id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12641v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12641v3 | A Comprehensive Survey of Sentence Representations: From the BERT Epoch to the ChatGPT Era and Beyond | 2023-05-22T02:31:15 | 2024-02-02T07:57:05 | Abhinav Ramesh Kashyap, Thanh-Tung Nguyen, Viktor Schlegel, Stefan Winkler, See-Kiong Ng, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentence representations are a critical component in NLP applications such as
retrieval, question answering, and text classification. They capture the
meaning of a sentence, enabling machines to understand and reason over human
language. In recent years, significant progress has been made in developing
methods for learning sentence representations, including unsupervised,
supervised, and transfer learning approaches. However there is no literature
review on sentence representations till now. In this paper, we provide an
overview of the different methods for sentence representation learning,
focusing mostly on deep learning models. We provide a systematic organization
of the literature, highlighting the key contributions and challenges in this
area. Overall, our review highlights the importance of this area in natural
language processing, the progress made in sentence representation learning, and
the challenges that remain. We conclude with directions for future research,
suggesting potential avenues for improving the quality and efficiency of
sentence representations. | [
-0.2564633489,
-0.5688744783,
0.8150302768,
0.2502932549,
-0.0901944414,
0.0465884246,
-0.2757640183,
-0.5090129972,
0.0137227867,
0.5669466853,
-0.3232721686,
-0.3066816032,
-0.7267715335,
0.1030220464,
-0.2628201842,
0.6852944493,
-0.0057849726,
0.1742257476,
-0.2943167388,
0.0285430904,
-0.8166152835,
-0.9181805849,
-0.1633597314,
-0.4586135149,
0.3181156218,
-0.0523980334,
0.4168888628,
-0.0211789757,
0.5621253252,
0.2152836174,
-0.0457242578,
0.1912445575,
-0.1755991727,
0.5187859535,
0.090232715,
-0.4479557276,
0.1909709424,
0.2515307963,
0.6569277644,
1.1734303236,
-0.1270567626,
-0.3860108852,
0.024686547,
0.5937465429,
-0.5664901137,
0.5101899505,
-0.6007651687,
0.4821014702,
-0.079561621,
0.027329823,
-0.9181267619,
-0.385365665,
0.3337973058,
-0.321626991,
-0.0831147432,
0.059859708,
0.5645967126,
-0.0814872459,
-0.8989933133,
-0.6698289514,
-0.5572164059,
0.7566787004,
-0.4863577485,
0.2453527302,
0.0889202431,
0.3273938298,
-0.3905435801,
-0.9723184109,
-0.0483695567,
-0.5810115337,
-0.1637836397,
0.2106586248,
-0.2718754411,
0.3802107275,
0.0619239993,
0.5114168525,
-0.4763140976,
-0.0671102628,
-0.1189339608,
-0.2225974798,
0.5004187822,
0.1036891863,
0.4328066707,
-0.4974445105,
-0.4961000979,
-0.2054667026,
-0.5435115695,
0.1337555647,
-0.1364712268,
0.1621246785,
0.3656702042,
0.7170738578,
0.2598992586,
0.5008133054,
-0.3812117279,
0.6541711688,
0.1110802442,
-0.189058423,
-0.299893856,
-0.1597990543,
0.9008792639,
0.1175203174,
0.3233087659,
-0.3142769039,
-0.0869047418,
-0.0702602863,
0.4948458076,
-0.4990772307,
-0.1930576265,
-0.1850531101,
-0.5937353373,
0.0904057324,
0.531452477,
-0.5395028591,
-0.5880173445,
-0.1729171723,
-0.0147346836,
-0.6505141854,
0.1228079274,
0.2777802348,
-0.1780131757,
0.3030726314,
0.3471430242,
-0.89220649,
0.2609097362,
0.580704093,
0.6526872516,
0.1966134012,
0.0229343381,
-0.2053351849,
-0.0606593154,
-0.5890922546,
0.7975352407,
-0.7267345786,
-0.3461507559,
0.6455268264,
0.076076299,
-0.1634285003,
-0.323325336,
0.7262941003,
-0.5827672482,
0.3973373473,
-0.4419073164,
-1.1282981634,
-0.6296722293,
0.1137215942,
-0.7537735105,
0.6549383402,
0.0149178803,
-0.5542256832,
0.1179771051,
-0.5357845426,
-0.4374659657,
0.0802289248,
-0.1893942207,
-0.2468985617,
0.5056087375,
0.7246652842,
0.9656782746,
0.1210090742,
0.1808300465,
0.0274925139,
-0.429361254,
0.4395775497,
-0.3411146402,
0.8417700529,
0.224247247,
0.23826617,
0.0469965748,
-0.335971117,
-0.1670090407,
-0.0234806985,
-0.1107426733,
-0.0276218615,
-0.0356898084,
0.2938742936,
-0.2868467271,
0.285654664,
-0.5285493731,
0.5457702279,
-0.4294293523,
0.9693621993,
0.4103248715,
0.2961208224,
0.7018796802,
0.0705919862,
0.5371101499,
-0.0105434963,
-0.2470040917,
-0.7717450857,
-0.5715465546,
-0.63237077,
0.2731199265,
0.4299386144,
0.3491109014,
-0.4733885229,
0.5172015429,
-0.0717675388,
-0.268463403,
-0.6927929521,
-0.0794112906,
-0.1359494776,
-0.1107729301,
0.4184070826,
-0.0755288452,
-0.7220150828,
-0.7749764919,
-0.1953352541,
-0.4067148268,
0.0519288741,
0.0628592074,
0.4002684653,
-0.3363947868,
0.9003266692,
-0.4711444676,
-0.3950778544,
-0.6184554696,
0.5473484993,
0.1169694588,
0.2046861947,
0.7859908342,
-0.7423349619,
-0.3492309749,
-0.0771205723,
-0.7168248892,
0.2178832293,
-0.4401579797,
0.20641087,
0.1086907908,
0.762047112,
-0.708461225,
0.0837172419,
0.3577851057,
-0.2488981485,
0.1712057889,
-0.3664022982,
0.1066055968,
-0.8430578709,
-0.0888321996,
0.0469252802,
-0.6531787515,
-0.3025787175,
0.1587300301,
0.0759696215,
-0.3702109158,
0.019630976,
0.001063857,
-0.5391902328,
0.2182252407,
0.0101846959,
0.1496174484,
0.004288373,
0.3196203113,
-0.0440188535,
0.6463168263,
0.4541151822,
-0.1440253407,
0.4546362758,
0.211328581,
-0.4140803218,
-0.0258206036,
-0.5293326378,
0.2947158515,
-0.5535952449,
0.4971991479,
-0.8750048876,
-0.1066629738,
0.1981358528,
-0.4289417863,
0.2287977934,
-0.0105385995,
-0.6938940287,
-0.1531003416,
-0.3267989457,
-0.1394235641,
0.7778919935,
-0.0991148874,
0.3379934728,
0.3443625867,
0.0770765394,
-0.3697811067,
-0.9875671268,
0.287768364,
0.088902317,
-0.3791025877,
0.462978065,
0.3784059286,
-0.0694599599,
0.0821872652,
0.1174733713,
-0.0827328339,
-0.1753869653,
0.0287005212,
0.0327543244,
-0.1552963257,
0.5815290213,
-0.147356078,
-0.1307954788,
0.0988763273,
-0.1365502328,
0.6169197559,
-0.1252176166,
-0.1226916239,
-0.1804644912,
0.7379279137,
0.0950290188,
-0.3094201684,
0.6494119763,
0.7279554009,
-0.278749913,
-0.1681331843,
-0.4498071074,
-0.0490529388,
-0.3048205972,
0.4128212333,
0.1244025826,
-1.2059650421,
0.3489452004,
-0.1445538104,
0.0157427639,
0.3675656319,
0.2819807827,
-0.6292886734,
0.6218424439,
0.8838107586,
-0.1397477686,
0.5973044038,
-0.1425418109,
0.4407202303,
-0.7565395832,
-0.2741954327,
-0.5168293118,
-0.0824768916,
-0.733895421,
-0.5070644617,
0.1194219366,
0.2554291189,
-0.2838552594,
0.4824663103,
-0.4270178378,
0.3075658083,
0.462683171,
0.0157527905,
0.0933358073,
-0.0496199019,
0.093706511,
-0.3450001478,
-0.465023458,
-0.741943419,
0.801248014,
0.485122323,
0.5047610998,
-0.1179219037,
0.7315167785,
0.5767613053,
-0.3081213534,
-0.7659801245,
0.6056536436,
-0.4949169755,
-0.2183046341,
0.0633036047,
-0.3094796836,
-1.0856102705,
0.3442303538,
-0.1577297598,
-0.9335084558,
0.1621653736,
-0.2995524406,
-0.3756437302,
0.1245617568,
-0.8708130717,
0.7922527194,
0.0163179487,
0.3246433735,
-0.1463665217,
-0.7493893504,
-0.0899833515,
0.7468633652,
-0.2648031414,
-0.0344765261,
0.1742240638,
0.618195951,
-0.1766903549,
0.8947376013,
-0.2080961168,
-0.0525240824,
0.5130264163,
-0.0685561001,
0.2808310091,
0.1664468944,
0.0513201877,
-0.0946597755,
0.0666877478,
-0.2119436562,
-0.6935198903,
0.4130325317,
-0.5293117762,
-0.2781125307,
-0.6158818603,
-0.4462834597,
-0.2827458382,
-0.012617087,
0.0575083196,
0.2127160579,
-0.443695426,
0.5360597372,
0.7335163355,
-0.1565603763,
0.7468345165,
-0.3223043978,
-0.3729520738,
-0.2979216874,
0.3443884254,
0.1735433191,
-0.2180367857,
0.8015471101,
-0.2254880667,
-0.3670104742,
-0.5614276528,
-0.1374356002,
-0.0240509007,
-0.9260342121,
0.0179920737,
-0.6414251328,
-0.4168777466,
-0.6368706226,
-0.0417595766,
0.0364057496,
-0.3920574784,
-0.6148697734,
-0.3857213557,
0.3843019009,
1.0539098978,
0.2324018478,
0.4221102297,
-0.7411441803,
0.1511044353,
0.2359505147,
0.0787150189,
0.0718380362,
0.0635752007,
-0.0068054767,
-0.1475422531,
-0.3376917541,
-1.145591855,
0.1905683279,
0.2709680796,
0.5002074242,
0.0723263696,
0.0537635237,
0.493104279,
-0.4609071314,
1.3317617178,
0.2439326197,
-0.840043962,
0.7258101702,
-0.056714043,
0.229669407,
0.3959310353,
0.3556029499,
-1.0249305964,
-0.1523330957,
-0.3016374707,
-0.851126194,
0.3151862919,
0.3431968987,
0.7271674871,
-0.0293495469,
0.4767896831,
0.123309195,
0.1465551555,
-0.9879696965,
0.1400021017,
-0.3085542917,
-0.2953771651,
-0.0199715234,
-0.3104770184,
0.3944323063,
-0.021009462,
0.1988763809,
-0.0945189223,
0.6562877893,
0.3706985712,
-0.5588676929,
0.4411256015,
0.6100812554,
0.0120786205,
0.4154026508,
-0.2517898977,
0.0991343185,
-0.2099980563,
-0.2984260619,
-0.0595190935,
0.1859921068,
-0.023039218,
0.3446345925,
1.0097440481,
0.8193058968,
0.1853056848,
-0.5934324265,
0.6555972099,
0.1029440388,
0.1842959225,
-0.4884715676,
-0.0901763663,
0.1054702103,
0.3779017627,
0.5497175455,
-0.0213097781,
0.3124834001,
-1.0472333431,
0.0539562888,
0.2948842645,
-0.798861742,
-0.056168966,
0.3480632007,
0.0844485834,
0.1964498162,
0.9949989915,
-0.1390521079,
-0.4811469615,
0.3524389267,
0.2153171748,
0.8680810928,
0.2139588147,
0.6656928062,
0.0667816401,
0.2996678352,
0.0364487283,
0.0786740258,
-0.0725473911,
-0.7196337581,
-0.591468215,
-0.2714675367,
-0.3389990032,
-0.1386084259,
-0.6157969236,
-0.0486679859,
-0.2216649652,
-0.2094241232,
-0.0858306885,
0.2496873885,
-0.5534652472,
-0.2051117271,
0.4683510661,
0.9068668485,
-0.7753105164,
0.564348042,
1.0165468454,
-0.9213215709,
-0.2980162203,
0.1091374308,
-0.3505982459,
-0.4647090435,
0.5228538513,
0.3364991844,
0.2253658473,
-0.2091105282,
-0.8081821203,
-0.1932659298,
0.7221922278,
0.6077697873,
-0.6497570276,
-0.4322446883,
0.3823865056,
0.6958507299,
-0.6120783687,
0.3130160868,
0.255960077,
0.3489477336,
-0.1447418183,
-0.4025663435,
-0.1229660511,
-0.0522778034,
0.7172816992,
-0.1353893429,
-0.2666406631,
0.7308193445,
0.1256618202,
-0.4754628539,
0.2324186265,
0.9314031601,
0.0050199395,
-0.2031213939,
-0.0129506597,
0.2564999759,
0.8097453117,
-0.5576265454,
1.0479074717,
0.2444870919,
0.4880527556,
0.6959130764,
-0.1708498746,
0.7847851515,
0.4730066657,
-0.2023758143,
0.6677135825,
0.7802993059,
-0.250770092,
0.5842189193,
0.3107232451,
-0.012957464,
-0.5005781651,
-0.0245788228,
-0.3664045632,
0.2912825942,
0.2996894419,
-0.5536659956,
-0.4811904132,
0.505853653,
-0.0781150162,
0.452643007,
-0.2686948478,
1.0233544111,
0.3371682763,
-0.4566507041,
0.0601460449,
-0.2362921238,
0.6576859355,
-0.5418413281,
-0.4696488082,
-0.1221641898,
0.0858270302,
-0.0112129031,
-1.0787799358,
0.1686369032,
-0.2844441235,
-0.127716437,
-0.7199169397,
0.8339921832,
-0.4136554599,
-0.4345939755,
0.3795076907,
0.2388428003,
0.0075206836,
-0.1900101304,
-0.3921323717,
0.1180938184,
0.0089195305,
-0.2510993779,
-0.0812074468,
0.7047514319,
0.1319429576,
0.5799584389,
0.0150348665,
0.0279985126,
0.3026920855,
0.2258475125,
0.7167057991,
-1.0528335571,
-0.2084314227,
-0.6269185543,
0.581763804,
-0.2010721117,
-0.2320904732,
0.4451260269,
0.1971012801,
0.6469643712,
-0.2112340778,
0.8705775142,
-0.2492664158,
0.193116203,
-0.8296535015,
0.6076817513,
0.0020239619,
0.0142130563,
-0.0561993867,
-0.9216512442,
-0.588790834,
0.9514586329,
-0.1425031424,
-0.0804899707,
0.7276698351,
0.0248274151,
0.0835571885,
0.3288135827,
0.0170978848,
0.0364930481,
0.559912324,
0.6783068776,
1.0270032883,
-0.7258212566,
0.4456088543,
-0.0210955516,
0.2575052679,
-0.3863129318,
-0.823276341,
-0.7723279595,
-0.938138783,
-0.3054287434,
0.1023971215,
0.2271986455,
0.9788137674,
0.7441365719,
-0.7787848711,
-0.0934271291,
-0.3496444225,
-0.0280671436,
-0.3953571618,
-0.1365515292,
0.446972996,
-1.0633801222,
-0.5942440033,
0.3604061604,
0.1968880594,
-0.1219612733,
-0.5311146975,
0.2866045535,
-0.3934112787,
-0.1967795938,
0.9232646823,
-0.1391886175,
-0.7381238341,
-0.3549731076,
0.0549152605,
-0.1747105271,
0.386515975,
1.0861723423,
-0.9219066501,
0.3755756021,
0.7244594097,
0.7603945732,
0.5257445574,
-0.4276775718,
0.7560518384,
-0.8737390041,
0.0352954976,
0.8103459477,
0.7441995144,
0.4814975262,
-0.0936008021,
0.390855521,
-0.148485586,
-0.4653809965,
-0.4933003783,
0.4097717106,
-1.219483614,
-0.3700312972,
0.6453446746,
-0.4259437621,
0.0360162593,
-0.0192407947,
-0.3827665746,
0.1126638725,
-0.5875645876,
0.5389294028,
1.1003005505,
-0.2186259031,
-0.8060924411,
-0.6622611284,
0.2108308375,
0.2561528087,
-0.6541692019,
0.2473403662,
0.5218137503,
-0.3852951229,
0.3385509253,
0.2151573896,
-0.3699515462,
-0.2135962248,
-0.4230169952,
0.0073063956,
0.2879203856,
-0.1136083081,
-0.320399493,
0.5748628378,
0.0329356529,
-0.0817129835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12634v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12634v2 | Data-efficient Active Learning for Structured Prediction with Partial Annotation and Self-Training | 2023-05-22T01:58:42 | 2023-10-19T02:13:51 | Zhisong Zhang, Emma Strubell, Eduard Hovy | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work we propose a pragmatic method that reduces the annotation cost
for structured label spaces using active learning. Our approach leverages
partial annotation, which reduces labeling costs for structured outputs by
selecting only the most informative sub-structures for annotation. We also
utilize self-training to incorporate the current model's automatic predictions
as pseudo-labels for un-annotated sub-structures. A key challenge in
effectively combining partial annotation with self-training to reduce
annotation cost is determining which sub-structures to select to label. To
address this challenge, we adopt an error estimator to adaptively decide the
partial selection ratio according to the current model's capability. In
evaluations spanning four structured prediction tasks, we show that our
combination of partial annotation and self-training using an adaptive selection
ratio reduces annotation cost over strong full annotation baselines under a
fair comparison scheme that takes reading time into consideration. | [
0.1537526399,
-0.6936969161,
0.3083576262,
0.1942650527,
-0.1148970574,
-0.0611028597,
-0.0305180773,
-0.6071189642,
0.1401118934,
0.1640933454,
-0.4468653202,
-0.2747469544,
-0.0203501098,
0.2305356711,
-0.0485048816,
1.0275499821,
-0.4442940354,
-0.0551433787,
-0.274566412,
-0.0555677749,
-0.3079631031,
-0.5391716361,
-0.4478852749,
-0.2709188759,
0.707469821,
0.1777323484,
0.5053884387,
1.0892255306,
0.4859984219,
0.2334603816,
-0.203001529,
0.1863009781,
-0.1940680295,
0.1028489619,
0.1046435535,
-0.2938310206,
-0.8419609666,
0.3041701019,
0.8383489251,
0.9379878044,
-0.1172460094,
0.2374962121,
-0.0733212382,
0.5979000926,
-0.7236299515,
0.5315701365,
-0.4583020806,
0.4429448545,
-0.1239030361,
0.1184821725,
-0.5758575797,
0.1012407765,
0.0229366738,
-1.1096196175,
0.1208208799,
0.1096654236,
0.7257863879,
0.7178270817,
-0.1341035366,
0.0398599803,
-0.592063427,
0.5116576552,
-0.1550147831,
0.3525753319,
0.6779277921,
0.1934286356,
0.1860025227,
-1.0550230742,
-0.3152491748,
-0.1788130552,
-0.1761938632,
0.5433228016,
-0.00985472,
0.356898278,
0.3587135971,
0.2588778734,
-0.2256403118,
-0.1257713735,
-0.6406539083,
-0.3976010382,
0.605730474,
-0.3686210811,
-0.1481380314,
-0.081582427,
-0.7015898824,
0.0283523742,
-0.4083830416,
-0.0404126942,
0.3703086972,
0.3985880017,
0.2358965427,
0.4319219887,
-0.1325628608,
0.8356143832,
0.1078218669,
0.0300477669,
0.5817400217,
-0.367018193,
-0.4490174055,
0.2535681129,
0.4894890785,
-0.1527960598,
0.0476362631,
-0.2277506888,
-0.3546232283,
0.0658044741,
0.3961999118,
-0.4098328352,
-0.9360587001,
-0.0802105367,
-0.1963717937,
-0.220401898,
-0.1270116121,
-0.1617916673,
-0.2400642037,
-0.2039881349,
0.6012820601,
-0.0680823177,
0.1820069104,
-0.1298110187,
0.013381457,
-0.356734246,
0.813516736,
-0.2860287726,
0.2568249404,
-0.0876095816,
0.9657260776,
-0.055500932,
0.0170610286,
-0.5181404352,
0.5308811069,
-0.2749836743,
0.8511115909,
-0.5523717999,
-0.1472507864,
-0.333646059,
-0.0551053435,
-0.0854302347,
-0.3608980179,
0.5851950049,
-0.2564326525,
-0.0145644872,
0.0154806376,
-0.3063656092,
-0.3054901361,
0.1432575136,
-1.0675771236,
1.1431584358,
0.3011504412,
-0.9011260271,
0.5032345653,
-0.648203969,
-0.636538744,
0.2811856568,
0.0875108913,
-0.9755481482,
-0.1844367981,
0.1321744025,
0.4899605215,
0.4808163345,
0.1064841077,
-0.4978511631,
-0.3371003866,
0.1820235252,
-0.0533781461,
0.1468874961,
0.2810112238,
-0.4505213499,
0.3864227533,
-1.0010348558,
-0.1454633772,
-0.0505610295,
-0.7525631785,
-0.2890563607,
0.0972942039,
-0.2911123931,
0.0953109488,
0.2669579387,
-0.5055915117,
0.4752950966,
-0.44849509,
0.1378152519,
0.9333264828,
-0.1485356688,
0.8333176374,
0.0075558904,
0.4299907982,
0.0322245397,
0.324107945,
0.0071132588,
-0.2425574362,
-0.8320081234,
-0.7084522843,
0.8221540451,
0.4727171063,
-0.7651450634,
0.2359366268,
0.1787308156,
-0.4550265074,
-0.487601608,
0.3694583774,
0.5774822235,
0.6186264753,
0.6014594436,
-0.1857677549,
-0.5908677578,
-1.0647889376,
-0.0358067155,
-0.3469882905,
0.2902230024,
0.1661061347,
0.436086297,
0.1213719398,
0.7718417645,
-0.5222504735,
-0.5272165537,
-0.0637334511,
0.0393345878,
0.1330934614,
0.3744427264,
0.4604819119,
-0.9407666326,
-0.6891716719,
-0.1777521819,
-0.4159818292,
-0.1302785277,
-0.2844642103,
-0.1516202986,
-0.0086145727,
0.1944343448,
-0.3384509385,
0.7172555923,
0.305752784,
-0.2203295231,
0.1340641528,
-0.2028642148,
-0.3967632353,
-0.669347167,
0.0038931416,
0.3667433262,
-0.2550620735,
-0.3648850918,
-0.4845514297,
0.4161801934,
0.0616434589,
-0.1549452543,
0.617353797,
-0.8605616689,
-0.0946578607,
-0.1529202759,
-0.1858043969,
-0.0062718606,
0.725957334,
0.3933452964,
0.6955148578,
0.5233499408,
-0.5107599497,
0.1792291403,
0.4510441422,
-0.1627044678,
-0.243520841,
-0.4789197445,
0.056535203,
-0.1611680686,
0.814751327,
-1.14191854,
-0.1866861582,
0.6159926057,
-0.2671460211,
0.5292348862,
-0.2858914435,
-0.2191458642,
-0.3283267021,
-0.2150788754,
0.2597512305,
0.1436385065,
-0.3858957291,
0.6028161645,
0.4615756273,
-0.0634853318,
-0.5536369681,
-0.7432190776,
-0.3163946569,
0.0492259525,
-0.2115241289,
0.4787347019,
-0.0873674527,
0.0326859392,
0.0995020494,
-0.5891959071,
-0.0845739096,
0.4720217586,
0.5054976344,
0.1807467639,
0.169654265,
0.3335206509,
0.2009769976,
-0.1897438765,
-0.191752255,
-0.4106764495,
-0.241461277,
0.0137703242,
-0.0472406894,
-0.4086262882,
-0.1481621414,
-0.089810282,
-0.3914621472,
0.9201213121,
0.2500063777,
-0.4705417454,
-0.6416938305,
-0.2170128971,
0.0960762277,
-0.4010037184,
0.4374106228,
-0.5336214304,
-0.4232700467,
0.3703215718,
-0.0341228135,
0.3876908422,
0.5236442685,
0.4106898606,
-0.3212607205,
0.9226163626,
0.4070840478,
0.5344903469,
0.8389519453,
-0.4556530714,
0.1130950674,
-0.5938770175,
-0.5611312389,
-0.3322125077,
-0.5573500395,
-0.1219286695,
-0.6478793621,
0.413877815,
0.1376667619,
-0.0893791616,
0.2249278426,
-0.8616836071,
0.1593670398,
0.5814819932,
0.369281888,
0.0068524145,
0.0971379653,
0.0989483818,
0.1582416594,
-0.9430177808,
-0.3516549766,
1.0211555958,
0.4683259726,
0.7036725879,
-0.1405983865,
0.4742071033,
0.5400441885,
0.656488657,
-0.7325206995,
0.2938534021,
0.0479821973,
-0.7814217806,
-0.3104546964,
-0.7267174721,
-0.7337811589,
0.2192516327,
-0.3136467338,
-0.0725282505,
0.2957746983,
0.5575175881,
-0.4682559073,
0.229482919,
-0.8311000466,
0.8258286119,
-0.3301741481,
-0.4124530256,
0.2165578157,
-0.6524077654,
-0.1373238415,
-0.452925235,
0.2599863112,
-0.07150729,
-0.2562249303,
1.2500693798,
-0.111017257,
1.1756498814,
-0.4837198853,
0.3350214064,
0.572614193,
0.0294278264,
0.4553234577,
-0.1015560776,
-0.3534949124,
-0.0459261686,
-0.3132198155,
-0.6113095284,
-0.3849049211,
0.1085236073,
-0.8826856017,
-0.2041590214,
-0.678016603,
-0.4217966497,
-0.2155105174,
-0.0021614262,
-0.1357852519,
0.4107964337,
0.3176258802,
0.2165253907,
0.5103086829,
0.1957246214,
0.4141605496,
0.2843555212,
0.4798537195,
-0.7637937069,
0.4543311298,
0.6405386925,
-0.0366972461,
0.4080194533,
0.2592417896,
-0.5238144398,
-0.7865601778,
-0.105256699,
0.2286760509,
-0.8755621314,
-0.7907171249,
-0.6560070515,
-0.0369300656,
-0.359515816,
-0.1836883426,
-0.2815758288,
-0.8390875459,
-0.2802117765,
-0.6699101329,
0.0972259939,
0.5452635288,
-0.0586988889,
0.547940731,
-0.3827601671,
0.0171223246,
0.2235143781,
0.3478839993,
-0.2067335993,
-0.7518897057,
-0.5158091784,
-0.0850644186,
-0.3324401677,
-0.9570456147,
0.1662050933,
0.648198247,
0.8827226162,
0.0661783814,
0.4825903773,
0.6826327443,
-0.4209970832,
0.385617584,
0.3430756629,
-0.7282539606,
0.8237789273,
-0.1294030845,
-0.0977945402,
0.564576745,
0.5072603226,
0.2735910416,
-0.0876066685,
-0.787599504,
-1.1791211367,
0.858002007,
0.4043800235,
-0.1835270971,
0.093609944,
0.8396341801,
0.2275149822,
0.0706038773,
-1.3422579765,
-0.2529036403,
-0.3911027014,
-0.3751616478,
0.1430264711,
-0.1613306552,
-0.1947322786,
-0.4904405773,
1.0789495707,
-0.420948565,
0.0361680165,
0.5188500881,
-0.1370139271,
-0.3372723758,
-0.1626660526,
0.0391032733,
0.7532043457,
-0.1794024408,
0.2138621658,
0.3274762928,
-0.2606009245,
0.0220518485,
0.2459421456,
-0.2955976725,
-0.019044878,
0.5664465427,
1.1878221035,
0.268520087,
-0.2332666218,
0.4670294523,
0.0450514443,
-0.3369526267,
-0.4139303565,
0.1287436336,
-0.2666240036,
0.2810279727,
0.4469879568,
0.0752933398,
0.1876505166,
-0.4056950808,
0.2754432261,
0.0167342629,
-0.6255096793,
-0.4727827013,
0.8172709346,
0.4407178462,
-0.0907855108,
0.480204761,
-0.1035802886,
-0.6015484333,
0.5362607837,
0.4750536382,
0.6181558967,
-0.1842083335,
0.2264054269,
0.5530577302,
0.0557600521,
-0.1841308177,
-0.0262656715,
-0.4024053812,
-0.4352943003,
-0.5757927299,
-0.9951055646,
-0.5015115738,
-0.2701095641,
-0.5844882131,
0.171365872,
-0.6739335656,
-0.3527530432,
0.1752686799,
0.5196741223,
-0.2801271081,
0.6059401631,
0.4269883335,
0.8985443115,
-1.0413349867,
0.843460083,
1.408192873,
-0.5280070901,
-0.8895798922,
-0.3675709367,
-0.58181566,
-0.4473748505,
0.5288125277,
0.2931781411,
0.2249429375,
-0.1192523912,
-0.5318531394,
-0.667740643,
1.0372389555,
0.3628543913,
-0.7142224312,
-0.1487618089,
-0.6693855524,
0.4037167728,
-0.1180745512,
0.0496180989,
0.0536250733,
0.5339486599,
0.4900816679,
-0.969876647,
0.0022945141,
-0.4079464674,
-0.4002823234,
0.3827446699,
-0.6342017651,
0.638361752,
0.0357425548,
-0.2067039609,
-0.1306182891,
1.1978789568,
0.2108706385,
0.5965532064,
0.7129116058,
0.2596643865,
0.8277488351,
-0.1987856925,
0.8511838317,
-0.1087589115,
0.4581747353,
0.8964425921,
-0.2165422291,
0.5796013474,
0.3199183643,
-0.2325664014,
0.2504708469,
1.0544089079,
-0.2259771526,
0.669074893,
0.1815998256,
-0.0413966104,
-0.6688379645,
0.1406570077,
-0.0609110817,
0.2642980516,
0.1332666427,
-0.2246605456,
0.0516767502,
-0.0918915197,
0.0007813742,
0.0948438644,
-0.4225707054,
0.8458009958,
-0.0520100296,
-0.5151932836,
0.2262061983,
-0.0529849306,
0.2786591649,
-0.7926934361,
-0.2162996382,
-0.0726476833,
0.2265923172,
-0.3394511938,
-0.6637806296,
0.17949453,
-0.267901957,
-0.1628454477,
-0.7387269735,
0.8089712262,
-0.4423810542,
-0.5901936293,
0.2156455219,
0.2105129063,
-0.0134733301,
-0.1238912866,
-0.8033934832,
-0.1676305681,
0.087466456,
-0.5307989717,
0.177836597,
0.4329390228,
-0.3111843467,
0.458301872,
0.7545791864,
0.3463651538,
0.1028083637,
-0.2633686662,
1.0875751972,
-0.5324605703,
-0.7576228976,
-0.369161129,
0.5121230483,
-0.1559244841,
-0.0857086629,
0.4840689003,
0.6901426911,
0.8138917089,
0.0852776989,
0.7665176988,
-0.0084122093,
0.4029840529,
-0.4828337431,
0.4443294406,
-0.7339064479,
0.2231972367,
-0.0981851667,
-1.1664834023,
-0.4178504646,
1.2251360416,
-0.4928439856,
0.1592884213,
0.491777271,
0.1718531996,
-0.0691170022,
-0.2471370697,
0.2056661099,
0.2948881686,
-0.0493075959,
0.2583069205,
0.7527365088,
-0.3109973669,
0.6091627479,
-0.630653441,
-0.494245559,
0.032859657,
-0.6515374184,
-0.8503326774,
-0.5758283138,
-0.8662406206,
-0.3524041176,
0.1224007905,
0.488240242,
0.8452016711,
-0.67665869,
0.2030664533,
0.2110315859,
-0.121211946,
-0.2640377879,
-0.1371324658,
0.7422362566,
-0.2402739078,
-0.5566684604,
0.5225034952,
0.211522162,
0.0424278677,
0.092070587,
0.0856322944,
-0.4527240396,
-0.0299512036,
0.3013335466,
0.2798269689,
-0.3814560175,
-0.221859619,
-0.3275618851,
-0.0009741532,
0.2395742685,
0.4994111061,
-1.0003507137,
0.4699236751,
0.4752181768,
0.4468570948,
0.8276382685,
0.3609611392,
0.2380805016,
-1.0394370556,
0.2542136908,
0.5232577324,
0.3604271114,
0.3185821772,
-0.5200197697,
0.9808023572,
0.5404090285,
-0.302275151,
-0.9699817896,
-0.0139938332,
-1.0017259121,
-0.4291107357,
1.0477442741,
-0.5617285967,
-0.7719407678,
-0.138356477,
-0.1534542143,
0.5471515059,
-0.2696616948,
0.6549871564,
0.321283251,
-0.4763407707,
0.0731204078,
-0.4481756985,
0.5187546015,
0.3796404898,
-0.5989201665,
0.050531134,
0.8059366345,
0.1741595119,
0.2701550126,
0.5519320369,
0.2550373971,
0.224529773,
0.0216564164,
0.2793683112,
-0.6360192299,
-0.8744110465,
-0.0083513632,
0.3654082417,
-0.0266273431,
-0.404270947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12628v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12628v1 | Duplex Diffusion Models Improve Speech-to-Speech Translation | 2023-05-22T01:39:40 | 2023-05-22T01:39:40 | Xianchao Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech-to-speech translation is a typical sequence-to-sequence learning task
that naturally has two directions. How to effectively leverage bidirectional
supervision signals to produce high-fidelity audio for both directions?
Existing approaches either train two separate models or a multitask-learned
model with low efficiency and inferior performance. In this paper, we propose a
duplex diffusion model that applies diffusion probabilistic models to both
sides of a reversible duplex Conformer, so that either end can simultaneously
input and output a distinct language's speech. Our model enables reversible
speech translation by simply flipping the input and output ends. Experiments
show that our model achieves the first success of reversible speech translation
with significant improvements of ASR-BLEU scores compared with a list of
state-of-the-art baselines. | [
-0.1741928905,
-0.7101740837,
0.4684431851,
0.5418313742,
-0.5469290018,
-0.2494502068,
0.0601315461,
-0.0856423452,
0.1982876062,
0.7375816703,
-0.4355431497,
-0.5036705136,
-1.0461456776,
-0.1813013703,
-0.8546628952,
0.9787011147,
0.2044970989,
0.3897346556,
-0.0719361007,
-0.0639878362,
-0.3726552129,
-0.1779386103,
-1.0518548489,
-0.6640428901,
0.4100806117,
0.389116019,
0.6338159442,
0.1938441098,
0.0785285607,
0.263499707,
-0.1037837192,
-0.2516974509,
-0.3962503076,
0.1271952689,
-0.1932039857,
-0.1871870458,
-0.637703836,
0.1674371511,
0.9770234823,
0.9310126305,
-0.5643011332,
-0.0121539813,
0.1242164075,
1.0171515942,
-0.2039088458,
-0.1808761209,
-0.1859118938,
-0.0840114355,
-0.0657729357,
-0.0354804508,
-0.4143071473,
-0.5231571198,
0.275269419,
-0.4349268675,
0.1240782067,
-0.4641788304,
0.1748038679,
0.2362594157,
-0.7208330035,
0.2227822244,
-0.8528015018,
0.4702960849,
-0.884809196,
0.9822503328,
0.2152498215,
0.302212745,
-0.1556385756,
-0.70552212,
-0.6652145982,
0.1291433424,
0.1874567121,
0.4154050648,
-0.0659680068,
-0.1602782607,
-0.1222761497,
0.0726230294,
-0.5819354653,
0.0332431197,
-0.3399580121,
0.1844591349,
0.7800606489,
-0.1588867456,
0.056285847,
0.2900871336,
-0.3067756593,
-0.1609708816,
-0.4893105626,
0.0368185639,
0.5765728951,
0.1679954529,
-0.150255695,
0.3770285249,
-0.17531012,
0.5184574723,
0.3926433623,
-0.1737300903,
0.4833963215,
-0.5389127731,
-0.1657553166,
0.0624513403,
0.5503468513,
0.1224453077,
0.1580125391,
-0.390634805,
-0.1280504018,
-0.3551564515,
0.3399050832,
-0.6343756318,
-0.3089673519,
0.4114745259,
-0.2899526656,
-0.0988133326,
-0.0681904778,
-0.4551084042,
-0.1196167991,
-0.4659070671,
0.6272219419,
-0.2094290853,
-0.627279222,
0.4180143178,
-0.3372222185,
0.2568143308,
0.3387927413,
-0.5860702991,
0.2073870003,
0.5952814221,
0.9143238068,
-0.4460332096,
-0.418777138,
-0.8101100326,
0.2627744973,
-0.2486736327,
0.7084318399,
-0.4082890153,
-0.6434206367,
-0.0956944823,
0.0339729413,
-0.1960912794,
-0.4481601119,
0.4264831841,
-0.6656507254,
0.1989507377,
-0.0366770066,
-0.1669354588,
-0.4096655846,
-0.5018603206,
-0.4441046119,
0.4224823117,
-0.249010548,
-0.5518251657,
0.1343034655,
-0.3424077928,
-0.9021627903,
-0.233620435,
0.1802575439,
-0.775700748,
0.1798712462,
-0.094619751,
0.2280912995,
0.0612937249,
0.2656683028,
-0.0728559047,
-0.273971647,
0.2591598332,
-0.5126898289,
1.020301342,
-0.0558932684,
-0.0219059065,
0.1799998134,
-0.6032425165,
-0.3108404577,
0.0992013589,
-0.6847870946,
-0.2017693371,
0.0222102106,
0.1962166429,
0.208796367,
-0.059714362,
-0.4773733616,
-0.004218739,
-0.4861659706,
0.2411059886,
0.3122593462,
-0.0502888747,
0.8005259037,
-0.4205267727,
0.255399704,
0.5276778936,
-0.1138488948,
0.178091839,
-0.7156969905,
-0.5376860499,
-0.2554846406,
0.1942153126,
0.7806714773,
-0.4778877795,
0.2106099725,
-0.2391357571,
-0.4042254388,
-0.7463694811,
0.1200129017,
0.3356232941,
0.6391464472,
0.575746417,
-0.7336322069,
-0.3282693326,
-0.7368550301,
-0.2522083521,
0.0316616558,
-0.0567470379,
-0.0913742483,
0.3072069287,
-0.4031137526,
0.5394918323,
-0.2583563626,
-0.3745273352,
-0.2081118673,
0.5802786946,
0.24564372,
0.6325957179,
0.0707485825,
-0.958073318,
-0.3078251183,
-0.1214223281,
-0.302921921,
-0.3097436428,
-0.1464883238,
-0.2007140219,
0.3194918334,
0.5071184039,
-0.4915636182,
0.4385933876,
0.7719578743,
-0.169334963,
0.5021463633,
-0.371483922,
0.1850556731,
-1.135299921,
0.1330344081,
-0.1427538991,
-0.5237511992,
-0.9652757645,
-0.256013006,
0.0176084936,
0.0945315212,
-0.4479729831,
0.0548918992,
-0.156434074,
-0.2769791782,
-0.4808872044,
0.3778084517,
0.0634314641,
0.304055959,
0.3895946741,
0.8601669073,
0.4676715732,
-0.5651846528,
0.3347718716,
0.3950922787,
-0.2488760799,
0.6508563161,
-0.8271405101,
0.2008211017,
-0.2159821838,
0.4304458499,
-1.5894516706,
0.2095760107,
0.0283878949,
-0.6548576355,
0.5553337336,
-0.333704561,
-0.1802205741,
-0.1341549903,
-0.036371652,
0.4935869277,
0.606051147,
-0.5116375089,
0.532402277,
0.4216047227,
-0.5411119461,
-0.4944020808,
-0.8781383038,
-0.1525291651,
-0.0911333561,
-0.75629884,
0.4068148136,
0.0331547111,
0.0511891991,
-0.3877590597,
-0.1579080075,
-0.1139643714,
-0.0690049604,
0.3626598418,
-0.0067831944,
-0.1273545027,
0.0962777436,
0.4253968894,
-0.2875595987,
0.2154230028,
-0.6014665961,
0.2776482105,
0.4633415043,
-0.3752734065,
-0.6470940113,
0.7137901783,
0.640147984,
-0.2368421853,
0.6834512353,
0.5423169136,
0.097110644,
-0.1680259556,
-0.4700465798,
-0.1917969733,
-0.4131993055,
0.4870330393,
-0.3020372689,
-0.3499156237,
0.1236113906,
-0.2140295357,
0.2998030484,
-0.0872525945,
0.3926503062,
-0.2695260048,
1.0398956537,
0.4698057473,
0.267842263,
0.5836212039,
-0.3074536622,
0.360152334,
-1.0065528154,
-0.0451233238,
-0.2564277351,
-0.2350238711,
-0.2608700991,
-0.5805734992,
0.3780626357,
0.2923713028,
-0.0391443446,
0.4726997912,
-0.2315243632,
0.1885409206,
0.7773076296,
0.1292552054,
0.6163645983,
0.0710380003,
0.0060730572,
0.3293426037,
-0.3854923546,
-0.4677248299,
0.8947049379,
0.4191645384,
0.5076185465,
0.5230687857,
0.9367688298,
0.079473272,
0.1759404093,
-0.5391801596,
0.4132888317,
-0.580454886,
-0.2024840117,
-0.457916975,
-0.3131656647,
-0.7789854407,
0.4963781536,
0.0157714318,
-0.2030612826,
0.2052285522,
0.2745249867,
-0.4043399692,
0.0237411335,
-0.7108522058,
0.7604342699,
0.0820599496,
-0.4056873918,
-0.484821409,
-0.5903276801,
0.2689623237,
-0.2599870265,
0.1747467667,
0.1488881558,
0.1157164723,
0.9257999659,
-0.0678280517,
0.7724481821,
-0.3368793428,
-0.3680125475,
0.061020162,
0.1825624853,
0.4495824873,
0.298039794,
-0.0419580154,
0.4213139713,
0.0340842158,
-0.266459167,
-0.3483861089,
0.6827366948,
-0.7098408341,
-1.0205943584,
-0.0327558294,
-0.4769176543,
-0.2336381227,
0.0819150582,
0.317528218,
0.1797544956,
-0.1873407066,
-0.156535551,
0.5555263758,
-0.0625226796,
0.3643589318,
0.9450089931,
-0.2759656906,
-0.3735265732,
0.6422539949,
0.2735400498,
0.6637971997,
0.1653957218,
0.1006363109,
-0.4771572351,
-0.689181447,
-0.3819846213,
0.5857765675,
-0.3957026303,
0.1594396383,
-0.6981179714,
-0.3289281428,
-0.8425714374,
-0.1819347143,
-0.618539691,
-0.6435591578,
-0.3029850721,
-0.1015936807,
0.021730233,
0.5519145131,
-0.4428269565,
0.4200927615,
-0.4270208478,
0.5752131939,
0.7701228857,
0.219497636,
-0.0853007585,
-1.3325129747,
0.0327474475,
0.3815937638,
-0.3821683228,
-1.0081096888,
0.5530851483,
0.0483113453,
0.2241075933,
0.2532515824,
-0.1857428253,
0.5803753138,
-0.7455939054,
0.4071972966,
0.3598414361,
-0.8971898556,
0.4949753582,
-0.1602532864,
0.5315466523,
0.1508912593,
0.289986372,
-0.5348362327,
-0.3469396532,
-0.139759779,
-0.7695121169,
0.646658361,
0.1204674616,
0.0475696884,
0.1606417298,
0.0042936536,
0.2264128774,
0.1019876525,
-0.3669169247,
-0.2332658321,
-0.4841535091,
0.0428966172,
-0.3401541114,
-0.1305664331,
-0.0623591803,
-0.2625059485,
0.8782716393,
0.2622585595,
0.2071902454,
0.2181209028,
-0.0130240275,
-0.2698612213,
0.4012845159,
0.6636359692,
0.2983899117,
-0.2648128271,
0.2111247331,
0.1104480252,
-0.5085413456,
0.2571808696,
0.3804286718,
-0.0690011233,
0.0443017632,
0.1300590485,
0.6393615603,
0.1049074009,
-0.0049386676,
0.6792724729,
0.0907246321,
-0.3342914283,
-0.4332529902,
-0.1776388437,
0.616949141,
0.5116062164,
0.1584301889,
0.1872291565,
0.3295887411,
-0.2244848907,
0.3622631133,
0.4073279202,
-0.0992903039,
-0.382989496,
0.8496517539,
0.5380375981,
-0.6252543926,
0.5862514973,
0.0756917149,
-0.2093554884,
0.4548439085,
0.7917878032,
1.0584688187,
-0.5631604791,
0.3467607796,
0.1666079164,
-0.1780982614,
-0.4242810905,
0.218687281,
-0.3821552694,
-0.6149126887,
-0.3331202865,
-0.5491973162,
-0.2359699905,
-0.2466371506,
-0.727730751,
0.0583545789,
0.0223310292,
-0.2129776776,
0.2577826977,
-0.4368110597,
-0.4844658375,
-0.0228570607,
0.3297200799,
0.7017099857,
-0.9369865656,
1.4355199337,
0.4451110959,
-0.4347178638,
-0.129156068,
0.0505540594,
-0.1000257209,
-0.5876262784,
0.8484090567,
0.0374354683,
-0.7652121782,
0.3366471231,
-0.2567572594,
-0.7211744189,
0.988948822,
0.0942455158,
-0.7731334567,
-0.0549072437,
0.265838474,
0.3869739771,
-0.2754295468,
-0.1013151407,
0.6472871304,
0.221930176,
0.2764086723,
-0.9466243982,
-0.3325258493,
0.2143246979,
0.1867022514,
0.1865215003,
-0.4899956882,
0.6366802454,
-0.6196819544,
-0.5670039058,
-0.1276058704,
0.7062484622,
0.1553308368,
0.4772980511,
0.487422049,
0.6618048549,
0.2321477532,
0.1157083362,
0.6814005971,
0.0199854299,
0.094250448,
1.4119180441,
-0.4111328125,
1.2405415773,
0.7730070949,
-0.1673897058,
0.5055515766,
-0.1932271123,
0.4746804833,
0.8322066069,
-0.0161012374,
-0.2511033416,
-0.4603766501,
0.1415371895,
-0.3154703975,
0.317257762,
0.187393412,
-0.3930408657,
-0.07558579,
0.2584823966,
-0.226497829,
0.2284423411,
-0.0064921728,
0.8031083345,
0.1716340482,
-0.674703002,
0.4594019353,
-0.035023801,
0.5632991791,
-0.432992965,
-0.1301235557,
-0.5561209321,
0.2613834143,
-0.1955658644,
-0.9617177844,
0.5773020983,
-0.3284684122,
-0.3394801915,
-0.3736252785,
0.1708221436,
-1.0037907362,
-0.3645926714,
0.5267447829,
0.440605402,
0.0832994729,
0.0022647257,
-0.4388991892,
-0.2207098007,
-0.137968421,
-0.2768577337,
0.1371343434,
0.2028685659,
0.3754703104,
0.6106322408,
0.6915768385,
0.2129750252,
0.1345620751,
0.2938807011,
0.4387291968,
-0.4607980549,
-0.5587228537,
-0.5157458782,
0.5020262003,
0.0877535567,
-0.0284658335,
0.5651898384,
0.4110099673,
0.8014881015,
-0.1122708097,
0.6721464396,
0.5098655224,
0.8214137554,
-0.3950510919,
0.6924884915,
-0.3629954159,
0.2521713376,
-0.134741053,
-0.5439549088,
-0.2189825326,
0.7673864365,
-0.5238500237,
-0.0598332062,
0.3747340143,
0.8564694524,
-0.2868928313,
0.0508745871,
0.5131555796,
0.2426639497,
0.2987581789,
0.727252841,
0.51971066,
-0.7501263618,
0.4346179366,
-0.259005785,
-0.2401553243,
-0.1025382578,
-0.5160705447,
-0.7660372257,
-0.8196520209,
-0.6197024584,
-0.324945122,
0.2721635699,
0.3269475102,
0.8604195118,
-0.8296457529,
-0.4094349742,
-0.1260518283,
0.1677940637,
-0.5951213837,
-0.1349622011,
0.1556825489,
-0.0870458856,
-0.6773466468,
0.5871055722,
0.28069067,
0.321113646,
-0.1237040311,
-0.1443699896,
-0.4402085543,
0.424348861,
0.6044169068,
0.2425088882,
-0.6767788529,
-0.0623365305,
-0.4784249663,
-0.2152986228,
-0.0146175772,
0.5727223754,
-0.7868759632,
0.3563300967,
0.6375382543,
0.3765407801,
0.5799487829,
0.2619473934,
0.6226943135,
-0.5555104613,
-0.0332201533,
-0.1049692482,
0.213110581,
0.2838037908,
-0.1612853408,
0.2746320665,
0.1808797717,
-0.7344796062,
-0.4131403863,
0.373503238,
-1.0661315918,
-0.3315149248,
1.2871086597,
-0.1012692004,
0.0751405433,
-0.3330801427,
-0.2461770177,
0.6224981546,
-0.3408817053,
0.7262253165,
0.3277027309,
-0.021952685,
-0.160419777,
-0.3130360246,
0.2788288295,
0.665400207,
-0.2600553036,
0.3594837487,
0.3018936515,
0.6309464574,
0.0102643399,
0.4370515049,
-0.1750114262,
0.4723750353,
-0.1203419864,
-0.1631666869,
-0.2190606445,
-0.3287024498,
-0.7581612468,
0.0423383489,
-0.1616079807,
-0.4727004468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12627v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12627v1 | MvP: Multi-view Prompting Improves Aspect Sentiment Tuple Prediction | 2023-05-22T01:32:50 | 2023-05-22T01:32:50 | Zhibin Gou, Qingyan Guo, Yujiu Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative methods greatly promote aspect-based sentiment analysis via
generating a sequence of sentiment elements in a specified format. However,
existing studies usually predict sentiment elements in a fixed order, which
ignores the effect of the interdependence of the elements in a sentiment tuple
and the diversity of language expression on the results. In this work, we
propose Multi-view Prompting (MvP) that aggregates sentiment elements generated
in different orders, leveraging the intuition of human-like problem-solving
processes from different views. Specifically, MvP introduces element order
prompts to guide the language model to generate multiple sentiment tuples, each
with a different element order, and then selects the most reasonable tuples by
voting. MvP can naturally model multi-view and multi-task as permutations and
combinations of elements, respectively, outperforming previous task-specific
designed methods on multiple ABSA tasks with a single model. Extensive
experiments show that MvP significantly advances the state-of-the-art
performance on 10 datasets of 4 benchmark tasks, and performs quite effectively
in low-resource settings. Detailed evaluation verified the effectiveness,
flexibility, and cross-task transferability of MvP. | [
-0.6378583312,
-0.5966673493,
0.5593019724,
0.7823670506,
-0.4461830556,
0.209221825,
0.1284360886,
0.0096715949,
0.2675382197,
0.0812908933,
-0.5260857344,
-0.273773849,
-0.6554589868,
0.19447577,
-0.0900136009,
0.850602746,
0.3677292466,
0.1720178127,
-0.213479057,
-0.1351385117,
-0.5840415955,
-0.376601547,
-0.4425693154,
-0.2228538245,
0.6743396521,
0.7872267365,
0.5199056864,
0.0653657466,
0.0102841267,
0.3112974763,
-0.1262557209,
0.677521348,
0.029414054,
0.4144078195,
-0.0145431869,
-0.2118958086,
-0.563275218,
0.0803902298,
0.3689650893,
0.5823705792,
-0.0526897572,
0.1298394352,
0.6255850196,
0.9102572799,
-0.6704499722,
0.1888503432,
-0.4113940597,
-0.008289475,
0.153965041,
-0.2906237543,
-0.3750591576,
-0.412766993,
0.319632262,
-0.2895183861,
0.0916990563,
0.1171581969,
0.3911801875,
-0.0030738991,
-0.1235064045,
0.4638205171,
-0.3677912354,
0.7486531734,
-0.3083359301,
0.2708821297,
0.102115497,
0.151288569,
0.0410190262,
-0.3090748191,
-0.6330641508,
0.0449180827,
0.0739828795,
0.4326313436,
-0.0709038675,
0.028044777,
-0.0531155095,
0.4479278922,
-0.3437780738,
-0.1964060515,
-0.1251931041,
0.0395253971,
0.2825990915,
0.1702245176,
-0.0979365855,
-0.7224236131,
-0.2095348239,
-0.1879748404,
-0.5790401697,
0.3864593506,
0.0693773925,
0.3404527009,
-0.3806287944,
0.61121732,
-0.2963796556,
0.6950291991,
0.2207922786,
0.0812208354,
0.5195394754,
-0.2443062067,
-0.3122646511,
-0.3039425313,
0.8526890278,
0.7421157956,
-0.1581424922,
0.3894745111,
0.0531850569,
-0.0261184219,
0.4410945177,
-0.3096961975,
-0.4471982419,
0.483986944,
-0.5299168825,
-0.5560688972,
0.1038942263,
-1.1841759682,
-0.9049063921,
-0.2934008837,
0.3300748765,
-0.6181024313,
-0.5044925213,
-0.1821570247,
-0.1857890636,
-0.0247145891,
0.7132770419,
-0.6295911074,
-0.2756726146,
0.815535903,
1.0404983759,
-0.1379246116,
-0.7250499129,
-1.0508531332,
-0.320879668,
-0.3960516155,
1.1208155155,
-0.9203311205,
-0.6652563214,
-0.0758378133,
-0.411062777,
-0.1962497979,
-0.3476251662,
0.3423577547,
0.0264966786,
0.5554512739,
-0.430528909,
-0.0173983201,
-0.3050999343,
0.7704788446,
-0.532918632,
1.2815630436,
0.0791376531,
-0.8075866103,
0.4664662182,
-0.7595624328,
-0.3151086569,
-0.0932230726,
-0.3490747809,
-0.4523449242,
0.634544611,
0.8619116545,
0.7816482186,
-0.2152123898,
-0.0216977261,
-0.1752214134,
0.222121954,
0.1212412491,
-0.4628976285,
0.0258039106,
0.0974961817,
-0.0904605016,
0.5398743153,
-0.4753957093,
-0.0486550257,
-0.1612026542,
-0.2559277117,
-0.3012009859,
0.004378546,
-0.0981387869,
0.445840925,
-0.0903312564,
-0.3280351758,
0.3925552368,
-0.5868324041,
0.1456126273,
0.7993155122,
0.3155858219,
0.5086842179,
-0.3352867067,
0.7598760724,
0.5023894906,
0.4471566975,
-0.4601151645,
-0.9571960568,
-0.5511061549,
-0.0058052801,
0.0021601268,
0.3800716996,
-0.9775419831,
0.1012316048,
-0.1812507659,
-0.6618397832,
-0.5028713942,
-0.0988839939,
0.5924115777,
0.5850210786,
0.3166649342,
-0.5425520539,
-0.3373861611,
-0.6391122341,
-0.2769168615,
-0.2064161152,
0.0851224437,
0.3830285966,
0.0855912864,
0.5317417979,
0.651050508,
-0.4621680081,
-0.1602550447,
-0.6633445024,
0.6269557476,
0.2939593494,
0.3379214406,
0.5406529307,
-0.8932649493,
-0.5751128197,
-0.0214938875,
-0.326869905,
0.0870374963,
-0.1661846489,
-0.1109650359,
0.1866955161,
0.0074987714,
-0.4072704315,
0.3279388547,
0.6503694057,
-0.3657154441,
0.8062348366,
-0.1631417423,
0.4663948119,
-1.4380476475,
-0.1514883488,
0.181382075,
0.0854856521,
-0.6020081639,
-0.4298580289,
0.0508783758,
0.0031566222,
-0.6615820527,
0.3337529302,
-0.4287126958,
-0.0147802606,
-0.2252140641,
-0.1557558477,
0.4913000762,
0.5331342816,
0.2258528769,
0.8847129345,
0.7870185971,
-0.7687737346,
0.1319913864,
0.2848515213,
-0.3687862754,
0.8977584839,
-0.3577013612,
0.1957958788,
-0.3552815914,
-0.0544384308,
-1.1569296122,
-0.1096296534,
0.3277961612,
-0.7530677319,
-0.0002369207,
-0.3736495376,
-0.3476841748,
-0.2505356073,
-0.6334727407,
0.1346657723,
0.0192436147,
-0.4140933752,
1.1147242785,
0.1613338292,
-0.3229091167,
-0.7424808145,
-0.1711122245,
0.0742454603,
-0.2079109699,
-0.43712762,
0.2537916899,
-0.0336031467,
-0.2080255896,
-0.3034384549,
-0.0044032922,
0.2575720549,
-0.119107306,
0.4442505538,
0.5051412582,
-0.0958047435,
0.0627580881,
0.2150217146,
-0.1259126365,
0.0025763204,
-0.1192403957,
0.859316051,
-0.1788471192,
-0.3187406361,
-0.3200427592,
0.6857210398,
0.8576170802,
-0.5218760967,
0.7195240259,
0.3729247451,
-0.1353720129,
0.0110984622,
-0.6155242324,
-0.0115764244,
-0.4458190799,
0.3871347904,
-0.6460863352,
-0.3876994848,
0.3271691501,
-0.0842923075,
0.3925819397,
0.1947400272,
0.6493026614,
0.0528437197,
1.4953047037,
0.5863590837,
-0.4660362899,
0.8238074183,
-0.3610664904,
0.1491179019,
-1.0301319361,
-0.4631707966,
-0.5920538902,
-0.3531424105,
-0.0048387693,
-0.4220373929,
0.9070708752,
0.0424362384,
-0.1269428581,
-0.1003618985,
-0.8465739489,
0.3751936555,
0.7925212979,
0.1264127344,
0.2511448264,
0.0584394597,
-0.3519560695,
0.0075594145,
-0.6251155138,
-0.1045100242,
0.7892234325,
-0.0029875145,
0.5154173374,
0.0459964015,
0.653170526,
0.3150428832,
0.2081846744,
-0.9844246507,
0.3908347785,
-0.150935635,
0.0750902146,
-0.0140556311,
-0.0164608695,
-0.8207260966,
0.4820986092,
-0.4359050989,
-0.6767633557,
0.2698579729,
0.4346892238,
-0.8122733235,
0.0599329062,
-0.8674040437,
0.7064445019,
-0.1348750889,
-0.3271818757,
-0.406704694,
-0.4118163288,
0.0011910106,
0.4085881114,
0.2888226509,
-0.183425203,
0.1550821513,
0.5073150396,
-0.4002707899,
0.7928673029,
-0.5268611312,
0.2940065861,
0.0921752527,
0.3776146472,
0.5669215322,
0.1863631606,
-0.164539054,
-0.2539776266,
-0.3308878839,
-0.0892902613,
-0.6136462688,
0.5741424561,
-0.6948853731,
-0.6474142075,
-0.4982219934,
-0.2419013977,
-0.5305917859,
0.0957965776,
0.5326032043,
0.5577951074,
0.2098595649,
-0.040220093,
0.4395008385,
-0.1067996323,
0.5498684049,
0.1248045415,
-0.2608259618,
-0.6679174304,
0.7569501996,
-0.355438441,
-0.0071241423,
0.456168592,
0.5475610495,
-0.4511815012,
-0.5641605258,
-0.6477156878,
-0.1166084632,
-0.4418803155,
-0.5337124467,
-0.7219672799,
0.1146979481,
-0.5219972134,
-0.0547539927,
-0.5053247809,
-0.4208672345,
-0.1403436661,
-0.1883327365,
0.5720260739,
0.6634621024,
0.1006835774,
0.111050956,
-1.188107729,
0.3920575678,
0.4443318844,
0.2716683149,
0.2867425382,
-0.3297145069,
0.0654770285,
-0.23781991,
-0.5500683784,
-1.1326014996,
0.6776353717,
0.2316114902,
0.4950212836,
0.513572216,
0.1403273344,
0.8211450577,
-0.3791694641,
1.1602846384,
0.4901582897,
-0.9040696025,
0.8832487464,
-0.2443245202,
0.3616647124,
0.3856171966,
0.0876173079,
-0.8277288675,
-0.47008726,
-0.2565942705,
-0.9138432145,
0.7384911776,
-0.021395728,
0.1424365193,
-0.0800282881,
0.0737930089,
0.4816958606,
0.2613297701,
-0.322917074,
-0.4166053832,
-0.8098657131,
0.0259273723,
0.1537219435,
-0.2264053226,
-0.0838259906,
-0.3171524405,
0.6252705455,
-0.4938182235,
0.458539933,
0.3325670063,
0.2350325882,
-0.0367210992,
0.5485940576,
0.3295325339,
0.6930491328,
0.2891805172,
0.102760084,
0.0017708994,
-0.3219555318,
-0.225064382,
0.0205417164,
0.0619857572,
-0.0937899053,
-0.1829736829,
0.7217674851,
-0.0566949733,
-0.2009268999,
0.5075824261,
-0.171776101,
-0.0178294946,
-0.1784290224,
-0.026325861,
-0.1806484163,
0.4159490764,
0.4189967513,
0.543230772,
0.2468571067,
-0.3812935948,
-0.1657096446,
0.2627576292,
-0.3195271492,
-0.3826512396,
0.6215868592,
0.3686363697,
-0.3110554218,
0.5649169683,
-0.1782366037,
-0.7487953305,
0.2326048464,
-0.018625306,
0.9902710915,
-0.2552999556,
0.656652689,
0.2491917014,
-0.1676249355,
-0.1865998656,
0.7934041023,
-0.1744632572,
-0.8956202269,
-0.6437598467,
-0.4734779894,
-0.6394964457,
0.1457036585,
-0.6630766392,
0.1063014716,
-0.4333551526,
-0.1866220087,
0.2282622308,
-0.277649343,
-0.5436628461,
0.1454006732,
0.270183146,
0.8739239573,
-0.8629014492,
0.7677641511,
1.1674220562,
-0.4047588706,
-0.9454502463,
0.0030636664,
0.4366312325,
-0.7865142226,
0.015033274,
0.4320900738,
-0.2865804732,
-0.3651099503,
-0.2965446115,
-0.4433703423,
0.6080070138,
-0.1002732217,
-0.169448331,
0.0752818063,
-0.1592908353,
0.3617144227,
-0.4882798791,
0.1344115585,
0.3021321595,
0.3904336691,
0.153782934,
-0.8936365247,
-0.1139051244,
-0.7435253859,
0.0476832502,
0.1885180175,
-0.5135732889,
0.8775731921,
-0.2401488125,
0.3613130152,
-0.0639173239,
0.8902433515,
0.6140394211,
0.3475713432,
0.8653479815,
0.0838858187,
0.5992046595,
-0.0439487249,
0.9352164865,
-0.4162625372,
-0.0857297331,
0.9465519786,
-0.0012055777,
0.909961164,
0.5996489525,
-0.1382063627,
0.7031806707,
0.5915116668,
0.2313945591,
0.6077553034,
-0.6927785873,
-0.3916007578,
-0.4487130642,
-0.1462448984,
-0.3215624392,
0.5738109946,
0.4304420054,
-0.290168941,
0.0062408224,
0.168709591,
-0.0106855836,
0.0723718926,
-0.6199755073,
0.7628412247,
0.0420881063,
-1.2911676168,
0.0349054821,
-0.1743642986,
0.8154138327,
-0.349804908,
-0.1549817622,
-0.3603427708,
0.1144025549,
-0.3311984241,
-1.1680598259,
0.2829250991,
-0.125246048,
-0.2865147293,
-0.5191537738,
0.4751055837,
-0.0686394051,
-0.4203417897,
-0.0429716334,
0.929158628,
-0.1310651302,
-0.7383909225,
-0.7873391509,
-0.3016016185,
-0.0325989276,
-0.44864586,
0.3575749397,
0.4549982846,
-0.0542690121,
0.6031935811,
0.4917730391,
0.0727753639,
-0.1160139516,
0.5197376013,
0.9939982891,
-0.6155517101,
-0.897157073,
-0.8519991636,
0.7902295589,
-0.2957096994,
-0.4740255475,
0.6596704125,
0.450919807,
0.4514916241,
-0.2004221529,
0.9394654632,
-0.2635149658,
0.698854208,
-0.3851877153,
0.4948158562,
-0.6426053643,
0.3071892262,
-0.3936576247,
-0.8537022471,
-0.3555779159,
0.4197553098,
-0.2860029936,
-0.0939186439,
0.5937681794,
0.5961050987,
0.1051546261,
0.1353340149,
0.1611866504,
-0.1080016047,
0.3234884739,
0.3589274287,
0.9063511491,
0.1429377943,
0.5667060614,
-0.6464726329,
-0.2230573744,
-0.0757682621,
-0.85048908,
-0.7391728163,
-0.8004655838,
-0.1839641482,
-0.4997649491,
-0.2893710732,
1.1776655912,
0.6986649632,
-0.6537722349,
0.1491213888,
-0.0042443145,
0.2874467671,
-0.854621172,
-0.287692368,
0.3999425173,
-0.2086907923,
-0.7952959538,
0.4688346386,
0.5186636448,
-0.2473838478,
-0.2024890929,
-0.0559301302,
0.2051357329,
-0.1149287894,
0.9162034988,
0.0012453567,
-0.6779646277,
-0.453271687,
0.1487901509,
0.3647052646,
0.5779375434,
0.9291671515,
-1.0498187542,
0.565285027,
0.8342978358,
0.1544941515,
0.187175408,
0.2585180998,
0.7811425328,
-1.1291954517,
-0.0724623054,
0.2028757185,
0.5030235052,
0.353079915,
-0.4273593724,
0.1033721492,
0.08740215,
-0.2588930726,
-0.4601471424,
0.4249158502,
-1.0421367884,
-0.1513018161,
1.0271099806,
-0.0115251541,
-0.0689700171,
-0.361679405,
-0.4248140156,
-0.0812483802,
-0.9808164835,
1.1282775402,
0.3924388587,
-0.7252996564,
-0.7235016823,
0.0979516283,
0.3843756914,
0.6723350883,
-0.8075005412,
0.1426053345,
0.6350027919,
0.0271909051,
0.215417847,
0.7460068464,
-0.1539642364,
0.5889604092,
-0.2076173872,
-0.2346175015,
-0.3475758135,
-0.6100649238,
-0.2928055823,
0.5870003104,
0.2766009271,
-0.5103561282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12620v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12620v1 | Keeping Up with the Language Models: Robustness-Bias Interplay in NLI Data and Models | 2023-05-22T01:02:45 | 2023-05-22T01:02:45 | Ioana Baldini, Chhavi Yadav, Payel Das, Kush R. Varshney | cs.CL | cs.CL | Auditing unwanted social bias in language models (LMs) is inherently hard due
to the multidisciplinary nature of the work. In addition, the rapid evolution
of LMs can make benchmarks irrelevant in no time. Bias auditing is further
complicated by LM brittleness: when a presumably biased outcome is observed, is
it due to model bias or model brittleness? We propose enlisting the models
themselves to help construct bias auditing datasets that remain challenging,
and introduce bias measures that distinguish between types of model errors.
First, we extend an existing bias benchmark for NLI (BBNLI) using a combination
of LM-generated lexical variations, adversarial filtering, and human
validation. We demonstrate that the newly created dataset (BBNLInext) is more
challenging than BBNLI: on average, BBNLI-next reduces the accuracy of
state-of-the-art NLI models from 95.3%, as observed by BBNLI, to 58.6%. Second,
we employ BBNLI-next to showcase the interplay between robustness and bias, and
the subtlety in differentiating between the two. Third, we point out
shortcomings in current bias scores used in the literature and propose bias
measures that take into account pro-/anti-stereotype bias and model
brittleness. We will publicly release the BBNLI-next dataset to inspire
research on rapidly expanding benchmarks to keep up with model evolution, along
with research on the robustness-bias interplay in bias auditing.
Note: This paper contains offensive text examples. | [
-0.2540657818,
-0.4643401206,
0.2520208657,
0.1412795931,
0.0983717516,
0.0880226791,
-0.1119948402,
-0.6236206293,
-0.0448583588,
0.4756296873,
-0.5822753906,
-0.1920092106,
-0.5829556584,
0.0215687249,
-0.4096358418,
1.2857073545,
0.1156729534,
0.5303646326,
-0.1955933422,
-0.4701812267,
-0.5052362084,
-0.4535475671,
-0.3792442679,
-0.5120939612,
0.4317699969,
-0.1831309795,
0.9012963176,
0.7132191062,
0.3348050714,
0.1200677156,
-0.4907179773,
-0.1277863085,
-0.400534749,
0.0813460201,
-0.245575726,
-0.5656747222,
-0.5914565921,
0.0313812196,
0.5273622274,
0.823938489,
0.0859808475,
0.2128811628,
0.2043180019,
0.7291384935,
-0.7164976001,
0.2101682425,
-0.8388038874,
-0.1083442867,
-0.4610607028,
0.2738833725,
-0.2919078171,
-0.6743680835,
0.3315006495,
-0.1176849231,
0.1381968856,
-0.0555124022,
0.9733693004,
0.2198812664,
-0.3441631496,
-0.4807268977,
-0.4466573596,
1.0024427176,
-0.9862340689,
0.5449678898,
0.3594104648,
-0.0213285573,
0.0998932272,
-0.2459831387,
-0.2703809142,
-0.1494997144,
0.1465763152,
0.0294356681,
-0.1598727554,
-0.1597412378,
0.3121604621,
0.1581929028,
-0.3903543055,
0.2243576646,
-0.2118787915,
-0.2367947549,
0.6128481627,
0.1380365789,
0.2406544089,
-0.0615475997,
0.0847270414,
-0.28612113,
-0.9874020219,
-0.1935309619,
0.8164172173,
0.3689005971,
0.1050942168,
0.4113521874,
0.1488042325,
0.3198235035,
-0.172591269,
0.0131480945,
0.2392555177,
-0.6016142964,
0.0704915747,
0.0669109225,
0.4933256507,
0.4588068128,
0.4593565464,
-0.1531175077,
-0.3240081966,
0.4242923856,
0.186784327,
-0.3120215237,
-0.1538583189,
0.2122110277,
-0.6185380816,
-0.6908488274,
-0.1337177455,
-0.9543744326,
-0.6450962424,
-0.1421940029,
0.2129725367,
-0.311660856,
-0.5364205837,
-0.1305982471,
-0.0729545802,
0.2866922319,
0.1621116251,
-0.7151188254,
0.4091612399,
0.8958303928,
0.6577133536,
-0.0400132313,
-0.2737829685,
-0.3286704123,
-0.1092061624,
-0.4041897655,
0.3104991615,
-0.3232580125,
-0.2102521658,
0.3067595363,
-0.0107645644,
0.1153107136,
-0.76635921,
0.7584055662,
-0.3896113634,
0.3541010916,
-0.5841442943,
-0.5430201292,
0.0112308385,
0.2688598335,
-0.6723824143,
1.0984098911,
0.0533844568,
-1.0710859299,
0.7004747391,
-0.4084760547,
-0.1962420344,
-0.3349240124,
-0.0767618045,
-0.7418161035,
0.2219683975,
0.2682537436,
0.1580234766,
-0.3452583849,
0.8182282448,
-0.9409677386,
-0.1616307497,
0.1577119082,
-0.7256608009,
1.2478957176,
-0.0183028951,
-0.4338869154,
-0.0469783768,
-0.8835527301,
-0.1050042659,
0.1540304869,
-0.1163564175,
-0.5788107514,
0.2859475911,
0.2818401754,
0.0997932181,
0.0736768097,
-0.2831311822,
-0.0459851921,
-0.3541207314,
0.2614315748,
1.1184922457,
-0.3996862173,
0.2930110991,
-0.5295343995,
0.1975687742,
0.0110197505,
0.2869432867,
-0.0493208915,
-0.4475542903,
-0.6977503896,
0.1085340083,
0.4802204669,
0.7604702115,
-0.4089548588,
0.3488434255,
-0.3558844626,
-0.4508078992,
-0.6318256855,
0.2489435524,
0.5900665522,
0.2535820007,
0.1217783988,
-0.4693543017,
-0.5762358308,
-0.9040660262,
-0.7746139169,
-0.5087435246,
-0.155976072,
0.3179802597,
0.4679088593,
-0.2505793869,
1.0214016438,
0.136165604,
-0.1298593879,
-0.1454483718,
0.2256511897,
0.3902101517,
0.4574266076,
0.6449885368,
-0.6249599457,
-0.0856420547,
-0.2049334496,
-0.7923358083,
-0.5495503545,
0.0120628132,
0.1917777807,
0.2645784616,
0.3064259291,
-0.3762554228,
0.4069701433,
0.4975886047,
-0.2840565741,
0.6911953092,
0.2790539861,
-0.3794799745,
-0.8964226246,
-0.0196981598,
0.2039477229,
-0.1737962961,
-0.6643736362,
-0.0458232015,
0.055251509,
0.2331425846,
-0.247573331,
0.45819965,
-0.6042917967,
-0.1693993509,
0.0368089154,
-0.0344190076,
-0.0273091588,
0.1546635479,
-0.193639949,
0.4330923855,
0.4784725606,
-0.3939945698,
0.1214705482,
-0.020152159,
-0.5239576697,
0.345975399,
-0.7122366428,
0.1520138979,
-0.1923322827,
0.0768484548,
-0.4607656002,
-0.1549381316,
-0.1101670861,
-0.1540926099,
0.47334373,
-0.1969250739,
-0.3405822814,
-0.1180406809,
-0.6209781766,
0.3557443023,
0.3721320033,
-0.5691592097,
0.7194936872,
0.5630695224,
-0.1659180075,
-1.0712231398,
-0.6204396486,
0.1107740998,
-0.3972202539,
-0.5775488019,
0.0428781919,
-0.1640800387,
-0.7444760799,
-0.0289552249,
-0.2586344779,
-0.0402689613,
0.2793090343,
0.0449446663,
0.4252356589,
-0.285082072,
-0.2578117847,
-0.0358127058,
0.3456054628,
0.4054635465,
-0.0411479734,
0.3277313113,
-0.2675698996,
-0.411757648,
-0.16041632,
0.2229831219,
0.6728332639,
0.1374253482,
0.6023670435,
0.5581551194,
-0.5194323659,
0.011472607,
-0.9765145779,
-0.2104031593,
-0.4035490751,
0.5543320179,
-0.1839370131,
-0.6902058721,
0.6504644156,
0.0225107912,
0.3320831954,
0.1601790786,
0.5135305524,
0.2222206891,
1.1381574869,
0.6526836157,
-0.5960608721,
0.4405017793,
0.1571306735,
0.265853852,
-0.7254692316,
0.053627342,
-0.6185523868,
0.2295642495,
-0.6369252205,
-0.0417875536,
0.1771755368,
0.1345659196,
0.0723620951,
0.1598490179,
-0.1133090407,
0.415202111,
0.4062818289,
-0.0380241387,
-0.0171458479,
-0.3891836703,
-0.0488837659,
-0.244187519,
-0.7357225418,
-0.6433061361,
1.2926448584,
0.7181397676,
0.8816357255,
0.2397380769,
0.4994972944,
0.3841398358,
0.5655343533,
-0.3924387693,
0.34094733,
0.0037516197,
-0.920945704,
-0.0612200387,
-0.4953562319,
-0.3756204545,
0.1211791858,
-0.3443868458,
-0.8582732677,
0.4788345993,
0.4480481148,
0.0605546869,
0.4044880271,
-0.7346897721,
0.8185533881,
-0.1569362283,
-0.7338036299,
0.2138572037,
-0.7098004222,
0.6141769886,
-0.2227008194,
0.475165993,
-0.2753487527,
0.3404453993,
0.6594254971,
-0.3085771799,
0.9006246328,
-0.1304018348,
-0.2026232332,
0.0057305316,
0.2385158837,
0.5795792937,
0.2212363183,
-0.3311186731,
0.4332724214,
0.069316119,
-0.4380976856,
-0.4069257081,
0.5156249404,
-0.6109012961,
-0.540612042,
-0.5655317903,
-0.5067806244,
-0.2922081947,
0.1999538988,
0.0798168108,
0.4951530695,
-0.4533195496,
0.0142539004,
0.7687587142,
-0.1409111023,
0.3633893132,
0.0946005136,
-0.0740663931,
-0.1525077671,
0.7859925628,
0.0002629196,
0.3411816657,
0.007033838,
0.3141986728,
-0.2762641311,
-0.6000741124,
-0.3144666851,
0.1345817596,
-0.721523881,
-0.0492310636,
-0.6626321673,
-0.112149395,
-0.6808322668,
0.0233587995,
-0.5008450747,
-0.2009888142,
-0.1740018129,
0.048202578,
0.1191320792,
0.8922608495,
-0.1212590709,
-0.1151140332,
-0.4820085168,
-0.1667860299,
0.2057021856,
0.3510049284,
0.1240388677,
-0.4637823701,
-0.1112039387,
-0.1408921331,
-0.0887761191,
-0.9391782284,
0.4142957032,
0.1184317842,
0.3533155024,
0.6415540576,
-0.0906560421,
0.5533589125,
-0.589733243,
0.7007545829,
0.0131283738,
-1.2238390446,
0.3677586317,
-0.4618046284,
0.2139650285,
0.6775414348,
0.3448246121,
-0.3746445477,
-0.6402443647,
-0.3600058556,
-0.895830214,
0.6341238022,
0.0519606881,
0.0600840934,
0.0454262421,
0.3374341726,
0.0793276504,
0.0893339962,
-1.1390300989,
-0.1633861661,
-0.1994353533,
-0.3347767591,
0.10231971,
-0.5853077769,
-0.1628453583,
-0.108989805,
0.9307448864,
-0.2594692409,
-0.1731146574,
0.0911297873,
-0.166953519,
0.1666903347,
0.2919102609,
0.381256789,
0.8152315617,
-0.4508476853,
0.075757511,
0.4364542663,
-0.4966459274,
-0.166379869,
0.0006899955,
-0.3456438482,
0.1288488507,
0.5989428163,
0.7317627668,
0.0856116638,
-0.7763044238,
0.6818101406,
-0.114018321,
-0.0045645302,
-0.4627754688,
-0.1529871672,
-0.0329139419,
0.0493518747,
0.0813993365,
0.1591557562,
0.0816257298,
-0.7215101719,
0.0451603308,
0.6047223806,
-0.6363613605,
-0.440659076,
0.791156888,
-0.0837817416,
-0.2710103095,
0.4354366064,
-0.0352600664,
-0.6265509725,
0.3871557713,
0.3741886616,
0.7904975414,
-0.3121836185,
-0.1842692196,
0.1239926368,
0.8191109896,
-0.3158744276,
0.1404729784,
0.1930161566,
-0.8989248276,
-0.1758920401,
-0.4581278861,
-0.5211308002,
0.3620050848,
-0.9530252218,
0.4053690135,
-0.4036685526,
-0.2000212371,
0.108619839,
-0.2903232276,
-0.6248093843,
0.1958315969,
0.0483933054,
0.8957573175,
-1.1515330076,
0.6599044204,
0.4664308727,
-0.1611444801,
-0.3855521083,
0.0962550789,
0.5330355167,
-0.6978416443,
0.349101305,
0.0819141641,
0.0900485441,
-0.6987404823,
-0.5591937304,
-0.701551795,
0.6542640924,
0.2154714167,
-0.5835985541,
-0.2592112422,
0.0068149837,
0.4617249072,
-0.1949305832,
0.583557725,
0.6366940141,
0.3428013921,
-0.6504295468,
-0.8856156468,
0.0617599972,
-0.4044690728,
0.2290483862,
0.0305717643,
-0.5230258107,
0.8047577143,
0.1078787297,
-0.0397841409,
0.0148464181,
0.4553002119,
0.0757968277,
0.5470166802,
0.8083039522,
0.4433985949,
0.6469145417,
-0.2746451199,
0.9134973884,
-0.2700332701,
0.1858767569,
1.2309788465,
-0.7828018069,
0.4600582719,
0.5493855476,
-0.0178682096,
0.3481126428,
0.4228925705,
-0.1122766137,
0.30229038,
0.268073231,
-0.3105917275,
0.0620524921,
-0.2871585488,
-0.1916779727,
0.4236556888,
0.3297639489,
-0.3850655258,
-0.0138652977,
-0.2996391058,
0.3809059858,
0.0593604557,
-0.0379152484,
0.7560787797,
-0.0408382565,
-0.6844989061,
0.2398112714,
-0.2202386558,
0.9032473564,
-0.6853076816,
0.2174046338,
-0.2384801358,
0.2749310732,
-0.0586058088,
-0.4960379004,
0.5353143811,
0.1840774864,
-0.396798104,
-0.2058503181,
0.7343862653,
-0.2270808667,
-0.3538750708,
0.6122158766,
0.6472018361,
0.0708628148,
0.2659801543,
-0.8310505152,
0.4777646661,
-0.0033853494,
-0.2279456854,
0.4956775606,
0.2301660329,
-0.3216499984,
0.6896739006,
0.5533134937,
0.1453187019,
0.2155610472,
0.4578691423,
0.733315587,
-0.4959193766,
-0.206751734,
-0.9759597778,
0.1177963689,
-0.335901916,
-0.4834388196,
0.8154061437,
0.5302138925,
0.9450351596,
0.162137568,
0.7928497791,
0.1596186757,
0.5397838354,
-0.4769064188,
0.8587751389,
-0.5877637267,
0.3678771257,
-0.7136158943,
-0.9392071962,
-0.249824971,
0.3759455979,
0.057456214,
0.2775960565,
0.4385705888,
0.9274438024,
-0.0629521757,
0.2859578431,
0.125959456,
0.4164001346,
0.2876309752,
0.2998841107,
0.7420540452,
-0.4440920055,
0.373703748,
-0.2356740087,
-0.2702066898,
0.0213714279,
-1.1448613405,
-0.9854753613,
-0.2902222574,
-0.5195817947,
-0.7612321973,
0.3757128119,
0.7285262346,
0.7579226494,
-1.0151963234,
-0.3557785153,
-0.1330256909,
0.2799485624,
-0.2356180549,
-0.3135710061,
0.2613043189,
-0.1637261957,
-0.7116330266,
0.4345243275,
0.1583346575,
-0.0552460253,
-0.531360507,
0.207530275,
-0.1748340279,
0.3629622757,
0.3489829004,
0.2950709462,
-0.8064932227,
-0.3633273244,
-0.1359715015,
0.1733721793,
-0.1787317991,
0.7262369394,
-0.3475248516,
0.4202753007,
0.2299068719,
0.7560262084,
0.1168353781,
-0.5018087626,
0.7970975041,
-0.6659532785,
-0.0484922603,
0.3190590441,
0.6931014657,
0.5424869657,
-0.1402343214,
0.5982657671,
0.281042695,
-0.5844801068,
-1.4300073385,
0.3478081226,
-0.7239151001,
-0.0870608017,
0.8376608491,
-0.0812418908,
-0.4118853807,
-0.3961659372,
0.1782754958,
0.1674716324,
-0.0923843458,
0.9836446643,
1.0902283192,
0.4424789548,
-0.0849062204,
-0.5374880433,
0.7064418197,
0.8547053933,
-0.5803862214,
0.2875605822,
0.1905878931,
0.4467156529,
0.2549951971,
0.4484885335,
-0.3973453939,
0.2179255784,
0.1419972628,
-0.0373507589,
0.3297303915,
-0.0569221564,
-0.612472415,
-0.1271005869,
-0.0649918765,
0.4999954998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12612v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12612v2 | PrOnto: Language Model Evaluations for 859 Languages | 2023-05-22T00:33:52 | 2024-03-28T14:23:08 | Luke Gessler | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluation datasets are critical resources for measuring the quality of
pretrained language models. However, due to the high cost of dataset
annotation, these resources are scarce for most languages other than English,
making it difficult to assess the quality of language models. In this work, we
present a new method for evaluation dataset construction which enables any
language with a New Testament translation to receive a suite of evaluation
datasets suitable for pretrained language model evaluation. The method
critically involves aligning verses with those in the New Testament portion of
English OntoNotes, and then projecting annotations from English to the target
language, with no manual annotation required. We apply this method to 1051 New
Testament translations in 859 and make them publicly available. Additionally,
we conduct experiments which demonstrate the efficacy of our method for
creating evaluation tasks which can assess language model quality. | [
-0.150396511,
-0.2942072153,
0.2852974236,
0.2333728075,
-0.6591459513,
-0.211869359,
-0.4352413416,
-0.2406494766,
0.2327606976,
0.6760418415,
-0.3459965885,
-0.4055964947,
-0.4063435495,
0.2352054119,
-0.5298468471,
1.0587992668,
-0.1635265052,
0.392940253,
-0.0315663554,
-0.1985601783,
-0.439637959,
-0.1797571182,
-0.3083172739,
0.0759423971,
0.1365584582,
0.2566513121,
0.9859446287,
0.7055357099,
0.8272702098,
0.4243945479,
0.0293047968,
0.0848435983,
-0.3871614039,
0.1144199446,
-0.0697247684,
-0.137206167,
-0.6790632606,
0.3016613424,
0.7160574198,
0.6973574758,
0.0130660208,
0.5834946036,
-0.1658389866,
0.3060097098,
-0.6219722629,
0.1258831769,
-0.5033399463,
-0.0071337833,
-0.5085003972,
-0.1538714617,
-0.5688309073,
-0.8044546247,
0.4673100412,
-0.9882069826,
-0.0332917832,
0.1947790086,
0.7199146152,
-0.0695592239,
-0.2720772624,
-0.1602496356,
-0.4041021168,
0.908847332,
-0.7767686844,
0.481015265,
0.4347752929,
0.3653028011,
-0.0123692006,
-0.7864462733,
-0.497805059,
-0.4868007004,
0.0149520515,
-0.0320106633,
-0.109654814,
-0.2037426233,
-0.0697282702,
0.5956115127,
-0.4114188254,
-0.2087212056,
-0.2617571056,
-0.2115692943,
0.7097501755,
-0.0087629966,
0.1986653656,
-0.4506630599,
-0.4518466294,
-0.29607144,
-0.6655872464,
-0.1642237157,
0.5340545177,
0.5468602777,
0.0630429015,
0.2018012553,
0.0367432833,
0.6065667272,
-0.1886323392,
-0.1057733744,
0.5444638133,
-0.4071377218,
-0.2672989666,
-0.0066860514,
0.8634303212,
0.4930625558,
0.447296232,
-0.287627846,
-0.5228074193,
-0.4268837273,
0.4384952486,
-0.4769108891,
0.1205477715,
-0.171085611,
-0.4048600197,
-0.5151961446,
-0.0568528362,
-0.6231544614,
-0.3762449026,
-0.3354753554,
0.8591372371,
-0.3863101304,
-0.210846886,
0.0904119983,
0.1234650537,
-0.2299906611,
0.4353989959,
-0.6878735423,
0.3148401976,
0.4636802077,
0.5502528548,
0.1554670036,
-0.3739949465,
-0.6699233651,
-0.0372060239,
-0.5712979436,
0.733130753,
-0.7607069016,
0.0169757307,
0.1277129948,
0.2781052589,
0.2402523756,
-0.4645996094,
0.8574549556,
-0.5665945411,
0.3936902583,
-0.1516554654,
-0.5829748511,
-0.3023375273,
-0.0160521287,
-0.886464715,
1.1112779379,
0.5536693931,
-0.6157134175,
0.1440937221,
-0.3970879614,
-0.3713348508,
0.5351092219,
-0.0233685803,
-0.1555846483,
0.4783603251,
0.1604981273,
0.2545966208,
-0.7199906707,
0.5673442483,
0.1581646949,
-0.476320982,
-0.0248521008,
-0.3534019887,
0.6870407462,
0.2820734084,
-0.4268271625,
0.1089235395,
-0.6008740067,
0.2452842891,
0.0681621358,
-0.309933573,
-0.4660935998,
-0.1848377734,
0.3320820034,
-0.1880483627,
0.2585729361,
-0.5887261033,
0.22105214,
-0.4846483767,
0.1313120127,
0.5422593951,
-0.3240528703,
0.2740034461,
0.1472883373,
0.814524889,
-0.3545247018,
0.4294277728,
-0.2442463934,
-0.472982794,
-0.6307529211,
0.2247245759,
0.7711791992,
0.380427748,
-0.6461200714,
0.5580168962,
-0.5486790538,
-0.6316734552,
-0.8060480952,
0.130174771,
0.7135677934,
0.3851397336,
0.519613564,
-0.5817688107,
-0.5311948061,
-0.9087933302,
-0.1896594763,
-0.0387152843,
0.0755165145,
-0.0620602705,
0.3672064841,
0.3033407032,
0.5848200321,
-0.1104360819,
-0.2418870628,
-0.4274236858,
0.0579695925,
0.0669541433,
0.5404666066,
0.6195497513,
-0.5331748128,
-0.2384196967,
-0.0198347662,
-0.3525248766,
-0.1378923059,
0.0088654011,
-0.3641749024,
-0.2729717493,
0.2434318513,
-0.0225013122,
0.3408018649,
0.6314114928,
-0.2326067984,
0.2765240371,
-0.1231805757,
0.3962523639,
-1.0249812603,
0.1838760823,
-0.0941781849,
-0.3696071804,
-0.5844038129,
-0.0795378983,
0.2587097585,
-0.0150506422,
-0.6745206714,
0.5210855603,
-0.3628070951,
-0.0185869411,
-0.1478070468,
0.3340949118,
0.1467996985,
-0.0858963802,
0.1151993871,
0.8545306921,
0.2603139579,
-0.1204764172,
0.5381566286,
0.5996329188,
-0.8892366886,
0.2918131948,
-0.5264402628,
0.0083156377,
-0.0732357576,
0.191092521,
-0.7837277055,
-0.0157372616,
0.0177063476,
-0.1911619157,
0.1797314435,
-0.1720577627,
-0.0768829435,
0.011769182,
-0.2452133745,
0.4115739167,
0.3370522261,
-0.3584935069,
0.2113818377,
0.3072099984,
-0.2315526009,
-0.7549499273,
-0.5987254977,
0.1215487197,
-0.177280128,
-0.5041660666,
0.2101835459,
0.2690984011,
-0.1371329874,
-0.027645072,
0.078455627,
-0.0127507839,
0.1987535506,
-0.0149658052,
0.2430494279,
-0.4840120673,
0.1343709081,
-0.1592992395,
-0.3871271312,
-0.1340517402,
-0.3289473057,
0.4393801987,
-0.0302477777,
-0.3593463898,
-0.35538885,
0.2878505886,
0.1616860181,
-0.7809591889,
0.5597161651,
0.2271640301,
-0.4637666047,
-0.079484269,
-0.6672756076,
0.0232433304,
-0.4477661252,
0.535942018,
-0.1998312324,
-0.6403692961,
0.179138422,
-0.1589522511,
0.1379198581,
0.5208138227,
0.2804789841,
0.2491063178,
0.5883802772,
0.2592507303,
0.1763819009,
0.5897654295,
-0.1376558095,
0.2756275833,
-0.6081809998,
-0.0659490153,
-0.5108681917,
-0.2772173584,
-0.3025730252,
-0.5304589272,
0.2575289309,
0.2554863989,
-0.1902796179,
0.707696557,
-0.2563248575,
0.8553037643,
0.6757133603,
-0.1582743227,
0.4473679662,
0.1997243613,
-0.0782593414,
-0.2724483311,
-0.1984678805,
-1.1660283804,
1.2944253683,
0.1743023396,
0.4531986117,
0.1161286682,
0.5799227953,
0.2393649369,
0.7927348614,
-0.5025764704,
0.416662395,
-0.4632943571,
-0.724111259,
-0.4243430793,
-0.3312330544,
-0.8008047342,
-0.0428792797,
-0.2019642144,
-0.6270770431,
0.116830349,
0.0165415928,
-0.5841375589,
0.0360559858,
-0.7958731651,
1.1393817663,
-0.4527951479,
-0.2926022112,
-0.1437229365,
-0.5362007022,
0.1004440263,
-0.2944691181,
0.3029569387,
-0.3040053546,
0.1419897377,
0.8820369244,
-0.3872858286,
0.3874333501,
-0.3062389791,
-0.1075213552,
0.2988127768,
0.2151066661,
0.3980335891,
0.0053327922,
-0.4446317554,
-0.0770635977,
0.1218824834,
-0.1779444069,
-0.5944318771,
0.3895594776,
-0.6056177616,
-0.409915179,
-0.2725720704,
-0.4197595417,
-0.2051848173,
0.2132010758,
0.047721304,
0.789475143,
-0.2211438119,
0.1520513892,
0.0199498385,
-0.3543698788,
0.414021045,
0.7596233487,
-0.208235383,
-0.8013783693,
0.8851803541,
0.3236388266,
0.2738583386,
0.1548173726,
0.1615714282,
-0.4613129497,
-0.7078620791,
-0.7841965556,
-0.0552080646,
-0.7222753167,
-0.3798842132,
0.0301255137,
0.1655362248,
-0.317525804,
0.036985416,
-0.6256130934,
-0.6049911976,
0.3368740678,
-0.1168285087,
0.3960668743,
1.0784091949,
0.0547471158,
0.6209340692,
-0.9142826796,
-0.1145346463,
0.0003779996,
0.3856963217,
-0.0291781705,
-0.8230712414,
-0.4899638593,
0.0009942654,
-0.3943731487,
-1.0692318678,
0.306268394,
0.2598767579,
0.4408715963,
0.3418235183,
0.1974234432,
0.8250403404,
-0.8022122383,
0.599426806,
0.0352073647,
-1.3233716488,
0.5488989949,
-0.1723133922,
-0.355296284,
0.9618159533,
0.5438488126,
-0.6206367016,
-0.2350877672,
-0.5080017447,
-0.8706049323,
0.7202783823,
0.2869496644,
0.4592266679,
-0.221692726,
0.4995772541,
0.233193323,
0.350022912,
-0.6913331747,
-0.2109020054,
-0.0518033728,
-0.4163527191,
-0.2344186008,
-0.122297734,
-0.0719851777,
-0.3399742544,
0.6477212906,
0.0170398559,
-0.0417464562,
0.0230403878,
-0.290155381,
-0.1865534782,
0.2907522023,
0.2506323457,
0.9053353667,
-0.2799012363,
0.1796981841,
0.2186165452,
-0.6097306609,
0.5126617551,
0.2826285362,
-0.1441656351,
0.0448114872,
0.6244471669,
0.7822958231,
0.2608455718,
-0.6020727754,
0.883451283,
-0.0667397603,
0.2104892582,
-0.2582055032,
-0.1999446154,
0.0460714959,
0.2378044277,
0.2213293165,
-0.3116856217,
-0.0099913022,
-0.3616028726,
0.1742627174,
0.1214232147,
-0.4819285274,
-0.4969083667,
0.5843928456,
0.4246499836,
-0.2211408764,
0.6741920114,
-0.2897117436,
-0.4779418707,
0.2437004298,
0.4727632999,
0.7572554946,
-0.7164207697,
0.253669858,
0.4463783801,
0.4118947983,
-0.1993319541,
0.5905336142,
0.3360985518,
-0.5414046049,
-0.7871884108,
-0.8813589811,
-0.4063484967,
0.1841763854,
-0.6908264756,
0.3248821199,
-0.03898127,
-0.2764258385,
-0.0036722897,
-0.1084143743,
-0.6989081502,
0.4717698693,
0.1992898583,
0.9504405856,
-1.10980165,
0.7272046208,
0.8738937974,
-0.6051020026,
-0.7555359602,
-0.1737887263,
-0.2745427489,
-0.8787385821,
0.7661265135,
0.21483922,
0.1054691374,
0.1691915691,
-0.2722734809,
-0.9637294412,
0.692538619,
1.0088233948,
-0.6776972413,
0.1341094077,
0.3909577429,
0.4556306899,
-0.3724783957,
0.8535458446,
0.6594220996,
0.7014209032,
-0.3030661047,
-1.1371945143,
0.0851468295,
-0.4771210551,
-0.1690694988,
0.2563968301,
-0.4113789797,
0.6007711887,
0.0447172895,
-0.0936048627,
0.169430092,
0.5319455266,
-0.1736613363,
-0.0998522565,
0.6496878266,
0.5796077847,
0.7481534481,
-0.2859348059,
0.9911074638,
-0.445808053,
0.4412285686,
1.1694655418,
-0.1697580069,
1.0664979219,
0.4237262309,
-0.3939633965,
0.1645975411,
0.5159742236,
0.1252488792,
0.4957394302,
0.549071312,
-0.3768575788,
-0.5840958953,
-0.5136525631,
-0.5246654153,
0.3911878169,
-0.0710007697,
-0.4429296553,
-0.1865575463,
-0.0849930719,
0.2108291686,
0.1482192278,
0.1545486897,
0.5203537941,
-0.2432921082,
-0.6244934797,
0.5413916111,
0.1032176018,
0.2547235489,
-0.6128258705,
0.0572088063,
-0.4429714084,
0.13551341,
-0.1537969261,
-0.530099988,
0.2551783323,
0.3894824386,
0.2847992778,
-0.2970187068,
0.01064118,
-0.4492299259,
-0.7867399454,
0.2384398133,
0.4695241749,
0.5031788349,
-0.0515472442,
-0.31335935,
0.0309207756,
0.0442648865,
-0.5190181732,
0.0617019907,
0.5027783513,
-0.3632468879,
0.2262876034,
0.2799061239,
0.1722689867,
-0.0192477796,
0.4013993442,
0.8805948496,
-0.6644338369,
-0.1309257001,
-0.6490320563,
0.6505773664,
0.1075871587,
-0.7959074378,
0.8097689152,
0.8374572992,
0.9148892164,
0.0536866002,
0.8029167056,
-0.007513341,
0.4462603927,
-0.2366958559,
0.5750438571,
-0.565464139,
0.0596856736,
-0.5214156508,
-1.1002160311,
-0.3178637326,
0.9712481499,
-0.4938772619,
-0.0613704957,
0.761705637,
0.6370644569,
-0.1903681308,
0.46583125,
0.0328768045,
-0.1112033501,
0.146450907,
0.3583845496,
1.1230944395,
-0.8495123386,
0.5448169112,
-0.4394611418,
-0.2093144208,
0.2354982644,
-1.1489907503,
-0.5362084508,
-0.4932317138,
-0.2603507042,
-0.1875092536,
0.1008156016,
1.1257966757,
0.6622334123,
-1.0203654766,
-0.2986103892,
0.154815644,
-0.3471796811,
-0.0337460004,
-0.0547947362,
0.7039209604,
-0.4844912291,
-0.8721159101,
0.7098724842,
-0.1019215286,
0.0101318937,
-0.3206349909,
-0.1377365142,
-0.0644030496,
-0.2836398482,
0.1702906489,
-0.4473927319,
-0.5645219684,
-0.1987726241,
-0.1737083942,
0.1879684627,
0.1083054766,
0.6781297326,
-0.5471710563,
0.6902839541,
0.4316167235,
0.6614955664,
0.1996656507,
0.1368346512,
0.8509096503,
-0.8138165474,
0.3782093823,
0.1196047962,
0.3984118998,
0.5703775883,
0.1622077525,
0.6451352835,
0.0286543034,
-0.3265557289,
-0.8428629041,
-0.1801218539,
-0.4937565625,
0.3744921386,
0.7553868294,
-0.6692202687,
-0.0867087096,
0.0214662869,
-0.1464003175,
0.2191675007,
-0.1902087927,
0.3660549521,
0.6840770841,
0.4517884552,
0.2384154648,
-0.9334873557,
0.6276552081,
0.6326395869,
-0.7460768223,
0.159052819,
0.3570022285,
-0.0038840084,
0.2814641893,
0.2525307834,
-0.2984468937,
0.2149145901,
-0.2278289348,
0.3336002231,
-0.1015781984,
-0.2176255435,
-0.293830663,
-0.1182502657,
0.2119548023,
-0.1079890132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12606v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12606v2 | Comparison of Multilingual Self-Supervised and Weakly-Supervised Speech Pre-Training for Adaptation to Unseen Languages | 2023-05-21T23:53:12 | 2023-05-31T01:27:41 | Andrew Rouditchenko, Sameer Khurana, Samuel Thomas, Rogerio Feris, Leonid Karlinsky, Hilde Kuehne, David Harwath, Brian Kingsbury, James Glass | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent models such as XLS-R and Whisper have made multilingual speech
technologies more accessible by pre-training on audio from around 100 spoken
languages each. However, there are thousands of spoken languages worldwide, and
adapting to new languages is an important problem. In this work, we aim to
understand which model adapts better to languages unseen during pre-training.
We fine-tune both models on 13 unseen languages and 18 seen languages. Our
results show that the number of hours seen per language and language family
during pre-training is predictive of how the models compare, despite the
significant differences in the pre-training methods. | [
-0.3150279224,
-0.1276910454,
0.4634760618,
0.3474280834,
0.055852063,
0.1740189344,
-0.5245121121,
-0.7587985396,
-0.1042758524,
0.3206214607,
-0.8281357288,
-0.3383425176,
-0.6143773794,
0.3410114348,
-0.2384515405,
0.9355277419,
0.1260994971,
0.1893551946,
0.1261932552,
-0.257784009,
-0.1315284073,
-0.5857877731,
-0.4463208914,
-0.1016778797,
0.3466914296,
0.3721872866,
0.6458944082,
0.2306468636,
0.2783623934,
0.3516965806,
0.1566458791,
-0.176418528,
-0.4782864451,
-0.0459580794,
-0.1918267608,
-0.3950757384,
-0.5300235152,
-0.1941090077,
0.7104690671,
0.8843836188,
0.1098418012,
0.3070519567,
0.5749107599,
0.4678368568,
-0.6767982841,
0.0670772567,
-0.5838717818,
0.1883888394,
-0.1152510047,
0.0271703694,
-0.3590406775,
-0.0010879076,
0.3740330935,
-0.8078722954,
0.2532548606,
-0.3345789313,
0.4692014456,
0.3019753098,
-0.3009682596,
-0.1653634608,
-0.9524751902,
0.8439682126,
-0.7882983685,
0.8987331986,
0.3193421364,
0.0481639989,
0.0668702424,
-0.6976364851,
-0.3452845514,
-0.2281001061,
-0.1611293852,
0.5282310247,
-0.4607750475,
0.0159901232,
0.0689223707,
0.1040124595,
-0.5748967528,
0.5868726373,
-0.3854131103,
-0.3518090546,
0.4880069494,
-0.2028887272,
0.0354848243,
0.02782383,
-0.0118213445,
-0.0664383844,
-0.4665220082,
0.0017841394,
0.5842866302,
0.7225271463,
-0.6582109332,
0.1868069768,
-0.4232455194,
0.7600546479,
-0.0140976934,
-0.4642704129,
0.2819340527,
-0.3903537989,
0.0047361357,
0.2018182874,
0.647254765,
0.0992805138,
0.6347675323,
-0.054916095,
-0.1012374088,
0.1368522644,
-0.1211059988,
-0.6372531056,
-0.4035271406,
-0.2161216736,
-0.5719802976,
0.0747925788,
-0.4575476944,
-0.3723917007,
-0.171207428,
-0.4635488987,
0.57347399,
-0.1270325631,
-0.4534379542,
0.1363476664,
0.1903995425,
0.0298190378,
0.3530356288,
-0.8171553612,
0.606869936,
0.3571147025,
0.808031261,
-0.2164642662,
-0.7078291774,
-0.679659307,
-0.1317324042,
-0.5611833334,
0.9540627003,
-0.4469437301,
-0.3177782893,
0.0353056677,
0.0632973388,
-0.2943502963,
-0.6167109013,
0.4543139637,
-0.0354036726,
0.3284659684,
-0.071899645,
-0.3366521597,
-0.0147935934,
-0.2963150144,
-0.2623027563,
0.8034882545,
0.1875631511,
-0.5796191692,
0.6987960935,
-0.6287531257,
-0.4067189395,
-0.008405406,
0.0396050774,
-0.4073592722,
0.1881687939,
0.4516499341,
0.5105828047,
0.30156973,
0.0273724236,
-0.4844073355,
-0.2417244464,
0.1230241656,
-0.480576694,
0.5817109346,
0.3156886399,
-0.2267353833,
0.3289451003,
-0.8657553196,
0.2360295057,
-0.1404615939,
-0.0635027885,
-0.1443727911,
0.0587407611,
0.0744768307,
0.3230388761,
0.0128445877,
-0.3981622159,
-0.1811040342,
-0.6077466607,
0.3271488547,
0.6579443216,
-0.2856189609,
0.3950388134,
0.0629668683,
0.6753979325,
0.1199668869,
0.1980492622,
-0.3430007398,
-0.132726565,
-0.9337412715,
-0.1126275361,
0.4204557836,
0.4928265512,
-0.51170367,
-0.0257475656,
-0.3162381351,
-0.3352046311,
-0.8943878412,
0.3857262135,
0.703543067,
0.3188612759,
0.3568794131,
-0.1834857464,
-0.5580582023,
-0.8724508882,
-0.4312822521,
0.0595820993,
0.0175854042,
0.2669987082,
0.3400544822,
-0.2279505134,
0.4584070742,
-0.1837611794,
-0.5482707024,
-0.3885393143,
-0.0307199862,
0.1749631464,
0.3937441707,
0.9776100516,
-0.4581453502,
-0.8374818563,
0.1188709512,
-0.6472221017,
0.0716332868,
0.1506551653,
0.2605943978,
0.3543623686,
0.6837557554,
0.2824428976,
0.5277796388,
1.1412307024,
0.0113404226,
0.3952184916,
-0.464053601,
0.0831944048,
-0.9217243195,
-0.3443214297,
-0.311173439,
-0.3499400616,
-0.810587585,
-0.3309612572,
0.1115417629,
-0.3731206059,
-0.7134336829,
0.6132597327,
-0.9103412032,
-0.5000748038,
-0.3791299462,
0.1837583929,
-0.2978626788,
0.3681726158,
0.4147571027,
1.0932279825,
1.2299338579,
-0.7243794799,
-0.1188013181,
0.0913305581,
-0.6342874169,
0.2754530311,
-0.5900169611,
0.3393916786,
0.1376967579,
0.0338905714,
-0.7238289714,
-0.1383171827,
-0.1939817369,
-0.3665947914,
0.3974785805,
-0.3072175682,
-0.2020276487,
-0.2686842382,
0.0102723995,
0.4143540561,
0.3779593706,
-0.7150743604,
0.6268046498,
0.4000529647,
-0.5113193989,
-0.6643102765,
-0.5140447021,
0.1170836613,
-0.1378933787,
-0.2508556247,
0.1072475463,
-0.1701561511,
-0.2070555389,
-0.0494176857,
-0.1911081374,
-0.1760521382,
0.2255552858,
0.2831805348,
-0.0566545986,
-0.6199650168,
-0.0279034805,
-0.0020429811,
-0.2726250589,
-0.2234188914,
-0.2873414755,
0.3623169661,
-0.3328494132,
-0.3746638894,
-0.4348281324,
0.3719765246,
0.1484418213,
-0.2748681307,
0.6948491335,
0.7191995382,
-0.2057776451,
-0.1933808923,
-0.456889838,
-0.1002107784,
-0.5191022754,
0.615803659,
-0.6634800434,
-0.8459771872,
0.4959695339,
-0.0577053688,
-0.1582296491,
0.3183309138,
0.4212851822,
-0.0707215518,
1.0079391003,
1.1214305162,
-0.1723776311,
0.5335199237,
0.1028602272,
0.0388057306,
-0.5596599579,
0.1740136743,
-0.635697186,
0.1616461873,
-0.7915079594,
-0.0875980482,
0.3484213948,
0.1115608886,
0.1191180572,
0.3628432155,
-0.3654862046,
0.4617128372,
0.5308178067,
-0.1685488075,
0.0491869561,
-0.0978972763,
-0.044831086,
-0.2041631043,
-0.9894414544,
-0.2789603174,
1.1724517345,
0.1145818308,
0.7791100144,
0.0769596174,
0.7329186797,
0.0179186072,
0.3475694656,
-0.58013767,
0.227398172,
-0.5737153292,
-0.5469071269,
-0.3121009469,
-0.1507454365,
-1.1435866356,
0.3015521765,
-0.5406816602,
-0.7415747643,
0.2656434774,
0.2753274739,
-0.4724068344,
0.1033346355,
-1.1139578819,
0.8318521976,
-0.4841631949,
-0.1429886669,
-0.1481074542,
-0.545184195,
0.0674730539,
-0.6134767532,
0.5717529058,
-0.1034514159,
0.2985029519,
0.9787200093,
-0.0506799482,
0.735044241,
-0.1465082318,
-0.1681598425,
0.1568509191,
0.0077749938,
0.1687213033,
-0.14221026,
0.0901481733,
0.4505521059,
0.1836050898,
-0.419431448,
-0.2984205186,
0.5904893279,
-1.0608025789,
-0.636752069,
-0.3955796361,
-0.4374145567,
-0.4521917701,
0.5827369094,
0.4637030661,
0.6126951575,
-0.3575690985,
0.170052439,
0.4298080504,
-0.5341851115,
0.504155457,
1.0480765104,
-0.5030373931,
-0.0205774028,
0.5996677876,
0.4418672621,
0.4921900332,
0.4084421694,
0.3214467466,
-0.4724805057,
-0.7952612042,
-0.2322285175,
0.1584452391,
-0.7310240865,
0.0683704987,
-0.7963526249,
-0.2415864766,
-0.9411420822,
-0.1158581004,
-0.6520633698,
-0.3082781732,
-0.3264235258,
-0.1191377491,
0.3132965565,
0.9365075827,
-0.4946731627,
0.5059455633,
-0.6167023778,
0.5076312423,
0.420704186,
0.4655977488,
-0.3370780945,
-1.1208082438,
-0.2122480124,
0.0148575213,
0.188923806,
-0.6101872921,
0.3222351074,
0.8134711981,
0.7015451193,
0.3475525379,
0.0606122352,
1.0848021507,
-0.7606188059,
0.3808746338,
0.1398389339,
-1.0250852108,
0.583432436,
-0.3387204111,
0.388143152,
0.5174961686,
0.4382324219,
-0.1819558293,
-0.2714696229,
-0.5020878315,
-0.4586637914,
0.822095871,
0.0658927932,
0.2757102251,
0.3945244849,
-0.0191991813,
0.344897598,
-0.0471563227,
-0.788574934,
-0.3170664608,
-0.5181926489,
0.1265631616,
-0.6709837914,
-0.1919543743,
0.05698625,
-0.3105257452,
0.4169316292,
-0.2282058001,
0.2038807124,
-0.1143281013,
-0.284455508,
-0.0696347207,
0.4450525343,
0.5604787469,
0.7249754071,
-0.1822007746,
0.1881453693,
0.6234150529,
-0.6209548116,
-0.0068601402,
0.1788794398,
0.2457178235,
0.10195788,
0.8937118649,
1.141518712,
0.6260282397,
-0.5535937548,
0.4898226559,
-0.1321931928,
-0.3408780992,
-0.4997267127,
0.2520036399,
0.1809571832,
0.1281089634,
0.118536517,
0.2151470482,
0.0553362705,
-0.7870860696,
0.1183618903,
0.2246121913,
-0.5099142194,
-0.4587303102,
0.6510745287,
0.03904799,
-0.4425263405,
0.2875510752,
0.0118025681,
-0.5489038229,
0.2236122638,
0.6056223512,
0.6949865818,
-0.5716255903,
0.000725832,
0.3483343422,
0.3301368058,
0.0672729537,
0.2040771842,
-0.307670325,
-0.8609881401,
-0.4759688675,
-0.597240448,
-0.3646822572,
0.1382437199,
-1.115267992,
0.1800103486,
0.0940149054,
-0.0647756085,
0.3835760653,
-0.0663851425,
-1.1034237146,
0.3163465559,
0.2279777825,
0.6382814646,
-1.1728861332,
1.1056724787,
0.526740849,
0.2224336565,
-0.9714063406,
-0.067421928,
-0.1669175178,
-0.9707527757,
0.6661917567,
-0.0186188538,
-0.5587006211,
0.1721421033,
-0.2872582674,
-1.1446130276,
0.5643138289,
0.5778384209,
-0.7866156101,
0.4883773923,
-0.068071492,
0.7789775729,
-0.1984713674,
0.2498751283,
0.3635389209,
0.1912810802,
-0.4290766418,
-1.4437390566,
-0.6201624274,
-0.0287417416,
-0.4192071557,
-0.2230804414,
-0.4149326086,
0.728197515,
-0.4722267687,
-0.2869754136,
-0.0418306775,
0.7713805437,
0.0253357794,
0.3219334185,
0.5740504861,
0.0208663903,
0.5420433283,
0.0172096323,
0.836796999,
-0.2287149876,
0.1070166156,
1.6084661484,
-0.4976325333,
0.912102282,
0.1282442659,
-0.5118274093,
0.2596719861,
0.5304405689,
0.2358291894,
0.620960176,
-0.2306593359,
-0.0792535022,
-0.4306000769,
-0.2631470859,
-0.6766953468,
0.6134907007,
0.278013289,
-0.0000223541,
-0.1234253719,
0.4815166295,
-0.0077077355,
0.2993592918,
-0.5414685011,
0.9223258495,
0.2061981261,
-0.670453012,
0.6965730786,
-0.3594868481,
0.7536112666,
-0.6102698445,
0.3715855777,
-0.1801584661,
0.412814647,
-0.3945673108,
-0.7992892861,
0.0513888523,
0.2333407551,
-0.0334026702,
-0.2922039628,
0.8281490803,
-0.2920856476,
-0.6850020289,
0.8670660257,
0.8269606233,
0.3321387172,
0.0423008911,
-0.8140819073,
-0.0598143898,
0.0553059839,
-0.0918310732,
0.6708108187,
0.4846772254,
0.0685396045,
0.7674242854,
0.6077376008,
0.2222271711,
0.4363082945,
0.5136455297,
0.7583298683,
-0.3885851204,
-0.654300034,
-0.4432693422,
0.0320519805,
0.3194628954,
-0.3566972911,
1.0282161236,
0.5756155849,
1.078417182,
-0.325027734,
0.6228403449,
0.5428270102,
0.8757033348,
-0.5698322654,
0.5429516435,
-0.632566452,
-0.1583875269,
-0.7887251377,
-0.8564267755,
-0.1296803802,
0.7782052159,
-0.4429441392,
0.1674474925,
0.6070894599,
0.7596178651,
-0.3016400039,
-0.217078045,
0.5946444869,
0.39129439,
-0.1367080361,
0.2397164851,
1.0367233753,
-0.2128931433,
0.4910042882,
-0.3581010401,
-0.0274384208,
0.119454205,
-1.0583744049,
-0.9238896966,
-0.5320557952,
-0.3761109412,
0.0291148182,
0.1390134394,
0.5237987041,
1.1206579208,
-1.1176253557,
-0.3254257739,
0.2110660672,
-0.2478337884,
-0.3488463759,
-0.0723868012,
0.4868350327,
-0.1265690625,
-0.6201348305,
0.9097360373,
0.306938827,
0.3397842348,
-0.0319754221,
-0.1669054776,
0.1087964252,
-0.1306371987,
0.5406222343,
0.3914709687,
-0.5216725469,
-0.3019309342,
0.0384628884,
0.3042492568,
0.1401591748,
0.5873086452,
-0.7984813452,
0.6155841947,
-0.1602904946,
0.1608662307,
0.7495524287,
-0.1472034007,
0.3385389447,
-0.5867794752,
0.7228535414,
0.0630602762,
0.3611041009,
0.3710459471,
-0.0541274063,
0.3959157169,
-0.0983539298,
-0.4002194703,
-1.0650393963,
0.1821589917,
-0.8262375593,
-0.4282295704,
1.061226368,
-0.3642905354,
0.1586383879,
-0.5051509738,
-0.0214320719,
0.2510685623,
-0.0621556863,
0.3970692456,
0.496124059,
-0.1519390643,
-0.2129006684,
-0.6538137794,
0.7110274434,
0.4231697321,
-0.5639305711,
0.0040527107,
-0.0306441057,
0.4092771113,
0.029361546,
0.8911712766,
0.1011510864,
0.179307878,
0.1869651079,
-0.1742459089,
0.1939494759,
-0.6239961982,
-0.6485013962,
-0.2123406678,
0.3774062693,
-0.0692061707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12599v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12599v6 | Abstract Meaning Representation-Based Logic-Driven Data Augmentation for Logical Reasoning | 2023-05-21T23:16:26 | 2024-06-06T23:17:32 | Qiming Bao, Alex Yuxuan Peng, Zhenyun Deng, Wanjun Zhong, Gael Gendron, Timothy Pistotti, Neset Tan, Nathan Young, Yang Chen, Yonghua Zhu, Paul Denny, Michael Witbrock, Jiamou Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Combining large language models with logical reasoning enhances their
capacity to address problems in a robust and reliable manner. Nevertheless, the
intricate nature of logical reasoning poses challenges when gathering reliable
data from the web to build comprehensive training datasets, subsequently
affecting performance on downstream tasks. To address this, we introduce a
novel logic-driven data augmentation approach, AMR-LDA. AMR-LDA converts the
original text into an Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) graph, a structured
semantic representation that encapsulates the logical structure of the
sentence, upon which operations are performed to generate logically modified
AMR graphs. The modified AMR graphs are subsequently converted back into text
to create augmented data. Notably, our methodology is architecture-agnostic and
enhances both generative large language models, such as GPT-3.5 and GPT-4,
through prompt augmentation, and discriminative large language models through
contrastive learning with logic-driven data augmentation. Empirical evidence
underscores the efficacy of our proposed method with improvement in performance
across seven downstream tasks, such as reading comprehension requiring logical
reasoning, textual entailment, and natural language inference. Furthermore, our
method leads on the ReClor leaderboard at
https://eval.ai/web/challenges/challenge-page/503/leaderboard/1347. The source
code and data are publicly available at
https://github.com/Strong-AI-Lab/Logical-Equivalence-driven-AMR-Data-Augmentation-for-Representation-Learning. | [
-0.1947855353,
-0.9238753319,
0.5528937578,
-0.2787876427,
-0.2714933157,
0.0980242267,
-0.0542600863,
-0.6441107392,
0.2793019712,
0.4468074143,
-0.629022181,
-0.4242797196,
-0.5203459263,
0.3428575695,
-0.2799299359,
0.6041709781,
0.0233880561,
-0.0450576209,
-0.0964963734,
-0.3390982449,
-0.6465597749,
-0.5529831648,
-0.4917597771,
-0.4855594337,
0.4324714839,
-0.0990198627,
0.8579531908,
0.7836976647,
0.3146855533,
0.3630025089,
0.1360775232,
0.4761928916,
-0.2248169333,
0.0213972274,
-0.5518219471,
-0.3639484644,
-0.4575093091,
-0.0494902208,
0.6472669244,
0.806055963,
-0.0855775848,
-0.1119213104,
-0.2977112532,
0.9738480449,
-0.6393862963,
0.543268919,
-0.7171944976,
-0.0456322916,
-0.0509001762,
-0.1331834197,
-0.4643082619,
-0.1991720349,
-0.0708147138,
-0.7901072502,
-0.2358714789,
0.1239718497,
0.7043440342,
0.4016308784,
-0.5550346971,
-0.2654205263,
-0.6135790348,
0.7344808578,
-0.5338386297,
0.5926115513,
-0.1057220846,
0.3726200163,
0.0443531051,
-0.4980807006,
-1.1054531336,
0.0757995322,
-0.2191292197,
0.1570557058,
-0.3986778855,
0.0271883626,
0.5137902498,
0.3832631111,
-0.3895575404,
-0.105061695,
-0.324010402,
-0.0774460137,
0.564109683,
0.1421968341,
0.3597373664,
-0.0870656446,
-0.3144372106,
-0.2281971127,
-0.7295882106,
-0.1812937707,
0.4673285782,
0.493757695,
-0.0470087975,
0.8469009995,
-0.4276837707,
0.9814975858,
-0.1643678248,
0.1542964578,
0.7670072317,
-0.4556336105,
-0.1148054227,
0.260638088,
0.5803486109,
0.2569509447,
0.2638021111,
0.0201653298,
-0.4748817086,
0.5401595831,
0.1104834452,
-0.700581789,
-0.3030011952,
0.1638531536,
-0.2358548343,
-0.1102826297,
0.1333216131,
-0.5242031217,
-0.5036982894,
-0.7249997854,
0.4264292121,
-0.6295005679,
-0.2022963166,
0.4261543453,
-0.068495512,
0.3023864031,
0.6730111837,
-0.7049609423,
0.3190771937,
0.6629135609,
0.5177967548,
-0.0431991629,
-0.0290225018,
-0.8199475408,
0.3780876398,
-0.2863160968,
0.7714913487,
-0.8714197874,
0.1064760536,
-0.0809038505,
-0.2930975556,
-0.1562426686,
-0.5830987692,
0.5865508914,
-0.7941192985,
0.1776812077,
-0.1060227305,
-0.7610136271,
-0.313862592,
0.4019114077,
-0.9022536278,
0.5655664206,
0.1684442312,
-0.8379907608,
0.1780192703,
-0.655041337,
-0.602864325,
-0.007629998,
-0.5057439208,
-0.0519121587,
-0.260412097,
0.5541000962,
0.239405632,
-0.2579666376,
-0.0968506485,
-0.1201101243,
-0.3245958984,
0.4037927687,
-0.401257962,
0.7767893672,
0.0600211285,
-0.0983254313,
0.3318159282,
-0.8966711164,
0.0292057544,
0.0915345624,
-0.3759053648,
-0.1997232288,
0.1863051057,
-0.2562136054,
0.4007677138,
0.2898799181,
-0.7615774274,
-0.0332548283,
-0.8221412301,
0.243742466,
0.8721756935,
-0.2102104127,
0.2022179514,
-0.1820809692,
0.2530930638,
0.433106631,
-0.3106339276,
-0.2570412159,
-0.4767547548,
-0.6985335946,
-0.2766992748,
0.2052141428,
0.8848688602,
-1.0371366739,
0.8973975778,
-0.5107389092,
-0.0274399705,
-0.7118538618,
0.2799494267,
0.224679023,
0.9232386351,
0.7342220545,
-0.0508791395,
-0.5060011744,
-0.7707103491,
-0.1272900552,
-0.3017947972,
-0.1459446102,
0.1120273322,
0.3859008551,
-0.558594346,
0.8305757046,
-0.723328054,
-0.4483190179,
-0.4567159414,
-0.1160806492,
0.421313107,
0.4350736737,
0.0649505109,
-0.8395828605,
-0.1194983125,
0.1786929965,
-0.8726087213,
-0.0623418838,
-0.0158983432,
-0.0565796457,
0.2440657169,
0.2060059458,
-0.7958859205,
0.5356018543,
0.2112826258,
-0.4968042076,
0.5759809017,
-0.1786382496,
0.2651467621,
-0.8470453024,
-0.0436119288,
-0.0039171916,
-0.1319290102,
-0.3930350542,
0.1668107361,
-0.0102830026,
-0.2706183791,
-0.151290983,
0.5325117707,
-0.0956341475,
0.0556564778,
-0.3260423839,
0.3423914313,
0.1808174402,
0.3995318413,
0.040337909,
0.6343137622,
0.4823093414,
-0.472594291,
0.7529700398,
0.4302218556,
-0.1988358349,
0.4449228346,
-0.575006485,
-0.1172451079,
-0.1851996779,
0.4168035388,
-0.7252952456,
-0.1441962868,
0.4883483946,
-0.4468827248,
-0.0080268895,
0.1163451672,
-0.7824446559,
-0.1406210065,
-0.0942133218,
0.4193401337,
0.5880602598,
-0.7362735868,
0.9337725639,
0.1546157897,
0.0856854022,
-0.4042611718,
-0.7215204239,
0.0048645367,
0.0076966034,
-0.9357665777,
0.3970856369,
0.1589219868,
-0.4508733451,
0.1602528393,
-0.0199503098,
0.2057495564,
-0.1901886016,
-0.205908969,
0.3927994072,
-0.1208976358,
0.2394596189,
0.0663661882,
-0.441172272,
0.3151551485,
-0.3123266101,
0.3029533923,
-0.0184959713,
-0.5959922671,
-0.5219623446,
0.2528522015,
0.0884763673,
-0.5346736908,
0.7446342707,
0.4786827266,
-0.5085083246,
-0.3636655211,
-0.289064467,
-0.2250104249,
-0.4635649621,
0.1082126424,
-0.4696644545,
-0.7314725518,
0.4512787759,
0.0127861844,
-0.0893039554,
0.3742068112,
0.2203125507,
0.1248405278,
1.1752477884,
0.0722260699,
0.1300680339,
0.1963629872,
-0.0991907865,
0.4850317836,
-0.6532700062,
-0.1842382401,
-0.1475421786,
-0.1228514314,
-0.5240977407,
-0.6903734803,
0.2300781757,
-0.1674067825,
-0.2493321449,
-0.150244236,
-0.4477253556,
0.2286782712,
0.3522721827,
0.3689535856,
0.5623121262,
0.1513333321,
0.0753002688,
0.0006621692,
-0.2543386221,
-0.360168606,
0.8420570493,
0.1507714093,
0.8170212507,
0.4114199579,
0.3990289867,
0.4285811484,
-0.0537288301,
-0.8237688541,
0.7453215718,
-0.2011495829,
-0.2719317377,
-0.0816162825,
-0.70966959,
-0.6193165183,
0.44429636,
-0.4051724374,
-0.5947161317,
-0.0624815747,
0.3126290441,
0.1392242759,
0.3423448205,
-0.7749987245,
0.7111158371,
-0.0649142489,
-0.3808598518,
-0.5222465396,
-0.6177350879,
0.316170752,
-0.000227466,
0.1297001541,
0.0828052759,
-0.0772603601,
0.4932748377,
-0.6801380515,
0.6334486604,
-0.3205345869,
-0.0584146492,
0.3079375327,
-0.1972219646,
0.8429949284,
-0.1335709393,
-0.321311295,
-0.2232359499,
-0.4047908783,
-0.5209079981,
-1.1967705488,
0.5512850285,
-0.5769914985,
-0.7426559925,
-0.4729664326,
-0.5179694295,
-0.359364897,
0.2287534475,
-0.4734321237,
0.6999031305,
0.3047893941,
0.0403452367,
0.7969128489,
-0.2731068134,
-0.1743234843,
0.2178263962,
-0.184501946,
-0.47788167,
1.0964105129,
-0.1485786885,
0.2520479858,
0.7827284932,
0.1892672479,
-0.6345077157,
-0.6525812745,
-0.5590613484,
0.1624756753,
-1.0794315338,
-0.103098698,
-0.6101208925,
-0.252702415,
-0.3515605927,
-0.0711782277,
-0.0127518913,
-0.5834646225,
-0.0616746657,
-0.411671102,
0.5911589265,
0.4713519216,
0.0957386643,
0.0050574215,
-0.5635381937,
0.4636640549,
0.2256462127,
0.2175608873,
-0.0322808996,
-0.2874465883,
-0.070249334,
0.099431023,
-0.0144690294,
-0.7250198722,
0.2521746755,
0.0049769208,
0.4046144187,
0.1841333807,
0.1083877757,
0.6201095581,
-0.5018197298,
0.4075733125,
0.2464630008,
-0.8438417912,
0.6973336935,
-0.3643180728,
0.360431999,
0.3732650876,
-0.0122202095,
-0.052886907,
-0.173676759,
-0.4070836008,
-0.8241373897,
0.5647245646,
0.3615697324,
0.161624819,
-0.0159449503,
0.2378130853,
-0.1138608754,
0.2250774503,
-0.761207819,
-0.3468711674,
-0.4488522708,
-0.6164562106,
0.2659994662,
0.2061737627,
0.0926941559,
-0.3590813279,
0.7804458141,
-0.2999662757,
0.1469552219,
0.0788353235,
-0.140743345,
0.2292191088,
0.4558587372,
-0.0134158013,
0.8359031677,
-0.1626481563,
0.3175863624,
-0.0732352734,
-0.3035748899,
0.0801457167,
0.7524087429,
-0.2194156498,
-0.2564575374,
0.4920316935,
0.769813478,
-0.1186415106,
-1.1761906147,
0.3893898427,
0.1810078025,
0.0485581085,
-0.2233514339,
0.2185890973,
-0.1068869233,
0.2125373334,
0.4287275374,
-0.0037038138,
0.2699733973,
-0.4465017021,
0.3293110728,
0.3302571774,
-0.2796573937,
-0.2313125134,
0.6285385489,
0.1908886582,
0.2077144086,
0.8690808415,
-0.4034102261,
-0.4082816541,
0.2698230147,
0.7006712556,
0.4202149212,
0.0683441609,
0.1053388491,
0.3977392614,
0.1166103631,
0.4101861417,
0.4244225025,
0.1379436404,
-1.0787369013,
-0.5901649594,
-0.6110795736,
-0.1875824034,
-0.1093442142,
-0.2682622373,
0.1909613758,
-0.4982757568,
0.3112582266,
0.0798597485,
0.1616432816,
-0.4595580399,
0.5099826455,
0.1072923392,
0.8731352091,
-0.7571430802,
0.7454648614,
0.830121696,
-0.5996038914,
-0.8286072016,
-0.1744374782,
-0.0794089213,
-0.6486387253,
0.6420205832,
0.3630974889,
-0.2692121863,
0.0437211506,
-0.1339635402,
-0.4906373024,
1.0255442858,
0.4690617919,
-0.336990267,
0.1363013387,
0.2666257322,
0.4562197626,
-0.5419624448,
-0.0329587795,
0.3711773753,
0.403351903,
0.4131779373,
-0.2003929168,
0.5376447439,
-0.4662214518,
-0.1070039645,
0.2581858039,
-0.2277481407,
0.6339624524,
-0.2592928708,
-0.2761204243,
-0.1818633676,
0.9384849668,
0.8036310077,
0.0933410898,
0.6631036997,
0.9588578343,
0.9326022863,
-0.0479411483,
1.1033827066,
-0.1151429638,
-0.1237987727,
1.0835421085,
-0.4594066143,
0.8867446184,
0.4291281104,
-0.1910826266,
0.8437552452,
0.2547779381,
0.0585631207,
0.4192427397,
0.1698773503,
-0.6084524393,
-0.3565224409,
-0.2236289829,
-0.198482886,
0.2229023576,
0.567605257,
-0.3146283031,
-0.2822701931,
-0.096680589,
-0.172720775,
0.4175659418,
-0.2311882973,
0.59224087,
-0.1376048476,
-0.3810681701,
0.3901762068,
0.1022154242,
0.3500050902,
-0.558957994,
-0.5143524408,
0.1065731049,
0.294750005,
-0.2875057757,
-0.9813230634,
0.3409522772,
-0.062590912,
-0.1926349401,
-0.1569062173,
0.842854023,
-0.2908444405,
-0.6586472988,
0.4233771563,
0.6244622469,
-0.2155338079,
0.0931891203,
-0.814833343,
0.3262996674,
0.0130803213,
0.0011573451,
0.1199072003,
0.591914475,
0.0087961927,
0.7635976076,
0.6293087602,
0.0294537786,
-0.0900158882,
0.3161751926,
1.2064820528,
-0.6707821488,
-0.6396852732,
-0.7522735,
0.5357950926,
-0.1755877882,
0.1952286214,
0.5816021562,
0.6882408857,
0.8298576474,
0.1447060555,
0.9234933853,
-0.297989279,
0.5331838727,
-0.9190354347,
0.269757241,
-0.3351681232,
0.5060406327,
-0.2102721334,
-0.7718437314,
-0.2944740653,
0.6454207301,
-0.5450136065,
-0.0036149637,
0.6137637496,
0.7947829366,
-0.316986829,
0.1170664206,
0.0246189442,
0.254630506,
0.4665531814,
0.5120604038,
0.691003263,
-0.3921439946,
0.4518315792,
-0.0956105813,
-0.2288934141,
0.3065128922,
-0.5891091228,
-0.7808645368,
-0.4803653359,
-0.412711978,
-0.4020168781,
0.2455799878,
0.955067873,
0.3056857586,
-0.7879307866,
0.0633454546,
-0.3531965613,
0.3214372694,
-0.1385017633,
-0.2723929882,
0.4438369572,
-0.423604995,
-0.535245955,
0.471826911,
0.1253738999,
-0.1160861328,
-0.1776299775,
-0.1702332795,
-0.4461034536,
0.0351405405,
0.769870162,
0.0710865855,
-0.6366128325,
-0.3485422432,
-0.3672382236,
0.2682154179,
0.2287677079,
0.4277795255,
-1.226811409,
0.557351172,
0.6546018124,
1.0975595713,
0.212859571,
0.3926703036,
0.6352009177,
-0.6633211374,
0.0750693753,
0.1466339231,
0.4082374871,
0.6326460242,
-0.2598361075,
0.5591027141,
0.4379507005,
-0.0133422371,
-0.5753362179,
0.5344110727,
-0.9537501931,
-0.2701162994,
0.8735622764,
-0.1114949882,
-0.2301029861,
-0.1298252642,
-0.0027545656,
0.0868621171,
-0.5565971732,
0.4611628056,
0.3879932463,
-0.452395618,
-0.2067551911,
-0.3874085248,
0.2165298015,
0.1853510588,
-1.1244935989,
0.2255151719,
1.0208333731,
-0.1543404162,
0.2303308845,
0.4964069426,
-0.2380267978,
0.1217478067,
-0.0955881178,
-0.3825919926,
-0.1459042728,
-0.1223073006,
-0.2182505429,
0.0737968162,
-0.1400329024,
0.0510536544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12594v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12594v1 | Modeling User Satisfaction Dynamics in Dialogue via Hawkes Process | 2023-05-21T23:04:14 | 2023-05-21T23:04:14 | Fanghua Ye, Zhiyuan Hu, Emine Yilmaz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue systems have received increasing attention while automatically
evaluating their performance remains challenging. User satisfaction estimation
(USE) has been proposed as an alternative. It assumes that the performance of a
dialogue system can be measured by user satisfaction and uses an estimator to
simulate users. The effectiveness of USE depends heavily on the estimator.
Existing estimators independently predict user satisfaction at each turn and
ignore satisfaction dynamics across turns within a dialogue. In order to fully
simulate users, it is crucial to take satisfaction dynamics into account. To
fill this gap, we propose a new estimator ASAP (sAtisfaction eStimation via
HAwkes Process) that treats user satisfaction across turns as an event sequence
and employs a Hawkes process to effectively model the dynamics in this
sequence. Experimental results on four benchmark dialogue datasets demonstrate
that ASAP can substantially outperform state-of-the-art baseline estimators. | [
-0.4029370248,
-0.2337495685,
0.7201889753,
0.1581827402,
-0.0796544775,
0.0340112485,
0.2469024211,
-0.456207484,
0.4601145983,
0.3960078359,
-0.7601478696,
-0.0090325288,
-0.5852506161,
0.3526852429,
-0.4244688451,
0.6454964876,
0.1690923721,
-0.1266458035,
-0.2771875858,
0.0598588958,
-0.2022847533,
-0.4342567623,
-0.8345918059,
-0.5226609111,
0.3934661448,
0.1515749246,
1.0089764595,
-0.1505154967,
0.1292738318,
0.3311489224,
-0.2945411503,
0.2209012359,
-0.3550974131,
0.7024790049,
0.0673400387,
-0.2510938644,
-0.0913933069,
0.1877715141,
0.6159914732,
0.7220531702,
-0.4984603524,
-0.040502701,
0.3216788471,
0.2769048512,
-0.686440587,
0.3067958355,
-0.2335498333,
0.3555451334,
0.1487731934,
-0.4033545554,
-0.5512112975,
-0.5299575329,
0.3825051188,
-0.5409755707,
-0.4550258517,
0.0246317573,
0.7399722338,
0.337718159,
-0.5506582856,
-0.2576033771,
-0.7912791371,
0.7289276123,
-0.9008609056,
0.2955412865,
0.3923529685,
0.2501687706,
-0.6316749454,
-0.7342345715,
-0.5259256959,
-0.3402891159,
0.0645095706,
0.2740877271,
-0.2370425463,
0.2379772216,
0.3650604486,
0.1585323215,
-0.2562870681,
-0.1998868585,
0.1828798056,
0.2380188406,
0.6009045243,
0.545796752,
0.087159805,
-0.5853019357,
-0.4399242401,
0.1856616735,
-0.003635624,
0.6746366024,
0.1632969826,
0.0450200476,
0.180374071,
0.6801890731,
-0.2443739772,
0.4717072845,
0.1339339018,
-0.1791679859,
0.2416775227,
0.0024996495,
-0.1358140558,
-0.5995646119,
0.9334316254,
0.5310584903,
-0.0340291411,
-0.2399276793,
-0.4756328166,
-0.0819755569,
0.4680835009,
-0.4652385116,
-0.2704842091,
0.3081714511,
-0.1741021872,
-0.1254741699,
-0.1624242961,
-0.694907546,
-0.4130547047,
-0.4695429504,
0.5281035304,
-0.4412874877,
-0.0597246103,
-0.0782373473,
-0.1213611811,
0.1141268313,
0.5437168479,
-0.5864659548,
0.5271689296,
0.587146759,
0.9285344481,
-0.3676508069,
-0.1198405698,
-0.8905906677,
-0.166225329,
-0.3424108922,
0.6521776319,
-0.5982044935,
-0.6091282368,
0.0213749241,
-0.2566382587,
-0.0210358314,
-0.461956203,
0.4625252187,
-0.6256577969,
0.2039941996,
-0.0053594336,
-0.7514687777,
0.1033851951,
0.1919924617,
-0.1304852813,
1.1844135523,
-0.1299579591,
-0.3268937171,
0.0986217633,
-0.6588635445,
-0.1388274729,
0.0702171475,
0.132215023,
-0.1552533209,
0.5027254224,
0.063433513,
0.1046333611,
-0.1638400257,
0.3258342147,
-0.397113055,
-0.2285262048,
0.5839290619,
-0.3613452017,
0.6279278398,
0.2338125557,
0.034061227,
0.1054403856,
-0.4159666598,
0.0192984566,
-0.4863808453,
-0.1760790348,
-0.0952140838,
0.1499024183,
-0.1437198669,
0.2806329429,
0.1617047191,
-0.5890501738,
0.332691133,
-0.4781883061,
-0.1748230308,
0.6799458861,
0.3721064329,
0.2621230781,
-0.3157917559,
0.8808835745,
-0.0479647443,
0.4604940414,
-0.3150025308,
-1.0463926792,
-0.7449611425,
-0.170155555,
0.3451206088,
0.3688353002,
-0.6125484705,
0.2593471408,
0.1647900343,
-0.1679092199,
-0.3000623584,
-0.418391645,
0.2496608645,
0.1994105279,
0.145507291,
-0.9367281795,
-0.3377464116,
-0.3939896524,
-0.3891358972,
-0.5141510367,
-0.3411141038,
0.4850164354,
-0.0190040525,
-0.3299253881,
1.258556366,
-0.542930007,
-0.0624862723,
0.0195077825,
1.1137524843,
0.1852997094,
0.2274262458,
0.1333902776,
-0.7294755578,
-0.3004819751,
-0.2928064466,
-0.7413652539,
-0.3989340067,
-0.128474161,
0.0292511284,
0.4621121883,
0.0129251024,
-0.3889264464,
0.9438990355,
0.5466709137,
-0.3425859809,
0.84409374,
-0.081603907,
0.5544903874,
-1.0254653692,
0.0537387952,
0.139977783,
-0.5144988298,
-0.5735234022,
0.0172738526,
-0.4431584775,
-0.4253109694,
-0.5679929852,
0.4955905974,
-0.420234412,
-0.6384983063,
-0.4693339169,
-0.0175954793,
-0.1634264886,
0.5703536272,
0.0146396738,
0.7981399894,
0.2798587084,
-0.4867947102,
0.4900350273,
0.6955472827,
-0.2819747925,
0.3126594722,
-0.6894456744,
-0.2114168108,
-0.0019686446,
0.2756592631,
-1.373467803,
-0.2256071121,
0.1631703526,
-0.7387487888,
-0.1071341783,
-0.5606069565,
-0.2804494798,
-0.2416414618,
-0.0988895372,
0.0676548108,
0.9080855846,
-0.3474655449,
1.1072821617,
0.6252128482,
-0.3937409222,
-0.4438292384,
-0.2675835788,
0.3652111292,
0.0262172706,
-0.6274781823,
-0.0375411063,
-0.0522413962,
0.0937613249,
-0.3644172251,
-0.2276646942,
-0.1232198998,
-0.0298334435,
0.6299518943,
0.304692626,
0.1674223393,
-0.234085992,
-0.1652461588,
-0.4632377923,
0.1812780946,
-0.145854637,
0.5684510469,
0.0255531576,
-0.400277406,
-1.3078384399,
0.3523153067,
0.6340608001,
0.0235150326,
0.7518037558,
0.0272663031,
-0.18261756,
0.3736981153,
-0.506147027,
-0.3800694048,
-0.4892015457,
-0.0794850141,
-0.4414642751,
-0.4953607321,
0.8736533523,
-0.50163275,
0.2676469088,
0.1346312761,
0.2013335228,
-0.4675574005,
1.537840724,
0.4538946152,
0.283038944,
0.5730420947,
-0.1371370554,
-0.0136883873,
-0.9408256412,
-0.2533225715,
-0.6318089962,
-0.4416532516,
-0.4030744433,
-0.2532926202,
0.7488526702,
0.2262013555,
-0.020391522,
0.3470909894,
0.1287703514,
0.1734657884,
0.5534133911,
-0.2257730961,
0.3202154934,
-0.1451923549,
-0.2975934744,
-0.3102150261,
-0.6608090401,
-0.4377748072,
0.6072553992,
0.0589058325,
0.9763910174,
0.1716123968,
0.8939993978,
0.5662349463,
0.0704290047,
-0.7123811841,
0.6221877337,
0.026012199,
-0.0877355039,
-0.5318551064,
-0.7130628824,
-0.9467892051,
0.103628248,
-0.2471075952,
-1.3792226315,
0.3851544559,
0.2959543467,
-0.3523338139,
-0.0874102116,
-0.3572146595,
0.8453572989,
0.2757860422,
-0.2854577303,
0.0292616636,
-0.6258544326,
0.0658614635,
0.2004081309,
-0.0035182559,
-0.4026838839,
0.0585015453,
0.5626242161,
-0.5590741038,
0.7636287808,
-0.2130443156,
0.2197352052,
0.1850370914,
0.3432602286,
0.8794580698,
0.1855696291,
-0.328119278,
-0.1650094986,
-0.0361268781,
-0.2807185948,
-0.8736709952,
0.6554386616,
-0.6844092011,
-0.5844723582,
-0.7457305193,
-0.4216672778,
-0.3822838068,
-0.3559867144,
0.1033188552,
0.6896283031,
-0.0539536737,
-0.2324909568,
0.1500189602,
0.0200428441,
0.4283876419,
0.4408155978,
-0.6987064481,
-0.093989782,
0.4953891039,
-0.0019113524,
0.4772959054,
-0.0574752986,
0.1208996549,
-0.6447439194,
-0.0781502277,
-0.3555268645,
-0.0708723292,
-0.2557715476,
-0.0141492803,
-0.8453685641,
-0.2009219974,
-0.0954582244,
-0.1959291995,
-0.5063800216,
-0.7358008623,
-0.2437175512,
0.353461951,
0.0382527225,
0.5991424918,
-0.0803153515,
0.2815684676,
-0.6559963226,
0.4588738978,
0.3533911705,
0.25499174,
-0.0178412013,
-0.82998842,
0.016181156,
0.1096425056,
-0.7273610234,
-1.1100467443,
0.831784904,
0.162801519,
0.4307386875,
0.3414126039,
0.5616490245,
0.7748258114,
-0.3104031384,
1.1494240761,
0.3140086532,
-1.0022103786,
0.6663985848,
-0.2086037099,
0.6562099457,
0.3695587516,
0.6753020883,
-0.9153311253,
-0.8328312039,
-0.6852583289,
-1.0454822779,
1.0244054794,
0.3792328835,
-0.0133420052,
0.0015754706,
0.3678476512,
-0.1351733059,
0.3544707298,
-0.5144810081,
-0.3604690135,
0.1779039949,
-0.0767597109,
-0.0893342718,
-0.3800718784,
0.0820718184,
0.1360334307,
0.9795558453,
-0.1064938977,
0.3194668889,
-0.0186110772,
0.2820032537,
-0.2737790644,
0.0721800551,
0.090106532,
0.7305153012,
-0.1877936721,
-0.1510578543,
0.1214768291,
-0.0174049418,
0.3490017951,
0.1106143594,
-0.362646997,
0.2925606668,
-0.2953586578,
0.6790112853,
0.5975829363,
-0.6479367018,
0.6090680957,
-0.3398357928,
0.3211469054,
-0.6143663526,
0.2438077778,
-0.2163606882,
0.3905565739,
0.5331915617,
0.5288463235,
0.66698879,
-0.4849095047,
0.3797555566,
0.36448282,
-0.8728060722,
-0.1949146837,
0.7081555724,
0.4545274675,
-0.7835609317,
0.5903276801,
-0.1930241138,
-0.3408609629,
0.3304757476,
0.2743746638,
0.9501482844,
-0.5592549443,
0.3529835343,
0.3610307276,
-0.2374956161,
-0.2564035058,
0.3053617477,
-0.0115249082,
-0.5283339024,
-0.5565165877,
-0.9841249585,
-0.9373391867,
-0.2006654143,
-0.8643462062,
0.1755785644,
-0.0110405087,
-0.6719152331,
0.2627891898,
-0.2528977096,
-0.2209708989,
0.0964071378,
-0.0271429513,
0.7792777419,
-0.6598555446,
0.3090035617,
0.4779252708,
-0.2590869069,
-0.5411636233,
0.3309788406,
0.4545345008,
-0.3266508877,
0.3195434213,
0.1062651202,
-0.5451539755,
-0.008687987,
-0.1677126735,
-0.7452506423,
0.6211945415,
0.2233792096,
-0.2917738259,
0.1389662027,
-0.0030760667,
0.5447768569,
-0.4267985225,
0.7895854712,
0.3797502518,
0.1183447391,
0.6725768447,
-0.9135621786,
-0.5708368421,
-0.227858901,
0.3629528284,
0.4175175428,
-0.2863909006,
0.2391567528,
-0.0756984055,
-0.352627933,
0.6580076814,
0.8054841757,
0.2118489146,
0.2901040614,
0.4681120515,
0.4312351942,
0.4436817169,
-0.3238900304,
1.2277128696,
-0.2042478472,
0.454957515,
1.0528922081,
-0.4007838666,
1.1437608004,
0.4654489756,
-0.2167872339,
0.5051790476,
0.4367510974,
0.6335155368,
0.3446002305,
0.0200333428,
-0.5287813544,
-0.4706201255,
-0.1713968366,
0.0337375738,
0.4644412994,
0.1593411267,
-0.1025315598,
0.0854406729,
0.0210976768,
-0.4545893669,
-0.1445800513,
0.0278991796,
1.1977519989,
-0.0304671712,
-1.0655269623,
0.5699444413,
0.0302490201,
0.3765730858,
-0.6883523464,
0.0980625823,
-0.2913676798,
-0.0670327321,
0.0328051411,
-1.0598375797,
0.3455162346,
-0.0152390432,
-0.1028453484,
-0.1165236607,
0.3405947983,
-0.3597042859,
-0.2869118452,
0.304977417,
0.1675901711,
0.5706281066,
0.1736540943,
-0.5163375139,
0.0766982362,
0.1598124504,
-0.5965281129,
0.2432685196,
0.0494876169,
0.3446744084,
1.0442903042,
0.6212835908,
-0.3205154836,
0.07894326,
0.0621915236,
0.5772128105,
-0.5257021785,
-0.7407057881,
-0.4339609742,
0.7939206958,
-0.2988801599,
-0.6865530014,
0.5667025447,
0.5692901611,
0.3666440248,
0.1959393173,
0.4188905358,
0.2110878974,
0.7126046419,
-0.1684757024,
0.325406611,
-0.7451334,
0.3611755073,
-0.3918580413,
-0.9126794338,
0.0008728881,
0.4893510342,
-0.1616460979,
0.0108863106,
0.2389059663,
0.6162461638,
-0.1349436641,
0.6712418795,
0.5071677566,
0.3918357491,
0.1997423172,
0.2945438027,
1.1916053295,
-0.4224770367,
0.1596766114,
0.0906556845,
-0.6987689734,
-0.4765426517,
-0.8223067522,
-0.3555997014,
-0.7523798943,
-0.2895687222,
-0.2513605356,
0.3637334406,
0.9719395638,
0.8113894463,
-0.7351827621,
-0.6170796752,
0.1960476935,
-0.2994987071,
-0.3249123096,
-0.2326430082,
-0.3855482042,
-0.7641842961,
-0.7218034863,
0.4058274925,
0.5592352748,
0.0050405362,
-0.1532318443,
-0.4605804682,
-0.3452739716,
0.4717054963,
0.3651751876,
0.6435351372,
-0.9212777615,
-0.2823139131,
-0.2249840051,
0.0134755932,
0.0816648751,
0.545578897,
-0.9746819735,
0.6405829191,
0.4036868513,
0.4367904961,
1.1055389643,
0.3317221999,
0.9468979836,
-0.9046397805,
-0.1610692143,
0.2485337704,
0.3107890785,
0.1483703554,
-0.1395687014,
0.4902434647,
-0.0251880549,
-0.9971411228,
-0.7292369008,
0.4911754131,
-0.9428538084,
0.1046980396,
0.7501743436,
-0.447334528,
0.076459378,
-0.2041719407,
-0.2109281272,
0.1591867805,
-0.784471035,
1.089163661,
0.5292479992,
-0.889388144,
-0.4028457105,
-0.215021953,
0.6862552762,
0.4939184487,
-0.6856110692,
0.0906236097,
0.6038684249,
-0.15304555,
0.4383238852,
0.5640819073,
0.1571091712,
0.4402440488,
-0.1678356975,
-0.0696418062,
0.2626108229,
-0.5403089523,
-0.2444505095,
0.3418106735,
0.057157062,
-0.0383903459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13342v1 | On the Limitations of Simulating Active Learning | 2023-05-21T22:52:13 | 2023-05-21T22:52:13 | Katerina Margatina, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Active learning (AL) is a human-and-model-in-the-loop paradigm that
iteratively selects informative unlabeled data for human annotation, aiming to
improve over random sampling. However, performing AL experiments with human
annotations on-the-fly is a laborious and expensive process, thus unrealistic
for academic research. An easy fix to this impediment is to simulate AL, by
treating an already labeled and publicly available dataset as the pool of
unlabeled data. In this position paper, we first survey recent literature and
highlight the challenges across all different steps within the AL loop. We
further unveil neglected caveats in the experimental setup that can
significantly affect the quality of AL research. We continue with an
exploration of how the simulation setting can govern empirical findings,
arguing that it might be one of the answers behind the ever posed question
``why do active learning algorithms sometimes fail to outperform random
sampling?''. We argue that evaluating AL algorithms on available labeled
datasets might provide a lower bound as to their effectiveness in real data. We
believe it is essential to collectively shape the best practices for AL
research, particularly as engineering advancements in LLMs push the research
focus towards data-driven approaches (e.g., data efficiency, alignment,
fairness). In light of this, we have developed guidelines for future work. Our
aim is to draw attention to these limitations within the community, in the hope
of finding ways to address them. | [
-0.2999968231,
-0.7754479647,
0.4430150092,
-0.0713053793,
-0.1388838589,
0.0162938088,
-0.2209658176,
-0.5820757151,
-0.0688204616,
0.177449733,
-0.3183064759,
-0.2027847469,
-0.0866295248,
0.0493097678,
-0.3487837911,
0.6848295331,
-0.645398438,
0.0095723402,
-0.3865432739,
-0.3368144929,
-0.1696914732,
-0.6484602094,
-0.4362135828,
-0.2689066529,
0.6310358047,
0.4782830179,
0.7217823267,
0.781981349,
0.4079301953,
0.1135488302,
-0.0845320597,
0.4942274988,
-0.3719713986,
0.1619821787,
0.2193286419,
-0.4821082056,
-0.3050547242,
0.5541549325,
0.7037556767,
1.0706180334,
-0.2161323577,
0.0798430666,
-0.0141591476,
0.3970623016,
-0.7670642734,
-0.0649677441,
-0.3690134883,
0.1956801713,
-0.2168833315,
0.2119900435,
-0.2857946455,
-0.2474571764,
-0.1049417257,
-0.700530827,
0.4547492564,
0.3728935421,
0.9273170233,
0.3329581916,
-0.3073452115,
-0.3746007681,
-1.153126955,
0.7661877871,
-0.5469652414,
0.0674547181,
0.4913620949,
0.4133379459,
0.0344061181,
-0.7339417338,
-0.4873219132,
-0.1119223014,
0.3214580417,
0.0702611282,
-0.0314823911,
0.310869813,
0.4626802802,
0.4090601802,
-0.0577820726,
0.1183027998,
-0.8474820852,
-0.0134521993,
0.779738605,
-0.073605217,
0.0194009431,
0.2870309949,
-0.2903779447,
-0.3304558098,
-0.6742178202,
0.1394787282,
0.668320775,
0.4468566477,
0.2754531801,
0.7223137021,
-0.022169983,
0.5485422015,
-0.272701174,
0.3805880249,
0.4953493178,
0.1018940955,
-0.2260571271,
0.1553770751,
0.4489299655,
0.0113083888,
0.2366633415,
-0.2600711584,
-0.4781249166,
0.1339182556,
0.5040400624,
-0.3406741619,
-0.431833446,
0.3280327618,
-0.2277932167,
-0.194152087,
0.3039206564,
-0.5362135172,
-0.2338929623,
-0.3704138398,
0.6482107639,
0.0230095424,
-0.223465234,
0.026100833,
0.1548028886,
-0.1459974498,
0.5188987851,
-0.2401755303,
0.3461930752,
0.3077486753,
0.6542212963,
-0.3812960684,
-0.3844660819,
-0.3092134893,
0.17361404,
-0.5397211909,
0.5938208699,
-0.5053492785,
-0.4932732582,
-0.0167693421,
-0.2527356744,
-0.0542613082,
-0.8490833044,
0.4940465987,
-0.52667588,
-0.2796943784,
-0.4373916984,
-0.5818225145,
-0.1086386591,
0.0052187615,
-0.9919031262,
0.8848106265,
-0.123751834,
-0.3803239763,
0.3147442937,
-0.8879111409,
-0.2873658836,
-0.2515843809,
-0.3556133807,
-0.7352643013,
0.2209533155,
-0.1636597812,
0.1596247852,
0.1503470838,
0.1063610315,
-0.5441433787,
-0.6367234588,
0.5528095365,
-0.4352788925,
0.5859923363,
0.6126061082,
-0.4369360805,
0.0315389894,
-0.6054685712,
-0.030226713,
-0.1204641089,
-0.3377256989,
-0.2290655673,
0.1563193053,
-0.0808738321,
0.0058128121,
-0.2231766284,
-0.5076870918,
0.4644501805,
0.0481274538,
0.1400213689,
0.8097330332,
0.0957652628,
0.6422008872,
-0.4033610821,
0.6828895807,
-0.0267719869,
0.2581872344,
0.0024424107,
-0.3325266242,
-0.6434831619,
-0.3248972297,
0.7630072832,
0.3352138996,
-0.6577872038,
-0.1187178642,
0.2658150792,
-0.3056927323,
-0.8881517649,
0.3685896993,
0.391731143,
0.0814834014,
0.4433340132,
-0.2263537943,
-0.4597411156,
-0.6983644962,
-0.1941195875,
-0.2363315821,
0.1839835197,
0.5626138449,
0.4410583377,
-0.1196861044,
0.9654762149,
-0.2715324759,
-0.2779578269,
-0.0844930261,
0.4892117381,
-0.3144139946,
0.4185344279,
0.4168142378,
-0.841483891,
-0.0325701535,
-0.3885586858,
-1.0657761097,
-0.0493529849,
-0.1911731064,
-0.0428891405,
-0.1302234679,
0.5582593083,
-0.4950716496,
0.8156349063,
0.4087844789,
0.0085161459,
0.1730852574,
-0.1371584237,
0.0514098406,
-0.3539078534,
0.218827337,
-0.046863649,
0.2835520506,
-0.4519087672,
0.0358900055,
0.0789289027,
-0.2939040959,
-0.4699510634,
0.6237720847,
-0.721141994,
-0.0609183013,
-0.3998054862,
-0.2885195017,
-0.2460421771,
0.2809246182,
-0.2164141387,
0.7622483969,
0.4834047258,
-0.8577235937,
0.2212134302,
-0.0870594159,
-0.2639456391,
-0.0640702769,
-0.6559524536,
0.042548541,
-0.2774142623,
0.4024899006,
-0.7466539145,
-0.3553233743,
0.3344467282,
-0.2415646017,
0.2285468131,
0.0342761688,
-0.5190182924,
-0.3703113198,
-0.2378742248,
0.790070653,
0.7291557193,
-0.4993143678,
0.6307797432,
0.3153863549,
0.5252105594,
-0.6185106039,
-0.4820747972,
-0.2358167619,
-0.148055166,
-0.1800453663,
0.0014502443,
-0.0832777768,
-0.6712212563,
0.2467257082,
-0.2442775071,
-0.0642944127,
0.4316001832,
0.5359548926,
-0.0216447543,
0.107051596,
0.1561980247,
0.0226367246,
0.1698229313,
0.1872955263,
0.1180260777,
-0.0840837136,
0.1472188234,
-0.9670864344,
-0.5451650023,
0.1148914322,
0.2260905802,
-0.1788389683,
0.5388874412,
0.2255325764,
-0.5469989777,
-0.6894915104,
-0.2772891819,
-0.3339676261,
-0.4700629115,
0.0293028597,
-0.0787718445,
-0.4056248665,
0.4419643879,
-0.3379885554,
0.8207060099,
0.1943484992,
0.1468823999,
-0.6340716481,
0.9796946645,
0.4651680887,
0.4524925351,
0.4002722204,
-0.5910043716,
0.2461025268,
-0.6836993694,
-0.2462560385,
-0.3459271491,
-0.7573291659,
0.0101879705,
-0.6595821381,
0.271402061,
0.3215444088,
0.1669666171,
-0.3361688554,
-0.2691197097,
0.2671803236,
0.5773929358,
0.2308579236,
0.1181654781,
0.1281763166,
-0.0177376401,
0.0558066741,
-0.8689053655,
-0.6491941214,
1.140520215,
0.3363521695,
0.9773813486,
-0.2464939654,
0.6733617783,
0.5564853549,
0.682434082,
-0.5175948143,
0.5854569674,
0.3497709036,
-1.1612627506,
-0.1239479557,
-0.5843321681,
-1.1578561068,
-0.2207163125,
-0.0746450871,
-0.0568538904,
0.3422302604,
0.7225265503,
-0.3750075698,
0.7902136445,
-0.7445967793,
0.4814586639,
-0.338450253,
-0.5798689723,
0.1287411153,
-0.4301999509,
0.2468019426,
-0.0901051313,
0.5538958311,
-0.1432278901,
-0.0412181988,
1.0067129135,
-0.2003670633,
1.0617501736,
-0.5221899152,
0.0123201851,
1.0407935381,
-0.102657631,
0.2618702054,
-0.2165718526,
-0.1273826212,
-0.076833263,
-0.4133221209,
-0.8274784088,
-0.411226362,
0.4354723394,
-1.0509412289,
-0.3199239671,
-0.6900004148,
-0.4069442153,
-0.2819714844,
-0.345523417,
-0.0871970132,
0.1799143404,
-0.1091565341,
-0.0676707178,
0.9487543106,
-0.0905532166,
0.328782618,
0.1716195047,
-0.1166386604,
-0.1558313817,
0.9837003946,
0.6562708616,
0.1354017258,
-0.2686647177,
-0.2395070791,
-0.0413683839,
-0.7518674731,
-0.465444237,
0.3485171199,
-0.7501090765,
-0.0852405429,
-0.3683466315,
-0.1456735879,
-0.0178636611,
-0.2671955526,
-0.5507560372,
-0.4239358306,
-0.5502656102,
-0.4322942793,
0.1720941067,
0.978309989,
-0.2431817055,
0.1983426809,
-0.3538348377,
0.2144722492,
0.4422137141,
0.3783449531,
0.333417654,
-0.3482920229,
-0.4507473111,
0.3419137597,
-0.2712855935,
-0.5590486526,
-0.0298701115,
0.1698035896,
0.9884164929,
0.5226176381,
0.5329911113,
0.7201095819,
-0.2782908976,
0.6728745699,
-0.1964069456,
-0.3467347622,
0.5391342044,
-0.0229859762,
-0.1852375716,
0.9293783307,
0.5955601335,
0.1459203064,
-0.3075927794,
-0.9406471252,
-1.2074626684,
0.5209285617,
0.4051923156,
0.140468508,
0.1974414438,
0.8868535757,
0.1411395222,
0.2061912268,
-0.5914844871,
-0.5855804682,
-0.0363916568,
-0.1298007667,
0.0519822724,
-0.0396235362,
-0.3137359023,
-0.1352366805,
0.8789157867,
0.153781563,
0.3494850099,
0.1376875937,
-0.0556842275,
-0.5454679728,
-0.0765688047,
0.2289860547,
0.7715940475,
-0.3483035266,
0.2654589117,
0.1481736898,
-0.4716478288,
0.142853871,
0.1267095357,
-0.4870891571,
0.0349489786,
0.3386420608,
0.7346514463,
0.1161378995,
-0.997274518,
0.2313748896,
-0.1870950609,
-0.5362342596,
-0.4343798757,
0.4449971318,
-0.3149114251,
0.0902353674,
0.8645176888,
0.2895766497,
-0.0641275272,
-0.8125866055,
0.3106263876,
0.2861507833,
-0.551522851,
-0.3667246401,
0.947673142,
0.3793046176,
-0.3035398126,
0.8240377307,
-0.341889888,
-0.2118099183,
0.6811543107,
0.0568043888,
0.3617882133,
-0.0152391195,
-0.1597563773,
0.331436336,
0.2333502769,
-0.5380805731,
0.3587388396,
0.047043629,
-0.4992596209,
-0.2715166211,
-0.4448885918,
-0.8018148541,
-0.0951085165,
-0.8863700628,
0.1352051049,
-0.4010993838,
-0.1606106013,
-0.2341700047,
0.2180657834,
-0.3623916209,
0.2428870201,
0.3075325489,
0.9322363138,
-1.27259624,
0.8312274218,
1.2644846439,
-0.2673206329,
-0.7550187111,
-0.1391815245,
-0.2108285427,
-0.5671601295,
0.1113301516,
0.1178654209,
0.1770842224,
0.0658968836,
-0.9127753973,
-0.3745332062,
1.1996542215,
0.1664675027,
-0.3257164359,
-0.1495294422,
-0.2021543533,
0.3794472814,
-0.0683177635,
-0.0221635774,
0.0474356115,
0.4519825876,
0.2308882773,
-0.6774403453,
-0.3268903792,
-0.3532115817,
-0.4674592912,
0.0366767831,
-0.6724721789,
0.9010158777,
-0.4540398121,
-0.1145079136,
-0.1279751062,
1.0725078583,
0.5854132771,
0.9170181155,
0.6034851074,
0.5094230771,
0.8291651011,
-0.0331252292,
1.0189051628,
0.0099864053,
0.2987419069,
0.7217696905,
-0.4715693593,
0.6434005499,
0.5943180919,
-0.2186194658,
-0.0149351312,
0.8914304972,
-0.243208617,
0.4924651086,
0.3404706419,
-0.4597233832,
-0.25658077,
0.0230112411,
-0.335806638,
0.2542960644,
0.2510452271,
-0.2158679962,
-0.0560611002,
0.2539521754,
0.0276644714,
0.2011683285,
-0.5116934776,
0.3255343437,
-0.0268125348,
-0.459510237,
0.3361186981,
-0.0136067197,
0.5125302076,
-0.5361222029,
-0.289080143,
-0.0441202447,
0.0427397862,
-0.2099573612,
-0.4180939794,
0.0307357553,
-0.0116182519,
0.1961082667,
-0.4282463193,
0.3924002349,
-0.1759937704,
-0.5527843237,
0.0342016593,
0.7791832685,
0.4246334136,
0.2365904152,
-0.6065909863,
0.3794508576,
0.052482523,
-0.5821998715,
0.5074914098,
0.6566377878,
-0.1106508151,
0.6757688522,
0.5266114473,
0.1506000459,
0.3010839522,
-0.2664580345,
1.0158190727,
-0.5254209638,
-0.0667779893,
-0.3684384227,
0.3192306161,
0.1187340468,
-0.3622458875,
0.6979888678,
0.7183736563,
0.9169820547,
0.2643520832,
1.0010139942,
-0.0654813349,
0.3507637978,
-0.3320342898,
0.6325063705,
-0.6459206343,
0.6081714034,
0.1228302494,
-0.6868744493,
-0.3289293647,
0.8408525586,
-0.166544199,
0.3729617596,
0.41739434,
0.3552777171,
-0.3147966266,
-0.0588271394,
0.1678245217,
0.1009562016,
0.2095386982,
0.0925256759,
0.860119462,
-0.4288648069,
0.6957752109,
-0.7258833647,
-0.2186645716,
-0.2249397784,
-0.5628805757,
-1.0248428583,
-0.5073865056,
-0.5094367266,
-0.3937364817,
0.2508295476,
0.8878204226,
0.624147296,
-0.7068468332,
-0.3437428474,
-0.0487656817,
-0.027716333,
-0.4827685356,
-0.1352166831,
0.3507576883,
-0.1215035766,
-0.6352840662,
0.1919965297,
-0.4610769749,
0.3324981332,
-0.3201136887,
-0.1881803721,
-0.2733076215,
0.0086360471,
0.0811200887,
0.7455915213,
-0.3941993713,
-0.0047483565,
-0.1374580562,
-0.1348051131,
0.0963075608,
0.8670374155,
-1.0080211163,
0.3138540685,
-0.1516122073,
0.6515517831,
0.4035193324,
0.2452499419,
0.3789736629,
-0.6099066138,
-0.0831509978,
0.706512928,
-0.0614546426,
0.0712541789,
-0.1421737671,
0.6706982851,
0.2404158562,
-0.5379341841,
-1.4035859108,
0.0667979792,
-0.995642662,
-0.5128649473,
1.2205635309,
-0.2753152251,
-0.3492430747,
-0.3382742405,
-0.0847804546,
0.4159252048,
-0.4326161444,
1.1817913055,
0.457336843,
-0.6284886599,
-0.0064628897,
-1.1236314774,
0.5177179575,
0.2520269752,
-0.5815705061,
0.2660828531,
0.4146549106,
-0.0243335925,
-0.0462054908,
0.3600684702,
0.1911634207,
0.3647469878,
-0.0388071351,
0.2976623774,
-0.4765187204,
-0.5634566545,
-0.3093930185,
0.3227972984,
0.4472489357,
-0.1359982044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12586v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12586v1 | Enhancing Few-shot Text-to-SQL Capabilities of Large Language Models: A Study on Prompt Design Strategies | 2023-05-21T22:44:25 | 2023-05-21T22:44:25 | Linyong Nan, Yilun Zhao, Weijin Zou, Narutatsu Ri, Jaesung Tae, Ellen Zhang, Arman Cohan, Dragomir Radev | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) has emerged as a new approach to various natural
language processing tasks, utilizing large language models (LLMs) to make
predictions based on context that has been supplemented with a few examples or
task-specific instructions. In this paper, we aim to extend this method to
question answering tasks that utilize structured knowledge sources, and improve
Text-to-SQL systems by exploring various prompt design strategies for employing
LLMs. We conduct a systematic investigation into different demonstration
selection methods and optimal instruction formats for prompting LLMs in the
Text-to-SQL task. Our approach involves leveraging the syntactic structure of
an example's SQL query to retrieve demonstrations, and we demonstrate that
pursuing both diversity and similarity in demonstration selection leads to
enhanced performance. Furthermore, we show that LLMs benefit from
database-related knowledge augmentations. Our most effective strategy
outperforms the state-of-the-art system by 2.5 points (Execution Accuracy) and
the best fine-tuned system by 5.1 points on the Spider dataset. These results
highlight the effectiveness of our approach in adapting LLMs to the Text-to-SQL
task, and we present an analysis of the factors contributing to the success of
our strategy. | [
-0.2809136808,
-1.0561255217,
0.8926649094,
0.0714452416,
-0.5154008865,
-0.0201283656,
-0.2286949456,
-0.2251042873,
-0.2238138914,
0.3235525489,
-0.7192460299,
-0.699426353,
-0.1070803776,
0.5635473132,
-0.2974226475,
0.8729632497,
0.0990607291,
0.041680906,
-0.5672299862,
0.0960081369,
-0.7456486821,
-0.4767145813,
-0.5873887539,
-0.0607105866,
0.3060173392,
0.8164176345,
0.3015554845,
0.4834566414,
0.2267596573,
0.1940434575,
-0.3388877809,
0.3800961971,
-0.3473486006,
0.438501209,
-0.2136860043,
-0.5638126135,
-0.0075428868,
-0.3862745166,
0.6928167343,
0.8350991607,
-0.0102109164,
0.098564893,
0.4316857457,
0.5168960094,
-0.6164559722,
0.0655268878,
-0.6359440088,
-0.004127936,
-0.0610748641,
-0.3596462607,
-0.8079641461,
-0.3416836858,
0.1974051297,
-0.5670886636,
-0.0845143124,
0.3764056563,
0.2975128293,
0.1976922452,
-0.6110038161,
-0.4250915945,
-0.4873461127,
0.7819676995,
-0.7128017545,
0.1338986605,
0.2067282498,
0.4558283687,
-0.4091014862,
-0.6117507815,
-0.4220387042,
-0.3486321568,
-0.3870414197,
-0.1256483942,
0.0881881118,
0.0452992879,
0.4987496734,
-0.0642403513,
-0.6170197725,
0.3304683864,
0.0004087338,
0.0567018129,
0.4636216164,
0.3008053005,
0.1982121468,
-0.3311933577,
-0.5433279872,
0.0143222166,
-0.984462738,
0.2855431139,
-0.0186824426,
0.6747666001,
0.0510224737,
0.6865552068,
-0.4161839187,
0.9792130589,
0.160557285,
-0.2034258991,
-0.2263683677,
-0.4910332859,
-0.2083277851,
0.0632874146,
0.5570568442,
0.18011415,
-0.0367982388,
-0.2535054088,
-0.2823955119,
-0.3935952783,
-0.0537068807,
-0.8325484991,
0.1277534366,
0.1723181456,
-0.462021172,
-0.0250718985,
-0.2500233352,
-0.8650109172,
-0.5671426654,
-0.3867063522,
0.5579815507,
-0.5874214172,
0.1641190797,
-0.200775668,
-0.2661728263,
0.4332908094,
0.5263292789,
-0.8652096987,
0.3819572031,
0.5731294751,
0.697861433,
-0.4346516728,
0.0282153729,
-0.6869350076,
0.3118212223,
-0.4688173831,
0.9038234949,
-0.4516852498,
-0.5588411689,
0.1832514554,
-0.236783877,
-0.0031703962,
-0.5136207342,
0.4093924761,
-0.6145108342,
0.561147511,
-0.4709855914,
-0.8975308537,
-0.0223762691,
0.3584949374,
-0.389601171,
0.8739574552,
0.0513155162,
-0.5938915014,
0.4246324301,
-0.8922333717,
-0.5382121801,
0.2563625872,
-0.3737340271,
-0.0924104601,
0.0571691506,
0.4362798035,
0.5919185877,
-0.3339562714,
0.0042729657,
-0.0439760871,
-0.632230103,
0.2981390059,
-0.1764915287,
0.7171463966,
0.1228717342,
-0.3553845584,
0.217951864,
-0.5781010389,
0.1222911999,
0.0896565393,
-0.3872584403,
-0.3577355444,
0.091451183,
-0.2916855514,
0.1339132339,
-0.0770946443,
-0.2492782772,
0.3079610169,
-0.7391065359,
0.2826637626,
0.6167997718,
0.3319300711,
0.7493698001,
-0.2472798675,
0.6811754107,
-0.0297455713,
0.0699168071,
-0.5958840847,
-0.2200701982,
-0.5602635145,
-0.2019049674,
-0.0194693133,
0.5261297226,
-1.1440476179,
0.1290314049,
-0.1000648141,
-0.1835775971,
-0.0719666481,
0.1726393998,
0.3415863514,
0.8310435414,
0.4636522233,
0.1299835742,
-0.3218199313,
-0.8355554938,
-0.4485169649,
-0.1338713318,
-0.1159810498,
0.4516217709,
0.378241837,
0.405128032,
1.2896296978,
-0.5396925807,
-0.1298595369,
-0.5342629552,
-0.2318698764,
0.3165454865,
0.2974996567,
0.6482526064,
-0.6085666418,
-0.6136906743,
-0.2271156609,
-0.6768971682,
0.2014391571,
-0.090477787,
0.0166967548,
0.4091866612,
0.5921160579,
-0.4987023771,
0.2342390418,
0.0233560167,
-0.3469037712,
0.5352822542,
0.0932790637,
0.2044654042,
-1.232539773,
-0.2058757097,
0.0859965235,
-0.1144483089,
-0.6726723313,
0.0089350715,
0.1410377473,
-0.1976519376,
-0.7252874374,
0.7227119803,
-0.6028190851,
0.0624426603,
-0.1827025563,
0.2712234557,
-0.0186941791,
0.4709112942,
-0.0435896255,
1.1702635288,
0.5231164694,
-0.8605885506,
0.1630342603,
0.4962468445,
-0.5823511481,
0.6452849507,
-0.6356677413,
0.3530066013,
-0.4592370987,
0.2668565512,
-1.2588974237,
-0.2386653423,
0.1188289076,
-0.2445557564,
0.3144681752,
-0.3633888364,
-0.6885390878,
-0.0495565869,
-0.3306715488,
-0.0279793348,
0.6039075851,
-0.7165070772,
0.3941982985,
-0.0896869823,
-0.3089998364,
-0.5336689353,
-0.7219802737,
0.2101611346,
-0.4640249312,
-0.4557728767,
0.4571323395,
-0.1142342687,
-0.3839348853,
-0.3481857777,
0.0289081074,
-0.1713671833,
0.1664834917,
-0.1076400951,
0.3613857329,
-0.3272109628,
0.636013031,
0.2798040211,
0.2147216797,
0.0090721939,
-0.2729274333,
0.4078339338,
0.1966117322,
-0.2429311723,
-0.5137753487,
0.6286193132,
0.0957150832,
-0.000987287,
0.8702782393,
0.1089954078,
-0.2377568781,
-0.6202945113,
-0.3564963937,
-0.6772626042,
-0.4883915186,
0.270460248,
-0.4507333934,
-0.9543629885,
0.0461480021,
-0.3247406185,
0.151231885,
0.1349084973,
0.3194578886,
-0.341814518,
0.9781845808,
0.7361513972,
0.1907927841,
0.7009027004,
-0.0363697559,
0.1652097553,
-0.6497200131,
-0.253115505,
-0.7514157295,
-0.0491938218,
-0.161309287,
-0.2506495118,
0.5814019442,
0.1321254671,
-0.25314942,
0.1748979241,
-0.4041087031,
0.6340756416,
0.3961347044,
0.2980993986,
0.3569285572,
0.1676913202,
-0.2096538544,
-0.0173348859,
-0.8827594519,
-0.6940481663,
0.8696379066,
0.0121126221,
0.7838255763,
0.2189480364,
0.6018499732,
0.0462143756,
0.0485107377,
-0.790373981,
0.73624295,
-0.0376004465,
-0.4705446362,
-0.4092548192,
-0.2077673525,
-0.6888926625,
0.117698364,
-0.252610743,
-0.6714872122,
0.0958436877,
0.1882341206,
-0.4074101746,
-0.0518269427,
-0.9458102584,
0.7891135216,
-0.1114862189,
-0.4477497339,
-0.0828208849,
-0.6311434507,
0.2461915463,
0.2283639908,
-0.0100747179,
0.2364609987,
-0.3327574432,
0.5458951592,
-0.2375773937,
1.0418981314,
-0.2487152517,
-0.024705559,
0.3989584148,
-0.0399956517,
0.7917340994,
0.0289170779,
-0.4746896327,
-0.5679178238,
-0.0830353945,
-0.2836544514,
-0.9050316811,
0.4926538467,
-0.3160136342,
-0.7591902614,
-0.0489033721,
-0.4944642782,
-0.5358015895,
0.0164736249,
0.2233463973,
0.6601802111,
-0.1919981986,
0.466794014,
0.923360467,
-0.2515429258,
0.7584846616,
0.3847857714,
0.0550776385,
-0.149495393,
0.3151929975,
0.0220081266,
0.383746624,
0.6877515316,
0.2418160588,
-0.6356360316,
-0.7188293338,
-0.6286695004,
-0.0076432889,
-1.0310230255,
-0.3220591843,
-0.6218484044,
0.0624116622,
-0.5947264433,
-0.1552917361,
0.2699320316,
-0.3824716508,
-0.6449584961,
0.027926214,
0.5412829518,
0.5054531693,
0.8608146906,
0.4987913668,
-0.5966893435,
0.0004789586,
0.3487060964,
0.1852809042,
-0.0525991917,
-0.6446031332,
-0.0774481222,
-0.190250501,
-0.245369181,
-1.1652163267,
0.1479305923,
0.255130887,
0.7853791714,
0.0753926337,
0.3499797583,
0.613715291,
-0.4637877047,
0.9565380812,
-0.0352731086,
-0.7851369977,
0.8747029305,
-0.2109286636,
0.3674840331,
0.6518538594,
0.5699129105,
-0.3084796965,
-0.0841462091,
-0.254073143,
-0.495429039,
0.6760078669,
-0.0570075959,
0.1551824212,
-0.0040108669,
0.5834652185,
0.2240787745,
0.2908042371,
-0.5331971049,
-0.0865815803,
0.1741145104,
-0.3304387629,
0.0114281373,
-0.3203867376,
-0.0622659251,
-0.1095868275,
0.4739536345,
-0.6874283552,
-0.0324902758,
0.2895347178,
-0.3497045934,
0.240093872,
0.7253881097,
0.5129559636,
0.8528874516,
0.1838936359,
-0.0346265621,
0.6218136549,
0.0446947739,
0.0358590819,
-0.1128152907,
-0.3777073622,
-0.009445224,
0.2832598686,
0.8747181892,
0.1403909326,
-0.7704592347,
0.5406477451,
0.0646222681,
0.0303884074,
-0.0130651575,
0.1720909327,
0.0097956061,
0.2680926919,
0.5385612249,
-0.3332974911,
0.2844313681,
-0.6289490461,
0.0258592665,
0.6766582131,
-0.2786435187,
0.0161083713,
0.3640240431,
0.1184136346,
-0.4091614485,
0.5083574653,
-0.1509067565,
-0.2424729317,
0.5135731101,
0.919328928,
0.6012983918,
-0.0869048983,
0.1567453295,
0.358217895,
0.1413020343,
-0.0035563908,
0.3510382175,
-0.3297875524,
-0.3130764961,
-0.5955909491,
-0.2977599502,
-0.5724556446,
-0.2345523685,
-0.3019997478,
0.6811417341,
-0.4407963455,
0.1111620441,
-0.1670257747,
0.0688819587,
-0.4638346136,
-0.0290270261,
-0.0974296033,
1.1555736065,
-0.7648733258,
0.6928574443,
0.8351864219,
-0.4157756269,
-0.7694288492,
0.0575118624,
0.0163627528,
-0.4213311374,
0.6001594663,
0.0440841764,
0.0673298091,
0.1100408584,
-0.8779016137,
-0.6454386711,
1.1307724714,
0.4387495816,
-0.4207566082,
-0.1820809245,
-0.0595042929,
0.4167401791,
-0.5020569563,
0.2635311782,
0.4716024399,
0.304389745,
0.2922840714,
-0.6017612815,
0.2250614464,
0.1591569632,
0.0829815418,
0.0308517534,
-0.3315520883,
0.6095409989,
-0.3530932963,
-0.3794368207,
0.2407703847,
0.7614505291,
0.5917959809,
0.2531737685,
0.6390485764,
-0.1165660396,
0.6489971876,
0.0493490249,
1.162835598,
0.1273724586,
-0.042582348,
1.1305915117,
-0.391428113,
0.9131097794,
0.7828223109,
-0.1284164935,
0.705927372,
0.6071623564,
0.2225893438,
0.5167978406,
0.0905019715,
-0.3117300272,
-0.1781126112,
-0.3986354172,
-0.0659966767,
0.2296265513,
0.3748730421,
-0.2112975866,
-0.4061615169,
0.2111917734,
-0.1131753698,
0.3787971139,
-0.123102285,
1.2030955553,
-0.0170778036,
-0.7899549007,
0.4425291717,
-0.2381221503,
0.6934485435,
-0.6391901374,
-0.3258094788,
-0.3198283017,
-0.1646335125,
-0.1654364467,
-0.9031838179,
0.0764147639,
0.0496333949,
-0.2128648907,
-0.3607927263,
0.8055624962,
-0.5004583001,
-0.0945380703,
-0.1122576743,
0.4933965504,
0.0500680357,
-0.1409944445,
-0.400493443,
-0.1593731046,
-0.1596589386,
-0.1022659317,
0.4198311567,
0.4641825855,
-0.2147589475,
0.649079442,
0.5331715941,
-0.1748918742,
-0.1403122544,
0.0863045156,
0.9016875029,
-0.6479079723,
-0.6287975311,
-0.936565876,
0.5116353035,
-0.2525915504,
-0.156699717,
0.9259605408,
0.559771955,
0.528914094,
-0.1591953039,
0.5768136382,
0.0939938724,
0.7067379951,
-0.7744373679,
0.3175571859,
-0.5303414464,
0.3508682251,
-0.2690900862,
-0.851197958,
-0.2721114457,
0.1309463233,
-0.1714228094,
0.0403950289,
0.9558687806,
0.946081996,
0.3109651208,
0.021410251,
0.2597747743,
0.0210105311,
0.3778116703,
0.5264408588,
1.0067284107,
-0.1318351924,
0.7051562667,
-0.1888597459,
-0.2399956435,
-0.2474921793,
-1.0300923586,
-1.0400590897,
-0.5601741672,
-0.1378615052,
-0.1688986421,
0.1423334032,
1.2522013187,
0.7123378515,
-0.6743602753,
-0.2402755618,
0.0396514013,
0.3418021798,
-0.204864189,
-0.1826325953,
0.4244764447,
-0.7829819322,
-0.6833534837,
0.8281860352,
0.3025293648,
0.1646884382,
-0.031578064,
0.1497453898,
-0.2012854218,
-0.1467140764,
0.9749140143,
0.0568845235,
-0.6450573802,
-0.1952774823,
0.3607075214,
-0.2405193597,
0.0276971851,
0.8647574782,
-1.1072138548,
0.1384473443,
0.6913683414,
0.8634905815,
0.2486999929,
0.1836919785,
0.5279474258,
-1.0219548941,
0.0956610069,
0.4360983372,
0.202272296,
0.3837923408,
-0.5564833879,
0.2602487504,
-0.0644039288,
-0.3691044152,
-0.6896058321,
0.1607288867,
-0.816108644,
-0.6371884346,
1.2723736763,
0.1427423209,
-0.2757048309,
-0.2433571965,
-0.4266397059,
-0.0340283327,
-0.3396428227,
0.5167748928,
0.5342962742,
-0.2681239843,
-0.3444103897,
-0.3803196847,
0.7256795168,
0.4583150744,
-1.1051927805,
0.0237996392,
0.5499794483,
0.2785708606,
-0.2399974167,
0.5322586298,
-0.0054999725,
0.2232916951,
-0.4152404368,
-0.3456037343,
0.0111148963,
-0.3803937733,
-0.6070589423,
0.3417355716,
0.2962629199,
-0.0548805371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12580v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12580v2 | A Framework for Bidirectional Decoding: Case Study in Morphological Inflection | 2023-05-21T22:08:31 | 2023-10-30T05:51:34 | Marc E. Canby, Julia Hockenmaier | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based encoder-decoder models that generate outputs in a
left-to-right fashion have become standard for sequence-to-sequence tasks. In
this paper, we propose a framework for decoding that produces sequences from
the "outside-in": at each step, the model chooses to generate a token on the
left, on the right, or join the left and right sequences. We argue that this is
more principled than prior bidirectional decoders. Our proposal supports a
variety of model architectures and includes several training methods, such as a
dynamic programming algorithm that marginalizes out the latent ordering
variable. Our model sets state-of-the-art (SOTA) on the 2022 and 2023 shared
tasks, beating the next best systems by over 4.7 and 2.7 points in average
accuracy respectively. The model performs particularly well on long sequences,
can implicitly learn the split point of words composed of stem and affix, and
performs better relative to the baseline on datasets that have fewer unique
lemmas (but more examples per lemma). | [
0.0471718349,
-0.1443681419,
0.3529931903,
0.2503481507,
-0.6444323659,
-0.1310896724,
0.1166404858,
-0.3795370758,
0.2138736099,
0.6053888202,
-0.7911866307,
-0.3736174107,
-0.6256004572,
0.5003968477,
-0.6445701718,
0.7260528207,
0.2048355937,
0.2519340217,
-0.1450497955,
0.034084294,
-0.1795393974,
-0.6459959745,
-0.4271514714,
-0.2948920727,
0.1332686096,
0.5601987839,
0.8836529851,
0.7525547743,
0.4500025511,
0.1844568551,
-0.1650657207,
0.2644555569,
-0.2693574429,
0.2654919326,
-0.169906795,
-0.5103130341,
-0.3719468117,
-0.3552600741,
0.6874946952,
0.7364029288,
-0.1756169349,
-0.1993608922,
0.1024369895,
0.5134333968,
-0.2488218695,
0.2525101304,
-0.4558057785,
0.1254532039,
-0.2192919403,
-0.380455941,
-0.4972166121,
-0.1331018656,
-0.1964984238,
-0.161990732,
0.125079155,
-0.3642789423,
0.7400677204,
0.3555984199,
-0.3364085853,
-0.3369891047,
-0.4211391509,
0.1515061706,
-0.9931064844,
0.9009849429,
0.3766828477,
0.168497771,
-0.1838204116,
-0.8259007335,
-0.7732456326,
0.210339129,
-0.0551690385,
0.3553172052,
0.0970475972,
0.1067995429,
-0.0056061256,
0.2378792763,
-0.5327365398,
0.0038836659,
-0.1143932119,
0.2150918096,
0.4975536764,
0.1774171293,
0.2332807481,
-0.3715004921,
-0.3113689125,
-0.1746090204,
-1.0316041708,
0.0483406708,
0.5936455727,
0.5809915662,
-0.2485934645,
0.7850069404,
0.2450472564,
0.4903148711,
0.4803999662,
0.1178883091,
-0.0133652156,
-0.324524492,
-0.1953603774,
0.0921438485,
0.4027351141,
0.2756491601,
-0.1558094621,
-0.2888472378,
-0.5490059257,
-0.1735144109,
0.2296553999,
-0.7914107442,
-0.0778071135,
0.1212965548,
-0.5912870169,
-0.1442274451,
0.1991276294,
-0.8681787848,
-0.2982739508,
-0.4874643087,
0.2645145059,
-0.5312331319,
-0.3902380764,
0.3827925026,
-0.0801405013,
0.3911818266,
-0.024810737,
-0.9923868179,
0.4861276746,
0.913438797,
0.9822703004,
-0.1442509294,
-0.0810932592,
-0.5864654183,
0.0740797818,
-0.3240407705,
0.5570601821,
-0.8236739635,
-0.5549297929,
0.3400830925,
0.1158692613,
-0.2314232588,
-0.5304384828,
0.1755204797,
-0.725707829,
0.1065484658,
0.0951789394,
-0.5928624868,
-0.0984352529,
-0.1041503102,
-0.6466679573,
0.6799032688,
-0.0527363271,
-0.8188586235,
0.1657668054,
-0.8327463269,
-0.6713548303,
0.2163018882,
-0.2884644866,
-0.2791339755,
0.2528128028,
-0.0369396694,
0.3725248575,
-0.3483949006,
0.472841084,
0.0552610345,
-0.2666619122,
0.1101072058,
-0.6164249182,
0.9052737951,
0.146414116,
-0.443133831,
0.082769379,
-0.9157556891,
-0.409275502,
0.1533755362,
-0.4146116972,
-0.0582672097,
0.2368276864,
0.0642745122,
0.1134614497,
0.0565037504,
-0.5642733574,
0.0318366066,
-0.7776345611,
0.8179405332,
0.5803648829,
-0.0403296053,
0.6187211275,
0.000629844,
0.4413297772,
0.260484606,
-0.0161321703,
-0.3618316352,
-0.4898070693,
-0.9449571371,
-0.450989753,
0.0232234858,
0.3880486488,
-0.890843451,
0.4649471641,
-0.5984992385,
-0.1700211167,
-0.3588214517,
-0.3973225653,
0.3686726093,
0.4734365344,
0.3446595967,
-0.3250570297,
-0.499373287,
-0.6866466403,
-0.0217573233,
-0.1236473396,
0.1287394315,
0.0728993863,
0.5358347297,
-0.4265502989,
0.8079238534,
-0.1675700098,
0.0473661534,
-0.3133429289,
0.0320568234,
0.735866189,
0.5706182718,
0.113314487,
-1.1236368418,
-0.1528143138,
-0.1595078111,
-0.54397434,
0.2134185731,
0.0505010076,
-0.2082907259,
0.3839026093,
0.7067060471,
-0.6486103535,
0.442802757,
0.5719206929,
-0.4868227839,
0.2001475543,
-0.3896961808,
-0.1360838413,
-1.4084804058,
0.0418784432,
-0.3663721085,
-0.2869254053,
-0.8444216251,
0.2954471707,
0.1766891032,
-0.1831845492,
-0.3157142997,
0.0385825559,
-0.3101903796,
-0.1302762926,
-0.0557150356,
-0.4374028444,
-0.0257136226,
0.5147297382,
0.514724195,
0.5714402795,
0.255684793,
-0.3929929435,
0.2325142771,
0.3105137944,
0.0390738994,
0.4594721794,
-0.5944513679,
0.3118824959,
-0.3812997043,
0.1554549187,
-0.7714363933,
-0.2533338964,
0.3405819833,
-0.2521314323,
0.590477407,
-0.4644745886,
-0.5501173139,
-0.3594617248,
-0.0681828633,
0.7658118606,
0.5044737458,
-0.8290832639,
0.7869554162,
0.3716372848,
0.0118674068,
-0.3934766054,
-0.7097712755,
0.2144094855,
-0.1976477951,
-0.6722257733,
0.5359990001,
-0.0317172632,
0.0283940975,
-0.1344297975,
0.0151628898,
-0.238625899,
-0.3812666535,
0.5289709568,
0.0849470198,
-0.2050666958,
-0.1302873194,
0.0550953038,
-0.1888824254,
-0.0367609337,
-0.6799086332,
0.6440502405,
0.0781638622,
-0.6038198471,
-0.3028758466,
0.6373491287,
0.8587427735,
-0.3425685763,
0.3384597003,
0.0392218828,
-0.6126585007,
-0.0946161672,
-0.0041632885,
-0.3274368644,
-0.5118855238,
0.4130250812,
-0.7102352381,
-0.4976891875,
0.4174024463,
0.1775691956,
0.0674253106,
0.210296765,
0.6101571918,
-0.1943243295,
0.9384769201,
0.9413558841,
0.2725676298,
0.4296115637,
-0.4806639254,
0.6112776399,
-0.4335000217,
-0.5374795198,
-0.3776462078,
0.0391606949,
-0.4798684716,
-0.7147151828,
0.3356226385,
-0.1806179434,
-0.2288842648,
0.6137488484,
-0.4842345119,
0.347889334,
0.6870008111,
0.2087306529,
0.2185024619,
-0.039291814,
-0.2488679886,
-0.0014949965,
-0.8325251937,
-0.4522239268,
0.7339264154,
0.4891601205,
0.6705115438,
0.2135101408,
0.9549362659,
0.2788151503,
-0.1880794317,
-0.7789533138,
0.5836982131,
-0.4537675381,
-0.1153517663,
-0.3985881209,
0.0257230792,
-0.9196494222,
0.1426320225,
0.1993405074,
-0.2010516822,
0.5422627926,
-0.0052982178,
-0.2502359748,
0.3702135384,
-0.1789754629,
0.6715604663,
0.0764465928,
-0.2762703896,
-0.1548547745,
-0.8820132613,
0.0106739765,
0.1472001225,
0.0546436235,
0.1976590902,
0.144701317,
0.6042716503,
-0.6395540833,
1.0681962967,
-0.3672476113,
-0.3189848065,
0.1627964079,
0.3097896576,
0.5216907263,
0.0621905364,
-0.1508496851,
0.2590485513,
0.2386800498,
-0.1447515786,
-0.4461109638,
0.1724050492,
-0.5536952615,
-0.4923498631,
-0.3272529244,
-0.6195469499,
-0.0819195732,
0.0608480945,
0.4990879595,
0.9890771508,
0.0218814779,
-0.0317809619,
0.5977437496,
0.2439122498,
0.7886100411,
0.1718164533,
0.3544754982,
-0.3719221652,
0.8164179325,
0.0080346214,
0.0281468574,
0.8161948323,
-0.0839654878,
-0.5649136305,
-0.7054337859,
-0.8064408898,
0.3507809639,
-0.8801169395,
-0.5126121044,
-0.4035426974,
-0.4670569599,
-0.3680183291,
-0.0859384015,
-0.5244756937,
-0.1135388911,
-0.3954394162,
-0.0712580383,
0.065296948,
0.9902227521,
-0.0819275305,
-0.0029813366,
-0.9540550709,
0.1612236202,
0.2622740865,
0.1705696285,
-0.1535992175,
-0.7289887667,
-0.2467131168,
0.2346471846,
0.0599291548,
-1.0375983715,
0.749394238,
0.2805561125,
0.3402923346,
0.569282949,
0.0273575038,
0.7883731723,
-0.9494327307,
0.7464280128,
0.1594440043,
-1.0789754391,
0.2396729439,
-0.1347139478,
0.0490275286,
0.1809075326,
0.2177285105,
-0.6342744231,
-0.3305531144,
-0.4318261147,
-0.7949582934,
0.756606102,
0.0942549333,
0.3047084808,
-0.2138892561,
0.2696291804,
0.515268445,
0.0903842002,
-0.459130913,
0.1643059701,
-0.6269196868,
-0.8041662574,
0.0746624693,
-0.4149787426,
-0.0560299568,
-0.1374814957,
0.3836126924,
-0.3793443143,
0.6028373837,
0.1373521537,
-0.4665483832,
0.0054109809,
0.0254963525,
0.6612636447,
0.463790983,
-0.0395449065,
0.5452819467,
-0.1210958064,
-0.4589459896,
0.0608845316,
0.1098974869,
-0.070148766,
-0.0017438756,
0.5468021035,
0.7046453357,
0.2587016225,
-0.6053168774,
0.8753640056,
0.1812816113,
-0.0218178779,
-0.031883955,
-0.4172193408,
-0.0697054416,
0.7151514292,
0.3756578565,
0.102085501,
0.3632279932,
-0.4147307277,
0.2298961133,
0.2799209952,
-0.2817581594,
-0.9293589592,
0.5374459624,
0.3073319495,
-0.4628124237,
0.699811399,
-0.0461150184,
-0.6683136821,
0.6098968983,
1.0201132298,
0.9697821736,
0.1107269749,
0.0883007571,
0.2173795253,
-0.0464872383,
-0.0484365001,
0.5557959676,
-0.3811746538,
-0.7515254021,
-0.1214430332,
-0.8180121183,
-0.2014358193,
-0.2354580909,
-0.7294126153,
0.2573406696,
-0.1291797608,
-0.0096583134,
-0.4621731639,
-0.5903896093,
-0.5727502108,
0.1821015179,
0.2627133429,
0.9742339253,
-0.7485859394,
0.8319948316,
0.6637669802,
-0.4002169669,
-0.4486810863,
0.1741715074,
-0.3010042012,
-0.9460960627,
0.7321950197,
0.282928586,
-0.5149164796,
0.0211471673,
-0.2679942846,
-0.9421765804,
0.8467189074,
0.4137541056,
-0.515483737,
-0.6421227455,
0.4399894178,
0.3425292969,
-0.4376778007,
0.0226696078,
0.6063572168,
0.1290821135,
0.2130729556,
-0.8514108062,
0.0947664827,
-0.3830869198,
0.2035880238,
0.0640652031,
-0.2941557467,
0.6878407598,
-0.1727927774,
-0.6035214067,
0.1984430254,
0.7206109166,
-0.1896098554,
0.0730963424,
0.3321815729,
0.3691679835,
0.4522164464,
0.0580672063,
0.7192581892,
-0.5672781467,
-0.0131484745,
0.9932490587,
0.0858446956,
1.0574007034,
0.7784853578,
-0.1125775725,
0.5092821121,
0.7166928649,
0.2526351213,
1.1293447018,
-0.1971684843,
0.0767041594,
-0.3255542815,
0.0950374752,
-0.237558499,
0.5504748225,
0.3579740226,
-0.4004873633,
-0.2107299268,
0.1945813149,
-0.1239685044,
0.1822072119,
-0.219190076,
0.7738086581,
-0.0200498272,
-0.5819658041,
0.6710224152,
0.0735558569,
0.7061685324,
-0.4285497665,
-0.1962700337,
-0.4969937801,
0.220082581,
-0.1443461031,
-0.8101030588,
0.4334893525,
-0.1933638901,
-0.2526327372,
-0.3682442009,
0.3361342251,
-0.7536530495,
-0.3202556372,
0.2866854668,
0.3815382123,
0.1338867694,
0.1031815708,
-0.3056242168,
-0.0895200744,
-0.1044855639,
0.0686630681,
-0.1320212334,
0.3797155023,
-0.0852521434,
0.3857539892,
0.4806557596,
-0.0405668058,
0.3296202421,
0.4389770329,
0.8041363955,
-0.5673247576,
-0.8642849922,
-0.8746919632,
0.5661373734,
0.19283095,
0.049712982,
0.339605242,
0.4918443561,
0.8711783886,
-0.080077827,
0.3670811951,
0.1514206231,
0.1090837866,
-0.580757916,
0.3953793347,
-0.6236696243,
-0.0994537324,
0.1763339341,
-0.763735652,
-0.5018729568,
0.5685735941,
0.1034212187,
-0.2805846035,
0.4663338661,
1.0776226521,
-0.2149961144,
0.3049834371,
0.3917779922,
0.0049439655,
0.3997136354,
0.4814689755,
0.8000013828,
-0.3759826124,
0.2216892689,
-0.0764978603,
-0.1542200893,
-0.3944751918,
-0.6224832535,
-0.8305788636,
-1.0749832392,
0.0650512502,
-0.4164444208,
0.3563217819,
1.1087992191,
0.7836458087,
-0.717176199,
-0.3768725693,
-0.4039216042,
-0.1118774563,
-0.2664929628,
-0.1097757295,
0.4449420273,
-0.400321424,
-1.0289008617,
0.6746448278,
0.6609768867,
0.2019679099,
-0.0097222505,
-0.3170697689,
0.0112632373,
0.4918320775,
0.7043426037,
0.1347303838,
-0.665155232,
-0.2158206552,
0.0147716179,
-0.2118804306,
0.428142786,
0.945591867,
-0.446639061,
0.4295563102,
0.5918983221,
0.6204299331,
0.5682728291,
-0.1433814615,
0.6926003695,
-0.4133633077,
0.2029546201,
0.5242776871,
0.5393439531,
0.4633979201,
-0.3473236561,
0.3652176857,
0.4137907922,
-0.0423251241,
-0.9415162206,
0.4545482099,
-0.5945039392,
-0.2223091871,
1.0295344591,
-0.1094673946,
-0.3094876111,
-0.1393676251,
0.1037116349,
0.4942377508,
-0.2062293291,
0.3761778772,
0.2032079101,
-0.1771474034,
-0.0547546148,
0.2712396979,
0.6204820275,
0.3299176097,
-0.4198877811,
0.1214902401,
0.4263261259,
0.192797631,
0.038498424,
0.3308878243,
-0.3769987226,
0.251458019,
0.119776763,
-0.0516511686,
-0.1801895648,
-0.8422694802,
-0.6883579493,
0.2527575493,
-0.0751818195,
-0.3798223436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12579v1 | Hystoc: Obtaining word confidences for fusion of end-to-end ASR systems | 2023-05-21T22:06:14 | 2023-05-21T22:06:14 | Karel Beneš, Martin Kocour, Lukáš Burget | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | End-to-end (e2e) systems have recently gained wide popularity in automatic
speech recognition. However, these systems do generally not provide
well-calibrated word-level confidences. In this paper, we propose Hystoc, a
simple method for obtaining word-level confidences from hypothesis-level
scores. Hystoc is an iterative alignment procedure which turns hypotheses from
an n-best output of the ASR system into a confusion network. Eventually,
word-level confidences are obtained as posterior probabilities in the
individual bins of the confusion network. We show that Hystoc provides
confidences that correlate well with the accuracy of the ASR hypothesis.
