2239198983,
0.7650765181,
-0.4072620869,
-0.4638221264,
0.3092722595,
-0.6107186675,
-0.0181225576,
0.0012381864,
-0.1114432812,
-0.2571168542,
0.525898695,
0.5464354753,
0.2209660262,
-0.5332986116,
0.3598975241,
-0.2906048,
-0.298350811,
-0.0967880338,
0.3204927146,
-0.2474419177,
0.1489387602,
0.2905957997,
0.0370414518,
0.314814508,
-1.1007328033,
0.3734369576,
0.3936084211,
-0.466420114,
-0.6501597762,
0.4587937295,
0.1709771603,
-0.2527423501,
0.2812815309,
-0.3501703441,
-0.6816064715,
0.7237796187,
0.4587584436,
0.9053989053,
-0.2226572335,
0.4297187924,
0.3810271323,
0.5250916481,
0.1231520399,
0.4956652224,
-0.259927094,
-0.5138645172,
-0.4399067163,
-0.7760500908,
-0.5864236355,
0.3599145114,
-1.0840402842,
0.0952312946,
-0.5980272293,
-0.0620678253,
-0.0904451162,
0.0604809076,
-0.6264116168,
0.6550580859,
0.0511559434,
0.7086401582,
-1.1955811977,
0.5659099817,
0.783412993,
-0.5682317019,
-0.6342561245,
0.1838374138,
-0.4311167598,
-0.7042735815,
0.6173965931,
0.1068896353,
0.0108801657,
-0.5299574137,
-0.1774598658,
-0.7834471464,
0.7614430189,
-0.0950788483,
-0.4906427562,
0.0215204582,
0.4413790405,
0.6934148669,
-0.3656232655,
0.2912303209,
1.0316941738,
0.4320085943,
0.1043156683,
-1.015920639,
0.0935390145,
0.1392158121,
-0.0018984673,
-0.0468599722,
-0.7633764744,
0.5777019262,
0.016498683,
0.1194313988,
-0.1684719026,
0.3991799653,
0.1974048316,
0.5730574131,
0.496255815,
0.5160452127,
0.7643173337,
0.0236183275,
1.1609311104,
0.072284922,
0.5334815383,
0.7641680241,
-0.2888759375,
0.3813453317,
0.2314530909,
-0.5569839478,
0.224935621,
0.7240642905,
0.1343213767,
0.8357221484,
0.3628129363,
0.179436639,
-0.0093672164,
0.4037484527,
-0.2539993227,
0.3062419593,
0.6131309867,
-0.0222227443,
-0.2451933473,
0.0982643738,
-0.2840020061,
0.109866783,
-0.510843277,
0.6758036017,
0.0168677047,
-0.6751964688,
1.0828049183,
-0.2911196053,
0.6744950414,
-0.8183799982,
0.2041418254,
-0.4426825047,
0.2766667604,
-0.3075039089,
-0.6316761374,
0.8433635235,
-0.3986915946,
0.2478635609,
0.0620200932,
0.602039814,
-0.1334553659,
-0.3531987667,
0.8711849451,
0.3187260628,
0.1259110719,
0.0187092349,
-0.7228945494,
0.0177942272,
-0.0437818542,
-0.235319376,
0.5956289172,
0.3701483011,
-0.150711,
0.8576654196,
0.5872427821,
-0.0322349593,
0.1702143848,
0.063408196,
1.0080728531,
-0.6496434808,
-0.6397255063,
-0.5644886494,
0.1294617951,
0.0415192284,
-0.5589855313,
0.6527777314,
0.6950648427,
0.9425133467,
0.0152801434,
0.9248572588,
0.0133896526,
0.2567287385,
-0.4596817493,
0.3518646657,
-0.5417004228,
0.1771218777,
-0.2888382077,
-0.7747621536,
-0.2370141447,
0.6039634943,
-0.749941349,
-0.0941528827,
0.8501980901,
0.5923985839,
-0.4719056189,
0.2192999572,
0.6662248969,
0.0127505613,
0.2740371823,
0.2684341669,
0.8868781924,
-0.4757522941,
0.3844206333,
-0.402646631,
-0.2739132941,
-0.2329051793,
-0.6637178659,
-1.4217615128,
-0.437716037,
-0.4489011168,
-0.3462038636,
0.3833939731,
0.2020740807,
0.6755844951,
-0.8123261929,
-0.4159855843,
0.0339650102,
-0.0002393812,
-0.6185175776,
-0.2627004981,
0.2895288765,
-0.5277389884,
-0.3703522086,
0.2297550291,
-0.1007007137,
-0.1498005837,
-0.4403877258,
-0.0887397602,
-0.2340006828,
0.4406349957,
0.725494802,
0.2821099758,
-0.0227888152,
-0.2139476985,
-0.2744604349,
0.4198915064,
0.0184956435,
0.6875502467,
-0.8532831669,
-0.0913048983,
0.3486385345,
0.5671364069,
0.8793171048,
0.0280257668,
0.5633034706,
-0.7290680408,
0.0701257735,
0.1790025532,
0.4180898666,
0.170767948,
-0.299818635,
0.8526644111,
0.3216598928,
-0.4749745131,
-0.8746384978,
0.1371680647,
-0.8664585948,
-0.4060144424,
1.09747684,
-0.3604179025,
-0.4902181327,
-0.252856642,
-0.1717031151,
0.0568331629,
-0.2556805015,
1.1772851944,
0.5682657957,
-0.2261957973,
0.4600481689,
-0.4715688825,
0.4556820095,
0.6969271898,
-0.6352755427,
-0.0439541116,
0.2000997216,
0.5996430516,
0.3487300277,
0.2114020139,
-0.1524515599,
0.3075890243,
-0.071860604,
-0.0391235426,
0.1131377593,
-0.2746127248,
-0.6329755187,
0.0737518668,
-0.3697680235,
-0.3127990067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12947v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12947v2 | ChatGPT to Replace Crowdsourcing of Paraphrases for Intent Classification: Higher Diversity and Comparable Model Robustness | 2023-05-22T11:46:32 | 2023-10-19T21:11:53 | Jan Cegin, Jakub Simko, Peter Brusilovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | The emergence of generative large language models (LLMs) raises the question:
what will be its impact on crowdsourcing? Traditionally, crowdsourcing has been
used for acquiring solutions to a wide variety of human-intelligence tasks,
including ones involving text generation, modification or evaluation. For some
of these tasks, models like ChatGPT can potentially substitute human workers.
In this study, we investigate whether this is the case for the task of
paraphrase generation for intent classification. We apply data collection
methodology of an existing crowdsourcing study (similar scale, prompts and seed
data) using ChatGPT and Falcon-40B. We show that ChatGPT-created paraphrases
are more diverse and lead to at least as robust models. | [
-0.1284874976,
-0.3417266905,
0.6017774343,
0.1654488295,
-0.216741696,
-0.0052775238,
-0.128641665,
-0.5099309087,
0.0039301557,
0.7434873581,
-0.4584585726,
-0.2284930795,
-0.696023345,
0.1819112152,
-0.6319343448,
1.2246183157,
0.1092223376,
-0.0422529392,
-0.3242999911,
-0.0613492951,
-0.0571404546,
-0.7781612873,
-0.5706095099,
0.111737527,
0.5354084373,
0.5657743812,
0.813211143,
0.4910176694,
0.6865675449,
0.3270298541,
-0.1909282207,
0.0280070677,
-0.5268169045,
0.295687139,
-0.2149400711,
-0.4666982889,
-0.0514725037,
0.2845200896,
0.4901051819,
0.8824513555,
-0.3547707796,
0.0313909464,
0.3478270173,
0.3801793754,
-0.5382121801,
0.3115320504,
-0.9610276222,
-0.1840882599,
-0.4028622806,
-0.0679836199,
-0.3170574605,
-0.4155491292,
0.1570946127,
-0.5002167225,
0.6070033312,
0.0645117015,
0.5498754978,
0.109708555,
-0.0033019655,
-0.6084560156,
-0.5353708267,
0.8092781305,
-0.8176476359,
0.1173737869,
0.5276039839,
0.1280726492,
-0.1671276391,
-1.1707574129,
-0.3995161355,
-0.4292818606,
-0.0159148704,
0.0669517741,
-0.0596385375,
0.0490220971,
0.1819370836,
0.4121938944,
-0.3266729414,
-0.0083514648,
-0.5231713057,
-0.1114796624,
0.5079994798,
0.1717255563,
0.4284083545,
-0.5775770545,
-0.2650745511,
0.0106077483,
-0.5202083588,
0.0937252864,
0.3418937027,
0.366016686,
0.2655724287,
0.7802125812,
-0.5987331867,
0.4943532348,
0.0434065834,
-0.0763958022,
-0.0639221221,
-0.3929280937,
-0.0265251789,
-0.2000679821,
0.8495615721,
0.2548843324,
0.2446671128,
-0.3000305593,
-0.0137010068,
-0.3535073996,
0.0222855937,
-0.6609708667,
-0.4085713625,
-0.0582586825,
-0.552167654,
-0.4476750791,
0.2501777709,
-0.6390256286,
-0.5789451599,
-0.2444534898,
-0.000165232,
-0.3072410524,
-0.0557327494,
0.0931578204,
-0.3098520637,
0.3743078411,
0.4194379151,
-0.8450455666,
0.1189546809,
0.9288448691,
0.980532527,
-0.2807299793,
-0.6012141109,
-0.6331270337,
0.0360768028,
-0.0989893153,
0.9835951328,
-0.7846765518,
-0.6542364359,
-0.1657349765,
-0.2701068819,
-0.1247341707,
-0.529322505,
0.8232008219,
-0.535897851,
0.5340626836,
-0.4055594504,
-0.5863445997,
-0.116794996,
0.1350452155,
-0.545404911,
0.9024925232,
0.0666137263,
-0.8356376886,
0.3593658507,
-0.6397774816,
-0.3037265241,
0.5475280881,
-0.1629903615,
-0.3716013134,
0.0056445128,
0.3715935647,
0.7051178217,
-0.3153023124,
0.4740187824,
-0.514975667,
-0.2501747608,
0.5563423634,
-0.7715955973,
0.8885694742,
0.3856061399,
-0.3483426273,
-0.3140038252,
-0.3828298748,
-0.1921323091,
-0.0661652908,
-0.4111676216,
-0.1776272058,
0.1959448904,
0.1577245146,
0.2421154678,
0.224646762,
-0.3713729084,
-0.0343785323,
0.1110345423,
0.5464051366,
0.6632643938,
0.3221888244,
0.3686111569,
-0.6484696269,
0.6555513144,
-0.3451049328,
0.2893252373,
0.0540642999,
-1.0834338665,
-0.3295371234,
-0.3221950233,
0.0841093361,
0.3458864093,
-0.5431956053,
-0.0193341263,
-0.3917373717,
-0.6426707506,
-0.2184149921,
0.1746109724,
0.1211575791,
0.3455022275,
0.2459550649,
0.0443512909,
-0.4345979393,
-0.6489114761,
-0.477592051,
-0.4027416706,
-0.2637125552,
0.4253374636,
0.20837906,
-0.0392347537,
0.9911593795,
-0.3276984394,
0.074078314,
-0.3646952808,
0.1780742705,
-0.0299664661,
0.29636994,
0.4541186988,
-1.0691673756,
-0.5123050809,
-0.1917656213,
-0.5191500783,
-0.3139366508,
-0.0307987221,
-0.1583431065,
-0.3044433296,
0.6173095107,
-0.8030993938,
0.1300340742,
0.5543219447,
-0.1048590764,
0.5222712755,
0.1763275862,
0.4381327033,
-1.4082226753,
-0.0470816605,
-0.2211797088,
-0.0692890882,
-0.5535647869,
0.0548666939,
-0.1076250821,
-0.5080819726,
-0.5477816463,
0.3119499683,
-0.3763359785,
-0.0406444632,
-0.3684249818,
0.2508578598,
-0.0356348082,
0.1073035523,
0.1017389074,
0.7835239172,
0.4134842753,
-0.5505114198,
0.3936926126,
0.3949998617,
-0.4642988443,
0.5425358415,
-0.6483575702,
0.2156962901,
-0.0988855138,
0.3785910606,
-0.956160903,
-0.7706810832,
0.3383908272,
-0.5759737492,
-0.2539932728,
-0.3152545094,
-0.4412904382,
-0.2075784951,
-0.2299772054,
0.2028146684,
0.7085389495,
-0.6248847246,
0.2850557566,
0.2156553864,
-0.7303750515,
-0.2776320279,
-0.6312336922,
0.4364416301,
-0.478035152,
-0.5835059285,
0.1507908702,
0.0829193443,
-0.2587315738,
-0.1490592808,
0.2726179659,
-0.1866706461,
0.05227625,
0.1598942727,
0.1187028363,
-0.0471659191,
0.1296656132,
-0.0192696806,
0.2062733471,
0.0399557911,
-0.18949233,
0.5585078597,
0.0098887682,
-0.7989621758,
-0.4480282366,
0.5501198769,
0.7414219975,
-0.5302945971,
0.5852321386,
0.4490558207,
-0.0388410874,
0.1594500244,
-0.6170867682,
-0.1248549968,
-0.5123024583,
0.4560141265,
-0.1492903531,
-0.9084448218,
0.4675807655,
0.0527756885,
0.2022093385,
0.3847827613,
0.5628170967,
-0.1015863642,
0.6256637573,
0.107959114,
-0.0913358033,
0.6619037986,
0.0713347569,
-0.1416639835,
-0.5672212243,
-0.2273585647,
-0.768294096,
-0.2167657465,
-0.6007234454,
-0.5970612168,
0.1748118997,
-0.0412491038,
0.1643926352,
0.2049715817,
-0.3881203532,
0.4718442559,
0.8184684515,
0.2462559789,
0.431224525,
0.1353553385,
0.7032440305,
0.0735351965,
-0.7735122442,
-0.6472473741,
1.3068181276,
-0.0303738676,
0.5897400975,
0.1010054052,
1.0477437973,
0.2549866438,
0.5747562051,
-0.5372591019,
0.6783913374,
-0.2530165911,
-0.6550410986,
-0.3886511922,
-0.3607499003,
-1.1190049648,
0.0694995373,
0.0499502718,
-0.7472050786,
0.2316551059,
-0.0636565983,
-0.1332907379,
0.4477973878,
-0.6478672624,
0.6658533812,
0.0403155051,
0.0682040378,
-0.0347223468,
-0.4733262062,
0.2747582793,
-0.2123647481,
0.2008772492,
-0.2604597807,
-0.0543801002,
1.0199195147,
-0.4709540606,
0.940954566,
-0.1614181548,
-0.0566963516,
0.6898207664,
-0.1534882188,
1.0006430149,
0.1604895741,
-0.3795153201,
-0.0317369625,
-0.3112478554,
-0.6289112568,
-0.5024335384,
0.5649821162,
-0.5290908217,
-0.8682423234,
0.0286814738,
-0.8684254885,
-0.2590824962,
-0.1555349082,
0.5626890659,
0.2821553946,
-0.1257674098,
0.7135776281,
0.3895873129,
0.1130491868,
0.4515427351,
0.0908949971,
0.0435213186,
-0.1989780068,
0.8534439206,
-0.0929305851,
0.5265487432,
0.3021984994,
0.2448142618,
-0.2830393612,
-0.6747294068,
-0.2162320465,
-0.0738945007,
-0.7392945886,
-0.0496197753,
-0.8363358974,
-0.0793154463,
-0.5294514894,
-0.2326554656,
-0.1459327638,
-0.3117150962,
-0.2817454636,
-0.0190948583,
0.6058499813,
0.6707580686,
-0.0067809708,
0.3322388232,
-0.8710566163,
0.1413548887,
0.7262251377,
-0.0235561021,
-0.2693395019,
-0.65032655,
0.003421688,
0.3552013934,
-0.2005597204,
-1.0235365629,
0.0338637792,
0.3163952529,
0.703717351,
0.3081853986,
0.1451441199,
0.4517723024,
-0.1423414797,
0.9514651895,
0.076379016,
-0.7951687574,
0.2807148695,
-0.6625262499,
0.1088172272,
0.6623679399,
0.2893818021,
-0.7190365195,
-0.8503189087,
-0.8245473504,
-0.6025884748,
0.6841146946,
0.5548687577,
0.4869536161,
-0.0760047212,
0.3436608016,
0.3408071697,
0.0324033834,
-0.7833542824,
0.1105047613,
-0.2698273063,
-0.2522007525,
-0.1190793887,
-0.1825703681,
0.2038765997,
-0.0098550105,
0.3564523458,
0.1724962294,
0.0714225695,
-0.0212842245,
0.0221080482,
0.301902473,
0.3616552055,
0.2969421446,
0.4954322278,
0.1306587309,
0.0887207687,
0.2598706186,
-0.5706208944,
0.0135388188,
0.2606359124,
-0.392349422,
0.1414452493,
0.3612573743,
0.6669967771,
0.2358859777,
-0.8000515699,
0.4572819173,
0.2078213543,
-0.3968415856,
0.0262243412,
0.2234171331,
0.2312071472,
0.4422670007,
0.509568572,
0.0022369511,
0.4968416393,
-0.323585242,
0.1562240124,
0.4871868491,
-0.1310251057,
-0.0058355844,
0.653447628,
0.0992069021,
-0.4547869265,
0.8208104372,
-0.2913665175,
-0.4315292835,
0.6127662063,
0.2599226534,
1.0398703814,
-0.2475745082,
0.5076613426,
0.018944066,
0.0691279247,
-0.3146132827,
-0.0597930104,
-0.1983736306,
-0.5513699055,
-0.4311426878,
-0.4724599123,
-0.7889572382,
0.0867477804,
-0.6065655947,
0.1929125488,
-0.0774965733,
0.0834630877,
-0.0499305315,
-0.5479239225,
-0.4344626665,
0.0214642324,
0.1593389511,
0.2804543376,
-0.7387751937,
0.6364187598,
0.921872139,
-0.3377743959,
-0.9218274355,
0.5894486904,
-0.4165760577,
-0.718266964,
0.5126237869,
0.0395169407,
0.2084283829,
0.2076978534,
-0.7924611568,
-0.9262002707,
1.1453652382,
0.2841582894,
-0.2354820222,
-0.1494783461,
0.363713026,
0.3325215876,
-0.0841100886,
-0.0955273062,
0.0830818117,
0.3628399372,
0.1989275664,
-0.8557377458,
-0.1108865067,
-0.0478099063,
0.1039477661,
0.0142928176,
-0.4683764279,
1.0351576805,
-0.1920123845,
-0.125962019,
0.1459047198,
0.6809355021,
0.5412403345,
0.2502938509,
0.406622231,
0.1373727024,
0.8731147051,
0.132468164,
1.0897957087,
-0.166189909,
0.5847994089,
1.0047748089,
-0.0355037972,
0.7561215758,
0.4981061816,
-0.5792323351,
0.3946750164,
0.6514828205,
-0.1020473391,
0.4208610654,
0.0498197749,
-0.5285335183,
-0.2654890418,
0.0246997364,
-0.304353714,
0.5353006721,
0.2003089637,
-0.3542636633,
-0.4220614433,
0.1351487637,
0.0761441886,
0.0047895107,
-0.3182787597,
0.7118536234,
0.0642772913,
-0.8912078738,
0.2380355597,
-0.007616316,
0.7418132424,
-0.3327124417,
0.2165080607,
-0.4477827251,
-0.0872134641,
-0.1644881368,
-0.8190183043,
0.2141111195,
0.1615247726,
-0.0738123506,
-0.1556935459,
0.6429985762,
-0.3466793299,
-0.6456682682,
-0.252055645,
0.586202085,
0.5318804383,
-0.6228717566,
-0.665240109,
-0.4910308719,
0.18541421,
-0.4112736285,
0.2867680192,
0.6083211899,
-0.0793100446,
0.7606857419,
0.7691011429,
-0.2926944792,
0.4120079875,
-0.0602434911,
0.7781742811,
-0.4377692342,
-0.3956197202,
-0.993441999,
0.2121691108,
-0.2340018749,
-0.22690925,
0.8832124472,
0.5227085352,
0.468803674,
-0.2637315094,
1.159109354,
-0.3441876769,
0.4635251462,
-0.3491976857,
0.6309021711,
-0.2398107797,
0.1494438499,
-0.4494190514,
-0.9365575314,
0.097860679,
0.1445042789,
-0.4449958801,
0.2562656701,
0.4741176963,
0.8344069719,
-0.2374096364,
0.1964283437,
0.2809214592,
-0.3723134398,
0.3942027688,
0.4709151387,
1.1345500946,
-0.1001686081,
1.1965018511,
-0.2256087214,
-0.2565025687,
-0.2870878875,
-0.6899649501,
-0.7181052566,
-0.7178531885,
-0.3940992057,
-0.149344489,
-0.0649153814,
0.6954218149,
0.4051854014,
-0.7858520746,
-0.0466053449,
-0.4749474823,
-0.1025601104,
-0.0927080065,
-0.2778814435,
0.366507262,
-0.5803653002,
-0.9548040628,
0.1921278685,
-0.0219948404,
0.1353792101,
-0.1240564957,
-0.2168797404,
-0.0898552611,
-0.0311370064,
0.3880023658,
0.2188541442,
-0.7056898475,
-0.138695851,
0.2602392733,
-0.2316969335,
-0.0380652547,
0.8993257284,
-0.4138095081,
-0.0554963946,
0.4057961404,
0.7494049072,
0.4279175997,
0.2704341114,
0.4771851003,
-0.5594829321,
0.0908778384,
0.3309850991,
0.3450507224,
0.4742487073,
-0.2020210326,
0.3372882307,
0.3972844481,
-0.7187210321,
-0.612000525,
0.3425107598,
-0.9800505042,
-0.2035322338,
1.7026028633,
-0.3980269134,
0.1594928503,
-0.3742640913,
-0.54237324,
0.2383126616,
-0.4219787717,
0.9082276225,
0.7725741863,
-0.1091186106,
-0.2502297163,
-0.3289650679,
0.3585010171,
0.3725966513,
-0.9757922888,
0.2182457447,
0.4484944642,
0.3263987601,
-0.0040359283,
0.630954504,
-0.2173539251,
0.2884148955,
0.0441368967,
0.029530149,
-0.0141843297,
0.3553082049,
0.2393538654,
0.3880651593,
0.4204661846,
-0.2854808569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12945v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12945v2 | ExplainCPE: A Free-text Explanation Benchmark of Chinese Pharmacist Examination | 2023-05-22T11:45:42 | 2023-10-26T03:15:41 | Dongfang Li, Jindi Yu, Baotian Hu, Zhenran Xu, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | As ChatGPT and GPT-4 spearhead the development of Large Language Models
(LLMs), more researchers are investigating their performance across various
tasks. But more research needs to be done on the interpretability capabilities
of LLMs, that is, the ability to generate reasons after an answer has been
given. Existing explanation datasets are mostly English-language general
knowledge questions, which leads to insufficient thematic and linguistic
diversity. To address the language bias and lack of medical resources in
generating rationales QA datasets, we present ExplainCPE (over 7k instances), a
challenging medical benchmark in Simplified Chinese. We analyzed the errors of
ChatGPT and GPT-4, pointing out the limitations of current LLMs in
understanding text and computational reasoning. During the experiment, we also
found that different LLMs have different preferences for in-context learning.
ExplainCPE presents a significant challenge, but its potential for further
investigation is promising, and it can be used to evaluate the ability of a
model to generate explanations. AI safety and trustworthiness need more
attention, and this work makes the first step to explore the medical
interpretability of LLMs.The dataset is available at
https://github.com/HITsz-TMG/ExplainCPE. | [
0.0124503095,
-0.3864381015,
0.9042294621,
0.0849249884,
-0.3602474034,
-0.4139715433,
-0.2264841646,
-0.3492281139,
-0.2092455328,
0.2982672453,
-0.5543872714,
-0.4822855592,
-0.7154278159,
0.1969038844,
-0.232450366,
1.0745359659,
-0.3671411872,
0.3746526837,
0.0915786922,
-0.1329190433,
-0.3924406469,
-0.5048232079,
-0.8350968361,
-0.3827170432,
0.4881349206,
0.2620021105,
0.6333857775,
0.7459211946,
0.4914524257,
0.1791166365,
0.119756639,
0.0370680504,
-0.3093157113,
-0.1212337762,
-0.1109125912,
-0.5336133242,
-0.3778416216,
-0.0124831237,
0.4012463987,
0.8122482896,
-0.1881327778,
-0.1486687064,
0.1713589579,
0.6382662058,
-0.465401262,
0.2742200792,
-0.4961800277,
-0.0640354231,
-0.0300081298,
-0.0936823934,
-0.4227640629,
-0.334063679,
0.4113185704,
-0.9460178614,
0.2728871107,
0.0258459859,
0.928347826,
0.1882925928,
-0.5956976414,
-0.3318546712,
-0.1956421882,
0.5760720968,
-0.6419029832,
0.3523640037,
0.030343188,
0.6480053067,
-0.2022142112,
-1.0294319391,
-0.6521615982,
-0.1171999797,
-0.1879149824,
0.0893639624,
0.0003020376,
0.1337909251,
-0.0324832648,
0.5071317554,
-0.7699484825,
0.0710446015,
-0.1302467883,
-0.206418097,
0.2954163849,
0.0398322456,
0.6822407246,
0.0548422299,
-0.6091372371,
-0.1225869283,
-0.8644456863,
0.2475719452,
-0.3422465026,
0.0215688515,
-0.2387335151,
0.3764550984,
0.0799531415,
0.4713425338,
-0.2439632118,
0.2498787344,
0.0814864114,
-0.2039182931,
-0.5256018639,
0.0841229782,
0.7531312108,
0.5480598211,
0.1695486009,
-0.1037792191,
0.0882593691,
-0.1920195371,
-0.0081802439,
-0.9939982891,
-0.4548299015,
0.5532031655,
-0.7347561121,
-0.0027611786,
-0.061090745,
-0.7829611301,
-0.6559301615,
-0.22166875,
0.1493030638,
-0.6114105582,
-0.1091368049,
0.1850792766,
-0.1774828434,
0.6304056048,
0.2800915241,
-0.914988935,
0.4765765071,
0.7813347578,
0.7143338323,
-0.5981632471,
-0.4165911674,
-0.259830296,
-0.0776048154,
-0.5356894135,
0.8099735379,
-0.192484498,
-0.2660714388,
-0.1388543248,
0.307282418,
-0.3687476814,
-0.736508131,
0.7794914842,
-0.0834954977,
0.401992768,
-0.6061469316,
-0.6910291314,
-0.3374598622,
0.252638787,
-0.3840159476,
0.7590047717,
-0.0238386635,
-0.6741284132,
0.4381685555,
-0.7715439796,
0.0106932735,
0.3197047412,
-0.3525632918,
-0.3661053181,
-0.0220692679,
0.6218784451,
0.283652097,
-0.6347624063,
0.652212441,
-0.1419081986,
-0.5012017488,
0.4368447661,
-0.5780242682,
1.1834872961,
0.2573411763,
-0.4411380589,
0.1083892882,
-0.5354843736,
0.0969752893,
0.2662248611,
-0.0492430776,
-0.0233137086,
0.1429275423,
-0.3240201771,
0.1427500099,
0.1901183575,
-0.2940731347,
-0.1414367557,
-0.5479328632,
0.4523535967,
0.5969588757,
0.2469045073,
-0.0280976519,
-0.3499532342,
0.4493742287,
-0.0240754187,
0.2788451612,
-0.3830198646,
-0.552568078,
-0.3632662594,
-0.240507707,
0.1004827768,
0.6067329049,
-0.7349231243,
0.0321113467,
-0.2782226801,
-0.3432883024,
-0.410802871,
0.2203427106,
0.4067875147,
0.699359715,
0.3042051494,
-0.1467659622,
-0.2276347131,
-1.1301096678,
-0.6968138218,
-0.2966397703,
-0.5795626044,
0.263690114,
0.347920835,
-0.0775889605,
0.4696362913,
-0.3849014938,
0.1470187902,
-0.2838379145,
-0.1255345494,
0.259875685,
0.1690839082,
0.4837315381,
-0.7905234098,
-0.3026626706,
-0.0536697991,
-0.7072071433,
-0.3765828311,
-0.263880372,
-0.1292908937,
-0.2317047864,
0.3531279564,
-0.4090748727,
0.0501415618,
0.5108843446,
-0.2198025286,
0.5871555209,
-0.3309444785,
0.219746545,
-0.6957589388,
0.0693456605,
0.2034121454,
0.1082595587,
-0.7254260778,
0.3358644843,
0.2912258804,
-0.3715345562,
-0.5988155603,
0.5000451207,
-0.3738803267,
0.1185451299,
-0.1530866325,
0.5755010247,
0.1033070683,
0.6237339377,
-0.0750722885,
0.6604211926,
0.5845654011,
-0.4101566672,
0.1829755157,
0.0938221291,
-0.2540866733,
0.4641197324,
-0.836484015,
-0.1848596334,
0.0880564302,
0.3613105416,
-1.167792201,
-0.3864445984,
0.3653178811,
-0.3061028123,
0.0143899126,
0.186694935,
-0.3902997375,
-0.3100964427,
-0.2400576621,
0.4476301968,
0.3825065792,
-0.9467974901,
0.2619414926,
0.1097924635,
-0.0213394798,
-0.5434278846,
-0.5441897511,
0.1148186922,
-0.3134224415,
-0.512825191,
0.1502842009,
-0.2542692125,
-0.3401862383,
-0.261247009,
-0.225004971,
-0.4265205562,
0.1721875966,
0.0970072821,
0.3651873469,
-0.3756027818,
0.3321672976,
0.0280652065,
-0.0724730864,
0.4517773092,
-0.1976709813,
0.0722425804,
-0.2258640677,
-0.4241193831,
-0.5950347781,
0.0446757376,
0.5129377246,
0.0563917346,
0.6349688172,
0.0871238485,
-0.3206661344,
-0.3166861236,
-0.0744908303,
-0.2150862813,
-0.445741266,
0.2928824127,
-0.2174215913,
-0.5310384035,
0.432085216,
-0.1753089577,
0.0853836611,
0.6500149369,
0.689752996,
0.2027534693,
0.8706032634,
0.1341846287,
0.2290807068,
-0.1670963317,
0.4323529303,
0.4679625928,
-0.3605813384,
-0.2777716219,
-0.3691354096,
0.12434984,
-0.6276170015,
-0.4721958935,
0.5049401522,
-0.1660801768,
-0.306709379,
-0.12635234,
-0.7718440294,
0.636461556,
0.1328362525,
0.1504873335,
0.1362513304,
-0.2478565425,
-0.2604396939,
-0.1032582819,
-0.4999495745,
-0.4685311019,
0.9263525605,
0.4731376171,
0.207761392,
-0.0981777459,
0.2368936986,
-0.0099610351,
0.4546715319,
-0.6041933894,
0.386654228,
-0.4435831904,
-0.6291433573,
-0.1000941247,
-0.2668005526,
-0.892595768,
0.5778169036,
-0.0477004573,
-0.7238917351,
0.0118936067,
0.2844842076,
-0.1095238104,
0.2464647591,
-0.9040285945,
1.2230606079,
-0.4562665224,
-0.0285604261,
0.1575123519,
-0.7746050358,
0.7879337072,
-0.2303172946,
0.352347821,
-0.1665974557,
-0.0701943636,
0.5169494152,
-0.7263095975,
0.7387490273,
-0.2087823153,
-0.1702969074,
0.1733630896,
-0.0331618115,
0.2548191249,
-0.0711562335,
-0.244146347,
0.2574440539,
0.1988417655,
-0.6455662847,
-0.7483492494,
0.6675023437,
-0.5887468457,
-0.5792118907,
-0.2152418047,
-0.4008772671,
-0.2123245299,
0.2552725375,
0.3120282888,
0.3071993887,
-0.2638926208,
-0.014697724,
0.6241173744,
-0.6831133366,
-0.0098554706,
0.5794312954,
0.0026256742,
-0.0665033087,
0.817310214,
-0.1276190877,
0.1612637192,
0.4885956943,
0.5401646495,
-0.3140672445,
-0.7419515252,
-0.4652982354,
0.2385469079,
-0.8521412015,
0.4187021852,
-0.3114793301,
-0.1661585122,
-0.1244892627,
-0.1516248286,
-0.0965506285,
-0.4605282545,
0.0206204038,
-0.1668151468,
0.0934522748,
0.5518372059,
0.1181076095,
0.4860657454,
-0.430066973,
0.4539596438,
0.1837955415,
0.5673035383,
0.0196361076,
-0.2664298415,
-0.088283591,
-0.060752511,
-0.4130679965,
-1.1837272644,
0.2860414982,
0.0047691697,
0.7928850055,
0.596298039,
0.0698636025,
0.3780729473,
-0.3337232471,
1.1689807177,
0.09878245,
-1.0781930685,
0.4881635904,
-0.3803273141,
0.17200239,
0.4002785087,
0.4029830992,
-0.7197810411,
-0.4469316304,
-0.4295048714,
-0.9144895077,
0.4367477298,
0.2369299233,
-0.4312650263,
-0.1093413308,
0.7070263028,
0.3408615887,
-0.1095528379,
-0.8851684928,
-0.4289165735,
-0.186352089,
-0.2930138111,
-0.1038606986,
-0.2922412157,
-0.0738373622,
0.1233729273,
0.6625339985,
-0.1602034271,
0.1444085389,
0.3939233422,
0.0368025638,
0.1169233397,
0.5086297989,
0.5684115291,
0.926005125,
-0.2301223874,
0.3097786903,
0.2900010943,
-0.433283627,
-0.0343549922,
0.3003839254,
0.2244919389,
-0.1314694881,
0.4974599183,
0.4742943347,
0.0927146748,
-1.0540460348,
0.6805315614,
-0.2969510853,
-0.3495082259,
-0.1948170364,
-0.0938842446,
-0.023085881,
-0.1715078503,
0.412874043,
-0.3819998503,
0.20281142,
-0.2796626687,
0.2628638744,
0.1088234633,
-0.56638515,
-0.1652181149,
0.9790606499,
-0.0089888396,
0.0168605298,
0.5462542176,
0.0908682793,
-0.3791769147,
0.8329423666,
0.318672955,
0.6633790731,
-0.2735396922,
0.105280526,
0.3040018082,
0.440828532,
-0.0281740781,
0.1202704236,
0.2272634059,
-0.5791686773,
-0.5446460247,
-0.0423486196,
-0.8550083637,
0.3400980234,
-0.5473206639,
0.2016519904,
-0.4591373801,
0.4722162783,
0.2181516737,
-0.0460518599,
-0.378276825,
0.3312075436,
-0.0266309679,
0.9960307479,
-0.9071330428,
0.7902848125,
0.3511397839,
-0.1321986169,
-1.0237138271,
0.1136366874,
0.3898562789,
-1.2116755247,
0.3921370804,
0.2827643752,
0.2342281044,
-0.7829484344,
-0.6708576083,
-0.1388872713,
0.9240977168,
0.4449288845,
-0.5218638778,
0.0284927767,
0.2321539074,
0.7981914878,
-0.3951307237,
0.3220691085,
0.7808690071,
0.4597375095,
-0.22537902,
-0.743868947,
0.3926234245,
-0.388081789,
-0.2310513854,
-0.0650549009,
-0.4251690209,
0.8812347651,
-0.2198129147,
-0.2056610435,
0.0216763616,
0.1204998195,
0.5260406137,
0.7380097508,
0.4519332945,
0.2013662755,
0.9599232078,
-0.1087736264,
1.4206062555,
-0.3273458779,
0.0500697792,
1.0776972771,
-0.1879706979,
0.6368616223,
0.3927407265,
-0.1935155243,
0.6615710855,
0.9940716028,
-0.0953037441,
0.2609201074,
0.3174770176,
-0.2070575058,
-0.22582528,
0.1038572788,
-0.2286385596,
0.1900200248,
0.5025044084,
-0.6303418875,
-0.2361293882,
-0.2441149652,
-0.0678255334,
0.1267626286,
-0.088530913,
0.5624623895,
0.2061540633,
-0.7089497447,
0.6652832627,
-0.2241208553,
-0.0345438533,
-0.6392884851,
-0.1080113873,
-0.1424971372,
0.3291391134,
-0.1319320053,
-0.7388316393,
0.1164650023,
-0.1955256164,
-0.0044705844,
-0.0857132599,
0.4311845899,
-0.2777375579,
-0.2331754267,
0.2429499477,
0.5002302527,
0.6683798432,
-0.0454215519,
-0.8243759871,
-0.3081073165,
0.1920891702,
-0.0135148773,
0.2740106583,
0.8746283054,
-0.1495518833,
0.7295111418,
0.4693220556,
0.1427517682,
-0.1963300556,
-0.1489894092,
0.6269875765,
-0.4616115391,
-0.4864272177,
-0.9736642838,
0.2200023234,
0.0721337721,
-0.1997256875,
0.7101032734,
0.5304713249,
0.3486213684,
0.1043433771,
0.8153835535,
0.4213688374,
0.7710371614,
-0.3593250811,
0.6771217585,
-0.6678487062,
0.5610463619,
-0.0069501856,
-0.4335685074,
-0.4680940211,
0.1739771515,
-0.2892868519,
-0.1446518302,
0.9873609543,
0.4728506207,
0.0413098298,
0.3806979954,
0.1646645516,
0.4965137839,
0.583717823,
0.9056107402,
0.4638177454,
-0.4303497076,
0.907816112,
-0.0843829513,
-0.3585142493,
0.025118487,
-1.0773291588,
-0.7368987799,
-0.3746421039,
-0.2759997547,
-0.2942090333,
0.1907162368,
0.7712341547,
0.4258919954,
-0.9931713939,
-0.0521833599,
-0.1236082017,
0.4243630469,
-0.6052135825,
-0.1937834471,
0.8759225607,
-0.2693785727,
-0.5215314627,
0.3368926942,
0.050552424,
-0.0700950623,
0.2331809253,
-0.2224161476,
0.3856181204,
0.0214802809,
0.3159959018,
0.4672019184,
-0.8280443549,
-0.0751307458,
-0.0966580063,
0.0315328427,
0.2853239477,
1.1522185802,
-0.3180221319,
0.7783867717,
0.2766793668,
0.7371765971,
0.1695382595,
-0.137825489,
0.9493932128,
-0.3396938443,
-0.1189145446,
-0.1126054525,
0.6173508763,
0.2893969119,
-0.4041678607,
0.4287272096,
0.0973767862,
-0.7780352235,
-0.590675354,
-0.1093323231,
-1.0577138662,
-0.7285268307,
0.8908397555,
-0.4308149219,
-0.2038137764,
-0.3923743069,
-0.3110221624,
0.1573022157,
-0.2573850155,
0.789460659,
0.7667060494,
-0.4473777115,
-0.4588757753,
-0.7959340215,
0.6372765303,
0.5823513865,
-0.9957966805,
0.5237126946,
0.3620385528,
0.4138777256,
-0.2991500199,
0.84999156,
-0.2822761238,
0.6101928353,
-0.0694008842,
-0.084076032,
0.2818234265,
0.1402950287,
-0.4180731475,
0.2528380454,
0.2761642635,
-0.1756906658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12941v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12941v1 | On the Correspondence between Compositionality and Imitation in Emergent Neural Communication | 2023-05-22T11:41:29 | 2023-05-22T11:41:29 | Emily Cheng, Mathieu Rita, Thierry Poibeau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.NE | Compositionality is a hallmark of human language that not only enables
linguistic generalization, but also potentially facilitates acquisition. When
simulating language emergence with neural networks, compositionality has been
shown to improve communication performance; however, its impact on imitation
learning has yet to be investigated. Our work explores the link between
compositionality and imitation in a Lewis game played by deep neural agents.
Our contributions are twofold: first, we show that the learning algorithm used
to imitate is crucial: supervised learning tends to produce more average
languages, while reinforcement learning introduces a selection pressure toward
more compositional languages. Second, our study reveals that compositional
languages are easier to imitate, which may induce the pressure toward
compositional languages in RL imitation settings. | [
0.0645462573,
-1.0103396177,
0.7287745476,
0.7359659076,
-0.1471803188,
0.4617390037,
-0.2978109717,
-0.7559391856,
0.7359628081,
0.2118876129,
-0.4397652149,
-0.0343446806,
-0.3761051297,
-0.1372157335,
-0.1260444969,
0.7606121898,
0.1194183007,
0.0882119387,
-0.1590471864,
0.2034813762,
-0.3287884891,
-0.4839362502,
-1.0507061481,
-0.8726431131,
0.7485580444,
-0.2258746624,
0.5885081887,
0.8756582141,
-0.0717350692,
0.5995473266,
-0.105892159,
0.2765192688,
-0.6451954246,
0.5879090428,
-0.0211552605,
-0.6548876762,
-0.0539407246,
0.3797483742,
0.8789182305,
0.6233978868,
-0.1289702803,
-0.3845196962,
0.3125117123,
0.5969187021,
-0.4397086799,
0.3407554626,
-0.4425051212,
0.3333504498,
0.4676147699,
-0.3641122878,
-0.4354825616,
-0.3162355125,
0.431089431,
-0.8178821206,
-0.2996186018,
-0.0884959847,
0.4048656225,
-0.1289578229,
-0.1891566217,
-0.7203684449,
-0.9315310717,
0.6205621958,
-0.5217111111,
0.0235616472,
-0.0137889953,
0.0370380729,
-0.2023228109,
-0.8315985799,
-0.6765108705,
-0.462357223,
-0.4963347912,
0.4151653349,
-0.2311755717,
0.2592289448,
-0.0039447364,
0.2661098242,
-0.4556114376,
-0.0299325604,
-0.4491874874,
-0.0200256538,
0.4368700981,
0.3715833426,
0.6314681172,
0.1828363836,
-0.3526055813,
-0.3765586317,
-0.3179631531,
0.2076101899,
0.7115260363,
0.3149829805,
-0.1812680662,
0.1603180319,
-0.064872019,
0.669021666,
-0.0071942001,
0.2625103891,
0.1232757792,
-0.2688875198,
-0.3005513847,
0.2663722634,
0.6748959422,
0.19748725,
0.4159668088,
-0.3204732239,
-0.2183614224,
0.2842784226,
0.4028202295,
-0.5189153552,
-0.5083983541,
0.0350346528,
-0.5610995889,
-0.3974643946,
0.4613112807,
-0.5428099632,
-0.3040426373,
-0.6987281442,
0.599583149,
-0.3484837413,
-0.533324182,
-0.0321567319,
-0.1432627887,
0.5036434531,
0.2598721683,
-1.0124765635,
0.436070621,
1.0303941965,
0.6848528385,
-0.280385524,
-0.908257246,
-0.4346055686,
-0.206201002,
-0.6290838122,
0.449014008,
-0.3391243815,
-0.5230025649,
-0.0893039927,
0.0537896641,
-0.4230174422,
-0.7558357716,
-0.0018075682,
-0.6232084632,
0.220600158,
-0.3361397684,
-0.6023893952,
-0.2826907039,
0.3915008008,
-0.8172423244,
0.4189465344,
0.1274943203,
-0.0500352904,
0.2673056722,
-0.5047008991,
-0.7933081985,
0.0962593555,
-0.2873212099,
-0.3573914468,
0.3005640805,
-0.2617653012,
0.4386358857,
0.2278883308,
-0.2729154229,
-0.1381553262,
-0.716930151,
0.9612898827,
-0.3404054642,
0.609685719,
0.0051334775,
-0.5026748776,
0.1574848145,
-0.623087585,
0.4823026955,
0.1210438088,
-0.5899820328,
-0.454125911,
0.0792143792,
-0.2060969025,
0.272867173,
0.1064966321,
-0.356844157,
-0.12022724,
-0.5252292156,
0.4279232025,
0.8918642402,
0.4683893919,
0.8297607899,
-0.7548185587,
0.4523162842,
0.1604726464,
0.1203185022,
-0.0321338177,
-0.2423454076,
-0.811958015,
-0.2447476983,
0.0063416255,
0.4245790839,
-0.5160410404,
0.1585121453,
-0.2339587063,
-0.3090677261,
-0.586371839,
0.3060953915,
0.7079042196,
-0.1704343557,
0.0791998655,
-0.3725329936,
-0.733401835,
-0.8697252274,
-0.0380119793,
-0.2912797034,
0.4089445472,
0.4389707744,
0.2092787325,
-0.0227391738,
0.5878031254,
-0.1598722935,
-0.0928406864,
-0.3225021064,
0.1767426878,
0.0294827148,
0.8321717381,
0.7102897763,
-0.6247020364,
-0.712706387,
0.0743463635,
-0.927336514,
0.2687898874,
-0.3562426865,
-0.1252282858,
0.0757532269,
0.625678122,
-0.4044187069,
0.0929288492,
0.7787459493,
-0.3151518404,
0.4993553758,
-0.4262670875,
0.246105969,
-1.0364608765,
-0.2360300571,
-0.495821327,
-0.0385865718,
-0.7008491755,
0.2967003882,
-0.3499247134,
0.1950051188,
-0.4749310613,
0.0814024359,
-0.7208886147,
-0.067401439,
-0.3799738884,
-0.0788172185,
-0.0090599861,
0.495690465,
0.0444486029,
0.9363995194,
0.6131590009,
-0.9407154918,
0.3096728325,
-0.072962448,
-0.4146227837,
0.5672484636,
-1.0071649551,
-0.0375045948,
-0.1763658375,
0.0738477185,
-0.8080303073,
0.0894440711,
0.3185897171,
-0.2134422511,
0.2351818383,
0.0622433722,
-0.4487444162,
0.0956898704,
-0.0639142618,
0.4341294467,
0.704208374,
-0.3793306053,
0.7826879025,
-0.1571191251,
0.3687395453,
-0.5765298605,
-0.9375510216,
-0.065265201,
-0.0838184953,
-0.2322668731,
0.0162954442,
-0.2961469889,
-0.501865983,
-0.0076134806,
0.3614654541,
0.2056786269,
0.4006423354,
0.27921018,
-0.2725107372,
-0.5022808909,
-0.2880235016,
-0.0503653958,
0.1804529727,
0.4283023775,
-0.5477774143,
0.7892476916,
-0.2090654969,
-0.3675608635,
-0.5912076235,
0.5042217374,
0.6399694085,
-0.0079732705,
0.7413785458,
0.0940038413,
0.2294703126,
-0.57744807,
-0.0473534465,
-0.5460040569,
-0.5292333961,
0.2888783813,
-0.499548465,
-0.4914748371,
0.466850698,
-0.0011980678,
-0.2636360824,
-0.0509299524,
0.1952524483,
-0.4590249062,
0.4754295945,
0.2256862223,
-0.0399185792,
0.7139390111,
-0.5420535803,
-0.3348866701,
-0.7351859212,
-0.1198295653,
0.0962717161,
-0.7884950042,
-0.6432862282,
-0.3639102876,
0.0897476077,
-0.2975322902,
-0.086736992,
0.4911123514,
-0.1682457477,
0.8644909263,
0.816216886,
0.6530685425,
0.2101645172,
0.0880323872,
-0.1890774369,
-0.273034215,
-0.6085653305,
-0.1020469218,
0.6854108572,
-0.0367435254,
0.7109635472,
0.546390295,
1.0462186337,
0.3199543953,
0.1088590994,
-0.7664074302,
0.5633241534,
-0.0147894667,
-0.330401212,
-0.0352993496,
-0.3923543096,
-1.3279242516,
0.2761448026,
-0.2839765251,
-0.5268311501,
0.3699982166,
0.1333336234,
-0.2409745604,
0.0815702379,
-0.582849443,
0.5034914017,
-0.1413874477,
-0.4285056591,
-0.3703812063,
-0.6126186848,
0.4494953752,
0.2572141886,
-0.2225185037,
0.4202903211,
0.0196119137,
0.2823753655,
0.0122044003,
1.1824089289,
0.1710768342,
-0.220548898,
0.4810736775,
0.7404693365,
0.3700115979,
-0.1321757734,
0.0253109969,
-0.5038152933,
-0.3641785681,
-0.4928748012,
-1.004848361,
0.7035651803,
-0.8951292634,
-0.4132285416,
-0.3873894215,
-0.4610722065,
0.1079040915,
-0.2145702094,
-0.0028832448,
0.3755877018,
-0.6082008481,
0.254603982,
0.7551119924,
0.0668434575,
0.9595856667,
0.3649633229,
0.0070142029,
-0.5430377126,
1.1301493645,
-0.1917773038,
0.8942324519,
0.5828810334,
0.1776932031,
-0.0639678463,
-0.1331561506,
-0.4086284935,
0.1453076601,
-0.6884955168,
0.1972854435,
-0.6709592938,
-0.3874398172,
0.148751989,
-0.2692523897,
-0.3256079555,
-0.1718165427,
-0.5256112814,
-0.1788430661,
-0.2383470833,
1.1195323467,
-0.2809913754,
0.6182169318,
-0.4752131402,
-0.4417292178,
0.8882029057,
0.1788954288,
0.4540434182,
-0.2695335746,
-0.0929596797,
0.1642831564,
-0.1713093817,
-0.6553814411,
-0.0944841504,
0.3992062509,
0.8018222451,
0.6847768426,
-0.381357193,
0.520121932,
-0.2051887214,
0.7012726068,
-0.0033770346,
-0.9889030457,
-0.0470311493,
-0.3010487854,
0.0623319075,
0.4683032334,
0.0267188419,
-0.5966420174,
-0.2596840262,
-0.5916624069,
-0.3519080877,
0.4306941032,
0.1687584221,
0.8455464244,
-0.0584257282,
0.0410081223,
-0.128012225,
0.3246017098,
-1.1959961653,
-0.4518343806,
0.0615823604,
0.0476095751,
-0.4326276779,
-0.3974584043,
-0.2175172716,
-0.1013702676,
0.51704669,
0.1336500347,
0.6085830331,
0.2654972672,
-0.1362460405,
-0.0624774061,
0.0211713016,
1.1240955591,
0.4525734782,
0.3273904324,
0.472848475,
-0.3122021854,
-0.2610616982,
0.5670705438,
-0.2122752815,
-0.3908517063,
-0.0582405403,
0.5721872449,
0.7993862629,
0.4645958543,
-0.4790718555,
0.3400088251,
0.2389316708,
-0.4023426771,
-0.1826249063,
0.2153927088,
0.2824204266,
0.6397009492,
0.0698074475,
0.0733303949,
0.0356562026,
-0.9725415111,
0.364117682,
0.5946760178,
-0.661770165,
-0.3564050496,
0.5182170272,
-0.1705841869,
-0.4667777717,
0.5292806625,
-0.3467838168,
-0.8460389972,
0.6345894337,
0.7061690092,
0.8241245747,
-0.3223842084,
0.4664984941,
0.2019750625,
0.4134237468,
-0.0074379314,
0.4194404781,
-0.1658644825,
-0.8780799508,
-0.5805079937,
-0.3184625208,
-0.2227071822,
-0.1258836836,
-0.3050372303,
-0.2697615325,
-0.559066534,
0.3686401248,
-0.2141468078,
-0.2457835376,
-0.2089677155,
-0.0848944038,
0.0253972299,
0.290135771,
-0.8608121276,
0.6215672493,
0.5779486895,
-0.5950770378,
-0.9281178117,
0.0548976846,
-0.3827166855,
-0.6164711714,
0.8164834976,
-0.0715069696,
-0.1992819607,
0.3498552144,
-0.5823186636,
-0.5081980228,
1.0200006962,
0.2057152539,
0.1720933765,
0.3851232827,
0.182975024,
0.7877290845,
-0.6881756783,
0.209967941,
0.2873608768,
0.3727766275,
0.019463677,
-0.4489527047,
0.1281708628,
-0.2547684312,
0.0858956054,
-0.1505723894,
-0.6915954947,
1.1340608597,
0.090822421,
-0.2597031891,
0.4995397925,
0.9348255992,
0.286097765,
0.2189217806,
0.5546942949,
0.3577437699,
0.2536828816,
0.0845927447,
0.7533168793,
-0.1522284597,
-0.1509911716,
1.1283550262,
-0.1762544662,
0.5156937242,
0.6101024747,
-0.015604822,
0.987151742,
0.2489757389,
0.0931108892,
0.366340369,
0.6390932798,
-0.5369524956,
-0.0964439288,
0.0911680907,
-0.0689740703,
0.7608984113,
0.294953078,
-0.8826200366,
0.0157817919,
-0.1564975828,
-0.0337803327,
0.6833658218,
0.038024731,
1.1501598358,
-0.1135150343,
-0.7835917473,
0.4109747112,
-0.3836258054,
0.5485744476,
-0.6228677034,
-0.1293138862,
-0.3179348409,
0.1794573516,
0.207284376,
-0.3714458346,
0.0073410003,
-0.9935333729,
-0.1183423027,
-0.3163174689,
0.2450213283,
-0.8051183224,
0.0465903021,
0.5509722829,
1.0138700008,
0.1616861969,
-0.100344032,
-0.5932638049,
-0.078011848,
-0.3074475229,
-0.1084044054,
0.2737081051,
0.3269730508,
0.3092823625,
0.4253731966,
0.6101687551,
0.1962070018,
0.2800385952,
-0.3213868737,
0.6953123808,
-0.2661752701,
-0.7103792429,
-1.1375089884,
0.4438824356,
-0.3690482676,
-0.1988313794,
0.6749982238,
0.7661719918,
0.6693957448,
-0.7217088342,
0.5457097888,
-0.0681286752,
-0.1647201926,
-0.6774709225,
0.875988245,
-0.3222734034,
-0.0806861445,
-0.4690019488,
-1.0961750746,
0.0715287998,
0.5950893164,
0.1526825875,
0.123941958,
0.768871963,
0.946588695,
-0.428230226,
0.0978865847,
0.7241126895,
0.0580057725,
0.1693043411,
0.5847781897,
1.3568193913,
-0.3535705805,
0.311334908,
-0.3151720762,
0.0130417552,
0.0382917076,
-0.7049670815,
-0.822089076,
-0.8024443388,
-0.0441601425,
-0.7434427738,
0.0805366114,
1.339315176,
0.9225776792,
-0.6568204761,
-0.6650899649,
-0.445666492,
0.1134754941,
-0.9500686526,
-0.2519262731,
-0.0198935047,
-0.4922380149,
-1.1325439215,
0.7854754925,
-0.0023678343,
0.7545878291,
-0.5291187167,
-0.3843942583,
-0.265992254,
0.1807102263,
0.7250229716,
0.6106547713,
-0.548330605,
-0.0589658953,
0.1131092608,
-0.3514046371,
-0.0452579707,
1.3922358751,
-0.6119092107,
0.5000683665,
0.4231154919,
0.8870557547,
0.2289050519,
-0.081269443,
0.8630697727,
-0.9104995131,
0.3086566925,
0.0845338106,
0.0751033351,
0.212971136,
-0.3962683976,
0.2671266198,
0.5799206495,
-0.2805043161,
-0.3170710504,
0.579092741,
-0.9683987498,
-0.2029628158,
1.2620573044,
-0.1504230797,
-0.2777502239,
-0.0007644332,
-0.2868894935,
0.027275281,
-0.344683975,
0.5724292397,
0.5729513168,
0.0084940819,
-0.1993770897,
-0.3232544065,
0.6757036448,
0.4936574101,
-0.538156271,
-0.2678748667,
0.286839664,
0.111661844,
0.1339291781,
0.483951211,
0.3348824978,
0.4066108167,
0.0911318511,
-0.1406431645,
0.0270954911,
-0.2084771395,
-0.3246251345,
0.0513190329,
-0.0616501532,
-0.4073167145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12940v1 | GEST: the Graph of Events in Space and Time as a Common Representation between Vision and Language | 2023-05-22T11:38:27 | 2023-05-22T11:38:27 | Mihai Masala, Nicolae Cudlenco, Traian Rebedea, Marius Leordeanu | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the essential human skills is the ability to seamlessly build an inner
representation of the world. By exploiting this representation, humans are
capable of easily finding consensus between visual, auditory and linguistic
perspectives. In this work, we set out to understand and emulate this ability
through an explicit representation for both vision and language - Graphs of
Events in Space and Time (GEST). GEST alows us to measure the similarity
between texts and videos in a semantic and fully explainable way, through graph
matching. It also allows us to generate text and videos from a common
representation that provides a well understood content. In this work we show
that the graph matching similarity metrics based on GEST outperform classical
text generation metrics and can also boost the performance of state of art,
heavily trained metrics. | [
-0.5383827686,
-0.5465769768,
0.8736076355,
-0.2335467786,
-0.4630077481,
0.2270278037,
-0.1080714464,
-0.5433057547,
0.346963346,
0.0289702695,
-0.4227346182,
-0.6472315788,
-0.5288451314,
-0.274056524,
-0.5911291838,
0.9198915362,
-0.261782825,
-0.1394490153,
-0.1530648917,
-0.3411546052,
-0.1584883332,
-0.528465867,
-0.6713715792,
-0.5735635161,
0.4649985731,
-0.112604849,
0.7894428968,
0.6950774193,
0.6447905302,
0.3318671584,
0.0620499626,
0.190320015,
-0.5494781733,
-0.3082770705,
-0.3838687241,
0.1848763078,
-0.0907183588,
-0.0582047142,
0.9301498532,
0.9008338451,
0.1840069294,
0.0593088716,
0.5260025859,
0.4990402758,
-0.156559974,
0.1926093698,
-0.4329983294,
0.3817636967,
-0.1180833131,
-0.4225085378,
0.1687091887,
-0.4430952668,
0.1423350573,
-1.0303539038,
0.6049349308,
0.070835568,
1.2954915762,
0.132708922,
-0.4345335662,
-0.2944427431,
-0.6678264737,
0.4250607789,
-0.178712219,
0.4756003618,
-0.1065410525,
0.4481469989,
-0.0835691169,
-0.9166615009,
-0.7525082827,
0.0848087817,
-0.2183491439,
0.0536147133,
-0.1115837693,
0.058847934,
0.3566115797,
0.194534719,
-0.8598700166,
-0.0272356011,
-0.1927925348,
-0.3568914831,
0.4216260016,
0.3358407021,
0.7126619816,
-0.2266968787,
-0.4260896146,
-0.4093820155,
-0.3341475129,
-0.2909661233,
0.4947759211,
-0.0675824583,
-0.1348678172,
0.535985589,
-0.1348244697,
0.7507508993,
-0.4418048859,
0.2245463133,
0.2528629899,
-0.5451740026,
-0.2710445821,
-0.1765890568,
0.7520002127,
0.9635616541,
0.6287434697,
-0.1993211061,
0.4255134463,
0.6248130202,
-0.0842159986,
-0.6488796473,
-0.1587621272,
-0.5833283067,
-0.3482598066,
-0.0541530959,
0.4640566111,
-0.8009775281,
-0.1908678263,
-0.3755494952,
0.4060400426,
-0.6367735863,
-0.0274909567,
0.3397471607,
-0.633607924,
0.2807354033,
0.4303439856,
-0.8151456118,
0.4164157212,
0.7401058674,
1.0244450569,
0.0660565421,
-0.4886003733,
-0.2501546144,
0.3047939837,
-0.3914518654,
0.8769587278,
-0.3599853814,
-0.2263596803,
-0.094405219,
-0.1181321219,
0.1025047302,
-0.0268883314,
0.297983557,
-0.4329757392,
0.2343933135,
-0.1763963103,
-0.7539311051,
-0.4017241597,
0.2199386209,
-0.5099617243,
1.0000060797,
0.0476342477,
-0.8275341392,
0.8680228591,
-0.7247357368,
-0.4675272405,
0.2371910959,
-0.4267390072,
-0.1970561743,
-0.2046174705,
0.4280315936,
0.5193797946,
0.072079733,
-0.0122981146,
-0.3711889386,
-0.4557951093,
0.0064253472,
-0.1213154271,
0.1278166026,
0.1885084361,
-0.1850560308,
-0.0879404247,
-0.5469692945,
0.16483742,
0.192460835,
-0.0517201796,
-0.5616893172,
0.3900519013,
0.2059261799,
0.0883602127,
0.1813737452,
-0.5797109604,
0.0412990935,
-0.4617805779,
0.5677517056,
0.5535830855,
0.2623816431,
0.6051424742,
0.0758729503,
0.2175549418,
-0.1837848127,
-0.0910655633,
-0.1437845528,
-0.4220944047,
-0.2634855509,
0.1797346026,
-0.1606800854,
0.4365715683,
-0.6104906201,
0.2809971571,
-0.7160955667,
-0.4998588264,
-0.184406504,
0.1627390236,
0.3379657269,
0.5335801244,
0.0403775126,
-0.5650061369,
-0.6837304831,
-0.6985964179,
-0.3261478841,
-0.3140980005,
-0.3140181601,
0.4868993461,
0.3908003867,
0.0019615483,
0.7848184109,
-0.6880754232,
-0.2077785134,
-0.0129505703,
0.0019079427,
0.2159997821,
0.153745532,
0.9272998571,
-0.7440600991,
-0.5310773253,
0.5424595475,
-1.1912766695,
-0.0271266606,
0.0208005682,
-0.0786469355,
-0.0553201213,
0.6823996902,
0.0997855961,
0.5433732867,
0.4978255928,
-0.9064579606,
0.1644893885,
-0.2801679373,
0.758441329,
-1.092428565,
0.0750514269,
-0.0222590193,
-0.4938344657,
-0.1679344177,
-0.0472243913,
-0.2886393368,
-0.6752377748,
-0.5243067145,
0.7844646573,
-0.3188354373,
-0.5453972816,
-0.1310792416,
0.914976716,
0.0637967661,
0.3481121659,
-0.0781881064,
0.7020084858,
0.5987741947,
-0.488065362,
0.5128938556,
0.4179632366,
-0.7501216531,
0.8084774613,
-0.5432790518,
0.0780283734,
-0.1452365071,
0.0159956813,
-0.9798186421,
-0.2732597589,
0.0360075496,
-0.6607416868,
-0.1668761224,
-0.0398395658,
-0.6935186982,
-0.4962398112,
0.1080260426,
0.3497101665,
0.6349242926,
-0.5754938722,
0.577570498,
0.337924242,
-0.1739399433,
-0.2601760924,
-0.5966430902,
0.231752798,
-0.2148154527,
-0.8869537115,
0.3332894146,
0.1831462085,
-0.2101130486,
0.5855710506,
0.1361998469,
0.1562882364,
-0.1830610484,
0.4087492228,
0.0987994224,
-0.4171757996,
0.0068147066,
-0.303037405,
-0.4998162389,
-0.3597220778,
-0.6984249353,
0.4956107438,
-0.1916809529,
-0.7273445725,
-0.2483380884,
0.5677168369,
0.358295083,
0.2270973027,
0.2889422774,
0.7344834805,
-0.3796581328,
0.1841689795,
-0.1609238535,
0.0233019348,
-0.3950048089,
0.7405334711,
-0.2654839754,
-1.0843193531,
0.6123890877,
-0.1307203174,
-0.1483647525,
0.4934594333,
0.384965241,
-0.3650452197,
1.0317274332,
0.5788987279,
-0.2177247703,
0.8241789937,
-0.1161726862,
0.0197035614,
-0.5909122825,
-0.0844399557,
-0.4496082962,
-0.6188346148,
-0.2463460565,
-0.4448531568,
0.3629363179,
0.0711886138,
-0.4538272619,
0.3552478552,
-0.591227293,
0.9636309743,
0.464507848,
-0.0781444162,
0.2908358872,
0.3750407398,
-0.2285718173,
-0.5068596005,
-0.6123397946,
-0.707272768,
0.6115834713,
-0.0589181557,
0.7256280184,
-0.1580756009,
0.5217554569,
0.3951644897,
-0.1458993405,
-0.4388804734,
0.7700988054,
-0.400482744,
-0.0994333401,
-0.3383280635,
-0.3281756341,
-0.9975112677,
0.1460001767,
-0.1740940064,
-1.0788621902,
-0.3078306019,
0.1004501656,
0.0239134617,
0.6406798959,
-0.7390998006,
0.9476924539,
0.0946408212,
0.099664174,
-0.5258306265,
-0.6425689459,
-0.2490205914,
0.2862353623,
0.1062168404,
-0.1268736571,
0.1535518467,
0.950156033,
-0.2340270132,
0.6781749129,
0.0430977754,
0.3865545392,
0.5467998385,
0.251914531,
0.1461263448,
0.0185074676,
0.2066136301,
0.2199237794,
-0.1739553511,
-0.2976813614,
-0.8666779399,
0.7600912452,
-0.9128897786,
-0.2319857776,
-0.2819668651,
-0.365115881,
0.2457302958,
0.1340464801,
0.3036285937,
0.7044496536,
-0.8036988974,
-0.2219722271,
0.1099750623,
-0.0073759118,
0.4621402919,
0.2589210868,
-0.5224667788,
-0.5604780316,
0.8116220832,
-0.0719993711,
0.1960376203,
0.5398656726,
-0.0782384798,
-0.3715827763,
0.0149743669,
-0.3421643674,
0.1224816069,
-1.0098278522,
-0.0113090416,
-0.552339375,
-0.402033329,
0.0602586642,
-0.8305113316,
0.2142858207,
-0.3712168634,
-0.3255757689,
-0.5134539008,
0.4760848582,
0.8571535945,
-0.2776829004,
0.2582353354,
-0.6949626207,
0.2529065013,
0.3791776896,
0.4373144209,
-0.1292507052,
-0.1460183263,
-0.2824435532,
-0.3818421364,
-0.4427468777,
-0.795119822,
-0.0297876727,
0.5604188442,
0.4321312904,
0.3812292218,
-0.6921369433,
0.896397531,
-0.7947682738,
1.0639897585,
0.3916230798,
-1.109795332,
0.6772537231,
-0.4121850431,
0.2274885476,
0.2121290863,
-0.0441387482,
-1.0706450939,
-0.5333824158,
-0.9664631486,
-0.6323981881,
0.3115131557,
0.3418355286,
0.1412695646,
0.0526640862,
0.0879742801,
-0.0552566648,
-0.289008528,
-0.4210953116,
0.2350073755,
-0.4008905888,
-0.2688613236,
-0.4520768523,
0.2657864392,
-0.1094481573,
-0.094960846,
0.1925803572,
-0.2948901951,
0.3683847785,
0.3660608232,
0.1060196236,
-0.0123223374,
0.1873150617,
0.2357248813,
0.473216027,
0.2429847568,
0.3311474919,
0.3994997144,
-0.5695538521,
0.1298204809,
0.0358094424,
-0.0879031122,
0.242968455,
0.6496403813,
0.9362357259,
0.3369305134,
-0.5597378016,
0.3098417819,
0.1366991699,
-0.3448339999,
-0.0211755652,
0.1535066962,
0.099742353,
0.3926511109,
0.3130814135,
-0.0014909039,
0.0359021537,
-0.4250292778,
0.5163319111,
0.2194622904,
-0.6932933927,
-0.4412929118,
0.8450779319,
0.0846578628,
-0.3887247443,
0.5904385448,
-0.351698786,
-0.6408887506,
0.7449899316,
0.5428112745,
0.6216628551,
0.3404945135,
0.4725163579,
0.6070518494,
-0.0168004651,
0.1674900502,
0.5345217586,
0.1382123381,
-0.965803504,
-0.4715301096,
-0.6032310128,
-0.1281237006,
-0.3205999732,
-0.4660659432,
0.1875113845,
-0.2365849316,
-0.1501438767,
0.1160355061,
0.0549305975,
-1.0301856995,
0.1851447821,
0.2198141217,
0.6462184191,
-1.1403163671,
0.3963357508,
0.8646832705,
-0.333011806,
-0.9102218151,
-0.2606216967,
0.0854528546,
-0.8244823813,
0.4400434792,
-0.0925547183,
-0.0263998136,
0.1169238314,
-0.3727438152,
-0.6026411057,
1.0613965988,
0.404084146,
-0.5544534326,
-0.0138844056,
0.0664493591,
0.8297069073,
-0.3846558332,
-0.1338834018,
0.2562624514,
0.3662755489,
0.1348233968,
-0.7816774249,
-0.063161321,
-0.1749268472,
0.0536829196,
0.7466762066,
-0.2664761543,
0.3952171504,
-0.4217794836,
-0.6853613257,
-0.1200609431,
0.7354480624,
0.0628887489,
0.4875976145,
0.4590364993,
0.7115865946,
0.6346094012,
-0.3463921249,
1.0077124834,
-0.019290911,
0.6297119856,
0.9547099471,
-0.2808342576,
0.4364556372,
0.3431182206,
-0.2429195046,
0.6660864949,
0.5582019091,
-0.1618096232,
0.5360584259,
-0.0114351939,
-0.0199402217,
-0.2799779177,
-0.136189267,
-0.2782173455,
0.1748411655,
0.2833697796,
-0.3041613102,
-0.7186431885,
0.150116995,
-0.1704920977,
0.5460258126,
-0.4034399986,
0.938039422,
0.2371552289,
-0.3246867359,
-0.0353674814,
-0.5496001244,
0.1297336668,
-0.7596606016,
-0.1124875695,
0.2656204104,
0.0667707399,
0.0193571541,
-1.6379790306,
0.4901153147,
0.015452059,
-0.1339453459,
-0.0827106982,
0.840169549,
-0.215388447,
-0.3351789713,
0.6335844994,
0.3826116621,
0.3966319263,
0.2706695199,
-0.5180604458,
-0.1917048246,
-0.0862643421,
0.1622877121,
0.1189620942,
0.7867967486,
-0.1960898787,
0.4371029437,
0.4073008895,
0.2677721679,
-0.0217507593,
0.4190891087,
0.5626485348,
-0.7954970002,
-0.9756957293,
-1.045429945,
0.169397831,
-0.4091734886,
-0.4775467217,
0.581017375,
0.6461575031,
0.9808910489,
-0.103279911,
0.8426272869,
-0.2819982469,
0.2123130113,
-0.5573707223,
0.6585386992,
-0.5342459083,
-0.4971170723,
-0.7494945526,
-0.8948551416,
-0.3750643432,
0.4431187809,
-0.2156559229,
-0.1543531418,
0.8942166567,
0.5696057081,
-0.3041467965,
-0.0539013371,
0.4862805307,
-0.1589112729,
0.3554325104,
0.9365313649,
0.8961820006,
-0.3647808731,
0.7871650457,
0.5306594372,
-0.1923548728,
-0.024798857,
-0.9139350653,
-0.8070150614,
-1.0556665659,
-0.2371559739,
-0.2311384529,
0.1653781533,
0.411703825,
0.6033089161,
-0.2931990623,
0.0550441965,
0.0637134016,
0.1583814621,
-0.4599087238,
-0.2171256393,
0.6250142455,
0.0008212373,
-0.6459565759,
0.1163371503,
0.5898435116,
0.4631548822,
0.0271034315,
-0.1588078588,
0.2202206552,
-0.0815368444,
0.5773389935,
0.3852887452,
-0.4943361878,
-1.0267332792,
-0.1392520964,
-0.233933419,
0.1312824935,
1.0063453913,
-0.7773706317,
0.4652074873,
0.7576418519,
0.397467494,
0.7897443771,
-0.0823013932,
0.627302587,
-0.9485386014,
0.3341526687,
0.072001636,
0.6294785142,
0.5828461647,
-0.1496395171,
0.9513113499,
0.487854898,
-0.6144918799,
-0.4425403178,
0.5965945125,
-1.2306190729,
0.104673624,
0.892043829,
-0.0659268275,
-0.14164415,
-0.0844339803,
-0.4141184688,
0.4169654548,
-0.1021517068,
0.5433751941,
0.8588383794,
-0.0676946267,
0.2095031291,
-0.3305734694,
0.1996767819,
-0.1130781844,
-0.6678321362,
-0.3807643652,
0.3743136525,
0.453646183,
0.2978380919,
0.7056769133,
-0.1188144684,
0.1803388894,
0.2720865309,
-0.0502057709,
0.1755078882,
-0.229352504,
0.0877585262,
0.2458171099,
-0.4318542778,
-0.2988477945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12927v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12927v1 | Exploring Speaker-Related Information in Spoken Language Understanding for Better Speaker Diarization | 2023-05-22T11:14:19 | 2023-05-22T11:14:19 | Luyao Cheng, Siqi Zheng, Zhang Qinglin, Hui Wang, Yafeng Chen, Qian Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speaker diarization(SD) is a classic task in speech processing and is crucial
in multi-party scenarios such as meetings and conversations. Current mainstream
speaker diarization approaches consider acoustic information only, which result
in performance degradation when encountering adverse acoustic conditions. In
this paper, we propose methods to extract speaker-related information from
semantic content in multi-party meetings, which, as we will show, can further
benefit speaker diarization. We introduce two sub-tasks, Dialogue Detection and
Speaker-Turn Detection, in which we effectively extract speaker information
from conversational semantics. We also propose a simple yet effective algorithm
to jointly model acoustic and semantic information and obtain
speaker-identified texts. Experiments on both AISHELL-4 and AliMeeting datasets
show that our method achieves consistent improvements over acoustic-only
speaker diarization systems. | [
-0.5448868871,
-0.8239943385,
0.6123063564,
0.0372154862,
-0.2490952015,
-0.1665351391,
-0.3804721832,
-0.6429347396,
0.2828018069,
0.769775629,
-0.7884957194,
-0.6081908941,
-0.4210891426,
-0.1126717627,
-0.4408551157,
0.7901572585,
0.6125154495,
0.0325882584,
-0.2315667272,
0.006337421,
-0.4398124218,
-0.4313031435,
-0.4695363641,
-0.5053009987,
0.3389543891,
0.6390378475,
0.4452663958,
0.5135486722,
0.3914097548,
0.352437377,
-0.2467744201,
0.0780984312,
-0.2954590321,
0.335126996,
-0.1795447916,
-0.2804579735,
-0.3515401483,
0.0392844267,
0.6755478978,
0.9682818651,
-0.3830984533,
-0.1923836321,
-0.1131449714,
0.4330433309,
-0.450858742,
0.6132995486,
-0.6798993349,
0.0020706223,
-0.5079901814,
-0.5601332188,
-0.6754559875,
-0.0135197127,
0.227515921,
-0.6035027504,
0.4636816084,
-0.1896420866,
0.6190761924,
0.0786246434,
-0.2958186269,
-0.3279111981,
-1.0569303036,
0.6738897562,
-0.7336634994,
0.8900539279,
0.521069169,
0.1733708084,
-0.2140681297,
-0.4007529318,
-0.8023812771,
0.048366949,
-0.1660500467,
0.1864819974,
-0.0219569132,
0.3233384788,
0.122130543,
0.252366066,
-0.3092075288,
0.0336690731,
-0.214679569,
-0.3447526991,
0.5908218026,
-0.1235680729,
0.4676506221,
-0.2455613613,
-0.3963292241,
-0.3108865321,
-0.5909859538,
-0.1252343804,
0.3174162507,
0.6858894825,
-0.0129449982,
0.5135324001,
-0.2285634577,
0.7378008962,
-0.1045161486,
-0.3675591946,
0.4223398566,
-0.9568062425,
0.210996449,
0.3848862052,
0.5338683128,
0.3162257969,
0.2856904864,
-0.362567395,
0.0547175892,
-0.2395118475,
-0.2129200548,
-0.520217061,
-0.558288157,
0.1894757301,
-0.4690932333,
0.1997705847,
0.1176895127,
-0.9375740886,
-0.4736527801,
-0.4157826602,
0.1831970364,
-0.5067787766,
-0.7453276515,
0.0401560329,
-0.5473942757,
0.4612905085,
0.2692397535,
-1.1447458267,
0.3948969543,
0.9136212468,
0.527844429,
-0.0612678155,
-0.209388569,
-0.8631939292,
0.5360584855,
-0.0509536527,
0.8022736311,
-0.679643631,
-0.447530508,
-0.2353852987,
-0.151813522,
-0.2584155798,
-0.5175059438,
0.3803194761,
-0.2970913351,
0.1600188017,
-0.1965780556,
-0.7000135183,
-0.0458765849,
-0.172992155,
-0.6166818142,
0.5718978643,
-0.2842949331,
-0.9974437952,
0.4856851399,
-0.3696583509,
-0.1771463752,
0.1995629966,
-0.4153056443,
-0.2424387485,
0.120879598,
0.2841045558,
0.4366115332,
0.2257458419,
-0.1525279284,
-0.0679457933,
-0.1865419596,
0.2250478119,
-0.1650254875,
0.4242454767,
-0.1397671551,
0.0266806092,
0.0524539314,
-0.970766902,
-0.257188797,
0.0745651349,
-0.3240184188,
-0.6642988324,
0.4709255695,
-0.0789330676,
-0.0434788987,
0.1673072577,
-0.9145610929,
-0.1232362464,
-0.7683140039,
0.0750651509,
0.5506266952,
0.2979186475,
0.3547454774,
0.0998097211,
0.0362425707,
0.1915381402,
-0.183620736,
-0.4911071062,
-0.7172971964,
-0.7071859837,
-0.2478929311,
0.1811453998,
0.5858318806,
-0.7349769473,
0.2721497416,
-0.1971877664,
-0.1173892692,
-0.6124907136,
0.047699973,
0.5096831918,
0.4741984904,
0.3659245968,
-0.3540950418,
-0.4627604187,
-0.7095839977,
-0.3321957886,
-0.6852465272,
-0.0581534095,
0.398150295,
-0.1035045907,
-0.0448627435,
1.0589156151,
-0.3998035192,
-0.2163374573,
-0.3208818734,
0.4869972765,
0.2533880174,
0.2142249197,
0.1997185946,
-1.0324664116,
-0.2981131375,
0.3082454801,
-0.2232573628,
-0.2673015594,
-0.0883000121,
0.2560553253,
-0.025611857,
0.6528564692,
-0.4391999245,
0.4503399134,
0.3554547429,
-0.3084582686,
0.4706028402,
-0.0100434227,
-0.0698815957,
-0.7143567204,
-0.4569708407,
-0.1164144501,
-0.2946867645,
-1.1462785006,
-0.3716937006,
-0.3293428123,
0.1200887337,
-0.2204981148,
0.2831073105,
-0.3519214988,
-0.3528377116,
-0.3811861277,
0.7256156206,
-0.0681190193,
0.4449077845,
0.4933263361,
0.6461653113,
0.371833086,
-0.5593158603,
0.5607867837,
0.562795043,
-0.5301759243,
0.6067795753,
-0.2818224728,
0.462951839,
-0.3653067052,
-0.0182556771,
-1.3054810762,
-0.1243412718,
0.1745992303,
-0.4139728546,
0.4106229246,
-0.398812294,
-0.2573325932,
0.0838651434,
0.0389644243,
0.3616125286,
-0.0691748187,
-0.6283102632,
0.5486155748,
0.7774299383,
-0.6817032099,
-0.242322892,
-0.3445475399,
0.1235684231,
-0.2408137918,
-0.6250485778,
0.5430107117,
0.1391627789,
-0.6292048097,
-0.275788933,
-0.0825210139,
-0.2057777047,
-0.188133955,
0.114236474,
-0.0387878418,
0.0329850353,
0.4365822971,
-0.3359495699,
-0.6465640068,
-0.1206733286,
-0.076437369,
0.6833689213,
-0.0101136034,
-0.3927874565,
-0.8202037811,
0.7558689713,
0.1459890455,
-0.3358795047,
0.6267834902,
0.7607415318,
-0.0253915917,
-0.0515873171,
-0.572073102,
-0.3879488111,
-0.4189634919,
0.522318244,
-0.6467541456,
-0.5949937105,
0.4372712076,
-0.2146639675,
0.0019431391,
0.2060904354,
0.5117605925,
-0.1990737468,
1.0289238691,
0.9176487327,
0.1041479483,
0.6358624697,
0.1880587637,
0.4766510725,
-0.6715809703,
-0.6741554141,
-0.8179306388,
0.2933261395,
-0.7617321014,
-0.3437649608,
0.2802618444,
-0.1600320488,
0.5061938167,
0.5897321701,
-0.2873968482,
0.3560266495,
0.4960053265,
0.0483843721,
0.5011232495,
-0.2895442247,
-0.0503096692,
-0.0583770201,
-0.3774276674,
-0.1293427944,
0.2546010315,
0.4832415283,
0.7908228636,
-0.0437521748,
0.8843916059,
-0.0814639181,
-0.6124626994,
-0.9282232523,
0.5684606433,
0.0762371197,
-0.2519203424,
-0.516870141,
-0.719072938,
-0.7888889909,
0.4412530065,
0.0601919331,
-1.0674362183,
0.6974439621,
-0.1790932268,
0.0255145766,
-0.0287881233,
-0.7624759078,
0.5632445216,
0.2017179281,
0.3948449194,
-0.5564135909,
-0.6933795214,
-0.2219407707,
0.0974796638,
0.7413496971,
-0.4585184157,
0.184842065,
1.0443502665,
-0.1494163573,
0.7248433828,
-0.4348563552,
-0.3006917834,
0.1867393702,
-0.0977923125,
0.3231346905,
0.01476005,
-0.2484934181,
0.250605166,
0.3185866177,
-0.222542882,
-0.5604490638,
0.5423308611,
-0.6119724512,
-0.4794407189,
0.0306009687,
-0.5061784983,
-0.423854351,
0.0159084052,
0.1154830754,
0.4841244817,
-0.2481723726,
0.0751084834,
0.6647663116,
-0.1034152806,
0.5516269207,
0.6123940945,
-0.1084470972,
-0.1087180302,
1.0454683304,
-0.1780036688,
0.2319273204,
0.6187528372,
0.0910313874,
-0.2816831768,
-0.6501805782,
-0.0769324526,
0.336664319,
-0.7462351918,
0.257309705,
-0.6634373665,
-0.1253432184,
-0.4218948483,
0.5333384871,
-0.5288988352,
-0.7387802601,
-0.1341771036,
-0.2775192559,
0.0080210874,
0.693248868,
-0.1581824571,
0.4874446094,
-0.6405677795,
0.2782177925,
0.5154953599,
0.0850181505,
-0.355232954,
-0.1214981377,
-0.2172456533,
0.0693613589,
-0.1106638536,
-1.2393014431,
0.1009741202,
0.669683814,
0.7619285583,
0.5748284459,
-0.0276771411,
0.566803813,
-0.4834021926,
0.7169832587,
0.263052851,
-1.0104602575,
0.8581157923,
-0.1685643196,
0.2367872894,
0.5011890531,
-0.0304268561,
-0.8988673687,
-0.3612809479,
-0.4240303636,
-0.9725549817,
1.0947716236,
0.3224323094,
0.1116969734,
-0.1119605824,
0.1730797887,
0.20975779,
0.0957005769,
-0.5459378362,
-0.0206552576,
-0.1412246972,
0.1532873362,
-0.2095166147,
-0.442092061,
-0.1178639606,
-0.1502504051,
0.6118516922,
-0.0403389558,
0.5243852139,
0.0697229356,
0.0140643893,
-0.0611307919,
0.4643089473,
0.2173366249,
0.6380574703,
-0.249609217,
0.3888191879,
0.1057874933,
-0.3895296156,
-0.2286862284,
0.0392863639,
0.4499824047,
0.2400303185,
0.8092625737,
0.7345343232,
0.1103183031,
-0.4117944241,
0.6858743429,
-0.1817277819,
0.2657622397,
-0.1404319406,
0.1795326173,
0.0878241956,
0.1404915899,
0.2086634934,
-0.3862873912,
0.3741950095,
-0.8262064457,
0.5596932173,
0.3167893291,
-0.6302199364,
-0.4989612997,
-0.0676543489,
0.255235821,
-0.3939366639,
0.8282921314,
0.0277851317,
-0.4412360191,
0.3326104581,
0.4654351771,
0.6396225095,
-0.6887658834,
0.2896794379,
0.0135101872,
-0.1304752827,
0.6283952594,
0.4444798231,
-0.8511943221,
-1.1005893946,
-0.6315112114,
-0.589584589,
-0.618668735,
-0.1892107576,
-0.7805321217,
0.1501054168,
0.1086641699,
-0.1939079762,
0.5644185543,
-0.0805164352,
-0.3024205267,
-0.1242496148,
0.5833291411,
0.5955025554,
-0.8474833965,
0.7489814758,
0.3502413034,
0.0621639155,
-0.4201325178,
0.1100013927,
0.0326633342,
-0.5732574463,
0.3774859309,
0.1417719424,
-0.2570181489,
-0.1903941333,
-0.3294867277,
-0.4382618368,
0.5085702538,
0.1349949539,
-0.6290891171,
-0.0645815432,
0.4790274203,
0.2675375938,
-0.160201475,
0.4350000024,
0.7681618929,
0.634039402,
0.5776348114,
-1.1599601507,
-0.4951123893,
-0.1133909151,
-0.11118038,
0.5221575499,
-0.4608044326,
0.6016045809,
-0.0285835881,
-0.3151614964,
-0.178103447,
0.7839860916,
-0.0353674218,
0.4429180324,
0.8270087242,
0.3203168809,
0.9617403746,
-0.2613555491,
0.6313635111,
-0.1246714592,
0.2368561178,
1.1534297466,
-0.1895215809,
0.6959927082,
0.6597496271,
-0.118998453,
0.502610743,
0.5314283967,
0.493214041,
0.8812195063,
0.0209688675,
-0.463866204,
-0.5577499866,
-0.3632839024,
-0.278116107,
1.1382468939,
0.6235071421,
0.106017828,
-0.3737358153,
0.2554528415,
-0.0260404795,
-0.0710764527,
-0.0686918274,
1.4994535446,
0.2006035894,
-0.2766630948,
0.214777723,
-0.0980535075,
0.0719735771,
-0.3021778166,
-0.2800986767,
0.1939193755,
0.1427557617,
-0.3499256074,
-0.7604243159,
0.5391589403,
-0.3949073255,
-0.2594517469,
-0.3174060583,
0.8605348468,
-0.6119844913,
-0.08193589,
0.5677277446,
0.4573585391,
0.3992724717,
0.036965929,
-0.242649883,
0.131088078,
-0.0504717641,
0.0497537963,
0.0748159364,
0.4945904315,
0.1008952782,
0.4513955712,
0.3421410918,
0.1853177398,
0.0640599355,
0.3715347648,
0.7974114418,
-0.5173530579,
-0.6439935565,
-0.865661025,
0.1375863403,
-0.2290886194,
-0.1107767075,
0.6993171573,
0.3996049762,
0.8934798241,
0.3727762997,
0.4117743969,
0.1558487564,
0.8015086651,
-0.5559777021,
0.2932304442,
-0.1066773906,
0.4781630933,
-0.4662924707,
-0.8381792903,
0.0088923993,
0.634824574,
-0.3016980886,
-0.2200576514,
0.3047664165,
0.5984976888,
-0.1224044263,
0.5752969384,
0.292021066,
0.3866427839,
0.5605504513,
0.2662393451,
1.058409214,
0.0282676443,
0.461574614,
-0.5179866552,
-0.4499155283,
-0.06527666,
-0.6869207621,
-0.8092127442,
-1.0513061285,
-0.5385136604,
0.0866143703,
0.1950399876,
0.6761056185,
1.0707454681,
-1.0175952911,
-0.2902256548,
0.0722273141,
0.3717598915,
-0.3006475568,
-0.2037095726,
0.2878451645,
-0.4177478552,
-0.7490881085,
1.0543448925,
0.5612748265,
-0.2538884282,
0.0770298243,
0.0694716796,
-0.1461084485,
0.3228441775,
0.4020578861,
0.1391550601,
-0.4444645941,
-0.4691067338,
-0.435685277,
0.317625165,
0.1570631862,
0.7537455559,
-0.6431132555,
0.817360878,
0.7468723655,
0.1354401112,
0.960089922,
0.2478844672,
0.562975347,
-1.093931675,
0.377220124,
0.2387725264,
0.1830527633,
0.4061621726,
-0.2775316536,
0.2065615952,
0.2274760008,
-0.4847633243,
-0.5991525054,
0.428933084,
-1.1301032305,
-0.1364645362,
1.0022051334,
-0.1561609358,
-0.0642734021,
-0.4655947387,
-0.2156800181,
0.3619353771,
-0.2563050985,
0.4693754315,
0.8405383825,
-0.5569643378,
-0.3676367998,
-0.3053041101,
0.5726007223,
0.1728046387,
-0.5913960934,
0.159885928,
0.1674085855,
-0.0626556575,
0.5493389964,
0.7881553769,
-0.1681338698,
0.0322602838,
-0.1794545352,
-0.0972976238,
0.2462148666,
-0.7455729842,
0.0114652105,
0.095892787,
-0.1827517301,
-0.3886972368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12924v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12924v2 | EnCore: Fine-Grained Entity Typing by Pre-Training Entity Encoders on Coreference Chains | 2023-05-22T11:11:59 | 2024-01-27T13:12:43 | Frank Mtumbuka, Steven Schockaert | cs.CL | cs.CL | Entity typing is the task of assigning semantic types to the entities that
are mentioned in a text. In the case of fine-grained entity typing (FET), a
large set of candidate type labels is considered. Since obtaining sufficient
amounts of manual annotations is then prohibitively expensive, FET models are
typically trained using distant supervision. In this paper, we propose to
improve on this process by pre-training an entity encoder such that embeddings
of coreferring entities are more similar to each other than to the embeddings
of other entities. The main problem with this strategy, which helps to explain
why it has not previously been considered, is that predicted coreference links
are often too noisy. We show that this problem can be addressed by using a
simple trick: we only consider coreference links that are predicted by two
different off-the-shelf systems. With this prudent use of coreference links,
our pre-training strategy allows us to improve the state-of-the-art in
benchmarks on fine-grained entity typing, as well as traditional entity
extraction. | [
-0.7963510156,
-0.5720941424,
0.5266969204,
-0.2405552566,
-0.4861777425,
0.0006421289,
-0.5405167341,
-0.7984704971,
0.3941569626,
0.5599582791,
-0.4079681039,
-0.3186652958,
-0.5741571188,
0.2758105099,
-0.2173615992,
1.2240839005,
-0.0641627535,
0.0441979766,
-0.2671934068,
0.0880980268,
0.0190899856,
-0.4677280188,
-0.4606862366,
-0.4437189102,
0.3581147492,
0.2388167232,
0.9219895005,
0.5718801618,
0.7611812949,
0.2032717913,
-0.0805342197,
0.3064342141,
-0.3723080754,
0.1011779904,
-0.4206648171,
-0.4559693635,
-0.5918604732,
-0.2079764456,
0.354516089,
0.7778006196,
0.2339738756,
0.1222769916,
0.2407723814,
0.5156977177,
-0.6877948642,
0.2343494594,
-0.7917011976,
0.0786626115,
-0.5511617661,
-0.2385570258,
-0.2902258933,
-0.3815242946,
0.4952355921,
-0.7921661139,
0.3902177215,
0.4890647829,
1.194067359,
0.1700826734,
-0.1507016718,
-0.3964645267,
-0.7984272242,
0.3727269769,
-0.3128750622,
0.6458292603,
0.4641662538,
-0.0365367644,
-0.0404043049,
-0.6238188744,
-0.2451163977,
-0.2852136195,
-0.0553787462,
-0.253595084,
0.1848481148,
0.5972809792,
0.2968118191,
0.5917406082,
-0.0597036593,
0.1005023122,
-0.2059814185,
-0.1947568357,
0.1845492721,
-0.3557235599,
0.0333500169,
0.1547739208,
-0.2085873485,
0.0791530982,
-0.7359765768,
-0.1915350258,
0.1658203304,
0.2999434769,
0.2891949713,
0.4816066325,
-0.4381237924,
0.4557478726,
0.9928151369,
-0.1780762523,
0.2540178597,
-0.1239584163,
-0.0442224815,
0.490091145,
0.5088654757,
0.2622556388,
0.537571609,
-0.64918679,
-0.326451838,
-0.1265856177,
0.3314606845,
-0.9314337373,
-0.3897603154,
-0.0344855711,
-0.4363916516,
-0.1818315387,
-0.1460108012,
-0.5579254031,
-0.2450959533,
-0.4318473637,
0.5423360467,
-0.6177453399,
-0.125815466,
0.0070823818,
0.1604435444,
-0.1335437447,
0.1725169569,
-1.1697585583,
0.4595302939,
0.8202852607,
0.6095740795,
-0.0350195244,
-0.293941617,
-0.449318409,
0.3874732554,
0.0051574525,
1.0156600475,
-0.8494935036,
-0.3893564641,
0.0746838525,
-0.2465450466,
0.1222925633,
-0.7064976692,
0.463395983,
-0.5926788449,
-0.4293161631,
-0.3665674627,
-0.9168540239,
0.2020652443,
0.3408544362,
-0.672209084,
0.925275743,
0.117003113,
-1.0870240927,
0.533182323,
-0.4634861946,
-0.529242456,
-0.0108697303,
-0.362511158,
-0.2847192883,
0.050036557,
0.233558625,
0.6689155102,
-0.4324221909,
0.3501060903,
-0.7413175106,
-0.200127095,
0.046511054,
0.1676139235,
0.119107835,
0.059290681,
-0.4326008856,
-0.2699051499,
-0.8105753064,
-0.1503173262,
-0.2347145677,
-0.0869386122,
-0.8246789575,
-0.1681001931,
-0.4636211693,
0.1216234192,
0.3741918206,
-0.4392592311,
0.2263470143,
-0.4792108238,
0.2932450473,
0.4544982016,
0.086885944,
0.90544945,
-0.1597884893,
0.168512553,
0.2115941197,
0.0991761312,
0.0739306808,
-0.1589578539,
-0.8416273594,
-0.0185088683,
0.1798779517,
0.1972516775,
-0.7362590432,
0.465193361,
-0.4792260528,
-0.6030330658,
-0.3037317693,
0.147784844,
0.6225482821,
0.6127400994,
0.6554396749,
-0.5176909566,
-0.6151999831,
-0.8546530008,
-0.3581941426,
-0.1491806954,
0.0112610376,
0.3474215567,
0.5513584018,
-0.1509998888,
1.0870589018,
-0.5616733432,
-0.2432962954,
0.174355492,
0.0663020909,
-0.1151063144,
0.8810349703,
0.4559010267,
-0.7056877613,
-0.3333377242,
0.0316827148,
-0.3537288904,
0.1916493475,
0.0320498161,
-0.2702343166,
-0.4554601908,
0.6225609779,
-0.642075181,
0.0072086821,
0.2043391317,
-0.0461308658,
0.6791005731,
0.0239758864,
-0.0401683673,
-1.0505077839,
-0.1825965643,
-0.1226972491,
-0.2021909952,
-0.4331464767,
-0.0158849992,
-0.0101064583,
-0.08516559,
-0.2165927738,
0.290746063,
-0.7246828675,
-0.1636271477,
-0.0727598444,
0.0859882534,
0.0570615865,
0.4852080643,
0.3532834351,
0.7647096515,
0.5816029906,
-0.8385509253,
0.101765655,
0.3478746712,
-0.1691488475,
0.9573261738,
-0.4144590199,
0.2239343375,
-0.2041478753,
0.4200446904,
-0.2945078909,
-0.0415570512,
-0.0501900762,
-0.105504021,
0.5506024361,
-0.2258482128,
-0.2994902134,
-0.3460584581,
-0.0542199798,
0.3551340699,
0.2181965858,
-0.4847104549,
0.6635234356,
0.3602019548,
0.0640265942,
-0.3890746832,
-0.5404202938,
-0.3969201446,
-0.1878242642,
-0.4292402267,
0.6054017544,
0.1810559779,
0.0621860139,
0.2775745094,
-0.4650784433,
-0.5278969407,
0.1627806723,
0.4824098945,
0.0547675453,
-0.440757215,
0.5023843646,
0.206772089,
-0.1997065693,
0.0471747257,
-0.8154144287,
0.4760139585,
-0.1530989856,
-0.328699708,
-0.2097503394,
0.2400940359,
0.0799095631,
-0.4407271743,
0.598959446,
0.6667593122,
-0.6713035703,
0.0822190717,
-0.7684380412,
-0.3532820642,
-0.4761970341,
0.3378808796,
-0.7102486491,
-1.0955866575,
0.186256215,
-0.6118894815,
-0.0238202978,
0.4345803261,
0.1085736901,
-0.1051065847,
0.2966293991,
0.702488184,
-0.0695254207,
0.5249406695,
-0.2137670964,
0.181871146,
-0.9623733163,
-0.1704789698,
-0.6843608618,
-0.1824229807,
-0.5131308436,
-0.4392175972,
-0.0859815553,
0.6746743321,
-0.4886395931,
0.7474555373,
-0.43526721,
0.5418957472,
0.6216036081,
0.2770273387,
0.2713715732,
0.0035390626,
-0.3550485671,
-0.0737678707,
-0.3178134263,
-0.4791261256,
1.0136293173,
0.1700767279,
0.8618414402,
-0.3728073239,
1.3160755634,
-0.0403004549,
0.3184203506,
-0.6009755731,
0.2502639294,
-0.3160912693,
-0.7161116004,
-0.1280878037,
-0.1414279491,
-0.5052075982,
-0.1882892698,
-0.5734304786,
-0.8685205579,
0.4919010699,
0.6061316133,
-0.6603707671,
0.4911663532,
-0.489277631,
0.696171701,
0.08796148,
-0.051510863,
-0.0559818484,
-0.512268126,
-0.0049497806,
-0.1844341457,
-0.00730022,
-0.10002435,
0.1734802127,
0.805627346,
-0.5106416941,
0.6588307023,
-0.0063255569,
0.0291203279,
0.5103576779,
0.1478072852,
0.9123339653,
0.1779748499,
0.0408645608,
0.0489353463,
-0.206872046,
-0.202262193,
-0.4232894182,
0.4970677495,
-0.7659571767,
-0.4057714939,
0.1286676973,
-0.0810273886,
-0.449531734,
0.3032761812,
0.7085876465,
0.6658112407,
-0.3875412345,
0.212059021,
1.1482946873,
0.3163270354,
0.338265866,
0.020959001,
0.1375411898,
-0.3391335607,
0.7890814543,
0.2178179175,
0.3938483298,
0.7368991971,
-0.0751181394,
-0.2520134747,
-0.4266916513,
-0.2455734611,
0.1008621976,
-0.5736342669,
-0.3957378864,
-1.1488877535,
-0.1272060722,
-0.5478596091,
-0.5310397744,
-0.8503450751,
-0.3234030902,
-0.5350147486,
-0.1462644041,
0.4047038555,
0.2249107808,
0.0770964921,
0.5522152781,
-0.9223607779,
0.1421522945,
0.5251951814,
0.5009418726,
0.009627006,
-0.312692076,
-0.3967130482,
-0.0454706587,
-0.2752596736,
-0.8751356006,
-0.1403668225,
0.5567525029,
0.2117312998,
0.8583170176,
0.3086255491,
1.0516374111,
-0.7773566842,
0.4835348129,
0.2004265487,
-0.9089475274,
0.5907335877,
0.0095794471,
-0.085684292,
0.946313858,
0.681989789,
-0.2461058199,
-0.3272953629,
-0.8227072954,
-0.5771820545,
0.3222691119,
0.2964034975,
-0.18936643,
-0.2047921717,
0.5038824677,
0.2392196357,
0.4037954807,
-0.4149382412,
-0.3364516497,
-0.2050137371,
0.0325816795,
0.0142959375,
-0.3998014629,
0.0795578286,
-0.0093720537,
0.6364239454,
-0.0777668878,
0.3915875256,
0.4740089774,
-0.4920205772,
-0.0311622284,
0.3825597465,
0.0808917508,
0.2816049159,
-0.2851166427,
0.4747004509,
0.2766547203,
-0.7537615299,
0.0272716098,
0.3771402538,
-0.3354351223,
0.1939115822,
0.2280799001,
0.9938634038,
0.6395985484,
-0.2424080521,
0.3341476023,
0.3350050747,
0.1176229715,
-0.3066013157,
-0.0829460472,
0.0994780287,
0.3024165034,
0.1182378158,
0.1820043325,
0.3626921475,
-0.3155818284,
0.4334850609,
0.0640440062,
-0.5944985747,
-0.5510392785,
0.6912637949,
0.5873995423,
-0.1756776273,
0.2832100093,
-0.4641900063,
-0.5298463106,
0.3872447014,
0.7038012147,
1.0396975279,
-0.0711886212,
-0.0015981121,
0.4948765635,
0.2775593996,
-0.4297412038,
-0.1619476229,
-0.2181500494,
-0.9454046488,
-0.1640589237,
-0.8448497653,
-0.4627934694,
-0.2590708733,
-0.9006533027,
0.3432401717,
-0.568369627,
-0.3243935406,
0.2399666458,
0.0819319934,
-1.0068649054,
0.2712482214,
0.133318305,
0.7556797862,
-0.6127727032,
0.9143645167,
0.8788410425,
-0.4936874509,
-0.886485815,
-0.138804093,
-0.3178848326,
-0.5164535046,
0.5262886286,
0.3704573512,
0.0826856568,
0.3125108778,
-0.2964449823,
-1.0482583046,
0.986117959,
0.1260870546,
-0.9777751565,
-0.5513162017,
0.0362662114,
0.2012121826,
-0.6059197783,
0.38040483,
0.7184434533,
0.2246723324,
-0.3132771552,
-1.1450401545,
0.1331690103,
0.2607788146,
-0.0024065084,
0.4651561975,
-0.4723314345,
0.8637915254,
-0.1283483356,
-0.1307955533,
-0.2292293161,
0.9314841032,
-0.0922371373,
0.021584807,
0.761362195,
0.6367400885,
0.8763968349,
0.0105561716,
0.6496626735,
-0.5107690692,
0.5840170979,
1.7137693167,
-0.2560046017,
0.6802518964,
0.3824531734,
-0.0416567624,
0.313901782,
0.6797738075,
-0.0341722183,
0.536288321,
-0.0495661385,
-0.2553341389,
-0.571598351,
-0.3198212683,
-0.5960533023,
0.0636541322,
0.4494137466,
-0.4535220861,
-0.3597534895,
0.1349756718,
0.1705710739,
0.0819973424,
-0.4988012016,
0.7424813509,
0.225108996,
-0.3379369378,
0.2992632985,
-0.3680637181,
0.972130239,
-0.3545950353,
0.2652052641,
0.003272397,
0.0133509301,
-0.2044922858,
-0.4220713079,
0.195010215,
0.0168859717,
-0.1905880868,
0.0214038566,
0.8956751227,
-0.5335508585,
-0.0334294215,
0.2641265988,
0.2482225001,
0.1909455955,
-0.5137608051,
-0.4722302854,
-0.4117126465,
-0.2400214374,
-0.1435529441,
0.2552889287,
0.8130314946,
-0.0886220932,
0.4708122611,
0.5294040442,
-0.0198500715,
0.2480212599,
-0.2119670212,
1.0986675024,
-0.7024402618,
-0.5199903846,
-0.5914327502,
-0.0439142585,
-0.0450494029,
-0.5386314988,
0.2501254976,
0.5186979771,
1.0772463083,
-0.2301271707,
0.3060604334,
-0.1556155086,
0.3547334075,
-0.4758353829,
0.443026185,
-0.0660096705,
-0.1408466548,
-0.5222020149,
-1.2625684738,
0.0520428419,
0.43615821,
-0.1254972368,
-0.1829057634,
0.9200777411,
0.621425271,
-0.1163044423,
0.1429925561,
0.1874141544,
0.2242077142,
0.0206769947,
0.5755494833,
0.5437127948,
-0.2231829166,
0.6282359958,
-0.7259945273,
0.0157065671,
-0.3412974775,
-0.6960727572,
-1.0379773378,
-0.5167379379,
-0.4691414833,
-0.3888293207,
0.2385409176,
1.2724614143,
0.6203525662,
-0.6829007864,
0.3188453913,
-0.0095287897,
-0.1741351634,
-0.1018821746,
-0.0570142865,
0.304687053,
-0.3220323324,
-0.6741175652,
-0.162527591,
0.1953178942,
0.2275434583,
-0.0435152799,
0.0255919918,
-0.1331971437,
-0.2162030935,
0.5392705202,
0.1686816365,
-0.5822481513,
-0.6657106876,
-0.1731500179,
-0.2554806173,
0.1626378745,
0.9425166845,
-0.5829592347,
0.2009709775,
0.2896758616,
0.9014760852,
0.4510043859,
-0.0562597662,
0.2986271083,
-0.5785374641,
0.223825261,
0.2425226718,
0.3370604515,
0.1406122893,
-0.6298086047,
0.4896218777,
0.1550952643,
-0.4301899374,
-0.4187130928,
0.2743666768,
-0.9825883508,
0.1741390377,
1.0045909882,
-0.5164341331,
-0.240089491,
-0.2252544016,
-0.1584849805,
0.4290732443,
-0.5429669619,
0.5312149525,
0.5517439246,
0.1735527664,
0.242202878,
-0.0420690402,
0.7868375778,
0.1994878501,
-0.6641866565,
-0.2267157733,
0.2359930724,
0.3801415265,
0.5506209731,
0.7512373328,
-0.0213323329,
0.1409710199,
0.1182326227,
0.367174983,
-0.010939152,
-0.2791062593,
0.0727435648,
0.0294313207,
0.1781005561,
-0.1995487958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12920v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12920v3 | A Diachronic Analysis of Paradigm Shifts in NLP Research: When, How, and Why? | 2023-05-22T11:08:00 | 2023-10-25T11:56:49 | Aniket Pramanick, Yufang Hou, Saif M. Mohammad, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding the fundamental concepts and trends in a scientific field is
crucial for keeping abreast of its continuous advancement. In this study, we
propose a systematic framework for analyzing the evolution of research topics
in a scientific field using causal discovery and inference techniques. We
define three variables to encompass diverse facets of the evolution of research
topics within NLP and utilize a causal discovery algorithm to unveil the causal
connections among these variables using observational data. Subsequently, we
leverage this structure to measure the intensity of these relationships. By
conducting extensive experiments on the ACL Anthology corpus, we demonstrate
that our framework effectively uncovers evolutionary trends and the underlying
causes for a wide range of NLP research topics. Specifically, we show that
tasks and methods are primary drivers of research in NLP, with datasets
following, while metrics have minimal impact. | [
-0.3939167559,
-1.0194275379,
0.4276764691,
0.4175344706,
0.0641299114,
-0.1306611449,
-0.0556721129,
-0.5082098842,
0.2812720239,
0.2453288585,
-0.6546829939,
-0.3289373815,
-0.6559004784,
0.4589560926,
-0.700001359,
1.0610163212,
0.2386970967,
-0.271979481,
-0.0963921174,
-0.1026812419,
-0.5241338015,
-0.2172117382,
-0.899266243,
-0.3808706403,
0.7500629425,
-0.0579292476,
0.5399637818,
0.9675966501,
0.8130119443,
0.1428486407,
-0.4336950481,
0.0838948712,
-0.2100373507,
0.4019895196,
-0.3060967326,
-0.64969033,
-0.0158833191,
-0.2782972753,
0.6236767769,
1.1247583628,
-0.1921962351,
0.150975734,
-0.0282683205,
0.5438610911,
-0.4092457592,
0.2870371044,
-0.6965003014,
0.3314298689,
-0.6312993765,
-0.8852126598,
-0.3415194154,
0.019048905,
0.3730302453,
-0.6976597309,
0.8211559057,
0.1362861097,
0.5753983855,
0.2089812458,
-0.3962838948,
-0.4478420913,
-1.0388886929,
0.8144707084,
-0.7083479762,
0.4406084716,
0.2586071491,
-0.0496082343,
-0.2211123556,
-0.9123924971,
-0.5020996928,
-0.0500113368,
-0.2075645626,
-0.0302614942,
-0.2495928109,
-0.300786376,
0.2276944667,
0.1301503479,
-0.5373392701,
0.1058368161,
-0.1853432208,
0.2906473875,
0.5225862265,
0.2130835354,
0.5178914666,
-0.2079198509,
-0.1521738321,
0.0956660286,
-0.6697202325,
-0.0360774584,
0.0388111807,
0.3247251809,
-0.0547503009,
0.4010007381,
0.0546704344,
0.5723928213,
0.1421096176,
0.2155596316,
0.0929371119,
-0.6722041965,
-0.0423866473,
0.1407145411,
0.6578679085,
0.3006485999,
-0.5184113979,
-0.324526608,
0.344938755,
0.0242248997,
0.3268595338,
-0.264374584,
-0.3119570613,
0.1216505095,
-0.4351186752,
-0.4824768305,
-0.1008532047,
-0.910412848,
-0.4743559957,
-0.5265468359,
-0.1413666457,
-0.1947805136,
-0.4444876611,
0.1992570907,
-0.3656710386,
0.2832367718,
0.0904913992,
-0.9899807572,
0.2721596658,
0.7949252129,
0.9668109417,
-0.2712521255,
-0.2448529005,
0.2440406084,
0.0094522759,
-0.6300505996,
0.7768345475,
-0.3154816628,
-0.2503567934,
0.1688211411,
-0.0115818605,
-0.2096670717,
-0.2381727397,
0.478764385,
-0.788387835,
0.2881025672,
-0.4182246029,
-0.2203127891,
-0.1225754693,
-0.0038072027,
-0.5531367064,
0.9633356929,
-0.3381607234,
-1.2198562622,
0.705758214,
-0.8417898417,
-0.3104667366,
0.1534835398,
-0.2899109721,
-0.284984082,
0.0415365621,
-0.054095313,
0.0924219787,
-0.5416525602,
0.8490749002,
-0.082189098,
0.0030889823,
0.2525383234,
-0.2362499535,
1.079121232,
0.2065165639,
-0.6013195515,
-0.3329902887,
-0.8337557316,
-0.6249793172,
0.1307264715,
-0.044698514,
-0.7800838351,
0.7288711071,
-0.0320213959,
0.1363247484,
-0.0822409093,
-0.2516686916,
0.215041101,
-0.3724287748,
0.5406909585,
0.3482232988,
0.5546985865,
0.4890780151,
-0.2398367226,
0.2663761675,
-0.1156999245,
0.2768146992,
-0.0700065717,
-0.4693999887,
-0.7053783536,
0.2213200629,
0.0462866165,
0.2369666994,
-0.3622517884,
0.513286829,
-0.0566975474,
-0.1942207366,
-0.3464776576,
-0.1012146026,
-0.0171293672,
0.7884112597,
0.7579986453,
-0.2947341502,
-0.5923408866,
-0.666441381,
-0.2898045182,
-0.4230996966,
0.0140288165,
0.2802939415,
0.2833653688,
-0.2464793324,
1.2264937162,
-0.5233303308,
0.1823142618,
0.0251564812,
0.6299650669,
0.2809370458,
0.5817031264,
0.6303159595,
-0.920191586,
0.0216403306,
-0.0904079154,
-0.970105052,
-0.615175724,
-0.5138233304,
-0.2814261317,
-0.250164479,
0.9731910825,
-0.557023406,
0.2468356788,
0.1141219586,
-0.5972266197,
0.7893286943,
0.317029357,
-0.0100664021,
-0.7249842286,
0.3783473372,
0.1735583395,
0.4667367041,
-0.9071972966,
-0.0111121358,
-0.2374389023,
0.1512085199,
0.201486811,
0.2342627496,
-0.2977481186,
0.2233350724,
-0.2070147991,
0.0485859066,
0.0809985921,
-0.1040059105,
0.2002813667,
0.0435633883,
0.4746049047,
-0.746948421,
-0.1195651367,
0.6164761782,
0.0994837433,
0.1936846823,
-0.5922531486,
-0.0650547519,
-0.3441288471,
0.213236019,
-0.7493725419,
0.3612593114,
0.1891912073,
-0.2449681163,
0.0947200879,
-0.1279151291,
-0.4135576785,
-0.1822968721,
-0.0404322259,
0.2654116154,
-0.0017851166,
-0.2389844656,
0.2594104111,
-0.0230566002,
-0.5730273128,
-0.5901352763,
-0.3365660012,
0.2566720545,
-0.6313356161,
-0.545006156,
0.4612506628,
0.0242999811,
-0.9431549311,
-0.118449904,
-0.3869371712,
0.0743812546,
0.3185244203,
-0.0681509227,
0.1321884543,
-0.4739973545,
0.357190758,
0.1261510402,
-0.0291985348,
0.5708053112,
-0.2869616449,
0.6032120585,
0.3625334501,
0.2779769003,
-0.153545782,
0.2041032761,
0.2422151417,
-0.0809325501,
0.5882329941,
0.3852750063,
-0.0019951952,
-0.323479861,
-0.3892375827,
-0.2120932192,
-0.3611422777,
0.2232155502,
0.0487642922,
-0.4894073904,
0.4157770872,
-0.2625871897,
0.4491880834,
0.6759751439,
0.2942774296,
-0.051804956,
0.6910048723,
0.8038702607,
0.1395293772,
0.5921139717,
-0.242748037,
0.301173389,
-0.9538667798,
-0.3485807776,
-0.8201531768,
0.0736838356,
-0.6968858242,
-0.352872014,
0.3071417809,
0.5422919393,
-0.1921468228,
0.3821552396,
-0.4741731286,
-0.0213969108,
0.2627464831,
-0.121189557,
0.5765970349,
-0.364200145,
0.2208053768,
0.0418996476,
-0.6853156686,
-0.2921173871,
1.099050045,
0.2469279766,
0.5268539786,
0.1118579507,
0.5431800485,
0.4492336512,
0.0119908191,
-0.4391309023,
0.2064257264,
0.2439279258,
-0.6118196845,
-0.4654430747,
-0.1043352187,
-1.2779425383,
0.3339554071,
-0.4810694754,
-0.5734347701,
0.707100451,
0.0543907173,
-0.0041832537,
-0.1689060032,
-0.1237168163,
0.6489210129,
-0.1317058951,
-0.4120953977,
-0.1986436248,
-1.0852298737,
0.4620310962,
-0.2879126668,
0.332069397,
-0.1613611281,
0.0928720832,
0.9862388968,
0.1127839237,
0.8301175833,
-0.022253925,
-0.0267565567,
0.1596781164,
0.3540457785,
0.1874750406,
0.5438994765,
0.0303428657,
0.2689087093,
0.1064444035,
-0.1140852645,
-0.6461231709,
0.458104074,
-0.5035766363,
-0.669804275,
-0.4599625468,
-0.6210030913,
-0.1941214353,
0.0480098724,
0.0802140385,
0.3410360813,
-0.3403358757,
-0.0216793939,
0.5699028373,
-0.2068460286,
0.5971330404,
0.7425858378,
-0.1094113961,
0.4514649212,
0.2295372784,
-0.1307932436,
0.0856574699,
0.4660644531,
0.6549970508,
-0.0573637411,
-0.84239012,
-0.0087723797,
0.2567973733,
-0.5004047751,
-0.0466895737,
-0.8222488761,
0.1915083677,
-0.5264384747,
-0.397251904,
-0.0345981047,
-0.2843893766,
-0.4750930369,
-0.00574303,
0.3214102983,
0.5575994849,
-0.3444637954,
0.2073279023,
-0.2644468546,
0.324691385,
0.0958650783,
-0.3121706545,
0.1098245159,
-0.3913936913,
-0.0519242324,
-0.2369470298,
-0.3562585413,
-0.9063316584,
0.6578652263,
0.3486466408,
0.3432091475,
0.6311732531,
-0.1820990145,
0.5334457755,
-0.7402324677,
0.9635218978,
0.2260461599,
-0.7145786881,
0.8196111321,
-0.6478017569,
0.088810727,
0.3966422677,
0.6671464443,
-0.8228935003,
-0.3061816692,
-0.9053484797,
-1.2447807789,
0.4262885451,
0.1106002554,
-0.1707901508,
-0.2217914909,
0.4661470652,
0.2834814191,
0.2245701849,
-0.5040317774,
-0.4632394314,
-0.0721332803,
0.2133583277,
-0.212468788,
0.1192448586,
-0.5006365776,
-0.2878100872,
0.2831231654,
-0.1332096905,
0.2536453605,
0.5170813799,
-0.0869146585,
0.0309647173,
0.2032666057,
0.3409657478,
1.065952301,
-0.1992284209,
0.3656846285,
-0.2558549047,
-0.388202697,
-0.2511710525,
0.3979098797,
-0.4744726717,
0.2459220141,
0.8347017765,
0.5009950399,
0.2953009009,
-0.258906126,
0.1474403739,
0.2465697229,
0.019970322,
-0.2492290884,
-0.2275880277,
-0.1168434173,
0.3311612904,
0.6331065893,
0.1063650548,
0.6008162498,
-0.6801053286,
0.4392245114,
0.3220096529,
-0.2059213966,
-0.6487115026,
0.5757775307,
-0.0557147227,
-0.1639833003,
0.38642627,
0.2293588966,
-0.0806080401,
0.752587378,
0.8324897885,
0.680473268,
-0.1235625148,
0.5927227139,
0.244406715,
0.2319068462,
-0.0870028213,
-0.2268146724,
-0.1908094734,
-0.7886059284,
-0.3136707246,
-0.8360961676,
-0.07169687,
0.0912160948,
-0.7544923425,
0.2343463004,
-0.059542954,
-0.0848804489,
0.8344984651,
-0.2020494491,
-0.53274405,
-0.0051367297,
-0.1634370536,
0.692260921,
-1.0924218893,
0.3196460605,
0.3564503789,
-0.287437588,
-0.1354492158,
0.0341077112,
0.4560844898,
-0.7305304408,
1.113633275,
-0.5404369235,
-0.0059031579,
0.1079597846,
-0.7987855673,
-1.0565773249,
1.0405083895,
-0.2902353108,
-0.5928835869,
-0.3390175104,
-0.1351519227,
0.9002183676,
-0.2744262516,
-0.0373656861,
0.7699317932,
0.3187802732,
-0.2277020812,
-0.6106829643,
-0.0774720386,
-0.1250303686,
0.0646473914,
0.4799534678,
-0.1372835189,
0.7539666295,
0.0497468412,
-0.3729856014,
-0.2677527368,
0.3816810846,
0.1716449261,
0.5982926488,
0.1616095454,
0.2771521509,
0.4275652468,
0.0251953285,
0.8400627971,
-0.1983412057,
0.4532421231,
0.7241519094,
-0.2086559981,
0.4715980291,
0.8594115376,
-0.3212378025,
0.5336053371,
0.5230103135,
-0.2527879775,
0.5733207464,
0.3914600313,
-0.2055699974,
0.1088193133,
-0.1791706234,
-0.3834053874,
0.4510656297,
0.5496468544,
-0.6119448543,
-0.3965303004,
-0.1302104443,
0.27602005,
-0.1006110609,
-0.1541217864,
0.7781231999,
0.1012985632,
-0.4958257973,
0.2961064279,
-0.1046513543,
0.5323563218,
-0.6868358254,
-0.1974392086,
-0.258805871,
-0.1795736551,
-0.1623426825,
-0.3006728888,
0.4862765968,
-0.3263574839,
-0.2180724889,
-0.1767788231,
0.5107808113,
-0.2320756912,
-0.2265273035,
0.2777402699,
0.6493285298,
-0.1001847759,
0.5247842669,
-0.6639817357,
0.0469935834,
-0.2672993541,
-0.1602852643,
0.3002297878,
0.3901218176,
-0.2343654186,
0.2907932997,
0.6686385274,
0.3842489719,
0.1531681865,
0.0302221105,
0.6409424543,
-0.7211414576,
-0.2706622481,
-0.8866949677,
0.2268460095,
-0.1160965562,
-0.8883462548,
0.9019524455,
0.3738091886,
0.3557038307,
0.083908312,
0.6522003412,
-0.5183272958,
0.2924820781,
-0.6057681441,
0.5829417706,
-0.3071397245,
0.2777308226,
-0.4889390469,
-0.7587388754,
-0.6398604512,
0.4189870059,
-0.0596033074,
-0.4788716137,
1.1355676651,
0.2654211223,
0.202481851,
0.3705698252,
-0.3283436596,
0.317196101,
0.3770217597,
-0.2265404165,
0.6575599909,
-0.2623745799,
-0.0527983978,
-0.2090206444,
-0.3790859878,
0.0533364676,
-0.8435239792,
-0.4644421339,
-0.8707805276,
-0.5955714583,
-0.1674630642,
0.3557251096,
0.4770728648,
0.2762900293,
-0.6911015511,
-0.3579806089,
-0.7086711526,
-0.0142321959,
-0.7344170213,
-0.3829325438,
0.7380833626,
-0.8106256723,
-0.2638477385,
0.5339481831,
0.1733347178,
-0.3434328437,
-0.1045071632,
0.6387248635,
-0.672183156,
0.1288152784,
0.7639407516,
0.6912212372,
-0.5018369555,
-0.1204329655,
0.268627584,
0.4319024086,
0.0129399551,
1.3895193338,
-0.3839610517,
0.4601626992,
0.467033118,
0.490542978,
0.5535233021,
0.0060067363,
0.746735394,
-0.7025914192,
-0.0311301388,
0.5428572893,
0.1265117824,
0.0849984661,
-0.2987562716,
0.6723855138,
0.6297276616,
-0.8612128496,
-0.9696729779,
0.2237678617,
-0.9165463448,
-0.5536252856,
1.0188996792,
0.2559880614,
0.2013521194,
-0.7020891309,
0.2861871421,
0.1603530794,
-0.0259370301,
1.4048537016,
0.559959054,
-0.8985750675,
-0.1695609242,
-0.7728637457,
0.8752804399,
0.3106248975,
-0.7236338258,
0.1936858445,
0.389410615,
-0.0103861112,
0.7838141322,
0.4604021907,
-0.3117641807,
-0.0415805578,
0.0567310601,
0.0048422851,
0.6593055129,
-0.4810903966,
-0.1570441127,
-0.0073374053,
0.0635498986,
0.2059694529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12918v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12918v1 | Improving Metrics for Speech Translation | 2023-05-22T11:01:38 | 2023-05-22T11:01:38 | Claudio Paonessa, Dominik Frefel, Manfred Vogel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce Parallel Paraphrasing ($\text{Para}_\text{both}$), an
augmentation method for translation metrics making use of automatic
paraphrasing of both the reference and hypothesis. This method counteracts the
typically misleading results of speech translation metrics such as WER, CER,
and BLEU if only a single reference is available. We introduce two new datasets
explicitly created to measure the quality of metrics intended to be applied to
Swiss German speech-to-text systems. Based on these datasets, we show that we
are able to significantly improve the correlation with human quality perception
if our method is applied to commonly used metrics. | [
-0.2562039196,
-0.4359300435,
0.399314791,
0.3389454484,
-0.4612388909,
0.1629288197,
-0.2018726766,
-0.3482012153,
0.1921377182,
0.5264719129,
-0.1928553283,
-0.4932484925,
-0.5892703533,
0.0679162219,
-0.564827323,
0.9672769904,
0.0902736634,
0.574390769,
-0.5501634479,
-0.5701221228,
-0.2087020278,
-0.4792731702,
-0.4625536203,
-0.3870429695,
0.6006413698,
0.631259799,
1.0625534058,
0.629103899,
0.8766427636,
0.2741764188,
-0.0389106497,
0.3609829247,
-0.2997214198,
0.0310287792,
-0.3902920485,
-0.5030568242,
-0.3083496094,
-0.0297137741,
0.998508215,
0.964594841,
-0.1670949608,
0.3037042916,
0.2993174493,
0.578032434,
-0.3091826439,
0.2189745009,
-0.2258351594,
-0.0918286145,
-0.4083630443,
-0.2947933078,
0.1046032012,
-0.3507754505,
0.1111090034,
-0.4127399623,
0.3994191885,
0.222763136,
0.9293149114,
0.3882340193,
0.0209261458,
-0.0689886659,
-0.6660565138,
0.9652317166,
-0.8925907016,
0.4894132316,
0.3632877171,
0.2948170304,
0.1722161323,
-0.9777341485,
-0.4534690082,
-0.2616563141,
-0.2345937043,
0.0076812017,
-0.2437743098,
-0.2148629427,
0.1885136068,
0.4609811306,
-0.4418629706,
-0.0083392449,
-0.5691081285,
-0.4787624478,
0.58803159,
0.0938952491,
0.428586185,
0.0551432334,
-0.1434688121,
-0.4712550342,
-0.361145854,
0.0044744797,
0.5527425408,
0.1458238661,
0.1182069182,
0.3986836374,
-0.4569295347,
0.7719528079,
-0.086542435,
-0.305221647,
0.7990977764,
-0.8203302026,
0.0840012953,
-0.0571970642,
0.8028700352,
0.6207875609,
0.2144637257,
-0.505885303,
-0.0137918117,
0.1238909215,
0.0014752839,
-0.4137608707,
-0.2041151971,
-0.1128062829,
-0.3961946666,
0.0660958886,
0.4295722246,
-0.7919262648,
-0.0874970481,
-0.48175776,
0.2313608676,
-0.3354784548,
-0.0766979009,
0.1325205564,
-0.4997319281,
0.0436181761,
-0.0963555649,
-0.5313764811,
0.4748543203,
0.6366111636,
0.891297996,
-0.3643721044,
-0.7702750564,
-0.6768805385,
0.2810532451,
-0.5386222005,
1.0963625908,
-0.4110945463,
-0.4458323419,
-0.12817882,
-0.2893944979,
0.058670219,
-1.004827261,
1.2547914982,
-0.006949354,
0.3041448593,
-0.4604517221,
-0.4491500258,
-0.2322558165,
-0.3454342782,
-0.4179666042,
1.0270358324,
-0.034942694,
-0.6715147495,
0.2088670433,
-0.4823245406,
-0.6450383067,
-0.0911208019,
-0.086300157,
-0.4486817122,
0.4430007339,
0.6455845237,
0.3400929272,
-0.5829168558,
0.2079991102,
-0.160356015,
-0.3557828963,
0.3117579818,
-0.14307262,
0.4232451916,
0.336659193,
0.10966295,
0.0876487345,
-0.6939449906,
0.1885830462,
-0.2584272325,
0.0013802784,
-0.2652496696,
0.1837114841,
0.0531502254,
0.2331101149,
0.3413805962,
-0.642758131,
-0.8128758073,
-0.5348681211,
0.5980824828,
0.1285610348,
0.0742626563,
0.4183733463,
-0.6355242729,
0.1174967661,
0.1412049532,
0.046271842,
-0.0593543351,
-0.4425292313,
-0.8217899203,
-0.078116782,
0.2129930258,
0.7412032485,
-0.5813014507,
0.5974552631,
-0.6565015912,
-0.5178940892,
-0.7896681428,
0.3004594743,
0.497808218,
0.7996980548,
0.6722170711,
-0.4183513522,
-0.3373214602,
-1.0789678097,
-0.6164064407,
-0.3589856625,
-0.349458456,
0.0186772775,
0.0906371847,
0.2656118274,
0.7090176344,
-0.4255993366,
-0.3274873495,
0.0160347316,
0.4419907331,
0.0818789303,
0.5848070383,
0.496276468,
-0.7865279317,
-0.5513948202,
-0.2087081522,
-0.7256043553,
-0.3370603323,
0.0743812099,
-0.0215676241,
-0.26351735,
0.5773204565,
-0.1376553178,
0.0720525384,
0.4269675016,
-0.1375850141,
0.5539368391,
-0.2613177299,
0.4844169915,
-1.1295977831,
-0.1305949092,
0.1661190242,
-0.2439034134,
-0.6727210879,
0.0245186761,
0.0903452933,
-0.0899525806,
-0.525123775,
0.3393367231,
-0.2468488067,
-0.3164365292,
-0.4415509701,
0.1875410825,
0.081772849,
0.1210053861,
-0.153544575,
1.3029414415,
0.7883226871,
-0.3782868683,
0.7228306532,
0.5294493437,
-0.7894487381,
1.2333334684,
-0.7114059925,
0.1642808318,
-0.192789793,
0.2477381527,
-1.0943633318,
-0.2290874273,
0.1138514578,
-0.8618326783,
0.0751913115,
0.454387486,
-0.8369222283,
-0.4382224381,
-0.0308270324,
0.1081138775,
0.6992224455,
-0.4995372593,
0.0083016166,
0.3562433422,
-0.6315803528,
-0.1889591366,
-0.9136570692,
0.5778369904,
-0.5866709948,
-0.6836202741,
0.5483387709,
0.0562283322,
-0.2904317677,
-0.0532283895,
-0.2410666049,
-0.4137999713,
-0.4644376338,
-0.2510425448,
0.0696077868,
-0.2860059738,
0.2081538886,
0.1540428102,
-0.293335259,
0.0876422077,
-0.4247008562,
0.0499310382,
-0.0393270217,
-0.3357331157,
-1.1037278175,
0.5704520345,
0.5666842461,
-0.2298915088,
0.3968575895,
0.8269315958,
-0.0688211396,
0.3084557354,
-0.869189918,
-0.2355383039,
-0.4275431931,
0.5232242346,
-0.4741978943,
-0.5190278292,
0.4600139558,
-0.1444687396,
-0.2352297157,
0.4382428527,
0.1477255821,
-0.2997657061,
1.1405853033,
0.2961316109,
-0.2660434246,
0.3662770987,
0.1472784132,
0.0757499784,
-0.8424912095,
-0.0553738102,
-0.9228383899,
-0.4091858566,
-0.3673837483,
-0.7656249404,
0.2648219168,
0.4034371078,
0.0763197243,
0.4553128481,
-0.3644009233,
0.3920133412,
0.7841883898,
0.2624191642,
0.4092507958,
0.3925718069,
0.0309245847,
-0.3864755332,
-0.6142958403,
-0.5658970475,
0.8991017342,
0.2006351352,
0.4552161396,
-0.151712954,
0.6149613857,
0.0734619796,
0.0160004105,
-0.4587860107,
0.5360457301,
-0.3786287904,
-0.3870407045,
-0.4417544603,
-0.6360923648,
-0.410839498,
0.1692156643,
0.0849110186,
-0.7010518312,
0.2945150733,
0.1495139748,
-0.255874604,
0.090374656,
-0.5476389527,
0.5077372193,
-0.1215029061,
-0.1157013103,
-0.6227586269,
-0.7339016199,
-0.1956794858,
-0.1713928133,
0.1615161747,
-0.3773227632,
-0.2937274873,
1.097517848,
-0.408680588,
0.3946278393,
-0.0409158394,
0.1116226688,
0.3860885203,
-0.4794875085,
0.6235870123,
-0.0758014098,
-0.3866994381,
0.4475824833,
0.1103217676,
-0.7623670697,
-0.760884881,
0.726853013,
-0.638964057,
-0.4868378341,
-0.2077664137,
-0.8408327699,
-0.5849644542,
-0.1404522657,
0.3298858106,
0.3365804851,
-0.1261597425,
0.3951155841,
0.3512348235,
-0.1745073944,
0.2242825627,
0.5782420039,
0.3814993501,
-0.7263749242,
1.1282699108,
0.0887717605,
0.3480229676,
0.3367218077,
0.2546791732,
-0.7025296092,
-0.7591388226,
-0.3482325971,
0.4757294357,
-0.6010844111,
-0.0095787123,
-0.3814529777,
0.0191282798,
-0.6079921126,
0.140025273,
-0.1829837412,
-0.6052076817,
-0.1333086789,
-0.313565731,
0.1802388728,
0.0901409984,
-0.3658377528,
0.5520998836,
-0.8916932344,
0.407640636,
0.2016144097,
0.0782738328,
-0.3501224518,
-0.9345365763,
-0.2612324059,
0.2366117835,
-0.169766292,
-0.6737798452,
0.3819728196,
0.4061733186,
0.6511785984,
0.2745901048,
-0.0572576337,
1.0432664156,
-0.6902791262,
0.8903478384,
0.4416585267,
-0.9388178587,
0.4144634902,
-0.2019938231,
0.2209275663,
0.6982910633,
0.1348615587,
-0.5211387277,
-0.6531437635,
-0.612980783,
-0.6188898683,
0.484708339,
0.3524151742,
0.40653947,
0.1809498221,
0.256118983,
0.1185413152,
0.273568958,
-0.0961770192,
-0.5050389171,
-0.1557365358,
-0.0502488688,
-0.83354038,
-0.2222787738,
-0.2557071447,
-0.623321116,
0.5451179743,
0.2069309801,
0.1610571593,
0.1143873483,
0.0366901159,
-0.0737917274,
0.3714189827,
0.4648147225,
1.1095389128,
0.0376212969,
0.0531883165,
0.323368609,
-0.1316995323,
0.198024258,
0.3504299521,
-0.0966063961,
0.5210063457,
0.1536710411,
1.0332745314,
0.1198869497,
-0.4858220816,
0.2114291787,
0.5710574985,
-0.2127616554,
0.0942602828,
-0.1022239923,
0.0280129854,
0.1547438949,
0.2749091387,
0.0727594048,
0.2830706835,
-0.3424274921,
0.5684933066,
-0.0311410166,
-0.7190914154,
-0.3145545125,
0.6254988313,
0.3071972728,
-0.566170454,
0.3292226493,
0.1891608536,
-0.0748344958,
0.3039130569,
0.621295929,
0.8206695914,
-0.4371545911,
0.3666353822,
0.473914355,
0.0305602383,
-0.4860481322,
0.1229201928,
-0.1032877192,
-0.5279796124,
-0.5436973572,
-0.6402434111,
-0.4783985913,
-0.0233418271,
-0.9811743498,
0.2291959375,
0.3799768984,
-0.172482416,
0.2973908484,
-0.4103646278,
-0.4290133715,
0.0936992094,
-0.0181573629,
0.5653079748,
-0.9142330289,
0.9391474724,
0.9756852984,
-0.4844579697,
-0.4692580402,
0.3584843576,
-0.2855840325,
-0.7581937909,
0.4606144726,
-0.2236998379,
-0.2641963661,
0.4103242457,
-0.1120684519,
-0.9456858635,
0.7800895572,
0.4078584015,
-0.4904562831,
-0.1460936368,
0.4391348958,
0.6423954964,
-0.0432141386,
-0.1673803329,
0.8286704421,
0.5562077761,
-0.1313024461,
-1.2522565126,
-0.2973390222,
0.1593289077,
0.1411706209,
0.2370956987,
-0.477398932,
0.4822971225,
-0.0904140919,
-0.1026695743,
0.340924263,
0.9273033142,
-0.2131055444,
0.3567540348,
0.521268487,
0.7187282443,
0.6496873498,
-0.0961768925,
0.8737254143,
-0.3365226984,
0.2814329565,
1.3013237715,
-0.1046945155,
0.9031769037,
0.6894831061,
-0.5674693584,
0.3612974584,
0.2459753156,
0.0580561385,
0.6180103421,
0.0260001626,
-0.3293689787,
-0.207527563,
-0.287414521,
-0.4536715746,
0.230150342,
0.5405684114,
-0.2917926311,
-0.5302323699,
0.303902477,
-0.1236599535,
0.6879353523,
-0.1058083177,
0.8087310791,
0.2808527648,
-0.8003605604,
0.709788084,
-0.0071170875,
0.4621140659,
-0.3945280015,
0.2155811042,
-0.271915108,
0.1130927578,
-0.0790953934,
-0.6761137247,
0.6659761667,
-0.0843564421,
-0.1218294874,
-0.3176196814,
0.2883978188,
-0.4916764796,
-0.6791706085,
0.2363988608,
0.7320119739,
0.5157197714,
-0.1231569126,
-0.8704499602,
-0.4009149075,
-0.0547908396,
0.2948201597,
0.1531792134,
0.2710051835,
0.05154505,
0.4823693037,
0.5943354368,
0.4666066766,
0.0554725155,
0.2017274499,
0.6034799814,
-0.5238603354,
-0.7574064732,
-0.6977672577,
0.1059910282,
-0.4153342247,
-0.1415787488,
1.0048360825,
0.6154500246,
0.8537519574,
0.1456905305,
0.7485166192,
0.2183240801,
1.2642873526,
-0.2706153393,
0.4898790419,
-0.2562943399,
0.0114551596,
-0.3212949634,
-1.0936529636,
-0.265860647,
0.4925645292,
-0.3306847811,
-0.5546463132,
1.0539157391,
0.968726337,
-0.2148372382,
-0.0609847158,
0.4966798723,
-0.0612856969,
-0.0896810517,
0.2474116385,
0.791466713,
-0.5361972451,
0.9220466614,
-0.3814660311,
-0.1792651266,
0.2015876323,
-0.4670325816,
-0.474024117,
-0.6671123505,
-0.5490962267,
-0.2933809459,
0.6014338732,
0.3133182824,
0.584766984,
-0.9715259075,
-0.5909816027,
-0.1794926822,
-0.1676072329,
-0.6882321239,
-0.1588384509,
0.4049193859,
-0.8166230917,
-1.0020067692,
0.5844102502,
0.0998037085,
-0.027135618,
-0.10358271,
-0.1409651339,
0.0449061058,
0.0992899239,
0.2357426584,
0.310611248,
-0.9304442406,
-0.3296159208,
-0.3210772276,
-0.0086394139,
0.4314819574,
0.7568654418,
-0.5489121079,
0.4546800852,
0.6955339313,
0.5431188941,
0.2484523505,
0.4529630244,
0.8417032361,
-0.7538460493,
0.4296729267,
0.1660605073,
0.1751716435,
0.644377172,
0.1516239792,
0.3698200285,
0.3335902393,
-0.5722380877,
-0.8036807179,
0.1119471043,
-0.6445488334,
-0.0138369109,
1.0108293295,
-0.3918574452,
0.1930561215,
-0.1442379653,
-0.2138685137,
0.3264982998,
-0.4489458799,
0.6069639325,
0.9592660069,
-0.2337421328,
0.1215371639,
-0.7081874013,
0.4388111532,
0.8257789612,
-0.7509198785,
-0.200697735,
0.5457699895,
0.3467442095,
0.3432015777,
0.3008986712,
-0.3201456666,
0.3290202618,
0.083029002,
-0.2727844119,
0.0137690809,
-0.1467015445,
-0.1903440952,
-0.067757003,
-0.042648688,
-0.7263657451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12908v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12908v1 | Language Models for German Text Simplification: Overcoming Parallel Data Scarcity through Style-specific Pre-training | 2023-05-22T10:41:30 | 2023-05-22T10:41:30 | Miriam Anschütz, Joshua Oehms, Thomas Wimmer, Bartłomiej Jezierski, Georg Groh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic text simplification systems help to reduce textual information
barriers on the internet. However, for languages other than English, only few
parallel data to train these systems exists. We propose a two-step approach to
overcome this data scarcity issue. First, we fine-tuned language models on a
corpus of German Easy Language, a specific style of German. Then, we used these
models as decoders in a sequence-to-sequence simplification task. We show that
the language models adapt to the style characteristics of Easy Language and
output more accessible texts. Moreover, with the style-specific pre-training,
we reduced the number of trainable parameters in text simplification models.
Hence, less parallel data is sufficient for training. Our results indicate that
pre-training on unaligned data can reduce the required parallel data while
improving the performance on downstream tasks. | [
-0.4892182648,
-0.6181797981,
0.5676712394,
0.2279229015,
-0.534853518,
-0.2758217752,
-0.3959919214,
-0.2880704403,
0.1459722519,
0.4896908402,
-0.6502133608,
-0.5356232524,
-0.7207339406,
0.4462041259,
-0.558698833,
1.0468925238,
-0.4236536622,
0.2005375624,
-0.256369561,
-0.1761377901,
-0.1705013365,
-0.6242271066,
-0.5030135512,
-0.3482370079,
0.4834685624,
0.65605551,
0.763682723,
1.118360877,
0.54186517,
0.3979334831,
-0.1202676371,
-0.0565606318,
-0.6626726985,
-0.0417690948,
-0.0569506995,
-0.3841731846,
-0.3575988412,
-0.2648230791,
0.563716948,
1.0720297098,
0.0378077775,
0.0259945169,
0.117091842,
0.8425813913,
-0.3878155649,
0.3821209967,
-0.2406478971,
-0.1391239017,
-0.3968025446,
-0.056285698,
-0.3523727655,
-0.2862163782,
0.064203538,
-0.7140184045,
0.412756145,
-0.0241084006,
0.9287554622,
0.2826744616,
-0.3951530755,
-0.2727625966,
-0.9736402035,
0.7431895137,
-0.5551185012,
0.3387298882,
0.2539901435,
0.1095764488,
0.1393312365,
-0.8167040348,
-0.3948485255,
0.2063170969,
-0.5010235906,
-0.1033609211,
-0.1483778954,
0.1446359754,
0.3710732162,
0.1782160699,
-0.6086470485,
0.0333495177,
-0.5235119462,
-0.0488085561,
0.6263687611,
0.1070913672,
0.1960934401,
0.0626818836,
-0.0167307947,
-0.3045843244,
-0.6798121333,
-0.0822945684,
0.489376843,
0.467110157,
-0.0464698635,
0.2048003972,
-0.5635192394,
0.4452328682,
-0.2059884518,
-0.1494221985,
0.4030832648,
-0.3175212145,
-0.109760873,
0.014106147,
0.5408390164,
-0.0479376726,
0.5752665401,
-0.200780943,
-0.3040742576,
-0.167725727,
0.0933874696,
-0.9752861857,
-0.1933638453,
0.1296018958,
-0.5463702679,
-0.0577038862,
0.2169265896,
-0.4546616375,
0.0388516448,
-0.5623493791,
0.2761067152,
-0.2739696801,
-0.0150032714,
0.4391770661,
-0.1576868296,
-0.1774244606,
0.5052754283,
-0.7971805334,
0.4642788768,
0.5239844918,
0.5707068443,
-0.1045694649,
-0.4846300185,
-0.2289215773,
0.3321836889,
-0.3036615252,
0.736825943,
-0.426659435,
-0.226669386,
-0.0071518277,
0.1973206848,
0.2093368322,
-0.5157488585,
0.768592,
-0.3483633995,
0.1539351195,
-0.1566316485,
-0.6444685459,
-0.189462021,
-0.2185112387,
-0.8535943627,
0.641951263,
-0.1085672975,
-0.9525219202,
0.1054310426,
-0.5317732096,
-0.7964915037,
-0.1125760004,
-0.0010021997,
-0.472707808,
0.1463995874,
0.3511977494,
0.4309836924,
-0.3928662241,
0.2748693228,
-0.4113593698,
-0.593228519,
-0.4327385724,
-0.3777668476,
0.5150985718,
0.3683174253,
-0.0601748899,
0.0029806404,
-0.8001103401,
0.0550171249,
0.2860483229,
-0.4464048445,
-0.5492539406,
-0.1078236625,
0.4773911834,
0.2375424355,
0.3830617368,
-0.3164680004,
0.1283673048,
-0.2876218855,
0.058749903,
0.5133724213,
-0.4034001529,
0.6759204268,
-0.3370861411,
0.4170141518,
0.1019260436,
0.0642718449,
-0.3715459704,
-0.14354752,
-1.1161781549,
-0.3895722926,
0.5794049501,
0.8012440801,
-0.5962643027,
0.3053183854,
-0.5263870955,
-0.4628780186,
-0.5268449187,
0.3322333097,
0.4744097888,
0.2386437058,
0.4372410178,
-0.3927149177,
-0.6560406685,
-1.0337444544,
-0.3888691664,
0.1180339232,
-0.1929136366,
0.0123381233,
0.1875430346,
-0.2119015753,
0.8767745495,
-0.5754074454,
-0.2318689376,
-0.3952467442,
0.5392860174,
0.1279892325,
0.6367522478,
0.2482325435,
-0.9847283363,
-0.5593288541,
-0.2081386745,
-0.8521646857,
-0.3673170805,
0.0648619458,
0.2271164656,
0.1458713263,
0.9428473711,
-0.4043656886,
0.4867682457,
0.3444488943,
0.0551871397,
-0.0055289604,
-0.5102565885,
-0.1062468141,
-0.8615432978,
0.0599700138,
-0.0941191614,
-0.4480490685,
-1.0150250196,
-0.0555539951,
0.1061842591,
-0.2642210126,
-0.4028980434,
0.6737962365,
-0.5944864154,
0.0245831814,
-0.468021363,
-0.3266090751,
-0.0564508252,
0.4402180612,
0.465626508,
0.3946761191,
0.4122102559,
-0.4606390297,
0.0129658934,
0.1063192189,
-0.2801516056,
0.0510557257,
-0.5771110654,
0.0741741881,
-0.6267308593,
0.3823832572,
-0.7136009932,
-0.433926791,
-0.0411330424,
0.1438361406,
0.3315007091,
-0.0331719369,
-0.6724892259,
-0.2411731929,
0.0224538893,
0.5517593622,
0.5095124841,
-0.3627056479,
0.507527113,
0.1059229672,
-0.6832885742,
-0.2735331357,
-0.606361866,
-0.2218980342,
-0.1699353158,
-0.6793560982,
0.5086404085,
-0.1249222606,
-0.2350450307,
-0.0229253825,
-0.0666538179,
-0.4250987172,
0.119135268,
0.1347670853,
0.0828857198,
-0.059371341,
0.2416606247,
0.3057094514,
-0.2879610658,
-0.3435474038,
-0.1594265103,
0.6053139567,
-0.1354113072,
-0.3277955949,
-0.5814114213,
0.869582057,
0.3065809906,
-0.0291082691,
0.6221661568,
0.4725378752,
-0.3062555194,
-0.2003281265,
-0.388212502,
-0.4075889587,
-0.5279078484,
0.3294421732,
-0.5584818721,
-0.9181348085,
0.2638328373,
-0.4398436248,
-0.0406106636,
0.3414137363,
0.3400635421,
-0.1094811559,
0.9321215153,
1.1690411568,
0.0165774468,
0.4131323397,
0.2704712451,
0.2569149435,
0.3663389087,
0.0982345641,
-0.474247098,
-0.1877025962,
-0.6314942241,
-0.2437176108,
0.232342422,
0.5637530088,
-0.2660522759,
0.4189150929,
-0.2297414541,
0.6174426675,
0.6966164112,
0.084711656,
0.5056582093,
0.2206035554,
0.1502042115,
-0.0916360617,
-0.7573423386,
-0.5685512424,
1.1096656322,
0.2765679657,
0.6151386499,
-0.2161724269,
1.0994324684,
-0.0145698553,
0.2115640342,
-0.4651707411,
0.3898527324,
-0.575712204,
-0.421169579,
-0.4403996468,
-0.5271332264,
-0.6099473238,
-0.1038919687,
-0.0731756017,
-0.2273030132,
0.0657917634,
0.2280019671,
-0.0158746764,
0.0276056882,
-0.9619005919,
0.7651398182,
0.126393795,
0.0893236026,
-0.2301760167,
-0.5946415663,
0.0808312371,
-0.6407169104,
0.4765471518,
-0.0629661158,
-0.0765752271,
0.623681426,
-0.8315472603,
0.7579859495,
0.1939944327,
0.1142179295,
0.0788438693,
-0.1781306267,
0.9611947536,
-0.2531073689,
0.0592947379,
0.1746570766,
-0.275359273,
-0.7501477599,
-0.5402345657,
0.337330699,
-0.5349966884,
-0.7558037639,
-0.0944984481,
-0.7784121037,
-0.2567642927,
0.3704785407,
0.4352054894,
0.146008417,
-0.2520467937,
-0.0106603373,
0.5712060928,
-0.0200504567,
0.7052225471,
0.5119522214,
0.0029926107,
-0.0574026331,
0.7612907887,
0.2600442469,
0.1817053407,
0.283991456,
0.010226395,
-0.1346863508,
-0.530903697,
-0.333601594,
0.2211014777,
-0.8368541002,
0.1638727486,
-0.8001047969,
-0.1399154216,
-0.5226336718,
-0.2636993229,
-0.2698284388,
-0.6350538135,
-0.2974822223,
0.0828623325,
0.4600092471,
0.8518109322,
-0.0890512094,
0.5767139196,
-0.8538480997,
0.2188943475,
0.3080343008,
0.3421494365,
-0.2840928733,
-0.5392335057,
-0.1817421019,
-0.3179540634,
0.1157006621,
-0.6964510679,
0.4921762347,
0.0976691172,
0.0666935742,
0.3956196308,
0.0783733577,
0.680003643,
-0.9502661824,
0.0752517208,
0.2351765931,
-1.0721782446,
0.2590192854,
-0.5057262182,
0.4222944975,
0.5875127912,
0.7047402859,
-0.5175694823,
-0.3064042926,
-0.623100996,
-0.9266662598,
1.0338071585,
0.296474725,
0.2211229354,
0.3830671906,
0.2393258214,
0.1451707184,
0.3750669658,
-0.6974518299,
-0.4430955052,
-0.219638899,
-0.494831264,
-0.2720727324,
-0.2572062016,
-0.1272035688,
-0.1821757257,
0.5959053636,
-0.0318926573,
-0.0023069382,
-0.1761118919,
-0.0871419013,
0.0985483304,
0.5339184999,
0.3946911693,
0.3608227074,
-0.088747859,
-0.041567754,
0.2141465396,
-0.3033759296,
0.3315891027,
0.4686384201,
-0.51956141,
0.4678797722,
0.2473836988,
0.8594648838,
-0.0272127688,
-0.6715540886,
0.5934675932,
0.1122293696,
-0.0725395679,
0.0271335468,
-0.2068874687,
0.2689361274,
0.0489130802,
0.2031336278,
0.0650529414,
0.1480616182,
-0.3053773046,
0.289216429,
-0.059759602,
-0.1410202235,
-0.0923254713,
0.372947216,
0.2070431411,
-0.2183157057,
0.2414307445,
-0.2669214308,
-0.1662474722,
0.6468119025,
0.5261904597,
0.6477829218,
-0.1831467748,
0.1709818542,
0.2045143545,
0.2929634452,
-0.7105617523,
0.4065149426,
0.1149430498,
-0.4211704731,
-0.3251282573,
-0.6246487498,
-0.3572005928,
0.1638899744,
-0.572240591,
0.6297212243,
-0.5150318146,
0.1641052514,
0.0278334841,
-0.3985086679,
-0.86126858,
0.3421713412,
0.114631325,
0.8592937589,
-1.0924481153,
1.2349375486,
0.6091150641,
-0.3620900512,
-0.8584212661,
0.0972314104,
-0.0030277239,
-0.5022539496,
0.8335261345,
0.3169214129,
-0.0218625572,
0.1315652728,
-0.4384122193,
-1.0164022446,
0.7013841867,
0.6235996485,
-0.7691235542,
-0.1797958314,
0.5155755877,
0.5626918674,
-0.3713854253,
0.0789037347,
0.540268898,
0.535418272,
-0.2259886712,
-0.9602402449,
-0.0069060982,
-0.2395236641,
0.2097417712,
0.3951396048,
-0.3470908999,
0.9741999507,
0.0174688455,
-0.4807606637,
0.1144094542,
0.7472447753,
-0.2080261409,
0.2025464773,
0.5317988396,
0.6251229644,
0.7358776331,
-0.0789310783,
0.8781040311,
-0.2953580618,
0.2971344292,
1.173216939,
-0.1534808129,
0.8571677208,
0.4884590507,
0.0417883024,
0.3658679128,
0.4738326073,
0.1566500068,
0.6102616191,
0.22020109,
-0.3182918727,
-0.4047495127,
-0.1961295456,
-0.1945178658,
0.3055593967,
0.017655693,
-0.3648375273,
-0.5271003246,
0.2156833261,
0.3310491443,
0.2422540784,
-0.398158133,
0.6935389638,
-0.0231125709,
-0.5706391931,
0.60010463,
0.3500340283,
0.8063756824,
-0.6413214803,
0.2584615648,
-0.4450102448,
0.2453277707,
-0.0886437744,
-0.3420373201,
0.3266337216,
0.1654908508,
-0.5414765477,
-0.570463419,
0.670463562,
-0.7067126632,
-0.5995454788,
0.3188265264,
0.7545264363,
0.3641691804,
-0.1780914515,
-0.4812290668,
-0.0798086226,
-0.0133901872,
-0.133203581,
0.405379355,
0.4955001175,
-0.2802197337,
0.5970172882,
0.5606713891,
-0.076017417,
0.0411220118,
0.0661246106,
0.8925773501,
-0.7057890296,
-0.6018598676,
-0.6434226632,
0.1282974184,
0.008652431,
-0.0904114619,
0.6046766639,
0.5090909004,
1.1270554066,
-0.2137552351,
0.8829289675,
0.2486821562,
0.663379252,
-0.4289445281,
0.6684966683,
-0.6769325733,
0.1190026775,
-0.3033700287,
-0.8106413484,
-0.3899834454,
0.1469096392,
-0.2111287862,
0.0262680873,
0.7789148092,
0.8475228548,
-0.2482199669,
0.0987470821,
0.2441240996,
-0.0381048657,
-0.2564266026,
0.3962803781,
0.314332217,
-0.3682125509,
0.9848513603,
-0.5202533603,
-0.1210757568,
-0.0671782345,
-0.9231133461,
-0.7759481072,
-0.4899149537,
-0.1408131272,
-0.1389992684,
0.1873524636,
0.8145608902,
0.6035791039,
-0.8484544754,
-0.363181144,
-0.3914611936,
-0.0331542753,
-0.1016699448,
-0.0792147443,
0.3771067262,
-0.5754985809,
-1.0541908741,
0.3135043383,
0.1931402087,
0.5324130058,
0.1126443595,
-0.053357251,
0.1295575351,
0.2607277036,
0.346748054,
0.4574707448,
-0.5607184768,
0.0680586472,
-0.120017074,
-0.3771455884,
0.1953561157,
0.9485180974,
-0.6433414221,
0.3007726967,
0.6853556037,
0.5943689942,
0.484899044,
0.0287647191,
0.7196186185,
-0.8049784899,
0.7294844985,
-0.0917816386,
0.3736737072,
0.3862610757,
-0.1467714459,
0.419473201,
0.2731641829,
-0.1085488126,
-0.6525912285,
0.2616665661,
-0.55108428,
-0.7029753327,
1.1332461834,
-0.3270899355,
-0.045984257,
-0.3696022928,
-0.0073103253,
0.3615633547,
-0.2267211378,
0.4985866845,
0.8418913484,
0.2116928548,
-0.0288340803,
-0.2307404429,
0.953615725,
0.8196060658,
-1.0287653208,
0.2050548196,
0.3369857967,
0.1438060552,
0.1087575704,
0.6567026973,
0.1618068516,
0.2160127461,
-0.0411112942,
0.1528605521,
-0.0219053049,
-0.5617063642,
-0.7224569321,
0.2917080224,
-0.1115692183,
0.1306404471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12907v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12907v1 | Meta-in-context learning in large language models | 2023-05-22T10:40:36 | 2023-05-22T10:40:36 | Julian Coda-Forno, Marcel Binz, Zeynep Akata, Matthew Botvinick, Jane X. Wang, Eric Schulz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models have shown tremendous performance in a variety of
tasks. In-context learning -- the ability to improve at a task after being
provided with a number of demonstrations -- is seen as one of the main
contributors to their success. In the present paper, we demonstrate that the
in-context learning abilities of large language models can be recursively
improved via in-context learning itself. We coin this phenomenon
meta-in-context learning. Looking at two idealized domains, a one-dimensional
regression task and a two-armed bandit task, we show that meta-in-context
learning adaptively reshapes a large language model's priors over expected
tasks. Furthermore, we find that meta-in-context learning modifies the
in-context learning strategies of such models. Finally, we extend our approach
to a benchmark of real-world regression problems where we observe competitive
performance to traditional learning algorithms. Taken together, our work
improves our understanding of in-context learning and paves the way toward
adapting large language models to the environment they are applied purely
through meta-in-context learning rather than traditional finetuning. | [
-0.134900704,
-0.8875593543,
0.5898582935,
-0.0481027626,
-0.0991347805,
0.1200988367,
-0.5451068282,
-0.231812492,
-0.1213500202,
0.4679476321,
-0.5735398531,
-0.1905242503,
-0.5226612687,
0.071914643,
-0.0508096181,
1.0747866631,
0.1481813788,
-0.0113702863,
-0.510025084,
-0.2123003304,
-0.7644239068,
-0.5447127223,
-0.6060784459,
-0.3301749527,
0.3492802978,
0.4177820086,
0.4181089103,
0.2620503008,
0.1296590865,
0.3760730028,
0.2095918357,
0.2026345581,
-0.7400289774,
0.3375339508,
-0.5624427199,
-0.406311959,
-0.1785499007,
-0.0131224534,
0.9621092081,
0.6557543278,
-0.149681434,
0.2682308555,
0.5723756552,
0.6663604975,
-0.8458574414,
0.3907003701,
-0.762891233,
-0.3985634148,
0.0405084006,
-0.131738767,
-0.622476697,
-0.1116579995,
0.3657059669,
-0.5715879202,
0.0311601255,
-0.3992242813,
0.4344934225,
0.2706899345,
-0.4986930192,
-0.2470383197,
-0.8494206667,
0.8708357811,
-0.4244179428,
0.4384660423,
0.2417873442,
0.6024332047,
-0.1677461863,
-0.8711723685,
-0.1190951169,
-0.0279543288,
-0.1963236928,
0.0341005363,
-0.1459527761,
-0.2198391855,
0.4155309796,
-0.2507128119,
-0.1955201924,
-0.0995013565,
-0.1803308427,
0.1315575391,
0.5227650404,
0.0829013512,
0.0027955961,
0.2260413766,
-0.0633621141,
-0.3223753273,
-0.8774610758,
0.1601291895,
0.003797513,
0.5882099867,
0.1453032643,
-0.1111570299,
-0.1592943519,
0.8991650939,
-0.0271676574,
-0.4653217196,
0.3171880245,
-0.0116074076,
-0.4350580275,
-0.3589431643,
0.1143851578,
-0.0726833791,
0.1825447083,
-0.1795610338,
-0.3168587983,
-0.5407195091,
0.3101660907,
-0.6828052998,
-0.0409228019,
-0.0870412141,
-0.4762949944,
0.0661855638,
0.0731298327,
-0.6241312623,
-0.1429331005,
-0.4464693964,
1.0238050222,
-0.3112415671,
-0.2969732583,
0.0706433952,
-0.1081639677,
0.1337938756,
0.3405946791,
-0.7382561564,
0.3810373843,
0.8435448408,
0.7922139168,
0.4362706244,
-0.5160160065,
-0.9764310718,
0.0412259288,
-0.2455271035,
0.5489432216,
-0.756011188,
-0.1503747702,
0.23644723,
-0.1586242169,
-0.4227744639,
-0.6959483027,
0.0926518589,
-0.5283822417,
0.3944678009,
-0.4288336635,
-0.3847751021,
-0.3872270584,
0.1484184116,
-0.4895199835,
0.7962135077,
0.2872088253,
-0.6395097971,
0.4747776091,
-0.708129108,
-0.6615378857,
-0.1438810825,
0.2609889209,
-0.3208829165,
0.3691785634,
0.1196949705,
0.5658892989,
-0.1203792766,
0.1808309257,
-0.2619553506,
-0.4089785814,
0.2512482107,
-0.1017354801,
0.7925652266,
0.0074547599,
-0.3537220657,
0.0289778206,
-0.4725349844,
-0.0773542225,
0.0435977429,
-0.3451513052,
-0.6259635091,
0.3328049779,
-0.1823279858,
0.2929649055,
-0.1140647829,
-0.2246547937,
0.3193015754,
-0.5803260207,
0.5564549565,
0.6053360105,
-0.2022316754,
0.629886806,
-0.1808644384,
0.2794418931,
-0.5026243925,
-0.0467948653,
-0.3750117719,
0.0281970184,
-0.4681552649,
-0.4516169429,
0.5530031323,
0.3608106673,
-0.9140076637,
0.0288483929,
-0.2779861689,
-0.1751635522,
-0.2942990959,
0.1423605084,
0.5658462048,
0.5965830684,
0.4602760971,
-0.1080379114,
-0.486605227,
-0.6353248358,
-0.5534436107,
0.0800752118,
-0.1965608597,
0.50004071,
0.6716601253,
-0.4433584213,
0.9173172712,
-0.4673913717,
-0.3009728193,
-0.3134159148,
0.2280383259,
0.1243010461,
0.2481601536,
0.5716882944,
-0.7459240556,
-0.7415248752,
-0.0910914093,
-0.4834871292,
-0.1069940999,
0.0120022185,
0.1693564802,
0.3354267478,
0.7542968392,
-0.0613486655,
0.0199655388,
0.4796390831,
-0.1383417398,
0.4313928485,
-0.4154134095,
-0.0732781515,
-1.0035800934,
-0.0869346708,
-0.0564540252,
-0.5095357895,
-0.6801903844,
0.3150036633,
0.2289520949,
0.2389109731,
-0.2773640454,
0.5650619864,
-0.1692249328,
-0.1927912086,
-0.5490302444,
0.1158415303,
-0.3597950041,
0.3460768759,
0.3031229973,
0.4714801908,
0.7402083874,
-0.5701870918,
0.0605307594,
-0.1128808782,
-0.5392307043,
0.3986762762,
-0.3615922928,
0.0050116898,
-0.3740587831,
0.7446911931,
-1.06569767,
-0.3740326464,
-0.1146121845,
-0.289494276,
0.4557009935,
-0.145055607,
-0.4119939208,
-0.0467235856,
-0.0255323891,
0.3734383583,
0.4317540228,
-0.8662084341,
0.7033819556,
0.1608722508,
0.0416319668,
-0.7366102934,
-0.307803899,
-0.0116689103,
-0.3095928133,
-0.3421396613,
0.4336108565,
0.1828867942,
-0.3358959258,
-0.1362561733,
0.0469242409,
-0.0084597683,
0.3219420016,
0.0454874784,
-0.1229596213,
-0.0240903981,
0.5572743416,
-0.158246249,
-0.2280170768,
0.0945169553,
-0.5722071528,
0.3514295518,
-0.0354208872,
0.0272166654,
-0.07724154,
0.152379483,
0.5158946514,
-0.3378429115,
0.8394181728,
0.4749940932,
-0.4970839322,
-0.5956382751,
-0.4523215294,
-0.210134685,
-0.4225193858,
0.5744959116,
-0.5197321177,
-1.0607520342,
0.318749547,
-0.3980206549,
0.2174721509,
0.3960386813,
0.4085305035,
-0.2349061072,
0.9142637253,
1.0303144455,
-0.0179766491,
0.7939920425,
-0.394746542,
0.0077973497,
-0.8329238296,
-0.1941210479,
-0.4812895954,
-0.3060365021,
-0.5005924106,
-0.2567310333,
0.523947835,
-0.1356863528,
-0.5034482479,
0.5068816543,
-0.0253670253,
0.6305368543,
0.5509998202,
0.3919712603,
-0.0249488764,
-0.1965064555,
-0.0501721911,
0.0546012297,
-0.825612247,
-0.2352688611,
1.0060255527,
0.3719309866,
0.5115663409,
0.1334604174,
0.6099807024,
0.0317981988,
0.7511910796,
-0.471726805,
0.0750820786,
-0.2019125968,
-0.4797912836,
-0.4442366362,
-0.5131269097,
-0.7988500595,
0.5436961055,
-0.439122647,
-0.6799439192,
0.1125630513,
0.1456764191,
-0.4747700691,
0.2313673943,
-0.6592843533,
0.993639648,
-0.2856007516,
-0.6034505963,
-0.4762104154,
-0.6070521474,
0.2171930671,
-0.2181523591,
0.5459227562,
0.4976523519,
-0.0313241854,
0.4696694613,
-0.0452060737,
1.0798227787,
-0.3704579771,
-0.1601706594,
0.1640663147,
0.2388802171,
0.6274555922,
0.0546302572,
0.0481333323,
-0.2128908783,
-0.1140433773,
-0.365293324,
-0.8032864928,
0.4824573398,
-0.4656180441,
-0.6423946619,
-0.2224125266,
-0.4087257683,
-0.3864296675,
-0.0500596613,
0.2029648423,
0.6709626317,
-0.4260299504,
0.5500892401,
0.6722924709,
-0.372987926,
0.5031679869,
0.6207649708,
-0.1210847497,
-0.3678382933,
0.7937415838,
0.1887578666,
0.5199364424,
0.7189047337,
0.3627994955,
-0.4178493917,
-0.2147750556,
-0.14795807,
0.1500422508,
-0.7280689478,
-0.3418111503,
-0.5753481388,
0.0945838839,
-0.2401885539,
-0.3306721747,
-0.2754546106,
-0.022966003,
-0.0419011563,
0.0091380123,
-0.1610967368,
0.8718989491,
-0.1237581149,
0.3300937712,
-0.6496989131,
-0.1096448228,
0.9152806997,
0.3219487071,
0.2069310546,
-0.7949352264,
-0.6167666316,
0.3141192496,
-0.2808566689,
-0.5001260638,
0.3120270371,
0.4796921313,
0.5879109502,
0.3235597908,
-0.2686531544,
0.7097638249,
-0.6420991421,
0.4679119885,
-0.2159926593,
-1.1625027657,
0.3099375367,
-0.4103833139,
0.4396857619,
0.4957939088,
0.4155199826,
-0.4625125527,
-0.0341062099,
-0.5990703106,
-0.5378887057,
0.6821123958,
-0.0768775865,
0.3481548727,
0.0975216553,
0.5284789801,
0.1973933131,
0.1949665546,
-0.9185429811,
0.1893941611,
-0.1151846424,
0.2460225672,
-0.5447342396,
-0.3019552529,
0.0031615009,
-0.3511891961,
0.6375524998,
-0.4599171579,
-0.0206523817,
-0.0381379053,
-0.4404415488,
-0.1170838177,
0.0429868847,
0.6301454902,
1.0605745316,
-0.3198400438,
0.1185075864,
0.6134098768,
0.0439771935,
-0.0690456852,
-0.2577323616,
0.1428242773,
-0.2294380665,
0.8389903903,
0.6379694939,
0.7817748785,
-0.7168366909,
0.5350975394,
0.0145623144,
-0.2397431731,
-0.0632943437,
0.0749448314,
-0.0058938432,
0.4987799227,
0.611035645,
-0.0381649435,
0.1297085136,
-1.1147531271,
0.3855977654,
0.7864024043,
-0.303122431,
-0.2644718587,
0.3924509585,
0.2102121711,
-0.3934808671,
0.4155749977,
-0.0341921076,
-0.8239103556,
0.4910884798,
1.0887283087,
1.0925577879,
-0.3409731388,
0.1985154748,
0.7330302,
0.2453700453,
-0.4088775814,
-0.3118084073,
-0.347679615,
-0.5775485635,
-0.6191444397,
-0.4631463885,
-0.2977255881,
0.0501672551,
-0.4529596567,
0.2030002922,
-0.1133185104,
0.2186508626,
-0.1237733141,
-0.0110551827,
-0.6420912147,
0.2969404161,
0.1157346219,
0.7681381106,
-1.0460858345,
0.8646569252,
0.6348355412,
0.0447914451,
-0.1606353372,
0.3525788784,
-0.1964713484,
-0.4068561494,
0.7392860055,
0.3640078008,
-0.2538155913,
-0.0676862076,
-0.6213694215,
-1.1477531195,
0.9951220751,
0.384729445,
-0.3872149885,
0.2618056834,
-0.304659903,
0.7322024703,
-0.839926362,
0.2643651664,
0.5679523349,
0.2694036961,
-0.1287823468,
-0.9772610664,
-0.093838118,
0.2701701522,
-0.1526302248,
0.3434060216,
-0.6390272975,
0.8281779289,
-0.2122837603,
-0.3861640096,
-0.2751967311,
0.5785625577,
-0.1299812198,
0.3300801218,
0.7371177673,
0.3645579517,
0.6181467175,
-0.1040185094,
1.0237728357,
0.1953761429,
0.5657290816,
1.1936448812,
-0.1855897009,
1.0535662174,
0.014033664,
-0.085887216,
0.9078914523,
0.5200191736,
0.4928628206,
0.8134128451,
0.0888750479,
-0.1209649518,
-0.5546649098,
0.3994591832,
-0.1316251755,
0.6771965623,
0.4831308126,
-0.2867997289,
-0.4756715298,
0.4699808061,
-0.1556909531,
0.3701010644,
-0.3412690759,
0.9490218163,
-0.1656502336,
-0.8063126206,
0.5785099268,
0.0540540516,
0.5843437314,
-0.5660439134,
-0.2796208858,
0.0715418383,
0.3369750977,
-0.0391549282,
-0.5187918544,
0.4594449103,
-0.2025350332,
-0.2674115896,
-0.3831547797,
0.5803655982,
-0.5227478743,
-0.3841122985,
0.4786991775,
0.5004873872,
-0.2171575576,
-0.2860736847,
-0.5536873341,
-0.2131042033,
-0.08853212,
0.0302774645,
0.602619648,
0.316339016,
-0.0713481903,
0.7179886699,
0.3956290781,
-0.4923653007,
-0.4200835228,
-0.2447215319,
0.7405463457,
-0.3990851641,
-0.3722341359,
-1.0031017065,
0.4794045389,
0.0466198847,
-0.0676499084,
0.7563180327,
0.5243961811,
1.3420031071,
-0.1501911581,
0.7204803228,
-0.1673725247,
0.5773541927,
-0.5159474611,
0.3249486685,
-0.7930812836,
-0.0172834489,
-0.4348405302,
-0.9743378758,
-0.4336756468,
0.6415626407,
-0.4687548876,
0.1651293933,
0.5868365169,
0.5365546346,
-0.1662932932,
-0.4261907935,
0.3332511187,
0.2164605856,
0.1227182522,
0.5872619152,
0.649881959,
-0.2973640561,
0.1369967014,
-0.171034202,
-0.5780150294,
-0.3993757963,
-0.9842372537,
-0.9542031884,
-0.9834427834,
-0.1093942448,
-0.3780995309,
0.1283263564,
1.074650526,
0.7350780368,
-0.5702243447,
-0.4119770825,
0.2468543947,
0.4630430937,
-0.8474296927,
-0.1776081473,
0.4150822759,
-0.7449057102,
-0.8125148416,
0.4989833236,
0.1576006263,
-0.4656956494,
-0.0243905187,
-0.0396133997,
-0.2441723794,
0.1283884495,
1.07337749,
0.3160897791,
-0.5011910796,
-0.4351159334,
-0.1611134261,
0.1606220156,
-0.2128157169,
1.06988585,
-1.1269123554,
0.7079835534,
0.5143280625,
0.5678268671,
0.4820382297,
0.2232828587,
0.5610516071,
-0.7987334132,
-0.0155049153,
-0.0431201346,
0.363106221,
0.1804756224,
-0.1175050661,
0.4879538119,
0.1600906551,
-0.6433495879,
-0.7781434655,
0.1886846274,
-0.1757747531,
-0.7593819499,
1.154319644,
0.0096726632,
-0.1496888399,
-0.061467804,
-0.0362492092,
0.0900407806,
0.0086064087,
0.9556936622,
0.6019502878,
0.1431717724,
0.0552815162,
-0.6673633456,
0.6787227988,
0.2017777264,
-0.5442774892,
0.461191684,
0.3604409099,
0.562838316,
0.0502353497,
0.3275184929,
0.1935465336,
0.3453711867,
-0.2652798891,
-0.310269475,
0.0534364767,
-0.8388846517,
-0.5709967017,
0.1038463116,
-0.1944326162,
-0.0433040783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12900v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12900v2 | Evaluating Prompt-based Question Answering for Object Prediction in the Open Research Knowledge Graph | 2023-05-22T10:35:18 | 2023-06-11T08:23:23 | Jennifer D'Souza, Moussab Hrou, Sören Auer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DL, cs.IT, math.IT | There have been many recent investigations into prompt-based training of
transformer language models for new text genres in low-resource settings. The
prompt-based training approach has been found to be effective in generalizing
pre-trained or fine-tuned models for transfer to resource-scarce settings. This
work, for the first time, reports results on adopting prompt-based training of
transformers for \textit{scholarly knowledge graph object prediction}. The work
is unique in the following two main aspects. 1) It deviates from the other
works proposing entity and relation extraction pipelines for predicting objects
of a scholarly knowledge graph. 2) While other works have tested the method on
text genera relatively close to the general knowledge domain, we test the
method for a significantly different domain, i.e. scholarly knowledge, in turn
testing the linguistic, probabilistic, and factual generalizability of these
large-scale transformer models. We find that (i) per expectations, transformer
models when tested out-of-the-box underperform on a new domain of data, (ii)
prompt-based training of the models achieve performance boosts of up to 40\% in
a relaxed evaluation setting, and (iii) testing the models on a starkly
different domain even with a clever training objective in a low resource
setting makes evident the domain knowledge capture gap offering an
empirically-verified incentive for investing more attention and resources to
the scholarly domain in the context of transformer models. | [
-0.444629997,
-0.8178941607,
0.6279153824,
-0.1927336454,
-0.1169854403,
-0.0791364312,
-0.1687892228,
-0.3561434746,
-0.171513781,
0.3194149733,
-0.7021815777,
-0.3912974,
-0.4708886445,
0.476675868,
-0.2654059231,
0.9108384252,
-0.0038685738,
0.0928659439,
-0.6923889518,
0.0022094809,
-0.8281198144,
-0.1424066275,
-0.6188285351,
-0.1647865325,
0.6218576431,
0.3792410195,
0.7083799839,
0.5446933508,
0.5536407232,
0.2077820152,
-0.0982025936,
-0.0153702544,
-0.4927569032,
0.1362776756,
-0.275259614,
-0.4661548436,
-0.0067205294,
0.1237349808,
0.4100238383,
0.7657331824,
0.1448495388,
0.2986126244,
0.0065425863,
0.3226624131,
-0.4695822299,
0.3917669654,
-0.7062262297,
0.1236182004,
0.1016957238,
-0.1068214253,
-0.8146201968,
-0.3277176023,
0.4245498776,
-0.9560884833,
0.6801435947,
0.5464574099,
0.8381208777,
0.2644984126,
-0.2895871997,
-0.3267765641,
-0.7099484205,
0.7347176075,
-0.2133902609,
0.3958170116,
0.1661987752,
0.7388254404,
0.1755165011,
-1.0383110046,
-0.6244359016,
-0.2736539543,
-0.3619304001,
0.2249763608,
-0.2204971611,
-0.0166021883,
0.4721115828,
0.3271643817,
-0.5594534278,
-0.0668713301,
-0.4382174611,
-0.1846605539,
0.2538423538,
0.2586164474,
0.2924802601,
-0.4931090176,
-0.3729545474,
-0.1152682975,
-0.4392883778,
0.3937776983,
0.2518641651,
0.5463379622,
0.2789251208,
0.6934696436,
-0.3629065454,
0.8133434653,
0.0460243151,
0.1025073156,
0.0684768558,
-0.3568663895,
0.0867639482,
-0.1856444776,
0.8139285445,
0.4195411801,
0.3649710715,
-0.5690649748,
-0.0988635123,
-0.0776488557,
0.2268475145,
-0.9636074305,
-0.2040052563,
-0.0194210913,
-0.4850332439,
-0.0775054246,
0.0098855319,
-0.8626875877,
-0.3807078004,
-0.2919989824,
0.1806295365,
-0.4498515129,
-0.1716417074,
0.1673355401,
-0.1736442894,
0.2098239511,
0.4223676324,
-0.7532914877,
0.2827762067,
0.5788332224,
0.961147666,
-0.2828320265,
-0.3146776557,
-0.8110553622,
-0.1416542083,
-0.1107095405,
0.9613058567,
-0.7234393954,
-0.5272759795,
0.1956058592,
0.2507163286,
-0.333433032,
-0.3630946577,
0.680971086,
-0.8708772063,
0.6070175171,
-0.3614341617,
-0.6103982329,
-0.0732415318,
0.3032849133,
-0.7953031659,
1.0733751059,
0.4984436631,
-1.0231442451,
0.3671541214,
-0.897462666,
-0.1003629714,
0.101957418,
0.1732242256,
-0.2070158422,
-0.2903802991,
0.3478370905,
0.3761363328,
-0.704603374,
0.2858125269,
-0.3258746862,
-0.3926930726,
0.2844406068,
-0.264377296,
0.7654034495,
0.2185505927,
-0.1293040216,
0.032029774,
-0.4689903259,
-0.1481132805,
0.1714846492,
0.0788159072,
-0.2751303911,
-0.3531814814,
-0.0996476337,
0.154597953,
0.1380774379,
-0.7987973094,
0.4068113863,
-0.3509453535,
0.1392475069,
0.4488988817,
0.2635844946,
0.6750221848,
-0.1007324085,
0.9142558575,
-0.1655582339,
0.2760498822,
-0.3558856249,
-0.6075498462,
-0.5967979431,
0.0904235393,
0.5112573504,
0.5529109836,
-1.1307660341,
0.2234378308,
-0.3981294334,
-0.6006890535,
-0.3895348012,
-0.309871912,
0.2469086647,
1.1130337715,
0.6084339023,
-0.0587268919,
-0.3145185113,
-0.5895341039,
-0.285251081,
-0.3576402366,
-0.2470913231,
0.4302390516,
0.4165695906,
0.0601916015,
1.3757663965,
-0.7657696605,
-0.0347090773,
-0.178066045,
0.2181558311,
0.2957150042,
0.2108771205,
0.5079235435,
-0.8139964342,
-0.5277103186,
-0.0983311236,
-0.8097626567,
0.0484349653,
0.0995452106,
-0.1651420444,
-0.2184136808,
0.4392869174,
-0.83682549,
0.2232375294,
0.1125328913,
-0.4327347279,
0.6425585747,
0.131638363,
0.2085537761,
-0.9481207728,
0.2257482857,
0.005888585,
-0.0646195635,
-0.7077224851,
-0.2691169083,
-0.0374262743,
-0.4217677414,
-0.5330709815,
0.8766082525,
-0.3482679427,
0.0232122205,
-0.1924538016,
0.2378284186,
0.0246404186,
0.4869623184,
0.0355226919,
1.0091995001,
0.646499157,
-0.5412410498,
0.2223314643,
0.7847042084,
-0.3341355324,
0.5575088263,
-0.9421206117,
0.2652150989,
-0.4144117236,
0.0197833814,
-0.9603655934,
-0.092472285,
0.4667530358,
-0.4544810057,
0.1538020819,
-0.3387771845,
-0.2521314621,
-0.6393842101,
0.0844718739,
0.2059984505,
0.5847482085,
-0.4558290541,
0.7920529246,
0.0511219725,
-0.2136135399,
-0.875056386,
-0.2065398991,
-0.2320128381,
-0.1417548507,
-0.5159726739,
0.1735065281,
-0.1467698663,
-0.0188778918,
0.2734649777,
0.0393214673,
-0.0396578461,
0.1935586184,
0.1500492394,
0.5128036737,
-0.3194850385,
0.3297633827,
-0.1311306357,
-0.241037786,
0.2576601207,
-0.3962333202,
0.426517725,
-0.1326691806,
-0.4762626886,
-0.127584219,
-0.1158149242,
0.3299819231,
-0.4061556458,
0.7329747081,
0.6262699366,
-0.1812397242,
-0.0438754223,
-0.348571986,
-0.4359292984,
-0.4262651801,
0.4098059833,
-0.4222353101,
-0.7869075537,
0.4921103418,
-0.2705155313,
0.0063012345,
0.6085675359,
0.1053055152,
0.0952165574,
0.7284058928,
0.6644446254,
0.1393734962,
0.4575543106,
-0.5041731596,
0.1550028175,
-0.7888795733,
-0.3251591027,
-0.8180294037,
-0.0298047885,
-0.2595142126,
-0.2856426835,
0.3584324718,
0.1645258516,
-0.1832358539,
0.3471373022,
-0.4869329631,
0.6160648465,
0.4461526573,
0.0144148208,
0.4269758165,
-0.0498268679,
0.0890759304,
-0.0202760976,
-0.8316476345,
-0.5483076572,
1.0479204655,
0.2667092681,
0.4356079102,
-0.479868263,
0.1735474318,
0.2295993119,
0.6523893476,
-0.9584246278,
0.4418182373,
0.052988559,
-0.4972648025,
-0.679046154,
-0.4142777026,
-0.9940104485,
0.0388975106,
-0.1058803871,
-0.3440080285,
0.1814755648,
0.0703548342,
-0.260607034,
0.3292185366,
-0.5653873682,
1.1417164803,
0.1736029088,
-0.1260017604,
0.2389681786,
-0.7080224156,
0.1763011813,
0.045569215,
0.0704322904,
-0.1297999471,
0.0068682688,
0.8458379507,
0.0029401048,
0.6892818213,
-0.6473497748,
0.2148203254,
0.5776510239,
0.0146748973,
0.6467890739,
0.1613206714,
-0.2886413336,
-0.0285786949,
-0.2422514558,
-0.334469378,
-1.0095728636,
0.0565599203,
-0.7433726788,
-0.6275494695,
-0.1496966183,
-0.6318410039,
-0.4833107591,
0.3721370697,
0.3748512864,
0.6871142387,
-0.3573946059,
0.2951748073,
0.8527111411,
-0.0634204,
0.2588100731,
0.6054921746,
-0.2927876115,
-0.3339798748,
0.6412426233,
-0.041436974,
0.0671770573,
0.5995264053,
0.3641994298,
-0.6373602152,
-0.5138756037,
-0.6635155082,
0.1203896999,
-0.8432669044,
-0.430121541,
-0.9545423985,
-0.1499099433,
-0.3680337965,
0.1826808006,
0.01137615,
-0.3576152027,
-0.3911189437,
-0.1521343589,
0.5453779101,
0.6346960068,
0.5876601934,
0.3644779325,
-0.7483160496,
0.0898273066,
0.5064020753,
0.2768963575,
-0.0383340269,
-0.6839620471,
-0.266523838,
-0.1592870057,
-0.1564219743,
-0.8264693022,
-0.0123295328,
0.0835617259,
0.6151775122,
0.0998393744,
0.386056602,
0.1279553771,
-0.6460449696,
0.8192521334,
0.1269034892,
-0.6593024731,
0.4361049831,
-0.4539440572,
0.1008200794,
0.7029958963,
0.7052537203,
-0.6614691019,
-0.2833857834,
-0.6664663553,
-0.4227140546,
0.7497255802,
-0.031833306,
0.289069593,
0.0042380174,
0.4312033355,
0.4371805787,
0.3231624067,
-0.5705057383,
-0.359223187,
-0.4799946547,
-0.2259002924,
-0.1346796155,
-0.1618050635,
0.0736529902,
-0.0750803426,
0.5338898897,
-0.4484573603,
0.3595131934,
0.1629906446,
-0.1459265798,
-0.0940590352,
0.2138925344,
0.1473344862,
0.6582540274,
-0.0473571233,
-0.0569843352,
0.2140077204,
-0.4155759215,
0.1530839503,
0.2066665888,
-0.5441967249,
0.186304599,
0.1963661462,
1.0656502247,
0.0959515795,
-0.4860705137,
0.7594245076,
-0.1482683569,
-0.0893874019,
-0.1063030586,
0.0910311118,
-0.1151176393,
0.1762754172,
0.4131832421,
0.3579546809,
0.2435662746,
-0.1484672278,
0.1086992323,
0.3186604381,
-0.5234775543,
-0.4141351581,
0.8191583157,
0.14002119,
-0.2219224274,
0.6789311171,
-0.3725330532,
-0.4792550504,
0.5164871216,
0.5090973377,
0.7704678774,
0.0064120758,
0.5652139783,
0.5856304765,
0.1847447902,
-0.0617404468,
-0.0133722164,
0.0275820717,
-0.6756734252,
-0.5622166991,
-0.4848375022,
-0.6360307336,
-0.1154812947,
-0.6077477336,
0.4498857856,
-0.0502739102,
-0.1017795429,
-0.1510768831,
-0.0037265522,
-0.8953407407,
0.0687501132,
-0.3403520584,
1.1817543507,
-0.9039250612,
0.4670135975,
0.7333632112,
-0.52787745,
-0.7831366062,
-0.0173456222,
-0.6135396957,
-0.7536871433,
0.7072399259,
0.2375152856,
0.0406754017,
0.2492688149,
-0.4366317093,
-0.8499478698,
1.1453610659,
0.5656878352,
-0.2122281939,
-0.3132725358,
0.0832877308,
0.5294288993,
-0.2749556005,
0.5268362761,
0.2660704553,
0.475866586,
0.1941159815,
-0.6225757599,
0.1323249638,
-0.2772640884,
-0.0066179279,
0.0995071381,
-0.4645735919,
0.8953924775,
-0.1045294404,
-0.4386293292,
0.1591896415,
1.0366111994,
-0.0008287535,
0.4690997303,
0.7334723473,
0.1987818182,
0.9777576923,
-0.1998966038,
1.2028118372,
-0.466982305,
0.5025351644,
0.813482523,
-0.254760921,
0.5042050481,
0.2995798588,
-0.2043810487,
0.6483717561,
0.5792996287,
-0.2001451999,
0.5065789819,
-0.1091233417,
-0.0403059386,
-0.0774815381,
-0.5791606307,
-0.428119719,
0.1288771182,
-0.1375421435,
-0.0939391032,
-0.183669433,
0.3228244185,
-0.1882137209,
0.1527727544,
-0.313835144,
0.6821838021,
-0.2783593237,
-0.9050787687,
0.3259878457,
-0.2419646233,
0.3499278724,
-0.5151693225,
0.1215181947,
-0.1558060646,
-0.2644878924,
0.0730692074,
-0.7406203151,
0.1017969325,
0.0255302545,
-0.3600917757,
-0.3315732777,
0.9971134663,
-0.3035702109,
-0.4082169235,
-0.0064202896,
0.8969295025,
-0.0759744421,
-0.1282203496,
-0.3881385922,
-0.4458779395,
-0.1204864755,
-0.3446321487,
0.0613245405,
0.6943956017,
0.1064397097,
0.5736988783,
0.5148805976,
-0.1544467658,
-0.012523911,
0.0954594761,
0.9065331817,
-0.3969259262,
-0.5461176634,
-0.3999223709,
0.4982804954,
-0.1317808628,
-0.3808479905,
0.7656109929,
0.5070151687,
0.8137407899,
-0.4406968057,
0.7587637305,
-0.0261592381,
0.7267379165,
-0.5721503496,
0.3537153304,
-0.2057189494,
-0.0703581199,
-0.0792978033,
-1.0238945484,
-0.0350552164,
0.081765607,
-0.6983761787,
0.0208041426,
0.9027926326,
0.6077922583,
-0.1006277353,
0.371653229,
0.1885495782,
-0.2382401526,
0.1191110834,
0.2654105425,
1.209394455,
-0.4000377953,
0.8818209767,
-0.3994324207,
-0.0523118898,
-0.0043864031,
-0.7208880186,
-1.0698796511,
-0.5810732245,
-0.2022482604,
-0.3023985922,
-0.1650028676,
0.6860557199,
0.3630447388,
-0.7473834157,
0.1141899452,
-0.1897510737,
0.0342782065,
-0.19929564,
-0.2722899914,
0.5316170454,
-0.5540172458,
-0.7429981828,
0.2212462127,
-0.1785169393,
0.1106052399,
-0.2204858363,
-0.069964394,
0.2983620465,
-0.3074950576,
0.4411348403,
0.1729816794,
-0.4233154058,
-0.3467678726,
0.8316034079,
-0.0332120024,
0.0896726549,
1.1423714161,
-0.9699901938,
0.4298706055,
0.4879627526,
0.9809610844,
0.3452123404,
0.2323555797,
0.3664852977,
-0.693695426,
0.1495497674,
0.3605151176,
0.427215755,
0.4836450815,
-0.4755908549,
0.6484713554,
0.4131162763,
-0.5279665589,
-0.7310263515,
0.2542743087,
-0.6728917956,
-0.1315686107,
0.9508941174,
-0.2008952796,
-0.2340736687,
-0.2304641902,
-0.2971791625,
0.5201890469,
-0.4178688824,
0.8230291605,
0.5482243299,
0.0656720772,
-0.0431514643,
-0.5683034062,
0.464705646,
0.265928328,
-0.9027823806,
0.1904009879,
0.3838202357,
0.0468501672,
0.408975333,
0.4479830861,
0.1014567614,
0.2922510505,
-0.1100334451,
-0.0084180012,
-0.5057976842,
-0.4890384078,
-0.2626987398,
0.3722504675,
0.0842051432,
-0.0990468413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12894v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12894v2 | Leveraging Human Feedback to Scale Educational Datasets: Combining Crowdworkers and Comparative Judgement | 2023-05-22T10:22:14 | 2023-11-09T18:02:58 | Owen Henkel, Libby Hills | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine Learning models have many potentially beneficial applications in
education settings, but a key barrier to their development is securing enough
data to train these models. Labelling educational data has traditionally relied
on highly skilled raters using complex, multi-class rubrics, making the process
expensive and difficult to scale. An alternative, more scalable approach could
be to use non-expert crowdworkers to evaluate student work, however,
maintaining sufficiently high levels of accuracy and inter-rater reliability
when using non-expert workers is challenging. This paper reports on two
experiments investigating using non-expert crowdworkers and comparative
judgement to evaluate complex student data. Crowdworkers were hired to evaluate
student responses to open-ended reading comprehension questions. Crowdworkers
were randomly assigned to one of two conditions: the control, where they were
asked to decide whether answers were correct or incorrect (i.e., a categorical
judgement), or the treatment, where they were shown the same question and
answers, but were instead asked to decide which of two candidate answers was
more correct (i.e., a comparative/preference-based judgement). We found that
using comparative judgement substantially improved inter-rater reliability on
both tasks. These results are in-line with well-established literature on the
benefits of comparative judgement in the field of educational assessment, as
well as with recent trends in artificial intelligence research, where
comparative judgement is becoming the preferred method for providing human
feedback on model outputs when working with non-expert crowdworkers. However,
to our knowledge, these results are novel and important in demonstrating the
beneficial effects of using the combination of comparative judgement and
crowdworkers to evaluate educational data. | [
-0.630531013,
-0.4891099632,
0.1150861904,
-0.0088080876,
0.1510503292,
0.1315734237,
-0.3673601747,
-0.5499058366,
-0.0442975201,
0.2975621521,
0.0069804741,
0.0449618958,
-0.6781003475,
0.2521281242,
-0.4224945307,
0.9701904058,
0.002852882,
0.5932548642,
-0.8439927697,
-0.2227464616,
-0.4545259476,
-0.7188045382,
-0.563341856,
-0.6060334444,
0.6388036609,
0.8143184185,
0.6836040616,
0.4757231474,
0.7784565687,
0.4241527617,
0.1364627928,
0.046657268,
-0.4809285104,
-0.0921370313,
-0.4094475508,
-0.7001681924,
-0.2793109715,
0.455645293,
0.3705033958,
1.046531558,
-0.0709771663,
0.4575581551,
0.3525990248,
0.9704115987,
-0.6508983374,
0.040134076,
-0.0552677885,
0.1682483703,
-0.0958630964,
0.0970582068,
-0.4884780347,
-0.6067504287,
0.292557925,
-0.4212251604,
0.3988674283,
-0.0752220154,
0.5754262805,
0.3276994228,
-0.4256514907,
-0.0484550111,
-0.6447922587,
0.9296246767,
-0.4913749397,
0.2642464936,
0.5996971726,
0.4775998294,
0.1656076163,
-0.5765377283,
-0.3541739583,
-0.2172172368,
-0.0961570814,
0.358343035,
-0.0109661622,
0.0089130616,
0.2498316169,
0.2046943903,
-0.366555959,
0.4504523575,
-0.6829212308,
-0.1575311124,
0.7414268851,
0.2129154354,
-0.0856771991,
-0.2024184167,
-0.3439307809,
-0.520139873,
0.003988862,
0.4475848973,
0.5841500163,
0.3043210208,
0.377843976,
0.6743420362,
-0.5506743193,
0.9379979968,
0.235867843,
0.0080414396,
0.2843622863,
0.090951927,
0.0917318463,
-0.2620376945,
0.6055681109,
0.8411837816,
0.5224193931,
-0.1555707455,
-0.3765062094,
0.3386064172,
0.3553083539,
-0.8399924636,
-0.4323590398,
0.0430679619,
-0.5945335627,
-0.4716570377,
0.3690689802,
-0.90510571,
-0.4104121029,
-0.776234746,
0.5463348031,
0.1929337084,
-0.2075763941,
-0.0749590322,
-0.3239967823,
-0.0669211671,
0.4735077918,
-0.5959939361,
0.2240133882,
0.5066462755,
0.6174423099,
-0.104009077,
-0.5104896426,
-0.5613318086,
-0.3900395334,
-0.2456708252,
0.898835063,
-0.7681400776,
-0.3725377917,
-0.2126776278,
-0.1703184098,
-0.019538885,
-0.9592671394,
0.4408075809,
-0.3575927019,
0.6088781953,
-0.2019000202,
-0.7104994655,
-0.1388679743,
0.3824124336,
-0.6435136795,
1.0628621578,
0.3270279169,
-0.828151226,
0.4929462969,
-0.6301222444,
-0.3326654136,
0.0487823598,
-0.0152149303,
-0.4654424787,
-0.0160733555,
0.1004021168,
0.5312519073,
-0.0903077573,
0.2907801867,
-0.4997699559,
-0.4977998137,
0.4564528167,
-0.3768477142,
0.5852121711,
0.0623948276,
-0.2395134121,
-0.0120866075,
-0.4948989451,
0.379145205,
-0.0771986619,
-0.5719451308,
-0.4901510775,
-0.0724202991,
0.1428658664,
0.1754926741,
-0.0252496861,
-0.3797128797,
0.2130552083,
0.0616874844,
0.3440422118,
0.7902652621,
-0.205646947,
0.4222271144,
-0.7728539705,
0.5291013718,
-0.291997999,
0.1759540737,
0.1401195824,
-0.4837406576,
-0.619550705,
0.1502272487,
0.6247227788,
0.4832470417,
-0.8010978103,
0.1285655349,
-0.0300836917,
-0.7598510981,
-0.7315047979,
0.0326132961,
0.4613656998,
0.7002147436,
0.4145547152,
-0.6755892038,
-0.3967698812,
-0.6071764231,
-0.5897192955,
-0.5351993442,
-0.3502210379,
0.4077791572,
0.406650275,
0.0799069926,
1.0984824896,
-0.465419054,
-0.3578958511,
0.1080129072,
0.2913603485,
-0.0405857787,
0.7036874294,
0.3065965474,
-0.7537916899,
-0.4346942604,
-0.3338284194,
-0.5330445766,
-0.1068427265,
-0.0659234598,
-0.1497440338,
-0.3349705637,
0.0240193624,
-0.054581929,
0.3850120604,
0.3114205599,
-0.4029170871,
0.6733089685,
-0.1237226352,
0.5154654384,
-0.5477911234,
-0.0302879754,
0.2976006269,
-0.3396370411,
-0.6000017524,
-0.0237757955,
0.1218397766,
0.1019627154,
-0.2731094956,
0.4547998011,
-0.2259670645,
0.1041759625,
-0.3082408011,
0.3662431538,
0.0180851426,
0.3247628212,
0.0176890828,
0.5618356466,
0.3493534029,
-0.3170841038,
0.5198769569,
0.1440436691,
-0.3671840727,
1.1828699112,
-0.6207764149,
0.3954341114,
-0.0411153324,
0.4587257802,
-0.6705944538,
-0.4425860047,
-0.0139085306,
-0.7039238214,
-0.0116266152,
-0.2130385041,
-0.4662000239,
-0.8413261771,
-0.398969382,
0.2214984596,
0.3651152551,
-0.6844528317,
0.2116600424,
0.4324003458,
-0.142937988,
-0.4172827601,
-0.7308093905,
0.0369533449,
-0.2422431856,
-0.4883083105,
-0.2208854556,
-0.0428804979,
-0.6449072957,
0.0112006394,
-0.1579679549,
-0.4772108495,
0.2740748227,
0.3872829378,
0.6333141327,
-0.0658909529,
0.2577026784,
-0.0027461911,
-0.2324231118,
0.2293334454,
-0.2083529979,
-0.0683224648,
-0.0413735509,
-0.5328083634,
-0.3636162579,
0.1295853108,
0.422663331,
-0.2863706648,
0.5960268378,
0.4950808287,
-0.2088900805,
-0.0628769174,
-0.7067486048,
-0.6159179211,
-0.4030154049,
0.2340231091,
-0.1706965864,
-0.8090499043,
-0.0123730944,
-0.3661366403,
0.2532820404,
0.1897663325,
0.49922809,
-0.407528311,
0.900913775,
0.3902104795,
-0.328613013,
0.5721580386,
-0.387596935,
-0.0528549701,
-0.6716619134,
-0.3267890215,
-0.6724554896,
-0.8398356438,
-0.1321768314,
-0.5385971069,
0.2359121591,
0.1877222359,
0.0250045117,
-0.0566022657,
-0.6855070591,
0.8744404316,
0.7245925069,
0.3430815041,
0.3404873013,
-0.1827220917,
0.173283577,
0.0312138889,
-0.5363873243,
-0.7674645782,
1.2617381811,
0.0704690516,
0.5590483546,
-0.2093113959,
0.5624005198,
0.4765495956,
0.8584612012,
-0.7485589385,
0.3320214748,
-0.1291517913,
-0.7974371314,
-0.5679581761,
-0.6708443165,
-0.9640668631,
0.7353574038,
-0.2840224504,
-0.4540404379,
0.2598649859,
-0.0513055734,
-0.2395642549,
0.5421850085,
-0.9663879275,
0.5859316587,
-0.0439740382,
-0.4924307764,
-0.2949115932,
-0.8021336794,
0.0561726876,
-0.270391047,
0.3774427772,
0.057793919,
0.1076150239,
1.250767827,
-0.6764944196,
0.8267906308,
-0.5140194893,
0.2457591295,
0.5083179474,
-0.2592949569,
0.3530849516,
-0.0980252922,
-0.5170565248,
0.0296759903,
-0.1113406494,
-0.7135335207,
-0.5482950211,
0.5081540942,
-1.0911240578,
-0.5409485102,
-0.153049469,
-0.5757062435,
-0.3523928821,
0.1048791707,
0.041494213,
0.500169456,
0.1363479197,
0.3205921948,
0.3460148275,
0.3566158414,
0.2446818352,
0.5433823466,
-0.0903156176,
-0.4677914381,
1.0271040201,
0.4789307415,
0.2381777763,
0.1979435086,
0.2038025558,
-0.1446088254,
-0.1091273129,
-0.6583381891,
-0.0335883275,
-0.640345037,
-0.3448225558,
-0.4331739843,
0.1980857551,
-0.2006029785,
-0.3799529374,
-0.0675571486,
-0.6011962891,
-0.2830307484,
-0.4895678461,
0.1103860959,
0.9164459705,
-0.3058482707,
0.0953425318,
-0.4636692405,
0.0450213552,
0.6837403774,
0.2363603115,
0.4360390902,
-0.4458383024,
-0.376452148,
0.03978993,
-0.3600609303,
-0.5628935695,
0.0561117195,
-0.1160130575,
0.4138217866,
0.5648877025,
0.4448466301,
0.7534311414,
0.0263939966,
0.5104711056,
0.1226421222,
-0.6151841283,
0.2474749088,
-0.0271771159,
0.175759986,
0.8572731614,
0.215838626,
-0.5843122602,
-0.6342684031,
-0.4340713322,
-0.6705664396,
0.8386548758,
0.1088500991,
-0.0256506391,
0.4274728894,
0.2082686275,
0.4079174399,
0.1036407277,
-0.2011213899,
-0.2811220288,
-0.33244735,
-0.0442818478,
-0.318238467,
0.037045598,
-0.1271218508,
-0.4347384274,
0.3859461844,
-0.0031829835,
-0.3813296258,
0.1912057102,
-0.1300019175,
-0.2442920953,
0.4308265746,
-0.0660651177,
0.6786805391,
0.0411046557,
0.167510286,
0.4735661447,
-0.5942492485,
0.2856391072,
0.1655463278,
-0.0827621594,
-0.1537852585,
0.5675753355,
0.4025516808,
0.0511921309,
-0.64409554,
0.4589729309,
-0.2296421826,
-0.3309292495,
0.1526581794,
0.1164826006,
-0.1941561699,
0.3454865515,
0.4643176794,
0.6273390651,
0.1972249746,
-0.1635915488,
0.3173566461,
-0.085779272,
-0.5104675293,
-0.2387491167,
0.5405766964,
0.561219573,
-0.4445758164,
0.9758328795,
0.2365355343,
-0.5459503531,
0.9255754352,
0.1862944216,
0.5255376101,
-0.2908430696,
0.4314356744,
0.369920224,
0.0788522959,
-0.33216241,
0.0961854458,
-0.3184013367,
-0.4051769376,
-0.1477683634,
-0.2124329507,
-0.9534220695,
-0.4794093668,
-1.2206213474,
0.0259379037,
-0.2164222896,
-0.5215658545,
-0.1814564317,
0.3130586147,
-0.7568284869,
0.6019740105,
-0.0475342125,
0.6622231603,
-1.0445435047,
0.5991815329,
1.1640197039,
-0.1881654412,
-0.9902883768,
-0.1291732192,
-0.0137093412,
-0.2919851243,
0.3610714078,
0.3952123821,
0.0773275644,
-0.1034824327,
-0.3757825196,
-0.5396383405,
0.9124808908,
0.0765220076,
-0.9756994843,
0.1175269336,
-0.0075978357,
0.6494316459,
0.0303715672,
0.7423386574,
0.3708410263,
0.7474966049,
-0.0825670883,
-0.9331507683,
-0.1507021189,
-0.344086796,
-0.3092369139,
0.1968778968,
-0.8660664558,
0.7448803782,
-0.5870237947,
0.1030053422,
-0.2295389026,
0.7239125967,
0.2071554959,
0.8028624058,
0.7829485536,
0.6368422508,
1.2467933893,
-0.0365950055,
0.8878480792,
-0.0671262965,
0.4153700471,
1.0241661072,
-0.0080509307,
0.8396773338,
0.3809266984,
-0.6496426463,
0.4874408543,
0.80274266,
-0.3013015985,
0.1545564532,
0.3719166517,
-0.11059957,
-0.5187500715,
-0.2103150785,
-0.3737757206,
0.257174015,
-0.1816399992,
-0.0656204522,
-0.0214054175,
0.2756454051,
-0.0596833602,
0.1586923599,
-0.5519014001,
0.5894989371,
0.003526133,
-0.7036206126,
0.1776112169,
-0.0887570754,
0.6368965507,
0.0689301193,
0.1170890853,
-0.2486707121,
0.2797371447,
-0.5033087134,
-0.726675272,
-0.0380408466,
0.3773539662,
-0.4140218496,
-0.1609905958,
0.5627526641,
-0.285639137,
-0.5814592838,
0.1633030474,
0.5818111897,
0.395026356,
-0.0373273641,
-0.4358240068,
-0.3044894338,
-0.1298090816,
-0.3010571003,
0.412709713,
0.3906771541,
-0.2000901401,
0.7382761836,
0.707084775,
-0.0057891752,
0.0495531857,
0.391261369,
1.0017720461,
-0.4956049621,
-0.2559060752,
-0.6181408167,
0.4010928273,
-0.0976281911,
-0.2925112545,
0.8651769161,
0.7336998582,
1.196564436,
0.0779412314,
0.8200438023,
0.092830956,
0.5115059018,
0.1554862112,
0.6018615961,
-0.347202301,
-0.048778791,
-0.2905545831,
-0.7840484977,
-0.1782410592,
0.4116267264,
-0.6059316993,
0.1213295013,
0.4122685492,
0.2386508435,
0.2638451457,
0.1957956105,
0.2418650538,
-0.134187758,
0.2312499434,
0.4028088152,
1.0451740026,
-0.1334522814,
0.6873537302,
-0.5497754812,
-0.5691028237,
-0.2820663154,
-0.0506567284,
-1.215755105,
-0.382602036,
-0.3295383751,
-0.1573217809,
-0.0675582066,
0.6754871011,
0.8189478517,
-0.736646533,
-0.4407992661,
0.5320221186,
0.28126508,
-0.3244845867,
-0.2994386554,
0.2266670316,
-0.092932649,
-0.8247185946,
0.1006829366,
-0.1185191423,
-0.0658514127,
-0.4082510769,
-0.062543422,
0.3017766476,
0.1090402976,
0.4157037735,
0.0454618111,
-0.4573182166,
-0.1414190382,
-0.2902005315,
-0.1991787404,
-0.0016678001,
0.7367759943,
-1.1827952862,
0.6613012552,
0.585621655,
0.5171228051,
0.1965561956,
0.5320692062,
0.249613747,
-0.1003815159,
-0.2434902191,
0.2201427966,
0.0914675742,
0.4871442318,
-0.2342379689,
0.6303929687,
0.1894683838,
-0.8579451442,
-0.9169472456,
-0.2378128916,
-0.4845638871,
-0.2747086883,
0.5707851648,
-0.3925545216,
-0.0065439357,
-0.1483716816,
-0.275932759,
0.0918298066,
-0.5477361679,
1.17633605,
0.8375365734,
-0.1810504496,
0.3373065293,
-0.2836843431,
-0.2039763778,
0.4126190245,
-0.8164356351,
-0.2211125195,
0.3040926158,
0.1912784129,
0.1382804066,
0.2514277995,
0.169903174,
0.1376260519,
0.015551459,
-0.0446059927,
-0.0995375663,
-0.2523992658,
-0.2591581047,
0.4832293987,
-0.1317632198,
-0.3178673387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12880v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12880v1 | Yes, this Way! Learning to Ground Referring Expressions into Actions with Intra-episodic Feedback from Supportive Teachers | 2023-05-22T10:01:15 | 2023-05-22T10:01:15 | Philipp Sadler, Sherzod Hakimov, David Schlangen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | The ability to pick up on language signals in an ongoing interaction is
crucial for future machine learning models to collaborate and interact with
humans naturally. In this paper, we present an initial study that evaluates
intra-episodic feedback given in a collaborative setting. We use a referential
language game as a controllable example of a task-oriented collaborative joint
activity. A teacher utters a referring expression generated by a well-known
symbolic algorithm (the "Incremental Algorithm") as an initial instruction and
then monitors the follower's actions to possibly intervene with intra-episodic
feedback (which does not explicitly have to be requested). We frame this task
as a reinforcement learning problem with sparse rewards and learn a follower
policy for a heuristic teacher. Our results show that intra-episodic feedback
allows the follower to generalize on aspects of scene complexity and performs
better than providing only the initial statement. | [
0.0247992612,
-0.6145430803,
0.5673565269,
0.3276957273,
-0.1562819481,
-0.1242516488,
-0.4514674544,
-0.0211897809,
0.2333109528,
0.227620855,
-0.7930131555,
-0.4125414789,
-0.7064602971,
0.1064286157,
-0.0210625511,
0.9772112966,
-0.1500989497,
0.473310858,
-0.4376826584,
-0.3313790858,
-0.6536125541,
-0.6548451781,
-0.6523364186,
-0.5091513991,
0.5746824145,
0.5643216372,
0.4824849367,
0.3951030076,
0.4105297327,
0.4701483548,
0.3364325464,
0.1725742519,
-0.6574239731,
0.3857782185,
-0.3716730475,
-0.4784825742,
0.2806955278,
0.0692791641,
0.5166168213,
0.9744079113,
-0.4922929704,
0.1164950356,
0.289486438,
0.4562489092,
-0.3643049002,
0.5025777817,
-0.2961027622,
0.25729689,
0.400289923,
-0.3015223145,
-0.5742482543,
-0.3835713565,
0.2780086398,
-0.6535139084,
-0.0987817347,
-0.0307515152,
0.8378787041,
0.4006479979,
0.2378823012,
-0.4726714492,
-0.7687942386,
0.741384089,
-0.0923125744,
0.1993633062,
0.7896333337,
0.1068895087,
-0.1740235835,
-0.7321854234,
-0.4660937488,
-0.4390812516,
-0.0971322209,
0.1803060919,
-0.111478515,
-0.0598103516,
0.3283920884,
-0.0009270926,
0.0410460532,
-0.2014567852,
-0.4521887004,
0.0702119172,
0.0393516161,
0.3000287712,
0.1777006239,
0.1877501756,
-0.2698306441,
-0.1792518198,
-0.6883268952,
0.3312157094,
-0.0193360876,
0.3576678634,
-0.1897815168,
0.3571096659,
-0.0266747139,
0.5023413301,
0.5478064418,
0.2836433947,
-0.1740289032,
-0.1892221868,
-0.0989514068,
0.0245829523,
0.4647158384,
0.2498139739,
0.1199890226,
-0.5259743333,
-0.0229240991,
0.4031710029,
0.419690311,
-0.4919148982,
-0.4561258852,
-0.2262195349,
-0.2246791273,
-0.0865563974,
0.1607379317,
-0.3827676773,
-0.2570728362,
-0.4418153763,
0.5646508932,
-0.3623948991,
-0.1395749003,
-0.3339104354,
0.1283777207,
0.0523438603,
0.6254088879,
-0.7994138598,
0.6477969289,
0.6455927491,
0.7945147753,
0.1700303257,
-0.701172173,
-1.1441605091,
0.3672866821,
-0.3166287839,
0.7641423345,
-0.7855308056,
-0.5372494459,
0.0063758306,
-0.0408478528,
-0.0560594834,
-0.7426194549,
-0.1226394325,
-0.2174490094,
0.5583410859,
-0.2007036954,
-0.4540297687,
0.0236687995,
0.441868484,
-0.4977033436,
0.8160337806,
0.3342599869,
-0.2990646362,
0.3111530244,
-0.3648117185,
-0.3041177094,
0.1659382731,
-0.5285462737,
-0.3013632894,
0.0540498309,
0.1064367369,
0.3219654262,
-0.2101621777,
-0.0505578369,
-0.3130773008,
-0.5671899319,
0.0965975225,
0.1332576722,
0.4988057911,
-0.1985038072,
-0.4959441125,
0.4610514045,
-0.1348676383,
0.1584823579,
-0.0638170093,
-0.3924711049,
-0.4589349627,
-0.0566850528,
-0.5907024741,
0.2581441998,
-0.0861936137,
-0.2375829369,
0.2225083858,
0.0583503097,
0.0100311618,
0.9367287755,
0.2459733933,
0.36589095,
-0.5401114225,
0.5294122696,
-0.0971777439,
0.0193114728,
-0.4345200956,
-0.4335880876,
-0.6450343728,
-0.1932406873,
-0.0037540458,
0.2568011284,
-1.0091890097,
0.2615651488,
-0.2460814714,
0.0330630988,
-0.5844302773,
0.1743586063,
0.7353336811,
0.3283095658,
0.188480407,
-0.5357319713,
-0.4877978265,
-0.2135254741,
0.203344211,
-0.479871124,
-0.0552752614,
0.3620260954,
0.1455249935,
0.2246970385,
0.7524507642,
-0.3093841672,
-0.3507237136,
-0.1596287936,
0.3413412571,
-0.0706087947,
0.3254077137,
0.2571716011,
-0.4873908758,
-0.725738585,
-0.0740420222,
-0.8891531825,
0.0184655264,
-0.1434171349,
-0.1436428279,
-0.0713210627,
0.5329207182,
-0.3262804449,
0.1083048284,
0.4616316557,
-0.6122633219,
0.1277299076,
-0.3843460679,
0.1730492115,
-0.7543076277,
-0.2926935852,
0.0073609715,
-0.3870676458,
-0.3500252068,
0.2873369455,
-0.4236920178,
0.0831742957,
-0.2015386373,
-0.0848803595,
-0.5520640612,
-0.1306584626,
-0.2305959463,
-0.009704357,
-0.5295132399,
1.0016747713,
0.4637516439,
0.6665375233,
0.5060382485,
-0.6195706129,
0.3967728615,
0.2078929543,
-0.2852139175,
0.8859601617,
-0.4587715268,
0.3700922728,
-0.0230103713,
0.095882453,
-0.739615202,
0.1152921617,
0.4107438326,
-0.5474183559,
0.0978854969,
-0.0762445554,
-0.6639758945,
-0.1217427999,
-0.1259884387,
-0.3527262807,
0.4333480895,
-0.5593453646,
0.3007420301,
0.477519542,
-0.000286088,
-0.2244029492,
-0.143681705,
-0.1077273041,
0.1489024609,
-0.1458224952,
0.0242567919,
-0.1605444103,
-0.3090858757,
0.3454675674,
0.0757448748,
-0.2014945596,
0.0213258173,
0.6350661516,
0.1671113819,
0.0000926018,
-0.050100863,
-0.2643873692,
-0.1381104589,
0.1356511116,
-0.1827468127,
0.6218257546,
-0.3406593204,
-0.3456532359,
-0.3276293874,
0.4296045303,
0.2055660188,
0.3441283107,
0.4664318562,
0.4317097962,
-0.4095691144,
-0.20888412,
0.0610152893,
-0.5540809035,
-0.4559610784,
0.3904058635,
-0.3873487115,
-0.8108428717,
0.1083953232,
-0.4331452847,
0.0394289009,
-0.0317422524,
0.6203985214,
-0.3033028245,
0.7537199259,
0.9185878038,
0.0039384877,
0.499962002,
-0.3238242865,
-0.2037326097,
-0.6012099981,
-0.296028465,
-0.4115842581,
-0.3501042724,
-0.1313724369,
-0.4578211606,
0.4321773648,
0.3287828267,
-0.3019091189,
0.5412030816,
-0.3951438665,
0.5746669173,
0.6133241057,
0.4308391511,
0.1006735861,
0.1783923954,
-0.4609257281,
-0.2885591686,
-0.77711308,
-0.0853284076,
0.5083069801,
0.1901088953,
0.5616643429,
0.3710337281,
0.8193705082,
0.1414073259,
0.9288011789,
-0.6933360696,
0.7433558702,
0.0619177446,
0.0551702306,
-0.3819313645,
-0.340010941,
-0.8872380853,
0.3441793025,
-0.1624330282,
-0.7165161371,
-0.1643291265,
0.0280930381,
-0.4149297774,
0.1017048061,
-0.5823035836,
0.6373807788,
0.1349898875,
-0.8252227306,
-0.7167583704,
-0.583922565,
-0.2480603606,
0.4293323457,
0.0928877294,
0.2683628201,
-0.0177924857,
0.3612795174,
-0.6580518484,
1.225541234,
-0.3756426573,
0.0871019885,
0.4516887069,
0.2689255476,
0.5804024935,
-0.1464969665,
0.2653572559,
-0.1806739122,
-0.2682906687,
-0.218916446,
-0.9581601024,
0.7153683901,
-0.9327300787,
-0.6582813859,
-0.3652801514,
-0.2912947237,
-0.3801790178,
-0.1998853236,
0.1308047026,
0.3008241057,
0.0699350908,
0.0328890868,
0.4788732529,
0.1298350394,
0.3934170604,
0.8224139214,
-0.1640275866,
-0.574118495,
1.1427674294,
-0.0807028711,
0.2835106254,
0.4654572308,
0.3137084544,
0.0343999825,
-0.1802382469,
-0.643456161,
0.1299999952,
-0.7594392896,
0.0124378139,
-0.2573891282,
0.2180968672,
0.0149906138,
-0.3079716265,
0.0089278445,
-0.1523084939,
-0.1290972829,
-0.0740446821,
0.1400276572,
1.0652043819,
-0.1599102616,
0.2526153028,
-0.9598074555,
-0.1509776711,
0.3992483914,
0.2067237794,
0.1840610206,
-0.297598511,
-0.4141528904,
-0.1709584445,
-0.3444642425,
-0.9197533131,
0.075126797,
0.0598944537,
0.478829056,
0.2944424748,
-0.0579118095,
0.9239257574,
-0.5366845131,
0.8523579836,
0.4627303481,
-0.733682394,
0.2860416472,
-0.2494373322,
0.5031847954,
0.539034307,
0.687306881,
-0.7602913976,
-0.4742102623,
-0.5853573084,
-0.7412473559,
1.0191982985,
-0.0459194519,
0.1757056117,
-0.2134495378,
0.2495666295,
-0.00445543,
0.4440369308,
-0.747048676,
-0.3226415813,
-0.0134050427,
-0.0602284223,
0.2791773677,
0.1067752838,
-0.4024868309,
-0.2470180988,
0.4413605332,
-0.158142671,
0.644364059,
0.2304601073,
-0.1602990776,
-0.6744835377,
-0.0959437713,
0.345790565,
0.3354500234,
0.1080065519,
0.0786641091,
0.2054415047,
-0.4270062447,
0.1035627648,
-0.3306511343,
0.019766314,
-0.052014228,
0.5926655531,
0.7179314494,
0.6125139594,
-0.4890761375,
0.6349161267,
0.0419442095,
-0.1816490144,
-0.3060853481,
0.0026260959,
-0.1373848766,
0.3005529046,
0.1849523485,
0.046416387,
-0.1231398806,
-0.9342777133,
0.5669156909,
0.1510775238,
-0.9377816319,
-0.5521663427,
0.2470727861,
0.1883823276,
-0.5011447668,
0.7801811099,
-0.200345546,
-0.7593809366,
0.5150851607,
0.7570176125,
0.9969402552,
-0.1942777783,
0.4925656319,
0.3685215414,
0.0517796203,
-0.0943519026,
0.3599372208,
-0.6818081141,
-0.6281377673,
-0.5571942329,
-0.0220981464,
-0.8489018083,
-0.2392896712,
-0.6622584462,
0.0134606929,
-0.8247224092,
0.1230264604,
-0.1820658296,
-0.1316435486,
-0.5084273815,
-0.1276434362,
0.131460771,
0.1376724541,
-0.5637149811,
0.9800254703,
1.1179929972,
-0.7914206386,
-1.029684186,
0.2721002102,
-0.113207154,
-0.728975594,
1.1479519606,
0.1430010647,
-0.3405239284,
-0.0754148811,
-0.6634733677,
-0.5894398093,
0.8910058737,
0.1113393158,
-0.4256616533,
-0.0713178739,
-0.1407013386,
0.8030906916,
-0.3533612788,
0.5672457218,
-0.0887306929,
0.1806593686,
0.2047365457,
-0.9769166708,
0.1404638886,
-0.2411672622,
-0.1170461923,
0.2748003602,
-0.8496214151,
0.746147275,
-0.4385724664,
-0.4338743687,
0.1167757362,
1.0221326351,
-0.059610229,
0.1005542576,
0.7302678227,
0.5382612944,
0.5642394423,
0.0057005812,
0.985224545,
-0.2559697926,
0.2077306062,
1.2660065889,
-0.424439162,
0.9823420048,
0.5685116649,
-0.4104411304,
0.9518544078,
0.282048434,
0.2186119854,
0.9151675701,
0.3189692795,
-0.5750678182,
-0.2426512539,
-0.2824087143,
0.183501035,
-0.1522258222,
0.5365974307,
-0.0947253853,
-0.4757851064,
0.1287636459,
-0.183260411,
0.6306797862,
-0.5677070022,
0.9950280786,
0.0654481798,
-1.0088671446,
0.263985306,
-0.0917801261,
0.5760439634,
-0.6341362596,
-0.7094929814,
0.0570605136,
0.4086531997,
-0.047893703,
-0.7301722765,
0.3856242299,
-0.2866923809,
-0.0946288854,
-0.4473665059,
0.1681607962,
-0.6793318987,
0.2126966268,
0.3770511448,
0.2904422283,
0.0765046328,
0.3081074953,
-0.5280573964,
-0.1532436609,
-0.055843588,
0.0640249997,
0.546671629,
0.3916586041,
-0.3298872709,
0.5136791468,
0.5582590699,
-0.0150396219,
-0.0650628656,
0.0824610963,
0.8945729733,
-0.439753145,
-0.5998668075,
-0.5825185776,
0.1774090379,
0.0501016304,
-0.375963062,
0.7704348564,
0.151485458,
1.2010705471,
-0.2011618912,
0.6105898023,
-0.1053806841,
0.4718640745,
-0.3308224678,
-0.0103182318,
0.0462458655,
0.0413990021,
-0.2508509755,
-0.5806706548,
-0.1421472877,
0.9405739903,
-0.2949836254,
-0.2085273713,
0.9207263589,
0.4223956764,
0.2950302362,
0.1542426348,
0.4690621793,
0.0153001249,
0.0066049835,
0.6646360755,
0.9679400921,
-0.1377748102,
0.5115694404,
-0.5318844914,
-0.2227101624,
0.1967273057,
-0.4192965329,
-0.8647017479,
-0.8182214499,
-0.3592675924,
-0.6775438786,
0.4602762759,
1.6281079054,
0.6598371267,
-0.6784542799,
-0.5006287694,
-0.2684721649,
0.113059327,
-0.7985110283,
-0.2335017771,
0.2172049135,
-0.424923569,
-0.9707840681,
0.3116141856,
0.1804051548,
-0.2945477068,
-0.4434733689,
-0.5455206037,
-0.0451097079,
-0.2437841147,
0.616704464,
0.3627221286,
-0.4782868922,
-0.22715047,
0.0657747686,
-0.2573439777,
-0.0153908143,
1.2639868259,
-0.9284421206,
0.3393127322,
0.302826941,
0.710514009,
0.3575741649,
-0.1150183827,
0.7552825809,
-0.8174766898,
0.158714518,
0.1923830658,
0.2439998686,
0.2865689397,
-0.4408088923,
0.5857117176,
0.4669517577,
-0.3755759895,
-0.5588133931,
0.1169900447,
-0.4830912054,
-0.1507095397,
0.9701376557,
-0.7060860991,
-0.3259652555,
0.0152533092,
-0.2454829216,
0.0617878959,
-0.4591307044,
0.7725619078,
0.8552986979,
-0.1049537212,
-0.4916020334,
-0.0058737257,
0.3832444549,
0.6814383268,
-0.6384278536,
-0.2002930045,
0.7594761252,
0.052861657,
0.2636272907,
0.8770852089,
0.1190400794,
0.5768486261,
0.1523798555,
-0.0817067102,
-0.1568717808,
-0.6047659516,
-0.4103887975,
0.2596777678,
0.2499295622,
-0.4965363741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12878v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12878v3 | Non-Autoregressive Document-Level Machine Translation | 2023-05-22T09:59:59 | 2023-12-09T11:31:32 | Guangsheng Bao, Zhiyang Teng, Hao Zhou, Jianhao Yan, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Non-autoregressive translation (NAT) models achieve comparable performance
and superior speed compared to auto-regressive translation (AT) models in the
context of sentence-level machine translation (MT). However, their abilities
are unexplored in document-level MT, hindering their usage in real scenarios.
In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive examination of typical NAT models in
the context of document-level MT and further propose a simple but effective
design of sentence alignment between source and target. Experiments show that
NAT models achieve high acceleration on documents, and sentence alignment
significantly enhances their performance.
However, current NAT models still have a significant performance gap compared
to their AT counterparts. Further investigation reveals that NAT models suffer
more from the multi-modality and misalignment issues in the context of
document-level MT, and current NAT models struggle with exploiting document
context and handling discourse phenomena. We delve into these challenges and
provide our code at \url{https://github.com/baoguangsheng/nat-on-doc}. | [
-0.1663872749,
-0.8709836602,
0.2731014192,
0.2198011577,
-0.3580869138,
0.2556675076,
0.188381657,
-0.6324861646,
-0.0181068517,
0.5867962241,
-0.4236521721,
-0.3095081449,
-0.7193832994,
0.3665629327,
-0.8507054448,
0.8345829844,
-0.3247538507,
-0.2207877338,
-0.1186659038,
-0.1129584089,
-0.514041543,
-0.3828714192,
-0.4539830387,
-0.216117993,
0.0920432284,
0.1757411361,
0.7951486111,
0.861552,
0.7446578741,
0.2728212178,
-0.075543046,
0.4198719263,
-0.3013704121,
0.3223240972,
-0.1064136848,
-0.2253344357,
-0.6101984978,
0.0282492731,
0.8215272427,
0.4933206141,
0.1188832372,
-0.0575258732,
-0.0633689314,
0.6507821679,
-0.1471330673,
-0.0154415062,
-0.5408143401,
0.021241216,
-0.2758528292,
-0.2032302022,
-0.5237134099,
-0.4600269496,
0.1155834273,
-0.5096401572,
0.3364196718,
0.4668829441,
1.0969218016,
0.5304217339,
-0.8531833887,
0.0268447939,
-0.6774106622,
0.5307930708,
-0.8163083792,
0.36591959,
0.1797452867,
0.0808211267,
-0.1723155081,
-0.4044266045,
-0.3176831305,
-0.1235374957,
-0.2566473484,
0.0424880907,
-0.4481463432,
0.0385271311,
0.1860941947,
0.6071228385,
-0.8420112133,
0.2825779617,
-0.13637124,
-0.0166634321,
0.425018698,
0.2962493002,
0.2590578198,
-0.4734587669,
-0.4570789337,
0.232994929,
-0.4954892695,
-0.129597947,
0.4281735122,
0.4314816892,
-0.1802187562,
0.7742412686,
-0.1776352376,
1.1782176495,
0.3337037265,
0.1554300487,
0.2457618266,
-0.6621419787,
-0.0615306087,
-0.1209754795,
1.0573022366,
0.1872954369,
-0.1470360458,
-0.3299769461,
-0.2887324691,
-0.2598175406,
0.5568346977,
-0.5889226198,
0.0983385518,
0.0890162811,
-0.4738066792,
-0.5312647223,
-0.207204029,
-0.7602674365,
0.0080852602,
-0.2150054425,
0.2379373759,
-0.4724674225,
-0.2169356495,
-0.168772608,
0.0625484586,
0.2065959275,
0.2570202947,
-0.656281054,
0.2049696296,
0.6200590134,
1.2643791437,
-0.3426169157,
-0.1955937892,
-0.5780761242,
-0.0521810576,
-0.6422080994,
0.7506988049,
-0.3097060919,
-0.3408576846,
-0.2421890646,
0.0757535174,
-0.372733593,
-0.2073808163,
0.5568475723,
-0.5368934274,
0.5618383288,
-0.1315114647,
-0.5282421708,
-0.0599973984,
0.2517277896,
-0.6301397681,
0.9129167199,
0.240909785,
-0.8389673233,
-0.0808857828,
-1.0287492275,
-0.718254745,
-0.1550465375,
0.3863427341,
-0.4102468491,
0.5053941607,
0.0691493377,
-0.0218288042,
-0.3003641069,
0.5670871735,
0.1072309315,
-0.2477227449,
0.2605470419,
-0.6543911099,
0.7743099928,
0.3751830459,
-0.4610779285,
0.1695330292,
-0.684186995,
-0.1300614923,
0.083887063,
-0.2434468716,
-0.2833417952,
-0.1935497969,
-0.0579523966,
0.627702713,
0.2032183558,
-0.3905983567,
0.2748864591,
-0.4959388673,
0.4859921634,
0.5409371257,
-0.1207131967,
0.6394864917,
-0.2603330016,
0.6154891253,
-0.0262059085,
0.1217222437,
-0.0784819052,
-0.4936942756,
-0.6293526888,
-0.0521380119,
0.6364138722,
0.5355289578,
-0.8854202628,
0.3701961637,
-0.3234129548,
-0.3537339568,
-0.7571825981,
0.0008934407,
0.6491898298,
1.0627150536,
0.5867083669,
-0.3305844367,
-0.1962503493,
-0.965601325,
-0.2390647829,
-0.1847103089,
0.1194289774,
0.0065391324,
0.3069984317,
0.0581756607,
0.8645581007,
-0.1933600605,
-0.147679165,
-0.0952572897,
0.7073403001,
-0.0942965671,
0.5758915544,
0.297281146,
-0.8056643009,
-0.5496221781,
-0.0008396936,
-0.8610208631,
-0.6055300236,
-0.1881543249,
-0.3166666329,
0.6543852091,
0.4813689888,
-0.5293868184,
0.4282074869,
0.7141812444,
-0.2892154753,
0.296638459,
-0.3804534376,
0.1352425516,
-1.1110131741,
0.4586437345,
0.0761348903,
-0.5116187334,
-0.8328235745,
0.0838311985,
0.4047934711,
-0.2160731703,
-0.5523569584,
0.3989430368,
-0.7448395491,
-0.2383376807,
-0.6706483364,
0.1885642558,
0.4337916672,
0.2425865531,
0.1928186566,
0.9234975576,
0.1974594444,
-0.535502851,
0.1798132658,
0.3703763187,
-0.0852906927,
0.8663441539,
-0.6416025758,
0.131353423,
-0.0170961842,
0.3577754796,
-0.7949417233,
0.0761502981,
0.3435220122,
-0.5226719379,
0.673638463,
-0.0261699613,
-0.701246798,
-0.3036157191,
0.0535633117,
0.4053395689,
0.3145846725,
-0.2317657322,
0.49342224,
0.2479566485,
0.0691402107,
-0.5337316394,
-0.7670146227,
0.5449448228,
-0.2313122004,
-0.5869504809,
0.5567674637,
0.1225865409,
-0.1093995124,
0.1279292107,
-0.0925354958,
-0.0757343769,
0.1253075302,
-0.0309416205,
0.3457735479,
-0.3049905896,
0.0919190198,
0.035311617,
-0.3108584285,
-0.1213271692,
-0.4975821078,
0.4173234403,
-0.2471572459,
-0.3188963234,
-0.5558558106,
0.6028543115,
0.6730002165,
-0.4356966913,
0.8699760437,
0.4789894819,
-0.2758169174,
0.3139843941,
-0.4769100845,
0.194584325,
-0.3866487443,
0.1887584329,
-0.3678341508,
-0.5425304174,
0.2381832004,
0.0110944677,
0.1807626039,
0.5786588788,
0.25443995,
-0.0630639866,
0.7986136079,
0.6255813241,
-0.0720535964,
0.4385911822,
-0.1084674224,
0.3979750276,
-1.3109166622,
-0.0705140978,
-0.555273056,
-0.3921931684,
-0.579113543,
-0.3867886662,
0.0069112377,
-0.0184401851,
-0.0041842014,
0.8340829015,
-0.5540961027,
0.1920754313,
0.463455379,
-0.4428763092,
0.4324486852,
-0.3289128542,
-0.1506751627,
-0.0357628763,
-0.7449545264,
-0.5170778632,
0.7388389111,
0.1542614996,
0.5584205389,
0.2209481299,
0.4437427819,
0.2499704212,
0.1324445754,
-0.6253454685,
0.3559450507,
-0.2687074542,
-0.8103482127,
-0.2636978328,
-0.6743994355,
-1.0418634415,
0.3855203986,
-0.0441191271,
-0.4879432917,
0.248616606,
0.0980462357,
-0.1937062293,
0.4267124832,
-0.5834268332,
1.0874326229,
-0.6949287653,
-0.4458245039,
0.3844706118,
-1.0086214542,
0.240934521,
-0.3195282817,
0.208017841,
0.0939523652,
-0.0960500613,
0.1683714241,
-0.4476165473,
0.6817619801,
-0.031038763,
-0.1643664837,
0.2723349333,
0.3309477568,
0.5651331544,
-0.3729703128,
-0.1697404683,
0.2855238318,
-0.3200052679,
-0.2873575985,
-0.3638837337,
0.6458870173,
-0.5805017948,
-0.5997789502,
-0.5089086294,
-0.8182001114,
-0.1051741913,
0.4390372038,
0.3608222604,
0.3969558179,
-0.3394783735,
0.1160862446,
0.7304278016,
-0.152992025,
0.510263741,
0.7663561106,
-0.1143101379,
-0.2543546259,
0.8811431527,
0.2326445132,
0.6408643723,
0.6450230479,
0.0526830889,
-0.5688587427,
-0.5870690942,
-0.7262004018,
0.1211900488,
-0.4292219877,
-0.2421797365,
-1.0229730606,
-0.2553411126,
-0.6173936725,
-0.1909526736,
-0.458322525,
-0.6448284388,
-0.5096693635,
-0.091848582,
0.0816204846,
0.5475831032,
-0.123959966,
0.3815950751,
-0.7669911981,
0.4367097318,
-0.1428913623,
0.1255423576,
-0.2429426014,
-0.7179850936,
-0.1596548408,
-0.1151860133,
-0.590124011,
-0.9066010118,
0.7178827524,
-0.0756681785,
0.3906150758,
0.1848035902,
0.2500883043,
0.6014050245,
-0.5623849034,
0.7235509753,
0.0963425934,
-1.1454070807,
0.4048487842,
-0.5183346868,
0.6382638812,
0.555357933,
0.2529318035,
-0.6832822561,
-0.5683199763,
-0.5717432499,
-0.9637311101,
0.723064959,
0.4035405815,
-0.0338162296,
0.026741093,
0.2768988013,
0.0562686957,
0.5062094927,
-0.8281114101,
-0.0424322784,
-0.4455675483,
-0.1143817976,
-0.115150325,
-0.0106452657,
0.1083730087,
0.0573789813,
0.7571060658,
-0.0911957398,
0.2933438122,
0.1742994785,
-0.3093019128,
-0.4877896905,
0.1673507541,
0.8365483284,
0.3726774454,
-0.1821757257,
0.0429683365,
0.0406257883,
0.1333143711,
0.29387784,
0.2349457294,
-0.4290508032,
0.2124901265,
0.2756472826,
0.9074605107,
0.1780819744,
-0.0303894915,
0.480260849,
-0.0853316635,
-0.2401823848,
0.0733995289,
-0.2974275947,
0.1756257713,
0.0019667803,
0.0785999447,
0.2053797543,
0.0291453805,
-0.3988586962,
-0.0398023687,
0.5706463456,
-0.3702169359,
-0.2282636464,
0.946860373,
0.3442408144,
-0.6723952293,
0.7740624547,
-0.223845765,
-0.5702435374,
0.440597713,
0.8271768689,
0.9035993218,
-0.1968663484,
0.3088642359,
0.0877466574,
0.571987927,
-0.1456933618,
-0.1505662352,
0.0685120076,
-0.2378666848,
-0.3730721176,
-0.3808500171,
-0.3646592498,
-0.0589835308,
-0.5055788755,
0.1414793283,
-0.0610976554,
-0.3069627285,
-0.3125081956,
-0.0594447702,
-0.3877965808,
0.0547123291,
-0.0364220925,
0.7198800445,
-0.797775209,
0.9061600566,
0.4216281474,
-0.3684215844,
-0.3460015953,
0.1618081629,
0.085047178,
-0.4302577972,
0.501024425,
0.0779079199,
-0.1831440628,
0.0053742887,
-0.2053817809,
-1.1626945734,
0.8381273746,
0.3552727699,
-0.386356771,
-0.4214501679,
0.2958294153,
0.7849864364,
-0.3490144014,
0.0086235395,
0.1019755155,
0.5399605632,
0.0307220221,
-1.0046263933,
0.0524112023,
-0.2638319731,
0.3274231851,
0.4566737711,
-0.9382272959,
0.8229496479,
0.3055348992,
-0.1749240756,
0.0274718627,
0.6148074865,
-0.2534073591,
0.3057835698,
0.2465699315,
0.5938988328,
0.6239482164,
-0.1773625612,
1.0374363661,
-0.4473381937,
0.0227085873,
1.2256264687,
-0.3142343163,
0.4868913293,
0.4435811937,
0.2973565757,
0.3589912653,
0.6183909774,
0.0358717255,
0.5702528954,
0.1735942215,
0.0477055162,
-0.0681074783,
-0.2163631171,
-0.4780484736,
0.3813195825,
0.0680465326,
-0.518461585,
-0.2030346096,
-0.1698606163,
-0.0615957454,
-0.0287274998,
0.0406496786,
0.7771813273,
0.1156600788,
-0.9143356085,
0.5809735656,
0.3215705454,
0.5300213695,
-0.5152339935,
0.2495596856,
-0.2726062536,
-0.153192088,
-0.0755682141,
-0.408860743,
0.8546772003,
0.2730432749,
-0.1279300004,
-0.5968782306,
0.6025785804,
-0.2496602535,
-0.4896362126,
0.1795024127,
0.7304387689,
0.1694651097,
0.1461764127,
-0.7726858854,
-0.0594005659,
-0.1167882979,
-0.1671020985,
0.4116283953,
0.7356030941,
-0.1407267153,
0.4307897985,
0.5947974324,
-0.0871345028,
0.1411159486,
-0.2697094977,
0.488658756,
-0.5601980686,
-0.3654335737,
-0.8658438921,
0.4321746826,
-0.1194790229,
-0.3188753724,
0.7964565754,
0.6495939493,
0.5515689254,
0.3395107388,
0.5425410271,
0.0201468151,
0.2131265402,
-0.366029501,
0.6113030314,
-0.724342525,
0.0102676786,
-0.4043114781,
-0.8377725482,
-0.3184130192,
0.5136488676,
-0.2898871303,
-0.2782802582,
0.9843937755,
0.3612938523,
-0.0508788079,
-0.0018116153,
0.3195521533,
-0.005993661,
0.4464633167,
0.3811641932,
0.6268880367,
-0.5078998804,
0.6537690759,
-0.1368173361,
-0.0676255897,
-0.2091580778,
-1.2633267641,
-0.6310836077,
-0.4414834976,
-0.5460603237,
-0.3066813648,
0.0717337728,
0.6939586401,
0.6133476496,
-0.4471146464,
-0.1707084477,
-0.4033720791,
0.1782812476,
-0.235230878,
-0.2230075896,
0.2290632725,
-0.3421717882,
-0.8481533527,
0.6803330779,
0.2806630731,
0.4908529818,
-0.1374402195,
0.179999277,
-0.6026582122,
0.266028136,
0.3146809042,
0.3038728535,
-0.5404076576,
-0.0076607638,
0.2271760702,
-0.38344872,
0.3812481463,
0.7054448724,
-0.4130194187,
0.5614373088,
0.5251346231,
0.6817979813,
0.4299064577,
0.440459013,
0.7987963557,
-0.6529800892,
-0.1322982609,
0.0498078577,
0.2678914666,
0.5781644583,
-0.6135669947,
0.5338183045,
0.1971243024,
-0.5707318187,
-0.8740596175,
0.2163835168,
-0.6982828975,
-0.1927309781,
0.9322046041,
-0.1461161077,
-0.2151591629,
-0.1102375239,
-0.0026895211,
0.5752446055,
-0.3518358767,
0.7932981253,
0.9348211288,
-0.2413883507,
-0.0427955203,
-0.6305185556,
0.1330780685,
0.393422693,
-0.7499317527,
0.0803372115,
0.6031527519,
0.0029951681,
0.2461104393,
0.6116958857,
-0.3748369813,
-0.126143083,
-0.1801541448,
-0.2380774468,
-0.4417209029,
-0.390884459,
-0.6401544809,
0.1023864448,
-0.0469525084,
-0.2059311867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12876v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12876v2 | Gloss-Free End-to-End Sign Language Translation | 2023-05-22T09:57:43 | 2023-05-27T16:43:18 | Kezhou Lin, Xiaohan Wang, Linchao Zhu, Ke Sun, Bang Zhang, Yi Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In this paper, we tackle the problem of sign language translation (SLT)
without gloss annotations. Although intermediate representation like gloss has
been proven effective, gloss annotations are hard to acquire, especially in
large quantities. This limits the domain coverage of translation datasets, thus
handicapping real-world applications. To mitigate this problem, we design the
Gloss-Free End-to-end sign language translation framework (GloFE). Our method
improves the performance of SLT in the gloss-free setting by exploiting the
shared underlying semantics of signs and the corresponding spoken translation.
Common concepts are extracted from the text and used as a weak form of
intermediate representation. The global embedding of these concepts is used as
a query for cross-attention to find the corresponding information within the
learned visual features. In a contrastive manner, we encourage the similarity
of query results between samples containing such concepts and decrease those
that do not. We obtained state-of-the-art results on large-scale datasets,
including OpenASL and How2Sign. The code and model will be available at
https://github.com/HenryLittle/GloFE. | [
-0.1496392936,
-0.2898039818,
0.4530522823,
0.0234544948,
-0.673055172,
-0.009336873,
0.0383654796,
-1.0765354633,
0.4765981436,
0.5501310229,
-0.2975366414,
-0.6720049381,
-0.9667587876,
-0.149483487,
-0.4653129876,
1.099539876,
-0.2812058032,
-0.144302085,
-0.147044152,
-0.3626062572,
0.2871365845,
-0.239588201,
-0.7876621485,
-0.1745647341,
0.0820929483,
0.3220941126,
1.0805668831,
0.2280002236,
0.5342811346,
0.0977213606,
-0.2574827075,
0.2399674803,
-0.3894102275,
-0.0361276977,
-0.0827751309,
0.0143436482,
-0.5620601177,
-0.2205312103,
0.4983017445,
0.7443950176,
0.3943834603,
0.1615103483,
-0.2873091996,
0.7122712135,
-0.3774949014,
0.2980573475,
-0.509150207,
0.0002378819,
-0.2034069896,
0.2597395778,
-0.4012035728,
-0.1783594638,
0.0931659788,
-0.8512644172,
0.1470924169,
0.4584510922,
0.9416678548,
0.3684489131,
-0.6413993835,
-0.603687644,
-0.591407001,
0.5859895945,
-0.7048048973,
0.7121301889,
0.4624048471,
0.3060156107,
-0.1992639601,
-0.5081372261,
-0.3397729993,
-0.4390063882,
-0.3765567541,
0.2563460469,
0.1019832864,
0.4553646147,
0.1095103696,
0.5833425522,
-0.6695742607,
-0.1656700522,
-0.2903654575,
-0.4058593214,
0.6446287632,
-0.2811785936,
0.3566259742,
0.2436101139,
-0.6611194611,
-0.0268232953,
-0.7147724628,
-0.0489524417,
0.0297277197,
0.54493469,
-0.3445774317,
0.470543623,
-0.2399949282,
0.7667142749,
-0.3605476916,
0.0139423851,
0.4099182189,
-0.3893449605,
-0.1535311043,
-0.2174390405,
0.8047043681,
0.3602006137,
0.5148994923,
-0.4781769812,
-0.3550700843,
-0.2907671928,
-0.4909891188,
-0.6542723775,
0.3204184771,
0.1959630549,
0.0093285218,
0.2683718503,
-0.0097656492,
-0.4938552082,
-0.2618349791,
-0.2207234502,
0.2648034394,
-0.2019587904,
-0.1820224822,
0.1314918995,
0.0102743395,
0.3595782518,
0.3452991545,
-0.8894904256,
0.507047534,
0.3311656117,
1.0247336626,
-0.2620109618,
0.2105752975,
-0.5840509534,
0.4042973518,
-0.3273963034,
0.2661257088,
-0.450183183,
-0.418338865,
-0.1028110236,
-0.0372518338,
0.0479331799,
-0.2890462875,
0.388851881,
-0.5170297027,
0.2596032023,
-0.1409143209,
-0.5188423991,
-0.1008066759,
-0.165441364,
-0.6727301478,
0.8878609538,
0.300545752,
-0.3117286265,
0.2829236388,
-0.7824046016,
-0.6932021379,
0.1163263023,
-0.1615861207,
-0.4411845207,
0.1573215127,
0.2351676077,
0.2055553645,
-0.3551757336,
-0.1373544037,
0.0472768769,
-0.3490481079,
-0.1096689031,
0.271400243,
0.4632534683,
0.1442706585,
-0.5061772466,
0.1049194336,
-0.6650280356,
0.0988536924,
0.0489241071,
0.0757616088,
-0.5547873974,
-0.2880902886,
0.1903018206,
0.4232855141,
0.3141481578,
-0.6637710929,
0.0299966615,
-0.3256573081,
0.0879276693,
0.3080664873,
-0.1062932089,
0.48488006,
0.2671598196,
0.4046082497,
0.0004015954,
0.4506104887,
0.1515861601,
-1.0888059139,
-0.841075182,
-0.1197514907,
0.0646574423,
0.4827396274,
-0.8546454906,
0.1472064704,
-0.1099668145,
-0.1041138247,
-0.7539585829,
0.3126010597,
1.0122013092,
0.3142985106,
0.8592361808,
-0.5264961123,
-0.1617915034,
-0.7744097114,
0.0054111131,
-0.1101740077,
-0.1153665483,
0.0897029862,
0.5445122719,
0.0212295949,
0.5794968605,
-0.3646408916,
-0.7281691432,
0.2012219578,
-0.0791364834,
0.1610724628,
0.3060445487,
0.4939212799,
-0.9806141257,
-0.7607269883,
0.5141732097,
-0.7013299465,
-0.1252041161,
-0.2780199945,
-0.1851843297,
0.1588276476,
0.6658865213,
-0.436694473,
0.5770728588,
0.6554492116,
-0.7553344369,
0.4400818646,
-0.0247116424,
0.0428382382,
-0.7089383006,
0.3392192125,
-0.1197193787,
-0.4333406091,
-0.8505856991,
0.3005735874,
0.0198837295,
-0.1299332976,
-0.6014316082,
0.8404586911,
-0.8619217873,
-0.4530261755,
-0.2694920599,
0.5569759607,
0.0302057043,
0.5132443905,
0.1830160916,
0.9632130265,
0.5576954484,
-0.5000581145,
0.0592797771,
0.2440689802,
-0.047893025,
0.4795524776,
-0.6552289724,
0.2997496128,
-0.1315788925,
-0.1339713484,
-0.975407064,
-0.0843755007,
0.6312434077,
-0.4440162778,
0.3078483939,
-0.0735033005,
-0.1946365237,
-0.226879999,
-0.0523411147,
0.0424477793,
0.4009307623,
-0.3136457205,
0.3126333952,
0.1628577262,
0.0306758583,
-0.5398875475,
-0.8298440576,
0.1742624193,
0.1607447416,
-0.5290782452,
0.43338871,
-0.0509892851,
-0.0710658655,
-0.1623935699,
-0.2801736891,
0.0321309902,
-0.1646866798,
0.0773847103,
-0.0536903776,
-0.0585361086,
0.1685131788,
0.0668036565,
-0.4379554391,
-0.2336685359,
-0.4921355247,
0.041320432,
-0.3109428883,
-0.580411613,
-0.2565261722,
0.5736845732,
0.8334553838,
-0.160418123,
0.6451993585,
0.4306870401,
-0.3196884692,
-0.0503115207,
-0.0174390282,
0.1260938495,
-0.4472778738,
0.161487326,
-0.3236983716,
-1.0101746321,
0.7193374038,
0.0600959472,
0.2466495782,
0.0484836921,
0.1457794905,
0.1942490637,
0.6368429065,
0.6670202613,
0.2785844207,
0.5112413764,
-0.0703626946,
0.3168480992,
-0.8852498531,
-0.3360890746,
-0.0996337831,
-0.3021483719,
0.0263478123,
-0.6626492739,
0.2564226389,
0.3197314143,
0.1731334478,
0.621927619,
-0.6886063814,
0.3542260528,
0.2864138186,
-0.1179963201,
0.6190816164,
0.0548436753,
-0.2084822208,
-0.0310157388,
0.0368949771,
-0.3028348386,
0.9832598567,
0.0665750206,
0.339396894,
0.3967148364,
0.6296271682,
0.1852836162,
0.4347919822,
-0.7311635613,
0.7170065045,
-0.2790763974,
-0.5309807658,
-0.6023012996,
-0.3478420675,
-0.6710470319,
0.6066890955,
0.0647307709,
-0.7312760353,
0.0893025845,
0.2850539982,
0.1404270828,
0.2011110187,
-0.9318071008,
0.6808968782,
-0.5421305299,
-0.3156480789,
0.1641697139,
-0.7985551357,
0.222311914,
-0.2246531546,
0.4512193203,
-0.3130909503,
-0.3854395747,
0.5645672083,
-0.538838625,
0.8625096083,
-0.2906703949,
-0.3659693301,
0.4467615485,
-0.0918917805,
0.6590331793,
-0.0119639011,
-0.1126515493,
0.0666540787,
-0.3351778984,
-0.5801798105,
-0.6167857051,
0.2239704132,
-0.4943851233,
-0.4038889706,
-0.2284757048,
-0.5311979055,
-0.3650430739,
0.3260349631,
0.3292098939,
-0.0232167412,
-0.1761857867,
-0.2499001473,
0.4589125514,
0.2742511928,
0.3931570947,
0.4348007739,
-0.6341323256,
-0.522721827,
0.9299808741,
0.0562422648,
0.8868878484,
0.4443174005,
-0.0388189033,
-0.5267365575,
-0.7338704467,
-0.6658332348,
0.3912527561,
-0.6949620843,
-0.0129317949,
-0.0596018061,
0.1602930129,
-0.5430502892,
-0.2678207457,
-0.1739640236,
-0.7017369866,
-0.0031445124,
-0.1106216833,
0.6821569204,
0.4780026674,
-0.0196848158,
0.6966445446,
-0.2751361728,
0.4581740499,
0.0806223452,
0.4151009917,
-0.1155017987,
-0.4533869326,
-0.4217188954,
0.0581617318,
0.0820650309,
-0.758253634,
-0.0093841515,
0.7656083703,
0.486061722,
0.4082041681,
0.1548383236,
0.6116070151,
-0.1878243983,
0.675976634,
0.7109843493,
-1.0107802153,
0.5218878388,
-0.1438352317,
0.4609713554,
0.484572649,
0.5912001729,
-0.8416172862,
-0.5840823054,
-0.3388733566,
-1.2683452368,
0.324894309,
0.4664239287,
-0.1383097023,
0.1085120514,
0.2727986276,
0.0846305713,
0.1681939662,
-0.8435969353,
-0.3048585355,
-0.2396069765,
-0.0774820596,
0.0584866703,
0.2006496638,
-0.1483006328,
-0.2145095021,
0.7429763079,
-0.4181602895,
0.11504969,
0.3007763624,
-0.4594126344,
-0.0877376348,
0.1730600744,
0.5654166937,
0.2634509206,
0.0160014983,
0.1010713577,
0.1902749538,
-0.7470329404,
0.0662945732,
-0.0576724522,
-0.674151957,
0.3518598974,
0.3661614358,
0.938307941,
0.2741929591,
-0.5014991164,
0.54115206,
0.2892052531,
-0.2379370332,
-0.0841823146,
-0.1747522801,
0.2650963366,
-0.1139889881,
0.3715484142,
-0.2563007176,
0.0222243965,
-0.2457573861,
0.4545989633,
0.3954243958,
-0.7618132234,
-0.3622201681,
0.8505238295,
0.2542508543,
-0.184520632,
0.2622794509,
-0.3788060248,
-0.2783949673,
0.4076556861,
0.6221427917,
0.8734337687,
-0.2009139806,
0.383851558,
0.1726228893,
0.3451690078,
0.1904672682,
0.4001656175,
-0.2265084535,
-0.2334802151,
-0.5015103221,
-0.6657858491,
-0.7573967576,
-0.0212336648,
-0.4366634786,
0.163575992,
-0.5457345247,
-0.2277097255,
-0.4878620207,
-0.2478111535,
-0.335835129,
0.4035987854,
0.3768492639,
0.6102287769,
-0.9811950326,
0.7531867623,
0.7056159973,
-0.6532803178,
-0.2157950103,
-0.1779052615,
-0.1062629968,
-0.8599347472,
0.2667763233,
0.1251147091,
-0.4672496915,
0.0215370469,
-0.494064033,
-1.2202464342,
0.8681060672,
0.4286774099,
-0.5247895718,
-0.2034148574,
0.6884895563,
0.6576703787,
-0.3992959857,
0.2558580041,
0.4619704485,
0.5732174516,
0.5462961793,
-1.0078788996,
0.3505669534,
-0.2019614875,
-0.0527540259,
0.2940972447,
-0.6776727438,
0.3234874904,
-0.5300713778,
-0.4498639405,
-0.060973119,
0.9055717587,
-0.0212289002,
0.418079704,
0.2621818185,
0.482632339,
0.8194038272,
-0.2268520892,
0.568125248,
-0.3113081753,
0.4132359624,
1.1077895164,
-0.1730010211,
0.708999753,
0.8043439388,
-0.1139859259,
0.2318507731,
0.3721856773,
0.2937804163,
0.6108568311,
0.3494229019,
-0.3743059337,
-0.2649488151,
-0.1262535453,
-0.4936023355,
-0.0441968702,
0.6312556267,
-0.3863532245,
-0.5602573752,
0.0744134709,
0.2256255895,
0.1421535015,
-0.2562174499,
0.3911052644,
0.5964182019,
-0.2430438995,
0.870005846,
-0.5212773681,
0.7191103101,
-0.8019911647,
0.0478967912,
-0.2787117958,
-0.0327998027,
-0.3657485247,
-0.8207073212,
0.5343983769,
-0.3369057178,
0.117489174,
-0.4079875946,
0.5863505006,
-0.6153161526,
-0.2700788081,
0.7892921567,
0.4295730293,
0.6075153947,
0.1692479253,
-0.6903530955,
-0.0538025647,
0.1020491347,
-0.3782904148,
0.2056025863,
0.4146065712,
-0.4538500607,
0.6155118346,
0.6700761318,
0.1196605414,
0.2474962622,
0.2667696476,
0.5745013952,
-0.5783085823,
-0.5166709423,
-0.2399183661,
0.6042016745,
-0.1914800256,
-0.6967455745,
0.4336779416,
0.5310011506,
0.8798511028,
-0.0810708776,
0.7574193478,
-0.1494844407,
0.1628646702,
-0.5741411448,
0.7227876186,
-0.6143385172,
-0.1755636483,
-0.3591105342,
-0.8140694499,
-0.7708736658,
0.3305653334,
-0.2765859067,
-0.1732980311,
0.6035695672,
0.7453644872,
0.1184247062,
-0.0353663824,
0.7161694169,
-0.1553180814,
0.4302244484,
0.8841531277,
0.1426725537,
-0.8298119903,
0.881867528,
0.1680693775,
-0.3741697669,
-0.2930437922,
-0.8218532205,
-0.7192006707,
-0.6818390489,
-0.4537734091,
-0.1970386505,
0.2959322631,
0.4945456684,
0.530731678,
-0.9847670794,
-0.1989712864,
-0.0546529181,
0.1507808119,
-0.462010324,
-0.0943112597,
0.5857004523,
-0.3446178436,
-0.6914855242,
0.4904823303,
0.1028239802,
0.489256978,
0.0945095494,
-0.5064413548,
-0.0468942337,
-0.2132962495,
0.6721463799,
0.7525528073,
-0.6749333143,
-0.5863782763,
-0.0085966708,
-0.057371404,
0.1103811115,
0.4446959496,
-0.5442025065,
0.4338266551,
0.2922300696,
0.3301611841,
0.7079683542,
-0.0808064193,
0.2394321114,
-0.9238801003,
0.325381428,
0.0677292719,
0.2729600668,
0.5383713841,
-0.3982914686,
0.7693198919,
0.3962329328,
-0.1040275097,
-0.4462892413,
0.6532866359,
-1.0881955624,
-0.0229875706,
1.1658574343,
-0.1396373659,
-0.2559053898,
-0.4985409379,
-0.0218264647,
0.2394337207,
-0.498699069,
0.2391550541,
0.4843911529,
-0.4412012994,
-0.0323418193,
-0.5683537126,
0.6064667702,
0.3793926537,
-0.4899759591,
0.2670450807,
0.303937465,
0.001267297,
0.5174988508,
0.9053217173,
-0.3261195719,
0.2695469856,
-0.1035793126,
0.3257521987,
-0.2987149358,
-0.2963708043,
0.0450212173,
0.0669381842,
0.1626144052,
-0.2904427648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12870v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12870v2 | Lion: Adversarial Distillation of Proprietary Large Language Models | 2023-05-22T09:49:16 | 2023-10-14T02:21:24 | Yuxin Jiang, Chunkit Chan, Mingyang Chen, Wei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The practice of transferring knowledge from a sophisticated, proprietary
large language model (LLM) to a compact, open-source LLM has garnered
considerable attention. Previous works have focused on a unidirectional
knowledge distillation way by aligning the responses of the student model with
those of the teacher model to a set of instructions. Nevertheless, they
overlooked the possibility of incorporating any reciprocal
"feedback"--identifying challenging instructions where the student model's
performance falls short--to boost the student model's proficiency iteratively.
To this end, we propose a novel adversarial distillation framework for a more
efficient knowledge transfer. Leveraging the versatile role adaptability of
LLMs, we prompt the teacher model to identify "hard" instructions and generate
new "hard" instructions for the student model, creating a three-stage
adversarial loop of imitation, discrimination, and generation. By applying this
adversarial framework, we successfully transfer knowledge from ChatGPT to a
student model (named Lion), using a mere 70k training data. Our results show
that Lion-13B not only achieves comparable open-ended generation capabilities
to ChatGPT but surpasses conventional state-of-the-art (SOTA) instruction-tuned
models like Vicuna-13B by 55.4% in challenging zero-shot reasoning benchmarks
such as BIG-Bench Hard (BBH) and 16.7% on AGIEval. Code and model can be found
at https://github.com/YJiangcm/Lion. | [
-0.2864528298,
-0.6607710719,
0.2356922477,
0.2756433487,
-0.0810185,
0.2506642342,
-0.3338863552,
-0.1303287745,
-0.0914037824,
0.4856847227,
-0.4282477796,
-0.180213958,
-0.7238267064,
-0.3285797834,
-0.6034616232,
1.1374928951,
0.1049144492,
0.1354736686,
0.2038334012,
0.0165446512,
-0.2103219777,
-0.5441796184,
-0.5650742054,
-0.7057635784,
0.225757435,
0.3156971633,
0.8630849719,
0.4133697748,
0.5187783241,
0.2499659657,
-0.3361960351,
0.1917844117,
-0.5719843507,
0.1951219887,
-0.420720011,
-0.2878661156,
-0.1812121123,
-0.0621118695,
0.2765467167,
0.5488553047,
-0.2853839695,
0.0034401198,
0.2834276557,
0.9498141408,
-0.5627249479,
0.1603361815,
-1.0477304459,
-0.0999556333,
-0.1579364389,
0.0744905025,
-0.5346193314,
-0.4218419492,
0.1621141732,
-0.6368080378,
0.249618873,
-0.4371980727,
0.7786282897,
0.220764026,
-0.1997361481,
-0.7512095571,
-0.7657855153,
0.6063030958,
-0.4883045554,
-0.2559558451,
0.1850271821,
0.7172665,
-0.53439188,
-0.8546248674,
-0.5992531776,
-0.4011361003,
0.2818655074,
0.1352276653,
-0.1594311893,
-0.0313834697,
-0.0769067928,
0.5792496204,
-0.284750849,
-0.0434439145,
-0.6709592938,
0.0441205651,
0.5145512223,
-0.2191156745,
0.1415780485,
0.06578511,
-0.5020095706,
-0.4565798342,
-0.5358718634,
-0.0516020805,
0.2817481458,
0.5191226006,
0.3337465227,
0.4567628801,
0.0778940395,
0.5018373728,
0.2717590332,
-0.032291688,
0.0160278082,
0.1257088184,
-0.0493331328,
0.1993828565,
0.6901643872,
0.0161460191,
0.3474159539,
-0.0214423016,
-0.3526273668,
0.0356754363,
0.3070604205,
-0.8860417604,
-0.7285144329,
-0.2492025346,
-0.2161963582,
-0.6040637493,
-0.0473861024,
-0.5044003129,
-0.8689809442,
-0.1805212647,
0.7332253456,
-0.6341927052,
-0.1454394013,
0.1896698028,
-0.0753073245,
0.0622908622,
0.2755618095,
-0.7975283861,
0.2154180855,
0.644410193,
0.8385688663,
-0.1889903694,
-0.237646237,
-0.3443728983,
0.0297648087,
-0.4166035056,
0.1685281098,
-0.3997461498,
-0.3235676587,
-0.0443654209,
-0.0833197758,
-0.1223168075,
-0.670086503,
0.2925809324,
-0.6180334687,
0.0698650628,
-0.2121793628,
-0.238632828,
-0.425930202,
0.2608141303,
-0.5564737916,
1.0397796631,
-0.0093578966,
-0.5645509958,
-0.0334050916,
-0.6617866755,
-0.5438013077,
-0.1213592514,
-0.0534332469,
-0.3050340414,
0.0173649825,
0.3306272924,
0.4616563618,
-0.5271182656,
0.4553625882,
-0.5107609034,
-0.3310857415,
0.2882698178,
-0.6229341626,
1.0958291292,
0.5496714115,
-0.4167817235,
-0.2738523185,
-0.9168507457,
-0.2533597648,
0.2783488631,
-0.2548773289,
-0.4846522808,
-0.3832463324,
-0.3512337208,
0.196600467,
0.2398707718,
-0.3337670267,
0.6364001632,
-0.1003981829,
0.5916411281,
0.8764542937,
-0.0970569476,
0.5419147611,
-0.4016446471,
0.4188170433,
-0.0117963338,
0.1608237773,
-0.1757863313,
-0.2425594479,
-0.7456427217,
-0.4795777202,
0.2249229401,
0.4993959963,
-1.3323413134,
-0.0791001916,
0.0473170318,
-0.815007031,
-0.484683603,
0.4034011662,
0.4411461353,
0.4397068024,
0.3572380543,
-0.2485226244,
-0.4623489976,
-0.6113269329,
-0.047427848,
-0.5304874778,
0.0481509864,
0.145011574,
0.5197445154,
-0.0168380551,
0.5583372116,
-0.517059207,
-0.564637661,
-0.3602123857,
0.3346435726,
0.211072579,
0.3840976655,
0.7383739948,
-0.4692076743,
-0.5331023932,
-0.0366850011,
-0.7842336297,
-0.1266247034,
-0.3151047826,
-0.2887409329,
-0.1764204055,
0.5953435898,
-0.264490664,
0.134344995,
0.5449119806,
0.1116461307,
0.3940914869,
-0.3648938239,
-0.0612447523,
-1.2469453812,
0.072348021,
-0.2719572186,
0.1065469235,
-0.5505382419,
0.3020706475,
-0.0285278317,
-0.0968452394,
-0.3842271864,
0.3066094816,
-0.4074024558,
0.2918313146,
-0.5130556822,
0.0770398304,
0.0275841821,
0.527469039,
0.0070207473,
0.7077580094,
0.6114931107,
-0.6068634391,
0.6587484479,
0.2089520395,
-0.3374670446,
0.2680217624,
-0.6943133473,
0.1849306673,
0.0398454592,
0.2956130207,
-0.8652907014,
0.0303419586,
0.1513438672,
-0.4929042161,
0.3800238669,
-0.0725154057,
-0.2309028208,
-0.3058008254,
-0.2852520943,
0.0610498413,
0.5554677844,
-0.8992904425,
0.6574477553,
0.0413926281,
-0.077822648,
-0.8750841022,
-0.921577394,
0.1717353612,
-0.0881144851,
-0.650942862,
0.2603872716,
0.0660534054,
-0.2215989828,
0.0533362255,
0.041544646,
-0.3238930106,
0.3517510891,
0.1132896766,
0.2966832221,
-0.287094295,
0.0624615774,
-0.1247251481,
0.2591771185,
0.0253233127,
-0.4201154709,
0.2450670153,
-0.1018355861,
-0.4240630269,
-0.0636384711,
-0.1680769473,
0.8545498252,
-0.0310610849,
0.9246483445,
0.4120936096,
-0.1170271933,
-0.5864848495,
-0.2274055183,
-0.3042482436,
-0.4894605875,
0.4085872173,
-0.3685719371,
-0.5297951698,
0.5020734668,
-0.1137690023,
0.2921849191,
0.1365649551,
0.4139140546,
0.3624509275,
0.7742910981,
0.5164132118,
-0.2508176565,
0.4048623145,
-0.3642100096,
-0.0236508362,
-0.4852833748,
-0.1022793055,
-0.4042384923,
-0.3365928233,
-0.2820019126,
-0.3996565938,
0.1841062754,
0.3107023835,
-0.3870069981,
0.4251624346,
-0.5660074949,
0.365113616,
0.724334836,
0.1042327434,
0.2477712482,
-0.0252210516,
-0.3223210871,
0.1655215323,
-0.7503672242,
-0.3758846819,
1.1924993992,
0.2776672542,
1.1364915371,
0.3621231616,
0.7355672717,
0.3451724052,
0.363652885,
-0.5810685754,
0.5752517581,
-0.6990940571,
-0.7651982307,
-0.155272305,
-0.3619424701,
-0.5063013434,
0.392544359,
-0.0125331329,
-0.4250299335,
-0.026988415,
0.0927907452,
-0.3350054622,
0.4744777679,
-0.7326610088,
0.6085607409,
-0.2128175199,
-0.3825639486,
0.1661732495,
-0.4120271504,
0.744350493,
-0.4225531518,
0.1540445685,
0.1564307362,
0.3712439835,
0.4055866599,
-0.5617134571,
0.8340756297,
-0.4312177002,
-0.2174220383,
0.5781282783,
0.4134097397,
0.6112979054,
-0.1503508985,
-0.2085689902,
-0.0605243035,
-0.2028889656,
-0.1813684255,
-0.7697100639,
0.6750323772,
-0.9782242179,
-0.7867008448,
-0.5843679905,
-0.5038126111,
-0.0408659801,
-0.1076052263,
0.214054659,
0.1898513138,
-0.1898422539,
0.508883059,
0.7116448283,
-0.308476001,
0.2272176445,
0.7747760415,
-0.3887090683,
-0.1939028203,
1.1400697231,
0.0761104152,
0.4937271476,
0.1666892916,
0.2171572745,
-0.2204809934,
-0.4743013084,
-0.5589540005,
-0.1542693675,
-0.7471444011,
-0.221943453,
-0.2308795601,
-0.6229943633,
-0.2842758298,
-0.2393878102,
-0.7446107268,
-0.6343562007,
-0.3472955525,
0.1383218318,
0.3331892788,
0.8078178763,
-0.4120506048,
0.4303168356,
-0.5781898499,
0.3100213706,
0.5809764862,
-0.0855993629,
0.2473120689,
-1.1604975462,
0.0603213683,
0.2437541336,
-0.6858563423,
-0.7063186765,
0.3112787902,
0.5323698521,
0.3552617133,
0.5312846899,
0.5878085494,
0.6908006668,
-0.2845211327,
0.7511404753,
0.311165899,
-0.9113451838,
0.3721214831,
-0.0166686624,
0.3015410006,
0.607062459,
0.2207500935,
-0.3430175781,
-0.502360642,
-0.2367681563,
-0.7590277791,
0.980021894,
0.3081320822,
0.1357066929,
0.1160483584,
0.2484477609,
0.0803831443,
-0.0438334607,
-0.6517404318,
-0.2287431955,
-0.38752985,
-0.1506749541,
-0.0189571194,
-0.0967548564,
-0.1584877372,
0.0854554251,
0.9825486541,
-0.0585893765,
-0.3651187718,
-0.0261634141,
-0.2298863977,
0.2080590874,
0.1983363479,
0.4007474184,
0.4069959819,
-0.1285846084,
0.3327849507,
0.1016783044,
-0.6717935205,
0.3632189929,
0.3956059515,
-0.3201003969,
-0.1073224694,
0.2073883265,
0.4866070151,
-0.0902502313,
-0.3383795321,
0.6477344632,
-0.1690549403,
-0.478861928,
-0.2952765524,
0.1121173501,
-0.0272212271,
0.4789276719,
0.4808432758,
0.0928657427,
0.0331639089,
-0.4483195245,
0.2416518182,
0.2501527071,
-0.523866117,
-0.1927723885,
0.7312653661,
0.2510161996,
0.1648503244,
0.4246728122,
-0.2850801349,
-0.6816520691,
0.5954230428,
0.3617146909,
0.7798169255,
-0.3906362653,
0.540633142,
0.1921256483,
0.4004479647,
-0.4738463461,
-0.0350596681,
0.0569723472,
-0.6011228561,
-0.3150761127,
-0.5553370714,
-0.3600462079,
0.4087459147,
-0.8348323703,
0.1846457273,
-0.5934079885,
0.1718769073,
0.2577731013,
-0.1655584425,
-0.1838248968,
-0.0346156731,
0.1396937817,
0.7551166415,
-0.7520489097,
1.1201514006,
0.7200437188,
-0.4813738763,
-0.894736886,
-0.0429663137,
0.2060976326,
-1.0918827057,
0.9430250525,
-0.0214359052,
-0.1962385327,
-0.3904718757,
-0.4581378996,
-0.3707198799,
1.0241671801,
0.6058527827,
-0.6104741096,
0.0465754271,
0.1683643758,
0.5431296825,
-0.1668812782,
0.2412556112,
0.3996215165,
0.0804938003,
0.8838841319,
-0.868858397,
0.1165558025,
-0.1599512845,
0.1714817286,
-0.1667123735,
-0.7486310005,
1.0305433273,
-0.2729354799,
-0.0600044169,
0.1118801162,
0.6254675388,
0.1744440347,
0.1767124832,
0.4077949524,
0.4396088123,
0.699958384,
0.0790708736,
0.5413658023,
-0.4810726643,
0.0934082642,
1.304898262,
-0.2560559809,
0.5199130177,
0.3216840625,
0.0458843596,
0.3675610125,
0.2381508052,
0.0979264975,
0.7238182425,
0.4795745611,
-0.3056711257,
-0.2356323451,
0.0302124526,
-0.6093194485,
0.6244744658,
0.1662115753,
-0.522906661,
-0.2740792632,
0.1357219517,
0.0580596291,
0.3535196185,
-0.2695954442,
0.7486679554,
0.1941522509,
-0.8753525019,
0.9950725436,
0.0390451215,
0.5551566482,
-0.7787960768,
-0.1252825856,
-0.4227670729,
0.8388038874,
0.0763166919,
-0.6081697941,
0.1848312765,
0.1713999659,
-0.098925449,
-0.2582865655,
0.7168629766,
-0.4951983094,
-0.359092474,
0.3022712767,
0.286441803,
0.0905182064,
-0.2646165788,
-0.7408012748,
0.0025196427,
0.3446040452,
-0.2817282677,
0.341601938,
0.7470645308,
0.1052231714,
0.7956264019,
0.5124105811,
0.0793282315,
0.0734403953,
-0.0243755169,
1.1996079683,
-0.2761606872,
-0.2145309895,
-0.7777327299,
0.0812544152,
0.0641195029,
-0.226766631,
0.6663655639,
0.2748005986,
0.7847487926,
0.0105636828,
1.0168815851,
-0.0779977515,
0.3714106083,
-0.3195208013,
0.8933820128,
-0.5866080523,
0.6634725928,
-0.2054514438,
-0.7687259316,
0.0346634164,
0.5034188032,
-0.1474825442,
-0.1682210118,
0.4107923508,
0.9608007669,
-0.0650183931,
0.1399965882,
0.2721863091,
0.2953671217,
0.5323169827,
0.8639196157,
0.984457612,
-0.3290641904,
1.2493662834,
-0.3124561012,
-0.4498403668,
-0.1747864783,
-0.7141499519,
-1.0690864325,
-0.4770839512,
-0.2086010128,
-0.5826317072,
0.5041129589,
0.7254831791,
0.4742393792,
-0.811599791,
-0.1656532586,
-0.1847961992,
-0.1811417043,
-0.3321950436,
-0.1941550821,
0.3253250122,
-0.3876015544,
-0.6113479137,
0.3538134396,
-0.1561218947,
0.0841736495,
-0.4718719721,
-0.1951608509,
-0.1045492738,
0.2336590588,
0.3236968815,
0.4237951636,
-0.5386918783,
-0.0449980944,
0.0984454677,
-0.3048804104,
-0.4607889056,
0.6426830292,
-0.5018817186,
0.7262794971,
0.2042289823,
0.8738211393,
0.5226500034,
-0.1941762865,
0.6944249868,
-0.6982383132,
0.1840914786,
0.1038040668,
0.0817597583,
0.3292823732,
-0.0348123685,
0.5348358154,
0.1662638336,
-0.4291632175,
-0.770337224,
0.0986274779,
-0.6177084446,
-0.6875320673,
1.2197841406,
-0.6272741556,
-0.1247963682,
0.131125316,
-0.3673591316,
0.2646858096,
-0.4241299629,
1.2380156517,
0.744721055,
0.2677657902,
0.1228625402,
-0.2700586319,
0.4154589772,
0.3811409771,
-0.2502383888,
0.1072831303,
0.2252324224,
0.0562250651,
0.141043216,
0.239931494,
-0.1146034077,
0.157472834,
0.196662724,
0.1313741505,
-0.595659852,
-0.3962276876,
-0.1835232675,
0.3174681365,
0.1607454866,
-0.4883876443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12868v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12868v1 | NAS-FM: Neural Architecture Search for Tunable and Interpretable Sound Synthesis based on Frequency Modulation | 2023-05-22T09:46:10 | 2023-05-22T09:46:10 | Zhen Ye, Wei Xue, Xu Tan, Qifeng Liu, Yike Guo | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM, eess.AS | Developing digital sound synthesizers is crucial to the music industry as it
provides a low-cost way to produce high-quality sounds with rich timbres.
Existing traditional synthesizers often require substantial expertise to
determine the overall framework of a synthesizer and the parameters of
submodules. Since expert knowledge is hard to acquire, it hinders the
flexibility to quickly design and tune digital synthesizers for diverse sounds.