Furthermore, we show that utilizing Hystoc in fusion of multiple e2e ASR
systems increases the gains from the fusion by up to 1\,\% WER absolute on
Spanish RTVE2020 dataset. Finally, we experiment with using Hystoc for direct
fusion of n-best outputs from multiple systems, but we only achieve minor gains
when fusing very similar systems. | [
-0.2967402935,
-0.1805350333,
0.4493018389,
0.1035522297,
-0.1747456193,
0.1767162979,
-0.1457507759,
-0.4787433147,
0.3723843396,
-0.107350938,
-0.2129436582,
-0.7387651801,
-0.6585868001,
0.2244567424,
-0.7194026113,
0.4294419289,
-0.0415787958,
-0.0385821275,
-0.2427150458,
0.0143900048,
-0.231331408,
-0.0947970375,
-0.4875353277,
-0.6287311316,
0.4270817339,
0.6025809646,
0.4188108444,
0.7674973607,
0.4551009238,
0.3647285104,
0.1163696274,
-0.0968262777,
-0.4904837012,
0.3386137784,
-0.1963997632,
-0.3087765574,
-0.1924103647,
-0.03265284,
0.6456276178,
0.458204031,
-0.4519045353,
0.1456655115,
0.2156927586,
0.303779453,
-1.0574673414,
-0.1971748322,
-0.6089318395,
0.0056424579,
-0.0852380544,
-0.3398048878,
-0.5054910183,
-0.246443823,
0.2587980032,
-0.8848983049,
-0.1178204864,
0.4206156731,
0.8521613479,
0.5067479014,
-0.1343088299,
-0.3809092343,
-0.8217630982,
0.7553941607,
-0.4066635966,
0.4552739263,
0.5880877972,
0.4185141325,
-0.2174500376,
-0.47500211,
-0.9015235901,
0.211702615,
0.2042435408,
0.3787719011,
-0.234305501,
0.1764845699,
0.0287912525,
0.2862789333,
-0.4367075264,
0.1934336126,
-0.3755158186,
-0.6484264135,
0.5420125127,
-0.2700946927,
0.0297970418,
0.0022345465,
-0.4686398208,
-0.5262081027,
-0.4768694937,
-0.1809700578,
0.3546413481,
0.087433435,
-0.0747907609,
0.8014858961,
-0.1105756238,
0.7112873793,
0.1498291492,
-0.4652143121,
0.2677036226,
-0.1108140871,
-0.3485997915,
0.7548034787,
0.9038774371,
0.3156530261,
0.0663267151,
-0.2103286386,
-0.3343325853,
0.4361138046,
0.017200917,
-0.4076134562,
-0.1081494242,
0.4921114445,
-0.0166551545,
0.0001174635,
0.3861682415,
-0.6107112765,
-0.2355618477,
-0.2673654258,
0.9632307291,
-0.3963855207,
0.0020103201,
-0.040294461,
-0.8026750088,
0.4390608072,
0.207614854,
-0.3614640236,
0.4891496301,
0.6418484449,
0.7381339073,
-0.4749106467,
-0.4725506902,
-0.606895268,
0.3046160936,
-0.5289279222,
0.6446504593,
-0.3966581523,
-0.4261619747,
-0.0790888593,
-0.1807680875,
-0.2177941501,
-0.4493001997,
0.5066470504,
-0.3710620403,
0.3601488769,
-0.0555027388,
-0.8537768722,
0.254606694,
0.2418705225,
-0.1655905247,
0.792096436,
-0.1204292923,
-0.6831589341,
0.2405058742,
-0.0200412329,
-0.5055101514,
-0.1800105125,
-0.4360083044,
-0.089979738,
0.0146788843,
-0.2091881484,
0.0339377783,
-0.2938591242,
-0.1335732043,
-0.2313315123,
-0.5789164901,
0.2366095632,
-0.2805873752,
0.4703918397,
0.1997050196,
-0.3774707615,
0.0838109329,
-0.6452203393,
0.2011912763,
-0.383384198,
-0.3922703862,
-0.427731663,
-0.1288230419,
-0.4603123665,
0.2724820375,
0.4732197523,
-0.9345520139,
-0.2879938781,
-0.2504175901,
0.222863093,
0.5576316118,
-0.1606566459,
0.5549821258,
-0.2261932939,
0.1064919159,
0.0176300574,
-0.0880705938,
0.1124728024,
-0.7108539939,
-0.8357222676,
-0.136312902,
0.4661923051,
0.7556632757,
-0.8815348744,
0.8947517276,
-0.2588409483,
-0.3936903477,
-0.9192892313,
-0.2247631103,
0.6778444052,
0.6286793947,
0.4329360723,
-0.2404863685,
-0.4818701744,
-0.8953401446,
0.0584490336,
-0.3491039574,
-0.2984921038,
0.1222325638,
0.2428179681,
-0.231738925,
0.9238444567,
-0.5381696224,
-0.4245597422,
0.1972393095,
0.2352615297,
0.1879345328,
0.5889998078,
-0.3970133662,
-0.5043894649,
-0.345983237,
0.0780011714,
-0.6067963839,
0.027135063,
0.2834174037,
-0.282307595,
0.2701393068,
0.3860538006,
-0.4689662457,
0.4606389999,
0.6723908782,
-0.2904713452,
0.3697233796,
-0.4466022849,
0.3655455709,
-1.2493212223,
-0.0091907606,
-0.016501667,
-0.0953183621,
-0.7633597255,
-0.1688844115,
-0.0217642225,
0.2440110594,
-0.0446574092,
0.2112026364,
-0.3196835816,
-0.3926928937,
-0.3457746506,
0.3863524199,
-0.1259854585,
0.129737407,
-0.0283465926,
0.4250380099,
0.5923236012,
-0.7404880524,
0.3608409762,
0.4152899086,
-0.083187744,
0.6640068889,
-0.5904279351,
0.24124448,
-0.169840917,
0.0988229141,
-1.1708004475,
-0.5136736631,
-0.0059856386,
-0.8511930108,
0.3571839035,
0.1714456081,
-0.0769042596,
-0.640694499,
-0.1564113349,
0.2172433585,
0.6459958553,
-0.491984874,
0.4025121629,
0.7032610774,
0.2007796019,
-0.824437499,
-0.6689611077,
0.127031371,
0.0019800649,
-0.3361469507,
0.6496158242,
0.1212054044,
-0.3839763105,
-0.2909767628,
-0.3279570937,
0.0469903126,
-0.2922815681,
0.4629659951,
0.1372107118,
0.1355310678,
0.1924143732,
0.1957457215,
-0.2895835936,
-0.3186328113,
-0.6300588846,
0.765091598,
0.1133879945,
-0.482988745,
-0.8286995888,
0.2623986602,
0.6305958629,
0.1693909913,
0.2273233831,
0.4712967277,
-0.9412770867,
0.11177551,
-0.5872769356,
-0.3701035976,
-0.487393707,
0.021037776,
-0.4168145955,
-0.662252903,
0.275454402,
0.138184309,
-0.0072602136,
0.5925841331,
0.4651919305,
-0.3211100101,
0.8148730397,
0.5676807761,
-0.219684124,
0.1688338965,
0.0085811038,
0.0573492721,
-0.7964705825,
-0.3802320957,
-0.6725101471,
-0.4952692688,
-0.5198939443,
-0.5041679144,
0.3863092065,
0.0810430497,
-0.3739250898,
0.5987956524,
-0.531257391,
0.173821494,
0.8048756719,
0.033203885,
0.5054038763,
0.2417543083,
-0.2054335773,
0.2120440751,
-0.6445345879,
-0.2481346577,
0.5410295129,
0.3027299643,
0.8728605509,
0.1662844419,
1.0886596441,
0.1974489689,
0.0350138098,
-1.0764827728,
0.3407424092,
-0.007291005,
-0.2642507851,
-0.8174019456,
-0.4867330492,
-0.709459722,
0.0732661635,
-0.3930697143,
-0.8596669436,
0.6985787153,
0.4214192629,
-0.6155821085,
-0.1238611564,
-0.4434970021,
0.2026375979,
0.3214064538,
-0.3009620309,
-0.259521246,
-0.8724672794,
0.0092991712,
0.0934874117,
0.0609566607,
-0.1056971475,
-0.1352033615,
0.9024088979,
-0.5044816136,
0.4787890911,
-0.1186552718,
-0.3246134222,
0.4310953617,
-0.0245559961,
0.4747613072,
-0.2759461403,
-0.3447486758,
0.1011581868,
-0.0244827028,
-0.0714051723,
-0.2401522547,
0.6926475167,
-0.8963944316,
-0.4247540534,
-0.3562656343,
-0.5518622994,
-0.2716109157,
0.2787854075,
0.7793937922,
0.3841856718,
0.0482493043,
0.1857011914,
0.4507223964,
0.1336967051,
0.5049155354,
0.2983351648,
0.1638949513,
-0.7544474602,
0.9861348867,
0.167714864,
0.4618157744,
0.4442959428,
0.2989372909,
-0.4211253226,
-0.2292276174,
-0.5825375915,
0.0039382419,
-0.4241252542,
-0.3606698811,
-0.577241838,
-0.2317543328,
-0.6162626147,
-0.1641116738,
-0.3203471899,
-0.5609673262,
-0.1168163866,
0.0795267373,
0.1286620647,
0.5265092254,
-0.3741648197,
0.566791296,
-0.3988240659,
0.2386294007,
0.3103903532,
0.1138185114,
-0.3414254785,
-0.6263270974,
0.0314105712,
0.3219983876,
-0.1906669438,
-1.0573003292,
0.418353945,
0.6408668756,
0.4145635366,
0.6397453547,
0.1981264204,
0.964445889,
-0.3606592119,
0.3640536964,
0.6561336517,
-1.1360486746,
0.3994865119,
-0.0477787331,
0.216552943,
0.7339442372,
0.5344043374,
-0.5838667154,
-0.3568329513,
-0.4498211741,
-0.7865526676,
0.4254692197,
0.1388279647,
-0.4935329556,
0.0996572971,
0.2605031133,
-0.2015461475,
0.3446536958,
0.0672170818,
-0.0158167686,
-0.0070976666,
-0.7062250972,
-0.1193557903,
0.0744627416,
-0.5504825711,
-0.2535581887,
0.7735010386,
-0.4264689982,
0.5075430274,
0.5766882896,
-0.1914337873,
-0.396849215,
0.1998819709,
0.3140923381,
0.3378089666,
-0.0689520389,
0.5542420149,
0.3198812604,
-0.4791437685,
0.279984206,
-0.073785305,
-0.1042067483,
-0.0268545542,
0.2363249063,
0.5616238117,
0.2131538689,
-0.3867573142,
0.5917550325,
0.0207282808,
-0.4168089628,
-0.3724884391,
0.0408378206,
0.2222667485,
0.1197161749,
0.4772074223,
0.0044127926,
0.3482792377,
-0.5632055402,
0.5559577942,
0.349709183,
-0.8162704706,
-0.0684329048,
0.2114511877,
0.0412196144,
-0.3318170309,
0.7686322331,
-0.190536499,
-0.4226608276,
0.4912031591,
1.0044134855,
0.6282128096,
-0.5736896396,
0.0479732528,
0.653526485,
0.1321703494,
-0.5655543208,
0.4207482934,
-0.1986248344,
-1.0881683826,
-0.3030884862,
-0.8897947073,
-0.6281286478,
-0.6709050536,
-0.9784556031,
0.2455834746,
-0.2425807118,
-0.3733390272,
-0.3274867535,
-0.2042414099,
-0.2409200221,
0.2604458928,
0.3857521415,
0.9448341727,
-0.7450025678,
0.8807711601,
0.3375912309,
0.2075185925,
-0.8458504677,
-0.0348418877,
0.1147011593,
-0.8933268785,
-0.0703856051,
0.2738881111,
-0.4831771553,
0.3206900358,
-0.4281858802,
-1.1756919622,
1.5599756241,
0.1288897693,
-0.880480051,
-0.0506175868,
0.122195825,
0.4150302708,
-0.4997507632,
0.0205764323,
0.8408911824,
0.6057192683,
0.8109164238,
-1.0645090342,
-0.0147538064,
-0.0654527023,
-0.3794170022,
0.0807797462,
-0.2114644945,
0.7165879607,
-0.6528563499,
-0.5664817095,
0.0318912305,
0.7801874876,
0.6390188336,
0.5887126923,
0.7192612886,
0.8120517135,
1.2016980648,
-0.3102523386,
0.7208512425,
-0.5591501594,
0.2941143513,
1.2746083736,
-0.3113222718,
1.3377572298,
0.6977013946,
0.0759310573,
0.4136956632,
0.5593634844,
0.3202843368,
0.4002786577,
0.3140881062,
-0.262015909,
-0.3119221032,
-0.2622316182,
-0.1815814525,
0.5205864906,
0.6199380159,
-0.1304922551,
0.1187231541,
-0.2073267102,
-0.0728766099,
-0.2363339067,
-0.3869881332,
1.0350843668,
0.4086658359,
-0.6606837511,
0.5346553922,
-0.3305740356,
0.9383807182,
-0.3519780636,
0.1306109726,
0.306876272,
0.2999200523,
-0.4151059091,
-0.6188610792,
0.2152218968,
-0.2457535118,
0.0617368892,
0.2632211447,
0.8157690763,
-0.9163842201,
-0.2663082182,
0.3536541462,
0.6200456619,
0.2616500556,
0.0060425731,
-0.0605895519,
-0.0017813235,
-0.2881816328,
0.2156540006,
0.0568984635,
0.0953122601,
0.2161283195,
0.5252908468,
0.473205775,
0.114448674,
0.0323962606,
-0.1007260159,
0.5299235582,
-0.4386734962,
-0.4553333819,
-0.7464838624,
0.1554577947,
-0.4123306572,
-0.336671114,
0.654229641,
0.3958464563,
0.6575619578,
0.34789747,
0.805572629,
-0.1936420649,
0.2406710684,
-0.1556154639,
0.7695873976,
-0.5137230158,
-0.1665405631,
-0.0027945242,
-0.7198672891,
-0.1962652355,
0.7778191566,
-0.0569786616,
-0.4438567758,
0.6733659506,
0.8705456853,
0.3330826163,
0.226753518,
0.5161614418,
0.2445708662,
0.0898234621,
0.4746572375,
0.6740821004,
-0.5793275237,
0.362179637,
-0.2485856414,
-0.5975429416,
-0.0412364639,
-0.5641950965,
-0.1354317516,
-0.6609991789,
-0.1878537834,
-0.6398454309,
0.3305347562,
1.2463955879,
0.5352168679,
-0.9253742099,
-0.5002172589,
0.0030971586,
0.1039351672,
-0.284291178,
-0.1094200462,
0.2047942281,
-0.0755506903,
-0.7252438664,
0.5101354718,
0.3116481304,
0.1316280812,
-0.0925286263,
-0.439912349,
0.0346200466,
0.0554669425,
0.5325061083,
0.4258442521,
-0.3592834175,
-0.5072273612,
0.1202496812,
-0.2404306084,
-0.0639028847,
0.5200366974,
-0.6988806725,
0.3179910779,
0.738724947,
0.3267070055,
0.2874354124,
0.0939758122,
0.9331068397,
-0.4927236736,
-0.1546214968,
0.1281425357,
0.5522347689,
0.3947241604,
-0.1344103664,
0.1841422915,
0.1717689335,
-0.4641217887,
-0.6739761233,
0.176083222,
-0.9944303036,
0.1252615899,
1.41802001,
-0.0687400401,
-0.4905250967,
-0.2557963133,
0.033470042,
0.5508293509,
-0.5361202955,
0.718672514,
0.3082942367,
-0.1441220492,
0.3042275608,
-0.0175254419,
0.3854507804,
0.0409339666,
-0.7013837695,
-0.1409102082,
0.3274473846,
0.1775125414,
0.8850448132,
0.6298907995,
-0.1367082894,
0.2067505866,
0.2127044797,
0.4027301967,
0.2778430879,
-0.7510301471,
-0.4512871504,
0.3946646154,
-0.0902974308,
-0.4570216238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12576v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12576v2 | Automated Few-shot Classification with Instruction-Finetuned Language Models | 2023-05-21T21:50:27 | 2023-10-21T06:46:51 | Rami Aly, Xingjian Shi, Kaixiang Lin, Aston Zhang, Andrew Gordon Wilson | cs.CL | cs.CL | A particularly successful class of approaches for few-shot learning combines
language models with prompts -- hand-crafted task descriptions that complement
data samples. However, designing prompts by hand for each task commonly
requires domain knowledge and substantial guesswork. We observe, in the context
of classification tasks, that instruction finetuned language models exhibit
remarkable prompt robustness, and we subsequently propose a simple method to
eliminate the need for handcrafted prompts, named AuT-Few. This approach
consists of (i) a prompt retrieval module that selects suitable task
instructions from the instruction-tuning knowledge base, and (ii) the
generation of two distinct, semantically meaningful, class descriptions and a
selection mechanism via cross-validation. Over $12$ datasets, spanning $8$
classification tasks, we show that AuT-Few outperforms current state-of-the-art
few-shot learning methods. Moreover, AuT-Few is the best ranking method across
datasets on the RAFT few-shot benchmark. Notably, these results are achieved
without task-specific handcrafted prompts on unseen tasks. | [
-0.3855627179,
-0.9167564511,
0.3691896498,
-0.3825489283,
-0.0458097979,
-0.112331152,
-0.2337338179,
-0.2039381266,
-0.3686845005,
0.404928863,
-0.7018167973,
-0.6358854771,
-0.6115141511,
0.1704538465,
-0.2327544689,
0.9117289186,
0.1515527517,
-0.2034359127,
0.0985120162,
-0.134352535,
-0.408288002,
-0.1693463624,
-0.5681189895,
-0.3205629587,
0.6086977124,
0.8481693268,
0.362285316,
0.7751948833,
0.4442761838,
0.2813268602,
0.22769171,
0.3783212602,
-0.2745657265,
-0.1541301757,
0.1039039567,
-0.7273010015,
-0.1344157159,
0.1462038159,
0.3427277207,
0.7338103056,
0.2337148935,
0.2259139717,
0.436204493,
0.4245743752,
-0.7177300453,
0.2682349682,
-0.4654204845,
0.1441235691,
-0.4745739698,
-0.2170988172,
-0.6478175521,
-0.1975587308,
0.3014145792,
-0.5028666854,
0.3224408627,
0.2033448964,
0.5908210874,
0.404434979,
-0.2572759688,
-0.0087818038,
-0.4960006773,
1.1030836105,
-0.4385308623,
0.203779459,
0.7644222379,
0.7192814946,
-0.0038156209,
-0.5214464664,
-0.3047527075,
-0.1011700779,
-0.1832391471,
0.1524273902,
-0.4873614907,
0.2861013412,
0.3016014993,
-0.0184965022,
-0.8293079734,
0.4300603867,
-0.3338727057,
-0.3151633441,
0.3886088133,
0.3266104758,
0.1179722026,
-0.3509757221,
-0.3490714133,
-0.018593099,
-0.6709990501,
0.0705272704,
0.2454809099,
0.7862588167,
-0.2434974164,
0.4054276347,
-0.3748728931,
0.9317330122,
0.2055379897,
-0.2670719922,
-0.088009946,
-0.0689908862,
-0.1814254373,
-0.094222635,
0.8330450058,
0.0453099832,
0.041696053,
-0.1136647984,
-0.3031598032,
0.1773779988,
0.0655959249,
-0.6151514649,
-0.3808107972,
-0.0327906832,
-0.3611986637,
-0.3091904223,
-0.2346441448,
-0.4655237794,
-0.1693985462,
-0.14933303,
0.5535995364,
-0.2782445252,
0.3482333124,
-0.4120023251,
-0.0106927687,
0.1296632737,
0.584792912,
-0.9967082739,
0.2975005507,
0.6316177845,
0.782743454,
-0.4615753293,
-0.3100935519,
-0.8134770393,
-0.3123207092,
-0.3653964102,
1.1749457121,
-0.67305547,
-0.2770419121,
-0.0060126074,
-0.1284788251,
0.1720267087,
-0.3559489846,
0.3084745705,
-0.383500725,
0.4365465343,
-0.1596718132,
-0.7529830337,
-0.3516138196,
0.4371103644,
-0.4043450058,
0.6727755666,
0.213620767,
-0.5284391642,
0.5377737284,
-0.416421175,
-0.2638421059,
0.4307352006,
-0.3292259276,
-0.1377937049,
-0.1126449034,
0.1694005281,
0.8278311491,
-0.2390656024,
-0.4964332581,
-0.1460227519,
-0.2344040871,
-0.1414942294,
-0.7148369551,
0.7040391564,
0.3178085983,
-0.2832966447,
-0.0898914486,
-0.7271800041,
0.1220162287,
-0.1114582121,
-0.3334746063,
-0.2179517448,
-0.5047217607,
-0.042835325,
0.0862822458,
0.0072847456,
-0.3268134296,
0.4690800011,
-0.6308028102,
0.0833771229,
0.5722357631,
0.1435254961,
0.8288550377,
-0.5460383296,
0.6854271889,
-0.0708750859,
0.1282704473,
-0.4030580819,
-0.5829433799,
-0.7058650255,
-0.3795199692,
0.1591596305,
0.795866251,
-0.8469094634,
0.2242956311,
0.1639671922,
-0.6112365723,
-0.4453049302,
0.5189026594,
0.4564840198,
0.5217286944,
0.5269038677,
-0.1466685236,
-0.2827643454,
-0.6828333139,
-0.1717907637,
-0.1084467024,
-0.0042468654,
0.311426729,
0.3064847887,
-0.1053988412,
0.8739033937,
-0.4955411553,
-0.5210273862,
-0.4311089516,
0.6030515432,
0.1062743738,
0.4678243101,
0.6590327621,
-0.2006678283,
-0.6322331429,
-0.0228471216,
-0.5310978293,
-0.0099628232,
-0.1634256393,
0.059738256,
0.1536376923,
0.1134508252,
-0.550624907,
0.4332737625,
-0.0905823186,
0.1452665478,
0.2415703982,
0.1885989159,
0.1463697106,
-0.6520785689,
-0.3276852965,
0.0814700946,
-0.291334182,
-0.5231460929,
-0.0627964437,
-0.0922285542,
0.00345221,
-0.7323561311,
0.879922092,
-0.2945600152,
0.1734738648,
-0.5743825436,
-0.0508698188,
-0.0838123336,
0.549398005,
0.1217166483,
0.4354707599,
0.8683766723,
-0.7496246099,
0.5248596072,
0.4242095947,
-0.091963388,
0.6227386594,
-0.2535941005,
0.3156119585,
-0.0815427378,
0.0554907359,
-1.0548170805,
-0.4047174454,
0.1465474963,
-0.4482540488,
0.4475734532,
-0.6553821564,
-0.3189856112,
-0.2857016325,
-0.3103486896,
0.1818882972,
0.7015120983,
-0.5650295615,
0.2587548792,
-0.0547647551,
-0.2490707636,
-0.5342895389,
-0.773304224,
-0.397325933,
-0.2280662209,
-0.0936511457,
-0.0508241169,
0.0409046523,
-0.0353873298,
-0.2452106327,
-0.2093843222,
-0.3235754073,
0.1945904046,
0.1698714644,
0.3289246261,
-0.3503396511,
0.1580527127,
0.1901171952,
-0.4265589118,
-0.3103415966,
-0.3509758711,
0.1620818377,
-0.1696467698,
-0.3721017838,
-0.7554314733,
0.2048377395,
0.1464269906,
-0.023448566,
0.3303131759,
0.7327826023,
-0.4713926613,
-0.5090226531,
-0.4292295575,
-0.5265598297,
-0.453656286,
-0.0192250814,
-0.2543385029,
-0.7962984443,
0.3022761047,
-0.1257255077,
0.4383151531,
0.3707713187,
0.3074251711,
-0.2203522325,
1.0197249651,
0.6230351925,
-0.0815650076,
0.6024107933,
-0.4253693223,
-0.2383218259,
-0.1380532235,
0.1710604727,
-0.626157105,
-0.2930775285,
-0.5326144099,
-0.1191862375,
0.4546897709,
-0.059519846,
-0.3494301438,
0.473618567,
-0.6921842694,
0.8760517836,
0.7725223303,
0.1979069412,
0.1977700144,
-0.0896789581,
-0.0758501589,
0.0281224567,
-1.0538696051,
-0.7446600795,
1.097951889,
-0.0160588045,
0.9813671112,
-0.2309260964,
1.259280324,
0.2854915857,
0.0725974888,
-1.1408509016,
0.435380131,
-0.2702724338,
-0.5664538145,
-0.3878447413,
-0.3464507759,
-0.9761226177,
-0.096122697,
-0.3143205047,
-0.672945261,
-0.0533429235,
0.2650024295,
-1.1674667597,
0.0181475319,
-0.8441610932,
0.9394036531,
-0.1676256508,
-0.3945171833,
-0.0898119211,
-0.8038124442,
0.3192759156,
0.0063376743,
0.0813771859,
-0.0703018159,
0.0502973422,
0.7542265654,
-0.4888389409,
1.1276731491,
-0.2111767679,
0.2938655615,
0.5865293145,
0.1887285113,
0.5250317454,
-0.3452181816,
0.1163177937,
-0.1586676389,
0.1194083542,
-0.3934966028,
-0.600027144,
0.5858102441,
-0.7210882306,
-0.2779316604,
-0.2469218522,
-0.1841092557,
-0.2165833414,
0.2784989774,
0.7113290429,
0.5967122316,
-0.0372680761,
-0.1073326245,
0.5453743935,
-0.1527520716,
0.5222287178,
0.3043036759,
0.2494035214,
-0.177493766,
0.8824912906,
0.3415746987,
0.2315851599,
0.5384781361,
0.3725126088,
-0.15084593,
-0.4113000929,
-0.4652715325,
-0.1627703607,
-0.9615085125,
-0.7189548016,
-0.4498469532,
0.0134075889,
-0.2623098195,
-0.392862618,
-0.469981432,
-0.5905581117,
-0.498236984,
-0.0699305311,
0.4565844536,
0.7516086102,
0.0118042696,
0.7170336843,
-1.093911171,
0.4870785177,
0.7387689352,
0.0538901724,
-0.0856715292,
-0.6381678581,
-0.0740335882,
-0.2199243605,
-0.484198004,
-0.70224756,
0.282345295,
0.4369457066,
0.6650598645,
0.5267156959,
0.3937346935,
0.5719596148,
-0.6428242326,
0.7379686236,
0.1864004582,
-0.6695228815,
0.9133330584,
-0.1215705052,
0.5154148936,
0.6900169849,
0.6118391156,
-0.1026402786,
-0.4186513722,
-0.6359607577,
-0.5536600947,
1.0536463261,
0.0063589215,
0.154328838,
-0.1729680598,
0.0676382259,
0.656103313,
-0.0618155599,
-0.4034367502,
-0.484108597,
-0.0700467825,
-0.5055649281,
0.3179524839,
0.1532084346,
-0.0961942151,
-0.1194264144,
0.6144869924,
-0.3872692883,
0.19106929,
-0.2781939507,
-0.4219203889,
-0.2929107547,
0.5416654348,
0.2407660633,
0.2212915868,
0.093178995,
0.2880140543,
0.3527368903,
-0.2065350115,
0.2132944763,
0.0683666095,
-0.269997716,
-0.0371422954,
0.6437287331,
0.8287673593,
0.3924052119,
-0.2349742353,
0.5434021354,
0.1234150752,
0.0973775163,
0.1769700944,
0.4655641913,
-0.626318574,
0.5079557896,
0.4220754802,
0.3094269931,
0.3843787313,
-0.3740702271,
0.3772402108,
0.4273337424,
-0.1621764004,
-0.3805291355,
0.488142252,
0.2752755582,
-0.1524669081,
0.465792954,
-0.4759400785,
-0.2872256339,
0.2549218833,
0.165235132,
0.9745294452,
-0.2104892731,
0.2976224422,
0.4252533019,
0.1898652762,
-0.3335975707,
0.0513956361,
-0.5015755296,
-0.61104846,
-0.1302581429,
-0.4052240252,
-0.6316463947,
-0.0388694555,
-0.5069503784,
0.5645865202,
-0.664060533,
-0.2803522348,
0.1677850783,
0.1662615538,
-1.0127688646,
-0.0394851901,
0.418242842,
0.5975939631,
-1.0112452507,
0.6183165312,
0.678166151,
-0.5676326156,
-0.7433726788,
-0.2287660986,
0.5247101188,
-0.670514822,
0.6678444147,
0.2415109724,
-0.093124859,
0.3335918188,
-0.8560214639,
-0.4193888009,
0.7853562832,
0.3256828189,
-0.5278714299,
-0.1529168338,
-0.0817269906,
0.2600886226,
-0.1576410234,
0.3745878041,
0.5755978823,
0.3819135427,
0.1685636938,
-1.0781607628,
-0.3293173313,
0.247242257,
-0.4066082835,
-0.1671565324,
-0.490129143,
0.491951108,
-0.3532855809,
-0.3034759164,
0.2083650231,
0.5830110312,
0.2224313468,
0.4458458722,
0.3144058883,
0.1785236001,
0.7648722529,
-0.1512736231,
0.8743143678,
0.0779669061,
0.3792943358,
1.0400333405,
-0.1018939987,
0.8058201075,
0.1480974555,
-0.3018963337,
0.1791651398,
0.6245458126,
0.0870898515,
0.7356305122,
-0.2793010473,
-0.1570279747,
-0.7282803655,
0.0455680862,
0.066222854,
0.6948943138,
0.2033815682,
0.0389416367,
-0.5553735495,
0.5170155764,
-0.3020088375,
-0.0646694005,
-0.4105484784,
1.1454399824,
0.2810586989,
-0.4471278787,
0.9022814631,
-0.2517758906,
0.9234186411,
-0.4658116102,
-0.1943054795,
-0.2704837918,
0.0877436176,
-0.3601677418,
-0.6446424127,
-0.0386960916,
0.4582914412,
-0.0058138948,
-0.2779780924,
0.7749522924,
-0.4964163303,
-0.2229658216,
-0.3283244967,
0.7101277709,
0.3393249214,
0.1506613493,
-0.7358293533,
-0.1723157614,
-0.2914407849,
-0.2335923165,
0.3144553304,
0.5962888002,
-0.104775019,
0.6490319371,
0.2947595119,
-0.1564661115,
0.2059408128,
-0.0642184094,
0.6189510822,
-0.5440468788,
-0.5275952816,
-0.8040462732,
0.3410033584,
0.4527664185,
-0.2070820779,
0.6970912218,
0.4238268733,
0.858818233,
-0.2295162827,
0.9286639094,
0.1749805063,
0.5457921028,
-0.5542470217,
0.5165973902,
-0.4200135469,
0.1918805689,
-0.3087036312,
-0.7235614657,
-0.5574070811,
0.793458581,
-0.3642938733,
0.1391885728,
0.6278403401,
0.6814553738,
-0.2245824635,
-0.0850045383,
0.5180390477,
-0.153028205,
-0.0738785118,
0.5754253864,
0.9326768517,
-0.4939936996,
0.5301561356,
-0.5423389673,
-0.2728282511,
-0.3761562407,
-0.5587110519,
-1.1394318342,
-0.4331099093,
-0.5684172511,
0.2133216709,
0.0006865707,
1.4698392153,
0.9477989674,
-0.9921417236,
0.0450637713,
0.0060779024,
0.1914919019,
-0.3174439967,
-0.2139355093,
0.3112390637,
-0.7195416689,
-0.7608052492,
0.6135449409,
0.1967431754,
0.4323823452,
0.0054981089,
-0.089919284,
0.2072149217,
-0.2176711559,
0.6106832623,
0.5073201656,
-0.7705516815,
-0.3014496565,
0.1143607274,
-0.2275032848,
-0.0620123707,
0.4562775791,
-1.1177072525,
0.2912206054,
0.6549402475,
0.7945304513,
0.2605874836,
-0.0602569841,
0.107864745,
-1.2504775524,
0.1912544817,
0.3986297846,
0.244971633,
0.2579753697,
-0.3050000072,
0.3070795238,
0.2024286389,
-0.4358189106,
-0.7759204507,
0.1834916025,
-1.0598058701,
-0.0420825258,
1.1307559013,
-0.2424555123,
-0.2387044579,
-0.1419893503,
-0.2775459588,
0.276928395,
-0.4247437119,
0.5597295165,
0.5847667456,
-0.3937976658,
-0.4755401015,
-0.4789904654,
0.5599635243,
0.1292192489,
-0.9302091002,
0.0910780281,
0.735191226,
0.1259538531,
0.0198750757,
0.3042085469,
0.2490998209,
0.6032121181,
0.0156804845,
-0.26764521,
-0.0462363176,
-0.6144109964,
-0.4209381044,
0.122561574,
0.3968189359,
-0.4215055704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12567v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12567v1 | Model-Generated Pretraining Signals Improves Zero-Shot Generalization of Text-to-Text Transformers | 2023-05-21T21:06:23 | 2023-05-21T21:06:23 | Linyuan Gong, Chenyan Xiong, Xiaodong Liu, Payal Bajaj, Yiqing Xie, Alvin Cheung, Jianfeng Gao, Xia Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper explores the effectiveness of model-generated signals in improving
zero-shot generalization of text-to-text Transformers such as T5. We study
various designs to pretrain T5 using an auxiliary model to construct more
challenging token replacements for the main model to denoise. Key aspects under
study include the decoding target, the location of the RTD head, and the
masking pattern. Based on these studies, we develop a new model, METRO-T0,
which is pretrained using the redesigned ELECTRA-Style pretraining strategies
and then prompt-finetuned on a mixture of NLP tasks. METRO-T0 outperforms all
similar-sized baselines on prompted NLP benchmarks, such as T0 Eval and MMLU,
and rivals the state-of-the-art T0-11B model with only 8% of its parameters.
Our analysis on model's neural activation and parameter sensitivity reveals
that the effectiveness of METRO-T0 stems from more balanced contribution of
parameters and better utilization of their capacity. The code and model
checkpoints are available at https://github.com/gonglinyuan/metro_t0. | [
-0.3966779113,
-0.4670908153,
0.5152260065,
0.069711715,
-0.6478020549,
-0.1085684672,
-0.1158339903,
-0.3060576022,
0.019210374,
0.3248131573,
-0.5793161392,
-0.5902325511,
-0.6841949224,
0.4244984984,
-0.7634871006,
0.903460145,
0.1699930876,
-0.0464171879,
0.3457759917,
0.1164337695,
-0.5311638117,
-0.5746534467,
-0.6340427399,
-0.548697412,
0.4660551846,
0.249792859,
0.1616958678,
0.3881019652,
0.527564466,
0.1615506858,
0.0577587411,
-0.362344861,
-0.4806313515,
-0.2244519293,
0.1429135054,
-0.5390977859,
-0.79196316,
-0.1373784095,
0.5801923871,
0.5118767023,
-0.1077492684,
0.3523073792,
-0.0115452651,
0.2417585403,
-0.4763966501,
-0.0694129914,
-0.7746806741,
-0.0454921052,
-0.1218892559,
-0.2854299545,
-0.8207566738,
-0.0164423175,
0.1064348146,
-0.6319932342,
0.7383079529,
-0.0783857927,
1.3954660892,
0.4184797704,
-0.5325831771,
0.1277031898,
-1.088578105,
1.0018317699,
-0.968519628,
0.5760490894,
0.0352719538,
0.4281779528,
0.1837693751,
-1.1142189503,
-0.3892219961,
-0.1298731118,
0.0189811289,
0.3633110225,
-0.2395415306,
0.3476726711,
0.5335441828,
0.0968874022,
-0.1336684525,
0.2724278867,
-0.4514273703,
0.0669991896,
0.367503345,
0.0194378719,
0.312266022,
-0.0804479942,
-0.2216367722,
-0.059482839,
-0.9041385651,
-0.1904588044,
0.2583675385,
0.1931327283,
-0.1756200045,
0.3480088115,
-0.3248630464,
0.9874468446,
0.2740530074,
0.1078288108,
0.3127559721,
-0.3609573841,
-0.2860142589,
-0.1037318781,
0.8150207996,
0.3809868991,
0.4458564222,
-0.3381551802,
-0.3692600131,
-0.0132716578,
0.6510596275,
-1.099881053,
-0.0714420229,
0.1988623738,
-0.5418530107,
-0.6452498436,
-0.0616622157,
-0.5037916303,
0.2037102878,
-0.5549188852,
0.637681067,
-0.3272657394,
-0.4082731605,
0.3429264724,
-0.3209115863,
0.2719712853,
0.1709603369,
-1.28794837,
-0.1108184457,
0.1706386209,
0.7073383331,
0.1318794191,
-0.0806353539,
-0.2181941271,
0.2058456093,
-0.4480907917,
1.0016752481,
-0.4130263329,
-0.4065769017,
-0.1190347224,
-0.2715330124,
-0.1994431019,
-0.4789332449,
0.6717445254,
-0.4259860814,
0.302051127,
-0.1207250729,
-0.2288863659,
-0.0174030624,
0.2190089077,
-0.7107231021,
0.8711820245,
0.0992242917,
-0.8221718669,
0.5788187385,
-0.9354467988,
-0.3144176602,
-0.1543647349,
0.0953283608,
-0.6059482694,
0.3614189625,
0.5861181021,
0.421366632,
-0.1959469467,
0.1674832851,
-0.2976156175,
-0.6979920268,
-0.000228595,
-0.4326488376,
0.5752664804,
0.1555621475,
-0.2905650139,
0.3096015751,
-0.8326427341,
-0.0154447965,
0.1517812759,
-0.0588844679,
-0.1638030857,
-0.0146565931,
-0.0697084963,
0.2644978166,
0.1020003632,
-0.5655611753,
0.0570313893,
-0.5037230849,
0.6310794353,
0.396738112,
0.1291564703,
0.500181675,
-0.3317967951,
0.5405110121,
0.1437072903,
0.2170377672,
-0.4821486473,
-0.2673206627,
-1.0576735735,
-0.1831350625,
0.5723438859,
0.350926429,
-0.899889648,
0.3734480739,
-0.3950413167,
-0.5657347441,
-0.62766397,
-0.3835699856,
0.098931998,
0.7397508621,
0.7050619721,
-0.1255438924,
-0.7653403878,
-0.6415596008,
-0.2483623177,
0.0644801557,
-0.5732237101,
-0.1449726075,
0.3658948541,
-0.2501204014,
1.0584796667,
-0.2755950093,
-0.2110017985,
-0.5525333881,
0.3785407245,
0.322368145,
0.302066654,
0.7462899089,
-0.3130443692,
-0.35131073,
-0.3373085856,
-0.6693876982,
-0.5873708129,
-0.2769348621,
0.1888908148,
-0.0649038926,
0.5789146423,
-0.615996182,
0.5700389743,
0.3624846339,
-0.1905838847,
0.7286604643,
-0.159842357,
0.0580730475,
-1.4810148478,
0.42366907,
-0.0816254392,
-0.2772974074,
-1.1563512087,
-0.0339461155,
0.0474156551,
-0.2582396865,
-0.5558575988,
0.368639946,
-0.436494261,
-0.1076898798,
-0.3466740549,
0.0640503913,
0.0489033945,
0.3379073143,
0.2549917996,
0.7829052806,
0.2593002319,
-0.7332256436,
-0.0892513543,
0.3505167067,
-0.1825815141,
0.2746036053,
-1.1109428406,
0.2988215387,
-0.3233579695,
0.1686059833,
-0.8481228352,
0.2162585407,
0.0426250361,
-0.7028459311,
0.345508039,
-0.1302285492,
-0.3484950066,
-0.3327094018,
-0.1393757761,
0.4716617763,
0.7605676055,
-0.410399586,
0.5972032547,
-0.0908726975,
0.1097461134,
-0.4965292513,
-0.6747594476,
0.1663214117,
-0.1774102747,
-0.2438109517,
0.4932120144,
0.1674123555,
0.2657310069,
-0.3325965703,
0.0015625344,
-0.0195098277,
0.0169514865,
-0.0444165468,
0.412111342,
-0.0835633352,
0.0191700812,
0.120408453,
-0.540594995,
-0.0113978777,
-0.344845742,
0.9091712832,
0.3266083002,
-0.1841434091,
-0.6724686027,
0.0464088172,
0.4171492159,
-0.2842265069,
0.4942977428,
0.8634037971,
-0.0352509208,
-0.2454987168,
-0.2410907894,
-0.5256956816,
-0.5060976148,
0.4092387855,
-0.5266809464,
-0.7323411107,
0.3183448911,
-0.1838254333,
0.3242731988,
0.541431427,
0.3628608286,
-0.0215049647,
1.1557732821,
0.8302453756,
0.0819127336,
0.7136246562,
-0.4899505377,
0.4332507551,
-0.8363546729,
-0.0763409659,
-0.636885941,
-0.3144953847,
-0.2631371617,
-0.197450459,
0.2840173841,
0.0502655208,
-0.416898936,
0.5305336118,
-0.5632179379,
0.1628802866,
0.5423510671,
0.1273213029,
0.3051527143,
0.2092587352,
-0.1543778777,
-0.2807954848,
-0.8403858542,
-0.4226177335,
1.5148265362,
0.4095320702,
0.6197569966,
-0.3394179642,
0.815043807,
0.0414727591,
0.3640497625,
-0.6119955182,
0.43587026,
-0.3199421465,
-0.6269801855,
-0.0010065092,
-0.4201049209,
-0.9222009182,
0.0103948265,
-0.4816061556,
-0.5997456908,
-0.0046730572,
0.2402166575,
-0.4436184466,
0.3346249461,
-0.8389278054,
0.757850945,
0.0744394735,
0.12829265,
-0.1194697842,
-0.2891879082,
0.2488203943,
-0.2158801854,
-0.2693942487,
0.1171358302,
0.088900663,
0.602927506,
-0.2650825679,
0.8537405729,
-0.1742251366,
0.0389320441,
0.2015352696,
-0.3663927913,
0.3060932159,
-0.4214007258,
-0.0686261207,
0.523973763,
-0.1047987044,
-0.4231160879,
-0.5227102637,
0.0302120075,
-0.9012070894,
-0.4992924631,
-0.0657297149,
-0.3859247863,
-0.1237320453,
0.5361861587,
0.8231582046,
0.740644753,
-0.1108975634,
0.3948304057,
0.6338012218,
-0.2102638781,
0.8274936676,
0.4682163894,
-0.5018868446,
-0.3420463502,
0.6662960052,
-0.0166346673,
0.5766764283,
0.5249772668,
-0.1988289058,
-0.3470950723,
-0.7128808498,
-0.51013273,
0.0760962516,
-0.3539402783,
-0.2161369026,
-0.5644257069,
-0.4155638218,
-0.3743529022,
-0.0390642919,
-0.4566745758,
-0.245542258,
-0.5173662305,
-0.1812845469,
-0.08400435,
0.7002933025,
0.3376128078,
0.8600945473,
-0.8656859994,
0.601298511,
0.0991890952,
0.2419382185,
0.0635018125,
-0.9114707112,
-0.1776198149,
0.2297654301,
-0.248366341,
-0.8507856727,
0.4790111482,
0.0982903913,
0.3216369152,
0.6157768369,
0.110774599,
0.6017447114,
-0.5838286877,
0.6994485855,
0.3614037931,
-1.0175285339,
0.2470738143,
-0.6963664889,
0.8172412515,
0.2489365637,
0.0941165984,
-0.3380627036,
-0.3522894382,
-0.5600117445,
-0.4913512468,
0.7334619761,
0.3937267363,
0.2836933136,
0.2790058553,
0.4721983671,
-0.1386613101,
0.2941924334,
-0.8853806257,
-0.14250651,
-0.63046664,
-0.373508215,
-0.0521180965,
-0.4444004297,
0.2755999565,
-0.2636191845,
0.2871142924,
0.0047944174,
0.7873939276,
0.1746561378,
-0.0038086399,
-0.0449740961,
0.3338599205,
0.6839094758,
0.5475310683,
-0.2602915764,
-0.0642319471,
0.4111714661,
-0.6560636163,
0.0835689306,
-0.0575667806,
-0.6924465895,
0.3511479199,
0.5149689913,
1.093862772,
0.0680544302,
-0.1538691372,
0.3870993853,
-0.1703457385,
-0.5308625698,
-0.1770749241,
0.0369116999,
-0.1434735656,
-0.2206082195,
0.3722579479,
0.1422001272,
-0.0571825877,
-0.2808802724,
0.1148126945,
0.2244538963,
-0.2706961334,
-0.6716388464,
1.0309325457,
0.4322565198,
-0.2678506076,
0.7183195949,
0.0275443234,
-0.5728712678,
0.4589693844,
0.8953551054,
1.0277098417,
-0.3419491053,
0.2703679204,
0.6524856687,
0.5984249115,
0.0743148923,
0.2280177623,
0.0169540644,
-0.7488695979,
-0.7762101293,
-0.59784621,
-0.1894359887,
0.2892801464,
-0.4472330511,
0.7901035547,
-0.512911737,
-0.4568863213,
-0.2279379666,
-0.1808674335,
-0.5866755843,
0.6138445735,
-0.0295872409,
0.8634715676,
-0.7799765468,
1.1194264889,
0.5861336589,
-0.4723792076,
-1.0218786001,
0.0440796092,
-0.6131544709,
-0.5858870149,
0.5574342012,
0.3814037442,
0.0854103714,
0.485019207,
-0.4263822436,
-0.8536447883,
1.170732975,
0.4215165377,
-0.7017002106,
-0.4349266589,
0.6341787577,
0.6164105535,
-0.4122828841,
0.7762131095,
0.4852389097,
0.2433851957,
0.2249397635,
-0.9722286463,
-0.1230249926,
-0.2168280929,
0.1242186353,
0.2803782523,
-0.4171850383,
0.7423818111,
-0.1168087497,
-0.2376125902,
-0.0417750664,
0.4236949384,
0.1377022266,
0.1468482018,
0.402652055,
0.8048967123,
0.1455830783,
-0.1720329374,
0.8331037164,
-0.4419748485,
0.3050418794,
0.9193974733,
0.0754648373,
0.8156428337,
0.3101533651,
0.0645173416,
0.5847896338,
0.4420187771,
-0.0925896391,
0.4709767103,
-0.2056961656,
-0.2306405008,
-0.2167693377,
-0.0091013601,
-0.4296255112,
0.3000329435,
0.1124876812,
-0.3452510834,
-0.5074427128,
-0.1003349721,
-0.1128792316,
-0.2235492021,
-0.2806361616,
0.7465628982,
0.2611338198,
-0.4896772504,
0.7034618855,
0.1621834785,
0.6952174902,
-0.6729745269,
0.0930822715,
-0.2666763961,
0.237062782,
-0.1587949991,
-0.1533650607,
0.4386686087,
0.092777282,
-0.185450539,
-0.492845118,
0.8960213065,
-0.3828043044,
-0.2773599923,
0.1396148205,
0.1638991535,
-0.0525313132,
-0.2399283499,
-0.5136765242,
-0.0799308419,
0.1807889938,
-0.1442850679,
0.1468965113,
0.0988455042,
0.2082309723,
0.5606433749,
0.7709924579,
0.0206872281,
0.238946721,
0.4733508527,
0.6398898363,
-0.731748879,
-0.3749909997,
-0.782142818,
0.7105209231,
-0.1352449507,
-0.3174116611,
0.6457747817,
0.2096528709,
0.6920945644,
-0.4367781281,
0.5973917842,
0.0753262639,
0.5640621185,
-0.5226125121,
0.9958352447,
-0.3848266602,
0.1809099317,
-0.2156800479,
-1.2125567198,
-0.3228993714,
0.2474256754,
-0.4515402317,
0.3436198831,
0.7871851921,
0.6916741729,
-0.1334019154,
-0.281057775,
0.5895756483,
0.0427869521,
0.464029938,
0.6759727597,
0.6729585528,
-0.9044716954,
0.7555397153,
-0.0913936943,
0.0805151612,
-0.0980796367,
-0.8917638659,
-1.3578974009,
-0.4371304512,
-0.1014784053,
-0.0490168445,
-0.1874686331,
0.4561206102,
0.9103621244,
-0.6251783967,
-0.05360277,
-0.4970653653,
-0.2522113919,
0.0605589487,
-0.1194645539,
0.10453742,
-0.7414427996,
-0.8040380478,
0.2344611585,
0.0443488173,
0.3100797236,
0.1499169022,
0.0625061914,
-0.0375098176,
0.1243741289,
0.6114723086,
0.0757808313,
-0.3228878081,
-0.2160623968,
0.2792370915,
0.0260075498,
0.0542696975,
0.7492566109,
-0.7989636064,
0.4118098319,
0.4558918476,
0.2843642235,
0.6726440787,
0.1842517704,
0.950214386,
-0.8337638974,
0.4378476143,
0.0525376946,
0.1452145875,
0.241211161,
0.1207600385,
0.3665735424,
0.2980885208,
-0.4303691685,
-0.7761436701,
0.2285686582,
-0.747228682,
-0.0528953932,
0.9843599796,
0.0660641491,
-0.1174774766,
0.0284534954,
-0.2378141433,
0.6392472386,
-0.1124299243,
1.0030134916,
0.488707304,
0.3469277918,
-0.4586235583,
-0.6248556972,
0.601308465,
0.6387690306,
-0.8172386289,
-0.3559335768,
0.1928123087,
0.3824871778,
0.0250487234,
0.5880254507,
-0.0716864094,
0.2526654601,
0.0672810599,
0.4369452894,
-0.2728381455,
-0.3233435452,
-0.4290785193,
0.019644063,
0.044262033,
-0.370921433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12565v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12565v1 | Understanding the Effect of Data Augmentation on Knowledge Distillation | 2023-05-21T21:02:55 | 2023-05-21T21:02:55 | Ziqi Wang, Chi Han, Wenxuan Bao, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge distillation (KD) requires sufficient data to transfer knowledge
from large-scale teacher models to small-scale student models. Therefore, data
augmentation has been widely used to mitigate the shortage of data under
specific scenarios. Classic data augmentation techniques, such as synonym
replacement and k-nearest-neighbors, are initially designed for fine-tuning. To
avoid severe semantic shifts and preserve task-specific labels, those methods
prefer to change only a small proportion of tokens (e.g., changing 10% tokens
is generally the best option for fine-tuning). However, such data augmentation
methods are sub-optimal for knowledge distillation since the teacher model
could provide label distributions and is more tolerant to semantic shifts. We
first observe that KD prefers as much data as possible, which is different from
fine-tuning that too much data will not gain more performance. Since changing
more tokens leads to more semantic shifts, we use the proportion of changed
tokens to reflect semantic shift degrees. Then we find that KD prefers
augmented data with a larger semantic shift degree (e.g., changing 30% tokens
is generally the best option for KD) than fine-tuning (changing 10% tokens).
Besides, our findings show that smaller datasets prefer larger degrees until
the out-of-distribution problem occurs (e.g., datasets with less than 10k
inputs may prefer the 50% degree, and datasets with more than 100k inputs may
prefer the 10% degree). Our work sheds light on the preference difference in
data augmentation between fine-tuning and knowledge distillation and encourages
the community to explore KD-specific data augmentation methods. | [
-0.6792059541,
-0.7046220899,
0.456063807,
-0.2299661934,
-0.4525859952,
0.0196201243,
-0.1869950444,
-0.3956663609,
-0.0497011915,
0.2074552029,
-0.3687107563,
-0.2002544403,
-0.8218100667,
0.1236928552,
-0.4093419909,
1.1205481291,
-0.0078348601,
0.0573729835,
-0.5098242164,
-0.0251162965,
-0.8546943665,
-0.5119608045,
-0.3161867857,
-0.8153158426,
0.476297766,
0.778667748,
0.8537697792,
0.7696931362,
0.4982731938,
0.2790662646,
-0.2468458712,
0.0137037225,
-0.6936751604,
0.1424951851,
-0.2327304184,
-0.7730680108,
-0.1064907387,
0.1163646579,
0.1840887368,
1.0947880745,
0.0759841204,
0.189436838,
0.1771091372,
1.3579318523,
-0.8133727312,
0.2727745175,
-0.7615535855,
0.0296450332,
-0.106553711,
-0.1011742428,
-0.0149062835,
-0.3846356273,
0.4906974137,
-0.8636345267,
0.2513071895,
-0.1607894003,
0.5711916089,
0.663551569,
-0.5754560828,
-0.2518482804,
-0.8901564479,
0.4383111298,
-0.615757525,
0.4862151742,
0.4998316169,
0.2457877547,
-0.3630109429,
-0.7024437189,
-0.9297755361,
0.1631733626,
-0.0386441052,
-0.0502043143,
-0.0337413661,
0.1975647211,
0.5960462093,
0.7382578254,
0.0872253254,
0.1029226184,
-0.5313755274,
0.0868486539,
0.5326939225,
0.2703592181,
-0.1206115112,
0.0386553928,
-0.4027479291,
-0.5200148225,
-0.4285459816,
0.047672227,
0.5423828959,
0.1708554029,
0.418389082,
0.6992886662,
-0.6045686603,
0.8016650081,
0.5102961659,
-0.2403533608,
0.4038001299,
-0.5096772909,
-0.2997641861,
0.384796232,
0.285481751,
0.7188237906,
0.2499792278,
-0.0929481909,
-0.0197585169,
0.178882286,
0.0815488845,
-0.9059273005,
-0.765756011,
0.0620138571,
-0.3217015266,
-0.5241959095,
0.0555654056,
-0.5147607327,
-0.6856888533,
-0.9794363976,
0.6115784645,
-0.5042282343,
-0.2179855555,
0.361012429,
-0.7495595217,
-0.1979785115,
0.2774496377,
-1.044698596,
0.0909760892,
0.7050279379,
0.5605348945,
-0.3369610012,
-0.1476291418,
0.0403512754,
0.0735644698,
-0.4724823534,
0.460144788,
-0.6588757634,
-0.5997901559,
-0.5381649137,
0.0046252226,
0.1045232192,
-0.8587617874,
0.4132383168,
-0.5960107446,
0.0637730882,
-0.6762073636,
-1.0107403994,
-0.1786812246,
0.030487854,
-0.6438990831,
1.0132774115,
0.2348349839,
-0.8300498128,
1.2336782217,
-0.6402230859,
-0.3285908997,
-0.2246869802,
0.1818652749,
-0.3002060652,
0.3582452238,
0.2406353951,
0.2139228135,
-0.045795694,
0.1107177958,
-0.4272289872,
-0.2291200161,
0.3817946315,
-0.5079240203,
0.3828709126,
0.3204551339,
-0.0685952306,
-0.4317780733,
-0.8130265474,
-0.1831206828,
-0.3001029193,
-0.3343876004,
-0.9575116634,
-0.0058739372,
-0.3676496744,
0.1427197754,
0.2429903001,
-0.6879763603,
0.3920934498,
-0.4829948843,
0.267742753,
0.9360236526,
0.2937846184,
0.8203345537,
-0.4362627566,
0.1361454278,
0.6929495931,
0.2221026719,
0.043437738,
-0.2985371947,
-0.5410993099,
-0.0444556661,
0.5648344159,
0.1978860348,
-1.0715579987,
0.1368542761,
-0.2849361002,
-0.5426449776,
-0.7659559846,
0.3075049818,
-0.2294099331,
0.9646576643,
0.496471405,
-0.0283647105,
-0.4669098854,
-0.8366265893,
-0.0940253958,
-0.0731337741,
0.1606327444,
0.1311905831,
0.2980143726,
-0.0815010816,
1.3092336655,
-0.924438715,
-0.366106391,
0.0280072428,
-0.0816190988,
0.3146227896,
0.5395391583,
0.5168092847,
-1.0686776638,
-0.6318487525,
0.1254244745,
-0.3398973048,
-0.0606829897,
0.0157480352,
-0.2188775837,
0.1466811895,
0.1651574075,
-0.4481538534,
0.727694869,
0.137339443,
-0.2086102217,
0.2793820202,
-0.3708840013,
0.4242981374,
-1.068213582,
-0.2050331235,
-0.242833674,
0.0190764647,
-0.6803352237,
-0.1592338681,
0.0788111389,
0.273149997,
-0.2304491252,
0.1051710993,
-0.1619740874,
0.2260351479,
-0.6131868958,
-0.0840793625,
0.2543825507,
-0.0200501792,
-0.1289478242,
0.6067157984,
0.6067672372,
-0.8621065021,
0.7979485989,
0.1622277051,
-0.4781191349,
0.759550333,
-0.499830097,
-0.0477688015,
-0.3598226011,
0.1834436357,
-1.1909037828,
-0.1177050248,
0.0026939602,
-0.4022969306,
0.2714010179,
-0.0731936172,
-0.4926581085,
-0.4359055459,
-0.4840681851,
0.3868446052,
0.6138516068,
-0.7930189967,
0.3129268289,
0.2756583691,
0.1383138746,
-0.4150110185,
-0.8292649388,
-0.023295993,
-0.6095207334,
-0.614911437,
0.4027330875,
-0.0871950537,
-0.2029598206,
0.2178658098,
-0.4157283902,
-0.0183750372,
0.1215590984,
0.1827765405,
0.3458829522,
0.1369802952,
0.3698429763,
0.4362757504,
-0.2344707549,
0.0641731694,
-0.4738479257,
0.2306552678,
0.5262954235,
-0.3072851598,
-0.4125577509,
0.02039342,
0.5612096786,
0.3907604814,
0.9189923406,
0.5672764778,
-0.0870279893,
0.1630855203,
-0.5332206488,
-0.6032996774,
-0.4966416359,
0.1073741838,
-0.5076798797,
-0.5695849657,
0.4653050005,
-0.2607241869,
-0.0103462171,
0.409760952,
0.3737598062,
-0.2350492626,
1.0153770447,
0.4311817884,
-0.3098592758,
0.5536218286,
-0.2804408073,
0.2838220596,
-0.7847698331,
-0.2055713981,
-0.3894641697,
-0.8823533654,
-0.6489502192,
-0.1684479415,
0.5403029919,
0.1554049104,
0.2322731465,
0.0644459277,
-0.6768217683,
0.6230509877,
0.6430081129,
0.3257370889,
0.4921912849,
0.1582641304,
0.1998089552,
-0.21554479,
-0.7663763165,
0.1365490705,
1.4295043945,
0.0955630317,
1.0612773895,
-0.1321253777,
0.724906683,
0.2684721351,
-0.30121997,
-0.7945178151,
0.2064604014,
-0.3144404292,
-0.4989100993,
-0.3940090835,
-0.412776649,
-0.8879513144,
0.112730518,
-0.2517290711,
-0.2638138235,
0.7194004655,
0.2822059989,
-0.0735725164,
0.3426454961,
-1.1036909819,
0.5098958611,
0.3665064871,
-0.097128503,
-0.2344697267,
-0.6197986603,
0.2441079319,
-0.2814557552,
0.0659587607,
0.0957359076,
0.033780463,
0.519811511,
-0.9005538225,
0.6080597639,
-0.5623040795,
-0.1293801516,
0.2721613348,
-0.1632872224,
0.6841840148,
-0.0640913174,
-0.026162833,
-0.1019865796,
0.3132109642,
-0.3219657838,
-0.8880985975,
0.8081380725,
-0.8631464839,
-0.7475265265,
-0.1970741153,
-0.7984492183,
-0.2118275464,
-0.2464298904,
0.20427984,
0.2166272551,
0.4314450622,
0.49614501,
0.7979080081,
0.2003249973,
0.1983360797,
0.2540495992,
-0.2078641057,
-0.0820547566,
1.0268198252,
0.6257312298,
0.7237496376,
0.0834870562,
0.4650297761,
-0.4994515777,
-0.4617946744,
-0.4533185959,
-0.3591482937,
-0.7889745831,
-0.177625671,
-0.5212088227,
0.0584890358,
-0.6534022689,
0.0332729705,
-0.1552599221,
-0.9282087684,
-0.4819500148,
-0.4184544086,
1.0768380165,
0.3909327388,
-0.4212360084,
0.1390489638,
-0.3665773869,
0.4882761836,
0.4256440997,
0.1290511638,
0.0242659543,
-0.6585734487,
-0.1697019637,
0.4823616743,
-0.1379550248,
-0.7239096761,
-0.0624720939,
0.3572999835,
0.2759756744,
0.3870512247,
0.4420707226,
1.1438586712,
-0.1671951115,
0.6996898651,
0.0247213971,
-0.5581970811,
0.4497947097,
0.0330962911,
0.4874260128,
0.8711564541,
0.2967514396,
-0.6057981849,
-0.3028396368,
-0.4607299566,
-1.0693562031,
0.7671865821,
-0.1019096673,
0.4378398359,
0.1881855577,
0.508525908,
0.5873945951,
0.3222438991,
-0.1636802703,
-0.626552999,
-0.2320604175,
-0.0890430734,
0.1189185306,
-0.0456162952,
0.0023141212,
-0.8157060742,
0.7836420536,
0.1441924125,
-0.2821725309,
0.1058612093,
0.1295870394,
0.0683930516,
0.1950494051,
0.2029878497,
0.6182413697,
0.0039336761,
0.2571979165,
0.3963365555,
-0.834707737,
0.2007973194,
0.1883694232,
-0.2822827101,
-0.0274798665,
-0.1488823146,
0.9441039562,
-0.1874766797,
-0.1426263899,
0.2370639145,
0.2312085181,
-0.348447144,
0.2769018114,
0.4387448728,
-0.0319371894,
0.1543697715,
0.5275619626,
0.1970824003,
0.3989668787,
-0.4527192116,
0.0581073873,
0.1326279193,
-0.1947562546,
-0.0557278469,
0.4731344283,
-0.2041621506,
0.3499253988,
0.569355309,
-0.0387051776,
-0.1384297907,
0.5005308986,
0.320232451,
0.4370909631,
-0.1940302104,
0.2527718842,
0.1974303722,
-0.0533205979,
-0.0619401857,
0.1095334515,
-0.3878497183,
-0.7202612162,
-0.2652957141,
-0.5495545268,
-0.1561005563,
-0.0571950711,
-0.8370768428,
0.3246177435,
0.0342961214,
-0.3899121284,
0.1311656684,
-0.170328185,
-0.544944644,
0.2864429951,
-0.3539330959,
0.8561537862,
-0.9472381473,
0.835924685,
0.698315084,
-0.115642108,
-0.8412483931,
-0.3226001263,
-0.0767410845,
-0.4819577038,
0.5689557195,
-0.2876245081,
0.3932079375,
0.1825776994,
-0.3358481824,
-0.7478915453,
1.2553821802,
0.2774404883,
-0.5958091617,
0.0855859518,
0.6656339765,
0.5747804046,
-0.0134182824,
-0.1177387834,
0.9799146652,
0.5963261127,
0.60690099,
-0.7641197443,
-0.1436673999,
0.2450472713,
0.1795171499,
0.4548561871,
-0.2575799227,
0.691770494,
-0.1668601483,
-0.1007717401,
-0.4934321344,
0.2783833742,
-0.1098560616,
0.6258004308,
0.6508882046,
0.9281490445,
0.7113682628,
-0.2980928719,
0.8319096565,
-0.2623656094,
0.1757935733,
0.9220756888,
-0.0983194485,
0.3728354871,
0.9888513684,
-0.4210709035,
0.2431467324,
0.7978069186,
0.096886009,
0.946688354,
0.1359111667,
-0.4048345387,
0.1123202667,
-0.2325968742,
-0.6652309895,
0.1962576061,
0.2168952972,
-0.3217536807,
-0.2590427101,
0.5126044154,
-0.0236361809,
-0.0513775051,
-0.3981766105,
1.2507200241,
-0.2009506822,
-0.5895013213,
0.5578535199,
-0.2830890715,
0.4323537052,
-0.2416041642,
0.1672470719,
-0.2057810724,
0.1878131181,
-0.4373102188,
-0.9366434216,
0.3453010619,
-0.2900248766,
-0.522977531,
-0.0909565389,
0.8135832548,
-0.6111667156,
-0.3856601417,
-0.180617705,
0.3014351428,
0.0349024683,
-0.1085310355,
-0.4518716335,
-0.0773687288,
0.0925976187,
-0.1511779875,
0.5308532119,
0.79528898,
0.1094322205,
0.4056954086,
0.8910751939,
0.2262146771,
0.2015199065,
0.0915267691,
1.3373587132,
-0.0824251249,
-0.394707948,
-0.9859426022,
0.5029310584,
-0.1410393119,
-0.130328849,
0.888269484,
0.6139887571,
0.9889359474,
-0.1501615494,
0.7453338504,
-0.1930129826,
0.3390584886,
-0.46197173,
0.3550238311,
-0.2934613824,
0.2055846304,
-0.3670188189,
-1.0151798725,
0.2345834821,
0.1673716456,
-0.6004165411,
-0.1376858652,
0.3799814284,
0.6333189011,
-0.0360258892,
0.2324518114,
0.2810304463,
0.0181099735,
0.2240531296,
0.3352849782,
0.7665606141,
-0.510866344,
0.2345330119,
-0.6154946089,
-0.1027308479,
-0.0187207069,
-0.5768153071,
-0.6366850734,
-0.8174496293,
-0.4744434655,
-0.264326185,
-0.0570321567,
0.7124906182,
0.5442519784,
-0.6061263084,
0.2871668041,
-0.2565428019,
0.2717197835,
-0.096331358,
-0.3379383087,
0.1670846939,
-0.4548324347,
-0.8008645177,
0.0950602069,
0.0793996304,
0.2658615708,
-0.0666627511,
0.1252256781,
0.0444963314,
-0.1033630893,
0.5219920874,
-0.0934937373,
-0.3336189389,
-0.302339077,
0.0298922937,
0.1861535609,
0.0666950867,
0.6340652704,
-1.0934827328,
0.9200193286,
0.6682019234,
0.7344734073,
0.6288976073,
0.316501677,
0.3908514082,
-0.6999186873,
0.1299406737,
-0.2930679023,
-0.1349746734,
0.1988244951,
-0.571041286,
0.4386321008,
0.416600734,
-0.6204063296,
-0.91798383,
-0.0688102469,
-0.516477704,
-0.3229695559,
0.9769711494,
0.1487289518,
-0.0609476119,
-0.2355909795,
-0.5016658306,
0.1734482944,
-0.5107781291,
1.0797306299,
1.1235255003,
-0.3196402788,
0.248847425,
-0.4241074026,
0.6860407591,
0.2296011448,
-0.4716008008,
0.059409406,
0.5797458291,
0.3367802799,
0.0249109082,
0.1855491996,
0.001249769,
0.0756570995,
-0.1364982128,
-0.4555024207,
-0.3422047198,
-0.0886354595,
-0.1808664948,
0.0074048801,
0.0372559875,
-0.5015001893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12564v1 | ChatGPT Is More Likely to Be Perceived as Male Than Female | 2023-05-21T20:57:12 | 2023-05-21T20:57:12 | Jared Wong, Jin Kim | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We investigate how people perceive ChatGPT, and, in particular, how they
assign human-like attributes such as gender to the chatbot. Across five
pre-registered studies (N = 1,552), we find that people are more likely to
perceive ChatGPT to be male than female. Specifically, people perceive male
gender identity (1) following demonstrations of ChatGPT's core abilities (e.g.,
providing information or summarizing text), (2) in the absence of such
demonstrations, and (3) across different methods of eliciting perceived gender
(using various scales and asking to name ChatGPT). Moreover, we find that this
seemingly default perception of ChatGPT as male can reverse when ChatGPT's
feminine-coded abilities are highlighted (e.g., providing emotional support for
a user). | [
-0.3347116411,
-0.5928232074,
0.2133352011,
0.2950985134,
0.0062163672,
0.397495836,
-0.2586017549,
-0.5079376101,
-0.0287659559,
-0.1865562648,
-0.7432482839,
0.108556293,
-0.7794421315,
0.2657008469,
-0.5902706981,
1.1455615759,
0.4828060567,
0.0305100735,
0.0091980882,
0.2935444117,
-0.7748700976,
-0.8233144879,
-0.9878579974,
-0.621863842,
0.671530664,
0.223670125,
0.9486239552,
-0.0970550776,
0.5282687545,
0.3076610863,
-0.0788591728,
-0.3726368845,
-0.5354633331,
-0.3745546639,
-0.1656930447,
-0.8814724088,
-0.4899082184,
0.3654237688,
0.2497530729,
0.5681094527,
-0.1676143408,
0.238152191,
0.4585318267,
0.8101420403,
-0.2688547671,
0.450363636,
-0.5434163213,
-0.0384886228,
0.0256519001,
-0.241467461,
-0.2657804489,
-0.2796283662,
0.6669764519,
-0.2726769447,
0.7293092608,
0.4423936307,
0.7199728489,
-0.4226486981,
-0.7556643486,
-0.1953683048,
-0.8770816922,
0.4468531907,
-0.0545693152,
0.4507226646,
0.2724367976,
0.5637654662,
-0.1215927675,
-0.2930757105,
-0.7648294568,
-0.3765303791,
-0.5405624509,
0.1583189368,
-0.4571538866,
-0.0625716075,
0.3292927146,
0.3264078796,
-0.8009047508,
-0.4031971991,
-0.4931062758,
-0.1297391653,
0.4882030487,
-0.2450599074,
0.8187277913,
-0.2537072003,
-0.5614027977,
-0.1152828336,
-0.4143000841,
0.1973536015,
0.9049851894,
0.3601872921,
-0.1629133224,
0.7385100722,
0.1554492414,
0.2336154431,
0.4648683965,
0.1541963965,
0.5901040435,
0.0292198211,
-0.2750126123,
0.5357348323,
0.6959140897,
0.4733270109,
0.5777025223,
0.0545298047,
0.1438474655,
-0.0666805506,
0.6260175705,
-0.6817088127,
-0.3755334914,
-0.1741212606,
-0.5118644834,
-0.2549241781,
0.1724932641,
-0.4949322641,
-0.7735987306,
-0.1926901788,
0.6504045129,
-0.4235671461,
-0.5490612388,
-0.1213892922,
-0.6962272525,
0.5470327735,
0.493719846,
-1.2483519316,
0.2853945792,
0.7324137688,
0.6102769375,
0.1036513075,
-0.4116891325,
0.2364749908,
-0.2190522552,
-0.4204615057,
0.6678029895,
-0.6102092266,
-0.4863237441,
-0.5397313237,
0.2733225524,
-0.308843106,
-0.174337253,
0.2773571312,
-0.176959753,
0.6962964535,
-0.3032939434,
-0.0792552307,
-0.1385836154,
0.1718263775,
-0.3394106328,
0.8182444572,
0.0717580542,
-1.0325285196,
0.7716969848,
-0.7263250351,
-0.0590206683,
-0.1829481125,
-0.3254000843,
-0.2434692234,
-0.1775196046,
0.074241057,
0.2634098232,
-0.2458638102,
0.033545766,
-0.058607623,
-0.1012931988,
0.7304962277,
-0.4557647407,
0.5458188057,
-0.1003027931,
-0.2438778728,
0.1197229251,
-0.0592877157,
-0.3532561362,
0.3072414398,
0.1943393797,
-0.0696705058,
0.2427139729,
-0.1870394498,
0.0297092926,
0.2206489295,
-0.6830539703,
0.1062530577,
-0.2745151222,
0.6391984224,
0.5369341969,
-0.1771170348,
0.6522428393,
-0.435418278,
0.4230418503,
-0.2827395499,
0.3510911167,
0.1809662133,
-1.1239314079,
-0.5452133417,
-0.2886120379,
0.0535434969,
0.5730062127,
-0.2117739767,
0.286264956,
-0.3397313654,
-0.5530850887,
-0.1319145709,
-0.1697163582,
0.5488026738,
0.4865083694,
0.0068114609,
-0.0929586515,
-0.4446148872,
-1.3136407137,
-0.5571625829,
-0.8519265056,
-0.4629251659,
0.6367470026,
0.6819863915,
-0.1935665607,
1.1755210161,
-0.6025657058,
-0.2837638855,
-0.6249274611,
0.3901567459,
0.4134128392,
0.5243399143,
0.6654290557,
-1.1493810415,
-0.1530866176,
0.1042257547,
-0.2871647179,
-0.0626083538,
-0.0357470624,
-0.3953088522,
-0.1398368776,
0.1818246096,
-0.5667702556,
0.648014009,
0.4952015877,
-0.6265677214,
0.5498022437,
-0.2496862859,
0.6448616982,
-0.8264353871,
0.0970148966,
-0.0465916581,
-0.1522493958,
-0.7029895782,
-0.1674764752,
0.0235609207,
-0.3652911186,
-0.3968941271,
0.5380094051,
-0.3538218737,
-0.6304957271,
-0.0553476326,
0.122541666,
-0.3338167667,
0.4859138727,
0.1369752884,
0.9301574826,
0.256988287,
-0.289898932,
0.3066160679,
0.3678033352,
-0.11150942,
0.6866062284,
-0.9552710652,
0.2405037135,
-0.4134498835,
0.5248815417,
-1.6414445639,
-0.2892543972,
0.5491793752,
-1.0750313997,
0.217077449,
-0.5472690463,
-0.3088475168,
-0.4763498008,
-0.0392463543,
0.3509510458,
0.6617936492,
-0.3721973896,
0.698125124,
0.1706549376,
-0.211862877,
-0.3318967819,
-0.6531867385,
0.1340047717,
-0.2564829886,
-0.4956664145,
0.1853107214,
0.0174293816,
-0.0295881107,
-0.3941545486,
-0.0064185821,
-0.2353675812,
0.1491889805,
0.6303385496,
0.2938211858,
0.2336758822,
0.3401241601,
-0.2924216092,
-0.3575313985,
0.022632787,
0.2845593989,
0.8906615376,
-0.3979729414,
-0.5184981227,
-0.3342836797,
0.1973676234,
0.2500077188,
0.0764264241,
0.6427742839,
0.7765598297,
-0.1972584575,
0.2417873144,
-0.1461060494,
-0.4515254796,
-0.4293036163,
0.2827278674,
-0.5080282092,
-0.6942413449,
0.6261854172,
0.3935306072,
0.119523488,
0.3843947947,
0.4442926943,
-0.4565317333,
1.2666044235,
0.5705798268,
-0.1512060463,
0.5648402572,
0.2536884248,
0.3368302286,
-0.696230948,
-0.3172592223,
-0.7536716461,
-0.8160729408,
-0.9625908732,
-0.2058060318,
0.0514804311,
-0.1076655015,
-0.5603314638,
0.4024946988,
-0.593618691,
0.2556167543,
0.6514156461,
0.3368487656,
0.18143408,
-0.1796073318,
0.528241694,
-0.303925544,
-0.4660106897,
-0.5596836805,
0.8837017417,
0.1873411685,
0.5676032901,
0.5811178088,
0.2684681416,
0.7091479897,
0.2724919021,
-0.3242324591,
0.6532874107,
0.0804322883,
-1.1797066927,
-0.1892432421,
-0.3160634041,
-1.3128012419,
0.0903551206,
-0.375367403,
-1.0930967331,
-0.0239129644,
0.3587807417,
0.1745907813,
0.0232366621,
-0.9424991012,
0.688688755,
0.0351199321,
0.0922552571,
-0.2874834239,
-0.7923915982,
0.2941333652,
0.1750955582,
0.0157188792,
-0.3975161612,
-0.0352620445,
0.3984417915,
-0.2810478806,
1.1887927055,
0.0873435363,
-0.0708927512,
0.0260940995,
0.1724014133,
0.2224850655,
0.0539356954,
0.3315583766,
0.2917560637,
-0.3168290555,
-0.3767819405,
-0.8513318896,
0.295111388,
-1.096762538,
-0.7028685212,
-0.3930617571,
-0.0347858705,
0.0175778288,
-0.1710687131,
0.404443115,
0.4207570553,
-0.3180030882,
-0.0753984675,
0.4096944034,
-0.5891764164,
0.1390991658,
0.1108091176,
-0.6118481159,
0.1140358374,
0.7834713459,
-0.2154990435,
0.4071854651,
0.5699374676,
0.5532335639,
-0.1951814741,
0.1992828846,
-0.4148665667,
0.0794603601,
-0.3786182702,
0.4086613357,
-0.6756612659,
-0.4318900108,
-0.1179238185,
-0.2462089062,
-0.3372276127,
-0.4674438536,
-0.0550173856,
-0.0337403491,
0.6646620631,
0.2100982815,
0.4606427252,
0.631380558,
-0.3813443482,
0.5751777291,
1.1793807745,
0.1207960472,
-0.2665126026,
-0.6494804025,
0.754799068,
0.2738536596,
-0.0108758314,
-0.9152612686,
0.3525207937,
0.3819657266,
0.5219256878,
0.4501594007,
-0.2147447616,
0.6310738921,
-0.4758809507,
0.9902513623,
0.2767809331,
-0.8609178662,
0.5056725144,
-0.6813929677,
-0.0566353649,
0.0712186173,
0.1793325692,
-0.9688850045,
-0.3149899542,
-0.7162840962,
-0.5510427952,
0.6696459651,
0.8943699002,
0.7085419297,
-0.0075935065,
0.2340475768,
0.379966259,
0.4730493128,
-0.8480305672,
-0.6290096641,
-0.3328931332,
0.1040680632,
-0.2919925749,
-0.4279236495,
0.0091586253,
-0.0922990218,
0.2712369263,
-0.0955920443,
1.22962749,
0.0256929249,
-0.0245777275,
0.3272322714,
0.5652274489,
0.6204890609,
0.5951928496,
-0.4017964303,
0.2296252102,
0.1338213235,
-0.5091684461,
0.1118675843,
-0.390620321,
0.1554821581,
-0.0503356047,
0.5695475936,
0.796710968,
0.3471993208,
-0.3835241795,
0.8952762485,
-0.3649885654,
-0.5244058967,
-0.2202351838,
0.3760704696,
0.0945493802,
0.3968709409,
0.6474018693,
0.0839906931,
0.2416078299,
-0.7096226215,
-0.2479358464,
0.4058513641,
-0.5035626888,
-0.4229551852,
0.7873167992,
0.4920312166,
-0.6763361096,
0.5440861583,
-0.1151237711,
-0.9794076085,
0.6230846047,
0.4240940511,
1.1511467695,
0.0484757125,
0.3607825935,
0.5575560331,
0.4836140573,
0.1125914529,
0.4589733779,
-0.0194112044,
-0.949901998,
0.023352528,
-0.0711818039,
-0.3647978306,
-0.5784637928,
-0.2801469266,
0.3848576546,
-0.251994133,
-0.6447917819,
-0.0251339469,
-0.2254454941,
-0.5961783528,
0.0662776157,
0.3125871718,
0.3411894739,
-0.7954810262,
0.2967823446,
0.7378430963,
0.0109656723,
-0.6956987381,
-0.1137158647,
0.3727889955,
-0.9476623535,
1.0564728975,
0.3258087635,
-0.1438093632,
-0.1061673537,
-0.4251879156,
-0.7378836274,
0.9410846233,
0.2540485561,
-0.440948993,
-0.0628277734,
0.3621208668,
0.554017365,
-0.0672942996,
0.8759524226,
0.2188452631,
0.4723217487,
-0.068840161,
-1.5467034578,
-0.3891968727,
-0.3238021135,
0.1196043491,
0.3606062829,
-0.8015615344,
0.973313868,
-0.2409213036,
-0.301440388,
-0.4120283127,
0.4582094252,
0.0603825748,
0.1922041178,
0.7560717463,
-0.1349618584,
0.6253120899,
-0.3137135804,
0.8523252606,
0.0525138974,
0.2269281894,
1.001103878,
0.0861104503,
0.4233956635,
0.3337576687,
-0.5679674745,
0.5496921539,
0.5434917808,
0.2849353254,
0.1384872943,
0.0561111383,
-0.0621021986,
-0.1120224223,
0.1698290706,
-0.4863345623,
0.7732183337,
0.0901959538,
-0.5881729126,
-0.0194639862,
0.0056641288,
0.1009241566,
-0.353787452,
-0.101128377,
0.7425503731,
-0.1676327735,
-0.2452930957,
0.0730302185,
-0.3232858777,
0.4311130047,
-0.6300324798,
0.0230067354,
-0.1637491733,
0.0276518669,
-0.270547986,
-1.0113874674,
-0.069809787,
-0.1177344322,
-0.3896889687,
-0.3377585411,
0.9327035546,
-0.140105918,
-0.3957401216,
-0.0630103424,
0.6388191581,
0.3822112978,
-0.2859502733,
-0.791873157,
-0.6134149432,
0.2942355275,
-0.1947015971,
0.4951593876,
0.4050076902,
-0.3558324277,
1.411450386,
0.6994890571,
-0.2129348069,
0.1934309155,
0.0765946284,
0.328499198,
-0.5504950285,
-0.4521403313,
-1.1602435112,
0.2986294031,
-0.1443616897,
-0.417216152,
0.8310921788,
0.324219346,
0.4066828191,
-0.151270166,
0.5960428119,
-0.446955353,
0.6202833056,
-0.127928555,
0.7849020362,
-0.3506630361,
0.1021338701,
-0.6885700822,
-0.973875761,
0.20418562,
0.5296173096,
-0.4055861235,
0.2816974223,
0.376635164,
0.6993408799,
0.0679092333,
0.3066796958,
0.2449089736,
-0.2727301121,
0.2648279965,
0.4806402624,
1.2945559025,
-0.1076280773,
0.5479564071,
-0.1402256489,
-0.1713420153,
-0.3825481832,
-1.0331999063,
-1.1775096655,
-0.6002277732,
-0.3933007717,
0.0745011419,
-0.1021624431,
0.8984503746,
0.9299004674,
-0.1394298673,
-0.1708634645,
-0.0096417749,
0.1114150584,
-0.284163326,
-0.1840392351,
0.0640176907,
0.0010795631,
-0.758749187,
-0.4953230321,
-0.0748561546,
0.0437549464,
0.0560261011,
0.1162052527,
0.3730175793,
-0.0381838381,
0.605851531,
0.0840289071,
-0.5575137138,
-0.7423674464,
-0.1399509013,
-0.2036046237,
0.3777738512,
0.7624950409,
-0.7922039628,
0.3248253167,
0.6430504322,
-0.006611459,
0.2999994755,
0.2606045902,
0.9535617828,
-0.6562747955,
0.1485103518,
-0.114826642,
0.2045237869,
0.087377511,
-0.3724155426,
0.6088360548,
0.286403507,
-0.6560233831,
-0.4004311562,
0.1380839348,
-1.1237825155,
-0.0891944841,
1.1774893999,
0.173524335,
-0.0080833882,
-0.190713048,
-1.059628129,
0.0256775413,
-0.9142725468,
0.6475810409,
0.6194209456,
-0.317445606,
-0.5077562928,
-0.8851485252,
0.4031630754,
-0.0264500324,
-0.7263872027,
0.2349765748,
0.17120184,
0.3082625568,
0.0153205981,
0.3636163175,
0.1952378303,
0.3316274881,
-0.098891139,
0.359990716,
0.2197409123,
0.0453067087,
0.1149857044,
-0.0731673762,
0.1036769524,
-0.353575021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12563v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12563v2 | A Symbolic Framework for Evaluating Mathematical Reasoning and Generalisation with Transformers | 2023-05-21T20:40:37 | 2024-04-08T14:29:06 | Jordan Meadows, Marco Valentino, Damien Teney, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper proposes a methodology for generating and perturbing detailed
derivations of equations at scale, aided by a symbolic engine, to evaluate the
generalisability of Transformers to out-of-distribution mathematical reasoning
problems. Instantiating the framework in the context of sequence classification
tasks, we compare the capabilities of GPT-4, GPT-3.5, and a canon of fine-tuned
BERT models, exploring the relationship between specific operators and
generalisation failure via the perturbation of reasoning aspects such as
symmetry and variable surface forms. Surprisingly, our empirical evaluation
reveals that the average in-distribution performance of fine-tuned models
surpasses GPT-3.5, and rivals GPT-4. However, perturbations to input reasoning
can reduce their performance by up to 80 F1 points. Overall, the results
suggest that the in-distribution performance of smaller open-source models may
potentially rival GPT by incorporating appropriately structured derivation
dependencies during training, and highlight a shared weakness between BERT and
GPT involving a relative inability to decode indirect references to
mathematical entities. We release the full codebase, constructed datasets, and
fine-tuned models to encourage future progress in the field. | [
-0.4023122787,
-0.5216593146,
0.7171103358,
0.4599023759,
-0.0955172703,
-0.1867911071,
-0.1336266398,
-0.2041236907,
-0.3256371617,
0.3327902257,
-0.6269756556,
-0.2166415304,
-0.644946754,
0.0876733512,
-0.8576592207,
0.8309082389,
-0.1595257372,
0.0328830779,
-0.0750814453,
0.0507695414,
-0.1468911618,
-0.7490435243,
-0.2224169374,
-0.3511309624,
0.078528583,
-0.0235021356,
1.0878552198,
0.2411110848,
0.8543015718,
0.3405818939,
0.0839096308,
-0.1465984881,
-0.3360226452,
0.1885394305,
-0.3312686086,
-0.5794772506,
-0.1744493395,
-0.1667966396,
0.6484661102,
0.5894685984,
-0.0987397432,
0.2063063383,
0.039717339,
0.4877245128,
-0.5412791371,
0.5454362035,
-0.717110455,
0.0161262751,
0.2326861471,
0.2233739048,
-0.5537501574,
-0.2446489483,
0.2814383507,
-0.6393271685,
0.5301088095,
-0.527895987,
0.9422671795,
0.5573239923,
0.0141792987,
-0.3567214608,
-1.0523298979,
0.8641007543,
-0.4921595156,
0.3623394072,
-0.0061318967,
0.9108546972,
-0.0667756274,
-1.0587664843,
-0.2997666001,
-0.0155362487,
-0.1668746769,
0.144459337,
-0.4388387203,
0.0391911119,
0.7067573071,
0.1522679329,
-0.4308374822,
-0.2903254926,
-0.3139902949,
0.122031495,
0.6604924202,
0.107373789,
0.1138706356,
-0.0791121647,
0.067155391,
-0.2961344719,
-0.8310280442,
-0.235021621,
0.5545253158,
0.148951292,
-0.0019312829,
0.5245480537,
0.230134055,
0.3644724786,
0.1266013682,
0.2937397957,
-0.0258556176,
-0.0717240348,
-0.3988192677,
-0.3420881629,
0.6435685158,
-0.217438072,
0.4291402996,
-0.1117901951,
-0.3761823773,
0.3123526871,
0.3790032566,
-0.8591344953,
-0.3986968696,
-0.1315263212,
-0.3519933522,
-0.1184563041,
0.2196601629,
-0.5480973721,
0.042289637,
-0.4496834874,
0.5585250258,
-0.3774036765,
-0.1139141768,
0.2047255188,
-0.2573455274,
0.1248465404,
0.3978729844,
-1.1804599762,
0.171772778,
0.7387733459,
0.5198833942,
0.3033151627,
0.0960675403,
-0.0659986213,
0.1513765305,
-0.1448640823,
0.7083365321,
-0.7301228046,
-0.5147908926,
0.0600431599,
-0.283297807,
-0.1271706522,
-0.6731770635,
0.6743026376,
-0.298537612,
0.2294693291,
-0.0936295986,
-0.5156582594,
-0.2848703563,
-0.1138566062,
-0.6167348623,
0.8381677866,
0.593506813,
-0.4485637546,
0.2765979767,
-0.9837294221,
-0.3838628232,
0.0494551733,
-0.3595049679,
-0.3746249974,
0.3181239963,
0.4352272451,
0.3992933035,
-0.6443485618,
0.4016126394,
-0.5399867892,
-0.4098205566,
-0.0472619422,
-0.6541065574,
0.7628022432,
0.3472226858,
-0.4942562878,
0.0663012266,
-0.6019998193,
0.0538212061,
0.1377017945,
0.2892996669,
-0.14733091,
0.2936477065,
-0.3369947076,
0.3060079813,
-0.0516639724,
-0.1608317941,
0.2134844214,
-0.5146664381,
0.8877994418,
0.7562235594,
-0.1449192017,
0.4806826413,
0.0285494234,
0.5899522901,
-0.0474194437,
0.4313524663,
-0.0862575024,
-0.7841333151,
-0.5389994383,
-0.2985524535,
0.3571845889,
0.2629830539,
-0.7968649268,
0.4946989119,
-0.3198183179,
-0.5250176787,
-0.2868711352,
-0.0971247628,
0.2158498019,
0.3849875927,
0.3878376484,
-0.0483569577,
-0.2096112669,
-1.0666277409,
-0.4037756026,
-0.2766881883,
-0.6065968275,
0.1468349248,
0.6133947372,
-0.405411005,
1.0539072752,
-0.4185127318,
0.0040952838,
-0.1299895197,
0.22480762,
0.5480662584,
0.3309311867,
0.6611374021,
-0.7155011892,
-0.3246776462,
-0.0673980862,
-1.0279256105,
-0.0650305003,
-0.0274538361,
-0.3027920723,
-0.0932638347,
0.1208518296,
-0.7918464541,
0.6090365052,
0.2109716237,
-0.1417295188,
0.6588432789,
-0.0836442411,
-0.2500499487,
-0.6874877214,
-0.0022700073,
0.2450557947,
0.2051214427,
-0.4263579547,
0.4215906858,
0.1755541712,
-0.2121715993,
-0.3490627706,
0.3800381124,
-0.0308576394,
-0.0869670659,
0.3835210204,
-0.2107857168,
-0.2961173356,
0.3479536176,
-0.1274065971,
0.7525556684,
0.5261160731,
-0.5498735309,
0.2695110738,
0.2850664258,
-0.1281081587,
0.4338460565,
-0.9025230408,
-0.0534535795,
-0.1261744201,
0.1824392229,
-0.9719208479,
-0.3408320248,
0.1616208255,
-0.2722739279,
0.1889486313,
-0.3357235193,
-0.8202397823,
-0.5358355641,
-0.0866883323,
0.3944934309,
0.8313849568,
-0.7096560001,
1.0209107399,
-0.0833945572,
0.0627892166,
-0.2830692828,
-0.4828945398,
-0.4779123664,
-0.2805855572,
-0.96751827,
0.0292496793,
0.0231221039,
-0.5062279701,
0.0495673902,
-0.3113876581,
-0.1175085157,
0.0603780113,
0.1504872143,
0.1153636575,
-0.2167025357,
0.2799170911,
0.4632131755,
-0.153785497,
0.5514487624,
-0.3841738701,
0.4203489423,
-0.1832523793,
-0.6320028901,
-0.037107721,
0.1531276852,
0.4225622714,
0.0148377595,
0.2653017342,
0.3186447024,
-0.4050351679,
-0.4369779229,
-0.2108686119,
-0.4025013149,
-0.5298142433,
0.1836381704,
-0.5931874514,
-0.4941614866,
0.4614365399,
-0.0489990339,
0.3020229042,
1.0622787476,
0.6340417266,
0.0820168406,
1.3221850395,
0.3512752354,
0.1470069289,
0.297283262,
-0.5814856291,
0.3912059069,
-0.2218070477,
0.1115269884,
-0.486479193,
-0.2766855955,
-0.4931671619,
-0.2778872848,
0.4683015049,
0.0800178573,
-0.6906164885,
0.4083468616,
-0.7230320573,
0.4764875174,
0.3474519849,
-0.0678958967,
0.1630147845,
0.2465039343,
-0.2716109455,
0.1106907129,
-0.4754810631,
-0.6007978916,
1.2809311152,
0.3394854069,
0.8258217573,
0.2379037142,
0.5135954022,
0.1288473755,
0.7884781957,
-0.4585464001,
0.4587064683,
-0.3431379199,
-0.7815954685,
-0.3883956671,
-0.6227107644,
-0.6768642664,
0.3525149524,
0.1572594494,
-0.6366217732,
0.0464361496,
0.0308256447,
-0.2527190745,
0.1636212766,
-1.1533027887,
0.7801678181,
-0.0140149761,
-0.0668334737,
-0.1845043004,
-0.5850480199,
0.5905662179,
-0.3275962174,
0.0492721163,
0.0002047175,
0.3433132768,
0.2748357952,
-0.5962013602,
0.5313588381,
-0.2229316533,
-0.2500852346,
0.5253663659,
0.1265998632,
0.3484079838,
0.3237501979,
-0.184936434,
0.3895167708,
-0.0685863644,
-0.3708415926,
-1.3278628588,
0.4581690729,
-0.9356548786,
-0.73512429,
-0.0524308756,
-0.5506654382,
-0.3880932331,
0.0920123458,
0.4793615937,
0.3421757221,
0.2341842055,
0.0441985093,
0.4248588681,
-0.0543554127,
0.3550388515,
0.0003866655,
-0.1172937602,
-0.2915819883,
0.6886764169,
0.0870344639,
0.3655478954,
0.3880559504,
0.1246214882,
-0.7648428082,
-0.0747917667,
-0.5955820084,
0.2505464852,
-1.1265854836,
-0.2070670128,
-0.2226367295,
-0.475505054,
-0.2179679126,
-0.147669673,
-0.1084002405,
-0.7544172406,
-0.1707295179,
0.1627071649,
0.2112633139,
1.0508612394,
0.123524271,
0.289303422,
-0.5945165157,
0.2085584402,
0.3389755487,
0.3726540506,
-0.0415430963,
-0.4436983168,
0.0890859887,
0.15639247,
-0.8357436657,
-0.6034578085,
0.1623539627,
-0.0922200233,
0.5115485787,
0.498472333,
-0.1304848641,
0.8058375716,
-0.4684315026,
0.7159606814,
0.3541203737,
-1.2436275482,
0.2857789695,
-0.3578371704,
-0.0052159103,
-0.0309616681,
0.3884856403,
0.0958946943,
-0.4198043048,
-1.0164414644,
-0.7128778696,
0.3505308926,
0.6661493182,
0.0918771476,
0.0686181709,
0.486261189,
0.1057523116,
0.1773372889,
-0.1906513721,
-0.263355583,
-0.5275207162,
-0.306381762,
-0.1680766195,
0.0031528859,
0.0991477519,
-0.5917656422,
0.439104408,
-0.1454544067,
0.7041427493,
0.0251768865,
-0.1318034381,
-0.0995478481,
0.2013210654,
0.552614212,
0.8446597457,
-0.0112019824,
-0.0457973778,
-0.0177878607,
-0.4307820201,
0.2554846406,
0.4473979771,
-0.1730726361,
0.2311802506,
0.2075760067,
0.4488107264,
0.3775220215,
-0.3749678135,
0.1922890395,
-0.0783530176,
-0.5848166943,
-0.2830898166,
0.0167178288,
-0.0130799226,
0.1887606829,
0.3377182186,
0.1743296534,
0.2582759857,
-0.1916880161,
0.218975991,
0.4298620224,
0.0303188656,
-0.5024681091,
0.8979999423,
-0.0351794995,
-0.053494487,
0.7871392965,
-0.0286929682,
-0.4559079409,
0.618309617,
0.4241715968,
1.1266638041,
-0.1869064122,
0.1177149341,
0.2579621077,
0.2595257461,
-0.2849313915,
0.1068441123,
0.0748221949,
-0.4974491298,
-0.7041005492,
-0.501132071,
-0.5225074291,
0.0051138881,
-0.5669590235,
0.3589084744,
-0.5732257366,
-0.2043884248,
0.2403321713,
-0.4246063828,
-0.8686923385,
-0.0017611509,
-0.2291932851,
0.7905811071,
-0.6658002138,
0.6732887626,
0.6013950109,
-0.6011801362,
-1.2357259989,
-0.0205385964,
-0.3073160648,
-0.7360504866,
0.8516901135,
0.0333536752,
-0.0099939322,
0.0923085585,
-0.5286629796,
-0.7965714931,
0.7283436656,
0.9552013874,
-0.4506114721,
-0.2428727001,
0.2912732661,
0.7322351933,
-0.0669245496,
0.7592134476,
0.7242280245,
0.549749732,
0.332362771,
-1.0038107634,
-0.105977416,
-0.1827816516,
0.0997558683,
0.552296102,
-0.2157781422,
1.0183019638,
-0.0355852582,
-0.2845487893,
0.306733489,
0.4233970046,
0.0775999203,
-0.1748627722,
0.2611792386,
0.7533214688,
0.3631815314,
-0.4611042142,
1.2149925232,
-0.1894159317,
0.7881259322,
0.5453554392,
-0.2268849611,
0.5812919736,
0.2474974692,
-0.5548058748,
0.5548340678,
0.1364914924,
-0.2420571297,
0.3549241722,
0.6867808104,
-0.1572663933,
-0.2700614035,
0.5862035155,
-0.5739693046,
0.1592513919,
0.5063596368,
-0.5876269937,
-0.7829288244,
-0.2915310562,
-0.4168779552,
-0.0031810296,
-0.31903705,
0.255484283,
0.1131923571,
-0.4911948442,
0.8151207566,
-0.2012647837,
0.2106716186,
-0.5330446959,
-0.2899694145,
-0.0506201498,
0.7083333135,
-0.1620422006,
-0.7346174717,
0.5242418647,
-0.0872907862,
-0.0936020985,
-0.3201984763,
0.5471510887,
0.047914587,
-0.745457232,
0.0581759699,
0.373740077,
0.1711161137,
-0.356258601,
-0.7531849742,
-0.1448914558,
-0.172548309,
-0.1131609157,
0.3057996929,
0.653678,
-0.3499133587,
0.5929999352,
0.6192435622,
-0.3716263175,
0.0614901781,
0.3139217794,
0.9673174024,
-0.4375838935,
-0.3438679874,
-1.037938714,
0.3633385003,
0.2287027985,
-0.2229836732,
0.7995262742,
0.2722878754,
0.9166848063,
-0.467679143,
0.8310052156,
0.080528304,
0.1937416196,
-0.2071226239,
0.5881690979,
-0.3015038073,
0.2639472783,
-0.6556075811,
-1.1781295538,
-0.7280319929,
0.8413171172,
-0.5990427136,
0.1545924246,
0.639862895,
0.3934404254,
-0.2744292319,
0.4148034751,
0.3708606064,
0.0244588964,
0.6986942291,
0.6910834312,
1.0318307877,
-0.4290422797,
0.5682554841,
-0.1626880467,
-0.0414299592,
0.0474909432,
-0.6663489342,
-0.8573245406,
-0.3661856651,
0.0284597091,
-0.4130191207,
-0.0594294332,
0.6509653926,
0.6261168718,
-0.7372485995,
-0.0765520707,
-0.5030604005,
0.1110306531,
-0.2909157276,
-0.238631174,
0.3273036778,
-0.6231400967,
-0.6779657602,
-0.0553112179,
0.244638592,
-0.1187200323,
-0.4128629565,
-0.0725160316,
0.590993464,
0.042436216,
0.8343476653,
0.0890009999,
-0.8525581956,
-0.3677425981,
0.0346853919,
0.2797843516,
-0.1213760823,
0.9221490622,
-0.6747208834,
0.2118106335,
0.2900989056,
0.5294701457,
0.4455492198,
0.0296874922,
0.7013005614,
-0.5432894826,
0.1108123288,
0.4061760008,
0.5192947984,
-0.1304856688,
-0.1338252127,
0.7621331215,
0.4594070911,
-0.4481669962,
-0.8327260017,
0.431876868,
-0.5383771658,
-0.1075019538,
1.106960535,
-0.2501865923,
-0.0502676889,
0.1091802269,
-0.0070835827,
-0.0230225082,
-0.4125954211,
0.75908041,
0.8070856333,
-0.1993614882,
0.1719294339,
-0.3833418787,
0.344020009,
0.3984569013,
-0.7150610685,
-0.058951322,
0.3144007325,
0.2067317218,
0.4647242129,
-0.0935010239,
-0.3967298567,
0.306479454,
0.019899739,
-0.1132118925,
0.1549063772,
-0.2521150708,
-0.2618572414,
0.2737006247,
-0.0868157819,
0.1442650557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12552v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12552v1 | Wav2SQL: Direct Generalizable Speech-To-SQL Parsing | 2023-05-21T19:26:46 | 2023-05-21T19:26:46 | Huadai Liu, Rongjie Huang, Jinzheng He, Gang Sun, Ran Shen, Xize Cheng, Zhou Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech-to-SQL (S2SQL) aims to convert spoken questions into SQL queries given
relational databases, which has been traditionally implemented in a cascaded
manner while facing the following challenges: 1) model training is faced with
the major issue of data scarcity, where limited parallel data is available; and
2) the systems should be robust enough to handle diverse out-of-domain speech
samples that differ from the source data. In this work, we propose the first
direct speech-to-SQL parsing model Wav2SQL which avoids error compounding
across cascaded systems. Specifically, 1) to accelerate speech-driven SQL
parsing research in the community, we release a large-scale and multi-speaker
dataset MASpider; 2) leveraging the recent progress in the large-scale
pre-training, we show that it alleviates the data scarcity issue and allow for
direct speech-to-SQL parsing; and 3) we include the speech re-programming and
gradient reversal classifier techniques to reduce acoustic variance and learned
style-agnostic representation, improving generalization to unseen out-of-domain
custom data. Experimental results demonstrate that Wav2SQL avoids error
compounding and achieves state-of-the-art results by up to 2.5\% accuracy
improvement over the baseline. | [
-0.0254291277,
-0.9149420261,
0.1621966362,
0.440759033,
-0.3285186887,
-0.0565814786,
-0.1903651655,
-0.161684379,
0.0090174787,
0.6127032638,
-0.7678103447,
-0.4871316254,
-0.2870310545,
-0.0910460651,
-0.5008032918,
0.769246161,
0.6091008782,
0.3240976334,
-0.3158879578,
-0.0848895684,
-0.5708075166,
-0.6097258925,
-0.8461545706,
0.0091778589,
0.1900052875,
0.3372865319,
0.5269625187,
0.7854033113,
0.201773718,
0.0647777393,
0.0528116338,
0.0048288703,
-0.5410347581,
0.3776647151,
-0.4142719209,
-0.4850930572,
-0.3975619972,
-0.4389739335,
0.6584052444,
0.8259548545,
-0.7251516581,
0.2867953479,
0.0691119805,
1.0589780807,
-0.1805397421,
0.251812458,
-0.9626857042,
0.0211360361,
-0.4636360705,
0.0920076296,
-0.3526286483,
-0.3841373622,
-0.032223355,
-0.2108375877,
0.1051452532,
-0.0937443003,
0.3817373514,
0.3390972316,
-0.4366755188,
-0.0568876229,
-0.8287568688,
0.9197013378,
-0.441586256,
0.6672862172,
0.2623523176,
0.5543478131,
-0.3096065521,
-0.8131930232,
-0.4052016437,
0.1821222901,
0.3228727281,
-0.0682373866,
-0.2527603805,
-0.1755413711,
0.2057696283,
0.2762995958,
-0.7487307191,
0.0252627973,
0.027838923,
-0.004465614,
0.7209228277,
0.0679247454,
0.0547765829,
-0.0644925013,
-0.2989651561,
0.3130860925,
-0.7766627669,
0.2150272727,
-0.0376673304,
0.6669355631,
0.2049366087,
0.6046609879,
-0.3465123773,
0.673181057,
-0.0445744917,
0.1050669104,
0.1663831919,
-0.2835228443,
-0.2596703172,
0.0933378637,
0.6959901452,
0.1890920401,
0.0944864601,
-0.1102181673,
-0.131652683,
-0.0363795236,
-0.1569099575,
-0.5414817333,
-0.0880889297,
0.6751243472,
-0.2575048506,
-0.1385901421,
-0.4521412551,
-0.732123673,
-0.4760631621,
-0.5185971856,
0.1963536143,
-0.2478488684,
-0.4314858019,
-0.1420871317,
-0.0160196107,
0.2143303752,
0.1906138211,
-0.8688043356,
0.6671406627,
0.7523270845,
0.7163956761,
-0.3014760017,
0.1899967194,
-0.7445455194,
0.4644722044,
-0.3724017739,
0.6321852803,
-0.3718394041,
-0.5866823196,
-0.0406453013,
-0.2802574039,
0.1276596785,
-0.8455114961,
0.7034971714,
-0.3521715701,
-0.0178468358,
-0.5325715542,
-0.4958646595,
0.2717567086,
-0.1782741249,
-0.2226090282,
1.0493810177,
0.0886640921,
-0.4065780938,
0.2590496838,
-0.3741690814,
-0.4655686319,
-0.0458391681,
-0.6055676341,
-0.3119193912,
-0.0316787809,
0.3848576546,
0.110279046,
-0.8119613528,
0.5729378462,
0.0228608493,
-0.3846824467,
-0.0791735798,
-0.0603280142,
0.801142931,
0.2513990998,
-0.1352189928,
0.077035293,
-1.0294655561,
0.0995853245,
0.2501499057,
-0.479752779,
-0.0167130511,
0.4554241002,
-0.0225896481,
0.3482429087,
-0.0246817395,
-0.5708909631,
0.1280558407,
-0.5321981907,
0.5411907434,
0.4253360629,
-0.1386910975,
0.279892385,
0.1062583327,
0.136174351,
0.2178929746,
0.1214927137,
0.0182540603,
-0.5166758895,
-0.5693121552,
-0.4367517531,
0.1789643168,
0.9640885592,
-0.5109829903,
0.6808142662,
-0.256092906,
-0.2797556221,
-0.6334626675,
0.0109917223,
0.2009703815,
0.8590183854,
0.6804881096,
-0.0871582106,
-0.6713593602,
-1.0197623968,
-0.7428575158,
0.0532136187,
-0.278236419,
0.470205158,
-0.1275519729,
-0.0899446383,
1.2209419012,
-0.3947195411,
-0.6315321922,
-0.2484689504,
-0.0582839586,
0.3242328167,
0.8320971727,
0.0488638096,
-0.4417716265,
-0.3388016224,
-0.1780473292,
-0.7077087164,
0.003556431,
0.2365613282,
-0.1935407966,
0.0742267519,
0.4368924499,
-0.7009941339,
0.19507128,
0.194836989,
0.0605892241,
0.4201898277,
0.3426989615,
-0.1297578216,
-0.8712664247,
-0.1752294749,
-0.1801054925,
-0.1442869753,
-0.7286358476,
-0.4464918375,
-0.0274923034,
-0.5840718746,
-0.197759077,
-0.1326163858,
-0.1377253085,
-0.3800219893,
0.0806991011,
-0.0625941232,
-0.1007373631,
0.2667070329,
0.1772626489,
0.6862919927,
0.8346177936,
-0.4968908131,
0.7226611376,
0.4563384056,
-0.1165541708,
0.7744833827,
-0.8205352426,
0.5509284735,
-0.1702540219,
0.4330792725,
-1.336001873,
-0.0981866121,
0.0526527502,
-0.4994971752,
0.2964016795,
-0.6099883914,
-0.2270222306,
-0.4054135084,
-0.1591486782,
0.1626291275,
0.5361189246,
-0.7665328979,
0.6559823155,
0.3084976971,
-0.456564486,
-0.6861016154,
-1.0312995911,
0.0618456677,
0.0139807975,
-0.8653545976,
0.2016704977,
0.2457215339,
-0.2011077553,
-0.2265156955,
-0.1759399623,
-0.3322877586,
-0.3904145062,
0.0681529418,
0.0718938559,
-0.3579364419,
0.4433607161,
0.4308641553,
0.0244049728,
0.2527635992,
-0.6838769913,
0.6372148991,
-0.0136129102,
-0.2427335083,
-0.7812119126,
0.6456855536,
0.0870298296,
-0.439093858,
0.5344772339,
0.2310764045,
-0.2630744576,
-0.3141766489,
-0.6776381731,
0.0321766734,
-0.4496813715,
0.5377168059,
-0.4912785888,
-0.6392633319,
0.1010197029,
-0.3731383383,
-0.0707754418,
0.3890601993,
0.2117647529,
-0.2476628721,
0.9325921535,
0.0800468028,
0.001453103,
0.2625238001,
0.0080766035,
-0.0273521096,
-0.5597093701,
-0.4696881771,
-0.7427874804,
0.0387476422,
-0.130945459,
-0.6716509461,
0.1635546982,
-0.0623535849,
-0.300980866,
0.0272685625,
-0.5249056816,
0.4763149321,
0.3343759179,
0.0578580312,
0.3347805738,
0.4256924391,
0.1725450158,
-0.2885294557,
-0.3115466237,
-0.0280894451,
0.9798457623,
0.2262402624,
0.5720743537,
0.2375858128,
0.6331862807,
0.2928876877,
-0.3043193817,
-0.7862870693,
0.5217916369,
-0.309520781,
-0.4845176637,
-0.4383567572,
-0.5045230389,
-0.6946727633,
0.5021041036,
-0.0434195884,
-0.576716423,
0.3253834248,
0.2524833083,
-0.1115354374,
0.1463926435,
-0.6926001906,
0.6293088794,
0.1489478946,
-0.4225325286,
-0.279081583,
-0.8472349644,
0.4617601335,
-0.0008478779,
0.3884112239,
-0.2173635662,
0.0366133302,
0.7868865728,
-0.5149655342,
0.4305951595,
-0.6840372682,
-0.1586289555,
0.4730174541,
0.0551272184,
0.7526205778,
0.1378445476,
-0.3006438911,
0.168615818,
0.0442791432,
-0.5438350439,
-0.5592209697,
0.8589324355,
-0.6051117182,
-0.6296195388,
-0.0764244497,
-0.2375209481,
-0.8481854796,
-0.1392944008,
-0.0867507011,
0.5471197367,
-0.152258575,
0.2481169552,
0.6191369891,
-0.2252164185,
0.138990894,
0.5197247863,
-0.2529417276,
-0.2877740264,
0.8525872827,
0.146116212,
0.1013983116,
0.317982316,
0.203659445,
-0.7819535732,
-0.5422184467,
-0.5341348648,
0.2224119008,
-0.5080971718,
-0.1245525032,
-0.7599850893,
0.043380037,
-0.6212914586,
0.3489857316,
-0.5935394764,
-0.854741931,
-0.2552958429,
0.0068048737,
0.2291414738,
0.4509410858,
0.0207719188,
0.223417744,
-0.5186600089,
0.4265317619,
0.5671042204,
0.366951555,
-0.2245415598,
-0.5325854421,
0.1685539633,
-0.0489942059,
0.0628822446,
-0.9026316404,
0.0558310561,
0.6078259349,
0.2550580502,
0.1349175274,
-0.0632695779,
0.786682725,
-0.6428496838,
0.9759022593,
0.3172245324,
-1.1091817617,
1.1852357388,
-0.5523038507,
-0.0928548947,
0.5973792076,
0.2047531456,
-0.4081188142,
0.1219811141,
-0.2692173719,
-0.9040603638,
0.8608130217,
0.1391809434,
0.11477568,
0.0131534003,
0.4324471056,
0.1453006268,
0.3303610981,
-0.2972000539,
-0.4334388375,
-0.438069284,
-0.0334142148,
0.0276753958,
-0.3604746163,
-0.1050603166,
-0.6466970444,
0.4673105478,
0.1052731946,
0.2840656936,
0.0726972818,
-0.0642711595,
-0.1467480659,
0.5136197805,
0.1583165079,
0.3954058588,
-0.3101432025,
-0.0637797862,
0.1866453141,
-0.3819580972,
0.1400070935,
0.1309382617,
-0.0333579406,
0.0568977408,
-0.2660893798,
0.6199378967,
-0.3045062423,
-0.6489906311,
0.6375555396,
-0.102730006,
0.00470996,
-0.1916482598,
-0.1039971113,
0.3570395708,
0.0834146589,
0.5535436869,
0.1425573379,
0.3916614056,
-0.4744022787,
0.1961013377,
0.3781072497,
-0.4555102885,
-0.05689447,
0.7825674415,
0.4066947401,
-0.2391524017,
0.6745270491,
0.0708255842,
0.2920021415,
0.2054933161,
0.6584582329,
0.5582869053,
-0.6989257932,
-0.0519228615,
0.3751353621,
0.0153263984,
-0.0815793872,
0.7138296366,
-0.0950290486,
-0.3323279023,
-0.3165621758,
-0.6451883316,
-0.2199860066,
0.1118793562,
-0.8511835337,
0.2391941398,
-0.6781896353,
-0.1758998483,
-0.1204484478,
-0.4245713055,
-0.4355457425,
0.3550481796,
-0.0946572497,
0.8434306383,
-0.5729219913,
1.1168516874,
0.2294325531,
-0.2743550241,
-0.6832185388,
-0.3159113526,
0.011999378,
-0.7543092966,
0.5570135713,
-0.2280839235,
-0.2228761315,
0.4449305534,
-0.6128310561,
-0.6967642307,
0.976231873,
0.4605736136,
-1.0077424049,
0.1305514276,
0.5886594653,
0.2132997215,
-0.195106566,
-0.1664013416,
0.9752274752,
0.0761651993,
0.2572538555,
-0.8085183501,
0.0463794209,
0.0558465086,
0.2235301882,
0.0931151211,
-0.3413284421,
0.8291665912,
-0.1423143148,
-0.1262133121,
-0.0893821418,
0.9303812385,
0.1064012721,
0.2754732668,
0.3944288492,
0.3731556535,
1.0068888664,
-0.3771669567,
0.801271379,
0.1567835361,
0.2019816637,
1.4009275436,
-0.5758163929,
1.149078846,
0.5290758014,
-0.7420632839,
0.3933004737,
0.1720993966,
0.1536555439,
0.6710153222,
0.4164592624,
-0.4304769337,
-0.1582819521,
-0.3610741198,
-0.8146550655,
0.3281462193,
0.6276745796,
-0.0769380853,
-0.0731026232,
-0.1082775295,
-0.2137251049,
0.1160323322,
-0.2801140249,
0.8102685213,
0.1224155501,
-0.2527922988,
0.7862560153,
-0.1218762696,
0.6347784996,
-0.6593344212,
0.1935465187,
-0.2525185645,
0.0301689953,
-0.4205765426,
-0.633214891,
0.5087899566,
-0.0564948134,
-0.1103354469,
0.0859586671,
0.816191256,
-0.519498229,
-0.0701869652,
0.1342447251,
0.5439424515,
0.2209955752,
-0.4850248098,
-0.7200844288,
0.1569574177,
-0.0069783372,
0.0142851816,
0.2756738365,
0.240087688,
0.1734688431,
0.4604551792,
0.7160051465,
0.0598334037,
0.142024681,
0.3943610787,
0.7714207768,
-0.7503080964,
-0.6886176467,
-0.5687711835,
0.3624575436,
-0.1283340156,
0.0285927393,
0.5932725072,
0.8082343936,
0.3209122121,
-0.2580870092,
0.8695483208,
0.172379747,
1.0952773094,
-0.3420119286,
0.3916535378,
-0.3619173467,
0.4630969167,
-0.0319590569,
-0.7353062034,
-0.1683844775,
0.3601604402,
-0.0793350637,
-0.1339015663,
0.4554416537,
0.808293581,
0.3529382348,
0.358674854,
0.2417435497,
0.1494811177,
0.4459636211,
0.4386526346,
0.9934809208,
-0.3875903487,
0.6591998935,
-0.0892582163,
-0.1764411628,
-0.0653764084,
-0.4303285182,
-0.5044980645,
-0.3751193285,
-0.3895936608,
-0.6457430124,
0.3542166054,
0.9841651917,
0.5622316599,
-0.9913098216,
-0.4323123097,
-0.2586862743,
-0.151980713,
-0.3534594178,
-0.1774424165,
0.3975214958,
-0.3365613818,
-0.3266374469,
0.8760800958,
0.2553150356,
-0.1112157255,
0.1965064555,
0.3149344325,
-0.0303347353,
0.3295563757,
0.6844963431,
0.3310912549,
-0.7083579898,
0.120521985,
-0.4261024296,
-0.0159193482,
0.3585632145,
0.6816946268,
-0.710462153,
0.2155166417,
0.2854079008,
0.4965577126,
0.6817189455,
0.1813838184,
0.3035261631,
-1.2535607815,
0.1465611458,
0.3055106401,
0.0822849423,
0.4245092273,
-0.4316657484,
0.3900216818,
0.4883134365,
-0.3866023123,
-0.8244538903,
0.4400475025,
-1.2194076777,
-0.094291836,
1.1846795082,
0.1310768723,
0.0162030663,
-0.4751645923,
-0.3935490847,
0.2422159463,
-0.6242892742,
0.1964798868,
0.2296864092,
-0.4229412675,
-0.0394185558,
-0.3567544222,
0.8544623852,
0.4764690399,
-0.7698557973,
0.5739495754,
0.5508288145,
0.412268579,
-0.3573285639,
0.9440864921,
-0.3175183237,
0.1447552592,
0.1220747903,
-0.1173560992,
-0.0581129678,
0.0096366778,
-0.5515379906,
0.2721689343,
0.0835287347,
-0.354036808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12544v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12544v2 | Has It All Been Solved? Open NLP Research Questions Not Solved by Large Language Models | 2023-05-21T19:06:30 | 2024-03-15T20:10:51 | Oana Ignat, Zhijing Jin, Artem Abzaliev, Laura Biester, Santiago Castro, Naihao Deng, Xinyi Gao, Aylin Gunal, Jacky He, Ashkan Kazemi, Muhammad Khalifa, Namho Koh, Andrew Lee, Siyang Liu, Do June Min, Shinka Mori, Joan Nwatu, Veronica Perez-Rosas, Siqi Shen, Zekun Wang, Winston Wu, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent progress in large language models (LLMs) has enabled the deployment of
many generative NLP applications. At the same time, it has also led to a
misleading public discourse that ``it's all been solved.'' Not surprisingly,
this has, in turn, made many NLP researchers -- especially those at the
beginning of their careers -- worry about what NLP research area they should
focus on. Has it all been solved, or what remaining questions can we work on
regardless of LLMs? To address this question, this paper compiles NLP research
directions rich for exploration. We identify fourteen different research areas
encompassing 45 research directions that require new research and are not
directly solvable by LLMs. While we identify many research areas, many others
exist; we do not cover areas currently addressed by LLMs, but where LLMs lag
behind in performance or those focused on LLM development. We welcome
suggestions for other research directions to include:
https://bit.ly/nlp-era-llm | [
-0.479070127,
-0.8347213864,
0.9557523131,
0.4459972978,
-0.0948932767,
0.1376460195,
-0.3458722234,
-0.5098551512,
0.526432395,
0.7814568877,
-0.6540495753,
-0.3970453143,
-0.9132352471,
0.3669367135,
-0.5091493726,
0.7891097665,
-0.0509316698,
-0.1939912736,
-0.354131937,
-0.0099776741,
-0.3413830101,
-0.7143192887,
-0.7230260372,
-0.3727793992,
0.652536571,
0.3250333965,
0.4462585747,
0.3882833719,
0.5695948005,
0.1825276464,
-0.7725411654,
0.3271877766,
-0.330099225,
0.2653503716,
-0.0748747736,
-0.6184940934,
-0.4151841402,
-0.0791246966,
0.7494192719,
1.1657700539,
-0.2926597893,
0.1731704772,
-0.1371687651,
0.8953176141,
-0.5910927057,
-0.0573320948,
-0.6960870028,
0.2776922584,
-0.5824358463,
-0.4382426143,
-0.2802964449,
-0.0975133479,
0.2189131379,
-0.3705625832,
0.1128075197,
0.1457601041,
0.4668534398,
0.0447356217,
-0.546094954,
-0.4754916131,
-1.0691337585,
0.9931374788,
-0.8666271567,
0.0324317254,
0.3296477199,
0.0267516449,
-0.6566206813,
-0.7441664934,
-0.4099772573,
0.1321585029,
0.2034416199,
-0.0216079671,
-0.6351538897,
-0.1984355003,
0.2741956115,
0.2378277332,
-0.4985384345,
0.3090113699,
-0.4132868052,
0.1577592343,
0.4957989752,
0.1013051867,
0.268507719,
-0.039212361,
-0.347542882,
0.2481891066,
-0.9718070626,
-0.1259863079,
0.0388453901,
0.1669528931,
0.1014359891,
0.942189455,
-0.1184789538,
0.7173396349,
-0.3968179226,
0.0307195671,
0.0441781133,
-0.2478130013,
-0.1154878065,
-0.0933837369,
0.7025300264,
0.3149442375,
0.244934082,
-0.3634397388,
-0.2786127925,
-0.461109519,
0.3211549819,
-0.1257639825,
0.3301958442,
0.442961067,
-0.21257779,
-0.0307680741,
-0.292001456,
-0.5955898166,
-0.5257815719,
-0.2047636062,
-0.0058006807,
-0.1067500636,
-0.7199109793,
0.2382240593,
0.1259591877,
0.5782753229,
0.4271338284,
-0.8901894689,
0.0994539186,
1.1294374466,
1.072285533,
-0.2517598569,
-0.1737092435,
-0.078450352,
-0.1930028796,
-0.7193272114,
0.8717551827,
-0.5799793601,
-0.4060089588,
0.4346803427,
0.1090574488,
-0.035936404,
-0.5625510216,
0.7056487799,
-0.5430938005,
0.4132011533,
-0.4723935723,
-0.5871962905,
0.0395210534,
0.5266319513,
-0.5260364413,
0.8758381605,
-0.2033748925,
-0.899627924,
-0.1280155182,
-0.7573872209,
-0.1408460885,
-0.1462336779,
-0.2204271257,
-0.1453678012,
0.4066254497,
0.2179052085,
0.3130768538,
-0.6300202608,
0.4518872201,
0.007442086,
-0.29832986,
0.4554299414,
-0.2033224702,
0.9769080877,
-0.0075469646,
-0.2438716888,
0.1666520536,
-0.5363233685,
0.0362912193,
0.2934903204,
-0.1461385638,
0.0588897206,
0.0232116003,
-0.0724656358,
-0.0514093526,
0.3053613603,
-0.5903155208,
0.4556155503,
-0.4084900916,
0.5513850451,
0.7639756203,
-0.2658852637,
0.4745630324,
-0.3000918329,
0.9454112649,
-0.2477222979,
-0.1018196419,
-0.0738856941,
-1.0933631659,
-0.9415873885,
0.3119058907,
0.2895545959,
0.1614602208,
-0.4856908619,
0.3223549426,
0.1252041459,
-0.4572355747,
-0.3588880002,
-0.2055900693,
0.0117083704,
0.1555853486,
0.4865740538,
-0.0992660373,
-0.5601459146,
-0.8683644533,
-0.2737483382,
-0.2251984626,
-0.1877917349,
0.2456504256,
0.4147746563,
-0.0690546706,
0.8971973658,
-0.6245415211,
-0.6288369298,
-0.2986089885,
0.1310165972,
0.2300319374,
0.1988748312,
0.5697004795,
-0.5714558363,
-0.2148668021,
-0.2095219791,
-0.818631053,
0.0182019118,
0.1687581092,
0.095893167,
-0.0526427887,
0.7316068411,
-0.849681735,
-0.0705840513,
0.7934795618,
-0.0200240482,
0.5743772388,
-0.1340049058,
-0.2719079852,
-0.7072580457,
0.2021998167,
-0.097334519,
0.1467536241,
-0.8312954307,
0.1625717729,
-0.2848167717,
-0.2601956129,
-0.2493194342,
0.5466460586,
-0.5495375395,
0.0026362857,
-0.4924339354,
0.5250917673,
-0.1923855543,
0.164646253,
-0.1796584129,
0.5247808695,
1.0035669804,
-0.3727709651,
0.368114233,
0.0944729671,
-0.4161105752,
0.0195260085,
-0.7952616215,
0.3369928598,
-0.4020154774,
0.356169194,
-0.8024048805,
-0.1312007755,
0.2238005251,
-0.3179136813,
0.2857497931,
-0.1172966659,
-0.3388135135,
-0.4403840303,
-0.0774121508,
0.4470928311,
0.4479137361,
-0.2961523533,
0.6359213591,
0.3724344969,
-0.4513094127,
-0.8720310926,
-0.6559051275,
0.3354356587,
-0.0607100837,
-0.5884284377,
0.2492340654,
-0.0006824557,
-0.5565685034,
0.0142511763,
-0.2439151853,
-0.1143928394,
0.1968179047,
-0.12569879,
-0.1579193473,
-0.3735448122,
-0.0241948422,
-0.4070131481,
-0.2044596225,
0.3324226439,
-0.0697703063,
0.5823513269,
-0.0735030249,
-0.5752619505,
0.1702337712,
0.5345038176,
0.3641063571,
-0.3266983628,
0.4967281222,
0.2255217731,
-0.3856447339,
-0.2336966097,
-0.6091911197,
0.1779455096,
-0.4067394733,
0.3561623394,
0.2279679179,
-1.2498962879,
0.3633978069,
-0.2027305663,
0.3404718637,
0.207092911,
0.4102397263,
-0.2224424332,
0.8471544385,
1.0816348791,
0.1911570728,
0.2324521095,
-0.2540518045,
0.5763794184,
-0.9350192547,
-0.3371349275,
-0.6451675296,
-0.2033455223,
-0.7738019228,
-0.5235134363,
0.3510649204,
0.3289387524,
0.3734751046,
0.213519901,
-0.4091449082,
0.4726803899,
0.5393773317,
-0.2678260505,
0.4948419929,
-0.261444509,
0.1751652956,
-0.1186250225,
-0.8227899671,
-0.3686023057,
1.2343045473,
0.3207908571,
0.4350109696,
0.2835628986,
0.6017657518,
-0.0581857078,
0.1589172781,
-0.7408710122,
0.5900964141,
-0.0654797032,
-0.8149738908,
-0.3478145599,
-0.2316733748,
-1.224869132,
0.4608727396,
-0.2126463205,
-0.7028912306,
-0.017428223,
-0.1776316464,
-0.1772619486,
0.4561079741,
-0.2276409864,
0.5901971459,
-0.2460263371,
0.0609269887,
0.0896691307,
-0.5755483508,
0.5209811926,
-0.1678440869,
0.3431667686,
-0.4489763081,
0.3007328212,
0.8120799065,
-0.2120701224,
0.6009472609,
-0.0181711074,
-0.5498315692,
0.3933080435,
-0.1915390342,
0.4876178205,
-0.2863032818,
0.0630429462,
0.1427307129,
-0.1537874192,
-0.4122050107,
-0.582393229,
0.8069221973,
-0.2350105345,
-0.9799204469,
-0.7563752532,
-0.2831936479,
-0.3060383201,
0.11979945,
0.1980425864,
0.1111289412,
-0.1414448619,
0.3075225055,
0.9061651826,
-0.3857975602,
0.6343437433,
0.4713267684,
-0.6099612713,
-0.0239440426,
0.4524755776,
0.1187821031,
0.0906692892,
0.2432984263,
0.2103474587,
-0.2286314964,
-0.8307855725,
-0.4466659427,
0.3556787372,
-0.535799861,
-0.0680808425,
-0.5343818069,
-0.3236242831,
-0.3247837424,
-0.0862875655,
-0.7229329944,
-0.0964209288,
-0.2695794404,
0.1345434487,
0.3514748812,
0.8404573202,
-0.0918651447,
0.1647283882,
-0.5681840181,
0.2651168406,
0.1563538164,
0.2765023708,
0.2613230646,
-0.3675580621,
-0.3037736714,
0.1201259196,
-0.1987224072,
-0.6448239088,
0.3986177742,
-0.0373180583,
0.5007504225,
0.2699379027,
0.2322248966,
0.3391104043,
-0.6654931307,
1.0359553099,
0.2459124476,
-0.4675419331,
0.2931555808,
-0.2531783581,
0.2749535143,
0.1352467835,
0.7187494636,
-0.6591297388,
-0.4207734168,
-0.5625917912,
-1.0445693731,
0.4496507645,
0.3210502565,
0.1502462775,
0.0282934457,
0.1478562802,
-0.1620811522,
0.2430752069,
-0.758692205,
-0.4938661754,
0.2548161745,
0.47813344,
-0.0794139504,
-0.2561681867,
-0.4368482828,
0.0118331704,
0.2562930286,
-0.0547327325,
0.3675896227,
0.0477389656,
0.4286649823,
-0.3494570553,
0.6682572961,
0.4722210467,
1.2055143118,
-0.2747887671,
0.1718852669,
-0.298191905,
-0.100186497,
0.0031205642,
-0.0096409693,
-0.4279353321,
0.2874666452,
0.5245727301,
0.6558456421,
0.1275832504,
-0.6555852294,
0.7776337266,
0.0271198303,
-0.3479926288,
-0.7143647671,
-0.0923978537,
0.37280339,
0.3263327181,
0.5900660753,
-0.0825237483,
-0.3156535327,
-0.6985049248,
-0.1713341773,
0.5931652784,
-0.2554724813,
-0.1787414849,
0.5961757302,
0.0523483753,
-0.4609677792,
0.5617699623,
0.0875820369,
-0.465511322,
0.5272158384,
0.7618616223,
0.9146267176,
0.1878490597,
0.2946915925,
0.1088116392,
0.4411766231,
-0.3121745884,
0.4035050571,
0.3238533139,
-0.7610805035,
-0.9562398791,
-0.7293356657,
-0.6009086967,
0.440177083,
-0.56313169,
0.0729960427,
-0.2938934267,
-0.1333922297,
0.1584322006,
-0.1938733608,
-0.4611516893,
-0.1029334217,
-0.1068411469,
0.910207808,
-0.6713783741,
0.5318002701,
0.6683194637,
-0.2571832538,
-0.214661032,
0.1811818033,
-0.058265578,
-0.7167440057,
0.6099900603,
0.0335568376,
-0.0803497434,
0.1793565452,
-1.009855628,
-1.0879638195,
0.8287325501,
0.1403218359,
-0.5668016672,
-0.4706532061,
0.3685875237,
0.5445948839,
-0.0665291324,
0.1198442057,
0.3451310396,
0.5251477957,
-0.0842457786,
-0.7964519858,
-0.2718964815,
-0.11208684,
-0.1890565604,
0.2389229089,
-0.5369955301,
0.8141744137,
-0.3045663238,
-0.2326547951,
0.2319158018,
0.5433185697,
0.3476863205,
0.2749239206,
0.2841596603,
0.65922153,
0.6336123943,
-0.2978519797,
0.8479543328,
-0.0171823073,
0.2776898444,
0.8322755098,
-0.343888104,
0.8010631204,
0.5495786071,
-0.4556452036,
0.0376389995,
0.5379766822,
-0.0713685825,
0.2711341977,
0.446012944,
-0.3783483505,
-0.2809191942,
-0.3618128002,
-0.5847392678,
0.433290869,
0.3731453121,
-0.2234146148,
-0.380063951,
0.0317987055,
0.0625905022,
0.0606638901,
-0.0791372359,
0.5900345445,
0.3468832672,
-0.5660110712,
0.572065413,
0.324660033,
0.9414336681,
-0.7915075421,
-0.1020411924,
-0.4463227987,
-0.2496345192,
-0.1627813876,
-0.937369585,
0.2679343522,
0.1903887838,
-0.1380700916,
-0.3507220149,
0.7248427272,
-0.3146483302,
-0.2100470662,
0.4261333644,
0.8845618963,
0.339455992,
-0.163502723,
-0.3385653198,
-0.0157828219,
-0.0583122931,
-0.2265684903,
0.4838695526,
0.7753715515,
0.2724106908,
0.988635242,
0.6501669884,
0.3344815671,
0.3273040056,
0.0259124991,
0.8351029754,
-0.9773260951,
0.1638003737,
-0.6775627732,
0.3225791454,
0.2026185989,
-0.6560346484,
0.8583880067,
0.2970962822,
0.9257247448,
0.1330852509,
0.7008195519,
-0.1128088683,
0.577883482,
-0.7039961815,
0.3667047322,
-0.6361929178,
0.2572305799,
-0.2091091275,
-1.2242842913,
-0.5393182635,
0.4475151598,
-0.0164263509,
-0.0355763286,
0.7956861258,
0.5762207508,
0.194152087,
0.1680873781,
0.305683434,
0.2146486044,
0.3668781221,
0.1774574816,
1.1535589695,
-0.1873321533,
0.3881607354,
-0.4072413743,
-0.1761700511,
-0.2516085207,
-1.1532216072,
-0.4478140473,
-0.4126245677,
-0.139610678,
-0.2022130191,
0.0485495292,
0.715265274,
0.2203836739,
-0.6391586065,
-0.2279393077,
-0.3139522076,
0.1595679224,
-0.0690923184,
-0.1996068656,
0.2151891887,
-0.2709605694,
-0.6569939256,
0.714425683,
0.0017191685,
-0.1406738609,
-0.6963219643,
0.252527535,
-0.5088785887,
-0.1189965904,
0.6874669194,
0.5817264915,
-0.8657737374,
-0.1057427377,
0.3569490314,
0.1822533458,
0.1584635824,
1.0461416245,
-0.1444061995,
0.3374994397,
0.2842382789,
0.7914434671,
0.5804626346,
-0.2446492314,
0.6479974985,
-0.8479251266,
-0.1687693447,
0.6018805504,
0.3660351038,
0.3276013434,
0.0639424026,
0.6761382818,
0.1007787585,
-0.9225393534,
-0.8222076893,
0.3154686093,
-0.9944306612,
-0.3953963518,
1.2971402407,
-0.0250478461,
-0.0789906085,
-0.2038041204,
0.0577166826,
-0.1369486749,
0.0762334839,
0.7056263685,
0.8714672327,
-0.5493020415,
-0.0915803909,
-0.8825529814,
0.3661979139,
0.5493267179,
-0.5101967454,
0.3815568089,
0.2676338255,
-0.0861198977,
0.5056197047,
0.8838354945,
-0.206927985,
-0.3576077521,
-0.1688192785,
0.115085341,
0.2495565116,
-0.5454145074,
-0.2562835813,
0.0587092116,
0.4911099672,
0.1816697568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12542v1 | ToxBuster: In-game Chat Toxicity Buster with BERT | 2023-05-21T18:53:26 | 2023-05-21T18:53:26 | Zachary Yang, Yasmine Maricar, MohammadReza Davari, Nicolas Grenon-Godbout, Reihaneh Rabbany | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Detecting toxicity in online spaces is challenging and an ever more pressing
problem given the increase in social media and gaming consumption. We introduce
ToxBuster, a simple and scalable model trained on a relatively large dataset of
194k lines of game chat from Rainbow Six Siege and For Honor, carefully
annotated for different kinds of toxicity. Compared to the existing
state-of-the-art, ToxBuster achieves 82.95% (+7) in precision and 83.56% (+57)
in recall. This improvement is obtained by leveraging past chat history and
metadata. We also study the implication towards real-time and post-game
moderation as well as the model transferability from one game to another. | [
-0.2105710059,
-0.7076420784,
0.4481309354,
0.7373533249,
0.1490096152,
-0.0353731327,
0.1425217837,
-0.6699448824,
0.1116026565,
0.5783372521,
-0.6427407861,
-0.3375381827,
-0.646674335,
-0.2685414255,
-0.5930220485,
1.3398134708,
0.4212178886,
-0.2746014297,
-0.1994432807,
-0.0429096259,
-0.6790789962,
-0.5835677385,
-1.2047510147,
-0.4752084315,
0.8802893162,
0.4481857717,
0.6231934428,
0.2451337874,
0.7385947108,
0.4193526804,
-0.2833252847,
-0.2450653315,
-1.3463772535,
0.1309870332,
-0.3046108782,
-0.625864625,
-0.3203694224,
-0.5018820167,
0.0666319504,
-0.0800495595,
-0.1550083011,
0.1916050017,
-0.0118418643,
0.2924060225,
-0.5847885013,
0.2144094557,
-0.5930653811,
-0.0353462957,
-0.0228309222,
-0.2060963064,
-0.6380609274,
-0.3795975745,
0.0445705652,
-0.4660721421,
-0.1787667871,
0.0041401032,
0.9720554948,
0.3895438313,
-0.4813950062,
-0.3513733149,
-0.9696087241,
0.6894555092,
-0.7546633482,
0.146352157,
0.2673381567,
0.7772205472,
-0.2388860583,
-0.9651217461,
-0.3248832822,
0.1073655114,
0.0537047572,
0.2413173616,
-0.6485406756,
0.1573293507,
0.108737804,
0.0404836312,
-0.1182373315,
0.1590546072,
-0.2639214396,
-0.285582751,
0.7766683102,
0.3404631615,
0.326399684,
-0.0354286209,
-0.6102349162,
0.0830306336,
-0.2034161836,
0.1947795004,
0.2152397335,
-0.1359217167,
0.1980182528,
0.1756002456,
0.4265412688,
0.1915941685,
0.1054217517,
-0.193838045,
-0.1624293178,
-0.1230371669,
0.2110446841,
0.1167019904,
0.5763241649,
0.8734243512,
0.0866936445,
-0.2173886895,
-0.2159222066,
0.3674668372,
0.4660612643,
-1.1367754936,
-0.8685239553,
0.5648841858,
-0.7231216431,
-0.4679063261,
-0.3371553719,
-0.8480411172,
-0.8425490856,
0.355868876,
0.8807180524,
-0.4870890677,
-0.3526521027,
-0.1618447751,
-0.5235843062,
0.0481340624,
0.3343584836,
-0.472500056,
0.1759024858,
0.6093118191,
0.8588317633,
-0.1417539716,
0.078700304,
-0.4891144633,
0.1722741723,
-0.3558165431,
1.1028072834,
-0.4261308014,
-0.5332106948,
-0.0758849978,
-0.2329864949,
0.6113368273,
-0.5273817778,
0.6104995012,
-0.4787185788,
0.0148007451,
-0.4508214295,
-0.8824585676,
-0.3355397284,
0.4985926747,
-0.5428391099,
0.9204003811,
0.1770359576,
-0.5166595578,
0.3700528145,
-0.9533824325,
-0.125459522,
0.354678601,
0.5011367202,
-0.5215826035,
-0.0748277456,
-0.1645980924,
0.1925499439,
0.1596336067,
0.0236801151,
-0.7698853612,
-0.6102179289,
0.261031121,
-0.0965736806,
1.0345253944,
0.2668167949,
-0.2578853369,
0.3994853199,
-0.4013565183,
0.0260174572,
-0.0734310299,
-0.4547394812,
-0.3915073276,
0.7344391346,
0.1230188683,
0.5237929821,
-0.049632974,
-0.7983327508,
-0.436040163,
0.1090572253,
0.5712171197,
0.757425189,
0.3114573061,
-0.0178282727,
-0.8198387623,
-0.0059529115,
-0.0244154502,
0.5813518763,
0.0880153179,
-0.708499074,
-0.6945047379,
-0.713093698,
0.1840672046,
0.7485612631,
-0.7107630968,
0.8052889109,
-0.2701732218,
-0.8803910017,
-0.2197883427,
-0.2343787253,
0.2702905834,
0.3017163277,
0.163719058,
-0.5052011013,
-0.3890950084,
-0.2612057328,
-0.0398827828,
-0.3625355959,
-0.1269681603,
0.5164378881,
0.3380755484,
-0.7640284896,
1.1083730459,
-0.3509020805,
-0.840113163,
-0.1618427187,
0.2380323708,
-0.2111719251,
0.2898622751,
1.0307184458,
-0.4061824381,
-0.652372241,
-0.3296026587,
-0.6976101398,
-0.4231513143,
-0.0313755684,
-0.4466120899,
-0.2416809052,
0.6957566738,
0.1828320473,
0.3288218975,
0.6663517952,
-0.6242759228,
0.1503225416,
-0.0351852775,
0.2405464202,
-0.9241560698,
-0.1014032289,
-0.0012476444,
-0.431423068,
-0.9796780944,
-0.0559653379,
-0.0396262258,
-0.1408046782,
-0.5361376405,
0.5378757119,
-0.0361824483,
0.3670585752,
-0.1925758868,
0.0265351497,
-0.2815621197,
0.3586693108,
0.0605576932,
0.6156253815,
0.20800969,
-0.4632318616,
0.6466632485,
0.525975287,
-0.1992875487,
0.7000650764,
-0.5362900496,
0.159633413,
-0.2680379152,
0.3798671365,
-1.7430678606,
0.0915003344,
0.0255530737,
-0.6951006651,
-0.1666795313,
-0.3688685,
-0.7560005188,
-0.3333036602,
-0.441301614,
0.0433687568,
0.6066510677,
-0.671580255,
0.7046726346,
0.6228282452,
-0.0537820943,
-0.2610173523,
-0.6807869077,
0.1003443971,
-0.4104221761,
-0.8192190528,
-0.0852602497,
-0.438993156,
-0.2393831611,
-0.183770597,
0.1291993409,
-0.475638926,
0.0414611623,
0.4828399718,
0.1137760058,
0.0635054335,
0.1942357868,
-0.2554165721,
0.0351185352,
0.6490766406,
0.3892220557,
0.4469562769,
0.0080995252,
0.0111377882,
-0.1735480279,
0.4360239804,
0.4172271788,
0.1124188378,
0.683336556,
0.5074095726,
-0.2300358117,
-0.1882079095,
-0.5969360471,
-0.4332236052,
-0.6267549992,
0.4667831063,
0.2468182594,
-0.5747636557,
1.0285431147,
-0.1774085909,
0.4367540181,
0.09905155,
0.3680100739,
-0.2698422074,
1.4359145164,
0.6261072159,
-0.2017901391,
0.7449298501,
0.1796971112,
0.1174563915,
0.0061466619,
-0.179969281,
-0.4119882286,
-0.6605525613,
-0.5194737315,
-0.2620593905,
0.5203006864,
-0.4557616711,
-0.6520784497,
0.0058227447,
-0.3402048647,
0.6908738613,
0.3390394747,
0.6128563881,
0.1260878146,
-0.2128436416,
0.5808416605,
-0.3647092283,
-0.7345614433,
-0.0526561514,
0.8033452034,
0.6241266131,
0.6926723123,
0.6220588684,
0.6734303832,
0.4091708958,
0.9360281229,
-0.7881835699,
0.4528296292,
-0.096788846,
-1.3950041533,
-0.1686904728,
-0.4051463604,
-0.6965595484,
-0.1439271122,
-0.4882800579,
-0.6775848269,
0.0781754553,
0.2123080641,
-0.6707450747,
0.5676395297,
-1.1227332354,
0.8068762422,
-0.2050756067,
-0.4953730404,
-0.0984810442,
-0.8041834831,
0.5620180964,
-0.0807344615,
0.1897498816,
-0.1491612047,
0.012969478,
0.6232180595,
-0.3842121363,
1.1027613878,
-0.1350322813,
-0.0541154705,
0.3829644322,
0.3743962049,
0.6237051487,
0.0024746193,
0.2359641045,
0.4187992811,
0.2028143704,
-0.3171005845,
-0.1674549878,
0.4864783585,
-0.8558078408,
-0.084408097,
-0.5170281529,
-0.5758660436,
-0.2271977812,
0.1567072123,
0.3907931149,
-0.0523203537,
-0.1432801634,
0.4228817225,
1.1055514812,
-0.5317741036,
0.2930123508,
0.4521872699,
-0.3753700852,
-0.0794511884,
1.0870429277,
-0.2608592212,
0.3743627369,
0.2331076711,
0.1393901408,
-0.2020450085,
-0.1029660106,
0.112860918,
0.1027642936,
-0.7065057158,
-0.5137472749,
-0.5402305126,
-0.5412710309,
0.0017142758,
-0.198769629,
-0.3941993117,
0.1842764467,
-0.1936608106,
0.1619304717,
0.7483167052,
0.6346593499,
-0.304846108,
0.7950204611,
-1.0111268759,
-0.0226396099,
0.5822701454,
0.8008793592,
-0.1284705848,
-0.4109502137,
0.3196600378,
-0.1151641831,
-0.4643538892,
-1.2304180861,
0.4728910625,
0.2278132886,
0.2570545673,
0.9064393044,
0.2443314046,
0.8376733065,
-0.1497566551,
0.7632469535,
0.0873639435,
-0.8591509461,
0.3062884212,
-0.5278952718,
-0.1179385558,
0.3782759607,
0.4115727246,
-0.7998489141,
-0.4945040941,
-0.4961666167,
-0.6071075201,
0.7118392587,
0.2701696157,
0.3051657379,
-0.0353681631,
0.0238140114,
-0.0779243261,
0.0405462161,
-0.8425358534,
-0.3316257894,
-0.2794228196,
-0.0015893922,
-0.1219148338,
-0.7382616401,
0.034892235,
-0.349295646,
0.5649062991,
0.3360919058,
0.6568740606,
-0.3183111846,
0.00006543,
-0.2554489374,
0.0962557271,
0.2175208628,
0.399690479,
-0.6524478793,
-0.1550532281,
0.4391160011,
-0.4323507249,
-0.1741481274,
-0.0368161313,
0.1057621017,
-0.0475780852,
0.2883837521,
0.3527533412,
0.4570464194,
-0.8947939873,
0.7555035353,
-0.2864522636,
-0.3340837359,
-0.2767270505,
0.1037956104,
0.0856001973,
0.4796675146,
0.0467039309,
-0.0832848027,
0.4914060533,
-0.6912795305,
0.5256498456,
0.3417471349,
-0.788566649,
-0.0566242002,
0.8658687472,
0.5347877145,
0.0285069291,
0.7699047327,
-0.1068252251,
-0.5802417397,
0.2327760011,
0.5642766953,
0.4291078448,
-0.4394902885,
0.1130581126,
0.3747444153,
0.1828199178,
0.0960158482,
0.3658771515,
0.2595528364,
-0.7694495916,
-0.240861252,
-0.3075903058,
-0.4109639525,
0.3039111197,
-0.3482955396,
0.2371261865,
-0.4634059966,
-0.5787565112,
0.2440444976,
0.0450119376,
-0.0067053912,
-0.1661841422,
0.1770218015,
0.9632105231,
-1.1036229134,
0.3938279152,
0.4500256181,
-0.4469403028,
-0.5178048611,
-0.4518704414,
0.1941832751,
-0.6778714657,
0.2837579548,
-0.031111246,
0.0786849856,
0.2795564234,
-0.8585800529,
-0.5686190724,
0.9128512144,
0.150581494,
-0.4170123041,
-0.1845395565,
-0.014497078,
0.7552574873,
0.2794589996,
0.4792444408,
0.5553880334,
0.4204522669,
0.4292655587,
-0.6528436542,
-0.3532942235,
-0.3670320809,
0.1919285357,
0.2877615392,
-0.6099454761,
0.7834913135,
-0.1185608357,
-0.2651804984,
-0.1799717098,
0.6021841764,
0.1351867467,
0.2215017676,
0.639421761,
0.3573965728,
0.344268471,
-0.3171394765,
0.6167442799,
-0.0953033268,
0.3820531666,
0.7794706225,
-0.1820635498,
0.7837274075,
0.1972267628,
0.1584853828,
0.6068099737,
0.7136369348,
-0.122977607,
0.5155420303,
0.1724409908,
-0.3791107833,
-0.450358361,
-0.0472714603,
-0.1553752571,
0.1552933007,
0.590246439,
-0.2119708508,
-0.7431654334,
0.0561836921,
0.4351779222,
0.06339968,
-0.5312657952,
1.1756695509,
-0.3044859469,
-0.5142728686,
0.354118526,
-0.3751018643,
1.0509747267,
-0.6833499074,
-0.0771060064,
-0.3034361303,
1.0134221315,
-0.1356820911,
-1.0840229988,
0.3123098314,
-0.0910440311,
0.2045083493,
-0.1394137591,
0.9890452027,
-0.3425050676,
-0.1846912652,
0.610033989,
0.2018722296,
0.2230357826,
-0.4672674835,
-0.6601113081,
0.155027464,
-0.0736201331,
0.2907191813,
0.1611143649,
0.5925344825,
-0.1759055108,
0.8660950661,
0.44149369,
-0.0649940968,
0.2472906858,
-0.5195177197,
0.7524173856,
-0.3107467592,
-0.6650716066,
-0.623909235,
0.4214452505,
-0.2785033584,
-0.1562403291,
0.7533049583,
0.5050988197,
0.6297941208,
0.0063978601,
0.7633658648,
-0.1895548999,
0.5878161788,
0.3690637648,
1.2650752068,
-0.3687883019,
-0.0710350126,
-0.2653598785,
-0.5371565223,
-0.2913899124,
0.5763096809,
0.0461962968,
-0.0459687077,
0.2367258221,
0.8610962033,
0.0323113054,
-0.1179501936,
0.3370420635,
0.1555096209,
0.7502308488,
0.8178771734,
0.9689230919,
-0.2978460491,
1.1624907255,
-0.2072016001,
-0.6260993481,
-0.6070687175,
-0.8757030964,
-1.4287325144,
-0.5865837336,
-0.0747871175,
-0.8076636791,
0.2591814995,
0.7632631063,
0.594222188,
-0.922208488,
-0.3341346085,
0.28242746,
-0.0097414711,
-0.5092788339,
-0.2135644853,
-0.3840992451,
-0.4280504584,
-0.4131681621,
-0.3043403924,
-0.0341473706,
-0.0123578245,
0.1501717716,
0.0485558249,
-0.2531881034,
0.5006119609,
1.1236461401,
0.3447757363,
-0.2411797196,
-0.6503430605,
-0.0709331259,
-0.1928731352,
0.1881586462,
0.2917926311,
-0.4615677893,
0.6266102195,
0.6101531982,
0.301409781,
0.4741066992,
0.0616995916,
0.4703254998,
-0.8355833888,
-0.1351336688,
0.238529548,
-0.0268840045,
0.0352463201,
-0.424551636,
0.4669948816,
0.0141202835,
-0.6917551756,
-0.9267383814,
-0.101854451,
-0.7806972861,
-0.3373297155,
1.220987916,
0.0077297739,
-0.159122467,
-0.37472561,
-0.700623095,
0.2553112209,
-0.6920434833,
1.3582811356,
0.750669837,
-0.0637388974,
-0.170122534,
-0.463965863,
0.8389102817,
-0.1369293481,
-1.0324481726,
0.0687623471,
0.7071790695,
0.6479743719,
0.3813121319,
0.4205908179,
-0.0550322272,
0.4861699045,
0.15490973,
0.1086094826,
0.186854437,
-0.0417969152,
0.0819333941,
0.0198398866,
-0.1896570027,
-0.1142321378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12535v1 | Explaining How Transformers Use Context to Build Predictions | 2023-05-21T18:29:10 | 2023-05-21T18:29:10 | Javier Ferrando, Gerard I. Gállego, Ioannis Tsiamas, Marta R. Costa-jussà | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language Generation Models produce words based on the previous context.
Although existing methods offer input attributions as explanations for a
model's prediction, it is still unclear how prior words affect the model's
decision throughout the layers. In this work, we leverage recent advances in
explainability of the Transformer and present a procedure to analyze models for
language generation. Using contrastive examples, we compare the alignment of
our explanations with evidence of the linguistic phenomena, and show that our
method consistently aligns better than gradient-based and perturbation-based
baselines. Then, we investigate the role of MLPs inside the Transformer and
show that they learn features that help the model predict words that are
grammatically acceptable. Lastly, we apply our method to Neural Machine
Translation models, and demonstrate that they generate human-like source-target
alignments for building predictions. | [
-0.5995689631,
-0.5321529508,
0.6144512296,
0.0731031671,
0.1830185652,
-0.2713907957,
-0.2450387776,
-0.2152770013,
-0.3420053422,
0.6074873209,
-0.7683666348,
-0.001945046,
-0.5250229836,
0.1001706049,
-0.7316860557,
1.0311729908,
-0.1083686948,
-0.0810614079,
-0.1426514387,
0.115034312,
-0.7651970983,
-0.3840787709,
-0.4118479788,
-0.8423239589,
0.4507509768,
0.3950222731,
1.1803854704,
0.7937831283,
0.2547640204,
0.3544241786,
-0.0399995148,
-0.2764308751,
-0.1881940216,
0.2276535034,
-0.148494944,
-0.5903065801,
-0.0342385657,
-0.0212405119,
0.5100528598,
0.7529811263,
-0.0175315719,
0.1517164558,
0.2088860273,
0.2647373676,
-0.4579187334,
-0.1051165983,
-1.0105569363,
0.1690862328,
-0.0431203656,
-0.4361795783,
-0.7086257935,
0.0990393162,
0.189246431,
-0.2155388892,
0.6370090246,
-0.092063956,
0.9741094112,
0.3873128891,
-0.3910512626,
-0.3301745355,
-0.9671361446,
0.7400149703,
-0.6263394356,
0.5285833478,
0.1806153655,
0.5730541945,
-0.3153726459,
-0.9542511702,
-0.8285343051,
-0.0865195245,
-0.5422978401,
0.0441278256,
-0.0714863092,
-0.2088730633,
0.3431062102,
0.2258538157,
-0.4327366948,
0.0863711014,
-0.1456025541,
-0.1443894804,
0.356495738,
0.0926297829,
0.2687559426,
-0.4683591723,
-0.3961770535,
-0.1503545493,
-0.7848392129,
0.1934650242,
0.2481772751,
0.41255036,
-0.0132374819,
0.8083943129,
0.2715711594,
0.7342700958,
0.3120019734,
0.0722163245,
-0.0569737181,
-0.2533839345,
-0.3843836486,
0.1366562992,
0.6190961003,
0.3893818259,
0.3311223686,
-0.2563885748,
-0.1511479616,
0.1099102721,
0.5781829953,
-0.605384171,
0.0043108109,
0.1054380685,
-0.6375375986,
-0.5072021484,
-0.0648962855,
-0.5408477187,
-0.1974632442,
-0.4985358715,
0.2493806481,
-0.2415075898,
-0.1671634912,
-0.1408903003,
-0.2558996379,
0.3550958931,
-0.1677600145,
-1.2657930851,
0.1738844365,
0.5754335523,
0.3881105483,
0.0139345322,
-0.5296421647,
-0.3181476593,
0.1402709931,
-0.2614798844,
0.7592353821,
-0.3685217798,
-0.2413648963,
0.2682178319,
0.0263122469,
0.0056415219,
-0.5262637138,
0.5123854876,
-0.4020197392,
0.6214241385,
-0.22042723,
-0.4587727487,
-0.0851454139,
-0.1930889934,
-0.5220376849,
0.8198932409,
0.1545192152,
-0.7327942848,
0.696233809,
-0.6658622622,
-0.4147382379,
-0.0057602595,
-0.0738540292,
-0.2965842187,
0.5190275311,
0.3404136002,
0.6626772881,
-0.1427252442,
0.5349454284,
0.1132395566,
-0.1151457652,
0.6172105074,
-0.4394493103,
0.745721221,
0.4032106698,
-0.4695357382,
0.185346067,
-0.4181892872,
-0.2361071259,
0.1127471104,
-0.1295194179,
0.0805303305,
0.521325469,
-0.0871939585,
0.3551215231,
-0.1173078045,
-0.2312530428,
0.0480357036,
-0.4340059161,
0.5158797503,
0.5814823508,
-0.2033292949,
0.8435807228,
-0.0622747652,
0.6238852739,
-0.0298768636,
0.0143520907,
-0.5017881989,
-0.5277017355,
-0.7403276563,
0.3520304561,
0.2514475882,
0.2801982164,
-0.6030701995,
0.2437125444,
-0.3433107436,
-0.2865561545,
-0.4353544116,
0.1080208048,
0.0796557888,
0.9316287041,
0.3002173305,
0.1540893614,
-0.891599834,
-1.1137189865,
-0.3755318522,
-0.0454516113,
-0.4014177024,
0.1265601218,
0.3203711212,
-0.4102988541,
1.1629269123,
-0.3152396083,
0.4623729885,
-0.4102675319,
0.1318394691,
0.2326346636,
0.3142880797,
0.6541229486,
-0.7815304399,
-0.3223046362,
0.034929499,
-0.6211819053,
-0.2826681733,
-0.2730442584,
-0.1747307628,
-0.0649431348,
0.7852826118,
-0.5889053941,
0.2106534541,
0.7117382288,
-0.5080268383,
0.4650635123,
0.1207327843,
-0.2645483911,
-1.3170862198,
-0.1029322594,
-0.0182732027,
-0.3043785393,
-0.7522516847,
0.0867956951,
-0.1003203839,
-0.2599403262,
-0.311668694,
0.3583313525,
-0.3211683333,
-0.1884705722,
-0.3392046392,
0.250649929,
-0.0648712814,
0.2015887499,
-0.0217028763,
0.6657905579,
0.3312859237,
-0.6457950473,
0.1010718942,
0.2692579627,
-0.2430698127,
0.2449133098,
-0.6677629352,
-0.2290400416,
-0.2758531868,
0.2416867316,
-1.0198339224,
-0.2162032574,
-0.102134645,
-0.6442734003,
0.3568587005,
-0.085087426,
-0.2772483528,
-0.3762058914,
0.3404408097,
0.0861989558,
0.7585359812,
-0.7855116725,
0.8336491585,
0.2178767174,
0.0678023696,
-0.6180496216,
-0.801076293,
0.0747388601,
-0.6286544204,
-0.7555676103,
0.7628674507,
0.0131540503,
-0.4680348635,
-0.1098527163,
0.1323743016,
0.0140277604,
0.432059586,
0.4008822143,
0.1912172586,
-0.6551248431,
0.1175400242,
0.0020574953,
-0.2328400016,
0.3172401786,
-0.13383618,
0.6818054318,
0.0408512205,
0.0617087297,
-0.2188232243,
0.1513772011,
0.5000904202,
-0.0302086417,
0.882991612,
0.6167155504,
-0.2878281474,
-0.4540437758,
-0.3335720897,
-0.3470473886,
-0.5114852786,
0.3045318723,
-0.6030817628,
-0.5542930961,
0.5575799346,
-0.044220645,
0.211826995,
0.9463772774,
0.8494701982,
-0.1375861615,
1.2132773399,
0.7637025714,
0.2240947038,
0.5695552826,
-0.0632306486,
0.3186220825,
-0.6712238193,
-0.0108723212,
-0.6143957376,
-0.2854582369,
-0.688346386,
-0.1706068069,
-0.188443616,
0.4734888375,
-0.050352972,
0.8679481745,
-0.4299162626,
0.5150572658,
0.3601393402,
-0.402569443,
0.0223791394,
0.098883681,
-0.2636287212,
-0.0658837259,
-0.7826103568,
-0.833194077,
0.9064286351,
0.5407400727,
0.385796845,
-0.0835467651,
0.4194920957,
-0.0095167235,
0.6090308428,
-0.607529819,
0.2100517452,
-0.1533152908,
-0.5687459111,
-0.146963492,
0.0154815512,
-0.9638360143,
0.2393878698,
-0.4381674826,
-0.6709667444,
-0.071137771,
0.2629135251,
-0.1866483241,
0.0141339563,
-0.868992269,
0.9740058184,
-0.1624811143,
-0.0695993602,
0.013277269,
-0.627638638,
0.3482325077,
0.0700622126,
0.2027440071,
0.241960749,
0.2505591214,
0.3863463998,
-0.3770283461,
0.5859628916,
-0.0756102949,
-0.3675237298,
0.2863179147,
0.0704067126,
0.1114068851,
-0.2507379353,
-0.2104469836,
0.0539134629,
-0.5181494355,
-0.0871323198,
-0.8882318735,
0.5209665298,
-0.4980443418,
-0.5147325993,
0.3042595387,
-0.7043952346,
-0.0842901021,
-0.071388267,
0.8366298079,
0.3956830502,
-0.1872395277,
0.2075425088,
0.2893597484,
-0.1960400641,
0.6382209659,
0.2308141887,
-0.4722906649,
0.1010955721,
0.6089627743,
-0.1356262714,
0.29491359,
0.381046474,
0.4643408656,
-0.305214256,
-0.3942656815,
-0.5222124457,
-0.0447282791,
-0.7301730514,
0.0355236046,
-0.4149293602,
-0.2677280903,
-0.417503804,
-0.5084681511,
-0.0801391676,
-0.4031319916,
-0.0085431077,
-0.3255830407,
-0.2803038657,
1.0547083616,
0.1605273634,
0.7593169808,
-0.6063258052,
0.2574847341,
0.2911456227,
0.11371281,
0.0296808295,
-0.623505652,
-0.3241021931,
0.1952021271,
-0.5903699994,
-1.096259594,
0.3143611848,
0.0903166905,
0.7098225951,
0.3349099457,
-0.5469040871,
0.5332552195,
-0.8759449124,
1.0680829287,
0.0962136313,
-1.2335444689,
0.6916612387,
-0.2318602651,
0.360198468,
0.0689532757,
0.2172000557,
-0.4540450871,
-0.5080977678,
-0.8155753016,
-0.6928623319,
0.4790123999,
0.3737781048,
0.3370693326,
-0.147875458,
0.5378264785,
0.2507944405,
0.0115888054,
-0.9686219692,
-0.3591935933,
-0.3278279006,
-0.2759696245,
-0.5093393922,
-0.3048750758,
0.0997141153,
-0.0214698445,
0.4728685319,
-0.1062991172,
0.4099891484,
-0.055445265,
-0.281269908,
-0.3276763558,
0.3607522845,
0.9382463694,
0.6346797943,
0.1660168469,
0.1999395639,
0.1281515211,
-0.022674473,
-0.0731734931,
-0.0912984982,
-0.1650858372,
0.339538604,
0.5878903866,
0.9169294834,
0.1247187257,
-0.3881158531,
0.428378135,
-0.162890628,
-0.1283575147,
-0.3401080966,
0.0489054248,
0.2774710059,
0.2875769138,
0.3150533736,
0.29257828,
-0.0383198112,
-0.5708345175,
0.3149693608,
0.4616718292,
-0.4370556772,
-0.5086966157,
0.779037416,
0.0909489766,
-0.5664467812,
0.5543602109,
0.3091297746,
-0.6616615653,
0.7245688438,
0.8826959133,
0.951625824,
-0.4340600669,
0.2153079063,
0.3644418418,
0.3002168536,
-0.0448140204,
-0.0755746961,
-0.107727997,
-1.1436135769,
-0.724142015,
-0.7318200469,
-0.0185365938,
0.1978341341,
-0.5525194407,
0.3511767089,
-0.0451416038,
-0.1719000638,
0.3731779158,
-0.6334581971,
-0.7935417891,
0.3613961339,
0.3987545371,
0.6883403063,
-1.1707884073,
0.574265182,
0.4366485476,
-0.3326583803,
-0.9636985064,
0.2632719278,
-0.1766541749,
-0.9213513732,
0.9033037424,
0.281027019,
-0.0112572489,
-0.1590406299,
-0.6077359915,
-0.789865315,
0.8458344936,
0.5186766982,
-0.377097249,
-0.2269927263,
0.2237910032,
0.790982306,
-0.6653599739,
0.1676575243,
0.5624516606,
0.4873329997,
-0.0655609518,
-0.6726287603,
0.0509383194,
-0.0543054491,
0.0288061611,
0.3739255965,
0.2686470449,
0.8592900038,
-0.2168158442,
-0.3464828432,
0.071894832,
0.7736926079,
-0.0899854004,
-0.0439251103,
0.5216810107,
0.3677019477,
0.3026086092,
-0.2190722525,
1.4420508146,
-0.426892072,
0.2171708643,
1.1879464388,
0.2029487342,
0.8983171582,
0.665610671,
-0.0527597107,
1.0860608816,
0.4318119586,
-0.068840526,
0.3435928524,
0.2569516301,
0.1729394943,
-0.0850373134,
-0.1003978178,
-0.1745263636,
0.8400698304,
0.3639340103,
-0.9981768131,
-0.1979067028,
-0.0213311762,
-0.2475445718,
0.074247241,
-0.1557842493,
0.6879706383,
-0.0538667291,
-1.114279151,
0.5271767974,
-0.0018869315,
0.4917283952,
-0.3604210615,
0.08715491,
0.1296969503,
0.2696199715,
-0.3306773603,
-0.8921545148,
0.6021351814,
-0.1691091955,
-0.4488395154,
-0.6743965149,
0.5833679438,
-0.528142333,
-0.3309546411,
0.1599372625,
0.4427777231,
-0.0999967307,
0.1279054135,
-0.5443378687,
-0.3116059899,
0.1329518706,
-0.2413998693,
0.0755657628,
0.2841010094,
0.0663303286,
0.3982880116,
0.4035549462,
-0.0220658835,
0.1166819111,
0.1215440705,
0.4064634442,
-0.476863116,
-0.1764380485,
-1.023697257,
0.9859176874,
0.1125919744,
-0.3804238737,
0.6496709585,
0.2849755883,
0.7729290128,
-0.2020016909,
0.5464825034,
0.0380734317,
0.288452208,
-0.5701247454,
0.5515457988,
-0.4841584861,
0.0947452337,
-0.2266016006,
-1.2357920408,
-0.155221954,
0.574167192,
-0.1087581664,
-0.0752024353,
0.8000581264,
0.6752026677,
-0.123063907,
0.0133853713,
0.284180522,
0.3918612599,
0.3227792978,
0.0608318485,
0.9170867205,
-0.4388674796,
0.5065175891,
-0.3865207136,
0.1553719938,
0.1208852679,
-1.1248483658,
-0.6914554238,
-0.7945013642,
-0.0334906504,
-0.3399215043,
-0.4443486333,
0.4353740513,
0.6879164577,
-0.8553705812,
-0.3560480773,
-0.5160704255,
0.0898811743,
-0.1985685527,
-0.3362226486,
-0.0068124053,
-0.5759884119,
-0.6615460515,
0.5400547981,
-0.0400072411,
0.1544790715,
-0.3383930922,
-0.0501314662,
0.1572635025,
-0.0513441153,
0.6970519423,
-0.0633419678,
-1.0482265949,
-0.3695220947,
0.0471648611,
-0.1128072739,
0.0206311215,
1.1467063427,
-0.8579357266,
0.2718485892,
0.621920228,
0.4762926102,
0.2285290956,
0.0440132506,
1.3537054062,
-0.8244988918,
0.0531036742,
-0.064216882,
0.6884030104,
0.4620135725,
-0.3704970777,
0.3715738952,
-0.1530065089,
-0.6310770512,
-0.6041764617,
0.5421566963,
-0.495734781,
-0.417706877,
0.8986224532,
0.1249471754,
-0.0456503779,
0.1134247556,
-0.0918500498,
0.4459417462,
0.0716363639,
0.6647216678,
0.7946567535,
-0.0137812886,
-0.1450585425,
-0.504755795,
0.6695231199,
0.5395111442,
-0.4900764823,
0.103862226,
0.3950619996,
0.1583873481,
0.4332675934,
0.0163977277,
0.0730427653,
0.0616339557,
-0.0353714637,
-0.0966729596,
0.3141780496,
-0.3156308234,
-0.39333269,
0.1874115318,
0.0280842464,
0.0911976248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12532v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12532v4 | Multilingual Simplification of Medical Texts | 2023-05-21T18:25:07 | 2023-10-18T04:20:05 | Sebastian Joseph, Kathryn Kazanas, Keziah Reina, Vishnesh J. Ramanathan, Wei Xu, Byron C. Wallace, Junyi Jessy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated text simplification aims to produce simple versions of complex
texts. This task is especially useful in the medical domain, where the latest
medical findings are typically communicated via complex and technical articles.
This creates barriers for laypeople seeking access to up-to-date medical
findings, consequently impeding progress on health literacy. Most existing work
on medical text simplification has focused on monolingual settings, with the
result that such evidence would be available only in just one language (most
often, English). This work addresses this limitation via multilingual
simplification, i.e., directly simplifying complex texts into simplified texts
in multiple languages. We introduce MultiCochrane, the first sentence-aligned
multilingual text simplification dataset for the medical domain in four
languages: English, Spanish, French, and Farsi. We evaluate fine-tuned and
zero-shot models across these languages, with extensive human assessments and
analyses. Although models can now generate viable simplified texts, we identify
outstanding challenges that this dataset might be used to address. | [
-0.0060216789,
-0.4265663326,
0.8234459162,
0.24412705,
-0.3753912449,
0.0773946196,
-0.2004000545,
-0.7679796815,
0.2661796808,
0.3161839247,
-0.7077228427,
-0.8933056593,
-0.6075863838,
0.4694623351,
0.1119166091,
1.1695426702,
-0.4335502684,
0.3365575671,
-0.0111656254,
-0.4161511362,
-0.2108825743,
-0.6716607213,
-0.2275049537,
-0.4512762129,
0.8556857705,
0.8173903227,
0.6011593342,
0.5474331379,
0.5805205107,
0.262725234,
-0.0200792942,
0.2369339466,
-0.1455931962,
0.0626569763,
0.2746861577,
-0.2186786085,
-0.4326570034,
-0.3251014054,
0.4910526276,
1.2314929962,
-0.056990955,
-0.0274520814,
-0.2117199153,
0.7581408024,
-0.5122593045,
0.1771634817,
-0.0326305591,
0.1481701434,
-0.2064810693,
-0.215258956,
-0.1414882988,
-0.3645190299,
0.1868112534,
-0.7115734816,
0.1301408708,
-0.045430351,
0.5632845759,
0.2561234236,
-0.9657732248,
-0.733009994,
-0.6165171266,
0.6924466491,
-0.5087242723,
0.3769255579,
0.1074831784,
0.2479418218,
0.0953681022,
-0.7198984027,
-0.2082418948,
-0.1429335177,
-0.3613949716,
0.1854120046,
-0.1986159384,
0.2284307331,
0.0933995917,
0.1563683599,
-0.7349357009,
0.0039227144,
-0.8478966355,
-0.3951938748,
0.5851412416,
0.0685543194,
0.5124269128,
-0.0671785101,
-0.259342432,
0.1057026163,
-0.5104984641,
-0.1010490358,
0.2262176573,
0.3900954127,
-0.2492156476,
0.600165844,
-0.2684598863,
0.3826836348,
-0.5546181202,
-0.301763773,
0.536485076,
-0.652510643,
-0.2446721047,
0.4834029078,
0.7092707157,
0.330655992,
0.1440575868,
-0.0775822848,
0.2478477806,
-0.0092169503,
0.1162464768,
-0.9360046387,
-0.0928145349,
0.7141628861,
-0.4638024569,
-0.2824601233,
-0.1591045856,
-0.6574152112,
-0.2205329537,
-0.0423781537,
0.0481277667,
-0.3951865733,
0.1512477398,
0.6916672587,
0.0317859538,
-0.2519422174,
0.447332561,
-0.4641360939,
0.3571504354,
0.2204920799,
0.728127718,
-0.04792789,
-0.5397596955,
-0.0291474741,
0.2507914603,
-0.3384339809,
0.747633636,
-0.2053204775,
-0.2051969469,
-0.039342314,
0.1613426656,
0.1244697049,
-0.4184632003,
0.9362541437,
0.0556729957,
0.1642238945,
-0.1258731335,
-0.4232898653,
-0.114689447,
0.0469571613,
-0.8088778853,
0.4517783523,
-0.2044312209,
-0.6033909917,
0.1933752745,
-0.6367542744,
-0.7428565025,
-0.0634449422,
-0.2604448795,
-0.5989813805,
0.0636030436,
0.2775601745,
0.155736059,
-0.3964141607,
0.2461496592,
-0.0497878194,
-0.1139258444,
-0.0834764913,
-0.5327595472,
0.7705768943,
0.3180136681,
-0.0644573793,
-0.0581597574,
-0.7264578938,
0.1000169739,
-0.0415349081,
-0.4012335539,
-0.4397338629,
-0.0777190179,
0.3126412034,
0.3985236585,
0.2504143417,
-0.7899181843,
0.2746086419,
-0.4097190797,
0.2759813666,
0.1555931717,
0.2458385974,
0.3329548538,
-0.4280021489,
0.678828001,
0.3692781925,
0.3215414882,
-0.5652199984,
-0.446934551,
-0.3013926148,
-0.562063098,
0.4851161242,
0.7300218344,
-0.5485942364,
-0.0382638387,
-0.268206656,
-0.4384658337,
-0.9191254973,
0.2197539508,
0.3768206239,
0.3982818425,
0.5792913437,
-0.0343849249,
-0.3478464484,
-1.1301234961,
-0.3428851068,
0.1901047379,
0.2435899675,
0.1771630347,
0.412727952,
-0.3227646947,
0.3078069389,
-0.6069603562,
-0.3809553683,
-0.1850331575,
0.2336073369,
0.0890729129,
0.5371636748,
0.4792376161,
-0.9295113683,
-0.5979138017,
0.4319008887,
-0.8480683565,
-0.312451005,
-0.1684343815,
0.1098014265,
-0.0202990621,
0.5521892309,
-0.3191830516,
0.5415693521,
0.8521277905,
-0.024252085,
0.3622053862,
-0.5330525637,
0.3022171855,
-1.0594031811,
0.1907686591,
-0.0876490623,
-0.3906023502,
-1.0290395021,
-0.0415689684,
0.2428489029,
-0.3115517795,
-0.519405961,
0.6574636102,
-0.6828073859,
0.5332585573,
-0.0420070328,
-0.0840649828,
0.0841054171,
0.2626115382,
-0.1214487031,
0.4588850737,
0.4507146776,
-0.4516427815,
0.0640286803,
0.266213119,
-0.1732784212,
0.3753632009,
-0.7789353728,
-0.3365737796,
-0.398787111,
0.3267934024,
-0.9582709074,
-0.5464242697,
0.0680248216,
-0.2246406674,
0.1044322848,
0.0103539973,
-0.263356328,
-0.3138430119,
-0.3818235695,
0.909599781,
0.0426384956,
-0.1388158649,
0.3224865496,
0.2992893159,
-0.6338784695,
-0.6089299321,
-1.0125236511,
0.0550808758,
0.1367172748,
-0.5247253776,
0.4239483178,
-0.360445112,
-0.174816072,
-0.2678259909,
-0.2800612748,
-0.4236311913,
-0.0630336627,
0.0818133205,
0.2220363468,
-0.0256759245,
0.403303653,
0.5569559932,
-0.1457966566,
-0.4536406398,
-0.0683408529,
0.2718224227,
0.0651640147,
-0.60847646,
-0.6638165116,
0.9875121713,
0.7398840189,
-0.1040842831,
0.5178076625,
0.2626802623,
-0.4540154934,
0.0675430074,
-0.3188048303,
-0.0527556092,
-0.3728224039,
0.2931414843,
-0.3756435215,
-0.8626004457,
0.5514811873,
-0.4036854506,
0.0815814659,
0.4255034924,
0.5928550959,
-0.173149541,
1.0178277493,
0.5548285246,
0.3385591209,
-0.1494067013,
0.2047008574,
0.2726765871,
-0.2925940454,
-0.2948395014,
-0.7093787789,
-0.1271736175,
-0.8506144285,
-0.3015883863,
0.6858831048,
0.1064614654,
0.1714558005,
0.1384550631,
-0.4600065053,
0.5592361093,
0.1849293113,
0.4353591502,
0.5524619818,
0.1582148373,
-0.3902949989,
-0.207149446,
-0.7875334024,
-0.563701272,
1.0471721888,
0.1952479482,
0.6994777918,
0.3444808722,
0.9723391533,
0.1689501703,
0.2428798378,
-0.754110992,
0.0462076366,
-0.4924558401,
-0.4909062386,
-0.0848010108,
-0.5121281147,
-1.1230338812,
0.0903217569,
-0.129921183,
-0.3120269179,
0.1371509135,
0.0129179368,
-0.3776968122,
-0.1087657213,
-1.0133060217,
0.7654201388,
-0.1751565784,
-0.0862793326,
0.0310282428,
-0.8637066483,
0.1541325599,
-0.333081007,
0.6167510152,
-0.0528783202,
-0.2142334282,
0.2201537788,
-0.6258997917,
0.7889651656,
0.190306142,
-0.2058698982,
-0.1228688285,
-0.0201214328,
0.1418130845,
0.0192697104,
-0.0466079377,
0.427957058,
0.2368273586,
-0.7687911987,
-0.3102288544,
0.5623310208,
-0.599914968,
-0.2874415815,
-0.474973768,
-0.5679054856,
-0.0340612605,
0.5043358207,
0.2759549618,
0.5085055232,
-0.393529892,
-0.1069774106,
0.299033314,
-0.486964047,
0.2509719729,
0.4768116474,
-0.0831246823,
-0.498036772,
0.6072371602,
0.2064685822,
0.3476691544,
0.3227712512,
0.1706941873,
-0.1548762918,
-0.4240472615,
-0.5570013523,
0.4991523325,
-0.819282949,
0.0219990872,
-0.728854239,
-0.0651427284,
-0.4917798638,
-0.2905219793,
-0.0563884191,
-0.7313463688,
0.0329797864,
0.0173185822,
-0.1208198592,
0.8952142596,
-0.0253208317,
0.1291149408,
-0.8720910549,
0.5478743911,
0.1337251365,
0.1717083305,
-0.4356517494,
-0.0074866158,
-0.2116815597,
0.0233921763,
-0.1013467386,
-1.1233391762,
0.1830558479,
0.225641638,
0.5394925475,
-0.0123939039,
-0.0902906656,
0.7537913918,
-0.9180817008,
0.5379351377,
0.4270683527,
-0.8712481856,
0.5359607935,
-0.1946537942,
0.6521300077,
0.7346107364,
0.6892802715,
-0.8517898917,
-0.3614210784,
-0.5175520778,
-0.9711347818,
0.5545599461,
0.2452487499,
-0.0504054874,
0.0830309838,
0.2130078673,
0.2682085931,
0.4625194073,
-0.6504822969,
-0.5656069517,
0.0501147658,
-0.7250123024,
-0.2868634462,
-0.130321756,
-0.349475354,
-0.3183253109,
0.4580236077,
-0.2886401415,
0.1205108315,
0.611446321,
-0.2621573806,
-0.0433550812,
0.6557489634,
1.1274403334,
0.5287039876,
0.1423874497,
0.1631667614,
0.0869543031,
-0.6260904074,
0.3292837441,
0.3250585198,
-0.1691682488,
0.4018158615,
0.5532742143,
0.5902922153,
0.1306440085,
-0.8611603975,
0.6170892119,
-0.1550999731,
-0.3486655951,
-0.0093907919,
-0.4051677883,
0.02103935,
-0.0224725734,
0.2176905721,
0.3053925037,
0.2574709952,
-0.5616170168,
0.3116094768,
0.0543253981,
-0.3787772059,
-0.3100033402,
0.4281072915,
0.0012300726,
-0.0881370679,
0.1047080681,
0.1686299443,
-0.3578214943,
0.6634097695,
0.3970865309,
0.4446944296,
-0.3449710906,
0.2744349837,
0.3750326633,
0.4696258307,
-0.0434071571,
0.506442368,
0.1033200547,
-0.4691184461,
-0.4368190765,
-0.3996642828,
-0.4663831592,
-0.2947414219,
-0.494176954,
0.4335142374,
-0.1235108301,
0.0087011997,
0.5318868756,
-0.1275961846,
-0.5727342367,
0.1797147095,
0.1401472986,
0.8533613682,
-0.9027886391,
0.8338692188,
0.9168302417,
-0.4743051231,
-0.6414605975,
0.020373838,
0.2036795765,
-0.5658887625,
0.41949597,
0.1749857515,
-0.2994795144,
-0.0566346869,
-0.4652859271,
-0.3547183871,
0.9564933181,
0.6523097754,
-0.5865055323,
-0.160977751,
0.6201661229,
0.8047987819,
-0.444448173,
0.2396631837,
0.2601174414,
0.6002965569,
-0.0571616068,
-1.0800858736,
-0.1448528171,
-0.2208396494,
-0.4129938483,
0.2158736587,
-0.5828477144,
1.0709385872,
-0.3851185143,
-0.081734404,
-0.0762488991,
0.037754152,
0.028979281,
0.5207067728,
0.1178389564,
0.3108286858,
1.0153595209,
-0.0527701229,
1.1106402874,
-0.4601740837,
0.4471354485,
1.021335125,
-0.5150532722,
0.5171109438,
0.6389276981,
0.1644753218,
0.6063454151,
0.3979277611,
0.4363082945,
0.4214238524,
0.0487949029,
-0.594389379,
-0.177134797,
-0.3004828393,
-0.150227353,
0.466958642,
0.2690053582,
-0.31926319,
-0.4208349884,
0.2860316336,
0.2992126048,
0.0748676658,
-0.2154352665,
0.8571776152,
0.0389983915,
-0.5452173948,
0.5259346366,
0.0622281767,
0.3012156487,
-0.751074791,
-0.129803881,
-0.1319301128,
0.177964434,
-0.3477369249,
-0.5275324583,
0.2761775851,
-0.0040837456,
-0.2799459398,
-0.1672734767,
0.621160686,
-0.8864388466,
-0.7369007468,
0.4965336323,
0.7417570353,
0.298507601,
0.1949031949,
-0.7186159492,
0.1350418627,
0.2002613395,
0.04822639,
-0.0438190065,
0.5178336501,
-0.1640997231,
0.6713261008,
0.5960193872,
0.3999797702,
0.1154375672,
0.2010817677,
0.7615464926,
-0.6777136922,
-0.4531511068,
-0.7924886346,
0.4500386417,
-0.0062768152,
-0.2834152877,
0.5392371416,
0.7297679186,
0.6553636789,
-0.0435537919,
0.9305773377,
0.1622018963,
0.4216995239,
-0.4565162659,
0.736523807,
-1.0406973362,
-0.0277187005,
-0.2019814253,
-0.2616370618,
-0.7396022081,
0.1979149431,
0.1465099454,
-0.0449052528,
1.2239149809,
0.5864240527,
-0.2494024336,
-0.0292502251,
0.5039682388,
0.1629205346,
0.0189153366,
0.5776132345,
0.1960671693,
-0.7179505229,
0.5575824976,
-0.3946144283,
-0.1431301534,
0.0076156049,
-0.7528583407,
-0.5493634343,
-0.4270797968,
-0.2802810371,
-0.1028785706,
0.08181642,
1.050070405,
0.6478287578,
-0.9400553703,
-0.179941684,
0.030603271,
0.0703213662,
-0.1939764917,
-0.0766139701,
0.2401045263,
-0.2678921521,
-0.7250796556,
0.4504778683,
0.542408824,
0.1662625372,
-0.1187902465,
-0.0627413914,
-0.3564019203,
0.1709042042,
0.5278265476,
0.1702469289,
-0.4930278063,
-0.0177959353,
0.1091356128,
-0.58963871,
0.3660301864,
1.062016964,
-0.3501800299,
0.7222056985,
0.2380117774,
0.4091887772,
0.3409541547,
-0.1364203542,
0.34814924,
-0.9565908909,
0.4420215487,
0.2665028274,
0.2879429162,
0.3151848018,
-0.226783216,
0.3601711392,
0.1316530854,
-0.4799876511,
-0.6735347509,
0.301253289,
-1.005317688,
-0.5749271512,
0.892947495,
-0.0902942792,
-0.2808380425,
-0.5746801496,
-0.4274448156,
0.3630663455,
-0.1513481587,
0.4775372446,
0.8804286718,
-0.0277375262,
-0.0953654051,
-0.7942869663,
0.6627815366,
0.5316696763,
-1.1892191172,
0.0148820765,
0.4783864021,
0.300737083,
0.3112268746,
0.9605014324,
-0.1630226225,
0.4409162998,
-0.2323259413,
0.4462876618,
0.202339679,
-0.5438855886,
-0.6537380815,
0.2965374291,
-0.1337009221,
0.2328348607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12524v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12524v3 | TheoremQA: A Theorem-driven Question Answering dataset | 2023-05-21T17:51:35 | 2023-12-06T03:02:45 | Wenhu Chen, Ming Yin, Max Ku, Pan Lu, Yixin Wan, Xueguang Ma, Jianyu Xu, Xinyi Wang, Tony Xia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The recent LLMs like GPT-4 and PaLM-2 have made tremendous progress in
solving fundamental math problems like GSM8K by achieving over 90% accuracy.
However, their capabilities to solve more challenging math problems which
require domain-specific knowledge (i.e. theorem) have yet to be investigated.
In this paper, we introduce TheoremQA, the first theorem-driven
question-answering dataset designed to evaluate AI models' capabilities to
apply theorems to solve challenging science problems. TheoremQA is curated by
domain experts containing 800 high-quality questions covering 350 theorems
(e.g. Taylor's theorem, Lagrange's theorem, Huffman coding, Quantum Theorem,
Elasticity Theorem, etc) from Math, Physics, EE&CS, and Finance. We evaluate a
wide spectrum of 16 large language and code models with different prompting
strategies like Chain-of-Thoughts and Program-of-Thoughts. We found that
GPT-4's capabilities to solve these problems are unparalleled, achieving an
accuracy of 51% with Program-of-Thoughts Prompting. All the existing
open-sourced models are below 15%, barely surpassing the random-guess baseline.
Given the diversity and broad coverage of TheoremQA, we believe it can be used
as a better benchmark to evaluate LLMs' capabilities to solve challenging
science problems. The data and code are released in
https://github.com/wenhuchen/TheoremQA. | [
-0.2472673059,
-0.6422555447,
0.8054822683,
0.1615105569,
-0.1429925263,
0.2414856255,
0.334010154,
-0.0147100948,
-0.2032891661,
0.3637098074,
-0.7723380327,
-0.5728139877,
-0.504912734,
0.1111259088,
-0.5120767951,
0.8003068566,
0.022529209,
0.2575546205,
-0.6416427493,
0.0306739807,
-0.3885433376,
-0.3677048683,
-0.0757014528,
-0.1883544475,
0.1162036732,
0.2534448802,
0.6184529066,
0.3586905897,
0.5826678276,
0.1870117188,
-0.0649072453,
0.2517179251,
-0.2615729868,
-0.0237858053,
-0.184398815,
-0.681841135,
-0.3699838221,
-0.0885672048,
0.3958090544,
0.6198927164,
0.0290747117,
0.4738049507,
-0.1278203875,
0.5559478402,
-0.3709165156,
0.3379603624,
-0.7685279846,
-0.0149331018,
0.0636277869,
-0.1375733316,
-0.1546068937,
-0.7326211929,
0.3734016418,
-0.7798467875,
-0.1002741084,
-0.1304837614,
0.5370131731,
0.6085859537,
-0.2782115042,
-0.5335839987,
-0.2197293937,
0.8056146502,
-0.5182564259,
0.306016326,
0.3551892638,
0.3448548019,
-0.1225635335,
-0.694996655,
-0.6704602242,
0.1966781467,
0.4672341347,
0.0913213864,
-0.1479983777,
-0.3696023524,
0.0670511872,
0.2005053014,
-0.7341448665,
-0.1193808019,
-0.5260180235,
-0.3324969411,
0.418133527,
0.3300460279,
0.0567832403,
-0.3546095788,
-0.1643716097,
0.0511734411,
-0.7886618376,
0.1388479918,
0.1414733529,
0.0604704954,
0.2298796475,
0.856361568,
-0.2338675708,
0.7950391769,
-0.2195329666,
-0.125472486,
-0.0314087905,
-0.4051184058,
-0.1664209664,
-0.2132811397,
0.4287388623,
-0.002170345,
0.2676774859,
0.0898931175,
0.0194360651,
-0.2646917999,
-0.0413879752,
-0.7970587015,
-0.5090719461,
0.6034088731,
0.1011822373,
-0.1339076608,
-0.0450996011,
-0.5915914774,
-0.6186316609,
-0.3524202108,
0.7196165323,
-0.5662046075,
-0.0366241001,
0.3524834216,
0.0358032063,
0.4774778187,
0.5016565323,
-0.3849959373,
0.1962918639,
1.1043884754,
0.8667114377,
-0.1479463577,
-0.2072438151,
-0.4003243148,
-0.1683682203,
-0.4298783243,
0.705947876,
-0.3921042085,
-0.2573049068,
-0.2246707529,
-0.4825493395,
0.0197390672,
-0.660326004,
0.5705965757,
-0.8614801168,
0.3483294845,
-0.5563301444,
-0.8319010735,
-0.2326224595,
0.2927241027,
-0.4311582148,
0.8178094029,
0.1680839658,
-0.7992339134,
0.2671138644,
-0.9184433222,
0.0822853521,
0.1938672215,
-0.2188187689,
-0.3277389407,
-0.2666558623,
0.6197513938,
0.2765069604,
-0.6797253489,
0.2565844059,
0.0516796596,
-0.3343704343,
0.5061989427,
-0.141582936,
0.9239137173,
0.2972429097,
-0.1294411421,
-0.0251545887,
-0.5402618051,
0.5410952568,
0.2242795974,
0.0523314849,
-0.1461709589,
-0.2971494496,
-0.6320771575,
0.0940898657,
0.4353401065,
-0.4831266999,
0.1327459812,
-0.3128843009,
0.6209549308,
0.9716943502,
0.2532996535,
0.0347053818,
-0.3973626494,
0.7926116586,
0.0507339165,
0.0014550976,
-0.0005229444,
-0.7448688149,
-0.5328691006,
-0.5608984828,
0.6241340041,
0.7279325128,
-0.7209640145,
0.2705043256,
-0.2341841459,
-0.5521003604,
-0.6527485847,
0.0356947444,
0.2272756994,
0.7163844705,
0.4391057491,
-0.1830040067,
-0.2371197492,
-0.7692941427,
-0.3376407623,
-0.3339956105,
-0.2294461876,
0.4282338917,
0.6541760564,
-0.1163195372,
1.2477205992,
-0.6513301134,
0.1602462828,
0.0661902949,
-0.0952137262,
0.2938802242,
0.0501160361,
0.1401235312,
-0.7696321011,
-0.2225701213,
-0.27997756,
-0.8469053507,
-0.2520880997,
0.283988148,
-0.2259587198,
-0.1156681031,
-0.1556271762,
-0.7573130727,
0.4049409032,
0.3569927216,
-0.2235074639,
0.7837767005,
0.1376252919,
0.1496813148,
-0.8887405396,
0.1522994339,
-0.0361727178,
-0.1272806227,
-0.4334969521,
0.1382794082,
0.033165168,
-0.2515511513,
-0.4764828682,
0.4823349118,
-0.0671761781,
-0.3910346925,
-0.0676734373,
0.1029644012,
0.1077065244,
0.2083063424,
-0.1725683659,
1.2193061113,
0.7624849081,
-0.7417666912,
0.5964398384,
0.8029148579,
-0.6270549893,
0.4085707963,
-0.8431933522,
0.4645551145,
-0.0036646472,
0.0405451097,
-0.7367103696,
-0.181040585,
0.2107453644,
-0.5254702568,
-0.4555779994,
-0.0837114006,
-0.5663430691,
-0.518848896,
-0.2036664188,
0.4155113101,
0.5496090651,
-0.5685090423,
0.2751162946,
0.2201715112,
-0.4810431898,
-0.8706001639,
-0.4830463529,
-0.1505750567,
-0.2815074325,
-0.6220202446,
-0.0507356077,
-0.29826352,
-0.3191840351,
-0.0112710716,
-0.3037252128,
-0.2889439166,
-0.0249899626,
0.0416984372,
0.3111508787,
-0.0418197811,
0.1043248326,
0.0161432605,
0.0386334807,
0.3553180695,
-0.8253328204,
0.5208172202,
-0.3829319179,
-0.4943165481,
-0.4388835132,
-0.0237432737,
0.4764168561,
-0.4011054635,
0.4869702756,
0.017219061,
-0.398339808,
-0.2312495708,
-0.0866373032,
-0.0857736766,
-0.515411675,
0.5176454186,
-0.7645021677,
-0.7922596335,
0.4502306283,
-0.1783106476,
0.0061265482,
0.3350389004,
0.745213747,
0.0114921285,
0.560590446,
0.3655777872,
-0.2085836828,
-0.2073991746,
-0.373262614,
0.323240906,
-0.5045181513,
-0.3505935073,
-0.4511467516,
0.1578611434,
-0.3296537101,
-0.697080195,
0.7787874937,
-0.0129388114,
-0.5116549134,
0.2922573984,
-0.5899059176,
0.5287917852,
0.61944592,
0.220910266,
0.5675783157,
-0.0942162946,
-0.2018589824,
-0.0690921992,
-0.7330254912,
-0.5075999498,
1.4118961096,
0.369668901,
0.627255559,
0.1978861541,
0.5884495974,
0.3667013347,
0.0477441289,
-0.7511063218,
0.7295486331,
0.4116425216,
-0.7407522202,
-0.4909315705,
-0.7248681188,
-0.6491681933,
-0.034140259,
0.2309185117,
-0.5665742159,
-0.1369465142,
0.0421582907,
-0.3849106133,
0.288975805,
-0.3441568911,
0.725248754,
-0.2767392695,
-0.3288411498,
-0.0727451742,
-0.4907756746,
0.4699888825,
-0.4861566722,
0.0867199749,
-0.0680417642,
-0.0874513835,
0.7811581492,
-0.5358073711,
0.3485447466,
-0.263620317,
-0.2999059856,
0.9055029154,
0.3164223135,
0.2915584147,
0.2733896077,
-0.2466508001,
-0.0644245893,
0.5398770571,
-0.6633492112,
-0.716761291,
0.493875742,
-0.872906208,
-0.6838465929,
-0.5445699692,
-0.6375082731,
-0.5044398308,
0.1734631062,
0.117387183,
0.3925813735,
0.0212233979,
-0.2114595324,
0.8048320413,
-0.3072562814,
-0.0990129709,
0.3345346153,
-0.3431220353,
-0.2888714373,
1.0537604094,
-0.0428467132,
0.134884119,
0.1484223604,
0.0832140371,
-0.6414861679,
-0.674407661,
-0.5039073229,
0.1623417735,
-0.9463918805,
-0.4868421257,
-0.5356820822,
-0.3507761955,
-0.2304019481,
0.2720457315,
-0.2471262068,
-0.7989787459,
-0.1493780464,
-0.1271935701,
0.5285180211,
0.7977865934,
0.020828668,
-0.1852684915,
-0.5409652591,
0.3135736287,
0.6248173714,
0.2012280673,
-0.362278372,
-0.6142203212,
0.0221126117,
0.0713720694,
-0.4057473838,
-0.7923881412,
0.3089051247,
0.1591020525,
0.2014227957,
-0.037830431,
0.2042581737,
0.4423593879,
-0.2453911901,
0.7007741928,
-0.1503116339,
-1.1765128374,
0.4743550718,
-0.2673063576,
0.1381850392,
0.427905947,
0.643394351,
-0.1710468233,
-0.0675670952,
-0.3886337876,
-0.2876015604,
0.3047001064,
0.2769307792,
-0.1586983949,
0.3745590448,
0.795738101,
0.390915215,
0.5670016408,
-0.4218397737,
-0.2042236626,
-0.4412125349,
-0.3887488544,
0.3317673504,
0.0923501626,
-0.2152744681,
-0.412284255,
0.6075029969,
-0.3453648388,
0.5623905659,
0.252897203,
-0.0902907327,
0.039535597,
0.2735455334,
0.369576931,
1.1520922184,
-0.1777433753,
-0.0711428449,
0.120772481,
-0.4969646633,
0.269554317,
0.3473307192,
-0.3453089893,
-0.3722711802,
0.0339270644,
0.3003656864,
-0.6233380437,
-1.0474170446,
0.4187009633,
-0.015413654,
-0.4382976592,
-0.3423248231,
0.2661811411,
0.0492685772,
0.2307066768,
0.8228564262,
-0.0974017382,
0.2768990695,
-0.4532404542,
0.4235953391,
0.5262914896,
-0.0972959176,
-0.3537586033,
0.8378010392,
-0.1253093332,
-0.1266181469,
0.4756645858,
-0.2952277958,
-0.9615280032,
0.8086723685,
0.2310240865,
0.3598426878,
0.199089542,
0.4587377012,
0.3194529116,
0.1394960433,
0.3139546216,
0.5553875566,
0.0381116122,
-0.6838470101,
-0.5222314,
-0.4191961586,
-1.1233359575,
0.102118507,
-0.423714757,
0.1275619119,
-0.6224744916,
-0.0090356385,
0.0038942338,
0.4542633891,
-0.7024424076,
0.2779144645,
-0.2352797687,
1.0242854357,
-0.3791766167,
0.670317471,
0.5502376556,
0.048140198,
-0.7695396543,
0.0165245235,
0.1388306469,
-0.862944901,
0.4948200285,
-0.0524446294,
-0.135470584,
0.3281221092,
-0.9805037379,
-0.8206501603,
1.2656797171,
0.2697409689,
-0.1539749801,
0.2519451082,
0.412091285,
0.3853414357,
-0.3363491893,
0.1764096916,
0.6756814718,
0.5378938317,
0.2036274672,
-0.8620402813,
-0.1652286053,
-0.2172274888,
-0.5536933541,
-0.1237859875,
-0.675362587,
0.8767498732,
-0.4229943752,
0.0844906941,
0.4671111405,
0.8496092558,
0.7019978762,
0.6014314294,
0.2128798664,
0.4404636323,
1.3179095984,
-0.1323614568,
0.8333160281,
-0.2892085314,
0.3180909753,
0.7634636164,
-0.4300014377,
0.4981884062,
0.1743731946,
-0.5264323354,
0.4838765562,
0.7114161849,
0.0803385153,
0.6776223183,
0.6062368155,
-0.3306748867,
-0.1546464413,
0.0023667263,
-0.3702443242,
0.3906058371,
0.3836463392,
0.2372442186,
0.1118812785,
-0.1609618664,
-0.2647657394,
0.0317358188,
-0.2688480616,
0.3631313443,
0.0339008793,
-0.5609617829,
0.6339178085,
0.0954899564,
0.2899191082,
-0.4328761101,
0.0355638862,
-0.3190065622,
-0.1232372448,
-0.013827269,
-0.8782691956,
0.0278600603,
0.193371743,
0.1472471654,
0.3626098633,
0.4082043469,
-0.0881357044,
-0.4836607575,
-0.3427107036,
1.006008029,
0.245802924,
0.0179830827,
-0.7171767354,
-0.2823349237,
0.0490500666,
-0.0291181765,
0.0506356545,
0.6014476418,
0.1155680045,
1.1965434551,
0.5071720481,
-0.1603375226,
0.2821550369,
-0.335422039,
1.0947388411,
-0.6395340562,
-0.3586776555,
-0.4227598011,
0.222634539,
0.2148789614,
-0.3514702618,
0.7305425406,
0.5173885822,
0.516431272,
0.0007357479,
1.0104233027,
-0.0103698345,
0.819540143,
-0.4951040745,
0.3519426584,
-0.4111071825,
0.5139585137,
-0.259857446,
-0.8627108335,
-0.3142878711,
0.4461705983,
-0.597268939,
0.1088954359,
0.5407493711,
0.7500383854,
0.0285589136,
0.2446360886,
0.1891667992,
0.0407307036,
0.3568985462,
0.8498939872,
1.0957651138,
-0.4668012857,
0.5838346481,
-0.1233134791,
-0.1591133922,
0.2416184992,
-0.6390073299,
-0.8740170002,
-0.5215787888,
-0.3880014122,
-0.4652048647,
0.1268692315,
0.8681676984,
0.516479969,
-0.9011956453,
0.1908179522,
-0.2415461242,
0.1229598969,
0.0402069725,
-0.2186009288,
0.5861338377,
0.14795807,
-0.7099867463,
0.4778439105,
0.0481337495,
-0.0256789494,
-0.3999664187,
-0.2561761439,
0.1503683627,
0.4394190907,
0.1985162646,
0.3976734281,
-0.3467253447,
-0.1295339763,
0.4559548199,
-0.0166561306,
0.1296633631,
0.6936286092,
-0.8468039036,
0.2265121788,
0.2142771631,
1.0498194695,
0.4458864033,
0.3887346685,
0.3178970814,
-0.4089865685,
-0.0253286958,
0.5857595205,
0.0533445626,
0.3324947953,
-0.279217273,
0.5601417422,
0.186763078,
-0.7247357965,
-0.6942654252,
0.2547948062,
-0.7010498643,
-0.309061259,
0.7970122099,
-0.124588944,
-0.1629588902,
-0.1594085693,
-0.0710659549,
-0.1208248883,
-0.2148577124,
0.7555458546,
0.6875700355,
-0.3279743195,
-0.3918742239,
-0.6486893296,
0.5096036196,
0.8479159474,
-0.8383378386,
-0.1632414907,
0.4459834099,
0.3133881986,
-0.0578628816,
0.569591403,
-0.1212205142,
0.3637619615,
-0.2339560986,
-0.3144088984,
-0.2411864847,
-0.4263702929,
-0.2320954204,
0.2382626235,
0.2521961331,
-0.0665303841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12519v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12519v3 | DPIC: Decoupling Prompt and Intrinsic Characteristics for LLM Generated Text Detection | 2023-05-21T17:26:16 | 2024-06-12T07:37:35 | Xiao Yu, Yuang Qi, Kejiang Chen, Guoqiang Chen, Xi Yang, Pengyuan Zhu, Xiuwei Shang, Weiming Zhang, Nenghai Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have the potential to generate texts that pose
risks of misuse, such as plagiarism, planting fake reviews on e-commerce
platforms, or creating inflammatory false tweets. Consequently, detecting
whether a text is generated by LLMs has become increasingly important. Existing
high-quality detection methods usually require access to the interior of the
model to extract the intrinsic characteristics. However, since we do not have
access to the interior of the black-box model, we must resort to surrogate
models, which impacts detection quality. In order to achieve high-quality
detection of black-box models, we would like to extract deep intrinsic
characteristics of the black-box model generated texts. We view the generation
process as a coupled process of prompt and intrinsic characteristics of the
generative model. Based on this insight, we propose to decouple prompt and
intrinsic characteristics (DPIC) for LLM-generated text detection method.