In this paper, we propose ``NAS-FM'', which adopts neural architecture search
(NAS) to build a differentiable frequency modulation (FM) synthesizer. Tunable
synthesizers with interpretable controls can be developed automatically from
sounds without any prior expert knowledge and manual operating costs. In
detail, we train a supernet with a specifically designed search space,
including predicting the envelopes of carriers and modulators with different
frequency ratios. An evolutionary search algorithm with adaptive oscillator
size is then developed to find the optimal relationship between oscillators and
the frequency ratio of FM. Extensive experiments on recordings of different
instrument sounds show that our algorithm can build a synthesizer fully
automatically, achieving better results than handcrafted synthesizers. Audio
samples are available at https://nas-fm.github.io/. | [
-0.7854485512,
-0.475818634,
0.5101748705,
0.2436591834,
-0.1276110113,
-0.1915594786,
-0.0831953138,
-0.2848692238,
0.7324177623,
-0.0255490243,
-0.9013723135,
0.071799159,
-0.2826294005,
0.1925984025,
-0.251013875,
0.4626664817,
0.1981881857,
-0.0683217645,
0.1254217625,
0.1765805185,
-0.4051135182,
-0.04540563,
-0.493878603,
-0.3218715787,
0.2350839376,
-0.0149676446,
0.5719696879,
0.470983088,
0.3288224936,
0.3775647879,
-0.4912173748,
0.0988443866,
0.0069718575,
0.2153134346,
-0.0538236797,
-0.5046625733,
-0.5829005241,
-0.1670504361,
0.1949485838,
0.3092209399,
-0.2027944028,
0.279802978,
-0.3974892199,
0.6682567596,
-0.1572356522,
-0.0958508626,
-0.6784771085,
0.4965153039,
-0.2882737219,
-0.4791442454,
-0.142981261,
-0.280490756,
-0.1510802358,
-0.9083756208,
0.1880191863,
-0.2655340135,
0.3938729763,
0.4928672016,
-0.1350621432,
-0.2264040709,
-0.8159464598,
0.4013582766,
-0.5460268259,
0.7269955277,
0.1656324416,
0.6855602264,
-0.4119768143,
-0.7157094479,
-0.4696151912,
-0.2073024809,
0.416564554,
0.2623716891,
0.2260974795,
0.1335959285,
0.0567411222,
0.5978836417,
-0.4858877957,
-0.6452718973,
-0.5259116888,
-0.2171694487,
0.4482307434,
0.0741700828,
0.3969392478,
0.0378215648,
-0.4206373096,
0.1354148984,
-0.5513613224,
-0.2542457581,
0.7794212699,
0.0896885395,
-0.082250379,
0.0909397304,
-0.006167178,
0.8101806641,
0.3874825537,
0.0453319959,
0.3458396792,
-0.4230924547,
-0.1855918765,
0.164143756,
0.5218014121,
-0.0653125048,
0.1562086642,
0.0517515168,
-0.9209825397,
-0.0555961728,
0.6574262977,
-0.4491482377,
-0.2606832981,
0.0477070212,
-0.5904483795,
-0.2894928753,
0.0062606777,
-0.3554496169,
0.2959856689,
-0.477189213,
0.9030895233,
-0.2850961089,
-0.4307319224,
0.3412984312,
-0.5491290092,
-0.3589704633,
-0.0255739689,
-1.1109853983,
0.2246053964,
0.4018396437,
0.850710392,
0.0526425801,
-0.0457446575,
-0.3220303059,
-0.2155928761,
-0.4243454933,
0.4000354707,
-0.3228391111,
-0.5835852027,
-0.476846844,
-0.4991173148,
0.0361262932,
-0.6389655471,
0.2454846501,
-1.0078309774,
0.0476387031,
0.0074942759,
-0.1829196066,
-0.056861084,
-0.047484424,
-0.8092650771,
0.6096650958,
0.4729950726,
-0.1912244558,
0.099306494,
-1.0207041502,
-0.6145327687,
-0.0700513646,
-0.2047093958,
-0.2080943584,
0.7184229493,
-0.044391375,
-0.0902899206,
-0.5848807693,
0.5894628167,
-0.0872344598,
-0.7995135784,
0.506043911,
-0.5232194662,
0.7994515896,
0.5853012204,
-0.4702951908,
0.3152237535,
-0.8301904202,
-0.0788910314,
-0.174502477,
-0.5757372975,
-0.1316599399,
-0.1370738149,
0.4787397683,
0.2559404075,
-0.0454178713,
-0.4763596654,
-0.1714630425,
-0.563059926,
0.7495148182,
0.6981474757,
0.0230319072,
0.4792167246,
-0.8760308623,
0.5774416327,
-0.4232503474,
0.4159790576,
0.1536083519,
-0.4612046778,
-0.3934739232,
-0.0820446759,
0.6861230135,
-0.024643641,
-0.5933644772,
0.5383327007,
0.0625969023,
-0.277600944,
-0.6142450571,
0.001081924,
0.1271800697,
0.2632121742,
0.4901832342,
-0.4986540377,
-0.9961042404,
-0.8804128766,
0.0424132533,
0.1457283497,
-0.2303751856,
0.3484776616,
0.2067831457,
-0.2771852911,
0.6311629415,
-0.3429242074,
-0.371263653,
-0.0112335468,
0.0583136976,
0.5062561035,
0.6889952421,
0.7235047221,
-1.0298788548,
-0.2445026487,
-0.0392454937,
-0.2048741728,
-0.2564977705,
-0.2364520878,
-0.0912991017,
-0.1054863036,
0.3787580729,
-0.5695790052,
-0.2360074967,
0.3636909723,
0.0772200748,
0.4808225632,
0.1830367893,
-0.0255423691,
-0.9754786491,
0.3348348737,
-0.2581499815,
0.1091082841,
-0.5465860963,
0.2560694218,
0.0774075687,
0.1369103789,
-0.5054568648,
0.2198308855,
-0.2946129143,
-0.2999390066,
-0.2306809723,
-0.3504647911,
-0.2196722776,
0.4633667171,
-0.0590094104,
0.8475804329,
0.2389632314,
-0.5279518366,
0.2702931166,
-0.057623107,
-0.7104360461,
0.4165746868,
-0.4432114065,
-0.0844084769,
-0.0225645155,
0.1608385444,
-0.632537365,
-0.1411384493,
-0.1239295378,
-0.7060286403,
0.139914304,
-0.1389436573,
0.040101178,
-0.0913365483,
-0.0070552328,
0.6356601715,
0.3522466123,
-0.4658752978,
0.80055511,
0.4531315565,
0.1266612709,
-0.2236490697,
-0.9338755608,
-0.2229865342,
-0.0444770232,
-0.4369963706,
0.5829156041,
-0.4513587356,
-0.2337726802,
0.0425525904,
-0.7758244872,
-0.2131725848,
0.5225479603,
0.2729309499,
0.2845487595,
-0.6834024191,
0.2345362306,
0.2631299496,
-0.2472181469,
0.2543674111,
-0.6873763204,
0.6762114763,
-0.0745220482,
0.0139649659,
-0.4955485463,
0.225438714,
0.8271733522,
-0.1882251203,
-0.0092416927,
0.2597366869,
-0.2259447724,
-0.6068840623,
-0.232103914,
-0.3346781433,
-0.6325813532,
0.0166923795,
-0.5562265515,
-0.5567113161,
0.4162881374,
-0.1813588738,
-0.0868223831,
0.5629862547,
0.4176169336,
-0.1041708142,
0.7308036685,
0.1542290002,
0.2404959947,
0.7531118989,
-0.2938854098,
-0.5454221964,
-0.7591609955,
-0.2240110487,
-0.3051077127,
-0.8945077658,
-0.3251132667,
-0.3160394728,
0.6375763416,
-0.6482901573,
-0.5636137724,
0.3999074399,
-0.6701437831,
0.7152743936,
0.7101646066,
0.0218769945,
-0.0093289046,
-0.0640863329,
-0.3173469901,
0.2082004547,
-0.4477222264,
0.2678712308,
1.136126399,
0.0453870036,
0.6343499422,
0.2372151315,
0.8714920878,
0.4161598086,
0.2081093937,
-0.767734468,
0.1654250771,
-0.1824277043,
-1.0536189079,
-0.1159591973,
-0.5366208553,
-0.4082642496,
0.0706968158,
-0.4440100193,
0.0287984498,
0.4296475947,
-0.1062962264,
-0.4376825094,
0.1409551799,
-0.3724082708,
0.248553887,
-0.3714844286,
0.3240261376,
0.0761649981,
-0.6336929202,
0.1917616874,
-0.3348403573,
0.0956506282,
0.1441844702,
0.0491475798,
0.2952705622,
-0.1504767686,
0.302464366,
-0.1921339333,
-0.0081408545,
0.0811385289,
0.4724183977,
-0.0425050929,
0.249667868,
-0.5090696216,
0.2042538524,
-0.193176657,
0.138211295,
-0.4158811569,
0.874119997,
-0.8827825785,
-0.6453669667,
0.1139450222,
-0.7837296724,
-0.2903417945,
0.3840460181,
0.2110263556,
0.5587257743,
-0.2890845239,
0.5634064078,
0.692427814,
0.1268121898,
0.3923469782,
0.337498039,
0.0544183888,
-0.7170084715,
0.8478862047,
0.1284578592,
0.178075552,
0.7461387515,
0.3532154262,
-0.0720034316,
-0.6107624769,
-0.7502060533,
-0.5194702148,
-0.2728217244,
-0.5156968236,
-0.3110531271,
-0.2601190209,
0.104358077,
-0.320798099,
-0.6233121753,
-0.7324277163,
-0.3142112494,
-0.0086873826,
0.2032969147,
0.5913207531,
-0.3755132258,
0.2364047915,
-0.5232617259,
0.7274157405,
0.447958976,
0.5866575837,
-0.0324282944,
-0.4010621607,
-0.0755399317,
0.2198335975,
-0.2009278536,
-0.8494182825,
0.4676308632,
0.2393736243,
0.5212426186,
0.1142258197,
-0.0647391528,
0.2331305146,
-0.1850848198,
0.3392890692,
0.1598784029,
-1.2178045511,
0.3503853679,
-0.3688949049,
0.3933013678,
0.4876012802,
0.2910669446,
-0.3495564461,
-0.0432654731,
-0.2962999642,
-0.8800068498,
0.9570087194,
0.2942493856,
0.277032733,
0.1223401874,
0.3967493176,
0.292881161,
0.2700188756,
-0.411331743,
-0.5555690527,
-0.4190339148,
-0.4182521105,
0.103737101,
0.2075179219,
-0.3802850544,
-0.1123497933,
0.7702131867,
-0.0245700553,
0.4101478159,
0.2534507215,
0.0488985963,
-0.5677443743,
0.1605350077,
0.8441129923,
0.4091933966,
-0.289568007,
0.2090409845,
0.0195422191,
-0.4434738457,
0.4171330035,
-0.1913582534,
-0.4297157824,
0.1605904996,
-0.2153206468,
0.787735045,
0.2716201246,
-0.4434967339,
0.3044348061,
-0.3167462647,
-0.6488469839,
-0.295511812,
0.6083593369,
0.6622135043,
0.3982839584,
0.4421158433,
0.55251652,
0.3743636608,
-0.5533949733,
0.2423603833,
0.2513182759,
-0.2436229587,
-0.302261591,
0.9759892821,
0.1535511017,
-0.7093995214,
0.5521405339,
0.0715921,
0.0560471192,
1.1272895336,
0.7322683334,
1.1189312935,
-0.2995108366,
0.0088825384,
0.0887293145,
0.3443498015,
-0.0715178177,
0.6506658792,
-0.4841980338,
-0.3641612232,
-0.0090720598,
-0.872843802,
-0.1883413047,
0.257062465,
-0.5799420476,
0.0117243687,
-0.8017121553,
-0.4312587976,
0.5931745172,
-0.3929258883,
-0.3527571559,
0.2887029052,
-0.158144027,
1.1298639774,
-0.5373719335,
0.865019381,
0.6297923923,
-0.1088834405,
-0.3955762684,
0.1258356124,
0.218618542,
-0.2802462876,
0.6935642362,
-0.0974841639,
-0.2061776966,
0.0207246915,
-0.1386311501,
-1.0324523449,
0.9324766994,
0.4453340769,
-0.6754710674,
0.2821315229,
-0.2444480211,
0.7027022243,
-0.3695394695,
0.1579446346,
0.3391391933,
0.7082642317,
0.1132441759,
-0.844343245,
-0.0785406902,
-0.6202759147,
0.2475018799,
0.4862138033,
-0.3903530538,
1.0792974234,
0.0942017883,
0.0098038893,
0.2170975804,
0.3955042064,
-0.0862276107,
0.264667362,
0.6242873073,
0.2934673727,
0.3303306997,
-0.1490070224,
0.5207227468,
-0.5503025055,
0.0238556284,
0.8559443951,
0.1961194575,
0.470975101,
0.5292079449,
0.0522167385,
0.1512260437,
0.3644731343,
-0.111037977,
0.7974910736,
0.4063083827,
-0.4392166436,
-0.539393723,
0.3733322918,
-0.498102963,
0.6935119033,
0.5516414046,
-0.6966605186,
0.2653746009,
0.0128348656,
-0.7035164833,
-0.0168953408,
-0.2267011702,
0.7294395566,
-0.0028771749,
-0.5947706699,
0.6748623252,
0.1544412524,
0.8734381199,
-0.7943725586,
0.0525306314,
-0.3549698293,
-0.0751456097,
-0.1047985554,
-0.4061047137,
0.6316080093,
-0.5875582099,
-0.464818269,
-0.2438233197,
0.5091441274,
-0.1693694592,
-0.041064702,
0.1232788712,
0.3871763349,
-0.4105600417,
-0.0361955315,
-0.4934691191,
0.2697484493,
-0.0679956302,
-0.3553924859,
0.2733202577,
0.045845516,
0.1186639071,
0.2631423175,
0.926928401,
0.2150260806,
-0.2425744981,
-0.3217199445,
0.7376677394,
-0.6714250445,
-0.6585134268,
-0.3374507129,
-0.0739149079,
0.4578845501,
-0.3994723558,
0.0141999889,
0.4671251774,
0.9912522435,
-0.5707235336,
0.6770865321,
-0.1060758233,
-0.1351008862,
-0.6119934916,
0.9983311892,
-0.8164556623,
0.3830652237,
0.1355316043,
-0.8770416975,
-0.3044697344,
0.7009519935,
0.2705321312,
0.2282680422,
0.2857981622,
1.0581178665,
-0.4148111343,
0.5341435075,
0.3999175429,
0.1143533066,
-0.1465776712,
0.623721838,
0.5578055382,
-0.4200283587,
0.4553197622,
-0.3701800406,
0.1713474393,
-0.5083908439,
-0.4449973106,
-0.321041435,
-0.7475917339,
0.0616376363,
0.013491651,
0.2776010931,
1.1717807055,
0.794500351,
-0.6336836815,
-0.34101969,
-0.3472805321,
0.3973016441,
-0.6684216261,
-0.2317044437,
-0.0220368411,
-0.0644513369,
-0.7767921686,
1.1191389561,
0.3879057467,
0.0932470262,
-0.2689499259,
-0.195215866,
-0.0690552071,
0.5113115311,
0.1689513475,
0.2512434721,
-0.4185163081,
0.0398107134,
0.1870128661,
-0.1529162526,
0.20355919,
0.8188098073,
-0.5953712463,
0.8424733877,
0.9449617863,
0.5046942234,
0.4692880809,
-0.5750140548,
0.7496384978,
-0.6573744416,
-0.3553590477,
0.2772671282,
0.2472247183,
-0.1013094336,
-0.3327823579,
0.423912555,
0.297889173,
-0.1188716441,
-0.3838691711,
0.2188477367,
-1.0514093637,
-0.5324728489,
0.9536018968,
0.2553600967,
-0.2691316903,
-0.173831135,
-0.3043919802,
0.2850113213,
-0.4185533524,
1.1189007759,
0.1013301387,
0.0260274373,
0.5019450784,
-0.4563587904,
0.6523762345,
0.2883982956,
-0.3608388901,
-0.3423722684,
0.4778868258,
0.4886560142,
0.3965809345,
0.4649917781,
-0.2136104703,
0.9712189436,
0.2819364667,
0.0849442109,
-0.8479222059,
-0.6997686625,
-0.2538357079,
0.5306437016,
-0.2294347733,
-0.1251667291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12851v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12851v2 | Enhancing Coherence of Extractive Summarization with Multitask Learning | 2023-05-22T09:20:58 | 2023-07-21T10:22:53 | Renlong Jie, Xiaojun Meng, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study proposes a multitask learning architecture for extractive
summarization with coherence boosting. The architecture contains an extractive
summarizer and coherent discriminator module. The coherent discriminator is
trained online on the sentence vectors of the augmented textual input, thus
improving its general ability of judging whether the input sentences are
coherent. Meanwhile, we maximize the coherent scores from the coherent
discriminator by updating the parameters of the summarizer. To make the
extractive sentences trainable in a differentiable manner, we introduce two
strategies, including pre-trained converting model (model-based) and converting
matrix (MAT-based) that merge sentence representations. Experiments show that
our proposed method significantly improves the proportion of consecutive
sentences in the extracted summaries based on their positions in the original
article (i.e., automatic sentence-level coherence metric), while the goodness
in terms of other automatic metrics (i.e., Rouge scores and BertScores) are
preserved. Human evaluation also evidences the improvement of coherence and
consistency of the extracted summaries given by our method. | [
-0.3572870791,
-0.5280002356,
0.2760867178,
0.2465597242,
-0.6529223323,
0.4810177684,
-0.2226783931,
-0.675211668,
0.5633480549,
0.2021253705,
-0.311442405,
-0.2705926001,
-0.7412027121,
0.2915963531,
-0.221827969,
1.2915767431,
-0.1232656687,
0.1354047209,
-0.3942664266,
-0.0833845958,
-0.6439007521,
-0.3362166882,
-0.3170454502,
-0.2762938142,
0.3172724843,
0.4616075158,
0.0351921208,
0.436637044,
0.6531193852,
0.3585015237,
0.1535793394,
0.3152601123,
-0.4473593533,
0.503020227,
0.0412825793,
-0.4260068238,
-0.7501537204,
-0.1225456148,
0.4070517719,
0.5492235422,
-0.3627300262,
0.1338840425,
0.6500789523,
0.6648326516,
-0.8010838628,
0.5862923861,
-0.3153660595,
0.0097011253,
-0.0061494429,
-0.3835752904,
-0.4171753526,
-0.2641231716,
0.2636189759,
-0.6951181889,
0.392172575,
-0.0607269816,
1.09291327,
0.1522486955,
-0.2392598987,
-0.2438288033,
-0.4448162913,
0.9947543144,
-0.3672409654,
0.3746529222,
0.330519408,
0.4038641751,
0.3811766207,
-0.5455016494,
-0.2097078413,
-0.0121595934,
-0.0208253935,
0.9246674776,
0.0245875884,
0.171352908,
-0.1839544028,
0.7158327699,
-0.5692375898,
-0.2243721932,
-0.2398161739,
-0.2871641219,
0.8005679846,
0.2769571841,
0.2439273149,
-0.188123554,
-0.3445878625,
-0.2124556303,
-0.2088713199,
0.0535190254,
0.1823897809,
0.1531790644,
-0.3237342536,
0.4679841697,
-0.4856713712,
0.327287823,
0.3384658992,
-0.3320787549,
0.4789572358,
-0.8991777897,
-0.0221738275,
0.2237695307,
0.535615921,
0.294349283,
-0.0786602721,
-0.3862069547,
-0.0464571901,
-0.0393737927,
0.4513352513,
-0.8266239762,
-0.271358788,
0.2767350376,
-0.6697841883,
-0.1067089215,
0.3014968634,
-0.887182653,
0.3098464608,
-0.4789569378,
0.3521502614,
-0.63690418,
-0.1952945292,
0.0141557381,
-0.5687864423,
0.0956246033,
0.5794818997,
-0.9925555587,
0.4117760062,
0.7263388634,
1.0059034824,
-0.6303073764,
-0.4178766608,
-0.56959337,
0.2346031368,
-0.2211466283,
1.1130849123,
-0.0121919783,
-0.1192680672,
-0.2396241426,
-0.1000757962,
-0.190295741,
-0.5919285417,
0.3719985485,
-0.3904543817,
0.4719416201,
-0.2404948771,
-0.5829054117,
-0.4145833254,
0.459307462,
-0.7329764366,
0.8274279833,
-0.0245423075,
-0.6760695577,
0.4630923569,
-0.6956351399,
-0.6968796253,
0.20012936,
0.1294232607,
-0.7599423528,
0.2068988979,
0.2631769478,
0.5476928353,
0.1964520812,
0.3923462331,
-0.1641126424,
-0.2376716286,
-0.1783765554,
-0.4476736784,
0.8989751339,
0.215360105,
0.0343936123,
0.1132220849,
-0.8376233578,
-0.0875306055,
-0.2358252555,
-0.7632194161,
-0.2802420557,
-0.0232417639,
0.0055798129,
0.0178959649,
0.2454211861,
-0.6226058602,
-0.0856533498,
-0.6725341082,
-0.1409067363,
0.3600021303,
0.2064604163,
0.5099593997,
-0.6990753412,
0.5395883322,
0.1556800753,
-0.2082676142,
-0.5721930861,
-0.4587891698,
-0.6639594436,
-0.8381282091,
0.0402992554,
0.6208339334,
-0.7560635209,
0.8195551634,
-0.4428655207,
-0.3329809308,
-0.4034528434,
0.1428672671,
0.4878922403,
0.3629689813,
0.6932786703,
-0.466029495,
-0.6542696953,
-0.4966961443,
-0.5417053699,
0.0484117009,
0.1148734242,
-0.188938722,
0.6258983016,
0.4399662018,
0.9217550159,
-0.6703842878,
-0.456589371,
-0.626039803,
0.3900758624,
-0.0642699301,
0.4896506071,
0.0468550436,
-0.6149669886,
-0.7184688449,
-0.1321060508,
-0.9543908238,
0.1214351729,
-0.1455724835,
0.0906914845,
-0.0980517045,
0.3256879151,
-0.5661557317,
0.2525258362,
0.3642700315,
-0.1273565441,
0.6977675557,
-0.3364954293,
0.2616833448,
-1.6616421938,
-0.0134490076,
-0.2645660043,
-0.5674731135,
-0.4731392562,
0.1542747617,
0.0032055513,
-0.0193088334,
-0.363353014,
0.107695885,
-0.6986678243,
-0.0344967879,
-0.2381729931,
-0.0348852165,
0.4690136015,
0.6053559184,
-0.1087987125,
0.6292514801,
0.2860433757,
-0.551109314,
0.1392742246,
0.3595793247,
-0.4225083292,
0.7426444292,
-0.4457913339,
-0.0576111935,
-0.2709690928,
0.3912307024,
-1.2120976448,
-0.4409478307,
0.0306010898,
-0.3073242009,
0.274929285,
0.2545926273,
-0.217874974,
0.0791577175,
-0.6519494653,
0.1505561322,
0.1532586962,
-0.5440054536,
0.7951807976,
0.350177139,
-0.3562031984,
-0.4696417451,
-0.7408970594,
0.1801117659,
-0.2028557062,
-0.482761085,
0.6013338566,
-0.0225109961,
-0.1474157125,
-0.0973688215,
0.0297260229,
-0.2947290242,
0.3620194197,
0.1658481807,
0.4444892704,
-0.1771324873,
0.0845768973,
0.4672856033,
-0.1118981093,
-0.1600704789,
-0.0998494849,
0.4328089058,
0.0752616227,
-0.0074891383,
-0.808146596,
0.798216939,
0.2595001459,
-0.4021597505,
0.6123803854,
0.5881810188,
-0.2305689752,
-0.0882667005,
-0.28655231,
-0.194675073,
-0.4135247469,
0.7098082304,
-0.3773866296,
-0.8597577214,
0.5007446408,
-0.0115398094,
0.1741035283,
0.6036586165,
0.5635141134,
-0.2403826416,
0.8834590316,
0.6179738045,
0.1481745988,
0.6982976198,
-0.355722785,
-0.0587243028,
-0.7388420105,
-0.1686985642,
-0.2969327867,
-0.0617456846,
-0.0154577959,
0.0421197638,
0.3100508153,
0.3378096521,
0.2431448996,
0.3094762862,
-0.3610076904,
0.615269959,
0.2013000399,
0.2633787692,
0.5357304811,
0.1841260195,
-0.0700306371,
0.0819857866,
-0.5530892611,
-0.1621908396,
0.9531032443,
0.0273131095,
0.3662442863,
0.3540090621,
1.0791579485,
0.1570644379,
0.0795611963,
-0.7569287419,
0.3418217897,
-0.3341211081,
-0.3713260889,
-0.1111642644,
-0.4235244393,
-0.9902350903,
0.5781455636,
-0.2752485275,
-0.5807522535,
0.2186813354,
0.1309975684,
-0.5201838017,
-0.1823973954,
-0.9192768335,
0.6888070703,
-0.0948619097,
-0.2466570288,
-0.445229739,
-0.5037669539,
0.366561383,
0.0904561654,
-0.1076205596,
0.0897253528,
-0.0586466081,
0.8863094449,
-0.3122854531,
0.8666104674,
-0.0198548604,
-0.0013961691,
0.2178038657,
-0.1631908864,
0.3550572097,
-0.1192774326,
0.1726851016,
0.3956458271,
0.0002001716,
-0.3113846183,
-0.3286241889,
0.2025244087,
-0.6661707759,
-0.4700785577,
-0.3447748125,
-0.8285234571,
-0.0594949797,
0.3768605888,
0.4042754471,
0.5634856224,
-0.4376359284,
0.1881337017,
0.2445718348,
0.1623786837,
0.9198743701,
0.2778137028,
0.0338218361,
-0.7847476602,
1.160962224,
0.242279008,
0.402476579,
0.6810013056,
0.313136965,
-0.2242930233,
-0.6058497429,
-0.3588214517,
-0.1285897344,
-0.5561503768,
-0.2665837109,
-0.8467959166,
-0.0388890356,
-0.4663415253,
-0.0936549008,
-0.2332798392,
-0.4443480074,
-0.3817743957,
-0.0320992656,
0.0464107171,
0.5453426838,
0.0720781684,
0.1835802495,
-1.0418176651,
0.3348731399,
0.187529251,
0.0355168618,
0.0932703838,
-0.3566607833,
-0.6874545217,
-0.2814283967,
-0.5531160831,
-0.7301902771,
0.5988332629,
0.5593718886,
0.3708598018,
0.4954556525,
-0.0350448862,
0.9879462719,
-0.3532264531,
0.7395927906,
0.3718950748,
-0.8640445471,
0.3006171286,
-0.1581625491,
0.7306005359,
0.8658536673,
0.2149785459,
-0.0322116986,
-0.7662728429,
-0.3174752295,
-0.552831471,
0.6809810996,
0.0519217663,
-0.1105089635,
0.0944734588,
0.0995390862,
0.5338730216,
0.2681940496,
-0.3131522238,
0.0372378491,
-0.5687815547,
-0.6912243962,
-0.2985918522,
-0.1718985885,
0.0059443545,
-0.2181406915,
0.4576436281,
-0.2222311795,
0.1524481326,
0.3371375203,
-0.4268302321,
0.1604989022,
0.3635616004,
0.591389358,
0.5232601762,
-0.1378462762,
0.3734509051,
0.1754497588,
-0.9172712564,
0.0509750918,
0.2380081415,
-0.0848765075,
0.0107983379,
0.7283536792,
0.4834169149,
0.1805476844,
-0.454898715,
0.638856709,
-0.1568367034,
-0.303047359,
-0.1098356694,
0.075830318,
0.0059425146,
0.2615661621,
0.3231661916,
0.6037696004,
0.3851416111,
-0.4432514012,
0.3216174841,
0.396792084,
-0.2000724673,
-0.5872961283,
0.4529342055,
0.1879858226,
-0.2337222099,
0.0843290836,
-0.3420384228,
-0.4574241936,
0.2600081563,
0.5702652931,
1.0897997618,
-0.3521531224,
0.1985872686,
0.4404574931,
-0.1555825472,
-0.2270465344,
0.3903264999,
-0.6083164811,
-0.7237908244,
-0.5976195931,
-0.5104078054,
-0.2275150716,
-0.4045490623,
-0.8063132763,
0.0860681981,
-0.032835681,
0.1869170964,
0.164019689,
0.2149204761,
-0.1643780917,
-0.1173848733,
-0.176737234,
0.3323573172,
-0.6773421168,
0.8147830367,
0.3543052971,
-0.5758206248,
-0.6330974698,
0.1436506808,
-0.1087089255,
-0.4503584802,
0.4357899427,
0.3592719436,
-0.1360462755,
0.0109857051,
-0.1032575667,
-0.685117662,
1.295081377,
0.676946044,
-0.4553169906,
-0.0851001889,
-0.0571738891,
0.4831733108,
-0.3770844042,
0.2092202455,
0.0309069045,
-0.0743766353,
-0.0646742508,
-0.9047989249,
-0.0974772498,
-0.1420643479,
-0.3524772823,
0.094209455,
-0.5360484123,
1.0442913771,
-0.0970818773,
-0.5602279305,
0.0286688004,
0.7396296859,
0.1603075266,
0.3114892244,
0.3724995553,
0.6622182727,
0.8545520306,
0.0990766585,
1.0940098763,
-0.2823524475,
0.4282523692,
1.4487797022,
-0.1135061234,
1.0855680704,
0.4297161698,
0.1258895099,
0.7342321873,
0.3473710716,
-0.0140070552,
0.769459486,
-0.4238390326,
-0.3672292829,
-0.1800414026,
0.0294331852,
-0.1593566984,
0.6842038035,
-0.0007607543,
-0.2840631604,
-0.5087562203,
0.1923500896,
-0.021483805,
-0.0583819896,
-0.345831126,
1.2796852589,
0.0917464197,
-1.0372083187,
0.4182906449,
-0.1394019872,
0.5954321623,
-0.5303390622,
-0.2618002594,
0.0852937028,
0.4984517992,
-0.432890445,
-0.4195232987,
0.697276175,
-0.1866315454,
-0.2818025053,
-0.3988803625,
0.8007739782,
-0.7222262025,
-0.3948413134,
0.238618046,
0.6847812533,
0.1037121713,
-0.080818221,
-0.578831315,
-0.3745782971,
-0.206304431,
0.114300102,
0.3918170035,
0.0099894134,
0.3174577355,
0.1538833827,
0.6820221543,
0.099649094,
0.0067342613,
-0.0480378047,
0.6721907854,
-0.4195203185,
-1.1115465164,
-1.0006330013,
0.4094446898,
-0.2555945516,
-0.3296642303,
1.1253243685,
0.8969579339,
0.54217875,
-0.1401321143,
0.5230701566,
0.2427496761,
0.4004096687,
-0.5860509276,
0.8397422433,
-0.4779986441,
0.0186107885,
-0.1915184408,
-0.8008713126,
-0.3259215057,
0.2977307737,
0.0350012928,
-0.3016727865,
0.9904338717,
0.518589139,
-0.072572954,
0.3251958787,
0.27358374,
0.0010237771,
0.2081262469,
0.3312841356,
0.6448720098,
-0.422575742,
0.4646614492,
-0.1717582494,
-0.1969528943,
-0.0357642472,
-0.5686488152,
-0.9378405213,
-0.6483547091,
-0.3546541929,
-0.3239166737,
0.1026577801,
0.7660461068,
0.7119663954,
-0.857801497,
-0.3882090151,
-0.3783517182,
0.0239352863,
-0.7449035645,
-0.2785272002,
0.524815321,
-0.6131412387,
-0.556163311,
0.4278931916,
0.5288025737,
-0.1888185591,
-0.1916078925,
-0.0567038208,
-0.482013464,
-0.1589125097,
0.8314682841,
-0.1053651869,
-0.3968094289,
-0.2271225601,
-0.1179082766,
0.0084083565,
0.5310527682,
0.6176792383,
-0.5986031294,
0.5952008367,
0.7067916989,
0.7074117064,
0.5963446498,
0.1944087148,
0.5125528574,
-0.8659245968,
0.0074847611,
0.0572444536,
0.3576889038,
0.1599185765,
-0.4541810751,
-0.0115799969,
0.4123003781,
-0.3757563531,
-0.4412725568,
-0.0253444184,
-1.2282143831,
-0.2052725405,
0.6352951527,
-0.5096777081,
-0.3481869102,
-0.7525328398,
-0.0628207996,
0.4533863962,
-0.470546484,
0.8922702074,
0.6177027822,
-0.3174190521,
-0.1235020012,
-0.119118765,
0.5067573786,
0.4167226255,
-1.2629976273,
-0.0733041242,
0.2477438599,
0.1978969872,
0.5513824821,
0.5972582698,
-0.0916536599,
0.4323343039,
0.1652799845,
0.1191540211,
-0.1739782542,
-0.3364768624,
-0.6160767078,
0.6421986222,
-0.5121586323,
-0.4940341413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12839v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12839v2 | CopyNE: Better Contextual ASR by Copying Named Entities | 2023-05-22T09:03:11 | 2024-05-27T06:35:36 | Shilin Zhou, Zhenghua Li, Yu Hong, Min Zhang, Zhefeng Wang, Baoxing Huai | cs.CL | cs.CL | End-to-end automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems have made significant
progress in general scenarios. However, it remains challenging to transcribe
contextual named entities (NEs) in the contextual ASR scenario. Previous
approaches have attempted to address this by utilizing the NE dictionary. These
approaches treat entities as individual tokens and generate them
token-by-token, which may result in incomplete transcriptions of entities. In
this paper, we treat entities as indivisible wholes and introduce the idea of
copying into ASR. We design a systematic mechanism called CopyNE, which can
copy entities from the NE dictionary. By copying all tokens of an entity at
once, we can reduce errors during entity transcription, ensuring the
completeness of the entity. Experiments demonstrate that CopyNE consistently
improves the accuracy of transcribing entities compared to previous approaches.
Even when based on the strong Whisper, CopyNE still achieves notable
improvements. | [
-0.2157062739,
-0.2661677301,
0.3427531123,
0.3667996526,
-0.4341151118,
-0.0170425661,
-0.2126457989,
-0.5876054168,
0.6940493584,
0.6746692061,
-0.3279739618,
-0.1615943611,
-0.614849627,
0.4751364589,
-1.0193167925,
0.8447973728,
-0.0403797477,
0.0901811719,
-0.0295132957,
-0.3020963967,
-0.194498986,
-0.5192326307,
-1.2036219835,
-0.2085325271,
0.322558552,
0.3284246325,
0.357783705,
0.7665787935,
0.06688115,
0.2975099087,
-0.4546204209,
0.0435516834,
-0.1692373753,
0.3656788766,
-0.2439278215,
-0.1113424525,
-0.5000144243,
-0.463683337,
0.8008776903,
0.797596693,
-0.120035693,
-0.0026105102,
0.0770880878,
0.3399192691,
-0.4842470884,
-0.1130415201,
-0.7321771383,
-0.116458036,
-0.0075800815,
-0.3057704866,
-0.2775538862,
-0.1384003758,
0.4746097922,
-0.7842541337,
0.0920593664,
-0.066955179,
0.5735886097,
0.1897351891,
-0.5747340322,
-0.6238523722,
-0.7419455051,
0.3579435647,
-0.659196794,
0.4965547025,
0.0614142269,
-0.0801316127,
0.0343540721,
-1.0229941607,
-0.8717115521,
-0.2503219843,
0.0944645405,
0.0421750806,
-0.1345470399,
-0.0910415128,
0.3336966038,
0.0853261128,
-0.1357719451,
-0.1544156671,
-0.4603520334,
-0.380469501,
0.3305384219,
-0.303735882,
0.6686418653,
-0.2676832378,
-0.6414080858,
-0.1184426844,
-0.6109268665,
-0.290025413,
0.1733687967,
0.4122391939,
0.3733206093,
0.5633040071,
-0.1864587963,
0.5173091292,
0.3094854951,
0.0830956399,
0.4124808013,
-0.3998908699,
-0.2539626658,
0.7110620737,
0.4764309824,
0.4938116372,
0.2263251692,
-0.6180061698,
-0.4704704881,
-0.2332727611,
0.3713004589,
-0.746163547,
-0.2123192698,
-0.1083991975,
-0.4329776764,
0.0550941192,
0.0510698371,
-0.5545885563,
0.0380634852,
-0.9729571342,
0.5772843361,
-0.5072724223,
-0.2516354322,
-0.2600906491,
-0.2387998104,
0.0064781155,
0.4213170409,
-0.6513382792,
0.7128170729,
0.6600912213,
1.0028909445,
-0.575022459,
-0.4514671564,
-0.8599362969,
0.654843688,
-0.1421314031,
0.7850412726,
-0.2254404724,
-0.6550852656,
-0.3310460448,
0.0758196563,
-0.0748743415,
-0.7771217823,
0.2929548621,
-0.3890907466,
0.0004381956,
-0.3609870076,
-0.8710495234,
-0.1443591416,
-0.0036149933,
-0.7768383026,
0.5891270041,
-0.1558413506,
-0.3834016323,
0.4759898484,
-0.569663763,
-0.7293694019,
-0.077051878,
0.0601159036,
-0.0653750971,
0.1726857573,
0.3771050572,
0.1761127263,
-0.095553562,
0.0916391388,
0.1292804182,
-0.291446358,
0.3034401834,
-0.3344769478,
0.7116864324,
0.2439496666,
-0.6605308056,
0.2522518039,
-0.7619685531,
0.0288168192,
-0.24033086,
-0.1998414546,
-0.6315354705,
-0.1492367387,
0.4810177684,
0.1355048716,
-0.0762477592,
-0.5278921723,
0.0227436163,
-0.3571339548,
0.5713330507,
0.5900508165,
0.2717037201,
1.2387689352,
-0.2787279189,
0.2507463396,
0.1368207484,
0.000091134,
0.1981440485,
-0.0975893065,
-0.7845982909,
-0.4653634131,
0.5655216575,
0.5634399056,
-0.6508737206,
0.3903243244,
-0.4960301816,
0.0013929181,
-0.2750086486,
0.1580750644,
0.4131065607,
0.7475786805,
0.55646348,
-0.6219577193,
-0.7814583182,
-0.8547886014,
-0.0878960192,
-0.0971930623,
-0.0866657719,
0.5393399596,
0.2953447998,
-0.3037448525,
0.6828970313,
0.152727291,
-0.4682213068,
-0.0285974368,
-0.1124068946,
-0.1253808439,
0.597958982,
0.2876649201,
-0.9165399075,
-0.4218908548,
-0.2394954264,
-0.5196496248,
-0.1575415134,
-0.3911160231,
-0.2791123986,
0.3180392087,
0.9469303489,
-0.5105859637,
0.3029316664,
0.1101627797,
-0.4277528822,
0.1697547138,
0.0188033823,
0.0220693145,
-1.3121398687,
0.1740977913,
-0.4957593679,
-0.4648866355,
-0.5283334255,
-0.2173096985,
-0.008212571,
-0.0375044979,
-0.6183850765,
0.7489306927,
-0.7812747955,
-0.2422675043,
-0.2315691859,
0.2075276971,
-0.2403367013,
0.0739852786,
0.2007292211,
0.8588311076,
0.5293622613,
-0.7756508589,
0.2300573885,
0.5086231232,
-0.156744957,
0.9666111469,
-0.7131279707,
0.2066719979,
-0.1839369684,
0.3240112662,
-0.1900984794,
0.0150749199,
0.1742313802,
-0.4020302892,
0.7132940292,
-0.1431117058,
-0.2274614722,
0.1405070275,
0.1905623674,
0.2976234853,
0.378038615,
-0.6498774886,
0.7089666724,
0.4544722438,
-0.1367388517,
-0.4565769136,
-0.8102869391,
0.6171898842,
-0.2389756292,
-0.275244236,
0.6709427834,
0.0236377232,
-0.0688126236,
0.4029991031,
-0.5522835851,
-0.0755887926,
-0.1312132329,
0.1787451059,
0.0804253668,
-0.1728770882,
-0.0381003954,
-0.1231048331,
-0.3055520356,
-0.0269011166,
-0.8070230484,
0.2351659983,
0.0519887917,
-0.1601644754,
-0.5019543171,
0.7288241386,
0.7482964396,
-0.0024487886,
0.3440874815,
0.1160521433,
-0.5083268881,
-0.4046496749,
-0.5587384701,
-0.4315504432,
-0.380120337,
0.3296531141,
-0.4884095788,
-0.7584225535,
0.5206906796,
-0.0984221473,
-0.1060469747,
0.11533463,
0.2156863362,
-0.0848155394,
0.3650642335,
0.2421970218,
-0.1968131661,
0.756688714,
-0.2495283186,
0.096631892,
-1.416428566,
-0.276022017,
-0.305996418,
-0.5458265543,
-0.1077240109,
-0.3436460197,
0.0493913889,
0.2556981742,
-0.230558157,
0.8953763843,
-0.696341455,
0.564663887,
0.9392233491,
0.1153264791,
0.3339366019,
0.2364475578,
-0.0587227158,
0.1832335293,
-0.3490276933,
-0.5394541621,
0.908623457,
-0.1665256768,
0.5467991233,
0.1753349155,
1.1798144579,
0.0777531713,
0.0931057259,
-0.6641756296,
0.6704147458,
-0.2956567407,
-0.4423123002,
-0.4226738214,
-0.5029787421,
-0.6489168406,
-0.0064414418,
0.1312078685,
-0.8838475943,
0.4773316085,
0.223673895,
-0.2870626152,
0.3584722877,
-0.3185674846,
0.5548407435,
-0.0846793875,
0.0587800555,
0.0297110528,
-0.6043074131,
-0.2634470761,
0.1124043912,
-0.2638401389,
0.1526840031,
-0.2216510624,
0.7914360762,
-0.611323297,
0.5424460173,
-0.2243034244,
0.0807673559,
0.4760988653,
0.3257866204,
0.51554811,
0.2137806565,
-0.1673248857,
0.0440844856,
0.0209332947,
0.0296133235,
-0.7508973479,
0.850225091,
-0.5897626877,
-0.1456612349,
-0.1489779353,
-0.0378253832,
0.0878955722,
0.299069494,
0.6291223764,
0.8405256867,
-0.0555706806,
0.2405422926,
0.6452901959,
0.2771582007,
0.4670787156,
0.3666256368,
0.0171487723,
-0.6569599509,
0.9237024188,
0.2719376087,
0.2851216793,
0.4129877687,
-0.3047280908,
-0.4520338476,
-0.3689742684,
-0.6650021672,
-0.0939282849,
-0.9079120755,
-0.2541749477,
-0.9977033138,
-0.3275333941,
-0.2543720007,
-0.4901468456,
-0.5702187419,
-0.7902393341,
-0.644931376,
-0.0032930926,
0.1857213527,
0.3502875268,
-0.1947956383,
0.0903674215,
-0.5908896327,
0.5393416882,
0.6228139997,
0.1414594203,
0.1519340277,
-0.613376677,
0.4938364923,
0.1096071228,
0.2376678586,
-0.9258339405,
0.2685593069,
0.550332427,
0.5030285716,
-0.0225019921,
-0.0981020555,
0.9381614923,
-0.7250617743,
0.5667609572,
0.2844802439,
-1.4519706964,
0.5301460624,
0.1415378451,
0.1869864613,
0.8702429533,
-0.1314666122,
-0.9518396854,
-0.1802155674,
-0.5770437717,
-1.2839683294,
0.6063619852,
0.2869445384,
0.1629638672,
-0.1936806887,
0.5375506282,
-0.0293253474,
0.1574956626,
-0.4347079098,
-0.2945665419,
-0.4168291688,
-0.3763401806,
0.065234676,
-0.2556577921,
0.0988128409,
-0.1751891971,
0.7847746611,
-0.1790945977,
0.475738883,
0.8103480935,
-0.5240320563,
0.1150572449,
0.3335264623,
0.5313067436,
0.5205626488,
0.2163077146,
0.2470997721,
0.4958267808,
-0.4776849151,
0.3008376956,
-0.0443047769,
-0.7910891771,
0.2323650271,
0.3068738878,
0.9220213294,
0.6652188301,
-0.4484077394,
0.7023342252,
-0.0962607414,
-0.205314815,
-0.7487295866,
-0.0894088745,
0.1361548007,
0.3359072804,
0.1105091348,
0.3869898319,
0.5248129368,
-0.6154716611,
0.6218938231,
0.091980353,
-0.58142519,
-0.2945357263,
0.7532895207,
0.214493826,
-0.5591837764,
1.0319149494,
-0.1218342632,
-0.6963723302,
0.6237258315,
0.8695508242,
1.1242752075,
0.011386496,
-0.0045331069,
0.3696628809,
0.1213543937,
-0.4722213745,
0.3670755923,
-0.445508182,
-0.6683067679,
-0.4725512564,
-0.6215158105,
-0.4663481116,
-0.3048829734,
-0.8593407869,
0.0959144235,
-0.3319737017,
0.0708037242,
0.0406099409,
-0.6488127708,
-0.7285906672,
0.1766546816,
0.3046155274,
0.8609257936,
-0.2237516046,
0.7982240319,
0.8712735772,
-0.4103219509,
-0.9923520088,
0.0323019065,
-0.0050806506,
-0.3670673668,
0.801276505,
0.0819558874,
-0.0746636391,
0.2445996851,
-0.2123445272,
-1.2177077532,
0.9571335912,
0.2004759014,
-0.8211340904,
-0.2599436641,
-0.3230852187,
0.2271405458,
-0.3800899684,
0.0648637563,
0.3595893979,
0.448682785,
0.2672448754,
-1.2048296928,
0.2588215768,
-0.241551742,
0.0514742509,
0.1865516603,
-0.2726992369,
0.5665689111,
-0.0968630239,
-0.3936732709,
0.0439704135,
0.7755429149,
-0.159645915,
0.1211479753,
0.8064505458,
0.4326931834,
0.9392667413,
0.1669109464,
0.8090133071,
-0.1878841668,
-0.1524283141,
1.5681549311,
-0.5182040334,
0.9662104845,
0.6720260978,
0.3443938494,
0.3703481257,
-0.0519030578,
0.0356236696,
0.8153696656,
0.1993534416,
-0.4863647521,
-0.1372718811,
-0.0367695466,
0.0381694399,
0.5627532005,
0.0117151933,
-0.3139373064,
0.0802209228,
0.3460230529,
-0.0548414104,
-0.0454893038,
-0.3842684627,
1.3118944168,
0.2882550955,
-0.6335050464,
0.1008611992,
-0.3922630548,
0.6911705732,
-0.3668923378,
0.0358473063,
0.0584794022,
0.211294964,
-0.0349704213,
-0.3865109384,
0.7040556669,
-0.0679212883,
-0.3784850836,
-0.487803936,
0.7270915508,
-0.7331877947,
-0.2382064313,
0.4433991909,
0.2658011913,
0.1826408207,
-0.3470562398,
-0.4328231514,
-0.0881270096,
0.1092184335,
-0.0650123954,
-0.0120053859,
0.4910317659,
-0.1495442241,
0.62161237,
0.715780139,
0.5180649757,
0.1105732173,
0.1717341542,
0.5895446539,
-0.7773082256,
-0.6262159348,
-0.7117725015,
0.3823819757,
-0.4378103912,
-0.4637623131,
0.5526254177,
0.5322440267,
0.9619294405,
0.0294452067,
0.5506222248,
-0.1699726433,
0.4972968102,
-0.5324500203,
0.7608858347,
-0.4086389542,
0.096210897,
-0.3486050069,
-1.2801668644,
-0.2525641024,
0.8308796883,
0.3585398197,
-0.270845294,
0.7274637222,
0.6168596148,
-0.2260670662,
0.0939400867,
0.0749723092,
0.1332670003,
0.2425076514,
0.3928951621,
0.7313725948,
-0.5609003305,
0.5050907135,
-0.3320070505,
0.0620015673,
-0.068824552,
-0.799071312,
-0.6596454978,
-0.7525071502,
-0.5713377595,
-0.3297388852,
0.1768352389,
1.2293821573,
0.9511090517,
-1.0007041693,
0.1088281572,
-0.202546224,
-0.068929404,
-0.2636964619,
-0.1825579703,
0.3898408413,
-0.028193092,
-0.6935030222,
0.6875416636,
0.3075407147,
0.2480093539,
0.3076485693,
-0.0713431612,
0.1233348399,
0.0091176378,
0.5613552928,
0.2859777212,
-0.7071484327,
-0.5104487538,
0.0350435451,
-0.035706237,
-0.2469685078,
1.050157547,
-0.7282301784,
0.4541706741,
0.3081589341,
0.6993758082,
0.5979521275,
-0.029444471,
0.6548988819,
-0.5609698892,
-0.0400716029,
0.5563462973,
0.4824057221,
0.5757397413,
-0.254930377,
0.3909978271,
0.1979862005,
-0.4935361445,
-0.5756094456,
-0.0463513732,
-1.1386497021,
-0.1947651207,
1.1613696814,
0.0582900904,
-0.2637773752,
-0.0092946365,
-0.3479081988,
0.4246690571,
-0.6730967164,
0.3964400887,
0.3196656704,
0.0814643651,
0.0315046906,
-0.3732230663,
0.4360512197,
0.3818697929,
-0.4738180041,
-0.070819445,
0.5119894147,
0.7181943059,
0.13908346,
0.8130725622,
-0.0745631158,
0.264575243,
0.0032217759,
0.1368927807,
-0.25014323,
-0.4509517252,
-0.3440935314,
0.1029724702,
-0.28834337,
-0.1707144082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12835v1 | Open-Domain Event Graph Induction for Mitigating Framing Bias | 2023-05-22T08:57:42 | 2023-05-22T08:57:42 | Siyi Liu, Hongming Zhang, Hongwei Wang, Kaiqiang Song, Dan Roth, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Researchers have proposed various information extraction (IE) techniques to
convert news articles into structured knowledge for news understanding.
However, none of the existing methods have explicitly addressed the issue of
framing bias that is inherent in news articles. We argue that studying and
identifying framing bias is a crucial step towards trustworthy event
understanding. We propose a novel task, neutral event graph induction, to
address this problem. An event graph is a network of events and their temporal
relations. Our task aims to induce such structural knowledge with minimal
framing bias in an open domain. We propose a three-step framework to induce a
neutral event graph from multiple input sources. The process starts by inducing
an event graph from each input source, then merging them into one merged event
graph, and lastly using a Graph Convolutional Network to remove event nodes
with biased connotations. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework
through the use of graph prediction metrics and bias-focused metrics. | [
-0.5933871865,
-1.0164721012,
0.502818644,
-0.1025775895,
-0.2697157562,
-0.0149235567,
-0.0403192565,
-0.5031452179,
0.2867848575,
0.4356325567,
-0.7099163532,
-0.4525068402,
-0.6400070786,
-0.2571074069,
-0.2324414104,
1.2569282055,
-0.3035655022,
0.2647566199,
0.181582123,
-0.370537132,
-0.2668276131,
-0.1856766492,
-0.7266206145,
-0.6598732471,
0.1206868887,
0.1966526657,
0.741768837,
0.5310824513,
-0.0850826204,
0.0596225373,
-0.0442851745,
0.2378124744,
-0.7127410173,
-0.0828598961,
-0.4620649815,
-0.1505296081,
-0.4571685195,
0.3599000573,
0.6679952741,
0.9325757027,
0.3213798702,
0.2767722309,
0.3009378314,
0.6061629057,
-0.8283661604,
0.3847239017,
-0.7349162698,
0.4185487032,
-0.4612932205,
-0.3103977442,
-0.6025468111,
-0.278329134,
-0.125045374,
-0.8170087337,
0.5631601214,
0.0282077249,
0.9327713251,
-0.0539387949,
-0.6872104406,
-0.0176075362,
-0.5875548124,
0.3775347769,
-0.2009500414,
0.382961452,
0.2457951456,
0.0630310699,
-0.1665965021,
-0.4561826289,
-0.5533810258,
0.3538511693,
-0.0590527803,
0.1983001679,
-0.3349760473,
-0.1301925331,
0.2768466473,
-0.1728532016,
-0.499673605,
-0.0382092819,
-0.3699555993,
-0.2171095014,
0.4086697102,
0.0499297678,
0.3975487947,
-0.2071823478,
-0.405788213,
0.4786479771,
-0.7577592731,
-0.1355044544,
0.6035110354,
0.3535538316,
-0.1923847347,
0.8122603297,
-0.4500010908,
0.4609629512,
0.4385168254,
0.2241740227,
0.4702021778,
-0.5645235777,
-0.1203369871,
0.6984962225,
0.5895329714,
0.6714863181,
0.4342056215,
-0.3343701363,
0.213991195,
0.3004493117,
0.1177656576,
-0.8779925704,
0.1161279976,
-0.0906887427,
-0.6670190096,
-0.4529311657,
0.0577356517,
-0.9339879751,
-0.5160799623,
-0.1492412537,
0.2468077987,
-0.205877617,
-0.3245237768,
-0.0152696995,
-0.5472275615,
0.0478151217,
0.3263379037,
-0.4336104989,
0.1342678517,
0.5035929084,
0.7661489844,
-0.1180678681,
-0.114620246,
-1.0080182552,
0.356605798,
-0.3074137866,
0.5151484609,
-0.4968906939,
0.0294176564,
0.1862160116,
0.0455655716,
0.2005965114,
-0.1818524748,
0.4859729409,
-0.8948557973,
0.3903405964,
-0.0218476057,
-0.4612924755,
-0.0534917787,
0.2134993076,
-0.7819339037,
0.6370613575,
0.2009417117,
-1.16401577,
0.6857867241,
-0.746271193,
-0.6026785374,
-0.1455400735,
-0.2492026687,
-0.6055147052,
-0.1239361912,
0.7414634228,
0.283043921,
0.145530805,
0.4413739741,
-0.8016471863,
-0.0931193903,
-0.0128596388,
-0.2282058746,
0.9530356526,
0.0995590761,
-0.5670466423,
-0.1283021271,
-0.5401209593,
-0.2588173151,
0.089651078,
0.0684114546,
-0.4041672051,
0.082495667,
-0.2532168031,
-0.0575787835,
-0.2139069289,
-0.8668897748,
-0.013582658,
-0.4171251357,
0.2738271356,
0.8241296411,
0.5311462283,
0.991807878,
-0.0710323304,
0.1867189556,
0.3487818241,
-0.0291789863,
-0.1070665494,
-0.6687322855,
-0.2734399438,
0.0686221793,
0.0549844168,
0.244984448,
-0.9709368944,
0.272505939,
-0.1365243047,
0.1145613343,
-0.024979623,
-0.0236857664,
0.2527459562,
0.8500007391,
0.260794878,
-0.503390789,
-0.724467814,
-0.5882413387,
-0.547186017,
0.2546290755,
0.0730673969,
-0.0793882906,
0.2115739584,
0.0350122228,
0.9768356681,
-0.5312542915,
-0.4688362777,
-0.0133584561,
0.3719124496,
0.1891344786,
0.3868677616,
0.5971179605,
-0.6126701832,
-0.2423672527,
0.0120646032,
-0.9124327302,
-0.0800759494,
-0.0173186474,
-0.3030181825,
0.1255464256,
0.5658511519,
-0.4812846482,
0.8425498605,
0.3262652159,
-0.5371249318,
0.5223063231,
0.6751451492,
0.0364553928,
-1.0676970482,
-0.2191072106,
0.1618726552,
-0.3627985418,
-0.6249620318,
-0.4742027521,
-0.1782478839,
-0.3715704083,
-0.4243316352,
0.7267305851,
-0.4718298614,
-0.1346991956,
-0.1796942353,
0.5527879596,
0.3822105527,
0.4258779883,
-0.0323252343,
0.3292625546,
0.3282355368,
-0.468052417,
-0.1202253476,
0.5189880133,
-0.5452950001,
0.4869011045,
-0.0749100447,
0.0507183708,
-0.4421883523,
0.4175755084,
-0.7011826634,
-0.0401148535,
0.6297241449,
-0.6804084778,
0.2627558708,
-0.4224072695,
0.0041476004,
-0.0556999296,
-0.3227590322,
0.5453032851,
0.0669188723,
-0.70373106,
0.3320972621,
0.4725079536,
0.0327011347,
-0.855883956,
-0.5583071709,
-0.155361712,
0.2380236685,
-0.6051232815,
0.4016108215,
0.3272506297,
-0.3077083826,
0.7779317498,
-0.453243345,
-0.0112483231,
-0.09894602,
0.2298367172,
0.1382266283,
-0.4388969839,
-0.0125535531,
0.319319725,
-0.3094945252,
-0.1114253253,
-0.7860870361,
0.3655483723,
0.1996570528,
-0.5812426209,
-0.7641428113,
0.4265090525,
0.4795674384,
-0.3622386754,
0.7245702744,
0.8520903587,
-0.654749155,
-0.4093383849,
-0.3433073461,
-0.3262209892,
-0.3409551978,
0.4269473851,
-0.0234411936,
-0.9601963162,
0.4368829429,
-0.1732237339,
-0.2916483879,
0.3654282987,
0.6764541864,
0.2371312827,
1.3651611805,
0.3146756291,
-0.2065345943,
0.8044406772,
-0.2067093998,
0.4371016622,
-0.789049089,
-0.128366679,
-0.3611255288,
-0.3765379786,
-0.1338533759,
-0.2867332399,
0.2871950865,
0.2384065539,
-0.4550402761,
-0.0687376931,
-0.337392807,
0.5094074011,
0.3187811971,
0.3292019069,
0.3134587109,
0.0909453034,
-0.0910523608,
0.263569802,
-0.8000543118,
-0.2371253669,
1.1326189041,
0.137317732,
0.6391316652,
-0.2675123513,
0.5933958292,
0.3798363805,
0.6939436197,
-0.4733379185,
0.165891543,
0.2300647795,
-0.9548235536,
-0.2989167869,
-0.3885984719,
-0.8300510049,
0.1251653284,
-0.2942636907,
-0.9691818357,
0.5531597137,
-0.1574461609,
-0.0139236543,
0.6155257225,
-0.5390436649,
0.6670576334,
0.2438925058,
-0.4962918162,
-0.0746757239,
-0.2941612899,
0.5313597322,
0.1946862638,
0.4442132711,
-0.496370554,
0.3285727203,
0.8644004464,
-0.1271968633,
0.8690467477,
-0.3846087158,
0.5084294677,
0.4809420407,
0.2261044383,
0.7097774148,
0.4964888096,
-0.301494956,
0.2154330313,
-0.3956220746,
-0.4009844661,
-0.5064014196,
0.2677218914,
-0.7873287797,
-0.281844914,
-0.0176028293,
-0.4657654464,
-0.2844959497,
0.433381021,
0.2955500185,
0.6847252846,
-0.5307278633,
0.1004084274,
0.3263186216,
0.3506446183,
0.496032387,
0.3529019356,
-0.0662603155,
-0.5158977509,
0.4194879532,
0.1818068475,
0.0275929607,
0.0934421718,
0.0288072377,
0.0606761612,
-0.5511519909,
-0.5483059287,
-0.1671313047,
-0.7141872644,
-0.4243359566,
-0.647822082,
-0.1894656718,
-0.4626223445,
-0.5640065074,
-0.2818984985,
-0.5635046363,
-0.4569408,
-0.6317965388,
-0.1478693187,
0.5055137277,
-0.1092138141,
0.2517940104,
-0.6220754981,
0.4725090265,
0.0307346024,
0.4450417757,
0.0638538152,
-0.0760328546,
-0.2790979147,
0.0507150404,
-0.625010848,
-1.0858724117,
0.2768564522,
0.0677800328,
0.7877745628,
0.8476951122,
0.3138017654,
0.226899907,
-0.6192945242,
0.8432076573,
0.5181557536,
-1.1431951523,
0.6971771121,
-0.3898214102,
-0.1100924313,
0.4111690521,
0.6841627955,
-0.0881563053,
-0.5783935785,
-0.8392739892,
-0.5120623112,
0.9743227959,
0.3219669163,
-0.0480467491,
-0.1767542958,
0.4302770197,
0.117322728,
0.287427932,
-0.8501364589,
-0.0514637083,
-0.4936298132,
-0.0163757019,
-0.0277108084,
-0.1061301082,
-0.6062063575,
-0.1976631284,
0.7136331797,
-0.476718545,
0.279679507,
0.3607797623,
-0.2001866847,
-0.512221694,
0.0802300796,
0.2225269079,
0.7907387614,
-0.1567742527,
0.3115759492,
0.1604593396,
-0.275162518,
0.0535851903,
0.070744805,
-0.4584945738,
0.1530871689,
0.4833128154,
0.8165187836,
0.1062711701,
0.0745040327,
0.7548831105,
0.1239682734,
-0.4047723413,
0.1565470695,
-0.1890106499,
-0.2036030889,
0.4007095098,
0.3756465912,
0.1717049927,
0.0823305249,
-0.5978246927,
0.6318593025,
0.5193808079,
-0.7913014293,
-0.4466776848,
0.9222108126,
0.3420398235,
-0.2442367971,
0.5841719508,
-0.4533868134,
-0.5362921953,
0.5755889416,
0.7178052068,
0.9512427449,
0.0862536207,
0.3581114709,
0.4244934022,
0.4060854316,
0.3517060876,
0.1338352859,
0.0065419683,
-1.3310344219,
-0.4889889657,
-0.5426598787,
-0.4018339515,
-0.0139398109,
-0.6733015776,
0.3450881541,
-0.260320276,
-0.324367553,
0.3504226208,
-0.0442758687,
-0.6764589548,
-0.0077903238,
0.3274426758,
0.9046436548,
-1.1653754711,
0.7697220445,
0.4720921218,
-0.4030883014,
-0.3431345522,
0.1203934401,
0.3764176667,
-0.7504131198,
0.4595496058,
0.2675036788,
0.0970199183,
-0.1132654324,
-0.4970953166,
-0.4037689567,
0.8249976039,
0.5756481886,
-0.0385866053,
-0.0180927292,
-0.1043723524,
-0.0013468446,
-0.7981210351,
-0.0911261961,
0.2526941895,
0.5351579785,
-0.1488327533,
-0.358510375,
0.3670148849,
-0.1668441743,
-0.3599103093,
0.3569021225,
-0.3465601802,
0.5964913964,
-0.0903882906,
-0.2507711053,
-0.5923855901,
0.6437112689,
-0.1549151689,
0.9957814217,
0.3941566348,
0.4914407134,
0.8452444673,
-0.0250176322,
0.6751984358,
-0.4280689657,
0.3836278021,
1.1417708397,
-0.5598925352,
0.1595718414,
0.2909889817,
0.2590807378,
0.6375363469,
0.2790924311,
0.2233575433,
0.6604452133,
-0.1120120659,
-0.2985827625,
-0.1789492667,
-0.2364419699,
-0.4068744481,
0.3411390483,
0.3235045671,
-0.4417739213,
-0.8655740619,
0.2908658385,
0.3795565963,
-0.0091215288,
-0.4606669247,
0.5891416669,
0.0262252707,
-0.6443340778,
-0.028566191,
0.0137447855,
0.0581578985,
-0.4955294728,
0.1499050409,
-0.0461914241,
0.2118301392,
-0.2616898417,
-0.8235557675,
0.7262614965,
-0.2899413407,
-0.4105724692,
-0.3144157231,
1.0294322968,
-0.150876075,
-0.0428270437,
0.5128363371,
0.5461697578,
-0.4061958492,
-0.222079277,
-0.2438894063,
0.1681417376,
-0.0886426121,
-0.4645889997,
0.4082359374,
0.5395767689,
-0.1934687197,
0.0583612435,
0.8032888174,
-0.1870741695,
-0.0588840917,
0.0426481105,
0.9286774397,
-0.3613176942,
-0.5533928275,
-0.880518198,
0.4356504381,
-0.4235193133,
-0.1462696046,
0.7640534639,
0.6476354599,
0.8963850141,
0.1780964881,
0.9214345217,
0.2197195441,
-0.0451523475,
-0.4536916912,
0.7901468873,
-0.2398503125,
-0.3622505367,
-0.1848798394,
-0.8106162548,
-0.3981082439,
0.1612244695,
-0.3500694335,
-0.3815096915,
0.7334396243,
0.6484766603,
-0.1618031263,
0.5787295699,
0.0402046964,
0.175470978,
0.2843484282,
0.3724866807,
0.6743718386,
-0.0940772668,
0.4787856936,
-0.1066357493,
-0.5540949106,
-0.2363053858,
-1.1348079443,
-0.9548947215,
-0.4634740055,
-0.4525739253,
-0.802182436,
0.3232804537,
0.507863462,
0.8942412138,
-0.8137617707,
0.2458571494,
-0.1519141197,
0.7594457865,
-0.3594312668,
-0.2672002912,
0.3660681844,
-0.5799999833,
-0.4404711127,
0.4112955332,
0.3443744183,
-0.374679625,
0.0959378481,
0.2033269405,
-0.2487670034,
0.2601168454,
0.6608384848,
0.2520360947,
-0.0974491611,
-0.8520971537,
-0.4247840643,
0.1568531841,
0.2471530139,
0.9283484221,
-0.8022017479,
0.6516305208,
0.5537088513,
0.5138463974,
1.0084205866,
-0.0600747429,
0.6095522046,
-1.0102696419,
0.3928873241,
0.0727938786,
0.3282148838,
-0.06805107,
-0.5691417456,
0.6153107285,
0.6103064418,
-0.279418081,
-0.9824077487,
0.4206656814,
-0.9487966299,
-0.228074342,
1.0059547424,
0.2653522491,
-0.3971774578,
-0.4242585003,
0.0484915935,
0.5468622446,
-0.1326160282,
0.3720970452,
0.4880361557,
-0.4298167825,
0.2412530035,
-0.5372564793,
0.3271118104,
-0.2110747546,
-0.4879994392,
-0.1067298204,
0.3803472519,
0.3213740289,
0.2541075945,
1.0177174807,
-0.2509048879,
0.2345468104,
0.2962636352,
0.2227721065,
-0.2849033773,
-0.3912343979,
-0.0317129456,
0.6294426322,
-0.4871256053,
-0.4703100324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12829v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12829v3 | On Bias and Fairness in NLP: Investigating the Impact of Bias and Debiasing in Language Models on the Fairness of Toxicity Detection | 2023-05-22T08:44:00 | 2024-04-26T08:50:12 | Fatma Elsafoury, Stamos Katsigiannis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models are the new state-of-the-art natural language processing
(NLP) models and they are being increasingly used in many NLP tasks. Even
though there is evidence that language models are biased, the impact of that
bias on the fairness of downstream NLP tasks is still understudied.
Furthermore, despite that numerous debiasing methods have been proposed in the
literature, the impact of bias removal methods on the fairness of NLP tasks is
also understudied. In this work, we investigate three different sources of bias
in NLP models, i.e. representation bias, selection bias and overamplification
bias, and examine how they impact the fairness of the downstream task of
toxicity detection. Moreover, we investigate the impact of removing these
biases using different bias removal techniques on the fairness of toxicity
detection. Results show strong evidence that downstream sources of bias,
especially overamplification bias, are the most impactful types of bias on the
fairness of the task of toxicity detection. We also found strong evidence that
removing overamplification bias by fine-tuning the language models on a dataset
with balanced contextual representations and ratios of positive examples
between different identity groups can improve the fairness of the task of
toxicity detection. Finally, we build on our findings and introduce a list of
guidelines to ensure the fairness of the task of toxicity detection. | [
-0.2038831711,
-0.5521251559,
0.559069097,
0.2980052829,
0.0044905082,
-0.4252901673,
0.0105498005,
-0.7022280693,
-0.1357047409,
0.8301725388,
-0.3086858988,
-0.4940431714,
-0.8050439954,
0.0726621971,
-0.193913132,
1.3618359566,
0.5119177699,
0.4558824897,
-0.0717603415,
-0.3684875071,
-0.6953029037,
-0.6562635303,
-0.7936967015,
-0.6150764823,
0.6478142738,
0.0704209358,
0.7630140185,
0.5304381251,
0.4992833734,
0.2467215806,
-0.619433105,
-0.421327889,
-0.4327041805,
0.2234281003,
-0.7404537797,
-0.628475666,
-0.4879003763,
0.2643375099,
0.3220077753,
0.669347167,
-0.1927789748,
0.2882090807,
0.1421659142,
0.8127523661,
-0.9862238765,
0.0998665392,
-0.8403724432,
0.3441615999,
-0.2548932731,
-0.1001689285,
-0.4868195951,
-0.29712677,
0.095945254,
-0.2993986011,
-0.0278337449,
-0.0393504277,
0.4704042077,
0.4644801319,
-0.6391637325,
-0.5533062816,
-0.6246412396,
1.1795047522,
-1.0683728456,
0.180525288,
0.2662072182,
0.1744544208,
-0.005990976,
-0.5683127046,
-0.44823277,
-0.0124304397,
-0.147827521,
0.0362133719,
-0.2362748384,
0.2235024869,
0.6554662585,
0.2957517505,
-0.2099978626,
0.2923201621,
-0.1725049913,
-0.1792508811,
0.5700654387,
0.0485137366,
0.4467395246,
-0.4604442716,
-0.2411429435,
0.305313468,
-0.5205932856,
-0.2876261175,
0.4605067372,
0.2446125895,
0.3340552747,
0.3837122619,
-0.1632213593,
0.4501154125,
-0.2358237654,
0.0985080153,
0.3337193727,
-0.3005375564,
-0.1742488444,
0.1357323825,
0.6099225879,
0.5711992979,
0.2780246437,
-0.0572288632,
-0.1115884781,
0.2983581424,
0.2323799729,
-0.7167799473,
-0.0849856883,
0.191388607,
-0.92218858,
-0.650975883,
-0.5773903728,
-0.9835343361,
-0.7462717295,
-0.053436555,
0.4908899665,
0.1235726178,
-0.4318919778,
0.3620978594,
-0.2653922141,
0.0689295381,
0.0681024641,
-0.9348430634,
0.4912644327,
0.5406463146,
0.6155604124,
-0.087726593,
0.0978808179,
-0.7206405997,
-0.0028875342,
0.1173066571,
0.6382915378,
-0.6011018157,
-0.1302891225,
-0.1083047315,
-0.125836283,
0.2206440717,
-0.814896524,
0.9979785085,
-0.4048801661,
0.5067688227,
-0.8858406544,
-0.4667190313,
-0.3864457309,
0.2170903981,
-0.7307366729,
0.7119519114,
0.0170637444,
-1.2303820848,
0.5610381961,
-0.8639098406,
-0.3630096018,
-0.1706099659,
0.2168208957,
-0.3850599527,
0.0284222309,
0.2611101568,
0.1285348237,
-0.2485519648,
0.3926179111,
-0.4262565374,
-0.3908181489,
0.0686110184,
-0.6324952245,
1.4541295767,
0.4740269482,
-0.6697151661,
-0.0120279528,
-0.5881394744,
-0.0211057905,
-0.0240265764,
-0.3760205507,
-0.5251784325,
0.4229086041,
0.221942395,
0.65190804,
-0.3543729186,
-0.6915253401,
-0.1241039559,
-0.5549147129,
0.3367529213,
0.769215107,
-0.1008738503,
0.5348549485,
-0.3262730539,
0.2634057701,
0.1643194407,
0.4193980694,
0.2478677928,
-0.7319737077,
-0.519370079,
0.0885051563,
0.4994386733,
0.538377583,
-0.4287771285,
0.2839767635,
0.0671521425,
-0.0932703763,
-0.531968236,
0.0431999192,
0.4533195198,
0.6457558274,
0.6689098477,
-0.482678324,
-0.4249720871,
-0.747467041,
-0.6365482807,
-0.1247399002,
-0.1106219441,
0.1649988592,
0.6160160899,
-0.2762932479,
1.0259311199,
-0.6324178576,
-0.7717345953,
-0.0923426524,
-0.0442594551,
0.0953752622,
0.6098715067,
0.9220255613,
-0.7757557631,
-0.3840373158,
-0.389967531,
-0.6471827626,
-0.7723011374,
0.3202536702,
0.0615177639,
0.1771083623,
0.4805976748,
-0.2043340653,
0.196186319,
0.4610001445,
-0.4323658347,
0.4082223177,
0.1840506792,
0.0494031534,
-0.6775103807,
0.1667151749,
0.0064503341,
-0.1480955929,
-0.7153695822,
0.2723306119,
-0.1413995773,
0.2279708683,
-0.7387472391,
0.6791713834,
-0.2240787446,
-0.023305241,
-0.3443967104,
-0.0037243343,
0.3220098615,
0.427005291,
0.0661079884,
0.0432735793,
0.4988995194,
-0.3461576402,
0.1171831489,
-0.0371763334,
0.0204941649,
0.4525227547,
-0.5638766885,
-0.2095174938,
-0.2674932778,
0.3645840883,
-0.618260622,
0.2980545163,
0.6828892827,
-0.2671843469,
-0.0309383888,
-0.4464272857,
-0.5357635617,
-0.1596550792,
-0.2600280046,
0.454225421,
0.6424006224,
-0.3977370858,
0.258438915,
0.6698471308,
0.0106185107,
-0.873221159,
-0.910318017,
-0.2284151167,
-0.4033993483,
-0.2954628468,
0.2474599928,
0.0578098223,
-0.5225067139,
0.0504673868,
-0.2014687955,
-0.1048853025,
0.1435688883,
0.1011126414,
-0.1962600201,
0.1288918555,
0.2223916948,
0.1465683579,
-0.2584877312,
0.5420677066,
-0.031119056,
0.4485370219,
0.0488911793,
-0.4532005489,
-0.1387738287,
0.3428934515,
0.3104109168,
-0.3675190806,
0.7805600762,
0.7070823908,
-0.5260683894,
-0.2290399969,
-0.5370394588,
-0.2733945251,
-0.4441863596,
0.2374197096,
0.3736854494,
-0.6111892462,
0.8092734814,
0.1078209803,
0.0416485444,
0.5217372775,
0.5301473737,
0.1590178758,
1.3381917477,
0.3557452261,
-0.3808096349,
0.4800390899,
-0.1842449307,
0.1481419355,
-0.7486132383,
-0.0372609459,
-0.6970627308,
-0.2522511482,
-0.6630718112,
-0.4265538454,
0.0997190848,
-0.1052354127,
-0.2375912517,
-0.2578656673,
-0.643173933,
0.6687312126,
0.5470097065,
0.2945556045,
0.5863065124,
-0.24599199,
0.0467884429,
-0.1520562768,
-0.6154381633,
-0.4483301938,
1.2029459476,
0.6733865738,
0.4478786886,
0.0278325751,
0.5678764582,
0.3433621228,
0.4517783821,
-0.6030434966,
0.2942010164,
-0.3056942821,
-1.2483305931,
-0.0933442712,
-0.5294280648,
-0.5886946917,
0.51608181,
-0.3785510063,
-0.6093928218,
0.3299327493,
0.1920291334,
-0.2528282404,
0.5209719539,
-0.6608884931,
1.0246547461,
-0.0179958697,
-0.4013070166,
-0.307539016,
-0.5902727842,
0.4126814902,
0.0732716471,
0.5170410872,
-0.3033472896,
0.4411050379,
0.6164207458,
-0.4264377654,
0.7635195255,
-0.5082275271,
-0.2946554124,
0.3083129525,
-0.014298467,
0.3072334826,
0.2557063401,
-0.4789248705,
0.4598802924,
-0.012237669,
-0.3156757355,
-0.3095153868,
0.6393955946,
-0.2789984941,
-0.3250822425,
-0.6821947694,
-0.4817571044,
0.1013375297,
0.460804224,
0.2207623273,
0.235483408,
0.1158620268,
-0.1680295914,
0.6487021446,
-0.7905459404,
0.363148123,
0.5605986118,
-0.3229462206,
0.1610869169,
0.7859212756,
0.1055807397,
0.430383563,
-0.0690742582,
0.2609269321,
-0.2445463091,
-0.7501844168,
-0.0418825038,
-0.074990578,
-0.8995883465,
-0.1784643084,
-0.8655115366,
-0.2413075715,
-0.3343220055,
0.2297125906,
-0.3810489476,
-0.1674164534,
-0.2295755893,
0.0158407204,
0.1929081827,
0.6440386772,
-0.3282690644,
0.4018912315,
-0.6796345711,
0.3234733939,
0.4131008089,
0.7271583676,
0.1427515,
-0.2899181545,
-0.0110080298,
0.2849889398,
-0.4787481129,
-1.0288676023,
0.4218897521,
-0.1571364254,
0.566364944,
0.2709995806,
0.0484723747,
0.1235576198,
-0.4001540244,
0.6755844355,
-0.1681973487,
-1.1699109077,
0.334482342,
-0.5409830809,
0.1737611145,
0.6525913477,
0.3190513849,
-0.7372732162,
-0.6878392696,
-0.3269451261,
-0.7823611498,
0.8318115473,
0.5273945928,
0.0531381331,
-0.1162407324,
0.1729518771,
0.0296548754,
0.2973711193,
-1.3255523443,
-0.4491494596,
-0.0682779625,
0.0476107299,
0.2459966242,
-0.4517279863,
0.0540755652,
-0.3202012479,
0.5015767813,
0.2029945403,
-0.0798143595,
-0.0226391833,
-0.3375765383,
-0.2523645759,
0.5010613203,
0.1539068967,
0.3971154392,
-0.4197681248,
-0.0391660109,
0.2780749202,
-0.5929961801,
-0.087463893,
-0.1250511259,
-0.4672810137,
0.0843336284,
0.3180609941,
0.4684853554,
0.1165645197,
-0.6076881289,
0.6522964835,
0.0103394948,
0.0877655521,
0.0900417864,
0.1367935389,
0.0330735259,
0.262217015,
0.163058117,
0.2608885765,
0.934899807,
-0.5460315347,
0.1644274145,
0.5828576088,
-0.5756723285,
0.0091283405,
0.8774235845,
0.2867221236,
0.1098653674,
0.505274713,
-0.4349054992,
-0.7667539716,
0.764652133,
0.3872388899,
0.7465161085,
-0.0687380508,
0.3019786775,
0.3896655738,
0.3035863638,
-0.1510868818,
0.258056879,
0.3739853501,
-0.7874678969,
-0.5292374492,
-0.7538504004,
-0.1118190363,
0.0799893215,
-0.7169569135,
0.1818509698,
-0.1396728754,
-0.410793066,
0.1423137337,
-0.0184880625,
-0.4371573031,
0.2107732594,
0.2505510151,
0.5372315645,
-1.2249531746,
0.4577152431,
0.3216705918,
-0.5170481205,
-0.4561013579,
0.0278796703,
0.2598121166,
-0.3125793934,
0.8042875528,
0.2201452106,
0.15739654,
-0.0116496198,
-0.3059412241,
-0.6550804973,
0.5885801315,
0.4822157621,
-0.4038121998,
-0.0248452276,
0.1855544001,
0.7743916512,
0.04294727,
0.6302282214,
0.5206611753,
0.4843009114,
-0.3016040623,
-1.0577884912,
0.1348799467,
-0.1245844886,
0.0622378662,
0.1279803663,
-0.2897721529,
0.985168457,
-0.0213481002,
-0.1418387741,
-0.4587402344,
0.0216521602,
0.1359992772,
0.4591297507,
0.6899920106,
0.6533576846,
0.4172664881,
0.0349702947,
0.6965702176,
0.1794996858,
0.6021330357,
1.0908782482,
-0.5060783029,
0.4496258795,
0.4208171964,
-0.1611907035,
0.640352428,
0.386315316,
0.0030976648,
0.6570421457,
0.4884938598,
-0.2021885812,
0.0453151092,
-0.3275508285,
-0.4465573728,
0.3382677436,
0.3177258074,
-0.573305428,
-0.5828933716,
0.237237975,
0.0851481557,
0.1586224735,
-0.6061577797,
0.6637372375,
0.0150676398,
-0.5396963358,
0.2814263999,
0.0167443175,
1.0151193142,
-0.2342335433,
-0.1070377678,
-0.0195857845,
0.2675127387,
-0.4827239513,
-0.8796645999,
0.6186258793,
-0.0795116872,
-0.3063181937,
-0.3868999183,
1.0019932985,
-0.4357144833,
-0.1957554519,
0.7163558006,
0.4406942427,
0.0199280679,
-0.4606237113,
-0.8636006117,
0.0612394065,
-0.0531167574,
-0.2621770203,
0.3145978153,
0.1843957305,
-0.1015355587,
0.8314903975,
0.5083140135,
0.2998019457,
0.0762984008,
0.3540124595,
0.8150292635,
-0.4374410808,
-0.3394551277,
-1.1381095648,
0.5109989643,
-0.058754541,
0.0640025735,
0.7426074147,
0.305388689,
0.8903446198,
-0.0645961538,
0.6277145147,
-0.0279108901,
0.480915606,
-0.4412112236,
1.1858218908,
-0.425578028,
0.4431566,
-0.6774244905,
-1.0677508116,
-0.5023006201,
0.6012641191,
-0.3312721252,
0.3792225718,
0.6615885496,
0.6442903876,
0.0367958769,
0.115651466,
-0.1953034699,
0.2881982625,
0.359420687,
0.420052588,
0.5524013042,
-0.6038703918,
0.4096082449,
-0.3088326454,
-0.0636196658,
-0.1471517533,
-1.150613904,
-0.7665231228,
-0.2443521023,
-0.3114985824,
-0.3487119675,
0.161554575,
0.6621151567,
0.3530375361,
-1.0047392845,
0.0195905678,
-0.1965709925,
0.7045121789,
-0.2121991217,
-0.3051627278,
0.0664157942,
-0.3734171689,
-0.6479617953,
-0.2532751262,
0.0936272144,
-0.2857759595,
-0.1824046373,
-0.0035862813,
-0.3208639324,
-0.1583620608,
0.8365291357,
0.012442654,
-0.4615655541,
-0.3114104569,
-0.1523115486,
-0.3226784468,
-0.0569419414,
0.5046174526,
-0.8401216865,
0.4821094871,
0.6686657667,
0.0766553804,
-0.0096094618,
-0.2414571345,
0.6087227464,
-0.6139323115,
0.0511452779,
0.4926496148,
0.2445943803,
0.0730729029,
-0.3866244555,
0.5370970964,
0.1207530275,
-0.7506633997,
-1.1246603727,
0.2994543016,
-0.6596300006,
-0.5767116547,
1.3025945425,
0.154435426,
0.0771323442,
-0.4892138839,
-0.4758973122,
0.3265392482,
-0.1790928543,
0.8761739731,
0.640203476,
0.0521427505,
0.2982110083,
-0.8740703464,
0.8892748356,
0.5879717469,
-0.8450343609,
0.171094805,
0.5322416425,
0.3894179463,
0.1143904403,
0.829656601,
-0.2807969153,
0.2240546048,
-0.251753509,
0.1343484372,
0.3713687062,
0.1160973087,
-0.4523975849,
-0.0869583115,
-0.0581274629,
0.1511150599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05523v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05523v2 | FACTIFY3M: A Benchmark for Multimodal Fact Verification with Explainability through 5W Question-Answering | 2023-05-22T08:29:47 | 2023-10-31T01:51:56 | Megha Chakraborty, Khushbu Pahwa, Anku Rani, Shreyas Chatterjee, Dwip Dalal, Harshit Dave, Ritvik G, Preethi Gurumurthy, Adarsh Mahor, Samahriti Mukherjee, Aditya Pakala, Ishan Paul, Janvita Reddy, Arghya Sarkar, Kinjal Sensharma, Aman Chadha, Amit P. Sheth, Amitava Das | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.MM | Combating disinformation is one of the burning societal crises -- about 67%
of the American population believes that disinformation produces a lot of
uncertainty, and 10% of them knowingly propagate disinformation. Evidence shows
that disinformation can manipulate democratic processes and public opinion,
causing disruption in the share market, panic and anxiety in society, and even
death during crises. Therefore, disinformation should be identified promptly
and, if possible, mitigated. With approximately 3.2 billion images and 720,000
hours of video shared online daily on social media platforms, scalable
detection of multimodal disinformation requires efficient fact verification.
Despite progress in automatic text-based fact verification (e.g., FEVER, LIAR),
the research community lacks substantial effort in multimodal fact
verification. To address this gap, we introduce FACTIFY 3M, a dataset of 3
million samples that pushes the boundaries of the domain of fact verification
via a multimodal fake news dataset, in addition to offering explainability
through the concept of 5W question-answering. Salient features of the dataset
include: (i) textual claims, (ii) ChatGPT-generated paraphrased claims, (iii)
associated images, (iv) stable diffusion-generated additional images (i.e.,
visual paraphrases), (v) pixel-level image heatmap to foster image-text
explainability of the claim, (vi) 5W QA pairs, and (vii) adversarial fake news
stories. | [
-0.5718721151,
-0.9092440009,
1.00079,
0.3542304635,
-0.2844233215,
0.060530059,
0.0549384654,
-0.1120859012,
-0.2121209204,
0.1505194157,
-0.6224595308,
-0.578646481,
-0.7589728832,
0.1614253223,
-0.4096260369,
0.9793137312,
-0.0763049498,
-0.3491747081,
-0.617061913,
-0.2204851508,
-0.1838089228,
-0.2945661545,
0.0500092879,
-0.1737594754,
0.712577939,
0.7193603516,
0.8666368127,
0.6629343033,
0.5167126656,
0.2961774766,
0.2498004436,
0.4329306185,
-0.5346216559,
-0.0634361878,
0.1451028585,
-0.5138852,
-0.1386985928,
0.4147476256,
0.3033242822,
0.2413831353,
-0.2004983872,
0.427439779,
-0.271666348,
0.5757169724,
-0.7773765922,
0.3475615978,
-0.6278463602,
-0.2715175748,
-0.1431794167,
-0.2557444572,
-0.3042401075,
-0.6724213958,
0.0484334491,
-0.6606629491,
0.4690418243,
0.0276861433,
0.898704052,
0.3365722895,
-0.8742935061,
-0.2831780314,
-0.7568045259,
0.4490909874,
-0.458499074,
0.3489973247,
0.2313927561,
0.5132764578,
0.0149567146,
-0.6897457242,
-1.2492375374,
0.2105865926,
-0.151199013,
0.3568148613,
-0.2971605957,
-0.213436693,
0.5714664459,
0.2615709305,
-0.7314053774,
-0.5190788507,
-0.3986473083,
-0.6083091497,
0.3429252803,
-0.1950268149,
0.4226026535,
-0.4123814106,
-0.777885139,
-0.0921920985,
-0.4821250737,
-0.147263661,
0.1529490501,
-0.3445880413,
-0.2142633945,
0.362690866,
-0.1753933132,
0.4291366339,
-0.0951005444,
-0.7508525848,
0.506872654,
-0.5397920012,
-0.1441293955,
0.2107783854,
0.5908316374,
0.8856853247,
-0.3495268226,
0.145292595,
0.1034193859,
0.2309508026,
0.1343016326,
-0.9921060801,
-0.0718565807,
0.4253103435,
-0.7266378999,
-0.0577989519,
0.1176022962,
-0.9449355006,
-0.6996163726,
-0.0290148258,
0.7608969212,
-0.4394424558,
-0.3521808386,
0.1812151521,
-0.4745157361,
0.0486754738,
0.4821509719,
-0.3974989653,
-0.1696000099,
0.388288945,
0.9215435386,
0.152293697,
-0.1074187011,
-0.1545939296,
0.1304407269,
-0.3210556507,
0.6834239364,
-0.1297746301,
0.1342772841,
-0.2710426748,
-0.0410232991,
0.0353473984,
-0.2929713726,
0.6674553752,
-0.7724644542,
0.4147254229,
-0.3641943634,
-0.2859550714,
-0.7976748347,
0.6535635591,
-0.9279235601,
0.8188793063,
-0.2822964787,
-0.8643165231,
0.4769785106,
-0.6596396565,
-0.1989845484,
-0.2399333119,
0.1058157235,
-0.8091810942,
-0.115982227,
0.4199867249,
0.6088992357,
-0.2990214825,
0.3043033481,
-0.4743354917,
-0.1332352906,
0.4938980937,
-0.9712095857,
0.3820700645,
0.5022259951,
-0.5195017457,
-0.1002691239,
-0.9979926944,
-0.337608844,
0.0369144082,
-0.205632329,
-0.1294222027,
-0.0945310518,
-0.251835227,
0.5122918487,
0.3426858485,
-0.7515692711,
-0.1132061034,
0.2131499201,
0.1573610455,
0.3471757472,
0.2616924345,
-0.1067659631,
-0.542805016,
0.2905687094,
0.5705755949,
0.4203745425,
-0.4975737631,
-0.508310616,
-0.6246051788,
-0.5228241086,
-0.0056585548,
0.4119370878,
-1.2270975113,
-0.3149363399,
-0.308082372,
-0.6557295322,
-0.3194156885,
0.0169429537,
0.0998586714,
0.7127967477,
0.709019959,
0.5037523508,
-0.6976714134,
-1.1804099083,
-0.1931359768,
-0.1841716021,
-0.0118040014,
-0.2431044579,
0.5836972594,
-0.0634525046,
0.9328189492,
-0.4808879495,
-0.1023592874,
-0.137937814,
0.489443332,
0.3942167461,
-0.0631200075,
0.4764356613,
-1.3388699293,
-0.2228682339,
-0.3885775506,
-0.8636077046,
0.1591475904,
-0.2564996481,
0.3828829527,
-0.052152846,
0.3315784931,
-0.5885022879,
0.3661597669,
0.6301199794,
-0.2333310694,
0.1079715937,
-0.3058837354,
0.6795215011,
-1.0764631033,
-0.0934244096,
0.1477050483,
-0.43801561,
-0.6287356019,
-0.2247031033,
0.3409611285,
-0.068410933,
-0.6635782719,
0.0441125743,
-0.6038610935,
0.2144870013,
-0.1907897145,
0.3356480598,
0.1042804122,
0.3816424906,
-0.2843162417,
0.5658246279,
0.406118691,
-0.6464464664,
0.5696719289,
0.0263846666,
-0.5022234321,
0.4926700294,
-0.380744338,
-0.1896176487,
-0.4250380993,
0.5982081294,
-1.2517874241,
-0.4545992613,
0.2070441246,
-0.4215950668,
-0.5034293532,
-0.0775265321,
-0.6756158471,
-0.319404155,
-0.4164470136,
0.1908351034,
0.4244578481,
-0.7278760672,
0.7146402597,
0.2352072746,
0.1430148631,
-0.6342358589,
-0.3815324903,
0.1224632934,
-0.3863847852,
-0.5857771039,
0.3569284379,
-0.0795503333,
-0.221736744,
-0.0751751512,
-0.2977629602,
0.008770247,
0.2051029801,
0.4495527148,
0.311198175,
0.0115846619,
0.1918844581,
-0.4965984523,
-0.1138287708,
0.1302744448,
0.074383691,
0.0278967116,
-0.0914202332,
-0.619881928,
-0.6468000412,
0.1184179634,
1.0088300705,
0.1325691491,
0.6455684304,
1.0857130289,
-0.4284337759,
0.1753320843,
-0.8114745021,
-0.1840640455,
-0.3620065451,
0.0261889175,
-0.2837532759,
-0.5447909832,
0.2418644428,
-0.0838730112,
0.1860346645,
0.5557969213,
0.6720114946,
0.0744182244,
1.2597440481,
0.357648164,
0.2476399392,
0.0511009991,
0.0782546625,
0.304626286,
-0.0411367826,
-0.6334274411,
-0.2034439594,
-0.2507002652,
-0.5463598371,
-0.7719570994,
0.8922989964,
-0.11066854,
0.3326389194,
0.0136619853,
-0.1121576354,
0.339092046,
0.3539709151,
0.1152482927,
0.5316341519,
-0.0437703654,
-0.0064226198,
0.1423216462,
-0.7060594559,
-0.6180551648,
1.0352882147,
0.5997384191,
0.7010363936,
0.614805162,
0.3543006182,
0.4033287764,
0.4503671825,
-0.4992132783,
0.4327287972,
0.236580044,
-0.8347739577,
-0.1222303882,
-0.3069390059,
-0.5109333992,
0.3011812568,
-0.3917961121,
-0.1542106122,
0.0868448466,
0.4629102945,
-0.558903873,
0.2284972519,
-0.804937005,
0.5242392421,
-0.0948636532,
-0.336215198,
-0.5313519239,
-0.7058951855,
0.5760541558,
0.085917294,
0.8253170252,
-0.4494258165,
-0.0619233474,
0.6261479855,
-0.2653486133,
0.8340094686,
-0.3799329102,
-0.1663803458,
0.2330400348,
-0.1308416873,
0.411313206,
0.3944018185,
0.2181134075,
0.0076257228,
0.1466422677,
-0.2634783089,
-0.9200902581,
0.4948812723,
-0.5503591299,
-0.6028804183,
-0.4955518544,
-0.5146198869,
-0.1970666498,
0.0806855187,
-0.0037374136,
0.6407040358,
-0.0687542111,
0.5436303616,
1.0001273155,
-0.027981963,
0.6024252772,
0.7353442311,
-0.1744270474,
-0.3576051891,
1.310598135,
0.020877162,
-0.0211470518,
0.4310773015,
0.2329187393,
-0.5924348235,
-0.4403114617,
-0.4844644368,
-0.0833608359,
-0.8222270608,
-0.1951054037,
-0.9066144228,
0.0522458665,
-0.1606641263,
0.2833884954,
-0.1934443861,
-0.3986619711,
-0.0664678365,
-0.1119565219,
0.480676502,
0.7335276604,
-0.4435532987,
0.0314117223,
-0.5573365092,
1.1149414778,
0.6172453761,
0.1229229867,
-0.5125256181,
-0.2327954769,
-0.1521956623,
0.296954751,
-0.4040353894,
-1.042914629,
-0.0661474094,
0.0289256908,
0.6038416624,
0.5882934332,
0.2756944895,
0.5282520652,
-0.2108686864,
1.0092133284,
0.4332736135,
-0.7919854522,
0.4277333319,
-0.1494621485,
0.0984776542,
0.2830778956,
0.9218506217,
-0.5981016755,
-0.2910918295,
-0.8706353903,
-0.6787628531,
0.396938771,
0.189051345,
-0.0692284107,
-0.0699659809,
-0.0915961191,
0.3076907098,
0.2929938734,
-0.6814453602,
-0.5953639746,
-0.8956629038,
-0.3816308379,
-0.062533319,
-0.5320678949,
-0.5456373692,
0.0786074251,
0.7907859087,
-0.4510973394,
0.2470189631,
0.3199834526,
-0.3431430459,
0.4386865497,
0.5342823267,
0.9682314396,
1.0108304024,
-0.3507495522,
0.8578807712,
0.1083002612,
-0.5073906779,
0.4347952306,
0.0935750231,
-0.0485961512,
0.2259235084,
0.4264538586,
0.7068089247,
-0.0298535917,
-0.3407129347,
0.905516386,
-0.2113391161,
-0.5336634517,
-0.091125682,
-0.119302094,
0.0377936698,
0.0747856572,
0.6859788895,
0.2095035613,
0.3039831817,
-0.6573217511,
0.2347722054,
0.1678614169,
-0.4030747414,
-0.3334076107,
0.6793712378,
0.2565324605,
0.5421058536,
0.1807659268,
0.0133086601,
-0.5607869625,
0.4925768375,
0.2679132223,
0.2747150362,
0.1776593924,
0.6661154628,
0.382199049,
0.4661004245,
-0.2445759475,
0.4655248225,
0.0210861247,
-0.7554599643,
-0.2856281996,
-0.2646423876,
-0.4118315279,
0.4991266727,
-0.4811700583,
0.1191154048,
-0.4321712255,
-0.108821407,
0.380407244,
-0.3058526814,
-0.5637590289,
0.6485027671,
0.3287860751,
0.8039806485,
-0.948279202,
0.2750021815,
0.4469742775,
-0.5642395616,
-0.6046424508,
0.205891937,
0.687581718,
-0.7833052874,
0.4987427294,
0.3088306785,
-0.2758717537,
-0.077925466,
-0.7211154699,
-0.6601532102,
1.1500136852,
0.5878204107,
-0.3871568143,
0.3916464448,
-0.0849248916,
0.1595621109,
-0.1696465611,
0.518884778,
0.3642644286,
0.9047668576,
0.2020093799,
-0.3912493885,
0.3134915233,
-0.0667546988,
-0.136189267,
-0.2323559076,
-0.7735901475,
0.6565915942,
-0.4654645324,
-0.4433550239,
-0.4806664586,
0.7842489481,
0.0843659043,
0.5100370646,
0.9343068004,
0.3288854361,
0.778824091,
-0.2509674132,
0.8070287108,
-0.4564649761,
0.2910280526,
0.7432769537,
-0.0003666675,
0.3859763741,
0.6640019417,
0.1395099014,
0.736428082,
0.7023823857,
-0.0629449785,
0.4534689188,
-0.1183701679,
-0.5358134508,
-0.5306227803,
-0.042830918,
-0.2975777984,
0.5455289483,
0.3530069292,
-0.1206339225,
-0.409845978,
0.321842581,
0.2994320393,
0.0410695039,
0.0312046148,
0.7542175651,
-0.4142768681,
-0.6727353334,
0.5252227187,
0.0112965042,
0.4143301547,
-0.5162991881,
-0.2566305399,
-0.0815212801,
0.0664768144,
-0.4604541957,
-0.8695937991,
0.1836072356,
-0.1593872011,
-0.5847483277,
-0.5375341177,
0.5534768105,
-0.4572305977,
-0.2258077562,
-0.2440982014,
0.6056668758,
0.0625556111,
-0.1030996814,
-0.4549230635,
0.1557182074,
-0.0365851931,
-0.0626925826,
-0.0597861335,
0.6011722684,
-0.0939292982,
0.9421864152,
0.8458749056,
-0.254597187,
-0.1580189019,
0.0271829348,
0.7649644017,
-0.35521245,
-0.3227992654,
-1.088165164,
0.4851620495,
-0.3493650854,
-0.0088828346,
1.1360746622,
0.6694811583,
0.3337329924,
-0.0992720202,
1.1096959114,
-0.3197145164,
0.614228487,
-0.6620457172,
0.7558050752,
-0.5595471263,
0.0842732042,
-0.09715195,
-0.440429002,
-0.1993131936,
0.19434084,
-0.1353676617,
-0.3059329689,
0.8530313373,
0.9555491209,
-0.2535073161,
0.1398437768,
0.4753871858,
0.395396024,
0.2673098743,
0.0553266406,
0.9885325432,
-0.4174847901,
1.0471202135,
-0.22970438,
-0.399012804,
-0.3628650606,
-1.1739670038,
-0.6209254861,
-0.8272383213,
-0.6055012345,
-0.3492330015,
-0.1874674559,
0.6779516935,
0.8804608583,
-0.545543313,
0.3615332246,
0.3777998388,
0.6625728607,
-0.4079425931,
-0.2129206508,
0.1753114313,
0.0163592845,
-0.2805045545,
0.3776779771,
0.4351415336,
0.1180367917,
-0.412729919,
0.2589675784,
-0.3409342468,
0.3136469126,
0.6255920529,
0.001984505,
-0.6903817058,
-0.3987622857,
-0.2224368155,
-0.0340236835,
0.0180077255,
0.8273215294,
-0.6439034343,
0.597119391,
0.3802908361,
0.395891279,
0.3755488396,
0.210043326,
0.3738512397,
-0.8336686492,
-0.065798305,
-0.3682061732,
0.1104374528,
0.5629419684,
-0.3558093309,
0.1829038858,
0.5604157448,
-0.23760131,
-0.581564784,
0.098802194,
-0.8868216872,
-0.128032431,
0.9733403325,
-0.1468943805,
-0.4033700228,
-0.5385473371,
-0.1702719033,
0.2274619937,
-0.4144770503,
0.988601923,
0.800570488,
-0.0894378498,
-0.3657189906,
-0.6981357932,
0.778146863,
-0.0949938148,
-1.0222793818,
0.1146616712,
0.7582525611,
0.5992931128,
0.4841941297,
0.5119646192,
-0.0151265198,
0.5250062943,
0.0065403334,
0.2084754258,
-0.2892182171,
-0.3900849819,
0.1527206004,
0.700062871,
-0.2849587202,
-0.4501883984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12820v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12820v2 | MultiTabQA: Generating Tabular Answers for Multi-Table Question Answering | 2023-05-22T08:25:15 | 2023-05-24T17:13:47 | Vaishali Pal, Andrew Yates, Evangelos Kanoulas, Maarten de Rijke | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in tabular question answering (QA) with large language models
are constrained in their coverage and only answer questions over a single
table. However, real-world queries are complex in nature, often over multiple
tables in a relational database or web page. Single table questions do not
involve common table operations such as set operations, Cartesian products
(joins), or nested queries. Furthermore, multi-table operations often result in
a tabular output, which necessitates table generation capabilities of tabular
QA models. To fill this gap, we propose a new task of answering questions over
multiple tables. Our model, MultiTabQA, not only answers questions over
multiple tables, but also generalizes to generate tabular answers. To enable
effective training, we build a pre-training dataset comprising of 132,645 SQL
queries and tabular answers. Further, we evaluate the generated tables by
introducing table-specific metrics of varying strictness assessing various
levels of granularity of the table structure. MultiTabQA outperforms
state-of-the-art single table QA models adapted to a multi-table QA setting by
finetuning on three datasets: Spider, Atis and GeoQuery. | [
-0.6366137862,
-1.2620798349,
0.5848109722,
0.1537170112,
0.0137471408,
0.0987413973,
0.36879161,
-0.1593844593,
0.1746632457,
0.6009060144,
-0.6784062982,
-0.493034184,
0.0826415271,
-0.0318918526,
-0.3024588227,
1.2000550032,
0.0068226289,
0.4006412327,
-0.4090943635,
-0.2000362724,
-0.6032108068,
-0.574246347,
-0.1747715175,
0.0564775392,
0.7167824507,
0.8047373295,
0.7089990377,
0.2614299357,
0.412403971,
0.2176807374,
0.319819808,
0.3812847137,
-0.1110387817,
0.3460124731,
0.195004046,
-0.6146547198,
-0.6429855824,
-0.1766641438,
0.7108053565,
0.6792376637,
-0.3990734816,
0.7665412426,
-0.1806751341,
0.7000117302,
-0.4779620767,
-0.0733277351,
-0.7685503364,
0.0874468684,
-0.1395826936,
-0.1058054939,
-0.3985125721,
-0.9118846059,
-0.1604323536,
-0.5503727794,
0.2188444138,
0.088872239,
0.732391417,
0.0708969757,
-0.9002614021,
-0.2822962999,
-0.6684895158,
0.1138649434,
-0.4302513003,
0.5520378947,
0.172605142,
0.7326633334,
-0.2618451118,
-0.7624539733,
-0.8237512112,
-0.2833189666,
-0.0126488246,
0.2051633,
0.2819616199,
-0.0737095773,
0.3115971088,
0.0672364086,
-0.8877649307,
-0.2200734019,
-0.3793367147,
0.0062202825,
0.242829591,
0.4353978634,
0.323975563,
-0.0961683169,
-0.2102993578,
-0.1273883879,
-0.7809590697,
0.5478368402,
0.1319703758,
0.3088442981,
0.3013288081,
0.6012415886,
-0.5569025874,
0.7413104177,
-0.1658857614,
-0.0046795052,
-0.0740467161,
-0.5645611286,
0.0669585243,
-0.3363298774,
0.4835667312,
0.0889710784,
-0.0460247137,
-0.2080169469,
0.1933068335,
-0.1199023649,
0.4400938153,
-0.6162100434,
-0.2841160893,
0.5272968411,
0.0741519406,
-0.0639433414,
0.0899930075,
-1.1131751537,
-0.218574509,
-0.0338777043,
0.7259541154,
0.0417597778,
-0.092362009,
-0.1290170997,
0.0364593901,
0.5265175104,
0.1293314397,
-0.5121954083,
0.4873681068,
0.1351419687,
0.3989523947,
0.1296235025,
-0.5081651211,
-0.9050040841,
0.415660888,
-0.5440809727,
1.0719394684,
-0.2288023233,
0.0201945994,
0.1239796132,
-0.1793450266,
0.0774854273,
-0.4165971875,
0.1920175999,
-0.7551703453,
0.1952962726,
-0.6161850095,
-0.0818943754,
-0.1256280392,
0.557268858,
-1.0546209812,
0.7935778499,
0.0250325669,
-0.4838230014,
0.7151678801,
-0.7917253375,
-0.2919476032,
0.0880320817,
-0.1381209195,
-0.75149405,
-0.1014228314,
0.5773717761,
0.229743287,
-0.3628720045,
0.2022907287,
-0.3930093944,
-0.0432792604,
0.646178782,
-0.0951349363,
0.2379407734,
0.0782019049,
0.0094618415,
0.2749891877,
-0.4352056086,
0.73805058,
0.0012284674,
-0.6881843209,
0.3502845168,
-0.1710654795,
-0.0138085969,
0.4237339497,
-0.1519410312,
-0.5544765592,
0.1446755975,
0.0804473832,
0.2219382823,
0.1547393501,
0.3799742758,
0.2748808265,
-0.5896977782,
0.785353601,
0.1719572097,
0.1023582146,
0.3104183972,
-0.3516165316,
-0.5072512627,
-0.0137877623,
0.5113347173,
0.5028913617,
-1.01877141,
-0.2637829781,
-0.217064172,
-0.7086597681,
-0.4571170509,
-0.1157746315,
0.5194477439,
0.286077261,
0.6240586042,
-0.2146122754,
-0.3140769005,
-0.9771738648,
-0.4401906133,
0.0585088506,
0.1088977754,
0.4609405994,
0.5350340009,
0.3391181827,
0.7789349556,
-0.8364578485,
-0.2682095468,
-0.4685165584,
0.0908534899,
0.0380172431,
0.3675496876,
0.3059705198,
-0.8679043055,
-0.6285619736,
-0.1614363641,
-0.534119308,
0.3151490092,
-0.1768220663,
-0.2869203985,
0.0844943896,
0.0996228829,
-0.8150849938,
0.3790240884,
0.1404762566,
-0.1876366138,
0.8988147378,
0.0438123196,
0.4017853737,
-1.1325691938,
0.0110019688,
-0.3093899786,
-0.1376099139,
-0.9706155658,
0.3038920462,
0.1256639957,
-0.5161626935,
-0.4689749777,
0.2883826792,
-0.5605785251,
-0.3936113715,
0.2979082167,
0.2007875443,
0.3670756221,
0.6825837493,
-0.1474933773,
0.9516269565,
0.251139164,
-0.7766785026,
0.3950708807,
0.7791498303,
-0.2356083989,
0.4424488246,
-0.5951524973,
0.1440511197,
-0.1743006706,
0.3690283,
-1.2445273399,
-0.413860172,
0.0666568205,
-0.5107764006,
0.0794819221,
0.0305352807,
-0.350723058,
-0.740216136,
-0.244473815,
0.2735963464,
-0.0185468066,
-0.3060476482,
0.8028084636,
0.5897142291,
-0.2691858709,
-0.853993535,
-0.6274636388,
-0.0542859882,
-0.2588790059,
-0.5820857286,
0.0749836564,
-0.0892517567,
-0.0055035418,
-0.1619529426,
-0.4113692939,
-0.8558961153,
-0.0711993724,
0.0920007229,
0.0254724491,
-0.2116014808,
0.3677561879,
0.2026852369,
0.3523118794,
0.1895053983,
-0.0413577743,
0.6821136475,
-0.3954814672,
-0.153692618,
-0.3642176092,
0.7331705093,
0.381518662,
-0.702011466,
0.8421398401,
0.5643135905,
-0.449573338,
-0.1329102367,
-0.6802751422,
-0.3239789307,
-0.3746235371,
0.703922987,
-0.8851042986,
-0.3735170662,
0.8723641038,
0.3535744548,
0.3374720216,
0.1399500966,
0.6292159557,
-0.2912758291,
0.7352920771,
0.2903550565,
0.5636765957,
0.040392939,
-0.0931468159,
0.0416751988,
-0.4149536192,
-0.4488034248,
-1.0165108442,
-0.0815391019,
-0.5463562012,
-0.151127547,
0.7581795454,
-0.211983338,
-0.2850741744,
0.2987594008,
-0.3257862031,
0.5329071879,
0.8151924014,
0.5384113789,
0.3740653694,
-0.1239916086,
0.124454774,
0.3167659342,
-0.8246120214,
-0.3633584976,
1.1449775696,
0.0438714139,
0.7348395586,
0.4869175851,
0.6636783481,
0.0498498939,
0.237310037,
-0.3661585748,
0.4153478146,
0.1323945671,
-1.1251602173,
-0.7510480881,
-0.6926491261,
-0.8394067287,
0.4610689878,
-0.5155833364,
-0.4291890264,
-0.1706510931,
0.3905704319,
-0.5920346379,
0.1872586459,
-0.8439620733,
1.2939522266,
-0.1148408651,
-0.3974015117,
0.1402478814,
-0.6969941258,
0.5222479701,
-0.1413165778,
0.0154971518,
0.0548527017,
0.2173735946,
0.7440727949,
-0.1125322506,
0.2817689776,
-0.3681138456,
0.181377545,
0.5411958098,
0.2388119996,
0.1569326669,
0.5223953128,
0.140206188,
-0.4582077861,
0.7427010536,
-0.4571840167,
-0.5928269029,
0.4015247226,
-0.6052969694,
-0.4605531096,
-0.1663294882,
-0.8879195452,
-0.7486550212,
0.112089403,
0.0801674649,
0.8339468837,
-0.0941754058,
0.2379257381,
0.5431931615,
-0.2770566642,
0.0807454288,
0.3526168168,
-0.1119017303,
-0.4129897654,
0.6764538884,
0.3155264556,
0.1168446094,
0.5529245138,
-0.0833106264,
-0.8659363985,
-0.4136756361,
-0.8789677024,
-0.0161503553,
-0.6261398792,
-0.6597309113,
-0.7508638501,
-0.1872397661,
-0.3100419939,
0.2211705595,
0.1334612519,
-0.586263299,
0.1869112551,
-0.0570656098,
0.0660431683,
0.6255676746,
0.36459741,
0.3562331498,
-1.1323530674,
0.8350684047,
0.7580023408,
0.4465627372,
-0.0914417878,
-0.2496901453,
-0.0552047342,
0.1891521215,
-0.547113657,
-1.5371699333,
0.1394969076,
0.4954093397,
0.630867064,
-0.4428357184,
0.1584252417,
0.826865077,
-0.5718348026,
0.5321641564,
0.0367082506,
-0.7983349562,
0.2398031801,
-0.2806890011,
0.4792629778,
0.8685122132,
0.6003780365,
-0.2885930538,
-0.4364350736,
-0.2014121115,
-0.5815768242,
0.4831095338,
-0.1098289341,
0.0023104839,
0.2426067293,
0.422300905,
0.2319257855,
0.5207813382,
-1.3196074963,
0.02868638,
-0.3603267074,
-0.0686977729,
0.4746813178,
-0.1562660933,
-0.1049614549,
0.0193154588,
0.665566802,
-0.3600213826,
0.2069830745,
0.0419845842,
-0.3598345518,
-0.0109853204,
0.7824454308,
0.3041735888,
1.0630443096,
-0.1391726583,
0.0004397735,
0.4257169366,
-0.3789301515,
0.2221371233,
0.1283684522,
-0.0728229955,
-0.1951258481,
-0.247841388,
0.3003994524,
-0.3916303515,
-0.4923131466,
0.3205775321,
-0.3665657938,
-0.3114459813,
-0.2092223316,
-0.1804256439,
0.0700455382,
0.1184489951,
0.4508138001,
-0.5969356894,
0.4403816164,
-0.7740409374,
0.6540632248,
0.5707614422,
-0.2128780633,
0.1404649466,
0.6528583765,
-0.0837731138,
-0.0752109066,
0.7709845901,
-0.0906805098,
-0.3187410533,
0.6999413371,
0.5578295588,
0.2437352687,
-0.0961190164,
0.6809694767,
0.5196183324,
0.2865017653,
0.4150950015,
0.9612830877,
0.0695170984,
-0.4504853487,
-0.322868675,
-0.7006260157,
-0.6670223475,
0.1051530913,
-0.8332746625,
-0.0799527541,
-0.2058910429,
-0.2377506793,
0.1803216636,
0.1231719255,
-0.7036769986,
0.3440800309,
-0.3131107986,
0.5599945188,
-0.7657034397,
0.4927493334,
0.852314055,
-0.8250879049,
-1.2132083178,
-0.1495331079,
-0.4786168635,
-0.236661762,
0.0798255578,
0.22946091,
0.2090711892,
0.127736032,
-0.4237880409,
-0.6852652431,
0.9002630711,
0.0349512659,
-0.0693765208,
-0.2724028528,
0.5947839022,
0.3970166743,
-0.0796747953,
0.3465104401,
0.6076843739,
0.49653247,
-0.2180793285,
-0.778983891,
0.1417019665,
-0.0564325787,
-0.3752682209,
0.3622252643,
-0.2869679332,
0.6844777465,
-0.381544739,
0.0128393453,
0.1032643318,
0.5896674991,
0.479583919,
0.1683766097,
0.3483548462,
0.4113232493,
0.5215180516,
-0.3872324228,
0.5725280046,
0.052734144,
0.0339940116,
1.3078844547,
-0.2340898514,
0.7946846485,
0.3222890496,
-0.2505713105,
0.4330055714,
0.6198995709,
0.0339038447,
0.2542370558,
0.4412055016,
-0.0045942934,
-0.271212101,
-0.0188064091,
-0.3579630554,
0.672452271,
0.1949151456,
0.459761858,
-0.5132068992,
-0.0953015685,
-0.365168035,
0.2235999256,
-0.371391505,
0.963804841,
-0.2243862301,
-0.6662469506,
0.4305789173,
-0.2107658982,
-0.258993417,
-0.6516198516,
-0.1996851265,
-0.379014343,
-0.2786813378,
-0.2173356116,
-0.8957131505,
0.2898472548,
-0.1514688134,
-0.1076222435,
0.1475417912,
0.1498678774,
-0.6872799397,
-0.258723855,
-0.379642725,
1.2450746298,
0.1380491108,
-0.2827065885,
-0.5761991143,
-0.5856707096,
-0.1391884983,
-0.1055738106,
0.0875883698,
0.4028818309,
-0.1241770014,
0.8336043358,
0.5266367197,
-0.1818179935,
0.5356031656,
0.0265705921,
0.9692280293,
-0.580915451,
-0.653428793,
-0.2314100116,
0.618040204,
0.1223984882,
-0.3675843179,
0.3965947032,
0.6883990169,
0.2972989082,
-0.4096596241,
0.291318357,
-0.1859159768,
0.5583593845,
-0.5897530913,
0.7386618257,
-0.700296104,
-0.2800883353,
-0.2505629659,
-1.074888587,
-0.3518161178,
0.1087317392,
-0.0716318712,
0.0210151747,
0.7784913778,
0.7608934641,
0.2124275416,
-0.2427455038,
0.1716919243,
0.0131404735,
0.4335228503,
0.7180457711,
0.9660430551,
-0.3492971361,
1.1415684223,
-0.1317831427,
-0.0486733578,
0.1779872477,
-0.3347221017,
-0.631716013,
-0.8274729252,
0.1110463142,
-0.3309655786,
-0.0554723404,
0.502443552,
0.6059982181,
-0.8573934436,
-0.2390155047,
0.1606567204,
0.1353651285,
-0.2992286086,
-0.2704468668,
0.449315995,
-0.3310756683,
-0.3373976648,
0.0682523623,
-0.2420124412,
0.0570914671,
-0.1097066626,
0.5077168941,
-0.5753091574,
0.061266657,
0.2778891027,
0.2930558622,
-0.4459216893,
-0.1584182829,
0.2957692444,
-0.0739400238,
0.3889372945,
0.4587767422,
-0.6279085279,
0.0247429144,
0.3535232544,
0.8868229985,
0.6929895282,
0.4533196986,
0.2932758927,
-0.8986535072,
-0.3274828792,
0.4503749013,
0.0270128548,
0.096436888,
-0.2733657658,
0.3045041263,
-0.540789187,
-0.7287692428,
-0.7885438204,
0.5465602279,
-0.9979425073,
-0.2043445855,
0.732088089,
0.1414200515,
-0.2181997299,
-0.4355586767,
-0.082850188,
0.3449705839,
-0.3409751058,
0.9190850854,
0.475736469,
-0.2713966072,
-0.1876811385,
-0.7249832749,
0.4714009166,
0.3801052272,
-1.5728089809,
0.1845265925,
0.8700373769,
0.2366878241,
0.2945450842,
0.666326046,
-0.1506768316,
0.8085072637,
0.0910673812,
0.2507101893,
-0.1589153111,
-0.9502536654,
0.150185436,
0.7550440431,
0.2161793709,
-0.2880853713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12818v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12818v2 | Crosslingual Transfer Learning for Low-Resource Languages Based on Multilingual Colexification Graphs | 2023-05-22T08:20:23 | 2023-10-19T14:38:17 | Yihong Liu, Haotian Ye, Leonie Weissweiler, Renhao Pei, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In comparative linguistics, colexification refers to the phenomenon of a
lexical form conveying two or more distinct meanings. Existing work on
colexification patterns relies on annotated word lists, limiting scalability
and usefulness in NLP. In contrast, we identify colexification patterns of more
than 2,000 concepts across 1,335 languages directly from an unannotated
parallel corpus. We then propose simple and effective methods to build
multilingual graphs from the colexification patterns: ColexNet and ColexNet+.
ColexNet's nodes are concepts and its edges are colexifications. In ColexNet+,
concept nodes are additionally linked through intermediate nodes, each
representing an ngram in one of 1,334 languages. We use ColexNet+ to train
$\overrightarrow{\mbox{ColexNet+}}$, high-quality multilingual embeddings that
are well-suited for transfer learning. In our experiments, we first show that
ColexNet achieves high recall on CLICS, a dataset of crosslingual
colexifications. We then evaluate $\overrightarrow{\mbox{ColexNet+}}$ on
roundtrip translation, sentence retrieval and sentence classification and show
that our embeddings surpass several transfer learning baselines. This
demonstrates the benefits of using colexification as a source of information in
multilingual NLP. | [
-0.2667607963,
-0.3397710323,
0.3170258999,
0.4489134848,
0.0128723746,
0.5138010383,
-0.5688357949,
-0.7260568142,
0.3452809751,
0.2636585236,
-0.4332095087,
-0.5339910388,
-0.3378161192,
0.1639773697,
-0.2566240132,
0.9504685402,
-0.2453355342,
0.2331683636,
-0.1480091065,
-0.5803612471,
-0.5229736567,
-0.3925761878,
-0.775519073,
-0.4061391354,
0.7536194921,
0.4883331954,
0.5484673977,
0.5902072787,
0.2324944884,
0.2815058827,
-0.0723608732,
0.1744062901,
-0.6025839448,
-0.158488676,
-0.3422037661,
-0.5616372228,
0.0122278323,
-0.058873672,
0.5451353788,
1.0914312601,
0.0275503974,
0.1091754362,
0.1527959704,
0.584798038,
-0.6339942217,
0.2271835059,
-0.3458661735,
0.4949401617,
-0.3791833222,
-0.1735693961,
-0.4599258602,
-0.4242808521,
0.0911251307,
-0.6362496018,
-0.1621511281,
0.2631908357,
0.6265480518,
-0.0720576569,
-0.4650161266,
-0.4518988729,
-0.5784049034,
1.0059306622,
-0.1839890927,
0.7561401129,
0.4661849141,
0.1028750911,
0.3800821304,
-0.7962676883,
-0.2528669536,
-0.3196150661,
-0.4894171357,
0.1923069656,
-0.2569892108,
-0.2078849077,
0.2300889194,
0.0487080514,
-0.8279206753,
0.1598484367,
-0.3396781385,
-0.4120233357,
0.4625463188,
-0.1122514606,
0.3755651116,
-0.1116636246,
-0.6354493499,
-0.3210293949,
-0.5827522874,
0.0055564251,
0.1828957647,
0.5657398105,
-0.167300716,
0.1454838067,
-0.0660272315,
0.4948870242,
-0.1950623393,
-0.1406319141,
0.5297366977,
-0.696421206,
0.1077267155,
0.2668147683,
0.7244377136,
0.0682789534,
0.4067029953,
-0.4557790458,
0.1631492376,
-0.083931677,
-0.1147236824,
-0.5608186722,
0.0231116489,
-0.0385810807,
-0.4804855287,
-0.0349849574,
-0.1688239425,
-0.6994861364,
-0.0793540254,
-0.3444811404,
-0.1079076156,
-0.6232534647,
-0.1698555946,
-0.084217906,
0.0751573667,
-0.0365714729,
0.0766225234,
-0.4270378947,
0.3186818659,
0.3977178931,
1.090510726,
-0.3837758303,
-0.6986330748,
-0.4683918655,
-0.034798719,
-0.3166430593,
0.7890126109,
-0.3767577112,
-0.1634201407,
0.1727216691,
0.2499986738,
-0.173526749,
-0.3674251437,
0.5276250243,
-0.4111507833,
0.1763549745,
-0.348783493,
-0.2821813226,
-0.3114837706,
0.4105408192,
-0.7139468789,
0.9383496642,
0.050834436,
-0.769092679,
0.0348471925,
-0.4047681987,
-0.7230491042,
0.1708175093,
0.0032623445,
0.030652402,
-0.2372089326,
-0.2542513609,
0.1765569001,
-0.2373022884,
-0.1463760138,
-0.2426425815,
0.0303742662,
0.0375919156,
-0.1710892767,
1.1651684046,
0.5092051625,
-0.0253095664,
-0.0346581452,
-0.6844755411,
0.3703506887,
0.0695929751,
-0.3325126469,
-0.778428793,
-0.3742356002,
0.2533443272,
0.4949171543,
-0.0019894999,
-0.5977780819,
-0.0248462781,
-0.1582532078,
0.3615842462,
0.3035676181,
-0.2115896344,
0.6654508114,
-0.4021612704,
0.5313025713,
0.0964854434,
-0.1067873314,
-0.0340883508,
-0.3856745064,
-0.7997282743,
0.2134579271,
0.4769653976,
0.8794961572,
-1.0757875443,
0.0703844577,
-0.2055677921,
-0.5156505108,
-0.3591750562,
0.4216250479,
0.5344954133,
0.4566092193,
0.5908107758,
-0.3451318145,
-0.6336787939,
-0.635895431,
0.0588611588,
-0.1271914691,
0.4589163065,
0.3196327388,
0.2377287,
-0.3427321613,
0.6427545547,
-0.2945069969,
-0.451901257,
-0.3391966522,
0.2955249548,
-0.0176955909,
0.37520805,
0.7103446126,
-0.6168552041,
-0.8448548913,
0.5470770001,
-0.6927409172,
-0.2366714776,
-0.4806535542,
-0.3016040027,
0.1855787188,
0.7994392514,
-0.1903841943,
0.0264689662,
0.7283549309,
-0.123498112,
0.4235913157,
-0.189030081,
-0.1609990448,
-1.1481494904,
0.1057858542,
-0.1355086267,
-0.5014546514,
-0.5940147042,
0.0429875664,
0.134700954,
-0.0938375443,
-0.7065239549,
0.5873121619,
-0.4848265946,
-0.0749473721,
-0.1242758483,
0.4803422689,
0.1083665863,
0.4874985218,
0.2578816116,
0.5333506465,
0.4431931078,
-0.3706896007,
0.5833551288,
0.2888616025,
-0.1314157844,
0.60683465,
-0.2992029786,
0.0708281323,
-0.1208387017,
0.1799539179,
-0.6365425587,
0.3640246391,
0.1541283578,
-0.1099863723,
0.1964227557,
-0.2790904641,
0.0039788717,
-0.1983205825,
-0.1823718399,
0.5777882338,
0.1652303487,
-0.6275351644,
0.2817698419,
0.217655167,
-0.2148758322,
-0.7684900165,
-0.9911160469,
0.0553820953,
-0.1858885288,
-0.4885566831,
0.389857173,
-0.1301603764,
-0.2507898808,
0.2948749065,
0.3545353413,
-0.0598639324,
0.0128469141,
-0.1606320739,
0.0383655019,
-0.2281656265,
0.2888552845,
-0.0526651032,
-0.1388493776,
-0.2381644249,
-0.5956092477,
0.6422559023,
-0.3009296656,
-0.239731878,
-0.0904264003,
0.7090372443,
0.1381273419,
-0.1968216896,
0.5755736232,
1.0323792696,
-0.2610261738,
-0.3270944059,
-0.1645574272,
0.0669274256,
-0.3510092497,
0.404881835,
-0.4333057702,
-0.9154971838,
0.6549613476,
-0.267295748,
-0.1678054631,
0.2817198634,
0.4571217597,
0.0382957086,
0.5917719603,
0.6543959379,
-0.0200302731,
0.448107481,
-0.3714188337,
-0.0046784664,
-0.6534301639,
-0.1913551986,
-0.5894251466,
-0.3225543201,
-1.0107287169,
-0.455671519,
0.0229571518,
0.2529156804,
0.0122745177,
0.7368429303,
-0.0389960036,
0.6204865575,
0.6437287927,
-0.0699505284,
0.3737592697,
0.1832953691,
-0.5145369768,
-0.0311747454,
-0.9137895703,
-0.0408639535,
0.7573499084,
0.051960241,
0.8411228061,
0.2066869587,
0.8097711205,
0.3726634681,
0.1422536969,
-0.9829814434,
0.2716718912,
-0.279612869,
-0.1052451655,
-0.1970998794,
-0.8225950599,
-1.1321282387,
0.1488439739,
-0.3862811029,
-0.6457372904,
0.5982410908,
-0.1524654031,
-0.2246382982,
0.2339272648,
-0.7577828169,
0.8034380674,
-0.4704415798,
-0.634049356,
-0.2766132653,
-0.6234821081,
0.1129905954,
-0.2315517366,
0.4498022795,
0.0801626593,
0.2001571208,
0.4916591048,
-0.3131708801,
0.8104521632,
0.1355272382,
-0.0397109538,
0.3080005646,
0.272154361,
0.416940093,
0.0504506789,
0.14469482,
0.5296090841,
0.1133862063,
-0.400408119,
-0.4309805036,
0.8249035478,
-0.8929034472,
-0.1334159374,
-0.5438665748,
-0.5984427929,
-0.0837456807,
0.5160873532,
0.214242354,
0.0609861836,
-0.3004344702,
-0.0274579953,
0.3272404671,
-0.3055564761,
0.6288431287,
0.2247104347,
-0.2347744107,
-0.3035472631,
1.1410843134,
0.2190242261,
0.4600705504,
0.4205480516,
0.2740765512,
-0.2177357227,
-0.3615966141,
-0.453469336,
0.4452553689,
-0.7544865012,
-0.2653676569,
-0.3921158314,
-0.2482476383,
-0.4516822696,
-0.2538055182,
-0.5195090771,
-0.5583955646,
-0.0406042039,
0.0785052702,
0.1092274487,
0.458201468,
-0.6344465017,
0.0984915644,
-0.9270612597,
-0.1253019124,
0.2380681187,
0.1892687529,
-0.0721487701,
-0.2519820631,
-0.600551784,
0.0978806913,
-0.10681656,
-0.6925622821,
0.5205951929,
0.4401310384,
0.4662601054,
0.4336354733,
0.014597863,
0.834495008,
-0.6172439456,
0.3875099123,
0.4373915195,
-0.9886942506,
0.2599039972,
0.0980888456,
0.1686960906,
0.5561532378,
0.8361362219,
-1.351682663,
-0.064527221,
-0.3995064199,
-0.730535686,
0.9256972075,
0.0126468372,
0.066793412,
0.0318947211,
0.198730737,
0.071550943,
-0.1658388674,
-0.8580630422,
-0.2514147758,
-0.374032557,
-0.0003271192,
-0.0944031999,
-0.0448276028,
-0.1827393472,
-0.0057771839,
0.6360434294,
-0.3420524895,
0.1897813082,
0.0012125664,
-0.5142613649,
0.0156942178,
0.2733660638,
0.4919361472,
0.4268550575,
-0.0389817022,
0.4034787416,
0.4138375223,
-0.3940244913,
0.1149731576,
0.1842106581,
-0.2679386139,
0.0784439519,
0.6682103276,
0.8448774219,
-0.0302635748,
-0.4574567974,
0.3429676294,
-0.1002511382,
0.0058078319,
-0.3044651151,
-0.2466991544,
0.1058146134,
0.271225065,
-0.0731773823,
0.1267914176,
0.2111689299,
-0.7312970161,
0.185309276,
0.2190103531,
-0.5764065981,
-0.3177742958,
0.2233790755,
0.1442106664,
-0.1449583769,
0.7077108622,
-0.4862398505,
-0.4809396863,
0.2751925886,
0.7708014846,
0.6311003566,
-0.2012683749,
0.5430876017,
0.6482595205,
0.3256492317,
0.0260457005,
0.0668574795,
-0.2442991138,
-1.0782402754,
-0.6171389818,
-0.5125182271,
-0.3159349263,
-0.2595425844,
-0.7198505402,
0.3035222292,
-0.1930521727,
-0.0118919332,
-0.1196506023,
-0.0444979966,
-0.6341695189,
-0.1261649877,
0.5387339592,
0.7800297141,
-1.1249796152,
0.9507513046,
0.7578856945,
-0.4971678555,
-0.5870736837,
-0.1850277632,
-0.0852893442,
-0.8960246444,
0.8263700008,
-0.0905483961,
-0.1284152865,
-0.0837092772,
-0.0726142824,
-1.1020768881,
1.036015749,
0.3832692802,
-0.5905306339,
-0.1978122741,
0.5180872083,
0.4809463918,
-0.3906011879,
0.4563969076,
0.4082882106,
0.4099711478,
0.3137179911,
-0.7953215837,
0.0040574488,
-0.1685317159,
0.1726812869,
-0.0495337658,
-0.8573501706,
0.7517707944,
-0.1402453333,
-0.462271899,
-0.1949792057,
0.5387653708,
-0.1354833692,
0.1581803411,
0.4589342773,
0.6496109366,
0.9659996033,
-0.1815690547,
0.8589359522,
-0.3654909432,
0.4300258458,
1.3477218151,
-0.3580335677,
0.6041106582,
0.3978470266,
-0.0106892437,
0.7789139152,
0.5906845331,
0.1650324315,
0.4693983197,
0.0306890458,
-0.1079782769,
-0.2605927289,
-0.6080795527,
-0.3658073246,
0.5584312677,
0.3572485745,
-0.2763155103,
-0.4457841516,
0.3885166645,
0.3380370438,
0.1132002771,
-0.2843741775,
0.6307187676,
0.1726995409,
-0.4855243862,
0.723764956,
0.0172711406,
0.4296380281,
-0.5654914379,
0.1325895339,
-0.6459280252,
0.2173209041,
-0.2713634074,
-0.7052333951,
0.4766971171,
-0.2729815543,
0.048371762,
-0.5466096401,
0.6352138519,
-0.9018625021,
-0.4509715736,
0.8422627449,
0.7948356271,
0.1863309592,
0.5227307677,
-0.8674836159,
-0.0947472602,
0.13764669,
0.1224221215,
0.2847253382,
0.620901525,
-0.3623491228,
0.5175712705,
0.5656319261,
0.4201612175,
0.0582542829,
0.3013971448,
0.6747770905,
-0.4535942078,
-0.4395963848,
-0.6262508631,
0.0215519723,
0.0172138903,
-0.2540363967,
0.8712557554,
0.530991137,
1.4081677198,
0.1153111309,
0.7305428982,
-0.1637884229,
0.289729327,
-0.5894392133,
0.5317344069,
-0.5587849617,
-0.1278513074,
-0.2141428888,
-0.8557581306,
-0.4731360674,
0.5848571062,
-0.0748909935,
-0.1529697925,
1.1084362268,
0.4855672717,
-0.1630069166,
-0.0928105637,
0.3505621552,
0.2565937936,
-0.1130688861,
0.8291583061,
0.9027493,
-0.2771135271,
0.8958669901,
-0.6168343425,
-0.198991552,
0.0095319804,
-0.7427011728,
-0.705272913,
-0.6885464191,
-0.4685167968,
-0.5225193501,
-0.0531135388,
1.0468621254,
0.8538830876,
-1.0213804245,
-0.5819308758,
-0.0152904224,
0.433868885,
-0.42933622,
-0.1807185858,
0.3851284087,
-0.702552855,
-0.8700818419,
0.4367526472,
0.0342384763,
-0.0358836018,
-0.2537072301,
-0.1772817373,
-0.5594323874,
-0.2777383327,
0.8601005673,
0.5007940531,
-0.0781270564,
-0.3095557094,
0.1035583317,
-0.047195293,
0.0941966251,
0.9436546564,
-0.7284222841,
0.3771083653,
0.5287926197,
0.6906183958,
0.5939249992,
-0.3622026742,
0.1608972996,
-1.0541621447,
0.5341069698,
0.1599448621,
0.4704342186,
0.2938742936,
-0.1348996907,
0.6839309931,
0.5867077708,
-0.2727778256,
-0.5180962682,
0.4640929401,
-0.8605258465,
-0.2748725116,
1.2195849419,
-0.396227777,
-0.3636308014,
-0.2119002342,
-0.0354729071,
0.2292768955,
-0.1191905364,
0.3921771049,
0.5273856521,
-0.1111381277,
-0.2494086176,
-0.1658900976,
0.4318342805,
0.3775337338,
-0.7922005057,
0.0186760575,
0.3811323345,
0.0947946459,
0.8175256848,
0.3307884037,
-0.0121648004,
0.1250678599,
-0.0371826701,
0.2685951889,
0.0616543256,
-0.3682547212,
-0.0503124744,
0.1372339427,
-0.1377698183,
0.0072873402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12816v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12816v1 | Farewell to Aimless Large-scale Pretraining: Influential Subset Selection for Language Model | 2023-05-22T08:18:58 | 2023-05-22T08:18:58 | Xiao Wang, Weikang Zhou, Qi Zhang, Jie Zhou, Songyang Gao, Junzhe Wang, Menghan Zhang, Xiang Gao, Yunwen Chen, Tao Gui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models have achieved remarkable success in various
natural language processing tasks. However, pretraining has recently shifted
toward larger models and larger data, and this has resulted in significant
computational and energy costs. In this paper, we propose Influence Subset
Selection (ISS) for language model, which explicitly utilizes end-task
knowledge to select a tiny subset of the pretraining corpus. Specifically, the
ISS selects the samples that will provide the most positive influence on the
performance of the end-task. Furthermore, we design a gradient matching based
influence estimation method, which can drastically reduce the computation time
of influence. With only 0.45% of the data and a three-orders-of-magnitude lower
computational cost, ISS outperformed pretrained models (e.g., RoBERTa) on eight
datasets covering four domains. | [
-0.5115791559,
-0.4911202192,
0.5493114591,
0.2544554174,
-0.3664591014,
-0.2623449564,
-0.530826807,
-0.4307656288,
0.3220238388,
0.7179064751,
-0.5022923946,
-0.2620327175,
-0.9621436596,
-0.0722873956,
-0.4455050528,
0.9520222545,
0.0726035535,
0.0945796892,
-0.2439026833,
0.1187896132,
-0.17558074,
-0.1512507647,
-0.7346583009,
-0.2958263755,
0.2340396345,
0.2233687937,
0.3665309548,
0.2765815258,
0.4311818779,
0.2872603834,
-0.1856707633,
-0.1768732965,
-0.9121030569,
0.0995155647,
-0.2852944732,
-0.4735108316,
-0.042996794,
0.2356796712,
0.4951505363,
0.797909379,
0.1628055871,
0.3252800107,
0.0012662878,
0.7651333213,
-0.8522078991,
0.0446786769,
-0.8792309761,
-0.1284134239,
-0.4268341064,
0.1974680275,
-0.6515542269,
-0.2531404495,
0.0355611257,
-0.714420557,
-0.0424766652,
0.2216506451,
0.4957153201,
0.5559377074,
-0.1555244476,
0.0587006882,
-0.6865804195,
1.1615842581,
-0.5042353272,
0.4514424205,
0.9513545632,
-0.0369927809,
-0.1128188446,
-0.6562344432,
-0.2513613701,
-0.3085303605,
-0.0302268788,
-0.0032415041,
-0.2362455279,
0.0911746621,
0.1860616356,
-0.0678839833,
-0.2584363818,
0.1726287752,
-0.3206743002,
0.1926470995,
0.4075080156,
-0.516353786,
0.2459646165,
0.1833442599,
0.0919476673,
0.0149065945,
-1.0577466488,
-0.1581788659,
0.2237818688,
0.1682729572,
0.042232722,
0.3027544022,
-0.4171042442,
0.8381311893,
0.2924552262,
0.2055950463,
0.187908724,
-0.2584867477,
-0.3018243015,
-0.1245367676,
0.7651588917,
0.05387602,
0.4659108818,
-0.2585149705,
-0.1103280708,
-0.2840878963,
0.1489493549,
-1.0698951483,
-0.1443748325,
-0.065481618,
-0.515222311,
0.0276853908,
-0.0016170456,
-0.6243304014,
-0.1647858024,
-0.5935076475,
0.3411925733,
-0.3861893713,
-0.3150480986,
-0.1494967192,
-0.0515695848,
0.0227022935,
0.2996476293,
-0.9588811398,
0.2521726787,
0.4534913599,
0.7277250886,
0.0290270261,
-0.2254502028,
-0.669536829,
-0.0336053111,
-0.4401960075,
0.5983368754,
-1.1025164127,
-0.5422698855,
-0.2659970224,
-0.2844825387,
-0.1630559862,
-0.5301147699,
0.3079957366,
-0.5502765179,
0.1550170034,
-0.3365835547,
-0.4953804314,
0.1456635147,
-0.1326402277,
-0.7246097922,
1.1113334894,
0.3656737804,
-0.7118848562,
0.4851834476,
-0.5026726127,
-0.7657950521,
-0.0204652306,
-0.1109932065,
-0.212909773,
0.2052139044,
0.3107987642,
0.5753257275,
-0.4628492594,
0.2601376772,
-0.5060912967,
-0.3872014284,
-0.2593375742,
0.0707777292,
0.8247390985,
0.1112167835,
-0.532520771,
0.0906471685,
-0.6690726876,
-0.0471867993,
-0.2897105217,
0.1095819995,
-0.8877665997,
-0.0225493424,
-0.0551052205,
0.4214532375,
0.1090933084,
-0.6142787933,
-0.0069724033,
-0.1516580433,
0.2647749782,
0.728556335,
0.143509984,
0.6829001904,
-0.0701562837,
0.6992796063,
-0.3578768075,
0.0971078947,
0.23973988,
-0.3197899461,
-0.524110496,
-0.3222745359,
0.5364462137,
0.1123876125,
-0.7891531587,
0.6117053032,
-0.2754048705,
-0.6737040281,
-0.5810237527,
0.391416043,
0.5497534275,
0.2526524961,
0.5989438295,
-0.074618943,
-0.7786188722,
-0.8879747987,
-0.4991449416,
0.0559367277,
-0.0904253572,
0.189891547,
0.5117958784,
-0.0780663565,
0.9177669287,
-0.612393856,
-0.5325247645,
-0.6223885417,
-0.0837590843,
0.0583670624,
0.5377525091,
0.9390597939,
-0.4991398454,
-0.9921011329,
-0.0308101401,
-0.3406397402,
-0.2850350738,
-0.1439489573,
-0.6327034831,
-0.3864015341,
0.988530159,
-0.6439068913,
0.2811142802,
0.5900858641,
-0.2390302569,
0.308411181,
0.0729617402,
-0.1451591551,
-0.9369562268,
0.3366627693,
0.3050523698,
-0.1050472334,
-0.7174978256,
-0.2672894597,
-0.0156577397,
0.164933145,
-0.1752666533,
0.8745527267,
-0.6528230906,
0.206702292,
-0.0512269735,
0.057455305,
-0.0793943182,
0.3899113536,
0.246392712,
0.6608319879,
0.7391107082,
-0.588059485,
-0.3210225403,
0.3179685175,
-0.6465786099,
0.3923318386,
-0.5143306851,
0.113939397,
-0.2650380135,
0.2772148252,
-0.7044274807,
0.0788318515,
-0.157373786,
-0.2176197618,
0.3846800923,
-0.2892170846,
-0.085793063,
-0.0862845257,
-0.2660604119,
0.1924672276,
0.6748278737,
-0.377030462,
0.5444127917,
0.5837789774,
-0.3734386861,
-0.5972132087,
-0.4897508025,
-0.0408962071,
-0.0328230374,
-0.0754636973,
0.4293549657,
-0.1261463463,
-0.3274285793,
-0.0104156788,
0.0783386379,
-0.0360720828,
-0.1009209231,
0.2559729815,
0.0408145785,
-0.06487225,
0.0779078379,
0.2131959349,
0.0297671221,
0.0096924724,
-0.24571082,
0.4817550778,
0.3709820509,
-0.2695775628,
-0.2509377599,
0.1880166531,
0.7246482968,
-0.4912785888,
0.9195041656,
0.4534957409,
-0.2721643746,
-0.4486568868,
-0.6817401052,
-0.1747914255,
-0.4137272239,
0.8392958641,
-0.0969799608,
-0.6527526975,
0.2226211876,
-0.1071577296,
0.1480092257,
0.4240488112,
0.3583450317,
0.3006950021,
0.8221077323,
0.7095204592,
-0.6164281964,
1.3112769127,
-0.1925249398,
0.0584576875,
-1.0637325048,
-0.0278780069,
-0.6508879066,
-0.3601167202,
-0.1210670993,
-0.3325637877,
0.235665977,
0.0338355266,
-0.2092484236,
0.3171642721,
-0.1725766957,
0.5506388545,
0.6437634826,
0.126654774,
-0.1061486974,
-0.1605594307,
0.1793403774,
0.0827594474,
-0.5239079595,
0.088322714,
1.4373314381,
-0.1277889609,
0.6628371477,
0.0099356892,
0.6199687123,
0.1468923539,
0.630061388,
-0.3813834488,
0.617435813,
-0.3210633695,
-0.5380970836,
-0.5504072309,
-0.5689982772,
-0.9718202353,
0.2954025865,
-0.3001243472,
-0.6590179801,
-0.0102411173,
0.1739727855,
-0.2883730233,
0.2178295553,
-0.7636799216,
0.7631616592,
-0.1204187945,
-0.3474169672,
-0.5185260773,
-0.6091464162,
0.2274735123,
-0.4593108594,
0.2707619965,
-0.0006680665,
0.3034787178,
1.139259696,
-0.4615365565,
0.8117849231,
-0.5582004189,
0.4137766659,
0.3097987473,
0.0220462475,
0.7909216285,
-0.2160982043,
-0.4108387828,
0.0964434892,
-0.2989970148,
-0.2466400415,
-0.4936612546,
0.6238998175,
-0.7644284964,
-0.3488377929,
0.2260496169,
-0.1674741358,
-0.4848170877,
0.5884973407,
0.5397823453,
0.4028727114,
-0.4539946318,
0.598939538,
0.4840011895,
0.1029758155,
0.5340715051,
0.4971911013,
-0.1897627413,
-0.224345535,
0.777076602,
0.2396025509,
0.466804713,
0.4546017945,
0.1727022827,
-0.2268274873,
-0.6735111475,
-0.3006398976,
0.3228607178,
-0.3875897229,
-0.1594199985,
-0.6231567264,
-0.0391208567,
-0.4029275775,
-0.2111392766,
-0.6110361218,
-0.0737157241,
-0.3391757011,
-0.1156556681,
0.1428100765,
0.904949069,
0.0889021382,
0.7368362546,
-0.485756129,
0.2242655605,
0.0511928238,
0.5561757684,
-0.0070871599,
-0.6151915193,
-0.584846437,
-0.2195474505,
-0.0076192077,
-0.6646367908,
0.307390511,
0.6210132837,
0.8138280511,
0.7089663148,
0.2054769993,
0.4490021467,
-0.4476309419,
0.5051851273,
0.3324915171,
-1.0661096573,
0.3915126622,
-0.1145199761,
0.5426769853,
0.9917024374,
0.4985496104,
-0.4385599494,
-0.3706480861,
-0.7436724305,
-0.7070816159,
0.727035284,
0.255340457,
-0.0375105254,
0.0664834157,
0.3320530057,
-0.011359225,
0.3689331412,
-0.6477614045,
-0.1238217354,
0.0690321401,
-0.1584634781,
-0.2718234658,
-0.0983217135,
0.2277660519,
-0.3948068917,
0.9948308468,
-0.0048385449,
-0.0400097854,
-0.0662867427,
-0.269066304,
-0.3554916382,
-0.0624802299,
0.3126630187,
0.7043623328,
-0.1023667976,
-0.079725273,
0.1457161307,
-0.7147431374,
-0.1528657824,
0.1440503597,
-0.3900454044,
0.0379664674,
0.5677048564,
0.9704173207,
0.3985703886,
-0.4680789411,
0.4882106781,
-0.0929962248,
-0.0755429864,
-0.1061265841,
0.0864750892,
-0.1194363013,
-0.1444429457,
0.1788582802,
0.3142528534,
-0.1611478925,
-0.2358341068,
0.2025416344,
0.7769137025,
-0.7449082732,
-0.4638400674,
0.580868721,
0.3537665606,
0.0434081405,
0.5160534382,
-0.2865146101,
-0.5298547745,
0.5205539465,
0.3647318184,
0.8282071352,
-0.5797079802,
0.0406348221,
0.423689127,
0.3813450038,
-0.4198538065,
-0.0584447756,
-0.0523293801,
-0.6447041631,
-0.7018430829,
-0.5216405392,
-0.2188765854,
0.4236167669,
-0.6877369285,
0.4259551466,
-0.4815410674,
-0.09484265,
-0.1485032141,
-0.07703311,
-0.7007579207,
0.3734621406,
-0.094479315,
0.7603222132,
-0.99867028,
0.9592202902,
0.6445648074,
-0.1447832286,
-0.5877954364,
0.1077965721,
-0.1619307697,
-0.6787486672,
0.6606303453,
0.0454304591,
-0.1624041796,
0.4334356189,
-0.6446621418,
-1.2021998167,
0.6289993525,
0.4680631161,
-0.5988643765,
0.1906986088,
-0.2491314262,
0.3883133233,
-0.3061969578,
0.561804533,
0.6367832422,
0.4781838953,
0.1815058142,
-0.8064506054,
-0.0118888784,
-0.3703446686,
-0.2679303586,
0.415874511,
-0.7063270211,
0.6898140311,
-0.2149070054,
0.1326001436,
-0.2277632654,
0.7122586966,
-0.0915648639,
-0.1940070242,
0.826126039,
0.3477065563,
0.6686912179,
0.3688010573,
0.9157164097,
-0.7318349481,
0.2375692129,
1.158084631,
-0.2650298476,
0.9960517883,
0.478527844,
-0.4138739705,
0.2439105064,
0.690615952,
0.3990497887,
0.7080556154,
0.2024301738,
-0.0934165046,
-0.3625050783,
-0.0191186033,
-0.4915771484,
0.4044941366,
0.2776183784,
-0.383169502,
-0.0609523021,
-0.042273581,
0.235543713,
-0.352774471,
-0.3594819605,
0.6077531576,
0.1675060689,
-0.9837605953,
0.2999446094,
-0.2277139872,
0.5862838626,
-1.0923665762,
0.0426922962,
-0.238550961,
0.1113833338,
-0.0660599619,
-0.2544957995,
0.0328835733,
-0.2268534303,
-0.1256531477,
-0.3682469428,
0.689535141,
-0.4751345813,
-0.45036906,
0.4698093235,
0.580866456,
-0.0695632994,
-0.5754907727,
-0.4154779315,
-0.1376353502,
0.3689081371,
-0.6201536059,
0.7549918294,
0.170775041,
-0.0728939176,
0.6058313847,
0.8968510628,
0.5512708426,
-0.0992727801,
0.0577091649,
0.9359200001,
-0.4662954211,
-0.6240612864,
-0.7696954608,
0.183354944,
-0.2685699165,
-0.5280704498,
0.6166645288,
0.4107707143,
0.669478178,
0.0354265049,
1.1512100697,
-0.1989416033,
0.5107787848,
-0.4627561271,
0.8738933206,
-0.4106875658,
0.1202167124,
-0.5794898272,
-1.1334722042,
-0.2395407259,
0.5410763621,
-0.7335947752,
0.3582319319,
0.6049991846,
0.591604948,
-0.0947930068,
0.02300217,
0.3770281971,
0.3543981314,
0.1969426721,
0.2656100094,
0.3500818312,
0.2003912181,
0.2324338257,
-0.1662865281,
-0.5600146651,
-0.1867027134,
-0.8574747443,
-1.1651672125,
-0.5849892497,
-0.1151083708,
-0.0993141979,
-0.1121485084,
1.195546031,
1.0628581047,
-0.8630697131,
0.0377662405,
-0.1252753586,
0.1343234032,
-0.1796390563,
-0.0893739387,
0.6304014325,
-0.3242375255,
-0.8491873741,
0.442736268,
-0.0159228574,
-0.3059716523,
-0.2119742036,
-0.0275229756,
-0.4379787445,
-0.1194602922,
0.5842680931,
0.3922820687,
-0.3605417609,
-0.1281651855,
-0.1379936188,
0.1517528892,
-0.1732761413,
0.940346837,
-0.7592062354,
0.3554500937,
0.2720074654,
0.7853393555,
0.5495918989,
0.0668803006,
0.5773397088,
-0.7903783321,
0.2225773782,
0.1475272179,
0.511187613,
0.0958545208,
-0.4293047488,
0.565741241,
0.2189709842,
-0.5664550662,
-0.5744462013,
0.0977862328,
-0.5792383552,
-0.3185220361,
1.480484724,
-0.1060802937,
-0.1497676373,
-0.2250941396,
-0.1834874302,
-0.04638578,
-0.538356185,
0.538505733,
0.5346303582,
-0.3392111659,
-0.0401568338,
-0.612834692,
0.7096904516,
0.7667945027,
-0.7105621696,
0.0435761549,
0.2921262085,
0.1779616475,
-0.0037650538,
0.7491108179,
0.3637795746,
-0.2539239228,
0.0212910715,
0.1854532212,
-0.0429131091,
-0.43763116,
0.0795036033,
0.025058873,
0.2315758616,
-0.0369130485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12815v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12815v2 | Investigating Agency of LLMs in Human-AI Collaboration Tasks | 2023-05-22T08:17:14 | 2024-02-08T02:22:53 | Ashish Sharma, Sudha Rao, Chris Brockett, Akanksha Malhotra, Nebojsa Jojic, Bill Dolan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Agency, the capacity to proactively shape events, is central to how humans
interact and collaborate. While LLMs are being developed to simulate human
behavior and serve as human-like agents, little attention has been given to the
Agency that these models should possess in order to proactively manage the
direction of interaction and collaboration. In this paper, we investigate
Agency as a desirable function of LLMs, and how it can be measured and managed.
We build on social-cognitive theory to develop a framework of features through
which Agency is expressed in dialogue - indicating what you intend to do
(Intentionality), motivating your intentions (Motivation), having self-belief
in intentions (Self-Efficacy), and being able to self-adjust (Self-Regulation).
We collect a new dataset of 83 human-human collaborative interior design
conversations containing 908 conversational snippets annotated for Agency
features. Using this dataset, we develop methods for measuring Agency of LLMs.
Automatic and human evaluations show that models that manifest features
associated with high Intentionality, Motivation, Self-Efficacy, and
Self-Regulation are more likely to be perceived as strongly agentive. | [
-0.4342106581,
-0.7786166668,
1.0312355757,
0.3257832825,
0.0789355189,
0.3711292744,
-0.097118035,
-0.5194638371,
0.5920915604,
0.4617818296,
-0.8155012131,
-0.173017174,
-0.230218932,
0.0788281485,
-0.1371979117,
0.4457782209,
-0.3814145029,
-0.093271412,
-0.5854142308,
-0.0708612949,
-0.8089486361,
-0.4319095016,
-0.4533177912,
-0.5335001945,
0.6803997755,
0.5166755319,
0.7984330058,
0.4201468825,
0.7271662951,
0.4011906087,
0.3609449565,
0.0893481076,
-0.4012046158,
0.1378431022,
-0.1183879972,
-0.447804153,
-0.8973050714,
0.5197917819,
0.2408970147,
0.3942044079,
-0.3970796168,
0.2505878508,
0.2265372425,
0.4573257565,
-0.3547911942,
0.392873317,
-0.1953549385,
-0.1293438077,
0.1582415551,
-0.3594173193,
-0.1014221981,
0.0662133917,
-0.0006912391,
-0.6277166605,
0.0520648472,
0.0573184565,
0.4801411927,
0.4794223011,
-0.4715586305,
-0.5383062959,
-0.9136999249,
0.4591677785,
-0.2152487636,
-0.0696624666,
0.6798467636,
0.1015915126,
-0.3180779815,
-0.5152240396,
-0.3636777997,
-0.4960534573,
-0.4391321838,
-0.004089681,
0.1360232681,
0.1660779268,
-0.268189013,
0.0065961354,
-0.2169417739,
0.0119510451,
-0.0147435945,
-0.1933441013,
1.169065237,
0.5625927448,
0.6601111889,
0.1797743738,
-0.4321758151,
0.014547009,
-0.3381695151,
0.1658168286,
-0.061586462,
0.0886042118,
-0.0435815379,
0.5463736653,
-0.1231768802,
-0.1287673116,
0.0400109664,
0.1879676133,
-0.2121876627,
-0.5798895955,
0.0283468775,
-0.0177665036,
0.5059816837,
0.302628696,
0.0665621161,
-0.3299833238,
-0.2062937915,
0.2044258267,
0.825987637,
-0.3765536845,
0.3211942017,
0.2457184941,
-0.3004390299,
-0.3007741272,
0.2018454075,
0.2054359764,
-0.4556567967,
-0.7554898262,
0.3354436159,
0.0064407461,
-0.4370794594,
-0.1845178753,
0.2084289193,
0.4423338175,
0.2931495607,
-0.5221859813,
0.5254964828,
0.8351891637,
0.5418418646,
-0.3751456439,
-0.6837932467,
-0.0035756652,
0.0211743936,
-0.8151885867,
0.576028049,
-0.1883198768,
-0.3917999566,
-0.0620806478,
-0.0410255194,
0.06295304,
-0.1951049119,
0.3254643679,
-0.1812558919,
-0.2305700034,
-0.5215328336,
-0.4733888209,
-0.1285980344,
0.3059776723,
-0.4255077243,
0.6143785715,
0.2387176603,
0.1005884558,
0.5048393607,
-0.9843870401,
-0.2600651979,
0.4783073068,
-0.4805586338,
-0.2754464746,
0.2147219181,
-0.3459376097,
0.5292831659,
-0.2409603596,
0.359888494,
-0.2865013182,
-0.4239913821,
0.9506415129,
-0.230736956,
0.5742768645,
-0.0186454002,
-0.3704040647,
0.5569169521,
-0.2614612281,
-0.0775343552,
-0.037426874,
-0.2337300032,
-0.1988684535,
0.0155609855,
-0.2013437599,
0.1879624575,
0.5878481865,
-0.1899430901,
0.0864107162,
0.1550045758,
0.195157215,
0.8938586712,
0.1841706038,
0.6986502409,
-0.6927149892,
0.4969852567,
-0.5021018386,
0.3755029142,
0.4529403746,
-0.2720158398,
-0.5708605051,
-0.4659857452,
-0.4819658101,
0.2368165553,
-0.5043956637,
0.7278321981,
-0.0229673982,
-0.4651701748,
-0.4772188365,
0.3796366155,
0.3927056789,
-0.1536551863,
-0.1352333277,
-0.6862533689,
-0.0464039594,
-0.7400087118,
-0.0754557997,
-0.1655642241,
-0.1359401643,
0.6041784286,
0.5077301264,
-0.4161865115,
1.171171546,
-0.3572696149,
-0.7986399531,
-0.3306883574,
0.3975897431,
0.022118289,
0.3572981656,
0.4658380449,
-0.740321815,
-0.4142343104,
-0.1424891204,
-1.0618282557,
-0.1899142116,
-0.0803005695,
-0.3666790128,
0.1049840599,
0.4870996475,
-0.8985657096,
0.5446602702,
-0.0171224661,
-0.9482722282,
0.4068268239,
-0.3720135093,
0.2018989921,
-0.8197135329,
-0.1704376936,
-0.132452175,
0.0967789963,
-0.8450831175,
0.2817623913,
-0.2412143499,
0.3295655251,
-0.5722453594,
0.4984734654,
-0.6870923042,
-0.3593789935,
-0.3875398338,
0.1217518523,
-0.0893258378,
0.8170573711,
-0.0902174041,
0.728582859,
0.3789700568,
-0.6120489836,
0.4772257805,
0.2547699809,
-0.2389058769,
0.8181712627,
-0.4878230095,
0.5769762993,
-0.0082739554,
0.2859993875,
-0.9094310999,
-0.4298542738,
0.1470043063,
-0.1948102415,
0.05428873,
0.4087793231,
-0.5683698058,
-0.0919135362,
-0.2339845151,
0.3031731546,
0.0432568491,
-0.1006599814,
1.2764203548,
0.4648109376,
-0.020548556,
-0.1031162441,
-0.621686101,
0.1886686981,
-0.2291821539,
-0.6704747081,
0.3196984828,
-0.1646190882,
-0.7254806757,
0.0445243865,
0.0456800573,
0.0516004004,
0.4725882113,
0.7022231221,
0.4476948678,
0.172475934,
-0.1908761263,
-0.5405471325,
0.0076110279,
0.5730811357,
0.3586760461,
0.397346288,
-0.4478677511,
-0.7035260201,
-0.5767998695,
0.1382834464,
0.6955832243,
-0.0223604925,
0.5556325316,
0.5215116143,
-0.2337926924,
0.0373658575,
-0.5207006335,
-0.4336218536,
-0.4886582494,
0.1084572822,
-0.2908301651,
-0.6255377531,
0.848969698,
0.1763093621,
0.1621800661,
-0.0478211269,
0.5805348158,
-0.4019881785,
0.7876895666,
0.6341009736,
-0.0551990159,
0.4039742053,
-0.3519110382,
-0.1358964741,
-1.0063881874,
-0.1629100293,
-0.0977563784,
-0.6639899015,
-0.6739794612,
-0.4722754359,
0.4025630653,
-0.5018687844,
-0.1698546857,
0.2669979334,
-0.315679729,
0.4224430621,
0.4704114497,
0.1883358508,
0.1677226424,
-0.5409159064,
0.4039760232,
0.1875650883,
-0.1896310151,
-0.5503081679,
0.815974772,
0.418530792,
0.7560279965,
0.380218029,
0.7203472257,
0.5187267065,
0.4750827551,
-0.8213994503,
0.8849270344,
0.3993743658,
-0.7642734051,
-0.736328721,
-0.0317824259,
-1.0605971813,
0.0943044052,
-0.1699320078,
-0.7580364347,
0.321044594,
-0.1823668033,
-0.2401519865,
-0.2244134992,
-0.5107831955,
0.4970109463,
-0.5556486249,
-0.6962864399,
-0.585281074,
-0.313251853,
0.1417274177,
-0.0844750404,
0.1699382812,
-0.4677237868,
-0.2328829616,
0.357188344,
-0.109802559,
1.0784031153,
0.1046353132,
-0.1993113607,
0.5690438151,
0.496334374,
0.6024831533,
-0.0194652174,
0.2077150196,
0.067521587,
-0.2274709791,
-0.3019160032,
-0.6640560627,
0.4533345401,
-1.0703930855,
-0.7592685223,
-0.3486965597,
-0.6730018854,
-0.1257487535,
-0.0291366559,
-0.2640457153,
0.2021746635,
-0.8125612736,
0.3168244362,
0.2662127912,
0.3372346759,
0.5251691341,
0.8333978057,
-0.1677764058,
-0.0381954126,
0.7305752039,
0.2621175647,
0.3323098421,
0.0751274303,
0.1400482059,
-0.1884238422,
-0.0150200203,
0.2592986226,
0.1300538182,
-0.5962941647,
0.09470357,
-0.1572742313,
-0.3114786148,
-0.1965630203,
-0.5180766582,
-0.2660969794,
-0.060699854,
-0.5705836415,
-0.1952394098,
-0.0081924098,
1.0472257137,
0.0447605103,
0.2805681527,
-0.2618688941,
0.1850005686,
0.5449278951,
0.2323810607,
-0.1093594804,
-0.1277673841,
-0.3432775736,
-0.0555838384,
-0.4070122242,
-0.533929646,
0.4101291299,
-0.1999353766,
0.8150510788,
0.3755848706,
0.1685689688,
0.2317807674,
0.1665730923,
0.7179537416,
-0.2232009619,
-0.7001574039,
0.2541494071,
-0.5014071465,
0.0420128591,
0.5415940285,
0.0429897383,
-0.2476578355,
-0.5264227986,
-0.835190773,
-0.6227207184,
0.8620481491,
0.5649963021,
0.1005042344,
0.2868330479,
0.3992567062,
-0.3983281851,
0.2311183363,
-0.5055791736,
-0.2547235787,
0.4160166085,
0.1185977533,
-0.1535917372,
-0.3189639449,
-0.5418145657,
0.0019224944,
0.4228375554,
-0.241646722,
0.3500088751,
0.2524503171,
0.1100074202,
-0.513707459,
0.3664988875,
0.6060717106,
0.8549175262,
-0.2217419147,
0.0715358853,
0.1463588476,
-0.2608406246,
0.3594944775,
-0.3210696578,
0.2348378301,
-0.5789372921,
0.4660428762,
0.5619820952,
0.0659387559,
-0.1480245292,
0.4932204485,
-0.3436447978,
-0.277273953,
-0.626486361,
0.5120130181,
0.1349765956,
0.5074380636,
0.4369086921,
-0.0398938134,
0.1412563473,
-1.0499573946,
0.0648340359,
0.652849257,
-0.3508704901,
-0.3178119957,
0.273670882,
0.3855591416,
-0.8833503723,
0.4448267817,
-0.3659388721,
-0.1747644544,
0.9850264788,
0.1056365073,
1.3711800575,
0.027118247,
0.2718009353,
-0.333088398,
0.3783591986,
0.0523297451,
0.2120843232,
-0.2175096571,
-1.0608429909,
-0.1489263177,
-0.1904179454,
-0.7030517459,
-0.0482507795,
-0.5726384521,
0.1012528539,
-0.1857448518,
-0.370785445,
-0.2157923877,
0.359809041,
-0.9569885731,
-0.1955725998,
0.0625241473,
0.5245421529,
-0.6395302415,
0.4720849693,
0.7951716781,
-0.3639868498,
-0.9867403507,
-0.1111406386,
0.2218062282,
-0.9137698412,
0.4193639457,
0.0115666846,
-0.2710653245,
-0.159534812,
-0.5948193073,
-0.9335277677,
1.6295884848,
0.0752633438,
-0.3738642931,
-0.1487390846,
0.3851175904,
0.8299043775,
-0.8612644076,
0.1612386256,
0.7015182972,
0.6442001462,
-0.0283343811,
-0.9279669523,
0.2879265547,
-0.1013839319,
0.0954575688,
-0.1624746174,
-0.8642224669,
0.4597978294,
-0.0792273656,
-0.1524920017,
0.1135047376,
0.6258546114,
0.2853610814,
0.5757324696,
0.6407248974,
-0.0020769595,
0.524930656,
-0.0447410829,
0.8093201518,
-0.4185258448,
-0.0434178524,
1.0273920298,
-0.430120647,
0.3931759298,
0.4345391393,
-0.0746546537,
0.3848392069,
0.2457425147,
0.2377953976,
0.2776836157,
0.0664561093,
-0.267868042,
-0.2214886844,
-0.4233952463,
0.3472871482,
0.8722084165,
0.5917388797,
-0.0590872392,
0.4615526795,
-0.108998172,
-0.2788292468,
0.0359732583,
-0.1746424735,
1.2494031191,
0.2278914601,
-0.9829412699,
0.0199079663,
-0.4631354809,
0.240001291,
-0.4303069711,
-0.0138019612,
-0.2139161229,
0.0712205619,
-0.1844613552,
-1.0870031118,
0.1759319454,
-0.5336378217,
0.0987752825,
-0.5619542599,
0.7138602138,
-0.3043830097,
-0.1633174717,
0.4723535478,
0.7345910072,
0.1647289693,
-0.0409826897,
-0.4637080729,
0.175270021,
-0.4303868711,
-0.3169134855,
0.4770430028,
0.5838143229,
-0.1046019271,
0.8067043424,
0.6242702603,
0.2325210571,
-0.4647808969,
0.0642157421,
0.6159482598,
-0.5607205629,
-0.4031949341,
-0.6656308174,
0.4518871605,
0.052066002,
-0.2166675925,
0.4474324286,
0.0062213517,
0.4243133366,
0.2034750134,
0.4551185071,
-0.0807682872,
-0.0656169578,
-0.1608447284,
0.7060830593,
-0.4233926833,
0.4494945407,
-0.0886016935,
-0.8485713601,
0.2263762057,
0.4952598214,
-0.2423351556,
0.0840903595,
0.3820714653,
0.9683285952,
0.3718944192,
-0.2447577566,
0.4571152627,
-0.0031122379,
0.5836042762,
0.1349931657,
1.1105577946,
0.2246622294,
0.1502472311,
-0.4454536736,
-0.3874050379,
-0.4837322235,
-0.6657912731,
-0.9106427431,
-0.8253400922,
-0.3298066854,
-0.0487838574,
-0.1997586787,
1.335950017,
0.7205385566,
-0.226274237,
-0.7596079707,
-0.4019909501,
0.2989378273,
-0.471468538,
-0.2672466636,
-0.015773749,
-0.3944078684,
-0.3674083054,
0.4128822684,
0.3970903158,
0.1268445104,
-0.939976275,
-0.4084672034,
-0.1425019056,
0.4463121295,
0.3621931076,
0.0911210552,
-0.7870589495,
-0.3102101684,
0.1181115955,
-0.6468006372,
-0.0925705582,
0.850343883,
-0.2209926397,
0.2722534537,
0.2789800763,
0.1493598074,
0.2211740017,
0.1725171059,
0.7246690989,
-0.8458455801,
-0.2331570983,
0.1291587204,
0.3125154972,
0.0731061772,
-0.9745422006,
0.8755478263,
-0.1228221878,
-1.0407385826,
-0.4500806034,
-0.0309647601,
-0.8615964651,
-0.2300243825,
0.9267203808,
0.1053510904,
-0.4683634043,
-0.1556608379,
-0.4398850203,
0.0420172103,
-0.5136349797,
1.102024436,
0.8203372359,
-0.7926592827,
-0.1166053638,
-0.2831549346,
0.6779148579,
0.2359813303,
-0.8247869611,
0.1379441023,
0.4505984187,
-0.0696370751,
0.7218259573,
1.1046010256,
0.5932572484,
0.3816705644,
-0.1406881511,
0.0930631608,
-0.0287331976,
-0.5707299113,
0.1061015204,
-0.0450655483,
0.3823512793,
-0.1389429122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12802v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12802v1 | Ultra-Fine Entity Typing with Prior Knowledge about Labels: A Simple Clustering Based Strategy | 2023-05-22T08:00:56 | 2023-05-22T08:00:56 | Na Li, Zied Bouraoui, Steven Schockaert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Ultra-fine entity typing (UFET) is the task of inferring the semantic types,
from a large set of fine-grained candidates, that apply to a given entity
mention. This task is especially challenging because we only have a small
number of training examples for many of the types, even with distant
supervision strategies. State-of-the-art models, therefore, have to rely on
prior knowledge about the type labels in some way. In this paper, we show that
the performance of existing methods can be improved using a simple technique:
we use pre-trained label embeddings to cluster the labels into semantic domains
and then treat these domains as additional types. We show that this strategy
consistently leads to improved results, as long as high-quality label
embeddings are used. We furthermore use the label clusters as part of a simple
post-processing technique, which results in further performance gains. Both
strategies treat the UFET model as a black box and can thus straightforwardly
be used to improve a wide range of existing models. | [
-0.5625194311,
-0.6107552052,
0.7745833993,
-0.3730499148,
-0.4655584991,
0.1314977705,
-0.1624609977,
-0.5776472092,
0.3484558761,
0.6389936805,
-0.0807271972,
-0.6727685928,
-0.4723826945,
-0.1334089935,
-0.4126478732,
1.1756341457,
0.0924099684,
-0.1178360805,
-0.3112872839,
-0.0204113834,
-0.0940670148,
-0.7310351133,
-0.5427046418,
-0.4027774632,
0.2752471566,
0.4939462841,
0.6174111366,
0.5695696473,
0.726387918,
0.1763285846,
-0.2999538183,
0.2467425764,
-0.5499722958,
-0.1633107066,
-0.1950717568,
-0.5491947532,
-0.1451790035,
-0.1309216022,
0.5757302642,
0.8498763442,
-0.124689199,
0.1680209339,
-0.0329393931,
0.4023531079,
-0.6827662587,
-0.0914282203,
-0.9194645286,
0.2229780555,
-0.3923071921,
-0.0985002443,
-0.5297815204,
0.0302338395,
0.3683863878,
-0.9050652385,
0.4284416735,
0.1638231128,
1.0143653154,
0.2197559774,
-0.4794582129,
0.194850862,
-1.1137961149,
0.4204391837,
-0.5578403473,
0.5066407323,
0.3442862034,
0.1365979612,
-0.2918505967,
-1.0420799255,
-0.3222385347,
-0.051724378,
-0.2931633294,
-0.0586452223,
-0.0542562827,
0.3773160577,
0.2327928096,
0.3588483334,
-0.1604734957,
0.3226418495,
0.0126095107,
-0.3129900396,
0.1657104194,
-0.1726329327,
-0.0133412248,
0.2156187892,
-0.5234637856,
-0.0033292749,
-0.9106427431,
-0.0006935087,
-0.2648499906,
0.0909258053,
0.5070423484,
0.7030745149,
-0.5980830789,
0.5809836388,
0.3980599344,
-0.0686790869,
0.0195034947,
-0.0576338097,
-0.2255004346,
0.0138003966,
0.4569224119,
0.1701991558,
0.1988488883,
-0.5110391378,
-0.3414718807,
0.2342870533,
0.2271791399,
-0.7717599273,
-0.5263829827,
-0.1569162607,
-0.5071763992,
-0.1218200773,
-0.0351543054,
-0.7499499321,
-0.2643167675,
-0.2432429641,
0.7612441182,
-0.3740366101,
-0.0853419751,
-0.0438865274,
-0.0265864767,
-0.128764376,
0.3250251412,
-0.946574986,
0.3303937018,
0.4822381139,
0.5121759176,
-0.2597619593,
-0.0301123261,
-0.426467061,
0.5498180389,
-0.0643951371,
1.3916226625,
-0.8178970218,
-0.5460163355,
-0.0987088755,
-0.3540368378,
-0.091453895,
-0.5707597136,
0.4788765311,
-0.8548752069,
-0.3354874551,
-0.0317048617,
-1.0513881445,
-0.168798238,
-0.2011226714,
-0.4736379087,
1.1954451799,
0.2145023197,
-0.7483378649,
0.6973060369,
-0.7629895806,
-0.4385042489,
0.2655446827,
-0.2835339904,
-0.3484420478,
0.4647974372,
0.2012321949,
0.8770442009,
-0.0624479838,
0.0019920412,
-0.5609492064,
-0.3766372204,
0.1325462759,
0.0443420671,
0.0726002678,
0.1233826205,
-0.4289081395,
-0.2642225623,
-1.0461028814,
0.0604904704,
-0.0175729617,
-0.1523434669,
-0.9046947956,
-0.1542720944,
-0.3015163541,
0.09171018,
0.0942467749,
-0.575199306,
0.2232540846,
-0.1469077468,
0.3439687192,
0.5505431294,
0.1439057738,
0.6271223426,
0.1795766354,
-0.0571106039,
0.2136342973,
0.1242435947,
0.1677384824,
-0.4621020555,
-0.857154429,
-0.3197689354,
0.816285789,
0.46274212,
-0.7379538417,
0.3783593476,
-0.1891299337,
-0.5864000916,
-0.4799118638,
0.1666793227,
0.4213681817,
0.591450274,
0.6059796214,
-0.4859230518,
-0.3048841059,
-0.8600694537,
-0.1072934121,
-0.0129257394,
0.0436363071,
0.0054195938,
0.6632823348,
-0.4233429134,
1.0701479912,
-0.8760940433,
-0.2112316936,
0.193389833,
0.3076985776,
-0.2387056649,
0.7215445638,
0.2788462937,
-0.8591897488,
-0.3019141555,
0.1501081139,
-0.5239315033,
0.4620319605,
0.1824732721,
-0.2968967259,
-0.0239450932,
0.6885226369,
-0.655857861,
0.5334043503,
0.0167229921,
-0.3964697123,
0.5490593314,
-0.2283764631,
0.0286559127,
-0.7830514312,
-0.3600218594,
0.1664687246,
-0.2854369283,
-0.6324266791,
0.1869348735,
0.0451608934,
0.0405994877,
-0.5363540649,
0.3656838238,
-0.4652876556,
-0.1593855172,
-0.2053069919,
-0.1789732724,
-0.0636311024,
0.4730387032,
0.3424159586,
0.6311418414,
0.5707705617,
-0.8051133752,
0.0635040179,
0.235796541,
-0.233504355,
0.8896276951,
-0.4810484648,
0.2088857442,
-0.1257588565,
0.2367243767,
-0.9786112905,
-0.0371615067,
-0.4413926303,
-0.2413746566,
0.5736904144,
-0.2554712296,
-0.6339647174,
-0.6512289643,
0.0674839243,
0.2343640178,
0.5198985338,
-0.6878837943,
0.428681463,
0.377330482,
0.121916391,
-0.1250102818,
-0.5787884593,
-0.3457309902,
-0.4022887647,
-0.3914270997,
0.6128040552,
0.1209642142,
0.1328399479,
0.303345412,
-0.4291292131,
-0.4840913713,
0.2305586338,
0.0269424021,
0.1106629446,
-0.4170793593,
0.2135688215,
0.324249804,
-0.2611254156,
-0.4678608179,
-0.7516760826,
0.3211060464,
0.0033242479,
-0.1395993382,
-0.6029788256,
0.3938034773,
0.1991673857,
-0.4277823865,
0.7093795538,
0.7533709407,
-0.6106624603,
-0.185870111,
-0.74591434,
-0.3945510983,
-0.4421779215,
0.145680815,
-0.5938529372,
-1.4527016878,
0.3408354521,
-0.6281580329,
-0.059435565,
0.6388309002,
0.1269537508,
-0.5040950775,
0.9486616254,
1.0974348783,
0.1300549954,
0.3582580388,
-0.3817546368,
0.1716595143,
-0.8218653202,
-0.133278355,
-0.6327247024,
0.0742687136,
-0.5548728704,
-0.3511301875,
0.2316364348,
0.5117613077,
-0.1573878229,
0.5319200754,
-0.5922187567,
0.5353198051,
0.8096436262,
0.195290029,
0.5381795764,
0.3146019876,
-0.5081999898,
0.073935926,
-0.586563766,
-0.5583734512,
1.1833270788,
0.1982715577,
0.5447944999,
-0.2653543651,
1.1607111692,
0.3540346622,
0.4152291417,
-0.4680825174,
0.3697057962,
-0.3884363472,
-0.6176633835,
-0.4672282338,
-0.3690954447,
-0.8248276711,
0.3469809592,
-0.5632588863,
-1.009616971,
0.3136704862,
0.400011152,
-0.8169612885,
0.3566400111,
-0.9893576503,
0.8889221549,
0.1607161909,
0.2264575809,
-0.009707408,
-0.5051430464,
0.0960560367,
-0.1722484231,
0.0308816098,
0.0257946774,
0.0832402334,
1.023463726,
-0.5860295892,
0.7127202749,
-0.1191892996,
0.1116988063,
0.4282301664,
-0.0267036017,
0.7504771948,
0.1080362797,
0.2859053016,
-0.012042895,
0.0884783342,
-0.5738483071,
-0.6819179058,
0.5931774974,
-0.7942227125,
-0.3242002726,
0.1486971974,
-0.1142248437,
-0.644998014,
0.4244241118,
0.6056063771,
0.5328721404,
-0.2942247391,
0.1678516716,
1.2368506193,
0.35261783,
0.3603520393,
0.5048438907,
0.1382241845,
-0.2057040483,
0.9651245475,
0.2915212512,
0.1563206911,
0.7236141562,
-0.0624754541,
-0.5096610188,
-0.8307367563,
-0.4187140167,
0.2195386589,
-0.5957349539,
-0.3849956095,
-0.9685713053,
0.1641289741,
-0.6040464044,
-0.2268864512,
-0.6398186684,
-0.6009274721,
-0.349922657,
-0.2988937199,
0.5640861392,
0.7768721581,
0.0626518503,
0.8865367174,
-0.8282677531,
0.3087222874,
0.6386892796,
0.6762002707,
-0.1287739277,
-0.3119285703,
-0.3695634305,
-0.0017456071,
-0.3077214658,
-0.7816160321,
-0.2470867187,
0.1439202726,
0.5994787216,
0.4866107404,
0.0004302467,
0.6484128237,
-0.5412012339,
0.5885547996,
0.0944672152,
-0.6893225908,
0.493052274,
-0.228044644,
-0.3018876314,
0.9790703058,
0.6242227554,
-0.1337058693,
-0.2039535195,
-1.0023419857,
-0.7846907973,
0.2598176301,
0.2435011715,
-0.3493757248,
0.1020609811,
0.5014644861,
0.0407111347,
0.3569585085,
-0.4436349571,
-0.560400784,
-0.0008312769,
-0.0111336214,
-0.3025824428,
-0.4170643687,
0.0053911842,
-0.4832316935,
0.6810888052,
0.001921723,
0.5464433432,
0.2734057605,
-0.4502171576,
0.2260831147,
0.1588673294,
0.2734400034,
0.317402333,
-0.197930485,
0.2710492611,
0.1053644642,
-0.4137363732,
0.3259151876,
0.460185647,
-0.6298663616,
0.037030343,
-0.0401554927,
0.8192444444,
0.4484181404,
-0.0586065911,
0.2762132287,
0.2268534899,
-0.0297471117,
0.0151805077,
-0.0477073714,
0.0897283405,
-0.0289473496,
0.2059789747,
0.0222489256,
0.4940599799,
-0.2209400535,
0.5411680937,
0.2000106573,
-0.4563193023,
-0.039973449,
0.5813439488,
0.2703307271,
0.1029078364,
0.1877429038,
-0.3940410912,
-0.3095866144,
0.3770776689,
0.8277419209,
0.597597599,
-0.2435024977,
0.5997151136,
-0.0844361037,
0.0841981098,
-0.4055022895,
-0.1960048229,
-0.0724395216,
-0.7724353671,
-0.4356154799,
-0.790964067,
-0.3684230149,
0.0153400432,
-0.5330630541,
-0.1500317752,
-0.4927195311,
-0.2743051648,
0.2800853252,
0.0593168698,
-0.8888063431,
0.54967767,
0.0319577456,
0.8260644078,
-0.7603283525,
0.6674973965,
1.1861637831,
-0.3960279822,
-0.8736325502,
-0.2002905309,
-0.2535134256,
-0.6067937613,
0.2024708539,
0.0996561125,
0.1789482981,
0.5392516255,
-0.3867094815,
-1.2455384731,
0.8262078762,
-0.035653498,
-0.5608090758,
-0.2604395151,
0.161658451,
0.6257988214,
-0.4243955612,
0.2363372147,
0.9169262052,
0.3693631291,
-0.01649311,
-0.7098113298,
0.011129762,
0.0035625573,
0.2864548564,
0.4356988668,
-0.5141578913,
0.4259990752,
-0.1296702921,
-0.1318181455,
-0.1181810051,
1.1829836369,
-0.0815379694,
0.2382276952,
0.540692389,
1.1097947359,
1.0227098465,
-0.0953453407,
0.900146246,
-0.0080007548,
0.5566532016,
1.0407401323,
-0.1845520884,
0.7934715152,
0.3037377,
-0.1686864346,
0.381963402,
0.7507295012,
-0.0197989978,
0.6321706772,
0.1771830022,
-0.2968789339,
-0.4833081961,
-0.2824456096,
-0.5028304458,
0.346884042,
0.4638239145,
-0.1192242727,
-0.2627176344,
0.2412912101,
0.2035076469,
0.1248165295,
-0.5922574997,
0.9252809882,
0.067968227,
-0.4259019494,
0.4024751782,
-0.0684828609,
1.0350515842,
-0.1909220517,
-0.0423835367,
-0.0483464152,
0.0632518381,
-0.1849939674,
-0.6194030046,
0.0073752683,
-0.201089099,
-0.2695682347,
0.1985932589,
0.9305371046,
-0.3208129704,
-0.4327825308,
0.2470307201,
0.3790290952,
0.198326245,
-0.4250454903,
-0.4163553417,
-0.5121618509,
-0.1498592794,
-0.1967396885,
0.4264560938,
0.6613723636,
-0.2609970272,
0.2784174085,
0.7085946202,
-0.0195021331,
0.2548142076,
-0.1037332416,
0.8435350657,
-0.6374791265,
-0.4734218121,
-0.3774293661,
0.3478811979,
-0.1498552114,
-0.3796159923,
0.3794697523,
0.4478721321,
1.1771174669,
-0.1249595508,
0.683098793,
0.1665075868,
0.6613035798,
-0.6062876582,
0.5546315908,
-0.4579799771,
-0.2227183431,
-0.6758403182,
-1.043872118,
-0.345113039,
0.4390940964,
-0.0867252871,
-0.1162904948,
0.8381256461,
0.5273956656,
-0.0743178204,
0.0988887176,
0.4654045999,
0.2053047717,
0.0876886249,
0.3998631239,
0.5992933512,
-0.1471614093,
0.5444672704,
-0.8490055799,
-0.4707881212,
-0.2397796065,
-0.6464595795,
-0.9082134366,
-0.5750853419,
-0.3755072653,
-0.1695303023,
0.0304397531,
0.6525712013,
0.9161917567,
-0.6913143992,
0.4351219237,
0.0880886987,
0.0087930728,
-0.1171322986,
-0.1661838889,
0.467299521,
-0.181230098,
-0.2669211924,
0.1457025558,
0.1094784141,
0.5018287897,
0.2912569642,
0.4233408868,
-0.1116996184,
-0.0957975313,
0.9959666133,
0.342423141,
-0.3267897069,
-0.4264113903,
-0.1952007562,
0.0028076866,
-0.0103592416,
0.9098844528,
-0.6551096439,
-0.0227029026,
0.1727280617,
0.857806921,
0.6769528389,
-0.0118277809,
0.2111308277,
-0.4228487611,
0.0321945883,
0.0365730748,
0.4440835118,
0.1912229359,
-0.7131751776,
0.5352063775,
0.567049861,
-0.5458400846,
-0.5930392742,
0.22254996,
-0.9186845422,
-0.1745730937,
0.9904522896,
-0.333414793,
-0.1548734158,
-0.2163984776,
-0.1585435718,
0.3191055655,
-0.6218467355,
0.6035619378,
0.4535650909,
-0.2413665801,
0.2737087607,
-0.2368153632,
0.6814911962,
0.4808705747,
-0.7543218732,
-0.2908321917,
0.3638895452,
0.3708102107,
0.4029242396,
0.8974626064,
-0.1661604792,
0.2988191247,
-0.1978421807,
0.2471019328,
0.1884153336,
-0.7280890346,
0.0522330776,
0.2105268687,
0.1508461833,
-0.0750163496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12798v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12798v2 | Word Embeddings Are Steers for Language Models | 2023-05-22T07:52:04 | 2024-06-06T06:07:27 | Chi Han, Jialiang Xu, Manling Li, Yi Fung, Chenkai Sun, Nan Jiang, Tarek Abdelzaher, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) automatically learn word embeddings during pre-training
on language corpora. Although word embeddings are usually interpreted as
feature vectors for individual words, their roles in language model generation
remain underexplored. In this work, we theoretically and empirically revisit
output word embeddings and find that their linear transformations are
equivalent to steering language model generation styles. We name such steers
LM-Steers and find them existing in LMs of all sizes. It requires learning
parameters equal to 0.2% of the original LMs' size for steering each style. On
tasks such as language model detoxification and sentiment control, LM-Steers
can achieve comparable or superior performance compared with state-of-the-art
controlled generation methods while maintaining a better balance with
generation quality. The learned LM-Steer serves as a lens in text styles: it
reveals that word embeddings are interpretable when associated with language
model generations and can highlight text spans that most indicate the style
differences. An LM-Steer is transferrable between different language models by
an explicit form calculation. One can also continuously steer LMs simply by
scaling the LM-Steer or compose multiple LM-Steers by adding their
transformations. Our codes are publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/Glaciohound/LM-Steer}. | [
-0.4417081475,
-0.5867512226,
0.4783070982,
0.0275817383,
-0.4480091035,
-0.1008524075,
-0.2347458452,
-0.0546164922,
0.3751845658,
0.4550800323,
-0.6107243299,
-0.5342041254,
-0.7445415854,
-0.087398991,
-0.4856542945,
1.0497626066,
-0.1369745582,
0.3090856671,
-0.0310129002,
-0.3150833249,
-0.5750656128,
-0.458263576,
-0.0744266957,
-0.4425504506,
0.6747856736,
-0.0431611054,
1.0289057493,
0.9472435117,
0.0513674058,
0.2153730989,
0.1476426423,
0.1110077873,
-0.6092060804,
0.2400351912,
-0.1622187346,
-0.2421561778,
-0.1871778667,
0.2656523883,
0.469235152,
0.747538507,
-0.2454414815,
-0.1909032613,
0.2102422267,
0.5213364959,
-0.6799749732,
0.194397673,
-0.8712199926,
0.1630034298,
-0.0721903592,
-0.3516134918,
-0.4995291829,
-0.5499241352,
0.1628609151,
-0.5245915651,
-0.1178860366,
0.3853946626,
0.8671781421,
0.1263013631,
-0.2799662054,
-0.8224227428,
-0.4574522078,
0.8868402243,
-0.7179511786,
0.6285362244,
0.0462450944,
0.0963983089,
0.1083793864,
-0.5278500915,
-0.3933520615,
0.0729723275,
-0.012093775,
0.0194241554,
-0.2753750086,
0.0301162247,
-0.1215786785,
0.1087637991,
-0.1227766201,
0.4201914966,
-0.3430162966,
-0.1668082625,
0.5413969755,
0.0319391526,
0.2944120467,
-0.1183803305,
-0.2627111673,
-0.3978459537,
-1.1701700687,
-0.1505273581,
0.3543162644,
0.3427631259,
-0.1612299681,
0.6901470423,
0.3195209503,
0.5152283907,
0.0051822192,
-0.2708158195,
0.3147180676,
-0.2246527076,
-0.224216491,
0.2460113466,
0.7807639241,
0.5186200142,
0.5669466853,
-0.2373748422,
-0.5568945408,
0.0083900569,
0.4761525095,
-0.633051157,
-0.1771816909,
-0.1405995488,
-0.4323418438,
-0.5540938377,
0.2815962732,
-0.3973807991,
-0.3682610095,
-0.2726017535,
0.645565927,
-0.6641892195,
-0.3098474145,
0.1787126958,
-0.4706707597,
0.7458016276,
0.2251674384,
-0.7432960868,
-0.0258386619,
0.9253516197,
0.6664261222,
-0.2854052782,
-0.0013490993,
-0.5573810935,
-0.001449291,
-0.7752532363,
0.2464477867,
-0.7166145444,
-0.7209095955,
0.7830318809,
0.002368059,
-0.0556828193,
-0.4315199554,
0.2882716954,
-0.639868319,
0.283387363,
-0.3224060535,
-0.8714497685,
-0.1321998686,
-0.0309522264,
-0.2420985401,
0.7762684822,
-0.2570430636,
-0.9000573158,
0.5574262142,
-0.3372124434,
-0.3933067024,
-0.0558528416,
-0.2474909276,
-0.3121387661,
0.3792790473,
0.0929289162,
0.8022788763,
0.0040306081,
0.1802994162,
-0.4049984217,
-0.1333259344,
0.3640993536,
-0.216342032,
0.3055119812,
0.1311096251,
-0.2902507484,
0.1013140082,
-0.5299687982,
0.0522312224,
0.2337189019,
-0.2346742451,
-0.7288600802,
0.2351631671,
-0.0801412016,
0.0728069469,
0.1257995963,
-0.6736822724,
0.1622842997,
-0.3731968701,
0.3382204771,
0.7359426618,
-0.0434266962,
0.7074479461,
-0.2286956906,
0.4905448258,
0.0753777698,
-0.3308681548,
-0.3295710087,
-0.3527666926,
-1.0256961584,
-0.1897176057,
0.2205601633,
0.2921013832,
-0.905395627,
0.598405242,
-0.3296689987,
-0.3905811906,
-0.8571628928,
0.1215972155,
0.4069948792,
-0.0284428913,
0.3246009946,
-0.0570593923,
-0.2382663339,
-1.0289547443,
-0.2944380939,
0.2041039616,
0.0305075701,
-0.013928907,
0.4032649696,
-0.1673861742,
0.9019854069,
-0.5423249602,
-0.0018610222,
-0.4739433825,
0.0572520234,
-0.1870904714,
0.2383942902,
0.6634085178,
-0.2869532108,
-0.1889917701,
-0.0339817591,
-0.7914603949,
-0.2957314849,
-0.0500200093,
-0.2170418203,
0.1693890095,
0.6995741725,
-0.1756919175,
0.3620793819,
0.8761742115,
-0.2359523624,
0.297072798,
-0.4165813327,
-0.5148927569,
-1.0118355751,
-0.4642234147,
0.0180709548,
-0.2989745438,
-0.5436992049,
0.0689046755,
0.2309622616,
0.1437259763,
-0.3365496099,
0.3423871398,
-0.6803690195,
-0.2557010651,
-0.4019338489,
0.5503089428,
0.0729866922,
0.2476049215,
-0.0166479032,
0.46589306,
0.4722538888,
-0.653577745,
0.025860494,
0.0403543748,
-0.2880909741,
0.4790320694,
-0.688231349,
0.2267437577,
-0.3465279341,
-0.0520147495,
-0.8442524672,
0.3900021315,
0.0157643072,
0.0124368872,
0.6323914528,
0.0821553916,
-0.364266932,
-0.0264540426,
-0.7191284895,
-0.3022812903,
0.7094991803,
-0.5515678525,
0.3181010783,
0.5212150812,
-0.1530027241,
-0.182038933,
-0.6536746621,
-0.3071242273,
-0.251229167,
-0.3526073694,
0.3687266111,
0.2999562919,
-0.3098873496,
0.1441496611,
0.2802051306,
0.5922105312,
-0.094507888,
0.4086417854,
0.3636390865,
-0.2971846759,
0.3909506798,
0.4851227701,
0.1667708158,
0.1480641514,
-0.2430770993,
0.7649554014,
0.057941556,
-0.429338038,
-0.1074266136,
0.228914097,
0.5133320689,
-0.4816330969,
0.9397699833,
0.6565032005,
-0.0727777928,
-0.5514627099,
-0.3492749333,
-0.197075665,
-0.493365109,
0.5383104086,
-0.4351303875,
-0.8155554533,
0.068298392,
-0.0872025788,
0.4462301135,
0.6159994006,
0.6255577207,
-0.1264913827,
1.0621443987,
0.8202489018,
-0.1023515835,
0.5133879185,
-0.2808130682,
0.1106364205,
-0.9047003984,
-0.2964478433,
-0.3362748921,
-0.4399213493,
-0.9143998027,
-0.6114400029,
0.2960953414,
0.2021045238,
-0.2838091254,
0.1739607155,
-0.4158522785,
-0.1894365251,
0.4411519468,
-0.2674065232,
0.0334653296,
0.1802392304,
-0.5299443603,
-0.3411714137,
-0.7761802077,
-0.573990345,
0.8905338645,
0.6259412169,
1.0751254559,
-0.0913671032,
0.9611173868,
0.2576148808,
0.3768545091,
-1.1508090496,
0.3635643721,
-0.2498265654,
-0.032056842,
-0.1940239817,
0.0075707091,
-0.8655595183,
0.4309734404,
-0.527728498,
-0.3979656696,
0.1093237102,
-0.0621798038,
0.1913811862,
0.4395270646,
-0.5019980073,
0.6161417365,
-0.3101681471,
-0.0745402724,
-0.377187103,
-0.1555226445,
-0.0751667172,
-0.0603828691,
0.3898752332,
-0.0869022757,
-0.2149584144,
0.9183892012,
-0.6606726646,
0.7652082443,
-0.2807160318,
-0.3894425035,
0.1697102189,
0.4934235215,
0.5529831052,
-0.4436973631,
0.1077224165,
0.0242563579,
-0.1439726651,
0.1184305921,
-0.5059092641,
0.8281117082,
-0.8914094567,
-0.6075031757,
-0.1949201375,
-0.4420880973,
-0.1728632599,
-0.0365150534,
0.1649031043,
0.7141470909,
-0.3254650235,
0.4930544198,
0.4057232738,
-0.4916448593,
0.65386796,
0.2608243227,
-0.775066793,
-0.1925651729,
0.875903964,
0.28238976,
0.3592024148,
0.3834691346,
0.2701563239,
-0.3734343648,
-0.5055997968,
-0.4962255955,
0.4513529837,
-0.7406591177,
-0.0302801039,
-0.6411713958,
-0.238372907,
-0.0495866835,
-0.3884704709,
-0.4591270983,
-0.4004459679,
-0.3138710558,
-0.3108948767,
0.499805063,
1.4751778841,
0.17605941,
0.3188250661,
-0.5789363384,
-0.1659246236,
0.2394542545,
0.0288342126,
0.0369488001,
-0.6640943885,
-0.1875051558,
0.0793561339,
-0.4813628495,
-1.00461936,
0.7063923478,
0.4441509247,
0.5340321064,
0.7280150056,
-0.1886401772,
0.4188715219,
-0.8249481916,
0.8267629147,
0.3761023283,
-0.890999794,
0.327313751,
-0.1617326587,
0.1529934406,
0.0863643214,
0.6369999051,
-0.7149110436,
-0.414535284,
-0.3526718616,
-0.747136116,
0.4059852064,
-0.1058350876,
0.4910398126,
-0.169506073,
0.1844314188,
0.3923644722,
0.3601086736,
-0.2053128183,
-0.3994513154,
-0.5798313022,
-0.2652922869,
-0.2387274653,
-0.343313992,
0.1326409578,
-0.0088433912,
0.554250896,
-0.0461489968,
0.2077787519,
-0.1082385927,
-0.2142135054,
0.282705456,
0.403391093,
0.3651767373,
0.4214791656,
-0.0230194777,
0.2500203848,
0.0037117924,
-0.1938990206,
-0.101589255,
-0.2494685352,
-0.3312664628,
0.2637297511,
0.3689888716,
1.1390019655,
0.5614771843,
-0.1638682336,
0.5646569729,
0.2985693812,
-0.1518146843,
-0.1433818638,
-0.015498816,
0.4693599045,
-0.0795883462,
0.2562100589,
-0.2848066092,
-0.1899253726,
-0.6886936426,
0.0089831967,
0.7311282754,
-0.6943606734,
-0.4954455495,
0.5771901608,
0.2697585225,
-0.2570106089,
0.4633877277,
-0.157753244,
-0.5251303911,
0.1012334451,
0.6923749447,
0.947229147,
0.0227677003,
0.3717378974,
0.0645762905,
0.1865856946,
0.0238251928,
0.1040662751,
0.1220809743,
-1.2438752651,
-0.0705619454,
-0.9259178042,
-0.2255578935,
-0.0268435813,
-0.8275322318,
0.2459210604,
-0.5113165975,
-0.1850471497,
0.005670133,
-0.544860661,
-0.8487211466,
-0.0969630107,
0.462233603,
0.8186128736,
-0.8284690976,
0.9390442371,
0.7731981874,
-0.1662229598,
-0.844571054,
-0.1188070476,
0.108130239,
-1.0212447643,
0.7958123684,
0.1841364652,
-0.3289321065,
-0.084674485,
-0.4600566328,
-0.5900914073,
1.0309232473,
0.0449422635,
-0.5468553901,
-0.1170054153,
0.1655739397,
0.4276767373,
-0.8441194296,
-0.0288383756,
0.4219340384,
0.1793084741,
-0.0998178869,
-0.7979900837,
0.0092712147,
0.079204388,
0.5203354955,
0.1258158386,
-0.1993652284,
0.7991107702,
-0.0452642143,
-0.2399045229,
-0.1164592579,
0.6409217119,
0.2759382427,
-0.2477731854,
0.474797368,
0.3740145564,
0.5092675686,
-0.298340857,
1.2579407692,
-0.5895972252,
0.2526389658,
0.6761176586,
-0.1689019352,
1.1663906574,
0.6295106411,
-0.1022118405,
0.6938854456,
0.1169139743,
0.2774704695,
0.6982544661,
0.2890081108,
0.2258725315,
-0.2289063931,
-0.1251940727,
-0.4089358747,
0.5947734118,
0.5185042024,
-0.7224386334,
-0.1034460664,
0.1259123683,
0.5572004318,
0.1326363683,
-0.4167761803,
0.7646516562,
0.3879729807,
-0.4069043696,
0.5817211866,
0.2825317979,
1.3579525948,
-0.8637428284,
0.0404749401,
-0.1200093254,
0.3565870225,
0.0547636561,
-0.9218534827,
0.1311199516,
-0.1867060214,
0.2101119012,
-0.6834421754,
0.7138780355,
-0.6153364182,
-0.5417240262,
0.5853800774,
0.7573191524,
-0.0465928614,
0.1080708131,
-0.5017755628,
0.3376341164,
0.0667904764,
-0.4847017229,
0.3799941838,
0.487957418,
0.0748979822,
0.5705418587,
0.3411690593,
0.4191904962,
0.4319746196,
0.2017242163,
0.7891547084,
-0.4676586986,
-0.3930724263,
-0.7844587564,
0.2492711991,
0.1241874471,
-0.2412841171,
0.7700845003,
0.2599763572,
0.8527691364,
-0.3165020347,
0.7402222157,
0.079226248,
0.242594704,
-0.6688659191,
0.9392039776,
-0.6366028786,
-0.08750128,
-0.2565280199,
-0.8832002282,
0.10938669,
0.631313026,
-0.3253239095,
0.0074805878,
0.4693702757,
0.6982074976,
0.1204821542,
-0.0409642644,
0.5888447165,
0.2204885483,
0.285114646,
-0.0027444246,
0.5877273679,
-0.2386906892,
0.2039072067,
-0.3669883311,
0.1271113604,
-0.1226891428,
-0.8853185177,
-0.8061597943,
-0.6038765907,
-0.302466929,
-0.1519203782,
0.146554783,
0.9889988899,
0.5850703716,
-0.7440031171,
-0.2160086036,
0.2808278799,
-0.0938854814,
0.1010345146,
-0.2689366043,
0.3834125996,
-0.3638053834,
-0.7055094838,
0.3785206974,
0.2550860047,
-0.0602039807,
-0.7341086268,
-0.334154278,
-0.0565562136,
0.1143753082,
0.9326007366,
-0.1371633708,
-0.7855678797,
-0.6927401423,
0.0164995715,
-0.2452999949,
-0.0545211323,
0.8045661449,
-0.7305487394,
0.4601529241,
0.5081954598,
0.5787633657,
0.3758265972,
-0.1702234596,
0.826644659,
-0.9207387567,
0.2542011142,
-0.1643282324,
0.6741997004,
0.5786470175,
0.1495964676,
0.0582083166,
0.1196075156,
-0.1261566728,
-0.4612005949,
0.1988142729,
-0.6788849831,
-0.1456403583,
1.3958594799,
-0.0611436889,
-0.0938169956,
0.2831739783,
-0.1331153363,
0.25473243,
-0.3233121634,
0.0694049671,
0.522567451,
0.2422017604,
-0.1696748137,
-0.5241632462,
0.4173638225,
0.2292407155,
-0.1821884215,
-0.1097259298,
0.2544671893,
0.4509516656,
0.2132832408,
0.0714105964,
-0.3759031594,
-0.2881619036,
-0.0857413039,
0.3466394842,
-0.2247737795,
-0.0988024026,
-0.3414828777,
0.115982607,
0.2048279941,
-0.4488217235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12793v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12793v2 | Zero-Shot End-to-End Spoken Language Understanding via Cross-Modal Selective Self-Training | 2023-05-22T07:42:52 | 2024-02-03T03:24:46 | Jianfeng He, Julian Salazar, Kaisheng Yao, Haoqi Li, Jinglun Cai | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD | End-to-end (E2E) spoken language understanding (SLU) is constrained by the
cost of collecting speech-semantics pairs, especially when label domains
change. Hence, we explore \textit{zero-shot} E2E SLU, which learns E2E SLU
without speech-semantics pairs, instead using only speech-text and
text-semantics pairs. Previous work achieved zero-shot by pseudolabeling all
speech-text transcripts with a natural language understanding (NLU) model
learned on text-semantics corpora. However, this method requires the domains of
speech-text and text-semantics to match, which often mismatch due to separate
collections. Furthermore, using the entire collected speech-text corpus from
any domains leads to \textit{imbalance} and \textit{noise} issues. To address
these, we propose \textit{cross-modal selective self-training} (CMSST). CMSST
tackles imbalance by clustering in a joint space of the three modalities
(speech, text, and semantics) and handles label noise with a selection network.
We also introduce two benchmarks for zero-shot E2E SLU, covering matched and
found speech (mismatched) settings. Experiments show that CMSST improves
performance in both two settings, with significantly reduced sample sizes and
training time. Our code and data are released in
https://github.com/amazon-science/zero-shot-E2E-slu. | [
-0.2048652917,
-0.8218010068,
0.5174925923,
-0.1354466826,
-0.5045651197,
0.1747004688,
-0.2856889367,
-0.6009386778,
0.268761009,
0.3009029627,
-0.7072221041,
-0.4131354094,
-0.575802207,
-0.0319316387,
-0.2786307633,
1.0166697502,
0.1881077588,
0.0453730039,
-0.1173578277,
-0.2682960629,
-0.5284466147,
-0.2340831459,
-0.6683216691,
-0.3675368726,
0.5134375691,
0.480009079,
0.401758492,
0.4659827054,
-0.2364380807,
0.1274904311,
0.1060378477,
-0.2254561484,
-0.7078698277,
0.2659039497,
-0.3033367693,
-0.4865112305,
-0.1445139199,
0.0567407049,
0.5880632401,
0.4715315998,
0.0056096208,
0.2223267704,
-0.2553074658,
0.3294990957,
-0.814342618,
-0.0660903156,
-0.9600317478,
0.1008845121,
-0.1115519255,
-0.3025541008,
-0.4210742414,
0.7576160431,
0.0860180408,
-0.8319726586,
0.0977983996,
-0.0674315989,
0.861839056,
0.527197659,
-0.3730452657,
-0.0545034632,
-0.7451039553,
0.9140396714,
-0.4734090865,
0.665006578,
0.6543959379,
0.2618044317,
0.290581435,
-0.2505765259,
-0.4970027804,
-0.0678310469,
0.0420690142,
0.6073659062,
-0.4223075807,
0.022552181,
0.0623341948,
0.0895694047,
-1.0219974518,
0.4088755846,
-0.3145324588,
-0.2598470151,
0.2618102431,
-0.2927212715,
0.2979375422,
0.010931287,
-0.354380548,
0.1771392822,
-0.4941306114,
-0.1006508097,
0.1176987514,
0.0973004103,
-0.1883769035,
0.3772827983,
-0.2167497426,
0.9785243869,
0.180594489,
-0.0768817961,
0.3615906835,
-0.4908797443,
-0.5597034097,
0.1862584651,
0.5381042957,
0.068854332,
0.1209066734,
-0.5584730506,
-0.1307358146,
0.1387256831,
0.0451867692,
-0.6737135053,
0.1089212,
0.1939949691,
-0.2337912619,
-0.1461061686,
-0.4079992473,
-0.2300583869,
0.2750909328,
-0.5343264341,
0.7331930995,
-0.3679735065,
-0.4156340659,
0.0103248712,
-0.2030328661,
0.5699595213,
0.1207091436,
-0.7492573857,
0.2255195826,
0.4312203228,
0.9811822176,
-0.1908659637,
-0.3154904842,
-0.5581021309,
0.3318263292,
-0.1120907515,
0.841324687,
-0.4799982607,
-0.3513029516,
-0.4039191008,
-0.2244998068,
-0.3106559515,
-0.3750752211,
0.3693033457,
-0.3886050284,
0.4352649152,
0.0633283556,
-0.5207772255,
-0.0114816064,
0.2223212719,
-0.1503992975,
0.8536608219,
0.1565538943,
-0.3671205938,
0.3297897875,
-0.3878237605,
-0.5349680185,
0.0818635374,
-0.4685285091,
-0.5477871895,
0.1469655484,
0.1210774109,
0.2303849906,
-0.1758556068,
0.1368351728,
-0.0909153447,
-0.3879439533,
0.0168035217,
-0.550976336,
0.7227496505,
0.2720416486,
-0.6107593179,
-0.0727663264,
-0.8452571034,
0.034910813,
0.2232428044,
0.1315065175,
-0.3927898407,
-0.2553617954,
0.1232248098,
0.4455317557,
0.0547378473,
-0.6793580055,
-0.2914974988,
-0.3271469474,
0.483571887,
0.4980405569,
-0.0828248635,
0.6182034016,
-0.3226445615,
0.5332224965,
0.1607200503,
0.1440931857,
-0.4428361952,
-0.3499753475,
-0.7549277544,
-0.3797124922,
0.1457071304,
0.6223464608,
-0.6506385803,
0.3803862631,
0.0442430153,
-0.3358491659,
-0.5632851124,
-0.0088717462,
0.6294906139,
0.6627732515,
0.5964989066,
-0.2065311819,
-0.3925642967,
-0.9708711505,
-0.2476230115,
-0.0849514231,
-0.0552728288,
0.3524127007,
0.2243522257,
-0.1288890541,
1.1011896133,
-0.1273358315,
-0.4003248513,
-0.2190729231,
0.3217431605,
-0.0952288583,
0.1773346812,
0.5727942586,
-0.4622886181,
-0.607164979,
0.0208116304,
-0.6006171703,
-0.5534691215,
-0.5339177847,
-0.1250074953,
0.2963822186,
0.473133415,
-0.3276400566,
0.3828035295,
0.6871125102,
-0.373386234,
0.3894324601,
0.0048807678,
-0.1517889947,
-1.0444471836,
-0.0296750609,
0.0579971522,
-0.4605623186,
-0.8742021918,
-0.2383252382,
-0.0458405428,
-0.1534091681,
-0.4859013855,
0.4369091094,
-0.7445929646,
-0.2898432612,
-0.5002251863,
0.5559470654,
0.0752001181,
0.5481461287,
0.2445885092,
0.8102797866,
0.7959997654,
-0.372992456,
-0.1778848916,
0.0062511256,
0.1629588008,
0.8590601683,
-0.6005038619,
0.2955628932,
-0.2621732056,
0.2826955616,
-0.8192333579,
0.2891726196,
0.273371309,
-0.7253274322,
0.5694960356,
-0.1839145571,
0.1062717885,
0.1447630227,
-0.0668020546,
0.5449525714,
0.3057911098,
-0.2946608067,
0.3420560062,
0.4005794227,
0.0941131115,
-0.6711705923,
-0.805927515,
0.3140553236,
0.2330227643,
-0.2361564934,
0.4176406264,
-0.2240505815,
0.0053969249,
0.0236357059,
-0.3567701578,
-0.1085996479,
-0.1247159541,
0.1131554544,
0.0734695196,
-0.2178339809,
0.228470996,
0.1151110828,
-0.3956110179,
-0.1389049143,
-0.7957751155,
0.422129482,
0.0020964528,
-0.4331062734,
-0.6141991019,
0.4926709533,
0.5060275197,
-0.1812270731,
0.5515989065,
0.7562164068,
-0.2191876769,
-0.3033295274,
-0.4556824267,
-0.2082222998,
-0.334087342,
0.4357012808,
-0.4177758098,
-1.0985649824,
0.2719419599,
0.2778290808,
0.1111979932,
0.3620645106,
0.6120665073,
-0.1308158785,
0.5928548574,
0.446752429,
-0.1167935804,
0.6198530793,
-0.2455779761,
0.4057024121,
-0.6651197672,
-0.1902833283,
-0.3287864923,
-0.3940114081,
-0.2188805193,
-0.6239852309,
0.2448224872,
0.0752086863,
-0.1118872017,
0.5552260876,
-0.4990656078,
0.5987350345,
0.5386254787,
0.0650906563,
0.2981553376,
0.1601919532,
0.0334747322,
-0.057149414,
-0.6734514832,
0.0569924526,
0.8492182493,
0.1986016035,
0.4945079088,
-0.0005291771,
0.7914251685,
0.1857221127,
-0.0897985399,
-0.9875435233,
0.339293927,
0.0025327334,
-0.4413005114,
-0.5906698704,
-0.4887720644,
-0.8685439229,
0.5303379297,
-0.0388516188,
-0.5812194347,
0.2074640542,
0.0856752098,
-0.1806758642,
0.1703859568,
-0.6949742436,
0.7019516826,
-0.4392836988,
-0.3124089837,
-0.444491446,
-0.7828183174,
0.1642326713,
-0.1762842536,
0.2998568416,
-0.1956254393,
-0.0193554647,
0.6759169698,
-0.2484877557,
0.9621880054,
-0.2070913762,
-0.0378901921,
0.3928519785,
0.2677538693,
0.1984469444,
-0.0786265209,
0.0693537369,
0.4117901027,
0.0169254541,
-0.7106413841,
-0.5987550616,
0.655816555,
-1.0235612392,
-0.3218362927,
-0.5051760077,
-0.4305317998,
-0.1607035846,
0.120743297,
0.4268011451,
0.5098276734,
-0.1607022434,
0.0428480543,
0.6105629206,
-0.0633061454,
0.6265616417,
1.0104577541,
0.1229105145,
-0.4034104645,
1.047654748,
0.2492295653,
0.7488175631,
0.5518636107,
0.1076990515,
-0.3759884834,
-0.4087012112,
-0.6881798506,
0.3048537076,
-0.4046172202,
-0.3288642466,
-0.7448428273,
-0.2675145268,
-0.3952965438,
-0.2975788116,
-0.4456983805,
-0.5393918157,
-0.4210856855,
-0.1839274317,
0.2298232764,
0.4197849929,
-0.4495938122,
0.5265759826,
-0.4865201712,
0.411116153,
0.2520378232,
0.2326945066,
-0.2334163189,
-1.0172489882,
-0.3702248037,
0.110437125,
-0.1669804752,
-0.9840047359,
0.2284487188,
0.5441286564,
0.6761888266,
0.3821141124,
-0.0329368822,
0.7031511664,
-0.3596180677,
0.6997032166,
0.5929512382,
-1.1544630527,
0.6610201001,
-0.3161111772,
0.6184901595,
0.6569087505,
0.0445271581,
-0.8477467299,
-0.4518294036,
-0.5681790709,
-0.720561564,
0.8848082423,
0.4647535384,
-0.0356493182,
-0.0424792431,
0.2436397076,
0.0837669,
-0.1054963768,
-1.0106031895,
-0.462500751,
-0.3633099496,
-0.0236065909,
-0.0079890341,
-0.1276321411,
0.0165414903,
-0.2597959042,
0.800884366,
-0.1912195832,
0.3376819193,
0.3728122711,
-0.6161667705,
-0.335935235,
0.416423291,
0.768971622,
0.554970026,
0.0337474868,
0.2007017136,
0.2091784924,
-0.3244619966,
0.1340081096,
-0.1198307723,
-0.4232504666,
0.1869659126,
0.1759465635,
1.0264693499,
0.4659479856,
-0.5144944787,
0.7150354981,
0.1634391993,
-0.4567470253,
-0.1281928271,
-0.3229893446,
-0.1308769435,
-0.0419056527,
0.1894301027,
0.0111810248,
0.0659760237,
-0.4696342051,
0.5385754108,
0.4794824421,
-0.6655297875,
-0.3925888836,
0.5820089579,
0.1834585667,
-0.3059337437,
0.3258192539,
-0.4191209674,
-0.3471188545,
0.4466506541,
1.0342898369,
1.0287015438,
-0.2066310495,
0.571377635,
0.1694536656,
0.3789363503,
0.4298357964,
0.0607140101,
-0.5570321083,
-0.6855255961,
-0.6918605566,
-0.5855858326,
-0.4852431715,
0.1780213863,
-0.5652039647,
0.2802755237,
-0.3123524785,
0.1170187071,
-0.2218681723,
-0.2811101377,
-0.4217430949,
0.2122192681,
0.4748788774,
0.551147759,
-0.9433681965,
0.9084618688,
0.4398053288,
-0.3496321738,
-0.4974976182,
-0.1202227101,
0.1656755805,
-0.9951864481,
0.2721179426,
0.0983276144,
-0.469366312,
0.0888545662,
-0.3560141921,
-0.869761467,
1.0507514477,
0.2636805773,
-0.9140363932,
0.2819884717,
0.1995841265,
0.3737662733,
-0.2398158908,
0.6692447662,
0.6136385202,
0.2978778481,
0.3211069107,
-1.023698926,
-0.2387335002,
-0.0555858612,
-0.3305095434,
0.1981495917,
-0.7488387823,
0.5401440859,
-0.1096378565,
-0.2116755694,
-0.4477099478,
0.6291530728,
0.0233445838,
0.7251875997,
0.6383143663,
0.8310648203,
0.5280766487,
0.228577435,
0.2977907062,
-0.2684454322,
0.4357912838,
1.4576634169,
-0.2989183664,
0.7724972367,
0.4257239103,
0.0410312973,
0.199659586,
0.5991731882,
0.1624984443,
0.5782302022,
-0.033952713,
-0.4706441164,
-0.5102273226,
-0.1831497401,
-0.2731787264,
0.685588479,
0.3608826697,
-0.0955490842,
-0.6202757359,
0.1953671873,
-0.0263627153,
0.0287942383,
-0.1159744486,
0.8563122153,
0.2402802408,
-0.3338286579,
0.7527195811,
-0.1199879423,
0.7332100272,
-0.6571359038,
0.2758652568,
0.0047372091,
-0.2261200696,
-0.162069574,
-0.6744478345,
0.4292670786,
-0.0976937637,
-0.2371058017,
-0.4362279177,
0.7205582261,
-0.7185012698,
-0.2195832133,
0.7282274961,
0.7144051194,
0.3638707101,
-0.1771831214,
-0.8275111318,
-0.1149540097,
0.0623332039,
-0.081108287,
0.5175226927,
0.2926914394,
0.1262013465,
0.2583926022,
0.6666214466,
-0.024871381,
0.1260272861,
0.4609794021,
0.6957630515,
-0.4157729745,
-0.4688133001,
-0.7594878078,
0.106486097,
-0.0448740236,
-0.4068396688,
0.3955442011,
0.7702242136,
1.1075814962,
0.1673605591,
0.8688920736,
-0.0843214989,
0.4447386265,
-0.3611944914,
0.5494460464,
-0.6574421525,
-0.1489048302,
0.104706265,
-0.7106167674,
-0.4298426211,
0.6298894286,
-0.1524649262,
-0.1924759448,
0.6810239553,
0.842913568,
-0.0654050186,
-0.0341567807,
1.0179907084,
0.2644836009,
0.0904569253,
0.6120656729,
0.4759656787,
-0.4488173127,
0.6547843218,
-0.1860130876,
-0.4460817575,
-0.0782460421,
-0.5240806341,
-0.9317681789,
-0.5599328279,
-0.3598922491,
-0.1639914215,
0.3330569565,
0.8255415559,
0.8814128637,
-0.7738771439,
-0.2040424198,
-0.1413720101,
-0.0294192564,
-0.0924322531,
-0.1988530308,
0.0341873206,
-0.5487620234,
-0.6441110373,
0.7916113734,
0.7467237711,
-0.0136505896,
-0.1228839234,
-0.1440027505,
-0.2153372914,
0.1062587053,
0.8508246541,
0.5893008709,
-0.7479940057,
-0.2164949477,
0.0805605948,
0.0614456423,
0.1631295532,
0.9073887467,
-0.8718056083,
0.5997319818,
0.3692997694,
0.7109307647,
0.7964597344,
-0.28518188,
0.4291635156,
-0.7505544424,
0.2746213377,
0.1558016688,
0.2363239974,
0.0684427246,
-0.4152345359,
0.269054383,
0.5289856791,
-0.6056454182,
-0.4648496509,
0.3827014863,
-1.3053416014,
-0.4074964821,
1.1840001345,
0.1273690313,
-0.1197633147,
-0.3807158172,
-0.1640885025,
0.5419971347,
-0.4564456046,
0.3984066248,
0.327201426,
-0.2787736952,
-0.4801359773,
-0.5763100386,
0.0584234782,
0.9196605682,
-0.6334611177,
-0.0793316439,
0.3980906606,
0.3214370012,
-0.1730159521,
0.7894432545,
0.0792407691,
0.2092973143,
-0.1927366704,
-0.0309436284,
-0.1294337064,
-0.4144749343,
-0.4838019311,
-0.3136847019,
-0.259744525,
-0.4812784493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12792v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12792v1 | Semantic Structure Enhanced Event Causality Identification | 2023-05-22T07:42:35 | 2023-05-22T07:42:35 | Zhilei Hu, Zixuan Li, Xiaolong Jin, Long Bai, Saiping Guan, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Event Causality Identification (ECI) aims to identify causal relations
between events in unstructured texts. This is a very challenging task, because
causal relations are usually expressed by implicit associations between events.
Existing methods usually capture such associations by directly modeling the
texts with pre-trained language models, which underestimate two kinds of
semantic structures vital to the ECI task, namely, event-centric structure and
event-associated structure. The former includes important semantic elements
related to the events to describe them more precisely, while the latter
contains semantic paths between two events to provide possible supports for
ECI. In this paper, we study the implicit associations between events by
modeling the above explicit semantic structures, and propose a Semantic
Structure Integration model (SemSIn). It utilizes a GNN-based event aggregator
to integrate the event-centric structure information, and employs an LSTM-based
path aggregator to capture the event-associated structure information between
two events. Experimental results on three widely used datasets show that SemSIn
achieves significant improvements over baseline methods. | [
0.0055383448,
-0.9179385304,
1.0157196522,
-0.0219118763,
-0.2712861598,
-0.5343040824,
0.1130706593,
-0.8289761543,
0.477324456,
0.1880119145,
-0.670088768,
-0.471634388,
-0.5493540168,
-0.0642770901,
-0.6581076384,
0.8924638033,
-0.2310451865,
-0.1593707949,
-0.0564430654,
0.1113999113,
-0.1221920103,
-0.5167841911,
-0.6068980694,
-0.2555284202,
0.7806165814,
-0.0441471748,
0.301165998,
0.5513011813,
0.4311401248,
0.3615373075,
-0.3765717149,
0.0144252181,
-0.1930203736,
-0.1752799451,
-0.1613709629,
-0.1718005389,
-0.6593260169,
-0.0632655025,
0.6251229048,
0.9654310346,
0.1664751023,
0.1535992771,
0.2484360039,
0.2600372732,
-0.5859819651,
0.1827196181,
-0.4443150759,
-0.0555037931,
-0.2483827025,
-0.5260522366,
-0.3304507732,
-0.0419589505,
0.018288197,
-0.7016553879,
0.2070584297,
-0.3950088024,
0.7669032812,
0.0645498261,
-0.8384518027,
-0.4668132067,
-0.5303202271,
0.5993844867,
-0.6330762506,
0.1585799456,
0.0397597663,
-0.0139658144,
-0.4404606223,
-0.6340051293,
-0.3374176621,
0.0438507162,
-0.4377761185,
0.2869314849,
0.0813519284,
0.0985288695,
0.1825350076,
-0.1917788833,
-0.4403266609,
0.1459055245,
-0.4839769602,
-0.0644257814,
0.6116831899,
0.3343048096,
0.7252983451,
-0.5762353539,
-0.597099483,
0.3072437346,
-0.697670877,
-0.0638982877,
0.6092720628,
0.4819586277,
-0.089601703,
0.6814194322,
-0.3618128002,
0.4196103513,
-0.0349812023,
0.1345484257,
0.2111088634,
-0.657284081,
-0.222260341,
0.5576934814,
0.488273561,
0.2413250059,
0.1008797735,
-0.3115029633,
0.0184632707,
0.4185814857,
-0.0834492519,
-0.9697893858,
0.1679967791,
0.6348087788,
-0.5412171483,
-0.1557760239,
0.2135853767,
-0.4043224752,
-0.2881047428,
-0.5099331737,
0.4426763952,
-0.281003356,
-0.2581523955,
0.0060854997,
-0.421118319,
0.7476585507,
0.5430610776,
-0.4929433763,
0.2134643346,
1.0088956356,
0.882086277,
-0.1588776708,
-0.2123373002,
-0.6365589499,
0.7244745493,
-0.0752280354,
0.776833415,
-0.4982190728,
-0.0563087426,
0.104116872,
0.2688967586,
-0.158326596,
0.2322395146,
0.735532701,
-0.6768105626,
0.0666957423,
0.0576514974,
-0.8601231575,
-0.2254666239,
0.1502867341,
-0.5899547935,
0.9322977066,
-0.4523696303,
-0.9279946685,
0.3976484239,
-0.3247472942,
-0.5606666803,
0.0869216099,
-0.4098857939,
-0.3468457162,
0.3662525713,
-0.0023360571,
0.6879225373,
0.079600133,
0.8118411303,
-0.4905309081,
-0.314168483,
-0.0639742836,
-0.1298265457,
0.6263417006,
-0.0634057894,
-0.0786708593,
0.3620178699,
-1.1783387661,
-0.1505433172,
-0.0044421097,
-0.0527430549,
-0.8682683706,
0.2629694343,
0.2254424095,
0.4076980352,
0.3493347168,
-0.6386144757,
0.0287078284,
-0.5626292825,
0.0389025584,
0.7943843603,
0.3251190186,
0.6532976627,
0.214303568,
-0.1999623775,
0.4199129939,
0.2253780067,
-0.2115765214,
-0.4270890951,
-0.5039383769,
0.0457057729,
-0.1998135448,
0.5300423503,
-0.3566710353,
0.5379252434,
-0.3173030615,
-0.2351174206,
0.0701829195,
-0.1175016761,
0.0775063038,
0.5084732175,
0.2881133258,
-0.0500872433,
-0.8246460557,
-0.7454897165,
-0.4998793006,
-0.252876997,
-0.2522236407,
0.2074794024,
0.6531855464,
-0.3081629574,
0.6509896517,
-0.1916196346,
-0.3053631783,
-0.2104336917,
0.3209929168,
0.3249039054,
0.496540904,
0.2979360819,
-0.6894419789,
-0.182200253,
0.1634185463,
-0.5767912269,
-0.1922134459,
-0.2819765806,
-0.3455189764,
-0.100960575,
0.5223645568,
-0.2671433091,
0.7907384038,
0.1960632354,
-1.0256229639,
0.0938122571,
-0.2553199828,
0.1860806942,
-1.3926659822,
0.0493106507,
0.0457445234,
0.0147048486,
-0.9666467309,
-0.5196958184,
0.2857795954,
0.1036253721,
-0.6103679538,
0.5457404852,
-0.4752227068,
-0.1822544038,
-0.2354003042,
0.507072866,
-0.0279976781,
0.7364905477,
0.2724065483,
0.0185931008,
0.3024858236,
-0.8614122272,
-0.0611904152,
0.4059339762,
-0.201014623,
0.4209422469,
-0.916115582,
-0.1042626426,
-0.4670532942,
0.1032034382,
-0.9239375591,
-0.3166636825,
0.2525858879,
-0.3242623508,
0.1499773115,
-0.2950332165,
-0.2735243738,
0.3137820065,
-0.3189118803,
0.499001056,
-0.0696654618,
-0.6031039357,
1.3782157898,
0.3540702164,
0.0276969112,
-0.3846657574,
-0.5621164441,
0.033352524,
-0.1835575402,
-0.8013929129,
0.5045531392,
0.1806897372,
-0.0528813526,
0.2135016918,
-0.1369183213,
-0.12761724,
0.3302512467,
0.6648741364,
0.5184144378,
-0.2691732049,
0.137995258,
0.1949629784,
-0.3924007118,
0.0615029112,
-0.0965105593,
0.0294409301,
0.0774906948,
-0.4942158461,
-0.8431369066,
0.8129081726,
0.4798662066,
-0.0544858091,
0.9887536168,
0.4591755569,
-0.5555207133,
0.2109270245,
-0.4873722196,
-0.0481475517,
-0.2950626612,
0.6945644021,
-0.4713242948,
-0.7040713429,
0.8192896843,
-0.2998374104,
-0.1396047622,
0.6778619885,
0.2118579149,
0.0013537916,
1.1784046888,
0.5675048232,
-0.1216791123,
0.7227056026,
0.1408542991,
-0.102163814,
-0.9362372756,
-0.3360770047,
-0.6864145398,
-0.1674393713,
-0.4769977927,
-0.181469664,
0.1844226867,
0.252946645,
-0.3927598596,
0.3336721659,
-0.026451977,
0.2768799961,
0.1722719371,
0.12349087,
0.3610146046,
-0.2606045306,
0.0579564869,
0.2984217107,
-0.6733059287,
-0.4267816842,
0.7062538266,
0.3620806336,
0.658141017,
0.3244727552,
0.6494883895,
-0.0371848308,
0.3456603885,
-0.4561012089,
0.4965203106,
0.1383001208,
-0.3608053923,
-0.3366487026,
-0.4045873284,
-0.8123663068,
0.1143893078,
-0.1289672107,
-0.9653534889,
0.6468272805,
-0.1874942631,
-0.0797558278,
-0.1136120036,
-0.7537167668,
0.7423089743,
-0.2110402137,
-0.4413351715,
-0.2201857567,
-0.5805240273,
0.0985934213,
0.1748816669,
0.1730923951,
-0.2602581084,
-0.1944963187,
0.8745248914,
-0.4421809316,
1.1774095297,
-0.0443685912,
0.1255778521,
0.2977235913,
-0.1603134274,
1.2388068438,
-0.0029414399,
0.0457472727,
0.2895263433,
-0.0260304641,
-0.3751502335,
-0.7951027155,
0.6944116354,
-0.7802995443,
-0.3155236244,
-0.1235747337,
0.0413559452,
0.0090099797,
0.0787254274,
-0.0846539959,
0.8190012574,
-0.2718624473,
-0.0616266057,
0.3265824914,
0.0070258458,
0.5919414759,
0.709651053,
0.2087643594,
-0.2888441086,
0.304474026,
-0.0447591133,
-0.0788234323,
0.4423976243,
0.2371713072,
-0.2451248467,
-0.1012060866,
-0.2158521116,
0.3203763962,
-0.7777990103,
-0.1267146468,
-1.0112221241,
-0.2977543175,
-0.3442542851,
-0.3626315892,
-0.3025119901,
-0.3262597919,
-0.3029967248,
-0.4685869813,
0.247085467,
0.532343626,
0.1391234845,
0.0982062668,
-0.6209618449,
0.1800031215,
0.0245736465,
0.301610589,
0.0988867283,
-0.3367087245,
-0.1015869007,
-0.4763399661,
0.4233830869,
-1.2759848833,
0.2135156542,
0.219977811,
0.635607481,
0.5611251593,
-0.0569819547,
0.85436064,
-0.7865024209,
0.5407969952,
0.3392599523,
-0.8788294196,
0.9700853229,
-0.0879550576,
0.0743747875,
0.232133463,
0.4643818438,
-0.5348100066,
-0.5389370322,
-0.5348153114,
-1.1476341486,
0.76519835,
0.38492167,
-0.0296074804,
-0.1935108155,
0.5502894521,
-0.2668276429,
-0.2367918491,
-0.8591371775,
-0.1186084971,
0.2315645963,
-0.4626307487,
0.1352225244,
-0.7575836778,
-0.0633543655,
-0.0555988811,
0.8632009625,
-0.1572171003,
-0.1116991937,
0.6428488493,
-0.4477602839,
0.0087792389,
0.4115445316,
0.3299669623,
0.2811277807,
-0.1883186847,
0.354051888,
0.2874144614,
-0.3456034064,
-0.1054635718,
0.1684486568,
-0.3074117601,
-0.0552310459,
0.656776309,
0.8232358098,
0.5648049116,
-0.2932013571,
0.648734808,
-0.0432551093,
0.165590927,
-0.3305169344,
-0.0541909039,
-0.1425865144,
0.5712338686,
0.1800681502,
-0.4181669652,
0.4740308225,
-0.3418428898,
0.1892344207,
0.3349662721,
-0.8248016834,
-0.6177358627,
0.5477217436,
0.3653790355,
-0.004863671,
0.2683327794,
0.2709588706,
-0.5295616984,
0.7735816836,
0.4182808995,
1.0674703121,
-0.120927915,
0.1050646156,
0.6530194879,
0.4258696735,
0.1995606869,
0.1367297471,
-0.3526535332,
-0.8521721959,
-0.6745572686,
-0.8068552017,
0.0288326778,
0.0031825956,
-0.3937177956,
0.4384459853,
0.2984273136,
0.0985652655,
-0.0970856994,
0.0523376353,
-0.6400861144,
-0.0036997662,
0.2351983637,
0.7626283765,
-1.4253399372,
0.4763516784,
0.6851200461,
-0.5304203629,
-0.8564985394,
-0.3687101901,
0.0014408885,
-0.118163161,
0.6843896508,
0.2263784409,
-0.0768428817,
-0.1307080388,
-0.1744911671,
-0.9506143928,
1.2281126976,
-0.1786314398,
-0.3459623158,
0.0047719744,
0.158063367,
0.4987500608,
-0.521451056,
0.5024705529,
0.3353160322,
0.5131369829,
0.1958558112,
-0.26803267,
0.4120388329,
-0.3365550339,
0.1781295091,
0.410161525,
-0.1556685716,
0.4830398858,
0.0923426002,
-0.6654393077,
-0.1027321368,
0.9812754989,
-0.0004896887,
0.5973781943,
0.4056116343,
0.2740471959,
0.7745223641,
0.1124578491,
0.9795607924,
-0.4187716544,
0.2419747263,
1.3059368134,
-0.1860254258,
0.7224085331,
0.6157719493,
0.2564094067,
0.4079003334,
0.4775997698,
0.4883909225,
0.4320263267,
-0.2364003658,
-0.290438056,
-0.3445007801,
-0.1121083051,
-0.2302151769,
0.1997158378,
0.4009649754,
-0.4017282724,
-0.499528259,
-0.256773144,
-0.1551221013,
-0.2975382507,
-0.5268081427,
1.0221815109,
-0.0059113074,
-0.1338992715,
-0.487570405,
-0.0277549159,
0.2679912746,
-0.794557035,
0.0532247424,
-0.0413149185,
0.0295683425,
-0.2251125127,
-0.3605380058,
0.6009739041,
-0.1008938253,
-0.2254570574,
0.0240794905,
1.2969948053,
-0.661023438,
-0.492313087,
0.5804457664,
0.5948604345,
0.0057639196,
0.0063305525,
-0.184472844,
0.0539146513,
-0.5390848517,
-0.6034516096,
0.2367559671,
0.8382259011,
-0.248077035,
0.0429805107,
0.6588861346,
-0.0562111624,
-0.2297146618,
0.3071114421,
0.7820034623,
-0.9594932795,
-0.7669439316,
-0.9740589857,
0.7422382236,
-0.4628114104,
-0.1897606254,
0.6542659402,
0.5078812242,
0.4066103995,
0.1127160788,
0.240452677,
0.2479933947,
0.2315538526,
-0.62799716,
0.5528675914,
-0.557349205,
0.2227232456,
-0.477417469,
-0.5179961324,
-0.3190630376,
0.1123909503,
-0.3086510599,
-0.3133062124,
0.6822927594,
0.7254548669,
-0.0918775275,
0.0787352175,
0.3403841257,
0.3266100287,
0.2544260025,
0.6058507562,
1.0280822515,
-0.5359272361,
0.2446679622,
0.2442459911,
-0.4299589694,
-0.3046167195,
-1.0094203949,
-0.8496406674,
-0.788148582,
-0.5578647852,
-0.1809553802,
0.121683687,
0.5440653563,
0.4300866723,
-0.9658487439,
0.159948945,
-0.3171271682,
0.351052165,
0.0163512174,
-0.2145999521,
0.8213090301,
-0.3081290126,
-0.5683677197,
0.3284402192,
0.7186473012,
0.0162217282,
0.2005065382,
0.2778299153,
-0.279299438,
0.5404097438,
0.7350316048,
0.0406393185,
-0.5017917752,
-0.7006291151,
-0.2916456461,
-0.2595023215,
-0.4007848799,
0.8586784005,
-0.6825870872,
0.0239979737,
0.6030342579,
0.7361244559,
0.32388255,
-0.114098914,
0.4151821434,
-0.7784693837,
0.3069510758,
-0.2334535271,
0.566344738,
-0.0868816525,
-0.7284083366,
0.5667741299,
0.2334381789,
-0.1574086398,
-0.5519839525,
0.343462944,
-1.2380026579,
-0.2941507101,
1.1468442678,
0.196947664,
-0.8186113238,
-0.3143194616,
0.0699390471,
0.4734916985,
0.0618872419,
0.4408527315,
0.4341759682,
-0.2229611874,
0.3572023511,
-0.1830052286,
0.3498951793,
0.1551202685,
-0.8339143991,
-0.278881669,
0.6132392287,
-0.0309575871,
0.1820272356,
0.5919242501,
-0.2908989787,
0.0706699044,
-0.0408996679,
0.1673979759,
-0.0341778956,
-0.5392957926,
-0.2666376829,
0.2918327153,
-0.6644058824,
-0.1652480066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12786v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12786v2 | Mitigating Data Imbalance and Representation Degeneration in Multilingual Machine Translation | 2023-05-22T07:31:08 | 2023-10-24T20:10:04 | Wen Lai, Alexandra Chronopoulou, Alexander Fraser | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite advances in multilingual neural machine translation (MNMT), we argue
that there are still two major challenges in this area: data imbalance and
representation degeneration. The data imbalance problem refers to the imbalance
in the amount of parallel corpora for all language pairs, especially for
long-tail languages (i.e., very low-resource languages). The representation
degeneration problem refers to the problem of encoded tokens tending to appear
only in a small subspace of the full space available to the MNMT model. To
solve these two issues, we propose Bi-ACL, a framework that uses only
target-side monolingual data and a bilingual dictionary to improve the
performance of the MNMT model. We define two modules, named bidirectional
autoencoder and bidirectional contrastive learning, which we combine with an
online constrained beam search and a curriculum learning sampling strategy.
Extensive experiments show that our proposed method is more effective both in
long-tail languages and in high-resource languages. We also demonstrate that
our approach is capable of transferring knowledge between domains and languages
in zero-shot scenarios. | [
-0.3644289672,
-0.6875844598,
0.1680950075,
0.3750805259,
-0.325270772,
0.4002592564,
-0.1133679748,
-0.3019296527,
0.2409551591,
0.5568210483,
-0.265894562,
-0.2002085447,
-0.7226731181,
0.2263839394,
-0.2128382921,
0.8830470443,
-0.2426802516,
0.3854379654,
-0.2311976105,
-0.6101208925,
-0.714492619,
-0.886727035,
-0.7180855274,
-0.4548947215,
0.5136863589,
0.489587903,
0.7111738324,
0.8106284142,
0.5971680284,
0.244475022,
-0.043523889,
0.191384241,
-0.2690511644,
0.1944956481,
-0.2171968073,
-0.43918854,
-0.3309332728,
-0.3546342254,
0.7426053286,
1.0941870213,
-0.0938018262,
-0.1264033169,
0.1944361776,
0.9256200194,
-0.4664226174,
0.1498652697,
-0.5844633579,
0.0912666917,
-0.208471939,
-0.1391640455,
-0.2848942578,
0.1493829638,
-0.1953091174,
-0.3344447911,
0.2965394258,
0.1614403427,
0.6069176793,
0.2987839282,
-0.7406964898,
-0.1951224357,
-0.6106036901,
0.6834695339,
-0.5681013465,
0.4371869862,
0.4464240372,
0.2991065085,
0.1917413175,
-0.2439402044,
-0.4377454817,
-0.1530954391,
-0.0560601652,
0.104629457,
-0.2215481699,
-0.1117363721,
0.1041226164,
0.3387580216,
-0.7517787218,
0.3423520923,
-0.6213831306,
-0.2134319991,
0.4520276189,
0.1881889999,
0.194626987,
-0.0867063701,
-0.5774313211,
-0.2187419981,
-0.8384690285,
-0.3744269013,
0.4877311587,
0.543818295,
-0.2478412688,
0.6534349322,
0.0002853974,
0.4716024101,
-0.1007622927,
0.5937669873,
0.540661335,
-0.5154836774,
-0.1181131899,
0.1599825025,
0.6327835917,
0.2787086666,
-0.0129526127,
-0.2204789668,
-0.2428241372,
-0.1096761003,
0.0703670979,
-0.6819934249,
-0.1824983507,
0.2080064863,
-0.4244866073,
0.128638342,
-0.1669633389,
-0.816758275,
-0.3901543021,
-0.4765405357,
0.5139255524,
-0.3225254714,
-0.3651516736,
-0.0202507898,
-0.0211458392,
-0.0630873442,
-0.1100554019,
-0.8316961527,
0.0703926608,
0.2604715228,
0.9089541435,
-0.1920223385,
-0.4184575677,
-0.4897663593,
0.2745240331,
-0.1705699712,
0.3196543753,
-0.268260777,
-0.354647994,
-0.0677843317,
0.0126317851,
-0.3343662024,
-0.7566524744,
0.076734595,
-0.446906507,
0.125517711,
-0.1819179654,
-0.1836296618,
-0.1202235892,
0.2172859311,
-0.8067777157,
0.7485948801,
0.2142328769,
-0.6364239454,
0.1449672431,
-0.5585595965,
-0.7306678295,
-0.212659657,
-0.0621041991,
-0.4447984695,
0.1733283401,
0.2225151807,
0.1895720959,
-0.2663250864,
0.1976247728,
-0.2795497477,
-0.2454374582,
0.0995005295,
-0.7837871909,
0.9378601313,
0.5032627583,
-0.3718860745,
-0.1051249951,
-0.616189003,
-0.3479448259,
0.2283682376,
-0.4089251161,
-0.3762319386,
0.0590186045,
0.1256152987,
0.459759891,
0.2112579048,
-0.5016426444,
0.1591251343,
-0.5320634842,
0.3819590807,
0.6940677762,
-0.1727782935,
0.4788287282,
-0.2493595481,
0.427398622,
0.8115618229,
-0.0047715409,
-0.2332864106,
-0.2140558958,
-0.9815706611,
-0.2006496787,
0.3257395327,
0.7032237053,
-1.0880115032,
0.2422483861,
-0.2968054116,
0.0485114604,
-0.9202962518,
0.4556981921,
0.506364584,
0.4175027013,
0.9179666042,
-0.4345702827,
-0.4963685572,
-1.1862658262,
-0.0414114781,
-0.0165091548,
0.2136354744,
0.0992094949,
0.2344749421,
-0.5383040309,
0.4349215627,
-0.0515417941,
-0.3882543445,
-0.2868404984,
0.4338507354,
0.036630813,
0.8195956349,
0.4663364589,
-1.0467200279,
-0.5942627192,
0.1473725736,
-0.6080594659,
-0.1556138098,
-0.0758841485,
0.0047268397,
0.6250107288,
0.5874067545,
-0.4533496201,
0.2731390297,
0.5914390683,
-0.2610487342,
0.0371308252,
-0.5199651122,
0.1188408732,
-1.0523768663,
0.1856849492,
-0.319912225,
-0.1450467557,
-0.4951294363,
0.0633519366,
0.2520615757,
-0.2861436605,
-0.3952227235,
0.3845691979,
-0.511661768,
0.1020068303,
-0.387118578,
0.0838368684,
0.1007094532,
0.406465739,
-0.1803971678,
0.5140061378,
0.4893407524,
-0.5074074864,
0.3962673247,
0.1373436898,
0.1251362562,
0.7046044469,
-0.3613752425,
0.0431445502,
-0.4811403453,
0.0171586815,
-0.9099969268,
0.0778899118,
0.2464028001,
-0.3571166098,
0.800144136,
-0.0913593024,
-0.6050138474,
-0.2651037574,
0.0032858255,
0.6371240616,
0.199163571,
-0.4681842029,
0.3429634273,
0.2375534773,
-0.1120107174,
-0.688285768,
-1.1742441654,
0.2612461448,
-0.0127221327,
-0.3146151006,
0.347314775,
-0.1578174978,
-0.1168883294,
0.2209693342,
-0.036236383,
-0.1268555671,
0.1580636203,
-0.0928966925,
0.1661548913,
-0.146294266,
0.1684029251,
0.1705213636,
-0.3218199909,
-0.1788412333,
-0.3044643402,
0.7241191268,
0.0239846241,
-0.598752141,
0.018636968,
0.8166151643,
0.7574641705,
-0.456435442,
0.834174335,
0.6309224367,
-0.2826751769,
0.0006583868,
-0.397007525,
0.0383808836,
-0.3915233314,
0.4982228875,
-0.4174503088,
-0.5278382897,
0.5092760324,
0.181499511,
0.0639469326,
0.5006501079,
0.711491406,
0.0383987613,
1.2897244692,
0.6303896308,
-0.3035430908,
0.2675528824,
-0.3320628405,
0.16331774,
-0.7382576466,
-0.2195398062,
-0.4411485791,
-0.5143131018,
-0.5767998099,
-0.4931236506,
0.259572804,
0.0355049446,
-0.1708840579,
0.4847647846,
-0.3720558584,
0.3359861672,
0.6788176894,
0.0454803742,
0.3490929306,
0.0868092328,
-0.5695109963,
0.0490142442,
-0.7696502805,
-0.1686831266,
1.0193296671,
0.1180571169,
0.4997196794,
0.1962750107,
0.688146174,
0.2334010601,
0.2185150534,
-0.6038219929,
0.227649793,
-0.4777192175,
-0.8970927,
0.0045905756,
-0.8287683725,
-0.9773795009,
0.4697037041,
-0.0630501807,
-0.1661232561,
0.3943127394,
0.2515905499,
0.090516977,
0.3673281372,
-0.7540123463,
0.9799486995,
-0.5159626007,
-0.4859758019,
-0.4385840595,
-0.8905084729,
0.0985066667,
-0.2658405602,
0.424338311,
-0.0938929096,
0.0548679605,
0.269359678,
-0.164752394,
0.6118171215,
-0.3380812705,
0.1230275929,
-0.0077580935,
0.1308403164,
0.3076244295,
-0.3367701769,
-0.1268385053,
0.1999905109,
0.0764311552,
-0.7347131968,
-0.2781387269,
0.6506035924,
-0.6276932359,
-0.3962365389,
-0.3422392607,
-0.7125242949,
-0.3156450093,
0.2683500051,
0.3721358478,
0.3298638463,
-0.0554556027,
0.3501751721,
0.4432377219,
-0.2789589167,
0.4744746387,
0.550590694,
-0.1945298314,
-0.604744792,
1.1966212988,
0.3467151523,
0.3766905069,
0.4380941391,
-0.1051612347,
-0.2623660862,
-0.6258396506,
-0.8075149059,
0.2008427829,
-0.7156019807,
-0.3361575902,
-0.4669214785,
-0.0540711172,
-0.263355881,
-0.0588127561,
-0.3897115886,
-0.599745214,
-0.3268856704,
0.0403784886,
-0.2480357587,
0.3271113336,
-0.2870160043,
0.2017754614,
-0.7659204602,
0.4780343175,
-0.1548523605,
0.1968419701,
-0.0779427141,
-0.4340395629,
-0.7091448307,
0.2678858936,
-0.5143728256,
-0.6796415448,
0.4670679271,
0.1705458313,
0.6353217363,
0.1823723763,
0.0286831595,
0.6978620887,
-0.5270286798,
0.4413246512,
0.2636933923,
-0.7480056882,
0.2426379323,
0.0504572876,
0.367523402,
0.5913047194,
0.5152031779,
-0.7013674974,
-0.5735157728,
-0.4036210179,
-1.1163578033,
0.6551263928,
0.2477163523,
0.4131376743,
-0.0610496402,
0.0299498774,
0.0528431535,
0.2669783831,
-0.7530611753,
-0.3496014476,
-0.4177194834,
-0.5782333612,
-0.335373044,
-0.104072012,
-0.0483102165,
-0.2196373492,
0.6309415102,
-0.1520271301,
0.2379303426,
0.2606816888,
-0.4436948001,
-0.3152922988,
0.1792902052,
0.353192836,
0.5511326194,
-0.0296073593,
0.3782382309,
0.0660064816,
-0.2070926577,
0.2194885314,
0.551364243,
-0.1756418049,
0.0194612313,
0.2209891528,
0.787525773,
0.1064396277,
-0.6439622641,
0.3922151625,
0.3108101487,
-0.2352787107,
0.1088179126,
-0.339130044,
-0.0089231832,
0.262783885,
0.4464198649,
0.1033189297,
0.0267719403,
-0.5701300502,
0.2558834851,
0.4802912772,
-0.3078712821,
-0.2858426273,
0.8292858601,
0.1192180663,
-0.0491514727,
0.8027803302,
-0.0482559577,
-0.5816200376,
0.5762781501,
0.7852066159,
0.8147193193,
-0.3419304788,
0.0109337801,
0.2204392254,
0.5744224787,
0.0967383534,
0.2385427654,
-0.1227689013,
-0.6248602867,
-0.1611354351,
-0.508077085,
-0.3596621454,
-0.066209808,
-0.5037685633,
0.2726540565,
-0.1918111444,
0.0639003664,
-0.1744092405,
-0.0416777767,
-0.5781040192,
-0.0777535886,
0.2864830196,
0.5822268724,
-0.7223995924,
1.0340297222,
0.5641131997,
-0.6320335269,
-0.2138236612,
-0.2806437016,
-0.1059900895,
-0.6863399148,
0.7206286788,
0.2131291926,
0.1436437368,
0.0972811282,
-0.1944290251,
-0.6400102377,
0.9303542972,
0.6617206931,
-0.5381069183,
0.0411250927,
0.5985142589,
0.4215010703,
-0.1753157228,
-0.2600699365,
0.2927342951,
0.4905702174,
0.0865794122,
-0.8394835591,
-0.2048936635,
-0.2735468447,
-0.0769360289,
0.4039066732,
-0.6423338652,
0.8604131937,
0.0530018136,
-0.2849177718,
-0.1773241907,
0.4115694165,
-0.0812679455,
0.4842807353,
0.3068332672,
0.6961935163,
0.5429862142,
0.0949826911,
0.7321818471,
-0.4136939049,
0.3739979863,
0.9596586823,
-0.3228865862,
0.6826493144,
0.7255607247,
0.0461147912,
0.0997185558,
0.4640273154,
-0.0720129386,
0.5938263535,
0.1458713412,
-0.2519683838,
-0.1096556187,
0.0094093531,
-0.3420177102,
0.4264694154,
0.2835058272,
-0.5073788762,
-0.4004671574,
0.3939157128,
-0.0356891081,
0.0470121987,
-0.16650258,
0.5588905215,
0.1576298624,
-0.4715157151,
0.7691967487,
0.161834687,
0.4323745072,
-0.4082406759,
-0.0356248878,
-0.5573980212,
0.4117877483,
0.0062078582,
-0.4229169488,
0.7081010938,
-0.1318432689,
-0.2786307335,
-0.4228332341,
0.4483072162,
-0.9036851525,
-0.542814672,
0.5923017859,
0.7020024061,
-0.0201749373,
-0.0190994572,
-0.8039625287,
-0.1054212302,
-0.1602146626,
0.0420446806,
0.3624561727,
0.4690234959,
0.0049642925,
0.5968530178,
0.5046963096,
0.1771792322,
0.214600876,
-0.0597467683,
0.8374715447,
-0.5553497672,
-0.2014433295,
-0.917887032,
0.3923181593,
0.0306345783,
-0.0791159645,
0.6232975125,
0.8613396883,
0.9317411184,
0.0192412753,
0.53723979,
-0.0343618318,
0.3418852091,
-0.5526636839,
0.7369661927,
-0.8329250216,
0.3010507226,
0.1320043504,
-0.9840195179,
-0.5998715162,
0.2773256004,
0.0339102149,
-0.1714911759,
0.6088001132,
0.7464838028,
-0.4079407454,
-0.5156434774,
0.3813712895,
0.1664138287,
0.2199482918,
0.6978869438,
0.6097414494,
-0.4462871253,
0.7763545513,
-0.3871854544,
-0.0560129583,
-0.295178026,
-0.6523143053,
-0.7571881413,
-0.6565752625,
-0.2877672017,
-0.2335156351,
0.0724435523,
0.9634767771,
0.505790174,
-0.8392056823,
-0.4438271523,
-0.1054313555,
0.3305387199,
-0.2537031472,
-0.1640356034,
0.3263816535,
-0.6256654263,
-0.7655926943,
0.490889132,
0.3417179286,
0.2585970759,
-0.3205135167,
-0.135011375,
-0.3377443552,
-0.063421078,
0.5968518853,
0.3050920963,
-0.3757447898,
-0.0473106988,
-0.0038177571,
-0.3002731204,
0.2971731424,
0.7463208437,
-0.5897808671,
0.8381014466,
0.406167537,
0.8582174778,
0.5381013155,
-0.0842490941,
0.6109459996,
-0.8310082555,
0.2814429402,
0.2682606876,
0.4237295687,
0.5653749108,
-0.1613744646,
0.4055975974,
0.4889987707,
-0.3235535026,
-0.803601265,
0.2773016691,
-0.7215354443,
-0.4396210313,
0.8614197969,
-0.0192711409,
0.0561827943,
-0.3175315261,
-0.0853616297,
0.5133113265,
0.1459340602,
0.6415173411,
0.7619638443,
0.1043371186,
-0.2030287385,
-0.6954786181,
0.1196494251,
0.7022975683,
-0.4662674665,
0.286498636,
0.5409480929,
-0.083879821,
0.1637129635,
0.2610366642,
-0.3281858861,
0.0568971299,
-0.1416055411,
0.0099275792,
-0.266102165,
-0.4372197986,
-0.6668428779,
-0.0043297941,
-0.0772402287,
-0.302295506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12785v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12785v2 | MacLaSa: Multi-Aspect Controllable Text Generation via Efficient Sampling from Compact Latent Space | 2023-05-22T07:30:35 | 2023-10-17T15:48:15 | Hanxing Ding, Liang Pang, Zihao Wei, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-aspect controllable text generation aims to generate fluent sentences
that possess multiple desired attributes simultaneously. Traditional methods
either combine many operators in the decoding stage, often with costly
iteration or search in the discrete text space, or train separate controllers
for each aspect, resulting in a degeneration of text quality due to the
discrepancy between different aspects. To address these limitations, we
introduce a novel approach for multi-aspect control, namely MacLaSa, that
estimates compact latent space for multiple aspects and performs efficient
sampling with a robust sampler based on ordinary differential equations (ODEs).
To eliminate the domain gaps between different aspects, we utilize a
Variational Autoencoder (VAE) network to map text sequences from varying data
sources into close latent representations. The estimated latent space enables
the formulation of joint energy-based models (EBMs) and the plugging in of
arbitrary attribute discriminators to achieve multi-aspect control. Afterwards,
we draw latent vector samples with an ODE-based sampler and feed sampled
examples to the VAE decoder to produce target text sequences. Experimental
results demonstrate that MacLaSa outperforms several strong baselines on
attribute relevance and textual quality while maintaining a high inference
speed. | [
-0.2971703112,
-0.7319371104,
0.551122427,
0.4459896386,
-0.1191613674,
0.312898159,
0.2255017757,
-0.272330761,
0.6954775453,
0.6248548031,
-0.3136252165,
-0.4339694977,
-0.5533448458,
0.0002970179,
-0.1483077705,
1.1035764217,
-0.4269666672,
-0.494368583,
-0.0786836445,
-0.1984865069,
-0.0695514753,
-0.3724643886,
-0.1144968718,
-0.0810680613,
0.5275738835,
0.2936329842,
0.3713106513,
0.3380467296,
0.5899436474,
0.2990964055,
-0.0813200772,
0.6056614518,
0.0424374677,
0.4102908671,
-0.0687700808,
-0.2840572298,
-0.6307587028,
0.2003803253,
0.6816241145,
0.4810287952,
-0.4087683558,
0.0987759233,
0.124975346,
0.7596082687,
-1.0098341703,
-0.0324377641,
-0.6627054811,
0.0493330546,
-0.074512206,
-0.4001909792,
-0.1802536249,
-0.1693204343,
-0.2676951885,
-0.6319702268,
0.3461690545,
-0.0132757165,
0.9889500141,
0.2561428547,
-0.4820817709,
-0.3718691766,
-0.7573660612,
0.8663492203,
-0.4894918203,
-0.0637654066,
0.4502891898,
0.1805879325,
-0.0710138977,
-0.6041766405,
-0.7792026401,
-0.1216867641,
-0.086934194,
0.3778256178,
-0.1539645642,
0.0640432462,
-0.1075338647,
0.3731978834,
-0.392552346,
-0.1282948703,
-0.2841152251,
-0.2710321844,
0.3917989433,
0.0450957753,
0.1437959969,
-0.561502099,
-0.3592830598,
-0.4425857365,
-0.4018069506,
0.4061418176,
0.5880317688,
0.076629959,
-0.0887009501,
0.6821140051,
0.0094564706,
0.5640805364,
0.0302389357,
-0.1730937213,
0.3920918107,
-0.2587116361,
-0.2818187475,
-0.2460432947,
1.0273638964,
0.0339705236,
-0.745012641,
0.0900138915,
-0.340469867,
-0.0860736892,
0.543897748,
-0.6757821441,
-0.2973116934,
0.3663048446,
-0.4501994848,
-0.2880544364,
0.2600560784,
-0.8884034753,
0.1288841218,
-0.317636162,
0.2961145043,
-0.2821715474,
-0.1281518787,
-0.2268314958,
0.098607637,
-0.1568728536,
0.1999290884,
-0.8628877997,
0.4119822085,
0.187280789,
0.9084278345,
-0.1801292747,
-0.2008061111,
-0.7523389459,
0.2710672021,
-0.3585180342,
0.5952120423,
-0.7514009476,
-0.2922787666,
-0.3850513995,
-0.1021235213,
0.0543629602,
-0.3723621666,
0.2007395774,
-0.3934498131,
0.0065181348,
0.2879375815,
-0.1788078845,
-0.3303414881,
0.261701405,
-0.9000402689,
1.064078331,
-0.014655414,
-0.6812874079,
0.1473067403,
-0.6442657113,
-0.4239129126,
-0.544511497,
-0.3223735988,
-0.7855348587,
0.374024272,
0.556843996,
0.6759514213,
-0.0762640014,
0.2880931497,
0.0129322289,
0.5235534906,
0.3219765723,
-0.6139413714,
0.0993615985,
0.4285430312,
-0.1922551841,
0.287917912,
-0.9687489867,
-0.0172648337,
-0.1174155176,
-0.2725276053,
-0.4893546104,
-0.0653500408,
0.3634383678,
0.3601003289,
0.1250770688,
-0.6248548031,
0.1861046404,
-0.3068529367,
0.1789182276,
0.3718711138,
0.0530293584,
0.5524107814,
-0.4026739597,
0.6680461168,
0.3291715086,
0.0560915731,
-0.3933163881,
-0.3000420928,
-0.5113033056,
-0.1584328562,
0.1232217997,
0.3955054581,
-1.2609674931,
0.5741688609,
0.1391916424,
-0.5133810043,
-0.452935189,
0.1621020436,
0.5470060706,
0.140265882,
0.5697473288,
-0.3846742213,
-0.0369587876,
-0.8208135366,
0.2117281407,
0.0927380994,
0.0268239118,
0.4592375457,
0.5790984631,
0.2326632887,
0.9463104606,
-0.5452314615,
-0.2771285474,
-0.2479643822,
0.5117331743,
-0.1614083946,
0.7761480808,
0.6706635356,
-1.1738779545,
-0.246187672,
-0.0382856019,
-0.410749346,
-0.1660767496,
-0.4938187599,
-0.2560012937,
-0.0534944758,
0.1703707129,
-0.1259410381,
0.3347604871,
1.0676692724,
-0.0997461155,
0.4560704827,
-0.6184244752,
0.3376035094,
-1.6289694309,
0.1807368994,
0.1270413101,
-0.3225133419,
-0.2464549541,
0.1862370074,
0.2432186455,
-0.0941745266,
-0.3988572359,
0.1880506128,
-0.6465497017,
-0.0271553602,
-0.6415328383,
0.0407942086,
0.4508247375,
0.370831877,
-0.005128399,
0.9069224596,
0.2488380969,
-0.7671239376,
-0.0804069638,
0.069295764,
-0.0435214341,
0.3067234159,
-0.5158023834,
0.0298131816,
-0.2624798715,
0.6029164791,
-0.6856655478,
-0.2706162632,
0.0686748251,
-0.2069505602,
0.5377082825,
0.3617831767,
-0.1991601288,
-0.2000653297,
-0.2672289312,
0.4693539143,
0.0759982839,
-0.3781847358,
0.9719848633,
0.5554048419,
-0.3657186925,
-0.7665926218,
-0.6707132459,
0.0851599351,
0.1065465733,
-0.2678699791,
0.8233620524,
-0.0304686613,
0.004642657,
0.0207915045,
0.0365103222,
-0.2466923743,
-0.0621176362,
0.2721562088,
0.0332718566,
0.0737125129,
0.045751337,
0.9618287683,
-0.2368694246,
-0.3423243761,
-0.434102416,
0.4291852415,
0.1239620447,
-0.3430092335,
-0.6305657625,
0.6888580918,
0.5014132857,
-0.3381054699,
0.6496940851,
0.3402990103,
-0.1639498174,
-0.3404998183,
-0.3686850071,
-0.0722813681,
-0.4081619382,
0.2933179736,
-0.5338403583,
-0.7158338428,
0.4807051718,
-0.1581673175,
0.211895749,
0.6458159685,
0.4468759894,
0.0197393987,
0.5732438564,
0.9484703541,
0.1464154571,
0.4660779536,
-0.4991137683,
-0.1871099472,
-1.1621702909,
-0.2470774502,
-0.7108008862,
-0.4729115665,
-0.6758599877,
-0.742225647,
0.3499927819,
0.2333542556,
0.1564847976,
0.3291713595,
-0.7009727955,
0.4887980223,
0.3906616271,
0.1775128841,
0.133499831,
-0.0546063893,
-0.3454158604,
-0.0953363106,
-0.4786264002,
-0.8004369736,
0.9217294455,
0.047769662,
0.8386825323,
0.2539140582,
0.7048642635,
0.0717846155,
0.257799536,
-0.4363728166,
0.0776172355,
-0.4600886703,
-0.3144471645,
0.0023577858,
-0.6308275461,
-0.7062902451,
0.3489579558,
-0.1972800046,
-0.7273542881,
0.3847231865,
0.2738674581,
-0.4080054462,
0.6387116313,
-0.4070171416,
0.3538235128,
0.0218630061,
-0.3032197356,
0.0044958848,
-0.7084596753,
0.2851546407,
-0.199816823,
0.1976131648,
-0.1270874739,
-0.1694731712,
0.6501954198,
-0.4358402491,
0.8022746444,
-0.0337458439,
-0.2717249393,
0.3143498898,
0.1017312109,
0.3855971098,
0.1360372305,
-0.1062526107,
0.0985168219,
-0.0894603282,
-0.5662078261,
-0.5870917439,
0.6723567843,
-0.7716752887,
0.0300818551,
-0.3247837424,
-0.572609663,
-0.0115004824,
-0.2191365063,
0.5025447607,
0.5890082717,
-0.1757979393,
0.0594986305,
0.3338980675,
-0.5056663752,
0.831409514,
0.3887199163,
-0.1961659044,
-0.5651260018,
1.0722590685,
0.0112508414,
0.3901002109,
0.9024263024,
-0.0395140648,
-0.1142388433,
-0.5515363812,
-0.466258347,
-0.1599873602,
-0.3095547855,
-0.3213371933,
-0.9231903553,
-0.1350851804,
-0.1322795749,
-0.1868392974,
-0.6448951364,
-0.3650470972,
-0.364331454,
0.193081364,
-0.0035476934,
0.8655924201,
-0.1681148857,
0.4994539917,
-0.9802909493,
0.5046243668,
0.0741718411,
-0.0184514187,
-0.0210786238,
-0.1204246879,
0.0618235059,
-0.2274862081,
-0.8532913327,
-0.759563148,
0.7015442848,
0.182996124,
0.2926856577,
0.0861598849,
0.0098675471,
0.1356618255,
-0.5301005244,
0.9837606549,
0.5165079832,
-0.9343900681,
0.7598800659,
0.1556871533,
0.1201635301,
0.4598974884,
0.2418864071,
-0.159193784,
-0.6820908785,
-0.5903236866,
-1.0644843578,
0.5279220343,
0.76289922,
0.2456287146,
0.0042776708,
0.4910436869,
0.5553165078,
0.3267887235,
-0.571378231,
-0.3104867935,
-0.448697418,
-0.3408952355,
0.0223330408,
-0.1310618222,
0.037191622,
0.1415483505,
0.7622297406,
-0.3725296259,
0.1538905352,
0.4274588227,
0.0818054825,
0.2537094355,
0.5253449082,
0.7813763618,
0.4565129578,
-0.0120812096,
0.3055291474,
-0.2175788134,
-0.9759847522,
0.4537537098,
0.3097072244,
-0.2499787956,
0.0694385245,
-0.0518904403,
0.897028029,
-0.1504437476,
-0.1257067174,
0.3223740757,
-0.1674780697,
-0.0411168858,
0.0872486159,
0.0390041657,
-0.4376796484,
0.0504071899,
0.391281575,
0.3959869444,
0.182927534,
-0.1631784886,
0.1996416748,
0.0324529856,
-0.4353279471,
-0.3148083091,
0.7481566668,
0.2235067338,
-0.041273959,
-0.0699636936,
-0.2886947989,
-0.1227049604,
0.8284783959,
0.4150183201,
0.7820206285,
-0.175716117,
0.4647564888,
0.1859185398,
0.3164225519,
0.2440428436,
0.4172504246,
-0.2360514253,
-0.6704486609,
-0.7659304142,
-1.0669192076,
-0.58238554,
0.0257508606,
-0.659730196,
-0.5579343438,
-0.3506962061,
-0.2267181128,
0.1485083401,
-0.1170491278,
-0.1941494197,
0.2844147682,
-0.2416838557,
0.5349211693,
-0.690053165,
0.7944223285,
0.7016780972,
-0.6270065308,
-0.9617146254,
0.3466980755,
-0.0005379054,
-0.1951555908,
0.577104032,
0.0954204276,
-0.325565815,
-0.2359754443,
-0.5389488339,
-0.7338234782,
0.9824576974,
0.1818919033,
-0.7787944674,
0.1470422,
-0.177181527,
0.0679273531,
-0.454541117,
0.3200981021,
0.2601301372,
0.2298811972,
0.2436620593,
-0.8367302418,
-0.1975788027,
-0.406365782,
0.2868825793,
0.4092882276,
-0.644494772,
0.8445284963,
0.0525166728,
0.1205333918,
0.2602289617,
1.1396018267,
0.2420451641,
0.224377051,
0.3421394527,
0.3606481552,
0.9673799276,
-0.0899090022,
1.2349537611,
-0.4157817662,
0.3514169157,
1.123032093,
-0.1488093436,
0.9080163836,
0.5815626383,
-0.0800850391,
0.6194472313,
0.3270094991,
0.5613133311,
0.5723270178,
0.082655482,
-0.3744930625,
0.015994532,
-0.0202783253,
-0.1875832528,
0.6542441249,
0.4601024091,
-0.5046508908,
-0.1840778142,
0.5226107836,
-0.1758584529,
0.352742672,
-0.0980120525,
0.656408906,
0.0303019714,
-0.5394276381,
-0.0339789391,
0.3623749018,
0.8626823425,
-0.7425062656,
-0.0731984153,
-0.1800097823,
0.0055141575,
0.0262088235,
-0.747145772,
0.3963603079,
0.041402258,
-0.4673304856,
-0.2113393545,
0.5267262459,
-0.4225541651,
-0.5814427137,
-0.175092876,
0.3555741906,
0.2279718518,
-0.0757308677,
-0.5409272313,
-0.078693524,
-0.2081878483,
-0.3757435083,
0.1306157708,
0.5541815758,
0.1500942409,
0.1791867167,
0.6629483104,
0.3098041415,
-0.1139102876,
0.0162373558,
0.8758829832,
-0.5833312273,
-0.756329596,
-0.429507494,
0.3380992115,
-0.1484422386,
-0.6331903934,
0.3133797646,
0.5246361494,
0.4020292163,
0.2497214824,
0.6858246326,
-0.2361662537,
0.2424842417,
-1.0903958082,
0.9006781578,
-0.7912272811,
0.047519464,
-0.3826304376,
-1.0177718401,
-0.2619585395,
0.5615311265,
0.0294313673,
0.1581138968,
0.7639635205,
0.6263766885,
-0.3089713156,
-0.0698858649,
0.3084242642,
0.0576800667,
0.9253934622,
0.5009793043,
0.3221404254,
-0.473228693,
0.3195074201,
-0.4466282129,
-0.3922003508,
0.1580177099,
-1.0225476027,
-0.3860929608,
-0.8274482489,
-0.1889045835,
-0.2583082914,
-0.2854347527,
0.8330183625,
0.8826552033,
-0.8273464441,
0.2092429101,
-0.1715403199,
-0.1559040397,
-0.3037685156,
-0.2281709313,
0.7099610567,
-0.4421251714,
-0.9003215432,
0.4158750474,
0.7138976455,
0.2350557446,
-0.5707039237,
0.0060775364,
-0.1685997844,
0.1981998831,
0.5597826838,
0.1781399101,
-0.6470547318,
0.0673927739,
-0.2658918798,
-0.3419034183,
0.1117447466,
1.0446308851,
-0.7362287641,
0.6550326943,
0.3731895387,
0.6885187626,
0.6660020947,
-0.0048698471,
0.4291419387,
-1.0766912699,
0.3399751484,
0.2072987705,
0.2579258084,
0.3647499084,
-0.2113340199,
0.131678924,
-0.0091729099,
-0.5141196251,
-0.1005712822,
0.11115399,
-1.2012113333,
-0.4541420043,
0.9286444783,
-0.2874366939,
-0.560064435,
0.0371485613,
-0.4173101485,
0.2058777809,
-0.5784961581,
0.9295276403,
0.3950994015,
-0.1935673058,
0.011598832,
-0.5517165065,
0.3001086414,
0.361243844,
-1.3471187353,
-0.1573225707,
0.5964668393,
-0.1928205788,
0.5304660201,
0.5789365172,
0.022374643,
0.0223096479,
0.0607561059,
0.1943291873,
-0.0516511463,
-0.7815819979,
-0.0986308604,
0.6065288186,
-0.4843355119,
-0.363933146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12782v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12782v1 | Towards Robust Personalized Dialogue Generation via Order-Insensitive Representation Regularization | 2023-05-22T07:24:29 | 2023-05-22T07:24:29 | Liang Chen, Hongru Wang, Yang Deng, Wai-Chung Kwan, Zezhong Wang, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generating persona consistent dialogue response is important for developing
an intelligent conversational agent. Recent works typically fine-tune
large-scale pre-trained models on this task by concatenating persona texts and
dialogue history as a single input sequence to generate the target response.