Specifically, given a candidate text, DPIC employs an auxiliary LLM to
reconstruct the prompt corresponding to the candidate text, then uses the
prompt to regenerate text by the auxiliary LLM, which makes the candidate text
and the regenerated text align with their prompts, respectively. Then, the
similarity between the candidate text and the regenerated text is used as a
detection feature, thus eliminating the prompt in the detection process, which
allows the detector to focus on the intrinsic characteristics of the generative
model. Compared to the baselines, DPIC has achieved an average improvement of
6.76\% and 2.91\% in detecting texts from different domains generated by GPT4
and Claude3, respectively. | [
-0.4601135254,
-1.1307185888,
0.7931903601,
-0.117477484,
-0.6274084449,
0.3371625841,
-0.2061573267,
-0.6253609061,
-0.0731769949,
0.5190597773,
-0.6708679199,
-0.5142604113,
-0.3403206468,
0.553894341,
-0.4932180345,
0.9415765405,
0.0413416103,
-0.4795800745,
-0.2300859094,
0.1756872386,
-0.5281696916,
-0.551451385,
-0.6454692483,
-0.1374259293,
0.1631813198,
0.1652309448,
0.2291157544,
0.3383967578,
0.3135513663,
0.3292685449,
-0.4214813709,
0.3726816475,
-0.4799591601,
0.4609011114,
-0.261531055,
-0.2540951371,
-0.462205261,
0.0672453642,
0.8335087895,
0.2234182954,
0.3276201487,
-0.0543524101,
0.3311730921,
0.4461467862,
-0.145129025,
0.1459183693,
-0.7879321575,
-0.1675604731,
-0.172715649,
-0.6466579437,
-0.4985614121,
-0.4343520999,
-0.1221622303,
-0.3274144232,
0.6254084706,
0.105454661,
1.0043762922,
0.0919045359,
-0.4433408678,
-0.2385935038,
-0.8679934144,
0.6859989166,
-0.7228488922,
0.0042524026,
0.1414630413,
0.0899427012,
-0.2339621037,
-0.5297936797,
-0.8802942038,
-0.4005877972,
-0.2762661874,
0.1635855585,
-0.3773453832,
-0.1026312783,
0.3916749656,
0.7179123759,
-0.3955506086,
0.4183840752,
-0.1167473048,
-0.3070857823,
0.6145013571,
0.3152672052,
0.5057129264,
-0.3137435019,
-0.4507571459,
0.0935538113,
-0.9374933243,
0.0758268461,
0.5325571299,
0.1904923469,
-0.0897376388,
0.3940296769,
-0.1907883584,
0.4851364195,
0.3599145412,
-0.517531991,
0.3386220336,
-0.6043705344,
0.1231360957,
0.0905915573,
0.921012342,
0.2275971621,
0.1352715045,
0.1751586646,
-0.5607168674,
0.0249537863,
0.0823475718,
-0.9272578359,
-0.0818758905,
0.1802573651,
-0.6312570572,
-0.5921126604,
-0.080551438,
-0.5420022011,
-0.3379594684,
-0.4175097048,
-0.0502171814,
-0.476287812,
-0.4922815263,
-0.2689526379,
-0.1120770201,
0.127617836,
0.535735786,
-0.7074133754,
-0.0125112478,
0.7112849951,
0.81357342,
-0.5124399066,
-0.0584741943,
-0.5771650672,
-0.1217690483,
-0.1807126701,
1.0110750198,
-0.5186065435,
-0.3886027336,
-0.150230512,
0.0642887801,
0.3099429011,
-0.5860732198,
0.9246108532,
-0.4777771831,
0.1371262074,
-0.2575097978,
-0.532148242,
-0.0699065328,
0.4246723056,
-0.7206756473,
1.2141737938,
0.2249661684,
-1.0347709656,
0.4825212657,
-0.3048107028,
-0.3568471968,
0.4733657837,
-0.2156121433,
-0.6799231172,
0.3721576035,
0.6049307585,
0.505769074,
-0.4283678234,
0.5277083516,
-0.3550422788,
-0.5202220678,
0.5837293863,
-0.868468225,
0.8419879675,
0.1593870074,
-0.2333804667,
0.1372555494,
-0.765308857,
-0.4822390378,
0.0408121087,
-0.5098444223,
-0.3130720854,
-0.111152418,
0.0603544153,
0.2078999579,
0.164848879,
-0.6493504643,
0.266443491,
-0.4527462721,
0.3332428038,
0.9179586172,
0.4005165398,
0.2078634053,
-0.2397361398,
0.6543997526,
0.259188056,
-0.1587846428,
-0.4992639124,
-0.5150561333,
-0.4104348421,
-0.6751309037,
0.1469372213,
0.5033910275,
-0.973148644,
0.7998655438,
-0.1133329272,
-0.1673654467,
-0.293480128,
0.1306907982,
0.2957089245,
0.8628379107,
-0.0241596811,
0.0512862056,
-0.208623752,
-0.7121321559,
0.0146802031,
-0.3444675505,
-0.1487895846,
0.2561902404,
0.4992628098,
-0.102073133,
0.9285900593,
-0.5599959493,
-0.1292417049,
-0.5605980158,
-0.0338850245,
0.5702143312,
0.2746138871,
0.7080584168,
-0.6522926688,
-0.5096288323,
-0.0270902719,
-0.7739921212,
-0.6036199927,
-0.1900432706,
0.0080282884,
0.2950253487,
0.476305902,
-0.7032982111,
0.4945294559,
0.1256496459,
-0.3865731061,
1.0458261967,
-0.1390540302,
0.341496706,
-1.0894722939,
0.212235719,
0.1795505583,
-0.2913552523,
-0.6430863142,
0.1740133166,
0.1753599197,
-0.1873139739,
-0.4085797369,
0.7512986064,
-0.6232260466,
0.1799870133,
-0.549130559,
0.2872575819,
0.3263219297,
0.3799559474,
0.0562017597,
1.0693842173,
0.541349113,
-0.779961288,
0.518961668,
0.1851032674,
-0.290055424,
0.9429838061,
-0.6861066818,
-0.1145287603,
-0.144171834,
0.2439202666,
-1.1914958954,
0.0371192545,
0.4756864309,
-0.4457155466,
0.3851850331,
-0.1327701062,
-0.6809518337,
-0.4097414613,
-0.4857185483,
0.3473528326,
0.5806133747,
-0.7249602675,
0.4743744433,
0.1847091764,
-0.5069482327,
-0.3348628283,
-0.3463057578,
0.117089808,
-0.3660670519,
-0.4789783359,
0.5850471854,
0.0053893174,
-0.0798746273,
0.0139856469,
0.1111997366,
0.1953950822,
0.2002411783,
0.128377229,
0.6007182598,
-0.1900475323,
0.1625907123,
0.4447327554,
-0.2731651068,
0.0493131876,
-0.0775930285,
0.5273023844,
0.2971673906,
-0.1025179401,
-0.6445320845,
0.3706819713,
0.5307807326,
-0.3178657293,
0.4374033213,
0.7059895396,
-0.288823843,
-0.2957319319,
-0.4608213902,
-0.3151963651,
-0.5132440329,
0.1691296101,
-0.5436726213,
-0.7502911687,
0.6111935377,
0.0285426993,
-0.0739161149,
0.4645111263,
0.7289214134,
0.057083562,
0.8540558815,
0.6089080572,
0.0161715634,
0.5663641691,
-0.0638096184,
0.2962200344,
-1.1380690336,
-0.1249781698,
-0.4767788947,
-0.1624625325,
-0.4769071341,
-0.0516529717,
0.2704760134,
0.2493240535,
0.1347733885,
0.1457939148,
-0.6424508691,
0.403903693,
0.6289508939,
0.4030133486,
0.5692712665,
0.2058160454,
-0.282568574,
0.0145870876,
-0.133724004,
-0.6134180427,
0.9104169011,
0.3119108081,
0.7715594172,
-0.0179936402,
0.7307059169,
0.3044979274,
0.3002571762,
-0.6909786463,
0.7393339276,
0.0099978549,
-0.3944722116,
0.0058492655,
-0.6361002922,
-0.8822330236,
0.0768257752,
-0.2426605225,
-0.832152307,
0.1661918312,
0.2005140483,
-0.1382626295,
0.3061405718,
-0.3835661411,
0.5007174015,
-0.1675126851,
-0.3306319118,
-0.0559801906,
-0.0543379709,
0.5952243805,
-0.1200450137,
-0.2991847992,
-0.3507418334,
0.0731591582,
0.414826721,
-0.2276034504,
0.9813711643,
-0.0500778742,
-0.487016052,
0.3730413318,
0.232182458,
0.6488568187,
0.4501580298,
0.0385567211,
0.044236552,
-0.4366136193,
-0.129875496,
-0.4955881238,
0.844014287,
-0.5320519805,
-0.8560569286,
-0.3161761463,
-0.4181462228,
0.2602593303,
0.3313530982,
0.4481062591,
0.7498371005,
-0.1704366505,
-0.1051722914,
0.6140559316,
-0.4966018796,
0.7244787812,
0.5007894635,
-0.2450021505,
-0.4180760682,
0.9108478427,
-0.3154190779,
0.1100353673,
0.5426384211,
0.2665186524,
-0.6065429449,
-0.9010978341,
-0.4388014376,
0.2286022156,
-0.681304276,
-0.3628995121,
-0.7748660445,
-0.3175198138,
-0.3343351781,
0.0358912833,
0.1357664019,
-0.2554797828,
-0.8137603998,
-0.2286571711,
0.5324774981,
0.4970715046,
0.2429846674,
0.1690994501,
-0.8690242767,
0.631991148,
0.0717539564,
0.1031613722,
0.0120244129,
-0.7626405954,
0.1755521297,
-0.1380870342,
-0.4865613878,
-0.9377673268,
0.6085449457,
0.0483616665,
0.6845296025,
0.5049273372,
0.3944411576,
0.1906621903,
-0.2294932604,
0.7378081679,
0.1261686534,
-0.9949073792,
0.7778590322,
-0.3639905751,
0.2272855043,
0.2570109367,
0.0887681469,
-0.2362981141,
-0.79100281,
-0.4381532669,
-0.7619036436,
0.6944423914,
0.3478407264,
0.1518802047,
-0.0944908634,
0.4618926644,
0.3410210907,
0.1959869117,
-0.8210246563,
-0.0981416255,
-0.0125879627,
-0.3342857063,
0.0141807785,
-0.5022833347,
0.0235092659,
-0.0579997934,
0.3290683031,
-0.0870330781,
0.1910552382,
0.1275081038,
-0.234826535,
0.2202681005,
0.2895559669,
0.486479044,
0.4669564068,
-0.1576616913,
0.2296646833,
-0.0256823543,
-0.574801147,
0.46226722,
0.0984823257,
-0.575217247,
0.0118396999,
0.5985049605,
0.7193084955,
-0.2122533172,
-0.5713903904,
0.4961209893,
-0.1195866242,
0.0362492539,
-0.1843592823,
0.1688887328,
-0.3431537449,
0.0709514096,
0.66559273,
-0.0384603254,
0.3217997849,
-0.571424365,
0.3670528233,
0.3940747976,
-0.1449728012,
-0.5575111508,
0.5057578683,
0.6818577647,
-0.3050516546,
0.6430691481,
-0.5406420231,
-0.7970966101,
0.5789403915,
0.8342636228,
1.1527136564,
0.0678572953,
0.2019533813,
0.4428018034,
0.3130895793,
0.2014515251,
0.0980104506,
-0.1500956714,
-0.7645041943,
-0.4530504942,
-0.6320378184,
-0.2086039782,
0.2120526731,
-0.3760595024,
0.4388391972,
-0.3602953553,
-0.0712964907,
-0.1208330318,
0.1608377397,
-0.5519318581,
-0.0749555826,
0.0601168685,
0.6525599957,
-0.9588991404,
0.635025084,
0.3908341527,
-0.3560588062,
-0.4536733031,
0.2475922406,
0.0531396344,
-0.5589069128,
0.6213489771,
0.5384603143,
0.1273539811,
0.0043208757,
-0.2681574523,
-0.5030864477,
0.9882435799,
0.4535933435,
-0.6323048472,
0.1330624521,
-0.1282042861,
0.4470664859,
-0.4477066696,
0.4456014037,
0.6664809585,
0.3341417611,
0.0586080588,
-0.6956532001,
0.6231560707,
-0.3651726544,
-0.038037397,
0.2853882611,
-0.2776935101,
0.8478395939,
-0.1448058337,
-0.794844985,
0.0272882376,
0.3788996935,
0.6097891331,
0.2873037159,
0.2774038613,
0.4527387619,
0.7513540387,
-0.2153199464,
1.0212278366,
-0.3364927769,
0.3291174471,
0.6885040998,
-0.3548325598,
0.4907926321,
0.2416409701,
-0.0885366425,
0.3968108594,
0.6057805419,
-0.1058970168,
0.3629637659,
0.0324677527,
-0.4724834263,
-0.0832979232,
-0.0595990233,
-0.3992759585,
0.2334717661,
0.3850158155,
-0.4455527067,
-0.259950459,
0.0941075981,
-0.147579506,
0.1065793261,
-0.2468570471,
0.8503596783,
-0.0465163849,
-0.6558024883,
0.6754806638,
-0.1061591804,
0.882871151,
-0.1199735925,
-0.2499585748,
-0.4590241015,
0.1622126102,
-0.0974686444,
-1.0515700579,
0.1733486056,
0.0900033489,
-0.3091133237,
-0.1214632839,
1.0082600117,
-0.3459851444,
-0.6173254251,
0.1486720443,
0.3936683238,
0.0694274157,
-0.2129693478,
-0.5714088082,
0.2267831564,
0.0048640333,
-0.1494289339,
0.0081850197,
0.7665064931,
0.0885193124,
0.6375756264,
0.8907942772,
0.1686150432,
-0.2554180026,
0.1952195615,
1.0610444546,
-0.7986499667,
-0.6074542403,
-1.1921247244,
0.5600025654,
-0.4242543578,
-0.3610928953,
0.6869725585,
0.3739004731,
0.4703796506,
-0.1711878031,
0.7268341184,
0.0691879615,
0.5297980309,
-0.8302909136,
0.5472710729,
-0.2625433505,
0.7159235477,
-0.415577054,
-1.1388486624,
-0.0184691977,
0.2334623337,
-0.0436070524,
-0.0610913858,
0.8092765808,
0.835273385,
-0.1013324261,
-0.3734848499,
0.2849162221,
0.0456984974,
0.7082190514,
0.399289012,
1.1453846693,
-0.1954543442,
0.6341714859,
-0.1352790743,
-0.4974227846,
-0.3384130597,
-1.035503149,
-1.3075834513,
-0.4994892478,
-0.5686320662,
-0.2745003402,
-0.3549144864,
0.4406152666,
0.4292967916,
-0.7616993189,
0.2550635934,
-0.1721815616,
0.457461834,
-0.2612664104,
-0.3772427142,
0.3533370495,
-0.1943665892,
-0.8677199483,
0.2759265304,
0.5988707542,
0.3518375754,
-0.3047824204,
0.1773038656,
0.1143487021,
0.0645921454,
0.6390594244,
0.0430095308,
-0.8739181757,
-0.2792728841,
-0.0301920641,
-0.166705966,
0.014759847,
0.8924480677,
-0.8455027342,
0.2149148881,
0.7348783016,
0.4226590395,
0.3045467734,
0.2305666059,
0.6315209866,
-0.9370535612,
0.1966213882,
0.183073625,
0.4733906686,
0.3879203498,
-0.7074574232,
0.235747695,
0.4476008415,
-0.4888422489,
-1.0933564901,
0.5661118031,
-1.0581262112,
-0.3184457719,
1.1278373003,
-0.2506426275,
-0.1464872807,
-0.1921819746,
-0.6279556155,
0.054661043,
-0.6639316678,
0.7664089203,
0.3716169894,
0.0246860683,
-0.5317796469,
-0.0490378477,
0.3497271538,
-0.1455256641,
-0.8821521997,
0.2774434984,
0.5649752617,
0.2589404881,
0.0561921857,
0.6899235249,
-0.0911040828,
0.2689973712,
0.0105070639,
-0.0041046371,
-0.2794611752,
-0.3101018071,
-0.3473209739,
0.032778699,
0.0514511503,
-0.1571926475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12518v1 | VAKTA-SETU: A Speech-to-Speech Machine Translation Service in Select Indic Languages | 2023-05-21T17:23:54 | 2023-05-21T17:23:54 | Shivam Mhaskar, Vineet Bhat, Akshay Batheja, Sourabh Deoghare, Paramveer Choudhary, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we present our deployment-ready Speech-to-Speech Machine
Translation (SSMT) system for English-Hindi, English-Marathi, and Hindi-Marathi
language pairs. We develop the SSMT system by cascading Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR), Disfluency Correction (DC), Machine Translation (MT), and
Text-to-Speech Synthesis (TTS) models. We discuss the challenges faced during
the research and development stage and the scalable deployment of the SSMT
system as a publicly accessible web service. On the MT part of the pipeline
too, we create a Text-to-Text Machine Translation (TTMT) service in all six
translation directions involving English, Hindi, and Marathi. To mitigate data
scarcity, we develop a LaBSE-based corpus filtering tool to select high-quality
parallel sentences from a noisy pseudo-parallel corpus for training the TTMT
system. All the data used for training the SSMT and TTMT systems and the best
models are being made publicly available. Users of our system are (a) Govt. of
India in the context of its new education policy (NEP), (b) tourists who
criss-cross the multilingual landscape of India, (c) Indian Judiciary where a
leading cause of the pendency of cases (to the order of 10 million as on date)
is the translation of case papers, (d) farmers who need weather and price
information and so on. We also share the feedback received from various
stakeholders when our SSMT and TTMT systems were demonstrated in large public
events. | [
-0.2745001316,
-0.5996196866,
0.0951305777,
0.5705787539,
-0.7336221337,
0.5355722904,
-0.3901770711,
-0.2247550935,
0.1683851033,
0.8191747665,
-0.1617733091,
-0.1852220595,
-0.6412875056,
0.2871156037,
-0.6756566763,
0.889072001,
-0.178984195,
0.1148628816,
0.1188580096,
-0.2991867661,
-0.7754179239,
-0.4703247249,
-0.6175723076,
-0.1700494885,
0.0792529136,
0.5533502698,
0.495072186,
0.433290869,
0.5691919327,
0.2416340411,
-0.1946968883,
0.2323996872,
-0.090525046,
0.2990297675,
-0.239724353,
-0.4638200402,
-0.1399780214,
-0.3737715781,
0.86153543,
0.3664619923,
-0.2336618453,
0.265742898,
-0.0446172841,
0.526728332,
-0.4450710416,
0.023113925,
-0.4807843566,
0.0162222311,
-0.5337825418,
-0.075288862,
-0.4166146517,
-0.6969997287,
-0.0728193447,
-0.4972371161,
-0.1622821093,
-0.1030508652,
0.8852120042,
0.6813145876,
-0.6929194927,
-0.1162666976,
-1.0732848644,
0.5812392831,
-0.4624749422,
0.2991232276,
0.4926612675,
0.7321743965,
-0.0088906297,
-0.5797749758,
-0.5596279502,
-0.0446683243,
0.2458044738,
0.4392918646,
0.1856547147,
-0.361594528,
-0.1747309566,
0.6059306264,
-0.4276484251,
0.2107608467,
-0.7421306968,
0.1437385976,
0.3098270893,
0.1192837879,
0.3638519943,
-0.4363591075,
-0.3525315523,
0.0220095553,
-0.6355340481,
-0.1966081411,
0.2239156663,
0.8235611916,
-0.3629276752,
0.88544631,
-0.0651556104,
0.5213772058,
-0.0658301786,
0.305496335,
0.0496603362,
-0.4560654163,
-0.3941043615,
0.2391014993,
0.7657980919,
-0.1239782721,
-0.0928225666,
-0.0272474643,
-0.1511336118,
0.1210766733,
0.409424752,
-0.2209312171,
0.4502637088,
0.1304237545,
-0.1499631852,
-0.4224017859,
-0.5819010735,
-0.5507771373,
-0.2237581462,
-0.458081305,
0.5040944219,
-0.6515157223,
-0.7414385676,
-0.2256743759,
0.0354905277,
0.4378602505,
0.2075884193,
-0.517590344,
0.3484085798,
0.4448406994,
1.0242130756,
-0.1902321577,
-0.0582927726,
-0.3489805758,
0.2893070877,
-0.4549124837,
0.745721221,
-0.4250379205,
-0.7253332734,
0.0659676194,
-0.1438283622,
0.0531151667,
-0.4101221263,
0.8927679658,
-0.2488287985,
0.1744626313,
-0.2741981149,
-0.2594889998,
0.1560679525,
0.102431044,
-0.3121123612,
1.0309318304,
0.0344074778,
-0.7136483192,
0.2519951165,
-0.9293667078,
-0.5300733447,
0.6336250305,
-0.1458062977,
-0.272677809,
0.1720731407,
0.2700948119,
0.3553903401,
-0.3948099315,
0.227009654,
0.2664156854,
-0.3443362713,
0.137601763,
-0.2238723934,
0.9318194985,
0.6029637456,
-0.2201353014,
0.3903826177,
-0.824680388,
-0.0809387192,
0.0213582385,
-0.2279868275,
-0.4914783537,
-0.0773986503,
0.5998432636,
0.3633444011,
0.1391998976,
-0.5767219067,
0.1553644836,
-0.5118858814,
0.728951335,
0.8000525832,
-0.1478782892,
0.2737286985,
0.1726030111,
0.6939684749,
0.3698156178,
0.245091185,
0.1762576699,
-0.3216602206,
-0.5440117717,
-0.1748746932,
0.3317334056,
0.5553463697,
-1.0474867821,
-0.0038308357,
-0.4956807196,
-0.5826767087,
-0.8494839668,
-0.4292414486,
0.4815304577,
0.4980129898,
0.2821338177,
-0.0645680577,
-0.5876625776,
-1.1011593342,
0.069651477,
-0.0649016276,
0.2677573562,
-0.2485205978,
0.174455747,
-0.0841358826,
0.7176043391,
-0.0413743779,
-0.3476907611,
-0.0367047302,
-0.2197766304,
-0.0055710524,
0.4242639542,
0.1485612541,
-1.0799127817,
-0.7034134865,
0.3731509745,
-0.7137363553,
0.0144608626,
0.3593332469,
0.0498596951,
0.4787189364,
0.3757434785,
-0.6407502294,
0.3767727911,
0.5799766779,
-0.1487398297,
0.5411882401,
-0.3476945162,
0.2852844,
-1.8654979467,
0.0531466044,
-0.1918917298,
-0.3369529545,
-0.4480381608,
0.3008852303,
-0.0861873552,
-0.5789904594,
-0.5509825349,
0.298448801,
-0.1926077008,
-0.0799149424,
-0.284034729,
0.3448936939,
-0.6500657201,
0.1538638622,
-0.2777058482,
1.2963360548,
0.4389428198,
-0.7543556094,
0.2247831225,
0.6508106589,
0.0326922312,
1.0662047863,
-0.4912784696,
0.0409172811,
0.250654608,
0.0621936619,
-0.7057959437,
-0.187429443,
0.3057167232,
-0.6353501081,
0.1513210982,
-0.2064851373,
-0.7182740569,
-0.4104889929,
0.0349914655,
0.1280106008,
0.4735099971,
-0.5170437098,
0.2843533754,
0.6549451947,
-0.1799253374,
-0.580168426,
-0.7497438192,
0.5240445137,
-0.2854804993,
-0.2598019242,
-0.0233356878,
0.0918518007,
-0.0064432663,
0.0266642086,
-0.0633449852,
-0.3212871253,
-0.2125672996,
0.5525133014,
0.0485925563,
-0.0761454701,
0.1757223308,
0.4306733608,
-0.1641929597,
-0.1879802197,
-0.4630093575,
0.4795785546,
-0.3295800686,
-0.146022439,
-0.2740292251,
0.5128669143,
0.531331718,
-0.2898006439,
0.5684652328,
0.7388939857,
-0.5415635109,
0.1001931578,
-0.4234637618,
0.3296873271,
-0.4255366623,
0.1480350941,
-0.617518127,
-0.8055194616,
0.4098475575,
-0.1404329985,
0.1898307651,
0.6013560891,
0.7566759586,
-0.0317799635,
0.6884676218,
0.7740384936,
0.0265550017,
0.3613056242,
0.0724784881,
0.335776329,
-0.7495630383,
-0.0920229182,
-0.6709791422,
0.1838292181,
-0.8704409599,
-0.2439911664,
0.3985301852,
-0.2128209919,
-0.1713999957,
0.6827454567,
-1.1257202625,
0.1502919644,
0.5637434125,
-0.0222704336,
0.3838263452,
0.1182056591,
-0.1024803072,
-0.2325531542,
-0.3901826739,
-0.7564326525,
1.1574132442,
-0.041371569,
0.212663874,
0.2650539279,
0.5989136696,
0.283051908,
0.2072119415,
-0.2627186477,
0.560085237,
-0.4122330546,
-0.6536338925,
-0.3442243338,
-0.3388901055,
-0.9126277566,
0.2742867172,
0.0775248706,
-0.4641876519,
-0.0655376613,
-0.1158549413,
0.0834128633,
0.4177959859,
-0.9343320727,
0.3813294172,
-0.1326889992,
-0.0958963409,
-0.4345322847,
-0.8220618367,
0.4344736636,
-0.1909108162,
0.0996027291,
-0.0420272201,
-0.05185996,
0.6420519352,
-0.4852231741,
0.4933148026,
-0.0995498002,
0.124709636,
0.1478376985,
-0.3363134563,
0.1651620865,
0.0336295255,
0.0308369119,
0.0699112192,
0.2947334945,
-0.4854263663,
-0.0895716622,
0.7604848146,
-1.0281639099,
-0.2906016707,
-0.5583618879,
-0.5291823745,
-0.2683154643,
0.3112192154,
0.2890646756,
0.1681538224,
-0.1668802351,
0.0496681221,
0.6569747925,
-0.1645847559,
0.4839574397,
0.328047812,
-0.4711607993,
-0.3719740212,
1.0114938021,
0.358692795,
0.108306706,
0.3481648564,
0.042162627,
-0.3418297172,
-0.6501305103,
-0.8006176353,
0.1151205152,
-0.5595960617,
-0.1185012236,
-0.6134857535,
-0.4558407962,
-0.5141957402,
-0.0412399918,
-0.6530532241,
-0.7497357726,
-0.0117214425,
-0.0321078412,
0.5753142834,
0.7222952247,
0.0076610944,
0.4712583721,
-0.3485019803,
0.3995169401,
-0.0463830903,
0.456807375,
-0.6519165039,
-0.5990476012,
-0.4290034771,
-0.0540775806,
-0.2906989753,
-0.6554408669,
0.3779432774,
-0.1980264187,
0.1688855439,
-0.1875207573,
-0.0945067331,
0.6106331944,
-0.4940095246,
0.8185396791,
0.0764971301,
-0.7999693751,
0.9223409891,
-0.5236710906,
0.4704978764,
0.4958292544,
0.1615150273,
-0.7621442676,
-0.6318864226,
-0.5020905733,
-0.9284499884,
0.6700402498,
0.5216304064,
0.106627278,
0.2383967489,
0.3620963693,
0.0929327682,
0.3117031753,
-0.4384006262,
-0.2643420398,
-0.4979444444,
-0.1961653084,
-0.036676567,
-0.0041727391,
-0.1055742428,
-0.1129328758,
0.9068002105,
0.2277422696,
0.2106727511,
0.037556041,
-0.099409543,
-0.153860271,
0.662404716,
0.7636970282,
0.6124021411,
-0.1866018325,
-0.231445998,
0.1197728589,
-0.7137252688,
0.3161719441,
0.2773580551,
-0.3416572213,
0.2651963532,
-0.4354801476,
0.906288743,
0.0189533085,
-0.5526478887,
0.1279509515,
-0.1663982868,
0.0740331635,
-0.7249717116,
-0.3782530725,
0.2178625315,
0.0485277176,
0.3717250526,
0.021557318,
-0.159464404,
-0.188788712,
-0.1589230299,
-0.0039049606,
-0.5521196127,
-0.2442573458,
0.9127586484,
0.348641783,
-0.7097125649,
0.5139735341,
0.0577930808,
-0.2854178548,
0.265232116,
0.4817305803,
1.0062493086,
-0.7624838948,
0.3446293175,
0.0477139875,
0.6489340067,
-0.1077211127,
0.4266259968,
0.1345003992,
-0.0839712992,
-0.4208342433,
-0.5943533182,
-0.7474253774,
0.1434714198,
-0.7642545104,
0.4455151558,
-0.3202570677,
-0.3468160331,
-0.2165418118,
-0.1068641171,
-0.5477443337,
0.2318646163,
-0.2236633301,
0.6074512005,
-0.8068658113,
0.9489121437,
0.9149713516,
-0.8340684772,
-0.8241959214,
-0.4048915803,
-0.2887010276,
-0.5219214559,
0.5496212244,
-0.2558635771,
-0.062928088,
0.1084854528,
-0.2283108532,
-0.7235773206,
0.8036858439,
0.394577235,
-0.4756617844,
0.1003800333,
0.504420042,
0.7300584912,
-0.1050879285,
-0.0848155618,
0.3463876247,
0.3598842323,
-0.2383392602,
-1.3590862751,
-0.0162402652,
-0.1910770386,
0.3132448792,
0.5276370049,
-0.7542496324,
0.5544158816,
0.36496225,
-0.0760429129,
-0.2661010623,
0.6687030792,
0.0303364955,
0.2849967778,
0.2781374753,
0.5606487989,
0.4010835886,
-0.0254551675,
0.9434142709,
-0.0617974289,
-0.011625641,
1.0753494501,
-0.1496430486,
1.0968096256,
0.9329383373,
-0.3617050648,
-0.1220623329,
0.7134076953,
0.2344914824,
0.4491993785,
0.1273714453,
-0.3877336681,
0.241498664,
-0.4465046525,
-0.5911204219,
0.3603222668,
0.5096538067,
0.2138741612,
-0.1044153348,
0.69263798,
-0.2288073897,
0.2750045657,
-0.2132173479,
0.4848163724,
0.2936758697,
-0.4627736509,
0.5320207477,
0.0512317121,
0.6473186016,
-0.5553735495,
0.1994501352,
-0.1615763307,
0.1169661805,
-0.0272769984,
-0.6767279506,
0.8217293024,
0.208060652,
-0.0720325634,
-0.3387966454,
0.5863966942,
-0.3469702601,
-0.507514596,
-0.0030369351,
0.5134041309,
0.4005393684,
-0.0722578615,
-0.4642052352,
0.2271697372,
-0.3037451804,
0.0242670793,
0.3408872783,
0.3300758004,
-0.5528495312,
0.8554373384,
0.523843348,
0.2534340918,
0.4830240607,
0.1649116725,
0.6007000804,
-0.4998413622,
-0.7036196589,
-0.3377830684,
0.2986546755,
-0.0937792882,
-0.46574682,
0.7180683613,
0.6839751601,
0.7530460358,
-0.1088207364,
0.9365887642,
-0.0085339602,
0.6651438475,
-0.0908829346,
0.7846267819,
-0.449593544,
0.0257228017,
-0.050997179,
-0.7997365594,
-0.0599611551,
0.0859102011,
-0.0010327519,
-0.3823710382,
0.6402361393,
0.3709952235,
-0.0926204845,
0.053024292,
0.3184097409,
0.1040725708,
0.3809275627,
0.2909369767,
0.6308943033,
-0.7934411764,
0.9361516237,
-0.0823881179,
0.031139886,
-0.2178113163,
-0.3400938213,
-0.4242818654,
-1.1019870043,
-0.4411697388,
-0.3982546031,
0.3129655123,
0.8308831453,
0.5696857572,
-0.5988085866,
-0.46266675,
-0.0369611755,
0.166063413,
-0.2488577217,
-0.186075151,
0.375056833,
-0.2200838476,
-0.7742279172,
0.5003708005,
0.6072356105,
-0.096718885,
-0.3538827598,
0.1961791813,
-0.5084565878,
-0.0007276508,
0.672000587,
0.4063619077,
-0.8241591454,
-0.152499333,
-0.3874164522,
-0.3059822619,
0.2249896824,
0.6299675107,
-0.4940739274,
0.6036332846,
0.1416872144,
0.9103317857,
0.8574309945,
-0.474111706,
0.4210205972,
-0.7780607343,
0.3707283735,
0.2735410631,
-0.0000784113,
0.6102731824,
-0.3156076074,
0.7057028413,
0.0828230157,
-0.5086356997,
-1.2349361181,
0.1858816445,
-1.2687929869,
0.0952903405,
0.8190562129,
0.1853792071,
-0.2563269138,
-0.3281471729,
-0.2596779168,
0.7845672965,
-0.1951540112,
0.6921132803,
0.6479229927,
0.3502486348,
-0.2613314986,
-0.8529891968,
0.2165776789,
0.4431319535,
-0.88876158,
-0.0811224952,
0.1223621368,
0.2805767655,
0.0263739564,
0.8569762111,
-0.3315506577,
0.1683488488,
-0.1306116134,
0.1217010766,
-0.1506570578,
0.1248738766,
-0.487947613,
0.0043053147,
0.0003075106,
-0.6732273698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12517v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12517v4 | Description-Based Text Similarity | 2023-05-21T17:14:31 | 2024-04-26T08:04:59 | Shauli Ravfogel, Valentina Pyatkin, Amir DN Cohen, Avshalom Manevich, Yoav Goldberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Identifying texts with a given semantics is central for many information
seeking scenarios. Similarity search over vector embeddings appear to be
central to this ability, yet the similarity reflected in current text
embeddings is corpus-driven, and is inconsistent and sub-optimal for many use
cases. What, then, is a good notion of similarity for effective retrieval of
text?
We identify the need to search for texts based on abstract descriptions of
their content, and the corresponding notion of \emph{description based
similarity}. We demonstrate the inadequacy of current text embeddings and
propose an alternative model that significantly improves when used in standard
nearest neighbor search. The model is trained using positive and negative pairs
sourced through prompting a LLM, demonstrating how data from LLMs can be used
for creating new capabilities not immediately possible using the original
model. | [
-0.2010758072,
-0.4734269977,
0.8766707182,
-0.150552243,
-0.2595339417,
-0.103032127,
0.1046613976,
-0.5764018893,
0.5215252042,
0.5030404329,
-0.1879475713,
-0.5304936767,
-0.3606239259,
0.3492577076,
-0.843945384,
0.8661538959,
-0.2201773971,
-0.1957091689,
-0.7030025125,
-0.1747964174,
-0.1817293614,
-0.5061206222,
-0.4519443214,
-0.5550912023,
0.5944555402,
0.1666765958,
0.8337027431,
0.9007875323,
0.7035859823,
0.1822599918,
-0.2319479436,
-0.0338805094,
-0.5588322878,
0.2410674095,
-0.4069774449,
-0.4542919099,
-0.1100675687,
-0.0098160589,
0.4690743089,
0.5808723569,
0.0034139142,
0.0773003399,
0.1066627577,
0.5582693815,
-0.6635944247,
-0.0129400473,
-0.7179626822,
0.3777305484,
0.0088670356,
-0.5439652205,
-0.051835943,
-0.4572677314,
0.4956317544,
-0.6391080022,
0.4714939296,
0.3410181403,
0.9865325689,
0.0628086403,
-0.2879065573,
-0.7127038836,
-0.4843719304,
0.7988860011,
-0.5963217616,
0.3976331353,
0.5483414531,
0.0350403637,
-0.0838960186,
-0.6151800156,
-0.6382678747,
-0.3351072669,
-0.2621160448,
0.0091593498,
-0.2165698856,
0.0836157352,
0.1019882336,
0.5136913061,
-0.488850683,
-0.0134890601,
-0.2548373044,
-0.1887248307,
0.1712091118,
0.2300887704,
0.152406022,
-0.3194338083,
-0.8277177215,
0.1302593648,
-0.786034584,
-0.172493875,
0.4641221464,
0.2920415401,
0.1746287197,
0.7951102853,
-0.3489419818,
0.7036776543,
-0.2788046598,
-0.1375879645,
0.3445162773,
-0.243217513,
-0.0726244226,
0.1366971135,
0.2845488489,
0.7493149638,
0.238892287,
-0.4912243187,
-0.5888123512,
-0.0974776745,
0.4005375803,
-0.7890613079,
-0.0592569374,
-0.1580731273,
-1.0892828703,
-0.5420857668,
0.3317830563,
-0.4849565327,
-0.3400249779,
-0.6194858551,
0.6344709992,
-0.4108429253,
0.0021427078,
-0.1509899944,
-0.4421197474,
0.4407672584,
-0.1081187427,
-0.9527173638,
0.5601689816,
0.772043407,
1.1909600496,
-0.414842844,
0.0394684412,
-0.1619341969,
0.2067157179,
-0.3200212419,
0.7041350007,
-0.7916715145,
-0.3522405922,
0.0392947719,
-0.1848944128,
0.3222202361,
-0.7525641322,
0.5353217125,
-0.5359150767,
0.0818215013,
-0.3941891491,
-0.8715059757,
-0.3538045287,
0.6038563251,
-0.7541382909,
1.1501939297,
0.0732242838,
-1.1393957138,
0.1632876992,
-0.473720789,
-0.2418814749,
-0.2898198664,
-0.3428167999,
-0.4449615479,
0.2620140314,
-0.0172054749,
0.471540153,
-0.3506105542,
-0.3946160376,
-0.4151287377,
-0.831633389,
0.2259660363,
-0.0070730029,
0.2015474439,
0.2737257481,
-0.0673705339,
-0.0456079468,
-0.667815268,
-0.0370637737,
0.0309115704,
0.0017562632,
-0.9968237877,
0.2431141734,
-0.1470524669,
-0.1226015985,
0.7361075282,
-0.6305303574,
-0.0139197558,
-0.6497888565,
0.3211469054,
0.484646678,
0.02625921,
0.5493946075,
-0.8551970124,
0.4986212254,
-0.2110577524,
-0.0864504874,
-0.2212276608,
-0.3822486401,
-0.2640829384,
0.0007578754,
0.4058628082,
0.5771170855,
-0.4777650535,
0.2529482841,
-0.2909888625,
-0.450276345,
-0.4348131716,
0.0000532246,
0.4488038719,
0.5471662283,
0.4512343109,
-0.4612188041,
-0.5053701401,
-1.0637946129,
-0.2404608727,
0.0309816971,
-0.1756040752,
0.3920843899,
0.3124619722,
-0.2601540089,
0.845031321,
-0.5286195874,
-0.4104489088,
-0.0945534706,
-0.0938136578,
0.2268975973,
-0.0342709981,
0.515656352,
-1.053319931,
-0.4385073483,
0.0107017532,
-0.769685626,
-0.0968236849,
0.1639476418,
0.1305862814,
-0.0342315547,
0.82196486,
-0.33840096,
0.468521297,
0.4132368267,
0.0380839892,
0.2429945171,
-0.3879564106,
0.2369387895,
-1.1885454655,
0.2256164402,
-0.0532901399,
-0.096562542,
-0.2332822978,
0.3406564295,
0.0268011708,
0.0649572089,
-0.3092219234,
0.7116127014,
-0.3038488328,
-0.326928407,
-0.8040509224,
0.5748925209,
-0.108277306,
0.1286257505,
-0.0415781587,
0.8800483346,
0.3889138103,
-0.6769794226,
0.4666682482,
0.3647854626,
-0.2444070727,
0.7144523263,
-0.6397832632,
0.0595074855,
-0.3421416879,
0.0653458312,
-0.6935506463,
0.1478399187,
-0.0817697644,
-0.4164080918,
0.1162246317,
-0.0476824269,
-0.6579325199,
-0.2695527077,
-0.7527321577,
0.6035509109,
0.4254861474,
-0.705789566,
0.3675331771,
0.2151135504,
-0.2263509184,
-0.7753695846,
-0.3888382316,
0.1200425103,
-0.2200912386,
-0.2190625966,
0.9118424058,
0.1511480063,
-0.2023388147,
0.2621685863,
-0.2167190015,
-0.1971671432,
-0.0413916931,
0.1102435365,
0.0241749398,
-0.0593703911,
0.6309418678,
-0.0878735557,
-0.1266466677,
-0.1000023633,
-0.286806196,
0.3828729093,
0.086075291,
-0.0787718818,
-0.0752428398,
0.4570468366,
0.1323792487,
-0.1307395995,
0.5804895163,
0.4550570548,
-0.5478622317,
0.1099049449,
-0.194470495,
-0.2969391048,
-0.4381953776,
0.3861306906,
-0.4850202203,
-0.8517346382,
0.4957904518,
0.003363295,
-0.1717438251,
0.4245047569,
0.2449219078,
-0.4230474532,
0.7251096964,
0.9685819149,
0.0451240875,
0.430175662,
0.0687931105,
0.141752556,
-0.7647106647,
-0.339520961,
-0.6502002478,
-0.4219039977,
-0.8362268209,
-0.2429448068,
-0.140914306,
-0.0387537479,
-0.1823229641,
0.5641199946,
-0.6206066608,
0.6006293893,
0.5895869136,
0.0774474293,
0.3422350883,
0.0874755532,
-0.5201128125,
-0.3787216842,
-0.4789101481,
-0.6794397235,
1.1251718998,
0.2393207401,
0.8375527263,
-0.0173197612,
0.9429246187,
0.2784348726,
0.124917686,
-0.7303456664,
0.4380729198,
-0.2521455288,
-0.3579349518,
-0.0636642948,
-0.6005018353,
-1.1008646488,
-0.0332358256,
-0.4979123175,
-0.5417248011,
-0.4294795096,
-0.0284691025,
0.0173489377,
0.3518657684,
-0.3678431511,
0.5319628716,
0.0611322969,
0.1217208505,
-0.2659561336,
-0.5493161678,
-0.1968526542,
-0.2480835021,
0.0956223309,
0.0674715564,
-0.4201752245,
0.71361655,
-0.0869451687,
0.454891324,
0.2460357845,
-0.0164467171,
0.2808776796,
0.0358956158,
0.4242875576,
-0.3580298424,
-0.1999123394,
-0.1500156522,
0.2842686474,
-0.465768069,
-0.8375670314,
0.9669525027,
-0.4331976473,
-0.2657192349,
-0.2076452672,
-0.1884061694,
0.2180145085,
0.2314826101,
0.2902951241,
0.5324994922,
-0.3194716573,
0.1790185869,
0.8488724232,
-0.384729296,
0.2696847022,
0.2370400429,
-0.3895345628,
-0.2275019884,
1.0146567822,
-0.2511975467,
-0.0119217336,
1.2332818508,
0.1815726906,
-0.5989866257,
-0.4510498941,
0.1000526175,
0.0706478879,
-0.6326363683,
-0.4351961017,
-0.55051893,
-0.1919188648,
0.0522177294,
-0.1742745787,
-0.2239418626,
-0.4646649957,
-0.4917874038,
-0.2773070633,
0.435708493,
1.0192360878,
0.0732874349,
0.0375715047,
-0.7457860112,
0.3276203573,
0.1967426538,
0.6356610656,
0.0337690152,
-0.378372997,
-0.3220331967,
-0.0946276337,
-0.5977581143,
-1.0106606483,
0.2428918332,
0.1661126167,
0.5990517735,
0.0709737092,
0.1818385273,
0.0586958304,
-0.5473541617,
0.5890495181,
0.0917015821,
-0.7908229828,
0.548604548,
-0.1897618324,
0.1235377565,
0.3763790131,
0.6692401171,
-0.3918221295,
-0.388690114,
-0.6528626084,
-0.7817390561,
-0.0470895655,
0.3807809055,
0.51780653,
-0.2263597846,
0.6343612075,
0.2257898152,
0.1902586818,
-0.8949289322,
-0.3207864165,
-0.0786217153,
-0.6037595272,
0.2096002251,
-0.2850878835,
0.2661751807,
0.070841983,
0.4750058949,
0.0826362371,
0.846417129,
0.3935825527,
0.093908973,
-0.0178980902,
0.341321677,
0.4018109739,
0.4658216238,
-0.2504030466,
0.4526130557,
0.4184911251,
-0.3430408239,
-0.0013875455,
0.1460400224,
-0.1904047728,
0.211308822,
0.2039035857,
0.2285398841,
0.4451083243,
-0.6939826608,
0.7637490034,
0.2140393406,
-0.1441589147,
-0.2774234414,
-0.0474124476,
0.059244737,
0.2142142206,
0.3945499659,
-0.2054035515,
0.4873410463,
-0.5914714932,
0.5235905647,
0.4827573001,
-0.6881179214,
-0.0645825788,
0.4290551543,
0.0373739004,
-0.5438266993,
0.3971910477,
-0.2023650706,
-0.644210279,
0.4748913944,
0.4373905957,
0.4583643079,
0.1788859814,
-0.0298132282,
0.3116375804,
0.12076056,
-0.2304097861,
0.3368468285,
0.0330118872,
-0.538225472,
-0.2747959495,
-0.450083077,
-0.4083798826,
-0.0832677484,
-0.4786435366,
0.4985671937,
-0.3609880805,
-0.0862592682,
-0.2758063972,
0.1652051955,
-0.4823193252,
0.2231585532,
-0.0540178977,
0.9309217334,
-0.3474080265,
0.5702857375,
0.7156701088,
-0.3996372223,
-0.4462550879,
0.1023582071,
-0.362634331,
-0.4547719359,
0.3366130888,
0.3980685174,
-0.0391838662,
-0.2048428357,
-0.3189930916,
-0.7697439194,
1.3689903021,
0.2003970444,
-0.5014250875,
-0.2707750797,
-0.1017251611,
0.8012264967,
-0.5365088582,
0.3760905862,
-0.0553411655,
0.0844605118,
-0.1473429501,
-0.9422198534,
0.0903527141,
0.0850384533,
0.1118971556,
0.4791126847,
-0.2508966029,
0.6661474705,
-0.3144793808,
-0.0521996096,
0.5883099437,
0.6851703525,
0.0218483247,
0.4889232218,
0.1753319204,
0.7796270251,
0.6989734173,
0.2825334072,
1.0390589237,
-0.0926588699,
0.6164777279,
1.1438483,
0.0576712899,
1.1553140879,
0.406688571,
0.0573372021,
0.558452785,
0.4525494576,
-0.1558460891,
0.7315946817,
0.3582139611,
-0.1560356319,
-0.0388667211,
-0.0621081293,
-0.3978036344,
0.3542427123,
0.1079437435,
-1.0720207691,
-0.3112240136,
-0.2681460977,
-0.4687319994,
0.8534637094,
-0.280018121,
0.8055583835,
0.2244344801,
-0.1216676831,
0.2278958559,
0.1904172897,
0.8928759694,
-0.0807112232,
-0.2629160583,
0.0166858379,
-0.1698664278,
-0.1322834641,
-0.7224654555,
0.4791887105,
-0.2447575033,
-0.5508103371,
-0.0838899165,
0.8373111486,
-0.3551754355,
-0.1552924961,
0.4910598695,
0.380853951,
0.3197698891,
0.0103868488,
-0.6296150684,
-0.2926630676,
0.0699720681,
0.3903515339,
0.2030693144,
0.4447407722,
0.1445436329,
0.6985693574,
0.2507507801,
-0.0052547483,
-0.093774423,
-0.3310416043,
0.4034707248,
-0.930321455,
-0.5598472357,
-0.7506746054,
-0.383648932,
-0.1208158731,
-0.260999918,
0.5504856706,
0.7454859614,
0.9390122294,
0.0405650809,
0.7748368979,
0.180453375,
1.0467193127,
-0.6024363041,
0.4815817177,
-0.6155520678,
0.3391672969,
-0.3624760807,
-1.4921435118,
-0.0598523133,
0.9153904319,
-0.0654836446,
0.0480397977,
0.6866244078,
0.8783844709,
-0.4171538949,
0.1409427673,
0.4603432119,
-0.0665284395,
-0.0167085268,
0.488843441,
1.029476881,
-0.4918269217,
0.7779984474,
0.1441123188,
-0.0747189075,
-0.164223969,
-0.9880055785,
-0.8129749894,
-0.7934007645,
-0.182901904,
-0.2027419358,
0.1531623751,
0.9802709818,
0.3564516604,
-0.4433493018,
0.112132825,
-0.2484956086,
0.2601960599,
0.0502092168,
-0.1886082292,
0.1763587147,
-0.2650410831,
-0.4094748795,
-0.0813482255,
0.2114540786,
0.4754239321,
-0.1177346408,
-0.044922594,
0.0895657912,
0.291916877,
0.5300162435,
0.1794449389,
-0.6422054172,
-0.5541395545,
0.0125622321,
-0.4716019332,
-0.0629892424,
0.797655344,
-0.7634693384,
0.3967796564,
0.4383686781,
0.8461047411,
0.5009903908,
-0.1505878121,
0.6888531446,
-0.7952666283,
-0.0987927988,
0.2545748949,
0.1143240482,
0.7100427151,
-0.2287341505,
0.4896265864,
-0.0114812208,
-0.4249872863,
-0.3923388124,
0.415415287,
-0.9217742682,
-0.2493499517,
1.2658318281,
-0.1874311715,
0.155470714,
-0.0956401303,
-0.2901830375,
0.0896721333,
-0.3256238401,
0.9496355057,
0.6012049913,
0.0267829895,
0.0330170691,
-0.2585118413,
0.4655205905,
0.2107055932,
-0.307711333,
-0.3424780667,
0.0057924874,
0.2992792726,
0.1823276579,
0.3825064003,
-0.2556809187,
0.0815071985,
-0.301928401,
-0.1805671751,
0.1028028205,
-0.1480546892,
-0.0959283635,
0.1061830819,
0.1686438173,
-0.0723083988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12510v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12510v1 | A Deeper (Autoregressive) Approach to Non-Convergent Discourse Parsing | 2023-05-21T17:04:21 | 2023-05-21T17:04:21 | Yoav Tulpan, Oren Tsur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Online social platforms provide a bustling arena for information-sharing and
for multi-party discussions. Various frameworks for dialogic discourse parsing
were developed and used for the processing of discussions and for predicting
the productivity of a dialogue. However, most of these frameworks are not
suitable for the analysis of contentious discussions that are commonplace in
many online platforms. A novel multi-label scheme for contentious dialog
parsing was recently introduced by Zakharov et al. (2021). While the schema is
well developed, the computational approach they provide is both naive and
inefficient, as a different model (architecture) using a different
representation of the input, is trained for each of the 31 tags in the
annotation scheme. Moreover, all their models assume full knowledge of label
collocations and context, which is unlikely in any realistic setting. In this
work, we present a unified model for Non-Convergent Discourse Parsing that does
not require any additional input other than the previous dialog utterances. We
fine-tuned a RoBERTa backbone, combining embeddings of the utterance, the
context and the labels through GRN layers and an asymmetric loss function.
Overall, our model achieves results comparable with SOTA, without using label
collocation and without training a unique architecture/model for each label. | [
-0.5532254577,
-0.8112084866,
0.347029537,
0.2382727712,
-0.3298766911,
0.2161061764,
-0.0655861571,
-0.3773520589,
0.4652949274,
0.5791276097,
-0.5274199247,
-0.3983775675,
-0.6742021441,
-0.0378891826,
0.0148660047,
1.1981292963,
0.3196038604,
-0.0132792024,
-0.2613920867,
-0.5504235625,
-0.3011808395,
-0.551907599,
-0.5394943357,
-0.3663635254,
0.3984609544,
0.18485488,
0.4010277689,
0.4537802935,
0.2460332364,
0.2813346386,
-0.4201839268,
0.1119198576,
-0.4666903615,
0.2939527035,
-0.4342139065,
-0.1353629678,
-0.5026119351,
-0.1533767283,
0.5217623115,
0.8718962669,
-0.0744873583,
0.2693591416,
0.2152045071,
0.4543426931,
-0.6357982159,
0.183820352,
-0.7298458219,
0.079083696,
-0.0886520073,
-0.1881119162,
-0.6169506311,
-0.2924779654,
0.0276197251,
-0.2936623991,
-0.0557036363,
-0.3748826385,
0.8762601614,
0.075495258,
-0.611210227,
-0.2052671015,
-0.5033307076,
0.5873203874,
-0.687961936,
0.2235589027,
0.0667274743,
0.247297585,
-0.0089247758,
-0.7211011052,
-0.1799215376,
0.1414926499,
0.0151508329,
0.1259263754,
-0.2709714472,
0.1963204145,
0.0385349356,
0.1896373332,
-0.4420049787,
0.0351643711,
0.0060951984,
-0.1108342409,
0.3477928042,
0.1678737402,
-0.0878717005,
-0.4720178843,
-0.7440472245,
0.0099251494,
-0.3538205922,
0.1791515648,
0.3011732399,
0.5145434737,
-0.0836568549,
0.35714975,
-0.0514118224,
0.683684051,
0.1935961396,
-0.0767733157,
0.026576804,
-0.28674981,
-0.1989119947,
-0.2658020258,
1.0802589655,
0.3068228364,
-0.1668595374,
0.1174061075,
0.0314570777,
0.1125416681,
-0.0188522227,
-0.6737906337,
-0.5286358595,
0.0423874445,
-0.4883345068,
-0.183281377,
-0.1962359101,
-0.9948258996,
-0.3429524004,
-0.2286010087,
-0.0910399556,
-0.1381498575,
-0.0932916775,
-0.1518579572,
-0.0391393118,
0.1290706992,
0.4202537835,
-0.4519192576,
0.2905583382,
0.5724272728,
0.8852881789,
0.275388509,
0.3174698353,
-0.4398780763,
0.1517250389,
-0.1562141925,
0.9928034544,
-0.9209690094,
-0.3856243193,
-0.102508992,
-0.0908911005,
-0.0222618207,
-0.266241163,
0.7455143332,
-0.6581022143,
0.2376338094,
-0.3208290935,
-0.5812938213,
-0.3070789874,
0.3684469759,
-0.5544600487,
0.7160217166,
-0.2554515898,
-0.82158494,
0.1315985322,
-0.7656066418,
-0.3756088316,
0.1954717487,
-0.2505028248,
-0.2646155953,
-0.1299032271,
0.2614881098,
0.1790959537,
-0.4632211924,
1.0134510994,
-0.6417371035,
0.2223645747,
0.2573664486,
-0.4912856817,
1.1071453094,
0.2618029416,
-0.3641580045,
0.0877463743,
-0.7270092368,
0.3248580098,
-0.1615104228,
-0.271509856,
-0.1991467625,
-0.1751366109,
0.0875156522,
0.423437506,
0.3241674602,
-0.7209878564,
0.2165094018,
-0.3753303885,
0.74817276,
0.5850097537,
0.0887256488,
0.3681096137,
-0.2057966143,
0.3544088006,
-0.0593124889,
0.106072858,
-0.3057424724,
-0.7086917758,
-0.7635679245,
-0.2628901005,
0.4850980937,
0.597266674,
-0.6874921918,
0.3911649883,
-0.149345845,
-0.3706117868,
-0.4165389538,
-0.0844708756,
0.7545685768,
0.4577664137,
0.4971598983,
-0.5434846878,
-0.734408617,
-0.9524906874,
-0.4388044775,
-0.3068593442,
0.1733036637,
0.496953845,
0.1619052291,
-0.1345260292,
1.0332964659,
-0.5362195969,
-0.4071519077,
-0.1864049882,
0.8743577003,
-0.0257937703,
0.4151941836,
0.2314124554,
-0.4738401473,
-0.5943198204,
-0.0588239953,
-0.6901493073,
-0.3713113964,
-0.0083726067,
-0.1443686187,
0.1991771609,
0.5207003355,
-0.6365993023,
0.3033239841,
0.4613523483,
-0.0045532989,
0.0006748401,
0.0874098986,
-0.1375350505,
-0.9888541102,
0.1098839864,
-0.0306664221,
-0.4843771756,
-0.6232848167,
0.1902738661,
-0.176167652,
-0.2890051603,
-0.3307561576,
0.3715261817,
-0.3666914999,
0.1372757405,
-0.218482554,
0.2261288166,
0.4655064046,
0.6083860993,
0.0283779651,
0.4501392543,
0.1569542289,
-0.3413242698,
-0.031050818,
0.2822747827,
0.1759440601,
0.5995785594,
-0.562612474,
0.3942408562,
-0.3219591379,
0.7795992494,
-1.2295053005,
-0.0100525962,
0.3904310465,
-0.4952230752,
0.176210627,
-0.5500384569,
-0.1847253442,
-0.0382164232,
-0.3449680507,
0.7374334931,
0.1359656155,
-0.3656542599,
0.810739398,
0.895889461,
-0.3812812269,
-0.414724648,
-0.635842979,
0.3964889348,
-0.2852911949,
-0.7671262026,
0.3315501809,
0.062480621,
-0.2466095388,
-0.0865757987,
0.4300411046,
-0.489930898,
-0.2175147086,
0.0905556679,
-0.006367208,
-0.3033623099,
0.1346852928,
0.0434431769,
-0.145375073,
-0.070864141,
-0.3653197587,
0.4638885558,
-0.4180101752,
-0.0294322651,
-0.6602568626,
0.7513524294,
0.3523679376,
-0.1793003231,
0.5445525646,
0.1649584621,
-0.0705834106,
0.0951153487,
-0.6195442677,
0.0076812268,
-0.4162219465,
-0.0706063882,
-0.199588418,
-0.962238729,
0.744663775,
-0.2667016387,
0.1866818666,
0.4948526025,
0.4938234091,
-0.0221526865,
0.832269311,
0.4189954996,
0.114246279,
0.1544048786,
-0.0106044514,
0.3835706115,
-0.8105812073,
-0.1601292044,
-0.5080658793,
-0.1382211596,
-0.5418382287,
-0.6472409964,
0.1652705371,
-0.1779084504,
-0.0850742012,
0.3200998902,
-0.4331021607,
0.4157932401,
0.1666002274,
-0.2890138626,
0.4632337987,
-0.2438880056,
-0.0804444402,
-0.3015832305,
-0.7836319208,
-0.6415739059,
0.7184994221,
0.3409261405,
0.5943484306,
0.226476714,
0.4370989203,
0.2514083385,
0.3977363408,
-0.6369614601,
0.5869115591,
-0.1343580484,
-0.6877430081,
-0.1291891634,
-0.5769354105,
-1.09245193,
0.6480757594,
0.0737010464,
-0.8608931303,
0.470426172,
0.1973565221,
-0.5775928497,
0.4254175723,
-0.500312984,
0.8066285849,
-0.0405434072,
-0.4687525034,
0.3593009412,
-0.9958639145,
0.43727386,
0.262901783,
0.5756902099,
-0.1152203977,
0.2526820302,
0.5753090382,
-0.3244371414,
1.2075734138,
-0.332248807,
-0.0855416805,
0.7217612267,
0.0547598116,
0.3977304101,
0.04689328,
0.2860952318,
0.2959165573,
-0.0715494305,
-0.2030991465,
-0.4754476845,
0.5062686801,
-0.6871948838,
-0.3785517812,
-0.1875772327,
-0.2627313435,
-0.2816564739,
0.0264568776,
0.2964490652,
0.4903840423,
-0.3706732988,
0.1762907058,
0.5143007636,
0.0194299333,
0.3657818139,
0.2838500738,
-0.0545612909,
-0.5349557996,
0.8853070736,
0.3498201668,
0.072308585,
0.2549299002,
0.1972565204,
-0.4196595848,
0.0706261769,
-0.5134522319,
0.1518047303,
-1.0632491112,
-0.5147153735,
-1.1615616083,
-0.1311385036,
-0.5275523663,
0.012658393,
-0.6757130623,
-0.7681756616,
-0.4093283415,
0.0554556549,
0.0115205515,
0.8004885316,
-0.1239028722,
0.4036956131,
-0.7435008883,
0.1109448746,
0.2146396488,
0.1785687506,
0.1370192617,
-0.6139267087,
0.2344172448,
0.119600825,
-0.7340270877,
-0.9934164882,
0.3269022703,
0.3481374085,
0.1704633534,
0.4018032551,
0.2551132441,
0.9389046431,
-0.3760855198,
0.7116288543,
0.1831175387,
-1.0081779957,
0.4218234122,
-0.5878999829,
0.1740370542,
0.8824468851,
0.1865588129,
-0.3942310512,
-0.4320123792,
-0.8361859918,
-1.4122669697,
0.5767113566,
0.1129547432,
0.2629031241,
0.0028582779,
0.038620811,
0.2000828236,
0.3342719376,
-1.0808981657,
-0.0704242215,
-0.3212530911,
0.1683415323,
0.3022832572,
-0.3669108748,
-0.4407666922,
-0.3892703056,
0.5593340993,
-0.1534505039,
0.2302376926,
-0.0130360201,
-0.0441014618,
0.0441857725,
0.5199580193,
0.4759174883,
0.2910593152,
0.0520641319,
0.1982399225,
-0.0603059642,
0.1976132691,
0.1880484819,
-0.0231302734,
-0.203989625,
0.1186523288,
0.1608638912,
0.9075724483,
0.4328059554,
-0.2896407843,
0.6984605193,
-0.2648602426,
-0.3032817841,
-0.2771744728,
-0.3877134919,
0.257312119,
0.2884039879,
-0.0339510515,
0.0842498764,
0.4128571451,
-0.5613662004,
0.2361014038,
0.4009600282,
-0.6315583587,
-0.2431123108,
0.4434381723,
0.3434353471,
-0.2477717996,
0.169062838,
-0.4958538711,
-0.334946394,
0.3642169535,
0.4060539305,
0.899022758,
-0.0521335267,
0.6054386497,
0.1937621087,
0.0039734719,
0.2274629772,
0.0435063653,
-0.238583982,
-0.5388603806,
-0.4326130748,
-0.4678777456,
-0.5011457801,
0.2737411559,
-0.7929822206,
-0.0026958236,
-0.7852095962,
-0.6916114688,
0.0947460756,
-0.3447968364,
-0.2898434103,
-0.0449497849,
-0.0236123744,
0.3335968554,
-0.8824269772,
0.3411697745,
0.6950570345,
-0.0768718719,
-0.5583171248,
0.1836705357,
0.0338166952,
-0.3083272278,
0.4618356526,
0.2187154144,
-0.3764800727,
-0.1575485319,
-0.4566362798,
-0.9738955498,
0.4870568216,
0.6584634781,
-0.4337213039,
0.0579759181,
0.0850325823,
0.6959771514,
-0.4744024575,
0.4407148361,
0.0840404406,
0.3441011608,
0.4908990264,
-0.8244066834,
-0.0381745063,
-0.3428396583,
0.0770106092,
0.2162372619,
-1.0013021231,
1.138640523,
0.2247285843,
-0.4988851845,
0.0164059773,
0.5461544394,
-0.1040886119,
0.3066960573,
0.2891627848,
0.6280969977,
0.7475249767,
0.0060409596,
0.7010251284,
-0.4725507796,
0.5856829882,
1.6072354317,
-0.3847701848,
0.6405922174,
0.2608029544,
-0.052792035,
0.7272485495,
0.4757726789,
0.323787868,
0.3672598302,
0.1215043887,
-0.220048219,
-0.4444534779,
-0.5457010865,
-0.3808763027,
0.6967164874,
0.4196007252,
-0.2962075174,
-0.6776812077,
-0.0617031306,
0.2673544884,
0.2619700134,
0.0605564117,
1.1049749851,
0.2363101691,
-0.8236615658,
0.6480605006,
0.3258434832,
0.2704712152,
-0.1448124051,
0.0711632147,
0.0141216787,
0.0201284885,
-0.1048129871,
-0.5746394396,
0.4608123302,
-0.0203360375,
0.0967697203,
-0.2698962688,
0.6596286893,
-0.3468578756,
-0.4022798538,
0.5517705679,
0.5027301311,
0.0593122616,
0.2458674163,
-0.8422242403,
0.1025107652,
-0.0427047014,
-0.0854569301,
0.3103359044,
0.6768893003,
-0.0932804868,
0.3990727067,
0.4630135298,
-0.3722824156,
-0.043277353,
0.1460428536,
1.34892416,
-0.4364745617,
-0.8117730021,
-0.775888741,
0.5909472108,
-0.2386702001,
-0.443803221,
0.5253820419,
0.4055845439,
0.4596477747,
0.5069237351,
0.7192405462,
0.1315525621,
0.501558125,
-0.316174984,
0.2181777656,
-0.4280355871,
0.2285591662,
-0.502946198,
-0.5946727395,
-0.3150732219,
0.8430486321,
-0.3985942006,
0.0083076386,
0.5034377575,
0.3905282617,
0.0698679835,
0.5372661352,
0.0772105753,
0.2271279097,
0.4502132833,
0.5207898617,
0.8707719445,
-0.2790268958,
0.4054765105,
0.0641140938,
-0.2726252973,
-0.2021557093,
-0.8624890447,
-0.9061935544,
-0.4533146322,
-0.2815352082,
-0.2698656321,
0.1014599204,
0.7996931076,
0.5533184409,
-0.5827850699,
-0.1868234724,
-0.1141023561,
-0.1612082124,
0.432202369,
-0.2868403792,
-0.0525807068,
-0.403301537,
-0.2825728655,
0.3062183559,
0.5183678269,
-0.2603914142,
-0.2585994601,
0.3529891074,
-0.5490726233,
0.340416044,
0.6177554727,
0.3477586508,
-0.6258964539,
-0.2501983047,
-0.3833552301,
0.0292589907,
0.6744940877,
0.9371129274,
-0.6194925308,
0.5838629603,
0.3865080476,
0.7426382899,
0.450226754,
0.4667425752,
0.3417067528,
-0.831443727,
0.2571525276,
0.5440926552,
0.1173612401,
0.5608327985,
-0.3064747155,
0.0487847514,
0.2845250368,
-0.6187616587,
-0.6740864515,
0.6579060555,
-0.7358530164,
-0.3663146794,
0.9279229045,
-0.5008538961,
-0.1917693913,
-0.5873069763,
-0.1654439718,
0.2274256051,
-0.8217712045,
0.7364305854,
0.6266003847,
-0.3618656993,
-0.0656819418,
-0.2905521989,
0.2843720913,
0.5781332254,
-0.6627897024,
0.433845818,
0.5477468967,
-0.0762994885,
0.4167798758,
1.1398646832,
-0.2537579834,
-0.2739325762,
-0.0644975901,
-0.2842159569,
0.3892408013,
-0.6010058522,
-0.2409620732,
0.7019425631,
-0.0600789785,
0.1244277954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12501v1 | Exploring How Generative Adversarial Networks Learn Phonological Representations | 2023-05-21T16:37:21 | 2023-05-21T16:37:21 | Jingyi Chen, Micha Elsner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper explores how Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) learn
representations of phonological phenomena. We analyze how GANs encode
contrastive and non-contrastive nasality in French and English vowels by
applying the ciwGAN architecture (Begus 2021a). Begus claims that ciwGAN
encodes linguistically meaningful representations with categorical variables in
its latent space and manipulating the latent variables shows an almost one to
one corresponding control of the phonological features in ciwGAN's generated
outputs. However, our results show an interactive effect of latent variables on
the features in the generated outputs, which suggests the learned
representations in neural networks are different from the phonological
representations proposed by linguists. On the other hand, ciwGAN is able to
distinguish contrastive and noncontrastive features in English and French by
encoding them differently. Comparing the performance of GANs learning from
different languages results in a better understanding of what language specific
features contribute to developing language specific phonological
representations. We also discuss the role of training data frequencies in
phonological feature learning. | [
-0.477542907,
-0.2458805144,
0.2281107903,
0.0214452855,
-0.0593863428,
-0.1859807521,
-0.3498249948,
-0.2019918412,
0.3863039911,
0.3251936138,
-0.1150393412,
-0.4510329068,
-0.5698332191,
-0.0931164026,
-0.1308088601,
0.9112567902,
0.2747909129,
0.1641232371,
0.2882992327,
-0.1934471726,
0.1251482964,
-0.5591721535,
-0.8463196158,
-0.5310641527,
0.5963736176,
0.0039564846,
0.8850064874,
0.5178846121,
0.2878772318,
0.3632703125,
-0.3227912188,
0.0491552986,
-0.3439326286,
0.0752646551,
0.1574621052,
-0.3821555674,
-0.135202691,
0.0387053117,
0.5717433095,
0.9476196766,
-0.41014871,
-0.5173607469,
0.2924169004,
0.5331429839,
-0.3619555831,
0.3405731618,
-0.5866261721,
0.4467996657,
-0.3819547594,
-0.3896528184,
-0.2712756395,
-0.1547543854,
0.2656290829,
-0.9007688165,
0.5518325567,
-0.1910583377,
0.8687187433,
-0.021820426,
-0.2949290574,
-0.5511181355,
-0.6834181547,
0.4850771427,
-0.3804198802,
0.4857907593,
0.2302932888,
0.2043377608,
-0.4054221511,
-0.659350276,
-0.6603476405,
-0.4888710976,
-0.2763356566,
0.533675313,
-0.0315442234,
0.3889417052,
0.2007119954,
0.899333179,
-1.07216084,
-0.014380713,
-0.4491450489,
-0.0443226136,
0.5548527241,
-0.237874493,
0.4410100281,
-0.1645205766,
-0.2273929417,
-0.5830630064,
-0.2171967477,
0.0322621502,
0.6370352507,
0.3782847226,
-0.4463601112,
0.4610889554,
0.1528824717,
0.4506056309,
-0.1603811383,
-0.1401218027,
0.5407953262,
0.4233291745,
-0.3162495792,
0.0498127714,
1.0118820667,
-0.3368018568,
0.4680179954,
-0.4058253765,
-0.2554286718,
0.0700891316,
0.0729490742,
-0.2042828798,
-0.8472771049,
-0.0585344657,
-0.442094624,
-0.1855873466,
0.4112164974,
-0.6181696653,
-0.5401235223,
-0.2010192871,
0.1621320546,
-0.5828460455,
-0.5373653769,
0.1462235004,
-0.1663273722,
0.272099942,
0.0270455796,
-1.3119522333,
0.3998118639,
0.6203693151,
0.7669117451,
0.134258002,
-0.3579008281,
-0.4410188794,
-0.0575675964,
-0.4641419649,
0.4546307921,
-0.4481991827,
-0.6469709277,
0.1305126101,
0.1392917186,
-0.2709396482,
-0.8440245986,
0.1510978341,
-0.543602109,
-0.0811621919,
-0.062736541,
-0.3160314858,
-0.4514905512,
-0.0082372408,
-1.1449153423,
0.7254441381,
0.2362390757,
-0.533016026,
0.2252325416,
-0.2861618102,
-0.5808176398,
0.0771073997,
-0.429143697,
-0.4924670458,
0.3556688428,
0.1190892309,
0.4256478846,
-0.0775217563,
0.0486093834,
-0.0482526086,
-0.2382567823,
0.3572181165,
-0.6865339875,
0.9347757697,
0.2280645221,
-0.2757695615,
0.0226484742,
-0.9383251071,
-0.2646169066,
0.2372470945,
-0.3246403933,
-0.0798925459,
-0.4347849488,
-0.131644547,
-0.0313347131,
-0.1879614741,
-0.2664190829,
0.0784768164,
-0.5756400228,
0.2559012175,
0.3125351071,
0.2681109905,
0.4892708659,
-0.3632035255,
0.3770676851,
0.1423597038,
-0.1421902478,
0.0776480436,
-0.5201530457,
-0.6977553964,
0.1416938752,
0.3237526417,
0.4381448925,
-0.924344182,
0.0552847944,
-0.102217339,
-0.0763589367,
-0.4127413034,
0.2846702337,
0.4281878173,
0.1028909981,
0.2022934258,
-0.6201862693,
-0.2085587084,
-0.7485516071,
0.3437606692,
-0.6587380171,
-0.2595370114,
0.1431992799,
0.1934358329,
0.3903285563,
0.0936934203,
-0.2326583564,
-0.3141848743,
0.0137278708,
0.6120175719,
-0.0060126199,
0.5215085149,
0.6520147324,
-0.9630414844,
-0.1465009749,
0.3508461416,
-0.7152684331,
0.1670510322,
-0.2519674599,
0.0045857918,
-0.1963802725,
0.5613728166,
-0.3862321675,
0.2034846395,
0.6448765993,
0.0616082624,
0.3714586794,
-0.4616021812,
0.0481250808,
-0.8286073804,
-0.1484846324,
0.1523306519,
0.0754931122,
-0.5140834451,
-0.2209145874,
-0.1722279638,
-0.4350901842,
-0.3037925661,
0.1900912374,
-0.7336372137,
-0.2356042564,
-0.017047165,
0.2182384133,
0.1258812398,
0.8853892684,
0.235182032,
0.8321865797,
0.5018104315,
-0.6453877687,
0.5167118907,
0.0532174669,
-0.0884315223,
0.3235845566,
-0.4314332306,
0.035281051,
-0.2192597538,
-0.1711434126,
-0.7301493883,
0.0157410167,
0.5024456382,
-0.7532972693,
0.7926943302,
-0.211645633,
-0.2623596191,
-0.1203253195,
0.0734898299,
0.1996835768,
0.5182526112,
-0.6687495112,
0.6116168499,
0.4675813615,
0.2186968029,
-0.2731790543,
-1.0206938982,
-0.1156835631,
-0.1663866639,
-0.2507687211,
0.4028815627,
0.3182336092,
-0.332613349,
0.3143143952,
0.2519067824,
0.1733230799,
0.2096458226,
0.1612192094,
-0.2634339929,
-0.4791499972,
0.3044863641,
-0.3762580156,
-0.1510686725,
0.1242080629,
-0.7691609859,
0.4407871366,
-0.0003239309,
-0.2987503111,
-0.3366421163,
0.2580209076,
0.4437532425,
-0.55968225,
0.8237402439,
0.6914477348,
-0.3990699947,
-0.4265019894,
-0.0225228481,
0.0885997638,
-0.4403945208,
0.426040709,
-0.7352428436,
-0.4884169698,
0.714363277,
-0.032774698,
-0.3255692124,
0.4354252517,
0.3545453846,
-0.2085918784,
0.6420555711,
0.4537740648,
0.0491605438,
0.5087170005,
-0.7970526814,
-0.083516404,
-1.0382671356,
-0.6337502599,
-0.4764769077,
0.0532278344,
-1.0526138544,
-0.3502389789,
0.3107076883,
0.1535708904,
-0.1554022282,
-0.0432226323,
-0.3819816113,
0.0763689503,
0.4661820531,
0.1764063835,
-0.2796008289,
0.1194303557,
-0.4325272739,
-0.11029502,
-0.7674124837,
-0.3354873955,
0.7171446085,
0.1153700724,
0.7003929615,
0.3893986642,
0.6167112589,
0.4330024123,
0.0049306159,
-0.8401858211,
0.2501990497,
-0.7408435345,
0.1574042737,
-0.2315821797,
-0.3678346574,
-1.0227538347,
0.3849425912,
-0.2070005387,
-0.5312618017,
0.6397340298,
-0.1581818014,
-0.229260385,
0.6509113312,
-0.6125312448,
0.7411897182,
-0.3920308352,
-0.0655132681,
0.149044618,
-0.4461622536,
0.0111895157,
0.6118935347,
-0.3302026987,
0.3204856217,
0.1340920031,
0.8096396327,
-0.4163605571,
0.7944241762,
-0.2062361538,
-0.2550666034,
0.3806831837,
0.2744146287,
0.1506250501,
0.1002793163,
-0.1134636849,
0.0490995161,
-0.7626649737,
-0.4494326115,
-1.014431119,
0.7315987349,
-1.0231062174,
-0.6532542706,
-0.6531056762,
-0.2572092414,
-0.3891305923,
-0.2385366261,
0.2574220002,
0.6976492405,
-0.4848669171,
0.122369349,
0.9945002794,
-0.1476101726,
0.3254856169,
0.0125361588,
-0.0517197922,
-0.3178492486,
1.0758026838,
0.1532485485,
0.2486188114,
0.7501929402,
0.0781113729,
-0.0450350381,
-0.878251791,
-0.6440786123,
0.2935009301,
-0.8074349165,
0.1935004741,
-0.4362487793,
-0.5680835843,
-0.2521418929,
0.0525550134,
-0.0396886915,
-0.1524860412,
-0.5839140415,
-0.3208489716,
0.3755770624,
0.9726700783,
-0.3870432675,
0.5109558105,
-0.5042062402,
0.4029516578,
0.7139122486,
0.1890663207,
0.3239936531,
-0.5548846722,
-0.3214581311,
-0.189959392,
-0.0372517593,
-1.0178258419,
0.291788727,
0.3965710998,
0.6870186329,
0.5786562562,
-0.362567693,
0.3467561603,
-0.2191557437,
0.856941402,
0.0998664349,
-0.7770047784,
0.3093173206,
-0.3039313257,
0.2304487228,
0.1916928142,
0.3910837173,
-0.643697381,
-0.3470916748,
-0.6153311729,
-0.5992644429,
0.6635509133,
0.329107672,
0.1673216671,
-0.1296326667,
0.4477596879,
0.1976054311,
-0.1045618132,
-0.4510478675,
-0.5066092014,
-0.5033800006,
-0.2668414116,
-0.2329785973,
-0.4281706214,
0.0177041665,
0.3195368648,
0.6441110969,
0.0309225358,
0.3100030422,
0.2949679792,
-0.0256657843,
0.2160092741,
0.1268722564,
0.469683677,
0.301648438,
-0.0075826487,
0.428645879,
-0.0396095552,
-0.6812823415,
0.0799206793,
0.3232153356,
-0.0409734212,
0.1356170774,
0.6911024451,
1.2227945328,
-0.0762344375,
0.0471958444,
0.3411644101,
-0.1560677737,
-0.2643766999,
-0.3696399033,
0.1032262295,
0.1846150458,
0.1969318092,
0.2779241502,
0.0808390006,
0.1755613536,
-0.6608188748,
0.1607244313,
0.107191436,
-0.6490387917,
-0.5871136785,
0.6088156104,
0.0578409359,
-0.1422405541,
0.6671956182,
-0.5058654547,
-0.7261263132,
0.7997650504,
0.4442034662,
1.0053658485,
-0.4476292729,
0.4705457687,
0.4356765449,
0.3231044114,
0.3532390296,
0.2409399152,
-0.2921660542,
-0.8053479791,
0.1705548614,
-0.4727290869,
-0.2414214462,
0.6013774872,
-0.8697077632,
-0.0005698798,
-0.5087277889,
0.033072304,
0.1449981481,
0.0178070813,
-0.7469643354,
0.5947369337,
0.5137367845,
0.3317446411,
-0.9449568391,
0.7854049206,
0.6205601096,
-0.7321968675,
-1.1273447275,
0.4725596011,
0.08642786,
-0.7433090806,
0.7122917771,
-0.2506911457,
-0.3994978368,
-0.205245778,
0.001442089,
-0.6247519851,
0.7307936549,
0.3751658499,
-0.4660778344,
0.2552445233,
0.1406476349,
0.7188559175,
-0.3409769237,
0.1777048409,
0.1898215264,
0.216031611,
0.0027797204,
-0.685299933,
-0.1679477245,
-0.5398916006,
0.480796963,
-0.0079558361,
-0.6270086169,
1.0080223083,
-0.0327083655,
-0.6899574399,
0.0218294188,
1.0650954247,
-0.1048019752,
-0.1509191543,
0.4093535542,
0.6072198153,
0.9895712733,
-0.2506144941,
1.2051471472,
-0.061532706,
0.0074853022,
0.7397710681,
-0.1032578275,
0.366030097,
0.1374453902,
-0.180541113,
0.5700470805,
0.6809477806,
0.0986413509,
0.6058987379,
0.7375612855,
-0.3989587426,
0.0952998176,
-0.1024857014,
-0.4471829832,
0.5684641004,
0.682046771,
-0.2590797246,
0.0756423101,
0.4728981853,
-0.0120312627,
0.3624141216,
-0.4234396219,
0.9246966839,
0.2792410553,
-0.2603941262,
0.5758851171,
-0.142604053,
0.500212431,
-0.7391955256,
-0.3060901761,
-0.2066787779,
-0.0069285696,
-0.1397235841,
-0.8364957571,
0.1536864042,
-0.3859217763,
-0.1720527112,
0.0840182826,
0.3207264245,
-0.6768763661,
-0.2664293945,
0.8376719952,
0.3614501357,
0.3193252683,
0.3517528474,
-0.668436408,
-0.0476243459,
-0.1865795404,
-0.2999001443,
-0.0164815485,
1.0478332043,
-0.1407004446,
0.3007513285,
0.4974426627,
0.7036944032,
0.127263397,
0.7922061086,
0.6034681797,
-0.5703180432,
-0.6626734734,
-0.4353228211,
0.1217288151,
0.2773015499,
-0.322737515,
0.361018151,
0.3884640932,
1.2510300875,
0.0114592575,
0.9129512906,
0.2240392715,
0.0251907036,
-1.0042210817,
0.7502249479,
-0.4598267376,
0.1795713603,
0.2802994251,
-0.7304122448,
-0.4640235603,
0.6186320186,
-0.2353712469,
0.3357935548,
0.8344913721,
0.8239571452,
-0.0664120093,
0.0434016325,
0.572390914,
0.1758432835,
0.1074592248,
0.5921851993,
0.7450182438,
-0.4247683883,
0.6659712195,
-0.4128668308,
-0.0025627457,
0.0885910243,
-0.2579898834,
-0.7509572506,
-0.9713028073,
-0.269390732,
-0.4586381316,
0.3262921572,
0.4701399803,
0.4350962341,
-1.04918015,
-0.2883501053,
-0.1249232516,
0.0832176208,
-0.3181352019,
-0.2387950569,
0.7836503386,
-0.1727779359,
-0.7269271016,
0.3753809929,
0.285852015,
0.3368514478,
-0.5285311937,
-0.2953834236,
-0.0737723485,
-0.3353813291,
0.0006122643,
0.6387750506,
-0.5679636598,
-0.0109608946,
-0.1398599595,
-0.4325466752,
0.3660486937,
1.0866289139,
-0.6353351474,
0.6942266226,
0.5570324659,
0.4746984243,
0.5236278772,
-0.3678896427,
0.577200532,
-0.7166939974,
0.4609916806,
0.2933465242,
0.5839288831,
0.789046824,
-0.4691244066,
0.1584849358,
0.1603516936,
-0.0226497799,
-0.155164063,
0.2413357645,
-0.7881345153,
-0.0935621709,
0.9613338709,
-0.4107936323,
-0.446983248,
-0.2898438275,
0.0640198812,
0.5436789393,
-0.2490676939,
0.4112437963,
0.5013076663,
-0.0111001516,
-0.3984743059,
-0.4038686752,
0.7699096799,
0.2513696551,
-0.2055448294,
-0.3677181304,
-0.0214617085,
-0.1890535653,
0.2957929671,
0.5762132406,
-0.3233357668,
0.331318289,
0.4416251779,
0.1104201004,
-0.1185465381,
-0.4354717135,
-0.7762580514,
0.2302075922,
0.1852022707,
-0.4928362668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12498v2 | Multi-Head State Space Model for Speech Recognition | 2023-05-21T16:28:57 | 2023-05-25T21:55:58 | Yassir Fathullah, Chunyang Wu, Yuan Shangguan, Junteng Jia, Wenhan Xiong, Jay Mahadeokar, Chunxi Liu, Yangyang Shi, Ozlem Kalinli, Mike Seltzer, Mark J. F. Gales | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | State space models (SSMs) have recently shown promising results on
small-scale sequence and language modelling tasks, rivalling and outperforming
many attention-based approaches. In this paper, we propose a multi-head state
space (MH-SSM) architecture equipped with special gating mechanisms, where
parallel heads are taught to learn local and global temporal dynamics on
sequence data. As a drop-in replacement for multi-head attention in transformer
encoders, this new model significantly outperforms the transformer transducer
on the LibriSpeech speech recognition corpus. Furthermore, we augment the
transformer block with MH-SSMs layers, referred to as the Stateformer,
achieving state-of-the-art performance on the LibriSpeech task, with word error
rates of 1.76\%/4.37\% on the development and 1.91\%/4.36\% on the test sets
without using an external language model. | [
-0.2248452008,
-0.5250413418,
0.5580078959,
-0.0277878158,
-0.239930436,
0.0510550104,
-0.1603568643,
-0.24525702,
0.4388601482,
0.0020063678,
-0.6627013087,
-0.0844103917,
-0.6525198221,
-0.1555017531,
-0.4045085907,
0.5659849048,
-0.0506961532,
0.126790598,
-0.1077600643,
-0.1677149087,
-0.4552720487,
-0.6609948277,
-0.4742039144,
-0.3902720213,
0.4708447456,
0.0246510841,
0.5374867916,
0.5570754409,
0.3618671,
0.3249367476,
-0.3961009383,
0.1202920154,
-0.1751851439,
0.1275541037,
-0.0763744935,
-0.2224428207,
-0.5143172741,
-0.1395163834,
1.030919075,
0.4678869247,
-0.4886919856,
0.1262838095,
0.1689207703,
0.4680616558,
-0.5708304644,
0.431399405,
-0.478530854,
0.0524271429,
-0.2948554158,
0.0075981854,
-0.3191080689,
-0.0352248251,
0.3582554162,
-0.3183712661,
0.166686818,
-0.0211874507,
0.5239548087,
0.319347471,
-0.0694982037,
0.0443877839,
-0.9175482988,
0.6564663053,
-0.5865086913,
0.9381635189,
-0.2160869837,
0.4852105081,
-0.0708046928,
-0.5795171261,
-0.7447814941,
-0.1013336331,
0.0061257919,
0.0822005346,
-0.253041625,
-0.0850738212,
0.276438266,
0.4215708077,
-0.5453980565,
-0.0085943779,
-0.5247349143,
-0.2803001702,
0.0947698802,
0.2102697194,
0.0682939813,
-0.0153505122,
-0.4824647009,
-0.2724611461,
-0.5512030125,
0.4211073518,
-0.0698894411,
0.6264926791,
-0.3590997159,
0.247174561,
-0.0270136762,
0.7616669536,
0.2816790938,
-0.2465435117,
0.3836877942,
0.067639783,
-0.28219679,
0.0261168238,
0.5946297646,
-0.0737060085,
-0.0544415452,
-0.2883780301,
-0.1135641783,
0.2261353582,
0.5514270663,
-0.7152299285,
-0.0231014192,
0.3067058921,
-0.2438003719,
0.2608380914,
0.0051275748,
-0.5578092337,
-0.4541686475,
-0.5082160234,
0.5734416246,
-0.4788109064,
-0.2724388838,
0.1937816292,
0.0470509678,
0.4022796154,
0.1499115527,
-0.6559655666,
0.3235243559,
0.4761562645,
1.1579478979,
-0.5304995179,
-0.4485841095,
-0.508939743,
0.2268711179,
-0.1666554213,
0.6197690964,
-0.4735067785,
-0.3998969197,
-0.229874894,
0.2003045082,
-0.4003850818,
-0.3898115158,
0.3629288077,
-0.3790262043,
0.0137172863,
-0.0295249876,
-0.6156205535,
-0.3803849518,
-0.101595372,
-0.7230511308,
0.6583951116,
-0.0807610601,
-0.4368258119,
0.119175382,
-0.7245885134,
-0.4726838768,
0.1168906689,
-0.3940865695,
-0.6695139408,
0.0740179271,
0.2708881497,
0.6737286448,
-0.0802265108,
0.284589082,
-0.1646317095,
-0.4100694656,
0.0162476879,
-0.3071023226,
0.4698842466,
0.0733679906,
-0.3170738816,
0.2717669904,
-0.8361668587,
-0.0360608213,
0.1228571981,
-0.4981411099,
-0.0107071437,
0.146788165,
0.0946143717,
0.5546791553,
-0.0252604615,
-0.7243324518,
-0.1259957999,
-0.4508121312,
0.8554582,
0.3512696326,
-0.1183543727,
0.6095768213,
-0.3690531254,
0.5046671629,
0.476208657,
-0.0159518123,
-0.2704723775,
-0.4492783844,
-0.6896242499,
-0.4963536859,
0.0063355328,
0.613186121,
-0.392585814,
0.4681980014,
-0.4535917044,
-0.697676003,
-0.6901091337,
-0.3124829233,
0.3720152676,
0.5522364974,
0.5139110088,
-0.0742260441,
-0.4381015003,
-0.8903089166,
-0.142719686,
0.1550194025,
0.0866962373,
0.2046886683,
0.3555550873,
-0.1075635552,
0.864960134,
-0.1746314913,
-0.3956493735,
-0.2158556879,
-0.0987947881,
0.24063842,
0.5454542637,
0.2147838771,
-0.4915525317,
-0.0998936296,
-0.2751978934,
-0.5393364429,
0.4261353612,
0.0689588189,
0.1048443317,
0.0353523456,
0.3540773094,
-0.8552308083,
0.5558748841,
0.6692435145,
0.1171510965,
0.3553536534,
0.0213415958,
-0.0346556976,
-1.108366847,
-0.0208315086,
0.106256105,
-0.1900719851,
-0.9865191579,
0.1346218586,
0.516864419,
-0.5456421375,
-0.857845366,
0.433961153,
-0.5319396257,
-0.1337719858,
-0.4104439914,
0.1505854577,
-0.1543445885,
0.8318508863,
0.1998113394,
0.8889468312,
0.8204317689,
-0.8240956068,
0.1285144985,
0.2892705202,
-0.4206830859,
0.4649950862,
-0.6213453412,
0.5067757368,
-0.3292610347,
0.3351123333,
-0.8619407415,
-0.0259971768,
-0.1015035585,
-0.309576422,
0.3731457293,
-0.0876655877,
-0.1883238405,
-0.5393499732,
-0.0607508458,
0.2914492786,
0.3572207987,
-0.5947798491,
0.9841970205,
0.7307437062,
-0.1772354692,
-0.4126367569,
-0.7184282541,
-0.2237737626,
-0.1751526147,
-0.4672836661,
0.4285760224,
0.1630408615,
0.3136809766,
-0.3077456653,
-0.48328951,
0.0989376083,
-0.2209853977,
0.4597998559,
0.2560136914,
-0.2253205627,
0.069955416,
-0.1304923147,
-0.0674747899,
-0.0856798738,
-0.446813792,
0.7379968762,
-0.3297118545,
-0.3099448085,
-0.7301895618,
0.2411678135,
0.6484929323,
-0.5837371945,
0.7093082666,
0.5062160492,
-0.7009932995,
-0.1640001088,
-0.3282058537,
-0.3040401936,
-0.4752597511,
0.4761641622,
-0.5737617016,
-1.2305430174,
0.3992338777,
0.0094219418,
0.0218956806,
0.2559666932,
0.7474274039,
-0.2288469523,
0.6858235598,
0.4772827923,
-0.4299989641,
0.4734819233,
-0.1740164757,
0.3261216283,
-0.9698967338,
-0.1859617978,
-0.2855819464,
-0.5071229935,
-0.4745772481,
-0.6060222387,
0.692833662,
-0.0506254099,
-0.1986120343,
0.5844490528,
-0.4867354035,
0.2142176181,
0.572878778,
0.3948636353,
-0.0880605429,
0.0412417017,
-0.2576223016,
-0.222436443,
-0.6481360793,
-0.3459479213,
0.7470404506,
0.3409841955,
0.9798240662,
0.0697975457,
0.5224609971,
0.0059809564,
-0.3159225285,
-0.7685261965,
0.5082944632,
-0.2770611048,
-0.3869823813,
-0.5084345341,
-0.0995123759,
-0.7100110054,
0.6366103292,
-0.0648311749,
-0.7147091031,
0.3586173952,
0.2697312236,
-0.8333470821,
0.5068868995,
-0.432048887,
0.593239069,
0.1176166609,
-0.0089150425,
-0.3570640683,
-0.6044290662,
0.0950073376,
0.0485983044,
0.1213099211,
-0.1568808556,
0.2228493094,
0.7318452597,
0.0220296122,
0.7467519045,
-0.6061096787,
0.0327421539,
0.2616391182,
0.0485055968,
0.4911616445,
-0.1737098992,
0.1566536576,
0.2772182822,
-0.1555097699,
0.01011841,
-0.4174774587,
0.4881541729,
-0.5966179371,
-0.4664668739,
-0.353803277,
-0.690156579,
-0.4050988257,
0.1389048547,
-0.2057409286,
0.6942024827,
-0.1240155473,
0.2352217883,
0.6814703345,
-0.0779205188,
0.5638868213,
0.6607550979,
-0.085922353,
-0.3667885959,
0.8248127699,
0.0932420641,
0.1351595521,
0.5620770454,
0.2246314138,
-0.3761241436,
-0.2136150897,
-0.3396691084,
0.1326430142,
-0.4447089732,
-0.174938187,
-0.8228183389,
-0.6802240014,
-0.4993137717,
0.3781535625,
-0.4705733657,
-0.3189916015,
-0.0663040057,
-0.0960677639,
0.2703730762,
0.432987541,
-0.0865282565,
0.6865079403,
-0.6975457668,
0.6189380884,
0.5005347133,
0.2214838266,
0.0402282961,
-0.8234264255,
-0.4245040715,
-0.094547011,
-0.3062083721,
-0.8224037886,
0.3380382061,
0.3724686503,
0.6143075824,
0.1731182784,
-0.4983043373,
0.9158042669,
-1.1281303167,
0.4981327951,
0.1883812845,
-1.0078628063,
0.588766396,
-0.2156884521,
0.6493235826,
0.1137099564,
0.2404016405,
-0.8287205696,
-0.5165628791,
-0.2869158685,
-0.556362927,
0.9398216605,
-0.0831677243,
-0.1556730866,
0.3677760661,
0.2675639987,
0.0580307879,
0.3105610311,
-0.5108391047,
-0.3185509741,
-0.1755748391,
-0.1071800888,
-0.10484045,
-0.0321016796,
0.1260096431,
-0.3225914836,
0.5506775379,
-0.0534087755,
0.6268535852,
0.061299365,
-0.399767518,
-0.0299863834,
0.534809649,
0.702714324,
0.6151497364,
-0.0079035982,
0.0657563657,
0.0942857042,
-0.5031759143,
0.3101237416,
0.2983967662,
-0.3373717666,
0.1327889264,
-0.1054165065,
1.3193312883,
0.5254750252,
-0.1413493454,
0.3860401809,
0.2360690534,
-0.1226659343,
-0.2682655454,
0.0061187143,
0.290533632,
0.4037714005,
0.3271830976,
0.3249179125,
0.1396963,
-0.0214679558,
0.3216130137,
0.3236505985,
-0.3604474664,
-0.4679101706,
0.9780698419,
0.1026321128,
-0.3639632761,
0.3077214062,
0.0139915003,
-0.5036901832,
0.3331418633,
0.4979104698,
0.8635282516,
-0.7799253464,
-0.0762638375,
0.4131155312,
0.3524310887,
-0.2116811574,
0.6801885962,
-0.0204591043,
-0.8341750503,
-0.4058280289,
-0.6363982558,
-0.6134701371,
0.3943063617,
-0.6900441647,
0.2221016586,
-0.4735918641,
-0.3218762577,
0.175193578,
-0.5070207119,
-0.7829068303,
0.2006970346,
0.5837546587,
0.6648621559,
-0.6096583009,
1.121473074,
0.6797794104,
-0.1876049638,
-0.5779492259,
-0.1322305053,
0.2447742969,
-0.9115818739,
0.2475159466,
0.4472069442,
-0.5828562975,
0.0625511184,
-0.1523265392,
-1.1773432493,
1.087272644,
0.4065183997,
-1.0415794849,
-0.3519199789,
0.0327181965,
0.1995631307,
-0.239467591,
-0.0229251124,
0.6302756667,
0.0783391073,
-0.4162324071,
-1.1100583076,
-0.1943682134,
0.0667299256,
0.3099836111,
0.138745591,
-0.7955544591,
1.1004174948,
-0.182586953,
-0.5281090736,
-0.1335725039,
0.9223693013,
0.567609489,
-0.2384780794,
0.8094701767,
0.6528119445,
0.6802003384,
-0.1765479892,
0.5006786585,
-0.4661325812,
0.287882328,
1.3459123373,
-0.5009347796,
1.2188000679,
0.4434081018,
-0.4557480812,
0.5713061094,
0.1272103637,
0.1208036914,
0.7291605473,
0.1629166156,
-0.1048315912,
-0.1767333001,
0.3525368869,
-0.1880654693,
0.6261916161,
0.3822817802,
0.0027208752,
-0.1462632418,
0.4722440541,
-0.1923134029,
-0.0750133395,
-0.3768522441,
0.6146706939,
0.2573138475,
-0.1972047985,
0.2155912966,
0.0986774787,
0.886099875,
-0.6508497,
0.1537239701,
0.0187528897,
0.3817690313,
0.0245081633,
-0.510984242,
0.2287396789,
-0.1154889911,
-0.4743442237,
-0.2352480143,
0.7449029088,
-0.6898157001,
-0.4526445866,
0.3433029354,
0.5939504504,
0.1955136955,
-0.2750571668,
-0.6007877588,
0.0151087064,
-0.5426101685,
-0.0216804575,
0.1165074036,
-0.0190901905,
0.101141654,
0.5615254045,
0.3847194016,
0.2123894393,
0.5680029988,
0.4392096102,
0.5689929724,
-0.8138149381,
-1.1004317999,
-0.8130899668,
0.3871117532,
0.1597003788,
0.0558236986,
0.5352472663,
0.5323739052,
0.8090180159,
-0.1877364367,
0.6841928959,
-0.0320443213,
1.181501627,
-0.3875528574,
0.9074065685,
-0.3953301609,
-0.3990746439,
-0.0179176889,
-0.6243293285,
0.0313138962,
0.6277640462,
0.1160438433,
0.1328750402,
0.7055423856,
0.792006135,
-0.0903314948,
0.2198690623,
0.5259716511,
0.1070905253,
0.1642590761,
0.7974470854,
0.7968633175,
-0.4984316826,
0.3567431271,
-0.3587257862,
-0.0775196478,
0.0471224003,
-0.5058071017,
-0.7481081486,
-0.8269488811,
-0.2178692818,
-0.0347221382,
0.0211183857,
0.9006119967,
1.0465120077,
-1.1464242935,
-0.4273799062,
0.2481760681,
-0.4645354748,
-0.5115996599,
-0.164478004,
0.3014799058,
-0.3732053041,
-0.7775003314,
0.9669830799,
0.4360015392,
-0.0693182647,
-0.4503977299,
-0.0390700325,
-0.0829765052,
-0.1767733693,
0.571328938,
0.1807078123,
-0.9875118136,
-0.2700758576,
-0.0973949134,
-0.1443687677,
0.335160315,
0.9371922016,
-0.8551858068,
0.4144157767,
0.2068977654,
0.8683048487,
0.5266147256,
-0.1702581942,
0.4004473686,
-0.835562706,
0.3148770034,
0.0997986495,
0.6356098056,
0.3120480776,
-0.1397329867,
0.1124205887,
0.2397662401,
-0.5054605603,
-0.4743511975,
-0.0291963872,
-0.9356789589,
0.1590907723,
0.8615639806,
-0.0906602591,
-0.4027627707,
0.2351795733,
0.0246846769,
0.5032124519,
-0.4872757792,
0.5550748706,
0.6640483141,
-0.2140439004,
-0.3879564404,
-0.4318901002,
0.3243806064,
0.1911983639,
-0.6416802406,
-0.0040672063,
0.3434162736,
0.3269892037,
0.3399375677,
0.5005970001,
-0.1407149881,
0.5066205859,
-0.173282817,
0.2939275801,
-0.1784998327,
-0.697699368,
-0.9464429617,
0.1786083132,
-0.3981438577,
-0.8270730376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12495v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12495v2 | Fair Without Leveling Down: A New Intersectional Fairness Definition | 2023-05-21T16:15:12 | 2023-11-07T10:19:02 | Gaurav Maheshwari, Aurélien Bellet, Pascal Denis, Mikaela Keller | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY | In this work, we consider the problem of intersectional group fairness in the
classification setting, where the objective is to learn discrimination-free
models in the presence of several intersecting sensitive groups. First, we
illustrate various shortcomings of existing fairness measures commonly used to
capture intersectional fairness. Then, we propose a new definition called the
$\alpha$-Intersectional Fairness, which combines the absolute and the relative
performance across sensitive groups and can be seen as a generalization of the
notion of differential fairness. We highlight several desirable properties of
the proposed definition and analyze its relation to other fairness measures.
Finally, we benchmark multiple popular in-processing fair machine learning
approaches using our new fairness definition and show that they do not achieve
any improvement over a simple baseline. Our results reveal that the increase in
fairness measured by previous definitions hides a "leveling down" effect, i.e.,
degrading the best performance over groups rather than improving the worst one. | [
-0.6250369549,
-0.5231045485,
0.5679888129,
0.0387694575,
0.0550043434,
0.1435282528,
0.0892838165,
-0.8138983846,
0.0148185585,
0.0886868313,
-0.171980679,
-0.3756740391,
-1.1010080576,
-0.0788227469,
-0.5665884614,
0.8569898009,
0.0712732449,
0.2818978429,
-0.3256796598,
-0.5800641179,
-0.4023467302,
-0.6123818159,
-0.6539261937,
-0.3241443336,
0.6115999222,
0.5358582735,
0.7242135406,
0.8036453724,
0.4860200286,
0.3454114795,
-0.1903755069,
-0.4423140883,
-0.4778627157,
-0.1684631705,
-0.0247345529,
-0.6935238242,
-0.5023294091,
0.2977250814,
0.774512291,
1.2869274616,
-0.1155006513,
-0.0865587518,
-0.0240369476,
0.8444737196,
-1.1464835405,
-0.2380955368,
-0.9345817566,
0.5420995355,
-0.2469005883,
0.0982673168,
-0.0860570222,
-0.70534271,
-0.1093518212,
-0.6146215796,
0.53386724,
0.1576772034,
0.6004901528,
0.3526153564,
-0.5176870823,
0.0562109873,
-0.3126498461,
0.9990357757,
-0.3429937065,
0.1410850585,
0.4259722829,
0.8330176473,
0.2677350044,
-0.6297269464,
-0.7027043104,
0.1488351673,
-0.0400272422,
0.0831503123,
-0.3266550303,
0.346994698,
0.4041629136,
0.7179501653,
-0.0217190795,
0.1338972449,
-0.5694249868,
0.2672427893,
0.6571562886,
0.2994382083,
-0.0853508636,
0.1298068613,
-0.3101798892,
0.1885981262,
-0.6352297664,
0.5218339562,
0.4252134562,
0.4616370499,
-0.1651930809,
0.3292994201,
-0.4753975272,
0.1167816371,
0.1817401201,
0.501036644,
0.5642455816,
0.1169098914,
-0.2338987887,
-0.0968343392,
0.3309311569,
0.7367996573,
0.180674538,
-0.4747406244,
-0.5379390121,
0.1971782297,
0.0228835568,
-0.7363824248,
-0.206467852,
-0.1803276241,
-0.679885149,
-0.431753844,
0.132913202,
-0.5721315742,
-0.4771958888,
-0.4402538538,
0.4020660818,
0.2034813762,
-0.1703342497,
0.1211738065,
-0.2252573669,
0.1627557576,
0.2610877156,
-0.8215634227,
0.7614325285,
0.7610064149,
0.5974382162,
-0.2953853309,
-0.0947329924,
-0.7435808182,
0.0359741524,
-0.093407914,
0.4468648136,
-0.7447890043,
-0.247613579,
-0.1967473328,
-0.1466348767,
0.1419092268,
-0.7601369619,
0.3023709655,
-0.3487688303,
0.3863222003,
-0.4822075665,
-0.3984096944,
-0.4580254853,
0.0891050771,
-0.5048071742,
0.4277130961,
0.0970130414,
-0.6254610419,
0.9165052772,
-0.8539537787,
-0.6108146906,
0.2244468033,
-0.3427217901,
-0.4965044856,
0.4029731154,
0.0335302576,
0.0479064733,
0.214363113,
0.0494380258,
-0.6976451874,
-0.6472456455,
0.034347292,
0.0623992458,
0.8852605224,
0.1995743811,
-0.4136028886,
0.0470961966,
-0.5794219971,
0.1057671756,
-0.0829884931,
-0.0459899567,
-0.2977234423,
0.0045865057,
-0.0785608441,
0.4503594041,
-0.0334566757,
-0.4967886508,
-0.2637722194,
-0.2924210429,
0.0576551706,
1.3325206041,
-0.5959527493,
0.7573177814,
-0.8408566117,
0.4163947403,
-0.0628465712,
0.5836423635,
0.6214137673,
-0.5152339339,
-0.9139009714,
-0.4705667496,
0.5259691477,
0.5227868557,
-0.4988101125,
0.4203858674,
-0.0348067544,
-0.0006142281,
-0.7623137236,
-0.2539231479,
0.4582931101,
0.5342220664,
0.476898402,
-0.7158337235,
-0.3842984736,
-0.9332113862,
-0.4318885803,
0.2495269775,
-0.0860784575,
0.4970047772,
0.1165874451,
0.1377305388,
0.7529828548,
0.0184011497,
-0.4042596817,
0.058443483,
0.0794429258,
-0.0012261478,
0.4847122729,
0.6500148177,
-1.0221495628,
-0.3807714581,
-0.2745748162,
-0.6636461616,
-0.3061376214,
0.7696695328,
-0.1178489253,
0.0402289256,
0.4309746027,
-0.0517428927,
0.7144577503,
0.1508613527,
-0.4179270566,
-0.0394207425,
0.1912121475,
0.3722108603,
-0.4419110119,
-0.0237612613,
-0.1031832173,
-0.3345260024,
-0.5517556667,
0.2037725747,
-0.2517647445,
0.3423481584,
-0.8193730116,
0.5744218826,
-0.042948775,
-0.508823216,
-0.538641274,
0.2237733752,
0.097219862,
0.5073289871,
-0.297835052,
0.2075891495,
0.7600107193,
-0.8712764978,
0.0175135843,
0.1940814555,
0.0326791592,
0.9289188385,
-0.4234886169,
0.067444101,
-0.6277684569,
0.1266846806,
-0.4166986048,
0.1080392301,
0.4029922485,
-0.5562515259,
-0.3302584291,
-0.3032620847,
-0.1342689991,
-0.1632987112,
-0.3289106488,
1.1675150394,
0.8315312266,
-0.5350427628,
0.4116078019,
0.7425652742,
-0.0889926776,
-0.5869303346,
-0.9763290882,
-0.3242435455,
-0.6277223825,
-0.5738382936,
0.5500155687,
0.0613975264,
-0.5613847971,
-0.0436190329,
-0.0154637247,
-0.2818244696,
0.3632202744,
0.3514124453,
-0.1131502241,
0.0581379868,
0.0938035771,
0.0012803709,
-0.1678604037,
-0.0339048915,
0.2337422371,
0.29656443,
-0.2688722014,
-0.3548293412,
-0.560972929,
0.646556735,
-0.0659330785,
-0.2075853646,
0.3243320882,
0.3753990829,
-0.743035078,
0.1606407166,
-0.3436288834,
-0.0924725235,
-0.4917438328,
0.0351135656,
-0.407754451,
-1.0698580742,
0.8359382153,
0.4391675293,
0.2097054273,
0.4575161636,
0.2533835769,
0.0666316524,
1.3725098372,
0.9447821379,
0.292794019,
0.5514042377,
0.1371432692,
0.3841266632,
-0.519949913,
-0.374949038,
-0.8026841283,
-0.924413085,
-0.8642559052,
-0.1184950396,
0.2683867216,
0.3568938971,
-0.6032863259,
-0.3724277318,
-0.3709235489,
0.7055340409,
0.7010238171,
0.0354949236,
0.5322348475,
0.0443288684,
0.1844592392,
-0.1214399189,
-0.4156350493,
-0.271635592,
1.1430178881,
0.2886592448,
0.4118531644,
0.1801374704,
0.8540830016,
0.4100573659,
0.6192497015,
-0.4563482404,
0.4481967092,
-0.4929563701,
-0.5968164802,
-0.1518989503,
-1.1085180044,
-1.0733745098,
0.4224835634,
-0.2486841381,
-0.7611472607,
0.3342083097,
0.1246930808,
-0.3855896592,
0.6157960296,
-0.5915369391,
0.8172965646,
-0.3558241725,
-0.1403294653,
-0.4230994582,
-0.576153636,
0.38248083,
0.0534267686,
0.545927465,
-0.7464923859,
-0.0178806931,
0.6820147038,
-0.175884068,
0.2328932583,
-0.7031956315,
0.4734067321,
-0.1246445701,
-0.0115208831,
-0.2064552307,
-0.0666107237,
-0.0656604469,
0.3646734059,
-0.2542025447,
-1.0238524675,
-0.5130619407,
0.5034142733,
-0.5023721457,
-0.2918843031,
-0.3878974319,
-0.7016128898,
-0.1206594408,
0.310195297,
-0.0676936582,
0.0650679395,
-0.0228099786,
-0.0693023205,
0.3542279899,
-0.1499846131,
0.3363618851,
0.5076534748,
-0.5741032958,
-0.2315203547,
0.8150053024,
-0.0680272579,
0.2806723416,
0.1636115909,
0.0131361773,
-0.4069228172,
-0.7452300191,
0.0276139751,
-0.2946814597,
-0.473710537,
-0.0916759819,
-0.5480406284,
-0.0382053927,
-0.3130292892,
-0.210295707,
-0.1179562956,
-0.9513744712,
0.2077329308,
-0.0172649696,
0.0777713805,
0.8570274115,
-0.5250249505,
0.309658885,
-0.2400378436,
0.705755949,
0.3832544684,
0.7741478682,
-0.039585039,
-0.3677788079,
0.1276224703,
0.2635949254,
-0.668002367,
-0.0937152058,
-0.1698608547,
-0.0730675533,
0.7530554533,
0.2296467125,
0.3081016541,
0.3340407014,
-0.2462796569,
0.2635433376,
0.623906374,
-1.2194342613,
0.1977386624,
0.0446839891,
-0.156269297,
0.9053723812,
0.1963504702,
-0.4772834778,
-0.7624005675,
-0.5912533402,
-1.1300278902,
0.6046907902,
0.3281618655,
0.0659237429,
-0.0017661842,
0.2372190207,
0.3701005578,
0.4081703424,
-1.2828433514,
-0.2731731236,
-0.2034080178,
-0.2646872401,
0.2457678467,
0.3443516195,
-0.300752908,
-0.4231722653,
0.4009487331,
0.0813558847,
0.0142521542,
-0.2883005738,
-0.082411252,
-0.2837008238,
0.1289842725,
0.0149839865,
0.7759424448,
-0.2433633953,
0.1565095335,
0.3290379941,
0.0528732538,
0.0315951966,
0.5195526481,
-0.2740920484,
-0.3885685205,
-0.1866395324,
0.4421446025,
-0.2026266456,
-0.379440248,
0.8384436965,
-0.3993814588,
-0.3886816204,
-0.0526262112,
0.1880209744,
-0.7122322321,
0.3914091885,
0.5265668035,
0.3099342883,
0.550830245,
-0.3274831772,
0.4607259929,
0.7145386934,
-0.7184678316,
0.2167436182,
0.7659680843,
0.4571768343,
-0.2777047753,
0.4160588086,
-0.6525664926,
-0.4732613266,
0.52846241,
-0.1202182695,
0.6634352803,
0.0752294213,
-0.2190695703,
-0.1159493402,
0.049147211,
0.2123907506,
0.0019447024,
-0.0337447152,
-0.6220375896,
-0.2211162448,
-0.470162034,
-0.3630930185,
-0.1148995832,
-0.7054163814,
0.1773285866,
-0.7034021616,
-0.1938555986,
-0.1096904352,
0.0100533962,
-0.694045186,
0.2876436412,
0.3705013692,
0.6415138245,
-0.8222760558,
0.1620918959,
0.3662239313,
-0.4462083578,
-0.266741246,
0.0670037344,
-0.2976214886,
-0.7909165621,
0.1382346749,
0.6929735541,
-0.0112218577,
-0.3401684165,
-0.4532930255,
-0.3435799479,
0.9169089794,
0.4534100294,
-0.2410009801,
-0.2329936028,
0.4188856781,
0.1574631333,
-0.3889266551,
0.3895127177,
0.4818609953,
0.4971102178,
-0.1239043325,
-1.0502663851,
0.0908984244,
-0.2602045238,
-0.0562172942,
0.0092268055,
-0.643106997,
1.059014678,
-0.0626119152,
-0.3802482188,
0.153950423,
0.5603470206,
0.3604709804,
0.9708794951,
0.8577187061,
1.0325423479,
0.9026594162,
-0.3848944008,
0.961885035,
0.1345136315,
0.1584050506,
0.6439071298,
-0.2256661057,
0.1974380314,
0.3521075547,
-0.2202925831,
0.0549531393,
0.4707220495,
0.2968724072,
0.6557320952,
0.653745234,
-0.3824467361,
-0.4755758941,
-0.089524515,
-0.756759882,
0.3681384623,
-0.1353871226,
-0.0966268405,
-0.4497361481,
0.0554549322,
-0.2150447369,
0.5338879824,
-1.0432705879,
0.5978050828,
0.2736487985,
-0.3051483035,
0.3669611514,
0.2282900065,
1.0846015215,
0.1184825897,
-0.0980490744,
-0.3064782321,
0.3989101946,
-0.4393624961,
-0.7939048409,
0.3507779837,
-0.1961561888,
-0.4811274707,
-0.1933297515,
0.2010240555,
-0.2564257979,
-0.4717174768,
0.7352122664,
0.5567654371,
0.3099821806,
0.0796630681,
-0.7828298807,
-0.2461891919,
-0.193163231,
0.3445303142,
0.3629401028,
0.6029573679,
-0.1289918721,
0.6023450494,
0.3077905476,
-0.2448960841,
0.5642197132,
0.3035428822,
0.5800885558,
-0.7111853361,
-0.7677465677,
-0.4607417881,
0.5984826684,
-0.1271985173,
-0.0780136213,
0.2662775218,
0.6364768147,
1.1431672573,
0.6503112316,
0.8730970621,
-0.1500146091,
0.8291119337,
-0.4102666676,
0.6273630857,
-0.781436801,
0.2495685369,
-0.2327338904,
-0.7391554117,
-0.4589498937,
0.6306134462,
-0.5432503819,
0.7509238124,
0.2531722486,
0.5103231072,
-0.3831737936,
0.2158465236,
0.2706847489,
-0.0135753192,
0.3702616096,
1.0025684834,
1.1354956627,
-0.27041471,
0.4773921967,
-0.227131635,
-0.5240210891,
-0.1111842915,
-0.7063579559,
-0.6739488244,
-0.1296867281,
-0.1854436398,
-0.2863642573,
0.3337002397,
0.4124064744,
0.7978034616,
-0.799218595,
-0.0694159642,
-0.3436869979,
0.6860514283,
0.048639711,
-0.278121978,
-0.1090385467,
-0.4014177918,
-0.7472607493,
-0.1013584286,
-0.0806630999,
0.023078952,
0.3334667087,
-0.4147153199,
0.1841657013,
-0.1141239554,
0.3287664056,
0.3356189728,
-0.2951808572,
-0.4028144181,
-0.6480198503,
-0.0681836084,
0.4228734374,
0.6255648732,
-0.9078117013,
0.0036443609,
0.0859943181,
0.537581563,
0.3848748803,
0.1076924056,
0.431291908,
-0.7060250044,
0.292804718,
0.623758018,
0.3826646209,
0.4480579793,
0.1107213423,
0.2914437652,
0.3344281912,
-0.480042398,
-0.902180016,
0.6244825125,
-0.7043085694,
-0.1405609399,
0.666146338,
0.0138892727,
0.0709386393,
-0.123525016,
0.3581216633,
0.2897418141,
-0.5435189605,
1.2456671,
0.2172796875,
-0.4176235497,
0.1322581619,
-0.2605762184,
0.5299588442,
0.6293138266,
-0.7658640146,
-0.0996879712,
0.5893665552,
0.1609578878,
-0.0564492866,
0.8703010082,
-0.4337303042,
0.6078439951,
-0.5339583755,
0.1901086718,
0.0366778523,
-0.3311764002,
-0.6248223186,
0.5217010379,
0.0175457783,
-0.3494407237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12493v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12493v5 | Contextualized End-to-End Speech Recognition with Contextual Phrase Prediction Network | 2023-05-21T16:08:04 | 2023-07-12T17:41:53 | Kaixun Huang, Ao Zhang, Zhanheng Yang, Pengcheng Guo, Bingshen Mu, Tianyi Xu, Lei Xie | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Contextual information plays a crucial role in speech recognition
technologies and incorporating it into the end-to-end speech recognition models
has drawn immense interest recently. However, previous deep bias methods lacked
explicit supervision for bias tasks. In this study, we introduce a contextual
phrase prediction network for an attention-based deep bias method. This network
predicts context phrases in utterances using contextual embeddings and
calculates bias loss to assist in the training of the contextualized model. Our
method achieved a significant word error rate (WER) reduction across various
end-to-end speech recognition models. Experiments on the LibriSpeech corpus
show that our proposed model obtains a 12.1% relative WER improvement over the
baseline model, and the WER of the context phrases decreases relatively by
40.5%. Moreover, by applying a context phrase filtering strategy, we also
effectively eliminate the WER degradation when using a larger biasing list. | [
-0.4987560511,
-0.5541884303,
0.2505537868,
0.1344689429,
-0.4153697789,
-0.323099792,
-0.2952855229,
-0.1390031129,
0.2707210779,
0.6397397518,
-0.6278887987,
-0.3325501978,
-0.6586182714,
-0.2055150568,
-0.3832520545,
0.6438202262,
0.1787359118,
0.4812923372,
-0.2993707955,
0.0108739175,
-0.8754196167,
-0.4653344154,
-0.758272469,
-0.5275177956,
0.2760342062,
0.0530317239,
0.2981432676,
0.4000863731,
0.2281379849,
0.1829776019,
-0.6648552418,
-0.0547580644,
-0.5150943398,
0.3194251955,
-0.3191084862,
-0.260111481,
-0.1673218757,
-0.2269489169,
0.421530813,
0.9287139773,
-0.1886434853,
0.0601661392,
0.054769747,
0.5964653492,
-0.6879886985,
-0.0377417468,
-0.7355138063,
0.4708604515,
-0.1455050707,
-0.4262848496,
-0.4164942205,
0.1334289163,
0.7347947359,
-0.1567741185,
0.0832516402,
-0.0027086015,
0.2033649981,
0.6686602831,
-0.3318193257,
-0.0443318263,
-0.3317640126,
0.5287849307,
-0.6373066902,
0.5297728777,
0.4587521851,
0.1927598566,
-0.0850228667,
-0.7411176562,
-0.2934535146,
-0.1401723772,
0.1981317103,
0.4062566459,
-0.0631347597,
0.0509601124,
0.1178187504,
0.0029431581,
-0.4696988761,
-0.0590379871,
-0.3768794835,
-0.1501512229,
0.2412841767,
-0.1454682201,
0.0096364673,
0.0785090253,
-0.4978435338,
0.1703107655,
-0.5679005384,
-0.1175015122,
-0.0681219697,
0.3453070223,
0.0798503608,
0.3579087257,
-0.2853335142,
0.7498138547,
0.1753473878,
0.1250126511,
0.3465794921,
0.0247466061,
-0.4851309359,
0.6665126085,
0.4412297904,
0.723382771,
0.2710005343,
-0.4544191957,
-0.0378866568,
-0.0111997565,
0.069675602,
-0.8523555398,
0.136310041,
0.0181222241,
-0.366669178,
0.074932754,
-0.1098748073,
-0.3546603322,
-0.4580750763,
-0.4316111207,
0.1522824466,
-0.3313043714,
0.0793824717,
0.0645426139,
-0.1935877055,
0.1698803455,
0.2860977352,
-0.2594221532,
0.2031001747,
0.3613381684,
1.1003382206,
0.0179405864,
-0.0387814082,
-0.6505961418,
0.368919313,
-0.3021916449,
0.4134857357,
-0.321042031,
-0.4968866408,
0.0688186437,
0.0128950169,
-0.0635807738,
-0.3241074085,
0.7611920834,
-0.5514564514,
0.3207088113,
-0.1210178733,
-1.0103677511,
-0.1319417059,
0.078283824,
-0.5518675447,
0.4926005006,
-0.4175898135,
-0.8938997388,
0.3394242525,
-0.6093304753,
-0.7039833665,
-0.1629626453,
0.0288640019,
-0.3923003078,
0.271386385,
0.4174769521,
0.6685552001,
-0.3377902508,
0.5612421036,
-0.4139055312,
-0.4242454171,
0.3374087811,
-0.5951644182,
0.661601305,
0.144517228,
-0.6220870614,
-0.0212112851,
-0.6129333377,
-0.0652985424,
-0.1297150403,
-0.0997314006,
-0.5444295406,
0.1174696013,
0.3225981593,
0.3180016577,
0.0950054675,
-0.5535519719,
-0.23117432,
-0.6288305521,
0.4435704052,
0.7597251534,
-0.1650834382,
0.694213748,
0.1059572622,
0.2862273753,
-0.0864128917,
-0.1370165497,
-0.3126750588,
-0.4287474155,
-0.6027236581,
0.1967494935,
0.1459237784,
0.5224987864,
-0.380187273,
0.7497097254,
-0.3796714842,
-0.0799628347,
-0.062951766,
-0.1358126402,
0.7557037473,
0.9427883029,
0.3680839241,
-0.3032913804,
-0.7541978955,
-0.914327383,
-0.2854118049,
0.3772381544,
-0.1180073097,
0.3928286433,
0.1767076105,
-0.3573428392,
1.157541275,
-0.4225785732,
-0.9013091326,
-0.1056482196,
-0.1613353938,
0.1824535131,
0.3441928029,
0.1992369294,
-0.7079369426,
-0.4585819244,
-0.1142424271,
-0.3590741456,
-0.1446919292,
0.2323283106,
0.0374085195,
-0.0501152575,
0.7740100026,
-0.1449944824,
0.4632718861,
0.4882200956,
-0.4781059623,
-0.0358489491,
0.0994224623,
-0.5548301339,
-1.4465903044,
-0.0791346878,
0.1875056475,
-0.3071516454,
-0.7574647069,
-0.5386748314,
-0.183890149,
0.0646768361,
-0.4092837274,
0.67437464,
-0.3882890344,
-0.3881794214,
-0.2745422125,
0.3201083839,
0.1860146075,
0.3035772443,
0.1501523703,
0.9710898995,
0.6250042915,
-0.445007652,
0.2354501039,
0.3219446242,
-0.1430456936,
0.4478245378,
-0.8285755515,
0.2082196474,
-0.1923966855,
0.7371371388,
-0.8622804284,
-0.0724348575,
-0.2778550982,
-0.6582443118,
0.4978693426,
-0.1530080885,
0.0463308282,
-0.0255094245,
-0.0637194514,
0.1705234498,
0.2323005646,
-0.6386166811,
0.2415192872,
0.5521708727,
-0.0105419094,
-0.773955524,
-0.9646031857,
0.3251030445,
-0.1486054659,
-0.5942003131,
0.8016461134,
0.0785366446,
0.235595122,
-0.1156850681,
-0.0519595668,
-0.100766845,
-0.1796167195,
0.2517540455,
-0.2921930254,
-0.0818047076,
0.3633738756,
-0.0341027789,
-0.0264729615,
0.2016931921,
-0.7995081544,
0.7250438333,
-0.0838714093,
0.0058479556,
-0.3753626347,
0.2358249426,
0.3029682934,
-0.3152557611,
0.5242846608,
1.1039056778,
-0.5551986694,
-0.0660765395,
-0.5223765969,
-0.1256477088,
-0.366815865,
0.7668655515,
-0.1943552196,
-1.018540144,
0.4474225044,
-0.0399560928,
-0.3730579615,
-0.0129559264,
0.4865117073,
0.0953622684,
0.8416154981,
0.4713951051,
-0.4705803394,
0.6864650846,
-0.4408268332,
0.0507833995,
-1.406281352,
-0.1907478869,
0.0015686087,
-0.2369003296,
-0.2532511353,
-0.6652728319,
0.399769634,
0.1631664038,
-0.3119592965,
0.1273964643,
-0.5671764612,
0.2643231452,
0.750176549,
0.2744376361,
-0.152434662,
0.1260121018,
-0.1734979004,
0.0825008005,
-0.4970104992,
-0.0929397643,
1.1907250881,
0.407040745,
0.618627131,
0.0410319194,
0.661740303,
0.4130265117,
0.1270166188,
-0.6062033176,
0.2856353223,
-0.2016931176,
-0.4740898609,
-0.6105197072,
-0.2787019908,
-0.4870584607,
0.1272921711,
0.2878950834,
-0.7983623147,
0.3127873838,
0.2582491934,
-0.3274779916,
0.0399474278,
-0.4280185401,
0.6562240124,
-0.0707924068,
-0.6687261462,
-0.0331516229,
-0.8797558546,
0.1069462523,
0.3213914037,
0.0594308637,
0.0162672643,
0.0155351656,
0.8893238306,
-0.2918933928,
1.0695074797,
-0.5172834396,
0.0761030093,
0.2671467364,
-0.351054579,
0.4562399983,
0.2703093886,
-0.1005146801,
0.0343288928,
-0.5447577834,
-0.0457622558,
-0.3564130664,
0.5071753263,
-0.5715186596,
-0.1346990019,
-0.1968437433,
-0.2967380583,
-0.4016950428,
0.2009667754,
0.620159626,
0.8199267983,
-0.3078171015,
0.5129188299,
0.8229369521,
-0.1252562851,
0.5579813123,
-0.021610627,
-0.077280812,
-0.6094250679,
0.5755727887,
0.0493887812,
0.0623517297,
0.6348918676,
0.32241714,
-0.7028215528,
-0.3274558485,
-0.3869905174,
-0.3565654159,
-0.788836658,
-0.3005188406,
-0.5998108387,
-0.1966902912,
-0.5923370719,
-0.2304521948,
-0.3614351749,
-0.2310389727,
-0.3768883348,
-0.2260236591,
0.2952848971,
0.0738816485,
0.0727473646,
0.8697344065,
-0.1865141541,
-0.0816665888,
0.157480821,
0.3625841737,
-0.2512102723,
-0.7812030911,
-0.3017996252,
-0.1239643544,
-0.0109477984,
-1.0036450624,
0.6311992407,
0.6202892065,
0.3414296508,
0.5685291886,
-0.0455752946,
0.6751592159,
-0.7862204909,
0.482917577,
0.57528615,
-1.0466382504,
0.6367812157,
-0.2276543081,
0.4300007224,
0.3254092932,
-0.1554857492,
-0.5985316038,
0.1892135888,
-0.225464493,
-0.9657933116,
0.4874432087,
-0.0393812731,
0.1510184556,
0.0433697477,
0.2576371431,
-0.3285488188,
0.4493429363,
-0.6247969866,
-0.2574999928,
-0.3703717589,
-0.0700477362,
-0.306222111,
-0.3293465078,
-0.0845628604,
-0.1212300733,
0.4871813953,
-0.4332024157,
0.4190135002,
0.6486212611,
-0.2564093173,
-0.1268620193,
0.3698199391,
0.6930251122,
0.5540377498,
-0.3577330112,
-0.0849076062,
0.3529008329,
-0.2503240407,
-0.075251244,
0.2582477033,
-0.4695835114,
0.2186685652,
0.1973355114,
1.3301428556,
0.2431474328,
-0.4607842565,
0.6330441236,
-0.0244445447,
0.101385735,
-0.9289228916,
-0.3459895253,
0.2276072949,
0.1499931812,
0.3319171667,
0.0966691971,
0.779699564,
-0.1900852025,
0.4313850701,
0.4896610975,
-0.9271757007,
0.0938845053,
0.7227984667,
0.2393352538,
-0.1246528998,
0.1398939192,
-0.1687817276,
-0.8292138577,
0.6128336191,
0.6210184693,
1.1856794357,
-0.6313129663,
0.0324954987,
0.2308162153,
0.0622913465,
0.1487209946,
0.0605448894,
0.0128456485,
-0.6115021706,
-0.5485653877,
-0.7385195494,
-0.2687152326,
0.1353079528,
-0.6933130026,
0.0060213581,
-0.3728224635,
-0.5113796592,
-0.1891008466,
-0.1985515505,
-0.5617394447,
0.7703433037,
0.3299268186,
0.6541252136,
-0.3613802493,
0.7246353626,
0.6501149535,
-0.1638366729,
-0.4481851757,
0.094564639,
-0.0636262894,
-0.5911770463,
0.76017344,
0.680162847,
-0.2257246524,
-0.0716454014,
-0.23548612,
-1.1195448637,
1.2400816679,
0.2128954083,
-0.9050995708,
-0.1187559366,
-0.1159672365,
0.3637191057,
-0.7739345431,
0.2763070166,
0.3531974554,
0.1773958504,
0.1344307363,
-0.8388377428,
-0.0879030228,
-0.0706768483,
0.4503094256,
-0.1617294997,
-0.3700868785,
0.919064939,
-0.1156640351,
0.1600930244,
-0.3994435668,
0.8672825694,
-0.1943331957,
0.5544522405,
0.5250848532,
0.4042240977,
0.4289962947,
-0.0358610936,
0.8497362733,
-0.4598937035,
0.291401118,
1.4577763081,
-0.4259912074,
0.8046489358,
0.508443296,
0.1438734978,
0.0970721543,
0.596352756,
0.3004438877,
0.9746447802,
0.306325376,
-0.1693240851,
0.0128144342,
-0.4188438952,
-0.4110904932,
0.3879234791,
0.5358707309,
-0.7168881297,
0.0753787756,
0.2682973146,
0.0505039841,
0.0101445159,
-0.4606587291,
0.6707747579,
0.2432598323,
-0.559597075,
0.4424493611,
-0.0803408548,
0.7144899964,
-0.0986656696,
0.2813373804,
-0.2194189429,
0.596976459,
-0.0212991685,
-0.435587436,
0.2314087003,
-0.3117762506,
-0.3335694671,
-0.0184427463,
0.8976395726,
-0.617482245,
-0.4069019258,
0.7729981542,
0.4786527455,
-0.1604989916,
-0.2869025767,
-0.638995409,
-0.1297681183,
-0.0844777822,
-0.4261401296,
0.2833491564,
0.1500899941,
0.1204804853,
0.6847848892,
0.5321884155,
0.0182443596,
0.3021073937,
0.5524086356,
0.9289972782,
-0.4050225019,
-0.9086890221,
-0.644303143,
0.3258095384,
-0.4818380475,
-0.3367425203,
0.3550263047,
0.4070264101,
0.8124257326,
0.0872716904,
1.0333468914,
0.16536057,
0.7782793045,
-0.503482759,
0.5802236795,
-0.5002636909,
0.1490012556,
-0.3712108433,
-0.9181640744,
-0.1902787983,
0.7011867166,
-0.1840599775,
0.1895627826,
0.3966207802,
0.442240864,
-0.0318926983,
-0.1366540939,
0.5487477183,
0.0853387713,
0.2533847392,
0.3555797935,
0.3189195096,
-0.3404572904,
0.2510600686,
-0.5160328746,
-0.2501592934,
-0.4988453686,
-0.7724464536,
-1.0748955011,
-0.4510255456,
-0.0370910801,
-0.2880762815,
0.5060223937,
0.8598642945,
0.7912868261,
-0.6298079491,
-0.1695040911,
-0.3585395515,
-0.201333046,
-0.0151026184,
-0.1599053741,
0.6060498953,
-0.4785844982,
-0.4982478321,
0.5770673156,
0.2338261008,
-0.3278945982,
-0.2989489436,
-0.279561013,
-0.0150626451,
-0.1060946509,
0.7231144309,
-0.122789219,
-0.9232177734,
-0.1016472727,
0.1204238087,
0.1958845854,
-0.2980002165,
0.641061008,
-0.7754151225,
0.4889820814,
0.218518436,
0.8122652173,
0.4463291466,
-0.0725046992,
0.713719666,
-1.0162135363,
0.2184311002,
0.2953603566,
0.7572577,
0.5196756124,
-0.3651662767,
0.6405482888,
0.025417747,
-0.5696228743,
-0.6535022855,
0.2288567126,
-0.872158885,
-0.1494725645,
1.0441137552,
-0.2918109,
-0.2441927344,
0.085513927,
-0.2752125859,
0.5833077431,
-0.580502212,
0.4776834846,
0.2603947222,
0.014653354,
-0.3287726343,
-0.5073083639,
0.392468363,
0.7054002285,
-0.3946458101,
0.1854634881,
0.6450842619,
0.15963687,
0.3594903648,
0.5346997976,
0.3989707232,
0.1400210559,
-0.3889354467,
0.1517687738,
-0.0790517554,
-0.2707312107,
-0.3793312609,
-0.0144369341,
-0.3971664906,
-0.2810845971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12487v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12487v1 | Augmenting Autotelic Agents with Large Language Models | 2023-05-21T15:42:41 | 2023-05-21T15:42:41 | Cédric Colas, Laetitia Teodorescu, Pierre-Yves Oudeyer, Xingdi Yuan, Marc-Alexandre Côté | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Humans learn to master open-ended repertoires of skills by imagining and
practicing their own goals. This autotelic learning process, literally the
pursuit of self-generated (auto) goals (telos), becomes more and more
open-ended as the goals become more diverse, abstract and creative. The
resulting exploration of the space of possible skills is supported by an
inter-individual exploration: goal representations are culturally evolved and
transmitted across individuals, in particular using language. Current
artificial agents mostly rely on predefined goal representations corresponding
to goal spaces that are either bounded (e.g. list of instructions), or
unbounded (e.g. the space of possible visual inputs) but are rarely endowed
with the ability to reshape their goal representations, to form new
abstractions or to imagine creative goals. In this paper, we introduce a
language model augmented autotelic agent (LMA3) that leverages a pretrained
language model (LM) to support the representation, generation and learning of
diverse, abstract, human-relevant goals. The LM is used as an imperfect model
of human cultural transmission; an attempt to capture aspects of humans'
common-sense, intuitive physics and overall interests. Specifically, it
supports three key components of the autotelic architecture: 1)~a relabeler
that describes the goals achieved in the agent's trajectories, 2)~a goal
generator that suggests new high-level goals along with their decomposition
into subgoals the agent already masters, and 3)~reward functions for each of
these goals. Without relying on any hand-coded goal representations, reward
functions or curriculum, we show that LMA3 agents learn to master a large
diversity of skills in a task-agnostic text-based environment. | [
-0.3743210137,
-0.5707979798,
0.5736577511,
-0.0435046703,
0.1613073796,
0.4773223698,
-0.5694822073,
-0.5134482384,
0.4289962053,
0.405934751,
-0.5025159717,
-0.4845034778,
-0.5001922846,
0.0165465511,
0.0504005179,
0.7326036692,
-0.3192944825,
-0.5737101436,
0.1778343916,
0.150358811,
-0.5284686089,
-0.3085878491,
-0.625669837,
-0.5575006008,
0.6079872251,
0.5267990828,
0.8606644869,
0.8092260957,
0.0547430515,
0.3503660858,
0.5063822865,
0.3768676519,
-0.3026977777,
0.2126906365,
-0.2151492089,
-0.4703961611,
-0.5745309591,
0.3353638053,
0.6118685603,
0.6290587783,
-0.0487867258,
0.1075917929,
0.0502931811,
0.420828104,
-0.4847505093,
0.6118384004,
-0.4914931357,
0.2898881435,
0.1977151185,
-0.1703152806,
-0.1004032195,
-0.2695890367,
0.0209932867,
-0.7648494244,
-0.1591820121,
-0.2655059695,
0.5973262191,
0.3642598689,
-0.3897512555,
-0.6072508097,
-0.8152205944,
0.5558584929,
-0.3840754926,
0.2692217529,
0.5590558648,
0.4954735339,
-0.0843158811,
-0.5642629862,
-0.5745117068,
-0.2621599734,
0.0104204547,
0.1788994521,
-0.212929517,
0.0095923748,
0.2170367241,
0.2459207177,
-0.5163744092,
0.2974489331,
-0.3006314039,
-0.2355747521,
0.8200124502,
0.2155316919,
0.5383886099,
0.0632703975,
-0.0942157358,
-0.2877942324,
-0.5559638143,
0.175380677,
0.4676633477,
0.3662105203,
0.033311788,
0.5160742998,
-0.4518014789,
0.8436726332,
-0.0696703494,
-0.0251236819,
0.2922030687,
-0.1235206425,
0.0696410835,
-0.0926325768,
0.8025861382,
0.1088348925,
0.5710639358,
-0.2343843132,
-0.4167712927,
-0.0998379663,
0.2392090857,
-0.577203393,
-0.1214962974,
0.0453709625,
-0.3546909094,
-0.0322356038,
-0.2240891606,
-0.1793765724,
-0.1631627977,
-0.5887181759,
0.4800842106,
-0.6610931158,
-0.3420678079,
0.3163021803,
0.1510157734,
0.2577388883,
0.3083346486,
-1.1107865572,
0.3863612711,
0.3683936298,
0.6676657796,
0.1812855005,
-0.7147298455,
-0.2106202692,
0.1246645302,
-0.4281225204,
0.5942977667,
-0.6653192639,
-0.2290744781,
-0.093651548,
-0.2366693169,
-0.075939171,
-0.2941065133,
0.0320172049,
-0.5004023314,
0.4297415316,
-0.1247648448,
-0.336560756,
-0.4302950203,
0.2474510074,
-0.5443203449,
0.7377215028,
0.2065265328,
0.1511821151,
0.3666298389,
-1.0166351795,
-0.413110882,
0.1452668756,
-0.2728102505,
0.0295029692,
0.0120577663,
0.1947309226,
0.5699090362,
-0.2300262451,
0.2812557817,
-0.0781632215,
-0.2649468482,
0.1483451128,
-0.3427934051,
0.6137093306,
0.3532530367,
-0.5395220518,
0.0538905002,
-0.4951060116,
0.0769043565,
0.134571746,
-0.3855205774,
-0.1350073218,
0.0013155887,
-0.2515107393,
0.4492563605,
0.5593176484,
-0.390499115,
0.364322722,
-0.4606314301,
0.2445730865,
0.6840266585,
-0.2166830152,
0.5820239186,
-0.5871862769,
0.6189552546,
-0.2340353578,
0.0606251769,
-0.2345530838,
-0.3362186849,
-0.4971530139,
-0.3424145877,
-0.2270730585,
0.3881219923,
-0.6972758174,
0.6131646037,
-0.271576643,
-0.5510692596,
-0.6150326133,
0.4325239658,
-0.0408929475,
0.1215904802,
0.3440202773,
-0.2428877801,
-0.3026652932,
-0.796759963,
-0.345218569,
-0.2524807751,
0.0658241808,
0.093817845,
0.5176134706,
-0.201175034,
1.054104805,
-0.3528238833,
-0.6431015134,
-0.4647553563,
0.2234875113,
0.2820670605,
0.5187070966,
0.617909193,
-0.6111782193,
-0.6294483542,
0.1100787446,
-0.9572123885,
-0.0631618425,
-0.2900897264,
0.1291711479,
-0.0514161997,
0.4173676968,
-0.5242458582,
0.3895965517,
0.4177373946,
-0.41434744,
0.4698463976,
-0.3307182491,
0.1974795759,
-1.0294460058,
-0.0415231213,
-0.3058518171,
-0.3438493311,
-0.5647884011,
-0.0828199312,
-0.1350156516,
-0.1536386013,
-0.1759250015,
0.7796574235,
-0.7587406039,
-0.2565369606,
-0.7153545618,
0.0570826754,
-0.1217960268,
0.7652298212,
0.5094572306,
0.5313278437,
0.8254423738,
-0.466684401,
0.4992201328,
0.0470050499,
-0.1372698545,
0.2595075667,
-0.5817636251,
0.0414715707,
-0.3188227713,
0.147369504,
-0.6516832113,
-0.3210561275,
0.4394799471,
-0.5523155928,
0.1814566255,
0.2599725425,
-0.5437886119,
-0.2891640365,
0.0317695439,
0.7288400531,
0.6382145882,
-0.3439884782,
0.922226727,
0.3197692633,
0.0858627856,
-0.5830253959,
-0.4787940085,
0.3085795343,
-0.1618794054,
-0.3310774267,
0.2603577971,
-0.0877058282,
-0.2512071729,
0.3531010747,
0.3575042784,
0.3301333785,
0.1266070604,
0.2767851353,
0.0853706151,
-0.0913439915,
-0.0275364537,
-0.1353422999,
0.0007701059,
0.1035625115,
-0.6675307155,
0.5942766666,
-0.3272852302,
-0.4244201481,
-0.4211513698,
0.3223024607,
0.7387793064,
-0.6323661208,
0.6209119558,
0.6070480943,
-0.4606997073,
-0.3359003961,
-0.4217237532,
-0.1436626017,
-0.4593806863,
0.4467297792,
-0.6972643137,
-0.8013759255,
0.5642955303,
0.0578758679,
0.3044686019,
0.3201077878,
0.6009879112,
-0.0623434857,
0.8936769366,
0.5358375907,
-0.0211897269,
0.6601085663,
-0.4635617733,
-0.1947011799,
-0.7782285213,
-0.211837709,
0.0246734172,
-0.5374715328,
-0.2180385888,
-0.6134909987,
0.4089758992,
-0.2263775766,
-0.3578117192,
0.4810112715,
-0.3515034914,
0.4990078807,
0.6004092097,
0.0067894976,
0.3027316332,
-0.04804888,
-0.1257817596,
0.1581030339,
-0.8680903316,
-0.5810886621,
1.1362376213,
0.5747435093,
0.739846468,
0.2378699481,
1.0420831442,
0.424551487,
0.4502708018,
-0.8801698685,
0.5297038555,
0.1372447908,
-0.657099247,
-0.4926581383,
-0.2694891989,
-0.9739316702,
0.1125600785,
-0.3006275594,
-0.9164279699,
0.2801008523,
0.2553843856,
-0.4106165171,
0.3696631491,
-0.3383991122,
0.9525023699,
-0.4626519084,
-0.4974467158,
-0.3621855378,
-0.4463530183,
0.3110564053,
-0.2021995187,
0.2421446741,
-0.1783613563,
-0.2282090783,
0.5113745332,
-0.3328300714,
1.0776580572,
-0.1807098389,
-0.2351544499,
0.4804621935,
0.3743168712,
0.5696943998,
-0.1940875947,
-0.1294332892,
-0.2479049712,
-0.388086915,
-0.4288536608,
-0.8279985785,
0.5282538533,
-1.0743931532,
-0.8123821616,
-0.3552302718,
-0.81591326,
-0.0674645305,
0.1890271604,
-0.0530503318,
0.5195092559,
-0.2062690407,
-0.191237092,
0.2143524885,
-0.2181389779,
0.5727363229,
0.6942397952,
-0.2898590267,
-0.3045380414,
0.7961175442,
-0.0824121311,
0.5314911604,
0.1773361564,
0.0188965723,
-0.5495478511,
-0.4726350307,
-0.3622130454,
0.4345310926,
-0.8923611641,
0.01778448,
-0.4543507099,
-0.2021704167,
-0.4697724283,
-0.2998502254,
-0.5396344662,
-0.1514876634,
-0.4625939429,
0.0125014484,
0.1342698932,
0.9047404528,
-0.609015286,
0.3806250989,
-0.5421526432,
0.2811686993,
0.3449912667,
0.1978215724,
0.0692074597,
-0.5681875944,
-0.431178689,
0.3004827201,
-0.0614674613,
-0.7891377807,
0.5549041033,
0.2949701548,
0.7323857546,
0.3052537441,
-0.2134587467,
0.5811101794,
-0.4689534605,
0.3963782489,
0.0828449875,
-0.7811518908,
0.4886823893,
-0.5681678653,
0.5987895131,
0.4561769962,
0.3653156757,
-0.6695405841,
-0.4204796851,
-0.5263454914,
-0.5127057433,
0.639372468,
0.2068058252,
0.2824677825,
-0.0698478073,
0.3463901877,
0.1877670437,
0.0290993918,
-1.0154790878,
-0.0082592331,
-0.5969539881,
-0.3413866758,
-0.3450120687,
0.2424381375,
-0.0024101955,
-0.1441222727,
0.6842539907,
-0.3814210892,
0.116171442,
0.2194733173,
-0.2375141084,
-0.1178506389,
0.0283212587,
0.4019911289,
0.4370842576,
0.0277187042,
0.1953594834,
-0.0715273097,
-0.2836553156,
0.433023721,
0.2537647784,
0.2226869315,
-0.3809199929,
0.3550672531,
0.8063884974,
-0.1150295958,
-0.7583877444,
0.1193545684,
-0.0873230249,
-0.2225461155,
-0.677107811,
0.2667269409,
-0.03622986,
0.4660785794,
0.5528891683,
0.1261673123,
-0.0125352517,
-0.9991654754,
0.2900614738,
0.4724764228,
-0.5228255987,
-0.3938365579,
0.8370837569,
0.1031831875,
-0.5144135356,
0.2981546521,
-0.4225989282,
-0.5941756964,
0.4384345412,
0.5906970501,
0.879103303,
-0.276055038,
0.4064137638,
0.2768245935,
0.6266028285,
-0.0470070466,
0.1681523323,
-0.2773286104,
-1.0663579702,
-0.4712764025,
-0.6610191464,
0.0833283216,
-0.059395887,
-0.1487391442,
0.1668504328,
-0.2104125917,
-0.1182125583,
-0.292355895,
-0.076490581,
-0.9542500973,
0.3518844247,
0.3641491532,
0.6392718554,
-0.6550334096,
0.9106155634,
0.8138595223,
-0.5491713285,
-1.086081624,
-0.0729859024,
-0.0668956414,
-1.0832102299,
0.9503874183,
0.0192213375,
-0.2879385352,
0.3570242524,
-0.0212992504,
-1.1047672033,
1.2314008474,
0.196538344,
-0.2797010541,
-0.4431067407,
0.5860369802,
0.522801578,
-0.8203923702,
0.3161049187,
0.4275624454,
0.3647794425,
0.1925733238,
-1.0202533007,
0.207474485,
-0.1917573214,
-0.3581881821,
0.1682493389,
-0.5275086164,
0.8586147428,
-0.3176513612,
-0.1413252801,
-0.0527439415,
0.7102162242,
-0.0174268316,
-0.1914598793,
0.6461991668,
0.3317394853,
0.5572513938,
0.0537329502,
0.9812048674,
-0.4227998257,
0.1181181818,
1.0446765423,
-0.0975299627,
0.3595706224,
0.083700113,
0.3019860387,
0.6515154243,
0.5461618304,
0.1768106669,
0.3457048237,
0.1649362594,
-0.2981840968,
-0.3626802862,
-0.1155314967,
-0.0291791223,
1.0846173763,
0.5242908597,
-0.5059560537,
-0.3006444871,
0.2422673106,
-0.0925181657,
0.2435896099,
-0.3591974378,
0.7170202732,
0.0071184337,
-0.9736599922,
0.7041605115,
-0.1725749224,
0.3550287485,
-0.6183622479,
-0.0400740728,
0.0371418186,
0.0576309673,
0.0068098065,
-0.7750006318,
0.2942104638,
-0.2947066128,
0.1739552617,
-0.5404499769,
0.7406799197,
-0.759740293,
-0.1861119568,
0.1621196121,
0.7587838173,
0.2485101968,
0.0295765325,
-0.6997761726,
-0.1825820506,
-0.0072363708,
-0.1939486861,
-0.1201358438,
0.336176008,
-0.1138362437,
0.7654464841,
0.4767003059,
0.4379555881,
-0.2601394951,
-0.1146827489,
0.7099165916,
-0.7126829624,
-0.586928606,
-0.8242082,
0.4865288436,
0.0226419847,
-0.1723322719,
0.4872021973,
0.497577697,
0.7117910385,
-0.0554142259,
0.9401693344,
-0.0753961578,
0.0616894215,
-0.4807525277,
0.7012955546,
-0.7602679729,
0.2802718282,
-0.064000681,
-1.1363135576,
-0.2177024931,
0.5625370145,
-0.6123229265,
0.212165609,
0.4402377903,
0.6311867833,
-0.0635662749,
-0.2138088197,
0.5198603868,
-0.084937036,
0.3267721832,
0.8597944975,
1.2254583836,
-0.0048789713,
0.2837751806,
-0.138986811,
-0.4374236166,
0.0461086519,
-0.4392435551,
-0.9965707064,
-0.7955679297,
-0.2818656266,
0.0335719958,
0.0223142076,
1.3136072159,
0.7098264098,
-0.2402368039,
-0.7312163115,
-0.075826183,
-0.0433686674,
-0.1385221034,
-0.1867621392,
0.1862027198,
-0.6391795278,
-0.9855209589,
0.5001856685,
0.2455527484,
0.3873703778,
-0.5518269539,
-0.149740845,
-0.135702759,
-0.0102693588,
0.5837907791,
0.711522162,
-0.5942150354,
-0.4493469596,
0.0820454955,
0.0628521442,
-0.1474464238,
0.8632977605,
-1.1065647602,
0.4169436097,
-0.0221860167,
0.5730572939,
0.3867903054,
-0.2529304028,
1.0026519299,
-0.498334378,
0.1536642611,
0.4030509293,
0.3607827723,
0.2678072453,
-0.2070047855,
0.3346534669,
0.0228794534,
-0.3999353647,
-0.4182231724,
0.4717095494,
-0.4368084669,
-0.4339673817,
1.0577920675,
-0.0215899926,
-0.2372395098,
-0.0798039213,
-0.2773090303,
0.4389119744,
-0.3753763735,
0.8149375319,
0.509247005,
-0.3073581457,
-0.1324054152,
-0.3825379908,
0.8542410731,
0.3853097558,
-0.9253384471,
0.0326000303,
0.6764664054,
0.1984697729,
0.2160400301,
0.8181679845,
0.1052690819,
0.3907622099,
-0.3514396548,
0.4056765735,
-0.389659524,
-0.4706735909,
-0.0306560937,
0.0617536008,
0.2420084774,
-0.1565624624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12485v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12485v2 | A Confidence-based Partial Label Learning Model for Crowd-Annotated Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-21T15:31:23 | 2023-07-27T10:06:49 | Limao Xiong, Jie Zhou, Qunxi Zhu, Xiao Wang, Yuanbin Wu, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Xuanjing Huang, Jin Ma, Ying Shan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing models for named entity recognition (NER) are mainly based on
large-scale labeled datasets, which always obtain using crowdsourcing. However,
it is hard to obtain a unified and correct label via majority voting from
multiple annotators for NER due to the large labeling space and complexity of
this task. To address this problem, we aim to utilize the original
multi-annotator labels directly. Particularly, we propose a Confidence-based
Partial Label Learning (CPLL) method to integrate the prior confidence (given
by annotators) and posterior confidences (learned by models) for
crowd-annotated NER. This model learns a token- and content-dependent
confidence via an Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm by minimizing
empirical risk. The true posterior estimator and confidence estimator perform
iteratively to update the true posterior and confidence respectively. We
conduct extensive experimental results on both real-world and synthetic
datasets, which show that our model can improve performance effectively
compared with strong baselines. | [
-0.5461312532,
-0.4698894322,
0.5070372224,
0.1407823712,
-0.2711368799,
0.1309327036,
-0.136348322,
-0.5775732994,
0.4787049294,
0.4470255971,
-0.2449595034,
-0.5214471817,
-0.8439037204,
0.6244242787,
-0.2397085726,
1.0699307919,
0.0533574894,
0.0126970131,
-0.0579126216,
0.1254764497,
0.0143094892,
-0.8133542538,
-0.9531590343,
-0.0444549099,
0.972966969,
0.2262108922,
0.2128832191,
0.509047389,
0.2133974433,
0.2594485283,
-0.1392727345,
0.3211844265,
-0.4693235159,
-0.0436192676,
-0.1476240307,
-0.128132239,
-0.2742615938,
0.1741981059,
0.7403707504,
0.6412147284,
-0.2294135094,
-0.0098723993,
0.0649561062,
0.2032964528,
-0.7420751452,
0.260268122,
-0.7557614446,
0.0152922682,
-0.1615487337,
0.1356948018,
-0.9013344049,
-0.3335643411,
0.2181846648,
-1.1057596207,
0.0673843026,
0.4349185824,
1.1275695562,
0.2317145318,
-0.2896312773,
-0.0722520798,
-0.4623195529,
0.7945868373,
-0.131238237,
0.5223815441,
0.5592854619,
0.0807016343,
-0.1663395911,
-0.7305948138,
-0.5568192601,
0.0677276924,
0.1810851544,
0.0421576463,
-0.0083510336,
0.1159729213,
0.2138519287,
0.0101578059,
-0.130242601,
0.1564052105,
-0.4352368712,
-0.4098364711,
0.5955396891,
-0.5275582671,
0.0308041181,
-0.1000737697,
-0.9226275682,
-0.1100252867,
-0.5029363632,
-0.0064986111,
0.1160712019,
0.451377511,
0.1496148705,
0.4725658894,
-0.294852972,
0.6162673235,
0.3916912675,
-0.2704883814,
0.3701502085,
0.2679111362,
-0.3764306307,
0.3814585805,
0.7155832052,
0.0294769052,
0.1662111282,
-0.2592000067,
-0.4431703091,
-0.4366693795,
-0.2997557223,
-0.728340745,
-0.6776196957,
0.0818232074,
-0.0955662578,
-0.1161914021,
0.3974207044,
-0.7102760673,
-0.6999765038,
-0.4265623987,
0.569526732,
-0.4124436975,
-0.2390746325,
-0.0719883293,
-0.0877192616,
0.1490573287,
0.7901896238,
-0.2130129635,
0.184657678,
0.5902509689,
0.7806817293,
-0.1583518237,
-0.0810065567,
-0.9075874686,
0.3118846714,
-0.0611144416,
0.7524687648,
-0.5451802015,
-0.3258062005,
-0.2803186178,
0.2084088922,
-0.1474632323,
-0.4924930334,
0.440541625,
-0.7051856518,
-0.1047545522,
-0.3282865584,
-0.9253088236,
-0.17779167,
0.1623667181,
-0.9629719257,
0.7848735452,
-0.3401883841,
-0.9048244357,
0.5325453281,
-0.2015990168,
-0.2270695567,
0.2990949154,
0.0721986964,
-0.4955218434,
0.0163826104,
0.2781059146,
0.5885870457,
0.1906195432,
0.4229075313,
-0.5334717631,
-0.2094585747,
0.5392492414,
-0.2604179978,
0.5369943976,
-0.1327795535,
-0.0043719858,
-0.0513044037,
-0.784843266,
-0.0815116465,
-0.106875807,
-0.5293911695,
-0.7014059424,
-0.1273116469,
0.038583573,
0.1178022623,
0.0779334977,
-0.6879172921,
0.12245588,
-0.0647439659,
0.0675101578,
0.9501654506,
0.2651208043,
0.4580130279,
-0.120832637,
-0.0156723596,
0.0188996345,
0.1225644797,
0.0730073303,
-0.8132498264,
-0.8796029091,
-0.7578748465,
1.1030255556,
0.4416991174,
-0.8019257188,
0.4657749832,
-0.1897095442,
-0.3927727938,
-0.5028266311,
-0.0400578231,
0.2890215814,
0.5446410775,
0.569299221,
-0.3762337863,
-0.6227312684,
-0.7537404895,
0.1474800557,
-0.3455426991,
-0.0861681551,
0.3919655383,
0.4951976538,
0.075384967,
0.9220711589,
-0.4557519257,
-0.2816287279,
-0.0235615764,
0.4251001775,
-0.0377037935,
0.4626738131,
-0.1348380297,
-1.0979077816,
-0.3922006786,
-0.3130986989,
-0.3560401797,
0.0367186144,
-0.0582462437,
-0.2690748572,
0.01292824,
-0.0347706303,
-0.4230193794,
0.4355359972,
0.3291780055,
0.1027817801,
0.3198549747,
0.0614560284,
0.0398176014,
-0.9327379465,
-0.2415530384,
0.4935314655,
-0.4068985879,
-0.589251101,
-0.1618963182,
0.2704304457,
-0.1633778661,
-0.4407755733,
0.5706499815,
-0.7650392652,
0.2322512716,
-0.2293040007,
0.275257647,
0.155047074,
0.3392243683,
0.7201378942,
0.4413195252,
0.5931349397,
-0.8239611387,
0.2417972237,
0.0185919888,
-0.172411412,
0.700319767,
-0.4831464291,
0.3518897593,
-0.3214026392,
0.4552508295,
-0.7679831982,
-0.5926634073,
0.4285525084,
-0.4333088696,
0.569554925,
-0.4828163087,
-0.4526666403,
-0.3687266707,
0.1027461067,
0.0952541828,
0.2908491492,
-0.7543548346,
0.5736554265,
0.6378400922,
-0.2224572301,
-0.4119928777,
-0.5019792318,
0.1526316404,
0.023911858,
-0.2282140851,
0.4634642005,
0.0288130101,
-0.1700324714,
-0.0550258197,
-0.0949086174,
-0.6744968891,
-0.1209179685,
0.4847973287,
0.3274856508,
0.1051536873,
0.6690987945,
0.0012088068,
-0.1683620065,
-0.3164250553,
-0.2931416333,
0.1619987637,
0.0492583141,
-0.2919384241,
-0.6531592011,
0.1227627322,
0.0065457914,
-0.4100184739,
0.931245327,
0.351880312,
-0.8524654508,
-0.1888839751,
-0.8359248042,
-0.2427162379,
-0.3921012282,
0.2087877393,
-0.2730428278,
-0.7918003201,
0.0691328943,
-0.4035638571,
-0.3271223009,
0.1992651671,
0.0720212087,
-0.0278665032,
0.4468846023,
0.6600180864,
-0.1644509137,
0.1965981722,
0.1446902901,
-0.1495296061,
-0.722201407,
-0.5208342671,
-0.3747178018,
-0.1972858012,
-0.0539932847,
-0.8317710161,
-0.0388940647,
0.226936236,
-0.1702711284,
0.3975253403,
-0.683675766,
0.4629892409,
0.6616295576,
0.3650359511,
0.4006848633,
-0.0417978913,
-0.0295868572,
-0.0785011426,
-0.1766980588,
-0.5313646793,
0.9028410912,
0.1996714771,
0.5934437513,
0.075565286,
1.1123124361,
0.2000621408,
0.8582630157,
-0.5970606208,
0.4407280385,
0.381478101,
-0.7148094177,
-0.2478500158,
-0.5620684028,
-0.6542323232,
0.2103567868,
-0.4005654454,
-0.9067946076,
0.6350097656,
0.0884257033,
-0.4991606176,
0.4993267655,
-0.637275517,
0.3781887591,
-0.1174207181,
-0.2542997897,
0.4914372861,
-0.5161142349,
0.3558098078,
-0.4203503728,
0.2389379293,
-0.2532142103,
-0.3771696389,
0.8553195,
-0.2993359566,
0.8995130658,
-0.4200719595,
0.1442004591,
0.5006268024,
-0.3052799106,
0.8957463503,
0.4113744199,
-0.208490625,
0.2421726733,
-0.5051190257,
-0.2589628994,
-0.2096679658,
0.5622932911,
-0.6793715954,
-0.4428001344,
-0.6037247777,
0.0383662358,
-0.045075044,
0.1987319291,
0.2413427383,
0.0172410719,
-0.0178161785,
0.1797005087,
1.0327591896,
-0.255715996,
0.348275423,
0.4518851638,
-0.1748993248,
-0.829231441,
0.8227275014,
0.2872343659,
-0.0009564647,
0.6625175476,
-0.1905500442,
-0.2938321829,
-0.189498961,
-0.2970273793,
0.2059650719,
-0.3596740961,
-0.3399787843,
-0.8734872341,
-0.1435441822,
-0.2105452865,
0.0841777176,
-0.4217664897,
-0.2521084249,
-0.5371494293,
-0.405687511,
0.2677535415,
0.5366472006,
-0.1029320061,
0.118095018,
-0.420966655,
0.017824227,
0.4313949645,
0.1704539657,
-0.0345720612,
-0.314745307,
0.2202220112,
0.0703853667,
-0.1181200594,
-1.4346407652,
0.286614418,
0.3017838001,
0.4506733716,
0.5292877555,
0.4793576598,
0.7246744633,
-0.3413879573,
0.2338724136,
0.2946910858,
-0.8776192665,
0.4711514115,
0.1281704754,
-0.387188673,
0.6737477183,
0.7288550138,
-0.2966697216,
0.0192979723,
-0.5940055251,
-0.9323057532,
0.4118493199,
0.219291389,
-0.1617670953,
-0.1561768204,
0.3335349262,
0.1472375393,
0.2124631107,
-1.0297186375,
-0.3586903811,
-0.0327596553,
0.0191177297,
0.1114655212,
-0.1651062369,
0.1222288758,
-0.2031994313,
1.0555105209,
0.0291529689,
0.1444854736,
0.6806624532,
-0.1634570062,
0.1537099183,
0.5003139973,
0.192103669,
0.1433824152,
-0.1628976315,
0.1690971851,
0.4061256349,
-0.2409984916,
0.1682246029,
0.6243284941,
-0.3127527237,
0.2296312153,
-0.1056786329,
0.7220413089,
0.292458266,
-0.4426833093,
0.7384163141,
0.0203593131,
-0.005895983,
-0.5133536458,
-0.4130402207,
0.1103187129,
0.1149910763,
0.7649341822,
0.1442134827,
0.1439226121,
0.1115514413,
0.5027759671,
0.1080587506,
-0.8777492642,
-0.2405051589,
0.5861469507,
0.1805989295,
-0.205680415,
0.6031730771,
-0.6640082598,
-0.3308154345,
0.6147055626,
0.4560247064,
0.5662133098,
-0.3832876086,
0.3932910264,
0.5180134773,
0.3150322735,
-0.4203161001,
0.0335620232,
0.0667118505,
-0.6096381545,
-0.4739282429,
-0.770160079,
-0.6326756477,
0.1081421152,
-0.7094122767,
0.2856906354,
-0.5777124763,
-0.5388307571,
0.1806737483,
-0.0979337767,
-0.5884153843,
0.3990688622,
0.5170314312,
0.7891596556,
-0.609817028,
0.8454685211,
0.8165196776,
-0.5417557955,
-1.1290878057,
-0.0631217659,
0.0375467055,
-0.3634802103,
0.7682853937,
0.6326524019,
0.3030203581,
0.2855023742,
-0.7525317073,
-1.102370739,
1.1356172562,
0.0603798069,
-0.9897677302,
0.0304829478,
-0.3974597454,
0.1381624341,
-0.2907039523,
0.1858944595,
-0.4197110534,
0.6022390127,
0.3696439266,
-0.724286139,
-0.0092313495,
0.0145919109,
-0.1323107332,
0.2283987701,
-0.6674818993,
0.7930906415,
-0.4001884758,
-0.5117491484,
0.1563683897,
1.0904017687,
0.7540675998,
0.5524339676,
0.5392205715,
0.5955805779,
1.4512505531,
-0.3189634085,
0.7868146896,
-0.0960325003,
0.5309297442,
1.3015068769,
-0.5814222097,
1.1491942406,
0.374787569,
-0.2164361477,
0.3956875801,
0.7473147511,
-0.3480767906,
0.4405067265,
0.5809726715,
-0.5179824233,
-0.5638634562,
-0.3599506021,
-0.1505864859,
0.0833945423,
0.2996919155,
-0.6323872805,
0.1936810613,
0.1401766986,
0.1322968155,
-0.2729152143,
-0.5099179745,
0.7479848862,
0.2471747398,
-0.285810262,
0.0490512028,
0.1332261413,
0.920298934,
-0.1225479543,
-0.0587322637,
0.1966636926,
-0.0369366221,
-0.1116214544,
-0.3947681785,
-0.3453159034,
0.0123954881,
-0.2585073709,
0.1172946692,
0.9513903856,
-0.4366925955,
-0.7250077128,
0.2277029008,
0.2863500118,
0.4045265317,
-0.4187116623,
-0.3843351007,
-0.337331444,
-0.1846049428,
-0.2724774182,
0.2581265867,
0.403888166,
0.0967887565,
0.6683324575,
0.7472003698,
0.1528347135,
0.2385971397,
-0.175115183,
0.6865950227,
-0.4242801368,
-0.2180879712,
-0.6840893626,
0.3185838163,
-0.5606245399,
-0.1314752251,
0.4572598636,
0.7449913025,
0.939049542,
-0.0040318514,
0.8439198732,
-0.0071694311,
0.5624864697,
-0.2742052078,
0.7228941321,
-0.3591622412,
0.0101160612,
-0.368419081,
-0.782521069,
-0.3887709677,
0.5730239749,
-0.3750457764,
-0.0351863019,
0.2968724072,
0.589176774,
0.1294816285,
0.0207182933,
0.3184424937,
0.1280189604,
-0.14336133,
0.7734075785,
0.7914084196,
-0.3029045761,
0.5784538984,
-0.5007644892,
-0.4148182869,
-0.0553088859,
-0.8677710891,
-0.722999692,
-0.5573120117,
-0.8486210108,
-0.2702752352,
0.3383285403,
1.0326952934,
0.9017034173,
-0.8642770052,
0.5075864792,
0.1607010663,
0.0758200735,
-0.0011261809,
-0.2535446882,
0.3380352259,
0.2098907977,
-0.9006890059,
0.2290666103,
0.2973444164,
0.2388221323,
0.1984435469,
-0.1331481636,
-0.3628357947,
0.0929064751,
0.0937953666,
0.4661076665,
-0.8130486012,
-0.2988342047,
-0.2384817004,
-0.2183489501,
0.0681436881,
0.1735810339,
-0.8113721609,
0.3674458563,
0.114773199,
0.6449251771,
0.3779943287,
0.4092893004,
0.1044246033,
-0.918725431,
-0.2898121476,
0.0719100758,
0.6187281609,
0.6722266674,
-0.424277544,
0.3978337646,
0.4764187634,
-0.5498822331,
-0.6582847238,
-0.0360021144,
-1.0425194502,
-0.0110543892,
1.2628451586,
-0.5902283192,
-0.239391014,
-0.3367517292,
-0.1399265975,
0.4600943327,
-0.8521721959,
0.3958993256,
0.5006551743,
0.1511964947,
-0.3254585564,
-0.2572403848,
0.1662704796,
-0.2474246025,
-0.5578425527,
-0.3032220304,
0.3964799345,
0.553308785,
0.4170184433,
0.6522857547,
0.0751485676,
-0.1530660242,
-0.1007646546,
0.5761930943,
-0.1413905323,
-0.3992036283,
-0.089425534,
0.6083726883,
-0.0436496399,
-0.135947004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12483v1 | Model Analysis & Evaluation for Ambiguous Question Answering | 2023-05-21T15:20:20 | 2023-05-21T15:20:20 | Konstantinos Papakostas, Irene Papadopoulou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Ambiguous questions are a challenge for Question Answering models, as they
require answers that cover multiple interpretations of the original query. To
this end, these models are required to generate long-form answers that often
combine conflicting pieces of information. Although recent advances in the
field have shown strong capabilities in generating fluent responses, certain
research questions remain unanswered. Does model/data scaling improve the
answers' quality? Do automated metrics align with human judgment? To what
extent do these models ground their answers in evidence? In this study, we aim
to thoroughly investigate these aspects, and provide valuable insights into the
limitations of the current approaches. To aid in reproducibility and further
extension of our work, we open-source our code at
https://github.com/din0s/ambig_lfqa. | [
-0.4993658066,
-0.9152250886,
0.5877300501,
0.2555117011,
-0.1121666059,
0.0747184977,
0.019033039,
-0.9302399158,
-0.0159844607,
0.2624710202,
-0.6191488504,
0.0124036567,
-0.5084715486,
0.1508248597,
-0.4909206629,
0.6991298795,
-0.1766279638,
0.2969152629,
-0.452370584,
-0.5151031613,
-0.6108006835,
-0.3062801957,
-0.4615344703,
-0.1551889479,
0.3586515784,
0.3452888727,
0.9848382473,
0.50736022,
0.6864123344,
0.2216026187,
0.0086699333,
0.0624702275,
-0.4870756865,
0.3092168868,
-0.1721406281,
-0.2961028814,
-0.6017342806,
-0.0966664627,
0.7147934437,
1.0886301994,
-0.0736998543,
0.5882378221,
-0.1339814216,
0.4724981785,
-0.6549602151,
-0.193489477,
-0.5735448599,
-0.0647561923,
0.0554183684,
0.1382555366,
-0.1799567938,
-0.3003534973,
0.0926734209,
-0.544470787,
0.1533855051,
0.1357375532,
0.8264449239,
0.3506594002,
-0.9026051164,
-0.3802928329,
-0.8800624609,
0.6447115541,
-0.9023128748,
0.2750570774,
0.0144464048,
0.5403637886,
-0.0082676411,
-0.8766539693,
-0.3679951131,
-0.0137898885,
-0.1674842685,
0.0858319849,
-0.3565419316,
0.0921995491,
0.4322423935,
0.4476122558,
-0.6628957391,
0.3497577608,
-0.5833736658,
-0.0851975828,
0.9764004946,
0.5563420653,
0.1428301781,
-0.2597135603,
-0.2693312764,
0.0237474218,
-0.3804294765,
0.4342779815,
0.552416265,
0.094261162,
0.2523390651,
0.8069748878,
-0.4592167139,
0.9449666739,
0.0567639396,
0.491409719,
0.1015510485,
-0.3264011741,
-0.1951471865,
-0.4352914989,
0.7428393364,
0.4917423725,
-0.0679690614,
-0.079162918,
-0.2920942903,
-0.2444636375,
0.4528055191,
-0.8147841692,
0.2548772693,
0.5644512177,
-0.5177754164,
-0.2739649117,
0.2266341895,
-0.9705858827,
-0.4624822438,
-0.1986547112,
0.6864358187,
0.1585660577,
-0.5766419172,
0.3463374674,
-0.1783290207,
0.3570404351,
0.4133636951,
-0.6051273942,
0.5085985661,
0.434392184,
0.2957273424,
-0.2470536828,
-0.0003859883,
-0.4724820256,
-0.4796517491,
-0.2585192919,
0.5861484408,
-0.5092284679,
-0.5893284678,
-0.0466211401,
0.0415485315,
-0.1173177361,
-0.58073771,
0.7798088789,
-0.7879442573,
0.4154410064,
-0.5006727576,
-0.6925715208,
-0.3244500458,
0.328424871,
-0.851002872,
1.0656358004,
0.2905495763,
-0.8159320354,
0.0873219892,
-0.806168139,
0.0611745864,
-0.0846987963,
-0.3399429321,
-0.4113413692,
0.2708242834,
0.2552949786,
0.1668461859,
-0.7564817071,
0.3985545933,
-0.4770401418,
-0.2084516436,
0.5376747251,
-0.3902775943,
0.8086248636,
0.311909467,
-0.1195444688,
0.2157543898,
-0.8722782731,
0.4688797891,
0.2302580029,
-0.1255236715,
-0.1861391962,
-0.1361077577,
-0.0014074411,
0.1844488233,
0.2889671028,
-0.6815373302,
0.2458826303,
-0.0816527754,
0.4181227386,
0.5744063854,
0.2705932856,
0.4151805937,
-0.4841659069,
1.0256248713,
-0.0135878539,
0.078018263,
0.1529996395,
-0.576677978,
-0.5845219493,
0.1602107882,
0.5294529796,
0.488930732,
-0.421789825,
-0.072981745,
-0.3544300497,
-0.5148145556,
-0.6948266029,
-0.0580822602,
0.1983026266,
0.6053795218,
0.4238204062,
-0.3333005011,
-0.5274352431,
-1.185325861,
-0.4200334847,
-0.2460252345,
-0.3620125353,
0.5515452027,
0.7637665272,
0.0452033915,
1.1299889088,
-0.7130151987,
0.3953469992,
0.1610970497,
0.1819362193,
0.1206116751,
0.3899860978,
0.6228870749,
-1.0293983221,
-0.2213012129,
-0.2243047953,
-0.7392401695,
-0.09981253,
-0.0839170143,
-0.1084269434,
-0.3138485253,
0.3528244495,
-0.8351632357,
0.507168591,
0.2500948608,
-0.2927882075,
0.7994411588,
0.114322044,
0.5038704276,
-0.8785645366,
0.2009887695,
-0.2552148104,
-0.0194843356,
-0.8564634919,
0.286098212,
0.2715806067,
-0.14112629,
-0.2069521695,
0.6981929541,
-0.4469369948,
-0.0797306001,
-0.1706465781,
0.0781851783,
0.1440558881,
0.2955982983,
-0.0749270841,
0.4522624612,
0.31554088,
-0.2039144039,
0.4766134322,
0.093089208,
-0.3340443075,
0.2983652949,
-1.0616872311,
0.4444548488,
-0.2327845693,
0.0170005541,
-1.184227705,
-0.5314008594,
0.2478540838,
-0.64029634,
0.1510435641,
-0.0235578157,
-0.4060365558,
-0.6210477352,
-0.1614329219,
0.8384231329,
0.2946261764,
-0.3109113574,
0.7359842062,
0.1113089323,
-0.0803849846,
-0.7590494156,
-0.4702568352,
-0.2878746688,
-0.5014511943,
-0.8442059755,
0.0627767369,
-0.2942715287,
-0.6681669354,
0.2127408385,
-0.375595361,
-0.4176179767,
0.2237143368,
0.1729202569,
0.1487962306,
-0.5587629676,
0.3690921962,
0.1025529802,
0.3793997467,
0.3642796576,
-0.019830117,
0.0938404351,
-0.3115936518,
-0.6291756034,
-0.096337229,
0.6689466834,
0.8777808547,
-0.6062820554,
0.5452071428,
0.367564559,
-0.6494655013,
0.1920376867,
-0.3639364839,
-0.0885863006,
-0.4318360686,
0.5463426113,
-0.3443832695,
-0.972941637,
0.9524778128,
0.1181543991,
0.2524236143,
0.6190402508,
0.4405777454,
0.0216654651,
1.0821735859,
0.3333525658,
0.4035148919,
-0.176800251,
0.1815311313,
0.1103899851,
-0.6475714445,
-0.2137441784,
-0.5853216052,
-0.2970048785,
-0.6629519463,
-0.3283392787,
0.2732025683,
0.1547878534,
-0.245650962,
-0.219002068,
-0.3926477432,
0.2824987769,
0.3937954009,
0.0877656713,
0.3237631321,
-0.6084389091,
0.2883638144,
0.1152307987,
-0.5242552161,
-0.4132068157,
1.2952779531,
0.4674157202,
0.7074933648,
0.4149149656,
0.3473863006,
0.2404506505,
0.1823290288,
-0.6680321693,
0.349698931,
0.3538523614,
-1.0811564922,
-0.6118634939,
-0.4715143144,
-1.0687339306,
0.663979888,
-0.4226005673,
-0.6507445574,
0.2705656886,
-0.0352995917,
-0.5559734106,
0.1070417985,
-0.8385439515,
1.0311162472,
-0.4406803548,
-0.2894234657,
0.1825742424,
-0.9016267657,
0.5548450351,
-0.3454959989,
0.0436425656,
-0.1274150461,
-0.0540442206,
0.7138873935,
-0.2046747059,
0.5703442693,
-0.1811594367,
-0.0127126072,
0.4178530276,
-0.0149576608,
0.2762268484,
0.2588294744,
-0.372759819,
0.0912277699,
0.3148994446,
-0.627651155,
-1.0543473959,
0.4076297581,
-0.632389605,
-0.9197573066,
-0.2031125128,
-0.8347827196,
-0.3458176553,
0.285651803,
0.0814052522,
0.2057967931,
-0.1534792483,
0.2192301303,
0.4839859903,
-0.0782991722,
0.0695273653,
0.571418643,
-0.5041435957,
-0.1469867527,
0.127541393,
0.2226223052,
0.4077478051,
0.1641442329,
-0.0249233376,
-0.3223733008,
-0.56533885,
-0.5378388762,
0.0615215525,
-0.6416101456,
-0.1765648127,
-0.4002863765,
-0.3532069027,
-0.3475692272,
0.3502978086,
-0.1159895658,
-0.7538947463,
-0.2958390713,
-0.1455251873,
0.1806950122,
0.7130022049,
0.2156563848,
0.1760052294,
-0.6546976566,
0.3378764093,
0.4038062692,
0.164838925,
-0.000574124,
-0.4849303961,
-0.2139491886,
0.3390651643,
-0.2259604186,
-1.2538743019,
0.0300637763,
0.0917549133,
0.5820694566,
0.1977388263,
0.4382053018,
0.7548640966,
-0.3514933288,
0.7832952142,
-0.045826409,
-0.6260780692,
0.4222143292,
-0.3516120315,
0.5046846271,
0.4793280363,
0.6222174168,
-0.3032647073,
-0.3974187076,
-0.6817510724,
-0.8467929959,
0.3426488638,
0.3561081588,
-0.0863405541,
0.3079587519,
0.6949025989,
0.1668098271,
0.1976229697,
-0.6427278519,
-0.2338876128,
-0.0554970205,
0.008254718,
0.1135822013,
-0.1792717129,
-0.2737153769,
-0.2146085948,
0.2118954659,
0.0076087289,
0.2010682076,
0.0976503268,
-0.0073105218,
-0.2203210145,
0.4926322401,
0.5204101801,
0.8576219678,
-0.3519721627,
0.0263754204,
0.306637466,
-0.2323231399,
0.0708814785,
0.4561958611,
-0.0628102273,
-0.2055668533,
0.3879374266,
0.608815372,
-0.1166224033,
-0.742156446,
0.3954972327,
-0.341578573,
-0.3105466068,
-0.3021443784,
0.0783081874,
0.0309842192,
0.3646098077,
0.566849947,
0.106665276,
0.251254648,
-0.2526625991,
0.056176465,
0.4804807603,
-0.2796135843,
-0.1160211489,
0.8358255625,
0.0911423042,
-0.2910591364,
0.9230931401,
0.0723379776,
-0.3757149279,
0.8296223283,
0.2829413116,
0.5630784035,
-0.2032122463,
-0.0077316319,
0.3633314073,
0.4059120715,
0.2074018717,
0.2617393434,
-0.1014475226,
-0.6819015741,
-0.315752089,
-0.4413771927,
-0.5302044749,
0.2621102929,
-1.2423267365,
0.0955689251,
-0.1117495,
-0.2800150812,
0.2501566112,
-0.0452439487,
-0.5740941167,
0.3828252852,
-0.2641532123,
0.942345202,
-0.9530070424,
0.5045425892,
0.8183101416,
-0.6187621355,
-0.7120348215,
-0.026573468,
-0.0281562917,
-0.4709219635,
0.4612329006,
0.0892442837,
0.0160730761,
-0.1331635267,
-0.5806401372,
-0.9133149981,
1.0042411089,
0.3433693945,
-0.0729274005,
-0.3004971743,
0.4186227024,
0.6917752028,
-0.4339927137,
0.5099254847,
0.438152194,
0.3479622304,
0.1311699152,
-1.1724867821,
0.1909104437,
-0.4721191823,
-0.1927693337,
0.1796408296,
-0.4115573168,
0.7366147637,
-0.2694994211,
-0.093404308,
0.3794038892,
0.7150117755,
0.0392036103,
0.3561654985,
0.6147118211,
0.4637507796,
0.9983549714,
-0.0349978767,
0.5962340832,
-0.0349850543,
0.5650495887,
1.4811538458,
-0.1699291617,
0.8691954613,
0.455909729,
-0.1890976131,
0.3580258191,
1.1055344343,
-0.0695671588,
-0.0640748665,
0.4664584398,
-0.146003902,
-0.4473442435,
0.1013684869,
-0.5304547548,
0.5375863314,
0.2347890288,
-0.2578618526,
-0.3872128129,
-0.0677366108,
-0.2677398622,
-0.0127380751,
-0.1074977517,
0.1924195439,
-0.1538255662,
-0.7043737173,
0.5319624543,
0.0186824892,
0.0710269064,
-0.5737635493,
-0.0650556237,
-0.3447645009,
-0.156282872,
-0.3009051085,
-0.9339441657,
0.3107666671,
0.0800822973,
-0.3293929696,
-0.0075161592,
0.5366597772,
-0.2178768218,
-0.3928632438,
0.057565771,
0.7869788408,
0.1977092028,
0.015623658,
-0.8165459633,
-0.0939396396,
0.0025371977,
-0.2813959122,
0.0599370152,
0.4076500237,
-0.2818928063,
0.7371320128,
0.3669685125,
-0.3711542785,
0.3466916084,
-0.0775253102,
0.7775902748,
-0.4498210847,
-0.0798077285,
-0.4515047371,
0.7646688223,
-0.1153158844,
-0.3538638651,
0.9119216204,
0.7295408845,
0.5879026055,
-0.0483256727,
0.4251500666,
-0.2803985178,
0.5585207939,
-0.3978625834,
0.5484588146,
-0.8888184428,
0.3837726116,
-0.0811018869,
-0.7107170224,
-0.4046629071,
0.11450845,
-0.3122886419,
0.2114309222,
0.529317677,
0.6671187878,
-0.0973481908,
0.1612881422,
0.2477613539,
0.1730494052,
0.1783575565,
0.5852025747,
1.0866619349,
-0.5207418203,
0.5933603048,
-0.0041911923,
-0.1721141636,
0.0021911866,
-0.6360020041,
-0.4260895848,
-0.6774725914,
-0.3847627044,
-0.3676936924,
-0.1389747411,
0.6202640533,
0.554333806,
-0.611463964,
-0.2358431071,
0.2481339723,
0.1919482946,
-0.1771906465,
-0.2474513352,
0.4139219224,
-0.0810513273,
-0.642469883,
0.0346831083,
-0.2538466752,
0.1395557672,
-0.1814188212,
0.0855380595,
-0.2074802965,
0.2320961654,
0.2891282141,
0.4821048975,
-0.6784618497,
-0.4621084929,
0.3941051662,
0.1355559677,
0.1975615025,
0.6436536908,
-0.4055460095,
0.6828234196,
0.5053953528,
0.8290755749,
0.5223228931,
0.4367091656,
0.5282686949,
-0.5668903589,
-0.2876663208,
0.4563404918,
0.2258392572,
0.0365106985,
-0.3808578253,
0.5389052033,
-0.1428762674,
-0.7765575051,
-1.1263947487,
0.4414634407,
-1.1426179409,
-0.2915616632,
1.1752675772,
-0.1667077988,
0.0521656424,
0.0119783515,
-0.1151896715,
-0.0693096593,
-0.0153788235,
0.5802620649,
0.8899983764,
-0.6993615031,
-0.0636411533,
-0.7851672173,
0.0890899599,
0.3918938339,
-0.7830875516,
0.0577353351,
0.7090793848,
0.3702477515,
0.1640784591,
0.3822226822,
-0.10309273,
0.445096463,
-0.0389415883,
-0.1429063082,
0.2313043177,
0.1047856957,
-0.6016100049,
0.4283436835,
0.305221051,
-0.1862860322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12480v1 | Is Translation Helpful? An Empirical Analysis of Cross-Lingual Transfer in Low-Resource Dialog Generation | 2023-05-21T15:07:04 | 2023-05-21T15:07:04 | Lei Shen, Shuai Yu, Xiaoyu Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual transfer is important for developing high-quality chatbots in
multiple languages due to the strongly imbalanced distribution of language
resources. A typical approach is to leverage off-the-shelf machine translation
(MT) systems to utilize either the training corpus or developed models from
high-resource languages. In this work, we investigate whether it is helpful to
utilize MT at all in this task. To do so, we simulate a low-resource scenario
assuming access to limited Chinese dialog data in the movie domain and large
amounts of English dialog data from multiple domains. Experiments show that
leveraging English dialog corpora can indeed improve the naturalness, relevance
and cross-domain transferability in Chinese. However, directly using English
dialog corpora in its original form, surprisingly, is better than using its
translated version. As the topics and wording habits in daily conversations are
strongly culture-dependent, MT can reinforce the bias from high-resource
languages, yielding unnatural generations in the target language. Considering
the cost of translating large amounts of text and the strong effects of the
translation quality, we suggest future research should rather focus on
utilizing the original English data for cross-lingual transfer in dialog
generation. We perform extensive human evaluations and ablation studies. The
analysis results, together with the collected dataset, are presented to draw
attention towards this area and benefit future research. | [
-0.1802779287,
-0.7614941597,
0.0997807831,
-0.0162028801,
-0.351691246,
0.0649367124,
-0.2327904999,
-0.5846813321,
-0.0169887096,
0.5721376538,
-0.3729050159,
0.1331615299,
-0.351757735,
0.2742109895,
-0.304271102,
1.0129088163,
0.0498691499,
0.2415674627,
-0.1219639033,
-0.1012380198,
-0.6972216964,
-0.5435478687,
-0.7764720321,
-0.2965034544,
0.5160859823,
0.3155399859,
0.9655413032,
0.4729540348,
0.4678432941,
0.2658024132,
0.1812431067,
0.3220646679,
-0.6537892818,
-0.1048265919,
-0.1698469967,
-0.5156909227,
-0.4064773619,
-0.0771233812,
0.5791758299,
0.9999878407,
0.178363204,
0.1458086818,
0.3415245116,
0.5003527999,
-0.2345653474,
-0.0233335868,
-0.6885478497,
0.3387244642,
-0.210176006,
-0.724501133,
-0.4873996973,
-0.1920876801,
0.4186277092,
-0.6998226047,
0.3033244908,
0.4624982178,
0.6557683945,
0.1189698502,
-0.5680430532,
-0.212696746,
-0.867693603,
1.0339152813,
-0.6516183019,
0.2698982358,
0.366388768,
0.2064386457,
0.058354754,
-0.3172106147,
-0.393856734,
-0.0633488372,
-0.2927186191,
0.0850808918,
-0.3384527564,
-0.081554167,
0.1604782492,
0.4997535348,
-0.5079872608,
0.0911847949,
-0.81413275,
-0.4411234856,
0.3911866248,
0.2827478647,
0.7935853601,
-0.2258254588,
-0.3613362312,
-0.2956974208,
-0.7986370921,
0.0710417628,
0.1985189468,
0.6587113142,
-0.3204129636,
0.517349422,
0.1450858116,
0.552953124,
-0.0314689279,
-0.1963026971,
0.337372601,
-0.9805881977,
-0.1176840961,
0.1405101866,
0.6521705389,
0.6251298785,
0.255692631,
-0.1233956218,
0.0747116655,
-0.2891421616,
0.178422451,
-0.8639485836,
0.1916874051,
-0.0598058105,
-0.5837522745,
-0.0973281264,
-0.3177423179,
-0.7402504683,
-0.2171604931,
-0.2534716427,
-0.0234341342,
-0.4891129434,
-0.2833382487,
-0.2811797559,
-0.0402553789,
0.039034795,
0.467307657,
-0.8037865758,
-0.1789942086,
0.2169171721,
0.8598346114,
-0.2993128598,
-0.287774682,
-0.7850845456,
0.0438875407,
-0.3996534348,
0.5196678638,
-0.3811530471,
-0.5381524563,
0.3252868652,
0.1189828888,
-0.1954133064,
-0.6811640263,
0.522257328,
-0.3045197427,
0.4723956883,
-0.1652602553,
0.0133616757,
-0.0415270142,
-0.0047081499,
-0.6716368198,
0.5219312906,
0.0439626127,
-0.4396161139,
0.2817673981,
-0.5220303535,
-0.7689630985,
0.0560299829,
0.1951403469,
-0.0628278479,
0.143673107,
0.1300465912,
0.2450839579,
-0.5304170251,
0.1575804055,
-0.099829413,
-0.2209207714,
0.5415734649,
-0.7703019381,
0.7566085458,
0.6574921012,
-0.1778281182,
-0.4935924709,
-0.2508945763,
-0.1081435531,
-0.0330146253,
-0.2910684645,
-0.4310224652,
-0.4156740606,
0.1633987427,
0.4968794882,
0.2020325363,
-0.4590836465,
-0.0092441319,
-0.3816637695,
0.198421672,
0.4856297672,
0.0208378844,
0.8003979325,
-0.4356215,
0.6184705496,
0.1957453936,
-0.0603248477,
-0.2582638562,
-0.469322443,
-0.4620474875,
-0.1371915489,
0.357167542,
0.6465544701,
-1.233784318,
0.0945584774,
-0.1328790337,
-0.0864467919,
-0.7447085381,
0.3130080104,
0.3818989992,
0.4184043407,
0.1567484438,
-0.2891341746,
-0.4382128417,
-0.8831655383,
-0.0735456571,
-0.3156359196,
-0.1936250031,
0.5040115714,
-0.1264280826,
-0.1127389818,
0.6352674961,
-0.0324909613,
-0.3917793036,
-0.5117822289,
0.1752004623,
-0.1504890025,
0.3261278868,
0.7265091538,
-0.6725652218,
-0.6563699245,
0.4360026121,
-0.8040288091,
-0.4202972651,
-0.4733731449,
-0.6715195179,
0.4508223832,
0.1403431892,
-0.4876881242,
0.1114415899,
1.0045770407,
-0.1945196837,
0.0584388226,
-0.1914350539,
0.5433831811,
-1.1103844643,
0.2696869373,
-0.1356961578,
-0.2137266099,
-0.693787694,
-0.3741858006,
-0.306981653,
-0.3044104576,
-0.7641533613,
0.669551909,
-0.2105881274,
0.034080822,
-0.2660241425,
0.3753373027,
0.0050786138,
0.4550007582,
-0.0264992267,
0.9620669484,
0.2076283395,
-0.4302458465,
0.1399313658,
0.361577332,
-0.1778278947,
0.7571735978,
-0.231975317,
0.0719836578,
0.1074093282,
0.1438135356,
-0.7421109676,
0.0623086169,
0.4166624844,
-0.4889391661,
0.1366625428,
-0.0565619431,
-0.4486631453,
0.1857866347,
0.0658575073,
0.3337074816,
0.6274052262,
-0.4464387,
0.412725091,
0.4431712031,
-0.4313015342,
-0.2778483927,
-0.7717344761,
0.0578182191,
-0.2854086161,
-0.7047784328,
0.1446054727,
-0.084432207,
-0.2009849399,
0.1091545299,
0.0145226587,
-0.0879567116,
-0.0796196535,
-0.1076684967,
0.4541812539,
-0.2499816716,
-0.0356899463,
-0.0410088785,
0.0848663896,
-0.1140223891,
-0.1281288266,
0.4153656363,
0.0790544674,
-0.1070091873,
-0.293915391,
0.5485617518,
0.5196391344,
0.0231857207,
0.6430777907,
0.7165034413,
-0.1477969587,
-0.1155273616,
-0.2352129221,
-0.1139297709,
-0.4152929783,
0.3185366094,
-0.2198533416,
-0.7269573808,
0.3286200762,
-0.012743094,
0.1658386588,
0.4026865363,
0.5771428943,
-0.1417068243,
1.0421668291,
0.5294039249,
-0.1012315303,
0.762958467,
-0.0098175341,
0.4874507785,
-0.6202369332,
0.2178500891,
-0.3327369988,
-0.2766286135,
-0.618770957,
-0.4965541065,
0.3543401062,
-0.1960090697,
0.40488258,
0.4847481549,
-0.2043661028,
0.07880456,
0.5024528503,
-0.178067565,
0.5531205535,
0.3305109441,
0.0787254944,
-0.3395665586,
-0.8927325606,
-0.4643992186,
0.9032495618,
0.1713751853,
0.5814896226,
0.0132006183,
0.2785640359,
0.4897100925,
0.441648066,
-0.630869031,
0.4950448871,
-0.4029706419,
-0.6581130028,
-0.367870003,
-0.869627893,
-1.311797142,
0.5911666751,
-0.2752873898,
-0.4884590209,
-0.0090921121,
0.1853401363,
-0.1741004437,
0.2225189209,
-0.8775389194,
0.8549166918,
-0.6011378169,
-0.4527284801,
-0.494750917,
-0.4352989793,
0.2332382202,
-0.4186220765,
0.382327199,
-0.0575343147,
0.425619185,
0.6175965071,
-0.1866937727,
0.8319628835,
-0.0522536226,
-0.3259830177,
0.4852877855,
0.1674360335,
0.3208448887,
-0.2593307197,
0.0724193901,
0.3743002117,
0.0783374608,
-0.3750273883,
-0.6430945396,
0.514064908,
-0.8041446209,
-0.6588935256,
-0.1885718852,
-0.743500948,
-0.1436746716,
0.2289945334,
0.1649958342,
0.2155305296,
-0.2091587335,
0.4630982578,
0.2119843811,
-0.4228669107,
0.0160212778,
0.462025702,
-0.0819574818,
-0.2892160118,
1.0564879179,
0.1750506759,
0.6390176415,
0.2285381109,
0.185103476,
0.1081283912,
-0.0681787431,
-0.892048955,
0.2339715362,
-0.4708132446,
-0.0675470456,
-0.4513379037,
-0.0885641053,
-0.292162478,
-0.4034190476,
-0.3134054542,
-0.3643934131,
0.0042587002,
0.0785123408,
0.0160025638,
0.1241173744,
-0.1312120706,
0.2267417312,
-1.1156845093,
0.3001076877,
0.1007255837,
-0.2821260989,
-0.0764656141,
-0.6319651008,
-0.7790572047,
0.4821023941,
-0.3743070066,
-0.4895893633,
0.6292037964,
0.1279530823,
0.694611609,
0.1439681947,
0.1966543049,
0.6864721179,
-0.5163218379,
0.8537439704,
0.2409191728,
-0.6168984771,
0.1887162626,
-0.2945860624,
0.3694660664,
0.5076473355,
0.164604798,
-0.9196984172,
-0.5447156429,
-0.4846459627,
-0.7597123981,
0.7857583165,
0.355122447,
0.3050233722,
0.2411979586,
-0.1613882184,
0.2502222359,
0.2024203092,
-0.4108669162,
-0.0671871528,
0.0450732224,
0.0675420612,
-0.0229573324,
0.2984347045,
-0.2163029909,
0.0363109484,
0.5638863444,
-0.1740784943,
0.2686033845,
0.0415361859,
-0.2568902671,
-0.4598000348,
0.393183291,
0.2602085769,
0.2079350948,
-0.1366337091,
-0.0854255706,
0.4839909375,
-0.3567667902,
-0.0592513084,
-0.0506881401,
-0.201077804,
0.1354393363,
0.2165996283,
0.7229478359,
0.0670017451,
-0.7672761679,
0.3535372019,
0.0825117528,
0.0029770671,
0.0169162136,
-0.1238201335,
-0.3556374609,
0.1835790128,
0.3123733997,
0.2358519137,
0.147033304,
-1.0362250805,
-0.0132538127,
0.4409872293,
-0.163171351,
-0.4443117976,
0.4831543565,
0.7514306307,
-0.1791336536,
0.8264595866,
0.0659794882,
-0.4323289394,
0.3126676977,
0.6817269325,
0.7911837101,
0.007563903,
0.1795007437,
0.3026538193,
0.3413409889,
0.1056434289,
-0.3941940963,
-0.1598595977,
-0.8653152585,
-0.6289432049,
-0.275767386,
-0.7473390102,
0.0154995304,
-0.3195002079,
0.2043804228,
0.2259585857,
-0.1860967577,
-0.2817978859,
-0.1847643107,
-0.8557090163,
-0.2473861575,
0.3857822716,
0.4301205277,
-0.9321084023,
0.8131691813,
0.5808727145,
-0.3440201581,
-0.3942670822,
-0.0145576643,
0.0598220117,
-0.7168111205,
0.8549415469,
-0.0924373865,
-0.2532356381,
-0.4527700841,
-0.2093371302,
-0.8246059418,
0.8612430692,
0.41978091,
-0.1943487823,
-0.2151391953,
0.5985334516,
0.8169306517,
-0.4874719679,
0.1160800233,
0.3619392514,
0.2959597707,
0.1424153298,
-1.2698121071,
0.126626119,
-0.4462101758,
-0.0160180181,
-0.0269786511,
-0.7186623216,
0.5934690237,
-0.0205731783,
-0.5721166134,
-0.0795329809,
0.4278620183,
0.1313354075,
0.3093630672,
0.5446124673,
-0.146333009,
0.4729174674,
0.0723406598,
0.9717954993,
-0.6340401173,
-0.0606941544,
0.6746013165,
-0.4317952991,
0.6153541207,
0.7449566722,
0.1036916301,
0.171449244,
0.2611600459,
0.1880609542,
0.5379788876,
0.0544436947,
-0.0756613165,
-0.1344921887,
-0.5586368442,
-0.3126044273,
0.1558571756,
0.4212514162,
-0.4430651367,
-0.1322301328,
0.2028236538,
0.0834286511,
-0.1271541715,
0.0050081448,
0.5977965593,
0.2393732369,
-0.9236163497,
0.7547643185,
-0.2823560834,
0.7948783636,
-0.4485398531,
-0.1382056177,
-0.4271447062,
0.0732038766,
-0.1763839722,
-0.4813987613,
0.4041695893,
0.2193018049,
0.1359567046,
-0.8174260259,
0.722543478,
-0.6549586058,
-0.1678030789,
0.2837296426,
0.9424139261,
0.3470097482,
0.3897897303,
-0.4090741575,
-0.1045440212,
0.2328350842,
-0.1618731469,
0.6112115383,
0.6745770574,
-0.1224400178,
0.3138501346,
0.9327337742,
0.3065720499,
-0.0787323341,
0.0084964121,
0.5313163996,
-0.4471214414,
-0.3013437092,
-0.4591425359,
0.4858437479,
-0.0845557675,
-0.3152795434,
0.9174061418,
0.4905687869,
1.0621908903,
-0.0898147821,
1.086565733,
-0.1459843814,
0.3177064955,
-0.5242653489,
0.450135082,
-0.6423211098,
0.2009452283,
-0.1361257583,
-0.9021530151,
-0.0454015546,
0.5199613571,
-0.3145908415,
-0.3571554422,
0.7512184978,
0.6975523233,
0.0181998946,
-0.0970337093,
0.6784632206,
-0.0889143497,
0.1622096747,
0.6111308932,
0.9338427782,
-0.3143781126,
1.0628885031,
-0.1415082663,
-0.1061376259,
-0.3330956101,
-0.492279321,
-0.9138088226,
-0.4969085455,
-0.2838882506,
-0.4728225172,
0.0592546426,
1.0467823744,
0.4826105535,
-0.5385870337,
-0.4776815176,
0.53203547,
-0.0355689339,
-0.2791385949,
-0.2428347617,
-0.0065574548,
-0.3177633584,
-1.175413847,
0.3243929446,
0.1235215738,
0.1299212426,
-0.3756880462,
-0.0695163906,
0.0771448463,
0.1090520024,
0.8604884148,
0.2987163961,
-0.4746575356,
-0.375562638,
0.3224997222,
-0.40173316,
0.142826587,
0.9973196387,
-0.4400116801,
0.4066246152,
0.6910710931,
0.9037494063,
0.4012579024,
-0.1001404673,
1.1722686291,
-0.7150693536,
0.2571249604,
-0.1064113975,
0.5121731162,
0.5288921595,
-0.4768094718,
0.6331307888,
0.2058744431,
-0.4630424976,
-0.7628832459,
0.0670191199,
-0.7634091377,
-0.0479581803,
1.3223809004,
-0.0191752128,
-0.2332635224,
-0.1299819797,
-0.6161473989,
0.3556841016,
-0.6116213202,
0.6806948781,
0.8803666234,
-0.1659712791,
-0.2804704905,
-0.8557139039,
0.2919401824,
0.7815686464,
-0.7670155168,
0.1061500236,
0.4854626358,
-0.1308217049,
0.4399864078,
0.6283503175,
-0.2095603645,
0.1599172354,
-0.0128467698,
-0.0784711018,
0.2451362461,
0.0568411052,
-0.0695558712,
-0.1389270723,
-0.0829318389,
-0.1395798624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12477v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12477v2 | GPT-3.5, GPT-4, or BARD? Evaluating LLMs Reasoning Ability in Zero-Shot Setting and Performance Boosting Through Prompts | 2023-05-21T14:45:17 | 2023-09-19T21:34:51 | Jessica López Espejel, El Hassane Ettifouri, Mahaman Sanoussi Yahaya Alassan, El Mehdi Chouham, Walid Dahhane | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable performance on various
Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. However, there is a current hot debate
regarding their reasoning capacity. In this paper, we examine the performance
of GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and BARD models, by performing a thorough technical
evaluation on different reasoning tasks across eleven distinct datasets. Our
paper provides empirical evidence showcasing the superior performance of
ChatGPT-4 in comparison to both ChatGPT-3.5 and BARD in zero-shot setting
throughout almost all evaluated tasks. While the superiority of GPT-4 compared
to GPT-3.5 might be explained by its larger size and NLP efficiency, this was
not evident for BARD. We also demonstrate that the three models show limited
proficiency in Inductive, Mathematical, and Multi-hop Reasoning Tasks. To
bolster our findings, we present a detailed and comprehensive analysis of the
results from these three models. Furthermore, we propose a set of engineered
prompts that enhances the zero-shot setting performance of all three models. | [
-0.2806873918,
-0.8183167577,
0.9662240744,
0.1489439756,
-0.0260932259,
0.1520701349,
-0.2211659402,
-0.5775859952,
-0.2639107406,
0.3631716073,
-0.4577817917,
-0.5379693508,
-0.4911139011,
0.3981231153,
-0.1812289208,
1.1154288054,
-0.1054164693,
0.0109856585,
-0.0360587239,
-0.0321999714,
-0.9074000716,
-0.5125015974,
-0.757659018,
-0.3536185026,
0.7473255992,
0.2801632881,
0.7004801631,
0.2451999336,
0.4845594764,
0.2010753006,
-0.1504284441,
0.0497776158,
-0.2066059858,
0.3704332113,
-0.296063751,
-0.4247552752,
-0.4627396464,
0.2129711658,
0.5452828407,
0.4140782952,
0.1246827468,
0.0691586286,
-0.040753074,
0.5835844278,
-0.3654928803,
0.1554141045,
-0.81346488,
-0.022089649,
-0.0641098917,
-0.261156708,
-0.4387393892,
-0.3353747725,
0.1712127328,
-0.7153704762,
0.3058818579,
0.059279982,
0.9144014716,
0.3353155255,
-0.2616612315,
-0.1976897269,
-0.7331722975,
0.6485430002,
-0.8666554093,
0.0807844326,
0.1765392274,
0.401251018,
-0.1210003421,
-0.4947085381,
-0.5502949357,
-0.4825628698,
0.1094281077,
0.1580961347,
-0.2159242779,
0.2579058409,
0.6686539054,
0.3126567304,
-0.9019534588,
0.26817137,
-0.3948707283,
-0.0566516072,
0.3785300255,
0.1855810434,
0.0640903264,
-0.2901160717,
-0.2349294573,
0.1800005734,
-0.8119909167,
-0.0224592555,
0.2754504681,
0.4871633947,
0.2231535167,
0.8942677975,
-0.3708304465,
0.9514326453,
0.0111127188,
-0.191102922,
-0.0570395626,
-0.379814744,
-0.3063187897,
-0.1541410834,
0.7570084929,
0.233343333,
0.3425242603,
-0.0729592592,
-0.0805594623,
0.205375433,
0.0675856173,
-0.576731503,
-0.0580291599,
0.2860621214,
-0.1082317904,
-0.0788808689,
-0.5182548165,
-0.1549786478,
-0.4478881955,
-0.3967725039,
0.624606967,
-0.6819489002,
-0.0713260323,
0.3657233119,
-0.3695624173,
0.5574902296,
0.5632998347,
-0.8996543288,
0.0962612107,
0.8011340499,
0.9113849998,
-0.2826066613,
-0.1448137462,
-0.3131687641,
0.0608209781,
-0.3232744038,
1.1757291555,
-0.5480732322,
-0.2482439429,
-0.2600819767,
-0.2244949639,
-0.3983275294,
-0.2723295391,
1.0155258179,
-0.3879293501,
0.5231389999,
-0.5886067748,
-0.8317261338,
-0.3653136492,
0.6763164401,
-0.5973014235,
0.9755405188,
0.0655752718,
-0.7241085172,
0.3987625539,
-0.9832579494,
-0.2205625623,
0.4344662428,
-0.2710374296,
0.0430491008,
-0.014740943,
0.3658401072,
0.5678222179,
-0.4384578764,
0.1094173193,
-0.3510770798,
-0.6867060661,
0.1492370665,
-0.6579759121,
0.7449884415,
0.1264005452,
-0.4279284477,
0.1512141824,
-0.497710377,
0.0331367292,
0.0478114747,
-0.2718455493,
0.2105226964,
-0.1439915299,
-0.593182981,
0.2307179719,
0.0170476008,
-0.6247648001,
0.2890675664,
-0.3795834482,
0.4634501636,
0.6081293821,
-0.0520568192,
0.2552927732,
-0.5041502714,
0.8136616349,
-0.3033194244,
-0.0537103117,
-0.2838559449,
-0.912715435,
-0.6038091779,
-0.2380073965,
0.3405388594,
0.8929750919,
-1.0096870661,
0.0214263499,
-0.1575756967,
-0.4981556237,
-0.343105495,
-0.1301924884,
0.2042537928,
0.6841778159,
0.3577810526,
0.2495251596,
-0.0373145714,
-0.7864980102,
-0.6241332293,
-0.2710361183,
-0.2929882109,
0.3326366842,
0.3688485622,
0.3466142714,
0.8833884001,
-0.2262648344,
0.1204726249,
-0.596830368,
0.2059880644,
0.5721061826,
0.1928865612,
0.5626553893,
-0.1781709492,
-0.5892239213,
0.0528934188,
-0.822081089,
-0.2855764031,
-0.2434049398,
-0.1006593406,
0.3769513369,
0.0718739703,
-1.0493266582,
0.4308407009,
0.3247061968,
-0.4325958788,
1.0327247381,
0.0056161294,
0.2716468275,
-0.5728741884,
-0.0497079566,
0.1211981326,
-0.2067359239,
-0.7412878871,
-0.0483294837,
-0.0654043406,
-0.1808302999,
-0.291816622,
0.7412620187,
-0.4745756984,
-0.2441820651,
-0.1595835388,
0.5736044049,
0.1848620474,
0.5962181687,
0.1732279062,
0.8383386731,
0.5420221686,
-0.4726296365,
0.6472437978,
0.0307330359,
-0.4703599811,
0.5977115631,
-0.899623394,
0.1107108742,
0.2124062777,
0.4720647335,
-0.8781426549,
-0.18580845,
0.2588343918,
-0.6535981297,
0.2141630501,
-0.1297896504,
-0.5552871227,
-0.5561996102,
-0.3397744,
0.1996400654,
0.5090526938,
-0.3222280145,
0.3492511213,
-0.2956041992,
-0.3695957065,
-0.5507020354,
-0.4628946781,
0.1631268114,
-0.3904194832,
-0.7445603609,
0.178186968,
-0.0757229552,
-0.2145493478,
-0.0820016935,
-0.0612114519,
0.2356398702,
-0.0029353274,
-0.0626205355,
0.5263578892,
-0.3040079474,
0.2235922217,
-0.1567405015,
-0.2047938704,
-0.1262092143,
-0.3418674469,
0.2166511714,
-0.3229488134,
-0.6471174955,
-0.4659477174,
0.2027229369,
0.2697734237,
-0.08373788,
0.6654492021,
0.4575825334,
-0.0390124694,
0.0296067689,
-0.7501117587,
0.0248120353,
-0.4219875634,
-0.0513317026,
-0.5803843141,
-1.1486268044,
0.4493787587,
0.1806014478,
0.2153121382,
0.64098382,
0.718318224,
-0.0765094161,
0.9220362902,
0.1331884712,
0.2638442814,
0.2857927978,
-0.0594258979,
0.4425305426,
-0.8057603836,
-0.0063950466,
-0.5696409941,
-0.1176693887,
-0.5824638605,
-0.4789253771,
0.4509703219,
0.0899448842,
-0.4786147773,
0.2361098379,
-0.5994435549,
0.6853134632,
0.5745407939,
-0.0845392868,
0.4198655784,
-0.2215412259,
-0.2669227719,
0.3596192896,
-0.8503375649,
-0.9028015137,
1.1105692387,
0.3266004026,
0.3405587375,
0.0823986977,
0.1967523694,
0.0407575853,
0.1527136862,
-0.9110949636,
0.6606788635,
0.0650158748,
-1.0098918676,
-0.5176018476,
-0.4432308376,
-0.8708250523,
0.3846056759,
-0.0517749116,
-0.7088080645,
-0.1411599219,
0.0039809523,
-0.78944242,
0.4726159275,
-0.7737414241,
0.7706365585,
-0.102440916,
-0.2756581604,
0.077555865,
-0.549998045,
0.6305751801,
0.1309717,
-0.0402523205,
-0.5388477445,
0.1087260246,
0.3755436838,
-0.1540133953,
0.5100973248,
-0.262753129,
-0.1874178201,
0.5570433736,
0.0389986783,
0.4194583595,
-0.1176292077,
-0.3235296011,
0.0971376449,
0.1993453801,
-0.5066426992,
-0.7166275382,
0.5971568823,
-0.5511656404,
-0.8388592601,
-0.442122072,
-0.532962203,
-0.519109726,
-0.0320920236,
0.2010812759,
0.5718048811,
-0.1130103096,
0.0933055505,
0.5936719775,
-0.4405774474,
0.6230641603,
0.5577075481,
-0.149115473,
-0.043099314,
0.578619957,
0.2580402493,
0.5380936265,
0.2503348589,
0.008854107,
-0.381056875,
-0.6781122684,
-0.6901069283,
0.3254557252,
-0.6821863055,
-0.2793294787,
-0.5276649594,
-0.324549824,
-0.4138676226,
-0.1545414031,
-0.0263927579,
-0.9284874201,
-0.1614542007,
-0.2344910949,
0.4435071051,
0.7643028498,
-0.1009989157,
0.2426566035,
-0.647536695,
0.3066654801,
0.3973159492,
0.4616228342,
-0.2477747649,
-0.6760821342,
-0.1000294983,
-0.1206252575,
-0.4814335406,
-0.9896854162,
0.1296111792,
-0.1678402126,
0.6190878153,
0.1900891811,
-0.1535823196,
0.3934565783,
-0.569819212,
1.2895928621,
-0.0010165616,
-0.8154125214,
0.4478413165,
-0.8968113065,
0.455773592,
0.2980257571,
0.2890249789,
-0.3643640876,
-0.2826320827,
-0.606849134,
-0.4312875271,
0.732110858,
0.4743757248,
-0.1061543599,
-0.1124103889,
0.5758693218,
0.1005873755,
-0.0293248855,
-0.8284187913,
0.1835419536,
-0.1859055012,
0.046833232,
0.0167739987,
-0.2441719025,
0.0418393277,
-0.2681261897,
0.7952666879,
-0.1415393353,
0.4172827601,
0.0889453515,
0.1195831448,
0.3365507722,
0.5711611509,
0.6106687784,
0.5573279262,
-0.1647925675,
-0.1418334991,
0.3462717831,
-0.1532075554,
0.1259378046,
0.1143524051,
-0.0155261224,
-0.0053197145,
0.5786653161,
1.0447076559,
-0.0478502885,
-0.4771516621,
0.4911555946,
-0.1413978487,
-0.469750315,
-0.0557789765,
0.3136134744,
0.0178204812,
0.3082050979,
0.0680469722,
-0.0934813395,
0.1203280836,
-0.4487472773,
-0.3821754158,
0.5002453327,
-0.0315806307,
-0.2373798192,
0.5173648596,
0.1602585465,
-0.1097679883,
0.5434963703,
-0.4459066689,
-0.4293042421,
0.4816344082,
0.4524210393,
0.9215557575,
-0.1295489073,
0.4495998621,
0.4282066226,
0.3960778713,
-0.1322124153,
0.2846652269,
-0.2405857444,
-0.8794073462,
-0.9991788268,
-0.4995289743,
-0.71280545,
0.1075776219,
-0.4398617744,
0.2963195145,
-0.3100362718,
-0.2243603319,
-0.0352703147,
0.2312919199,
-0.6997249722,
0.041603785,
0.1322305948,
0.9569935799,
-0.616481185,
0.6413175464,
0.4496661723,
-0.3350835443,
-0.9852818847,
-0.1882644892,
0.0557223335,
-0.6480234861,
0.4313933253,
0.2017790824,
-0.1097482443,
-0.0556445718,
-0.5459567904,
-0.761480093,
1.1776082516,
0.4739415646,
-0.4491650164,
-0.0754861534,
0.0159476791,
0.5202071667,
-0.2258247584,
0.6609535217,
0.9558966756,
0.5341074467,
0.5418690443,
-1.2655643225,
-0.1677375585,
-0.130015105,
-0.1058704928,
-0.0805493146,
-0.4251501858,
0.7560178041,
-0.1685320139,
-0.3115212619,
0.1879872829,
0.3412703574,
0.8568853736,
0.1609728485,
0.2728209496,
0.5090458989,
0.8820516467,
-0.2825695574,
1.3025004864,
-0.1034525856,
0.0540886074,
1.1739797592,
-0.5576691031,
0.7748295665,
0.0002579095,
-0.3080307245,
0.5919939876,
0.8354848623,
0.0770215243,
0.1340765208,
0.2148976922,
-0.5022218823,
-0.3188129961,
0.0672957152,
-0.3530494273,
0.3848846555,
0.4110109806,
0.0860705227,
-0.2133584917,
-0.1351751983,
0.1817443371,
-0.2780656219,
-0.3759416342,
0.668228209,
-0.0179834254,
-0.8488846421,
0.5419967175,
-0.031100044,
0.4202861786,
-0.3832654059,
0.0432278737,
-0.2284723967,
-0.1978098601,
-0.0486444496,
-0.9888735414,
0.220583573,
0.4679480791,
-0.0359081998,
-0.3154713809,
0.8765128255,
0.0156087968,
-0.4525246024,
0.0287769474,
0.6375903487,
0.5365635157,
-0.2556208074,
-0.7455195189,
-0.109938316,
-0.0549571253,
-0.4727267623,
0.0843895823,
0.8205227256,
-0.0595524572,
0.6695415378,
0.6236656308,
0.1952157468,
0.051554475,
0.3933521211,
0.7747694254,
-0.8117742538,
-0.1387324482,
-0.900118351,
0.3770622015,
-0.133006826,
-0.1708808094,
0.9299390316,
0.3908185959,
0.4334783852,
0.1879296601,
0.8991698623,
0.1260178536,
0.9493700266,
-0.5962141156,
0.1474068463,
-0.0694994926,
0.4735350609,
-0.2763056755,
-1.0129897594,
-0.490313828,
0.6390094757,
-0.7625589967,
0.3516601622,
0.8122090697,
0.6563777924,
0.2935238779,
0.4114175737,
0.5578120351,
0.2905469835,
0.4724654257,
0.665157795,
1.1903256178,
-0.0475320481,
0.4709598422,
0.3127824962,
-0.3325784802,
0.120424144,
-1.1406062841,
-1.1010317802,
-0.1488790512,
-0.0924526006,
-0.056343589,
-0.121898815,
0.5929108858,
0.4173247218,
-0.535535574,
0.0566247217,
-0.1795889735,
0.1671396047,
-0.0595379397,
-0.2286684811,
0.1799474508,
-0.6719380617,
-0.4074013233,
0.672980845,
0.5295769572,
-0.029341517,
-0.2758220732,
0.0259897988,
-0.0351076201,
0.4728714824,
0.8306282759,
0.2520851791,
-0.9837607145,
-0.3696707189,
0.0718579143,
0.1807323843,
-0.0718490556,
0.6152094007,
-1.1020998955,
0.1602042466,
0.4989974797,
0.3896289766,
0.6380621195,
0.0925673693,
0.5820116401,
-0.3846970499,
-0.2142381668,
0.3225367665,
0.3281037509,
0.4984619915,
-0.2408791035,
0.7804755569,
0.2055841535,
-1.0016725063,
-0.7099285126,
0.1350185871,
-0.8709922433,
-0.357583195,
1.3542109728,
-0.2208050787,
0.2500393391,
-0.1982299536,
-0.3955731094,
0.0821172372,
-0.2507685125,
0.3982878029,
1.0576169491,
-0.6937719584,
-0.2323269248,
-1.1746909618,
0.5350349545,
0.4211944938,
-0.8115637898,
0.0104475105,
0.680980742,
0.16552715,
-0.0641692653,
0.812522471,
-0.1311811209,
0.1488016099,
-0.0286411792,
-0.1964347959,
-0.0132646104,
-0.2792368531,
-0.4275430441,
0.213837862,
0.1031011492,
0.1304589659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12474v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12474v3 | Evaluating the Performance of Large Language Models on GAOKAO Benchmark | 2023-05-21T14:39:28 | 2024-02-24T15:44:21 | Xiaotian Zhang, Chunyang Li, Yi Zong, Zhengyu Ying, Liang He, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models(LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance across
various natural language processing tasks; however, how to comprehensively and
accurately assess their performance becomes an urgent issue to be addressed.