While simple and effective, our analysis shows that this popular practice is
seriously affected by order sensitivity where different input orders of persona
sentences significantly impact the quality and consistency of generated
response, resulting in severe performance fluctuations (i.e., 29.4% on GPT2 and
83.2% on BART). To mitigate the order sensitivity problem, we propose a
model-agnostic framework, ORder Insensitive Generation (ORIG), which enables
dialogue models to learn robust representation under different persona orders
and improve the consistency of response generation. Experiments on the
Persona-Chat dataset justify the effectiveness and superiority of our method
with two dominant pre-trained models (GPT2 and BART). | [
-0.4065378904,
-0.5318860412,
0.3674445748,
0.0209672619,
-0.0539461933,
0.0941646472,
0.0104958257,
-0.3980461955,
-0.0604017004,
0.5999431014,
-0.5804340839,
-0.2805829048,
-0.4801576138,
-0.0345751978,
0.1104003787,
0.952267766,
0.6495518684,
0.1695846766,
-0.0437138714,
-0.2047315091,
-0.4377378523,
-0.6702549458,
-0.9051879644,
-0.1917836815,
0.3530804217,
0.3338196278,
0.8610191941,
0.4928146303,
0.3952718079,
0.3069086373,
0.2829683125,
0.1923650205,
-0.6102318168,
0.6055256724,
-0.1705695391,
-0.228767395,
-0.7148080468,
-0.2212165147,
0.4321775138,
0.6091716886,
-0.2177333683,
0.0327037983,
0.2739714384,
0.1170059666,
-0.4775893986,
0.3276409805,
-0.73527354,
-0.0409500673,
0.0499831364,
-0.2836174369,
-0.7674333453,
-0.419914782,
0.326656729,
-0.4898566008,
0.3002417684,
0.1661237776,
0.8667853475,
0.3132143319,
-0.1322203577,
-0.0291919746,
-0.9745646119,
0.4987185895,
-0.7565799356,
0.2308701426,
0.2392443269,
0.3700713813,
-0.4381691515,
-0.8256044984,
-0.2612870336,
0.0366441831,
-0.1715254188,
0.3742265105,
-0.1289059669,
0.3524621427,
0.4124371111,
0.0450397767,
-0.596619904,
0.2550467253,
0.1565615684,
-0.0995505825,
0.5343182087,
0.4782347381,
-0.088934198,
0.0675869659,
-0.2893769443,
-0.2940713465,
-0.4663496912,
0.2636432052,
0.6497976184,
0.4871951938,
0.1440969259,
0.3802206814,
-0.076710768,
0.5275676847,
0.786334455,
-0.1888035387,
-0.0080385357,
-0.248854652,
-0.3375682831,
-0.0821051449,
1.1635885239,
0.2884172797,
0.3928115964,
0.1660198122,
-0.1229560301,
-0.0493166894,
0.4801803231,
-1.127129674,
-0.4193263352,
0.0188709032,
-0.2790902555,
-0.2946182787,
0.2146731168,
-0.9145763516,
-0.4010360539,
-0.0818609968,
0.0509637482,
-0.4026614428,
0.1009322256,
0.0458435677,
0.4627913237,
0.1239232421,
0.3466596603,
-1.1886639595,
0.3736838996,
0.3161786199,
0.1914310604,
0.0764524341,
0.1025706455,
-0.6595574617,
0.2164842188,
-0.3704416752,
0.7958184481,
-0.706967473,
-0.4297757149,
-0.019985348,
-0.2906736135,
-0.1418297142,
-0.4864683449,
0.3451217711,
-0.3389669359,
0.6051750183,
-0.1160273775,
-0.3443659544,
0.1396287084,
0.0878326446,
-0.0094804782,
0.5492094755,
0.3623158634,
-0.701194644,
0.5171899796,
-0.4704730213,
-0.3478386998,
0.2506303191,
-0.4484208226,
-0.5857832432,
0.0306804236,
0.3534888029,
0.6475701332,
-0.1514362246,
0.3160187006,
-0.4077060223,
-0.2246706486,
0.1736220121,
-0.4668225944,
0.4790919125,
0.217664957,
-0.4854344726,
0.2418105006,
-0.8255296946,
0.1894556135,
0.2359529138,
-0.3315236568,
-0.1438662261,
0.1601227671,
-0.1215542406,
0.1340320259,
0.0728934556,
-0.5295746922,
0.1167532429,
-0.6587495208,
0.3322812915,
0.979480207,
0.2606091797,
0.4705420136,
-0.2843472362,
0.4846039414,
0.082682468,
0.1965182275,
-0.3870668411,
-0.5793659687,
-0.6379966736,
-0.3623548746,
0.0932463482,
0.5792577267,
-0.5511856079,
0.6808968782,
-0.4663385451,
-0.2615156174,
-0.3297999203,
-0.1780886948,
0.6703251004,
0.8453478813,
0.0632690787,
-0.7236427069,
-0.3301074803,
-0.8998810649,
-0.1990414262,
-0.6729302406,
-0.4312084615,
0.5419301391,
-0.0363315828,
-0.2690822184,
1.0139580965,
-0.5880517364,
0.0693546236,
-0.1867938638,
0.2783679068,
-0.1832373142,
0.5956911445,
0.7170512676,
-0.7451176047,
-0.7632314563,
0.0875800774,
-0.3748631775,
-0.0779526606,
-0.247336477,
-0.3121270537,
0.084879145,
0.3938882351,
-0.4359755814,
0.5818641186,
-0.0287837461,
-0.150997445,
0.1585615277,
-0.0642436519,
0.2691819668,
-1.4282429218,
-0.0288674589,
-0.0319138803,
-0.5784872174,
-0.9852048755,
-0.1633737981,
-0.3043823242,
-0.2995876372,
-0.3002401292,
0.2351514697,
0.0297763329,
0.1277029812,
0.0777480677,
-0.2866780758,
0.1272636652,
0.8869435787,
-0.0161384828,
0.6794944406,
0.1956993937,
-0.4529978037,
0.0960568413,
0.5988169312,
-0.2474629432,
0.86223948,
-0.8694797754,
0.531768918,
-0.2986671925,
0.176515907,
-1.3490200043,
-0.8932898045,
0.7353073955,
-0.4254190922,
0.6754020452,
-0.1754213423,
-0.472576201,
-0.1477952302,
-0.0549455248,
0.2219620645,
0.6986546516,
-0.4888143539,
0.8029215336,
0.1839329004,
-0.5493423939,
-0.1625191271,
-0.4371023178,
-0.3261599541,
-0.3454880118,
-0.7756087184,
0.1923439801,
-0.6145252585,
-0.1788068712,
-0.7471024394,
-0.0031627694,
-0.0833658949,
0.018967798,
0.2430082411,
-0.0608195215,
-0.0817059427,
-0.1570419818,
0.1680337489,
0.1142345816,
0.0914454907,
-0.1458091587,
0.7007113099,
0.0351383984,
-0.4890678227,
-0.4998416901,
0.5392878056,
0.8274446726,
-0.2081579417,
0.4201536477,
0.3898286521,
-0.1463625282,
0.0808283538,
-0.4010262787,
-0.3266808987,
-0.5238693953,
0.1648798883,
-0.4266264141,
-0.6843824387,
0.7815399766,
0.0822913647,
0.4338458478,
-0.0363531411,
0.624659121,
-0.1100297719,
1.6441845894,
0.4945611358,
-0.0610357299,
0.6531027555,
0.3163706064,
0.3387083113,
-0.4427388906,
-0.3735592365,
-0.4677829742,
-0.1255794168,
-0.4502182305,
0.2397889942,
0.3845805526,
-0.3584716916,
-0.5306433439,
0.2810302079,
-0.6012994647,
0.1268882155,
0.557264626,
0.2061219364,
0.0603570342,
0.2705276012,
0.1663965285,
-0.2936567962,
-0.7492410541,
-0.4009379745,
0.8625141382,
0.3346846998,
0.8430204988,
0.1879389733,
0.5604166389,
0.1208747327,
0.0285734981,
-0.6121166348,
0.5168849826,
0.111384064,
-0.297167331,
-0.1344338059,
-0.3950041234,
-1.1134713888,
0.1225050241,
-0.0648460835,
-0.9684023857,
0.5035575628,
0.3025201857,
-0.9730370641,
-0.1539844871,
-0.9003847241,
0.6452949643,
0.1081599221,
-0.3044930398,
0.3671475053,
-1.210935235,
0.2117499709,
-0.0196412113,
-0.1901976913,
0.0754475594,
0.3379983902,
0.2824245393,
-0.581441462,
0.9358008504,
-0.0560376123,
0.022128351,
0.1801595986,
0.2515232265,
0.8064749241,
0.3001463413,
0.1733265966,
-0.3774410188,
-0.4061354995,
-0.5438680649,
-0.7312956452,
0.4499894679,
-0.6944925785,
-0.7289648652,
-0.1354755908,
-0.5877898335,
-0.4906698763,
0.1274642348,
0.9442497492,
0.5485184193,
-0.2457814515,
-0.0902444124,
1.0624328852,
-0.0645909905,
0.256919384,
0.4133868515,
0.1010191217,
-0.5829133391,
0.8405324221,
0.0400561281,
0.4924497604,
0.2712096274,
-0.0040705064,
-0.1071317196,
-0.4734314978,
-0.3726063669,
-0.1026895568,
-0.4794293344,
-0.2253614813,
-0.7743569613,
-0.0892839059,
-0.8184680939,
-0.2710925341,
-0.3527542651,
-0.0002136937,
-0.5609861612,
0.0947048143,
0.0743278861,
0.752323091,
0.3699600399,
0.4481427073,
-0.4451628327,
0.3416237533,
0.615618825,
0.2050980479,
-0.3504249752,
-0.6874725223,
0.1274740696,
0.1266364753,
-0.4492104352,
-0.7250137925,
0.4388980865,
0.3951684535,
0.3596233726,
0.7768036723,
0.3383262455,
0.8156832457,
-0.5458446145,
0.7660877109,
0.1767479777,
-0.4948818684,
0.7710208297,
-0.8237223625,
0.488271296,
0.6574456096,
0.1439433098,
-0.0497399382,
-0.5960280895,
-0.8685307503,
-0.8859983087,
0.8223845363,
0.3888703883,
0.4366799891,
-0.0776368752,
0.4083913267,
0.3402699828,
0.4266824722,
-0.4732205868,
-0.1715445668,
-0.4710309505,
-0.1113154069,
-0.0403930955,
-0.3584196568,
-0.1206420138,
-0.0277378019,
0.442026794,
-0.3274149299,
0.3782194257,
0.0985152423,
0.3009863198,
-0.2063386142,
0.2102350742,
0.6940035224,
0.3368144035,
-0.3554466963,
-0.3337338567,
-0.2507354319,
-0.425227046,
0.0383075252,
0.1506870389,
-0.3565851748,
-0.0984213874,
0.0098679587,
0.798664093,
0.0114395088,
-0.4353827834,
0.579128921,
-0.3607861996,
-0.0563084036,
-0.2307800055,
0.1597926021,
-0.5450789332,
0.2723110318,
0.0544656627,
0.5281882286,
0.3575790823,
-0.445438236,
0.0227024537,
0.3388834596,
-0.3220473826,
-0.4046460986,
0.819645226,
0.1628698558,
-0.3675832748,
0.6644800305,
-0.1698971242,
-0.3491341472,
0.2940723598,
0.4341771305,
0.985231638,
-0.6191202402,
0.2110417634,
0.2213347405,
-0.1089898273,
-0.0087924413,
0.1789015681,
-0.0603736192,
-0.6274988055,
0.0446028821,
-0.2897602022,
-0.400731802,
0.2643556595,
-0.9429941773,
0.0881118029,
-0.9381303191,
-0.4340202808,
-0.2272675633,
-0.3638820946,
-0.6448229551,
0.1009614766,
-0.0199643914,
0.2131382972,
-0.6251689196,
0.5455448031,
0.6656867266,
-0.2458106875,
-0.8924478889,
0.2946889102,
-0.1613625437,
-0.3970116675,
0.1257970631,
0.0307330023,
-0.0429073125,
0.1439380795,
-0.7450934649,
-0.6491834521,
0.8535105586,
0.7820906043,
-0.4435644746,
0.0012040774,
0.1190888435,
0.6982139945,
-0.8116696477,
0.2641732693,
0.5147867203,
0.0912025794,
0.1742740721,
-0.5858163834,
-0.0831943378,
-0.5138739347,
0.4323267639,
0.0476623178,
-0.8624075055,
0.5569889545,
0.067808263,
-0.3656615615,
0.5035918355,
0.6911122203,
0.1537664831,
0.1066889614,
0.3130720258,
0.2877259552,
0.7286524773,
-0.2817651927,
1.1046094894,
-0.2546353042,
-0.0881637037,
1.3983927965,
-0.3943885565,
0.406771332,
0.2111227065,
0.0900956169,
0.4424531162,
0.8612242937,
0.0500137098,
0.7510108352,
-0.0384646952,
-0.2859750986,
-0.4213359654,
-0.2955009341,
-0.3740368187,
0.2548005283,
0.3111580908,
-0.5153358579,
0.1171125621,
0.0776387602,
0.0663150027,
0.2994583547,
-0.1599978805,
1.0242308378,
-0.2605623603,
-0.8005631566,
0.6308274865,
-0.3237289786,
0.4319781363,
-0.6076827645,
0.0682800859,
-0.5051543713,
0.1807757914,
0.0855901986,
-0.332184732,
-0.1106202453,
-0.1747157723,
-0.4065700769,
-0.3338546455,
0.6499102116,
-0.4893070161,
-0.3052539825,
0.0564140193,
0.1822206974,
0.1033254415,
0.2128269821,
-0.5990130901,
-0.195172444,
0.144716233,
-0.5069339275,
0.5680242777,
0.3598353267,
-0.0064941053,
0.59253335,
0.3975760639,
-0.4990992844,
0.0950341448,
0.2271915823,
0.9429471493,
0.1185110807,
-0.4130327702,
-0.5528748035,
0.8739261031,
-0.1039424762,
-0.3556529284,
0.5832260847,
0.1695218384,
0.9339148998,
-0.2063914984,
0.8037089109,
0.031493742,
0.4109809399,
-0.0932812616,
0.6188697815,
-0.1904317737,
0.3670681715,
-0.5756852627,
-1.0062141418,
-0.4193337262,
0.4675523043,
-0.0897009447,
0.2787423432,
0.1681631058,
0.9046159387,
-0.1365540624,
-0.2599139512,
0.5443406105,
0.1971382052,
0.5571967363,
0.5632257462,
0.6621136665,
-0.3978124559,
0.5986214876,
-0.1554855555,
-0.1420890987,
-0.1892174333,
-0.4763798416,
-1.2024476528,
-0.3499071002,
-0.3799628317,
-0.5251675248,
0.2008351982,
1.0736835003,
0.7261385918,
-0.8803700209,
0.1013078466,
-0.3172680438,
-0.3481726646,
0.044212766,
-0.2263206542,
0.0428470224,
-0.3642147481,
-1.0749402046,
0.3828164637,
0.3453539908,
0.4863831103,
-0.111755237,
-0.2610290051,
0.2549656332,
0.423340559,
0.4733118713,
0.4031074345,
-0.6896877289,
-0.5515409112,
0.0438330807,
-0.3614200652,
0.4420879781,
0.7078944445,
-0.7217181325,
0.7451912165,
0.4709643424,
0.3971042633,
0.0139241647,
0.4159225821,
0.9793291688,
-0.9806824327,
0.1904017776,
0.434618324,
0.3182427883,
0.3093982935,
-0.7782139778,
0.3531144261,
0.0653826222,
-0.7255038023,
-0.7684443593,
0.8683269024,
-0.9697977304,
0.00966358,
0.8417672515,
-0.6235445142,
0.2348356545,
-0.2169210464,
-0.3424975574,
0.0185654461,
-0.8853901625,
0.7322802544,
0.38372311,
-0.441280812,
-0.2061325759,
-0.0192174874,
0.5184897184,
0.571439147,
-0.5707247257,
-0.0540123247,
0.5846848488,
0.0585598275,
0.2338394672,
0.6563816071,
-0.0097931763,
0.2457018346,
-0.1002316102,
-0.1710211933,
0.092452541,
-0.5041396022,
-0.1727457494,
0.4773394763,
0.2035906762,
0.0005427887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12777v1 | Evaluating Pragmatic Abilities of Image Captioners on A3DS | 2023-05-22T07:15:33 | 2023-05-22T07:15:33 | Polina Tsvilodub, Michael Franke | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating grounded neural language model performance with respect to
pragmatic qualities like the trade off between truthfulness, contrastivity and
overinformativity of generated utterances remains a challenge in absence of
data collected from humans. To enable such evaluation, we present a novel open
source image-text dataset "Annotated 3D Shapes" (A3DS) comprising over nine
million exhaustive natural language annotations and over 12 million
variable-granularity captions for the 480,000 images provided by Burges & Kim
(2018). We showcase the evaluation of pragmatic abilities developed by a
task-neutral image captioner fine-tuned in a multi-agent communication setting
to produce contrastive captions. The evaluation is enabled by the dataset
because the exhaustive annotations allow to quantify the presence of
contrastive features in the model's generations. We show that the model
develops human-like patterns (informativity, brevity, over-informativity for
specific features (e.g., shape, color biases)). | [
-0.5283891559,
-0.5685089827,
0.3886199296,
0.2225218564,
-0.6103560328,
-0.0236142874,
-0.2374809086,
-0.4440052807,
0.0224845577,
0.4850259423,
-0.3206420839,
-0.4895972908,
-0.5193542242,
0.387034297,
-0.2736954093,
0.6518952847,
0.0334841087,
0.0610160492,
-0.5319696665,
-0.2735688984,
-0.2120800763,
-0.3561624885,
-0.4404224455,
-0.1065415293,
0.3108791709,
0.3959908783,
1.2041679621,
0.9114306569,
0.6315389276,
0.3181465268,
-0.1455020159,
0.0311641861,
-0.4620699584,
-0.1939793229,
-0.2389381528,
-0.2715095282,
0.0187673122,
0.039993871,
0.5308362246,
0.7090789676,
-0.0338900723,
-0.0621654019,
-0.0623012409,
0.6332624555,
-0.3289917111,
0.5227515697,
-0.355204314,
0.2361131459,
0.1917270124,
-0.0274872519,
-0.1291999668,
-0.4081986845,
0.4314742982,
-0.9220398068,
0.4391150773,
0.1645918041,
1.1027954817,
0.2740167677,
-0.1238069162,
-0.3370818198,
-0.3959320188,
0.7255446315,
-0.6257048845,
0.2269210815,
0.2041455954,
0.498837769,
0.1514513046,
-0.6858076453,
-0.6986935139,
-0.6061134934,
-0.2099136412,
0.1516188979,
-0.078188926,
0.2107640207,
0.1545092463,
0.502340436,
-0.3274962306,
0.058915589,
-0.5021998286,
-0.2280748487,
0.7989718318,
-0.0140627259,
0.3470273018,
-0.156915009,
-0.3796599209,
-0.2907503545,
-0.3413293362,
-0.1197819933,
0.4735687971,
0.3174436688,
-0.4177856147,
0.8015545607,
-0.1737592667,
0.8683655262,
-0.1136920601,
0.1695186496,
0.3869127929,
-0.2279316336,
0.0217274595,
-0.2103677392,
0.924648881,
0.6395153999,
0.7424554825,
-0.3181874156,
-0.2504790425,
0.0114071341,
0.4244941771,
-0.8170809746,
-0.4620402753,
0.0241476186,
-0.6285053492,
-0.2789286077,
0.3063928783,
-0.7738639712,
-0.9988675117,
-0.5960814357,
0.2445179075,
-0.4503733218,
-0.6255249977,
0.2008976042,
-0.3251946867,
0.1781732142,
0.372453928,
-0.3820803761,
0.3464384377,
0.2659552097,
0.9979716539,
-0.1180145666,
-0.4418548644,
-0.1889464259,
-0.1859201938,
-0.3610194027,
0.8519704938,
-0.5452151299,
-0.2746742964,
-0.0083496524,
-0.2200093418,
-0.2515647411,
-0.6420191526,
0.3865961134,
-0.1746176034,
0.0805581734,
-0.1287856847,
-0.3435665071,
-0.3864106834,
0.12050616,
-0.9761943817,
0.2764010429,
0.088511616,
-0.6854028106,
0.2488347888,
-0.8791650534,
-0.5786494613,
0.2953008115,
-0.5763346553,
-0.4231666625,
0.3340054154,
0.1755792797,
0.5349900723,
-0.2497996837,
0.4181821048,
-0.1620968133,
-0.6617328525,
0.4268150628,
-0.2402140647,
0.4432081282,
0.0487611294,
-0.3149872422,
0.3795625567,
-0.7735769749,
-0.2844146788,
0.429423213,
-0.1048063785,
0.0693265721,
0.0178905111,
0.153868258,
0.4951539934,
0.0540674068,
-0.4352685213,
-0.2842493057,
-0.2610595822,
0.4659439623,
0.4717786312,
0.0176604725,
0.3818795979,
-0.5207391381,
0.6166381836,
0.2942070365,
0.1578158289,
-0.356161505,
-0.62696594,
-0.5747364163,
-0.6568337083,
-0.0291317962,
0.3245150447,
-0.8463645577,
0.4666192532,
-0.4661878049,
-0.5574020147,
-0.7087355852,
0.0720184371,
0.6484102011,
0.5056689382,
0.2687024772,
-0.5416972041,
-0.2200399488,
-1.4728877544,
-0.0451206826,
-0.125938043,
-0.3838376105,
0.4854704142,
0.4328721464,
0.0907793492,
0.9031851292,
-0.2409128547,
-0.2042654455,
-0.0670734048,
0.3957849145,
-0.0897362903,
0.4112401307,
0.478369087,
-1.0760654211,
0.0596296974,
0.0233638361,
-0.7437195778,
-0.0540521443,
-0.2049916834,
-0.0211191867,
0.0025243035,
0.5261290669,
-0.6101869941,
0.4266496301,
0.4949608147,
-0.5663815141,
0.5656997561,
0.0104243355,
0.2471070141,
-0.5894493461,
0.3629681468,
0.3272216916,
0.0896115452,
-0.4028586149,
-0.1257217377,
-0.0205370858,
-0.2398746312,
-0.648388803,
0.6078851819,
-0.4855124056,
-0.2631360292,
-0.0353507996,
0.3054567277,
0.1877020448,
0.6486819983,
0.5708002448,
0.7656268477,
0.6364072561,
-0.6541742682,
0.2182247341,
0.433483094,
-0.4811703265,
0.7365574837,
-0.6861275434,
0.0643005148,
-0.3159211576,
-0.098721467,
-1.1082414389,
-0.2507983446,
0.290153414,
-0.3088476062,
0.0528599136,
-0.0803002939,
-0.5622682571,
-0.1761971116,
-0.1609325558,
0.2101931721,
0.3138588369,
-0.4560209215,
0.6179665923,
0.2018901259,
-0.2159208804,
-0.121697776,
-0.7617346644,
0.3978565633,
-0.1317265481,
-0.6231700778,
0.2464302778,
0.0348383226,
-0.2496055514,
0.1454035193,
0.0529202111,
-0.0929846168,
0.0479023419,
0.3699165583,
0.048273325,
-0.0931295678,
-0.221484825,
-0.2293034494,
0.1141280308,
0.1522058994,
0.0475228056,
0.2847850621,
-0.4993438721,
-0.3437013328,
-0.5434488654,
0.0065361108,
0.6972441673,
-0.2190912068,
0.6930930018,
0.4845398664,
-0.279461354,
0.1869265586,
-0.3774977922,
-0.2137615085,
-0.3843064308,
0.5318431854,
-0.35101071,
-0.7477523685,
0.8487230539,
0.1572492868,
0.0343682729,
0.2997588813,
0.1126208007,
0.1805036962,
1.0940605402,
0.2599423528,
0.5838593841,
0.5428207517,
-0.2652637661,
0.0931171477,
-0.6224455237,
-0.4862030745,
-0.2776318192,
-0.2009926736,
-0.440774858,
-0.3800387979,
-0.0131107727,
-0.0393650047,
-0.3122748137,
0.12625283,
-0.5737296939,
0.3915989697,
0.5271684527,
0.179448545,
0.0762233511,
0.0051619089,
-0.0578331761,
-0.1800203621,
-0.6633467078,
-0.7148274183,
0.6875485182,
0.4573776722,
0.3362279534,
0.0372347794,
0.2319304049,
0.2836197615,
0.5143017173,
-0.741586566,
0.7701069713,
-0.0996887013,
-0.344941467,
-0.1345834732,
-0.6133873463,
-0.7686472535,
0.3577954769,
-0.3757796884,
-0.3344544172,
0.1597655416,
0.0687170103,
-0.1100518927,
0.0897813961,
-0.9390607476,
0.99678123,
-0.3352420628,
-0.5270754695,
0.0289972425,
-0.8004889488,
0.3574545681,
0.0263058878,
0.1578675956,
-0.1183533147,
-0.1695802957,
0.7535951734,
0.0509100445,
0.9364880323,
-0.4275304377,
0.0683707297,
0.2359678596,
0.263989836,
-0.0396826603,
-0.1066013053,
-0.1067858115,
0.6644207239,
-0.2383027226,
-0.4949660599,
-0.5750806332,
0.3765157759,
-0.6838706136,
-0.4309190214,
-0.3108931184,
-0.4827362001,
-0.1969824433,
0.3625306487,
0.1005541161,
0.257984221,
-0.2618150413,
0.3154476583,
0.3116563857,
-0.466778338,
0.2683277726,
0.387819171,
-0.0496624857,
-0.5800537467,
0.9381847978,
-0.1316191256,
0.2079484165,
0.1103412658,
0.2634531856,
-0.5171672106,
-0.9165207148,
-0.6895372272,
0.3724558651,
-0.7976537943,
-0.227708295,
-0.2753485143,
-0.2359473854,
-0.0249422416,
-0.463994205,
-0.2333599478,
-0.502666831,
-0.3061224818,
-0.2180611938,
0.2111316323,
0.9225870371,
0.2935953438,
0.3344045281,
-0.5688950419,
0.5541061163,
0.1431257427,
0.6425494552,
-0.1561046541,
-0.4576302767,
-0.1630662233,
0.152436167,
-0.1158730909,
-0.7908195853,
0.388343513,
0.1839231998,
0.7475866079,
0.4209893048,
-0.2425118685,
0.6167672873,
-0.1967156231,
0.9105081558,
0.3450856805,
-0.9671289921,
0.4132657647,
-0.4688808322,
0.4483755231,
0.6305884719,
0.1581396312,
-0.1979490519,
-0.525942266,
-0.7004383206,
-0.8238729835,
0.7318738103,
0.6323552728,
0.1874858141,
-0.1398650259,
0.4357374609,
-0.0469922237,
0.5318132043,
-0.5934801102,
-0.0033694762,
-0.777184844,
-0.3547265232,
0.0519563928,
0.0127857234,
-0.3117599785,
-0.1473862827,
0.1551635861,
-0.3304466009,
0.1809866875,
0.1925205439,
-0.1178640872,
-0.0099420492,
-0.0254847035,
0.6882779598,
0.9376180768,
-0.1218070015,
0.190637067,
-0.2320179939,
-0.5041187406,
-0.1917364299,
0.4544098973,
-0.0782057866,
0.0076264935,
0.5194115639,
0.9616980553,
0.3987226486,
-1.0283544064,
0.6276770234,
-0.3768517673,
-0.3530118465,
-0.0175690074,
0.0284673609,
-0.0394651964,
-0.0875055119,
0.3312299848,
0.2265636772,
0.0849276707,
-0.136198625,
0.1917262375,
0.2005781382,
-0.4511477351,
-0.2903931737,
0.506161809,
0.4864460528,
-0.2751030624,
0.7009544969,
-0.368405968,
-0.3491104245,
0.8226309419,
0.3977775872,
0.8013703823,
0.0325665288,
0.397223264,
0.4647140801,
0.356251508,
-0.2661297619,
0.1366565526,
0.0152985044,
-0.8194003105,
-0.1693567783,
-0.5053675175,
-0.5373501182,
0.1239192188,
-0.7452481985,
0.2733301818,
-0.5851337314,
0.0899411067,
0.0253058597,
-0.1159456745,
-0.8183976412,
0.401699543,
0.1464825869,
0.7211509347,
-0.9493638873,
0.1401411593,
1.1989314556,
-0.6763334274,
-0.320712477,
-0.1464974582,
-0.1934016049,
-0.6416416168,
0.2989037335,
0.4980345368,
-0.1212759539,
0.0092605064,
-0.5278444886,
-0.5166226029,
1.0571248531,
0.5927308202,
-0.4655898809,
0.1899650097,
0.1264555305,
0.7569382787,
-0.5742964149,
0.2149705142,
0.4983557165,
0.5245918632,
0.3204697669,
-0.7240092158,
0.1271020174,
-0.5878506303,
0.129334867,
-0.308427006,
-0.3455061018,
0.4727427065,
-0.2332697809,
-0.5031095147,
-0.0494251475,
0.586505115,
0.4712159336,
0.2634433806,
0.6867778301,
0.2589197457,
0.5509809852,
-0.0321542956,
1.23148036,
-0.22970815,
-0.1550806314,
0.8784104586,
-0.1964541525,
0.5090864897,
0.4129517376,
0.1413849443,
0.3071068823,
0.3483983874,
-0.1097536534,
0.458558023,
0.4905982018,
0.0440266132,
-0.2027865648,
-0.2521383166,
0.1252646744,
0.403706938,
0.4212714136,
-0.3539142609,
-0.1459570825,
-0.0614081807,
-0.1802968681,
0.6596280336,
-0.1778512001,
0.8000216484,
-0.0107206348,
-0.6090841293,
0.5835515857,
-0.1325931847,
0.5760504603,
-0.3065443635,
-0.3105011284,
-0.0856421068,
-0.1473370641,
-0.2388632596,
-1.1669815779,
0.342638284,
-0.0327303708,
0.1123260856,
-0.199207291,
0.3852443993,
-0.3034521639,
-0.3530823588,
0.1142579988,
0.3265116811,
0.1228594854,
-0.2321410477,
-0.9655579329,
0.1638692766,
-0.1848926097,
-0.2645558119,
-0.0600290745,
0.4473514259,
-0.1019517928,
0.6390811205,
0.4735146761,
0.1712632477,
-0.1492165625,
0.4447994828,
0.8259726763,
-0.6529791951,
-0.4842473269,
-0.5495275259,
0.696008265,
-0.3474395573,
-0.459195286,
0.6220920086,
0.6219215989,
0.7707716823,
-0.1833098829,
0.8997789621,
0.0198385771,
0.108709231,
-0.4377020299,
0.5774253011,
-0.1828698218,
0.0669261888,
-0.0928270072,
-0.8510960937,
-0.6482052207,
0.971691072,
-0.5166031122,
0.3144952953,
0.4704653919,
0.8503418565,
-0.0876985714,
0.2227534503,
0.4392876625,
0.1267887503,
0.2381379157,
0.2315487862,
1.1487965584,
-0.0844978914,
0.5313475132,
-0.4539944828,
-0.2398079038,
-0.131878078,
-0.9944425821,
-1.1039495468,
-0.6604024768,
-0.6077024341,
-0.2479212284,
-0.0037439377,
0.6111795306,
0.7167301774,
-0.714271307,
-0.0613871403,
-0.546118021,
-0.0930990726,
-0.3128146529,
-0.2603149116,
0.353564769,
0.0417243689,
-0.6132751107,
0.1890975982,
0.1028274819,
0.3088306785,
-0.3087537885,
-0.2607356608,
0.0610135011,
0.0788878649,
0.3958926797,
0.234886378,
-0.6264603734,
-0.1215898693,
-0.0208759271,
-0.0465577915,
0.06934122,
0.7144767642,
-0.4839571714,
0.6505435705,
0.2718296051,
0.2896280289,
0.173784554,
0.3776680231,
0.588224411,
-0.8161023259,
0.3816532791,
0.5864517689,
0.2524803281,
0.950791657,
-0.1806406081,
0.3199375272,
0.0931937769,
-0.1913888156,
-0.6700723767,
0.1404901445,
-0.8676421642,
-0.2758998275,
1.2959301472,
-0.2541606128,
-0.1850849837,
-0.1794330329,
-0.5091671348,
0.1173805818,
-0.3412517309,
0.912328124,
0.5781083703,
-0.1293763369,
-0.4055632353,
-0.4387230277,
0.5759335756,
0.2753056288,
-0.8120289445,
0.1051796824,
0.9221061468,
-0.0479168221,
0.3988708556,
0.3470537663,
-0.382044673,
0.3926275671,
0.0920392647,
0.2965628207,
-0.6622980237,
-0.3751711845,
-0.6360562444,
0.1705980003,
0.152742669,
-0.358840853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12774v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12774v3 | Learning Optimal Policy for Simultaneous Machine Translation via Binary Search | 2023-05-22T07:03:06 | 2023-05-27T15:27:40 | Shoutao Guo, Shaolei Zhang, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Simultaneous machine translation (SiMT) starts to output translation while
reading the source sentence and needs a precise policy to decide when to output
the generated translation. Therefore, the policy determines the number of
source tokens read during the translation of each target token. However, it is
difficult to learn a precise translation policy to achieve good latency-quality
trade-offs, because there is no golden policy corresponding to parallel
sentences as explicit supervision. In this paper, we present a new method for
constructing the optimal policy online via binary search. By employing explicit
supervision, our approach enables the SiMT model to learn the optimal policy,
which can guide the model in completing the translation during inference.
Experiments on four translation tasks show that our method can exceed strong
baselines across all latency scenarios. | [
-0.513056457,
-0.459989816,
0.6831333041,
0.5647315979,
-0.5290307403,
-0.0807910562,
-0.2012575418,
-0.0530231968,
0.1565081328,
0.4901661277,
-0.7065913677,
-0.3107393384,
-0.4795989394,
0.4090237319,
0.062018916,
1.3526360989,
-0.4140156806,
0.096448116,
-0.064050287,
0.1571857333,
-0.5967751741,
-0.3565066457,
-0.4798160791,
-0.1761551648,
0.3990834951,
0.3192268908,
0.9411671758,
0.7589052916,
0.7023583651,
0.285681963,
-0.1613773406,
0.5678868294,
-0.3188439012,
-0.0378766507,
-0.2470167726,
-0.5559233427,
-0.0450251102,
-0.2473956496,
0.8420181274,
0.4934237301,
-0.0972836018,
-0.2720265985,
-0.2409627587,
0.2253923714,
-0.3611522913,
0.3020039499,
-0.6279626489,
0.2652194202,
0.0918071717,
-0.4263820052,
-0.3517077863,
-0.7053225636,
-0.159650296,
-0.6236475706,
0.1754189879,
0.0873120651,
0.9877809882,
0.5669631958,
-0.7202325463,
-0.0199996196,
-0.7854002118,
0.8566827178,
-0.521122098,
0.3266260624,
0.511115551,
0.2741860747,
-0.1697496623,
-0.5807184577,
-0.4367672205,
-0.284487009,
-0.1283942908,
0.3118255734,
0.0442932621,
0.3434231281,
0.2440888286,
0.0859669894,
-0.5109320283,
-0.205189541,
-0.5115839839,
-0.1530411392,
0.566052556,
0.0280201696,
0.0672879517,
-0.1060977429,
-0.6091937423,
-0.0996689796,
-0.1901519001,
0.0300889295,
0.4743491709,
0.1359153539,
0.0947188213,
0.4041817188,
-0.1862792075,
0.3668057919,
-0.0851170644,
-0.0787266642,
0.3922611475,
-0.5369543433,
0.2507763505,
0.2092413157,
0.8044804931,
0.16423437,
0.0786716938,
-0.5467489362,
-0.6391025782,
0.0093021449,
0.6830430627,
-0.621486783,
0.3801074028,
0.1280110627,
-0.1148059219,
-0.2507659495,
0.2409133017,
-0.4830568433,
0.3950476348,
-0.3861406446,
0.6889433861,
-0.2306506783,
-0.0605540685,
0.1655562371,
0.0216870997,
0.0243507177,
-0.0854164287,
-0.843035996,
0.6167641878,
0.5123429894,
1.1071135998,
-0.3131505251,
-0.351975441,
-0.8180369139,
0.2231192887,
-0.5619193316,
0.3329024315,
-0.2434894443,
-0.3734067678,
-0.0255070645,
-0.1576129645,
-0.1722496599,
-0.0804544389,
0.6818195581,
-0.6268082261,
-0.0908521041,
-0.0299584009,
-0.4959888458,
-0.1341927201,
-0.0734952241,
-0.672147572,
0.9870454669,
0.0776635483,
-0.8113543391,
0.2203246057,
-0.8929942846,
-0.603448689,
-0.1562289894,
-0.3185015023,
-0.6197034717,
0.0977840424,
0.3876142502,
0.4350394607,
0.1513011605,
0.7898826599,
-0.2604075074,
-0.6559379697,
0.1206963435,
-0.4524304867,
0.6393100023,
0.204657957,
-0.5355427861,
0.0766074657,
-0.4111655653,
-0.0722323507,
0.2039028853,
-0.4662500024,
-0.0917134061,
0.1233301386,
-0.1609429419,
0.2089502662,
0.423856467,
-0.5754411817,
0.3491617441,
-0.4290070236,
0.3193595409,
0.8785144091,
0.2017714679,
0.4461590052,
-0.1727926582,
0.5310711265,
-0.2307675183,
0.5120764971,
-0.0987829491,
-0.3265003562,
-0.5076317787,
0.0134312883,
0.3050697446,
0.6529989839,
-0.754247725,
0.3829330802,
-0.318828553,
-0.0326286294,
-0.7769755125,
0.1990623921,
0.6982643604,
-0.1847964525,
0.4978072643,
-0.4498533905,
-0.2780463696,
-0.8548591137,
-0.4011828005,
0.012964596,
0.3346301019,
0.4077537954,
0.4357596934,
-0.1645372212,
0.883438468,
-0.5310872197,
-0.2702586949,
-0.0663189217,
0.2693939507,
0.2971019745,
0.3813893795,
0.3958107233,
-1.2488027811,
-0.55477494,
0.1337872297,
-0.7620995641,
-0.3136629462,
-0.5160615444,
-0.5266159773,
0.2561788559,
0.6577154398,
-0.330435127,
0.2184955031,
0.5812398791,
-0.079492487,
0.3369532526,
-0.5692383647,
-0.0589468405,
-1.0339084864,
-0.0770273134,
-0.374252826,
-0.6776291132,
-0.3295114338,
0.3230491281,
0.148803845,
0.1452302486,
-0.3529714346,
0.2826847136,
-0.3914904892,
-0.3975916505,
-0.1084083915,
0.0015290295,
-0.1556138247,
0.7661793232,
0.0824958682,
1.0343940258,
0.1086791605,
-0.4860134721,
0.1273126304,
0.2875293493,
-0.0476348214,
0.0814757496,
-0.4980382919,
0.1165675893,
0.0470150523,
0.4538780749,
-0.8299919963,
-0.0798351616,
0.2414761484,
-0.382101059,
0.4337972999,
-0.2284498513,
-0.7468527555,
-0.356025964,
0.1944213212,
0.2753288746,
0.4956985712,
-0.451032877,
0.4006943107,
0.2984649241,
-0.0790482163,
-0.7290042639,
-0.6044049263,
-0.1242858097,
0.1142250672,
-0.4535590708,
0.6064347029,
-0.1030726209,
0.2413808256,
0.1180763021,
-0.4011495709,
-0.2778838873,
-0.0664889663,
0.2416674346,
0.266053617,
-0.0455797985,
-0.1996519417,
0.4824951291,
-0.3950137198,
-0.0244083572,
-0.5445847511,
0.4641797245,
-0.1914246231,
-0.3547655344,
-0.5430245399,
0.5187990069,
0.3924680352,
-0.2317788005,
0.7510592341,
0.9012820721,
0.0303839017,
-0.1096689329,
-0.4248104095,
-0.1277006716,
-0.4656085074,
0.2566367686,
-0.6963773966,
-0.570088625,
0.14763017,
-0.2259629518,
0.3111465871,
0.3432173431,
0.3484521508,
0.2006985843,
1.3536547422,
0.6895023584,
0.1922839433,
0.6285715699,
-0.1888049692,
0.0742420331,
-0.4728764594,
-0.1668850034,
-0.0819098949,
-0.0117986882,
-0.7658317089,
-0.4323411286,
0.6767153144,
0.2605785728,
-0.3200111985,
0.5018461943,
-0.3745367527,
0.6122453213,
1.0644545555,
0.5268141627,
0.3195482194,
0.2127701044,
-0.782120645,
-0.0627807006,
-0.6650212407,
-0.244429633,
0.9462205768,
0.091117993,
0.4933863282,
0.0144865671,
1.1237900257,
0.1450522691,
-0.250312537,
-0.3724198937,
0.4144390523,
-0.140479818,
-0.4489164948,
-0.2936709523,
-1.0277324915,
-0.7940408587,
0.3774104714,
-0.1307392418,
-0.326489836,
-0.1219110116,
0.355812788,
-0.066496022,
0.3392332792,
-0.5255805254,
0.8976447582,
-0.669295609,
-0.3461045623,
-0.3299532235,
-1.1072690487,
0.3208257258,
-0.4524735808,
0.0773812383,
0.0490546003,
-0.3961300552,
0.3193228543,
-0.1713466197,
0.7556698918,
-0.0650446117,
0.3872434199,
-0.0707351491,
0.2270347774,
0.7545862794,
-0.2145720422,
0.2271049619,
0.43010059,
-0.0105857933,
-0.5681174994,
-0.3438264728,
0.2182500511,
-1.0581706762,
-0.1771217138,
-0.5831785202,
-0.6284371614,
-0.0886155069,
0.4859990478,
0.2082484514,
-0.0276186951,
-0.3401521146,
-0.0133047597,
0.6084523201,
-0.4386948049,
0.2207708359,
0.5605486035,
-0.3800943494,
-0.2895991802,
1.2236869335,
0.0967869088,
0.5379023552,
0.6082602739,
0.3756175637,
-0.4775013626,
-0.3866373599,
-0.4185772538,
0.3095083237,
-0.3737851977,
-0.0365529731,
-0.892709434,
-0.4083899558,
-0.3098069727,
-0.2452336252,
-0.413359046,
-0.2539415359,
0.0142844431,
0.2691924572,
0.314700067,
0.5681189299,
-0.5287243724,
0.6357057691,
-0.6659052968,
0.6097411513,
0.0690106004,
0.4304893017,
-0.5657675266,
-0.412519455,
-0.1526495367,
0.0371816158,
-0.413646698,
-0.8406724334,
0.378344357,
0.1767414361,
0.5437431931,
0.4003955424,
0.1654244661,
0.5082629323,
-0.831993103,
0.2222005278,
0.2827951014,
-0.8090075254,
0.3247787356,
-0.2252134532,
0.2547232509,
0.3989041746,
0.6757503748,
-0.5682982206,
-0.3360754251,
-0.634477973,
-1.1138153076,
1.0035233498,
0.5671231151,
0.0378257558,
0.0206491165,
0.1141630486,
0.0675824806,
0.3650022149,
-0.4229323864,
-0.2122823596,
-0.033926256,
0.0140235042,
0.0533723831,
0.0165523198,
0.1847640425,
0.0040972736,
0.9119267464,
-0.1481779218,
0.4784945548,
-0.053577736,
-0.0819698721,
-0.0041616983,
0.0846306235,
0.3298710585,
0.4300480783,
-0.4061242938,
-0.0909285545,
0.175714463,
-0.3208478391,
0.0288585816,
0.1793921739,
-0.729229331,
0.4111359119,
-0.1220058054,
1.1807049513,
0.6791577339,
-0.4504325092,
0.8560045958,
-0.1197707281,
-0.4111873209,
-0.3998374939,
0.0874399096,
-0.0744798928,
0.4071120322,
-0.113687858,
0.1604636461,
0.0461954288,
-0.0236500222,
0.5658640862,
0.2209249884,
-0.1452320218,
0.1171921119,
0.8837665319,
0.0068699918,
-0.2805380225,
0.4957791865,
-0.2957322299,
-0.7265779376,
0.4452484548,
0.6613703966,
0.7225096226,
-0.3048406839,
0.4934011102,
0.239911437,
0.3992671072,
-0.5194140673,
0.3025136292,
-0.1147296429,
-0.4400548339,
-0.5776908994,
-0.7551699281,
-0.5562326908,
-0.4872858524,
-0.7268671989,
0.2564712167,
-0.1217632145,
-0.1600494534,
-0.1192266122,
0.0374131091,
-0.7778396606,
-0.1513840854,
-0.0659954175,
0.4155525863,
-0.7355203032,
0.610947907,
0.3072162867,
-0.8701220751,
-0.650811255,
-0.0294838063,
-0.1271790117,
-0.9889653325,
0.3596980572,
0.1111516058,
-0.0445973799,
0.2714572549,
-0.6848659515,
-0.8608173132,
0.6695427895,
0.7109541893,
-0.5789964795,
-0.3326641619,
0.1999743581,
0.1483857781,
0.0166855119,
0.1934186369,
0.3581257761,
0.4412009716,
0.0540333129,
-0.9603096843,
-0.2681514919,
0.1349521875,
0.0277267471,
0.4750300348,
-0.6967093349,
0.6742770076,
-0.2441257685,
-0.2102424055,
-0.1676521599,
0.5428487062,
-0.0762745291,
0.2055242211,
0.5563470721,
0.2273074985,
0.4091918468,
0.0841859728,
1.2624791861,
-0.2569057941,
0.4049959183,
1.2065585852,
0.1656970531,
1.0133898258,
0.4319280088,
-0.0405937396,
0.0946934819,
0.786886692,
-0.0363690145,
0.5980111361,
-0.0122934142,
-0.3405468464,
-0.4548372626,
-0.2904733121,
-0.1191501766,
0.1404099911,
0.1412843615,
-0.4309562147,
-0.2753612995,
-0.0831330568,
0.2411019653,
0.0445282459,
-0.0952740833,
0.9526564479,
0.0801737085,
-0.899240613,
0.5374335051,
0.2642611861,
0.3798529208,
-0.7985512018,
-0.2121140659,
-0.2837666571,
0.3496882319,
-0.0319411159,
-0.7094812989,
0.1270315349,
-0.0325575881,
-0.0913948193,
-0.352204591,
0.1193730459,
-0.8286581635,
-0.46156919,
0.4289028049,
0.3688395023,
0.7691165209,
-0.0779666081,
-0.9098036885,
-0.1819287539,
0.0768104643,
-0.1614561379,
0.31908831,
0.5333172679,
-0.2992743552,
0.427572161,
0.8551508784,
0.4585894644,
0.6109981537,
-0.2236635536,
0.5870530009,
-0.4228134751,
-0.9243847728,
-0.5694268346,
0.0414024815,
-0.1552409381,
-0.0867565423,
0.2583245337,
0.5004696846,
1.2491848469,
0.1927248389,
0.927821815,
0.1183701456,
0.2005437911,
-0.5099589229,
0.3449005187,
-0.7373251319,
-0.1449829787,
-0.151676625,
-1.0490236282,
-0.2548429072,
0.9719012976,
-0.2236752063,
-0.0699976981,
1.0344409943,
1.0387738943,
-0.5645526052,
-0.1885189265,
0.3845740855,
0.0140959667,
-0.0092334691,
0.6293305159,
0.1687525809,
-0.3816684186,
1.1240365505,
-0.308794558,
-0.1697117984,
-0.2400059402,
-0.8576651812,
-0.6947922111,
-0.3323656619,
0.1117787734,
-0.3021870255,
0.5322892666,
1.339630723,
0.4958495498,
-0.6054765582,
-0.165407449,
-0.3510310054,
0.0324534476,
-0.6140729189,
-0.150252983,
0.4981638193,
-0.8562915325,
-0.766507566,
0.1385347098,
0.1245361492,
-0.0942260846,
-0.1352666467,
-0.4198772907,
-0.4184437692,
0.0920629352,
0.2319540232,
0.1599710286,
-0.6699807048,
0.2167069614,
-0.2645308673,
-0.2767220736,
0.0194218587,
0.9677672386,
-0.1913399398,
0.9152759314,
0.4367264211,
1.1788401604,
0.9266168475,
0.0203125272,
0.7718989253,
-0.8189326525,
-0.0338512138,
0.2047525346,
0.1104591787,
-0.0191913061,
-0.2534315586,
0.8839190602,
0.4152594507,
-0.6156112552,
-0.7348879576,
0.1218678802,
-0.8379215002,
-0.2084816545,
1.3354744911,
-0.3460140824,
-0.1670807451,
-0.0651994348,
-0.4709893167,
0.6717376113,
-0.6337784529,
0.4531639516,
0.2072097659,
0.0411863849,
-0.0199592076,
-1.1654208899,
0.2807908356,
0.4221662879,
-0.4195447564,
-0.3399070501,
0.2397372425,
-0.060168311,
-0.1571517885,
0.6902394891,
-0.0735535771,
0.0859255418,
0.1956821233,
0.0364202671,
-0.1477121562,
-0.6198525429,
-0.1393387765,
-0.1751334965,
-0.3296417296,
-0.4216217697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12767v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12767v2 | D$^2$TV: Dual Knowledge Distillation and Target-oriented Vision Modeling for Many-to-Many Multimodal Summarization | 2023-05-22T06:47:35 | 2023-10-16T10:04:37 | Yunlong Liang, Fandong Meng, Jiaan Wang, Jinan Xu, Yufeng Chen, Jie Zhou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Many-to-many multimodal summarization (M$^3$S) task aims to generate
summaries in any language with document inputs in any language and the
corresponding image sequence, which essentially comprises multimodal
monolingual summarization (MMS) and multimodal cross-lingual summarization
(MXLS) tasks. Although much work has been devoted to either MMS or MXLS and has
obtained increasing attention in recent years, little research pays attention
to the M$^3$S task. Besides, existing studies mainly focus on 1) utilizing MMS
to enhance MXLS via knowledge distillation without considering the performance
of MMS or 2) improving MMS models by filtering summary-unrelated visual
features with implicit learning or explicitly complex training objectives. In
this paper, we first introduce a general and practical task, i.e., M$^3$S.
Further, we propose a dual knowledge distillation and target-oriented vision
modeling framework for the M$^3$S task. Specifically, the dual knowledge
distillation method guarantees that the knowledge of MMS and MXLS can be
transferred to each other and thus mutually prompt both of them. To offer
target-oriented visual features, a simple yet effective target-oriented
contrastive objective is designed and responsible for discarding needless
visual information. Extensive experiments on the many-to-many setting show the
effectiveness of the proposed approach. Additionally, we will contribute a
many-to-many multimodal summarization (M$^3$Sum) dataset. | [
-0.4284624159,
-0.4603444338,
0.7033789158,
0.1745758951,
-0.4448292553,
-0.0601681955,
-0.0747439042,
-0.2850584388,
0.0738693327,
0.3780232668,
-0.5058156848,
-0.4603240192,
-0.9062002897,
0.1050655544,
-0.1556579769,
1.1390842199,
-0.1798612624,
0.216434449,
-0.1274296045,
-0.0279656723,
-0.331823051,
-0.3815698624,
-0.2845881879,
-0.0807783008,
0.8756289482,
0.6538863778,
0.2595631778,
0.3661673665,
0.6633487344,
0.2540221512,
-0.092214942,
0.5429952145,
-0.783490777,
0.1138021648,
-0.0559286028,
-0.5615316033,
-0.4789740443,
0.0505394898,
0.4620579779,
0.6409130096,
0.095594123,
0.2077475488,
0.5051355362,
0.9834247231,
-0.9078577757,
0.2239854634,
-0.4217446744,
0.1279340684,
-0.0721664876,
-0.2182857096,
-0.2333402187,
0.0529072508,
0.2532316446,
-0.4956823289,
0.1228572279,
-0.0873501524,
0.3228304684,
0.3148519993,
-0.8562873006,
-0.1969131231,
-0.6452326179,
0.9562338591,
-0.3672129512,
0.3128416538,
0.0896106213,
0.6296451688,
0.2137532383,
-0.6020277143,
-0.5359505415,
0.003806497,
-0.1702315062,
0.6208574772,
-0.1974897832,
-0.0175582822,
0.2586179674,
0.2424861044,
-0.3937863708,
-0.1554229558,
-0.5452857018,
0.2121234238,
0.4510699213,
0.3167280257,
-0.2566857934,
-0.1435389519,
-0.8185657859,
0.0992518812,
-0.5646057129,
-0.0836286396,
0.099845089,
-0.0429474562,
-0.3800317943,
0.8704624176,
-0.5328249931,
0.6921592355,
-0.0027245891,
-0.7148416638,
0.1138115898,
-0.7868471742,
-0.1490582973,
-0.2922086418,
0.4997622669,
0.9458290935,
0.1918559372,
0.1867604852,
-0.097110413,
0.0180803109,
-0.0487290248,
-0.7916507125,
-0.0923042595,
0.02440775,
-0.6213744283,
-0.3651310503,
-0.0454532802,
-1.032269001,
-0.4275624156,
-0.5814688802,
0.4578858316,
-0.2990036607,
-0.3947513998,
0.0193512123,
-0.6670773625,
-0.2249870449,
0.6136801243,
-1.0175046921,
0.109530285,
0.4495387971,
0.8326094747,
-0.1113386378,
-0.5976229906,
-0.212496087,
0.805527389,
-0.0720289126,
0.6360973716,
-0.147072956,
-0.3423962593,
-0.3260343373,
-0.3433708847,
-0.0436749645,
-0.259483695,
-0.1541522592,
-0.1575415134,
0.1382752806,
-0.2874601185,
-0.0686544478,
-0.4745763242,
0.5316017866,
-0.5560956597,
0.4309632182,
-0.1054471657,
-0.7820212841,
0.3233421147,
-0.7168140411,
-0.412427187,
-0.5014067888,
-0.1989820898,
-0.311155051,
0.3469143212,
0.2240704745,
0.8396248817,
-0.3663551509,
0.3739818335,
-0.3909742236,
-0.1467723399,
0.0026373072,
-0.7084912062,
0.5950503349,
0.2572776973,
-0.1522466838,
0.1071812809,
-0.5624156594,
-0.5966876149,
0.0008685139,
-0.2282225639,
-0.2039202154,
0.0297121778,
-0.1570644379,
0.550740242,
0.264654398,
-0.2427950352,
0.0964811295,
0.1078618839,
0.1593095809,
0.5561852455,
0.1166391969,
0.3687640131,
-0.5853286386,
0.2087568045,
0.5502462387,
0.3063474596,
-0.447178632,
-0.6489244103,
-0.6801973581,
-0.6494488716,
-0.3312404156,
0.465197593,
-1.1941430569,
-0.2413971424,
-0.4205686748,
-0.4839830399,
-0.0797472224,
0.1940558851,
0.5544172525,
0.6117097735,
0.5284962058,
0.0824997425,
-0.490565598,
-1.1784772873,
0.0900582224,
0.064210169,
-0.131995976,
0.2142146975,
0.5292455554,
0.1085900068,
0.6843916774,
-0.8766118288,
-0.8656085134,
-0.4408310056,
0.1311832666,
0.1010837927,
0.3213802278,
0.7539243698,
-1.0395179987,
-0.4852076173,
-0.1967616081,
-1.08533144,
0.2456913441,
0.164496243,
0.0829118937,
0.024258906,
0.4739106596,
-0.3899743259,
0.5189028978,
0.6448024511,
-0.2387443632,
0.5767884851,
-0.2115217596,
0.5822027922,
-1.4579672813,
0.0682025924,
0.139364332,
0.0097371209,
-0.8042597175,
-0.1394046843,
0.0162198637,
-0.0099595329,
-0.745302856,
0.2653724253,
-0.6579143405,
-0.111951597,
-0.2407213598,
0.2067665607,
0.3919089437,
0.8496345878,
0.1255158186,
0.2667829096,
0.5655342937,
-0.7322219014,
0.5911343694,
0.1396056861,
-0.1495949924,
0.9215763807,
-0.2782029212,
-0.4800750017,
-0.3632104099,
0.132326737,
-1.3306465149,
0.0208203383,
0.2412349284,
-0.3662599325,
0.372384727,
-0.2066490501,
-0.3144064844,
-0.3004318774,
-0.5704072118,
0.5103522539,
0.2590384781,
-0.493393749,
0.8460229039,
0.2857097685,
-0.221746102,
-0.7239204645,
-0.9448145032,
0.1391606927,
-0.4122805595,
-0.725497365,
0.3711320162,
0.0510103256,
-0.2901349068,
-0.0883279368,
0.0039684302,
0.0516043119,
0.0007555652,
0.2437191606,
0.5182569027,
-0.111463286,
-0.068742916,
0.044625517,
-0.3022276163,
-0.1858483255,
-0.1842565984,
0.0660124421,
0.1904559135,
-0.3912728429,
-0.3773362339,
0.647570014,
0.6808952689,
-0.2459330857,
0.5746095181,
0.6407183409,
-0.2221931815,
0.140713796,
-0.7634009123,
-0.2382497489,
-0.3975122869,
0.7652264833,
-0.8459791541,
-0.7553960085,
0.3411868811,
-0.1669679582,
0.1610402316,
0.4392715693,
0.7198492289,
-0.4141815901,
1.0410342216,
0.6711076498,
0.1907537133,
0.5314691067,
-0.4762828648,
0.0311412215,
-1.0935630798,
-0.4907186031,
-0.1397523433,
-0.6073808074,
-0.1244792864,
-0.5794880986,
0.7610314488,
0.0681487322,
0.3367277086,
0.0516826026,
-0.1381564438,
0.4008263946,
0.6378022432,
0.3215487301,
0.5962716341,
-0.0140857827,
-0.1917183101,
-0.0561144762,
-0.7424561977,
-0.2377112657,
1.4010107517,
0.1533629745,
0.7760614753,
0.2952204347,
0.6848634481,
-0.002315677,
0.1939524412,
-0.6531721354,
0.4950809181,
-0.409907043,
-0.524254024,
-0.1933770627,
-0.4120274484,
-0.5107224584,
0.637673676,
-0.2622307539,
-0.3311589956,
0.3343107402,
0.4135056138,
-0.2468816638,
0.5238428712,
-0.9244092703,
0.8094871044,
-0.358288914,
-0.5381692648,
-0.5469933748,
-0.9344025254,
0.8323181868,
0.0047902898,
0.2470919043,
-0.1630476713,
-0.0830983818,
0.6220250726,
-0.0534725636,
0.8856449723,
-0.3600594401,
-0.0788131207,
0.2160572261,
-0.1018071547,
0.2250136286,
0.0239200275,
0.302981019,
0.2776521146,
-0.0969972387,
-0.2176114321,
-0.6297843456,
0.5950827599,
-0.437938422,
-0.6324165463,
-0.3899661601,
-0.6572559476,
-0.0867036209,
0.1413086951,
0.1819613129,
0.5361194611,
-0.0405523479,
0.1082895845,
0.4693545103,
0.148026526,
0.5844832063,
0.6459493041,
-0.2645699084,
-0.4351708293,
0.9774832129,
0.0516839027,
0.5107424855,
0.69280231,
-0.0016030298,
-0.2262372077,
-0.7874936461,
-0.4523712099,
0.0952313915,
-0.7068850398,
-0.3001327515,
-0.5791283846,
0.086695388,
-0.3869922459,
-0.1157070398,
-0.3173382878,
-0.5332986712,
-0.5233494043,
0.0723197162,
0.1116943359,
0.7337667346,
-0.3500396311,
0.2014644146,
-0.7603073716,
1.0751568079,
0.5143942237,
0.2265313417,
-0.0589101762,
-0.3632263243,
-0.359441787,
0.3377340436,
-0.4308644533,
-0.8899491429,
0.1941788793,
0.1390933394,
0.4781336784,
0.7553323507,
-0.1173407137,
0.898748517,
-0.5211481452,
0.6486120224,
0.7446744442,
-0.6629116535,
0.4825501442,
-0.118964836,
0.2236087918,
0.480835557,
0.2915244997,
-0.3969815075,
-0.3167891502,
-0.019641662,
-0.4621734321,
0.8341796994,
0.0563236922,
-0.2374062985,
0.3379008472,
-0.0406958461,
0.1509881318,
0.3495551646,
-0.57337749,
-0.3992548585,
-0.366720438,
-0.3904116452,
-0.4789862931,
-0.6189929843,
-0.2237212956,
-0.0181434713,
0.49928689,
-0.089174971,
-0.0942145884,
0.0766514018,
-0.2098748237,
0.1780216843,
0.1457019448,
0.7701176405,
0.6342020035,
-0.3136650026,
0.4920005798,
-0.0178360716,
-0.4270695746,
0.2428978682,
0.1552355886,
0.0068072667,
-0.2191950828,
0.1407264918,
0.7407506108,
0.2666863203,
-0.4384583235,
0.6146452427,
-0.0170021895,
-0.5533717275,
0.1504705697,
-0.1500413716,
0.1684521288,
0.5766479373,
0.5099332333,
0.4702923,
0.4056203365,
-0.4596745074,
0.1633900404,
0.4017115533,
-0.2838179767,
-0.1926934719,
0.6353284717,
0.3466853499,
0.4599734843,
0.2922536433,
-0.0317327864,
-0.3643750548,
0.3707336485,
0.3955067098,
0.6288794279,
-0.2632539868,
-0.0406410173,
0.2694081664,
0.1804409176,
-0.0434612893,
0.170623675,
-0.2817314863,
-0.4722960591,
-0.2061179727,
-0.4355329573,
-0.2677681744,
-0.2361230403,
-0.5346870422,
0.4682857394,
-0.0809036344,
-0.0598250479,
0.1504772455,
-0.4023806155,
-0.4564509392,
0.2679060996,
0.2208084464,
0.4086765051,
-0.851323843,
0.7087369561,
0.5075909495,
-0.4765754938,
-0.2977811992,
-0.3791396916,
0.3506177962,
-0.8421656489,
0.7392017841,
0.0505471677,
-0.2704678178,
0.0382058769,
-0.2087141722,
-0.8335909843,
1.4781168699,
0.2892897129,
-0.5871446133,
-0.2434506267,
0.1515149325,
0.1001866758,
-0.3953335285,
0.0235090274,
0.3669985533,
0.4857576489,
0.6093677878,
-0.8625946641,
-0.206997171,
-0.344071269,
-0.0386631079,
0.1742888987,
-0.6348258853,
0.9242206216,
-0.7181101441,
-0.0330701694,
-0.2259583324,
0.3870785534,
0.3730179071,
0.5863938928,
0.3408990204,
0.5670717955,
0.0496872663,
-0.1398231387,
0.8248487711,
-0.0861756802,
0.1079003587,
1.3656725883,
-0.3274852037,
0.5948050618,
0.8464161754,
-0.168307364,
-0.0938936695,
0.2461008281,
-0.2290818691,
0.8800079823,
-0.0856436789,
-0.1312084943,
0.0802720189,
0.0244133566,
-0.4216752648,
0.572070539,
0.4592347443,
-0.4344661236,
-0.4084014595,
0.4283050597,
-0.1979495585,
-0.2421618998,
-0.3229200542,
1.1955153942,
0.1126689985,
-0.7120518088,
0.3802063465,
0.0325213522,
0.8134806752,
-0.6860224009,
-0.1537223756,
-0.1135904342,
0.2510733604,
-0.125843361,
-0.744767487,
0.2907428741,
-0.0510323308,
-0.3999620378,
-0.3484944403,
0.503025949,
-0.7012751698,
-0.5391597748,
0.2515826225,
0.6832239032,
0.1254865378,
-0.3634377122,
-0.3259595335,
-0.2786332369,
0.2510580719,
-0.0516105182,
0.2822165787,
0.4268935621,
0.2044216245,
0.6410967708,
0.5072510839,
0.0866234079,
0.0798016936,
0.1062900051,
0.9131609201,
-0.3990551531,
-0.5600233674,
-1.107624054,
0.755035162,
0.0633261502,
-0.0104457056,
0.9634981155,
0.7712084055,
0.5692944527,
-0.350022167,
0.7771268487,
0.149930954,
0.4591859281,
-0.7302491069,
0.6635068655,
-0.9429523945,
0.1178994104,
-0.3446221948,
-1.0811719894,
-0.3262734115,
0.2009434849,
-0.0924997553,
-0.0180130843,
0.7982251644,
0.677614212,
-0.1784642041,
-0.1498972923,
0.6126877666,
0.0398453288,
0.1989863068,
0.9323920608,
1.0644621849,
-0.3066969812,
0.7972162962,
-0.4044161141,
-0.4913699627,
-0.449434787,
-0.7088367343,
-0.9055100083,
-0.6650564075,
-0.2201619744,
-0.0238712318,
-0.0406538025,
0.3902198076,
0.7765609622,
-0.5863159299,
-0.2702181637,
0.278904587,
0.2081001997,
-0.4079174995,
-0.0978817791,
0.2641652822,
-0.0072469725,
-0.8383017182,
0.226430282,
0.7480822206,
0.5613556504,
-0.2598944604,
-0.0632021278,
-0.3257195652,
-0.4239221811,
0.8751901388,
-0.2359634042,
-0.7773554325,
0.2276481092,
-0.0757148862,
-0.04812124,
0.0369742662,
0.7776244879,
-0.5986219049,
0.6292019486,
0.3423595726,
-0.0807545409,
0.8085616231,
-0.0797892585,
0.5346903801,
-0.8107530475,
0.2984265089,
0.0159264784,
0.5531641245,
0.2569055557,
-0.06739939,
0.4480911791,
0.2832394838,
-0.1112126857,
-0.4497402012,
0.341989249,
-1.1484179497,
-0.2968332171,
1.0074820518,
-0.2252897471,
0.0417485982,
-0.1104401723,
-0.4899584353,
0.4468865097,
-0.1700569838,
0.7087062597,
0.4296763539,
-0.0790230632,
-0.2073035836,
-0.3018680513,
0.4506229758,
0.1684770882,
-0.8582808375,
0.0872752368,
0.8146803975,
0.1839833409,
0.308826685,
0.4534781873,
-0.1402651221,
0.3228912652,
0.1154744774,
-0.1291759163,
-0.5518455505,
-0.6785398722,
-0.2066816241,
0.4171043634,
-0.3069998622,
-0.4404253066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12766v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12766v2 | Explaining Emergent In-Context Learning as Kernel Regression | 2023-05-22T06:45:02 | 2023-10-05T16:04:43 | Chi Han, Ziqi Wang, Han Zhao, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have initiated a paradigm shift in transfer
learning. In contrast to the classic pretraining-then-finetuning procedure, in
order to use LLMs for downstream prediction tasks, one only needs to provide a
few demonstrations, known as in-context examples, without adding more or
updating existing model parameters. This in-context learning (ICL) capability
of LLMs is intriguing, and it is not yet fully understood how pretrained LLMs
acquire such capabilities. In this paper, we investigate the reason why a
transformer-based language model can accomplish in-context learning after
pre-training on a general language corpus by proposing one hypothesis that LLMs
can simulate kernel regression with internal representations when faced with
in-context examples. More concretely, we first prove that Bayesian inference on
in-context prompts can be asymptotically understood as kernel regression $\hat
y = \sum_i y_i K(x, x_i)/\sum_i K(x, x_i)$ as the number of in-context
demonstrations grows. Then, we empirically investigate the in-context behaviors
of language models. We find that during ICL, the attention and hidden features
in LLMs match the behaviors of a kernel regression. Finally, our theory
provides insights into multiple phenomena observed in the ICL field: why
retrieving demonstrative samples similar to test samples can help, why ICL
performance is sensitive to the output formats, and why ICL accuracy benefits
from selecting in-distribution and representative samples. | [
-0.3417944908,
-0.7886003852,
0.7663043737,
0.1563976407,
-0.0885427445,
-0.0523509569,
-0.3584749699,
-0.3840011954,
-0.4709764123,
0.3291662335,
-0.4928185344,
-0.1859735399,
-0.5430287719,
-0.0333286896,
-0.7784073353,
1.0783263445,
0.0304695014,
-0.0376458652,
-0.4210008383,
0.2960016727,
-0.4234686494,
-0.3859582841,
-0.557696104,
-0.3776060045,
0.3301720917,
0.4837509692,
0.244318977,
0.2194515169,
0.2605474591,
0.1889849752,
0.0545818172,
-0.3476473689,
-0.3959255517,
0.190527916,
0.2015025169,
-0.5919104815,
0.2083429992,
0.0007813418,
0.9390638471,
0.8845104575,
0.1162675694,
0.1179769039,
0.6892917156,
0.2459008098,
-0.6851553321,
0.1630065292,
-0.8404220343,
-0.1400951147,
-0.0341261029,
0.0503524318,
-0.9041184187,
-0.1479385197,
0.43423599,
-0.2393815219,
0.1349852085,
-0.3946467042,
0.7151824236,
0.1474512815,
-0.6026862264,
-0.4126975834,
-0.9400908351,
0.808639586,
-0.5351515412,
0.4409106672,
0.2772104144,
0.5042494535,
-0.1134680882,
-1.0122289658,
-0.4767763019,
-0.4863779545,
-0.4102131724,
-0.0000798588,
-0.1860155463,
-0.1331214607,
0.3707861304,
0.0209905226,
-0.0024636539,
0.2576117218,
-0.1946979761,
0.0375663117,
0.1917935759,
-0.0881959498,
0.0568159856,
0.2151724249,
-0.5629577637,
-0.1897813231,
-0.9723244905,
0.521749258,
-0.1103949025,
0.4863657057,
-0.2163203061,
0.0227764957,
0.3801044524,
0.7553460598,
0.0917101353,
-0.0982698128,
0.0550723858,
0.0448049344,
-0.4117320478,
0.1186144054,
0.4193317592,
-0.1484716833,
0.1219404861,
-0.223276034,
-0.2580237687,
-0.1801045835,
0.3616915941,
-0.7866586447,
0.0869177282,
0.021925075,
-0.3639352024,
-0.1963322163,
0.2169151902,
-0.6931522489,
0.012021644,
-0.4775436223,
0.8251231909,
-0.4478626847,
-0.1450379491,
-0.1677109301,
0.1066290587,
0.4040775597,
0.3879075646,
-0.8544434309,
0.4182181656,
0.5956842899,
0.6008239388,
-0.2528144121,
-0.3084000647,
-0.6015428901,
0.1296562552,
-0.3203597963,
0.7119207978,
-0.5834390521,
-0.313696593,
0.3138560653,
-0.0520826876,
-0.2288383394,
-0.5470917225,
0.0503526218,
-0.5109621882,
0.0549290739,
-0.2415659279,
-0.4899454117,
-0.2121628076,
-0.1164434627,
-0.2344833165,
0.9814913869,
0.139010638,
-0.5376461148,
0.6919588447,
-0.5944544077,
-0.3834202886,
0.1576489359,
-0.2179573923,
-0.2795392871,
0.2876262069,
-0.0123533988,
0.7612578869,
-0.1658530235,
0.3954937458,
-0.2149495184,
-0.3906190693,
0.6090540886,
-0.3607437909,
0.7994309068,
0.3060905933,
-0.4107404649,
0.0532050468,
-0.4126328528,
-0.2552802265,
-0.2178227603,
-0.323621124,
-0.4521439672,
0.1184863672,
-0.0915589631,
0.1520062983,
-0.1384730786,
-0.4683436751,
0.045595102,
-0.2686716318,
0.4200647473,
0.6948712468,
-0.1698428541,
0.6719501615,
-0.1088839397,
0.3922143877,
0.1926210523,
0.1120520756,
-0.5245261192,
-0.2758000195,
-0.5354412794,
-0.4300380349,
0.1072460115,
0.1910468191,
-0.5206882954,
0.0388190709,
-0.1581335366,
-0.1868300885,
-0.4380758703,
-0.0377589874,
0.2626259029,
0.9081260562,
0.3633521199,
0.2018686384,
-0.4019803107,
-1.0084497929,
-0.1234190166,
-0.0146597084,
-0.1832643598,
0.1864128262,
0.4318016768,
-0.3600572348,
1.3116316795,
-0.2108310014,
-0.0302535333,
-0.5581519008,
0.0638749897,
0.3255741298,
0.3192923963,
0.5792309046,
-0.8588730693,
-0.6932726502,
-0.0383617468,
-0.5712979436,
-0.3285766542,
-0.1821621954,
0.2749013305,
0.1566920877,
0.9912705421,
-0.2653098106,
0.4383888245,
0.4705987275,
-0.2267215997,
0.5104538798,
-0.3055456877,
-0.3554501235,
-1.1240714788,
-0.119108595,
0.0645273253,
-0.1551035643,
-0.7853915691,
0.0748011321,
0.3128147721,
0.1436242908,
-0.5467510819,
0.5219673514,
-0.2874173224,
-0.150919348,
-0.3248164356,
-0.1609303951,
-0.392994076,
0.228861481,
-0.067267403,
0.8394544125,
0.8880315423,
-0.9200049639,
-0.3394788802,
0.116863139,
-0.4153878391,
0.1738739908,
-0.3019081354,
-0.2000616938,
-0.4606554508,
0.4319138229,
-1.2212225199,
-0.1078147516,
-0.1118516847,
-0.1546729505,
0.4953653216,
-0.1741136014,
-0.2697277963,
-0.0607723817,
0.0944356397,
0.3663649261,
0.7967591286,
-0.935262084,
0.5989042521,
0.3413335979,
0.1723031998,
-0.4669654965,
-0.6682273149,
-0.0756721497,
-0.6244725585,
-0.293050319,
0.5236788392,
-0.1202438325,
-0.5388796926,
-0.1815778762,
0.1661049575,
-0.0316784196,
0.2677175403,
0.2629704177,
0.198456496,
-0.3644579649,
0.3277432323,
0.0032320488,
-0.1232177019,
0.3320203424,
-0.3208394945,
0.3333992958,
-0.1912407726,
-0.2530792654,
-0.2973071635,
0.2171076089,
0.4307784736,
0.2657773197,
0.5281493664,
0.5181881189,
-0.267228514,
-0.3886654079,
-0.4645433426,
-0.5341070294,
-0.4321220219,
0.3035481572,
-0.4216861129,
-1.0161254406,
0.5703585148,
-0.3192610145,
-0.0345607549,
0.3868335187,
0.5517832041,
-0.165204674,
0.7796122432,
0.8145014048,
0.1938835979,
0.6085304618,
-0.249764964,
0.0684105605,
-0.9876852632,
-0.2463240921,
-0.4242102802,
-0.2087042034,
-0.6910864711,
-0.0479793735,
0.5151603818,
0.1055878848,
-0.4585555792,
0.2334990948,
-0.0378473625,
0.5558325648,
0.5522049665,
0.1211072654,
0.0197985768,
-0.038068492,
-0.334250927,
-0.0075796,
-0.6801115274,
-0.4289748371,
0.903547883,
0.3693306148,
0.8447732329,
0.0221913755,
0.4507830143,
0.0840797648,
0.8008979559,
-0.6820312738,
0.3334041238,
-0.1330910027,
-0.2990432382,
-0.1735396236,
-0.0936617106,
-0.9388639331,
0.2791347802,
-0.1363716722,
-1.1216188669,
0.1685962975,
0.2324794084,
-0.336393863,
0.2493231446,
-0.7472203374,
0.7379212379,
-0.0315204449,
-0.5550603867,
-0.0709987655,
-0.8065039515,
0.3197382092,
-0.2985213101,
0.3119150996,
0.3531338871,
0.1734515578,
0.4787218571,
-0.135565877,
1.1312724352,
-0.1946006268,
-0.1605513543,
0.2970305979,
0.2319475114,
0.4054139555,
0.1155573353,
0.1630223095,
0.0041303523,
-0.160281077,
-0.0532717332,
-0.6061088443,
0.5723280311,
-0.7440313697,
-0.6426571608,
-0.2410320193,
-0.5248021483,
-0.2814422548,
-0.1848827302,
0.5333631039,
0.4849762321,
-0.0128905457,
0.5069622397,
0.762098074,
-0.2421620637,
0.9037024379,
0.3874383271,
-0.4343824685,
0.1832979321,
0.4682131112,
0.0883806795,
0.5059021115,
0.6471771598,
0.5048213005,
-0.317514956,
-0.3852916658,
-0.0679802597,
0.0674272999,
-0.7805451155,
-0.0312575847,
-0.7200475335,
-0.3532781899,
-0.167958945,
-0.4576503336,
-0.0106251528,
0.0941986516,
-0.2506906688,
-0.0711195767,
0.0179739036,
1.0209727287,
-0.0104993964,
0.7485311627,
-0.609506011,
-0.2799675465,
0.5599916577,
0.1100859568,
0.3843657076,
-0.8886201978,
-0.424192518,
0.0284702294,
-0.337433666,
-0.8174551725,
0.4627369046,
0.1677902639,
0.6604498029,
0.5340799093,
-0.2665489912,
0.6894920468,
-0.4360663891,
0.7445588708,
-0.1379408389,
-0.9897964597,
0.3377993107,
-0.3477135599,
0.3802397847,
0.3140919805,
0.4927897751,
-0.243893519,
-0.4980324805,
-0.617405951,
-0.7281323075,
0.7205591798,
-0.0908617973,
0.2829878628,
0.0740164146,
0.5239338875,
0.5174767971,
0.0037352035,
-0.9181468487,
0.0779921561,
0.0130964424,
0.004457525,
-0.3051807582,
-0.5049976707,
0.1879978627,
-0.4942663014,
0.4232332706,
-0.3017016649,
0.3800086081,
0.0486155264,
-0.4302515388,
0.0799478069,
0.1755554229,
0.6830662489,
0.7415109277,
-0.2993087471,
0.4266715348,
0.3547129929,
-0.3379601836,
0.0174086131,
-0.2114156634,
-0.1214871779,
-0.2207134664,
0.4971314073,
0.8505923152,
0.5708729029,
-0.4668866098,
0.6013267636,
0.0188062973,
0.0246473942,
-0.6523587108,
-0.0784483254,
-0.0592692122,
0.2644805908,
0.8691043854,
-0.0169220921,
0.0580777116,
-0.6257029772,
0.4184542894,
0.5603970289,
-0.7197567821,
-0.5962324142,
0.6721832156,
-0.2674096525,
-0.2416941822,
0.7007151842,
0.1463241726,
-0.3515206873,
0.5493142009,
1.2248473167,
1.0487323999,
-0.2489770502,
0.0793049634,
0.2865331173,
0.1084295958,
0.0125210136,
-0.1942749321,
-0.337116152,
-0.8561335802,
-0.6355638504,
-0.7663357258,
-0.2058003247,
0.3370049894,
-0.6422519684,
0.3884937465,
0.0802117065,
0.1126526818,
-0.1736402959,
-0.65675807,
-0.7738829851,
0.0452657789,
0.221546635,
0.9117934704,
-1.0252015591,
0.9488227367,
0.4072302878,
-0.1892156154,
-0.6235547662,
0.3619887829,
-0.3631606698,
-0.879455924,
1.1808036566,
0.3738845289,
0.0603993163,
0.1783278286,
-0.7005589604,
-0.9169656038,
0.9202844501,
0.5986887217,
-0.3819762766,
-0.021635659,
0.1419020742,
0.3702270687,
-0.9069949985,
0.4399703443,
0.532789886,
0.2826358974,
0.1743061393,
-0.6482435465,
0.00949883,
0.256886214,
-0.0212887432,
0.1271812171,
-0.2422785014,
0.9751878381,
-0.4278489351,
-0.0597954355,
-0.2970183194,
0.6623846292,
0.0144307837,
0.2052210569,
0.5265874267,
0.1906670779,
0.1934677809,
-0.035848327,
1.2941087484,
-0.1182010025,
0.1393780559,
0.9218722582,
-0.1409731805,
0.8635781407,
0.7701448798,
-0.1155002862,
0.6828151345,
0.6397770643,
0.362911135,
0.6914859414,
0.0230759643,
-0.3124661446,
-0.3212693036,
0.0064049982,
-0.0708049908,
0.5946833491,
0.5766066909,
-0.4843261838,
-0.5609510541,
0.5094391108,
-0.0832067207,
-0.0831963122,
-0.2545958459,
0.9091506004,
0.2039418221,
-0.6708553433,
0.2514035404,
-0.5607877374,
0.5293081999,
-0.7916117907,
-0.1079937145,
0.0159463007,
0.3020263314,
0.078444168,
-0.7476000786,
0.4155180454,
-0.355912447,
-0.0528212078,
-0.6229165792,
0.4958386719,
-0.3542535007,
-0.3510417938,
0.4333107173,
0.5189697146,
0.0867463425,
0.0033530057,
-0.2014649361,
-0.0877901316,
-0.0893093422,
-0.1621696651,
0.8157798648,
0.4495081306,
-0.2286506295,
0.6115362048,
0.4585925341,
-0.1247516498,
-0.0743963867,
-0.0786287785,
0.7886504531,
-0.2972153723,
-0.5072485209,
-1.2620266676,
0.6261308789,
0.3096928298,
-0.1981042027,
0.7533456087,
0.4094905257,
0.9765404463,
-0.2544983029,
0.7762473226,
0.0298679303,
0.3212283254,
-0.5798640251,
0.5650724769,
-0.3617806137,
0.1471214443,
-0.1596159935,
-0.7881207466,
-0.3182065785,
0.4793027043,
-0.3666154444,
-0.0436633341,
0.6983278394,
0.5986157656,
-0.1848383248,
-0.134867087,
0.5059266686,
0.4193603396,
0.3841277659,
0.3343598247,
1.0144598484,
-0.1005513221,
0.2692130804,
-0.1100163013,
-0.3890365064,
-0.2472469211,
-1.0299803019,
-0.6286402345,
-1.126473546,
-0.0142330928,
-0.3453062475,
-0.184561193,
1.0234181881,
0.6696690321,
-0.6773937345,
-0.6719691157,
-0.1762828082,
-0.0741411597,
-0.3386058211,
-0.3039807379,
0.3759589195,
-0.8454478979,
-0.5611957312,
0.4474368989,
0.106657058,
0.2012490332,
-0.1714104861,
0.1378911734,
-0.0620097779,
-0.1524167359,
0.8925695419,
0.0752157047,
-0.6556079388,
-0.3906445801,
-0.0615147762,
0.1045067832,
0.1083566919,
0.9734657407,
-1.2959035635,
0.316223681,
0.1892983913,
0.7426569462,
0.6034402251,
-0.3066790402,
0.6664839983,
-0.7248185277,
0.1787440926,
0.0481041409,
0.3648982346,
0.211367771,
-0.2451445013,
0.1816472262,
0.0131979669,
-0.5574102402,
-0.8979788423,
0.4163145721,
-0.6077727675,
-0.4368887246,
1.2665299177,
0.0583679639,
-0.2855900526,
-0.0528972298,
0.0653165355,
0.1501903981,
-0.238878116,
1.0417255163,
0.4718894064,
-0.3713138402,
-0.1060877442,
-0.6121817827,
0.7449270487,
0.1128027365,
-0.5661741495,
0.1469144523,
0.0438815989,
0.2524307072,
0.0493506938,
0.2645015419,
0.1551759839,
0.0114461239,
-0.3519204557,
-0.2589364946,
0.1895801127,
-0.4298208654,
-0.4906313419,
0.3104238212,
0.0510792956,
-0.0694363788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12761v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12761v1 | Enhancing Cross-lingual Natural Language Inference by Soft Prompting with Multilingual Verbalizer | 2023-05-22T06:31:29 | 2023-05-22T06:31:29 | Shuang Li, Xuming Hu, Aiwei Liu, Yawen Yang, Fukun Ma, Philip S. Yu, Lijie Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Cross-lingual natural language inference is a fundamental problem in
cross-lingual language understanding. Many recent works have used prompt
learning to address the lack of annotated parallel corpora in XNLI. However,
these methods adopt discrete prompting by simply translating the templates to
the target language and need external expert knowledge to design the templates.
Besides, discrete prompts of human-designed template words are not trainable
vectors and can not be migrated to target languages in the inference stage
flexibly. In this paper, we propose a novel Soft prompt learning framework with
the Multilingual Verbalizer (SoftMV) for XNLI. SoftMV first constructs
cloze-style question with soft prompts for the input sample. Then we leverage
bilingual dictionaries to generate an augmented multilingual question for the
original question. SoftMV adopts a multilingual verbalizer to align the
representations of original and augmented multilingual questions into the same
semantic space with consistency regularization. Experimental results on XNLI
demonstrate that SoftMV can achieve state-of-the-art performance and
significantly outperform the previous methods under the few-shot and full-shot
cross-lingual transfer settings. | [
-0.4374693334,
-0.7558413148,
0.3615259528,
0.2751321197,
-0.1432811916,
-0.0194082949,
-0.6022639275,
-0.0615000613,
0.1415812224,
0.0702508837,
-0.7956269383,
-0.4472127557,
-0.1424811333,
0.531095624,
0.2616896629,
0.8955931067,
0.0954466462,
0.1997365654,
0.1615598351,
-0.2609881461,
-0.6435859799,
-0.1550203413,
-0.8354439735,
-0.1097874269,
0.7363653183,
0.5137833953,
0.6228701472,
0.0142736183,
-0.7218829989,
0.4210638106,
-0.1062928289,
0.350802958,
-0.1506222188,
0.0832547769,
-0.265316695,
-0.6337608099,
-0.0221019257,
-0.1137768477,
0.798581779,
0.9098775983,
0.0418442562,
-0.1795481443,
-0.0000669881,
0.2663834691,
-0.5668377876,
0.1915757358,
-0.4897445142,
0.2276319265,
-0.0111472718,
0.0876254141,
-0.4518183172,
-0.3387474418,
0.0083579328,
-0.8285503983,
0.2176267505,
-0.0038003656,
0.519340992,
0.0295314826,
-0.493065238,
-0.1686998606,
-0.3160409927,
0.8915999532,
-0.4878309667,
0.6364399195,
0.230687052,
0.3960233033,
0.0457841456,
-0.4712409377,
-0.69832623,
-0.3632052243,
-0.0923193991,
0.2096490711,
0.1224818453,
-0.0514261574,
0.1586442888,
0.0026194942,
-0.878693521,
0.3116526008,
-0.1554673463,
-0.310623914,
0.4107911587,
-0.0861139819,
0.4109590352,
-0.4278694987,
-0.5105877519,
-0.1731314361,
-0.4754458666,
0.2802356482,
0.2579484582,
0.562525332,
-0.0057217614,
0.1381727755,
-0.0329929888,
0.7408371568,
0.1252614409,
-0.1330029815,
0.4401909411,
-0.5875552893,
0.0289302878,
0.4364629984,
0.7415976524,
0.2089071721,
0.5145868659,
-0.1348030716,
0.0312900655,
-0.2204945385,
-0.2459985614,
-0.4716493189,
0.2591653466,
0.3664435148,
-0.0873336568,
0.1495731324,
0.1288926303,
-0.8533103466,
-0.2887396514,
-0.3266525269,
0.1052952334,
-0.4563984573,
-0.5802708864,
0.0666158274,
-0.1565399766,
0.4437776804,
0.208528772,
-0.8331679106,
0.0478202738,
0.725666225,
0.6507118344,
-0.0057188915,
-0.6205897927,
-1.0014237165,
0.0725194812,
-0.3398839533,
0.5754679441,
-0.3401927054,
-0.4671100676,
0.1935650408,
0.1981780082,
-0.3317371607,
-0.3088236153,
0.4634954035,
-0.4396226704,
0.7041501403,
-0.2882317603,
-0.3062364459,
-0.2198910117,
0.4768846333,
-0.5876429081,
0.9897767305,
-0.0002144686,
-0.5497457981,
0.5035486221,
-0.2883305252,
-0.4227407277,
0.1853823811,
-0.3012260199,
-0.0132268229,
0.0488144271,
0.4510634243,
0.2616739571,
-0.0649684221,
0.6509767771,
-0.1723890603,
-0.1307356954,
0.2084111571,
-0.6073557138,
0.9086946845,
-0.0853296593,
-0.4077137113,
0.3892454505,
-0.8260297179,
0.2574068606,
-0.126556769,
-0.1066388264,
-0.4802846909,
-0.51271981,
0.1929783523,
0.4073268175,
0.0186591707,
-0.7308782339,
0.1207230017,
-0.5989714265,
0.1624696851,
0.681633234,
-0.14980115,
0.6000497937,
-0.1200355887,
0.682452023,
-0.0372938029,
0.070441924,
-0.2427188903,
-0.6801481843,
-0.3290171325,
-0.4080629051,
0.4446632862,
0.9862541556,
-1.1839869022,
0.1588116437,
-0.2615662813,
-0.0878360197,
-0.5860742927,
0.4398422539,
0.5780593157,
0.6085987687,
0.3077911735,
0.212778911,
-0.3605035245,
-0.6010777354,
-0.082887128,
-0.052229654,
-0.1584769487,
0.2885212898,
0.1633179933,
0.032847885,
0.9477035403,
-0.1464965343,
-0.2054977268,
-0.6782023311,
0.4413308501,
0.3264914155,
0.3304864168,
0.4964800477,
-0.9706073999,
-0.6671516895,
0.0799492151,
-0.6462221742,
-0.4456778467,
-0.3352143466,
-0.1336806118,
0.2819008529,
0.4428937137,
-0.6096404791,
0.0303116199,
0.3316365182,
-0.3682058454,
0.5933774114,
-0.3499971926,
0.1239260137,
-1.1309167147,
0.0847476125,
-0.0441973843,
-0.225896433,
-0.7876062393,
-0.1042543128,
0.1190450415,
-0.1967049688,
-0.8782680631,
1.0496050119,
-0.5959355831,
0.2193305194,
-0.0152872754,
0.3650713861,
0.2834183872,
0.5904607177,
0.3828384578,
0.7244274616,
0.6007481813,
-0.5076218843,
0.2180238813,
0.3390160799,
-0.0508925579,
0.7681190372,
-0.7513120174,
0.0572620779,
-0.3422308266,
0.3390694559,
-0.9459553957,
0.0983483493,
0.2797047198,
-0.3400087357,
0.4496669471,
-0.3324713409,
-0.3241356611,
-0.0607202873,
-0.5705074072,
0.5008655787,
0.2888549566,
-0.629141748,
0.767944634,
-0.1274500042,
-0.3698849082,
-0.727806747,
-0.662180841,
0.2106427699,
-0.0268307626,
-0.8476148248,
0.1317482144,
-0.2356007546,
-0.2468406111,
-0.2030034661,
0.2531946003,
-0.1564431489,
-0.2185480595,
0.0363212265,
0.4042609632,
-0.4666191339,
0.0209645946,
0.2836977541,
-0.3853288889,
0.0097947875,
-0.4533389211,
0.2255327553,
-0.1291505545,
-0.2343499959,
-0.3761405647,
0.7955314517,
0.3595534265,
-0.3397625983,
0.6492891312,
0.9404344559,
-0.1304530799,
-0.2347434461,
-0.5237498879,
-0.1581737697,
-0.4831926525,
-0.0651271045,
-0.7475749254,
-0.7220603228,
0.4060302973,
0.0162181426,
0.0635372177,
0.0174808893,
0.4278321564,
0.4955513477,
1.2022148371,
0.2127862275,
0.0470817797,
0.3727946877,
-0.1453489512,
-0.1824747175,
-0.3896760046,
-0.013651819,
-0.336802125,
0.0255507808,
-0.5452684164,
-0.3990715146,
0.3592897654,
-0.1686145514,
0.0311703235,
-0.0379492305,
-0.0652971789,
0.3326924145,
0.772674799,
-0.0236929059,
0.1833372414,
-0.1153729409,
-0.5865809917,
-0.1294766963,
-0.8947703838,
-0.2230070084,
0.2871501148,
-0.0452098325,
0.4427526593,
0.1455677003,
0.6676604152,
-0.1123939678,
-0.0024999136,
-0.6673942804,
0.5399962068,
-0.0121866092,
-0.5086039305,
-0.2944370508,
-0.5228629112,
-1.1218440533,
0.5528509021,
-0.1147070974,
-0.4764660001,
0.4683208764,
-0.0187104046,
-0.5295820832,
0.0923494622,
-0.9575127363,
1.092155695,
-0.1527176648,
-0.5833280683,
0.0723824874,
-0.8145560026,
0.2763123214,
0.1352328062,
0.4365243316,
-0.0188470799,
-0.2659089267,
0.3882773817,
-0.4909726381,
1.1663860083,
-0.5057912469,
-0.2670490742,
0.4137941897,
-0.0559351854,
0.3235395849,
0.538371861,
-0.2460765094,
0.116387628,
-0.0747369528,
-0.4289263785,
-0.904878974,
0.6971085668,
-0.4023824334,
-0.56271559,
-0.410048455,
-0.5335819125,
-0.2985115945,
0.3226067126,
0.2592124045,
0.6879823804,
-0.2516626418,
-0.349960655,
0.7126669884,
-0.4197496474,
0.4955250919,
0.7591977119,
0.002079977,
-0.5719454885,
1.0878812075,
0.0768780708,
0.1840895712,
0.5459403992,
0.6225667596,
-0.6130865812,
-0.1633912325,
-0.9488229156,
0.4075783789,
-0.6272504926,
-0.0038747394,
-0.5155563354,
0.1494212598,
-0.5895662308,
-0.2982057631,
-0.112928167,
-0.3589141965,
-0.1834381521,
-0.0991215184,
0.2402729541,
0.3912867308,
-0.2918667197,
-0.0187976323,
-0.9849801064,
0.4266715348,
0.3937008083,
-0.0027941214,
-0.2660159469,
-0.3673794866,
0.1695896983,
-0.0548092276,
0.3315247893,
-0.8638045788,
0.2249626964,
0.5300335884,
0.5339348912,
0.4150145054,
0.2438061833,
0.5401713848,
-0.763233006,
0.7273009419,
0.2391557693,
-0.8867052794,
0.4690847993,
-0.0808091536,
0.7198970914,
0.7098251581,
0.5069192052,
-0.8587152958,
-0.199426502,
-0.3639314175,
-0.7744999528,
0.5110817552,
-0.3186846972,
0.2366924882,
-0.270352751,
0.081636399,
0.5834074616,
0.099511005,
-0.499955982,
-0.1439878494,
-0.3234095573,
-0.3000900447,
0.0348580219,
-0.1500979066,
0.1649205685,
-0.2521316111,
0.5759550929,
-0.6259794235,
-0.2221291959,
0.2936299741,
-0.4555806816,
0.1770479828,
0.5912273526,
0.5230798125,
0.5691089034,
0.1246501654,
0.2157799304,
0.5051913261,
-0.1592875272,
0.2268814892,
0.3200417459,
-0.3115179837,
0.3388539255,
0.3264380693,
0.8222808242,
0.6149591208,
-0.6897552609,
0.6676467657,
-0.3359848559,
-0.1709312797,
-0.1629743278,
-0.1494279802,
-0.1875551343,
0.0888775513,
0.2772847116,
-0.2307718843,
0.0470185615,
-0.3860583603,
0.232481271,
0.4083017111,
-0.4020827115,
-0.5195106268,
0.5996381044,
0.1616953462,
-0.1681382954,
0.4911766648,
-0.5730779767,
-0.6281325817,
0.14510189,
0.3871173263,
0.6539237499,
-0.3866205513,
0.5031066537,
0.4791014194,
0.1463207901,
0.1669192016,
0.6174819469,
-0.3618575931,
-0.5491299629,
-0.7487165928,
-0.2344586104,
-0.4378426671,
-0.1786164641,
-0.5374039412,
0.3181372285,
-0.2233585417,
0.1046768799,
-0.1273506433,
-0.0172304232,
-0.4971454144,
0.1240339279,
0.5077930689,
1.1619971991,
-0.9660269022,
0.7382355928,
0.6870541573,
-0.3702080548,
-0.682772398,
-0.3584607244,
0.06163124,
-0.7396267653,
0.4734346867,
0.3906748593,
-0.1124899983,
-0.010089851,
-0.2476434559,
-0.469558686,
0.6436367035,
0.5152230263,
-0.242601648,
-0.0617724359,
0.2476580292,
0.2204356641,
0.0423290469,
0.5938449502,
0.3418304324,
0.7229731679,
0.1433369517,
-0.7721425891,
0.2456277609,
-0.3094215989,
0.0607340634,
0.0925143659,
-0.342520833,
0.5165891647,
-0.3628977835,
-0.2455526888,
-0.0050484203,
1.0389108658,
0.3616676629,
0.4688765705,
0.9428291321,
0.0525891669,
0.8929589987,
0.1564513445,
0.9093604088,
-0.2283584625,
-0.2132846266,
1.1326504946,
-0.5071437359,
0.669555366,
0.5388786197,
0.2965741456,
0.6720415354,
0.473754257,
0.1609242409,
0.2518050075,
-0.0077104815,
-0.5917280316,
-0.1851374507,
-0.3896189332,
-0.1813292503,
0.3100315332,
0.3759470582,
0.0448370762,
-0.4028096199,
0.4515733719,
0.1490285397,
0.0444502085,
-0.1700021923,
0.7310442924,
0.0563252456,
-1.0459599495,
0.7507835031,
-0.2251566201,
0.8918171525,
-0.9356999993,
-0.1694605649,
-0.2974020839,
0.0284471642,
-0.0798534155,
-0.6942566633,
0.0601301789,
-0.1512109637,
-0.014414167,
-0.4617833197,
0.5486909747,
-0.8456952572,
-0.5095593333,
0.3759930134,
0.8007278442,
0.1797527969,
-0.0970044881,
-0.9990932345,
-0.2509305775,
-0.1522898972,
-0.3134607375,
0.2488576621,
0.6661509871,
-0.2440597117,
0.3907013535,
0.5519173145,
-0.0696793199,
0.2864677012,
0.6169573665,
0.6166904569,
-0.5175558329,
-0.7440699339,
-0.6187108159,
0.6398026347,
-0.0154904062,
-0.5598940253,
0.8933598399,
0.2897599936,
0.7547096014,
-0.0972347781,
0.680149436,
-0.0343432017,
0.2786981463,
-0.6001928449,
0.3657754958,
-0.4904778302,
-0.1945345104,
0.0341101028,
-0.5804212689,
-0.282218188,
0.3301985264,
-0.2410683632,
0.0647227243,
0.6859482527,
1.0677241087,
-0.1956176311,
-0.0227521565,
0.4233932793,
0.0363467894,
0.0504387431,
0.5360605717,
0.6993240714,
-0.126648277,
0.6989700198,
-0.3634563982,
-0.3056551516,
0.1478153169,
-0.9283797145,
-0.9570199251,
-0.5189054608,
-0.455681324,
-0.2883270979,
-0.0253016688,
1.1588973999,
0.7325700521,
-0.9558320045,
-0.1564072967,
0.0877756998,
0.4880922437,
-0.4104000628,
-0.2601676285,
0.3080274165,
-0.7150677443,
-1.0117748976,
0.8524087071,
-0.0223750398,
-0.1868447512,
-0.385079205,
-0.0182159543,
-0.5143780708,
-0.0891441405,
0.5635026693,
0.567394495,
-0.6302646995,
-0.0258061364,
0.1104265675,
0.0454398245,
0.1403089315,
0.8424535394,
-0.9328234196,
0.4802009463,
0.6184919477,
0.6310020089,
0.1278807223,
-0.1298184246,
0.8013626933,
-1.2525013685,
0.3682964146,
-0.0482703894,
0.4940866232,
0.6347402334,
-0.3575128615,
0.16833359,
0.264675945,
-0.1719357818,
-0.5605397224,
0.2032235116,
-0.7747411132,
-0.4279128909,
1.2467429638,
-0.1803986132,
-0.6877465248,
-0.4621037543,
-0.519400835,
0.204897508,
-0.4170354009,
0.1060781032,
0.2872288227,
0.2179218531,
-0.3675700724,
-0.4842430651,
0.2651070654,
0.7413281202,
-0.5217524767,
-0.0309129022,
0.355661422,
0.2356473356,
0.2229084969,
0.4135674834,
0.3066782355,
0.4358745217,
-0.1563198268,
-0.078334339,
-0.1537888795,
-0.1793055832,
-0.6552726626,
0.2519585788,
-0.163416326,
-0.1422138959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12759v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12759v2 | Kanbun-LM: Reading and Translating Classical Chinese in Japanese Methods by Language Models | 2023-05-22T06:30:02 | 2024-07-02T13:39:31 | Hao Wang, Hirofumi Shimizu, Daisuke Kawahara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies in natural language processing (NLP) have focused on modern
languages and achieved state-of-the-art results in many tasks. Meanwhile,
little attention has been paid to ancient texts and related tasks. Classical
Chinese first came to Japan approximately 2,000 years ago. It was gradually
adapted to a Japanese form called Kanbun-Kundoku (Kanbun) in Japanese reading
and translating methods, which has significantly impacted Japanese literature.
However, compared to the rich resources for ancient texts in mainland China,
Kanbun resources remain scarce in Japan. To solve this problem, we construct
the first Classical-Chinese-to-Kanbun dataset in the world. Furthermore, we
introduce two tasks, character reordering and machine translation, both of
which play a significant role in Kanbun comprehension. We also test the current
language models on these tasks and discuss the best evaluation method by
comparing the results with human scores. We release our code and dataset on
GitHub. | [
-0.231945917,
-0.8277727365,
0.4159450829,
0.1630375981,
-0.5895563364,
0.0669487566,
-0.2754544914,
-0.664747417,
0.0358233415,
0.7817636132,
-0.5075466037,
-0.5365607142,
-0.2063401937,
0.2590322793,
-0.1842691749,
0.8272579312,
-0.248128742,
0.1596725136,
0.0743989795,
-0.0993356779,
-0.4511910975,
-0.286706984,
-0.864358604,
-0.4415153265,
0.7033336759,
0.3618724346,
0.998685956,
0.8895825148,
0.4832245708,
0.1784143448,
-0.0227309763,
0.1534895003,
-0.4966091812,
0.0192225538,
0.1705501527,
-0.8263821602,
-0.1492968798,
-0.2848087549,
0.9257515073,
0.5899977684,
-0.0063906047,
-0.1938386112,
0.0552419089,
0.7076514363,
-0.3455198705,
0.2041007727,
-0.140353322,
0.2893157899,
-0.3132724464,
-0.1842796355,
-0.5583384633,
-0.4733609557,
-0.0146837505,
-0.838799119,
0.313041836,
0.1521633714,
0.8631435633,
0.0216172226,
-0.4629285932,
-0.1348789632,
-0.3764193952,
0.689684689,
-0.7887900472,
0.2054577023,
0.5162460804,
0.3921723068,
-0.2245074213,
-0.6940968037,
-0.4135545194,
-0.5049366355,
-0.2881846726,
0.0646967515,
0.2990225255,
-0.0089688217,
0.264100343,
0.5480604172,
-0.9873834848,
0.3425931633,
-0.2187056243,
0.1577372253,
0.8803952932,
0.241704762,
0.8262296319,
-0.5497819185,
-0.2664173543,
-0.438272208,
-0.5528286099,
-0.1700311154,
0.0456214286,
0.1797880828,
-0.0591376238,
0.4227823913,
-0.0849494115,
0.7759455442,
-0.4517057538,
-0.4055274725,
-0.2090521604,
-0.5611572266,
-0.1742642373,
0.1978194565,
1.0970970392,
0.4060703814,
0.2890155315,
-0.2248427719,
-0.0482078046,
-0.3645139337,
0.0594147444,
-0.7188178301,
-0.2271545082,
-0.1598352343,
-0.713676393,
-0.4160362184,
-0.0983161554,
-0.7050449252,
-0.481765449,
-0.2495256066,
0.1290154308,
-0.4575378597,
-0.3236302733,
0.0934758186,
0.0533585213,
0.4439248741,
0.2129416764,
-0.9507473707,
0.2773712873,
0.6604153514,
0.8809887171,
-0.1053623632,
-0.2840289474,
0.1181268841,
-0.0308331493,
-0.5522081852,
0.5467963219,
-0.2104932517,
-0.5045414567,
-0.1121994033,
0.1409016401,
0.1842838973,
-0.4792102873,
0.6978319883,
-0.4355320632,
0.1909539551,
-0.316139251,
-0.2296691686,
-0.5277087092,
-0.0582550615,
-0.7256413698,
0.7852742076,
-0.0090976236,
-0.6532570124,
-0.0304609388,
-0.424169004,
-0.8474942446,
0.2290869355,
0.2076556981,
-0.2963171899,
-0.0002288837,
0.4070966542,
0.4054615498,
-0.5834627151,
0.2774917483,
-0.3909777403,
-0.2363669276,
0.5276856422,
-0.5443232656,
1.0536025763,
0.573086679,
-0.2010782808,
0.0045995475,
-0.5005697012,
0.1073293313,
0.4263895452,
0.0239160731,
-0.6026021242,
0.0561516769,
0.3214120865,
-0.0503712744,
0.2570413053,
-0.2046274841,
0.4437759817,
-0.2227144837,
0.4667105973,
0.4960559905,
-0.1877061427,
0.4565758705,
-0.4695546925,
0.5114793777,
-0.2555781007,
0.0240220856,
-0.4937894046,
-0.4220580757,
-0.7250435948,
0.0979818329,
0.3655245602,
0.7075577378,
-0.8306288123,
0.2288318127,
-0.439032644,
-0.6195266843,
-0.7347686887,
-0.0578270555,
0.2292170525,
0.2114145309,
0.1027007699,
-0.1873651296,
-0.1841327995,
-0.7358171344,
-0.2945074141,
-0.2052630335,
-0.0635475814,
0.1112174541,
0.116384156,
-0.1514958739,
0.391515404,
-0.5934349895,
-0.0763099417,
-0.2936187983,
0.3244894147,
0.111158058,
0.602083683,
0.1248833984,
-0.7905811071,
-0.6844232082,
0.5004140735,
-0.9159550667,
-0.0710369051,
-0.4935489595,
-0.3960138857,
0.1458728909,
0.5311747789,
-0.1399087161,
0.1088043898,
0.3736696243,
0.0530589633,
0.3863229752,
-0.0168059599,
0.2902000248,
-1.5198082924,
0.4377551377,
-0.0296629183,
-0.6270183325,
-0.583344698,
0.6160340309,
0.1840981394,
-0.4592139125,
-0.0456102751,
0.5612867475,
-0.5228481293,
-0.0738508105,
-0.4151921272,
0.4589993656,
-0.0301236827,
0.3359967768,
0.3501826525,
0.3396213055,
0.0763393864,
-0.3873113096,
0.5556996465,
-0.0496633202,
-0.4969084263,
0.3276459575,
-0.3035341203,
0.1385840923,
-0.1198104694,
0.0718339533,
-0.927654326,
-0.121707879,
0.6860420704,
-0.387326479,
0.5774835944,
-0.0128401751,
-0.7825793624,
-0.1658340096,
0.1664313227,
0.3737498522,
0.4464963973,
-0.3564059138,
0.4034541547,
0.1156952381,
-0.408616215,
-0.5564514399,
-0.8915776014,
0.0628723428,
0.0116129005,
-0.3958361745,
0.1783955395,
-0.090974465,
0.0062832702,
0.1282921135,
-0.0522032343,
-0.2766361833,
0.2054697573,
-0.128935799,
0.2420750558,
-0.4951300621,
-0.1583064944,
0.2219780385,
-0.2197825611,
0.0129735349,
-0.1205222458,
0.3124130964,
0.092339009,
0.0019315706,
-0.5009293556,
0.293625325,
0.4568247497,
-0.2455140799,
0.7332414985,
0.7472778559,
-0.4492654502,
0.0493102968,
-0.4592704475,
-0.1575266123,
-0.3855178356,
0.5374321342,
-0.4397624433,
-0.6507202983,
0.334572345,
0.101015605,
0.3234353662,
0.3144581318,
0.1613628417,
-0.1737302393,
1.0343648195,
0.5021631122,
-0.3456353247,
0.6298475266,
0.0203327984,
-0.007381869,
-0.4996748567,
0.039069891,
-0.3324595988,
-0.3852520883,
-0.7093172073,
-0.3077425659,
0.0463027284,
0.4116745293,
0.1126808152,
0.4761362076,
-0.3537606001,
0.5300910473,
0.2810588777,
0.3368773162,
0.5965209603,
0.0217410084,
-0.0493124872,
-0.1707414389,
-0.6794905066,
-0.3378882706,
1.0916064978,
0.4037669897,
0.6910498142,
0.0473876372,
0.5924710631,
0.0554376952,
0.6158453226,
-0.8745564818,
0.5864691734,
-0.3076710403,
-0.677952528,
-0.4457021058,
-0.6575085521,
-1.1027050018,
0.4216090739,
0.0485603921,
-0.2773241103,
-0.0758115053,
-0.3052569032,
-0.0824540854,
0.2786542177,
-0.5391145945,
1.1310271025,
-0.5421693921,
-0.173411727,
-0.4604196548,
-0.7285166979,
0.781252265,
-0.0135767162,
0.3363869786,
0.0676292405,
-0.0325910151,
0.400652796,
-0.229518503,
0.5509608388,
0.1692996472,
-0.2345691025,
0.1976333708,
0.2487537116,
0.334390521,
0.2038189322,
-0.0573855005,
-0.0495051108,
0.3340677917,
-0.5699054003,
-0.6889153719,
0.6024420857,
-0.8326993585,
-0.2615218759,
-0.5782541633,
-0.6110044122,
0.4253523052,
0.6186330318,
0.1808163375,
0.2125065327,
-0.2781162262,
0.2933880389,
0.48464486,
-0.1370272487,
0.3076807559,
0.8656786084,
-0.8629202247,
-0.5762678981,
0.8437491059,
0.1269783229,
0.4145794213,
0.9169372916,
0.207350418,
-0.2464194894,
-0.2425579876,
-0.55651021,
0.4408725202,
-0.7172500491,
0.2162506431,
-0.0599312894,
-0.1035146564,
-0.0761318877,
-0.0094994269,
-0.1845010668,
0.0272729732,
-0.3296797574,
0.1251013875,
0.0320735499,
0.5593178272,
0.0222402532,
0.2689855993,
-0.8366350532,
0.6087911725,
0.1073975191,
0.215578407,
0.0889012143,
-0.391166389,
-0.5713810325,
0.2245720178,
-0.151682049,
-0.974347055,
0.4231519699,
-0.2071637213,
0.4459801912,
0.514208138,
0.0724052712,
0.6228662133,
-0.2847371399,
0.4252914488,
0.0673449039,
-0.5993595719,
0.3359098434,
-0.4545681477,
0.4986014664,
0.4042390883,
0.6747094393,
-1.122944355,
-0.1050856113,
-0.3248477578,
-0.4618490338,
0.7429711223,
0.0417013504,
-0.2073681951,
0.3514391184,
0.6317299008,
0.1235371307,
-0.0196379572,
-1.0755794048,
-0.3034128845,
-0.1844414324,
-0.2731104493,
-0.6867079139,
0.0727857873,
0.1444074512,
-0.1220928654,
0.4671474099,
-0.181350559,
0.0405380875,
0.2863712609,
-0.6018539667,
-0.1369241476,
0.0959281549,
0.5097869039,
0.4480243623,
-0.0729593635,
-0.0850512609,
0.1444126219,
-0.4037775397,
0.1409712881,
0.2715044022,
-0.5684450269,
0.1425312757,
0.2179421186,
1.0063525438,
0.4433073401,
-0.5022013187,
-0.0258066114,
-0.0083354991,
0.1409172863,
-0.386742413,
-0.0913529396,
0.1522334218,
0.0426016189,
0.1980199665,
-0.2851373255,
0.1260173768,
-0.6863170862,
-0.1095650494,
0.0471926667,
-0.391492635,
-0.0457189344,
0.5420337319,
-0.0037046773,
-0.2023211122,
0.6105346084,
-0.2433964312,
-0.2535768747,
0.3626468778,
0.7375553846,
0.9555336833,
-0.2647456825,
0.2086285949,
0.684499383,
0.5010880828,
-0.3690395653,
0.087790288,
-0.1394962668,
-0.5232575536,
-0.4515970647,
-0.5580766797,
-0.342290163,
0.2565222979,
-0.8115105033,
0.4611307085,
-0.5033047199,
-0.0250943918,
-0.396363765,
0.2286711037,
-0.2610657215,
0.1737074107,
0.2845218182,
0.5162255168,
-0.7143295407,
0.8826903105,
0.5912448764,
-0.6387339234,
-0.4498257935,
0.048300419,
-0.1770967245,
-0.6983212233,
0.3236171305,
0.2112724334,
0.3129559755,
0.5032171011,
-0.3839331865,
-0.7311060429,
0.9505276084,
0.0900551155,
-0.8312963843,
-0.2507834136,
0.11432679,
0.4862032533,
0.1370279044,
0.2981052101,
0.3647343814,
0.5895622969,
-0.4794418514,
-0.6964740753,
0.2119330913,
-0.3405873477,
0.3444612026,
0.3602563143,
-0.6360832453,
0.4226420522,
0.0688126832,
-0.5491879582,
0.6012670398,
0.7878803015,
0.2585704029,
0.0993794501,
0.2837570012,
0.5478746891,
0.75201267,
-0.2351665348,
1.1969152689,
-0.073690258,
0.0570109859,
0.6891813874,
0.0299189705,
0.9521520138,
0.150982976,
-0.4788452983,
0.6162306666,
0.9525290132,
-0.113491796,
0.3393708766,
0.3658553362,
-0.3625259101,
-0.2275355756,
0.0305814296,
-0.4797016978,
-0.1367653757,
0.2527971864,
-0.3479539454,
0.0656788349,
0.2161784619,
0.2280049622,
0.1640583277,
-0.286883533,
0.8090468645,
0.6083559394,
-0.8476855159,
0.7135985494,
0.1840857565,
0.6071697474,
-0.7755435109,
0.2900097966,
-0.3753832281,
0.1337710619,
0.0283935461,
-0.8720083237,
0.0736575648,
-0.1805766225,
-0.2561548054,
-0.2005453408,
0.638292551,
-0.5930901766,
-0.5953347683,
0.2877888978,
0.1614128798,
0.4715655744,
0.0357314609,
-0.8213170767,
-0.1664002538,
0.1205668077,
0.0559949577,
0.4373811483,
0.3367665112,
-0.1234653145,
0.676941514,
0.7483498454,
-0.0276107881,
-0.0657403767,
0.1139591858,
0.1508398354,
-0.9377301931,
-0.5689467192,
-0.7632809877,
0.4272277951,
0.2204898596,
-0.1589396149,
0.6163775325,
0.4239967167,
0.8193340302,
-0.0732044578,
0.7603510618,
0.1854081303,
0.3148523271,
-0.6644833088,
1.0786354542,
-0.7673787475,
-0.1687299758,
-0.363427639,
-0.8764273524,
-0.4614220262,
0.6563947797,
-0.1854627877,
-0.1212071478,
0.8657187819,
0.725043714,
0.1256892681,
0.1787261665,
0.1500730366,
0.0925780982,
0.2045659423,
0.6644641161,
0.7498478293,
-0.9101437926,
0.5944228172,
-0.4539964497,
-0.0146330185,
-0.4451930225,
-0.6446723938,
-0.6715912819,
-0.566747427,
-0.3063389361,
-0.348922044,
0.1225273982,
0.5462483764,
0.286318481,
-0.7895752192,
-0.6574872136,
-0.3971484303,
0.4187679887,
-0.3691439331,
-0.2751649916,
0.2882324457,
-0.3970602453,
-0.8130133152,
0.4198837578,
-0.075568825,
0.1604603976,
-0.2617554069,
-0.1812148988,
-0.2109022886,
-0.6234260201,
0.4967130423,
0.5953738689,
-0.938839376,
0.1862460971,
0.307341218,
-0.5356653929,
0.0491151549,
0.5640479326,
-0.3821131885,
0.7553149462,
0.9045148492,
0.8167237639,
0.7030605674,
-0.1088852137,
0.9640598893,
-0.1601972431,
-0.0798690841,
0.0597357489,
0.2271101773,
0.4250281751,
0.0228133053,
0.4087420404,
0.4223766327,
-0.5787719488,
-0.8939701915,
0.0493913144,
-0.8406211138,
-0.6033446789,
0.8520592451,
-0.1636340171,
-0.2332129031,
0.0382233337,
-0.5390960574,
0.7586233616,
0.0237017497,
0.411244452,
0.80513376,
0.4276760221,
-0.7963134646,
-0.7520182133,
0.2998642921,
0.6931508183,
-0.7938652635,
-0.0746085867,
0.2050921172,
0.1496245712,
0.0720348582,
0.3588461876,
-0.1221807152,
0.384262085,
0.0134489555,
0.3688572645,
0.1112408116,
-0.0571720302,
-0.3818665147,
-0.1491321474,
0.2187300473,
0.0473924503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12757v1 | This Prompt is Measuring <MASK>: Evaluating Bias Evaluation in Language Models | 2023-05-22T06:28:48 | 2023-05-22T06:28:48 | Seraphina Goldfarb-Tarrant, Eddie Ungless, Esma Balkir, Su Lin Blodgett | cs.CL | cs.CL | Bias research in NLP seeks to analyse models for social biases, thus helping
NLP practitioners uncover, measure, and mitigate social harms. We analyse the
body of work that uses prompts and templates to assess bias in language models.
We draw on a measurement modelling framework to create a taxonomy of attributes
that capture what a bias test aims to measure and how that measurement is
carried out. By applying this taxonomy to 90 bias tests, we illustrate
qualitatively and quantitatively that core aspects of bias test
conceptualisations and operationalisations are frequently unstated or
ambiguous, carry implicit assumptions, or be mismatched. Our analysis
illuminates the scope of possible bias types the field is able to measure, and
reveals types that are as yet under-researched. We offer guidance to enable the
community to explore a wider section of the possible bias space, and to better
close the gap between desired outcomes and experimental design, both for bias
and for evaluating language models more broadly. | [
-0.5196101665,
-0.653847456,
0.3295608461,
0.4537172616,
0.0073127714,
-0.018479012,
0.0181525946,
-0.3358175159,
0.3036049902,
0.4222984314,
-0.65641433,
-0.1907184124,
-0.8176260591,
-0.0244968105,
-0.6462643743,
1.1017632484,
-0.033976797,
0.2751711309,
-0.2818005681,
-0.2528278232,
-0.7354111671,
-0.3319699466,
-0.5951967835,
-0.4587506354,
0.567702651,
0.0835276693,
0.6033996344,
0.3629012704,
0.3097424507,
0.1219378635,
-0.3434922397,
-0.1440283209,
-0.1734239012,
0.1051358506,
-0.3487954438,
-0.301756084,
-0.4789334238,
0.4383148849,
0.5628315806,
1.2978127003,
0.2511193454,
0.7674109936,
0.0782176107,
0.5162698627,
-0.7817568779,
0.0690943599,
-0.4724317491,
0.2875797153,
-0.3328521848,
0.0812313408,
-0.1895675957,
-0.2446201891,
0.2517081201,
-0.1440702379,
0.1375668198,
0.3145887256,
0.6137280464,
0.0033537399,
-0.490398407,
-0.3038214743,
-0.2811230123,
0.9318782687,
-0.7122485042,
0.2169426084,
0.4926047027,
0.2283514142,
0.2866905332,
-0.726149261,
-0.4391928911,
0.0083312402,
-0.1319972426,
-0.1227909848,
-0.3098005056,
-0.1727094501,
0.4500012398,
0.4860870242,
-0.3936487436,
-0.1253724247,
-0.1894435585,
-0.4857430756,
0.4826404154,
0.1889282614,
0.4128424227,
-0.2835364938,
-0.0481989346,
0.1890293509,
-0.5280196667,
-0.1358244568,
0.7927989364,
0.1744160354,
0.0077540632,
0.61025846,
-0.1702913046,
0.9320243001,
-0.1208145171,
0.1216439679,
0.0161522813,
-0.5059677958,
-0.0978195965,
-0.1702788025,
0.5503768325,
0.5874441266,
0.0774561092,
-0.1575292051,
-0.341763109,
0.3758616447,
0.2902825475,
-0.3757594824,
-0.0338648222,
-0.0367748737,
-0.5465303063,
-0.5355635285,
-0.2758127153,
-1.0148445368,
-0.5969868302,
-0.112534523,
0.3272764385,
0.0726091936,
-0.5107605457,
0.361805588,
-0.5618914366,
0.3419890702,
-0.0669831038,
-0.8919368386,
0.4405456781,
0.7373899817,
0.6354776621,
-0.1673037857,
-0.1214727089,
-0.3857304752,
-0.5371866822,
-0.3318443298,
0.6581367254,
-0.5913297534,
-0.2463491261,
0.435438782,
-0.0972841978,
0.0329306833,
-0.3038957119,
0.9087076783,
-0.3416975439,
0.5695356131,
-0.6739794016,
-0.539998889,
-0.2037730962,
0.2701852024,
-0.5482648015,
1.1888666153,
0.4264672697,
-0.9659128189,
0.7970094681,
-0.775077343,
-0.142205134,
0.0841327235,
-0.1221563667,
-0.2342927456,
0.1051869318,
0.0082810149,
0.2355640084,
-0.6407539845,
0.4260241985,
-0.4272784591,
0.0197019763,
0.4262363017,
-0.2222166508,
1.1622539759,
-0.0559891239,
-0.5826931596,
0.0827635527,
-0.6950039864,
-0.1033584699,
-0.0505494215,
0.0900560692,
-0.5334945917,
0.0731708556,
0.3769505918,
0.3244582415,
-0.1260291189,
-0.5940076709,
0.0842916667,
-0.3938119411,
0.509341538,
0.8437919617,
-0.0390213802,
0.6800028682,
-0.3303972185,
0.7528392673,
-0.3867220879,
0.2700639963,
-0.0140544446,
-0.694814086,
-0.8330867887,
-0.0596148744,
0.5332534909,
0.0017721019,
-0.4595686495,
0.3636761606,
0.0493724979,
-0.3619911671,
-0.7593998313,
-0.0107039968,
0.479924351,
0.6644553542,
-0.0010629437,
-0.784820497,
-0.6231252551,
-0.9120354652,
-0.7248267531,
-0.2463696897,
-0.1954155266,
0.1989438534,
0.8449223042,
-0.2619250119,
1.149600625,
-0.4091890752,
-0.2486080825,
-0.1158725917,
0.2765680254,
-0.0739099234,
0.2091501355,
0.5532172322,
-0.4577416182,
-0.0348802917,
-0.4171713293,
-0.5145150423,
-0.8281927109,
0.1081705242,
-0.1712401956,
-0.3537278175,
0.2793609798,
-0.3092956543,
0.335285455,
0.4223133326,
-0.7335216999,
0.8506365418,
0.7643907666,
-0.1133133695,
-0.6053598523,
0.1615904719,
0.1155027226,
-0.130399242,
-0.6965247989,
0.1822634935,
-0.0798669234,
0.1180492938,
-0.6985817552,
0.8759723306,
-0.4913588166,
-0.0568850301,
0.0715504736,
0.242006436,
0.3094598353,
-0.0584119447,
-0.2762658,
0.5287978649,
0.783804059,
-0.6045024991,
0.1994980574,
0.2038044035,
-0.6292799115,
0.7599208355,
-0.6733288169,
0.2456187159,
0.0244005527,
-0.027386291,
-0.9318939447,
-0.1462060362,
0.3867335916,
-0.6561049819,
0.0348051153,
-0.0563867278,
-0.3283006847,
-0.3217298687,
-0.4288212955,
0.6803584695,
0.4235954881,
-0.2993809879,
0.4387963116,
0.7993986011,
0.3032745421,
-0.7942394614,
-0.7184721231,
0.001618061,
-0.5670953989,
-0.606518805,
0.0646268353,
-0.0289777406,
-0.7208017707,
-0.1986590773,
-0.1273723245,
-0.0460273847,
0.2323133796,
0.1576650441,
-0.1700848639,
-0.4123123884,
-0.0883141607,
-0.0928005204,
0.1039732173,
0.7038234472,
-0.2723356187,
0.6324818134,
0.2306938916,
-0.410915792,
0.1304349154,
0.3118674159,
0.2180322856,
-0.071475029,
0.4559004307,
0.4829830825,
-0.5346294641,
-0.3487389386,
-0.7427411675,
-0.1452714354,
-0.372961849,
0.2348629385,
-0.129221797,
-0.8891918659,
0.7827688456,
0.0449122936,
-0.1593946218,
0.4855020344,
0.5392192006,
0.2133486718,
0.8978407383,
0.7396786809,
-0.1706162542,
0.1662486196,
0.0869216472,
0.5407240987,
-1.2201497555,
-0.0595451444,
-0.7119517326,
-0.0223880727,
-0.3028428257,
-0.432836026,
0.0836035609,
-0.0868068412,
-0.0846803933,
0.174494043,
-0.6763793826,
0.4977869093,
0.4550419152,
-0.2008036822,
-0.0909537748,
-0.4411389232,
-0.2297139913,
-0.229432255,
-0.5753135085,
-0.7783846855,
1.0434063673,
0.6966913939,
0.638243258,
-0.0253718216,
0.214614749,
0.539785862,
0.3777311742,
-0.7793499827,
0.4799014628,
0.4889108837,
-1.1095757484,
-0.3544376791,
0.0643940121,
-0.7419763803,
0.376843065,
-0.0132504879,
-0.7932822704,
0.2173303813,
0.0518402196,
-0.1978883296,
0.1956925988,
-0.4335496128,
1.0485808849,
0.1131478399,
-0.091669634,
0.4306308329,
-0.4980487525,
0.6637906432,
-0.0183872022,
0.0942607,
-0.2321034223,
0.0616976209,
1.2416760921,
0.0494614877,
0.9788835645,
0.0569957048,
-0.1248965263,
0.3331590891,
0.1749523878,
-0.2028281838,
-0.0739004239,
-0.1513669044,
0.2448351085,
0.0605196729,
-0.4338620901,
-0.5703159571,
0.251940459,
-0.4575704336,
-0.408308208,
-0.7359694242,
-0.5310422182,
-0.2494603246,
0.1885281652,
0.0551917218,
0.2593493164,
-0.5056052208,
-0.0370943435,
0.6698272824,
-0.5177110434,
0.265694648,
0.5588194132,
-0.5210081339,
0.1298066229,
0.3786752224,
0.0649532229,
0.3838549554,
0.2840617895,
0.3587163687,
-0.4833548665,
-0.15188016,
-0.3381207585,
0.0305474494,
-1.0466119051,
-0.1934557259,
-0.628572762,
-0.1506204754,
-0.8671236634,
-0.0567850992,
0.0381155573,
-0.4581109583,
-0.1449166685,
-0.2897200286,
0.1703738868,
0.8036521077,
-0.069893986,
0.5393009782,
-0.0154783353,
0.0356374756,
0.3904162049,
0.3170737326,
0.101993084,
-0.7010530233,
0.0964136124,
-0.1609164029,
-0.3636023402,
-1.2984223366,
0.556127429,
-0.1640353799,
0.4703040719,
0.2641744018,
-0.0813238472,
0.3632374406,
-0.5489632487,
1.1418704987,
0.1091285869,
-1.3861167431,
0.5494126081,
-0.4737691283,
0.1649877429,
0.4664862156,
0.2869839072,
-0.8515905142,
-0.5390598774,
-0.7179068923,
-0.7494747043,
0.4843190908,
0.0537836775,
0.3362362385,
-0.2671388388,
0.2123288661,
0.0394758359,
0.4213513732,
-0.9214506745,
-0.5389130116,
0.1027499661,
0.0366746671,
-0.0116152326,
-0.6969884634,
-0.3667622507,
-0.2102775276,
0.4911253154,
-0.1030609682,
0.2337237895,
-0.0486498661,
-0.278447479,
-0.0196268316,
0.2830559015,
0.5375151038,
1.0733175278,
-0.117857635,
0.3312778473,
0.2316553444,
-0.4000889957,
-0.041571591,
-0.2465868443,
-0.4442638755,
0.2956259251,
0.5060239434,
0.6971052885,
0.0380044878,
-0.3565184474,
0.8155788779,
0.0780875534,
0.0226621795,
-0.2768197358,
-0.0977542102,
-0.0624823906,
-0.2547973394,
0.2835558057,
-0.1583256871,
0.529315412,
-0.6749668717,
0.3923867643,
0.5490090847,
-0.8175409436,
-0.2949506938,
0.6708972454,
0.1861028373,
-0.5365355611,
0.1463313252,
-0.2296537012,
-0.6576085687,
0.6887854934,
0.4403614402,
1.0491509438,
-0.2167618424,
0.4761424661,
0.1601566523,
0.8497084975,
0.1143429875,
0.162950322,
0.1199098825,
-0.7988274097,
-0.2432568222,
-0.859729588,
-0.2217694074,
0.2536249757,
-0.9164427519,
0.1949031204,
-0.0828235969,
-0.2245396525,
0.3667070568,
-0.1859636754,
-0.7776405215,
0.27587834,
-0.0718376413,
1.141087532,
-1.5557262897,
0.4355604649,
0.3799729049,
-0.5554654002,
-0.4911762476,
-0.2446449101,
0.3886255026,
-1.0586605072,
0.666666925,
0.1946128905,
0.1023285687,
-0.5126335025,
-0.4886192977,
-0.5989417434,
0.5432993174,
0.1286976337,
-0.0530260056,
0.0762734339,
0.3799716532,
0.67220819,
-0.5508491993,
0.7531624436,
0.9848795533,
0.4755068719,
-0.5889571905,
-0.9154943824,
0.273724705,
-0.2363484502,
0.223195225,
0.0002338821,
-0.1472521573,
0.7486365438,
0.3080072105,
-0.0701788664,
-0.1937489957,
0.5534926653,
-0.0560357571,
0.4264054,
0.5080094337,
0.4764737785,
0.4983408153,
-0.3881736696,
1.0598561764,
0.0108109452,
0.3035844862,
0.9338793755,
-0.350079447,
0.0599332452,
0.6395489573,
-0.2243138403,
0.1464705616,
0.830691278,
0.1566090435,
0.263178587,
0.7945725918,
-0.3208473325,
0.1588495225,
-0.6123550534,
-0.2647793889,
0.2966492474,
0.3404566348,
-0.5640500784,
-0.14864631,
0.0317587033,
0.1975424141,
0.1238119155,
-0.3625368178,
0.6840240359,
0.1953202188,
-0.8763161302,
0.1096188128,
0.0574616529,
0.6365060806,
-0.5001325607,
-0.0052605988,
-0.3756264448,
-0.1505393684,
-0.1291779727,
-0.9863529801,
0.5453107953,
-0.0885329619,
-0.3124590218,
-0.4854714572,
0.7284524441,
-0.3267032206,
-0.4895276129,
0.4427990913,
0.606171906,
0.2333867401,
0.0220708475,
-0.8150376678,
0.447909832,
-0.1213000119,
-0.0217494741,
0.4367009699,
0.4984198213,
-0.0575080886,
0.5997774005,
0.2952267826,
0.2970716953,
0.4401593208,
0.5321415067,
0.5545511842,
-0.3659877479,
-0.2024920881,
-0.9120982289,
0.6536831856,
-0.2053068578,
-0.8064770699,
1.0025136471,
0.496191889,
0.8215335011,
0.0214471947,
0.7660714388,
-0.1320791245,
0.6252493858,
-0.3246508241,
0.7203044295,
-0.3103510737,
0.1579271704,
-0.7640684843,
-0.9403582215,
-0.3766837418,
0.7122778296,
-0.2766013145,
-0.0209592283,
0.7205166221,
0.7410573959,
0.013098035,
-0.0518560484,
0.2925139368,
-0.0401897356,
0.1391450018,
0.1032089293,
1.0083781481,
-0.4838734567,
-0.1461601555,
-0.1324080974,
-0.3224140108,
0.1571607739,
-0.9927327037,
-1.0590136051,
-0.8144922853,
-0.505931139,
-0.6267804503,
-0.0032148808,
0.4179217219,
0.6918863654,
-0.742110014,
-0.3845105171,
0.2959323525,
0.4782160819,
-0.1368452609,
-0.3325277269,
0.0416269787,
-0.406221211,
-0.482686311,
-0.0303782336,
0.1538811624,
-0.431284219,
-0.6908022165,
0.3513564169,
-0.2456376106,
0.2765297592,
0.7574321628,
0.1003882587,
-0.9324900508,
-0.531468749,
0.1078914925,
0.0990310982,
-0.3289975822,
0.8634410501,
-0.350897938,
0.6662812829,
0.4726839364,
0.7111961246,
0.1473301798,
-0.3821121156,
0.8040720224,
-0.8830605149,
-0.038300965,
0.499352634,
0.4977863431,
0.4284543693,
-0.2063435614,
0.788741231,
0.0208587609,
-0.5278414488,
-1.3173246384,
0.428619951,
-0.8331488371,
-0.0337935127,
1.2936997414,
0.1002835706,
-0.0887419358,
-0.2278223485,
-0.0786099508,
0.0562642403,
0.1286904812,
0.9684349895,
1.1926221848,
0.0915263593,
-0.0877953619,
-0.8053776622,
0.8069101572,
0.5699942708,
-0.4703917503,
-0.0909147784,
0.3059664667,
0.3709527552,
0.4045829177,
0.817527473,
-0.2880911529,
0.0960199162,
-0.0708029196,
0.1862204969,
0.7083801031,
0.0246357955,
-0.5755129457,
-0.0877364501,
0.0222233348,
0.0041936678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12755v1 | GNCformer Enhanced Self-attention for Automatic Speech Recognition | 2023-05-22T06:26:05 | 2023-05-22T06:26:05 | J. Li, Z. Duan, S. Li, X. Yu, G. Yang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | In this paper,an Enhanced Self-Attention (ESA) mechanism has been put forward
for robust feature extraction.The proposed ESA is integrated with the recursive
gated convolution and self-attention mechanism.In particular, the former is
used to capture multi-order feature interaction and the latter is for global
feature extraction.In addition, the location of interest that is suitable for
inserting the ESA is also worth being explored.In this paper, the ESA is
embedded into the encoder layer of the Transformer network for automatic speech
recognition (ASR) tasks, and this newly proposed model is named GNCformer. The
effectiveness of the GNCformer has been validated using two datasets, that are
Aishell-1 and HKUST.Experimental results show that, compared with the
Transformer network,0.8%CER,and 1.2%CER improvement for these two mentioned
datasets, respectively, can be achieved.It is worth mentioning that only 1.4M
additional parameters have been involved in our proposed GNCformer. | [
-0.5112130642,
-0.298694253,
0.1241923496,
0.2895276248,
-0.1228718013,
-0.0990424007,
0.0140099069,
-0.7346910834,
0.3923293352,
0.4400322735,
-0.4234312475,
-0.1313574761,
-0.7657337785,
0.07063099,
-0.7140720487,
0.4622332752,
0.0164263174,
-0.0546339341,
0.0175297223,
-0.1525924951,
-0.2304791808,
-0.7558485866,
-0.5827773213,
-0.194389537,
0.1687493473,
0.0491177738,
0.3392454386,
0.8984003663,
0.5945597887,
0.4785760939,
-0.0677578449,
-0.1922071278,
-0.0708067194,
0.4517679214,
0.0131751532,
-0.0006620288,
-0.4525066912,
-0.1252341419,
0.8430576324,
0.0815800056,
-0.182695955,
0.278956145,
0.3638269007,
0.3994654119,
-0.6790081859,
0.2002703995,
-0.4905549288,
-0.0700371191,
-0.1000047997,
0.1122270525,
-0.0308882389,
-0.076033771,
0.1878804117,
-0.2204250842,
0.6014848351,
-0.1461846679,
0.791433692,
0.6619612575,
0.0048043435,
-0.3041528761,
-0.6648267508,
0.6490474939,
-0.329407692,
0.8449530005,
0.1455473304,
0.6071701646,
-0.0162191279,
-0.99756217,
-0.4919939637,
-0.2449681014,
-0.1795667857,
0.1265301555,
-0.5669951439,
0.163888365,
0.3734887242,
0.6620104909,
-0.3735540211,
0.2498984635,
-0.2874487638,
-0.5778576136,
0.5305020213,
-0.1878299564,
0.2065226287,
-0.1235960051,
-0.2481331527,
-0.1690587699,
-0.4596958756,
0.4527225196,
0.2771963775,
0.4275830388,
-0.120527342,
0.3130317926,
-0.3456538022,
0.3800160289,
0.5335594416,
0.2573809922,
0.4836844206,
-0.3331020474,
-0.3868660629,
0.4172243476,
0.9666494131,
-0.2519262731,
0.085376963,
-0.2145873755,
-0.3245732486,
0.2365687191,
0.3138768971,
-0.8631670475,
-0.2958159745,
0.2732065022,
-0.5760403872,
-0.0665993243,
0.1260372251,
-0.5616535544,
0.0414389521,
-0.4222292304,
0.3339082599,
0.0271628369,
-0.133823216,
-0.0677490011,
0.158846736,
0.5194193125,
0.2716419101,
-1.1088403463,
0.6998613477,
0.4745813608,
0.8269382119,
-0.2780072093,
0.0845970958,
-0.9082149267,
0.0827677101,
0.2495513856,
0.8241640329,
-0.3803623021,
-0.3735404313,
-0.4674812555,
0.3438934386,
-0.3186233342,
-0.4071574807,
0.7839714885,
-0.2733132839,
0.3351979256,
-0.1435732841,
-0.2874351442,
-0.2452953011,
-0.064516969,
-0.9736729264,
1.0012003183,
-0.1993179917,
-0.5264753699,
0.078878358,
-0.8748067617,
-0.3994853199,
0.073874414,
-0.4311487675,
-0.840108335,
-0.144344449,
0.8638207316,
0.3683824539,
-0.1371865422,
0.0940949619,
-0.2585965097,
-0.2313905805,
0.0024979943,
-0.7635953426,
0.6667300463,
0.2246961743,
-0.7132793665,
0.1773969829,
-0.715280652,
0.1861199141,
-0.0507700555,
-0.3435331285,
0.1643343568,
-0.1032204852,
0.144511342,
0.4350762963,
0.2154740393,
-0.8223541975,
-0.1461011767,
-0.698931694,
0.4527145028,
0.3505733907,
0.1288366318,
0.427426815,
0.1992013156,
0.5526713729,
-0.2625303268,
0.2486103177,
0.0894589946,
-0.2069414556,
-0.7012838125,
-0.5126838088,
0.5442718863,
0.5269676447,
-0.2413916886,
0.7520244718,
-0.0159710795,
-0.2816232145,
-1.0558724403,
0.2035805434,
0.5555570722,
0.4735391736,
0.5479281545,
-0.3363212347,
-0.6253812909,
-0.8395493627,
0.075488098,
0.1433981955,
-0.3701068461,
0.309550792,
0.0792824924,
-0.0695937425,
0.9723489881,
0.0672602281,
-0.5788608193,
-0.3658741117,
-0.0303381048,
0.2628811896,
0.5940546393,
0.593326211,
-0.8102056384,
-0.467782259,
0.0576863401,
-0.4292699099,
-0.1456131488,
0.0637576357,
0.1509558409,
0.0494465902,
0.5775738358,
-0.3761953413,
0.544585824,
0.5198658109,
0.0811575055,
0.212636888,
-0.0718841851,
0.1716961712,
-0.8097211123,
0.1400080919,
0.2004412562,
-0.2519770861,
-0.7891837955,
-0.4131599665,
0.2331277132,
-0.1341606081,
-0.5041043758,
0.3462854922,
-0.6974259615,
-0.217871204,
-0.4208382964,
0.0746193379,
-0.0238799695,
0.4678007066,
0.0544684231,
0.8596566319,
0.8255477548,
-0.523657918,
0.4416019022,
0.3426487148,
-0.012261725,
0.2036289871,
-1.1130340099,
0.3248342276,
-0.0875341371,
-0.0141311502,
-1.1512931585,
-0.0862444192,
0.2751182616,
-0.5920912623,
0.7248938084,
-0.1082252935,
0.0538378097,
-0.7396419048,
-0.2191814631,
0.195768103,
0.1617037356,
-0.8347357512,
0.8673739433,
0.5989865065,
-0.2880256474,
-0.591550827,
-0.6302033663,
0.0582709648,
-0.193749994,
-0.4172559977,
0.3075614274,
0.1638617218,
0.108116731,
-0.2287284732,
-0.3438293934,
0.2515964806,
0.0783816651,
0.3399607837,
-0.0185505301,
-0.2761120796,
0.0188075714,
-0.0031750475,
-0.4837847054,
0.2579198778,
-0.1054030955,
0.3795931637,
-0.2317763418,
-0.5435070992,
-0.9119810462,
0.5339151025,
0.4507134557,
-0.6603029966,
-0.0465410054,
0.7133975625,
-0.4471897185,
0.1086449325,
-0.7178356051,
-0.3292000294,
-0.5664474964,
0.425452143,
-0.455842942,
-0.9677531123,
0.6394678354,
0.1119456366,
-0.1432995349,
0.6736332774,
0.4044516385,
-0.1031511873,
1.0994126797,
0.6149326563,
-0.5712555647,
0.6283510923,
-0.3441036046,
0.0756312534,
-1.1552267075,
-0.0980940685,
-0.9168141484,
-0.3816613257,
-0.6839128137,
0.0757571012,
0.2237543017,
-0.1164877862,
-0.0642791539,
0.3886144459,
-0.9804289341,
0.2760288119,
0.6228305697,
0.0802448988,
-0.1671622545,
-0.1118929088,
0.1592386663,
-0.1116039306,
-0.5460998416,
-0.2298203856,
0.6829078197,
0.5928860903,
0.8191518784,
0.0436663479,
0.6524828672,
0.240938127,
0.1107357368,
-0.7682226896,
0.2537223995,
-0.3368278742,
-0.2148937285,
-0.7168064117,
-0.0722292587,
-1.0015771389,
0.2986514568,
-0.0240513049,
-0.9228992462,
0.7258595824,
0.3167587817,
-0.6235456467,
-0.1795056462,
-0.7085211873,
0.8320563436,
-0.355853498,
0.0079397568,
0.2393666506,
-0.8668552637,
-0.111596331,
0.2018675953,
-0.1894148886,
0.0266273227,
0.3441998363,
0.787638247,
-0.0319899656,
0.6932234168,
-0.4793108404,
0.0861099958,
0.3475317359,
-0.2976802289,
0.5665140152,
-0.2364254445,
-0.0779377967,
0.2363230437,
-0.4582870007,
0.2125549614,
-0.6244853139,
0.5084391832,
-0.7786759734,
-0.7484693527,
-0.1538466066,
-0.2444566041,
0.0006686655,
0.0046528038,
0.1868708134,
0.8000010848,
-0.0025485936,
0.5415595174,
0.6470122933,
0.2542639673,
0.8739441633,
0.2276715934,
0.2250800133,
-0.8254375458,
0.7321948409,
0.1860952228,
0.3352700472,
0.3271810412,
0.1873369515,
-0.8042305112,
-0.4304673374,
-0.301898092,
0.0282226931,
-0.6272289157,
-0.4008440673,
-1.0483385324,
-0.7522033453,
-0.7678141594,
0.0765816197,
-0.3670289516,
-0.3293867707,
-0.4560530186,
-0.0972412676,
0.328422457,
0.3360526264,
-0.2118470073,
0.4810805619,
-0.4447057545,
0.6061401367,
0.5113614202,
0.1486585736,
-0.0710349679,
-0.6308149695,
-0.1223288253,
-0.1876904964,
-0.3546453118,
-0.5855193138,
0.5193760395,
0.5720942616,
1.2650457621,
0.4006686211,
-0.0551604107,
0.5516076088,
-0.3427829742,
0.4363887906,
0.1205665469,
-1.0427480936,
0.7684470415,
-0.032361377,
0.4745315015,
0.4322662354,
0.0627604574,
-0.218108654,
-0.6715719104,
-0.5750109553,
-0.7719109058,
0.6523848176,
0.2091183811,
-0.0364009179,
0.194539994,
0.2752495408,
-0.1462677568,
-0.0424976908,
-0.6563862562,
-0.2900400162,
-0.5731717944,
-0.3496318161,
-0.0097526442,
-0.3172052503,
0.245511055,
-0.3544296026,
0.5043108463,
-0.2151791602,
0.4800871611,
0.5783404112,
-0.0129075767,
-0.0816181228,
0.3742812872,
0.3957759738,
0.0463868007,
0.016393017,
0.0771139115,
0.2909160852,
-0.8559570312,
-0.0100129321,
0.5519316196,
-0.0600624382,
0.0107572377,
0.0328919776,
0.7915465236,
0.1332024485,
0.2720985115,
0.4646497071,
-0.2710750401,
-0.2648958862,
-0.1881053746,
0.2477151453,
-0.198116228,
0.3670034409,
0.4200839996,
-0.0100372359,
0.801659584,
0.0413725451,
0.5664105415,
0.5669556856,
-0.6117324233,
-0.0912414938,
0.900914073,
0.2693827748,
-0.3395417035,
0.3314344883,
-0.0152743217,
-0.7694434524,
0.6900620461,
0.7155812979,
1.2559626102,
-1.0250144005,
-0.2244786322,
0.4242859483,
0.3275110722,
0.1255140901,
0.3923317492,
-0.4438218474,
-0.4898092449,
-0.4557478428,
-0.5778879523,
-0.4843770564,
0.113886483,
-0.7955147028,
0.3000319898,
-0.0260516312,
-0.055817239,
0.0594276153,
0.104762353,
-0.6480326653,
0.4081316888,
0.1513544619,
0.5249954462,
-0.5938087702,
0.9627779722,
0.2343633622,
-0.0486648977,
-0.8043389916,
-0.1561611444,
-0.098336786,
-0.6900500655,
0.280353725,
0.5963453054,
-0.6219180822,
0.1449409425,
-0.349631846,
-1.3360658884,
1.087933898,
0.3711155653,
-0.8748442531,
0.3206587434,
0.0206128582,
0.4311148226,
-0.3831342161,
0.1997838169,
0.5055462718,
0.2364683151,
0.3283327818,
-1.1293239594,
0.0206518658,
-0.4495034516,
-0.0471873358,
0.1402246356,
-0.4988671243,
0.5968187451,
-0.0804182068,
-0.4260896444,
-0.1747468412,
1.0121104717,
0.0595712215,
0.039910607,
0.6048713923,
0.2807031274,
0.707143724,
-0.147032693,
0.6502822042,
-0.2411154509,
0.3251442015,
1.2395806313,
-0.1557493508,
0.6824526787,
0.3172116876,
0.0166686699,
0.291067332,
0.3463661969,
-0.1649843007,
0.8429515362,
0.0762682557,
-0.0898324847,
-0.2214564383,
0.0875160471,
-0.5420129895,
0.8058084249,
0.3583261669,
-0.3841019571,
-0.249017328,
0.1907730699,
-0.292494297,
-0.140035063,
-0.5099499822,
1.037132144,
0.1254007518,
-0.1646111459,
0.3172367811,
-0.5246323347,
0.5880881548,
-0.4949447811,
-0.0475160852,
0.2071556598,
0.2284768671,
-0.1530353874,
-0.6234372258,
0.3577180505,
-0.0830458924,
-0.2930932343,
-0.2943323851,
1.1396768093,
-0.4529983401,
-0.4677653313,
0.3063105047,
0.2606033385,
-0.0311656427,
-0.2605316937,
-0.6895101666,
0.0931778103,
-0.1504300684,
-0.3492047191,
0.1227227077,
0.4509079456,
0.1531556696,
0.5587710142,
0.5885205865,
-0.0077722236,
-0.0403374024,
0.4705781639,
0.9608259797,
-0.5350575447,
-0.9609644413,
-0.696886301,
0.5530846715,
-0.3327195346,
0.0364519209,
0.7499421239,
0.3983159363,
0.3519588113,
0.2530724108,
0.7511619925,
0.174667716,
0.6738961339,
-0.2915239036,
0.7953993678,
-0.0315481313,
0.0015898822,
-0.2897234857,
-0.6221042275,
-0.4236513078,
0.7322673798,
-0.2668458819,
0.1101883799,
0.3804694712,
0.6983692646,
-0.0730730444,
0.1856856644,
0.3494157195,
0.0196154881,
0.4879894555,
0.2101312578,
0.4976848364,
-0.6126689315,
0.3907769322,
-0.2326108068,
-0.237551406,
0.1097700149,
-0.7162129283,
-0.6839331985,
-0.489282459,
-0.3662582636,
-0.0886316523,
-0.0328752697,
0.8801687956,
0.5600395799,
-1.1979745626,
0.0370184109,
0.0774154216,
-0.173094511,
-0.2749597132,
-0.1949311197,
0.6364344358,
-0.3727112412,
-0.5157215595,
0.5881845951,
0.354342252,
0.2619381547,
-0.2434140146,
-0.0355036221,
0.1586208791,
-0.2927193344,
0.2684988081,
0.4048831463,
-0.7521740794,
-0.6854212284,
0.1204872504,
-0.0259365272,
0.2362407744,
0.5428732038,
-0.915194869,
0.5372413397,
0.0928345323,
0.6303611994,
0.4968586862,
0.2672331035,
0.4547439218,
-0.6857306361,
0.0065241405,
0.1403647959,
0.5522427559,
0.3947413266,
-0.7431960702,
0.1649920046,
0.0220195837,
-0.8129988313,
-0.4780367017,
-0.1443904936,
-1.1382417679,
0.5845320225,
0.9594717026,
0.0357520841,
-0.3303436339,
-0.3892879784,
-0.3503697217,
0.3331731856,
-0.5644241571,
0.881771028,
0.2532972395,
-0.3564844429,
-0.4181145728,
-0.2794191241,
0.5957233906,
-0.1170603335,
-0.7759425044,
0.1809658259,
0.2740551233,
0.1601081491,
0.3121621907,
0.5644700527,
-0.2326661497,
0.6028280258,
-0.1526042372,
0.3266480267,
-0.164938882,
-0.4422993064,
-0.8284076452,
0.36045596,
-0.3219646811,
-0.8356657028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12753v1 | Learning to Rank Utterances for Query-Focused Meeting Summarization | 2023-05-22T06:25:09 | 2023-05-22T06:25:09 | Xingxian Liu, Yajing Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Query-focused meeting summarization(QFMS) aims to generate a specific summary
for the given query according to the meeting transcripts. Due to the conflict
between long meetings and limited input size, previous works mainly adopt
extract-then-summarize methods, which use extractors to simulate binary labels
or ROUGE scores to extract utterances related to the query and then generate a
summary. However, the previous approach fails to fully use the comparison
between utterances. To the extractor, comparison orders are more important than
specific scores. In this paper, we propose a Ranker-Generator framework. It
learns to rank the utterances by comparing them in pairs and learning from the
global orders, then uses top utterances as the generator's input. We show that
learning to rank utterances helps to select utterances related to the query
effectively, and the summarizer can benefit from it. Experimental results on
QMSum show that the proposed model outperforms all existing multi-stage models
with fewer parameters. | [
-0.4237203598,
-0.2754886448,
0.5878344178,
0.1220352799,
-0.4332328141,
0.1123688966,
-0.077161178,
-0.3879196942,
0.4595757723,
0.3935910761,
-0.5114094019,
-0.4863649905,
-0.6929010749,
0.2161434591,
-0.4803610742,
1.2603193521,
0.5262634158,
0.1020460352,
-0.5168666244,
-0.2473040074,
-0.157022953,
-0.7164204717,
-0.6582603455,
-0.2172574699,
0.4894438386,
0.5563409925,
0.6530178785,
0.1444963068,
0.3915501237,
0.3567072749,
-0.2795240879,
0.3861945271,
-0.8778256774,
0.5409908295,
0.2914318144,
-0.3992033601,
-0.5129240751,
0.0950122699,
0.6644868255,
0.8550753593,
-0.4519614279,
0.2317714542,
0.0871028975,
0.4098706245,
-0.2078520209,
0.505058825,
-0.7854554653,
0.0440893136,
0.2731349766,
-0.3580213189,
-0.313251555,
-0.5038291216,
0.0860505104,
-0.4813446403,
0.3089451194,
0.0742771477,
0.7450352311,
0.0303015076,
-0.464060843,
-0.0596546158,
-0.5037521124,
0.6727703214,
-0.5318713784,
0.3487638831,
0.3521669805,
0.5114262104,
-0.0619040616,
-0.7617297769,
-0.289833039,
-0.0151278237,
-0.1230959073,
0.2599709928,
0.206682682,
0.1614556611,
0.267072022,
0.5228472352,
-0.5984262228,
-0.0160332303,
-0.4438139498,
0.1659570634,
0.6798788905,
0.2623587251,
-0.0543630943,
-0.3052771389,
-0.2829541564,
-0.1296802163,
-0.448259443,
0.099041,
-0.2229646295,
0.4497953355,
0.1083013341,
0.3724894822,
-0.6795442104,
0.4140487313,
0.372397244,
-0.1985628009,
0.0565374829,
-0.4459804893,
-0.1675337553,
-0.0168551505,
0.765081048,
0.6866210699,
0.1206695586,
-0.6443181634,
-0.2599643469,
-0.4957871139,
0.061085619,
-1.2361353636,
-0.3003068268,
0.4325186908,
-0.3597059846,
-0.438652426,
0.2092183679,
-0.6315095425,
-0.1333705187,
-0.1851745248,
0.5187913775,
0.0299006291,
-0.0995482877,
-0.4807336032,
-0.2951650918,
0.3496557176,
0.3383488059,
-0.9408277869,
0.2890965343,
0.5532611012,
0.814858675,
-0.3175421357,
-0.2698519826,
-0.9901886582,
0.015557901,
-0.3344408572,
0.7566654086,
-0.3096143007,
-0.9025594592,
-0.2204424441,
-0.1707215011,
-0.1697722524,
-0.8615094423,
0.2379979193,
-0.508731246,
0.605117023,
-0.2584384084,
-0.4347760081,
0.1571783721,
0.0234233625,
-0.2768842876,
1.1143835783,
0.2443991899,
-0.2868746221,
0.6239051223,
-0.4214121401,
-0.4770095646,
0.2528474331,
-0.5137515068,
-0.5270496011,
0.258305043,
0.3644491732,
0.5124295354,
0.0445752889,
0.359392494,
0.0933516771,
-0.4348661005,
0.3438625038,
0.18288818,
0.4059303701,
-0.1013124064,
-0.195475325,
0.6378757358,
-0.8100942373,
0.2721714675,
0.1389144212,
-0.5254861712,
0.0459690392,
0.2798653841,
-0.0803256482,
0.3286050558,
0.0467209034,
-0.2664647698,
-0.0322024561,
-0.5457504988,
0.2411347777,
0.5035160184,
0.4990797639,
0.5255950689,
-0.4945525527,
0.535086751,
-0.1765286177,
0.1788002402,
-0.2061138004,
-0.4452335536,
-0.6016660929,
-0.3215641379,
0.2784782052,
0.3540478051,
-0.6399357319,
0.3629758358,
-0.6282526851,
-0.4607006311,
-0.3699900806,
-0.0802272707,
0.5647533536,
0.228701964,
0.2654847503,
-0.1488314271,
-0.278670013,
-0.5949541926,
-0.2109119147,
-0.2876373827,
-0.1714664102,
0.345664829,
-0.0069808746,
0.5463864207,
0.8219129443,
-0.5577831268,
-0.3047490418,
-0.544152081,
0.1495536417,
0.1443344206,
0.3184301257,
0.5226103663,
-1.0575144291,
-0.2707460225,
-0.2402455956,
-0.5794122219,
0.0744511411,
0.0752054304,
-0.205625087,
-0.0285707191,
0.5169817805,
-0.5489917397,
-0.0018972515,
0.3872277439,
-0.1671251953,
0.4612894952,
0.1232600808,
0.3699809015,
-1.3816019297,
-0.181475088,
-0.549430728,
-0.6090902686,
-0.5084203482,
0.2050488144,
-0.1740505099,
-0.5688994527,
-0.3390842378,
0.1850272119,
-0.5489937663,
-0.2953168452,
-0.2909278274,
0.4203451574,
0.2057867497,
0.8626260757,
0.0738195702,
0.9370852113,
0.272570312,
-0.8303793669,
-0.1351130754,
0.699559629,
-0.4090518057,
0.2845022678,
-0.6628133059,
0.2280234843,
-0.0362435654,
0.0683741346,
-1.2859210968,
-0.2614692152,
-0.1065835804,
-0.8572726846,
0.3879888952,
-0.2683864534,
-0.187406987,
-0.1022490561,
-0.4037716687,
0.2710667253,
0.5031007528,
-0.4939806759,
0.4068193734,
0.7885063887,
-0.6124395728,
-0.2616069615,
-0.2959964871,
0.0071776356,
-0.1161381453,
-0.2040415704,
0.3130904436,
-0.1096033305,
-0.0563383475,
-0.5166817307,
-0.3782932162,
0.1028654054,
0.1973510683,
0.6690032482,
0.0207218416,
-0.0890239179,
0.0528072417,
0.0722772181,
-0.0215571038,
0.2138845026,
-0.2445108742,
0.5073142648,
0.0170148667,
-0.0159697458,
-0.3629718423,
0.7516279817,
0.7901807427,
-0.4128383994,
0.8067986965,
0.2540801167,
-0.2120599896,
0.0007708267,
-0.3522367179,
-0.3144877851,
-0.4341989458,
0.5997259021,
-0.3652952015,
-0.8171458244,
0.5238751173,
-0.1643541157,
0.3587563634,
0.354773134,
0.3542529345,
-0.1051704586,
1.5088595152,
0.5669857264,
-0.1258877516,
0.7288123965,
-0.3117283583,
0.0977617502,
-0.6189283729,
-0.3534170985,
-0.6391888857,
-0.2045162469,
-0.495205909,
-0.3660752177,
0.6651937366,
0.1184099317,
0.2174060494,
0.0466377512,
-0.1927725375,
0.4630948603,
0.3641533554,
-0.0699064881,
0.3094292283,
0.1929084063,
-0.1818687767,
0.0467643291,
-0.7489625216,
-0.3398814201,
0.6148159504,
-0.2307014167,
0.1090031117,
0.291821599,
1.1693143845,
0.0695782676,
0.2435102016,
-0.95521909,
0.7248466611,
0.1358872652,
-0.3432692587,
-0.5431453586,
-0.7877767682,
-0.8617696166,
0.9634968042,
-0.321390897,
-0.7029650807,
0.2465118766,
-0.1107625291,
-0.3573594391,
-0.1712929159,
-0.5340826511,
0.7381036282,
-0.0349198394,
0.0543244258,
-0.198273778,
-0.6218892932,
0.2598241866,
0.2800485492,
0.310028553,
-0.3256899714,
0.247335732,
0.9759659171,
-0.5116105676,
0.3937377632,
-0.2013985068,
0.1013495773,
0.0397936925,
0.0254246555,
0.2922520041,
0.2349452078,
-0.3376115561,
-0.088882789,
-0.0229218062,
-0.2826423049,
-0.6108051538,
0.412707299,
-0.5489524603,
-0.6536411047,
-0.1061782837,
-0.2948969603,
-0.4624934793,
0.2520513833,
0.5138276219,
0.9364131093,
-0.4180983901,
0.0324941613,
0.3152372539,
0.2033483684,
0.4359581172,
0.3745130897,
-0.4949160218,
-0.7248262167,
0.9889922142,
0.0632925928,
0.3890503049,
0.5109666586,
0.0489066988,
-0.2458222359,
-0.8958688974,
-0.4738462567,
0.0488366894,
-0.6301169991,
-0.3883410692,
-0.7890741229,
-0.1967650503,
-0.5468072295,
0.0698489025,
0.0344283357,
-0.9139506221,
0.068240121,
-0.4323313832,
0.0546501353,
0.5230459571,
0.1574410498,
0.438331604,
-0.8471629024,
0.6128952503,
0.4567704797,
-0.0311817899,
0.0629303232,
-0.4165619314,
-0.2948234081,
-0.2296113223,
-0.4442057312,
-0.9703880548,
0.4508615434,
0.5673068166,
0.8279865384,
0.576660037,
0.2724115849,
0.6541058421,
-0.1774528325,
0.8458870053,
0.1457170844,
-0.6425053477,
0.8418405652,
-0.3279696405,
0.4970175922,
0.9351417422,
0.3454561532,
-0.4135445654,
-0.9762912989,
-0.5547444224,
-1.2813609838,
0.9935097694,
0.3818088174,
-0.0069785551,
-0.2850978374,
0.342959851,
0.1407231838,
0.4827769101,
-0.5582657456,
-0.3183284998,
0.0385830365,
0.0025222539,
-0.3309389353,
-0.3833676875,
-0.0683397725,
-0.0767271146,
0.6478728056,
-0.20101583,
0.1405085027,
0.1359470487,
-0.424005419,
-0.109764874,
0.3053088188,
0.4416940808,
0.9688683152,
-0.4082753658,
-0.1051554009,
0.1297106296,
-0.2438749969,
-0.2687130272,
0.2153446674,
-0.18113105,
0.0766065419,
0.1121780053,
0.7752449512,
0.5742332339,
-0.6782604456,
0.5836600065,
-0.4641842842,
-0.333742857,
0.158506766,
0.1969590336,
0.0616669878,
0.2969883084,
0.5671173334,
-0.1918433756,
0.4969787598,
-0.5279232264,
0.3321816325,
0.3632291555,
-0.4663105905,
0.0063038133,
0.7755410075,
0.4072114825,
-0.2736904323,
0.587587893,
-0.3505818546,
-0.7089573145,
0.5197204947,
0.2370382696,
0.638492167,
-0.2482149601,
0.21662274,
0.481317848,
-0.2225299478,
0.2267906517,
0.4410323501,
-0.7940612435,
-0.1954986602,
-0.2980012596,
-0.8798146248,
-0.5958292484,
-0.1037428677,
-1.0784399509,
-0.1258806586,
-0.1756314933,
-0.2706010938,
0.063592039,
0.14298141,
-0.2479004115,
-0.008157705,
0.037047185,
0.3664966822,
-0.3770624697,
0.2587216198,
0.5939727426,
-0.4624628723,
-0.7529622912,
0.1090310812,
-0.2623832524,
-0.554926157,
0.1521204561,
0.4095120728,
-0.1342322379,
0.2599894106,
-0.2449346632,
-0.7744942307,
1.0554932356,
0.1133678481,
-0.2977567017,
-0.178931728,
-0.1779689193,
0.2696281075,
-0.3492362499,
0.3847493231,
0.259701401,
-0.0587239228,
0.1652936935,
-1.0477463007,
0.0327472687,
-0.109059684,
-0.3077206612,
0.4367765784,
-0.6879135966,
0.6241759658,
-0.4408741295,
-0.4244556129,
0.2457617521,
0.954256773,
0.2235738784,
0.3611200154,
0.4429652691,
0.1442587227,
0.8399419188,
-0.082558319,
0.9811230302,
-0.1709543914,
0.3189908564,
1.2510325909,
-0.1778984815,
1.0442790985,
0.1263373494,
-0.1698843092,
0.3330185115,
0.5785981417,
0.2390181869,
0.6187124252,
0.076450333,
-0.095434539,
-0.4316516519,
0.0195104815,
-0.47444278,
0.7429246902,
0.3531717062,
-0.2479501963,
-0.3505650461,
-0.1455244869,
-0.202177301,
-0.1396623105,
-0.392847389,
1.5207207203,
0.2405963987,
-0.971991241,
0.8016628027,
-0.0218650643,
0.2458470166,
-0.4620260596,
0.0109767914,
-0.3861622512,
-0.0276932772,
-0.1091363803,
-0.258338958,
-0.0462071933,
-0.157172218,
-0.3673197329,
-0.3014318645,
0.2699022293,
-0.7282267213,
-0.3640482724,
0.1426170766,
0.7207183242,
0.4183663428,
-0.4200627804,
-0.3083319962,
-0.3982758224,
-0.2864834666,
-0.2167848647,
0.6606357694,
0.1033377945,
-0.0522307046,
0.3170471191,
0.5179594159,
-0.0571099706,
0.0216861051,
0.5898331404,
0.7393690944,
-0.5851510763,
-0.957536459,
-0.3786019683,
0.1916924417,
-0.2620413303,
-0.2810021937,
0.4852156043,
0.8006514907,
0.6000835896,
0.1643271446,
0.5487110615,
0.2576572597,
0.6170126796,
-0.5005016327,
0.8691663146,
-0.6082080007,
-0.010980282,
0.0126762465,
-0.8240963221,
0.0396716148,
0.4728730619,
-0.0514532365,
0.0874163583,
0.4641994536,
0.6588631868,
0.2413827181,
0.092875123,
0.497020483,
-0.0554109961,
0.2532380521,
0.4560311735,
0.8591460586,
-0.5358678102,
0.8260697126,
-0.0949096531,
-0.2264689505,
-0.5362967849,
-0.4272028506,
-0.817555964,
-0.6967763901,
-0.3283797503,
-0.227968514,
0.1251265109,
0.9479981661,
0.9152000546,
-0.8006556034,
-0.331867069,
0.3456948698,
0.3744527996,
-0.4514369667,
-0.2751584053,
0.3192424476,
-0.4031175673,
-0.8556259871,
0.7047992945,
0.179117471,
-0.0918768272,
0.3376383483,
0.1090475917,
-0.0233611185,
0.0172254536,
0.8012881279,
0.1543679833,
-0.4873673916,
-0.0043903338,
-0.0940778553,
-0.0955431759,
0.2121810913,
0.9838109612,
-0.8977270126,
0.113012597,
0.4489379227,
0.2998514175,
0.6772446632,
0.3584164381,
0.6012515426,
-1.0847053528,
-0.2939555347,
0.2118360698,
0.159646824,
0.1775317639,
-0.4635382593,
0.1828687489,
-0.0760792717,
-0.5136044621,
-0.8585031033,
0.1514178365,
-1.2527346611,
-0.1388020515,
1.0071741343,
0.0499237627,
0.1738324463,
0.0414029881,
-0.113683939,
0.3866015077,
-0.4861946702,
0.8234660029,
0.3033783436,
-0.4660890102,
-0.0787940621,
-0.2833851576,
0.7769207358,
0.4297731519,
-0.7490814924,
0.0056453184,
0.5408149362,
0.1040887907,
0.0646913946,
0.9553755522,
-0.2704916894,
0.3801725805,
-0.2795445621,
-0.2935161293,
-0.1421390772,
-0.4500208795,
-0.3104774952,
0.705809176,
0.3323929608,
-0.4743702114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12749v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12749v1 | A Benchmark on Extremely Weakly Supervised Text Classification: Reconcile Seed Matching and Prompting Approaches | 2023-05-22T06:18:23 | 2023-05-22T06:18:23 | Zihan Wang, Tianle Wang, Dheeraj Mekala, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Etremely Weakly Supervised Text Classification (XWS-TC) refers to text
classification based on minimal high-level human guidance, such as a few
label-indicative seed words or classification instructions. There are two
mainstream approaches for XWS-TC, however, never being rigorously compared: (1)
training classifiers based on pseudo-labels generated by (softly) matching seed
words (SEED) and (2) prompting (and calibrating) language models using
classification instruction (and raw texts) to decode label words (PROMPT). This
paper presents the first XWS-TC benchmark to compare the two approaches on fair
grounds, where the datasets, supervisions, and hyperparameter choices are
standardized across methods. Our benchmarking results suggest that (1) Both
SEED and PROMPT approaches are competitive and there is no clear winner; (2)
SEED is empirically more tolerant than PROMPT to human guidance (e.g., seed
words, classification instructions, and label words) changes; (3) SEED is
empirically more selective than PROMPT to the pre-trained language models; (4)
Recent SEED and PROMPT methods have close connections and a clustering
post-processing step based on raw in-domain texts is a strong performance
booster to both. We hope this benchmark serves as a guideline in selecting
XWS-TC methods in different scenarios and stimulate interest in developing
guidance- and model-robust XWS-TC methods. We release the repo at
https://github.com/ZihanWangKi/x-TC. | [
-0.0440447927,
-0.4906962812,
0.597250104,
-0.0044874498,
-0.1297251582,
-0.0981079787,
-0.4713484049,
-0.4124992788,
-0.3843576014,
0.1641997099,
-0.6356533766,
-0.5575802326,
-0.3471928835,
0.2816531658,
-0.6109714508,
1.1465775967,
0.1176286116,
-0.1124325246,
-0.1468090415,
-0.1245679483,
-0.1750970334,
-0.3131993115,
-0.5964708328,
-0.182728827,
0.5889051557,
0.5120518208,
0.5528523326,
0.8312200904,
0.3386989236,
0.3703356683,
-0.3412633538,
-0.0775613561,
-0.4549198747,
0.1475161314,
-0.2136326134,
-0.3482920527,
-0.0941492394,
0.2289057076,
0.4734752774,
0.8068646789,
0.1013423502,
0.2419435233,
0.4598127007,
0.1705223918,
-0.847855866,
0.1417789906,
-0.5452084541,
0.1278031766,
-0.3611725271,
-0.1775289476,
-0.7516893148,
-0.2572013736,
0.4166338742,
-0.5041750669,
0.6008011699,
0.372620225,
0.939242363,
0.0246498212,
-0.4275779128,
-0.2193762362,
-0.2636881173,
1.0349799395,
-0.4876248837,
0.2919160128,
0.3594243228,
0.1254582852,
-0.1862725019,
-1.009807229,
-0.3571927249,
-0.2586353123,
-0.0574305877,
0.3736726344,
-0.4905500114,
0.1991258562,
0.4507037997,
0.4102550745,
-0.6256412864,
0.3304736018,
-0.0887734815,
-0.3642556071,
0.1552787274,
0.1349768639,
-0.1098369062,
-0.3771367669,
-0.6347708106,
-0.5254750848,
-0.3941699862,
0.3743505478,
0.1131777242,
0.6087005138,
-0.2578143179,
0.3302795291,
-0.5000309944,
0.6676843762,
-0.1580448896,
-0.206060335,
0.2892003059,
-0.3158590794,
-0.1918741167,
0.3546622694,
1.0987664461,
0.3228371143,
-0.0428451374,
-0.27530393,
-0.252792865,
0.3137062192,
-0.0734496191,
-0.489920944,
-0.2488591373,
-0.1850774437,
-0.6704824567,
-0.6913846135,
-0.0377006643,
-0.4675891995,
-0.3901246786,
-0.0332819559,
0.2047002912,
-0.1325810552,
0.161281243,
-0.2564347684,
-0.2631911635,
0.2378556579,
0.3776550293,
-0.7734930515,
0.4591704309,
0.7173936963,
1.018746376,
-0.3536843657,
-0.2006199509,
-0.7380183339,
-0.1624728888,
-0.2610833645,
0.9538444281,
-0.2702222168,
-0.2725197077,
0.0078006508,
0.0383487493,
0.2972930372,
-0.3215623796,
1.2954757214,
-0.13790977,
0.3479458094,
-0.4990049601,
-0.5099457502,
-0.0322417095,
0.4300507605,
-0.3637979627,
1.2013301849,
0.2097377479,
-0.989413619,
0.6141997576,
0.0751058832,
-0.2777218223,
0.1027200669,
-0.174376294,
-0.4998660684,
0.0397885256,
-0.1366381794,
0.5959826112,
-0.7267588973,
0.2453381866,
-0.4459541738,
-0.5859642625,
0.084287107,
-0.8326529264,
0.8217750192,
0.0102078049,
-0.5619728565,
0.253905803,
-1.0636270046,
0.4375345111,
-0.0012911607,
-0.0619665422,
-0.5054271221,
-0.0282489434,
0.1872439384,
0.3487025797,
-0.152899012,
-0.5131129622,
0.028821934,
-0.2141930312,
0.4081177711,
0.7810621262,
-0.3448599279,
0.2466612607,
-0.4442224801,
0.1340174526,
-0.0877299383,
0.0627290234,
-0.4204874337,
-0.6875736117,
-0.6091126204,
-0.1053377241,
0.2994228601,
0.4207696319,
-0.6634414792,
0.3435154259,
-0.1569987684,
-0.5815027356,
-0.406596899,
0.0225589462,
0.8038085103,
1.0411645174,
0.4870459735,
0.0536072738,
-0.4797014892,
-0.6045789123,
-0.0790371224,
-0.5717644095,
0.0392934643,
0.0817027241,
0.139005363,
0.074447237,
0.6913712621,
-0.3744346201,
-0.4033700824,
-0.0846131518,
0.5748946071,
0.1438056529,
0.3652272224,
0.3538075089,
-0.6672340631,
-0.5753042698,
0.0520744659,
-0.8251215219,
-0.393322438,
0.1102912426,
0.0685390085,
-0.0014356473,
0.5794516802,
-0.0535277314,
0.3563132286,
0.5056723356,
-0.2278934717,
0.6390327215,
-0.0786381587,
0.2606777251,
-0.6792510748,
-0.0621543676,
0.2465837598,
-0.439230293,
-0.489553839,
0.059209194,
0.4390094578,
0.058287546,
-0.6566584706,
0.429012984,
-0.5390262604,
0.3747072816,
-0.4876837432,
0.1414553672,
-0.0381150544,
0.4138662517,
0.2517494559,
0.746620357,
0.7230465412,
-0.4841534793,
0.3643600345,
0.11367286,
-0.2629391849,
0.5745478272,
-0.6442592144,
0.1045726314,
0.2221689522,
0.183617264,
-1.0955550671,
0.1970477402,
0.2669924498,
-0.2814034522,
0.1882098764,
-0.2291011512,
-0.4617535174,
-0.5166768432,
-0.7097469568,
0.2168540955,
0.7794707417,
-0.7215373516,
0.0315463021,
-0.2587724626,
-0.0025617077,
-0.4733603895,
-0.7227739692,
0.1028291136,
-0.0443031341,
-0.2764783204,
0.4195210934,
0.0999790058,
-0.0539022796,
0.1000896469,
-0.1977787763,
0.0376219973,
0.0254523251,
0.3316140473,
0.2565368116,
-0.4707078338,
-0.2504548728,
0.3051680923,
-0.6076214314,
0.0232619364,
-0.4878981709,
-0.0303193573,
-0.0640932843,
-0.103458941,
-0.5369521379,
0.1622729748,
0.152180478,
0.2767457962,
0.5051048398,
0.504961431,
-0.160435617,
-0.2062660456,
-0.5097533464,
-0.0961460546,
-0.5218319893,
0.0053985566,
-0.4319685102,
-0.6948900819,
0.0834074095,
-0.1447231025,
-0.045013763,
0.1516274512,
0.3184212148,
-0.1586989462,
1.2185097933,
0.7455359697,
-0.1013539284,
0.3458864689,
-0.0288548302,
-0.271892786,
-0.6058526039,
0.0028047522,
-0.9444161654,
-0.0829192549,
-0.6332794428,
-0.0659699589,
-0.0000527582,
-0.0418385305,
0.0825301185,
0.4753290415,
-0.5977073908,
0.3292898536,
0.815936625,
-0.0674217045,
0.4027074873,
-0.10942173,
-0.2833323181,
-0.1840696037,
-0.7456852794,
-0.5782451034,
0.7710519433,
-0.0105693284,
0.7613280416,
-0.2221970558,
0.6668137908,
0.4260097742,
0.3451479375,
-0.7594097257,
0.5713629723,
-0.1427315474,
-0.1459453106,
0.0511233956,
-0.6967915893,
-1.010468483,
0.2037123889,
-0.4065680206,
-0.7675285935,
0.1571657509,
0.2089553326,
-0.2151122093,
0.2817201316,
-1.1125838757,
0.9435665607,
0.0497229844,
-0.4341426194,
0.3748458326,
-0.7986707091,
0.3286366761,
-0.0967680514,
-0.0109695401,
-0.08378952,
-0.2208617479,
0.8527097106,
-0.5873405337,
0.6771669388,
-0.1455191076,
-0.0883829147,
0.3086125851,
-0.2230086327,
0.6336984038,
-0.194843784,
-0.1601037383,
-0.0332316458,
0.0489103831,
-0.5402929187,
-0.4054408669,
0.8552048802,
-0.7758010626,
-0.4272248149,
-0.6707801223,
-0.1820900142,
-0.2538763285,
0.4528165162,
0.7666027546,
0.6520687938,
-0.1219964772,
0.1592808962,
0.8232544065,
0.0142266611,
0.405934602,
0.557887733,
0.1689761132,
-0.1346163154,
1.0423030853,
0.0583496615,
0.1901526004,
0.5891253948,
0.6407207251,
-0.2686395645,
-0.7504982948,
-0.28079319,
-0.19615753,
-0.6813133955,
-0.6370067596,
-0.737631917,
0.0625114292,
-0.4552186728,
-0.2365396768,
-0.1419905871,
-0.0723667964,
-0.1909694374,
0.1114097387,
0.2911901176,
0.6198476553,
0.1497315615,
0.4573601186,
-0.765027225,
0.4791273177,
0.0679129809,
0.2415002733,
0.0070011658,
-0.5451812744,
-0.0350029208,
-0.1248831153,
-0.081765011,
-0.9230504632,
-0.2049610615,
0.0426694192,
0.4176955223,
0.6165803075,
0.7822681069,
0.5432816744,
-0.3899376392,
0.6094303727,
0.3216643929,
-0.9601873755,
0.4944940507,
-0.1279728562,
0.3660351336,
0.958206296,
0.3983370662,
-0.5623944998,
-0.723916173,
-0.6237075925,
-0.841802001,
1.1601015329,
0.1933622509,
-0.0475732237,
-0.2287016064,
0.0885663182,
0.3777671456,
-0.0046717334,
-0.6181974411,
-0.4417354763,
-0.0089001618,
-0.2836438119,
0.2645204961,
-0.2570395172,
0.2010040283,
-0.0219867639,
0.7702496648,
-0.3461395204,
-0.0239713844,
0.117137447,
-0.1609771848,
0.0097877616,
0.2274552584,
0.054753866,
0.1224314719,
-0.179657653,
0.4182645082,
0.3294007778,
-0.5993432403,
0.5218518972,
0.1340018362,
-0.5258151889,
-0.0436069705,
0.6839227676,
0.5684292316,
0.5056186914,
-0.5760524273,
0.8104994893,
-0.4791633189,
-0.2437797934,
0.4122545123,
0.2055677474,
-0.4529493451,
-0.0079337116,
0.2817437649,
0.2272205651,
0.4418598711,
-0.4044986367,
0.0436721481,
0.0781067982,
-0.836150229,
-0.3225657642,
0.6736563444,
0.116898708,
0.0133836381,
0.5529715419,
-0.7534051538,
-0.3713885248,
0.2121438831,
0.5519762635,
0.8972233534,
0.2501497269,
0.2905858159,
0.2262778282,
0.0719284862,
-0.3526970744,
0.0983115956,
-0.6852557659,
-0.3664034307,
-0.3472007513,
-0.0578985214,
-0.6543478966,
-0.033521235,
-0.888112843,
0.5753314495,
-0.3870424926,
-0.161590308,
0.0953368768,
0.3280171454,
-0.4343785048,
0.3030338883,
0.3035753667,
1.2316430807,
-0.9833984375,
0.7854179144,
0.8854962587,
-0.1998419315,
-0.7528656721,
0.1363335103,
0.2956400812,
-0.5396561623,
0.14384754,
0.3015311062,
-0.3477252126,
0.0532537401,
-0.6390846968,
-0.4543693066,
0.783865869,
0.1496589184,
-0.6057002544,
0.0964322239,
-0.3168212473,
0.4483382702,
0.4888838828,
0.5808666348,
0.3873604238,
0.2835941911,
0.0644318312,
-0.659429729,
0.3270397484,
-0.41319561,
-0.0062294407,
0.105341807,
-0.7326018214,
0.4102716446,
-0.1278627068,
-0.4389800131,
0.704216063,
1.1013758183,
0.2723268867,
0.6115679145,
0.6337683797,
0.2619079053,
0.8118415475,
-0.4883728027,
0.9262340665,
-0.044898767,
0.3526459038,
1.0134638548,
-0.4338606894,
0.6965097785,
0.3108288348,
-0.3760604262,
0.2854169607,
0.4878362417,
0.034381181,
0.6257975101,
0.0629420802,
-0.1692592353,
0.0496185012,
-0.446506232,
-0.4980633855,
0.1539548486,
-0.0691357031,
0.0539772585,
-0.3634650409,
0.2644280493,
0.0287899934,
0.2084118724,
-0.2012036443,
0.9144141674,
0.1162883118,
-0.632574439,
0.4808046222,
0.1921158284,
1.0600696802,
-0.8057085872,
0.1767348796,
-0.0516507886,
0.3097820878,
-0.2391626537,
-1.0561597347,
-0.1523057222,
0.362364769,
-0.3243196011,
-0.3600317538,
0.7905537486,
-0.0952378809,
-0.2297205776,
0.450227499,
0.3264241517,
0.0421811491,
0.0852762088,
-0.8024385571,
0.1345620304,
-0.229576081,
-0.2376030833,
0.3051178157,
0.9337612391,
-0.3875052929,
0.4310857356,
0.5820240378,
-0.0053482745,
0.0113592669,
0.3017084002,
0.8558744788,
-0.8417489529,
-0.6614118218,
-0.6421142817,
0.0299926642,
-0.0869881511,
-0.6167928576,
1.0223327875,
0.5299879909,
0.9359721541,
0.3017047644,
0.6871380806,
-0.1592000574,
0.376598686,
-0.4243990779,
0.2904184759,
-0.4002822936,
-0.0779946074,
-0.7112903595,
-0.8185042143,
-0.2843019962,
0.2592470944,
-0.1247866899,
0.1105962396,
0.7999904752,
0.5737627149,
-0.1626214087,
0.2271283716,
0.3368887603,
0.1082976833,
0.1233492047,
0.404779315,
1.211537838,
-0.5593666434,
0.9229351878,
-0.5516042113,
-0.4719849229,
-0.0689202473,
-0.9541223645,
-0.8427643776,
-0.3948099613,
-0.55957371,
-0.3865391314,
0.2390382588,
1.0099132061,
0.8389484882,
-0.9216899276,
0.0433544107,
-0.2051359713,
0.1597051322,
-0.7173827887,
-0.227448985,
0.3868735731,
-0.4933654368,
-0.6457264423,
0.342423737,
0.2177131921,
0.151976198,
0.0734439716,
0.0542359278,
0.0982578695,
-0.4095624089,
0.429220587,
0.3442007303,
-0.3255591989,
0.0315293968,
0.160752818,
-0.4903388619,
-0.0019733123,
0.8734354377,
-1.0390946865,
0.3986236155,
0.7276634574,
0.4310616851,
0.2264779061,
-0.0234760251,
0.254858464,
-0.8791154623,
0.2552276552,
0.0401750952,
0.2381890863,
0.3497954905,
-0.1670397073,
0.282753706,
0.3338687718,
-0.2694147229,
-1.0146300793,
-0.1914210171,
-1.0724486113,
-0.1585189104,
0.9268518686,
-0.3951717615,
-0.516943872,
-0.2869795859,
-0.4419876933,
0.264542073,
-0.4167713523,
0.4043517113,
0.3650416136,
0.2328438312,
-0.1624761075,
-0.1697074175,
0.3253863752,
0.4386923313,
-0.6253961921,
0.1765362918,
0.0169625226,
-0.2703804672,
-0.060531728,
0.6362273097,
0.0738196,
0.4371028244,
0.2568356991,
-0.3325355947,
0.0021031997,
-0.307169199,
-0.3616963029,
0.1180638,
0.1329757571,
-0.1381765753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12744v1 | Fact-Checking Complex Claims with Program-Guided Reasoning | 2023-05-22T06:11:15 | 2023-05-22T06:11:15 | Liangming Pan, Xiaobao Wu, Xinyuan Lu, Anh Tuan Luu, William Yang Wang, Min-Yen Kan, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Fact-checking real-world claims often requires collecting multiple pieces of
evidence and applying complex multi-step reasoning. In this paper, we present
Program-Guided Fact-Checking (ProgramFC), a novel fact-checking model that
decomposes complex claims into simpler sub-tasks that can be solved using a
shared library of specialized functions. We first leverage the in-context
learning ability of large language models to generate reasoning programs to
guide the verification process. Afterward, we execute the program by delegating
each sub-task to the corresponding sub-task handler. This process makes our
model both explanatory and data-efficient, providing clear explanations of its
reasoning process and requiring minimal training data. We evaluate ProgramFC on
two challenging fact-checking datasets and show that it outperforms seven
fact-checking baselines across different settings of evidence availability,
with explicit output programs that benefit human debugging. Our codes and data
are publicly available at https://github.com/mbzuai-nlp/ProgramFC. | [
-0.1602095515,
-0.8651368618,
0.7364754677,
0.2391172945,
-0.1466096193,
0.17093274,
-0.0884627476,
-0.4097321033,
-0.3079834282,
0.6875055432,
-0.413434267,
-0.6104902029,
-0.7029636502,
0.0162617788,
-0.3696406484,
1.1968021393,
-0.1348755062,
-0.1355419904,
-0.4049330056,
0.0319976248,
-0.2938921154,
-0.3920363784,
-0.2844409645,
-0.7233929038,
0.1423867792,
0.6390991807,
0.4459887445,
0.4021239281,
0.3973945081,
0.2002354413,
0.082455419,
0.5135057569,
-0.4187911749,
-0.2358282655,
-0.0570657104,
-0.54526788,
-0.3242679834,
-0.0424173735,
0.20783104,
0.5791611075,
-0.1821800172,
0.2816236317,
-0.1236805841,
0.3682340086,
-0.7283116579,
0.5415961742,
-0.3861868083,
-0.0336009003,
0.018018689,
-0.037182115,
-0.5591648817,
-0.6488286853,
0.0822573751,
-0.4397350848,
0.4920403063,
0.2060204893,
0.9788103104,
0.2153753787,
-0.7671241164,
-0.5421849489,
-0.6490851641,
0.5423218608,
-0.5169597268,
0.077849783,
0.4907409847,
0.3033509254,
-0.1308307499,
-0.5513566732,
-0.4341793358,
-0.3953747451,
-0.3553088605,
-0.0023313919,
0.0746907443,
0.2602552772,
0.7201619744,
0.2685777545,
-0.6796375513,
-0.3240602911,
-0.4195213914,
-0.5849168897,
0.524554491,
-0.1400557756,
0.2505206764,
-0.0447401702,
-0.3470028639,
0.1467435658,
-1.0673171282,
0.3491967022,
0.251319468,
0.187670812,
-0.1175302044,
0.5094178319,
-0.4964182377,
0.6612035632,
-0.1598580629,
-0.3119986653,
-0.0640177354,
-0.3504275084,
-0.3224617243,
0.522518754,
0.2837307155,
0.1050042212,
0.0371865332,
-0.1267146617,
-0.1498002708,
0.1760554463,
-0.095508039,
-0.8983807564,
-0.454280436,
0.2185040861,
-0.4104361832,
-0.2554841638,
0.2585499883,
-0.1280038953,
-0.5340480804,
-0.363624841,
0.3890029192,
-0.281727463,
-0.114905946,
0.5270339251,
-0.1197811738,
0.0736859888,
0.5118393898,
-0.3133203983,
0.1079896539,
0.8917701244,
0.6397662163,
0.2754983008,
0.0211748183,
-1.0826538801,
0.1379972994,
-0.2321647704,
1.0550730228,
-0.5709462166,
-0.1020454019,
-0.0252179913,
-0.028823249,
0.1686613262,
-0.6269484162,
0.8941015601,
-0.4636535943,
-0.1266955137,
-0.7428997159,
-0.6752617955,
-0.2514113784,
0.7141937613,
-0.6853541732,
0.8142264485,
-0.2132708579,
-0.634163022,
0.4408888817,
-0.574049294,
-0.6241368651,
0.0163330156,
-0.2997902036,
-0.4123037755,
-0.0479078554,
0.2402499318,
0.2523812652,
-0.2768069804,
0.7288207412,
-0.369440943,
-0.3106715977,
0.0469822846,
-0.1804714948,
0.9350957274,
0.1887123585,
-0.5104523301,
-0.0496752225,
-0.8933711648,
-0.2109467983,
-0.0186088663,
-0.701461494,
-0.3085522056,
0.0544982664,
-0.2503406107,
0.0149496188,
0.27500844,
-1.0688815117,
0.4824340343,
-0.0334333703,
0.1387585402,
0.3185119629,
-0.1492143124,
-0.104362689,
-0.3159532249,
0.2681767046,
0.1925497204,
0.2915818989,
-0.4475419819,
-0.3030781746,
-0.6615514159,
-0.2946270406,
0.327911973,
0.7472762465,
-0.6898195148,
0.2886382639,
0.0275806561,
-0.170941323,
-0.0961648896,
-0.1331304908,
0.3911298513,
0.7735271454,
0.3776890635,
0.2081730068,
-0.4497957528,
-0.8850617409,
-0.4776112735,
-0.2870976329,
0.083853364,
0.1050411165,
0.6023548841,
-0.11636246,
1.0248974562,
-0.9479039311,
-0.0897136331,
-0.2857336104,
0.5200018287,
0.2182106078,
0.433755964,
0.3778576553,
-0.6926720738,
-0.213582024,
-0.1217538863,
-0.8098522425,
-0.4163999856,
-0.4678889513,
0.0086788442,
-0.216611445,
0.380191654,
-0.6567820907,
0.4437569082,
0.3658427596,
-0.6540147662,
0.8950158954,
-0.234614104,
0.2696178854,
-0.5194911957,
0.1312012821,
-0.1193755642,
-0.5488114357,
-0.3913466334,
0.2258991748,
0.1835373938,
0.0890221894,
-0.0938931555,
-0.0208945423,
-0.3360849619,
0.0978345647,
-0.4666180611,
-0.079584606,
0.1383411586,
0.3574485183,
-0.1139288619,
0.2556224167,
0.6666402817,
-0.6149848104,
0.6114193797,
0.103110902,
-0.7772114873,
0.5040261745,
-0.6813320518,
-0.0959937945,
-0.1995533705,
0.5426294208,
-0.7402673364,
-0.235205844,
0.1141384616,
0.0333767571,
0.0523304492,
-0.3093172014,
-0.5843366981,
-0.1966882348,
-0.1039748639,
0.1491444111,
0.0769366696,
-0.842261672,
0.7489094734,
0.1658251584,
-0.0381036103,
-0.73865062,
-0.5411091447,
0.1759315431,
0.2105782032,
-0.4699557126,
0.4337429404,
-0.0440756194,
-0.4085876346,
0.0657507628,
-0.4868059456,
-0.2648515701,
0.0643700734,
0.3258700073,
0.1417068541,
-0.1218173802,
0.0066728899,
0.3402097523,
-0.0153220631,
0.2096635252,
-0.1583208889,
-0.0263799317,
-0.3150529563,
-0.8522558808,
-0.1483880579,
0.5995534658,
0.6385381222,
-0.2583675981,
0.4468886256,
0.5486134291,
-0.5849608183,
-0.2850904167,
-0.656596005,
-0.2053832114,
-0.3902475536,
0.1504971981,
-0.3946178854,
-0.9358627796,
0.4507438838,
-0.6512638927,
0.5562140346,
0.1281866729,
0.2708914578,
0.1933788061,
0.9517087936,
0.5209736824,
0.2657591999,
0.0962203965,
-0.1893418878,
0.6281341314,
-0.1906510592,
-0.5153548121,
-0.6091012955,
0.057552278,
-0.0491403043,
-0.3219187558,
0.3094313741,
0.1761793941,
-0.1273560524,
0.1173443049,
-0.1395640224,
0.7119033933,
0.5208360553,
0.3269968033,
0.802854538,
-0.3068803847,
-0.045853667,
0.2842727304,
-0.5605378151,
-0.4757201374,
0.6802632809,
0.1192511767,
0.723395586,
0.2491780668,
0.6640319228,
0.6470752954,
0.5538745522,
-0.657654345,
0.5473963022,
-0.1563428491,
-0.7622590065,
0.0523538589,
-0.4302518666,
-0.3995234966,
0.3329963684,
-0.3600755632,
-0.3790843487,
0.0991559774,
0.4608651102,
-0.6589151621,
0.1691023856,
-0.7139339447,
0.7301393151,
-0.2723376155,
-0.0663791746,
-0.7153855562,
-0.4340120256,
0.8291498423,
0.1417355686,
0.2176237404,
-0.3025151491,
0.4342015386,
0.3182757795,
-0.6108933687,
0.9068130255,
-0.4966757298,
-0.1332554966,
0.5428564548,
0.2041629851,
0.7231765389,
0.3948178589,
0.1901198924,
0.0106422883,
0.2852030396,
-0.359377265,
-0.550348103,
0.5649009943,
-0.3227057755,
-0.7066136599,
-0.5085158348,
-0.4121657312,
-0.0422582179,
0.2931899428,
-0.0190381631,
0.7775127888,
-0.4002362192,
0.3858934045,
1.0466753244,
-0.2836559713,
0.1545962095,
0.7116618156,
-0.00992426,
0.1440780759,
0.7388240695,
-0.1162662655,
-0.1488650292,
0.5828287005,
0.4442267418,
-0.2910417318,
-0.4668533802,
-0.3644419909,
0.0547676347,
-0.7924984097,
-0.2423146665,
-0.7505020499,
0.2710815966,
-0.2329063267,
0.158813715,
-0.4782842696,
-0.3255337775,
0.2285113335,
-0.2041221559,
-0.0348260291,
0.7432535887,
0.0100461431,
0.0163718406,
-0.8639909625,
0.7824009657,
0.4859001338,
0.3099556267,
-0.452044338,
-0.0782219693,
-0.2484548837,
0.0392979495,
-0.1205212921,
-0.8171958327,
-0.1832884997,
0.2400741875,
0.4813885391,
0.3987924457,
0.5860110521,
0.5851362944,
-0.1860366464,
0.7139135003,
0.0368704498,
-1.034311533,
0.6222823262,
-0.0992522761,
0.191661194,
0.5157305002,
0.1079101712,
-0.3584053814,
-0.3501582742,
-0.3338829279,
-0.5150740743,
0.7462420464,
0.0550352074,
-0.3304441571,
0.2573595643,
0.4850786626,
0.1702921242,
0.0250276662,
-0.5614976287,
-0.018460609,
-0.276224196,
-0.2592398822,
0.4848180413,
-0.1463129371,
-0.6240209937,
-0.0664669201,
0.6776304245,
-0.5210841894,
-0.104392536,
0.4023375511,
-0.3853588998,
0.1796839237,
0.401581645,
0.7323874831,
0.5645720363,
-0.1540057063,
0.4556119144,
0.0266579986,
-0.4988285899,
0.0205306187,
0.1664792001,
-0.3391593397,
0.1014814824,
0.3984725773,
0.5595454574,
0.0749154389,
-1.0196849108,
0.5702258348,
-0.2830271721,
-0.2392602414,
-0.0495491549,
0.2525053322,
0.1508297175,
0.4079272449,
0.4327435791,
0.3310699463,
0.1847559512,
-0.4446696341,
0.2371328175,
0.1823250353,
0.2025789917,
-0.2165420949,
0.3524487913,
0.2417204827,
0.201754719,
0.6313708425,
-0.2368473858,
-0.5920019746,
0.8853530884,
0.4429487586,
0.6822323799,
0.1737982184,
0.3970247507,
0.5141381025,
0.4002861679,
-0.6216638088,
0.1883188635,
-0.4106841683,
-0.6373586655,
-0.8109317422,
-0.3725711405,
-0.6333709955,
0.2350222766,
-0.5862476826,
0.0450091176,
-0.5318217874,
0.0280870665,
0.031748984,
-0.0514396317,
-0.4757074714,
0.2009976208,
0.1160088107,
0.9201976061,
-0.9797216058,
0.8655910492,
0.5841365457,
-0.1542265117,
-0.6217721105,
0.1333785951,
0.2333149761,
-0.4737858772,
0.814563036,
0.2395443916,
-0.5766376257,
-0.3901908398,
-0.8845790625,
-0.6436074972,
0.8362938762,
0.8072941899,
-0.5826904774,
0.2084467709,
-0.0741960406,
0.2754457891,
-0.368707329,
-0.1090367138,
0.5202593803,
0.5129070282,
0.2021512687,
-0.6234654188,
0.3031628132,
0.0474442095,
-0.5807648301,
-0.1441288143,
-0.4658032358,
0.5823942423,
-0.6391545534,
-0.0650198683,
-0.3748629987,
0.7679419518,
0.4641070664,
0.4642189443,
0.7914501429,
0.4049372077,
0.9418029785,
-0.2408251464,
0.8439591527,
-0.3751965463,
0.5647985339,
1.2394829988,
-0.2093131989,
0.4001409411,
0.1342552453,
-0.0293900501,
0.7052362561,
0.4897226393,
-0.0929163992,
0.2864490151,
0.1506923288,
-0.4011109471,
-0.8208075166,
-0.3489872515,
0.0329287089,
0.5202253461,
0.3615097106,
-0.0978843048,
-0.4516896009,
-0.1552580893,
0.1411121339,
-0.087772198,
-0.0483173057,
0.2553766072,
-0.1101618856,
-1.1275936365,
0.3139036298,
0.181075111,
0.4348521233,
-0.6009222269,
-0.3596535623,
-0.0622331351,
0.3248638809,
-0.5647065639,
-0.7454918623,
0.4735143781,
0.4247195125,
-0.3029690385,
-0.2541517317,
0.8879820704,
-0.5453116298,
-0.0728650987,
-0.0935695469,
0.2669384181,
-0.1052820086,
-0.3991823494,
-0.6951838136,
0.0499911942,
0.0615842715,
-0.216770187,
0.0238473359,
0.1346228123,
-0.2097765505,
0.6357883215,
0.7363330126,
-0.1018454656,
-0.1630601734,
0.3948063254,
0.5851226449,
-0.3576948345,
-0.5325776935,
-0.8648662567,
0.204744339,
-0.2357324213,
0.1449569315,
0.5725036263,
0.7618589401,
0.6753612757,
-0.044381056,
0.9761996865,
-0.3959767222,
0.1429244131,
-0.4823699892,
0.364789784,
-0.1339574009,
0.2406268269,
0.1102577001,
-0.3391957879,
-0.5301520824,
0.6746513844,
-0.1151657999,
-0.2538614571,
0.5820188522,
0.883713305,
-0.1544695497,
0.295266211,
0.0707933158,
0.1651839465,
0.7268325686,
0.7355177402,
0.7700694203,
-0.1706848145,
0.7027264237,
-0.1224290878,
-0.4400308728,
-0.385127455,
-1.2569925785,
-0.7773498297,
-0.1628499627,
-0.9524886608,
-0.5175396204,
-0.2955671549,
0.9315374494,
0.8353165984,
-1.0284655094,
0.168461591,
-0.2393125743,
0.472522229,
-0.5165899992,
-0.166323632,
0.4396630228,
-0.0321808569,
-0.4588380456,
0.3949506581,
0.3661758006,
-0.3829360306,
-0.1689128727,
-0.0452282727,
-0.2268033326,
0.1247306764,
0.6960632205,
0.5254184604,
-0.6390711069,
-0.3463699818,
-0.2381304353,
-0.1473848224,
-0.1927349418,
1.4690535069,
-0.6038182974,
0.4949582219,
0.870746851,
0.6151147485,
0.5421206951,
0.1193169281,
0.2741852403,
-0.7891945839,
-0.2358525693,
-0.009457116,
0.6230178475,
0.2078055292,
-0.5240254402,
0.2468063682,
0.499445647,
-0.3339523077,
-0.8745381832,
0.5535878539,
-0.938277781,
-0.4282880723,
0.8760796189,
-0.6423724294,
-0.0324226022,
-0.5022683144,
-0.340294987,
0.2633912563,
-0.2290219516,
1.0301240683,
0.7815104723,
-0.4850234687,
0.0245207213,
-0.3002305031,
0.4897437692,
0.1021156907,
-0.8429751992,
0.5605834126,
0.7343567014,
0.5550242662,
0.1715715528,
0.4642338455,
0.0251250062,
0.3264058232,
0.105143711,
-0.0516039543,
-0.4871864617,
-0.4701764882,
0.0082742004,
0.6458869576,
-0.1258136034,
-0.0652726516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12740v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12740v1 | Can We Edit Factual Knowledge by In-Context Learning? | 2023-05-22T06:07:58 | 2023-05-22T06:07:58 | Ce Zheng, Lei Li, Qingxiu Dong, Yuxuan Fan, Zhiyong Wu, Jingjing Xu, Baobao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous studies have shown that large language models (LLMs) like GPTs store
massive factual knowledge in their parameters. However, the stored knowledge
could be false or out-dated. Traditional knowledge editing methods refine LLMs
via fine-tuning on texts containing specific knowledge. However, with the
increasing scales of LLMs, these gradient-based approaches bring large
computation costs. The trend of model-as-a-service also makes it impossible to
modify knowledge in black-box LMs. Inspired by in-context learning (ICL), a new
paradigm based on demonstration contexts without parameter updating, we explore
whether ICL can edit factual knowledge. To answer this question, we give a
comprehensive empirical study of ICL strategies. Experiments show that
in-context knowledge editing (IKE), without any gradient and parameter
updating, achieves a competitive success rate compared to gradient-based
methods on GPT-J (6B) but with much fewer side effects, including less
over-editing on similar but unrelated facts and less knowledge forgetting on
previously stored knowledge. We also apply the method to larger LMs with tens
or hundreds of parameters like OPT-175B, which shows the scalability of our
method. The code is available at https://github.com/Zce1112zslx/IKE. | [
-0.2894363701,
-0.8087299466,
0.7933420539,
-0.1248280033,
-0.1794195473,
0.2333229035,
-0.4189529121,
-0.6067742109,
-0.1982750446,
0.3728156984,
-0.4039128721,
-0.5289760828,
-0.2895136178,
-0.0244689826,
-0.2379983217,
1.1850206852,
-0.0878279135,
0.1251582503,
-0.5113950372,
-0.4363172948,
-0.3202089071,
-0.4612506628,
-0.6963356733,
-0.0494119748,
0.1854711175,
0.6009052396,
0.5420755148,
0.696667552,
0.1499549896,
0.2871721983,
-0.5608482957,
0.3444706202,
-0.4430474639,
0.0450946428,
-0.4927675426,
-0.4717446566,
-0.4940923154,
-0.1551835537,
0.8550100923,
0.739227891,
-0.008127219,
-0.0537808724,
0.2586878538,
0.6070141792,
-0.5523414612,
0.0260775499,
-1.0810462236,
-0.1049392074,
-0.0353051126,
-0.1105373278,
-0.3624738753,
-0.17772533,
0.2605155706,
-0.4667195678,
0.2298704237,
0.1916037798,
0.6633139253,
0.320145309,
-0.3272897303,
-0.4481089711,
-0.6003400683,
0.669175148,
-0.6995865703,
0.4165698886,
0.2443231344,
0.1855950207,
-0.0903554708,
-0.6568044424,
-0.6220212579,
-0.3104810417,
-0.2679737806,
-0.1564177126,
0.1134474352,
0.2789985836,
0.6644799113,
0.0817302763,
0.0430996567,
0.0326473452,
-0.2941828072,
0.0689608231,
0.4278322458,
0.0031569581,
0.3987766504,
-0.2057363242,
-0.5868284106,
0.2073996514,
-1.1507973671,
0.1534176469,
-0.1476472467,
0.0096298456,
0.0354857147,
0.4716780782,
-0.2032131255,
0.6847392321,
0.3638945818,
-0.3565445244,
-0.1449741125,
-0.05762963,
-0.4975572526,
0.2640972435,
0.3591735661,
0.3801691532,
-0.2976476252,
-0.4597711563,
-0.4240362048,
-0.3941313922,
0.1040888131,
-0.6175757051,
0.1524027586,
-0.0791237354,
-0.0803042576,
-0.036448732,
-0.1068343893,
-0.5974174738,
-0.4288622439,
-0.5038205385,
0.6776249409,
-0.6207871437,
0.4678158164,
0.0083836131,
-0.0399387218,
0.012698004,
0.7583674192,
-0.5644562244,
0.2485381961,
0.5266754627,
0.8687497377,
0.2203516811,
-0.3420393169,
-0.5074345469,
0.3073987365,
-0.3794032633,
0.4485113025,
-0.323059082,
-0.2420872897,
-0.0502861328,
-0.3025422692,
0.1768326014,
-0.4732714593,
0.4255711138,
-1.0122126341,
0.1269369423,
-0.7356713414,
-1.053973794,
-0.175822556,
0.3029004335,
-0.3426119387,
0.8223065734,
0.0138444677,
-0.6870270371,
0.6701452136,
-0.8810596466,
-0.515094161,
0.1078142896,
-0.0220558699,
-0.151979208,
-0.0352731086,
0.2274066359,
0.5167373419,
-0.117302753,
0.6308647394,
-0.1964098513,
-0.4563606083,
0.3707321882,
-0.3898806572,
0.7945408821,
-0.0184754189,
-0.6953980923,
-0.0369031727,
-0.8411517143,
-0.3299542964,
-0.4800611436,
-0.5055189133,
-0.3445132077,
0.1055247337,
-0.3195801079,
0.440880239,
0.1781040877,
-0.8262067437,
0.3623075783,
-0.2412888706,
0.3188633025,
0.8984590769,
0.1077376083,
0.5763761997,
-0.3764392436,
0.2802511752,
-0.0984776542,
0.0888782814,
0.0007770272,
-0.3487341404,
-1.0051047802,
-0.4264393151,
0.288269639,
0.2663436234,
-0.966165185,
0.2257823199,
-0.2721706927,
-0.3320952654,
-0.4337216318,
0.2037138641,
0.4409630001,
1.056994319,
0.6410469413,
0.2246915549,
-0.5035333633,
-0.7423533797,
-0.4601814151,
-0.010694189,
-0.0563829616,
0.3851839304,
0.5487889647,
-0.1418112516,
1.2143367529,
-0.4320046604,
-0.3216491938,
-0.0233872142,
0.008269636,
-0.0996266752,
0.3821259439,
0.6211157441,
-0.5984686613,
-0.801727891,
0.093492575,
-0.9382095337,
-0.0925469846,
-0.2362530231,
0.1137506887,
0.3382343054,
0.8354552388,
-0.5797123909,
0.421341747,
0.3076287508,
-0.2807497084,
0.3953644335,
-0.4971866608,
0.2542180717,
-0.7621768713,
-0.1410654634,
0.0109827789,
-0.3029896319,
-0.6070898771,
0.2117423415,
0.6010823846,
0.047905013,
-0.617833972,
0.8697125912,
-0.2898627818,
0.1196258888,
-0.1270054132,
0.1212320626,
-0.0130819464,
0.6958217025,
-0.0056284671,
0.8998590112,
0.5984161496,
-0.8041402698,
0.0190321654,
0.2382077873,
-0.8269091249,
0.696020782,
-0.4319407344,
0.1055775434,
-0.3997680545,
0.5319027305,
-0.6044968367,
-0.0532268025,
0.2653337419,
0.043664448,
0.3262310326,
-0.3340286016,
-0.4042327702,
0.4239338636,
-0.2432987988,
0.1046551988,
0.426335752,
-1.0363969803,
0.4237394929,
0.0986339822,
-0.118988499,
-0.6619770527,
-0.7371037602,
0.3675403297,
-0.3039846718,
-0.5098751783,
0.6655730605,
-0.2883272171,
-0.454351753,
0.159119159,
0.0821663514,
-0.1115982607,
0.0301618036,
-0.1067925021,
0.2212592959,
-0.1915395409,
0.4035336971,
0.4540657103,
0.1552771479,
-0.1485012323,
-0.3933418691,
-0.0959177688,
-0.1162135899,
-0.3445058167,
-0.5222234726,
0.1245833114,
0.7833884954,
-0.0756946132,
0.9367612004,
0.0541891493,
-0.5198928118,
-0.286016047,
-0.6156270504,
-0.0109979445,
-0.4818190634,
0.341684401,
-0.328096956,
-0.9178745151,
0.4103664756,
-0.1626481563,
0.1014012918,
0.2155497819,
0.1643168777,
-0.2944811881,
0.7104145288,
0.3574182689,
0.0258055888,
0.4177136123,
-0.2021915019,
0.1572787613,
-1.2151364088,
-0.0518899485,
-0.3670526743,
-0.4533003271,
-0.2570990324,
-0.2795101702,
0.8392524719,
0.1763773859,
-0.3289541006,
-0.0071439454,
0.1268698424,
0.7319034934,
0.4392148554,
0.4925674498,
0.422927916,
-0.2769382298,
-0.1080031767,
-0.1997401863,
-0.8611364961,
-0.3768543899,
1.2289916277,
0.1388493031,
0.5247456431,
0.2936557233,
0.2957706749,
0.3963806331,
0.806512475,
-0.4836010039,
0.5598621368,
0.0088714976,
-0.6352301836,
-0.5332399011,
-0.241473496,
-0.1922820061,
0.3097241819,
-0.2603317797,
-0.6353423595,
0.3064858019,
0.4344158769,
-0.2370641083,
0.8024891615,
-0.6084148884,
0.4466420114,
-0.2742567062,
-0.5525100827,
-0.2047298253,
-0.583096683,
0.2095450461,
-0.1435676068,
0.3270519674,
0.3964012265,
-0.0631455258,
0.4304392636,
-0.5831137896,
0.8983204961,
-0.4768186212,
0.0357071906,
0.0390513539,
0.1208334044,
0.8173464537,
0.4462999403,
-0.2191455513,
-0.0492042638,
-0.3293260634,
-0.3396319747,
-1.110378623,
0.7637376785,
-0.5051919818,
-0.6665978432,
-0.2751678824,
-0.5013874173,
-0.5591515303,
-0.0227324609,
0.2827472389,
0.8110018969,
-0.2123033702,
0.5928589702,
0.9050146341,
-0.153160587,
0.4179569185,
0.5383880734,
0.0234934986,
-0.2627158165,
0.6975089312,
0.3502840996,
0.4687972367,
0.6561881304,
0.3784870505,
-0.3882399797,
-0.6271069646,
-0.6770170927,
-0.0017736093,
-1.0189870596,
-0.167131424,
-0.7859745622,
-0.0040953504,
-0.0160312131,
-0.7134230137,
-0.2040518969,
-0.3050772548,
-0.1049019247,
-0.1551038772,
0.3039551377,
0.686876297,
-0.1281811148,
0.3184931278,
-0.3869618177,
0.1804674119,
0.5607270598,
0.4729093313,
0.1233015805,
-0.5655581355,
-0.4027423263,
0.3812839687,
-0.0356555693,
-0.6117398143,
0.0911719352,
0.2988576591,
0.2791159749,
0.3409152627,
0.0288489182,
0.8617638946,
-0.4851877689,
0.8840094805,
-0.2277226597,
-1.3743146658,
0.2061912119,
-0.2694972754,
0.175525412,
0.5885932446,
0.2964312434,
-0.7353513241,
-0.3154610693,
-0.7961205244,
-0.3620412052,
0.8354297876,
-0.2845352888,
0.20768857,
0.2002638727,
0.6711955667,
0.1132380888,
0.4053048193,
-0.6174658537,
-0.2416223884,
-0.1525177658,
-0.0615428127,
-0.1480162889,
-0.458332181,
-0.1928035021,
-0.710916996,
1.0402780771,
-0.1723898947,
-0.1163741574,
0.3704120815,
-0.5176903009,
-0.0117662875,
0.3932374418,
0.8318995833,
0.9997121692,
-0.2878222764,
-0.0733629912,
0.6860840917,
-0.0662794113,
0.0973145962,
-0.3655569851,
-0.7434282899,
-0.1292435676,
0.3507317603,
1.0342795849,
0.8545483947,
-0.6534698009,
0.5413735509,
-0.0177055169,
-0.3219158649,
0.0386790745,
-0.0000646595,
-0.1418112814,
0.0879953057,
0.2533198297,
0.433249414,
-0.0615531728,
-0.5200224519,
0.1165444478,
0.3882088959,
-0.4988147318,
-0.1505441368,
0.6625500917,
0.0202782899,
-0.1789661795,
0.4933577776,
-0.2895823419,
-0.4553677738,
0.2304047197,
0.6578862071,
0.5524842143,
-0.0006273703,
0.3076848984,
0.0518646017,
0.1608772129,
0.044789128,
-0.2406218797,
-0.1509338021,
-0.9017697573,
-0.335578084,
-0.3119878471,
-0.6155467629,
0.3356825113,
-0.3839465678,
0.3413802981,
-0.7301240563,
0.4402033985,
-0.1084343344,
-0.1181351915,
-0.7231788039,
0.5109503269,
-0.4585254788,
0.8491837382,
-0.5975388288,
0.8940056562,
0.8437225223,
-0.0144907311,
-0.4859183431,
0.1523401439,
0.0481327511,
-0.4694150686,
0.5318384767,
-0.2821418643,
-0.0814445987,
0.0186325107,
-0.7240801454,
-0.8269981146,
1.0820771456,
0.651309669,
-0.2796039879,
0.0784917772,
-0.1091777682,
0.5669602156,
-0.2194797695,
-0.0345742032,
0.2193470001,
0.4695126116,
0.1020603776,
-0.4860759377,
-0.0438640192,
0.1512531638,
-0.1129052415,
-0.0641505718,
-0.5874977708,
0.9709684253,
-0.0973087251,
-0.1681566834,
-0.1514321566,
0.6801085472,
-0.0718725175,
0.117039226,
0.3713416755,
0.4465723336,
0.9652149081,
0.1908165663,
1.0031132698,
-0.402405113,
0.3782519698,
1.1862502098,
-0.4310187399,
0.5147113204,
0.5001614094,
0.0317206047,
0.5167964101,
0.2650315166,
0.481536001,
0.4783443809,
-0.203207016,
-0.5894346237,
-0.0408137105,
0.1339703351,
-0.213498503,
0.3635559678,
0.3970615566,
-0.0821472928,
-0.1959179491,
0.169649303,
0.5270427465,
0.2059003264,
-0.3240378499,
0.7083428502,
-0.1743297428,
-0.6512527466,
0.4594067633,
0.3107227087,
0.6951964498,
-0.6055935621,
-0.0647234991,
-0.2138896435,
0.0523048118,
-0.0250240024,
-0.655831039,
0.2225659043,
0.1336456686,
-0.2142184973,
-0.3952648938,
0.6470223069,
-0.5352742076,
-0.2957739532,
0.0327601098,
0.3364225626,
-0.4461993575,
-0.0917265862,
-0.3796515465,
-0.1889648587,
-0.0055005141,
-0.0889754593,
0.5709373951,
0.5491174459,
-0.0745938271,
0.7908598185,
0.6125429273,
0.1112237424,
-0.0914328992,
-0.4012520015,
0.7485322356,
-0.4186224937,
-0.6172369123,
-0.8199346662,
0.6433190703,
-0.2384411395,
-0.354480058,
0.6058469415,
0.3918857872,
1.1925258636,
-0.1859037578,
1.1020997763,
-0.0757205263,
0.4280793965,
-0.9772621393,
0.8042691946,
-0.6827553511,
0.2898487449,
-0.3926422298,
-0.6408923268,
-0.343156755,
0.3017292023,
-0.3191103041,
-0.2650474906,
0.8639017344,
0.7492290735,
-0.1751904637,
0.2066908926,
0.3604310453,
0.474740237,
0.3877215683,
0.069186382,
0.7381370664,
-0.2051556855,
-0.0536926128,
-0.5349071622,
-0.3422674537,
-0.1622835249,
-1.0141762495,
-0.7813078165,
-0.7257606387,
-0.2660467327,
-0.1161958799,
0.327054292,
1.0725353956,
0.5607138276,
-0.5332117677,
-0.1449481994,
0.1086947322,
0.3889884949,
-0.4521365464,
-0.1882272363,
0.62921381,
-0.3817229271,
-0.5776808262,
0.7539248466,
0.2816302776,
-0.1004022881,
-0.0106539642,
-0.1126211733,
-0.2690608501,
-0.0246163737,
0.8363207579,
0.3089610636,
-0.6605861187,
-0.6721645594,
-0.2877383232,
0.1067534164,
0.2119581699,
0.7673473358,
-0.8201296926,
0.5300689936,
0.1940197647,
0.8630957007,
0.3547342122,
0.0255526341,
0.4368140996,
-0.8810672164,
0.0893154368,
-0.0013557858,
0.4904345274,
0.4195181727,
-0.5790551901,
0.0024807756,
0.2982062399,
-0.5166771412,
-0.5795253515,
0.0356825106,
-0.650483489,
-0.2313008457,
1.1260639429,
-0.1019020304,
-0.106077373,
-0.1995389462,
-0.4496167004,
0.020517271,
-0.2646203041,
0.9906051159,
0.7406381369,
-0.1834473163,
0.1093101278,
-0.4696605802,
0.9514387846,
0.1689511091,
-0.7120158076,
-0.0047042985,
0.5437470078,
0.434774667,
-0.3727821112,
0.4865918458,
0.0684453398,
0.2614245117,
-0.4079058468,
-0.0913349763,
-0.1042961255,
-0.5485075712,
-0.3583197892,
0.1436600685,
0.1081524938,
0.1527714282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12737v1 | The Best of Both Worlds: Combining Human and Machine Translations for Multilingual Semantic Parsing with Active Learning | 2023-05-22T05:57:47 | 2023-05-22T05:57:47 | Zhuang Li, Lizhen Qu, Philip R. Cohen, Raj V. Tumuluri, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multilingual semantic parsing aims to leverage the knowledge from the
high-resource languages to improve low-resource semantic parsing, yet commonly
suffers from the data imbalance problem. Prior works propose to utilize the
translations by either humans or machines to alleviate such issues. However,
human translations are expensive, while machine translations are cheap but
prone to error and bias. In this work, we propose an active learning approach
that exploits the strengths of both human and machine translations by
iteratively adding small batches of human translations into the
machine-translated training set. Besides, we propose novel aggregated
acquisition criteria that help our active learning method select utterances to
be manually translated. Our experiments demonstrate that an ideal utterance
selection can significantly reduce the error and bias in the translated data,
resulting in higher parser accuracies than the parsers merely trained on the
machine-translated data. | [
-0.1685530245,
-0.562767148,
0.3904938698,
0.2995929718,
-0.4404764175,
0.0882906392,
-0.4608766139,
-0.6481217146,
-0.0204248801,
0.3561807573,
-0.138710171,
-0.2316575944,
-0.5394578576,
0.370418191,
-0.0703582913,
0.6394916177,
-0.2060025781,
0.4760130942,
0.0641955063,
-0.5331420898,
-0.4515340328,
-0.3323756754,
-0.604064703,
-0.3029664755,
0.4288447797,
0.4990751445,
0.9490673542,
0.7521495819,
0.262763381,
0.3902539015,
-0.0250650141,
0.6295726895,
0.0986108631,
0.2448699325,
-0.2601976991,
-0.4280831218,
-0.508928597,
0.1099869683,
0.7694934607,
1.0282597542,
-0.0783760622,
-0.0016438881,
-0.0479389876,
0.4546357989,
-0.7352542281,
0.2024383098,
-0.8499686122,
0.2295687497,
-0.0092151416,
0.134615615,
-0.3727405667,
0.0565003529,
-0.1859820783,
-0.5866339207,
0.2001891583,
0.0337638445,
0.8132096529,
0.3308246732,
-0.6607530713,
-0.1306229085,
-0.4922783673,
1.0221924782,
-0.5268660188,
0.5926325917,
0.5011344552,
0.3045192659,
0.155650124,
-0.4596826434,
-0.6237435937,
0.0781514496,
-0.0696026087,
0.1908917725,
-0.1743436009,
-0.0776964948,
-0.0951150954,
0.4888176322,
-0.3406942189,
0.0103445919,
-0.287024051,
-0.195291549,
0.4635421932,
-0.1316054761,
0.5185818672,
-0.1168973148,
-0.3727343678,
-0.3666497171,
-0.1948307604,
-0.0545180403,
0.2966215312,
0.6124556065,
0.1999991685,
0.6222836375,
-0.1755487621,
1.0044699907,
-0.1248650029,
-0.1497792304,
0.4326756299,
-0.5531896949,
-0.1536577493,
0.2691744566,
0.5978938341,
0.1001519933,
0.1660455763,
-0.3736040592,
-0.3468885422,
0.2165010571,
0.2733978033,
-0.2537130117,
0.013218754,
0.1001932099,
-0.2951273322,
-0.2150038332,
0.0401574336,
-0.4939579666,
0.0760902315,
-0.5301417708,
0.2063330114,
-0.2156851441,
-0.3844425082,
0.4076193869,
-0.024514813,
0.1892307699,
0.3561211824,
-0.7485234737,
0.3087422848,
0.4078503549,
0.6016084552,
-0.1504628062,
-0.4653091431,
-0.8787000179,
0.3898791373,
-0.2941311598,
0.8391869664,
-0.3923456669,
-0.0888816863,
-0.1128828228,
0.2347314954,
-0.2867611051,
-0.6298232675,
0.9137434959,
-0.4783626497,
0.2193366736,
-0.1469774842,
-0.1525526047,
-0.2055166513,
0.2154315561,
-0.6320449114,
1.0008569956,
0.2369886786,
-0.4080313444,
0.6819375157,
-0.3786062002,
-0.8128089905,
-0.0959289074,
0.0527456515,
-0.5178126693,
0.067164138,
0.3066487312,
0.399908334,
-0.1028947607,
0.3246712089,
-0.0872302875,
0.2685522139,
0.1355407685,
-0.4237395823,
0.8621494174,
0.5200932622,
-0.4732413888,
0.1729992479,
-0.6488193274,
0.0146312676,
0.1838737279,
-0.7052315474,
-0.3205047846,
0.1070560589,
0.0852761567,
0.5699723959,
0.1695692539,
-0.599676013,
0.0510792062,
-0.5578580499,
0.3572890162,
0.5087821484,
-0.3343595564,
0.6675342321,
0.0492137522,
0.1820942163,
0.2682944238,
-0.0364138037,
-0.1554200053,
-0.5341098309,
-0.7968588471,
-0.2882378995,
0.3319538236,
0.9171555042,
-0.6966816783,
0.5969275236,
-0.3179977536,
0.0564836003,
-1.0814195871,
0.8271862268,
0.5722030997,
0.5085003376,
0.7862104177,
-0.2686155736,
-0.1477345675,
-0.8163748384,
-0.5113922358,
-0.2385588288,
0.0357928835,
0.1794047207,
-0.2149017155,
-0.1238972172,
0.7974731326,
-0.1511032283,
-0.6149347425,
-0.505233109,
-0.0379146561,
-0.0493123941,
0.5263284445,
0.4579732716,
-1.1238002777,
-0.6366784573,
0.3149599731,
-0.6313305497,
-0.1609383821,
0.0249008872,
-0.3792357147,
0.065766409,
0.127667591,
-0.5736783743,
0.0756648704,
0.4029933512,
-0.6298866868,
-0.2846670449,
-0.2698426247,
0.1925002187,
-0.9885134697,
-0.0191685781,
-0.2151831686,
-0.5832334161,
-0.3983790576,
-0.0470391065,
0.4757484198,
-0.2514719665,
-0.7303580642,
0.6476458907,
-0.6534964442,
-0.2247944176,
-0.3095121384,
0.2246629298,
0.2861744463,
0.4200573862,
0.0145648131,
0.5921173096,
0.3001865447,
-0.5115286708,
0.5141384006,
0.4115227163,
-0.0886220634,
0.3778792918,
-0.319334805,
-0.1479547173,
-0.1013234258,
0.0624252707,
-1.0442533493,
-0.3773349226,
0.2096595019,
-0.5597642064,
0.5138143897,
-0.1684273332,
-0.6664879918,
-0.0429926291,
0.0752188712,
0.3521236479,
0.3901064396,
-0.6532205343,
0.5788831711,
0.4616737664,
0.0028603605,
-0.3660821915,
-0.7963620424,
0.4123722017,
0.024582224,
-0.777620554,
0.2780644298,
0.3347908258,
-0.4431582093,
0.1344406605,
-0.1407759786,
-0.0024470214,
0.3230070174,
-0.3875596523,
0.1251475066,
-0.2076185197,
-0.0693534166,
0.2012379616,
-0.4862699807,
-0.3229795098,
-0.561141789,
0.3105173111,
-0.1311107129,
-0.6351342797,
-0.4055682123,
0.5535514951,
0.6152899861,
-0.5838276744,
0.7875984311,
0.7021566629,
-0.1827041358,
-0.0053450186,
-0.5342434049,
0.1065171435,
-0.3947516382,
0.204303816,
-0.4111519456,
-0.3391944468,
0.1607923359,
-0.0635149553,
0.4950810671,
0.6633198857,
0.5260851383,
0.0023084909,
1.5592815876,
0.2438129783,
-0.0582761243,
0.539535284,
-0.04966693,
0.0993649289,
-0.4400515854,
-0.0195344351,
-0.5227498412,
-0.3828680813,
-0.1430860609,
-0.5348834991,
0.1190290302,
0.1541971564,
0.1924968213,
0.1949588507,
-0.343062222,
0.4409726262,
0.5201859474,
0.2072643489,
0.4059725404,
0.2081547081,
-0.2162204534,
-0.0307578575,
-0.646322906,
-0.514544189,
0.7036492825,
0.1232978553,
0.4078665078,
0.4303734601,
0.18700625,
0.1508827806,
-0.0927524492,
-1.0345518589,
0.3306597769,
-0.4398248792,
-0.4494296014,
-0.1679793447,
-0.5202715397,
-1.1255294085,
0.7766653299,
-0.3006494641,
0.0160427,
0.0987741277,
0.2736744881,
0.1159154773,
0.4030668437,
-0.9463371038,
1.0666962862,
-0.6878836751,
-0.5736413002,
-0.222154662,
-0.9472528696,
-0.0112329498,
0.0609592572,
0.5051724911,
-0.2396160513,
-0.2752675712,
0.5470074415,
-0.1567886323,
0.9172055125,
-0.3861271441,
-0.0881455615,
0.2229786366,
-0.0424784608,
0.5736792088,
-0.0644049793,
-0.0712276474,
0.0333316922,
-0.4794446528,
-0.9822856784,
-0.3248091638,
0.4659625292,
-0.970634222,
-0.2085934132,
-0.3692811728,
-0.3262082338,
-0.4257361889,
0.424482137,
-0.1485518217,
0.2319992781,
0.0127406288,
0.0160807148,
0.6827766299,
-0.0520920344,
0.4174644947,
0.6611177921,
0.1362196654,
-0.6919793487,
0.8897638321,
-0.0553469695,
0.5545976162,
0.3481403291,
0.2164675593,
-0.1218318716,
-0.3662285209,
-1.2403979301,
0.2865144014,
-0.8446611166,
-0.2715122104,
-1.1074198484,
0.3179597855,
-0.5989806652,
-0.2830859721,
-0.5167580247,
-0.6421903372,
-0.211754486,
-0.1549638659,
-0.0811857656,
0.1174081564,
0.0601920784,
0.3718167543,
-1.0067915916,
0.6907744408,
0.4332774878,
-0.0514255054,
-0.2167742103,
-0.3691069484,
-0.2718887031,
0.0937900171,
-0.4188557267,
-0.7619487643,
0.5310507417,
0.6082949638,
0.9140098095,
0.4594286978,
0.0803434476,
0.9305281043,
-0.5224065185,
0.5889738202,
0.2884857357,
-0.8301862478,
0.6594517827,
-0.1068645492,
0.4864435792,
0.8514241576,
0.1983721554,
-0.6620659232,
-0.543538332,
-0.7025155425,
-1.161703825,
0.9888414741,
0.1043820754,
0.2250703424,
-0.0774374902,
0.1093575656,
0.1381609291,
0.0220103972,
-0.6832174659,
-0.0146138445,
-0.2788303494,
-0.39695701,
-0.1476287246,
-0.0265201665,
-0.1104015931,
-0.3064655662,
0.8525425792,
-0.2728561759,
0.0974765643,
-0.0887686163,
-0.6608900428,
-0.4056159556,
0.2508115768,
0.1149843037,
0.4495771527,
0.1075362414,
0.5667640567,
0.3173204362,
-0.3993676007,
0.2107305527,
-0.0074146539,
-0.0550397411,
0.1859779358,
0.4305988848,
0.8835948706,
0.6228626966,
-0.9067387581,
0.6626081467,
-0.0823506489,
-0.0137697551,
-0.0483448058,
0.1284610331,
-0.0485052988,
0.0048037176,
0.291913569,
0.423142314,
-0.0764445662,
-0.4616261125,
0.2261534035,
0.2233824879,
-0.4334262013,
-0.3280563056,
0.6302489638,
0.3315790594,
-0.0479203127,
0.6665419936,
-0.1721158028,
-0.6593345404,
0.2242365032,
0.5980405807,
0.84179914,
-0.426253289,
-0.1505862325,
0.3891608417,
0.1757053733,
-0.2688666582,
0.153956905,
-0.4853684604,
-0.7463032603,
-0.5861729383,
-0.856870532,
-0.3727064729,
-0.5373932719,
-0.7356637716,
0.6473525167,
0.2238292992,
0.0081264032,
-0.1262444705,
-0.0638545007,
-0.3862257004,
0.0857848749,
0.135602802,
0.6381942034,
-1.0877579451,
0.8424579501,
1.1647573709,
-0.3030982316,
-0.4725794196,
-0.2971219122,
-0.1967570037,
-0.8231015205,
0.4969461262,
0.0068673869,
-0.0065677059,
0.1924930066,
-0.1765799522,
-0.7000322342,
0.6141645312,
0.4013466239,
-0.0059542409,
0.1130346581,
0.0401775502,
0.1350891888,
0.0138491746,
-0.1973941028,
0.3263121545,
0.5995458364,
0.264297992,
-0.9634642601,
-0.322787106,
-0.2983168662,
-0.4459609091,
0.5585435033,
-0.5314786434,
0.7157173753,
0.09278813,
-0.203265667,
-0.4653941691,
0.859171927,
-0.1047042906,
0.2924892902,
0.7353227735,
0.6401793361,
0.6721989512,
0.1384466439,
0.7130630016,
-0.3172493279,
0.1630206555,
0.6924497485,
-0.2171894908,
0.7438013554,
0.4895995855,
-0.1687681526,
-0.1124765351,
0.7362213731,
0.2502174675,
0.6056029797,
-0.4056697488,
-0.6661823392,
-0.6510794759,
0.0293644667,
0.0340781361,
0.5726591945,
0.4314601719,
-0.3267458379,
-0.6097324491,
0.4238842726,
0.3549595177,
0.1993314475,
-0.0935606286,
1.2329754829,
-0.006517441,
-0.8951850533,
0.6810224056,
0.3703117967,
0.4594683349,
-0.57663095,
-0.0827901065,
-0.0707091317,
0.4053030312,
-0.2693214715,
-0.5124669671,
0.3918101788,
0.1356960386,
-0.1898796856,
-0.8465610147,
0.6534068584,
-0.6054372787,
-0.626988709,
0.3640415668,
0.697737515,
0.167431891,
0.1230184063,
-0.8491971493,
-0.1567376405,
0.112985149,
-0.1628079414,
0.5181165934,
0.5376409888,
-0.304207623,
0.3164252043,
0.7473253608,
0.2618944645,
0.2862744927,
-0.0574660152,
0.9084811211,
-0.5443145633,
-0.6230788231,
-0.7631559372,
0.4834420383,
-0.0686037689,
-0.2060280591,
0.7044661641,
0.6384372711,
0.9570246935,
0.1547225863,
0.7786307931,
-0.1224930286,
0.543140471,
-0.4359562099,
0.4293165207,
-0.6898342371,
0.1243638471,
-0.0097227404,
-1.0508760214,
-0.4968343079,
0.9198045135,
-0.1484755576,
-0.3482792079,
0.4347956777,
0.3599656224,
-0.6168154478,
-0.2130087912,
0.4157086313,
-0.1695699692,
0.2470004708,
0.2949573994,
0.6256530285,
-0.2853257358,
0.6163053513,
-0.3592965901,
-0.4109487236,
-0.1566040069,
-0.6004095674,
-0.6175462604,
-0.4545910656,
-0.1749442965,
-0.3365677297,
-0.0904756263,
1.0204229355,
0.54031533,
-0.8314577937,
-0.2271023244,
0.0423947424,
0.113014698,
-0.4339811802,
-0.0916075632,
0.1487910748,
-1.0300747156,
-1.059027791,
0.7023565769,
0.0969016999,
-0.0091361422,
-0.056685999,
-0.1205842793,
-0.5094924569,
-0.2247323692,
0.7462641001,
0.1614082605,
-0.6897481084,
0.1575055122,
0.0091871535,
-0.2368959635,
0.1750583947,
0.756735146,
-0.7677033544,
0.6621058583,
0.5040676594,
0.9702118635,
0.4550544322,
0.1919074059,
0.4549669027,
-0.6998746991,
0.5001373887,
0.1991629153,
0.307756722,
0.4343963265,
-0.141605556,
0.5075129271,
0.4993183613,
-0.2003018707,
-0.8050621152,
0.0956109539,
-0.9638113379,
-0.4848033488,
1.2622920275,
-0.2835532725,
-0.3906298578,
-0.5018007755,
-0.313338697,
0.5203769207,
-0.2937273383,
0.4563011825,
0.4559436142,
-0.108633548,
0.1577565223,
-0.7684755921,
0.1675608307,
0.5628579855,
-0.5599769354,
0.1257546693,
0.6832655072,
-0.1794941127,
0.1173827499,
0.1759311408,
-0.1737257391,
0.3177631497,
-0.1480612755,
0.1369770616,
0.0441758931,
-0.2375217527,
-0.2495871335,
0.1356146187,
0.2062122077,
-0.302020818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12733v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12733v2 | MADNet: Maximizing Addressee Deduction Expectation for Multi-Party Conversation Generation | 2023-05-22T05:50:11 | 2023-10-18T02:09:24 | Jia-Chen Gu, Chao-Hong Tan, Caiyuan Chu, Zhen-Hua Ling, Chongyang Tao, Quan Liu, Cong Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modeling multi-party conversations (MPCs) with graph neural networks has been
proven effective at capturing complicated and graphical information flows.
However, existing methods rely heavily on the necessary addressee labels and
can only be applied to an ideal setting where each utterance must be tagged
with an addressee label. To study the scarcity of addressee labels which is a
common issue in MPCs, we propose MADNet that maximizes addressee deduction
expectation in heterogeneous graph neural networks for MPC generation. Given an
MPC with a few addressee labels missing, existing methods fail to build a
consecutively connected conversation graph, but only a few separate
conversation fragments instead. To ensure message passing between these
conversation fragments, four additional types of latent edges are designed to
complete a fully-connected graph. Besides, to optimize the edge-type-dependent
message passing for those utterances without addressee labels, an
Expectation-Maximization-based method that iteratively generates silver
addressee labels (E step), and optimizes the quality of generated responses (M
step), is designed. Experimental results on two Ubuntu IRC channel benchmarks
show that MADNet outperforms various baseline models on the task of MPC
generation, especially under the more common and challenging setting where part
of addressee labels are missing. | [
-0.7637087107,
-0.7053411007,
0.4343949556,
0.2506094277,
-0.0321638845,
-0.0774457902,
0.2764326036,
-0.2659290135,
0.4142141938,
0.2451501191,
-0.4464027286,
-0.4950671494,
-0.7387487888,
-0.1423707902,
-0.047882434,
1.0103487968,
0.4621960223,
-0.435693562,
-0.1022160128,
-0.0269168522,
-0.2105634809,
-0.6227896214,
-0.897547245,
-0.3681638241,
0.7673498988,
0.5068187714,
0.4899803996,
0.4721641839,
0.1967512965,
0.2975944281,
-0.3169417679,
0.7136774659,
-0.7543173432,
0.2389253229,
0.1756016016,
0.1211019978,
-0.7326437235,
0.0676680431,
0.510840714,
0.6081527472,
-0.375331074,
-0.0710039884,
-0.0921366289,
0.4606848359,
-1.1543937922,
0.2488747686,
-0.7193155289,
0.191726476,
0.202479586,
-0.0594228804,
-0.6329064965,
-0.2233374566,
-0.0517244078,
-0.1971524805,
-0.2085596174,
0.0233178847,
0.9874660373,
-0.1819712073,
-0.3707476258,
0.1064664349,
-0.7359169722,
0.2659828365,
-0.6995725632,
0.151915133,
0.3869891763,
0.2371823043,
-0.4147226214,
-0.6909988523,
-0.4134603143,
-0.0524376966,
0.2340079248,
0.3812344968,
-0.7268220782,
0.3294716775,
0.2379900962,
0.0386844389,
-0.1277447343,
0.054962121,
-0.1816995889,
-0.1614293009,
0.5088709593,
0.3556824923,
-0.0629799813,
-0.2275870293,
-0.1747803539,
-0.0162929222,
-0.4142696261,
-0.0959682539,
1.0064799786,
0.3311161399,
0.1998670399,
0.4361132383,
-0.3831760287,
0.8988717794,
0.1362492591,
0.1020256206,
0.1933573931,
-0.1135153696,
-0.0669351667,
0.1563482136,
1.0115199089,
0.2522393465,
0.1673331857,
-0.1822001785,
-0.0887382552,
-0.1640433669,
0.1073625162,
-1.0665076971,
-0.641798079,
0.3685666621,
-0.2935294211,
-0.1704152226,
-0.0196390413,
-0.7150123119,
-0.3771299124,
-0.1896282732,
-0.17147246,
-0.2947801352,
-0.4918667376,
-0.2365635335,
-0.2849801183,
-0.1867294312,
0.310016185,
-0.4993150234,
0.3367405832,
0.5154391527,
0.8516465425,
-0.0246141944,
-0.3558680415,
-0.8285452724,
0.2323331088,
-0.2615830302,
0.9151617885,
-0.4828457534,
-0.2277909368,
-0.2602367997,
-0.3732506633,
-0.1266364306,
-0.2340482473,
0.0950253606,
-0.3245156109,
-0.1796035022,
0.1450130045,
-0.4092976153,
0.0095681157,
0.5313006639,
-0.4760802686,
0.4422324896,
-0.0825723037,
-1.0186226368,
-0.1714484096,
-0.4841783047,
-0.5522103906,
-0.0506834984,
-0.0539848842,
-0.4723225534,
0.0242942646,
0.2162539959,
0.6357656121,
-0.117511712,
0.2360152155,
-0.4727570713,
0.0378376916,
0.2903291583,
-0.549264133,
0.5373376012,
0.5246527195,
-0.2479771078,
0.1040574461,
-0.8667141795,
0.3600753546,
-0.0081299162,
-0.2450768352,
-0.1432430446,
0.2350954711,
-0.0959188417,
0.5369591117,
-0.0970353335,
-0.7284054756,
-0.1575509757,
-0.4023416042,
0.5117768645,
0.8707621694,
0.3363538682,
-0.0944735333,
-0.1570568234,
0.1705278158,
0.5606237054,
0.0720293894,
-0.2083887607,
-0.5644399524,
-0.7335745692,
-0.3277848065,
0.2017277628,
0.6374078393,
-0.4431194365,
0.264844656,
-0.1160047054,
-0.416759789,
-0.2424362749,
-0.3829633594,
0.3621735275,
0.3264003396,
0.0259882789,
-0.3929256201,
-0.6832287312,
-1.1795761585,
-0.0063236984,
-0.3525184989,
0.1235095039,
0.7559354305,
0.0843836293,
-0.231169492,
0.830732584,
-0.5361623764,
0.2123742104,
-0.2562357485,
0.3115575314,
0.0930529088,
0.4413735569,
-0.0022576004,
-0.7340381742,
-0.2993977368,
0.2317225784,
-0.1979940832,
-0.0244399272,
-0.098549284,
-0.4333380461,
0.176891908,
-0.0913293883,
-0.3990063965,
0.5745583177,
0.6641292572,
-0.2544417381,
0.2403733879,
-0.2925131917,
0.3101573586,
-1.1648870707,
-0.0271563269,
0.2288606614,
-0.5058897734,
-0.6982464194,
-0.4428322613,
-0.2939117551,
-0.4839768112,
-0.3690949082,
0.0861386806,
-0.5242641568,
-0.0829646364,
-0.280046463,
0.3137604892,
-0.0413173437,
0.9489191771,
-0.1293951124,
0.4106023908,
0.3746238351,
-0.6298606992,
0.2884312272,
0.1605956405,
0.0587338619,
0.6854147315,
-0.6739090681,
0.6096187234,
-0.246449694,
0.1302779913,
-1.2574971914,
-0.1872771084,
0.6125307083,
-0.4513961375,
0.4231326282,
-0.3711049259,
-0.3297929764,
-0.3786997795,
0.203914851,
-0.0689798445,
0.3905388713,
-0.3686194122,
0.6767858267,
0.8385869265,
0.0103036929,
-0.4473083615,
-0.4831312597,
0.394529134,
0.0848988667,
-0.8124642372,
-0.0429127999,
0.1707168519,
-0.1143243089,
-0.2051176131,
-0.1251816005,
-0.2118763179,
-0.0195103344,
0.4319684505,
-0.0142321484,
0.0555953197,
-0.2935255468,
0.005231638,
-0.022411909,
0.1521745324,
-0.5169211626,
0.6962843537,
-0.2833929658,
-0.3993659019,
-0.4289146364,
0.9864344001,
0.5166376829,
-0.2230682373,
0.8279064298,
0.2856784761,
-0.2341680378,
-0.0667801946,
-0.5559915304,
0.0174050294,
-0.3606798351,
0.6916394234,
-0.6821365952,
-0.6918967366,
0.6081120968,
-0.356924504,
0.1343971789,
0.1241859943,
0.6150670648,
0.0865552202,
1.4950144291,
0.3634805679,
0.1356054097,
0.2809088826,
-0.1234834641,
0.4355683029,
-0.7510170937,
-0.3031321466,
-0.5238533616,
-0.4148917794,
-0.58124578,
-0.1909628808,
0.2205605656,
-0.2808445692,
-0.4084636569,
0.1948566884,
-0.6161772013,
0.4720437825,
0.6539028883,
0.2830219567,
-0.0488180704,
0.1458462924,
-0.066353932,
0.2686070502,
-1.0847752094,
-0.254843384,
0.4972816706,
0.3036874533,
0.6108702421,
0.0113703562,
0.7025048733,
0.0587451942,
0.0449165888,
-0.4492953718,
0.5573706627,
-0.0403917693,
-0.4081043601,
0.0475310162,
-0.9812735915,
-0.8771134019,
0.4056967497,
0.1134103313,
-1.3252876997,
0.3914045393,
0.4253796935,
-0.0518294349,
0.6217252016,
-0.6968493462,
0.8696645498,
0.2495570183,
-0.1307346672,
0.1120617539,
-0.8114984035,
0.2659234703,
0.5020784736,
-0.2707991898,
-0.4392910898,
0.350479871,
0.5616249442,
-0.4590717852,
0.8559983969,
-0.2331875265,
0.1142627224,
0.7976185083,
0.2468612641,
0.9653692842,
-0.0665484145,
0.1733925045,
0.2424173504,
-0.2891245782,
-0.3261115253,
-0.1923372149,
0.7917785645,
-0.9491100311,
-0.4600697458,
-0.0834280849,
-0.8222932816,
-0.3871265352,
-0.0622725897,
0.4364525378,
0.5559087396,
-0.0782723129,
-0.0635710582,
0.6180929542,
0.0394538343,
0.3777880371,
-0.0805902928,
0.0455100238,
-0.4510410726,
1.1127544641,
0.0562483892,
0.4883218706,
0.0318011828,
0.1862694621,
0.1109572873,
-0.4055508971,
-0.3130304813,
-0.0960906297,
-0.8362910748,
-0.2865535319,
-1.2750430107,
-0.3795151114,
-0.421665132,
0.3433039188,
-0.6785755157,
-0.4058530629,
-0.1841169,
0.0232409406,
0.1024649888,
0.3538307846,
-0.3704313338,
0.4737318456,
-0.5960563421,
0.1656920612,
0.3113737702,
0.0796884224,
0.156023711,
-0.1612835377,
0.109580338,
0.3139310777,
-0.4488599002,
-1.1506299973,
0.3099557161,
0.192859143,
0.5687978268,
0.4141113162,
0.1577498913,
0.6651118994,
-0.6269375682,
0.2842131555,
0.5580888391,
-0.6867792606,
0.6364040971,
-0.3299455643,
0.2877124846,
0.2808404267,
0.2019895017,
-0.7974570394,
-0.6804936528,
-0.9150992632,
-1.0746158361,
0.8176270127,
0.525608182,
0.2297283262,
-0.4299409389,
-0.0248040557,
-0.1464900523,
0.2926933467,
-0.5275732875,
-0.6458370686,
-0.323145777,
0.0044935145,
0.4368118644,
-0.2870111465,
-0.1770961583,
-0.0279570222,
0.7828899622,
-0.1657773554,
0.7210168242,
0.1308323145,
0.4814292192,
0.0356132127,
0.3653413057,
0.5027640462,
0.7274314165,
-0.054579217,
0.3464340866,
-0.0096305087,
-0.2955520153,
0.0957777649,
0.3333253562,
-0.0366586931,
0.1944401264,
-0.4112077355,
1.3808341026,
-0.3497244418,
-0.2285164595,
0.311599642,
-0.1864868104,
-0.1437070966,
0.0543133169,
0.0833003968,
0.2810110152,
0.2333036959,
0.0035636951,
0.465002805,
0.2396199256,
-0.2437424809,
0.1555107385,
0.3885777295,
-0.4731750488,
-0.1829497963,
0.4966557026,
0.1869973093,
-0.4443565607,
0.8420856595,
-0.3736144602,
-0.4682386816,
0.692135632,
0.7821491957,
1.008893013,
0.0400047377,
0.3546724916,
0.4374158978,
0.2103560865,
0.2643989325,
0.1448295563,
-0.0195154063,
-0.5888397098,
-0.4731635749,
-0.2722911239,
-0.4357189834,
0.0156986229,
-0.2140057832,
-0.0508513488,
-0.3567268252,
-0.3981467187,
0.0315142609,
-0.4446668923,
-0.6071953773,
-0.0952479467,
0.4297609627,
0.3566887081,
-0.5796937943,
0.4778935015,
0.5738056898,
0.0046952609,
-1.235299468,
-0.4020468295,
-0.1424196362,
-0.4871593714,
0.5491670966,
0.2002554238,
-0.347255975,
0.1488856226,
-0.5746580958,
-0.5771811604,
0.4773769081,
0.3703503907,
-0.5547738075,
-0.1072889715,
-0.0391848609,
0.0536738299,
-0.5486801863,
0.5008560419,
0.1180200279,
0.4019383788,
0.7328690886,
-0.4386354983,
-0.2245602012,
-0.4293189645,
0.2324217111,
0.5692549944,
-0.4975994229,
0.9950764775,
-0.160336569,
-0.178867504,
-0.2177435458,
0.7720332742,
0.2514656186,
0.4097628891,
0.4597096443,
0.6374392509,
0.7187711,
-0.1430034488,
1.1859536171,
-0.0512005836,
0.2758148015,
1.2443708181,
-0.1901795715,
0.3791432381,
0.3707506359,
0.0488934144,
0.1186705083,
0.7639733553,
0.234745577,
0.3591941893,
0.6285815239,
-0.2841495275,
-0.5719532371,
-0.3622604311,
-0.087676324,
0.3766113818,
0.2431243062,
-0.162950322,
-0.2294938713,
0.0689768717,
0.271591872,
-0.3504442573,
-0.4048834741,
0.8234906197,
-0.1025975049,
-0.8138819337,
0.421263814,
-0.0431136116,
0.3680319488,
-0.5639897585,
-0.0925687477,
-0.3978433609,
0.2847433388,
-0.1573472321,
-0.5725471377,
0.0047725677,
-0.0958505943,
-0.1026275903,
0.1393684447,
0.9956839681,
-0.4690801203,
-0.3075809777,
-0.0447522737,
0.5917685628,
0.506157577,
-0.1136979759,
-0.4729163349,
-0.0725727081,
0.0774085745,
-0.4856267869,
0.2612145245,
0.7467657924,
0.2694761753,
0.6163233519,
0.4521227479,
0.1267478913,
0.1004861668,
0.1227991283,
0.8320539594,
-0.1529329121,
-0.6928057671,
-0.8605514765,
0.4184288979,
-0.4916957319,
-0.4941733479,
0.5002379417,
0.4626582265,
0.5395392179,
0.1264651567,
0.4743205011,
-0.1528651863,
-0.0595597513,
-0.0713637099,
0.7227760553,
-0.313064903,
-0.0500938334,
-0.4546895921,
-0.9827972651,
-0.0668550059,
0.6813933253,
0.0309582744,
0.0826409981,
0.4004986584,
0.5400688052,
-0.2756496668,
0.2365218401,
0.4343347549,
-0.1241352186,
0.4553520381,
1.1324009895,
1.0939277411,
-0.3378162682,
0.8026893139,
-0.2966920137,
-0.0100491801,
0.0764375627,
-0.8915598989,
-0.962826252,
-0.5239114761,
-0.7605952621,
-0.5716303587,
0.2779308259,
0.8875911236,
0.9741923213,
-0.5410478115,
-0.1430854201,
-0.196351856,
0.1131956726,
-0.1794604659,
-0.1959988922,
0.1571466029,
-0.365347296,
-0.9007827044,
0.0311483573,
0.4314773679,
0.0646177456,
0.0840505958,
-0.1085442081,
-0.6419141889,
0.0953118727,
0.4225535989,
0.3321188986,
-0.3173567355,
-0.3456941545,
-0.2200600356,
-0.3433505297,
0.4227876663,
0.8602221012,
-0.5538960099,
0.3623657823,
0.4467811882,
0.7623792291,
0.6096963286,
0.0307595935,
0.5126174688,
-1.1209510565,
0.254235357,
0.5343077779,
0.2379796058,
0.0726288632,
-0.3774079978,
0.3013770878,
0.0949602351,
-0.6477761865,
-0.6045885682,
0.3531862795,
-0.8193462491,
-0.3337875307,
1.2378594875,
-0.3826841712,
-0.3019234538,
-0.028096091,
-0.272834003,
0.4164014757,
-0.5367149711,
0.2779318392,
0.52932477,
-0.3312107623,
-0.2531510592,
-0.4315012395,
-0.113557227,
0.2811329365,
-1.0204324722,
0.1770679504,
0.8643496037,
-0.226654321,
0.2921556234,
0.6956692934,
0.2542387843,
0.1393231601,
0.2933918536,
0.0832802802,
-0.5813133717,
-0.6324677467,
0.2842819691,
0.5033019185,
-0.1483130753,
-0.5977905989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12726v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12726v2 | Towards Explainable In-the-Wild Video Quality Assessment: A Database and a Language-Prompted Approach | 2023-05-22T05:20:23 | 2023-08-03T09:26:36 | Haoning Wu, Erli Zhang, Liang Liao, Chaofeng Chen, Jingwen Hou, Annan Wang, Wenxiu Sun, Qiong Yan, Weisi Lin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | The proliferation of in-the-wild videos has greatly expanded the Video
Quality Assessment (VQA) problem. Unlike early definitions that usually focus
on limited distortion types, VQA on in-the-wild videos is especially
challenging as it could be affected by complicated factors, including various
distortions and diverse contents. Though subjective studies have collected
overall quality scores for these videos, how the abstract quality scores relate
with specific factors is still obscure, hindering VQA methods from more
concrete quality evaluations (e.g. sharpness of a video). To solve this
problem, we collect over two million opinions on 4,543 in-the-wild videos on 13
dimensions of quality-related factors, including in-capture authentic
distortions (e.g. motion blur, noise, flicker), errors introduced by
compression and transmission, and higher-level experiences on semantic contents
and aesthetic issues (e.g. composition, camera trajectory), to establish the
multi-dimensional Maxwell database. Specifically, we ask the subjects to label
among a positive, a negative, and a neutral choice for each dimension. These
explanation-level opinions allow us to measure the relationships between
specific quality factors and abstract subjective quality ratings, and to
benchmark different categories of VQA algorithms on each dimension, so as to
more comprehensively analyze their strengths and weaknesses. Furthermore, we
propose the MaxVQA, a language-prompted VQA approach that modifies
vision-language foundation model CLIP to better capture important quality
issues as observed in our analyses. The MaxVQA can jointly evaluate various
specific quality factors and final quality scores with state-of-the-art
accuracy on all dimensions, and superb generalization ability on existing
datasets. Code and data available at https://github.com/VQAssessment/MaxVQA. | [
-0.684885025,
-0.6225573421,
0.3934343159,
0.3305724263,
-0.3107557595,
0.0727189407,
-0.0112178549,
-0.3594889939,
0.3020934165,
0.4109438062,
-0.6926138997,
-0.4528824389,
-0.5459402204,
-0.0312409345,
-0.6651741862,
0.7754708529,
-0.1929024309,
0.0716266036,
-0.3195092976,
-0.551494956,
-0.5203444958,
-0.539016664,
-0.0221118387,
0.1710633337,
0.2289912999,
0.4910968542,
1.1549085379,
0.572663188,
0.5109730959,
0.2664216161,
-0.1371937394,
0.3204365373,
-0.668461442,
-0.0763769671,
-0.2411612272,
0.0471806042,
-0.3635849953,
-0.0522218719,
0.5713592768,
0.5388787985,
-0.0879150406,
0.3509308696,
-0.1686062068,
0.4822556973,
-0.6087580323,
-0.1699376255,
-0.4670962393,
0.2826674581,
-0.068242304,
-0.3822660446,
0.0478327982,
-0.2865506113,
0.2416998446,
-0.5455924869,
0.3962599337,
-0.4012308419,
1.3804475069,
0.2385918647,
-0.5325745344,
0.0619707368,
-1.0365040302,
0.6481072903,
-0.4596163929,
0.4247339368,
0.4605429471,
0.5810417533,
-0.0747876316,
-0.4027903676,
-0.9130179286,
-0.0064688665,
0.3336107135,
0.2799702287,
-0.1420601755,
0.0873403773,
0.3021080494,
0.7907853723,
-0.7255913615,
0.0858831108,
-0.155172199,
-0.3860097826,
0.818797946,
0.4354633987,
0.247903958,
-0.1299922615,
-0.1903166175,
-0.2393512726,
-0.5923662186,
0.3641684353,
0.4332878888,
-0.2155246139,
0.3729343414,
0.7858569026,
-0.5135819912,
0.7516969442,
-0.1199293062,
-0.1542604417,
0.2680356205,
-0.7170807719,
-0.4984379411,
-0.5896543264,
0.7984884977,
0.737354219,
0.0444883965,
0.132964626,
-0.1680330783,
0.0625731125,
0.1539949924,
-0.9041465521,
-0.1378056258,
0.2947060466,
-0.4734746814,
-0.1587620825,
0.0045518065,
-0.957654953,
-0.4513549507,
-0.3521446288,
0.9368093014,
-0.2593571246,
-0.3841654062,
0.125885278,
0.0216404144,
0.4355875552,
0.2491686046,
-0.6586545706,
0.2699219882,
0.1673662812,
0.6551476121,
0.0714934543,
-0.1770389974,
-0.509483099,
-0.2785185874,
-0.2041988671,
0.8668441772,
-0.494150281,
-0.2466993332,
0.1575800776,
0.0259765163,
0.4510025978,
-0.472691983,
0.6128883362,
-0.4417988658,
0.2505322397,
-0.5345537663,
-0.3913855255,
-0.4661823213,
0.2845176756,
-0.6731260419,
1.0391968489,
0.1099529043,
-0.4027578235,
0.9226623774,
-0.2714779675,
0.0314893536,
0.0467899106,
-0.1221437156,
-0.3993223608,
0.2083132267,
0.5557239056,
0.3822496831,
-0.2223237455,
0.2640291154,
-0.3596970141,
-0.1754400283,
0.511992991,
-0.7709417939,
0.6252456307,
0.0820493624,
-0.076263532,
0.0815006793,
-0.9124096036,
0.2393035442,
-0.1455899626,
-0.1184843928,
-0.0584054515,
-0.0347043425,
0.0410773344,
0.480160743,
-0.2425760925,
-0.2919827104,
0.0260562319,
-0.297883004,
0.329957217,
0.4950549006,
0.3743369877,
0.3464005888,
-0.0762916282,
0.5880185366,
-0.1720568389,
0.8710576296,
-0.0482063591,
-0.3345017731,
-0.5859177709,
-0.309327811,
0.1953143626,
0.1650077254,
-0.6623424888,
0.0398364216,
-0.2354345024,
-0.4865260124,
-0.4741822183,
0.2922114134,
0.2468312234,
0.1767101139,
0.410058558,
-0.9415090084,
-0.2661958635,
-0.6696661115,
-0.0311537758,
-0.2676986754,
-0.0507669039,
0.4599760771,
0.3770052195,
-0.1063111946,
0.9485808611,
-0.1671443284,
-0.3137150705,
0.0851382762,
-0.1149666384,
0.4050643146,
0.1263788044,
0.5709409714,
-1.0559455156,
-0.3351037502,
-0.1255931258,
-0.8153164983,
0.0127209108,
-0.1402922124,
-0.2947726548,
-0.2913765311,
0.2104126215,
-0.6304935813,
0.4064385891,
0.6018704176,
-0.4904966056,
0.8209790587,
-0.1579770744,
0.2799432874,
-0.6347840428,
-0.3114984334,
0.0991459116,
0.0958142877,
-0.5336680412,
0.2598154247,
-0.1542042792,
0.0560446233,
-0.5106090307,
0.1426958144,
-0.2541365027,
-0.1887449324,
0.1114951298,
0.1047048569,
0.1500212252,
0.5121139884,
-0.0620848574,
0.4530665576,
0.7783933878,
-0.5829812288,
0.7627843022,
0.2737487257,
-0.3715162873,
0.9035301208,
-0.4653768837,
-0.1815551519,
-0.2886566222,
-0.052108217,
-1.1307541132,
-0.588809967,
0.022367293,
-0.7114393115,
0.1845329404,
-0.1747819185,
-0.2934518754,
-0.2484087795,
-0.2918453813,
0.3535921276,
0.2526941299,
-0.6854552627,
0.6458469033,
0.5779396296,
0.1832669228,
-0.9033781886,
-0.3191426694,
0.5645861626,
-0.4553426206,
-0.8268886805,
0.3573319614,
-0.2616934776,
-0.2395895123,
0.2277267873,
-0.4583526254,
-0.5448887348,
-0.0945881233,
0.2601137459,
0.0931684151,
-0.2083479315,
0.0599666722,
0.0087222988,
0.259509027,
0.2572708428,
-0.3964951336,
-0.1137287468,
-0.0622559674,
-0.07927569,
-0.2561216056,
0.52691257,
0.8520672917,
-0.3992530107,
0.6002818346,
0.639995873,
-0.3548790514,
-0.4255618155,
-0.3970192373,
0.1194823459,
-0.4100979269,
0.5204254985,
-0.2406621426,
-0.5538986325,
0.6083532572,
0.1175207272,
0.1400592178,
0.2668980658,
0.572265029,
-0.2626749575,
1.1381831169,
0.9183685184,
0.3235753775,
0.5397689342,
-0.5569072366,
0.1138499081,
-0.3360029161,
-0.4498211145,
-0.3101822138,
0.0923487619,
-0.4250357151,
-0.4012701213,
0.4272366166,
0.0930104628,
-0.1654283553,
0.2350147367,
-0.317244947,
0.7232087255,
0.127680406,
0.1479768306,
0.295514673,
0.0896506011,
0.0088677015,
-0.2298316061,
-0.4469051659,
-0.4932219088,
0.9815375805,
0.4150378108,
0.5610156059,
0.6109460592,
0.3237515092,
0.2711617649,
0.3337726295,
-1.0808207989,
0.4341838658,
-0.004054016,
-0.645831883,
-0.45710814,
-0.4252431095,
-0.4311689734,
0.3399573267,
-0.4671300054,
-0.5766724348,
0.2541512251,
0.1512235105,
-0.4494231045,
-0.0406597145,
-0.5481707454,
0.8923627138,
-0.3137090504,
-0.6868816018,
-0.0952408388,
-0.7019581795,
0.6644083858,
-0.0939618275,
0.3647721112,
0.0096654529,
0.1507294029,
0.5682810545,
-0.7776080966,
0.5762375593,
-0.1463358402,
-0.042153988,
0.4488581717,
0.245947212,
0.2398287207,
0.4546115994,
0.2615796924,
0.1176092401,
0.1964111328,
-0.37695539,
-0.9792222381,
0.5179551244,
-0.8766300678,
-0.4002289772,
-0.2234848291,
-0.17151317,
-0.4675500393,
-0.0003304852,
0.279484719,
0.7467861772,
-0.2054281086,
-0.038392406,
0.9077928066,
-0.5243558884,
0.1928954124,
0.4072724581,
-0.2056600899,
-0.4069264233,
1.1610289812,
0.2673383057,
0.3273867667,
0.2501098812,
0.1074919179,
-0.3866674304,
-0.7578494549,
-0.5738883615,
0.0131995389,
-0.9563006163,
-0.3101416528,
-0.5280070305,
-0.2357307076,
0.1237355992,
0.1080297828,
-0.322776109,
-0.1843646318,
0.0138110379,
-0.3772659004,
0.3310229182,
0.5091301799,
-0.02090347,
0.0689306781,
-0.7899791002,
0.4070982039,
0.7222942114,
0.4823944569,
-0.2739861906,
-0.8490008712,
-0.3152176142,
-0.2185788006,
-0.259447217,
-0.9717636108,
0.5795779228,
0.4413439631,
0.6189007759,
0.3975397944,
-0.1262717247,
0.8440592289,
-0.0292792618,
1.1198058128,
0.0269967429,
-1.0260503292,
0.1705708951,
-0.1483878195,
-0.1346881837,
0.457660079,
0.3850424886,
-0.3779151738,
-0.3599717915,
-0.5133062005,
-0.9854456186,
0.2005645931,
0.4108524919,
0.413492173,
0.3603288233,
0.1392053068,
0.1686164141,
-0.03533848,
-0.6252000928,
-0.1684648544,
-0.8343223929,
0.1461796612,
-0.0100047747,
-0.2958689332,
-0.0729957297,
-0.2653540373,
0.3953146636,
-0.1305411309,
0.1195752323,
0.2534869313,
-0.1587622017,
-0.2411389947,
0.1512405127,
0.4469456077,
0.8145390153,
-0.3682205081,
0.1504132003,
0.2145174742,
-0.6566269398,
0.1633769423,
-0.3114477396,
0.0065813619,
0.2674496174,
0.2171939164,
0.5699918866,
-0.3687779903,
-0.7098116875,
0.8291410208,
-0.311544627,
-0.346947968,
-0.3615812063,
-0.1343829185,
-0.5503758788,
0.0498077795,
0.2356639653,
0.2344252467,
0.3568306267,
-0.5723124743,
0.0997043028,
0.3731622696,
-0.5328306556,
-0.463264823,
0.5341052413,
0.1985365748,
0.0449800864,
0.4289720058,
-0.296475023,
-0.4702000618,
0.6201651692,
-0.1039607674,
0.6530472636,
0.0964871943,
0.5692461133,
0.6254914403,
0.4903799295,
-0.2741034925,
0.3313860297,
-0.0713672712,
-0.7115511298,
-0.9497103095,
-0.6491315961,
-0.5509154797,
0.3291771114,
-0.6584764719,
0.1891364902,
-0.2620837092,
-0.1351458281,
0.0586663857,
-0.1863666922,
-0.921664536,
0.5184254646,
0.1253083646,
0.8463870287,
-0.8946207166,
0.6948086619,
0.3728337288,
-0.6812807322,
-1.0537540913,
-0.1018620729,
0.1135296971,
-0.445936352,
0.4227594733,
-0.1716349721,
-0.0464172959,
-0.3261503279,
-0.7783854008,
-0.9813098907,
0.7420521379,
0.2710190713,
-0.252709955,
0.2212705761,
-0.0376087874,
0.7372959852,
0.0919222757,
0.4053944349,
0.6329632401,
0.3386726975,
0.2118621171,
-0.8451218009,
-0.1477831155,
-0.2854832709,
-0.1470176727,
0.1540152729,
-0.3364360631,
0.4644420445,
-0.3570958972,
-0.2663136125,
-0.00220757,
0.7570689917,
-0.2709687948,
0.3431360424,
0.2523900867,
0.2690141499,
0.66965729,
0.0224653482,
0.83922261,
0.1234817281,
0.5865443349,
0.743455708,
0.0358612165,
0.5424664617,
0.6096845865,
-0.2671786547,
0.2111011147,
0.6814867258,
-0.1223553494,
0.557937324,
0.3684589863,
-0.3269745708,
-0.4829274714,
-0.2811337113,
-0.0758848861,
0.5647875667,
0.5533855557,
-0.1425661892,
-0.1312225759,
0.2015574574,
-0.3412148654,
0.1167528778,
-0.4555541277,
0.4650666416,
-0.2427946627,
-0.4285906553,
0.6602444649,
-0.2600745559,
0.3410016298,
-0.3523943126,
-0.2440564036,
-0.6111193299,
-0.1076344773,
-0.5067970157,
-1.149189353,
0.3304562569,
0.2464577258,
-0.2022289485,
-0.074201487,
0.1569803208,
-0.3337179124,
-0.1257438511,
-0.0843872279,
0.4129577577,
0.3879113793,
-0.0184284523,
-0.3906297684,
0.0917107314,
-0.2665680051,
-0.1099711135,
0.261447072,
0.8164216876,
-0.2814887762,
0.4716619849,
0.4479671121,
0.007760054,
0.024969317,
0.0178216267,
0.7929823995,
-0.5131273866,
-0.0864039809,
-0.6989961863,
0.615162611,
-0.0887997523,
-0.5538395643,
0.8069121242,
0.1423710585,
1.1635326147,
0.0518580526,
0.646186173,
-0.1330302507,
-0.0506755263,
-0.5912668109,
0.4020993114,
-0.6094204187,
0.2508502305,
-0.6338533163,
-1.0292098522,
-0.6007359624,
0.4344319403,
0.1221925095,
-0.2930497527,
0.5796840191,
0.9605804682,
-0.0273689162,
-0.253733933,
0.5781508088,
0.4159085453,
0.5889912844,
0.5950524807,
1.1987047195,
-0.4207930565,
1.0407607555,
-0.1867793053,
-0.4655760229,
-0.1136669442,
-0.9011098742,
-0.6389092207,
-0.6754785776,
-0.4133366048,
-0.6183332801,
-0.1643501669,
0.8274698257,
0.6561894417,
-0.5323637724,
-0.041493021,
0.1479532123,
0.0866974518,
-0.6003831029,
-0.2065600157,
0.3278104365,
0.3039874136,
-0.387421906,
0.3143796921,
0.342043668,
-0.1235364601,
-0.4889004529,
-0.0834135711,
0.5501503348,
0.4282760918,
0.7697592378,
0.5760267377,
-0.652633369,
-0.3994328678,
0.1708737463,
0.0059015215,
-0.1397279799,
0.6444635391,
-0.6487994194,
0.9253101349,
0.5258384347,
0.4403383434,
0.4492657185,
-0.1895275563,
0.5500141382,
-0.4648169577,
-0.2565479279,
0.2020663619,
0.2607395351,
0.3351253271,
-0.2451573312,
0.2814991772,
0.249430418,
-0.5302542448,
-1.0167130232,
0.2811552882,
-1.1969970465,
0.055858966,
1.1132427454,
-0.1621727347,
-0.0591299571,
-0.2591868341,
-0.4435317516,
-0.1119869798,
-0.133003667,
1.007170558,
0.6961615682,
0.0390801355,
-0.2304960638,
-0.8593637943,
0.6187231541,
0.2368972301,
-0.5213950276,
0.0098551046,
0.7536433339,
0.2830529511,
-0.0380183421,
0.2702775598,
-0.322355479,
0.5784455538,
-0.0694364458,
-0.0460173227,
-0.1071176901,
-0.5132876039,
-0.6495704651,
0.3357828856,
0.1682640314,
-0.0979529843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12723v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12723v2 | Enhancing Small Medical Learners with Privacy-preserving Contextual Prompting | 2023-05-22T05:14:38 | 2024-05-16T05:53:55 | Xinlu Zhang, Shiyang Li, Xianjun Yang, Chenxin Tian, Yao Qin, Linda Ruth Petzold | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable medical expertise, but
data privacy concerns impede their direct use in healthcare environments.