This paper introduces GAOKAO-Bench, an intuitive benchmark that employs
questions from the Chinese GAOKAO examination as test samples, including both
subjective and objective questions. To align with human examination methods, we
design a method based on zero-shot settings to evaluate the performance of
LLMs. With human evaluation, we obtain the converted total score of LLMs,
including GPT-4, ChatGPT and ERNIE-Bot.Our findings reveal that LLMs have
achieved competitive scores in Chinese GAOKAO examination, while they exhibit
significant performance disparities across various subjects. We also use LLMs
to grade the subjective questions, and find that model scores achieve a
moderate level of consistency with human scores. In conclusion, this research
contributes a robust evaluation benchmark for future large language models and
offers valuable insights into the advantages and limitations of such models. | [
-0.1527812928,
-0.8630463481,
0.6683186293,
0.255614996,
-0.3360645473,
-0.112168029,
-0.6884644628,
-0.5947054625,
-0.3240354061,
0.5795516372,
-0.2914803326,
-0.6619922519,
-0.6230885386,
0.240025118,
-0.2003334463,
0.7233375907,
0.1111689284,
0.1670693606,
-0.1020775661,
-0.2337114066,
-0.5844377279,
-0.4084486663,
-0.4648396671,
-0.4843092263,
0.249771595,
0.1036737934,
0.6114438176,
0.4606514573,
0.3918443024,
0.3355201185,
-0.0761509091,
-0.1301986277,
-0.4115113616,
0.0673779473,
0.0433834791,
-0.6144269109,
-0.345582813,
0.2007777393,
0.9260185957,
0.729712069,
-0.2312541902,
0.2809507549,
-0.0277297664,
0.5134754181,
-0.5595297813,
0.1454159915,
-0.8227736354,
0.080570817,
-0.1450219154,
0.1351340264,
-0.5489023328,
-0.517201066,
0.0459774435,
-0.4459137619,
-0.0647832528,
-0.06100614,
0.9697545767,
0.1129340306,
-0.433421582,
-0.087632075,
-0.321041882,
0.9052157998,
-1.0033661127,
0.1670663208,
0.1728131771,
0.5290591121,
-0.1827232391,
-0.245420292,
-0.3887222707,
-0.6801778674,
0.0547577552,
0.201264888,
0.0396399498,
-0.0497126505,
0.1429080069,
0.4247469902,
-0.8010309339,
0.2985348105,
-0.0292756446,
-0.0951855034,
0.7535411119,
0.3074959219,
0.2435309142,
-0.258249253,
-0.2008377314,
-0.1045806929,
-0.3498044312,
0.0061110486,
0.2710698545,
0.4309673309,
0.0807024911,
0.4160090983,
-0.5416253805,
0.9191620946,
-0.1541303843,
-0.2616991699,
0.2634574771,
0.0171476752,
-0.3500225842,
-0.1081282943,
1.1840363741,
0.4335345626,
0.4305702746,
-0.4470489323,
-0.1344539374,
-0.0398751572,
0.1722069085,
-0.9479603171,
0.0873793736,
0.1013760045,
-0.3197941184,
-0.3701387048,
-0.200832516,
-0.8289939165,
-0.3553039432,
-0.1992471665,
0.5256593823,
-0.177128911,
-0.2091463804,
0.0654386356,
0.1107033119,
0.5798931122,
0.3915145099,
-0.7890930772,
0.5497954488,
0.8805814385,
0.816426456,
-0.1779767573,
-0.3368214965,
-0.6970567703,
-0.1542000771,
-0.6462310553,
0.7231178284,
-0.6407117844,
-0.125419721,
0.0198599491,
-0.1552516669,
0.110213995,
-0.7130841613,
0.7265723944,
-0.5164762735,
0.0143217873,
-0.3627949357,
-0.6171703935,
-0.1963402778,
0.7477636337,
-0.4447790682,
1.0718383789,
0.0815442428,
-0.2176383585,
0.2612110972,
-0.4266180396,
-0.3376045823,
0.2312071621,
-0.1461150646,
-0.2713541985,
0.1171674579,
0.0765850171,
0.546916604,
-0.806412816,
0.43090716,
-0.4579885304,
-0.5611931086,
0.265093565,
-0.3917554319,
0.6925169826,
0.0538091697,
-0.2825736701,
0.1373639107,
-0.7662281394,
0.3107428551,
0.4055791497,
-0.2501073778,
-0.2835849822,
-0.0442607477,
-0.1486021578,
0.1342556775,
0.2601394951,
-0.4614052176,
0.3439897001,
-0.2935799956,
0.336551398,
0.8152080178,
-0.3424887657,
0.2755893171,
-0.0376605093,
0.3468909562,
-0.4508877397,
0.2686666548,
0.1671976745,
-0.5919043422,
-0.6717767715,
-0.0654091537,
0.4012462199,
0.4612070024,
-0.2425696552,
0.6097890139,
-0.2687374353,
-0.8059331179,
-0.4677483141,
0.2950949073,
0.2860212922,
0.6079286337,
0.1520154029,
-0.2253417224,
-0.0187999811,
-0.9115641713,
-0.36243397,
-0.3317334652,
-0.3298660219,
0.3875625432,
0.4432645738,
0.1596038789,
0.5081127286,
-0.5626266003,
0.0053971685,
-0.2353178412,
0.4247030318,
0.4305059612,
0.0705239102,
0.5008329153,
-0.4021189511,
-0.6270213723,
0.1140231043,
-0.939856112,
-0.4630587995,
-0.0105965836,
-0.2864014208,
0.2382268459,
0.1907968819,
-0.51865834,
-0.1188031286,
0.7214912772,
0.0201628264,
0.7739309669,
-0.0314655341,
0.3149562478,
-0.6926798224,
0.1766035557,
-0.0579162724,
-0.2078966945,
-0.54278332,
0.3488558233,
0.1308178902,
-0.070040293,
-0.3088949323,
0.6612950563,
-0.4459560812,
-0.2322328091,
-0.3388662338,
0.6240561604,
-0.022779163,
0.4414131343,
0.0029451083,
0.5147671103,
0.6074342728,
-0.4310977757,
0.3740864098,
-0.0816591531,
-0.5743708611,
0.4766707718,
-0.8863797784,
0.3104090691,
0.2231577486,
0.0091677504,
-1.0863769054,
-0.1419260055,
0.0882457495,
-0.3661755919,
0.1997472197,
-0.2732740939,
-0.7981384993,
-0.2172196656,
-0.4188163579,
0.1720625609,
0.6816872358,
-0.3715395629,
0.500770092,
0.2610580027,
-0.0282844715,
-0.4455711246,
-0.4352778792,
0.2360662669,
-0.348962009,
-0.7510218024,
-0.0551852062,
-0.0615067482,
-0.2416037023,
-0.2943150699,
0.0997417122,
0.0154263806,
0.3002851903,
-0.1390196979,
0.4950146079,
-0.3311817646,
0.1444217414,
-0.3265696168,
0.0465791263,
0.1869704425,
0.076929383,
0.7701369524,
-0.3826160133,
-0.1358915865,
-0.2379272282,
-0.0210979749,
0.4779447019,
-0.2438777387,
0.6994941831,
0.3913525641,
-0.2806302905,
-0.0730869398,
-0.8483560681,
0.1761507541,
-0.4239697456,
0.3936130702,
-0.3154923022,
-0.7131032944,
0.5980685353,
-0.1017191559,
-0.1045994237,
0.3548120558,
0.6385641694,
0.2566659451,
0.923301816,
0.3437368274,
-0.4112462997,
0.1957166195,
0.1013878137,
0.0837311745,
-0.934431076,
-0.0598346069,
-0.579082787,
-0.005530729,
-0.6263127327,
-0.3207287192,
0.1809302419,
0.2740022838,
-0.3554275036,
0.3766201437,
-0.4295415878,
0.5404337049,
0.3470547795,
-0.1996093988,
0.4562250674,
-0.486125201,
0.0595527403,
0.0558795221,
-0.2995896339,
-0.9031338096,
1.1512883902,
0.2311111391,
0.640083313,
0.0107288985,
0.432767719,
0.1954477131,
0.5561964512,
-0.8968420625,
0.7474656105,
-0.0797497034,
-0.7493894696,
-0.4652633071,
-0.6003623009,
-0.8106535077,
0.76256001,
-0.0781236067,
-1.0196961164,
-0.4117894173,
-0.2472430766,
-0.2126778215,
0.1019980535,
-0.7502599955,
1.1528718472,
-0.6553112268,
-0.5105081797,
0.0556925908,
-0.4369575977,
0.749114573,
-0.1740231216,
0.0240580942,
-0.5510475039,
-0.1933695227,
0.6903867722,
-0.2151243687,
0.5439015031,
0.006767258,
-0.0706126019,
0.4154505432,
0.1440359056,
0.2922998071,
0.1116364077,
-0.5027424693,
0.4814327657,
0.0026170653,
-0.4460823238,
-0.6224651337,
0.7420666814,
-0.8383377194,
-0.6059036255,
-0.4992414415,
-0.4516689777,
-0.3883428276,
0.3206090331,
-0.0798252597,
0.1611862332,
-0.527623713,
0.1435473263,
0.1516711414,
-0.4604573846,
0.2507511675,
0.9657126665,
-0.3367733359,
-0.2182005793,
0.4739858806,
0.124246262,
0.4610033929,
0.4082072675,
0.535623312,
-0.3503443897,
-0.5112624764,
-0.6011198163,
0.3996244967,
-0.664167583,
-0.0747427717,
-0.3448092639,
-0.1438123733,
-0.4342062771,
0.0340208337,
-0.5358189344,
0.2360517085,
0.096310772,
0.141475305,
0.0408057868,
0.511877358,
0.2244900316,
0.1099314466,
-0.6970491409,
0.4159674048,
0.3155656457,
0.5138555169,
0.2752301693,
-0.6969901919,
-0.0007662731,
0.0137410183,
-0.3441595435,
-0.6143071055,
0.2613268793,
-0.0770860761,
0.7543320656,
0.3304181695,
0.1162693948,
0.6647683978,
-0.6840831637,
0.8262429833,
0.1043570265,
-1.0543720722,
0.502402842,
-0.4870644212,
0.3806729913,
0.7325263023,
0.3162820041,
-0.6992296576,
-0.1841055006,
-0.2513555884,
-0.6084669828,
0.7662290931,
0.2294470072,
0.1315273494,
-0.0163542889,
0.1974918842,
0.1660584062,
0.1187578291,
-0.839653194,
0.0049042562,
-0.0184883364,
0.0889949799,
-0.2103856355,
-0.0750097632,
-0.007960951,
-0.0691283941,
0.453451097,
-0.1285478324,
-0.0148492455,
-0.1862395555,
-0.1703264415,
-0.0663552061,
0.4042480588,
0.4811021388,
0.5407540202,
-0.5339941978,
-0.1444367617,
0.3887519538,
-0.1757345498,
0.0436322428,
-0.0860545486,
-0.1257800162,
-0.1653104573,
0.5007141232,
0.5541442037,
0.1345536113,
-0.9522505999,
0.6077650785,
-0.2457247227,
-0.0414308496,
-0.2569215596,
0.1348423362,
0.242150709,
0.0286836457,
0.2626050413,
-0.4029982388,
0.199623242,
-1.0354858637,
-0.207847327,
0.4510138333,
-0.2267737091,
-0.2362748832,
0.5067264438,
0.1792658418,
-0.3404927254,
0.8002240062,
-0.0762505382,
-0.5474427938,
0.6148262024,
0.3626773655,
0.8587140441,
-0.1370031983,
0.1292149574,
0.5802812576,
0.4009857178,
-0.3175734878,
-0.1041224152,
-0.1378071606,
-0.6438879371,
-0.4647173285,
-0.69968611,
-0.5699042678,
0.5496288538,
-0.745357573,
0.3806370199,
-0.4353491366,
0.0016488667,
-0.1683076322,
0.2203073949,
-0.4650780261,
0.3385251462,
0.4546554983,
0.7339115143,
-0.7946895957,
0.6691787839,
0.3467512131,
-0.4183780253,
-0.5843675733,
0.0976616591,
-0.0787122697,
-0.8890826106,
0.4769099057,
0.4747694433,
-0.0665796995,
-0.5578312874,
-0.4708945751,
-0.8213824034,
0.89732939,
0.4603054821,
-0.6672636271,
0.2761397362,
0.3245243728,
0.932410121,
-0.0881557837,
0.7108860016,
0.749935329,
0.6153798103,
-0.0903246254,
-0.991784215,
0.1644933224,
-0.30314821,
0.0352339931,
0.0599855706,
-1.0471904278,
0.6966193318,
0.1538560688,
-0.0398616008,
0.4217859805,
0.4400852621,
0.3742796481,
0.0250648446,
0.442183286,
0.3484138846,
0.6726874113,
-0.3161738813,
1.329293251,
-0.2568591535,
0.3716802895,
1.1118183136,
-0.7835498452,
1.1095626354,
0.1024933085,
-0.3483019471,
0.229071483,
0.5215588212,
-0.2039805353,
0.4180391133,
0.5129978657,
-0.0142103517,
-0.5889671445,
-0.0266967807,
-0.3189735413,
0.8076230288,
-0.1253257841,
0.0301652383,
-0.2236824781,
-0.4080997109,
-0.0079388916,
0.2012797147,
-0.1895969957,
0.657982409,
0.0105891358,
-0.9414089322,
0.764705658,
0.1253409535,
0.7513815165,
-0.8963726759,
0.142892316,
-0.3070088923,
0.3247556686,
0.1697092801,
-0.7976717353,
0.0451949909,
0.3273532093,
0.1660107821,
0.1873798072,
0.4084077179,
-0.1221420914,
-0.6488050818,
0.688344121,
0.1569797546,
0.420016259,
-0.3121319413,
-0.6509198546,
0.1965120882,
-0.3745529056,
-0.3362025619,
0.5722975135,
0.4031515121,
-0.0166083649,
0.6878303289,
0.3952811658,
-0.0305121634,
-0.0552213378,
0.4273995757,
0.4066037238,
-0.6810072064,
-0.1175612658,
-0.9759778976,
0.2562769055,
-0.2944955826,
-0.6288360953,
0.8568361998,
0.6923397779,
0.8501363993,
-0.0093346983,
0.6519140601,
0.2012548149,
0.455642879,
-0.4398302734,
0.8735255003,
-0.744163394,
0.1202738136,
-0.6059465408,
-1.0006244183,
-0.236914739,
0.6416501403,
-0.6331287026,
0.2037858963,
0.5060101748,
0.6305012107,
0.2255785465,
-0.0743265003,
0.7662938833,
0.2527851462,
0.4199156761,
0.7070459723,
1.0337201357,
-0.7679485679,
0.6113770604,
-0.17755799,
-0.2176491171,
-0.220209837,
-0.9686083198,
-1.0914640427,
-0.1651263535,
-0.1277669519,
0.1342106611,
0.0253040139,
0.5009306073,
0.6262101531,
-0.7170600891,
-0.5669864416,
0.2361155599,
-0.1302480251,
-0.1057440639,
-0.2492025793,
0.3337395489,
-0.2960104346,
-0.8498845696,
0.2780539095,
0.2559389472,
-0.4178142548,
-0.1604254246,
-0.185757041,
-0.2937161624,
0.1295781434,
0.7650064826,
-0.0109432219,
-0.9667283297,
-0.2732920051,
0.1138113365,
-0.2789025605,
0.11137712,
0.4644410312,
-0.6299170256,
0.3846061528,
0.4934018552,
0.573908627,
0.4387923777,
0.1532556564,
0.4824232757,
-0.3303177953,
-0.0173430685,
0.1765680462,
0.3398839533,
0.5673346519,
-0.1010285243,
0.6757516861,
-0.0363525413,
-0.59255898,
-0.8666963577,
-0.2788815796,
-1.1421262026,
-0.3501248658,
1.1612794399,
-0.232851848,
-0.2250658721,
0.1943488121,
-0.0378768817,
0.196219638,
-0.278136462,
1.0621157885,
0.9579211473,
0.0240069143,
-0.0851897821,
-0.8324845433,
-0.1715971529,
0.509082377,
-0.9322564006,
0.2328694761,
0.2739183009,
0.5584185123,
0.0986846313,
0.5495583415,
-0.2610016763,
0.2082410157,
0.0915771052,
0.1570060998,
0.045313295,
0.0255138092,
-0.2933474183,
0.0870154873,
0.2195997238,
-0.0247275811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12473v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12473v2 | Continually Improving Extractive QA via Human Feedback | 2023-05-21T14:35:32 | 2023-11-03T18:23:58 | Ge Gao, Hung-Ting Chen, Yoav Artzi, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We study continually improving an extractive question answering (QA) system
via human user feedback. We design and deploy an iterative approach, where
information-seeking users ask questions, receive model-predicted answers, and
provide feedback. We conduct experiments involving thousands of user
interactions under diverse setups to broaden the understanding of learning from
feedback over time. Our experiments show effective improvement from user
feedback of extractive QA models over time across different data regimes,
including significant potential for domain adaptation. | [
-0.3208276927,
-0.7417581677,
0.5436894298,
0.0578466542,
-0.0226662513,
0.3333507478,
-0.1562274247,
-0.6673570275,
0.0406247824,
0.2455695271,
-0.7515845299,
-0.0962072015,
-0.1325879842,
0.3203612268,
-0.2418933213,
0.723937273,
0.1117670611,
0.273997128,
-0.2406531274,
0.122974135,
-0.8292809129,
-0.5813209414,
-0.9117524028,
-0.2629965246,
0.7192295194,
0.6511204243,
0.585686326,
0.2156400383,
0.5438913107,
0.1963251233,
0.0793392509,
0.1624492407,
-0.4574304521,
0.2476234734,
-0.5337230563,
-0.7320775986,
0.0543355681,
-0.0034680692,
0.5059301853,
0.6217309237,
-0.5335573554,
0.4616240859,
0.1268295944,
0.6479564905,
-0.5347548127,
-0.1113575995,
-0.2600320578,
-0.0986319259,
0.109494403,
-0.3869563043,
-0.411190927,
-0.6931387186,
0.3397163749,
-0.6749463081,
0.2338872701,
-0.0035160368,
0.968800962,
0.1302159876,
-0.1370309293,
-0.1266088337,
-1.179728508,
0.7775845528,
-0.697408855,
0.2981613278,
0.4470681548,
0.7457484603,
-0.1646535993,
-0.8381365538,
-0.3824879825,
-0.3910361528,
0.0588365495,
0.2159085572,
-0.0999184325,
-0.2389457375,
0.2414609492,
0.2693689466,
-0.1102715805,
-0.1374733001,
-0.6648355722,
-0.0218093172,
0.9699329734,
0.2481218725,
0.4914048314,
0.0668983459,
-0.3177888095,
-0.1876134425,
-0.6412911415,
0.5316948295,
0.1308170259,
0.0241595563,
0.5592815876,
0.3706456125,
-0.4852463007,
0.3625648022,
0.0545660034,
0.3812516034,
0.1647838801,
-0.442953974,
0.0277369581,
-0.6038683653,
0.3904600739,
0.2904577851,
0.0769982785,
-0.7347652316,
-0.5277984738,
-0.0362736918,
0.6791145802,
-0.6591098905,
-0.5672189593,
0.4246934354,
-0.5926409364,
-0.2602737844,
0.3153702915,
-1.0114262104,
-0.3577330709,
-0.3786718249,
0.7479488254,
-0.3329744637,
-0.4897424281,
-0.0078906901,
-0.5951458812,
0.2714152038,
0.5582734942,
-0.6975717545,
0.5448553562,
0.2720249593,
0.4695923626,
-0.4061675072,
-0.3628896475,
-0.7443410158,
-0.2251761407,
-0.3304274082,
1.1597969532,
-0.4667223096,
-0.5459187031,
-0.1024012417,
0.2752271593,
-0.0157183446,
-1.051761508,
0.3714797497,
-1.0255723,
0.4559800327,
-0.6688085198,
-0.5505512357,
-0.1930061281,
0.2936230004,
-0.5499768257,
1.1008998156,
0.4599940777,
-0.5335156322,
0.381275475,
-1.1760619879,
0.1343101263,
0.297696203,
0.3202118576,
-0.2494764775,
0.2556658983,
0.2489938289,
-0.1228748336,
-0.2314115018,
0.0620153137,
-0.3265199959,
-0.3792399466,
0.7810699344,
-0.1737363338,
0.7580587268,
0.4567890465,
-0.2417418361,
0.3983944058,
-0.8031678796,
0.3364826143,
0.1933745593,
-0.605034411,
-0.2197568566,
0.1667396724,
0.0729954615,
0.1372570843,
0.0404719003,
-0.8637626171,
0.3871825933,
-0.2320358902,
0.5673177242,
0.6316962242,
0.5838060975,
0.3172436059,
-0.5642769337,
0.8987109661,
-0.0785399154,
0.2756074071,
-0.0427532531,
-0.3116137981,
-0.3948636949,
0.0724854022,
0.6068605185,
0.4467433691,
-0.7169881463,
-0.081143707,
-0.1079291403,
-0.2593114376,
-0.5572857857,
0.4231201112,
0.0801805779,
0.3852560818,
0.336964339,
-0.7793892622,
-0.4638665318,
-0.5240733624,
-0.2279318571,
-0.3926227093,
-0.5512731671,
0.2156192809,
0.3542364538,
-0.2690420747,
1.1263902187,
-0.5579164028,
0.1123652011,
-0.0581195019,
0.3509316742,
-0.2180992812,
0.2789546251,
0.2837991416,
-0.913788259,
-0.1982742995,
-0.1848083436,
-0.6857331991,
-0.1430107504,
0.011604555,
-0.2799330652,
-0.2293843329,
0.1999412179,
-0.3888714314,
0.4665649533,
-0.0425610356,
-0.3960164189,
0.692964375,
-0.0513191745,
0.3482352495,
-0.8595029712,
0.2771341503,
-0.3032165766,
-0.3406736553,
-0.5886602402,
0.2934488058,
0.0388674736,
-0.1516538262,
-0.2312207967,
0.4959962964,
-0.4653883278,
-0.1769644618,
-0.3924081326,
0.1571360528,
-0.0183717031,
0.5653755665,
-0.0451164581,
0.8374841213,
0.1660324484,
-0.716624856,
0.4144078195,
0.2127498686,
-0.0709928498,
0.4508397579,
-0.8823008537,
0.5719216466,
-0.2823735774,
-0.0463963002,
-1.2353619337,
-0.4726501107,
0.1693280339,
-0.6012237668,
0.012878906,
0.0978943408,
-0.3859663308,
-0.6893848777,
-0.4664227664,
-0.0414373986,
0.5824694633,
-0.5967026353,
0.6537694335,
0.3837991655,
-0.4061804414,
-0.280836612,
0.0758388191,
0.0768573955,
-0.1473083198,
-0.5024408698,
-0.0499599576,
-0.3911495209,
-0.4561674595,
0.0954657122,
0.0303828847,
-0.4021178484,
0.5411176085,
0.1729125232,
0.2440338433,
-0.053396903,
0.5741906166,
-0.2019636631,
0.2161848247,
0.4005595744,
-0.252469033,
0.408533901,
0.030316852,
-0.064355202,
-0.8945364356,
0.4922358394,
0.1539154202,
-0.3377551436,
0.2542617023,
0.4655991197,
-0.3716023862,
-0.1508106738,
-0.4460855722,
-0.7270377278,
-0.4537349939,
0.2441427112,
-0.4018599093,
-0.770044446,
0.7077961564,
-0.2713191509,
0.4716676474,
0.541970849,
0.4865984917,
-0.5497301817,
1.2775576115,
0.9823953509,
0.1596778929,
0.5958721638,
-0.2548496425,
-0.3356673121,
-0.6048267484,
-0.2141558677,
-0.6492631435,
-0.3260232508,
-0.0721828043,
0.0216116775,
0.1202087775,
0.4604108334,
0.0748997778,
0.1616757363,
-0.4794695973,
0.2463977784,
0.6309152246,
0.461704731,
0.2359618843,
-0.2144298851,
0.4117734134,
0.0901278779,
-0.4361445904,
-0.2721424401,
1.1094578505,
0.5650578737,
0.7493925095,
0.1785922945,
0.6885464787,
0.5700193048,
0.7774735689,
-0.7426707745,
0.010401383,
0.5064706802,
-0.6690946221,
-0.5616412163,
-0.4701524675,
-0.9280786514,
-0.024783209,
-0.050457228,
-0.9388272166,
0.2143306732,
0.4227066636,
-0.6495752335,
0.0645796806,
-0.8692652583,
0.49131006,
-0.0510815009,
-0.361749202,
-0.1848235279,
-0.8319535851,
-0.0961553454,
0.1391394734,
-0.1058894917,
0.2082387209,
0.2925048769,
1.0137075186,
-0.381264925,
0.9114732146,
-0.6557578444,
-0.1998790056,
0.6916432381,
0.0797633603,
0.299254477,
0.1885911226,
0.0008906104,
-0.1990977228,
0.4792414606,
-0.7220139503,
-0.8901663423,
0.0688612089,
-0.9959127307,
-0.7736257315,
-0.029129928,
-0.6641702652,
-0.4874630272,
0.0535289757,
0.0765692815,
0.2646670938,
-0.1893275529,
-0.0265607573,
0.5949270725,
-0.0281993467,
0.1872237921,
0.4039332271,
-0.4839833677,
-0.3073329031,
0.7054783106,
-0.0479356498,
0.2485783249,
0.3466339111,
0.3393068612,
-0.5480811596,
-0.4939772487,
-0.723390758,
0.1967958659,
-0.6533119678,
-0.0369380414,
-0.5361059308,
-0.0703163221,
-0.393781662,
0.3506634533,
-0.0212951265,
-0.5077880621,
-0.3416014314,
-0.1852642894,
0.1924661249,
1.1092529297,
-0.0105481772,
0.2488973141,
-1.108043313,
0.2371028215,
0.7775366902,
0.1952398121,
0.0756404772,
-0.6266411543,
-0.2333487272,
0.1412457079,
-0.4666681588,
-0.9754793048,
0.3321203887,
0.2368545532,
0.5122194886,
0.1396517307,
0.0086491965,
0.4413563013,
-0.1240767017,
1.1543067694,
-0.1277280748,
-0.668386817,
0.7146725059,
-0.0661692768,
0.5344007611,
0.7006213069,
0.3313693702,
-0.4833297133,
-0.1224183515,
-0.3531140387,
-0.5107255578,
0.4425049424,
-0.0771739408,
0.0447640792,
0.2802476287,
0.9413434267,
0.2608304322,
0.2212163061,
-0.2803193033,
0.3179158866,
-0.2091899663,
0.0701767802,
0.2822125256,
-0.3551055789,
-0.3112715781,
-0.0905285999,
0.5811953545,
-0.3929477036,
0.3166673183,
0.3984203339,
-0.2324156612,
-0.4180961549,
0.4478057027,
0.293613255,
1.4122370481,
-0.3660674095,
0.0373158455,
0.3088558614,
-0.4730882943,
0.1865271479,
-0.0672748238,
-0.2124511302,
-0.1614827216,
-0.0271682218,
0.2680032551,
-0.2777394652,
-0.8753888011,
0.2566444874,
-0.6036266088,
-0.2518015802,
-0.3843791485,
0.2110778093,
-0.0196072794,
0.3281701803,
0.7893965244,
-0.0390569866,
0.3679008782,
-0.7124994993,
0.5487430096,
0.0418003462,
-0.7533008456,
-0.6634759903,
0.8123046756,
0.1902830005,
-0.5845685601,
0.9054281116,
0.0229492281,
-0.5444239974,
0.5988604426,
0.4099346101,
0.8452060223,
-0.2428921759,
0.4545530081,
0.4874073863,
-0.076589793,
-0.0690991208,
0.8570466638,
-0.5245722532,
-0.4422818124,
-0.460003376,
-0.4264010489,
-0.6867607832,
-0.1161373556,
-1.0698831081,
-0.0419547595,
-0.3929130435,
-0.2642617226,
0.1025912166,
0.2093805075,
-0.6176724434,
0.3702566624,
-0.3656292856,
0.9934567809,
-0.650165379,
0.7396765947,
0.8045424223,
-0.7535796165,
-0.9197147489,
-0.0255218688,
-0.2578166127,
-0.4500317276,
0.9017264843,
0.0035482005,
-0.1096658483,
0.0148672061,
-1.1470034122,
-0.7998784184,
1.1162376404,
0.0973652601,
-0.3394939899,
-0.0323016159,
-0.4130107462,
0.8481505513,
-0.1117740273,
0.278131634,
0.685058713,
0.1028911248,
-0.0596485995,
-0.6854223013,
-0.1751068085,
-0.6296849847,
0.126384005,
-0.0266806707,
-0.349742204,
0.486577183,
-0.5279173255,
-0.5599360466,
0.3107985556,
1.07409513,
-0.0243404657,
0.3267531097,
0.8099640012,
0.3339488208,
1.0438052416,
0.0046247276,
1.1749019623,
-0.0803460628,
0.2608253062,
1.0975009203,
-0.2893208563,
0.9560924172,
0.536386013,
-0.2721920311,
0.6898981333,
0.9080717564,
0.1244373843,
0.465308249,
0.3833755255,
-0.2413308173,
-0.2473318428,
-0.1355613321,
-0.1483589858,
0.0370914117,
0.0607062951,
-0.0319887884,
0.1423885524,
0.0479384251,
-0.2719056904,
0.0262280945,
-0.1199835166,
1.0999422073,
-0.1597201824,
-1.0252928734,
0.445069164,
-0.1624841541,
0.3519880474,
-0.4288969338,
-0.3346123099,
-0.3513623178,
0.098635532,
-0.2696862221,
-0.5342354774,
0.1745836735,
-0.0554399677,
-0.4111340642,
0.1574352384,
0.6891049743,
-0.3719570637,
-0.0539742336,
0.2099382877,
0.5187978745,
0.1084215492,
-0.1081934124,
-0.4325758815,
-0.3056506217,
0.0061879028,
-0.2610488832,
0.2657167614,
0.0992160738,
-0.2067524195,
0.8543301821,
0.7545454502,
0.2437764406,
0.306510359,
0.0551199839,
1.0212388039,
-0.8934518695,
-0.4677735865,
-0.2807304859,
0.4478650093,
-0.3424000144,
-0.3206889629,
0.5745488405,
0.1620006263,
0.813411355,
-0.0897448733,
0.8960068226,
-0.0600700341,
0.9752679467,
-0.2191431224,
0.3294283748,
-0.5123744011,
0.3032646179,
0.1794698834,
-0.8500045538,
0.0363712497,
0.1126097143,
-0.0212667603,
-0.1412372887,
0.5265669823,
0.6671184897,
0.3230217695,
0.258054316,
-0.0010384397,
0.1071356833,
0.6480588317,
0.3567688763,
1.3369050026,
-0.403670162,
0.3709902763,
-0.3943949044,
-0.3923890591,
0.007035227,
-0.2880922556,
-0.5431780219,
-0.5365344882,
-0.3369899392,
-0.5099861026,
0.3170718849,
0.9040879011,
0.6276155114,
-1.0696057081,
-0.3063197136,
0.1901506782,
0.0277563576,
-0.7618870139,
-0.375710994,
0.3297767639,
-0.5224179626,
-0.5762168169,
0.3298196197,
0.0893816724,
-0.3587712348,
-0.4736304283,
0.0671793297,
-0.0414755046,
-0.000072165,
0.4547583163,
0.7407814264,
-0.3378860354,
-0.5938056111,
0.4996118844,
0.1159792468,
0.1693602055,
0.8581576943,
-0.8096441031,
0.7305197716,
0.6893801689,
1.1260055304,
0.3377327919,
0.5308930278,
0.9221463203,
-0.4737477601,
-0.6330379248,
0.1842174977,
-0.0996387154,
0.3471712768,
-0.5360172987,
0.6936000586,
0.1664429158,
-0.850456655,
-0.7055575848,
0.0570829809,
-0.7301222086,
-0.2787505686,
1.0320680141,
-0.3787008822,
-0.3215346336,
-0.389703095,
-0.479852438,
-0.0038419571,
-0.5168460608,
1.3646609783,
0.539308846,
-0.5390167832,
-0.2511464953,
-0.3830181956,
0.4909928143,
0.2664476335,
-1.365041256,
0.0318537094,
0.5629027486,
0.6784694791,
0.3987934589,
0.8874817491,
-0.259134233,
0.7201151252,
-0.2414346933,
0.1463492066,
0.311771363,
-0.4283748269,
-0.6224995255,
0.6147421002,
0.534232378,
-0.3120953739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12464v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12464v3 | Self-supervised Predictive Coding Models Encode Speaker and Phonetic Information in Orthogonal Subspaces | 2023-05-21T14:03:54 | 2023-12-11T11:36:22 | Oli Liu, Hao Tang, Sharon Goldwater | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD | Self-supervised speech representations are known to encode both speaker and
phonetic information, but how they are distributed in the high-dimensional
space remains largely unexplored. We hypothesize that they are encoded in
orthogonal subspaces, a property that lends itself to simple disentanglement.
Applying principal component analysis to representations of two predictive
coding models, we identify two subspaces that capture speaker and phonetic
variances, and confirm that they are nearly orthogonal. Based on this property,
we propose a new speaker normalization method which collapses the subspace that
encodes speaker information, without requiring transcriptions. Probing
experiments show that our method effectively eliminates speaker information and
outperforms a previous baseline in phone discrimination tasks. Moreover, the
approach generalizes and can be used to remove information of unseen speakers. | [
-0.3907445669,
-0.3080459833,
0.4984763861,
0.096418418,
0.1749405563,
0.0234293509,
-0.3749171197,
-0.2059893161,
0.5071854591,
0.4893693626,
-0.5549442768,
-0.4434489012,
-0.4930358231,
-0.1694210172,
-0.2956944406,
0.2478950024,
0.5644401908,
0.0913800076,
-0.1472653896,
0.1387210041,
-0.5572863817,
-0.9206376672,
0.1282540858,
-0.4126057625,
0.0354618132,
0.5690957904,
0.8086861372,
0.967599988,
0.1770127714,
0.3491688967,
-0.174556002,
0.0452612005,
-0.4501460791,
-0.1850936562,
-0.0572690442,
-0.5978522301,
-0.6129627824,
0.1561888903,
0.5681619048,
1.1929091215,
-0.4092775583,
0.0984109938,
0.2584429383,
0.2530218959,
-0.3725746572,
0.3612280488,
-0.5982354283,
0.3589578271,
-0.1562540382,
-0.5623093843,
-0.5732587576,
-0.231847927,
-0.2138766497,
-0.3477746546,
0.3167100847,
-0.2316527665,
0.4873051643,
0.0241427273,
-0.3459423482,
-0.0368919782,
-1.1109086275,
0.8589753509,
-0.5390414596,
0.754956007,
1.0186325312,
0.3173624873,
-0.1591853797,
-0.2670088708,
-0.5023726821,
-0.030030271,
-0.0904880092,
0.0635816157,
-0.570135653,
0.337872237,
-0.1640543044,
0.3249708414,
-0.531075716,
0.4171383679,
-0.72057271,
-0.2517156005,
0.6923264861,
-0.3120753169,
0.1970409602,
-0.5944207907,
-0.3001242578,
-0.1386544108,
-0.3780650795,
-0.0345462114,
0.3313082457,
0.5164691806,
-0.1614866853,
0.4720648527,
0.0649518594,
0.2765035331,
0.471031934,
-0.4152759314,
0.6074854732,
0.0683381781,
-0.2428835183,
0.269487083,
0.7813186646,
0.2098944634,
0.0784694254,
-0.2993910909,
-0.0001847777,
0.0025019671,
0.1658946574,
-0.2806633413,
-0.4571357965,
0.2379659861,
-1.0878844261,
-0.145217821,
-0.0412443988,
-0.6523989439,
-0.0934996083,
-0.7432222366,
0.2914561927,
-0.4174438715,
-0.4173820317,
0.2040219456,
-0.0921550691,
-0.1358050257,
0.0490097329,
-1.1713372469,
0.6988830566,
0.4756682515,
0.2511283457,
0.1105367765,
-0.3274230659,
-0.4507314861,
0.044417046,
-0.5071612597,
0.1052847281,
-0.5175940394,
-0.43311432,
0.0995159224,
-0.1533892751,
0.1029930115,
-0.7920691371,
0.2743703425,
-0.2452710718,
0.0908702314,
-0.3746438622,
-0.6513909698,
-0.1398534924,
-0.4005894065,
-0.3835339546,
0.5872891545,
-0.0359321348,
-0.4401828647,
0.0741319656,
0.2014687061,
0.0335090011,
0.0061454512,
-0.8100848198,
-0.39174968,
0.2989753485,
0.388800472,
0.6123968959,
0.0221848637,
0.3184578717,
-0.4204362929,
-0.2924987972,
0.0769550651,
-0.3540869057,
0.7161455154,
0.4766424596,
-0.2512338758,
-0.4313966036,
-1.2487248182,
-0.0915314481,
0.156678617,
-0.1937706918,
-0.3465024233,
0.0894523412,
-0.2251013666,
-0.0531477965,
0.3156060874,
-0.7303370833,
0.0454434492,
-0.0220908299,
0.1169728041,
0.7794014215,
-0.1470406502,
0.7993152738,
0.0314189084,
0.4561964869,
0.0244913045,
0.0308820661,
-0.0285684429,
-0.389500916,
-0.5521422029,
-0.3267427683,
0.0950998515,
0.4112199843,
-0.4318051934,
0.6713494062,
-0.114035137,
-0.4410808682,
-0.4942135215,
0.218886897,
0.5520653129,
0.3897347152,
0.4801060557,
-0.1835443079,
-0.6939533353,
-1.0337291956,
-0.1358402967,
-0.3389977813,
-0.1647329032,
0.3137076795,
-0.2242297679,
-0.3097822368,
1.139243722,
-0.4729975462,
-0.5978990793,
-0.1701645702,
0.3487434089,
0.3255679905,
0.6857431531,
0.7235234976,
-0.6858804822,
-0.1331015527,
0.0846690536,
-0.840955317,
-0.0840975642,
-0.1433285624,
0.4843358696,
-0.603574574,
0.7745927572,
-0.2690740228,
0.6225199699,
0.5418089628,
-0.0872235224,
0.3382838368,
-0.584417522,
-0.0710800663,
-0.5622099042,
-0.4980875254,
-0.0364555195,
-0.3278392851,
-1.0222469568,
-0.3129924238,
0.3315143287,
-0.4626614451,
0.1276816577,
-0.2958627343,
-0.6803362966,
-0.2175870091,
-0.2423566878,
-0.0221068244,
-0.1582249999,
0.763330996,
-0.0518847331,
0.5650526285,
0.5494830608,
-0.4466906488,
0.1195727438,
0.425845772,
-0.0206647888,
0.1376664191,
-0.5371391773,
0.2332702577,
-0.6144168377,
0.0901688486,
-1.0285719633,
-0.1349727958,
-0.0855511203,
-0.6842900515,
0.3732635379,
-0.2161979079,
-0.1705418378,
-0.3107099533,
0.0691589564,
0.653447926,
0.728019774,
-0.9014025927,
0.4813941717,
0.7343177199,
-0.3350785375,
-0.3300949633,
-0.9942438006,
-0.0686241016,
-0.1426938623,
-0.2683272064,
0.5905154943,
0.1954065263,
-0.0389054641,
-0.1091660336,
-0.0169108622,
-0.6149528027,
-0.3049992919,
0.4384793341,
-0.0256304126,
-0.119053416,
0.4560499787,
0.0183673371,
-0.0998527333,
0.2120471448,
-0.382130444,
0.515544951,
0.1707954258,
-0.5373557806,
-0.7406989336,
0.6259405017,
0.2056577951,
-0.4582852423,
0.198696062,
0.5260778666,
-0.5616956353,
-0.3062685728,
-0.7936494946,
0.0398425385,
-0.553650856,
0.4540431201,
-0.3942638636,
-0.9796180129,
0.6518004537,
-0.0102026574,
-0.6161865592,
0.0283425972,
0.260825634,
-0.1030431166,
0.8522024155,
1.0271019936,
-0.2539767325,
0.2173470408,
-0.1930423826,
0.5861121416,
-0.416710794,
-0.3843357265,
-0.5493618846,
0.0777203739,
-0.6275221109,
-0.7378796339,
0.4157960713,
0.2346862704,
0.1815872937,
0.4875986576,
-0.6232571602,
0.4256983399,
0.8318634629,
0.1711263508,
0.0986010283,
0.0083261961,
0.0736142918,
-0.5410630107,
-0.6361401677,
-0.1407590359,
1.1868152618,
0.9447550774,
0.9157695174,
0.0093121435,
1.2925249338,
0.2791475058,
-0.8344044685,
-0.365013659,
0.2882247865,
-0.3611769974,
-0.1320338845,
-0.2714800239,
-0.4767045379,
-0.8318316936,
0.2769875526,
0.024240559,
-1.0928117037,
1.3079804182,
0.2464392632,
-0.4845600426,
0.2953350246,
-0.6376005411,
0.3360564113,
0.0185391959,
0.3062424064,
-0.3792649806,
-0.437296927,
0.0924547911,
-0.082904689,
0.5164468884,
-0.1103769243,
0.576513648,
0.6997038126,
-0.5870576501,
1.0731881857,
-0.3549135625,
-0.0833191052,
0.2354765385,
0.2698069513,
0.1741037518,
0.0145365531,
0.0454091914,
0.2392714918,
-0.1173076853,
-0.2726174295,
-0.4600254595,
0.4770668447,
-0.9674369097,
-0.3127309978,
0.0489154719,
-0.3724519908,
-0.3149936497,
0.1986607015,
0.4684391022,
0.7116888165,
-0.1812249422,
0.0691323131,
0.7699997425,
-0.3504067957,
0.3268568814,
0.0783440024,
-0.2467167079,
-0.2892480493,
1.046595335,
0.2130703777,
0.149259612,
0.4469936788,
0.2057816088,
-0.2010261267,
-0.5141946673,
0.4031812847,
0.0570135526,
-0.8721573949,
-0.2036399692,
-0.4987309277,
-0.302100718,
-0.7558200359,
0.0341015048,
-0.7985750437,
-0.515902102,
-0.4335724115,
-0.3767376244,
-0.3713941872,
0.9358825684,
-0.7765555978,
0.4712562561,
-0.5917534232,
0.6403788924,
0.8953017592,
0.2149883807,
-0.0661009252,
-0.445309937,
-0.2009823173,
0.0199662168,
-0.1943937391,
-0.9012110233,
0.6410826445,
0.2978759408,
0.6213902831,
0.4952432215,
0.1750278473,
0.8143288493,
-0.7005895972,
0.602674365,
0.5107356906,
-1.1811882257,
0.6187297106,
-0.4976258874,
0.0112822438,
0.2443061322,
0.1795689613,
-0.3119132221,
-0.3181060851,
-0.5348231196,
-0.3729478419,
0.6694222093,
0.2095022351,
0.2884650528,
-0.1422105581,
-0.0026584654,
0.2462194264,
0.0771093816,
-0.7849392295,
-0.4922295511,
-0.4423931241,
0.024891153,
-0.2344687283,
-0.934923768,
-0.113488704,
-0.416528821,
-0.0298692007,
0.1996178776,
0.8296259046,
0.4156874716,
0.0834026113,
-0.1481127292,
0.315794915,
0.2447157949,
0.5776463747,
-0.5305308104,
0.2973548472,
-0.0208167192,
-0.1919387281,
0.2238938808,
0.0361392051,
0.513871789,
0.4084210098,
0.4755096436,
0.6037122011,
0.1625065506,
-0.0988744572,
0.9351629615,
-0.0258331802,
-0.482614547,
-0.720431447,
-0.4153604805,
-0.1738764197,
0.2328820676,
0.5651086569,
0.1960935146,
0.463794142,
-0.4150685668,
0.3645607829,
0.0223752744,
-0.4335767329,
-0.3691346049,
0.7694504857,
0.0970524698,
-0.1754073352,
0.4827859402,
-0.3737860322,
-0.4144349694,
0.3416926563,
0.5829806328,
0.8421868086,
-0.5906550884,
0.2043856382,
0.1995158046,
0.1686958224,
0.328168124,
0.2628957033,
-0.3730590045,
-0.831366539,
-0.2499151081,
-0.3218078315,
-0.1053571105,
0.0185601059,
-1.1301416159,
-0.0977904946,
-0.5435426831,
-0.1600062847,
0.1770999134,
-0.570718348,
-0.693366766,
0.1297145337,
0.7585651875,
0.5762904882,
-0.9734629393,
0.9634872079,
0.0975999013,
-0.0105427178,
-1.0795890093,
-0.0315203071,
0.236752525,
-0.7534222007,
0.9459782243,
-0.0355883799,
-0.0947298706,
-0.4668927789,
-0.3560844064,
-1.0889354944,
0.7213246226,
0.5713657737,
-0.6302333474,
-0.0633536279,
0.5538717508,
0.3064287007,
-0.2677379847,
-0.0236898325,
0.5883483887,
0.0669995174,
-0.3137527704,
-1.4158837795,
-0.4286744893,
-0.3704058826,
0.3580658138,
-0.2479782104,
-0.3784674108,
1.2824836969,
0.1229662523,
-0.1680455357,
-0.1484555006,
0.9001198411,
-0.1563780159,
-0.0575476512,
0.3701274991,
0.4295777678,
0.9853495955,
0.1313353628,
0.676371038,
-0.1840959042,
0.5774275064,
1.2222319841,
0.1874821782,
0.6557875872,
0.409401834,
-0.4205946922,
0.2948988974,
0.0697341859,
0.1191267222,
0.780166328,
0.1148292795,
0.1171198115,
-0.512244761,
0.0432674512,
-0.6273210645,
1.1529468298,
0.1947539747,
-0.4091995656,
-0.2107114643,
0.3418366313,
-0.1310913861,
0.6743090153,
-0.2093071193,
0.5808171034,
0.1432386339,
-0.2427179068,
1.0075256824,
0.0896728411,
0.471845746,
-0.2586158216,
-0.0828433782,
-0.0345777459,
0.3743560016,
-0.3866343498,
-0.3176471293,
0.0145036485,
-0.4352764785,
-0.310456574,
-0.6435993314,
0.7510156631,
-0.7214899063,
-0.2844261527,
0.669680357,
0.3948665261,
-0.021248389,
0.1698077172,
-0.1975336671,
0.0248966571,
0.2749260068,
0.3588374257,
0.2591594458,
0.4548839033,
0.3878807425,
0.6220084429,
0.3330492973,
0.2006069273,
0.4462818801,
0.1663224101,
0.9364588261,
-0.5490247011,
-0.8853129148,
-0.3624892533,
0.1656563729,
-0.031766098,
-0.1027885824,
0.863253653,
0.4033741653,
0.8093839884,
-0.2077690214,
0.6859215498,
0.3049779832,
0.9995049834,
-0.2752538323,
0.4840262532,
-0.2970935702,
0.4151319265,
-0.4306294322,
-0.5880841017,
-0.0942527801,
0.7692595124,
-0.1646206975,
-0.1142269596,
0.2715127766,
0.5934504271,
-0.3425931334,
0.185159415,
0.5019919872,
0.0818487704,
0.4323678613,
0.2827301323,
0.6916307211,
-0.3921065331,
0.2541693747,
-0.9446730018,
-0.4750745296,
-0.2572853863,
-0.4509049952,
-0.9302919507,
-0.7067276835,
-0.2654034197,
0.1144620404,
0.0536133274,
0.8672573566,
1.0184390545,
-0.7315655947,
-0.6315233707,
0.041575633,
-0.3085876703,
-0.1745141149,
-0.1147417799,
0.3582223058,
-0.5145534873,
-0.4318507612,
0.9439367652,
0.2878108621,
0.0491494946,
-0.0901530311,
-0.1673211306,
0.3225016594,
-0.1665098965,
0.3078191578,
0.3964824378,
-0.6243136525,
-0.2707279325,
-0.2349011004,
-0.109702982,
0.3297498524,
0.445225209,
-0.6192072034,
0.8639628887,
0.3445310295,
0.4491464198,
0.3426842391,
0.1576022357,
0.8737164736,
-1.1199485064,
0.6309210658,
0.3714994192,
0.4846471846,
0.0044962266,
-0.4262268841,
0.0312032327,
-0.0874781534,
-0.5759990811,
-0.8256560564,
0.2025692165,
-1.1025503874,
-0.3614047468,
0.9635178447,
-0.1349654347,
-0.091610834,
-0.037613783,
0.0975275263,
0.0042411592,
-0.2180149406,
0.5886048079,
0.2226974368,
-0.1652668267,
-0.1547812968,
-0.29857409,
0.528049469,
0.6810961962,
-0.1551324725,
0.1689622104,
0.4446533322,
-0.0073874192,
0.5055055022,
0.9300817847,
-0.177367866,
0.4123838842,
0.1915317923,
0.3937878609,
-0.0565433539,
-0.4672211111,
-0.639827013,
0.2855451405,
0.258628875,
-0.7575054765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12463v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12463v1 | Teaching the Pre-trained Model to Generate Simple Texts for Text Simplification | 2023-05-21T14:03:49 | 2023-05-21T14:03:49 | Renliang Sun, Wei Xu, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Randomly masking text spans in ordinary texts in the pre-training stage
hardly allows models to acquire the ability to generate simple texts. It can
hurt the performance of pre-trained models on text simplification tasks. In
this paper, we propose a new continued pre-training strategy to teach the
pre-trained model to generate simple texts. We continue pre-training BART, a
representative model, to obtain SimpleBART. It consistently and significantly
improves the results on lexical simplification, sentence simplification, and
document-level simplification tasks over BART. At the end, we compare
SimpleBART with several representative large language models (LLMs). | [
-0.2806711197,
-0.6094673276,
0.7063080072,
0.3018601835,
-0.7126485109,
-0.0286900885,
-0.3301895559,
-0.2005551457,
0.1183341518,
0.8332531452,
-0.8650980592,
-0.48380813,
-0.4440000057,
0.3923626244,
-0.3419453204,
1.3478144407,
-0.2418331355,
0.059741661,
0.0050852662,
0.3827700019,
-0.5164548755,
-0.7211033702,
-0.7819380164,
-0.1734198779,
0.5571292043,
0.2995818555,
0.3324913681,
0.4156428874,
0.363894105,
0.2926525176,
0.0176297948,
0.1133779734,
-0.6019586325,
0.1115106717,
0.1759679019,
-0.6281644702,
-0.3503141999,
-0.0088598365,
0.5872818828,
1.0148216486,
0.0161086395,
-0.0659491271,
0.3064629436,
0.7048023939,
-0.3533629477,
0.0541770235,
-0.4908930063,
-0.1935356557,
-0.2655558288,
-0.1631480455,
-0.6740373373,
-0.6393632889,
0.0050481954,
-0.8431689739,
0.2313428372,
0.1516405046,
0.8446884751,
0.2773461044,
-0.4307388663,
-0.2768106163,
-0.8145794868,
0.646707952,
-0.4554170072,
0.1168315485,
0.283515811,
0.1516640484,
-0.0625042617,
-1.0880982876,
-0.4180653393,
-0.3893490434,
-0.2618348897,
0.1668797135,
-0.0921040773,
0.3164878786,
0.40227741,
-0.0951039791,
-0.3504488468,
-0.0999246985,
-0.5019364953,
0.0387452208,
0.4485687912,
0.0697467029,
0.0929683894,
-0.0309650358,
-0.6042128205,
-0.2066179812,
-0.8805934787,
-0.0029217184,
0.2613954842,
0.3051388264,
0.0968245044,
0.4429315925,
-0.2371613681,
0.4575130939,
-0.0608218312,
-0.1060858369,
0.1810234189,
-0.3904046714,
-0.3752254546,
0.0797273889,
0.6663575172,
-0.2242566347,
0.4914992154,
0.047642462,
-0.2373420894,
-0.0777344555,
0.3427383304,
-0.9243378639,
-0.2750010192,
-0.3184451759,
-0.2879174352,
-0.5477998853,
-0.0138076581,
-0.2313720137,
0.0370956324,
-0.3119747639,
0.6512605548,
-0.5283293128,
0.1532223523,
0.3994573355,
0.0627668649,
-0.3715663254,
0.7856001258,
-0.8170859218,
0.7540848255,
0.3667767346,
0.4121094942,
0.0387722217,
-0.4084681571,
-0.3852132857,
0.1676459461,
-0.6291790009,
0.7023252845,
-0.1309060603,
-0.2181465328,
-0.2575651109,
-0.126773864,
0.1773757339,
-0.4099247754,
0.4651012123,
-0.3097100258,
0.2256678194,
-0.2357125431,
-0.5968199372,
-0.0818021223,
0.1800481826,
-0.6769459844,
1.0641299486,
-0.0703781173,
-0.8185287118,
0.3852175474,
-0.415759474,
-0.4361045659,
-0.017444171,
-0.1341250986,
-0.5574914813,
0.1591762006,
0.4618481398,
0.4715533257,
-0.0516298376,
0.2969070673,
-0.165817976,
-0.4789082706,
-0.0533079132,
-0.596543014,
0.6652051806,
0.0120821455,
-0.1649506837,
-0.0923918635,
-0.7944873571,
-0.1046231091,
0.1599383056,
-0.573462069,
-0.5948771834,
-0.3330573738,
-0.0157507434,
-0.0479438007,
0.1637492031,
-0.3489607573,
0.3928148746,
-0.4934207797,
-0.2831757367,
0.7278792262,
0.0494358167,
0.4543454647,
-0.5579903722,
0.6252342463,
-0.1113760471,
-0.1980626732,
-0.6444638371,
-0.3561602831,
-0.9419398308,
-0.6226292253,
0.6875298023,
0.3133227229,
-0.901806891,
0.3153054714,
-0.4869799614,
-0.4195612371,
-0.3951373994,
0.2187767476,
0.5271517038,
0.3119672537,
0.4027763307,
-0.4806631207,
-0.7204887271,
-0.7300717235,
-0.2893609405,
0.0477273352,
-0.2008681595,
-0.2386666089,
0.5403044224,
-0.1545115709,
1.0916912556,
-0.4997477829,
-0.2038978338,
-0.6029176712,
0.4580734372,
-0.024050124,
0.4765255451,
0.4903846085,
-0.5391731858,
-0.7207711339,
-0.2274705023,
-0.5701084733,
-0.2335567027,
-0.3746815622,
-0.0147988033,
0.0151963839,
0.6515452862,
-0.5620848536,
0.6909375191,
0.2392055094,
0.0746924579,
0.6652449965,
-0.3403524756,
-0.0541748777,
-0.8825858831,
-0.1368483156,
-0.4788607061,
-0.798676312,
-0.6389575005,
-0.1001454368,
0.0076002823,
-0.4239879847,
-0.3820921481,
0.6481348872,
-0.7070290446,
0.0919098705,
-0.3800574243,
-0.0450441912,
0.0556242839,
0.4443922937,
0.1544820517,
0.5248070359,
0.1446834952,
-0.5924601555,
0.0785940215,
0.0485622324,
-0.5578868985,
0.0846437663,
-0.5342780352,
0.0850251913,
-0.2595742047,
0.6488385201,
-1.034856081,
-0.2209969759,
0.0004988281,
-0.0972775966,
0.3193576932,
0.0314436741,
-0.5416397452,
-0.5139963627,
-0.3872846365,
0.4235391915,
0.6455011964,
-0.5937365294,
0.4124950469,
-0.2952510417,
-0.6174442768,
-0.4088652432,
-0.7173653245,
-0.2045462281,
0.1161751822,
-0.4725213051,
0.4650815725,
-0.2098163515,
0.1490077078,
0.0147880958,
-0.1361420155,
-0.0050876904,
0.2345642149,
0.1054797173,
0.0590470023,
-0.1448817551,
0.2657642663,
0.5519939065,
-0.261136353,
-0.2686026096,
0.1491909176,
0.8131202459,
0.0202739649,
-0.491189003,
-0.4306366742,
0.4111047983,
-0.0936637968,
0.0550209731,
0.5651971102,
0.3562662601,
-0.2541305125,
-0.3883870244,
-0.422131598,
-0.4085959494,
-0.4680330455,
0.485542357,
-0.6482766271,
-0.7950236797,
0.1137491763,
-0.5532367229,
0.0801937729,
0.2228143662,
0.4630476534,
-0.3641302288,
0.7709748745,
0.9536203742,
0.2543767393,
0.4635953307,
0.0507362373,
0.0075791287,
-0.2557356954,
0.0939581618,
-0.2803347111,
0.0821042135,
-0.3126330078,
-0.1850938201,
0.16416201,
0.5426499844,
-0.4375500083,
0.2643070519,
-0.3775319159,
0.5894563198,
0.6073565483,
0.2368213385,
0.3509100676,
0.3411483169,
-0.096390754,
-0.1478953063,
-0.6622700095,
-0.6688224077,
1.1368623972,
0.4282429516,
0.9987253547,
-0.2340589464,
1.5434904099,
-0.064333111,
0.7653919458,
-0.4400248826,
0.5181707144,
-0.1437180638,
-0.6497053504,
-0.3053997755,
-0.473759681,
-0.9791948795,
0.2209843695,
-0.2015434206,
-0.328820765,
-0.1487528682,
0.1701298207,
-0.4236218333,
-0.0120612979,
-0.7411799431,
0.6093663573,
-0.1849761605,
0.0521520339,
0.0500902645,
-0.5837091208,
0.3918211758,
-0.469058305,
0.3727163672,
0.2443742007,
-0.0305123981,
0.9131038785,
-0.658913672,
1.1486092806,
0.0796213374,
0.303363651,
0.2507626414,
0.1529111564,
0.6658574939,
-0.1344238222,
0.2858501673,
-0.4836129546,
-0.2748750746,
-0.5248916745,
-0.4176954627,
0.043733608,
-0.6551676393,
-0.7590608001,
-0.3287146688,
-0.1966053843,
-0.03290518,
0.5522220731,
0.539239943,
0.1704007387,
-0.4753925204,
0.2295316756,
0.6610386372,
-0.1601606607,
0.4488869607,
0.1331379563,
-0.5162937641,
-0.4321272671,
0.5612477064,
0.0057294136,
0.3697298467,
0.2454700321,
0.1049804464,
0.0942360088,
-0.2768937349,
-0.0596951507,
0.3439061642,
-0.8356782794,
-0.2333404869,
-0.5797855258,
-0.353772074,
-0.3222059906,
-0.4493424296,
-0.4358428121,
-0.4368491471,
-0.18396236,
-0.2394759804,
0.0623811595,
0.865347147,
0.000432538,
0.9327736497,
-0.6890442967,
0.2985427678,
0.6556673646,
-0.2651376724,
-0.2138094157,
-0.3632869422,
-0.2585142851,
-0.0309789982,
-0.4615854621,
-0.8826572895,
0.3981299698,
0.0756986439,
0.3614076674,
0.1368757784,
-0.0119115338,
0.5140756369,
-0.6802107096,
0.5589505434,
0.6537176371,
-1.0399874449,
0.4247557819,
-0.2983370125,
0.4340809286,
0.7296256423,
0.5147694349,
-0.2364616096,
-0.4412558675,
-0.7394267917,
-0.7681785822,
0.8804171681,
0.4964719415,
0.3681465983,
0.0607350059,
0.2040247023,
0.2519775033,
0.5058226585,
-1.3422858715,
-0.2047803551,
-0.2082740963,
-0.4064105153,
0.0398070961,
-0.5275707245,
-0.1625922769,
-0.1802202463,
0.5977070928,
0.1079627499,
0.32506302,
0.0480101109,
-0.2331129313,
0.2563685775,
0.347661376,
0.6904580593,
0.276050061,
-0.2580128014,
0.1830879897,
0.33748281,
-0.5105737448,
0.2873194218,
0.1684901863,
-0.344322741,
0.3284373879,
0.7481777668,
1.0473953485,
0.3409414589,
-0.2690312862,
0.7809590697,
0.0653977171,
-0.4355594516,
-0.2759202421,
-0.0879011005,
0.2067113966,
-0.1705567837,
0.3835981786,
0.1811793596,
-0.1681967825,
-0.5590399504,
0.3342786431,
-0.1241956204,
-0.07414902,
-0.107429266,
0.4820202589,
0.1002026349,
-0.1417036653,
0.334343493,
-0.2805289328,
-0.6180483699,
0.6110029817,
0.8216032982,
0.6268730164,
-0.2710472643,
0.1231260896,
0.2338387519,
0.5506634712,
-0.5585894585,
0.1549811959,
-0.2442728132,
-0.5637330413,
-0.3732747138,
-0.5445753932,
-0.3433270752,
-0.0677171201,
-0.4799423218,
0.5438119769,
-0.6382229924,
-0.1298287064,
-0.1370978504,
0.1004068628,
-0.9256498814,
0.5137084723,
0.1680744141,
0.7457110882,
-0.8446230292,
1.1596859694,
0.5072032213,
-0.5752993822,
-1.038022995,
0.0725888237,
-0.2920655012,
-0.5796718001,
1.0748724937,
0.4202977717,
-0.1611506939,
0.0175286122,
-0.832526207,
-0.7497527003,
1.0524520874,
0.3873127997,
-0.7874851227,
-0.4184438586,
0.0081831552,
0.5717043281,
-0.6571857929,
0.3166875839,
0.1630590111,
0.3401318192,
-0.1543467343,
-0.7842596173,
0.1182607114,
0.0727914646,
0.244598642,
-0.1215305477,
-0.2007827312,
0.9880614281,
-0.1047384739,
-0.3044837117,
0.2803328633,
0.7729618549,
0.4415455759,
0.2720584273,
0.550168395,
0.6201896071,
0.8396659493,
0.0759434924,
1.1745429039,
0.2919369638,
0.481215328,
1.3121951818,
-0.05865895,
0.7994977236,
0.267721504,
-0.0421301387,
0.6474195123,
0.5784637928,
0.1057413891,
0.9121183753,
0.341186136,
-0.2835813463,
-0.3900394738,
0.3968402743,
-0.362232089,
0.095414415,
0.0450113155,
-0.3878472149,
-0.3905676901,
0.4545749724,
0.3688994646,
0.1684405208,
-0.2467569411,
0.6449406147,
0.3500780463,
-0.4633485973,
0.5326402187,
0.117552191,
0.7847017646,
-0.7510862947,
0.3057970405,
-0.4141567051,
0.1054453254,
0.1722821444,
-0.3062826991,
0.1339824945,
0.0689442828,
-0.149581641,
-0.4759360552,
0.7481899858,
-0.5858274698,
-0.6098145843,
0.1457777917,
0.3762027919,
0.2971404791,
-0.0982098579,
-0.4373656213,
-0.0085249841,
0.1969701201,
-0.6826543808,
0.241868034,
0.6567717195,
-0.0892407447,
0.6063324213,
0.7333616614,
-0.0574528426,
0.2361587882,
0.1571614593,
1.056194663,
-0.6429477334,
-0.6347423792,
-0.7679939866,
0.4300751388,
-0.1778209209,
-0.2317816019,
0.4427633882,
0.623369813,
0.8996146917,
-0.4228510261,
0.787997365,
0.2861580253,
0.6931053996,
-0.6413763762,
0.6760869026,
-0.6210835576,
0.2949105203,
-0.2829871774,
-0.9880283475,
-0.312676996,
0.6699393392,
-0.3978380561,
0.2334253937,
1.0971456766,
0.5855099559,
-0.2698385715,
-0.3550911844,
0.5070487261,
0.1279404163,
0.1365934163,
0.4285597503,
0.6977331042,
-0.3984340727,
0.7400576472,
-0.3276047111,
-0.1574313641,
-0.1452675164,
-0.7993178964,
-1.2093902826,
-0.3705528378,
0.0294883456,
-0.0636623502,
0.0908373967,
0.8512222171,
0.6721643209,
-0.3883979619,
-0.0116556427,
-0.3026126027,
-0.1107009947,
-0.0133953765,
-0.137262255,
0.3862264156,
-0.7034081221,
-0.5817245841,
0.2942487001,
-0.0148118958,
0.3391417563,
0.076576598,
0.0218423363,
0.085800454,
0.4247277379,
0.5078665614,
-0.0094988365,
-0.5043964386,
-0.1295359284,
-0.2873853445,
-0.6242883205,
0.0304226037,
0.7824085951,
-0.8131747842,
0.2649406493,
0.2961827219,
0.7029545903,
1.0833877325,
0.0926900655,
0.590729773,
-1.266371727,
0.4174476862,
0.1746205091,
0.1792776883,
0.2530551851,
-0.0784657001,
0.4433580339,
0.2515894473,
-0.204878673,
-0.8660026789,
0.3266157508,
-0.9901505113,
-0.6324394345,
0.9198223352,
-0.317887038,
-0.211408481,
0.033114057,
-0.5269711614,
0.320777446,
-0.13406986,
0.4168635309,
0.5988722444,
0.2623546422,
-0.343993932,
-0.3072481751,
0.8682716489,
0.6613407731,
-0.9681857228,
-0.1555942744,
0.1068784893,
0.4725687802,
0.0811695531,
1.1444876194,
0.1890769005,
0.2704869807,
0.2370042056,
0.4181648791,
-0.2309298515,
-0.4570458531,
-0.2013251185,
0.1154975146,
0.115511775,
-0.0606745929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12458v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12458v1 | Infor-Coef: Information Bottleneck-based Dynamic Token Downsampling for Compact and Efficient language model | 2023-05-21T13:30:56 | 2023-05-21T13:30:56 | Wenxi Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL | The prevalence of Transformer-based pre-trained language models (PLMs) has
led to their wide adoption for various natural language processing tasks.
However, their excessive overhead leads to large latency and computational
costs. The statically compression methods allocate fixed computation to
different samples, resulting in redundant computation. The dynamic token
pruning method selectively shortens the sequences but are unable to change the
model size and hardly achieve the speedups as static pruning. In this paper, we
propose a model accelaration approaches for large language models that
incorporates dynamic token downsampling and static pruning, optimized by the
information bottleneck loss. Our model, Infor-Coef, achieves an 18x FLOPs
speedup with an accuracy degradation of less than 8\% compared to BERT. This
work provides a promising approach to compress and accelerate transformer-based
models for NLP tasks. | [
-0.5279418826,
-0.8329849839,
0.042652566,
0.2573401332,
-0.3368358314,
0.1928205639,
-0.4057921767,
-0.2581276298,
-0.1575716138,
0.5549820065,
-0.6621468067,
-0.2509938776,
-0.6099774241,
0.1221506521,
-0.4439419508,
0.7116400003,
0.1571176946,
-0.0968336314,
-0.1028962955,
-0.1204242855,
-0.5447067618,
-0.8223662972,
-0.677590549,
-0.2304413617,
-0.129169032,
0.4061992466,
0.7659596205,
0.7493516207,
0.6969863772,
0.3586193323,
-0.424026072,
0.0373095423,
-0.5481230617,
0.119478099,
-0.0808183774,
-0.5112576485,
-0.1717886329,
-0.1218206137,
0.7481592298,
0.6235164404,
-0.4656125903,
0.2382023633,
-0.1718274653,
0.7117128968,
-0.4642153382,
0.2331952453,
-0.8629166484,
0.001526119,
-0.0519570597,
-0.187772572,
-0.51313591,
-0.3317959607,
-0.0950535834,
-0.3444259167,
0.4363150597,
0.2139204741,
0.90920645,
0.510202527,
-0.1020018533,
-0.3079781532,
-0.9836627245,
0.8291438222,
-0.8151438236,
0.5341092944,
-0.0097512752,
0.0543177836,
-0.1109026894,
-0.8970036507,
-0.7708934546,
-0.3139595985,
-0.2416879833,
-0.3540811837,
-0.2793464363,
0.2097103298,
0.3076569438,
0.5740402341,
-0.1944032013,
0.163613379,
-0.3126831055,
0.097480543,
0.2230984718,
0.035000477,
0.1181840152,
-0.0579514354,
-0.6277979016,
-0.3545309603,
-0.8017145991,
-0.0662531704,
0.518250227,
0.3576745391,
-0.2448137105,
0.4071579576,
0.2787022591,
1.0515761375,
0.2414339781,
-0.2410216779,
0.101462163,
-0.668774724,
-0.1604762375,
-0.0918614566,
0.5866602659,
-0.0522474386,
0.2080242783,
-0.2550468445,
-0.0703404024,
0.0039291377,
0.1762209535,
-1.0624700785,
-0.2955263853,
0.2483851165,
-0.2934371531,
-0.3374481797,
0.1769519895,
-0.8628393412,
-0.2359215021,
-0.4274002612,
0.1507922709,
-0.4299072623,
-0.3041600585,
0.1958002895,
0.0431922004,
-0.0974351615,
-0.0236620642,
-0.5263212919,
0.5049368739,
0.6022797823,
0.8428845406,
-0.1739620566,
0.0776057541,
-0.6822670698,
-0.1220153719,
0.0467472151,
0.4099602997,
-0.7586802244,
-0.2188530266,
-0.2598085701,
-0.2641282976,
-0.2291599512,
-0.6569882035,
0.8060685396,
-0.6260246634,
0.0182459913,
0.1073485017,
-0.633236289,
-0.2365705073,
0.115125306,
-0.941247344,
1.130979538,
0.1170403734,
-1.0966912508,
-0.0217186473,
-0.7482998967,
-0.4855570495,
0.040581882,
0.0492755771,
-0.4308236539,
0.0740619972,
0.2349632531,
0.2589928508,
-0.597777009,
0.7593439817,
-0.0353207663,
-0.5792633295,
0.096210137,
-0.5308606625,
0.6613310575,
0.2969914079,
-0.2550337315,
0.0661118552,
-1.0694439411,
-0.2464734316,
0.0211657397,
-0.6743704081,
-0.1506376565,
-0.0080619249,
0.1024646237,
0.2211040854,
0.1499522775,
-0.4274069667,
0.3081109822,
-0.436412245,
0.4632254541,
0.4245649874,
-0.1649774462,
0.3022471666,
-0.2840312719,
0.5892241001,
-0.0782543197,
0.1644761264,
-0.362416476,
-0.0770920962,
-0.9507979155,
-0.4602949619,
0.7209972143,
0.4523638487,
-0.6966745853,
0.844476819,
-0.5218812227,
-0.5527275205,
-0.6994256973,
0.0669087097,
0.2980656922,
0.8186750412,
0.356697619,
-0.1448277831,
-0.6349872947,
-0.5120906234,
-0.2994943559,
-0.2650909424,
0.0880924612,
0.1013783664,
0.1207930371,
-0.0088149421,
0.7268059254,
-0.1758170277,
-0.4607057869,
-0.5280441642,
0.5874508023,
0.4634256959,
0.6177465916,
0.3573185802,
-1.1355475187,
-0.1692920476,
-0.5372384191,
0.1021021605,
-0.3093599975,
-0.0221168678,
0.2201841176,
0.1152887493,
0.5731324553,
-0.8090915084,
0.40960145,
0.9128180742,
-0.2626930177,
0.6704655886,
-0.3643651605,
-0.0388103016,
-0.6935646534,
0.3960393369,
-0.3248069286,
-0.3853546679,
-0.7763274312,
0.1296372265,
-0.0089178178,
-0.142790854,
-0.3548292518,
0.4449875057,
-0.5251743197,
0.1683797091,
-0.2822945714,
0.2741277218,
0.2323788702,
0.5300235152,
0.1632293165,
0.7947033644,
0.2415969819,
-0.902616024,
0.1354025453,
0.2441135943,
-0.5097809434,
0.1081115454,
-0.5562410951,
0.11133039,
-0.2815534472,
0.2110056132,
-0.9866735339,
0.0593167692,
0.0096168676,
-0.0235447474,
0.5789033771,
-0.118967779,
-0.6822240353,
-0.5029162765,
-0.3164819181,
0.4908379614,
0.5015516281,
-0.7320848703,
0.6861838698,
0.6549478769,
-0.1843363345,
-0.6371199489,
-0.7509382963,
0.0464610346,
-0.0558786616,
-0.6804164648,
0.8793255687,
-0.2278516889,
-0.1222986728,
-0.0557507202,
0.0137374448,
-0.0752161518,
-0.0324975513,
0.0734190494,
0.2272232175,
-0.0165667608,
0.5800281167,
-0.3857036531,
0.0555952042,
-0.5508710742,
-0.0279937536,
1.0062172413,
-0.3055696189,
-0.2545948327,
-0.3820635974,
0.1446135044,
0.6646937132,
-0.3625885248,
1.0050588846,
0.6323989034,
-0.1540347785,
0.0647540912,
-0.8700900078,
-0.1984930933,
-0.4871297777,
0.4309104085,
-0.1329687387,
-0.9343253374,
0.3345468044,
-0.4136416316,
-0.1005806103,
0.3234708607,
0.445536077,
0.3654066026,
0.7171685696,
0.9713003635,
-0.0329176709,
0.6763477921,
-0.2031182647,
0.4705443382,
-0.6374727488,
0.0229724348,
-0.6619243026,
-0.2867023051,
-0.46320346,
-0.6848010421,
0.203549847,
0.3555349708,
-0.3187350929,
0.4672948122,
-0.6347706914,
0.2347534895,
0.6123651266,
-0.2440826595,
0.5828940272,
-0.0646057799,
-0.0078145266,
0.0871243104,
-1.1295109987,
-0.3123013377,
0.5888665915,
0.3453998864,
0.9545871615,
-0.188530758,
-0.0065073133,
0.1147148237,
0.2884123921,
-0.5250376463,
0.4057079554,
-0.4492299855,
-0.5784481764,
-0.3969323635,
-0.6396618485,
-0.5562647581,
-0.0495651439,
-0.1830164343,
-0.7775324583,
0.3206029236,
0.507571876,
-0.2864962816,
0.6506274343,
-0.6026386619,
0.6597396731,
-0.1771291643,
-0.1156311482,
-0.0564809926,
-0.6066094637,
0.3581022918,
-0.2569598854,
0.4540506005,
-0.1296044439,
0.0259418599,
0.7370055318,
-0.644084692,
0.6767830253,
-0.3446463943,
0.1568050683,
0.4139428139,
0.0195561759,
1.0522546768,
-0.2929746509,
-0.4584380686,
0.2214501798,
-0.0274339896,
0.1364984661,
-0.4317225218,
0.3671384752,
-0.2775540948,
-0.5009335876,
0.0639303476,
-0.6048319936,
-0.0394759253,
0.0238107182,
0.3121336401,
0.523960948,
-0.0076262983,
0.465967536,
0.4184216261,
-0.289226979,
0.5867750645,
0.6445055008,
-0.0704688653,
-0.1652545184,
0.4381162524,
0.1445079446,
0.2000245452,
0.6413758397,
0.0681667179,
-0.4529615939,
-0.5106620193,
-0.0499535315,
0.3197974563,
-0.5770744085,
-0.5091274381,
-0.6444070339,
-0.1915821582,
-0.3437006474,
0.1707326025,
-0.8162150383,
-0.443489641,
-0.1431836039,
-0.0173518993,
0.4545857906,
0.3994618952,
0.1217994317,
0.8824217916,
-0.7103595138,
0.2581171989,
-0.2547509968,
0.5173748136,
-0.0454870127,
-0.6925911307,
-0.0383331962,
-0.0934345946,
-0.1231036112,
-0.4439976215,
0.488358736,
0.4944612086,
0.1558601409,
0.2739002705,
0.5267152786,
0.9196329713,
-0.3291037083,
0.5506312251,
0.3121031225,
-1.0389562845,
0.0823489651,
0.3340170383,
0.4568080604,
0.6419044137,
0.1717914343,
-0.5390334129,
-0.3303854465,
-0.5716359019,
-1.0309607983,
0.7384485006,
0.2496173829,
0.1907702535,
0.0368374661,
0.3195099235,
0.1182349771,
0.4542013109,
-0.6698855162,
-0.1809538752,
0.2805865407,
-0.3729475439,
0.1971812993,
-0.4668221474,
0.143133834,
-0.2702962756,
0.7969071865,
-0.0016094969,
0.3371582031,
0.110299848,
-0.1251299828,
-0.157037586,
0.3746088147,
0.2540362477,
0.4831601381,
-0.2252657115,
0.2345003784,
0.1292973459,
-0.6004903316,
0.2262451947,
0.3115218878,
-0.2579424381,
0.210709393,
0.1374287307,
1.1151539087,
0.427506417,
-0.8379818201,
0.7985984087,
-0.3920634687,
0.2906772494,
-0.2847399414,
0.047150217,
0.0093904762,
-0.0057053943,
0.1954390258,
0.2382040024,
-0.2714069784,
-0.1898459643,
0.3308180273,
0.4128577113,
-0.4816330373,
-0.3504514098,
0.6039398313,
0.1708034426,
-0.3824762404,
0.6534956694,
0.0303547513,
-0.4326146543,
0.3172827065,
0.6114851832,
0.5690636635,
-0.3798811138,
-0.023713395,
0.4449535608,
0.2484091967,
-0.2510535419,
0.2242031097,
-0.1914732605,
-0.6772450805,
-0.6682818532,
-0.9324792027,
-0.2192793041,
0.5300099254,
-0.3542355001,
0.5837025046,
-0.3406185508,
-0.442863673,
-0.2149859071,
-0.1041840762,
-0.831893146,
0.2219057083,
-0.0751370788,
1.3282166719,
-0.336484611,
0.9432335496,
0.2609402537,
-0.0307277329,
-0.7710902095,
-0.0785415322,
-0.5128200054,
-0.3168806434,
0.6868659258,
0.2515483797,
-0.3026135266,
0.2501890659,
-0.4414807558,
-1.0477079153,
0.8534891605,
0.8136486411,
-0.8821275234,
-0.3854542971,
0.1066747308,
0.3801007569,
-0.4297181964,
0.1526665241,
0.5533976555,
0.6907669902,
0.3078778684,
-0.718845427,
0.0138509097,
-0.3048533797,
0.0555411913,
0.2210523486,
-0.6168279052,
0.9674326777,
-0.0241398849,
-0.5669292808,
0.1344600767,
0.3871135712,
0.0630856603,
-0.3426662087,
0.7327118516,
0.4820044637,
0.9408975244,
-0.1288003176,
0.9545188546,
-0.9354980588,
0.4234244823,
1.2872548103,
-0.0182676855,
0.7774974704,
0.6430084109,
-0.1002732962,
0.4864105582,
0.152966395,
-0.1265237182,
0.4336096644,
0.3935356736,
-0.2286376208,
-0.0656874552,
-0.253737241,
-0.1125568524,
0.5115448833,
0.3224234581,
-0.3871759474,
-0.2287665308,
0.0428977273,
0.1492466331,
-0.0714766979,
-0.0880647972,
0.4866557717,
-0.0174078625,
-0.9247940183,
0.7622547746,
0.4184295237,
0.7963950038,
-0.6980834007,
0.0788633674,
-0.0160702765,
0.4033080041,
0.1952546984,
-0.19063811,
0.4775731862,
0.1081377342,
0.0273074564,
-0.2261140198,
1.0484796762,
-0.6482533813,
-0.5195339918,
0.2859925926,
0.1019955575,
-0.0871091336,
-0.1454261988,
-0.5248929262,
0.3233035803,
-0.2349065691,
-0.4083859324,
-0.1941923946,
0.1124791801,
0.2479451001,
0.7867819071,
0.549518168,
0.2148102522,
0.140021041,
-0.0521434434,
0.8605706692,
-0.5120254159,
-0.5851391554,
-0.9263579249,
0.5402982831,
-0.0544258207,
-0.0608840995,
0.2732720673,
0.3038571179,
0.6818378568,
-0.0933473855,
0.5786142349,
-0.0687337965,
0.6043447852,
-0.4937572777,
0.6363565922,
-0.1940490901,
0.5802136064,
-0.1335366964,
-0.6888118386,
-0.4221464097,
0.2903255522,
-0.0915871188,
-0.0690506697,
0.3209325969,
0.8532220125,
-0.0927914307,
0.0761313736,
0.1954298764,
0.3111956716,
0.2507033348,
0.2217118293,
0.5090385079,
-0.3512908518,
0.8355774879,
-0.4335349202,
-0.2575595379,
-0.3155142665,
-1.2068142891,
-0.843721509,
-0.5408055782,
-0.4509150982,
0.1032947078,
-0.1472537518,
0.9261766076,
0.9358198047,
-0.8059204817,
-0.1358169019,
-0.5668359995,
0.1476203948,
-0.0451255739,
-0.2422102988,
0.5255253911,
-0.5588755608,
-0.7413615584,
0.2256821692,
0.3650297225,
0.1270257533,
-0.1218231767,
0.0703130886,
-0.4114628136,
0.3244249225,
0.2331703901,
0.0926885307,
-0.4516144395,
-0.1422022879,
-0.1802199334,
0.0993610397,
0.3210323155,
0.9730332494,
-0.9485130906,
0.5331107378,
0.548350811,
0.5902494192,
0.6076458097,
0.4483596385,
0.646474719,
-1.1266072989,
0.5029861927,
0.210729748,
0.2737855315,
0.6322351098,
-0.3142975271,
0.4660291076,
0.292439878,
-0.3336171806,
-1.0056174994,
0.1787843555,
-0.5347349644,
-0.2536719739,
0.9542282224,
-0.4265902936,
-0.4113332629,
-0.0337855741,
-0.2684472501,
0.5297343135,
-0.0369244218,
0.824760139,
0.6567861438,
-0.0077787451,
-0.1266438067,
-0.0624315068,
0.6745944619,
0.1881047338,
-0.5479872227,
0.4897013307,
-0.0302697755,
-0.1088546515,
0.4435229897,
0.4209062755,
-0.2884187996,
-0.2168495655,
-0.0068222671,
0.2760305405,
-0.3185501099,
-0.3693121374,
-0.2211331725,
0.5008333921,
-0.091918081,
0.0589083843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12449v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12449v1 | Communication Efficient Federated Learning for Multilingual Neural Machine Translation with Adapter | 2023-05-21T12:48:38 | 2023-05-21T12:48:38 | Yi Liu, Xiaohan Bi, Lei Li, Sishuo Chen, Wenkai Yang, Xu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Federated Multilingual Neural Machine Translation (Fed-MNMT) has emerged as a
promising paradigm for institutions with limited language resources. This
approach allows multiple institutions to act as clients and train a unified
model through model synchronization, rather than collecting sensitive data for
centralized training. This significantly reduces the cost of corpus collection
and preserves data privacy. However, as pre-trained language models (PLMs)
continue to increase in size, the communication cost for transmitting
parameters during synchronization has become a training speed bottleneck. In
this paper, we propose a communication-efficient Fed-MNMT framework that
addresses this issue by keeping PLMs frozen and only transferring lightweight
adapter modules between clients. Since different language pairs exhibit
substantial discrepancies in data distributions, adapter parameters of clients
may conflict with each other. To tackle this, we explore various clustering
strategies to group parameters for integration and mitigate the negative
effects of conflicting parameters. Experimental results demonstrate that our
framework reduces communication cost by over 98% while achieving similar or
even better performance compared to competitive baselines. Further analysis
reveals that clustering strategies effectively solve the problem of linguistic
discrepancy and pruning adapter modules further improves communication
efficiency. | [
-0.4018799067,
-0.435738951,
0.1972878426,
0.5582178831,
-0.4736540318,
0.0334884003,
-0.5096619725,
-0.2396767139,
0.0849329531,
0.2955665886,
-0.3430352211,
-0.268840909,
-0.5891809464,
0.192850396,
-0.064587377,
0.7586679459,
-0.2206225246,
0.2579948902,
-0.2761076689,
-0.70981282,
-0.3588560224,
-0.3611097634,
-0.5966258645,
-0.5347664356,
0.5904167891,
0.4440355599,
0.6085953116,
0.8725039363,
0.7183606625,
0.3555130959,
0.0208285749,
0.1791034192,
-0.3690955937,
0.2265511006,
-0.0613774657,
-0.6903666258,
-0.3996147513,
-0.104940556,
0.8517385125,
0.6989125013,
-0.3283386827,
0.191230163,
-0.0422210246,
0.7820557356,
-0.4431941807,
0.2566394508,
-0.572532773,
0.0911718011,
-0.2364526838,
-0.0729755312,
-0.5059296489,
-0.2810381353,
0.0775006786,
-0.3866690695,
0.0395598337,
-0.0506375469,
0.5606348515,
0.2618079782,
-0.2292051613,
0.0314594246,
-0.5376337767,
0.5927743912,
-0.5098458529,
0.4269293547,
0.0826875046,
0.3578173816,
-0.0551912077,
-0.6208541393,
-0.3112053871,
0.2219391167,
-0.2983283699,
0.0873774514,
-0.1713673323,
-0.0161681864,
-0.1950917691,
0.2252877802,
-0.6016939878,
0.2806333601,
-0.1718475968,
-0.1871733516,
0.4281919003,
-0.0247343704,
0.0701020882,
0.2457173318,
-0.5382838249,
-0.2003878653,
-0.5287976265,
-0.1090090796,
0.3197070956,
0.3359868824,
-0.1351311803,
0.1332287937,
-0.0817767382,
0.6734056473,
0.1857001334,
-0.0070340899,
0.3170832396,
-0.3548946381,
-0.1251557618,
0.0861725807,
0.8945787549,
0.2499615103,
-0.2195480019,
-0.5066776872,
-0.2226279229,
-0.1683024317,
0.1691824347,
-0.884393394,
-0.0862936601,
0.0678535402,
-0.4425494373,
0.0378944017,
-0.1039418727,
-0.7846098542,
0.0814193785,
-0.1601237357,
0.3763400316,
-0.3838305473,
-0.5043587089,
-0.1461044699,
0.180342555,
0.001931801,
0.1559063643,
-1.075097084,
0.2686173916,
0.6481885314,
1.0305049419,
-0.1555292308,
-0.527341187,
-0.445394218,
0.0162289683,
-0.1350267529,
0.4757353365,
-0.1649011225,
-0.2063248903,
-0.2831850648,
0.1087526008,
-0.6862620711,
-0.4739152491,
0.1890331805,
-0.6112530231,
0.2622218132,
-0.0119691016,
-0.488238126,
-0.2386850268,
0.2376316935,
-0.4643896222,
0.4396838844,
0.0942887217,
-0.6012063026,
0.0600340739,
-0.8163691163,
-0.445199728,
0.2591716945,
-0.0465065092,
-0.6640713215,
0.036827527,
0.1587823033,
0.6245675087,
-0.1431737095,
0.6337689757,
-0.239470765,
-0.4233471751,
0.2489634752,
-0.344398737,
0.5642249584,
0.5450489521,
-0.3482792675,
0.2336926609,
-0.6102731824,
-0.051982183,
-0.0142369298,
-0.5385533571,
-0.3697480261,
-0.2705632448,
0.0638200641,
0.212480396,
0.2344688028,
-0.3561164439,
0.0178003162,
-0.4514299333,
0.6392716169,
0.5718615055,
-0.4324462116,
0.8837549686,
-0.3769445419,
0.33233127,
0.3899623454,
0.2428438663,
-0.243180126,
-0.3354718685,
-0.7496297359,
-0.4858158529,
0.3241436779,
0.3280729949,
-0.8913087845,
0.3078311086,
-0.4516748488,
-0.4403312504,
-0.9200212359,
0.2422967106,
0.3880030811,
0.5030941963,
0.2978539467,
-0.0952263176,
-0.2502916157,
-0.8138647079,
-0.20243451,
0.1708515435,
0.214315474,
0.1648407727,
0.2240417153,
-0.1591741145,
0.7204958797,
-0.0818088204,
-0.2123159021,
-0.2177558392,
0.1760661006,
0.3388622701,
0.8205457926,
0.6510850191,
-0.9941359758,
-0.7131491899,
0.4429194033,
-0.6033326387,
0.0075950739,
-0.1276743561,
-0.2125336677,
0.3061319292,
0.1556992382,
-0.5093724132,
-0.1138245538,
0.9696294665,
-0.1049082056,
0.1722721308,
-0.4380455017,
0.1339743435,
-1.4369477034,
0.2808848321,
-0.2955309749,
-0.3648191988,
-0.6980450153,
0.2093364298,
0.1900176257,
-0.0952955484,
-0.4613974094,
0.3455737829,
-0.5582483411,
0.0437472053,
-0.3061728179,
0.2010853291,
-0.1450545788,
0.5407859683,
-0.1685923636,
0.9119100571,
0.4735297859,
-0.3923202753,
0.2887968123,
0.3393957615,
0.0243780911,
0.7171964645,
-0.3735538721,
0.1220310926,
-0.0472044051,
0.1718824506,
-0.4538201988,
0.0485921502,
0.2819498777,
-0.3093080819,
0.3677666485,
-0.036489889,
-0.482475698,
-0.0915514231,
-0.0607550368,
0.354137361,
0.2005201876,
-0.6711187363,
0.5379593968,
0.1473251134,
-0.0256208517,
-0.7212683558,
-0.9315519929,
0.0744302496,
-0.4416235685,
-0.7236604691,
0.1957951188,
-0.2010602653,
0.1877639294,
0.0433158986,
-0.2138409168,
-0.3021709025,
0.2938297093,
0.0878585875,
0.0202536192,
-0.4936366081,
0.2055126131,
0.227747798,
-0.2467871606,
-0.105029054,
-0.6091808081,
0.5585153103,
-0.3338702917,
-0.2728355229,
-0.4960364103,
0.4816961288,
0.6572090983,
-0.2240879238,
1.2926601171,
0.9664873481,
-0.0708457679,
-0.0826044083,
-0.6477829218,
-0.2782595754,
-0.4434967637,
0.2532126606,
-0.4159497023,
-1.183193326,
0.6692926288,
-0.2280265689,
0.1372110546,
0.1378661841,
0.3273148239,
0.167290166,
0.8398768306,
0.7286560535,
-0.1685510278,
0.5759079456,
0.105548501,
0.1856945455,
-0.6887323856,
-0.0660854653,
-0.3956609964,
-0.4567750096,
-0.5957164764,
-0.40649876,
0.1880413145,
0.2191879749,
-0.0499814637,
0.5584222674,
-0.3536509871,
0.3827069104,
0.5909481645,
0.0281217899,
0.2930521667,
0.1220130175,
-0.3628337383,
0.0559515022,
-1.1083791256,
-0.1463943869,
1.0126488209,
0.2112139165,
0.278275758,
0.3885307312,
0.7500048876,
-0.21579732,
0.70990026,
-0.4407651424,
0.3559163809,
-0.2248075306,
-0.3825164437,
0.0594784655,
-1.0408329964,
-0.8188328743,
0.7344183326,
-0.252912879,
-0.5679091215,
0.2966450453,
0.0971946791,
-0.1131025925,
0.3044615686,
-0.8445116282,
1.0034276247,
-0.0172208715,
-0.2624554932,
-0.1975905299,
-0.9541044235,
0.3383418918,
-0.4319912195,
0.0528463013,
-0.0571635365,
0.1302791983,
0.557902813,
-0.389590323,
0.5089149475,
-0.0291995946,
0.3104815483,
-0.1046639234,
-0.2040265054,
0.42484954,
0.0845357329,
-0.1899062991,
0.3610444069,
-0.1533732563,
-0.4707609117,
-0.4319624901,
0.7498656511,
-0.7262984514,
-0.4169093668,
-0.0493550673,
-0.9144789577,
-0.0971776843,
0.3730337918,
0.1669519842,
0.2421358973,
-0.0417581201,
0.4360188544,
0.6233979464,
0.0609302223,
0.7402665019,
0.9860560298,
0.112147294,
-0.6788694263,
0.8517878056,
0.0374547392,
0.4710344076,
0.5092861056,
0.179532975,
-0.1960897893,
-0.4832825959,
-0.5282164216,
0.3365092278,
-0.5740286112,
-0.4050489962,
-0.7570639253,
-0.027758047,
-0.3541423678,
-0.2047753781,
-0.5555603504,
-0.2008815557,
-0.3337927163,
0.0418240875,
0.294100672,
-0.0556969792,
-0.2092030346,
0.9103230834,
-0.9351015091,
-0.3029875755,
-0.0429495089,
0.4901595712,
-0.0812371746,
-0.2401474714,
-0.507973969,
0.1026224345,
-0.1778322011,
-0.6205433011,
0.3881243169,
0.2954395711,
0.605250299,
0.4973591864,
0.1216770485,
0.7610153556,
-0.4577351213,
0.2992661893,
0.4664737582,
-0.9222201705,
0.0434007607,
-0.2882454693,
0.5959871411,
0.6029411554,
0.1887457371,
-0.5598989725,
-0.4310049415,
-0.5055565238,
-0.6935352087,
0.9073708057,
0.1755030155,
0.1091469899,
0.1107494384,
0.2427462339,
0.1351736188,
0.3747444749,
-0.6089586616,
-0.3967799246,
-0.0597279631,
-0.3244498968,
-0.2230844945,
0.0732514188,
-0.3284500837,
-0.1801474094,
0.5454849601,
-0.2692538798,
0.1984346956,
-0.0135237481,
-0.2543914616,
-0.2244265079,
0.3572497666,
0.8182699084,
0.5367016792,
0.0499077179,
0.2449390292,
0.1101030856,
-0.417941004,
0.2049208432,
0.4477337897,
-0.175888896,
0.1943041682,
-0.0681372285,
1.0154072046,
0.3857416809,
-0.3860198855,
0.4685921669,
-0.1726834774,
-0.3437718451,
0.2185566127,
-0.1762997359,
0.4207910895,
0.3914680481,
0.0370739661,
0.6344860792,
-0.2276851833,
-0.0135810589,
0.3156985343,
0.2181483209,
-0.2048909664,
-0.4440438449,
0.656588912,
0.3192769885,
-0.2137658894,
0.5636565685,
0.01557987,
-0.493272543,
0.3479630947,
0.6657469869,
0.7261860967,
-0.6701805592,
0.3791009784,
-0.0704487562,
0.3504808545,
-0.4935485423,
-0.0729686469,
-0.2454582006,
-0.6536383033,
-0.3602130711,
-0.5580481887,
-0.1945921928,
-0.2226164043,
-0.6554605961,
0.0188304447,
-0.192000702,
-0.1767085344,
-0.3433109522,
-0.166077137,
-0.4891482294,
-0.2448136359,
-0.0966505408,
0.78547436,
-0.7325054407,
1.0082355738,
0.708089292,
-0.1885771602,
-0.7248491049,
-0.4845560491,
-0.1778791249,
-0.5173413754,
0.2846055627,
0.2962651551,
0.1660739481,
0.2363564223,
-0.1319966465,
-0.6775512695,
1.2060959339,
0.6360557079,
-0.6175377369,
0.3324487805,
0.3292999268,
0.4156073034,
-0.43931216,
0.0357967056,
0.3228196204,
0.4027222693,
0.0562250838,
-0.9086703658,
0.0312208775,
-0.0588303246,
-0.021928506,
0.4715589583,
-0.7847076058,
0.8931211233,
0.1702280492,
-0.30684641,
-0.0341955759,
0.6602967978,
-0.1236677468,
0.4003831446,
0.4300623238,
0.5221064091,
0.7169861794,
-0.1017751545,
0.4064460099,
-0.4603269696,
0.4769521654,
0.9714974165,
-0.2420838922,
0.7458262444,
0.7497423291,
0.2017141879,
-0.05052156,
0.3773764968,
0.0891814828,
0.5345566273,
0.0670591593,
-0.4152543843,
-0.1068233252,
-0.0386214256,
-0.4026209414,
0.3251421154,
0.1485475004,
-0.4973854423,
-0.4161351621,
0.3031833768,
0.3034787178,
0.1798573434,
-0.0707162991,
0.822380662,
0.2572794259,
-0.5422410965,
0.5334728956,
0.055043757,
0.7319613099,
-0.7200700045,
0.4205611944,
-0.5315072536,
0.5174766183,
-0.0074487561,
-0.2205808163,
0.5880178809,
-0.211080566,
-0.2207160145,
-0.526932478,
0.3932465613,
-0.9668061733,
-0.2222179174,
0.2583073378,
0.6761363745,
0.1384976059,
0.0002665533,
-0.7596327066,
0.0635974929,
-0.2147365659,
-0.0651255846,
0.7146606445,
0.3221433163,
0.1694619954,
0.6175447106,
0.6477180123,
0.1879914701,
0.1446956545,
-0.2025377452,
0.8238280416,
-0.1149315163,
-0.5817136765,
-0.7585143447,
0.3323739171,
-0.1354313493,
-0.1964473724,
0.7738518119,
0.383303225,
0.7973352075,
-0.1271227598,
0.253447473,
0.2293026596,
0.079530172,
-0.2930365503,
1.1863918304,
-0.4138722718,
0.256526649,
0.1161748543,
-0.9407244325,
-0.451320827,
0.485299021,
-0.0671144128,
-0.4165436625,
0.681499064,
0.7185493112,
-0.1959563345,
0.1926100254,
0.4040235579,
0.0292215422,
0.2333821058,
0.5375217795,
0.2576317191,
-0.5093578696,
0.5283303857,
-0.4508281946,
-0.1465975046,
-0.2878498733,
-0.7763828635,
-0.8450633883,
-0.419434011,
-0.4445981681,
0.0306063592,
0.2725573778,
0.9439685941,
0.9373457432,
-0.6359874606,
-0.3425187171,
-0.154941529,
0.3076298237,
-0.6484200358,
-0.2061440796,
0.2097171992,
-0.4688158333,
-0.5539126396,
0.470841676,
0.2500448525,
-0.0339857601,
-0.1370141506,
-0.0791690573,
-0.2268980891,
-0.1642874032,
0.2655466795,
0.088328518,
-0.4832584262,
-0.0049884282,
-0.1245739534,
-0.1534275711,
0.2234027982,
0.6592355371,
-0.2746175528,
0.5176022649,
0.2554712892,
1.1064885855,
0.2221018225,
-0.0160788037,
0.7296757698,
-1.0036524534,
0.4709898829,
-0.0176409371,
0.1466507763,
0.4704134464,
-0.4168965816,
0.2437933683,
0.4063591957,
-0.6731587052,
-0.7915213704,
-0.0656151623,
-0.8005876541,
-0.1707303673,
0.6716554165,
-0.691850841,
-0.3561027944,
0.1465782821,
0.2448492348,
0.326397419,
-0.2853864133,
0.5656131506,
0.5434297323,
0.2794659436,
-0.4297360182,
-0.3751222789,
0.252653867,
0.5225576162,
-0.7654977441,
-0.1606805325,
0.2092293501,
0.3145284951,
0.1429799944,
0.3490516245,
0.1261575818,
0.0201119259,
-0.0469975285,
-0.0337290913,
-0.3196364939,
-0.1538426429,
-0.5959559679,
0.2884088457,
-0.3330363035,
-0.5314102173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12441v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12441v2 | A Pilot Study on Dialogue-Level Dependency Parsing for Chinese | 2023-05-21T12:20:13 | 2023-06-01T03:03:43 | Gongyao Jiang, Shuang Liu, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue-level dependency parsing has received insufficient attention,
especially for Chinese. To this end, we draw on ideas from syntactic dependency
and rhetorical structure theory (RST), developing a high-quality
human-annotated corpus, which contains 850 dialogues and 199,803 dependencies.
Considering that such tasks suffer from high annotation costs, we investigate
zero-shot and few-shot scenarios. Based on an existing syntactic treebank, we
adopt a signal-based method to transform seen syntactic dependencies into
unseen ones between elementary discourse units (EDUs), where the signals are
detected by masked language modeling. Besides, we apply single-view and
multi-view data selection to access reliable pseudo-labeled instances.
Experimental results show the effectiveness of these baselines. Moreover, we
discuss several crucial points about our dataset and approach. | [
-0.3457390368,
-0.5056154132,
0.5458627939,
0.0970244929,
-0.2120634913,
-0.0728172585,
0.195274964,
-0.5690321326,
0.1676998883,
0.4355177879,
-0.3122714758,
-0.467784971,
-0.2938222885,
-0.0041349432,
-0.1329718083,
0.8915457726,
0.3473076522,
-0.0558081903,
0.2209919691,
-0.1694049239,
-0.3801258504,
-0.6131438017,
-0.5817670226,
0.0618083663,
0.621111095,
0.2211061716,
0.4610980451,
0.6177656651,
0.0567118637,
0.2213142663,
-0.4484993517,
-0.1496109962,
-0.2097793818,
0.045130033,
0.0584941618,
-0.4316278398,
-0.4480251968,
0.0927158073,
0.764582932,
0.9767837524,
0.052097369,
0.0712568387,
0.3466049135,
0.2118248492,
-0.5471636653,
0.5439651608,
-0.5817918777,
0.0466579683,
-0.3407752216,
-0.0585840233,
-0.7420296669,
0.181035921,
0.2328587323,
-0.6475310922,
0.0920937434,
0.0503096469,
1.1079587936,
0.1479774266,
-0.2570920289,
0.3046486378,
-0.6632812619,
0.7089034915,
-0.9021716118,
-0.0094940877,
0.4721141756,
-0.0103466026,
-0.2935131788,
-0.5156888366,
-0.1367770433,
-0.1747717708,
-0.6168875694,
0.2243333608,
0.1911444813,
0.6373265386,
0.4848590791,
0.3267453015,
-0.4182697237,
0.0117307836,
-0.2906758785,
-0.172243163,
0.1162512079,
0.1056448594,
0.6389036775,
-0.7998347282,
-0.2971359193,
0.1591389328,
-0.8432569504,
0.3140588105,
0.1840141863,
0.7437267303,
-0.077235885,
0.2121707648,
-0.2645839751,
0.8409288526,
0.0178636145,
-0.1488468498,
-0.0969515741,
-0.5231509805,
-0.2506302297,
0.1880547255,
0.7408616543,
-0.1140411422,
-0.0414097607,
0.3825105131,
-0.1099951044,
-0.1050261483,
-0.0902349055,
-0.8255545497,
-0.4984948933,
0.2978105247,
-0.3534742892,
-0.1963473111,
-0.0689170957,
-0.4615848362,
-0.3652125299,
-0.1930567771,
0.1459628195,
-0.4297176898,
-0.4132149518,
-0.2181251049,
0.0800304189,
0.1610301584,
0.3835105896,
-1.0199946165,
0.121320419,
0.5084044933,
0.8484056592,
0.3067053556,
-0.0818362758,
-0.7520785332,
0.1493551284,
-0.3664009571,
1.1225061417,
-0.3770261705,
0.0123699792,
0.0941061005,
-0.0495417826,
-0.2396926135,
-0.3834899366,
0.6605744362,
0.1749085635,
0.4558571875,
-0.2976286411,
-0.4240039885,
-0.1442080587,
0.200412944,
-0.7075881958,
0.8565365672,
0.3621974885,
-0.8382143378,
0.1583988518,
-0.4484415054,
-0.5334950089,
0.4969531,
-0.5334132314,
-0.1518480778,
-0.176598981,
0.3316333294,
0.2218993306,
0.0626452491,
0.4166361392,
-0.011451277,
-0.3769153059,
-0.2454586774,
-0.3831674159,
1.2336820364,
-0.0272228811,
-0.2171135098,
0.1599738449,
-1.1212004423,
-0.2222791165,
-0.2283006161,
-0.1310618371,
-0.4184631407,
0.1934848279,
0.0144240381,
0.3543351591,
0.0013019418,
-0.7999693751,
0.0276464242,
-0.8488780856,
0.5520371795,
0.671874702,
0.1184784174,
0.1122705862,
-0.0132206827,
0.5184777379,
0.3223929107,
0.0813219845,
-0.9494249225,
-0.6020597816,
-0.9349362254,
-0.3247398734,
0.2471881658,
0.4185644686,
-0.7272641063,
0.3238702118,
0.1895058006,
-0.0218435824,
-0.4443536997,
-0.1739853173,
0.521835506,
0.5710251927,
0.2851122618,
-0.1711675376,
-0.5737619996,
-0.9116275907,
-0.0416381843,
-0.8095493317,
-0.0600050204,
-0.067888312,
0.0129914386,
0.5829043388,
0.899479568,
-0.4043474197,
-0.4945116341,
-0.6300895214,
0.3602690697,
0.155295074,
0.2938800752,
0.5125808716,
-0.2081886083,
-0.4834245145,
-0.017936768,
-0.5617938042,
-0.3291725814,
-0.4329895973,
-0.0539890528,
0.0127591481,
0.3981645405,
-0.5480900407,
0.4796400368,
0.474899739,
-0.1145706698,
0.3808433712,
0.2221011668,
-0.0676280782,
-0.9534258246,
0.0047484026,
0.1830183715,
-0.2016203403,
-0.8273115158,
-0.305352062,
-0.0978183821,
-0.2305915207,
-0.7935526967,
0.3021289408,
-0.4745449722,
-0.0667072013,
-0.1479332596,
0.1664663404,
0.2278535366,
1.0517078638,
0.1818798035,
0.4597848952,
0.2511946857,
-0.1331773996,
0.0370280482,
0.2838937938,
-0.2484848946,
0.4370743036,
-0.594083488,
-0.0009458661,
0.0393276922,
0.4011807144,
-1.1844910383,
-0.0770154446,
0.6763313413,
-0.2073229998,
0.0738438442,
-0.615503788,
-0.4332333505,
0.1854370236,
-0.310931772,
0.5402786136,
0.1292197108,
-0.3993383348,
0.3605040312,
0.3510775566,
-0.2948772609,
-0.4537163675,
-0.3902060091,
0.1171991527,
-0.0284573287,
-0.4592722356,
0.1211962029,
0.4016344249,
-0.2077028155,
-0.0140479365,
-0.0155750187,
-0.0411194228,
-0.0406387635,
0.4923764169,
0.3930640519,
-0.5375364423,
0.0274527129,
-0.012394513,
-0.3415588439,
-0.0077370033,
-0.2187832147,
0.3632374704,
-0.0101836734,
-0.3572217524,
-0.6628423333,
0.3941272795,
0.1221307218,
-0.2669480741,
0.4940831363,
0.1572035849,
-0.4263726175,
-0.2521899641,
-0.1200424209,
0.0864993557,
-0.4431666434,
0.2937152684,
-0.2907166779,
-0.6942546964,
0.4300825298,
0.1387098581,
0.3679327071,
0.4070516527,
0.2735365331,
-0.1123884618,
1.0090845823,
0.4853725433,
-0.1951701641,
0.7241595387,
0.1536877304,
0.3680518866,
-0.5816650391,
0.2967419028,
-0.4990499914,
0.0092469975,
-0.3839916885,
0.0153828012,
0.4036303759,
0.0711418465,
-0.0418612696,
0.6078026295,
-0.5058906674,
0.4438580573,
0.4484464228,
-0.1199852601,
0.457077831,
-0.2530560195,
0.0373537354,
-0.0543548949,
-0.690015614,
-0.401096493,
0.5536201596,
0.3595133722,
0.2568959892,
-0.1658588648,
0.4462977946,
-0.0582816713,
0.2164587528,
-0.8180861473,
0.6648594737,
-0.1832341105,
-0.5291993618,
-0.4572864473,
-0.279586345,
-1.1238930225,
0.5871274471,
0.060905803,
-0.9031501412,
0.0878591537,
0.0577289946,
-0.7753365636,
0.1287637204,
-0.7415995002,
1.0279407501,
-0.0989874974,
-0.1073621511,
0.1925312281,
-0.742421329,
0.492653966,
0.3456616402,
0.1018399373,
-0.2755801976,
0.5636463165,
0.7323368192,
-0.4284967482,
1.2399640083,
-0.1937282085,
-0.1263236552,
0.4891001284,
-0.031894505,
0.152328074,
-0.0875775442,
0.1983591765,
0.1253950298,
0.3703604639,
-0.5390507579,
-0.5240028501,
0.2977492809,
-0.5211166739,
-0.6862068176,
-0.6540179849,
-0.483532995,
-0.1446393281,
0.2426196337,
0.0296727866,
0.6271103024,
-0.2244322151,
-0.2701896429,
0.3600153029,
-0.4963712692,
0.5544979572,
0.3563851416,
-0.3662763536,
-0.1923635602,
0.9082475305,
0.3086211681,
0.4812342227,
0.3116548359,
0.0442145765,
0.2273711413,
-0.4105386436,
-0.8858036995,
0.2040117383,
-0.5900612473,
-0.0485033281,
-0.4721741974,
-0.7589845657,
-0.2771651745,
0.2204511613,
-0.522120595,
-0.5432881713,
-0.2422041893,
-0.3549120426,
-0.03313528,
0.7262580991,
0.1780169457,
0.386590004,
-0.6977592111,
0.2722381055,
-0.0813651457,
0.1508530825,
-0.0408623703,
-0.3334769309,
-0.4978198111,
-0.0857552886,
-0.3662282526,
-0.735024929,
0.3213759959,
0.0784726143,
0.3895818293,
0.6608431339,
0.328920573,
0.6858474612,
-0.2773874104,
1.0460113287,
0.2303536683,
-0.9227750301,
0.6574974656,
-0.6438753009,
0.412184149,
0.4842495918,
-0.0568426289,
-0.6744642258,
-0.906021297,
-0.6295919418,
-0.8179634213,
1.0985536575,
0.2647459805,
-0.1350188702,
0.043222364,
0.0784960911,
-0.0255108681,
-0.214702487,
-0.7131121159,
-0.2263337374,
-0.1891024113,
-0.0859764442,
0.3544290066,
-0.170636043,
0.0079972893,
-0.3739560843,
0.3817369044,
0.0193849318,
-0.0497436412,
0.0238221493,
-0.0252664387,
-0.1560286582,
0.3709950447,
0.4205549955,
0.5044767857,
-0.3100035787,
0.3843668997,
-0.1565635055,
-0.3277491927,
0.1426960081,
0.0099585922,
-0.6163410544,
0.3495191634,
0.5214254856,
0.7342867255,
0.2983939052,
-0.5845717788,
0.5605822206,
0.2051865458,
0.0219067205,
-0.3645724058,
-0.0972252712,
0.1759449691,
-0.1221494153,
0.0265674088,
-0.1222238243,
0.1361536235,
-0.7072072625,
0.3236753047,
0.2096801251,
-0.5552208424,
-0.5544805527,
0.5318117142,
0.4209164381,
-0.1162724495,
0.4056437016,
-0.2391033918,
-0.5687548518,
0.3848073483,
0.2424640208,
0.6804690361,
-0.2834146321,
0.5264120698,
0.6093289256,
0.289334327,
-0.1399166137,
-0.0147007266,
0.0123194614,
-0.628973186,
-0.733278513,
-0.4039240777,
-0.4984533787,
0.2984578907,
-0.5953289866,
0.501755178,
-0.6832971573,
0.1028037891,
0.2344085425,
-0.2486556768,
-0.0867793858,
-0.0932214186,
0.370196104,
0.2273341417,
-0.889400959,
1.067420125,
0.3855164051,
-0.7869977951,
-0.9701328278,
-0.0045587434,
0.1267744899,
-0.6979020238,
0.5552366972,
0.2394993752,
-0.1603581607,
-0.1837802678,
-0.3319487572,
-0.5411258936,
0.6050976515,
0.4117826223,
-0.5646780133,
-0.0199232753,
0.4854198992,
0.7418162227,
-0.2831570804,
0.6203235984,
0.6792014241,
0.2625027895,
0.0589075945,
-0.9142589569,
0.0546058156,
-0.2947718203,
-0.082484372,
0.3113853633,
-0.6765532494,
0.9304270744,
0.2180836946,
-0.6330823302,
0.1177982613,
0.5376486778,
0.0783784911,
0.3424702585,
0.5453060269,
0.2949679196,
0.3258403242,
0.1936616153,
0.4314171076,
-0.4042882919,
0.2143998742,
1.2862051725,
-0.2164516449,
0.8624737859,
0.2930740416,
-0.2369153351,
0.5532729626,
0.6567844152,
0.0612991042,
0.154348135,
0.2685503066,
-0.3823841512,
-0.2717988193,
-0.6026703119,
-0.0484259725,
0.2409625798,
0.414057523,
-0.3959105909,
-0.4028190076,
-0.2077541351,
0.1386238784,
-0.1286233813,
0.0063380427,
0.8285562396,
0.4137745202,
-0.6209499836,
0.6877193451,
-0.2205147892,
0.1781706363,
-0.4099514782,
-0.3766777515,
-0.3470807076,
-0.132441625,
-0.4394899309,
-0.598854363,
0.1649578065,
-0.001515748,
0.2322967798,
-0.4414560497,
0.6812831759,
-0.5136759877,
-0.4375990927,
0.3115350306,
0.7094643712,
0.2949828804,
-0.2025741488,
-0.2994492352,
-0.094753705,
0.1530258209,
-0.3469268382,
0.7088983655,
0.5147663951,
-0.0291571319,
0.1548215002,
0.4585767686,
0.1702851504,
-0.1048367247,
0.370896548,
0.7946158051,
-0.8372430801,
-0.433296442,
-0.7786817551,
0.5456475616,
0.052967269,
-0.4408096373,
0.5551828742,
0.4460579455,
0.7439520955,
0.4525315762,
0.8959753513,
0.0418222547,
0.587240994,
-0.2317558676,
0.506644249,
-0.2333192378,
0.6402566433,
-0.3635686934,
-0.9180851579,
-0.5013652444,
0.4377484024,
-0.2225337178,
-0.537666738,
0.8477610946,
0.7344355583,
0.0584388971,
0.2815251052,
0.5951051116,
0.3191785812,
0.4552171528,
0.8261798024,
1.1947327852,
-0.3041810691,
0.804346025,
-0.3212711513,
-0.2439801842,
0.1781275272,
-0.5952103138,
-0.961874187,
-0.5468686223,
-0.4117024839,
-0.2377288193,
-0.0763827339,
0.8300101161,
0.5673565269,
-0.9274365306,
-0.3135097325,
-0.0277128369,
0.0673519298,
-0.2096496373,
-0.1862822771,
0.5663288236,
-0.4763348103,
-0.7117974162,
0.4071857929,
0.6535983682,
-0.2999849319,
-0.3396577537,
0.3726345003,
-0.1924948841,
-0.1219036803,
0.6432314515,
0.4724011421,
-0.8929162025,
-0.6470972896,
-0.2239329815,
-0.2369887829,
0.6275920272,
0.9460391402,
-0.7356145382,
0.2597519159,
0.5754635334,
0.3658494949,
0.3205345869,
0.2519402504,
0.5561239123,
-0.7078799605,
0.334397465,
0.1665543765,
0.4394476116,
0.2016910762,
-0.1740515977,
0.4046491086,
0.4224924147,
-0.2648853362,
-0.7650444508,
0.4294971526,
-1.2119705677,
-0.3147039413,
1.2031098604,
-0.6625907421,
0.0420138128,
-0.7362105846,
-0.597034514,
0.2112783343,
-0.4550244808,
0.6182255745,
0.8159708381,
-0.4865025282,
-0.7486718297,
-0.5785651803,
0.5417546034,
0.6834344864,
-0.8426696658,
0.293343395,
0.5147323608,
-0.0891888961,
0.2355947495,
0.8792936206,
0.0286322478,
-0.1197487712,
0.3086778224,
-0.0105481334,
0.167633459,
-0.2027530223,
-0.1258436143,
0.2949044108,
0.2145891041,
-0.3231785595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.11916v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.11916v1 | F-PABEE: Flexible-patience-based Early Exiting for Single-label and Multi-label text Classification Tasks | 2023-05-21T12:17:27 | 2023-05-21T12:17:27 | Xiangxiang Gao, Wei Zhu, Jiasheng Gao, Congrui Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Computational complexity and overthinking problems have become the
bottlenecks for pre-training language models (PLMs) with millions or even
trillions of parameters. A Flexible-Patience-Based Early Exiting method
(F-PABEE) has been proposed to alleviate the problems mentioned above for
single-label classification (SLC) and multi-label classification (MLC) tasks.
F-PABEE makes predictions at the classifier and will exit early if predicted
distributions of cross-layer are consecutively similar. It is more flexible
than the previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) early exiting method PABEE because it
can simultaneously adjust the similarity score thresholds and the patience
parameters. Extensive experiments show that: (1) F-PABEE makes a better
speedup-accuracy balance than existing early exiting strategies on both SLC and
MLC tasks. (2) F-PABEE achieves faster inference and better performances on
different PLMs such as BERT and ALBERT. (3) F-PABEE-JSKD performs best for
F-PABEE with different similarity measures. | [
-0.755779624,
-1.0427824259,
0.5321409702,
0.4736539721,
-0.1653098315,
0.0715515316,
-0.4839870334,
-0.1296346486,
-0.2687734962,
0.2967804372,
-0.9654093385,
-0.1510122418,
-0.7092714906,
0.0322484635,
-0.2027784735,
1.1563310623,
-0.3521113098,
-0.3372469246,
-0.3122623861,
0.0960759372,
0.0863663927,
-0.6111354828,
-0.7075178623,
-0.4260586798,
0.888761282,
0.5282161832,
0.6650378108,
0.6475005746,
0.4327765703,
0.2759097219,
-0.2971390784,
0.0094110034,
-0.451541096,
0.0053866296,
0.2199301273,
-0.4801419675,
-0.2386447489,
0.3053588867,
0.3646919429,
0.7934276462,
-0.2860108316,
0.2123905122,
0.1060095727,
0.7833344936,
-0.9424800277,
0.2501213253,
-0.0764870122,
0.3163963258,
-0.7283337712,
-0.006076728,
-0.8308252692,
-0.2608242631,
0.3473238051,
-0.7804202437,
-0.0421431139,
-0.186883837,
0.9884121418,
0.4658433795,
-0.2294791192,
-0.4220245779,
-0.7115954161,
1.0051395893,
-0.3985788822,
0.5366551876,
0.2487414032,
0.4229035676,
-0.3478392959,
-0.6628170013,
-0.9109595418,
-0.1951446533,
0.3563848734,
0.1360277534,
0.2792643607,
-0.0708176866,
0.0302041844,
0.2704540193,
-0.2253060639,
0.2253954113,
-0.169898808,
-0.0202207603,
0.338478446,
-0.0653115734,
0.0652492121,
0.217377454,
-0.5522707105,
-0.3628170192,
-0.4471729994,
0.6367805004,
0.3147283494,
0.2772403955,
-0.04939197,
0.1581365764,
-0.1735861897,
0.7007870674,
0.0424768589,
-0.4764549434,
0.590157032,
0.0907758251,
-0.3122195303,
-0.2728590667,
0.7061239481,
-0.0506447963,
0.1763032973,
-0.2850644588,
0.020684829,
0.2781540155,
0.0517900512,
-0.7256724834,
-0.3660232723,
0.3097523749,
-0.9801861644,
-0.2381082326,
0.2166286856,
-1.0057063103,
-0.1218221113,
-0.1927196681,
0.4052088261,
-0.4617302418,
-0.5284217,
-0.0432816111,
0.2522015274,
0.0501399562,
0.2285278291,
-0.7745648026,
0.4235832393,
0.670961082,
0.7755759954,
-0.6015147567,
-0.5040279627,
-0.9736677408,
-0.3009394109,
-0.0811983794,
0.6326884031,
-0.6134074926,
-0.4063978195,
-0.1718281209,
0.0718298405,
-0.1322709322,
-0.3512216508,
0.8547146916,
-0.3638129532,
0.319937855,
-0.0433138572,
-0.3800778687,
-0.2298928201,
0.1299072653,
-0.5592230558,
1.1519405842,
0.1634140015,
-0.5359307528,
0.5501329303,
-0.7261462212,
-0.3812119067,
-0.2110570371,
0.1065873057,
-0.6147028804,
0.0922090337,
0.1616484374,
0.6765615344,
-0.4182652235,
-0.1462124586,
-0.7069394588,
-0.4533418715,
0.3811663091,
-0.2624216974,
0.7742177844,
0.6015537381,
-0.2803962827,
-0.0294939,
-0.8982403874,
0.2896676362,
-0.05646782,
-0.4897347689,
-0.4744152427,
-0.0002755571,
0.1178476289,
0.5716174245,
0.1753306389,
-0.6062247753,
0.2957532704,
-0.5384724736,
0.1213269234,
0.896812737,
-0.2587454319,
0.4573322237,
-0.4117673934,
0.8311752677,
0.1209652051,
0.4035039544,
-0.0969365537,
-0.8192715645,
-0.8490843773,
-0.466861397,
0.444611311,
0.6906475425,
-0.7370890379,
0.4011188745,
0.0904966667,
-0.8964063525,
-0.6111305952,
0.2042494714,
0.7617555261,
0.3514103591,
0.368021369,
-0.4033805728,
-0.3286632001,
-0.4703886807,
0.0104240021,
-0.1399245709,
-0.0079829376,
0.0512320325,
0.3320911825,
-0.284075439,
0.7531554699,
-0.5406932831,
-0.3286109269,
0.1561460346,
0.5260854959,
0.5580431223,
0.3122579753,
0.4737007022,
-0.9916025996,
-0.725799799,
-0.208749488,
-0.3308887184,
-0.2468446344,
-0.2778635323,
-0.0561849028,
0.6173195243,
0.3419765234,
-0.5981040597,
0.5556524396,
0.3994755149,
-0.209270075,
0.5881437659,
-0.0082128085,
0.1687848866,
-0.6121616364,
-0.0060721049,
-0.1233314201,
0.2157882601,
-0.5816504955,
-0.2558604181,
-0.0749668255,
0.107663326,
-0.7264829874,
0.5112160444,
-0.1972611099,
0.1562132984,
-0.238312155,
-0.1575479656,
-0.1416045576,
0.4584754109,
-0.0237254538,
0.819034338,
0.6331529021,
-0.9405435324,
-0.0048863878,
0.2111992985,
-0.0292572863,
0.1371864378,
0.0082488554,
0.2731071711,
-0.0755706578,
0.1056941077,
-1.0637155771,
0.1641052812,
0.4126425087,
-0.4655926824,
0.1460126489,
0.2717587948,
-0.2463270128,
-0.6499571204,
-0.3421133757,
0.2388164103,
0.6062693596,
-0.6496103406,
0.7936835885,
0.116019994,
-0.3839166462,
-0.6378044486,
-0.8208735585,
-0.4947172403,
-0.2662847638,
-0.4874763489,
0.4449914396,
-0.2679887116,
0.0375298597,
0.0711924881,
-0.2250968367,
-0.3671894372,
0.1863531917,
0.3269783258,
-0.016716158,
-0.1787127256,
0.0813701376,
-0.0303413346,
-0.4462308586,
-0.0011762659,
0.0405610502,
0.589613378,
-0.4144290686,
-0.0799870342,
-0.4399611652,
0.4751690328,
0.5082802176,
-0.3088230193,
1.1051279306,
0.9102156758,
-0.240575999,
-0.2957577407,
-0.4952103496,
-0.0935974419,
-0.4762280583,
-0.0063307332,
-0.8861802816,
-0.6397529244,
0.5971743464,
-0.3484300971,
0.0386911556,
0.350944519,
0.5434445739,
-0.4266861379,
0.6488313079,
1.0144931078,
0.2224204093,
0.4394279122,
-0.1006708145,
0.2126416713,
-0.3224341273,
-0.4944369495,
-0.6238819957,
-0.0439321138,
-0.2929268181,
-0.3208855689,
0.1781707555,
0.416425705,
-0.1283621788,
-0.2453404218,
-0.5466700196,
0.4000484645,
0.7100704312,
0.0372695439,
-0.1408320665,
-0.2004359812,
-0.1220784485,
-0.2121555954,
-0.7444118261,
-0.2602486908,
1.2434872389,
0.3157627285,
0.5278626084,
0.1616948694,
0.8634352088,
0.1246610284,
0.7251265645,
-0.6406035423,
0.5156579614,
-0.8212397099,
-0.3364295959,
-0.2272428721,
-0.2927478254,
-0.7308219075,
-0.0814094245,
-0.2914083004,
-0.8545549512,
0.2289341688,
0.3180256486,
-0.5280640125,
0.1817049533,
-0.8650752306,
0.9578190446,
-0.3370100558,
-0.2242762893,
0.2213435024,
-0.8562815189,
0.6050380468,
-0.3996105492,
0.1068495959,
-0.0646994859,
-0.20601888,
0.9480109811,
-0.7103311419,
0.5396839976,
-0.4786055684,
0.0936412215,
0.292521745,
-0.1709546298,
0.2463726401,
-0.2598855197,
-0.1616744995,
0.035391625,
0.0364072397,
-0.2465912104,
-0.5785201192,
0.3979696631,
-0.7078046203,
-0.1016778797,
-0.8411679268,
-0.2526366115,
-0.3366204202,
0.2104333192,
0.2413424253,
0.0763822049,
0.2861973643,
0.5250924826,
0.7987703681,
-0.3943836391,
0.6093708277,
0.3109604716,
-0.4135686755,
-0.3043342829,
0.9346381426,
0.1025744081,
0.0391385518,
0.4324063361,
0.4452675283,
-0.6390913725,
-0.5454716086,
-0.1329255849,
-0.1490472853,
-0.5051169395,
-0.2529910803,
-0.5952336192,
-0.2147485912,
-0.3241592646,
-0.2601679564,
-0.4787435234,
-0.2230564207,
-0.2659215331,
0.3865402043,
0.4300862551,
0.3342490792,
-0.0636256039,
0.8153347969,
-0.8531072736,
0.4854534864,
-0.0399487317,
0.5688593388,
-0.1042513251,
-0.2796292603,
0.034059193,
-0.4892452657,
-0.3204807937,
-1.0041533709,
0.100830175,
0.4266749918,
0.760658145,
0.7776888013,
0.1270837933,
0.6370893717,
-0.1343782693,
0.6034299731,
0.4257720411,
-0.9789699316,
0.3785574436,
-0.2752010524,
0.2041063458,
0.6931321621,
0.5575302839,
-0.3455404937,
-0.0254910104,
-0.2254610509,
-1.1612440348,
0.9302688241,
0.2337854207,
-0.7101892233,
0.2045712322,
0.3639505506,
0.5322334766,
0.4792525172,
-0.6536586285,
-0.4439357817,
-0.4033225477,
-0.321087867,
-0.3552874327,
-0.2401284277,
0.2921075523,
-0.1880137771,
0.8135439157,
0.0189447775,
0.3189809024,
0.0050111096,
0.0137342047,
0.0580312759,
0.3957082629,
0.3960955739,
0.2707875371,
-0.4742527604,
-0.2574822605,
0.0690328181,
-0.4230989516,
0.5305721164,
0.5344388485,
-0.2944235504,
-0.2993811965,
0.144480139,
0.5891314745,
0.203669861,
-0.7015349865,
0.3486307263,
-0.1301064938,
-0.2473159283,
-0.3575668931,
0.1215769872,
-0.1123107001,
-0.0223439336,
0.4888028502,
0.1893923581,
0.0229346901,
-0.5553776026,
0.629219234,
-0.1405705363,
0.1464086175,
0.1929515004,
0.6379879713,
0.1481823474,
-0.4573889077,
0.5380702019,
-0.4900750816,
-0.4513601065,
0.4935925901,
0.2950989008,
0.8539910913,
-0.4820689261,
0.3863955438,
-0.0603935495,
0.1973503232,
-0.1575243175,
0.5194632411,
-0.1288572103,
-0.5444540381,
-0.6500840783,
-1.0172028542,
-0.519523859,
0.2908898592,
-0.853317976,
-0.0277588982,
-0.6730251908,
-0.3022673726,
0.0135705834,
0.3295437694,
-0.7772606015,
0.3992997706,
0.1619222015,
1.0613226891,
-0.9303447008,
1.0483906269,
0.840734303,
-0.3184246123,
-0.7926635146,
0.1442488432,
0.1702143401,
0.0280163866,
0.6444347501,
0.5255202651,
-0.359872371,
-0.2668320239,
-0.0547602512,
-0.6557375789,
0.7664686441,
0.1125868335,
-0.6767247319,
-0.0286462493,
0.0860441774,
0.4865338802,
-0.5097702742,
0.037342269,
0.6372262239,
0.7306650281,
-0.0147003029,
-0.8144051433,
-0.2118020803,
-0.4313982427,
-0.1280199587,
0.3388225436,
-0.844943285,
1.2066444159,
-0.0058134245,
0.0262441281,
0.4778921306,
0.7541063428,
0.3795824349,
0.7422087789,
1.2116942406,
0.4786891937,
0.8725208044,
-0.4632719755,
0.6535543799,
-0.1103195101,
0.0560390912,
1.1622736454,
-0.3513901234,
1.06724298,
0.7638655305,
-0.32749331,
0.4150539935,
0.964353621,
0.1001158059,
0.8378669024,
0.1532586068,
-0.2208448499,
-0.2543316782,
0.2622950971,
-0.4638938904,
0.7850310206,
0.5486055017,
0.1730118692,
0.0983084738,
0.5386196971,
0.0381061807,
0.3339060545,
-0.1782076657,
0.4480939209,
0.0258594714,
-1.0045024157,
0.3647656143,
-0.0290258285,
0.8689602017,
-0.8502100706,
0.261313647,
0.0376407243,
0.5240946412,
0.0884621814,
-0.5872470737,
0.344524473,
-0.2539017498,
-0.2639125884,
-0.4068821073,
0.7546288371,
-0.4098418951,
-0.3863204718,
0.4668895602,
0.3538020253,
0.2171496153,
0.0705839247,
-1.0339847803,
0.4896672666,
-0.1654257923,
-0.6249808073,
0.1499842852,
0.3426626921,
0.167302236,
0.8834336996,
0.8464529514,
0.012509943,
0.2840703428,
-0.1841578931,
0.7740969658,
-0.6033591032,
-0.8884879947,
-0.560138166,
0.3962843418,
0.1153289527,
-0.5367007256,
0.505851686,
0.2288925052,
0.6725444198,
-0.3513028026,
0.6226480603,
-0.2603566051,
0.7172576785,
-0.8007386923,
0.7052353024,
-0.7678290606,
-0.0903149992,
-0.5015293956,
-0.8611813188,
-0.1647236496,
0.6746153235,
-0.0782791153,
0.243822217,
0.9313395023,
0.3587289155,
-0.0382409915,
0.1037241593,
-0.0788352266,
0.1651364863,
0.3922196031,
0.8894046545,
0.7056969404,
-0.1070706248,
0.8463175297,
-0.5448477864,
-0.4848861396,
-0.3078479469,
-0.9654937387,
-0.8723135591,
-0.7845324874,
-0.2909273803,
-0.3688338399,
0.0847422555,
0.6631441712,
0.9200720191,
-0.7592310905,
0.2245483398,
-0.0237816349,
-0.2936112285,
-0.5710125566,
-0.2929631472,
0.4209725261,
-0.4154693484,
-0.6002345085,
0.3291762769,
0.1909089088,
0.12935552,
-0.2429759353,
-0.3512132466,
-0.4359778166,
-0.1125344932,
0.358083576,
0.6083137989,
-0.8185882568,
-0.0439078659,
-0.1547403336,
0.2094964087,
-0.0692087859,
0.6655161977,
-0.8711209297,
0.472443521,
0.4176183641,
1.005540967,
0.6968944669,
-0.1279782504,
0.5116986632,
-0.8024855256,
0.7144590616,
0.1814003587,
0.0335133038,
-0.031681262,
-0.0995446295,
0.4887775183,
0.0666946098,
-0.4766601324,
-1.0739489794,
0.1903420389,
-1.1764791012,
-0.1800390333,
0.6825908422,
-0.5507871509,
-0.5224734545,
-0.2234069109,
0.0611834712,
0.3140340149,
-0.367199719,
0.7657589912,
0.9651466012,
-0.2217154205,
-0.320917815,
-0.4036072791,
0.6210986376,
0.7829420567,
-0.9169319868,
-0.1447425932,
-0.020554103,
-0.0368326269,
0.4369085133,
1.0473583937,
0.1259261221,
0.4729322493,
0.1080848947,
-0.0499831997,
-0.2327968627,
-0.8839790821,
0.0122321667,
0.7275890112,
-0.1123946086,
-0.4381443262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12434v1 | BiasAsker: Measuring the Bias in Conversational AI System | 2023-05-21T11:25:59 | 2023-05-21T11:25:59 | Yuxuan Wan, Wenxuan Wang, Pinjia He, Jiazhen Gu, Haonan Bai, Michael Lyu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Powered by advanced Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques, conversational
AI systems, such as ChatGPT and digital assistants like Siri, have been widely
deployed in daily life. However, such systems may still produce content
containing biases and stereotypes, causing potential social problems. Due to
the data-driven, black-box nature of modern AI techniques, comprehensively
identifying and measuring biases in conversational systems remains a
challenging task. Particularly, it is hard to generate inputs that can
comprehensively trigger potential bias due to the lack of data containing both
social groups as well as biased properties. In addition, modern conversational
systems can produce diverse responses (e.g., chatting and explanation), which
makes existing bias detection methods simply based on the sentiment and the
toxicity hardly being adopted. In this paper, we propose BiasAsker, an
automated framework to identify and measure social bias in conversational AI
systems. To obtain social groups and biased properties, we construct a
comprehensive social bias dataset, containing a total of 841 groups and 8,110
biased properties. Given the dataset, BiasAsker automatically generates
questions and adopts a novel method based on existence measurement to identify
two types of biases (i.e., absolute bias and related bias) in conversational
systems. Extensive experiments on 8 commercial systems and 2 famous research
models, such as ChatGPT and GPT-3, show that 32.83% of the questions generated
by BiasAsker can trigger biased behaviors in these widely deployed
conversational systems. All the code, data, and experimental results have been
released to facilitate future research. | [
-0.6778883934,
-1.079641819,
0.2414385378,
0.3414360881,
0.0760671943,
-0.0320762582,
-0.0559477247,
-0.3148292005,
0.3906633556,
0.1224168614,
-0.5849485397,
-0.1775046885,
-0.5585771799,
-0.2638092935,
-0.4437117577,
1.1450885534,
0.1681294888,
0.3156758845,
-0.3482394516,
-0.3661034405,
-0.5770965219,
-0.3871132135,
-0.4011177421,
-0.5770311356,
0.0574362949,
0.384976536,
0.5927635431,
0.2127976269,
0.3020989001,
0.3503229916,
-0.0634872317,
-0.1803899407,
-0.4067915678,
0.2407234907,
0.0995979682,
-0.3931599855,
-0.2619534135,
0.0369628295,
0.2826597989,
0.2767419815,
0.1895146519,
0.4261994958,
0.1977157593,
0.4439627826,
-0.6342810392,
0.2322483063,
-0.6103510857,
0.2876592278,
-0.0922885239,
-0.0135089848,
-0.0621608011,
-0.747754097,
0.2970402837,
-0.2342500538,
0.2744753361,
-0.0078897532,
0.4803849459,
0.4755406976,
-0.3905436695,
-0.477336973,
-0.6643772721,
0.9498528838,
-0.7466080785,
0.099024564,
0.0853722692,
0.5399885774,
-0.0184632763,
0.1385846436,
-0.7723907232,
-0.3431874216,
-0.0972530395,
-0.0377854668,
-0.2192932814,
-0.1283871382,
0.0703300461,
0.2249275595,
-0.4460414648,
-0.3685698509,
-0.1473183185,
-0.4552007318,
0.7948260903,
0.0762419477,
0.5348631144,
-0.0977494717,
0.0371211581,
-0.0765393376,
-0.1297360212,
-0.2865418196,
0.5386815071,
-0.1941525191,
-0.3582024872,
0.4669949114,
-0.1183952168,
0.3175938427,
0.4336892068,
0.0450369455,
0.2671011984,
-0.3402236104,
-0.0574003905,
0.1619906873,
0.9098505378,
0.5155947804,
0.4382464588,
-0.0191276185,
0.1147366613,
0.4312038422,
0.1364738941,
-0.5676741004,
-0.2638492584,
0.400241822,
-0.405916065,
-0.8222123384,
-0.2720252872,
-0.9541795254,
-0.7812826037,
0.0709680393,
0.0847185031,
-0.1503248215,
-0.4309018552,
-0.5318152905,
-0.3839780092,
0.6044515371,
0.1787808686,
-0.5539365411,
0.1968334317,
0.3657349944,
0.8715056777,
-0.321215421,
-0.0735102892,
-0.3226465881,
-0.1631700844,
-0.2519800663,
0.7746216655,
-0.4908165634,
-0.3920966983,
0.1072593853,
-0.3562270403,
0.2965540588,
-0.5589846969,
0.5663423538,
-0.5075549483,
0.38166219,
-0.2974110246,
-0.5037688017,
0.1836894453,
0.7760523558,
-0.2864559591,
0.7538122535,
-0.1931144893,
-0.9326180816,
0.5412880182,
-0.8808878064,
-0.4543427229,
-0.0380282253,
-0.400488019,
-0.5833278298,
-0.2792087495,
0.3212434649,
0.3710021377,
-0.2831319273,
0.492218107,
-0.7026590705,
-0.2342554033,
0.436637491,
-0.5963176489,
0.9447104335,
0.0289640389,
-0.8268510103,
0.3746871948,
-0.4854889512,
0.0665172562,
0.0236123092,
-0.1186720356,
-0.1840598583,
0.1789963692,
0.2916022241,
0.1748627871,
0.2342718393,
-0.6988130212,
-0.2056702971,
0.0290462114,
0.4377702773,
1.1360064745,
-0.1182168573,
0.598433435,
-0.191523388,
0.3646527529,
0.1371856779,
0.2804394066,
0.1143353879,
-0.4139514565,
-1.1059890985,
-0.0642137676,
-0.0932979211,
0.6566604972,
-0.3770963848,
0.8445519805,
-0.2118518353,
-0.4449695945,
-0.3058447242,
-0.019995952,
0.3614724576,
0.5016022921,
0.0999136046,
-0.3476447761,
-0.2584728897,
-1.0367970467,
-0.4663481116,
-0.2268532068,
-0.208640039,
0.8271799684,
0.4118497372,
-0.5782383084,
1.0847328901,
-0.2936267257,
-0.3331179023,
-0.0694590807,
0.2028895915,
-0.1457828432,
0.3608545959,
0.3857542574,
-0.4289533794,
-0.4098611474,
-0.0765468851,
-1.0928052664,
-0.4823335707,
0.0667731836,
-0.1538392901,
-0.0459963642,
0.1674367189,
-0.4171531498,
0.3855178952,
0.1806779206,
-0.2931789756,
0.6121795774,
0.2300577462,
0.1358353347,
-0.6519491076,
0.1267429739,
0.4135577381,
-0.0809644088,
-0.6592288017,
-0.2727373838,
-0.1275592297,
-0.0905588567,
-0.3266198635,
0.6541236043,
-0.2274650186,
-0.0180772506,
-0.1533515006,
-0.0264001302,
-0.3183507919,
0.4011719227,
-0.1429811269,
0.7574878931,
0.5365993381,
-0.5266932249,
0.5582268834,
0.2652553618,
-0.1655964404,
0.8907155395,
-0.9002521634,
0.457680136,
-0.1780354381,
0.6003381014,
-0.9330853224,
-0.4915150404,
0.5496106744,
-0.6010079384,
-0.3988852799,
-0.2762383521,
0.0941696763,
-0.3403804302,
-0.3425602317,
0.5141277313,
0.5193962455,
-0.3964796066,
0.570702374,
0.7339675426,
-0.0913935006,
-0.6818076968,
-0.3572367132,
-0.0438866839,
-0.3706126809,
-0.7989325523,
-0.1961567551,
-0.0892873108,
-0.6263446808,
-0.3251654208,
-0.0668207631,
-0.1121403947,
-0.1694136262,
0.3563848138,
0.2798378766,
0.0385272168,
-0.1515678018,
0.2398653775,
0.0280448589,
0.4740905166,
-0.2568824887,
0.7701289058,
-0.0630580708,
-0.5256355405,
-0.6483341455,
0.08568535,
0.9499248862,
0.0689957216,
0.3036544919,
0.7400318384,
-0.0839625597,
-0.0585200228,
-0.9939128757,
-0.2899881899,
-0.4880897403,
0.2897784412,
0.1358925402,
-0.546736598,
0.6763442755,
0.3312053084,
-0.0178756919,
-0.0168601405,
0.5689815879,
0.2824101746,
1.3058105707,
0.2950507402,
-0.9935238957,
0.5101962686,
0.0498678721,
0.4021582901,
-0.3496105373,
-0.1734076589,
-0.4592391253,
-0.3249771893,
-0.5173862576,
-0.1228882223,
0.6962871552,
-0.561311543,
-0.496689707,
-0.2523194849,
-0.7608265281,
0.5385700464,
0.8906717896,
0.1832358241,
0.0460219048,
-0.119984813,
0.3059732318,
0.2754472494,
-0.2299339771,
-0.6858633757,
1.1588110924,
0.3579488695,
0.7181962132,
-0.1842991859,
0.5435094237,
0.841386199,
0.4290281832,
-0.7693603635,
0.5306102037,
0.7187016606,
-0.7709137201,
-0.4490368962,
-0.3842404485,
-0.3503212035,
0.1401875317,
0.056007199,
-0.5555745959,
0.1468201131,
0.4729277492,
-0.1138694361,
0.0121558961,
-0.7018042803,
0.6618478894,
-0.2063294798,
-0.6537843943,
-0.2608593404,
-0.6350461245,
0.3488909602,
0.2516366541,
0.1448057294,
-0.2302402705,
0.5604789257,
1.0111839771,
-0.3195630908,
0.8056260943,
-0.5257298946,
-0.0824753717,
0.2982544005,
0.157947138,
0.5875478387,
0.2496408075,
0.0346033946,
0.4495089948,
-0.0137858419,
-0.5829828978,
-0.482534945,
0.8189083338,
-1.0334992409,
-0.2777136564,
-0.5851120949,
-0.4054452777,
-0.1967071742,
0.2442274541,
0.1269396842,
-0.029175492,
-0.7606393695,
-0.250392139,
0.5042210817,
-0.3666164577,
0.0396173857,
0.3740589619,
0.236549601,
-0.0771953985,
0.750230968,
-0.2450886071,
-0.1083338335,
-0.097551249,
0.150191322,
-0.0380897708,
-0.1918241084,
-0.5409249067,
-0.0991759822,
-0.1865353137,
0.0508088358,
-0.6439413428,
-0.1510281712,
-0.553260088,
-0.2129643708,
-0.2071684003,
-0.031002596,
0.0400799848,
-0.0503642038,
0.0143489065,
0.7132353187,
-0.0034783569,
0.352627039,
-0.2354578823,
0.2017895132,
0.6948223114,
0.2860875428,
0.1411291659,
-0.0357559621,
0.1304505765,
0.4096387029,
-0.696987927,
-0.8170873523,
0.4541274011,
-0.1482616216,
0.3011164665,
0.7673925161,
-0.0263367482,
0.3837143481,
-0.3176680803,
0.8554673791,
0.085184589,
-1.1018254757,
0.746720016,
-0.5878094435,
-0.0447661206,
0.4234154522,
0.067551218,
-0.6900646091,
-0.3805818856,
-0.4578478336,
-0.5456670523,
0.7714783549,
0.2936349511,
0.2660113871,
-0.1291433275,
-0.0050941133,
-0.0724562779,
0.2091841549,
-0.7185994387,
-0.4360794425,
-0.4289501607,
-0.3248715997,
0.0558394976,
-0.1280186027,
-0.2408016473,
-0.1398923546,
0.7047272325,
-0.0261324309,
0.4507789612,
-0.0592743009,
-0.2204279304,
-0.1025757939,
0.5248416066,
0.2364902049,
0.4171667993,
-0.2934176326,
-0.0271361358,
0.2638594806,
-0.5214297175,
0.2915785015,
0.0191705413,
-0.3482978046,
-0.1149790064,
0.2063794434,
0.4084419608,
-0.4246369004,
-0.7909089327,
0.7826861143,
-0.0503496714,
0.003621567,
-0.8091711402,
0.3125220537,
-0.4193642735,
0.1203312948,
0.3193807602,
0.1848582476,
0.4107154608,
-0.4890009761,
0.138196677,
0.8998535275,
-0.929430604,
-0.3848588765,
0.5424903035,
0.6599668264,
-0.4709226787,
0.5850459933,
-0.1536135823,
-0.6632180214,
0.6500408053,
0.1656973362,
0.8670817018,
-0.192276448,
0.4116947353,
0.0933344141,
0.1274397373,
0.1559865624,
-0.233427465,
-0.3996022046,
-1.1877714396,
0.1891753823,
-0.2027193606,
-0.3808760345,
0.287293911,
-0.6104385853,
0.1205359027,
-0.2975035012,
-0.2577263117,
0.0881843939,
-0.2717883885,
-0.7626501918,
-0.0923720822,
-0.0143906586,
0.3807974458,
-1.2430068254,
0.1701410264,
0.6033973098,
-0.1025585979,
-0.1797830909,
0.2201007456,
0.4614937901,
-1.025178194,
0.5000296831,
0.0932982489,
-0.2009059936,
-0.3644334376,
-0.8056249022,
-0.4235958755,
0.7313377857,
0.0663997009,
-0.3097714186,
0.1279479563,
0.2615954578,
0.5226260424,
-0.0177756716,
0.9731821418,
0.735200882,
0.5886920691,
-0.2498701364,
-0.8919016719,
-0.0504707284,
-0.7920581102,
-0.1283397228,
-0.0586247072,
-0.7021362782,
0.3127351701,
0.2681383193,
0.1351715326,
-0.3280704916,
0.3516271114,
0.1916964203,
0.6901672482,
0.5478198528,
0.2390031815,
0.6250804067,
0.0197205506,
0.6020021439,
-0.3883292377,
0.2409248948,
0.7315852046,
-0.6266714334,
0.022746861,
0.4997943044,
-0.1716234684,
0.2290378511,
0.2905215025,
0.2082049996,
0.3059212565,
0.5001423955,
-0.5249303579,
-0.0715108886,
-0.1830852181,
-0.432395637,
0.3038971424,
0.2644817531,
-0.4651901424,
0.1350573003,
0.1195789129,
0.2149349004,
-0.2368566841,
0.0997908935,
1.0383281708,
-0.2849726379,
-0.8006914258,
0.3999507725,
-0.2557485402,
1.1385195255,
-0.2790425122,
0.060455367,
-0.4573867023,
0.5153695345,
-0.063154377,
-0.4652536213,
0.1080811322,
0.0726734623,
-0.0905644372,
0.0749387741,
0.9181696773,
-0.0899094492,
-0.6022716761,
0.2080620974,
0.5336747169,
0.0916933119,
-0.1179863885,
-0.6723325849,
0.2614864409,
0.1572650969,
0.0598183908,
0.1667807102,
0.1524551809,
0.0348646753,
0.9328953624,
0.3775765896,
-0.0293522924,
0.0263773017,
0.0188559871,
0.8570244312,
-0.3209731877,
-0.5192514658,
-0.8867693543,
0.1974537224,
-0.6700896621,
-0.3498601615,
0.9546766281,
0.524269104,
0.5691529512,
0.1187749654,
1.4640492201,
-0.279317975,
0.4359086752,
0.3069203496,
0.9351757765,
0.0106747886,
0.2274064422,
-0.7214612961,
-0.9632314444,
0.0056021377,
0.8262027502,
-0.7272289991,
0.0860184208,
0.0130416611,
1.142965436,
-0.3497489095,
0.3666159213,
-0.1812134087,
0.2474120408,
0.5837137103,
0.1312535107,
0.9226400256,
-0.2888625264,
0.5126289725,
0.0512570627,
-0.7839613557,
-0.2554958165,
-0.3891465664,
-1.1501921415,
-0.3903463781,
-0.2878305018,
-0.3518866599,
0.500705421,
0.7792704105,
0.9700193405,
-1.0591714382,
-0.3637210429,
-0.3674761057,
0.2738727033,
-0.0377428979,
-0.3436384499,
0.0326456502,
-0.2480611056,
-0.4884105325,
-0.0314725563,
-0.0726192072,
-0.2719761133,
-0.4538178444,
-0.1495257169,
0.2630185783,
0.1789892614,
0.5187121034,
0.1289089769,
-0.5265858769,
-0.4391862452,
-0.1273921877,
0.2717781961,
0.0599722303,
0.7701339722,
-0.5492761135,
0.3550003171,
0.5658640862,
0.3359831274,
0.4749510884,
0.0695789382,
0.675190866,
-0.5387833118,
0.0305234529,
0.3518163264,
0.035358835,
0.204763636,
-0.3606437743,
0.1020123661,
-0.0123931244,
-0.8193569779,
-0.74225384,
0.0449444875,
-0.6190627813,
0.1398941427,
1.1623058319,
0.2903064787,
-0.0526629575,
-0.4208557308,
-0.4677057862,
0.259837389,
-0.8726367354,
1.3289204836,
0.6463933587,
-0.2249475867,
0.0515065268,
-0.1540556848,
0.4305360913,
0.4632488191,
-0.7436535954,
-0.0340728424,
0.8436176777,
0.3649584055,
0.339604944,
0.867156446,
-0.0527182147,
0.0654476881,
-0.2015469074,
0.1503451616,
0.3270274401,
0.2190750539,
-0.0078122076,
0.1523532122,
-0.3387610018,
-0.2508463562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12421v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12421v4 | Evaluating Open-QA Evaluation | 2023-05-21T10:40:55 | 2023-10-23T14:26:26 | Cunxiang Wang, Sirui Cheng, Qipeng Guo, Yuanhao Yue, Bowen Ding, Zhikun Xu, Yidong Wang, Xiangkun Hu, Zheng Zhang, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study focuses on the evaluation of the Open Question Answering (Open-QA)
task, which can directly estimate the factuality of large language models
(LLMs). Current automatic evaluation methods have shown limitations, indicating
that human evaluation still remains the most reliable approach. We introduce a
new task, Evaluating QA Evaluation (QA-Eval) and the corresponding dataset
EVOUNA, designed to assess the accuracy of AI-generated answers in relation to
standard answers within Open-QA. Our evaluation of these methods utilizes
human-annotated results to measure their performance. Specifically, the work
investigates methods that show high correlation with human evaluations, deeming
them more reliable. We also discuss the pitfalls of current methods and methods
to improve LLM-based evaluators. We believe this new QA-Eval task and
corresponding dataset EVOUNA will facilitate the development of more effective
automatic evaluation tools and prove valuable for future research in this area.
All resources are available at \url{https://github.com/wangcunxiang/QA-Eval}
and it is under the Apache-2.0 License. | [
-0.3259723485,
-1.1038962603,
0.6096788645,
0.0918292701,
-0.0652187914,
-0.0625031814,
-0.5574877858,
-0.4432842433,
-0.088050887,
0.3127859235,
-0.2828056216,
-0.5108013153,
-0.3201997578,
0.3304478228,
-0.2679235935,
0.8488422632,
-0.1807776541,
0.0352105685,
-0.7172211409,
-0.3181305826,
-0.547929287,
-0.3815096915,
-0.7297936082,
-0.0459932163,
0.3889327645,
0.2481077909,
0.8580718637,
0.4732512236,
0.5708395839,
0.2641182542,
0.0398032553,
0.2453120202,
-0.5409203768,
0.0105753867,
-0.1797048151,
-0.5431002378,
-0.3980540335,
0.2517308593,
0.6691542864,
0.37348032,
-0.1465216577,
0.7650880218,
-0.2042452097,
0.6634606123,
-0.7239064574,
0.2996022105,
-0.4124903679,
-0.0698481649,
-0.0768480375,
0.0021200832,
-0.3465836942,
-0.7662017941,
0.2976289093,
-0.5608062744,
-0.1157744005,
0.135533303,
0.8379700184,
0.3362238109,
-0.2254558355,
-0.3122979105,
-0.9400426149,
0.6720174551,
-0.7181425095,
0.4408828616,
0.3262025714,
0.5232203603,
-0.1232744381,
-0.5629262328,
-0.8506957889,
-0.6641683578,
0.1450061053,
0.1846408993,
-0.3188627958,
0.0133171901,
0.2778644562,
0.5720230937,
-0.6143094897,
0.1725257933,
-0.3448185921,
-0.021845974,
0.8121274114,
0.1653959453,
0.5813658834,
-0.0609913319,
-0.1886110455,
-0.0244096257,
-0.4383523762,
0.1196869537,
0.5220522881,
0.0134536019,
0.0676719621,
0.7437755466,
-0.4839095771,
0.5428454876,
-0.1253127903,
0.0917032361,
0.3815303743,
-0.401345104,
-0.3336292505,
-0.3487792015,
0.8523817062,
0.3174462318,
0.3176343739,
-0.2704992294,
-0.2813118994,
-0.0534767173,
0.2994750142,
-0.5373152494,
-0.1012206301,
0.4775372148,
-0.5013023615,
-0.2982348204,
0.3925751746,
-0.8320071101,
-0.2886407077,
-0.2756445706,
0.777297914,
-0.1096976995,
-0.3295709789,
-0.0479897186,
0.1373942494,
0.2201941162,
0.4370145202,
-0.3446253836,
0.4606810808,
0.6720231771,
0.6136458516,
-0.1043308154,
-0.2745221555,
-0.8650852442,
-0.4811531901,
-0.4396165907,
0.5980334878,
-0.356039077,
-0.0212931465,
0.0849513486,
-0.1187661812,
-0.094765842,
-0.7603929639,
0.9603633285,
-0.8098581433,
0.4477238059,
-0.1341298521,
-0.5541625619,
-0.3719083369,
0.3054430783,
-1.0473328829,
1.0836666822,
0.2760660052,
-0.5273011923,
0.1383712143,
-1.0107564926,
-0.0952229127,
0.0232710037,
0.0444248766,
-0.331174314,
0.0793249533,
0.2773042917,
0.1018112898,
-0.6209405661,
0.1649498343,
-0.1216476336,
-0.3936209977,
0.5664275885,
-0.556471467,
0.9615235329,
0.1606605798,
-0.1701414883,
0.411105901,
-0.7272507548,
0.1377866268,
0.1779415905,
-0.4101145864,
-0.1907740533,
-0.1457487047,
-0.1943582743,
0.2132110298,
0.3817860186,
-0.7503325343,
-0.0631543249,
-0.5532650352,
-0.0740308464,
0.716556251,
0.0419527628,
0.1131468117,
-0.2768650353,
0.8821222782,
-0.2372941524,
0.3518495262,
0.1323967427,
-0.6402332783,
-0.6290358901,
-0.1051305979,
0.6028971672,
0.6157364845,
-0.6288920045,
0.5861780047,
-0.1582082659,
-0.728936851,
-0.9951356053,
0.1275866181,
0.6050650477,
0.3711430132,
0.2852576077,
-0.4286123812,
-0.5026395321,
-0.8541452289,
-0.2616867721,
-0.4449684918,
-0.1550522745,
0.3133404553,
0.6077648997,
-0.0112003842,
0.9666081667,
-0.3867026269,
-0.0189030841,
-0.0574728064,
0.1702848226,
0.145913288,
0.244936347,
0.3912960887,
-0.5660020709,
-0.3384443521,
-0.1738886684,
-0.7697634697,
-0.1724313945,
0.1205488443,
-0.2303485721,
0.2716642022,
-0.0821587592,
-0.8547801971,
0.5208687186,
0.5424827933,
-0.4735914469,
0.8892219663,
-0.0712908059,
0.6039639115,
-0.5925002694,
0.2275555581,
0.0212051515,
-0.0428564362,
-0.4763879776,
0.2159288228,
-0.0611929446,
0.014966513,
-0.4538145363,
0.7742690444,
-0.317560643,
-0.2569975555,
-0.0806260183,
0.3229521513,
0.0068695112,
0.3684414625,
-0.3774408102,
0.8783320189,
0.2489088625,
-0.2270710617,
0.6702878475,
0.3445631266,
-0.5945896506,
0.343826592,
-0.6594887376,
0.5159742832,
-0.1056151316,
0.1078168899,
-0.9730687737,
-0.1888676137,
0.4353424609,
-0.5659024119,
-0.0325227082,
0.0948745385,
-0.6170830131,
-0.4604333341,
-0.4286518991,
0.440251559,
0.7091008425,
-0.5682592392,
0.3423169553,
0.1664177179,
-0.0675098598,
-0.3995837867,
-0.1789703369,
0.0514233001,
-0.1074140593,
-0.74871099,
-0.1977635026,
-0.1014449596,
-0.6231822371,
0.1630084366,
0.0217855554,
-0.2038659006,
0.3668471277,
0.1509981304,
0.4111301303,
-0.4077082276,
0.2418998331,
-0.2680673301,
0.0478552766,
0.3477489054,
-0.0754226223,
0.2981045842,
-0.3592117429,
-0.6099273562,
-0.6962295175,
-0.0903407484,
0.4640522897,
-0.7289814949,
0.6157027483,
0.5510946512,
-0.486423552,
0.1263559312,
-0.5743106604,
0.0395631418,
-0.3243912458,
0.4597971439,
-0.2361979932,
-0.6863280535,
0.4580706954,
0.2297214717,
0.2310199142,
0.7824921012,
0.5761336684,
0.0293818861,
0.8610303998,
0.3064773083,
0.1366516948,
-0.0175464582,
0.0000737752,
0.12854743,
-0.863066256,
-0.2246102095,
-0.7339822054,
0.0099592768,
-0.3749621511,
-0.5852565169,
0.3715581,
0.1919963062,
-0.0375798456,
-0.1091288403,
-0.1609330624,
0.418520391,
0.5025679469,
0.0842960551,
0.4546493292,
-0.3229004741,
0.325096637,
0.2931118608,
-0.3345671594,
-0.8944830894,
1.4256852865,
0.6427520514,
0.3603759408,
0.1333872527,
0.4129148126,
0.4087043405,
0.5929463506,
-0.6766536236,
0.4585767984,
0.1154682264,
-0.5441846848,
-0.8263728619,
-0.3764252067,
-0.8011847734,
0.2755059898,
-0.273658365,
-0.8006584644,
-0.2890112698,
-0.0760659277,
-0.5149587989,
0.1851235628,
-0.6297420859,
0.9823808074,
-0.4180777669,
-0.2007348239,
-0.2449266911,
-0.4156003296,
0.5433225036,
-0.1200414002,
0.0726614967,
-0.2007894665,
0.000029101,
1.0226515532,
-0.227546677,
0.5016357303,
-0.3075057864,
-0.2810253799,
0.629763484,
-0.2035070807,
0.27429533,
0.0836137533,
-0.473392725,
0.2307838947,
0.2208355814,
-0.3655945361,
-0.9820553064,
0.3803257346,
-0.8326935172,
-0.5747153759,
-0.3393308222,
-0.4236640632,
-0.2688329816,
0.0311000738,
-0.2596148551,
0.4280056357,
-0.6233004332,
-0.0604120269,
0.5198329687,
-0.5456372499,
-0.0122025562,
0.5657756329,
-0.5328086019,
-0.5840225816,
0.7723198533,
0.0330833755,
0.2111165673,
0.329213351,
0.3100550473,
-0.4529274404,
-0.7463359833,
-0.8941115737,
0.1805699915,
-0.6628191471,
0.0468614586,
-0.3798952699,
-0.1204419136,
-0.3298182786,
0.4448213875,
-0.1388634443,
-0.4314011633,
-0.1548854411,
-0.0999628827,
0.1963417679,
0.9293594956,
0.2306694835,
-0.1535215825,
-0.8310027122,
0.4448151886,
0.3684949577,
0.3523930907,
0.1009583995,
-0.5120127797,
-0.3946917653,
0.1843554676,
-0.0815259665,
-0.7552596927,
0.0338801704,
0.0426710583,
0.6368875504,
0.2221971005,
0.1488453746,
0.2730717957,
-0.3008468449,
0.9641993046,
-0.1058036536,
-0.7520713806,
0.4090268612,
-0.2010851353,
0.3030667603,
0.7509883046,
0.3242585957,
-0.3619933128,
-0.3868688941,
-0.5276619196,
-0.5487595201,
0.5220685005,
0.4389957786,
-0.0941228569,
-0.0195493866,
0.3683330715,
0.210555464,
0.2952290177,
-0.3635031879,
-0.1249614805,
0.0921505615,
-0.3432694376,
0.0212748926,
-0.3992320299,
-0.1169023141,
-0.1149083972,
0.8051057458,
-0.0760236531,
0.2132527381,
0.2152876407,
-0.1990225762,
-0.3903363645,
0.4845253229,
0.4398524761,
1.1372214556,
-0.3796446025,
-0.0977032185,
0.3322928548,
-0.4063895345,
0.0834847987,
0.2030692995,
-0.3421094716,
-0.0964726508,
0.4347297549,
0.7895152569,
-0.1182628274,
-1.085711956,
0.7278605103,
-0.2424172759,
0.0132866725,
-0.4060133696,
-0.0580773652,
-0.1538244039,
0.2437945902,
0.3388352692,
-0.188759625,
0.1858401,
-0.6160553694,
0.1958107352,
0.2812671661,
-0.3180892467,
-0.5504711866,
0.5640618801,
0.3444181681,
-0.4585382044,
0.8084999323,
-0.2701861858,
-0.5197338462,
0.8148723841,
0.2546047866,
1.28827703,
-0.3184888661,
0.2447646856,
0.4019829035,
0.4763939977,
0.2053176463,
0.5543542504,
0.1980603486,
-0.577449441,
-0.6188296676,
-0.8356730342,
-0.5851252675,
0.246671617,
-0.7026677728,
0.1283573955,
-0.1692495197,
0.1226213351,
-0.2264187336,
0.1529887617,
-0.7745226622,
0.3816441298,
-0.0618193001,
0.9903123379,
-0.7705664039,
0.5480933785,
0.9355113506,
-0.6392734051,
-0.6754978895,
0.2240081728,
-0.2318679541,
-0.4571988285,
0.6674400568,
0.1609678119,
-0.0099340519,
-0.0994426236,
-0.3156789541,
-0.8510301113,
1.0467860699,
0.2971973717,
-0.3572952747,
0.1180797219,
0.1178797856,
0.80571872,
-0.1794598252,
0.7277781963,
0.6482537985,
0.6371715069,
-0.4432536662,
-1.3053048849,
0.1404188573,
-0.2526196837,
-0.1545295268,
-0.0245002955,
-0.6343279481,
0.4802792966,
-0.2902889848,
-0.3336474001,
0.475292474,
0.914268136,
0.1194862276,
0.4471874237,
0.7243008018,
0.6357810497,
0.9221026897,
0.0122994669,
1.1161580086,
-0.1235327125,
0.3933250606,
1.1362662315,
-0.3466467261,
0.9482434392,
0.2395952493,
-0.5272176266,
0.3474238217,
0.4502471685,
0.0175046809,
0.0847877488,
0.4680908024,
-0.2192896903,
-0.089305006,
-0.141269803,
0.0092679355,
0.6095873117,
-0.1115576401,
-0.1362971961,
-0.1696802527,
-0.0190480482,
-0.1716074944,
0.2096411437,
-0.1871824116,
0.6847465038,
-0.262296021,
-0.791534543,
0.4830263257,
0.0788994581,
0.317348659,
-0.2810949981,
-0.2933072448,
0.0603520498,
-0.2708912194,
-0.2581945956,
-0.8781982064,
0.2558165789,
0.2504658401,
0.0295515116,
0.2489111722,
0.6220454574,
-0.4653207064,
-0.2325475216,
0.0547639616,
0.7503545284,
0.4262270331,
-0.1934369504,
-0.5108920336,
0.0115945814,
-0.0537567921,
-0.4342564344,
0.0898635909,
0.1809531003,
-0.1932276189,
0.4999992549,
0.6343078613,
0.0076539307,
0.0517571457,
0.1801109314,
0.5749747157,
-0.5217394233,
-0.2028616965,
-0.6310303211,
0.4770465791,
0.0084166164,
-0.3896295726,
0.8962535858,
0.7387580276,
0.886488378,
-0.0825028047,
0.9392932653,
-0.1680504531,
0.7252304554,
-0.6021339297,
0.6207830906,
-0.233874768,
0.1342766434,
-0.1950331479,
-1.0090564489,
0.0118054161,
0.2698765695,
-0.4341428876,
-0.0167906526,
0.6898339391,
0.5942084789,
0.2114168257,
0.2743976414,
0.3413445652,
0.230755046,
0.30425632,
0.3194525242,
1.2397098541,
-0.5219667554,
0.3599810302,
-0.3752060533,
-0.4745793641,
-0.1021248251,
-0.6975330114,
-0.7227103114,
-0.5257332325,
-0.4369859397,
-0.3123031855,
0.1809120327,
1.0277153254,
0.1606794447,
-0.8144129515,
-0.2345666289,
0.3010241389,
0.2147629559,
-0.3771767616,
-0.2941928804,
0.5580399632,
-0.2265639603,
-0.8395648003,
0.4580783546,
0.1153734848,
-0.2704804242,
-0.6145777702,
-0.1244781539,
-0.2799148858,
0.1101292968,
0.6826426983,
0.2286486626,
-0.852029562,
-0.5420342088,
-0.0582782403,
0.0330594182,
0.0194209348,
0.4385189116,
-0.802613318,
0.6242143512,
0.6251770854,
0.9115973115,
0.0212162193,
0.3759144247,
0.6279358268,
-0.2613992691,
-0.5029398203,
0.2981601059,
0.1382559091,
0.2913890779,
-0.2696962655,
0.7540617585,
-0.0381932743,
-0.6845275164,
-0.9006841779,
-0.0485992655,
-0.8435585499,
0.1022610292,
1.232927084,
-0.4056283832,
-0.3801834285,
-0.2195152342,
-0.3008354902,
0.3638534844,
-0.3692187667,
0.8271725774,
0.715459764,
-0.2495858669,
0.0763344541,
-0.8246023059,
0.3405600786,
0.2402889431,
-1.2595350742,
0.0439031497,
0.6651664972,
0.2842904925,
0.2557744384,
0.6511213779,
-0.2059569806,
0.558103025,
-0.3310873508,
0.2297735512,
-0.1817474365,
-0.225061655,
-0.6812666655,
0.2614070773,
0.4898261428,
-0.3665877581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12412v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12412v1 | EM Pre-training for Multi-party Dialogue Response Generation | 2023-05-21T09:22:41 | 2023-05-21T09:22:41 | Yiyang Li, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue response generation requires an agent to generate a response
according to the current dialogue history, in terms of which two-party
dialogues have been well studied, but leaving a great gap for multi-party
dialogues at the same time. Different from two-party dialogues where each
response is a direct reply to its previous utterance, the addressee of a
response utterance should be specified before it is generated in the
multi-party scenario. Thanks to the huge amount of two-party conversational
data, various pre-trained language models for two-party dialogue response
generation have been proposed. However, due to the lack of annotated addressee
labels in multi-party dialogue datasets, it is hard to use them to pre-train a
response generation model for multi-party dialogues. To tackle this obstacle,
we propose an Expectation-Maximization (EM) approach that iteratively performs
the expectation steps to generate addressee labels, and the maximization steps
to optimize a response generation model. Theoretical analyses and extensive
experiments have justified the feasibility and effectiveness of our proposed
method. | [
-0.801689744,
-0.5548937321,
0.6333764195,
0.0728247315,
-0.1468305886,
-0.1268668026,
-0.1334148198,
-0.2474940121,
0.3944135904,
0.5417900085,
-0.8292458653,
-0.2072105408,
-0.4665177166,
0.2129772604,
0.1318708658,
1.0884308815,
0.3692455292,
-0.1046420187,
-0.1060288399,
0.0179284941,
-0.3131535649,
-0.7717589736,
-0.8263043761,
-0.0000367273,
0.6457412243,
0.5361173153,
0.0084934263,
0.0981720611,
0.4177727401,
0.3549751937,
0.4041568935,
0.0590174682,
-0.3840681016,
0.292666018,
0.1426686347,
-0.322401911,
-0.6382287145,
0.1051501408,
0.5113759041,
0.5474431515,
-0.3425934315,
0.211882323,
-0.0517479219,
0.3960849643,
-0.8705772161,
0.1328284889,
-0.6316848993,
0.0392629206,
0.1676637381,
-0.5000389814,
-0.7792441845,
-0.3117420077,
0.1606834978,
-0.7060417533,
-0.0146755381,
0.2781349719,
0.476947397,
0.0350118615,
-0.3247030079,
-0.1295910776,
-0.8162740469,
0.533783257,
-0.6437024474,
0.2695544064,
0.2222597301,
0.3599254489,
-0.1281332821,
-0.5655007362,
-0.5480190516,
0.0273512844,
0.1299464554,
0.4321285188,
0.0051679309,
0.2717917562,
0.4810009003,
-0.0649654269,
-0.3300906122,
-0.1282847524,
0.0651831552,
-0.0057694698,
0.6434211731,
0.334084481,
-0.1263655722,
0.157293126,
-0.4939993918,
-0.3625943959,
-0.5337113738,
0.0250591245,
0.679323554,
0.4710868895,
0.2977105081,
0.3701248765,
-0.2465792298,
0.4487933517,
0.1461312473,
0.1266399324,
0.2557748854,
-0.4357432127,
-0.0466654152,
0.1814259887,
0.9428347945,
0.3616471589,
0.209241882,
0.1102843955,
-0.2433032542,
-0.0078396797,
0.1356563419,
-1.3094835281,
-0.1219335571,
0.2719292045,
-0.3052230179,
-0.141860038,
-0.0772001147,
-1.2389397621,
-0.0509636141,
-0.1297979653,
0.1990570873,
-0.1475130469,
-0.6459438801,
-0.2350333929,
0.1434913129,
0.1990101933,
0.1766875386,
-0.7421307564,
0.3398174047,
0.1877329648,
0.1578598619,
0.3984164,
-0.1758820266,
-0.9828143716,
0.1892511696,
-0.0680501312,
0.9532237649,
-0.8189437985,
-0.4405941069,
0.2419361025,
-0.3136514425,
-0.2464786917,
-0.1649123281,
0.2899119258,
-0.3827165365,
0.3214418292,
-0.1323081553,
-0.6153530478,
0.1386067718,
0.1634450406,
-0.3260112107,
0.3964172602,
-0.0885422155,
-0.9730588794,
0.2959163189,
-0.5377268791,
-0.320625186,
-0.1876429915,
-0.2272669077,
-0.5977948904,
0.2216798663,
0.6221172214,
0.3219222426,
-0.248409301,
0.0915597081,
-0.4912973046,
-0.0252047163,
0.2736327052,
-0.323600471,
0.5133843422,
0.2509386241,
-0.0715153962,
0.0318595693,
-0.9285680652,
0.3390252292,
0.2515393198,
-0.1503941715,
-0.2023236156,
0.172357291,
-0.0251385756,
0.4630603492,
0.0849443898,
-0.7498256564,
-0.0955380574,
-0.6501713991,
0.121863991,
0.8168343902,
0.2440614551,
0.2220770717,
-0.0859520361,
0.5165191889,
0.3314085305,
-0.0443851091,
-0.8659437299,
-0.239897579,
-0.5880796313,
0.02152366,
0.2085883915,
0.5955879688,
-0.7170261741,
0.5166332126,
-0.0583248287,
-0.0458902642,
-0.5927357078,
-0.2476537377,
0.5822486281,
0.2711645663,
0.3692486584,
-0.2714020908,
-0.8668359518,
-0.8408197761,
-0.2990159094,
-0.4487951994,
-0.1437918246,
0.3409818411,
0.1798668206,
0.1438952535,
0.9555417299,
-0.5151184201,
-0.165775001,
-0.4229350388,
0.3190320134,
-0.2546045184,
0.3725978732,
0.1771187931,
-0.7153655887,
-0.362980932,
-0.0968781039,
-0.3452076614,
-0.1985039264,
-0.1697321236,
-0.0446937233,
0.1654374301,
0.1284745336,
-0.364416182,
0.4752158821,
0.5332866311,
0.0209893323,
0.0618286692,
-0.2733730674,
0.3302604556,
-1.609749794,
-0.0608035624,
0.0654189959,
-0.2553091943,
-0.6856257915,
-0.3926152289,
-0.2333472222,
-0.2939715683,
-0.4135112464,
0.359048903,
-0.5921022296,
-0.1024911851,
-0.214831233,
0.22081016,
-0.3070891201,
0.8710267544,
0.3057731688,
0.5352264643,
0.2121130824,
-0.5941890478,
0.1109531522,
0.4044325054,
0.0376342684,
0.8153679967,
-0.4890476763,
0.720754981,
-0.3150260448,
0.3557240069,
-1.1323010921,
-0.2511289418,
0.227549389,
-0.4368382096,
0.5443713069,
-0.015167336,
-0.1868613958,
-0.5135716796,
-0.1624329686,
0.4172497094,
0.4670431912,
-0.4232557118,
0.8495170474,
0.5856872797,
-0.5252501369,
-0.5223600268,
-0.0651543438,
-0.0829057246,
-0.1457566917,
-0.605794251,
0.0440495908,
-0.3005855083,
-0.0493438318,
-0.4165790677,
-0.0179166328,
-0.0848908573,
-0.2001173347,
0.2834706604,
-0.0241308846,
0.0177073013,
-0.1385099739,
-0.0156591479,
-0.3360055983,
0.250782311,
0.0271335486,
0.5764071941,
-0.033792071,
-0.3921292126,
-0.5807461143,
0.7751892209,
0.0884636194,
-0.5508056879,
0.5368218422,
0.3992675245,
-0.1525489688,
0.0287633184,
-0.7579624653,
-0.4352554679,
-0.4533869028,
0.6694844365,
-0.7209514976,
-0.5632279515,
0.4050349593,
-0.3889293671,
0.3212586045,
-0.013077911,
0.5377990603,
-0.0609168671,
1.6186528206,
0.5143560767,
0.1630252004,
0.5853883624,
0.1301967353,
0.3575853109,
-0.8654929399,
-0.2666213214,
-0.7293218374,
0.0343693048,
-0.4757497609,
0.0675870329,
0.1707670987,
-0.3447246552,
-0.2365429699,
0.179974705,
-0.2238520682,
0.3095550537,
0.4655311704,
0.1152290851,
-0.0639367178,
0.1261596233,
0.0401577167,
-0.1227365285,
-0.6851670742,
-0.4166086316,
1.0341970921,
0.3708644509,
0.6731143594,
-0.1682481915,
1.070877552,
-0.262886107,
0.2543863952,
-0.4255450368,
0.6587181091,
0.3201766312,
-0.3121055365,
-0.2269075066,
-0.5835487247,
-0.9697158933,
0.3361423314,
-0.1418751776,
-0.7857657075,
0.041466549,
0.2872940004,
-0.4069347084,
0.0726683214,
-0.70398736,
0.5980283618,
0.0652166158,
-0.1117606983,
0.0409067422,
-1.0685493946,
0.108209312,
-0.0345555171,
0.2607408166,
-0.0726127476,
0.3281207681,
0.7612478733,
-0.5288146734,
0.6822624207,
-0.6413226724,
0.123473987,
0.5573731065,
-0.1296142042,
0.7858703732,
0.0528467074,
0.2912576497,
-0.2540468574,
-0.2220405638,
-0.3076657951,
-0.3600670695,
0.2067092061,
-0.6390891671,
-0.731846869,
-0.1080750749,
-0.425381422,
-0.5788733363,
-0.0662842393,
0.4781241119,
0.3951820433,
-0.4321689606,
-0.0613904409,
0.6520594954,
-0.3457483649,
0.5842952132,
0.3976085186,
-0.061059352,
-0.4952428043,
0.7587563992,
-0.178181082,
0.2833354473,
0.3762263656,
-0.0777363926,
-0.3137308359,
-0.2454351485,
-0.1804142296,
0.0016965393,
-0.3407919109,
-0.2268172204,
-0.906722486,
-0.0715832412,
-0.3869684935,
0.2036884278,
-0.4841456711,
-0.2131833732,
0.0970776826,
-0.1159302592,
-0.1891505122,
0.4325658977,
-0.059783902,
0.3701562583,
-0.8006973267,
0.2043888718,
0.3844763637,
0.0741933137,
-0.2581914067,
-0.210711658,
-0.1415903419,
0.4162740409,
-0.434238106,
-1.1750183105,
0.3445667624,
0.3797647655,
0.6278631687,
0.2710509002,
0.2916404605,
0.4824666679,
-0.9214277864,
0.5906682611,
0.5408300757,
-0.651881814,
1.081766367,
-0.056148313,
0.1103746295,
0.4174506068,
0.0337334536,
-0.1107448861,
-0.6742389202,
-0.7529042959,
-1.1468603611,
0.9364472628,
0.372398138,
0.4008946717,
-0.3040808439,
-0.0822216868,
0.0524155758,
0.4143626988,
-0.4430672228,
-0.2859354019,
-0.143854633,
-0.1095908731,
0.0217090789,
-0.3212765753,
-0.2468435466,
0.3496159613,
0.6859429479,
-0.1642508656,
0.7960872054,
0.0244565029,
-0.0237927698,
-0.3691608906,
0.6201767921,
0.6387827396,
0.50454247,
-0.3990354836,
-0.1691074222,
0.1228387803,
-0.1528600305,
0.384763509,
0.2682737112,
0.3720172942,
-0.0318452492,
-0.0573263504,
0.9684795737,
-0.2490317225,
-0.3068940341,
0.791264236,
-0.4116369486,
-0.2749291658,
-0.3501411974,
-0.1480332315,
-0.1151934341,
0.2167849392,
0.3190662265,
0.0958848521,
0.1581325829,
-0.3192132711,
0.3117387593,
0.3963684142,
-0.0820410326,
-0.3841853738,
0.7775301933,
0.4087610841,
-0.4449192882,
0.7069013119,
-0.1102829725,
-0.3967241347,
0.6428157091,
0.7838152051,
1.1313726902,
-0.6967425346,
0.172655493,
0.5891183019,
0.1456726938,
0.3314877748,
0.1927685142,
0.0503049456,
-0.7668850422,
-0.4602308571,
-0.5072149634,
-0.3789840043,
0.0109987762,
-0.9530640841,
0.0045224195,
-0.2941371202,
-0.466724515,
-0.0582172386,
-0.1888191551,
-1.1403508186,
0.2765479386,
0.2494985014,
0.4966644943,
-0.7688751817,
0.5942215919,
0.728050828,
-0.5196034908,
-1.0162168741,
-0.0136012761,
-0.3480345607,
-0.6462678313,
0.6375912428,
0.4185860157,
-0.0815977082,
0.2244809717,
-0.3780686557,
-0.4358624518,
0.6565012336,
0.370474577,
-0.9239112735,
-0.2051148862,
0.042869214,
0.3564329445,
-0.8502582908,
0.8067600727,
0.2347565591,
0.187834695,
0.2071303278,
-0.704782486,
-0.0360720083,
-0.3860784471,
0.4716659188,
0.4708989859,
-0.6639635563,
0.6707532406,
-0.3262859583,
-0.0887169018,
-0.0648756251,
0.6953318119,
0.2921583951,
0.3666886091,
0.6677860022,
0.5940253735,
0.4716407061,
-0.1866534501,
1.0488214493,
-0.3882947862,
0.3513942063,
1.3424633741,
-0.6204533577,
0.9013086557,
0.5003307462,
-0.1803246886,
0.1985311955,
0.6514454484,
0.3495544195,
0.7272052169,
0.3403877914,
-0.4147252738,
-0.4537548721,
-0.0458820798,
-0.4762305617,
0.2369904071,
0.449498862,
-0.2796297967,
-0.1791328937,
0.2262794226,
-0.2429789454,
-0.0913210735,
-0.0890663117,
1.1136574745,
-0.0226869378,
-0.6408916116,
0.2324041128,
-0.3528233171,
0.2846085131,
-0.4466701746,
-0.3010047078,
-0.2864350677,
0.0201401934,
-0.0228916928,
-0.3877275288,
-0.1316278428,
-0.0860444531,
-0.055641409,
-0.0939998552,
0.5275955796,
-0.6256913543,
-0.2582414448,
0.2566297054,
0.5395359993,
0.1643086523,
0.0442897379,
-0.5097110271,
-0.2354042381,
0.0917952731,
-0.816562891,
0.4121391475,
0.5048745871,
0.3834572434,
0.481516093,
0.4497078955,
-0.0248462446,
0.132087633,
0.1779355705,
0.8780287504,
-0.1972422004,
-0.7230691314,
-0.6236070991,
0.7094103098,
-0.178457588,
-0.0148954224,
0.2553744912,
0.4332583845,
0.8830637336,
0.0754276738,
0.9438755512,
-0.0397934467,
0.6210466623,
-0.3664943576,
0.0354721136,
-0.3776475787,
0.2348519713,
-0.3489521146,
-1.3687033653,
0.0636104271,
0.8860253096,
-0.1412336379,
0.4864990115,
0.7192785144,
0.7854087949,
0.2536222637,
0.1497086287,
0.3843061626,
0.0206762347,
0.4000959694,
1.0914824009,
1.0062940121,
-0.3962828517,
0.69118011,
-0.1462503672,
-0.1078171954,
-0.0999364033,
-0.780592382,
-1.082224369,
-0.617493093,
-0.3882620037,
-0.3759933412,
0.2308196425,
1.3185120821,
0.6717964411,
-0.7626675367,
-0.0002661142,
-0.0492537245,
-0.4013290405,
0.0252442192,
-0.1501010656,
0.0681343526,
-0.6946520209,
-1.0136719942,
0.1697480828,
0.1533646435,
0.1007198393,
0.1329403222,
-0.1933151186,
-0.1821270883,
0.2207581103,
0.346807152,
0.1936977357,
-0.4590267241,
-0.318168968,
-0.1896471679,
-0.0625407398,
0.2895304859,
0.8831136823,
-0.5788469911,
0.6864326596,
0.1140478253,
0.8104346991,
0.5975203514,
0.08842998,
0.9343917966,
-1.2080680132,
0.2145759016,
0.3648019433,
0.2485820204,
0.0864689201,
-0.3477289379,
0.327930063,
-0.117917344,
-0.7593232393,
-0.6980844736,
0.4660544693,
-0.7598977685,
0.0249982476,
0.8997305632,
-0.485596031,
-0.005219108,
0.1795112044,
-0.404196173,
0.4547618926,
-0.7324028611,
0.2726955116,
0.6184713244,
-0.1587930322,
-0.401308924,
-0.4630877376,
0.2696480453,
0.5667615533,
-1.0958082676,
-0.0283058882,
0.5986942649,
-0.0044588507,
0.2233374566,
1.0751849413,
0.2996230423,
0.1131312326,
0.230787158,
0.2355261147,
-0.0606255308,
-0.5334802866,
0.0479736328,
0.3289771974,
0.0114483899,
-0.4889597595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12401v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12401v2 | WOT-Class: Weakly Supervised Open-world Text Classification | 2023-05-21T08:51:24 | 2023-11-22T23:56:43 | Tianle Wang, Zihan Wang, Weitang Liu, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art weakly supervised text classification methods, while
significantly reduced the required human supervision, still requires the
supervision to cover all the classes of interest. This is never easy to meet in
practice when human explore new, large corpora without complete pictures. In
this paper, we work on a novel yet important problem of weakly supervised
open-world text classification, where supervision is only needed for a few
examples from a few known classes and the machine should handle both known and
unknown classes in test time. General open-world classification has been
studied mostly using image classification; however, existing methods typically
assume the availability of sufficient known-class supervision and strong
unknown-class prior knowledge (e.g., the number and/or data distribution). We
propose a novel framework WOT-Class that lifts those strong assumptions.
Specifically, it follows an iterative process of (a) clustering text to new
classes, (b) mining and ranking indicative words for each class, and (c)
merging redundant classes by using the overlapped indicative words as a bridge.
Extensive experiments on 7 popular text classification datasets demonstrate
that WOT-Class outperforms strong baselines consistently with a large margin,
attaining 23.33% greater average absolute macro-F1 over existing approaches
across all datasets. Such competent accuracy illuminates the practical
potential of further reducing human effort for text classification. | [
-0.442802161,
-0.81370157,
0.416597873,
-0.2374822944,
-0.2225928307,
-0.2984554172,
-0.4565612078,
-0.7634063959,
-0.3746819198,
0.1423307806,
-0.2195196748,
-0.8435271382,
-0.6575700045,
-0.0113003626,
-0.5029847026,
1.3291788101,
0.0042408053,
-0.4902242124,
-0.1217328832,
-0.2344565839,
-0.0917495042,
-0.2432670742,
-0.2838938236,
-0.1590829641,
0.6891903281,
0.677100718,
0.8050615191,
0.3265583515,
0.6216064095,
0.3772419095,
-0.1531190276,
0.1634010822,
-0.4129846096,
-0.1660185456,
-0.3172037303,
-0.4015623033,
-0.3841739297,
-0.0921736583,
0.2441692948,
0.8440767527,
0.1880808175,
0.2568760216,
0.3374316692,
0.3512436152,
-0.8539430499,
0.295301497,
-0.5680216551,
0.2338657826,
-0.5458801985,
-0.0810083747,
-0.5233039856,
-0.0497742817,
0.4581411481,
-0.5976281762,
0.6119650602,
0.0876782686,
0.7025495172,
0.0713602901,
-0.6030511856,
0.0017771593,
-0.6522144675,
0.7188219428,
-0.2608498335,
0.1097422093,
0.3642773926,
0.1814825088,
-0.1336467266,
-0.7618333697,
-0.5115628839,
0.2754455209,
-0.076746352,
0.3152591288,
-0.177391544,
0.1963641196,
0.0589608401,
0.6376978755,
-0.3993065953,
0.2105766684,
-0.5640232563,
-0.1439700872,
0.2865595818,
-0.2001068741,
0.1456832439,
-0.1695189029,
-0.6098101735,
0.1212551594,
-0.2615400255,
-0.0257993042,
0.1060722321,
0.5611534119,
-0.185707286,
0.6569502354,
-0.1763105989,
0.5880515575,
-0.3821873069,
-0.3137219548,
0.1652513593,
0.2940432131,
-0.1138838157,
0.1017333791,
0.7470999956,
0.4576129317,
-0.0503748581,
-0.3387441933,
-0.1021489203,
0.3206003606,
0.1531062573,
-0.6355459094,
-0.1271251738,
0.002143143,
-0.6284874082,
-0.577041924,
0.2554169595,
-0.9049140215,
-0.1852933019,
-0.1234950349,
0.6325187087,
-0.1142429933,
-0.3279258907,
-0.0713797435,
-0.2260468304,
0.1104083583,
0.3882796764,
-0.7652060986,
0.3531348109,
0.4791512489,
1.0338642597,
-0.3312045038,
-0.300180614,
-0.4986265004,
0.242963776,
-0.1968097836,
1.0861347914,
-0.4259602427,
-0.1931201667,
0.1372170001,
0.0292782709,
0.4271208346,
-0.046783261,
0.9149733186,
-0.3818476796,
0.6119133234,
0.1478820443,
-0.4703002274,
-0.0945930481,
0.4333980083,
-0.523170054,
1.1631137133,
0.2936221659,
-1.3094375134,
0.5133676529,
-0.4493605494,
-0.5610900521,
0.1494582444,
0.0332706049,
-0.5425070524,
0.1336454451,
0.1067587063,
0.6059548259,
-0.3881257772,
0.0620398745,
-0.5184495449,
-0.8044016361,
-0.2874614596,
-0.4313445985,
0.3846140504,
-0.0025439879,
-0.4069907665,
-0.0742926672,
-0.7272399664,
0.2351628542,
-0.0079487478,
-0.1349954009,
-0.9406658411,
-0.2741163373,
0.4206536412,
0.0863572136,
0.2429004312,
-0.6407880187,
0.4937426746,
-0.3903326392,
0.2205842435,
0.8193063736,
0.0449773595,
0.7038345933,
-0.2785111666,
0.1650647223,
-0.2005869746,
0.1380185932,
-0.0381840058,
-0.7379233837,
-0.7537198663,
-0.3678234518,
0.3222113252,
0.4722037315,
-0.7232122421,
0.5201584101,
-0.1228456497,
-0.6246348023,
-0.2329932898,
0.0146464724,
0.3845835328,
0.4109068513,
0.5641258359,
0.1453209668,
-0.5458344817,
-0.8235936761,
-0.1899656057,
-0.3389498591,
-0.0891325176,
-0.0951234251,
0.308290422,
-0.4736869633,
0.7930564284,
-0.7441502213,
-0.8504903913,
-0.181653291,
0.3039380312,
0.0448937342,
0.3413928747,
0.0750970915,
-0.9840361476,
-0.3510472476,
0.1205474362,
-0.961073041,
0.095293954,
0.1572142094,
-0.2680843472,
0.1263449192,
0.7208015919,
-0.3489712179,
0.5910989046,
0.2549355328,
-0.0465016365,
0.1178172231,
-0.2830894589,
-0.1528762281,
-0.9297503829,
-0.1954929382,
0.2088562995,
-0.0951934829,
-0.2358375788,
0.0789028928,
0.0296557974,
-0.1850234717,
-0.4233317375,
0.6406329274,
-0.4717136919,
0.220843643,
-0.4936983287,
0.1567292362,
-0.3476248085,
0.6668132544,
0.1644393504,
0.1568015516,
0.8873556852,
-0.6850946546,
0.0925604925,
0.4252965152,
-0.1206769347,
0.6884878874,
-0.1795019507,
0.016107928,
-0.1658167839,
0.0667594522,
-0.811036706,
-0.2465607077,
-0.270606041,
-0.1358989924,
0.232363224,
-0.3122080564,
-0.5484739542,
-0.4997687936,
-0.1708038002,
0.2535439432,
0.7149046063,
-0.8983972073,
0.3427333236,
0.3952241242,
0.0698598251,
-0.4708615839,
-0.5957688689,
-0.0166396275,
-0.2068885565,
-0.2833937407,
0.580150187,
0.4253198206,
-0.1235957667,
0.3467350602,
-0.3731715679,
-0.3372086287,
-0.1650512367,
0.4219059646,
0.2122285366,
-0.152849108,
0.2704049945,
0.1294933856,
-0.305150032,
-0.3666546345,
-0.6164898872,
-0.0993831903,
-0.4127610028,
-0.3106467128,
-0.4058480561,
0.3153123856,
0.465511322,
0.109147042,
0.414516598,
0.8823279142,
-0.6684421301,
-0.5165944695,
-0.1837302744,
0.0105634714,
-0.4876169562,
0.3541228473,
-0.2536315024,
-0.857231617,
0.0053436654,
-0.2394863814,
0.2767197192,
0.3644813299,
0.2909601927,
-0.1104929894,
0.8745332956,
1.1219576597,
-0.1908330917,
0.3777540028,
-0.200460732,
0.1671526581,
-0.1670523286,
-0.2152511328,
-0.433293879,
-0.3515023589,
-0.9344901443,
-0.2414840609,
0.4070020318,
0.0573506542,
-0.0448664092,
0.302762568,
-0.5653460622,
0.6645531654,
0.586401701,
0.3528577089,
0.4931860566,
0.0993998572,
-0.0695767328,
-0.0840238705,
-0.5994731188,
-0.6085931659,
0.9765308499,
0.0283202939,
0.7557442188,
0.0580042191,
0.876609087,
0.4918581843,
0.6705098152,
-0.840636611,
0.5715962052,
-0.3805701733,
-0.4833067954,
-0.3608736992,
-0.373083204,
-0.8794948459,
0.4537694156,
-0.2710770071,
-0.4944494367,
-0.1612575799,
0.1839002669,
0.194331333,
0.7711019516,
-0.9440123439,
0.8976360559,
0.1075851619,
-0.7311966419,
0.1710461229,
-0.5694466829,
0.5111406446,
-0.0098055778,
0.5495628119,
-0.0199391507,
-0.1971684247,
0.5021606684,
-0.7183809876,
0.9470564127,
-0.3538786173,
-0.2123737037,
0.4717617333,
-0.2253355086,
0.486908257,
0.0391211957,
0.158205986,
-0.04736913,
-0.2420406193,
-0.7250204086,
-0.4709064066,
0.5486729741,
-0.4725490808,
-0.1745386571,
-0.6928716302,
-0.0317640454,
-0.4330719709,
0.3604111075,
0.6829203367,
0.5186024308,
-0.4603019655,
0.0702557266,
0.5690472722,
0.0664304644,
0.2915358245,
0.3579190075,
-0.1075105667,
-0.0991503298,
1.062897563,
-0.2246523052,
0.0105292071,
0.7299847603,
0.420217663,
-0.2504358888,
-0.515193224,
-0.210183382,
-0.2364124805,
-0.6092067957,
-0.50551337,
-0.6356110573,
0.0244808309,
-0.0268353149,
-0.3723949492,
-0.175370723,
-0.3274850547,
-0.0978409946,
-0.0396120884,
0.3897248805,
0.7082417011,
0.0342930108,
0.4763725102,
-0.75925529,
0.5487340093,
0.3981090486,
0.5730953813,
-0.0258253384,
-0.2998949885,
-0.0931164771,
-0.480328232,
-0.3756821156,
-0.6841725707,
0.0974148437,
0.3920345008,
0.4540974498,
0.5278196931,
0.5376774669,
0.5198203921,
-0.5451620221,
0.3739753962,
0.295860827,
-0.843419075,
0.4626064599,
-0.3649365604,
0.2050394863,
0.6567272544,
0.3995017707,
-0.4012556076,
-0.9343903065,
-0.8605337143,
-0.9802901745,
0.6945118904,
0.248143971,
-0.0912515521,
-0.0509245582,
0.0767160803,
0.3522464335,
-0.0511644781,
-0.9076223373,
-0.008924447,
-0.2293010205,
-0.5160921216,
0.1609452367,
0.173940897,
0.2204113901,
-0.0861157626,
0.7096503973,
-0.320512265,
0.2466635704,
0.2217334062,
-0.2582140863,
0.1089996696,
0.6051441431,
-0.176788941,
0.0314103812,
-0.3140491843,
0.7489410043,
0.3261978328,
-0.5623720288,
0.2584549487,
-0.1289251894,
-0.2023340613,
-0.0783279389,
0.5791653395,
0.1752568185,
0.4654120207,
-0.6529830694,
0.835462451,
-0.1237729266,
-0.3786410391,
-0.0906949788,
0.1486508548,
-0.3294026256,
0.1662520617,
0.4238338768,
0.4955649972,
0.3143703043,
-0.5548965335,
0.2063694447,
0.0914733857,
-0.6537792087,
-0.3593717515,
0.4532224536,
0.1690657139,
0.0713153407,
0.2377201915,
-0.6935955286,
-0.6641474962,
0.274033457,
0.5518243313,
0.6493988037,
0.214813292,
0.2161890417,
0.3766935766,
0.3348105848,
-0.6033420563,
0.140384689,
-0.2063753009,
-0.3489173651,
-0.1726225019,
-0.6043453813,
-0.5744072199,
0.1439222991,
-0.6920104623,
0.5440170765,
-0.3189642429,
-0.0347584076,
-0.1454487294,
-0.1967837214,
-0.587026298,
0.1890910566,
-0.0772154033,
0.6490172148,
-0.8658699989,
0.610046804,
0.7683596015,
-0.2266661227,
-0.2202851325,
0.4306142628,
-0.0020565505,
-0.3055287302,
0.403441608,
0.5629570484,
-0.0689493194,
0.0037430576,
-0.5945106149,
-0.4215497971,
0.5960706472,
0.0282582082,
-0.3643237948,
-0.1881109178,
-0.2614714205,
0.6710684896,
0.216719985,
-0.0191621985,
0.0466288738,
0.4904764593,
0.0172182824,
-0.6249520779,
0.0829768032,
-0.3628593683,
-0.2841717601,
0.4358555079,
-0.7534433603,
0.516420126,
-0.5505520105,
-0.2425906509,
0.0942879319,
0.8867611885,
-0.197331354,
0.5997874737,
0.7220801115,
0.5699424148,
0.8312026262,
-0.1270695478,
0.6778762937,
0.3844328225,
0.4248589277,
0.9992796779,
-0.2021153271,
0.9798308611,
0.0319744982,
-0.3938487768,
0.4075170457,
0.493119508,
-0.0156126805,
0.7056398988,
0.0398832075,
-0.429597199,
-0.3320419788,
0.0671091378,
-0.3751659393,
0.5897946954,
0.0767377242,
0.1365984082,
-0.5026604533,
0.4052303731,
-0.2531379759,
0.2774290442,
-0.4605874717,
0.7408590317,
0.0474593863,
-0.3852412403,
0.378218025,
0.2124227434,
1.130330801,
-0.3423116803,
0.059507452,
0.0982486233,
0.5638034344,
-0.4653948545,
-0.5676245689,
0.1585908234,
0.3359496891,
-0.1965684295,
-0.1445766985,
0.874430418,
-0.3427646458,
-0.4973928034,
0.3107652068,
0.5259148479,
0.1915823221,
-0.1662063599,
-0.1621082425,
-0.4721902013,
-0.2482410222,
0.010809035,
0.4104942679,
1.1019443274,
-0.2948440015,
0.1914404631,
0.5231392384,
-0.1442350149,
-0.1400615871,
-0.1253652126,
0.7419300079,
-0.7598674297,
-0.7181755304,
-0.5442274809,
0.1170538217,
-0.1277499795,
-0.4222065508,
0.6928426027,
0.8453130126,
0.8302839994,
0.0731817409,
1.1488953829,
-0.218804121,
0.5565127134,
-0.4639889002,
0.4451332092,
-0.6831141114,
-0.0820505172,
-0.7506068349,
-0.8325098157,
-0.3126461804,
0.5131698251,
-0.0576232113,
-0.148126632,
0.9329044819,
0.2771708071,
-0.4109534621,
0.4746883512,
0.2603788078,
0.0490978621,
0.1674279422,
0.4654951394,
0.8369673491,
-0.4955806136,
1.0153559446,
-0.2618121505,
-0.5080032945,
-0.098480016,
-0.8698279262,
-1.0848596096,
-0.6342546344,
-0.3078702092,
-0.1824545115,
-0.0265599545,
0.7482190728,
0.71422261,
-0.5729133487,
0.3359978497,
-0.3145658374,
0.2179156989,
-0.3123967946,
-0.2380315065,
0.5752034187,
-0.5641713142,
-0.7910641432,
0.1134874523,
0.1368142068,
0.4730211198,
0.0152113093,
0.3112349808,
0.1449848711,
-0.5285109282,
0.710236311,
0.3365499675,
-0.2819272876,
0.0011209623,
-0.0828045905,
-0.1655519605,
-0.0502002761,
0.7659426332,
-0.6337680221,
0.0594946668,
0.3017151058,
0.5924341679,
0.7386829257,
-0.1178637818,
0.0508936793,
-1.1449450254,
0.6462257504,
0.3072315753,
0.2415228933,
0.2101183236,
-0.2274119109,
0.4817702174,
0.4525644779,
-0.2702759504,
-0.9945380688,
0.0339392982,
-1.127300024,
-0.4938294888,
0.9784067273,
0.0381890126,
-0.2925563455,
-0.365903765,
-0.3498102129,
0.1620377451,
-0.4014856219,
0.7771288753,
0.4854460359,
0.0719999596,
0.1650341004,
-0.6102285385,
0.3516221941,
0.0243676528,
-1.1783722639,
0.135659799,
0.3619214594,
-0.0962340757,
0.1382202208,
0.5596280694,
-0.1351178288,
0.1074984893,
0.0867710561,
0.0415922552,
0.1316015273,
-0.4105188847,
0.2676261961,
0.717007339,
-0.1086978614,
-0.1500607431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12394v1 | Pruning Pre-trained Language Models with Principled Importance and Self-regularization | 2023-05-21T08:15:12 | 2023-05-21T08:15:12 | Siyu Ren, Kenny Q. Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Iterative pruning is one of the most effective compression methods for
pre-trained language models. We discovered that finding the optimal pruning
decision is an equality-constrained 0-1 Integer Linear Programming problem. The
solution to this optimization problem leads to a principled importance
criterion which we use to rank parameters during iterative model pruning. To
mitigate the poor generalization at high sparsity levels, we propose a
self-regularization scheme where model prediction is regularized by the latest
checkpoint with increasing sparsity throughout pruning. Our experiments on
natural language understanding, question-answering, named entity recognition,
and data-to-text generation with various Transformer-based PLMs show the
effectiveness of the approach at various sparsity levels. | [
-0.6562228203,
-0.5154542923,
0.4119914472,
0.5037170649,
-0.3791632056,
-0.3356725574,
-0.3514770865,
0.1649655402,
0.1105303615,
0.4580154121,
-0.4390114546,
-0.3946373761,
-0.5488997102,
-0.0165952444,
-0.4229165614,
1.0888589621,
0.2015623897,
-0.1410830468,
-0.0546433367,
0.0429445766,
-0.47464782,
-0.8247537017,
-0.4625762105,
0.0331480429,
0.2329841554,
0.2819052041,
0.6822052002,
0.8020491004,
0.6075332165,
0.2746556103,
-0.0538062826,
-0.3060597777,
-0.6817904115,
0.0653273016,
-0.0387546904,
-0.3407050073,
-0.0529515781,
0.1786935925,
0.9804316163,
0.9764904976,
-0.2609827518,
0.2025046647,
0.2097491026,
0.5879154205,
-0.4760239124,
-0.1784506291,
-0.4378339946,
0.0660066232,
-0.1692310721,
-0.3293381929,
-0.2423145771,
-0.4267562926,
-0.0492115989,
-0.2993229926,
0.5471855998,
0.046653185,
1.1244686842,
0.6652699709,
-0.0688838884,
0.1624108851,
-0.9725908637,
1.0154544115,
-0.8905756474,
0.4481532574,
0.4983120263,
0.1127729267,
0.0229230747,
-0.5921493769,
-0.2157112807,
-0.149418667,
-0.1149894074,
-0.0073869079,
0.1440506577,
0.5678158998,
0.2189614624,
0.7397158146,
-0.4979635477,
0.1054173186,
-0.6793838143,
-0.1492849886,
0.4566361904,
-0.2415686101,
0.2036229968,
-0.0926341489,
-0.3843893111,
-0.1496131867,
-0.7253936529,
0.1517651081,
0.3562018573,
0.1172941476,
0.5264223814,
0.3859579563,
-0.0448100977,
1.0226876736,
0.0096558686,
-0.2087691873,
-0.0785758644,
-0.4990362227,
-0.2763627768,
-0.2066713125,
0.6557450891,
0.091071099,
0.3446445465,
-0.3905024827,
-0.2597073019,
0.049796544,
0.398784101,
-0.8368896246,
-0.1788782328,
0.3105643988,
-0.6175224781,
-0.3657239676,
0.1886602789,
-0.6004291177,
0.3721177876,
-0.365576297,
0.4704967439,
-0.225063473,
-0.2809089124,
0.3742900193,
0.0793120489,
0.04146038,
0.1951704621,
-0.9319927096,
0.5455084443,
0.5902988911,
0.6718782783,
-0.080863215,
-0.2119309306,
-0.434359014,
0.0283909142,
-0.438080579,
0.6243473291,
-0.4897851646,
-0.2576550841,
-0.2875131369,
-0.1595776826,
-0.3123156428,
-0.3857730031,
0.8516519666,
-0.2623048723,
0.1978834271,
-0.0252354275,
-0.5783038735,
-0.1905467808,
0.1987113804,
-0.542224288,
1.0679006577,
0.1079085842,
-0.5469422936,
0.3056401312,
-0.4002883434,
-0.5067961216,
-0.036090672,
-0.1432625651,
-0.755379796,
0.5467882156,
0.1720327139,
0.5668775439,
-0.3870609105,
0.7120985985,
0.0350033715,
-0.1812539846,
-0.1485908031,
-0.2029769868,
0.551478982,
0.4237301946,
-0.2186919302,
0.1180660129,
-0.6167227626,
0.2500125468,
0.0668182373,
-0.4378969073,
-0.2837819159,
0.0492561981,
-0.1960976571,
0.3493673205,
0.1683452278,
-0.2440787852,
0.3763293922,
-0.672747612,
0.6330700517,
0.7038068771,
0.1315793246,
0.5808278918,
-0.191771552,
0.6189537644,
-0.1496495456,
0.3369677663,
-0.0872894973,
-0.3758840561,
-1.1183496714,
-0.1499011219,
0.7061218023,
0.3109731972,
-0.1700419337,
0.8230521083,
-0.2769854367,
-0.1699021906,
-0.6693401933,
0.2636162937,
0.3589408696,
0.2444590032,
0.4083509147,
-0.4637319148,
-0.4264101684,
-0.9016343355,
-0.117289938,
-0.0128670307,
-0.0085455785,
0.0075228228,
0.1780983955,
-0.0134196095,
1.0844680071,
-0.2142095119,
-0.4296934307,
-0.3018466532,
0.4279469848,
0.2138436437,
0.8811711669,
0.4227878749,
-0.8584629893,
-0.3797523379,
-0.4660803974,
-0.2748355865,
-0.13975811,
-0.2501491308,
0.0980769694,
-0.3079693019,
0.4730808437,
-0.4167674184,
0.4581458867,
0.4848240912,
0.0126721272,
0.1004097611,
-0.3297175467,
0.0428462327,
-0.8754237294,
-0.048730053,
0.0721843913,
-0.3904910386,
-0.936165452,
-0.0542289503,
-0.1026029065,
-0.5566810369,
0.0852041468,
0.2536544502,
-0.7769876719,
-0.2710778415,
-0.1488508582,
-0.0646143854,
-0.074859269,
0.5321819186,
0.267683208,
0.693793416,
0.4988546371,
-0.8442925215,
-0.328201592,
-0.0773311257,
-0.1426021308,
-0.1307832152,
-0.7244908214,
0.1620964557,
-0.3772404194,
-0.2786876559,
-1.0254995823,
0.3178469539,
-0.2011021674,
-0.3982203901,
0.5604771376,
-0.3210070729,
-0.2670706511,
-0.389111191,
-0.2945957482,
0.4329460859,
0.5806070566,
-0.3975959122,
0.3979738057,
0.4565730989,
-0.2452330887,
-0.4165872633,
-0.3961411417,
0.05291095,
-0.3034006655,
-0.6405534148,
0.4887375236,
-0.2446808368,
-0.0034034112,
-0.2081900835,
-0.3331002295,
-0.1907354295,
0.3883016407,
0.0469629876,
0.0042674788,
-0.1108293608,
0.0473348573,
-0.0075759436,
-0.5439012051,
-0.1485513449,
-0.4706308544,
0.7250283957,
-0.1006861851,
-0.2609964311,
-0.3356798589,
0.3149493337,
0.2081363797,
-0.4573836923,
0.6332437396,
0.3232459724,
-0.320743531,
-0.1217571497,
-0.8700742722,
-0.3726599216,
-0.4605951905,
0.1207842454,
-0.4262052178,
-0.929033041,
0.1351858824,
-0.3560802042,
0.0845904872,
0.3645196855,
0.2502099574,
0.0172350183,
1.2023605108,
0.8982091546,
-0.3333105147,
0.5245684981,
-0.3190140128,
0.454285264,
-0.4788187146,
0.3740801215,
-0.8024405241,
-0.1291667968,
-0.3680514395,
-0.5058946609,
0.2449209094,
0.6183112264,
0.1820261627,
0.3354771137,
-0.8956956267,
0.5113499761,
0.6188243628,
-0.1659891903,
0.22018224,
0.1469962597,
0.1868880838,
-0.3296131492,
-0.9044172168,
-0.5226204395,
0.9110963941,
0.6380932331,
0.7256883383,
-0.1279622167,
0.9259369969,
0.000641598,
0.2710976303,
-0.7204127908,
0.3251170516,
0.0234156176,
-0.6122921109,
-0.578006506,
-0.4815428853,
-0.9249667525,
0.2336512506,
-0.0059020226,
-0.7118448019,
0.3603856266,
0.3816050589,
-0.4518205822,
-0.085765399,
-0.6372277141,
0.9078157544,
-0.28761971,
-0.1450936198,
-0.4056866467,
-0.708959341,
0.1734556854,
0.2063897252,
0.2735117972,
0.0690199733,
-0.0046537207,
0.9395881295,
-0.6025215983,
0.6680910587,
-0.2945079505,
0.2050402611,
0.1510927379,
0.2003399283,
0.4239974618,
-0.0946420059,
0.066117309,
0.1888763011,
-0.050460685,
-0.3514392674,
-0.5698900819,
0.5323104858,
-0.7134850025,
-0.9287161827,
-0.3016386628,
-0.2768766582,
-0.0895956531,
0.1501216739,
0.358477056,
0.4264521003,
-0.1282344311,
0.3691151738,
0.8673993945,
0.0267453659,
0.4314192533,
0.4140024185,
-0.0308381896,
-0.3718698919,
1.1930260658,
0.4375415444,
0.3640656471,
0.3562051952,
0.289195478,
0.0512362346,
-1.0066208839,
-0.1391507983,
0.3019681573,
-0.5964755416,
-0.1894061714,
-0.6563886404,
-0.4582054019,
-0.6460250616,
-0.2394088358,
-0.5625835061,
-0.687399745,
-0.1573154926,
-0.187884897,
-0.0726039261,
0.5712630749,
-0.2185279429,
0.484559685,
-0.7731875181,
0.4624983966,
0.3147797585,
0.3411771357,
-0.34953475,
-0.495736748,
-0.1095078811,
-0.3428967297,
-0.086252816,
-0.8405062556,
0.703361392,
0.5087734461,
0.8290445209,
0.673224628,
0.0458297133,
0.6298718452,
-0.4259666204,
0.4522729516,
0.0986014232,
-0.7636404634,
0.7640342712,
-0.0676440895,
0.0835237131,
0.7585963011,
0.5048731565,
-0.3973922729,
-0.3185402155,
-0.855522275,
-0.8520427346,
0.6239955425,
0.5297453403,
-0.1175814793,
0.0172662903,
0.5067666769,
-0.0420080796,
0.4353510737,
-1.0312540531,
-0.2876918614,
-0.4156383872,
-0.3107447922,
-0.1170801446,
-0.74950701,
-0.1827658266,
-0.3393367231,
0.6565979123,
0.0096382704,
0.2614471316,
0.344338268,
-0.3248036206,
0.0593052879,
0.368134886,
0.3219625354,
0.5451641679,
-0.214192614,
0.0542541705,
-0.0746928006,
-0.3820860386,
0.148216933,
0.1859331578,
-0.3346240222,
-0.0231488906,
-0.0540877841,
0.7308599353,
0.2247225344,
-0.1689811647,
0.5084529519,
-0.0850503221,
0.0546309985,
-0.130348742,
-0.0428844579,
-0.2086646408,
-0.2800923884,
0.3395731151,
-0.0674873069,
0.3008911014,
-0.2169431895,
0.0575979464,
0.4340357184,
-0.2809875011,
-0.2360802144,
0.4190184772,
0.326061666,
-0.328594178,
0.4651263952,
-0.098962903,
-0.6853590012,
0.5667788386,
0.558668077,
0.7413431406,
-0.5711821318,
0.054777842,
0.7558719516,
0.6801207662,
-0.4313617349,
0.018720204,
-0.574424386,
-0.6765233278,
-0.4894928038,
-0.6593081355,
-0.0604966395,
0.0277946275,
-0.5956817865,
0.3433182538,
-0.709505856,
-0.1657674015,
-0.2542112172,
-0.1234807596,
-0.419626385,
0.4337289929,
-0.2127705663,
0.6170158982,
-0.8461971879,
0.8972901106,
0.2748793364,
-0.5632433891,
-0.7553840876,
-0.0881114379,
-0.3451042175,
-0.4664052129,
0.6869795918,
0.3367374241,
0.1589239836,
0.6125635505,
-0.5575366616,
-1.2413152456,
0.7950828075,
0.370569557,
-0.7315872908,
-0.1769929081,
0.0386330001,
0.2504627705,
-0.1335746944,
0.0781332403,
0.5340299606,
0.4801197648,
-0.1382155865,
-0.8659202456,
-0.1955839694,
-0.2631008029,
0.2534629703,
0.4937547445,
-0.5955830812,
0.7531251907,
-0.0295195449,
-0.5199435353,
-0.021724578,
0.6220818162,
0.0277381018,
-0.1829602122,
0.7183517218,
0.8408035636,
0.5371074677,
-0.1560343057,
0.8692817688,
-0.605594337,
0.5308851004,
0.8897675276,
0.1466253847,
0.4042937458,
0.5015885234,
-0.2097696811,
0.0336059444,
0.7145690918,
0.075257495,
0.504914701,
0.2726151049,
0.012250388,
-0.4822726846,
0.012693868,
-0.4155472815,
-0.1067368835,
0.4932774603,
-0.2319644094,
-0.2368173897,
0.0798572451,
-0.0348693468,
0.0499366112,
-0.1543774456,
0.8236342072,
0.0159086399,
-0.8188540339,
0.75406003,
0.0759135783,
0.6775747538,
-0.6326721907,
-0.0194663107,
-0.0687312782,
-0.0043230611,
-0.1610150784,
-0.3666503429,
0.2324184775,
-0.3627743423,
-0.1797096729,
-0.6887590289,
1.0062673092,
-0.4153281152,
-0.4478697777,
0.0588444807,
0.2460073829,
0.3153118789,
-0.2763991356,
-0.6252574921,
-0.0043469523,
0.0352988802,
-0.510050416,
0.4656711221,
0.1673562974,
0.0246475283,
0.8446428776,
0.4372349381,
0.1917057782,
0.0961903185,
0.219693318,
1.012929678,
-0.6739555001,
-0.5237591863,
-0.6276928782,
0.4616071284,
-0.1691545993,
-0.1502581835,
0.8342859149,
0.4770356119,
0.6459168196,
0.1440515071,
0.5638887286,
-0.0346897729,
0.6078457236,
-0.4567823112,
0.3204139173,
-0.2717675269,
0.2859646082,
-0.1502325535,
-0.9300224781,
-0.32230407,
1.0457489491,
-0.4693662226,
0.1014229283,
0.6610993743,
0.7926715016,
0.0401309729,
-0.2370632887,
0.4990172386,
0.0583499484,
0.2048632652,
0.1939187646,
0.5387819409,
-0.354736656,
0.5609201193,
-0.6085115075,
-0.3346456587,
-0.0050175544,
-0.759363234,
-0.8817172647,
-0.7862201929,
-0.4199751616,
-0.1686912328,
0.004554607,
0.8205938935,
1.1224483252,
-0.7281749845,
-0.2500698268,
-0.5589615107,
0.0121666864,
-0.0609403029,
-0.264921546,
0.2006845325,
-0.8050398231,
-0.5850858688,
0.3929572701,
0.4624401033,
0.0834964961,
-0.5583844185,
0.1003388315,
-0.302215755,
-0.2223388255,
0.2369128019,
0.4536656737,
-0.4995045662,
-0.0419593975,
-0.2086259723,
0.1105346233,
0.181669265,
1.2438668013,
-0.7448601127,
0.3520952165,
0.5067121983,
0.6611710191,
0.6663432121,
0.3826452196,
0.9441512823,
-0.8697710037,
0.4700220227,
0.4870942831,
0.3032879233,
0.3225223124,
-0.39518556,
0.6567580104,
0.1404493153,
-0.7707768679,
-0.8256310821,
0.110682413,
-0.6515841484,
-0.3130500913,
1.0501521826,
-0.1692675799,
-0.3112542033,
-0.1713289768,
-0.3063575625,
0.0320840217,
-0.2579587698,
0.7539429665,
0.6048573256,
0.159675464,
-0.4203825891,
-0.4945813119,
0.681270659,
0.7453970909,
-0.724380672,
-0.0012126623,
0.3966254592,
0.1123847961,
0.2736929655,
0.7887780666,
-0.0414513014,
-0.0032577487,
-0.3202271163,
0.1313963979,
0.1922226399,
-0.5215036273,
-0.4931700826,
0.2572860718,
0.536316216,
-0.0773433894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12392v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12392v3 | PiVe: Prompting with Iterative Verification Improving Graph-based Generative Capability of LLMs | 2023-05-21T08:11:24 | 2024-05-30T13:23:24 | Jiuzhou Han, Nigel Collier, Wray Buntine, Ehsan Shareghi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown great abilities of solving various
natural language tasks in different domains. Due to the training objective of
LLMs and their pre-training data, LLMs are not very well equipped for tasks
involving structured data generation. We propose a framework, Prompting with
Iterative Verification (PiVe), to improve graph-based generative capability of
LLMs. We show how a small language model could be trained to act as a verifier
module for the output of an LLM~(i.e., ChatGPT, GPT-4), and to iteratively
improve its performance via fine-grained corrective instructions. We also show
how the verifier module could apply iterative corrections offline for a more
cost-effective solution to the text-to-graph generation task. Experiments on
three graph-based datasets show consistent improvement gained via PiVe.