Although offering improved data privacy protection, domain-specific small
language models (SLMs) often underperform LLMs, emphasizing the need for
methods that reduce this performance gap while alleviating privacy concerns. In
this paper, we present a simple yet effective method that harnesses LLMs'
medical proficiency to boost SLM performance in medical tasks under
privacy-restricted scenarios. Specifically, we mitigate patient privacy issues
by extracting keywords from medical data and prompting the LLM to generate a
medical knowledge-intensive context by simulating clinicians' thought
processes. This context serves as additional input for SLMs, augmenting their
decision-making capabilities. Our method significantly enhances performance in
both few-shot and full training settings across three medical
knowledge-intensive tasks, achieving up to a 22.57% increase in absolute
accuracy compared to SLM fine-tuning without context, and sets new
state-of-the-art results in two medical tasks within privacy-restricted
scenarios. Further out-of-domain testing and experiments in two general domain
datasets showcase its generalizability and broad applicability. Our code can be
found at https://github.com/XZhang97666/PrivacyBoost-SLM. | [
-0.0286442414,
-0.6521805525,
0.7909463644,
-0.2444299161,
-0.2358675003,
-0.1002104655,
-0.5172774196,
-0.2540038526,
-0.1313163042,
0.5004065633,
-0.5485967398,
-0.899535954,
-0.494404912,
-0.1894972026,
0.1846920997,
0.9341691136,
0.2169675827,
0.163524732,
-0.4581930041,
-0.0823048428,
-0.3990413845,
-0.4924574494,
-0.7091947794,
-0.2011403739,
0.5061362982,
0.5271942019,
0.5522509813,
0.8896799088,
0.1927559823,
0.153546989,
-0.0911490396,
0.5999538898,
-0.3714741468,
0.3214470744,
-0.3001438081,
-0.3640567958,
-0.48349455,
-0.2190744281,
0.5999521613,
0.6897127032,
-0.1830973476,
0.185303539,
0.2863090336,
0.619074285,
-0.6664707661,
0.2491948158,
-0.5793041587,
-0.0281814951,
-0.0342321135,
-0.4246226251,
-0.4441425502,
-0.322229743,
0.2263575494,
-0.404881835,
0.2262742966,
0.1149716005,
0.5496212244,
0.5102519989,
-0.1519475132,
-0.0240606554,
-0.3596430719,
0.5051147342,
-0.6723619103,
0.5432487726,
0.713767767,
0.130472824,
0.0436396748,
-0.7555147409,
-0.3505160809,
-0.219474867,
-0.2172540277,
-0.1297140121,
0.0435564779,
0.3140732348,
0.4746937156,
0.1324422657,
-0.4562240839,
0.2786548436,
-0.2853776813,
-0.0524734147,
0.462049216,
0.3374609649,
0.0431496315,
-0.0773938522,
-0.1402828395,
-0.0281105731,
-0.9199104309,
0.2382977009,
-0.1232903376,
0.3125669658,
-0.3724578619,
0.5019984841,
-0.1639849842,
0.7665861249,
0.0143539179,
-0.540350616,
0.2628206313,
-0.1390631795,
-0.5414789915,
-0.0732000619,
0.5284007788,
0.5192291141,
-0.0089184707,
-0.0685221404,
0.1098552495,
-0.1390734613,
0.1811163872,
-0.9301193357,
-0.3578930795,
0.3560701609,
-0.3436280787,
-0.2737837434,
-0.238038823,
-0.7232033014,
-0.6812500954,
-0.302483201,
0.2938826084,
-0.3936047852,
0.2209358215,
0.2995479405,
0.3322517872,
-0.0457595661,
0.2972766459,
-0.9063467383,
0.3463097513,
0.8321942091,
0.7943037152,
-0.3341492414,
-0.0297175888,
-0.6594513059,
0.3869855106,
-0.1438812912,
0.1106857881,
-0.4820822775,
-0.557387352,
0.1191349924,
0.2163641751,
-0.0947249308,
-0.752671957,
0.1044049561,
-0.3666386902,
0.165565297,
-0.11067947,
-0.6442514658,
0.1360411942,
0.3222649395,
-0.2185421884,
0.5907976627,
-0.0021748089,
-0.6064058542,
0.4463010132,
-0.7235486507,
-0.5037389994,
0.2998011112,
-0.7040277719,
-0.5608657598,
0.1312331259,
0.2899970412,
0.7212094665,
0.2017066926,
0.1308207661,
-0.0750501975,
-0.2101243436,
0.3419833481,
-0.1141658947,
0.6545416117,
-0.0555129945,
-0.3384151161,
0.1230517551,
-0.5730322599,
0.2192315906,
-0.0155073414,
-0.2991418839,
-0.6085793376,
-0.2289572805,
-0.4680307508,
0.1576473266,
0.2528622448,
-0.341658771,
0.0008546848,
-0.8110562563,
0.2946894169,
0.6422128677,
0.3249565363,
0.6560992599,
-0.3984701335,
0.6209195852,
0.1164360046,
0.3178392649,
-0.1857694834,
-0.8407276273,
-0.3558983207,
-0.5275902748,
0.3770206571,
0.46366027,
-0.8508218527,
0.2069226801,
-0.3902693689,
-0.035419926,
-0.8130943775,
0.3216684461,
0.540455699,
0.8524718881,
0.2377516627,
-0.0838009417,
-0.2922330499,
-0.7946413755,
-0.4249451756,
0.132656306,
-0.1590653807,
0.8847118616,
0.1613693684,
-0.358976692,
0.7465590835,
-0.6199234724,
-0.6109215021,
-0.0222520344,
-0.3213456869,
-0.0206804592,
0.7683520913,
0.0873218849,
-0.7196783423,
-0.4307267964,
-0.0342529528,
-0.6934679747,
0.1076680943,
0.047469195,
-0.0097940676,
0.1584120989,
0.343075186,
-0.4183638692,
0.5725037456,
0.4777937829,
-0.2345061004,
-0.0648666844,
-0.5912453532,
-0.0764573514,
-1.0944093466,
0.0837765485,
-0.1671747565,
-0.5267263651,
-0.706831634,
0.264049232,
0.2973101735,
-0.2471339703,
-0.8518080115,
0.7607676387,
-0.4644749463,
0.211226508,
-0.3738106489,
0.0225513298,
-0.1478694677,
0.2754011154,
0.1629880071,
0.8350033164,
0.8678327203,
-0.7387883663,
-0.2466245443,
0.3636387885,
-0.2087397724,
0.5062414408,
-0.2511818707,
0.3262123466,
-0.1200881079,
-0.0713731125,
-0.5025957823,
-0.6417297125,
0.2772683799,
-0.3841511309,
0.3675236404,
-0.2527914643,
-0.6312013268,
-0.0696843639,
-0.2948278487,
0.4085708559,
0.8785045147,
-0.5974538326,
0.3944987655,
0.5549912453,
-0.2078709751,
-0.5569080114,
-0.8324201703,
0.082953088,
-0.2432957143,
-0.3313173354,
0.3220894337,
-0.2062992156,
-0.1888338774,
-0.2055319995,
-0.1028429866,
-0.0848299488,
0.1988262087,
0.5944965482,
0.4644741118,
0.079470776,
0.1910951287,
0.5645141602,
-0.0048555145,
0.210097,
-0.4445273578,
0.2509566247,
-0.0887222216,
-0.1644372344,
-0.4986607432,
0.3465614617,
0.0794799179,
-0.0197615195,
0.9543191195,
0.1642872244,
-0.628544867,
-0.4743609726,
-0.4393247664,
-0.6677017808,
-0.5809824467,
0.0554765202,
0.0064505767,
-1.4496971369,
0.1353673637,
-0.2340383232,
0.0366186015,
-0.3492409885,
0.8316361904,
-0.1239960045,
0.9153575301,
0.477022171,
0.1725492924,
0.1580814421,
-0.0175629072,
0.1855051666,
-0.8533813953,
-0.3851722181,
-0.0339181274,
-0.1598052979,
-0.5775453448,
-0.7921788096,
0.7999634147,
-0.4313516915,
0.0870993361,
-0.2241742462,
-0.5714375973,
0.8026675582,
0.3735975027,
0.6928350329,
0.3541162312,
0.078061536,
-0.1062899455,
-0.2926359177,
-0.6966204643,
-0.4169712663,
1.2553706169,
0.3295716345,
0.8530387282,
0.0112121264,
1.0303616524,
0.1284907758,
0.3812322915,
-0.6737533212,
0.6607114673,
-0.192569077,
-0.4794145823,
-0.1172767282,
-0.4144503474,
-0.919937849,
0.1215725616,
-0.0670777112,
-0.8967756629,
0.2488150299,
0.4747537673,
-0.8962405324,
0.0400804542,
-0.5409628153,
0.6079547405,
0.0504569113,
-0.8225046992,
0.056704469,
-0.9010946155,
0.371829927,
-0.2022467703,
0.3208189905,
0.0346227698,
-0.5615113974,
0.4316250086,
-0.2316806763,
1.119943738,
-0.4510224462,
-0.0834618285,
-0.106368199,
0.0521786436,
0.441106379,
0.4549741149,
0.1972139776,
0.0214890167,
-0.1715523601,
-0.1406816393,
-0.4047091007,
1.0807967186,
-0.2616253793,
-0.8807871342,
-0.1078365892,
-0.7124550343,
-0.7708248496,
0.2613045871,
0.2308149785,
0.2192544788,
0.0935364962,
0.3472532034,
1.1784672737,
-0.2733048499,
0.1498424113,
0.6287894845,
-0.1213623881,
-0.1911252737,
0.6826885343,
-0.0723857209,
0.2632800639,
0.1373824328,
0.3893460631,
-0.5039364696,
-0.6144100428,
-0.4430097342,
0.319629848,
-0.8165926933,
-0.2717111707,
-0.8234667182,
-0.1558699161,
-0.3810977936,
-0.2061323524,
-0.01702586,
-0.2669305503,
-0.3162664175,
-0.1593459249,
0.2698837519,
0.1882573664,
-0.0763689578,
0.3529914618,
-0.6504719257,
0.2968397737,
0.4089206457,
0.2725878656,
-0.2318441719,
-0.4622561336,
-0.3372516334,
-0.1588358432,
0.0627623722,
-0.516779542,
0.4033402801,
0.1625457257,
0.4089191854,
0.3632209301,
0.1782308072,
0.6360527873,
-0.8536233902,
0.8151839375,
-0.065779306,
-0.7195354104,
0.8115571737,
-0.3498386443,
0.1353179812,
0.9961562157,
0.2206524462,
0.0356118456,
-0.4516111612,
-0.7001743317,
-0.7574759722,
0.532767415,
0.0371523909,
0.3047482073,
0.0973988846,
0.4992910922,
0.1175293177,
0.4814046323,
-0.4694781601,
-0.4526206851,
0.2813235819,
-0.3563770056,
0.0191605426,
-0.0542642847,
-0.7088654637,
-0.475235492,
0.409318924,
-0.4077166617,
0.1017717198,
0.2952036858,
0.0264254138,
0.0781338289,
0.3067090213,
0.7852150798,
0.625043571,
0.0401385352,
0.2500683963,
0.3935542405,
-0.4808829725,
0.0971332639,
0.1491593122,
-0.3051825166,
0.0020443695,
-0.2312516719,
0.492205292,
0.4517318904,
-0.8255106807,
0.7886258364,
-0.1425709426,
-0.1465438157,
-0.1248611435,
0.4109513164,
0.1685260236,
0.1873174906,
-0.0265708864,
-0.0004115656,
0.2619057596,
-0.1080756858,
0.3282562196,
0.3450249434,
-0.0596612431,
-0.0270574745,
0.9683275223,
-0.0191874448,
-0.3286412954,
-0.0497204773,
-0.1071030721,
-0.000983102,
0.1851892322,
0.5231633782,
0.6076003313,
-0.2176457196,
0.019787807,
0.0393783674,
0.1445087492,
-0.2002962083,
0.4709068239,
-0.3886485696,
-0.3140654266,
-0.2076593339,
-0.1537375003,
-0.5519498587,
0.279515326,
-0.816396296,
-0.1397280544,
-0.8548264503,
-0.3222975433,
-0.2034930438,
-0.1781659275,
-0.7835450172,
0.3567916453,
0.3284732401,
0.8180631995,
-0.3329670727,
1.1985397339,
0.7606492043,
0.1572880447,
-0.7662332058,
0.2149436176,
0.2069720477,
-1.0462191105,
0.330999285,
0.1575235575,
-0.1226368845,
-0.1552706063,
-0.5943607688,
-0.3013380766,
1.0465116501,
0.3059060872,
-0.8311039805,
-0.2015661597,
0.3083930612,
0.600474894,
-0.5025521517,
-0.6214622855,
0.5662887692,
0.1956321746,
-0.334315598,
-0.6970088482,
0.4755210578,
0.1710845977,
0.108029142,
-0.2440822423,
-0.3241313994,
0.5355268717,
-0.4036585093,
-0.1661085784,
0.116133891,
0.3649606407,
0.6596395373,
0.6223924756,
0.4629457295,
0.1819525957,
1.2272083759,
0.1869548559,
1.0854489803,
-0.5418272018,
0.1038931832,
1.3330272436,
-0.4542197287,
0.6915137768,
0.6009774804,
0.3148101568,
0.330196172,
0.2617888153,
0.2900973856,
0.7812615633,
0.0499841794,
-0.7757440805,
-0.2621690631,
-0.3036287725,
-0.4258963168,
0.1395231187,
0.6069948077,
-0.8550888896,
0.1079526991,
0.3328824341,
0.3419423103,
0.156380251,
-0.4544912279,
0.9375684857,
0.4679937661,
-0.550947845,
0.4638364613,
-0.1117899641,
0.5866756439,
-0.575524807,
0.196303755,
0.021913724,
0.2323081642,
-0.2672327459,
-0.6837362647,
0.0762391537,
0.1506199539,
-0.1566980034,
-0.3558586836,
0.9179320335,
-0.5991895199,
-0.1574943513,
0.0407105647,
0.6583240628,
0.1588431746,
0.1122572497,
-0.7113026977,
-0.0808144733,
0.0221104175,
0.1109835282,
0.6792170405,
0.2908455729,
0.1316120923,
0.4832732975,
0.7162268758,
0.4008038044,
-0.1185544208,
0.1784292758,
1.0469436646,
-0.4497638047,
-0.8139088154,
-0.9428299665,
0.3507184386,
-0.2628146112,
-0.1098070368,
0.7303684354,
0.5251154304,
0.772808075,
-0.1789085716,
0.7485262156,
0.365398854,
0.7011446357,
-0.6463008523,
1.0957658291,
-0.5056867003,
0.3994862437,
0.1309573799,
-0.0739595443,
-0.4174028039,
0.5784792304,
-0.424303174,
-0.1138539761,
0.5195998549,
0.9468895793,
0.0685084313,
-0.0293397326,
0.7031280398,
0.0619717017,
0.1011722684,
0.5698238611,
0.6188922524,
-0.0023527243,
0.026594894,
-0.5380300283,
-0.3311463296,
-0.0325701125,
-0.8892369866,
-1.2006686926,
-0.2130292654,
-0.3829269409,
-0.4604098797,
0.1914961785,
1.0234929323,
1.0619039536,
-0.6383731365,
0.1323202252,
0.2880599797,
-0.1194878146,
-0.1036576554,
-0.1833045036,
0.4113675654,
-0.0949115008,
-0.5524818301,
0.7118370533,
0.2640782297,
0.169454515,
-0.1307884902,
-0.1808690727,
0.4393179715,
-0.034500327,
0.4187581539,
0.2027109116,
-0.6622760296,
-0.1605313122,
-0.0501501001,
-0.2562433183,
0.0898306146,
0.9323126078,
-0.8576830029,
0.4633411169,
-0.0078697894,
0.9102730155,
0.3636700213,
0.307259202,
0.2288310528,
-1.2237530947,
0.2258635312,
0.4791216254,
0.2227166593,
0.3640863299,
-0.9049797058,
0.3090480268,
-0.0451457016,
-0.5543479919,
-0.9259858131,
-0.0188929848,
-0.9830956459,
-0.1936139613,
1.1329413652,
-0.3600799143,
-0.2764154673,
-0.2211479098,
-0.1130630821,
-0.1268532723,
-0.5853624344,
0.7848316431,
0.0823045373,
-0.2449737042,
-0.0986262485,
-0.6586341858,
1.0552867651,
0.5270239711,
-1.0058737993,
0.1597373933,
0.4093571007,
0.582442224,
-0.2888891995,
0.8209658265,
-0.3161225021,
0.4295023084,
-0.5375071168,
-0.6085634828,
-0.405769825,
-0.4171383381,
-0.7358229756,
0.1842657179,
-0.017070828,
-0.3639693558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12720v1 | llm-japanese-dataset v0: Construction of Japanese Chat Dataset for Large Language Models and its Methodology | 2023-05-22T04:59:33 | 2023-05-22T04:59:33 | Masanori Hirano, Masahiro Suzuki, Hiroki Sakaji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study constructed a Japanese chat dataset for tuning large language
models (LLMs), which consist of about 8.4 million records. Recently, LLMs have
been developed and gaining popularity. However, high-performing LLMs are
usually mainly for English. There are two ways to support languages other than
English by those LLMs: constructing LLMs from scratch or tuning existing
models. However, in both ways, datasets are necessary parts. In this study, we
focused on supporting Japanese in those LLMs and making a dataset for training
or tuning LLMs in Japanese. The dataset we constructed consisted of various
tasks, such as translation and knowledge tasks. In our experiment, we tuned an
existing LLM using our dataset and evaluated the performance qualitatively. The
results suggest that our dataset is possibly beneficial for LLMs. However, we
also revealed some difficulties in constructing LLMs in languages other than
English. | [
-0.354816407,
-0.6693323255,
0.4527357817,
0.0226593781,
-0.3034673929,
0.1283723116,
-0.4893606603,
-0.3743282855,
0.4067838788,
0.7068074942,
-0.6651815176,
-0.6955174208,
-0.4208547175,
0.2653333545,
-0.1817860305,
0.8783333898,
-0.0465216599,
0.236531049,
-0.1523596495,
-0.0171911754,
-0.8726232052,
-0.5171859264,
-0.9176567197,
-0.3172419965,
0.6138807535,
0.8241555095,
0.6082421541,
0.6625775695,
0.625490427,
0.2703400552,
0.1332354546,
0.3375073969,
-0.9253181219,
0.2538557649,
0.0803298578,
-1.0481904745,
-0.4494282007,
-0.1664497554,
0.7009752393,
0.7233442068,
-0.012320756,
0.1824473441,
-0.0920981169,
0.5401543379,
-0.2534088492,
0.4670009911,
-0.6417839527,
0.1714898199,
-0.7235956788,
-0.2530062199,
-0.2830639184,
-0.1045430601,
-0.2859544754,
-0.7243971825,
0.0694066808,
0.429346472,
0.4826331735,
0.0505160838,
-0.2610431314,
-0.1903675944,
-0.6575766802,
0.6643192768,
-0.815723896,
0.3987599313,
0.4765439034,
0.3685453832,
-0.4433522224,
-0.2591956258,
-0.2531517744,
-0.0409948118,
0.0293486323,
0.1658152044,
0.2761978805,
-0.1440723687,
0.5067498684,
0.3987808228,
-0.5820730925,
0.6792435646,
-0.3392599821,
-0.1823719591,
0.8776547313,
0.5816568136,
0.2515743077,
-0.0916589946,
0.1026577428,
-0.0207058694,
-1.1057981253,
-0.3215668499,
0.6780080199,
0.6618662477,
-0.2453849316,
0.7876344919,
-0.3720703125,
0.514842689,
-0.429765135,
-0.6223866343,
0.2112528682,
-0.3124768734,
0.1068933979,
0.1364150494,
0.9671719074,
0.3337672353,
0.6520838737,
-0.1609138399,
-0.1841173768,
-0.0171323493,
-0.0514923893,
-0.6175298095,
-0.0301729292,
-0.0761747807,
-0.4459270835,
-0.2251074612,
-0.2080310732,
-0.5237827301,
-0.313551873,
-0.4607837796,
0.1067188382,
-0.2520051301,
-0.4077581167,
0.1410185844,
0.042838499,
0.1610257328,
0.1849482208,
-0.7500345111,
0.3475654125,
0.589928329,
0.8292860985,
-0.2247154415,
-0.2523871064,
0.0509082228,
0.0793127269,
-0.5714409947,
0.6005860567,
-0.5422345996,
-0.6842678189,
0.0389578901,
0.1111794561,
0.1472836882,
-0.5472528934,
0.5398022532,
-0.4592449367,
0.3393467069,
-0.2500479817,
-0.9325447679,
0.0215139575,
0.1139796674,
-0.6871963739,
0.8954517245,
0.0190375578,
-0.6087167263,
0.1684727818,
-0.6171089411,
-0.6531942487,
0.3521372676,
-0.2983074784,
-0.3786728382,
0.1035004035,
0.2400913388,
0.6820898056,
-0.4580973089,
0.2101440281,
-0.5000689626,
-0.4814608991,
0.3715590239,
-0.4432668388,
0.5239501595,
0.2331311703,
0.1261258125,
-0.4418969452,
-0.7766412497,
-0.1078103036,
0.3155628741,
-0.2459825128,
-0.3238016069,
0.1340379119,
-0.0495559089,
-0.0555289425,
0.3180496395,
-0.4398461878,
0.3695174456,
-0.4623169005,
0.2675296962,
0.5732412934,
0.068949528,
0.1212461442,
-0.3867868781,
0.7506988645,
0.0066660265,
-0.0131484438,
-0.3381211758,
-0.6310531497,
-0.802346766,
-0.0027744123,
0.3098324835,
0.4921270013,
-0.8412726521,
0.363573879,
-0.4448280931,
-0.4040387571,
-0.6604727507,
0.3447191119,
0.306528002,
0.3955394626,
-0.0907400176,
-0.1313325018,
-0.9137189388,
-0.9560520053,
0.1952244788,
-0.012112163,
0.007329342,
0.4290811419,
0.363627553,
0.0628878847,
0.5861726999,
-0.4963710606,
-0.2120482475,
-0.3224623203,
-0.3415634036,
0.5697959661,
0.2480807453,
0.4054899216,
-0.4492452145,
-0.5234884024,
0.0844294503,
-0.755279243,
-0.0849737003,
0.2252575159,
-0.1650624126,
0.1382955164,
0.5629419088,
-0.2832404971,
0.0318075828,
0.5665436983,
-0.0014251504,
0.3255938292,
0.0516291037,
0.2705442905,
-1.5950707197,
-0.0237537902,
0.0239886921,
-0.4541816413,
-0.6046561599,
-0.167939797,
-0.197214067,
-0.2397478968,
-0.4631421864,
0.5339997411,
-0.4381971359,
-0.2430667132,
-0.4333626926,
0.2240515351,
-0.405559361,
0.4295616448,
0.2846173048,
0.7952975035,
0.7195853591,
-0.570757091,
0.6092715859,
0.3586707711,
-0.6506739855,
0.5335001945,
-0.5291101933,
0.1500645727,
-0.0422511473,
-0.0624390095,
-0.9510850906,
-0.4227136672,
0.2984102666,
-0.3362480998,
0.4566299617,
-0.2965438664,
-0.6296207309,
-0.3240172565,
0.0030235432,
0.0481207259,
0.5310621858,
-0.2960853279,
-0.0502404794,
0.6229153275,
-0.4217082858,
-0.2168814093,
-0.5929070115,
0.2301406115,
-0.488560766,
-0.3732376397,
0.1694518477,
-0.1108258069,
-0.1690405011,
-0.1731402278,
0.0947638527,
0.2351588458,
0.1206612661,
0.2954987288,
0.3343594968,
-0.2927259207,
0.1028000638,
-0.0938579589,
-0.2605649531,
-0.061230395,
0.1130080894,
0.723428309,
0.2890928388,
-0.3497855961,
-0.3800705671,
0.1424042881,
0.2399937212,
0.2192322314,
0.6594502926,
0.1596782655,
-0.1296924651,
-0.2244994789,
-0.595870018,
-0.1415371299,
-0.4416083694,
0.4714218676,
-0.5408782363,
-1.1151007414,
0.6020567417,
-0.0504861809,
0.1568140537,
0.205059126,
0.7094157338,
-0.2808858454,
1.1554065943,
0.480804652,
-0.7859584689,
0.510938704,
-0.0229470842,
-0.0512077734,
-0.6853673458,
-0.13476789,
-0.5965510011,
-0.4942039549,
-0.9073952436,
-0.263000071,
0.315731436,
-0.2177631408,
-0.0815282613,
0.313759625,
0.0240273271,
0.592528224,
0.2566050589,
0.1248055026,
0.4420086145,
0.1065513194,
0.2093342543,
-0.1263668239,
-0.8442600965,
-0.4896743894,
1.4743878841,
0.3262172341,
0.9725028276,
0.0584903359,
0.5122081041,
-0.1043914109,
0.0428584814,
-0.864326179,
0.5494977832,
-0.2448525876,
-0.5640810132,
-0.3678619862,
-0.6241182089,
-0.9569945335,
0.0041882265,
-0.0946999341,
-0.4297553003,
-0.4550479352,
-0.1122585908,
0.2216981202,
-0.1251088232,
-0.4624249339,
0.4683077931,
-0.2818975449,
0.0022719207,
-0.1781402677,
-0.4257035255,
0.4556176364,
-0.0872383118,
0.283215344,
-0.3239578903,
-0.0975000784,
0.9745799899,
-0.2903184593,
0.9896357656,
-0.0853862837,
-0.2409085631,
-0.0144928591,
-0.2314717621,
0.4080015421,
0.4364393353,
-0.1880959868,
0.1437239051,
-0.0812330842,
-0.3310834169,
-0.5454589128,
0.6621989608,
-1.0079696178,
-0.6259102225,
-0.0471332669,
-0.5951763988,
-0.5814344287,
0.1994254142,
0.220079571,
0.3817327619,
-0.1684935093,
0.4614569545,
0.7139427066,
0.0553724244,
0.1812082827,
0.9537286758,
-0.530334115,
-0.2998914719,
0.7197865248,
0.2959258258,
0.1122004017,
0.4029844701,
0.0217718519,
-0.3123065531,
-0.6739851832,
-0.3350306749,
0.3368469775,
-0.3631261587,
-0.2527438998,
-0.0597920567,
-0.4232847691,
-0.2680565417,
0.2904537618,
-0.5110837221,
-0.2760592699,
-0.2384810299,
-0.0930159837,
0.6286485791,
0.6773968339,
0.3258079588,
0.4171388447,
-0.7644188404,
0.1925848126,
-0.1579055786,
0.6033369303,
-0.2971183062,
-0.6414911747,
-0.6241099834,
0.3965247273,
0.0291102622,
-0.5865926743,
0.2926958501,
0.2693512738,
0.789931953,
0.2853093445,
-0.2811127007,
0.8596835732,
-0.4507858157,
0.5976775885,
-0.0944162831,
-0.4522145987,
0.6877170205,
-0.4972234666,
0.3081699312,
0.5790598392,
0.6976699233,
-0.7199745774,
-0.5663545132,
-0.5041668415,
-0.3918211758,
0.8450093269,
0.2547629476,
0.2945619822,
0.158235535,
0.7513364553,
0.2495744973,
0.3544676602,
-0.4305997491,
-0.4255025983,
0.2670546472,
-0.3291391432,
-0.5682058334,
-0.0485128947,
-0.0434065461,
-0.0309754629,
0.774404943,
-0.2769376338,
0.0839705989,
-0.3908640146,
-0.0027872212,
-0.1070911735,
0.045361165,
0.1302347779,
0.4532411993,
0.0667295083,
-0.2765464783,
0.2280690521,
-0.3854815662,
0.0600845963,
-0.1455260068,
-0.2684647143,
-0.1391596049,
0.4351056516,
1.2713000774,
0.2591000795,
-0.7237482071,
0.1206672341,
-0.1460989714,
-0.2460357845,
-0.2528345585,
0.3969896138,
0.3782111108,
0.0772724524,
-0.093954511,
-0.6038210392,
-0.1028974205,
-0.5630910397,
-0.0962822959,
0.4511246085,
-0.0343710668,
-0.274163425,
0.2068189085,
0.0668511912,
-0.187517181,
0.8704727292,
0.0974328741,
-0.1917369217,
0.4442127347,
0.7767435908,
0.2919404805,
-0.2358160317,
0.0428481027,
0.4373342991,
0.0569879003,
-0.2600306273,
0.4994977415,
0.0645861328,
-1.0986111164,
-0.5292549133,
-0.5544990897,
-0.6805533767,
0.3867072761,
-0.7061033249,
0.5835761428,
-0.099767521,
-0.0743928477,
-0.2136843503,
0.416777283,
-0.6316881776,
0.2321361154,
0.1994459629,
0.7063007951,
-1.0158907175,
0.866471529,
0.8618851304,
-0.2318442166,
-0.8110089898,
-0.4655509591,
-0.020690009,
-1.1540722847,
0.2893534601,
-0.1322222203,
0.2930358946,
0.1279500425,
-0.5543094277,
-1.0494328737,
1.0449866056,
0.2971738577,
-1.0783240795,
0.1278626025,
0.6758186221,
0.684671998,
-0.3848203719,
0.1729778945,
0.5989595056,
0.2698839605,
0.2866559625,
-0.7866345644,
-0.2163615674,
-0.3615346849,
0.2298052013,
0.3246825635,
-0.8962030411,
0.2460154891,
0.3184891343,
-0.0877958164,
0.213069275,
0.5205956697,
0.3306354284,
-0.1661258191,
0.2301278114,
0.5555724502,
0.6843729615,
-0.1760583669,
0.569206357,
-0.4308235347,
0.0646640658,
1.2145848274,
-0.4817219377,
0.7561013103,
0.3292274475,
-0.3802095354,
0.0583724454,
0.6580907702,
-0.1441018432,
0.3181577623,
0.2091607004,
-0.0107258353,
-0.2402344495,
-0.066762805,
-0.4384846091,
0.6164395213,
0.6196577549,
-0.1267068386,
-0.0281542055,
0.1318062544,
0.2642642856,
-0.2207371891,
-0.2879048586,
1.0477817059,
0.2794222832,
-0.619646132,
0.2229427397,
-0.0871873498,
0.6214901805,
-0.7095766068,
0.2244881541,
-0.4767125249,
-0.036056634,
-0.1145084947,
-1.0154973269,
0.2624289095,
0.2558079064,
-0.071868442,
-0.1515383571,
0.6861131191,
-0.4915265739,
-0.670822978,
-0.1329701841,
0.5671516061,
0.4739063084,
0.2704894543,
-0.455499053,
0.2126085907,
0.057539098,
-0.4568454027,
0.5942873955,
0.4289986789,
-0.0567844249,
0.6241778731,
0.5890373588,
0.5548087358,
-0.1313299537,
0.4746230543,
0.6945948601,
-0.6263213754,
-0.2554699481,
-0.7638633251,
0.2913635671,
0.0261763185,
-0.3256056011,
1.0324904919,
0.841994226,
0.8998365998,
0.0556528494,
1.0042830706,
0.0357611738,
0.83561939,
-0.7719903588,
0.4179700911,
-0.5688385367,
0.2677316666,
0.0017442013,
-0.9035098553,
-0.3002312481,
0.4494510591,
-0.121828936,
0.0151592083,
0.3181251585,
1.1712145805,
0.1184827536,
0.3141519427,
0.4628535509,
0.2542034686,
0.3788531721,
0.6031661034,
0.8722563386,
-0.4520993233,
0.2727213204,
-0.3799249232,
-0.0424708501,
-0.0058494513,
-0.8476886153,
-0.956805706,
-0.4954026937,
-0.2779788077,
0.0244294982,
0.0310265124,
0.6697466373,
0.5747053623,
-0.788872242,
-0.6088818908,
-0.0279035307,
-0.0524177141,
0.1637698263,
-0.1796990186,
-0.0297363754,
-0.5097208023,
-0.8960923553,
0.6316438913,
0.0810193419,
0.0310974438,
-0.3744818866,
-0.1222399771,
0.1205936894,
-0.2163084745,
0.5087767243,
0.1072962955,
-0.2139422297,
-0.1021339223,
0.0060387929,
-0.0171283334,
0.1826088279,
0.6976569295,
-0.465664506,
0.3765248954,
0.5521760583,
0.3958999813,
0.671415031,
-0.2580520511,
0.8461677432,
-0.8666388392,
0.1794776171,
-0.0498436689,
0.5616129637,
0.3845209777,
-0.246920079,
0.5734555125,
0.1834323555,
-0.5918207169,
-0.6740343571,
0.0845370069,
-0.7445030808,
0.0429915227,
1.2213802338,
0.0792744532,
-0.1348818094,
-0.1046517193,
-0.4645982683,
0.306242317,
-0.1954304278,
0.5255787969,
0.931645453,
-0.0592056215,
-0.1754880548,
-0.5724716783,
0.2599284947,
0.0116660772,
-0.999538362,
-0.0106127467,
0.4223281145,
0.4614034593,
-0.2097535878,
0.7195268869,
-0.1247144938,
0.0624627322,
-0.0376266763,
-0.1531285048,
-0.1522010714,
-0.2665469348,
-0.1180685535,
-0.1189250425,
0.3913317621,
0.0514971837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12717v1 | TADA: Efficient Task-Agnostic Domain Adaptation for Transformers | 2023-05-22T04:53:59 | 2023-05-22T04:53:59 | Chia-Chien Hung, Lukas Lange, Jannik Strötgen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Intermediate training of pre-trained transformer-based language models on
domain-specific data leads to substantial gains for downstream tasks. To
increase efficiency and prevent catastrophic forgetting alleviated from full
domain-adaptive pre-training, approaches such as adapters have been developed.
However, these require additional parameters for each layer, and are criticized
for their limited expressiveness. In this work, we introduce TADA, a novel
task-agnostic domain adaptation method which is modular, parameter-efficient,
and thus, data-efficient. Within TADA, we retrain the embeddings to learn
domain-aware input representations and tokenizers for the transformer encoder,
while freezing all other parameters of the model. Then, task-specific
fine-tuning is performed. We further conduct experiments with meta-embeddings
and newly introduced meta-tokenizers, resulting in one model per task in
multi-domain use cases. Our broad evaluation in 4 downstream tasks for 14
domains across single- and multi-domain setups and high- and low-resource
scenarios reveals that TADA is an effective and efficient alternative to full
domain-adaptive pre-training and adapters for domain adaptation, while not
introducing additional parameters or complex training steps. | [
-0.4003823102,
-0.5906413198,
0.4190121591,
0.1335803866,
-0.2977233529,
0.1827170104,
-0.2527575195,
0.0265957173,
0.0652962774,
0.2440606207,
-0.6546745896,
-0.2965679765,
-0.775618732,
0.0497210175,
-0.1154898033,
0.9075257778,
-0.17813389,
-0.2439396083,
-0.1077307165,
-0.1869332939,
-0.697620213,
-0.4540195167,
-0.8285606503,
-0.060561616,
0.5854876637,
0.4378082454,
0.4448725283,
0.369043082,
0.2034065574,
0.2729592919,
0.4414129257,
0.3007051349,
-0.4114388525,
0.0942594111,
-0.5627027154,
-0.3853695393,
-0.5159372687,
-0.2722317278,
0.4971286952,
0.4919526279,
-0.0873677805,
0.498621881,
0.0285371169,
0.5320279002,
-0.9753042459,
0.2391317189,
-1.1346086264,
-0.1556176245,
-0.049997028,
-0.2937042117,
-0.6468169689,
0.116422087,
0.1654050648,
-0.9824400544,
0.3335122168,
-0.0605553687,
0.7342708707,
0.4252672493,
-0.3762954473,
-0.0775470361,
-0.8453484178,
0.9356704354,
-0.3472890556,
0.655076921,
0.2405366451,
0.4608742595,
0.1737504452,
-0.7951855659,
-0.8621291518,
0.2584348917,
-0.000266363,
0.1541477144,
-0.2552531064,
-0.1552739888,
-0.0624584407,
0.0391728319,
-0.3067034483,
-0.1465690285,
0.0875509679,
-0.0450389497,
0.123558186,
-0.0959496871,
0.3592989147,
0.0666939765,
-0.3120855987,
-0.1075907275,
-0.7250579,
-0.0736639202,
0.0260106903,
0.6377125978,
0.0058033178,
0.0587443002,
-0.0560135953,
0.5590728521,
0.4624755085,
-0.0088843824,
0.160443902,
-0.1334510446,
-0.1391920298,
-0.4357601404,
0.4121735096,
-0.1266553551,
0.1869292259,
-0.7035873532,
-0.2606739104,
-0.1280300021,
0.8365285993,
-0.7901355624,
-0.3115260303,
0.0947526917,
-0.1488652676,
0.1573265493,
-0.3894635439,
-0.5131556988,
-0.1560444385,
-0.4234569669,
0.9386968017,
-0.3615584373,
-0.1579198986,
-0.0891435146,
0.1954001933,
0.3766448498,
0.2630943656,
-1.2381163836,
0.5662444234,
0.5593980551,
0.7158110142,
-0.5135463476,
-0.6020076275,
-0.7158476114,
0.2534489334,
-0.2694500983,
0.8164737821,
-0.528849721,
-0.2661517262,
-0.0805518255,
0.3466773331,
-0.7116757035,
-0.5559239388,
0.6212437153,
-0.9628699422,
-0.0113964733,
-0.0737733543,
-0.2367128432,
-0.3483611047,
0.0820829868,
-0.6421899199,
0.6929584146,
0.5232922435,
-0.1866741329,
0.7274176478,
-0.7715299726,
-0.6444303989,
-0.1876589358,
0.2539219856,
-0.5781415701,
0.2724475563,
0.4229906797,
0.6469938159,
-0.3070553839,
0.3725618124,
0.0289626755,
-0.1814726293,
0.0232577752,
-0.3052752912,
0.329960674,
-0.017426759,
-0.29310745,
0.2532801032,
-0.5374135375,
-0.1363337934,
0.1466716528,
-0.1943185329,
-0.1748738736,
-0.0969336778,
0.1119899973,
0.16751118,
0.015182985,
-0.3815768063,
0.1752027124,
0.033472538,
0.2611637712,
0.9087298512,
-0.2132976651,
0.6359963417,
-0.2779391408,
0.4838854074,
0.2096877843,
0.3334264755,
-0.1269695759,
-0.2989569902,
-1.0176230669,
-0.5742374063,
0.6505693197,
0.3621773124,
-1.1381924152,
0.4861118495,
-0.604663074,
-0.3184638321,
-0.4735726714,
0.1082101464,
0.2417871505,
0.4747716188,
0.6399523616,
-0.4815294445,
-0.4365653694,
-0.6966373324,
-0.2670912743,
0.2418107837,
-0.0377288945,
0.2496033907,
0.5649187565,
-0.3142348826,
0.9433583021,
-0.5669078231,
-0.4507767558,
-0.2393110096,
-0.0735834166,
0.1106589437,
0.4822995663,
0.7114678621,
-0.7694576383,
-0.8735503554,
0.0444982722,
-0.3028734326,
0.1278859228,
-0.290325284,
-0.3147054315,
0.0476843752,
-0.0676213354,
-0.7819582224,
0.0581448339,
0.5799610615,
-0.2914861143,
0.2769635022,
-0.2502332628,
0.2057561427,
-1.2294706106,
0.1606701314,
-0.0675875992,
-0.4859256446,
-1.1267684698,
0.0423629172,
0.1976860762,
-0.1997471005,
-0.372066915,
0.6007038355,
-0.3257316947,
0.1804714203,
-0.4749752879,
-0.0414803997,
0.0200773887,
0.943911016,
0.1406018436,
1.1832848787,
0.979780674,
-0.7467107773,
-0.2457876503,
0.4196508825,
0.2394774258,
0.4790502191,
-0.3323796093,
0.5228318572,
0.1100752279,
0.1035377607,
-0.6907960176,
0.0597960576,
0.3288561404,
-0.1944447607,
0.4799143672,
-0.2415021211,
-0.3603020012,
-0.0878230855,
-0.236630708,
0.5874307156,
0.6157569885,
-0.8930860758,
1.306748867,
0.5982776284,
-0.1746920496,
-0.5202376246,
-0.2267144471,
0.0896143019,
-0.1911183745,
-0.1426162571,
0.6486990452,
-0.05746755,
0.5327093005,
-0.0937084109,
-0.5032156706,
-0.4716545939,
0.1468556523,
0.1220048442,
0.2077566534,
-0.198104918,
-0.0583174787,
0.2443093359,
-0.2580014765,
-0.0776199326,
-0.5628203154,
0.4679071903,
0.1214011982,
-0.3378014863,
-0.4909585118,
0.1554091275,
0.6536538005,
-0.0705372766,
0.83408916,
0.6688373089,
-0.4053342938,
-0.7152951956,
-0.3348764181,
-0.1434295326,
-0.5337011218,
0.3447948992,
-0.804761529,
-0.7759051919,
0.5195827484,
-0.4005508125,
-0.0277549215,
0.5270920992,
0.4235104024,
0.3734183908,
0.6565877795,
0.9033776522,
-0.1439423412,
0.353204906,
-0.3450250328,
0.593374908,
-0.9528318644,
-0.0785496235,
-0.4302252829,
-0.2205788344,
-0.188480854,
-0.9007770419,
0.1190912947,
-0.170156002,
-0.1267091036,
0.7021523714,
-0.4121716917,
0.5260050297,
0.3823766708,
0.1668210328,
0.0686918944,
-0.2220652699,
0.4708773196,
0.1955390573,
-0.8130789995,
-0.3321354091,
1.3024264574,
0.1278885156,
0.3354863822,
0.1006456614,
0.3726586998,
0.5859116912,
0.4007418454,
-0.8462722301,
0.4773006439,
-0.5060150623,
-0.4987488985,
-0.301823616,
-0.178406328,
-0.7252830863,
0.2341985404,
-0.117994681,
-0.6167396307,
0.4447256923,
0.2097610235,
-0.3892610669,
0.4907365441,
-0.8322720528,
0.8911525607,
0.1383383721,
-0.2247614413,
-0.294131875,
-0.2763025165,
0.0190867409,
-0.8356880546,
-0.0136138108,
-0.1768335551,
-0.2311956137,
0.7056023479,
-0.1270962059,
0.8812654018,
-0.5609915853,
-0.100402303,
0.3566966653,
-0.083643809,
0.6071637869,
0.0724256486,
0.0233093482,
0.0628361702,
-0.1169545874,
-0.6263406873,
-0.8606790304,
0.599142015,
-0.8606657982,
-0.661118269,
-0.1859288663,
-0.6651329994,
-0.8392729163,
0.1669860333,
-0.1520302892,
0.4492707551,
-0.1548658311,
0.0745073929,
0.6029748321,
-0.0606777184,
0.3687468767,
0.5904023647,
0.2673912048,
-0.2613970041,
1.2970592976,
-0.2021599263,
0.2316861302,
0.608514607,
-0.0441609211,
-0.251449734,
-0.7679021955,
-0.6826950312,
0.0381044298,
-0.7804682255,
-0.3831419051,
-0.6835016608,
-0.1184634492,
-0.1436181813,
-0.2726795375,
-0.4272485077,
-0.5056576133,
-0.3662894964,
0.1319343448,
0.2412308604,
0.4453157783,
0.312330395,
0.4706077576,
-0.6072673202,
0.7653470039,
0.6883609295,
0.5516251326,
0.1454250365,
-0.8077762127,
-0.4468973875,
-0.2483527958,
-0.2928505838,
-0.366079241,
0.1073496714,
0.7968961,
0.6257688403,
-0.0247377679,
0.1117237583,
0.6748036742,
-0.8486450315,
0.7535085678,
0.0691641942,
-1.3830975294,
0.1808592677,
-0.109711647,
0.2870769799,
0.5530343652,
0.4694283903,
-0.0986758694,
-0.0502488837,
-0.2905714512,
-0.7217825055,
0.906543076,
0.2039005458,
0.6582827568,
0.203519538,
0.491828084,
0.6377770901,
0.056687206,
-0.5309337974,
-0.2261548489,
-0.4912424982,
-0.23053509,
-0.0357433744,
-0.1230997369,
-0.0979542434,
-0.3569796681,
0.9066772461,
-0.6004477739,
0.3350093961,
-0.1628863662,
-0.6130228043,
0.0011037673,
0.2618780732,
0.366114378,
0.7585995197,
0.1799686253,
0.0936716348,
0.7430053353,
-0.671574235,
0.4113290012,
0.1058181822,
0.0224224702,
0.0206328742,
0.1308629811,
0.9230974317,
0.3113544285,
-0.4698245227,
0.5349177718,
-0.1630109698,
-0.2429697216,
0.1785290092,
0.1792779416,
-0.1122879162,
0.2359262556,
0.5428756475,
0.485558629,
0.1436680853,
-0.3865217566,
0.3691374063,
0.2427379042,
-0.332260251,
-0.8117451072,
0.7536405325,
0.3459176421,
-0.163314417,
-0.0265400242,
-0.1681304574,
-0.335742712,
0.1673922688,
0.6687722802,
1.4545557499,
-0.3896319568,
0.4057228565,
0.0572829507,
-0.014084504,
0.2712986171,
0.1298805922,
-0.2264759541,
-0.7826724648,
-0.562627852,
-0.7365221381,
-0.4417406619,
-0.1819079369,
-0.468750447,
0.0618643276,
-0.3747026026,
-0.3429448605,
0.051924035,
-0.2838386893,
-0.8516651988,
0.3634291887,
-0.0700576603,
0.9057744145,
-0.7026958466,
1.0592668056,
0.5671585798,
-0.0522871204,
-0.6316447854,
0.3874308169,
-0.5414146185,
-0.8437880278,
0.3913130164,
-0.0992761701,
-0.4930925369,
0.2002133131,
0.1048259437,
-0.8098750114,
1.0911602974,
0.670555234,
-0.2081384063,
0.0314115845,
0.2915939689,
0.4897081554,
-0.4382663667,
-0.0657579526,
0.654428184,
0.2585266232,
-0.146627292,
-0.8712407351,
0.3835086823,
-0.2900250554,
0.138543874,
0.1582861096,
-0.6569889784,
0.4531120956,
-0.0540357344,
-0.2699365914,
-0.0799304843,
0.7366536856,
-0.1910514683,
0.1757134646,
0.846211791,
0.1699233949,
0.5722241998,
-0.2230953574,
0.7470910549,
-0.63901335,
0.327381134,
0.8352456093,
-0.2750131488,
0.7908141613,
0.4467032254,
-0.2269199044,
0.5777506828,
0.1924700886,
0.2484222651,
0.9121574759,
-0.0121718589,
-0.4137099385,
-0.2041902393,
-0.1173788607,
0.015740009,
0.3851206899,
0.1954312325,
0.0372315906,
-0.017606616,
0.2133992165,
-0.1744982153,
-0.0951237082,
-0.2362520844,
0.8015311956,
0.0057929927,
-0.5623307228,
0.7846339345,
-0.0542629585,
0.5901029706,
-0.6505568027,
0.2971457541,
0.0215462316,
0.2051749825,
-0.0363556333,
-0.3820634484,
0.5072292686,
0.0898540318,
-0.2598819435,
-0.3187900782,
0.8453576565,
-0.2462931275,
-0.1272410154,
0.1843845546,
0.6817510724,
-0.5063523054,
-0.3281576335,
-0.5788850784,
-0.0800783113,
-0.2442198545,
-0.3205670118,
0.3438934982,
0.4602066278,
0.0694241673,
0.6530817747,
0.4914623201,
-0.1833185405,
0.008312596,
0.2508082986,
1.0976877213,
-0.5250591636,
-0.2534923553,
-0.3504268527,
0.6362468004,
0.2052754313,
-0.3459023535,
0.481908828,
0.4746609628,
0.6347221732,
-0.5569500923,
0.7824004292,
0.0384685881,
0.1857670993,
-0.5310685635,
0.6724236012,
-0.5528722405,
0.0490714684,
-0.0183994006,
-1.0421993732,
-0.239693597,
0.0298576429,
-0.3035108447,
0.143279925,
0.7267639041,
0.5713120699,
-0.4843334854,
-0.063515529,
0.3699248731,
-0.1525818408,
0.2285621762,
0.5632060766,
0.5195372701,
-0.5446687341,
0.4347633123,
-0.1691060066,
-0.0679894611,
0.0599761121,
-0.6606979966,
-0.9582000375,
-0.9630321264,
-0.4353717864,
0.1850476265,
0.2598339915,
0.6332346797,
1.1007779837,
-1.2630566359,
-0.0058295736,
0.0355360806,
-0.0222662427,
-0.4547538757,
-0.1384490877,
0.6121444106,
-0.6710151434,
-0.9371343851,
0.5289009809,
0.3418792188,
-0.2225853652,
0.013915292,
-0.012895219,
0.1011055559,
0.4128595889,
0.7889971733,
0.126732111,
-0.5696876645,
-0.5453808308,
0.0533381216,
0.2503686249,
0.1932297349,
0.8850318789,
-0.8841898441,
0.4040572345,
0.2202257812,
1.0849852562,
0.3692929149,
-0.0624518618,
0.7247524858,
-0.8438830972,
0.0239115953,
0.0478857867,
0.2770020068,
0.3680439591,
-0.2253828198,
0.3246507645,
0.1758791357,
-0.4165412188,
-0.7180587053,
0.0344243571,
-1.0197534561,
-0.2225785702,
0.6992558837,
-0.2718612254,
-0.2068908513,
-0.1894339323,
-0.1012204662,
0.3483449221,
-0.3451235294,
1.0019785166,
0.3049057424,
0.1217313111,
-0.1181141511,
-0.275036335,
0.6079748869,
0.4457612038,
-1.0791729689,
0.1820603013,
-0.1933874488,
0.2061766386,
0.1176409274,
0.5675922632,
0.2794604599,
0.2667998075,
0.0328522325,
-0.2027027309,
0.0524015315,
-0.7260183692,
-0.1912759393,
0.1140115708,
0.1749477088,
-0.4766599834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12710v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12710v2 | Beyond Labels: Empowering Human Annotators with Natural Language Explanations through a Novel Active-Learning Architecture | 2023-05-22T04:38:10 | 2023-10-23T16:44:59 | Bingsheng Yao, Ishan Jindal, Lucian Popa, Yannis Katsis, Sayan Ghosh, Lihong He, Yuxuan Lu, Shashank Srivastava, Yunyao Li, James Hendler, Dakuo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Real-world domain experts (e.g., doctors) rarely annotate only a decision
label in their day-to-day workflow without providing explanations. Yet,
existing low-resource learning techniques, such as Active Learning (AL), that
aim to support human annotators mostly focus on the label while neglecting the
natural language explanation of a data point. This work proposes a novel AL
architecture to support experts' real-world need for label and explanation
annotations in low-resource scenarios. Our AL architecture leverages an
explanation-generation model to produce explanations guided by human
explanations, a prediction model that utilizes generated explanations toward
prediction faithfully, and a novel data diversity-based AL sampling strategy
that benefits from the explanation annotations. Automated and human evaluations
demonstrate the effectiveness of incorporating explanations into AL sampling
and the improved human annotation efficiency and trustworthiness with our AL
architecture. Additional ablation studies illustrate the potential of our AL
architecture for transfer learning, generalizability, and integration with
large language models (LLMs). While LLMs exhibit exceptional
explanation-generation capabilities for relatively simple tasks, their
effectiveness in complex real-world tasks warrants further in-depth study. | [
-0.2855671048,
-0.9531170726,
0.3466737866,
-0.1230109856,
-0.3176387846,
0.0936605483,
-0.5586957335,
-0.8049442768,
-0.0429591015,
0.1298613548,
-0.4540513158,
-0.4756451547,
-0.3236321807,
0.0516337268,
0.0060988581,
1.0305643082,
-0.3306437731,
-0.2039700598,
-0.0021033483,
-0.1933237463,
-0.2556593418,
-0.1486997604,
-0.7881920934,
-0.3960645795,
0.8485838175,
0.5979712009,
1.0264792442,
1.0794684887,
0.1089722738,
0.2152317762,
-0.0607210509,
0.5606914759,
-0.0828456059,
0.2070771456,
-0.2414837629,
-0.4114383757,
-0.5680370927,
0.167501986,
0.4683376849,
1.1507850885,
-0.0259604566,
0.1626957804,
-0.2669311464,
0.4731715322,
-0.7551669478,
0.2715585828,
-0.4889881909,
0.2770636082,
0.0760912523,
0.2345062643,
-0.362113744,
-0.2496072948,
0.3076505661,
-0.8340343237,
0.2729869485,
0.0931228101,
0.8719898462,
0.4565941095,
-0.3783145249,
-0.2925792933,
-0.9480912089,
0.6557092667,
-0.224193573,
0.3624783754,
0.6078196168,
0.5761901736,
0.377094686,
-0.7594323158,
-0.6187810302,
0.1330518574,
-0.0313002691,
0.1119588092,
-0.2204501778,
0.1613837183,
-0.0077221207,
0.3188670874,
-0.1834126264,
0.3441040516,
-0.4106330872,
-0.2092586011,
0.6127748489,
-0.2489576638,
0.2001772821,
0.1234449744,
-0.3430231512,
0.2148620188,
-0.5530765653,
-0.065442577,
0.0484760217,
0.2552548647,
-0.2129663825,
0.2152357846,
0.0175409075,
1.0034300089,
-0.060315121,
0.0562587529,
0.2374631017,
-0.088796936,
-0.3896687925,
0.2482516617,
0.5344944,
-0.2176308185,
0.0763261169,
-0.4697275162,
-0.2082072198,
-0.0049434621,
0.3167076409,
-0.5183538795,
-0.4982336462,
0.2903821468,
-0.5357249975,
-0.3010214865,
-0.2549208999,
-0.7567117214,
-0.53839463,
-0.4272418618,
0.5385538936,
-0.2022914588,
-0.4372934997,
0.0272726603,
0.2314878553,
-0.2384212315,
0.6209867001,
-0.8151142001,
0.188539058,
0.3528724611,
0.7770216465,
-0.2435070127,
-0.0096646799,
-0.6180809736,
0.3218065202,
-0.1574076116,
0.8727906346,
-0.6513168812,
-0.0701930448,
0.1283925325,
-0.1900609583,
0.1106927171,
-0.5454068184,
0.5070731044,
-0.6826139688,
0.052860748,
-0.0273122955,
-0.1782252342,
-0.6397510767,
0.2567599118,
-0.8438785076,
0.855225265,
-0.117068015,
-0.2786472738,
0.5579802394,
-1.0779448748,
-0.5269969702,
0.3642914593,
-0.1149437726,
-0.5422948003,
-0.1512742341,
0.1612987518,
0.5154012442,
-0.0547985174,
0.2153470963,
-0.0780748054,
-0.2733254433,
0.5180193186,
-0.6637526751,
0.7152531147,
0.3990214467,
-0.472907424,
0.0822827592,
-0.7790367603,
-0.2476797849,
0.0763085186,
-0.567546308,
-0.1976730973,
-0.1198225841,
-0.2889956236,
0.0757976845,
0.2056873292,
-0.3432618678,
0.1754430085,
-0.1000335664,
0.2661075592,
0.7078062892,
0.0861347914,
0.6701796055,
-0.1512616873,
0.8037102222,
-0.0908183679,
0.2001825124,
-0.290930897,
-0.5250949264,
-0.4840226173,
-0.7213668823,
0.3676873744,
0.4570922256,
-0.6974726915,
0.1496223509,
-0.1783433259,
-0.4353145063,
-0.8632409573,
0.3993301988,
0.5335245132,
0.6466279626,
0.5867756605,
0.1277678609,
-0.4718183279,
-0.8350319266,
-0.3947209418,
-0.1975840032,
-0.0777575448,
0.4642253518,
0.2554767132,
-0.3426302969,
1.0434495211,
-0.2931889892,
-0.0536000952,
-0.4392235875,
0.3150689602,
0.01555466,
0.0981944352,
0.2093776613,
-1.1392906904,
-0.1960196346,
0.0203147512,
-0.6025050282,
-0.1289575398,
-0.3024483323,
-0.1342206597,
0.0265236702,
0.1995209008,
-0.5111121535,
0.2499594539,
0.4392664731,
-0.3437315822,
0.3059355915,
-0.1973593831,
-0.2591139972,
-0.6789709926,
0.0897553489,
0.2262839079,
-0.0397657491,
-0.6738370657,
-0.1662631482,
-0.0927571133,
-0.3188259304,
-0.3939219713,
0.8682092428,
-0.7650057077,
0.1291970462,
-0.2188735008,
0.2510723174,
0.1001159474,
0.4885616302,
0.1554355472,
0.3363288343,
0.6102931499,
-0.7491681576,
0.336840868,
0.3547857106,
-0.0651369095,
0.0582061671,
-0.3125443459,
-0.0299128909,
-0.2678762376,
0.4139751792,
-0.9950342178,
-0.4406577051,
0.4444836676,
-0.4173611403,
0.2245332301,
-0.5310899615,
-0.3821289837,
-0.2225060314,
0.0932848677,
0.4117870033,
0.5544669628,
-0.7740042806,
0.7816821337,
0.3079850078,
0.0119654601,
-0.4565156996,
-0.8475484848,
0.0953823924,
-0.1198922172,
-0.2662677467,
0.2172088921,
0.0458059572,
-0.5881710649,
0.1870053709,
-0.2344803214,
-0.3119651079,
0.5851627588,
0.2967078388,
0.2910116315,
-0.1279385835,
0.601864934,
0.1867594272,
-0.1612159163,
-0.0014415948,
-0.133623898,
-0.1372179687,
0.044074513,
-0.452878803,
-0.5093781352,
0.1336286664,
0.2758747935,
-0.4612641931,
0.9054022431,
0.8163350224,
-0.5801851153,
-0.4937603474,
-0.297776401,
-0.2350535542,
-0.4182222188,
0.1767543107,
-0.2200025022,
-0.4768595099,
0.3687400818,
-0.2696520686,
0.6636332273,
0.3809360266,
0.6174327135,
-0.0430057608,
1.1092705727,
0.339597255,
0.5520138741,
0.6357699037,
-0.2525730729,
0.4334352612,
-0.3995886445,
-0.4157132208,
-0.2561302781,
-0.6448910236,
-0.0741019025,
-0.6565049887,
0.1077229753,
0.2591721416,
-0.1110507473,
-0.1991313398,
-0.641438067,
0.4397787154,
0.4066371918,
0.04105746,
0.2144473642,
0.1104171127,
0.1805871278,
0.1692576557,
-0.7331366539,
-0.6992516518,
0.7127498388,
0.5359792113,
0.6249665618,
0.1989513338,
0.6283868551,
0.483810246,
0.8549826145,
-0.8836706281,
0.3647471368,
-0.0034709745,
-0.8058081865,
-0.3416545093,
-0.35233289,
-1.0803345442,
0.4253946841,
-0.4986562431,
-0.3565223515,
0.1466236115,
0.5367333293,
-0.5577012897,
0.4495505393,
-0.955632329,
0.8271389604,
-0.4368425906,
-0.576251328,
-0.0881896392,
-0.5535591841,
0.2430592477,
0.0019544314,
0.6717454791,
-0.119578898,
-0.442312628,
0.9167875648,
-0.0597317144,
1.2450590134,
-0.5859732628,
-0.1483041495,
0.3806374073,
0.127272591,
0.3337240815,
0.0374783203,
-0.480527848,
-0.0617965385,
-0.8311160207,
-0.4798957705,
-0.6451847553,
0.453348726,
-0.7133052349,
-0.2807792127,
-0.0508074239,
-0.3949332237,
-0.2553707361,
0.0224142224,
-0.203789562,
0.4446367025,
0.1966706812,
-0.0956012309,
0.9174317122,
-0.1677667797,
0.2223805934,
0.7203099132,
0.3525782526,
-0.2089955509,
0.9126302004,
0.1150886342,
0.0321562402,
0.2906390131,
0.2732577026,
-0.2570932209,
-0.8373057246,
-0.7441419959,
0.2104771137,
-0.8033598661,
-0.21445705,
-0.7703074217,
0.1908973157,
-0.0499840342,
-0.4738707244,
-0.2012763023,
-0.5225041509,
-0.4974250793,
-0.5801830888,
0.524635613,
0.7109190822,
-0.0865108445,
0.247871086,
-0.7832508087,
0.5600098372,
0.5724209547,
0.3990627229,
0.3452693522,
-0.5842204094,
-0.7813857794,
0.2724296153,
-0.1488085687,
-1.0467572212,
0.1175531,
0.5081682205,
0.8906978369,
0.7282855511,
0.1546037942,
0.5898918509,
-0.2598864734,
0.7161775827,
0.0049823304,
-0.741531074,
0.6040870547,
-0.0282641239,
0.1746699065,
0.4686372578,
0.4898180962,
-0.4803693593,
-0.3232267499,
-0.6343408823,
-1.2621507645,
0.7316129804,
-0.0482669845,
-0.0388491899,
-0.1123320609,
0.7296367884,
0.5583950877,
-0.1133308038,
-0.8468785286,
-0.4391314983,
-0.2246490866,
-0.3925561309,
0.1475176066,
0.0301642828,
-0.4794946909,
0.0373117328,
0.7890267372,
-0.2777418494,
0.1754708737,
0.0993127748,
-0.3913824558,
-0.3806104064,
0.3028455675,
0.36411497,
0.7962220311,
0.1013869122,
0.548289597,
0.1790156215,
-0.2901719213,
-0.0685185716,
0.4158642292,
0.0387190357,
0.0560382791,
0.7429904342,
1.0382281542,
0.1453549117,
-0.8612236381,
0.2656469345,
-0.0142500754,
-0.2145104259,
-0.1750434786,
0.1606751829,
0.1616990417,
0.0807656422,
0.8034963012,
0.0225036312,
0.0000470229,
-0.6142299771,
0.04697432,
0.1385584921,
-0.6363849044,
-0.5520165563,
0.8334269524,
0.545661509,
-0.4509086907,
0.296004653,
-0.243812561,
-0.4390080571,
0.4724672437,
0.2833728492,
0.63479954,
-0.0553136952,
0.3562625647,
0.0824374259,
0.0517715849,
0.042777583,
0.1493771076,
-0.5773965716,
-0.6857556105,
-0.7675676346,
-0.4659452438,
-0.7380125523,
-0.2764757872,
-0.6654112339,
-0.0492151082,
-0.3684911132,
0.0911540687,
0.2743605375,
-0.0350914188,
-0.6523128748,
0.4576495588,
0.4422160089,
0.9108879566,
-1.2340289354,
0.677372396,
1.3329126835,
-0.5335296392,
-0.6522754431,
-0.0723247379,
-0.1833008826,
-0.9620298743,
0.7012372613,
0.0752653182,
0.0049040397,
-0.2772473991,
-0.5403651595,
-0.30540815,
1.1559712887,
0.3152637184,
-0.2913787961,
0.0338533074,
-0.3680832386,
0.7272176147,
-0.1830251068,
0.2161398381,
0.2270818204,
0.6727636456,
0.0167026091,
-0.6235150695,
0.1619932503,
-0.1049350202,
-0.6039313078,
0.2505865395,
-0.3621334732,
0.5117285848,
-0.4144064188,
-0.1512963474,
-0.5075642467,
0.8402507901,
0.2606161833,
0.455502212,
0.7660665512,
0.2944933772,
1.0360215902,
0.0407500118,
0.8977767229,
-0.1532327235,
-0.0643582717,
0.7153099775,
-0.017486684,
0.5620065928,
0.4113638699,
0.1132000014,
0.7626928091,
0.8605030179,
0.1373749375,
0.3573415875,
0.1352886111,
-0.6125853062,
-0.66334939,
-0.2448706478,
0.0323540457,
0.3292243481,
0.5368894935,
-0.5845096111,
-0.1400709152,
0.2888436317,
0.0863985643,
0.1248421222,
-0.5222851634,
0.981975317,
-0.021359235,
-0.6762986779,
0.6320567727,
0.0377227105,
0.3474956453,
-0.3816254437,
-0.3446925282,
0.0530890338,
0.1939313859,
-0.3882836699,
-0.8512227535,
0.0852580294,
0.0470266603,
-0.2296515703,
-0.7931299806,
0.5398263931,
-0.5683000088,
-0.242908895,
0.0909088701,
0.5783808231,
0.2588758767,
0.2090637535,
-0.7923896313,
-0.0579129905,
0.0524858199,
-0.3614178598,
0.1684664339,
0.7743102312,
-0.3364863694,
0.7966330051,
0.5748503208,
0.2537537515,
-0.0692777857,
0.0218089353,
0.7793108225,
-0.3797334135,
-0.4426498115,
-0.6587686539,
0.5032036304,
0.0833145306,
-0.1400328726,
0.3763465881,
0.5352079272,
0.2837913036,
0.1497942805,
1.1045377254,
-0.0113371983,
0.6113176942,
-0.3499679863,
0.443371892,
-0.5827046037,
0.3266527057,
0.2632338703,
-0.6526021957,
-0.4798697233,
0.6408833265,
-0.3462770879,
-0.104708612,
0.3586741686,
0.0994491205,
-0.3259528279,
-0.0433280878,
0.0434462354,
0.4555187821,
0.3601059318,
0.1854251027,
0.4577977359,
0.0761360601,
0.993842423,
-0.1820007265,
-0.4310293794,
-0.2474884689,
-0.7308191061,
-0.9172780514,
-0.3687581122,
-0.6187588573,
-0.1321882755,
0.1878835857,
0.9053145647,
0.8459442258,
-0.5921202302,
0.2683660388,
0.1113301665,
0.3305965662,
-0.485352695,
-0.2020547986,
0.616328299,
-0.1915354282,
-0.652556777,
0.4930403233,
0.058257971,
-0.0455266982,
-0.4188803434,
-0.1154612675,
-0.1981550008,
-0.0182477683,
0.4786534905,
0.5354265571,
-0.7249919176,
-0.118954964,
-0.3413093984,
0.1661950201,
0.0564431809,
0.7663264275,
-1.0821269751,
0.5907818079,
0.2807523906,
0.8370912075,
0.2667455673,
0.1470131576,
0.5790489316,
-0.728284061,
0.0515466183,
0.544064641,
0.1443606168,
0.4715629816,
-0.2790004611,
0.4325313568,
0.0469288267,
-0.231879279,
-0.8533216119,
0.2721911967,
-0.8698878884,
-0.4080747366,
1.3392647505,
-0.3990440369,
-0.343806982,
-0.6847661138,
-0.2025041431,
0.6664941907,
-0.5460630655,
1.0534026623,
0.3705433011,
-0.3021620214,
-0.279813081,
-0.6507803798,
0.5831848383,
0.2835546434,
-0.9168693423,
0.441978991,
0.4624466598,
0.0534006581,
0.1322013438,
0.3233007491,
0.0888852775,
0.5203858614,
-0.3565806448,
0.3532199562,
-0.4685623944,
-0.1955287457,
-0.3572191894,
0.1544026583,
0.2245982587,
-0.3639388382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12709v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12709v1 | Cross-lingual Transfer Can Worsen Bias in Sentiment Analysis | 2023-05-22T04:37:49 | 2023-05-22T04:37:49 | Seraphina Goldfarb-Tarrant, Björn Ross, Adam Lopez | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis (SA) systems are widely deployed in many of the world's
languages, and there is well-documented evidence of demographic bias in these
systems. In languages beyond English, scarcer training data is often
supplemented with transfer learning using pre-trained models, including
multilingual models trained on other languages. In some cases, even supervision
data comes from other languages. Does cross-lingual transfer also import new
biases? To answer this question, we use counterfactual evaluation to test
whether gender or racial biases are imported when using cross-lingual transfer,
compared to a monolingual transfer setting. Across five languages, we find that
systems using cross-lingual transfer usually become more biased than their
monolingual counterparts. We also find racial biases to be much more prevalent
than gender biases. To spur further research on this topic, we release the
sentiment models we used for this study, and the intermediate checkpoints
throughout training, yielding 1,525 distinct models; we also release our
evaluation code. | [
-0.5815623403,
-0.379748106,
0.1240732223,
0.4296602011,
-0.1749457419,
0.0200619362,
-0.0463042594,
-0.8561003804,
0.3353094161,
0.3686326146,
-0.7314522862,
-0.0421930477,
-0.8167164922,
0.0250533819,
-0.3324644566,
1.2945924997,
0.0344706997,
0.7516275644,
-0.1426883638,
-0.4529185593,
-0.5001945496,
-0.8487132192,
-0.3912293911,
-0.477444917,
0.3126462102,
0.2630934715,
0.6671037674,
-0.2555900812,
0.3587681949,
0.1647638232,
0.0236585941,
-0.3300385773,
-0.4837017059,
-0.241176039,
-0.5750092864,
-0.6410366893,
-0.3999050856,
0.256318897,
0.3715985119,
1.0308016539,
0.3137487173,
0.2914581299,
0.0068866061,
0.852599144,
-0.6801682115,
0.0110718682,
-0.3383566141,
0.3437564075,
-0.1776005626,
0.0187552255,
-0.4391203821,
-0.4318046272,
0.6922144294,
-0.4348558486,
0.2140070796,
-0.1316261292,
0.7682484388,
-0.0892989337,
-0.6933495998,
-0.2533326745,
-0.5908356309,
0.9441864491,
-0.4615163207,
0.4748512506,
0.142983675,
0.1297578067,
0.4108391404,
-0.1354839057,
-0.4215779006,
-0.1213189736,
-0.2422691286,
0.130077377,
-0.2965111732,
-0.2763126194,
0.3549003005,
-0.0764779374,
-0.5733712912,
-0.0359495021,
-0.6224759817,
-0.2373751104,
0.7620202303,
-0.1353393495,
0.805175662,
-0.3078044653,
-0.5237474442,
-0.0983665884,
-0.7871106863,
-0.0726506561,
0.6149833798,
0.6051914096,
-0.3547941148,
0.3661490381,
-0.0009851264,
0.4186312854,
0.2104805261,
0.1089011207,
0.4749462903,
-0.5574433804,
0.0980425775,
0.3460603356,
0.7208049297,
0.7773823142,
0.8545594215,
-0.0928531662,
0.1034073085,
0.2474951297,
0.2380945534,
-0.6024647355,
-0.0484890454,
-0.2220582217,
-0.5316338539,
-0.2738656998,
0.011082666,
-1.1639487743,
-0.4870212078,
-0.2170560658,
0.1890495867,
-0.2162548453,
-0.3932796419,
-0.1138312519,
-0.2892367542,
0.3661725521,
0.0788571462,
-0.8830164075,
0.0782196298,
0.435821861,
0.6360146403,
-0.4125014544,
-0.5018339157,
-0.4335905313,
-0.3074003458,
-0.4845842421,
0.7056388259,
-0.6723479629,
-0.6469020247,
0.1871664077,
0.1211903319,
-0.283419311,
-0.5259246826,
0.2175023705,
-0.3344059885,
0.4616494775,
-0.9970209599,
0.0764394328,
-0.1353230029,
-0.0116523691,
-0.4559539557,
0.9131219387,
0.1515693218,
-0.8420510292,
0.7431812882,
-0.5171049237,
-0.818243444,
-0.4391483665,
-0.0028279929,
-0.1003224254,
-0.0822756961,
0.3255117834,
0.0112386849,
-0.1514065117,
0.2766411901,
-0.6023845673,
-0.3456911147,
0.3410839438,
-0.3237352967,
1.2197370529,
0.262588203,
-0.5915191174,
-0.3488159776,
-0.4636350572,
-0.4066714644,
-0.1872442663,
0.0198029354,
-0.8530579209,
-0.5120561719,
0.0237329416,
0.5663848519,
0.0674386844,
-0.7252644897,
0.0398272127,
-0.1788550019,
0.0271187611,
0.5872058868,
-0.1291741133,
1.0313917398,
-0.1497891545,
0.8603803515,
0.4024064243,
0.1974043548,
0.1374629885,
-0.2729468346,
-0.7368909121,
0.2196829766,
0.243961677,
0.7107166052,
-0.9399394989,
-0.0859133601,
-0.3213468194,
-0.2665111721,
-0.3296242654,
-0.0286107119,
0.4030278623,
0.4718825817,
0.2739608884,
-0.4730819762,
-0.5691534281,
-1.1003359556,
-0.6236504912,
-0.3231890798,
0.4234968424,
0.1719191223,
0.542642951,
-0.2945690155,
0.8017225266,
-0.3023173213,
-0.2933337986,
-0.2593614459,
0.3361581564,
-0.2965364456,
0.5495951772,
1.1516420841,
-0.4770564735,
-0.517223835,
0.0325510949,
-0.811537683,
-0.5429973602,
-0.2700871229,
-0.4731637537,
0.5307747126,
0.5551461577,
-0.429507345,
0.3147139549,
0.830082655,
-0.4297442138,
0.5757288933,
0.4532471299,
0.2374822497,
-0.8507944942,
0.1731099635,
0.2753112912,
-0.0853727162,
-0.5551221371,
-0.2208061367,
-0.1285109222,
-0.0012220117,
-0.6810227633,
0.7460703254,
-0.5013902187,
-0.4199753106,
-0.0316241905,
0.0681596622,
0.1367038339,
0.3563287258,
0.0890133828,
0.8556373715,
0.5291936994,
-0.268042326,
0.1571013778,
0.1603073031,
-0.3488577902,
0.9848245382,
-0.2099379003,
0.117976509,
-0.2759665549,
0.3120616376,
-0.9785744548,
0.3449463546,
0.5291550756,
-0.4046994448,
0.2268900573,
-0.3612181544,
0.2288533002,
-0.1360741556,
-0.242147401,
0.4809915423,
0.249040857,
-0.5784783363,
0.6817964911,
0.4347996414,
-0.3967851102,
-1.0490920544,
-1.2585859299,
-0.0304771513,
-0.1860536635,
-0.3669935763,
-0.1612918675,
0.1794164628,
-0.4519858956,
0.0020839644,
-0.0714989677,
0.0760750845,
-0.1493446082,
0.0384074524,
0.4691472352,
-0.0642075464,
0.0317080542,
0.2511942387,
0.1169749424,
0.4358022511,
-0.0405247882,
0.4855572581,
0.0446674936,
-0.4164564312,
-0.0355017632,
0.4768548906,
0.9059782624,
-0.1907836199,
0.7449020147,
0.6339278221,
-0.0082071349,
-0.2289832979,
-0.3655305803,
-0.1888877004,
-0.365398258,
0.4873902798,
-0.365501821,
-0.552783668,
0.6807824969,
0.2414252758,
-0.0350614414,
0.4563225806,
0.1892179251,
-0.0938602239,
1.1609851122,
0.5907597542,
-0.5334225893,
0.7628004551,
-0.1722295731,
0.1605743319,
-0.6008700132,
-0.1333318353,
-0.5747802258,
-0.2867776752,
-0.793587029,
-0.1090595201,
0.1319775432,
-0.3485229313,
-0.1920544356,
-0.0427216068,
-0.0107745929,
0.3367371261,
0.3040174246,
-0.0954123363,
0.1283689439,
0.2736658454,
-0.2033134401,
-0.3154729307,
-0.8482694626,
-0.2444292009,
1.0874136686,
0.3059351742,
0.8717516661,
-0.1058835164,
0.4208568931,
0.4855610132,
0.7051896453,
-0.6768447757,
0.5517088771,
-0.626223743,
-0.7601551414,
-0.0706584305,
-0.4961697757,
-0.6957245469,
0.4284637272,
-0.3070177734,
-0.5289571881,
0.8632256389,
-0.0335111581,
0.0674251243,
0.2233783007,
-0.7494775653,
0.7154530287,
-0.3293206692,
-0.333879143,
-0.0561878085,
-0.5524414182,
0.6994023323,
-0.2407876551,
0.6025024056,
0.0392831527,
0.4665018022,
0.8346239924,
-0.3409586251,
0.9878803492,
-0.5075567365,
-0.4458645582,
0.0094044218,
0.181216538,
0.2518378794,
-0.2755992413,
-0.1637749821,
0.6363139749,
-0.0119648948,
-0.5045222044,
-0.5568956733,
0.6367101073,
-1.1056880951,
-0.4200030267,
-0.6098840833,
-0.5517279506,
-0.323186487,
-0.0695207119,
0.4447276592,
0.2676203847,
-0.2850328386,
-0.2544904053,
0.3775032759,
-0.4720156193,
0.1027764603,
0.4366325438,
-0.5398521423,
0.0326852277,
0.8432793617,
0.484467715,
0.5164493918,
-0.0600721166,
0.0655098483,
-0.2977332473,
0.013349398,
-0.7952159643,
0.2435963899,
-0.8663659096,
0.2453400493,
-0.5494027138,
0.0368086286,
-0.6517436504,
-0.1858665198,
-0.4461803734,
-0.4288509786,
0.0258756652,
-0.1557430029,
0.0778879598,
0.5649963021,
-0.1643828601,
0.377091229,
-0.9203817844,
0.2025927603,
0.409458369,
0.2201637626,
0.0267703403,
-0.7522934675,
-0.1713254154,
0.2883426547,
0.1790486276,
-1.0506321192,
0.4701962173,
-0.044502046,
0.566259861,
0.3769155741,
-0.0016615081,
0.6604570746,
-0.2339298129,
0.9061574936,
0.2732506096,
-1.1107633114,
0.206727013,
-0.2865689099,
0.3779383898,
0.7987652421,
0.6268804669,
-0.7862411141,
-0.335270822,
-0.281489253,
-0.6871045828,
0.9194363356,
-0.5527104735,
0.271789819,
0.0473639071,
0.148430869,
0.4043479264,
0.0665170178,
-0.9934511185,
-0.4105657339,
-0.4019726813,
0.0707246065,
-0.1793165058,
-0.235541448,
-0.0598405227,
-0.2163360268,
0.6915213466,
-0.1071902215,
-0.0256690346,
0.1436835974,
-0.6638869047,
-0.3963978291,
0.3435243666,
0.2855976224,
0.6574872732,
0.0387998931,
0.0259479806,
0.6167138815,
-0.5555273294,
0.3363351822,
0.0604888573,
-0.4349621832,
0.226864472,
0.4288623929,
0.957903266,
0.1081141382,
-0.3712726831,
0.5838802457,
-0.0620412864,
-0.1907905936,
-0.1116402298,
-0.3717989028,
-0.1813737005,
0.1341518164,
0.3123835027,
0.3216171563,
0.2162387669,
-0.9816741943,
-0.107495442,
0.6157277226,
-0.616186738,
-0.4083731174,
0.2487538159,
0.4591600299,
0.234727025,
0.6090050936,
0.1572107971,
-1.0500637293,
0.4790823162,
0.3519905806,
0.8689855933,
-0.3866376579,
0.4138837755,
0.3175373971,
0.6338815689,
0.0164536014,
0.3022748232,
0.1099783108,
-0.8744848371,
-0.6036391258,
-0.5815497041,
-0.4098237157,
-0.326844275,
-0.8799882531,
0.208094731,
-0.0058804583,
-0.2703298032,
-0.1718100458,
-0.2821262479,
-0.6770406961,
0.320846796,
0.507694602,
0.5641494989,
-1.758244276,
0.681165278,
1.0324953794,
-0.3309096396,
-0.48522982,
0.0054666568,
0.0434284881,
-0.7085969448,
1.1842913628,
0.0562422127,
-0.3466674984,
-0.6050129533,
-0.2611712813,
-0.7921130657,
0.3019214869,
0.4699047506,
-0.6678923965,
0.0694448799,
0.6784930825,
0.6324483156,
-0.3974775076,
0.4081225991,
0.7005158663,
0.6027215123,
-0.2494727373,
-1.1198542118,
0.003230443,
-0.1913713515,
-0.1796925962,
0.0066567888,
-0.7216844559,
0.9530807734,
-0.0821895674,
-0.0717610642,
-0.6025146246,
0.3349734247,
0.0294813197,
0.2747256458,
0.7602113485,
0.4064936042,
0.4688195586,
-0.0848713517,
1.1120679379,
-0.2081607729,
-0.0174289402,
0.9673979282,
-0.6282708049,
0.4772357345,
0.6250100732,
-0.2780368328,
0.8689842224,
0.3817048073,
0.2140128613,
0.3497290611,
0.0465865396,
0.0056166123,
-0.0699161217,
-0.2958531976,
-0.5291990042,
0.5657041073,
0.0696739629,
-0.4084142745,
-0.1073569879,
0.3376449347,
0.276119858,
-0.1702774763,
-0.3304289281,
0.5426576138,
0.2896066308,
-0.9575282931,
0.3117972314,
-0.3273044527,
1.0064021349,
-0.5625583529,
0.1836311817,
-0.7318735123,
0.0092706541,
-0.4814288914,
-0.6117044687,
0.5334206223,
0.0243206266,
-0.1430746317,
-0.3107717335,
0.7752981186,
-0.5546122193,
-0.5267346501,
0.7487869859,
0.9413562417,
0.1631445438,
0.1149213985,
-0.6537003517,
-0.0774621293,
0.21287781,
-0.2604110241,
0.7801257968,
0.2173012644,
-0.4874207973,
0.4771788418,
0.7774367929,
0.5030508637,
0.3542428613,
0.5997625589,
0.6859149933,
-0.5893817544,
-0.5629154444,
-0.8680225611,
0.1098477319,
0.0958034545,
-0.1609121412,
0.9621164203,
0.3370592296,
1.0660374165,
-0.0642706454,
1.0477735996,
0.1477290541,
0.3417319953,
-0.3158742487,
0.88036865,
-0.5720380545,
0.1348119527,
-0.7040600181,
-1.1247487068,
0.0184515193,
0.5192703009,
-0.6852741838,
0.2894619703,
0.7354657054,
0.531409204,
-0.0577592961,
0.2546077073,
0.0472423062,
0.0970132202,
-0.0039624334,
0.3114677668,
1.1010782719,
-0.3281904757,
0.6235817075,
-0.3973791599,
-0.0668876916,
-0.0376892202,
-0.7644821405,
-0.8663021922,
-0.1117088422,
-0.4171577692,
-0.3609149754,
0.2178910673,
0.8043482304,
0.6333326697,
-0.8478600383,
-0.4219729304,
0.4005711377,
0.180992946,
-0.0544166975,
-0.302996695,
0.0882660225,
-0.303045392,
-0.8947038054,
0.021567082,
-0.1690076143,
-0.0394320041,
-0.496483773,
0.0108472789,
-0.2913799882,
-0.0346968882,
0.8109050989,
0.2185531706,
-0.3237780333,
-0.422596544,
0.0213645846,
-0.1866710931,
-0.0438320599,
0.9109170437,
-0.671444118,
0.4742281735,
0.8084768653,
0.4739795327,
0.451925993,
0.0496261492,
0.8661680818,
-0.6403251886,
0.2115097046,
-0.1918418109,
0.5331916809,
0.5032939911,
-0.2633247375,
0.3244687617,
0.418997854,
-0.1839151382,
-0.8923565745,
-0.0225884058,
-0.618619442,
-0.4814522266,
1.3629994392,
-0.1106061563,
-0.1382882893,
-0.2701274157,
-0.1743202507,
0.325257957,
-0.375215292,
0.598703146,
0.9616351724,
-0.0002041614,
-0.1030730382,
-0.4815666974,
0.3065479696,
1.0078760386,
-0.7020067573,
-0.0229183566,
0.5478113294,
0.5302807093,
0.2598930597,
0.4967135787,
-0.3112203181,
0.3938449323,
-0.0654535964,
0.3170619011,
0.4009387493,
-0.2620923519,
-0.6584270597,
-0.0142652718,
-0.1362842917,
0.0218440723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12707v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12707v2 | Quantifying Association Capabilities of Large Language Models and Its Implications on Privacy Leakage | 2023-05-22T04:30:35 | 2024-02-09T05:31:11 | Hanyin Shao, Jie Huang, Shen Zheng, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) brings notable improvements
across various applications, while simultaneously raising concerns about
potential private data exposure. One notable capability of LLMs is their
ability to form associations between different pieces of information, but this
raises concerns when it comes to personally identifiable information (PII).
This paper delves into the association capabilities of language models, aiming
to uncover the factors that influence their proficiency in associating
information. Our study reveals that as models scale up, their capacity to
associate entities/information intensifies, particularly when target pairs
demonstrate shorter co-occurrence distances or higher co-occurrence
frequencies. However, there is a distinct performance gap when associating
commonsense knowledge versus PII, with the latter showing lower accuracy.
Despite the proportion of accurately predicted PII being relatively small, LLMs
still demonstrate the capability to predict specific instances of email
addresses and phone numbers when provided with appropriate prompts. These
findings underscore the potential risk to PII confidentiality posed by the
evolving capabilities of LLMs, especially as they continue to expand in scale
and power. | [
-0.2697891891,
-0.4476973414,
0.8046520948,
0.0944385603,
0.1535102725,
0.1210525185,
-0.0195066426,
-0.974347651,
-0.0427192003,
0.3214704394,
-0.0909450278,
-0.2809063494,
-0.9695765376,
-0.2003041506,
-0.5118427873,
0.7311769724,
0.4068074524,
-0.3109332919,
-0.3259869218,
-0.2534623444,
-0.4412421882,
-1.0036743879,
-0.3973146975,
-0.0305794384,
0.5452390313,
0.2439914048,
0.6263664365,
0.6274892092,
0.8026582003,
0.3072154522,
-0.1560409218,
-0.1419849396,
-0.5224076509,
0.1134041846,
-0.1654909849,
-0.6487424374,
-0.7415004969,
-0.0799438879,
0.7571161985,
0.9040775299,
-0.0426374376,
0.4289607108,
-0.0085169068,
0.6733725667,
-0.8553196192,
0.2988808155,
-0.7671455145,
-0.3465515375,
-0.4502127767,
0.0192994103,
-0.4632348716,
0.0053745508,
0.2840808928,
-0.3185440302,
-0.0115607409,
0.1159130633,
0.6590536237,
-0.0303839818,
-0.260314405,
-0.4559730291,
-0.846580863,
0.6688715816,
-0.7610843182,
0.3451756835,
0.5658527017,
0.1428921521,
-0.086679928,
-0.3330982029,
-0.2944000065,
-0.1930086762,
-0.4483859837,
-0.449162066,
-0.3754354417,
-0.0700976402,
0.3135521412,
0.5253365636,
-0.1937456876,
0.4636208117,
-0.4061782062,
-0.084227629,
0.9920981526,
0.1080266833,
0.4717661142,
0.257378757,
-0.1305627376,
0.1118787006,
-0.8088085055,
0.1264250278,
0.5689800978,
0.2489696443,
-0.3704232872,
0.6509303451,
0.003001241,
0.6183639765,
0.0095692547,
0.0331701301,
0.0828670561,
-0.3035439849,
-0.1118919328,
-0.01286403,
1.0755631924,
-0.1083547324,
0.5204136372,
-0.2091681063,
0.1067142785,
-0.3716816604,
-0.0933108106,
-0.5847681761,
-0.2533138096,
0.287048161,
-0.2664234638,
-0.1599351317,
0.5335114002,
-0.5646237731,
-0.5479387641,
-0.0170514435,
0.2362085134,
-0.1810079813,
-0.3669870496,
-0.0919827372,
0.0714885667,
0.0508925878,
0.0202870648,
-1.177400589,
0.4319863021,
1.0106916428,
0.8209546804,
-0.3434625268,
-0.2358057648,
-0.3810658157,
0.3878901005,
-0.2865246832,
0.3079541624,
-0.7557336092,
-0.4090574682,
0.0806884468,
-0.121033065,
-0.1749490649,
-0.5373030305,
-0.2260377258,
-0.6762187481,
0.0506562218,
-0.1245407537,
-0.5672117472,
0.0723838508,
-0.0849827304,
-0.7141319513,
0.6313987374,
-0.0866070464,
-0.7773857713,
0.0587211885,
-0.520637393,
-0.2455813885,
0.1502877772,
-0.2098687738,
-0.4815362096,
0.3280762136,
-0.1794463843,
0.896004796,
-0.0931782573,
0.3599244654,
-0.6842802763,
-0.2237094939,
0.9586786628,
-0.3166441917,
0.5906809568,
0.1255384237,
0.0284020472,
-0.1495541781,
-0.7562947273,
-0.266785562,
0.0073165558,
-0.1685547084,
-0.7151623964,
-0.2983457744,
-0.6666000485,
-0.0084318155,
0.6916169524,
-0.2425853759,
-0.0580386482,
-0.22441791,
0.135538891,
0.746172905,
0.284657985,
0.599006474,
-0.2910266519,
0.4030980468,
0.1967245787,
0.0231837053,
-0.3059323728,
-0.7085306644,
-0.3805922568,
-0.3720087111,
0.3415081501,
0.4310514927,
0.3062254786,
0.5466868877,
-0.6460623741,
-0.5435159802,
-0.2829227149,
0.3666370213,
0.5781819224,
-0.1499211937,
-0.1818268299,
-0.2944853902,
-0.1393336803,
-1.1030063629,
-0.3831042051,
-0.3692962229,
-0.2159172148,
0.8034358025,
0.2695307732,
0.051217474,
0.66005826,
-0.415035218,
-0.290993005,
-0.1673011631,
-0.043440327,
0.2457600832,
0.3563336432,
0.3307996094,
-0.7068794966,
-0.7218975425,
0.1376681775,
-0.6893291473,
-0.0129483389,
-0.133682549,
0.0068327747,
-0.1029075757,
0.2544488609,
-0.4682579637,
0.3498389125,
0.9588267803,
-0.4904121459,
0.1689429134,
-0.4705758095,
-0.2186363339,
-0.9733439088,
0.1428959966,
0.1987012029,
0.0452139415,
-1.011849165,
-0.0766487792,
0.0560752898,
-0.1201737523,
-0.4336547256,
0.6576230526,
-0.8655636311,
-0.4408603311,
-0.0224234276,
0.0556345657,
-0.2573938966,
0.157427296,
-0.1194776073,
1.0095003843,
0.6900544763,
-0.8296830654,
-0.0686486959,
0.2061472684,
-0.2717047036,
-0.0023531001,
-0.4777004421,
0.291039288,
0.2355110198,
-0.1859636456,
-0.7496517301,
-0.507281661,
-0.0423970409,
-0.493447125,
0.514097333,
0.2896173894,
-0.542729497,
0.0906559676,
-0.0844571888,
0.552157402,
0.2508526742,
-0.4221134782,
0.7401368022,
0.8100357056,
-0.2559335828,
-0.5374035835,
-0.6728349924,
0.1241010353,
-0.3802432418,
-0.638354063,
0.1580097675,
0.0287033804,
-0.6306052208,
-0.25029549,
0.1104873791,
-0.2949350774,
0.4467084408,
0.5845352411,
0.1859501302,
0.12395408,
0.3125958443,
-0.3230835199,
0.0748281926,
0.2329015434,
0.3279596865,
0.6486472487,
-0.2942691445,
-0.3193193376,
-0.6410899162,
0.402357161,
0.6686323881,
-0.3463075161,
1.313708663,
0.0637106523,
-0.3189105093,
0.1200651452,
-0.5229231715,
0.0396617018,
-0.4819737375,
0.3166723251,
-0.4476576149,
-0.700897336,
0.8985797167,
0.0007361757,
-0.113369517,
0.0597962216,
0.56017977,
0.1822531372,
0.7761338353,
1.0448372364,
-0.4353294671,
0.5282440186,
-0.1629322767,
0.4778121114,
-0.9847078919,
-0.3907269537,
-0.3722094297,
-0.1717116088,
-0.923666954,
-0.2716223001,
0.1229688227,
0.0584877096,
-0.1191827208,
0.1324706227,
-0.0438374355,
0.4428395629,
0.4914620519,
-0.033683978,
0.4706272185,
-0.2284926027,
0.5845299959,
0.2479857802,
-0.499494344,
-0.5931277871,
1.2956132889,
0.8172080517,
0.7575582266,
0.6434059739,
0.6915640831,
0.2941158712,
0.2675330043,
-0.4845621586,
0.6155033708,
-0.2459500432,
-0.6476467252,
-0.3796170056,
-0.2691365778,
-0.8953151107,
-0.1304936409,
-0.2324801683,
-1.2972919941,
0.6019053459,
0.1369841993,
-0.250328809,
0.1223255098,
-0.785345912,
0.4163271189,
-0.152110666,
-0.6400687695,
-0.0604114495,
-0.5751000643,
0.5690832734,
-0.5456483364,
0.2452295423,
-0.3520994484,
-0.3656366169,
0.7146221995,
-0.0054601957,
1.0131701231,
0.1994461566,
-0.2244546115,
-0.0482466705,
0.1243886575,
0.6049643159,
0.0086013572,
-0.1898599118,
0.5770282745,
-0.0749029517,
-0.3740089536,
-0.4159617722,
0.7813097239,
-0.8032690883,
-0.856695354,
-0.3253982663,
-0.6865323782,
-0.4851186872,
0.1103893444,
0.0405747518,
0.1161663681,
-0.0927742049,
0.3191134036,
0.8817086816,
-0.1656591892,
0.545789957,
0.5017394423,
-0.0499659441,
0.0796851143,
0.7939977646,
0.0916707665,
0.5713788271,
0.3346041143,
0.3076044023,
-0.2845710218,
-0.6075270176,
0.1095590368,
0.7377147079,
-0.5086176395,
-0.1416677535,
-0.5578403473,
-0.2599933147,
-0.3836200535,
0.1603011787,
-0.171256572,
-0.3258748353,
-0.4247315228,
-0.1024348959,
0.2236413658,
0.7936972976,
0.0918406546,
0.4418568909,
-0.7280435562,
-0.013658016,
0.1973036081,
0.4115458429,
0.0538568348,
-0.4650008678,
-0.2524124384,
-0.1710502952,
0.1686393023,
-1.1717165709,
0.3552083373,
0.2944996953,
0.5400980711,
0.6971926093,
-0.0557981841,
0.5926904678,
-0.1734914631,
0.7308294177,
0.1373161227,
-0.8155199289,
0.2144342959,
-0.451171428,
0.0058735157,
0.4117545784,
0.543076694,
-0.297013849,
-0.6831181645,
-0.9405676723,
-0.6006222963,
0.527946353,
-0.0466775782,
0.5177488327,
0.2710507214,
0.4231818616,
-0.0774784982,
0.3503975868,
-0.8837291598,
-0.2209682465,
0.5621631742,
-0.0939894095,
-0.0784146115,
-0.6038588881,
-0.1270308793,
0.0715828389,
0.4931969345,
0.1210968718,
0.1807078719,
-0.3316797316,
0.1126887575,
0.0266836304,
0.3865455091,
0.5160508752,
0.9225074649,
-0.1016106084,
0.1676672101,
0.1462349594,
-0.4897946417,
0.0176264904,
-0.1333332658,
0.1645730585,
-0.2954813838,
0.588891983,
0.6956908703,
-0.2116049975,
-0.6601293087,
0.649584353,
0.0881477743,
0.1293675601,
-0.5250377059,
0.3865877092,
0.155250147,
0.1377069205,
0.3559280634,
-0.29595384,
-0.0058410428,
-0.8201290369,
0.022142671,
0.6815903783,
-0.1706708074,
-0.4195572734,
0.3112199008,
0.0171271525,
-0.6031914353,
0.340118587,
0.1383022368,
-0.1471464932,
0.3314093351,
0.3006411493,
0.6728239655,
-0.5561440587,
-0.1909844726,
0.1564455926,
0.1501457691,
0.2328295708,
-0.2374141216,
0.0045389887,
-0.7999526858,
-0.1149905324,
-0.3481875956,
-0.2782513499,
0.3969308734,
-0.8245584369,
0.0855314136,
-0.5871595144,
-0.1295790523,
-0.0883903801,
0.0800352544,
-0.6536675096,
-0.0938962922,
0.2576940656,
0.6444172859,
-1.1404405832,
0.9293457866,
0.3209978044,
-0.1723958701,
-0.7759969831,
0.1691578776,
-0.0384114459,
-0.7710114717,
0.8287779689,
0.1530319154,
0.0996687785,
-0.1451786608,
-0.1271918863,
-0.995873332,
1.1854704618,
0.1652383655,
-0.9534808397,
-0.2782790065,
0.6240049005,
0.6157303452,
-0.8160389066,
0.0001195479,
0.7695529461,
0.325515449,
-0.182035625,
-0.9671766162,
0.1807220429,
-0.0311137587,
0.2144916952,
0.1454286277,
-0.617312789,
0.8352104425,
-0.3493063152,
-0.4117230475,
0.1116066203,
0.6574822664,
0.2077963948,
0.3677954078,
0.271345377,
0.3493805528,
0.959433198,
0.1782033294,
1.0884783268,
-0.5562949181,
0.0124701615,
1.2616688013,
-0.2341455072,
1.0885099173,
0.5103543997,
-0.0655430928,
0.3660778403,
0.3099010587,
-0.0771348774,
0.3131782711,
0.1065622717,
-0.5309365392,
-0.0546811037,
-0.0467077307,
-0.1897300929,
0.4217794836,
0.6488806605,
-0.8297550678,
0.2069560438,
-0.2021992207,
0.0713692531,
0.168120563,
-0.1943015307,
1.1795282364,
0.0282089487,
-0.4139667749,
0.0645348877,
-0.1739454567,
0.3984341025,
-0.4927852154,
0.1256394833,
-0.0594421141,
0.2205530703,
-0.1666948497,
-0.8650888205,
0.2734309137,
-0.0472085364,
-0.1181550398,
0.0221035052,
0.5246577859,
-0.2840583622,
-0.4055458307,
0.2751121819,
0.6710523367,
0.2362488508,
0.0186386313,
-0.5564050674,
0.2225167751,
-0.1673489064,
-0.1368681639,
0.7172574997,
0.4224381149,
0.0120352795,
0.8705922365,
0.5785246491,
0.4992807209,
0.2694682181,
-0.2851770222,
0.7313097715,
-0.3805611134,
-0.177637741,
-0.9659842849,
0.401003629,
-0.2259344608,
-0.0845988616,
0.9340156913,
0.5560206771,
0.5653938055,
0.1029304564,
0.702565968,
0.2362630516,
0.5002724528,
-0.3820383549,
0.6688426733,
-0.0500774868,
0.952655077,
0.1102567986,
-0.7844364047,
-0.2588667572,
0.1688171178,
-0.7567900419,
0.0400733575,
0.4047348797,
0.8379794359,
-0.073002778,
-0.4108438492,
0.5360100865,
0.2363187969,
0.4166190028,
0.4757364988,
0.5251484513,
-0.1974548846,
0.3024680614,
-0.3344232142,
-0.2599163651,
-0.1638254225,
-0.7851879001,
-1.0671685934,
-0.6207921505,
-0.3936779201,
-0.1176010817,
-0.0833077952,
0.2925594747,
0.7200547457,
-0.7786043882,
-0.3921481669,
-0.122060135,
-0.0381434336,
0.2253579497,
-0.2407243103,
0.3621563315,
-0.115993306,
-0.7685318589,
0.0940347537,
0.2436197996,
0.3767421842,
-0.6466415524,
0.0417213105,
-0.1580293477,
0.3091498613,
0.3012121618,
0.47494784,
-0.6421145201,
-0.1995988786,
-0.0545090102,
0.0170855429,
-0.0052166288,
0.717535913,
-0.3656609356,
0.3248063624,
0.3704608381,
0.5093099475,
0.1825327724,
0.3709704876,
0.7204060555,
-0.8135966063,
0.1322130263,
0.0477073044,
0.3459041417,
0.3451765478,
-0.7146221995,
0.2452040911,
-0.2819670141,
-0.5774355531,
-0.9479444623,
0.3298556507,
-0.7709867358,
-0.2626170814,
1.3002619743,
-0.4375571609,
-0.30819121,
-0.1321564615,
0.3358462155,
-0.1540423632,
-0.3984053731,
0.8210263848,
0.809999764,
-0.3065345585,
-0.3553800285,
-0.502602458,
0.5221948624,
-0.0520232953,
-0.7854766846,
0.5534085631,
0.3031469285,
0.2385313511,
0.6222839355,
0.5242062807,
-0.1491148472,
-0.0505556688,
-0.2515387237,
-0.4282513857,
-0.154438287,
-0.5175608993,
-0.4882797003,
0.1894152015,
0.3865913451,
-0.1821651012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12696v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12696v2 | Learning Interpretable Style Embeddings via Prompting LLMs | 2023-05-22T04:07:54 | 2023-10-09T19:20:32 | Ajay Patel, Delip Rao, Ansh Kothary, Kathleen McKeown, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Style representation learning builds content-independent representations of
author style in text. Stylometry, the analysis of style in text, is often
performed by expert forensic linguists and no large dataset of stylometric
annotations exists for training. Current style representation learning uses
neural methods to disentangle style from content to create style vectors,
however, these approaches result in uninterpretable representations,
complicating their usage in downstream applications like authorship attribution
where auditing and explainability is critical. In this work, we use prompting
to perform stylometry on a large number of texts to create a synthetic dataset
and train human-interpretable style representations we call LISA embeddings. We
release our synthetic stylometry dataset and our interpretable style models as
resources. | [
-0.0947962329,
-0.8031989336,
0.7714516521,
0.1489459425,
-0.3269692361,
0.2455873489,
-0.4220003784,
-0.1932135522,
0.7387209535,
0.4432362914,
-1.0495675802,
-0.4496281445,
-0.5030242205,
0.5480719805,
-0.2817272544,
0.85682863,
-0.2586599886,
0.3108797371,
-0.2914246619,
-0.0094142752,
-0.5274120569,
-0.2925119996,
-0.7191210985,
-0.0382382274,
0.608009994,
0.4820182025,
0.5087218285,
0.476447463,
0.075805746,
0.2561122775,
0.1270254105,
0.4874240458,
-0.4512110353,
0.5931537151,
0.0121623902,
-0.4837525189,
-0.0998832807,
0.1509158611,
0.5326884389,
0.7040861249,
-0.1303251088,
0.2344002575,
0.2841563225,
0.7517386675,
-0.4032671154,
0.1635468304,
-0.2940333784,
0.3499696851,
-0.2508128583,
-0.6432199478,
-0.7678152323,
-0.465239346,
0.1267410666,
-0.6273030043,
0.0662880242,
0.2386398762,
0.4691812694,
0.3096305728,
-0.2811347842,
-0.8217442632,
-0.5268256068,
0.7017009854,
-0.2862257957,
0.437150687,
0.3714041412,
0.2552884817,
-0.0793468878,
-0.7331957221,
-0.5038990378,
-0.1467764527,
-0.2427508682,
0.1647752076,
-0.0559902228,
-0.2952970862,
0.2237506062,
0.1249090955,
-0.2462121695,
-0.1288709491,
-0.2343164235,
-0.0725139752,
0.6397518516,
0.1806231588,
0.4238201976,
-0.2879356444,
-0.3986777067,
-0.2762518525,
-0.7515844703,
0.111642465,
0.5279287696,
0.4787352383,
-0.0395398587,
0.2942298353,
0.3385072351,
0.3869433105,
0.1128126755,
0.1452056319,
0.1623182148,
-0.1320068091,
-0.0033456113,
0.3510522842,
0.7307506204,
0.1689611077,
0.4080584943,
-0.0962554514,
-0.0805673525,
-0.4483596683,
0.5735826492,
-0.5680673122,
-0.4360450208,
0.1002768949,
-0.4442096353,
-0.4001288116,
0.2622686028,
-0.8371730447,
-0.6952064633,
-0.5217524767,
0.3908764422,
-0.5061668754,
-0.2055468708,
-0.0229718983,
-0.1444289535,
-0.0309120174,
0.4594753981,
-1.1700897217,
-0.0165016316,
0.2737409472,
0.8555471897,
0.0361119956,
-0.0819984823,
-0.3644578755,
0.0213613063,
-0.785651505,
0.4245097339,
-0.6575248837,
-0.4099653065,
0.0352541804,
0.2370112091,
0.0950077251,
-0.4245411754,
0.2408601344,
-0.5470427871,
-0.0951255187,
-0.5881080627,
-0.6243979335,
-0.3094534874,
-0.1034465805,
-0.8005154133,
1.0399435759,
0.0330618098,
-0.4956526756,
0.4300760925,
-0.6680375934,
-0.1685961038,
0.0716733113,
-0.1100595593,
-0.5859045982,
0.1169715002,
0.4771481752,
0.8685547113,
0.330222398,
0.1047682315,
-0.3519168794,
-0.4029256105,
0.4010511935,
-0.2655162811,
0.8247068524,
0.2183243632,
-0.1209996119,
0.2933102846,
-0.5390233397,
-0.221281141,
0.4802805483,
-0.3322627246,
-0.4379760623,
-0.1859558076,
0.0508438498,
-0.3636516035,
0.2430074066,
-0.4779975414,
0.3391283751,
-0.0858458281,
0.4707404971,
1.0987846851,
0.0707644373,
0.4086812735,
-0.4572716653,
0.5927754045,
-0.1202299297,
-0.3009495735,
-0.4529362917,
-0.4414858818,
-0.6531084776,
-0.3780177534,
0.0625267252,
0.4666416645,
-0.8774322271,
0.1413598508,
-0.1805182546,
-0.5223238468,
-0.5195416212,
0.4816091657,
0.2448047251,
0.2050854564,
0.384393096,
-0.2251482457,
-0.7597756386,
-0.6117531657,
-0.4020038247,
0.1947500259,
-0.1219923869,
0.0902422816,
0.4258187115,
-0.1775768399,
1.098810792,
-0.1964784414,
-0.0540086813,
-0.4446312785,
0.2516204715,
0.032028947,
0.4875112772,
0.4917955101,
-0.3921292126,
-0.3770113587,
-0.3873624206,
-0.8935949802,
-0.0822879001,
-0.4112040997,
-0.1646237969,
0.1704209447,
0.930085063,
0.015314945,
0.3610787392,
0.3462330401,
-0.3049856722,
0.6037220359,
-0.0852282047,
-0.0130526889,
-1.2739517689,
-0.0120896911,
0.1418225616,
-0.3552363515,
-0.5272536874,
-0.1236267313,
0.2333943844,
-0.2743532062,
-0.4547484815,
0.605979085,
-0.8116973042,
-0.1944434643,
0.2231514752,
-0.1808408052,
0.2950175405,
0.505097568,
0.1423195601,
0.7251540422,
0.4132197201,
-0.5449075699,
0.5439507365,
0.4850645661,
-0.6093841195,
0.4606202543,
-0.4404768944,
0.4829411507,
-0.2941785455,
0.3612496257,
-1.3033542633,
-0.3926698565,
0.4335561991,
-0.1428149492,
0.6007473469,
-0.3322319388,
-0.6099197268,
-0.0145675978,
-0.4880669415,
0.2882722318,
0.3809154928,
-1.002671957,
0.6030417681,
0.0158472955,
-0.2874937057,
-0.4461323321,
-0.5805419087,
-0.0339841582,
-0.3923544884,
-0.5669924617,
0.1783831269,
0.0063361856,
-0.2803781033,
-0.0502128601,
0.2168835551,
0.2544236481,
0.1797637939,
0.2951882482,
0.5286118984,
-0.0828010365,
0.2671170831,
0.1499683559,
0.0380538516,
0.2010579854,
-0.0460256562,
0.5082085729,
0.0254311375,
-0.5611679554,
-0.8309029341,
0.369140923,
0.1526450664,
0.024196256,
0.749968648,
0.7218955159,
-0.0518583655,
-0.5997180343,
-0.2100840658,
-0.5748028159,
-0.5322608948,
0.1127531081,
-0.3068852723,
-0.8869008422,
0.5836657286,
-0.0833317414,
0.0529283211,
0.1376976967,
0.4366774559,
-0.3114098012,
0.7674674392,
0.3353763521,
0.1711613536,
0.7559897304,
-0.1301917136,
0.005977822,
-0.7320626378,
-0.1607874483,
0.0748739094,
-0.6619976759,
-0.4800245464,
-0.3022691011,
0.4149645567,
0.0146979913,
-0.2194069326,
0.2304697633,
-0.6369737983,
0.6517845392,
0.7056282759,
0.5284861922,
0.1463863999,
0.3208293915,
-0.149364531,
-0.2343304157,
-0.2733295858,
-0.5770727992,
1.2954590321,
0.5394811034,
0.9249094725,
0.2595483661,
0.8258155584,
0.2590613961,
0.2199870199,
-1.2012760639,
0.3470565081,
-0.1019183248,
-0.3182987273,
-0.2990194857,
-0.3286145627,
-0.7815092206,
-0.241653949,
-0.3238898516,
-0.768909812,
0.3006694019,
0.1406106353,
-0.5350517035,
0.4369266629,
-0.4038186371,
0.4903015196,
0.0980443284,
-0.3441806734,
0.0806739703,
-0.3099820316,
0.1616440713,
-0.0002689222,
0.1411751211,
-0.0162546784,
0.0002382073,
1.1288944483,
-0.2761499584,
1.2881014347,
-0.0406692438,
-0.1778662503,
0.2376309037,
0.591734767,
0.5298122168,
0.0337894186,
-0.1393480599,
0.207979247,
0.075011,
-0.1251025796,
-0.6692811847,
0.2760085166,
-0.591098845,
-0.5586403608,
-0.3755012453,
-0.4432181418,
-0.2831573188,
-0.0574798584,
0.3037070334,
0.718149662,
-0.0893998146,
0.1470368952,
0.5138318539,
-0.1587750465,
0.408174634,
0.0308556948,
-0.1892391592,
-0.2150636911,
0.9087253213,
0.0698123649,
0.0560509674,
-0.0299570505,
0.2706230283,
-0.4151468873,
-0.3283017874,
-0.7515618205,
0.2972542048,
-0.997834444,
0.2659943998,
-0.2101535648,
0.0275668837,
-0.3024355173,
-0.5304893255,
-0.0719462782,
-0.2815576196,
-0.659457624,
-0.1962893754,
0.7929204106,
1.2920154333,
-0.0556029752,
0.2384766042,
-0.7704417109,
-0.3107968569,
0.4031331241,
0.0669565946,
0.105172582,
-0.6124108434,
-0.2323560119,
-0.2694713473,
-0.2879562974,
-1.1112021208,
0.710578084,
0.279635191,
0.3680593669,
0.709051609,
0.0180129819,
0.5859102607,
-0.5407705307,
0.6806648374,
0.0014068603,
-1.0535149574,
0.7435852885,
-0.4540673494,
-0.226360783,
0.5780505538,
0.7198462486,
-0.8214988708,
-0.078772001,
-0.4595943093,
-0.6820498705,
0.6941947341,
-0.2003368735,
0.492870152,
-0.015817849,
0.6362490058,
0.3065511882,
0.0726166964,
-0.4578441679,
-0.1202153489,
-0.2963253558,
-0.449195683,
-0.1078071073,
-0.4640770257,
-0.3867255449,
-0.1446141452,
0.6060122252,
-0.3366487324,
0.457711041,
0.1392864883,
-0.0864330232,
-0.0633856803,
0.1286091506,
0.4287187457,
0.7434359789,
-0.2116306722,
0.1575585902,
0.143484503,
-0.4208083749,
0.0553756617,
-0.2801933587,
0.0696922913,
0.1942570955,
0.6167263389,
0.7367387414,
0.2700063288,
-0.515222013,
0.4514516592,
-0.067837134,
-0.1236997098,
-0.7829201818,
0.1179322526,
0.1373500675,
0.0463375822,
0.3673014343,
-0.047035899,
-0.0239992328,
-0.7369613647,
0.2289950103,
0.3633570373,
-0.6784256697,
-0.3038794696,
0.5075113773,
0.0669884235,
-0.025371531,
0.550596118,
-0.2014724314,
-0.3855536878,
0.4041934907,
0.3301745951,
0.6526503563,
-0.2831534445,
0.2679003477,
0.5402818918,
-0.083336778,
-0.078575477,
0.2418358475,
-0.2245118916,
-0.9231789708,
-0.2525439262,
-0.7452974319,
-0.6740265489,
-0.1817300767,
-0.859367013,
0.3071252108,
-0.8847022057,
0.1599664092,
0.0193181839,
-0.3428324461,
-0.450279057,
-0.1224392578,
0.1589456052,
0.6806465387,
-1.0775843859,
0.4497852027,
0.7199342251,
-0.5426442027,
-0.9801286459,
-0.0354605988,
0.6843584776,
-1.2513905764,
0.9975645542,
0.344709307,
-0.0521915741,
0.1479244381,
-0.8738726974,
-0.6150630713,
1.1864717007,
0.4794860482,
-0.4651202857,
-0.0775871947,
-0.0526355542,
0.0898219198,
-0.4321324229,
0.284373045,
0.392360568,
0.3618258238,
0.2634682655,
-0.4835144579,
0.3352954388,
-0.3914085925,
-0.0625272468,
-0.0448731855,
-0.1322633326,
0.9095281959,
0.0029368082,
-0.5683997273,
0.119697921,
0.568980813,
0.3143678308,
0.2092108577,
0.551035881,
0.5015150905,
1.1316175461,
-0.2492052913,
1.0340656042,
-0.1372121274,
0.1829346269,
0.9803411961,
0.0896509886,
0.9359226823,
0.5273225307,
-0.1437523663,
0.9739457965,
1.0728268623,
-0.1095397323,
0.3378598988,
0.2476366311,
-0.4113403261,
-0.43711555,
-0.1592921317,
-0.1424200386,
0.5102986097,
0.4896246195,
-0.7875109911,
0.1062978432,
0.1101835892,
0.4424625933,
0.0418508686,
-0.2483733892,
0.8609357476,
0.2911025882,
-0.4062462151,
0.43652457,
-0.4032783508,
0.7370785475,
-0.6227930784,
-0.188651219,
0.0490895286,
-0.0298828594,
-0.3581246734,
-1.0046346188,
0.3321583867,
-0.3271869123,
-0.0183329247,
-0.6886027455,
0.4637663066,
-0.4912348986,
-0.6119621396,
0.174694404,
0.4134572446,
0.2166876048,
0.1012784541,
-0.3896821439,
-0.0688369945,
-0.0368789583,
-0.4634121656,
0.159670189,
0.479881376,
0.1206585541,
0.7430148721,
0.9283956885,
0.0750663206,
-0.2839633822,
0.1683717817,
0.7385787964,
-0.5904683471,
-0.6023641825,
-1.1261085272,
0.413688153,
0.1797176003,
-0.1553463042,
0.8975280523,
-0.0242135394,
0.6177240014,
-0.1452977657,
0.6057496071,
0.2746723294,
0.4930682778,
-0.9951925278,
0.9501420856,
-0.6915231347,
0.2092968822,
-0.3580693901,
-0.7577540278,
-0.2085907459,
0.7161678672,
-0.397174567,
0.1322838664,
0.5144245625,
0.9538459182,
-0.0357709639,
0.4554989636,
0.0855471641,
-0.0771361142,
0.0615662262,
0.2086568475,
0.9294688106,
0.1574399322,
0.2005700916,
-0.2698358297,
-0.1523289829,
-0.4710855186,
-0.9973823428,
-0.9351094365,
-0.924072206,
-0.1400656402,
-0.5892813802,
-0.0586453825,
1.2828388214,
0.6851900816,
-0.8462756872,
-0.0190803204,
0.0855312273,
-0.1519290507,
-0.1412694752,
-0.219636023,
0.5499910116,
-0.3535797894,
-0.8447153568,
0.686773181,
0.0349619798,
0.2326839417,
-0.5663797855,
-0.0582839102,
0.2486033738,
0.0038565537,
0.3774286807,
0.1177242473,
-0.6449109316,
-0.4209788144,
-0.15077959,
0.1335605234,
0.0809187442,
0.84414047,
-0.4493643939,
0.8181033731,
0.5278590918,
0.7310099006,
0.2600116432,
0.069888033,
0.5290126204,
-1.18358922,
-0.0985047892,
0.060491614,
0.7104414701,
0.5194271803,
-0.6356489062,
0.4338383675,
0.2561933398,
-0.3367160857,
-0.503667593,
0.2902213335,
-0.9688462019,
-0.2874196768,
1.0377304554,
-0.3107789755,
-0.4700311422,
-0.1182359904,
-0.2797697186,
0.2552315891,
-0.6031689644,
0.5051549077,
0.7399263978,
-0.2463780493,
-0.4598606825,
-0.4482277036,
0.8193635941,
0.4640429318,
-0.4405083954,
0.1446109414,
0.3159827888,
0.3900901377,
0.3536001444,
0.5023101568,
0.0780269578,
0.1446057707,
-0.0922795013,
0.0075551965,
-0.489931792,
-0.3203088939,
-0.3853336871,
-0.0540879145,
-0.1090539694,
-0.0179177094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12694v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12694v1 | Automatic Spell Checker and Correction for Under-represented Spoken Languages: Case Study on Wolof | 2023-05-22T04:03:20 | 2023-05-22T04:03:20 | Thierno Ibrahima Cissé, Fatiha Sadat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents a spell checker and correction tool specifically designed
for Wolof, an under-represented spoken language in Africa. The proposed spell
checker leverages a combination of a trie data structure, dynamic programming,
and the weighted Levenshtein distance to generate suggestions for misspelled
words. We created novel linguistic resources for Wolof, such as a lexicon and a
corpus of misspelled words, using a semi-automatic approach that combines
manual and automatic annotation methods. Despite the limited data available for
the Wolof language, the spell checker's performance showed a predictive
accuracy of 98.31% and a suggestion accuracy of 93.33%. Our primary focus
remains the revitalization and preservation of Wolof as an Indigenous and
spoken language in Africa, providing our efforts to develop novel linguistic
resources. This work represents a valuable contribution to the growth of
computational tools and resources for the Wolof language and provides a strong
foundation for future studies in the automatic spell checking and correction
field. | [
-0.4520091414,
-0.5935673118,
0.2175629735,
0.1126097813,
0.0754401907,
0.2636112571,
-0.1399594396,
-0.8072520494,
0.370932132,
0.5519102812,
-0.3616700768,
-0.5971957445,
-0.481261611,
0.5697677732,
-0.4452499747,
0.5571090579,
-0.3404369354,
-0.1815921366,
0.0060351351,
-0.4533584714,
-0.318338573,
-0.6075944304,
-0.4310973287,
-0.4486477375,
0.5192976594,
0.7330608964,
0.8239143491,
0.2077310383,
0.1333929747,
0.3015242517,
-0.2164932638,
0.5646696687,
-0.3230926991,
-0.1680313647,
-0.1164594293,
-0.3415808082,
-0.3885837793,
-0.2204808891,
0.3230502605,
0.8463060856,
-0.3940328658,
0.3446413875,
-0.3080663681,
0.8231649995,
-0.7852842212,
-0.0759557039,
-0.6699939966,
0.1316902041,
-0.5863267183,
0.0676260963,
-0.041818358,
-0.5290469527,
0.0482483692,
-0.4908288121,
0.3951141536,
0.3413367569,
0.5653970838,
0.2102052569,
-0.3163149953,
-0.4863759279,
-0.5722164512,
0.4294784367,
-0.7947137952,
0.2764110565,
0.7678176761,
0.1928931326,
-0.4653249085,
-0.6080107689,
-0.8623583317,
-0.0174350329,
-0.087365821,
-0.1518439353,
-0.0599940643,
0.3297990561,
0.4011001885,
0.6477491856,
-0.4466848671,
0.0755800307,
-0.1854459345,
-0.7811818719,
0.6602284908,
-0.3079520166,
0.4820093811,
-0.0163331404,
0.2769052684,
0.0956718922,
-0.7843886018,
-0.1758435369,
0.7466819882,
0.2843954265,
0.0936361477,
0.8100221753,
-0.4751344919,
0.8984258771,
-0.1732293814,
-0.2881759405,
0.291526109,
0.2235312611,
-0.0665985867,
0.3876722157,
0.6346440315,
0.3739158809,
0.4959147573,
-0.1166763976,
-0.4436593652,
-0.094982475,
-0.0238744188,
-0.3560103178,
-0.3680776358,
0.1553061306,
-0.288700074,
-0.2570896745,
-0.111737825,
-1.0349472761,
-0.5418080091,
0.3387232721,
0.6835705042,
-0.2545121312,
0.1173389032,
-0.1328373104,
-0.0726503506,
-0.5059708953,
-0.0211961027,
-0.9116558433,
0.0696500614,
0.0405833274,
0.5301237702,
0.0982901379,
-0.4235817492,
-0.2570356727,
0.2075806856,
-0.3239200711,
0.766674459,
-0.4659234285,
-0.6606667042,
0.6066696048,
0.0264691897,
0.1850605458,
-0.6885655522,
0.8327591419,
-0.4850096405,
0.2607734501,
-0.4873360991,
-0.5343532562,
-0.4073633552,
0.0058589834,
-0.9391792417,
1.5088551044,
0.3606871963,
-0.7394376397,
0.5027757287,
-0.8034670353,
-0.7978360653,
0.2581023276,
0.4027664363,
-0.4283260405,
-0.0213546436,
0.2809467614,
-0.0698125809,
0.0347486883,
-0.1169530749,
-0.155652687,
-0.3731183708,
0.0024102586,
-0.3061337173,
0.6797395349,
-0.1861885339,
-0.7742062211,
-0.1579482704,
-1.2113550901,
0.2226931453,
0.1298004389,
-0.382805407,
-0.3488054574,
0.0373764895,
0.1467248648,
0.0685582906,
0.5023688078,
-0.8920279145,
0.2612178624,
-0.4352746308,
0.2024135441,
0.1265591532,
-0.1135781705,
0.1881011575,
0.1108677909,
0.3467400372,
-0.3497005105,
0.1458882093,
0.2836490273,
-0.5651265979,
-0.9405462146,
0.1465062797,
0.7023249865,
0.8461571932,
-0.9162951708,
0.3148171008,
0.3024120927,
-0.4368711114,
-0.6616489887,
0.3979586959,
0.4065658748,
0.5757968426,
0.5301659703,
0.031041868,
-0.965293169,
-0.8937345147,
-0.2544416487,
-0.3964369297,
0.0993031636,
0.1355900317,
0.4697935879,
-0.720154345,
0.768509686,
-0.5571386218,
-0.5991593599,
-0.1193273216,
0.3492749333,
-0.0398015045,
0.1110537276,
0.5832314491,
-0.7298207879,
-0.4479978383,
-0.0413808525,
-0.2879148126,
-0.7338777781,
0.403945595,
-0.03992071,
0.5787414312,
0.3150597811,
-0.2164410055,
0.7869607806,
0.7141772509,
-0.3441827893,
0.6077103615,
-0.6308315396,
0.2698331475,
-0.6108554602,
0.0851684064,
-0.4688543677,
-0.2283864468,
-0.3745559752,
-0.2782007754,
0.1731933057,
0.1173649952,
-0.2555064559,
0.5736774206,
-0.6821151972,
0.0891921297,
-0.4858554602,
0.1974077821,
-0.3626668751,
0.3870282769,
-0.0830788091,
0.9290834665,
0.3717741668,
-0.5324960351,
0.5100982189,
0.4165574312,
-0.2122008651,
0.6325202584,
-0.4362613559,
0.0436584391,
0.3342762589,
-0.0158333797,
-0.7860159278,
-0.3231787086,
0.120228745,
-0.0735259578,
0.3200139105,
0.0912043601,
-0.6804211736,
-0.994577229,
0.1601319164,
0.3664180636,
0.2835934758,
-0.6448242068,
0.310680151,
0.8001142144,
0.0488781221,
-0.5892518163,
-0.5687829256,
0.2166548073,
0.1025448665,
-0.3313750625,
0.4168758094,
0.1073836312,
-0.1115658209,
-0.1349278688,
-0.0147025809,
-0.2467768788,
-0.1775729209,
0.4172740281,
0.1270467937,
0.081641227,
0.0440312512,
-0.0884845406,
0.1794227064,
-0.4525228441,
-0.5386529565,
0.2895914018,
-0.0660604462,
-0.4519242644,
0.0384113863,
0.3401239514,
0.5912081599,
-0.2116781324,
0.9995737672,
0.8354052901,
-0.8322220445,
-0.1261465847,
-0.9663177729,
0.2129170299,
-0.4274575412,
0.0785319656,
-0.1306082755,
-0.7791821957,
0.8440518975,
-0.0703449994,
-0.0817795619,
0.7249042392,
0.384175539,
-0.2790709436,
0.7968850136,
0.9183378816,
-0.1388135105,
0.2476781607,
-0.1576269567,
0.3100822568,
-0.6446142793,
-0.4096176326,
-0.481785208,
-0.5487416387,
-0.720539093,
-0.1197816283,
0.2564761639,
0.1505027711,
0.2859550714,
0.6056560874,
-0.1584816277,
0.3751635253,
0.5740916729,
-0.0562106036,
0.1321837008,
-0.1365425289,
-0.7771192789,
-0.0041989479,
-0.8122233152,
-0.6801274419,
0.8057223558,
-0.1480547041,
0.5402437449,
-0.0299216881,
0.6852265596,
0.6209281683,
0.2512015402,
-0.6731075644,
0.3972958922,
-0.1719073951,
-0.6430604458,
-0.7342097759,
-0.021451734,
-0.7409867644,
-0.1845591366,
-0.2502297461,
-0.8961567879,
0.5292893052,
0.6632114053,
-0.2321307808,
0.7624182701,
-0.6718184352,
0.9299764037,
-0.2095440179,
-0.1216941699,
-0.1184176505,
-0.5171474814,
0.0564143769,
-0.262155503,
0.2953911424,
0.0253231097,
0.1901674271,
0.740044117,
-0.8487849832,
0.8127650023,
-0.1970664412,
-0.5435294509,
0.6268036962,
0.0701108202,
0.4999819398,
-0.23408705,
-0.4180538952,
0.6275213957,
0.1588910073,
-0.3719030023,
-0.1943695694,
0.4232231677,
-0.3477165699,
-0.2505595386,
-0.4511314929,
-0.6372523904,
-0.371837914,
0.4135613143,
0.4194484353,
0.5138422251,
-0.4915204346,
-0.1272606105,
0.465195477,
-0.2942266166,
0.5348463058,
0.5798919201,
-0.1834454536,
-0.5156580806,
0.8030870557,
0.2881676853,
0.050100401,
0.5830396414,
0.0190209132,
-0.5594433546,
-0.4827378392,
-0.4826040268,
0.2150838077,
-0.654645741,
-0.187253952,
-0.3906322122,
0.0500916615,
-0.4109871387,
-0.0338225588,
-0.2845970094,
-0.4496341348,
-0.1227268577,
0.2804504633,
0.4372709394,
0.99974823,
-0.3985701799,
0.5216545463,
-0.6333584785,
0.5461919308,
0.2843439281,
0.5738042593,
-0.2346815616,
-0.346363008,
-0.3555293381,
0.3026860356,
-0.241262868,
-0.9927919507,
0.3092279732,
0.6548402309,
0.6690542102,
0.1606949568,
0.1364623308,
0.8743774295,
-0.7883728147,
0.6384316087,
0.0516387522,
-1.0018385649,
0.5405793786,
0.1074251309,
0.3734510243,
0.5554830432,
0.2650996149,
-1.0904796124,
-0.3294832706,
-0.6607250571,
-0.5774154663,
0.5134531856,
0.2362647951,
-0.4141471386,
-0.0316541418,
0.3097634614,
0.1680442989,
0.3269424438,
-0.2131038159,
-0.3770795763,
-0.0514093116,
-0.3547186553,
0.0328456834,
-0.7370000482,
0.0567186698,
-0.077271983,
1.0176366568,
-0.2006656677,
-0.0560683571,
0.3074797392,
-0.5663910508,
-0.427125603,
0.2845333219,
0.6248654127,
0.8103079796,
-0.0588458851,
0.1668060273,
0.6371250749,
-0.9522479773,
-0.0458527505,
0.1608967334,
-0.3970640004,
0.297314465,
0.3794530034,
0.6192771792,
0.3608742952,
-0.6418827772,
0.1594275385,
0.2601112425,
-0.1571939439,
-0.2304343134,
-0.0683789849,
0.0464910008,
0.0546062253,
0.5437947512,
0.160178408,
0.1516598016,
-0.5358913541,
0.0762734935,
0.4506740272,
-0.2581878006,
-0.0929033533,
0.5299770236,
0.3538803756,
-0.5927448869,
0.2558578551,
-0.4531317651,
-1.1085773706,
0.4235551357,
0.5246554017,
0.5502625704,
-0.3569969237,
0.4126754403,
0.2989307046,
0.4977553189,
-0.3330442905,
0.5678986311,
-0.0375098772,
-0.618952632,
0.0279711522,
-0.8489180207,
-0.4492073953,
0.0800597072,
-0.4857830107,
0.2975488901,
-0.038085036,
-0.3928361535,
-0.1960292906,
0.1373248994,
-0.5679351687,
0.4672849178,
0.2435957491,
0.7236767411,
-0.7021782994,
0.7398433685,
0.7249999046,
-0.2029883116,
-0.6183848381,
0.1370302439,
0.0706150532,
-0.902028203,
0.503025651,
-0.1873223484,
-0.3662275672,
0.048755303,
-0.1959329247,
-0.8548226357,
0.6469069123,
0.304961741,
-0.939109385,
0.2951945662,
0.2778482437,
0.7675398588,
0.0528203808,
0.164167434,
0.7121841311,
0.6266486049,
0.1084127277,
-1.3453805447,
-0.3410458267,
0.0240228046,
0.0658290908,
0.4519758523,
-0.4036388993,
0.1986315846,
-0.6396759152,
-0.1393755078,
0.2234826237,
0.8347789049,
-0.2396546453,
0.3031982481,
0.6322276592,
0.5447897315,
1.0520424843,
-0.1944212615,
0.5865868926,
-0.3246831,
0.2780586481,
0.987942934,
-0.4033887684,
0.7974970341,
0.4528189003,
-0.4288817644,
0.6094208956,
0.6160204411,
0.1446356326,
0.2940318584,
0.1816963255,
-0.2513907254,
-0.0121253524,
-0.243011862,
-0.1824158579,
0.4222590923,
0.2876286209,
0.0468285345,
-0.0849494264,
0.0496534966,
-0.2847083509,
0.2000390142,
-0.3527864814,
0.4691666663,
-0.0790421367,
-0.3793955147,
0.6070556641,
0.0351577289,
0.747154057,
-0.4053039551,
-0.1326243579,
-0.1089804396,
0.12887609,
-0.500944674,
-0.8292438388,
0.2763730884,
0.083797507,
-0.1846428961,
0.1497889608,
0.8176278472,
-1.0890305042,
-0.546328485,
0.3401300311,
0.2162132859,
0.147621721,
-0.0020420027,
-0.434662044,
-0.0296510421,
0.0741393641,
0.4173880816,
-0.4043616056,
0.5830751061,
-0.3249978721,
0.6216932535,
0.4074953794,
0.5741692781,
0.2510950863,
0.6433223486,
0.1089478359,
-0.3804405332,
-0.3715068996,
-0.6775218248,
0.1258517653,
-0.0587262809,
-0.2739652693,
0.7319226861,
0.489880532,
1.0607842207,
-0.2898356318,
0.6366502047,
-0.4083512127,
0.6145219207,
-0.2796605527,
0.8900630474,
-0.6064912677,
-0.2080208659,
-0.5982314944,
-1.020070672,
-0.2492857277,
0.4942629635,
-0.2657302916,
-0.1344231963,
0.8920197487,
0.8291431069,
0.2287656814,
0.0312055238,
0.4939594269,
0.2052163184,
-0.1883770525,
0.2366955727,
0.3960249722,
-0.6559334397,
0.6209195852,
-0.5776337385,
-0.0714686438,
-0.4552336633,
-0.9177777767,
-0.9929614663,
-0.7314142585,
-0.4810403585,
-0.2169908583,
0.0576818883,
0.878287077,
0.3705237806,
-1.5022170544,
-0.071688354,
0.1411142498,
0.2535595298,
-0.3352996111,
-0.0831540227,
0.290451318,
0.1504247934,
-0.7127094865,
0.2426514477,
0.3572002351,
0.2455032468,
-0.2828570008,
0.0189481899,
-0.4925667346,
-0.2311065346,
0.6600772738,
0.6954609156,
-0.7388516068,
-0.3802541196,
-0.1576677561,
-0.1688372493,
-0.1879479587,
0.7411987185,
-0.4668605626,
0.6098234057,
0.3817316592,
0.4757488966,
0.079509832,
-0.2431812733,
0.5932230353,
-0.8450853825,
0.3165618181,
-0.0147857293,
0.7591065764,
0.6159750819,
-0.5963016152,
0.4116917253,
0.5453858376,
-0.4046715796,
-0.6693178415,
-0.0859708637,
-0.4916344881,
0.2064431906,
0.988055408,
0.2183975726,
-0.3179349005,
-0.3360776305,
-0.7289981246,
0.6875972152,
-0.2582504153,
1.0538717508,
0.9833956361,
0.1135792732,
0.1615222096,
-0.3467056155,
0.6814675927,
0.2614575028,
-0.6219149828,
-0.1045793891,
0.5092012286,
0.2012622058,
0.3598992229,
0.2836889625,
-0.0409488045,
0.3234335184,
-0.0777393207,
0.5581880212,
0.0483214073,
-0.1570234001,
-0.0178758763,
0.020782372,
-0.1741091907,
-0.1817607284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12692v1 | MetaAdapt: Domain Adaptive Few-Shot Misinformation Detection via Meta Learning | 2023-05-22T04:00:38 | 2023-05-22T04:00:38 | Zhenrui Yue, Huimin Zeng, Yang Zhang, Lanyu Shang, Dong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With emerging topics (e.g., COVID-19) on social media as a source for the
spreading misinformation, overcoming the distributional shifts between the
original training domain (i.e., source domain) and such target domains remains
a non-trivial task for misinformation detection. This presents an elusive
challenge for early-stage misinformation detection, where a good amount of data
and annotations from the target domain is not available for training. To
address the data scarcity issue, we propose MetaAdapt, a meta learning based
approach for domain adaptive few-shot misinformation detection. MetaAdapt
leverages limited target examples to provide feedback and guide the knowledge
transfer from the source to the target domain (i.e., learn to adapt). In
particular, we train the initial model with multiple source tasks and compute
their similarity scores to the meta task. Based on the similarity scores, we
rescale the meta gradients to adaptively learn from the source tasks. As such,
MetaAdapt can learn how to adapt the misinformation detection model and exploit
the source data for improved performance in the target domain. To demonstrate
the efficiency and effectiveness of our method, we perform extensive
experiments to compare MetaAdapt with state-of-the-art baselines and large
language models (LLMs) such as LLaMA, where MetaAdapt achieves better
performance in domain adaptive few-shot misinformation detection with
substantially reduced parameters on real-world datasets. | [
-0.4247521758,
-0.6113040447,
0.2035073191,
-0.0769480392,
-0.5115566254,
-0.0437411852,
-0.0542362891,
-0.3822348118,
0.3342106044,
0.1745865792,
-0.8115885854,
-0.5369789004,
-0.6898813248,
0.0151281757,
-0.0591597818,
1.0304739475,
0.1764803827,
-0.211696744,
-0.2252064645,
-0.3515883088,
-0.5649752021,
0.0667887852,
-0.471260041,
-0.2227578908,
0.2578011453,
0.9693579674,
0.2723197043,
0.3135432601,
0.5401796103,
0.049282223,
0.4465841651,
0.4677946568,
-0.6138839722,
0.0565384477,
-0.3105223477,
-0.3544994593,
-0.3250758946,
0.0859403759,
0.3321013153,
0.2191782147,
-0.2881488502,
0.5905567408,
0.1120020971,
0.5697062612,
-0.9566107988,
-0.0991474763,
-0.8527866602,
-0.1318677664,
-0.400857836,
-0.5638308525,
-0.2847052813,
-0.0847647637,
0.0589560941,
-0.6939448714,
0.2814764977,
0.0381240435,
0.4918743372,
0.3966031373,
-0.3716642261,
-0.1744444072,
-0.6812485456,
0.6234321594,
-0.4560045004,
0.1071345583,
0.5401812196,
0.6692136526,
0.0003509278,
-0.6657789946,
-0.5032188296,
0.5297324657,
0.2563718855,
0.151094228,
-0.4331055284,
-0.5288693309,
0.0533273369,
-0.1399834156,
-0.773040235,
-0.0937256366,
-0.2135874927,
-0.4066660702,
0.3547096252,
-0.0083945701,
0.1137892455,
-0.4457486272,
-0.3542644382,
-0.0198489949,
-0.7080739141,
-0.3790588975,
0.144181788,
0.5099503398,
-0.0821545795,
0.168207109,
-0.2442159504,
0.7642046213,
0.3352521956,
-0.4927027225,
0.3423732817,
-0.0629019216,
-0.3199306428,
0.1364336014,
0.6634021401,
0.3974474072,
0.024699185,
0.3258422315,
0.16335769,
-0.328912586,
0.2263233066,
-0.805619359,
-0.1522721499,
0.0630422458,
-0.5977605581,
-0.2814638615,
-0.2634235322,
-0.8761107326,
-0.6280974746,
0.0548154339,
0.5887030363,
-0.4716793299,
-0.1692907959,
-0.1554845721,
-0.3017863929,
-0.0317306146,
0.4954900742,
-0.866155386,
0.0653719306,
0.5779384375,
0.9099075198,
-0.1971536577,
-0.3772886693,
-0.7436099052,
0.2463627011,
-0.037299566,
1.2425396442,
-0.6899666786,
0.0397880636,
-0.0342686176,
-0.0400314257,
-0.1732971817,
-0.5694291592,
0.5646723509,
-0.5323568583,
0.1474184692,
-0.3985934258,
-0.3800223768,
-0.4209891558,
0.6689536572,
-0.6344283819,
0.8169596195,
0.2032040954,
-1.0360846519,
0.7260148525,
-0.687192142,
-0.3948090374,
0.3113193214,
0.0691035017,
-0.4741495848,
-0.019823553,
0.3492378592,
0.4918698668,
-0.1384722441,
-0.1826578081,
-0.3410024941,
-0.2512048483,
-0.0705500916,
-0.5702698827,
0.3192026019,
0.1332623065,
-0.2197887897,
-0.1833609343,
-0.8065812588,
-0.1416109949,
0.1040901691,
-0.456248343,
-0.7008114457,
0.0948668793,
-0.0774404258,
0.2577466071,
-0.2404130846,
-0.3253929913,
0.3732419014,
-0.0173873361,
-0.030729631,
0.4601990283,
0.4295948446,
0.4973458052,
-0.4005810022,
0.5046349764,
0.1939156502,
0.098756738,
-0.2291346639,
-0.4223047197,
-0.2796931565,
-0.3102174103,
0.3585214615,
0.5526793003,
-1.0958875418,
-0.0632674322,
-0.5223219395,
-0.273855865,
-0.5891453028,
0.3503454924,
-0.1747364104,
0.6186421514,
0.679271102,
-0.0714100823,
-0.7366336584,
-0.5479517579,
-0.9010118842,
0.2498778403,
-0.0202146545,
0.332704097,
0.5428358912,
-0.409394592,
0.9719201326,
-0.4640421867,
-0.6402746439,
-0.3931589127,
0.4392085671,
0.2493799627,
0.0454712473,
0.7270494699,
-0.694737792,
-0.8513763547,
-0.1712343842,
-0.5916751027,
-0.1563420147,
-0.0848683044,
0.1327837706,
0.0074938196,
0.2689147592,
-0.3404214978,
0.2042128593,
0.5745484233,
-0.1108071059,
0.2646377683,
0.2646720409,
0.3739676178,
-1.205036521,
-0.0288082045,
-0.0580075197,
-0.7585250735,
-0.7334074378,
-0.2927542627,
0.0453779101,
-0.0050529209,
-0.7551723719,
0.3628325164,
-0.1010480523,
-0.04821321,
-0.9119063616,
0.216333285,
-0.1987961829,
0.1819999814,
0.0089190518,
0.7392967939,
0.311609596,
-0.7975426912,
0.4208540022,
0.2345488071,
-0.1912063211,
1.0026059151,
-0.1120811701,
0.0290090479,
-0.2090575695,
0.5224134922,
-0.7183743715,
-0.4720164835,
0.7233325243,
-0.5446645617,
0.0497211777,
-0.5590885878,
-0.2372005135,
-0.2682971656,
-0.4407571852,
0.3526110351,
0.1532299221,
-0.6220135689,
0.447124958,
0.1863719225,
0.0318359621,
-0.7509431243,
-0.6828335524,
0.0608521774,
-0.1175888106,
-0.3720792532,
0.2343452573,
0.0854167566,
0.1488827318,
0.0850486159,
-0.3828238845,
-0.1748969108,
0.0185253061,
0.1510679126,
-0.2621017098,
-0.1771327555,
0.4758864939,
0.0811773315,
-0.229652673,
-0.32903108,
-0.6920403242,
0.512671411,
0.1907643676,
-0.362567395,
-0.5451152325,
0.030072771,
0.5494276881,
0.1672006249,
0.7910662293,
0.7506546378,
-0.6357097626,
-0.58604002,
-0.2967216969,
-0.0711004809,
-0.3923316002,
0.1833033562,
-0.1679119021,
-0.405625999,
0.0854565799,
-0.5257770419,
-0.047319673,
0.8278158903,
0.3440930247,
-0.1706243306,
0.2913134098,
0.6297784448,
-0.2655776739,
0.6226364374,
-0.3008250296,
-0.1747135669,
-0.6411023736,
0.0062411395,
-0.0926955119,
-0.650765121,
-0.1952226162,
-0.6205635071,
0.338922739,
-0.3294700682,
0.0096803345,
0.3468429148,
-0.2524841428,
0.7339963317,
0.5682526231,
0.3357300162,
0.3959665895,
0.134003818,
0.1705708504,
-0.111135073,
-0.8982868195,
-0.2076000869,
1.4351081848,
0.1824104786,
0.8773424029,
-0.0225647949,
0.5691862106,
0.8948580623,
0.2962810993,
-0.7069950104,
0.0890648142,
-0.1394996196,
-0.6379896998,
-0.1812357903,
-0.3356179893,
-0.6159304976,
0.2912076414,
-0.4121243656,
-0.1734854877,
0.3756793737,
0.2345055044,
-0.4196029603,
0.3755821884,
-0.2766247392,
0.6813448668,
-0.0254327413,
-0.2999054492,
-0.4208147228,
-0.5699222088,
0.3939037025,
-0.2659374475,
0.4017245471,
-0.1357087195,
0.0272920858,
0.8263628483,
-0.1466493756,
1.038030386,
-0.4281121194,
0.2360079139,
0.454885453,
0.1384053975,
0.5411012173,
0.0605491102,
0.0209447108,
0.0591161475,
-0.153226465,
-0.3755015731,
-0.315435797,
0.3871159256,
-0.5439287424,
-0.1360364556,
-0.5840178132,
-0.4309897721,
-0.0308690779,
0.3292252421,
0.5665269494,
0.0155212171,
-0.4323413968,
0.1273081601,
0.5290349722,
-0.135299474,
0.5167884827,
0.7504585981,
0.0767498463,
-0.4820246994,
0.8668118715,
0.0184758827,
0.1062947661,
0.3431052864,
0.2154694498,
0.1466907114,
-0.3533006012,
-0.4185173213,
0.1524776518,
-0.9215047359,
-0.8451015949,
-0.443187356,
-0.0139400726,
-0.1608272344,
0.0776898637,
-0.3784663975,
-0.3861621022,
-0.380926609,
0.0687124431,
0.3800935447,
0.4555816054,
-0.332899183,
0.7309028506,
-0.8191316724,
0.6657906175,
0.5151316524,
0.2302243114,
-0.2974152863,
-0.8089925647,
-0.3995140493,
0.3866440654,
-0.5963965058,
-0.8082271814,
0.3958568871,
0.6745595336,
0.3860234916,
0.7400809526,
-0.0379907489,
0.5985617042,
-0.4840841293,
0.5753858685,
0.0167021677,
-0.9350638986,
0.765150547,
-0.1787367314,
0.2808924019,
0.8748978972,
0.7487708926,
-0.747677505,
0.1928173155,
-0.3861056566,
-0.0921572372,
0.8334152699,
-0.2530019581,
0.0288590584,
0.1246243492,
0.4597921371,
0.3892734647,
0.1690862328,
-0.852904737,
-0.1140687168,
-0.2829449177,
-0.2673758566,
0.1185580269,
-0.1730698645,
-0.2655317187,
-0.0932923257,
0.6108846068,
-0.5085428953,
0.3268930614,
0.0452146232,
-0.7529517412,
-0.4934508502,
0.0812737495,
0.7935990095,
0.6026184559,
-0.1775939018,
0.2121060044,
0.3619247079,
-0.8803347945,
0.1192508489,
-0.1063598916,
-0.1014099941,
0.197381556,
0.5960700512,
0.5798709393,
0.0604555905,
-0.2377341837,
0.9643611312,
0.0632740632,
-0.3633482754,
0.1369362921,
-0.0421337225,
-0.1556514949,
0.4392257035,
0.7431237102,
0.5533846617,
0.1362351626,
-0.6384056807,
0.4799691439,
0.3371485472,
-0.2210376263,
-0.3961803913,
0.5259665847,
0.3515821993,
-0.0464175083,
0.3165945113,
-0.0697981417,
-0.5824286342,
0.273568809,
0.4850886464,
0.8914664984,
-0.5191583633,
0.4973990321,
0.2309762239,
0.6021963358,
-0.2270072103,
0.1333176047,
-0.1145620346,
-0.73406142,
-0.3634710312,
-0.3194140494,
-0.3330108821,
0.175030753,
-0.2335481644,
0.497372508,
-0.4373428226,
-0.142618224,
-0.1717265993,
-0.1137838513,
-0.7164371014,
0.1460538805,
0.2073999792,
1.0545469522,
-1.2415078878,
0.6380061507,
0.3753247559,
-0.2866557837,
0.0594063364,
0.5456554294,
0.2818007171,
-0.8451536894,
0.525404036,
0.1165653393,
0.123211652,
-0.0981979147,
-0.7220101357,
-0.8101462126,
1.3286960125,
0.3496115804,
-0.5495114923,
0.290089339,
0.2123567462,
0.3255789578,
-0.4738211334,
0.0352463461,
0.4425291717,
0.4898068607,
0.2572554052,
-0.5572952628,
0.0034288845,
0.20019871,
-0.6228564382,
0.0567393191,
-0.5336548686,
0.5847188234,
-0.1145626307,
-0.1539715379,
-0.6060806513,
0.4323048592,
-0.0049984828,
0.8481737375,
0.4103296995,
0.5284447074,
0.8164688349,
0.0936538279,
0.8408881426,
-0.0463052467,
0.4869694412,
1.1647908688,
-0.1977413297,
0.8775808811,
0.3207642436,
0.0594697148,
0.7379662395,
0.8076671958,
-0.0884731859,
0.9725801945,
-0.2384956032,
-0.1980092078,
-0.2930370271,
0.167509228,
-0.3109053075,
0.4713228345,
0.4551307261,
-0.2803359628,
-0.4356682599,
0.5246055126,
-0.1999223083,
-0.3939876258,
-0.456725806,
0.8740726709,
-0.0153073864,
-0.2691567838,
0.679225862,
0.0613592342,
0.6035773754,
-0.5939390659,
0.0029998026,
-0.1961119324,
0.0725436956,
-0.5442857742,
-0.3402057588,
0.5033473969,
0.0385848992,
-0.2752838731,
0.0446761325,
1.200823307,
-0.3858605325,
-0.2014232129,
0.0168689657,
0.5959142447,
-0.006705909,
-0.3817069829,
-0.5498594642,
-0.0354367644,
-0.2454733849,
-0.0259664692,
0.113173686,
0.4081053734,
0.0826257765,
0.6534929872,
0.4855308235,
-0.0411393456,
0.0051502306,
-0.1160372496,
0.8204278946,
-0.375587225,
-0.3575843275,
-0.7981824875,
0.2864150405,
-0.0988623127,
-0.0894310325,
0.6577446461,
0.4905253351,
0.5585502386,
-0.2732926011,
1.1690782309,
-0.0085631078,
0.6900314689,
-0.323287487,
0.5748797059,
-0.6098746657,
0.2897720933,
-0.3610097468,
-1.0532182455,
-0.5959946513,
0.3406480253,
-0.3147648573,
-0.1081430018,
0.7563968897,
0.3010468781,
-0.6048312783,
-0.3401562572,
0.2565266788,
0.1192081645,
0.1428857595,
0.5576146841,
0.5955548286,
-0.7029294968,
0.7165349722,
0.1804419011,
-0.2592439353,
-0.821713388,
-0.9265127778,
-0.8666471839,
-0.2650049925,
-0.3056876063,
-0.1660512686,
0.1445778906,
0.9883397222,
0.7740218043,
-0.7714518309,
0.2601576746,
0.0555865429,
0.3836103082,
-0.3893330395,
-0.2144584805,
0.2929831743,
-0.1880245656,
-0.4556726217,
0.5646531582,
0.3114418983,
-0.0292509552,
0.2074708492,
0.0879427418,
-0.493647933,
0.3029127717,
0.5762619376,
0.4772595465,
-0.1901664287,
-0.2846535444,
-0.1797610372,
0.0096540339,
0.1064099595,
0.7170975208,
-0.9245233536,
0.3449972868,
0.5003388524,
0.7972565293,
0.6002442837,
0.3332502246,
0.2102347761,
-1.1025198698,
0.045462925,
-0.0105842901,
-0.0229172744,
0.3731102943,
-0.3345088065,
0.4191672802,
0.6900734901,
-0.3302599192,
-0.5759595633,
0.1090153679,
-0.7043745518,
-0.4697591066,
1.0991960764,
0.275421083,
-0.142422393,
-0.1126667708,
-0.1163227782,
0.0913010016,
-0.3731506467,
0.7913405895,
0.4363014698,
0.0233125221,
-0.2299709767,
-0.5533660054,
0.7334834933,
-0.0820199922,
-0.9638716578,
-0.013379409,
0.2301267833,
0.8050849438,
0.0431576706,
0.5751118064,
0.3661039472,
0.7856786251,
-0.0035321824,
0.0313119739,
-0.0925046727,
-0.5379552841,
-0.4679884315,
0.1280459911,
-0.2843074203,
-0.6217083931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12689v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12689v2 | FIT: Far-reaching Interleaved Transformers | 2023-05-22T03:56:44 | 2023-05-25T16:27:30 | Ting Chen, Lala Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | We present FIT: a transformer-based architecture with efficient
self-attention and adaptive computation. Unlike original transformers, which
operate on a single sequence of data tokens, we divide the data tokens into
groups, with each group being a shorter sequence of tokens. We employ two types
of transformer layers: local layers operate on data tokens within each group,
while global layers operate on a smaller set of introduced latent tokens. These
layers, comprising the same set of self-attention and feed-forward layers as
standard transformers, are interleaved, and cross-attention is used to
facilitate information exchange between data and latent tokens within the same
group. The attention complexity is $O(n^2)$ locally within each group of size
$n$, but can reach $O(L^{{4}/{3}})$ globally for sequence length of $L$. The
efficiency can be further enhanced by relying more on global layers that
perform adaptive computation using a smaller set of latent tokens. FIT is a
versatile architecture and can function as an encoder, diffusion decoder, or
autoregressive decoder. We provide initial evidence demonstrating its
effectiveness in high-resolution image understanding and generation tasks.