Additionally, we create GenWiki-HIQ and highlight that the verifier module can
be used as a data augmentation tool to help improve the quality of
automatically generated parallel text-graph datasets. | [
-0.2335220277,
-0.9534255862,
0.5267828107,
0.0786096454,
-0.2302515805,
0.2213216126,
-0.4589484036,
0.0313386209,
-0.1698154807,
0.4873774946,
-0.5708283186,
-0.786313951,
-0.6139722466,
0.3942442536,
-0.4197288454,
0.749102354,
-0.2286847085,
-0.0313316137,
-0.5451449156,
0.2829365134,
-0.6061064005,
-0.2866047621,
-0.8315590024,
-0.529170692,
0.3393322825,
0.5965986252,
0.335352093,
0.4937783182,
0.2540159523,
0.4118693173,
0.026934661,
0.6200705171,
-0.8616966605,
0.1988295615,
-0.1047253311,
-0.4143131673,
-0.3318150043,
-0.2355867177,
0.7830495834,
0.6210348606,
0.1347251832,
0.0052743116,
0.1722483337,
0.7705674171,
-0.2531447113,
0.4052794874,
-0.6439980865,
-0.2880272567,
-0.2981683314,
-0.3850549757,
-0.693221271,
-0.5090045929,
-0.3106588125,
-0.6154592633,
0.4177184701,
0.3041935861,
1.0998747349,
0.2602597475,
-0.2720096409,
-0.1843082011,
-0.7118006349,
0.2534184754,
-0.5140715241,
0.2824889123,
0.5741415024,
0.2519386411,
-0.3852695823,
-1.0272437334,
-0.8042391539,
-0.4012132883,
-0.0992503911,
0.0387189686,
-0.232848987,
0.0880270004,
0.4682120383,
0.6456464529,
-0.5309032202,
0.2415764332,
-0.4498258233,
-0.3575468659,
0.4422360957,
0.116499491,
0.2386996895,
-0.1616971642,
-0.1085670367,
-0.2028005421,
-1.2401790619,
0.0821262076,
0.5290010571,
0.3725783825,
0.0471517742,
0.9872354269,
-0.4497723281,
0.9221711159,
0.098802641,
0.1135457978,
0.2957719266,
-0.5050176978,
-0.0580786578,
-0.1457949579,
0.9381309748,
0.2537274659,
0.3836295605,
0.0530854464,
-0.0410426445,
0.1146646813,
0.1531338692,
-0.7994299531,
-0.4090438485,
0.2829682827,
-0.0260725319,
-0.1781257242,
-0.049939163,
-0.5066534281,
-0.3371510506,
-0.1228290349,
0.3918693364,
-0.6962703466,
-0.040998783,
0.1752143949,
-0.0040601203,
0.0621320792,
0.4718019366,
-0.7181676626,
0.0137987761,
0.7570177317,
0.7711382508,
-0.0082890196,
-0.3498868644,
-0.9042907953,
0.1849078536,
-0.3770484626,
0.9769899845,
-0.4362947345,
-0.4365070462,
0.0498405881,
0.082339026,
-0.2935818732,
-0.36707443,
0.4561777115,
-0.4025966227,
0.4342090487,
-0.2913607359,
-0.9629135132,
-0.0392358452,
0.5773581862,
-0.5584173203,
1.3825092316,
0.2949127257,
-0.8598992229,
0.2627717257,
-0.5613604188,
-0.4817794561,
0.3896494806,
-0.4270133674,
-0.7240297794,
-0.0739399567,
0.4298444986,
0.3969471753,
-0.3073678315,
0.0354451947,
-0.1649459153,
-0.2992290258,
0.1311166584,
-0.3207224309,
0.706646204,
-0.1336838454,
-0.1020392329,
0.3421606421,
-0.7923161387,
0.1513679028,
0.204817608,
-0.4375701547,
0.0473402031,
-0.0815402195,
-0.4473411739,
-0.2306253612,
0.0667849556,
-0.5934940577,
0.5031063557,
-0.550290823,
0.5283243656,
0.6693019867,
0.2162099183,
0.390450269,
-0.2904239893,
0.46098575,
-0.3890909851,
-0.0108982557,
-0.5326822996,
-0.6983188391,
-0.7786582708,
-0.5508666635,
0.4311861694,
0.480394572,
-1.1995577812,
0.3894572258,
-0.3059844971,
-0.3354200721,
-0.1846806705,
0.3059142828,
0.1738468558,
0.8021763563,
0.1270329803,
-0.0615295358,
-0.3490391672,
-0.2318426818,
0.2052000165,
-0.5102985501,
-0.125642404,
0.2538818121,
0.2968548834,
-0.2902916074,
1.0169795752,
-0.3498926163,
-0.2584495842,
-0.2704691589,
0.1600136757,
0.1365712434,
0.3415007889,
0.2788870633,
-0.4807716906,
-0.5754756331,
0.1490137875,
-0.5150081515,
-0.3952940106,
0.1459697783,
-0.0509334281,
0.0701530576,
0.607488513,
-0.4733016491,
0.3788594306,
0.6324939728,
-0.1256888509,
0.3883868754,
-0.52156353,
0.2847903073,
-0.9451695085,
0.0051220795,
-0.4399810433,
-0.6545706391,
-0.5649380088,
-0.184191972,
0.1373488009,
-0.1826644987,
-0.2145243138,
0.5405516028,
-0.4376163781,
0.0637160987,
-0.3957254291,
0.3153402507,
0.2360803932,
0.1568908989,
-0.1031325236,
0.9359489083,
0.839286685,
-0.7557805181,
0.6343404651,
0.3767044246,
-0.2685314715,
0.6040821075,
-0.678371191,
0.250349015,
-0.3143157363,
0.3100461662,
-1.2606842518,
-0.4161088467,
0.5835386515,
-0.4999086261,
0.3307510316,
-0.181198746,
-0.7467483878,
-0.6360903382,
-0.1731607914,
0.1543486863,
0.4224259555,
-0.6932225227,
0.6184259653,
-0.067010425,
-0.2152510881,
-0.282874167,
-0.2901751995,
0.1052783132,
0.0431320295,
-0.7997736931,
0.3366714418,
-0.2080710679,
0.0258673877,
-0.131683439,
0.2362311035,
0.181196928,
-0.0424821042,
0.3293181956,
0.3382797241,
-0.0391887166,
0.3007846177,
0.0458139665,
-0.4854717851,
-0.276758939,
-0.4684196413,
0.7091456056,
-0.1448635161,
-0.7653801441,
-0.4862211347,
0.178892985,
0.0936832204,
-0.2921743989,
0.31863451,
0.480550319,
-0.2321217954,
-0.1961568594,
-0.4145448208,
-0.2341694236,
-0.5292016268,
0.148186177,
-0.4091497362,
-1.1911001205,
0.3432781696,
-0.5356698036,
-0.1506065279,
0.4694221318,
0.8564502597,
-0.2371556759,
0.8430854678,
0.6518032551,
0.0633965284,
0.4941087365,
-0.3134086728,
0.2002109289,
-0.4107838571,
-0.3140018582,
-0.7068773508,
0.1836007535,
-0.4846275449,
-0.5728090405,
0.3565716743,
0.1478091478,
-0.0800655559,
0.246760875,
-0.5105065107,
0.5659710765,
0.3771586418,
0.2102878839,
0.460083276,
0.2660506368,
-0.140013814,
0.1381554753,
-0.8289268017,
-0.6031878591,
0.8220044971,
0.2150640786,
0.7086775303,
-0.1103270948,
0.6458573341,
0.2958962619,
0.4174300134,
-0.6959109902,
0.4016491473,
-0.1583779156,
-0.2254696041,
-0.2973605096,
-0.516797483,
-0.838285923,
-0.2821058333,
-0.0714908689,
-0.7880905271,
0.0166991521,
0.6237828732,
-0.1376191825,
-0.083845377,
-0.4873634875,
0.794773519,
-0.1123951301,
-0.2547683418,
-0.0627828687,
-0.220709309,
0.1254174262,
0.0232205,
-0.0625346527,
-0.2016829848,
0.0916533694,
0.1976056546,
-0.8248484135,
0.993239224,
-0.145033583,
-0.3336352706,
0.3817460239,
-0.1160859391,
1.0984237194,
0.1503109932,
-0.2512917817,
-0.0365794376,
-0.4103284776,
-0.2280418873,
-0.4961283505,
0.5391758084,
-0.5142844915,
-0.6275838017,
-0.0326767601,
-0.3045288026,
-0.2953736186,
0.3190538287,
0.8681952953,
0.3080770373,
-0.016226083,
0.1461643875,
0.8983950019,
-0.0798347145,
0.1685461253,
0.1493533403,
-0.4337370694,
-0.4960431159,
0.9514992833,
-0.1497499496,
0.2969027758,
0.4224268496,
0.3183872402,
-0.3794157803,
-0.7021378279,
-0.7280187011,
0.1496265382,
-0.8184791207,
-0.4345890284,
-0.439563483,
-0.1884022504,
-0.2231421322,
-0.0189878922,
-0.4311676621,
-0.409868747,
-0.2197230458,
-0.0493390113,
0.8529382944,
0.7560384274,
0.1972365379,
0.6672322154,
-0.6424847245,
0.2076556236,
0.2627903521,
0.3804400563,
-0.4254966676,
-0.5558944345,
-0.0326636545,
-0.0370932817,
-0.0285221972,
-0.8343793154,
-0.0166857764,
0.3285007775,
0.5465273857,
0.3583714366,
0.0739355162,
0.5586048961,
-0.7313550115,
0.7240090966,
0.0983135477,
-1.0462348461,
0.6287837029,
-0.2905689776,
0.045940645,
0.5042045116,
0.1552111953,
-0.3253299594,
-0.6005579829,
-0.4208515882,
-0.8466169834,
0.4548753798,
0.4676193297,
0.3084403872,
0.038517531,
0.6135499477,
0.0881219134,
0.1512402445,
-0.6025335193,
-0.158279568,
-0.5166684985,
-0.1929111034,
0.0410473607,
-0.2336963117,
-0.1985409409,
-0.0353653617,
0.8525450826,
-0.5640040636,
0.2518611848,
0.0178965554,
-0.0530456193,
0.0041904217,
0.0993931517,
0.5226447582,
0.6056853533,
0.2134848833,
0.16567038,
0.1121660098,
-0.1193611175,
0.2647919059,
0.1567753702,
-0.3595247567,
0.1031032801,
0.2230697125,
1.0264691114,
-0.2040745467,
-0.4164354205,
0.6687071323,
-0.1983908564,
-0.1249108016,
0.0239853896,
0.2204433978,
0.1154988483,
0.1657650769,
0.1733161509,
-0.3579714298,
-0.1835220307,
-0.0070376415,
0.2047035694,
0.3262572885,
-0.0322095603,
-0.0625017136,
0.4361971617,
0.1579446495,
-0.4616638422,
0.7461147904,
-0.4094099998,
-0.603854239,
0.3405449986,
0.584890902,
0.5397409797,
-0.0606914796,
0.4362625182,
0.5415714383,
0.271851629,
-0.1260856241,
0.3440828919,
-0.2338501066,
-0.7027269602,
-0.7201201916,
-0.1853882521,
-0.6986314058,
-0.0805573165,
-0.245681107,
0.3649287224,
-0.394256711,
-0.2237998247,
-0.1791973859,
-0.1648838073,
-0.5586728454,
-0.0128890928,
-0.0514255054,
0.8480332494,
-0.7315570712,
0.8743360043,
0.6129544973,
-0.4129047692,
-0.8949654102,
-0.0019156355,
-0.098063536,
-0.9994785786,
0.6711798906,
0.201172784,
-0.161843732,
0.3692876101,
-0.69316715,
-0.5593402386,
1.071726203,
0.5299973488,
-0.7338278294,
0.1675014496,
0.305703938,
0.41032812,
-0.3022101521,
0.0370044149,
0.1104680076,
0.5577313304,
0.5052692294,
-0.5681366324,
0.0180567745,
-0.1417780668,
0.2401051372,
-0.0010579524,
-0.3175912201,
0.6250533462,
-0.2486789376,
-0.3767163754,
0.1927196831,
0.7793949246,
0.4663120806,
0.1618302464,
0.5133974552,
0.2225117385,
1.2966263294,
-0.2543298304,
1.0585803986,
-0.4116514027,
0.4502162635,
1.1587992907,
-0.4381449819,
0.7047170997,
0.4114511609,
-0.1530030221,
0.4777830541,
0.8173333406,
-0.1405816078,
0.2230792195,
0.241248399,
-0.5273687243,
-0.2455035001,
-0.0195252672,
-0.3266613185,
0.3127102554,
0.3626304567,
-0.2398362905,
-0.3913163543,
0.2289497852,
-0.0055573303,
0.1965498179,
-0.2757454813,
0.7777557373,
-0.183595404,
-0.6336907744,
0.5521450043,
0.0847395808,
0.2583626509,
-0.5971221924,
-0.0333956145,
-0.1950910389,
0.2128694803,
-0.1471105218,
-0.7012043595,
0.1077539399,
0.1434044689,
-0.237547189,
-0.3290138543,
1.042003274,
-0.4776164293,
-0.515787065,
0.0418743379,
0.4370348454,
0.0353245437,
-0.1342746466,
-0.5048447251,
0.2746625841,
0.0836499855,
-0.1926294863,
-0.1791332215,
0.6030229926,
-0.1426538378,
0.7446841598,
0.6644403338,
0.1972102821,
0.0517839454,
0.4594708979,
1.0495297909,
-0.2959485948,
-0.3647498786,
-0.8882101178,
0.4759033024,
-0.2602551877,
0.1317073554,
0.8283246756,
0.4025206864,
0.9555188417,
0.0732884035,
0.8390738368,
-0.1959725618,
0.3537866175,
-0.6888921261,
0.4815490544,
-0.1193523705,
0.4662460089,
0.1208666638,
-0.774045229,
-0.3177669942,
0.5931549072,
-0.3693022728,
0.0757671446,
0.6816966534,
1.0960870981,
0.2024987042,
-0.0425168797,
0.2760112882,
0.1442540735,
0.4776881635,
0.2985610962,
0.9513338208,
-0.3696400225,
0.5657456517,
-0.1012641415,
-0.261942476,
-0.074529469,
-1.2355186939,
-1.0719313622,
-0.5349968076,
-0.5148866177,
-0.6331654787,
0.1226202175,
0.7837607265,
0.403940767,
-0.6322488785,
-0.0319789089,
-0.4321297407,
0.2599606812,
-0.1681458205,
-0.1807887554,
0.3314466774,
-0.5854275823,
-0.808791697,
0.4527719915,
0.3856986463,
0.1840465814,
-0.265320003,
-0.2736490667,
0.0424852744,
-0.1968992203,
0.5137636662,
0.4046996832,
-0.5090700984,
-0.3247851729,
-0.1292543858,
-0.1984882802,
0.3772054315,
1.0303205252,
-0.7713859081,
0.6079828739,
0.7566904426,
0.7722525001,
0.6718530655,
-0.0273457393,
0.7091017962,
-0.9919852614,
-0.2099621147,
-0.1730226874,
0.4448770881,
0.6677283049,
-0.4650212824,
0.3916498125,
0.2654466331,
-0.4296757579,
-0.6555358171,
0.3139870167,
-0.6811175346,
0.1107012853,
1.1628962755,
-0.422386229,
-0.2538000345,
-0.1552059501,
-0.4063511789,
0.3199334443,
-0.2595015764,
0.5358039737,
0.617672503,
-0.1331997067,
-0.3461672068,
-0.1113205254,
0.5208373666,
0.1241875067,
-1.186465621,
0.4303840697,
0.5923880935,
0.3321262598,
0.0487799905,
0.963408649,
-0.0686025321,
0.2466327995,
-0.1262852848,
-0.0379119255,
-0.4577898681,
-0.2659950852,
-0.2687887549,
0.2211335897,
0.2542088926,
-0.1639558971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12389v1 | SHINE: Syntax-augmented Hierarchical Interactive Encoder for Zero-shot Cross-lingual Information Extraction | 2023-05-21T08:02:06 | 2023-05-21T08:02:06 | Jun-Yu Ma, Jia-Chen Gu, Zhen-Hua Ling, Quan Liu, Cong Liu, Guoping Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Zero-shot cross-lingual information extraction(IE) aims at constructing an IE
model for some low-resource target languages, given annotations exclusively in
some rich-resource languages. Recent studies based on language-universal
features have shown their effectiveness and are attracting increasing
attention. However, prior work has neither explored the potential of
establishing interactions between language-universal features and contextual
representations nor incorporated features that can effectively model
constituent span attributes and relationships between multiple spans. In this
study, a syntax-augmented hierarchical interactive encoder (SHINE) is proposed
to transfer cross-lingual IE knowledge. The proposed encoder is capable of
interactively capturing complementary information between features and
contextual information, to derive language-agnostic representations for various
IE tasks. Concretely, a multi-level interaction network is designed to
hierarchically interact the complementary information to strengthen domain
adaptability. Besides, in addition to the well-studied syntax features of
part-of-speech and dependency relation, a new syntax feature of constituency
structure is introduced to model the constituent span information which is
crucial for IE. Experiments across seven languages on three IE tasks and four
benchmarks verify the effectiveness and generalization ability of the proposed
method. | [
-0.1537169367,
-0.7778664827,
0.3667230606,
0.4309809208,
0.2107552886,
0.2435974628,
-0.1477619261,
-0.605971992,
0.6089619398,
0.167555809,
-0.1653705537,
-0.2541991472,
-0.4322167337,
-0.0366589651,
-0.3782522678,
0.6033384204,
-0.0318279415,
-0.1319541335,
0.1170417741,
0.0058714091,
-0.3368698955,
-0.4602244198,
-0.2250324488,
0.0023786977,
0.2891203463,
0.4225124419,
0.4831675291,
0.5426747799,
0.370865792,
0.2102829069,
0.194143936,
0.0552328117,
-0.3321998119,
0.0549818426,
-0.2861869037,
-0.5453910828,
-0.6411576271,
-0.2927716672,
0.70210886,
0.9932529926,
0.0909386799,
0.0852763653,
0.117885299,
0.2242667526,
-1.0325068235,
0.2900490761,
-0.7548212409,
0.2583474219,
-0.3377832174,
-0.6008984447,
-0.3745458126,
0.1524429321,
-0.0115005709,
-0.8580179214,
-0.3264389932,
0.0217453148,
1.1900119781,
-0.0078467457,
-0.2921400964,
0.0212478489,
-0.7184172273,
0.8692843914,
-0.4350567758,
0.691332221,
0.2679900229,
0.2948015332,
0.4771184325,
-0.7346122265,
-0.5188148618,
0.0052729375,
-0.18318896,
0.415751338,
-0.2449448854,
0.0416332148,
-0.1178249866,
0.3930505216,
-0.1881186217,
0.0168032888,
0.0143361837,
-0.0352824666,
0.2899729013,
0.0293444041,
0.8049792647,
-0.5174974799,
-0.5675335526,
0.1631318033,
-0.7930845618,
0.2714917362,
-0.2125826031,
0.6606728435,
-0.3001741767,
0.4775187671,
-0.212338686,
0.4810067713,
0.5538554788,
0.0125230877,
0.3184502125,
-0.5033992529,
-0.3467953205,
0.2092276216,
0.7278003693,
0.1381765902,
0.2043007612,
-0.474360615,
-0.0374130458,
-0.1943381876,
0.0333736092,
-0.766505301,
0.1365574747,
0.0443589687,
-0.3129652143,
0.0100428117,
0.2665266097,
-1.0160433054,
-0.0292066298,
-0.2667558193,
0.4825351536,
-0.5172530413,
-0.4450774491,
0.0869528726,
-0.0924502537,
0.5353791118,
0.3845869005,
-1.0545481443,
0.3188505471,
0.3519289494,
0.6355490088,
-0.2343738824,
-0.6162139177,
-0.9215336442,
0.659248054,
-0.0983643755,
0.42176193,
-1.0247182846,
-0.0175274368,
0.1875549257,
0.038700819,
-0.6614776254,
-0.4177940786,
0.0570647568,
-0.5216890574,
0.201693669,
-0.1216700971,
-0.4059869051,
0.0780677348,
0.2454300225,
-0.7239884138,
0.8738279343,
0.3822748959,
-0.8415656686,
0.4168606699,
-0.795450449,
-0.458670944,
0.4107633233,
-0.4802963436,
0.1009878963,
-0.1836297661,
0.5142745972,
0.1706212163,
0.042728208,
0.1493533254,
-0.267565757,
-0.4061440825,
-0.0969367996,
-0.293156743,
0.760707438,
-0.1527690738,
-0.6923787594,
-0.0227328669,
-0.7889973521,
0.0044682622,
0.0211956128,
-0.4460946321,
-0.4602734745,
-0.4263524413,
0.2664709091,
0.1425366849,
0.4739564061,
-0.6803464293,
0.2030475289,
-0.2379327863,
0.0214365367,
0.2776064277,
0.1390176713,
0.6710765958,
0.1896962225,
0.6561055779,
0.0275644884,
0.133973062,
-0.2393399477,
-0.08356978,
-0.8288447261,
-0.3808571398,
0.5809079409,
1.0787039995,
-1.0206750631,
0.6196563244,
-0.4635220766,
0.2373171598,
-0.8156188726,
0.1390806735,
0.3710674644,
0.431694299,
0.5103540421,
-0.3348322213,
-0.7270644903,
-0.6929457784,
-0.356516242,
-0.0838692784,
-0.0655416921,
0.2735341787,
0.1870229244,
-0.2077130079,
1.24546206,
-0.0113311391,
-0.3325566649,
-0.5251169205,
0.1103184968,
-0.2734904885,
0.2426245064,
0.7688795328,
-0.7647853494,
-0.8289632201,
0.5777647495,
-1.0431997776,
-0.3097000122,
-0.1776700318,
-0.2638754249,
-0.1729623228,
0.3962315917,
-0.490773946,
0.4972487092,
0.2140916139,
-0.1022302434,
0.3166047931,
0.2427324355,
0.468141973,
-0.7868431211,
0.360932827,
-0.0770732686,
-0.1784739047,
-0.7822342515,
0.2735765874,
0.2012442797,
-0.0495920293,
-0.5561423302,
0.7657682896,
-0.5331267715,
-0.048004996,
0.0620507374,
0.3223424256,
0.1404322833,
0.6355552673,
0.2246815413,
0.6758439541,
0.6993435025,
-0.2094178945,
0.0994449779,
0.3147307634,
0.1177984402,
0.8912510276,
-0.3479902744,
-0.1302241534,
0.1621278375,
-0.309492588,
-0.5397350192,
-0.3439749777,
0.0552273579,
-0.4011244178,
0.5121091604,
-0.2199752331,
-0.283570379,
0.2940754592,
-0.4702706337,
0.2636666894,
0.3560346067,
-0.6907984018,
0.6883195639,
0.4285226464,
-0.3769419491,
-0.511523664,
-0.7749354243,
0.3734408915,
-0.1852570921,
-0.5705813766,
0.6888278723,
0.2761485279,
-0.2256434411,
0.1538124532,
0.0256856158,
-0.1141123474,
-0.1937961131,
0.0156751089,
0.1313928366,
-0.3202425838,
-0.2166790366,
0.1632988453,
0.0227904767,
-0.234780252,
0.0248953383,
0.3467720449,
-0.1642871797,
-0.5356640816,
-0.2496103495,
0.613614738,
0.5779674649,
-0.4305817187,
0.4701559544,
0.673289299,
-0.4981289804,
-0.2429501861,
-0.31345734,
0.0848587528,
-0.4073121846,
0.4394027293,
-0.4358626902,
-0.9937385917,
0.6047344208,
-0.3728182018,
-0.134203583,
0.450348407,
0.1609232128,
0.1564162821,
0.9785015583,
0.8701462746,
-0.1647691578,
0.5672220588,
-0.1533241421,
0.2251606137,
-1.0305999517,
-0.3527487218,
-0.1865068227,
-0.154137373,
-0.0568162166,
-0.0573782809,
0.317725122,
0.5830960274,
-0.0961815268,
0.3713234365,
-0.0662019849,
0.0021874125,
0.4200928509,
-0.1249554306,
0.1600060165,
0.2362457365,
-0.2543922365,
-0.3778987527,
-0.7567184567,
0.0332263447,
0.4821363986,
0.1599832177,
0.8026032448,
0.0769061521,
0.7417455912,
0.2193032354,
-0.1360772252,
-0.6308363676,
0.4650665522,
-0.1715797782,
-0.1356185675,
-0.2131846845,
-0.4528651834,
-0.8632043004,
0.2877378464,
-0.0367532261,
-0.8813925982,
0.7061855197,
-0.1891356856,
-0.3024722636,
0.3933579028,
-0.6137627363,
0.7361400723,
-0.4352913797,
-0.5014033318,
0.3012160957,
-0.7682775855,
0.0015657056,
0.0126723219,
0.2532827556,
0.3583784103,
-0.0903183967,
0.4837905467,
-0.3621177673,
1.0331766605,
-0.255753994,
-0.0306049306,
0.1266019493,
0.264970541,
0.1217773035,
-0.2710867226,
-0.1022224277,
0.0344458818,
-0.2169270962,
-0.2179208845,
-0.7528935075,
0.546987772,
-0.5815333128,
-0.2355775088,
-0.0430822708,
-0.4278669655,
-0.431216985,
0.2588756979,
0.0851430893,
0.4111565351,
-0.147326842,
0.2170932591,
0.1111667529,
-0.0304879099,
0.665504992,
0.4071075916,
-0.3633078635,
-0.5742747188,
1.0849894285,
0.2181176245,
0.2776277959,
0.7983669043,
-0.1790187657,
0.0200564303,
-0.1153299883,
-0.7584511042,
-0.0025137065,
-0.6218698621,
-0.2202161402,
-0.5479470491,
-0.6861838102,
-0.1808345914,
-0.4643101096,
-0.2533370554,
-0.6203938723,
-0.1733279824,
-0.1317003816,
0.3067207634,
0.4580107927,
-0.2648347616,
0.1629142314,
-0.779076755,
0.3913089037,
0.402688086,
0.1771496683,
0.0941637605,
-0.3852067292,
-0.4924734533,
0.00244538,
-0.0620697103,
-0.8500927091,
0.4838484228,
0.6279180646,
0.7872021794,
0.5098767281,
-0.0883089602,
0.9153027534,
-0.5339742303,
0.8486012816,
0.2595028281,
-1.1527549028,
0.6020485163,
-0.1751260608,
0.2548688352,
0.6105294824,
0.404425174,
-0.4030811191,
-0.3166168332,
-0.4501389861,
-0.8889735937,
0.6466223598,
0.1220734194,
-0.1354321241,
-0.1304056197,
0.1171586961,
0.2168994844,
0.2588243186,
-0.7857466936,
-0.1613988727,
-0.3162101209,
-0.1528918594,
0.7830455899,
-0.0540922955,
0.0966984034,
-0.3859545887,
0.234207809,
-0.2133473754,
0.0478126556,
0.2499994487,
-0.6149249673,
-0.2943560779,
0.5485600829,
-0.1803792417,
0.5756809711,
-0.2779491842,
0.3666985333,
0.1643481255,
-0.4903253615,
-0.2357839197,
0.4017460048,
-0.3059539199,
0.0135357482,
0.658622086,
0.8728396893,
0.7029616237,
-0.3386435211,
0.6562750936,
0.2820631862,
0.0318292342,
0.173037231,
-0.1800717115,
-0.1195681617,
0.0131139373,
0.5547213554,
-0.0318300314,
0.3678900898,
-0.8036911488,
0.423899442,
0.4289978147,
-0.5700322986,
-0.6044159532,
0.5408005714,
0.4125426412,
-0.1684449613,
0.3172062635,
-0.2768216729,
-0.6760240197,
0.2427527308,
0.7547336817,
0.793603003,
-0.4813900292,
0.2410327494,
0.2081610411,
0.0993333086,
0.719039619,
0.3809793591,
-0.2581183612,
-0.6024554372,
-0.6008344293,
-0.7702148557,
-0.4605046213,
-0.0484580882,
-0.8355537653,
0.0906410515,
-0.1083346531,
0.2104116231,
-0.0971034467,
-0.1414744705,
-0.649125576,
0.07551153,
0.1950077266,
0.7299841046,
-0.7961177826,
0.6560135484,
0.4839423299,
-0.6345157027,
-0.635320127,
0.0442766622,
-0.071712479,
-0.9565370083,
0.7341054678,
0.0313006826,
-0.1648132205,
-0.0995308757,
-0.363786459,
-0.809930861,
1.0785704851,
0.6389697194,
-0.4967069924,
-0.1984268576,
0.4879619181,
0.3799045384,
-0.642318964,
0.4150013924,
0.4746229053,
0.5646932125,
0.1418814808,
-1.3549813032,
0.0903382301,
-0.7079502344,
-0.1920839697,
0.0864689797,
-0.3558265567,
0.9125441313,
0.0664142147,
-0.3465272784,
-0.1459283978,
0.3677191436,
0.0383585319,
0.0557763949,
0.256136179,
0.3845363557,
0.4744278789,
0.1005849764,
0.8945396543,
-0.5475901365,
0.17664662,
0.8846302629,
-0.7825565338,
1.1450233459,
0.466431886,
-0.0577974543,
0.7585445642,
0.1293757856,
0.1336768717,
0.6924784184,
-0.3568867445,
-0.3622448742,
-0.2092811763,
-0.4000190496,
-0.4485637248,
0.5113543868,
0.6116441488,
-0.2157440186,
-0.4643187523,
0.132931754,
0.0172479916,
-0.2373945862,
-0.4272314012,
0.8472682238,
0.0248610862,
-0.2937771082,
0.5782456994,
-0.0779900551,
0.87672472,
-0.7624725699,
-0.4679963887,
-0.1090809479,
-0.0471381918,
-0.4873477519,
-0.8203805685,
0.1358863413,
-0.0276806783,
0.0102798585,
-0.2705962956,
0.9998166561,
-0.857221961,
-0.262760371,
0.8264869452,
0.9115455747,
-0.0530202948,
0.019357089,
-0.4178968966,
0.0501261316,
-0.0810826644,
-0.0792149454,
0.4928124845,
0.6314741969,
0.0370405167,
0.0984081328,
0.3850703537,
0.3615704775,
0.2532863915,
0.4841495156,
0.7810737491,
-0.7409004569,
-0.5313905478,
-0.5416846871,
0.7559147477,
-0.3523934484,
-0.0197526868,
0.9206504822,
0.4661081433,
0.6974620223,
0.0000323008,
1.0516586304,
-0.2496681064,
0.2329014093,
-0.467918992,
0.7376922369,
-0.6425547004,
0.0290680006,
-0.2428225577,
-0.866902709,
-0.3705761731,
0.4599716961,
-0.1283857226,
0.1548172832,
0.7295742035,
0.4163048565,
-0.5413452387,
-0.1664973348,
0.4387783408,
0.1608222574,
0.0758753642,
0.5612459183,
0.6409042478,
-0.2910127342,
0.4466499388,
-0.2331993878,
-0.416200012,
-0.2801269293,
-0.6699630022,
-0.717006743,
-0.4372350276,
-0.2773729861,
0.0739289895,
0.1610361338,
0.557503283,
0.8604595661,
-0.7834266424,
-0.2239302993,
0.0880607739,
-0.2607568204,
-0.2279800177,
-0.3807108402,
0.6052220464,
-0.4574064314,
-0.522002697,
0.7660750747,
0.8060896993,
-0.4367942512,
-0.1817449331,
-0.0240136907,
-0.32772699,
0.1350485682,
0.7405979037,
0.6265708208,
-0.5810718536,
-0.5930640697,
0.2474924922,
0.0101707112,
0.3633035421,
0.4921379089,
-0.7920352221,
0.4847545624,
0.2431665361,
0.7988049388,
0.2993909121,
-0.1334188282,
0.5015903711,
-1.0923094749,
-0.0306063499,
-0.009262193,
0.5457661152,
0.5056652427,
-0.3597107232,
0.4147563577,
0.2013739794,
-0.1553831846,
-0.5731878877,
0.1467940062,
-1.14334023,
0.0671854094,
1.1200805902,
-0.2124170661,
-0.2493586689,
-0.1038884148,
-0.1964288354,
0.0475192592,
-0.2286368906,
0.3689919412,
0.2792341709,
-0.2900040746,
-0.3718616366,
-0.3516641855,
0.2813226283,
0.2409736514,
-1.0740695,
0.0062964158,
0.127931118,
0.1181628928,
0.4985888302,
0.5758937001,
-0.3104985058,
0.4469173551,
0.2765716612,
0.2477688789,
-0.0496191867,
-0.550018847,
-0.3361882865,
0.4252128303,
-0.1494666934,
-0.1301484257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12376v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12376v1 | Measuring Intersectional Biases in Historical Documents | 2023-05-21T07:10:31 | 2023-05-21T07:10:31 | Nadav Borenstein, Karolina Stańczak, Thea Rolskov, Natália da Silva Perez, Natacha Klein Käfer, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Data-driven analyses of biases in historical texts can help illuminate the
origin and development of biases prevailing in modern society.
However, digitised historical documents pose a challenge for NLP
practitioners as these corpora suffer from errors introduced by optical
character recognition (OCR) and are written in an archaic language. In this
paper, we investigate the continuities and transformations of bias in
historical newspapers published in the Caribbean during the colonial era (18th
to 19th centuries). Our analyses are performed along the axes of gender, race,
and their intersection. We examine these biases by conducting a temporal study
in which we measure the development of lexical associations using
distributional semantics models and word embeddings. Further, we evaluate the
effectiveness of techniques designed to process OCR-generated data and assess
their stability when trained on and applied to the noisy historical newspapers.
We find that there is a trade-off between the stability of the word embeddings
and their compatibility with the historical dataset. We provide evidence that
gender and racial biases are interdependent, and their intersection triggers
distinct effects. These findings align with the theory of intersectionality,
which stresses that biases affecting people with multiple marginalised
identities compound to more than the sum of their constituents. | [
-0.6142405868,
-0.6319100261,
0.6676489115,
-0.0080418261,
-0.1667167246,
0.2445859909,
-0.1689006835,
-0.7466640472,
0.5819965601,
0.539966166,
-0.2870171368,
-0.3176168501,
-0.8705401421,
0.1386859417,
-0.324269861,
0.7901916504,
-0.3220179677,
0.4726478457,
-0.0365612358,
-0.4223663509,
-0.4885740578,
-0.8665486574,
-0.2403399348,
0.2878476381,
0.3555003405,
-0.0421500877,
0.8293895125,
0.6467089653,
0.4792354405,
0.1536435634,
-0.287452966,
0.5125511289,
-0.4537739456,
0.1464004815,
-0.3691656291,
-0.5441783071,
-0.0544850081,
0.0277537387,
0.2767781615,
0.9512762427,
0.4254710972,
0.0148587683,
0.1463933587,
0.6764597297,
-0.8726776838,
0.1603120118,
-0.6501084566,
0.1274880022,
-0.5169099569,
-0.6762605906,
-0.1067762375,
-0.6229266524,
-0.0436823852,
-0.2441535592,
0.4482095242,
-0.0585549474,
0.7237993479,
-0.2381451726,
-0.5487485528,
-0.6699854136,
-0.7361625433,
0.8265736699,
-0.406696409,
0.33057338,
0.3778979182,
0.1108565778,
-0.097662136,
-0.3673347533,
-0.6173191071,
0.0722971037,
-0.1376312077,
0.0617558025,
-0.0678155497,
-0.248889342,
0.2823729813,
0.1568754166,
-0.1772648245,
0.0229147878,
-0.8793016076,
0.012999515,
0.4900989234,
0.2389356196,
0.7126540542,
-0.1926169991,
-0.2802281082,
0.1153906509,
-0.7201626301,
-0.1112338677,
1.1086863279,
0.5296049118,
0.138917461,
0.8130751848,
0.2909875512,
0.3711398542,
0.1130987704,
-0.0639300719,
0.042407237,
-0.5264592767,
0.4074237347,
0.3800106645,
0.6682097316,
0.4969094396,
0.3925896883,
-0.0372724645,
0.0614127554,
0.1776442975,
0.4612823129,
-0.0556838177,
0.2739110589,
-0.1277687848,
-0.487526238,
-0.0270357523,
0.3836936951,
-1.1133769751,
-0.3953942955,
-0.34453547,
-0.0525742471,
-0.2767724693,
-0.0604450777,
0.1077068076,
-0.5473148227,
-0.0332080908,
0.3375300765,
-1.3463523388,
0.2684708536,
0.5808428526,
0.8631614447,
-0.2305735797,
-0.0633499473,
0.0959168151,
0.0481544994,
-0.3110524714,
0.4053545296,
-0.4750205576,
-0.3369359672,
0.4981580079,
-0.033538796,
-0.0004649127,
-0.399387747,
0.6570933461,
-0.4842403233,
0.3257176876,
-0.5198022127,
-0.0578565672,
0.0153082972,
0.0567037947,
-0.6520389915,
1.0390410423,
0.2531235814,
-0.8954319954,
0.7502120137,
-0.0410918966,
-0.2520857453,
-0.3555179834,
-0.7401553988,
-0.6177895665,
0.1290298104,
0.6004199386,
-0.1602529138,
-0.1211067662,
0.2378428876,
-0.5140641928,
-0.2913096547,
-0.0506022163,
-0.2583381534,
1.2538415194,
-0.2135448605,
-0.7897412777,
-0.5941717625,
-0.5746487379,
-0.5674613714,
0.0736156479,
-0.1869996488,
-0.8485454917,
-0.0449192859,
0.0523022562,
0.108088173,
0.1266478002,
-0.5431332588,
0.3499695659,
0.0521073267,
0.1542931199,
0.4279981256,
0.0169355441,
0.3479049802,
-0.4969486892,
0.3979532123,
0.2236172706,
0.0580295436,
-0.0943165794,
-0.4949159324,
-0.6615025401,
0.1302401274,
0.4391077459,
0.3256554008,
-0.4733533561,
0.5126023889,
-0.36680305,
-0.1221570298,
-0.3744740486,
-0.187426433,
0.0288103968,
0.2500507832,
0.325132817,
-0.7041051984,
-0.9553413391,
-0.932158649,
-0.4679513276,
-0.3484083414,
-0.0736734569,
0.2839496732,
0.5643463135,
0.0136295483,
1.1630061865,
-0.253082782,
-0.4988185465,
0.3311507702,
0.3196481466,
-0.1568450481,
0.3493750393,
0.9082470536,
-0.8051989079,
0.0522979535,
-0.0970875025,
-0.6723027825,
-0.423024863,
-0.2139772624,
-0.1164131388,
0.464076966,
0.7013266087,
0.0045364196,
0.8908033371,
0.3830913901,
-0.2533735037,
0.5491328835,
0.0916886702,
0.5487022996,
-0.504614234,
-0.0410564989,
-0.0763994828,
-0.1384910643,
-0.3176272511,
-0.1498810947,
0.0874563009,
0.1237212792,
-0.3829834163,
0.27440539,
-0.7667871714,
-0.2490221858,
0.1377433836,
0.429938525,
-0.0253778268,
0.2055010945,
0.3874706328,
0.3465695083,
-0.2294676155,
-0.3225848079,
-0.4768893421,
0.4488915503,
-0.2300052792,
0.8665229678,
-0.1323829889,
0.1015694663,
-0.4237193465,
-0.0157835968,
-1.087720871,
0.3740369081,
0.1245228499,
-0.582103312,
-0.0671288446,
-0.1849242747,
-0.3305253386,
-0.2817055881,
-0.3913907707,
0.6956605315,
-0.0499696285,
-0.5540651679,
0.4486847222,
0.7528889775,
-0.2259959579,
-0.5425750613,
-0.9762021899,
0.1764036268,
-0.0939493924,
-0.6096211672,
0.234355852,
0.2118452042,
-0.5299752355,
-0.1605916619,
-0.0821766555,
-0.2073460966,
-0.3891872168,
0.2772601843,
0.2861324251,
-0.2181363851,
-0.1062670872,
0.2117998302,
0.3923866451,
0.0468126424,
-0.1542628706,
0.6999498606,
0.5018242598,
-0.3231918812,
0.0750682056,
0.3560250998,
0.7308287621,
-0.1619221866,
0.8090147972,
0.1593184322,
-0.35250175,
0.2167119682,
-0.8097293377,
0.0318975709,
-0.3234345317,
-0.048683662,
0.0086764777,
-0.7339466214,
0.8801568151,
0.2747395337,
0.136665836,
0.6354734898,
0.4634278715,
0.0614513755,
0.6998616457,
0.1965996325,
-0.1413346976,
0.7196018696,
-0.0225217454,
0.1064857394,
-0.8189893961,
-0.3538908064,
-0.7873210907,
-0.3835251927,
-0.6935135126,
-0.207413286,
0.6858791709,
-0.014249675,
-0.1704711318,
0.1033856571,
-0.2329460084,
0.2474453151,
0.4078200459,
0.29984954,
0.5164890885,
0.0140557699,
0.0787965581,
-0.4792310894,
-0.4514763057,
-0.6778851151,
1.20477736,
0.2156728655,
0.3381183743,
0.2050203234,
0.5925200582,
0.5477612615,
-0.1830930412,
-0.164224878,
0.0754236728,
-0.0185147282,
-0.5922669768,
0.0143145658,
-0.2084167153,
-1.2513743639,
0.1378092915,
-0.5229650736,
-0.8117890358,
1.0741052628,
-0.0002523878,
-0.1020857021,
0.5404121876,
-0.2049600929,
0.4423089027,
-0.3993197978,
-0.4677606523,
0.1086643636,
-0.5248686671,
0.6128955483,
-0.0049684956,
0.4245600998,
0.2620810866,
-0.1075134426,
0.6669636965,
-0.45437181,
0.7678374052,
0.1771890074,
0.0181148835,
0.2382300794,
0.1925224811,
0.0617199019,
-0.2240424156,
0.0708355233,
0.5589652061,
0.1429545432,
-0.5371236205,
-0.3023242056,
0.3952777982,
-0.8280932307,
-0.3302410543,
-0.5823215842,
-0.5007184744,
0.141505748,
0.2606142759,
0.1342187822,
0.5553504229,
-0.3983829021,
-0.1621030867,
0.3728598356,
-0.0780630484,
0.5572063327,
0.2941187024,
-0.2680202425,
-0.3235605657,
0.2149460465,
0.5828644037,
0.3349200785,
0.3640149236,
-0.038738858,
-0.1163057238,
-0.758831203,
-0.4014257193,
-0.051620435,
-0.4335758686,
0.0999238342,
-0.7648370862,
-0.030753335,
-0.4312426448,
-0.3922956288,
-0.1716419756,
-0.5473028421,
-0.5118975639,
0.1658038199,
-0.0273040589,
0.7464133501,
0.0641524419,
0.2558472455,
-0.4058098197,
0.3604006767,
0.0706034079,
0.005261506,
0.0496288128,
-0.2921111584,
-0.0038606517,
-0.0304863192,
-0.3450767696,
-1.1303408146,
0.4441181719,
-0.4212547243,
0.3049833775,
0.3261325657,
0.1445824504,
0.3820962906,
-0.3923129439,
0.7420222163,
0.061149504,
-0.9475201964,
0.2737286091,
-0.7715066671,
0.1503293961,
0.8524391055,
0.6231139302,
-0.6009417176,
-0.8534933329,
-0.6861923933,
-1.0736927986,
0.4200825095,
0.0586422198,
-0.2167174965,
-0.3788833916,
0.2280493528,
0.3271529078,
0.3092976511,
-0.5659326911,
-0.1649540067,
0.0544748381,
-0.0290637966,
0.3455233574,
-0.2534403205,
0.0717706233,
-0.0263903886,
0.2160503864,
0.0041190982,
0.0197209697,
0.4981198907,
-0.4700086415,
-0.089781858,
0.1148933172,
0.6136748791,
1.230280757,
-0.3653655648,
0.3920757771,
-0.0515473224,
-0.8099076152,
-0.1171491221,
0.0520423353,
-0.5789644122,
0.3900289237,
0.5331719518,
0.5590481162,
0.1747772992,
-0.5305199027,
0.6064287424,
-0.1176400557,
0.0614104867,
-0.6497579217,
-0.3315805793,
-0.3095840216,
0.115020141,
0.7350690961,
0.1632113606,
-0.0376059972,
-1.1693092585,
-0.0561531112,
0.5052515268,
-0.4810147882,
0.104250446,
0.7801014781,
0.1371523142,
-0.1676924527,
0.3208724856,
0.026334174,
-0.7702615261,
0.5013005137,
0.2152882963,
0.4259305,
0.0508330055,
-0.0474211983,
0.4823251665,
0.7048234344,
0.0006474498,
0.1144723743,
0.1309201568,
-0.572144568,
0.2497801036,
-0.36953637,
-0.268922776,
-0.1960719377,
-0.7834501266,
0.4692915976,
-0.4441202581,
-0.3384605944,
0.164436996,
-0.0073970328,
-0.7783337831,
0.120973736,
0.142958194,
0.5161709189,
-1.0942887068,
0.0030616953,
-0.0093602743,
-0.686060667,
0.1342673749,
0.1017535329,
0.4111836851,
-0.8773471117,
0.7301165462,
-0.211372152,
0.1541823,
-0.4098628759,
-0.1519493908,
-0.5578439832,
0.7055737972,
0.2030831724,
-1.0348696709,
-0.0030937665,
0.5817212462,
0.585855484,
-0.4182803035,
0.7255163193,
0.8556865454,
0.6217643619,
-0.6370636821,
-1.1010583639,
-0.0052434709,
0.2714257836,
0.0527117625,
0.5700615644,
-0.4429547191,
0.8467341065,
0.0591179803,
-0.4664328396,
-0.0746060908,
0.4828347266,
-0.051607769,
0.4035089314,
0.4354958236,
0.4292498529,
0.5846704245,
-0.3638171852,
0.970929563,
-0.0488633737,
0.0517709181,
0.8148410916,
-0.0128761046,
0.4840841889,
0.6874099374,
-0.4784757495,
0.5010948777,
0.3782199025,
0.0990968272,
0.1321691871,
0.2188239545,
-0.2152957916,
0.5029311776,
-0.3437533975,
-0.31248191,
0.5223125219,
0.1709762365,
-0.8197154403,
-0.1422102302,
-0.2605493069,
0.3698919415,
0.5313139558,
-0.7638399005,
0.564581275,
-0.030641865,
-0.4901176393,
0.1727081686,
-0.3410131633,
0.7532557249,
-0.4962215424,
0.1840249449,
-0.136070326,
0.0544379316,
-0.3474569917,
-0.7834286094,
0.5081959367,
-0.4128007591,
-0.4023752213,
0.0562028922,
0.5636922121,
-0.8554807901,
-0.4664531946,
0.3333435357,
0.6218979955,
-0.076701425,
0.1851668805,
-0.101449661,
0.61522609,
0.0427426212,
0.233391434,
0.3814371228,
0.2175167352,
-0.413973093,
-0.2904289365,
0.3982488215,
0.5327400565,
0.2270715386,
-0.0269880872,
0.4589707553,
-0.6976245642,
-0.4992901981,
-0.8849691749,
0.2284093648,
-0.207750544,
-0.5778492093,
0.8240489364,
0.7181026936,
1.0677661896,
0.1218636259,
0.9000332952,
0.1592194438,
0.4176679254,
-0.603064537,
0.6789446473,
-0.211239472,
0.023982184,
-0.5964608192,
-0.8664677739,
-0.2332996279,
0.2665751576,
-0.5700202584,
0.2678051591,
0.7212454677,
0.4309839308,
-0.223838225,
0.3844711781,
-0.2265249938,
-0.1282387823,
0.1408773065,
0.1983324587,
0.6718139648,
-0.354727298,
0.3761444092,
-0.1007482782,
-0.1486701071,
-0.3274171352,
-0.9324395657,
-0.7885044217,
-0.8419595957,
-0.0970408916,
-0.398339361,
0.5946350098,
0.7322875261,
0.2605879009,
-0.5101622343,
-0.2131413966,
0.2637161314,
0.1787749678,
-0.1311556995,
-0.2650595009,
0.6483529806,
-0.0048936089,
-0.9212934375,
-0.2444891334,
0.1907584965,
0.0179130863,
-0.4930438101,
0.49037081,
-0.2864224315,
0.0814059675,
0.4406611025,
0.4480086863,
-0.3958297968,
-0.3994579911,
-0.5499774218,
-0.1407283843,
0.4441868663,
1.3455348015,
-0.5175871849,
0.8292227387,
0.5761014223,
0.5227309465,
0.6029859185,
0.0931595266,
0.733219862,
-0.6975293756,
0.2534152567,
0.4383690059,
0.6075521708,
0.4593537152,
-0.3498759866,
0.4520283639,
0.3744675219,
-0.4982234538,
-0.7184390426,
-0.0676705465,
-1.0197526217,
-0.3011111617,
0.815848887,
0.260594964,
-0.2607538104,
-0.6348159313,
-0.320768863,
0.2983365953,
-0.3558579385,
1.3014490604,
0.5654860139,
-0.0807925835,
-0.0367506817,
-0.7887716293,
0.0896016806,
0.2254008353,
-0.6906837225,
-0.1920877546,
0.6556059718,
-0.0807785466,
0.5948905945,
0.6119260192,
-0.5603098869,
0.2422830015,
0.1922566593,
0.2109283358,
0.2058654577,
-0.0106004532,
-0.1823816746,
0.232780084,
-0.4380342364,
-0.0237490162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12371v1 | Machine Translation by Projecting Text into the Same Phonetic-Orthographic Space Using a Common Encoding | 2023-05-21T06:46:33 | 2023-05-21T06:46:33 | Amit Kumar, Shantipriya Parida, Ajay Pratap, Anil Kumar Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL | The use of subword embedding has proved to be a major innovation in Neural
Machine Translation (NMT). It helps NMT to learn better context vectors for Low
Resource Languages (LRLs) so as to predict the target words by better modelling
the morphologies of the two languages and also the morphosyntax transfer. Even
so, their performance for translation in Indian language to Indian language
scenario is still not as good as for resource-rich languages. One reason for
this is the relative morphological richness of Indian languages, while another
is that most of them fall into the extremely low resource or zero-shot
categories. Since most major Indian languages use Indic or Brahmi origin
scripts, the text written in them is highly phonetic in nature and phonetically
similar in terms of abstract letters and their arrangements. We use these
characteristics of Indian languages and their scripts to propose an approach
based on common multilingual Latin-based encodings (WX notation) that take
advantage of language similarity while addressing the morphological complexity
issue in NMT. These multilingual Latin-based encodings in NMT, together with
Byte Pair Embedding (BPE) allow us to better exploit their phonetic and
orthographic as well as lexical similarities to improve the translation quality
by projecting different but similar languages on the same orthographic-phonetic
character space. We verify the proposed approach by demonstrating experiments
on similar language pairs (Gujarati-Hindi, Marathi-Hindi, Nepali-Hindi,
Maithili-Hindi, Punjabi-Hindi, and Urdu-Hindi) under low resource conditions.
The proposed approach shows an improvement in a majority of cases, in one case
as much as ~10 BLEU points compared to baseline techniques for similar language
pairs. We also get up to ~1 BLEU points improvement on distant and zero-shot
language pairs. | [
-0.2243067473,
-0.4148947597,
0.2903631032,
0.1589041203,
-0.5981689692,
0.3488286734,
-0.3215735555,
-0.3393094242,
0.4475758076,
0.141704157,
-0.2396248281,
-0.513088882,
-0.5660257936,
0.2839990556,
-0.2569074035,
0.5738006234,
-0.236948818,
0.3316126764,
0.1923080534,
-0.4305268824,
-0.5615563989,
-0.5712301135,
-0.1932824701,
-0.1596125066,
0.3693179786,
0.0117167281,
0.6827402115,
0.9315065145,
0.7428528666,
0.360030055,
-0.0696985275,
0.30329898,
-0.0195874423,
0.2470608354,
-0.2568748891,
-0.4431589246,
-0.2104426324,
-0.3783229589,
0.7119775414,
0.8335813284,
-0.0885086432,
-0.1059631705,
0.0532210506,
0.4779199064,
-0.4752984047,
0.1471232921,
-0.5712068081,
0.1242328063,
-0.2633535862,
-0.4351976216,
-0.3186739683,
-0.4693779349,
-0.0949414,
-0.3224070668,
-0.054058779,
0.2036860734,
0.5513651967,
0.3413597345,
-0.0745692626,
-0.2957438529,
-0.7351494431,
0.9558111429,
-0.6992318034,
0.4764975607,
0.0335646942,
0.2581452727,
0.0162324496,
-0.1669489592,
-0.5252622962,
0.013924785,
-0.2275047898,
0.1660791039,
0.0229016934,
-0.0645139962,
0.0818735212,
0.4687885344,
-0.6814288497,
0.0421943553,
-0.4899534285,
-0.1739798784,
0.3381043971,
0.0936543271,
0.6682994962,
-0.2871830761,
-0.5290275812,
-0.2469916642,
-0.6317855716,
-0.2156016827,
0.1553295553,
0.6675617099,
-0.1908559352,
0.766563952,
0.0254120342,
0.6215438843,
-0.0680228323,
-0.3155930936,
0.5031183362,
-0.5958049893,
-0.2025596946,
0.3351996839,
0.6349998116,
0.176932767,
0.2886560857,
-0.2402983606,
-0.1559554487,
0.2273855507,
-0.0916505978,
-0.4567051232,
0.6390162706,
-0.0596995875,
-0.5444536209,
0.2337044626,
-0.3643105328,
-0.6003291607,
-0.3508180082,
-0.5912463069,
0.2440063357,
-0.8971202374,
-0.4016860127,
0.0220813416,
-0.0813627541,
0.7181994319,
0.1661869586,
-1.050016284,
0.1802132875,
0.548181951,
1.0579708815,
-0.3004387021,
-0.3429918289,
-0.1902541667,
0.1188423634,
-0.3555644155,
0.6942778826,
-0.4884682596,
-0.3702058196,
0.1043166742,
-0.3506540358,
-0.410758853,
-0.3488194644,
0.3263813853,
-0.3668754697,
-0.0895323902,
-0.133291021,
-0.2654177248,
-0.2030982226,
0.3038805127,
-0.2135133445,
0.6685928106,
0.2003434151,
-0.5095638633,
0.2772276402,
-0.5758804679,
-0.5597852468,
0.1075023711,
-0.2604201734,
-0.0209141131,
0.2699840367,
0.2921195626,
0.408580929,
-0.3342420757,
-0.1376679391,
0.0663917884,
-0.4612117708,
0.1203407049,
-0.2848977149,
0.5239057541,
0.3856893182,
-0.2224422544,
-0.0227862336,
-0.6286854744,
0.2769357264,
-0.1675593853,
-0.2741191089,
-0.6206641197,
-0.5038627386,
0.1836280674,
0.3201810718,
0.0893125981,
-0.7245146632,
0.2565293014,
-0.7397288084,
0.6840088367,
0.4077049792,
-0.1536454856,
0.8185634613,
-0.0222634021,
0.5017123222,
0.0620897375,
-0.0189776588,
-0.119334355,
-0.4175646901,
-0.5084462762,
-0.2420170754,
0.5162340403,
0.7632104158,
-0.7254973054,
-0.1267349571,
-0.5012819767,
-0.2956324518,
-0.9681199789,
0.2068410218,
0.8058689237,
0.1967033744,
0.519199729,
-0.4685199261,
-0.4850574434,
-0.9875579476,
-0.1189824045,
0.0568793081,
0.3168000579,
-0.1996646225,
0.223770842,
-0.155675292,
0.4599670768,
-0.087046288,
-0.2731476724,
-0.339612633,
0.0655620843,
0.1588618755,
0.713277638,
0.411698848,
-0.8281456828,
-0.9334124923,
0.4214649498,
-0.6597205997,
0.1327251047,
0.0737316906,
-0.1345418394,
0.5902691483,
0.6232062578,
-0.5250475407,
0.4382702708,
0.5674988627,
0.1999987364,
0.1205319092,
-0.3549385369,
0.4029777348,
-1.4044055939,
-0.0011063754,
-0.3151879311,
-0.1228267401,
-0.4116874337,
0.2026125342,
0.0789559484,
-0.3355101049,
-0.7318727374,
0.4805497527,
-0.7054575682,
-0.179150328,
-0.099128589,
0.1579999775,
-0.4432250559,
0.8183528781,
0.0476122387,
0.9152253866,
0.3244566619,
-0.3325587809,
0.0071205669,
0.2076349705,
-0.0610507056,
0.8329414725,
-0.5517315865,
0.1168127507,
-0.1702022702,
-0.1122659743,
-0.819667697,
0.116500333,
0.2674464285,
-0.6638367772,
0.6699755192,
-0.2534721792,
-0.5103996992,
0.2976647317,
-0.2363087088,
0.5186468363,
0.6420804262,
-0.109675169,
0.4388402998,
0.2456153333,
-0.2193043828,
-0.6342236996,
-1.1313443184,
0.0701228827,
-0.0984933078,
-0.5302704573,
0.3909831941,
-0.000857883,
-0.1805087328,
0.2051758021,
-0.0141575187,
-0.0423558652,
-0.4556459486,
0.2654117346,
0.0725967586,
-0.3956848979,
0.0724567398,
0.2616286874,
-0.3844162822,
-0.5507492423,
-0.4946017861,
0.7877904773,
-0.2109743804,
-0.4236119688,
-0.3790343702,
0.7790074348,
0.7881686091,
-0.4165211618,
0.9276030064,
0.838676393,
-0.4774846435,
0.1790976822,
-0.4149613678,
0.0599347353,
-0.3252520561,
0.2247100174,
-0.6229102612,
-0.5678123832,
0.3928683996,
-0.2316673547,
-0.0906436145,
0.5184236765,
0.661875844,
-0.0191127714,
0.943944931,
0.7669609785,
-0.0927075297,
0.3172643781,
-0.2312793583,
0.4544479549,
-1.0194602013,
-0.3150303662,
-0.5306206346,
-0.3316763043,
-0.8170544505,
-0.5823566318,
0.2708107531,
0.0590165555,
0.2378781587,
0.7662495971,
-0.6795928478,
0.2608201206,
0.5863295197,
-0.2011524141,
0.2574121952,
0.4384118319,
-0.66270262,
-0.4191351235,
-0.5831961036,
-0.4671582282,
0.8980217576,
0.0103998315,
0.5748560429,
0.29947263,
0.8195646405,
0.267639786,
-0.0387966968,
-0.6738876104,
0.2606219947,
-0.2907678485,
-0.3838584125,
-0.2357252836,
-0.1640047729,
-0.8331978321,
0.4141737819,
-0.2405647486,
-0.4836448431,
0.3229978979,
-0.1135393381,
-0.2546975017,
0.1933352798,
-0.981851697,
0.5036147237,
-0.1490915865,
-0.2481401265,
-0.3653283417,
-0.6510908604,
-0.0050469553,
-0.0155319478,
0.2070942819,
0.2216850072,
-0.2205750793,
0.2805176079,
-0.5074273944,
0.638051033,
0.129193157,
0.1882269382,
0.187727496,
0.0401649699,
0.1920082569,
-0.1520472616,
-0.1761121899,
0.1863934696,
0.0476632714,
-0.5823975205,
-0.6708849669,
0.7700547576,
-0.695091784,
-0.3029561341,
-0.6155870557,
-0.6705778241,
-0.1156553403,
0.327316761,
0.3190719187,
0.4408807158,
0.0587376207,
0.151538074,
0.583850801,
-0.372333616,
0.4690336883,
0.2970024943,
-0.0181327611,
-0.493730247,
0.8668243885,
0.1996112019,
0.3046293557,
0.8439301848,
0.0306079909,
-0.4922177792,
-0.8238230944,
-0.794852078,
0.3326580822,
-0.6124537587,
-0.2682408392,
-0.6364220381,
-0.3317176402,
-0.5876010656,
-0.2990203202,
-0.3623276651,
-0.603964746,
0.3790350556,
0.2664549351,
0.3376773,
0.5452353954,
-0.2547363043,
0.3115798831,
-0.779691577,
-0.0067703277,
0.0345895365,
0.1711289138,
-0.1304581612,
-0.4800932109,
-0.3356783688,
0.0227340907,
-0.1596684754,
-0.7228257656,
0.5981334448,
0.1461690813,
0.5963005424,
-0.0679827109,
-0.2415626645,
0.7784083486,
-0.661722064,
0.4695061445,
0.2749244869,
-0.8893445134,
0.5320956707,
-0.260219723,
0.2414599657,
0.4807732999,
0.3952538967,
-0.7726409435,
-0.2335329354,
-0.2845467031,
-0.8058699965,
0.3569096327,
0.3577308655,
0.1583881229,
0.0523126237,
0.3308651149,
0.1946681589,
0.1893595755,
-0.2822218537,
-0.2296970487,
-0.1267014146,
-0.2184463441,
-0.1113014519,
-0.0071994946,
0.2948574722,
-0.187787354,
0.401684463,
0.2031869739,
0.4605355263,
0.279586792,
-0.3532764912,
0.01651356,
0.6500812769,
0.9253206849,
0.3628646731,
-0.2286333442,
0.1956174821,
0.3113634586,
-0.545861423,
0.1610086858,
-0.0526730977,
-0.1984247118,
0.122061491,
0.4085081816,
0.56735605,
0.17578803,
-0.3786797523,
0.1091390476,
0.0822432414,
0.1278403401,
-0.1352067888,
-0.2761745751,
0.2282605767,
0.0674356371,
0.0984497443,
0.5400025249,
0.0385840796,
-0.7547743917,
-0.0935657099,
0.2643724084,
-0.4683229327,
-0.3226290047,
0.3708104491,
0.2065297514,
-0.5447676778,
0.5533073545,
-0.2600830793,
-0.6336514354,
0.3659235537,
0.7639035583,
0.6677277088,
-0.4056612253,
-0.0404844657,
0.563039124,
0.5446680188,
-0.0756056979,
0.237155214,
0.0867957175,
-0.3393132389,
-0.5562061071,
-0.8383854032,
-0.4092374742,
-0.0958233252,
-0.4179157615,
0.2592046857,
-0.4539096653,
0.0566292815,
-0.1407275796,
-0.0636806414,
-0.6986014843,
-0.0353074186,
0.0137579534,
0.5977317691,
-0.7245028615,
0.9484846592,
0.7726863027,
-0.761854589,
-0.8629888892,
-0.292086482,
-0.046265021,
-0.9730114937,
0.5867212415,
-0.1039029062,
-0.1954533011,
-0.0361372493,
0.0552341156,
-0.9634102583,
0.9463919997,
0.3987019956,
-0.6166316271,
0.1573935747,
0.5109752417,
0.8976435661,
-0.4996027052,
0.0491757356,
0.2493345439,
0.3922619224,
-0.0234031677,
-1.0164628029,
0.1979465336,
-0.4114615023,
0.2883439362,
0.4930693507,
-0.4566504657,
0.7581554651,
-0.0241388045,
-0.294836998,
0.1195247844,
0.4034395218,
-0.1214873195,
0.1281780303,
0.152272895,
0.4697439671,
0.3685335517,
0.0743649974,
1.1443934441,
-0.3404718935,
-0.0255002175,
0.8406068683,
-0.0193147417,
1.0087965727,
0.7308812141,
-0.0681559965,
0.2503395677,
0.3533389866,
0.1895248294,
0.5937476158,
0.2079692781,
-0.0181664899,
0.0159439631,
-0.4298150539,
-0.7509596348,
0.5184894204,
0.5096658468,
-0.4955305755,
-0.2313560694,
0.0985382572,
-0.0064949533,
0.5553922653,
-0.2248140126,
0.513785243,
0.3152635396,
-0.6682145,
0.8199657202,
0.1942915171,
0.9603644609,
-0.4825844765,
-0.1844244897,
-0.4223536849,
0.2042304873,
-0.0686232895,
-0.4650439322,
0.7220790982,
0.0294539127,
-0.2402746081,
-0.4462080598,
0.6004320383,
-0.5955494046,
-0.4610352516,
0.3365111053,
0.7165254354,
0.4103429019,
0.1126023084,
-0.5158715844,
0.079709962,
-0.2002580762,
0.4638710022,
0.4225317836,
0.4619838297,
-0.2395202965,
0.3179135323,
0.6090741158,
0.3975345194,
0.3278702199,
-0.0432843044,
0.4148787558,
-0.6206802726,
-0.3052917719,
-0.8027743101,
0.1626934856,
0.0289822295,
-0.3044050336,
0.7682082057,
0.524489224,
0.8842718601,
-0.3195972741,
0.6871810555,
-0.1031057015,
0.4332027733,
-0.4794351459,
0.7567562461,
-0.4895021915,
0.0200292636,
-0.3195524216,
-1.1971867085,
-0.4434877634,
0.5826666951,
-0.0796887577,
-0.2100180835,
0.9869846106,
0.8675022125,
-0.206314072,
-0.4771896005,
0.5735536218,
-0.1084903851,
-0.0714438185,
0.7213842869,
0.6185620427,
-0.6868060827,
0.9053822756,
-0.1091726571,
-0.2226310074,
-0.0953234732,
-0.6195661426,
-0.727170229,
-0.7347990274,
-0.2508160174,
-0.2512388825,
0.1388770044,
1.0327179432,
0.6567201018,
-0.7319797277,
-0.0875218138,
0.124682568,
0.2006260902,
-0.428669095,
-0.0826463327,
0.5664620996,
-0.3647142649,
-1.1519286633,
0.2929087281,
0.7192476988,
0.1087455004,
-0.2319188714,
-0.0826428905,
-0.4362486005,
0.0845586434,
0.6715309024,
0.4386633039,
-0.676428616,
-0.0643834472,
0.1851027459,
-0.5364724994,
0.1997188181,
0.8022343516,
-0.4531942904,
0.3473964334,
0.7430585623,
0.8327950239,
0.326399684,
-0.4230342805,
0.5274728537,
-0.6577653289,
0.337500304,
-0.0106546218,
0.273185581,
0.6293516755,
-0.3203648627,
0.6158733368,
0.2126505822,
-0.1524736583,
-0.6743097901,
0.1983685344,
-1.2050070763,
0.0325584114,
1.0398116112,
-0.0315801352,
-0.3913586438,
-0.2286955714,
-0.293250531,
0.52896595,
-0.4072897434,
0.6287044883,
0.5083531737,
0.0924587622,
-0.0060947016,
-0.4527880847,
0.2544311881,
0.4755681753,
-0.4489493072,
-0.3887223601,
-0.1271581948,
0.184327364,
0.6776567101,
0.544873178,
-0.5825642943,
0.1047800779,
0.2076684982,
0.1367342025,
-0.0578779057,
0.0170140602,
-0.3549832106,
0.0544335432,
-0.0268115681,
-0.5873152614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12351v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12351v2 | Are Your Explanations Reliable? Investigating the Stability of LIME in Explaining Text Classifiers by Marrying XAI and Adversarial Attack | 2023-05-21T05:06:46 | 2023-10-15T13:19:44 | Christopher Burger, Lingwei Chen, Thai Le | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | LIME has emerged as one of the most commonly referenced tools in explainable
AI (XAI) frameworks that is integrated into critical machine learning
applications--e.g., healthcare and finance. However, its stability remains
little explored, especially in the context of text data, due to the unique
text-space constraints. To address these challenges, in this paper, we first
evaluate the inherent instability of LIME on text data to establish a baseline,
and then propose a novel algorithm XAIFooler to perturb text inputs and
manipulate explanations that casts investigation on the stability of LIME as a
text perturbation optimization problem. XAIFooler conforms to the constraints
to preserve text semantics and original prediction with small perturbations,
and introduces Rank-biased Overlap (RBO) as a key part to guide the
optimization of XAIFooler that satisfies all the requirements for explanation
similarity measure. Extensive experiments on real-world text datasets
demonstrate that XAIFooler significantly outperforms all baselines by large
margins in its ability to manipulate LIME's explanations with high semantic
preservability. | [
-0.0464917123,
-0.7625262737,
0.5141649246,
0.1996891201,
-0.1347247958,
0.0429435894,
-0.1137958243,
-0.2746792138,
-0.0366808027,
0.3267918229,
-0.3208344281,
-0.1007210165,
-0.5935637355,
-0.2344586551,
-0.5283065438,
1.3561933041,
-0.1399001479,
0.0330406539,
-0.0773326829,
-0.2465570867,
-0.6957636476,
-0.2785255611,
-0.7711890936,
-0.4135485888,
0.6845607162,
0.4585087597,
1.2870141268,
0.81279248,
0.292660147,
0.4524276853,
-0.2371950597,
0.0055067474,
-0.7745108008,
0.4166429043,
-0.1412527114,
-0.5473006964,
0.0122113442,
-0.0697395951,
0.5550149679,
0.4382007718,
0.1206295043,
-0.1819743514,
0.1840118915,
0.6464414001,
-0.7606021762,
-0.0466619246,
-0.7871823311,
-0.262396574,
-0.1262057275,
-0.4608700573,
-0.538993597,
-0.3822937906,
0.5385221243,
-0.5564952493,
0.1898639053,
0.0249979645,
1.2554917336,
0.4808569849,
-0.3202291727,
-0.2139661163,
-0.8028560877,
0.7344802618,
0.1814384907,
0.0596662611,
0.0100738117,
0.5654740334,
-0.3160569668,
-0.7163677216,
-0.6141815782,
-0.0516326278,
-0.2549832165,
0.1718135476,
-0.0348780565,
0.1906110346,
-0.3195199966,
0.4468044341,
-0.5829648972,
-0.1363900155,
-0.1232362166,
-0.2265421003,
0.4814402759,
-0.0273325779,
0.2958273292,
0.0013653164,
-0.7462177873,
-0.1963591725,
-0.6485270262,
0.2628850639,
0.1350819319,
-0.0251781475,
0.1345008016,
0.2935897112,
0.3683885932,
0.5028398037,
0.1351232976,
-0.0589963868,
-0.1535088718,
-0.2103826255,
-0.2861881852,
0.5311909318,
0.6394867301,
0.2688008845,
0.201195851,
-0.2591258287,
0.1071901098,
0.2423087955,
0.2982373238,
-0.6988348365,
-0.3052301109,
0.633577168,
-0.3831740022,
-0.6779283881,
-0.1297242045,
-0.5688602924,
-0.6468205452,
0.0749685839,
0.7021087408,
-0.3326630592,
0.0146311605,
-0.1487856209,
-0.422850281,
-0.0420753509,
0.4680493772,
-0.8605805039,
0.1624045223,
0.5561023951,
0.7746825814,
0.1675289571,
-0.209075734,
-0.4124811292,
0.1173359305,
-0.3423464298,
0.4828132093,
-0.289380759,
-0.2295365185,
-0.2772102058,
-0.2572134435,
-0.0842211246,
-0.1814283431,
0.4116365314,
-0.6345877647,
0.2871879637,
-0.0360396877,
-0.3060527742,
-0.0321180597,
0.3621726036,
-0.7279908657,
0.8014793992,
0.10743393,
-1.1957364082,
0.4677371085,
-0.6018417478,
-0.2197676301,
0.0443331152,
-0.3562403619,
-0.6549425125,
0.0036163183,
0.0472669043,
0.1052046865,
-0.2843166888,
0.3226591051,
-0.1818134785,
-0.4637141824,
0.621525526,
-0.6925585866,
1.1251524687,
0.0958292931,
-0.6050068736,
0.2411058247,
-0.6013475657,
0.0533734336,
0.14005436,
-0.002651412,
-0.4796663821,
0.2058739364,
0.1575107723,
0.1125092506,
0.1081086546,
-0.5243526697,
-0.0976296812,
-0.2574084103,
0.5132821202,
0.928620398,
-0.1909899563,
0.209286958,
-0.4577029943,
0.5532960892,
-0.2583103776,
0.0011066401,
-0.5606358647,
-0.369391948,
-0.5162062049,
-0.2997698784,
0.5856311321,
0.6189945936,
-0.6401509643,
-0.0837306306,
-0.5013272166,
-0.4737036824,
-0.4819992483,
0.0202923566,
0.6673093438,
0.6798319817,
0.1706429273,
0.1015965939,
-0.4062365592,
-0.6601027846,
-0.4476464689,
-0.6103124619,
0.4041775167,
0.2680863142,
0.2352504879,
-0.2267634273,
1.3331400156,
-0.3420245349,
-0.0181696825,
-0.1463825405,
0.2777200937,
-0.0748882145,
0.5673243403,
0.8290017843,
-1.4305948019,
-0.5104721785,
0.3532483876,
-0.7584095001,
0.0764783174,
-0.3979871869,
-0.1524936706,
0.1886551678,
0.1837379783,
-0.2884458899,
0.6815841794,
0.5485808849,
-0.4242281914,
0.6460995674,
-0.1861603558,
0.1354377419,
-0.6899500489,
-0.0631278753,
0.1039515957,
-0.4858609438,
-0.7267069817,
0.1135214716,
0.0360683836,
-0.1405300796,
-0.1268203408,
0.76086092,
-0.2224770486,
0.5564712882,
-0.448071748,
0.2829514146,
-0.0129191848,
-0.0396160595,
0.0021943494,
0.6122472286,
0.5339395404,
-0.4389451742,
0.0611201786,
0.2563614547,
-0.0363412201,
0.1191680059,
-0.8925075531,
-0.1804327071,
-0.2480221242,
0.2470831722,
-1.3267793655,
-0.0970411897,
0.1137554944,
-0.8966430426,
0.3567247689,
-0.4573574066,
-0.0870774016,
-0.0642319322,
-0.4513125122,
0.5408313274,
0.2976273298,
-0.8518032432,
0.6315456033,
0.1761863083,
-0.1404938996,
-1.0932970047,
-0.630213201,
0.10437987,
-0.352209717,
-0.9726810455,
0.6102328897,
-0.0562147051,
-0.5157564878,
0.0893649831,
-0.5338208079,
-0.2531180084,
0.4180672467,
0.5347757936,
0.2798645198,
-0.186357975,
-0.0594650432,
0.1993895173,
-0.4546221793,
0.219980225,
-0.418957293,
0.2521158457,
0.0150155565,
0.2639762759,
-0.4406709671,
-0.2307941616,
0.5966153741,
0.2302132696,
0.9118651152,
0.2659847736,
-0.1483279169,
-0.011398769,
-0.2155427784,
0.3107367456,
-0.57321769,
0.2787223458,
-0.4396397769,
-0.7592759132,
0.4387084842,
0.1877916604,
0.1360495985,
0.2327728868,
0.4190638959,
-0.1106136888,
0.9404041171,
0.7110472918,
-0.2994628549,
0.3809455037,
-0.077830568,
0.1447034329,
-0.168836236,
-0.0043265256,
-0.5241094232,
-0.1990487874,
-0.8671774268,
-0.083680287,
0.2229501456,
0.0079176016,
-0.115483284,
0.039398931,
-0.3496942222,
0.6893056035,
0.1910487562,
-0.0555775017,
0.0407292806,
0.0409007035,
0.0287186354,
0.0555474311,
-0.6262800694,
-0.5645621419,
0.6933008432,
0.4163165092,
0.7982351184,
0.0850735232,
0.5906607509,
0.4717788398,
0.2025654316,
-0.4139105082,
0.0973474905,
-0.2571453154,
-0.8911656737,
-0.4660310149,
-0.5461751223,
-1.2202422619,
0.4799374938,
-0.1412870437,
-0.8683782816,
0.2033510357,
0.7128823996,
-0.1993631423,
-0.0333002992,
-0.5506614447,
1.0537561178,
-0.6636821628,
-0.6288975477,
-0.051348161,
-0.8175845146,
0.2895243764,
0.0254876669,
0.3283250034,
0.2871578932,
0.1261785775,
0.4864777029,
-0.8546692729,
0.5263747573,
-0.287026763,
-0.1443659067,
0.1277139485,
-0.0073405132,
0.1671018004,
0.31446293,
-0.2466447204,
-0.1025338173,
-0.0645133406,
-0.72950387,
-0.9648483396,
0.7472535372,
-0.8316027522,
-0.5951374769,
-0.6157281995,
-0.3508737683,
0.0772127584,
0.2222073823,
0.444583118,
0.3932645023,
-0.1102611497,
0.2009221613,
0.808534503,
0.0435009897,
0.2488243431,
0.0553766787,
-0.2592260242,
-0.5448173881,
1.1589554548,
0.0705282763,
0.2778646052,
0.7454528213,
0.4059800208,
0.038313929,
-0.7310743928,
-0.6678384542,
-0.1459469944,
-0.61826998,
0.0310741849,
-0.2883499265,
-0.2019908726,
-0.0908832848,
-0.3968870044,
-0.0703547746,
-0.6736155748,
-0.0071255323,
-0.0423187204,
0.2979136109,
0.5698801279,
0.3402834833,
0.7080534101,
-0.6469099522,
0.2862994671,
0.0486589447,
0.0991697758,
-0.0613398328,
-0.433694154,
-0.357652992,
0.1046658978,
-0.1283187419,
-1.1275062561,
0.2076488733,
0.1270659119,
0.5263425708,
0.9478834271,
0.1447732896,
0.8208538294,
-0.2047502697,
0.6901232004,
-0.0556014404,
-1.133684516,
0.596467495,
-0.2335519344,
0.029370036,
0.7096831203,
0.5609464645,
-0.2923819125,
-0.5023546219,
-0.5310615301,
-1.1467210054,
0.633441627,
0.7297590971,
-0.1380271465,
0.1935320199,
0.8457033038,
0.225128144,
-0.0005346274,
-0.9384462237,
-0.7752049565,
-0.3901259899,
-0.2938559055,
0.1030035093,
-0.23867926,
0.009898915,
0.1942826658,
0.9242170453,
-0.0710436702,
-0.0568757541,
0.1626088172,
-0.4636743069,
0.1200287342,
0.0824727565,
0.3548914492,
0.6603038907,
-0.1501551121,
0.1759727299,
-0.2286648005,
-0.9296810031,
0.4077940285,
0.3478446603,
-0.4699754119,
0.0021815433,
0.443877399,
0.5087876916,
0.0004377071,
-0.7436796427,
0.4838525653,
-0.5668575168,
0.0163014047,
-0.3980375528,
0.3457946181,
-0.5154461265,
-0.0285940953,
0.4963576794,
0.1533602476,
0.019391546,
-0.4426854551,
-0.0831659213,
0.5272958875,
-0.7136067748,
-0.1038127169,
0.8525363803,
0.195928961,
0.0712370574,
0.4688476324,
-0.0231625251,
-0.7821484208,
0.7461664677,
0.4151436388,
0.6788926721,
-0.0782093704,
0.2112406492,
-0.2439499944,
0.4270577431,
0.0472224019,
0.267031163,
-0.2293845862,
-0.7940875292,
-0.3077228665,
-0.1893177032,
-0.4313681424,
-0.0872155279,
-0.7007500529,
0.3030728996,
-0.6904296279,
0.0005329784,
0.4338594675,
0.0838532895,
-0.0218461975,
0.6606888175,
-0.0841522738,
0.9006876945,
-0.9382882714,
0.7591219544,
0.7695947289,
-0.4275457561,
-0.4039451182,
0.2139340341,
0.3537803888,
-0.6608774662,
0.618067801,
0.4214931726,
-0.3812252879,
-0.486081332,
-0.5732896328,
-0.9005194306,
1.040484786,
0.5156601667,
-0.3786827326,
0.1662805229,
-0.122415863,
0.5114066005,
-0.0029990212,
0.4142166078,
0.6172956824,
0.6237174273,
-0.0682676286,
-0.6479340792,
-0.034123119,
-0.5859851837,
-0.0286705643,
0.4425682425,
-0.8445059061,
0.5234891176,
-0.1499112844,
-0.0375772268,
0.5558933616,
0.7692611814,
0.2750211656,
0.604481101,
0.60590446,
0.4910244048,
0.9328857064,
-0.3335542381,
1.0789641142,
-0.2718391418,
0.1795032322,
1.0778743029,
-0.1104117259,
0.3722094297,
0.271655947,
0.04532893,
0.8907114863,
0.7257694602,
0.1221922338,
0.3806607723,
0.2012981176,
-0.1525023282,
0.0668052286,
0.3117889166,
-0.1560742855,
0.4515306652,
0.3290609121,
-0.5315807462,
0.1165935323,
0.0264435001,
0.2220864594,
0.0381635353,
-0.3335841,
0.5844879746,
-0.4511482418,
-0.551682055,
0.6069359779,
-0.0369368605,
0.2605506182,
-0.6384863853,
0.0194938183,
0.0118566258,
0.5429136157,
-0.3373453021,
-0.6188483834,
0.0348394625,
-0.1644799262,
-0.6298434734,
-0.2274680734,
0.769589901,
-0.1752356738,
-0.2196186036,
0.2293229997,
-0.2212672234,
0.2977111638,
0.0906414241,
-0.6236051917,
0.032703504,
0.1887875199,
0.1009357721,
0.2602775097,
0.7123038173,
-0.3313633502,
0.6880553365,
0.1580757648,
0.0317252986,
0.0516130812,
-0.2896094918,
0.7864025235,
-0.6947774291,
-0.6213512421,
-1.031668067,
0.6531407237,
-0.1371017545,
-0.4014376998,
0.9084857106,
0.5365029573,
0.5975679755,
0.493532598,
1.0625559092,
-0.105909355,
0.1087402031,
-0.5090369582,
0.9132971168,
-0.5010914207,
0.4070748091,
-0.4207170308,
-0.6417962313,
-0.3591733873,
0.5426582694,
0.0185254179,
0.2205713391,
0.6843084693,
0.5198304057,
0.1389340758,
0.2839395404,
-0.0911511034,
0.5496470332,
0.3233376443,
-0.1104390174,
0.7464564443,
-0.3945969045,
1.0222293139,
-0.3076957762,
-0.5467578769,
-0.2902823091,
-0.9346318841,
-0.7501413822,
-0.2933392525,
-0.556640625,
-0.6999983191,
0.5962153673,
0.5755121708,
0.8092905879,
-0.7706680298,
-0.0599535629,
-0.2651046216,
0.5857663751,
-0.3826797009,
-0.2797608376,
0.4287721515,
-0.4379940629,
-0.5271494389,
0.1636969298,
0.2956798673,
-0.0202505216,
-0.2530836761,
-0.1850250065,
0.2276130915,
0.1099441797,
0.3225963116,
0.4167716205,
-0.5918180943,
-0.0378813744,
-0.2456230372,
0.2790671587,
0.0540143475,
0.896761179,
-0.9934257865,
0.7219465971,
0.5897902846,
0.8594480753,
0.3793921173,
0.334826231,
0.7078358531,
-0.6770156026,
-0.0974684805,
-0.0512525626,
0.362965107,
0.1773722023,
-0.6616352201,
0.3662368059,
-0.1165339723,
-0.7917926908,
-0.8359451294,
-0.0802374855,
-0.8329307437,
-0.4999704361,
0.7084938288,
-0.3443926871,
-0.5088869929,
-0.3540912569,
-0.280634135,
-0.0377554074,
-0.5147604942,
1.028567791,
0.60192734,
-0.3169161379,
-0.1542174071,
0.0498060435,
0.3269244134,
0.5663072467,
-0.4453752637,
0.120139882,
0.35093683,
0.1613141745,
0.6444205046,
0.3285939097,
-0.0912814215,
0.8006985784,
0.0298695564,
-0.3498751223,
0.193808943,
-0.5418803692,
-0.4856210649,
0.2606763244,
0.1881065071,
-0.3104162514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12330v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12330v1 | Task-agnostic Distillation of Encoder-Decoder Language Models | 2023-05-21T03:35:45 | 2023-05-21T03:35:45 | Chen Zhang, Yang Yang, Jingang Wang, Dawei Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Finetuning pretrained language models (LMs) have enabled appealing
performance on a diverse array of tasks. The intriguing task-agnostic property
has driven a shifted focus from task-specific to task-agnostic distillation of
LMs. While task-agnostic, compute-efficient, performance-preserved LMs can be
yielded by task-agnostic distillation, previous studies mainly sit in
distillation of either encoder-only LMs (e.g., BERT) or decoder-only ones
(e.g., GPT) yet largely neglect that distillation of encoder-decoder LMs (e.g.,
T5) can posit very distinguished behaviors. Frustratingly, we discover that
existing task-agnostic distillation methods can fail to handle the distillation
of encoder-decoder LMs. To the demand, we explore a few paths and uncover a
path named as MiniEnD that successfully tackles the distillation of
encoder-decoder LMs in a task-agnostic fashion. We examine MiniEnD on language
understanding and abstractive summarization. The results showcase that MiniEnD
is generally effective and is competitive compared to other alternatives. We
further scale MiniEnD up to distillation of 3B encoder-decoder language models
with interpolated distillation. The results imply the opportunities and
challenges in distilling large language models (e.g., LLaMA). | [
-0.3269023895,
-0.7275154591,
0.663944602,
0.0482708216,
-0.2672676742,
0.2159511298,
-0.3382162452,
-0.3069340289,
0.0504526943,
0.2515016496,
-0.6912710071,
-0.091157265,
-0.9385740757,
0.5039812326,
-0.5423032045,
1.2053127289,
0.0200619828,
-0.2655999959,
-0.3650730252,
-0.1186283007,
-0.3073363602,
-0.5888602734,
-0.6143656969,
-0.6993142366,
0.3687541187,
0.2402034551,
0.4706376195,
0.7119504213,
0.2020157278,
0.2848437726,
-0.1912947744,
0.0808841214,
-0.4946493804,
0.109593153,
-0.1090254933,
-0.6821652651,
-0.4198124111,
-0.0610276423,
0.2218971103,
0.7523063421,
-0.3326413333,
0.3107725978,
0.4914285839,
0.8376651406,
-0.7615609169,
0.154958114,
-0.815805614,
-0.2773088515,
-0.2938572466,
0.1789551079,
-0.3348498344,
-0.1603172719,
-0.0241365191,
-0.3191583455,
0.41929546,
-0.0449752994,
0.6058770418,
0.6431279778,
-0.1683306247,
-0.6718115211,
-0.8772702217,
0.7339302897,
-0.7977108359,
0.2168273479,
0.4727571011,
0.4351177514,
-0.0776008293,
-0.802595675,
-0.6727485657,
-0.2236583531,
-0.2135915905,
-0.1133479401,
-0.6147187948,
0.330304116,
0.3372881114,
0.7195605636,
-0.4182682931,
0.0676455423,
-0.1796361804,
0.060268186,
0.1633543372,
0.2147875428,
0.1452907324,
0.1028594971,
-0.0619057529,
0.1537923664,
-0.7475657463,
0.0998257026,
0.2430069,
0.2654920518,
0.0489534102,
0.40093261,
-0.2627711296,
0.6754255295,
0.4162863493,
-0.2830784917,
0.0495813005,
-0.5324680209,
-0.194452405,
0.2034979761,
0.7945375443,
-0.011839035,
0.324493438,
-0.0845463276,
-0.3444200158,
0.323535651,
0.0797944516,
-1.0003014803,
-0.5854925513,
0.4253635108,
-0.4129921496,
-0.0926481858,
-0.4745115638,
-0.2362565398,
-0.2384819537,
-0.1933999509,
0.414486587,
-0.3750188649,
-0.2265868187,
0.1038394868,
-0.1836938113,
-0.2292080522,
0.2650040984,
-1.3989577293,
0.6139481664,
0.6627039909,
0.9273575544,
-0.1186257452,
-0.1503803879,
-0.4112600088,
0.0600965656,
-0.0648397952,
0.4988153577,
-0.4228201509,
-0.2906115353,
-0.3397997916,
-0.0415468551,
0.1241922379,
-0.8155082464,
0.4121531546,
-0.2453787774,
-0.1604067832,
-0.3845351636,
-0.5295036435,
-0.0293603484,
0.2935997844,
-0.6688753963,
0.810426414,
-0.2941357493,
-0.7401491404,
0.3754829764,
-0.6798736453,
-0.4227909148,
-0.1861366183,
-0.0631686077,
-0.2000100613,
0.6007309556,
0.3757446408,
0.3003930748,
-0.2742298841,
0.2741473019,
-0.154855445,
-0.3957032263,
-0.1429328173,
-0.6062826514,
0.7337441444,
0.4724055827,
-0.2736818194,
-0.1510541737,
-0.6190917492,
-0.3329661191,
0.0652074441,
-0.2615584433,
-0.6653280854,
0.2613444328,
-0.3700212836,
0.1434562057,
0.4678804278,
-0.6396220922,
0.2096716464,
-0.2034078985,
0.6224544048,
0.5108005404,
-0.2859368026,
0.3945392668,
-0.2095994353,
0.4440928102,
0.1103647798,
0.0642217845,
-0.3509521484,
-0.2166631222,
-0.9450134635,
-0.4422983527,
0.2037641853,
0.4484281838,
-1.0570466518,
0.1623467654,
-0.3898865283,
-0.5221200585,
-0.7882670164,
0.1491778046,
0.4744746089,
0.4122550488,
0.4325489104,
0.035047967,
-0.4368756413,
-0.9718437791,
-0.4468010366,
-0.1367555857,
-0.0511717722,
-0.2416907698,
0.4792964756,
-0.2724249661,
0.9543905854,
-0.4262717664,
-0.3781011403,
-0.5829355717,
0.1430604011,
0.7738263011,
0.372923404,
0.6384275556,
-0.4592021108,
-0.7375890613,
-0.1044786796,
-0.5906649232,
-0.3116164207,
0.1240919605,
0.4903553724,
-0.0197311286,
0.485629946,
-0.4839495122,
0.3167643547,
0.6960003376,
0.0410498306,
0.485226512,
-0.5312720537,
0.0326532498,
-0.938003242,
0.125260666,
-0.1323649287,
-0.570091188,
-0.9080198407,
-0.0716570839,
0.0306024179,
0.2472415715,
-0.2124482542,
0.3090305626,
-0.7250198126,
0.0958890095,
-0.7941018939,
-0.2090086341,
0.0095813386,
0.3819794357,
0.059166871,
0.7455555201,
0.4441585839,
-0.6275532246,
0.2061486691,
0.1085004881,
-0.2138213366,
0.1874363124,
-0.8396621346,
0.1983907223,
-0.2978248,
0.0453205965,
-0.9648812413,
0.156693399,
0.0025043429,
-0.2485323995,
0.3710610271,
-0.356997937,
-0.5409917235,
-0.2773333788,
-0.2249993831,
0.4918729067,
0.7687396407,
-0.5258536935,
0.6138063073,
0.263422519,
-0.378257215,
-0.7162287235,
-0.8834551573,
0.0844618008,
-0.2495689243,
-0.0577994585,
0.1738430113,
-0.1111219823,
-0.3186174631,
0.0385032408,
-0.3062211275,
0.0241995938,
0.059583202,
0.2319931835,
0.0017350712,
0.1129300147,
-0.2732898891,
0.3460998535,
-0.2110069841,
-0.1077584773,
-0.3322713375,
0.4132446945,
-0.2023348957,
-0.3683172464,
-0.1474205405,
0.2801231742,
0.4796819985,
0.0439606123,
0.6262713671,
0.3224512637,
-0.3469230533,
-0.1691042632,
-0.65307796,
-0.2332063317,
-0.5549108982,
0.3926436007,
-0.7167187333,
-1.0610011816,
0.6094079614,
-0.0678443685,
0.2549943924,
0.3148349226,
0.5840739012,
-0.2190273106,
0.8529092073,
0.993639648,
-0.1109762639,
0.4492410421,
-0.1711138785,
0.2446189672,
-0.5943092108,
0.1139174998,
-0.5288075805,
-0.4129388034,
-0.3693465292,
-0.076535739,
0.5244256258,
0.064990364,
0.0787386671,
0.4821152091,
-0.4696701467,
0.7170573473,
0.4600024819,
-0.2654434741,
0.6703659892,
0.0786014423,
-0.1172979772,
-0.0267212726,
-0.9397791028,
-0.5599905849,
0.878228128,
0.3611940742,
0.9196617007,
-0.028115917,
0.9223613143,
0.4604964852,
0.1304940283,
-0.6292350292,
0.4799261391,
-0.6449431181,
-0.6940134764,
-0.1926552206,
-0.255317837,
-0.8470828533,
0.3792708814,
0.1585074663,
-0.7804328203,
0.3416370153,
0.6141888499,
-0.4378881454,
0.233320564,
-0.69294101,
0.8993498683,
-0.0607871301,
-0.2285034508,
-0.2834679484,
-0.573636651,
0.3891980052,
-0.1513036489,
0.4214121997,
-0.1756527126,
0.0088746585,
0.4244472384,
-0.7858086228,
0.8094376922,
-0.3366320431,
-0.1690344512,
0.302801162,
0.3410984576,
0.7008287907,
-0.3000862598,
0.0236047115,
0.2486484498,
0.3556996286,
-0.1902511269,
-0.5497201085,
0.6932342052,
-0.5052309632,
-0.8243510723,
-0.4711054862,
-0.3452108204,
-0.1625523418,
0.3332601786,
0.4918434024,
0.2689207196,
-0.118284829,
-0.1094363853,
0.6227895617,
0.2533711195,
0.7300708294,
0.3316318393,
-0.1584483385,
-0.1281404495,
0.9318765402,
0.0189487971,
0.5633018613,
0.4083904326,
0.0741445869,
-0.468277961,
-0.9475979805,
-0.4165839851,
0.0525007583,
-0.7552747726,
0.018399002,
-0.7084040642,
0.1349344254,
-0.043343436,
0.076810658,
-0.6748223901,
-0.3998027742,
-0.2991916835,
0.012182815,
0.2464876771,
0.7763464451,
-0.1030785367,
0.2989536822,
-0.9463655949,
0.4880280495,
0.3156709373,
-0.0117598837,
0.0903342217,
-0.5511002541,
-0.4661507905,
0.4049213231,
-0.0473466851,
-0.6348075867,
0.328286767,
0.4463730454,
0.5229921341,
0.2937869728,
0.2289675027,
0.8068582416,
-0.842115283,
0.7349401116,
0.2977212667,
-1.1156781912,
0.3946458399,
-0.1906589121,
0.5305145383,
0.9335180521,
0.3297693431,
-0.4112149477,
-0.46737203,
-0.2246226221,
-0.7783074975,
0.665160358,
0.2602342963,
0.1121968701,
-0.0244618282,
0.2351521552,
0.5582160354,
0.5060444474,
-0.7752235532,
-0.2419382334,
-0.2864559889,
-0.3853681684,
-0.2633324862,
-0.4007516503,
0.1176361963,
-0.2421853244,
0.4602277577,
-0.1141543016,
0.0732893646,
0.0297152791,
-0.3819866478,
0.2853858173,
0.3549419343,
0.3268595636,
0.4956844151,
-0.1262947172,
0.4618636668,
0.2096889317,
-0.6373099089,
0.5525383949,
0.0895533636,
-0.1333364546,
0.1778941303,
0.3116538525,
0.8884462118,
-0.1781914532,
-0.5391626358,
0.4319505692,
-0.0932814851,
-0.0886241123,
-0.2247681171,
0.1869300902,
0.1549133807,
0.3138435185,
0.4333830178,
-0.0128900018,
0.4204197824,
-0.695199132,
-0.1306269765,
0.3265758157,
-0.2967689335,
-0.5578768849,
0.8471589088,
0.1375884265,
0.0867060721,
0.33511585,
-0.2865212262,
-0.2780534923,
0.3148520589,
0.4167909622,
1.2009276152,
-0.1493627429,
-0.3227789104,
0.0950324237,
0.419629097,
-0.2739787102,
0.1409154832,
-0.4625579119,
-0.5721458793,
-0.5169346929,
-0.8283135295,
-0.2276286036,
-0.0863334388,
-0.6406418085,
0.0376795903,
-0.158708185,
-0.3420619965,
-0.0639339089,
-0.3282323778,
-0.5084142685,
-0.0028850446,
0.1709651649,
0.8095676303,
-0.8009580374,
1.2918425798,
0.7243145704,
-0.088642858,
-0.4847668707,
0.1226863936,
-0.1567328423,
-0.5342873931,
0.6027197242,
-0.0617517233,
-0.3707431853,
0.0820644572,
-0.1662341654,
-0.58808285,
1.0666321516,
0.5889254212,
-0.9550127983,
-0.3429939747,
0.2450501025,
0.5860995054,
-0.148016274,
0.2123520672,
0.8187431097,
0.1211220622,
0.0425453,
-1.4537149668,
0.0714202598,
-0.3306477368,
0.1608922631,
0.1506450474,
-0.4881760776,
0.9069080353,
-0.1987597793,
-0.2567650378,
-0.1028585061,
0.5229743123,
0.212792024,
0.203855738,
0.5044674873,
0.4447585046,
0.3282124996,
-0.2034391612,
0.8656767607,
-0.2357171178,
0.2885971069,
1.2660106421,
-0.1160599366,
0.6709811687,
0.7473578453,
-0.4356327355,
0.3355960548,
0.4268316329,
0.3737799525,
1.0146203041,
0.0243853051,
-0.3564016223,
-0.1913350374,
0.1372412294,
-0.2255092263,
0.36171785,
0.4500467479,
-0.1327934563,
-0.4267916083,
0.2074316889,
-0.0193626899,
0.0487096757,
-0.464292109,
0.9513480663,
0.3901077509,
-0.610963881,
0.9115535021,
-0.0506944507,
1.0346250534,
-0.7896812558,
0.0914591849,
-0.1601572335,
0.4087981582,
-0.1148405522,
-0.3506143093,
0.5541474223,
0.191308111,
-0.3616770208,
-0.3557997346,
0.8851525784,
-0.6213037372,
-0.2213741839,
0.1506353319,
0.5839502215,
0.0667295754,
-0.1469762474,
-0.3854988813,
0.2129881978,
0.1564639211,
-0.1774878502,
0.4981417358,
0.4403266013,
0.2046047002,
0.7049154639,
0.4317303002,
0.1233831421,
0.1212075502,
-0.2999171019,
0.9158933759,
-0.3384902179,
-0.6823108196,
-1.4238673449,
0.5412427187,
0.259791702,
0.1565858275,
0.8608884811,
0.4240715206,
0.7422744632,
-0.399749279,
1.0301017761,
-0.1081200242,
0.3834334016,
-0.4716869295,
0.8574824333,
-0.6818077564,
0.3028211296,
-0.2706966996,
-0.9533495307,
0.194900915,
0.292568326,
-0.3004026711,
-0.0283927675,
0.5852118134,
0.3250017166,
-0.2191242576,
-0.0942346603,
0.3599994481,
0.1897410154,
0.3701337576,
0.6858446002,
0.7318207622,
-0.1779414117,
0.3953029513,
-0.1767027527,
-0.2529140413,
-0.1516266316,
-1.0892326832,
-1.0202660561,
-0.5220893025,
-0.2306675315,
-0.0054557803,
0.1845724285,
0.8701084256,
0.4506068826,
-0.8537422419,
-0.3938179612,
-0.3125478625,
-0.1702005267,
-0.3080212474,
-0.0804981813,
0.1164828166,
-0.2689888775,
-1.0443785191,
0.3397822082,
0.3464643359,
0.2032946646,
-0.1134876981,
0.071764335,
0.078616783,
-0.0349574126,
0.5684307218,
0.3506343365,
-0.7500222325,
0.0144949853,
-0.2386882156,
0.0183713418,
-0.0682491809,
0.7762030959,
-0.779615283,
0.4592239857,
0.516502142,
0.5421482325,
0.7126808167,
-0.1920079738,
0.6261475682,
-0.8988640904,
0.4056417048,
0.2834523618,
0.517049253,
0.1010574177,
-0.1152423099,
0.2148287296,
0.1010454521,
-0.4252491593,
-0.899089396,
0.3437590003,
-0.5655711293,
-0.2302992642,
0.8813750744,
-0.3519351482,
-0.1188557446,
-0.1826602072,
0.054114677,
0.169744119,
-0.1739773303,
0.5113885403,
0.729716897,
-0.2919840813,
-0.2254931033,
-0.4808492362,
0.7581181526,
0.3510079384,
-0.5192946196,
0.326621294,
0.4349046946,
0.4889001548,
0.1031754762,
0.903486073,
0.1450104266,
-0.1054841504,
0.0658546239,
0.0872975588,
-0.6267784834,
-0.3279342949,
-0.3672735095,
0.0591920279,
0.4555458724,
-0.3518890738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13338v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13338v2 | Gene Set Summarization using Large Language Models | 2023-05-21T02:06:33 | 2023-05-25T19:10:13 | Marcin P. Joachimiak, J. Harry Caufield, Nomi L. Harris, Hyeongsik Kim, Christopher J. Mungall | q-bio.GN | q-bio.GN, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.QM | Molecular biologists frequently interpret gene lists derived from
high-throughput experiments and computational analysis. This is typically done
as a statistical enrichment analysis that measures the over- or
under-representation of biological function terms associated with genes or
their properties, based on curated assertions from a knowledge base (KB) such
as the Gene Ontology (GO). Interpreting gene lists can also be framed as a
textual summarization task, enabling the use of Large Language Models (LLMs),
potentially utilizing scientific texts directly and avoiding reliance on a KB.
We developed SPINDOCTOR (Structured Prompt Interpolation of Natural Language
Descriptions of Controlled Terms for Ontology Reporting), a method that uses
GPT models to perform gene set function summarization as a complement to
standard enrichment analysis. This method can use different sources of gene
functional information: (1) structured text derived from curated ontological KB
annotations, (2) ontology-free narrative gene summaries, or (3) direct model
retrieval.
We demonstrate that these methods are able to generate plausible and
biologically valid summary GO term lists for gene sets. However, GPT-based
approaches are unable to deliver reliable scores or p-values and often return
terms that are not statistically significant. Crucially, these methods were
rarely able to recapitulate the most precise and informative term from standard
enrichment, likely due to an inability to generalize and reason using an
ontology. Results are highly nondeterministic, with minor variations in prompt
resulting in radically different term lists. Our results show that at this
point, LLM-based methods are unsuitable as a replacement for standard term
enrichment analysis and that manual curation of ontological assertions remains
necessary. | [
-0.4888141155,
-0.7082799077,
0.6437396407,
-0.1822252125,
-0.1529736519,
0.2090349346,
-0.3205676973,
-0.1660089493,
0.5165148377,
0.6405465603,
-0.5276694894,
-0.3212722242,
-0.8251109719,
0.3374975622,
-0.6237850785,
1.2397054434,
0.2731334567,
0.0052955705,
-0.1826291978,
-0.000134978,
0.329223007,
-0.3661700785,
-0.0651472285,
-0.5261762142,
0.5563237071,
0.3245871067,
0.9050588012,
0.6482289433,
0.7955394983,
0.1903339028,
-0.4073770344,
0.3345538974,
-0.6226817369,
0.0609135143,
-0.294831723,
-0.2287626415,
-0.4875149131,
0.3233427405,
0.5383381248,
1.1314634085,
0.2757296562,
0.1314550787,
0.0527260527,
0.5298170447,
-0.4759916663,
0.2313361913,
-0.3555098176,
0.1697497368,
0.0163466949,
-0.4927331805,
-0.2445301712,
-0.3802930117,
0.3803036511,
-0.6334999204,
0.3965499997,
-0.2295546234,
0.6797684431,
0.2713027894,
-0.0756516159,
-0.4396637082,
-0.6120278239,
0.6388575435,
-0.9890725613,
0.0633999929,
0.4656890929,
-0.0335223302,
-0.4720926881,
-0.6538153887,
-0.6697691083,
-0.7287352681,
-0.2398571819,
0.1646541655,
-0.0225100126,
0.1141933873,
0.4919977784,
0.6677533984,
-0.6032664776,
-0.1265138239,
-0.4579798281,
0.086710602,
0.4350384176,
-0.1293091327,
0.4532390237,
-0.5001453161,
-0.0881360322,
-0.3772832155,
-0.743421793,
-0.2013687491,
0.2684929669,
0.4515539408,
0.0367233418,
1.0889201164,
-0.0360744596,
0.6371532083,
-0.1071518138,
-0.1692394614,
0.0885587931,
-0.3413077593,
-0.2272010446,
-0.1734383851,
0.7967317104,
0.3468797803,
0.2835859954,
-0.4272727966,
0.0253809299,
-0.367659986,
0.1490601599,
-0.6795087457,
-0.257090807,
0.4513108134,
-0.4989251792,
-0.5797053576,
0.2026821375,
-1.1359803677,
-0.5229975581,
-0.1857283711,
0.4954472482,
-0.4467464983,
-0.101032488,
-0.1174063608,
-0.633479476,
0.2156805843,
0.011987322,
-0.6550989151,
0.1346738786,
0.6128680706,
1.1182346344,
-0.3163234293,
-0.1132395118,
-0.5032503009,
0.2780787051,
-0.2491771132,
0.730566144,
-0.7193021178,
-0.8210473061,
-0.2538618445,
0.0790446699,
0.0554122925,
-0.3188653588,
0.1671602279,
-0.3769279122,
0.2592519522,
-0.4978716969,
-0.6914623976,
-0.2759616375,
0.0264586397,
-0.6292020679,
0.7057828903,
0.1746953279,
-0.9162806869,
0.1643899232,
-0.7137243748,
-0.3811405301,
0.2021115571,
-0.4780728519,
0.06088439,
0.0595825128,
0.1154726893,
0.7539122105,
-0.4619490802,
0.3460721076,
-0.4517095387,
-0.2163841873,
0.5468539,
0.0914559066,
0.6833299398,
0.1398362815,
-0.3367687762,
0.1831729859,
-0.712099731,
0.0683387667,
-0.1399088651,
0.0023266885,
-0.23611027,
0.1914091259,
-0.3187462687,
0.0514567792,
0.0691587329,
-0.4682121277,
0.5290629864,
-0.385404706,
0.4536886513,
0.5111073256,
-0.059293475,
0.363283962,
-0.2736687064,
0.6298965812,
-0.3074837923,
-0.3658562005,
-0.0771021098,
-0.5381037593,
-0.3633434176,
-0.5595842004,
0.2844838798,
0.6974935532,
-0.9169309735,
0.6961296797,
-0.723800838,
-0.5792894959,
-0.0111554489,
-0.1371496022,
0.4084161222,
0.8053655624,
0.5793790221,
-0.0706139952,
-0.2451363057,
-0.9011737108,
-0.0072148736,
0.1556274593,
-0.3331626058,
0.0132123167,
0.7063137293,
-0.0645326003,
1.056501627,
-0.8565382957,
-0.057119742,
-0.542691946,
0.3296025693,
0.5068220496,
0.2345773876,
0.315450877,
-0.546559453,
-0.0939174667,
0.1171008125,
-0.80335778,
-0.1941657215,
0.1663427502,
0.0144256847,
-0.1339638829,
0.5979242921,
-0.5052294135,
0.4995552897,
0.4874061942,
-0.3786621094,
0.5002981424,
-0.3806286752,
0.3724313974,
-1.0950580835,
0.4822255373,
-0.0318743959,
-0.2217565477,
-0.7568919659,
0.13122347,
-0.0911533237,
0.0241646525,
-0.0631930083,
0.5077404976,
-0.3335189521,
-0.2508009076,
-0.6142926216,
0.2431360036,
-0.0466075577,
0.2490061373,
0.0199803505,
0.910236299,
0.1873557568,
-0.6605495811,
0.3140829802,
0.5490320921,
-0.0458240733,
0.1193495244,
-0.7642142177,
-0.1901219189,
-0.2735536397,
0.2808008492,
-0.8501386642,
-0.5018534064,
0.4300523996,
-0.4637870491,
0.3578743339,
-0.1172211617,
-0.3966601193,
-0.1956027597,
-0.7439765334,
-0.1736817062,
0.6092600822,
-0.5602180362,
0.5448405147,
0.3230631948,
-0.3707348406,
-0.5393722653,
-0.8583831787,
-0.0589363426,
-0.1019502208,
-0.6207044125,
0.3242511153,
0.1445824802,
-0.2132544667,
0.1008381918,
-0.2285099179,
0.0812886208,
-0.0870917588,
0.0618392564,
0.5445310473,
0.0160513129,
0.3279563189,
0.0125412839,
0.1140937135,
-0.199294731,
-0.071446687,
0.4739048779,
0.1843925864,
0.0578104332,
0.3034099042,
0.6258658767,
0.4352331758,
-0.2853724957,
0.7668872476,
0.4305621982,
-0.1933336854,
-0.2396530211,
-0.2187779695,
-0.2414575368,
-0.389772445,
0.436477989,
-0.0801413506,
-0.9952263832,
0.5170404315,
0.123375386,
0.0272985511,
0.6785063148,
0.373834312,
-0.1617281437,
0.6043141484,
0.5037484765,
0.3161879182,
0.2671864331,
-0.2960210443,
0.3264006376,
-0.9929475784,
0.106132865,
-0.6641641259,
-0.175031215,
-0.6484202147,
-0.6558371782,
0.6146345139,
0.0731362626,
-0.0211076252,
0.220513612,
-0.504232347,
0.4962156117,
0.5790337324,
0.0710275173,
0.2970662117,
0.2183704972,
0.1059970036,
0.2769096494,
-0.5004637837,
-0.738139689,
1.3907368183,
0.0604596771,
0.7126368284,
0.142881602,
0.375962317,
0.2698016167,
0.2927827835,
-0.7815439701,
0.6424934268,
-0.8902893066,
-0.2675200403,
-0.2891135216,
-0.7422665954,
-0.7244076133,
0.1706540883,
-0.2315845937,
-0.8650360107,
0.3185661435,
0.1808786988,
-0.319449693,
0.2992964387,
-0.4914259315,
0.5401673913,
0.0283672865,
-0.0369308218,
-0.0344060734,
-0.7435417771,
0.6191151738,
-0.2001847625,
0.147015661,
-0.2173663676,
-0.1118024513,
0.98743999,
-0.6182698011,
0.6410289407,
0.0575041771,
-0.0633887574,
-0.037472561,
-0.0104528358,
0.4445666075,
-0.0175181422,
-0.0330275558,
0.0650088117,
0.3287768364,
-0.2151195705,
-0.5164374709,
0.7576977015,
-0.5976805091,
-0.5750716925,
-0.5749809146,
-0.611585021,
-0.4182431102,
0.1465574801,
0.5050901771,
0.4608516395,
0.2137862295,
0.1230741292,
0.9829442501,
-0.4222318828,
0.2585834563,
0.1880195439,
-0.4842646718,
-0.3945932984,
0.8610102534,
0.2521511614,
0.5159893632,
0.4072494209,
0.4166624248,
-0.1404199451,
-0.4439396262,
-0.0863258764,
0.2802595496,
-0.7224783301,
-0.0626937449,
-0.8164260983,
-0.1960823834,
-0.5670680404,
-0.175639838,
0.0633948669,
-0.8576012254,
-0.1735660136,
-0.1415089071,
0.6746993065,
0.605938077,
-0.1189997345,
0.3315377533,
-0.8655049801,
0.6773362756,
0.0324219353,
0.2512527704,
-0.3650504351,
-0.5938051939,
0.0005061418,
0.0649690628,
0.0697160065,
-1.1735044718,
0.4069227576,
0.3334513605,
0.5528857112,
0.1777436733,
-0.2198722363,
0.4783915281,
-0.2758854032,
0.7891132832,
-0.1218472347,
-0.6891085505,
0.5237214565,
-0.4442075193,
0.2388874441,
0.3313530684,
0.5899842978,
-0.5704957843,
-0.434456706,
-0.5138632655,
-1.0280112028,
0.6314579248,
0.0781502724,
-0.2242262959,
-0.254003346,
0.4503248036,
0.2746073306,
0.1890782267,
-0.429217279,
-0.2287013829,
-0.231976822,
-0.3844826519,
-0.3425062895,
-0.2260526866,
-0.4564138651,
0.0062301052,
1.0169705153,
-0.4216368794,
0.3207319975,
0.549805522,
-0.1781084836,
0.0816847607,
0.399957478,
0.5717176795,
0.7520414591,
-0.3821133077,
0.1567889601,
-0.2954601347,
-0.6507328749,
-0.1015795469,
0.443121165,
-0.3769539595,
-0.1862532347,
0.6807726622,
0.2318897247,
-0.0236464292,
-0.8525497317,
0.3442472219,
0.2545253634,
-0.1369364411,
-0.057091523,
0.0822503194,
0.0545965955,
0.2178759724,
0.1958044469,
-0.1599733531,
0.4032844901,
-0.4049750566,
0.1216248795,
0.4837901592,
-0.2369241565,
-0.1087949425,
0.3928177655,
-0.1078487411,
0.3714302778,
0.5483717322,
-0.2267941087,
-0.3810130358,
0.6069512963,
0.308110863,
1.0380960703,
0.0663985386,
0.3246981502,
0.2292040884,
0.258344084,
-0.2458022833,
0.4490653872,
0.3292183876,
-0.7165073156,
-0.6394963861,
-0.7329063416,
-0.5364407301,
0.103691496,
-0.4377807081,
-0.0106422873,
-0.4739069343,
-0.0328015834,
0.2520613372,
-0.3176759481,
-0.2132142186,
0.0052988902,
0.0368162245,
0.9283393025,
-0.7705495358,
0.7006002665,
0.669663012,
-0.6074832678,
-0.6915566921,
0.0071708309,
0.1452686042,
-0.5629104376,
0.6645955443,
-0.0401056521,
-0.3155290782,
-0.2284602225,
-0.5529386997,
-1.139123559,
1.049726367,
0.0860164091,
-0.3098708391,
-0.1083448604,
-0.0633651987,
0.6108155847,
-0.3007935584,
0.1566491723,
0.530721128,
0.5631032586,
0.3363780677,
-0.6664689779,
0.1907329112,
-0.2112720907,
0.0780546367,
0.3912599683,
-0.2104212046,
0.8810850382,
-0.1053766683,
0.0431324989,
0.0756925344,
0.4334044456,
0.1561534256,
-0.060921628,
0.1687377244,
0.3468700051,
0.7448235154,
-0.2115837485,
1.2170120478,
-0.24276416,
0.3658028543,
1.2542203665,
-0.2184147239,
0.6982524395,
0.5995722413,
-0.2971723676,
-0.0668068007,
0.4142030478,
-0.3000566661,
0.3781474531,
0.3970061541,
-0.0966619626,
-0.0229935963,
0.102361232,
-0.3582772017,
0.1998630911,
0.514089644,
-0.5079138279,
-0.1327280849,
0.0393427089,
0.2552322745,
-0.1204353049,
-0.4311536252,
0.4794590473,
-0.1063842997,
-0.6330894232,
0.0793203562,
-0.0530198738,
0.6770310998,
-0.8518614173,
-0.145781517,
-0.2028863877,
0.0669235513,
-0.4190913737,
-0.7960861325,
0.4215984046,
0.1186901405,
-0.2562229335,
-0.0398785099,
0.6087598205,
-0.4569343626,
-0.7301810384,
0.1510423571,
0.5573529601,
0.1501894146,
0.1421716958,
-0.1017325073,
-0.4030834734,
0.0976047218,
-0.5949300528,
0.1115284413,
0.0470700301,
-0.0785787106,
0.745606482,
0.7831110358,
0.3329362273,
0.036472898,
-0.1519947648,
0.9740612507,
-0.905374825,
-0.2701269388,
-0.8145910501,
0.2173974365,
-0.2307503521,
-0.2244696766,
0.5209357142,
0.3689235151,
0.5426896811,
-0.3014731109,
1.0668696165,
-0.4687369466,
0.9097918868,
-0.6336680651,
0.7106744647,
-0.4970243573,
0.3560602963,
-0.2585116625,
-0.8124803901,
-0.4405327737,
0.4899640083,
-0.3913295865,
0.1886855662,
0.8850268126,
0.6931118369,
0.011233245,
0.2265846282,
0.2158802301,
0.4772181511,
0.5295141935,
-0.0420353189,
0.5431343317,
0.1067304388,
0.3178902566,
-0.2441584766,
-0.6524052024,
-0.1245272309,
-1.1455868483,
-0.9062899947,
-0.4120146334,
-0.2763608992,
-0.4386826456,
0.1689745188,
1.1688636541,
0.2716866136,
-0.8510091305,
-0.163237974,
0.1930000931,
-0.1340731978,
-0.1012011319,
-0.2435654998,
0.5911641121,
-0.3609151244,
-0.465249747,
0.5693512559,
0.4487567842,
-0.069941476,
-0.2652509809,
0.2577341795,
-0.3094945252,
0.1116117686,
0.5362409353,
0.4179743528,
-0.582757175,
-0.3418047428,
0.0331098922,
0.0300652497,
-0.0579189211,
0.7410809994,
-0.7137724161,
0.3098023236,
0.7011944652,
0.5579236746,
0.1842111349,
-0.1226775572,
0.8165752888,
-0.4508731365,
-0.2169859409,
0.1623443365,
0.4633978903,
0.226736486,
-0.3787969947,
0.7977659702,
0.1291911155,
-0.5198662877,
-0.6035882831,
0.2960397005,
-1.2288628817,
-0.3628415763,
1.1566770077,
-0.1880505383,
-0.2675762475,
0.1673066616,
-0.0120278541,
0.2389708608,
-0.1203568131,
0.5799859166,
0.8371415734,
-0.3518338501,
0.0650705174,
-0.5688521266,
0.5737181902,
0.1847179383,
-0.9712385535,
0.1874981523,
0.4560914338,
0.293853581,
0.3245169222,
0.4027419984,
-0.3799593151,
0.1664237529,
-0.2905493081,
0.038716387,
-0.1918131113,
-0.0516840741,
-0.3532239795,
0.1404980123,
-0.1391408741,
0.3063570261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12311v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12311v1 | i-Code V2: An Autoregressive Generation Framework over Vision, Language, and Speech Data | 2023-05-21T01:25:44 | 2023-05-21T01:25:44 | Ziyi Yang, Mahmoud Khademi, Yichong Xu, Reid Pryzant, Yuwei Fang, Chenguang Zhu, Dongdong Chen, Yao Qian, Mei Gao, Yi-Ling Chen, Robert Gmyr, Naoyuki Kanda, Noel Codella, Bin Xiao, Yu Shi, Lu Yuan, Takuya Yoshioka, Michael Zeng, Xuedong Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, eess.AS | The convergence of text, visual, and audio data is a key step towards
human-like artificial intelligence, however the current Vision-Language-Speech
landscape is dominated by encoder-only models which lack generative abilities.
We propose closing this gap with i-Code V2, the first model capable of
generating natural language from any combination of Vision, Language, and
Speech data. i-Code V2 is an integrative system that leverages state-of-the-art
single-modality encoders, combining their outputs with a new modality-fusing
encoder in order to flexibly project combinations of modalities into a shared
representational space. Next, language tokens are generated from these
representations via an autoregressive decoder. The whole framework is
pretrained end-to-end on a large collection of dual- and single-modality
datasets using a novel text completion objective that can be generalized across
arbitrary combinations of modalities. i-Code V2 matches or outperforms
state-of-the-art single- and dual-modality baselines on 7 multimodal tasks,
demonstrating the power of generative multimodal pretraining across a diversity
of tasks and signals. | [
-0.245091632,
-0.3783934116,
0.1949896514,
0.3272514641,
-0.3548325896,
0.2049199194,
-0.2260710299,
-0.45863989,
0.1602212787,
0.2950762808,
-0.5608170629,
-0.2064443231,
-0.6049131155,
0.1122423559,
-0.6730279922,
0.9156094193,
0.1143940017,
0.1408694088,
-0.6010971665,
-0.0424350686,
-0.3372593224,
-0.7194654942,
-0.1638072282,
-0.3432830572,
0.2088985443,
0.4371827245,
0.4612061977,
0.6629391313,
0.5209667683,
0.1653133333,
0.6219558716,
0.174155131,
-0.4662469029,
-0.0024318993,
-0.096208483,
-0.4846310914,
-0.1814166903,
-0.1246540025,
0.4393013418,
0.357678771,
0.0827042386,
0.3473860919,
0.1572151929,
0.6983909607,
-0.5707899332,
0.5231238604,
-0.7097956538,
0.009860334,
-0.1405326575,
-0.3573186398,
-0.2863290608,
-0.1699213386,
-0.2327880859,
-0.4273871481,
0.00149655,
-0.1622890681,
0.84939605,
0.6715863347,
-0.4699109197,
-0.2810421288,
-0.777813673,
0.441613853,
-0.4944245219,
0.4606615901,
0.5751504302,
0.0969791636,
0.2658335865,
-1.0446670055,
-0.9368007183,
-0.1997977644,
-0.1050419658,
0.246104911,
-0.3892876506,
-0.1290489286,
0.0487122312,
0.3189305067,
-0.6991255879,
0.1881333739,
-0.7704461813,
-0.076449953,
0.567057848,
-0.0308476929,
0.335976094,
-0.1543737054,
-0.4851622581,
-0.2378927171,
-0.5745882988,
-0.043635793,
0.4072532654,
0.0841378719,
-0.3093627095,
0.66951859,
-0.2612415552,
0.7259403467,
-0.0643332526,
0.028029602,
0.4054487944,
-0.7652142644,
-0.0326557234,
-0.0587064475,
1.0062872171,
0.443721205,
0.2823790312,
-0.1058559194,
-0.1614266187,
0.5332262516,
0.4523794353,
-0.7326045036,
-0.3135521412,
0.0679993033,
-0.3210403025,
-0.3299680948,
0.0167582817,
-0.5686740279,
-0.0147746857,
-0.5650388598,
0.42027843,
-0.3954329491,
-0.4738050699,
0.1032921374,
0.1041021347,
0.4240801632,
0.0443680659,
-0.9265972972,
0.1980592012,
0.5242245793,
0.6230851412,
-0.065868184,
-0.2533985078,
-0.4653598368,
0.0485388152,
-0.287422061,
0.4759398699,
-0.4328076541,
-0.3191406727,
0.1775904,
-0.3389806151,
0.1730695516,
-0.595746994,
0.2889030576,
-0.2838206589,
0.423486948,
0.0566240139,
-0.3920551538,
-0.0213430617,
0.0280843917,
-0.643928051,
0.9264173508,
0.4416960478,
-0.5919343829,
0.4971907437,
-0.468724221,
-0.6340840459,
0.2710573971,
-0.8415375948,
-0.5838991404,
-0.0745159984,
-0.0515311547,
0.1961295158,
-0.6313146353,
0.4070490897,
-0.1933596283,
-0.2506481409,
-0.107547164,
-0.5289100409,
0.4669440985,
0.3943434656,
-0.4985915124,
-0.1838107109,
-0.8135300875,
0.367759645,
0.1892745048,
-0.5453156829,
-0.003898517,
0.1184269935,
0.3610960245,
0.3485266566,
0.352255404,
-0.398976922,
0.2507990003,
-0.2361202538,
0.5626652241,
0.4182011485,
-0.3418678641,
0.5125007033,
-0.1822849363,
0.5524475574,
0.1395142376,
-0.0055175684,
-0.6547439694,
-0.4162458181,
-0.7560187578,
-0.0951523334,
0.0414981581,
0.876521647,
-1.0901049376,
0.6269375682,
-0.5373653769,
-0.1848366857,
-0.4149074852,
0.2661421299,
0.7845427394,
0.3498488367,
0.3266211748,
-0.4029755294,
-0.71356529,
-1.058701992,
-0.0678094402,
-0.4671311677,
0.0630592033,
0.0198784564,
0.2863307297,
-0.5913648605,
1.2037723064,
-0.0599989146,
-0.2488932163,
-0.2080577016,
0.1981322765,
-0.0701762959,
0.9445257783,
0.6378495097,
-0.9089268446,
-0.3061968088,
0.0399237238,
-0.8582831025,
-0.0587719828,
-0.0479934998,
0.0102722952,
0.2808844447,
0.7338562608,
-0.2298399657,
0.5664938092,
0.6299557686,
-0.3819435835,
0.1689595431,
-0.3801507354,
0.1282818764,
-1.0474954844,
0.0454664752,
-0.1735928804,
-0.2874318063,
-0.5054488778,
-0.0211892482,
0.1756534576,
-0.2015757412,
-0.1025055721,
0.4952072203,
-0.4405651689,
-0.1054171622,
-0.1726968884,
-0.2825050354,
0.004527438,
0.5484722257,
-0.0678700358,
0.9578753114,
0.5665785074,
-0.6863468885,
0.332215488,
0.3492962122,
-0.3783158362,
0.3213098049,
-0.5743077397,
0.2562066019,
-0.5492222309,
0.0245525148,
-0.9199468493,
-0.5318083167,
0.1758473963,
-0.6681375504,
0.2950339019,
0.0784410387,
-0.5618989468,
-0.5568269491,
0.1264433861,
0.7939858437,
0.8995197415,
-0.5715825558,
0.4454441667,
0.3169478178,
-0.147410199,
-0.2258362174,
-0.9669493437,
0.3625531197,
0.2543756664,
-0.5192984343,
0.2037815601,
-0.1700947434,
-0.2313709706,
0.0690383241,
0.0259301085,
-0.2452990711,
-0.2507897019,
0.2265656739,
0.1235033497,
-0.1062443927,
0.0319976993,
0.2691403329,
-0.3599559069,
-0.1463229358,
-0.4681307971,
0.6483279467,
-0.0916100889,
-0.557890296,
-0.3207959533,
0.691188693,
0.7046491504,
-0.6586116552,
0.0334230438,
0.7143599391,
-0.3504792154,
-0.0943708643,
-0.4207817316,
-0.0883048251,
-0.4582862258,
0.6603778005,
-0.4129941165,
-0.8109618425,
-0.0754887313,
-0.0658314899,
0.0096767377,
0.127267018,
0.6626968384,
-0.0504592136,
0.9894076586,
0.8451352119,
0.1187568456,
0.6653836966,
-0.3757009804,
0.4036030471,
-0.4297748804,
-0.4715395272,
-0.1869223118,
-0.2415275127,
-0.1393135041,
-0.5998041034,
0.5547499657,
0.2421485186,
-0.1299767047,
0.3893770576,
-0.6265748143,
0.3352312446,
0.8820734024,
0.1232765466,
0.1004711837,
0.1888688058,
0.4118807614,
-0.1083778813,
-0.8241966963,
-0.4408681095,
1.0450743437,
0.0577072687,
0.7440925241,
0.1222199798,
0.6830098033,
0.4791364074,
0.0310515575,
-0.6371048093,
0.4099806249,
-0.3638001382,
-0.2999370098,
0.1689989269,
-0.1372473985,
-0.7025672793,
-0.014276796,
-0.2771556079,
-0.4104013145,
0.2436329573,
0.474640429,
-0.2005592883,
-0.0793573633,
-0.785030663,
0.7824715376,
-0.4310292006,
-0.4019762576,
-0.1538994908,
-0.767605722,
0.5353254676,
-0.0681074858,
0.2635618448,
0.0860682204,
-0.0666355342,
0.3655894101,
-0.4059820771,
0.7962015867,
0.0124954414,
-0.0338915214,
0.3885631561,
0.0472667627,
0.4643791914,
0.0926001519,
0.1682143807,
0.1077181846,
-0.154377088,
-0.3257770538,
-0.3256856501,
0.4920610785,
-0.7221295238,
-0.1330217719,
-0.1697803438,
-0.2121856958,
-0.1401633769,
0.2146438807,
0.7392434478,
0.8190720081,
-0.0658970848,
0.2414685935,
0.5932353735,
-0.1367408633,
0.635129869,
0.2482864559,
-0.2081080526,
-0.7046436667,
1.0423189402,
-0.1121081188,
0.4444278181,
0.2973549366,
-0.3496353328,
-0.1182645187,
-0.2322881371,
-0.711309433,
-0.0948173702,
-0.7600471377,
-0.4527350366,
-0.8962418437,
-0.3229478002,
-0.4520944655,
-0.2182577252,
-0.483631283,
-0.1077461317,
-0.6009073853,
-0.014364982,
0.1876648366,
0.7717221975,
-0.3380506635,
0.1758140475,
-0.7490026951,
0.6569607258,
0.5138876438,
0.2816460133,
-0.4466652572,
-0.1501584649,
-0.3862493038,
0.0596288368,
0.1299524307,
-0.7456706166,
0.4098398089,
0.4508098364,
0.3713008165,
0.2508147061,
-0.103535302,
0.526285708,
-0.5018259287,
0.7902981043,
0.7789000273,
-0.8846518993,
0.5262224078,
-0.1488273293,
0.5550904274,
0.6096541286,
-0.0505975597,
-0.2492799908,
-0.4322012365,
-0.3796065748,
-0.9520311356,
0.7380814552,
0.2709598839,
0.2575130463,
-0.0811705962,
0.3645084202,
0.2300132662,
0.3897554278,
-0.8648276925,
-0.1167845652,
-0.7938007712,
-0.6344020367,
0.1473679245,
-0.3304182291,
-0.0526781045,
-0.4565201104,
0.3747912347,
-0.488489598,
0.5794959068,
0.3129450977,
-0.2361264825,
-0.1260149479,
0.0275834315,
0.6319479942,
0.5109499693,
0.3768150508,
0.100576289,
-0.3587195277,
-0.5464041233,
0.216281414,
0.1235541925,
-0.3073465228,
-0.0749736652,
0.5015879869,
1.1380850077,
-0.0290997624,
-0.8777878881,
0.8270477653,
-0.0595869496,
-0.4390329719,
-0.5683065653,
0.1212739125,
-0.4121980071,
0.3435124755,
0.4662210643,
0.4259498417,
0.1955026388,
-0.5555455685,
0.5788791776,
0.3392112255,
-0.4820156991,
-0.3781752288,
1.1301071644,
0.2957235277,
-0.3873358965,
0.3816886246,
-0.3355354369,
-0.4177927077,
0.7172278166,
0.6571204662,
1.0659868717,
0.2624411285,
0.0989524052,
0.7047202587,
0.4374470413,
0.1896970868,
0.5632218719,
-0.3767656088,
-0.509237349,
-0.3317048848,
-0.7205844522,
0.0444310345,
-0.0722481161,
-0.7509147525,
0.3607142568,
-0.5078837276,
-0.1061045974,
-0.4454246461,
-0.4975196123,
-0.8189983964,
0.28403157,
0.6151475906,
0.6557967663,
-0.5004464388,
0.9933645725,
0.6560832262,
-0.6663954258,
-0.5442831516,
0.0267807767,
-0.1755417287,
-0.9487814307,
0.7462002039,
0.1186026558,
-0.2627478838,
0.2968696654,
-0.8345940113,
-1.0534102917,
1.2428327799,
0.4294528961,
-0.8204747438,
-0.2641257048,
0.0668595135,
0.2651795447,
-0.4580956697,
-0.0793911889,
0.4719971418,
0.3634359241,
0.0996498764,
-1.1491445303,
-0.3169426322,
-0.6972526908,
0.2040657848,
0.1282359809,
-0.6294917464,
0.8441312313,
-0.3218182921,
-0.3858171105,
0.1601730883,
0.7440020442,
-0.0969319493,
0.0692837387,
0.3375543952,
0.595426023,
0.3461850286,
-0.2107747644,
0.919046104,
-0.8412685394,
0.1232105121,
1.1703038216,
-0.0640690997,
0.5696451068,
0.3751451075,
-0.009126137,
0.4554758966,
0.1241055131,
0.2020810694,
0.7134422064,
-0.0201614238,
-0.4030349553,
-0.4125786126,
0.1680750251,
-0.5535747409,
0.7489956617,
0.3535615206,
-0.3517676592,
-0.1859379262,
0.408277303,
-0.0211300254,
0.2367444634,
-0.0988558978,
1.0892722607,
-0.0775963962,
-0.7318940759,
0.7224847674,
-0.0465995073,
0.8052120805,
-0.8026754856,
-0.2440702766,
-0.1244340539,
0.1230526567,
-0.131649062,
-0.5972366333,
0.250875026,
-0.1068988517,
-0.2717500329,
-0.5098330975,
0.6111024618,
-0.8775025606,
-0.3572511375,
0.1744305491,
0.3792437315,
-0.2488669455,
0.1837596148,
-0.389416337,
0.3072968125,
0.1722879559,
0.1540733725,
-0.0299355797,
0.2562743425,
0.2327004671,
0.5530710816,
0.5573145151,
-0.2856492102,
0.4345787764,
-0.0588812232,
1.0348204374,
-0.5695993304,
-0.6814012527,
-0.6386865377,
0.7383792996,
0.0307471585,
-0.456880182,
0.3090538383,
0.6887332201,
0.8730592728,
-0.0556173213,
1.2730900049,
-0.4498654306,
0.24060449,
-0.6181553602,
0.5497560501,
-0.7288060188,
-0.0796220601,
0.1352826208,
-0.6825957894,
-0.1704759896,
0.4602548778,
0.1118009835,
-0.2305429876,
0.4280121326,
0.627854526,
-0.0602593273,
-0.31156075,
0.2551041543,
-0.0204083752,
0.4449580312,
0.6236215234,
0.669246316,
-0.6359598041,
0.6283661127,
-0.111197345,
-0.3411259055,
-0.2595962882,
-0.4804420769,
-0.6004763842,
-0.9648350477,
-0.2672915161,
-0.3565695584,
-0.0704566985,
1.0664434433,
0.6863783598,
-0.381893158,
-0.1357042193,
-0.4330188036,
-0.4504926205,
0.1339397728,
-0.2227506042,
-0.3149515092,
-0.5810188651,
-0.813123405,
0.4743598104,
0.7256156802,
0.222830832,
-0.642575562,
-0.4020211399,
0.1154420823,
0.1122027934,
0.785264194,
0.5281521678,
-0.6902955174,
-0.0694830939,
-0.2413091362,
-0.4314917922,
0.1767222732,
0.9599724412,
-1.1432698965,
0.8634324074,
0.422154665,
0.596758306,
0.457133621,
-0.1497271955,
0.7662191987,
-0.5849864483,
0.5335238576,
0.4789180458,
0.2460382581,
0.3266879022,
-0.2235503346,
0.5287911892,
0.2602622807,
-0.3169733584,
-0.7984294295,
0.7327324748,
-0.9623956084,
-0.0867468938,
1.2263793945,
0.2319472283,
-0.167846784,
0.0349741057,
-0.2060120702,
0.1416674107,
-0.1126763746,
0.3982388377,
0.213208586,
-0.0181826763,
-0.2172309905,
-0.3507545888,
0.5523824692,
0.2742094398,
-0.833622098,
-0.0968032777,
0.8581652641,
-0.0125734387,
0.0791181922,
1.221119523,
-0.1758625209,
0.4689222574,
0.3085224926,
0.3508874178,
-0.1919689029,
-0.4970696568,
-0.2648938298,
0.031236425,
-0.1607104987,
-0.2151855528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12307v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12307v3 | OntoType: Ontology-Guided and Pre-Trained Language Model Assisted Fine-Grained Entity Typing | 2023-05-21T00:32:37 | 2024-06-11T16:16:19 | Tanay Komarlu, Minhao Jiang, Xuan Wang, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-grained entity typing (FET), which assigns entities in text with
context-sensitive, fine-grained semantic types, is a basic but important task
for knowledge extraction from unstructured text. FET has been studied
extensively in natural language processing and typically relies on
human-annotated corpora for training, which is costly and difficult to scale.
Recent studies explore the utilization of pre-trained language models (PLMs) as
a knowledge base to generate rich and context-aware weak supervision for FET.
However, a PLM still requires direction and guidance to serve as a knowledge
base as they often generate a mixture of rough and fine-grained types, or
tokens unsuitable for typing. In this study, we vision that an ontology
provides a semantics-rich, hierarchical structure, which will help select the
best results generated by multiple PLM models and head words. Specifically, we
propose a novel annotation-free, ontology-guided FET method, OntoType, which
follows a type ontological structure, from coarse to fine, ensembles multiple
PLM prompting results to generate a set of type candidates, and refines its
type resolution, under the local context with a natural language inference
model. Our experiments on the Ontonotes, FIGER, and NYT datasets using their
associated ontological structures demonstrate that our method outperforms the
state-of-the-art zero-shot fine-grained entity typing methods as well as a
typical LLM method, ChatGPT. Our error analysis shows that refinement of the
existing ontology structures will further improve fine-grained entity typing. | [
-0.3735870719,
-0.9149904847,
0.6732933521,
-0.0684044585,
-0.075350523,
0.06127996,
-0.1561631411,
-0.386059463,
0.1472735852,
0.9246965647,
-0.3009179235,
-0.6273925304,
-0.4746416211,
0.0716971532,
-0.3995136321,
1.2180867195,
0.0350214988,
0.1209584773,
0.0559428893,
0.1968210042,
-0.0334888995,
-0.5354901552,
-0.5711883307,
-0.3383953571,
0.2590411305,
0.4220598936,
0.6930174828,
0.773878634,
0.7734235525,
0.2444528043,
-0.1095546111,
0.1862371564,
-0.2357971817,
-0.1266940832,
-0.3176583946,
-0.5795984864,
-0.6292451024,
0.0269687306,
0.313780725,
0.7272877097,
0.0150152836,
0.0891319215,
-0.0029595587,
0.2710251212,
-0.3539811969,
0.2027523965,
-0.8854123354,
0.1655815691,
-0.5010063648,
-0.5173212886,
-0.1642652303,
-0.2246164531,
0.6194338799,
-0.8516336679,
0.2493831366,
0.3594807684,
0.8382827044,
0.168489784,
-0.3445074856,
-0.3004422188,
-0.5637450218,
0.5810800791,
-0.5579160452,
0.3386787772,
0.5040122867,
0.1912865341,
-0.1528343111,
-0.802795589,
-0.3192844093,
-0.2228778899,
-0.1230321229,
-0.1334224939,
0.4660988152,
0.5806716681,
0.0039270883,
0.665320158,
-0.224847585,
0.1147375628,
0.1799855679,
-0.1572927982,
0.1976970732,
-0.0850578621,
0.3702770472,
-0.4201167226,
-0.5244196057,
0.1346332729,
-0.7520026565,
-0.1019826531,
-0.1120861769,
0.5832339525,
0.1797795743,
0.6208879948,
-0.4173816741,
0.5846892595,
0.2030149102,
-0.4632716775,
-0.0424885638,
-0.2742207348,
-0.2174305022,
0.0445347354,
0.6431566477,
-0.0025260409,
0.4251403809,
-0.6634336114,
-0.3560580909,
-0.0796724409,
0.1146852374,
-0.6573627591,
-0.1721696556,
0.0961829647,
-0.3469958007,
-0.579836607,
-0.1729813218,
-0.8268949389,
-0.330930382,
-0.2311686575,
0.666323185,
-0.6286027431,
-0.1179201901,
0.0346647389,
-0.053858988,
0.0286243092,
0.3749295473,
-1.1296117306,
0.2411605269,
0.6142796874,
0.6054289937,
0.0602673404,
-0.0259398874,
-0.3909713328,
0.3436242342,
-0.1187575683,
1.1487003565,
-0.6262010932,
-0.2042127401,
0.0392953902,
-0.3927922249,
0.0879980326,
-0.3426125646,
0.5519574881,
-0.588578999,
0.0802647695,
-0.241389066,
-0.732385695,
-0.1417801529,
0.4819037616,
-0.4136439264,
1.0338400602,
0.3263575435,
-0.9367536902,
0.5673380494,
-0.8888865113,
-0.207833752,
0.2705549896,
-0.5433700085,
-0.0495806821,
-0.0214668997,
0.0043803197,
0.671554327,
-0.5549515486,
0.2459724545,
-0.4710538983,
0.0734256059,
-0.0131169707,
0.025910927,
0.3008625507,
0.0188687611,
-0.352317214,
-0.0719018802,
-1.14551723,
0.0177473184,
0.1009525135,
-0.3004601598,
-0.7730315328,
0.0022990603,
-0.0538012423,
0.4941162467,
0.1930197626,
-0.7095989585,
0.3371188939,
-0.53551507,
0.5317685604,
0.523857832,
-0.0821042657,
0.5979109406,
-0.1625800878,
0.1096056998,
-0.1893461794,
-0.0769849122,
-0.0622346625,
-0.3526795506,
-0.7490620017,
-0.3104610741,
0.3638399839,
0.69203794,
-0.8792640567,
0.4221912324,
-0.2253435999,
-0.309260726,
-0.3752003908,
0.0893329307,
0.5914142132,
0.7218557,
0.4955851436,
-0.1586065441,
-0.5880215168,
-0.5482541919,
-0.1911907047,
-0.1301232278,
-0.0279706754,
0.2605414987,
0.3692368865,
-0.2826661468,
1.282099247,
-0.6167279482,
-0.5707535744,
-0.0463436432,
0.2432963699,
-0.4370354712,
0.4787679017,
0.2967612147,
-0.8152890801,
-0.211921975,
0.1950201541,
-0.4841678441,
-0.11579106,
0.1143146977,
-0.3028574884,
0.0188905168,
0.3445920646,
-0.5917565823,
0.3118748665,
0.2080122232,
-0.554338634,
0.5310784578,
0.0836165026,
-0.0031766195,
-1.0307539701,
-0.0080670873,
-0.196684137,
-0.3704669774,
-0.6264599562,
0.0421107635,
-0.1823646873,
0.1446601301,
-0.2415127307,
0.6700807214,
-0.2771698236,
-0.1988359988,
-0.2498945594,
0.2956273556,
0.1726474762,
0.4404931366,
0.5336930752,
0.4810126722,
0.4833050072,
-0.490811646,
-0.0829210728,
0.6321666837,
-0.1246297807,
0.377548486,
-0.2322258055,
-0.0147499153,
-0.0159823392,
-0.0575471185,
-0.8267089128,
-0.1435312629,
-0.0993189737,
-0.1534738094,
0.3362675309,
-0.0514375605,
-0.5506587625,
-0.0365889259,
-0.059540391,
0.0481261201,
0.2014467269,
-0.4171950817,
0.6649312973,
0.2982898355,
-0.1674575657,
-0.2604156733,
-0.7974422574,
-0.3798273504,
-0.0367538631,
-0.6163492799,
0.56283319,
0.2021994889,
-0.1405751705,
0.0329151936,
-0.3832366168,
-0.4400451183,
0.1603035182,
0.0951603428,
0.3142340481,
-0.4432010353,
0.251198262,
0.042076584,
-0.0595247932,
-0.1621216536,
-0.4522787333,
0.5278241038,
-0.0349171869,
-0.0817349032,
-0.1250123084,
0.2361973971,
0.2260881066,
-0.2797680497,
0.6505508423,
0.4861853123,
-0.3447172046,
-0.1024527624,
-0.5120453835,
-0.2967107892,
-0.4209984839,
0.2554487586,
-0.6166426539,
-1.4103213549,
0.3877180219,
-0.2057992518,
0.28994748,
0.4723264575,
0.3093102276,
0.0394296497,
0.6602544188,
0.6714193821,
0.301710397,
0.4645734727,
-0.1135756671,
0.2441187203,
-0.5970667005,
-0.0931308866,
-0.6013756394,
0.2068083286,
-0.6789054275,
-0.3471103907,
0.0033468893,
0.2967564762,
-0.1327519119,
0.366672039,
-0.3542580903,
0.126265794,
0.5146386027,
-0.07876122,
0.6258359551,
-0.106542252,
-0.4394721687,
0.1232915968,
-0.4446171224,
-0.8247584701,
1.1576100588,
0.3242568374,
0.6165621281,
-0.138850376,
0.8083783984,
0.1095216274,
0.3396735787,
-0.6928371191,
0.4772117138,
-0.597512424,
-0.9927455783,
-0.4216614962,
-0.3838485479,
-0.4307553172,
0.2818951011,
-0.3987357318,
-1.0002690554,
0.1349621266,
0.4910953343,
-0.826108098,
0.4141131639,
-0.6617707014,
0.8824906945,
-0.0719984919,
0.1347065717,
0.2428586483,
-0.6422128677,
0.3648844063,
-0.4212270081,
0.0853639022,
-0.2874495387,
-0.0510587431,
0.6737866998,
-0.4724173248,
0.7280539274,
0.0134907421,
-0.1970141977,
0.3148197532,
0.1012575254,
0.5812385082,
0.2581046522,
-0.0255932547,
0.1575803906,
0.15214324,
-0.1067684889,
-0.4273376465,
0.4415422976,
-0.6756796241,
-0.4898128808,
-0.006040914,
-0.4896814525,
-0.5262099504,
0.3063049614,
0.598639667,
0.6659379005,
-0.1502141804,
0.0847119763,
0.9298534393,
0.0261830445,
0.2941713333,
0.5554881692,
-0.3918150961,
-0.1537324935,
0.8407764435,
0.3401576281,
0.4151799083,
0.9346247315,
0.1901284605,
-0.2221388817,
-0.5024254918,
-0.1894481927,
-0.1774638295,
-0.4418642819,
-0.3189449012,
-1.0150610209,
-0.2526743114,
-0.7597221732,
-0.241448462,
-0.6330327988,
-0.6920728087,
-0.3067349195,
-0.0419695154,
0.4706159532,
0.4055204093,
0.3250728846,
0.745770216,
-0.8129183054,
0.4363392293,
0.4203722775,
0.4745748341,
-0.273430407,
-0.4348897636,
0.0358432345,
-0.1982348412,
-0.2097024322,
-0.6035536528,
0.1281109154,
0.3491255641,
0.2851316929,
0.6951085925,
0.0787599236,
0.6164306402,
-0.6555946469,
0.3982152045,
-0.1547773778,
-0.7265003324,
0.5322279334,
-0.3902232051,
-0.0687477365,
0.622081399,
0.3568643034,
-0.3228449821,
-0.4750768244,
-0.6426002383,
-0.6823726296,
0.8563613296,
0.2489133626,
-0.3606545031,
-0.0506623946,
0.4506237507,
0.3971334696,
0.3350351751,
-0.6694280505,
-0.3618836999,
-0.2813941836,
-0.2189084589,
0.161986053,
-0.3949422538,
0.0343793146,
0.0714371428,
0.603836596,
-0.1202222332,
0.32420367,
0.3146974444,
-0.1865326911,
0.0647776127,
0.535687983,
0.1382499188,
0.2057966739,
-0.4631926417,
0.2886158228,
-0.0677151307,
-0.5161646008,
-0.0561018437,
0.4653205872,
-0.5489541292,
-0.1590144187,
0.2373064607,
0.7408582568,
0.4824905396,
-0.4719960093,
0.2287353128,
0.2259684503,
-0.1001487896,
-0.1673913747,
0.0419345126,
-0.1574973166,
0.064161472,
0.2426033914,
0.044866316,
0.4071791172,
-0.3156400323,
0.3067221642,
0.31184268,
-0.282584995,
-0.380649209,
0.5265958905,
0.3574475944,
-0.0421731137,
-0.0028440885,
-0.3924496174,
-0.3598941863,
0.1578731686,
0.6568172574,
0.7772568464,
-0.133176282,
0.2808229029,
-0.0994171724,
0.1647857428,
-0.2649151981,
0.2821340561,
0.023122659,
-0.9831951261,
-0.4444066882,
-1.0427378416,
-0.2137116194,
0.1431986094,
-0.3908645213,
0.1642431021,
-0.6416522264,
-0.2495449781,
0.3069616854,
0.1707493216,
-0.5659776926,
0.453412503,
0.152874589,
0.9614576697,
-0.667758882,
0.9551175833,
0.9969918132,
-0.5498200655,
-0.9753476977,
-0.0048329849,
0.0003796253,
-0.7082184553,
0.5831682682,
0.118139118,
0.1275795996,
0.4751977921,
-0.1865170747,
-1.1970841885,
0.9415269494,
0.1934001297,
-0.3610763848,
-0.5520669222,
0.3596143723,
0.3682293892,
-0.5090891123,
0.225880608,
0.8353950381,
0.4423255622,
0.0433747545,
-0.919798255,
0.0301561542,
0.2075622231,
0.3524145782,
0.4046681821,
-0.5599676371,
0.9201574326,
0.0869213939,
-0.0125671159,
0.0742313713,
0.6192903519,
0.1293172091,
-0.0102785975,
0.4642190337,
0.7127226591,
0.48494789,
-0.1408033669,
0.7344669104,
-0.30091995,
0.3821903467,
1.1615399122,
-0.3042559326,
0.6995363235,
0.3955672085,
0.0271052346,
0.501583755,
0.5028095841,
0.2101433128,
0.6349022388,
-0.0782484189,
-0.2121541798,
-0.4274741113,
-0.288544327,
-0.2717666626,
0.6887850165,
0.4055479169,
-0.3425807655,
-0.4709117711,
0.1638129354,
0.1204118729,
-0.0165928528,
-0.5104721785,
0.6972378492,
0.1490271986,
-0.4450326562,
0.0273087081,
0.0659196377,
0.8390437961,
-0.526683867,
0.0170028713,
-0.0711889938,
0.0266814288,
-0.2847483158,
-0.4985867143,
0.2556079924,
0.0466006324,
-0.2638112307,
-0.1171590686,
0.9665715694,
-0.532348454,
-0.1966866851,
0.2666552663,
0.4377298653,
0.1049470827,
-0.4057172239,
-0.4557435215,
-0.5123693943,
-0.2087737024,
-0.5943741798,
0.3665881753,
0.8435189724,
-0.3114301264,
0.5930005312,
0.5536916256,
0.0067593008,
0.1643541157,
-0.061615739,
0.7835202813,
-0.7249602675,
-0.5138652921,
-0.5914049745,
0.3116397262,
0.1463888139,
-0.4904147089,
0.530487597,
0.2812383771,
0.7621622682,
-0.0381395482,
0.7074684501,
-0.44209975,
0.7068610787,
-0.5678663254,
0.6522707939,
-0.3736282587,
-0.0177405421,
-0.4205692112,
-0.7712135911,
-0.3237416148,
0.4389865398,
-0.4186320901,
-0.0441929176,
0.7674095631,
0.6078421474,
0.1142243147,
0.0986248478,
0.4797236323,
0.2262912989,
-0.0460905395,
0.2842896283,
0.471734643,
-0.2476342171,
0.6655855179,
-0.2561691403,
-0.3150147796,
-0.4135099649,
-0.6612116694,
-0.9672878981,
-0.4752447605,
-0.2512207031,
-0.0758858398,
-0.0640672073,
1.0965535641,
0.6468356252,
-0.8297774196,
0.2269490063,
-0.2754996717,
-0.0630970895,
0.202021867,
-0.2187809944,
0.2719710171,
-0.6172149181,
-0.4406939447,
0.0852094069,
0.3633855283,
0.1802045852,
-0.2182374001,
0.1881409734,
-0.3544672728,
0.016003849,
0.7854396701,
0.1993348151,
-0.770580411,
-0.4497353137,
0.0315139741,
-0.3766312301,
0.1386943758,
0.6840325594,
-0.5041604638,
0.1238888204,
0.4356167316,
0.7686427832,
-0.0020701243,
-0.0939967111,
0.3779499233,
-0.7782469392,
0.096210964,
0.0803931579,
0.3270171583,
0.1271325052,
-0.5064854622,
0.5569456816,
0.3457534015,
-0.5092513561,
-0.587780416,
0.1101786494,
-0.9382724762,
-0.098848857,
1.2443768978,
-0.3459373713,
-0.1595624238,
-0.3745914102,
-0.2865166366,
0.3482899666,
-0.408390075,
0.6936804056,
0.5961150527,
-0.1246409044,
0.0526425876,
-0.4161274135,
0.8778057098,
0.2095954567,
-1.0235270262,
-0.1039989442,
0.2573012114,
0.3498266339,
0.4662206471,
0.8139593601,
-0.215082258,
0.0306860562,
-0.0629669279,
0.6325307488,
0.0871353373,
-0.290643394,
0.1164057851,
0.2610416114,
0.2574750185,
-0.0223754551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12301v1 | Sentence Embedder Guided Utterance Encoder (SEGUE) for Spoken Language Understanding | 2023-05-20T23:55:55 | 2023-05-20T23:55:55 | Yi Xuan Tan, Navonil Majumder, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | The pre-trained speech encoder wav2vec 2.0 performs very well on various
spoken language understanding (SLU) tasks. However, on many tasks, it trails
behind text encoders with textual input. To improve the understanding
capability of SLU encoders, various studies have used knowledge distillation to
transfer knowledge from natural language understanding (NLU) encoders. We use a
very simple method of distilling from a textual sentence embedder directly into
wav2vec 2.0 as pre-training, utilizing paired audio-text datasets. We observed
that this method is indeed capable of improving SLU task performance in
fine-tuned settings, as well as full-data and few-shot transfer on a frozen
encoder. However, the model performs worse on certain tasks highlighting the
strengths and weaknesses of our approach. | [
-0.0292734578,
-0.8707842827,
0.7839748859,
0.1917874962,
-0.4503499568,
0.0354262069,
-0.1139046028,
-0.2542201281,
-0.0581597798,
0.510415554,
-0.4247123301,
-0.3856518865,
-0.8166021705,
-0.1417587996,
-0.3184770942,
0.9167686701,
0.076443702,
0.1245760322,
-0.5745233297,
-0.1531605124,
-0.7532425523,
-0.3930778503,
-0.5734268427,
-0.6809585094,
0.0089307353,
0.2926886082,
0.3217379749,
0.1784761846,
0.2263312489,
0.2589167058,
-0.1797746718,
0.0431019962,
-0.6203322411,
0.2488334775,
-0.0143354712,
-0.6323640943,
-0.1553837657,
-0.1322857887,
0.0452025607,
0.5030655861,
-0.4179752767,
0.0506266579,
0.364664793,
0.6540468335,
-0.541369915,
0.3650675118,
-0.5882618427,
0.114543654,
-0.0038409766,
-0.1052156836,
-0.5397818685,
-0.2799000144,
0.5370446444,
-0.7210581899,
0.1067235693,
-0.288277626,
0.5239194632,
0.8035901785,
-0.4400834739,
-0.5740858316,
-0.678646028,
0.5361170769,
-0.8524649143,
0.4219283164,
0.6306732297,
0.1572922468,
0.2125105262,
-0.8651983738,
-0.4499590397,
0.0757957995,
-0.1808161139,
0.3403711617,
-0.462587893,
0.1693201065,
0.2918431461,
0.0616229884,
-0.5729556084,
0.0716112405,
-0.592651546,
-0.219515875,
0.3318344057,
-0.1122554317,
0.2020313591,
-0.0438195132,
-0.3044559658,
0.0485844053,
-0.3022567034,
0.2397592217,
0.0319986381,
-0.1183520854,
-0.1189341322,
0.3112688363,
0.1416135281,
0.8331890106,
0.0847324654,
-0.2449511737,
0.4861839712,
-0.3726071119,
-0.2907516062,
0.4029048085,
0.5169945359,
0.2995687425,
0.2781073451,
-0.1794932187,
-0.0599502102,
0.0506572872,
0.3440317214,
-0.7725312114,
-0.3195491731,
0.0610656105,
-0.3254507482,
-0.1638302356,
0.1529954076,
-0.5111797452,
-0.3006438017,
-0.4018700719,
0.6155295372,
-0.5863380432,
0.0543459691,
0.2563818693,
-0.4966104925,
0.3391189277,
0.3186753392,
-0.8281623721,
0.4235298634,
0.5908812881,
0.936365664,
0.0234985296,
0.0502551422,
-0.7925249338,
0.1009705141,
-0.0127845909,
0.5238066912,
-0.4358295798,
-0.5049713254,
-0.1132052988,
-0.1714534312,
-0.102386497,
-0.619119823,
0.507689178,
-0.2756472528,
0.1081894487,
-0.217062071,
-0.6718811989,
-0.2453569174,
-0.1408692598,
-0.5805290937,
0.8657301068,
-0.1133887321,
-0.5839854479,
0.2792065144,
-0.484143436,
-0.8869890571,
-0.0548881739,
-0.1029577628,
-0.0652514473,
0.2914965153,
0.5830898881,
0.4886634946,
-0.0232011918,
0.3171504736,
0.0969988257,
-0.4385085404,
0.2427054197,
-0.430365473,
0.6740322709,
0.4630284011,
-0.3954622149,
-0.280677408,
-0.6549289227,
-0.1456574202,
-0.1154480055,
-0.1807218194,
-0.6497886181,
0.0365330987,
-0.0884043872,
0.0488353223,
0.1646544486,
-0.4645436108,
-0.0079039242,
-0.4686490893,
0.894418478,
0.5352403522,
0.0726125613,
0.7399734259,
0.075422436,
0.4050829411,
0.1380471289,
-0.0782805085,
-0.2017211467,
-0.4938796759,
-0.8582488894,
0.204173997,
0.1407190263,
0.772977531,
-0.8813714385,
0.5357385874,
-0.048178345,
-0.3615276814,
-1.0407723188,
0.2533102334,
0.4370157123,
0.6674519181,
0.5609964132,
-0.0015992856,
-0.5864383578,
-0.7625986338,
-0.1603581309,
-0.0781387389,
-0.0747002289,
0.1978624165,
0.3302379549,
-0.2411909252,
0.8950062394,
-0.6151168942,
-0.3259570301,
-0.4336307943,
0.3554844558,
0.1601699889,
0.3211622536,
0.2742984295,
-0.7211633325,
-0.2734986544,
-0.0754312649,
-0.7186437845,
-0.285836488,
-0.1772324443,
0.0447850078,
-0.0589457229,
0.756072402,
-0.1315632612,
0.4658220708,
0.7569673061,
-0.3334759176,
0.0177127086,
-0.433409512,
0.2503332496,
-1.2565857172,
-0.226363197,
0.009144919,
-0.381183356,
-0.9737585187,
-0.4945129454,
0.1170045063,
0.0029012156,
-0.4331390262,
0.0307218507,
-0.4471645355,
0.14435862,
-0.1540725827,
0.4992372394,
0.2993296683,
0.2314984351,
0.0882395282,
0.6449990869,
0.4499422312,
-0.6080434918,
0.3189397156,
0.5016790628,
-0.5386948586,
0.3834580183,
-0.9198427796,
0.6386082172,
-0.3389157951,
0.0270488784,
-0.9494021535,
0.2657629848,
-0.1073457152,
-0.4627045393,
0.3080928028,
-0.233464852,
0.0336537026,
-0.2120763808,
-0.0075101638,
0.137489751,
0.7830488682,
-0.6293464899,
0.5035377741,
0.4018464684,
-0.1705249399,
-0.3819761574,
-1.3879047632,
-0.0922513604,
-0.1165203601,
-0.6674433947,
0.3012449741,
0.0178803243,
-0.3206179142,
-0.0266179703,
-0.2367002517,
-0.2051762342,
0.020424705,
0.4303697944,
0.0526824966,
-0.177302748,
0.3007959723,
0.2883397937,
-0.2050823569,
0.0298389457,
-0.3353665173,
0.4696882367,
0.0053663109,
-0.2187101692,
-0.7286355495,
0.1284075379,
0.3513352275,
-0.3061408997,
0.8189656734,
0.5587637424,
-0.1376686096,
-0.1444758177,
-0.687728703,
-0.1436606944,
-0.4478583634,
0.3919495642,
-0.4503252804,
-1.1435421705,
0.1782865524,
-0.0965702608,
-0.0922524631,
0.2365912199,
0.2066320628,
-0.4189127386,
0.6007682681,
0.4447918832,
-0.258015871,
0.3651314974,
-0.3209259808,
0.3401035368,
-0.5950881839,
-0.5040591955,
-0.5071840882,
-0.3342192173,
-0.1004254892,
-0.7506956458,
0.0949058235,
0.286136061,
0.158309415,
0.3707839251,
-0.3317083716,
0.3676665425,
0.4423858225,
0.2094421387,
0.1860938221,
-0.1394203901,
0.0839051902,
-0.2570659518,
-0.5558721423,
-0.4840329885,
0.6635567546,
0.3743991852,
1.0228556395,
0.0739422515,
0.8927949667,
0.321994096,
-0.6174604297,
-0.7927883267,
0.2226434648,
-0.3321078122,
-0.026596019,
-0.3004097641,
-0.2529806197,
-0.6583964825,
0.1250169724,
-0.0565108769,
-0.7023738027,
0.2176474333,
0.286210537,
-0.4097878337,
-0.0023790014,
-1.015375495,
0.7815315723,
-0.3395534456,
0.0228022058,
-0.2652171254,
-0.6039873362,
-0.0621409714,
-0.0100392187,
0.3597304821,
0.0745335892,
0.0989888757,
0.9861228466,
-0.4445943832,
0.6523677111,
-0.6070227623,
0.0124311419,
0.3804363906,
-0.0152134653,
0.57623142,
0.0824682787,
-0.1606620848,
-0.0094692744,
-0.0036611366,
-0.1765081435,
-0.8902124763,
0.439584434,
-0.7614344954,
-0.5600783825,
-0.1389997602,
-0.1664381623,
-0.1540821493,
-0.3345544934,
0.4490705431,
0.548974514,
-0.4078561366,
0.5332288742,
0.856066525,
-0.1891552359,
0.4546845257,
0.3852106333,
0.1543286145,
-0.1663502753,
0.5543548465,
0.0090236459,
0.2839620113,
0.4983832538,
0.0701293647,
-0.3972757459,
-0.6959895492,
-0.1827795357,
-0.1406817883,
-0.6062253714,
-0.0837347507,
-0.7285076976,
-0.3047831059,
-0.7252232432,
-0.2381715328,
-0.4339048862,
-0.2600704432,
-0.7101219296,
-0.489153415,
0.5425360799,
0.9557493329,
0.0048987567,
0.4594965875,
-0.9474397302,
0.4033861458,
0.4815585613,
-0.203345567,
-0.2849526107,
-0.9681609869,
-0.2199390382,
0.251871258,
0.0982797071,
-1.0285329819,
0.3678402603,
0.4831997156,
0.6833034754,
0.5092650652,
0.077920258,
1.0364991426,
-0.4816411734,
0.9450558424,
0.3047831655,
-1.2815513611,
1.2169225216,
0.2816019952,
0.6033663154,
0.8400592804,
0.1905954778,
-0.5331072211,
-0.2616871893,
-0.2892055809,
-0.8245094419,
0.7332559824,
0.3603300154,
0.1568040699,
0.257273376,
0.394077301,
0.280506283,
-0.0087832268,
-0.485988766,
-0.2202870995,
-0.3514483273,
-0.3225392103,
-0.4700899422,
-0.4903252423,
0.1505473852,
-0.3804821074,
0.6121954322,
0.0823769867,
0.0741550624,
0.4522792101,
-0.7810778618,
0.397159934,
0.5540674329,
0.2759987712,
0.4465554953,
-0.0230514128,
0.2786841094,
0.4858902097,
-0.6829014421,
0.1991582811,
0.1323836744,
-0.095521085,
-0.0787522346,
0.4651987553,
1.349601388,
0.229763642,
-0.4748308957,
0.5973527431,
-0.1784466505,
-0.4330119193,
-0.0724075809,
0.1987433881,
0.2812079489,
0.381137073,
0.2208952308,
0.098394759,
0.4007786214,
-0.4450191557,
0.2181632966,
-0.1129000112,
-0.7648126483,
-0.1902414113,
0.4564351737,
0.5196930766,
-0.2770319879,
0.7365341783,
-0.0419683345,
-0.4568298459,
0.4371026754,
0.6895622015,
0.6725566387,
-0.2474911511,
0.2736754119,
0.3058331907,
0.3524865806,
-0.132905066,
0.1368274242,
-0.3810221851,
-0.7419024706,
-0.276600033,
-0.6713445783,
0.0246377233,
-0.0005159521,
-1.0857714415,
-0.0115909996,
-0.0001397252,
-0.1151813343,
-0.0830256864,
-0.2654295862,
-0.8369613886,
-0.0447425731,
0.3456130922,
0.554554224,
-0.8920638561,
1.201633811,
0.5393720269,
-0.2972736657,
-0.906752944,
0.003944661,
0.045963522,
-0.7159494758,
0.553073287,
0.1879184097,
-0.3461907208,
0.0801097974,
-0.2473359257,
-0.4746521115,
1.3798779249,
0.4319470227,
-1.1703999043,
0.0358044207,
0.0621878058,
0.5107204318,
-0.1813716888,
0.1849142611,
1.0439091921,
0.3623648882,
0.1747272164,
-0.9541863203,
-0.1344765127,
-0.2652978897,
0.1004578993,
-0.0389200188,
-0.1680733263,
0.3375985026,
-0.346511662,
-0.132414937,
-0.1787501574,
0.6516889334,
-0.0128861787,
0.5373422503,
0.6008384228,
0.6504272223,
0.9829816222,
-0.2306916863,
0.5373649597,
0.1961752772,
0.2380174994,
1.5368984938,
-0.2055729628,
0.9776011109,
0.7396911383,
-0.2409763932,
0.4541146159,
0.2826450467,
0.0642289743,
0.9058809876,
0.1063583493,
-0.1009458899,
-0.1509761214,
0.1048045903,
-0.3755652606,
0.7585991025,
0.4096976817,
-0.4131340086,
0.1749456078,
0.5173153281,
-0.0973555967,
0.275380373,
-0.1423449069,
1.2811313868,
0.331854105,
-0.6040786505,
0.270734489,
-0.4155259728,
0.8182746172,
-0.5314794779,
-0.0996186659,
-0.0973978266,
0.0879556537,
-0.2425507307,
-0.925560236,
0.3569996655,
0.1800465435,
-0.0145322289,
-0.5335153341,
0.9596844316,
-0.6427915692,
-0.1669339687,
0.6259837151,
0.6754574776,
0.2631022334,
-0.0976283252,
-0.5334251523,
-0.0103688911,
0.3711351752,
-0.1016287208,
0.0242689941,
0.436963588,
0.6109568477,
0.3445976973,
0.4057468772,
-0.108658202,
0.0445757993,
0.6329371929,
0.7238996625,
-0.5911022425,
-0.6982124448,
-0.9991571307,
0.5888549089,
-0.1450151801,
-0.01080631,
0.6165215969,
0.535900712,
0.6772389412,
-0.0874486193,
0.9032080173,
-0.115460299,
0.1837940216,
-0.8953772187,
0.9210020304,
-0.3653652072,
0.2130101174,
-0.1265955418,
-0.6135413051,
0.0971189886,
0.8921278119,
-0.1594560742,
-0.3409281969,
0.8259544373,
0.6509364247,
0.2057420313,
0.2886627913,
0.4728723168,
0.3625973463,
0.183424294,
0.6073200107,
0.8244982958,
-0.4375641346,
0.5823886991,
-0.3007536829,
-0.1054790914,
0.0316828862,
-0.5541796088,
-1.0113966465,
-0.8165490627,
-0.2870709896,
-0.1872714013,
0.3650565445,
0.7136676311,
0.7553043962,
-0.8060317039,
-0.1156053841,
-0.2331736982,
-0.1960108131,
0.0993064493,
-0.1923111379,
0.0362165347,
-0.3078799546,
-0.5680398345,
0.710257709,
0.3294377029,
0.0052303006,
0.1297860742,
-0.4142273664,
-0.1366560906,
-0.1932600737,
0.6608029008,
-0.2288169414,
-0.7474517226,
-0.2222221047,
-0.0997382849,
0.0075016143,
0.0978462771,
1.0517803431,
-0.9148210883,
0.7518945932,
0.6174466014,
0.5260208249,
0.9808553457,
-0.0156072425,
0.6974278092,
-0.753845036,
0.4103806019,
0.2800010741,
0.4655626714,
0.1822683215,
-0.4018437862,
0.3960243464,
-0.0532698445,
-0.487745434,
-0.300432384,
-0.152313605,
-1.2049338818,
-0.3229108751,
1.1945819855,
-0.246670261,
-0.1094779,
-0.3417135477,
-0.3747522831,
0.5968467593,
-0.6364082098,
0.0679661334,
0.5113292933,
-0.0895403177,
-0.2818510532,
-0.6805386543,
0.4058173895,
0.2978499532,
-0.8315364122,
-0.0883211046,
0.3104484081,
0.2764720023,
-0.0414690785,
0.6772865057,
0.0175273269,
0.0814672112,
0.0851730332,
-0.1617359966,
-0.1829086542,
-0.223560527,
-0.5862435699,
-0.0872683451,
0.0305637885,
-0.4554634094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12295v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12295v2 | Logic-LM: Empowering Large Language Models with Symbolic Solvers for Faithful Logical Reasoning | 2023-05-20T22:25:38 | 2023-10-19T01:54:27 | Liangming Pan, Alon Albalak, Xinyi Wang, William Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown human-like reasoning abilities but
still struggle with complex logical problems. This paper introduces a novel
framework, Logic-LM, which integrates LLMs with symbolic solvers to improve
logical problem-solving. Our method first utilizes LLMs to translate a natural
language problem into a symbolic formulation. Afterward, a deterministic
symbolic solver performs inference on the formulated problem. We also introduce
a self-refinement module, which utilizes the symbolic solver's error messages
to revise symbolic formalizations. We demonstrate Logic-LM's effectiveness on
five logical reasoning datasets: ProofWriter, PrOntoQA, FOLIO,
LogicalDeduction, and AR-LSAT. On average, Logic-LM achieves a significant
performance boost of 39.2% over using LLM alone with standard prompting and
18.4% over LLM with chain-of-thought prompting. Our findings suggest that
Logic-LM, by combining LLMs with symbolic logic, offers a promising avenue for
faithful logical reasoning. Code and data are publicly available at
https://github.com/teacherpeterpan/Logic-LLM. | [
-0.0284510758,
-0.8410155177,
0.9668931365,
0.1901970804,
-0.0938601941,
0.1552690268,
-0.2582139075,
-0.3705446422,
-0.1373315156,
0.6769734025,
-0.7727059126,
-0.3171952367,
-0.4295709431,
0.4077641368,
-0.2386263907,
0.4655358195,
-0.064716503,
0.4153345227,
-0.3327683508,
-0.0696541294,
-0.4766921699,
-0.6216167212,
-0.4847044647,
-0.6193773746,
0.3899540305,
0.002544574,
0.663942039,
0.7346619368,
0.4452315867,
0.3804292679,
0.1326089203,
0.4288756251,
-0.2908285856,
0.3643725216,
-0.5328021646,
-0.7602833509,
-0.3158702552,
-0.1848103404,
0.6315205097,
0.5607385635,
-0.1544665694,
0.1281642467,
-0.2736380398,
0.8415585756,
-0.4806657135,
0.6026224494,
-0.6393079758,
0.0515236706,
0.0203641336,
-0.0770464018,
-0.5243993402,
-0.5764824748,
-0.264770925,
-0.7022115588,
-0.2800881565,
0.2051423788,
0.4445223212,
0.707619071,
-0.1910213232,
-0.0620377176,
-0.8025170565,
1.0472031832,
-0.7366726995,
0.5778981447,
-0.0508794039,
0.5063017607,
-0.6448508501,
-0.5723353028,
-0.6453301311,
-0.0972194597,
-0.0552416556,
0.0276769847,
-0.2331035435,
0.0151101062,
0.5332946777,
0.0331470184,
-0.4158121347,
-0.246142894,
-0.2029573172,
-0.0186858922,
0.6941996813,
0.3143020272,
0.1840844601,
0.3119146526,
-0.2633527219,
0.1205261499,
-0.7937729359,
-0.3855561614,
0.0752526745,
0.2730448842,
0.3960616291,
0.5747907758,
-0.1707334369,
0.849658668,
-0.0942693129,
-0.3250710964,
0.1202091798,
-0.123601228,
-0.3079939485,
0.1776891053,
0.6393873692,
-0.0418495163,
0.7411513925,
0.1685966104,
-0.5888494849,
0.4026705325,
-0.0322000384,
-0.7055151463,
-0.1841213107,
0.1551253945,
-0.2697167397,
-0.0200606473,
-0.0069696498,
-0.124601312,
-0.4550290108,
-0.8752849102,
0.6182097197,
-0.4330378771,
-0.19769831,
0.6791135669,
-0.0031243812,
0.2167007476,
0.7303435206,
-0.2854609787,
0.512675941,
0.9287555218,
0.3132741749,
0.1650574356,
-0.0452922173,
-0.8881450295,
0.3412161171,
-0.4316985011,
0.6031296253,
-0.4819096029,
0.1225646511,
-0.076258406,
-0.1525341421,
0.1242039353,
-0.7544522882,
0.6040754914,
-0.5436018109,
0.1532897651,
-0.3449600935,
-0.7595512867,
-0.1450981498,
0.4167764485,
-0.8013601303,
0.9306441545,
-0.1359915435,
-0.4212061465,
-0.1094287187,
-0.4353588223,
-0.2862758934,
0.116011478,
-0.5416125655,
-0.1427731961,
0.1557538658,
0.2133052051,
0.4982251525,
-0.5942821503,
0.6638159752,
-0.1978712231,
-0.4225858152,
0.2986088693,
-0.1525112689,
0.8011651039,
0.2908518612,
-0.1500848383,
0.3250344098,
-0.5739586949,
0.0586143211,
0.5008930564,
0.0962820202,
-0.1943676621,
0.1936234683,
-0.3379099667,
0.5443717241,
0.3028135002,
-0.4850567579,
0.1095827073,
-0.4596087635,
0.3104262352,
0.7716169357,
-0.3985281587,
0.1089309379,
-0.5097352266,
0.302821219,
0.1757505089,
0.0419954807,
-0.1943415552,
-0.387850076,
-0.7325630188,
-0.2932845056,
-0.0529215857,
0.6167585254,
-0.7389384508,
0.5752037168,
-0.21980533,
-0.2196767628,
-0.4680967331,
0.450150162,
0.444455564,
0.5111339092,
0.4576105177,
0.2251744121,
-0.4755377471,
-0.9638499022,
-0.6981301308,
-0.2983860672,
-0.0328997113,
-0.090818353,
0.4843364358,
-0.2480893731,
1.0935474634,
-0.4791163206,
-0.3859267831,
-0.5459987521,
-0.2670195401,
0.437056005,
0.3134292662,
0.0055410531,
-0.5969459414,
-0.2127285898,
-0.2607794404,
-0.9901247621,
-0.4459173381,
-0.1680254638,
-0.0567632914,
0.377150178,
0.5729905367,
-0.7383960485,
0.1213390678,
0.1098188311,
-0.3406058848,
0.7482684255,
-0.1920609325,
-0.2743562758,
-0.9170249701,
-0.1847559512,
0.1609254926,
-0.4146843851,
-0.4597898722,
0.2535347939,
0.1337257028,
-0.0756306425,
-0.4780025482,
0.7142086625,
-0.4402776062,
0.1539107859,
-0.1805368066,
0.4316010177,
0.0065261787,
0.3386643231,
0.1738995165,
0.3652483225,
0.3292287886,
-0.2292876244,
0.676852107,
-0.1084881201,
-0.1408484578,
0.4110108316,
-0.6941601038,
0.0100130625,
-0.3068484664,
0.4877616465,
-0.5523271561,
-0.0597232431,
0.3963571489,
0.0317443646,
0.1411312819,
0.1614217311,
-0.9358427525,
-0.3037187457,
-0.283123374,
0.4476184249,
0.5563836694,
-0.5333316922,
1.032499671,
-0.0096604293,
0.1064104512,
-0.3395933509,
-0.6574477553,
0.1100140661,
0.0295915995,
-0.7766939998,
0.065368861,
-0.2061614394,
-0.7271727324,
0.0491820723,
-0.3700968325,
0.2170391083,
-0.0466353521,
-0.0210370962,
0.2340007573,
-0.1667298824,
0.3528764844,
0.0067281113,
-0.3243477345,
0.6027789712,
-0.6301909089,
0.434255302,
-0.551727891,
-0.6028243303,
-0.5566548109,
0.2241212279,
0.3760851622,
-0.4474240839,
0.7279261351,
0.309684664,
-0.6120314002,
-0.5843760371,
-0.8017160296,
-0.4634952545,
-0.4694434404,
0.200459227,
-0.5570605397,
-0.943569839,
0.2258620262,
-0.3898802102,
0.025271818,
0.2692418098,
0.5034361482,
0.005095074,
1.0012480021,
0.2204438448,
-0.0667330027,
-0.0121697625,
0.1620902717,
0.2567366958,
-0.3014464676,
-0.3373813629,
-0.3924074471,
-0.1847463548,
-0.2283387482,
-0.5444691181,
0.0324202999,
0.0992993787,
-0.5617538691,
0.0826642811,
-0.4171920717,
0.6338956356,
0.3226770163,
0.0840192139,
0.6769384742,
-0.0255146828,
-0.1361334771,
-0.2190945596,
-0.6919131875,
-0.4193955362,
0.6611050367,
0.3698842227,
1.140639782,
0.2177649736,
0.6860818863,
0.0121947573,
0.2548571229,
-0.800950706,
1.0325381756,
-0.1110184267,
-0.3565832675,
-0.0727244094,
-0.6121156812,
-0.4377030134,
0.2663112879,
-0.1945041567,
-0.5003587008,
-0.3443286419,
0.2047014534,
-0.0435604937,
0.3373534977,
-0.4849350154,
0.7226663828,
-0.6210434437,
-0.3637545109,
-0.3488376141,
-0.6213313341,
0.4925508797,
-0.2520521879,
0.2776291072,
-0.2916395962,
-0.116677925,
0.5120473504,
-0.4709151387,
0.8214460015,
0.014457738,
-0.4100872576,
0.1404589713,
0.425588876,
0.7519226074,
-0.0544115603,
-0.0744935274,
-0.055984728,
-0.0401049852,
-0.2185813189,
-1.2163767815,
0.6744242907,
-0.5211084485,
-1.1303429604,
-0.5821300745,
-0.8122858405,
-0.1545911133,
0.2906375527,
-0.5068942308,
0.3696666658,
0.2852953076,
0.116024524,
0.9298380017,
-0.1528103054,
-0.0006360108,
0.4617683291,
-0.6645613909,
-0.278411746,
0.7081454992,
-0.098161146,
0.3419315517,
0.4452735186,
0.5115925074,
-0.4660282433,
-0.0397915095,
-0.2923367023,
0.5611102581,
-0.9364089966,
-0.3041798174,
-0.4936250448,
-0.4801240265,
-0.0621225238,
0.0126185352,
-0.3632583022,
-0.6025691032,
0.0519863218,
0.0843124986,
0.4904793203,
0.4928610623,
0.2102419883,
-0.1350145489,
-0.7244933248,
0.543745935,
0.1783939302,
0.1822817773,
-0.2132121176,
-0.3213205338,
0.150688678,
-0.0025530455,
-0.0081216451,
-0.7503145933,
0.355889231,
0.0469807796,
0.4737113118,
0.2460197806,
0.1872029006,
0.6013136506,
-0.5252671838,
0.2974380553,
0.238452971,
-0.9912245274,
0.7156146765,
-0.3038719893,
0.5324581265,
0.2571929097,
0.2495930195,
-0.3557266891,
-0.5189743638,
-0.2624971271,
-0.4863655567,
0.5141171813,
0.2745865583,
-0.2671630383,
0.0081734369,
0.4293047488,
-0.1508229226,
0.0605542809,
-0.8191106915,
-0.3514757752,
-0.1436947286,
-0.6227538586,
0.1637650877,
-0.0159607958,
-0.2806017995,
-0.5375608206,
0.7864188552,
-0.2058648467,
-0.0133739719,
0.1468159258,
-0.1215486601,
-0.1164926961,
0.3915172517,
0.3229216337,
0.5964179635,
0.0115491487,
0.4430017471,
0.1380696446,
-0.0400319658,
0.2488737553,
0.216084674,
-0.1892254949,
-0.1979585439,
0.2758240402,
0.2653205693,
0.0357544608,
-1.0197689533,
0.0995432734,
-0.055831328,
-0.203142345,
-0.432122618,
0.3289444149,
0.3673539162,
0.4318552911,
0.3816585541,
-0.1664845347,
-0.093492575,
-0.4203698039,
0.0298114885,
0.492364049,
-0.1094724834,
-0.0776319653,
0.7053928375,
0.0028276895,
-0.3037512302,
0.6492317915,
-0.1715291739,
-0.7557418942,
0.483651787,
1.0883572102,
0.7905861735,
-0.1478238106,
-0.0683817044,
0.2197829634,
0.4247189462,
-0.3478918076,
0.557293117,
0.1789966226,
-0.9156183004,
-0.7020739317,
-0.5923942327,
-0.2977126241,
0.0365474299,
-0.1492967606,
0.2131883055,
-0.551964581,
0.1526711732,
-0.383692205,
0.1179246455,
-0.4752404094,
0.1422798038,
-0.0591077618,
1.1969950199,
-0.4740825891,
0.8942190409,
0.8148781061,
-0.1301998794,
-0.9357109666,
-0.2793682814,
0.230780229,
-0.5350294709,
0.9291399121,
0.3065243363,
-0.6005445719,
0.0418166406,
-0.4680010378,
-0.5227581859,
1.0510201454,
0.7565520406,
-0.9458639026,
0.3164019585,
0.5133572817,
0.4183821082,
-0.3073083758,
-0.009531742,
0.5265724659,
0.6124531031,
0.0913412869,
-0.5976591706,
0.527723074,
-0.2420448512,
-0.0782846808,
0.4616886377,
-0.5923289061,
0.5749407411,
-0.1966836303,
-0.0912317112,
0.0530460551,
0.8814296126,
0.9245700836,
0.1673661172,
0.5020879507,
0.7236210108,
0.8136472106,
-0.1956646591,
0.7638343573,
-0.4023055136,
0.0653914437,
1.1095869541,
-0.6114265919,
0.6909813285,
0.5717106462,
0.0148302317,
0.4396997988,
0.0981899202,
0.028517371,
-0.0218251683,
0.5401490331,
-0.5586069822,
-0.838514924,
-0.173611477,
-0.3299728036,
0.0935863703,
0.4240665436,
-0.1879844368,
-0.3316350281,
-0.4558770955,
0.034963768,
0.4218839705,
-0.2605088949,
0.2910954952,
0.5198442936,
-0.3968945146,
0.3550526798,
0.1157812327,
0.3433595002,
-0.6006575823,
-0.1853111088,
-0.1560913473,
0.5538991094,
-0.2622258663,
-0.7465137839,
0.3470704257,
-0.1404341459,
-0.0044138082,
-0.3744731843,
1.1319625378,
-0.379986912,
-0.7810320854,
0.4310412407,
0.8017895222,
-0.1077597663,
-0.1676016152,
-0.6672953963,
0.2309530228,
-0.3369083703,
-0.0536413714,
0.1563465893,
0.6529352665,
-0.3451372981,
1.2108536959,
0.6876441836,
-0.0477220081,
-0.1653492153,
0.325473994,
0.90551126,
-0.8652626872,
-0.1223777309,
-1.1066682339,
0.2174856216,
0.0727869496,
0.2799371481,
0.7996171117,
0.5520836115,
0.8838008046,
-0.194590807,
0.5098028779,
0.3258505166,
0.1299231052,
-0.5513064861,
0.549227953,
-0.5374424458,
0.5317380428,
-0.1618298441,
-1.0627797842,
-0.6714491248,
0.6844545603,
-0.219457984,
0.0995065868,
0.5458129644,
0.8663475513,
-0.0296326503,
0.0681306645,
0.2266861796,
0.3553147912,
0.3144153655,
0.7890750766,
1.1455526352,
-0.1732891351,
0.3188800216,
-0.1854260713,
-0.0897897631,
0.2211149633,
-1.0421607494,
-0.9694501758,
-0.1317592263,
-0.3395593464,
-0.2337003946,
0.275413096,
1.3910735846,
0.3943409324,
-0.6049326062,
-0.3527105451,
-0.1699861586,
0.2540768385,
-0.1436260343,
-0.2299012393,
0.053169746,
-0.4830987751,
-0.4200503826,
0.480473876,
0.3355898857,
-0.4551507831,
-0.3691701889,
-0.4206399918,
-0.0160873085,
0.3353760839,
0.7796162963,
0.0587151162,
-1.0222189426,
-0.166765213,
0.1094945222,
0.0076508205,
-0.1307111681,
0.7426456809,
-1.1548284292,
0.2534825802,
0.4383822978,
0.7828741074,
0.2043606192,
-0.0231601037,
0.6142432094,
-0.4305746853,
-0.0500632562,
0.2402996868,
0.6054897308,
0.1071694866,
-0.0854548439,
0.4887008965,
0.47764045,
-0.2950309515,
-0.6563021541,
0.4766276479,
-0.8462039828,
-0.4286252558,
1.0839517117,
0.1130908579,
-0.2448834628,
-0.0187125076,
-0.0989851654,
0.0943601578,
-0.3578910232,
0.5737994313,
0.5230116844,
-0.1690972149,
-0.3382916749,
-0.3703430295,
0.2191739082,
0.5631014109,
-0.9595558643,
0.0005354756,
0.7534512281,
0.2341959625,
-0.0136326374,
0.3493457139,
-0.2498059869,
0.2018831074,
-0.4271039665,
-0.0504718423,
-0.5193637013,
-0.5087358952,
-0.3500208557,
-0.0124973245,
0.0117652221,
0.4083403051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12289v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12289v1 | Revisiting the Architectures like Pointer Networks to Efficiently Improve the Next Word Distribution, Summarization Factuality, and Beyond | 2023-05-20T21:52:24 | 2023-05-20T21:52:24 | Haw-Shiuan Chang, Zonghai Yao, Alolika Gon, Hong Yu, Andrew McCallum | cs.CL | cs.CL | Is the output softmax layer, which is adopted by most language models (LMs),
always the best way to compute the next word probability? Given so many
attention layers in a modern transformer-based LM, are the pointer networks
redundant nowadays? In this study, we discover that the answers to both
questions are no. This is because the softmax bottleneck sometimes prevents the
LMs from predicting the desired distribution and the pointer networks can be
used to break the bottleneck efficiently. Based on the finding, we propose
several softmax alternatives by simplifying the pointer networks and
accelerating the word-by-word rerankers. In GPT-2, our proposals are
significantly better and more efficient than mixture of softmax, a
state-of-the-art softmax alternative. In summarization experiments, without
significantly decreasing its training/testing speed, our best method based on
T5-Small improves factCC score by 2 points in CNN/DM and XSUM dataset, and
improves MAUVE scores by 30% in BookSum paragraph-level dataset. | [
-0.2792268991,
-0.4130836129,
0.3834585547,
0.0780314505,
-0.3282937109,
-0.3348897398,
-0.1553941816,
-0.1418210864,
0.1044182926,
0.3022379577,
-0.193783626,
-0.2924360335,
-0.5912682414,
0.1118773669,
-0.5197386146,
1.0433996916,
0.2407954484,
-0.2650954425,
-0.0700813755,
-0.3763943315,
-0.3370873928,
-0.2562139332,
-0.5301963091,
-0.6039335728,
0.8169324398,
0.508390367,
0.9540838003,
0.785792172,
0.5918784738,
0.4678291678,
-0.2432480901,
0.2075579315,
-0.6077097058,
0.082941778,
-0.0585366562,
-0.2744296789,
-0.5579901934,
0.0037630652,
0.6847214103,
1.0424752235,
0.0134155536,
0.1551047266,
0.1959246397,
0.9224179983,
-0.7532051206,
0.29834041,
-0.3720581532,
0.2514878213,
0.0618836582,
-0.2604466677,
-0.4511443079,
-0.5326387286,
0.3672114611,
-0.3287674189,
0.2600204647,
-0.0366431251,
0.4271255732,
0.1854649782,
-0.257989645,
0.2076069713,
-0.7413523197,
0.6899540424,
-0.4697158635,
0.5560619235,
0.0338373482,
0.0253083557,
0.0802543089,
-0.946195066,
-0.5658969879,
-0.232181862,
0.0707181469,
0.2312933952,
-0.1450548619,
-0.072088629,
-0.001703368,
0.144258678,
-0.5109359622,
-0.2367001772,
-0.5114099979,
-0.0534159951,
0.3854646385,
0.175389275,
-0.0539853647,
-0.1688137054,
-0.1795991212,
-0.2476278841,
-1.0291961432,
-0.1807278991,
0.158971265,
-0.0330316275,
0.373796761,
0.6948499084,
-0.1355493218,
0.5276491046,
0.0466584228,
-0.2183926851,
0.5189458728,
-0.4069690108,
-0.2277381271,
0.1312445104,
0.5599355102,
0.450192064,
0.3528829515,
-0.3239457607,
-0.0589430369,
-0.2817400694,
0.1361106038,
-0.7923690081,
-0.3974074125,
0.1775650531,
-0.4935956895,
-0.1865279078,
-0.1542126387,
-0.1356093138,
-0.2697604299,
-0.2938494384,
0.2952556014,
-0.5297144651,
-0.3480944335,
0.1990777403,
-0.3952909708,
0.1946286708,
0.2007357627,
-0.7097155452,
0.0566493385,
0.9549737573,
1.0186662674,
0.0093363086,
-0.3136005998,
-0.287651062,
0.3109737635,
-0.5492726564,
0.9899665713,
-0.2188940048,
-0.4863358736,
0.0338957012,
-0.2109142989,
-0.1885546148,
-0.565253377,
0.6632087231,
-0.4178521037,
0.4214325845,
-0.3679529727,
-0.5157685876,
-0.2622452974,
0.4084418416,
-0.6318703294,
0.8344312906,
-0.1835181266,
-1.0589174032,
0.2690197825,
-0.3334664404,
-0.6458512545,
-0.130859822,
0.1679147631,
-0.4306062758,
0.2831697166,
0.0151372068,
0.6016482711,
0.0670428872,
0.17035833,
-0.2956706882,
-0.6513568759,
0.2093411982,
-0.4219890237,
0.5490452051,
0.0535194948,
-0.2976303697,
0.0627628118,
-0.8021609783,
-0.1006577238,
-0.1330994517,
-0.4854999781,
-0.1636531055,
0.3817592859,
-0.2568099201,
0.262001425,
0.10298305,
-0.3112223744,
-0.030265091,
-0.7766839862,
0.4891922772,
0.8525575399,
-0.1890153587,
0.6112565398,
-0.4357224703,
0.3215892017,
0.0298894793,
0.2936908305,
-0.1652387232,
-0.6543439031,
-1.0336712599,
0.0023526684,
0.0362680331,
0.8817945123,
-0.8459922075,
0.3445954025,
-0.6995201111,
-0.3927830458,
-0.1662761271,
0.088978678,
0.5154307485,
0.8421918154,
0.3390409946,
-0.3902909756,
-0.2796770632,
-0.9549880028,
-0.2691605687,
-0.4243171513,
0.0382637829,
0.1492086053,
0.1171657294,
0.1979929507,
0.8913896084,
-0.4418075979,
-0.2159019262,
-0.6338537931,
-0.0375572369,
0.543125391,
0.274530977,
0.1591037363,
-0.7970204353,
-0.299483031,
-0.2519746721,
-0.4395413995,
0.0248147827,
0.3163532019,
0.2411089987,
0.0019919372,
0.4434420168,
-0.6728072166,
0.0910134688,
0.1693556011,
-0.1057864502,
0.6542713046,
-0.3446782529,
-0.2469770461,
-0.999591589,
0.1193580925,
0.0233401265,
-0.2067889571,
-0.7597863078,
-0.1807257384,
-0.0449118204,
0.0488648042,
-0.5505300164,
0.3931525946,
-0.635491848,
-0.1214123741,
-0.3820943534,
0.3263365328,
0.1196677834,
0.5253174305,
-0.0938412026,
0.7926152945,
0.3625255823,
-0.5150110126,
0.3596233726,
0.3062142432,
-0.3285078108,
0.2179140598,
-0.9061471224,
0.0143759884,
-0.6285110116,
0.393915236,
-1.1345105171,
0.3358834386,
0.2311792672,
-0.3334677219,
0.4251244664,
0.0062250234,
-0.3772799671,
-0.3962091506,
-0.9035077691,
0.1562719196,
0.6040834785,
-0.2870527208,
0.3498044908,
0.3986282945,
-0.1711758375,
-0.9300612807,
-0.8846443892,
0.3284615278,
-0.1027141884,
-0.6626582742,
0.238016963,
0.0944882557,
-0.1365474463,
-0.0028828094,
0.0706809238,
0.1683858186,
-0.1276166588,
0.1651413888,
0.0108913258,
-0.3450841606,
0.237797305,
-0.118026562,
-0.3996061683,
-0.0293778256,
-0.6209585071,
0.2225446105,
-0.2075822651,
0.0811402798,
-0.2706630528,
0.3714173436,
0.1882970631,
-0.2122613788,
0.6555100679,
0.6980187893,
0.0150237856,
-0.0661853477,
-0.5571275949,
-0.1047489271,
-0.500710845,
0.634763658,
-0.3876186013,
-0.9604501128,
0.2087165862,
0.0292353779,
0.1814725697,
0.3662655652,
0.6944825649,
0.0331604816,
0.9465248585,
0.8413449526,
-0.2484572679,
0.5063845515,
-0.5026524067,
0.4748747349,
-0.893611908,
-0.2206440866,
-0.3671357036,
-0.3734493256,
-0.5534229875,
-0.4927656054,
0.6649163961,
-0.1478875428,
0.0438297726,
0.3385794163,
-0.4253142774,
0.401715368,
0.570672214,
0.1207775474,
0.301338017,
0.0846761763,
-0.1724819094,
0.1857172996,
-1.0792270899,
-0.3598749638,
1.0358192921,
0.3025850952,
0.3536327779,
0.2363382429,
0.4755658805,
0.1517307162,
0.6911517978,
-0.7002516389,
0.8425787687,
-0.3498327136,
-0.283948034,
-0.4490479529,
-0.3770645559,
-0.8336824179,
0.6530639529,
0.0934133306,
-0.6002342105,
0.42091313,
0.3077383935,
-0.4018693268,
0.2108044028,
-0.8906427026,
0.740316689,
0.469203651,
-0.5714584589,
-0.313151449,
-0.7294711471,
0.484775722,
0.3773097098,
0.007176497,
-0.0832286328,
-0.3912794292,
0.6565086842,
-0.6460772753,
0.6869180799,
0.0182596128,
-0.1048512161,
0.4679629803,
-0.138871491,
0.4882253706,
-0.0311536975,
-0.3074371219,
-0.1732853055,
-0.5334736109,
-0.2352211624,
-0.555570662,
0.664549768,
-0.6255375743,
-0.7434282899,
-0.2241703719,
-0.4260246456,
-0.3666798174,
0.0760665163,
0.1813200116,
0.9651395679,
-0.1540359259,
0.2099075913,
0.7526461482,
-0.0112614725,
0.6636779308,
0.2015835196,
0.2996256351,
-0.3499378264,
1.1022398472,
0.1722708195,
-0.0894316882,
0.8194779158,
0.3712466061,
-0.5730946064,
-0.8096619844,
-0.1652312875,
0.3063305318,
-0.7402814627,
-0.2431774139,
-1.0519617796,
-0.2125725895,
-0.5526369214,
0.1374482512,
-0.2925786972,
-0.8002937436,
-0.1266516447,
-0.3877726793,
0.1175889298,
0.5329078436,
-0.2343633473,
0.2448120415,
-0.7671819925,
0.1051353663,
0.3317064047,
0.1456715018,
0.0226306338,
-0.6558465362,
-0.2183153033,
-0.4653349221,
-0.3100173473,
-0.8576540947,
0.1895148307,
0.5425751209,
0.2117084116,
0.548120141,
-0.296997577,
0.3348791599,
-1.0029667616,
0.5435706377,
0.3259882033,
-0.6325408816,
0.0613841712,
-0.1644794792,
0.3848709166,
0.4197460711,
0.2871395648,
-0.5918405652,
-0.4034644663,
-0.6079663634,
-0.8672196865,
0.3732759356,
0.1237236187,
0.3460284472,
-0.1374283731,
0.3276470602,
-0.0915163085,
0.3100566864,
-0.3402962983,
-0.4023271501,
-0.3102731407,
-0.248301819,
-0.239291653,
-0.7700806856,
0.2695493996,
-0.2187154889,
0.6990544796,
-0.1626374573,
0.1710814536,
0.3051127195,
-0.0865619481,
0.2414142787,
0.2197550684,
0.542532146,
1.0847601891,
-0.1428613812,
0.3777870536,
0.1946405321,
-0.5606130958,
0.0881586745,
0.082439959,
-0.3747596145,
0.2261503637,
0.5897009373,
0.7773283124,
0.3157806098,
-0.4163634777,
0.8171630502,
0.0750286207,
-0.2158388644,
-0.1476258039,
0.2816971242,
0.2271474004,
0.3112832308,
0.2048022151,
0.0064313244,
0.528722465,
-0.4724850953,
0.373521179,
0.3141655326,
-0.3418684006,
-0.4205558598,
0.4578659832,
0.229204759,
-0.146182701,
0.5050110221,
-0.0036895501,
-0.6644489169,
0.4460591972,
0.3221479952,
0.8506797552,
-0.2179685086,
0.4950295389,
0.2353053242,
0.4167684019,
-0.1480975002,
0.1829042286,
-0.1461760253,
-0.7543209195,
-0.8897550702,
-0.2684298754,
-0.289842546,
-0.1611610502,
-0.0321314447,
0.1007836089,
-0.4997750223,
-0.2520524561,
-0.1912480742,
0.1089993417,
-0.354519695,
0.1445034891,
0.0816078633,
1.0009768009,
-0.5895140171,
0.9065895677,
0.5784717798,
-0.1081858128,
-0.8198517561,
-0.3623819649,
-0.2167471051,
-0.7472106218,
0.4952042103,
0.1913217753,
-0.199201107,
-0.0691529438,
-0.1526859254,
-0.7704042196,
1.1820908785,
0.1183860451,
-0.4020924866,
-0.0892497376,
0.1315945089,
0.4959838092,
0.020626368,
0.529173553,
0.4529334605,
0.4535533488,
0.2310303152,
-0.5841347575,
-0.0854349434,
-0.2942331433,
0.2535084188,
0.3246865571,
-0.7949672937,
0.8267496228,
-0.4918012917,
-0.1267874837,
0.0566130839,
1.0641777515,
0.0276151784,
0.109496668,
0.5795659423,
0.6643334627,
0.4282563627,
0.0645174384,
1.1661016941,
-0.2645601332,
0.3211028874,
1.0837602615,
-0.1896350682,
0.7915709615,
0.4021269977,
-0.1885431111,
0.2908605039,
0.2741609514,
0.1509174705,
0.4291647375,
0.2947773635,
-0.2665795982,
-0.1419083476,
-0.2137753516,
-0.436609149,
0.2656342983,
0.1875033528,
-0.2061482817,
-0.3626896739,
-0.2132348418,
0.1609168202,
-0.163485527,
-0.1781998873,
0.6539056897,
0.225275591,
-0.5784454942,
0.3892371953,
0.2756214738,
0.5141579509,
-0.4198521078,
0.0910199359,
-0.7194654346,
0.5180581212,
0.0386502557,
-0.7327758074,
0.2369514108,
-0.2412956953,
-0.1661281288,
-0.3763293624,
1.0863384008,
-0.4679745436,
-0.6302188039,
-0.1232862845,
0.7539849281,
0.133914426,
-0.0602475069,
-0.716676414,
-0.2419289052,
-0.3498485684,
-0.6019325256,
0.0249934103,
0.5466561913,
0.1581512541,
0.8655885458,
0.5500237346,
0.1655504405,
0.2618911266,
0.2172735333,
0.9071444869,
-0.4831550121,
-0.601577282,
-0.8902309537,
0.1833654046,
-0.1197713837,
-0.354426682,
0.7328042388,
0.4635327756,
0.5426930785,
0.1547163129,
0.430024296,
0.1375969201,
0.4411307275,
-0.3204016387,
0.4649762213,
-0.481505245,
0.090823561,
-0.1522047818,
-1.1011699438,
-0.4106220901,
0.3355989158,
-0.2633731067,
0.0547162704,
0.8338492513,
0.8386709094,
-0.132890448,
0.0129907094,
0.2978610396,
0.3195236027,
0.3020237982,
0.8004475236,
0.7039870024,
-0.4420509636,
0.8434091806,
-0.246303454,
-0.2462831587,
-0.2611423135,
-0.9607894421,
-0.8489285111,
-0.4307449162,
-0.3954694271,
-0.2428672165,
0.392097801,
0.4349947274,
0.6107258797,
-0.5680402517,
-0.0734405667,
0.1359661222,
0.4819494188,
-0.2526291013,
-0.1342242807,
0.705968082,
-0.335224092,
-0.6015082598,
0.2278211564,
0.6243342757,
-0.3036392033,
-0.3280336857,
0.0730191842,
-0.0235754456,
-0.0412859693,
0.9176698327,
0.1787534207,
-0.2152620256,
-0.3152484596,
-0.0622276627,
-0.1209830642,
0.0395741537,
1.1145869493,
-0.7836354375,
-0.0915544853,
0.8886376619,
0.6166610122,
0.0154442443,
-0.194966495,
0.514714241,
-0.5640985966,
0.4213284552,
0.1787870079,
0.5474863648,
0.4795980453,
0.0035644521,
0.4427839816,
0.4247884154,
-0.2687428892,
-0.414590925,
0.0776135847,
-0.7230036259,
-0.2284230143,
1.1223250628,
-0.0753670707,
-0.5981144905,
-0.202555865,
-0.0179818757,
0.1180176884,
-0.1294008046,
0.6238148808,
0.4548717141,
0.0221224949,
-0.340202719,
-0.3064028919,
0.4377687275,
0.8142268658,
-0.4508258998,
-0.1325607896,
0.4848785102,
0.2906554341,
0.2285804152,
0.8949737549,
-0.0798612013,
0.1852112859,
-0.4003668725,
-0.3464538157,
-0.2949746549,
-0.6491393447,
-0.1077088714,
0.54006809,
-0.0651665777,
-0.2200443596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12281v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12281v1 | Lifelong Language Pretraining with Distribution-Specialized Experts | 2023-05-20T21:15:19 | 2023-05-20T21:15:19 | Wuyang Chen, Yanqi Zhou, Nan Du, Yanping Huang, James Laudon, Zhifeng Chen, Claire Cu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pretraining on a large-scale corpus has become a standard method to build
general language models (LMs). Adapting a model to new data distributions
targeting different downstream tasks poses significant challenges. Naive
fine-tuning may incur catastrophic forgetting when the over-parameterized LMs
overfit the new data but fail to preserve the pretrained features. Lifelong
learning (LLL) aims to enable information systems to learn from a continuous
data stream across time. However, most prior work modifies the training recipe
assuming a static fixed network architecture. We find that additional model
capacity and proper regularization are key elements to achieving strong LLL
performance. Thus, we propose Lifelong-MoE, an extensible MoE
(Mixture-of-Experts) architecture that dynamically adds model capacity via
adding experts with regularized pretraining. Our results show that by only
introducing a limited number of extra experts while keeping the computation
cost constant, our model can steadily adapt to data distribution shifts while
preserving the previous knowledge. Compared to existing lifelong learning
approaches, Lifelong-MoE achieves better few-shot performance on 19 downstream
NLP tasks. | [
-0.5175141096,
-0.6400333047,
0.182852,
0.163637802,
-0.2727609277,
0.1377669424,
-0.4910101593,
-0.5084363222,
0.1975393295,
0.6689932346,
-0.4431546926,
-0.2108612657,
-0.6091614962,
-0.03389154,
-0.1346872896,
0.965331018,
0.1474408954,
-0.2367205769,
0.0668208301,
-0.1607240438,
-0.6641152501,
-0.347417593,
-0.7859892249,
-0.0930616781,
0.4914085865,
0.3939734995,
0.6747640967,
0.4744984806,
0.2232338488,
0.2055435479,
0.3191491961,
0.2366157919,
-0.8372510076,
0.2678847015,
-0.1660231054,
-0.5400535464,
-0.5078866482,
-0.2247204632,
0.8809772134,
0.7675539255,
-0.3390346467,
-0.1488162577,
0.223764047,
0.7849159241,
-0.793114841,
-0.0257898793,
-1.0190924406,
-0.0726201236,
-0.2767451704,
-0.261580348,
-0.5652395487,
-0.0966858417,
0.2747693062,
-0.5699259639,
-0.0599769279,
-0.0192857292,
0.7133398056,
0.4960797727,
-0.15701814,
-0.2137655765,
-0.7845272422,
0.816200316,
-0.6226252317,
0.4708284438,
0.3162552714,
0.2177583873,
-0.0886018053,
-0.3775013685,
-0.3428171575,
-0.2174127549,
0.2965977788,
0.1379188597,
0.0216637384,
0.0063622626,
-0.2377382219,
0.1292218268,
-0.4207948744,
0.3504621387,
-0.2861769795,
0.0955615789,
0.6717840433,
0.0869018212,
-0.0051069655,
0.4359624982,
-0.2117280215,
0.2949628532,
-0.8173588514,
-0.296222806,
0.3677342534,
0.0254359934,
0.089463383,
0.0687990561,
-0.1676349044,
0.6587318182,
0.171863988,
0.0423247032,
0.1939814389,
-0.0319084637,
0.043653544,
-0.2796187103,
0.6654394865,
-0.0969135314,
0.8741622567,
-0.2605271041,
-0.2419260293,
-0.4098060727,
0.3552121818,
-0.2928639054,
-0.5304718614,
-0.0163117759,
-0.122736752,
0.0315595791,
-0.2164915353,
-0.4884271622,
0.0027859539,
-0.4257084429,
0.4353740215,
-0.5650718808,
-0.3886896968,
0.1608930379,
0.2384571731,
-0.1980234534,
0.306696862,
-1.2229537964,
0.2557656765,
0.5605737567,
0.685847044,
-0.5520740151,
-0.4109076858,
-0.634111166,
0.5357038975,
-0.4419471323,
0.8508453369,
-0.687173903,
-0.2435014099,
-0.0400817282,
-0.2320504487,
-0.2600502968,
-0.7020713091,
0.08637169,
-0.7761340141,
-0.2034489363,
0.1003323868,
-0.6717615724,
0.1667016894,
0.0872483626,
-0.4193592072,
1.0246771574,
0.1339534223,
-0.4936032891,
0.5894382,
-0.5532726049,
-0.3601790667,
0.3739577532,
-0.1564374417,
-0.2988602519,
0.1872774363,
0.1153622419,
0.7776402235,
0.1829558164,
0.380105406,
-0.4542404413,
-0.2766123414,
-0.0526478328,
-0.5027315021,
0.4699241519,
0.0824512988,
-0.0837040469,
-0.0014555465,
-0.7348989844,
-0.2655911446,
-0.1335167736,
-0.6762980819,
-0.3438368142,
0.2260195911,
-0.0945091099,
-0.0329720415,
0.3938810527,
-0.2383231819,
0.3224364221,
-0.3892709315,
0.255698204,
1.0180796385,
-0.0438428894,
0.6527512074,
-0.2373907566,
0.4115488231,
0.0678385571,
0.1879182756,
-0.142310217,
-0.5031092167,
-0.8725559115,
-0.319768995,
0.1264503151,
0.6362373829,
-0.6688410044,
0.7450982928,
-0.7208039761,
-0.4072210789,
-0.2993237376,
0.6366251707,
-0.0035502492,
0.3805024326,
0.4773332179,
-0.2392310947,
-0.4600144923,
-0.7774056792,
0.0193888228,
0.065726459,
-0.064430438,
0.2810322344,
0.4664459229,
-0.4779734612,
1.1869883537,
-0.3853729963,
-0.2905959785,
-0.3579710722,
-0.0085885348,
0.215168491,
0.6042698026,
0.4197244048,
-0.5544964671,
-0.7220376134,
0.009612673,
-0.6089476943,
0.0828867182,
-0.2626325488,
-0.2091511041,
0.2250796854,
0.3405303359,
-0.44969365,
-0.1425552368,
0.6339227557,
0.1617891788,
0.6049540639,
-0.499652952,
-0.4618887901,
-0.9913473725,
-0.1372417361,
-0.3135735393,
-0.3375604451,
-0.5017958879,
0.1218709424,
-0.0208340455,
-0.0613626763,
-0.2456649393,
0.778546989,
-0.4721949697,
0.0325383022,
-0.192036584,
-0.0978974029,
-0.4155101478,
0.3655438721,
0.2550341189,
0.6408661008,
0.7283799052,
-0.9794964194,
0.2917748094,
-0.0295132212,
-0.2370917648,
0.4887813628,
-0.4601169229,
0.1715138257,
-0.0842895955,
0.4610484242,
-0.5881431699,
-0.3240373135,
-0.0296963491,
-0.2621504366,
0.4028800428,
-0.0019682841,
-0.4198641479,
-0.2711651623,
-0.0548399054,
0.1367944628,
0.6520685554,
-0.2324417979,
0.8404664397,
0.3254817426,
-0.3446398675,
-0.5831011534,
-0.7306514978,
0.2490398437,
-0.0767518505,
-0.7009943724,
0.2503097951,
-0.2149435431,
0.1134581417,
0.0653231591,
0.200800702,
-0.296010077,
0.3332084119,
0.0006377472,
-0.0572052076,
-0.3622506857,
0.3727770746,
0.2371101975,
-0.4032537937,
-0.2430698872,
-0.5120324492,
0.5687973499,
0.129108578,
-0.2752252817,
-0.3565579951,
0.464993149,
0.2688061595,
-0.1540179253,
0.9333570004,
0.6978823543,
-0.184914887,
-0.3150332272,
-0.8520648479,
-0.0338238142,
-0.4686051905,
0.4859943986,
-0.3573826253,
-0.9258335829,
0.4825645089,
0.0185357053,
0.3385582566,
0.3658105135,
0.5828803778,
-0.2887866199,
0.6137759089,
0.8902807236,
-0.4073339105,
0.5402277112,
-0.1089193746,
-0.0527078398,
-0.5990396738,
0.1073241755,
-0.0123033393,
-0.2186324596,
-0.1597053558,
-0.2190312594,
0.3100176156,
0.3465870321,
-0.2292203605,
0.2356642038,
-0.1890627146,
0.5785340071,
0.5104880333,
0.1247617677,
0.1883320957,
-0.0070115156,
0.155818671,
0.2050555646,
-0.7532843947,
-0.3512628078,
1.3385672569,
0.4492664337,
0.7670765519,
0.039648369,
0.9654434323,
0.2166922837,
0.5948736668,
-0.4200187624,
0.4516733587,
-0.388929069,
-0.5926286578,
-0.4258435071,
-0.3274354935,
-0.7887851596,
-0.1109635755,
-0.189406395,
-0.5792816281,
0.151798144,
0.555429101,
-0.5786390305,
0.117100127,
-0.6077961326,
0.4367730319,
-0.1453037411,
-0.3160222471,
-0.4573130012,
-0.6105012298,
0.1631585658,
-0.5281389356,
0.1313516796,
-0.0981263891,
-0.2921660244,
0.6471095681,
-0.1597547084,
0.8323486447,
-0.2549906373,
-0.0074242041,
0.0676601976,
-0.1246112883,
0.6316247582,
0.2140999138,
-0.2210776955,
0.1296389848,
-0.3437820077,
-0.6567822099,
-0.4527624249,
0.532959342,
-0.8195283413,
-0.56163311,
0.1838141978,
-0.5598502755,
-0.4062383175,
0.2188088894,
0.4046392143,
0.2997130156,
0.0003630127,
0.6362530589,
1.0556014776,
-0.0260662995,
0.2958791554,
0.4343293011,
0.1055672765,
-0.305349052,
0.9000585079,
0.4290640056,
0.4658426642,
0.5188679099,
0.14023453,
-0.0776617303,
-0.8034402132,
-0.3087168932,
0.026354285,
-0.6899600625,
0.1428151876,
-0.9753168821,
-0.0351625942,
-0.3096528053,
-0.5119199753,
-0.5546405315,
0.0319992341,
-0.5435654521,
0.1286322773,
0.1834796369,
0.4662855864,
-0.2071022987,
0.5102245808,
-0.9263113141,
0.1459772587,
0.5080587268,
0.3200049102,
0.0717941001,
-0.6258497238,
-0.466599077,
-0.0231688246,
-0.1310592145,
-0.5881176591,
0.243081212,
0.7814776897,
0.7973766923,
0.5710889697,
-0.106100522,
0.6113188863,
-0.7344010472,
0.6660789847,
0.0451427922,
-0.621307075,
0.1956202686,
-0.6441997886,
0.3468245268,
0.72141397,
0.5876585245,
-0.2637210488,
-0.4692046344,
-0.31965065,
-0.8584948182,
0.2024648786,
-0.157576263,
0.6214601994,
-0.1768130064,
0.3722800314,
0.418859899,
0.0746196136,
-0.648575902,
0.0018144158,
0.0054467949,
-0.3823348284,
-0.3001384437,
-0.3182055056,
0.1606769711,
-0.2648076713,
0.5857721567,
-0.1397346109,
0.2083971053,
-0.3021869659,
-0.4283941984,
0.1925998032,
0.1176375523,
0.5207078457,
0.9192672372,
-0.2174233347,
-0.0908591598,
0.3955462873,
-0.4427234232,
0.0536506884,
-0.1539130807,
0.0078958971,
-0.0422290489,
0.4809805453,
0.8595376015,
0.5916320682,
-0.5156103969,
0.2685596943,
0.3781983852,
-0.1146572158,
-0.5242210031,
0.4898266196,
0.3324470818,
-0.0430470333,
0.7833331227,
0.2613326013,
-0.2858124673,
-0.4897332788,
0.4430534542,
0.2682548761,
-0.0487892255,
-0.2680368423,
0.4886090159,
0.4079093039,
-0.0747873262,
0.6215583086,
-0.1155491248,
-0.3199409544,
0.2793757319,
0.291823864,
0.7386529446,
-0.4367876351,
-0.0763693601,
0.0530201457,
0.1285670847,
-0.3325799406,
0.0058808159,
-0.2009729743,
-0.8353358507,
-0.5390959382,
-0.5774946213,
-0.1411959976,
-0.0478818119,
-0.5213734508,
0.2876708508,
-0.4939327538,
0.0119266072,
-0.3924541175,
-0.3792446256,
-0.8315096498,
0.2402415276,
0.0808200389,
0.8677479625,
-0.8086317778,
1.0111103058,
0.2484210134,
-0.1632114202,
-0.4795604944,
-0.0159147978,
-0.3512190878,
-0.7875861526,
0.8736875653,
0.0142109012,
0.1019675136,
0.4765543044,
-0.4924561679,
-0.9049466848,
0.8685928583,
0.422701925,
-0.87786901,
-0.3447972238,
-0.0875412747,
0.4492707253,
-0.4009920061,
0.2453685701,
0.2634964585,
0.1531557888,
-0.1116412506,
-0.8956201673,
-0.4844067693,
-0.0487884767,
-0.1401051134,
0.1166433096,
-0.4464178979,
0.9425525665,
0.0268140808,
-0.0628773943,
-0.1290232837,
0.8749639988,
0.2077695727,
-0.1170293093,
0.6067462564,
0.6026192307,
0.7545531988,
0.2176954448,
0.8955611587,
-0.3938619196,
0.2792866528,
1.2047456503,
-0.1848209947,
1.2652125359,
0.2080682963,
-0.0824740678,
0.5341050029,
0.6924871206,
0.1303064078,
0.4930753112,
-0.0418496281,
-0.3390139341,
-0.5714895129,
0.2439608723,
-0.4710130394,
0.1113536283,
0.5644211173,
-0.1827765405,
-0.1883094311,
0.3190749884,
-0.2152891308,
-0.1866036803,
-0.3605774343,
0.688026309,
0.0832592398,
-0.4977847934,
0.630148232,
-0.3683349788,
1.1017338037,
-0.8031519055,
0.3216310143,
-0.2377456576,
0.1564042121,
-0.0854153484,
-0.6780915856,
0.3922568858,
-0.1793131977,
-0.2270343751,
-0.230620414,
0.4515858293,
-0.3831752837,
-0.2976807356,
0.2253051996,
0.2314068973,
0.1561729908,
-0.1510380358,
-0.6983627081,
-0.1177229658,
-0.2577651143,
-0.4421082139,
0.5150337219,
0.3535403907,
-0.0113085527,
1.0557559729,
0.5853995681,
0.2662638128,
0.551834166,
-0.0783690512,
0.8345313072,
-0.1467106342,
-0.8010733128,
-0.7238273025,
0.6126970649,
0.0323706344,
-0.440808028,
0.4519450366,
0.242756635,
0.9365600944,
-0.2427929044,
0.7224962115,
0.2164843231,
0.2308851331,
-0.7153410912,
0.749258399,
-0.5407014489,
0.0159106273,
-0.0831333622,
-1.1063258648,
-0.2612009048,
0.4029159248,
-0.4719234407,
0.1245716438,
0.4595883787,
0.565659821,
-0.2490979135,
-0.3498359323,
0.4654944539,
0.0724312365,
0.3571157455,
0.7397410274,
0.5849190354,
0.0394431725,
0.2946139872,
0.0830584466,
-0.2544729412,
-0.433373481,
-0.8282423615,
-0.724927187,
-0.481056422,
-0.335467875,
0.2686342895,
0.3792617917,
0.9337684512,
0.9971396923,
-0.6972551346,
0.0784304142,
-0.370355159,
-0.259921968,
0.0020000292,
-0.2017718852,
0.186841473,
-0.610904336,
-0.6107158065,
0.5093518496,
0.5177406669,
-0.1729804277,
-0.4666635096,
-0.2336047888,
-0.213975206,
-0.0100770798,
0.4691086411,
0.3719690442,
-0.5141290426,
-0.3297136128,
-0.1860563159,
0.048415713,
-0.0418483019,
0.5362710953,
-0.7016379237,
0.5470283031,
0.4562714398,
1.1827315092,
0.2019885182,
-0.1466714442,
0.688575685,
-0.781632185,
0.1759974211,
0.3477623463,
0.2630552948,
0.0844823197,
-0.4220806956,
0.233578667,
0.3050207496,
-0.7512456179,
-0.6328826547,
0.2547283769,
-0.6391496658,
-0.2499875873,
1.0961989164,
-0.322873801,
0.0867439657,
-0.4896634817,
0.0999894291,
0.0079451418,
-0.4500029385,
0.5766413212,
0.7247183323,
0.0072538285,
-0.3005719483,
-0.6448357701,
0.2475273758,
0.562150538,
-0.7114212513,
-0.1661166996,
0.1939682215,
0.5222457051,
0.0424404889,
0.9783818126,
0.3431004584,
0.0944231153,
-0.0678041875,
-0.1552117467,
-0.1469495595,
-0.6080875993,
-0.1521706432,
0.1471628547,
0.0985196829,
0.0037832907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12280v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12280v3 | Contextualizing Argument Quality Assessment with Relevant Knowledge | 2023-05-20T21:04:58 | 2024-06-18T03:11:21 | Darshan Deshpande, Zhivar Sourati, Filip Ilievski, Fred Morstatter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic assessment of the quality of arguments has been recognized as a
challenging task with significant implications for misinformation and targeted
speech. While real-world arguments are tightly anchored in context, existing
computational methods analyze their quality in isolation, which affects their
accuracy and generalizability. We propose SPARK: a novel method for scoring
argument quality based on contextualization via relevant knowledge. We devise
four augmentations that leverage large language models to provide feedback,
infer hidden assumptions, supply a similar-quality argument, or give a
counter-argument. SPARK uses a dual-encoder Transformer architecture to enable
the original argument and its augmentation to be considered jointly. Our
experiments in both in-domain and zero-shot setups show that SPARK consistently
outperforms existing techniques across multiple metrics. | [
-0.4212650955,
-1.1881041527,
0.3546231091,
0.0883065313,
-0.317244947,
-0.1652458906,
-0.1276693344,
0.0368399918,
0.1848080009,
0.0731587559,
-0.201731801,
-0.2396695614,
-0.496533215,
-0.0371773839,
-0.3691719174,
0.8194695115,
-0.0642148852,
0.0957680419,
-0.8158164024,
-0.418181628,
-0.8781101108,
-0.3732681572,
-0.3996509612,
-0.3190096915,
0.4733341038,
0.386816144,
0.7041211724,
0.43306306,
0.2183413208,
0.3395813107,
-0.1122141778,
0.1363334507,
-0.3948079944,
0.4153249264,
-0.5267838836,
0.0115602966,
-0.1752782613,
-0.0805986971,
0.6395555735,
0.7356056571,
0.1126526743,
0.1718084663,
0.0488560908,
0.3019758165,
-0.8092220426,
-0.1004217714,
-0.6220814586,
-0.0897764191,
0.0618482195,
-0.3811801076,
-0.4010972381,
-0.4633180499,
0.1644984037,
-0.5394490957,
0.1718917489,
-0.0779129639,
0.9364154339,
0.4667862356,
-0.3541361988,
-0.2827313542,
-0.6002260447,
0.5270650983,
-0.7687690258,
0.0009208189,
0.091061078,
0.5265320539,
-0.0793326646,
-1.0373108387,
-0.5624372363,
0.2896488011,
-0.3154639006,
0.1815760583,
-0.1716673821,
-0.1190383658,
0.369238466,
0.307700634,
-0.3506262898,
-0.0620599873,
-0.2255958319,
-0.2591162026,
0.7785189152,
0.0788558125,
0.2844531238,
-0.3522316813,
-0.0916118324,
-0.4014719129,
-0.6942373514,
0.4902278781,
0.4306174219,
0.1015608013,
0.2216665596,
0.5069538951,
-0.3125386238,
0.978690505,
0.4388525486,
0.1823723316,
0.0381494164,
-0.4452794194,
-0.5105121136,
0.262675941,
0.8186703324,
0.3233427703,
-0.3177761734,
-0.0907691494,
0.335036695,
0.0031697068,
0.4397195876,
-0.8549942374,
-0.1663381159,
0.5546808839,
-0.2647188902,
-0.0536524318,
0.0619020499,
-0.9687739015,
-0.6552436352,
-0.2316350043,
0.484965682,
-0.2546618581,
-0.2419788837,
-0.1679216474,
-0.3111650348,
0.2084854096,
0.1897067279,
-0.8327250481,
-0.1441900879,
0.8957346678,
0.4280852377,
-0.0347709619,
-0.1878596544,
-1.007463932,
-0.0701415017,
-0.8049817085,
1.44252491,
-0.9621629119,
-0.0510064214,
0.2044127584,
-0.0535851717,
-0.077568993,
-0.4584697485,
1.1704852581,
-0.6134592891,
0.6678968072,
-0.5388402939,
-0.9934775233,
-0.5530506968,
0.2723582685,
-0.4555973709,
0.9217318296,
0.1753405035,
-0.7494916916,
1.2105902433,
-0.8206355572,
-0.5963142514,
0.4755967855,
-0.2705423832,
-0.3347994685,
0.2744017541,
0.5893089771,
0.6864796877,
0.0174744427,
0.5324533582,
-0.3576752841,
-0.3104919493,
0.0492675342,
-0.3628715575,
0.581915915,
0.0131739452,
-0.28814134,
0.4748690426,
-0.5438709259,
0.1168626398,
-0.1701280922,
-0.0131492317,
-0.4529250562,
0.2889544964,
-0.3446953893,
0.2282880992,
-0.0295243505,
-0.5127552748,
-0.0054916455,
-0.8919566274,
0.4339938462,
0.2588538229,
0.3539337516,
0.332259804,
0.0059794467,
0.2159745097,
-0.1472644508,
-0.0742293149,
-0.5564941168,
-0.4912484288,
-0.6987101436,
-0.1488926262,
0.3456085622,
0.3060086966,
-0.6092823744,
0.5746945143,
-0.4663657546,
-0.3138014078,
-0.6021518111,
-0.0793270171,
-0.0902284905,
0.6980589628,
0.4844734967,
0.0593173765,
-0.4075872004,
-0.8117325902,
-0.6385013461,
-0.179853186,
-0.0383683741,
0.1125720441,
0.2247989327,
-0.1600873023,
1.4659701586,
-0.0195353609,
-0.0973735228,
-0.0212930217,
0.3742203116,
0.3849896193,
0.3145534098,
0.3224953711,
-0.6224402785,
-0.4995244443,
0.2912904918,
-1.0968948603,
-0.0648178458,
-0.358969897,
0.0644466132,
-0.2834944129,
0.351110369,
-0.2929326892,
0.2730703652,
0.1893177629,
-0.7517570853,
0.3406986892,
0.024828447,
0.6283777356,
-1.1567078829,
0.0055865576,
-0.1504497677,
-0.1683370471,
-0.7842831612,
0.1319019496,
0.0200832579,
-0.0332537889,
-0.5228424668,
0.7254244685,
-0.0120062204,
0.2494153231,
-0.4216974676,
0.0175246596,
0.3358078897,
0.2131042629,
0.0482782423,
0.9180069566,
0.5192244053,
-0.2855316103,
0.639339149,
0.1255444288,
-0.6729537249,
1.1354705095,
-0.763027668,
-0.0199937094,
0.0428366363,
0.0693407729,
-1.0120335817,
-0.5554807782,
-0.0958192647,
-0.4442611337,
0.2157709152,
-0.2079132497,
-0.2967662811,
-0.151896596,
-0.0772397071,
0.4721736908,
0.3989947438,
-0.8944597244,
0.7598034739,
0.438991487,
-0.3287876248,
-0.5432713628,
-0.2418768257,
0.2764540315,
-0.6973332167,
-0.845828712,
0.2847476304,
0.1510071307,
-0.427359283,
0.0677185431,
0.0920924842,
-0.2403436303,
-0.0693514049,
0.3317550719,
-0.3682951629,
-0.2458915859,
0.3017403185,
0.6444930434,
-0.0654977188,
0.180861786,
-0.1238030791,
-0.010303732,
-0.0488637388,
-0.5925670266,
-0.3274800181,
0.6801874638,
0.5175487399,
0.1280715019,
0.4759483933,
0.7513183355,
-0.3725605607,
-0.2687033415,
-0.8535191417,
-0.1917870492,
-0.4639847577,
0.3165635467,
-0.5608224869,
-0.9723303318,
0.3051594794,
-0.3686208725,
0.48756513,
0.7380544543,
0.7659546137,
-0.1801704466,
0.9856540561,
0.0097533762,
0.2201130837,
0.2299719304,
-0.0711871609,
0.7270445824,
-0.7340432405,
-0.1093695164,
-0.3691862226,
-0.0517685749,
0.235031873,
-0.5059601068,
0.224680528,
0.578671515,
-0.2855555415,
0.2033083737,
-0.6604241133,
0.696998179,
0.1920717955,
-0.5337770581,
0.0746677369,
0.1805221736,
-0.1747599989,
-0.2888319194,
-0.8795892596,
-0.600638926,
0.7986697555,
0.5162829757,
0.2355032563,
-0.0679455549,
0.3253714144,
0.7175682187,
0.5068995357,
-0.7629798055,
0.0180821214,
0.2179421186,
-0.4477832913,
-0.3867753446,
-0.3913464248,
-0.8312334418,
0.6843595505,
-0.2228312045,
-0.5741471648,
0.1771764606,
0.181338653,
-0.550748229,
0.0223489273,
-0.9239803553,
1.1676659584,
0.0434733368,
-0.6760263443,
-0.1611794531,
-0.1419402659,
0.3404726386,
0.0955558792,
0.3787368238,
-0.0678612664,
0.6411495209,
1.152564168,
-0.3919814527,
0.4202718735,
-0.3388038278,
-0.0115212137,
0.6199685335,
0.0003836319,
0.2876799107,
0.3101527691,
-0.1668106616,
0.1707333326,
0.1884230524,
-0.2851135731,
-1.1378403902,
0.7873452306,
-0.4059347212,
-0.810100615,
-0.2007252723,
-0.3686484694,
-0.453601867,
0.0862155706,
0.220189333,
0.6148917079,
-0.386228472,
0.4646540284,
0.3400887251,
-0.1370256245,
0.5305690765,
0.1869947165,
0.4158539772,
-0.6754872203,
1.0375320911,
0.0003279952,
-0.2471971512,
0.0985023081,
0.5266472697,
-0.8040973544,
-0.3606921434,
-0.7911040187,
-0.0578831062,
-1.1215900183,
-0.3577221036,
-0.722307384,
0.0996629968,
-0.4376815259,
-0.3888847232,
-0.3715562224,
-0.3613637984,
-0.1130578816,
-0.2744114697,
0.1561547518,
0.5564813018,
0.1229986995,
0.1685393155,
-0.5137172937,
0.0175841488,
0.7186357975,
0.4141459465,
-0.1959400773,
-0.6306756139,
-0.260345161,
0.0934953541,
-0.2661075592,
-0.7808689475,
0.243695423,
0.1959159672,
0.7928337455,
0.6624875069,
0.1866004467,
0.9595069885,
-0.4719090462,
1.4087306261,
0.2371628881,
-1.0037156343,
0.705024302,
-0.0628871918,
0.1501026005,
0.7384815216,
0.0159352869,
-0.2865268886,
-0.1205760986,
-0.521251142,
-0.7373001575,
0.3573843241,
-0.1437900215,
0.0682102442,
-0.1352021992,
0.2631525397,
0.2119457424,
-0.1589578539,
-0.4822154343,
0.2295581996,
-0.7052195668,
-0.1970820427,
0.105600737,
-0.3274202645,
-0.577065289,
-0.4758041799,
0.4618089199,
-0.3475717902,
0.098276794,
0.1879686415,
-0.2287359834,
-0.0079572303,
0.5352491736,
0.7097145915,
0.8663343787,
0.0861918777,
0.0722337738,
0.4844906926,
0.0199434031,
0.253349185,
-0.0876458809,
-0.1303444058,
0.195120886,
0.7142246962,
0.9169946313,
0.085771516,
-0.4192110896,
0.6899533272,
-0.2144504189,
-0.2835481465,
0.0283675976,
0.1088559628,
0.0030897849,
0.1601337045,
0.2004217952,
0.0060525071,
0.1527485847,
-0.2308908999,
0.3682222068,
0.5417739749,
-0.7026033401,
-0.1632867157,
0.3925807476,
0.4823353887,
-0.2161271721,
0.2082896382,
-0.1312476248,
-0.3643820286,
0.2238816619,
0.2964292467,
0.9197189808,
-0.0740390867,
0.1008764133,
0.7045696378,
0.0384773836,
0.1217442304,
-0.1801701188,
-0.2999732792,
-0.5163835883,
-0.7830100656,
-0.6320770383,
-0.4302789271,
-0.0864679441,
-0.4375565052,
0.0830522627,
-0.1948131472,
-0.0854777694,
-0.1904625446,
0.0440588295,
-0.5019883513,
0.1654967666,
-0.2103704363,
0.7082276344,
-1.1412934065,
0.678681016,
0.6932794452,
-0.2548705637,
-0.5740696788,
-0.1718358696,
-0.3230320513,
-0.1765685827,
0.6111723781,
0.065210551,
-0.1225205958,
-0.4656127095,
-0.239217639,
-0.7316116691,
0.7334327698,
0.3710324466,
-0.0413130447,
0.4886093438,
-0.0566185713,
0.6097914577,
-0.5106697083,
0.6651869416,
0.5279926658,
0.5941132307,
0.1172529906,
-0.5358000994,
-0.0691873506,
-0.3231402636,
-0.2383971661,
-0.1881020963,
-0.0333035961,
0.4947476685,
0.0599626042,
-0.62176615,
-0.6053769588,
1.0940157175,
0.0109966472,
0.4324418306,
0.3385173976,
0.644149065,
0.7453599572,
-0.1444679648,
1.0058857203,
-0.1711511165,
0.4195512235,
1.0901585817,
-0.3425764143,
0.9638982415,
0.497038126,
0.0553367026,
0.7104151845,
0.7902142406,
0.1686565876,
0.3514660001,
0.0199416094,
-0.1427484602,
-0.3731283247,
-0.287779659,
-0.4238829315,
0.209862262,
0.7208212614,
-0.0633085147,
-0.3200052679,
-0.008568719,
-0.1262834221,
0.4430302978,
-0.0220285188,
1.0753552914,
-0.3168543279,
-1.2029162645,
0.809235394,
-0.1030972376,
0.4773645997,
-0.2724606693,
-0.4073536992,
-0.2561966777,
-0.1827029139,
-0.4253991842,
-0.8819562793,
0.739287138,
0.1074798331,
-0.3034048975,
-0.1234683022,
0.5336191058,
-0.3169926405,
-0.4697290063,
0.1287942827,
0.2543572485,
-0.1207151562,
-0.0387788489,
-0.486159265,
0.1598807126,
-0.4253050983,
-0.1285570413,
0.2100178301,
0.2676797807,
0.0548305959,
0.255836606,
0.6652681231,
0.0363504887,
0.0391694233,
0.1084496453,
0.7555102706,
-0.2916851342,
-0.641035974,
-0.8647621274,
0.7289295793,
-0.7296762466,
-0.3836357296,
0.860370636,
0.3181061149,
0.5505298972,
0.2198697776,
0.6416344047,
0.0234108306,
0.6411257386,
-0.3344660699,
0.7506222129,
-0.3680955768,
-0.0409409516,
-0.3699652851,
-0.995457828,
-0.583818078,
0.8372666836,
-0.5381586552,
-0.2719191015,
0.86473912,
0.6246989965,
-0.2742256522,
0.2321510762,
0.5744072795,
-0.0363551863,
0.690551877,
0.3472667634,
0.9297477603,
-0.6013861299,
0.1977266222,
0.0566304177,
-0.3875053227,
-0.1563142985,
-1.1091908216,
-0.960714221,
-0.7104051709,
-0.677374959,
-0.3024625778,
-0.1835442185,
0.7733830214,
1.0656331778,
-1.0992063284,
-0.0554911159,
0.0793634057,
0.3504445553,
-0.5053697824,
-0.2956904471,
0.7070587873,
-0.7189432979,
-0.3405112922,
0.9479475021,
0.462723732,
-0.8671899438,
-0.1563436836,
-0.1072086021,
-0.0690043345,
0.3379611075,
0.8320500851,
0.3462485671,
-1.0565868616,
-0.5087752342,
-0.6022074819,
0.2637351155,
0.1622128785,
0.9684910178,
-0.9064536095,
1.1166775227,
0.8564234972,
1.1328276396,
0.0181595907,
0.4501141906,
0.6722677946,
-0.6638228297,
-0.0126241902,
0.299901545,
0.5165569782,
0.5083500743,
-0.2569225729,
0.1429588795,
0.1058316901,
-0.5065381527,
-0.8109047413,
-0.0342197344,
-0.7095714808,
-0.3407590687,
1.1964755058,
-0.4426244199,
-0.0890663713,
-0.2723700702,
-0.1665553004,
-0.0175235737,
-0.258046627,
0.7614896894,
0.8540611863,
-0.1194933355,
-0.1742983758,
-0.1708753258,
0.7080557942,
0.5641773343,
-0.9963288307,
0.133485809,
0.6508064866,
0.0221673772,
0.46637097,
0.275387764,
0.000910916,
0.3923807144,
0.2222259492,
-0.3282591999,
-0.1570456028,
-0.3305085301,
-0.6422711015,
0.9677783251,
-0.0448624156,
-0.0060215979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12276v1 | Analogy in Contact: Modeling Maltese Plural Inflection | 2023-05-20T20:16:57 | 2023-05-20T20:16:57 | Sara Court, Andrea D. Sims, Micha Elsner | cs.CL | cs.CL | Maltese is often described as having a hybrid morphological system resulting
from extensive contact between Semitic and Romance language varieties. Such a
designation reflects an etymological divide as much as it does a larger
tradition in the literature to consider concatenative and non-concatenative
morphological patterns as distinct in the language architecture. Using a
combination of computational modeling and information theoretic methods, we
quantify the extent to which the phonology and etymology of a Maltese singular
noun may predict the morphological process (affixal vs. templatic) as well as
the specific plural allomorph (affix or template) relating a singular noun to
its associated plural form(s) in the lexicon. The results indicate phonological
pressures shape the organization of the Maltese lexicon with predictive power
that extends beyond that of a word's etymology, in line with analogical
theories of language change in contact. | [
-0.5497857928,
-0.795219779,
0.6897019744,
0.2296078354,
-0.5070796013,
0.0125467125,
-0.1711936891,
-0.6195688844,
0.7658105493,
0.5675309896,
-0.5011345148,
-0.1597433537,
-0.5636044145,
0.409491092,
-0.2534103692,
0.5880468488,
-0.1540647298,
0.2620314658,
-0.0405763835,
-0.3833049536,
0.1462574452,
-0.969384551,
-0.318841964,
-0.0474367887,
0.6826533675,
0.3008687198,
0.9508528709,
0.6971558332,
0.4733560085,
0.5200456381,
-0.1207880229,
0.1188079342,
0.0313463546,
0.0290361587,
-0.1825938821,
-0.6985661387,
0.2760757804,
-0.0137531897,
0.916655302,
1.0745596886,
-0.132698223,
-0.3357057571,
-0.2362208217,
0.4980707169,
-0.2854471505,
-0.1520730704,
-0.6533834934,
-0.309746325,
-0.7271823287,
-0.3275176585,
0.0195532013,
-0.3104364872,
-0.1737889051,
-0.3686502874,
0.3580708206,
-0.1785580814,
0.6190927029,
-0.0429304354,
-0.1665446162,
-0.3278600276,
-0.8346889019,
0.2495483756,
-0.5618582368,
0.6453924775,
0.0534390248,
0.0773893446,
-0.3857577443,
-0.5546190739,
-0.7926812768,
-0.5398764014,
-0.0289077349,
0.2192199379,
0.0740038007,
0.0834343061,
0.1479915082,
0.3787022531,
-0.2113063782,
0.0593266636,
-0.7307565212,
0.401776433,
0.4730761647,
0.1370099634,
0.6042576432,
0.0709125698,
-0.489528507,
0.2173290998,
-0.4984235764,
0.2338151187,
0.7900239825,
0.6291367412,
-0.3161932826,
0.5516961813,
0.500197649,
0.4306973219,
0.394729048,
-0.2369368523,
0.3000262976,
-0.4003952146,
-0.0175633077,
0.440414995,
0.8914274573,
-0.1934944987,
0.0697264224,
-0.2881726027,
0.0711807832,
0.2872073054,
0.4164020419,
-0.4399954975,
0.2818559706,
-0.1586397886,
-0.2457719296,
-0.228333056,
0.7203775048,
-0.4251867235,
-0.0147467479,
-0.4091187418,
0.2689718008,
-0.6099259853,
-0.610291779,
0.2663752437,
-0.3250364661,
-0.2171100974,
0.0733888149,
-0.9898884296,
0.8224642873,
0.7423706651,
0.8293218017,
-0.3275192976,
-0.4307537377,
0.073248148,
-0.1903667897,
-0.3075414598,
1.02117908,
-0.8618528843,
-1.1052738428,
-0.1604962349,
0.3619690835,
-0.6307567954,
-0.6737933159,
0.5311241746,
-0.0073432662,
0.1143522635,
0.2066574246,
-0.6108618975,
-0.2325595468,
-0.0911742523,
-0.7497051954,
0.7950569391,
0.2934114337,
-0.5012868643,
0.0127129816,
-0.3605800867,
-0.4211263955,
0.2994671464,
-0.3558395505,
-0.1399200559,
0.6247076988,
-0.5692526698,
-0.0072212308,
-0.1970575452,
0.1962748021,
-0.5170480609,
-0.1840243936,
0.4515517354,
-0.1249288917,
0.8318533897,
-0.1707038134,
-0.2938323915,
-0.3107298017,
-0.5818753839,
-0.2943120599,
-0.2452944219,
-0.1714161038,
-0.6292636991,
-0.0250125024,
0.08942426,
0.4012916982,
-0.0751896054,
-0.826903522,
0.2067519724,
-0.6318522096,
0.3610801399,
0.1597771198,
0.4048835635,
0.2856894732,
-0.3747938573,
0.4710767269,
0.4838839471,
0.497669816,
0.2908782661,
-0.6587285399,
-0.7306224108,
-0.2623900175,
0.4189412594,
0.3399890959,
-0.2285739481,
0.094339706,
-0.2005230337,
-0.7034080029,
-0.4059778154,
-0.0112104602,
0.3868013024,
0.0082471063,
0.0503118895,
-0.528416276,
-0.5924958587,
-1.3408116102,
-0.1171101779,
-0.4100809991,
0.5512564182,
0.1964567602,
0.3548327982,
-0.1113227457,
0.6940565705,
0.3311319649,
-0.0375293046,
-0.0387992039,
0.0846702307,
0.546146214,
0.4861148894,
0.6340264082,
-1.1078692675,
-0.3437688351,
0.2154189646,
-0.2699656188,
0.0072478368,
0.170236066,
-0.2110566348,
0.0613593049,
0.6285959482,
-0.6030399799,
0.4063356817,
0.3598766625,
-0.3459245265,
0.8024941087,
-0.1742763072,
0.2438992262,
-1.1901489496,
0.0437398441,
0.1459053606,
0.2977018654,
-0.7655802369,
0.0196684506,
0.112383917,
0.167068556,
-0.6981995106,
0.6081541777,
-0.3821787536,
-0.0036766469,
0.085030213,
-0.173379153,
-0.1058208048,
0.3157275617,
0.2305262238,
0.7153080702,
0.0471027009,
-0.7247478366,
0.4420703053,
0.2325641513,
-0.2557945251,
0.5433771014,
-0.3706304431,
-0.3324746192,
-0.0671661198,
0.005284152,
-1.1221696138,
-0.0595866479,
0.0976456255,
-0.6026923656,
0.2127260268,
-0.3082244098,
-0.6156077385,
-0.2016739845,
0.0599043071,
0.7973347306,
0.0391356833,
-0.3280127645,
0.5039910674,
0.4013632238,
-0.460937202,
-0.0132794343,
-0.5527632833,
0.1653779149,
-0.3304690421,
-0.3720006645,
0.6668521166,
-0.1981248856,
-0.974781394,
0.0488884635,
0.1199220568,
-0.3658077121,
0.0952425376,
0.6602906585,
0.5605275035,
-0.3192327917,
0.1787788719,
-0.0584523454,
0.1038994193,
0.0104353139,
-0.3428924978,
0.3082516193,
0.2448742837,
-0.3666068912,
-0.4023008049,
0.6626524329,
0.9362104535,
-0.0730912983,
0.7574089766,
-0.2764687538,
-0.256559819,
0.1949339062,
-0.5749065876,
0.2581895292,
-0.3917132318,
-0.1228109002,
-0.7848961353,
-0.507635951,
0.5747609138,
0.0415409356,
-0.0025677991,
0.6893137097,
0.6260302663,
-0.0992831141,
0.822167635,
0.5413459539,
0.1318085045,
0.4838113785,
0.0771679431,
0.0890423581,
-0.5464990139,
-0.4732257724,
-0.9538652301,
-0.099467136,
-0.9530952573,
-0.3736401796,
0.3815985918,
0.2756794989,
0.0146983722,
0.2223274857,
-0.0383973084,
0.3889718652,
0.3365816176,
-0.0593918599,
0.1103675142,
0.1825506836,
-0.563462019,
-0.1245037094,
-0.6074905992,
-0.3918128312,
0.515629828,
-0.0984154865,
0.2214751244,
0.4461870492,
0.7833598256,
0.2039780021,
0.3059101403,
-0.8265793324,
0.2395246923,
-0.5294317007,
-0.5047286749,
0.1880591959,
-0.2656829059,
-0.9957037568,
0.2701562941,
-0.323323071,
-0.7545841932,
0.692086041,
-0.3692311943,
-0.167388767,
0.5423899889,
-0.2525456548,
0.374686271,
-0.2976146638,
-0.2881554067,
-0.062666744,
-0.44117558,
0.3901977539,
-0.1053088382,
0.6172757745,
0.0693814531,
-0.3142446876,
0.6101773977,
-0.7578673363,
0.8206813335,
0.1466385424,
-0.107513465,
0.2723944187,
0.4756546021,
0.0734480545,
-0.4459386468,
-0.3186970055,
0.1815669984,
0.328210175,
-0.2945167124,
-0.619530201,
0.8182764649,
-0.9095440507,
-0.3350140452,
-0.1261191964,
-0.2002478093,
-0.3446949422,
-0.1913129091,
0.5102464557,
0.989060998,
-0.6253498197,
-0.0763219148,
0.3088106811,
0.0978909656,
0.2753667831,
0.3696483374,
0.0082397936,
-0.5383307934,
0.7749018669,
0.2257056832,
0.1805545092,
0.4219663739,
-0.0293565877,
-0.5608131289,
-0.4776607752,
-0.6091039777,
0.6520851851,
-0.2489816099,
0.3412530422,
-0.5780336857,
-0.194222793,
-0.3636585176,
-0.2701698542,
-0.1497722864,
-0.8352130055,
0.0115669398,
-0.0049068974,
0.2505296469,
1.0879948139,
-0.1299956888,
0.3779672384,
-0.9610517621,
0.045453988,
0.0144462744,
0.2110485137,
-0.4727971554,
-0.5058857799,
-0.1997225136,
0.0098307878,
0.19453834,
-1.2076985836,
0.2763879895,
0.2349785566,
0.7772238851,
0.6754615307,
-0.3791545033,
0.7210743427,
-0.4878056347,
0.7350140214,
0.5535446405,
-0.7945318818,
0.061863523,
-0.6855365634,
-0.0189121664,
0.6509051323,
0.4173743725,
-0.7896847725,
-0.6401327252,
-1.4015828371,
-0.8597976565,
0.2657795846,
0.1425697654,
-0.0130028883,
-0.253456533,
0.5962777138,
0.5198519826,
0.2816274762,
-0.1423054188,
-0.1663234681,
0.1213462353,
-0.3110778928,
-0.4965718389,
-0.2859284282,
0.0407266393,
-0.3366604745,
0.5438786149,
0.2923510075,
0.3383803666,
0.0220014695,
-0.2289251387,
-0.3449238539,
0.1440059841,
1.0492362976,
0.625156045,
0.0454096906,
0.4880363345,
-0.0693908036,
-0.4517346323,
0.4292471409,
0.0247301646,
0.0888838693,
0.7357970476,
0.5023540854,
0.6770803928,
0.6889488101,
-0.3063650727,
0.1711048931,
0.0807880461,
-0.6217179298,
-0.4287246764,
0.1830495298,
0.043178536,
0.1496278197,
0.1074762717,
0.0233806949,
0.1461190581,
-0.9089845419,
0.0953402296,
0.2900282741,
-0.383523941,
-0.5541923642,
0.0622689165,
0.1142683402,
-0.6496791244,
0.2539340854,
0.3203087747,
-0.8578150868,
0.797781229,
0.4123953879,
0.5056053996,
-0.6186483502,
0.1098409668,
0.5334421992,
0.0890666991,
0.0384604931,
0.1661456674,
-0.2396411151,
-0.8564376831,
0.137320742,
-0.7105686665,
-0.3736646771,
-0.0283216238,
-0.8872296214,
0.0339306518,
-0.7271132469,
-0.2439993024,
0.6005859375,
-0.0052644894,
-0.4353050292,
0.155987829,
0.5013102889,
0.9759706855,
-0.823110342,
0.7183728218,
0.9085797668,
-0.2910892069,
-0.7633054852,
-0.3144388497,
0.1665876806,
-0.7616729736,
0.668195188,
0.1599617004,
-0.4706057012,
-0.0338189937,
-0.3187863231,
-0.6531276107,
0.2999330163,
0.0358224362,
-0.562771678,
0.1793970466,
0.3582680523,
0.5316407084,
-0.6227995157,
0.2452955693,
0.6617600918,
0.789901197,
0.0265331753,
-1.0552204847,
-0.2203175575,
-0.7744669914,
0.1191707999,
0.9169758558,
-0.4988394976,
0.9235498309,
-0.0144555271,
-0.5960453153,
0.2387445867,
0.0774551705,
0.0276670512,
-0.2030605674,
0.5554998517,
0.53817904,
0.2979675233,
-0.1179327741,
1.0235949755,
-0.4700382948,
-0.1020949334,
0.8348715305,
-0.0833674595,
0.7809005976,
0.7604348063,
-0.3666585684,
0.8696519732,
0.886115253,
0.1119192913,
0.2276310772,
0.0730380639,
-0.5122758746,
-0.3289245665,
-0.2784045935,
-0.2730221748,
0.5855378509,
0.7734152079,
-0.4318704307,
-0.2514251769,
-0.1935626566,
-0.1142790541,
0.0933681875,
-0.5214942694,
0.8971461654,
0.0138064595,
-0.7362393141,
0.549567461,
0.0930264071,
0.4137122631,
-0.7962040901,
0.1191221997,
-0.1608004719,
0.089863129,
-0.1321777403,
-0.745881319,
0.2822746933,
-0.3475167155,
-0.344748199,
0.0784084275,
0.32165429,
-0.5810916424,
-0.7485724688,
0.52250278,
0.7009808421,
0.4064227343,
0.2051793039,
-0.6935700178,
-0.068852976,
-0.0789626911,
0.1148839891,
0.2158065587,
0.5025750995,
-0.2752655447,
0.1844550371,
0.7717088461,
0.5465151072,
0.3202681243,
0.0904460698,
0.5870165825,
-0.7120406628,
-0.7476412058,
-0.9100297689,
0.2862805426,
0.2069072276,
-0.3544852436,
0.3022603989,
0.4401788414,
0.6102938056,
0.1836941838,
0.7138776183,
0.118089065,
0.2996059656,
-0.3263582587,
0.2205794305,
-0.6086575985,
-0.3704319894,
-0.1160762683,
-0.8449832797,
-0.2064165324,
0.4163593948,
-0.215046078,
-0.1500130594,
0.8936059475,
0.699229002,
-0.4869279563,
0.3394765556,
0.3756470084,
0.5054482818,
-0.3819356561,
0.1091476157,
0.9629263878,
0.1128711328,
0.0221818406,
-0.2018129379,
0.0195508413,
-0.288390398,
-0.1441076994,
-0.4340273738,
-1.1592655182,
0.1162320897,
-0.3934418559,
0.1772289723,
1.2256566286,
0.5474099517,
-0.6512696147,
-0.7298387885,
-0.0392456166,
-0.3921106458,
-0.0438307375,
-0.1671331078,
0.0482707359,
-0.0780664533,
-0.715865016,
0.4097161889,
0.4788641334,
0.4651644826,
-0.1810903102,
0.2620069981,
-0.199345544,
0.2592684031,
0.2852765918,
0.4550932944,
-0.7313978672,
0.2225089818,
-0.487877965,
-0.2841698527,
0.3251441717,
1.3210229874,
-0.4055630565,
0.294077307,
0.1871065646,
0.0311719999,
0.4160576761,
0.1099448502,
0.6949554682,
-0.3732062876,
0.6513915062,
0.1712268442,
0.5809113383,
0.2198305875,
-0.4892159998,
0.1069588885,
0.5956117511,
0.2002943605,
-0.5132242441,
0.4950590432,
-0.9660337567,
-0.45525226,
0.9050273299,
0.0623743534,
-0.5374763608,
-0.3639298975,
-0.1177146211,
0.2158414423,
-0.1962172687,
0.5966049433,
0.7548926473,
-0.2198433429,
-0.3807821572,
-0.3374102414,
0.3429307938,
0.0817639381,
-0.5341757536,
-0.3558673561,
0.4262179434,
0.4493207633,
0.3342961073,
0.3877795339,
-0.277846992,
0.1229334772,
0.0708419457,
0.0994457975,
-0.1269410849,
-0.3009344339,
-0.2790853083,
0.1753619313,
0.0253896806,
0.0442002863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12272v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12272v1 | Autoregressive Modeling with Lookahead Attention | 2023-05-20T19:29:47 | 2023-05-20T19:29:47 | Li Du, Hongyuan Mei, Jason Eisner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | To predict the next token, autoregressive models ordinarily examine the past.
Could they also benefit from also examining hypothetical futures? We consider a
novel Transformer-based autoregressive architecture that estimates the
next-token distribution by extrapolating multiple continuations of the past,
according to some proposal distribution, and attending to these extended
strings. This architecture draws insights from classical AI systems such as
board game players: when making a local decision, a policy may benefit from
exploring possible future trajectories and analyzing them. On multiple tasks
including morphological inflection and Boolean satisfiability, our lookahead
model is able to outperform the ordinary Transformer model of comparable size.
However, on some tasks, it appears to be benefiting from the extra computation
without actually using the lookahead information. We discuss possible variant
architectures as well as future speedups. | [
-0.2080916166,
-0.6197564006,
0.5510557294,
-0.0869284868,
-0.0028564394,
-0.0438104346,
0.3685547113,
-0.6002184153,
0.5951499343,
0.6878010631,
-0.7473563552,
-0.024719229,
-0.5355542302,
-0.3293061256,
-0.843588531,
0.6783978939,
-0.114540562,
-0.3134534955,
0.1385488063,
0.0258671399,
-0.5059328079,
-0.4518874884,
-0.7022891641,
-0.5278455019,
0.3560831547,
0.182461977,
1.0561058521,
0.8030295372,
0.5990888476,
0.3248805702,
-0.0362406969,
-0.3568535149,
-0.1467381418,
0.4009598196,
-0.0312369745,
-0.6419425607,
-0.4092576802,
0.181045264,
0.290140152,
0.279109925,
-0.385710746,
0.4699620008,
-0.2535364032,
0.525024116,
-0.5837233067,
0.1802784353,
-0.4193757176,
0.3791359067,
-0.0451077372,
0.0504054874,
-0.2405840605,
-0.3280906379,
0.1626680344,
-0.1436818689,
0.2372301817,
0.024061678,
0.4651106298,
0.7846129537,
-0.1317767352,
0.0578515008,
-0.7911754847,
0.3477171659,
-0.8032018542,
0.6653127074,
0.298170656,
0.7023091912,
-0.0349539667,
-0.9433832765,
-0.5947396755,
-0.0938188881,
-0.1460164338,
0.2675683498,
-0.224721238,
-0.2937195599,
0.0882139131,
0.3850121498,
-0.6335605383,
0.0991883129,
0.075166449,
0.0309541989,
0.3356612325,
0.4047910571,
-0.1676821113,
-0.1230991036,
-0.3682231605,
-0.4198286235,
-0.3462831974,
0.1616869122,
0.3758184314,
-0.2254503071,
-0.1885857284,
0.4438614547,
-0.1504221112,
0.5479708314,
0.3053373992,
0.3330287635,
0.1086231396,
0.0721523389,
-0.3086596131,
-0.272307694,
0.5777599812,
-0.0319554545,
-0.3094959855,
-0.0320026278,
-0.2899428904,
-0.1168677956,
0.3287192881,
-0.4975218475,
-0.7190044522,
0.2845810354,
-1.0391838551,
-0.2621691525,
-0.1337519139,
-1.0622870922,
-0.1004888043,
-0.3080950975,
0.3759175241,
-0.4533789158,
-0.106964469,
-0.0495804474,
-0.261968255,
0.4576286972,
0.2683542371,
-0.8296160698,
0.2215815037,
0.5854288936,
0.9586412907,
-0.2762708068,
-0.2959541678,
-0.4225588739,
0.1853222251,
-0.3664520085,
0.9852526188,
-0.7434540391,
-0.4825989604,
-0.2152775079,
-0.1046451256,
0.0833543837,
-0.2395665944,
0.1793633103,
-0.6548047066,
0.1965433955,
0.2508061826,
-0.2790871859,
-0.2120776325,
0.1734934896,
-0.9875095487,
0.8973144889,
-0.0924564898,
-0.5123876333,
0.4827828109,
-0.7406126857,
-0.5651747584,
0.0678743944,
-0.019792458,
-0.4053098857,
0.311242193,
0.233519271,
0.2054150254,
0.0011465031,
0.304602325,
-0.4514683187,
-0.3383677304,
0.0468061082,
-0.9586160183,
0.6569863558,
0.2765228152,
-0.6928197742,
0.1636880487,
-0.6276741624,
-0.1313504875,
0.034578532,
0.1106610373,
-0.0639789477,
0.3354580104,
0.0250332914,
0.2947680652,
0.4181351066,
-0.1662734896,
0.129728809,
-0.211624071,
0.4162592888,
0.7461304069,
-0.1250301898,
0.3024027348,
-0.3712373078,
0.7723477483,
-0.0463895984,
0.6783997416,
-0.5604408979,
-0.516923666,
-0.7444737554,
-0.2406159192,
0.235102281,
0.381783098,
-0.6612411141,
0.2836875021,
0.0695539787,
-0.4911129773,
-0.2602368295,
-0.6734958291,
0.1820420921,
0.2861926854,
0.459423691,
-0.2729100585,
-0.433793962,
-1.0157709122,
-0.2559587061,
-0.3731772006,
0.222740218,
0.3235030472,
0.4065169096,
-0.155944407,
0.7803560495,
-0.6418767571,
-0.0530977622,
0.0673776269,
0.4363090396,
0.286480099,
0.3409939408,
0.3012565374,
-0.8966552019,
-0.2538504303,
-0.2537966967,
-0.309930861,
0.3158331513,
-0.1718311906,
-0.2095401287,
0.1519975513,
0.6975602508,
-0.6547190547,
0.6994732022,
0.4966132343,
-0.3264711797,
0.2670004368,
-0.4053999782,
0.0239791628,
-0.9114304185,
0.1758409739,
-0.4659626484,
-0.3361085355,
-0.2811680734,
0.0938125923,
0.0374389961,
-0.0916627347,
-0.1767537594,
0.7370013595,
-0.310506314,
-0.4067878425,
-0.3372320235,
-0.3667170107,
-0.3382687867,
0.3458756804,
0.2822669148,
0.7297824621,
0.3164588511,
-0.5199825764,
0.1184795052,
0.3625305295,
-0.0931721479,
0.2553735077,
-0.6724285483,
0.1502576321,
-0.1959038377,
0.5424057245,
-1.0861656666,
-0.1461621523,
0.0459951907,
-0.6643745303,
0.2912182808,
-0.0020502878,
-0.3707112372,
-0.7759413123,
-0.1391255707,
0.4612360001,
0.780818522,
-0.7665795088,
1.1406722069,
0.4529902935,
0.0243604481,
-0.6912757158,
-0.7518033385,
0.1263588518,
-0.2578445077,
0.0481515937,
0.1475454122,
-0.0786610544,
-0.20196262,
0.1160815954,
0.1710395813,
-0.05390637,
0.1253918409,
0.1946697831,
0.3159393668,
-0.0425590798,
-0.1260285676,
0.0784331709,
-0.1010446325,
0.0790104195,
-0.7893902063,
0.6428325772,
0.2965113223,
-0.2973128855,
-0.3384437859,
0.6376952529,
0.5214024186,
-0.4258235991,
0.3455649614,
0.3759358227,
-0.353936702,
-0.0740611404,
-0.6751092672,
-0.1116251424,
-0.4825491905,
0.32012707,
-0.3694466352,
-0.5827067494,
0.7653752565,
0.4040879011,
0.3480054438,
0.5836571455,
0.7325004935,
-0.15538086,
1.0567162037,
0.8736124039,
-0.0858848169,
0.7333192229,
-0.0927555114,
-0.0528172255,
-0.5276492834,
-0.3000952303,
-0.2982234061,
-0.4923224449,
-0.6210219264,
-0.2947574854,
0.0970327407,
-0.4702081084,
-0.3166183829,
0.5368703008,
-0.3601385951,
0.4180905819,
0.8977714181,
0.0987113044,
0.0710868165,
-0.4193621576,
0.0416398495,
0.1830684245,
-0.7588527203,
-0.2016324848,
1.0433139801,
0.1986175179,
0.7527734041,
0.0956230834,
0.8555358052,
0.598942101,
0.6092413664,
-0.4772880971,
0.3131287992,
-0.2318416685,
-0.4078103304,
-0.3780308664,
-0.2234364897,
-0.7786936164,
0.1493072063,
0.1684423089,
-0.6424891949,
0.6642759442,
0.5765625834,
-0.4526700974,
0.2070940584,
-0.3429928422,
0.752224803,
-0.0668627918,
0.0380822718,
-0.2825078964,
-0.681006074,
0.3699146211,
-0.0171706602,
0.0283121988,
0.3759308159,
-0.1375681013,
0.555515945,
-0.3085174263,
0.7588987947,
-0.056625098,
-0.124271594,
0.2726377249,
0.2054261118,
0.6958999038,
-0.082314685,
0.1583464593,
0.1659972221,
-0.0621794537,
-0.1956124157,
-0.6021390557,
0.5883797407,
-0.4767234921,
-0.5579074621,
-0.31014359,
-0.5026062727,
-0.1559612453,
0.2298814803,
0.3432513773,
0.3728924394,
-0.2553880513,
-0.3316131234,
0.4221270084,
0.1298752129,
1.0002090931,
0.3520343602,
-0.194768697,
-0.2593266964,
0.5814139843,
-0.1114106253,
-0.0759099349,
0.6230838895,
0.145186767,
-0.6015506983,
-0.4110860825,
-0.2425413877,
0.0305574741,
-0.5772365332,
-0.2182608098,
-0.8418486714,
0.1276490986,
-0.3887556791,
0.0240974762,
-0.4472908676,
-0.45765239,
-0.207675606,
0.0109064337,
0.2504690588,
0.9958888888,
-0.2691566646,
0.3835508525,
-0.5436463356,
0.2209345549,
0.2803124487,
0.4907275736,
0.4315007627,
-0.6936648488,
-0.3240218163,
-0.3029901087,
-0.2244662344,
-0.7325718403,
0.680205822,
-0.1809786856,
0.5433104634,
0.2713040113,
-0.2619157135,
0.7552637458,
-1.1224536896,
0.6939962506,
0.1713732183,
-0.8304290771,
0.2260117978,
-0.1690489799,
0.5278690457,
0.4669133127,
0.1511488259,
-0.5162439942,
-0.4797222316,
-0.924369812,
-0.7844924331,
0.5691327453,
-0.052762378,
0.1627955735,
-0.2800837755,
0.465057075,
0.3984581828,
0.2692757547,
-0.2499562651,
-0.3728671968,
-0.4745518565,
-0.2839994431,
-0.2348584384,
-0.1206374317,
0.3488447368,
0.161743477,
0.4237137139,
-0.0636731163,
0.6889538765,
0.0657400638,
0.0781483054,
-0.0447556674,
-0.106761992,
0.4614004195,
0.3126197457,
-0.0284376387,
-0.0093834056,
-0.0736352876,
-0.5466294885,
0.0673523173,
0.5234493613,
-0.3456355333,
0.0913461074,
0.2393401712,
0.7451950908,
0.0718448609,
-0.4904446006,
0.2426110059,
-0.1853835583,
-0.0443948694,
-0.6636291146,
-0.0894217938,
-0.2198717743,
0.8803392053,
0.5429816246,
0.238417998,
0.6792978644,
-0.6345508695,
0.5720458627,
0.4788604975,
-0.5750244856,
-0.3452679515,
1.1375032663,
-0.2524491549,
-0.7018099427,
0.3701676726,
0.1279756129,
-0.5366000533,
0.8540510535,
0.3311766088,
1.1966307163,
-0.4956290424,
0.101160109,
0.0126260547,
0.123244375,
-0.2950316072,
0.217797175,
-0.2947458625,
-0.2153367698,
-0.4647875726,
-0.3398092985,
-0.4641821384,
0.0940043703,
-0.7313798666,
-0.0246163625,
-0.3436605334,
-0.4330648482,
-0.3349677324,
-0.4789980352,
-0.7793348432,
0.2841549218,
0.254034251,
0.8348514438,
-0.4791049063,
0.5654054284,
0.4683734179,
-0.1057662219,
-0.5046775341,
0.5479550362,
-0.3238117695,
-0.7422722578,
0.6960799098,
0.131071806,
-0.1844546199,
-0.0015717528,
-0.3026566505,
-1.4592562914,
1.0564556122,
0.0305549167,
-0.655726552,
-0.4150476456,
-0.4772447646,
0.5302234888,
-0.1695688814,
0.602840364,
0.7059386373,
0.254548341,
0.0385543108,
-0.5981050134,
-0.15548338,
-0.0940642431,
-0.0878105536,
0.5824737549,
-0.9810761809,
0.9412955642,
-0.1798690706,
0.0193556659,
0.2451556474,
1.1450840235,
-0.1327727884,
0.0945010707,
0.410012573,
0.4032810926,
0.420442611,
0.1881172508,
1.2312998772,
-0.435713619,
0.2953008711,
1.6351019144,
-0.1630716026,
1.0136953592,
0.4475573003,
-0.160558939,
0.5269924402,
0.6776545644,
-0.0349819846,
0.6509131789,
-0.1872824878,
0.3105646372,
-0.2000174224,
0.3034334779,
-0.0985539109,
0.6613829732,
0.0657635927,
-0.4007942975,
-0.1583247185,
0.0026258891,
-0.457003653,
-0.2527209818,
-0.2097294033,
0.7022217512,
-0.1022364274,
-0.9086917043,
-0.0415447801,
-0.2388698459,
0.4206301272,
-0.2666333616,
-0.3967583477,
-0.5297394395,
0.2501411736,
0.4221438766,
-0.5271437764,
0.2457967848,
-0.3235200942,
-0.1868708879,
-0.1132581681,
0.1863637567,
-0.2710267603,
-0.5913146734,
0.2016061693,
0.4387079179,
0.0265883673,
0.2747689486,
-0.8438042402,
-0.3118822277,
-0.151883468,
-0.54909271,
0.0866401717,
0.2654454112,
-0.2324090302,
0.7407328486,
0.3950330317,
-0.0116225677,
0.2174655199,
-0.1017668843,
0.4939147532,
-0.7923820019,
-1.0103005171,
-0.8729168773,
0.1250994354,
0.0430756733,
-0.4432145655,
0.4539603293,
0.4353172183,
0.5346441865,
0.1593605429,
0.5425595641,
0.1970193237,
0.5520109534,
-0.5482073426,
0.560048759,
-0.6066424251,
-0.1311803907,
-0.0238316059,
-0.8411505222,
-0.1017952934,
0.5025545955,
-0.2036185265,
0.0853359178,
0.6459683776,
0.0619829223,
-0.0585721545,
0.1819280386,
0.3244751394,
0.1606290042,
0.3594114184,
0.4420514405,
0.6613759398,
-0.3368825018,
0.3653614223,
-0.0059675002,
-0.145756036,
-0.2631179392,
-0.5312384963,
-0.7851265073,
-0.5474692583,
0.0689154863,
-0.1039874181,
0.1226468682,
0.6344064474,
0.6236165762,
-0.6390911341,
-0.0522683077,
-0.1651379615,
-0.2622283697,
-0.310151726,
-0.2367095947,
0.6473321915,
-0.3008172512,
-0.7480494976,
0.3620325029,
0.3655308783,
0.3269013762,
-0.5861591101,
0.3392569721,
0.0865293965,
0.4339781404,
0.3661922216,
0.2886134684,
-0.608625114,
-0.3023874164,
0.0494905822,
0.1964093149,
0.1246556938,
1.0724858046,
-1.180237174,
0.2493434101,
0.192980662,
0.5855589509,
0.9001922607,
-0.0495712496,
0.7938691974,
0.10717161,
0.3206910193,
0.4157783389,
0.5256112814,
0.0053464444,
-0.5834124684,
0.3153677881,
-0.1661371738,
-0.4899980128,
-0.4968217015,
0.4566755295,
-0.2808411419,
-0.2524678409,
0.6438967586,
-0.0234720819,
-0.492506206,
-0.1442697346,
0.1956303567,
0.2391844094,
-0.5336585641,
0.8608619571,
0.4685606658,
-0.4068995714,
-0.4237821102,
-0.3914131522,
0.4233471751,
0.5665206909,
-0.6917014122,
0.2636586428,
0.5517336726,
-0.1229592636,
0.0361879468,
0.5468018055,
-0.1850904226,
0.4629023373,
0.1759571433,
-0.2214876413,
0.0824068636,
-0.5822245479,
-0.5027390122,
0.0043676859,
-0.3973115087,
-0.1506825835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12268v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12268v1 | Patton: Language Model Pretraining on Text-Rich Networks | 2023-05-20T19:17:10 | 2023-05-20T19:17:10 | Bowen Jin, Wentao Zhang, Yu Zhang, Yu Meng, Xinyang Zhang, Qi Zhu, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A real-world text corpus sometimes comprises not only text documents but also
semantic links between them (e.g., academic papers in a bibliographic network
are linked by citations and co-authorships). Text documents and semantic
connections form a text-rich network, which empowers a wide range of downstream
tasks such as classification and retrieval. However, pretraining methods for
such structures are still lacking, making it difficult to build one generic
model that can be adapted to various tasks on text-rich networks. Current
pretraining objectives, such as masked language modeling, purely model texts
and do not take inter-document structure information into consideration. To
this end, we propose our PretrAining on TexT-Rich NetwOrk framework Patton.
Patton includes two pretraining strategies: network-contextualized masked
language modeling and masked node prediction, to capture the inherent
dependency between textual attributes and network structure. We conduct
experiments on four downstream tasks in five datasets from both academic and
e-commerce domains, where Patton outperforms baselines significantly and
consistently. | [
-0.5477434993,
-0.6881763935,
0.3172984123,
0.1434067637,
-0.0942461118,
-0.0204434898,
-0.2628740966,
-0.561888814,
0.3545421362,
0.6347859502,
-0.7785262465,
-0.2941176593,
-0.7394539714,
0.3381636441,
-0.4917342067,
1.2713913918,
-0.1180423498,
-0.0871283263,
0.054359287,
0.1022226661,
-0.0391169637,
-0.5074792504,
-0.4411322474,
-0.2731977403,
0.6858488917,
0.1454752833,
0.5715251565,
0.7348499894,
0.380374372,
0.3816134036,
0.2341956198,
-0.2948283851,
-0.7498683929,
0.2281750739,
-0.3714895248,
-0.2094280422,
-0.3797614872,
0.2126798928,
0.7776888609,
0.7564849257,
0.3422703743,
-0.0667602569,
0.1538861096,
0.417027384,
-0.8254284859,
-0.0413846485,
-0.5514165163,
0.1179683581,
-0.4897003174,
-0.2113990784,
-0.2086810172,
0.0292194411,
0.6248995662,
-0.6872743368,
0.4092593491,
0.0533531979,
0.9974971414,
-0.0909845084,
-0.5229951143,
-0.1148514673,
-0.7384760976,
0.7032921314,
-0.3549399674,
0.609033823,
0.7339189649,
0.2305409312,
0.1335451901,
-1.0587539673,
-0.5487095118,
-0.1024327427,
-0.1295106411,
0.0921222121,
-0.0616472028,
0.2519552708,
0.1798079908,
0.2536833584,
-0.5451200604,
0.1167074144,
-0.3922916949,
-0.1303514391,
0.4527603984,
-0.2714202404,
0.3600425422,
0.1699189544,
-0.4940377176,
-0.4139611721,
-0.531277895,
-0.359320581,
0.594917357,
0.3405743241,
-0.1340112686,
0.3963216841,
-0.5676111579,
0.7517367005,
-0.3527512848,
0.1097265035,
0.2130836695,
-0.216643706,
-0.3237778544,
0.150316447,
0.802421391,
-0.2640584707,
0.704229176,
-0.3848736286,
-0.4193327129,
0.0021780347,
0.28127262,
-0.9757201672,
-0.6058610082,
-0.0485671721,
-0.4479244053,
-0.2399241775,
0.2280850708,
-0.5886718035,
-0.0274997465,
-0.2391997874,
0.6494129896,
-0.2903009653,
-0.5715975165,
-0.0083686151,
-0.2910531163,
-0.0461546555,
0.1508075595,
-1.0047183037,
0.5524591804,
0.5380546451,
0.847976923,
-0.0588371828,
-0.6398234963,
-0.703045249,
0.2433291376,
0.0352981873,
0.8263736963,
-0.6244568825,
-0.1715332568,
0.1063690111,
0.0752358064,
-0.4095577002,
-0.1498067081,
0.3802603483,
-0.672752142,
0.2096745521,
-0.0176845994,
-0.5701645613,
0.0394901,
0.4455548525,
-1.0169882774,
0.8540711403,
0.2699034512,
-1.0373985767,
0.0116152503,
-0.4426119328,
-0.5712262988,
-0.0532278344,
-0.1978683472,
-0.2118337452,
-0.1079624295,
0.052490104,
0.8423394561,
-0.2136974931,
0.1699289232,
-0.5417838097,
-0.2536925077,
0.12780343,
-0.3456235826,
0.8630700111,
0.1715095788,
-0.5386732817,
0.0804956257,
-0.8264448047,
0.0429681093,
-0.0778937489,
-0.2976014316,
-0.427988857,
-0.1415970325,
0.4133053422,
0.3349385262,
-0.1302541643,
-0.498898983,
-0.2305682451,
-0.4394522607,
0.3740977943,
0.7656974196,
-0.366275996,
0.5210917592,
-0.2804495394,
0.5877373815,
-0.0929259434,
-0.1651371866,
-0.2073624879,
-0.4433065951,
-0.6725811958,
-0.2855409682,
0.4017958343,
0.5708345771,
-0.7403362393,
0.27875489,
-0.4439607561,
-0.4058153033,
0.0862388611,
0.162653774,
0.7388818264,
0.5377520919,
0.3689509928,
-0.4297915399,
-0.5347936749,
-0.638884306,
-0.4483413696,
-0.1872355491,
-0.0527250282,
0.0332668312,
0.5875695944,
-0.4616759419,
1.0269749165,
-0.4877585471,
-0.3890022933,
-0.3627880812,
0.0999361277,
-0.2785796523,
0.6540214419,
0.3449486494,
-1.0035889149,
-0.4315525293,
-0.1696225405,
-0.3849050403,
-0.1229327843,
0.17571491,
-0.2849446833,
-0.1854660958,
0.7371277809,
-0.3452386856,
0.238825798,
0.7573298812,
-0.3646746278,
0.7101482153,
0.1151255295,
-0.1468539387,
-1.2029265165,
0.0928787664,
0.2050527334,
-0.372248143,
-0.7211634517,
-0.1104443669,
-0.0178365577,
-0.3641075492,
-0.3588602543,
0.9029396176,
-0.4223971665,
-0.1568263918,
0.0381925851,
0.0519051813,
0.2718354166,
0.4768463373,
0.3560527861,
0.6171039343,
0.4102710783,
-0.6583014727,
0.142232269,
0.2010936588,
-0.319370091,
0.5229959488,
-0.7423943281,
-0.1562759429,
-0.0014660038,
0.3520151079,
-0.6423152089,
-0.2657411397,
0.1371504515,
-0.2698417306,
0.3971756995,
-0.1221719235,
-0.2094187587,
0.0519515984,
-0.1512094438,
0.5332596898,
0.0087557603,
-0.3578786552,
0.5254631639,
0.3360931277,
-0.1429798007,
-0.4892739654,
-0.7461949587,
0.0441740863,
0.0066523044,
-0.6505271196,
0.6917026639,
0.102722913,
-0.1736427546,
0.2390220016,
0.0080989236,
-0.4869492352,
0.2972246408,
0.1100820899,
0.0634911433,
-0.4401960373,
0.240905568,
-0.2154628634,
-0.3608501554,
0.014121782,
-0.6520031691,
0.3877334297,
-0.1434902847,
-0.2364067584,
-0.2820793986,
0.4443647265,
0.0903511941,
-0.6111017466,
0.8619597554,
0.8575376272,
-0.4426861107,
-0.4061168432,
-0.5168820024,
-0.3592996895,
-0.4698196948,
0.6272345185,
-0.3703850508,
-1.1447193623,
0.2182243913,
-0.2857536972,
-0.2135318965,
0.3935644627,
0.1904562712,
-0.1546640694,
0.6979817748,
0.986402452,
0.107902959,
0.9300844669,
-0.394969672,
0.2287424952,
-0.7016458511,
-0.0519524068,
-0.8655368686,
-0.0290653668,
-0.5857841372,
-0.2047658712,
0.0780601203,
0.4546921551,
-0.5784857869,
0.5331614614,
-0.059533421,
0.3900741041,
0.5874524117,
0.0488412865,
0.0929200798,
0.227441594,
-0.2535196841,
0.2750575542,
-0.7699556947,
-0.5072128177,
1.1630159616,
0.2519020736,
0.6432520151,
0.0132837733,
0.8658661842,
0.1295958906,
0.4042596221,
-0.5304250121,
0.2561601698,
-0.1212748513,
-0.5835399628,
-0.4082092643,
-0.7159098983,
-0.7832623124,
0.1056205109,
-0.6084012389,
-0.6712489724,
0.0883706659,
0.1900064945,
-0.0333719552,
0.1711533815,
-0.7241528034,
1.2480871677,
-0.1744475663,
-0.3598406315,
0.0885185674,
-0.6845527291,
0.190315038,
-0.0756731927,
0.0534025915,
-0.0097686006,
0.1041097194,
0.9828493595,
-0.4922194779,
0.7555074096,
0.2105166912,
0.2096485496,
-0.0992356688,
-0.0842976421,
0.6465386152,
0.0677495524,
-0.2727078497,
0.2059874833,
0.1029119715,
-0.5677845478,
-0.5531049371,
0.5172986984,
-1.0466448069,
-0.2661826313,
-0.4402309954,
-0.0425153561,
-0.4944522679,
0.5795838237,
0.5395542979,
0.8421484232,
-0.5354661942,
0.1682540774,
0.9683508277,
0.1392228901,
0.4006303251,
0.1721345186,
0.0339661911,
-0.342273742,
0.8277912736,
0.0327792838,
0.3898166418,
0.7041631937,
0.1203655899,
-0.3070961833,
-0.5011628866,
-0.4637879133,
0.1604647785,
-0.6776935458,
-0.1131961793,
-1.0701966286,
-0.4582915604,
-0.5892470479,
-0.3769684732,
-0.294585526,
-0.3075869977,
-0.4561072588,
-0.0179809611,
0.1875429451,
0.6708956361,
0.2922793329,
0.502427578,
-0.7954156995,
0.2120702863,
0.4850078225,
0.7956824303,
-0.0277975723,
-0.048242934,
-0.5130039454,
-0.0624515973,
-0.0855480134,
-0.9912592173,
0.2175072581,
0.5884858966,
0.5054578781,
0.611897707,
0.2498418242,
0.5504016876,
-0.4658254385,
0.375562042,
0.281825304,
-0.9146271944,
0.3851101696,
-0.4043658674,
0.1008879319,
0.7621676326,
0.5544775724,
-0.372461766,
-0.3191280961,
-0.4629560113,
-0.5961403251,
0.5973889828,
0.3775441349,
0.2857220173,
0.0000142277,
0.1044933647,
-0.1021814719,
0.216140613,
-0.9294146895,
0.218801707,
-0.5084529519,
-0.1715721339,
-0.3541204333,
-0.1984386891,
-0.027731698,
-0.0587499477,
0.7349155545,
-0.1521455497,
0.0373105183,
0.2723616958,
-0.5091137886,
0.2092862427,
0.1307222545,
0.4592283964,
0.7860748172,
-0.1859976351,
0.4061634541,
-0.2083038986,
-0.7645350695,
0.0126966359,
0.2297620624,
0.0075583966,
-0.014197072,
0.766912818,
1.0638074875,
0.4846531451,
-0.5144146681,
0.6217092276,
-0.1948480457,
-0.2347998321,
-0.2479936481,
0.1377932578,
0.0363395847,
0.1426927,
0.1486976892,
0.0060234554,
-0.0701939166,
-0.4874356687,
0.2037314922,
0.2868466079,
-0.690433383,
-0.3197602034,
0.5326806903,
0.3499257267,
-0.359077096,
0.6555793881,
-0.1029882357,
-0.8020793796,
0.4442406297,
0.7785003781,
1.0794898272,
-0.1059648618,
0.4078661203,
0.0909587964,
0.3190414608,
-0.2580526471,
-0.1026651114,
-0.2541510165,
-0.7916173339,
-0.2607890069,
-0.9852662086,
-0.1351489872,
0.0230687577,
-0.3865262568,
0.3377815485,
-0.3764297068,
-0.0394630916,
-0.1515984982,
0.2944561839,
-0.9831966758,
0.5225504041,
-0.2651236951,
0.9347367287,
-0.9965471625,
1.069254756,
0.6010862589,
-0.257424593,
-0.8552681804,
0.0671022981,
-0.1430252343,
-0.3535246849,
0.7489138246,
0.3677788973,
-0.2782974243,
0.5066875815,
-0.064477399,
-0.8664195538,
0.9387605786,
0.3978973031,
-0.3939739168,
-0.0498853251,
0.0572781637,
0.3020038605,
-0.4915897846,
0.4550638199,
0.0569089986,
0.1912110895,
-0.1274796873,
-0.7905086875,
-0.0642431825,
-0.5564361215,
0.2779065669,
0.0653673261,
-0.1980260164,
1.2165044546,
0.3168825209,
-0.2524485886,
-0.3116559386,
0.6570314169,
-0.1115442589,
0.131904617,
0.5029717684,
0.6821380258,
0.5934352875,
0.2244013846,
0.9788962603,
-0.3471277356,
0.1130521521,
1.0815294981,
-0.2500716746,
0.9340891838,
0.1560553014,
0.0849325359,
0.5994455814,
0.6517921686,
0.3681136072,
0.5120722651,
0.1633505076,
-0.4839935303,
-0.1706218868,
0.0767487213,
-0.6125045419,
0.5072441697,
0.1744575649,
-0.4154743254,
-0.1940203607,
0.047346279,
0.1185306832,
0.0313263871,
-0.2497969419,
0.6270890236,
0.0707787126,
-0.5033227801,
0.276165247,
0.3714322746,
0.6967821717,
-0.8545817733,
0.2139152437,
-0.0311255325,
0.0705535263,
-0.1263181567,
-0.2512326539,
0.3854961693,
0.0213569254,
-0.2872756422,
-0.5184258223,
1.0000150204,
-0.3722030818,
-0.4365831614,
0.4859362245,
0.524040103,
-0.0158324298,
-0.2876460552,
-0.6491078138,
0.1353448182,
-0.5405905247,
-0.5252244473,
0.6947583556,
0.5165444613,
-0.1735410094,
0.4519301951,
0.8643890023,
0.1686772257,
0.1120326146,
-0.0854203776,
1.0040946007,
-0.4367821515,
-0.9990279078,
-0.781786263,
0.145430088,
-0.2871906161,
-0.5180079341,
0.7199346423,
0.439042002,
1.3720684052,
0.100896962,
0.8234906197,
0.1427126825,
0.083909601,
-0.6226186752,
1.1281403303,
-0.3161572814,
0.0298476424,
-0.5515759587,
-1.3288599253,
-0.0893675238,
0.7200168371,
-0.2552478909,
0.2420544624,
0.7631826401,
0.8709716797,
-0.4549081028,
0.175815925,
0.055985067,
-0.1093468443,
0.1071235389,
0.3351176083,
0.4290746748,
-0.2727838159,
0.4635496736,
-0.2497637868,
-0.3565890789,
-0.1900239438,
-1.1102254391,
-1.0422263145,
-0.9515941143,
-0.1909576356,
-0.5884773731,
0.2050317973,
0.7953294516,
1.0736876726,
-0.6766161323,
-0.3251166344,
-0.341001004,
0.1833444238,
-0.0140763279,
-0.179763481,
0.3540719748,
-0.3529784083,
-0.3345760703,
0.1643567383,
0.3007844985,
0.0637531728,
-0.3601735532,
-0.2772165537,
-0.5151574016,
-0.007731169,
0.5801007152,
0.4807334542,
-0.214725256,
-0.1142612472,
-0.0591768026,
-0.2697664499,
-0.28245911,
1.1275202036,
-1.0248425007,
0.4312028885,
0.5969375968,
0.9656952024,
0.5835058093,
-0.2809134722,
0.7956928611,
-0.793441534,
0.2528168261,
0.2758498788,
0.1249694005,
0.3394787908,
-0.0620051213,
0.2630979419,
0.4619732499,
-0.2830774784,
-0.7818965912,
0.4296804965,
-0.5215041637,
-0.3626926839,
0.9334102273,
-0.531267941,
-0.2949173152,
-0.4934527874,
0.2311937809,
0.4943829775,
0.1851269603,
0.4658591449,
0.4508707821,
0.3801040947,
-0.2277576774,
-0.6791652441,
0.774052918,
0.307838738,
-0.8324671984,
-0.2695838511,
0.2816211581,
0.2656373382,
-0.0900994018,
1.220107913,
0.2993175685,
-0.0520011596,
0.0758049935,
-0.2577413321,
-0.3184312284,
-0.6856874228,
-0.0657337904,
0.1431260109,
-0.1986627579,
0.0695948675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12263v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12263v2 | Self-supervised representations in speech-based depression detection | 2023-05-20T18:41:13 | 2023-07-06T13:43:56 | Wen Wu, Chao Zhang, Philip C. Woodland | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper proposes handling training data sparsity in speech-based automatic
depression detection (SDD) using foundation models pre-trained with
self-supervised learning (SSL). An analysis of SSL representations derived from
different layers of pre-trained foundation models is first presented for SDD,
which provides insight to suitable indicator for depression detection.
Knowledge transfer is then performed from automatic speech recognition (ASR)
and emotion recognition to SDD by fine-tuning the foundation models. Results
show that the uses of oracle and ASR transcriptions yield similar SDD
performance when the hidden representations of the ASR model is incorporated
along with the ASR textual information. By integrating representations from
multiple foundation models, state-of-the-art SDD results based on real ASR were
achieved on the DAIC-WOZ dataset. | [
-0.5088227391,
-0.6217900515,
0.5635060668,
0.6742495894,
-0.1058369726,
-0.2614929378,
-0.123300083,
-0.1476387084,
0.380983144,
0.5367801785,
-0.7541531324,
-0.6657812595,
-0.8364354372,
0.1613297611,
-0.6714390516,
0.967934072,
-0.0414546318,
0.3149686158,
-0.0173036922,
0.0829933435,
-0.1769981384,
-0.7705993056,
-0.8475875854,
-0.2580830753,
0.0011913648,
0.1490596831,
0.2923008204,
0.3898468018,
0.4815129042,
0.3135499358,
-0.0297338646,
-0.3056574166,
-0.3337922096,
0.0019945081,
-0.098448053,
-0.2298722118,
-0.4540012479,
-0.0405221358,
0.3231447339,
0.504607141,
-0.2988165021,
-0.0080799498,
0.2670511901,
0.57091856,
-0.6559956074,
0.3386985362,
-0.03937402,
0.3745448589,
0.0237876195,
0.0403874926,
-0.245148465,
-0.2357314378,
0.1316816807,
-0.1211822107,
0.3341204226,
-0.7635219097,
0.4732201397,
0.8934332728,
-0.4410369098,
-0.8272753954,
-0.5428532362,
0.5647795796,
-0.7874219418,
0.3811970651,
0.5863683224,
0.3363345563,
0.196775496,
-0.3523431122,
-0.2999789417,
0.0402314141,
-0.1329411864,
0.2661474347,
-0.1510290205,
0.1064817235,
0.1965700835,
0.5602266788,
-0.4796763957,
0.1743605733,
-0.292270571,
-0.1951744109,
0.9125034809,
0.0272650793,
0.2496245503,
-0.3775399029,
-0.2963525057,
-0.1464353055,
-0.1530494243,
0.0731559247,
-0.1640172303,
0.4567382038,
-0.4092674553,
0.4504017234,
-0.089733921,
0.5060812831,
0.396146059,
-0.0837244242,
0.4199008942,
0.1283563673,
-0.3823010623,
0.3262789547,
0.7699607015,
-0.0095599899,
0.2622585595,
0.0400765799,
-0.3091743886,
0.5279866457,
0.2489962727,
-0.4259468913,
-0.4738659263,
0.128300786,
-0.7251159549,
-0.1546416879,
-0.2918627858,
-0.8517051935,
-0.4822623432,
-0.55349648,
0.6032583714,
-0.6515567303,
-0.6452132463,
0.3153069615,
-0.0864206925,
-0.3071488738,
0.0468726121,
-0.8275534511,
0.5213633776,
0.2681401968,
0.8253145218,
-0.3804389834,
0.1105589792,
-0.3953147531,
0.2460677475,
-0.1418994963,
0.6802377701,
-0.2191957682,
-0.4792434573,
-0.0435157456,
0.0190633964,
-0.317471385,
-0.4908249676,
0.671346426,
0.1004299298,
0.004618038,
-0.1829366684,
-0.8232177496,
0.1091770902,
-0.1678874642,
-0.8231913447,
0.8815220594,
0.3441777229,
-0.8106220961,
0.0157705732,
-0.6737592816,
-0.493490696,
-0.2042717785,
-0.1276246756,
-0.3452960849,
0.2245587409,
0.3198683262,
1.0507386923,
0.2185963541,
0.234507814,
-0.4145789146,
-0.151299268,
0.1610319763,
-0.1624444723,
0.5755932927,
0.4455502927,
-0.4343069196,
-0.2477116883,
-1.1451995373,
-0.2027608901,
-0.2297058553,
-0.3061894178,
-0.6558873653,
-0.1397446543,
0.0395783894,
0.2753340006,
0.0765760466,
-0.3609329164,
-0.4297104776,
-0.4503642917,
0.2489268035,
0.7070848942,
-0.0591918007,
0.1979946941,
0.3169099092,
0.5259535313,
0.3187829256,
-0.1209140122,
0.1064020395,
-0.0465668775,
-0.7012906671,
-0.5458667874,
0.1686085761,
0.519538939,
-0.3624498248,
0.8948023319,
0.2229446769,
-0.1774065495,
-0.8254143596,
-0.0017140091,
0.4665022194,
0.6156119704,
0.7935333848,
-0.3155813813,
-0.5607492924,
-0.7168397903,
-0.1298842728,
0.1683898121,
0.0697901323,
0.1272675991,
0.2399311662,
-0.4340238869,
1.0562167168,
-0.51012218,
-0.8438162208,
-0.1347747147,
0.5061063766,
0.1102668419,
0.7150295973,
0.5676299334,
-0.7536644936,
-0.7444999814,
-0.2853582203,
-0.8170692325,
-0.2479513139,
-0.0061810482,
0.2821033895,
0.0153488237,
0.3689998984,
-0.7621985674,
0.8227000833,
0.4610291421,
-0.4345092773,
0.4004135132,
-0.0976230428,
0.0767101422,
-0.9681189656,
-0.2780575752,
0.3472248614,
-0.1647980511,
-0.6325759888,
-0.5921824574,
0.0238295849,
-0.3655648828,
0.0089974804,
0.2127098888,
-0.4442851543,
-0.3699664176,
-0.2921329141,
0.1412787586,
-0.2136680186,
0.1219933704,
0.284476459,
0.6775030494,
0.9896133542,
-0.7242138386,
0.4401319325,
0.3698534966,
-0.0466833487,
0.7529093623,
-0.5598450303,
-0.3013843596,
-0.2293526381,
0.1269509047,
-1.0135287046,
-0.0659584254,
0.2834245861,
-0.3960644305,
0.4112071991,
-0.0794888064,
0.0017011676,
-0.579905808,
0.1824159622,
-0.0343020298,
0.368327409,
-0.5553710461,
0.5932486057,
0.330439508,
-0.3382711709,
-0.3623624146,
-1.1836804152,
-0.231638357,
-0.4773228168,
-0.4572842121,
0.5405004621,
-0.0480608791,
-0.0224330258,
0.1713474393,
-0.114063032,
-0.2480200082,
-0.0057938616,
0.3868998289,
-0.2560949624,
-0.3577326536,
0.3903388083,
0.0536915399,
-0.4252382517,
0.3390101194,
0.2787416875,
0.4670636058,
-0.1841002405,
-0.4255300164,
-1.0319957733,
0.4453231394,
0.2522428632,
-0.0337626785,
0.5653502941,
0.5719150901,
-0.4556539357,
-0.3275377154,
-0.5890392065,
-0.1451511532,
-0.4840551913,
0.0034330951,
-0.50106287,
-0.7510365844,
0.5046098232,
-0.2990214527,
-0.6955037713,
0.4755401611,
0.4844961762,
-0.4447427392,
1.2010316849,
0.9518406987,
-0.5182076097,
0.4166572094,
-0.4170629382,
0.0794565007,
-0.7115803361,
0.1860983074,
-0.4638641477,
0.0456609577,
-0.09766265,
-0.1994870901,
0.0572279617,
0.2944374382,
-0.1855509281,
0.2219860852,
-0.6448000073,
0.1358483881,
0.0201239958,
0.1647565514,
0.0183200706,
0.0403524265,
0.1093387604,
-0.3198019266,
-0.2166199535,
-0.2053254843,
0.8129230738,
0.3244724572,
0.9696619511,
-0.2838265002,
1.0528939962,
0.9384230971,
0.0958112627,
-0.3992425203,
0.2398738861,
-0.5619045496,
-0.16966708,
-0.3333785236,
-0.5480878353,
-0.587016046,
-0.0231244881,
0.0910502821,
-0.6608837843,
0.6119759679,
0.2567589581,
-0.5589661598,
-0.1819055378,
-0.8486734033,
1.0568410158,
-0.4009979367,
0.4357098937,
-0.5518302321,
-0.5433581471,
0.2665808797,
0.0736711323,
0.3003705442,
-0.2225543708,
0.5095564723,
0.5851210952,
-0.2552479506,
0.9734876752,
-0.5777911544,
-0.2072046846,
0.224610731,
-0.1751204282,
0.3884140551,
-0.1070513204,
-0.2691736221,
-0.2348909229,
0.0604044497,
-0.1474207342,
-0.6682694554,
0.815588057,
-0.9003679752,
-0.3631257713,
-0.2761794627,
-0.037761379,
-0.2754535377,
-0.0704256669,
0.1466596872,
0.3923145831,
-0.3882735074,
0.0828516409,
0.7499867678,
-0.1109189764,
0.2476796508,
0.4922053814,
0.0124210818,
-0.38513726,
0.8443178535,
0.2428700775,
0.045486588,
0.1164207458,
0.0326739997,
-0.4594688118,
-0.2018258423,
-0.0673110783,
0.3090132475,
-0.9422200322,
-0.4349820316,
-0.8495897651,
-0.4212996066,
-0.818302393,
-0.1349284053,
-0.6285082698,
-0.4503958523,
-1.0317200422,
-0.4447685182,
0.5318877697,
0.5428776145,
-0.6701734066,
0.5029092431,
-0.4683517516,
0.8926182985,
0.2732726634,
0.4805990458,
-0.1066908762,
-0.2344449162,
-0.260747999,
0.2694192231,
-0.0111866193,
-1.134344697,
0.8511372805,
0.5901629329,
0.4722157717,
0.6828904152,
0.4057802558,
0.8432276249,
0.0030021276,
0.5594559312,
0.4355556965,
-1.282875061,
1.0069657564,
0.2231035829,
-0.233381778,
0.5758445859,
0.9030117393,
-0.3792913556,
-0.1670511812,
-0.5718826056,
-0.4246652424,
0.9897332191,
0.0029437006,
-0.127738893,
-0.0435072407,
0.5003755093,
0.1214169636,
-0.0900710225,
-0.7462314963,
-0.2747486234,
-0.8057273626,
-0.7867011428,
-0.1674093008,
-0.4225150943,
-0.01831243,
-0.1486987174,
0.5429080725,
-0.1398148835,
0.3480286598,
0.518800199,
-0.2142767757,
-0.1798923463,
0.1723696142,
-0.2744959593,
0.092378743,
-0.2677745521,
0.2399158031,
0.0292010792,
-0.2091271281,
0.2021915466,
0.2826635242,
0.1815083772,
0.0923363566,
0.0370677672,
0.9050477743,
0.1839321405,
-0.7288236022,
0.7368195653,
-0.1073087081,
0.0888243169,
-0.5700883269,
0.2645207345,
0.2711549401,
0.4932883084,
0.3363542259,
-0.1527085006,
0.6785170436,
-0.3705210686,
0.3959352672,
0.3168665171,
-0.5588102341,
-0.4001285136,
0.4498102963,
-0.0204959475,
-0.178142041,
0.6112472415,
0.0404889919,
-0.513887763,
0.6585528851,
0.7488945723,
0.7280676961,
-0.8243321776,
0.5338658094,
0.114734672,
-0.2045989186,
-0.1983450502,
0.5251943469,
-0.3521767855,
-0.6943569183,
-0.2458192408,
-0.7322262526,
-0.1016965881,
0.0923405662,
-1.2911727428,
0.2922025025,
-0.4104908109,
-0.3717007041,
0.0386876091,
-0.1242268756,
-0.5235503316,
0.815603137,
0.4512589276,
0.6320487857,
-1.1823903322,
0.8175137043,
0.4896895885,
-0.4946023822,
-0.5739585161,
-0.1664744914,
0.0244616829,
-0.5097238421,
0.8000116944,
0.303727895,
-0.2130144387,
0.2904498577,
-0.3796302676,
-1.0463700294,
1.0480524302,
0.4303471744,
-0.450756669,
0.2500108182,
0.267242074,
0.9005243778,
-0.5089805722,
-0.1466892809,
0.6883555651,
0.1713351309,
0.0236232951,
-0.7641153336,
-0.1430684924,
-0.2459216714,
-0.0964803994,
-0.1710641682,
-0.4835476875,
0.8500193954,
0.1256238371,
-0.6188783646,
-0.1606925726,
0.8187151551,
0.1871228069,
0.4568207264,
0.5600683093,
0.85477525,
0.7837631106,
0.000354036,
0.8375793695,
-0.3975073993,
0.4767165184,
0.8231562376,
-0.3333819211,
0.7328535318,
0.0858001933,
-0.2353363484,
0.4739027619,
0.6161318421,
-0.1142621487,
0.9799969792,
0.0934875458,
-0.2578762472,
-0.3004300296,
0.0451239012,
-0.6461786628,
0.1410355419,
0.8625481725,
-0.4858590066,
-0.2714191973,
0.5610494614,
-0.4188002646,
0.1223296151,
-0.3333480358,
0.8809306026,
0.4736640155,
-0.1692112982,
0.721763432,
-0.1186891124,
0.7526429892,
-0.4773307741,
0.0732875764,
-0.200260669,
0.3707121015,
-0.3881876767,
-0.6447304487,
0.7175055742,
0.1043512374,
-0.43640697,
-0.4143902361,
1.1727445126,
-0.6075674295,
-0.3932698965,
0.8179487586,
0.3634543419,
0.3281785846,
-0.3075817823,
-0.7602490187,
0.0446462743,
-0.0864108726,
-0.211314559,
0.391000241,
0.8851659298,
0.2126705945,
0.8919019699,
0.2586680651,
0.1332167834,
0.1539439261,
0.2643382549,
1.0230458975,
-0.8485215902,
-0.8125027418,
-0.687400043,
0.2694186866,
-0.0917198062,
-0.0615718327,
0.6570619345,
0.1618394256,
0.3518597782,
-0.3579630554,
0.9286775589,
-0.0837171897,
0.9460077882,
-0.4992806613,
0.652747035,
-0.4632871449,
-0.1186444163,
-0.5192576051,
-0.3348253965,
-0.1750559658,
1.1600751877,
-0.2478981018,
-0.2811886668,
0.3808448911,
0.4738432169,
-0.1544230282,
0.3899272382,
0.0873259529,
0.4679871798,
0.0372853316,
0.3838338554,
0.8947181106,
-0.2285618484,
0.2038285732,
-0.4371741712,
-0.2156139761,
-0.1178416386,
-0.501591742,
-0.8380303383,
-0.6887742877,
-0.6944453716,
0.0276323985,
0.1791799814,
0.717654407,
0.6892496347,
-1.000774622,
-0.1139469966,
-0.139004916,
-0.060459286,
-0.3162362874,
-0.294949472,
0.7678707838,
-0.4312194884,
-0.1318686008,
0.6771109104,
0.0788477808,
0.262996465,
-0.3853363991,
-0.1029042676,
-0.0043277629,
-0.345089674,
0.4740345478,
0.1228212565,
-0.5008519292,
0.1159444377,
-0.5748160481,
-0.1118437871,
0.1425267905,
0.6558653712,
-0.9816852212,
0.1673583835,
0.1674871892,
0.5423252583,
0.7465189695,
0.2768410146,
0.4523572326,
-0.8169996738,
0.0008618802,
0.1878283024,
0.234422639,
0.6069386005,
-0.7710730433,
0.5013491511,
0.1195884049,
-0.3686188459,
-0.6746234298,
-0.0773956403,
-0.7604759932,
-0.3108731508,
0.7618501186,
-0.469656527,
-0.0542179756,
-0.3149107993,
-0.1496050656,
0.3431976438,
-0.4025920033,
1.1387470961,
0.6543263793,
-0.5141035318,
-0.4037980735,
-0.1862762868,
0.9000347853,
0.1741993725,
-0.703156352,
0.2620808184,
0.5777293444,
0.1943686754,
0.2450684458,
0.955237329,
-0.0098784026,
-0.0142038092,
-0.1597418636,
0.2681126595,
0.3493141532,
-0.1446932852,
-0.629298687,
0.1753215939,
-0.5305013061,
0.0864809901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12260v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12260v2 | Cross2StrA: Unpaired Cross-lingual Image Captioning with Cross-lingual Cross-modal Structure-pivoted Alignment | 2023-05-20T18:30:03 | 2023-05-25T04:02:17 | Shengqiong Wu, Hao Fei, Wei Ji, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Unpaired cross-lingual image captioning has long suffered from irrelevancy
and disfluency issues, due to the inconsistencies of the semantic scene and
syntax attributes during transfer. In this work, we propose to address the
above problems by incorporating the scene graph (SG) structures and the
syntactic constituency (SC) trees. Our captioner contains the semantic
structure-guided image-to-pivot captioning and the syntactic structure-guided
pivot-to-target translation, two of which are joined via pivot language. We
then take the SG and SC structures as pivoting, performing cross-modal semantic
structure alignment and cross-lingual syntactic structure alignment learning.
We further introduce cross-lingual&cross-modal back-translation training to
fully align the captioning and translation stages. Experiments on
English-Chinese transfers show that our model shows great superiority in
improving captioning relevancy and fluency. | [
0.1006416529,
-0.3265295923,
0.118242465,
0.3835879862,
-0.6425974965,
0.2901038826,
0.122393772,
-0.3204501867,
0.0091371983,
0.5086485147,
-0.6919299364,
-0.3073617518,
-0.459020108,
-0.0143079106,
-0.2972884476,
0.7130405307,
-0.1718017012,
0.5303803086,
-0.0507265329,
-0.1904048771,
-0.6256395578,
0.0664880425,
-0.2896755934,
-0.0588381886,
0.2592380345,
0.5558892488,
0.9231757522,
0.3857587278,
0.2762728333,
0.1783892214,
0.2545372248,
0.1475845426,
-0.2447263896,
-0.1403257698,
-0.5916578174,
-0.3654544055,
-0.0898946673,
-0.3727783859,
0.6579229832,
0.828579545,
0.2784626782,
-0.2404760867,
-0.0034213525,
0.8842195272,
-0.2046626955,
0.6193956733,
-0.6394808292,
0.4891985059,
-0.2334971726,
-0.4024662077,
-0.4480775297,
0.296377331,
-0.2378378659,
-1.0197703838,
-0.1008148491,
0.4815544188,
1.0606900454,
0.429428786,
-0.6020133495,
0.0716960877,
-0.3091553748,
0.3402591944,
-0.3517744839,
0.2432925701,
-0.1604987681,
0.6391376257,
-0.0050144005,
-0.6514195204,
-0.3360596597,
0.3600616455,
-0.4002151489,
0.2696039975,
-0.3053453565,
-0.3146038055,
-0.087816678,
0.1936903298,
-0.5694315434,
0.2532118857,
-0.6050821543,
-0.3371214867,
0.5990464091,
0.0886558518,
0.764248848,
-0.3035438657,
-1.0247594118,
-0.2359217852,
-1.0116904974,
0.2092082649,
-0.0689674243,
0.4144528508,
-0.1353454739,
0.7517786622,
-0.0627874509,
0.520034194,
0.3192993701,
0.3228060603,
0.2615463734,
-0.7262305617,
-0.1253605932,
0.0698322207,
0.8047168851,
0.79583776,
0.4456622303,
-0.3499668241,
-0.0888178051,
-0.2867313623,
-0.0904112384,
-0.6453102827,
-0.377695024,
-0.1773832887,
-0.3559755385,
-0.0161078572,
0.1368044317,
-0.8841283321,
-0.2355090082,
-0.1297031492,
0.4978572726,
-0.2917575836,
-0.1604678333,
-0.2412559986,
0.0812645182,
0.5065329671,
0.3619927168,
-0.8230342865,
0.2393946201,
0.2687186003,
0.7659468055,
-0.4470288157,
-0.5368516445,
-0.6085047126,
0.6139140129,
-0.4734078646,
1.1033730507,
-0.317825228,
0.0489369892,
0.0322867967,
0.6466766596,
-0.3935833573,
-0.180968523,
-0.0121236006,
-0.363440305,
0.6870332956,
-0.259303093,
-0.2053119093,
-0.4829355776,
0.0156797878,
-0.6618734598,
0.7779709101,
0.4785443544,
-0.6483712792,
0.2305149436,
-0.6718327403,
-0.7893657684,
0.0822742805,
-0.2128434926,
-0.4584355652,
-0.1071880013,
0.5354464054,
0.4966481626,
-0.210856989,
0.0373133905,
0.1171139404,
-0.2497590035,
0.154897511,
-0.0910151079,
0.9591700435,
0.0103939502,
-0.401285857,
0.3840978444,
-0.2895186841,
0.0461728871,
0.3214867711,
0.1092517823,
-0.2022372633,
-0.3518228233,
0.298648119,
0.5660149455,
0.0684392452,
-0.4202169478,
0.1332832426,
-0.2314953208,
0.5676229596,
0.2002115399,
0.03044625,
0.828758657,
0.057778459,
0.3593097925,
0.3368007839,
-0.0062065478,
-0.3172340989,
-0.4484986961,
-0.3124074936,
-0.0624664798,
0.2543026805,
0.6763165593,
-1.1060584784,
0.3174937069,
-0.440297544,
-0.1024835929,
-0.1912434995,
0.1379928291,
0.7737762332,
0.4642335474,
0.4390898645,
-0.7800900936,
-0.1350700259,
-0.9480344653,
0.0955665708,
-0.0148682194,
0.2198605686,
0.0257028379,
0.1896454692,
0.1885945052,
0.4043794274,
-0.1441480368,
-0.8036279082,
-0.4335277677,
0.0059819827,
-0.431850642,
0.5424320698,
0.6645966172,
-0.8865292668,
-0.8377742171,
0.2535257041,
-0.4863623679,
-0.2490471303,
-0.3560318351,
-0.44229877,
0.6382550597,
0.650783062,
-0.6782804728,
0.4514979124,
0.5066716671,
-0.4780475795,
0.1356114298,
0.0127083948,
0.1965868622,
-1.237646699,
0.0811129063,
-0.4583761692,
-0.5063422322,
-0.1995629072,
0.0593691468,
0.1080637723,
-0.2723517418,
-0.7690877914,
0.2469586134,
-1.0453625917,
-0.9236142039,
-0.1382364482,
0.2018713951,
0.2185791582,
0.8942190409,
0.2287341803,
0.6141594648,
0.8721088171,
0.2139253914,
0.4844097793,
0.4879648685,
-0.2446344644,
0.8392348289,
-0.4251638353,
-0.1662374586,
0.0483011603,
0.280220896,
-1.3573633432,
-0.1033379436,
0.7318308353,
-0.4754558206,
0.6896680593,
-0.3369630575,
-0.2374412715,
0.1055482253,
-0.1039570495,
0.5080329776,
0.1927994937,
-0.5134752393,
0.4988707602,
0.2147887945,
-0.1308624297,
-0.5688652992,
-0.867452383,
0.2865238786,
-0.0041962508,
-0.624327302,
0.4896614552,
0.5029274821,
0.2410656959,
0.6093190312,
-0.2262809724,
-0.209991321,
-0.3658947349,
0.2775737643,
0.3214149177,
-0.2663430572,
-0.1839756817,
0.2336332649,
-0.1675713807,
-0.019801734,
-0.2885273993,
0.3537065089,
0.0428023711,
-0.462690264,
-0.4373663962,
0.5996769667,
0.6721980572,
-0.492220968,
0.2198136449,
0.6273495555,
-0.2835009694,
0.0492687225,
0.1542112529,
0.1303082108,
-0.2842611969,
0.8315490484,
-0.3183068037,
-0.6403223872,
0.436757654,
-0.0540908314,
0.1099118516,
0.3707001805,
0.4400998652,
-0.2101055384,
0.7477171421,
0.4908547699,
0.1371945292,
0.43370381,
-0.1407224387,
0.1535082161,
-0.7975282669,
-0.5197555423,
-0.0451884493,
-0.5201732516,
-0.1280741841,
-0.8668525219,
0.0689054504,
0.0560202785,
-0.180249542,
0.6308714747,
-0.4059833586,
0.5608739853,
0.0435689501,
-0.0879536569,
0.2328473181,
0.5009427667,
-0.0349654183,
-0.2627418041,
-0.8286110759,
-0.0717351064,
0.5221930742,
0.1762221605,
0.8113880157,
0.073158361,
0.0841868892,
0.2122066468,
0.1010328382,
-0.6863417625,
0.5518173575,
-0.4278715253,
-0.5848580599,
-0.6622063518,
-0.2367424965,
-0.8991451263,
0.5716730952,
-0.0881299153,
-0.5896705985,
0.3587075174,
-0.1581641436,
-0.0379775576,
0.4410051405,
-0.421348393,
1.3994194269,
-0.7435539961,
-0.3220176101,
-0.0598963872,
-1.1915882826,
0.3603700995,
0.2517974675,
-0.0235705432,
-0.0983697101,
-0.2012445033,
0.2439409345,
-0.3204216957,
0.953597188,
-0.2070452422,
0.1179196164,
0.2705547512,
0.4309490025,
0.303912133,
-0.2243843824,
0.6651446223,
0.2331395894,
0.1108694524,
-0.3984100521,
-0.8377205729,
0.201983586,
-0.6659153104,
-0.4430995882,
-0.4090531468,
-0.8538013697,
-0.0515031219,
0.4016044736,
0.3062677085,
0.3201514184,
-0.0482012928,
0.2295420915,
0.4065790474,
-0.1138665453,
0.5274412036,
0.4262679815,
-0.3747549653,
-0.6568319201,
0.7215049267,
-0.1491971165,
0.6372782588,
0.7504454851,
-0.0919180736,
-0.5153766274,
-0.3562171757,
-1.1882716417,
0.2443690896,
-0.8151170611,
-0.4886131585,
-0.2358434796,
-0.2404037118,
-0.4013569951,
-0.2803641558,
-0.660930872,
-0.8148921132,
-0.0255136415,
0.1601077318,
0.0084894812,
0.398531884,
0.0479763523,
0.2381504923,
-0.7965680361,
0.0851744413,
0.1485865861,
-0.008085263,
-0.278806746,
-0.7755452991,
-0.0955355167,
-0.1413351595,
-0.1417386383,
-1.060017705,
0.4431984425,
0.3884639442,
0.4221145511,
0.4015977085,
-0.0524978787,
0.7781001329,
-0.5000829697,
0.5400321484,
0.5788357854,
-0.8332221508,
0.2073020786,
-0.1131465286,
0.0541321784,
0.4568067491,
0.2321636975,
-0.5211074352,
-0.015924463,
-0.1861707866,
-0.7115622759,
0.6418235302,
0.1068034321,
-0.0371326841,
0.6336678267,
-0.0602712445,
0.0628629103,
0.0329850875,
-1.0928410292,
0.2372942865,
-0.730727911,
0.016825458,
0.2219709605,
0.1273211092,
-0.36417979,
-0.4090428054,
0.4867782891,
-0.5233005285,
0.0487108119,
0.221880585,
-0.288739115,
-0.4439253807,
0.146142289,
0.4247933924,
0.5772023201,
0.2279370129,
0.2325446606,
-0.0900506452,
0.1252375096,
0.1833091676,
0.1293158531,
-0.3227098286,
0.1192165166,
0.383330524,
0.8499517441,
0.7184724808,
-0.3785124719,
0.8357903957,
0.4525192976,
-0.2511214614,
-0.1299483329,
-0.3559164107,
0.2685820758,
0.3103275299,
0.1532590538,
-0.0136929145,
-0.1106253788,
-0.9360281825,
0.2270156741,
0.512535274,
-0.5213224292,
-0.3901818693,
0.6729322076,
0.3295339644,
-0.1130619422,
0.4702171385,
-0.1377392858,
-0.8668332696,
0.4992631376,
0.7430736423,
0.6598103046,
0.023131676,
0.5276140571,
0.2524419725,
0.4740505815,
0.0947570801,
0.15292193,
-0.1896261275,
-0.5442557931,
-0.3813257515,
-0.0191725846,
-0.318120718,
-0.5544800758,
-0.5547075868,
0.1061764657,
-0.2138144225,
0.5240584612,
-0.2824530602,
-0.0893295407,
-0.2345532775,
0.1069356948,
0.1701539159,
0.8391292095,
-1.1582710743,
0.8530926108,
1.0125166178,
-0.8130694032,
-0.9640707374,
-0.1386726052,
-0.0139587503,
-1.0487232208,
0.8086642027,
0.1873524785,
0.0980277732,
-0.1078413352,
-0.47212708,
-0.8532472849,
1.4391405582,
0.1846174747,
-0.4619049728,
-0.040733058,
0.5086804628,
0.4338432848,
-0.8748415709,
-0.1802293211,
0.1452279985,
0.5593832731,
0.6460176706,
-0.8247390985,
0.451186806,
-0.3004529476,
-0.0275922995,
0.0620389767,
-0.8534163833,
0.6376707554,
-0.3836838603,
-0.5204241276,
0.1063572094,
0.7189277411,
-0.1234821826,
0.4552268684,
0.7020199299,
0.4265103936,
0.1877076328,
-0.1524183452,
0.6122738123,
-0.3056876957,
-0.025032768,
1.1637458801,
-0.4205409884,
0.7931714058,
0.8018564582,
0.003947882,
0.6475260854,
0.7173791528,
-0.2988804281,
0.7638627291,
-0.1221058369,
0.3366522789,
-0.4949430227,
-0.2145458758,
-0.2544084489,
0.5443382859,
0.0717290118,
-0.2734196484,
-0.5421770811,
-0.2029845864,
-0.1113228798,
0.2587459683,
-0.2377327383,
0.5446182489,
0.0918072239,
-0.621301651,
0.4155213833,
-0.2223271728,
0.1956405938,
-0.478969276,
-0.0798513815,
-0.4142613113,
-0.2083182186,
-0.3347021043,
-1.134057641,
0.6129242182,
-0.3058972359,
0.0787635744,
-0.2940428555,
0.5640809536,
-0.8904845119,
-0.4445245266,
0.29266572,
0.5713941455,
0.5314536691,
0.0162715204,
-0.7906010747,
-0.2074833363,
0.1912644804,
0.0222514533,
0.4237696528,
0.7634878755,
-0.5898821354,
0.4637435675,
0.3737276196,
0.0489919148,
0.0265409779,
0.2511351705,
0.8529839516,
-0.5176155567,
-0.4772480726,
-0.3375073671,
0.6640101075,
-0.0971709788,
-0.1460361779,
0.6152772903,
0.6217132211,
0.9917832613,
-0.1675735414,
0.2916757166,
-0.3035675287,
-0.1194747016,
-0.6847902536,
0.6206902266,
-0.8177425265,
-0.0428391695,
-0.2196528316,
-1.1464476585,
-0.5042090416,
0.3707470298,
0.0274991598,
-0.5132688284,
0.8537758589,
0.9070590138,
-0.1674809158,
-0.4534441531,
0.3082059324,
-0.1322690248,
-0.0135481562,
1.1099330187,
0.7003403902,
-0.54967767,
0.9649381638,
-0.311724484,
-0.0273842141,
-0.0029938759,
-0.8211349845,
-1.0093692541,
-0.6903817058,
-0.5277638435,
-0.0718268231,
0.2881279588,
0.4974764287,
0.6502125859,
-0.8255210519,
-0.1491745561,
0.0597621165,
0.0996348038,
-0.3689729571,
-0.2272871584,
0.5979708433,
-0.2562741041,
-0.6061720252,
0.2585676908,
0.5646595359,
0.06822294,
-0.4119951129,
-0.2316947281,
-0.1780859977,
-0.2781160772,
0.4355726838,
0.6092703342,
-0.6655136943,
-0.1960304081,
-0.0118709402,
-0.3038668633,
0.2847057581,
0.8261169791,
-0.2551665604,
0.270920068,
0.6101559401,
0.669908762,
0.2935072482,
0.4200205803,
0.4760592282,
-0.6033872366,
0.2149636,
-0.1488501579,
0.5148377419,
0.6389567256,
-0.3337198198,
0.6899693012,
0.5206605792,
-0.1903341115,
-0.5394294858,
0.1221099645,
-1.3248648643,
-0.5199546218,
1.0504187346,
-0.3218408823,
-0.3820149601,
0.1362435222,
-0.3750116229,
0.3894485235,
0.0041823159,
0.4409638047,
0.4313125014,
-0.1462550908,
-0.7475261688,
-0.0091769369,
0.2085507065,
0.5729242563,
-0.7808120251,
0.1591724902,
0.6946802735,
0.4313359857,
0.1417695284,
0.2197738588,
-0.8067632318,
0.5678973794,
0.0443309844,
0.2589211762,
-0.6112415791,
-0.4428424835,
-0.259678036,
-0.0991546661,
-0.364230454,
-0.6136209369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12258v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12258v3 | Constructing Code-mixed Universal Dependency Forest for Unbiased Cross-lingual Relation Extraction | 2023-05-20T18:24:06 | 2023-06-04T13:29:51 | Hao Fei, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Latest efforts on cross-lingual relation extraction (XRE) aggressively
leverage the language-consistent structural features from the universal
dependency (UD) resource, while they may largely suffer from biased transfer
(e.g., either target-biased or source-biased) due to the inevitable linguistic
disparity between languages. In this work, we investigate an unbiased UD-based
XRE transfer by constructing a type of code-mixed UD forest. We first translate
the sentence of the source language to the parallel target-side language, for
both of which we parse the UD tree respectively. Then, we merge the
source-/target-side UD structures as a unified code-mixed UD forest. With such
forest features, the gaps of UD-based XRE between the training and predicting
phases can be effectively closed. We conduct experiments on the ACE XRE
benchmark datasets, where the results demonstrate that the proposed code-mixed
UD forests help unbiased UD-based XRE transfer, with which we achieve
significant XRE performance gains. | [
-0.3590930104,
0.0193941034,
0.1622962207,
0.4673399329,
-0.3143248856,
0.2018806934,
-0.2062465698,
-0.8720402122,
0.2411851734,
0.6883805394,
-0.3864043057,
-0.3105769455,
-0.2797318995,
-0.0247206129,
-0.435428232,
1.0635203123,
-0.0995058864,
0.0243793018,
-0.0869077742,
-0.5179204345,
-0.4078292549,
-0.8778805733,
-0.0512296148,
-0.3259767294,
0.3919094801,
0.3286288083,
0.6093225479,
0.6094467044,
0.2214223146,
0.2454427332,
0.08222837,
-0.2500570416,
-0.2546522021,
-0.0442110486,
-0.4105564356,
-0.4183492064,
-0.4196150601,
-0.2253378332,
0.5265263319,
0.6773603559,
-0.1267377138,
0.1164636388,
0.1642815769,
0.5137609243,
-0.6596274972,
0.514534831,
-0.7821767926,
0.0243335404,
-0.4256198108,
-0.2727269232,
-0.3850688934,
0.1751938164,
0.2703023851,
-0.6055134535,
0.2123987973,
0.1341438144,
1.0629347563,
-0.0154402591,
-0.4250736535,
0.2082627118,
-0.668189168,
0.8945834041,
-0.4065561593,
0.5713627338,
0.304790318,
0.1792053133,
0.0246794857,
-0.3659122586,
-0.1955757141,
-0.0906318501,
-0.3709409535,
0.1120861769,
-0.3522883058,
0.0583996959,
-0.1583091468,
0.5970941186,
-0.4095907509,
0.0510993041,
-0.1332943141,
-0.1804667115,
0.7135443687,
-0.1326064914,
0.4735119343,
-0.5861881971,
-0.5275273323,
-0.2867235243,
-0.7824164629,
0.0594216585,
0.0732211322,
0.5385017991,
-0.1591950804,
0.4694120884,
-0.1713178903,
0.4403856695,
-0.0824458748,
-0.0102126487,
0.1876783073,
-0.589566052,
-0.3393085897,
0.1421028376,
0.8900073767,
0.3195009828,
0.6685160398,
-0.484693855,
-0.2620206773,
0.2663371563,
-0.0775788948,
-0.7832249999,
-0.415515542,
-0.0483232029,
-0.3567014337,
-0.3128732741,
-0.1035777703,
-0.8860356212,
0.1789330393,
-0.2609711885,
-0.1161775738,
-0.2426350862,
-0.5080462694,
0.0013977054,
0.1570989192,
-0.0785972029,
0.0875492617,
-0.7821504474,
0.3871784508,
0.0953926444,
0.5049079657,
-0.2786495984,
-0.2919683158,
-0.7128075957,
0.3848173618,
-0.0091163144,
0.8624648452,
-0.5750024319,
-0.4047072828,
0.1242695823,
-0.0933034867,
-0.1146113276,
-0.5891866684,
0.3895570338,
-0.5408973694,
0.4157437682,
-0.167769298,
-0.0325538702,
-0.2299229652,
0.0430017263,
-0.8292196393,
1.0386528969,
0.5531477332,
-0.8893012404,
0.4238838255,
-0.3691505492,
-0.5888662338,
-0.0519115143,
-0.5510354638,
-0.1609222144,
-0.0753921196,
0.3766084611,
0.1594181508,
-0.5889085531,
0.35744524,
-0.5676985383,
-0.0278463978,
0.1752704531,
-0.3295854032,
1.2093477249,
0.1697612107,
-0.5451852083,
0.0008759752,
-0.8962700963,
0.1910819858,
-0.1903871,
-0.2127252072,
-0.8522994518,
-0.251786083,
0.4501054287,
0.4383330643,
-0.1468039453,
-0.6485404372,
0.335747838,
0.0203465745,
-0.0506089926,
0.662276268,
-0.1381898224,
0.5682920814,
-0.1020581648,
0.5802760124,
0.116393514,
0.0057370872,
-0.0819402486,
-0.2543857396,
-0.5861978531,
-0.3516163826,
0.6405014992,
0.5823022127,
-0.7127097845,
0.5233569741,
-0.466922164,
0.0980076864,
-0.4987764359,
0.3653982282,
0.831962049,
0.1699281782,
0.3833281696,
-0.5589550734,
-0.8340319395,
-0.6744117737,
0.0276531354,
-0.4482513666,
-0.0072884681,
0.1944871545,
0.1886709332,
-0.203648895,
1.1032259464,
-0.5181988478,
-0.797919929,
-0.2244849503,
0.0952834859,
-0.1528848857,
0.4202478826,
0.7895858288,
-0.7538963556,
-0.8039345145,
0.5036908984,
-0.7921088338,
-0.3461652994,
-0.1197991744,
-0.1372123063,
0.3674042523,
0.2535676062,
-0.4619823098,
0.3646314144,
0.7340865731,
-0.3685298264,
0.519775629,
-0.0290972535,
0.1642253399,
-1.0148878098,
0.2874861956,
0.0909250304,
-0.2416128069,
-0.16854918,
0.0392284431,
-0.0708660707,
0.3385816216,
-0.3940767646,
0.5706353784,
-0.971167326,
-0.3217903078,
0.0035443299,
-0.0601318479,
0.0585146956,
0.8801361918,
0.1207860187,
0.5845404863,
0.6212272048,
-0.1789161116,
-0.0154401511,
0.4158828259,
-0.3493977785,
0.5401291251,
-0.372946918,
-0.0549593084,
0.3560653925,
0.0989327505,
-0.6202476621,
0.2150270641,
0.1893261075,
-0.3090097308,
0.3447297812,
-0.497391969,
-0.3272490501,
-0.0420120955,
-0.118802771,
0.5514514446,
0.4913608432,
-0.5863053203,
0.3293538988,
0.469042331,
-0.204982996,
-0.6591626406,
-0.7660675049,
0.098221004,
-0.0412131473,
-0.5696746707,
0.6106463075,
-0.0562801659,
-0.353092432,
0.4353672266,
-0.4462813437,
-0.406190604,
-0.388155967,
0.3352098465,
0.5228180885,
-0.3741644621,
-0.4314704239,
-0.010516623,
-0.064540185,
0.1861638427,
-0.2341827899,
0.1141379327,
0.1897161305,
-0.2349485159,
0.1434690058,
0.7116770148,
0.7226361036,
-0.2668316066,
0.2310971171,
0.0477912389,
-0.1562526226,
-0.3137429655,
-0.3583937585,
0.1274939328,
-0.3481439352,
0.4311035573,
-0.6568619013,
-0.8651342988,
0.5177853107,
0.3008208275,
0.0015822756,
0.1662184298,
0.170162797,
0.2519195676,
1.0019521713,
1.0282400846,
-0.6888734102,
0.5311691761,
-0.4065343142,
-0.1804915667,
-0.7437742949,
-0.2436410636,
-0.6385583282,
0.1117686629,
-0.4256382287,
-0.4013728797,
-0.1258884221,
0.3021390736,
0.13205266,
0.6666437984,
-0.2183898836,
0.2569641471,
0.3627061844,
-0.1904688329,
0.6805369854,
0.5336217284,
-0.3071106374,
-0.1045954451,
-0.7683656812,
0.0811506286,
0.9289579391,
-0.0817390755,
0.7803410292,
-0.174540326,
0.6117635965,
0.4415662289,
0.5002812147,
-0.3367887139,
0.4910168946,
-0.36105901,
-0.4865537286,
-0.0933282152,
-0.6095891595,
-1.0140608549,
0.4662330747,
-0.0962653086,
-1.01821208,
0.4509827793,
0.0378878117,
0.0350247584,
0.5711065531,
-0.4481606185,
0.7673878074,
-0.4940364361,
-0.3015704155,
-0.1212381646,
-0.6856023073,
0.4785583913,
-0.2019812465,
0.1151450574,
0.0511846878,
0.4242971539,
0.7513520718,
-0.3332900703,
0.6806161404,
0.1271741092,
-0.208356455,
0.2212172151,
0.1290500909,
0.2826304436,
0.005515933,
0.1435165405,
0.5390658975,
0.0508906394,
-0.4043346047,
-0.6806284189,
0.6936087608,
-0.9185183048,
-0.3924189806,
-0.548275888,
-0.8965728879,
-0.298382163,
0.3617008924,
0.149676308,
0.4131602049,
-0.4260898829,
-0.0238301326,
0.3836328089,
0.2260229141,
0.3763577342,
0.5828551054,
-0.639723599,
-0.6544165611,
0.8819591403,
0.0523560084,
0.2616925538,
0.6699285507,
-0.1302982569,
-0.3564437628,
-0.3669418395,
-0.8017047048,
0.1230227351,
-0.4066549242,
-0.4340674877,
-0.5595602393,
-0.419408381,
-0.219018966,
-0.0468825623,
-0.3069392443,
-0.2583277225,
0.2183603942,
0.0365366079,
0.4056656659,
0.6344205737,
-0.2184790075,
0.2625127435,
-1.1609719992,
0.353777051,
0.1068371832,
0.3699420393,
-0.1460833848,
-0.318489641,
-0.3222251832,
0.1992021799,
0.1201631054,
-0.803601563,
0.4311068356,
-0.0295738261,
0.5844120383,
0.4457401931,
0.2041626573,
0.8446111679,
-0.1220123544,
0.0928725675,
0.5033521056,
-0.8030984998,
0.0718521327,
-0.3301464021,
0.0811843872,
0.7093128562,
0.198778078,
-0.2885063291,
-0.3756481409,
-0.7126146555,
-0.6848598123,
0.8883128762,
0.4082430601,
-0.3103184402,
0.4416017234,
-0.1091693714,
0.0513557121,
0.0546567775,
-0.8267068863,
-0.3077342808,
0.0368064418,
0.1370876431,
0.0393573083,
-0.1715692729,
-0.0003790441,
-0.3924403489,
0.3925261497,
-0.0695988014,
-0.1720280349,
0.074159272,
-0.3010460734,
-0.5171800852,
0.3433016539,
-0.1691847146,
0.3790196776,
-0.5404694676,
0.1290449649,
-0.0847745389,
-0.4125654399,
0.2840817869,
0.3641585708,
-0.3468306661,
0.0826847553,
0.3321669698,
0.6064659953,
0.5262897611,
-0.4669840336,
0.4644347131,
0.0942765772,
-0.0844839886,
0.0551199466,
-0.2054320574,
-0.0458115563,
0.093365714,
0.1612982005,
0.3824994862,
0.0306539945,
-0.7519617677,
0.6364322305,
0.4321064353,
-0.3917273581,
-0.4949866831,
0.5136255026,
0.4225516319,
0.0458045304,
0.850884676,
-0.0289347768,
-0.7150071859,
0.348005414,
0.6121964455,
1.097481966,
-0.187188834,
0.2360138446,
0.161468789,
0.1933321357,
0.1382503659,
0.2308084518,
-0.6192879081,
-0.6830115318,
-0.8448477387,
-0.6497265697,
-0.1919273734,
-0.0695508048,
-1.0474977493,
0.141038388,
0.1972317547,
0.3606599569,
-0.2895070612,
0.0741862506,
-0.5087946057,
0.2392306328,
0.141163826,
0.8724089265,
-1.1221960783,
1.4647278786,
0.6744986176,
-0.6658174992,
-0.8659951091,
0.0686317608,
-0.144213438,
-0.7910116911,
0.6216608286,
-0.0177254453,
-0.1237217188,
-0.2473385483,
0.0513095967,
-0.8988150954,
0.7609317303,
0.5865604877,
-0.7200102806,
-0.1318828464,
0.3245970905,
0.4277326167,
-0.5451394916,
0.2356821448,
0.5905703306,
0.4318542182,
0.3051334023,
-0.9401379228,
0.2701161802,
-0.6279954314,
-0.0221850108,
0.457203418,
-0.3749781847,
0.6147920489,
-0.3426243067,
-0.4182268977,
-0.0399678722,
0.830565989,
0.2750634253,
0.0957809836,
0.7569562793,
0.6556511521,
0.3403137028,
0.4019337595,
0.8159372211,
-0.3392805755,
0.2493920177,
1.3448425531,
-0.573256731,
0.8932669163,
0.5941409469,
-0.3258338869,
0.8122600913,
0.4959258437,
0.0585752539,
0.6962342858,
0.03293873,
-0.1920508146,
-0.147555694,
-0.2836778462,
-0.5260692239,
0.2480490655,
-0.0673516989,
-0.1668553501,
-0.5780408978,
-0.1393167973,
0.3025027514,
-0.09531077,
-0.1008063555,
0.4902910292,
0.2702337205,
-0.9503902197,
0.6457446814,
-0.4147474468,
0.704534173,
-0.8080881834,
-0.2858995497,
-0.4630061984,
0.3662465513,
-0.3397876918,
-0.8263819814,
0.3413324952,
0.0187184997,
-0.4005970061,
-0.3963137865,
0.6167786717,
-0.8004702926,
-0.3439999819,
1.1463270187,
0.7109318972,
0.0484126583,
-0.259408772,
-0.6191609502,
0.064110823,
0.5422555208,
-0.062262103,
0.8652380705,
0.5561679006,
-0.5954594612,
0.3140415251,
0.7963314652,
0.4383571744,
-0.0307586379,
0.1578124166,
0.9799095988,
-0.593901515,
-0.3967424035,
-0.4883718789,
0.549819231,
-0.0674038678,
-0.3847884834,
0.9045051932,
0.6028543115,
1.078132391,
0.1176509038,
1.0186569691,
-0.4388038516,
-0.1525566876,
-0.2801061273,
0.6323499084,
-0.6451227665,
0.2609736323,
-0.3674044609,
-1.119332552,
-0.2780943513,
0.0194963012,
0.2196806222,
-0.0822733268,
0.8872668743,
0.7955861092,
-0.4375628829,
-0.1763075739,
0.4367516935,
0.1428351998,
0.0353164934,
0.6463781595,
0.5265808702,
-0.1945798099,
1.076069355,
-0.7107263803,
-0.4167733192,
0.1187783256,
-0.7868743539,
-0.8506160378,
-0.5635753274,
-0.4166929126,
-0.4285495877,
0.1800518781,
0.5448989272,
0.832449615,
-1.0371333361,
-0.749276638,
-0.1294941753,
0.1531562656,
-0.3288806081,
-0.1964022964,
0.527479589,
-0.0222927872,
-0.5503985882,
0.2793608606,
0.4559627473,
-0.1019708589,
-0.3988895714,
-0.2163954973,
-0.2477236092,
-0.2890482247,
0.4948310554,
0.5494691133,
-0.5387340188,
-0.1773056835,
0.1996181309,
-0.1906597018,
0.2950976491,
1.0609327555,
-0.8177976012,
0.3863459229,
0.4783891439,
0.5125355124,
0.563323319,
-0.1806178242,
0.9774492383,
-0.7832877636,
0.1299385875,
-0.1117972434,
0.6810187697,
0.2458742112,
-0.2725414038,
0.8151831031,
0.2883622944,
-0.3316163123,
-0.8648380637,
0.0589534901,
-1.4236880541,
-0.2020925283,
1.1935169697,
-0.2210116386,
-0.3190126419,
-0.3753269315,
-0.2623282075,
0.1208996251,
-0.3312931955,
0.6905585527,
0.1874931604,
-0.0284859128,
-0.0775736943,
-0.0006346785,
0.2771953642,
0.5181115866,
-0.9163938761,
0.308904171,
0.457516253,
0.3192838728,
0.2904089391,
0.6850122213,
-0.241473183,
0.2709633112,
0.1414622366,
0.5164577365,
0.1151906103,
-0.4356398582,
-0.1266125143,
0.0828731358,
0.0295399241,
-0.3699098527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12257v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12257v1 | SEntFiN 1.0: Entity-Aware Sentiment Analysis for Financial News | 2023-05-20T18:20:39 | 2023-05-20T18:20:39 | Ankur Sinha, Satishwar Kedas, Rishu Kumar, Pekka Malo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | Fine-grained financial sentiment analysis on news headlines is a challenging
task requiring human-annotated datasets to achieve high performance. Limited
studies have tried to address the sentiment extraction task in a setting where
multiple entities are present in a news headline. In an effort to further
research in this area, we make publicly available SEntFiN 1.0, a
human-annotated dataset of 10,753 news headlines with entity-sentiment
annotations, of which 2,847 headlines contain multiple entities, often with
conflicting sentiments. We augment our dataset with a database of over 1,000
financial entities and their various representations in news media amounting to
over 5,000 phrases. We propose a framework that enables the extraction of
entity-relevant sentiments using a feature-based approach rather than an
expression-based approach. For sentiment extraction, we utilize 12 different
learning schemes utilizing lexicon-based and pre-trained sentence
representations and five classification approaches. Our experiments indicate
that lexicon-based n-gram ensembles are above par with pre-trained word
embedding schemes such as GloVe. Overall, RoBERTa and finBERT (domain-specific
BERT) achieve the highest average accuracy of 94.29% and F1-score of 93.27%.
Further, using over 210,000 entity-sentiment predictions, we validate the
economic effect of sentiments on aggregate market movements over a long
duration. | [
-0.7120425105,
-0.6916517019,
0.2439360768,
0.6937085986,
-0.5207504034,
0.0006305561,
-0.322501123,
-0.4155520797,
0.5290132761,
0.4488229454,
-0.52584517,
-0.6973212957,
-0.6563428044,
0.0135146612,
-0.3324985802,
1.3658138514,
0.3614363372,
0.0867668539,
-0.1351161003,
-0.0829888582,
0.117704168,
-0.2592588663,
-0.9022727609,
0.1194082871,
0.537509203,
0.5413453579,
0.68405509,
0.1907156706,
1.0263748169,
0.1219642833,
0.0200752281,
-0.0715525448,
-0.2467000932,
-0.2591624558,
-0.2515476644,
-0.2222053856,
-1.0240796804,
0.5305173397,
0.4656842947,
0.6749433875,
-0.2778407633,
0.2891590297,
0.0929887816,
0.9171178937,
-0.5064768791,
0.3631438315,
-0.3873151541,
0.1727959514,
-0.4586303234,
-0.1455167979,
-0.2300092578,
-0.4288447797,
0.5060907006,
-0.8465794325,
0.0667179525,
0.3078837693,
0.8611732125,
0.2131421119,
-0.3079007566,
-0.4743204713,
-0.2382725328,
0.7637701035,
-0.5443341732,
0.6677597165,
0.3098127246,
0.1825625151,
0.1891067922,
-0.7507388592,
-0.3898568451,
0.2053909004,
-0.11448773,
0.4390910268,
-0.4465338588,
0.0921230838,
0.0555732325,
0.5676201582,
-0.4950191379,
-0.0661355257,
-0.4156846702,
0.0029398699,
0.5164495111,
-0.2700524926,
-0.2054099143,
-0.5679132938,
-0.8358860016,
-0.1971011013,
-0.5387294292,
0.0566644147,
0.4751017988,
0.5536754727,
-0.2204568088,
0.2234419733,
-0.2186113745,
0.4813191295,
0.2395841777,
-0.0532627627,
0.3563985527,
-0.0713701323,
-0.4843893051,
0.4125823379,
0.8293708563,
0.6974081993,
0.30224666,
-0.0717131048,
-0.5045300722,
0.0127004376,
0.3866283,
-0.5984567404,
0.018686099,
0.2375942767,
-0.5565163493,
-0.6108026505,
0.3425117135,
-1.4255766869,
-0.3012704551,
-0.1883573234,
-0.0812316388,
-0.112676248,
-0.3773090541,
0.3574159443,
-0.3333595395,
0.5496295094,
0.1703103334,
-0.5835921764,
0.5535408258,
0.9384973645,
0.5798290968,
-0.0360788479,
0.0544211194,
-0.5880382061,
-0.234325856,
-0.1801970005,
1.0709835291,
-0.6089953184,
-0.3498882353,
-0.2306090742,
-0.2985659838,
-0.0691651627,
-0.4620283842,
0.6971938014,
-0.532679975,
0.3817280829,
-0.2984912395,
-0.7917120457,
-0.3598607183,
0.3431214094,
-0.7039325237,
0.7297984958,
0.4532763064,
-1.0467873812,
0.5254882574,
-1.1657364368,
-0.5370936394,
-0.1330195367,
0.0165995415,
-0.2614196241,
0.1836263686,
0.6227443218,
0.5319634676,
-0.4579835832,
0.1677311212,
-0.5472001433,
-0.2040951252,
0.2596662045,
-0.4040976465,
0.5220659971,
0.323817879,
-0.4844015241,
-0.1826042384,
-0.7447020411,
-0.212917164,
-0.1960706711,
-0.118418999,
-0.3811288774,
-0.1299688667,
0.2728593349,
0.0044912025,
0.1845039427,
-0.745094955,
-0.0064400714,
-0.6071026921,
0.154183656,
0.7962872386,
0.2578700483,
0.6355912685,
-0.0393760726,
0.5713157058,
0.4441071153,
0.2514650524,
0.0755198374,
-0.0705469474,
-0.4621812701,
-0.4338851869,
0.277249068,
0.7614856362,
-0.4002181292,
0.2165397108,
-0.4158331752,
-0.3366951346,
-0.3930287957,
-0.0071677272,
-0.0084416559,
0.5152203441,
0.2985855043,
-0.0808424726,
-0.5676084161,
-1.0644010305,
-0.4818799496,
-0.2521771789,
0.1507661045,
0.2892894447,
0.0316949002,
-0.2306706607,
1.0155726671,
-0.7595695257,
-0.2187681049,
0.0718071014,
0.1646602154,
0.3334116936,
0.472625941,
0.6890570521,
-0.9823275805,
0.1213623732,
0.1115724146,
-0.8181325197,
0.3825110197,
-0.2757981122,
-0.1592560261,
0.0359980538,
0.4450904727,
-0.5748353601,
0.024700135,
0.3678804934,
-0.4980613589,
0.1367262155,
0.2106202394,
0.1779989898,
-1.064876318,
-0.0434483178,
0.6304759979,
-0.4486825168,
-0.1895881444,
-0.0663995072,
-0.091838643,
-0.1584681869,
-0.4703351855,
0.5892471671,
-0.1536179334,
-0.194284156,
-0.1941114515,
0.3339838088,
0.0139083639,
0.5146656632,
-0.0745141655,
0.6660845876,
0.7536429763,
-0.489040643,
0.5380598903,
0.1096193045,
-0.3100222647,
0.8139975667,
-0.604511559,
-0.0523032658,
-0.3419400454,
0.0103988936,
-0.7244152427,
-0.1366598457,
0.6275712848,
-0.3886232078,
0.3215665519,
0.3325989842,
-0.3334176838,
-0.2004946619,
-0.2322976738,
-0.0999821126,
0.1358137876,
-0.3683855534,
0.5746033192,
0.4875378907,
-0.5748505592,
-0.5255438089,
-0.628221035,
0.0497669429,
-0.4794758558,
-0.4104764163,
-0.0636763722,
0.1533402801,
-0.53396523,
0.1484640092,
-0.3617684841,
-0.0495420843,
0.3609965742,
0.173733145,
0.4282923043,
-0.3611933887,
0.2386056334,
0.3452959657,
-0.2569365799,
0.1920807362,
-0.5430654883,
0.018048279,
-0.6110541821,
0.1653023958,
-0.0024956912,
0.3764448166,
0.7833324671,
-0.469265461,
0.5706683397,
0.5441365242,
-0.6500044465,
0.1502355635,
-0.3251227736,
-0.0330704488,
-0.4687378705,
0.1881514192,
-0.1992415935,
-0.9142435789,
0.4948640168,
-0.0457024425,
0.3188834786,
0.7099245191,
-0.0365314931,
-0.2385542393,
0.6567123532,
0.5808912516,
-0.2776463032,
0.3473260701,
-0.0089653106,
0.0758572295,
-0.4724796712,
-0.0199772082,
-0.1715710312,
-0.3107518554,
-0.5780268312,
0.0605651103,
0.2061946094,
0.0908210129,
-0.1382592469,
0.3053857684,
-0.2848211527,
0.1954394132,
0.3839658201,
0.3421570659,
0.0650384873,
0.1430772841,
0.1592653394,
0.1462713629,
-0.3797601759,
-0.5157965422,
0.9995393753,
0.6532995701,
0.6165836453,
-0.0796660706,
0.5780075192,
0.6598527431,
0.6787763238,
-0.7750198245,
0.4591353536,
-0.3743195832,
-0.6545898914,
-0.1283535063,
-0.6481875777,
-0.3828341365,
-0.1960293055,
-0.3164291084,
-0.2653226554,
0.4472687542,
-0.0376720838,
-0.7149296999,
0.0390191674,
-0.5060007572,
0.8632836938,
-0.0630764514,
0.071749717,
-0.142619282,
-0.3919422925,
0.3609678745,
-0.3363318443,
0.3816207945,
-0.2870060205,
-0.1253201067,
0.829218924,
0.0103890505,
0.6670985222,
-0.3311594427,
-0.3668732047,
0.2331486195,
-0.3898035884,
0.4581215084,
0.5435341001,
-0.2665700912,
0.1063708961,
-0.2071295977,
-0.5960503817,
-0.5523888469,
0.7931580544,
-0.3536121547,
-0.4973855615,
-0.3184825182,
-0.2841863334,
-0.2635753453,
0.0077899857,
0.3119589388,
0.595972538,
-0.3051280379,
0.0962996632,
0.6274317503,
0.1279702485,
0.5778706074,
0.1627507061,
-0.2132300884,
-0.8651692867,
0.9619635344,
-0.0179199781,
-0.3093755543,
0.3449260294,
0.0287573934,
-0.249211818,
-0.1494861245,
-0.4838840961,
-0.0381926298,
-0.7334077358,
-0.4371547699,
-0.6035473347,
0.3472534418,
-0.4632399976,
-0.2807642519,
-0.6954030991,
-0.3752996027,
-0.5656675696,
-0.5181103349,
0.4113551676,
0.3745509982,
-0.0160849467,
0.4476023316,
-1.1888593435,
0.0777576864,
0.1895312965,
0.7200533152,
-0.39383021,
-0.0359185822,
-0.3140030205,
0.1890691072,
0.0630353913,
-0.8064383864,
0.2299850881,
0.3163559735,
0.3630909324,
1.0523542166,
0.139161706,
0.4689503908,
0.0860579982,
0.6057984233,
0.2086866498,
-0.9796284437,
0.6515452266,
-0.4919928312,
-0.0561925955,
0.6139739752,
0.3912505507,
-0.3543536067,
-0.5316750407,
-0.8034310341,
-0.4815951586,
0.498059243,
0.1142978072,
-0.0218776017,
-0.5031576753,
0.65038836,
0.2736571133,
0.4491834641,
-0.3133691847,
-0.5183652043,
-0.4739321172,
-0.4832285047,
-0.2293441892,
-0.1916667074,
0.292619586,
-0.057302177,
0.6450209022,
-0.0472219028,
0.2128201574,
0.4582121074,
-0.1071832255,
-0.0146124074,
0.2668830454,
0.6428247094,
0.4151540101,
-0.3555992842,
0.0047864956,
-0.0026366671,
-0.5170320272,
-0.0759748369,
0.7295737863,
-0.0261770412,
0.1482334137,
0.2320473492,
0.8746916056,
0.8055411577,
-0.6019135118,
0.4464308023,
-0.1907443702,
-0.1891567707,
-0.3763929605,
-0.2264695466,
-0.1777714044,
0.5863873363,
0.5384905338,
0.4301065207,
0.463993907,
-0.4646472037,
0.6219519377,
0.1863500327,
-0.830681324,
-0.4568855464,
0.5970434546,
0.4149889946,
0.5191137195,
0.7348141074,
-0.327223897,
-0.4945789278,
0.3361594081,
0.0981441289,
0.9858466387,
0.0867629573,
0.3310745955,
0.304319948,
0.2672433853,
-0.3597830534,
0.3219217062,
0.0801975802,
-0.7806174159,
-0.1692726016,
-0.8143061996,
-0.2687596977,
-0.4565546811,
-1.0449800491,
0.1873614341,
-0.6500869989,
-0.5379271507,
0.4095204175,
0.2600505054,
-0.6908811927,
0.4504490793,
0.4094828069,
1.1993488073,
-0.5896832347,
0.257114321,
1.1435159445,
-0.3280043006,
-0.5457838774,
-0.0702495128,
-0.1341254711,
-0.2721292675,
0.3585304916,
0.2322569638,
0.1876903623,
0.3424254358,
-0.5722702146,
-0.6189488173,
0.7834780812,
0.370745033,
-0.5082998872,
-0.215775758,
-0.0825859904,
0.0086594094,
-0.6198199391,
-0.0060757576,
0.5756273866,
0.7521646023,
-0.1055293009,
-0.5627593994,
-0.1496823132,
-0.2949720621,
-0.5249716043,
0.4281293154,
-0.6644684672,
0.7486693859,
0.0368196256,
-0.3655027449,
-0.6380979419,
1.2188645601,
-0.1005982831,
0.6806230545,
0.6562498212,
0.7027463317,
1.0233432055,
-0.1817541569,
1.095980525,
-0.4442315102,
0.5827845931,
0.8415495157,
-0.1964940578,
0.7087007761,
0.2361873537,
-0.0227963254,
0.5338918567,
0.7564238906,
0.1752470583,
0.493817091,
0.0020890865,
-0.3391087949,
-0.3357383609,
-0.0212999899,
0.0125170862,
0.7775599957,
0.5153554082,
-0.3656656146,
-0.3941897154,
0.4650875926,
0.0496679842,
-0.2237415016,
-0.7604643106,
0.6632495522,
0.4383512437,
-0.4491325617,
-0.2502165139,
-0.0063876552,
0.768795073,
-0.2563263178,
0.185258016,
-0.5279518962,
0.1121448129,
-0.1515510231,
-0.7163277268,
0.4009038806,
0.2193161398,
-0.3059542775,
-0.1629187763,
0.8475247025,
-0.3674493432,
-0.6795957685,
0.0666767731,
0.6436826587,
-0.046289403,
-0.6012480855,
-0.4668999314,
-0.286368221,
-0.0807201043,
-0.7091677785,
-0.0182559825,
0.5071357489,
0.1800957173,
0.3969955146,
0.6492305398,
-0.0834994018,
-0.3407245874,
-0.1554117352,
0.8155522943,
-1.1213009357,
-0.7214518785,
-0.8214328289,
0.1969082803,
-0.1811409146,
-0.4776831269,
0.5540736914,
0.6314077973,
0.6223659515,
0.0112819495,
0.6327927709,
0.3257106543,
0.4936518967,
-0.4714941382,
0.7301822305,
-0.3833367825,
0.2404789031,
-0.3931393027,
-1.0722851753,
-0.2672423422,
0.5335988402,
-0.0852699503,
-0.2699023783,
0.3881062269,
0.3554062545,
-0.0891838744,
0.5695206523,
-0.1073505133,
-0.250028044,
0.0692778155,
0.140769124,
0.3284556866,
-0.4762454629,
0.2884942293,
-0.2491241097,
-0.0487849228,
-0.0445497073,
-0.8314412832,
-0.5804078579,
-0.1527682394,
-0.6026269794,
-0.0786324292,
-0.0303039104,
1.2533311844,
0.3279930353,
-0.567991972,
0.1428401172,
0.0078713354,
0.0143728256,
-0.3036865592,
-0.3044953346,
0.3296674192,
-0.3407251239,
-0.7023543715,
0.2266797572,
0.4631625414,
0.143150717,
-0.0622624606,
0.1964303702,
0.0229785535,
0.289756,
0.5761832595,
0.0176086035,
-0.1723235846,
-0.4639301002,
0.2821246684,
-0.3699105382,
-0.0402753577,
0.7902873755,
-0.6642580032,
-0.1416674405,
0.1751435548,
0.6478962898,
0.128118068,
0.2830908895,
0.5007058382,
-0.935734868,
0.1862058938,
0.1396979839,
0.4002289772,
0.3562687337,
-0.560123682,
0.3283339739,
0.2684755027,
-0.0564496927,
-0.4561540484,
-0.2910918593,
-1.1130011082,
-0.1234610155,
0.811889708,
-0.1507358849,
-0.4399414957,
0.3694140017,
0.2319869548,
0.1680345684,
-0.7889127731,
0.3141674697,
0.7268766165,
0.2867385149,
-0.3854318261,
-0.3155245781,
0.5074440837,
0.1670758426,
-0.9410507679,
0.1103005633,
0.4691669047,
0.0093020992,
0.1252613813,
0.5990486741,
-0.0620624311,
0.3860658705,
0.1350774318,
0.0948031247,
-0.1218944341,
-0.3137803972,
-0.2398859262,
0.2872951031,
-0.463753432,
-0.3999600708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12256v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12256v2 | Scene Graph as Pivoting: Inference-time Image-free Unsupervised Multimodal Machine Translation with Visual Scene Hallucination | 2023-05-20T18:17:20 | 2023-05-25T04:24:34 | Hao Fei, Qian Liu, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we investigate a more realistic unsupervised multimodal machine
translation (UMMT) setup, inference-time image-free UMMT, where the model is
trained with source-text image pairs, and tested with only source-text inputs.
First, we represent the input images and texts with the visual and language
scene graphs (SG), where such fine-grained vision-language features ensure a
holistic understanding of the semantics. To enable pure-text input during
inference, we devise a visual scene hallucination mechanism that dynamically
generates pseudo visual SG from the given textual SG. Several SG-pivoting based
learning objectives are introduced for unsupervised translation training. On
the benchmark Multi30K data, our SG-based method outperforms the
best-performing baseline by significant BLEU scores on the task and setup,
helping yield translations with better completeness, relevance and fluency
without relying on paired images. Further in-depth analyses reveal how our
model advances in the task setting. | [
-0.2416111827,
-0.7962802052,
0.7167215943,
0.1152340844,
-0.5644934773,
-0.1322309673,
0.017460661,
-0.1351863444,
-0.0873472989,
0.6581590176,
-0.6412414312,
-0.5517330766,
-0.634023726,
0.0211126022,
-0.5731444955,
0.7332027555,
0.1640476137,
0.3065623641,
-0.1549250484,
-0.1441036314,
-0.2756549418,
-0.3909999728,
-0.1071645468,
-0.1967427582,
0.4164545834,
0.2248345166,
0.9026136398,
0.5432311893,
0.4108745456,
0.3723745048,
0.2274747193,
0.4443988502,
-0.1841150075,
0.0647729263,
-0.0754112825,
-0.1266078204,
-0.1691229492,
-0.0053914208,
0.4879415035,
0.7991847396,
0.0656944141,
-0.0614344366,
0.0301514119,
0.6713482141,
-0.4250021577,
0.4992498755,
-0.7831354737,
0.3275696635,
-0.060631834,
-0.1858516783,
-0.7249462008,
0.0350700505,
-0.226066336,
-0.5952254534,
0.1652584374,
0.2637045383,
0.7964856029,
0.4809134603,
-0.7002568841,
-0.0896714777,
-0.4360069931,
0.5691030622,
-0.3289112449,
0.5663926601,
0.1092711017,
0.4829058051,
-0.251193583,
-0.792424202,
-0.5964207053,
-0.0753415823,
-0.2722511888,
0.1664100438,
-0.2028024793,
0.0063046333,
0.0862553343,
0.3310987949,
-0.6970437765,
-0.2665664852,
-0.2489537895,
-0.1257977635,
0.2021203488,
0.0200801026,
0.4308619201,
-0.5300984383,
-0.5594421625,
-0.3948235214,
-0.3386860788,
-0.1315213591,
-0.2614878714,
0.3546790183,
0.129774183,
1.1507797241,
-0.0824454725,
0.639993608,
-0.0201214682,
0.1678572744,
0.4680882096,
-0.3732452989,
-0.332013309,
-0.0075751343,
1.0700297356,
0.6608076096,
0.3708853722,
-0.4615221322,
-0.119430244,
0.1525750607,
0.3861391842,
-0.954349041,
-0.2883140445,
-0.0190986134,
-0.3548870683,
-0.2079618126,
0.051751148,
-0.8770632148,
-0.1811668575,
-0.1694887429,
0.4085547328,
-0.7214610577,
-0.0152516654,
-0.2165703624,
0.0727359429,
0.139796257,
0.4305945635,
-0.4214601517,
-0.1643419117,
0.060385529,
1.0210869312,
-0.3443653584,
-0.5275855064,
-0.8550251722,
0.3395325243,
-0.5860640407,
0.8727824092,
-0.3920484781,
-0.3416231871,
-0.1256578118,
0.422304064,
-0.5005639791,
-0.2852646112,
0.145868361,
-0.3422688246,
0.2660701573,
0.0491947085,
-0.2141086757,
-0.3443989158,
0.1550021768,
-0.4576972723,
0.9819077849,
0.0116407825,
-0.5616213679,
0.0387987345,
-0.6607704759,
-0.3899384737,
-0.0858120322,
-0.1457647234,
-0.3062336147,
0.241489619,
0.6956455112,
0.7304077148,
0.1636513472,
0.3089483678,
-0.1671453416,
-0.1979457438,
0.4851891696,
-0.5364704728,
0.3985387683,
0.388017863,
-0.3313549459,
0.3479618728,
-0.3683099151,
0.0030346082,
0.1809734851,
0.2814570665,
-0.0452946424,
-0.0688752457,
0.0912932232,
0.5660399795,
-0.0122546926,
-0.4752647877,
0.2392724007,
-0.1667928547,
0.3950910866,
0.3486452699,
0.0418256186,
0.5953313112,
0.2026790082,
0.1778181046,
0.4273406565,
-0.0545106344,
-0.574280262,
-0.7205501795,
-0.6620379686,
-0.3654258251,
-0.093760103,
0.6639334559,
-1.3106409311,
0.147161752,
-0.3526610136,
-0.0869571939,
-0.5271218419,
-0.0968823209,
0.4889510274,
0.4817503095,
0.7142513394,
-0.329583168,
-0.1191663146,
-0.8287149072,
-0.0100294901,
0.1416601837,
-0.1451652348,
0.104590714,
0.4592673481,
-0.422722578,
0.4908843935,
-0.5735260248,
-0.5748158097,
-0.367382288,
0.3481463492,
-0.0685016736,
0.2985131145,
0.4598381817,
-0.7646595836,
-0.3658588529,
0.2979134023,
-1.0091542006,
0.0998222008,
-0.2102159709,
-0.3367849588,
0.1800412685,
0.6774325967,
-0.7234238982,
0.8973291516,
0.5283049941,
-0.160235852,
0.2114987671,
-0.3756113052,
0.6142713428,
-1.1914534569,
-0.0857680589,
0.0439964719,
-0.4897106588,
-0.5325852036,
0.0947760791,
0.0827990323,
-0.4651989937,
-0.6310372949,
0.408336103,
-0.5424047112,
-0.4537388086,
-0.3261405528,
0.3105336428,
-0.0002918224,
0.8056329489,
0.0966502875,
0.8974530697,
0.3671288192,
-0.4526498616,
0.2238857448,
0.3921093345,
-0.323717773,
0.5063900948,
-0.2072487622,
0.168566972,
-0.0187188759,
0.0883449018,
-1.0706006289,
-0.3781393468,
0.5493375659,
-0.5256598592,
0.1868133843,
-0.2867311537,
-0.6350422502,
-0.1129578203,
0.2326261699,
0.3588166535,
0.377029717,
-0.4808704257,
0.3766537309,
0.1117249131,
0.1077623963,
-0.317843467,
-0.7968136072,
0.2903476357,
0.0830087289,
-0.4569514394,
0.2661539018,
0.1196157336,
-0.0239152964,
0.0563206971,
-0.1090167686,
-0.2986757159,
-0.2950415909,
0.3952330351,
0.183026582,
-0.0648022816,
-0.1463448852,
0.3859758079,
-0.3355455101,
-0.2293132842,
-0.3665671349,
0.5560637116,
-0.3620369434,
-0.642332375,
-0.5490098596,
0.4083734751,
0.8650889993,
-0.3807790279,
0.7200362086,
0.8572378755,
-0.2927858233,
0.127380833,
-0.1464858055,
-0.0352984592,
-0.4018198848,
0.603533566,
-0.553273201,
-0.5023142695,
0.2185808718,
-0.1933644563,
-0.1140031442,
0.445479393,
0.5777418017,
-0.4007347822,
1.1251778603,
0.3779839575,
0.3339110613,
0.428937465,
-0.2564587593,
0.3621272743,
-0.6859471202,
-0.3560651541,
-0.0785408169,
-0.2207269818,
-0.4654514194,
-0.8707636595,
0.4806257486,
0.074385412,
0.0822507963,
0.2864406407,
-0.5689480901,
0.4570771456,
0.2176602483,
0.286513418,
0.397872299,
0.4379347861,
-0.3260101974,
-0.2699576318,
-0.5212466717,
-0.4052293599,
0.7393038869,
-0.139534533,
0.3428397477,
-0.1166125685,
0.203415066,
0.3351308405,
0.1598431319,
-0.7623886466,
0.7080013156,
-0.3199145198,
-0.3369078934,
-0.4340874255,
-0.4274516106,
-0.8344708085,
0.8458533287,
-0.0915001407,
-0.6444760561,
0.1365460604,
0.0938515663,
0.3369856477,
0.6258188486,
-0.6084592342,
1.1096662283,
-0.4209136069,
-0.2294856012,
-0.1380024552,
-0.7129078507,
0.2290488034,
0.1358809173,
0.3600752652,
-0.1121578738,
0.1887736768,
0.0941885188,
-0.2807037234,
0.8491516113,
-0.1171717644,
0.3166009486,
0.1773232967,
0.4436918497,
0.2464913726,
-0.117933616,
0.0965470895,
0.4137102664,
-0.0247862674,
-0.5272817016,
-0.7049700618,
0.4694377184,
-0.622303009,
-0.221884042,
-0.5403637886,
-0.8925056458,
-0.0000982985,
0.3717437983,
0.517726779,
0.252101779,
-0.2637495697,
0.26662606,
0.5677284598,
-0.1695414931,
0.4629735351,
-0.01091439,
-0.8383929729,
-0.5425693989,
1.0832718611,
-0.1179851741,
0.2878419161,
0.6130053401,
-0.1255823076,
-0.3547715545,
-0.438460201,
-1.1181678772,
0.1706508994,
-0.728049159,
-0.0455058627,
-0.8250057101,
-0.2929443419,
-0.3736925423,
-0.2293792814,
-0.6437733769,
-0.3719197512,
-0.1237287894,
-0.0264672618,
0.1234971806,
0.5251324177,
0.31411466,
0.3657165468,
-0.7145375609,
0.5241779685,
0.1238200739,
-0.1640516967,
-0.313587755,
-0.5540750027,
-0.2334715575,
0.2367315143,
-0.295601666,
-0.9730666876,
0.7373995185,
0.1761872172,
0.3417968452,
0.4942171872,
-0.0001665689,
0.9157976508,
-0.6640202403,
0.7032693028,
0.447526902,
-0.7758527994,
0.382995218,
-0.2375341952,
0.4097780287,
0.3941056728,
0.1692392081,
-0.5345511436,
-0.230425626,
-0.1353850067,
-0.7304831743,
0.5166514516,
0.545141995,
-0.0349188074,
-0.0183377005,
0.1835040897,
0.1057482064,
0.4505195916,
-0.9636889696,
-0.1169198379,
-0.9032952189,
-0.1663948894,
-0.2427684665,
-0.0113687525,
0.0687530041,
-0.439602077,
0.3077978194,
-0.3753226697,
0.4922779799,
0.1300058961,
-0.7012999058,
0.128876701,
0.1931159198,
0.4855619967,
0.4036573768,
-0.0625618547,
0.2774110734,
-0.0539056659,
-0.2278038859,
0.1300429404,
-0.0996330008,
-0.2419053018,
0.2839304507,
0.1914114505,
1.0372241735,
0.4915220737,
-0.3305362761,
0.6392253041,
0.124335669,
-0.2261611968,
0.0350504331,
-0.2130321264,
-0.0098878276,
0.3219034076,
0.2772454619,
0.2111018747,
0.0755814835,
-0.444778949,
0.347342968,
0.3699555695,
-0.7489786148,
-0.3229571283,
0.6950929165,
-0.1536536068,
-0.3039347529,
0.8274385333,
-0.4074424803,
-0.3652199507,
0.2091699392,
0.565353632,
0.8867691159,
-0.2603676021,
0.6013334394,
0.1714448333,
0.4622543752,
0.1147316918,
-0.1138442382,
-0.0901594758,
-0.503313899,
-0.362955451,
-0.5419409871,
-0.3064245582,
-0.1014945507,
-0.6293624043,
-0.0233094003,
-0.0333104953,
0.0494297445,
-0.3354048133,
-0.6112782359,
-0.458712697,
0.1731984615,
-0.0993030518,
0.3403987885,
-0.7225964069,
1.061055541,
0.8802405596,
-0.5449117422,
-0.1278115213,
0.1476971507,
-0.0722524971,
-0.8670625687,
0.5363075733,
0.4519487023,
-0.2622929215,
0.0285112597,
-0.4561308622,
-0.537612617,
1.0932871103,
0.4141544402,
-0.3028695285,
-0.15366292,
0.4267012477,
0.3876147866,
-0.5043660402,
0.0057946877,
0.0379431769,
0.3662240803,
0.4674046338,
-0.5835819244,
-0.1694732308,
-0.3768917918,
0.1472412646,
0.1741766185,
-0.3827395141,
0.7204247713,
-0.2011284381,
-0.2323570102,
-0.0296463799,
0.8417838216,
-0.0562994853,
0.5550934672,
0.4392497241,
0.4120507836,
0.4725969136,
-0.1830100566,
0.9321443439,
-0.2502421439,
0.1098711342,
1.0667911768,
-0.0282997526,
0.725933075,
0.7761303782,
0.0627511144,
0.2547457516,
0.6573781371,
0.0337526985,
0.8303253651,
-0.3234070241,
0.0106758606,
-0.5032574534,
0.0637447834,
-0.3612959385,
0.3658216596,
0.3495621085,
-0.4131882191,
-0.3984874189,
0.3284490705,
-0.0516506806,
-0.0226809178,
-0.0810396001,
0.6491463184,
0.2786259949,
-0.4854584932,
0.3142507374,
-0.0155653125,
0.1329647303,
-0.4453337491,
-0.057662636,
-0.2856578827,
0.1365115941,
-0.0094293999,
-0.6756637096,
0.4188677073,
-0.0518323779,
-0.1745415479,
-0.3579408526,
0.335871309,
-0.5669665933,
-0.839607954,
0.2828704119,
0.7171316743,
0.5452060103,
-0.5580748916,
-0.7070246339,
-0.1328865588,
0.1784408838,
-0.2506440282,
0.58541435,
0.8851316571,
-0.3288907409,
0.695677042,
0.6484735012,
-0.2506376505,
0.3221492767,
-0.0578370616,
0.7348055243,
-0.5708614588,
-0.3670108616,
-0.7078757286,
0.6003296971,
0.0351586081,
-0.0610064417,
0.7029262185,
0.5854946971,
0.7171931863,
-0.1772172153,
0.4214020073,
0.2261624634,
-0.1651025414,
-0.7380124331,
0.7757967114,
-0.7138010263,
-0.0564085245,
-0.5297181606,
-1.0157217979,
-0.5010764003,
0.7427775264,
-0.2254777849,
-0.2437231243,
1.103898406,
0.7261533737,
-0.299251914,
-0.1596033275,
0.7820280194,
0.0598733313,
0.1424330622,
0.24295412,
0.5483856797,
-0.4564128816,
0.845674634,
-0.294349432,
-0.1229429618,
-0.1409938931,
-0.8109452724,
-1.0433146954,
-0.7924041152,
-0.301386863,
-0.270032227,
0.0627456605,
0.577375114,
0.6047918797,
-0.7102711797,
-0.2453650683,
-0.0023228819,
0.0788112879,
-0.3263393342,
-0.1438706964,
0.3817099333,
-0.4757795036,
-0.80036062,
0.5806930661,
0.5907431841,
0.1029907241,
-0.0885455981,
-0.1761169434,
-0.1884708554,
-0.2032327801,
0.9270627499,
-0.1072032005,
-0.7803933024,
-0.0210550688,
0.1836968958,
-0.0454629175,
0.4752147198,
0.7613016367,
-0.4937806427,
0.609354794,
0.1425917596,
0.5903865695,
0.9851101637,
0.0024870848,
0.3708049059,
-0.6293029189,
0.5580758452,
-0.264134258,
0.4234873354,
0.3317185044,
-0.1692154258,
0.4675461352,
0.4773564041,
-0.2987284064,
-0.8093179464,
0.2915074825,
-1.0024886131,
-0.5168026686,
0.7965710759,
-0.1212380826,
-0.40320912,
0.0591822006,
-0.2954342067,
0.5098859668,
-0.3137416542,
0.5751718879,
0.5400621295,
-0.286033839,
-0.5426370502,
-0.6031700373,
0.0749348849,
0.2102721334,
-0.7297545075,
-0.1256722063,
0.6778780818,
-0.1852629483,
0.1593858302,
0.3802616596,
-0.3666957915,
0.0016784201,
-0.0469482206,
0.3287999034,
-0.2599545717,
-0.6209774017,
-0.0175457895,
0.3288444579,
-0.4019774497,
-0.5778202415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12248v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12248v1 | Brain encoding models based on multimodal transformers can transfer across language and vision | 2023-05-20T17:38:44 | 2023-05-20T17:38:44 | Jerry Tang, Meng Du, Vy A. Vo, Vasudev Lal, Alexander G. Huth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Encoding models have been used to assess how the human brain represents
concepts in language and vision. While language and vision rely on similar
concept representations, current encoding models are typically trained and
tested on brain responses to each modality in isolation. Recent advances in
multimodal pretraining have produced transformers that can extract aligned
representations of concepts in language and vision. In this work, we used
representations from multimodal transformers to train encoding models that can
transfer across fMRI responses to stories and movies. We found that encoding
models trained on brain responses to one modality can successfully predict
brain responses to the other modality, particularly in cortical regions that
represent conceptual meaning. Further analysis of these encoding models
revealed shared semantic dimensions that underlie concept representations in
language and vision. Comparing encoding models trained using representations
from multimodal and unimodal transformers, we found that multimodal
transformers learn more aligned representations of concepts in language and
vision. Our results demonstrate how multimodal transformers can provide
insights into the brain's capacity for multimodal processing. | [
-0.5757534504,
-0.2115346193,
0.5572602153,
0.0431067534,
-0.1378181279,
0.0519517586,
-0.1436605901,
-0.5044654012,
0.0906432942,
0.2532327175,
-0.5935180187,
0.2528855801,
-0.8521523476,
-0.0288804714,
-0.3642616272,
0.7887880206,
-0.0504788943,
0.3847406507,
-0.5253815055,
-0.3177068233,
-0.6912782192,
-0.7556859851,
-0.1529867947,
-0.4899289906,
0.5593121648,
-0.227114588,
0.5984130502,
0.2899170816,
0.8799912333,
0.2828243375,
0.4761424363,
-0.0383909084,
-0.0644747987,
-0.1292827278,
-0.3572998643,
-0.6583672166,
-0.1829725504,
0.0823698938,
0.586273849,
0.5793141127,
-0.0852436125,
0.1764254719,
0.0024044367,
0.1278811693,
-0.6404072046,
0.3357100189,
-0.548317194,
0.1460788399,
0.2791645527,
-0.469799757,
-0.7036821842,
0.0761683956,
0.0935958922,
-0.6905312538,
0.2309740931,
-0.0874397382,
0.967820406,
0.4421780109,
-0.8206968904,
-0.188259989,
-0.7199775577,
0.5735037923,
-0.1033218428,
0.7277303338,
0.2015291452,
0.2663221955,
0.3015772402,
-0.739931345,
-0.9760523438,
-0.1052157506,
-0.5569067001,
0.3119874001,
-0.1527136415,
0.0049002441,
0.3532080948,
-0.1374660879,
-0.3184640706,
-0.1434468031,
-0.5621054173,
-0.3911601901,
0.4672470689,
0.151354298,
0.5271551013,
-0.5109826922,
-0.8533485532,
-0.8066973686,
0.0174022987,
0.1517823935,
-0.1398955733,
-0.1829582155,
-0.2647542655,
0.6512428522,
0.4305915236,
0.5031458139,
0.0008342873,
-0.2952585518,
0.5409125686,
-0.6238803267,
0.0822234899,
0.0213137586,
0.6782449484,
0.6727408767,
0.3042221665,
-0.3471162915,
-0.1508615762,
0.721595943,
0.7466682196,
-0.5007631779,
-0.0474363975,
-0.2459272593,
-0.5956807733,
0.1240244731,
0.1137704328,
-0.8061931729,
-0.3401137292,
-0.4034221768,
0.8776103258,
-0.6633049846,
-0.4000967145,
0.2489139438,
-0.5274258852,
0.4260496199,
0.1442268044,
-1.2424356937,
-0.0090402607,
0.2745703161,
0.549102664,
-0.2351120412,
-0.6675394773,
-0.1114095747,
0.6093874574,
-0.2357383519,
0.897775054,
-0.6012768745,
0.059089452,
-0.086948581,
0.0360988639,
-0.4840537012,
-0.1430428177,
0.171639964,
-0.6422998309,
0.012964705,
-0.1150358245,
-0.1605304182,
-0.2742759883,
0.1683742404,
-0.9610218406,
0.2809556723,
0.0675808787,
-0.6652776003,
0.5044476986,
-0.5498879552,
-0.4127676487,
-0.2719569504,
-0.4083370864,
-0.0817062929,
0.6590549946,
0.4294553399,
0.4151753783,
-0.1808590591,
0.1808689535,
-0.2304285467,
-0.1225880384,
0.7596899867,
-0.5583548546,
0.3790113628,
0.3305113912,
0.2039861977,
0.0500130504,
-0.5639910698,
-0.1168147922,
0.0661221668,
-0.142198056,
-0.3163703084,
-0.1702712774,
0.0202928297,
0.4015106857,
0.1494414657,
-0.5898294449,
-0.1423186064,
0.0983056501,
0.4790924191,
0.5325967669,
-0.1460131407,
0.7551308274,
-0.2751665413,
0.4194748104,
0.6258728504,
-0.0878586695,
-0.5555331111,
-0.1310218275,
-0.7954087257,
-0.2222057134,
0.0795915499,
0.3487445116,
-0.9767290354,
-0.0049304566,
-0.6714065671,
-0.1160091832,
-0.7795452476,
-0.3863863945,
0.0167142097,
0.3158096969,
0.5202097297,
-0.7634072304,
-0.4066238403,
-1.0824446678,
-0.031243233,
-0.1258380264,
-0.1929120123,
-0.016628135,
0.5111997128,
-0.2559037805,
0.9721359015,
-0.4270058274,
-0.4216599762,
-0.2044508755,
0.4252412915,
-0.1073783562,
0.4355937839,
0.6270971894,
-0.9399021864,
0.0130637325,
0.2189880013,
-1.0231702328,
0.4647562206,
-0.5326721668,
0.1118354946,
-0.1159065813,
0.4055110216,
-0.7068738341,
0.1304558963,
0.685400784,
-0.409373939,
0.1419913024,
-0.3671820462,
0.3396476805,
-1.2027045488,
-0.0865007937,
-0.2070470452,
0.0027638602,
-0.3502711356,
-0.0321524628,
0.405818671,
-0.0740447715,
-0.3849877119,
0.3262032866,
-0.4127966166,
-0.295252353,
0.0228783581,
0.0022260279,
0.2169514596,
0.8325064182,
0.2971164584,
0.7637917995,
0.7498092651,
-0.4721666276,
0.4884935319,
0.4836138785,
-0.5218091011,
0.805162251,
-0.4873875082,
0.2316630483,
-0.6586794853,
0.2497880906,
-0.9788136482,
-0.3764169812,
-0.1687174141,
-0.4544485807,
0.3581806719,
0.182561174,
-0.3978815675,
-0.2533173561,
0.0840927064,
0.4964275956,
0.4431683421,
-0.3470679224,
1.2309765816,
0.2354136556,
0.1968735456,
-0.566560626,
-0.9882878065,
-0.1816621274,
-0.1708277315,
-0.4680271447,
0.463375479,
0.0185277332,
0.2853170037,
0.1069121435,
-0.1376207322,
-0.3394456506,
-0.2178379595,
0.2557784319,
0.3604179621,
-0.2608875334,
0.2222802639,
-0.0710717589,
-0.1905400008,
0.2463403493,
-0.0070340233,
0.5346804261,
0.0838645324,
-0.6003642082,
-0.3807601929,
0.3901146054,
0.9227228165,
-0.5508403182,
0.8844938874,
1.1798682213,
-0.2436710894,
0.2577714324,
-0.3882969618,
-0.5267134309,
-0.384942174,
0.8599438667,
-0.7734608054,
-0.745844245,
0.3096351624,
-0.1076978222,
-0.2432404757,
0.30756405,
0.5770499706,
-0.3194868863,
1.214241147,
0.9681626558,
0.3656119406,
0.4733676016,
-0.2692317069,
0.2047678977,
-0.9831727147,
-0.5091428161,
-0.1740315706,
-0.4869278967,
-0.1279795021,
-0.5299138427,
0.3557926118,
-0.0108921947,
0.1010449231,
0.507574141,
-0.1955019832,
0.6519221067,
0.4179816246,
0.1257712096,
0.4257994592,
0.3241146207,
-0.3540760279,
-0.199287653,
-0.6124225259,
-0.3389168978,
0.9163940549,
0.4042986035,
0.889066577,
-0.0275358539,
0.0814271942,
0.0233489983,
0.305008024,
-0.5882528424,
0.3436109722,
-0.192310974,
-0.7599439025,
0.1549020559,
-0.1450368613,
-0.6493373513,
0.378874898,
-0.6196414232,
-0.5794655085,
0.4559769928,
-0.2338172644,
-0.5600888729,
0.2766588628,
-1.0513609648,
0.9516150355,
-0.2827355862,
0.0481676944,
-0.662714839,
-0.6782661676,
0.3011959195,
-0.3357731998,
0.006269977,
0.1230854094,
0.0195789747,
0.5761594772,
0.4401652813,
0.7937614322,
0.3326966166,
-0.034193743,
0.0273035038,
0.005299611,
-0.2429247946,
0.1353024095,
0.3070233464,
0.3654182255,
0.2662504017,
-0.1947556734,
-0.8533516526,
0.422737211,
-1.206156373,
-0.3562184274,
-0.4422813654,
-0.944856286,
-0.2181726247,
0.0827813074,
0.3930788934,
0.5148755908,
-0.1084982604,
0.203957811,
0.4526726007,
-0.126362741,
0.6382906437,
0.2468976527,
-0.1890100241,
-0.2815884948,
0.6386942267,
-0.0260513499,
0.4331343472,
0.692858398,
-0.3294760585,
-0.443038404,
-0.3015393019,
-0.3132429421,
0.0856045708,
-0.9190353751,
-0.1849700212,
-0.779807806,
-0.3134829104,
-0.2059076875,
-0.092601724,
-0.4139063358,
-0.2485324889,
0.0904546082,
-0.0429777838,
0.1506771445,
0.6496561766,
-0.1351287961,
0.270704031,
-1.091950655,
0.6339339614,
0.732054472,
0.2893812954,
0.1362006515,
-0.3979140222,
-0.3639244735,
0.3020552993,
-0.366938144,
-0.7647749186,
0.3209221959,
0.2865065932,
0.4589446485,
0.2201151252,
-0.1957811415,
0.7705198526,
-0.6171421409,
0.644526124,
0.823603332,
-0.7642831206,
0.1894170195,
0.1100080088,
0.4270313382,
0.2347122282,
0.6647827625,
-0.581155479,
0.0964098126,
-0.2230843008,
-0.06859909,
0.8982067704,
0.1071818769,
0.5423645377,
0.0028384833,
-0.0239472445,
0.1953274906,
0.1106485724,
-0.7503193617,
0.0215955358,
-0.653627038,
-0.1694128364,
-0.3751988709,
0.0148713421,
-0.2994719744,
-0.3166952431,
-0.323315531,
-0.1667806357,
0.978071928,
0.1165683344,
-0.4204767346,
-0.0781062245,
0.2020629793,
0.3450746238,
0.4440504014,
-0.0600625761,
0.5778627992,
0.184262082,
-0.521260798,
0.2304974198,
-0.1110828146,
0.3447934091,
0.0033317024,
0.6107903123,
1.2123551369,
-0.020021446,
-0.5331092477,
0.5460377336,
-0.3626072407,
-0.0004292277,
-0.2043532878,
0.0498917401,
0.2494664788,
0.466655612,
0.231085822,
0.779358685,
-0.2854379714,
-0.7238622904,
0.3702221215,
0.3624165654,
-0.4327828586,
-0.7423471808,
0.7314525247,
-0.037314292,
-0.015240347,
0.9074610472,
0.3169030845,
-0.3166294992,
0.4725544453,
0.8534947038,
0.619369626,
-0.1097871214,
0.1721387804,
0.5035288334,
0.2344153821,
0.1576720476,
-0.0349413864,
-0.0572088212,
-1.311909914,
-0.6711749434,
-0.7961614728,
0.0314388908,
-0.0399785526,
-0.763528645,
0.1790814996,
-0.1933158338,
-0.3727515936,
0.1792289019,
-0.7316347361,
-0.9726628065,
0.1419480741,
0.6161309481,
0.4470523596,
-0.8887731433,
1.1330020428,
0.8689264655,
-0.8482426405,
-0.8291741014,
-0.2008021176,
-0.3857323825,
-0.8621476293,
0.9293987751,
0.2019015551,
-0.1825970113,
0.0776233375,
-0.2533281744,
-1.0021044016,
1.0366121531,
0.6155385375,
-0.3592837751,
-0.3893017769,
0.4332824945,
0.5477737784,
-0.6814219356,
0.4316770732,
0.4097343683,
0.2843446136,
0.2630328238,
-1.0763422251,
-0.137892738,
-0.1789193898,
0.1865053773,
0.0818358883,
-0.3037874997,
0.8439048529,
-0.2928866446,
-0.4001642168,
-0.1911459267,
0.6819296479,
-0.0605946817,
-0.0253889114,
0.2760854363,
0.5357650518,
0.2021767795,
-0.1324494034,
1.0694897175,
-0.2677744627,
0.2565005422,
0.7344195843,
-0.0874589458,
0.8735230565,
0.7326254845,
0.0862427577,
0.6792236567,
0.1749669611,
-0.0168804191,
0.813047111,
-0.3789356351,
0.0004112114,
-0.4703907669,
-0.3546990454,
-0.2781459093,
0.7698985934,
0.2800546885,
-0.3328910172,
-0.1157848239,
0.6954027414,
-0.4298912287,
-0.0563744381,
-0.2297490388,
0.7178779244,
0.2581553459,
-0.8566115499,
0.5594244599,
-0.2254983336,
0.8435495496,
-0.7697518468,
-0.000063046,
-0.0282793883,
0.4532269835,
0.0533501729,
-0.7715678215,
0.4615880847,
-0.4607744515,
-0.311878413,
-0.5910100937,
0.5914410353,
-0.5249282718,
-0.279926002,
0.3315584958,
0.3966384828,
-0.1692410558,
0.1381425411,
-0.4422305226,
0.0363956504,
-0.0871702433,
0.1088267565,
0.4715590775,
0.2800243199,
-0.0323072039,
0.537504673,
0.5169762969,
-0.1534153521,
0.3723043501,
0.0886785462,
0.6295128465,
-0.7116155624,
-0.4558011889,
-0.661028266,
0.5233673453,
0.1125113666,
-0.2597965002,
0.435464263,
0.0316584632,
1.1253092289,
-0.7125254273,
0.3977954984,
-0.1992598772,
-0.2105215639,
-0.675552249,
0.6238576174,
-0.6476498246,
-0.3249396086,
-0.0558802299,
-1.0223190784,
-0.1942557693,
0.9219159484,
-0.0707164556,
-0.0775234476,
1.2698535919,
0.6594959497,
-0.3010572493,
-0.0056175496,
0.4016628563,
0.0638275445,
0.0553543828,
0.8480443954,
1.0501850843,
-0.3716367185,
0.5388838053,
-0.2174057066,
0.1021175385,
0.1822157204,
-0.5407685041,
-0.9137408733,
-0.9937737584,
-0.1988913864,
0.0254473966,
-0.3013376296,
0.6360929608,
0.8893918395,
-0.5037186146,
-0.2255634218,
0.2933567762,
-0.3353022933,
-0.4969254136,
-0.1223854348,
0.2537522316,
-0.3232645094,
-0.680247128,
0.1939782202,
0.3658496737,
0.1266513169,
-0.5462677479,
-0.032957036,
-0.1961075068,
0.064505972,
0.7565472126,
-0.3737251163,
-0.6263485551,
-0.5085923672,
0.2242428809,
-0.3891914189,
0.2726238072,
1.0770038366,
-1.0511870384,
0.5126593113,
0.5487696528,
0.5857981443,
0.612123847,
-0.3898994625,
0.7882086635,
-0.6603277326,
0.3838378787,
0.0774799064,
0.4979938567,
0.2791544199,
-0.0464330055,
0.2748995125,
0.0896316692,
0.0633255094,
-0.421425879,
0.5041958094,
-1.245277524,
-0.2885347009,
0.7923778892,
0.0304724593,
-0.3318917155,
0.0894548669,
-0.1360287368,
0.3423738182,
-0.0012811563,
0.6683886051,
0.9577022791,
-0.0305888616,
-0.5098541379,
-0.380589515,
0.1983668506,
0.4654324949,
-0.506927669,
-0.2523694634,
0.2439835221,
0.1334385276,
0.7830819488,
0.225960061,
-0.3174152672,
0.2985007763,
0.2256666869,
0.2024569958,
0.0237584803,
-0.443826288,
-0.2728372812,
0.3368957341,
-0.2469201237,
-0.2823417187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12233v1 | A Measure of Explanatory Effectiveness | 2023-05-20T16:52:30 | 2023-05-20T16:52:30 | Dylan Cope, Peter McBurney | cs.CL | cs.CL | In most conversations about explanation and AI, the recipient of the
explanation (the explainee) is suspiciously absent, despite the problem being
ultimately communicative in nature. We pose the problem `explaining AI systems'
in terms of a two-player cooperative game in which each agent seeks to maximise
our proposed measure of explanatory effectiveness. This measure serves as a
foundation for the automated assessment of explanations, in terms of the
effects that any given action in the game has on the internal state of the
explainee. | [
-0.4703199863,
-0.9764310122,
0.6080856919,
0.4131683707,
-0.1339876652,
0.014983926,
-0.2677331567,
-0.471069932,
0.4319849014,
-0.2051498443,
-0.4260208011,
0.1351011246,
-0.8989157081,
0.0144100711,
-0.5514577627,
0.9796991944,
0.0078791017,
-0.1468184143,
-0.3532269597,
-0.3691770732,
-0.6918032169,
-0.0392781906,
-1.0941369534,
-0.769430697,
0.3212197721,
0.6943270564,
1.1137385368,
0.6313923597,
0.6454677582,
0.4643279314,
-0.0041625826,
-0.1335701942,
-0.6201774478,
0.4174669385,
-0.2620795071,
-1.0166801214,
-0.0996553153,
0.2017952353,
0.6601523161,
0.9033945203,
-0.1880805045,
0.2167481482,
0.1456975639,
0.3207648098,
-0.6309243441,
0.3302400112,
-0.1413856298,
0.0678386465,
0.3471624553,
-0.307861656,
-0.1481489688,
-0.1983558387,
0.5595237613,
-0.7684448957,
-0.0165350325,
-0.1101223975,
0.7777213454,
0.3064379394,
-0.193516463,
-0.8216663003,
-1.1335996389,
0.5719140172,
-0.2946632802,
-0.1640687138,
0.3361563981,
0.5129337311,
-0.2221937478,
-0.5920492411,
-0.8494293094,
-0.1685076207,
-0.1459311098,
0.6348060966,
-0.5779822469,
0.0533182435,
0.1793995947,
0.3658999205,
-0.259429127,
0.1051690653,
-0.1657654494,
-0.0883494318,
0.7722965479,
0.2488187999,
0.4361945689,
0.2565696836,
-0.4082238376,
0.1229380891,
-0.1330664903,
0.49082762,
0.1865828186,
-0.4411564171,
-0.3720045984,
0.5422644615,
0.2358467281,
0.2866973281,
0.2372672707,
0.0824420005,
-0.34290573,
-0.6899604201,
-0.2814993858,
-0.2395911068,
0.4704478383,
0.4254403114,
-0.2455080748,
-0.3409386575,
-0.2102437615,
0.3719702661,
-0.1641413122,
-0.2973739505,
-0.3631839156,
0.4747981727,
-0.7099175453,
-0.1889972538,
0.2427786738,
-0.8148349524,
-0.2453552485,
-0.1158569902,
0.7989434004,
-0.0363456272,
-0.5794888139,
-0.5883844495,
-0.8934214711,
0.3450846076,
0.2052725106,
-1.0038926601,
0.4717590213,
0.6959828734,
0.8542333245,
-0.091905795,
-0.4032565355,
-0.5636220574,
0.1650767624,
-0.4844070375,
0.9666185379,
-0.312720716,
-0.5346294641,
-0.3919730783,
0.0436017402,
-0.0543655828,
-0.5112678409,
0.2235860974,
-0.0271681789,
0.5602450371,
-0.2104925364,
-0.8607898355,
-0.1894797236,
0.1394483149,
-0.5036206245,
0.6452901363,
0.1869616956,
-0.2085961252,
0.5362945795,
-1.2281509638,
-0.2970766723,
0.2417583913,
-0.1324897557,
-0.2234862596,
0.4878585935,
-0.1638492793,
0.0066781994,
-0.0757000223,
0.2082643956,
0.1121289432,
-0.7900677323,
0.564025104,
-0.5946228504,
0.918125689,
0.1924743354,
-0.7812206745,
0.2957670093,
-0.4874629676,
0.1442601681,
0.2330871373,
-0.072990939,
-0.2253040969,
0.1231347769,
-0.4938325286,
0.0039003862,
0.2397265285,
-0.17234613,
-0.3068886101,
-0.5242573619,
0.4852423668,
0.6556349993,
0.1646252126,
0.6907711029,
-0.6097447872,
0.7507791519,
-0.4016775489,
0.4985693097,
-0.5150165558,
-0.6875504851,
-0.6664744616,
-0.4365833998,
0.0149487043,
0.4921601415,
-0.4916194379,
0.2200552672,
0.0049061682,
-0.3611091971,
-0.3927530646,
-0.1812911779,
0.5398789644,
0.129001826,
-0.0595446751,
-0.278777957,
-0.10523431,
-1.0130974054,
-0.1431546956,
-0.5821397901,
0.0904334784,
0.3709433377,
0.6183534265,
0.2321424782,
0.7875437737,
-0.0658290088,
0.0964765996,
-0.4970682561,
0.450951159,
-0.0085523613,
0.2976796031,
0.2921786308,
-1.1060378551,
-0.4970055521,
-0.2976644337,
-1.1165661812,
0.03930014,
-0.4343444705,
-0.0614888556,
0.0096354596,
0.2948879004,
-0.6369307041,
0.7452310324,
0.3371701241,
-0.4663015604,
0.5786876082,
-0.6302068233,
0.2115059793,
-0.6996716261,
0.186682716,
-0.2854775786,
-0.0759904832,
-0.730435133,
0.5066918731,
-0.4296737015,
0.0472230129,
-0.0984907597,
0.3816150725,
-0.8083106875,
-0.2462617159,
-0.3877437413,
0.7066967487,
0.1726147979,
0.3075905442,
-0.1380057335,
0.6205233335,
0.6351752281,
-0.7346785665,
0.6060171127,
0.2756851912,
-0.0296783801,
1.1093695164,
-0.9676253796,
0.0197354946,
-0.1230769604,
0.0931814611,
-1.4339872599,
-0.4924378097,
0.3859061301,
-0.7800291777,
-0.0491302311,
0.3086086214,
-0.1120229065,
-0.609787643,
-0.134975642,
0.0780155212,
0.441432178,
-0.5532178283,
0.6167404652,
0.2785030901,
-0.037663687,
-0.4376806617,
-0.6024523973,
0.2659342289,
-0.5594380498,
-0.7485693693,
0.0875153765,
-0.2518732548,
-0.8386206627,
0.1354551464,
-0.0786863342,
-0.407987833,
0.7246801257,
0.4475506842,
0.0050684391,
-0.2784440517,
0.3838115633,
-0.0661263689,
-0.2797193229,
0.5490275621,
0.3677400053,
0.2179643363,
0.0269785803,
-0.5181222558,
-0.9443172812,
0.943838954,
0.5562850237,
0.0298836473,
0.9391457438,
0.2902630866,
-0.2133071274,
-0.0814161822,
-0.0754925534,
-0.2210606188,
-0.4463286698,
0.4803272486,
-0.6144453883,
-0.2884482443,
0.8807384968,
-0.1780163646,
-0.0898919702,
0.5193977952,
0.3394930959,
-0.1499696672,
1.4566628933,
0.6393342614,
0.2212081254,
0.1916873455,
-0.2013822198,
0.2707594931,
-0.5277283192,
-0.5754179955,
-0.6486113667,
-0.389072448,
-0.5757066607,
0.0259680208,
0.3800927997,
0.4205185473,
-0.1085579097,
0.0808939636,
-0.5385586023,
0.6891415715,
0.9681965709,
-0.0349971317,
0.2554201782,
-0.3107890189,
0.3555108905,
0.1506759375,
-0.7857385874,
-0.4361100793,
0.6448276639,
0.4057607949,
0.4494416416,
0.6711684465,
0.8179474473,
0.2821904719,
0.1051497757,
-0.8174384236,
0.3402724564,
0.6629442573,
-0.669346571,
-0.7410367131,
-0.3327266574,
-1.2113522291,
0.0983454138,
-0.4977999628,
-0.8075746894,
0.0731259733,
0.1339785159,
-0.5468348265,
-0.1787202209,
-1.1288045645,
0.8173984885,
-0.2672770023,
-0.3299776912,
-0.5812447071,
-0.8175978661,
0.2401238084,
0.1215400696,
0.2310589403,
0.2656561136,
-0.1282396019,
0.8783831,
-0.3913590014,
0.5460968614,
-0.4766983092,
0.0429896601,
0.5697455406,
-0.032814756,
0.650557816,
-0.0535011142,
0.0703156367,
-0.0624888577,
0.088898018,
-0.6990087032,
-1.0778478384,
0.1908383518,
-0.734205842,
-0.8936323524,
-0.2272985429,
-0.5334529281,
0.2306584269,
-0.1146317869,
0.4962882698,
0.3681860566,
-0.5222141147,
0.0162451454,
0.3310417533,
-0.502594173,
0.5728945732,
0.5291570425,
0.0475983359,
0.1348750144,
1.0041087866,
0.081889689,
0.5724775195,
0.0372334681,
0.3397740126,
-0.2403727323,
-0.5590043664,
-0.4984849095,
-0.1107604951,
-0.8162299395,
0.386126101,
-0.3973506093,
0.0009281075,
0.0559626631,
-0.3116956651,
0.011501329,
-0.5730445981,
-0.2104979008,
0.0309097748,
-0.1767227203,
1.2776446342,
-0.61898458,
0.7593907714,
-0.2381148785,
0.2263059467,
0.469976753,
0.0466588177,
0.1278480291,
-0.4473645389,
-0.183488667,
0.2790531516,
-0.2178878933,
-0.9998980165,
0.12066333,
0.3921521306,
1.0308667421,
0.8341790438,
-0.2799004614,
0.685025394,
0.1168755963,
1.1076176167,
0.3344396949,
-1.1793932915,
0.6757057905,
-0.0167911202,
0.3116496503,
0.2225874513,
0.047873985,
-0.4523844719,
-0.8863521218,
-0.8682716489,
-0.7886747718,
0.742566824,
0.3888494372,
0.012269306,
-0.2677862644,
0.3497065604,
0.3710816205,
0.182998687,
-0.4752223194,
-0.7317698002,
0.201598227,
0.0252920911,
-0.1082073078,
-0.2290684581,
-0.3487531245,
0.1530718654,
0.6577570438,
0.1364261657,
0.9044689536,
0.248635307,
0.0312123504,
-0.4789737761,
0.2403664738,
0.8364599943,
1.1017225981,
0.121428445,
0.3820691407,
-0.1229137033,
-0.0505723618,
0.2646570504,
0.0788700208,
0.0207100995,
0.038161952,
0.954939723,
0.545958817,
-0.1885962933,
-0.3863527477,
0.768393755,
-0.1590200365,
-0.1455229372,
-0.3442626297,
0.3808394074,
-0.0787374973,
0.4657794833,
0.5449595451,
0.322450459,
0.3752620816,
-0.9797136188,
0.2731303275,
0.8459354639,
-0.575086236,
-0.4628169537,
0.7057135701,
0.3094031215,
-0.9175674915,
0.3513554037,
-0.3939931989,
-0.5600827336,
1.330722928,
0.7514465451,
0.4540592432,
-0.1809887737,
0.7235289216,
0.0698689371,
0.3304960132,
0.0320123807,
0.1707680523,
-0.2301964164,
-0.4270607233,
-0.4189044535,
0.2078454792,
-0.6613803506,
-0.1398936361,
-0.9087516069,
-0.1862206459,
0.0048616854,
0.0176083613,
0.4574336112,
0.019561002,
-0.6759144664,
-0.0008470836,
-0.1236295253,
0.7294127345,
-0.9105327725,
0.0157040451,
0.3209695518,
-0.6169604659,
-0.9818193316,
-0.1751272678,
-0.0556274205,
-1.0886836052,
0.5199753046,
-0.07379926,
-0.02733225,
-0.0848395899,
-0.859338522,
-0.7064759731,
0.9490434527,
0.2156024128,
-0.451249212,
0.3096041381,
-0.0917139128,
0.9172192216,
-0.3506405354,
0.9746428132,
0.4773594439,
0.8086473346,
-0.1340950727,
-1.1175807714,
-0.1351849437,
-0.3527374864,
-0.4254883528,
0.1145721823,
-0.8386695981,
0.3802464008,
-0.5831037164,
-0.5289807916,
0.4714547098,
0.6546541452,
-0.3914789557,
1.0382635593,
0.5750461817,
0.1665970981,
1.1173119545,
-0.2255758643,
1.3419953585,
0.0349891447,
0.0547380745,
1.1267536879,
0.1115069613,
0.4140295982,
0.4870554507,
-0.1670022458,
0.5006011128,
0.5378375053,
0.1322419941,
0.4446183443,
0.3397624791,
-0.1810901761,
-0.0378891714,
-0.3143277764,
-0.1752081215,
0.8669957519,
0.3421058059,
-0.5389481187,
-0.0959343091,
0.260803014,
-0.1422636509,
0.1453567147,
-0.168682456,
1.068811059,
-0.2146098912,
-1.1008068323,
0.3491838872,
-0.4043300152,
0.0524887256,
-0.2744543254,
-0.3794691265,
-0.515078485,
0.1796718538,
-0.0048269625,
-0.9513988495,
0.3926026523,
-0.4855380058,
-0.3357277513,
0.3315277696,
0.2953075767,
-0.586851716,
0.018335769,
0.4415159225,
1.0398197174,
0.7304008007,
0.1603787988,
-0.7292353511,
-0.1210838333,
-0.1578165442,
0.0249732099,
-0.0724771991,
0.7305196524,
-0.0703204125,
0.7648761272,
0.2379541993,
0.0537179783,
-0.1952458322,
-0.2590281665,
0.4526723325,
-0.3959702551,
-0.6171375513,
-1.0684722662,
0.2827824652,
-0.3380894065,
-0.285585016,
1.0936845541,
0.4401652813,
0.1720553339,
0.3657828569,
0.8245980144,
-0.2002086192,
0.2814794481,
0.1078806445,
0.4301736951,
-0.437730968,
0.2591994703,
-0.0777724385,
-1.0630823374,
0.0559516922,
0.6670075655,
0.1257312745,
-0.0342673473,
0.758035481,
0.4193468392,
0.1926716417,
0.5789531469,
0.3649218082,
0.3928316534,
0.1597997099,
0.7026430964,
1.2757638693,
-0.1553476453,
0.4535764158,
-0.008532878,
-0.9440969825,
0.0017611748,
-0.5672982335,
-0.9190450907,
-0.4716178477,
-0.4436493516,
-0.2508059442,
0.4303159714,
0.6724442244,
0.7934694886,
-0.5864527225,
0.0383638628,
-0.2909383774,
0.4691093862,
-0.8822854757,
-0.3105494678,
0.4665087461,
-0.0756935477,
-0.7988294959,
0.3410333991,
0.2862708271,
-0.0910617858,
-0.4184065461,
-0.1131061837,
-0.0157176238,
0.3351165056,
0.474681735,
0.3419488966,
-0.5921844244,
-0.5237358212,
0.0218006801,
0.2325084955,
-0.0458639748,
0.4371574819,
-0.4923826158,
0.8815481663,
0.2298822999,
0.096330516,
0.0555941276,
0.0996515676,
0.8274195194,
-0.1817129999,
0.0035963017,
-0.0187728107,
-0.0696561038,
0.0576573648,
-0.6784802079,
0.7214369774,
0.1360183507,
-0.7969700098,
-0.66968292,
0.0568204597,
-0.5361776352,
-0.3063907921,
0.7991838455,
-0.6774496436,
-0.1923239529,
-0.5093122125,
-0.1850072294,
0.3915894628,
-0.4898821712,
0.9650956988,
0.9574357867,
-0.4541095793,
-0.1241461113,
-0.3252782524,
0.2579644024,
0.4891888499,
-0.8233162761,
-0.2993840873,
0.4667256474,
-0.2305764407,
0.4787552953,
0.6765552759,
0.2299383581,
0.5757992864,
0.6181466579,
-0.5053427815,
0.0755313858,
-0.32139799,
-0.4123346806,
0.3451382816,
0.0664204061,
-0.3663409054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12228v1 | Dynamic Transformers Provide a False Sense of Efficiency | 2023-05-20T16:41:48 | 2023-05-20T16:41:48 | Yiming Chen, Simin Chen, Zexin Li, Wei Yang, Cong Liu, Robby T. Tan, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite much success in natural language processing (NLP), pre-trained
language models typically lead to a high computational cost during inference.