Notably, FIT exhibits potential in performing end-to-end training on
gigabit-scale data, such as 6400$\times$6400 images, or 160K tokens (after
patch tokenization), within a memory capacity of 16GB, without requiring
specific optimizations or model parallelism. | [
-0.5746824145,
-0.4306999743,
0.4083119333,
0.5447733402,
-0.158271879,
0.2151040435,
0.1139714569,
-0.3379596472,
0.3389639854,
0.2632035911,
-0.8035499454,
0.1158590317,
-0.5709709525,
-0.0470219515,
-0.6850531101,
0.7499770522,
-0.0548439659,
-0.2100798339,
-0.204433158,
-0.2638994455,
-0.4082388878,
-0.2324861884,
-0.3856073618,
-0.180959031,
0.4745593965,
0.3164492548,
0.8308396935,
0.6946827173,
0.7177324891,
0.2372189462,
0.0988100618,
-0.0873555169,
-0.6100082397,
0.1530195624,
-0.2096859515,
-0.3616595864,
-0.3765466213,
-0.0942921937,
0.6278542876,
0.2821688354,
-0.0060242596,
0.6227889061,
0.0744387656,
0.9938150048,
-0.6082257628,
-0.0747199357,
-0.4037563205,
0.3195365667,
-0.0456244498,
-0.1120234504,
-0.4351469576,
0.2679790854,
-0.0456972457,
-0.5146096945,
0.4873453081,
0.1148376241,
0.4922750294,
1.1091760397,
0.0504767559,
-0.0777476877,
-0.8445230126,
0.3897587061,
-0.3884782493,
0.9005380273,
0.1445340812,
0.74632442,
0.0193266962,
-1.1175966263,
-0.4064771831,
0.4701327085,
-0.1590788215,
0.6271932125,
-0.5040935278,
-0.2231547683,
0.3641685247,
0.617474854,
-0.5603252053,
0.1283242702,
-0.4343967438,
-0.0569246486,
0.5008789301,
0.2783503532,
0.0901046693,
0.1661422402,
-0.4584902823,
-0.135875836,
-0.4054001272,
-0.0168905072,
0.2637955546,
-0.0384984538,
-0.2779338062,
0.2489001155,
-0.2134659886,
0.5461669564,
0.4231109619,
0.2240178287,
-0.0621422268,
-0.1367819458,
-0.3938806653,
0.099230051,
0.5967764258,
0.0380985588,
-0.2030511945,
-0.467184931,
-0.1701029241,
-0.0619518459,
0.5562250614,
-0.9559184313,
-0.3458536267,
0.1991381198,
-0.7246858478,
0.0002632546,
-0.0243170466,
-1.0246421099,
0.2489615679,
-0.2640866339,
0.7070414424,
-0.1383420378,
0.017562082,
0.1562908888,
-0.0029999944,
0.8847023845,
0.3370490372,
-0.8308120966,
0.328565836,
0.3545518219,
1.153821826,
-0.2008846253,
-0.1885426939,
-0.5040476918,
0.1898271739,
-0.1783422083,
0.8820026517,
-0.3772536814,
-0.1235861182,
-0.2149478644,
0.0785230994,
-0.0198355522,
-0.405590564,
0.5920827985,
-0.658595264,
0.5092491508,
0.0889381915,
-0.5620753169,
-0.1222047135,
0.0590436012,
-0.7768129706,
1.2430177927,
0.4837748706,
-0.7932789326,
0.1833462566,
-1.0148602724,
-0.4415616095,
0.2094864845,
-0.0113866189,
-0.9138080478,
0.3043817878,
0.4603883624,
0.6594205499,
-0.4805225134,
-0.0670543537,
-0.2125142217,
-0.6595118642,
-0.2289506644,
-0.5673386455,
0.4344628155,
0.1786635518,
-0.702644825,
0.1651125401,
-0.5770545602,
-0.0528580062,
0.5340515375,
-0.1189661622,
0.2895092964,
0.0390422642,
0.1563539952,
0.2386936098,
0.0574127324,
-0.4426817298,
0.1796787679,
-0.1115486622,
0.7366238236,
0.8385724425,
-0.4004939795,
0.4817150235,
-0.2971997559,
0.7234317064,
-0.0962252095,
0.430054456,
-0.6318307519,
-0.3254545927,
-0.7784548998,
-0.4789052904,
0.2020941973,
0.3128162026,
-0.3828659356,
0.6101498008,
-0.4089477956,
-0.7359273434,
-0.5558909774,
-0.2495206594,
-0.113900058,
0.4966464639,
0.7426127195,
-0.0506376699,
-0.2392749786,
-0.9333949685,
-0.2299356312,
0.3368833959,
-0.2208464891,
0.3062949181,
0.3376746178,
-0.5587185621,
0.9467528462,
-0.6021462083,
-0.4904629886,
0.1635308564,
-0.5055262446,
0.3746480644,
0.4122059941,
0.6659433246,
-0.9340228438,
-0.735319674,
0.0279317461,
-0.4913298786,
0.2541483045,
-0.2364308983,
-0.1326005161,
-0.2798544765,
0.7473175526,
-0.3815277517,
0.8151923418,
0.7219724655,
-0.3678736985,
0.1004428715,
-0.2469511628,
-0.0492676347,
-1.2339885235,
0.123261787,
-0.2059762329,
-0.5305424929,
-0.5584006906,
-0.141310066,
0.36854285,
-0.2340344638,
-0.3454062641,
0.4750181437,
-0.5262049437,
-0.4108095169,
-0.1406895816,
-0.2801807225,
-0.0585884824,
0.581156671,
-0.292255193,
1.0183649063,
0.6826687455,
-0.5914409161,
0.3150102198,
0.515407145,
-0.1581493914,
0.6354289651,
-0.7976673245,
0.5571549535,
-0.4892840385,
0.340000093,
-1.1622591019,
-0.6007565856,
0.0264967717,
-0.4030300677,
0.346090436,
0.0592062585,
-0.3663848639,
-0.6539857984,
-0.1368164271,
0.8257995844,
0.7398329377,
-1.1021155119,
1.1476130486,
0.165742144,
0.3605459034,
-0.4333547652,
-0.8180078864,
0.0210157987,
-0.3286136091,
-0.6453658938,
0.4138429761,
-0.3776096702,
0.3250654042,
0.0866315886,
-0.1133286059,
-0.0665107071,
-0.0297187138,
0.3195595741,
0.1130433306,
-0.3838494122,
-0.0011433777,
0.0112655247,
-0.0809164867,
-0.0480604693,
-0.5281940103,
0.6473084688,
-0.0790428221,
-0.4445383251,
-0.4467779398,
0.4195889533,
0.9720280766,
-0.3021114469,
0.3444287181,
0.8654561043,
-0.3937024772,
-0.2508110106,
-0.6219302416,
-0.0290084388,
-0.5558869839,
0.4486244917,
-0.4253377914,
-0.928362608,
0.8880390525,
-0.0473864339,
0.1588736176,
0.6838593483,
0.7048509121,
-0.2776428759,
0.9335864782,
0.632596314,
-0.0978995115,
0.7219616175,
-0.1977926344,
0.2603029609,
-1.0862389803,
-0.1349763125,
-0.1478421092,
-0.8438253999,
-0.3408453763,
-0.7213005424,
0.4019965231,
-0.1515065432,
-0.277397573,
0.4667172134,
-1.0408645868,
0.6031714082,
0.4124059677,
0.3130938709,
-0.293987602,
-0.1298028678,
0.4865932763,
0.0252355989,
-0.929633081,
0.0468472615,
0.9912292957,
0.573523581,
1.0573073626,
-0.0184767283,
0.4887266457,
0.4097575843,
0.2359695733,
-0.9470869303,
0.1160556525,
-0.2821244299,
-0.3011217117,
-0.231232062,
-0.1637499481,
-1.1038197279,
-0.0305913314,
0.0852669924,
-0.4133088589,
0.1642990857,
0.3226852417,
-0.2738822997,
0.5497780442,
-0.6454994082,
0.6947188377,
-0.2782065272,
-0.2663243711,
-0.143769756,
-0.8043976426,
0.1491662562,
-0.3526989222,
-0.1071635038,
0.0656391531,
0.1455416977,
0.713616848,
-0.0343757533,
0.5794758201,
-0.125340268,
0.1459846646,
0.2687160373,
-0.0934241414,
0.5065394044,
-0.0676914155,
0.1234110147,
0.2459524274,
-0.1859199554,
-0.7303221822,
-0.6959142089,
0.313293159,
-0.6794111133,
-0.4131062627,
0.0221670698,
-0.7844191194,
-0.1106733307,
0.4631699324,
0.4571231604,
0.484174341,
-0.1081523746,
0.4682125747,
0.6917052269,
-0.0069640251,
0.663469553,
-0.0119536985,
0.0360317305,
-0.5720147491,
0.7209959626,
-0.1207516119,
0.3677880764,
0.4794903994,
0.2678460479,
-0.4056832194,
-0.3005013466,
-0.4784285426,
0.134994939,
-0.6400867701,
-0.7833646536,
-0.6805052757,
-0.4220633209,
-0.3715407848,
-0.3884460032,
-0.7173716426,
0.0146567523,
-0.4049572945,
0.3057423532,
0.1673425883,
0.9942043424,
0.0102690151,
0.5649363399,
-0.7781353593,
0.4388273656,
0.3929643333,
0.6991046071,
-0.0538928807,
-0.7855224609,
-0.5263955593,
-0.2463500202,
-0.1556506306,
-0.5578103662,
0.2374683321,
0.3223380148,
0.6035679579,
0.1672826409,
-0.0328109823,
0.8833552599,
-0.6705211401,
0.4263290465,
0.3520118594,
-0.9612079263,
0.4251664877,
-0.1145842969,
0.6220573783,
0.2807104886,
0.2465652078,
-0.3755503893,
-0.0340736583,
-0.7412694097,
-0.5621128678,
0.8030925393,
0.206563279,
0.1634991914,
0.3573761582,
0.8331543803,
-0.0091829849,
-0.2295131683,
-0.4554007351,
-0.2590487003,
-0.4763324559,
-0.5370935798,
0.1367307603,
0.0664550215,
-0.092954725,
-0.3468940854,
0.3750426769,
-0.8784306645,
0.8439653516,
0.6011930704,
-0.0618941896,
-0.187212348,
-0.2163292021,
0.4444736242,
0.374764204,
0.1269991249,
0.0499060117,
0.1455780268,
-0.7010099888,
0.0817162842,
0.1037940979,
0.0750741512,
-0.3514829576,
0.2592825592,
0.9557538629,
0.1436789334,
-0.3787274659,
0.6540606022,
-0.566337347,
-0.3706714511,
-0.087419495,
0.0296756364,
0.0738317743,
0.6791963577,
0.3741717637,
0.4925452173,
0.0887763277,
-0.276145637,
0.5338475704,
0.4082597494,
-0.6540622115,
-0.6663412452,
1.1339060068,
-0.10970705,
-0.4391233325,
0.6391763091,
0.29522416,
-0.6923723817,
0.6069749594,
0.8151761293,
0.990462184,
-0.3912587762,
-0.1515083611,
0.3652100861,
0.2495314926,
0.0802542567,
-0.1168171838,
-0.3849920332,
-0.482530266,
-0.5386599898,
-0.6641682386,
-0.1611337364,
-0.0835586414,
-0.7275435925,
0.364967078,
-0.3675603569,
0.1763419956,
-0.0321450606,
-0.4677947462,
-1.1540299654,
0.4295176566,
0.1536090821,
1.0317095518,
-0.4219998419,
0.7024094462,
0.4750111401,
0.0554047674,
-0.8353776932,
0.2979201674,
-0.5585606694,
-1.1688681841,
0.4007147849,
0.5643686652,
-0.0721859112,
0.3101640344,
-0.581712544,
-1.2470743656,
1.4815821648,
0.6923802495,
-0.7723150849,
-0.2815675437,
0.0536478981,
0.3252453208,
-0.3287662864,
0.3292086422,
0.4628406167,
0.2195648402,
0.3530973792,
-0.7753694057,
-0.0725583434,
-0.0275252853,
-0.2503094077,
0.5487972498,
-1.1209801435,
0.6561117172,
-0.1742058992,
-0.2426797897,
-0.134611845,
0.8582974076,
-0.5074311495,
0.1420031041,
0.7711470723,
0.7530866265,
0.5341826081,
-0.0907936245,
0.7403903604,
-0.4537878633,
0.7054062486,
0.9682180882,
0.1407937258,
0.5027269721,
0.4809601605,
-0.2538851798,
0.2577970922,
0.6700499058,
-0.0774634406,
0.5133871436,
-0.2638812661,
0.1872497946,
-0.2085169256,
0.3058350086,
-0.2129107863,
0.694875598,
0.4038656652,
-0.4416483641,
-0.2008864135,
-0.0124742184,
-0.5666891932,
-0.2549664378,
-0.3044905066,
0.7669132948,
-0.1733650118,
-0.5719367862,
0.2534722388,
-0.5627481341,
0.5524013638,
-0.4657694697,
-0.0807113796,
-0.1140272021,
0.1914663911,
-0.4541806579,
-1.0641493797,
0.4965712428,
-0.4211201668,
-0.3790735006,
-0.2994101644,
0.7544404268,
-0.1752770245,
-0.4096618891,
0.3519985974,
0.2176697999,
-0.1104446501,
-0.2532179952,
-0.6876750588,
0.1597355157,
0.1755390763,
-0.367928952,
0.2239843011,
0.2900308669,
0.2438719571,
0.4489651024,
0.5510692,
-0.3621328473,
0.4800771773,
-0.2374719828,
1.1576783657,
-0.746034503,
-0.7625441551,
-0.5255863667,
0.600743413,
0.0615742207,
-0.2346833497,
0.3030465245,
0.6389171481,
0.6317298412,
0.1060360596,
0.4422484934,
-0.0399670303,
0.0906319022,
-0.3079305291,
0.3562909663,
-0.7910776734,
-0.3549597263,
0.0175224766,
-1.3763160706,
-0.4234094918,
0.5605148077,
0.0104674259,
-0.1592993289,
0.3513969481,
0.2732927501,
-0.616469264,
0.0080672372,
0.5699048638,
-0.0007862022,
0.7157667279,
0.4398786724,
0.634236753,
-0.9196654558,
0.4600502253,
-0.184913367,
-0.2062890083,
-0.0566885509,
-0.5345402956,
-0.7874472141,
-0.6517743468,
-0.184238255,
-0.2373425812,
-0.5320422649,
0.5300536156,
1.0505601168,
-0.4447147846,
0.3667805493,
-0.2403527349,
-0.3739517927,
0.0679344311,
-0.2811306715,
0.5729568601,
-0.4129732847,
-0.7661331296,
0.4396580458,
0.8299527168,
0.0444304496,
-0.5055574179,
-0.1860782653,
0.1192694157,
0.1861901581,
0.6810390949,
0.2204153985,
-0.5355727077,
-0.6031074524,
0.3099011183,
0.1433086842,
0.4944416881,
0.9899036884,
-0.9185684919,
0.6610458493,
0.3352346718,
1.2410202026,
0.9106028676,
-0.0321128778,
0.3745505512,
-0.533318162,
0.2383113056,
0.5352272987,
0.4289006889,
0.3486332595,
-0.8263784647,
0.6958967447,
-0.0515101328,
-1.0322623253,
-0.6359241009,
0.2913279533,
-1.0261319876,
0.0167664476,
0.6699571609,
-0.062411949,
-0.5874497294,
0.1804246455,
-0.0904866755,
0.1903123707,
0.0164876524,
0.5521870255,
0.2527808845,
-0.5833713412,
-0.1647480428,
-0.3104099929,
0.249461472,
0.6517399549,
-0.9443531036,
0.0115729179,
0.0847605392,
0.31554088,
0.3890139163,
0.4296557009,
-0.1026892066,
0.3626813293,
-0.0441929698,
-0.3894367516,
0.3627814353,
-0.3415152431,
-0.3291859925,
0.1019067019,
-0.4561288059,
-0.2727849782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14380v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14380v2 | Finding the Pillars of Strength for Multi-Head Attention | 2023-05-22T03:44:44 | 2023-10-15T04:10:13 | Jinjie Ni, Rui Mao, Zonglin Yang, Han Lei, Erik Cambria | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, I.2.0; I.2.7 | Recent studies have revealed some issues of Multi-Head Attention (MHA), e.g.,
redundancy and over-parameterization. Specifically, the heads of MHA were
originally designed to attend to information from different representation
subspaces, whereas prior studies found that some attention heads likely learn
similar features and can be pruned without harming performance. Inspired by the
minimum-redundancy feature selection, we assume that focusing on the most
representative and distinctive features with minimum resources can mitigate the
above issues and lead to more effective and efficient MHAs. In particular, we
propose Grouped Head Attention, trained with a self-supervised group constraint
that group attention heads, where each group focuses on an essential but
distinctive feature subset. We additionally propose a Voting-to-Stay procedure
to remove redundant heads, thus achieving a transformer with lighter weights.
Moreover, our method achieves significant performance gains on three
well-established tasks while considerably compressing parameters. | [
-0.8106665611,
-0.148883909,
0.4305627942,
0.4461008608,
-0.4257175624,
-0.0857705772,
-0.1749649346,
-0.3979230523,
0.7060328722,
0.5394984484,
-0.7823987007,
-0.0528607443,
-0.893102169,
0.3289244771,
-0.1066947356,
0.9972693324,
0.151360631,
-0.3885192871,
-0.0446700491,
-0.8173125386,
-0.5911625028,
-0.3759323359,
-0.4815070927,
-0.4078087509,
1.1891344786,
0.6535631418,
0.6347802877,
0.9579977989,
0.8849135637,
0.2972328067,
-0.0346367583,
0.2542319596,
-0.6451180577,
-0.0726130754,
-0.0900737494,
-0.2000676394,
-0.5241679549,
-0.0856343359,
0.5671188831,
0.8632060885,
0.0252523534,
0.3512747884,
0.4872326553,
0.9308387637,
-0.7066720128,
0.1449934393,
-0.7047174573,
0.2121465504,
-0.1984205395,
-0.2122461945,
-0.0899423361,
-0.0311285798,
0.1285140961,
-0.4474656582,
0.4150930941,
-0.0648402125,
0.6583470106,
0.7542746663,
-0.3637135327,
0.3407744169,
-0.5405006409,
1.0733258724,
0.0619916096,
0.5426063538,
0.3995539844,
0.2340203822,
0.4597275555,
-0.4504643381,
-0.1302759051,
0.3016483486,
-0.2068451792,
0.1430074275,
-0.1806444526,
0.0879266188,
0.2670759559,
0.3196062446,
-0.3275282979,
-0.2401589453,
-0.7021808624,
-0.0803859532,
0.5573355556,
-0.0444777124,
-0.1532369852,
0.0378024988,
-0.3878047764,
-0.3568850458,
-0.6271957755,
-0.034847945,
-0.1829805225,
0.4820711315,
0.2120917439,
0.5778506994,
-0.5071086287,
0.5262560248,
0.5722751021,
-0.4369916618,
0.2756645083,
-0.3259733319,
-0.2323622108,
-0.0510005578,
0.336622417,
0.2636065185,
0.1270305961,
-0.4744685888,
0.0068014213,
0.2407919914,
0.7241680026,
-0.7982453704,
-0.2008222491,
0.0599425137,
-0.8425045013,
-0.3325305581,
-0.1125047654,
-0.7197126746,
-0.2254173607,
-0.498862952,
0.4176244736,
-0.082551688,
-0.2047379464,
-0.250433445,
-0.1505592763,
0.1271029413,
0.1017044112,
-1.3647664785,
-0.0636242926,
0.5030899644,
0.7288224101,
-0.4911331236,
-0.477902621,
-0.3050541282,
0.4392350018,
-0.0157461744,
0.74477911,
-0.4460698962,
-0.0941917598,
-0.4336148798,
0.019763831,
-0.1860555708,
-0.6171635389,
0.4742130935,
-0.3347176015,
0.0095801139,
-0.6429278255,
0.1339714974,
-0.4877056479,
0.2810239494,
-0.7597568035,
0.4198261201,
0.4104566276,
-0.6448763609,
0.5995800495,
-0.2380068749,
-0.6055150628,
-0.1792032719,
-0.6052137613,
-0.7725721002,
0.3455545902,
0.4654934406,
0.3880878389,
-0.1189161167,
-0.2934372723,
-0.4789007902,
-0.2686789036,
-0.345189333,
-0.0646142885,
0.5502163172,
0.0325015634,
-0.4259338975,
0.3778894544,
-0.6789705753,
0.0515357591,
-0.048616074,
-0.2603996694,
-0.0450085886,
-0.1597394943,
0.0234781206,
0.4255228341,
0.0125545105,
-0.2781025469,
0.1282564104,
-0.0378756076,
0.4227310419,
0.5765960813,
0.1009610295,
0.2444247752,
-0.3622637093,
0.4997547567,
0.0071939374,
0.2069728673,
0.1331142187,
-0.3604514301,
-0.7255176306,
-0.5314286947,
-0.0616531633,
0.2586172223,
-0.500823319,
0.602011919,
-0.1742077321,
-0.4361952543,
-0.4176469743,
0.4458515942,
0.4569790661,
0.3970881701,
0.4949929714,
-0.6366682053,
-0.3932729959,
-1.2999068499,
-0.1294637918,
-0.0258510523,
0.0074942498,
0.0655706674,
0.0693578571,
-0.2980844378,
0.9363645315,
-0.604619801,
-0.799695313,
-0.3486288786,
0.1365286559,
0.0770516992,
0.3259385824,
0.5436890125,
-0.9496818185,
-0.2164466232,
0.0112935631,
-0.7027022243,
-0.048383832,
-0.0993617848,
-0.0197674986,
-0.3903806508,
0.1785624027,
-0.6456959844,
0.172066465,
0.5151737928,
0.0198366046,
0.2091681659,
0.2401177287,
0.1865855902,
-0.5962123275,
0.1288313419,
0.1200235561,
-0.1925383508,
-0.5991274118,
0.1064207777,
0.1532205641,
-0.2813952863,
-0.3621175289,
0.1056161225,
-0.5136434436,
-0.0252106749,
-0.5021861792,
0.0002151111,
-0.039207872,
1.2969272137,
0.0234307349,
0.5532050133,
0.4448410273,
-0.8805015683,
0.1964040548,
0.4812475145,
0.1018396467,
0.8894284964,
-0.744520247,
0.3049840927,
-0.3088159263,
-0.1952232122,
-0.9654633999,
-0.4766976833,
0.1001169384,
-0.1980595291,
0.3730578721,
0.0904948637,
0.1253076494,
-0.5090485215,
-0.446293056,
0.705665648,
0.1243269742,
-0.3720984459,
0.6620405316,
0.8412683606,
-0.1100739986,
-0.8154546022,
-0.7713236213,
-0.160612002,
-0.6895822883,
-0.6260924339,
0.5568109155,
0.2891848981,
0.0797174498,
-0.0120173329,
-0.4102685452,
-0.2329361886,
-0.0846961513,
0.2826243043,
-0.2234287709,
-0.013413934,
0.2640136778,
-0.0848403871,
-0.4166909158,
-0.1512399614,
-0.036274381,
0.2414115667,
-0.1596535891,
-0.4615325928,
-0.3292673528,
0.5988223553,
0.7906709313,
-0.5599518418,
0.4620607495,
0.6656128764,
-0.4346216917,
0.1567860693,
-0.730224967,
-0.6079934239,
-0.4934945107,
0.6708183885,
-0.4106287956,
-1.0867971182,
0.3813970387,
-0.000989133,
0.2275763452,
0.5467780828,
0.6404897571,
-0.0550075099,
0.9940052629,
0.7565119863,
-0.4055818617,
0.4219251871,
-0.0312230121,
0.1640914679,
-0.8874387741,
-0.0795490816,
-0.3544240892,
-0.8393490314,
-0.3670044541,
-0.3123939335,
0.7647860646,
-0.0468647815,
0.2625417411,
0.5301327109,
-0.9789267182,
0.3236300051,
0.5124397278,
0.3199813068,
0.0963334888,
0.107639648,
0.3895938993,
-0.2404022515,
-0.583596468,
-0.1183118224,
0.978495121,
0.3785861731,
0.6765859127,
-0.0822039992,
0.6699682474,
0.1370198131,
0.1155353859,
-0.8197160363,
0.4598074555,
0.0699802712,
-0.5194737315,
-0.5042886138,
-0.5457153916,
-1.1896152496,
0.8329405785,
-0.1277035475,
-0.3957755864,
0.3362452686,
0.3406069875,
-0.8144279718,
-0.0256132483,
-0.4410642982,
0.9976062179,
-0.055243846,
-0.2864926755,
-0.7157978415,
-0.6620130539,
0.4017682374,
-0.093981944,
-0.1827192754,
-0.0873365477,
0.0580908172,
0.6967548132,
0.0268029086,
0.6189562082,
-0.0843336284,
0.2359542698,
0.2939991653,
-0.5648728013,
0.4349081516,
-0.0936814919,
0.5728801489,
0.0514440872,
-0.4970702529,
-0.364493072,
-0.487522155,
0.3996061683,
-0.6462935805,
-0.739538312,
-0.1239349991,
-0.4484170377,
-0.3743667006,
0.3365448415,
0.1386181414,
0.4293963909,
0.0316875614,
0.7588644028,
0.7603319883,
0.4214653373,
0.5249813199,
-0.1575882733,
-0.0234782863,
-0.7598419785,
1.000434041,
0.339471668,
0.181248799,
0.3413805366,
0.0819128528,
-0.1216936558,
-0.5532123446,
-0.2981067002,
0.2456910908,
-0.4676529765,
-0.2373777181,
-0.8003919125,
-0.0121509768,
-0.2850317359,
0.1007612124,
-0.5241689086,
-0.6473429799,
0.0323811248,
0.0309948027,
-0.1266095638,
0.4184420407,
0.080940865,
0.6679490209,
-0.7497238517,
0.8588626385,
1.0434955359,
0.1876232177,
-0.0666869879,
-0.1782301515,
-0.501932621,
-0.5687607527,
-0.8104798198,
-0.9399437904,
0.1571704894,
0.0873206481,
0.7296826839,
0.873780489,
-0.1177079007,
0.7342303991,
-0.2553699613,
0.1002702191,
0.3395444453,
-0.5026503801,
0.3873909414,
-0.2692121565,
0.3817982674,
0.9690786004,
0.1740225405,
-0.4232946634,
-0.5045670867,
-0.6660878658,
-0.6647338867,
0.6268203855,
0.4065127969,
-0.2818616033,
0.21811831,
0.1238919869,
-0.1028982699,
0.601385355,
-0.8116188049,
-0.4000675976,
-0.0294196829,
-0.2042693049,
0.3439611793,
-0.2363902628,
-0.410912782,
-0.1675953716,
0.3529209495,
-0.3410981297,
0.3442460299,
0.2854469121,
-0.1194526628,
-0.2684102058,
-0.0475379452,
0.6446739435,
0.9024323821,
-0.06599392,
0.2424467355,
0.3630037308,
-0.5959815979,
0.200328365,
-0.1923874766,
-0.0291564483,
-0.2097078711,
0.3790427744,
0.7538239956,
0.2727181315,
-0.0329861566,
0.3329868019,
0.1384471953,
-0.1448397636,
0.0027906492,
0.0941827744,
-0.1756314635,
0.3998464644,
0.620339334,
0.6299579144,
0.1494323462,
-0.299569726,
0.5669140816,
0.6238536239,
-0.5794712305,
-0.1873780042,
0.5591903329,
0.4229951501,
0.0108144181,
0.1571179777,
-0.1138379648,
-0.5253509879,
0.5044475794,
0.0615067594,
1.0532612801,
-0.3853931427,
-0.1384346485,
0.3901922107,
0.6761313677,
-0.0997718424,
0.0188227315,
-0.0690895021,
-0.522664547,
-0.418127507,
-0.1478814036,
-0.3830498457,
0.1118697375,
-0.7142648697,
0.284183234,
-0.6300376058,
-0.5130144358,
-0.2193603516,
-0.1433164328,
-0.6118553877,
0.5257533193,
0.1805280298,
0.1485778093,
-0.799867332,
0.6045925021,
0.4499279857,
-0.26693362,
-0.5783681273,
0.0766471699,
0.0630450621,
-0.7738592625,
0.3242081404,
0.6432290077,
-0.342733413,
-0.18094486,
-0.0099949148,
-1.1430801153,
1.0486671925,
0.3708185852,
-0.568516314,
-0.0298181102,
0.0436218008,
0.0198462047,
-0.3238841295,
0.1868923008,
0.4444309473,
0.4802033901,
0.0464221649,
-0.8950818181,
-0.0802821442,
0.1582270265,
-0.0928618833,
0.1041199714,
-1.4068859816,
0.9159935117,
-0.1403177828,
-0.2929527462,
-0.6488137841,
1.2338756323,
0.4809017479,
0.1823902279,
0.9634315372,
0.6743233204,
0.8770321012,
0.0047085863,
0.5797641873,
-0.3040273786,
0.3724198043,
0.7964529395,
0.0724700615,
0.5060444474,
0.7675036788,
-0.2344439179,
0.0398919173,
0.4686700106,
0.0352870226,
0.9315420985,
-0.0711582825,
-0.0362132713,
-0.3171576858,
0.015941361,
-0.486479342,
0.7480587959,
-0.0260250345,
-0.3172883391,
-0.1850901395,
0.1131074429,
-0.1772910058,
-0.2669022083,
-0.6146990061,
0.5155798793,
0.1278578937,
-0.7352296114,
0.6128905416,
-0.1194924042,
0.6488380432,
-0.5721887946,
0.1089680269,
-0.1609765142,
0.5009470582,
-0.2461429685,
-0.2560402751,
0.6709920764,
-0.3331186771,
-0.4999243617,
-0.4095178843,
0.8640274405,
-0.5102781057,
-0.4755953252,
0.1827672273,
0.3070142567,
-0.0673180968,
-0.7632653713,
-0.3537747264,
0.0808082595,
0.1935909986,
-0.3585608304,
0.3963087201,
0.3728756309,
0.0351950563,
0.6097792387,
0.1165514439,
-0.0134109156,
0.0275467001,
0.0060930206,
0.952973783,
-0.7330873013,
-0.5316362381,
-0.8311735988,
0.29733634,
-0.1821989715,
-0.5298829675,
0.6993435025,
0.2911455035,
0.6202277541,
-0.1546559781,
0.5568389297,
0.0976446643,
0.5137576461,
-0.1560405791,
0.7915350199,
-0.6310124993,
-0.4859982133,
-0.174643591,
-1.2569565773,
-0.3907651007,
0.9122548699,
0.31422171,
0.0913596526,
0.9151485562,
0.5388282537,
-0.1206645146,
-0.056297183,
0.3765875697,
-0.3284216225,
0.1139004678,
0.818349123,
0.3973853886,
-0.2668221891,
0.766184628,
-0.3161884248,
-0.3817782104,
-0.2471339405,
-0.5873781443,
-1.0614236593,
-0.290384084,
-0.6528171301,
0.0885072723,
-0.3731377721,
0.7921925187,
1.0220518112,
-0.9014120102,
-0.1103248671,
0.1856556386,
0.1715198159,
-0.8587880135,
-0.0832916647,
0.3805575669,
-0.4886638224,
-0.5196380019,
0.4320862889,
0.5102172494,
-0.3793740273,
-0.5319254398,
0.1476422846,
0.1434755027,
-0.321482569,
0.6237922907,
0.3062931597,
-0.7716229558,
-0.5813392997,
-0.1499750763,
-0.3037411869,
0.2340522408,
1.0237829685,
-0.6689534783,
0.090670377,
0.3836075068,
1.0496585369,
0.4912364781,
0.3016915321,
0.3146283329,
-1.1573250294,
0.2604390085,
0.3043673337,
0.375675112,
0.2452061027,
-0.312323302,
0.7437590957,
0.451721698,
-0.5952640772,
-0.5513171554,
0.1644103974,
-1.1986056566,
0.2064065635,
0.8123153448,
0.0120508019,
-0.1537432969,
-0.1397470832,
-0.2794335783,
0.3048447073,
-0.0860290006,
1.0795544386,
0.8145819902,
-0.4280987382,
-0.5897627473,
-0.1780365407,
0.5827367306,
0.8478998542,
-0.6948515177,
0.1666845679,
0.2127431631,
-0.2747545838,
0.6691205502,
0.5127773285,
0.0360064395,
0.1642939299,
-0.0350593254,
0.0036571026,
0.0058520855,
-0.9780577421,
-0.2467743903,
0.7967564464,
0.0033819077,
-0.6440995336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12680v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12680v2 | G3Detector: General GPT-Generated Text Detector | 2023-05-22T03:35:00 | 2023-08-04T06:07:49 | Haolan Zhan, Xuanli He, Qiongkai Xu, Yuxiang Wu, Pontus Stenetorp | cs.CL | cs.CL | The burgeoning progress in the field of Large Language Models (LLMs) heralds
significant benefits due to their unparalleled capacities. However, it is
critical to acknowledge the potential misuse of these models, which could give
rise to a spectrum of social and ethical dilemmas. Despite numerous preceding
efforts centered around distinguishing synthetic text, most existing detection
systems fail to identify data synthesized by the latest LLMs, such as ChatGPT
and GPT-4. In response to this challenge, we introduce an unpretentious yet
potent detection approach proficient in identifying synthetic text across a
wide array of fields. Moreover, our detector demonstrates outstanding
performance uniformly across various model architectures and decoding
strategies. It also possesses the capability to identify text generated
utilizing a potent detection-evasion technique. Our comprehensive research
underlines our commitment to boosting the robustness and efficiency of
machine-generated text detection mechanisms, particularly in the context of
swiftly progressing and increasingly adaptive AI technologies. | [
-0.3251746297,
-1.0837162733,
0.8978213072,
-0.1725504398,
-0.3208658397,
0.234394908,
-0.0168118905,
-0.5380894542,
-0.1405418515,
0.4179588556,
-0.317882359,
-0.5811845064,
-0.8086435795,
0.4792034328,
-0.812287569,
0.9500209093,
0.0329725891,
-0.3364121914,
0.046386797,
0.2468133867,
0.0357608199,
-0.7877919674,
-0.8228553534,
-0.2314287275,
0.3451869488,
0.0570908599,
0.539924562,
0.6243442893,
0.1668801755,
0.4281682968,
-0.1783588231,
0.4017466009,
-0.4217415154,
0.1050539091,
-0.021490803,
-0.1408296824,
-0.421548456,
0.0527931154,
0.8050940633,
0.0795342252,
0.0530287102,
-0.2659118176,
0.2362309992,
0.3349833786,
-0.6548710465,
0.0149349691,
-0.9178932309,
-0.0440126024,
-0.4472822547,
-0.3507447839,
-0.4590005875,
-0.3807371557,
-0.0861752555,
-0.5825072527,
0.7305968404,
-0.1628630459,
0.6173024774,
-0.1389155388,
-0.46132496,
-0.615300715,
-0.7466165423,
0.6433752179,
-0.2765527368,
0.3294772804,
0.2177226841,
0.3237641156,
-0.3041881621,
-0.9539678693,
-0.9111793041,
-0.1304473728,
0.0797062665,
0.2304326743,
-0.4458093941,
0.1014594883,
-0.028398972,
0.5713298321,
-0.7414238453,
0.0533084907,
-0.2466352135,
-0.6338438392,
0.3548062742,
0.146754235,
0.7365834117,
-0.2360154688,
-0.1600347608,
-0.0263976678,
-0.8207262754,
-0.4827459753,
0.7767897844,
0.2066469342,
-0.0573637336,
0.6112823486,
0.0043162606,
0.5361433625,
-0.2279213071,
0.0936717242,
0.1686730832,
-0.3578546345,
-0.2564142644,
-0.0345707498,
1.3049417734,
0.1340338439,
0.4006129205,
-0.0115679223,
-0.2043355703,
0.1918655634,
0.3621870577,
-0.867698133,
-0.3763949573,
0.0876235291,
-0.3536242545,
-0.6741423607,
-0.0033185056,
-0.7440736294,
-0.4929386079,
-0.0895729437,
0.2370977104,
-0.4791612029,
-0.4694138765,
0.2524441183,
-0.2346661836,
0.2896792889,
0.1852748692,
-1.2394112349,
0.0403118692,
0.7504329085,
0.8977780342,
-0.2585172653,
0.0212275255,
-0.4683634043,
0.3757712841,
-0.3952731788,
0.9694818258,
-0.5335125327,
-0.9526097178,
0.114709869,
0.0594497509,
0.0560766123,
-0.5351682901,
0.7354710102,
-0.2835058272,
0.6667246222,
-0.1296651512,
-0.5220193267,
-0.0308017302,
0.3829372525,
-0.750297606,
0.8750118613,
0.2491293997,
-0.784080863,
0.4086374044,
-0.6332894564,
-0.409091562,
0.3888495266,
-0.4920363724,
-0.6989941001,
0.1772098541,
0.467000246,
0.5166410804,
-0.4233221114,
0.2470848858,
-0.2164859176,
-0.6494897604,
0.0820674598,
-0.8628962636,
0.6023851633,
0.2066204548,
-0.1685241908,
0.1712098569,
-0.7677378058,
0.0012445643,
0.3241049945,
-0.5186695457,
-0.1475749016,
-0.0374156609,
0.2420569658,
-0.2076023221,
0.0302115139,
-0.6059122682,
0.1722881198,
-0.3140623569,
0.4975838363,
0.8636888266,
0.0719373226,
0.3447229564,
-0.002853493,
0.6489346623,
-0.2490518838,
-0.1559312791,
-0.0043162573,
-0.6669885516,
-0.4231640697,
-0.5866877437,
-0.1504094303,
0.4906533957,
-1.1452205181,
0.4146933556,
-0.1220479161,
-0.3754546344,
-0.2018664926,
0.1759287119,
0.3751265109,
0.3014252484,
0.4142799377,
0.2878374755,
-0.5174123645,
-0.9715821147,
-0.6258221865,
-0.3272834718,
-0.5921474099,
0.0691105276,
0.5070687532,
-0.6250286102,
0.8032000065,
-0.3773153424,
-0.3144457042,
-0.6658872366,
0.2658970356,
0.1407761127,
0.3507899046,
0.6516535878,
-0.8307723403,
-0.3619367778,
0.1646565795,
-0.9768534303,
-0.2412222028,
0.001002709,
-0.0363704041,
0.2393357456,
0.8111041784,
-0.6796278954,
0.1192217842,
0.4842778146,
-0.2443431318,
0.6180425882,
-0.1468982846,
0.1580747664,
-1.0667879581,
0.1670332402,
0.0639731139,
-0.2694939375,
-0.8323051333,
-0.2466040105,
0.1735073626,
0.1889714897,
-0.5083312392,
0.7121717334,
-0.4014859796,
0.2467578351,
-0.4040034115,
0.136623472,
0.0296714026,
0.1501671076,
-0.0004072973,
1.2013878822,
0.1916976422,
-0.6299827099,
0.3009887934,
0.2802734375,
-0.4468922317,
0.4955333173,
-0.7925902605,
0.3725758195,
-0.1225963756,
0.0984297991,
-0.9045500755,
-0.5569411516,
0.5975644588,
-0.5665700436,
0.3320305943,
-0.418836832,
-0.6938459277,
-0.2853649855,
-0.3278236091,
0.445808202,
0.4280163646,
-0.7033034563,
0.8058585525,
0.5432970524,
-0.1757315844,
-0.2760991156,
-0.4960099757,
0.1616729945,
-0.333002001,
-0.3632780612,
0.2451854646,
0.1146595329,
-0.0509413369,
-0.2492800355,
0.0234125089,
0.0088075064,
0.1516432166,
-0.0970037431,
0.4622993469,
-0.1110690534,
-0.1232618093,
0.171040982,
-0.304217279,
0.2801166773,
-0.1464677155,
0.4535781443,
-0.1469978392,
-0.1730968654,
-0.2294487059,
0.2944952846,
0.6435690522,
0.0780218393,
0.3954844177,
0.9026454091,
-0.4029863775,
-0.1293685883,
-0.3822601736,
0.117293641,
-0.6382947564,
0.6649639606,
-0.2705714405,
-1.128092885,
0.2704698145,
0.1530781388,
-0.3757624626,
0.6070347428,
0.7726410031,
0.4139573574,
1.3402556181,
0.5462064147,
-0.1725458354,
0.23221156,
0.0089557152,
0.3599834144,
-0.908287406,
-0.0849735066,
-0.6058663726,
0.2462260127,
-0.8574695587,
-0.1499780118,
0.3693883121,
-0.0748561025,
-0.2356794626,
0.1320087612,
-0.8753622174,
0.8524582386,
0.3019940555,
-0.1563693434,
0.3892289698,
-0.0352915302,
-0.1224222854,
0.1857837439,
-0.1632845551,
-0.8020783067,
1.1649200916,
0.2669751942,
0.4363054037,
0.3031260073,
0.6311202049,
0.2597407401,
0.5355934501,
-0.5457001328,
0.7210793495,
-0.2406203151,
-0.6049362421,
0.053344015,
-0.5726044178,
-1.0157216787,
0.5200798512,
-0.1518767625,
-1.0044249296,
-0.1333641708,
0.2031829059,
-0.0497402549,
0.4832992554,
-0.7566418052,
0.902626574,
0.0234973039,
-0.3354331851,
0.1930967569,
-0.0691350177,
0.6315207481,
-0.1749104112,
0.0365136117,
-0.1876155287,
0.0710466802,
0.5149365664,
-0.0746448934,
0.5727167726,
-0.1741456538,
-0.4556632936,
0.3217686117,
0.2540162504,
0.5873779655,
0.2795901597,
0.1092537493,
0.0570843741,
-0.2999955714,
-0.0974474028,
-0.1962186396,
0.6087348461,
-0.5185653567,
-0.5957562327,
-0.5876774192,
-0.3268623054,
-0.2111149579,
0.5759577155,
0.76370579,
0.4085382819,
-0.5521000624,
0.137779966,
0.4352333546,
-0.4869899154,
0.2746389806,
0.2575919628,
-0.4883556664,
-0.3997291923,
1.0707467794,
-0.5486260056,
0.2176066786,
0.2927994728,
0.0925397947,
-0.6474499702,
-0.8580124378,
-0.4555747211,
0.0678275228,
-0.6635681391,
-0.181476295,
-0.8496575952,
-0.3915344477,
-0.1757725328,
-0.2526843548,
-0.1812064052,
0.0104349134,
-0.558138907,
-0.2267625034,
0.2344205528,
0.842921257,
0.0079583544,
0.3578016758,
-0.832436204,
0.743683815,
0.2461756766,
0.2479977608,
-0.3891186714,
-0.2986913323,
0.1906111389,
0.0061299428,
-0.3198697269,
-0.4589962959,
0.6954573989,
0.0364062339,
0.5215249658,
0.2742495835,
-0.217253238,
0.1109679341,
-0.4570648968,
0.7526891232,
0.0724329427,
-1.0930911303,
0.4228106439,
-0.829513669,
0.385239929,
0.2990522981,
0.1988929808,
-0.3061273396,
-0.7257139683,
-0.2902186215,
-0.8170385957,
0.5292561054,
0.4712937772,
0.3442677855,
-0.4097696245,
0.1852471083,
0.0688265041,
0.1249229535,
-0.7035118937,
0.1339552552,
-0.2155644745,
-0.4165975749,
-0.0254029371,
-0.4345280826,
0.0843230635,
0.1210575253,
0.5452651381,
-0.3119290769,
0.6213212609,
0.2003012449,
-0.0139608542,
0.2520495951,
0.3864861727,
0.5706896186,
0.2485710084,
-0.242880106,
0.2262657881,
-0.132894516,
-0.989022553,
0.2414635569,
0.1466596425,
-0.1707110405,
-0.0530886687,
0.3829415441,
0.3638846874,
-0.0209492017,
-0.395028621,
0.4894810319,
-0.3035026789,
-0.6121424437,
-0.2823969126,
0.2692700028,
-0.0967779905,
0.0282767192,
0.4986975789,
-0.0590769649,
0.439797461,
-0.4407859147,
0.1703458875,
0.6252716184,
-0.2305300385,
-0.4102300107,
0.8313264251,
0.2763856351,
-0.0909555554,
0.6694344878,
-0.3721058369,
-0.8546803594,
0.4357344806,
0.6746156216,
1.3316286802,
-0.122264646,
0.3237026334,
0.1412652135,
0.2755191624,
-0.1591222286,
0.1889846623,
0.1610412598,
-1.2017463446,
-0.2384294122,
-0.5224542022,
-0.3185296953,
0.6503328085,
-0.3686692119,
0.2073664665,
-0.446675837,
-0.0193795431,
0.2039034218,
-0.2717910707,
-0.4458230734,
0.0450782776,
0.2638521194,
0.3990106881,
-0.6153438091,
0.8593911529,
0.250861913,
-0.0480759181,
-0.3439396322,
0.1779799014,
0.5747220516,
-0.8454354405,
0.309250921,
0.5678547621,
-0.5258151293,
0.1912680864,
-0.5709059238,
-0.4253768623,
0.8889070153,
0.3649278283,
-0.2337206006,
0.0705528781,
0.2466188371,
0.5678375959,
-0.1030432805,
0.2414557189,
0.7239894271,
0.416552335,
0.1061645523,
-0.6195294857,
0.1310308725,
-0.4782039523,
-0.0175304376,
0.3421555758,
-0.0867926404,
0.8810723424,
0.1349162906,
-0.6194270253,
0.3623952866,
0.3639753461,
0.4638766348,
0.0581222586,
0.1990878135,
0.1879924834,
0.7229517698,
-0.3757697046,
1.267647624,
0.0214659646,
0.2171079665,
0.6535408497,
-0.3498982787,
0.3054099977,
0.0959468633,
-0.0229231752,
0.2072713375,
0.279235065,
-0.2751400769,
0.4550781846,
0.1288934648,
-0.5802140832,
-0.2216208577,
0.1734119207,
-0.3728818595,
0.5084696412,
0.643183291,
-0.2651160955,
-0.2364521921,
-0.2121044993,
0.2029224634,
0.0318378918,
-0.2712045312,
0.5840988159,
-0.0882352665,
-0.4168860316,
0.5578640103,
0.0443876386,
0.7253151536,
-0.6543618441,
-0.1012817547,
-0.0107169608,
0.5494470596,
0.0518973619,
-0.9360626936,
0.2193321884,
0.1200081035,
0.1304058731,
-0.1780476868,
0.9817515016,
-0.3606289923,
-0.4935593605,
0.3036246896,
0.5595621467,
-0.1080218628,
-0.3383320272,
-0.4465154707,
0.4171870053,
0.10725265,
-0.233211413,
0.1929088831,
0.6135863662,
0.150984779,
0.5137181878,
0.930480361,
-0.1529181302,
-0.3869274557,
0.0938416794,
0.84441787,
-0.6836926937,
-0.4545866251,
-1.1600371599,
0.3624274731,
-0.2977549732,
-0.3368496001,
0.7999294996,
0.6889440417,
0.7358223796,
-0.1794497967,
1.1954677105,
0.1468916237,
0.4151984751,
-0.8747917414,
0.7987226248,
-0.2881833315,
0.4669856429,
-0.5220487118,
-0.9480298758,
-0.6052007079,
0.5782351494,
-0.1025438756,
0.2384066582,
0.5716903806,
0.7324703932,
-0.0713010207,
0.3591044247,
0.2547343075,
0.0997391194,
0.9562675953,
0.4425624311,
1.0588989258,
-0.3963204622,
0.6663798094,
0.2943554819,
-0.0995744094,
-0.0783048645,
-0.9419007897,
-1.1796851158,
-0.4716206193,
-0.038948413,
-0.2285720408,
0.0700322315,
0.3874037266,
0.2321426868,
-0.7018433809,
0.0794467255,
-0.5799298882,
0.0601588339,
0.3130603731,
-0.2453189343,
0.3530374467,
-0.1236930639,
-0.9508517981,
0.6492738128,
0.4018919468,
0.5965579748,
-0.0851328522,
0.0632012114,
0.0838327929,
0.0908056498,
0.6949292421,
0.370049715,
-0.5238649845,
-0.550039947,
-0.1088938564,
-0.1943065822,
-0.2015982419,
0.8129885793,
-0.6613015532,
0.3152873814,
0.4575865567,
0.5065439939,
0.3556192219,
-0.0407752246,
0.8250563741,
-0.7653719187,
0.1195247471,
0.2521855235,
0.3759181201,
0.4587045908,
-0.4494766891,
0.5250307918,
0.3316428363,
-0.7279206514,
-0.8393266797,
0.2480110526,
-0.8072566986,
-0.19878003,
1.323512435,
0.3088619411,
-0.1446941942,
-0.4153169096,
-0.3965717852,
-0.0276512131,
-0.4001888335,
0.707760036,
0.5764114857,
0.1423724294,
-0.0606506355,
-0.5246098638,
0.8134422898,
-0.147617653,
-0.892777741,
0.2604988515,
0.6494409442,
0.1386936605,
0.0726890787,
0.8794896007,
-0.3114100099,
0.1685670018,
0.0457209311,
-0.144422546,
-0.0750654936,
-0.2288206518,
-0.0356539488,
0.1121714711,
-0.2394470721,
-0.1937948614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12678v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12678v2 | Gradient-Boosted Decision Tree for Listwise Context Model in Multimodal Review Helpfulness Prediction | 2023-05-22T03:31:00 | 2023-05-25T04:51:43 | Thong Nguyen, Xiaobao Wu, Xinshuai Dong, Anh Tuan Luu, Cong-Duy Nguyen, Zhen Hai, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal Review Helpfulness Prediction (MRHP) aims to rank product reviews
based on predicted helpfulness scores and has been widely applied in e-commerce
via presenting customers with useful reviews. Previous studies commonly employ
fully-connected neural networks (FCNNs) as the final score predictor and
pairwise loss as the training objective. However, FCNNs have been shown to
perform inefficient splitting for review features, making the model difficult
to clearly differentiate helpful from unhelpful reviews. Furthermore, pairwise
objective, which works on review pairs, may not completely capture the MRHP
goal to produce the ranking for the entire review list, and possibly induces
low generalization during testing. To address these issues, we propose a
listwise attention network that clearly captures the MRHP ranking context and a
listwise optimization objective that enhances model generalization. We further
propose gradient-boosted decision tree as the score predictor to efficaciously
partition product reviews' representations. Extensive experiments demonstrate
that our method achieves state-of-the-art results and polished generalization
performance on two large-scale MRHP benchmark datasets. | [
-0.6335391998,
-0.3342753649,
0.1131892949,
0.5746275783,
-0.3696561456,
-0.1549758464,
-0.2101702839,
-0.4837778807,
0.5586339831,
0.1531073153,
-0.7652782202,
-0.1861946881,
-0.3310704827,
-0.0063849925,
-0.2043493092,
1.5255224705,
0.3808947504,
0.0757897869,
-0.3253366649,
-0.2235818654,
-0.2845138013,
-0.2728236914,
-0.465479821,
-0.1797198951,
0.8923692703,
0.3566924334,
0.7217435837,
0.1279283613,
0.5701767802,
0.1586605906,
-0.0631826073,
0.2957079709,
-0.4714884162,
0.2850080729,
0.0166238807,
-0.0316285677,
-0.6233667731,
-0.0502972752,
0.4091049433,
0.5849750638,
-0.2097280771,
0.298201859,
0.4465614557,
0.6963354945,
-0.6073274612,
0.2942971587,
-0.4449465275,
0.1644252837,
0.4715830088,
-0.2719234526,
-0.1452555954,
-0.1529781371,
0.1058600321,
-0.6632651687,
0.3115864396,
0.0672403947,
0.4888623953,
0.2817866802,
-0.3955548704,
0.161001116,
-0.6011440158,
0.7126005292,
-0.4393851459,
0.48475191,
0.4478493631,
0.3863584995,
0.338255465,
-0.4167494178,
-0.4000001252,
-0.2043208182,
-0.0576025881,
0.5132018328,
-0.0846565813,
0.2034072876,
0.1666082591,
0.3998064101,
-0.5556554198,
-0.4016337991,
-0.1222916096,
-0.1987282783,
0.6046369672,
-0.0680776387,
-0.2708430588,
-0.4950877428,
-0.6676858068,
-0.2513385713,
-0.2399902344,
0.4686932266,
0.0625673309,
0.3301495314,
0.0954151079,
0.2397396863,
-0.4752836823,
0.6408638954,
0.0530440435,
-0.1418443918,
0.6168345809,
-0.735001266,
-0.5078089833,
-0.1235422045,
0.8200678825,
0.8546625972,
0.2970933318,
0.1238098145,
-0.5137611628,
-0.0435815938,
0.2858272195,
-0.8499860764,
-0.148924619,
0.1959989667,
-0.8281886578,
-0.4635569751,
0.1538140625,
-0.7412954569,
-0.445532769,
-0.1362353414,
0.0785245374,
0.0565530807,
-0.4279956222,
-0.1316394508,
-0.1235962957,
-0.3366056681,
0.323147893,
-0.8663849831,
0.0091640903,
0.5248389244,
0.712392509,
-0.0936625153,
-0.2716022134,
-0.6186448336,
0.0875949189,
-0.1185051054,
0.980094254,
-0.6360305548,
-0.3551039696,
0.1015314907,
0.0849140808,
-0.1861391068,
-0.4396636188,
0.64686656,
-0.568192482,
0.2281542718,
-0.0488567613,
-0.1498366147,
-0.3377317488,
0.8812382817,
-0.6756312847,
0.8842424154,
0.1833837181,
-0.8718819618,
0.54929775,
-0.4764176607,
-0.603587687,
-0.1207507849,
-0.0368803069,
-0.6388280988,
-0.0180940069,
0.5638706684,
0.668413341,
-0.0746583194,
0.3192402422,
-0.6217550635,
-0.2016223967,
0.0050929789,
-0.3016846776,
0.4018322527,
0.0862952769,
-0.1751139611,
0.780703187,
-0.4718624949,
0.0180149376,
-0.116282478,
-0.3496950567,
-0.2371221185,
-0.1544102132,
0.5155300498,
0.4533247948,
-0.1802787334,
-0.3793932796,
0.2127557397,
-0.2803803384,
0.0595594831,
0.7205066085,
0.2395124882,
0.304489553,
-0.355874002,
0.8421217799,
0.0942672417,
0.5413102508,
-0.1981069893,
-0.9073303342,
-0.4992658496,
0.1003328636,
0.3288156688,
0.3620834649,
-0.6099678874,
0.429900229,
-0.2691639662,
-0.0923758894,
-0.3279827535,
0.1198671535,
0.3780291975,
0.7839626074,
0.4368284941,
-0.3740054965,
-0.3319414556,
-1.1247400045,
-0.1758837849,
-0.2828940749,
-0.2525728345,
0.5917420983,
0.1339264214,
-0.3288792074,
0.7220720053,
-0.2639601827,
-0.8143023849,
-0.2878961265,
-0.2406546175,
0.4076586962,
0.3249345124,
0.3049285412,
-0.9083752632,
-0.3670884669,
0.0412750952,
-0.260692656,
0.1643194705,
-0.0627029389,
0.1052026451,
-0.1474113911,
-0.0269819386,
-0.3933253288,
0.2788184583,
0.4386014938,
-0.1956940293,
0.4376477003,
-0.0419912301,
0.3777001798,
-1.1020938158,
0.151647523,
0.4479024708,
-0.2753733993,
-0.2989690006,
-0.2765348554,
0.1521569937,
-0.004072105,
-0.2538891137,
0.3173964918,
-0.1292348802,
-0.230761975,
-0.0060079051,
0.0022648026,
0.0727285519,
0.8351644278,
0.0266454015,
0.5900111198,
0.2388774902,
-0.5583916306,
0.2563033402,
0.3034173846,
-0.3365468383,
0.5902942419,
-0.4918138981,
-0.2718220353,
-0.0510936454,
0.5263124108,
-1.160908103,
-0.148575455,
0.138859272,
-0.6294286251,
0.2063375115,
-0.1025186926,
-0.303504169,
-0.3352436423,
-0.7821834683,
0.47145769,
0.1794020683,
-0.5001837611,
0.3467282057,
0.4046517909,
-0.0393734425,
-0.8083290458,
-0.6198946238,
-0.2012814879,
-0.0698421001,
-0.7946491241,
0.5408040285,
-0.1218668669,
0.0311764609,
-0.1907491386,
-0.1480854154,
0.2042443901,
-0.072277315,
0.1932604611,
0.183361873,
-0.0539412908,
0.3279316723,
-0.0677251145,
-0.2357089221,
0.1046241447,
-0.3220247328,
0.1482639462,
-0.0793844908,
-0.0401675403,
-0.2787480652,
0.2996443212,
0.4181719124,
-0.3599870801,
0.284765929,
0.7608552575,
-0.3300227225,
-0.4756207764,
-0.4688948393,
-0.4963966608,
-0.3793208599,
0.6127785444,
-0.236755535,
-0.7030417323,
0.3917584419,
0.2393373996,
-0.0412360989,
0.3143830597,
0.5607023239,
-0.24585706,
1.4572660923,
0.5494473577,
-0.20075728,
0.81050843,
-0.2950776815,
0.0952078402,
-0.9675819278,
-0.3064417243,
-0.2173139751,
-0.7317721248,
-0.4416585565,
-0.3189782202,
0.6835839152,
0.0414769761,
-0.0430252887,
-0.1417573392,
-0.7327433825,
0.2970376611,
0.6080758572,
0.1601255238,
0.2598046362,
0.4509775937,
-0.4264212847,
0.1397969425,
-0.7350221872,
0.0276299994,
1.3011518717,
0.3021662831,
0.3117335737,
-0.1565602869,
0.2669391632,
0.3896476626,
0.6452746987,
-0.8658023477,
0.4318616688,
0.0219574161,
-0.5019757152,
-0.0435384996,
-0.445396781,
-0.6925724149,
0.2412478328,
-0.2763722837,
-0.3488699496,
0.1342049688,
0.2722828686,
-0.5370433331,
0.1205473468,
-0.4718428552,
0.8921105266,
-0.1962608248,
-0.7677963972,
-0.5039023161,
-0.9039742351,
0.5083188415,
0.3490010798,
0.3449634612,
0.0961072445,
0.0062158233,
0.953268826,
-0.3707557321,
0.504570663,
-0.4144714773,
0.1367682666,
0.0292396899,
0.0502093807,
0.3326981664,
0.3605001569,
0.0550006926,
-0.1501292437,
-0.2655079067,
-0.2165032476,
-0.5805711746,
0.93674016,
-0.5784094334,
-0.5098602176,
-0.4369041324,
-0.429725498,
-0.7334292531,
0.3009781837,
-0.0597709492,
0.3549840748,
0.0720862076,
0.2450052053,
0.5039855838,
0.2324310541,
0.5933611989,
0.0225517415,
-0.5200769901,
-0.9656180739,
0.9608530402,
-0.1414684504,
-0.0164324977,
0.3721548617,
0.3357256651,
-0.638895452,
-0.5893844366,
-0.543913722,
0.0562388748,
-0.6555659175,
-0.3071759343,
-0.5193352699,
-0.0507181957,
-0.2933664322,
0.2310237139,
-0.0220051799,
-0.5668013096,
0.000006025,
-0.3264397979,
0.1395381838,
0.7927941084,
-0.0213364568,
-0.0069897389,
-0.6650363207,
0.3407250643,
0.5269642472,
0.6728057861,
0.3303797841,
-0.1554519534,
-0.3337661922,
-0.1543041319,
-0.4926802814,
-0.7676383257,
0.1498481631,
0.0964910015,
0.5058080554,
0.8343411088,
-0.0120660923,
0.553989768,
-0.0866737217,
0.5572749972,
0.3902496696,
-0.2524878383,
0.4043364227,
-0.7016060352,
0.3059080243,
0.7651716471,
0.3761609495,
-0.6505332589,
0.1488220543,
-0.4594462812,
-0.7367859483,
0.5648149848,
-0.0760493875,
-0.0829043388,
0.0354286991,
-0.1995395571,
0.1932393312,
0.6344991922,
-0.8136011958,
-0.2811043859,
-0.5565689802,
-0.0157181229,
-0.2090346813,
-0.3112939894,
-0.181836769,
-0.5174387097,
0.7161666751,
-0.3354405463,
0.1618860811,
0.4292240441,
0.1080715656,
-0.3316108584,
0.1660040915,
0.6721426249,
0.5123819709,
-0.4515863955,
-0.1093753278,
-0.2491190881,
-0.3307198882,
-0.1107147634,
0.3366414905,
-0.0905524492,
-0.2423541546,
0.3134380281,
0.6738740802,
0.2680819631,
-0.2985054553,
0.7767225504,
-0.2393069416,
-0.137310937,
-0.1034621447,
-0.1744784862,
0.1016756073,
0.1507534534,
0.4603583217,
0.7334874868,
0.3800054193,
-0.2620592117,
0.4471851289,
0.7370351553,
-0.6726980209,
-0.2165616751,
0.7393955588,
0.7030270696,
-0.1925474554,
0.4946638942,
-0.2232463062,
-0.7187805176,
0.5446398258,
0.3430020213,
1.0257153511,
-0.2215110064,
0.1755403876,
0.5548882484,
0.2427165806,
0.1944112033,
0.1851497144,
-0.7110769153,
-0.5040250421,
-0.1840448678,
-0.5461981297,
-0.3183390796,
-0.0123168575,
-0.6407940984,
0.135660693,
-0.6532996893,
-0.3222999871,
-0.1276903898,
-0.0843661577,
-0.5282481313,
0.5309841037,
0.2402142733,
0.7055870295,
-0.4553239346,
0.7130428553,
0.5047722459,
-0.5667066574,
-0.6913253665,
0.1950977594,
-0.0779017583,
-0.5831826329,
0.4252213836,
0.7693315744,
-0.2168667912,
-0.2700944245,
0.1182120964,
-0.4980965257,
1.096429348,
0.0496318601,
-0.7674745321,
0.0365093462,
-0.2174372077,
0.4031662345,
-0.6191557646,
0.79586339,
0.1386882365,
0.4916622341,
0.0624684878,
-0.8826044798,
-0.0983443484,
-0.7188120484,
-0.0892824829,
-0.0226995349,
-0.6627979279,
0.670134604,
-0.2517485917,
0.0198137071,
-0.3439976275,
0.4511666596,
0.2824157774,
0.5254687667,
0.808310926,
0.5636427999,
0.5757151842,
0.2074023932,
1.3592393398,
-0.4308922887,
0.3892945349,
0.8827894926,
-0.1846794337,
1.062713027,
0.4296497107,
-0.2584275901,
0.5056750178,
0.8979840875,
0.0078101009,
0.6141471863,
0.0172538795,
-0.1645837873,
-0.3148364425,
-0.4208200574,
-0.7073200345,
-0.0832504258,
0.1118197143,
-0.8139664531,
-0.0129399896,
-0.0756816715,
-0.3966534734,
-0.3295143843,
-0.6696355939,
0.8010182381,
-0.0910095349,
-1.0285558701,
0.7926854491,
-0.2120438218,
0.9458115697,
-0.4966801107,
0.0337669998,
-0.2704967856,
0.375448972,
-0.6748558879,
-0.6785635948,
0.0206610393,
-0.3037573397,
-0.6445282698,
-0.5309038758,
0.7780355811,
-0.2750225067,
-0.8237223029,
0.6160851717,
0.5182796717,
-0.3430851698,
-0.3059669733,
-0.8995874524,
-0.2560716867,
0.2448896468,
-0.5261297226,
0.4432710409,
-0.3498171866,
-0.2032501847,
0.6211229563,
0.8051121831,
-0.0555705577,
-0.234275952,
0.4062878191,
0.9539072514,
-0.4618318975,
-1.0044023991,
-0.5609512925,
0.5621320605,
-0.2233309597,
-0.4710037112,
0.6574832797,
0.6788322926,
0.7770484686,
-0.0892214477,
0.754414916,
0.3782067001,
0.5109148026,
-0.156153366,
0.9384442568,
-0.7242085934,
0.1940977424,
-0.3353112042,
-1.2299488783,
-0.5396416187,
0.6119960546,
-0.2434977591,
0.4623476863,
0.8624953032,
0.8147066832,
-0.3017596602,
0.2439084798,
0.239755109,
0.0000873753,
0.0742828846,
0.5976547003,
0.691914916,
-0.1416041851,
0.7312167287,
-0.5121353269,
-0.3520667553,
-0.3035929501,
-0.7613616586,
-0.9645345211,
-0.5265181065,
-0.2425340712,
-0.5457789302,
-0.1105310172,
0.9420118332,
0.9925625324,
-0.9195437431,
-0.2215590477,
-0.0860785246,
0.2583568394,
-0.5786629319,
-0.2798572481,
0.3636985719,
-0.1314352006,
-0.3458149135,
0.5201806426,
0.3155322671,
-0.3805282116,
-0.5016610622,
-0.1630783379,
-0.1335578263,
-0.3121569455,
0.4483830631,
-0.0895338506,
-0.6470024586,
0.0437705815,
-0.0276764184,
0.180891186,
0.3676144481,
1.0107115507,
-1.0759898424,
0.6793400049,
0.6357623339,
0.6991446614,
0.3935033381,
0.1501556635,
0.4947743714,
-0.8325023055,
-0.0640812889,
0.570587635,
0.4783289731,
0.4473997355,
-0.2164988518,
0.3086971641,
0.262329042,
-0.5919023156,
-0.6838675737,
0.262781471,
-1.0734423399,
0.0227305144,
1.1236503124,
-0.0037643909,
-0.2528751194,
0.0309946295,
-0.2725479901,
-0.0522390269,
-0.797917366,
0.7142434716,
0.4322379529,
-0.3347871602,
-0.2557370663,
-0.3108307123,
0.8140590191,
0.7176412344,
-0.6232224107,
0.0379234143,
0.5723590851,
0.2238005251,
0.2492622733,
0.3997562826,
0.2478057593,
0.6406200528,
-0.3855718672,
-0.1373768449,
-0.5077785254,
-0.4239055514,
-0.626116693,
0.6909519434,
-0.0076890066,
-0.2367038876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12676v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12676v3 | Exploring Energy-based Language Models with Different Architectures and Training Methods for Speech Recognition | 2023-05-22T03:28:48 | 2023-05-29T06:38:21 | Hong Liu, Zhaobiao Lv, Zhijian Ou, Wenbo Zhao, Qing Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Energy-based language models (ELMs) parameterize an unnormalized distribution
for natural sentences and are radically different from popular autoregressive
language models (ALMs). As an important application, ELMs have been
successfully used as a means for calculating sentence scores in speech
recognition, but they all use less-modern CNN or LSTM networks. The recent
progress in Transformer networks and large pretrained models such as BERT and
GPT2 opens new possibility to further advancing ELMs. In this paper, we explore
different architectures of energy functions and different training methods to
investigate the capabilities of ELMs in rescoring for speech recognition, all
using large pretrained models as backbones. | [
-0.1008450687,
-0.4633886814,
0.2384044379,
-0.1945692599,
-0.1259053349,
0.0567943342,
-0.4368431866,
-0.6069803834,
0.3018382788,
0.2990035415,
-0.1136110947,
-0.2358126789,
-0.3029738367,
0.0669546127,
-0.4693039656,
0.7525746226,
-0.0814393461,
0.2664889395,
-0.1948268414,
-0.2971312702,
-0.1179110259,
-0.7547280192,
-0.4644218981,
-0.4536947012,
0.3315325975,
-0.0600867681,
0.6274527311,
0.5853794217,
0.6092658043,
0.2688213587,
0.101467438,
-0.4681189954,
-0.059384387,
0.0598543286,
0.0916445106,
-0.3349336684,
-0.081225954,
0.1090972498,
0.6938361526,
0.7620456815,
-0.2853661776,
0.124607645,
-0.0469465218,
0.6090678573,
-0.6144382954,
0.1531913579,
-0.970077157,
0.2391420454,
-0.1415375918,
0.1541306078,
-0.5011231899,
-0.2090374529,
0.3607899845,
-0.1779854894,
0.1851278096,
0.1284815669,
0.768279016,
0.084132567,
-0.2307444364,
-0.4289798141,
-0.9849233627,
1.0931615829,
-0.7219464183,
0.6812266111,
0.4270887673,
0.3146816492,
0.3509165645,
-1.012838006,
-0.2992264926,
-0.479873836,
-0.2223202288,
-0.0466529503,
-0.4619715214,
0.4158298671,
0.0839910954,
0.3338621259,
-0.5549883246,
0.5321404338,
-0.0879569724,
-0.2681283355,
0.4388653934,
-0.0642615855,
-0.0540470034,
-0.1420534402,
-0.3982220292,
-0.5055634975,
-0.5206565857,
0.1100429893,
0.2897724509,
0.4400461316,
-0.0700002611,
0.2291541249,
0.1335380226,
0.8047241569,
-0.3861409724,
0.1272516549,
0.3313422203,
0.0979659185,
-0.3733703196,
0.272950232,
0.7437883615,
-0.0970396549,
0.148822993,
-0.2350585312,
-0.4303540885,
-0.1753985733,
0.0287601836,
-0.6407150626,
-0.4539655447,
-0.0016162869,
-0.8814229369,
0.055671297,
-0.2818495035,
-0.5466577411,
0.1808465123,
-0.3896455467,
0.6750603914,
-0.510166049,
-0.4633041918,
0.202819705,
0.0107673928,
0.2582769692,
-0.0486565828,
-1.1947860718,
0.4244728684,
0.305060029,
0.7497209907,
0.2883061767,
-0.0477755927,
-0.2371705174,
-0.214260608,
-0.1423763484,
0.6897442341,
-0.7024177909,
-0.3822146058,
0.1320865154,
-0.3731690943,
-0.4204784632,
-0.363647908,
0.4746612906,
-0.5645014048,
0.2528324723,
-0.1036890745,
-0.6048911214,
-0.2126292735,
-0.0651581809,
-0.7050379515,
0.9490672946,
-0.116489239,
-0.5541736484,
-0.1057203338,
-0.8323268294,
-0.563305676,
-0.1218582839,
-0.0105334781,
-0.453273952,
0.47369802,
-0.0732717365,
0.4004955888,
-0.1665748954,
-0.0546599813,
0.0024398332,
0.0646522194,
0.0364111587,
-0.9752873778,
0.5413573384,
0.6630324125,
-0.1074210405,
-0.0098515879,
-0.9431796074,
0.1577495337,
0.10783647,
-0.357793957,
-0.3765215576,
0.3131376207,
0.2650391459,
0.0016984954,
0.3824080527,
-0.6511833668,
-0.0215348545,
-0.3722486198,
0.796792388,
0.5446331501,
-0.4155038595,
0.214203164,
-0.2449429631,
0.2496313751,
-0.3155276179,
-0.1699759662,
-0.3658179343,
-0.127407521,
-0.6970125437,
-0.1069281995,
0.4428704977,
0.570077002,
-0.4568372965,
0.5790914893,
-0.0446270779,
-0.796743989,
-0.6060749888,
-0.286385566,
0.4184957743,
0.5509496331,
0.6000378728,
0.1473104358,
-0.7900982499,
-0.9865253568,
-0.2110574245,
-0.2836492956,
-0.1850056201,
0.3687882125,
0.348746419,
0.0631091297,
0.9851256609,
-0.2980621159,
-0.0994988158,
-0.1803106368,
0.3658030331,
0.1013310254,
0.5945437551,
0.708558917,
-0.5854392648,
-0.3597734869,
-0.0279935505,
-0.5826585293,
0.1740694493,
0.0787884295,
0.5381663442,
0.1523247361,
0.6012886763,
-0.6350182295,
0.3106870353,
0.7860463858,
0.1969189942,
0.6117506027,
-0.187623322,
-0.0939144194,
-1.0027860403,
0.1877893955,
-0.1345443428,
-0.1859806776,
-0.776334703,
-0.2610707283,
-0.261983186,
-0.415802002,
-0.6402782202,
0.1788685024,
-0.7848080993,
-0.4722316563,
-0.3077099621,
-0.2921223938,
-0.0966823623,
0.4781647623,
0.4284625053,
0.6401210427,
0.8179560304,
-0.5203416944,
0.4991280138,
-0.1286873519,
-0.5193356276,
-0.069487609,
-0.6520637274,
0.5752235055,
-0.0721484423,
0.22173886,
-0.9828116894,
0.0500779971,
-0.6321505904,
-0.1602949947,
0.366891861,
0.2502854168,
-0.511588037,
-0.3856264353,
-0.2074098587,
0.5806792974,
0.6681725383,
-0.5559337735,
1.0105984211,
0.2976448238,
0.1201776564,
-0.3257700205,
-0.4982662797,
0.0477565005,
-0.3964277208,
-0.5185829997,
0.4403310716,
0.2059582025,
-0.3343647122,
0.0397181287,
0.0902316794,
-0.0435269736,
0.0571031459,
0.0080497041,
0.0381132886,
-0.501562655,
0.4877010584,
-0.4359952509,
0.1110439301,
0.0590285137,
-0.3444331884,
0.7768539786,
-0.3797644079,
-0.4494438171,
-0.8164860606,
0.3719154596,
0.4716393054,
-0.3678273261,
0.6334355474,
0.6177750826,
-0.6324024796,
0.2973338068,
-0.6382376552,
-0.4043319523,
-0.4861671031,
0.6289646626,
-0.2748622,
-0.850581646,
0.4471859932,
-0.1515248716,
0.3816523552,
0.5511597395,
0.4575146139,
-0.2896534204,
0.9082437754,
0.5291272402,
-0.3522587717,
0.8889089227,
-0.1610836536,
0.1419834346,
-0.841846168,
-0.0728685409,
-0.9062085152,
-0.4732894301,
-0.5919032097,
-0.0867763162,
0.3425569236,
-0.0331018344,
0.0409249961,
0.5632533431,
-0.4533482194,
0.4020269513,
0.4868812561,
-0.1135447174,
-0.1792460978,
0.2087460011,
-0.0816069096,
0.1586785167,
-0.7304148078,
-0.4920422733,
1.0777587891,
0.4721149206,
0.8055433631,
-0.2604492903,
0.4759781063,
0.189407438,
0.1675166637,
-0.7758888602,
0.4044395685,
-0.5056557059,
-0.5006687045,
-0.4232110679,
-0.3623719215,
-1.1788831949,
0.0792685896,
-0.1114656627,
-0.838391006,
0.0258982275,
0.3447930515,
-0.4597202539,
0.6537919641,
-0.9428830743,
0.6470623016,
-0.4328356385,
0.0894380286,
-0.4970113635,
-0.6251812577,
-0.2506317496,
0.2949188948,
0.1705495268,
0.0284936279,
0.4464099109,
1.1334418058,
-0.3031388819,
0.7412487864,
-0.3712389767,
0.0201828703,
0.6586431861,
-0.2410385311,
0.5519679189,
-0.5309055448,
-0.317412585,
0.4078069925,
-0.1785927713,
-0.1928841025,
-0.4517399371,
0.5504549146,
-0.8270699978,
-0.7341530919,
-0.3191699982,
-0.3520114124,
-0.4559288919,
0.0665357187,
0.4435895681,
0.6474919915,
-0.4285136759,
0.5386761427,
0.5430300236,
0.0109697655,
0.9910368323,
0.4390591383,
0.0092841126,
-0.3114965558,
0.7416477799,
0.2377148122,
0.3071339726,
0.7140502334,
0.1646588892,
-0.6104884744,
-0.5854364038,
0.0108132316,
-0.1328614801,
-0.3981960118,
-0.2947643101,
-0.5181338191,
-0.545253098,
-0.48164469,
-0.0496528856,
-0.4938802123,
-0.4981914759,
-0.5483062267,
-0.4527126551,
0.5009065866,
0.5239589214,
-0.5492954254,
0.3336985409,
-0.7481900454,
-0.0283526294,
0.7187923789,
0.2516751289,
0.2381888777,
-0.4534204006,
-0.4863073826,
0.1606786847,
-0.2640573084,
-0.6750167012,
0.2486097515,
0.5689923763,
0.4730516374,
0.3791761994,
-0.2646555901,
0.4223187566,
-0.8391728997,
0.7165229321,
0.6007629037,
-0.9428589344,
0.6743599772,
-0.0152314669,
0.0380205177,
0.2949762046,
0.2586796582,
-0.3967763484,
0.1949906051,
-0.5066156983,
-0.6361746788,
0.5316680074,
0.2844969928,
0.5148010254,
-0.0055925441,
0.2846425772,
-0.1717669517,
0.0860675722,
-0.6136159897,
0.0544848219,
-0.6783373952,
-0.3937605917,
0.0484265946,
-0.0900694281,
0.1997690648,
-0.1264583021,
0.5084149241,
0.1011027023,
0.4479835331,
0.1466112435,
-0.0097005256,
-0.1374640167,
0.3222877085,
0.3761812449,
0.0056558722,
-0.3872999847,
0.1478975862,
0.2553305328,
-0.6131840348,
0.2043843418,
0.1320924461,
0.371640712,
0.29203704,
0.6023263931,
1.3666481972,
0.1437956691,
-0.5691793561,
0.0180862099,
-0.0363012291,
-0.1356223822,
-0.4238773882,
0.1861643195,
0.0427469797,
0.057430651,
0.5670354366,
0.0963746384,
0.0255224295,
-0.7294012904,
0.1601331085,
0.785535574,
-0.4170548916,
-0.6804500222,
0.4758427739,
0.3228330016,
-0.7243273854,
0.6826482415,
0.2331622541,
-0.3344899118,
0.6989095807,
0.5969085097,
1.0419440269,
-0.7380396128,
-0.3035582602,
0.1943112016,
0.13383995,
0.0683136582,
0.1781027168,
-0.2573029995,
-0.8773047924,
-0.3403244317,
-0.8088564873,
-0.3595128953,
0.4546965063,
-1.0025051832,
0.1661744416,
-0.3940161169,
-0.3059257865,
0.14148058,
-0.094133839,
-0.6886230111,
0.3527727425,
0.3359835148,
1.0080420971,
-0.7373787165,
1.0749971867,
0.7609192729,
0.070472613,
-0.8068894148,
-0.0849317461,
-0.3326395452,
-0.9980247021,
0.7325217724,
0.1517272145,
-0.2097019851,
0.4018588662,
-0.3901341259,
-0.9933390021,
1.0049021244,
0.3968801796,
-0.9125838876,
-0.3789303005,
0.1704825759,
0.6476644278,
-0.4500989318,
0.2256616056,
0.4380812645,
0.1052348465,
-0.073988162,
-1.1979473829,
-0.6892871261,
0.064826183,
0.1973497868,
0.2080017626,
-0.6679167151,
0.8854068518,
0.0115071665,
-0.1757525653,
0.1471948922,
0.8076842427,
0.1809846163,
0.0803243965,
0.6796810031,
0.7680674195,
0.5693318248,
-0.012533064,
0.6346389055,
-0.5106621981,
0.6047002077,
0.7723701,
-0.498079896,
1.19404006,
0.1635996103,
-0.4946517348,
0.7785117626,
0.4055173099,
0.1847307086,
0.7569630146,
0.3377374411,
-0.4046816826,
-0.2438072115,
-0.1931574047,
-0.6080256104,
0.8110744357,
0.5892058611,
-0.5287755728,
-0.3849672079,
0.4794200659,
-0.0314202309,
-0.0132682091,
-0.437215656,
0.7261722684,
0.2841431201,
-0.3373920023,
0.6412638426,
-0.1031081975,
0.5673422217,
-0.7377816439,
0.0806678534,
0.099646315,
-0.0568983145,
-0.0292079952,
-0.5569066405,
0.433232367,
0.1438931525,
-0.2753813565,
-0.4882633984,
0.7536689043,
-0.2150812894,
-0.450011462,
0.1583151817,
0.1506385803,
0.2783744931,
0.1451660693,
-0.6479084492,
0.1382565498,
-0.0570421107,
-0.2876339257,
0.3110160232,
0.3159773648,
0.3388069272,
0.4295990169,
0.5921337008,
-0.1190150082,
-0.088282764,
0.1304065585,
0.6190757155,
-0.5590741038,
-0.5224381685,
-0.7602133155,
0.182384938,
0.3100782931,
-0.1928668171,
0.5693529248,
0.5970911384,
0.4863779843,
-0.0209270492,
0.5004065633,
0.1439533979,
0.6328747272,
-0.942456007,
0.6549552679,
-0.2593794465,
0.0909844413,
-0.0024892725,
-0.8400283456,
-0.0152035309,
0.9159600735,
-0.3137643039,
0.1276555508,
0.6102781296,
0.2956071198,
0.0637490898,
0.3068854809,
0.4177585244,
0.3776400089,
0.3029407263,
0.705535233,
0.6251478791,
-0.3413918316,
0.4348590076,
-0.1591681689,
0.0614508316,
-0.2237906754,
-0.7668963671,
-0.6901619434,
-0.8421609402,
-0.2525590956,
0.0201856419,
-0.0103883417,
1.03670609,
0.926269412,
-0.9250661135,
-0.3308844268,
-0.3939104676,
-0.3181718886,
-0.1467394084,
-0.1888836324,
0.6994668245,
-0.2837452888,
-0.5085969567,
0.5515833497,
0.1723951548,
0.3979747593,
-0.4178431332,
0.1759359986,
-0.2307265848,
0.1788246036,
0.599685967,
0.4890275002,
-0.4706065953,
-0.5036801696,
0.0837058127,
0.1558369249,
0.2775773406,
0.8051580787,
-1.2806924582,
0.2161325365,
0.238137871,
0.44973737,
0.3336915374,
-0.198981449,
0.2683933079,
-0.8919184804,
0.4164434373,
0.6717440486,
0.8166809082,
0.4704461992,
-0.0673569366,
0.0512596816,
0.3294049799,
-0.6913118958,
-0.9714235663,
0.5014012456,
-0.5941756368,
-0.1064537317,
0.8943786621,
-0.2008669823,
-0.1476864666,
0.1410840452,
0.0177809838,
0.2081824988,
-0.1912022829,
0.8344923854,
0.7616406679,
-0.5266315937,
-0.1122112945,
-0.1423279196,
0.6260812283,
0.6455802917,
-0.6948463917,
0.1193927005,
0.357806474,
0.160652563,
0.5294699669,
0.3790648282,
0.1666990668,
-0.0696928278,
0.0382705182,
-0.0632071868,
0.1815808564,
-0.3356022835,
-0.4319570065,
0.1333144754,
-0.0469536372,
-0.5339852571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12675v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12675v2 | A Frustratingly Simple Decoding Method for Neural Text Generation | 2023-05-22T03:28:47 | 2024-02-27T06:57:36 | Haoran Yang, Deng Cai, Huayang Li, Wei Bi, Wai Lam, Shuming Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce a frustratingly simple, super efficient and surprisingly
effective decoding method, which we call Frustratingly Simple Decoding (FSD),
for neural text generation. The idea behind FSD is straightforward: we build an
anti-LM based on previously generated text and use this anti-LM to penalize
future generation of what has been generated. The anti-LM can be implemented as
simple as an n-gram language model or a vectorized variant. In this way, FSD
introduces no extra model parameters and negligible computational overhead (FSD
can be as fast as greedy search). Despite the simplicity, FSD is surprisingly
effective; Experiments show that FSD can outperform the canonical methods to
date (i.e., nucleus sampling) as well as several strong baselines that were
proposed recently. | [
-0.0782494769,
-0.6867796779,
0.647100687,
0.161284104,
-0.556085825,
0.0932630599,
0.0092959208,
-0.1178895906,
0.2980096638,
0.2440254688,
-0.8475230336,
-0.6600090861,
-0.2821909487,
0.3254413307,
-0.5733498335,
1.0514644384,
0.2461244166,
0.274949044,
-0.1769001484,
0.1084988043,
0.0399242342,
-0.5203439593,
-0.7182607055,
-0.4004761875,
0.6292490959,
0.3566311002,
0.6010904908,
0.7394962907,
0.422377795,
0.2421903759,
-0.606390357,
0.3061928153,
-0.7261724472,
-0.0820518956,
-0.1189623773,
-0.81631428,
-0.2058014572,
-0.3424833119,
0.3365893364,
0.9266363978,
-0.0810848176,
-0.137834087,
-0.0429306552,
0.7722567916,
-0.729645431,
0.1034186184,
-0.6075155735,
0.1541216075,
-0.3258618414,
-0.5023736954,
-0.7100892663,
-0.5489345789,
-0.0352937616,
-0.5686633587,
0.5429159403,
-0.1151080132,
0.5039748549,
0.2933984101,
-0.0805175081,
-0.8125727177,
-0.6038659811,
0.8276073933,
-0.7008857131,
0.0594981238,
0.3202477694,
0.1120874584,
-0.3444080055,
-0.9358275533,
-0.6858053803,
-0.2192681283,
0.0346828848,
-0.1044190228,
-0.454239279,
0.4223386943,
0.325830102,
0.3031972945,
-0.3960971832,
0.0251416899,
-0.1706113368,
-0.2008503079,
0.4585075974,
0.5148620605,
0.4848824441,
-0.4679914713,
-0.2901081443,
-0.1119348258,
-0.8883658648,
0.1371466964,
0.4887239933,
0.4167943597,
0.21865955,
0.5176862478,
-0.2368944138,
0.6745547056,
-0.0905308351,
-0.0098731006,
0.2318797708,
-0.4639668763,
-0.094511807,
0.0875652805,
0.6085005999,
0.4538221955,
0.0903534591,
-0.4453585148,
-0.5269441009,
0.4096369147,
0.4115489721,
-0.7822742462,
-0.4467812479,
0.0831438228,
-0.9004134536,
-0.685400784,
-0.4080950916,
-0.8859324455,
-0.3820528984,
0.0051133335,
0.3972000778,
-0.685983181,
0.0147635322,
0.037418291,
-0.2811444402,
0.0654763058,
0.1037672609,
-1.1488516331,
0.2496956438,
0.4758493006,
0.9228333831,
0.0691087618,
-0.1485843807,
-0.6124123931,
-0.1033374816,
-0.6223917007,
0.87779814,
-0.2033381611,
-0.5701737404,
-0.027751375,
-0.2901988924,
0.3130619824,
-0.5359039903,
0.5054145455,
-0.3852568567,
-0.30979231,
-0.4690174758,
-0.5525779724,
0.0059174197,
-0.2344435006,
-0.799693048,
0.6863046288,
0.0396022573,
-0.6777569056,
0.2798973322,
-0.531036377,
-0.474353224,
0.1523036659,
-0.2903372347,
-0.1456422508,
0.5959255695,
0.0374151692,
0.3203781843,
-0.4253468215,
-0.0251761377,
-0.1601267606,
-0.6380149722,
0.1908192188,
-0.5051349401,
0.7760877013,
0.7050873041,
-0.3037204146,
0.0058604353,
-0.971075654,
0.2217658162,
0.3932344913,
-0.3887866139,
-0.5394454598,
0.1327949017,
-0.1699508876,
-0.0718210787,
0.231286034,
-0.6134217978,
0.0522335358,
-0.8298504949,
0.6105523705,
0.7362185717,
-0.2252187878,
0.7661784887,
-0.2203950733,
0.4406659901,
0.0288042631,
-0.2181902826,
-0.5038828254,
-0.3914943337,
-0.5844741464,
-0.1202678755,
0.4450802803,
0.3730640411,
-1.2736369371,
0.1808667779,
0.0259342957,
-0.5350324512,
-0.6457819939,
0.3641537428,
0.7938598394,
0.3857930601,
0.4681543708,
0.0568814911,
-0.5670336485,
-0.8443470001,
-0.4139966369,
0.093350485,
0.017723402,
-0.0973167643,
0.273163259,
-0.1954018921,
0.848123014,
-0.7411321998,
-0.0915901959,
-0.4973110259,
0.366489917,
0.1908287853,
0.4832599461,
0.6630724072,
-0.6308121681,
-0.3528466523,
-0.464373976,
-0.7902280092,
-0.0383926779,
-0.2253545076,
-0.0180286914,
0.2970865369,
0.9062863588,
-0.7378493547,
0.6845375299,
0.1225703284,
-0.2385488898,
0.2928687036,
-0.355981797,
-0.3491134644,
-0.8246221542,
0.0654373094,
-0.1949466616,
-0.0111146159,
-0.9507192969,
0.2889277935,
0.112797156,
0.1019096375,
-0.5167666078,
0.2593519688,
-0.5219262838,
0.2389709949,
-0.4613045454,
-0.0454852246,
-0.4470561743,
0.4998038411,
-0.1575774997,
0.5865144134,
0.1463731676,
-0.5190179348,
0.1860006005,
0.0411049351,
-0.20309183,
0.3653986454,
-0.6629356146,
0.2004696131,
-0.6151739955,
0.1866988689,
-1.1847577095,
-0.0459315665,
0.180998832,
-0.4501106739,
0.2563341856,
0.0277593583,
-0.4624471664,
-0.4686962068,
-0.4027195573,
0.5811315775,
0.649610579,
-0.9421156645,
0.5133863688,
0.0045884452,
0.0074053197,
-0.4073666334,
-1.1417211294,
0.1770160645,
0.0630593225,
-0.567457974,
0.6011300683,
-0.3196471035,
0.0726895183,
0.1729124486,
-0.2827497423,
0.1098784357,
0.0064805532,
-0.0793510824,
-0.1538795531,
-0.3301485181,
-0.2333330661,
0.4012778103,
-0.5672852397,
0.075953424,
0.007599324,
0.7819103599,
-0.0319837779,
-0.0412952304,
-0.5155774951,
0.6544809341,
0.3668752909,
0.2560766637,
0.5048881769,
0.2281387895,
-0.6149449348,
-0.7276878953,
0.0208359472,
-0.367092371,
-0.5654755235,
0.2446174622,
-0.532337606,
-0.3513631821,
0.426792115,
-0.1785902828,
-0.2220195085,
0.196614787,
0.2770686746,
-0.2387636304,
1.4163668156,
0.6048915386,
0.3652043641,
0.2267774343,
-0.3914126158,
0.3916050196,
-0.3340509534,
-0.3465134203,
-0.5292985439,
-0.3886918426,
-0.2336476296,
-0.1509270966,
-0.1464309692,
0.5225458741,
0.2325940132,
0.1439734697,
-0.5755118132,
0.7739937305,
0.8632467985,
0.2124536484,
0.0919376016,
0.1817034185,
-0.3738285005,
-0.5549837351,
-0.9972932935,
-0.3605870306,
1.0424876213,
0.0984515548,
0.8627504706,
0.136121884,
1.0968661308,
0.1908934563,
0.2478955835,
-0.7852470279,
0.8321256638,
-0.892637074,
-0.0049282187,
0.0911470428,
-0.6214620471,
-0.924403429,
-0.0585324168,
-0.2424181551,
-0.5559776425,
0.0473231971,
0.3463166952,
-0.7596219778,
0.3603649139,
-0.7978121042,
0.5901811123,
-0.0211285632,
-0.1129960865,
0.039697703,
-0.5960947275,
0.3384047151,
0.0353784859,
0.0430337191,
0.3940024376,
-0.0014504651,
0.7600129247,
-0.867580235,
0.732489109,
-0.4943205714,
-0.0049094022,
0.2163063884,
0.1255088598,
0.4981335998,
-0.071390748,
0.116205208,
-0.0193619486,
-0.2104395032,
-0.3769868016,
-0.7052189708,
0.721044004,
-0.6142396927,
-0.2986966074,
-0.4051653743,
-0.3488332927,
0.122846134,
0.4301659465,
0.7844467759,
0.4573848248,
-0.0349628404,
0.1336545199,
0.8478968143,
-0.379463166,
0.7947729826,
0.2078065574,
-0.2480784357,
-0.6107257605,
1.4051126242,
0.2415507585,
0.1943262815,
0.2993323803,
0.2455460578,
-0.3500090241,
-0.8249214888,
-0.43597579,
0.1431984603,
-0.7606076002,
-0.4154826999,
-0.7802147269,
-0.3058575094,
-0.0871602148,
-0.4543263614,
-0.5177212358,
-0.3597968817,
-0.537204504,
-0.0886907429,
0.0970938876,
0.8834796548,
-0.2463229299,
0.7047395706,
-0.7973133922,
0.8121961355,
0.1883091182,
0.2472396195,
0.1623781174,
0.054495763,
0.0120425643,
0.3464199305,
-0.1132150888,
-1.079203248,
0.4188296199,
0.0513583757,
0.6639765501,
0.3748148978,
0.1784748435,
0.4706511497,
-0.6052955389,
0.966058135,
0.4591477513,
-1.1223582029,
0.5195898414,
-0.1024039835,
0.3549040854,
0.461314708,
0.2287391722,
-0.2133485526,
-0.2462764382,
-0.5283940434,
-1.1793301105,
0.9768413305,
0.2520053983,
0.3860120177,
-0.3054399192,
0.5277094245,
0.1785525978,
0.1396661401,
-0.4959728122,
-0.6008756757,
-0.3863912225,
-0.5775200129,
-0.0901081488,
-0.722589016,
0.0208322499,
-0.0799026042,
0.3769584894,
-0.1538322419,
0.521653533,
0.1723195612,
-0.1805955172,
0.0337302759,
-0.1095683947,
0.8992669582,
0.0115458127,
-0.2827399075,
0.2684064209,
0.0602598451,
-0.5201718211,
0.2422380298,
-0.0718092546,
-0.5910502076,
0.2149206251,
0.1662863791,
0.783985436,
0.3957980573,
-0.4774036407,
0.6014155149,
-0.390681088,
-0.5562832355,
-0.1354492754,
0.2238642573,
0.3174218833,
0.1111139506,
0.5730377436,
0.3557533026,
0.066136837,
-0.2328968793,
0.330821842,
0.2376514673,
-0.0651863813,
-0.201837182,
0.8613749146,
0.1980428994,
-0.681014657,
0.5165906549,
-0.625472188,
-0.3395363092,
0.6690445542,
0.9790534377,
0.9200424552,
-0.1827451289,
0.3684161305,
0.137207225,
0.3703661263,
-0.2679703534,
0.8538632393,
-0.0643687323,
-0.6126052141,
-0.2845833302,
-0.6727429032,
-0.0880930945,
0.1392895281,
-0.6558738947,
0.1248046383,
-0.8054276109,
-0.0908069164,
0.196599558,
-0.2720909119,
-0.4942456484,
0.2659154236,
0.0723091811,
1.2924702168,
-0.4679668844,
0.7946210504,
0.5947258472,
-0.3510816097,
-0.6335579157,
0.0790031627,
0.1829688698,
-0.596311748,
0.6427752972,
0.2929157317,
-0.4162790179,
0.1667871922,
-0.6663256288,
-0.7490737438,
0.8855293393,
0.468169421,
-0.5627272129,
-0.4738421142,
0.2415739,
0.7538662553,
-0.2865099609,
0.0282275323,
0.4184110165,
0.2393678278,
0.0026128469,
-0.0962431207,
0.2371744514,
-0.6219359636,
0.2747716904,
0.1976871192,
-0.511862576,
1.0424531698,
-0.4401935041,
-0.3929046094,
0.5840989947,
0.8654558063,
0.063619867,
0.6538329124,
0.5422457457,
0.5781075358,
0.7894265652,
-0.0491176881,
0.9641389847,
-0.3495248556,
0.1857795119,
0.8797686696,
0.0296396036,
0.6347072721,
0.6565452814,
0.1372037083,
0.2077935636,
0.2468916625,
0.2233091742,
1.1053085327,
0.6106644273,
-0.1731870621,
-0.1462996602,
0.2274766862,
-0.3542564809,
0.505397439,
0.5243596435,
-0.377433151,
-0.561326921,
0.1259569228,
0.2101333141,
0.3632691205,
-0.3932821453,
0.7132171392,
0.2242681533,
-0.4966165423,
0.7825651765,
0.1955005527,
1.0732444525,
-0.6110479832,
-0.0276073124,
-0.4091587663,
0.3768182993,
-0.262011826,
-0.4417713881,
0.5085386038,
0.1320922971,
-0.5291390419,
-0.1765731573,
0.6639767885,
-0.39367944,
-0.1992441863,
0.4212636352,
0.2293698192,
0.038857501,
0.1342614144,
-0.4564770162,
0.0556814112,
0.3845269382,
-0.1503100544,
0.1210628375,
0.1961007714,
0.2397259623,
0.4592359364,
0.9767891169,
0.1067917719,
0.2455843389,
-0.1724307835,
0.7777319551,
-1.0860302448,
-0.7546948791,
-0.9187270999,
0.4236541092,
-0.0112866005,
-0.5359672308,
0.6090948582,
0.2667427659,
0.8200499415,
-0.1451113969,
0.8355774879,
0.1152858213,
0.386648953,
-0.8400071859,
0.9994481802,
-0.7422575951,
0.3482887447,
-0.4422266781,
-0.6925350428,
-0.4652713239,
0.727986753,
0.1500798166,
-0.1145407557,
0.9418008327,
0.8641047478,
0.067551136,
0.5651727915,
0.2545936406,
0.3244723678,
0.409681797,
0.6611422896,
0.8942452669,
-0.3223467469,
0.7113358378,
-0.5751641393,
-0.3561684787,
-0.1927444339,
-0.9375180006,
-0.761517942,
-0.3500463068,
0.0239878073,
-0.4863345921,
0.2049711049,
0.7095330358,
0.3384047747,
-0.6979939342,
0.1481376737,
-0.7433975339,
0.0335113928,
-0.0903952345,
-0.2037148327,
0.1619851738,
-0.6264969707,
-0.7787914276,
0.7433124781,
0.0029611296,
0.0692378208,
-0.0968044922,
-0.2509258986,
0.0175401662,
0.3504526019,
0.623349905,
0.2649863362,
-0.4085666239,
-0.040073514,
0.2074463665,
-0.5563846827,
-0.2894113064,
1.0106122494,
-0.6888529658,
0.3701066673,
0.7191648483,
0.8803505898,
0.2982612252,
-0.3794021308,
0.6759998798,
-0.7158625126,
0.0934969261,
0.1659097672,
0.2372240573,
0.1033889279,
-0.4114390612,
0.3239627779,
0.4283292592,
-0.2446344942,
-1.3010891676,
0.2466606647,
-0.8657859564,
-0.6855717301,
0.9174854755,
-0.0650686845,
-0.4538718164,
-0.0058479281,
-0.3366003931,
0.2225017846,
-0.3190468252,
0.5917835236,
0.4791994691,
-0.001933064,
0.2177906185,
-0.1214836016,
0.9595386386,
0.9076381326,
-0.4821466208,
-0.1407755613,
0.3360154331,
0.1879690588,
0.3817652166,
0.8214322925,
0.0561930686,
0.6719297767,
0.5285238624,
-0.0999379084,
-0.2128526717,
-0.5145323277,
-0.6190609336,
0.4661687911,
-0.2298483253,
-0.2228308767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12660v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12660v2 | Beneath Surface Similarity: Large Language Models Make Reasonable Scientific Analogies after Structure Abduction | 2023-05-22T03:04:06 | 2023-10-10T11:36:08 | Siyu Yuan, Jiangjie Chen, Xuyang Ge, Yanghua Xiao, Deqing Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The vital role of analogical reasoning in human cognition allows us to grasp
novel concepts by linking them with familiar ones through shared relational
structures. Despite the attention previous research has given to word
analogies, this work suggests that Large Language Models (LLMs) often overlook
the structures that underpin these analogies, raising questions about the
efficacy of word analogies as a measure of analogical reasoning skills akin to
human cognition. In response to this, our paper introduces a task of analogical
structure abduction, grounded in cognitive psychology, designed to abduce
structures that form an analogy between two systems. In support of this task,
we establish a benchmark called SCAR, containing 400 scientific analogies from
13 distinct fields, tailored for evaluating analogical reasoning with structure
abduction. The empirical evidence underlines the continued challenges faced by
LLMs, including ChatGPT and GPT-4, in mastering this task, signifying the need
for future exploration to enhance their abilities. | [
-0.5596197844,
-0.4524533153,
0.953465879,
-0.0056693396,
-0.1350354254,
0.4387123883,
-0.0442068465,
-0.6022675633,
0.0079227071,
0.2081472278,
-0.4930498898,
-0.3626536429,
-0.5997211337,
-0.0273519587,
-0.5638822913,
0.7581906915,
-0.1569031924,
-0.0839322954,
-0.3790317476,
-0.0708842576,
-0.1506593674,
-0.5401070118,
-0.3538828492,
-0.5337535739,
0.3111898303,
0.0040091155,
0.7102398872,
0.8297992349,
0.5214821696,
0.3573795259,
-0.204522714,
0.0575041845,
-0.4878183007,
-0.1769789159,
-0.4536225796,
-0.351826638,
-0.3060110211,
0.3158284128,
0.5765657425,
1.2168064117,
-0.0634673014,
0.1092905104,
0.1716877669,
0.6102873683,
-0.4847294688,
0.1367305219,
-0.8738114238,
-0.4148751497,
0.2311384529,
0.0462355055,
0.020169571,
-0.5770364404,
0.2402124852,
-0.7942974567,
0.1979306787,
0.1068527028,
0.7572965622,
-0.145518288,
-0.1515450031,
-0.5688897371,
-0.474147439,
0.6206565499,
-0.4305281937,
0.3029512465,
0.2267794013,
0.1312507689,
-0.4203459322,
-0.6115148664,
-0.5698080659,
-0.5486125946,
0.0151062608,
-0.0684529319,
-0.2811874449,
0.0047887149,
0.3303512931,
0.2133414149,
-0.3443584442,
0.0634659976,
-0.6451414824,
-0.1378137618,
0.1764543951,
0.0795165524,
0.363013953,
0.0295756441,
-0.6562610865,
-0.1202483997,
-1.0742257833,
-0.0441535339,
0.2624439001,
0.1087465808,
0.0157596078,
0.4753734767,
-0.1104545966,
0.2193355113,
-0.1577119976,
0.0743136108,
0.2884064019,
0.087618269,
-0.0510130189,
0.1614095122,
0.324701488,
0.6780224442,
0.4753861129,
-0.4339473546,
-0.0652352199,
0.4634900987,
0.3395161629,
-0.6317469478,
-0.1549403369,
-0.2150045186,
-0.4409094155,
-0.2238272727,
0.1854401976,
-0.5149460435,
-0.3902153969,
-0.3489550054,
0.457873106,
-0.6570824981,
-0.2761841714,
-0.0969525203,
-0.3969487846,
0.2670104802,
0.1802053452,
-0.7072005272,
1.0941927433,
1.0651248693,
0.8293814659,
-0.4435413778,
-0.5370252728,
0.0439363867,
0.187827602,
-0.7528851628,
0.8324605227,
-0.7581245303,
-0.4821888208,
-0.2823661566,
-0.0897832066,
-0.037234243,
-0.8723448515,
0.4322527051,
-0.2665096819,
-0.0597389154,
-0.4785474539,
-0.4948423803,
-0.5153226256,
0.4235322177,
-0.3926402628,
0.9850811362,
0.2319866717,
-0.4075309336,
0.083907716,
-0.3879365325,
-0.0900094584,
-0.1425640136,
-0.2153983265,
-0.0689006671,
0.5320574045,
0.187189728,
0.1288645267,
-0.5864485502,
-0.0673382282,
-0.6988608837,
-0.6768474579,
0.4734143615,
-0.110457398,
0.4189990461,
0.1349139661,
-0.3049389124,
-0.2183660418,
-0.7998433113,
0.2018542886,
-0.0478252321,
0.009603681,
-0.9793994427,
-0.0834095404,
-0.2885038853,
0.2748667002,
-0.0486982055,
-0.5499711037,
0.1454799324,
-0.5669011474,
0.6908748746,
0.6077615619,
0.0322688036,
0.537979126,
-0.4134924412,
0.2048618048,
-0.2143519968,
-0.4926959574,
-0.0613065027,
-0.0640738159,
-0.4768378735,
-0.5411784053,
0.0364218727,
0.3717821538,
-0.4611400664,
0.0369256362,
-0.5441393256,
-0.7562298775,
-0.486990869,
-0.0684263483,
0.6385371089,
0.5727517605,
0.4704449773,
-0.3281726837,
-0.596449852,
-1.0576400757,
-0.6222852468,
-0.2148650289,
-0.4067377746,
0.1944998801,
0.6309939027,
0.0407925434,
0.8176349401,
-0.3796159625,
-0.2162063122,
0.2730404735,
0.1208076477,
0.269885242,
0.4003274441,
0.5746034384,
-0.5815306902,
0.001814014,
0.0028626726,
-1.0760873556,
-0.1548971534,
-0.0405234098,
-0.0160051901,
-0.1656235009,
0.871096909,
-0.9488463402,
0.3163251281,
0.3565682471,
-0.0959680527,
0.7546633482,
-0.1122766882,
0.3476782143,
-0.6579071283,
0.3775531948,
-0.1505574882,
0.1141780764,
-0.5711245537,
0.3923802078,
-0.0757028088,
-0.1061211005,
-0.372667551,
0.6730461121,
-0.7868044376,
-0.3875460923,
-0.3850606382,
0.1421726793,
-0.1304161251,
0.3089398742,
0.1210814938,
0.8783885241,
0.5007794499,
-0.5671117306,
0.0053298222,
0.0239974651,
-0.524653554,
0.5551386476,
-0.5365546346,
0.0907483101,
0.0203010663,
0.1904961765,
-0.9217962027,
0.1539425999,
0.1762949526,
-0.24739784,
-0.2130141407,
0.0342069827,
-0.2145289779,
-0.6411811709,
-0.4013407826,
0.4732610285,
0.8345112205,
-0.4813879132,
0.6276869774,
0.148567453,
-0.2896843255,
-0.4812730253,
-0.4568633437,
0.014009797,
-0.7031906843,
-0.0181881897,
0.4746036828,
0.0384299345,
-0.698069036,
0.2126015723,
-0.5390467048,
-0.0569731668,
0.1684817076,
0.5954420567,
0.123749949,
-0.4931869209,
0.0132864174,
-0.0129745277,
-0.0354524516,
0.6068458557,
-0.3114760816,
0.3083027005,
-0.246889025,
-0.3498573005,
-0.1196848154,
0.1704365909,
0.8202183247,
0.4282740653,
0.5365915895,
-0.21304515,
-0.4366612136,
0.0895257816,
-0.6381453872,
-0.3750978708,
-0.4853329957,
0.4772522449,
-1.0032930374,
-0.5432056785,
0.6416969299,
-0.4332702458,
-0.1670414358,
0.2269287705,
0.3342719674,
-0.3892966807,
0.3963290751,
0.3397685885,
0.0563799255,
-0.0158339571,
0.0249524042,
0.1662161648,
-0.8942273855,
-0.221452117,
-0.3676054776,
-0.2390771359,
-0.2092927694,
-0.4758470058,
0.0674849302,
0.6064342856,
-0.3397257924,
0.6060023904,
-0.4059152305,
0.4828646779,
0.4341854155,
0.1402413249,
0.2741611302,
0.3859300613,
-0.2847688794,
-0.2653556764,
-0.3658901155,
-0.5481190085,
0.8422413468,
0.258931309,
0.5261511803,
-0.1278292388,
0.5542294383,
-0.0261760242,
0.5797324777,
-0.4964317381,
0.8384178877,
0.0462251678,
-0.4514599442,
-0.1553060561,
-0.3345274925,
-0.886755228,
0.6223849654,
-0.2516003847,
-0.9430652261,
0.1723161191,
0.0262172464,
0.0826403797,
0.3338296711,
-0.49337852,
0.4085873067,
0.2365855128,
0.0630172864,
-0.6557863355,
-0.471993804,
0.5448365211,
-0.2765350938,
0.597902596,
-0.3718436956,
-0.1589017063,
0.6179254651,
-0.2453631461,
0.6699014306,
0.0008607184,
0.1004106402,
0.5890866518,
0.6575993299,
0.1258534491,
-0.3960044086,
-0.2723245621,
0.3124881387,
0.1500239074,
-0.3578518331,
-0.8161693811,
0.8907174468,
-0.5537052155,
-0.7754314542,
-0.4397049248,
-0.7446396947,
-0.1510168165,
0.0914470553,
-0.1144984737,
0.1369422227,
-0.5151351094,
0.0790735483,
0.3172347844,
0.027666945,
0.5217977762,
0.5684304237,
0.0462008268,
-0.2708417177,
0.8252100348,
-0.108953774,
0.3827807903,
0.3677315712,
0.1649034917,
-0.09290649,
-0.7095115185,
-0.1102637947,
0.300077945,
-0.6462088227,
-0.1627120227,
-0.7324296236,
-0.3167614341,
-0.1802496314,
-0.3812143505,
-0.4510310292,
-0.5820926428,
0.188588053,
-0.2287894636,
0.3056626022,
0.5164292455,
-0.1135801375,
0.1605041772,
-0.46490255,
0.5291383266,
0.1151996776,
0.2476271242,
0.2586414814,
-0.6575180888,
0.2097041309,
0.1069269627,
-0.2520083487,
-0.5070106983,
0.1299514621,
0.098919332,
0.7536969781,
0.4128362536,
-0.1757124513,
0.8689960837,
-0.8915283084,
0.386419028,
0.3785450757,
-1.0414177179,
0.0887078643,
-0.3035564721,
0.141597867,
0.3987572789,
0.8430162072,
-0.3524064124,
-0.5064654946,
-0.6574478745,
-0.6182435155,
0.1768823713,
0.3817988634,
0.1225308701,
-0.0118977418,
0.5263774991,
0.3313546181,
0.2999405861,
-0.830616653,
0.0355197005,
0.088815406,
-0.0180172417,
-0.0044085239,
-0.1788647175,
-0.264478296,
-0.1694487184,
0.1398389041,
0.0306823812,
0.2905465364,
0.0412367582,
-0.0864039883,
0.0964002684,
0.1345127374,
0.5171204209,
0.8601092696,
-0.1066728234,
0.5959564447,
0.4512710273,
-0.444876641,
0.192743361,
0.1899424791,
0.2308801562,
-0.3195982575,
0.7672560215,
0.2614779472,
0.6300724149,
-0.8092684746,
0.1655567735,
0.6220284104,
-0.4083731174,
-0.140746966,
0.0333318971,
0.2618919015,
0.2306779921,
0.6403213739,
0.3347598016,
0.2320027649,
-0.9756073952,
0.4190644026,
0.5658336282,
-0.3997247219,
-0.4143228531,
0.5171180367,
-0.100459069,
-0.4055248797,
0.6009165645,
0.231725052,
-0.665538311,
0.8382973075,
0.5538476706,
0.418023169,
-0.2380499989,
-0.1081285626,
0.2395271808,
0.4696472883,
-0.2805353999,
-0.0445924066,
0.2759753764,
-0.697081089,
-0.2255999893,
-0.4105859399,
-0.0755926669,
0.1666842848,
-0.6294141412,
0.1982360929,
-0.4570431113,
0.2893259227,
0.0418066643,
-0.3112358451,
-0.4692608714,
0.2053229362,
0.22288692,
1.021863699,
-1.0560132265,
0.8263530731,
0.3958312273,
-0.2226270288,
-0.5816805959,
-0.17559205,
0.1171553731,
-1.0356131792,
0.7670843005,
0.3495225012,
-0.3807798028,
-0.1771373302,
-0.2712601721,
-0.9874546528,
0.8730614781,
0.3740135431,
-0.4243859351,
-0.2606230676,
-0.0732401311,
0.7925410867,
-0.7587471008,
0.3075282872,
0.7308729291,
0.2684408724,
0.1295404136,
-0.9384596944,
0.592166841,
0.0981602445,
-0.177960366,
-0.0411256775,
-0.1926200837,
0.7881162167,
-0.426034987,
-0.2791768014,
0.6579171419,
0.5098095536,
0.7332280278,
0.3581627607,
0.6339769363,
0.3753338754,
0.2563763559,
0.0723888129,
0.9192674756,
0.0941056609,
0.0679611787,
1.1545376778,
-0.3503775001,
0.8493281603,
0.808241725,
-0.2156589329,
0.6874204874,
0.4248574078,
-0.2053312063,
0.8714624643,
0.5596432686,
0.0182928462,
-0.0163531918,
0.219027251,
-0.4553152621,
0.3846318722,
0.7205752134,
-0.4760604501,
-0.4156734347,
-0.0941165686,
-0.1418430358,
0.665415287,
-0.3630617857,
0.4798116386,
0.4266964197,
-0.5852968693,
0.7575577497,
-0.295021683,
0.1188967228,
-0.460450083,
-0.3413965106,
-0.1178657562,
0.1940582544,
0.2433402091,
-0.7402317524,
0.2552882731,
-0.3773873448,
-0.1969083995,
-0.0352886766,
0.494068563,
-0.2771817148,
-0.3653838634,
0.6308269501,
0.5110652447,
0.6368866563,
-0.1667398363,
-0.6622858644,
0.2766343355,
-0.1760738641,
-0.2475676537,
0.2297576815,
0.4906287193,
-0.5154805779,
1.070628047,
0.5605070591,
0.3122669458,
-0.0320679061,
-0.3480778337,
1.1484111547,
-0.8997440338,
-0.3309090137,
-0.9548151493,
0.062202163,
-0.1885965466,
-0.2246422619,
0.5231689215,
0.6803352833,
0.5980532765,
-0.2402130216,
0.5100224018,
0.0084143896,
0.615526557,
-0.558467567,
0.477162987,
-0.3360696733,
0.2924572825,
-0.6789657474,
-1.623486042,
-0.2470147014,
0.629727006,
-0.4792611301,
-0.1041147336,
1.166312933,
0.7594740391,
-0.3901399374,
-0.0803196207,
0.3267127275,
0.4533102214,
0.106676355,
0.7077001333,
1.0356668234,
-0.3099732399,
0.6857939363,
0.1917284429,
-0.1823458821,
-0.0129619353,
-0.9706872106,
-1.1605943441,
-0.4790771604,
-0.101958096,
-0.3367581069,
0.3058500886,
0.8044915199,
0.6923708916,
-0.7737128735,
-0.2431300282,
-0.231235981,
0.0049092667,
-0.725931406,
-0.1546123624,
0.7388309836,
0.1500572115,
-0.701761663,
0.6094581485,
0.0514742509,
0.1921922565,
0.0096541708,
0.1957965046,
0.0415467322,
0.0325632021,
0.4545685947,
0.4563809335,
-1.230224371,
-0.5680331588,
-0.2331715077,
-0.3018641472,
-0.011258048,
1.0446597338,
-1.082806468,
-0.0305411965,
0.1568999887,
0.6097816825,
0.4970240295,
0.1896043271,
0.8140235543,
-0.2675679028,
0.4924226105,
0.0201417934,
0.060405422,
0.216196835,
0.0345458016,
0.6620714664,
0.2120282501,
-0.0699861273,
-1.1146618128,
0.2249031216,
-0.8913063407,
-0.7935728431,
0.8873342276,
-0.3039906323,
-0.1297403127,
-0.0036873932,
-0.1228583306,
-0.169365555,
-0.1820781529,
1.0989778042,
0.9876443744,
-0.1534891278,
-0.3592998087,
-0.3500040472,
0.5138878226,
0.4802916944,
-0.594686985,
0.0457318351,
0.167141363,
0.5666583776,
0.3162285089,
0.343411088,
-0.125630796,
0.1526469886,
0.3608243763,
0.0980060175,
-0.1239643395,
-0.1970813125,
0.0033213852,
0.2639744282,
-0.1613762826,
-0.1584637165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12647v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12647v1 | Reflective Linguistic Programming (RLP): A Stepping Stone in Socially-Aware AGI (SocialAGI) | 2023-05-22T02:43:15 | 2023-05-22T02:43:15 | Kevin A. Fischer | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | This paper presents Reflective Linguistic Programming (RLP), a unique
approach to conversational AI that emphasizes self-awareness and strategic
planning. RLP encourages models to introspect on their own predefined
personality traits, emotional responses to incoming messages, and planned
strategies, enabling contextually rich, coherent, and engaging interactions. A
striking illustration of RLP's potential involves a toy example, an AI persona
with an adversarial orientation, a demon named `Bogus' inspired by the
children's fairy tale Hansel & Gretel. Bogus exhibits sophisticated behaviors,
such as strategic deception and sensitivity to user discomfort, that
spontaneously arise from the model's introspection and strategic planning.
These behaviors are not pre-programmed or prompted, but emerge as a result of
the model's advanced cognitive modeling. The potential applications of RLP in
socially-aware AGI (Social AGI) are vast, from nuanced negotiations and mental
health support systems to the creation of diverse and dynamic AI personas. Our
exploration of deception serves as a stepping stone towards a new frontier in
AGI, one filled with opportunities for advanced cognitive modeling and the
creation of truly human `digital souls'. | [
-0.1939521134,
-0.8384154439,
0.512506187,
0.5073148012,
0.2609291375,
0.4273720682,
-0.2019926459,
-0.559307456,
0.5432088971,
0.348290205,
-0.9812188745,
-0.3039450645,
-0.4008945227,
-0.2509468496,
-0.3242338896,
1.0742230415,
0.5110322833,
0.0999505669,
0.0662187636,
-0.0165758636,
-0.3243252933,
-0.3164487183,
-0.9738422632,
-0.5649114847,
0.3912683129,
0.3738969564,
0.7548515797,
0.3730304241,
0.3381314576,
0.2989926636,
0.4497328401,
0.0016578777,
-0.5357882977,
0.303526938,
-0.3675075471,
-0.3890663087,
-0.4335871041,
0.2867572904,
0.3271450996,
0.5633825064,
-0.503549993,
0.3926735818,
-0.1559325159,
0.812636137,
-0.7007218003,
0.2428515106,
-0.661678493,
0.3615324795,
0.0429868437,
0.0713457465,
-0.5856078863,
-0.2823446095,
-0.1729117036,
-0.709937036,
0.0331769176,
-0.2103865743,
0.5072242618,
0.5515617132,
0.0194912106,
-0.5213156939,
-1.0223101377,
0.896725297,
-0.6273881793,
0.3991937041,
0.3046494126,
0.3006326854,
-0.0552642681,
-0.6918359995,
-0.7128176689,
-0.1637130976,
-0.0063657439,
0.3263890743,
0.038710352,
-0.1270946562,
-0.0914356783,
0.0956648067,
-0.5266776681,
-0.1152543724,
-0.2799145281,
0.0389388092,
1.1434528828,
0.2317267656,
0.3469729722,
0.165829733,
-0.1842665523,
0.0362544805,
-0.3169092834,
-0.0513640642,
0.1713331789,
0.3270949423,
-0.3335617483,
0.4048222005,
-0.2681483328,
0.6507914662,
0.1403399557,
-0.2173422426,
0.0246490929,
-0.1035478488,
-0.1463883072,
0.0295701735,
0.6637613773,
0.4038649201,
0.7597737908,
-0.0906708837,
-0.2218839526,
0.6111316681,
0.6721160412,
-0.1991910189,
-0.2604785562,
0.2058970183,
-0.7260835171,
-0.5421764851,
-0.0012900661,
-0.9200348854,
-0.4757974148,
-0.2174675465,
-0.0106436182,
-0.3590869606,
-0.3364461064,
0.2674417496,
0.0797667801,
0.4769154489,
0.1951211393,
-0.8914220929,
0.5358496308,
1.2011121511,
0.7720804214,
0.1327652782,
-0.5219029784,
-0.3880489767,
0.4218834937,
-0.2498951703,
0.4362071753,
-0.9147372842,
-0.6352975965,
0.1458735913,
-0.5966868401,
-0.1208102182,
-0.2587504387,
0.5508797765,
-0.3570062518,
0.3424189091,
0.1562885791,
-0.1626595408,
-0.0956844166,
0.3634822667,
-0.1818975359,
0.6501970291,
0.0548077524,
-0.3277455568,
0.3107638955,
-0.8727501035,
-0.541839242,
0.4792935252,
-0.5269289017,
-0.1894606352,
0.3188275695,
-0.1411847174,
0.4462664425,
-0.0124883689,
0.5098741651,
-0.3112436831,
-0.26509583,
0.3074409366,
-0.3227967322,
0.7235435247,
0.424785614,
-0.548263371,
0.1929216385,
-0.7745280266,
0.3938038647,
0.4125469029,
-0.1991654336,
-0.2754638791,
0.2424273789,
-0.2405496538,
0.0648556799,
0.320769608,
-0.4256432056,
0.1855354458,
-0.3171876669,
0.4228617251,
1.084274292,
-0.2394238412,
0.2821259201,
-0.1689981967,
0.6001075506,
-0.6264081597,
0.5481584668,
0.0687488094,
-0.7335528135,
-0.9045115113,
-0.18897295,
-0.1806964725,
0.7874550223,
-0.7777567506,
0.3281919956,
-0.3862196803,
-0.6078249812,
-0.7282957435,
-0.3015524745,
0.6820738912,
0.4226383269,
0.1321896762,
-0.4095992148,
-0.3088662028,
-0.9669243693,
-0.5847521424,
-0.6310704947,
0.2145546228,
0.6389325857,
0.3281026781,
-0.5214141011,
0.8064739704,
-0.747990191,
-0.5274570584,
-0.480789125,
0.1857088655,
0.1264110953,
0.4420979917,
0.2731612027,
-0.8413391113,
-0.8467109799,
-0.2025646716,
-0.9048609138,
-0.2085741013,
-0.4680710137,
0.0540718734,
0.10768722,
0.1967082471,
-0.4986160994,
0.4529854059,
0.6022808552,
-0.5556564927,
0.6905782223,
-0.1387062073,
-0.0026350899,
-0.674718678,
0.0839443579,
-0.0239795875,
-0.1457759142,
-1.1132979393,
0.3866611421,
-0.479911834,
-0.2788609862,
-0.2410627753,
0.6107949018,
-0.3951407373,
-0.1102842912,
-0.125350371,
-0.0248775668,
-0.2984471023,
0.4935432076,
0.2266477346,
0.9495930076,
0.6583853364,
-0.5644323826,
0.2445846647,
0.3393596709,
-0.0071578627,
0.6331984401,
-0.5723361969,
0.2927471399,
-0.1743134856,
0.1166936755,
-0.5698038936,
-0.1846831143,
0.5238774419,
-0.8988853693,
0.3415645361,
0.2262672186,
0.0262170564,
-0.1047263294,
-0.2279952168,
0.4398196638,
0.3839736879,
-0.2889863253,
1.0683686733,
0.5652264357,
-0.2383553088,
-0.5380169749,
-0.8186906576,
0.4413002133,
-0.1626022607,
-0.5614435077,
0.1043922156,
-0.1255399585,
-0.5120624304,
-0.116572082,
0.2879565954,
0.0904299915,
0.128729105,
0.2727315426,
0.1952549815,
0.1368243694,
-0.3849008083,
-0.3936608732,
-0.4714609087,
0.3989657462,
-0.1707525402,
0.7859297395,
-0.6193513274,
-0.5287694335,
-0.411783278,
0.7480562925,
0.3839343786,
-0.3168202639,
0.6284787059,
0.5712869167,
-0.1518074274,
-0.2237440497,
-0.5958773494,
0.040239431,
-0.5417364836,
0.221414566,
-0.2862480581,
-0.8014017344,
0.5803863406,
-0.0405548066,
-0.1285420209,
-0.0102969827,
0.3933550119,
0.1153594106,
1.1511051655,
0.9483870864,
-0.1891279966,
0.3867737055,
-0.1789417267,
0.5603100061,
-0.8472306132,
-0.4919426739,
-0.2637707889,
-0.3475096226,
-0.5773487687,
-0.3366837204,
0.2993005812,
-0.6795355082,
-0.3266325295,
-0.1882495284,
-0.9513025284,
0.3052312136,
0.8035967946,
-0.1596519798,
0.0715465173,
-0.3250336051,
0.1864473075,
-0.2076236308,
-0.6154694557,
-0.5964506865,
0.7780519128,
0.50981915,
0.978197515,
0.2408090234,
0.880784452,
0.7099966407,
0.3572549224,
-0.7316738963,
1.116678834,
0.1206082776,
-0.5925382972,
-0.2271655351,
-0.2606463134,
-0.6609256268,
-0.0551692918,
-0.1192097589,
-0.9405314326,
0.3313001692,
0.1836464554,
-0.3910008669,
0.0634250045,
-0.795247674,
0.6935430765,
-0.4931909442,
-0.4425205886,
-0.4351890981,
-0.9262759089,
0.4243903756,
0.2929370403,
0.4171149433,
0.1437706947,
0.0585146062,
0.5225746036,
0.1701667011,
1.0903552771,
-0.3723880947,
-0.064264521,
0.2043364942,
0.3894871771,
0.5232483149,
0.1257131398,
0.0896493345,
0.0901608467,
-0.3229817152,
-0.2063611895,
-0.6450128555,
0.6634177566,
-0.602865994,
-0.7871332169,
-0.7153983116,
-0.3041726649,
-0.3061407506,
0.2295493335,
-0.1782664061,
-0.0208654553,
-0.4448944926,
-0.1935391873,
0.8748121262,
-0.3528197408,
0.2337914109,
0.5964503884,
-0.3387251496,
-0.3895998299,
1.1413267851,
-0.4766471982,
0.3743633032,
0.0631247908,
0.1907885671,
-0.1249156371,
-0.2550480366,
-0.0569491386,
0.5243702531,
-0.6999801993,
0.0350319706,
-0.6203648448,
-0.3254898787,
-0.6910013556,
-0.6326227784,
-0.5494447351,
-0.316439718,
-0.1158381552,
0.1182278097,
-0.2858037055,
0.890699923,
-0.2780703008,
0.1865924597,
-0.4689748585,
0.3506865799,
0.2910598218,
0.5430806279,
0.2976454198,
0.0177483317,
-0.0784901604,
0.1249853373,
0.0411705598,
-0.9432929158,
0.5171537995,
0.5613476038,
0.680716455,
0.6778433323,
-0.0007008882,
0.6456274986,
-0.58769238,
0.9684013724,
0.141796276,
-0.8511471748,
0.7238836884,
-0.3342128694,
0.1237402558,
0.7384606004,
0.227910921,
-0.9205836654,
-0.4177314937,
-0.7347390652,
-0.7572002411,
0.5510346889,
-0.1362433881,
0.3810580373,
-0.1678455323,
0.5344543457,
-0.044221323,
0.4093789458,
-1.2145223618,
-0.4458468854,
-0.3789010346,
-0.1283884197,
-0.1373057663,
-0.3482173383,
-0.329012543,
-0.1597293764,
1.0124566555,
-0.3598507941,
0.5835056305,
0.2526151538,
0.2914322019,
-0.0211905334,
0.1222554147,
0.7339385748,
0.3938637376,
0.1724637747,
0.0614171997,
-0.2957704067,
-0.6255807281,
0.0225406028,
-0.3113935292,
-0.4977990389,
-0.534384191,
0.3561557233,
0.5109604001,
-0.1162761152,
-0.743321538,
0.3299263418,
-0.2544051707,
0.049747251,
-0.7283694148,
0.4088089466,
-0.1683614552,
0.4734533131,
0.2915554047,
-0.0956028253,
0.3425302505,
-1.0505626202,
0.0775450543,
0.9261729717,
-0.5763480663,
-0.2327765673,
0.8267282248,
0.1757240742,
-0.8662666082,
0.7087231278,
-0.4497403502,
-0.742195189,
0.0421624221,
0.690459609,
1.1606413126,
-0.3486543,
0.6906333566,
0.0444265082,
0.4167805016,
0.3583600819,
0.4248875082,
-0.2829174697,
-0.9350295663,
-0.2389445603,
-0.4738698304,
-0.2350710183,
-0.0080279969,
-0.745437026,
-0.2293103337,
-0.5550788045,
-0.060334608,
-0.2673749924,
-0.091524668,
-0.1875795871,
0.3927624822,
0.18066594,
0.7280396819,
-0.9658120275,
0.4229391515,
0.7739873528,
-0.0736230761,
-0.5289133191,
0.1515203416,
0.1536355019,
-1.2237321138,
0.5835822225,
-0.0051891999,
-0.5005367398,
0.1145938709,
-0.8236899972,
-0.7164484859,
0.9015482664,
-0.2882869542,
0.056623809,
-0.0028954674,
0.3686300218,
0.7326043844,
-0.5959103107,
-0.1065091267,
0.4371185601,
0.6468089223,
0.1495869905,
-0.501665771,
0.0206734333,
-0.5400688052,
0.0751979649,
0.0075891498,
-1.0369621515,
0.4860926569,
-0.3352558315,
-0.4156998992,
-0.1037776768,
0.8001716733,
0.2515149415,
0.6061882973,
0.3770222664,
0.6794983745,
0.3971602917,
-0.037797261,
0.8654564619,
-0.3651075363,
0.0113653494,
1.2790825367,
-0.5942744017,
0.5439684391,
0.4165166616,
0.0306262653,
0.5868934393,
0.1417770684,
-0.0688778311,
0.7114071846,
-0.0143364239,
-0.5063884854,
-0.1335857958,
-0.3118883669,
-0.1653168947,
0.6267178059,
0.6415550709,
-0.051983539,
0.0173684712,
-0.0942490622,
-0.0187546499,
0.5626775622,
-0.1596857458,
0.9937500358,
-0.0093418239,
-0.9257540107,
0.0952152982,
0.0567891411,
0.6424343586,
-0.7491641045,
0.0072272648,
-0.0390705317,
0.3133233488,
-0.1250849068,
-0.9068102241,
0.667304635,
-0.1744928956,
0.083458297,
-0.6990525723,
1.156208396,
-0.0715324059,
-0.4283803999,
0.333242476,
0.5271388888,
0.0590246543,
0.203727752,
-1.2196191549,
0.139010191,
0.2041021287,
-0.1748000383,
0.2070155293,
0.2930243909,
0.2375731766,
1.3685028553,
0.6147347689,
0.3218470812,
-0.0603453778,
0.1105414554,
0.7351382971,
-0.6187574267,
-0.7137730718,
-0.7696992755,
0.5642219186,
-0.136952579,
-0.1698480248,
0.7668576837,
0.5809271336,
0.7839428782,
-0.1060306504,
0.7789965272,
-0.2961696386,
0.4457314909,
-0.2414757758,
0.6670315266,
-0.3051124513,
0.083947517,
-0.3366488516,
-0.6718756557,
-0.2249640822,
1.0114276409,
-0.2893537879,
0.1990467608,
0.2483338416,
0.6404575706,
0.1796324104,
0.0475689992,
0.2934874892,
0.1282729059,
0.4746868014,
0.3868507147,
0.8402653337,
0.1085264757,
-0.1900428236,
-0.2085522562,
-0.5735086799,
0.0530455299,
-0.7594038844,
-0.666303575,
-0.5580929518,
-0.378991574,
-0.2880749404,
0.1918110102,
0.6333488822,
0.5703401566,
-0.3861157298,
-0.4190772474,
-0.2606109381,
0.0885854959,
-0.2861037552,
-0.3890396953,
-0.2875680029,
-0.2971040606,
-0.4578707218,
0.5003764033,
0.5396319032,
-0.0428699665,
-0.8745217919,
-0.181144312,
-0.4669883251,
0.4319547713,
0.501121521,
0.4843463004,
-0.6450698972,
-0.3922567964,
-0.0327013656,
0.2702386975,
-0.1484675705,
0.7688509226,
-0.7979784012,
0.3672640324,
0.0472693406,
0.3888339698,
0.1424831897,
0.2219248563,
0.6143732071,
-0.6486394405,
0.1550280452,
0.6463801265,
-0.0783555508,
0.2177524716,
-0.7284607291,
0.7789945602,
0.1455537081,
-0.7153778672,
-0.824103117,
0.9195418358,
-0.7677407265,
-0.3122003376,
1.0363100767,
0.0233975295,
-0.2691085339,
-0.0177503079,
-0.032312274,
-0.0327754766,
-0.3568551242,
1.2779974937,
0.6693008542,
-0.4230795205,
-0.1195160002,
-0.5190902948,
0.535558641,
0.4115065336,
-0.6860566735,
0.1956420094,
0.5438759923,
-0.1729854345,
0.6321949363,
1.0799233913,
0.0368514135,
-0.0280780792,
0.0514094904,
0.1261212975,
0.0105268676,
-0.5666448474,
-0.1296528876,
0.037305031,
-0.1034759581,
0.1599197686
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.