Multi-exit is a mainstream approach to address this issue by making a trade-off
between efficiency and accuracy, where the saving of computation comes from an
early exit. However, whether such saving from early-exiting is robust remains
unknown. Motivated by this, we first show that directly adapting existing
adversarial attack approaches targeting model accuracy cannot significantly
reduce inference efficiency. To this end, we propose a simple yet effective
attacking framework, SAME, a novel slowdown attack framework on multi-exit
models, which is specially tailored to reduce the efficiency of the multi-exit
models. By leveraging the multi-exit models' design characteristics, we utilize
all internal predictions to guide the adversarial sample generation instead of
merely considering the final prediction. Experiments on the GLUE benchmark show
that SAME can effectively diminish the efficiency gain of various multi-exit
models by 80% on average, convincingly validating its effectiveness and
generalization ability. | [
-0.6036420465,
-0.899463892,
0.2957610488,
0.0196382925,
0.0588795319,
0.2477010041,
-0.4743482471,
-0.0758707896,
-0.1742679477,
0.2693195045,
-0.8494882584,
-0.145976603,
-0.8621327281,
0.0214745477,
-0.6818000674,
0.9012708068,
0.1597708017,
-0.1416999698,
0.1223577783,
-0.1986140162,
-0.1224299073,
-0.4217274487,
-0.999302268,
-0.0754647925,
0.6370422244,
-0.019752007,
1.1251294613,
0.5777199268,
0.694922924,
0.3258815408,
-0.1590806097,
-0.2462536544,
-0.553260982,
0.1715285778,
0.0114907837,
-0.5044190288,
-0.2467870116,
0.2581599653,
0.5264031291,
0.3454816937,
-0.3990155756,
0.017915627,
0.1646603495,
0.7278533578,
-0.8565028906,
-0.0437710732,
-0.9317333102,
0.3166232407,
-0.4684222937,
0.0883381143,
-0.9067078829,
-0.0199272893,
0.0744283646,
-0.4254507422,
0.3263920844,
-0.4022240043,
0.9014181495,
0.7686638236,
-0.2181004286,
-0.098004967,
-0.8133870959,
0.884822607,
-0.8303059936,
0.5768957734,
-0.3000695705,
0.6398085952,
-0.283341676,
-0.8414263725,
-0.6466365457,
-0.203785941,
-0.0379798748,
0.3045212626,
-0.4419087768,
0.0532445274,
0.3627725244,
-0.0685275719,
-0.435870409,
0.2470880896,
-0.2360901088,
0.0602961443,
0.3386436701,
-0.0290997606,
0.1740851849,
0.055996839,
-0.6904357076,
-0.4591425061,
-0.6271798611,
0.108449325,
0.5473312736,
0.4665101767,
-0.1988619119,
0.1930434555,
0.1345839947,
0.6797910333,
0.2614589036,
-0.1783057153,
-0.0405596308,
-0.2146075815,
-0.2970311046,
-0.1188711599,
0.9769061208,
0.1060236096,
0.0672537833,
-0.4423445165,
-0.027553983,
0.1927450895,
0.661223352,
-1.0264248848,
-0.2942625284,
0.3023070991,
-0.4012162387,
-0.5610564351,
0.0542498343,
-1.079554677,
-0.0294338465,
0.1089940369,
0.3290715218,
-0.4353621006,
-0.1074751616,
-0.0333816372,
-0.1444409341,
0.1088818312,
0.0278614145,
-0.5803543925,
0.341180712,
0.4678483307,
0.9589655995,
-0.3165516555,
-0.49954018,
-0.941644609,
0.0157829281,
-0.2080944926,
0.6104397774,
-0.5622091889,
-0.2078568786,
-0.1854994446,
-0.1785453111,
-0.3871946931,
-0.1635065228,
0.5882355571,
-0.8523244858,
0.4032693505,
0.1852292269,
0.0276204534,
-0.2499943525,
0.2760543823,
-1.0759456158,
0.784206152,
-0.2802119553,
-0.82865417,
0.3851817548,
-0.9702782035,
-0.4114159346,
-0.4933915436,
0.146331653,
-0.5809598565,
0.2791307569,
0.3406908512,
0.3519656062,
-0.4057827294,
0.2287714928,
-0.421316117,
-0.324213177,
0.0407866091,
-0.8688414693,
0.715660274,
0.3708729148,
-0.5670062304,
-0.0420449376,
-0.9085014462,
-0.0375522785,
0.2167061269,
-0.4617623389,
-0.1558672935,
0.2596685588,
-0.3638975918,
0.3546414077,
0.0229226314,
-0.3541909456,
0.3109312356,
-0.4657209516,
-0.1020503938,
0.8963964581,
-0.3071254194,
0.5146023035,
-0.1584048867,
0.8364737034,
-0.1289250255,
0.1950881481,
-0.0872052014,
-0.5405783653,
-0.6266174316,
-0.5626968741,
0.5187960267,
0.4878767133,
-0.8149455786,
0.2552620173,
-0.15516451,
-0.8024656773,
-0.5003715754,
-0.1080874652,
0.4937694967,
0.4479548931,
0.4498149157,
-0.1870077401,
-0.4470148683,
-0.6530678272,
-0.7958115935,
-0.0067821471,
-0.0266797859,
-0.2592385113,
0.3159838319,
-0.2026565522,
0.7275747657,
-0.5595222116,
0.0105137881,
-0.1903914362,
0.1761560291,
0.5873374343,
0.3192833066,
0.6719270945,
-0.9121940732,
-0.6131953597,
-0.4348474145,
-0.7442560792,
0.1146137565,
-0.6952387691,
-0.2171768993,
-0.1983779073,
0.2899110913,
-0.9410425425,
0.5185803771,
0.7455340624,
-0.1085553393,
0.6677609086,
-0.0738765001,
0.2297162861,
-0.8789155483,
-0.0524350218,
-0.1401764452,
0.2672173977,
-0.853280127,
0.3024151623,
-0.0257976782,
-0.1976714879,
-0.6887159944,
0.3834025562,
-0.384126693,
0.1435730755,
-0.1666275561,
0.0075834962,
0.3212132454,
0.479025811,
-0.3351346552,
0.7707021236,
0.5721130371,
-0.77440238,
0.2213334739,
0.2212739587,
0.086080499,
0.4312740564,
-0.4500460923,
0.3397414684,
-0.3153756559,
0.2989599109,
-0.8744369745,
0.0383883156,
0.2476333231,
-0.4855592847,
0.689193368,
-0.1595345289,
-0.1913414747,
-0.4781546593,
-0.6436497569,
0.0478724912,
0.4053878486,
-0.8292904496,
1.019335866,
-0.0424080417,
0.1446289867,
-1.1834359169,
-1.0168969631,
0.2051260024,
-0.413389504,
-0.8154184222,
0.4187948108,
-0.1353046447,
-0.2122928053,
-0.0630446523,
0.0213054735,
-0.1455373317,
0.4201758206,
-0.125478521,
0.0295935776,
-0.3865661025,
0.0469143987,
-0.0561980419,
-0.3948946297,
0.2244552076,
-0.0872474909,
0.6418668032,
0.0883830935,
-0.5838909149,
-0.4733794928,
0.4650278687,
0.8688345551,
-0.3104152679,
1.4135996103,
0.8456232548,
-0.2719783783,
-0.1058162749,
-0.3709422052,
-0.3230769932,
-0.5317258835,
0.5197728872,
-0.7854000926,
-0.0602986179,
0.5350388288,
-0.0365430117,
0.5525270104,
0.6893997788,
0.5770453215,
0.1188174561,
1.0261185169,
0.6047364473,
0.1769897342,
0.4340983629,
-0.406730026,
0.6055954695,
-0.6008225679,
-0.036695417,
-0.6565997601,
-0.2478457838,
-0.5103052855,
-0.227459237,
0.2203855515,
0.287768811,
-0.1451187879,
0.5701571107,
-0.5811777711,
0.2836001813,
0.4937728047,
-0.0233006254,
0.2174054384,
-0.1805880517,
-0.1296273768,
-0.2516447008,
-0.9960027933,
-0.3551843464,
1.206235528,
0.1153300479,
0.8961770535,
0.4892649353,
0.6104395986,
0.3312343061,
0.4801844656,
-0.5856692791,
0.3378833234,
-0.2624906301,
-0.5007472038,
-0.1967396736,
-0.4975525141,
-0.9244579673,
0.5378795266,
-0.2050656229,
-0.6640201807,
0.0550462082,
0.2174332887,
-0.4902293086,
0.8813107014,
-0.8421071768,
1.0531545877,
-0.2120954841,
-0.2159606367,
-0.1100464314,
-0.6113675237,
0.6361435056,
-0.5641462207,
0.2697989345,
0.0514384508,
0.0107001588,
0.8163420558,
-0.3233848214,
0.5613393188,
-0.3097399175,
0.2311667204,
0.2225024849,
0.1697469652,
0.81436795,
-0.2697277963,
-0.4414557517,
0.2433835119,
-0.5039727688,
-0.2309183478,
-0.8109439015,
0.5644822717,
-0.3911239803,
-0.3886598349,
-0.3625029027,
-0.3534170091,
0.0557338372,
0.1141336262,
0.3913021684,
0.4937520623,
-0.1407172978,
0.2193975598,
0.3726364374,
-0.4386643767,
0.6865532994,
0.4305774868,
0.2145138383,
-0.2540299296,
0.6368666291,
0.0665076077,
0.6641234756,
0.2058442235,
0.4962773621,
-0.5744413137,
-0.3871260881,
-0.6690919995,
-0.0081043988,
-0.799429059,
-0.2816954255,
-0.7461528778,
-0.0974329636,
-0.5884041786,
-0.3773321509,
-0.9077532887,
-0.1121658981,
-0.1506105363,
0.0055013676,
0.1193813309,
0.5087590218,
-0.2619758844,
0.6098803282,
-0.9814429879,
0.532715261,
0.1595909297,
0.157761842,
0.1578902155,
-0.5176542401,
-0.1945359856,
-0.0924931839,
-0.5611516237,
-1.0929239988,
0.3907875717,
0.4399048984,
0.7789603472,
0.8251621127,
0.3463647962,
0.6275496483,
-0.5185709596,
0.7049630284,
0.5972474217,
-0.7079439759,
0.1331985295,
0.0005459544,
0.3628910184,
0.4578363299,
0.4100457132,
-0.1834267378,
-0.4388007522,
-0.8211205602,
-0.7798449993,
0.6977648139,
0.3226993382,
-0.0638799742,
0.1089676321,
-0.0395740233,
-0.010834612,
0.3750568926,
-0.5691900253,
-0.5590122938,
-0.1931312978,
-0.1392136961,
0.141986534,
-0.0131355533,
0.0032270169,
0.0867041722,
0.5814902782,
-0.1769811809,
0.29400298,
-0.2932928205,
-0.0264800023,
0.0816904753,
0.3900167942,
0.3560217619,
0.3725940883,
-0.1973158866,
0.1450062096,
0.379091382,
-0.3478292823,
0.342001915,
0.2548697293,
-0.2709241807,
-0.0005249746,
0.3376991749,
0.3425132036,
0.2807582021,
-0.4149967134,
0.467928946,
-0.3482847214,
0.1464820206,
-0.1157494634,
-0.0065078465,
-0.0338529348,
0.1638120413,
0.3886692822,
0.7177963853,
0.0983827934,
-0.3722859621,
0.6090549231,
0.4786625803,
-0.4118099511,
-0.3470287621,
1.0445075035,
0.0820541903,
-0.49882707,
0.4528456926,
-0.1644375026,
-0.6960284114,
0.5535111427,
0.3251816332,
1.1447379589,
-0.4498629272,
-0.0065746624,
0.3045538664,
0.5746317506,
-0.0964018255,
-0.2119374871,
0.1122411788,
-0.6386223435,
-0.7459103465,
-0.495021522,
-0.2862613797,
0.1156035066,
-0.8238683343,
0.2820010483,
-0.3803282678,
-0.2797403336,
-0.161655277,
-0.4206450284,
-0.7629106641,
0.244809106,
0.0692012534,
0.665912807,
-0.6578955054,
0.542750597,
0.1242495775,
-0.1549237221,
-0.4815246165,
0.2052064985,
0.242088601,
-0.321855396,
0.4892893136,
0.4474582672,
-0.4956120849,
-0.3842850029,
-0.2881241441,
-0.9576051831,
0.5304414034,
0.5940003395,
-0.399479568,
-0.3648236692,
-0.1427320838,
0.2618481219,
-0.1719732434,
0.4867464304,
0.8014149666,
0.7353099585,
-0.0501673445,
-0.5272762775,
-0.0135848466,
-0.0905986577,
-0.2746512592,
0.3531886041,
-0.7321605086,
1.0715088844,
-0.4296653867,
-0.5534318686,
-0.1624023467,
0.566182971,
0.0507212989,
0.1804210693,
0.7797157168,
0.7553261518,
0.4231479466,
-0.1018923,
1.164688468,
-0.4694230556,
0.2112278044,
1.2533775568,
0.0846144557,
0.6633633971,
0.3043838143,
-0.2074370235,
0.366122961,
0.2272221893,
0.0018426395,
0.7533887029,
0.0929105282,
-0.0169367883,
-0.1008245721,
0.2996213734,
-0.3485007584,
0.8022093773,
0.1784924567,
-0.2076953948,
-0.4431561828,
-0.1477263868,
0.4051481485,
0.0056113135,
0.3214177787,
0.4511040449,
-0.1055080518,
-0.683042407,
0.6708590388,
0.0295650586,
0.7843449116,
-0.8194305897,
0.0458637029,
0.1118112132,
0.3359273374,
-0.0689191222,
-0.211667046,
0.4836286902,
-0.0596341379,
-0.1450197101,
-0.1548609138,
0.5323351026,
-0.1991901696,
-0.5038573146,
0.5933465362,
0.4747122228,
-0.0345234126,
-0.1910337806,
-1.0153167248,
0.031094227,
0.100910835,
-0.7864525318,
0.0895097032,
0.1577440351,
0.533228159,
0.6945474744,
1.0069692135,
0.212837711,
0.2824417949,
0.0684420466,
0.8240157366,
-0.6486141682,
-0.4981211126,
-1.1383484602,
0.7161370516,
-0.298723042,
-0.2891367972,
0.7456610799,
0.3452211022,
0.6540923715,
0.1113850102,
0.6766366959,
0.1520213336,
0.3803315759,
-0.6532641053,
0.7065830231,
-0.5101428032,
0.3387271762,
-0.4538199902,
-0.970902741,
-0.2130778581,
0.3064764142,
0.0524092615,
0.0526777357,
0.860424757,
0.7331078649,
-0.1569991112,
-0.2852505445,
0.4272134602,
0.2456746548,
0.880002439,
0.4864996076,
0.7667995095,
-0.576767683,
0.8657294512,
-0.2001618743,
-0.1934494674,
-0.0253887139,
-0.8749021292,
-0.8270364404,
-0.0737751499,
-0.1732992083,
-0.4862563014,
-0.0295429658,
0.3142701983,
0.7824295759,
-0.6777980924,
0.2940533459,
0.1963478476,
-0.0458749309,
-0.4155046344,
-0.2486458123,
0.5572077036,
-0.4633118212,
-0.7268932462,
0.8583360314,
0.3423585594,
-0.1862501204,
-0.5568006635,
-0.0441167876,
-0.2805891633,
0.3139040172,
0.2196210623,
0.1510863751,
-0.6663908362,
-0.228288725,
-0.1470573545,
0.0214987826,
0.2585014403,
0.8156690001,
-0.8162180185,
0.5873832703,
0.3854342997,
1.0001449585,
0.3940716684,
0.0165286791,
0.7586911321,
-0.585331738,
0.580644846,
0.2268272042,
0.3424971998,
0.2530214489,
-0.3238400221,
0.5966811776,
0.1986759007,
-0.20386599,
-0.8565410376,
0.2258516848,
-0.6379345655,
-0.2222192287,
0.7297436595,
-0.3763585091,
-0.4090597034,
-0.1002866626,
0.2129310519,
0.3303076923,
-0.5353149176,
0.7950978279,
0.4969459474,
-0.0028658009,
0.1482910961,
-0.5021318793,
0.5651898384,
0.4704278409,
-0.7954346538,
-0.1449126154,
0.0307227504,
-0.1210237667,
0.5210638046,
0.2788771987,
0.0330302678,
0.1754705608,
0.4450650513,
0.0286260936,
0.0788144842,
-0.6871911883,
-0.2131495476,
0.6704313755,
-0.2542739511,
-0.4412215352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18243v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18243v3 | Practical PCG Through Large Language Models | 2023-05-20T16:08:45 | 2023-07-02T09:11:17 | Muhammad U Nasir, Julian Togelius | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have proven to be useful tools in various
domains outside of the field of their inception, which was natural language
processing. In this study, we provide practical directions on how to use LLMs
to generate 2D-game rooms for an under-development game, named Metavoidal. Our
technique can harness the power of GPT-3 by Human-in-the-loop fine-tuning which
allows our method to create 37% Playable-Novel levels from as scarce data as
only 60 hand-designed rooms under a scenario of the non-trivial game, with
respect to (Procedural Content Generation) PCG, that has a good amount of local
and global constraints. | [
-0.5105238557,
-0.9873042703,
0.6171481609,
-0.0161298737,
-0.5618976355,
-0.1476552486,
-0.3272790909,
-0.112328358,
-0.318690449,
0.6671551466,
-0.7056893706,
-0.7622743249,
-0.0668830127,
0.1190425977,
-0.0910458937,
0.6386783123,
0.1278053969,
0.2108321339,
0.0334858745,
0.4428946972,
-0.6830255985,
-0.6068462133,
-0.6606578231,
-0.4884451926,
0.2462136745,
0.5399181247,
0.7662318349,
0.5800913572,
0.4755296111,
0.2900303602,
0.1843616813,
0.2397981733,
-0.5416556001,
0.0429573879,
0.0085213138,
-0.4134301245,
-0.6685580611,
0.0969518647,
0.4375131726,
0.4028882384,
-0.3881284595,
-0.0100627085,
0.3079460263,
0.4446763396,
-0.2522731423,
0.2035671771,
-0.4933370352,
0.3966786563,
-0.1743289232,
-0.3061947525,
-0.3089152575,
-0.1721438915,
-0.0287071131,
-0.6179596782,
0.4033023417,
-0.3303769827,
0.2322639674,
0.2459770292,
-0.0892396048,
-0.3604698181,
-0.9302949905,
0.610391736,
-1.0227228403,
0.1396197081,
0.4430626035,
0.4690228105,
-0.568384409,
-0.730650425,
-0.5408316255,
-0.2399051785,
0.1179356948,
-0.0841672868,
-0.1965167671,
0.3698307276,
0.5369718075,
0.1819572896,
-0.5201787949,
-0.0205529686,
-0.3356142342,
0.1175371185,
0.6131637692,
0.5517590046,
0.5038055778,
-0.1788798869,
-0.1316591352,
0.124417834,
-1.1322541237,
-0.2008849233,
0.374347955,
0.6698510647,
0.1645592749,
0.7582828403,
0.3394509852,
0.7047468424,
0.0447953567,
-0.3764573038,
-0.1323478818,
-0.4416818917,
-0.3302469552,
-0.0866710842,
0.8030040264,
0.4727883935,
0.3606851101,
-0.0335045643,
-0.0194089692,
0.1259002388,
0.5713009834,
-1.0728694201,
-0.1999073476,
0.1437989473,
-0.5476384759,
-0.2595053315,
-0.3287025392,
-0.8511863351,
-0.4595371783,
-0.4128114283,
0.231719017,
-0.3955158889,
-0.2313158661,
0.2797082365,
-0.1173185334,
0.4438021779,
0.1417722106,
-0.877464354,
0.3706623614,
0.5647414327,
0.8756200075,
-0.0509331189,
0.0071877777,
-0.3727359772,
0.3166018128,
-0.4920199215,
0.4896009862,
-0.4379245937,
-0.9147220254,
0.0243021864,
-0.1854977161,
0.5762975812,
-0.6091685295,
0.4834482968,
-0.0359395295,
0.2059038579,
-0.4494468272,
-0.4681703746,
0.1841656715,
0.2430316508,
-0.4122181833,
0.4310614169,
-0.0632147342,
-0.4843518436,
0.3915413916,
-0.5266722441,
-0.4570200741,
0.5324189663,
-0.2875794768,
-0.273893714,
0.4735960364,
0.1800320297,
0.47630319,
-0.2616793811,
0.4221190512,
-0.1626403332,
-0.6480507851,
-0.1358381957,
-0.2626049519,
0.4631050229,
0.2311761081,
-0.635032773,
-0.07648848,
-0.6890143752,
0.0155806914,
-0.0210739486,
-0.4719080031,
-0.0524565689,
0.5469573736,
-0.202880457,
0.2715775967,
-0.0545505211,
-0.3655202091,
0.5675453544,
-0.364113301,
0.520593822,
0.2479619235,
-0.0859329328,
0.5018304586,
-0.1045360938,
0.9016384482,
-0.4715014994,
0.0955411717,
0.0664903373,
-0.8294497728,
-0.5440511107,
-0.2656239569,
0.1030196995,
0.4668676257,
-1.0116618872,
0.3793449104,
0.1988514066,
-0.5717186928,
-0.2780014277,
-0.0724082813,
0.341157198,
0.0606589615,
0.1062625349,
0.0104458081,
-0.6071414948,
-0.7900922298,
-0.1282515824,
0.15208745,
-0.3796640933,
0.6076631546,
0.1650324017,
-0.6428539157,
0.7295228839,
-0.6110518575,
-0.5171040297,
-0.3314492404,
0.4624285996,
0.2423078269,
0.375569731,
0.5575860739,
-0.2055560648,
-0.551573813,
-0.0716847405,
-0.7475310564,
-0.305426091,
0.0971898139,
0.1491539925,
-0.0016831263,
0.7681345344,
-0.6760204434,
0.5708477497,
0.6113321185,
-0.2364211082,
0.3820264637,
-0.4874493778,
-0.0342678241,
-1.0771641731,
-0.0901125073,
-0.2665060759,
-0.4560571015,
-0.7913341522,
0.4583329558,
-0.2667185068,
-0.4936625957,
-0.5247365236,
0.3947336972,
-0.8120127916,
0.058923088,
-0.8940050602,
0.2849728465,
-0.4318897724,
0.373613447,
0.2012179047,
0.943757534,
0.5738704801,
-0.6097382903,
0.5032530427,
-0.0126509918,
-0.1898751259,
0.3287400007,
-0.7570978999,
0.2467574328,
0.0527501181,
0.3614908457,
-0.8701556921,
-0.1883818656,
0.084746331,
-0.3139443994,
0.152018711,
-0.205116421,
-0.7008363605,
-0.5793427229,
-0.1668424159,
0.4069772363,
0.6999843121,
-0.2437906414,
0.7443589568,
0.5083023906,
-0.0530596673,
-0.1307718158,
-0.8374459743,
0.2172616571,
-0.2099059671,
-0.5756262541,
0.307282567,
-0.2075250298,
-0.2719986439,
-0.3277066648,
0.3047266603,
0.0873565823,
-0.1320563406,
0.4324108958,
-0.1884362549,
-0.1947416961,
0.1700269282,
-0.1126032323,
-0.0854034573,
0.1960437894,
-0.1852260381,
0.7775852084,
-0.1005310416,
-0.2705998123,
-0.1076067463,
0.3350629508,
0.3055569828,
0.2267274261,
0.5011942387,
0.592571795,
-0.6008731127,
-0.4383411407,
-0.3115553856,
-0.1602433026,
-0.563826263,
0.3232362866,
-0.4772931337,
-0.8989804387,
0.7025595903,
-0.1999450028,
-0.019457411,
0.2708387971,
0.7790285945,
0.1311912984,
1.2298098803,
0.7232702971,
0.3199899495,
0.1051523238,
-0.251111269,
0.2991095483,
-0.7870048881,
-0.1573600769,
-0.3858907223,
-0.343939662,
-0.8685679436,
-0.9386166334,
0.4503985047,
0.2339490056,
-0.0113828564,
0.4008948207,
-0.4567485154,
0.9055595398,
0.4366129339,
0.0661223009,
0.1723270863,
-0.1553280205,
-0.2059787512,
-0.2167854309,
-0.5804597735,
-0.6625595689,
1.1161155701,
0.2853693962,
0.8922796845,
0.1441254914,
0.7129553556,
0.1426287293,
0.2462757826,
-0.6709555984,
0.5263034105,
-0.3659430146,
-0.8754614592,
-0.5976567268,
-0.4394700229,
-0.9656791687,
0.0721510053,
-0.2056940347,
-0.4153706133,
0.2096089572,
0.0476724356,
-0.7296236753,
0.3864989877,
-0.5268320441,
0.4504457116,
-0.0223402698,
-0.4035609365,
-0.2177184671,
-0.3322423697,
0.5296058059,
-0.3060328066,
0.3314817548,
0.1128622368,
-0.0505168885,
0.3546045721,
-0.5433798432,
0.9070047736,
-0.3071357906,
-0.4612250626,
0.637396276,
0.4932262301,
0.4160453677,
0.3368326128,
0.0502947494,
0.0419146717,
-0.4126951993,
-0.1664480269,
-0.353071034,
0.7772732973,
-0.9046730995,
-0.769030273,
-0.3427821398,
-0.5749870539,
-0.1739639342,
0.3304598629,
0.4349759519,
0.4702889919,
-0.6041076183,
0.2602048218,
0.6418237686,
-0.7243459225,
0.621869266,
0.5523501635,
-0.2800753415,
-0.5403727293,
0.5943909883,
-0.0469372831,
0.1675725877,
0.211515069,
0.4874884188,
-0.1537675709,
-0.5665025711,
-0.1462576985,
0.1347342432,
-0.3302051723,
-0.4136192799,
-0.496099472,
-0.3283241689,
-0.3104761243,
-0.4514546692,
-0.304794997,
-0.0312783942,
-0.4814048707,
-0.0217442736,
-0.2462101132,
1.1811906099,
-0.354450047,
0.7403740883,
-0.8123283982,
0.5648444295,
0.8499692678,
0.3721124232,
-0.3165798783,
-0.2954251468,
-0.011453406,
0.3387310505,
-0.4308023751,
-0.8839021325,
0.5727353692,
0.0388957225,
0.4730324447,
0.4997147024,
-0.398521632,
0.7612181902,
-0.9238885641,
1.0432910919,
0.1921325475,
-1.0314638615,
0.5499546528,
-1.1047796011,
0.5930031538,
0.433511734,
0.1075169891,
-0.3286853433,
-0.2406674773,
-0.5631629825,
-0.6775892377,
0.7912845612,
0.3474180102,
0.2408349514,
-0.2651602626,
0.7872229218,
0.0744574815,
0.4376887977,
-0.9258300066,
-0.080356583,
-0.0583144017,
0.2715571225,
-0.3783296347,
-0.4050588012,
-0.0527399965,
-0.3772973418,
0.4329976439,
-0.1411583126,
0.3392276168,
-0.1072053835,
0.1738680154,
-0.511670351,
0.1374553144,
1.0698379278,
0.9041086435,
-0.4131494761,
0.2010139078,
0.321380198,
-0.5366253853,
0.269346416,
-0.1613834351,
0.1040889546,
-0.1213284954,
0.3899931312,
0.5467792749,
0.0814060718,
-0.4574509561,
0.6566082239,
-0.3201698661,
-0.5291761756,
-0.1889477223,
0.2197690308,
0.2594563961,
0.3922388554,
0.0619010404,
-0.2988404334,
0.171990633,
-0.8088267446,
0.272051245,
0.7122568488,
-0.2817627788,
-0.302980274,
0.6089355946,
0.4861625433,
-0.6463916898,
0.6374353766,
-0.3758954406,
-0.3873367906,
0.3469261825,
0.8041198254,
1.1794183254,
-0.3366725743,
0.3728667498,
0.5253235102,
0.4675812125,
-0.18874681,
0.4568695426,
0.1532374024,
-0.5427009463,
-0.7309677601,
-0.6492667198,
-0.1987569779,
0.3777574301,
-0.2462191433,
0.565235436,
-0.5548733473,
-0.3954643309,
-0.3572977185,
0.1017371491,
-0.6459278464,
-0.0315954275,
0.5222703815,
0.7351344228,
-0.7200298905,
0.8200870752,
0.4111170471,
-0.1474414617,
-0.7591643333,
-0.1735626012,
-0.1528131068,
-0.7745582461,
0.464255929,
-0.2687161267,
-0.1220820993,
-0.1527489424,
-0.7767974138,
-0.5334659219,
0.9832290411,
0.2749848962,
-1.2113013268,
-0.3921557069,
0.6535633802,
0.9914985895,
-0.4909533262,
0.0800326318,
0.5763200521,
0.5164055228,
0.1970214695,
-0.66665411,
-0.0317267701,
0.0299214069,
0.108654879,
0.3042054772,
-0.4286939204,
0.9744964242,
-0.1824198812,
-0.2007860839,
0.002106721,
0.2876636684,
0.5677554011,
-0.1210418269,
0.4063091278,
0.7160739899,
0.4494358599,
-0.1919988096,
0.9338624477,
-0.2653914988,
0.1993156821,
1.0999970436,
-0.2344171405,
0.5377098322,
0.1630720943,
-0.0720213726,
0.2512179315,
0.4644416571,
-0.0550090373,
0.6073068976,
0.7874325514,
-0.0491752103,
-0.4101004303,
0.3319372535,
-0.4977333546,
0.5490052104,
0.3543107212,
-0.3579626381,
-0.3253705204,
0.0423606895,
0.1853410155,
-0.2102461755,
-0.3168977499,
1.0699015856,
0.2579680681,
-0.578922987,
0.577283442,
0.0982783958,
0.568713665,
-0.4993719459,
-0.2970563471,
-0.3665807545,
0.2989041805,
0.0342067145,
-0.590798378,
0.1920944005,
0.1018944457,
0.0596447326,
-0.3132303059,
0.7613162994,
-0.6042416692,
-0.7167146802,
0.137418434,
0.6485046744,
0.1090325117,
-0.3497842848,
-0.3646893501,
-0.0793497041,
-0.0333586074,
0.0846977532,
0.0476520248,
0.8173480034,
0.1958433837,
0.383115828,
0.3820141256,
0.3849104941,
0.0306356065,
0.2256991565,
0.8077507019,
-0.8358018398,
-0.3957727551,
-1.1387660503,
0.3787080348,
0.253590852,
-0.1807949841,
0.7636297941,
0.5010662675,
0.4493098557,
-0.0792093202,
0.7125642896,
0.1343130469,
0.1454755217,
-0.2701938748,
0.5722003579,
-0.2879659534,
0.1351234019,
-0.6096327305,
-1.3543102741,
-0.4234236181,
0.5982529521,
0.0224642996,
0.024249509,
0.5539640188,
0.5955164433,
-0.0813154727,
-0.0963420868,
0.5992181897,
0.2256934196,
0.7893923521,
0.6077401042,
1.000716567,
-0.1982573718,
0.3467013538,
0.0471112914,
-0.5227103829,
-0.0691480711,
-0.9742621183,
-1.5264173746,
-0.3768928051,
-0.0245834291,
-0.2100934684,
0.0521712527,
0.722050786,
0.7474910021,
-0.4950229228,
-0.4938659072,
-0.5355027914,
-0.2918459475,
0.0604289137,
-0.1598188132,
0.0419280641,
-0.2473820448,
-0.6036272645,
0.4482851028,
0.1224026382,
0.1875600666,
-0.8348605037,
0.0633396804,
-0.0185280684,
0.2955217063,
0.7396325469,
-0.2267164737,
-0.6092204452,
-0.2116315961,
-0.1479097754,
-0.0401535705,
-0.1371242255,
1.319773674,
-0.7631261349,
0.493032068,
0.6557319164,
0.0521913357,
0.5534392595,
0.0222371742,
1.1902040243,
-0.8348120451,
0.1775564998,
0.268812865,
0.2368512303,
0.1595281959,
-0.4005335867,
0.5205307603,
0.0304804873,
-0.8009120226,
-0.6501637101,
0.2159559578,
-0.4396984577,
-0.4859619141,
1.5333564281,
0.2623379529,
-0.0029391602,
-0.0244378988,
-0.442617029,
0.3008342087,
-0.1385681927,
0.8168488741,
0.7690118551,
-0.0672991425,
-0.0574664697,
-0.5313244462,
1.1303009987,
-0.3611505926,
-0.9629127383,
0.1877631694,
0.6128777862,
0.1122541353,
0.1956334859,
0.7173743248,
-0.186284706,
0.0671188533,
-0.0089887874,
0.3178374171,
-0.0482016094,
-0.4444564581,
-0.2358727157,
0.2133157402,
-0.0051243352,
0.0611721128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12219v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12219v2 | Collaborative Development of NLP models | 2023-05-20T15:55:39 | 2023-05-24T22:05:16 | Fereshte Khani, Marco Tulio Ribeiro | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite substantial advancements, Natural Language Processing (NLP) models
often require post-training adjustments to enforce business rules, rectify
undesired behavior, and align with user values. These adjustments involve
operationalizing "concepts"--dictating desired model responses to certain
inputs. However, it's difficult for a single entity to enumerate and define all
possible concepts, indicating a need for a multi-user, collaborative model
alignment framework. Moreover, the exhaustive delineation of a concept is
challenging, and an improper approach can create shortcuts or interfere with
original data or other concepts.
To address these challenges, we introduce CoDev, a framework that enables
multi-user interaction with the model, thereby mitigating individual
limitations. CoDev aids users in operationalizing their concepts using Large
Language Models, and relying on the principle that NLP models exhibit simpler
behaviors in local regions. Our main insight is learning a \emph{local} model
for each concept, and a \emph{global} model to integrate the original data with
all concepts. We then steer a large language model to generate instances within
concept boundaries where local and global disagree. Our experiments show CoDev
is effective at helping multiple users operationalize concepts and avoid
interference for a variety of scenarios, tasks, and models. | [
-0.4878001213,
-0.5703454614,
0.3169895113,
0.3243543506,
0.0753891319,
0.3247604668,
-0.2546661794,
-0.5435456634,
0.1799042225,
0.8692439198,
-0.4663034678,
-0.5929118991,
-0.2704454362,
0.0085305031,
-0.285027951,
1.0968068838,
0.0591264889,
-0.1450980455,
-0.5675568581,
-0.3460249305,
-0.90482831,
-0.7775050402,
-0.4737936854,
-0.4239864051,
0.3743083775,
0.5026042461,
0.9930858016,
0.5579348207,
0.8403711915,
0.310475111,
0.0643153191,
0.2306925803,
-0.2748477459,
0.3358607888,
-0.211095944,
-0.523098886,
-0.7146879435,
-0.2047116607,
0.1801318079,
1.0277638435,
-0.4140512049,
-0.0936282501,
0.0154694337,
0.6083814502,
-0.5216050744,
0.1222471148,
-0.5919552445,
-0.0108430451,
0.0300159939,
0.1032557562,
-0.2938003838,
-0.1752967089,
0.583787322,
-0.8329094052,
0.4161033332,
-0.0407864898,
0.6315744519,
0.3234057426,
-0.249194473,
-0.3458757102,
-0.761770606,
0.8342986107,
-0.6502255201,
0.1710048765,
0.3594278693,
-0.0594050921,
-0.1292297691,
-0.6261875033,
-0.5446743965,
0.0817301273,
-0.0992273763,
-0.0330903344,
-0.2125842422,
0.1821979433,
0.3167429566,
0.2546526492,
-0.6151785851,
0.2401495278,
-0.4005745053,
-0.0740795657,
0.711404562,
0.4029118419,
0.3234784901,
-0.1494906992,
-0.4456955492,
0.0960838944,
-0.4925157726,
0.097464323,
0.2322281152,
0.4685545266,
-0.1739278883,
0.592761755,
-0.2422197014,
0.7679579854,
-0.1649231911,
0.2064909339,
0.5006011128,
-0.606218338,
-0.3462221622,
-0.115873374,
0.8082771897,
0.4330742359,
0.0798195899,
-0.2692923546,
-0.1413134634,
0.353451252,
0.6550045013,
-0.535811007,
-0.3459135592,
0.2674793899,
-0.3753487766,
-0.5262644291,
0.0376602858,
-0.6287817359,
-0.5747728944,
-0.6957066059,
0.2705695331,
-0.1807749718,
-0.5090060234,
0.4160913527,
-0.0976941288,
0.0095322691,
0.2935095131,
-1.2167698145,
0.6681172848,
0.8632519841,
0.7959028482,
-0.1937158108,
-0.3937528729,
-0.4234132767,
0.1013137251,
-0.3318328261,
0.6028456092,
-0.6982272267,
-0.5163477659,
-0.1701033562,
-0.3064100146,
0.0032245789,
-0.4212269783,
0.217734158,
-0.399620682,
0.1519031227,
-0.1900676638,
-0.655185461,
-0.1469783187,
0.1323722303,
-0.596749723,
0.7965112329,
-0.002886219,
-0.8185165524,
0.4463895559,
-1.0541321039,
-0.1674938798,
0.2693082988,
-0.4353810251,
-0.2758910954,
0.2928946018,
0.2504915893,
0.4780839086,
-0.0939972252,
0.4182326198,
-0.313475579,
-0.215487659,
0.1212608442,
0.1872468144,
0.5068821311,
0.3359609842,
0.1890500784,
0.5099832416,
-0.7732205391,
0.0104149356,
-0.0303441845,
-0.1644965708,
-0.7070847154,
0.1889184117,
0.067995064,
0.1567204893,
0.1566616148,
-0.1153737381,
0.6957755685,
-0.6444311738,
0.4261614084,
0.4447922409,
0.0709966719,
0.8373445272,
-0.5425688028,
0.7835462093,
-0.2411410958,
0.0110042579,
-0.3762176335,
-0.6707371473,
-0.6910657287,
-0.1424166709,
0.1670804173,
0.4038420618,
-0.8246881366,
0.4088020027,
-0.184426114,
-0.4377843738,
-0.5889878273,
0.4439256191,
0.2934091389,
0.3326315582,
0.2505391538,
-0.7587411404,
-0.8475929499,
-0.7649096847,
-0.0492457859,
-0.0989833325,
-0.2593887448,
0.1606729329,
0.4108934402,
-0.3356219232,
1.3637875319,
-0.5490458608,
-0.3316209316,
-0.3178706765,
0.4612877965,
0.0856193751,
0.6283091903,
0.2373218238,
-1.1382688284,
-0.3104236424,
0.0868980512,
-0.7956777811,
-0.1389386803,
-0.2512897253,
-0.1490792036,
0.064587757,
0.4512973428,
-0.2163618803,
0.3474023938,
0.8174753189,
-0.2167071551,
0.308662653,
-0.4232284427,
0.0222307108,
-1.4209651947,
-0.0749108493,
0.0630417466,
-0.2259835005,
-0.6730153561,
0.3452376425,
-0.1643363684,
-0.2172405273,
-0.2846335471,
0.0679053292,
-0.2253177017,
-0.1086493582,
-0.2371445894,
0.2044245899,
0.2581319511,
0.3331730068,
0.4274447858,
0.6878788471,
0.4937649667,
-0.6645644307,
0.3767149448,
0.6591345072,
-0.2961068153,
0.5299115181,
-0.8708120584,
0.4021503031,
0.2212554663,
-0.0452464186,
-0.5825709105,
-0.1981527805,
0.0573845245,
-0.4061053395,
-0.1374378502,
-0.2575441301,
-0.5538314581,
-0.0210842825,
-0.0234408043,
0.3904235661,
0.2399910688,
-0.3501155078,
0.6503971219,
0.6712637544,
-0.0875744671,
-0.507335186,
-0.6451878548,
0.2675181329,
-0.2194535285,
-1.0425400734,
0.5654175878,
-0.2637315989,
-0.3270026147,
0.0374131538,
0.0859470144,
-0.4229263067,
0.1894441247,
0.3517489135,
0.3074041009,
-0.2827425897,
0.4297387004,
-0.3706080914,
-0.120018594,
-0.0044428604,
-0.2428409159,
0.4011420012,
-0.3054712117,
-0.1688969582,
-0.1714158654,
0.4937209189,
0.4035030603,
-0.6754452586,
0.6829531193,
0.4394183755,
-0.5249680877,
-0.281029433,
-0.372012645,
0.1095151901,
-0.4873928726,
0.3569401205,
-0.3680826128,
-0.9535185695,
0.4835367203,
-0.1471590102,
0.0227931552,
-0.0114227189,
0.5757645369,
-0.0409273431,
0.9109945297,
1.2903462648,
0.2002680004,
0.2855285406,
-0.2429367453,
0.3850063682,
-0.8304136992,
-0.2493439913,
-0.5931478143,
-0.1019145399,
-0.530621767,
-0.4807229936,
0.0204466768,
0.3165369332,
0.0994763523,
0.7292191386,
-0.7089832425,
0.5012351274,
0.509011507,
-0.069176726,
0.4097753465,
-0.1015600115,
-0.1931542009,
-0.4662439227,
-0.6389743686,
-0.4808968306,
1.0040183067,
0.1817839295,
0.9119425416,
0.3240653872,
0.8704230785,
0.2235674411,
0.0965107754,
-0.8780186772,
0.2005063295,
-0.0132037262,
-0.4825601578,
-0.0933764875,
-0.3732200265,
-0.9061875939,
0.3136695027,
-0.6714289188,
-0.8790694475,
0.0928140059,
0.3192746639,
-0.5938261151,
0.0598614328,
-0.9039280415,
1.1961407661,
-0.0557463616,
-0.3742659092,
-0.2264012694,
-0.5564336181,
0.3891736567,
-0.4567195773,
0.53603971,
0.0320692919,
0.0057204952,
0.5396468043,
-0.466422677,
0.9979799986,
0.0928835198,
-0.1191996485,
0.1897949576,
0.1864408553,
0.170579955,
0.0139224101,
0.1832025498,
0.0904802978,
0.0461012647,
-0.0761088431,
-0.6217752099,
0.5065026283,
-0.6381379962,
-0.4273656011,
-0.3296220899,
-0.7186387777,
-0.2504209876,
0.1962540597,
0.0407800414,
0.3751629889,
-0.2748297155,
0.4442210793,
0.5961462259,
-0.3063378036,
0.3407371938,
0.4835934043,
-0.4900785983,
-0.2088748664,
0.7786586881,
-0.2061608285,
0.4343004227,
0.2700355351,
0.2221935391,
-0.0276888441,
-0.482891202,
0.1205538213,
-0.1166597381,
-0.5922786593,
-0.1308130622,
-0.6511875987,
-0.0126080569,
-0.3174373806,
-0.5263280869,
-0.536432445,
-0.3136831522,
-0.1143766418,
0.1384581625,
0.1975000054,
0.9515241981,
-0.0748471394,
0.4443898797,
-1.0328456163,
0.3980062306,
0.1568104178,
0.3277188838,
-0.151804179,
-0.1880392581,
-0.357486397,
0.0149264578,
-0.323836863,
-0.5735510588,
0.4643479288,
-0.0290741939,
0.3299829662,
0.018917717,
0.0536955371,
0.7067355514,
-0.4250149429,
0.7372962832,
0.3947814703,
-1.3327739239,
0.6914611459,
-0.3885816038,
0.326312393,
0.5111409426,
0.2266448885,
-1.076233983,
-0.2445272356,
-0.4535965323,
-0.9340447187,
0.6738868952,
0.2615206242,
0.2530223727,
0.2081772834,
0.2055354416,
0.0910872668,
0.4016401172,
-0.6758390069,
-0.0855212063,
-0.0266759787,
-0.318169117,
0.1153012961,
-0.0011219467,
-0.0813121572,
-0.213968128,
0.3500853181,
-0.2904108167,
-0.0793266147,
0.0492656194,
-0.1236573681,
0.0145973042,
0.2100386322,
0.61969769,
1.0500267744,
-0.1161459312,
-0.1638058722,
-0.0159841478,
-0.2250074744,
-0.0803616121,
-0.092122227,
0.0088800546,
-0.2382188141,
0.3449011147,
0.5800611973,
0.3835716844,
-0.4866239727,
0.7082051039,
-0.467974931,
-0.3377972245,
-0.3096021712,
0.3383100033,
0.3032222092,
0.2220563442,
-0.0913367346,
0.7529286742,
-0.0361138806,
-0.2194550335,
0.4700696468,
0.165014267,
-0.3016811311,
-0.2274116874,
0.7691445947,
0.4651795626,
-0.6281023622,
0.563508451,
-0.2091370821,
-0.4820726514,
0.7520871758,
0.3202627003,
0.7298983932,
-0.0155274523,
0.2935426831,
0.1716973484,
0.1983905584,
-0.2349614352,
0.1364806741,
-0.0070294035,
-1.2254213095,
-0.7944873571,
-0.3928252757,
-0.6234071851,
0.0344191864,
-0.9912491441,
0.5817219615,
-0.3893395066,
-0.0561171174,
0.2891830504,
-0.1428454816,
-0.8744043112,
0.0156802591,
0.1533675194,
0.59717381,
-0.7395575047,
1.0977109671,
0.7172152996,
-0.7821583748,
-0.6908343434,
-0.2347740978,
0.2309650779,
-0.5898190737,
0.4702322185,
0.1670472473,
-0.030495096,
-0.126265645,
-0.6359606385,
-0.6682420373,
0.7645241022,
0.0434802175,
-0.6680364609,
-0.138726607,
-0.0650740862,
0.7536946535,
-0.7515619397,
-0.2211460769,
0.3918649852,
0.0141758062,
0.0029381569,
-0.9309254289,
-0.1732562333,
-0.0835056528,
0.1542735994,
0.1147248819,
-0.2632526457,
0.6576722264,
-0.4326752126,
0.0279445071,
-0.0246133078,
0.4920903444,
0.0506002679,
0.0833552256,
0.5785549879,
0.4205675423,
0.9390893579,
0.1536770761,
0.8141872883,
-0.192472741,
0.4437922835,
1.5290894508,
-0.4490053952,
0.9158668518,
0.3569878042,
0.0186900664,
0.3193669021,
0.2116444558,
-0.3324724734,
0.4180317521,
0.2275871336,
-0.2208316177,
-0.2869305313,
-0.228671208,
-0.2542502582,
0.7212013602,
0.4751139879,
-0.1125174686,
0.0601696111,
-0.0597642474,
-0.0826902464,
0.5032336116,
-0.0825496167,
0.8844722509,
0.0483128391,
-0.6495351791,
0.2829707563,
0.0733415782,
0.7683460712,
-0.6272383332,
-0.2196813524,
-0.0363993533,
0.243598938,
-0.4384355247,
-0.5291358232,
0.613722384,
0.0961161032,
-0.3342000246,
-0.4039216638,
0.4983252287,
-0.5998333097,
-0.241561532,
0.3491382897,
0.513450861,
-0.1160393208,
0.0490367189,
-0.7008751035,
0.258597672,
0.0198395383,
0.2065610141,
0.1220049188,
0.1886028647,
0.0729267001,
0.6321866512,
0.6501325965,
0.101670377,
-0.0900602192,
0.4155241549,
0.6343830824,
-0.5279983878,
-0.4830750525,
-0.7057179213,
0.6426247358,
-0.1236839145,
-0.3670349419,
0.5924631357,
0.4595777988,
1.314232707,
0.1748235226,
1.0041465759,
0.0039097364,
0.3349581659,
-0.5209046602,
0.5597780943,
-0.441814065,
0.4515006244,
-0.493989706,
-0.7622359991,
-0.6771525741,
0.8915683627,
-0.0592344105,
-0.1928972453,
0.7259762883,
0.5966213346,
0.0554755703,
0.1952231079,
0.339048624,
-0.1377867311,
0.6497440934,
0.5518877506,
0.9010393023,
-0.2598291337,
0.500295639,
-0.3573506176,
-0.1447288692,
0.1962691396,
-1.0968102217,
-0.9070709348,
-0.5195201635,
-0.6293091178,
-0.1926763058,
-0.2930780947,
1.2834316492,
0.9797356725,
-0.7316386104,
-0.4731353521,
-0.36015746,
0.0643528998,
-0.2415824234,
-0.2064431608,
-0.0290328749,
-0.5771635175,
-0.650991261,
0.4493921995,
0.2287701368,
-0.0639135167,
-0.2154286355,
-0.1185354963,
-0.1463749707,
-0.0842503533,
0.3032898307,
0.0924087092,
-0.6233169436,
-0.1660838574,
0.0102702565,
-0.1631040275,
0.3068105578,
1.1100072861,
-0.7020009756,
1.0251127481,
0.3043971956,
1.0012481213,
0.2676292062,
0.039842125,
1.1204953194,
-1.1630716324,
0.1249406114,
0.1517004371,
0.3929972649,
0.5088756084,
-0.307737112,
0.6012197137,
0.2734415829,
-0.6416729093,
-0.6276770234,
0.3110660017,
-0.7980539203,
-0.33806023,
0.782541573,
-0.0454873145,
0.2116076797,
-0.2686155438,
-0.2859916389,
-0.1075190455,
-0.3686197996,
0.5466139913,
1.0151295662,
-0.1165740639,
-0.0096594375,
-0.6898329258,
0.5355619788,
0.2773878574,
-0.7821597457,
0.1490001231,
0.4284009635,
0.0903123841,
0.3124616146,
0.7005637884,
0.2913934886,
-0.0042888992,
0.0449215807,
0.5299757123,
-0.0611025505,
-0.2974804938,
-0.6001931429,
0.0616771653,
0.1948182732,
-0.2426985502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12217v1 | PromptNER: A Prompting Method for Few-shot Named Entity Recognition via k Nearest Neighbor Search | 2023-05-20T15:47:59 | 2023-05-20T15:47:59 | Mozhi Zhang, Hang Yan, Yaqian Zhou, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few-shot Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a task aiming to identify named
entities via limited annotated samples. Recently, prototypical networks have
shown promising performance in few-shot NER. Most of prototypical networks will
utilize the entities from the support set to construct label prototypes and use
the query set to compute span-level similarities and optimize these label
prototype representations. However, these methods are usually unsuitable for
fine-tuning in the target domain, where only the support set is available. In
this paper, we propose PromptNER: a novel prompting method for few-shot NER via
k nearest neighbor search. We use prompts that contains entity category
information to construct label prototypes, which enables our model to fine-tune
with only the support set. Our approach achieves excellent transfer learning
ability, and extensive experiments on the Few-NERD and CrossNER datasets
demonstrate that our model achieves superior performance over state-of-the-art
methods. | [
-0.6995741725,
-0.4984768629,
0.4172389209,
-0.1732567102,
-0.0791723877,
-0.1665036678,
-0.0669959709,
-0.2354728878,
0.319562763,
0.0645947829,
-0.7309051156,
-0.4151326418,
-0.5253363848,
0.6427228451,
0.0432312116,
0.8847665191,
0.1605866849,
0.0140853291,
0.038651213,
-0.0409901701,
-0.5070259571,
0.0184225813,
-1.0602465868,
-0.2111437768,
0.8195068836,
0.7096104026,
0.3388393521,
0.3694327474,
0.3771250248,
0.298850596,
-0.3162825704,
0.0411131419,
-0.3611909449,
0.1976044327,
-0.046266038,
-0.5034236312,
-0.0648691729,
-0.351462692,
0.666811049,
0.66732651,
0.5309260488,
0.2877600789,
0.0045521543,
0.4955928028,
-0.805789113,
0.0007530681,
-0.7252709866,
0.1360090375,
-0.4123484194,
-0.0686424747,
-0.4090231061,
-0.53085953,
0.3148231208,
-0.805868566,
0.4731408954,
0.3526317477,
1.0284948349,
0.2354147285,
-0.136358887,
-0.1826273203,
-0.3515094519,
0.3197110295,
-0.2735943496,
0.354236722,
0.4596935511,
0.7718312144,
-0.3785510957,
-0.738804698,
-0.8409768343,
-0.2200224251,
-0.1839400679,
-0.1762509644,
-0.5882954001,
0.0856599137,
0.4531790316,
-0.2158088535,
-0.5082059503,
0.2793831825,
-0.2846269906,
-0.2097221762,
0.0600774996,
0.35115695,
0.0570202731,
-0.4386693537,
-0.3552596271,
-0.1265938133,
-0.5897006989,
0.3904668093,
0.2156191766,
0.7743617296,
0.072386153,
0.5067563057,
-0.5949109197,
0.8019686937,
0.5091971159,
0.0432537384,
0.2048369348,
0.0177738108,
-0.1448863298,
0.4230526686,
0.7772972584,
0.3380967379,
0.1036433131,
-0.0503533185,
-0.1620524377,
-0.1550678611,
-0.2350738645,
-0.9898399115,
-0.7226281762,
-0.1528117657,
-0.527192235,
-0.2551603019,
-0.2103912681,
-0.9116037488,
-0.5182557702,
-0.0324910283,
0.4510397911,
-0.3091899157,
0.1187774912,
-0.4227241874,
-0.1692513674,
0.2394687384,
0.1567901671,
-0.7217957377,
0.2366648167,
0.3254770041,
1.0771042109,
0.0090754284,
-0.2630399764,
-0.9730440378,
-0.1302821934,
-0.3802691698,
1.0748493671,
-0.7962553501,
-0.4287525117,
-0.2367392927,
0.028399704,
0.1004321277,
-0.5660860538,
0.0383674763,
-0.8370440006,
-0.1356467903,
-0.4269469976,
-0.6408160925,
0.0746110827,
0.5504869819,
-0.7760512233,
1.0428060293,
0.0810570121,
-0.8472043872,
0.6871526837,
-0.4591837823,
-0.1290241629,
0.4451754987,
-0.1548592001,
-0.4178334773,
-0.0789366737,
0.4851397276,
0.5793438554,
0.0063481526,
-0.1859531999,
-0.5136414766,
-0.2606204748,
0.0757081434,
-0.0024426486,
0.3550617695,
-0.167881757,
0.0303100813,
-0.0512603484,
-0.9136627913,
0.0773138255,
0.0547186211,
0.0016559198,
-0.4952832162,
-0.6196879148,
-0.0560624227,
0.2993804514,
0.0014157788,
-0.467069,
0.4563765824,
-0.4458173215,
0.0968979672,
0.6863169074,
0.5600855947,
0.8552855849,
-0.2899996638,
0.7478064299,
-0.0266017877,
-0.1552079171,
-0.4341567457,
-0.4948518872,
-0.6332446933,
-0.1863458902,
0.5768213272,
0.3866742253,
-0.890037775,
0.1723143905,
-0.3343584836,
-0.4266483784,
-0.5247272849,
0.0718882605,
0.3555907905,
0.9843841195,
0.4577961266,
0.0301731359,
-0.7112805843,
-0.9145387411,
0.0166647062,
-0.1262425184,
-0.0080795642,
0.6862547398,
0.4930411875,
0.1003695428,
1.2362389565,
-0.5218783617,
-0.5820606947,
-0.3176100254,
0.0550824441,
0.4048873186,
0.3296226859,
0.3597218692,
-0.6333913803,
-0.6411195993,
-0.0457299873,
-0.4118302763,
-0.022268692,
-0.1627262533,
-0.1452597678,
-0.3190967441,
0.4370173812,
-0.3089726269,
0.1947085112,
0.1244320422,
-0.0228039473,
0.4790777862,
0.2964861095,
-0.0331216156,
-1.1264574528,
0.0900959894,
0.1459302157,
-0.1977876127,
-0.5878328681,
-0.3431773186,
-0.1037452072,
-0.1717520952,
-0.6256697178,
1.0621199608,
-0.4875566959,
0.0622906014,
-0.4124380648,
0.188788563,
-0.1408131868,
0.2691928744,
0.1000328586,
0.8657696843,
0.9603999257,
-0.958663404,
0.2852702737,
0.6245821118,
-0.080328986,
0.9688870907,
-0.7214311361,
0.3621295691,
-0.4403246641,
0.294868499,
-0.7271849513,
-0.4452394247,
0.3892166018,
-0.5465883017,
0.3447683156,
-0.80623281,
-0.240542382,
-0.443492651,
-0.0122280419,
0.335095197,
0.3847232759,
-0.8553568721,
0.4885197878,
-0.0851712823,
-0.072424531,
-0.314602077,
-0.3266145885,
0.013720734,
-0.1466095299,
-0.4695936441,
0.4966844618,
0.1365427673,
0.2889064252,
0.0696464926,
-0.3035078943,
-0.2950617373,
-0.3455190659,
0.3639000654,
0.236075893,
-0.4341983199,
0.3532660902,
0.0199079812,
-0.5315849781,
-0.3134075105,
-0.161156863,
0.3020508885,
-0.1086887419,
0.0385263786,
-0.6360123754,
0.152868256,
-0.1694021672,
-0.0204330999,
0.4850702882,
0.4677820802,
-0.4528326094,
-0.3686565459,
-0.4057340324,
-0.5953766704,
-0.5029589534,
0.1243643463,
-0.9866797924,
-0.9535766244,
0.4211117923,
-0.505553484,
-0.4716553986,
0.0888251066,
0.0510752872,
-0.0431086943,
0.7525773644,
0.6236327291,
-0.2115108222,
0.4160052538,
-0.2392500043,
0.0956744775,
-0.8942785859,
-0.4879721403,
-0.7164510489,
-0.6602868438,
-0.3843176663,
-0.1753381491,
0.5024579763,
0.3480362594,
-0.1459605396,
0.6244475842,
-0.4463694394,
0.9925460219,
0.6037403345,
0.2269895822,
-0.0369521677,
-0.1257227808,
-0.3827574849,
-0.3360600471,
-0.8153803945,
-0.4963781834,
0.4929743707,
-0.0597927123,
0.6213764548,
-0.1436354369,
1.1513673067,
-0.0340111814,
-0.0668624043,
-0.9840817451,
0.6445792913,
0.1110319644,
-0.4344483018,
-0.3203315437,
-0.2727922201,
-1.0483760834,
-0.1685014069,
-0.2649942338,
-1.0162134171,
0.5487933159,
0.2827813327,
-0.6159664989,
0.1640919745,
-0.2694583535,
0.6966063976,
0.2882019579,
-0.0556256212,
0.5783296824,
-0.7565797567,
0.1518950015,
0.1747512519,
-0.3866051733,
-0.186211437,
-0.1538222432,
0.6310384274,
-0.1503314376,
0.8363925815,
-0.2423351556,
0.5307055116,
0.1935960203,
0.4860582948,
0.8620339632,
0.2487329543,
-0.0523256175,
-0.1812674105,
-0.3947332501,
-0.2311789691,
-0.7111825943,
0.6203578711,
-0.3091171682,
-0.2283737063,
-0.0661948174,
0.1142568514,
-0.1753145903,
0.5275815725,
0.7267267108,
0.2501631379,
-0.1413022727,
-0.110920094,
0.7151770592,
0.2070434242,
0.6340997219,
0.0725130141,
0.021131441,
-0.4560345709,
0.7811700702,
-0.1327708811,
-0.2407690585,
0.49680987,
0.2474794984,
-0.3539484143,
-0.2648199797,
-0.5077475905,
-0.0347633101,
-0.78400594,
-0.756311059,
-0.8517691493,
0.0151782101,
-0.0287917163,
-0.4716450274,
-0.3507717252,
-0.050711412,
-0.5196903348,
-0.050589405,
0.6096345186,
0.4770003259,
0.1148674786,
0.6023795605,
-0.872010231,
0.4355647266,
0.4252252877,
0.2972047031,
0.1022940353,
-0.4158469439,
0.2292869836,
-0.5091724396,
0.0953078344,
-1.312122345,
0.0483101048,
0.4911952019,
0.4293263257,
0.4848914146,
0.3196448684,
0.7588328719,
-0.5910972953,
0.59070611,
0.3048323095,
-0.8660502434,
0.9837505817,
-0.0083437515,
0.3252462447,
1.0331505537,
0.8306598663,
-0.4090016186,
0.1388748884,
-0.4945130944,
-0.6119600534,
0.7403816581,
0.0546475165,
0.2285933048,
-0.261927098,
0.1954297721,
0.1174537465,
-0.1129790694,
-0.5005030632,
-0.3331780434,
0.0785664916,
0.1263554245,
0.4813697934,
-0.0161838382,
0.3019491434,
-0.013566697,
0.7413295507,
-0.4859440625,
0.1268129051,
0.2919362187,
-0.1588774472,
0.0987213105,
0.3991548419,
0.1405796111,
0.0226051398,
0.1079781577,
0.2236327529,
0.6159936786,
-0.1648519039,
0.4194625616,
0.0964554623,
-0.5450255275,
0.330114305,
0.2306268364,
0.9979148507,
0.4441752732,
-0.081574358,
0.6429049969,
0.1641736031,
-0.0441817641,
0.1235258132,
0.1524067074,
-0.1992990375,
0.5209056139,
0.230191946,
0.2475915253,
0.3583677709,
0.206792146,
0.3393727541,
0.2781765461,
-0.7114860415,
-0.3261685967,
0.4339367151,
-0.0940924138,
-0.349399358,
0.7633738518,
-0.7127733231,
-0.5002153516,
0.5474073887,
0.6500362158,
0.8823472261,
0.0181780495,
0.3912432492,
0.8800674081,
0.0368712097,
-0.1710664928,
0.0732575059,
-0.2463243604,
-0.6115925908,
-0.0271307267,
-0.4482145011,
-0.1725382656,
0.0096554467,
-0.5284743905,
0.704457581,
-0.5776346326,
-0.4663676322,
0.4486316144,
-0.1572511494,
-0.9507321119,
-0.0639091283,
0.0572070032,
0.911654532,
-0.7165865302,
0.4056850076,
0.9522483945,
-0.5618945956,
-1.0275598764,
-0.0235148091,
0.189701423,
-0.5252628326,
1.1077885628,
0.3307073712,
-0.0811947584,
0.3546142876,
-0.5571468472,
-0.6882022619,
0.9594534636,
0.0104894424,
-0.8748583198,
-0.2430745363,
-0.3869290948,
0.1387569606,
-0.4850974083,
0.4938838184,
0.2728822827,
0.5417075753,
0.5289868116,
-0.647433579,
0.2224228382,
-0.0777328983,
0.3824872375,
0.3841479123,
-0.4145495594,
0.4420891106,
-0.6143737435,
-0.1966772228,
0.2142163515,
0.79974401,
0.5398460627,
0.5641056895,
0.4201183617,
0.230250746,
0.9441392422,
0.1420528293,
0.6262176037,
0.0608154163,
0.1606280357,
1.3901193142,
-0.3807934523,
0.8142362833,
0.4488503039,
-0.1937486529,
0.348086983,
0.5102878809,
-0.4811290205,
0.6846920848,
0.2823996842,
-0.3907569051,
-0.3466889858,
-0.3388477564,
-0.2282874882,
0.4120483994,
0.0256734379,
-0.2636524737,
-0.5714296699,
0.2922497988,
-0.1548471302,
-0.1047030985,
-0.3678209782,
1.0360401869,
0.1615269184,
-0.2322393656,
0.3535716534,
-0.2210427076,
0.7501805425,
-0.2740627825,
-0.2288470417,
-0.1488552094,
-0.2556634545,
-0.2586810291,
-0.4823157489,
-0.1423438191,
-0.0070738061,
-0.3590062559,
0.3476929367,
1.0938664675,
-0.0910406038,
-0.3688109219,
-0.0873279274,
0.4417720735,
0.2589915991,
0.0551277548,
-0.5122386813,
-0.3726684451,
-0.3209648728,
-0.0498767383,
0.1736618727,
0.5407208204,
-0.085494943,
0.7285628915,
0.6657558084,
0.1904425621,
0.2910368443,
0.0837330222,
0.8960871696,
-0.6231126189,
-0.6118873358,
-0.7797544003,
0.2867458463,
0.0216872822,
-0.646622479,
0.5713769794,
0.4933983982,
0.7894858122,
-0.1934808195,
0.4947838187,
-0.1447073966,
0.2248699516,
-0.5157690644,
0.4499973059,
-0.0768637583,
-0.0917128995,
-0.3556912839,
-1.0929327011,
-0.4987049401,
0.5355798602,
-0.2720992863,
0.1605280638,
0.427623868,
1.1514084339,
-0.3205773234,
-0.1152948067,
0.3694737852,
-0.1413681209,
-0.0789449587,
0.5658807158,
0.8609763384,
-0.4781904221,
0.6102187634,
-0.361523211,
0.0958575308,
-0.3340254128,
-0.9846150279,
-1.2171720266,
-0.4434331954,
-0.5274349451,
-0.3616830111,
0.168465063,
1.2030062675,
0.972417295,
-0.7897685766,
0.5597352982,
-0.1824571043,
0.1210946962,
-0.0411911272,
-0.1976300478,
0.3439342976,
-0.4982236028,
-0.5841210485,
0.5181127191,
0.0188484974,
0.2141158432,
0.2877785563,
-0.228092581,
0.168449685,
-0.5145556331,
0.1370563954,
0.5226513147,
-0.5699614882,
0.0049667587,
0.3685414791,
0.029134674,
0.1468600631,
0.7834320068,
-1.250754714,
0.6371344924,
0.610326767,
0.9063317776,
0.4035413265,
-0.2287056148,
0.0143855363,
-1.1498738527,
-0.0811431706,
0.4462452829,
0.0859756321,
0.3349135518,
-0.4768718183,
0.1333947182,
0.0737220943,
-0.3329233229,
-0.6410336494,
0.2708181441,
-0.8381955028,
0.2343541086,
0.8284060955,
-0.0029720964,
-0.1608993858,
-0.0621012077,
-0.22241503,
0.1647344232,
-0.8075492978,
0.2824709117,
0.3367082179,
-0.2668012977,
-0.6841332912,
-0.204698965,
0.5242906213,
-0.0198445208,
-0.6275671124,
-0.5246105194,
0.293610096,
0.3878478408,
0.0328116305,
0.6411185861,
0.3863715529,
0.373421073,
0.1551275998,
-0.2162320912,
-0.3093408942,
-0.5463958383,
-0.611296773,
0.2399825007,
0.1155087203,
-0.3799566627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12212v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12212v2 | Prompting ChatGPT in MNER: Enhanced Multimodal Named Entity Recognition with Auxiliary Refined Knowledge | 2023-05-20T15:24:38 | 2023-10-18T17:05:58 | Jinyuan Li, Han Li, Zhuo Pan, Di Sun, Jiahao Wang, Wenkun Zhang, Gang Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal Named Entity Recognition (MNER) on social media aims to enhance
textual entity prediction by incorporating image-based clues. Existing studies
mainly focus on maximizing the utilization of pertinent image information or
incorporating external knowledge from explicit knowledge bases. However, these
methods either neglect the necessity of providing the model with external
knowledge, or encounter issues of high redundancy in the retrieved knowledge.
In this paper, we present PGIM -- a two-stage framework that aims to leverage
ChatGPT as an implicit knowledge base and enable it to heuristically generate
auxiliary knowledge for more efficient entity prediction. Specifically, PGIM
contains a Multimodal Similar Example Awareness module that selects suitable
examples from a small number of predefined artificial samples. These examples
are then integrated into a formatted prompt template tailored to the MNER and
guide ChatGPT to generate auxiliary refined knowledge. Finally, the acquired
knowledge is integrated with the original text and fed into a downstream model
for further processing. Extensive experiments show that PGIM outperforms
state-of-the-art methods on two classic MNER datasets and exhibits a stronger
robustness and generalization capability. | [
-0.5656965375,
-0.7451070547,
0.7048720717,
0.2844691873,
-0.371948123,
-0.0970160067,
-0.3001235127,
-0.3677077293,
0.0409698114,
0.254029125,
-0.6521614194,
-0.4758501947,
-0.7812202573,
0.1155598238,
-0.2158827633,
1.0382745266,
0.0742378682,
0.0471467189,
-0.2545461059,
0.1089143753,
-0.6542209387,
-0.0841567889,
-1.1920565367,
-0.2100874037,
0.8115053773,
0.5305359364,
0.3689026237,
0.3019133806,
0.4279546738,
0.1699754298,
0.2570203245,
0.5767786503,
-0.4814041555,
0.3834320307,
-0.1123954505,
-0.2684436142,
-0.2180163711,
-0.2546091676,
0.5310556889,
0.2549234033,
-0.0157932341,
0.0841744021,
0.0684891641,
0.3730509877,
-0.5395655632,
0.4891062677,
-1.0404605865,
-0.1070790067,
0.0577387773,
-0.4537893236,
-0.4026610553,
-0.1722094417,
0.2689862549,
-0.7540590167,
0.2508144081,
0.1505008936,
0.7768861055,
0.2666916251,
-0.4664112628,
-0.3052658439,
-0.6264635324,
0.4452236593,
-0.1437493563,
0.5170630813,
0.4997056425,
0.5710963011,
-0.1912829429,
-0.9849461913,
-0.7734916806,
-0.1684782654,
-0.1296946406,
0.207744047,
-0.1434923261,
0.0032117846,
0.3039964139,
-0.0279270839,
-0.4074366093,
-0.2426226586,
-0.5467287302,
-0.1953914464,
0.3457896113,
-0.1693344265,
0.4454965293,
-0.4361592531,
-0.6404422522,
0.0724971443,
-0.6464945078,
-0.0115485033,
0.262037009,
0.2060627639,
0.0536227338,
0.637040019,
-0.1447379589,
0.2151240259,
0.1989722997,
0.0362903662,
0.1869379729,
-0.2090171427,
0.0693356767,
0.1128573716,
0.9996041059,
0.7127786279,
0.264344424,
-0.2064664811,
-0.1984637827,
0.0998483077,
0.1091831475,
-0.9405155778,
-0.5052812099,
0.2987003624,
-0.2843545079,
0.1002340689,
0.0424039178,
-0.9858595729,
-0.5383728147,
-0.4152495861,
0.3246788681,
-0.8824828267,
-0.3107255697,
-0.3504740894,
-0.5554641485,
0.1978079528,
0.6490277648,
-0.8697459102,
-0.0804905891,
0.7042268515,
0.8508565426,
0.0883890167,
-0.0582053959,
-0.6579694152,
0.4107388556,
0.0419187024,
1.1639565229,
-0.8555857539,
-0.5349799395,
-0.2236124873,
0.078959696,
-0.2990345955,
-0.23891747,
0.6719764471,
-0.5824803114,
0.3739840984,
-0.2080995739,
-0.5259895325,
-0.3518631756,
0.4276840389,
-0.5211056471,
1.1138987541,
-0.1710833758,
-0.9783602357,
0.6957625747,
-0.6216496825,
-0.2232967019,
0.1630010158,
-0.4878357351,
-0.3001880646,
-0.0311131068,
0.6237283349,
0.6421390772,
-0.080941014,
0.3465649486,
-0.4193394482,
-0.1571058035,
0.0230567586,
-0.482611835,
0.2010190189,
-0.019343948,
-0.022433389,
0.0473122969,
-0.8636502624,
0.0995745137,
0.1646715254,
-0.2821865678,
-0.344276011,
0.0724482387,
-0.0292491522,
0.2949756384,
-0.0999488905,
-0.2869082391,
0.2676000893,
0.0390958041,
0.4302286804,
0.6475946903,
0.4581862986,
0.4641900063,
-0.250600487,
0.3219537139,
0.0941705331,
-0.0669942945,
-0.5852586627,
-0.8180292845,
-0.6436786652,
-0.4781363308,
0.4110302627,
0.7272542715,
-1.1067967415,
-0.0361653343,
-0.5314548612,
-0.3426485062,
-0.364244163,
0.1169287264,
-0.0541051999,
0.4706954956,
0.5604704618,
-0.0241034757,
-0.7966965437,
-0.9360516667,
-0.090381451,
-0.1438033581,
-0.3338781297,
0.5120540857,
0.4113487303,
-0.4955569804,
0.9764871597,
-0.4084452093,
-0.360850364,
-0.2364781052,
0.3562244773,
-0.0472101234,
0.5644432306,
0.3130878508,
-1.0678290129,
-0.4659661055,
-0.0368710533,
-0.5311925411,
0.1410536915,
-0.1487890035,
-0.3835413754,
-0.1588219702,
0.3661288023,
-0.8107554317,
-0.012720474,
0.3624888957,
0.0235804953,
0.3112037778,
-0.0393851884,
0.2413552701,
-1.4409658909,
-0.0490452312,
0.1562465876,
-0.2184587568,
-0.581115365,
-0.3986179233,
0.1783186793,
-0.0890891328,
-0.09276025,
0.7244377732,
-0.73460567,
0.3501482308,
-0.157983467,
0.3151474595,
-0.0699339733,
0.5982728601,
0.2805419564,
0.6060100794,
0.6790811419,
-0.7056990862,
0.2816185653,
0.1769120991,
-0.0412549414,
0.6723374128,
-0.6356925964,
0.3059233129,
-0.6074740887,
0.2175542563,
-1.0733808279,
-0.5003830194,
0.5830378532,
-0.7346603274,
0.5828573704,
-0.6420818567,
-0.4728116989,
-0.074130781,
-0.2574817538,
0.1627061516,
0.5143154263,
-0.2862744033,
0.9429542422,
0.394253552,
-0.4091202021,
-0.5339599848,
-0.4623736441,
0.1007351726,
-0.0667867213,
-0.6012404561,
0.4062240422,
0.1598252654,
0.044877056,
0.1894966662,
-0.112051487,
-0.1564729363,
-0.2525295317,
0.5310741067,
0.3701269031,
-0.2927525342,
0.4511626363,
0.2611988783,
-0.2300572991,
-0.0063028191,
-0.3597160578,
0.5911234617,
0.2243818939,
-0.3558535576,
-0.3979147971,
0.3281660974,
0.2780694664,
-0.1761225015,
0.7288329601,
1.1044427156,
-0.635543108,
-0.0808410943,
-0.69313097,
-0.2266678065,
-0.4287311137,
0.2111940533,
-0.4785761833,
-0.8093709946,
0.3044001162,
-0.2377907485,
0.0684185326,
0.4907514453,
0.3109100759,
0.0386370197,
1.1985430717,
0.5748946071,
0.1549551934,
0.685106039,
-0.1071342155,
0.1479669064,
-0.8115884662,
-0.3315354884,
-0.2226884812,
-0.1384379268,
-0.6638150811,
-0.7120236158,
0.259024024,
0.1063030884,
0.0530677736,
0.2679598331,
-0.2331794053,
0.4572577775,
0.5716493726,
0.3599261343,
0.3322457373,
0.2339931428,
-0.1832512319,
0.055052802,
-0.643804431,
-0.5891833901,
0.9568356276,
0.266405493,
0.4398082197,
-0.012118672,
0.5025490522,
0.1642430574,
0.5803788304,
-0.8886882663,
0.4387769103,
0.2180873007,
-0.5351074934,
-0.0352811143,
-0.5282765031,
-0.8228213191,
0.3185598552,
-0.4772199094,
-0.7745629549,
0.1546184272,
0.4613022208,
-0.3787924349,
-0.0097989487,
-0.8925394416,
0.6316003799,
0.0006740745,
-0.3117652833,
-0.0843734071,
-0.5587717891,
0.3288519681,
0.1290335804,
0.0665446445,
-0.3934696317,
-0.2628605664,
0.3846946657,
0.0770175084,
0.7460381985,
-0.2757209837,
0.0556918085,
0.2786741853,
-0.1965786815,
0.7218071818,
0.6311314106,
0.023775965,
-0.086064972,
-0.2824410796,
-0.1044605002,
-0.6766178012,
0.6400638819,
-0.4118404984,
-0.5841035843,
-0.0095781945,
-0.291346103,
-0.4649519324,
0.3170149624,
0.4155436456,
0.4678797424,
-0.1250823587,
0.1974210292,
0.7968840003,
-0.1026040986,
0.2439004183,
0.0933819413,
-0.2086215466,
-0.7358777523,
0.9275356531,
0.0395736769,
-0.0580627099,
0.6440255046,
-0.1329264343,
-0.4987155497,
-0.4129789174,
-0.7026438713,
0.1232412457,
-0.8286166191,
-0.2536012232,
-1.2899876833,
-0.1627951264,
-0.3594805896,
0.1102294326,
-0.0709515661,
-0.2987591326,
-0.1631350368,
-0.1091736928,
0.3962565064,
0.3035609126,
0.2609710097,
0.2737888694,
-1.0195016861,
0.348002404,
0.4745536447,
0.3429918587,
-0.1193919107,
-0.1824879944,
0.2331465185,
0.2534710467,
-0.1641421318,
-0.9862667918,
0.0636598915,
0.4750887454,
0.7218543887,
0.6337261796,
0.0404950753,
0.6635178924,
-0.7253859043,
0.4836253226,
0.2611921132,
-0.4378196299,
0.6601330638,
-0.5624887943,
0.1209844872,
0.4731973112,
0.6919791102,
-0.7560294271,
-0.2344521284,
-0.5144584775,
-0.9844398499,
0.5169685483,
0.313781023,
0.4521570504,
-0.1676205546,
0.0986668169,
0.2886632979,
0.3631442189,
-0.6298034787,
-0.1994018555,
-0.1367072463,
-0.2747195661,
0.1468349695,
-0.3726180196,
0.0593767986,
0.0065418058,
0.8943693638,
-0.2706072927,
0.4867963493,
0.2298445404,
-0.3588950634,
0.1737498045,
0.468936801,
0.4564971924,
0.5360967517,
-0.0697227865,
0.1422811151,
0.2516773939,
-0.4240306318,
-0.1955003738,
0.4245601892,
-0.2031980157,
0.1703926921,
0.1120676547,
1.0633047819,
0.3423703909,
-0.5071477294,
0.3832529187,
-0.3377886713,
-0.0975311622,
-0.3756990135,
0.0872188956,
0.1739092022,
0.3556023538,
0.5198919177,
0.3429962695,
0.2161565721,
-0.3909977973,
0.1750014275,
0.4275897741,
-0.4193957448,
-0.3021421134,
0.5953733921,
0.1566349566,
0.1183598042,
0.5572220087,
-0.4047824144,
-0.5562438369,
0.3056182861,
0.4192890525,
0.6660051942,
0.0345849246,
0.1649985015,
0.5196540356,
0.2666514516,
-0.1844186783,
0.287971735,
-0.3215922415,
-0.8125846982,
-0.2701707482,
-0.5009588599,
-0.3271272779,
0.1367637813,
-0.2808690667,
0.6093147397,
-0.5682098866,
-0.4068454504,
0.1870260537,
-0.4613195956,
-0.7991312146,
0.0255146585,
0.2859885991,
0.7430435419,
-0.4108786583,
0.5087777376,
1.0169826746,
-0.4836523533,
-0.8575063348,
0.1559635401,
0.0065853661,
-0.8563489318,
0.5240798593,
0.611449182,
0.0946038365,
0.2093608677,
-0.2648637891,
-0.7799310684,
1.197660923,
0.349709332,
-0.4763534963,
-0.1320341825,
-0.0928440019,
0.278647989,
-0.286564678,
0.5734838247,
0.0732088313,
0.6068873405,
0.5093407631,
-0.6977589726,
0.1267892569,
-0.4609349668,
0.1600835621,
0.3497013152,
-0.395852387,
0.4705203176,
-0.409227401,
-0.6404787898,
-0.3822244406,
0.7251862288,
0.2510267198,
0.4723027945,
0.6113922596,
0.3585316241,
0.8556365371,
-0.1527498215,
0.710535109,
-0.345652014,
0.1933175623,
1.1764711142,
-0.168156147,
0.8106853962,
0.4523460567,
0.0225964487,
0.3993630111,
0.7973178625,
-0.2622412741,
0.4538548887,
-0.2337026745,
-0.4020029008,
-0.257520318,
-0.2725197077,
-0.4794532061,
0.3589861095,
0.5090045333,
-0.6008304358,
-0.2440340072,
0.0022579634,
0.1636778116,
-0.5026018023,
-0.5322090387,
0.9473327994,
0.1515278518,
-0.8340711594,
0.0315351002,
-0.0999305621,
0.6938182712,
-0.5364226103,
-0.2851916254,
0.0008662302,
0.0904008448,
-0.2095945477,
-0.6626199484,
0.1297639161,
-0.0308144782,
-0.3769105375,
-0.10793598,
1.3222562075,
-0.8239736557,
-0.5103393793,
0.0747553781,
0.6940915585,
-0.1046735644,
-0.5390703678,
-0.5085440874,
-0.474791795,
-0.10243918,
-0.2695259154,
0.1421066821,
0.7710914016,
-0.0589900576,
0.7701488137,
0.7681463957,
-0.2258346677,
0.010728498,
0.1745556444,
0.9298960567,
-0.254979223,
-0.4482085109,
-0.9704133272,
0.669228971,
-0.3715542555,
-0.0493584275,
0.6269945502,
0.3644390702,
0.7498400807,
-0.1581039727,
1.0359367132,
-0.2000236511,
0.2956273556,
-0.5955315828,
0.6599357724,
-0.4488808215,
0.0857986808,
-0.2271881998,
-0.8215191364,
-0.0707076117,
0.2210272104,
-0.3481868207,
0.1943581104,
0.5881894231,
0.8428382874,
-0.2096118182,
0.1333849728,
0.1696196496,
-0.2351181507,
0.0572764985,
0.3682107925,
0.9944384694,
-0.2397590876,
0.7244881392,
-0.1731811464,
-0.0255722366,
-0.1197851896,
-0.9557487965,
-1.0020052195,
-0.6770486236,
-0.3153190911,
-0.0330510214,
0.1238793209,
1.3355157375,
0.6938441396,
-0.7469248176,
0.5644765496,
0.0548131913,
0.1038968861,
0.0167277511,
-0.2583145201,
0.168282181,
-0.356205374,
-0.7319081426,
0.1369143277,
0.2234569788,
0.2354943007,
0.225460887,
0.1633923352,
-0.1085848212,
-0.0489041433,
0.6568955779,
-0.0560317338,
-0.4749879241,
-0.2668282092,
-0.0093084341,
-0.0368556865,
0.1111177951,
0.7887317538,
-0.6740695238,
0.2669505179,
0.6138076782,
0.7214425206,
0.2074756175,
0.1867333055,
0.6995357871,
-0.976184845,
-0.0705450624,
0.0809818953,
0.6715341806,
0.4587181509,
-0.6207498908,
0.4056810737,
0.4069161117,
-0.3189900815,
-0.5183832645,
0.0804387182,
-0.9490275979,
0.0679566562,
1.2878793478,
-0.141498208,
0.032344345,
-0.0586706512,
-0.6204664707,
0.3791756034,
-0.9663866162,
0.6006325483,
0.6443352103,
-0.0294592623,
-0.7538323998,
-0.7302399278,
0.5463466048,
-0.0151159577,
-0.8050758243,
-0.265816927,
0.6628682017,
0.4313614964,
0.121503368,
0.7237353921,
0.2060023546,
0.2494725138,
0.1141674519,
0.0042487113,
-0.3234501183,
-0.2476238012,
0.177544862,
0.3012109101,
-0.0808928609,
-0.1392183453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12209v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12209v1 | Self-Distillation with Meta Learning for Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-05-20T15:12:25 | 2023-05-20T15:12:25 | Yunshui Li, Junhao Liu, Chengming Li, Min Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a selfdistillation framework with meta
learning(MetaSD) for knowledge graph completion with dynamic pruning, which
aims to learn compressed graph embeddings and tackle the longtail samples.
Specifically, we first propose a dynamic pruning technique to obtain a small
pruned model from a large source model, where the pruning mask of the pruned
model could be updated adaptively per epoch after the model weights are
updated. The pruned model is supposed to be more sensitive to difficult to
memorize samples(e.g., longtail samples) than the source model. Then, we
propose a onestep meta selfdistillation method for distilling comprehensive
knowledge from the source model to the pruned model, where the two models
coevolve in a dynamic manner during training. In particular, we exploit the
performance of the pruned model, which is trained alongside the source model in
one iteration, to improve the source models knowledge transfer ability for the
next iteration via meta learning. Extensive experiments show that MetaSD
achieves competitive performance compared to strong baselines, while being 10x
smaller than baselines. | [
-0.3019606769,
-0.7046723962,
0.7104071379,
0.0321907178,
-0.5091290474,
0.5141966343,
0.0016035978,
-0.1462275684,
0.6438310146,
0.5681860447,
-0.8510545492,
-0.6757752895,
-0.5809733868,
0.2461600602,
-0.3344462514,
0.8245219588,
-0.2019780129,
-0.5275809765,
-0.3810476065,
-0.2273373008,
-0.5390980244,
-0.2410655767,
-0.3871991038,
-0.297206223,
0.2995323539,
0.3407582641,
0.2560830116,
0.8780384064,
0.0894148722,
0.376263082,
-0.1131787002,
0.4683595896,
-0.7738404274,
0.2979758382,
-0.3570225239,
-0.1217095256,
-0.3322422802,
0.2131415457,
0.6273374557,
0.7274259329,
-0.4256445765,
0.4375647306,
0.5969408154,
0.6520659328,
-0.7468246222,
0.4706659317,
-0.4178926349,
0.1658827066,
-0.0257565398,
-0.0981518552,
-0.2738922238,
-0.454891026,
0.2424204648,
-0.8451195955,
0.3197100759,
-0.2423674315,
0.5192747116,
0.7038987875,
-0.8629876971,
-0.1822074056,
-0.7388817072,
0.4113642871,
-0.4840852618,
0.2799645662,
0.1908280402,
0.4901791513,
0.0353693217,
-1.3157941103,
-0.3966419697,
0.282328248,
-0.1415594369,
0.222626403,
0.0843748301,
0.2079053521,
0.2104135156,
0.1799940169,
-0.1653587222,
-0.2033591568,
-0.4976359308,
-0.184341222,
0.5216116309,
0.0899307951,
-0.26627931,
-0.4658430517,
-0.5319023728,
-0.3152386546,
-0.5375101566,
-0.2908332348,
0.4306606054,
0.1329476386,
0.4363908172,
0.3149980903,
-0.2886863947,
0.9549456835,
0.1857721806,
-0.5144569874,
0.5584974289,
-0.3620008528,
-0.3654980063,
0.0337531678,
0.8342831135,
0.1539005935,
0.1147053614,
-0.0883608311,
0.17871508,
-0.5985962152,
0.3284217715,
-0.8698878884,
-0.6792801619,
0.1802396774,
-0.5341285467,
-0.3965772092,
-0.0266819447,
-0.9178930521,
-0.1398555487,
-0.3003659844,
0.4393186569,
-0.4452057481,
-0.498555541,
0.1712500751,
-0.3426326215,
-0.4676049948,
0.2227714956,
-0.6243653893,
0.2007961869,
0.4272959232,
0.9470306039,
-0.09720321,
-0.4651959836,
-0.1973211467,
0.7060058117,
-0.2652003765,
0.4143077135,
-0.1862023771,
-0.5350581408,
-0.312174201,
0.0373359844,
-0.039677456,
-0.6425507665,
0.3892435431,
-0.6040351391,
-0.2258506715,
-0.4871150553,
-0.6502884626,
-0.6124085188,
0.1906214803,
-0.8574874997,
0.8871549368,
0.3329911828,
-0.9548766613,
0.4538717866,
-0.4129745364,
-0.4381786287,
0.0468729362,
-0.0565003417,
-0.5025976896,
-0.0975048244,
-0.0245199427,
0.4572623372,
0.1351086199,
0.4951163232,
-0.5797916055,
0.0761575401,
-0.2922888696,
-0.2703844309,
0.6822520494,
0.3005124927,
-0.1938240826,
-0.0464367606,
-0.8991972804,
0.0556334108,
0.2737323642,
-0.1629740596,
-0.492349714,
0.1664298773,
-0.7110302448,
0.2571302056,
0.0308553614,
-0.3927296996,
0.6352853179,
-0.0996926874,
0.8066327572,
0.840818584,
0.5067193508,
0.2961500585,
0.1452936232,
0.2802037597,
0.0027717839,
0.1609463841,
-0.1259953976,
-0.1040964648,
-0.5472228527,
-0.4697916806,
0.7702798843,
0.3081418276,
-0.8026381731,
0.6347624063,
-0.4061882794,
-0.4415751398,
-0.38986817,
0.4153716862,
0.0496439748,
0.8898590803,
0.625500381,
-0.2083473206,
-0.295330286,
-0.7266310453,
0.1439007223,
0.0872341394,
0.0239653736,
0.2632491589,
0.4328019321,
-0.0519108772,
1.358708024,
-1.0575885773,
-0.7557080388,
-0.1112680286,
0.5311859846,
0.1491841972,
0.3764051199,
0.7070248723,
-0.6071990728,
-0.6392883062,
-0.5379217863,
-0.8684524298,
0.1067728102,
0.2344521433,
0.0804460347,
-0.3865143657,
0.6385406852,
-0.5220156312,
0.3015015721,
0.5814664364,
-0.1627295464,
0.3737277687,
-0.3465479016,
0.0874606967,
-1.1450634003,
-0.0844987482,
-0.4462047219,
-0.5897186399,
-0.2833929062,
-0.0707811341,
0.1813051105,
-0.2370359004,
-0.3517795801,
0.2082703412,
-0.7558888793,
0.2499662042,
-0.3696272969,
0.1027539372,
0.1668281704,
0.4061467648,
0.0539866462,
0.3952439725,
0.3662373424,
-0.8099588752,
0.7032592893,
0.3250768185,
-0.4735662341,
0.0852204338,
-0.5372086763,
0.0168654956,
-0.2310042977,
0.59678334,
-1.0245747566,
-0.0806923732,
0.2161419988,
0.0802809373,
0.609870553,
-0.619571805,
-0.2071870863,
-0.7520493269,
-0.0896074176,
0.5915477276,
0.4380023777,
-0.5456808805,
0.7922562361,
0.2443758249,
0.0819060728,
-0.5291124582,
-0.5348562002,
-0.1727212369,
-0.2480330169,
-0.659825325,
0.5924749374,
0.0696433634,
0.36641559,
0.3276702762,
-0.209592253,
0.1671991944,
0.2265199274,
0.2356637716,
-0.1549240649,
0.2631062269,
0.3366558254,
0.2282104045,
-0.2860776782,
0.0515453964,
-0.7130841017,
0.4967334867,
0.443015337,
-0.6623886228,
-0.3761288524,
-0.074575454,
0.4705326557,
-0.2934772372,
0.7299888134,
0.4326884449,
-0.1323650777,
-0.3251975179,
-0.5636833906,
-0.4385163188,
-0.5223093033,
0.2127693892,
-0.5707421303,
-0.6130388975,
0.5108975768,
-0.6796025038,
-0.1230393723,
0.6938221455,
0.0010976903,
-0.1110754162,
0.7843692303,
0.6082251072,
0.0182397626,
0.4237754345,
-0.9701822996,
0.0506548807,
-0.7886558771,
-0.2986155748,
-0.1975771189,
-0.5967728496,
-0.3544732928,
-0.4439427853,
0.4781833887,
0.1731659472,
-0.027287975,
0.273889184,
-0.6768423319,
0.4377961457,
0.6652209759,
0.2577199936,
0.3663005829,
-0.1325544864,
-0.2088181973,
-0.0866604149,
-0.8983586431,
0.0579612702,
1.1602392197,
0.3451015353,
0.8223006725,
-0.1278622448,
1.1151771545,
0.3315246999,
0.0516910478,
-0.5530012846,
0.2863419056,
0.058599811,
-0.4798553884,
-0.5376676917,
-0.6892889738,
-0.7456800938,
-0.0156375449,
-0.2130606771,
-0.1812084317,
0.4970210791,
0.3576064706,
-0.5822604895,
0.4755806029,
-0.6033067703,
0.9679127932,
-0.1397127658,
-0.340919435,
-0.3698854744,
-0.6649948955,
0.4943226576,
-0.1861255169,
0.1778003573,
-0.1457066983,
0.1482786089,
1.0194078684,
-0.5293613672,
0.9572944641,
-0.4944592714,
0.0458581932,
0.6945316792,
0.5100990534,
0.7881658077,
0.0052963952,
0.1106792986,
0.015357079,
0.0834288597,
-0.2493623197,
-0.8515722156,
0.3551362455,
-0.741830945,
-0.7997413874,
-0.3616750836,
-0.0868106186,
0.0133370198,
0.4510643184,
0.1611049324,
0.3114671111,
-0.1231133342,
0.2578864992,
0.7486323118,
0.2033442259,
0.2723526061,
0.4462815523,
-0.2720986903,
-0.6626957655,
0.9463202953,
0.7298113108,
0.4136168659,
-0.0877581462,
0.1639606953,
-0.2655537724,
-0.6943668127,
-0.2566961944,
0.4644476175,
-0.7923518419,
-0.6035590172,
-0.8211622238,
-0.4624865651,
-0.6290435791,
0.2346675694,
-0.6199198365,
-0.3797546029,
-0.3722164333,
-0.4095462859,
0.2778618932,
0.8591966033,
-0.3156935275,
0.2128822207,
-0.9596397877,
0.3658148348,
0.6934015751,
0.2544643879,
0.2048836499,
-0.3760491014,
-0.2048316002,
0.2539412379,
-0.5618502498,
-1.1231086254,
0.366985023,
0.3674642444,
0.6768766642,
0.6755341887,
0.5988659859,
0.7819389105,
-0.4982238412,
0.5283652544,
0.2152525336,
-0.8662192822,
0.6662980318,
-0.0655889362,
0.0475624986,
0.9285549521,
0.6914813519,
-0.3139719963,
-0.1993302405,
-0.8225077391,
-0.8337187767,
0.4054892659,
-0.2385578007,
-0.0723187998,
-0.1204799935,
0.6471581459,
-0.0404185317,
0.3609925508,
-0.4691745639,
-0.2406722307,
-0.6094042063,
-0.229637444,
-0.0742246509,
-0.5201856494,
-0.5822092295,
-0.4843406081,
0.6027081013,
-0.5408285856,
-0.0640737489,
0.3670026064,
-0.1297243536,
-0.0061788876,
-0.376029551,
0.0600080006,
0.8860234022,
-0.4074380696,
0.2658876777,
0.337579757,
-0.3637238741,
0.2337591648,
-0.0933280513,
-0.2278817594,
-0.2049045265,
0.4827142358,
0.7803410888,
0.1963951886,
-0.0537187159,
0.7372108102,
0.2282096595,
-0.5305415392,
0.0208728723,
0.0709596351,
0.2097608745,
0.3245224953,
0.5031093955,
-0.2086692601,
0.1566743553,
-0.4897096455,
0.2051269412,
0.3975632191,
-0.1753202975,
-0.1214341149,
0.5281298757,
0.3616863191,
0.221192345,
1.0256624222,
-0.376912117,
-0.8081606627,
0.4614731669,
0.5442126989,
0.7273914814,
-0.3983523846,
0.3128327429,
0.7051517963,
0.0237698033,
-0.1407639384,
-0.2369503975,
-0.4815229475,
-0.3905872405,
-0.5030798912,
-0.680916369,
0.0105187688,
-0.1625851542,
-0.5353922248,
0.3999751508,
-0.3547623456,
-0.3452452421,
-0.3006126285,
0.2322861105,
-0.3699541986,
0.1727470309,
-0.2995953858,
1.1749198437,
-1.0745062828,
1.0255115032,
0.0077373213,
-0.2988062501,
-0.8620231152,
-0.0916524976,
-0.0846518725,
-0.485907197,
0.7154152989,
-0.1465952545,
0.019234566,
0.354796499,
-0.3015282154,
-1.3251026869,
1.758466363,
0.4259646535,
-0.5722806454,
-0.4305593967,
-0.2065793574,
0.2443791032,
-0.1287864298,
-0.1203414649,
0.3641953766,
0.5390558243,
0.7349156141,
-0.7877141237,
0.0896555781,
0.2938036323,
-0.3838094473,
0.3726421893,
-0.9650599957,
0.8933312893,
-0.1596130431,
-0.4735153317,
-0.4956344366,
1.0176374912,
-0.0058344146,
0.1368345916,
0.7094526291,
0.8206506371,
0.9114671946,
0.0138580557,
0.4671907723,
-0.4685937464,
0.7549260259,
1.2540507317,
-0.2667903304,
0.4412381053,
0.2159794271,
-0.2667588592,
0.6751143932,
0.7976856232,
-0.0228674337,
1.0532500744,
0.0060788011,
0.0207587872,
-0.3402152658,
0.3414117694,
-0.6306872368,
0.2820414305,
0.2205593884,
-0.3230003119,
-0.4231321216,
0.2387116849,
-0.0618677735,
-0.2093158066,
0.0023455173,
1.0856690407,
0.0492307469,
-0.7928586006,
0.587611258,
-0.1523552537,
0.2295770943,
-0.9012149572,
0.0314327404,
-0.0309492629,
0.038047418,
-0.2707318366,
-0.806946516,
0.5634526014,
-0.7334403396,
-0.1060331762,
-0.4451005459,
0.8149228096,
-0.5285694599,
-0.3818779588,
0.611495018,
0.5152308345,
-0.1007586643,
-0.0284757391,
-0.4851158857,
-0.199633643,
0.0540377349,
-0.3480036855,
0.2021828741,
0.5431938171,
0.2437252104,
0.861258626,
0.5333913565,
0.096175991,
0.0479787737,
-0.3016167581,
1.158031106,
-0.4186831713,
-0.5792210698,
-0.8688166738,
0.1680764258,
-0.287566334,
0.2428896725,
0.7415707111,
0.5547200441,
0.6512858868,
0.0794384703,
0.6208958626,
-0.1444821656,
0.7004028559,
-0.527921319,
0.7677269578,
-0.523208499,
-0.0771244913,
-0.1116990075,
-0.9345837831,
0.1802201122,
0.4304599166,
-0.2820674181,
0.0401049927,
0.695484519,
0.2517510056,
-0.480443418,
-0.269138366,
0.0938322544,
0.2963137031,
0.2900767922,
0.3398174644,
0.3918915987,
-0.1392633766,
0.4882994592,
-0.5299861431,
-0.4002594948,
-0.1535336077,
-1.2036583424,
-0.6064607501,
-0.7799961567,
-0.3868287504,
-0.5988330841,
-0.0932008177,
0.6981573105,
0.8163945675,
-0.3299193382,
0.0712527111,
0.1037004292,
0.3991358876,
-0.3245003223,
-0.2042950243,
0.6543328166,
-0.3663089275,
-0.4779489636,
0.4003862143,
0.1078894734,
0.2168737203,
-0.4484445751,
0.0869184658,
-0.361676991,
-0.0606495403,
0.3358697891,
0.304518491,
-0.1122230589,
-0.3198840618,
-0.2941515446,
0.1897308379,
-0.0638692304,
0.9276109934,
-1.2341631651,
0.5773661137,
0.5565897226,
0.3069289327,
1.1504318714,
0.318312943,
0.3783737123,
-0.8106418252,
0.1334336698,
0.0130821075,
0.2244853377,
0.071226269,
-0.1932953149,
0.6411631107,
0.7005655169,
-0.5627105236,
-0.7822956443,
0.3536842465,
-0.698792994,
-0.572943449,
0.9720503092,
-0.3727188706,
-0.4612662792,
0.0069933059,
-0.0253486149,
0.6006098986,
0.0827809423,
0.8206552267,
0.7155955434,
0.1056593508,
0.1201044023,
-0.2407980412,
0.813737452,
-0.1192232296,
-0.480148524,
0.3039097786,
0.3613876998,
0.8040723801,
0.3887982965,
0.6774759293,
0.2093599141,
-0.1708867252,
-0.0591445714,
-0.1731815934,
-0.6595095992,
-0.7851240039,
0.0868495703,
0.5140372515,
-0.0836874396,
-0.1551279426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12199v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12199v1 | VNHSGE: VietNamese High School Graduation Examination Dataset for Large Language Models | 2023-05-20T14:13:08 | 2023-05-20T14:13:08 | Xuan-Quy Dao, Ngoc-Bich Le, The-Duy Vo, Xuan-Dung Phan, Bac-Bien Ngo, Van-Tien Nguyen, Thi-My-Thanh Nguyen, Hong-Phuoc Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The VNHSGE (VietNamese High School Graduation Examination) dataset, developed
exclusively for evaluating large language models (LLMs), is introduced in this
article. The dataset, which covers nine subjects, was generated from the
Vietnamese National High School Graduation Examination and comparable tests.
300 literary essays have been included, and there are over 19,000
multiple-choice questions on a range of topics. The dataset assesses LLMs in
multitasking situations such as question answering, text generation, reading
comprehension, visual question answering, and more by including both textual
data and accompanying images. Using ChatGPT and BingChat, we evaluated LLMs on
the VNHSGE dataset and contrasted their performance with that of Vietnamese
students to see how well they performed. The results show that ChatGPT and
BingChat both perform at a human level in a number of areas, including
literature, English, history, geography, and civics education. They still have
space to grow, though, especially in the areas of mathematics, physics,
chemistry, and biology. The VNHSGE dataset seeks to provide an adequate
benchmark for assessing the abilities of LLMs with its wide-ranging coverage
and variety of activities. We intend to promote future developments in the
creation of LLMs by making this dataset available to the scientific community,
especially in resolving LLMs' limits in disciplines involving mathematics and
the natural sciences. | [
-0.37694332,
-0.8041075468,
0.5991470814,
0.2313309461,
-0.0928354859,
-0.0742534325,
-0.3259189427,
-0.1303742528,
0.1416120976,
0.7573650479,
-0.2719811797,
-0.7535430193,
-0.5328751206,
0.0480836481,
-0.4092692733,
0.9796780944,
0.0238298643,
0.0539974906,
-0.4390191138,
0.0642503574,
-0.440676719,
-0.5966279507,
-0.6870634556,
-0.1464152038,
0.6828166246,
0.336201638,
0.2384545952,
0.5587645769,
0.6034501791,
0.2250157595,
-0.1063966602,
0.0587841719,
-1.0119969845,
0.0669136792,
-0.1908063591,
-0.1503525078,
-0.2492006421,
-0.0489025787,
0.7407913804,
0.6067119837,
0.0700121522,
0.4391726255,
0.2311710864,
0.6871591806,
-0.6171709895,
0.2576403022,
-0.3415891528,
-0.14966546,
-0.1834868044,
-0.0205117706,
-0.2316960841,
-0.4338047802,
0.4628792703,
-0.3046561778,
-0.1657486409,
-0.3788588345,
0.6866978407,
-0.0862215906,
-0.9513828754,
0.0682256222,
-0.2708719075,
0.9074878097,
-0.5036085844,
0.2920016646,
0.0538036041,
0.4863357246,
-0.383562088,
-0.6452599764,
-0.3209026456,
-0.4858179688,
0.1957783699,
0.378067553,
-0.01609396,
0.2883649766,
0.2661493421,
0.5189205408,
-0.9897770286,
0.168543756,
-0.6556726694,
-0.1113008559,
0.5624771714,
0.2852793336,
0.1418018788,
-0.5100538731,
-0.4767455161,
-0.0438914932,
-0.7164213657,
-0.2706666589,
0.1780446768,
0.1952435821,
-0.0820567012,
0.8753330112,
-0.3187631369,
0.9049141407,
-0.9391488433,
0.0319726095,
0.3294898272,
-0.4226257205,
-0.297046572,
-0.2495224774,
0.7416113615,
0.5631112456,
0.5366265178,
0.3942230642,
-0.1640481651,
-0.0027376425,
0.1128301769,
-0.8514764309,
0.0745165497,
0.2291561663,
-0.4948343337,
-0.118381165,
0.2004921138,
-0.9503315687,
-0.3174223304,
-0.6553298831,
0.4120980501,
-0.04782065,
-0.0951242819,
0.3143099844,
-0.2351182252,
0.3500365615,
0.3554239571,
-0.5120772123,
0.3644777834,
0.9321810603,
1.0090771914,
-0.6595398784,
-0.6161596775,
-0.5029385686,
-0.186294809,
-0.0850123614,
0.6372499466,
-0.3576310575,
-0.5710603595,
0.3213467598,
0.1681219786,
-0.1579521298,
-0.6770998836,
0.8155487776,
-0.3536839783,
0.3080924153,
-0.3600216806,
-0.8105067015,
-0.1367559582,
0.4234005213,
-0.7452426553,
1.1055731773,
0.307310164,
-0.5388857722,
-0.1125354841,
-0.6314557195,
0.0229508094,
0.1215325743,
-0.3942720592,
-0.0142691163,
0.0023858414,
-0.0082807774,
0.6937363744,
-0.6737650037,
0.250613302,
-0.124448359,
-0.5419533849,
-0.1651492715,
-0.5847705007,
0.9293397069,
0.1290475428,
0.1349906027,
0.1530465484,
-0.7470656037,
0.034244366,
0.2680982351,
-0.6032736897,
-0.3525260687,
-0.310313195,
0.36698699,
0.2273713648,
0.5436490774,
-0.4236340225,
0.4378198981,
-0.0754797384,
0.33874318,
0.6643662453,
0.1130873859,
-0.019614486,
-0.3880430758,
0.5080396533,
-0.0684009269,
-0.0090855742,
-0.3847740293,
-0.7147211432,
-0.4744110703,
-0.2088662833,
0.2452185452,
0.8675401211,
-0.6935414672,
0.5015408397,
-0.3137978613,
-0.7290181518,
-0.376069963,
0.1245759949,
0.1714960635,
0.5256894231,
0.0773945227,
-0.0856913254,
-0.6270908117,
-0.74991256,
-0.1570412517,
-0.1938483864,
-0.406246841,
0.2127111256,
0.8620313406,
-0.2672218084,
0.5643957853,
-0.7177872658,
-0.0547426008,
0.0216793194,
0.0442311205,
0.2896656096,
0.2285808176,
0.6549967527,
-0.6008868814,
-0.3668892682,
0.110934183,
-0.9158727527,
-0.2771681547,
0.0785202309,
-0.3825592101,
-0.0969261155,
0.3789389729,
-0.5273069739,
0.1724696904,
0.7306943536,
-0.4491051435,
1.0179558992,
-0.1539187133,
0.3152568042,
-1.0217727423,
-0.1956261247,
0.460640043,
-0.090161711,
-0.5029290915,
-0.1437179744,
-0.1302864105,
-0.0680087507,
-0.426977843,
0.978097558,
-0.3600253463,
-0.0472126044,
-0.356487751,
0.3512422442,
-0.2559739351,
0.0587059222,
0.0159109421,
0.5906292796,
0.8246705532,
-0.2735989094,
0.6871016622,
0.0385929532,
-0.5795501471,
0.665681541,
-0.7435213923,
-0.1321749389,
-0.205997631,
0.0798036829,
-0.8959844708,
-0.2877579927,
-0.1404750496,
-0.3084824979,
-0.2494627386,
-0.1240424961,
-0.1595243663,
-0.5847653151,
-0.3550778329,
0.1840685904,
0.4517374039,
-0.5320903063,
0.2790929973,
0.3266485631,
-0.260758549,
-0.6224364042,
-0.3250105977,
0.3908188939,
-0.3967200518,
-0.6284821033,
-0.149517566,
-0.0301485397,
-0.3880721927,
-0.0098615885,
0.3735013008,
-0.1800673455,
-0.1951293051,
0.0027038543,
0.5675215125,
-0.6899036765,
0.2698683143,
-0.1989793628,
0.0302430205,
0.1641165614,
-0.3914089501,
0.6180914044,
-0.1278162152,
-0.2048056871,
-0.0890987441,
0.3147599995,
0.7751810551,
-0.0479468666,
0.6480448842,
0.5524141192,
-0.4266408384,
0.0479354486,
-0.4295133054,
-0.1058130488,
-0.4006748497,
0.7260635495,
-0.1848397106,
-1.2406884432,
0.301248163,
0.0978128687,
0.3522863388,
0.363255173,
0.8001927733,
0.1443746537,
0.469008863,
0.3702234626,
-0.3884811103,
0.49018839,
-0.1510613561,
-0.1181564331,
-0.6210255027,
0.0582205839,
-0.5550631881,
0.0185978375,
-0.985435605,
-0.723837316,
0.2491218895,
-0.2474564314,
-0.5413541198,
0.1238583028,
-0.294582963,
0.5928415656,
0.4896700084,
-0.3128130734,
0.2870947123,
0.1482412368,
0.3630700409,
-0.282830447,
-0.3119376898,
-0.9533459544,
1.2735544443,
0.1940324157,
0.5467125177,
-0.0846830159,
0.6210219264,
0.2635657191,
0.2227790207,
-1.0623275042,
0.6301725507,
-0.3535993993,
-0.4183501303,
-0.5488427281,
-0.8401627541,
-1.0749365091,
0.6927211285,
-0.1708976477,
-0.8023449779,
-0.2661170959,
-0.3139699399,
0.0183437541,
-0.001667914,
-0.6368188858,
0.9430055618,
-0.2779755592,
-0.1769734919,
-0.0588283986,
-0.4422409832,
0.6929675341,
-0.2171070576,
-0.069457911,
-0.1445563436,
-0.0038465781,
1.1485549212,
-0.0779627413,
0.5217781663,
-0.0654488951,
-0.183370322,
0.6003249288,
-0.2006493211,
0.1435732991,
0.1665670872,
-0.359796077,
0.2208596468,
0.2388408929,
-0.6222347021,
-0.5728301406,
0.9257944822,
-0.8399600983,
-0.6500614285,
-0.4981969595,
-0.3641239703,
-0.1627086252,
0.3692822754,
-0.0665807277,
0.200680837,
-0.5486124754,
0.3532781601,
0.6591796875,
-0.3334812224,
0.0510382801,
0.2842572927,
-0.5737826228,
-0.5812379122,
1.1278452873,
0.3780452907,
0.3065122366,
0.1556348354,
0.4463049769,
-0.3273420632,
-0.2351800203,
-0.1768691987,
0.7105917335,
-0.7262686491,
0.2068953663,
-0.5416877866,
-0.66483289,
-0.458907038,
-0.0207062792,
-0.0850948617,
-0.1125846505,
-0.3502435386,
-0.2711574435,
0.3365699053,
0.9507036805,
0.10264121,
0.584330678,
-0.8080704808,
0.3732594848,
0.3659744263,
0.0226447973,
-0.194089219,
-0.5512287617,
0.0202798191,
-0.0130472062,
-0.3859771788,
-0.6380608678,
0.0600481369,
0.1644047648,
0.5788551569,
0.321527034,
-0.282294631,
0.3156371713,
-0.3620046675,
0.99020648,
0.1042207032,
-0.6791208982,
0.2876766622,
-0.6937199831,
0.4637265503,
0.3143250644,
0.5392223597,
-1.0700169802,
-0.0148504302,
-0.3283186257,
-0.7310314178,
0.1250072718,
0.0971738473,
0.3526208103,
0.0949571431,
0.3378518522,
0.0533573776,
0.3451301455,
-0.5296348333,
-0.2304171175,
0.0704113096,
-0.2756795883,
-0.313970834,
-0.4459728301,
0.0694279224,
-0.3302412629,
0.4288629293,
-0.1710452735,
-0.0136109879,
-0.244328782,
0.4129141271,
0.2961139381,
0.2083414495,
0.5780609846,
0.8321714997,
-0.0692371801,
0.0927498266,
0.1743215322,
-0.83705163,
0.1330242902,
-0.1837677211,
0.0963464752,
-0.0091561079,
0.4869319797,
0.6799379587,
-0.3055562079,
-0.9143178463,
0.5621728897,
-0.2362339199,
-0.2495553493,
-0.1444165111,
0.0148284929,
0.3083687425,
-0.0383152664,
0.3276458979,
-0.5293459892,
0.0138910171,
-0.503934741,
0.3353267014,
0.0283756629,
-0.3520978689,
-0.1408535391,
0.2002106756,
0.0477187783,
-0.1092988849,
0.7450207472,
0.2100378275,
-0.2429680228,
0.800838232,
0.405696243,
0.6011840105,
-0.2684049904,
0.3610863984,
0.5872753859,
0.4337118268,
-0.3859978318,
0.7495088577,
0.4049556553,
-0.4956758618,
-0.4412378669,
-0.672496438,
-0.332817167,
0.5276678205,
-0.4436032176,
0.6514997482,
-0.0853386149,
-0.0537159033,
-0.402264595,
0.1023069471,
-0.5749524236,
0.4093241692,
0.0349124223,
0.8811215162,
-0.9831992984,
0.6534978151,
0.6879063249,
-0.0726834163,
-0.1373764426,
-0.0799746513,
0.2402149141,
-0.6530908942,
0.484239608,
0.1643949151,
0.0125417346,
-0.0478352904,
-0.4116950929,
-0.839617312,
0.7185968757,
0.5199844241,
-0.6555345654,
-0.0064072125,
0.2616669238,
0.7339285612,
-0.2482920438,
0.3219349384,
0.7108825445,
0.567407012,
0.0653214231,
-0.8709333539,
-0.3381690085,
-0.1324270219,
0.034971904,
-0.0601539612,
-0.7140690684,
0.8979457021,
0.0374845341,
0.0762730315,
0.020312015,
0.8866463304,
0.6702047586,
0.1420866102,
0.3053417504,
0.3651066124,
0.8705078363,
-0.2683292329,
0.6690049171,
-0.0042489851,
0.3557020724,
1.0428295135,
-0.2934102118,
0.9049630761,
0.4594558477,
-0.0886721462,
-0.1871312857,
0.8530020118,
-0.0564689636,
0.1270842999,
0.7935692072,
-0.3164364398,
-0.2083718777,
-0.2913495302,
-0.4704185128,
0.7122715712,
0.367259711,
-0.1193578467,
-0.3049615622,
0.2020102143,
-0.0349080674,
-0.0322331898,
-0.2932195067,
0.3821288049,
0.4348940551,
-0.418451637,
0.5872390866,
-0.2991651595,
0.612434566,
-0.5355801582,
-0.1753921807,
-0.1472461373,
-0.1429469883,
-0.1591484994,
-1.1552382708,
0.0260405038,
0.1738804579,
0.0615839586,
0.1140968427,
0.5486748219,
-0.4095012546,
-0.6840758324,
0.3034722209,
0.7540091872,
0.5169612169,
0.0505779274,
-0.472345382,
0.1582231373,
-0.2311578244,
-0.556720674,
0.274745971,
0.639768362,
-0.2730690241,
0.6146285534,
0.3230484724,
0.4559119046,
0.1282084435,
0.1797872037,
0.558103025,
-0.7489426136,
-0.2898232341,
-0.8047895432,
0.3344295323,
-0.169900313,
-0.6773382425,
0.9932863116,
0.8464896679,
1.0841909647,
-0.08274436,
1.1656370163,
0.2342973053,
0.3873263896,
-0.490154177,
0.6882770658,
-0.5871137977,
-0.0533037223,
-0.3070320189,
-1.0195838213,
-0.1712617427,
0.3900069594,
-0.426648587,
0.2732596993,
0.5640459061,
0.588162601,
0.1385225356,
0.0771371201,
0.7310162187,
-0.0200031959,
0.4629903734,
0.6128672957,
1.107866168,
-0.4129636288,
0.1150627732,
0.139949888,
-0.2737945914,
-0.1752071977,
-0.6117704511,
-1.0846598148,
-0.6794680357,
-0.1412126422,
-0.2034799159,
0.0242977627,
0.9444298744,
0.2089316249,
-0.600064218,
-0.8512334824,
0.3654699326,
0.0883062109,
-0.0346839651,
-0.2627871335,
0.4098611176,
0.0112178773,
-0.7264142036,
0.3465974033,
0.1682747453,
0.1408775151,
-0.4822938442,
0.1055786163,
-0.1826796532,
0.0241676215,
1.0159240961,
0.1191766709,
-0.4499416649,
-0.2150068879,
0.0604116544,
-0.4457902312,
0.1973971725,
0.8263913989,
-0.3316239119,
0.2708582282,
0.869168818,
0.78818959,
0.3169402182,
-0.1290119737,
0.3940332234,
-0.1953103244,
0.0213462505,
0.1630128771,
0.3837108314,
0.1853122711,
-0.2711322606,
0.4824815989,
0.284835428,
-0.8417967558,
-0.8597363234,
-0.0543811992,
-1.0114139318,
-0.2420862913,
1.2269752026,
-0.0411131568,
-0.4611363113,
-0.1176291555,
-0.5724548101,
0.1953770667,
-0.2908582985,
0.83504498,
0.9988223314,
0.0855163857,
-0.0537564643,
-1.3461974859,
0.2057342678,
0.3037038743,
-1.2963813543,
0.2914168239,
0.6706018448,
0.1337134391,
-0.2891542017,
0.5832489133,
-0.0068472158,
0.2232204676,
-0.2779387534,
-0.045010414,
0.3961011469,
-0.4100988209,
-0.4098505378,
0.2598868012,
-0.1113031209,
0.069114998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12196v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12196v1 | Experimental results from applying GPT-4 to an unpublished formal language | 2023-05-20T14:00:08 | 2023-05-20T14:00:08 | Gregor vom Scheidt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LO, math.LO, 03B35, F.4.1; I.2.3; F.4.3 | Can large language models be used to complete mathematical tasks that are
traditionally performed either manually or with the aid of theorem provers? To
answer this question, a state-of-the-art system, GPT-4, was provided with a
concise natural language specification for a previously unpublished formal
system and asked to complete a number of tasks, from stating function and type
definitions to proving simple theorems and verifying user-supplied proofs. The
system completed all tasks successfully, showed extensive domain knowledge,
invented helpful new syntax and semantics, and exhibited generalization and
inference abilities. So the answer seems to be: yes. | [
-0.0621800236,
-0.851215899,
1.0463955402,
0.1084712297,
-0.1941929311,
-0.1051379517,
-0.358198911,
-0.7775506377,
-0.1475294232,
0.3774518371,
-0.1394458264,
-0.1988797337,
-0.5597220063,
0.463476181,
-0.7742581367,
1.0200293064,
-0.4834025502,
-0.0838797241,
-0.0848197192,
0.4547922015,
-0.2719870508,
-0.7036771178,
-0.3808232248,
-0.3766174316,
0.119101584,
0.1048357636,
0.6913795471,
0.3047078252,
0.7835303545,
0.5343078971,
0.3650721908,
-0.1197895259,
-0.0029722604,
-0.0274449307,
-0.3209916353,
-0.718742907,
-0.5708194971,
0.1603064388,
0.8384318352,
0.677097559,
-0.1322431266,
-0.1449642926,
0.0594987273,
0.4589014649,
-0.1776477396,
0.6570191979,
-0.3978791833,
0.100734137,
-0.3812382519,
-0.2361013293,
-0.2741167247,
-0.712500453,
0.2997397482,
-0.8987680674,
0.258644551,
-0.4410959184,
0.8600433469,
0.0140749747,
-0.5130898952,
-0.5855999589,
-1.0351445675,
0.7899157405,
-0.8171793818,
0.2764033973,
0.3575792313,
0.5358145833,
0.0144663788,
-1.0418353081,
-0.5701618195,
-0.4859183431,
-0.2972234786,
-0.0789938197,
-0.0741827115,
0.2499298751,
0.7950518727,
0.4847792089,
-0.4158596694,
-0.4159253538,
-0.6916857958,
-0.3361470103,
0.4833557904,
-0.0809732303,
0.4651290774,
-0.1646325141,
0.1058039293,
0.5037058592,
-0.760938704,
-0.2373541445,
0.1388181299,
0.0430286303,
-0.0285339355,
0.8527569175,
-0.400752008,
0.692470789,
-0.2714022398,
0.0051125721,
0.2295327932,
-0.810557425,
-0.29777807,
-0.2312011123,
0.716070056,
-0.0575362928,
0.437074095,
-0.3223467767,
-0.5846371651,
0.2845001519,
-0.092610836,
-0.6310914755,
-0.3338744342,
0.0578897633,
0.1702078134,
-0.0361129344,
-0.0043194634,
-0.54528898,
0.0682962015,
-0.5437695384,
0.6487179399,
-0.4622698426,
-0.2626519203,
0.3816467822,
-0.3032118976,
0.1470033228,
0.4364270568,
-0.9640409946,
0.7882464528,
0.8057734966,
0.8858301044,
0.2785391212,
-0.1823784709,
-0.4143745303,
0.0506243035,
-0.5634242892,
0.5278396606,
-0.498034209,
-0.1586430073,
0.0885505602,
-0.0834342316,
0.0849069506,
-0.3195509613,
0.690608263,
-0.6657124758,
0.3517407477,
-0.4417769909,
-0.6395661831,
0.0664464012,
0.2414091378,
-0.4626573026,
0.8497111797,
0.1664498001,
-0.6715133786,
0.3041646481,
-0.8802187443,
-0.5889753699,
0.1991251111,
-0.2219575942,
-0.2215717137,
0.0406020023,
-0.0979851112,
0.3920928836,
-0.2071222365,
0.3624813557,
-0.0781095996,
-0.4514451623,
0.3580524027,
-0.0928585231,
0.6421154141,
0.1420236975,
-0.8953431845,
-0.2544808984,
-0.6438490152,
0.1962966621,
0.2212941349,
-0.4811443686,
-0.267585218,
-0.3223350346,
-0.3660320044,
0.1716631949,
0.6231090426,
-0.7937595844,
0.4344928265,
-0.4184072912,
0.7324005365,
0.4376863837,
-0.1238306463,
0.2964205444,
-0.2270202041,
0.5954862833,
-0.4691505134,
-0.1482769549,
-0.1572628915,
-0.7620074749,
-0.6734265089,
-0.3387176394,
0.497469753,
0.5498945117,
-0.7314096093,
0.3358672261,
-0.1124321371,
-0.34330374,
0.2973201573,
-0.0983046144,
0.4315661788,
0.3548398316,
0.12226367,
0.0133245857,
-0.5585957766,
-0.7440063357,
-0.1856323034,
-0.0375322439,
-0.2717895508,
0.0928376168,
0.6446100473,
-0.0088999979,
0.861948967,
-0.5813349485,
-0.0718198493,
0.0330340192,
0.3781199455,
0.2773994505,
0.2583386004,
0.454333514,
-0.5638448,
-0.2891247869,
0.3642055988,
-1.0463885069,
-0.2773960233,
0.3052747846,
0.1083898097,
0.1380087733,
0.3245680034,
-0.8025522232,
0.3390409946,
0.3031468093,
-0.1369272619,
0.8515745997,
-0.5990216136,
0.3130348623,
-0.6376450658,
0.0303273872,
-0.0253591612,
-0.5650244951,
-0.7712265849,
0.1355627477,
0.2527911067,
-0.1622839868,
-0.0586062074,
0.4064380229,
-0.4285907447,
-0.3299356997,
-0.3531883359,
0.0088211559,
-0.2186762244,
0.1312090605,
0.1514590681,
0.741994381,
0.9245590568,
-0.742405653,
0.4480960667,
-0.0276933853,
-0.167916283,
0.3729846478,
-0.9173727632,
0.1508262008,
0.000165936,
0.0583845377,
-1.0693815947,
-0.5858296156,
0.1681742817,
-0.3201122582,
0.0853349119,
-0.0837824494,
-0.6531729102,
-0.6113674045,
0.0993890911,
0.3747248054,
0.6034064293,
-0.0459323712,
0.4451789856,
0.1819862872,
-0.3883126378,
-0.1997941881,
-0.8308157325,
0.1521289647,
-0.0970387831,
-0.5312834382,
0.1834020615,
0.0657344088,
-0.290679276,
0.0256291013,
0.2560459077,
-0.3104070425,
-0.0717217177,
-0.0427975841,
0.2361498326,
-0.2541064918,
0.0763600916,
-0.0887753516,
0.0252138637,
0.1264845729,
-0.3780555129,
0.4237987995,
-0.4375180304,
-0.6739913225,
-0.6254379749,
0.2698164284,
0.5739204884,
-0.391258359,
-0.0122983353,
0.1027444974,
-0.6852918267,
0.1069644541,
-0.3544257283,
-0.2159339488,
-0.5263934731,
0.1775021553,
-0.5822393894,
-1.0802506208,
0.3362388313,
-0.1305814534,
0.3804556131,
0.5368802547,
0.4561174512,
0.2728743553,
0.8413610458,
0.4860274494,
0.3189358413,
0.326479584,
-0.2648229301,
0.4125358164,
-0.4514324665,
0.0946495682,
-0.6855716705,
-0.1249451861,
-0.6489008665,
-0.2810119092,
0.3729867041,
0.0567515977,
-0.3053756356,
0.4648928344,
-0.4212342501,
0.3844328523,
0.6065472364,
0.0177857243,
0.6400671601,
-0.1758505702,
-0.1868685931,
-0.0434410572,
-0.1152952909,
-0.6961736083,
1.2394099236,
0.1615844667,
0.41618523,
0.2586078644,
0.9972830415,
0.1462693959,
0.5419432521,
-0.6358656883,
0.6022646427,
0.1303232461,
-0.8569629192,
-0.6150045991,
-0.4697280824,
-0.9482212067,
0.0102447923,
0.27375561,
-0.8389656544,
-0.1022373065,
0.2231115997,
-0.2434837371,
-0.1241754144,
-0.8921094537,
0.7079199553,
-0.2602716684,
0.010640529,
-0.1694763005,
-0.3118040562,
0.8219591379,
-0.4775726199,
0.3245952129,
0.1261627674,
-0.0447376408,
0.9532827735,
-0.6657992005,
0.775912106,
-0.2784528732,
-0.3104851544,
0.4935694337,
0.2810202539,
0.6434859633,
0.0328078642,
-0.135978505,
-0.2728227377,
0.3247943521,
-0.3602205515,
-0.9198893905,
0.6549494863,
-0.6342271566,
-0.6130559444,
-0.5601062179,
-0.3699104488,
-0.069007799,
0.6324717402,
-0.0412565805,
0.7016265988,
-0.1251799166,
-0.2131782621,
0.3003357053,
0.2690125704,
0.4766985774,
0.6766671538,
-0.310729593,
-0.2095226347,
0.7621182799,
0.2422937751,
0.3929621279,
0.3057818115,
0.4094668031,
-0.2786170244,
-0.6385313272,
-0.2211448252,
0.4636308849,
-0.7047703862,
0.051420968,
-0.6760540605,
-0.1638548672,
-0.4064891338,
-0.0705026463,
-0.3182516396,
-0.7397513986,
0.1762851626,
-0.2008416057,
0.2618790865,
1.2717242241,
-0.0956316441,
-0.0731102824,
-0.8446834683,
0.3294501007,
0.6045039892,
0.2802037895,
-0.4910084009,
-0.2019699514,
-0.0939221755,
0.1946173459,
-0.4150079191,
-0.7190449238,
0.1280433387,
0.1771514565,
0.4062508345,
0.1906919628,
-0.1596352011,
0.2972494364,
-0.823912859,
0.8609153628,
0.1561325043,
-1.2253445387,
0.4275103807,
-0.7166774869,
0.2004069388,
0.0026063293,
0.3947790265,
-0.3444720209,
-0.5337247252,
-0.6272306442,
-0.3376431167,
0.3480779827,
0.3780617118,
0.0955869332,
-0.09483964,
0.5561116338,
0.0349616148,
0.3545985222,
-0.7358831167,
0.0601687878,
-0.1982107311,
0.0639462546,
0.0051502842,
-0.0785128102,
-0.2199089974,
-0.249015972,
0.4883282781,
-0.0679689199,
0.5154198408,
0.1956918389,
0.0204471201,
-0.0338125713,
0.5598953962,
0.7608470321,
1.3454653025,
0.0203171894,
0.282345295,
-0.1029909998,
-0.4263319373,
0.3323116302,
0.5259032249,
-0.276116401,
0.0120730111,
0.302393645,
0.218209669,
0.3159476221,
-0.5701038241,
0.5006899834,
-0.0035940248,
-0.6399427056,
-0.2818798721,
-0.0636347383,
0.0504353344,
0.0906559899,
0.4348587096,
-0.0123372925,
0.4323418736,
-0.774130702,
0.6246462464,
0.5410926938,
-0.1681927145,
-0.8019971848,
0.6241622567,
-0.0511650667,
-0.1999309957,
0.0741662383,
-0.2857186198,
-0.673147738,
0.3886807561,
0.8387806416,
0.5057380199,
-0.3305489719,
0.4024742246,
0.124885492,
0.2918694913,
-0.4928909242,
0.5437070131,
0.0859985352,
-0.6761575937,
-0.8523320556,
-0.4327122271,
-0.5495132804,
-0.0101291286,
-0.2100783885,
0.3390598297,
-0.5120178461,
-0.12524876,
0.3542640507,
-0.0181686487,
-0.8120348454,
0.1287269443,
-0.1139643937,
0.4096757472,
-0.8637334108,
0.7141539454,
0.766130507,
-0.3615590036,
-1.0966675282,
-0.3112132549,
0.0456585512,
-0.5387542844,
0.9929337502,
-0.1964216083,
-0.1015782654,
-0.0157363228,
-0.3187562525,
-1.1247330904,
0.9090671539,
0.5992060304,
-0.4526494741,
-0.0995112881,
0.3224338591,
0.7222451568,
0.0214541387,
0.4348839819,
0.5168207884,
0.7246325612,
0.2635382116,
-1.588535428,
0.2400269508,
-0.1020924896,
-0.3163478673,
0.4783975184,
-0.2851568758,
0.9913756251,
-0.1851166934,
-0.2068400681,
0.3058645427,
0.6887577176,
0.1313653886,
0.155579105,
0.220600903,
0.4353534877,
1.2366738319,
-0.2308324426,
1.4268511534,
-0.1700474769,
0.3788164854,
0.7062770724,
-0.5402764678,
0.5906246901,
-0.0508204103,
-0.6100260615,
0.3289249837,
0.3309282362,
0.4047448337,
0.3843721747,
0.4864280522,
-0.4670575261,
-0.0404168963,
0.2628776729,
-0.5012655258,
0.1774947643,
0.3383655846,
-0.0940127522,
-0.3071506619,
-0.0151609629,
0.0436994471,
-0.2337131947,
-0.094695963,
0.4962008893,
0.1403285861,
-0.8400167227,
0.6875156164,
0.0787650347,
0.5648810267,
-0.6497647762,
-0.2507167161,
0.1749891192,
0.3269848228,
-0.232878074,
-0.8081437349,
0.3804589808,
-0.0538573861,
0.2594560087,
-0.0881206989,
0.7340112925,
-0.317904681,
-0.7007260323,
-0.2578486502,
0.5379357338,
0.3440739512,
-0.1802680194,
-0.1746859401,
-0.3222520947,
-0.1905167699,
-0.1525058299,
0.0589694381,
0.93016994,
-0.0999676734,
0.7063997388,
0.5463101268,
0.2400042415,
0.3687120676,
-0.0171670876,
0.9979789257,
-0.6127529144,
-0.5011973381,
-0.8365219235,
0.2297513485,
-0.0544033609,
0.1963638365,
0.9340327978,
0.7682248354,
0.7099551558,
-0.0707053319,
1.3832734823,
-0.2403620183,
0.6219341755,
-0.5530517697,
0.0437566601,
-0.1847344935,
0.11919076,
-0.6257865429,
-1.009188652,
-0.5602635741,
0.5650649667,
-0.7311800718,
0.2203007936,
1.2348335981,
0.4381859601,
-0.2151203603,
0.1961780041,
0.3733724356,
0.0677356869,
0.762824595,
0.4054583609,
0.7830613852,
-0.2878382802,
0.5138271451,
-0.1003195196,
-0.7023106813,
0.2746826708,
-0.6871371865,
-0.8206039071,
-0.5556536317,
-0.3246533871,
-0.1847316623,
0.2162383944,
0.5971053243,
0.37972036,
-0.7274832129,
-0.1593365967,
-0.317661643,
-0.1784840822,
-0.2041843832,
-0.2175526917,
0.3645740151,
-0.4522772133,
-0.9482778907,
0.3037328124,
0.2487304956,
0.071823433,
-0.2818161249,
-0.0329062939,
-0.0077073015,
-0.0247176327,
0.5195632577,
0.4384207726,
-0.592676878,
-0.5795214772,
0.0927734375,
0.0181004722,
-0.0392694473,
1.3164850473,
-0.5935232639,
0.1978108287,
0.5853715539,
0.5452010036,
0.5513125658,
-0.0595583692,
0.9701244831,
-0.462172538,
0.0107768476,
0.2083596885,
0.7332618237,
0.2784834802,
-0.478261739,
0.4196831882,
0.3114052117,
-0.7864974737,
-0.4827980399,
0.2411911339,
-0.608061254,
0.1434500515,
1.1717481613,
-0.2491672933,
-0.0802797899,
-0.4664643705,
-0.2796171904,
0.163748011,
-0.3441185951,
0.5264306664,
0.9600864649,
-0.2245492488,
-0.0810527056,
-0.9564689398,
0.6232019663,
0.1588497162,
-0.979908824,
-0.0145132579,
0.5196545124,
0.5128728747,
0.4975371659,
1.055049777,
-0.5231927037,
0.3008802831,
-0.3914841413,
-0.161846593,
0.0049076653,
-0.1168853268,
0.0933467075,
0.0403855965,
0.2590982914,
-0.0135695441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12191v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12191v2 | Pointwise Mutual Information Based Metric and Decoding Strategy for Faithful Generation in Document Grounded Dialogs | 2023-05-20T13:34:34 | 2023-12-01T10:37:56 | Yatin Nandwani, Vineet Kumar, Dinesh Raghu, Sachindra Joshi, Luis A. Lastras | cs.CL | cs.CL | A major concern in using deep learning based generative models for
document-grounded dialogs is the potential generation of responses that are not
\textit{faithful} to the underlying document. Existing automated metrics used
for evaluating the faithfulness of response with respect to the grounding
document measure the degree of similarity between the generated response and
the document's content. However, these automated metrics are far from being
well aligned with human judgments. Therefore, to improve the measurement of
faithfulness, we propose a new metric that utilizes (Conditional) Point-wise
Mutual Information (PMI) between the generated response and the source
document, conditioned on the dialogue. PMI quantifies the extent to which the
document influences the generated response -- with a higher PMI indicating a
more faithful response. We build upon this idea to create a new decoding
technique that incorporates PMI into the response generation process to predict
more faithful responses. Our experiments on the BEGIN benchmark demonstrate an
improved correlation of our metric with human evaluation. We also show that our
decoding technique is effective in generating more faithful responses when
compared to standard decoding techniques on a set of publicly available
document-grounded dialog datasets. | [
-0.299710542,
-0.5915439725,
0.5229420662,
0.1220277995,
-0.3791463077,
-0.1326268911,
-0.0382355042,
-0.2470652312,
0.1425335705,
0.1487863064,
-0.747960031,
-0.6873977184,
-0.5674971342,
0.2732909322,
-0.1989998668,
0.731531918,
0.1967511773,
0.4925089777,
-0.537055254,
-0.1972291023,
-0.6098017097,
-0.6122491956,
-0.6024309993,
-0.2856084704,
0.3577122986,
0.2796221673,
0.5287885666,
0.3478405476,
0.7194523811,
0.2897731662,
0.1428798586,
0.1530126482,
-0.6132646203,
0.2550124526,
-0.0389786772,
-0.5253548622,
-0.5890151262,
0.242171362,
0.6802322268,
0.6809232235,
-0.0240835417,
0.1874964386,
0.2325406969,
0.6634923816,
-0.6294458508,
0.1270439476,
-0.7128988504,
0.41658476,
0.1386642456,
-0.5477064848,
-0.3498444557,
-0.4274347126,
0.1564347744,
-0.8949846625,
0.581518352,
-0.1782989502,
0.984822154,
0.0468335748,
-0.2273144573,
-0.2881822288,
-0.5549872518,
0.7402909994,
-0.9475608468,
0.517544508,
0.6986995935,
0.1220850497,
-0.224498257,
-0.5891294479,
-0.7183002234,
-0.083312571,
-0.0239599105,
0.5947620869,
-0.1055302471,
0.157818377,
0.3149928451,
0.436553508,
-0.393324405,
-0.4529663622,
0.0785288885,
-0.4172100425,
0.4647863209,
0.3747956753,
0.0261627734,
-0.2962565422,
-0.1054587886,
-0.3362615108,
-0.5564368963,
0.0254459474,
0.5176135302,
-0.1317032576,
0.0848784074,
0.5967214704,
-0.2834083736,
0.5551705956,
0.4968122542,
-0.2800929546,
0.1827978939,
-0.8133859634,
-0.1809039116,
-0.1356113106,
0.8517146111,
0.9447096586,
0.0943373963,
-0.1068281308,
-0.3169750571,
0.1403832734,
0.36896649,
-0.9466308951,
0.1055776402,
-0.1834797114,
-0.8284324408,
-0.2792924941,
0.3849582672,
-0.5290256739,
-0.1888082623,
-0.5541057587,
0.038326703,
-0.7943974137,
-0.3071652055,
-0.0837166905,
-0.2904216349,
0.2520674765,
0.5195861459,
-0.5968369246,
0.1454804987,
0.9231438041,
0.8191267848,
0.2304262817,
-0.3488632441,
-0.6860922575,
0.1586669236,
-0.4176512659,
0.5617041588,
-0.6033352613,
-0.6917796731,
0.236942485,
-0.1271400303,
0.0633306205,
-0.4194290936,
0.6956648231,
-0.5025315881,
0.3877621293,
-0.7749528885,
-0.5935029387,
-0.0838250667,
0.5896493196,
-0.5101783276,
0.7234323621,
0.3118316233,
-1.181040287,
0.6139470935,
-0.2217216641,
-0.3134514093,
-0.0707831681,
-0.5029720068,
-0.3270154595,
0.3928382695,
-0.0106805665,
0.3624354601,
-0.4041024446,
0.5643926859,
-0.5027580261,
-0.4392185211,
0.4943921566,
-0.7318114638,
0.1879970431,
0.3704529405,
-0.2686972618,
-0.044963222,
-0.8946427107,
0.0700504854,
0.1389459968,
-0.3933281898,
-0.3579822779,
0.0491227023,
-0.3580507338,
-0.1070773527,
0.2699445784,
-0.6772964001,
-0.0719363466,
-0.4135368764,
0.1422671676,
0.5431876779,
0.3170728087,
0.4628677368,
-0.5278137326,
0.1473057568,
0.181489557,
0.100669153,
-0.2214542478,
-0.3004583716,
-0.7435739636,
0.1208063588,
0.1119886041,
0.3754611611,
-0.5837643147,
0.6685248613,
-0.5943971276,
-0.1229535043,
-0.5907219648,
0.0436531715,
0.7041054368,
0.9337573647,
0.0108989077,
-0.607999146,
-0.4846819043,
-0.8072730303,
-0.1701108217,
-0.5068046451,
-0.3243600726,
0.479341656,
0.0883098543,
-0.1278901845,
1.1443902254,
-0.4076554477,
-0.1537660211,
-0.0075477744,
0.5860889554,
0.1993311048,
0.3562611639,
0.5558601618,
-0.8158903122,
-0.5928936005,
-0.2031299174,
-1.0157667398,
-0.0908068717,
-0.1616623253,
-0.1172173992,
0.1073123217,
0.4045825005,
-0.5396163464,
0.3843726516,
0.4401516914,
-0.4131147563,
0.4280132353,
-0.1821218878,
0.6124749184,
-1.332557559,
0.2082709372,
-0.0078415424,
-0.1556867361,
-0.4695708156,
-0.1027204618,
-0.1234750152,
-0.2516566813,
-0.083513923,
0.2173992693,
-0.4880964756,
0.0474424846,
-0.344157666,
0.0293905754,
0.2977421582,
0.531216383,
0.1380475312,
0.9429773092,
0.3085798323,
-0.4914894104,
0.1365047097,
0.6135271192,
0.0096013937,
1.1163916588,
-0.7548579574,
0.3796245456,
-0.3118206561,
0.4772156775,
-0.716780901,
-0.1682473272,
0.4015157223,
-0.8686495423,
0.34063223,
-0.1976772994,
-0.4136587679,
-0.0685050264,
-0.4575608075,
0.5263655782,
0.3688934743,
-0.3419858217,
0.5777576566,
0.0647511706,
-0.1201531217,
-0.4612026215,
-0.5562348962,
0.0600285716,
0.0075391787,
-0.8800026774,
0.1929604411,
-0.3383589089,
-0.2655388117,
0.0595814548,
-0.3972346485,
-0.0821641684,
0.0015394371,
0.6144650578,
0.0383397266,
-0.4109520316,
-0.1730894148,
0.1427315325,
-0.3054048419,
0.4190793037,
-0.4417930245,
0.5483090878,
-0.2103871107,
-0.5998924375,
-0.6868840456,
0.783469975,
0.564435184,
-0.1878511459,
0.711309135,
0.7134046555,
-0.2954209447,
0.3827029169,
-0.6381270885,
-0.2115939707,
-0.4868645072,
0.0744075179,
-0.6807779074,
-0.5636175275,
0.3817963898,
-0.0992843583,
-0.168161422,
0.4093841314,
0.2259980142,
-0.2339877188,
0.9455486536,
0.5942627788,
-0.2138379365,
0.468286097,
-0.2858173847,
0.0781920329,
-0.6913759708,
-0.3368867338,
-0.6147642136,
-0.0734063238,
-0.096681051,
-0.2692070305,
0.3394610882,
0.4859644473,
0.0294239819,
0.1796726882,
-0.3390441537,
0.1511786431,
0.7649575472,
0.2290954292,
0.2513826191,
0.1788988411,
-0.2338350713,
-0.306158483,
-0.5507076383,
-0.4262001216,
1.0822899342,
0.291095376,
0.546267271,
0.0072404589,
0.8045147061,
0.395850718,
0.1427544504,
-0.6175507307,
0.5808352828,
0.1994876266,
0.0138487909,
-0.1890268177,
-0.747764051,
-0.688847065,
-0.0299198162,
-0.4368025064,
-0.3090689778,
0.1514770091,
0.0061697126,
-0.1266234368,
0.0581191145,
-0.5124222636,
0.3239922822,
-0.0621663891,
-0.1900495738,
-0.4413082898,
-0.5996713638,
-0.1162552238,
-0.0238143355,
-0.2944719195,
-0.0213780701,
0.2981403172,
0.7729569674,
-0.6709955335,
0.9115478992,
-0.4500266016,
-0.1801526845,
0.3934507668,
0.2044267356,
0.5995850563,
0.5337400436,
-0.2698325515,
0.3489726484,
-0.1147291511,
-0.4036271572,
-0.8167719841,
0.6337081194,
-0.7850881815,
-0.6938152313,
-0.1887253225,
-0.4245159328,
-0.3961188793,
0.4194168448,
0.6643903255,
0.5557165146,
-0.59389925,
-0.0180649869,
0.8600162268,
-0.0267039817,
0.2021365911,
0.7034712434,
0.4783942997,
-0.7976532578,
0.8723065853,
-0.3160820007,
0.0712979734,
0.6121653914,
0.1423842609,
-0.2177495658,
-0.7381657362,
-0.1679281741,
0.2512714267,
-0.7122542858,
-0.5494502783,
-0.6072711945,
-0.2437985688,
-0.6213271618,
-0.1503022164,
-0.2221580297,
-0.0137718497,
-0.435172677,
-0.1514442861,
0.0466186702,
0.5457721949,
-0.0940234959,
0.2242218703,
-1.2365802526,
0.3437842727,
0.2728333473,
0.4266428649,
-0.1682620496,
-0.4270348549,
-0.0474061035,
0.5276321769,
-0.1392434537,
-0.9833857417,
0.1643602997,
0.2782324553,
0.5117886662,
0.7495797276,
0.2765046358,
0.6559479833,
-0.5105587244,
0.63863796,
0.5101470947,
-1.0774934292,
0.6025448442,
-0.457917124,
0.1753235012,
0.9724664688,
0.2545564771,
-0.6899892688,
-0.572878778,
-0.525937438,
-0.438965708,
0.5191538334,
0.3495304585,
0.425599575,
-0.166351229,
0.4914423525,
0.2795338929,
0.3336952925,
-0.4584074318,
0.0080103725,
-0.5765712857,
-0.2225566953,
0.0627881289,
-0.4962836802,
-0.4348298907,
-0.068057619,
0.3985453546,
-0.3030679226,
0.688526988,
0.5733524561,
-0.1467528492,
-0.4246291816,
0.1692955792,
0.5523915291,
0.5192213058,
-0.4264287055,
0.0094608879,
-0.0310851075,
-0.5473564863,
0.0108231865,
-0.0478206128,
-0.2442053556,
0.3189207315,
0.5243798494,
0.8738144636,
-0.0883420706,
-0.2173297554,
1.0504393578,
-0.4799359739,
-0.4624483287,
-0.4287616313,
-0.0108036185,
-0.3305486143,
0.2433689237,
0.3171228468,
0.1736058593,
0.1212805659,
-0.3028744757,
0.299423188,
0.6126496196,
-0.4483406246,
-0.4902739227,
0.4422588944,
0.5255448222,
-0.3904092312,
0.8356705904,
-0.2807216942,
-0.4334269762,
0.3186561763,
0.6206595302,
1.0218200684,
0.0887327343,
0.4744003415,
0.5971140862,
0.011436264,
0.2935333848,
0.1477768719,
-0.4110622406,
-0.7251976728,
-0.0869436711,
-0.5859088898,
-0.1825656593,
0.18287839,
-0.9096214771,
-0.1211502403,
-0.5373687744,
-0.3112048507,
-0.5647941828,
0.0039645922,
-0.6545836926,
0.2433517873,
0.1326679438,
0.9769613147,
-0.7708914876,
0.741478622,
0.4436707199,
-0.4321861863,
-0.7906655669,
0.5917761326,
-0.102342546,
-0.6182051897,
0.4497193992,
0.2587899566,
-0.3590449691,
-0.2058828175,
-0.3510412574,
-0.7304404378,
1.3298465014,
0.3393740058,
-0.5913397074,
-0.0075597391,
0.4219038486,
0.5722679496,
-0.3209264278,
0.3960329592,
0.2059565932,
0.4345994294,
0.0560528301,
-0.6248673797,
0.2262383401,
-0.616014719,
0.1022090614,
0.0775325522,
-0.5222289562,
0.4063937068,
0.1603268236,
-0.605848074,
0.2840692997,
0.9439666271,
0.0328043699,
0.6785527468,
0.5614189506,
0.6745337248,
0.7862935066,
-0.0339786299,
0.9438381791,
-0.5334690809,
0.141917631,
0.9272460938,
-0.1615387648,
0.6091250181,
0.3316875994,
0.1957430542,
0.2554869354,
0.4103435576,
-0.2138623297,
0.5114690065,
-0.0428958386,
-0.4589883089,
-0.2037477493,
-0.3463665247,
-0.5892457962,
0.1923036873,
0.1555780917,
-0.3041641414,
-0.1450243294,
-0.274133563,
-0.1877797842,
0.3563975096,
-0.0048302901,
1.0696386099,
-0.0224515796,
-0.9040881395,
0.7659641504,
0.2689815462,
0.6322906017,
-0.720590353,
-0.1858705133,
-0.7088419795,
-0.1352684051,
-0.2257717252,
-0.6011821032,
0.242220968,
0.0074387155,
-0.6133275628,
-0.3080286086,
0.8267686963,
-0.3150605857,
-0.1911427975,
0.2617666125,
0.3419306874,
-0.1992551237,
-0.1184849888,
-0.6825733781,
-0.0896195918,
0.0508147366,
0.0513960607,
0.299308598,
0.5229161978,
0.2003962994,
0.3557859957,
0.8473003507,
-0.2128668725,
-0.027382303,
0.282772094,
0.9400259852,
-0.5382018089,
-0.4843974113,
-0.4682143927,
0.2862297595,
-0.2225893587,
-0.1981822252,
0.7314992547,
0.5232786536,
0.6263604164,
-0.1181159094,
0.8148364425,
0.0395538211,
0.2920226455,
-0.6853971481,
0.6940459609,
-0.3340390027,
0.1219078973,
-0.4547026157,
-1.1458575726,
0.0873585939,
0.3966486752,
0.0421980657,
-0.1817598492,
0.8256474137,
0.7614022493,
-0.1761411577,
0.03365127,
0.3491714895,
-0.1475826055,
0.3059317768,
0.5097170472,
0.9976279736,
-0.3513077796,
0.599752605,
-0.1013238654,
-0.2716837227,
0.0616696514,
-0.7889879942,
-0.8719155192,
-0.6707889438,
-0.1407390088,
-0.5848911405,
0.0771044642,
0.4483765066,
0.5625753403,
-0.6363450289,
0.0630739555,
-0.5623102188,
-0.219578594,
0.0310551319,
-0.2502813041,
0.08654771,
-0.3507142067,
-0.6597870588,
0.4816149771,
0.2292990983,
0.1763370335,
-0.0952450633,
-0.6065635681,
0.2789107263,
0.2755322754,
0.3469701409,
0.1627884209,
-0.4748042524,
-0.2234129906,
0.0974515006,
-0.3670921326,
0.2365644723,
1.2318553925,
-0.5694665909,
0.3616624773,
0.630545795,
0.7871745229,
0.2811683416,
0.2137068659,
1.0274600983,
-0.9505905509,
0.1796329468,
0.268143177,
0.2834035158,
0.4004859924,
-0.6029708385,
0.3890833855,
0.5256550908,
-0.3158934414,
-0.4178205431,
0.490871191,
-1.0509421825,
-0.094358325,
1.1156446934,
-0.52966851,
-0.0692093149,
0.2190235555,
-0.1726738214,
0.463696748,
-0.6352465153,
0.6041933298,
0.6284787059,
0.2497131824,
0.0727535561,
0.1323496848,
0.2777165174,
0.676430881,
-0.6069024801,
-0.1710425019,
0.8452056646,
0.33946684,
0.3581389785,
0.8598254919,
-0.0439193323,
0.3864378035,
0.3702189624,
-0.2757842839,
-0.253752619,
-0.3463549018,
-0.2279136181,
0.1137235537,
0.0883914232,
-0.2799553871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12190v1 | Paragraph-level Citation Recommendation based on Topic Sentences as Queries | 2023-05-20T13:28:22 | 2023-05-20T13:28:22 | Zoran Medić, Jan Šnajder | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Citation recommendation (CR) models may help authors find relevant articles
at various stages of the paper writing process. Most research has dealt with
either global CR, which produces general recommendations suitable for the
initial writing stage, or local CR, which produces specific recommendations
more fitting for the final writing stages. We propose the task of
paragraph-level CR as a middle ground between the two approaches, where the
paragraph's topic sentence is taken as input and recommendations for citing
within the paragraph are produced at the output. We propose a model for this
task, fine-tune it using the quadruplet loss on the dataset of ACL papers, and
show improvements over the baselines. | [
-0.3398618996,
-0.6198961139,
0.9925508499,
0.2360693216,
-0.1012090221,
-0.2460860759,
0.123860158,
-0.4801025391,
-0.1353760511,
0.4491140246,
-0.4717760086,
-0.382068336,
-0.3504730761,
0.1748224199,
-0.5984237194,
0.9974514842,
-0.1175378114,
0.2030204982,
-0.5143926144,
0.115500018,
-0.6443013549,
-0.8620185852,
-0.6763981581,
-0.454487443,
1.083065629,
0.7063481808,
0.263707757,
0.5120866895,
0.6536921859,
0.1548001617,
-0.2631745338,
-0.0461350121,
-0.4118341804,
0.2114537805,
-0.540160954,
-0.5698471069,
-0.0357845053,
0.1439724416,
0.5612578988,
0.8125042915,
0.0563618951,
0.0080099637,
0.2131222934,
0.7021269202,
-0.5637409687,
-0.2264477462,
-0.7322659492,
0.2183010727,
-0.1969385147,
-0.6103317142,
-0.5713657141,
-0.7544694543,
0.5727664232,
-0.4798086286,
0.6307193637,
0.4258727729,
0.7905478477,
-0.2692621648,
-0.5021175742,
-0.5220708847,
-0.8008428812,
0.6183152199,
-0.3304517865,
0.2638970315,
0.5523967147,
-0.0823277384,
0.0904409066,
-0.939555645,
-0.2769663334,
-0.5327932835,
-0.328330636,
-0.3019282222,
-0.2992429137,
-0.0258904975,
0.2607928813,
0.5176454186,
-0.5982161164,
-0.3724766076,
-0.2249616832,
-0.1752908677,
0.3759219646,
0.3580062687,
0.2582077384,
-0.1285101175,
-0.2444011718,
0.3407896161,
-0.6754947901,
0.011610386,
0.2923567593,
0.5694105625,
0.2694320083,
0.5598680973,
-0.3108559549,
0.6522195339,
0.4521468878,
0.1863095611,
-0.1029096395,
-0.7395757437,
0.1912055612,
-0.0519910008,
0.1297493577,
0.4793811738,
0.3782745004,
-0.4048078954,
0.1351336092,
-0.2882903814,
0.3474512398,
-0.6965386271,
-0.5055180788,
-0.0992267132,
-0.5289446712,
-0.0916380882,
0.2195059955,
-0.5106729865,
-0.4013954401,
-0.6763674617,
0.188922599,
-0.4789161384,
0.3744901419,
-0.2371384799,
-0.1526195258,
0.0561251864,
0.4241524637,
-0.6199933887,
0.1325431168,
0.2906025946,
1.1754821539,
0.030751029,
-0.3244671226,
-0.5749716759,
0.469343245,
-0.1008209735,
1.4896517992,
-0.8090744615,
-0.5453388691,
0.3008702099,
0.0500605144,
-0.2059852481,
-0.3206699789,
1.0492604971,
-0.4988884032,
0.3221237361,
-0.8869095445,
-0.6499629021,
0.0725931004,
-0.0500884801,
-0.3202039003,
0.7331334949,
0.004352429,
-1.0261081457,
0.6542968154,
-0.5576115847,
-0.6353996396,
0.1095102578,
0.2287096828,
-0.2561300993,
0.0408251993,
0.2593280673,
0.3074389398,
-0.3292651474,
-0.0148577662,
-0.4609885514,
-0.1987460256,
0.1159582734,
0.1077009365,
0.4203782678,
0.3161128461,
0.106490247,
0.2042754143,
-0.8405716419,
0.16342704,
-0.1925592124,
-0.275641799,
-0.6313292384,
0.2194099724,
0.147421658,
-0.0056598866,
0.2008398622,
-0.4267075062,
0.2406497896,
0.053169962,
0.6591482759,
0.3680741787,
0.7157783508,
0.6770311594,
-0.5993778706,
0.3659020364,
-0.1736054271,
-0.0094081564,
-0.1983288825,
-0.3460390568,
-0.9274092317,
0.0956238955,
0.3902876675,
0.3302452564,
-0.4001375437,
0.2860856056,
0.3742367327,
-0.4897833169,
-0.1588383168,
-0.1602917314,
0.2486955076,
0.6919916868,
0.521345377,
0.1643610895,
-0.7170871496,
-0.8793096542,
-0.50197047,
-0.3530934751,
0.0689487681,
0.198402524,
0.2401763052,
0.2897675931,
0.8323222399,
-0.7771263719,
-0.6050682068,
-0.2360840887,
0.5044640899,
-0.0453489237,
0.473110944,
0.657382369,
-0.5450608134,
-0.6409676075,
-0.2730639577,
-0.3978001475,
-0.4973873794,
-0.2360498309,
-0.3570120037,
-0.0529491752,
0.4938996136,
-0.3354334235,
0.4437648058,
-0.0164906289,
-0.7303361893,
0.4048701525,
-0.4166908562,
0.2371722013,
-0.8093394637,
0.2127739936,
0.4688948989,
0.0451605953,
-0.6819743514,
-0.0887592211,
-0.0081913099,
-0.2777528763,
0.1575289518,
0.135205999,
-0.5240001082,
-0.0400292128,
-0.3690162599,
0.0435162671,
0.4944726825,
0.2675491571,
0.0417356007,
0.7908346653,
0.3128015995,
-0.4501514733,
-0.203907907,
0.3969121277,
-0.1459594816,
0.8295714855,
-0.9147676826,
0.2170982659,
-0.0595324785,
0.4870613515,
-0.8922368288,
0.2605140805,
-0.0760999098,
-0.1258143932,
-0.0711566657,
-0.2523272336,
-0.184352681,
-0.2700578868,
-0.108231768,
0.34270522,
-0.1438633949,
-0.1514322609,
0.258749634,
0.296879679,
-0.4739347994,
-0.1595534682,
-0.4612344801,
0.1769446284,
-0.2841913998,
-0.5527216792,
0.6996931434,
-0.3459192216,
-0.0906459019,
0.0149427513,
0.0880556703,
-0.2598638833,
-0.2413782477,
0.307926625,
-0.012324932,
-0.1925498694,
-0.0138376607,
-0.1528695226,
0.0549691543,
-0.0777782723,
-0.294793725,
0.7428515553,
-0.259422034,
-0.1261436939,
-0.692127347,
0.8858353496,
0.3780934513,
-0.4541966021,
0.5160332322,
0.4803080857,
-0.1232483909,
-0.0753876418,
-0.4908756614,
0.1908584535,
-0.3801102042,
0.0030819026,
-0.404165417,
-0.6825319529,
0.5953488946,
0.3364054561,
-0.1487114727,
0.6234295964,
0.7561014891,
-0.1184513196,
0.7454478145,
0.730002284,
-0.0321070962,
0.8072263002,
-0.4406481385,
0.3910349905,
-0.8650461435,
-0.4838534892,
-1.2597594261,
-0.1791610569,
-0.0498141795,
-0.1463582069,
0.1598661244,
0.3776777089,
-0.4048414528,
0.3253960907,
-0.5601045489,
0.3652787209,
0.9680743217,
0.0226643942,
0.4208193123,
-0.0013899627,
-0.2826620936,
-0.0305733103,
-0.6892680526,
-0.5946907997,
0.5979415774,
0.1870898306,
0.5274301171,
-0.1776503026,
0.6593013406,
0.722950995,
0.0082326066,
-0.493858844,
0.5108248591,
0.0039778487,
-0.5490112901,
-0.3089836538,
-0.1515084654,
-1.0051614046,
0.2478964329,
-0.296002239,
-0.6604447365,
0.7597494125,
-0.000634779,
-0.3641170561,
0.0589477755,
-0.4410484433,
0.6326726079,
0.1711951345,
-0.3161925673,
-0.3223339915,
-0.2874125838,
-0.0658959225,
0.1593974233,
-0.1676084399,
-0.1577950865,
0.2476875782,
0.6217351556,
-0.4119509757,
0.424323678,
-0.4142019153,
0.1438911259,
0.6162967086,
-0.0133480998,
0.4251922667,
0.2509077787,
-0.3113262057,
-0.0874291956,
0.163439706,
-0.274482578,
-0.332326442,
0.7189281583,
-0.8098015785,
-0.678811729,
-0.6063660383,
-0.7596635222,
-0.2263102382,
0.2640336156,
0.3122814,
0.7204963565,
-0.1676385552,
0.3373319209,
0.2898358107,
-0.0522321835,
0.4604708254,
0.6072292924,
0.1499083638,
-0.4743653238,
0.610275805,
0.2129741162,
-0.2917328775,
0.4681838751,
0.0865311623,
-0.2774182558,
-1.1397849321,
-0.2206278592,
0.0140199065,
-0.7719292641,
-0.4485192001,
-0.7912356853,
-0.1624933332,
-0.4742205441,
-0.5314411521,
0.304600656,
-0.4804162085,
-0.5444123745,
-0.0076631699,
0.2141682804,
0.5278506279,
-0.0609003864,
0.3168086112,
-0.5243400335,
0.3892060816,
0.1420293152,
0.2459410578,
0.210150376,
-0.6512369514,
-0.3080632985,
-0.1803993881,
-0.5598213077,
-0.6857327223,
0.272832334,
0.3830235898,
0.7380464077,
0.3115303814,
0.3267637193,
0.8140857816,
-0.7207241058,
0.8831889629,
0.2335996628,
-0.8054884076,
0.6913708448,
-0.6376020312,
0.2637176514,
0.7638191581,
0.4038649797,
-0.2753456235,
-0.4576080739,
-0.2977782786,
-0.9644005299,
0.5693584681,
0.2111176848,
-0.0019148292,
-0.0588411689,
0.605122149,
-0.0866288692,
-0.0466610119,
-0.7008699775,
0.1034672484,
-0.0886513144,
0.1176154241,
0.266464144,
-0.495936811,
-0.1439294815,
-0.2148602158,
0.5670387149,
0.033838056,
0.2930683792,
0.7394759059,
-0.026432164,
-0.6007077694,
0.1062698886,
0.4965114594,
1.0461887121,
-0.2435690314,
-0.0148059186,
-0.0381692573,
-0.1458072215,
0.0895917118,
0.0978460088,
-0.3670226038,
0.0100825801,
0.5161822438,
0.4615099728,
0.1852389276,
-0.0421440899,
0.223359555,
-0.1753455848,
-0.4491081536,
-0.3433645368,
0.0418895222,
-0.0460664257,
0.3814848363,
0.7632154226,
-0.0191985313,
0.3941068947,
-0.8363656402,
0.5610006452,
0.2031958103,
-0.2953599691,
-0.0383371152,
0.649371922,
0.2198976278,
-0.4369496703,
0.5046092272,
0.3089189827,
-0.4219795465,
0.2835355997,
0.7496631742,
0.892994225,
0.0327663124,
0.4029444754,
0.3787136078,
-0.1369218826,
0.0600141734,
0.1432172209,
0.0805220231,
-0.4262018204,
-0.2154053748,
-0.8315756917,
-0.3862915933,
-0.1140669733,
-0.8626148701,
0.226083234,
-0.4498506486,
-0.2356511801,
0.4577979147,
0.3826900721,
-0.4815609753,
0.2452626377,
0.0744524822,
0.8960950375,
-0.6276034117,
0.978705883,
0.8341955543,
-0.8890051246,
-0.5236273408,
0.3741619885,
-0.486333251,
-0.3742374778,
0.5361586213,
-0.3465153277,
-0.1438250244,
-0.3516816497,
-0.3478770554,
-1.0554047823,
1.1176456213,
0.2456611991,
-0.4138011932,
-0.3472481966,
0.0387889557,
0.661711514,
-0.8602004051,
0.0171805844,
0.1150260493,
0.4683000147,
0.3065371811,
-0.6139023304,
0.073452197,
-0.1426861435,
0.4460320771,
0.0102396058,
-0.7169715166,
1.2586871386,
-0.2187326401,
0.0785461217,
0.2925995588,
1.0560978651,
0.3506343663,
0.6730592251,
0.5399451256,
0.3285781145,
0.8688153625,
0.1331198961,
1.0799351931,
-0.56077075,
0.1807903498,
1.1600562334,
-0.4208340347,
0.8046190739,
0.295314908,
-0.1745468974,
0.8550299406,
0.703083694,
-0.336674273,
0.9098884463,
0.1601413041,
-0.0103646992,
-0.098041147,
-0.3512838483,
-0.5343633294,
0.0461356081,
0.0840439051,
-0.5077389479,
-0.1421605945,
-0.1721985787,
-0.1230782345,
0.2019349635,
-0.5462146997,
0.5932546258,
0.1304769367,
-0.7662168741,
0.4382225871,
-0.0055618333,
-0.0108310133,
-0.3022173941,
-0.1475824714,
-0.4922393262,
0.156596005,
-0.3621228039,
-0.6849374175,
0.4305435419,
0.0246090814,
-0.8896023631,
-0.1254001111,
0.9609006047,
-0.5172792673,
-0.5449986458,
0.0179557055,
0.3579799533,
-0.1818487197,
-0.0295921806,
-0.6638149023,
-0.1233006269,
0.0264462922,
-0.1842180789,
0.4736867845,
0.7543560863,
0.0971178263,
0.669947803,
0.5619156361,
0.0420253836,
-0.1983360946,
0.1825086176,
0.9682891369,
-0.7607989311,
-0.6604630351,
-0.4151806235,
0.2944783568,
-0.2616567612,
-0.529876709,
0.8962574601,
0.6048649549,
0.6052447557,
0.2330115885,
0.9123034477,
-0.1075756177,
0.6880276203,
-0.4943166673,
0.406838119,
-0.4238651991,
0.3239689171,
-0.4657168388,
-1.1385353804,
-0.4189252853,
0.7427746654,
-0.5053001642,
0.0549933873,
1.0099118948,
0.5221056938,
0.0640222356,
0.2926008999,
0.1542050391,
-0.0026563639,
0.2177147567,
0.2717655897,
0.822332263,
-0.0425757505,
0.6381936073,
-0.1974496245,
0.0977684334,
-0.3825661242,
-0.8637346029,
-0.8568083048,
-0.8164009452,
-0.4358182549,
-0.3443519473,
0.336471051,
0.5093391538,
0.6346019506,
-0.9785652161,
-0.1587902308,
-0.3272294998,
-0.0071716835,
0.0570431575,
-0.2337230742,
0.5397926569,
-0.6415262818,
-0.48591429,
0.314475596,
0.0693902448,
-0.2043455988,
-0.167146638,
0.2641348243,
-0.6265097857,
0.1139621511,
0.5249848962,
-0.0226669218,
-0.5887040496,
-0.7253793478,
-0.15079768,
-0.0635705888,
0.0659871697,
1.6410106421,
-0.488846451,
-0.1834581047,
0.6498659253,
0.0833297297,
0.5063449144,
0.2097292244,
1.0178309679,
-0.361032933,
-0.0321845375,
0.3294639885,
0.5951611996,
0.228138864,
-0.4121722281,
0.5679546595,
0.1694934219,
-1.1199662685,
-0.8228418827,
0.0167359095,
-1.0609916449,
-0.4320642948,
1.1213909388,
-0.6053817272,
0.2732973099,
-0.4077247083,
-0.4162652194,
0.1893830001,
-0.5869471431,
0.7856538892,
0.803101778,
-0.496738404,
-0.2807602882,
-0.1167301238,
0.3814680874,
0.218807146,
-0.4164668322,
0.3851411939,
0.7893278003,
0.1225024983,
0.0887523219,
0.5513312817,
0.024645796,
-0.0320496149,
-0.0177988727,
-0.1761824936,
0.1518395245,
-0.6385387182,
-0.1586323231,
0.8558632731,
0.4626857042,
0.2850913703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12182v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12182v2 | Glot500: Scaling Multilingual Corpora and Language Models to 500 Languages | 2023-05-20T12:26:41 | 2023-05-26T11:30:08 | Ayyoob Imani, Peiqin Lin, Amir Hossein Kargaran, Silvia Severini, Masoud Jalili Sabet, Nora Kassner, Chunlan Ma, Helmut Schmid, André F. T. Martins, François Yvon, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | The NLP community has mainly focused on scaling Large Language Models (LLMs)
vertically, i.e., making them better for about 100 languages. We instead scale
LLMs horizontally: we create, through continued pretraining, Glot500-m, an LLM
that covers 511 predominantly low-resource languages. An important part of this
effort is to collect and clean Glot500-c, a corpus that covers these 511
languages and allows us to train Glot500-m. We evaluate Glot500-m on five
diverse tasks across these languages. We observe large improvements for both
high-resource and low-resource languages compared to an XLM-R baseline. Our
analysis shows that no single factor explains the quality of multilingual LLM
representations. Rather, a combination of factors determines quality including
corpus size, script, "help" from related languages and the total capacity of
the model. Our work addresses an important goal of NLP research: we should not
limit NLP to a small fraction of the world's languages and instead strive to
support as many languages as possible to bring the benefits of NLP technology
to all languages and cultures. Code, data and models are available at
https://github.com/cisnlp/Glot500. | [
-0.6270080805,
-0.0925172046,
0.3036257327,
0.430806607,
0.3059491217,
0.1526175588,
-0.5344585776,
-0.615439117,
0.2991667986,
0.670660913,
-0.3927081823,
-0.4359176457,
-0.6098964214,
0.4095922709,
-0.3431685269,
1.1175339222,
0.1518462449,
0.4356576204,
-0.1240529791,
-0.4680389464,
-0.1878585815,
-0.7743165493,
-0.6015563607,
-0.1844858974,
0.8658667207,
0.4812251925,
0.7026860118,
0.4289304614,
0.4320854247,
0.2941678762,
-0.1871380061,
0.0229426716,
-0.4508691132,
-0.1773495823,
0.0258941185,
-0.509072721,
-0.9697257876,
-0.1362871826,
0.638749063,
1.2674971819,
-0.0377245173,
0.618347168,
0.1923992038,
0.7894998789,
-0.5003194809,
0.0211067572,
-0.2671109736,
-0.1232789755,
-0.2815928459,
0.061832089,
-0.6505429149,
-0.1217270195,
-0.1887355298,
-0.725459516,
0.2700987756,
0.3452554345,
0.4904766083,
-0.0531683899,
-0.3521527648,
-0.4189832807,
-0.7521226406,
0.8893465996,
-0.5901213288,
0.2484336495,
0.4072091281,
0.2540039122,
-0.0494942218,
-0.6295583844,
-0.4714753628,
-0.2566188872,
-0.0509308092,
-0.153839469,
-0.4822418094,
-0.0726946667,
0.5851534605,
0.3273620605,
-0.6282844543,
0.1501872391,
-0.630046308,
-0.3225291073,
0.4452980161,
0.0083846217,
0.2762978673,
-0.0554576553,
-0.2734315395,
-0.2190445811,
-0.7282586694,
-0.0677045062,
0.5968556404,
0.4386104941,
0.0320407636,
0.6016807556,
-0.1940859258,
0.549038589,
-0.2485467046,
-0.2109627575,
0.4560537636,
-0.5965033174,
-0.1904218048,
-0.1411020309,
0.7793995738,
0.1528467238,
0.470523268,
-0.1280527264,
0.0226912647,
-0.2572952211,
0.3168115914,
-0.5082331896,
-0.0033210753,
0.335793227,
-0.368201822,
0.113993898,
-0.4243721366,
-0.7956151962,
-0.2923488915,
-0.5482151508,
0.2267873734,
-0.26425758,
-0.3592423797,
0.299859345,
-0.024084948,
-0.0505942889,
0.4305416942,
-1.0240931511,
0.4145407379,
0.450761199,
0.6970826983,
0.0751217157,
-0.1910891533,
-0.511487186,
0.0688509867,
-0.4660695493,
0.6783453226,
-0.3025642335,
-0.2160340846,
0.2407631874,
0.1676957458,
0.058254879,
-0.8438254595,
0.5182654858,
-0.477870971,
0.2245547175,
-0.6467951536,
-0.3908488452,
-0.1723640561,
0.1939703524,
-1.155790329,
1.1158336401,
0.0045187841,
-0.5878475904,
0.4318710864,
-0.4695135951,
-0.0776123255,
0.2346980274,
0.0629006252,
-0.088666521,
0.1639565825,
0.2870002985,
0.2830553651,
-0.2285486311,
0.1091500595,
-0.6173657179,
-0.2139938772,
-0.0610711388,
-0.0943105444,
0.8913311362,
0.1661262512,
-0.0253089666,
0.3555335701,
-0.7559188008,
0.2568652034,
-0.2210677564,
-0.4221123159,
-0.0542878732,
-0.3653337061,
0.4856700897,
0.3880043924,
0.3071952462,
-0.4987484515,
0.1784358472,
-0.2049571425,
0.3162368238,
0.4135302007,
-0.5407352448,
0.5826160908,
-0.0954081565,
0.897529006,
-0.291344434,
0.0439744554,
-0.1596267074,
-0.4142377079,
-0.9333737493,
-0.4555815458,
0.5443403125,
0.4959974289,
-0.6937665343,
0.4170292616,
-0.403293401,
-0.2675230503,
-0.6939606667,
0.4583937228,
0.1490610689,
0.0481522083,
0.6736994386,
-0.4255287945,
-0.4805737138,
-1.0766067505,
-0.0039248914,
0.1013537198,
-0.5008579493,
-0.1748654842,
0.4497933686,
-0.17121014,
0.7674276829,
-0.1406697482,
-0.5254085064,
-0.8466207385,
-0.0208254736,
0.1517959684,
0.2165963501,
0.7645055056,
-0.4796809852,
-0.4828923047,
-0.1148708314,
-0.6359246373,
-0.0137404548,
0.1062177196,
-0.1632391959,
0.2489455193,
0.8881167173,
-0.2589855194,
0.0991434902,
0.8642665148,
0.0256167278,
0.5461871624,
-0.5764111876,
-0.1205433756,
-0.8550783992,
0.2785313427,
0.1549712569,
-0.3267221153,
-0.744743526,
-0.0956764221,
0.2420211732,
-0.0446938314,
-0.3511075974,
0.4826509655,
-0.4852249324,
-0.2295669913,
-0.2586508989,
0.1738316417,
-0.1669545472,
0.5884849429,
0.0114528388,
0.5637837648,
0.2163083851,
-0.3525604606,
0.2678619325,
-0.1359188557,
-0.2704765499,
0.5498857498,
-0.7211676836,
-0.1310445517,
0.0042604827,
0.5691557527,
-1.0613600016,
-0.2746777534,
-0.0779087692,
-0.1887059957,
0.267275691,
0.090904355,
-0.7920684814,
-0.3878079057,
-0.1472359598,
0.4226438999,
0.2237754613,
-0.480927825,
0.4812290967,
0.3737104833,
-0.3612944782,
-0.6234994531,
-0.563446939,
0.3339869082,
-0.276989758,
-0.5381817222,
0.0288140457,
-0.0700088367,
-0.2308449745,
-0.2375151217,
0.0795923695,
0.1189881712,
-0.1551703364,
-0.0259366073,
0.172883302,
-0.2041878402,
0.3638919592,
-0.3036754429,
-0.29913643,
-0.0259630047,
-0.3837807178,
0.8298883438,
-0.2645726204,
-0.2341177166,
-0.2462880313,
0.5019974113,
0.2559697628,
-0.2882757485,
0.7800064683,
0.7712926269,
-0.2276377082,
-0.19151631,
-0.4350525141,
0.1609149128,
-0.4236498475,
0.5762544274,
-0.2757920623,
-0.9807171226,
0.4662823379,
-0.2715497911,
-0.0040326305,
0.657099545,
0.5842232704,
-0.1638683826,
0.7669622302,
1.1852377653,
-0.405256927,
0.2898049951,
-0.1742464751,
0.112289153,
-0.851662159,
0.04886261,
-0.763743937,
-0.3681724966,
-0.885646224,
-0.7535963655,
0.4893277884,
0.2136449218,
-0.23248294,
0.3518749774,
-0.2105613649,
0.4923134744,
0.6246131063,
-0.1726973355,
0.4753521979,
0.1130235866,
0.0398096442,
-0.0236441754,
-0.7815076709,
-0.9544805288,
1.3511147499,
0.5305395722,
0.46385777,
0.1414067298,
0.6067509055,
0.1491615623,
0.5364189148,
-0.5709722042,
0.5417480469,
-0.4285962582,
-0.9237731695,
-0.5178572536,
-0.3426310718,
-0.8351152539,
0.3402799666,
-0.058625862,
-0.58133775,
0.1875479072,
0.2150082588,
-0.2960923612,
0.197932899,
-0.6092585325,
0.9100823402,
-0.2013397068,
-0.1798321903,
-0.3656263947,
-0.5754832029,
0.3212901056,
-0.1814995557,
0.6617004275,
-0.2891855836,
-0.1956093758,
0.5894098878,
-0.078545168,
0.8651925325,
-0.0961173475,
-0.3606618345,
-0.0551718138,
-0.1179790869,
-0.0586620644,
-0.087502189,
-0.029042244,
0.3563413024,
0.0716967061,
-0.8346361518,
-0.1403506845,
0.3534933925,
-0.691765368,
-0.2242474109,
-0.2963850796,
-0.5913808942,
-0.3892252445,
0.1062382087,
0.1614278406,
0.3775248528,
-0.2661951482,
0.3531815112,
0.6267494559,
-0.6732461452,
0.4662262499,
0.207669273,
-0.5303099155,
-0.4686045647,
0.7385926247,
0.1134026498,
0.7728444338,
0.4150034785,
-0.300024718,
-0.2012168914,
-0.2515262663,
-0.6470000148,
0.2682730854,
-0.7909674644,
0.0530150756,
-0.5098692179,
0.239746958,
-0.3498134017,
0.0222276989,
-0.3107950687,
-0.6370381713,
0.0908805877,
0.084305726,
-0.0058336728,
0.7920081019,
-0.2438146174,
0.2358118147,
-0.5114958286,
0.4154676199,
0.0137216942,
0.0933970511,
-0.0035541768,
-0.5489494801,
-0.4957770407,
0.0603627563,
-0.1516554058,
-0.4163428247,
0.6105326414,
0.251673609,
0.3868945539,
-0.035418354,
-0.127181679,
0.6160451174,
-0.7199603319,
0.5939823389,
0.3448075652,
-0.8724146485,
0.1209939718,
-0.3330213428,
0.6329677701,
0.4273818433,
0.7578493953,
-0.8761216998,
-0.6323752999,
-0.3975558877,
-1.0989525318,
0.5013357401,
-0.1593122035,
0.197673589,
0.215423733,
0.2488465607,
0.0861944631,
0.1734839827,
-0.9373022914,
-0.2150622457,
-0.0707808509,
-0.2306940556,
-0.5844803452,
-0.2010310888,
-0.4098862112,
-0.1067310125,
0.380736053,
-0.5598440766,
0.2341272384,
-0.1357569396,
-0.165349856,
0.022098979,
0.5027699471,
0.6049921513,
0.6821831465,
-0.1218522117,
0.2345904112,
0.3841001093,
-0.5093874335,
0.0633156821,
-0.01148488,
0.1557234079,
-0.1616921723,
0.9195052385,
0.5091828108,
0.2184360027,
-0.6418967843,
0.1439183056,
-0.0594327822,
-0.2352338135,
-0.2867261171,
0.1036619097,
0.5085511208,
0.138104707,
0.5704569817,
0.0412539914,
0.0073084384,
-0.5532853007,
0.1698791534,
0.3100000024,
-0.1252690256,
-0.27297768,
0.6509976983,
0.0621645227,
0.1728574336,
0.6400965452,
-0.1995214373,
-0.2067155242,
0.635450542,
0.1477554739,
0.4538214803,
0.0979086682,
0.3090959489,
0.7478534579,
0.5624446273,
-0.1751064211,
-0.0131207453,
0.2160598487,
-0.6258360744,
-0.7301825881,
-0.9596979618,
-0.6534895897,
0.0707013309,
-0.9049623609,
0.1651533693,
-0.176196143,
-0.1628423333,
0.3447338641,
0.2418566793,
-0.8563883901,
0.2572652996,
0.1889692545,
1.0041064024,
-0.7533304095,
1.1888974905,
0.3822733164,
-0.4926276207,
-0.6123467088,
-0.0209595673,
0.0606961064,
-0.8238961101,
0.8530592322,
0.1427657157,
-0.0017186268,
-0.1448433101,
-0.583168745,
-0.9076892138,
0.8981170058,
0.670584619,
-0.8628931642,
0.0412251428,
0.7036622763,
0.9994639158,
-0.4159510732,
0.1872467101,
0.3498855233,
0.392970413,
-0.0530120842,
-1.2469922304,
-0.1217548549,
-0.059176676,
0.0251710471,
-0.0578996651,
-0.4409780502,
0.6597875357,
-0.2887427211,
-0.0310926363,
0.1815619171,
0.6926131845,
0.1728826761,
0.0180689562,
0.4430503547,
0.5283871889,
0.9077752829,
-0.1980725825,
1.1993649006,
-0.2762401998,
0.2498025894,
1.1309758425,
-0.3474128246,
1.0761567354,
0.3669928014,
-0.4100989401,
0.2265139967,
0.5895913839,
0.1176737919,
0.0764720887,
0.3970890045,
-0.2201677561,
-0.380949378,
-0.0788787305,
-0.390060693,
0.2137476206,
0.2074933052,
-0.01180383,
-0.1055282578,
0.2515393496,
0.155738607,
0.0312249605,
-0.2971946895,
0.5054771304,
0.0069662491,
-0.3815945089,
0.5175439119,
-0.0040700082,
0.618676424,
-0.5454574823,
0.3822953105,
-0.3853006065,
0.4516232014,
-0.2235962003,
-0.5539203286,
0.3643144667,
0.1110185087,
-0.3222059011,
-0.6138144135,
0.2233614773,
-0.7307302356,
-0.7180364728,
0.7212387323,
0.6678874493,
0.1469414681,
-0.0228340346,
-0.3613637984,
0.2090297639,
0.0422568433,
-0.2637851238,
0.7553256154,
0.6097282171,
-0.0827801377,
0.6158498526,
0.5356934071,
0.2187965959,
0.0940599814,
0.3212930858,
0.7095801234,
-0.6859411001,
0.0553244166,
-0.4259894788,
0.4692323804,
-0.0527196154,
-0.3724164069,
0.8683717251,
0.6460350752,
1.1414774656,
-0.1103021875,
0.5897777081,
-0.0343890488,
0.6261314154,
-0.3407997787,
0.486774087,
-0.5971286893,
0.1870218664,
-0.1374428868,
-0.828258574,
-0.4913827777,
0.4154523611,
-0.2148470432,
0.0993774161,
0.6139595509,
0.4916815758,
0.3020828366,
-0.0150465015,
0.30028373,
-0.0324110799,
0.4105427265,
0.3832232952,
0.3965956867,
-0.2652668357,
0.6526440382,
-0.1499740779,
-0.2847987413,
0.1150146127,
-0.7797271609,
-0.6003724337,
-0.5239849687,
-0.1613584459,
-0.1120394543,
-0.419973284,
0.6946255565,
0.7226750255,
-0.8172434568,
-0.7941607833,
0.3210712075,
-0.2462115437,
-0.2986267209,
-0.1088422984,
0.1707002074,
-0.7877789736,
-0.9342268109,
0.2510554492,
0.2295993268,
-0.3435373604,
-0.6363123655,
0.014420026,
-0.1838261932,
-0.1567086279,
0.772847414,
0.2344142348,
-0.5236171484,
-0.0979559571,
0.2164273411,
-0.3543534577,
-0.0084303981,
0.7384698987,
-0.4797313511,
0.3506287634,
0.1563541889,
0.2815496624,
0.5568920374,
-0.4318628907,
0.8536522985,
-0.840559423,
0.2897328734,
0.0149160801,
0.35858652,
0.4323951304,
0.1125890613,
0.6486911774,
-0.0384799652,
-0.5930786133,
-0.7557476759,
0.023323087,
-0.9897389412,
-0.1949674934,
1.162129879,
-0.1019567326,
0.0296205152,
-0.0787278935,
-0.2991525233,
-0.0461160652,
-0.0691830441,
0.4669085145,
1.0075685978,
-0.2325137556,
-0.0215618219,
-1.2155781984,
0.6708294749,
0.3660508692,
-1.0099103451,
0.3122594357,
0.4910338521,
0.1130528674,
0.6461833715,
0.7046544552,
-0.1283931285,
0.0026865685,
-0.074783124,
0.5046348572,
0.5487208366,
-0.4656893611,
-0.4717884958,
0.5426563621,
0.1804430485,
0.210907191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12169v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12169v2 | Learning to Compose Representations of Different Encoder Layers towards Improving Compositional Generalization | 2023-05-20T11:16:59 | 2023-10-18T14:19:40 | Lei Lin, Shuangtao Li, Yafang Zheng, Biao Fu, Shan Liu, Yidong Chen, Xiaodong Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have shown that sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models struggle
with compositional generalization (CG), i.e., the ability to systematically
generalize to unseen compositions of seen components. There is mounting
evidence that one of the reasons hindering CG is the representation of the
encoder uppermost layer is entangled, i.e., the syntactic and semantic
representations of sequences are entangled. However, we consider that the
previously identified representation entanglement problem is not comprehensive
enough. Additionally, we hypothesize that the source keys and values
representations passing into different decoder layers are also entangled.
Starting from this intuition, we propose \textsc{CompoSition} (\textbf{Compo}se
\textbf{S}yntactic and Semant\textbf{i}c Representa\textbf{tion}s), an
extension to seq2seq models which learns to compose representations of
different encoder layers dynamically for different tasks, since recent studies
reveal that the bottom layers of the Transformer encoder contain more syntactic
information and the top ones contain more semantic information. Specifically,
we introduce a \textit{composed layer} between the encoder and decoder to
compose different encoder layers' representations to generate specific keys and
values passing into different decoder layers. \textsc{CompoSition} achieves
competitive results on two comprehensive and realistic benchmarks, which
empirically demonstrates the effectiveness of our proposal. Codes are available
at~\url{https://github.com/thinkaboutzero/COMPOSITION}. | [
-0.1517303586,
-0.6479275227,
0.5320582986,
0.2001610696,
-0.2340242118,
0.3265204728,
-0.2397314161,
-0.5061295033,
0.2749007344,
0.5010812879,
-0.3250504434,
-0.3935932815,
-0.5481581092,
0.1015106663,
-0.293081671,
0.7121854424,
-0.1291448772,
-0.0680863559,
-0.633651495,
-0.0852813274,
-0.634452343,
-0.4223762751,
-0.4443846047,
-0.622323513,
0.1603143662,
0.1110449433,
0.5326614976,
0.5785391927,
0.2333148867,
0.3522847891,
-0.1971701682,
0.3663319945,
-0.3074551821,
0.7004019022,
-0.1138157174,
-0.6292586923,
-0.1847922206,
-0.2812029719,
0.624319613,
0.5510905385,
-0.1170498356,
-0.1607406139,
0.2887499034,
0.6595628262,
-0.9408041239,
0.1101726294,
-0.3858824372,
0.5118808746,
0.159244597,
-0.187683627,
-0.6158546209,
0.1320515275,
0.1419910342,
-0.6270005703,
0.1216112077,
-0.1967323571,
0.2938885391,
0.1347228289,
-0.5603095889,
-0.1012141779,
-0.9132393599,
0.6030099988,
-0.5385352969,
0.546245575,
0.0669645965,
0.3473748863,
0.1407071054,
-0.6739293337,
-0.3315520585,
-0.0431493148,
0.0550163388,
0.7943385243,
-0.0335626826,
-0.0742197633,
0.2723848224,
0.4804312885,
-0.5436981916,
-0.0964043811,
-0.2019850314,
-0.2396272868,
0.5020890832,
0.2533656657,
0.425514549,
0.1398530751,
-0.4636542499,
-0.2719253004,
-0.5860863924,
0.0678844005,
0.3394144773,
-0.2258818895,
-0.2238373756,
0.5419589877,
-0.152654767,
0.5312548876,
0.4998161495,
0.2699697316,
0.303597033,
-0.2139109373,
-0.1798506528,
0.2442563921,
0.557931602,
0.2785943747,
-0.033675082,
-0.6022561193,
-0.1578722,
0.1336385161,
0.5314125419,
-0.665122807,
-0.2756352723,
0.3236440718,
-0.4234490991,
-0.0156173473,
0.3657366633,
-0.3710012734,
-0.3392122984,
-0.5431833267,
0.7212192416,
-0.3344387412,
-0.2935892344,
0.3427004814,
-0.3114925325,
0.6191695333,
0.1091364324,
-1.1099146605,
0.4348725677,
0.7457019687,
0.6523110271,
-0.1631541848,
-0.2112350017,
-0.2320421934,
0.6200193763,
-0.2570776045,
0.5796917677,
-0.5693684816,
-0.1733650863,
-0.0602803379,
-0.065119639,
-0.2437937856,
-0.6896797419,
0.2106984705,
-0.5703137517,
0.3262805641,
-0.3500546217,
-0.8960135579,
-0.0383582562,
0.123502858,
-0.9406247735,
0.7286171317,
0.0814956725,
-0.7652998567,
-0.0047204169,
-0.2085373849,
-0.6158869267,
-0.0290428251,
-0.3894691169,
-0.4574879706,
0.491222918,
0.4405933321,
0.3785990477,
-0.2440864295,
-0.046252951,
-0.0547208488,
-0.572253406,
0.6474885941,
0.1104037017,
0.6027858257,
0.3290901184,
-0.378290534,
0.0020801143,
-0.5579395294,
0.0063724583,
0.1627484262,
-0.4369344115,
-0.1740019172,
0.0060815443,
-0.2197481692,
-0.0956755802,
0.3241929114,
-0.4017516673,
-0.1769768447,
-0.4490351975,
0.6938747764,
0.5646660328,
0.2605432272,
0.9779512286,
-0.4254536331,
0.4857923985,
0.5104832649,
0.0618029647,
-0.3150442839,
-0.235482052,
-0.8733537197,
0.1428683549,
0.3055574596,
0.4746486247,
-0.6913110018,
0.8009136319,
-0.2140892148,
-0.3071600199,
-0.4275696278,
-0.1403080821,
0.4458771944,
0.2377652526,
0.4296052158,
-0.6152840257,
-0.5010794997,
-0.8638949394,
-0.3344361782,
0.2265910953,
-0.0625192821,
-0.0882048309,
0.2352329046,
-0.232735768,
0.5550151467,
-0.3734121323,
-0.1524839252,
-0.1499518156,
-0.2901876271,
0.0158035997,
0.7878258824,
0.2126876563,
-0.6976742744,
-0.4808576107,
0.1051383987,
-0.7600491643,
0.2112204134,
-0.0705566481,
-0.4868375659,
-0.0471696481,
0.4596608877,
-0.6059356332,
-0.1947188526,
0.435218066,
-0.0711676776,
0.1669436097,
-0.1317686141,
0.0611779913,
-1.3615944386,
-0.2592449486,
-0.1666319668,
-0.1426730901,
-0.729084909,
0.4948444963,
0.0530421697,
-0.1126579642,
-0.1693177968,
-0.1251787394,
-0.568569541,
-0.0162587985,
0.0141422534,
-0.1987793744,
0.3162758648,
0.6335129142,
0.0141402362,
0.4655451477,
0.7012737989,
-0.4580457509,
0.3233730197,
0.2098937184,
-0.3187344968,
0.4054526985,
-1.0388803482,
0.406455785,
-0.2634500861,
0.3847143054,
-0.6211552024,
-0.3140663207,
0.3308561444,
-0.3252207339,
0.4347431958,
-0.2229114622,
-0.4026373625,
0.0550069548,
-0.2165441364,
0.5157494545,
0.7410274744,
-0.2595747709,
1.0808851719,
0.4115791023,
0.3238168061,
-0.5413134694,
-1.224703908,
-0.1267332584,
-0.2253404409,
-0.7757251263,
0.7485564351,
-0.0262486115,
0.2706199288,
0.1111908555,
-0.4556256533,
0.1020491347,
0.0024409352,
0.1926660687,
-0.221108377,
-0.2873156071,
0.0486430749,
0.3316499591,
0.0069860658,
0.2580555379,
-0.5705271363,
0.568690002,
-0.0335769691,
-0.5693916678,
0.043323528,
0.7021235824,
0.1812312305,
-0.5943505764,
0.6228950024,
0.5820160508,
-0.4125204682,
-0.6032646298,
-0.4013613164,
-0.1551790684,
-0.4756916463,
0.1776978672,
-0.5639092326,
-1.0210959911,
0.9998500943,
0.2388496548,
-0.4463445544,
0.2973010242,
0.3241789639,
-0.2024241388,
1.0351010561,
0.2859120965,
0.1304302365,
0.5631372929,
-0.7844661474,
0.0871589929,
-1.0359956026,
-0.5036334991,
-0.0804980025,
-0.4410542548,
-0.8325793743,
-0.5231334567,
0.3943978548,
0.1294752955,
-0.3746909797,
0.4125674367,
-0.5338968039,
0.8920589685,
0.6290329099,
0.6610409021,
0.1274630278,
0.2349473983,
-0.2172127217,
0.1879009157,
-0.6650493145,
-0.1298494041,
0.9115462899,
0.3287605345,
0.8448226452,
0.4083161354,
1.2717620134,
0.1088589057,
-0.6711935401,
-0.7432490587,
0.398424685,
-0.4207475185,
-0.1485748142,
0.1644831002,
-0.3574794829,
-0.7646046877,
0.3161323369,
-0.1252804399,
-0.2837611139,
0.5036084652,
0.1168723032,
-0.2150119096,
-0.1158894151,
-0.6120886207,
0.8000151515,
0.0246886238,
-0.4014568925,
-0.1506806165,
-0.7960650325,
0.0725349337,
0.2949961722,
-0.4323845208,
0.3954773843,
-0.0504354537,
0.4795837402,
-0.2801707387,
0.7925089598,
-0.0587351136,
-0.2379995883,
0.508516252,
0.1046292409,
0.403190434,
0.0038497553,
0.1480399966,
-0.2586091757,
-0.1541704237,
-0.4097964168,
-0.7710527778,
0.5316223502,
-0.9312203526,
-0.4387417436,
-0.1467524469,
-0.0827929601,
-0.2235303372,
-0.0968001112,
0.577677846,
0.7451104522,
-0.042547904,
0.4276889265,
0.987185955,
0.0066355742,
0.1775632799,
-0.0467862859,
0.2571524978,
-0.5736823678,
0.8279998899,
-0.0753846318,
0.3370213211,
0.8445842862,
0.0951734185,
-0.3256587386,
-0.4644319415,
-0.2271242738,
-0.0395491086,
-0.9989880323,
-0.3700191081,
-0.6631999612,
-0.6330233812,
-0.3698442876,
-0.0351459011,
-0.1397210062,
-0.4036353528,
-0.4589177966,
-0.0893182755,
-0.1768519431,
0.4921623766,
0.1491301209,
0.2103911191,
-0.8633744717,
0.2253336608,
0.5679936409,
0.1555299461,
0.2299588025,
-0.4816015959,
-0.6961103082,
0.11130099,
-0.4608284533,
-0.8883892298,
-0.0293856096,
0.3630760908,
0.7746829987,
0.1928775012,
-0.105474934,
0.593474865,
-0.2850524187,
0.770534575,
0.2416085005,
-1.2172213793,
0.5041153431,
-0.1537952274,
0.6080294847,
0.3323882222,
0.1540566385,
-0.5347393155,
-0.6385707855,
-0.3971148133,
-0.8067997694,
0.4752974808,
0.116216369,
0.4204550385,
-0.0418367423,
0.1537929773,
0.1299871057,
-0.090415597,
-0.8246479034,
0.0510512926,
-0.4961453974,
-0.4886963665,
0.2071190327,
-0.4236903489,
-0.1228253692,
0.0353325084,
0.3507046103,
-0.0584034882,
0.7557297349,
0.3575564325,
-0.4466751814,
-0.043179445,
0.4291772544,
0.3241716921,
0.4570479691,
0.1497209966,
0.5780778527,
-0.159238413,
-0.2376436442,
0.2484812438,
-0.0620171949,
-0.3386239707,
-0.4095361829,
0.7316548824,
1.0329803228,
0.2213580161,
-0.2966691256,
0.5823769569,
0.2707890272,
-0.2445465475,
-0.3273904324,
0.4332772195,
0.2524459362,
0.7068372369,
0.1966395527,
0.1487251669,
0.5007747412,
-0.5347543359,
-0.0559401922,
0.1756906658,
-0.0599822067,
-0.5091299415,
0.6269059777,
0.1919106841,
0.3085224032,
0.4851901233,
-0.1283141375,
-0.7189570665,
0.7000117302,
0.8458818793,
1.1312947273,
-0.0921156779,
0.2109745294,
0.302349478,
0.038618844,
-0.2566255331,
0.4392415285,
-0.4661431313,
-1.0017035007,
-0.5626632571,
-0.3847000897,
-0.2714757919,
-0.2450434715,
-0.6852027178,
-0.0152219627,
-0.3378084302,
-0.0189591758,
-0.2077301145,
-0.1688693911,
-0.6779363155,
-0.0059324829,
0.2834489048,
0.3910534978,
-0.9633826017,
0.4959180355,
0.8832775354,
-0.466935724,
-0.7548438907,
0.1474541277,
-0.5339072347,
-0.4687095582,
0.4434641004,
0.2738246322,
-0.0865630209,
0.0394183807,
-0.4614713788,
-0.7029720545,
1.1620898247,
0.5038399696,
-0.4338153899,
-0.0802991912,
0.3952947855,
0.636336565,
-0.6853820682,
0.1330978721,
0.3079947233,
0.2636424303,
0.0680344254,
-0.3390436769,
0.1883063912,
-0.3416746557,
0.3883242011,
0.0391700938,
-0.5714402795,
0.8296508789,
0.0683832988,
-0.5477480292,
0.0052957344,
0.6562520266,
0.0546669476,
0.2458316684,
0.1567351669,
0.9476097226,
0.3910667598,
-0.1230809167,
0.8533504605,
-0.085492,
0.0859976113,
1.2868645191,
-0.0165209733,
0.5902061462,
0.2307643294,
-0.0970330909,
0.6290397048,
0.4576010108,
-0.1098669842,
0.9269095659,
0.194525376,
-0.4414851367,
-0.3723645806,
0.0960284621,
-0.4305506349,
0.7025460601,
0.1433441192,
-0.5352888703,
0.1885108799,
0.019455716,
-0.5137190819,
0.2410189807,
-0.1478210539,
1.2439250946,
0.0469832942,
-0.7084274888,
0.3681097627,
0.0085104937,
0.3312963247,
-0.4477640986,
0.0285968408,
-0.310187459,
0.1113287956,
-0.2839356661,
-0.761751771,
0.2329843938,
-0.528097868,
-0.1556038707,
-0.1313590109,
0.9169850349,
-0.8968920112,
-0.1648109257,
0.1908323616,
0.5643047094,
-0.3236910999,
-0.1212143227,
-0.3357881904,
0.2636499405,
-0.2212254405,
-0.0562889613,
0.0507741757,
0.416077584,
0.1647514254,
0.0859003291,
0.3290067315,
-0.1489144862,
0.2772476673,
0.3504051268,
0.8438006639,
-0.7113140821,
-0.6885447502,
-0.7642890811,
0.6451026201,
-0.1122729555,
0.1565556079,
0.4570780694,
0.6346461773,
1.0897365808,
-0.6257881522,
0.5886995196,
0.0249340609,
-0.0908432603,
-0.9690331817,
0.3623841107,
-0.3071854413,
0.133580327,
0.0000025512,
-1.4639811516,
-0.1633292586,
0.617554307,
0.2595117092,
0.1324174702,
0.6432176232,
0.6900100708,
-0.2907990813,
0.2659340203,
0.2299526334,
-0.0391930901,
0.2239508629,
0.9365075827,
1.3010360003,
-0.6961535215,
0.0245786831,
-0.3653836846,
0.120727025,
-0.1260224581,
-0.7125070691,
-0.7850281596,
-0.730553925,
-0.4454508424,
-0.1947243065,
-0.0554127656,
0.7224696875,
0.6512643099,
-0.8229830265,
-0.1782348156,
-0.3329602778,
-0.0884066969,
-0.4385696352,
-0.1896633953,
0.058799386,
-0.2129420638,
-0.5522720814,
0.3878802657,
0.2326670885,
0.278283596,
-0.201338008,
-0.2328915596,
0.3925004005,
0.1523036808,
0.7548376918,
-0.1008974835,
-0.6253913045,
-0.2720435262,
0.1178981736,
-0.014642735,
0.0952947736,
1.107446909,
-0.5661708713,
0.5688656569,
0.842923522,
0.9453573823,
0.7841265202,
-0.1938711703,
0.4909291565,
-0.9858299494,
-0.230982244,
0.2434292436,
0.4927323163,
0.4392102063,
-0.3713544607,
0.4679360986,
0.0480599292,
-0.4574257135,
-0.1917813122,
0.4834916592,
-1.361722827,
-0.2243703008,
0.9213871956,
0.0048422543,
-0.262953192,
0.3979584277,
0.0966276005,
0.4600262344,
-0.2727550566,
0.4138821959,
0.517937541,
-0.1019938514,
-0.3857232928,
0.0157936048,
0.1007536799,
0.3671821356,
-0.7196832299,
-0.2351964414,
0.5660907626,
0.275721848,
0.1780474335,
0.3898544014,
-0.2197969407,
0.2995133996,
-0.0489904135,
-0.2536829412,
-0.2567529678,
-0.2887161076,
-0.4052095413,
0.0813800246,
-0.0831417069,
-0.2817789614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12152v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12152v2 | Revisiting Automated Topic Model Evaluation with Large Language Models | 2023-05-20T09:42:00 | 2023-10-22T09:46:13 | Dominik Stammbach, Vilém Zouhar, Alexander Hoyle, Mrinmaya Sachan, Elliott Ash | cs.CL | cs.CL | Topic models are used to make sense of large text collections. However,
automatically evaluating topic model output and determining the optimal number
of topics both have been longstanding challenges, with no effective automated
solutions to date. This paper proposes using large language models to evaluate
such output. We find that large language models appropriately assess the
resulting topics, correlating more strongly with human judgments than existing
automated metrics. We then investigate whether we can use large language models
to automatically determine the optimal number of topics. We automatically
assign labels to documents and choosing configurations with the most pure
labels returns reasonable values for the optimal number of topics. | [
-0.7628703117,
-0.5290178061,
0.9464039803,
0.1195298061,
-0.2574315369,
-0.1681823432,
-0.5106329918,
-0.4130538404,
0.0127702747,
0.5809805989,
-0.2947374582,
-0.201721698,
-0.7722346187,
0.2401714921,
-0.7790331244,
0.9386630654,
0.0362699889,
-0.1244374141,
-0.4288338423,
0.0122083267,
-0.5165377259,
-0.3736740947,
-0.4969410002,
-0.6272300482,
0.4601888359,
0.1797787547,
0.6558811665,
0.6083350182,
0.7886094451,
0.4654377401,
-0.0531190895,
0.0667470098,
-0.483614862,
0.0220389497,
-0.3863342404,
0.0344150662,
-0.2993749678,
0.167841211,
0.7220522761,
0.8969489932,
0.0746178254,
0.0962909088,
-0.1497784853,
0.454238236,
-0.4992785752,
-0.0559044778,
-0.5619011521,
-0.1032306179,
0.1353137642,
-0.2488149256,
-0.6834508181,
-0.2636070848,
0.5763114691,
-0.4049275517,
0.0891505256,
0.103100054,
0.952680707,
0.1297002435,
-0.7012702823,
-0.5578368902,
-0.7453426719,
0.9152857661,
-0.4534133077,
0.4179989398,
0.6220203042,
0.2869089544,
0.0528532825,
-0.7541677952,
-0.4519466162,
-0.6570366025,
-0.0259864964,
0.0235470086,
-0.3402560353,
-0.1602272987,
0.2272567153,
0.4539998472,
-0.7546055913,
0.377141118,
-0.1766394228,
-0.0288770031,
0.9979373813,
0.3499237001,
0.388064146,
-0.249029696,
0.1022621393,
-0.1058573276,
-0.0894564241,
-0.4752855301,
0.3509064019,
-0.0022537073,
0.2704664171,
0.5948594213,
-0.2017495632,
0.9803866148,
0.1379083246,
-0.0240861103,
-0.0623203032,
-0.3785121143,
-0.1772464812,
-0.210979104,
0.7970377803,
0.3940792382,
0.1824977249,
-0.1888496429,
-0.418941319,
-0.0426806696,
0.5673725009,
-0.7823932767,
-0.1517531425,
0.4009204805,
-0.4048907757,
-0.3146212101,
0.1483341455,
-0.6161493659,
-0.4794387817,
-0.7523658872,
0.6192603111,
-0.1507741809,
-0.0144257285,
0.4042117,
-0.2333716005,
-0.1569951326,
0.7005618811,
-0.8900399208,
0.2812107801,
0.9232490659,
0.8374205232,
-0.3780003786,
-0.3011744916,
-0.4259157181,
-0.0666205809,
-0.6363825798,
0.9044637084,
-0.5971274376,
-0.440528065,
-0.1755374521,
0.1082533374,
0.1261579543,
-0.4298850596,
0.3621847034,
-0.6699342132,
0.4081261158,
-0.1233076751,
-0.9357174039,
0.1946819127,
0.2247475535,
-0.7989585996,
0.5628249049,
-0.0971117765,
-0.7048777938,
0.3911798596,
-0.7935343981,
-0.1362451464,
-0.034667667,
0.2247593403,
-0.3946889937,
0.0359111242,
-0.0109017417,
0.4643302262,
-0.6484016776,
0.9064036608,
-0.2331151515,
-0.067903243,
0.3612130582,
-0.5386040211,
0.7907624841,
0.4432958066,
-0.1461474448,
0.3946292996,
-0.4129622281,
-0.2866737247,
0.0726995692,
-0.2901251018,
-0.5464562774,
0.0692891926,
0.0581955835,
-0.2690346837,
0.3914780319,
-0.3357944489,
0.1439920366,
-0.3877994716,
0.3904569447,
0.6838623285,
0.0665738434,
0.7026557922,
-0.253395319,
0.3947526813,
-0.5985042453,
-0.0836995617,
-0.268197298,
-0.4994589984,
-0.755867362,
-0.2544108033,
0.6404464841,
0.2535685003,
-0.3705160618,
0.9984663725,
-0.1478236318,
-0.7639958262,
-0.1082992777,
-0.1117656454,
0.0204951093,
0.1740388274,
0.0037883485,
-0.4722717404,
-0.1385055035,
-0.9404990077,
-0.0932915881,
-0.179722473,
-0.1110701263,
0.3046800494,
0.8093347549,
-0.2331620157,
1.014857173,
-0.75647825,
0.2387625724,
-0.1407672763,
0.5999686718,
0.0462114774,
0.345025152,
0.4408700466,
-0.9133859873,
-0.3296412528,
0.1738476455,
-0.5798694491,
-0.2561416626,
-0.3420902789,
-0.3094189167,
0.2855205238,
0.3203671277,
-0.560378015,
0.1793949455,
0.2946597338,
-0.3319513202,
0.5502462983,
-0.3325808942,
0.1545456946,
-0.8969881535,
0.2482717782,
0.205478251,
-0.2335786372,
-0.3122103214,
0.0950218216,
0.1107559502,
-0.5771380067,
0.0112341726,
1.0341514349,
-0.4267074466,
-0.3262274563,
-0.5482840538,
0.1546150446,
0.2170829475,
-0.0657215044,
0.2032189667,
0.5347049832,
0.2149318457,
-0.3910582066,
0.715457499,
0.1175152287,
-0.6691322327,
0.3021302223,
-0.6683453918,
0.1637014449,
-0.3494705558,
0.5969403386,
-1.2151795626,
-0.3839904666,
-0.156179741,
-0.2501221299,
0.394028306,
-0.0125292717,
-0.3972998261,
-0.6328876019,
-0.221233815,
-0.1114801094,
0.2774478495,
-0.2825856507,
0.2536334395,
0.6955856085,
-0.3596025407,
-0.336227566,
-0.2456078529,
0.351690501,
-0.2826113999,
-0.5854480863,
0.207520932,
-0.2841206491,
-0.5550430417,
-0.045621369,
0.0308685694,
-0.107860215,
0.1977117807,
0.0504163168,
0.1384488046,
0.0100469356,
0.5321864486,
-0.1085999981,
-0.3316157162,
-0.1236234307,
-0.5450517535,
0.7647991776,
-0.2339071333,
-0.5453122258,
-0.2069408745,
0.5536329746,
0.6682022214,
-0.5852692723,
0.5288734436,
0.3814002275,
-0.5561133027,
0.0639977008,
-0.6519232392,
-0.1622341722,
-0.4162223339,
0.7289738655,
-0.2498773634,
-0.7862531543,
0.1181879044,
0.0138873225,
0.2793865502,
0.7257984877,
0.9155228138,
0.047216028,
0.9154726863,
0.6414185166,
-0.1099392697,
0.4053259194,
-0.3333625197,
0.3037184775,
-0.3435048163,
-0.0322202779,
-0.8699794412,
-0.0637794137,
-0.364487946,
-0.3628875017,
0.2229880393,
-0.1412916631,
-0.2577263415,
0.2678506076,
-0.5246154666,
0.5278485417,
0.4873847961,
-0.0067404332,
0.3180858195,
0.040783342,
0.324950397,
0.0727298632,
-0.3898929358,
-0.943862021,
0.8615668416,
0.4655627012,
0.464890331,
-0.1713335663,
0.682290554,
0.4422884583,
0.5935716033,
-1.0908417702,
0.5638142824,
-0.5565010309,
-0.6469042301,
-0.8005998135,
-0.2934606671,
-1.1236413717,
0.1976590008,
-0.1615942717,
-0.6676020026,
0.189537093,
-0.1003389284,
-0.3145834506,
0.0344380811,
-0.6671798229,
1.0155600309,
-0.3515413404,
-0.1347599626,
-0.3439121246,
-0.2591731548,
0.2690857649,
-0.6164135337,
0.0506553315,
0.0776641294,
-0.0600606129,
1.1241948605,
-0.3690104187,
0.6093683243,
0.2539436221,
-0.4934221208,
0.3261846304,
-0.0645342693,
0.1658302099,
0.0448946096,
-0.4966554046,
-0.1531389207,
-0.1076150611,
-0.1785196662,
-0.538064003,
0.7094073892,
-0.9495638609,
-0.7893408537,
-0.392962575,
-0.5476719141,
-0.0488138422,
0.3755365908,
0.1840662509,
0.5850417018,
-0.4214338362,
0.2698526978,
0.4998903871,
-0.682985723,
0.4051575363,
0.6305151582,
-0.4777173996,
-0.2671820521,
1.0732793808,
0.2875265181,
0.1655501127,
0.4159603417,
0.4413435459,
-0.3734425008,
-0.4733643234,
-0.5738899708,
0.2620174587,
-0.6429408789,
-0.0534755066,
-0.9606297612,
-0.0821447819,
-0.2058414221,
-0.299859941,
-0.3107344806,
-0.21300596,
-0.216114223,
0.0188658629,
0.2565036714,
0.6598860025,
-0.0990378261,
0.113684766,
-0.8271965981,
0.583768487,
0.7449263334,
0.2528992891,
0.0805636346,
-0.7245793343,
-0.1216855869,
-0.1164142713,
-0.334997952,
-0.9628821015,
0.4904772937,
0.0438564718,
0.4480447769,
0.3065325022,
0.1525509208,
0.2552308738,
-0.5939977169,
0.529732883,
-0.0371341296,
-1.035078764,
0.5220566988,
-0.6397519112,
0.3182009161,
0.4235741794,
0.6776995063,
-0.5656142831,
-0.2199108154,
-0.6178410649,
-0.9206671715,
0.524869442,
0.0340594612,
0.3872029185,
-0.1525059938,
0.0803307518,
0.2746656835,
0.1496881247,
-0.3809357285,
0.138622731,
0.1342716217,
-0.1157824844,
-0.2900117338,
-0.3067702949,
-0.0204809159,
-0.1088298634,
0.4234608412,
-0.0553086102,
0.3478195965,
-0.1573195457,
0.0338930376,
-0.3152019978,
0.1417357773,
0.5773362517,
1.2687437534,
-0.1900832802,
-0.0242064558,
0.1025209278,
-0.170698747,
0.2127569765,
0.081434451,
-0.1237341091,
0.1050956845,
0.4475049376,
0.9408472776,
-0.0930211619,
-0.8096163869,
0.3223260045,
-0.0407870598,
-0.1405083984,
-0.2896496952,
-0.1148547828,
0.4690076113,
0.0560350642,
0.2530943453,
-0.2782808244,
0.2455702424,
-0.7285180092,
0.4838156402,
0.4184634387,
-0.0540669113,
0.1848638952,
0.3111420572,
0.2494483292,
-0.5633468628,
0.6824689507,
0.0957786441,
-0.6816321611,
1.1808618307,
0.3328272402,
0.7661492825,
-0.1195495948,
0.4218397141,
0.4026075304,
0.2187413573,
-0.39757514,
-0.2251377553,
0.2039369345,
-0.6238862276,
-0.5984000564,
-0.8447724581,
-0.7216855288,
0.1763503999,
-0.5090186,
0.446516484,
-0.1856960952,
-0.2154756188,
0.5427321196,
0.1926992685,
-0.3521858752,
0.5307770967,
0.2347805202,
0.7602951527,
-1.0636533499,
0.6946207881,
0.7989373207,
-0.2271837741,
-0.410402894,
0.0071493946,
-0.1651243418,
-0.3759313524,
0.6940435767,
-0.0047459709,
0.1124612838,
-0.0700224191,
-0.6363877058,
-0.8147379756,
0.6616407633,
0.2311002165,
-0.787057519,
0.3176985383,
-0.1934173554,
0.7534565926,
-0.1695128828,
0.3651212752,
0.3122382164,
0.727243185,
0.0045275846,
-1.1414384842,
-0.2896061242,
-0.2340667993,
-0.0786843002,
0.456106931,
-0.5248211026,
0.7481546402,
0.0781699643,
0.1193936542,
0.1378827691,
0.719625175,
0.1189208031,
0.5041598678,
0.6906003356,
0.4154882431,
0.9335297346,
0.1123559475,
1.2559423447,
-0.1162732467,
0.5674354434,
0.9170463681,
-0.4341645539,
0.7626223564,
0.0879987702,
-0.437507689,
-0.2224878967,
0.9465045929,
-0.1970124543,
0.2525136471,
0.5271602869,
-0.0674882531,
-0.4188044965,
-0.1219320148,
-0.2722728252,
0.512991488,
0.3595711589,
-0.274337709,
-0.139146924,
0.1330192536,
-0.0773184448,
0.098312825,
-0.0899654999,
0.8684574962,
-0.0835499167,
-0.8879525065,
0.4767787158,
0.4523053169,
0.4746303558,
-0.3899414837,
0.1107494384,
-0.3695267737,
-0.0894798562,
0.0993746445,
-0.9308254123,
0.4535831511,
0.3356264234,
-0.3734835088,
-0.324693501,
0.9152091742,
-0.3622000217,
-0.8186534047,
0.1111602187,
0.2841637433,
0.2880757749,
-0.1058631539,
-0.4984349608,
0.0803350434,
-0.0573430955,
-0.3798061311,
0.5602276921,
0.5254300833,
-0.4286358654,
0.6728567481,
0.5391687751,
-0.1007365435,
-0.3107168972,
0.0824563205,
0.647431314,
-0.5397062898,
-0.6338819861,
-0.7623510957,
0.268070668,
-0.2335730344,
-0.2040907443,
0.4839397967,
0.4042006135,
0.6761979461,
-0.0845448971,
0.8780775666,
-0.0304208435,
0.4266979098,
-0.394515276,
0.8656666875,
-0.9013648629,
0.2813126743,
-0.5285711288,
-1.1601338387,
-0.2208708674,
0.7173365355,
-0.757706821,
0.0382817499,
0.5213578343,
0.5678192377,
-0.1117453277,
0.1606035531,
0.3127847314,
0.0955483615,
0.2547776699,
0.3222964108,
0.9946824312,
-0.06524425,
0.2016578913,
-0.2109403014,
-0.3320672512,
-0.2961277962,
-0.9878870845,
-0.6758336425,
-0.7990831733,
-0.4194145501,
-0.0176974889,
0.2337166369,
0.89832443,
0.5324817896,
-0.7705818415,
-0.4517035186,
0.3366858959,
0.1746393889,
0.3883928359,
-0.1847926378,
0.6455658674,
-0.151694715,
-0.9850948453,
0.1436025351,
0.2823027968,
-0.1197619438,
-0.4449062049,
0.0324490033,
-0.2141864002,
0.0277866777,
0.6354566216,
0.056933891,
-0.6119129062,
-0.2272487432,
-0.1367727369,
-0.3762291074,
-0.4378970861,
0.9990362525,
-0.438369602,
0.4784885347,
0.7870736718,
0.9478746057,
0.4704533815,
0.1621633619,
0.901317358,
-0.1052895784,
0.0162905697,
0.125518471,
0.386996448,
0.1876333803,
-0.1107832491,
0.5777590871,
-0.0021172648,
-0.5702900887,
-0.9696095586,
0.0681474656,
-0.7832457423,
-0.6942782998,
1.1364761591,
-0.1668524444,
0.0882779062,
-0.1894650459,
-0.3848769665,
0.1460636705,
-0.2097347975,
0.8410090208,
0.8968192339,
0.093664512,
-0.0748128816,
-0.66356951,
0.0130269369,
0.5905680656,
-0.9163993597,
-0.0125659034,
0.7250859141,
-0.0738801807,
0.349252969,
0.5628318787,
0.0787652731,
0.1084436327,
-0.3065035641,
-0.1066291407,
0.3097676039,
-0.6257375479,
-0.2919362485,
0.1816043854,
0.2402985543,
0.2751024663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12147v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12147v2 | LogiCoT: Logical Chain-of-Thought Instruction-Tuning | 2023-05-20T09:23:09 | 2023-10-28T04:22:58 | Hanmeng Liu, Zhiyang Teng, Leyang Cui, Chaoli Zhang, Qiji Zhou, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative Pre-trained Transformer 4 (GPT-4) demonstrates impressive
chain-of-thought reasoning ability. Recent work on self-instruction tuning,
such as Alpaca, has focused on enhancing the general proficiency of models.
These instructions enable the model to achieve performance comparable to
GPT-3.5 on general tasks like open-domain text generation and paraphrasing.
However, they fall short of helping the model handle complex reasoning tasks.
To bridge the gap, this paper presents LogiCoT, a new instruction-tuning
dataset for Logical Chain-of-Thought reasoning with GPT-4. We elaborate on the
process of harvesting instructions for prompting GPT-4 to generate
chain-of-thought rationales. LogiCoT serves as an instruction set for teaching
models of logical reasoning and elicits general reasoning skills. | [
-0.4170471132,
-0.8197769523,
0.6044747829,
-0.3666609526,
-0.6380274892,
-0.108472079,
0.2264841199,
-0.2797628343,
0.1520797312,
0.6490389705,
-1.0169270039,
-0.1734446287,
-0.4450894594,
0.0300400276,
-0.3708871007,
1.5408914089,
0.1301168203,
-0.3624378145,
0.347817868,
0.088551648,
-1.0616960526,
-0.336760968,
-0.5479847789,
-0.3031449914,
0.210517928,
0.2588078976,
0.8853976727,
0.5432209969,
0.4789700806,
0.3312064409,
0.6168193221,
0.1824174821,
-0.3570512831,
0.0486922637,
-0.8535246849,
-0.570115149,
-0.6679548025,
0.4318991303,
0.1947295666,
0.0556529723,
-0.2189993709,
0.2884896696,
-0.5675743222,
0.7540594935,
-0.4282938242,
0.1657911241,
-1.0796563625,
-0.0299111344,
-0.1374120414,
-0.4727615416,
-0.4040765762,
-0.6949070096,
0.2996399999,
-1.0668898821,
0.2473780513,
0.4441370368,
0.7355313897,
0.4924066067,
-0.4387762547,
-0.6070551276,
-0.5071698427,
0.637236774,
-0.3050167263,
0.2106668204,
0.2811635137,
0.5331945419,
-0.1586640626,
-0.9333525896,
-0.9027142525,
0.4042254388,
0.1414415091,
0.3349274993,
-0.1650557071,
0.0415071845,
0.4436828196,
0.4508416951,
-0.2602136135,
-0.5142341852,
-0.5969048142,
-0.1001298949,
0.253808409,
-0.145937413,
0.1413320452,
0.0323319137,
-0.4307874441,
-0.0596471801,
-0.7251466513,
-0.3370883167,
0.4349759519,
-0.0733120963,
0.2690834999,
0.3598944545,
-0.0514141805,
0.9239054322,
0.2696889937,
0.0444116332,
0.2981855273,
-0.2279300541,
-0.4396979213,
0.2088885754,
0.4859576225,
0.1332095563,
0.5457040668,
0.1692375243,
-0.3423300385,
0.290122807,
0.4503664672,
-0.7320860028,
-0.7618762851,
-0.1348989159,
-0.0699831173,
-0.1587061435,
0.1077954546,
-0.5474997163,
0.1937597692,
-0.4875044823,
0.7052721381,
-0.6171419621,
-0.1406970471,
0.4386294484,
-0.2893756032,
0.5821650028,
0.4435811937,
-1.0949662924,
0.3611156642,
0.5391862988,
0.43776384,
0.152726844,
-0.1748154163,
-0.6777474284,
0.2590833604,
-0.4674479663,
0.987490952,
-0.7032219172,
0.0869945958,
-0.3985850215,
0.0449780859,
-0.2930832505,
-0.3081669509,
0.727673173,
-0.8549590111,
0.4812374711,
-0.6125913262,
-0.7990496755,
-0.3271639347,
0.2070451677,
-0.6964441538,
0.609962821,
0.3448895514,
-0.8572157621,
0.2474019229,
-0.7532666922,
-0.5357333422,
0.2728345394,
-0.4174907804,
-0.1695413888,
-0.1072595567,
0.4549728036,
0.1731824279,
-0.4792214334,
0.011361965,
0.1256162971,
-0.2965586782,
-0.1166400164,
-0.2251660377,
0.7027853727,
0.2229062021,
-0.5312147141,
0.2377430648,
-0.6000718474,
0.3878709078,
0.1951777339,
0.301012516,
-0.1792057902,
0.0277206711,
-0.6995421648,
0.4403087795,
-0.0251779277,
-0.3280971944,
0.420810461,
-0.4087655842,
0.8013079762,
1.1175996065,
0.1394093335,
0.0893827453,
-0.2482410669,
0.6892458797,
-0.0894580558,
0.2091429383,
-0.1331165135,
-0.8935136199,
-0.801219523,
-0.1394762248,
0.1119221151,
0.6690903306,
-1.2078646421,
0.6595209837,
-0.139193505,
-0.2427950948,
-0.511418283,
0.1393839568,
0.2788881063,
0.7954822183,
0.5938715935,
0.1095022857,
-0.2280244976,
-0.9451409578,
-0.216218546,
0.2317563593,
-0.0817218497,
-0.3738778234,
0.8561375141,
-0.0282967798,
0.9475802183,
-0.6884405017,
-0.2016963065,
-0.2294444293,
-0.019003801,
0.3365332186,
0.4596190155,
0.2368009835,
-0.5242785215,
-0.1197770834,
0.0960593149,
-0.7220476866,
0.1746712327,
0.0900640562,
-0.6409124732,
-0.2165959179,
0.2217650115,
-0.8585447669,
0.3780572712,
0.4051361084,
-0.3780890405,
0.4710142314,
-0.2401157916,
0.1419338733,
-0.8871176243,
-0.3077372909,
-0.4910500944,
-0.0987203717,
-0.232223928,
-0.1819307506,
0.0711754709,
-0.0457841977,
-0.3012343049,
0.2019299865,
-0.2655278146,
-0.023006862,
-0.2145527154,
0.2509895265,
0.0521313958,
0.5666432977,
-0.0806431472,
0.861661315,
0.3331478834,
-0.439005971,
0.5473182201,
0.4087285101,
-0.2505558729,
0.6452935338,
-0.5852012038,
0.5064960122,
0.1365755796,
0.4000405073,
-0.2379922271,
-0.2569274902,
0.3566689193,
0.065236032,
-0.1860392988,
0.1707504839,
-0.5061315894,
-0.5858697891,
-0.0432133898,
0.5149210691,
0.6846491098,
-0.7060421705,
0.7302593589,
0.1213591471,
0.1858299524,
-0.1851570755,
-0.2289324999,
-0.553219676,
-0.1123946086,
-0.492393136,
0.1628000438,
-0.0798468292,
0.1212553158,
0.0218810681,
-0.323997587,
0.1613029093,
-0.2676344514,
-0.149608776,
0.277510941,
-0.0118837934,
0.4314386845,
0.545932591,
-0.2665723562,
0.3628732264,
-0.9316722751,
0.3567172885,
-0.6601951718,
-0.4508194029,
-0.4311110973,
-0.0063834204,
0.0434161536,
-0.5277563334,
0.2286006957,
0.3794495463,
-0.1444869637,
-0.652659595,
-0.4307170212,
-0.3774562478,
-0.5454952121,
0.0735757947,
-0.7413036227,
-0.755890727,
0.1532010883,
-0.3205680549,
0.0118563743,
0.7533310056,
0.3226184845,
-0.0787641183,
0.7083884478,
0.3422389925,
0.1659677476,
0.1581515074,
-0.2176764756,
0.4464896619,
-0.4973706901,
-0.0781152248,
0.0270735919,
-0.2381518781,
-0.5035839081,
-0.4430404305,
0.197572723,
0.0870239139,
-0.665792942,
0.1490956545,
-0.9794906974,
1.0236167908,
0.8256002665,
0.0558831282,
0.3865346611,
-0.0813966319,
0.1130782068,
0.1334021688,
-0.7219310999,
-0.273042798,
0.8761637211,
-0.0524168685,
0.6952789426,
-0.1284884661,
0.39799878,
0.2764009237,
0.1841512173,
-0.4419952035,
0.4750809073,
0.0939009786,
-0.7897704244,
-0.2360824645,
-0.3670320213,
-0.7064197659,
0.1156525761,
0.0168832242,
-0.4649507701,
-0.3313025236,
0.5676711202,
-0.1859527528,
0.3783742189,
-0.849819839,
0.8287398219,
-0.3196665347,
0.0904844105,
-0.3339471817,
-0.9291912317,
0.6506616473,
-0.1631665975,
-0.0521819852,
-0.0984571278,
0.2677916884,
0.5924508572,
-0.7307029366,
0.4177224934,
-0.0093370695,
-0.1711612195,
0.8200805783,
0.0618026629,
0.614162147,
-0.1179285645,
0.1518588364,
-0.0002073159,
-0.0916797295,
-0.4627512395,
-0.9213532209,
0.5492497683,
-0.7577958107,
-0.8128281832,
-0.5026559234,
-0.5928928256,
-0.2627881169,
0.4134942889,
0.5291214585,
0.2639286816,
0.2636788785,
-0.1609105319,
0.8928065896,
-0.0691262335,
0.0094238436,
-0.1329562366,
-0.2050453424,
-0.5479899645,
1.0197540522,
-0.0097858235,
0.5279955268,
0.3276118338,
0.3631106317,
-0.3255914152,
0.0954068229,
-0.5357381701,
0.149874717,
-0.9858327508,
-0.3856665492,
-0.2892311811,
-0.3600027561,
-0.0271929502,
-0.3015468419,
-0.3191317916,
-0.6232368946,
0.2678923607,
-0.5798019767,
0.7533813715,
0.9421447515,
0.2917293012,
0.3994269669,
-0.4202288687,
0.5144917369,
0.9287264347,
0.1949004531,
-0.1847393066,
-0.4238787591,
0.028758185,
-0.1431108266,
-0.5922683477,
-0.8553056121,
0.0697431862,
0.2458059937,
0.3021195829,
0.2604156435,
-0.0020257344,
0.5333083868,
-0.7250839472,
0.309900254,
0.2832601964,
-1.3037701845,
1.1628866196,
-0.6027610302,
0.5071960688,
0.2989672422,
0.3251047134,
0.0451927446,
-0.1413769126,
-0.719091475,
-0.4038107693,
0.6833536029,
0.5498897433,
-0.1176644489,
-0.4652583003,
0.3168250322,
0.3232243955,
0.4664475024,
-0.8019636869,
-0.0296981428,
-0.9502564073,
-0.3444979787,
0.427952379,
0.2607777715,
-0.3615221083,
-0.6301910281,
0.7402620912,
-0.3070931435,
0.3555167019,
0.0687390193,
0.0657719448,
-0.0145542761,
0.2542462647,
0.3514190316,
0.7614998221,
-0.1535089612,
0.2341406941,
0.1039353982,
-0.4947308004,
0.2549388111,
-0.0793899894,
-0.1632140726,
-0.4961497486,
0.3004582524,
0.8862971663,
0.005710464,
-0.5596639514,
0.4461597204,
0.1034132168,
-0.5560401082,
-0.1608490348,
0.512591064,
0.0518414155,
0.102454327,
0.1064675897,
0.2438791692,
0.1103015989,
-0.4714767933,
0.1186210215,
0.0791151226,
-0.0713840872,
-0.5174251199,
0.7521316409,
0.5074014664,
-0.1610033959,
1.1736854315,
-0.4842580557,
-0.5898185968,
0.3564765751,
0.8667853475,
0.808406055,
-0.1968076974,
0.1020331904,
0.2270956933,
0.5555167794,
-0.1229799613,
0.430087775,
-0.0563218147,
-0.8991152644,
-0.5788847208,
-0.4555449486,
-0.2573466003,
-0.0628684908,
-0.5300075412,
0.1390776187,
-0.668356657,
-0.0435630791,
-0.2762380838,
-0.2874189615,
-0.86324507,
0.3543262482,
-0.2700817287,
0.7184819579,
-0.6499088407,
1.3193125725,
0.271786809,
-0.4665947258,
-1.1806225777,
-0.1429121345,
-0.0896912515,
-0.7774694562,
0.6471986771,
0.3522820473,
-0.645727396,
0.4186449647,
-0.5625485182,
-0.7039251328,
1.3164154291,
0.5361568928,
-0.6017423272,
-0.0157447103,
-0.0839552358,
0.3442871869,
-0.2856178284,
0.2025007755,
0.8949877024,
0.3492325544,
0.2008423656,
-0.4423117936,
0.232883662,
-0.3181877732,
-0.211441949,
0.4365773797,
-0.6818067431,
0.9850197434,
-0.2498383224,
-0.0653635561,
-0.2750900388,
0.7838819623,
0.4377688169,
-0.0923324823,
0.7925223708,
0.736913383,
1.0578569174,
-0.1429992318,
1.0145440102,
-0.2242556959,
0.0651610121,
1.3621060848,
-0.3201933503,
0.6067174673,
0.3200407624,
0.0252836067,
0.8450292349,
0.3639341593,
0.0266114473,
0.5875149965,
0.1531672329,
-0.1924862415,
-0.3810751438,
0.5167369843,
-0.5591486692,
0.1353011876,
0.5623168349,
-0.1713326871,
0.1139827073,
-0.0719714835,
-0.1809835285,
-0.135593906,
-0.362844795,
0.3716802597,
0.0802892148,
-0.9595983624,
0.3709935248,
-0.3925974369,
0.2347978503,
-0.6621467471,
-0.4763198495,
0.0310782939,
0.2664081752,
-0.0772187412,
-0.6986196041,
0.1830539405,
-0.2037559748,
-0.1635315865,
-0.1856730729,
0.6955706477,
-0.1219794378,
-0.5627982616,
0.2220552117,
0.4341212809,
0.0606830493,
-0.033619944,
-0.7907037139,
-0.2434282452,
0.1179537922,
-0.3242545426,
-0.0054421457,
0.9775547981,
-0.3219971061,
0.7109843493,
0.6271156669,
-0.3187998235,
0.3457306325,
0.3753498793,
0.9945347309,
-0.8704289794,
-0.4632946849,
-0.5406574011,
0.1010688171,
-0.0043715429,
-0.5322743058,
0.6549377441,
0.2881250679,
1.0196499825,
-0.2126369029,
0.8470128775,
-0.2476299852,
0.3260072172,
-0.7375013828,
0.1449596733,
-0.0422934517,
0.2076244503,
-0.1796493083,
-0.9635050297,
0.1657016873,
0.853953898,
-0.5221823454,
0.2215553969,
1.2401083708,
0.3888497949,
-0.2370556742,
0.6215648055,
0.1359099299,
0.0770919472,
0.3490949571,
0.6200823188,
0.8312061429,
-0.4949404597,
0.520426929,
-0.0040866309,
-0.2972761691,
0.4600214064,
-0.7320584655,
-0.9744036794,
-0.2503097653,
0.0209267363,
0.0574750751,
0.2816455662,
0.8918766975,
0.6907760501,
-0.5611137748,
0.0806822032,
-0.6701212525,
0.057355199,
-0.5009732842,
-0.1872314811,
0.4494521618,
-0.5854592919,
-0.3459096849,
0.2235456705,
0.2722694576,
-0.3035760522,
0.0623286478,
-0.0862871334,
-0.2734923065,
0.1020412743,
0.6801220179,
-0.0170403495,
-0.7156992555,
-0.48200652,
-0.1716222614,
0.3807296753,
0.0413152687,
0.8613154292,
-0.8756698966,
0.5334115028,
0.2406479269,
0.5767948627,
0.5707273483,
0.1353455484,
0.8144395351,
-0.5366129279,
0.0738751069,
0.1734588444,
0.1295435727,
0.046262607,
-0.2453310639,
0.6835741401,
0.4279777408,
-0.7831414342,
0.069134213,
0.4137192965,
-0.8856409788,
-0.1879804432,
0.6827810407,
0.0053323228,
-0.1802562773,
0.0109137353,
-0.2465084195,
0.1815489829,
-0.2871906757,
0.5463495255,
0.5609132648,
-0.4073213339,
-0.0742346719,
-0.7887845635,
0.5838435888,
0.3995391726,
-1.2944902182,
-0.2489299327,
0.3731979728,
0.2127504945,
-0.0526218116,
0.8678928614,
0.0874876454,
0.3398143351,
0.1223588288,
0.1029748693,
0.1756139398,
-0.4109824598,
0.3873289227,
0.0191793852,
-0.1769961864,
-0.1348839998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12146v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12146v2 | Hedges in Bidirectional Translations of Publicity-Oriented Documents | 2023-05-20T09:19:39 | 2023-05-23T01:42:06 | Zhaokun Jiang, Ziyin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hedges are widely studied across registers and disciplines, yet research on
the translation of hedges in political texts is extremely limited. This
contrastive study is dedicated to investigating whether there is a diachronic
change in the frequencies of hedging devices in the target texts, to what
extent the changing frequencies of translated hedges through years are
attributed to the source texts, and what translation strategies are adopted to
deal with them. For the purposes of this research, two types of official
political texts and their translations from China and the United Nations were
collected to form three sub-corpora. Results show that hedges tend to appear
more frequently in English political texts, be it original English or
translated English. In addition, directionality seems to play an important role
in influencing both the frequencies and translation strategies regarding the
use of hedges. A noticeable diachronic increase of hedging devices is also
observed in our corpus. | [
-0.227829054,
-0.6130900979,
0.460203588,
0.4331897497,
-0.5606501698,
0.1803987324,
-0.1706637293,
-0.2865023017,
0.4597334564,
0.556571424,
-0.4261741042,
-0.7493774295,
-0.6882032156,
0.0835930854,
-0.6742121577,
1.1164779663,
-0.1181768402,
-0.1840378642,
0.3827347159,
-0.2998259664,
0.0091152219,
-0.3880094886,
-0.4386178851,
-0.2862748504,
0.665040493,
0.3277150393,
0.9917025566,
0.6250177026,
0.8080146909,
0.3024155498,
-0.1435553581,
-0.3182191849,
-0.1835726798,
-0.0504982583,
-0.2781728506,
-0.3029005527,
0.1282950491,
0.6291677356,
0.974892199,
0.4486828446,
-0.2533763349,
-0.3621764779,
-0.0855730698,
0.7962788939,
-0.4498462081,
0.0324580036,
-0.7926893234,
-0.2249449939,
-0.927611649,
-0.5214022398,
-0.4751952291,
-0.3533670306,
0.0713277012,
-0.5354857445,
0.1060500219,
-0.1864252985,
1.2314356565,
-0.0766214728,
-0.783831656,
-0.2905197442,
-0.4521906078,
0.7862608433,
-0.599244833,
0.2427602857,
0.030688623,
0.2388255149,
-0.0048409854,
-0.6813396811,
-0.1006774083,
-0.1691198647,
-0.3278650045,
0.4296309948,
-0.3959158957,
0.0739963129,
-0.0317867175,
0.025834959,
-0.1255128384,
0.1156683639,
-0.3496944308,
-0.2712188363,
0.8754532933,
-0.0544905625,
0.3038624227,
-0.7217109799,
-0.5472887754,
-0.5847613215,
-0.9327400327,
0.0767165422,
0.9302268028,
0.1289422363,
-0.1574561298,
0.3936249316,
-0.0115665309,
0.3042741716,
0.2672052383,
0.2508323193,
-0.2810072303,
-0.7436340451,
0.0233980622,
0.1696242094,
0.8908092976,
0.8309847116,
0.2523850799,
0.0646045506,
-0.2543741763,
-0.2081987262,
0.0489721186,
-0.8381940126,
-0.4130180478,
-0.2145725489,
-0.5455762744,
-0.4929070473,
0.4509528279,
-0.7754507065,
-0.4726231992,
0.2718518972,
-0.1505118012,
-0.393293649,
-0.1432018578,
0.3172572851,
-0.5066062212,
0.1984331608,
0.0596121773,
-0.4224890172,
-0.0438665301,
0.6599498987,
0.8424488306,
-0.352049619,
-0.0403449833,
-0.2590019703,
0.2024535388,
-0.9377773404,
0.9416549206,
-0.5593517423,
-0.6788723469,
0.4742941558,
0.2317708135,
-0.1013051867,
-0.2640834749,
0.7704665065,
-0.9812929034,
0.4943127036,
-0.2681860328,
0.0683102608,
-0.1293172985,
-0.0830065981,
-0.6037144065,
0.550989747,
-0.1491256058,
-0.8962807655,
0.5199362636,
-0.026615886,
-0.7457637191,
-0.2897085249,
-0.092929244,
-0.5204927325,
-0.1006893292,
-0.2825115919,
0.1765286177,
-0.2081991732,
0.1607649773,
0.2461038679,
-0.2108540684,
0.1940767318,
-0.5506407619,
0.9689939618,
0.1651685685,
-0.3706434965,
0.3999252319,
-0.521206975,
-0.447055459,
-0.1930466741,
-0.3601130545,
-0.9543021917,
0.5063553452,
-0.1031003222,
0.1512046456,
0.1150069907,
-0.4960119128,
0.2109600008,
-0.6242464781,
0.6542518139,
0.7157214284,
0.7074072957,
0.4899753034,
-0.2938399911,
0.1787722409,
0.4336251318,
-0.1505496055,
-0.0954351351,
-0.3957570493,
-0.5885611773,
0.1620901227,
0.2117615938,
0.6671097279,
-0.4841069579,
-0.1759622991,
-0.0463611782,
-0.4064371884,
-0.3540525734,
-0.4033664763,
0.1906940043,
-0.0729334652,
0.0989582241,
-0.1884863377,
-0.3621159196,
-1.0321836472,
-0.5319649577,
-0.4824238718,
0.3468266726,
0.2671763897,
0.211831972,
-0.1333484054,
0.5243476033,
-0.4734306037,
-0.110644199,
0.3038339615,
0.4954409003,
0.3005986214,
0.0928376839,
0.7906849384,
-0.8851925731,
-0.8215264082,
0.3166697323,
0.2480906546,
-0.3283228278,
-0.9287981987,
-0.5840592384,
0.2717111707,
0.9621514082,
-0.6185972691,
0.2708357573,
0.4250974655,
-0.3021814227,
0.5279527903,
0.0884027407,
0.5850976706,
-0.8560993075,
-0.2157878131,
-0.0846353173,
-0.2731951475,
-0.3619148433,
-0.2310873568,
0.2369361669,
0.5983474255,
-0.3262068033,
0.0491062365,
-0.4246325493,
0.4565548599,
-0.0144993002,
0.6174281836,
0.0839578658,
-0.1624315381,
-0.0493475012,
0.9170539975,
0.2540140152,
-0.7164616585,
0.3435897827,
0.3910309672,
-0.0294591542,
0.9239231348,
-0.5074868798,
0.0257398654,
-0.2525278628,
0.0125482902,
-1.3835878372,
0.1541751623,
0.3553160429,
-0.0859746113,
0.4279271364,
-0.1013688296,
0.0368218161,
-0.3097653389,
-0.7073149681,
-0.3312394619,
0.4494193196,
-0.2120856792,
-0.299775809,
0.1143412665,
0.0340873487,
-0.4818829,
-0.6444872618,
0.3064166307,
-0.4446119964,
-0.3828458488,
0.8462965488,
0.2382089794,
-0.6575403214,
0.2835683525,
-0.1564485431,
0.3322692215,
-0.2125534862,
-0.0015706319,
0.0785462409,
-0.1132463142,
-0.1144977883,
0.2015477568,
0.0162520241,
0.3540828526,
-0.4404513538,
0.1191426143,
0.4191569388,
-0.4113856852,
-0.398534447,
0.393972218,
0.40273422,
-0.2490859032,
0.8812745214,
0.3949925005,
0.1314968467,
0.1194315404,
-0.5009331107,
0.1295782477,
-0.441901803,
0.3756658435,
-0.3272117078,
-0.2404136658,
0.3622660339,
-0.1090793535,
0.4346057475,
1.2013661861,
0.452151686,
-0.1465587616,
1.0031400919,
0.438960731,
-0.2827665806,
0.7375253439,
-0.1446495801,
-0.1460147351,
-0.4552367628,
-0.2556135058,
-0.7677428126,
-0.2453586608,
-0.9927487373,
-0.3751209676,
0.1886010617,
-0.0619998164,
-0.1398995817,
0.6456511021,
-0.5364564657,
0.121047169,
0.5325325131,
-0.5402496457,
0.2909969687,
0.0767905638,
-0.022564698,
-0.2464323193,
-0.3455193937,
-0.5018535256,
0.3458610475,
0.1648395956,
0.7511479259,
0.2582612038,
0.5952258706,
0.3034421206,
0.3705511689,
-0.5791661739,
0.5830631852,
-0.50179708,
-0.2813908756,
-0.1836834252,
-0.2222491801,
-1.3426394463,
0.1334165782,
0.1527243853,
-0.4153615236,
0.5460911393,
-0.4534921646,
-0.1592116058,
0.3626452982,
-0.0330167711,
0.6155571342,
-0.18703942,
-0.366302222,
-0.5666579604,
-0.6660892367,
0.149119705,
0.163717106,
-0.0826022252,
-0.1178936511,
-0.4537267685,
1.0573713779,
0.0444127023,
0.6309526563,
0.0405793041,
-0.456307292,
0.4931493402,
0.2660606205,
0.7651116848,
-0.0544653274,
-0.2803102136,
0.1914049536,
0.6889705658,
-0.0678071231,
0.0156052494,
0.7401704192,
-0.8176392913,
-1.1442016363,
-0.7424006462,
-0.6253940463,
0.2383060008,
0.2370591015,
0.4572405815,
0.083183445,
-0.7633789182,
0.3734388053,
0.3160323203,
-0.0522524416,
0.5980349183,
0.5427889824,
0.1809432358,
-0.3272511363,
0.4102453887,
0.470131129,
0.348669827,
0.3684559762,
0.1388960034,
-0.2482304275,
-0.3671091795,
-0.7481514215,
0.3432764411,
-0.4143408239,
-0.0352367125,
-0.2684219182,
-0.2622424662,
-0.5381562114,
-0.3337039649,
-0.2431612909,
-0.3462323844,
-0.4527612031,
0.0143332044,
0.7217969298,
0.9655327201,
-0.2151627541,
0.5662792325,
-0.482496202,
0.1726332009,
-0.056034077,
0.1022499353,
-0.7065880299,
-0.6704522371,
-0.1311049163,
0.0766798854,
-0.2491053194,
-1.8740634918,
0.330514729,
0.1025028527,
0.4037101269,
0.8617898226,
0.120724313,
0.6351751089,
-0.7330077887,
0.670409143,
0.134487316,
-0.5283711553,
0.0843950287,
-0.8308960795,
0.1402272433,
0.6147404313,
0.5461537838,
-1.0357354879,
-0.1200478598,
-0.7948771119,
-0.7146881819,
0.8564172983,
-0.0242554005,
0.4908334613,
-0.2938697636,
0.4090771675,
-0.1921269298,
0.3749995232,
-0.220308587,
-0.2457740158,
-0.0259593762,
0.1523404568,
-0.2745038867,
-0.5538720489,
-0.4567508698,
0.1952686459,
0.5986017585,
0.2462452054,
-0.2551661134,
0.3552934229,
0.2555237114,
-0.2869691253,
0.512342453,
0.3287857175,
0.479177624,
-0.1434147954,
0.3766728342,
-0.151009962,
-0.4767072499,
0.2271432132,
0.248689726,
-0.7215444446,
0.4351330996,
0.05282332,
0.5778955817,
0.3603222072,
-0.0470922515,
0.4154500663,
0.5846787095,
-0.2808144689,
-0.2144482881,
-0.4513533413,
0.3112000227,
0.1273757219,
-0.016361298,
-0.0668370649,
0.3301355541,
-0.8227899075,
0.364282608,
0.9063625336,
-0.6652587652,
-0.4387795925,
0.8665084243,
0.4366480112,
-0.3107168376,
0.3168873787,
-0.610483706,
-0.5729930997,
0.5435952544,
0.5621667504,
0.8820257783,
-0.4277521074,
0.6671133041,
0.1881553084,
0.6513999701,
0.2395076305,
0.0196633413,
0.1082395241,
-0.1863779277,
-0.2489189357,
-0.1953750551,
-0.2093132734,
-0.1202514321,
-0.5569603443,
0.2421436608,
-0.115611285,
-0.3872097433,
-0.0994642228,
0.1363798827,
-0.1721154898,
-0.4022046924,
-0.0313140154,
1.0958179235,
-0.9610443711,
0.5421206951,
0.7728068233,
-0.2512662709,
-0.2456435561,
0.2930676043,
-0.0185350887,
-0.1775264591,
0.418122679,
-0.2326269299,
-0.3781872988,
0.1310693622,
-0.2955922484,
-0.8477960229,
0.6881117821,
-0.0259187408,
-0.530293107,
0.0525855906,
0.3508780599,
0.4072800875,
0.0382814072,
-0.166618973,
0.9399735928,
0.6148405671,
0.0743723437,
-0.6839338541,
-0.1077462807,
0.1119813025,
-0.1926585138,
0.7176047564,
-1.1866188049,
1.1707581282,
0.0864178613,
-0.7454869747,
0.0111696171,
0.6231308579,
-0.1895256788,
0.3133068085,
0.4290915132,
-0.0822504386,
0.3523028195,
-0.1454530954,
0.8155988455,
-0.6104611754,
-0.1433269978,
0.1514295489,
-0.3036979735,
0.7160896659,
0.6285431385,
-0.3653630316,
1.2112978697,
0.6039431691,
0.2505702376,
0.5074778795,
0.1789141595,
-0.0924584642,
-0.1124002635,
-0.3360612094,
-0.2102452219,
0.3014015853,
0.2185287923,
-0.2257467359,
-0.4013787806,
-0.1580437422,
0.5214944482,
0.5388345718,
-0.139673084,
0.6720535755,
0.253841728,
-0.9099551439,
0.2453460842,
0.6317455173,
0.7457527518,
-1.0220725536,
-0.0681509823,
-0.1574605256,
0.1229975298,
-0.0475749373,
-0.8973739147,
0.5448526144,
-0.1638289094,
0.2476567179,
-0.6913148761,
0.5286154151,
-0.6139019728,
-0.3718534708,
0.3273380697,
0.3638302386,
0.1895399094,
-0.011605571,
-0.8316635489,
-0.2821158469,
0.0618700758,
-0.7346063256,
0.0480890907,
0.5211056471,
-0.5497674942,
0.0352875069,
0.6216208339,
0.4003618956,
-0.1244776472,
0.0557374656,
0.7510917187,
-0.7558045983,
-0.3894838095,
-0.9923203588,
-0.0860013291,
-0.3742325306,
-0.0969157889,
1.3889219761,
0.4327003956,
0.3906627595,
0.3063016832,
0.4976641238,
-0.0806814134,
0.0029985819,
-0.502250433,
1.0047879219,
-0.2080414146,
0.0616563223,
-0.1646126062,
-0.4069597423,
0.0475360528,
0.3989098668,
-0.6201733947,
-0.2132007629,
0.6919486523,
0.5377289057,
0.147964865,
-0.3802936375,
0.0379520617,
0.3953160942,
0.0845497102,
0.4320369959,
0.4488128722,
-0.3706010878,
0.7644162178,
-0.4391221702,
0.2030954212,
-0.0703859106,
-0.9773007035,
-0.6228359342,
-0.8984869719,
-0.4087201953,
-0.4481008649,
0.4707077444,
0.2162308842,
0.5357603431,
-0.6853452325,
-0.413754791,
0.0683301687,
0.2923648059,
-0.1344273239,
-0.1149690598,
0.8754762411,
0.1794772595,
-0.9626794457,
0.2396855652,
0.2468422353,
0.2307801247,
-0.5313057303,
0.3409387767,
-0.6365312934,
0.8309226632,
0.4047321379,
0.107421793,
-0.5237370133,
-0.4284386337,
0.1477742791,
-0.5778265595,
0.0504572093,
0.8982449174,
-0.5896232724,
0.0934730247,
0.8194847107,
-0.099456422,
0.2054669112,
0.6962304711,
0.2186521739,
-1.011998415,
0.7953820825,
-0.0198724531,
-0.0564283989,
0.3521693051,
-0.4510797858,
0.2592850029,
0.4167235196,
-0.323176831,
-0.4869403839,
0.1271781176,
-0.6211367846,
-0.2021770775,
1.5835274458,
0.2289309502,
-0.0554289371,
0.0350855179,
-0.6065180898,
0.2457535416,
-0.1753611118,
0.4077138901,
0.9398121238,
0.11362084,
0.1962777525,
-0.8977630734,
0.7727370262,
0.3240275681,
-0.4672217667,
-0.0252801254,
0.438690573,
0.0084453281,
0.2591604292,
0.7642277479,
-0.2381595373,
0.0790889934,
0.2532151937,
-0.1956872195,
0.3694111109,
-0.3251999021,
-0.0221679974,
-0.0106632281,
0.0137823187,
-0.3233358264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12129v1 | Lifting the Curse of Capacity Gap in Distilling Language Models | 2023-05-20T07:30:55 | 2023-05-20T07:30:55 | Chen Zhang, Yang Yang, Jiahao Liu, Jingang Wang, Yunsen Xian, Benyou Wang, Dawei Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pretrained language models (LMs) have shown compelling performance on various
downstream tasks, but unfortunately they require a tremendous amount of
inference compute. Knowledge distillation finds a path to compress LMs to small
ones with a teacher-student paradigm. However, when the capacity gap between
the teacher and the student is large, a curse of capacity gap appears, invoking
a deficiency in distilling LMs. While a few studies have been carried out to
fill the gap, the curse is not yet well tackled. In this paper, we aim at
lifting the curse of capacity gap via enlarging the capacity of the student
without notably increasing the inference compute. Largely motivated by sparse
activation regime of mixture of experts (MoE), we propose a mixture of minimal
experts (MiniMoE), which imposes extra parameters to the student but introduces
almost no additional inference compute. Experimental results on GLUE and CoNLL
demonstrate the curse of capacity gap is lifted by the magic of MiniMoE to a
large extent. MiniMoE also achieves the state-of-the-art performance at small
FLOPs compared with a range of competitive baselines. With a compression rate
as much as $\sim$50$\times$, MiniMoE preserves $\sim$95\% GLUE score of the
teacher. | [
-0.5722780228,
-0.6311178803,
0.3930219412,
-0.1559346765,
-0.422798723,
0.2628446817,
-0.4578830898,
-0.2851240039,
0.32070297,
0.4822428823,
-0.3434042335,
0.1088050827,
-0.9761965275,
-0.1084829643,
-0.2175182402,
0.9754107594,
0.3137153983,
-0.1057889462,
-0.6642136574,
0.0492256135,
-0.9194982052,
-0.0106186979,
-0.5774601698,
-0.4003811777,
0.097599633,
0.7895802259,
0.582828939,
0.5237411261,
-0.0880749151,
0.3674061596,
0.0632977858,
0.2597295046,
-0.7973757982,
-0.0208023656,
0.1449637115,
-0.6854599118,
-0.3755455017,
0.2851936221,
0.4220121503,
0.9491372705,
-0.3219706118,
-0.0644384548,
0.731505692,
0.5833596587,
-0.6621600389,
-0.0117434338,
-1.0716967583,
-0.2755421698,
-0.2637273073,
-0.1167815775,
-0.5567439795,
-0.0825857893,
0.2256843895,
-0.5248950124,
0.4189530909,
0.0138885817,
0.7708964944,
0.6914497018,
-0.3515364826,
-0.0926805064,
-0.6565119028,
1.0018622875,
-0.6377082467,
0.1438423842,
0.6563164592,
0.3395927548,
-0.3483685255,
-0.5389333963,
-0.5486060977,
-0.2256169766,
-0.0648387894,
-0.08479321,
-0.038767118,
0.1751087457,
0.2226796746,
0.4965519607,
-0.3036303222,
0.2197988778,
-0.7521523237,
-0.1163380444,
0.3963451982,
-0.0366545729,
0.2202962488,
0.1557389349,
-0.434856385,
-0.0240142718,
-0.5455157161,
-0.1228640974,
0.3310505748,
0.2479533404,
0.0927314237,
0.3394041359,
0.102103211,
0.8117038012,
0.1398777664,
-0.460801214,
-0.0856643394,
-0.1115930825,
-0.2450947315,
0.0942535773,
0.7265626788,
0.0740935877,
0.4641512334,
0.0204284824,
-0.0852963105,
-0.0547511876,
0.1489280909,
-0.866179347,
-0.6579217911,
-0.1053577811,
-0.0362230465,
-0.0775072128,
-0.1177991927,
-0.9727139473,
-0.5623729229,
-0.2237823308,
0.4337759912,
-0.5457553267,
-0.4048573375,
0.1130991131,
-0.1008076072,
-0.4587456584,
0.2011886686,
-1.0267156363,
0.5195599198,
0.3591115177,
0.796967268,
-0.0360433646,
-0.0486217923,
-0.436553508,
0.0003442903,
-0.0774248913,
0.5025522113,
-0.4910153449,
-0.4637842178,
-0.351546973,
-0.6065413952,
-0.1774298251,
-0.8603856564,
0.4443404973,
-0.2794497311,
0.1357452571,
-0.0353007838,
-0.6995581388,
-0.0127908308,
-0.1020888314,
-0.8450772166,
1.1253744364,
0.1959336847,
-0.4296656847,
0.5479390025,
-0.191188395,
-0.1740361005,
0.1280421764,
-0.3775880337,
-0.2743062377,
0.3998177052,
0.2387877554,
0.2294940352,
-0.3939260542,
0.2337535173,
-0.3293579221,
-0.4427638948,
0.198264569,
-0.6803277135,
0.7241801023,
0.2584023178,
-0.0776432827,
-0.4112313092,
-0.7014095187,
-0.0458244644,
-0.1427865624,
-0.3291545212,
-0.8619558811,
-0.2627911866,
-0.334962368,
0.2506460845,
0.2339947224,
-0.3578620851,
0.498003006,
-0.4016130567,
0.2451683432,
0.9223257303,
-0.3040083051,
0.7460587621,
-0.2514697313,
0.4767884016,
0.2961393595,
-0.0166028738,
0.1366778016,
-0.5754083395,
-1.0060471296,
-0.5201278925,
0.7666732073,
0.1965070367,
-1.1118085384,
0.3881489336,
-0.5204060674,
-0.4583342671,
-0.9893075824,
0.655690372,
0.3227018714,
0.5392955542,
0.3715060651,
-0.2874926329,
-0.4882270694,
-0.8533607125,
-0.2704202831,
-0.2060949504,
-0.0779656023,
0.2316811681,
0.3069224656,
0.279792577,
1.3255097866,
-0.7003452778,
-0.5791692734,
-0.4343540967,
0.1629630029,
0.3960080445,
0.9517807961,
0.5983902812,
-0.6504523754,
-0.7811300755,
-0.3166787922,
-0.282543987,
-0.3644196987,
-0.1437291652,
0.1355085373,
0.1941689849,
0.3074167669,
-0.6155876517,
0.1885024905,
0.6608567238,
-0.318838805,
0.4861301482,
-0.2638444602,
-0.0610025823,
-0.806227088,
-0.3188563585,
-0.1424759179,
-0.3862291574,
-0.6448997259,
-0.1207458898,
-0.1492536217,
0.0215048864,
-0.224678278,
0.5300936699,
-0.7236303091,
0.3608822525,
-0.5475285649,
0.3289654553,
-0.1475909799,
0.3824139833,
-0.2866465449,
0.6738683581,
0.4646677077,
-0.6435973644,
-0.0298028104,
-0.2167510539,
-0.5247142315,
0.2108097076,
-0.3716416657,
0.2395592481,
0.1222920418,
0.0019417343,
-0.9795700312,
-0.015047241,
0.0020372092,
-0.3076102436,
0.625513494,
-0.3084261715,
-0.5130698085,
-0.5274345279,
-0.0575342961,
0.6029325724,
0.9200510979,
-0.3493493795,
0.6204249263,
0.3738159239,
-0.0069328402,
-0.6760832667,
-0.7468783855,
0.030828014,
-0.3379610479,
-0.6779501438,
0.2347011417,
-0.1384357214,
-0.1904533952,
0.1870919168,
-0.4002680779,
-0.3366651535,
0.1146799028,
0.0737727433,
0.2156771123,
-0.1890717894,
0.0829835162,
0.316708535,
-0.2204747349,
-0.2854826748,
-0.3898192942,
0.6526322365,
-0.0813568756,
-0.2822163999,
-0.1835319251,
-0.0089621274,
0.5016437769,
0.2039559484,
0.9781140089,
0.213688612,
-0.3004032969,
-0.5196765661,
-0.9565390348,
-0.5901840925,
-0.5349962711,
0.1777215749,
-0.4595154524,
-0.9946940541,
0.3913911581,
-0.1368905902,
-0.3036226034,
0.1968462318,
0.2821754813,
0.0915751308,
0.6593667865,
0.7354354262,
-0.3157380819,
0.2885647714,
-0.4524427652,
0.1806195378,
-0.5111736655,
0.0939491764,
-0.3473789394,
-0.5177416801,
-0.2238883823,
-0.7050251365,
0.5485443473,
0.717912972,
0.4453785419,
0.3057475388,
-0.2574315369,
0.8500176072,
0.4682306647,
0.1244112477,
0.3645662665,
-0.0264252555,
-0.2907139063,
-0.2955585122,
-1.1233384609,
-0.399135381,
0.9379326701,
0.1379658431,
0.6325743198,
-0.0002310991,
0.8830459714,
0.2323864698,
0.1715405881,
-0.5774713755,
0.7158520222,
-0.2345487624,
-0.6489854455,
-0.4197207689,
-0.4800675809,
-0.7978554964,
0.5712236762,
-0.2798316777,
-0.6791501045,
0.2875441909,
0.4177879691,
-0.5257527232,
0.4520092607,
-0.886385262,
0.7067195773,
0.1635142416,
-0.5596830249,
-0.4678113461,
-0.3912388682,
0.7360168695,
-0.3232625425,
0.2374534756,
-0.0939471275,
-0.0239345878,
0.6812516451,
-0.8752841353,
1.1182633638,
-0.3528069258,
-0.0071271951,
0.5263845921,
0.1653902382,
0.5755234361,
-0.1051105112,
0.0046196077,
-0.0967232808,
-0.171672374,
-0.7005068064,
-0.7573142648,
0.681302011,
-0.5446797013,
-0.8962367773,
-0.2720481753,
-0.5755860806,
-0.3101253211,
0.2075858116,
0.1695049256,
0.2518373132,
0.0952818096,
0.2091906965,
0.8318122029,
0.1538309157,
0.4503569007,
0.5843787789,
-0.0161397699,
-0.0322041623,
1.0174182653,
0.4126485288,
0.5243713856,
-0.2052903324,
0.3663532138,
-0.1621992737,
-0.6663696766,
-0.4027760327,
0.1468291134,
-0.4392046034,
-0.1947120577,
-0.4301460087,
-0.1879851818,
-0.423412174,
-0.0069239452,
-0.6123994589,
-0.4919812679,
-0.4094648659,
-0.021077754,
0.235432446,
0.4154298604,
-0.132615,
0.3776940107,
-0.8223967552,
0.0217534918,
0.380035013,
0.0755160153,
0.2922152877,
-0.7249312401,
-0.5445426702,
0.0798477232,
-0.3067171276,
-0.7238311768,
0.3348899484,
0.4736298919,
0.530351758,
0.8414286971,
0.3414687216,
1.2109003067,
-0.4716555774,
0.7315473557,
0.3430324197,
-0.8413404226,
0.2107873559,
-0.0703739747,
-0.0419052057,
0.7782462239,
0.2995512486,
-0.1878200322,
-0.9739136696,
-0.725135684,
-0.8749284148,
0.5157247782,
0.198203966,
0.2692020535,
0.2054639906,
0.0945083871,
0.4600313008,
0.2082037926,
-0.6473674178,
-0.1812195331,
0.1057541296,
-0.191710785,
-0.0361184962,
-0.3597507477,
0.0980108902,
-0.4839064777,
0.7151266336,
0.0828964263,
-0.2223377079,
-0.1488324106,
-0.302937746,
0.0099165263,
0.3092727959,
0.3671715558,
0.5570778847,
-0.1017991304,
0.4509254098,
0.4532584846,
-0.6217175722,
0.1620656103,
-0.0476474091,
-0.0630985647,
-0.1466659009,
0.4319185913,
0.7501823902,
0.3946277499,
-0.611017108,
0.4988691211,
0.2058998197,
-0.0782070085,
-0.1911729574,
0.4393827915,
-0.0369566493,
0.0556920767,
0.5215549469,
0.2524856031,
-0.0358660556,
-0.4310546219,
0.2537114322,
0.2231488675,
-0.325638473,
-0.1918694824,
0.5795761347,
0.32361871,
0.2531403303,
0.6577994227,
-0.2333019227,
-0.360553503,
0.5185421705,
0.5277113914,
0.5897520185,
-0.3672339022,
-0.1229280457,
0.2310829908,
0.3514464498,
-0.2067626715,
-0.046334859,
-0.0480004139,
-0.8181122541,
-0.6180905104,
-0.6610229015,
0.059903603,
0.2704704404,
-0.5731902719,
0.2256670147,
-0.1103188023,
-0.0891510621,
-0.4627176225,
0.1838552058,
-0.4394600093,
0.0433369242,
-0.0477821156,
0.9177523255,
-1.0485596657,
1.3575571775,
0.2145981193,
-0.420943439,
-0.7921888232,
-0.0923381001,
-0.0113917142,
-0.5725992918,
0.6303427219,
0.0431173258,
0.0536593795,
0.15643695,
-0.3194391131,
-0.4979835451,
0.8801913261,
0.5352346897,
-0.8045787215,
0.013169894,
0.2104620337,
0.4756785333,
-0.2961787879,
0.1365779787,
0.7746042609,
0.4426751137,
0.0614241995,
-0.9949448109,
0.0745509937,
-0.1741641611,
-0.1071093231,
0.1764495671,
-0.4816992879,
1.0117778778,
-0.2047642618,
-0.2525816262,
0.0720189214,
0.8724634647,
0.3261648715,
0.1497725397,
0.9693222046,
0.8605929613,
0.9612487555,
0.0088707088,
0.9165942669,
-0.2179118991,
0.2178948075,
1.2286986113,
-0.0508087501,
0.6536856294,
0.7427415848,
-0.2522774339,
0.4499940574,
0.2968955636,
0.0949366316,
0.4459373653,
0.2186769843,
-0.3813266158,
-0.6073846221,
-0.0398441069,
-0.2590557337,
0.3511176109,
0.3218933046,
-0.0917054713,
-0.0992394686,
0.259480387,
0.0947040617,
0.3579569161,
-0.3384349942,
0.5577794313,
0.520653367,
-0.6478247643,
0.7809966207,
-0.3322175145,
0.755764544,
-0.3903851807,
-0.0002518205,
-0.1432151049,
0.2071813345,
-0.1050919294,
-0.5210846066,
0.1298772246,
-0.0923418999,
-0.2029293478,
-0.125716418,
0.975399375,
-0.9106492996,
-0.3135447204,
0.2962030768,
0.5523549318,
0.3479270637,
0.1217994317,
-0.31425488,
-0.2122125924,
-0.0845939815,
-0.0838877782,
0.5865133405,
0.49809587,
0.178504914,
0.7274622917,
0.4434956312,
0.413122654,
0.4254406989,
-0.1430933326,
1.1207439899,
-0.105381161,
-0.4714058042,
-1.0952811241,
0.6414432526,
-0.1669919938,
-0.122217074,
0.9813178182,
0.5990687609,
0.8379662037,
-0.3345785737,
0.6286203265,
-0.1705144644,
0.170878455,
-0.6816911101,
1.0334368944,
-0.7576005459,
0.3670628369,
-0.1342496276,
-0.6974629164,
0.2090853453,
0.331803143,
-0.2557436526,
0.1258520633,
0.6537905931,
0.6963937283,
-0.2584620714,
-0.2149618268,
0.5434180498,
0.4775731564,
0.0828531757,
0.8530385494,
0.7415910363,
-0.2388775945,
0.7651192546,
-0.2755654752,
-0.3473417163,
-0.2617938817,
-0.8246408701,
-0.9988942146,
-0.5985773802,
-0.2438593209,
-0.3261400461,
-0.2202450037,
0.9215018153,
0.7043268681,
-0.7081922889,
-0.231854856,
-0.0702112317,
0.2551037669,
-0.3371801376,
-0.2275598198,
0.1670568883,
-0.4476796091,
-1.0905292034,
0.5210499167,
-0.0918351337,
0.1209373102,
-0.3051847816,
-0.2126443088,
-0.0506402701,
0.1624097377,
0.2083542347,
0.1939287037,
-0.5608536005,
-0.1152670383,
-0.4779110849,
-0.014726189,
-0.074815698,
0.9708417058,
-0.9234064221,
0.5848629475,
0.5637792349,
0.5699688792,
0.47959885,
-0.2589478493,
0.605841279,
-1.1715248823,
0.5069536567,
0.2573417127,
0.4321313202,
0.0175983123,
-0.1035239249,
0.4027935863,
0.4874589145,
-0.3922163844,
-1.1150943041,
0.1174078584,
-0.8865001798,
-0.5076524019,
0.8303953409,
-0.1485735029,
-0.0691627115,
-0.2376273721,
-0.1214804053,
0.4040564299,
-0.4903938174,
1.0313913822,
0.8004398942,
0.1680814475,
-0.1496019363,
-0.6404078603,
0.674718976,
0.6388214231,
-0.3395821452,
-0.0263167452,
0.3699789941,
0.2360935956,
0.1216522977,
0.8064600825,
0.0935695395,
-0.088371709,
0.2390858084,
-0.0928324759,
-0.3983006179,
-0.6182467341,
-0.1115629375,
0.2507700026,
0.1274092048,
-0.108876206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12123v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12123v1 | Modeling the Q-Diversity in a Min-max Play Game for Robust Optimization | 2023-05-20T07:02:27 | 2023-05-20T07:02:27 | Ting Wu, Rui Zheng, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Models trained with empirical risk minimization (ERM) are revealed to easily
rely on spurious correlations, resulting in poor generalization. Group
distributionally robust optimization (group DRO) can alleviate this problem by
minimizing the worst-case loss over pre-defined groups. While promising, in
practice factors like expensive annotations and privacy preclude the
availability of group labels. More crucially, when taking a closer look at the
failure modes of out-of-distribution generalization, the typical procedure of
reweighting in group DRO loses efficiency. Hinged on the limitations, in this
work, we reformulate the group DRO framework by proposing Q-Diversity.
Characterized by an interactive training mode, Q-Diversity relaxes the group
identification from annotation into direct parameterization. Furthermore, a
novel mixing strategy across groups is presented to diversify the
under-represented groups. In a series of experiments on both synthetic and
real-world text classification tasks, results demonstrate that Q-Diversity can
consistently improve worst-case accuracy under different distributional shifts,
outperforming state-of-the-art alternatives. | [
-0.3395876586,
-0.2794050276,
-0.0517662428,
0.1685103327,
-0.5044444799,
0.3924619257,
-0.0775676146,
-0.3105219603,
-0.0658073723,
0.1128222793,
-0.6488669515,
-0.5282895565,
-0.589171052,
0.1663013995,
-0.0734666735,
1.1590794325,
0.2108503878,
-0.0108813355,
0.0957699642,
-0.6660588384,
-0.0980351567,
-0.5111451745,
-0.4917055964,
0.0361257941,
0.5066196918,
0.3037933409,
1.0266350508,
0.8577201366,
0.3587885499,
0.302944392,
-0.2691559196,
0.2540595531,
-0.9487937093,
0.2595728338,
0.2552992105,
-0.8230319023,
-0.1785000116,
-0.035223864,
0.6826434135,
0.6073599458,
-0.5932712555,
-0.1392499357,
0.0527316406,
0.5277978778,
-0.7657120228,
-0.3996952176,
-0.4903002977,
0.3590723276,
0.1093983054,
-0.0362145156,
-0.1210951433,
-0.4596964419,
0.196880132,
-1.0066901445,
0.3643301427,
0.2575419247,
0.6131408811,
0.3562604189,
-0.4695696831,
-0.103180252,
-0.8980825543,
1.0651108027,
-0.4431990087,
0.3436754942,
0.3251188993,
0.458170712,
-0.235062629,
-0.1865805984,
-0.353358686,
0.3800831735,
0.1327894926,
0.3864426315,
0.0538479686,
0.2151407301,
0.0388086215,
0.6158893704,
-0.339599967,
0.207838729,
-0.2741627991,
-0.0250418428,
0.6693230271,
0.2264914513,
0.4678346217,
0.5034413338,
-0.3763149083,
-0.3126371801,
-0.1945507675,
0.3047388196,
0.5432216525,
0.1141516715,
-0.1239228323,
0.201553151,
-0.1099605113,
0.2580848038,
0.1097713783,
-0.4140933156,
0.2737552822,
-0.4147214592,
-0.3270332515,
-0.5941179395,
0.6480451822,
0.573010087,
-0.1833617687,
-0.219404906,
-0.2593850195,
-0.3739028573,
-0.1407309622,
-0.6702940464,
-0.3875382543,
0.0549628921,
-0.7288956046,
-0.7136164308,
-0.1575602144,
-1.1505246162,
-0.371624738,
0.3093925416,
0.4525098205,
-0.1933746934,
-0.1688822508,
0.1833937913,
-0.6017494202,
-0.110302344,
0.3633804619,
-1.0098619461,
0.2548445463,
0.2752769589,
0.6946162581,
-0.2646290362,
-0.0533216372,
-0.5615041852,
0.1790379733,
-0.2662584186,
0.5224163532,
-0.3329167664,
-0.8255968094,
-0.1183401346,
-0.4794013798,
0.0331145301,
-0.7625165582,
0.5465230346,
-0.4484359026,
0.6198831201,
-0.1770642549,
-0.2982164621,
0.0027962406,
0.2919844091,
-0.7163334489,
0.962303102,
0.4323974848,
-0.8888071775,
1.0050747395,
-0.2614146769,
-0.0692684054,
0.1393937171,
-0.1999131739,
-0.9159191847,
0.2953687012,
0.2602007687,
-0.1776634455,
-0.2063692659,
-0.1146870479,
-0.8813750744,
-0.5493551493,
0.2209957689,
-0.0798152909,
0.7927718163,
0.4201137125,
0.0117441854,
0.2880067527,
-0.6034366488,
0.0645652711,
0.0059261983,
-0.4533321261,
-0.8753637671,
0.1762129515,
-0.138071537,
0.166144684,
-0.2807929218,
0.0497901961,
0.2342025638,
-0.1890083849,
0.4972015023,
0.7602639198,
0.0691472515,
0.8697965145,
-0.590990901,
0.8080146313,
-0.1265702546,
0.6844933629,
0.2582241297,
-0.456795603,
-0.2808128297,
-1.0894988775,
0.357209295,
0.6466025114,
-0.7260125875,
0.4947048724,
-0.0357764661,
-0.1697233915,
-0.2730144858,
0.1943504214,
-0.0338298604,
0.3113991022,
0.1151051894,
-0.2906315327,
-0.2708541751,
-0.745803535,
-0.2676910758,
-0.321511358,
-0.0125413071,
0.3130345345,
-0.0405453593,
-0.5398795605,
0.7481514812,
-0.1797617227,
-0.2432686687,
-0.5454763174,
0.1266852617,
0.105824545,
0.4275471568,
0.592849195,
-0.9417794347,
-0.5619489551,
-0.1654645354,
-0.5499079227,
-0.08569967,
-0.0408531539,
-0.4608412981,
-0.1110139862,
-0.0411656834,
-0.2888782322,
0.3901332915,
0.4926716685,
0.0649371296,
0.1330143809,
-0.1281827986,
0.1534395367,
-0.9964521527,
-0.4839841127,
-0.211463809,
-0.0220336057,
-0.513053298,
0.2085143328,
-0.1475822479,
-0.162303552,
0.0080681872,
0.1743810028,
-0.465852797,
0.2169713378,
-0.1568296254,
-0.1575523317,
-0.0372049585,
0.2981137931,
-0.3341162801,
0.5730270743,
0.7388971448,
-0.7390297055,
-0.0442932732,
0.0948420241,
0.1039347798,
0.4626602232,
-0.4700022638,
-0.1483073682,
-0.4813269675,
0.1730850935,
-0.9146120548,
-0.3622708619,
0.307697773,
-0.1884991378,
0.323659271,
-0.3412672877,
-0.2733344734,
-0.2350586355,
-0.7324826121,
0.9786219597,
0.8508841991,
-0.5540126562,
0.6429263353,
0.4721246958,
0.1817183048,
-0.6909849048,
-0.5229819417,
-0.414996624,
-1.0719885826,
-0.6227753758,
0.1229533553,
-0.2076661587,
-0.3539721072,
-0.3413614035,
-0.3063288927,
-0.3931623697,
0.3237796724,
0.0248221401,
0.0567416362,
0.2548681498,
0.5009060502,
0.3049224615,
0.2899903953,
-0.3090727329,
-0.2590315342,
0.1828271598,
0.2161248475,
-0.0401572399,
-0.2107325494,
0.775862515,
0.1310997605,
-0.0736321881,
0.7480965853,
0.3435249031,
-0.2238490134,
-0.7642711997,
-0.0885543823,
-0.1180372462,
-0.544486165,
0.5579541326,
-0.1952142566,
-1.0843964815,
0.861563623,
-0.0812017024,
0.2879452407,
0.2541370094,
0.201547876,
-0.3226520717,
1.0464967489,
0.9668818712,
-0.0562403798,
0.7865738869,
-0.0581505336,
0.0466387458,
-0.2479425073,
0.0491558053,
-0.4485279918,
-0.4499204159,
-0.8677546978,
-0.4247325659,
0.374789387,
0.5937773585,
-0.2099998295,
-0.1317598522,
-0.5945960283,
0.4924394786,
0.6411188245,
0.233114332,
0.3333206177,
0.2068338543,
0.1092077866,
-0.2738100886,
-0.9726404548,
-0.2363244593,
1.2486424446,
0.4560005069,
0.9978089333,
0.1973514259,
1.434910059,
0.453032583,
0.6522821188,
-0.8096044064,
0.3210454881,
-0.0519216657,
-0.5577348471,
-0.4889722764,
-0.9936625361,
-0.796222508,
0.6350333691,
-0.3412639499,
-0.477068156,
0.6938865185,
0.3595354557,
-0.4749936759,
0.2809207439,
-0.6184744835,
0.6591528654,
-0.0929393321,
-0.1557120383,
0.1520060003,
-0.4414459467,
0.5851883292,
-0.1436628103,
0.7106238604,
0.1603476256,
-0.360517025,
0.5369669199,
-0.4458800256,
0.521830976,
-0.0466012023,
-0.0288671851,
0.4907410443,
0.0133377071,
0.4471175671,
0.3501745164,
-0.0495160334,
-0.0927147567,
-0.170427531,
-0.6304383874,
-0.7247135639,
0.2015929073,
-0.9354181886,
-0.3442073464,
-0.4088049233,
-0.6222339272,
-0.1491858065,
0.0575306378,
0.6638569832,
0.0520098172,
-0.1388790905,
0.0895600244,
0.6509524584,
-0.1672297418,
0.3579037786,
0.0913634822,
-0.0855912194,
-1.0679615736,
0.7660931349,
-0.1118425131,
0.5824776292,
0.2893958092,
0.3055644929,
-0.2239613533,
-0.7957482338,
-0.1437243372,
-0.0099638617,
-0.6831385493,
0.1598840952,
-0.5003494024,
0.3872531056,
-0.0549105108,
0.0493701287,
-0.03481289,
-0.5015940666,
-0.2062621266,
-0.204831183,
-0.1314418167,
0.2882712483,
-0.3622214794,
0.4887543917,
-0.7860392928,
0.1774142534,
0.5730333328,
0.3067084551,
-0.3864769638,
-0.5693515539,
-0.2736010253,
0.01889343,
-0.312577337,
-1.1214641333,
0.294701308,
0.4364648461,
0.8508409858,
0.5867463946,
0.4172630906,
0.3630194366,
-0.0885853842,
0.261007905,
0.3649645448,
-0.593664825,
0.1975184977,
-0.5943832994,
-0.2470944226,
0.8039336801,
0.2055433095,
-0.0994294509,
-0.4253734946,
-0.4452553689,
-1.0171421766,
0.5126395226,
0.347014308,
-0.0032802843,
0.0854245499,
0.235826388,
0.2213001102,
0.3583095372,
-0.9958710074,
-0.2506033778,
-0.3611595333,
-0.3620697558,
0.1488213092,
-0.1599305719,
-0.603980422,
0.1182243749,
0.3580543995,
-0.1627521366,
0.1378054172,
0.1336411387,
0.249173522,
-0.2670750618,
0.2466983646,
0.5162658095,
0.3089872301,
-0.2636177838,
0.0953829587,
0.1323790997,
-0.3652532995,
0.3557067811,
0.2206428796,
-0.3860437274,
-0.1958112866,
0.1718965471,
0.3456726968,
-0.2763070166,
-0.6447325349,
0.2982566059,
-0.1713297963,
-0.335116148,
0.1036330685,
0.3514969349,
-0.3877951801,
0.3983720839,
0.6562573314,
0.0919138715,
0.5685405135,
-0.6262685657,
0.1489672363,
0.6014023423,
-0.1524291188,
-0.0838544294,
0.6592133641,
0.200464949,
-0.2612191439,
0.2453810573,
-0.5195721984,
-0.6458518505,
0.7612401843,
0.2679127157,
0.9846938848,
-0.0743177906,
0.2459580451,
0.1684681177,
0.56409657,
-0.413798213,
0.1912617534,
-0.0788290054,
-0.5658780336,
-0.1097197905,
-0.1383787096,
-0.5162289739,
-0.1306331754,
-0.6459643245,
0.0339604132,
-0.5919591188,
-0.5021452904,
-0.7664535642,
-0.3525052071,
-0.407553792,
0.4028093219,
-0.1913913935,
0.2456019819,
-0.7908133864,
0.4050889015,
0.7276083231,
-0.1374518424,
-0.6211674213,
0.2602223456,
-0.2836305797,
-0.5245057344,
0.4336988926,
0.0061376332,
0.1645408571,
-0.2504442632,
-0.6279294491,
-0.8411197662,
1.0793457031,
-0.0307299253,
-0.3998203278,
0.0755225793,
0.0386257619,
0.5274749994,
-0.3113900721,
0.2172555923,
-0.1805197746,
0.0080446675,
0.0907851234,
-0.6208118796,
-0.0657544732,
-0.117136009,
0.2410910279,
0.1980050504,
-0.9502132535,
0.925568223,
-0.334934175,
-0.4462581873,
-0.0706799328,
0.762163043,
0.4682252705,
0.6150755286,
0.8606875539,
0.6702159047,
0.8642416596,
0.0360699706,
0.8158937693,
0.0669997782,
0.4260528386,
0.8830408454,
-0.1263786852,
0.2525604665,
0.2983765006,
-0.3142231405,
0.0499160141,
0.8419635296,
0.0378310084,
0.8351767063,
0.4348957539,
-0.4508484304,
-0.556448102,
0.2703894675,
-0.4398827851,
-0.0020155045,
0.0738392845,
-0.3229497075,
-0.1324637234,
-0.2345708609,
-0.4995798767,
0.1087671444,
-0.2107907534,
0.587259829,
-0.0404258333,
-0.1600611806,
0.4959250093,
-0.0759314299,
0.9527932405,
-0.4405603707,
0.204968676,
-0.6446324587,
0.1181748062,
-0.0904314145,
-0.1368298978,
0.1249719113,
-0.5645388961,
-0.3014552295,
0.1205240116,
0.5309976339,
-0.4247884452,
-0.2481742501,
0.2317011803,
0.4083429575,
-0.1464157104,
0.1327384263,
-0.4630108476,
0.0063650426,
0.0614329353,
0.0027857104,
0.6505565643,
0.8527156115,
-0.2532247901,
0.8667323589,
0.4082925022,
-0.2370658964,
0.3448417187,
-0.1224109232,
0.8986184597,
-0.5134822726,
-0.831528604,
-0.6570862532,
0.4561611116,
-0.2406827062,
-0.5245578289,
0.5620455742,
0.4939447939,
0.6042788029,
-0.0058825314,
0.9292523861,
0.3442052603,
0.441642195,
0.0034807974,
0.7050114274,
-0.8700364232,
0.2849961817,
-0.2085733712,
-0.8975015283,
-0.425865978,
0.4249257147,
0.1225856245,
0.2791029215,
0.2880088389,
0.3973474801,
-0.0755107626,
-0.0606193617,
0.3684411645,
-0.3173811436,
0.3768977821,
0.5683273673,
0.893784225,
-0.3551881909,
1.0316872597,
-0.358296901,
-0.6797057986,
-0.2296489924,
-0.7043737769,
-1.1690813303,
0.0974171981,
-0.4867628217,
-0.3272780776,
0.1642136425,
0.7174040675,
0.7265850306,
-0.592036128,
-0.0806534365,
-0.1734559089,
0.3380802274,
-0.3347579241,
-0.2200191915,
-0.0385620892,
-0.3363898695,
-0.6904060245,
0.1828686744,
0.1647620201,
0.4523211718,
0.1235304251,
-0.2150350362,
0.4573527277,
0.185010612,
0.2282952666,
0.4695278108,
-0.2092424631,
0.0244986508,
0.0462611243,
-0.2104815394,
-0.1060996801,
0.5587260723,
-0.1516139954,
0.3890790343,
0.61397928,
0.754064858,
0.0737651736,
0.4326232672,
0.6669338942,
-0.3977497816,
0.1866133064,
0.5078210235,
0.0908112377,
-0.0289908368,
-0.3322044611,
0.4820092916,
0.624124527,
-0.6876642108,
-1.0638444424,
0.4262909889,
-0.8835663795,
0.0255233198,
0.9686148167,
-0.2171552628,
0.0291404892,
-0.169069767,
-0.1327131093,
0.1717887074,
-0.6321977973,
1.2447818518,
0.5990810394,
-0.0343200192,
-0.3935952783,
-0.1226657853,
0.8011221886,
0.700758934,
-0.7474176288,
-0.3462215066,
0.5241829157,
0.2232216597,
-0.1638724208,
0.6360105872,
0.056799639,
0.169961676,
0.0142864091,
-0.0231491923,
-0.0156422555,
-0.0826065466,
-0.3012835681,
0.3267205656,
0.1359730214,
-0.4696584046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12107v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12107v2 | EE-TTS: Emphatic Expressive TTS with Linguistic Information | 2023-05-20T05:58:56 | 2024-04-14T12:33:07 | Yi Zhong, Chen Zhang, Xule Liu, Chenxi Sun, Weishan Deng, Haifeng Hu, Zhongqian Sun | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | While Current TTS systems perform well in synthesizing high-quality speech,
producing highly expressive speech remains a challenge. Emphasis, as a critical
factor in determining the expressiveness of speech, has attracted more
attention nowadays. Previous works usually enhance the emphasis by adding
intermediate features, but they can not guarantee the overall expressiveness of
the speech. To resolve this matter, we propose Emphatic Expressive TTS
(EE-TTS), which leverages multi-level linguistic information from syntax and
semantics. EE-TTS contains an emphasis predictor that can identify appropriate
emphasis positions from text and a conditioned acoustic model to synthesize
expressive speech with emphasis and linguistic information. Experimental
results indicate that EE-TTS outperforms baseline with MOS improvements of 0.49
and 0.67 in expressiveness and naturalness. EE-TTS also shows strong
generalization across different datasets according to AB test results. | [
-0.3802787662,
-1.1405870914,
0.5284903646,
0.5789293647,
-0.1217250526,
0.2989187539,
-0.5619292855,
-0.6410916448,
0.8041739464,
-0.0623098277,
-0.2978228629,
-0.5086705089,
-0.6839042902,
0.3624419272,
-0.5680932403,
0.755869925,
0.357804209,
-0.2070701867,
0.6663288474,
0.0876747295,
-0.2579937875,
-0.4046797454,
-0.7406478524,
-0.094470121,
0.6488402486,
0.4068197906,
0.4804808497,
0.5885389447,
0.1381936371,
0.3753405809,
-0.2435902506,
-0.1162292957,
-0.3703979254,
0.5820887089,
-0.0091704978,
-0.4177053571,
-0.5156935453,
-0.48247841,
0.604051888,
0.6597249508,
-0.1773944348,
0.0879388079,
0.2550995648,
0.2736996412,
-0.7342863083,
0.0797274187,
-0.6228387952,
0.0030561469,
-0.3240717947,
-0.3216813505,
-0.6230418682,
-0.3701618612,
0.6752279997,
-0.8665184379,
-0.2038749307,
-0.0320748016,
0.7210664749,
0.1806652248,
-0.4212571979,
0.1174420118,
-0.8908749819,
0.9164383411,
-0.4568243921,
0.7671434879,
0.0845321119,
0.1872280687,
0.2488252968,
-0.7713503242,
-0.3258070052,
-0.2735539973,
0.047513321,
0.3405539095,
-0.0053805318,
0.3486149907,
0.1775369495,
0.1875888258,
-0.2712961137,
0.0625836775,
0.0788259059,
-0.0999433771,
0.294893831,
-0.0473110788,
0.3319420218,
-0.0642663613,
-0.34334144,
0.0695359632,
-0.4808243513,
-0.0025867992,
-0.0826104805,
0.6714941263,
-0.1487704217,
0.6920546293,
-0.3041419387,
0.4562689066,
0.3977486789,
-0.154001534,
0.4485896826,
0.0683243573,
-0.33877334,
0.1266657412,
0.4894009531,
0.3057509959,
0.170851022,
-0.2348785251,
-0.3066714108,
0.0503791831,
0.0059599578,
-0.6495156884,
0.4806096852,
0.371629715,
-0.3468528092,
-0.1925082207,
0.0636213347,
-0.9841729999,
-0.1766131222,
-0.7287185788,
0.23512429,
-0.6552504301,
-0.439878732,
-0.2749076188,
-0.4036514163,
0.3685270548,
0.4866035283,
-1.0600321293,
0.2159546912,
0.5472774506,
0.6621828675,
-0.1752452701,
-0.205535084,
-0.3602736592,
0.6046082377,
-0.1925553381,
0.6493587494,
-0.7742754817,
-0.2044342607,
0.2121981978,
-0.1332980543,
-0.0326147676,
-0.2950209379,
0.9182169437,
0.0328124389,
-0.037395943,
-0.0668544322,
-0.6894814372,
0.1059302166,
-0.1018136293,
-0.6075936556,
1.1973958015,
0.0498273745,
-0.5110234022,
0.4384611249,
-0.67410326,
-0.5357682109,
0.1776719838,
-0.2336120456,
-0.0496683531,
0.4776881635,
0.1596311033,
0.2144976258,
-0.227472052,
0.2487235367,
-0.2878599763,
-0.2804075181,
0.254665643,
-0.2292740792,
0.2076488584,
0.3501266837,
-0.6719044447,
-0.0747816712,
-0.9041177034,
0.4674868584,
-0.0711003989,
-0.2375551462,
-0.3477028608,
-0.1596212536,
0.3342712224,
-0.0970739722,
0.2137534618,
-0.7106389999,
-0.22120215,
-0.5793496966,
0.3346810043,
0.6133234501,
-0.2335544825,
0.416965872,
-0.1892894506,
0.5043697357,
-0.4125120342,
-0.0859736055,
-0.2459121794,
-0.7644889355,
-0.8027796745,
-0.4567269087,
0.476667881,
0.7835147381,
-0.5348138213,
0.7669425011,
-0.3417123258,
-0.4672691524,
-0.5586049557,
-0.5933314562,
0.6033778787,
0.3857501149,
0.2820383012,
-0.0318201333,
-0.7763867378,
-1.0315443277,
-0.7000972033,
-0.0471487194,
-0.2961265743,
-0.0135413222,
-0.1339424551,
0.2959066033,
0.915348947,
-0.2912024558,
-0.1329462826,
-0.2780607939,
0.5054303408,
-0.2014491707,
0.4056316018,
0.5553165674,
-0.6096303463,
-0.5416897535,
0.0759738237,
-0.3890405893,
-0.5281857252,
0.2539380193,
-0.0097948145,
0.1140126958,
0.3951843083,
-0.5349285007,
0.4182508588,
0.2130807042,
-0.3936323225,
0.1545895189,
0.1381901205,
0.4707562923,
-0.8704877496,
0.0747820735,
0.2029986382,
-0.1704904288,
-0.8915053606,
-0.0680256337,
-0.1491055191,
-0.2031155676,
-0.4814014435,
0.4383404255,
-0.3122168779,
0.0537121929,
-0.0546953455,
0.3248406053,
0.2013693601,
0.6229047179,
0.1262435019,
0.4136427343,
0.5929492712,
-0.5071629286,
0.1230897829,
0.1826139688,
0.1122401655,
0.9609865546,
-0.6608333588,
0.1650396883,
-0.1138395965,
0.0691999272,
-1.0008548498,
-0.2751505375,
-0.0971228704,
-0.5520632267,
0.7241697907,
-0.1728546023,
-0.1369018704,
-0.1411932409,
-0.3006606698,
0.1506560892,
0.5182255507,
-0.2727248371,
1.0191994905,
0.6304939389,
-0.7553265095,
-0.4853425026,
-1.0344679356,
0.1056953743,
-0.3591979742,
-0.6457520127,
0.7065038085,
0.2874804437,
-0.1332235336,
-0.0731792375,
0.0993557721,
-0.2075712681,
-0.0465264171,
-0.0427468531,
-0.0396226309,
-0.2281134874,
0.326196909,
0.2535702586,
-0.0550766475,
-0.1415346861,
-0.304874897,
0.3907938302,
-0.2272178978,
-0.2159526199,
-0.8883966208,
0.6210154891,
0.7484804988,
0.0269112438,
0.3824002743,
0.4282874465,
-0.5602463484,
-0.0001131537,
-0.6871141195,
-0.2094417512,
-0.4098997712,
0.5408495069,
-0.7086632848,
-0.7168515921,
0.4117298722,
-0.1607420743,
-0.0904078558,
0.6441035271,
0.4898589253,
-0.0561192185,
1.3395148516,
0.5804041028,
0.3177857101,
0.9490013719,
0.1493754387,
-0.0664573163,
-0.8166807294,
-0.2405920178,
-0.8598686457,
-0.5002679229,
-0.7642310858,
0.170902133,
0.2581068277,
-0.4448589981,
-0.2409359813,
0.2004942,
-0.6599757671,
0.2152707577,
0.4369196296,
0.1988780946,
0.0692175403,
0.0728856474,
-0.1651903391,
-0.3149620891,
-0.1928325146,
-0.6843132973,
1.1823294163,
0.534476757,
0.8074953556,
0.1843921244,
0.5592028499,
-0.025283115,
0.172090292,
-0.8024948239,
0.4364171922,
-0.3296909332,
-0.3687689304,
-0.5432465076,
-0.222550109,
-0.9258170128,
0.1617511362,
-0.288689971,
-1.0352803469,
0.2337163389,
0.2186166942,
-0.4378126264,
-0.0606067553,
-1.1561220884,
0.433780551,
-0.1646405309,
-0.4507565796,
-0.2160088867,
-0.7489571571,
-0.1786271036,
0.0352522694,
0.2028409392,
-0.1705689877,
-0.4215125144,
0.6219759583,
-0.2995840013,
0.8069725633,
-0.2895665169,
-0.2667064667,
0.1328955442,
-0.0875698999,
0.487305373,
-0.1595718116,
-0.3138555586,
-0.2082080692,
-0.3032156527,
-0.208168909,
-0.8245536685,
0.5211580992,
-0.4146744907,
-0.6333963871,
0.0583988354,
-0.151235491,
-0.4810674787,
0.2102996409,
0.4222509563,
0.7483972907,
-0.459959656,
0.2516779304,
0.6289540529,
-0.1421251595,
0.2829421461,
0.2848682106,
-0.2904846966,
-0.6533021927,
0.7208298445,
0.165415138,
0.5335822701,
0.720041573,
0.2996667027,
-0.5539324284,
-0.2493098229,
-0.4924820662,
0.0605304167,
-0.5422216654,
0.0019163216,
-0.6952157021,
-0.1396988481,
-0.4953527451,
-0.2196307629,
-0.4117533565,
-1.1957771778,
0.0290094502,
-0.2061723024,
0.4512808621,
0.7865415215,
0.0724022314,
0.2003130913,
-0.7248419523,
0.562425375,
0.2460900694,
0.4235164821,
-0.2554295361,
-0.7553815246,
-0.0940253884,
0.0636723191,
-0.5756343007,
-1.0209202766,
0.3487362862,
0.5186244249,
0.4877138138,
0.3386720419,
-0.2299185693,
0.4224726558,
-0.4675093889,
0.7723531723,
0.2907955348,
-1.3721625805,
0.8148218989,
-0.3892197311,
0.2316413522,
0.4701009691,
0.0413988978,
-0.3265605569,
-1.1327339411,
-0.8201252818,
-1.1031144857,
0.6785738468,
0.4655979574,
-0.1053956673,
0.0547847338,
0.1309830099,
0.0262781028,
0.3004143536,
-0.5863331556,
-0.4176415503,
-0.2200367749,
-0.5942884684,
0.3851879835,
-0.1848765016,
-0.1517444998,
-0.1721499264,
0.6514117122,
-0.0724040419,
0.5514860749,
0.4696293473,
0.0746120885,
-0.1181427911,
0.8266494274,
0.3935717642,
0.4472782612,
-0.1627039015,
0.2305817604,
0.2277077287,
-0.5167460442,
0.2294823378,
0.3287126422,
-0.3116068244,
0.2940580547,
-0.0763739571,
0.8964130878,
0.2737247348,
-0.4914656281,
0.5242637396,
0.0510138869,
0.1664044559,
-0.1869704574,
-0.3164587915,
0.0015699757,
-0.0716434047,
0.4588126838,
0.0506666042,
0.463080883,
-0.4878151715,
0.0760108232,
0.1857904494,
-0.3584173024,
-0.4872746468,
0.6437785625,
0.7948625088,
-0.1715851277,
0.072182633,
-0.0864382759,
-0.6121131778,
0.7318601012,
0.6606192589,
1.3259414434,
-0.7166203856,
-0.1464629471,
0.2565296292,
0.2236446291,
0.2178403884,
0.8712788224,
0.2351828516,
-0.4995557666,
-0.5292596817,
-0.3164097071,
-0.633631587,
-0.2424750179,
-0.6648852825,
0.7948887944,
-0.2894030809,
-0.664744556,
0.0949008763,
-0.604460597,
-0.5862149596,
0.5386339426,
0.393822968,
0.6286340952,
-0.71339643,
0.4662255645,
0.7759119868,
-0.2868317664,
-0.9039790034,
0.0975481346,
-0.0634832457,
-0.5821247101,
0.6454688907,
0.4576315284,
-0.3337473869,
0.370734483,
-0.2600235343,
-1.0173574686,
0.741612494,
0.724085927,
-0.5911778808,
0.0254918281,
0.3023429215,
0.6194564104,
-0.4416846633,
0.8667652607,
0.6499146819,
0.7212046981,
-0.0854307711,
-1.221491456,
0.0897872448,
-0.3394298851,
0.0230589565,
0.3240126371,
-0.6463088393,
0.5918760896,
-0.0236167908,
-0.4646567404,
0.1529184282,
0.6626929045,
0.2336957604,
0.1945047975,
0.6624822021,
0.862447381,
0.8499919772,
-0.5353293419,
0.9480712414,
-0.5079415441,
0.0958269909,
0.7812272906,
-0.226983428,
0.8348166347,
0.3769958913,
-0.1498826146,
0.5423528552,
0.3298569024,
0.4746987522,
0.3857020438,
0.1624482572,
-0.3234370947,
0.0597843118,
-0.5692760944,
-0.5213534236,
0.4788273871,
0.8214549422,
-0.3799893856,
0.2118043154,
0.1600220054,
-0.2331718057,
-0.0618954971,
-0.202992782,
0.7230759263,
0.0619854666,
-0.733589232,
0.5562975407,
-0.2496825904,
0.7011730671,
-0.5260951519,
-0.0685704052,
0.2375765145,
-0.1850447655,
-0.3260954022,
-0.8234218359,
0.2519834936,
0.008011613,
-0.0003296155,
-0.4251627326,
0.6662370563,
-0.4833936393,
-0.1984318346,
0.4659270346,
0.5553383827,
-0.0711144209,
0.0722514912,
-0.3252131939,
0.0121057443,
-0.2274460196,
-0.5013769269,
-0.1064114571,
1.0390087366,
0.3244378865,
0.5179342628,
0.2639669478,
0.2850475311,
0.1999851167,
0.5968247652,
0.6075904369,
-0.8394114971,
-0.8518670201,
-0.5106082559,
0.6220806241,
-0.2209936827,
-0.4681366086,
0.3605959415,
0.4582705498,
0.4483076334,
-0.0026321134,
1.1190685034,
-0.3183641732,
1.1336203814,
-0.6296278238,
0.189640522,
-0.4133567512,
0.0784002841,
-0.605158329,
-0.9266678095,
-0.1794302464,
0.3208179176,
0.0501359254,
0.2346479148,
1.0872219801,
0.5008076429,
0.2283237875,
0.4994953573,
0.3508999944,
0.3782154024,
-0.0032627441,
0.3845907152,
1.2870435715,
-0.1887243539,
0.4814993441,
-0.2933585942,
-0.5538980961,
-0.1478532702,
-0.9575217962,
-0.2620116472,
-0.5041699409,
-0.3165969551,
-0.0989741087,
-0.0646291375,
1.1716134548,
0.628223598,
-0.9299308062,
-0.052317407,
-0.1066266894,
-0.1568797678,
-0.20696868,
-0.3137458861,
0.2139193118,
-0.4670479596,
-1.2770496607,
0.4613930881,
0.4342072606,
0.3101677299,
0.263579905,
0.2973498106,
0.1773405075,
0.1679435074,
0.6309736371,
0.1949187368,
-0.9666370749,
-0.5017727017,
0.1370245069,
-0.1802412868,
0.1673275679,
0.9380076528,
-0.6216369271,
0.3972152472,
0.4203629494,
0.7166073918,
0.2487734407,
-0.0690430254,
0.9813039303,
-0.9178853035,
0.365149051,
0.3703653812,
0.6957086325,
0.2875889242,
-0.3744398355,
0.4461282194,
0.038370382,
-0.4844360054,
-0.4890348315,
0.1988068819,
-1.1554253101,
0.1103447527,
1.2219946384,
-0.0516541973,
-0.0463051125,
-0.2732093334,
-0.4411239922,
0.4757751226,
-0.9537706971,
0.5469340086,
0.6567690969,
-0.2569532692,
0.1183605418,
-0.265761584,
0.4799087644,
0.9022732377,
-0.8361909389,
-0.0261935052,
0.3506523073,
-0.25962767,
0.3026627004,
0.4595898092,
-0.1403720826,
0.1636025906,
-0.1953829676,
0.139222607,
0.6034370065,
-0.3636179268,
-0.2486209571,
0.3528986573,
0.2249649912,
-0.146161586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12096v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12096v1 | Can NLP Models Correctly Reason Over Contexts that Break the Common Assumptions? | 2023-05-20T05:20:37 | 2023-05-20T05:20:37 | Neeraj Varshney, Mihir Parmar, Nisarg Patel, Divij Handa, Sayantan Sarkar, Man Luo, Chitta Baral | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-training on large corpora of text enables the language models to acquire
a vast amount of factual and commonsense knowledge which allows them to achieve
remarkable performance on a variety of language understanding tasks. They
typically acquire this knowledge by learning from the pre-training text and
capturing certain patterns from it. However, real-world settings often present
scenarios that do not abide by these patterns i.e. scenarios that break the
common assumptions. Can state-of-the-art NLP models correctly reason over the
contexts of such scenarios?
Addressing the above question, in this paper, we investigate the ability of
models to correctly reason over contexts that break the common assumptions. To
this end, we first systematically create evaluation data in which each data
instance consists of (a) a common assumption, (b) a context that follows the
assumption, (c) a context that breaks the assumption, and (d) questions based
on the contexts. Then, through evaluations on multiple models including GPT-3
and Flan T5, we show that while doing fairly well on contexts that follow the
common assumptions, the models struggle to correctly reason over contexts that
break those assumptions. Specifically, the performance gap is as high as 20%
absolute points. Furthermore, we thoroughly analyze these results revealing
several interesting findings. We believe our work and findings will encourage
and facilitate further research in developing more robust models that can also
reliably reason over contexts that break the common assumptions. Data is
available at \url{https://github.com/nrjvarshney/break_the_common_assumptions}. | [
-0.39179793,
-0.8957442641,
0.9396719933,
0.3511371613,
-0.1883585751,
-0.5092980862,
-0.2622035146,
-0.6047382951,
-0.5090059042,
0.3973301351,
-0.4545131922,
-0.3754449189,
-0.4393381178,
0.2801482379,
-0.3907161951,
0.7727966309,
-0.1111884117,
-0.0776648074,
-0.3453129232,
-0.2577129602,
-0.7808633447,
-0.8233585358,
-0.3471235037,
-0.3279998899,
0.336335063,
0.2050927579,
0.6033036709,
0.3279964924,
0.1082529649,
0.2434628606,
-0.2357224375,
0.236230284,
-0.3562385142,
0.1807989776,
-0.5688890219,
-0.3550405502,
-0.3223125041,
0.1574786901,
0.3951669335,
0.6487632394,
-0.2659050226,
-0.2543151677,
0.1062242389,
0.3540105522,
-0.5172951818,
0.0042118668,
-0.9808890224,
-0.0185060054,
0.1089436039,
-0.2462771237,
-0.7528946996,
0.0042417031,
0.4354330599,
-0.6791968942,
0.3611321151,
0.030534694,
1.1484768391,
0.2503016889,
-0.5335249901,
-0.4505932927,
-0.9333081841,
0.9128136039,
-0.8013666272,
0.2466022372,
0.300360173,
0.3150801659,
0.0021962298,
-0.829742074,
-0.62236619,
0.0087705143,
-0.2876989245,
-0.0194066539,
-0.2973438203,
-0.1041398942,
0.5753824115,
0.2311291546,
-0.4664168358,
-0.0523894727,
-0.3595630229,
0.2294487804,
0.3213140368,
-0.113971889,
0.4758758545,
-0.2274343073,
-0.5790387392,
0.0717343092,
-0.7244186997,
0.0152163059,
-0.0703836158,
0.2788955569,
-0.146376133,
0.254884243,
-0.0623133183,
1.0147612095,
-0.2192036211,
0.1920608133,
-0.0669787973,
-0.4156311154,
-0.5602119565,
-0.1260746121,
0.4494511187,
0.3948391974,
0.5796919465,
-0.3699061871,
-0.3118844032,
0.2344565839,
0.5224785805,
-0.5327398181,
0.0699311867,
0.4638220668,
-0.2869332731,
-0.2474315315,
-0.1855050325,
-0.5883245468,
-0.0691337585,
-0.7724195123,
0.4680998623,
-0.5640564561,
-0.375959605,
0.475382477,
-0.0133617967,
0.1970045269,
0.4572851062,
-0.7572849393,
0.4347936213,
0.851179719,
0.9502915144,
-0.0195893664,
-0.348582536,
-0.3160038292,
-0.1272231638,
-0.2834540308,
0.7125679255,
-0.6154512167,
-0.0974863097,
-0.0401810035,
-0.1712360233,
-0.5419293046,
-0.5601156354,
0.7091069818,
-0.4796948731,
0.2355156094,
-0.4684439301,
-0.7017785311,
-0.2523766756,
0.5610906482,
-0.6827946305,
0.4753136933,
-0.2407858372,
-0.8838102221,
0.8148760796,
-0.6493248343,
-0.3671996593,
-0.2646386325,
-0.2870375812,
-0.0568997227,
0.2044146359,
0.5761631131,
0.4886040986,
-0.3959343433,
0.8601379991,
-0.4105651677,
-0.3336968422,
0.349154532,
-0.5431510806,
0.9342213273,
0.2717651129,
-0.4801387787,
-0.0022451619,
-0.738777101,
0.0752759203,
0.1089287922,
-0.0414837226,
-0.3697708249,
0.0961451605,
0.1745755225,
0.6202048063,
-0.2739340663,
-0.252915591,
0.1776768118,
-0.315091759,
0.6613286734,
0.5664665699,
-0.1326297522,
0.2672156096,
-0.2318752855,
0.5003407001,
0.0791690126,
-0.1151596904,
-0.0686079338,
-0.3378819227,
-0.3859162331,
-0.1128330529,
0.3342798352,
0.362391293,
-0.5479596257,
0.3019290268,
-0.1648381948,
-0.2930930853,
-0.1724278033,
-0.1226521507,
0.186836198,
0.9254742861,
0.6718762517,
0.2046055943,
-0.6909546852,
-0.6351369023,
-0.5394568443,
0.0194807835,
-0.1043823957,
0.2895251215,
0.7619200349,
-0.1676283479,
1.3671267033,
-0.1249538139,
0.1973829716,
-0.5498387814,
0.3306596875,
0.4259242117,
0.5312559605,
0.5867730975,
-1.2603561878,
-0.1201553121,
-0.2740194201,
-0.9023954272,
-0.0677807406,
-0.4703142345,
0.0676626936,
0.2717250884,
0.4167051613,
-0.7816570997,
0.566637218,
0.5792822838,
-0.5328096747,
0.7261236906,
-0.1028743908,
-0.0448750816,
-0.8919951916,
0.2796064913,
0.1877884865,
-0.2703935802,
-0.6822510362,
0.0571393035,
-0.2754962742,
0.0499210693,
-0.307156384,
0.5102491379,
-0.1665884256,
-0.0867771134,
-0.0365653448,
0.0910344794,
0.3254791796,
0.2753620744,
0.4723874331,
0.3894855082,
0.7136208415,
-0.7242620587,
-0.107765846,
0.0581109077,
-0.6565877199,
0.4155281484,
-1.0896135569,
-0.0433876812,
-0.0780577883,
0.5525724888,
-0.6712392569,
-0.3154808283,
0.22324799,
-0.1905069798,
-0.1126599684,
-0.2874670327,
-0.4307941496,
0.1236405373,
0.4906742871,
0.4385445714,
0.225942418,
-0.8639395833,
0.5666083694,
0.0500672646,
0.1019765362,
-0.7979917526,
-0.7612320781,
0.0795283765,
-0.513394475,
-0.9477000833,
0.4196285605,
0.1739519387,
-0.6207748055,
0.0375819691,
-0.3165821731,
-0.3560546935,
0.261587441,
0.202092886,
0.2192659825,
-0.274954915,
0.1251949668,
-0.3063479662,
0.0927329063,
-0.0098698949,
-0.3215807974,
0.5561426878,
-0.4687632024,
-0.1966669559,
-0.1414748728,
0.2251243144,
0.5633559227,
-0.1747387648,
1.0618536472,
0.422360152,
-0.666285634,
-0.3266836107,
-0.4579712152,
-0.1078937352,
-0.3877343833,
0.120754756,
-0.4486383796,
-0.7623425126,
0.5162044764,
0.0293626226,
0.2266365141,
0.4649876058,
0.3424265981,
-0.0837691799,
0.9058902264,
0.4535155594,
0.3018854558,
-0.1988400072,
-0.1358807236,
0.3956023455,
-0.4444227219,
0.1929836571,
-0.3952314258,
-0.1010388955,
-0.4676592648,
-0.3838146329,
0.0527041703,
0.515696466,
-0.0320047326,
0.0728706867,
-0.2561676204,
0.5937636495,
0.1536211818,
-0.1801995635,
0.3066491783,
-0.231022507,
-0.2515659332,
0.0763729289,
-0.8525964618,
-0.8714174032,
0.8684744835,
0.3687506914,
0.2494409382,
-0.0013016717,
0.6269550323,
0.1300731301,
0.4702211022,
-0.4906262755,
0.3027626872,
0.0891336128,
-1.0248702765,
-0.2667693496,
-0.4970142245,
-0.8866779804,
0.5372461081,
-0.1651301533,
-0.8780255318,
0.3605901301,
0.2994625568,
-0.2796359956,
0.3050280213,
-0.6928992271,
1.3389612436,
-0.1151022464,
-0.2100304067,
-0.0291804541,
-0.6770118475,
0.7381542921,
-0.007095404,
0.3681361377,
0.0055747707,
0.4871210158,
0.6108396053,
-0.5401828885,
0.7914717793,
-0.2462468296,
-0.0566597097,
0.4113736451,
-0.1662470102,
0.3400788307,
0.1697179973,
-0.0602466278,
0.1618332565,
0.1822879612,
-0.3670589924,
-0.8039947152,
0.2520832717,
-0.4484788775,
-0.3096227348,
-0.455639571,
-0.3873902261,
-0.2987751365,
0.0086948937,
0.6036425233,
0.6504595876,
-0.2673794031,
0.2863527834,
0.5087858438,
-0.2189486772,
0.2245047539,
0.2906813622,
-0.2509618998,
0.0721385032,
0.5044063926,
0.0745624974,
0.2448743433,
-0.0137147866,
0.3043875098,
-0.3806814849,
-0.4472749829,
-0.2292372733,
0.0205119438,
-0.8505618572,
0.151988402,
-0.6022728682,
0.0528576449,
-0.3434864879,
-0.3476140201,
-0.1887260973,
-0.2517320216,
0.0106989229,
-0.1117350608,
-0.1764367521,
0.599057734,
-0.1457894593,
0.2222273052,
-0.8570494056,
0.3442083597,
0.274222225,
0.1344034225,
0.1524233669,
-0.4435546696,
-0.04010709,
0.0903243721,
-0.1050746292,
-0.8321589231,
0.418969214,
0.0435310118,
0.5470042229,
0.2838837206,
0.0518893152,
0.6424844265,
-0.5309824944,
0.7219836712,
0.0279480387,
-1.1569163799,
0.5164114237,
-0.52386415,
0.1875661612,
0.5349313617,
0.5541482568,
-0.7622663975,
-0.3772673011,
-0.9807139635,
-0.9428921342,
0.6353146434,
0.3615634143,
-0.2196175456,
-0.0659104735,
0.3717653155,
0.1361090541,
-0.0402739942,
-1.1436042786,
0.0753397048,
-0.1875629127,
0.042643968,
-0.1020938605,
-0.1479530334,
-0.3083774447,
-0.0921695679,
0.3579454124,
-0.0358091667,
0.0746080726,
0.2609733641,
-0.4441524744,
0.2618373334,
0.6089858413,
0.9339087605,
1.3726913929,
-0.3258954883,
0.2018623203,
0.1242483035,
-0.0183385499,
0.0480799042,
0.1512022018,
-0.2040622979,
0.172022,
0.6930835843,
0.7143165469,
0.266505897,
-0.662859261,
0.4088637531,
-0.4098852575,
-0.1883446723,
-0.1722727567,
0.0249806345,
0.1198519021,
0.1253174096,
0.3415829837,
0.4692737162,
-0.068214938,
-0.7206707597,
0.4955204725,
0.1200938299,
-0.1042716801,
-0.3341472149,
0.4893431067,
0.0960824117,
0.0937150866,
0.466452986,
-0.1224353835,
-0.6875411868,
0.6753944159,
0.702968955,
0.5771760345,
0.049153775,
0.1472725272,
0.3687314391,
0.3940187097,
-0.6009809971,
-0.007462956,
-0.1751226038,
-1.2808097601,
-0.7589312792,
-0.5879611373,
-0.4947161376,
0.5016118288,
-0.7300226092,
0.1786724031,
-0.4541381598,
0.0722419843,
-0.0714121833,
-0.4398084879,
-0.8926593065,
0.7614398003,
0.228759855,
0.862503469,
-1.0274139643,
0.6236010194,
0.4946107864,
-0.4384594262,
-0.8042511344,
0.2591665685,
0.0497531667,
-0.4254915118,
0.8368310928,
0.6009922028,
-0.0394148678,
-0.5743787289,
-0.7614430189,
-0.6972023845,
0.7543970346,
0.2714581192,
-0.6889194846,
-0.1774322093,
0.0075852587,
0.5311532021,
-0.6260014772,
0.139696002,
0.7770837545,
0.5441271067,
0.0572562367,
-0.8096742034,
0.0754134879,
-0.1766503304,
-0.3846397698,
-0.335228622,
-0.1261525005,
0.8710156083,
-0.1314773262,
-0.3273315728,
-0.2320387959,
0.5374134183,
0.7150300741,
0.7027993798,
0.8301551342,
0.7121093273,
0.8534990549,
-0.0961950198,
1.0963352919,
-0.1082492992,
0.3950322866,
1.4205164909,
-0.3794468641,
0.6821300387,
0.282518357,
0.0156416856,
0.4395048022,
0.6948642135,
0.1995581239,
0.2633173168,
0.0440891907,
0.0614469424,
-0.4976657927,
0.2334593832,
-0.3228355944,
0.6428816319,
0.4223648012,
-0.2259298861,
-0.3063846529,
-0.2905846834,
0.1304196119,
0.1450514346,
-0.0765359029,
0.2365788221,
0.1738217622,
-1.0180889368,
0.7285100222,
0.069118768,
0.6208803654,
-0.3571895659,
-0.0617615655,
0.1315193623,
-0.0232089609,
-0.2210705876,
-0.4905506074,
0.6355132461,
0.3053717017,
-0.0590011291,
-0.461304158,
0.9417023063,
-0.2303110957,
-0.269405514,
0.0870308131,
0.5241317153,
0.0601132996,
-0.1289942563,
-0.5715045929,
0.0533291623,
0.00768334,
-0.2420866191,
0.1086401492,
0.6177976727,
0.242183283,
0.4018670619,
0.533835113,
0.127178967,
-0.0867671892,
0.0453710221,
0.4271792471,
-0.6813709736,
-0.5424889326,
-0.9308220148,
0.8060171604,
-0.3065344095,
-0.5434868336,
0.4583439827,
0.1828172207,
0.7733593583,
0.1930784285,
0.8757392168,
-0.1194152832,
0.4863798916,
-0.8427733779,
0.4723411202,
-0.5906741023,
0.3652846813,
-0.4062720835,
-1.0001609325,
-0.3554121852,
0.8820092082,
-0.6693353653,
0.0650518015,
0.5885733962,
0.2300344557,
-0.2292144001,
0.4037522972,
0.3213588893,
0.3000769317,
0.5646945238,
0.4228073955,
1.013074398,
-0.1700570732,
0.3156985641,
0.040407408,
0.0419608206,
-0.1301957965,
-1.0725461245,
-0.6585964561,
-0.5161376595,
-0.2488761544,
-0.3052931726,
-0.0381584316,
0.6916593313,
0.5718203783,
-0.592412591,
0.0948945433,
-0.6133993268,
0.1773894876,
-0.2428808212,
-0.2739275992,
0.1798013449,
-0.7398848534,
-0.5440323949,
0.5331614017,
0.1630795747,
-0.1250139922,
0.0389770381,
-0.0213801935,
-0.3707752824,
0.2475993335,
0.4523236454,
0.2863854766,
-0.8261444569,
-0.3843458891,
-0.2299712747,
-0.0800171196,
0.0618984327,
0.8665626645,
-0.8273413777,
0.2665239871,
0.4191896617,
0.552783072,
0.3921082318,
0.2639326453,
0.9513241053,
-0.7274546623,
0.0217344053,
0.3902986646,
0.6101151705,
0.4196814895,
-0.1294314265,
0.7007625699,
0.1982874721,
-0.6254342794,
-1.0890169144,
0.3872180581,
-0.8619281054,
-0.53681463,
1.0967056751,
-0.3923667371,
0.0019448716,
-0.15534015,
0.3185219467,
0.1193898991,
0.0578139238,
0.8704758286,
1.1474202871,
-0.1591427177,
0.0470245555,
-0.6996461749,
0.6516669989,
0.8592989445,
-0.6886807084,
0.2439672649,
0.537294507,
0.2495867163,
0.1750766933,
0.4750787318,
0.0399926715,
0.296361655,
-0.113746196,
-0.4004811943,
0.3074640334,
-0.5918902159,
-0.2920466959,
0.1910114437,
-0.2818516195,
0.1933933794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12092v1 | ESCOXLM-R: Multilingual Taxonomy-driven Pre-training for the Job Market Domain | 2023-05-20T04:50:20 | 2023-05-20T04:50:20 | Mike Zhang, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasing number of benchmarks for Natural Language Processing (NLP)
tasks in the computational job market domain highlights the demand for methods
that can handle job-related tasks such as skill extraction, skill
classification, job title classification, and de-identification. While some
approaches have been developed that are specific to the job market domain,
there is a lack of generalized, multilingual models and benchmarks for these
tasks. In this study, we introduce a language model called ESCOXLM-R, based on
XLM-R, which uses domain-adaptive pre-training on the European Skills,
Competences, Qualifications and Occupations (ESCO) taxonomy, covering 27
languages. The pre-training objectives for ESCOXLM-R include dynamic masked
language modeling and a novel additional objective for inducing multilingual
taxonomical ESCO relations. We comprehensively evaluate the performance of
ESCOXLM-R on 6 sequence labeling and 3 classification tasks in 4 languages and
find that it achieves state-of-the-art results on 6 out of 9 datasets. Our
analysis reveals that ESCOXLM-R performs better on short spans and outperforms
XLM-R on entity-level and surface-level span-F1, likely due to ESCO containing
short skill and occupation titles, and encoding information on the
entity-level. | [
-0.4918528497,
-0.5593982339,
0.2038929164,
0.0232325401,
-0.2480316907,
0.5728983283,
-0.2889871299,
-0.7399094105,
0.2612235248,
0.6619512439,
-0.6208181381,
-0.672768116,
-0.6589238048,
0.4308789372,
-0.3744291961,
0.9753662348,
0.2029148489,
-0.1342830956,
-0.5883707404,
-0.0350489542,
0.0165404398,
-1.1094210148,
-0.6189075112,
0.0211406276,
0.7542964816,
0.277667433,
0.3715955019,
0.742171526,
0.2236327082,
0.2838232815,
0.0373176709,
0.3380853236,
-0.1867664456,
0.2092690915,
-0.1961003691,
-0.2750180662,
-0.578245163,
-0.2198210508,
0.4811228812,
0.7083456516,
-0.4684391022,
0.2698063552,
0.0463261716,
0.2879706025,
-0.6311587095,
0.168068707,
-0.8960859179,
-0.1138479486,
-0.353923291,
-0.1994454861,
-0.4887762368,
0.0923434943,
-0.0250929352,
-0.643073678,
0.2036755085,
0.1719631106,
0.8300911784,
0.0705579594,
-0.4694838524,
-0.4611569047,
-0.4886897802,
1.0047072172,
-0.5066187978,
0.7581720352,
0.4088102877,
0.1648823321,
0.3504659534,
-0.7157052755,
-0.0926598758,
0.0239328723,
-0.2067753375,
0.1398679614,
-0.0786694884,
0.0062211896,
0.209438175,
-0.0230147429,
-0.6047560573,
0.3821341395,
-0.3509115875,
-0.1158583388,
0.6438932419,
0.2786598802,
0.1813705415,
0.355905056,
-0.5045485497,
-0.0514069572,
-0.5034899712,
-0.1189859509,
0.4980953336,
0.5401363373,
0.0528929681,
0.2414694577,
-0.2341793478,
0.8435027003,
-0.5269858241,
-0.3004862368,
0.2796593308,
-0.0450648218,
-0.0879870057,
-0.0895651579,
0.5477648377,
-0.0928734988,
0.0212383699,
-0.4043402672,
-0.5349858999,
0.1411171407,
0.5117341876,
-0.584022522,
0.3105031252,
0.1823040992,
-0.012347972,
-0.1567969322,
-0.1323148012,
-0.6820909381,
0.0667674989,
-0.5038603544,
0.2575398982,
-0.1059703305,
-0.297211349,
0.2962885201,
0.0755135864,
-0.0180000477,
0.0662727132,
-0.7079346776,
0.7920250893,
0.7588285804,
0.5872792006,
-0.5655439496,
-0.457564652,
-0.5692432523,
-0.0627594665,
0.0512791835,
0.9321513772,
-0.7988661528,
-0.1516440064,
0.2583540976,
0.3077718019,
-0.5051518083,
-0.5087034106,
0.4525405169,
-0.8250168562,
0.0166718215,
0.152680099,
-0.3261839747,
-0.208582446,
0.5083802938,
-0.5039259195,
1.2416057587,
0.0513149351,
-0.6421552896,
0.1982996613,
-0.7256646156,
-0.4097593427,
0.1705970317,
-0.205591172,
-0.5640295148,
-0.294634521,
-0.0196242817,
0.4808159471,
-0.2632249296,
0.170876354,
-0.1187798008,
-0.1214182675,
0.1734222472,
-0.0811568946,
0.6223421097,
0.3745684326,
-0.0733717903,
-0.0230385717,
-0.9479768276,
0.1380032301,
0.0798161849,
-0.0468347892,
-0.4894066751,
-0.0720296353,
0.1970704645,
0.6543607712,
0.0255211294,
-0.4104596674,
-0.0705352873,
-0.3182691634,
0.2017925233,
0.3539609015,
-0.3154087365,
0.2665438652,
-0.0072288676,
1.0318419933,
0.0247438308,
0.109800905,
-0.0360276811,
-0.2736134827,
-0.4674905241,
-0.3125348091,
0.4410096705,
0.6495718956,
-0.9539728165,
0.2449010313,
-0.2633725405,
-0.6430196762,
-0.3083460927,
-0.0478168465,
0.5735532641,
0.3755322397,
0.5238847733,
-0.5186864734,
-0.6681303382,
-0.8067246079,
-0.4368728399,
0.4305281639,
0.1036892161,
0.1368653774,
0.5481444597,
-0.5231344104,
0.9279286265,
-0.693739593,
-0.4349906445,
-0.2557058334,
0.2258061618,
0.1313283294,
0.1565452814,
0.5248836279,
-0.894348681,
-0.5780231357,
0.1763215512,
-0.2990956306,
-0.0757112429,
0.2206668407,
0.1127414033,
0.3751165569,
0.4518062472,
-0.2552964985,
0.0273143593,
0.8361920714,
-0.2366266549,
0.7075656652,
-0.3776513636,
-0.1956259906,
-0.904510498,
0.3154886663,
-0.040199358,
-0.4357659519,
-0.8004844785,
0.0244697481,
0.0844256207,
-0.3972951472,
-0.6530498862,
0.7479774952,
-0.6694299579,
-0.4122960567,
-0.205349341,
0.1500163078,
0.0194749087,
0.681822896,
0.6611472368,
0.5795875788,
0.7801779509,
-0.7577183843,
0.0449705869,
0.2191163898,
-0.3623290658,
0.3714517355,
-0.3332976401,
0.4980098605,
-0.0893416032,
-0.0940037668,
-0.5137423873,
0.1842351109,
-0.110979721,
-0.1300329715,
0.1695273817,
-0.0960534513,
-0.2842287123,
-0.5155180693,
0.1377850026,
0.3099510968,
0.2602009475,
-0.2231672704,
0.7201647162,
0.4002435505,
-0.5304661393,
-1.1402027607,
-0.6128332019,
-0.1050998494,
-0.085779883,
-0.2694991231,
0.6851716042,
-0.0287489351,
-0.0458121412,
-0.161095351,
0.0013826828,
-0.3854236603,
0.3100565374,
-0.1204519123,
0.2661606967,
-0.0376889333,
-0.0672463998,
-0.0405742936,
-0.2965030074,
-0.0669838786,
-0.1859525144,
0.5181512833,
0.1235972494,
-0.3434947431,
0.1473908871,
0.3659249246,
0.500698626,
-0.6841956973,
0.9038310647,
0.5228183866,
-0.2836562097,
-0.450140059,
-0.3435125947,
-0.1773564965,
-0.4224500954,
0.7105454206,
-0.3872942626,
-0.891694963,
0.4812241495,
-0.0614811033,
0.060705062,
0.3835250139,
0.3559734523,
0.2476320565,
1.0659734011,
0.6998654008,
0.3407677114,
0.2184204906,
-0.2757079899,
0.0822476894,
-0.5715364814,
-0.3059952259,
-0.7127622366,
0.2400923818,
-0.2140488476,
-0.2888005972,
0.1843342781,
-0.1928222179,
-0.0552083366,
0.6248170733,
-0.33117342,
0.2421827316,
0.339217782,
-0.1812389195,
0.2460643202,
0.0955953076,
-0.1855938137,
0.1284733862,
-0.7606401443,
-0.4958551824,
0.9070215225,
0.2671196759,
0.5173121095,
-0.1432953328,
0.5641369224,
0.3599717319,
0.314211756,
-0.6451654434,
0.3602656424,
-0.5088199377,
-0.4073905051,
-0.3526949584,
-0.2989450991,
-1.0745046139,
0.5696889162,
-0.3911571205,
-0.3500643075,
-0.0159604233,
0.1262296587,
-0.3787300885,
0.1061876416,
-0.4797602594,
0.9214084744,
-0.5723838806,
-0.099578999,
-0.0974428579,
-0.5693621039,
-0.081689395,
-0.6669493914,
0.9051524997,
-0.1689773053,
-0.2404105514,
0.7870131731,
-0.3326538205,
0.7403088212,
-0.1807759702,
-0.2029393613,
-0.0344066396,
-0.2402275503,
0.708545506,
-0.2131463289,
-0.2881905735,
0.3526903689,
0.2907502651,
-0.3159722388,
-0.3290543854,
0.2104628086,
-0.658673048,
-0.3684730232,
-0.5578739643,
-0.3377594352,
-0.5698211789,
0.4430163503,
0.2765491605,
0.5735557079,
-0.2976469398,
0.1838001758,
0.4211826921,
-0.3885959685,
0.0486014001,
0.8572704196,
-0.3296868205,
-0.2132993788,
0.733471036,
0.3895251155,
0.3991501927,
0.5806139112,
-0.2165299803,
-0.5215040445,
-0.5780489445,
-0.082852155,
0.1338918805,
-0.6118124127,
-0.3314530253,
-1.0512844324,
-0.2779240012,
-0.4620889127,
-0.1108792648,
-0.4602661729,
-0.0666980892,
0.0727472454,
0.0071085771,
0.1535177976,
0.5542586446,
0.1509174258,
0.1510251164,
-0.796677947,
0.2853503227,
0.3878941834,
0.4498021007,
-0.2373294383,
-0.3673956096,
-0.6576171517,
0.1847626418,
0.0017072498,
-0.3836946189,
0.8156309724,
0.349991709,
0.8383232355,
0.1249830797,
-0.0029906051,
0.4368919134,
-0.5326727033,
0.596136868,
0.1431950033,
-0.8054533005,
0.2530259192,
-0.1784163266,
0.1327275187,
0.2217012942,
0.7223447561,
-0.9281891584,
-0.4728454351,
-0.6376317739,
-0.9889598489,
1.0437611341,
0.0850295797,
0.1542199701,
-0.2273477316,
-0.0495934784,
0.3717560172,
0.3330131769,
-0.6011465788,
-0.3803683519,
0.0359309427,
-0.0595019385,
-0.2742113173,
-0.4122526348,
0.0463730916,
-0.0284393765,
0.787568748,
-0.1538180858,
0.2009683102,
-0.0637416318,
-0.5125230551,
0.3232768476,
0.4284388721,
0.9575642943,
0.6870335937,
-0.2019688189,
0.333638072,
0.3984208107,
-0.5490300059,
0.0781087056,
0.2989882529,
0.3414034247,
0.1211684942,
0.2332980633,
0.8718873262,
0.2873422205,
-0.9644179344,
0.4755419195,
-0.0600547083,
-0.3523060083,
-0.4358346164,
0.0371858887,
0.0711898804,
-0.1628255993,
0.4924302101,
0.1706396043,
-0.0793288201,
-0.4597642124,
0.2887950838,
0.1950071752,
-0.4043488801,
-0.3699818254,
0.6274170876,
0.1325360835,
-0.3211831152,
0.4477207661,
-0.1888440847,
-0.6197163463,
0.7477027774,
0.7020241022,
0.6324177384,
-0.4749214649,
0.2274685651,
0.3388254344,
-0.0579072721,
-0.123690553,
0.3063056469,
0.0660125986,
-0.9941228032,
-0.4677837491,
-0.8245025873,
-0.4884897172,
-0.0318480358,
-0.9725908637,
0.3766403794,
0.0285985768,
-0.1056007519,
0.0432176962,
-0.2219002992,
-0.9910258651,
0.6245524287,
0.2598709762,
0.8905497193,
-0.9040651321,
1.1274900436,
0.7220159769,
-0.1117374077,
-0.4395872056,
-0.5715723634,
-0.1868493557,
-0.872882545,
0.8213897347,
0.1463890076,
-0.4319304228,
0.3660567105,
-0.0732606873,
-0.996275425,
1.0689126253,
0.4698543549,
-0.7674629688,
-0.0708436221,
0.5163974762,
0.5551694632,
-0.6866130233,
0.2769036591,
0.3560017645,
0.2199515551,
-0.2183489352,
-0.9942441583,
-0.3678607643,
-0.3047878146,
0.1224052086,
0.1504723281,
-0.3650453389,
0.6119900942,
0.1498420089,
-0.3409022689,
-0.2205450982,
0.3462589085,
0.2428708225,
0.182536751,
0.7486454844,
0.2966143489,
0.8206045032,
-0.1235591546,
0.9194909334,
-0.5529946089,
0.4908286333,
1.0866434574,
-0.5905948281,
0.9301479459,
0.2245939076,
-0.2603200674,
0.771484971,
0.6340299249,
0.087168932,
0.4568343163,
0.0264906883,
-0.139865309,
-0.247140348,
-0.1376430839,
-0.4291129112,
0.5298629999,
0.423632741,
-0.3698358238,
-0.0854185224,
0.5184300542,
-0.040724121,
0.1920995116,
-0.4901635349,
0.6506271958,
0.1184567362,
-0.5905756354,
0.5826829672,
0.0689237192,
0.9053798318,
-0.9497509599,
0.1821191162,
-0.0356380306,
0.0125323748,
-0.1435511112,
-0.6510891914,
0.6732820868,
0.0746956095,
-0.020455068,
-0.6473448277,
0.7384732962,
-0.7373003364,
-0.3736993968,
0.5901325345,
0.4675012529,
0.1519386768,
-0.1939863265,
-0.8518069386,
0.106693387,
-0.3215323687,
-0.0821655467,
0.4268197417,
0.2046718448,
0.0393316075,
0.626711905,
0.5009192228,
0.0495974384,
0.0029957294,
0.2388736159,
0.5148604512,
-0.6343305707,
-0.8149298429,
-0.4743945599,
0.4959360063,
-0.1143703684,
-0.1531953067,
0.6011770368,
0.8220572472,
1.1630259752,
-0.4710104764,
0.7338715792,
0.1370648593,
0.8223740458,
-0.5693742633,
0.5320717096,
-0.7492316365,
-0.0274683889,
-0.2026532739,
-0.9041257501,
-0.3487710357,
0.0466277152,
-0.4104300439,
0.0778155848,
0.7172947526,
0.8799801469,
-0.0626079738,
-0.4342962801,
0.7501689792,
-0.0552801043,
-0.1866636723,
0.2767952383,
0.7473114133,
-0.218812272,
0.604141295,
-0.2307674885,
0.2131486833,
-0.1500098109,
-0.8500326276,
-0.6341353655,
-0.8069065213,
-0.5405698419,
-0.0333816931,
0.0418808311,
0.9647445679,
0.842325449,
-0.7530514598,
-0.4306947291,
0.1859721839,
-0.1574243605,
-0.7905135155,
-0.1567544639,
0.2825094163,
-0.5170637369,
-0.7449479699,
0.3471183181,
0.403334111,
-0.1495778114,
-0.054655157,
-0.112638846,
-0.0891708136,
0.0268144682,
0.9271826744,
0.320096463,
-0.5111528635,
0.0269438922,
0.1115525961,
-0.1630076319,
0.1245132163,
0.7694166303,
-0.5697562695,
0.4226672053,
-0.0481112972,
0.5732846856,
0.4402176142,
-0.0746515989,
0.479788661,
-1.0222085714,
0.3243792355,
0.2253959477,
0.2485622913,
0.1770102829,
-0.3499978483,
0.6205857992,
0.1858217567,
-0.3047667146,
-0.841239512,
0.1636419594,
-0.8443699479,
-0.4311932921,
1.224314332,
0.0071729226,
-0.1063439921,
-0.5978229642,
-0.0799105316,
0.1291929483,
0.0311969351,
0.5393030643,
0.4289557338,
0.1447609961,
-0.3561785817,
-0.3930443823,
0.5882463455,
0.1501742154,
-0.9320673347,
0.1370560974,
-0.0105032921,
0.2587788999,
0.1484154165,
0.691583395,
-0.0738451406,
0.1623042077,
-0.1254452914,
0.4226885736,
-0.1842749119,
-0.3181074858,
-0.1758924425,
0.2896843255,
0.3234782219,
0.1113927662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12091v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12091v2 | "What do others think?": Task-Oriented Conversational Modeling with Subjective Knowledge | 2023-05-20T04:43:26 | 2023-10-03T03:33:20 | Chao Zhao, Spandana Gella, Seokhwan Kim, Di Jin, Devamanyu Hazarika, Alexandros Papangelis, Behnam Hedayatnia, Mahdi Namazifar, Yang Liu, Dilek Hakkani-Tur | cs.CL | cs.CL | Task-oriented Dialogue (TOD) Systems aim to build dialogue systems that
assist users in accomplishing specific goals, such as booking a hotel or a
restaurant. Traditional TODs rely on domain-specific APIs/DBs or external
factual knowledge to generate responses, which cannot accommodate subjective
user requests (e.g., "Is the WIFI reliable?" or "Does the restaurant have a
good atmosphere?"). To address this issue, we propose a novel task of
subjective-knowledge-based TOD (SK-TOD). We also propose the first
corresponding dataset, which contains subjective knowledge-seeking dialogue
contexts and manually annotated responses grounded in subjective knowledge
sources. When evaluated with existing TOD approaches, we find that this task
poses new challenges such as aggregating diverse opinions from multiple
knowledge snippets. We hope this task and dataset can promote further research
on TOD and subjective content understanding. The code and the dataset are
available at https://github.com/alexa/dstc11-track5. | [
-0.6434482932,
-0.7609966993,
0.7600497007,
-0.2384356409,
-0.3859835863,
-0.0138615975,
-0.0482538715,
-0.3903858662,
0.2756547034,
0.5275463462,
-0.6893239021,
-0.5056868196,
-0.4971458316,
-0.1468999386,
-0.1359379888,
1.1751177311,
0.3153795302,
0.0086295009,
-0.3890015185,
-0.0202555787,
-0.5537929535,
-0.6095095277,
-0.4211906195,
-0.2817652225,
0.6427704096,
0.7901862264,
0.5345712304,
-0.0620414019,
0.1750780195,
0.2195840329,
0.1662165821,
0.1718316823,
-0.4318594933,
0.2538409829,
-0.2183369696,
-0.3093056679,
-0.499001205,
-0.2363020927,
-0.1333802491,
0.6700427532,
-0.0686630011,
0.3151693046,
-0.0634152591,
0.6248766184,
-0.3358047605,
0.4020185471,
-0.5570605397,
0.2283147722,
0.0583057888,
0.0084755952,
-0.327673316,
-0.2757634819,
0.713986516,
-0.5471322536,
-0.0622465648,
0.0885551348,
0.4462880194,
0.361951232,
-0.6052398086,
-0.4019781053,
-0.8311031461,
0.8120501041,
-0.7804883718,
0.3599716723,
0.6178951859,
0.1875007153,
0.2097683102,
-0.1782694459,
-0.8594526649,
-0.0712965876,
0.0236649774,
0.2302604467,
-0.2290563285,
-0.0621591695,
-0.0957060084,
0.2189773768,
-0.3820881844,
-0.3413089812,
-0.1424164027,
0.2619637251,
0.4754130542,
0.2661989629,
0.0004141443,
-0.3809577525,
-0.331712395,
0.4522415698,
-0.2527972758,
0.1068707258,
0.1835833937,
0.232305333,
-0.0687845498,
0.753744483,
-0.7010645866,
0.7934313416,
0.1727696657,
0.1150529385,
0.1909425408,
-0.1137731671,
-0.3661481738,
-0.2999350727,
0.6343035102,
0.836623311,
0.0793877244,
-0.2946228683,
-0.0466440953,
-0.2519254088,
0.6150128841,
-0.2983579636,
-0.3649633229,
0.5429081321,
-0.5645667911,
-0.3178160787,
-0.3237759173,
-0.5058697462,
-0.4268960655,
-0.8435099721,
0.3406754434,
-0.2314479053,
-0.5069183111,
-0.0158477537,
-0.2073152661,
-0.1388324499,
0.6551681161,
-0.4560106099,
0.2030852437,
0.7350357175,
0.6988252997,
-0.2276860178,
0.0429794751,
0.1380974501,
0.0281936992,
-0.0208865684,
0.9361641407,
-0.4689296484,
-0.8098721504,
-0.1738271713,
-0.0919921622,
0.1591810882,
-0.1866066009,
0.5529505014,
-0.4551766217,
0.2405407578,
-0.6214213371,
-0.3870323598,
-0.2912395,
0.6991609931,
-0.1337596774,
0.8208530545,
0.0173162501,
-0.8037090302,
0.3652879894,
-0.6938037872,
-0.3200371861,
0.1124325842,
-0.0846526474,
0.0830787197,
0.4297133684,
0.0295178331,
0.3548548222,
-0.3350828588,
0.399379015,
-0.4540551901,
0.1616204381,
0.5651019812,
-0.2444688678,
0.402897507,
0.5296052694,
-0.3048256934,
0.0645109043,
-0.4628983736,
0.1625149399,
-0.0575171337,
-0.0244216714,
-0.5426111221,
0.2296281755,
-0.165558219,
0.347261101,
0.4126467109,
-0.7244184017,
0.1638357043,
-0.1782735437,
0.2117570639,
0.899309516,
-0.057717476,
0.3938289285,
-0.6862015724,
0.352632314,
0.345584929,
0.3583227992,
0.201810956,
-0.84259516,
-0.9003117681,
0.0747287571,
-0.0670112222,
0.3343200684,
-0.9841644764,
0.269649744,
-0.3667037487,
-0.6764458418,
-0.1817247421,
-0.2295529991,
0.4110301137,
0.9971243143,
0.1103148907,
-0.4429986775,
-0.4787074924,
-0.8638615012,
-0.0713091642,
-0.2920584977,
0.0103351567,
0.9138481021,
0.3256510198,
0.0202976279,
1.3714089394,
-0.8277174234,
-0.1981822699,
-0.3333742619,
0.1935289353,
0.1896044314,
0.4803619385,
0.3499839306,
-0.7520353198,
-0.6652958989,
0.1580282897,
-0.7171429396,
0.1324504912,
0.3863298893,
-0.1631980538,
0.1680176854,
-0.0809969231,
-0.5341531634,
0.3226238489,
0.3476780057,
-0.2429815084,
0.5007043481,
0.1143322885,
0.4280703366,
-1.2412179708,
0.0299723707,
0.076954037,
-0.2627853453,
-0.7420911193,
-0.4232757986,
-0.6607761383,
-0.1888753027,
-0.4504881799,
0.6369549036,
0.2462002635,
-0.1756617874,
-0.2724246681,
0.0642794371,
0.0310041346,
1.0046937466,
0.4193664491,
0.4379085302,
0.5231040716,
-0.6319221258,
0.1681597978,
0.4977734089,
-0.3829108775,
1.0681495667,
-0.571922183,
0.6351277828,
-0.1336649656,
0.4120232463,
-0.7956802249,
-0.2566886544,
0.3462551236,
-0.5620806217,
-0.580016315,
-0.5948195457,
-0.2881072164,
-0.2885417938,
0.1630085558,
0.3893843889,
0.3455767632,
-0.2228161991,
0.7891682386,
0.8922966719,
-0.6312755346,
-0.3617636263,
-0.4727472663,
0.0561546683,
-0.1079258174,
-0.3010953367,
-0.0542320982,
-0.0236020647,
-0.4153845906,
0.0346421078,
-0.126789704,
-0.3942090869,
-0.0336165056,
0.453166157,
0.0835261494,
0.1841562241,
0.166492939,
0.0356795862,
-0.0078014624,
0.1804477572,
-0.8928363919,
0.6396089196,
-0.1052814499,
-0.5600203276,
-0.6599251032,
0.6317896843,
0.5526143909,
0.0591352172,
0.3373208642,
0.327549547,
-0.217654869,
-0.1694167852,
-0.4948908091,
-0.0177529771,
-0.4478580356,
0.2344594449,
-0.5528658628,
-0.7060191631,
0.4913243353,
-0.0498847812,
0.210953638,
0.0857169852,
0.7784166336,
-0.6297110915,
1.0825867653,
0.4254852831,
-0.0514080711,
0.4907746017,
-0.2424887121,
0.388805896,
-0.7507225871,
-0.5211771131,
-0.5642240644,
-0.4212124646,
-0.1481342167,
-0.4831365049,
0.4445237517,
-0.5560007095,
-0.0588941872,
0.2785815597,
-0.4602651894,
0.1833991557,
0.9277333021,
0.4551355541,
0.5451943874,
-0.4782565832,
0.0799239427,
0.1454110593,
-0.4211576879,
-0.6214399338,
1.1869345903,
0.1137278154,
0.7457193732,
0.1278895736,
0.5351153016,
0.7433955073,
0.215390414,
-1.0699627399,
0.6206739545,
-0.0283460636,
-0.701851368,
-0.2134979963,
-0.3441184759,
-0.4665400386,
-0.0739708319,
0.2450492382,
-0.7033886313,
0.4347627163,
0.1810603589,
-0.2648216486,
0.2086197287,
-0.8627816439,
0.6030669212,
-0.0400647633,
-0.0339156128,
-0.2890059054,
-0.463136673,
0.1927618533,
0.2468147725,
0.3418989778,
-0.3446967602,
0.3598958254,
0.7204645872,
-0.5237616301,
1.0220612288,
-0.6018933654,
-0.3703615367,
0.4968053401,
0.1698019058,
0.4926860034,
0.3024351597,
-0.1227875426,
0.1864086092,
0.0825757831,
-0.3147483468,
-0.6818931699,
0.5722180009,
-0.6945980787,
-0.5528913736,
-0.2440847903,
-0.5907769203,
-0.7695606947,
0.0598953143,
0.0486354083,
0.5730413198,
-0.2150112092,
0.0466337912,
0.4456784427,
0.1466567218,
0.124357909,
0.6381479502,
-0.1531875283,
-0.3369154632,
1.0637103319,
-0.1275987774,
0.1890771389,
0.2639427781,
0.0342163481,
-0.331568718,
-0.570163846,
-0.395429343,
-0.4969214201,
-0.6275592446,
-0.2063729465,
-1.0288637877,
0.1844737679,
-0.2582696378,
-0.024733061,
-0.3672694862,
-0.6518720984,
-0.155072704,
-0.1710039079,
0.2980169952,
1.0608013868,
0.2028305978,
0.2184643447,
-0.6486619711,
0.2554597855,
0.6988691688,
0.3452440202,
0.1886265278,
-0.1894212663,
-0.5391426682,
0.4657465219,
-0.3476714492,
-0.6484913826,
0.376151979,
-0.2135280222,
0.3612930477,
0.2404630631,
0.5212280154,
0.2849455774,
-0.3728187084,
1.0020051003,
0.1195710301,
-0.985845983,
0.7866493464,
-0.5737828612,
0.2722206414,
0.8807171583,
0.2580598891,
-0.6478701234,
-0.6325958371,
-0.5244057178,
-0.3662650883,
0.7837631702,
0.1529452503,
0.2242096364,
-0.1907523423,
-0.0547183678,
0.3320531845,
0.6615083218,
-0.6736959815,
-0.2498634458,
-0.6187676191,
-0.3932041228,
0.1018196717,
0.0247353762,
-0.4539781213,
-0.187767297,
0.4929080009,
-0.4007988274,
0.6041476727,
0.3450264037,
-0.0292199533,
0.0093479296,
0.3914215565,
0.3884748816,
0.5843001008,
-0.266253382,
0.0230055153,
0.0829751641,
-0.1666504592,
-0.04507263,
-0.2916964889,
-0.2180922031,
-0.0437159985,
-0.3512740135,
0.8419923186,
0.089933373,
-0.7669255733,
0.3919607699,
-0.2486515641,
-0.2007743567,
-0.1778335869,
0.0276448037,
-0.181106776,
0.191783756,
0.4915180802,
0.4381453097,
0.4286364317,
-0.7049021721,
0.1007857248,
0.3556363881,
-0.7573049664,
-0.5927738547,
0.2654286623,
0.7713450789,
-0.4418198466,
0.1807721555,
-0.1894663572,
-0.7154712081,
0.4095905721,
0.0355763398,
0.9466378093,
0.3530566096,
0.6281278729,
0.0810739025,
-0.2726269066,
0.3065367937,
0.5635030866,
-0.7481290698,
-0.7859404683,
-0.2349958569,
-0.5136278868,
-0.9372502565,
-0.2771380544,
-0.7292953134,
-0.0536666103,
-0.3083135188,
-0.4956608117,
-0.368679136,
-0.0918516815,
-0.7427790165,
0.4288770854,
-0.1472636163,
0.3760567307,
-0.4698437154,
0.8128730059,
0.580153048,
-0.0747425035,
-0.527025342,
0.0835994184,
0.1207494214,
-0.7229303718,
0.7467978597,
-0.3841628432,
-0.2227082551,
-0.0998207331,
-0.2910467088,
-0.7683092356,
0.634571135,
-0.1596816778,
-0.4783643484,
-0.2870264053,
0.1200306565,
0.4605753124,
-0.4765802622,
0.2123651505,
0.2414169014,
0.462413609,
0.0946128592,
-1.0854638815,
-0.2615089118,
-0.3169438541,
-0.2886762619,
-0.1673871428,
-0.6594247222,
0.5435938835,
-0.0663628802,
0.1182749644,
0.0251300484,
0.315725714,
0.0273862295,
0.5589048266,
0.7177215815,
0.7890763879,
0.5030648708,
-0.1949833184,
0.8350679278,
-0.3390622139,
0.2651112676,
1.5906276703,
-0.3689582646,
0.7457891107,
0.3076467812,
-0.1047670692,
0.540461421,
0.5092887878,
0.2939701974,
0.8854140639,
-0.136822924,
-0.3322855234,
-0.1965485364,
-0.4763753414,
-0.3163526952,
0.5591264367,
0.2516518235,
-0.1335101873,
0.0733044147,
0.334361583,
-0.3321616352,
-0.2811163962,
-0.0138035472,
1.4952756166,
-0.1163906232,
-0.8930200338,
0.0540449321,
-0.3575784862,
0.4826335311,
-0.2310885638,
0.2732119858,
-0.1261630356,
-0.2187340558,
-0.0366466492,
-0.9277669787,
0.3744287491,
0.2809170485,
-0.328916043,
-0.431502372,
0.2817725241,
-0.1114205196,
-0.2851832509,
-0.0915590674,
0.7279764414,
0.0210704878,
-0.0774039701,
-0.5904569626,
-0.1036817357,
0.0912111625,
-0.0273336619,
0.1628976315,
0.7165293097,
0.3328798413,
0.763502419,
0.5303381681,
-0.1528906375,
-0.1722883731,
0.268110007,
0.980369091,
-0.4974245727,
-0.6239451766,
-0.2220176756,
0.7217167616,
-0.1951950639,
-0.5419723988,
0.6801682115,
0.5475711823,
0.8519986272,
-0.2249835432,
1.1019052267,
-0.5104472041,
0.701379478,
-0.1338333935,
0.5682688951,
-0.5003940463,
0.1592891663,
-0.4948922694,
-0.6773770452,
0.3957604468,
0.2733724415,
-0.4870785475,
-0.0240840632,
0.4333974421,
0.4841200411,
0.1681043655,
0.5115486979,
0.2640417516,
0.1627530903,
0.5508045554,
0.425311774,
1.1881095171,
-0.008982012,
0.4026020467,
-0.362029165,
-0.1049695462,
-0.1557074338,
-0.4766162336,
-0.7045366764,
-1.1260570288,
-0.2960094512,
-0.0760538355,
0.0711090267,
0.8865733743,
1.1290817261,
-0.7727373242,
-0.1114363596,
-0.4912897646,
0.2744247615,
-0.1257554591,
-0.2888811231,
-0.0335700549,
-0.3958583772,
-1.0009562969,
0.2724541426,
0.1375012398,
0.0252994467,
-0.1050548926,
0.081302397,
0.0266190413,
0.1420023441,
0.5991635323,
0.0346290283,
-0.8291385174,
-0.2727839649,
0.0610228106,
0.1024041399,
0.0580861159,
1.0412297249,
-0.9184327126,
0.5307011604,
0.3916743994,
0.3326638341,
0.5149573684,
0.1019145027,
0.8284476995,
-0.7450111508,
-0.0047381404,
0.6159296632,
0.2404401749,
0.079503946,
-0.2787815332,
0.2588337958,
0.0859970972,
-0.5570237041,
-0.7589146495,
0.4169257879,
-1.3713169098,
-0.2490956336,
0.7975543737,
-0.2783831358,
-0.07800062,
-0.6724152565,
-0.5083992481,
-0.1702613682,
-0.7819622755,
0.9754109383,
0.5956221819,
-0.3001672924,
-0.0457677357,
-0.2067388594,
0.601477623,
0.3797358274,
-0.9879433513,
0.1816317141,
0.4729346931,
0.2507341504,
0.1649476439,
0.9002292752,
0.1943558753,
0.1224645823,
-0.1693768203,
-0.3083175719,
-0.052311305,
-0.2437663972,
0.3547857106,
0.3007161617,
0.0148711819,
-0.1302725375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12090v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12090v2 | UP5: Unbiased Foundation Model for Fairness-aware Recommendation | 2023-05-20T04:32:59 | 2024-05-29T16:46:47 | Wenyue Hua, Yingqiang Ge, Shuyuan Xu, Jianchao Ji, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in Foundation Models such as Large Language Models (LLMs)
have propelled them to the forefront of Recommender Systems (RS). Despite their
utility, there is a growing concern that LLMs might inadvertently perpetuate
societal stereotypes, resulting in unfair recommendations. Since fairness is
critical for RS as many users take it for decision-making and demand
fulfillment, this paper focuses on user-side fairness for LLM-based
recommendation where the users may require a recommender system to be fair on
specific sensitive features such as gender or age. In this paper, we dive into
the extent of unfairness exhibited by LLM-based recommender models based on
both T5 and LLaMA backbones, and discuss appropriate methods for promoting
equitable treatment of users in LLM-based recommendation models. We introduce a
novel Counterfactually-Fair-Prompt (CFP) method towards Unbiased Foundation
mOdels (UFO) for fairness-aware LLM-based recommendation. Experiments are
conducted on two real-world datasets, MovieLens-1M and Insurance, and compared
with both matching-based and sequential-based fairness-aware recommendation
models. Results show that CFP achieves better recommendation performance with a
high level of fairness. Data and code are open-sourced at
https://github.com/agiresearch/UP5. | [
-0.1179113016,
-0.2970637679,
0.4971192777,
0.6033213139,
-0.1483166516,
-0.1890570819,
0.2566947341,
-0.501367569,
-0.1050684303,
0.6853711009,
-0.5799744725,
-0.464551121,
-0.3249974847,
-0.1189082041,
-0.4679186046,
1.0024780035,
0.3212973177,
0.3611811697,
-0.4582980573,
-0.2302244753,
-0.8364004493,
-0.4699027836,
-0.5677886605,
-0.7114377022,
0.0980407223,
0.4898335636,
0.7793691158,
0.5671641231,
0.3332328796,
0.2915987372,
-0.2249955237,
-0.4413635433,
-0.5162206888,
0.0736876726,
-0.3941527009,
-0.515658021,
-0.5506916046,
0.0122511154,
0.2047424316,
0.7628443837,
-0.6242042184,
0.2489378899,
-0.1465248168,
0.7938992977,
-0.689910233,
-0.2447949797,
-0.5706605315,
0.4067887664,
-0.2551580071,
0.0702891201,
-0.2338104844,
-0.3795182109,
0.2301017046,
-0.5095078945,
0.375389725,
0.4989097416,
0.3765825331,
0.1206111386,
-0.3395932019,
-0.1873351783,
-0.375082612,
0.8783634305,
-0.5352031589,
0.4249359667,
0.3205673099,
0.6378448009,
-0.3105202317,
-0.5789461732,
-0.4872193038,
-0.2301121354,
-0.1102162749,
-0.150287196,
-0.4155797958,
-0.0348465331,
0.1694716066,
0.4777421355,
-0.2728424072,
0.2723713219,
-0.1111076325,
-0.2120668292,
0.5257790685,
0.0512695312,
0.2208587378,
-0.2756614089,
-0.5308035016,
0.2853824794,
-0.8403964043,
0.4056034982,
0.5331620574,
0.1946756542,
-0.1609174609,
0.6881753802,
-0.4912735522,
0.5218872428,
0.4112786055,
0.1706270725,
0.2392692566,
-0.2121163756,
-0.3165324032,
0.2142871171,
0.3960000873,
0.8345797062,
0.7647634745,
-0.2706626952,
-0.255015105,
0.2222219557,
0.0822077617,
-0.6680490375,
0.2601940334,
0.0519931652,
-0.663220048,
-0.6859061122,
-0.1339008063,
-0.759416163,
-0.7711793184,
-0.0402017087,
0.1980243623,
0.2463786006,
-0.04091895,
0.2599552274,
-0.0299739838,
-0.1000786945,
0.1834149063,
-0.7372837067,
0.3680655062,
0.2834430337,
0.4090203345,
0.1395238191,
0.0450637825,
-0.7558020949,
0.1912471652,
0.0788416788,
0.8407145739,
-0.8031491041,
-0.542850554,
-0.1146156639,
-0.089353852,
0.4244960248,
-0.5157517791,
0.7854090333,
-0.4150077105,
0.3847215772,
-0.6384973526,
-0.2551406026,
-0.3086830676,
0.0110741556,
-0.3725941479,
0.7754083872,
0.086864762,
-0.6046559811,
0.6119738221,
-0.8088998199,
-0.2485488802,
-0.1226690859,
-0.2282881737,
-0.3404149413,
0.0506249964,
0.442846626,
0.4814225435,
-0.3940014243,
0.8422749043,
-1.0155391693,
-0.5798499584,
0.0979935378,
-0.6577732563,
0.8919916153,
0.3238759637,
-0.5015179515,
0.0401244946,
-0.4290955067,
-0.3983497024,
0.0222522337,
0.0762455314,
-0.1274571121,
-0.0922989547,
0.1806581318,
0.29036358,
0.1696026474,
-0.5758054852,
-0.0856630802,
-0.3990526199,
0.3215208054,
1.1856007576,
-0.5149006248,
0.4872315228,
-0.7458176017,
0.3393112123,
0.1916363537,
0.3015694916,
0.1651660949,
-0.4246685207,
-0.4998640716,
-0.1609330475,
0.2388981283,
0.5009941459,
-0.3073034883,
0.2740053236,
0.1565414816,
-0.0191422664,
-0.4542107284,
0.1492542028,
0.3685821593,
0.5694437027,
0.3283702135,
-0.5226940513,
-0.435770452,
-0.7773754001,
-0.4104360938,
-0.1346262097,
0.1424523145,
0.7360631824,
0.2051580399,
-0.2732024789,
1.0315701962,
-0.3465168178,
-0.6875254512,
-0.0478316955,
-0.4014730155,
0.3842448294,
0.2158069164,
0.9539492726,
-0.797588408,
-0.0960879847,
-0.5643051267,
-0.632157445,
-0.7432805896,
0.4261747003,
-0.0726090521,
0.1105998084,
0.3111221492,
-0.2811617851,
0.3884619176,
0.2726258039,
-0.9871956706,
0.1982292235,
-0.2551214695,
0.3899217248,
-0.8786347508,
0.0957875997,
0.0802055001,
-0.4641813636,
-0.073912397,
-0.0574102253,
-0.4191282988,
0.0114928987,
-0.4257990122,
0.8438748717,
-0.0651644096,
-0.3285210729,
-0.1783419847,
-0.031264212,
-0.0862053484,
0.3503902256,
-0.3401303589,
0.3881852627,
0.4211988449,
-0.392773509,
0.3147834837,
0.0427562445,
-0.0735560283,
1.0400631428,
-0.7890090942,
-0.0477671511,
-0.2494565845,
0.6135290265,
-0.8112487793,
0.1441053301,
0.2744613886,
-0.2000874877,
-0.3583668768,
-0.1175355911,
-0.1280536056,
-0.2295559347,
-0.4956720471,
0.6164775491,
0.3901882172,
-0.6897864938,
0.6874449849,
0.4906136096,
-0.1412761956,
-1.2225596905,
-0.5630173683,
-0.0671331882,
-0.4455366135,
-0.6286056042,
0.6588895321,
-0.4150562286,
-0.396882385,
0.0632803142,
-0.1464061141,
0.1721675247,
0.3208883703,
0.5909371376,
0.0623076595,
0.2774090767,
-0.152782917,
0.0658536777,
-0.179659754,
-0.1188769639,
-0.4155267179,
0.2612223029,
-0.3973095119,
-0.3856831491,
-0.0652888119,
0.3443425894,
0.3620070219,
0.1651451737,
0.302922368,
0.6626387239,
-0.5281462073,
-0.083538875,
-0.793590486,
-0.1393675357,
-0.4923591018,
0.0094285551,
-0.2972725928,
-1.0954017639,
0.6738802791,
0.20775567,
0.1006477028,
0.3990217745,
0.6746913195,
-0.1352119595,
0.9494003654,
1.0027633905,
-0.2397464067,
0.4374226034,
0.0269380361,
-0.0057729082,
-0.2501541078,
-0.3315847814,
-0.6898043156,
-0.2831332982,
-0.4829132855,
-0.0366142727,
0.0281014573,
0.3079410791,
-0.2949259579,
-0.1492469758,
-0.3192064464,
0.5782806277,
0.4750548005,
0.1671241671,
0.7363585234,
0.0545714535,
-0.5902586579,
0.1074433178,
-0.6596410275,
-0.4047407508,
1.104252696,
0.2467235923,
0.7198641896,
0.4155801237,
0.1400852054,
1.1992759705,
0.5050125122,
-0.3742222488,
0.5584130287,
-0.7822261453,
-0.6650271416,
-0.0416849665,
-0.3957850337,
-0.6564266682,
0.1381394863,
-0.3639353514,
-0.5905243158,
0.6045908332,
0.357239306,
-0.3363553882,
0.1640891731,
-0.4807335734,
0.6498700976,
-0.092684105,
-0.2316739857,
-0.4492209554,
-0.4985639453,
0.277128607,
-0.0701669827,
0.4559218585,
-0.47092098,
0.2657539546,
0.5837981701,
-0.4072638154,
0.6964803934,
-0.5296319723,
-0.0145688383,
-0.0539835542,
0.0869325697,
0.324585855,
0.4449968636,
-0.3284263611,
0.401918292,
-0.1270372272,
-0.3229908943,
-0.4183793366,
0.9507733583,
-0.6697441339,
-0.7593407035,
-0.4963695705,
-0.3674465716,
-0.0164968073,
0.2973053157,
-0.0020645955,
0.4123896658,
-0.2317063063,
0.3020349741,
0.4138332605,
-0.2340717614,
0.4285057783,
0.9181614518,
-0.5120087862,
-0.2651329041,
0.4857880175,
0.0213581063,
-0.3117607236,
0.2367530763,
0.2500620484,
-0.5757146478,
-0.3681045175,
-0.5034402013,
-0.1002695784,
-0.7886019945,
-0.1977133304,
-0.7311043739,
0.3261485398,
-0.4912565947,
-0.3432546556,
-0.1184879094,
-0.4916404188,
-0.0927806124,
-0.0103739612,
0.3322053254,
0.571315527,
-0.1995520145,
0.3145595193,
-0.0839672089,
0.5184831023,
0.344355762,
0.7206770778,
-0.0431346558,
-0.6215093136,
0.1721839905,
-0.0683794394,
-0.2872930467,
-0.4322876632,
-0.0808997974,
-0.0807978809,
0.822889328,
0.4458370507,
0.295548588,
0.1670129001,
-0.201346904,
0.5019684434,
0.2114350051,
-0.9342214465,
0.2022417337,
-0.3229720891,
-0.0387997665,
0.5359539986,
0.0176662039,
-0.4385155439,
-0.1325645745,
-0.4052332342,
-0.6413943172,
0.6961564422,
0.0419283323,
0.0967251658,
0.3404280841,
0.2737493515,
0.2641798258,
0.446020931,
-0.9964796305,
-0.2049081326,
-0.4329828024,
-0.3061287105,
-0.1495606005,
-0.3205755651,
-0.0348553397,
0.126261875,
0.5147348642,
-0.055985678,
0.0683974996,
0.1171208099,
-0.2196639925,
-0.3354385197,
0.624904871,
0.3576833606,
0.463717103,
-0.5412184,
-0.1277489364,
0.2632277906,
-0.1751046628,
0.4845881462,
0.4612568915,
-0.2378077507,
-0.3853103518,
-0.2184329927,
0.5075152516,
0.147565946,
-0.5156074166,
0.6827899218,
-0.2599160969,
0.0878952742,
-0.2691166997,
0.1386050433,
-0.1312002987,
0.3151179254,
0.3243426085,
0.2877580822,
0.5293189287,
-0.4840114117,
0.1928468347,
0.4564519525,
-0.7278165221,
0.14742814,
0.7136499882,
0.7218625546,
-0.1815628111,
0.4330040812,
0.1166709214,
-0.2385330796,
0.50275141,
0.415708214,
0.8230245709,
-0.0326144584,
0.1650054753,
-0.3842167854,
0.1217017248,
-0.2539795637,
0.193714276,
-0.1341549754,
-0.9111614227,
-0.145870626,
-0.6581596136,
-0.2835043371,
-0.2874269187,
-0.331771493,
0.455484271,
-0.4662212133,
-0.4187928438,
-0.0633924678,
0.0902154446,
-0.8139397502,
0.3836827576,
-0.0620366856,
0.8618691564,
-0.656829536,
0.313049674,
0.6411312222,
-0.2103151679,
-0.3655121922,
-0.2159931511,
0.1799274981,
-0.7547441721,
0.3530004621,
0.2821290195,
-0.4638899565,
-0.0237056222,
-0.2554979026,
-0.2200998515,
1.1817618608,
0.9333231449,
-0.5830972791,
0.0089176018,
0.0940795392,
0.3803965449,
-0.6222557425,
0.7852087021,
0.1442298889,
0.445959419,
-0.0448432975,
-0.8738040924,
0.3016052842,
-0.2516550422,
0.018944012,
-0.3105308712,
-0.8248862624,
0.6079082489,
-0.6654579043,
0.1002609208,
0.040732637,
0.5176308155,
0.7625558376,
0.866728127,
0.9006990194,
0.6219794154,
0.6471073627,
0.0531999357,
0.9483793974,
0.1022461578,
0.143639639,
0.8031512499,
-0.5597324371,
0.1663468182,
0.3026774824,
-0.0720790774,
0.6633684635,
0.7242800593,
-0.1637749672,
0.5077787042,
0.4113879204,
-0.0438425951,
-0.306307137,
-0.7545236945,
-0.6303775907,
0.3531136513,
-0.2306317687,
-0.3516427577,
-0.2463305742,
-0.132051751,
0.0822028294,
0.2166547477,
-0.4221657217,
0.4509161413,
0.3902296722,
-0.3634895384,
-0.0860845521,
0.5647167563,
1.1375335455,
-0.3655965924,
-0.0974979848,
-0.513252914,
0.2271298468,
-0.2783508599,
-0.641690731,
-0.1242150217,
0.1208651066,
-0.8333665133,
-0.1842958778,
0.8853239417,
-0.1874085069,
-0.5837779641,
0.5901910663,
0.4204329252,
-0.0611098707,
0.1352551579,
-0.980371356,
-0.3818723559,
-0.0493002348,
-0.1631644368,
0.296536088,
0.1185965836,
-0.5377238393,
1.1422140598,
0.7416351438,
-0.0654774606,
-0.4324418902,
0.49009642,
0.4644075036,
-0.8009049892,
-0.9226712584,
-0.7885426283,
0.4218194485,
0.1111164913,
-0.2000848502,
0.3477739692,
0.0747303441,
0.9097818732,
0.1987757236,
0.4830417335,
0.1191683188,
0.3105463684,
-0.435097307,
0.8183583021,
-0.6496555805,
0.877907753,
-0.3631662428,
-0.9677275419,
-0.0538801551,
0.1076469496,
-0.1510685682,
0.9648140669,
0.1542285383,
0.8311036825,
0.0215715598,
0.2230191678,
0.197422415,
0.0509161726,
0.1940968931,
0.5737004876,
0.6584514976,
-0.2010678053,
0.5493816137,
0.1379452199,
-0.1707489192,
-0.4356813133,
-1.111961484,
-0.8496865034,
0.0301146768,
0.0827929899,
-0.2914945483,
0.4670455754,
0.9596405029,
0.7171025872,
-0.7831143737,
-0.3203689754,
0.0359119661,
0.4823715091,
-0.0294042416,
-0.2352789193,
0.108509481,
0.2908035517,
-0.3234830797,
0.2030767351,
0.0873526186,
0.1152231172,
-0.3625842929,
-0.2145145684,
0.08805684,
0.176692754,
0.2442412376,
-0.2887770534,
-0.6340363026,
-0.1583747864,
-0.2857246399,
-0.0653579012,
-0.2757502794,
0.8513893485,
-1.1001517773,
0.2346853763,
0.3511889279,
0.2821931839,
0.0919356942,
-0.0342498496,
1.0288270712,
-0.5293590426,
-0.0461872108,
-0.1661584079,
0.5412790775,
0.5200424194,
-0.8110525012,
0.40496701,
0.5829355717,
-0.3877485096,
-1.0360281467,
0.1294432431,
-0.7948953509,
-0.3076233864,
0.6494932771,
-0.051614847,
0.3773450553,
-0.3168023527,
-0.1216362342,
0.0789654702,
-0.8747861385,
1.0333544016,
0.6398567557,
0.1202073544,
-0.0266420282,
-0.1691730767,
0.4212098122,
0.7793858647,
-0.4452064633,
-0.0890780687,
0.3862072229,
0.4743838906,
-0.419111222,
0.9495059252,
-0.2028808445,
0.4435103834,
-0.5120919943,
-0.0935324654,
-0.4938294291,
-0.290463239,
-0.5090357065,
0.3900048733,
-0.0179095306,
0.3919706941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12086v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12086v2 | Prefix Propagation: Parameter-Efficient Tuning for Long Sequences | 2023-05-20T04:07:06 | 2023-05-24T21:13:24 | Jonathan Li, Will Aitken, Rohan Bhambhoria, Xiaodan Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Parameter-efficient tuning aims to mitigate the large memory requirements of
adapting pretrained language models for downstream tasks. For example, one
popular method, prefix-tuning, prepends trainable tokens to sequences while
freezing the rest of the model's parameters. Although such models attain
comparable performance with fine-tuning when applied to sequences with short to
moderate lengths, we show their inferior performance when modelling long
sequences. To bridge this gap, we propose prefix-propagation, a simple but
effective approach that conditions prefixes on previous hidden states. We
empirically demonstrate that prefix-propagation outperforms prefix-tuning
across long-document tasks, while using 50% fewer parameters. To further
investigate the proposed architecture, we also show its advantage in
calibration, and perform additional study on its relationship with kernel
attention. To the best of our knowledge, this work is the first to focus on
parameter-efficient learning for long-sequence language tasks. | [
-0.6212225556,
-0.6346132159,
0.5122280121,
0.4548133016,
-0.7169216275,
-0.3309814036,
-0.5833625793,
-0.3014801741,
0.1894052029,
0.3600816131,
-0.5706806779,
-0.2938232124,
-0.5275919437,
-0.0024781509,
-0.3676115274,
0.9121878743,
0.3423096538,
-0.3302751482,
0.0570461676,
0.1468584239,
-0.6035431027,
-0.1899753958,
-0.9273940325,
-0.1026358977,
0.9176040292,
0.4200960398,
0.8261153698,
1.1659474373,
0.1368666738,
0.2248877138,
-0.3034615219,
0.4132508636,
-0.5831612945,
0.2201503813,
-0.215530619,
-0.2721952498,
-0.4433946908,
-0.3461634517,
1.0400912762,
0.853731215,
-0.0596329682,
0.0609148853,
0.0155302696,
0.9390988946,
-0.7515095472,
0.0021030984,
-0.5432442427,
-0.2977246046,
-0.5850296617,
-0.3889249861,
-0.5924587846,
-0.2072833031,
-0.1651630104,
-0.7542610168,
0.2799644172,
0.269805789,
0.6290931702,
0.5531790257,
-0.3298552632,
-0.0923223421,
-0.7848688364,
0.6615824699,
-0.4854596257,
0.8585412502,
0.577156961,
0.0402484871,
-0.3762618303,
-0.7642480731,
-0.1919589639,
0.0220200717,
0.0065869209,
-0.0229441077,
0.1234282479,
0.2111325562,
0.4688581526,
0.1875973344,
-0.3989941776,
0.332008481,
-0.541718483,
-0.1994910985,
0.5167642832,
-0.1223449111,
-0.284802258,
0.0379028283,
-0.3333413005,
-0.0289908051,
-0.856498003,
-0.2307682633,
0.6417742968,
0.3739278018,
0.1669693738,
-0.0523974337,
-0.1992002279,
1.1937912703,
0.1455198228,
0.1220230311,
-0.0338614546,
-0.1425127089,
-0.1710719913,
0.2131207287,
0.2354731411,
-0.0553659163,
0.2064263225,
-0.3602650464,
-0.1125343889,
-0.1387088746,
0.4078434408,
-0.7922993302,
-0.2325627059,
-0.1192114726,
-0.1408617944,
0.1799898893,
-0.2838204801,
-0.6819823384,
-0.0732205808,
-0.5395685434,
0.6270455122,
-0.4753387868,
0.0477369837,
0.3613935113,
-0.2041587681,
0.2615353465,
0.2439606339,
-1.1367558241,
0.5263018012,
1.0775533915,
0.5228790045,
-0.3320888579,
-0.3577946126,
-0.8198808432,
0.1848842949,
-0.3989387751,
0.4662747383,
-0.661476016,
-0.4066350758,
-0.4491595924,
-0.0475493148,
0.0296623912,
-0.4182513356,
0.7640476823,
-0.8447580338,
-0.2792538404,
-0.1477539241,
-0.6592304707,
-0.0406311639,
-0.3560945988,
-0.6661989093,
0.9906071424,
0.1037883013,
-0.4771648943,
0.3703436553,
-0.6873220205,
-0.7032573223,
-0.093052946,
0.2948049605,
-0.3736062348,
0.3929183185,
0.2175571769,
0.456420809,
-0.3516404331,
0.2447057664,
0.0744014606,
-0.6539962292,
-0.1726212502,
-0.5224292278,
0.1325455159,
0.3878041804,
-0.1496830881,
-0.0186866689,
-0.6730905175,
0.0722220913,
-0.2367820889,
-0.0955642834,
-0.7189918756,
0.1577668339,
-0.3380015194,
-0.1444873512,
-0.2174392492,
-0.1776962429,
0.3302850723,
-0.587857604,
0.3982153535,
0.6237916946,
-0.0570558943,
0.5427116752,
-0.0296516232,
0.3364924788,
0.0701679587,
0.2899098992,
-0.6931830049,
-0.404201299,
-0.9403631091,
-0.3622229695,
0.5986311436,
0.0210626293,
-0.4768208861,
0.240387097,
-0.4584027231,
-0.5100575686,
-0.509528935,
0.2332970351,
0.569075644,
0.6741353869,
0.6232521534,
-0.3831109107,
-0.280349493,
-0.9060431123,
-0.4586606324,
0.2264917344,
0.2699486911,
0.1795535982,
0.1666428447,
0.0693555996,
0.7631819248,
-0.8176010251,
0.1763995886,
0.1359999478,
0.3439328372,
0.3489690423,
0.6612940431,
0.2695572972,
-0.9285744429,
-0.3283399343,
-0.4345875382,
0.1384551823,
-0.0279715806,
-0.0473704673,
-0.2316197604,
0.1999875456,
0.6913611293,
-0.4474952817,
0.4183080792,
0.4953310788,
-0.2901161015,
0.2883886993,
-0.3799990714,
-0.2184803784,
-1.1131584644,
0.2004665136,
-0.1186655387,
-0.5018179417,
-0.7865875959,
0.169582203,
0.4134040475,
-0.1551437527,
-0.5467770696,
0.7558685541,
-0.6238508821,
-0.0237555709,
-0.3992099464,
-0.2246152014,
-0.0465506576,
0.5008171201,
0.2052989304,
0.8179751039,
0.7209051847,
-0.9899582267,
0.0984417424,
0.097259447,
-0.4072990716,
0.2701363564,
-0.416162312,
0.2977510393,
-0.3540760577,
0.0454361252,
-0.6578994989,
-0.0669886544,
0.0255282428,
-0.28730762,
0.6565992236,
-0.3090375364,
-0.3789930046,
-0.2773899734,
-0.0501107201,
0.9583244324,
0.9345124364,
-0.6262985468,
0.1864053458,
-0.1016480178,
-0.1023412794,
-0.4647186697,
-0.2589085102,
-0.0171028655,
-0.4824396074,
-0.2649151981,
0.5169647336,
-0.0588730685,
0.2335363626,
-0.158163175,
-0.2145693153,
0.0207426175,
0.2568075657,
0.3328451216,
-0.3656117916,
-0.2608587742,
0.543309927,
0.1816387028,
-0.5071238875,
-0.2799114287,
-0.4931949973,
0.5793355703,
0.1758473516,
-0.380528152,
-0.1863493472,
0.48744753,
0.4044249952,
-0.4254076481,
0.5572366714,
0.408523947,
-0.0852281898,
-0.7530352473,
-0.6109902263,
-0.3699352443,
-0.5812336802,
0.2745490968,
-0.3071979582,
-0.8185355663,
0.2051564902,
-0.504198432,
-0.2228108644,
0.3586942852,
0.1604480892,
0.0796310827,
0.7682492137,
0.9156084657,
-0.1438732296,
0.3721518219,
-0.0037839231,
0.0773173943,
-0.7457048297,
0.011550881,
-0.5254408121,
-0.2967076898,
-0.3718295395,
-0.6779922247,
0.4411473274,
0.3772559762,
-0.3372601271,
0.3578144014,
-0.2871555984,
0.7037998438,
0.715903163,
0.1024891734,
0.0673608184,
-0.1172933504,
0.1023700684,
0.1842711568,
-0.6633332968,
0.0885765925,
0.6316366196,
0.2432207018,
0.8146231771,
-0.1218336523,
0.7789068818,
0.1415833533,
-0.0277793258,
-0.842911303,
0.4502705932,
-0.1911105812,
-0.3619148731,
-0.6058662534,
-0.2421785146,
-1.0792934895,
-0.1135041341,
0.1305897534,
-0.6229507923,
0.1528243273,
0.3613659441,
-0.4463435113,
0.1304833442,
-0.5174768567,
0.7798721194,
-0.1367983669,
-0.5019853115,
-0.5852215886,
-0.7116982341,
0.1106187031,
-0.5808548331,
0.0101980343,
-0.1200699285,
-0.2874670923,
0.6786777377,
-0.4411420524,
0.7235676646,
-0.1258608848,
-0.0852250382,
-0.0598817468,
-0.0166105591,
0.5712270737,
0.0732786506,
-0.4887528419,
-0.1110788509,
-0.2552473247,
-0.4389337897,
-0.7250612974,
0.7271575928,
-0.4481110275,
-0.8414676189,
-0.1423270255,
-0.4725191593,
-0.346314311,
0.4605182111,
0.0939482972,
0.6027809381,
-0.0603851937,
0.050492581,
0.8092994094,
-0.0391005501,
0.8246805072,
0.5709776282,
0.0814078003,
-0.2282480299,
0.7058382034,
-0.0763731673,
0.3415446281,
0.3757459819,
0.1265766174,
-0.2782132328,
-0.6773340106,
-0.4304617047,
0.3873684406,
-0.5424222946,
-0.3722321093,
-0.1940006912,
-0.209667936,
0.0313989036,
-0.1293796897,
-0.5479845405,
-0.3088574409,
-0.4327114522,
0.0751368329,
0.6909211278,
0.37728706,
-0.1409781575,
0.6540503502,
-0.7937237024,
0.457216531,
0.3436879218,
0.8654631972,
0.0601569153,
-0.5951984525,
-0.3940300047,
-0.0696688294,
-0.0698311031,
-0.748375833,
0.4094675779,
0.7540905476,
0.1977543235,
0.4788904488,
0.1609175056,
1.274977088,
-0.9239712954,
0.5358886123,
-0.0558318123,
-1.1744670868,
0.5831823349,
-0.3229034245,
0.5472901464,
0.6288999915,
0.6315405965,
-0.5358350277,
-0.0613939352,
-0.4149790406,
-0.9323689938,
0.7930781841,
0.0440494977,
0.4270072281,
-0.2264293581,
0.9548760056,
0.3392217159,
0.0762307569,
0.016938094,
-0.3508146405,
0.1979815662,
0.3945227563,
-0.7723340392,
-0.4689250886,
0.06965933,
-0.5400195718,
0.6061403155,
-0.2179125696,
0.2356750071,
0.0153301042,
-0.1263656467,
-0.027980024,
0.1832900047,
0.7800218463,
0.7365474701,
-0.0643100962,
0.2814627886,
0.2350290269,
-0.3367430866,
0.040353097,
0.0032872728,
-0.0982243866,
0.0793233588,
0.0448808968,
1.2191830873,
0.5308167934,
-0.160024479,
0.4679129422,
0.2717632651,
0.058452446,
-0.056893345,
0.1507066041,
0.26240924,
-0.0188046824,
0.2547431886,
-0.1215041205,
0.0633750781,
-0.4741757512,
0.3539452851,
0.1498409361,
-0.3587765396,
-0.5068261027,
0.680367589,
0.1497907341,
-0.3980113864,
0.9213902354,
-0.0762389228,
-0.2592619061,
0.6081277728,
0.8721185923,
0.7977427244,
-0.4285012186,
-0.079435505,
0.1946059167,
-0.0971393883,
-0.2979490459,
0.4473271072,
-0.4967161417,
-0.2182712257,
-0.7550920844,
-0.9172796011,
-0.0856426135,
-0.045168642,
-0.7779924273,
0.4579368532,
-0.1197939515,
-0.2534205616,
0.1713359505,
-0.4372957051,
-0.586638093,
0.2402544469,
0.353513658,
1.4360814095,
-0.802153945,
1.1914092302,
0.37425524,
0.2457296848,
-0.85758394,
-0.0225050971,
-0.4972217679,
-0.6411591172,
0.8590974212,
0.0896641985,
-0.2248381376,
0.5023982525,
-0.1298012882,
-1.2084671259,
0.751110673,
0.5126979947,
-0.4804813862,
-0.0993762091,
0.1621450782,
0.4247124493,
0.3140709698,
0.0815677643,
0.5140252709,
0.6068305373,
0.1468874961,
-1.1743423939,
0.0327831246,
0.0127153229,
0.1371165067,
0.9140811563,
-0.8252552748,
0.4763337672,
-0.0840155408,
-0.2613588572,
0.1933496445,
0.7961226106,
-0.414008081,
0.2087962925,
0.5816760659,
0.6379005909,
0.6795392036,
-0.1657671779,
0.7883859873,
-0.5453476906,
0.0193506032,
0.961863935,
0.0464635193,
0.9046621919,
0.6636257768,
0.1753045768,
0.2010119706,
0.5483658314,
0.205011189,
0.8225956559,
0.5879879594,
-0.1713607162,
-0.4691646993,
-0.0734743699,
-0.4015285671,
0.4576119184,
0.4626907706,
-0.277472049,
-0.3287062943,
0.0913511738,
0.0067918822,
-0.1544982642,
-0.7451123595,
0.7715040445,
0.3118156493,
-1.1385376453,
0.9044511318,
0.1517487615,
0.4743508399,
-0.9081907272,
-0.0134073459,
-0.2678442895,
0.0912130326,
-0.1364830136,
-0.4473870993,
0.3749876022,
-0.3260874748,
-0.2231419533,
-0.4574256241,
0.4561354816,
-0.3540806174,
-0.1196171045,
0.0887413621,
0.3048572838,
0.2344285995,
-0.0253065377,
-0.1874872446,
0.0189856924,
-0.4237153232,
-0.335940659,
0.3966526091,
0.0953218043,
-0.2842380702,
0.5900719762,
0.5583548546,
0.2570708692,
0.2271609306,
-0.1410807222,
0.9912813902,
-0.9131832719,
-0.7498177886,
-1.001535058,
0.3514749408,
0.2367035449,
-0.3077476025,
0.7455109358,
0.7811351418,
0.5886647701,
-0.1882352829,
0.2048687488,
0.3975173831,
0.2558431029,
-0.7206155062,
0.4770795703,
-0.5619219542,
0.0659271553,
-0.0221093558,
-1.0489301682,
-0.5362061858,
-0.082280919,
-0.2225659043,
-0.0543745458,
0.5250630975,
0.9867917299,
-0.432095319,
-0.0336927623,
0.4108090699,
-0.0760217234,
-0.1197222844,
0.6603338122,
0.701177001,
-0.2030933946,
-0.0098269871,
-0.2373118848,
0.102908805,
-0.2181176394,
-1.3823792934,
-0.6007729769,
-0.7712237239,
-0.2032477856,
0.0245542713,
0.6883248687,
0.8056352139,
1.0511438847,
-0.5023467541,
-0.033304628,
-0.0456906743,
0.0309904981,
-0.3099758029,
-0.055613324,
0.7374798059,
-0.578468442,
-0.8293712735,
0.7417083979,
0.2249759734,
-0.1977127939,
0.039802365,
-0.1058937609,
0.1325763762,
0.2569585741,
0.6155779362,
0.7199730873,
-0.5270289779,
-0.3109484315,
-0.1897813827,
0.1684051603,
0.1547731608,
0.8530151844,
-1.0482863188,
0.5446740985,
0.3761031032,
0.657521069,
0.7800050378,
0.2698762119,
0.6508604884,
-1.0414675474,
0.2832435966,
0.2755556405,
0.0348977447,
-0.0039024376,
-0.2699435055,
0.3407518864,
-0.0888493955,
-0.4638219476,
-0.7927958965,
0.3318058252,
-0.9282940626,
-0.2495317757,
1.2588465214,
0.109340556,
-0.213760823,
0.1132171527,
-0.0641999021,
0.4412680268,
-0.2141103446,
0.536988318,
0.2502572238,
-0.0551264584,
-0.0031125881,
-0.3916590512,
1.0399769545,
0.5983365178,
-0.444945097,
0.0579116717,
0.1869144887,
0.2084892839,
-0.0615208447,
0.3175823092,
0.1941655725,
0.3991092741,
-0.349146992,
-0.335653156,
-0.5435273051,
-0.6742388606,
-0.6249167323,
0.0434995703,
0.4432362616,
-0.0752817839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12084v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12084v2 | Revisiting Entropy Rate Constancy in Text | 2023-05-20T03:48:31 | 2023-10-18T01:02:56 | Vivek Verma, Nicholas Tomlin, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL | The uniform information density (UID) hypothesis states that humans tend to
distribute information roughly evenly across an utterance or discourse. Early
evidence in support of the UID hypothesis came from Genzel & Charniak (2002),
which proposed an entropy rate constancy principle based on the probability of
English text under n-gram language models. We re-evaluate the claims of Genzel
& Charniak (2002) with neural language models, failing to find clear evidence
in support of entropy rate constancy. We conduct a range of experiments across
datasets, model sizes, and languages and discuss implications for the uniform
information density hypothesis and linguistic theories of efficient
communication more broadly. | [
-0.2347789556,
-0.7272940278,
0.6941782832,
0.2342319041,
-0.1433812827,
-0.1917472035,
-0.2132550627,
-0.3382281959,
0.311722368,
0.0744362697,
-0.0762864575,
-0.3294992149,
-0.3644452989,
-0.0823527798,
-0.5506567955,
0.5708885193,
0.1288217902,
0.1936439276,
-0.2683266997,
-0.1420133263,
-0.2445022613,
-0.7773469687,
-0.8132705092,
-0.6630920172,
0.6562260389,
0.4537293315,
0.8162139654,
0.532594502,
0.5676745772,
0.2246017754,
0.0318989567,
-0.2662670314,
-0.2595129311,
0.4430010319,
-0.034764342,
-0.5241615176,
0.0118894922,
0.0596536808,
0.8847910166,
1.0456066132,
-0.7002655864,
-0.3803610206,
0.3566161394,
0.8793740273,
-0.7123062611,
-0.3414068222,
-0.3894382417,
-0.0820242167,
-0.2621050775,
-0.4432319403,
-0.6574336886,
-0.3931293488,
0.2236145437,
-0.5651163459,
0.4533828795,
-0.109334968,
0.641941607,
0.1698699147,
-0.4434645772,
-0.1468916535,
-0.7601801753,
0.5873944759,
-0.5851287842,
0.5162210464,
0.7563360333,
-0.2198487371,
-0.1390641779,
-0.612161994,
-0.8968936205,
-0.2649489939,
0.042549368,
0.0426295251,
-0.3306768239,
0.214779377,
0.4548639059,
0.2563036084,
-0.6926239133,
0.0942604765,
-0.0727465302,
0.065608792,
0.6281184554,
0.1134858057,
0.4638218284,
0.0667957515,
-0.2427992374,
-0.2612543702,
-0.3786998093,
0.1578740776,
0.5471471548,
-0.2905984819,
-0.2761879563,
0.6005674601,
-0.4129140079,
0.3201740384,
0.0871808827,
0.1588963419,
0.2979635,
-0.4808499217,
-0.3068852127,
0.1925541759,
0.8865948319,
0.5202690363,
0.281821698,
-0.3903435767,
0.0827842578,
0.005289231,
0.1590321213,
-0.7070599198,
-0.3025088906,
0.1692083776,
-0.6264432073,
-0.0226304289,
0.2732313573,
-0.4773492813,
-0.5684378147,
-0.1390638351,
0.13019979,
-0.7111884952,
-0.5280433297,
0.3042344451,
-0.7055246234,
0.1327338815,
0.2235540748,
-1.2593793869,
0.101920642,
0.6211529374,
0.6995377541,
-0.4072213769,
-0.3290229142,
0.1828312725,
0.071391128,
-0.5997740626,
1.0258829594,
-0.4409321249,
-0.2135364413,
-0.1509159505,
-0.2590050697,
-0.1498026699,
-0.3492698967,
0.6636730433,
-0.2136775702,
-0.0944190845,
-0.2772813141,
-0.8093765378,
-0.0561847761,
-0.0365851074,
-0.6111143231,
0.8309956193,
0.084020339,
-1.2896025181,
0.7449430823,
-0.3402774632,
-0.3887343109,
0.0976138115,
-0.2518000901,
-0.0224631,
0.43456617,
-0.6256480813,
0.3223856091,
-0.2638683319,
0.4290058613,
-0.5556163192,
-0.2535436749,
0.6555004716,
-1.0239595175,
0.9178962111,
0.6496721506,
-0.3128718138,
-0.5980495214,
-0.7417917848,
0.3145099878,
-0.313346833,
-0.6648833156,
-1.0307334661,
0.3909666538,
0.0768437386,
-0.3627224267,
0.0185953751,
-0.828810811,
0.278134048,
-0.1063530296,
0.1574124992,
0.5513383746,
-0.0830809623,
0.7224218249,
-0.4301898777,
0.1745432466,
-0.1330685318,
-0.1510699987,
0.0404768959,
-0.6846933961,
-0.3911033869,
-0.3703351915,
0.295659095,
0.4784130156,
-0.6480157375,
0.1983019561,
-0.2575572729,
-0.4012967348,
-0.5709956288,
0.0207968466,
0.3397780657,
0.2189434171,
0.0113128778,
-0.481253922,
-0.5540511608,
-0.9789982438,
-0.4131915569,
-0.6924114227,
-0.2814938426,
-0.0677530095,
0.0758450329,
-0.2313630581,
0.9580690265,
-0.2913563848,
0.4218786359,
-0.0484661162,
0.4766204953,
-0.010544884,
0.7091702223,
0.3088301122,
-0.8846724629,
-0.5568127632,
0.1428851932,
-0.9292043447,
-0.273316443,
0.0176000446,
-0.0867493376,
0.4061995745,
0.7556499839,
-0.6144646406,
0.8773053885,
0.4328661859,
-0.6325950623,
0.262111336,
-0.4984072745,
0.2817634642,
-1.0623021126,
-0.0616275519,
0.1885210723,
-0.0284409057,
-0.8864299655,
-0.1378940493,
0.1792327613,
0.6021160483,
-0.1220342889,
0.4883810282,
-0.2529985905,
0.1596114933,
-0.3947581649,
-0.1119738445,
-0.1386848092,
0.0137831513,
-0.0537784658,
0.6157982349,
0.3006439507,
-0.632312417,
0.261872828,
-0.1744402647,
-0.6915069222,
1.0445356369,
-0.7128710151,
-0.2200210541,
-0.40292117,
0.3203398883,
-1.3070137501,
-0.3699791133,
-0.2161473185,
-0.4453655481,
0.1155634224,
0.2227271348,
-0.5584084392,
-0.0536837466,
-0.3541194201,
0.6215131879,
0.6280123591,
-0.3401590288,
0.2541610003,
0.4971395433,
-0.1499106586,
-0.3935989141,
-0.9828434587,
0.0655849203,
-0.1413429677,
-0.9148668647,
0.2452320606,
-0.6590226293,
-0.8863034248,
-0.2153721452,
-0.0136346947,
-0.435090065,
0.4159196019,
0.2679375708,
-0.2200718075,
-0.1610006839,
0.322276175,
-0.2978055477,
0.1210192591,
-0.0312513858,
-0.1818234473,
0.6103095412,
0.4634242356,
-0.3479784429,
-0.8374951482,
0.4808476865,
0.4008470178,
0.6528252363,
0.9067032933,
0.3151902258,
-0.3427500725,
0.0949702337,
-0.7776522636,
-0.1316493005,
-0.3947516978,
0.2071295679,
-0.3362323046,
-0.5533618331,
0.5306589603,
0.2094620317,
-0.2214505076,
0.5170986056,
0.2962962389,
-0.4520483911,
0.9946830869,
0.8017965555,
0.0252464395,
0.6144929528,
-0.1441919506,
0.0995453373,
-0.8703197837,
-0.2679364979,
-0.8930340409,
-0.3081310391,
-0.7736554146,
-0.0042033955,
-0.113308683,
0.400285244,
-0.3539325595,
-0.0828524828,
-0.3051821589,
0.6178305149,
0.8157071471,
0.0290028714,
0.178268224,
0.1269535273,
-0.2389791161,
0.0583240129,
-0.7600207925,
-0.2657323182,
1.000970602,
0.2749718726,
1.1777865887,
0.1272881329,
0.5236489177,
0.5620017052,
0.1223688722,
-0.3062259555,
0.2322149277,
-0.359823972,
-0.5037893057,
-0.4087256491,
-0.4888397753,
-1.1084580421,
0.0465418659,
0.1109174639,
-0.8757368922,
0.8032998443,
0.0910065472,
-0.0640136003,
0.2588227689,
-1.2133951187,
0.5428423285,
0.1045263261,
-0.0026301723,
-0.070788525,
-0.3706348538,
0.442124486,
-0.1264692843,
0.2060521096,
-0.1567281485,
0.0883367583,
1.0047008991,
-0.4921427369,
0.6801003814,
-0.0372047536,
-0.3467012048,
0.3432469964,
-0.1095743775,
0.3397491276,
0.1981056184,
-0.3688813746,
0.2132736593,
0.0015045893,
-0.431332767,
-0.4553160965,
0.5287398696,
-0.7657176852,
-0.1846163273,
-0.41055125,
-0.74319911,
0.432749778,
-0.1166956201,
0.7318482995,
0.4799742997,
-0.283952564,
0.6589661837,
0.7802652717,
0.0251582842,
0.5709295273,
0.4788973927,
0.2831603885,
-0.2095241249,
0.5814976692,
0.4080245793,
0.6291576624,
0.2106895149,
0.0174612291,
-0.0999925062,
-0.3028753996,
0.0941304937,
-0.201898694,
-0.615018785,
-0.0176331382,
-0.7131303549,
-0.3706106842,
-0.4449887872,
-0.2897230089,
-0.231069833,
-0.4383107424,
0.0560828596,
-0.0928316414,
0.352978617,
0.7607278824,
-0.427195251,
0.3601752818,
-0.141100049,
0.4526614845,
0.2460936755,
0.3701466918,
-0.0337520875,
-0.5878719091,
-0.1778346598,
0.6905788183,
-0.1485880017,
-0.5512962341,
0.1401045322,
0.2873832285,
0.7874853611,
0.4987798035,
0.2065410763,
0.2714698613,
-0.4022859633,
0.7868083715,
0.4963093996,
-0.6324796677,
0.1133176759,
-0.1233708933,
0.4233385623,
0.3770210445,
0.2514492869,
-0.8972277045,
-0.8068595529,
-0.8313572407,
-0.758841157,
0.3463473022,
0.2081020623,
0.2193112373,
-0.2958864272,
0.5085319877,
0.2646891475,
-0.064888984,
-0.4723330736,
-0.407073468,
0.0181187429,
-0.4745064974,
-0.1611288786,
-0.6277127266,
0.0638714582,
-0.2861042023,
0.3068259656,
-0.0247166641,
0.5470499992,
0.5163112879,
0.0010374753,
-0.0965090841,
0.4234331548,
0.8366161585,
0.7816352844,
-0.1860474497,
0.6306145787,
-0.1284603626,
-0.9651992321,
0.5385104418,
-0.1410171688,
-0.691429317,
0.1360986829,
0.3235122859,
0.6932374835,
0.051063031,
-0.2484507263,
0.3789469302,
-0.4926405549,
-0.4244190753,
-0.3285657465,
0.3657161295,
0.1291495413,
0.2965034246,
0.6798185706,
0.2896738648,
0.0571903847,
-0.7387027144,
0.335973233,
0.7812727094,
-0.1846152693,
-0.4298123121,
0.6763353348,
-0.0681509972,
-0.3513022959,
0.7149819136,
-0.1848128885,
-0.1166711003,
0.7238084674,
0.464356631,
0.9576306939,
-0.4517311454,
0.4261122942,
0.1251901537,
0.3472341597,
-0.5990456343,
0.467019707,
0.0713479742,
-0.957030654,
-0.2867518961,
-0.3393913507,
-0.0925792605,
-0.2371301204,
-0.6306551099,
-0.0436351337,
-0.2485364377,
-0.3655053079,
0.3430951238,
-0.1796354204,
-0.5525714159,
0.0180586223,
0.1588198245,
1.0546498299,
-0.6300641894,
0.9926171899,
0.0831312239,
-0.2847382426,
-0.7717725635,
0.2057914287,
-0.1982148439,
-0.6361253858,
0.7495833635,
-0.1862633675,
0.1657563299,
0.1241002902,
-1.0936669111,
-0.8736201525,
0.9836425781,
0.5061966777,
-0.3545341194,
0.2355507314,
-0.0299347118,
0.5377348661,
-0.4769302905,
0.3876926899,
0.5863904357,
0.4434129894,
-0.0179576054,
-0.8756427765,
-0.1908745468,
-0.4044210315,
0.2140978873,
-0.0070580901,
-0.3508150578,
0.9852523208,
-0.437071234,
-0.3314402401,
0.2730508149,
0.6249521971,
-0.0055143866,
0.6667200327,
0.3307097554,
0.8077958226,
1.0367836952,
-0.1211062446,
1.5045104027,
-0.1260139942,
0.1660198867,
0.6973633766,
-0.2469190955,
0.9863096476,
0.6294355392,
-0.0862616003,
0.7394345403,
0.5398577452,
0.3740552068,
0.7479034066,
0.3303405643,
-0.44458583,
0.1531817764,
-0.4284552634,
-0.3794179857,
0.1652861536,
0.0226155743,
-0.1363764703,
0.1898060292,
0.1139774173,
0.0143879205,
-0.0679364502,
-0.1491086185,
0.8179145455,
0.006936674,
-0.740093708,
0.8005747199,
-0.0751947537,
0.7435185313,
-0.4852197766,
0.0674358159,
-0.6606158614,
0.1683368832,
-0.1224647164,
-1.0424257517,
0.0673389211,
-0.0717816353,
-0.6049895883,
-0.1702661514,
0.6188585758,
-0.7581678033,
-0.125657469,
-0.0361605138,
0.0152192293,
0.3340834677,
0.0718489662,
-0.2927546501,
-0.0021760573,
0.0593021736,
-0.1848334074,
0.3039484322,
0.9147700667,
0.1170925871,
0.8344062567,
0.5674436688,
0.123606123,
0.3046292365,
-0.1059808135,
0.4170226455,
-0.5614456534,
-0.6184975505,
-1.0252285004,
0.4586010873,
-0.2941183746,
-0.2418881059,
0.9065119028,
0.4761572182,
0.7727068663,
0.1738589704,
1.0293287039,
-0.2491166294,
0.2893170416,
-0.6003385782,
0.8017440438,
-0.2690522373,
0.1134366393,
-0.3973255754,
-0.8319901228,
-0.1106956154,
0.7335488796,
0.1312146187,
0.1214084476,
1.1924278736,
0.3549895585,
0.1631142348,
0.0876187906,
0.3486192226,
0.3850355744,
0.1807949394,
0.1655397266,
0.7978289723,
-0.3321971297,
0.2323405743,
-0.2499753982,
-0.087150611,
-0.2392684668,
-0.7797743678,
-0.3657171428,
-0.9110044837,
-0.4499824047,
-0.5826020837,
0.0768206418,
0.5675852299,
0.6055225134,
-0.3492283523,
-0.349149853,
-0.4221709371,
0.1833413541,
-0.0778255612,
-0.2483259737,
0.288081795,
-0.3527223468,
-0.2421324253,
0.0454071127,
0.2234841138,
0.3621124625,
0.0921912715,
-0.4090209603,
-0.2323562354,
0.3532578051,
0.2457873672,
0.4809783995,
-0.3858848214,
-0.4082707763,
-0.1196569949,
-0.8915421367,
-0.1045388132,
0.7452626228,
-0.5861573815,
0.332662046,
0.8406959772,
0.4111548066,
-0.133274734,
0.0924766213,
0.8603671193,
-0.7228210568,
0.5012125969,
-0.2808324695,
0.2523560822,
0.3616528809,
-0.3125746846,
0.5480408072,
0.4413233399,
-0.6804212332,
-0.9599715471,
0.0392985456,
-0.845053494,
-0.2264309824,
1.3506463766,
-0.0611953996,
-0.3386508524,
-0.2717511654,
-0.0908060074,
-0.0297408197,
-0.4647365212,
0.9729431272,
1.0123161077,
0.1203173995,
0.0137307458,
-0.8016021252,
0.6687353849,
0.2546407878,
-0.6761181951,
0.2159279287,
0.2678359449,
0.2293355018,
0.256560266,
1.2345569134,
0.5618853569,
0.3152524531,
0.1499557048,
0.3237455785,
0.7156109214,
-0.059535943,
-0.1358489245,
-0.0702067167,
-0.0360965654,
-0.0778800547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12077v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12077v2 | Few-Shot Dialogue Summarization via Skeleton-Assisted Prompt Transfer in Prompt Tuning | 2023-05-20T03:32:48 | 2024-02-27T02:51:16 | Kaige Xie, Tong Yu, Haoliang Wang, Junda Wu, Handong Zhao, Ruiyi Zhang, Kanak Mahadik, Ani Nenkova, Mark Riedl | cs.CL | cs.CL | In real-world scenarios, labeled samples for dialogue summarization are
usually limited (i.e., few-shot) due to high annotation costs for high-quality
dialogue summaries. To efficiently learn from few-shot samples, previous works
have utilized massive annotated data from other downstream tasks and then
performed prompt transfer in prompt tuning so as to enable cross-task knowledge
transfer. However, existing general-purpose prompt transfer techniques lack
consideration for dialogue-specific information. In this paper, we focus on
improving the prompt transfer from dialogue state tracking to dialogue
summarization and propose Skeleton-Assisted Prompt Transfer (SAPT), which
leverages skeleton generation as extra supervision that functions as a medium
connecting the distinct source and target task and resulting in the model's
better consumption of dialogue state information. To automatically extract
dialogue skeletons as supervised training data for skeleton generation, we
design a novel approach with perturbation-based probes requiring neither
annotation effort nor domain knowledge. Training the model on such skeletons
can also help preserve model capability during prompt transfer. Our method
significantly outperforms existing baselines. In-depth analyses demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method in facilitating cross-task knowledge transfer in
few-shot dialogue summarization. | [
-0.2742968202,
-0.4688522518,
0.5384563804,
0.1917156726,
-0.6927697659,
0.0466793813,
0.0445320271,
-0.4072097242,
0.2823771238,
0.4608924091,
-0.9256539345,
-0.3926354051,
-0.4364095032,
0.1829635501,
-0.0081283795,
1.3397754431,
0.2021099776,
-0.0598308817,
0.0992747024,
0.0519791245,
-0.593354702,
-0.3032889068,
-0.7121717334,
-0.1670981646,
0.57526052,
0.4343402386,
0.1431770921,
0.4183688462,
0.258795023,
0.1259067357,
-0.0005199212,
0.0274216719,
-0.4490529299,
0.1108895689,
-0.2228484452,
-0.5857371092,
-0.5980371237,
-0.2403442115,
0.493828088,
0.6156798005,
0.3368605375,
0.3434543014,
0.1107272655,
0.2182365656,
-0.4681576788,
0.4921523929,
-0.4719074368,
0.0023706853,
-0.0943428501,
-0.4458696842,
-0.3159835339,
-0.5043213367,
0.3723113835,
-0.7696346045,
0.3284196258,
0.1064518616,
0.493748039,
0.4018244445,
-0.3917019963,
0.094031401,
-0.3888424039,
0.4997517169,
-0.7112576962,
-0.2368578613,
0.4310923815,
0.4862844348,
0.0366164595,
-0.6153674722,
-0.3452174366,
-0.1617882848,
-0.1449189484,
0.2150100321,
0.0792657658,
0.2907385528,
0.4628452063,
-0.2028408945,
-0.384452492,
-0.0208556503,
-0.3035956025,
-0.5283004045,
0.5875045657,
0.4112495482,
0.3343174756,
-0.510242939,
-0.4543798268,
-0.2898208499,
-0.7164358497,
0.1729563475,
0.1782497019,
0.7112893462,
-0.1653428376,
0.5579870939,
-0.3544037342,
0.652926445,
0.2169807702,
-0.3697308898,
-0.1036641002,
-0.7037146091,
0.0691530108,
0.5590920448,
0.4144303799,
0.620654583,
0.1537829638,
0.1002479717,
-0.0046026791,
-0.2126086652,
0.0241027158,
-0.8330565095,
-0.5259665847,
-0.2524313331,
-0.3052947521,
-0.0905789658,
-0.3641327024,
-0.7765805125,
-0.4466735125,
-0.2075443268,
0.5147534609,
-0.4028747976,
-0.0343174338,
-0.2379632294,
-0.4026811719,
0.1038768515,
0.8605986238,
-1.0087766647,
0.1720377356,
0.2980457246,
0.9781222343,
-0.1587766111,
0.0166018978,
-0.8114819527,
0.3650074601,
-0.1332541704,
1.1280901432,
-0.2997762263,
-0.4016489089,
-0.2167453319,
-0.0362247713,
-0.1788738966,
-0.2178719491,
0.1888548881,
0.1734163612,
0.1069497913,
-0.3349100053,
-0.2458875328,
-0.1405313909,
0.1434785277,
-0.2979342937,
0.82475245,
0.3588801026,
-0.6320716739,
0.3978778422,
-0.3200832307,
-0.6015487909,
0.0010197706,
-0.0782490447,
0.1075066105,
0.1774523556,
0.6271207333,
0.4882899523,
-0.2347203046,
-0.0589892007,
-0.1977682412,
-0.2438525259,
-0.0976914167,
-0.2973105311,
0.6967375278,
-0.1041744202,
-0.0845267177,
0.0994163156,
-0.7333733439,
-0.1992238462,
-0.2525830865,
-0.0052571516,
-0.3338994682,
-0.5867061615,
-0.1661888808,
0.2512757778,
-0.0583364628,
-0.4714937806,
0.5832939744,
-0.4884678423,
-0.0558205694,
0.6345533729,
0.4885843992,
0.661580205,
-0.6491644382,
0.6879586577,
-0.2006534934,
-0.1389727741,
-0.5891676545,
-0.3689441681,
-0.4536311924,
-0.5134974718,
0.2906362116,
0.7870265841,
-0.8985313773,
0.2777397037,
-0.048094295,
-0.4380198717,
-0.5092818737,
-0.0375321954,
0.1629269719,
0.9956535101,
0.4434322715,
-0.4697302282,
-0.4536135197,
-0.6948454976,
-0.3124163747,
-0.5403603911,
-0.2019566894,
0.4636487365,
0.1928025186,
0.5580086112,
1.1285324097,
-0.5447052717,
-0.4417915344,
-0.7850039005,
0.4938518405,
0.274658531,
0.7810044289,
0.6251531243,
-0.0635521337,
-0.5181055069,
-0.1711749136,
-0.4938257933,
-0.4283339381,
-0.5509214997,
-0.2056239545,
-0.2403346747,
0.3342926502,
-0.8058040142,
0.3500468731,
0.2173871994,
0.0636020377,
0.7147068977,
0.1814626455,
0.230466947,
-1.3714250326,
0.123455368,
-0.1396470219,
-0.4847430587,
-0.3652150333,
-0.7520880699,
-0.2018211931,
-0.1073598191,
-0.6020926833,
0.8033275008,
-0.3631309569,
-0.0579371378,
-0.2576598227,
0.3387935162,
-0.1612047553,
0.7611508965,
0.0512469076,
0.595906198,
0.689907074,
-0.5293081403,
0.4827769101,
0.6367563605,
-0.0844712853,
0.8715924621,
-0.4579038322,
0.3406190574,
-0.0272181444,
0.8343895078,
-1.2025133371,
-0.2136386931,
0.5494269729,
-0.4634338319,
0.4041428864,
-1.0574349165,
-0.2257983983,
0.2467751503,
-0.2801696062,
0.3192157149,
0.5622451305,
-0.3792189658,
0.6755161285,
-0.0807871073,
-0.8962988257,
-0.3747660816,
-0.5054324865,
-0.0733318031,
-0.3284709454,
-0.5544457436,
0.1382606477,
0.1189260334,
0.1326525658,
-0.2462474853,
-0.7014247775,
-0.0285087377,
-0.0788464397,
0.1747296602,
0.3843296468,
-0.3567371368,
0.1305756867,
0.6044146419,
-0.2835671604,
0.0215734448,
-0.4319052994,
0.328312248,
0.5962184668,
-0.1905286461,
-0.7790955901,
0.2374950349,
0.323559761,
0.0794445798,
0.4067932069,
0.5710176826,
-0.1113080308,
-0.1476418823,
-0.265209049,
-0.5522542,
-0.351372093,
0.2436285615,
-0.4373542666,
-0.6748549342,
0.5719971657,
-0.7075837255,
0.2496166229,
0.4337983131,
0.2407101691,
-0.2623812854,
1.167959094,
0.688182056,
-0.1785212457,
0.8717368245,
-0.0756472871,
-0.1305722296,
-0.9560399055,
0.0161081422,
-0.6860785484,
-0.3724780977,
0.0776999965,
-0.2239130288,
0.5064954162,
0.3253299892,
-0.0576963164,
0.5940816402,
-0.0389518514,
0.374982506,
0.2079011798,
0.0896220058,
0.4785437286,
-0.0748230815,
-0.1185005009,
0.003467082,
-0.9051238894,
-0.4012341499,
0.7119137049,
0.0554672107,
0.9664306641,
0.0102055287,
0.7542100549,
0.2774505913,
0.0531749949,
-0.7518174052,
0.5851062536,
0.1496237516,
-0.4008973539,
-0.3778594732,
-0.4271267056,
-0.6649374366,
0.2531836033,
-0.3131130934,
-1.1815383434,
0.2589134276,
0.3322041929,
-0.7736994624,
0.1413094103,
-0.6579704881,
0.545234859,
0.0370875262,
-0.202724278,
-0.172208488,
-1.1375408173,
0.3512987196,
0.0876731351,
-0.3741846979,
-0.4207140505,
0.1271361858,
0.5785044432,
-0.1668924093,
1.1651413441,
-0.3296833038,
-0.0846946836,
0.0644778013,
0.2784658372,
0.89578861,
0.4296242893,
0.2288914323,
-0.2608072162,
0.046714019,
-0.3268537521,
-0.8695747256,
0.2125102878,
-0.3639004529,
-0.5765596032,
-0.1994272768,
-0.5615825653,
-0.4393260479,
0.1402328461,
0.4660165012,
0.4945775867,
-0.1440898925,
-0.1539849788,
0.5767766833,
-0.1165867001,
0.4308156967,
0.3592875898,
0.0447496101,
-0.0605658926,
0.7612347603,
-0.0258991551,
0.3935071528,
0.3194009066,
0.0600404516,
-0.382771492,
-0.4764727354,
-0.9200509787,
0.1386727244,
-0.5781117082,
-0.5099723339,
-0.6844174862,
-0.1256875545,
-0.5999420285,
-0.3837961257,
-0.3550611436,
-0.8245956302,
-0.4531848729,
-0.0742403418,
0.5165362954,
0.2913083434,
0.0713565275,
0.5680416226,
-1.0839334726,
0.4288005233,
0.3596154451,
-0.046287626,
-0.251116991,
-0.7312295437,
-0.074277766,
-0.1465603858,
0.2081368715,
-0.9868866205,
0.2491176277,
0.2028038353,
0.4962576628,
0.0484723747,
0.4974258542,
0.7701361179,
-0.1155296713,
0.8512169719,
0.3558092713,
-0.9691699743,
0.680826664,
-0.3892036378,
0.559127152,
0.8248077631,
0.1129231453,
-0.4713691175,
-0.35638237,
-0.4224946499,
-0.8919906616,
1.2775045633,
0.1102986783,
0.0444793478,
0.3955466151,
0.1388527453,
0.3617144227,
0.0820570216,
-0.0638173595,
0.1185782254,
-0.1521592736,
-0.2114895582,
0.0003752901,
0.3794837594,
-0.1949866563,
-0.1422174126,
0.5267842412,
-0.7478325963,
0.0754746869,
0.4653587341,
-0.6339101791,
-0.1082511097,
0.3009134531,
0.5531156063,
0.333160162,
-0.1841007918,
-0.001371889,
0.6921791434,
-0.421993196,
0.2800057232,
0.1782167256,
0.0212745517,
-0.0180485509,
0.4573284686,
0.9996227026,
0.2615868747,
-0.3630650043,
0.4027298689,
-0.0401072912,
-0.0730316043,
0.0268188734,
0.2338282615,
-0.2668678761,
0.6282707453,
0.4077139199,
0.3719502985,
0.1445104927,
-0.3644125462,
0.0747615993,
0.0632860363,
-0.3274633288,
-0.5475751758,
0.3517254889,
0.44397825,
-0.0388571285,
0.5428405404,
0.2435105294,
-0.2886025608,
0.4359326661,
0.6239348054,
0.9902786016,
-0.0318089835,
0.3168895245,
0.3996929228,
0.2540858686,
-0.1294279695,
-0.0080263335,
-0.6413787603,
-0.3676009178,
-0.6938836575,
-0.3706402481,
-0.5687713623,
-0.255800426,
-0.6717703342,
0.2899458706,
-0.5540194511,
-0.0901873112,
-0.1877359003,
-0.1563280374,
-0.4977175891,
-0.107443288,
-0.0386751555,
0.8690184355,
-0.985611856,
0.7478931546,
0.6699499488,
-0.4965321124,
-0.7119359374,
0.1437637359,
0.1867531836,
-0.5724540949,
0.3589833975,
-0.0571984947,
-0.3197124004,
0.3651037514,
-0.5880423784,
-0.7571385503,
1.0172101259,
0.7286564112,
-0.5473391414,
-0.2901975513,
-0.3354097307,
0.3996236324,
-0.3504847586,
0.3653670847,
0.7045795321,
0.416983217,
0.3724955916,
-1.0706979036,
0.2316456884,
-0.0380966663,
-0.3440288305,
0.0645891726,
-0.6663910151,
0.4730414152,
-0.1762600541,
-0.2908427715,
0.3366215527,
0.5421438813,
0.2157023996,
0.2837663591,
0.4673586786,
0.0792361572,
0.5417063832,
0.0401158333,
0.8274496794,
-0.1798509657,
0.0620360933,
1.2407460213,
-0.3762557209,
0.3609602451,
0.3567854166,
0.139391005,
0.1884175688,
0.5293983221,
0.2102432698,
0.5754568577,
0.1390442848,
-0.3530302644,
-0.3917150497,
-0.3892736435,
-0.2411085516,
0.3826623261,
0.1792332679,
-0.1482755989,
-0.4922529161,
0.1676721424,
-0.1247930229,
-0.5139219165,
-0.2712378204,
1.3809862137,
0.1097490937,
-0.6922290921,
0.3305552304,
-0.5731076002,
0.3554675579,
-0.9359118342,
-0.4567775726,
-0.497151643,
-0.2305678576,
-0.1798865944,
-0.4934902787,
0.0669964924,
0.1109534428,
0.087103419,
-0.3899554312,
0.90895468,
-0.383171916,
-0.0238520261,
-0.118526414,
0.7797353268,
0.4607384503,
-0.0514839254,
-0.3017085195,
-0.3873850703,
0.0724080354,
-0.0912039876,
0.6484578252,
0.348775059,
-0.1352164596,
0.353843987,
0.657887578,
0.2323557585,
0.0469005741,
0.1338122636,
0.9895643592,
-0.748252511,
-0.6335406899,
-0.4186655879,
0.6332821846,
0.0108532906,
-0.7093474269,
0.6317068338,
0.2285167724,
0.5199780464,
0.0289658867,
0.9538893104,
-0.0821881369,
0.4086852074,
-0.7558004856,
0.5593492389,
-0.1896520704,
0.2407064438,
-0.5406295657,
-1.0303630829,
-0.1825606227,
0.6067121029,
0.0206808336,
-0.2018425614,
0.6506009698,
0.655426085,
-0.0704477429,
0.011145887,
0.2376473993,
0.0952103063,
0.1223669648,
0.4275743961,
0.8050447702,
-0.07079795,
0.6234498024,
-0.1563778222,
-0.1387074441,
-0.2728610337,
-0.7907984853,
-1.0414370298,
-0.4071467817,
-0.3235405385,
-0.1888161451,
0.1840211004,
1.2295942307,
0.8207108974,
-0.6470566392,
0.0117604164,
0.12974675,
-0.0426595621,
-0.2912164629,
-0.1465816051,
0.3889830112,
-0.4351123869,
-0.6474379301,
0.73418957,
0.3435529768,
0.2502758503,
0.0199191365,
0.2355704308,
-0.0440861769,
0.0450292118,
0.4121848941,
0.3732275367,
-0.3583191633,
-0.3929590285,
-0.1733139306,
-0.0202360116,
0.0598847717,
1.1200996637,
-1.0402561426,
0.4170756936,
0.7356770635,
0.6152365804,
0.880361557,
0.3862862885,
0.8064219356,
-1.2291067839,
0.1321485043,
0.3688142002,
0.0437487252,
0.1737149209,
-0.4269574881,
0.3702402413,
0.2996195853,
-0.0775773078,
-0.6728364229,
0.2492327392,
-1.2026507854,
-0.039022781,
0.9001780152,
-0.3423437178,
-0.0798161626,
-0.4219248593,
-0.8655084372,
0.6628261805,
-0.7320618629,
0.5400153399,
0.4455668926,
-0.5515838861,
-0.4844092727,
-0.3620426059,
0.7536075711,
0.510831058,
-0.9782035947,
0.0311017185,
0.5589382648,
0.1622603536,
-0.0526367277,
0.6406031251,
0.1624549329,
0.48712641,
0.2015250027,
-0.1609047949,
-0.0097844815,
-0.4058198929,
-0.4781229496,
0.0658401921,
-0.1916375309,
-0.2021936476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12074v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.12074v3 | DisCo: Distilled Student Models Co-training for Semi-supervised Text Mining | 2023-05-20T03:23:16 | 2023-10-20T02:11:16 | Weifeng Jiang, Qianren Mao, Chenghua Lin, Jianxin Li, Ting Deng, Weiyi Yang, Zheng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many text mining models are constructed by fine-tuning a large deep
pre-trained language model (PLM) in downstream tasks. However, a significant
challenge nowadays is maintaining performance when we use a lightweight model
with limited labelled samples. We present DisCo, a semi-supervised learning
(SSL) framework for fine-tuning a cohort of small student models generated from
a large PLM using knowledge distillation. Our key insight is to share
complementary knowledge among distilled student cohorts to promote their SSL
effectiveness. DisCo employs a novel co-training technique to optimize a cohort
of multiple small student models by promoting knowledge sharing among students
under diversified views: model views produced by different distillation
strategies and data views produced by various input augmentations. We evaluate
DisCo on both semi-supervised text classification and extractive summarization
tasks. Experimental results show that DisCo can produce student models that are
7.6 times smaller and 4.8 times faster in inference than the baseline PLMs
while maintaining comparable performance. We also show that DisCo-generated
student models outperform the similar-sized models elaborately tuned in
distinct tasks. | [
-0.2777219117,
-0.5654515624,
0.4441309273,
-0.1288238019,
-0.4593044817,
0.4720228612,
-0.1204928011,
-0.238350004,
-0.0038288941,
0.5404036641,
-0.7027863264,
-0.6021526456,
-0.2230532616,
0.236553371,
-0.5330005884,
1.1320650578,
0.3396025896,
0.0297781881,
-0.623624742,
0.0094970055,
-0.4690023363,
-0.7057512403,
-0.6183763742,
-0.4996538758,
0.2424006909,
0.5611775517,
0.2907659411,
0.1035773605,
0.2313413918,
0.2732632458,
-0.2620070279,
0.3411316574,
-0.8553087711,
-0.0080567375,
-0.2976403832,
-0.6702187657,
-0.0805612206,
0.0845913291,
0.076026313,
0.946256578,
-0.2735088766,
0.1585731059,
0.3974804878,
0.7625499964,
-0.4474952221,
0.0919336975,
-0.6614229083,
-0.0850475952,
-0.0629469752,
0.0705606341,
-0.8270202279,
-0.2674538195,
0.5041187406,
-0.5937703252,
0.7926270962,
0.0954564735,
0.8102279305,
0.3973088861,
-0.4441098869,
-0.1728545725,
-0.7006109953,
0.8737425804,
-0.4434961677,
0.1870190203,
0.194222495,
0.2263778895,
-0.0016106486,
-0.8258647323,
-0.2161970437,
0.0129053751,
-0.2372348011,
0.3388871551,
0.1801349372,
0.1589719951,
-0.0527093299,
0.5508498549,
-0.0431430489,
0.1924942732,
-0.4623382688,
-0.1586992145,
0.7104962468,
0.1381449997,
-0.015604903,
-0.0232582502,
-0.6467764378,
0.0963353142,
-0.3483548164,
0.0256790798,
0.432484597,
0.4236679673,
-0.3807133734,
0.5367044806,
-0.2207359225,
0.9143329859,
0.107045196,
0.1671105176,
-0.0821668208,
-0.5662676692,
-0.1636400521,
0.42089656,
0.6947659254,
0.1304397285,
0.2267331481,
-0.1221551299,
-0.0978600085,
0.1364921182,
0.0414686874,
-0.7429241538,
-1.1215826273,
-0.2353619337,
-0.1792930216,
-0.5901733637,
0.0336249396,
-0.8296971917,
-0.4829907119,
-0.5750125051,
0.3834762275,
-0.2284974903,
-0.2006416172,
0.3365238309,
-0.5479274392,
-0.5623330474,
0.5547323227,
-0.7704436183,
0.4797171652,
0.4254328609,
0.8788210154,
-0.3156576455,
0.0669197589,
-0.5626250505,
0.2537686527,
-0.1476528794,
0.5059190989,
-0.3760063648,
-0.4124644399,
-0.1633873284,
-0.4092853963,
0.0962916836,
-0.5606151819,
0.3158512115,
-0.5568528771,
0.2367125154,
-0.1669831574,
-0.798879087,
0.0032865924,
-0.0758971944,
-0.9229325056,
1.1397565603,
0.1300005913,
-0.9099917412,
0.5462042093,
-0.1939712763,
-0.336676836,
0.1545826644,
-0.1419836432,
-0.6058323383,
0.3036175072,
0.0542461798,
0.5715876818,
-0.1393819004,
0.4790299833,
-0.3709448576,
-0.249488771,
0.0106863137,
-0.2509503365,
0.8246073127,
0.1557707787,
0.2531140447,
-0.2427894175,
-0.9506805539,
-0.3798680007,
-0.1701040566,
-0.3462446034,
-1.1217468977,
-0.1259748489,
-0.1076422185,
0.1522103101,
0.3389490247,
-0.3056696057,
0.0114151444,
-0.3716043532,
0.4709841609,
0.5743216276,
0.2625467181,
0.5908505321,
-0.176596567,
0.1140134707,
0.3557285368,
-0.0489655882,
-0.0067429943,
-0.115297623,
-0.9336477518,
-0.5855032802,
0.5258045197,
0.1057486981,
-1.1244392395,
0.4982691407,
-0.0022446816,
-0.7609822154,
-0.5173949003,
0.4182713628,
0.1929128319,
0.5467684269,
0.4800412655,
-0.3098776639,
-0.6981132627,
-0.7102261186,
-0.3390149772,
0.0341186747,
0.1941358,
0.0985202193,
0.4785776138,
0.1251112372,
1.2369066477,
-0.6079254746,
-0.5720952749,
-0.5650640726,
0.4972432256,
0.2882155478,
0.2913671434,
0.2381276488,
-0.9539140463,
-0.6941382885,
-0.2742860615,
-0.679864049,
-0.1320948154,
-0.2277093083,
0.0868950859,
0.1185350716,
0.5466282368,
0.076989606,
0.084613055,
0.5233965516,
-0.1722792685,
0.2276712358,
-0.4574670196,
-0.3852051497,
-1.2436333895,
-0.2725145221,
0.3616515696,
-0.5578897595,
-0.5286000371,
-0.4450758994,
-0.0268091634,
-0.089158535,
-0.4924561977,
0.1600575298,
-0.5892387629,
0.2736667991,
-0.2003750801,
0.0665798709,
0.2422632128,
0.293481946,
0.2231960893,
0.4273812473,
0.4597759247,
-0.9830841422,
0.2543281913,
0.1324777454,
-0.4347184002,
0.4395934939,
-0.5269574523,
-0.0578651465,
0.1102510244,
0.1802828908,
-0.9735469818,
-0.0111578051,
-0.4407301843,
-0.0038743969,
0.3149535358,
-0.3113555312,
-0.3678183258,
-0.2402348667,
-0.1566872299,
0.2108779252,
0.3992250264,
-0.7543683648,
0.4841150939,
0.4169279933,
0.0356080718,
-0.2301859558,
-0.3957929909,
-0.2240761518,
-0.3021146655,
-0.2500578463,
0.3369141221,
0.1956796199,
-0.0055876495,
0.1545882225,
-0.3187867403,
-0.2068592757,
0.4199172556,
0.1926772594,
0.4279606044,
0.3587368131,
0.26040259,
0.295199573,
-0.141852349,
-0.1687197089,
-0.1897582859,
0.7654877901,
0.1051563695,
0.0888167322,
-0.6051611304,
-0.2157369405,
0.1178864092,
-0.1877233237,
0.794421196,
0.0922298953,
-0.1139019877,
-0.6382539272,
-0.2333264351,
-0.3917383552,
-0.477689147,
0.2578677833,
-0.4967863262,
-1.0228862762,
0.2468574494,
-0.6130698323,
0.017773727,
0.3925893009,
0.5035715103,
-0.3854505718,
0.7075871229,
1.0654500723,
-0.1508986354,
0.4926565886,
-0.5298288465,
0.0187644418,
-0.3454671204,
-0.5183611512,
-0.7091730833,
-0.3938614726,
-0.3646489978,
-0.2251744419,
0.2928171158,
0.2055377662,
-0.029353641,
0.3038295507,
-0.4279521406,
0.649666667,
0.6203344464,
0.3520580828,
0.6976652741,
-0.0437520184,
-0.136788711,
0.0277424697,
-0.8592674136,
-0.3345836401,
0.8498368263,
0.1854092777,
1.2754963636,
-0.3322642744,
1.156925559,
0.4491694868,
-0.1073919982,
-0.5067414641,
0.547552228,
-0.6311121583,
-0.6186212897,
-0.1227942258,
-0.700701952,
-0.4334893823,
0.0478400402,
-0.3943127096,
-0.4247156978,
0.2813845277,
0.2786419094,
-0.4031502903,
0.1339629889,
-0.7811156511,
0.756888926,
-0.1191473454,
-0.5805368423,
-0.3016370833,
-0.4971072674,
0.3659763336,
-0.369012475,
0.1167653427,
0.0992210209,
0.1775182486,
0.9116996527,
-0.4880720675,
1.2307243347,
-0.2660075426,
-0.0180680174,
0.4265247285,
0.1262158304,
0.2967210114,
0.3685970902,
-0.0460285917,
0.3428040743,
0.1428406835,
-0.0903917924,
-0.1759858727,
0.5069847703,
-0.8677011132,
-0.4647372067,
-0.517220974,
-0.6185370684,
-0.0240008309,
0.2225028723,
0.3921066821,
0.236131683,
-0.2018938065,
0.5122262239,
0.8694139123,
-0.0442611426,
0.2522727847,
0.5365030766,
-0.1143419594,
-0.1383353621,
0.8108417988,
0.1565554738,
0.4381586909,
0.5197577477,
0.1204644889,
-0.4556248784,
-0.4633348882,
-0.2168985158,
0.0694611296,
-0.3258515,
-0.1744553,
-0.6858150959,
-0.2298081815,
-0.0874804333,
-0.0650264919,
-0.5898797512,
-0.531858027,
-0.6466616392,
-0.0935330763,
0.3471019566,
0.4659022093,
0.0967371687,
0.5542181134,
-0.764337182,
0.3920532763,
0.243859604,
0.0903929025,
-0.301163882,
-0.4542314708,
-0.5273809433,
0.1660852432,
-0.1768884212,
-0.6164171696,
0.2813692093,
0.4620444775,
0.3606213927,
0.1018793955,
0.6204740405,
0.5843378305,
-0.3051744998,
0.6284688115,
0.5098698735,
-0.860830307,
0.6767770648,
0.0806887746,
-0.0973724127,
1.1295311451,
0.5086555481,
-0.1628727615,
-0.6812263727,
-0.7589379549,
-0.7645511031,
0.8528597355,
-0.0330335088,
0.0150508573,
0.4234016836,
0.2599925101,
0.5402089357,
0.3749805391,
-0.5884609222,
-0.1385311633,
0.0075670904,
-0.6948623061,
-0.3172895014,
-0.0927513242,
-0.1638652086,
-0.2984097004,
0.7559441328,
-0.0352324359,
-0.5049750209,
0.0422593541,
-0.2338060439,
0.1478296071,
0.0150031699,
-0.3242277503,
0.3708653748,
-0.2983662784,
0.42845577,
0.228932932,
-0.4194292724,
0.1975442916,
0.0823055133,
-0.3974887729,
0.1969343722,
0.0521995984,
0.6740251184,
0.1637316346,
-0.4394897223,
0.2827650309,
-0.3796157241,
-0.238858059,
-0.1659686863,
0.554741621,
0.1235225722,
0.2353305519,
0.14646101,
0.1745996028,
0.2381200641,
-0.5292161107,
0.3086160123,
0.2715379298,
-0.4928808808,
-0.3076974452,
0.7137345672,
0.4163967371,
0.148442179,
0.5892309546,
0.1303009689,
-0.3396870494,
0.4569090307,
0.4708739519,
0.5100626349,
-0.0379095972,
0.3381769061,
0.2193998843,
0.1142705306,
-0.4071823657,
0.0311328936,
-0.1419058293,
-0.5361483693,
-0.1163954884,
-0.8301941156,
-0.5005928874,
-0.0658887252,
-0.8236930966,
0.7962579727,
-0.1632842422,
0.014690985,
0.1736689359,
0.4057735205,
-0.59747684,
0.4168679416,
-0.072559312,
0.9411103725,
-1.3401566744,
1.0418727398,
0.8627022505,
-0.3672824502,
-0.8617215753,
-0.3306733072,
-0.2414699644,
-0.1506111473,
0.484739542,
0.2025984824,
0.0930680111,
0.4236209989,
-0.3765043914,
-0.1799544096,
1.0783754587,
0.3712409139,
-1.0710381269,
-0.0722892359,
0.3592897654,
0.6941203475,
-0.2489101887,
-0.1409164071,
0.5110531449,
-0.267843008,
0.4322898686,
-0.588345468,
-0.33711344,
0.0903876126,
-0.0185548365,
0.149364531,
-0.6719522476,
0.7272715569,
-0.1266955882,
-0.1721134931,
-0.0485678725,
0.8379275203,
0.3631838858,
0.7549288869,
0.6640346646,
0.9001790881,
1.0892095566,
-0.2663906813,
0.6274446845,
-0.147865817,
0.5938868523,
1.4546246529,
-0.3597323895,
0.4566084445,
0.4365091026,
0.0834134594,
0.3937927485,
0.7950784564,
-0.093532674,
1.0636730194,
0.1203595623,
-0.3960611224,
-0.6482614875,
-0.2174171954,
-0.2616590858,
0.2511709929,
0.0682098344,
-0.3139488995,
-0.289236635,
0.1333514154,
-0.176436618,
0.347766459,
-0.399451375,
1.0538847446,
0.4121477306,
-0.447851032,
0.1231748238,
-0.1499734521,
0.5859824419,
-0.4056698084,
-0.024901215,
-0.2652028501,
0.5720073581,
-0.2740803063,
-0.4576858282,
0.0485677682,
0.156434834,
-0.3057872355,
-0.1882440448,
1.0289173126,
-0.6709161997,
-0.6475564837,
0.2168545425,
0.5566506386,
0.111435391,
0.0785503313,
-0.3764153123,
-0.2677416503,
0.2077075243,
0.0262255613,
0.2624723315,
0.8462904692,
-0.1201023459,
0.5215668082,
0.5829874873,
0.1573242992,
0.0936677754,
0.2684669793,
1.0715554953,
-0.3336660862,
-0.5554410219,
-1.2015584707,
0.5097030997,
-0.2856861651,
0.1044852883,
0.8758769631,
1.1387997866,
1.1802903414,
-0.1964074373,
0.9383724928,
0.0983284563,
0.4832148552,
-0.4399297237,
0.7727879882,
-0.6006891727,
0.5002914071,
-0.1468955129,
-0.7495865822,
0.0282859728,
0.3167752922,
-0.2220423371,
-0.1103555262,
0.3831561804,
0.4882261157,
-0.1900161803,
0.363293469,
0.1631874591,
0.1172579378,
0.4119650722,
0.5913444757,
0.95283705,
-0.2609615922,
0.4221310914,
-0.7265572548,
-0.186272949,
-0.1989423037,
-0.7261576056,
-1.379689455,
-0.55553478,
-0.5687105656,
-0.0802843198,
0.0676913187,
0.5461796522,
0.538333714,
-0.5979300141,
-0.1501046568,
-0.4406312704,
0.0911307484,
-0.1984986365,
-0.1752723604,
0.2743656039,
-0.3852636218,
-0.8055912256,
0.0970943049,
-0.0052554086,
-0.0461694114,
-0.0923649743,
0.0721440017,
-0.3072070777,
-0.242386356,
0.3517366052,
-0.27480039,
0.1322858036,
0.0475451015,
-0.1362055093,
-0.1501790732,
-0.2121432722,
0.6194821596,
-0.9883039594,
0.5710489154,
0.4685487747,
0.4287320375,
0.8166889548,
0.170553863,
0.3493051231,
-1.2660672665,
0.1340001076,
0.2439463288,
0.1743917763,
0.2168518305,
-0.2758529484,
0.5250002146,
0.5188025236,
-0.379321754,
-0.9165964127,
-0.055424422,
-1.1308768988,
-0.3950810134,
0.8022385836,
-0.1013211608,
-0.1023811549,
-0.2785724103,
-0.2463546842,
0.7778478265,
-0.4250832498,
0.9661458135,
0.5327566862,
0.0839545578,
-0.0079267109,
-0.3465470672,
0.4735894501,
0.1362454891,
-0.787838161,
0.1028239354,
0.5532354116,
0.2610613704,
0.1096201167,
0.2868227959,
0.0650823638,
-0.076615639,
-0.2291698307,
-0.0016986004,
-0.384952724,
-0.7196787596,
-0.1444025487,
0.2740116119,
-0.1052566916,
-0.1285710484
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.